Microwave and RF Engineering
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
Wiley Series in Microwave and Optical Engineering KAI CHANG, Editor Texas A&M University FIBER-OPTIC COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS, Third Edition, Govind P. Agrawal ASYMMETRIC PASSIVE COMPONENTS IN MICROWAVE INTEGRATED CIRCUITS, Hee-Ran Ahn COHERENT OPTICAL COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS, Silvello Betti, Giancarlo De Marchis, and Eugenio Iannone PHASED ARRAY ANTENNAS: FLOQUET ANALYSIS, SYNTHESIS, BFNs, AND ACTIVE ARRAY SYSTEMS, Arun K. Bhattacharyya HIGH-FREQUENCY ELECTROMAGNETIC TECHNIQUES: RECENT ADVANCES AND APPLICATIONS, Asoke K. Bhattacharyya RADIO PROPAGATION AND ADAPTIVE ANTENNAS FOR WIRELESS COMMUNICATION LINKS: TERRESTRIAL, ATMOSPHERIC, AND IONOSPHERIC, Nathan Blaunstein and Christos G. Christodoulou COMPUTATIONAL METHODS FOR ELECTROMAGNETICS AND MICROWAVES, Richard C. Booton, Jr. ELECTROMAGNETIC SHIELDING, Salvatore Celozzi, Rodolfo Araneo, and Giampiero Lovat MICROWAVE RING CIRCUITS AND ANTENNAS, Kai Chang MICROWAVE SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS AND APPLICATIONS, Kai Chang RF AND MICROWAVE WIRELESS SYSTEMS, Kai Chang RF AND MICROWAVE CIRCUIT AND COMPONENT DESIGN FOR WIRELESS SYSTEMS, Kai Chang, Inder Bahl, and Vijay Nair MICROWAVE RING CIRCUITS AND RELATED STRUCTURES, Second Edition, Kai Chang and Lung-Hwa Hsieh MULTIRESOLUTION TIME DOMAIN SCHEME FOR ELECTROMAGNETIC ENGINEERING, Yinchao Chen, Qunsheng Cao, and Raj Mittra HIGH EFFICIENCY RF AND MICROWAVE SOLID STATE POWER AMPLIFIERS, Paolo Colantonio, Franco Giannini and Ernesto Limiti DIODE LASERS AND PHOTONIC INTEGRATED CIRCUITS, Larry Coldren and Scott Corzine RADIO FREQUENCY CIRCUIT DESIGN, W. Alan Davis and Krishna Agarwal MULTICONDUCTOR TRANSMISSION-LINE STRUCTURES: MODAL ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES, J. A. Brand~ ao Faria PHASED ARRAY-BASED SYSTEMS AND APPLICATIONS, Nick Fourikis FUNDAMENTALS OF MICROWAVE TRANSMISSION LINES, Jon C. Freeman OPTICAL SEMICONDUCTOR DEVICES, Mitsuo Fukuda MICROSTRIP CIRCUITS, Fred Gardiol HIGH-SPEED VLSI INTERCONNECTIONS, Second Edition, Ashok K. Goel FUNDAMENTALS OF WAVELETS: THEORY, ALGORITHMS, AND APPLICATIONS, Jaideva C. Goswami and Andrew K. Chan HIGH-FREQUENCY ANALOG INTEGRATED CIRCUIT DESIGN, Ravender Goyal (ed.) ANALYSIS AND DESIGN OF INTEGRATED CIRCUIT ANTENNA MODULES, K. C. Gupta and Peter S. Hall PHASED ARRAY ANTENNAS, R. C. Hansen STRIPLINE CIRCULATORS, Joseph Helszajn THE STRIPLINE CIRCULATOR: THEORY AND PRACTICE, Joseph Helszajn LOCALIZED WAVES, Hugo E. Hern andez-Figueroa, Michel Zamboni-Rached, and Erasmo Recami (eds.) MICROSTRIP FILTERS FOR RF/MICROWAVE APPLICATIONS, Jia-Sheng Hong and M. J. Lancaster MICROWAVE APPROACH TO HIGHLY IRREGULAR FIBER OPTICS, Huang Hung-Chia NONLINEAR OPTICAL COMMUNICATION NETWORKS, Eugenio Iannone, Francesco Matera, Antonio Mecozzi, and Marina Settembre FINITE ELEMENT SOFTWARE FOR MICROWAVE ENGINEERING, Tatsuo Itoh, Giuseppe Pelosi, and Peter P. Silvester (eds.)
INFRARED TECHNOLOGY: APPLICATIONS TO ELECTROOPTICS, PHOTONIC DEVICES, AND SENSORS, A. R. Jha SUPERCONDUCTOR TECHNOLOGY: APPLICATIONS TO MICROWAVE, ELECTRO-OPTICS, ELECTRICAL MACHINES, AND PROPULSION SYSTEMS, A. R. Jha OPTICAL COMPUTING: AN INTRODUCTION, M. A. Karim and A. S. S. Awwal INTRODUCTION TO ELECTROMAGNETIC AND MICROWAVE ENGINEERING, Paul R. Karmel, Gabriel D. Colef, and Raymond L. Camisa MILLIMETER WAVE OPTICAL DIELECTRIC INTEGRATED GUIDES AND CIRCUITS, Shiban K. Koul ADVANCED INTEGRATED COMMUNICATION MICROSYSTEMS, Joy Laskar, Sudipto Chakraborty, Manos Tentzeris, Franklin Bien, and Anh-Vu Pham MICROWAVE DEVICES, CIRCUITS AND THEIR INTERACTION, Charles A. Lee and G. Conrad Dalman ADVANCES IN MICROSTRIP AND PRINTED ANTENNAS, Kai-Fong Lee and Wei Chen (eds.) SPHEROIDAL WAVE FUNCTIONS IN ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY, Le-Wei Li, Xiao-Kang Kang, and Mook-Seng Leong ARITHMETIC AND LOGIC IN COMPUTER SYSTEMS, Mi Lu OPTICAL FILTER DESIGN AND ANALYSIS: A SIGNAL PROCESSING APPROACH, Christi K. Madsen and Jian H. Zhao THEORY AND PRACTICE OF INFRARED TECHNOLOGY FOR NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING, Xavier P. V. Maldague METAMATERIALS WITH NEGATIVE PARAMETERS: THEORY, DESIGN, AND MICROWAVE APPLICATIONS, Ricardo Marqu es, Ferran Martı´n, and Mario Sorolla OPTOELECTRONIC PACKAGING, A. R. Mickelson, N. R. Basavanhally, and Y. C. Lee (eds.) OPTICAL CHARACTER RECOGNITION, Shunji Mori, Hirobumi Nishida, and Hiromitsu Yamada ANTENNAS FOR RADAR AND COMMUNICATIONS: A POLARIMETRIC APPROACH, Harold Mott INTEGRATED ACTIVE ANTENNAS AND SPATIAL POWER COMBINING, Julio A. Navarro and Kai Chang ANALYSIS METHODS FOR RF, MICROWAVE, AND MILLIMETER-WAVE PLANAR TRANSMISSION LINE STRUCTURES, Cam Nguyen FREQUENCY CONTROL OF SEMICONDUCTOR LASERS, Motoichi Ohtsu (ed.) WAVELETS IN ELECTROMAGNETICS AND DEVICE MODELING, George W. Pan OPTICAL SWITCHING, Georgios Papadimitriou, Chrisoula Papazoglou, and Andreas S. Pomportsis SOLAR CELLS AND THEIR APPLICATIONS, Larry D. Partain (ed.) A complete list of the titles in this series appears at the end of this volume. ANALYSIS OF MULTICONDUCTOR TRANSMISSION LINES, Clayton R. Paul INTRODUCTION TO ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY, Second Edition, Clayton R. Paul ADAPTIVE OPTICS FOR VISION SCIENCE: PRINCIPLES, PRACTICES, DESIGN AND APPLICATIONS, Jason Porter, Hope Queener, Julianna Lin, Karen Thorn, and Abdul Awwal (eds.) ELECTROMAGNETIC OPTIMIZATION BY GENETIC ALGORITHMS, Yahya Rahmat-Samii and Eric Michielssen (eds.) INTRODUCTION TO HIGH-SPEED ELECTRONICS AND OPTOELECTRONICS, Leonard M. Riaziat NEW FRONTIERS IN MEDICAL DEVICE TECHNOLOGY, Arye Rosen and Harel Rosen (eds.) ELECTROMAGNETIC PROPAGATION IN MULTI-MODE RANDOM MEDIA, Harrison E. Rowe ELECTROMAGNETIC PROPAGATION IN ONE-DIMENSIONAL RANDOM MEDIA, Harrison E. Rowe HISTORY OF WIRELESS, Tapan K. Sarkar, Robert J. Mailloux, Arthur A. Oliner, Magdalena Salazar-Palma, and Dipak L. Sengupta PHYSICS OF MULTIANTENNA SYSTEMS AND BROADBAND PROCESSING, Tapan K. Sarkar, Magdalena Salazar-Palma, and Eric L. Mokole SMART ANTENNAS, Tapan K. Sarkar, Michael C. Wicks, Magdalena Salazar-Palma, and Robert J. Bonneau NONLINEAR OPTICS, E. G. Sauter
APPLIED ELECTROMAGNETICS AND ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY, Dipak L. Sengupta and Valdis V. Liepa COPLANAR WAVEGUIDE CIRCUITS, COMPONENTS, AND SYSTEMS, Rainee N. Simons ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS IN UNCONVENTIONAL MATERIALS AND STRUCTURES, Onkar N. Singh and Akhlesh Lakhtakia (eds.) MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING, Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi ANALYSIS AND DESIGN OF AUTONOMOUS MICROWAVE CIRCUITS, Almudena Su arez ELECTRON BEAMS AND MICROWAVE VACUUM ELECTRONICS, Shulim E. Tsimring FUNDAMENTALS OF GLOBAL POSITIONING SYSTEM RECEIVERS: A SOFTWARE APPROACH, Second Edition, James Bao-yen Tsui RF/MICROWAVE INTERACTION WITH BIOLOGICAL TISSUES, Andr e Vander Vorst, Arye Rosen, and Youji Kotsuka InP-BASED MATERIALS AND DEVICES: PHYSICS AND TECHNOLOGY, Osamu Wada and Hideki Hasegawa (eds.) COMPACT AND BROADBAND MICROSTRIP ANTENNAS, Kin-Lu Wong DESIGN OF NONPLANAR MICROSTRIP ANTENNAS AND TRANSMISSION LINES, Kin-Lu Wong PLANAR ANTENNAS FOR WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS, Kin-Lu Wong FREQUENCY SELECTIVE SURFACE AND GRID ARRAY, T. K. Wu (ed.) ACTIVE AND QUASI-OPTICAL ARRAYS FOR SOLID-STATE POWER COMBINING, Robert A. York and Zoya B. Popovic’ (eds.) OPTICAL SIGNAL PROCESSING, COMPUTING AND NEURAL NETWORKS, Francis T. S. Yu and Suganda Jutamulia SiGe, GaAs, AND InP HETEROJUNCTION BIPOLAR TRANSISTORS, Jiann Yuan ELECTRODYNAMICS OF SOLIDS AND MICROWAVE SUPERCONDUCTIVITY, Shu-Ang Zhou
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino University of Perugia, Italy
Giovanni Bianchi Verigy Ltd, Bo¨blingen, Germany
This edition first published 2010 Ó 2010, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd Registered office John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, United Kingdom For details of our global editorial offices, for customer services and for information about how to apply for permission to reuse the copyright material in this book please see our website at www.wiley.com. The right of the author to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The publisher is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Library of Congress Cataloguing-in-Publication Data Sorrentino, Roberto. Microwave and RF engineering / R. Sorrentino, G. Bianchi. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-470-75862-5 (cloth) 1. Microwave devices. 2. Radio–Transmitters and transmission. I. Bianchi, Giovanni. II. Title. TK7876.S666 2010 621.381’3–dc22 2009051049 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5 (Hbk) Set in 9/11pt, Times Roman by Thomson Digital, Noida, India Printed in Singapore by Markono Print Media Pte Ltd
Contents About the Authors Preface 1 Introduction 1.1 Microwaves and radio frequencies 1.2 Frequency bands 1.3 Applications Bibliography
xv xvii 1 1 4 6 8
2 Basic 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7
electromagnetic theory Introduction Maxwell’s equations Time-harmonic EM fields; polarization of a vector Maxwell’s equations in the harmonic regime Boundary conditions Energy and power of the EM field; Poynting’s theorem Some fundamental theorems 2.7.1 Uniqueness theorem 2.7.2 Lorentz’s reciprocity theorem 2.7.3 Love’s equivalence theorem 2.8 Plane waves 2.9 Solution of the wave equation in rectangular coordinates 2.9.1 Plane waves: an alternative derivation 2.9.2 TEM waves 2.9.3 TE and TM waves 2.10 Reflection and transmission of plane waves; Snel’s laws 2.10.1 Snel’s laws; total reflection 2.10.2 Reflection and transmission (Fresnel’s) coefficients 2.10.3 Reflection from a conducting plane 2.11 Electrodynamic potentials Bibliography
9 9 9 12 14 15 17 19 19 19 20 21 22 24 25 26 27 28 31 34 36 38
3 Guided EM propagation 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Cylindrical structures; solution of Maxwell’s equations as TE, TM and TEM modes 3.3 Modes of propagation as transmission lines 3.4 Transmission lines as 1-D circuits 3.5 Phase velocity, group velocity and energy velocity 3.6 Properties of the transverse modal vectors et, ht; field expansion in a waveguide 3.7 Loss, attenuation and power handling in real waveguides
39 39 41 48 52 55 57 59
viii
CONTENTS 3.8 3.9 3.10 3.11 3.12 3.13 3.14
The rectangular waveguide The ridge waveguide The circular waveguide The coaxial cable The parallel-plate waveguide The stripline The microstrip line 3.14.1 The planar waveguide model 3.15 The coplanar waveguide 3.16 Coupled lines 3.16.1 Basic principles for EM analysis 3.16.2 Equivalent circuit modelling Bibliography
61 67 68 72 74 76 78 82 82 84 85 86 88
4 Microwave circuits 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Microwave circuit formulation 4.3 Terminated transmission lines 4.4 The Smith chart 4.5 Power flow 4.6 Matrix representations 4.6.1 The impedance matrix 4.6.2 The admittance matrix 4.6.3 The ABCD or chain matrix 4.6.4 The scattering matrix 4.7 Circuit model of a transmission line section 4.8 Shifting the reference planes 4.9 Loaded two-port network 4.10 Matrix description of coupled lines 4.11 Matching of coupled lines 4.12 Two-port networks using coupled-line sections Bibliography
91 91 91 94 97 105 109 109 110 111 112 119 123 124 125 126 127 129
5 Resonators and cavities 5.1 Introduction 5.2 The resonant condition 5.3 Quality factor or Q 5.4 Transmission line resonators 5.5 Planar resonators 5.6 Cavity resonators 5.7 Computation of the Q factor of a cavity resonator 5.8 Dielectric resonators 5.9 Expansion of EM fields 5.9.1 Helmholtz’s theorem 5.9.2 Electric and magnetic eigenvectors 5.9.3 General solution of Maxwell’s equations in a cavity 5.9.4 Resonances in ideal closed cavities 5.9.5 The cavity with one or two outputs 5.9.6 Excitation of cavity resonators Bibliography
131 131 131 134 136 139 142 144 146 147 148 148 153 154 155 157 161
CONTENTS
ix
6 Impedance matching 6.1 Introduction 6.2 Fano’s bound 6.3 Quarter-wavelength transformer 6.4 Multi-section quarter-wavelength transformers 6.4.1 The binomial transformer 6.4.2 Chebyshev polynomials; the Chebyshev transformer 6.5 Line and stub transformers; stub tuners 6.6 Lumped L networks Bibliography Simulation files
163 163 163 165 167 171 172 178 180 185 185
7 Passive microwave components 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Matched loads 7.3 Movable short circuit 7.4 Attenuators 7.5 Fixed phase shifters 7.5.1 Loaded-line phase shifters 7.5.2 Reflection-type phase shifters 7.6 Junctions and interconnections 7.6.1 Guide-to-coaxial cable transition 7.6.2 Coaxial-to-microstrip transition 7.7 Dividers and combiners 7.7.1 The Wilkinson divider 7.7.2 Hybrid junctions 7.7.3 Directional couplers 7.8 Lumped element realizations 7.9 Multi-beam forming networks 7.9.1 The Butler matrix 7.9.2 The Blass matrix 7.9.3 The Rotman lens 7.10 Non-reciprocal components 7.10.1 Isolator 7.10.2 Circulator Bibliography Simulation files
187 187 187 188 190 193 193 194 195 198 203 204 205 209 211 221 223 224 225 227 230 232 232 234 235
8 Microwave filters 8.1 Introduction 8.2 Definitions 8.3 Lowdpass prototype 8.3.1 Butterworth filters 8.3.2 Chebyshev filters 8.3.3 Cauer filters 8.3.4 Synthesis of the lowdpass prototype 8.4 Semi-lumped lowdpass filters 8.5 Frequency transformations 8.5.1 Lowdpass to highpass transformation 8.5.2 Lowdpass to bandpass transformation
237 237 237 239 240 240 244 245 250 254 255 257
x
9
CONTENTS 8.5.3 Lowdpass to bandstop transformation 8.5.4 Richards transformation 8.6 Kuroda identities 8.7 Immittance inverters 8.7.1 Filters with line-coupled short-circuit stubs 8.7.2 Parallel-coupled filters 8.7.3 Comb-line filters Bibliography Simulation files
260 261 264 267 273 277 281 286 286
Basic 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4
289 289 289 302 303 303 305 306 313 314 316 317 317 319 321 326 328 334 334 336 338 339 340 342 342 348 360 360
concepts for microwave component design Introduction Cascaded linear two-port networks Signal flow graphs Noise in two-port networks 9.4.1 Noise sources 9.4.2 Representation of noisy two-port networks 9.4.3 Noise figure and noise factor 9.4.4 Noise factor of cascaded networks 9.4.5 Noise bandwidth 9.5 Nonlinear two-port networks 9.5.1 Harmonic and intermodulation products 9.5.2 Harmonic distortion 9.5.3 Intermodulation distortion 9.5.4 Gain compression 9.5.5 Intercept points 9.5.6 Saturation and intercept point of cascaded two-port networks 9.6 Semiconductors devices 9.6.1 Basic semiconductor physics 9.6.2 Junction diode 9.6.3 Bipolar transistor 9.6.4 Junction field effect transistor 9.6.5 Metal oxide field effect transistor 9.7 Electrical models of high-frequency semiconductor devices 9.7.1 Linear models 9.7.2 Nonlinear semiconductor models Bibliography Related Files
10 Microwave control components 10.1 Introduction 10.2 Switches 10.2.1 PIN diode switches 10.2.2 FET switches 10.2.3 MEMS switches 10.2.4 Alternative multi-port switch structures 10.3 Variable attenuators 10.4 Phase shifters
363 363 363 368 375 379 385 389 400
CONTENTS 10.4.1 10.4.2 10.4.3 10.4.4 10.4.5 Bibliography Related files
True-delay and slow-wave phase shifters Reflection phase shifters Stepped phase shifters Binary phase shifters Final considerations on phase shifters
xi 402 404 407 408 412 412 413
11 Amplifiers 11.1 Introduction 11.2 Small-signal amplifiers 11.2.1 Gain definitions 11.2.2 Stability 11.2.3 Matching networks 11.2.4 Maximum gain impedance matching 11.3 Low-noise amplifiers 11.4 Design of trial amplifier 11.5 Power amplifiers 11.5.1 Output power optimization with negligible transistor parasitics 11.5.2 Output power optimization in presence of transistor parasitics 11.5.3 Load pull 11.5.4 Balanced amplifiers 11.5.5 PA classes 11.5.6 Amplifier linearization 11.5.7 Additional PA issues 11.6 Other amplifier configurations 11.6.1 Feedback amplifiers 11.6.2 Distributed amplifiers 11.6.3 Differential pairs 11.6.4 Active loads 11.6.5 Cascode configuration 11.7 Some examples of microwave amplifiers 11.7.1 Two-stage millimetre-wave amplifier 11.7.2 Low-noise amplifier Bibliography Related files
415 415 415 416 420 424 425 429 432 440 440 444 451 454 459 473 481 482 483 485 489 494 495 497 497 499 501 501
12 Oscillators 12.1 Introduction 12.2 General principles 12.3 Negative resistance oscillators 12.4 Positive feedback oscillators 12.5 Standard oscillator configuration 12.5.1 Inductively coupled oscillator 12.5.2 Inductive gate feedback oscillator 12.5.3 Hartley oscillator 12.5.4 Colpitts oscillator
503 503 503 508 512 518 521 523 525 526
xii
CONTENTS 12.5.5 Clapp oscillator 12.5.6 Differential oscillator 12.6 Design of a trial oscillator 12.7 Oscillator specifications 12.8 Special oscillators 12.8.1 Lumped element and transmission line oscillators 12.8.2 Cavity oscillators and dielectric resonator oscillators 12.8.3 Voltage-controlled oscillators 12.8.4 Push–push oscillators 12.8.5 Amplitude-stabilized oscillators 12.9 Design of a push –push microwave VCO Bibliography Related files
527 528 530 534 543 543 547 549 553 555 557 559 559
13 Frequency converters 13.1 Introduction 13.2 Detectors 13.2.1 Quadratic diode detector 13.2.2 Envelope detectors 13.2.3 FET detectors 13.3 Mixers 13.3.1 Product detector 13.3.2 Single-ended diode mixers 13.3.3 Singly balanced diode mixers 13.3.4 Doubly balanced diode mixers 13.3.5 Subharmonically pumped mixers 13.3.6 Image reject mixers 13.3.7 Suppression in presence of amplitude and phase imbalance 13.3.8 FET mixers 13.3.9 Mixers based on differential pairs 13.3.10 Mixer nonlinearities 13.4 Frequency multipliers Bibliography Related files
561 561 561 563 570 573 577 579 581 584 590 594 597 600 602 606 617 625 630 630
14 Microwave circuit technology 14.1 Introduction 14.2 Hybrid and monolithic integrated circuits 14.2.1 High-frequency PCB 14.2.2 Hybrid MICs 14.2.3 MMICs 14.2.4 Advanced hybrid MICs 14.2.5 Parasitic elements associated to physical devices 14.3 Basic MMIC elements 14.3.1 Transmission lines 14.3.2 Via holes 14.3.3 Resistors 14.3.4 Inductors
633 633 633 634 635 636 637 637 639 640 640 641 643
CONTENTS 14.3.5 Capacitors 14.3.6 Semiconductor devices 14.4 Simulation models and layout libraries 14.4.1 Single element models 14.4.2 Scalable models 14.4.3 Nonlinear models 14.4.4 MMIC statistical models 14.4.5 Temperature-dependent models 14.5 MMIC production technique 14.5.1 Lithography 14.5.2 On-wafer testing 14.5.3 Cut and selection 14.6 RFIC Bibliography
xiii 645 646 649 650 650 651 651 652 652 653 655 655 656 657
15 RF and microwave architectures 15.1 Introduction 15.2 Review of modulation theory 15.2.1 Amplitude modulation 15.2.2 Angular modulation 15.3 Transmitters 15.3.1 Direct modulation transmitters 15.3.2 Polar modulator 15.3.3 Cartesian modulator 15.3.4 Transmitters with frequency translation 15.4 Receivers 15.4.1 RF tuned receivers 15.4.2 Superetherodyne receivers 15.4.3 Zero-IF and low-IF receivers 15.4.4 Walking IF receivers 15.4.5 One practical IC-based receiver 15.4.6 Digital receivers 15.5 Further concepts on RF transmitters and receivers 15.5.1 Transceivers 15.5.2 CAD analysis of a radar transmitting subassembly 15.5.3 Receiver performance analysis 15.6 Special radio functional blocks 15.6.1 Quadrature signal generation 15.6.2 PLL 15.6.3 ALC and AGC 15.6.4 SDLVA Bibliography Related files
659 659 659 660 663 665 665 675 677 681 682 682 692 696 699 701 703 710 710 719 725 731 731 735 744 749 753 754
16 Numerical methods and CAD 16.1 Introduction 16.2 EM analysis 16.2.1 The method of moments
757 757 760 761
xiv
CONTENTS 16.2.2 16.2.3 16.2.4 16.2.5 16.3 Circuit 16.3.1
The finite difference method The FDTD method The finite element method The mode matching method analysis Linear analysis: the signal flow graph and the admittance matrix methods 16.3.2 Time domain nonlinear analysis 16.3.3 Frequency domain nonlinear analysis 16.4 Optimization 16.4.1 Definitions and basic concepts 16.4.2 Objective function 16.4.3 Constraints 16.4.4 Optimization methods Bibliography
763 766 770 771 780 780 785 786 788 789 790 791 791 792
17 Measurement instrumentation and techniques 17.1 Introduction 17.2 Power meters 17.3 Frequency meters 17.3.1 RF digital frequency meter 17.3.2 Microwave digital frequency meter 17.3.3 Frequency conversion frequency meters 17.3.4 Frequency conversion frequency meter without preselector 17.4 Spectrum analyzers 17.4.1 Panoramic receiver 17.4.2 Superheterodyne spectrum analyzer 17.5 Wide-band sampling oscilloscopes 17.6 Network analyzers 17.6.1 Scalar analyzers 17.6.2 Vector analyzers 17.6.3 Noise figure meters 17.7 Special test instruments 17.7.1 IFM 17.7.2 Complex test benches 17.7.3 Test instruments for non-electrical quantities Bibliography Related files Appendix A Useful relations from vector analysis and trigonometric function identities Appendix B Fourier transform Appendix C Orthogonality of the eigenvectors in ideal waveguides Appendix D Standard rectangular waveguides and coaxial cables Appendix E Symbols for electric diagrams Appendix F List of acronyms
795 795 795 798 798 799 800 802 803 803 806 809 816 817 821 833 837 837 843 846 849 849
Index
883
851 861 865 869 873 877
About the Authors Roberto Sorrentino received the Laurea degree in Electronic Engineering from the University of Rome ‘‘La Sapienza’’, Rome, Italy, in 1971, where he was an Associate Professor until 1986. From 1986 to 1990 he was a Professor at the University of Rome ‘‘Tor Vergata’’. Since 1990 he has been a Professor at the University of Perugia, Perugia, Italy. He has authored and co-authored over 100 technical papers in international journals, 300 refereed conference papers and three books in the area of the analysis and design of microwave passive circuits and antennas. He is an IEEE Fellow (1990), a recipient of the IEEE Third Millennium Medal (2000) and of the Distinguished Educator Award from IEEE MTT-S (2004). He was the President of the European Microwave Association from 1998 to 2009. Giovanni Bianchi received the Laurea degree in Electronic Engineering from the University of Rome ‘‘La Sapienza’’, Rome, Italy, in 1987. In 1988, he joined the microwave department of Elettronica S.p.A. where he was involved in microwave components (including GaAs MMICs) and subassembly design. He joined Motorola PCS in 2000, where he worked on GSM and WCDMA mobile phone design, and in 2004 joined SDS S.r.L where he was responsible for microwave designs. Since January 2008 he has worked as a R&D Engineer in the hardware/RF division at Verigy, and is an expert of high frequency theory and techniques. In his 23 years of design experience he has covered both passive and active microwave components, including filters, amplifiers, oscillators, and synthesizers. He is the author of four books (including the present one) as well as 12 papers.
Preface This book deals with a rather complex discipline that involves many different techniques and approaches: the result is a difficult and alluring subject at the same time. Most academic tradition focuses on the electromagnetic-related aspects of microwaves, i.e. on the science of the solution of Maxwell’s equations, which is quite difficult to divulgate because of the remarkable difficulties it involves. The electromagnetic theory is the basis of the high-frequency techniques, from radio frequency (RF) up to millimetre waves; therefore it must be well understood, in order to comprehend and dominate a variety of phenomena utilized in many applications, mainly – but not exclusively – in telecommunications. Microwaves, however, do not reduce to the electromagnetic theory. The microwave engineer, i.e. the designer operating with frequencies that are so high as to need a specific methodological approach, must have a basic knowledge of the electromagnetic theory, but must also be familiar with network theory, signal theory, linear and nonlinear circuits, and electronic technology – particularly microwave integrated circuits, CAD techniques and test instruments. Such considerations have motivated us to write this book. It differs from traditional microwave books because it includes several topics, such as semiconductor device modelling or test instruments, that are commonly considered at the boundary with other electronic disciplines, but are equally important for practising microwave engineers. This book is intended for both students and professionals. Therefore the topics are presented – wherever possible – at different levels of depth. The reader will find some topics, discussed in specific sections printed in line boxes, that can be ignored without lack of continuity of the discussion. In this way, we tried to circumvent the difficulties related to the conventional approach to microwaves, without losing a detailed and rigorous exposition. We are aware that many important topics have not been included in the book, particularly propagation in dielectric waveguides and optical fibres. The study of propagation in microstrips and printed circuits has been limited to a brief qualitative description. The same treatment applies to the analysis of many components and devices, as well as many other specific topics. The size limitation for the book to be manageable has imposed some exclusion. We hope nevertheless to have provided a useful tool for a first approach and for subsequent in-depth study aswell. Based on own different experience, we had to realize a book combining formal academic rigour with a practical approach useful for the designer. The conventional research-oriented list of subjects has thus been extended to cover a number of application-oriented aspects. Examples from actual engineering practice are included in all chapters. After the introduction to the field of microwaves and radio frequencies, the basic electromagnetic theory is concisely recalled in Chapter 2, with more emphasis on the propagation of plane waves. The reader is assumed already to have a background in the electromagnetic theory, so that this chapter serves as a reference and as a reminder. Chapter 3 is then devoted to the study of guided electromagnetic propagation along unlimited transmission lines. In contrast with most textbooks, the telegrapher’s equations are introduced here as a special case of the mode propagation in cylindrical waveguides. The conventional derivation from a lumped circuit model is presented in a subsequent section. Some of the most common guiding structures are discussed, including coupled transmission lines. The concept of a microwave circuit, a powerful model for the characterization of microwave structures, is introduced in Chapter 4. The chapter concerns the modelling of microwave structures and transmission lines of finite length, including the Smith chart, N-port circuits and terminated coupled lines. Chapters 5 to 8 are devoted to the study of various classes of passive microwave components. Chapter 5 deals with microwave cavities and resonators. The theory of resonant mode expansion is also introduced
xviii
PREFACE
as a significant theoretical approach to the solution of Maxwell’s equations in a volume. The matching of microwave circuits is treated in Chapter 6, a significant part being devoted to quarter-wave transformers. A number of microwave passive components are then presented in Chapter 7. The term passive is interpreted here as linear. Switches and tuning elements are not included in such components, but are discussed instead in Chapter 10. Chapter 7 is devoted to interconnections, the various types of directional couplers, dividers and combiners, in various technologies, including a brief description of microwave multi-beam forming networks. Non-reciprocal components are described briefly in the last sections of the chapter. Because of their importance in the design activity of the practising microwave engineer, microwave filters are treated in some detail in Chapter 8. The basic concepts needed for the study of control and active components in the subsequent chapters are introduced in Chapter 9. Chapter 10 is devoted to microwave control components: these are passive components using control devices, such as diodes and transistors, to operate on the microwave signal without increasing its associated energy. Microwave amplifiers based on solid state devices are dealt with in Chapter 11. Due to space limitations, the discussion is necessarily limited to the main concepts and to the most common configurations, specifically to the one-transistor amplifier with one input and one output matching network, including small-signal, low-noise and power amplifiers. The generation of microwaves is discussed in Chapter 12, which is devoted to oscillators, presenting the most common configurations and illustrating some analytical techniques. Frequency conversion, discussed in Chapter 13, is a fundamental technique in the nonlinear processing of microwave and RF signals, from detection to mixing to frequency multiplying. The technologies for the fabrication of microwave circuits are the subject of Chapter 14. Here attention, for obvious reasons, is confined to integrated circuits (ICs), spanning microwave integrated circuits (MICs) and the most sophisticated monolithic microwave integrated circuits (MMICs), including an overview of silicon radio frequency integrated circuits (RFICs). The system perspective is taken into consideration in Chapter 15 on RF and microwave architectures for transmitters and receivers, including a summary of basic modulation theory. Chapter 16 introduces the reader to the foundations of numerical methods and CAD techniques for microwave circuit design. Although much more space could gave been devoted to this important subject, we feel that we have provided enough fundamental information for the reader prior to consulting specialized books on the subject. Measurement and instrumentation are the subjects of the concluding chapter. We felt, indeed, that the microwave engineer should be conscious of the basic aspects related to such essential steps which are the final verification of the results of his or her work. In order to illustrate and extend the material presented in text form in Chapters 5 to 17 (except 14), 98simulation files have been developed and collected in a separate CD-ROM. These simulation files will allow the reader to ‘play with the numbers’ to see what happens to the circuit response when some parameters are changed, and to generate different examples from those already presented in the book, and so on. The CD also includes two setup programs to install the required application tools: namely, Ansoft Designer SV and SIMetrix. The simulation files are grouped in folders, one for each chapter. Each folder is further divided into subfolders, one per file type, i.e. Ansoft Designer SV, Mathcad and SIMetrix, which are the commercial programs we have employed. Although they have much wider capabilities, these programs have been adopted here for the following use: .
Ansoft Designer SV A functional subset of Ansoft Designer, the commercially distributed designmanagement environment and circuit simulator for RF and microwave hardware development. We used this program for linear S-parameter and noise analyses.
.
Mathcad A computer mathematical manipulation program to implement and simultaneously document mathematical calculations. The Mathcad visual format and user interface integrate the familiar standard mathematical notation with text and graphs in a single worksheet. Our use of Mathcad is in the analysis and synthesis of microwave/RF structures.
PREFACE .
xix
SIMetrix This comprises a SPICE simulator with a schematic editor, and a waveform viewer in a unified environment. We have used it here to provide the reader with examples of nonlinear circuit and subsystem analysis.
For detailed descriptions and/or to download updated versions, the interested reader can visit the respective websites: http://www.ansoft.com/, http://www.ptc.com and http://www.simetrix.co.uk/. We gratefully acknowledge the help received from Elisa Fratticcioli and Cristiano Tomassoni for text and figure editing and revision. Luca Pelliccia is gratefully acknowledged for carefully and patiently revising the whole text and removing many typos and mistakes. Michele Ancis, Simone Bastioli, Loris Caporali, Federico Casini, Paola Farinelli, Elisa Sbarra and Roberto Vincenti Gatti have kindly contributed to some parts of the book. Their contribution is acknowledged in the specific sections. We are aware that, in spite of many revisions, the book may need some improvement and that some mistakes may unavoidably still be present. We welcome input from anyone who has read this material and wishes to point out mistakes, make suggestions or ask questions to clarify any issue. Suggestions can be sent to us at out respective email addresses.
September 2009
Roberto Sorrentino (
[email protected]) Giovanni Bianchi (
[email protected])
1
Introduction 1.1 Microwaves and radio frequencies Technical terms sometimes have odd histories. The term microwaves, after being confined for decades to a restricted circle of specialists in radar, telecommunications and electromagnetism, has become, with the introduction of microwave ovens about 30 years ago, a popular term associated with cooking. This might be the reason why its use among specialists has declined somewhat, being often replaced by the ampler and more generic term radio frequencies (RFs) and, above 30 GHz, millimetre waves. At about the same time the term radio is being replaced by the term wireless, an expression coined and adopted by Marconi which has become fashionable in recent years. Microwaves were first introduced in the technical literature in 1932 by Nello Carrara, to designate those electromagnetic (EM) waves whose wavelength was smaller than 30 cm, i.e. the electromagnetic spectrum above 1 GHz [1]. In those years, the use of such high frequencies was motivated by the research on radar, for which many studies were launched and enormous resources spent worldwide.1 The simplest definition of microwaves is the one based on a precise interval of frequencies. Figure 1.1 depicts the full electromagnetic spectrum from long waves up to ultraviolet. According to the majority of textbooks, microwaves correspond to frequencies between 300 MHz and 300 GHz, corresponding to wavelengths between 1 millimetre and 1 metre. According to some sources, the lower limit is raised to 500 MHz or 1 GHz. The frequency range between 30 and 300 GHz is also referred to as millimetre waves, since the wavelengths are between 1 and 10 mm. This terminological uncertainty reflects the fact that there is no specific physical phenomenon identifying a precise frequency boundary. Also, RF does not correspond to a precise frequency range but indicates all frequencies employed in the radio technique, usually below the microwave range. Rather than a frequency range, microwaves actually identify a methodology, i.e. a specific approach to the study of electromagnetic phenomena. Such an approach is intermediate between the two other methodologies derived from Maxwell’s equations, namely circuit theory and optics. To be more precise, the discriminating element of the three methodologies is not really the frequency but rather the wavelength, or, better, the ratio between the wavelength and the dimensions of the circuits or objects where the EM field manifests itself.
1
The development of radar absorbed more funds than the atomic bomb (see [2], p. 22).
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
2
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 1.1
The electromagnetic spectrum.
In the case of low-frequency EM fields, for which the wavelength is much larger than the dimensions of the circuits and the EM field propagation times from one point to another of the circuit are a small fraction of the period, one applies the lumped circuit theory which represents a simplification of Maxwell’s equations. In the opposite case, i.e. when the objects and the circuit elements are much larger than the wavelength, one can apply the optical laws which are another type of simplification of Maxwell’s equations. The microwave regime corresponds to those cases when the wavelengths are of the same order (roughly, from one-tenth to 10 times) as the circuit dimensions, so that neither one nor the other approximation is permissible: Maxwell’s equations must be solved in their entirety. Peculiar and often non-intuitive effects arise when the wavelength is comparable with the dimensions of the objects involved in the EM field. This confers a special difficulty on this discipline: circuit elements, such as the capacitors and inductors that are familiar in low-frequency ranges, not only assume totally unconventional shapes but do not actually exist as distinct regions of space that store only electric or magnetic energy. Because of their peculiarity, the intuitive perception of EM phenomena may sometimes be misleading. Special attention and specific expertise are therefore often required in the study of devices, circuits and systems operating at microwave frequencies. A typical phenomenon is wave diffraction from obstacles. As already mentioned, such a phenomenon is strictly related to the ratio between the wavelength l and the obstacle dimension d. The following example illustrates this point. While an acoustic signal whose wavelength is of the order of tenths of centimetres can easily reach a listener sitting behind a wall 2 or 3 metres high, the same is not possible for an optical signal, whose wavelength is of the order of fractions of a micrometre. While two people sitting on opposite sides of the wall can hear each other because the acoustic wave is diffracted by the edge of the wall, they cannot see each other because the optical wave is not significantly diffracted. The diffraction of waves by an aperture of width d created in a wall is illustrated in Figure 1.2 under different conditions when d l or d l. As can be seen, in the former case the wave is diffracted by the aperture edges so as to propagate beyond the wall in all directions. On the contrary, in the latter case, the wave propagates through the aperture in a straight fashion reaching only the points located in the direction of the incident wave.
INTRODUCTION
Figure 1.2
3
EM wave diffraction by an aperture for (a) d l and (b) d l.
Other phenomena difficult to perceive on the basis of simple intuition are due to evanescent waves, i.e. waves that are attenuated in a lossless medium.2 Indeed, such waves can produce interactions between distant objects and circuit elements producing energy exchanges between them. This is a phenomenon that is totally unexpected on the basis of normal experience of mechanical phenomena. One of these effects is the optical tunnel effect, which consists of the transmission of power through space regions where the EM wave does not propagate but is evanescent.3 The interaction through evanescent fields is also responsible for the altered responses of circuit elements when put in relatively close proximity, so that the circuit models of the isolated elements can no longer be employed. The distributed character of microwave circuits is responsible for other phenomena that do not occur at low frequencies when all circuit elements can be considered as lumped. A microwave filter never behaves as an ideal lumped element filter, which normally possesses one passband and one stopband, but contains a virtually unlimited number of spurious passbands. A microwave amplifier is not merely a diagram block with an associated gain (and possibly a noise figure) but has frequency-dependent gain and mismatch, distorts the signal, adds noise, and, in the worst case, self-oscillates. When, in the design of microwave circuits, we are confronted with the practical implementation of the theory, surprises may occur if we blindly trust the design tools at our disposal. It must be borne in mind that the simulators, though indispensable tools in the analysis and design of our circuits, are based on 2 3
See for example the phenomenon of total reflection described in Section 2.10.1. This has recently been proposed as a possible way to provide a means to recharge the batteries of portable devices.
4
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
models, and thus can predict the actual responses of our circuits as long as such models accurately represent the corresponding structures or circuit elements. In the same way, the numerical values that appear on the display of a measuring instrument are not the quantity under measurement, but just another physical quantity related to it in a more or less accurate way. In spite of such difficulties, or perhaps just because of them, microwaves are a technology and a discipline that are at the same time both stimulating and fascinating. This book attempts to attenuate some theoretical difficulties by presenting the discipline in as simple a way as we could, but we need to stress that the problems one has to face when dealing with microwaves never run out, even after years of study and professional practice.
1.2 Frequency bands Although the term microwaves should concern a methodology rather than a frequency range, a conventional subdivision into frequency bands is clearly needed for practical reasons. This does not eliminate some confusion since different conventions are in use. Table 1.1 lists the frequency band designations according to the CCIR (Consultative Committee on International Radio) over the full 30 Hz to 300 GHz spectrum. The microwave spectrum actually occupies the bands 9 (UHF), 10 (SHF) and 11(EHF). The most common designation of microwave bands is that quoted in Table 1.2, where a letter is used to designate the various bands. Such a denomination dates back to the Second World War, when random letters were chosen in order to confuse the enemy, but some confusion is still present [2] (e.g. in some books the Q band is used for the 33–50 GHz band). From a practical point of view, the selection of a frequency band is based on the specific application and on the characteristics of the EM wave propagating in the atmosphere. The ratio d/l between the circuit dimension and the wavelength is of paramount importance in determining the ability of an antenna to radiate the EM field into space. To this end, the circuit dimensions and the wavelength should be of the same order of magnitude, so that the higher the frequency, the smaller the antenna size. Similarly, the speed of data transmission depends on the frequency band employed. The use of higher frequencies allows one to increase the channel capacity and thus to increase the data transmission rate. The propagation through the atmosphere, however, produces attenuations that depend not only on the distance, as in free space, but also on the physical and chemical properties of the medium, as illustrated by Figure 1.3, where atmospheric attenuation is plotted at sea level and at 4000 m altitude.
Table 1.1 Denomination of radio bands. Band
Denomination
Frequency range
Wavelengths
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
ELF SLF ULF VLF LF MF HF VHF UHF SHF EHF LHF
< 30 Hz 30–300 Hz 300 Hz–3 kHz 3–30 kHz 30–300 kHz 300 kHz–3 MHz 3–30 MHz 30–300 MHz 300 MHz–3 GHz 3–30 GHz 30–300 GHz >300 GHz
>10 000 km 10 000–1000 km 1000–100 km 100–10 km 10–1 km 1 km–100 m 100–10 m 10–1 m 1 m–10 cm 10–1 cm 10–1 mm < 1 mm
INTRODUCTION
5
Table 1.2 IEEE denomination of microwave frequency bands. Denomination
Frequency range (GHz)
UHF L S C X Ku K Ka V W Millimetre waves Submillimetre waves
0.3–1 1–2 2–4 4–8 8–12 12–18 18–27 27–40 40–75 75–110 30–300 300–3000
As can be seen in the figure, the attenuation rapidly increases over 10 GHz with a non-monotonic behaviour, reaching the peaks due to water vapour absorption at 22 GHz and oxygen absorption at 63 GHz, the minima of attenuation being located at 24 and 94 GHz. In general, as observed above, the use of ever higher frequencies is spurred by a number of advantages such as the reduced dimensions of the components (antennas, line sections, circuit elements), wider bandwidths, high signal processing and data transmission speeds, higher radar resolution, higher antenna directivities and thus reduced interference. By contrast, the use of higher frequencies involves a number of practical problems, such as higher atmospheric attenuation (although not necessarily), more stringent fabrication tolerances (because of the reduced dimensions), higher fabrication costs, higher circuit loss and reduced available power from the solid state devices, and lower or insufficient maturity of the semiconductor technology. For such contrasting reasons, most civil RF systems (such as television, cellular communications, GPS, microwave ovens) employ frequencies located between 500 MHz and 5 GHz, corresponding to Wavelength, mm 100
30
1
3
millimetre waves
10 Attenuation, dB/km
10
sea level
4000 MSL
1
0.1 O2
O2 0.01
H2O
H2O
H2O
1E-3 10
30
100 Frequency, GHz
Figure 1.3 Atmospheric attenuation.
300
400
6
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
wavelengths between 6 and 60 cm. As pointed out in [2], this is due, on the one hand, to the antenna size, which needs to be small enough, and, on the other hand, to the increase of atmospheric attenuation at higher frequencies. The latter would require higher radiated powers, also involving a potential risk to the population. For example, if for practical reasons a maximum antenna size of 10 cm is chosen, the condition d/l > 0.1 implies a frequency no lower than 300 MHz.
1.3 Applications RF and microwave technology, originally finalized for military applications (radar), is nowadays spurred by a number of civil applications, especially cellular telephony and the so-called personal communication systems (PCS). Communications remain the most important application area where, besides cellular telephony and satellite communications, we may include radio and television broadcasting, wireless local area networks (WLANs) and point–multipoint broadcasting systems, namely LMDS (Local Multipoint Distribution Systems) and MMDS (Multipoint Multichannel Distribution Systems). RF and microwave technology also concerns several application sectors including, among others: .
Navigation and localization systems, such as GPS, based on 24 orbiting satellites and providing the user with geographical coordinates and height, or the corresponding European system Galileo, and aircraft landing systems such as MLS (Microwave Landing System).
.
Electromagnetic sensors for the measurement and characterization of physical quantities and the properties of materials for industrial applications.
.
Weather forecasting and remote sensing of environmental parameters (e.g. temperature, wind speed, water content) and monitoring of natural resources.
.
Automotive, road traffic aids and control.
.
Civil and military surveillance systems.
.
Healthcare and medicine, for investigation, diagnosis and treatment, such as microwave hyperthermia for treating cancer.
.
Radio astronomy and space exploration.
.
Microwave imaging, for civil and military applications.
.
RF identification (RFID), a technique which is rapidly replacing the bar code system to identify and track products, animals or persons using RFs.
.
Food processing, industrial treatment (drying, curing, heating, etc.) of materials and goods (e.g. for killing pests).
We should not fail to mention scientific research, which is the basis for future developments in various and newsworthy directions (e.g. lower energy consumption) to support humanity. The reader should consult the website of EURAMIG, the European Radio and Microwave Interest Group (http://www.euramig.org/), a non-profit European initiative for the promotion of microwaves and RF. It is not necessary to recall that the pervasiveness of microwave technology in everyday life is such as to induce fears about possible biological risks to humans and living organisms. Avast area of investigation has been developed concerning the interaction of EM fields (not only within the RF spectrum) with biological systems. The reader may deepen his or her knowledge on what is called, in general terms, electromagnetic compatibility (EMC), by consulting the research literature on this subject (e.g. [3, 4]). Figure 1.4 displays the main applications of microwaves and RF. Actually, the list could be extended much further, but it might shortly become obsolete. One can indeed expect that the use of EM fields
MMDS LMDS
WLAN
Terrestrial
PCS
Cellular Telephony
Civilian
Surveillance
Guidance of weapons
Ship traffic control
Space vehicles
Radar
Military
Electronic warfare
Navigation
Curing
Sensing and monitoring
Waste treatment
Drying
Process control
Industrial
Figure 1.4 Applications of microwaves and radio frequencies.
Remote sensing
Car traffic control
Air traffic control
Satellite
Communications
Applications of Microwaves and RF
Hyperthermia
Imaging
Biomedical
INTRODUCTION 7
8
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
is destined to spread further to the most diverse applications – some useful, others less so, or possibly useless – like many everyday items that the market imposes on us for solving problems that nobody perceives today but that tomorrow we might not be able to do without. A vast literature of treatises, textbooks and handbooks has been published on the subject of microwaves, RF and applications since the first decades of the twentieth century. In the bibliography at the end of this chapter the reader will find a very short and somewhat arbitrary list of those books, chosen from the most popular ones.
Bibliography 1. N. Carrara, ‘The detection of microwaves’, Proceedings of the Institute of Radio Engineers (IRE), Vol. 20, No. 10, pp. 1615–1625, 1932. 2. T. H. Lee, Planar Microwave Engineering, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2004. 3. C. R. Paul, Introduction to Electromagnetic Compatibility, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 2006. 4. H. Ott, Electromagnetic Compatibility Engineering, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 2009. 5. J. A. Stratton, Electromagnetic Theory, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1941. 6. N. Marcuvitz, Waveguide Handbook, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1951. 7. R. E. Collin, Field Theory of Guided Waves, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1960. 8. C. G. Montgomery, R. H. Dicke and E. M. Purcell, Principles of Microwave Circuits, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1948 and Peter Peregrinus, Stevenage, 1987. 9. R. F. Harrington, Time-Harmonic Electromagnetic Fields, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1961. 10. J. D. Jackson, Classical Electrodynamics, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1962. 11. S. Ramo, J. R. Whinnery and T. Van Duzer, Fields and Waves in Communication Electronics, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1984. 12. J. D. Kraus, Electromagnetics, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1984. 13. C. A. Balanis, Advanced Engineering Electromagnetics, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1989. 14. D. M. Pozar, Microwave Engineering, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 2004.
2
Basic electromagnetic theory 2.1 Introduction This chapter summarizes the basic elements of the electromagnetic (EM) theory, from Maxwell’s equations to the propagation of EM waves. Since this subject is normally taught in basic courses on EM theory, only the fundamental concepts are provided as they are needed for subsequent discussions in the rest of the book. The scope here is essentially to recall the foundations of EM theory and to establish the basic formulae and symbolism that will be employed throughout the book. The experienced reader may skip this chapter.
2.2 Maxwell’s equations EM fields can be established and propagate both in a vacuum and in natural media. EM phenomena are governed by Maxwell’s equations combined with the constitutive equations of the material. Using modern notation and adopting Giorgi’s or the MKS system [1], Maxwell’s equations in differential form can be written as rE ¼ rH ¼
@B @t
@D þJ @t
ð2:1Þ ð2:2Þ
rD ¼ r
ð2:3Þ
rB ¼ 0
ð2:4Þ
In Equations (2.1)–(2.4) vector quantities are indicated in bold and: E (V/m) is the electric field D (C/m2) is the electric displacement or induction
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
10
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING H B J r
(A/m) is the magnetic field (Wb/m2) is the magnetic induction (A/m2) is the electric current density (C/m3) is the electric charge density.
The above quantities are, in general, functions of both space and time. If we take the divergence of (2.2) (remember that the divergence of a curl is zero) and combine the result with (2.3), we obtain the continuity equation for the electric current rJ ¼
@r @t
ð2:5Þ
The continuity equation can be interpreted as expressing the principle of conservation of the electric charge in local or differential form. The decrease with time of the charge density in an infinitesimal volume equals the current flowing outward from the same volume. Equations (2.1)–(2.4) are the differential form of Maxwell’s equations. Their integral form is sometimes more useful for computational purposes or in the derivation of their numerical counterparts (see Chapter 16). By applying Stokes’ theorem (A.61) to (2.1) and (2.2) and the divergence theorem (A.60) to (2.3) and (2.4) one obtains þ ð @ E dl ¼ B dS ð2:6Þ @t S C þ
@ H dl ¼ @t C
ð
ð D dS þ S
J dS
ð2:7Þ
S
ð
þ D dS ¼ S
r dV
ð2:8Þ
V
þ B dS ¼ 0
ð2:9Þ
S
Similarly, the continuity equation can be converted into its integral counterpart using the divergence theorem (A.60) þ J dS ¼ S
@ @t
ð r dV
ð2:10Þ
V
Maxwell’s equations (2.1)–(2.4) need to be supplemented by the constitutive relations which characterize the EM properties of the material (or medium) where the EM is established. In the case of linear isotropic media, including the vacuum, the constitutive relations are simply scalar and linear relationships between the electric displacement and the electric field and between the magnetic induction and the magnetic field D ¼ eE
ð2:11Þ
B ¼ mH
ð2:12Þ
In (2.11) e is the dielectric permittivity, usually expressed in terms of the dielectric constant (or relative permittivity) er and the permittivity of the vacuum e0 e ¼ e0 er
ð2:13Þ
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
11
where e0 ¼ 8:854 10 12 ffi
10 9 F=m 36p
ð2:14Þ
Similarly, in (2.12), m is the magnetic permeability, usually expressed as the product of the relative permeability mr and the vacuum permeability m0. The latter has the value m0 ¼ 4p 10 7 H=m
ð2:15Þ
Permittivity and permeability are the constitutive parameters of the medium. If this is inhomogeneous, i.e. its physical properties vary in space, the constitutive parameters are functions of the space coordinates. When, as we will always assume in this book, the constitutive parameters are independent of the electromagnetic field, the medium is linear. In conducting materials where an electric current is induced by the electric field, Ohm’s law holds, stating the proportionality between the conduction current density J c and the electric field E through the conductivity s (S/m) of the medium: J
c
¼ sE
ð2:16Þ
The constitutive relations (2.11) and (2.12) can alternatively be expressed using another pair of vectors that characterize the electric and magnetic properties of the medium, i.e. the electric polarization P and the magnetic polarization M . Such relations are as follows: D ¼ e0 E þ P
ð2:17Þ
B ¼ m0 ðH þ M Þ
ð2:18Þ
For linear and isotropic media, P and M
are proportional to the electric and magnetic fields P ¼ e0 we E
ð2:19Þ
¼ wm H
ð2:20Þ
M
where we and wm are the electric and magnetic susceptibilities, respectively. It is easily found that we ¼ er 1
ð2:21Þ
wm ¼ mr 1
ð2:22Þ
In many practical cases, the material where the EM exists is such that a more complex relation than the simple proportionality (2.19) holds between the polarization and the electric field. Such a relationship may also depend on the time variation of the field. As an example, the molecules of many materials, including water, have their own oscillation frequencies. As a consequence the dielectric properties of such materials are frequency dependent and the material is said to be dispersive. Its constitutive relation can be rather complex in the time domain, but in the frequency domain (see next section) it simply implies a frequency dependence of the dielectric constant. For a discussion on the permittivity dispersion see for instance [2]. In the case of a material with crystal structure, the orientation of the field with respect to the crystal lattice may affect its electrical or magnetic properties. In particular, the electric or magnetic polarizations may have directions that do not coincide with those of the originating electric or magnetic field, respectively. In such a case the material is said to be anisotropic. The relationships (2.19) and (2.20), although linear, become of tensor type:
12
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING P ¼ e0 v E
ð2:23Þ
M
ð2:24Þ
e
¼ v H m
a tensor or dyadic being represented by a matrix. Correspondingly, (2.11) and (2.12) become D ¼ eE
ð2:25Þ
B ¼ m H
ð2:26Þ
where e and m are referred to as tensor permittivity and tensor permeability. The tensor permittivity has the matrix form 3 2 exx exy exz 7 6 ð2:27Þ e ¼ 4 eyx eyy eyz 5 ezx
ezy
ezz
and similarly for the tensor permeability. In scalar form (2.25) is thus written as Dx ¼ exx E x þ exy E y þ exz E z Dy ¼ eyx E x þ eyy E y þ eyz E z
ð2:28Þ
Dz ¼ ezx E x þ ezy E y þ ezz E z and similarly for (2.26).
2.3 Time-harmonic EM fields; polarization of a vector EM field quantities depend on the three spatial coordinates and time. The complexity of linear EM problems may be considerably reduced by referring to a time-harmonic regime. In such a case, all timevarying quantities (due to the linearity of Maxwell’s equations) are assumed to have a sine or cosine behaviour with the same radian frequency o ¼ 2pf ¼ 2p=T, where f is the frequency and T the corresponding period. This approach allows us to eliminate time from Maxwell’s equations and, as shown below, to replace the time derivatives with simple algebraic products. Under the time-harmonic regime, in fact, a time-varying quantity, aðtÞ ¼ jAjcosðot þ fÞ
ð2:29Þ
where |A| is a real positive constant, can be expressed in the form aðtÞ ¼ Re½Ae jot
ð2:30Þ
A ¼ jAje jf ¼ jAjðcos f þ j sin fÞ
ð2:31Þ
where A is a complex quantity given by
The complex number A, which is called the phasor of a(t), can thus be used to represent the corresponding time variable. It is straightforward to verify that the time derivative of a(t) has joA as its phasor, thus the time derivative is equivalent to multiplication by jo.
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
13
When dealing with quantities that are squares or products of time-harmonic variables, such as energy or power, time variations at twice the radian frequency o are produced along with steady state components. In such cases, we normally refer to the average over a time period T. Using the phasor notation (2.30), consider the product cðtÞ ¼ aðtÞbðtÞ. It can easily be seen that the time-averaged value of this quantity is ð 1 T 1 c ¼ cðtÞ dt ¼ Re AB* ð2:32Þ T 0 2 Let us now consider a vector quantity A ðtÞ: each component behaves as (2.29) so that the vector can be expressed in the form A ðtÞ ¼ Re½Ae jot
ð2:33Þ
where A is a complex vector consisting of a real and an imaginary part A ¼ Ar þ jAj
ð2:34Þ
A ðtÞ ¼ Ar cosðotÞ Aj sinðotÞ
ð2:35Þ
From (2.33) and (2.34) we obtain
Equation (2.35) shows that the vector A ðtÞ lies in the plane of the vectors Ar, Aj, its tip describing an ellipse (see Figure 2.1a). The vector is therefore said to be elliptically polarized. In special cases the ellipse may degenerate into a circle or a segment: in such cases we have circular polarization or linear polarization, respectively. The circular polarization occurs when Ar and Aj are orthogonal to each other and have equal magnitudes depending on their relative directions, the resulting vector can be right or left circularly polarized, as shown in Figures 2.1b,c. The linear polarization occurs when Ar and Aj are parallel or one of them is null (which can be considered as a special case of parallelism). Thus we have Circular polarization:
Ar Aj ¼ 0 and
Linear polarization:
Ar Aj ¼ 0
jAr j ¼ Aj
As already pointed out, a substantial simplification is obtained by assuming a time-harmonic regime. In the next section this will become more explicit by writing the corresponding expressions of Maxwell’s equations. Although at first sight this may appear as a totally arbitrary assumption, it must be recalled that Fourier series and Fourier integrals allow us to expand in harmonic components any time-periodic or time-integrable function.
ωt =
−Aj
ωt = π
30º
a(t)
ωt =
3 π 2
Ar
π 2
ωt =
ωt = 0, 2π ...
ωt = π
−Aj
3 π 2
Ar a(t)
(a)
ωt =
ωt = 0, 2π ... ωt = π
−Aj
π 2 a(t)
Ar
(b) ωt =
π 2
ωt = 0, 2π ...
(c) ωt =
3 π 2
Figure 2.1 Vector polarization: (a) elliptic; (b) right circular; (c) left circular.
14
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
From now on, unless otherwise stated, we will refer to the time-harmonic regime so that all timevarying quantities will be represented by the corresponding phasors. The time variable disappears from our equations, since the time derivative is replaced by the product jo. The commonly adopted terminology is that we operate in the frequency domain in contrast to the normal time domain.
2.4 Maxwell’s equations in the harmonic regime As shown in the previous section, time-varying quantities, both scalar and vectorial, can be represented in terms of the corresponding phasors. Since the time derivative corresponds to a multiplication by jo, the time dependence can be totally omitted from Maxwell’s equations (2.1)–(2.4), which therefore become r E ¼ joB
ð2:36Þ
r H ¼ joD þ J
ð2:37Þ
rD ¼ r
ð2:38Þ
rB ¼ 0
ð2:39Þ
We say that Equations (2.36)–(2.39) are the frequency domain Maxwell’s equations, while (2.1)–(2.4) are their time domain counterparts. In integral form (2.36)–(2.39) are written as þ ð E dl ¼ jo B dS ð2:40Þ C
S
þ
ð
ð
H dl ¼ jo D dS þ C
S
þ
J dS
ð2:41Þ
S
ð D dS ¼
S
r dV
ð2:42Þ
V
þ B dS ¼ 0
ð2:43Þ
S
The continuity equation (2.5) becomes r J ¼ jor
ð2:44Þ
The constitutive relations (2.11) and (2.12) are also expressed in the frequency domain as D ¼ eE
ð2:45Þ
B ¼ mH
ð2:46Þ
For lossy dielectrics, the permittivity e is a complex quantity, whose imaginary part (if not zero) is negative:1 e ¼ e0 je00 1
A positive imaginary part would violate the principle of energy conservation.
ð2:47Þ
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
15
Similar considerations hold for the permeability of magnetic materials. It should be stressed that the complex dielectric permittivity does not correspond to a time-varying quantity. The presence of the imaginary part of e corresponds, in time domain, to the fact that the polarization P, thus the displacement D, is phase-shifted with respect to the electric field. This has the effect of producing within the medium an energy dissipation which depends on the imaginary part of the complex permittivity (see Section 2.6). Indeed, the presence of an imaginary part is equivalent to the presence of a conduction current. According to Ohm’s law (2.16),2 the latter is proportional to the electric field. In (2.37) this current can be lumped into the displacement current in just one term proportional to E: r H ¼ joeE þ sE ¼ joðe j s=oÞE ¼ joðe0 je00 ÞE
ð2:48Þ
e00 ¼ s=o
ð2:49Þ
with
Maxwell’s equation (2.37) can thus be written as r H ¼ joec E
ð2:50Þ
where the subscript ‘c’ indicates that the permittivity is complex, its imaginary part (2.49) incorporating the ohmic current density. The complex permittivity (2.47) is often put in the form ec ¼ e0 ð1 j tan dÞ
ð2:51Þ
where tan d ¼
e00 e0
ð2:52Þ
is a parameter (called tangent delta) commonly used to characterize the quality of the dielectric material. Its values range from a few 10 4 for excellent dielectrics such as quartz (SiO2) or alumina (Al2O3) to 5 10 4 for glass and up to 10 or 100 10 4 for silicon. The permittivity is also, in general, a function of frequency. In such a case, the medium is said to be dispersive. Dispersion is indeed a feature of the material, or a transmission line, consisting of properties that are frequency dependent. A non-dispersive medium, on the contrary, does not change its properties with the frequency.
2.5 Boundary conditions The differential form of Maxwell’s equations (2.36)–(2.39) can be applied provided that the constants of the medium, such as the permittivity, permeability and, possibly, the conductivity, are continuous functions of the spatial coordinates. In practical cases we have clearly to deal with a variety of different media, so that such constants vary abruptly at the interfaces between different materials.3 The differential form of Maxwell’s equations can thus be solved only within the spatial regions where the medium’s constants are continuous. In order to obtain a unique and physically meaningful solution, suitable boundary conditions must then be imposed at the boundaries between regions occupied by different materials. Such conditions can be derived using the integral form of Maxwell’s equations and applying a 2 Since (2.16) is an instantaneous relation between J c and E , it is unchanged between the corresponding phasors: Jc ¼ sE. 3 This is true from a macroscopic point of view, where we assume a geometrical surface represents the boundary between two materials.
16
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 2.2 Continuity of B and E components at the boundary between two media. The same conditions apply to D and H, respectively, unless there are surface charges and currents.
limit procedure where a continuous variation of the medium’s constants is gradually transformed into an abrupt change. Only the results of such a procedure are reported here, along with simple hints on how it can be developed. For a complete derivation, the reader is directed to the classical textbooks in the bibliography, e.g. [3, 4]. We consider the surface S to represent the boundary between two media with constants e1, m1 and ^ be the unit vector normal to S directed from medium 1 towards medium 2 (see Figure 2.2). e2, m2. Let n From (2.42) and (2.43) we obtain4 ^ ðD2 D1 Þ ¼ 0 n
ð2:53Þ
^ ðB2 B1 Þ ¼ 0 n
ð2:54Þ
The former condition holds as long as there is no surface charge (i.e. a finite charge in an infinitesimal volume) on the boundary, which may happen only if one of the media is a perfect conductor. In all other cases, the above equations state the continuity of the normal components of both the electric displacement D and the magnetic induction B at the boundary between different materials. As far as the other EM field components are concerned, with reference to Figure 2.2, from (2.40) and (2.41) we obtain5 ^ ðE2 E1 Þ ¼ 0 n
ð2:55Þ
^ ðH2 H1 Þ ¼ 0 n
ð2:56Þ
The former condition holds as long as there is no surface current density (i.e. a finite current through an infinitesimal cross-section) on the boundary, which may happen only if one of the media is a perfect conductor. In all other cases, the above conditions state the continuity of the tangential components of both the electric and magnetic fields at the boundary between two media. When medium 1 is a perfect conductor (Figure 2.3), both a surface charge rs (C/m2) and a surface current density Js (A/m) are associated with the EM field on its boundary. In reality, these are charges and currents concentrated within a very thin layer ds (the skin depth) under the surface of a good conductor. As we will see later on in Section 2.10.3, the skin depth is given by ds ¼ ðoms=2Þ 1=2
ð2:57Þ
4 Apply (2.42) and (2.43) to a small cylinder of height h crossing the boundary, and compute the limit for vanishing h. 5 Apply (2.40) and (2.41) to a small rectangular loop with side h crossing the boundary in the limit as h ! 0.
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
17
Figure 2.3 Boundary conditions at the surface of a perfect electric conductor (pec).
For good conductors such as silver, copper or gold,6 the skin depth at a frequency of 10 GHz is a fraction of a micrometre. From a mathematical point of view, however, it is more convenient to refer to the limit case of infinite conductivity (perfect electric conductor, or pec); in this case the EM field in medium 1 is exactly zero and the skin depth is zero as well. Omitting the subscript 2, Equations (2.53)–(2.54) become in this case ^ D ¼ rs n
ð2:58Þ
^B ¼ 0 n
ð2:59Þ
On the surface of a perfect conductor, the normal component of the electric induction thus equals the surface current density, while that of the magnetic induction is zero. Concerning (2.55) and (2.56), for a perfect conductor we have ^E¼0 n
ð2:60Þ
^ H ¼ Js n
ð2:61Þ
The former equation states that on the surface of a perfect conductor the tangential component of the electric field is zero, while that of the magnetic field, after a 90 clockwise rotation, equals the surface current density. In the solution of some EM problems it may be convenient to introduce fictitious magnetic charges rsm and currents Jsm .7 Consequently, the boundary conditions (2.59) and (2.60) assume the dual form of (2.58) and (2.61) respectively: ^ B ¼ rms n
ð2:62Þ
^ E ¼ Jsm n
ð2:63Þ
2.6 Energy and power of the EM field; Poynting’s theorem The creation of an EM field requires energy to be consumed. If not transformed into other forms (e.g. thermal energy), by virtue of the conservation principle such energy is then to be found stored in the electric and magnetic fields.
6 7
Silver, copper and gold conductivities are 63 106 , 60 106 and 45 106 S/m respectively. Correspondingly, magnetic charges rm and currents Jm are introduced in the r.h.s. of (2.1) and (2.4).
18
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING The electric energy stored in an electric field in a volume V at time t is given by ð ð 1 e E ðtÞ DðtÞ dV ¼ E 2 ðtÞ dV W e ðtÞ ¼ 2 V 2 V
ð2:64Þ
using the constitutive relation (2.11). In a dual fashion, using (2.12), the instantaneous magnetic energy in V is ð ð 1 m H ðtÞ B ðtÞ dV ¼ H 2 ðtÞ dV ð2:65Þ W m ðtÞ ¼ 2 V 2 V In the case of conducting media, the electric field produces a conduction current according to Ohm’s law (2.16). The electric energy dissipates in the medium and is transformed into heat by the Joule effect. The power dissipated in a volume V is given by ð
ð E ðtÞ J ðtÞ dV ¼ s E 2 ðtÞ dV
P d ðtÞ ¼ V
ð2:66Þ
V
For time-harmonic fields, one refers to the corresponding quantities averaged over a time period T according to the formula (2.32). We therefore have, for the average electric and magnetic energies stored in one period, 1 We ¼ Re 4
ð
E D dV ¼
e0 4
ð E E* dV
ð2:67Þ
ð ð 1 m H B* dV ¼ H H* dV Wm ¼ Re 4 4 V V
ð2:68Þ
*
V
V
while the time-averaged power dissipated is ð ð 1 s E J* dV ¼ E E* dV Pd ¼ Re 2 2 V V
ð2:69Þ
the last equality holding for ohmic currents. From Maxwell’s equations (2.36)–(2.39), and using expansion (A.25) for the divergence of the product of two vectors, one obtains the following identity: r ðE H* Þ ¼ joðE D* H* BÞ E J*
ð2:70Þ
Integrating over a volume V bounded by a closed surface S, and applying the divergence theorem to the l.h.s. (A.60), one obtains the expression for Poynting’s theorem: þ ð ð 1 jo P dS ¼ E J* dV þ ðH* B E D* Þ dV ð2:71Þ 2 V 2 V S The l.h.s. of (2.71) is the flow of the complex Poynting vector defined as 1 P ¼ E H* 2 entering into the volume V. The real part of (2.71) þ ð ð 1 s E E* dV ¼ Pd Re P dS ¼ Re E J* dV ¼ 2 2 V S V
ð2:72Þ
ð2:73Þ
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
19
is interpreted as the real power entering into the volume V through S; this quantity equals the power dissipated by the conduction current by Joule effect.8 The imaginary part of (2.71) ð þ 2o ðmH H* e0 E E* Þ dV ¼ 2oðWm We Þ ð2:74Þ Im P dS ¼ 4 V S is the flow of reactive power entering in V and is equal to 2o times the difference of the average values of the magnetic and electric energy densities.
2.7 Some fundamental theorems In this section we describe some fundamental theorems of electromagnetism; the proofs can be found in many textbooks like those cited at the end of this chapter.
2.7.1
Uniqueness theorem
In the solution of EM problems it is of paramount importance to know under what conditions a solution exists and is unique. The uniqueness theorem, which we consider here only for time-harmonic fields, states that, in a volume V,9 the solution to Maxwell’s equations exists and is unique once the following quantities are known: 1. The sources of the EM fields, i.e. the electric current densities J (and possibly the magnetic currents Jm in case they are assumed to be non-zero). Here J and Jm are so-called impressed currents, corresponding to generators in lumped circuit theory. ^ E or of the magnetic field n ^ H on the 2. The tangential component of either the electric field n boundary S of V. In a source-free region the EM field is thus uniquely determined by the tangential electric or magnetic distributions on its boundary.
2.7.2
Lorentz’s reciprocity theorem
This theorem is the basis for a number of fundamental properties of both microwave and lumped circuit elements. In a volume V filled with a linear and isotropic medium with constants e, m, let J1 and J2 be two current distributions that produce the EM field distributions E1H1 and E2H2 respectively. Making use of Maxwell’s equations (2.36) and (2.37) along with the constitutive relations (2.45)–(2.46) and the expression (A.25) we obtain the following identity: r ðE1 H2 E2 H1 Þ ¼ . . . ¼ J2 E1 þ J1 E2 Integrating over the volume V and applying the divergence theorem we obtain ð þ ðE1 H2 E2 H1 Þ dS ¼ ð J2 E1 þ J1 E2 Þ dV S
8
ð2:75Þ
ð2:76Þ
V
Power loss due to polarization currents may formally be lumped into the conductivity term, recalling (2.49). For the theorem to hold, the volume is required to be filled with a lossy material, although the loss can be arbitrarily small. In a totally lossless region, such as an ideal cavity resonator, there are infinite solutions to Maxwell’s equations, called the resonant modes of the cavity (see Chapter 5). 9
20
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
S being the boundary of V. This is the basic form of Lorentz’s reciprocity theorem. In many practical cases, the l.h.s. of (2.76) vanishes (the proof can be found in [3]) so that the theorem assumes a much simpler form. This occurs when all sources of the EM field are within the volume V, for instance when V coincides with the whole space and no sources are located at infinity, or when V is bounded by a perfect electric conductor or by a surface exhibiting a surface impedance Zs such that ^H Et ¼ Zs n
ð2:77Þ
^ is the outward-directed unit normal vector. As shown later on in Section 2.10.3, a special case of where n Equation (2.77) is the so-called Leontovic boundary condition on the surface of a good conductor: Zs ¼ ð1 þ jÞ
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi om 2s
ð2:78Þ
In all the above cases, Equation (2.76) reduces to ð
ð J2 E1 dV ¼ V
J1 E2 dV
ð2:79Þ
V
Equation (2.79) constitutes the reciprocity theorem. In the case of point sources we may put Ji ¼ Ji dðr ri Þti ;
i ¼ 1; 2
ð2:80Þ
d being the Dirac delta function and ti the unit vector directed along Ji. Equation (2.79) therefore reduces to E1 ðr2 Þ t2 J2 ¼ E2 ðr1 Þ t1 J1
ð2:81Þ
The above result implies that the component of the electric field produced by the current J1 in r2 in the direction of J2 is equal to the electric field component produced by J2 in r1 in the direction of J1. As we will see in Chapter 4, such a theorem implies the symmetry properties of the impedance, admittance or scattering matrices used to characterize the electric circuits. It should be noted that the validity of the theorem is subject to (2.11)–(2.12) being applicable. It does not therefore apply to nonlinear or anisotropic materials.
2.7.3
Love’s equivalence theorem
This theorem is a consequence of the uniqueness theorem. It allows one to replace a source outside the region V with a suitable distribution of electric and magnetic currents that produce the same tangential E or H components on the boundary S of V. Consider (see Figure 2.4) a set of known sources J1 located outside the region V. Let E1, H1 be the EM field generated by J1 within V. By virtue of the uniqueness theorem, the field in V will remain unaltered if we modify the external sources, provided that the same tangential component of either the ^ E and n ^ H on S is conserved. In particular, we may put a perfect electric or magnetic field n conductor on the outer surface of V impressing at the same time on S a surface magnetic current ^ E. In this way the tangential component of the electric field on S remains unaltered. In a Jms ¼ n similar fashion we may put a perfect magnetic conductor on S by impressing at the same time on S an ^ H. The theorem can clearly be applied to the region outside V when the electric current density Js ¼ n sources are inside V.
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
21
Figure 2.4 Illustrating Love’s equivalence theorem.
2.8 Plane waves In this section we cover the basic concepts concerning wave functions and show that these are solutions to Maxwell’s equations. Let us consider a space region filled with a lossless material deprived of any sources of an EM field, thus J ¼ 0, s ¼ 0. The time-harmonic EM fields are governed by the homogeneous Maxwell’s equations r E ¼ jomH
ð2:82Þ
r H ¼ joeE
ð2:83Þ
Taking the curl of the second equation and substituting in the first one, we obtain an equation with only the E field, i.e. r2 E þ k2 E ¼ 0
ð2:84Þ
pffiffiffiffiffi k ¼ o me
ð2:85Þ
where we have put
In the derivation of (2.84) we have used the expansion (A.31) and that r E ¼ 0. Equation (2.79) is Helmholtz’s equation or the wave equation in the frequency domain. For the sake of simplicity and as an introduction, let us consider the one-dimensional case, which corresponds to the well-known harmonic motion equation d 2 f ðxÞ þ k2 f ðxÞ ¼ 0 dx2
ð2:86Þ
The general solution can be expressed as the superposition of two exponentials: f ðxÞ ¼ C þ e jkx þ C e þ jkx C
þ
and C
being arbitrary complex constants.
ð2:87Þ
22
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
As we will see later on, expression (2.87) represents voltages and currents along a transmission line. The phasor f(x) corresponds to the time function f ðx; tÞ ¼ Re½ f ðxÞe jot ¼ Re½ðC þ e jkx þ C e þ jkx Þe jot ð2:88Þ ¼ jC þ jcosðot kx þ f þ Þ þ jC jcosðot þ kx þ f Þ jj putting C ¼ C e . Either term in (2.88) is a harmonic function of the variable c ¼ ot kx or c ¼ ot þ kx. The time period is related to the radian frequency o by T ¼ 2p=o
ð2:89Þ
while the spatial period or wavelength is related to the phase constant k by l ¼ 2p=k
ð2:90Þ
In the space–time domain (x, t), the former function in (2.88) is a cosine travelling in the positive x direction with a velocity vp ¼ o=k
ð2:91Þ
This is called the phase velocity: it is the velocity of a hypothetical observer that sees a constant phase: c ¼ ot kx ¼ const:
ð2:92Þ
Differentiating (2.92), one indeed obtains dx=dt ¼ o=k. The second term in (2.88) is a cosine travelling with opposite velocity in the negative x direction. In contrast to the 1-D case, in the 3-D case no general solution exists for the wave equation (2.84). The solution is to be found on a case-by-case basis depending on the geometry of the problem and on the boundary conditions. It is nevertheless possible to identify some solutions of (2.84) that, although they do not constitute the general integral, are nevertheless meaningful solutions from a physical point of view and, due to linearity, useful for building up more complex solutions of a number of practical problems. This is specifically the case for plane waves that are obtained as special solutions of Maxwell’s equation in rectangular coordinates.
2.9 Solution of the wave equation in rectangular coordinates Using a rectangular coordinate system, Equation (2.84) can be broken down into three scalar equations, one for each scalar component: r2 Ei þ k2 Ei ¼ 0;
i ¼ x; y; z
ð2:93Þ
Solutions to the above scalar wave equations can be obtained by the method of separation of variables.
The method consists of factorizing the unknown function Ei(x,y,z) into the product of three functions, each depending on a single coordinate: Ei (x,y,z) ¼ X(x)Y(y)Z(z). In such a way, with simple algebra, Equation (2.93) becomes 1 d 2X 1 d2Y 1 d 2Z þ þ ¼ k2 ¼ ðkx2 þ ky2 þ kz2 Þ 2 2 X dx Y dy Z dz2
ð2:94Þ
where the constant k2 has been expressed as the sum of three constants kx2 , ky2 , kz2 . The above equality can hold at any point (x, y, z) only if each term on the r.h.s. is a constant. This yields three ordinary differential equations (harmonic motion equations) whose solutions are of the type XðxÞ ¼ Cx e jkx x etc., whence we easily get (2.95).
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
23
In a rectangular coordinate system the solutions are of the type Eðx; y; zÞ ¼ E0 e jk r
ð2:95Þ
where E0 is a (complex) constant vector, r is the position vector r ¼ x^x þ y^y þ z^z
ð2:96Þ
and k is the propagation vector which has only to satisfy the separability condition k k ¼ kx2 þ ky2 þ kz2 ¼ o2 me
ð2:97Þ
The magnetic field is obtained from the E field (2.95) using (2.82): Hðx; y; zÞ ¼ H0 e jk r
ð2:98Þ
where H0 ¼
1 k E0 om
ð2:99Þ
Note that (2.97) is equally satisfied by reversing the sign of k. Therefore, if (2.95) and (2.98) are a solution to Maxwell’s equations, then another solution is obtained by reversing the sign of k. Inserting (2.98) and (2.95) into (2.83), we obtain also E0 ¼
1 k H0 oe
ð2:100Þ
In the general case, k is a complex vector which has to satisfy the condition (2.97). Let us split k into its real and imaginary parts by putting k ¼ b ja
ð2:101Þ
The reason for the minus sign in the imaginary part will become clear later on. Equation (2.97) then implies b2 a2 ¼ o2 me ab ¼ 0
ð2:102Þ
The second of the above equations shows that a and b are orthogonal one to each other, or a is zero, which is a particular case of orthogonality. Inserting expression (2.101) into (2.95), we obtain for the E field Eðx; y; zÞ ¼ E0 e jb r e a r Hðx; y; zÞ ¼ H0 e jb r e a r
ð2:103Þ
The electric field has a constant phase when b r ¼ const:, thus on any plane perpendicular to the vector b, which is therefore called the phase vector. The EM field represented by (2.103) is called a plane wave because the constant-phase surfaces are planes. The field amplitude is constant on the planes a r ¼ const: which are orthogonal to a. The field decays exponentially in the direction of the vector a, which is therefore called the attenuation vector, and has constant amplitudes on the planes orthogonal to a. It is important to point out that the orthogonality between a and b, thus of the constant-phase and constant-amplitude planes, depends on the medium where the wave propagates being without loss. Otherwise, the dielectric constant would be complex and the r.h.s. of the second equation of (2.102) would be non-zero.
24
2.9.1
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Plane waves: an alternative derivation
As we have just seen, plane waves are a solution to homogeneous (i.e. source-free) Maxwell’s equations in rectangular coordinates. This result has been obtained by solving the wave equation for the E field using the method of separation of variables. An alternative and speedier way to reach the same result consists of searching directly for a solution of homogeneous Maxwell’s equations (2.82) and (2.83) by assuming Eðx; y; zÞ ¼ E0 e jk r
ð2:104Þ
Hðx; y; zÞ ¼ H0 e jk r
ð2:105Þ
with E0 and H0 constant vectors and k a (so far) arbitrary vector. E0 and H0 are not independent of each other since the EM field must satisfy Maxwell’s equations (2.82)–(2.83). It is easy to realize that, because of (2.104)–(2.105), the divergence and curl operators become simple algebraic vector operators: r ¼ jk r ¼ jk
ð2:106Þ
Using the above equalities, after inserting (2.104) and (2.105) into (2.82) and (2.83), we obtain k E0 ¼ omH0
ð2:107Þ
k H0 ¼ oeE0
ð2:108Þ
which are clearly equivalent to (2.100) and (2.99) respectively. From (2.107), and (2.108) in particular, we deduce that k E0 ¼ 0 k H0 ¼ 0
ð2:109Þ
The above expressions imply the orthogonality of k, E and H;10 they are a consequence of E and H having zero divergence (see the first equation of (2.106)). Equations (2.107)–(2.108) constitute six homogeneous scalar equations in six unknown EM field components. In order for non-trivial solutions to exist, the determinant of the coefficient matrix must be zero. It can easily be verified that such a condition coincides with the separability condition (2.97); moreover, when such a condition is satisfied, the rank of the coefficient matrix reduces to 4. This means that only four out of six equations are linearly independent and two arbitrary quantities must be given. For example, we may arbitrarily fix the Ez and Hz components and express all other components in terms of them. In this fashion, provided that kx and ky are not both zero (i.e. the wave does not propagate in the z direction), we obtain E0x ¼
1 ðkx kz E0z þ omky H0z Þ kx2 þ ky2
E0y ¼
1 ðky kz E0z omkx H0z Þ kx2 þ ky2
H0x ¼
1 ðoeky E0z kx kz H0z Þ kx2 þ ky2
H0y ¼
ð2:110Þ
1 ðoekx E0z þ ky kz H0z Þ þ ky2
kx2
10 The term orthogonality is used here in a generalized sense to mean that the scalar product of two possibly complex vectors is zero. If such vectors have non-zero real and imaginary parts, this type of orthogonality clearly does not imply geometrical orthogonality, as is the case when the vectors are real.
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
25
When E0z and H0z are given, all remaining EM field components are thus determined. Other solutions can be obtained by simply circularly interchanging the indexes (x ! y, y ! z, z ! x).
2.9.2
TEM waves
Let us now suppose that kx ¼ ky ¼ 0, thus k2 ¼ kz2 . Since the propagation vector has only the z component, because of (2.102) a must be zero and the propagation vector is real: k¼b
ð2:111Þ
Because of (2.111), Equations (2.104) and (2.105) may be rewritten as Eðx; y; zÞ ¼ E0 e jbz Hðx; y; zÞ ¼ H0 e jbz
ð2:112Þ
x0 . Let us assume for simplicity that E0 is real and directed along the x axis, thus E0 ¼ E0r ¼ E0x ^ Using (2.33), the corresponding time-harmonic quantity is E ðx; y; z; tÞ ¼ Re½E0 e jbz e jot ¼ E0r cosðot bzÞ
ð2:113Þ
This is a linearly polarized vector wave function propagating in the positive z direction with phase velocity, as already defined in (2.91), vp ¼
o 1 ¼ pffiffiffiffiffi b me
ð2:114Þ
Expressions (2.110) cannot clearly be applied as all denominators are zero. From (2.107)–(2.108) we easily obtain instead b H0y oe b E0y ¼ H0x oe E0z ¼ 0 E0x ¼
ð2:115Þ
H0z ¼ 0 where pffiffiffiffiffi b ¼ kz ¼ o me
ð2:116Þ
Equations (2.115) are two distinct solutions of (2.107)–(2.108), each possessing only two non-zero components of the EM field: either Ex, Hy or Ey, Hx. Both are therefore linearly polarized. One can be obtained from the other by a simple 90 rotation around the z axis (Ex ! Ey, Hy ! Hx). Such solutions represent TEM (or Transverse Electromagnetic) waves, since the electric and magnetic fields are both perpendicular to the direction of propagation z. Since the attenuation is zero, the EM field has the same amplitude in the whole space. For this reason they are also called uniform plane waves. The ratio between the transverse components of the electric and magnetic fields is given in both cases by rffiffiffi Ex Ey m ð2:117Þ Z¼ ¼ ¼ e Hy Hx where we have used (2.116). The above quantity is called the wave impedance. Observe that the E- and H-field components and the propagation direction z must be taken according to a right-handed orthogonal
26
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
triplet (e.g. [x, y, z], [y, x, z], [y, x, z], etc.). This is the reason for the minus sign in front of Hx in (2.117). Equation (2.99) can be written in the form 1 H0 ¼ b^ E0 Z
ð2:118Þ
where ^b is the unit vector in the direction of b. Using (2.112) and (2.118), the Poynting vector (2.72) is 1 1 P ¼ E H* ¼ . . . ¼ E02 ^ b 2 2Z
ð2:119Þ
The wave impedance of TEM waves depends only on the parameters of the medium. For a generic material we define its intrinsic impedance as pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð2:120Þ Zi ¼ m=ec For a lossless material ec ¼ e, thus this quantity clearly coincides with the wave impedance of the TEM waves. This result does not hold in general, as the wave impedance may differ from the intrinsic impedance of the medium. For the vacuum we have rffiffiffiffiffi m0 Z0 ¼ ffi 120p ¼ 377O ð2:121Þ e0 It is also important to observe that, because of linearity, any linear superposition of the two solutions (2.115) is still a solution of (2.107)–(2.108).
2.9.3
TE and TM waves
Expressions (2.110) show that, apart from the case of TEM waves propagating in the z direction already discussed above, plane wave solutions in the general case when a „ 0 can be expressed as the combination of TE (Transverse Electric) waves with E0z ¼ 0 and TM (Transverse Magnetic) waves with H0z ¼ 0. Let us look at those solutions. Because of (2.102), the phase vector and the attenuation vector must be orthogonal. For simplicity, suppose that the waves propagate in the z direction and attenuate in the x direction. Therefore k ¼ b^z ja^ x
ð2:122Þ
Eðx; y; zÞ ¼ E0 e jbz e ax
ð2:123Þ
Hðx; y; zÞ ¼ H0 e jbz e ax
ð2:124Þ
Equations (2.104) and (2.105) become
Let us consider TE waves first. From (2.110), putting E0z ¼ 0 we obtain jom H0z a jb H0z ¼ a
E0y ¼ H0x
ð2:125Þ
while E0x ¼ 0 and H0y ¼ 0. The wave impedance of TE waves is ZTE ¼
E0y om ¼ H0x b
ð2:126Þ
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
27
The Poynting vector is
1 1 2ax 2 * 1 1 a 2 2ax ^z þ j ^ E0y k ¼ e P ¼ E H* ¼ . . . ¼ e x E0y 2 2om 2 ZTE om
ð2:127Þ
In contrast with the TEM case, the Poynting vector is complex and the power density decays exponentially with attenuation 2a in the x direction. The real part of the Poynting vector is directed along the direction z of the phase vector, while the imaginary part is directed along the direction of the attenuation. In a dual way, for TM waves (H0z ¼ 0) one obtains jb E0z a joe H0y ¼ E0z a
E0x ¼
ð2:128Þ
while E0y ¼ 0 and H0x ¼ 0. The wave impedance of TM waves is ZTM ¼
E0x b ¼ H0y oe
ð2:129Þ
The Poynting vector is
1 1 2ax 2 1 a 2 2ax ^ e ZTM ^z j x H0y H0y k ¼ e P ¼ E H* ¼ . . . ¼ 2 2oe 2 om
ð2:130Þ
Similar considerations hold as for the TE waves.
2.10 Reflection and transmission of plane waves; Snel’s laws The solutions to Maxwell’s equations discussed in the previous section are valid in unbounded media, but practical problems involve discontinuities between media with different EM properties. To take a step further towards reality, and still using an oversimplified model, let us consider two half spaces, each filled with a different dielectric material with parameters e1, m1 for z < 0 and e2, m2 for z > 0. Both media are supposed to be lossless. The geometry of our problem is depicted in Figure 2.5, the z axis being perpendicular to the boundary z ¼ 0 between the two media. Suppose there exists a uniform plane wave, produced by an infinitely remote source, with phase vector b1, forming an angle yi, the angle of incidence, to the normal to the surface of separation bi ¼ b1 ð^x sin yi þ ^z cos yi Þ
Figure 2.5
Reflection and transmission of plane waves.
ð2:131Þ
28
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where b1 ¼ o me0 er1 ¼ b0 er1 and b0 is the phase constant of vacuum.The EM field of the wave can be expressed as Ei ¼ E0i e jbi r ¼ E0i e jb1 ðx sin yi þ z cos yi Þ Hi ¼ bi Ei =ðomÞ
ð2:132Þ
E0i is orthogonal to bi and in general may be linearly or elliptically polarized. Expressions (2.132) for the EM field would be a valid solution if all space were filled with dielectric 1. However, they do not satisfy Maxwell’s equations in medium 2 for z > 0. The solution to the problem must be found by summing in (2.132) the ‘reaction’ of the structure to the wave (2.132) that we have impressed on it, and which we call the incident wave. Such a reaction must be sought among the solutions to Maxwell’s equations in such a way that, after summing to the incident wave, the boundary conditions at z ¼ 0 are satisfied. To this end it is sufficient for z < 0 to add to the incident wave (2.132) another wave, which we call the reflected wave, and, for z > 0, to consider another wave in medium 2, which we call the transmitted wave. The overall field for z < 0 that results from the superposition of the incident plus the reflect wave, and the field of the transmitted wave for z > 0, must satisfy the boundary conditions at z ¼ 0, i.e. the continuity of the tangential components of the electric and magnetic fields. With the notation of Figure 2.5, the reflected wave for z < 0 is expressed as Er ¼ E0r e jbr r ¼ E0r e jb1 ðx sin yr z cos yr Þ Hr ¼ br Er =ðomÞ
ð2:133Þ
where br ¼ b1 ð^x sin yr ^z cos yr Þ
ð2:134Þ
while the transmitted wave in z > 0 can be written as Et ¼ E0t e jbt r ¼ E0t e jb2 ðx sin yt þ z cos yt Þ Ht ¼ bt Et =ðomÞ
ð2:135Þ
with bt ¼ b2 ð^x sin yt þ ^z cos yt Þ pffiffiffiffiffiffi b2 ¼ b0 er2
2.10.1
ð2:136Þ ð2:137Þ
Snel’s laws; total reflection
Expressions (2.132), (2.133) and (2.135) are all solutions of Maxwell’s equations in the respective media 1 and 2. The solution to our problem, as already stated, must satisfy the boundary conditions, i.e. the continuity conditions at z ¼ 0. Such conditions first imply that the law of variation along the common x direction for z ¼ 0 must be the same for all waves. Therefore bix ¼ brx ¼ btx
ð2:138Þ
Using (2.131), (2.134) and (2.136) we easily obtain yr ¼ yi pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffi er1 sin yi ¼ er2 sin yt
ð2:139Þ
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
29
The above equations constitute Snel’s laws. The former states that the angle of reflection is equal to the angle of incidence; according to the second law, the transmission angle (or angle of refraction) can be expressed as sin yt ¼ where ni ¼
rffiffiffiffiffiffi er1 n1 sin yi ¼ sin yi er2 n2
ð2:140Þ
pffiffiffiffiffi eri is the refractive index of the ith medium.
Willebrord Snel van Royen (1580–1626) was a Dutch mathematician, whose Latinized name was Snellius. Snel observed that a ray of light incident on a rectangular tank of water, as shown in Figure 2.6, refracted at the point O, is such that the distance of the actual refracted ray C from the point of refraction O is in a fixed ratio to the distance B from O of the extrapolated ray, regardless of the angle of incidence. The reader can easily prove that OC=OB ¼ n2 , n2 being the refractive index of water.
From (2.140) it follows that cosyt ¼
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er1 2 1 sin2 yt ¼ 1 sin yi er2
ð2:141Þ
Note that when er1 > er2 , i.e. the wave comes from a denser to a less dense medium, e.g. from glass to air, the angle of refraction is greater than the angle of incidence: yt > yi . Clearly there exists a critical angle yc such that yt ¼ p/2. Using (2.140) we obtain yc ¼ sin 1
er2 er1
ð2:142Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi For angles of incidence greater than yc, er1 =er2 sin yi > 1 and Equation (2.140) does not yield real solutions for yt.11 Such a seeming inconsistency occurs because we have implicitly assumed that the 11
In fact, solving for yt , (2.140) yields
yt ¼ p2 þ j cosh 1
qffiffiffiffi er1 er2
sin yi
ð2:143Þ
Putting yt ¼ ytr þ jytj , and using well-known trigonometric formulae, we have
sin yt ¼ sin ytr cosð jytj Þ þ cos ytr sinð jytj Þ ¼ sin ytr cosh ytj þ j cos ytr sinh ytj
ð2:144Þ
In deriving the last equality we used the following properties:
cosð jjÞ ¼ cosh j sinð jjÞ ¼ j sinh j
ð2:145Þ
Inserting (2.139) into (2.135) and equating the real and imaginary parts of both sides, we easily find
ytr ¼
p 2
cosh ytj ¼
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er1 sin yi er2
ð2:146Þ
30
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 2.6
Snel’s experiment.
transmitted wave is a uniform plane wave, i.e. that at ¼ 0. In reality, for angles of incidence greater than the critical angle, the transmitted wave is attenuated along the z direction, the propagation vector being kt ¼ b2 ^x ja2^z . In fact, (2.141) can be written as cos yt ¼ j
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er1 2 sin yi 1 er2
ð2:147Þ
The minus sign in front of the square root has been used for a reason that will soon become apparent. Inserting (2.140) and (2.147) into the expression for the phase vector of the transmitted wave (2.136) and using kt instead of b t, we obtain rffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er1 er kt ¼ bt jat ¼ b2 x^ sin yi j^z sin2 yi 1 er2 er2
ð2:148Þ
The complex propagation vector represents a TE or TM wave propagating in the x direction and attenuated in the z direction, with rffiffiffiffiffiffi er1 sin yi ¼ ^ xb1 sin yi er2
ð2:149Þ
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er1 2 er2 sin yi 1 ¼ ^zb1 sin2 yi er2 er1
ð2:150Þ
bt ¼ ^xb2
at ¼ ^zb2
As we saw in the previous section, such a wave does not carry any real power in the z direction, and thus inside the second medium. This is called a surface wave since it propagates along the boundary between the two media and decays exponentially towards the second medium. The real power carried by the incident wave is conveyed into the reflected wave. For this reason we say that for angles of incidence greater than the critical angle yc, the total reflection occurs. It is worth specifying that, although the incident power is totally reflected by the discontinuity between the two media, the field inside the second medium is not zero, but it decays exponentially as it enters from its surface.
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
2.10.2
31
Reflection and transmission (Fresnel’s) coefficients
Conditions (2.138), and thus Snel’s laws (2.139), are necessary but not sufficient to ensure the continuity of the tangential components of the electric and magnetic fields across the boundary z ¼ 0. Let us assume that the incident field is linearly polarized; by virtue of the linearity of Maxwell’s equations, the case of elliptical polarization can be studied by superposition. We intend now to derive the expressions for the reflection and transmission coefficients at the boundary between the two media. To do this in a speedy way we will follow a procedure based on the equivalence between waves and transmission lines. More precisely, an equivalence can be stated between the E and H components tangential to the discontinuity between the media and voltages and currents along transmission lines. The reader already familiar with transmission lines will easily recognize the similarity of the procedure that we are going to develop with that used in the simple problem of computing the reflection coefficient of a load (medium 2) seen by a transmission line of different impedance (medium 1). Using the subscript ‘t’ to indicate components parallel to the z ¼ 0 plane, let E0it ; E0rt ; E0tt H0it ; H0rt ; H0tt be the E-field and H-field components of the incident, reflected and transmitted waves, respectively, tangential to the boundary z ¼ 0. The continuity of the fields across the plane z ¼ 0 requires E0it þ E0rt ¼ E0tt H0it þ H0rt ¼ H0tt
ð2:151Þ
Let us now introduce the concept of tangential impedance Zt as the ratio of the tangential E- and H-field components. Using the field equations (2.132), (2.133) and (2.135), we may write E0it E0rt ¼ H0it H0rt E0tt Zt2 ¼ H0tt
Zt1 ¼
ð2:152Þ
As we will see in detail later on, the tangential impedances Zt1, Zt2 depend in practice on the polarization and angle of incidence of the incoming wave. The reflection coefficient and the transmission coefficient are defined as E0rt E0it E0tt T¼ E0it
G¼
ð2:153Þ
respectively. Using (2.152) and (2.153), the system (2.151) can be written as 1þG ¼ T 1 1 ð1 GÞ ¼ T Zt1 Zt2
ð2:154Þ
The above system of equations is easily solved to get G¼
Zt2 Zt1 Zt2 þ Zt1
T¼
2Zt2 Zt2 þ Zt1
ð2:155Þ
32
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 2.7
Perpendicular polarization.
In order to specify the values of the tangential impedances, we need to distinguish two cases, depending on whether the electric field is perpendicular or parallel to the plane of incidence, i.e. the plane (xz) containing the phase vector b 1 of the incident wave and the direction (z) normal to the boundary (see Figure 2.5).
Perpendicular polarization This case is illustrated in Figure 2.7. The electric field vectors of the incident, reflected and transmitted fields in (2.132), (2.133) and (2.135) can be written as follows: E0i ¼ E0i ^y E0r ¼ E0r y^
ð2:156Þ
E0r ¼ E0t ^y Correspondingly, the magnetic field vectors are H0i ¼
E0i ð ^x cos yi þ ^z sin yi Þ Z1
H0r ¼
E0r ð^x cos yi þ ^z sin yi Þ Z1
H0t ¼
E0t ð ^x cos yt þ ^z sin yt Þ Z2
ð2:157Þ
recalling that yr ¼ yi . The tangential impedances are therefore Zt1 ¼
E0i E0r Z ¼ ¼ 1 H0ix H0rx cos yi
Zt2 ¼
E0t Z ¼ 2 H0tx cos yt
ð2:158Þ
Inserting (2.158) into (2.155) and using (2.141), we obtain after some simple algebra rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er2 sin2 yi er1 Z2 cos yi Z1 cos yt . . . rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi G? ¼ ¼ ¼ er2 Z2 cos yi þ Z1 cos yt sin2 yi cos yi þ er1 cos yi
T? ¼
2Z2 cos yi ¼ ... ¼ Z2 cos yi þ Z1 cos yt
2 cos yi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er2 cos yi þ sin2 yi er1
ð2:159Þ
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
Figure 2.8
33
Reflection coefficients vs. angle of incidence.
Typical behaviour of the reflection coefficient versus the angle of incidence for the case of perpendicular polarization is shown in Figure 2.8. Note that the reflection coefficient is an increasing function of yi.
Parallel polarization
This is a dual case of the perpendicular polarization. As sketched in Figure 2.9, the magnetic field is directed along y while the electric field lies is in the xz plane: Ei ¼ E0i ð^x cos yi ^z sin yi Þ
H0i ¼ ^ yE0i =Z1
Er ¼ E0r ð ^x cos yi ^z sin yi Þ
H0r ¼ ^ yE0r =Z1
Et ¼ E0t ð^x cos yt ^z sin yt Þ
H0t ¼ ^ yE0t =Z2
ð2:160Þ
The tangential impedances are Zt1 ¼
E0ix E0rx ¼ ¼ Z1 cos yi H0i H0r
Zt2 ¼
E0tx ¼ Z2 cos yt H0t
Figure 2.9
Parallel polarization.
ð2:161Þ
34
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Using (2.161) in (2.155) we get E0rx Gjj ¼ E0ix
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er2 sin2 yi er1 Z2 cos yt Z1 cos yi ¼ rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ er2 Z2 cos yt þ Z1 cos y sin2 yi þ er1
er2 cos yi er1 er2 cos yi er1
ð2:162Þ
As far as the transmission coefficient is concerned, notice that the definition (2.153) corresponds to the ratio of the tangential x components to the transmitted and incident fields. Rather, one commonly refers to the transmission coefficient as the ratio of the full amplitudes of the fields.12 Therefore Tjj ¼
E0t E0tx =cos yt 2Z2 cos yi 2cos yi ¼ ¼ ¼ rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er2 er2 E0i E0ix =cos yi Z2 cos yt þ Z1 cos yi sin2 yi þ cos y er1 er1
ð2:163Þ
Typical behaviour of the reflection coefficient (2.162) as a function of the angle of incidence is also shown in Figure 2.8. A special feature is apparent, since for a particular incident angle yB, called the Brewster angle, the reflection coefficient becomes zero. Putting Gjj ¼ 0 in (2.162), one obtains13 yt ¼ p=2 yi Therefore, inserting this into Snell’s law (2.139) we obtain rffiffiffiffiffiffi er2 tan yB ¼ er1
ð2:164Þ
ð2:165Þ
The Brewster angle is also called the polarization angle. Indeed, when the incident wave is elliptically polarized, it can be seen as the superposition of two linearly polarized waves, one parallel and one perpendicularly polarized. Since the parallel polarized wave is totally absorbed by the second medium, the reflected wave will be linearly polarized.
2.10.3
Reflection from a conducting plane
So far we have assumed that both media where the EM field propagates are perfect dielectrics. While we will not consider the case of lossy dielectrics, an important case is to be considered, i.e. when medium 2 is a good conductor. In fact, this case is representative of a number of practical applications and is the basis for the evaluation of the loss in a conductor. As shown in Figure 2.10, if medium 2 is a good conductor, then s oe0 er2 so that its complex dielectric constant can be written as ec2 ¼ e0 er2 js=o ffi js=o
ð2:166Þ
In contrast with the case of a perfect dielectric considered so far, the propagation vector kt of the transmitted wave in medium 2 has both a real and an imaginary part; the condition (2.97) becomes kt kt ¼ b2t a2t 2jbt at ¼ o2 mec ffi joms
ð2:167Þ
Equating the real and imaginary parts of the above complex equation we obtain b2t ¼ a2t bt at ffi
oms 2
ð2:168Þ ð2:169Þ
12 In the case of the reflection coefficient the two definitions coincide since the angle of reflection equals the angle of incidence. pffiffiffiffi 13 pffiffiffiffi e1 cos yt ¼ e2 cos yi . Combining with (2.139) we get sin yt cos yt ¼ sin yi cos yi , thus sin 2yt ¼ sin 2yi . This equality implies that yt ¼ p=2 yi , since the case yt ¼ yi may not be considered as it would imply e2 ¼ e1.
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
Figure 2.10
35
Reflection from a conducting plane.
To ensure the continuity of the fields along the x axis for z ¼ 0, we must have ktx ¼ kix, thus atx ¼ 0
ð2:170Þ
btx ¼ bt sin yt ¼ bix ¼ b1 sin yi
ð2:171Þ
and pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where b1 ¼ o me0 er1 ¼ b0 er1 . Using the above equations, (2.168) and (2.169) become b21 sin2 yi þ b2tz ¼ a2tz btz atz ¼
oms 2
ð2:172Þ ð2:173Þ
In the hypothesis of very high conductivity of medium 2, the x component (2.171) of bt becomes pffiffiffi negligible with respect to the z component since, according to (2.173), both btz and atz increase with s. 2 2 Neglecting the term b1 sin yi in (2.172) we obtain rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi oms 1 ð2:174Þ bt ¼ at ¼ ¼ 2 ds where
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 ds ¼ oms
ð2:175Þ
is the skin depth of the conductor (see below).14 As the EM field penetrates into the conductor, its amplitude decays exponentially with attenuation at given by (2.174); at the distance ds ¼ 1=at the field
14
If the reader is interested in the exact solution of (2.167) here it is:
1 ¼ 2 ds
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 2 d b b2 1 þ s ix ix 2 2
1 a2tz ¼ 2 ds
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 2 d b b2 1 þ s ix þ ix 2 2
b2tz
Since the quantity
2 2 ds bix oe1 2
¼ sin yi 2 s is negligible with respect to unity, the above expressions for btz and atz reduce to (2.174).
ð2:176Þ
ð2:177Þ
36
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
amplitude is reduced to e 1 ffi 0:137. From (2.171) we get for the angle of refraction rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi b1 sin yi 2oe0 er1 sin yt ¼ ¼ ds b1 sin yi ¼ sin yi 1 bt s
ð2:178Þ
Consider for example a plane wave at a frequency f ¼ 10 MHz impinging from air on a metal surface of iron at an angle of 45 . Since the conductivity of iron is s ¼ 1 107 S=m, we obtain in this case that the skin depth is ds ¼ 0:159 mm. Moreover, b1 ¼ 0:210 per metre and the angle of refraction is yt ¼ 0:33 10 6 rad. Using (2.174), the propagation vector of the transmitted wave is therefore rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi oms ð1 jÞ^z ð2:179Þ kt ffi 2 This result tells us that the transmitted wave is a uniform plane wave in practice, since the equal-phase planes are also equal-amplitude planes; indeed the x component of the phase vector is much smaller that the z component, so that the angle of refraction can be very well approximated with zero whatever the angle of incidence. In such conditions, the electric and magnetic fields of the transmitted wave are tangential to the surface z ¼ 0 of the conductor. More specifically, suppose that the incident field is perpendicularly polarized: Ei ¼ ^yE0i e jb1 ðx sin yi þ z cos yi Þ Hi ¼
E0i ð ^x cos yi þ ^z sin yi Þe jb1 ðx sin yi þ z cos yi Þ Z1
ð2:180Þ
The electric field transmitted in the conductor is Et ¼ ^yE0t e jbt r ¼ ^yE0t e jb1 x sin yi jbt z e at z
ð2:181Þ
while the magnetic field can be written as Ht ¼
1 1 kt Et ¼ ^z Et om Zc
where Zc is the intrinsic impedance of the conductor rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffi m om ffi ð1 þ jÞ Zc ¼ ec2 2s
ð2:182Þ
ð2:183Þ
Such a quantity plays the role of a surface impedance as it determines the ratio of the electric and magnetic fields tangential to the surface of the conductor. Equation (2.182) can be put in the form ^ Ht Et ¼ Zc n
ð2:184Þ
^ being the normal unit vector directed outside the metal. Equation (2.184) is called the Leontovic n condition: it allows us to determine the electric field at the surface of a conductor in terms of the magnetic field. The same result is obtained for a parallel polarized incident wave.
2.11 Electrodynamic potentials Maxwell’s equations can be solved formally in terms of auxiliary variables, called electrodynamic potentials, which represent the generalization to the dynamic case of the static scalar potential V(r) from which the static electric field can be obtained as its gradient E ¼ rV.
BASIC ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY
37
Consider Maxwell’s equations in a medium with constants m and e. r E ¼ jomH
ð2:185Þ
r H ¼ joeE þ J
ð2:186Þ
If the magnetic permeability is the same in the whole space, from (2.185) it follows that r H ¼ 0. Since a zero divergence vector can be expressed as the curl of another vector we may write H¼rA
ð2:187Þ
A is called the magnetic vector potential.15 Inserting (2.187) into (2.185), we find r ðE þ jomAÞ ¼ 0 ) E þ jomA ¼ rF
ð2:188Þ
where the last equality is a consequence of the fact that a zero curl vector, i.e. a conservative field, can be expressed as the gradient of a scalar potential F. The electric field can thus be expressed in terms of the vector potential A and the scalar potential F: E ¼ jomA rF
ð2:189Þ
Inserting (2.189) and (2.185) into (2.186), we obtain r r A ¼ rr A r2 A ¼ joeð jomA rFÞ þ J
ð2:190Þ
rr A r2 A ¼ k2 A joerF þ J
ð2:191Þ
whence
where k2 ¼ o2me. So far, we have specified only the curl of the vector potential A; without affecting its curl we may arbitrarily fix its divergence in such a way as to simplify Equation (2.190). Let us therefore put r A ¼ joeF
ð2:192Þ
This is called the Lorentz gauge. As a consequence, (2.191) becomes r2 A þ k2 A ¼ J
ð2:193Þ
Suppose we are able to solve (2.193) with appropriate boundary conditions: the magnetic field can then be calculated using (2.187), while the electric field can be expressed in terms of only A using (2.189) and (2.192). The resulting expression is E ¼ jomA þ
rr A jom
ð2:194Þ
A totally dual procedure can be developed assuming that there are magnetic current sources Jsm instead of electric sources Js. In such a case Maxwell’s equations are r E ¼ jomH Jm
ð2:195Þ
r H ¼ joeE
ð2:196Þ
15 Usually (see for instance [3] and [4]) the magnetic vector potential is defined through the magnetic induction, i.e. we put B ¼ r A. Assuming that the medium is homogeneous, and thus m is constant, the choice of (2.187) is preferred here as it yields dual expressions for E and H.
38
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
It is now the turn of the E field to be solenoidal. By introducing an electric vector potential F and continuing in much the same way, we find that it must satisfy Helmholtz’s equation r2 F þ k 2 F ¼ J m
ð2:197Þ
E ¼ r F
ð2:198Þ
while the EM field is obtained from
H ¼ joeF þ
rr F jom
ð2:199Þ
In the absence of both electric (J ¼ 0) and magnetic (Jm ¼ 0) sources, Equations (2.193) and (2.197) become homogeneous. The EM field can be derived either in terms of A through (2.187) and (2.194) or in terms of F through (2.198) and (2.199).
Bibliography 1. 2. 3. 4.
J. A. Stratton, Electromagnetic Theory, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1941. J. D. Jackson, Classical Electrodynamics, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1962. R. E. Collin, Foundations for Microwave Engineering, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1992. C. A. Balanis, Advanced Engineering Electromagnetics, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1989.
3
Guided EM propagation 3.1 Introduction Transmission lines are fundamental components of any RF apparatus or system. They are necessary to connect devices and components in order to transmit the RF signal from one point to the other. At RFs the passive components themselves behave as distributed elements made of transmission line or waveguide sections. Because of the high operating frequencies, in fact, the dimensions of the circuit elements are normally of the same order of magnitude as the wavelength. There is an ample variety of transmission lines or, more generally, of guiding structures or waveguides. The choice of one rather than another type is based on a number of practical considerations, such as loss, weight and size, cost, compatibility with active devices. The use of high frequencies requires on the one hand more sophisticated models capable of accounting for propagation delay effects along the circuit elements and within the electronic devices themselves; on the other hand, the frequency increase is normally associated with an increase in the losses. These are mainly due to electric currents flowing in the conductors and to spurious radiation from discontinuities and interconnections. For such reasons, the structures employed to guide the EM signal must be chosen properly depending on the operating frequency, in order to minimize the power loss. As an example, the twin line commonly employed at industrial or low frequencies cannot be used at RF because of its high radiation loss. It is therefore replaced by the coaxial cable, which, in turn, becomes quite lossy above a few tens of gigahertz and must be replaced by the waveguide. Figure 3.1 shows the most common transmission lines and guiding structures employed at RF and microwaves. On the one side, except for the circular dielectric waveguide where the EM field is confined by the dielectric discontinuity, we have conventional closed structures such as the coaxial cable and metal waveguides of various shapes, where the field is confined by metal walls. On the other side, we have planar, printed or integrated circuits fabricated on top of a thin dielectric substrate, such as the stripline or the microstrip line; because of their advantages in terms of reduced size, weight and cost, they are the most frequently employed transmission lines, except when the requirements of low loss or high power can only be matched by the use of waveguides. Multi-conductor transmission lines such as the coaxial cable support the propagation of a TEM mode starting from DC. Waveguides that are made of only one conductor, on the contrary, are characterized by a cut-off frequency, below which EM propagation cannot take place. Intermediate between the printed circuit and waveguide is the fin line, consisting of a slotline
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
40
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.1
Some common transmission lines for RF and microwaves.
located in the so-called E plane of the rectangular waveguide. The image line consists of a rectangular dielectric guide laid on a metal plane. With the exception of the stripline, planar circuits are characterized by the inhomogeneity between the dielectric substrate and the air over it. As a consequence they exhibit a dispersive behaviour, i.e. a frequency dependence of the propagation characteristics. A comparison of the properties of the various structures according to application is presented in Table 3.1. Under the term waveguide we consider circular, rectangular and ridge waveguides, in the order of increasing loss (thus decreasing quality factor). Similarly, the useful frequency range is narrowest for the circular and broadest for the ridge waveguide – and just the opposite with the transverse size and power handling. The quality factors are of the order of a few thousands for rectangular guides, some hundreds for coaxial cables, a few hundreds for the suspended stripline and some tenths for striplines and microstrip lines. Another important characteristic of a transmission line is its integrability with active devices. From this point of view, printed circuit lines, particularly the microstrip and the coplanar waveguide, offer the best advantages as they allow the use of multi-terminal devices. The coplanar waveguide has the further advantage over the microstrip of having all conductors on the same side of the substrate, so allowing easy mounting of devices in shunt configuration. On the contrary, the other technologies, such as the stripline, the suspended stripline, the fin line, the coaxial cable and the waveguide, do not allow anything but two-terminal devices (diodes) to be employed.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
41
Table 3.1 Comparison between various types of transmission lines. Transmission line Waveguide Coaxial cable Stripline Microstrip Coplanar line Slotline Suspended stripline Image line
Z0 ðOÞ
Q
Small size
Handled power
Compatibility with active devices
Low cost
1–300 <50 <20 <50 <100 <40 <50
100–500 10–600 10–120 10–120 40–150 20–150 30–200
þþ þ 0 þ
0 þ 0 0
þþ þ 0 0
0 þþ þ þ 0
0 þ þ 0 þ
10–300
30–200
þþ
0
Usable frequency range (GHz)
Legend: þþ very good; þ good; 0 neutral; poor; very poor.
Although the propagation characteristics differ appreciably depending on the guiding structure, it is nevertheless possible to employ for all of them a common mathematical model based on voltage and current waves propagating along the structure. Such voltages and currents are actual physical quantities (the line integral of the electric field and the circulation of the magnetic field) only in the special case of multi-conductor lines (twin lines, coaxial cable, etc.), while in the case of waveguides they are just equivalent quantities representing electric and magnetic fields respectively. We will include in the common category of guiding structures both multi-conductor transmission lines and waveguides, and use the term generalized transmission lines, possibly omitting the word ‘generalized’ when unnecessary.
3.2 Cylindrical structures; solution of Maxwell’s equations as TE, TM and TEM modes As is customary in the study of guided EM wave propagation, transmission lines are considered to be cylindrical structures whose cross-section is independent of the linear axial coordinate, usually coincident with the z axis of a Cartesian or cylindrical reference frame. We will also consider, for the moment, closed, homogeneous and ideally lossless transmission lines: the EM field is confined within a cylindrical wall made of a perfect conductor ðs ¼ 1Þ filled with a homogeneous lossless dielectric ðe00 ¼ 0Þ. The geometry is depicted in Figure 3.2. The theoretical analysis of inhomogeneous or open structures requires further considerations that are not included in this text, apart from very short hints. As shown in Section 2.11, the EM field can be obtained from a magnetic vector potential A(x, y, z) using the following expressions: H¼rA E ¼ jomA þ
rr A joe
ð3:1Þ ð3:2Þ
In the absence of electric sources (Ji ¼ 0), Equation (2.193) reduces to Helmholtz’s equation r2 A þ k2 A ¼ 0
ð3:3Þ
42
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.2
Waveguide geometry with cross-section S and line contour C.
with k2 ¼ o2 me. The EM field can also be derived from an electric vector potential F(x, y, z) using the dual expressions E ¼ r F H ¼ joeF þ
rr F jom
ð3:4Þ ð3:5Þ
In the absence of magnetic sources (Jmi ¼ 0), the electric potential F satisfies Helmholtz’s equation as well. Because of the cylindrical property of the structure, we may search for solutions of Maxwell’s equations by splitting all vector quantities, including operators, into their longitudinal and transverse components. For the electric field, for instance, we write E ¼ Et þ ^zEz
ð3:6Þ
and similarly for all other field vectors. The nabla operator r is also decomposed into its transverse and longitudinal components: @ r ¼ rt þ ^z ð3:7Þ @z The solutions to the homogeneous Maxwell’s equations in a cylindrical structure can then be reduced to three categories: 1. TM modes or E modes, having zero longitudinal component of the magnetic field: Hz ¼ 0. 2. TE modes or H modes, having zero longitudinal component of the electric field: Ez ¼ 0. 3. TEM modes, having zero longitudinal component of both electric and magnetic fields: Hz ¼ 0, Ez ¼ 0. The modes, which are infinite in number, are the source-free solutions of Maxwell’s equations and thus represent free oscillations of the EM field in the structure. It can be proved that, due to the linearity of Maxwell’s equations, any field distribution in a cylindrical structure can be expressed as the superposition of the modal solutions. In some instances, e.g. in a waveguide filled with two different dielectric materials, all boundary conditions cannot be satisfied by one single mode pertaining to the above
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
43
categories, but require a solution to be built as the superposition of a TM with a TE mode. A mode resulting from the combination of TM and TE modes is called a hybrid mode, which possesses both E and H longitudinal components. Let us consider the above three categories separately.
TM Fields Fields with no longitudinal component of the magnetic field are obtained from a vector potential directed along the z axis. Putting A ¼ ^zAz
ð3:8Þ
in (3.1)–(3.2) and using the decompositions (3.6) and (3.7), the following expressions for the TM fields are obtained: Ht ¼ rt Az ^z Hz ¼ 0 1 @Az Et ¼ rt @z jo e 1 r2 A Ez ¼ jo ec t
ð3:9Þ
Using (3.7), Helmholtz’s equation (3.3) reduces to the scalar equation r2t Az þ
@ 2 Az þ k2 Az ¼ 0 @z2
ð3:10Þ
This equation can be solved by the method of separation of variables. The method consists of expressing the unknown Az(x, y, z) as the product of a function T(x, y) of the transverse coordinates by a function L(z) of the longitudinal coordinate: Az ðx; y; zÞ ¼ Tðx; yÞLðzÞ
ð3:11Þ
Inserting (3.11) into (3.10) and dividing by the product T(x, y)L(z), one obtains 1 2 1 d 2L þ k2 ¼ 0 rt T þ T L dz2
ð3:12Þ
The first term in the above equation depends only on the transverse coordinates, while the second term depends only on the longitudinal coordinate z and the third one is a constant. In order that the equation can be satisfied for any x, y and z, each of the above terms must be a constant. Let kt2 and kz2 be such constants; then we obtain r2t T þ kt2 T ¼ 0
ð3:13Þ
d2L þ kz2 L ¼ 0 dz2
ð3:14Þ
In order for (3.12) to be satisfied, the following condition of separability must hold: kt2 þ kz2 ¼ k2
ð3:15Þ
where kt2 and kz2 are still unknown quantities. Equation (3.13) is a partial differential equation that can be solved after the boundary conditions have been specified. This requires the geometry of the waveguide to be specified. Equation (3.14), on the contrary, is an ordinary differential equation that we are quite familiar with, and whose general integral can be put in the following form: LðzÞ ¼ P þ ejkz z þ P e þ jkz z
ð3:16Þ
44
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
where P þ and P are arbitrary integration constants representing the (complex) amplitudes of an incident and a reflected wave propagating in the positive and negative directions of the z axis, respectively. Note that one solution can be obtained from the other by simply reversing the sign of kz2 . For the sake of simplicity and without loss of generality, we may thus confine our attention to only the incident wave, i.e. to the first term of (3.16). In practical cases when the reflected wave is also present, the relevant expressions are obtained from those of the incident wave by simply reversing the sign of kz2 . We therefore simply put in (3.9) LðzÞ ¼ P þ ejkz z
ð3:17Þ
Note that deriving L(z) is equivalent to multiplying it by the factor (jkz). We thus obtain the following expressions for the TM fields: Ht ¼ LðzÞrt Tðx; yÞ ^z ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ ^zejkz z Hz ¼ 0 1 dLðzÞ kz Et ¼ rt Tðx; yÞejkz z rt Tðx; yÞ ¼ oe joe dz
ð3:18Þ
1 k2 Ez ¼ LðzÞr2t Tðx; yÞ ¼ t Tðx; yÞejkz z joec joec where (3.13) has been taken into account. In the r.h.s. of the above equations we have omitted the common factor P þ . We are indeed solving the homogeneous Maxwell’s equations where no source is present: any non-trivial solution is therefore determined apart from an arbitrary factor. The latter could be found provided that additional information is specified, such as the energy associated with the EM field or the field value at a given point. The transverse part T(x, y) of the potential function (for simplicity we will call it the transverse potential) has to satisfy Equation (3.13) along with the appropriate boundary conditions. Assuming that the waveguide walls are made of a perfect electric conductor, the boundary conditions state that the tangential component of the electric field must vanish on such walls. In general, the E field has two tangential components, one along the z axis and the other along the tangent ^t to the contour C (see Figure 3.2): Ez ¼ 0
ð3:19Þ
^t Et ¼ 0
ð3:20Þ
From the fourth equation of (3.18) and (3.19) we conclude that the following condition must hold: Tðx; yÞ ¼ 0 on C
ð3:21Þ
C being the contour of the cross-section S. Condition (3.20) along with the third equation of (3.18) lead to ^t rt T ¼
@T ¼0 @t
ð3:22Þ
The above condition implies that T(x, y) must be constant along C. Such a condition is already contained in (3.21). In other words, the condition for Ez to be zero on the waveguide walls automatically implies also that the tangential component of the E field is zero along the contour C. In conclusion, the boundary condition for TM fields reduces to (3.21), i.e. T(x, y) must vanish along the cross-section contour C. Condition (3.21) is called the Dirichlet condition. Note incidentally that, as expected due to the absence of EM sources, (3.13) and (3.21) are both satisfied by the trivial solution T ¼ 0. The possibility for non-trivial solutions to exist depends, as we will see better in what follows, on special values of the constant kt2 . Such values are called eigenvalues, and eigensolutions are the corresponding solutions for T.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
45
TE fields An identical procedure to that for TM fields can be applied to derive TE fields, except that we have to start from a z-directed electric vector potential F ¼ ^zFz
ð3:23Þ
Using (3.4)–(3.5) instead of (3.9), we obtain Et ¼ rt Fz ^z Ez ¼ 0 1 @Fz rt jom @z 1 r2 F Hz ¼ jom t
ð3:24Þ
Ht ¼
Proceeding with the separation of variables, we put Fz ¼ Tðx; yÞLðzÞ
ð3:25Þ
so that, instead of (3.18), we get Et ¼ LðzÞrt Tðx; yÞ ^z ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ ^zejkz z Ez ¼ 0 Ht ¼
1 dLðzÞ kz rt Tðx; yÞ ¼ rt Tðx; yÞejkz z jom dz om
Hz ¼
ð3:26Þ
1 k2 LðzÞr2t Tðx; yÞ ¼ t Tðx; yÞejkz z jom jom
Let us now determine the boundary condition for the transverse potential T(x, y). The starting point is the condition that the tangential E field must vanish on the waveguide contour, as expressed by (3.19)–(3.20). In contrast with TM fields, in the present case Ez is already zero, so that only (3.20) needs to be imposed. Using the first of (3.26) we obtain ^ rt T ¼ ^s ðrt Tðx; yÞ ^zÞ ¼ n
@T ¼0 @n
ð3:27Þ
^. The transverse potential Tðx; yÞ must therefore have zero where we have used the equality ^s ^z ¼ n normal derivative on the section contour C: @T ¼0 @n
ð3:28Þ
The above is known as the Neumann condition. Determining the functions T that satisfy (3.13) and (3.28) is again an eigenvalue problem: one needs to find those particular kt2 values (the eigenvalues) that make possible non-zero solutions for T(x, y) (the eigensolutions).
TEM fields A TEM field is obtained from a TM field by imposing the additional condition of zero axial electric field component1 Ez ¼ 0
ð3:29Þ
1 Although in principle one could, in a dual fashion, derive the TEM field from a TE one by imposing Hz ¼ 0, it can be proved that this procedure, in the case of metal waveguides, does not yield anything but the trivial solution.
46
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
From the fourth equation of (3.18), one can therefore conclude that for the TEM field the following condition has to be satisfied: kt2 ¼ 0
ð3:30Þ
As a consequence, Equation (3.13) for the transverse potential reduces to Laplace’s equation: r2t T ¼ 0
ð3:31Þ
The expressions for the TEM field are then obtained from (3.18) with the further condition (3.30): Ht ¼ LðzÞrt Tðx; yÞ ^z ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ ^zejkz z Hz ¼ 0 1 dLðzÞ kz Et ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ ¼ rt Tðx; yÞejkz z joe dz oe Ez ¼ 0
ð3:32Þ
where, we recall, the transverse potential T satisfies (3.31) instead of (3.13). It is worth noting that because of (3.15) and (3.30) the phase constant of a TEM field coincides with that of a uniform plane wave in the same medium: pffiffiffiffiffi ð3:33Þ kz ¼ k ¼ o me Concerning the boundary conditions associated with (3.31), as for TE fields we need to impose only (3.20), since (3.19) is already satisfied. From (3.32) we then obtain the boundary condition for TEM fields in a metal waveguide: ^s rt Tðx; yÞ ¼
@T ¼0 @t
ð3:34Þ
The above condition implies that T(x, y) must be constant along the contour C of the waveguide. When the section S is simply connected, as for a waveguide, C consists of just one segment. In such a case, it can be demonstrated that only the trivial solution T(x, y) ¼ 0 exists for (3.31) and (3.34). As a consequence, no TEM fields can be supported in a metal waveguide. When, on the contrary, the cross-section is multiply connected, as for a coaxial cable or a stripline, then the contour C consists of more than one segment. In such cases, a non-trivial solution of Laplace’s equation exists by imposing that T(x, y) has different constant values T1, T2 . . . on the various contour segments. This will be better illustrated later on in the case of the coaxial cable (Section 3.11). The expressions for the TM, TE and TEM fields are summarized in Table 3.2. Once the transverse boundary value problem has been solved, and thus an eigenfunction T(x, y) and the corresponding eigenvalue kt2 have been determined,2 the propagation constant of the mode is obtained from the separability condition (3.15) which gives qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð3:35Þ kz ¼ k2 kt2 ¼ o2 mekt2 It is worth noting that kz , in resulting from a square root, is defined apart from its sign. It may thus assume two opposite values corresponding to two waves propagating in opposite directions of the z axis. Equation (3.35) shows that kz is real above the cut-off frequency kt oc ¼ 2p fc ¼ pffiffiffiffiffi me 2
It can be proved that the eigenvalues are real and non-negative.
ð3:36Þ
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
47
Table 3.2 TM, TE and TEM fields. The z dependence ejkz z is omitted. For modes below cut-off jkz should be replaced with a. TM modes
TE modes
TEM modes
Ht ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ ^z
Et ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ ^z
Ht ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ ^z
Hz ¼ 0 kz rt Tðx; yÞ Et ¼ oe k2 Ez ¼ t Tðx; yÞ joec
Ez ¼ 0 kz Ht ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ om
Hz ¼ 0 kz rt Tðx; yÞ Et ¼ oe Ez ¼ 0
Hz ¼
kt2 Tðx; yÞ jom
r2t Tðx; yÞ þ kt2 Tðx; yÞ ¼ 0
r2t Tðx; yÞ ¼ 0
Boundary conditions @Tðx; yÞ ¼ 0 on C @n
Tðx; yÞ ¼ 0 on C
Equation (3.35) can also be put in the form sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 ffi pffiffiffiffiffi oc f pffiffiffiffiffi kz ¼ o me 1 2 ¼ o me 1 c2 o f
@Tðx; yÞ ¼ 0 on C @t
ð3:37Þ
For frequencies above cut-off, f > fc, kz is real. If we consider the incident wave, the field propagates according to (3.17) which we write again here for the reader’s convenience: LðzÞ ¼ P þ ejkz z
ð3:38Þ
The wavelength is lg ¼
2p l0 l0 ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi kz 1ðfc = f Þ2 1ðl0 =lc Þ2
ð3:39Þ
pffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffi where l0 ¼ 2p=b0 ¼ ð f meÞ1 is the free space wavelength and lc ¼ ð fc meÞ1 the wavelength at the cut-off frequency. Below the cut-off frequency, the propagation constant is imaginary; in such a case we may put qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð3:40Þ jkz ¼ az ¼ kt2 o2 me so that (3.17) becomes LðzÞ ¼ P þ eaz z
ð3:41Þ
Below the cut-off frequency, the EM field decays exponentially with distance z. At cut-off, kz ¼ 0 so that the EM field is constant with z, thus the same for all cross-sections. Furthermore, as shown by the formulae in Table 3.2, the transverse E field or H field vanishes for TE modes or TM modes, respectively. For a TEM mode for which kt2 ¼ 0, the propagation constant (3.35) equals that of a uniform plane wave in an infinite medium (2.116): pffiffiffiffiffi kz ¼ o me ð3:42Þ In other words, the TEM mode has no cut-off and can propagate at any frequency, even in the limit of zero frequency (DC).
48
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 1.2
TEM
1.0
kz / β
0.8
TE 10 TE 01
TE 20
TM 11
0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0
1
2
3
4 5 ω / ω c,10
6
7
8
Figure 3.3 Waveguide dispersion diagram.
It can be proved that any waveguide possesses a numerable infinity of eigensolutions, and thus of modes. The mode with the lowest cut-off frequency is called the fundamental or dominant mode. All other modes propagate at higher frequencies and are called higher order or simply higher modes. Normally, a waveguide is employed in the unimodal frequency range, i.e. that where only the fundamental mode can propagate while all higher order modes are evanescent. The unimodal range is bounded by the cut-off frequency of the fundamental mode and that of the first higher mode. For the coaxial cable, as in other TEM structures, the fundamental mode is the TEM mode. Figure 3.3 shows the dispersion diagram of a waveguide. It represents the phase constants (3.35) of pffiffiffiffiffi the waveguide modes, normalized to the TEM phase constant b ¼ o me, versus the angular frequency. As can be seen, the phase constant of each mode is zero at the corresponding cut-off frequency and approaches the free space value asymptotically.
3.3 Modes of propagation as transmission lines The field expressions obtained in the previous section exhibit some interesting properties. The first is that the transverse fields Et, Ht form a right-handed orthogonal triplet with the propagation direction z. Equations (3.18), (3.26) and (3.32) for TM, TE and TEM fields, respectively, show in fact that when only the incident wave is present we may write Et ¼ Zz Ht ^z
ð3:43Þ
where Zz is the wave impedance of the EM field and is given by Zz ¼
kz oe
for TM fields
ð3:44Þ
Zz ¼
om kz
for TE fields
ð3:45Þ
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION Zz ¼ Z ¼
rffiffiffi m e
49 ð3:46Þ
for TEM fields
where Z is the intrinsic impedance of the medium and the wave impedance of a uniform plane wave in the unbounded medium. The second property is that, by virtue of separability, the transverse fields are expressed as the product of a wave function that determines the axial variation times a vector that depends only on the transverse coordinates x, y and is therefore the same for any cross-section. This means that the EM field in a waveguide can be factorized as follows: Et ¼ VðzÞet ðx; yÞ Ht ¼ IðzÞht ðx; yÞ
ð3:47Þ
ht ¼ ^z et ðx; yÞ
ð3:48Þ
with
Note that the above factorization is not unique. A possible choice of quantities in (3.47) is shown in Table 3.3. The case of TEM modes can be considered as a special case of TM modes with kt2 ¼ 0. The axial field components corresponding to (3.47) are Ez ¼
kt2 Tðx; yÞIðzÞ joe
for TM modes
ð3:49Þ
Hz ¼
kt2 Tðx; yÞVðzÞ jom
for TE modes
ð3:50Þ
The functions V(z) and I(z) can be interpreted as voltages and currents equivalent to the mode propagating along the waveguide. They do not necessarily coincide with physical quantities, but are to be interpreted as auxiliary quantities representing the field behaviour along the generalized transmission line. As we have already noted and will see better later on in this section, this definition contains a certain degree of arbitrariness. From the expressions in Table 3.3 one can easily show that V(z) and I(z) satisfy the following differential equations: dV ¼ ZI dz dI ¼ YV dz
ð3:51Þ
Table 3.3 Equivalent voltages and currents. TM modes
TE modes
TEM modes
Et ¼ VðzÞet ðx yÞ Ht ¼ IðzÞht ðx yÞ ht ðx yÞ ¼ ^z et ðx yÞ VðzÞ ¼
1 dL joe dz
IðzÞ ¼ LðzÞ et ðx; yÞ ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ Zz ¼
kz oe
VðzÞ ¼ LðzÞ IðzÞ ¼
1 dL jom dz
et ðx; yÞ ¼ ^z rt Tðx; yÞ om Zz ¼ kz
VðzÞ ¼
1 dL joe dz
IðzÞ ¼ LðzÞ et ðx; yÞ ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ rffiffiffi m Zz ¼ e
50
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
where 8 kz2 > > > < j oe Z¼ > jom > > : jom
for TM modes for TE modes
ð3:52Þ
for TEM modes
8 joe > > > 2 < k Y¼ j z > om > > : joe
for TM modes for TE modes
ð3:53Þ
for TEM modes
Equations (3.51) constitute a set of linear homogeneous differential equations known as the telegrapher’s equations, whose general solution can be put in the following form: VðzÞ ¼ V þ egz þ V e þ gz 1 IðzÞ ¼ ðV þ egz V e þ gz Þ Z0
ð3:54Þ
where Z0 ¼ g¼
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Z=Y
ð3:55Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffi ZY
ð3:56Þ
Equations (3.54) provide expressions for the equivalent voltages and currents along a generalized transmission line, corresponding to the complex amplitudes of the E and H fields propagating in the guiding structure. As shown in the next section, the telegrapher’s equations can also be derived from conventional circuit theory by considering an infinitesimal length of a two-wire transmission line. This approach has the advantage of associating the per-unit-length impedance and admittance with the familiar lumped element concept. The quantity Z0 is the characteristic impedance and, as can easily be verified, it is coincident with the wave impedance (3.44), (3.45) and (3.46) of the respective mode. The quantity g is the propagation constant; as can be found using (3.52) and (3.53), it coincides with jkz . Both Z0 and g are, in the general case, complex quantities. In the case of lossless structures both Z and Y in (3.52)–(3.53) are imaginary, so that the characteristic impedance is real while the propagation constant is imaginary. An exception is represented by the modes below cut-off, or evanescent modes, for which the propagation constant g becomes real and the characteristic impedance is imaginary. From (3.55) and (3.40) in fact we obtain 8 a z > > < joe for TM modes ð3:57Þ Z0 ¼ jom > > : for TE modes az Note that, as solutions of a homogeneous problem, the functions T representing the transverse potential are determined apart from an arbitrary factor. This implies a corresponding uncertainty in the transverse modal vectors et, ht in Table 3.3. Such an uncertainty can be eliminated by imposing that the modal vectors satisfy the normalization condition: ð et ht ^z dS ¼ 1 ð3:58Þ S
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
51
Such a condition implies that V(z) and I(z) may be interpreted as equivalent voltages and currents in such a way that the power associated with the voltage and current waves equals that transported by the EM field. Using (3.47), the latter is given by P¼
1 2
ð
ð 1 1 E H* ^z dS ¼ VI * et ht ^z dS ¼ VI * 2 2 S S
ð3:59Þ
It is worth noting that only the transverse components of the EM field contribute to the power flow, since, as can easily be verified, ðE H* Þ ^z ¼ ðEt H*t Þ ^z. The normalization condition (3.57) therefore ensures that the power travelling along the equivalent transmission lines is equal to that transported by the mode. It should also be noted that the equivalent voltages and currents V(z) and I(z) in (3.47) can be chosen in different ways, still leaving the electric and magnetic fields unaltered. In fact, we may factorize the fields as Et ¼ VðzÞet ðx; yÞ ¼ ½CVðzÞ½et ðx; yÞ=C ¼ V 0 ðzÞe0t ðx; yÞ Ht ¼ IðzÞht ðx; yÞ ¼ ½IðzÞ=C½Cht ðx; yÞ ¼ I 0 ðzÞh0t ðx; yÞ
ð3:60Þ
where C is an arbitrary real constant. An alternative definition of equivalent voltages and currents is therefore V 0 ðzÞ ¼ CVðzÞ I 0 ðzÞ ¼ IðzÞ=C e0t ðx; yÞ ¼ et ðx; yÞ=C
ð3:61Þ
h0t ðx; yÞ ¼ Cht ðx; yÞ It can easily be verified that condition (3.59) on the power transported is also satisfied by the new voltages and currents V 0 I 0 : ð ð 1 1 1 * * E H* ^z dS ¼ V 0 I 0 e0t h0t ^z dS ¼ V 0 I 0 ð3:62Þ P¼ 2 S 2 2 S The transverse field vectors e0t and h0t are orthogonal, but instead of (3.48) the following relation holds: ht ðx; yÞ ¼ C 2^z et ðx; yÞ
ð3:63Þ
The characteristic impedance of the new equivalent transmission line defined in terms of V 0 I 0 is Z00 ¼
V 0 ðzÞ VðzÞ ¼ C2 ¼ C 2 Z0 I 0 ðzÞ IðzÞ
ð3:64Þ
In the general case we can write ht ðx; yÞ ¼
Z0 ^z et ðx; yÞ Zz
ð3:65Þ
where Zz is the wave impedance of the mode [20]. As we will see in the particular case of the coaxial line, the voltage V(z) for TEM modes, rather than using the definition in Table 3.3, is defined in terms of the line integral of the electric field between the two conductors. This can be done because rt Et ðx; yÞ ¼ 0, thus the electric field of a TEM mode is conservative in the cross-section and therefore its line integral between two points is independent of the integration path. As a consequence, the characteristic impedance of the TEM line differs from the wave impedance Zz given by (3.46).
52
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING I(z,t) Z0, β0
I(z+dz,t)
R dz L dz
V(z,t)
C dz
G dz
z
V(z+dz,t) z+dz
dz
Figure 3.4
An infinitesimal length of transmission line and its equivalent lumped element circuit.
3.4 Transmission lines as 1-D circuits The telegrapher’s equations (3.51) can alternatively be obtained by considering an infinitesimal length dz of a two-wire transmission line (twin conductor line, coaxial line, etc.). Since dz is negligible with respect to the wavelength, the conventional lumped element circuit theory may be employed. With reference to Figure 3.4, the infinitesimal length is characterized by a series resistance R dz and inductance L dz associated with the electric current flowing along the conductors, and by a conductance G dz and capacitance C dz, associated with the voltage difference between the conductors. The quantities R, L, G and C are the resistance, inductance, conductance and capacitance per unit length, respectively, of the transmission line, and are therefore expressed in O/m, H/m, S/m and F/m. The series resistance depends on the conductivity of the conductor(s) of which the line is made; it is zero in the ideal case of perfect conductors. Similarly, the conductance G depends on the dielectric interposed between the conductors: it is zero in the ideal case of a perfect dielectric. An ideally lossless transmission line has, therefore, both R ¼ 0 and G ¼ 0. By applying Kirchhoff’s voltage law (i.e. the total voltage drop along a closed path must be zero) to the circuit of Figure 3.3b we obtain Vðz þ dzÞVðzÞ þ ðR dz þ joL dzÞI ¼ 0
ð3:66Þ
From Kirchhoff’s current law (the total current entering a node must be zero) we get Iðz þ dzÞIðzÞ þ ðG dz þ joC dzÞV ¼ 0
ð3:67Þ
From simple algebra (writing Vðz þ dzÞVðzÞ ¼ dV etc.), we get the differential equations governing voltages and currents along the line: dV ¼ ðR þ joLÞI dz
ð3:68Þ
dI ¼ ðG þ joCÞV dz
ð3:69Þ
These equations are nothing but the telegrapher’s equations (3.51) with R þ joL ¼ Z
ð3:70Þ
G þ joC ¼ Y
ð3:71Þ
being the line per-unit-length impedance and admittance, respectively. The solution of (3.68)–(3.69) is given by (3.54). Correspondingly, the characteristic impedance and the propagation constant are given by sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi R þ joL Z0 ¼ Z=Y ¼ ð3:72Þ G þ joC
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION g ¼ a þ jb ¼
pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ZY ¼ ðR þ joLÞðG þ joCÞ
53 ð3:73Þ þ
The solutions (3.54) represent two voltage and current waves propagating in the positive (V ) and negative (V ) directions of the z axis. Indeed, the time domain voltage is expressed as Vðz; tÞ ¼ Re½Ve jot ¼ V þ eaz cosðotbzÞ þ V e þ az cosðot þ bzÞ
ð3:74Þ
The first term in (3.74) represents an incident wave propagating in the positive z direction with phase velocity (see Equation (2.91)) vph ¼
o b
ð3:75Þ
and attenuation a (nepers per metre). Similarly, the second term in (3.74) represents a reflected wave travelling in the negative z direction with the same phase velocity and attenuation as the incident wave. V þ and V are arbitrary constants that can be determined only when additional conditions are provided, namely the boundary conditions at the line ends, the line having so far been supposed to have an indefinite length. In general, the voltage to current ratio, i.e. the impedance along the line, is a quantity varying with z. Using Equations (3.54) we obtain ZðzÞ ¼
VðzÞ V þ egz þ V e þ gz ¼ Z0 þ gz V e V e þ gz IðzÞ
ð3:76Þ
When only the incident wave is present, then V ¼ 0 and the impedance equals everywhere the characteristic impedance Z0. Similarly, if only the reflected wave is present, the impedance is independent of z and equal to the opposite of the characteristic impedance (Z0).3 The characteristic impedance thus represents the ratio of the voltage and current along the line when only the incident (or, apart from the sign, the reflected) wave is present. In the general case the impedance varies along the line according to (3.76). The reflection coefficient, in general varying with z as well, is defined as the ratio of the reflected and incident voltages.4 From the first equation of (3.54) GðzÞ ¼
V e þ gz V þ 2gz ¼ e V þ egz V þ
ð3:77Þ
From some easy algebra we obtain the relations relating the impedance and the reflection coefficient: ZðzÞ ¼ Z0
GðzÞ ¼
1 þ GðzÞ 1GðzÞ
ZðzÞZ0 ZðzÞ þ Z0
ð3:78Þ
ð3:79Þ
When the admittance YðzÞ ¼ 1=ZðzÞ is employed instead, the following formulae hold between the admittance and reflection coefficient: Y ¼ Y0
1G 1þG
ð3:80Þ
3 The minus sign corresponds to the convention for the sign of the current, which is positive when flowing in the positive z direction. For the reflected wave the current flows in the negative direction. 4 A current reflection coefficient can be defined as well, but it is seldom used. When no specification is given, the reflection coefficient is invariably the voltage reflection coefficient.
54
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Y0 Y Y0 þ Y
G¼
ð3:81Þ
where, to simplify the notation, the z dependence has been omitted. For lossless transmission lines R ¼ 0 and G ¼ 0, and Equations (3.72)–(3.73) become rffiffiffiffi L Z0 ¼ C pffiffiffiffiffiffi g ¼ jb ¼ jo LC
ð3:82Þ ð3:83Þ
Therefore, the characteristic impedance is real, while the propagation constant is imaginary. Equations (3.54) hold with g being replaced by jb. Correspondingly, the phase velocity (3.75) is expressed in terms of the inductance and capacitance per unit length of the line: pffiffiffiffiffiffi vph ¼ 1= LC ð3:84Þ Equations (3.76) and (3.77) become ZðzÞ ¼ Z0
V þ ejbz þ V e þ jbz V þ ejbz V e þ jbz
GðzÞ ¼
V þ 2jbz e Vþ
ð3:85Þ ð3:86Þ
respectively. The reflection coefficient thus varies only by its phase, while its amplitude remains constant along the line. If we put Gð0Þ ¼
V Vþ
and
Zð0Þ ¼
V þ þ V V þ V
the previous formulae can be written in the form ZðzÞ ¼ ¼ Z0
Zð0Þcos bzjZ0 sin bz Zð0ÞjZ0 tan bz ¼ Z0 Z0 cos bzjZð0Þsin bz Z0 jZð0Þtan bz GðzÞ ¼ Gð0Þe þ 2jbz
ð3:87Þ
ð3:88Þ
In most practical cases, microwave and RF transmission lines have small losses, i.e. R oL and G oC. For low-loss transmission lines, (3.73) can be greatly simplified. By neglecting the product RG pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi and by approximating 1 þ x ffi 1 þ x=2 one obtains pffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 pffiffiffiffiffiffi R G g ¼ a þ jb ffi LC þ þ jo LC ð3:89Þ 2 L C To the same degree of approximation, the characteristic impedance is still given by (3.82). The phase constant is therefore the same as in the lossless case, while the attenuation due to small losses is expressed as 1 pffiffiffiffiffiffi R G 1 ð3:90Þ LC þ ¼ ðRY0 þ GZ0 Þ a¼ 2 L C 2 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where Z0 ¼ 1=Y0 ¼ L=C . In the following sections, for the sake of simplicity we will normally refer to lossless transmission lines.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
55
3.5 Phase velocity, group velocity and energy velocity In Section 2.8 we have seen that a function such as eðx; y; z; tÞ ¼ e0 cosðotbzÞ
ð3:91Þ
represents a wave propagating with phase velocity vp ¼
o b
ð3:92Þ
The phase velocity is indeed the velocity at which a hypothetical observer should travel in order to ‘see’ the wave phase as constant.5 Equation (3.91) represents a monochromatic wave, whose spectrum consists of just a single radian frequency o. This is therefore a more mathematical than physical solution, since it represents a signal of infinite time duration. Any practical signal used for transmitting information, on the contrary, has a spectrum which occupies a finite frequency band. This is not without important consequences for the quality of the transmission. In fact, except for the case when the phase constant b is proportional to the frequency, as for plane waves or TEM modes, the phase velocity varies with the frequency. In the former case, each spectral component of the signal propagates with the same phase velocity and the signal propagates without distortion. In the latter case, each spectral component travels with a different phase velocity so that the signal, which is nothing but the superposition of its spectral components, undergoes a progressive distortion as it travels. Such a phenomenon is called dispersion: it causes a waveform to be distorted at the output of a transmission line. This inevitably happens not only in any non-TEM lines but also in any real line when some loss is present. The practical relevance of this phenomenon depends, as might be expected, also on the signal’s bandwidth and on the line length. For narrow-band signals and not-too-long lines it can often be neglected. For wide-band or ultra wide-band (UWB) applications, which are recently being widely exploited, the concept of phase velocity becomes almost meaningless and cannot be adopted to quantify the propagation velocity of the signal. In such cases one has to resort to the concept of group velocity. Instead of a monochromatic signal such as (3.91), let us consider a signal consisting of two monochromatic waves with angular frequencies close to each other, say o0 Do. Correspondingly, the waves will propagate with phase constants b0 Db. After travelling a distance z the resulting signal is aðz; tÞ ¼ sin½ðo0 DoÞtðb0 DbÞz þ sin½ðo0 þ DoÞtðb0 þ DbÞz ¼ 2cosðDotDbzÞsinðo0 tbzÞ
ð3:93Þ
where we have made use of known trigonometric formulae. The above expression can be seen as a waveform at frequency o0, like (3.91), its amplitude being modulated by the function cosðDotDbzÞ which has an angular frequency Do and a phase constant Db. Figure 3.5 shows the waveform (3.93) at a given time instant t. The group velocity is the velocity with which the modulating function propagates, in the limit of infinitesimal frequency shift Do. It is therefore given by the expression 1 do db vg ¼ ð3:94Þ ¼ db do Although obtained with an oversimplified procedure based on just two frequencies, the above expression (3.94) can be demonstrated in the general case of a continuous spectrum.6 5 It should be stressed that this is a mathematical rather than a physical velocity, as it does not imply any motion of particles. The reader should not be astonished when ascertaining that in many cases the phase velocity is greater than the velocity of light, seemingly contradicting Einstein’s principle of relativity. 6 See [3], pp. 200–204.
56
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 1 0.8 signal amplitude
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 –0.2 –0.4 –0.6 –0.8 –1 0
10
20
30
40 50 z (m)
60
70
80
90
Figure 3.5 Waveform resulting from the superposition of two waves at frequencies f0 Df, with f0 ¼ 100 MHz and Df ¼ 4 MHz. Equation (3.94) holds as long as the dispersion of the transmission line is limited or, in other terms, if the phase velocities at the band limits are close enough so that b can be approximated by a linear function of frequency. Otherwise, the signal distortion is such that a velocity of the signal cannot be defined. In the case of a waveguide, using (3.37) with b ¼ kz , we obtain for the phase and group velocities c vp ¼ rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð3:95Þ o 2 c 1 o rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi o 2 c o
ð3:96Þ
P Wm þ W e
ð3:97Þ
vg ¼ c 1
pffiffiffiffiffi where c ¼ 1= me is the velocity of light in the medium. Note that the product of the two velocities is 2 equal to c ; their frequency behaviours are shown in Figure 3.6. While the phase velocity is always greater than c, the group velocity is always less than the velocity of light in the medium. At the cut-off frequency, the phase velocity becomes infinite. This corresponds to the phase being everywhere the same at any distance (b ¼ 0), thus the wave has simultaneously the same phase at points infinitely distant from one another. On the contrary, at cut-off the group velocity is zero because there is actually no field propagation. Both velocities approach c asymptotically at very high frequencies. This implies that dispersion becomes negligible at frequencies well above cut-off, as reflected by the dispersion diagram of Figure 3.3. Since a power flow is associated with the EM field travelling along a transmission line, it seems reasonable to define an energy velocity vE. This can be computed on the basis of the following reasoning. The power transmitted through the waveguide cross-section is nothing but the energy flowing through it in 1 second. Such energy is to be found in a cylindrical volume whose length equals the distance d covered by the energy in 1 second, thus d ¼ vE 1. By equating the real power P through the cross-section S to the total energy stored in the cylinder, we find the following expression for the energy velocity: vE ¼
where P is computed as the flow of the real part of the Poynting vector through S, and Wm ; We are the magnetic and electric energy densities, respectively, per unit length of guide, or, equivalently, the energy densities over the guide cross-section:
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
10
57
x 108
9 8 7 6
vp
m 5 s 4 3
vg
2 1 0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
ω ωc Figure 3.6
Phase and group velocities of a waveguide mode. ð m jHj2 dS 4 S ð e We ¼ jEj2 dS 4 S
Wm ¼
ð3:98Þ
Using the field expressions quoted in Table 3.2, it can be shown that the energy velocity (3.97) has exactly the same value as the group velocity (3.94).7
3.6 Properties of the transverse modal vectors et, ht; field expansion in a waveguide The functions T(x, y) introduced in Section 3.2 in the factorization of the potentials Az or Fz show a number of important mathematical properties that derive from Helmholtz’s equation (3.13) and the relevant boundary conditions for TM, TE or TEM modes. As an immediate consequence, also the transverse vectors et and ht (3.47) that determine the field dependence on the transverse coordinates possess specific mathematical properties referred to, as we will see in a moment, as orthogonality properties. To simplify our discussion, we are not going to demonstrate these properties, although it is an instructive procedure – the interested reader will find the proofs in Appendix C. Let us consider an ideal waveguide, i.e. one made of a perfect conductor and filled with a perfect dielectric, and having two different modes, identified by the superscripts ‘p’ and ‘q’. The following equation holds between the corresponding electric field transverse vectors: ð ðpÞ ðqÞ et et dS ¼ 0 ð3:99Þ S
The above equation states the orthogonality of the transverse modal vectors of an ideal waveguide. This is a consequence of the boundary conditions where the tangential electric field must be zero on the metal wall. Therefore, (3.99) does not hold true in the case of a lossy conductor. 7
A complete treatment of the various velocities can be found in the classical book by J. A. Stratton [2], pp. 330–340.
58
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
If p and q refer to the same mode, the r.h.s. of (3.99) is not zero. Using the normalization condition (3.58) along with relation (3.48) to express ht in terms of et, we find ð ðpÞ ðpÞ et et dS ¼ 1 ð3:100Þ S
Equations (3.99) and (3.100) can be combined into the orthonormalization of the modal vectors ð 1 for p ¼ q ðpÞ ðqÞ et et dS ¼ dpq ¼ ð3:101Þ 0 for p 6¼ q S where dpq is called the Kronecker delta. Because of (3.48), Equation (3.101) also implies8 ð ðpÞ ðqÞ ht ht dS ¼ dpq
ð3:102Þ
S
ð
ðpÞ
ðqÞ
et ht ^z dS ¼ dpq
ð3:103Þ
S
It can be proved that the orthogonality (3.99) holds without any exceptions if p and q refer to different types of modes, one TM and the other TE. If both p and q refer to TM or TE modes, the orthogonality holds provided that the modes have different eigenvalues, i.e. if 2 2 6¼ ktq ktp
ð3:104Þ
Different modes having the same eigenvalue are called degenerate modes. Although they have different field distributions, they have the same cut-off frequency, wavelength and phase velocity.9 As we will see later on, degenerate modes are systematically present in circular and square waveguides. A very important consequence of the modal orthogonality, from the physical point of view, is that the power carried by a combination of modes equals the sum of the powers individually carried by each mode. In other words, each mode carries power independently of the others. Such a result is not obvious at all, since the power is quadratic with respect to the EM field, and thus, in general, the power of the superposition of various field distributions differs from the sum of the powers associated to each of those. The above property is easily proved by computing the power carried by the superposition of the p and q modes: ð 1 ðpÞ ðqÞ ðpÞ ðqÞ P¼ ðE þ Et Þ ðHt þ Ht Þ* ^z dS 2 S t ð ð 1 1 ðpÞ ðpÞ ðqÞ ðqÞ ¼ V ðpÞ I ðpÞ* et ht ^z dS þ V ðqÞ I ðqÞ* et ht ^z dS 2 2 ð3:105Þ S ð S ð 1 ðpÞ ðqÞ* ðpÞ 1 ðqÞ ðpÞ* ðqÞ ðqÞ ðpÞ et ht ^z dS þ V I et ht ^z dS þ V I 2 2 S S ¼ PðpÞ þ PðqÞ 8
If we adopt (3.63) instead of (3.48), then (3.101) and (3.102) must be replaced by ð ðpÞ ðqÞ C 2 et et dS ¼ dpq S
1 C2
ð
ðpÞ
ðqÞ
ht ht dS ¼ dpq S
respectively. 9 Although the orthogonality (3.99) cannot be proved for a pair of degenerate modes, it is nevertheless always possible to resort to mode orthogonality by the so-named Gram-Schmidt orthogonalization procedure consisting of ðpÞ ðqÞ 0ðpÞ 0ðqÞ substituting the pair et ; et with two linear combinations et ; et such that (3.101) holds.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
59
where P(p) and P(q) are the powers carried by the p and q modes respectively. As already observed in connection with (3.59), it can be seen that only the transverse components of the EM fields contribute to the power carried by the modes. From the mathematical point of view, the mode orthogonality is a basic property which allows the expansion of any EM field in the waveguide in terms of a summation (or a series) of the waveguide modes. It can be proved, in fact, that the three groups of TM, TE and TEM waveguide modes form a complete set of orthonormal functions, which means that an arbitrary piecewise-continuous square-integrable vector function defined in the waveguide cross-section can be expanded in terms of the waveguide modal vectors [1]. The most general EM field in a waveguide can thus be expressed by the summation of all its modes; using (3.47)–(3.50) with an index n to designate the generic mode we can therefore write Et ¼
1 X Vn ðzÞetn ðx; yÞ n¼0
1 X In ðzÞhtn ðx; yÞ Ht ¼
ð3:106Þ
n¼0
Ez ¼
Hz ¼
1 1 X k2 Tn ðx; yÞIn ðzÞ joe n¼0 tn 1 1 X k2 Tn ðx; yÞVn ðzÞ jom n¼0 tn
for TM modes
for TE modes
The above expansions are the basis for the so-called mode matching method, discussed in Chapter 16. One application is the calculation of the field excited in a waveguide by a current source, presented in Section 7.6.1.
3.7 Loss, attenuation and power handling in real waveguides Power loss, and thus signal attenuation, specifically distinguishes real from ideal waveguides. Moreover, the amount of power that can be handled practically is limited because the filling dielectric breaks down when subject to very high electric fields. Losses in a real waveguide are mainly due to the finite conductivity of the metal and, to a lesser extent, to the conduction and polarization currents in the filling dielectric. It can therefore be concluded that, by virtue of energy conservation, the EM field cannot propagate in a real waveguide without attenuation. In most cases, however, the losses are usually so small that a simplified approach can be employed in order to evaluate the attenuation in a waveguide. Since the EM field propagates along the waveguide axis z under an exponential law, the attenuation can be expressed in terms of the power dissipated per unit length Pd (this is thus a power density per unit length, to be measured in W/m) and the power travelling in the guide. The latter in fact can be expressed as PðzÞ ¼ P0 e2az
ð3:107Þ
where P0 is the power transmitted through the section in z ¼ 0 and a is the attenuation of the EM field. To ensure energy conservation, the rate of power decrease along an infinitesimal length dz must be equal to the power dissipated per unit length; from (3.107) we easily get Pd ¼
dP ¼ 2aP0 e2az ¼ 2aP dz
ð3:108Þ
60
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The attenuation is therefore found as the ratio of the power density dissipated per unit length to the propagating power a¼
Pd 2P
ð3:109Þ
By simple extension of the above reasoning it can be seen that when more than one type of loss occurs, producing the power losses Pd1, Pd2. . . , the total attenuation will then be the sum of the individual attenuations. A rigorous treatment of conductor loss in a waveguide would be very difficult. This is because the finite conductivity of the metal implies different boundary conditions than those we have employed to derive the waveguide modes. Indeed, the tangential electric field is not exactly zero at the metal walls. Moreover, the metal’s conductivity is strongly affected by the status and roughness of its surface, and thus by the manufacturing process of the guide. For such reasons, the approach universally adopted to evaluate conductor loss in a transmission line is based on the following points: 1. The boundary condition of zero tangential electric field on the perfect electric conductor is replaced by the Leontovic condition (2.184) between the tangential components of the E and H fields on the metal surface ^ Et ¼ Zc Ht n ^ is the inner-directed normal unit vector at the metal surface and where n rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi om Zc ¼ ð1 þ jÞ 2s
ð3:110Þ
ð3:111Þ
is the intrinsic impedance of the conductor, s its conductivity and m its magnetic permeability. 2. The magnetic field at the surface of the metal is assumed to be the same as in the ideal case. Equation (3.110) is thus used to compute the tangential electric field at the metal surface. Note that this is the most significant difference with respect to the ideal case. Indeed, because of Ohm’s law, the conduction current flowing on the surface of a real conductor is associated with a non-zero tangential electric field parallel to the current. 3. Once the tangential E field at the metal surface is known, the power density Pd dissipated in the metal can be computed. This can be done using two alternative but fully equivalent approaches. The first consists of computing, via the Leontovic condition, the Poynting vector flow into the metal. The second approach consists of computing the power dissipated in the metal due to the Joule effect. Poynting’s theorem ensures the equality of both results. Following the former approach, the power dissipated in a waveguide section of unit length is expressed as the flow of the Poynting vector into the metal: rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi þ þ þ 1 1 1 om ^ dl ¼ Re Zc Ht H*t dl ¼ Pd ¼ Re Et H*t n Ht H*t dl ð3:112Þ 2 2 2 2s C C C ^ is the unit inward-directed normal to the metal wall and the index t indicates the where n ^. C is the linear contour of the crosscomponent tangential to the metal and thus orthogonal to n section. By virtue of the boundary condition (2.61) at the surface of a perfect conductor, the tangential magnetic field Ht is equal (in amplitude) to the surface current density Js. The previous expression can then be put in the form rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi þ 1 om Js J*s dl ð3:113Þ Pd ¼ 2 2s C
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
61
The same expression would have been obtained by computing the power lost in the metal by the Joule effect (2.69), using (3.110) and (3.111). For TM modes the H field has only one tangential component transverse to the axial direction and associated with the longitudinal current density. For TE modes there is also an H-field longitudinal component associated with a transverse current density. The axial and transverse currents give rise to different attenuation behaviours. The former decreases, while the latter increases with frequency. Dielectric loss can be computed much more easily than conductor loss. In fact, if we know the conductivity or the complex permittivity of the filling dielectric (in most cases air), then, recalling (2.69), the power dissipated is ð ð ð 1 s oe00 Pd ¼ E J* dS ¼ E E* dS ¼ E E* dS ð3:114Þ 2 S 2 S 2 S The power transported is
ð ð 1 1 * ^ P ¼ Re E H z dS ¼ ReY0 E E* dS 2 2 S S
ð3:115Þ
where Y0 ¼ 1=Z0 is the characteristic admittance of the mode, having implicitly supposed that only one mode is present. From (3.109), (3.114) and (3.115) we obtain ad ¼
1 oe00 2 ReðY0 Þ
ð3:116Þ
As an alternative, the attenuation due to dielectric loss can be computed by inserting the complex permittivity in expression (3.35) for the propagation constant: qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi kz ¼ o2 mðer js=oÞkt2 ¼ o2 mer kt2 je00 and computing the imaginary part. The result is exactly the same. Let us now discuss the maximum power that can be handled by a practical waveguide. As for the attenuation, the power limitation may be due to the dielectric (most often) or to the conductor. Any real dielectric is characterized by a maximum electric field value, called the dielectric rigidity or dielectric strength, that can be withstood, above which breakdown occurs. In the case of air at normal atmospheric pressure, the dielectric rigidity is 29 kV/cm. The maximum power that can be transmitted by the waveguide can be evaluated from the dielectric rigidity by expressing the power carried by the fundamental mode in terms of the maximum amplitude of the electric field and equating the latter to the dielectric rigidity. This can easily be done using the expressions for the electric field and for the power associated with the fundamental mode propagating in the waveguide. It might be worth specifying that any mismatch can only reduce the maximum power handling, not only because of the power reflected, but also because the reflected wave increases the maximum electric field amplitude. Another potential limitation on the maximum power is due to the excessive heating of the metal walls due to the current flowing in them. In this case, rather than the maximum instantaneous power, the limitation is put on the average power. For the applications considered in this book, power handling is of no concern.
3.8 The rectangular waveguide The rectangular waveguide is the most common type of waveguide, which is used in an ample frequency range from 320 MHz to 333 GHz, with decreasing inner dimensions from 1483.87 741.93 mm for guide WR-2300 down to 0.086 0.043 mm for guide WR-3. Appendix D reports the data on standard rectangular waveguides.
62
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.7 Geometry of the rectangular waveguide. The geometry of the rectangular waveguide is shown in Figure 3.7. As we have seen, waveguides cannot support TEM modes, but only TE and TM ones. Such modes can be derived as illustrated in Section 3.2 by first solving the eigenvalue equation (3.13) for the transverse potential T(x, y) with boundary conditions (3.21) or (3.28) for TM and TE modes, respectively. The solutions can be obtained without difficulty using the separation of variables method (see Section 2.9), which consists of assuming the unknown function as the product of two functions of a single variable x or y: Tðx; yÞ ¼ XðxÞYðyÞ
ð3:117Þ
mpx npy sin ; a b
m; n ¼ 1; 2 . . .
ð3:118Þ
m; n ¼ 0; 1; 2 . . .
ð3:119Þ
In this manner we obtain TTM ðx; yÞ ¼ Csin TTE ðx; yÞ ¼ Ccos
mpx npy cos ; a b
In both cases the eigenvalue is given by kt2 ¼
mp2 a
þ
np2 b
ð3:120Þ
Note that for TE modes the indexes m and n should not be simultaneously zero since this would lead to a trivial solution.
The proof of (3.118)–(3.119) is as follows. Inserting (3.117) into (3.13) we obtain two ordinary differential equations d 2X þ kx2 X ¼ 0 dx2 d 2Y þ ky2 Y ¼ 0 dy2
ð3:121Þ
where the constants kx and ky are linked by the separability condition kx2 þ ky2 ¼ kt2
ð3:122Þ
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
63
Equations (3.121) are the very well-known equations of harmonic motion, whose solutions can be put in various equivalent forms. In this instance it is convenient to use trigonometric functions: XðxÞ ¼ C1 sinðkx xÞ þ C2 cosðkx xÞ YðyÞ ¼ D1 sinðky yÞ þ D2 cosðky yÞ
ð3:123Þ
with C1, C2, D1, D2 arbitrary coefficients to be determined using the relevant boundary conditions. Imposing the boundary conditions (Table 3.2) for TM modes, X(x) must vanish for x ¼ 0 and x ¼ a. The former condition yields Xð0Þ ¼ C2 ¼ 0
ð3:124Þ
XðaÞ ¼ C1 sinðkx aÞ ¼ 0
ð3:125Þ
thus the latter implies
Since C1 ¼ C2 ¼ 0 would yield a zero EM field everywhere, we must have kxa ¼ mp, where m is a non-zero integer number. Therefore, in order for a non-trivial solution to exist, kx may only assume a discrete set of values given by kx ¼ mp=a;
m ¼ 1; 2 . . .
ð3:126Þ
Correspondingly, there are an infinite number of solutions for X(x): mpx a
ð3:127Þ
npy b
ð3:128Þ
m ¼ 1; 2 . . .
ð3:129Þ
XðxÞ ¼ C1 sin Using an identical procedure we obtain YðyÞ ¼ D1 sin ky ¼ np=b;
For TM modes we thus obtain (3.118), where C ¼ C1D1; using (3.122) the eigenvalue kt2 is found to be given by (3.120). For TE modes an identical procedure can be applied, except that the boundary conditions require the normal derivative rather than the function itself to vanish. For example, in x ¼ 0 we must have dX ð0Þ ¼ kx C1 ¼ 0 dx
ð3:130Þ
The procedure easily yields (3.119).
The cut-off frequency associated with the eigenvalue (3.120) is rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi m2 n2 1 fc ¼ pffiffiffiffiffi þ 2 me a b
ð3:131Þ
The expressions for the EM fields of the TM and TE modes are finally obtained by inserting (3.118) and (3.119) into (3.18) or (3.26), respectively, and are given in Table 3.4. The modes are labelled as TM or TE and with indexes m and n, which indicate the number of half swings of the EM fields in the x and y directions, respectively: we then speak of TMmn or TEmn modes. One can immediately realize that the fundamental mode of the rectangular waveguide (i.e. the mode with
64
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Table 3.4 TM and TE modes in a rectangular waveguide. TM modes Tðx; yÞ
Cmn cos
mpx npy cos a b
Cmn sin
Et ¼ Zz;mn et ðx; yÞejkz;mn z Ht ¼ ht ðx; yÞejkz;mn z kz;mn Zz;mn ¼ oe Ez ðx; yÞ ¼
TE modes
kt2 Tmn ðx; yÞ joe
mpx npy sin a b
Et ¼ et ðx; yÞejkz;mn z ht ðx; yÞ jkz;mn z Ht ¼ e Zz;mn om Zz;mn ¼ kz;mn Hz ðx; yÞ ¼
kt2 Tmn ðx; yÞ jom
ex ðx; yÞ
Cmn
mp mpx npy cos sin a a b
Cmn
ey ðx; yÞ
Cmn
np mpx npy sin cos b a b
Cmn
Ez ðx; yÞ
Cmn
kt2 mpx npy sin sin a b joe
0
hx ðx; yÞ
Cmn
np mpx npy sin cos b a b
Cmn
mp mpx npy sin cos a a b
hy ðx; yÞ
Cmn
Cmn
np mpx npy cos sin b a b
Hz ðx; yÞ
0
mp mpx npy cos sin a a b
Cmn
np mpx npy cos sin b a b mp mpx npy sin cos a a b
kt 2 mpx npy cos cos a b jom
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi mp2 np2 þ a b qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 o2 mekt;mn
kt;mn kz;mn
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dm dn 1 ab kt;mn
Cmn
lowest cut-off frequency) is the TE10 mode. By putting m ¼ 1 and n ¼ 0 in the equations of Table 3.4 we obtain the expressions for the EM field of the TE10 mode: Ex ¼ 0 Ey ¼ j
px oma C sin ejkz;10 z p a
Ez ¼ 0 px kz;10 a Ey ejkz;10 z ¼ Hx ¼ j C sin Z10 p a Hy ¼ 0 px ejkz;10 z Hz ¼ C cos a
ð3:132Þ
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
65
with kt10 ¼ p=a qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi kz10 ¼ o m0 e 1ð fc10 = f Þ2 1 c pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ pffiffiffiffi 2a m0 e 2a er om0 Z10 ¼ kz10 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi c ¼ 1= m0 e0
fc10 ¼
ð3:133Þ
As can be seen, the EM field is independent of y (because n ¼ 0); the electric field has only the y component with a sinusoidal variation along the x axis, being zero, as it must, at the side walls in x ¼ 0 and x ¼ a. Identical behaviour occurs for the transverse magnetic field Hx. On the waveguide crosssection, there is only the Ey component of the electric field and the Hx component of the magnetic field. The plane containing the waveguide axis and the transverse E field is called the E plane, while that containing the waveguide axis and the transverse H field is called the H plane. With the reference system used in Figure 3.7, the E plane and H plane coincide with the yz and xz planes, respectively. The third non-zero component of the EM field, Hz, has a cosinusoidal behaviour with maxima at the side walls. The surface current density flowing on the metal walls can be obtained from the tangential magnetic field using the boundary condition (2.61), which we repeat here: ^H Js ¼ n
ð3:134Þ
The EM field and electric current lines of the TE10 mode are shown in Figure 3.8. In practical cases we are interested in evaluating the attenuation of the dominant mode. The procedure is that of Section 3.7. Longitudinal and transverse currents are found to produce two different contributions to the total attenuation due to conductor loss: ac ¼ acl þ act
ð3:135Þ
pffiffiffiffipffiffiffi 1:90 104 er f acl ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi b 1ð fc = f Þ2
ð3:136Þ
where
is the attenuation due to the longitudinal currents, and 2 2b fc act ¼ acl f a
ð3:137Þ
is the attenuation due to the transverse currents. The above expressions have been obtained by assuming the wall to be made of copper (s ¼ 5:8 107 S=m). Note also that at cut-off both attenuations become exceedingly high, while atpfrequencies well above cut-off the longitudinal currents give rise to an ffiffiffi attenuation increasing with f , and the attenuation associated with the transverse currents tends to zero. The latter phenomenon, however, occurs at frequencies when also higher order modes propagate and is therefore hard to exploit to get attenuation-free EM wave propagation. The attenuation due to the filling dielectric is found to be ad ¼ 27:3
er Zc tan d dB=m f eo
ð3:138Þ
Figure 3.9 shows the total resulting attenuation along with its various contributing terms versus the frequency normalized to the cut-off frequency, in the useful band. Below cut-off the mode cannot propagate, while above twice the cut-off frequency higher order modes can propagate, which is an
66
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Signal direction
λg/4
λg
Signal direction
H Js Figure 3.8 Electric and magnetic field lines and current density lines of the TE10 mode. Reprinted with permission from Ingegneria delle microonde e radiofrequenze by R. Sorrentino and G. Bianchi, Copyright (2006) McGraw-Hill.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
67
0.50
Rectangular Waveguide WR-75 ( a=19.05 mm; b=a/2 )
0.45
Attenuation (dB/m)
0.40
b
0.35
a
0.30 0.25
α cl
0.20
α c = α ct + α cl
0.15 0.10
α ct
0.05 0.00 1
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5 1.6 f/fc
1.7
1.8
1.9
2
Figure 3.9 Attenuation of the TE10 mode due to conductor loss. undesirable situation since it produces a signal distortion because of the different propagation behaviours of the various modes.
Useful bandwidth The frequency band of unimodality of the rectangular waveguide depends on the aspect ratio b/a, but in any case cannot be more than one octave.10 Equation (3.131) in fact shows that the cut-off of the TE20 mode is twice that of the TE10 mode: c fc20 ¼ pffiffiffiffi ¼ 2 fc10 a er If b > a=2, however, the cut-off of the TE01 mode is lower than that of the TE20 mode: c c fc01 ¼ pffiffiffiffi < pffiffiffiffi ¼ fc20 2b er a er In order not to reduce the useful bandwidth of the guide, the smaller size of the guide should not exceed a/2. On the other hand, since the greater the value of b, the smaller the attenuation, the optimum b is exactly a/2: smaller values would not increase the useful bandwidth but would increase conductor loss.
3.9 The ridge waveguide The ridge waveguide is derived from the rectangular waveguide by inserting one or two symmetrical rectangular ridges on one or both broader sizes, as sketched in Figure 3.10. The ridges have the effect of confining the EM field of the fundamental mode within the central gap. As a result, the cut-off of the fundamental mode of the rectangular waveguide is lowered while the cut-off of the TE20 mode, whose E field is zero at the centre of the broad walls, is almost unaffected. As a consequence, the ridge waveguide has a wider bandwidth than the corresponding rectangular guide. The price for this improvement is paid in terms of higher attenuation due to higher current density in the metal walls. The ridge guide is thus employed in those applications where a useful bandwidth greater than one octave is required. More details on this type of waveguide can be found in [4, 5].
10
Taken from music terminology, this term indicates a frequency interval from f0 to 2f0.
68
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.10
Single and double ridge waveguide.
3.10 The circular waveguide The circular waveguide, whose geometry is sketched in Figure 3.11, is employed in all applications where for mechanical reasons a circular geometry is necessary, as in rotary joints or for particular applications where the rotation symmetry can be usefully exploited, as in devices like the rotary phase shifter or the Faraday isolator. The analytical procedure for deriving the TM and TE modes of the circular waveguide is the same as for the rectangular waveguide, with the obvious difference that the coordinate system must be cylindrical with variables (r, f). As a consequence, the separation of variables must be performed by factorizing the potential T(r, f) as the product of a function of the radius r with a function of the azimuth angle f: Tðr; fÞ ¼ RðrÞ FðfÞ
ð3:139Þ
The transverse potential for the circular waveguide is found to be Tðr; jÞ ¼ CJn ðkt rÞcosðnj þ j0 Þ
ð3:140Þ
Tðr; fÞ ¼ Jn ðkt rÞ½C1 cosðnfÞ þ C2 sinðnfÞ
ð3:141Þ
or, equivalently,
with C1 ¼ C cos f0 and C2 ¼ C sin f0. Jn is the nth-order Bessel function of the first kind. As shown in Figure 3.12, such functions have a pseudo-periodical behaviour with decreasing maximum amplitudes.
Figure 3.11 The circular waveguide.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
Bessel functions Jn(x)
1
0.5
69
← J (x) 0
← J (x) 1 ←J
2
(x) ←J
10
(x)
0
-0.5 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
x
Figure 3.12 Bessel functions of the first kind.
The proof of (3.140) is as follows. In polar coordinates the eigenvalue equation (3.13) is written as (see A.42): 1@ @T 1 @2T ð3:142Þ r þ 2 2 þ kt2 ¼ 0 r @r @r r @f Inserting (3.139) into (3.142) and separating the variables, we obtain two ordinary differential equations in the unknown functions R(r) and F(f): r2
d 2R dR þr þ ðkt2 r2 n2 ÞR ¼ 0 dr2 dr d2F þ n2 F ¼ 0 df2
ð3:143Þ ð3:144Þ
where n2 is the separation constant of the two equations. The solution of (3.144) is easily found and can be put in the form FðfÞ ¼ P cosðnf þ f0 Þ
ð3:145Þ
with P and f0 arbitrary constants. Equation (3.145) shows that n must be an integer number (including 0) in order for the function F(f) to be periodic with period 2p. The solution of (3.143) is RðrÞ ¼ C1 Jn ðkt rÞ þ C2 Yn ðkt rÞ ð3:146Þ where C1 and C2 are integration constants and Jn and Yn are Bessel functions of the first and second kind of order n, respectively. The behaviours of the Bessel functions Jn(x) and Yn(x) (n ¼ 0,1,2) are shown in Figures 3.12 and 3.13, respectively. The reader can observe that Bessel functions of the second kind diverge when x ! 0. As a consequence, because the EM field must remain finite, the corresponding integration constant must be zero, C2 ¼ 0, so that (3.146) reduces to ð3:147Þ RðrÞ ¼ C1 Jn ðkt rÞ Inserting (3.147) and (3.145) into (3.139), we obtain the final expression (3.140). Equations (3.140) and (3.141) show that when n ¼ 0 the field is independent of f. In all other cases, T(r, f) results from the superposition of two distinct solutions.
70
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Bessel functions Yn(x)
1
0.5
← Y (x) 0
← Y (x) 1 ← Y (x) 2
←Y
10
(x)
0
-0.5
-1
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
x
Figure 3.13 Bessel functions of the second kind.
TM modes
According to the boundary condition (3.21) for TM fields, (3.141) must vanish on the guide boundary, and thus for r ¼ a. Therefore we must impose Jn ðkt aÞ ¼ 0
ð3:148Þ
As can be seen from Figure 3.13, such an equation has infinite solutions corresponding to the curve Jn crossing the abscissa. Let pnm be the mth zero of Jn(x). We then have the following expression for kt: kt ¼
pnm a
ð3:149Þ
The first zeros of Jn are given in Table 3.5. Equation (3.148) identifies the eigenvalues of the TM modes of the circular waveguide. They are labelled by a pair of indexes (n, m), m representing the number of half swings in the radial direction and n those in the azimuth direction. The EM field components of TMnm modes are given in Table 3.6. Except when n ¼ 0, each pair (n, m) corresponds to two distinct field distributions sharing the same eigenvalue kt2 . They are therefore degenerate modes (see Section 3.6).
TE modes
Instead of (3.148), for TE modes we need to impose (3.28), i.e. the vanishing of the normal derivative of the potential at the boundary. Since the normal direction coincides with the radial direction, we must have dJn ðkt rÞ ¼0 ð3:150Þ dr r¼a Let p0nm be the mth zero of (3.150), i.e. the mth maximum or minimum of the Bessel function Jn(x); the TEnm eigenvalues are obtained as p0 ð3:151Þ kt ¼ nm a Table 3.5 First zeros of Jn ðxÞ: n
pn1
pn2
pn3
0 1 2
2.405 3.832 5.135
5.520 7.016 8.417
8.654 10.174 11.620
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
71
Table 3.6 EM fields of TM and TE modes of the circular waveguide. Jn0 is the derivative of Jn : TM modes
TE modes
(
jnoe pnm r sin nj Jn rkt2 a cos nj ( jpnm oe 0 pnm r cos nj ¼ Jn akt2 a sin nj
Hr ¼
Hr ¼
Hj
Hj ¼
Hz ¼ 0 Er
Ej
Ez
( jkz pnm 0 pnm r cos nj ¼ Jn a akt2 sin nj ( jnkz pnm r sin nj ¼ Jn rkt2 a cos nj ( p r cos nj nm ¼ Jn a sin nj
Hz ¼ Er ¼ Ej ¼
( cos nj jkz p0nm 0 p0nm r J n akt2 a sin nj 0 ( sin nj jnkz p r Jn nm 2 a rkt cos nj 0 ( cos nj p r Jn nm a sin nj 0 ( sin nj jnom p r Jn nm rkt2 a cos nj 0 ( 0 cos nj jpnm om 0 pnm r J akt2 n a sin nj
Ez ¼ 0
The first p0nm values are given in Table 3.7. By comparison with Table 3.5 we note that p00m ¼ p1m . This is not by chance but is a consequence of the following property of Bessel functions:11 dJ0 ðxÞ ¼ J1 ðxÞ dx
ð3:152Þ
The field components of TEnm modes are given in Table 3.6. Also, in this case, whenever n 6¼ 0, modes are degenerate in pairs. Inspection of Tables 3.5 and 3.7 indicates that the fundamental mode is the TE11 mode corresponding to the eigenvalue kt11 ¼ 1:841=a. The field lines are sketched in Figure 3.14. The degenerate mode has its field lines rotated by 90 . The normalized frequency behaviour of the attenuation associated with the axial and transverse currents is shown in Figure 3.15, where, as for the case of the rectangular waveguide in (3.136)–(3.137), acl ¼
pffiffiffiffipffiffiffi 0:420 3:80 104 er f qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2a 1ð fc =f Þ2 Þ
ð3:153Þ
is the attenuation due to the longitudinal currents, and act ¼
2 1 fc acl 0:420 f
ð3:154Þ
Table 3.7 Zeros of the derivatives of Jn ðxÞ.
11
n
p0n1
p0n2
p0n3
0 1 2
3.832 1.841 3.054
7.016 5.331 6.706
10.174 8.536 9.970
More generally, xQ0n ðxÞ ¼ nQn ðxÞxQn þ 1 ðxÞ where Qn denotes any Bessel function of order n.
72
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.14
Electric (solid line) and magnetic (dashed line) field lines of the TE11 mode.
0.50 0.45
circular waveguide
Attenuation (dB/m)
0.40 0.35
20 mm
0.30 0.25
α ct
0.20
α c = α ct + α cl
0.15
α cl
0.10 0.05 0.00 1
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5 f/fc
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2
Figure 3.15 Attenuation due to conductor loss for the TE11 mode.
is the attenuation due to the transverse currents, while the total attenuation due to conductor losses is the sum of (3.153) and (3.154) as given in (3.135). The above expressions have been obtained by assuming the wall to be made of copper (s ¼ 5:8 107 S=m).
3.11 The coaxial cable The coaxial cable consists of two concentric cylindrical conductors separated by a dielectric material where the EM field propagates (Figure 3.16). Due to the presence of two distinct conductors and a homogeneous dielectric, the fundamental mode is a TEM mode, which has a zero cut-off frequency.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
Figure 3.16
73
Geometry of the coaxial cable.
Higher TM and TE modes do exist and start propagating at frequencies approximately above fc ¼
1 1 pffiffiffiffiffi ffi pffiffiffiffiffi lc me pða þ bÞ me
ð3:155Þ
Up to this frequency, the cable is unimodal. As in the case of the circular waveguide, the coordinate system is the cylindrical one. As we have seen in Section 3.2, the EM field of the fundamental TEM mode is obtained by solving Laplace’s equation for the potential T(r, f) along with the boundary condition that T must be constant on the contour. The cylindrical symmetry allows us to search for solutions independent of f. In such a case, if @=@f ¼ 0 Laplace’s equation simplifies to 1d dT r ¼0 ð3:156Þ r dr dr After two integrations the general solution is obtained as Tðr; fÞ ¼ A ln r þ B
ð3:157Þ
with A and B integration constants. Assuming T ¼ 0 on the outer conductor (r ¼ b) and T ¼ T0 on the inner one (r ¼ a), we get lnðr=bÞ Tðr; fÞ ¼ T0 ð3:158Þ lnða=bÞ T0 is an arbitrary constant that determines the amplitude of the EM field. The latter is obtained by inserting (3.158) into expressions (3.32) for the TEM mode and recalling that in the present case rt T ¼ ð@T=@rÞ^r. For the progressive (or incident) wave we obtain Et ¼
k jkz z @T T0 Z 1 jkz z ^r ¼ ^r e e oe @r lnðb=aÞ r
Ht ¼ ejkz z
@T T0 1 jkz z ^ ^¼ u u e @r lnðb=aÞ r
ð3:159Þ
ð3:160Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where Z ¼ m=e is the wave impedance. Note that the electric and magnetic fields are orthogonal at any point and form a right triplet with the direction of propagation. The E field lines are purely radial, while the H lines are purely circumferential (Figure 3.17).
74
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.17
Field lines of the TEM mode of the coaxial cable.
The current density flows in the axial direction with opposite signs on the outer and inner conductors: ^ Hjr¼a ¼ ^r Hjr¼a ¼ Js;int ¼ n
T0 ejkz z ^z lnðb=aÞ a
^ Hjr¼b ¼ ð^rÞ Hjr¼a ¼ Js;ext ¼ n
T0 ejkz z ^z lnðb=aÞ b
ð3:161Þ ð3:162Þ
The total current is obtained by integrating the current density along the circumference of the inner conductor þ ð 2p T0 ejkz z 2pT0 jkz z a dj ¼ e IðzÞ ¼ Js;int ^z dl ¼ ð3:163Þ lnðb=aÞ C 0 lnðb=aÞ a The same result is obtained by performing the integral along any line (in particular a circumference) encompassing the inner conductor. As already observed in Section 3.3, in the case of the TEM mode the electric field is conservative in the cross-sectional plane; we may therefore uniquely define a potential difference between the two conductors. It therefore appears natural to define the voltage along the cable in terms of the line integral of the electric field: ðb ð ða T0 Z jkz z b 1 ð3:164Þ e dr ¼ T0 Zejkz z VðzÞ ¼ E dl ¼ Er dr ¼ lnðb=aÞ b a a r Equations (3.163) and (3.164) define the characteristic impedance of the coaxial cable as Z Z0 ¼ lnðb=aÞ 2p
ð3:165Þ
Note that (3.165) differs from pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi the wave impedance (3.46) for TEM modes. The present choice corresponds to putting C ¼ lnðb=aÞ=2p in (3.60)–(3.64). The attenuation due to conductor loss can be computed using the method described in Section 3.7. In the case of the TEM mode, only the axial current is present. Since both the attenuation and the characteristic impedance of the coaxial cable depend on lnðb=aÞ, it is possible to express the former as a function of the latter, as shown in Figure 3.18. Note that the minimum attenuation is achieved for characteristic impedance close to 75 O. Data on standard coaxial cables are reported in Appendix D.
3.12 The parallel-plate waveguide Rather than an actual waveguide, the parallel-plate waveguide (PPW) is an EM model of the propagation in practical TEM lines; it can be used for example as a simplified model of the microstrip line. The PPW
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
75
–3
x 10
1.4
Coaxial cable
εr
1.3
2b
1.2 1.1 1
Attenuation
.
2b (dB/ GHz ) ε r fGHz
1.5
0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
εr Z0
Figure 3.18
Conductor loss attenuation of the coaxial cable vs. characteristic impedance.
consists of two infinite metal plates, supposedly made of a perfect conductor, set at a distance h from one another, as sketched in Figure 3.19. The two plates are supposed to be of infinite extent in both z and x directions. The z axis is assumed, as usual, to be the direction of propagation. As long as the filling dielectric is homogeneous, as we assume here, the presence of two different conductors assures us that the fundamental mode is the TEM mode. To determine the EM field we can follow the procedure described in Section 3.2 and solve Laplace’s equation (3.31) for the transverse potential T(x, y) with the boundary condition (3.34) that T is constant on the metal boundaries, i.e. for y ¼ 0 and y ¼ h. The EM field can then be obtained from T(x, y) using Table 3.2. In implementing this procedure it is convenient to look for solutions that are independent of the x coordinate. The 2-D Laplace’s equation thus reduces to an ordinary differential equation in T(y) that can immediately be integrated, yielding TðyÞ ¼ T0 y=h
ð3:166Þ
where T0 is an arbitrary constant representing the potential for y ¼ h, while T has been assumed to be zero for y ¼ 0. Using the formulae in Table 3.2, the corresponding EM field is easily found to be
Figure 3.19
The parallel-plate waveguide.
76
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Et ¼ Z Ht ¼
T0 jbz ^ye h
T0 jbz ^xe h
ð3:167Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffi with b ¼ o me and Z ¼ m=e. We immediately recognize that the above field is nothing but a uniform plane wave propagating in the z direction. By putting E0 ¼ ZT0 =h we can indeed write Et ¼ E0 ^yejbz E0 jbz ^xe Ht ¼ Z
ð3:168Þ
The PPW, as mentioned above, is representative of two-conductor TEM lines of finite lateral extent. Indeed, we may take a slice of width w by inserting two side walls made of a perfect magnetic conductor (pmc). Since the magnetic field is directed along the x axis, such walls do not affect the EM field because they do not modify the boundary conditions.12 The PPW therefore becomes a closed waveguide with upper and lower walls made of pec and side walls made of pmc. We are now interested in evaluating the characteristic impedance of such a transmission line, in much the same way as we did for the coaxial cable in Section 3.11. Let us compute the voltage and current along the PPW. The voltage is obtained as the line integral of the E field between the two conductors: ðh ð3:169Þ V ¼ E0 ejbz dy ¼ hE0 ejbz 0
The current flowing on the plates can be obtained by integrating the axial current density over the width w. Because of the boundary condition on a metal surface (2.61), the z-directed current density is equal to the x-directed magnetic field. The total current is thus given by ðw E0 Hx ejbz dx ¼ w ejbz ð3:170Þ I¼ Z 0 By taking the ratio of (3.169) to (3.170), we finally get the characteristic impedance of the line: rffiffiffi mh Z0 ¼ ð3:171Þ ew This equation shows that the characteristic impedance of the PPW with magnetic side walls is equal to the wave impedance times the aspect ratio h/w.
3.13 The stripline The stripline belongs to the category of planar circuits that can be fabricated with printed circuit technology. As shown in Figure 3.20, it consists of a metal strip embedded in a dielectric substrate symmetrically sandwiched between two metal ground planes. The stripline can be considered as a printed version of the coaxial cable. As for the coaxial cable, because of the presence of the two distinct conductors13 and a homogeneous dielectric, the fundamental pffiffiffiffiffi mode is a TEM mode, with zero cut-off frequency and propagation constant kz ¼ o me. The EM analysis is thus based on the solution of Laplace’s equation for the transverse potential T(x, y) with boundary conditions T ¼ 0 on the ground planes and T ¼ T0 on the metal strip. Assuming to 12
It is worth specifying that this reasoning is valid only for the TEM mode propagating in the z direction. The ground planes are to be considered as the same conductor since in practice they are electrically connected at some distance from the central strip. From a mathematical viewpoint they are connected at infinity. 13
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
77
Figure 3.20 Geometry of the stripline (a) and electric field lines of the TEM mode (b). a first approximation that the metal strip has zero thickness, Laplace’s equation can be solved by the method of conformal mapping. This is a mathematical method for solving Laplace’s equation in two dimensions, based on the properties of complex analytical functions. In practice, the conformal mapping transforms the original problem into another simpler configuration for which the solution to Laplace’s equation is known. The reader is directed to [3] for details of the method. Figure 3.20b shows the electric field lines of the TEM mode, while the following expression for the characteristic impedance of the stripline with an infinitely thin strip is obtained [3]: 8 pffiffiffi! > 1 1 þ k > > pffiffiffi ln 2 0:707 k < 1 > > < p 1 k Z0 KðkÞ Z0 Z0 ¼ pffiffiffiffi ffi pffiffiffiffi " ð3:172Þ pffiffiffiffi!#1 > 1 4 er Kðk0 Þ 4 er > 0 1 þ k > > pffiffiffiffi 0 < k 0:707 > : p ln 2 1 k0 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where k0 ¼ tanhðpw=2bÞ, k ¼ 1k0 2 , Z0 ¼ m0 =e0 ¼ 377 O. KðkÞ is a complete elliptic integral of the first kind; the ratio KðkÞ=Kðk0 Þ can be expressed to an excellent approximation as indicated in (3.172). In the case of finite thickness t of the strip, some corrections to the above formulae can be implemented. Figure 3.21 shows the characteristic impedance of the stripline for different values of the
200 180 160 140
εZ
r 0
120 100
t /b
=0
0.05 0.10 0.20 0.15 0.25
80 60 40 20 0 0.1
1 w/b
Figure 3.21 Characteristic impedance of the stripline.
4
78
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
normalized metal thickness t/b, based on Cohn’s formulae [6]. Note that Zc decreases with w/b and with t/ b as a consequence of the increasing capacitance per unit length.
3.14 The microstrip line The microstrip line, or simply microstrip, is the most common transmission line employed in microwave and RF engineering. This is because of a number of advantages such as its simplicity of manufacturing, low cost, low weight and excellent integrability with active devices. As shown in Figure 3.22, it is a planar transmission line like the stripline, but, in contrast, it is an open structure; it is not fully embedded in a dielectric but printed on top of a dielectric substrate metallized on the opposite side. The EM field guided by the metal strip propagates in a inhomogeneous medium consisting of the dielectric substrate and the air on top of it. In spite of the presence of two separate conductors so that Laplace’s equation has a non-trivial solution, the dielectric inhomogeneity prevents a TEM from propagating. Indeed, for a TEM mode we pffiffiffiffiffi know that kt2 ¼ 0, and the propagation constant is given by kz ¼ o me according to (3.42). In the presence of two different dielectric materials we would have two different propagation constants, one for the substrate and the other for air: pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi kz0 ¼ o m0 e0 ; kzd ¼ o m0 e0 er ð3:173Þ This result is in contrast with the continuity condition of the fields at the separation between the two media. Note, nevertheless, that the two propagation constants (3.173) tend to coincide in the limit of zero frequency. Only in the static case is it indeed possible to get a TEM solution. Under such a condition, however, the electric and magnetic fields are independent solutions of the static Maxwell’s equations (@=@t ¼ 0) representing the electrostatic and magnetostatic conditions, respectively. The former is associated with a static potential between the strip and the ground plane, while the latter is associated with a direct current flowing along the line. When a harmonic regime is established at a finite frequency, the electric and magnetic fields are linked by the full Maxwell’s equations. However, as long as the frequency is small enough so that the wavelength is much greater than the cross-section of the microstrip, the EM field distributions in the cross-section can be approximated by the static ones. We are thus led to the characterization of the microstrip in terms of an approximate model based on the static solution, called the quasi-static model. In practice, the quasi-static approach consists of modelling the microstrip as a TEM line with a perunit-length capacitance C and a per-unit-length inductance L, evaluated by solving Laplace’s equation. Such quantities allow us to compute the characteristic impedance and phase constant of the transmission line using (3.82) and (3.83). The fundamental mode is thus approximated by a TEM mode and for this reason is named the quasi-TEM mode. Figure 3.23 shows a typical electric field line distribution based
Figure 3.22
The microstrip line.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
Figure 3.23
79
Electric field lines of the quasi-TEM mode (static approximation).
on the static approximation. As we will see better in a moment, this approximation cannot account for the frequency dispersion of the line parameters, so some proper modifications need to be implemented. Before going any further, let us for the moment show that the static model of the microstrip, instead of using C and L, can be expressed in terms of the capacitances C and C0, the latter being the per-unit-length capacitance when the dielectric is hypothetically removed or, equivalently, when the substrate has a unit relative permittivity er ¼ 1. Under static conditions the change in the substrate permittivity affects only the electric field distribution, thus the capacitance, but not the magnetic field nor the inductance L. The last can therefore be expressed in terms of the phase velocity and capacitance of the ‘empty’ microstrip L¼
1 v20 C0
ð3:174Þ
so that the phase velocity of the ‘full’ microstrip can be written as 1 v0 vp ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi LC C=C0 where v0 ¼ ðm0 e0 Þ1=2 . The phase constant is therefore given by pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi o o pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi C=C0 ¼ k0 C=C0 kz ¼ ¼ vp v0 Concerning the characteristic impedance, we may write rffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi L LC0 1 Z0 ¼ ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ CC0 v0 CC0 C
ð3:175Þ
ð3:176Þ
ð3:177Þ
Equations (3.176) and (3.177) show that both the characteristic impedance and the phase constant can be expressed in terms of C and C0. The capacitance ratio ee f f ;stat ¼
C C0
ð3:178Þ
is the static microstrip effective permittivity. Besides being the ratio of the microstrip capacitances with and without the substrate material, this quantity allows us to express the phase constant (3.176) as pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi kz ¼ k0 ee f f ;stat ð3:179Þ
80
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.24
Derivation of the quasi-static model of the microstrip.
Similarly, the characteristic impedance can be expressed in terms of the characteristic impedance of the empty microstrip Z00 and the effective permittivity. In fact rffiffiffiffiffiffirffiffiffiffiffiffi L C0 Z00 ð3:180Þ Z0 ¼ ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ee f f ;stat C0 C With reference to Figure 3.24, the effective permittivity can be interpreted as the permittivity of a hypothetical homogeneous material filling the whole space in such a way as to produce the same per-unitlength capacitance C and phase constant kz as the original microstrip line. Needless to say, the homogeneous transmission line of Figure 3.24c supports a true TEM mode, which is not the case in Figure 3.24a. From a computational point of view, C and C0 can be computed by solving Laplace’s equation with various techniques, in particular, as for the stripline, using the conformal mapping technique, originally used by Wheeler [8]. For practical applications it is more convenient to use simple formulae; though approximate, they easily provide the capacitance values required for evaluating the microstrip parameters. Among the most popular formulae, those due to Hammerstad and Jensen [9] are quite accurate and simple enough, and thus worth reporting here:14 u ¼ w=h "
1 u4 þ ðu=52Þ2 A ¼ 1 þ ln 49 u4 þ 0:432
!
# #" u 3 1 er 0:9 0:053 ln 1 þ þ 0:564 18:7 18:1 er þ 3
ee f f ;stat ¼
er þ 1 er 1 10 A þ 1þ 2 2 u
2 3 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2ffi 0:7528 60 6 2p6 2 5 Z0 ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ln4 þ þ 1þ eð30:666=uÞ ee f f ;stat u u u
ð3:181Þ
ð3:182Þ
ð3:183Þ
The effective permittivity and the characteristic impedance are plotted in Figure 3.25 for various substrate permittivities er and aspect ratios u. Observe that the effective permittivity is a sort of average between the substrate and air permittivities, and it is closer to one or the other depending on whether the field is more or less confined to the dielectric substrate. Expression (3.182) shows that, depending on the aspect ratio u ¼ w=h, the effective permittivity varies between the limits er þ 1 ee f f er 2
ð3:184Þ
14 The interested reader can open the Mathcad file 05_Microstrip_Analysis_Synthesis.MCD (associated with Chapter 12) which enables the analysis and synthesis of arbitrary isolated microstrips, based on Hammerstad–Jensen formulae.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
Figure 3.25
81
Characteristic impedance and effective permittivity of the microstrip.
which correspond to the limit cases of extremely narrow (w=h ! 0) or extremely wide (w=h ! 1) strips, respectively. The effective permittivity defined so far as a capacitance ratio (3.178) corresponds to a static, thus frequency-independent, microstrip model where the dominant quasi-TEM mode is approximated with a TEM mode. Figure 3.26 shows a typical dispersion diagram of the microstrip, i.e. the normalized phase constant kz =k0 versus the frequency. While at lower frequencies kz =k0 is almost constant, as the pffiffiffiffi frequency increases it progressively departs from (3.177) and increases asymptotically towards er . If the dominant mode were a TEM, its normalized phase constant would have been frequency independent. On the contrary, the microstrip is dispersive as the phase velocity varies with the frequency. From a physical point of view this causes the EM field to be progressively more confined, as the frequency increases, within the substrate. A frequency fstat can be introduced that represents the boundary between the quasi-static and the dynamic regimes. Above fstat we need to resort to a more accurate model to
εr
3.0 2.9
w/h = 5
2.8
w/h = 2
kz /k0
2.7
w/h = 1
2.6
w/h = 0.5
2.5 2.4 2.3 0
10
20
30
Frequency, GHz
Figure 3.26
Microstrip dispersion diagram for er ¼ 9.
40
82
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
characterize the propagation and the field distribution of the fundamental mode. The very definition (3.178) of effective permittivity loses its meaning. A more general definition of the effective permittivity stems from (3.179), where it appears that ee f f ¼ ðkz =k0 Þ2
ð3:185Þ
This can be seen as a dynamic effective permittivity since it implies that the effective permittivity must be calculated using a dynamic rather than a static model, the latter being a particular case of the former in the limit of low frequencies. Various analytical and numerical methods have been developed in past years for the rigorous modelling of planar circuits such as microstrip circuits. A partial and very limited account is given in Chapter 16. The interested reader is referred to the vast literature on this subject, see for instance [10–12]. Here it suffices to say that rigorous analyses can be performed to compute the EM field distribution in a microstrip line and the corresponding values of the effective permittivity (thus the phase constant) and characteristic impedance. Such analyses involve a full solution of Maxwell’s equations without neglecting the axial field components Ez, Hz that are actually non-zero though smaller that the others. The full wave solution constitute a hybrid mode, i.e. a mode that is neither TM nor TE but a combination of both. For practical purposes, however, what interests us most is the knowledge of kz =k0 and Zc rather than a complete description of the EM field. From this perspective, we may just use the same model as in the quasi-static case, but introduce a frequency dependence in the expression for the effective permittivity so as to account for the dispersion. Among the dispersion formulae proposed in the literature we report here those by Yamashita et al. [13]: pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er ee f f ;stat pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 ð f Þ ¼ þ e ee f f e f f ;stat 1 þ 4F11:5 F1 ¼
h 4h f pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi w i2 er 1 0:5 þ 1 þ 2log 1 þ c0 h
ð3:186Þ
where ee f f ;stat is the static value given by (3.178). As far as the characteristic impedance is concerned, the dispersion is less pronounced, so it can usually be neglected.
3.14.1
The planar waveguide model
A simple and popular approach to the approximate modelling of microstrip lines and circuits is the planar waveguide model. Accordingly, the microstrip line is modelled as a parallel-plate waveguide with magnetic side walls (see Section 3.12), filled with a homogeneous dielectric of relative permittivity ee f f , and having the same height h and the same characteristic impedance Z0 as the microstrip line. From Equation (3.171) it follows that the last condition is fulfilled by assuming for the parallel-plate guide an effective width rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi h m0 h 120p we f f ¼ ffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Z0 e0 ee f f Z0 ee f f In practice, we f f > w, i.e. the effective width is larger than the microstrip line as it accounts for the presence of fringing fields at the strip edges. For example, for h ¼ 100 mm, er ¼ 12:5 and Z0 ¼ 50 O, the inversion of formulae (3.181)–(3.183) gives w ¼ 76 mm and ee f f ¼ 8:102, then we f f ¼ 265 mm.
3.15 The coplanar waveguide The coplanar waveguide or CPW is the second most common printed circuit configuration after the microstrip line. As its name suggests, both strip and ground are made on the same side of the dielectric
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
Figure 3.27
83
The coplanar waveguide.
substrate. As sketched in Figure 3.27, the ground consists of two half planes symmetrically located on both sides of the metal strip. This geometry offers the great advantage of allowing the shunt connection of solid state devices without requiring perforation of the substrate, as required by the microstrip. The CPW can be seen as the planar version of the coaxial cable, but unlike the latter it is inhomogeneous so that the dominant mode is, as for the microstrip, a quasi-TEM mode. The characteristic impedance depends on both the width w of the strip and the gap g: essentially, it depends on their ratio, similar to the coaxial cable. With respect to the microstrip, this confers on the CPW an additional degree of freedom in the realization of a given characteristic impedance. The main drawback of the CPW is due to the existence of two different ground planes that must be electrically connected to each other. Otherwise, another spurious quasi-TEM mode would appear. This can be easily seen by recognizing that, referring for simplicity to the static case, two independent TEM modes can be supported by three distinct conductors. To suppress the spurious mode, the ground planes must be maintained at the same potential. As sketched in Figure 3.28, metal bridges located at various critical points of the CPW, such as bends, junctions and discontinuities, are fabricated to connect the ground planes electrically.
Figure 3.28
Metal bridges for spurious mode suppression in CPW.
84
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.29
Static EM field lines in the coplanar waveguide.
Figure 3.29 shows the typical electric field lines of the dominant mode of the CPW. As for the microstrip, a quasi-static approach based on the solution of Laplace’s equation can be adopted. If the substrate thickness is large enough (g=h 1) and the metal thickness t can be assumed to be zero, the solution can be found with relative ease by conformal mapping as originally proposed by Wen [14]. More accurate formulae were then developed by Ghione and Naldi [15] and are reported here. With the notation of Figure 3.27, the characteristic impedance Z0 and the effective permittivity ee of the CPW are expressed as ee ¼ 1 þ
er 1 K 0 ðkÞ Kðk1 Þ 2 KðkÞ K 0 ðk1 Þ
ð3:187Þ
Z00 Z K 0 ðkÞ Z0 ¼ pffiffiffiffi ¼ p0ffiffiffiffi ee p ee KðkÞ where
8 pffiffiffi! > 1 1þ k > > > > ln 2 1pffiffiffi k Z0 KðkÞ Z0 < p ffi pffiffiffiffi " Z0 ¼ pffiffiffiffi ffiffiffiffi!#1 p 0 > 4 er Kðk Þ 4 er > 1 1 þ k0 > > > pffiffiffiffi : p ln 2 1 k0
0:707 k < 1 ð3:188Þ 0 < k 0:707
KðkÞ is a complete elliptic integral of the first kind. Fortunately, the ratio K 0 ðkÞ=KðkÞ can be very well approximated, as indicated by the last equality in (3.188).
3.16 Coupled lines So far we have considered various microwave guiding structures and studied their modes of propagation, each line being considered as isolated. In many practical cases, on the contrary, two or more transmission lines are located, intentionally or not, close to each other so that the field guided by each of them interacts with the field of the other. Actually the field is simultaneously guided by the whole set of coupled lines, so that one must refer to the modes of the entire set rather than to the modes of each transmission line. The coupling between different lines is used in the realization of directional couplers and coupledline filters. The characterization of coupled lines, however, is required not only for the design of such devices, but also to model cross-coupling and interference phenomena occurring within the same circuit. In the following discussion we will limit ourselves to the simplest case, though the most common one, of a symmetrical pair of identical lines. The symmetry indeed allows a substantial simplification of the
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
85
Figure 3.30 Cross-sections of some coupled lines: (a) stripline; (b) microstrip line; (c) coaxial cable; (d) square coaxial cable. analysis. The generalization to an arbitrary number of non-symmetric coupled lines is beyond the scope of this discussion. A thorough discussion can be found in [16, 17].
3.16.1
Basic principles for EM analysis
We consider here coupled lines made of three conductors with a longitudinal symmetry plane: two identical conductors with uniform cross-section along the z axis plus a third one acting as the common ground. The three conductors are separated by one or more dielectrics. Figure 3.30 shows the crosssections of four types of coupled lines: (a) the stripline; (b) the microstrip line; (c) the coaxial cable; (d) the rectangular coaxial cable. Without going into the EM analysis of coupled lines, we will just make some general considerations from the EM point of view in order to get an insight into their behaviour. In cases (a), (c) and (d) the dielectric involved by the EM field propagation is homogeneous. The structures can therefore support the propagation of TEM modes. Let us recall that, as we saw in Section 3.2, a TEM mode is obtained by solving Laplace’s equation (3.31) for the potential T(x, y) along with the boundary condition (3.34) of constant T on the conductor boundaries. We can immediately observe that, because of the presence of three conductors, there are two distinct TEM modes. We can in fact arbitrarily choose two values of T on the first two conductors, while the third one is taken as the reference (T ¼ 0). Given the symmetry of the structure, the two TEM modes are determined by ascribing equal (T1 ¼ T2 ¼ 1) or opposite potentials (T1 ¼ T2 ¼ 1) to the two conductors.15 The former case gives rise to the even mode: it corresponds to putting a magnetic wall on the symmetry plane (thus the normal electric field is zero); the latter gives rise to the odd mode: it corresponds to putting an electric wall on the symmetry plane (thus the tangential electric field is zero). As an example, Figure 3.31 shows the electric and magnetic field flux lines of the even and odd modes of a pair of coupled striplines. In the case (b) relevant to the coupled microstrip lines, the filling dielectric is inhomogeneous. As we saw in Section 3.14 for the single microstrip line, true TEM modes cannot exist, but two quasi-TEM modes can be supported, one even and one odd. The basic difference with the former cases where the 15 It should be observed that any linear combination of the two modes is still a solution of the boundary value problem, so it can be considered as another mode of the structure. There are, however, two and only two independent solutions.
86
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 3.31
Odd and even mode field lines in a pair of coupled striplines.
dielectric is homogeneous is that the even and odd modes have different effective permittivities and thus exhibit different phase velocities. In all cases, in spite of the limitations involved in the case of the microstrip, we will refer to a static analysis based on the solution of Laplace’s equation. Such an equation allows us to compute the per-unitlength capacitances and inductances of the coupled lines. Each conductor, in fact, exhibits a capacitance C towards the ground and a mutual capacitance Cm towards the other conductor. Similarly, there will be a mutual inductance M between the two conductors, in addition to the self-inductance L. Once such parameters have been computed by solving Laplace’s equation, a simple circuit model can be employed to characterize the coupled lines.
3.16.2
Equivalent circuit modelling
Figure 3.32 shows the equivalent circuit of an infinitesimal length of lossless symmetrically coupled lines. The circuit is the generalization of the elementary equivalent circuit of Figure 3.4 for the isolated
Figure 3.32
Equivalent network of an infinitesimal length of coupled lines.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
87
transmission line, by adding the mutual capacitance CM and inductance M. For reasons to become clear soon, CM has been replaced by the series of two capacitances 2CM. By applying Kirchhoff’s laws to the nodes and loops of the circuit one obtains four rather than two of the telegrapher’s equations. Rather than using this procedure, which is somewhat lengthy, we can greatly simplify the analytical treatment by exploiting the structure’s symmetry. Any solution, in fact, can be obtained by superimposing an even and an odd solution, which are equivalent to putting on the symmetry plane a magnetic wall (or open circuit) and an electric wall (short circuit). In this manner, the analysis is reduced to that of two isolated transmission lines, each having its characteristic impedance and phase constant. Let us therefore separately compute the even and odd mode characteristics.
Even mode In the even mode, equal voltages and currents are present on both lines. The symmetry plane is an open circuit that prevents the current flow. In such conditions, the mutual capacitance does not play any role, while the mutual inductance produces an equal voltage drop M I2 ¼ M I1 on both lines. The even mode thus behaves as a transmission line with a capacitance per unit length equal to C and an inductance per unit length equal to L þ M. Its characteristic impedance and phase velocity are thus given by rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi LþM 1 Z0e ¼ ; ve ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð3:189Þ C ðL þ MÞC Odd mode
The symmetry plane in this case is a grounded (V ¼ 0) electric wall. Voltages and currents on the two lines have the same amplitudes but opposite signs. Concerning the mutual capacitance CM, we may replace it with the series of two identical capacitors 2CM: the symmetry plane will thus connect the node between the two capacitors to ground. The mutual inductance, on the contrary, because of the opposite directions of the two currents, produces opposite voltage drops M I2 ¼ M I1 on the two lines. One infers that the odd mode is equivalent to a transmission line with per-unit-length capacitance C þ 2CM and inductance L M. The characteristic impedance and phase velocity of the odd mode are therefore given by rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi LM 1 ; vo ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð3:190Þ Z0o ¼ C þ 2CM ðLMÞðC þ 2CM Þ The four parameters C, CM, L and M are actually not independent of each other. This is found by using the EM analysis. Consider the particular case when the dielectric is homogeneous (excluding the microstrip). We know that both even and odd modes are TEM modes for which the phase constant is given by (3.33) pffiffiffiffiffi (kz ¼ o me) and depends only on the dielectric permittivity of the filling dielectric. Both modes thus have equal phase velocities: c v ¼ ve ¼ vo ¼ pffiffiffiffi er
ð3:191Þ
As a consequence ðL þ MÞC ¼ ðLMÞðC þ 2CM Þ ¼
er c2
ð3:192Þ
where c 3108 m/s is the phase velocity in vacuum and er is the dielectric permittivity. Equation (3.192) establishes two links among the four parameters C, CM, L, M of the coupled lines. In the case of a single line, this equation corresponds to the condition where the phase velocity of the transmission line must be equal to that of the TEM mode: pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffi v ¼ c= er ¼ 1= LC ) LC ¼ er =c2
88
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
In the general case, voltages and currents propagating along the coupled lines result from the linear superposition of the corresponding even and odd mode quantities. In the formulae, the voltages and currents on the two lines are given by V1 ðzÞ ¼ Ve ðzÞ þ Vo ðzÞ ¼ Veþ ejbe z þ Ve e þ jbe z þ Voþ ejbo z þ Vo e þ jbo z 1 1 I1 ðzÞ ¼ Ie ðzÞ þ Io ðzÞ ¼ ðV þ ejbe z Ve e þ jbe z Þ þ ðV þ ejbo z Vo e þ jbo z Þ Z0e e Z0o o V2 ðzÞ ¼ Ve ðzÞVo ðzÞ ¼ Veþ ejbe z þ Ve e þ jbe z Voþ ejbo z Vo e þ jbo z 1 1 I2 ðzÞ ¼ Ie ðzÞIo ðzÞ ¼ ðV þ ejbe z Ve e þ jbe z Þ ðV þ ejbo z Vo e þ jbo z Þ Z0e e Z0o o
ð3:193Þ
where expressions (3.54) for the voltages and currents along a transmission line have been used, g being replaced by jb, and with the subscripts ‘e’ and ‘o’ used to designate the even and odd modes respectively. In the case of a TEM line for which be ¼ bo ¼ b, the above formulae simplify to V1 ðzÞ ¼ Ve ðzÞ þ Vo ðzÞ ¼ ðVeþ þ Voþ Þejbz þ ðVe þ Vo Þe þ jbz þ Ve Vþ V V I1 ðzÞ ¼ Ie ðzÞ þ Io ðzÞ ¼ þ o ejbz e þ o e þ jbz Z0e Z0o Z0e Z0o V2 ðzÞ ¼ Ve ðzÞVo ðzÞ ¼ ðVeþ Voþ Þejbz ðVe þ Vo Þe þ jbz þ Ve Voþ jbz Ve Vo þ jbz e e I2 ðzÞ ¼ Ie ðzÞIo ðzÞ ¼ Z0e Z0o Z0e Z0o
ð3:194Þ
Notice that in the case of coupled lines, we cannot define a unique characteristic impedance as the ratio of progressive voltage to current wave amplitudes. Such a ratio depends on the respective amplitudes of the even and odd modes: it equals the even (or odd) characteristic impedance only when only one mode is present, either Voþ ¼ 0 or Veþ ¼ 0. When the lines are located far enough one from each other so that the coupling becomes negligible, then M ¼ 0 and CM ¼ 0 and both even and odd impedances (3.189) and (3.190) become equal to the characteristic impedance of the isolated line. The four equations (3.193) become equivalent to two pairs of the unrelated telegrapher’s equations. The modelling of coupled lines of finite length is discussed in Sections 4.10–4.12.
Bibliography 1. K. Kurokawa, An Introduction to the Theory of Microwave Circuits, Academic Press, New York, 1969. 2. J. A. Stratton, Electromagnetic Theory, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1941. 3. R. E. Collin, Foundations for Microwave Engineering, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1992. 4. C. A. Balanis, Advanced Engineering Electromagnetics, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1989. 5. S. Hopfer, ‘The design of ridged waveguides’, IRE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. MTT-3, pp. 20–29, 1955. 6. S. B. Cohn, ‘Problems in strip transmission lines’, IRE Transactions, Vol. PGMTT-3, No. 2, pp. 119–126, 1955. 7. G. Matthaei, L.Young and E. M. T. Jones, Microwave Filters, Impedance Matching Networks, and Coupling Structures, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1964. 8. H. A. Wheeler, ‘Transmission-line properties of a strip on a dielectric sheet on a plane’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 25, No. 8, pp. 631–647, 1977.
GUIDED EM PROPAGATION
89
9. E. Hammerstad and O. Jensen, ‘Accurate models for microstrip computer-aided design’, IEEE Microwave Symposium, pp. 407–409, 1980. 10. T. Itoh (ed.), Numerical Techniques for Microwave and Millimeter-Wave Passive Structures, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1989. 11. J. A. Dobrowolski, Introduction to Computer Methods for Microwave Circuit Analysis and Design, Artech House, Norwood, NJ, 1991. 12. R. C. Booton Jr, Computational Methods for Electromagnetics and Microwaves, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1992. 13. E. Yamashita, K. Atsuki and T. Hirahata, ‘Microstrip dispersion in a wide frequency range’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. MTT-29, No. 6, pp. 610–611, 1981. 14. C. P. Wen, ‘Coplanar waveguide: a surface strip transmission line suitable for nonreciprocal gyromagnetic device application’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. MTT-17, pp. 1087–1090, 1969. 15. G. Ghione and C. Naldi, ‘Analytical formulas for coplanar lines in hybrid and monolithic MICs’, Electronics Letters, Vol. 20, pp. 179–181, 1984. 16. J. A. G. Malherbe, Microwave Transmission Line Couplers, Artech House, Norwood, NJ, 1988. 17. C. L. Paul, Analysis of Multiconductor Transmission Lines, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ, 2007. 18. K. C. Gupta, R. Garg, F. Bahl and P. Barthia, Microstrip Lines and Slotlines, 2nd edition, Artech House, Norwood, NJ, 1996. 19. R. K. Hoffmann, Handbook of Microwave Integrated Circuits, Artech House, Norwood, NJ, 1987. 20. G. Conciauro, M. Guglielmi and R. Sorrentino, Advanced Modal Analysis, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1999.
4
Microwave circuits 4.1 Introduction In the previous chapter we showed that each propagating mode of a generalized transmission line can be modelled in terms of equivalent voltages and currents or, in other words, a transmission line. The transmission line model not only allows for a notable simplification of the electromagnetic problem by breaking it down into the longitudinal and transverse problems, but also allows us to employ established models and tools taken from the transmission line theory and circuit theory. As we will show in this chapter, by adopting the concept of microwave circuit it is possible to represent electromagnetic problems relevant to three-dimensional structures in terms of quantities typical of lumped element circuits. In this manner we can get intuitive vision and a physical insight into otherwise extremely complex electromagnetic models.
4.2 Microwave circuit formulation The analysis carried out in the previous chapter dealt with EM propagation in cylindrical guiding structures (generalized transmission lines) of infinite length. We have thus determined the modes of propagation as solutions to homogeneous Maxwell’s equations, i.e. free ‘oscillations’ of the system. In reality, of course, there are no transmission lines or guides of infinite length, but sections and stubs of finite lengths connecting circuit elements and components such as bends, bifurcations and junctions between different waveguides etc., or devices for the processing of the RF signal (filters, attenuators, etc.). In general terms, any deviation from the axial uniformity of the guide represents a discontinuity. Discontinuities are unavoidably present in any RF circuit either by the constraints imposed on the circuit (e.g. space occupation) or in order to perform specific functions on the RF signal (e.g. an attenuator). For the sake of illustration, Figure 4.1 shows some typical discontinuities in rectangular waveguide and microstrip lines. As an example, let us consider a metal iris or diaphragm (ideally made of a perfect conductor) inserted in the cross-section of a rectangular waveguide, as depicted in Figure 4.2. Suppose that an incident wave, represented by the dominant TE10 mode coming from an infinite distance z ¼ 1, impinges onto the iris. As we saw in the previous chapter, waveguide modes are homogeneous solutions
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
92
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 4.1 Examples of discontinuities: inductive iris (a), T junction (b) and bend (c) in a rectangular waveguide; double step (d), bend (e), gap (f) and T junction (g) in microstrip.
to Maxwell’s equations in an infinite waveguide; as such they satisfy the boundary conditions at the waveguide walls. From a mathematical point of view, the presence of an obstacle represents additional boundary conditions for the EM field. In our case, the tangential electric field must vanish on the iris surface. The TE10 mode (whose field lines are shown in Figure 3.8) clearly does not satisfy such a condition, since it has a non-zero electric field component Ey ¼ sinðpx=aÞ tangential to the iris. In order to satisfy the boundary conditions on the iris, we may add other waveguide modes to the TE10 mode. If the superposition of such modes satisfies the boundary conditions we are assured that this is the solution to our problem. In fact, since each mode satisfies Maxwell’s equation, so does their superposition by virtue of linearity. In other words, Maxwell’s equations and the boundary conditions on the waveguide wall are individually satisfied by each mode, while the boundary conditions on the obstacle are collectively satisfied by the mode superposition. As mentioned in Section 3.6, waveguide modes represent a complete set of vector functions. Similar to the well-known Fourier series for scalar functions in a linear interval, any vector function defined on the cross-section of the waveguide can be expanded in terms of waveguide modes. Such a property tells us that there exists a suitable superposition of waveguide modes such that, together with the incident TE10 mode, the boundary conditions on the iris are satisfied. Needless to say, knowing that the combination exists does not mean that we know it. We will come back to this point in the discussion of the mode matching method in Chapter 16.
Figure 4.2
(a) Symmetrical inductive iris in rectangular waveguide and (b) its equivalent circuit.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
93
At the plane z ¼ 0 where the iris is located, the EM field can be represented as the superposition of the TE10 mode plus a certain number (possibly infinite) of higher order modes. Under the normal assumption that the working frequency is such that only the fundamental mode can propagate while all other modes are below cut-off, the higher modes excited by the obstacle will die out as soon as we move away from it. On the contrary, the TE10 mode will propagate after the obstacle and will also be reflected by it towards the negative z direction. While the reader is referred to the rigorous treatment based on the mode matching method presented in Chapter 16, here we simply conclude that at a sufficient distance from the discontinuity, where we put our reference planes T1 and T2, the amplitude of the higher order modes becomes negligible so that the field distribution is that of the dominant mode. The latter consists of the incident plus the reflected waves for z < 0, and of the transmitted wave for z > 0. If we adopt the microwave circuit point of view by representing the mode as a transmission line, i.e. using equivalent voltages and currents, the iris can be modelled by a lumped element equivalent circuit as shown in Figure 4.2b. The reactance X that, as can be proved, is inductive represents the EM energy stored through the higher modes excited in the proximity of the obstacle. It should be stressed that since we have put the reference planes T1 and T2 far enough from the discontinuity, the EM field distribution on them is that of the dominant mode and is thus known apart from its amplitude coefficient. In conclusion, the region between the reference planes T1 and T2 can be represented by a simple two-port circuit where the voltages and currents represent the electric and magnetic fields of the dominant mode at the reference planes. Generalizing what we have just discussed, we define a microwave circuit as a region of space confined by perfectly conducting walls, enclosing an EM field and connected to the external space by N generalized transmission lines, as schematically depicted in Figure 4.3. Normally, though not always, we assume that the operating frequency is such that only the dominant mode propagates along each transmission line, while all other modes are below cut-off. At the ith (i ¼ 1. . . N) line we put a reference plane Ti at sufficient distance from the circuit so that higher modes can be neglected; from Ti on, the electric and magnetic fields are those of the dominant mode and can be represented in terms of equivalent voltages and currents, respectively, as in the previous chapter. The volume V, together with the line sections up to the reference planes, can thus be represented as an N-port network, with the notation shown in Figure 4.3b. The voltage and current at port i represent the electric and magnetic fields at the reference plane Ti. The reader might observe that the latter has a somewhat arbitrary position. Indeed, such an arbitrariness affects the values that voltages and currents may assume at the ports of the network of Figure 4.3b. We will see in Section 4.8 how the effect of a possible reference plane shift can be quantified. For the moment we may say that, because of the linearity of Maxwell’s equations, there will be a linear relationship between the set of currents and the set of voltages at the
Figure 4.3
A microwave circuit and its N-port network representation.
94
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
network ports. Seen from its terminals, the N-port network can be described in terms of 2N scalar quantities (i.e. N voltages þ N currents at the ports) instead of 2N vector functions (N electric þ N magnetic fields at the waveguide cross-sections). The simplification is apparent, although one has still to determine the relationship between the voltages and currents. In practice this indeed implies solving Maxwell’s equation in the volume V along with the proper boundary conditions. In this chapter we are not dealing with the field-theoretical problem of solving the EM field equations, but rather with the various ways of how the EM fields can be efficiently represented using circuit models, as discussed in the next section.
4.3 Terminated transmission lines Microwave circuits, as defined in the previous section, are connected together via lengths of generalized transmission lines, where we normally assume that the frequency is such that only the fundamental mode can propagate. EM propagation along transmission lines is governed by the telegrapher’s equations (3.51), the solution for voltage and current (or electric and magnetic field) waves being represented by Equation (3.54). After the study of infinite transmission lines presented in Chapter 3, in this and the following sections we study the behaviour of transmission lines of finite length from the circuit point of view, i.e. in terms of the usual parameters, such as impedance and admittance, employed in circuit theory. Consider a transmission line of finite length l terminated in z ¼ 0 with a load ZL (Figure 4.4). From its input terminals located in z ¼ l the line is seen as a dipole whose impedance we now wish to compute. The termination with ZL implies that the voltage to current ratio in z ¼ 0 is equal to ZL. Using (3.76), Zð0Þ ¼
Vð0Þ Vþ þV ¼ Z0 þ ¼ ZL Ið0Þ V V
ð4:1Þ
From (4.1), expressing V in terms of V þ , we have V ¼ GL V þ
ð4:2Þ
ZL Z0 ZL Z0
ð4:3Þ
where GL ¼
is the reflection coefficient at the load, i.e. in z ¼ 0. Such a quantity can be utilized instead of the impedance ZL to characterize the load. The reflection coefficient of the load is therefore the reflection
I(0)
+ Z0
0
V (0)
Zin
Z=
Z=0
Figure 4.4
Terminated transmission line.
ZL
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
95
coefficient at the end of a transmission line of characteristic impedance Z0 terminated by ZL. It is important to stress that the reflection coefficient depends not only on the load but also on the transmission line to which the load is connected. On another line with a different Z0, the same load ZL has a different reflection coefficient. Once the reflection coefficient (4.3) at the load has been found, Equations (3.87)–(3.88) provide the reflection coefficient and the impedance at any point on the line, in particular at its input z ¼ l: Gin ¼ Gð lÞ ¼ GL e þ 2jbl Zin ¼ Z0
ZL cos bl þ jZ0 sinbl ZL þ jZ0 tan bl ¼ Z0 Z0 cos bl þ jZL sinbl Z0 þ jZL tan bl
ð4:4Þ ð4:5Þ
Equation (4.5) is an important formula that allows the line input impedance to be expressed in terms of the load impedance and the line characteristic impedance. In terms of admittance rather than impedance, with a similar procedure one obtains Yin ¼ Y0
YL cos bl þ jY0 sinbl YL þ jY0 tan bl ¼ Y0 Y0 cos bl þ jYL sinbl Y0 þ jYL tan bl
ð4:6Þ
Note that the impedance along the line, and the reflection coefficient as well, are periodic functions of the electrical length bl ¼ 2pl=l and take equal values every l ¼ l=2. In many cases it is preferable to refer to impedances normalized to the characteristic impedance Z0 of the line. This is equivalent to assuming a unitary characteristic impedance of the line. In such cases, using the symbol ^ to indicate normalized quantities, the load reflection coefficient (4.3) becomes Z^ L 1 Z^ L 1
ð4:7Þ
1 þ GL Z^ L ¼ 1 GL
ð4:8Þ
Z^ L cos bl þ j sinbl Z^ L þ j tan bl ¼ Z^ in ¼ cos bl þ j Z^ L sinbl 1 þ j Z^ L tan bl
ð4:9Þ
GL ¼ Conversely,
The input impedance (4.5) becomes
The voltage amplitude along the line can be expressed as a function of the amplitude of the incident wave and of the reflection coefficient: ð4:10Þ jVðzÞj ¼ jV þ e jbz þ V e þ jbz j ¼ jV þ jj1 þ Ge þ j2bz j ¼ jV þ j1 þ jGje þ jð2bz þ fÞ This equation shows that the voltage amplitude varies along the line, swinging between a maximum jVmax j ¼ jV þ jj1 þ jGjj
for 2bz þ f ¼ 0; 2p; 4p . . .
ð4:11Þ
jVmin j ¼ jV þ jj1 jGjj
for 2bz þ f ¼ p; 3p; 5p . . .
ð4:12Þ
and a minimum
The ratio between the maximum and minimum voltage amplitudes along the line is called the voltage standing wave ratio(VSWR): VSWR ¼
Vmax 1 þ jGj ¼ Vmin 1 jGj
ð4:13Þ
96
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
VSWR=
1.8
8
2
1.6 1.4
Volt
1.2
VSWR=3
1
VSWR=1
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
π
π
2
βz
3 2
π
2π
Figure 4.5 Voltage along a loaded line: |G| ¼ 0, VSWR ¼ 1; |G| ¼ 0.5, VSWR ¼ 3; |G| ¼ 1, VSWR ¼ 1. The VSWR clearly takes a value between 1 (when G ¼ 0, and thus the line is matched) and 1 (when |G| ¼ 1, and thus the line is totally mismatched). Figure 4.5 shows the voltage amplitude along the line for three different values of VSWR. Let us consider some noteworthy cases. In such a case ZL ¼ 0, YL ¼ 1, the reflection coefficient is unitary with phase p. GL ¼ 1, and VSWR ¼ 1. From (4.4)–(4.6) we obtain
Short-circuited line
Zin ¼ jZ0 tanðblÞ; Yin ¼ jY0 cotðblÞ Gin ¼ e 2jbl
ð4:14Þ
Open-circuited line In such a case ZL ¼ 1, YL ¼ 0, the reflection coefficient is unitary with phase 0: GL ¼ 1. Moreover, VSWR ¼ 1. From (4.4)–(4.6) we obtain
Zin ¼ jZ0 cotðblÞ; Yin ¼ jY0 tanðblÞ Gin ¼ e 2jbl
Matched line
ð4:15Þ
Since ZL ¼ Z0, YL ¼ Y0, then GL ¼ 0, VSWR ¼ 1. We obtain Zin ¼ Z0 Yin ¼ Y0 Gin ¼ 0
The input impedance equals the characteristic impedance of the line, whatever its length.
Half-wavelength line When the line length is equal to an integer multiple n of l/2, then bl ¼ bnl=2 ¼ np. Equation (4.5) gives Zin ¼ ZL: the input impedance equals the load impedance. Correspondingly, Gin ¼ GL.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
Quarter-wavelength transformer bl ¼ ð2n þ 1Þp=2. From (4.5) we get
97
When the line length is an odd multiple 2n þ 1 of l/4, then Z02 ZL
ð4:16Þ
1 Z^ in ¼ Z^ L
ð4:17Þ
Zin ¼ or, using normalized impedances,
A quarter-wavelength section of transmission line has therefore the property of ‘inverting’ the load impedance. With a suitable choice of its characteristic impedance Z0, such a circuit can be used to match the load ZL to a generator of internal impedance Zg. By imposing in (4.16) the condition Zin ¼ Zg we obtain pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Z0 ¼ Zg ZL ð4:18Þ When (4.18) is satisfied, the input reflection coefficient is zero at the frequency corresponding to the line length being l/4 (or an odd multiple of it), thus the frequency f0 ¼ vph =ð4lÞ (or an odd multiple). The matching property of the quarter-wave transformer is limited to a narrow frequency band centred on f0. Using multiple quarter-wave sections, a wide-band impedance transformer can be designed, as discussed in Section 6.4.
4.4 The Smith chart The Smith chart, shown in Figure 4.6, is an extremely useful graphical tool for the representation and solution of a variety of transmission line problems. It is nothing but the representation of the normalized ^ þ jX ^ in the complex plane of the reflection coefficient. It thus allows for an immediate impedance Z^ ¼ R conversion of the impedance into the reflection coefficient, and vice versa. In mathematical terms, the chart represents the Z^ to G mapping expressed by Equation (4.7) that we repeat here for the reader’s convenience: GðzÞ ¼
^ 1 ZðzÞ ^ ZðzÞ þ 1
ð4:19Þ
This expression represents a so-called bilinear transform between the plane of the complex quantity Z^ and that of the complex quantity G. The transform is such that a circle in one plane is transformed into a circle in the other, the term circle being meant to include the limit case of infinite radius when the circle degenerates into a straight line. In addition, the angle formed by two intersecting curves is conserved in the transformation. As a consequence, two orthogonal lines in the Z^ plane transform into two ^ orthogonally crossing circles in the G plane. The Smith chart simply maps in the G plane the constant R ^ ^ and constant X lines of the Z plane (Figure 4.8). As stated above, such orthogonal line families are transformed into orthogonal circle families. Let us now present some examples for the sake of illustration. Consider first a purely reactive load for ^ From (4.19) we obtain which Z^ ¼ j X. GðzÞ ¼
^ 1 ^ jX 1 jX ¼ ^ þ1 ^ jX 1 þ jX
ð4:20Þ
This equation shows that the amplitude of G, being the ratio of complex conjugate numbers, is unitary and ^ varies from 1 to þ 1, the phase of G varies from 0 to 2p, being equal to p for X ^ ¼ 0. that, as X Equation (4.20) is thus the equation of a circle of unit radius in the G plane, corresponding to the outer ^ ¼ 0. Since for any circle of the Smith chart. Such a circle is indeed the mapping of the straight line R
98
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 90º
0.3 λ
0.2 λ 60º
8.0
1.0
120º
2.0
9.0
0.4 λ 150º
0. 4
3.0
0.1 λ 30º 4.0 5.0
0.2 10.0
4.0 5.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.8
0.6
180º 0.5 λ
0.4
0
0.2
10.0
0º 0λ –10.0
–0.2
0
–5.
.0
–4
.0
.4
–0
0.9 λ
–1.0
–0.8
–0.
6
–2.
0
0.6 λ
–30º
–3
–150º
–120º
–60º 0.8 λ
0.7 λ –90º
1
8.0
∞
9
0 ∞
0.6 5 3
5
3
2
0.4 3
2
6
10 1
0.2
0
1.5
1.2 1
0.2 1.2
1.5
15 20
∞
20 15
0.5 0.2 0.05
0
0.05 0.2
0.4
0.6
2
3
10
6
0.5
1
0.8 5
∞ SWR
9
0 Return Loss, dB
3 2
3
1 Γ
5
∞ Reflection Loss, dB
Figure 4.6 The Smith chart.
^ 0, then jGj 1: any point corresponding to a passive load is contained in the unit circle passive load R ^ 0 in the complex Z^ plane is transformed into the area internal to the of the Smith chart. The half plane R circle jGj 1. ^ straight lines. It can easily be verified that they are Let us now consider the other constant R ^ ¼ 0, having their centres on the real axis, all transformed into circles internal to the outer circle R passing through the point G ¼ 1. As shown in Figure 4.6, each of such circles is labelled with the ^ value. Note that, in particular, the circle R ^ ¼ 1 intersects the origin G ¼ 0. This is the corresponding R ^ ¼ 1, X ^ ¼ 0) and the reflection matching condition for which the normalized impedance is unitary (R ^ circles intersect G ¼ 1 is explained as follows. As shown coefficient is zero. The fact that all constant R ^ is, the load behaves as an open circuit, by (4.20), when the load reactance is infinite, whatever R corresponding to G ¼ 1.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
jX
99
X=2 X=const
R=const
R=3
R=1
X=1
R
X=-1 X=-2
Figure 4.7
The constant R and constant X lines transform into the Smith chart circles of Figure 4.6.
^ lines in the Z^ plane transform into the G plane. Let us We now wish to examine how the constant X ^ ^ ^ Equation (4.19) gives start with a purely resistive load X ¼ 0, thus Z ¼ R. G¼
^ 1 R ^ þ1 R
ð4:21Þ
^ varies from 0 (short circuit) to 1 (open In such a case G is purely real and varies from 1 to þ 1 as R ^ ^ circuit). The half line X ¼ 0, R 0 of Figure 4.7 thus maps into the real axis of the G plane. ^ lines. It can be proved that they map in G plane circles all Let us finally consider the other constant X passing through the point G ¼ 1 (open circuit) with centres lying on the straight line Re(G) ¼ 1. The ^ > 0) have their centres on the upper half line (Im(G) > 0), circles corresponding to inductive loads (X ^ < 0) have their centres on the lower half line while those corresponding to capacitive loads (X (Im(G) < 0). As shown by Figure 4.6, the two circle families are separated by the straight line (degenerate ^ ¼ 0. circle) X The usefulness and simplicity of the Smith chart are apparent if one considers that when moving along a lossless transmission line the normalized impedance varies according to a somewhat complicated law expressed by (3.87), while the reflection coefficient varies only by its phase, as shown by (3.88). As we move from the load in z ¼ 0 towards the generator (negative z), the phase of the reflection coefficient decreases by the angle z ð4:22Þ f ¼ 2bz ¼ 2p l=2 and the corresponding point in the G plane of the Smith chart moves clockwise along an arc f. Note that a half-wave displacement towards the generator corresponds to a full 2p rotation of the corresponding point in the Smith chart. Vice versa, moving towards the load (increasing z) corresponds to counterclockwise rotations. On the outer circle, an angular scale is attached where angles are measured in terms of fractions of wavelength. In such a way one can immediately identify the reflection coefficient at any location on ^ and constant X ^ circles, the corresponding impedance values. the line as well as, through the constant R The Smith chart is also usually equipped with various additional rulers to evaluate graphically the amplitude of the reflection coefficient, the corresponding VSWR, etc.
100
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
It is worth observing that the mapping (4.19) between the impedance and the reflection coefficient depends on the reference impedance Z0 used for normalization. When transmission lines of different characteristic impedances are cascaded together, the problem arises of denormalizing the impedances when we move from one line to the next one. This typically happens when dealing with multi-section impedance transformers (Section 6.4). Let us go into more detail by considering again the simple problem in Figure 4.4 of a transmission line terminated at one end with a load ZL. We want to determine how the reflection coefficient changes as the result of a change of reference impedance. Let the transmission line with characteristic impedance Z0 be connected at its left end to another line of impedance Z1. The reflection coefficient Gin;1 seen from Z1 is different from Gin;0 seen, although at the same point, from Z0. In order to determine the relation between the two reflection coefficients, we use Equations (3.78) and (3.79) to write
Gin;1
Zin Z1 ¼ ¼ Zin þ Z1
1 þ Gin;0 Z1 Gin;0 þ G01 1 Gin;0 ¼ ... ¼ 1 þ Gin;0 Gin;0 G01 þ 1 Z0 þ Z1 1 Gin;0 Z0
ð4:23Þ
where G01 ¼
Z0 Z1 Z0 þ Z1
ð4:24Þ
As expected, if Z0 ¼ Z1 then the above formula gives Gin;1 ¼ Gin;0 . Equation (4.23) is a bilinear transform between the Gin;1 and Gin;0 planes, mapping circles into circles. As we move along the line Z0 from the load towards the generator, the representative point in the Gin;0 plane describes a circle centred at the origin, as expressed by (3.88). The corresponding point in the plane Gin;1 still describes a circle; in order to find its centre and radius, let us put Gin;0 ¼ re jy . Since G01 in (4.24) is real, when y1 is varied the circle described by (4.23) has its centre on the real axis and intersects it when y1 is 0 or p, i.e. when Gin;0 ¼ r. Inserting such values into (4.23), we easily obtain that the centre x0 (on the real axis) and the radius r are given by 1 G01 þ r G01 r 1 r2 þ ¼ G01 x0 ¼ 2 1 þ G01 r 1 G01 r 1 G201 r2 ð4:25Þ 1 G01 þ r G01 r 1 G201 r ¼ ¼ r1 2 1 þ G01 r 1 G01 r 1 G201 r2
EXAMPLE 4.1 A 10 mm long section of coaxial cable with 50 O characteristic impedance, filled with a dielectric with er ¼ 4, is terminated with a load ZL ¼ 100 þ j70. We want to determine the input impedance, input reflection coefficient and VSWR at the frequency f ¼ 3 GHz. We first need to determine the normalized load impedance: 100 þ j70 Z^ L ¼ ¼ 2 þ j1:4 50 The corresponding point in the Smith chart is shown in Figure 4.8. Using the angular ruler attached to the outer circle, we read off the phase of the reflection coefficient of the load GL (about 30 , or p/6). Its magnitude is found by projecting the end of the radius onto the scale provided below the chart. One thus finds jGj ¼ 0:52
ð4:26Þ
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
101
90º 60º
8.0
1.0
120º
2.0
9.0
30º
3.0
0. 4
150º
4.0 5.0
0.2
2 + j1.4
10.0
10.0
4.0 5.0
2.0
3.0
0.8
1.0
0.6
180º
0.4
0
0.2
ρ = 0.52
0º
–10.0
–0.2
–5. 0
.0
0.56 + j0.72
–4
–30º
–3 .0
–150º
.4
–1.0
–0.8
–0.
6
–2.
0
–0
–120º
–60º
144º
–90º
1
8.0
0.6
9 0 ∞
5 3
5
3
2
0.4
0.2
0
1.5
1.2 1
3
2
6
10
15 20
0.5
0.2 0.05
1
0
0.2 1.2
1.5
0.52 0.6
0.4 2
3 3.2
20 15
10
6 5.7
0.05 0.2
0.5
1
0.8
5
1.4 2
∞ SWR
9
0 Return Loss, dB
3 3
1 Γ
5
∞ Reflection Loss, dB
Figure 4.8 Using the Smith chart.
In order to determine the corresponding point at the line input we first need to compute the electrical length of the line. Using the data provided and assuming the velocity of light in a vacuum to be 3108 m/s, the wavelength is 3 108 ¼ 50 mm l ¼ pffiffiffi 4 3 109
ð4:27Þ
The line section is 0.2l long and corresponds to an angular rotation j ¼ 2p
0:01 ¼ 2p 0:4 radians 0:05=2
ð4:28Þ
corresponding to 144 . After moving 144 clockwise, the input reflection coefficient is found at 114 and the following input normalized impedance can be read on the chart: Z^ in ¼ 0:56 j0:72
ð4:29Þ
102
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Denormalizing, Zin ¼ 50 Z^ in ¼ 28 j36 Using the VSWR scale we also obtain VSWR ¼ 3:2
ð4:30Þ
The Smith chart can also be used for admittance rather than impedance computation. Indeed, as already seen, the normalized impedance of a quarter-wave section is equal to its inverse, thus to the normalized admittance. Since a l/4 shift corresponds to a 180 rotation, we conclude that symmetrical points with respect to the origin correspond to impedances that are the inverse of each other. The numerical value associated with one point in the Smith chart is thus the admittance (or impedance) corresponding to the impedance (admittance) of the symmetrical point. As an alternative, the Smith chart can simply be rotated by 180 in order to represent the admittances rather than the impedances. Constant Q curves In some applications it is useful to consider the constant quality factor curves because they can give information at a glance about the performance of a matching network.1 The quality factor or the Q factor or simply the Q of an impedance Z ¼ R þ jX corresponding to the admittance Y¼
1 1 R X j 2 ¼ G þ jB ¼ ¼ Z R þ jX R2 þ X 2 R þ X2
is defined as2 Q¼
jX j jBj ¼ R G
Note that the Q factor is invariant with respect to any impedance normalization with respect to a resistance. The reflection coefficient corresponding to Z or Y can be expressed in terms of Q: R0 ð1 jQÞ R0 Z R0 R jX R0 ð1 jRQÞR G¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ R R0 þ Z R0 þ R þ jX R0 þ ð1 jRQÞR R0 þ ð1 jQÞ R By taking the real and imaginary parts G ¼ GR þ jGI we obtain 2 R0 R0 1 Q2 2Q R R GR ¼ ; GI ¼ 2 2 R0 R0 2 þ1 þQ þ 1 þ Q2 R R
ð4:31Þ
As Q is fixed and R is varied, the above are the parametric equations of two curves in the complex G plane. Such curves are symmetrical with respect to the real axis, since Q does not change when an impedance Z ¼ R þ jX is replaced by its conjugate Z ¼ R jX. Moreover, by recalling that by a 180 rotation in the G plane the normalized impedance transforms into the normalized admittance
1 2
Matching networks are discussed in Chapter 6. See Section 5.3.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
103
and that the Q factor computed from the impedance is the same as that computed from the admittance, we find that the two curves (4.31) are also symmetrical with respect to the imaginary axis. After some manipulation, R can be eliminated from (4.31) so as to obtain G2R þ G2I
2 GI 1 ¼ 0 Q
ð4:32Þ
It is readily seen that the above are the equations of two circles with centres 1 c 0; j Q and radius
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 4 r ¼ 1þ 2 Q
All circles pass through the points ð1; j0Þ. The two circles, when Q becomes infinite, degenerate into the unitary circle of the Smith chart. The pair of circles for Q ¼ 0 degenerate in the real axis. Figure 4.9 shows some of the constant Q circles (Q ¼ 0, 0.5, 1, 2, 4, 1) in the Smith chart. Constant Q circles can be used to identify the Q factor of a matching network. Higher Q factors generally correspond to narrower bandwidths and higher sensitivities with respect to component tolerances. As an example consider the quarter-wavelength impedance transformer. Suppose we have to match a resistive 200 O load to a 50 O source. This can be done using either one of the matching networks in Figure 4.10a,b representing two impedance transformers made of quarterwavelength line sections at the frequency f0. The simplest circuit is that of Figure 4.10a, consisting of just a line section whosepcharacteristic impedance is the geometrical average of the load and ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi source impedances: Z01 ¼ 50 200 ¼ 100. At f0 the 200 O load is perfectly matched to 50 O, but the matching degrades as the frequency departs from f0. 10.0
0
6.0
4
2.0
8.0
∞
0.4
3.
2
4.0 5.0
1
0.2
10.0
4.0 5.0
Q=0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
10.0
–10 .0
0.2
Q=0.5
Q=0.5 –0 .2
–4 .0 –5. 0
1 .0
2
–2
–0.10
–0.8
–0 .6
4
.0
–3
.4
–0
Figure 4.9 Constant Q circles.
104
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Zin
Zin
Z01
Z01 ′
Z02 ′
RL = 200 Ω (a)
RL = 200 Ω (b)
ZB
Figure 4.10
Impedance matching transmission line circuits: (a) single section; (b) two sections.
As we move from the load towards the source, the trajectory of the reflection coefficient describes the semicircle A–C in Figure 4.11. Note that while both A and C correspond to resistive (zero-reactance) loads, the impedance is complex in all intermediate points along the line. The Q factor is zero in A, increases up to a maximum of about 0.75, and then goes back to zero in C. The maximum Q can be reduced using a two-section transformer like that shown in Figure 4.10b. The impedance matching is achieved in two steps. The first section transforms 200 Offi load into pthe ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 0 the intermediate value of 100 O. The characteristic impedance is Z02 ¼ 100 200 ffi 141 O. The reflection coefficient from the load to the junction between the two sections describes the semicircle A–B in Figure 4.11. The second l/4 section transforms 100 O into 50 O as required. Its
Figure 4.11
Reflection coefficient trajectories of the circuits in Figure 4.10.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
105
4
VSWR
3
1 section (∆f/f0≈0.625)
2
2 sections (∆f/f0≈0.964)
1 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
f/f0
Figure 4.12
VSWR of the circuits in Figure 4.10.
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 0 characteristic impedance is Z01 ¼ 50 100 ffi 70:7 O. The reflection coefficient describes the semicircle B–C in Figure 4.11. As in the single section transformer, the impedance is real at the ends but complex along the lines. The maximum Q factor is half that of the single section transformer. Although the result is already well known, simple inspection of Figure 4.11 allows us to conclude that the two-section transformer has a wider bandwidth that the single section transformer. A quantitative comparison of the performances of the two circuits in Figure 4.10 can be obtained, for example, in terms of the VSWR vs. frequency, as shown in Figure 4.12. Observe first that both responses are periodical with period 2f0. Only the first period is shown in the figure. For both circuits the mismatch is maximum at the band ends (VSWR ¼ 4) and zero at mid-band. Elsewhere, the VSWR of circuit (b) is better than that of circuit (a). Finally, for a given maximum VSWR, the frequency band of the two-section transformer is wider than the single section one. For example, for VSWR < 2, the former has a 96% bandwidth, while the latter has only 60% bandwidth. In conclusion, monitoring the Q factors of the reflection coefficients in the design of a matching network can provide some useful information; minimizing the Q generally leads to less critical networks and wider bandwidths.
4.5 Power flow In this section, we are concerned with the power flow associated with EM waves travelling along a generalized transmission line. Let us suppose, for the moment, that only the incident wave is present; this implies that the line is matched and the reflected wave amplitude is zero (V ¼ 0). We also assume that the line is lossless. Using (3.54) for the voltage and current along the line, the real power3 travelling along the line in the positive z direction is 1 V þ* þ jbz 1 2 ¼ e ð4:33Þ P þ ¼ Re V þ e jbz jV þ j 2 2Z0 Z0 3
Using the phasor representation, the real power is the average power in one period T ¼ 2p/o, see (2.32).
106
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Zg Vg +
Iin
+ Vin –
Z0 , β0
ΓL
ZL
Zin Z= 0
Z= –
Figure 4.13
ΓL =
ZL – Z0 ZL + Z0
Γin =
Zin – Zg Zin + Zg
z
Power transfer from a source to a load through a transmission line.
When, on the contrary, only the reflected wave is present, thus V þ ¼ 0, the power travelling in the negative z direction is P ¼
1 jV j2 2Z0
ð4:34Þ
In the general case, when both incident and reflected waves are present on the line, 1 Re ðV þ e jbz þ V e þ jbz ÞðV þ* e þ jbz V * e jbz Þ 2Z0 i 1 h þ 2 ¼ jV j jV j2 ¼ P þ P 2Z0
P¼
ð4:35Þ
This equation shows that, as might be anticipated, the flow of real power is constant along the lossless line and equals the difference between the incident and the reflected power. This is clearly because the line is lossless and by virtue of the principle of energy conservation. Note, however, that in addition to the real or active power there is an imaginary or reactive power Pj ¼
1 1 Im ðV þ e jbz þ V e þ jbz ÞðV þ* e þ jbz V * e jbz Þ ¼ ImðV þ* V ej2bz Þ 2Z0 Z0
ð4:36Þ
that varies along the line and depends on the simultaneous presence of both waves. Indeed, if either V þ or V is zero, the reactive power is also zero. Let us now study the power transfer from a source Vg to a load ZL through a transmission line section of characteristic impedance Z0 and phase constant b0, as depicted in Figure 4.13. Zg is the internal impedance of the source, located in z ¼ ‘. We want to determine the power delivered to the load and the conditions for maximum power transfer. Since the line is lossless, the power delivered to the load equals the input power entering into the line: " # " # Vg Zin 2 1 1 1 jVin j2 Pin ¼ Re Vin Iin* ¼ Re Re ¼ Zg þ Zin 2 Z * 2 2 2 Zin* in 2 Vg 1 1 Rin 2 ¼ Re½Zin ¼ Vg 2 Zg þ Zin 2 2 ðRin þ Rg Þ2 þ ðXin þ Xg Þ2 having put Zin ¼ Rin þ jXin and Zg ¼ Rg þ jXg. We now consider some particular cases.
ð4:37Þ
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
107
Matched load ZL ¼ Z0. In such a case no reflection occurs at the load, thus GL ¼ 0 and Zin ¼ Z0. Equation (4.37) becomes 1 2 Z0 Pin ¼ Vg 2 ðZ0 þ Rg Þ2 þ Xg2
ð4:38Þ
The power delivered is just the same as if the load is connected directly to the source. Zin ¼ Zg. In this case the input reflection coefficient is zero. If, however, Zin 6¼ Z0 the line is generally matched neither to the load nor to the source, so that there will be a standing wave. The power transferred to the load is
Matched source
1 2 Rg Pin ¼ Vg 2 4ðR2g þ Xg2 Þ
ð4:39Þ
It is interesting to note that the power (4.39) delivered when the source is matched may be less than that when the load is matched to the line (4.38).
Maximum power transfer; available power
The condition for maximum power transfer for a given source impedance can be established by simply equating to zero the derivatives of (4.37) with respect to Rin and Xin. From easy algebra one obtains the well-known condition for conjugate matching: Zin ¼ Zg*
ð4:40Þ
When the impedance seen by the source equals the conjugate of the internal impedance of the generator, the power delivered to the load is a maximum and equal to the power available from the source 1 2 1 Pav ¼ Vg 2 4Rg
ð4:41Þ
Note that (4.40) does not imply the matching of the generator to the line (Zg ¼ Z0), nor of the load (Z0 ¼ ZL), nor of the generator (Zg ¼ Zin) except, in the last case, when Xg ¼ Xin ¼ 0. Let us finally observe that, as far as the input terminals of the line are concerned, the voltage source Vg with internal impedance Zg is equivalent to an incident wave of amplitude Vgþ ¼ Vg =2 travelling along a line with characteristic impedance Zg. Suppose for the moment, as illustrated in Figure 4.14, that the line Z0 is matched and thus is terminated with Z0. Let us compute the voltage Vin at the line input in both cases. In the former case, when the line is fed by the source Vg, we have Vin ¼ Vg
Z0 Zg þ Z0
ð4:42Þ
while in the latter case, when the line Z0 is connected to the transmission line Zg with an incident voltage Vgþ , the input voltage at z ¼ l is Vin ¼ Vgþ ð1 þ Gin Þ ¼ Vgþ
Figure 4.14
ð4:43Þ
+
V g = Vg /2
Zg Vg
2Z0 Zg þ Z0
+
Z0
Zg
Z0
Equivalence between a voltage source and an incident voltage wave.
108
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Both circuits produce the same voltages and currents on the line if 2Vgþ ¼ Vg . The power carried by the incident wave Vgþ is þ 2 V 1 g ð4:44Þ Pav ¼ 2 Rg and is thus coincident with the available power from the generator (4.41). Consider Figure 4.13 again, where the line Z0 is terminated with ZL. Let V þ and V be the wave amplitudes on the line Z0, with V ¼ GL V þ . The voltage and current at z ¼ l are given by Vð lÞ ¼ V þ ðebl þ GL e bl Þ V þ bl ðe GL e bl Þ Z0
Ið lÞ ¼
ð4:45Þ
The above quantities are related to the source voltage Vg by Vg ¼ Vð lÞ þ Zg Ið lÞ
ð4:46Þ
þ
Inserting (4.45) into (4.46) and solving for V , we find that the incident wave voltage on the line is Vþ ¼
Vg 1 1 þ Z^ g e jbl GL Gg e jbl
ð4:47Þ
with Zg Z^ g ¼ ; Z0
Gg ¼
Z^ g 1 Z^ g þ 1
ð4:48Þ
Let us now replace the voltage source Vg with internal impedance Zg by a transmission line of characteristic impedance Zg with an incident voltage wave Vgþ . The voltage and current at z ¼ l can be expressed in terms of the incident and reflected voltages with the usual formulae: Vgþ þ Vg ¼ Vð lÞ Vgþ Vg ¼ Zg Ið lÞ
ð4:49Þ
Inserting (4.45) into (4.49) and solving for V þ , we obtain V þ¼
2Vgþ 1 1 þ Z^ g e jbl GL Gg e jbl
ð4:50Þ
Again we see the equivalence between the two models of Figure 4.14, when 2Vgþ ¼ Vg . Note that from (4.49) and (4.45) we also get Vg ¼ Vgþ
Gg þ GL e 2jbl 1 GL Gg e 2jbl
ð4:51Þ
Therefore, the input reflection coefficient seen from the Zg line is Gin;g ¼
Gg þ GL e 2jbl 1 GL Gg e 2jbl
ð4:52Þ
while the input reflection coefficient seen from the Z0 line is Gin;0 ¼ GL e 2jbl
ð4:53Þ
It can easily be shown that (4.52) can also be obtained by (4.23) with Gin;1 ¼ Gin;g and G01 ¼ Gg .
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
109
4.6 Matrix representations As we have seen above, a microwave circuit with N apertures can be represented as an N-port network. Different representations may be adopted and are in use to characterize such a circuit by expressing the relationships between the 2N voltages and currents at its ports or between other variables related to such quantities. Here we will limit our attention to the most common and practical representations.
4.6.1
The impedance matrix
The impedance matrix relates the voltages V1, V2, . . . , VN at the circuit ports to the currents I1, I2, . . . , IN entering into those ports. Because of linearity, we can write V1 ¼ z11 I1 þ z12 I2 þ þ z1N IN V2 ¼ z21 I1 þ z22 I2 þ þ z2N IN .. . VN ¼ zN1 I1 þ zN2 I2 þ þ zNN IN
ð4:54Þ
½V ¼ ½Z ½I
ð4:55Þ
In matrix form,
where [V] and [I] are N 1 column vectors and [Z] is an N N matrix called the impedance matrix of the network. The physical meaning of the impedance matrix becomes apparent by considering how, at least in principle, we can measure its elements, also called the impedance parameters or Z parameters of the network. Suppose the current Ij is applied to the jth port while all other ports are open-circuited (thus Ii ¼ 0 for any i 6¼ j). From (4.54) we obtain Vi ¼ zij Ij , thus Vi ð4:56Þ zij ¼ Ij I1 ¼I2 ¼¼IN ¼0;Ij 6¼ 0 The impedance parameters are thus evaluated by feeding one port with a given current while all remaining ports are open-circuited. In particular, zii represents the input impedance at the ith port when all remaining ports are open-circuited, while the quantity zij (with i 6¼ j) is the transimpedance between ports i and j. For lossless networks, the Z parameters, thus the Z matrix, are purely imaginary. For reciprocal networks, i.e. when Lorentz’s theorem holds, it can be proved that zij ¼ zji
ð4:57Þ
This implies that the impedance matrix is symmetrical with respect to its main diagonal. Such a property does not hold true for networks containing nonlinear devices (such as diodes and transistors) or anisotropic materials (such as ferrites). Let us now consider the particular case of a two-port network, as depicted in Figure 4.15a. Figure 4.15b shows a particular circuit topology, called a T network because of its shape.
I1 V1
I2
[Z]
V2 (a)
Figure 4.15
I1
I2 ZA
V1
ZB ZC
V2
(b)
A two-port network and its T network representation.
110
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The T network lends itself to represent a generic two-port network in terms of its impedance parameters. To prove this statement, let us determine its Z parameters by adopting their definitions. To compute z11 and z12 we apply a unit current at port 1 and compute V1 and V2. By examining Figure 4.15b we easily obtain z11 ¼ ZA þ ZC z21 ¼ ZC
ð4:58Þ
In much the same way, we obtain z22 ¼ ZB þ ZC z12 ¼ ZC
ð4:59Þ
Conversely, given the Z matrix of a two-port network, by reversing (4.58)–(4.59) we can compute the impedances ZA, ZB and ZC of the T network: ZA ¼ z11 z12 ZB ¼ z22 z12 ZC ¼ z12 ¼ z21
ð4:60Þ
From the external terminals, the original network and its T network representation are fully equivalent as they have the same Z matrix. Note that a reciprocal network is characterized by three complex parameters (ZA, ZB and ZC), or, equivalently, by six real parameters. They reduce to three real parameters (XA, XB, XC) in the lossless case.
4.6.2
The admittance matrix
Dual to the impedance matrix, the admittance matrix expresses the currents entering into the network in terms of the voltages applied to the ports. Using the matrix notation already used for the impedance matrix, we can write ½I ¼ ½Y ½V
ð4:61Þ
where [Y] is the admittance matrix of the network. Its physical interpretation is analogous to that of the impedance matrix, except that now we have to set the voltages to zero rather than the currents. Instead of (4.56) we now have Ii yij ¼ ð4:62Þ Vj V1 ¼V2 ¼¼VN ¼0;Vj 6¼ 0 Therefore, yij equals the current Ii entering into the ith port when a unit voltage (Vj ¼ 1) is applied to the jth port, while all remaining ports are short-circuited. By comparing (4.55) with (4.61) we can deduce that the Z and Y matrices are inverses of each other, provided that the inverse matrices exist (which is not always true, as we will soon see). Therefore ½Z ¼ ½Y 1
ð4:63Þ
We deduce that, like the Z matrix, the Y matrix is also purely imaginary for lossless networks and symmetrical for reciprocal networks: yij ¼ yji
ð4:64Þ
In the case of two-port networks, the network topology suited to the Y matrix representation is the P network shown in Figure 4.16.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
I1
111
I2 YC
V1
YB
YA
Figure 4.16
V2
A P network.
By a similar reasoning as for the Z parameters, the parameters y11 and y12 are obtained by computing the currents I1 and I2 when voltage V1 ¼ 1 V is applied at port 1 with port 2 short-circuited (V2 ¼ 0). With reference to Figure 4.16, we easily find y11 ¼ YA þ YC y21 ¼ YC
ð4:65Þ
y22 ¼ YB þ YC y12 ¼ YC
ð4:66Þ
Similarly,
By inverting the above formulae we can express the admittances of the P network in terms of the Y parameters: YA ¼ y11 þ y12 YB ¼ y22 þ y12 YC ¼ y12 ¼ y21
ð4:67Þ
These formulae allow us to identify the P equivalent of a generic two-port network of which the Y matrix is known. It is hardly necessary to specify that the admittance parameters are not the inverse of the impedance parameters, i.e. that yij 6¼ 1/zij. In particular, the input admittance y11 is not the inverse of the input impedance z11, as it clearly appears since the former is obtained when port 2 is short-circuited and the latter when port 2 is open-circuited.
4.6.3
The ABCD or chain matrix
The ABCD matrix, also called the chain matrix, is particularly useful for characterizing two-port networks when such networks are cascaded together, as shown in Figure 4.17. The ABCD matrix belongs to the category of transmission matrices, for which the quantities at port 1 are expressed in terms of those at port 2. The ABCD parameters in fact express the voltage and current at the first port in terms of the corresponding quantities at the second port, as follows: V1 A B V2 ¼ ð4:68Þ I1 I2 C D The reader will notice that the current I2 appears with a minus sign; this is because I2 corresponds to the current flowing out of port 2, and thus is equal to the current entering into the next network. With reference to Figure 4.17, since the cascade connection implies that the voltages and currents at the output of the first network are equal to the corresponding quantities at the input of the second network, we can write
112
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Cascade connection of two-port networks.
Figure 4.17
"
ð1Þ
V1
ð1Þ
I1
#
A1 ¼ C1
B1 D1
"
#
ð1Þ
V2
ð1Þ
I2
A1 ¼ C1
B1 D1
"
ð2Þ
V1
ð2Þ
I1
#
A1 ¼ C1
B1 D1
A2 C2
B2 D2
"
ð2Þ
V2
ð2Þ
I2
# ð4:69Þ
The ABCD matrix of the whole network is thus simply the product, taken in the proper order, of the ABCD matrices of the constituent networks:
B A1 ¼ D C1
A C
B1 D1
A2 C2
B2 D2
ð4:70Þ
This result can be immediately generalized to the cascade of any number of cascaded two-port networks. In a lossless network, it can be proved that A and D are real while B and C are imaginary. The reciprocity of the network implies that the matrix determinant is unitary: AD CD ¼ 1
ð4:71Þ
From simple algebra we can obtain the relationship between the chain matrix and the impedance matrix. In fact, solving V1 ¼ z11 I1 þ z12 I2 V2 ¼ z12 I1 þ z22 I2 for V1 and I1 we obtain
A
B
C
D
¼
Z11 =Z21
ðZ11 Z22 Z12 Z21 Þ=Z21
1=Z21
Z22 =Z21
ð4:72Þ
The relationships between the ABCD parameters and the other network parameters are quoted in Table 4.1.
4.6.4
The scattering matrix
In contrast with the matrix representations discussed so far, the scattering matrix, or S matrix, does not deal with voltages and currents but with incoming and outgoing waves at the ports of the network. From the physical point of view, the scattering matrix is the matrix that best represents the behaviour of a microwave circuit, where voltages and currents are somewhat fictitious quantities that cannot be measured directly. On the contrary, we can measure amplitudes and phases of the waves travelling along the transmission lines connected to the circuit ports.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
113
In order to introduce the scattering parameters, however, it is first necessary to clarify what we mean as incoming and outgoing waves, since the commonly adopted terminology for such waves is somewhat improper and confusing. Indeed, the waves travelling towards the network are usually called incident waves, while those travelling from the network are called reflected waves. The latter term does not account for the fact that the wave coming out of a circuit can result not only from the reflection of a wave incident at that port, but also from the transmission of other wave(s) incident at other port(s). In spite of this, we will occasionally use the term reflected wave to indicate a wave coming out of a network. Let us now refer to the generic microwave circuit of Figure 4.3. Along the ith feeding line with characteristic impedance Z0i there are voltage and current waves travelling towards (Viþ ; Iiþ ) and away from (Vi ; Ii ) the circuit. We define the following quantities as incoming and outgoing waves at the reference plane Ti : ai ¼
Vi þ Z0i Ii Vþ pffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ pi ffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 Z0i 2 Z0i
ð4:73Þ
bi ¼
Vi Z0i Ii V pffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ pi ffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 Z0i 2 Z0i
ð4:74Þ
Conversely, the voltage and current are expressed in terms of the wave amplitudes ai, bi as follows: pffiffiffiffiffiffi Vi ¼ ðai þ bÞi Z0i ð4:75Þ pffiffiffiffiffiffi Ii ¼ ðai bi Þ= Z0i In these expressions we have assumed that the characteristic impedance of the line is real; moreover, we have considered that, according to the expressions for voltage and current along a transmission line, we have Vi ¼ Viþ þ Vi
Ii ¼ ðViþ Vi Þ=Z0i
ð4:76Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffi Apart from the factor 1=ð2 Z0i Þ, therefore, ai and bi represent the incident ( þ ) and reflected ( ) voltage waves, respectively, along the ith line at the reference plane Ti. Note that the power entering into the ith port can be expressed in terms of the (complex) wave amplitudes (4.74) 1 Pi ¼ Vi I *i ¼ jai j2 jbi j2 ¼ Piþ Pi 2
ð4:77Þ
where 1 Piþ ¼ Viþ Iiþ * ¼ jai j2 2 1 Pi ¼ Vi Ii * ¼ jbi j2 2
ð4:78Þ
are the incoming (incident) and outgoing (reflected) power from the ith port, respectively. The scattering matrix expresses the outgoing waves bi as linear functions of the incoming waves ai: b1 ¼ s11 a1 þ s12 a2 þ þ s1N aN b2 ¼ s21 a1 þ s22 a2 þ þ s2N aN .. . bN ¼ sN1 a1 þ sN2 a2 þ þ sNN aN
ð4:79Þ
114
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
or, in matrix form, ½b ¼ ½S ½a
ð4:80Þ
The elements of the scattering matrix are the scattering parameters or simply S parameters. It is important to note that they can be defined only when the set of impedances Z0i (i ¼ 1, 2, . . ., N) of the feeding lines has been specified. Such impedances are also called the reference impedances. By changing the reference impedances, the scattering parameters change too. This should not be surprising, since the scattering parameters in the case of multi-port circuits play the same role as the reflection coefficient of a dipole. The latter (see Equation (3.79)) indeed depends on the characteristic impedance of the transmission line connected to it. In most practical cases, however, the reference impedances are chosen to be the same and equal to 50 O. To appreciate the physical meaning of the S parameters, let us proceed as for the impedance or admittance parameters. From (4.79) we obtain bi sij ¼ ð4:81Þ aj a1 ¼a2 ¼¼aN ¼0;aj 6¼ 0 The scattering parameter sij is thus the ratio of the wave amplitude bi coming out of port i to the wave amplitude ai incident on port i when no other wave is incident on the remaining ports. Considering that all ports are assumed to be terminated with transmission lines with characteristic impedances Z0i (i ¼ 1. . .N), the last statement implies that all such lines are matched, i.e. are of infinite length or terminated with their own characteristic impedance. In other words, all ports must be terminated with the respective reference impedance Z0i. Such a condition ensures that no wave is reflected back from the load towards the network (thus ai ¼ 0). From (4.81) for j ¼ i we deduce that sii is the reflection coefficient at the ith port when all ports are matched (i.e. when they are terminated with their reference impedance Z0i). The parameters sij are directly related to the power travelling through the network. Indeed, using (4.78) and (4.81) we find that jsij j2 ¼ Pi =Pjþ
ð4:82Þ
The relationship between the S matrix and the Z matrix can be written as follows: ^ ½U Þ ^ þ ½U Þ 1 ð½Z
½S ¼ ð½Z
ð4:83Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffi ^ ¼ diag 1= Z0i ½Z diag 1= Z0i ½Z
ð4:84Þ
zij ^zij ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Z0i Z0j
ð4:85Þ
where [U] is the unit matrix and
or, equivalently,
^ as defined by (4.84) or (4.85) is the normalized impedance matrix of the network. It The matrix ½Z
coincides with the impedance matrix when the reference impedances Z0i are unitary. In order to prove (4.83), let us write (4.76) in matrix form: ½V ¼ ½V þ þ ½V
½I ¼ diag½Z0i ð½V þ ½V Þ Equations (4.73)–(4.74) can be also written in matrix form as follows: pffiffiffiffiffiffi ½a ¼ diag½1=ð2 Z0i Þ ½V þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffi ½b ¼ diag½1=ð2 Z0i Þ ½V
ð4:86Þ
ð4:87Þ
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS The above equations can immediately be reversed to get pffiffiffiffiffiffi ½V þ ¼ diag½2 Z0i ½a
pffiffiffiffiffiffi ½V ¼ diag½2 Z0i ½b
115
ð4:88Þ
Inserting (4.86) into (4.55) and reordering, we obtain ½V ¼ ð½Z diag½1=Z0i þ ½U Þ 1 ð½Z diag½1=Z0i ½U Þ½V þ
Using the second equation of (4.87) and the first equation of (4.88), after some algebra we find pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffi ½b ¼ diag½1= Z0i ð½Z diag½Z0i þ ½U 1 Þð½Z diag½Z0i ½U Þdiag½ Z0i ½a
ð4:89Þ pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ diag½ Z0i ð½Z þ diag½Z0i Þ 1 ð½Z diag½Z0i Þdiag½1= Z0i ½a
Therefore we have pffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffi ½S ¼ diag½ Z0i ð½Z þ diag½Z0i Þ 1 ð½Z diag½Z0i Þdiag½1= Z0i
ð4:90Þ
The previous expression reduces to (4.83) using the position (4.84). Note the similarity of (4.83) to the reflection coefficient of a dipole with normalized impedance Z^ L : _
GL ¼
ZL 1 _ ZL þ 1
In the common case of reciprocal circuits, the impedance matrix is symmetrical and therefore the S matrix is symmetrical too: sij ¼ sji
ð4:91Þ
^ ½U Þð½Z
^ þ ½U Þ 1 ½S ¼ ð½Z
ð4:92Þ
Equation (4.83) can then also be written as
For lossless networks, the scattering matrix satisfies the so-called unitary property ½S T ½S* ¼ ½U
ð4:93Þ
Equation (4.93) is obtained by imposing that the power entering into the network be equal to the power going out of it. Because of (4.78), we must then impose that X X jb j2 ¼ ja j2 ð4:94Þ i i i i The sum of the squared amplitudes can be put in the following form: X ja j2 ¼ ½a T ½a*
i i
ð4:95Þ
Recalling that the transpose of the product of matrices is the product of the transposed matrices in reverse order, we therefore have that, in order for the power to be conserved, ½b T ½b* ¼ ½a T ½S T ½S* ½a* ¼ ½a T ½a*
Since the excitation is totally arbitrary, the last equality holds only if (4.93) holds.
116
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Equation (4.93) implies, in particular, that N X i¼1
sin s*in ¼
N X
jsin j2 ¼ 1 for n ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; N
ð4:96Þ
i¼1
N X i¼1
sin s*im ¼ 0
for n 6¼ m
ð4:97Þ
According to (4.96), the sum of the squared amplitudes of any column must be equal to one, while, according to (4.97), the product of any column with the conjugate of another column must be zero. Let us now consider the particular case of a lossless two-port network. The unitary condition (4.93) becomes " #" # " # " # 1 0 s11 s21 js11 j2 þ js21 j2 s11 s*12 þ s21 s*22 s*11 s*12 T * ¼ ¼ ð4:98Þ ½S ½S ¼ 0 1 s12 s22 s*21 s*22 s12 s*11 þ s22 s*21 js12 j2 þ js22 j2 Equating the single elements of the matrix to those of the unit matrix we obtain js11 j2 þ js21 j2 ¼ 1 js12 j2 þ js22 j2 ¼ 1
ð4:99Þ
s11 s*12 þ s21 s*22 ¼ 0 s12 s*11 þ s22 s*21 ¼ 0
ð4:100Þ
If the network is reciprocal, then s12 ¼ s21, so that (4.99) implies js11 j ¼ js22 j; qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi js12 j ¼ 1 js11 j2
ð4:101Þ
Therefore, the reflection coefficients at both ports have the same amplitude, but the phases are not necessarily the same, unless the network is symmetrical.4 In addition, if the network is reciprocal, Equations (4.100) become equivalent, since one is the complex conjugate of the other. By writing the S parameters in polar form, i.e. sij ¼ jsij je jjij we obtain from (4.100) s11 s*12 þ s21 s*22 ¼ js11 jjs12 jðe jðj11 j12 Þ þ e jðj12 j22 Þ Þ ¼ 0
ð4:102Þ
having used (4.101). Equation (4.102) is satisfied when the two terms within brackets are opposite, i.e. if the phases differ by odd multiples of p: Thus, j12 ¼
j11 þ j22 p þ þ np 2 2
ð4:103Þ
Apart from multiples of p, the phase of s21 therefore differs by p/2 from the average phase of s11 and s22. In summary, the three complex S parameters of a reciprocal lossless two-port are related by the three real equations (4.101)–(4.102) so that the degrees of freedom of the network are reduced to three. This is
4 One should not confuse the symmetry of the network with that of the S matrix. The former implies that the network looks identical as seen from the first or second port, thus s11 ¼ s22; the latter depends on reciprocity, it implies s12 ¼ s21 and it holds true independently of the symmetry of the network.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
I1
117
I2 Yc
V1
Figure 4.18
V2
A two-port network which does not have a Z matrix representation.
consistent with the representation in terms of impedance parameters that, for a lossless reciprocal network, reduce to three reactances X11, X12 ¼ X21, X22. In contrast to the impedance and admittance matrices that may not exist for particular network topologies, the scattering matrix does exist for whatever real network. Let us take as an example the network made by the series element shown in Figure 4.18. The network equations are V1 ¼ V2 ZC I2 I1 ¼ I2
ð4:104Þ
where we have put Zc ¼ 1/Yc. By comparison of (4.104) with (4.68) we find that the ABCD matrix is A B 1 ZC ¼ ð4:105Þ C D 0 1 The network may also be considered as a special case of the P network with YA ¼ YB ¼ 0. From (4.65)–(4.66) we find that the admittance matrix is 1 1 ½Y ¼ YC 1 1 Such a network does not have an impedance matrix since the Y matrix has no inverse (its determinant is zero). This reflects the fact that the impedance parameters are open-circuit parameters. Because of the network topology I1¼ I2: it is therefore impossible to excite one port with a non-zero current while the other port is open-circuited. Or, in other terms, the input impedance at one port is infinite when the other port is open-circuited. In order to compute the S matrix of Figure 4.18, we assume that the network is connected at both ports with transmission lines with Z0 ¼ 1/Y0 characteristic impedance. This will be our reference impedance at both ports. We can use the dual expression of (4.83) to express [S] in terms of [Y]: ½S ¼ ð½U þ ½Y^ Þ 1 ð½U ½Y^ Þ " # 1" # " # 1 1 þ Y^ C Y^ C 1 Y^ C Y^ C 1 2Y^ C ¼ ¼ ... ¼ 1 þ 2Y^ C 2Y^ C 1 Y^ C 1 Y^ C Y^ C 1 þ Y^ C
ð4:106Þ
^ C , and the S parameters become where Y^ C ¼ YC =Y0 . If the network is lossless, Y^ C ¼ j B 1 ^C 1 þ j2B ^C j2B ¼ ^C 1 þ j2B
s11 ¼ s22 ¼ s12 ¼ s21
ð4:107Þ
118
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The reader can easily verify that the lossless conditions (4.101)–(4.102) are satisfied. Note that (4.107) can also be calculated without resorting to the admittance matrix, but using the scattering parameter definition. With both ports terminated on transmission lines with Z0 characteristic impedance, we consider a wave a1 incident from line 1 to port 1, while the second line is matched (a2 ¼ 0). In such conditions, the input reflection coefficient is s11 and is given by s11 ¼
ðZC þ Z0 Þ Z0 ZC 1 1 ¼ ¼ ¼ ðZC þ Z0 Þ þ Z0 ZC þ 2Z0 1 þ 2Z0 =ZC 1 þ 2Y^ C
ð4:108Þ
To compute s21, since a2 ¼ 0, from the second equation of (4.75) we have I1 ¼ a1 b1 ¼ a1 ð1 s11 Þ I2 ¼ b2 where, for simplicity but without loss of generality, we have put Z0 ¼ 1. Because I2 ¼ I1 from previous equations, we obtain I2 b2 s21 ¼ ¼ ¼1 I1 a1 ð1 s11 Þ 1 s11 thus s21 ¼ 1 s11 ¼
2Y^ C 1 þ 2Y^ C
ð4:109Þ
This is the same expression we already found. Let us now consider the dual case of the network made of shunt impedance ZC, as shown in Figure 4.19. The relevant network equations are V1 ¼ V2 I1 ¼ YC V2 I2
ð4:110Þ
From the above, the ABCD matrix is immediately obtained: A B 1 0 ¼ C D YC 1
ð4:111Þ
The impedance matrix is obtained from (4.110) or from (4.58)–(4.59) by putting ZA ¼ ZB ¼ 0: 1 1 ð4:112Þ ½Z ¼ ZC 1 1 while an admittance matrix cannot be defined. Indeed, since V1 ¼ V2 one port cannot be set to a non-zero voltage when the other is short-circuited. In other words, the input admittance at one port is infinite when the other port is short-circuited.
I1
V1
Figure 4.19
I2
Zc
V2
A two-port network which does not have a Y matrix representation.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
119
Let us compute the scattering parameters using Z0 as the reference impedance at both ports. Consider a wave a1 incident to port 1, while the second line is matched (a2 ¼ 0); the reflection coefficient at port 1 is s11 ¼
ZC jjZ0 Z0 Y0 ðY0 þ YC Þ Y^ C 1 ¼ ¼ ¼ ZC jjZ0 þ Z0 Y0 þ Y0 þ YC 2 þ Y^ C 2Z^ C þ 1
ð4:113Þ
Since V1 ¼ a1 þ b1 ¼ a1 ð1 þ s11 Þ V2 ¼ b2 we obtain from the equality of the voltages V2 b2 s21 ¼ ¼1 ¼ V1 a1 ð1 þ s11 Þ 1 þ s11 Therefore s21 ¼ 1 þ s11 ¼
2Z^ C 1 þ 2Z^ C
ð4:114Þ
The same results could obviously be obtained by inserting (4.112) in (4.83). If the network is lossless, then ZC ¼ jXC. It can be easily verified that (4.101)–(4.102) are satisfied. Table 4.1 provides the relationships among the Z, Y, ABCD and S parameters of a two-port network.
4.7 Circuit model of a transmission line section The matrix representations introduced in Section 4.6 can be applied to represent a section of transmission line as a two-port network. With reference to Figure 4.20, let us consider a transmission line section of characteristic impedance Zc located between z ¼ 0 and z ¼ l, with electrical length y ¼ bl. From the transmission line equations VðzÞ ¼ V þ e jbz þ V e þ jbz 1 IðzÞ ¼ ðV þ e jbz V e þ jbz Þ Zc
ð4:115Þ
expressing the voltages and currents at the two ports as the voltages and currents along the transmission line at the electrical lengths 0 and y, i.e. putting V1 ¼ Vð0Þ V2 ¼ VðyÞ
I1 ¼ Ið0Þ I2 ¼ IðyÞ
ð4:116Þ
we obtain V1 ¼ V þ þ V Vþ V I1 ¼ Zc V2 ¼ V þ e jy þ V e jy
1 þ jy I2 ¼ V e V e þ jy Zc
ð4:117Þ
The first two equations can be used to express the quantities V þ and V in terms of V1 and I1: 1 V ¼ ðV1 Zc I1 Þ 2
ð4:118Þ
y12 y21 y22
z22
z22 jZj
z12 jZj
z21 jZj
z11 jZj
z11 z21
jZj z21
1 z21
z22 z21
z22
y11
y12
y21
y22
A
B
C
D
D
C
jYj y21 y11 y21
B
A
A B
1 B
BD AC B
B D
1 y21
y22 y21
y11
z21
z21 D C
y11 jYj
z12
z12
A C AD BC C 1 C
y22 jYj y12 jYj y21 jYj
z11
[ABCD]
[Y]
z11
[Z]
Table 4.1 Relations among the Z, Y, ABCD and S parameters of a two-port network
ð1 þ s11 Þð1 s22 Þ þ s12 s21 ð1 þ s11 Þð1 þ s22 Þ s12 s21
2s21 ð1 þ s11 Þð1 þ s22 Þ s12 s21
s12 ð1 þ s11 Þð1 þ s22 Þ s12 s21
ð1 s11 Þð1 þ s22 Þ þ s12 s21 ð1 þ s11 Þð1 þ s22 Þ s12 s21
ð1 s11 Þð1 þ s22 Þ þ s12 s21 ð1 s11 Þð1 s22 Þ s12 s21
ð1 s11 Þð1 s22 Þ s12 s21 2s21
ð1 þ s11 Þð1 þ s22 Þ s12 s21 2s21
ð1 s11 Þð1 þ s22 Þ þ s12 s21 2s21
Z0
Z0
ð1 þ s11 Þð1 s22 Þ þ s12 s21 2s21
Y0
Y0
Y0
Y0
Z0
ð1 þ s11 Þð1 s22 Þ þ s12 s21 ð1 s11 Þð1 s22 Þ s12 s21 2s12 Z0 ð1 s11 Þð1 s22 Þ s12 s21 2s21 Z0 ð1 s11 Þð1 s22 Þ s12 s21 Z0
[S]
120 MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
2y12 Y0 DY 2y21 Y0 DY ðY0 þ y11 ÞðY0 y22 Þ þ y12 y21 DY
2z12 Z0 DZ
2z21 Z0 DZ
ðz11 þ Z0 Þðz22 Z0 Þ z12 z21 DZ
s12
s21
s22
A þ B=Z0 CZ0 D A þ B=Z0 þ CZ0 þ D
2 A þ B=Z0 þ CZ0 þ D
2ðAD BCÞ A þ B=Z0 þ CZ0 þ D
A þ B=Z0 CZ0 D A þ B=Z0 þ CZ0 þ D
DZ ¼ ðz11 þ Z0 Þðz22 þ Z0 Þ z12 z21 ; DY ¼ ðy11 þ Y0 Þðy22 þ Y0 Þ y12 y21 ; Y0 ¼ 1=Z0
jZj ¼ z11 z22 z12 z21 ; jYj ¼ y11 y22 y12 y21 ;
ðy0 y11 ÞðY0 þ y22 Þ þ y12 y21 DY
ðz11 Z0 Þðz22 þ Z0 Þ z12 z21 DZ
s11
s22
s21
s12
s11
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS 121
122
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 4.20
A transmission line section as a two-port network.
Substituting into the remaining equations and reordering, we obtain V1 ¼ jZc cotyI1 j V2 ¼ j
Zc I2 sin y
ð4:119Þ
Zc I1 jZc cot yI2 sin y
The impedance matrix of the line sections is therefore " # 1 jZc cos y coty ðsinyÞ 1 ¼ ½Z ¼ jZc sin y 1 cos y ðsinyÞ 1 coty
ð4:120Þ
Notice that, consistent with the definition of the impedance matrix, Z11 ¼ Z22 is nothing but the input impedance of an open-circuited stub. Reordering the equations so as to express the currents in terms of the voltages, we obtain the admittance matrix of the line section: " # jYc cos y 1 coty ðsinyÞ 1 ð4:121Þ ½Y ¼ jYc ¼ siny 1 cos y ðsinyÞ 1 coty where Yc ¼ 1/Zc. Note that y11 ¼ y22 is the input admittance of a short-circuited stub. Finally, for the ABCD matrix we obtain from simple manipulations A B cos y jZc siny ¼ ð4:122Þ C D cos y jYc sin y To compute the scattering matrix, let us choose the same reference impedance Z0 at both ports. Using (4.83), " ½S ¼ 1 ¼ D
"
j Z^ c cot y þ 1 j Z^ c ðsin yÞ 1
j Z^ c ðsin yÞ 1 j Z^ c cot y þ 1
#! 1 "
2 Z^ c 1
2j Z^ c ðsin yÞ 1
2j Z^ c ðsin yÞ 1
2 Z^ c 1
#
j Z^ c cot y 1 j Z^ c ðsin yÞ 1
j Z^ c ðsin yÞ 1 j Z^ c cot y 1
#! ð4:123Þ
where Z^ c ¼ Zc =Z0 D ¼ 1 2j Z^ c cot y þ Z^ c
2
ð4:124Þ
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
123
If the reference impedance Z0 is the same as the characteristic impedance Zc of the line, then Z^ c ¼ 1. From simple algebra (4.123) reduces to " # 0 e jy ½S ¼ ð4:125Þ e jy 0 As might be expected, the reflection coefficients s11 ¼ s22 are zero, while the transmission coefficients s21 ¼ s12 consist of just a phase shift equal to the electrical length of the line. It should be remembered that this result holds true only when Zc ¼ Z0.
4.8 Shifting the reference planes In deriving the circuit model of an N-port microwave circuit, on each feeding line we have introduced a reference plane where we evaluate voltages and currents relative to that port. The location of such reference planes is to a large extent arbitrary, as long as they are sufficiently far from the microwave circuit that all higher modes have died out. In many practical cases it is useful to shift the reference planes, e.g. in order to obtain simpler circuit representations. In this section we want to determine how the shift of the reference planes affects the scattering matrix of a two-port network. The extension to the general case of N-port networks is straightforward. Let us refer to Figure 4.21, where a two-port network is characterized in terms of the scattering matrix [S] with respect to the reference planes T1, T2. Shifting such planes to T01 ; T02 is equivalent to adding two line sections of electrical lengths y1, y2, respectively. By simple inspection of Figure 4.21 we can write a1 ¼ a01 e jy1 a2 ¼ a02 e jy2 thus
Finally,
b0 1 ¼ b1 e jy1 ¼ ðs11 a1 þ s12 a2 Þe jy1 ¼ s11 a01 e jy1 þ s12 a02 e jy2 e jy1
b0 2 ¼ b2 e jy2 ¼ ðs21 a1 þ s22 a2 Þe jy2 ¼ s21 a01 e jy1 þ s22 a02 e jy2 e jy2 "
# " # # " s11 s12 e jy1 0 e jy1 0 s11 e j2y1 s12 e jðy1 þ y2 Þ ½S ¼ ¼ 0 e jy2 s21 s22 0 e jy2 s21 e jðy1 þ y2 Þ s22 e j2y2 jy jy ¼ diag e i ½S diag e i 0
T′1
T1
θ1
T2
θ2
a′1
ð4:126Þ
T′2 a′2
Z0
[S]
Z0 b′2
b′1 a1
a2
b1
b2
Figure 4.21
Shifting the reference planes.
124
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
More explicitly, s0ij ¼ sij e jðyi þ yj Þ
ð4:127Þ
A much harder effort would be required to obtain the corresponding relation between the impedance or admittance matrix.
4.9 Loaded two-port network We want here to determine the behaviour of a two-port network at port 1 when port 2 is terminated with a load ZL, as sketched in Figure 4.22. The latter condition is expressed by V2 ¼ ZL I2
ð4:128Þ
Combining (4.128) with the network description in terms of the impedance matrix V1 ¼ z11 I1 þ z12 I2 V2 ¼ z21 I1 þ z22 I2 we easily obtain the input impedance at port 1: Zin ¼
V1 z12 z21 ¼ z11 I1 z22 þ ZL
ð4:129Þ
Note that Zin reduces to z11 when the load is an open circuit (ZL ¼ 1). In much the same way the input admittance is found to be Yin ¼ y11
y12 y21 y22 þ YL
ð4:130Þ
which coincides with y11 when the load is a short circuit (YL ¼ 1). If the load is characterized by its reflection coefficient GL with respect to a given reference Z0, we have a2 ¼ GL b2
ð4:131Þ
Utilizing the scattering matrix (using the same reference impedance), we obtain with a similar procedure the input reflection coefficient Gin ¼ s11
s12 s21 s12 s21 GL ¼ s11 þ s22 1=GL 1 s22 GL
ð4:132Þ
Two port network
Γin
1
[Z]
2
[Y] [S]
Zin Yin Figure 4.22
A terminated two-port network.
ZL
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
125
4.10 Matrix description of coupled lines In Section 3.16.2 we derived the voltages and currents along a set of coupled lines in terms of their even and odd modes. In this section we will derive the Z matrix description of a length of coupled lines. We will also provide an expression for the scattering matrix, without any proof, since the derivation procedure is the same as for the Z matrix. Let us therefore consider a length l of TEM coupled transmission lines. For simplicity of notation, rather than physical length l we will refer to the electrical length y¼o
l v
ð4:133Þ
representing the phase shift of the signal through the distance l. For example, when the lines are l/4 long, the electrical length is y ¼ p/2. Figure 4.23 shows the schematic for a four-port network consisting of a section of coupled lines with characteristic impedances Z0e, Z0o and electrical length y. For simplicity, the ground terminals on the l.h.s. and r.h.s. are not indicated. Line 1 connects terminals 1 and 2, while line 2 connects terminals 3 and 4. As mentioned above, we can express the electrical quantities at the four ports as a linear superposition of the even and odd mode quantities. Taking into account that the even mode corresponds to equal quantities on both lines, while the odd mode corresponds to opposite quantities, we obtain V1 ¼ V1e þ V1o
I1 ¼ I1e þ I1o
V2 ¼ V2e þ V2o V3 ¼ V1e V1o V4 ¼ V2e V2o
I2 ¼ I2e þ I2o I3 ¼ I1e I1o I4 ¼ I2e I2o
ð4:134Þ
As we have seen, each mode can be modelled as a transmission line. Rather than manipulating (4.134), the Z matrix can be easily obtained by applying expression (4.120) for the impedance matrix of a line section to relate the voltages and currents of the even and odd modes:
V1e;o V1e;o
¼ jZ0e;o
1 cosy sin y 1
1 cosy
I1e;o I1e;o
ð4:135Þ
where for brevity we have used subscripts ‘e’ or ‘ o’ to refer to the even or odd mode. Substituting (4.135) into (4.134), we obtain the relationships between the voltages and currents at the four ports of the network:
3
4
1
2
Figure 4.23 Four-port network made of a section of coupled lines.
126
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 3 2 3 V1 I1 6V 7 6I 7 6 27 6 27 6 7 ¼ ½Z 44 6 7 4 V3 5 4 I3 5 V4 I4 2
ð4:136Þ
where the elements of the matrix [Z] are Z0e þ Z0o cot y 2 Z0e þ Z0o ðsinyÞ 1 ¼ j 2 Z0e Z0o ¼ j cot y 2 Z0e Z0o ¼ j ðsinyÞ 1 2
z11 ¼ z22 ¼ z33 ¼ z44 ¼ j z12 ¼ z21 ¼ z34 ¼ z43 z13 ¼ z31 ¼ z24 ¼ z42 z14 ¼ z41 ¼ z32 ¼ z23
ð4:137Þ
As can be seen, because of the symmetry and reciprocity of the structure, the network is characterized by only four independent parameters. The same procedure can also be applied to compute other matrix representations, such as the Y matrix or the scattering matrix S. In the former case, instead of (4.137) by duality, one obtains Y0e þ Y0o cot y 2 Y0e þ Y0o ¼ j ðsinyÞ 1 2 Y0e Y0o cot y ¼j 2 Y0e Y0o ðsinyÞ 1 ¼j 2
y11 ¼ y22 ¼ y33 ¼ y44 ¼ j y12 ¼ y21 ¼ y34 ¼ y43 y13 ¼ y31 ¼ y24 ¼ y42 y14 ¼ y41 ¼ y32 ¼ y23
ð4:138Þ
where Y0e ¼ 1=Z0e , Y0o ¼ 1=Z0o . The scattering matrix elements are found to be s11 s13
! 2 2 1 Z^ 0e 1 Z^ 0o 1 ¼ þ 2 De Do ! 2 2 1 Z^ 0e 1 Z^ 0o 1 ¼ 2 De Do
s12 ¼ s14
j Z^ 0e Z^ 0o þ Do siny De
j Z^ 0e Z^ 0o ¼ siny De Do
ð4:139Þ
where De;o ¼ 1 2j Z^ 0e;o cot y þ Z^ 0e;o . The other elements of the matrix are simply obtained by permutations of the indexes, just like the Z matrix. In (4.139) the impedances are normalized with respect to the reference impedance Z0. 2
4.11 Matching of coupled lines As already observed, a set of coupled lines does not possess a unique characteristic impedance. We are therefore interested in investigating whether and how the four-port network constituted by a section of coupled lines can be matched to an external reference impedance Z0. To answer this question it is
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS
127
sufficient to consider the scattering parameters (4.139) of the network and to impose the matching conditions at all ports; that is, the reflection coefficient s11 is zero (the reflection coefficients at the other ports are equal to s11). After some algebra, the condition s11 ¼ 0 in the first equation of (4.139) yields Z^ 0e Z^ 0o ¼ 1
ð4:140Þ
Z0e Z0o ¼ Z02
ð4:141Þ
or, using denormalized impedances,
The above equations imply that the coupled-line section is matched at any frequency to an impedance equal to the geometric mean of the even and odd impedances. Let us assume that the coupled-line length is matched. Inserting (4.141) into (4.139), we obtain s11 ¼ s22 ¼ s33 ¼ s44 ¼ 0
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 C2 s12 ¼ s21 ¼ s34 ¼ s43 ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 C2 cos y þ j sin y jC sin y s13 ¼ s31 ¼ s24 ¼ s42 ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 C2 cos y þ j sin y s14 ¼ s41 ¼ s32 ¼ s23 ¼ 0
ð4:142Þ
where C¼
Z0e Z0o Z0e =Z0o 1 ¼ Z0e þ Z0o Z0e =Z0o þ 1
ð4:143Þ
is the coupling coefficient. When y ¼ p/2, i.e. at the frequency when the coupled-line section is l/4 long, C is equal to the magnitude of s31, whose square is proportional to the power transfer from the input port 1 to the coupled port 3. Notice that when the matching condition is verified, ports 1 and 4 are mutually isolated; similarly, ports 2 and 3 are isolated as well. The power entering into port 1 is thus split between ports 2 and 3, while port 4 is uncoupled. This is the behaviour of a directional coupler, a device discussed in Section 7.7.3. Ports 2, 3 and 4 are called the direct, coupled and isolated ports, respectively. The behaviour of the scattering parameters is periodic with period y ¼ 2p. Considering their magnitude, the period is p. The magnitudes of the transmission parameters s21 and s31 of the direct and coupled branches are shown in Figure 7.33. Notice that the maximum coupling occurs at y ¼ p/2 (thus the length is l/4), for which |s31| ¼ C.
4.12 Two-port networks using coupled-line sections Sections of coupled transmission lines can also be employed as two-port networks by short- or opencircuiting two out of four ports in Figure 4.23 and using the remaining ports as the input/output ports. Let us first observe that the four-port network of Figure 4.23 is equivalent to a network made of three transmission lines, as shown in Figure 4.24. The transmission lines A and C have characteristic impedance ZA ¼ ZC ¼ Z0e ¼ ðY0e Þ 1 , while the central line has characteristic impedance ZB ¼ ðYB Þ 1 ¼
Y0o Y0e 1 2
128
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
1
1
3
2
3
1
3
4
V1A
I1A
+ V1B I1B –
4
3
V1C
I2A
ZA
I2B
ZB
I1C
I2C
ZC
V2A
2
+ V2B – 4
V2C
ZA = ZC = Z0e –1 –1 ZB= 2 (Y0o –Y0e)–1=2/(Z0o – Z0e )
Figure 4.24
Equivalent circuit (right) of a pair of coupled lines (left).
The equivalence is readily proved by computing the admittance matrix of the three-line network of Figure 4.24. Because of the symmetry of the structure, it suffices to compute the first row of the admittance matrix, i.e. y1j ; j ¼ 1 . . . 4, the remaining elements being obtained by simple permutation of the indexes. According to (4.121) and with the notation of Figure 4.24 we can write
(Z0e + Z0o)/2
1
3
4
2
1
2
open
1
2 (a) 2 Z0e Z0o (Z0e + Z0o) (Z0e – Z0o)2
Z0o
1
3
4
open
1
2
1
3
4
1
2
open
Z0o
1
2
2 (b)
(Z0e – Z0o)/2
–1
–1
2/(Z0e – Z0e )
1 2 (c)
2 Z0e
Z0e
–1
–1
2/(Z0o – Z0e )
1
3
4
2
1
2
1
2 (d) Z0e
Figure 4.25
Z0e
Circuits using coupled lines.
MICROWAVE CIRCUITS A I1A A V1 ½
¼ Y IA VA 2B 2B V I1 ¼ ½Y B 1B I2B V C 2C V I1 ¼ ½Y C 1C I2C V2
129
where
# coty ðsin yÞ 1 ½Y ¼ ½Y ¼ jY0e ðsinyÞ 1 cot y " # Y0o Y0e cot y ðsin yÞ 1 B ½Y ¼ j 2 ðsinyÞ 1 cot y
ð4:144Þ
"
A
C
With reference to Figure 4.24, we find that the input current at port 1 is given by
I1 ¼ I1A þ I1B ¼ yA11 V1A þ yA12 V2A þ yB11 V1B þ yB12 V2B
¼ yA11 V1 þ yA12 V2 þ yB11 ðV1 V3 Þ þ yB12 V2 yB12
¼ yA11 þ yB11 V1 þ yA12 þ yB12 V2 yB11 V3 yB12 V4
ð4:145Þ
ð4:146Þ
In conclusion, from (4.144)–(4.146) we find Y0e þ Y0o cot y 2 Y0e þ Y0o ðsin yÞ 1 y12 ¼ yA12 þ yB12 ¼ j 2 ð4:147Þ Y0e Y0o coty y13 ¼ yB11 ¼ j 2 Y0e Y0o B y14 ¼ y12 ¼ j ðsinyÞ 1 2 which are clearly coincident with (4.138). Of special interest are the cases illustrated in Figure 4.25, where coupled-line sections are used as two-port networks, the remaining two ports being open- or short-circuited depending on the case. Such circuits are used in the realization of bandstop and bandpass filters (see Sections 8.7.2 and 8.7.3). The equivalences illustrated in the figure can easily be proved after some algebra by computing the matrix representation of each pair of equivalent networks. Other equivalences involving coupled line two-port networks can be found, for example, in [5, 6]. y11 ¼ yA11 þ yB11 ¼ j
Bibliography 1. N. Marcuvitz, Waveguide Handbook, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1951. 2. C. G. Montgomery, R. H. Dicke and E. M. Purcell, Principles of Microwave Circuits, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1948. 3. J. C.Slater, Microwave Electronics, Van Nostrand, Princeton, NJ, 1950. 4. K. Kurokawa, An Introduction to the Theory of Microwave Circuits, Academic Press, New York, 1969. 5. G. Matthaei, L. Young and E. M. T. Jones, Microwave Filters, Impedance Matching Networks, and Coupling Structures, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1964. 6. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Simulation and Design, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007.
5
Resonators and cavities 5.1 Introduction Due to their property of sustaining, and thus stabilizing, EM field oscillations at given frequencies, resonators play a special role in electronic techniques at both low and high frequencies. They are employed in a large variety of circuits and devices, including filters, oscillators, amplifiers and frequency meters. Obviously, depending on the frequency band of the application, different technologies and configurations are employed to fabricate resonators, but the basic features are common to all of them. After introducing the general features of resonators in this chapter, we examine lumped element, then one-dimensional (or transmission line) resonators, two-dimensional (or planar) resonators and finally three-dimensional or cavity resonators. The last case is of special interest from the theoretical point of view, since it offers the opportunity to present a very general and powerful theory concerning EM expansion in resonant modes.
5.2 The resonant condition A generic one-port circuit like that depicted in Figure 5.1 can exchange energy with the outer space through a terminal pair or through the cross-section of a generalized transmission line (as we saw in Chapter 4, this can also be represented as a terminal pair) depending on whether we adopt the point of view of circuit theory or the microwave network. We can therefore enclose the circuit within a region V such that the EM energy exchange occurs only through the terminal pair (or the transmission line crosssection), while the EM field is zero on the remaining part of the surface. In the absence of external sources, non-zero voltages or currents can occur in a passive circuit only at specific frequencies, called resonant frequencies, of the circuit. The condition for such free oscillations to occur is the resonant condition. It is apparent that only an ideal lossless circuit can sustain such oscillations indefinitely, while a lossy circuit can only sustain damped oscillations. A resonant circuit, or resonator, usually exhibits low loss so that its oscillations are maintained over a prolonged period of time that includes several oscillation cycles. In the ideal case of no losses, free oscillations of a two-terminal network occur at real frequencies such that either the input impedance Zin or admittance Yin is zero. In the former case, in fact, a non-zero
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
132
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
One port circuit
Figure 5.1
V
A generic one-port circuit.
current may flow in the network, although with zero input voltage (V ¼ ZinI ¼ 0); in the latter case, conversely, a non-zero voltage may be present at the input port without any current flow (I ¼ YinV ¼ 0). For a lossless network, such conditions therefore imply that the input reactance or susceptance, respectively, is zero: Xin ¼ 0
ð5:1aÞ
Bin ¼ 0
ð5:1bÞ
or
These are the resonant conditions for a lossless one-port network. In practice, since for a lossless circuit Xin ¼ 1=Bin the resonant frequencies correspond to the zeros and poles of the input reactance or susceptance. As illustrated below, the two conditions above correspond to series and parallel resonances, respectively. When losses are present in the circuit, the resonant conditions (5.1) still occur, but in this case, as we will see below, at resonance the resonant circuit exhibits a pure real input impedance or reactance. The resonant condition can be related to the EM energy stored in the circuit by making use of Poynting’s theorem (2.71). When applied to the volume V, the theorem can be put in the form Pin ¼ Pd þ 2joðWm We Þ
ð5:2Þ
where Pin is the complex power entering into the network, Pd is the real power dissipated by the Joule effect, Wm and We are the magnetic and electric energies, respectively, stored in V in a period T ¼ 2p/o. Expressing the input power in terms of voltage and current, Pin ¼ VI * =2, we obtain from (5.2) the energybased definitions of such quantities: Zin;par ¼
Pd þ 2joðWm We Þ II * =2
ð5:3Þ
Yin;ser ¼
Pd 2joðWm We Þ VV * =2
ð5:4Þ
The above expressions show that the input impedance and admittance are real when Wm ¼ We
ð5:5Þ
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
133
Equation (5.5) can be considered as the network resonant condition: when the average magnetic energy equals the average electric energy, the input impedance and admittance become real. If the network is lossless, thus Pd ¼ 0, the resonant condition implies zero input impedance or admittance, as stated above in (5.1). In such conditions, the network can sustain oscillations indefinitely without an external source. For this reason, the resonant condition can be seen as the condition such that the network, in the absence of loss, can oscillate freely. The resonant condition therefore corresponds to a free oscillation of the network. As already mentioned, when the input impedance (or, in the presence of losses, the reactance) is zero we will speak of series resonance, and when the input admittance (or the susceptance) is zero we will speak of a parallel resonance or anti-resonance. To illustrate this point, let us consider for example the parallel and series circuits of Figures 5.2a,b. The average magnetic energy stored in an inductor carrying the current IL and the average electric energy in a capacitor subject to the voltage VC are 1 Wm ¼ LjIL j2 4 1 We ¼ CjVC j2 4
ð5:6Þ
respectively. For the parallel circuit of Figure 5.2, both the magnetic and electric energies can be expressed in terms of the common voltage V: 1 1 jV j2 1 jV j2 ¼ Wm ¼ LjIL j2 ¼ L 2 4 4 ðoLÞ 4 o2 L 1 We ¼ C j V j 2 4
ð5:7Þ
Equating and solving for o, we obtain the resonant radian frequency 1 o0 ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffi LC
ð5:8Þ
In a dual fashion, for the series resonant circuit of Figure 5.2b we express the energies in terms of the common current I: 1 Wm ¼ LjI j2 4 1 1 jI j2 W e ¼ C j VC j 2 ¼ 4 4 o2 C
ð5:9Þ
Equating both terms, we obtain for the resonant frequency the same expression (5.8) as for the parallel resonant circuit.
Figure 5.2
Parallel (a) and series (b) resonant circuits.
134
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
5.3 Quality factor or Q In the lossless case, since the input impedance or admittance is zero, the resonator is able to sustain free oscillations at the resonant frequency (or frequencies). The unavoidable presence of dissipative elements in the circuit is such that the free oscillations are damped in time. The quality of a resonator is measured by a figure of merit called the quality factor or Q factor, or simply the Q of the resonator defined by the following general expression: Q¼
o0 W Pd
ð5:10Þ
where o0 is the radian resonant frequency, W ¼ Wm þ We is the total average energy stored in the resonator in one period T ¼ 2p/o0, and Pd is the average power dissipated in the resonator in one period. For the parallel and series circuits of Figure 5.2 we have Qpar ¼
2 o0 W o0 2We o0 2 14 CjV j o0 C ¼ ¼ 1 ¼ 2 Pd G Pd 2 GjV j
ð5:11Þ
Qser ¼
2 o0 W o0 2Wm o0 2 14 LjI j o0 L ¼ ¼ 1 ¼ 2 Pd Pd R R I j j 2
ð5:12Þ
An ideal resonator with no loss (G ¼ 0, or R ¼ 0) therefore has an infinite Q factor. In deriving (5.11)–(5.12) we have taken into account the equality of the electric and magnetic energies at resonance, so that W ¼ 2Wm ¼ 2We. Note that in both cases Q is the ratio of the imaginary and real parts of the admittance or impedance, respectively. This result can be generalized to the case of non-resonant oneport circuits. Let us now consider the behaviour of the input impedance of a parallel resonator in the proximity of the resonant frequency. In the lossless case (G ¼ 0) the input impedance goes to infinity producing an open circuit. In the general lossy case when G 6¼ 0, from inspection of Figure 5.2a we can write 1 1 1 1 o2 joC o2 Zin;par ¼ G þ joC þ ¼ G þ joC 1 02 ¼ R 1þ ð5:13Þ 1 02 joL G o o where R ¼ 1/G. At frequencies close to o0, we may put o ¼ o0 þ Do, with jDo=oj 1, so that in (5.13) the following approximation holds: o2 oDo 2 2Do ffi 1 02 ¼ 1 ð5:14Þ o o o neglecting the second power of Do=o. Using (5.11) and (5.14), then (5.13) becomes 2Do 1 Zin;par ffi R 1 þ jQ o0
ð5:15Þ
The magnitude of the impedance attains its maximum 1/G ¼ R at the resonant frequency. In much the same way it can be seen that at the resonant frequency the magnitude of the input admittance of the series resonator is maximum, 1/R ¼ G. Figure 5.3 shows the behaviour of the magnitude and the imaginary part of (5.15) as functions of Do/o0. The magnitude has a bell-shaped pffiffiffibehaviour. The 3.01 dB fractional bandwidth is the interval between the points where jZin j ¼ R= 2; from (5.15) it can be seen that such points occur when Q2Do=o0 ¼ 1. The fractional bandwidth is therefore B¼
2Do 1 ¼ o0 Q
ð5:16Þ
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
135
1 0.9 0.8 0.7
1/Q
Zin 0.6 R
0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1
(a)
–0.5 –0.4 –0.3 –0.2 –0.1
0
0.1
0.2 0.3
0.4
0.5
0.2 0.3
0.4
0.5
∆ω /ω0 80
Phase of Zin (deg)
60 40 20 0 –20 –40 –60 –80
(b)
–0.5 –0.4 –0.3 –0.2 –0.1
0
0.1
∆ω /ω0
Figure 5.3
Input impedance of a parallel resonator.
The quality factor can thus be evaluated as the reciprocal of the fractional bandwidth of the resonator. In a dual fashion we obtain the admittance of the series resonator in the proximity of the resonant frequency: 2Do 1 Yin;ser ffi G 1 þ jQ ð5:17Þ o0 while Equation (5.16) still holds. The quality factor is also related to the damping of the free oscillations of the circuit. Indeed, the amplitude of the field oscillations decreases in time as ext, x being the damping factor. The instantaneous energy stored in the circuit will thus decay as WðtÞ ¼ W0 ej2xt where W0 is the energy stored at t ¼ 0. Because of energy conservation, the rate of energy decrease in time dW=dt must be equal to the power loss: Pd ¼
dW ¼ 2xW0 ej2xt ¼ 2xWðtÞ dt
ð5:18Þ
The damping factor can therefore be expressed as x¼
Pd o0 ¼ 2W 2Q
ð5:19Þ
136
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
using (5.10).1 This equation shows that the higher the value of Q, the slower the damping of the oscillations. The lossy elements in the parallel and series resonators of Figure 5.2 can represent either the unwanted power loss Pd within the circuit or the power loss Pe due to an external load coupled to the resonator. In order to distinguish between the two effects, we define an external quality factor Qe due to the external load only and a loaded quality factor QL resulting from both types of loss. Based on the definition (5.10), we thus have QL ¼
o0 W 1 1 ¼ ¼ Pd þ Pe Pd =o0 W þ Pe =o0 W 1=Q þ 1=Qe
ð5:20Þ
where Qe ¼
o0 W Pe
Q¼
o0 W Pd
is the external Q and
is the resonator’s intrinsic or unloaded Q resulting only from the internal power loss. As an example, consider the parallel resonator and assume there is an external load represented by a resistance Re parallel to the internal resistance R ¼ 1/G. The loaded Q is o0 C 1 1 1 ¼ ð5:21Þ þ QL ¼ 1=R þ 1=Re Q Qe with Q ¼ o0 RC and Qe ¼ o0 Re C. In the most general case when various loss sources are present in the circuit (including, for example, radiation loss), each one absorbing a power Pdi (i ¼ 1, 2, . . ., N), the resulting loaded Q is given by !1 N X o0 W 1 1 ¼ N ð5:22Þ ¼ QL ¼ N X X Qi i¼1 Pdi Pdi =ðo0 WÞ i¼1
i¼1
where Qi is the Q associated with the ith loss source.
5.4 Transmission line resonators At radio and microwave frequencies electronic circuits are normally distributed and so are resonant circuits. The latter can be realized with transmission line sections like those shown in Figure 5.4. In contrast with lumped elements that resonate at a finite number of frequencies, distributed resonators have an infinite number of resonances as they are described by trigonometric, and thus periodic, rather than rational functions of frequency. Let us first consider the lossless case. As discussed in the previous sections, when no losses are present the resonant frequencies of the distributed circuits of Figure 5.4 are obtained when the input impedance or admittance is zero. Recalling the input impedance of a short-circuited stub (3.85a), we thus have for Figure 5.4a: Zin ¼ jZ0 tanðblÞ
ð5:23Þ
1 Strictly speaking, (5.10) refers to average values while (5.18) refers to instantaneous values. The equality (5.19) can be assumed to be valid provided that the damping factor is small with respect to the period T of the oscillations.
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
Z0, α, β
Z0, α, β Zin
Zin
(a)
Figure 5.4
137
(b)
Resonant circuits realized with a short- (a) or open-circuited (b) stub.
where b is the phase constant of the line and Z0 its characteristic impedance. Series resonances are obtained by setting Zin ¼ 0, which implies bl ¼ np
n ¼ 0; 1; 2 . . .
ð5:24Þ
Recalling the relation (3.75) between radian frequency, phase constant and phase velocity vph , the series resonant frequencies are npvph ð5:25Þ on ¼ l Similarly, there are infinite parallel resonances when Yin ¼ 0, thus Zin ¼ 1: bl ¼ ð2n þ 1Þp=2
n ¼ 0; 1; 2 . . .
ð5:26Þ
Thus at the radian frequencies on ¼
ð2n þ 1Þpvph l
ð5:27Þ
The resonant conditions can also be expressed in terms of line lengths. Recalling that b ¼ 2p=l, l being the wavelength, it can be immediately seen that series resonances occur when the stub length l is an integer multiple of l/2, while parallel resonances are obtained when l is an odd multiple of l/4. This is easily understood by recalling the properties of half- and quarter-wave line sections. When the line is half a wavelength long, the input impedance is the same as the load impedance, thus a short circuit is seen at the input. For the quarter-wavelength line, instead, the input impedance is the reciprocal of the load impedance, thus an open circuit is seen at the input. For the open stub of Figure 5.4b, we have a dual condition so that parallel resonances are obtained when the line is a multiple of half wavelengths, while series resonances occur when the length is an odd multiple of l/4. In fact the input impedance is Zin ¼ jZ0 cotðblÞ so that the condition (5.24) corresponds to parallel resonances while (5.26) corresponds to series resonances. Let us now consider a more realistic case, assuming a non-zero per-unit-length resistance R of the line conductor, while the dielectric loss can still be neglected so that G ¼ 0. From the complex propagation constant (3.89) of a low-loss transmission line, assuming G ¼ 0, we find rffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffi R C g ¼ a þ jb ¼ þ jo LC ð5:28Þ 2 L so that the attenuation is R a¼ 2
rffiffiffiffi C R ¼ L 2Z0
ð5:29Þ
138
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
while the phase constant b is the same as in the lossless case. Using the above results, the input impedance (5.23) of the short-circuited stub becomes2 Zin ¼ jZ0 tanhðglÞ ¼ Z0
tanh al þ jtan bl 1 þ jtanh al tan bl
ð5:30Þ
In the proximity of the series resonance, e.g. for bl ffi p, let us put b ¼ p=l þ Db o ¼ pvph =l þ Do
ð5:31Þ
with both Db=b 1 and Do=o 1. Under the assumption of low loss, al 1, thus tanhðalÞ ffi al. Moreover, by virtue of (5.31), tanðblÞ ¼ tanðp þ lDbÞ ¼ tanðlDbÞ ffi lDb so that (5.30) becomes Zin ffi Z0 ðal þ jlDbÞ
ð5:32Þ
In deriving (5.32) we have neglected in the denominator of Zin the product (al)(Dbl) with respect to unity. Using (5.29) and writing Db ¼ DðoL=Z0 Þ ¼ DoL=Z0 , the input impedance (5.32) of the lossy line resonator becomes Zin ¼
R l þ jlLDo 2
ð5:33Þ
By comparison, let us now consider the input impedance of a series R0L0C0 resonator in the proximity of the resonant frequency: 1 o2 Zin ¼ R0 þ joL0 þ ¼ R0 þ joL0 1 0 ffi R0 þ j2L0 Do ð5:34Þ joC0 o where we have used the approximation (5.14). Comparing (5.33) and (5.34), we conclude that the resonant line is equivalent to a series resonator having a resistance R0 ¼ Rl=2 and an inductance L0 ¼ Ll=2, so that the Q factor can be computed from that of its equivalent circuit: Q¼
o0 L0 o0 L 1 b ¼ ¼ R 2a R0
ð5:35Þ
The Q of a low-loss resonant line with negligible dielectric loss is therefore one-half the ratio of the phase and attenuation constants. Note that the line resonator behaves as if it has half overall resistance Rl and half overall inductance Ll. The factor 1/2 derives from the current having a sinusoidal behaviour along the line, so that its effective value is one-half of its maximum magnitude. In fact, the magnetic energy and the power loss associated with the current on the l/2 line, assuming sinusoidal behaviour, are given by ð 1 l=2 l Wm ¼ LjI0 j2 sin2 bz dz ¼ LjI0 j2 4 0 16 ð5:36Þ ð 1 l=2 l Pd ¼ RjI0 j2 sin2 bz dz ¼ RjI0 j2 2 0 8 I0 being the current amplitude. Using (5.10) with W ¼ 2Wm, we again find (5.35).
2
Remember that tanhða þ bÞ ¼
tanh a þ tanh b 1 þ tanh a tanh b
and tanhðjbÞ ¼ jtan b
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
139
Figure 5.5 Calculating the resonant frequencies of a shorted stub loaded with a capacitor at the input port.
EXAMPLE 5.1 We want to determine the resonances of a line section terminated with a capacitor C on one end and with a short circuit on the other. Compared with Figure 5.4a, we have a shunt capacitive load located at the input of the resonator. Seen from the junction of the line with the capacitor, the circuit looks like that in Figure 5.5b, where the admittances at the left and right of the junction are 1 joC Z2 ¼ jZ0 tanðblÞ
Z1 ¼
ð5:37Þ
The input impedance is Zin ¼ jZ0
tanbl 1oCZ0 tanbl
ð5:38Þ
The condition for series resonance Zin ¼ 0 is (5.24), the same as for the unloaded line. Indeed, the line resonates when it is a multiple of half a wavelength, so that the capacitor is short-circuited. Parallel resonances occur at the poles of Zin or zeros of Yin, thus when Y0 cotðblÞ ¼ oC
ð5:39Þ
Figure 5.6 shows the graphical solution (dots) of the above equation for two different values of C. Notice that in the limit for C ! 0 (open circuit) the solutions tend to (5.26) (quarter-wavelength line); conversely, if C ! 1 (short circuit) the solutions tend to (5.24) (half-wavelength line). Compared with the unloaded line, the capacitor, as we can see, has the effect of lowering the parallel resonant frequencies and is thus equivalent to an extension of the line. Such an extension, however, is not the same for all resonant modes. It is interesting to note that if the stub is open circuited, as the reader can easily verify, the resonant condition is (5.39), while the anti-resonances are obtained when Y0 cotðblÞ ¼ oC. The graphical solutions are shown with triangles in Figure 5.6.
5.5 Planar resonators Modern microwave and RF technology commonly employs printed circuits realized by depositing a metal film on a thin dielectric substrate metallized on the opposite side. Since the substrate’s thickness is normally very small (of the order of a fraction of a millimetre) with respect to the wavelength, the EM field can be considered to a first approximation to be constant along the direction normal to the substrate, so as to neglect the presence of a fringing field at the metal strip edges. This is equivalent to assuming that
140
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Y0cot(βl) = Y0cot(πω/2ω0)
ωC2
C1
Im(Y1),Im(Y2)
ωC1
0
π
2π
ω / ω0 –ωC1
–ωC2
Figure 5.6 Graphical solutions of Example 5.1: dots represent the solutions of (5.39), while triangles represent the anti-resonances when the capacitor is put at the end of the line. a magnetic conductor is placed at the periphery of the circuit. Actually, a bending of the electric field lines with respect to the direction normal to the substrate is produced at the metal edges so that the electric field partially goes through the air on top of the circuit, as sketched in Figure 5.7. As qualitatively illustrated in Figure 5.7b, the effect of the fringing field is taken into account by ascribing to the circuit an effective width we, suitably enlarged with respect to the physical strip width w, and assuming the electric field to be perpendicular to the substrate even at the metal edges. Moreover, as for the microstrip line, an effective dielectric constant is introduced to account for the electric field being present also in air. This is in essence the so-called planar waveguide model [10–12] that has been widely employed in the past for analyzing planar circuits, when the computing resources were not sufficiently developed to allow for more rigorous full wave analyses. In the case of linear microstrip resonators, typically obtained with an open l/2 line, the spreading of the field beyond each line ends produces an effect (the end effect) equivalent to a prolongation of the line or to terminating the line end with a capacitor (see Example 5.1). The latter accounts for the additional electric energy stored at the line end. Besides linear resonators using transmission line lengths, planar (i.e. two-dimensional) resonators, with various shapes such as polygons, circles, rings, etc., can also be realized with microstrip technology, as sketched in Figure 5.8. The resonator may be electrically connected or capacitively coupled to the external circuit. Note that the input port of a planar resonator can be placed at any location around its contour. Such a location affects the load presented by the resonator to the external circuit, but does not affect the resonant frequencies.
w
we
εr (a)
magnetic conductor
εeff (b)
Figure 5.7 The fringing field effect in a planar circuit can be taken into account through a suitable effective width and an effective permittivity.
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
Figure 5.8
141
Planar resonators.
Let us consider an arbitrarily shaped planar resonator realized in microstrip technology on a substrate of thickness h and relative permittivity er. Let us put the coordinate system with the z axis normal to the substrate. Based on the above considerations, we ascribe an effective permittivity ee f f to the substrate and effective dimensions to the planar circuit to account for fringing field effects at the resonator edges. The EM field is therefore assumed to be independent of z, thus @=@z ¼ 0. Since the boundary conditions at z ¼ 0 and z ¼ h require the tangential electric field to be zero on the conductor surface, the electric field is everywhere perpendicular to the substrate, and thus has only the z component Ez. For the same reason, the magnetic field has only the component Ht parallel to the substrate, or transverse to z. The EM field in the planar resonator is therefore a TM field with respect to the z direction. From expressions (3.18) for TM waves with kz ¼ 0 (independent of z), the Ez field is proportional to the transverse potential T(x, y): Ez ðx; yÞ ¼
k2 Tðx; yÞ ¼ jomTðx; yÞ joe
ð5:40Þ
while the magnetic field is given by Ht ðx; yÞ ¼ rt Tðx; yÞ ^z ¼
1 ^z rt Ez ðx; yÞ jom
ð5:41Þ
Because of (3.13), the electric field satisfies the two-dimensional Helmholtz’s equation r2t Ez ðx; yÞ þ k2 Ez ðx; yÞ ¼ 0
ð5:42Þ
@Ez ¼0 @n
ð5:43Þ
with the boundary condition
Equation (5.43) derives from the fact that the tangential magnetic field and the normal electric field must be zero on the perfect magnetic conductor at the boundary of the planar circuit. Equation (5.42) with (5.43) constitutes a homogeneous problem which has non-trivial (thus non-identically zero) solutions only for special values of k2 ¼ o2 me, thus of o2 . An example is the best way to illustrate this point. Suppose the planar resonator is a rectangle with sides a and b (effective dimensions). In rectangular coordinates Equation (5.42) can be solved by the method of separation of variables (Section 3.2) in much the same way as the rectangular waveguide, except the boundaries are now made of magnetic rather than electric conductor. Consequently, we obtain Ez ðx; yÞ ¼ XðxÞYðyÞ XðxÞ ¼ C1 sinðkx xÞ þ C2 cosðkx xÞ YðyÞ ¼ D1 sinðky yÞ þ D2 cosðky yÞ
ð5:44Þ
142
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
with kx2 þ ky2 ¼ k2 . Imposing the boundary condition (5.43) at the boundaries, i.e. for x ¼ 0, a and y ¼ 0, b, and expressing the magnetic field through (5.41), we obtain mp np x cos y Ez ðx; yÞz ¼ Ccos a b 1 @Ez C np mp np cos x sin y Hx ¼ ¼ jom @y jom b a b ð5:45Þ 1 @Ez C mp mp np Hy ¼ sin x sin y ¼ jom @x jom a a b mp2 np2 þ with m; n ¼ 0; 1; 2 . . . k2 ¼ a b From the last equation, being k2 ¼ o2 me, we derive the resonant frequencies of the planar rectangular resonator: fmn
c ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2p ee f f
ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi2 r mp2 np þ a b
m; n ¼ 0; 1; 2 . . .
ð5:46Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where c ¼ 1= m0 e0 is the velocity of light in a vacuum. Note that for m ¼ n ¼ 0 the electrostatic solution is obtained: the resonator behaves as a capacitor. The same procedure can be applied to other resonator shapes (e.g. circular, annular, etc.), in all cases obtaining a discrete infinite number of frequencies corresponding to the numbers of field swings along the coordinates. As mentioned in the above discussion, suitable effective dimensions are assumed for the resonator to account for the electric field lines extending outside the metallization of the planar circuit. At the same time, as for the microstrip, an effective dielectric constant has to be assumed. It must be stressed, however, that such effective parameters (dimensions and permittivity) generally depend on the field distribution along the circuit periphery, so that they vary from one resonant mode to another [11].
5.6 Cavity resonators In the general case, a microwave resonator consists of an arbitrarily shaped volume bounded by a metal surface (or possibly by a magnetic conductor) with one or more apertures for the coupling to the external world. This is the case of the so-called cavity resonators. The EM field may also be confined by a dielectric discontinuity: this is the case of dielectric resonators and is briefly mentioned in Section 5.8. Determining the resonant frequencies is, as always, a homogeneous problem: the resonant frequencies are those that allow non-trivial solutions of Maxwell’s equation in the cavity in the absence of electric or magnetic sources. The corresponding EM field distributions constitute the cavity’s resonant modes. In many practical cases, the resonator consists of a cylindrical cavity, like that sketched in Figure 5.9, resulting from a waveguide length bounded at both ends with metal planes. Compared with a generic 3-D shape, the problem of calculating the resonant frequencies is greatly simplified, since the analysis is reduced to that of the corresponding waveguide. Moreover, according to Section 3.3, the waveguide modes can be represented as simple transmission lines. Let us consider the generic cylindrical resonator of Figure 5.9. The two conducting planes at the ends require the transverse electric field (3.47) of any waveguide mode Et ðx; y; zÞ ¼ VðzÞet ðx; yÞ
ð5:47Þ
to vanish at z ¼ 0 and z ¼ d. Recalling that VðzÞ ¼ V þ ejkz z þ V e þ jkz z
ð5:48Þ
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
Figure 5.9
143
A cylindrical cavity obtained by short-circuiting a waveguide length at its ends.
we easily obtain qp z VðzÞ ¼ 2jV þ sin d qp with integer q kz ¼ d
ð5:49Þ
We can observe that the case q ¼ 0, thus kz ¼ 0, corresponds to the cut-off of the corresponding waveguide mode. Under such conditions the EM field is independent of z, thus Et ¼ 0 everywhere. If the mode is a TE mode, then Ez ¼ 0 and the electric field is everywhere zero. This is a trivial solution (also the magnetic field would be zero), thus the case q ¼ 0 must be discarded. If, on the contrary, the mode is a TM mode, the electric field Ez will be non-zero even in the case q ¼ 0, which has thus to be taken into consideration.3 From the second equation of (5.49), recalling the condition of separability (3.15) kt2 þ kz2 ¼ k2 ¼ o2 me
ð5:50Þ
we obtain the resonant frequencies fmnq
c ¼ pffiffiffiffi 2p er
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qp2ffi 2 kt;mn þ d
ð5:51Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where kt,mn is the eigenvalue of the mode TMmn or TEmn of the waveguide, c ¼ 1= m0 e0 is the velocity of light in a vacuum and er the dielectric constant of the dielectric filling the cavity. For a rectangular cavity the resonant modes are derived from the TM and TE modes of the corresponding waveguide and the resonant frequencies are therefore given by r ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi c m2 n2 q 2 ð5:52Þ þ þ fr;mnq ¼ pffiffiffiffi 2 er a b d
3 The reader can obtain such results using the expressions for V(z) in Table 3.3 for TM and TE modes. For V(z) identically zero, in the former case the current I(z) is constant, while in the second case the current is identically zero.
144
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
For a resonator with a circular cross-section of radius a, the resonant modes are derived from those of the corresponding circular waveguide; from (3.149) and (3.151) we have ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 8 r pnm 2 qp2 > > for TM modes þ > < d ffi a c ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi s fr;nmq ¼ pffiffiffiffi ð5:53Þ 0 2 2p er > p nm qp 2 > > þ for TE modes : a d The same procedure can be applied to cylindrical cavities of other shapes, the problem being reduced to that of determining the cut-off frequencies of the corresponding waveguides.
5.7 Computation of the Q factor of a cavity resonator As for waveguides, in a cavity resonator the EM power dissipates on the metal walls and in the filling dielectric. In this section we show how to compute the quality factor of a cylindrical cavity like that shown in Figure 5.9, by separately considering the two loss factors. Correspondingly, a quality factor Qd associated with the dielectric loss and a quality factor Qc associated with the conductor loss can be introduced. The overall Q factor of the cavity, according to (5.22), will be Qtot ¼ ð1=Qd þ 1=Qc Þ1
ð5:54Þ
Dielectric loss
The loss in the dielectric is represented by the imaginary part of the complex dielectric constant (see (2.47)) ec ¼ ejs=o ¼ e0 je00
ð5:55Þ
where s is the finite conductivity of the dielectric material. The power dissipated in the dielectric is, according to (2.69), ð ð 1 s E J* dV ¼ jEj2 dV ð5:56Þ Pd ¼ 2 V 2 V while the energy stored in the electric field is given by (2.67): ð e0 We ¼ jEj2 dV 4 V
ð5:57Þ
From the definition (5.10) of the Q factor, and recalling that at resonance the total energy stored is twice the electric energy, thus W ¼ 2We, we obtain Qd ¼
2o0 We o0 e0 e0 1 ¼ 00 ¼ ¼ Pd s e tan d
ð5:58Þ
Notice that Qd depends only on the dielectric, not on the resonant mode. It is interesting to note also that one arrives at the same result (5.58) by computing the damping factor due to the imaginary part of ec. In fact, since the l.h.s. is real, Equation (5.50) can be satisfied only for complex values of o. Replacing jo with s ¼ x þ jo and solving (5.50), we obtain the complex resonant frequency sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi s ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi s kt2 þ kz2 s 2 s kt2 þ kz2 ð5:59Þ s ¼ x þ jo0 ¼ 0 j 0 ffi 0j me0 me0 2e 2e 2e The damping factor is therefore x ¼ s=2e0 . Using Equation (5.19) we obtain again (5.58).
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
145
Conductor loss
The computation of the loss due to the finite conductivity of the metal walls can be carried out using the same procedure as for the waveguides (Section 3.7); that is, by expressing the tangential electric field on the metal through the Leontovic condition (2.184). For the power dissipated in the metal, similar to (3.112) and (3.113) we thus obtain rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiþ þ 1 om Rc Pd ¼ Ht H*t dS ¼ Js J*s dS ð5:60Þ 2 Sc 2 2s Sc
where Ht is the tangential magnetic field on the metal surface Sc and rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi om Rc ¼ ReðZc Þ ¼ 2s is the surface resistance of the conductor. The metal surface Sc is composed of the lateral wall and the end sections, so that the Q factor can be expressed as ð ð ð * 2o0 m 14 H H* dV H H dV H H* dV pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi V 2 V V Qc ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiþ ¼ 2o0 ms þ ¼ þ ð5:61Þ ds o0 m * * * 1 H H dS H H dS H H dS t t t t t t 2 2s Sc
Sc
Sc
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi The quantity ds ¼ o0 ms=2 is the skin depth (2.175) in the metal at the resonant frequency. In an equivalent manner, expressing the Q in terms of electric rather than magnetic energy, instead of (5.61) we obtain ð E E* dV 2e0 V þ Qc ¼ ds m Ht H*t dS
ð5:62Þ
Sc
The above expressions for Q must be evaluated depending on the resonant mode of the resonator. In the case of a rectangular resonator with sides a, b, d, if d > a > b the first resonant mode is the TE101 mode, which corresponds to the first resonance of the dominant mode TE10 of the rectangular waveguide of sides a, b. Using (5.52), its resonant frequency is ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi r c p2 p2 þ fr;101 ¼ pffiffiffiffi ð5:63Þ 2p er a d The expressions for the EM field of the TE101 resonant mode are obtained from those of the TE10 mode of the rectangular waveguide (Table 3.4) by adding to the incident wave (kz ¼ kz10 ¼ p/d) a reflected wave (kz ¼ kz10 ¼ p/d) of the same amplitude and opposite phase, so that the Ey field is zero in z ¼ 0, d. We therefore obtain the three components of the EM field of the mode: oma px oma px pz Ey ¼ j Csin ðejkz;10 z ejkz;10 z Þ ¼ sin sin p a p a d a px a px pz Hx ¼ j Csin ðkz;10 ejkz;10 z þ kz;10 ejkz;10 z Þ ¼ j sin cos ð5:64Þ p a d a d px px pz Hz ¼ Ccos ðejkz;10 z ejkz;10 z Þ ¼ jcos sin a a d In order to simplify the expressions, we have put C ¼ 1/2 in the last terms of (5.64). The computation of the Q can be more easily done using (5.62). The stored electric energy is ð ð ðb ðd 2 e0 m2 a3 bd e0 o2 e0 m2 a2 a 2 px o2 e0 m2 a3 bd fr;101 2 pz We ¼ Ey2 dx dy dz ¼ sin dy sin ¼ dx dz ¼ 2 4 V 4p2 a d 8p2 0 0 0 ð5:65Þ
146
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The power loss is computed by integrating (5.60) over the six cavity walls: ð Rc Pd ¼ jHt j2 dS 2 Sc ðb ðd ð ð Rc a Rc a dx ðHx2 ðx; y; 0Þ þ Hx2 ðx; y; dÞÞ dy þ dx ð2Hx2 ðx; 0; zÞ þ 2Hz2 ðx; 0; zÞÞ dz ¼ 2 0 2 0 0 ð 0 ðd Rc b Rc 2 2 dy ðHz ð0; y; zÞ þ Hz ða; y; zÞÞ dz ¼ . . . ¼ 2 ð2a3 b þ a3 d þ ad 3 þ 2d 3 bÞ þ 2 0 4d 0 ð5:66Þ Finally, we obtain o3 m2 e0 a3 bd 3 4pb fr;101 ad 3 Zd ¼ c 2p2 Rc ð2a3 b þ a3 d þ ad 3 þ 2d 3 bÞ ð2a3 b þ a3 d þ ad 3 þ 2d 3 bÞ Rc pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffiffiffiffiffiffi p where Zd ¼ m=e0 is the intrinsic impedance of the dielectric and c ¼ 1= me0 . Qc ¼
ð5:67Þ
5.8 Dielectric resonators As in the case of waveguides, the metal walls in cavity resonators are used to confine the EM field within the cavity. At the same time, however, because of the finite conductivity, the current flowing in the metal produces a power loss that reduces the Q factor of the resonator. Metal loss can be avoided using resonators made of high-permittivity dielectrics. Typical values are of the order of 30–40 or higher. The strong discontinuity between the resonator and the outside space (usually air) has the effect of confining the EM field within the dielectric. The phenomenon is analogous to the total reflection discussed in Section 2.10.1. Of course, as for that case, the EM field is not zero outside the dielectric resonator, but decays exponentially from its surface. As a consequence, the resonator can be coupled to a closely spaced external circuit element, such as a microstrip or another dielectric resonator. Dielectric resonators are usually, though not necessarily, disc shaped. The dominant resonant mode is designated as TE01d (see below). Because of the high permittivity, the dimensions of a dielectric resonator are considerably smaller than those of an empty cavity resonator for the same resonant frequency. The Q factor is usually of the order of 5000–10 000. Computation of the resonant frequencies of a dielectric resonator is a rather difficult procedure. In a first approximation, if the dielectric constant is very high, the air–dielectric boundary can be modelled as a perfect magnetic conductor.4 Although not extremely accurate, this model can be used to compute the resonant modes of the dielectric resonator, in much the same way as for the cavity resonators of Section 5.6, except that the boundaries are now made of a perfect magnetic conductor rather than a perfect electric conductor. For a thin dielectric disc, the lowest mode is a TE010 mode. The three indexes correspond to the cylindrical coordinates j, r, z and indicate a constant field with respect to the azimuth (j), one half-wave variation in the radial direction (r) and constant field along the thickness (z). In practice, since the field is not fully confined within the dielectric, along the disc thickness the field varies
4
The reflection coefficient of a plane wave incident from the dielectric to the air is pffiffiffiffi er 1 Z Z ¼ pffiffiffiffi G¼ 0 er þ 1 Z0 þ Z
This value approaches unity (as for an open circuit) when er becomes very large.
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
Figure 5.10
147
Microstrip line coupled to a dielectric resonator.
but by less than one half wave. As a consequence this mode is designated as TE01d, where d < 1. More details can be found in [5–7]. Figure 5.10a shows the layout of a dielectric resonator coupled to a microstrip. The coupling mainly occurs through the magnetic field of the TE01d mode and is such that the signal travelling along the line is reflected back at the disc resonances. From a circuit point of view, each resonance is seen as an RLC resonant circuit inductively coupled to the line. This is equivalent to putting a parallel resonant circuit in series with the line, as shown in Figure 5.10b. Figure 5.11 shows the measured and simulated frequency responses of the circuit compared with that of the isolated microstrip. As can be observed, the RF signal is transmitted through the line with small attenuation but at the disc resonances.
5.9 Expansion of EM fields In the previous sections we saw that lossless cavity resonators, fully enclosed by perfect electric conductors, possess an infinite number of resonant modes, each corresponding to a homogeneous solution of Maxwell’s equations. In practice, the cavity is not isolated but must be connected to the external world in order to exchange energy with it. The connection often occurs through apertures produced in the cavity walls, so that the boundary conditions are modified with respect to the isolated cavity. As a consequence, the EM field distribution in a cavity with openings results from the superposition of several resonant modes, the boundary conditions on the openings being satisfied by the collective contribution of all the modes. The theory of resonant modes is a powerful and very general approach to the expansion of the EM field in an arbitrary region of space. This theory is succinctly described here, the various proofs being omitted for brevity and simplicity. The reader is referred to [2, 8, 9] for a complete and exhaustive treatment.
148
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 0.0
–0.2
20 log10(Is21I)
–0.4 measure model –0.6
line
–0.8
–1.0
–1.2 2.0
2.2
2.4
2.6
2.8
3.0
Frequency, GHz
Figure 5.11
5.9.1
Responses of the circuit of Figure 5.10.
Helmholtz’s theorem
Let us first introduce a fundamental theorem of field theory, namely Helmholtz’s theorem [8]. The theorem states that any vector A(x, y, z) defined in a space region V bounded by the surface S can be expressed as the sum of an irrotational term plus a solenoidal term according to the following formula: ð þ ^ 0 r0 Aðr0 Þ 0 Aðr0 Þ n AðrÞ ¼ r dV þ dS 4pR 4pR V S ð þ ^ 0 r0 Aðr0 Þ 0 Aðr0 Þ n dV þ dS þr 4pR 4pR V S
ð5:68Þ
where R ¼ jrr0 j is the distance between the observation point and the integration point. Equation (5.68) shows that the vector originates from volume sources r A and r A and ^ and A n ^ . The vector A is irrotational, and thus can be sources located on the boundary S, i.e. A n ^ ¼ 0 on S; derived from the gradient of a scalar potential, if and only if r A ¼ 0 in V and A n conversely, A is solenoidal, and thus can be derived from the curl of a vector potential, if and only ^ ¼ 0 on S. if r A ¼ 0 in V and A n
5.9.2
Electric and magnetic eigenvectors
In order to create a base of solutions that can be used to expand any EM field inside the volume V, we need to specify suitable sets of boundary conditions, in such a way that the modal base is unique and complete. The term complete means that any vector function which is square integrable and piecewise continuous in V can be expressed as a combination of the modes. Even if not explicitly
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
149
stated, we will implicitly consider only square-integrable piecewise-continuous functions. Complete modal bases can be obtained from the solutions of eigenvalue problems that, depending on the boundary conditions, are of the electric or magnetic type. Electrical eigenvectors are solutions of5 r2 E þ k2 E ¼ 0 rE ¼ 0 ^E¼0 n
ð5:69aÞ
in V
on S
ð5:69bÞ
Magnetic eigenvectors are solutions of r2 H þ k2 H ¼ 0
in V
ð5:70aÞ
^rH¼0 n ^H ¼ 0 n
on S
ð5:70bÞ
It is worth specifying that, although we have used the same symbols for the electric and magnetic fields which are solutions to Maxwell’s equations, the above quantities are not the electric and magnetic fields, but should be regarded as merely mathematical quantities. Similarly, k2 is not the wavenumber but simply denotes the generic eigenvalue of (5.69) or (5.70). The two problems differ in the boundary conditions, which are of the electric or magnetic type respectively. However, both lead to solutions having the following properties: 1. There is a countable infinity of real non-negative eigenvalues and real eigenvectors. 2. Eigenvectors are orthogonal and can be normalized in such a way that ð Am An ¼ dmn V
ð5:71Þ
where Am ; An are two independent eigenvectors. Each set of solutions consists of three different groups: I. Solenoidal electric eigenvectors: r Em 6¼ 0; r Em ¼ 0. As a consequence, (5.69) becomes 2 E¼0 r r Em km
in V
ð5:72aÞ
^ Em ¼ 0 n
on S
ð5:72bÞ
6 0. These are obtained from II. Irrotational electric eigenvectors: r f m ¼ 0; r f m ¼ scalar potentials f m ¼ rvm =lm , where the potential is obtained by solving the scalar eigenvalue equation
5
r2 vm þ l2m vm ¼ 0
in V
ð5:73aÞ
vm ¼ 0
on S
ð5:73bÞ
Recall that r2 A ¼ r r A þ rr A.
150
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING III. Harmonic electric eigenvectors: r E0 ¼ 0; r E0 ¼ 0. Such eigenvectors correspond to the zero eigenvalue of (5.69), if it exists. They are non-trivial solutions of r2 E0 ¼ 0 r E0 ¼ 0 ^ E0 ¼ 0 n
ð5:74aÞ
in V on S
ð5:74bÞ
Such eigenvectors satisfy the same equation and boundary conditions as the electrostatic field. Non-trivial solutions can exist only if the volume is multiply connected, so that the boundary S is made of different parts. There will be as many independent solutions as the number of parts minus one. Let the boundary consist of P portions; then, there will be P 1 independent harmonic eigenvectors E01 ; E02 ;. . . ; E0P1 . Due to the completeness of the above base, any piecewise-continuous vector A in V can be expanded as follows: A¼
1 X
am Em þ
m¼1
1 X
bm f m þ
m¼1
P1 X m¼1
cm E0m
ð5:75Þ
where the expansion coefficients are Ð am ¼ V Em A dV Ð bm ¼ V f m A dV Ð cm ¼ V E0m A dV
ð5:76Þ
The last term in (5.75) using harmonic eigenvectors is present only if the volume is multiply connected. If A is solenoidal it is easily seen that6 ð A f m dV ¼ 0 ð5:77Þ V
In much the same way, we obtain a complete base of magnetic eigenvectors that can be divided into three groups: I. Solenoidal magnetic eigenvectors: r Hm 6¼ 0; r Hm ¼ 0. As a consequence, (5.70) become 2 r r Hm km Hm ¼ 0
^ r Hm ¼ 0 n
on S
in V
ð5:78aÞ ð5:78bÞ
In fact, taking into account the properties of the irrotational eigenvectors II and that, since r A ¼ 0, A rvm ¼ r ðAvm Þ, one obtains ð ð þ ð rvm 1 1 ^vm dS ¼ 0 A f m dV ¼ A dV ¼ r ðAvm Þ dV ¼ An lm lm lm S 6
V
V
V
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
151
II. Irrotational magnetic eigenvectors: r gm ¼ 0; r gm 6¼ 0. These are obtained from scalar potentials, gm ¼ rwm =lm , where the potential wm is obtained by solving the scalar eigenvalue equation r2 wm þ l2m wm ¼ 0 @wm ¼0 @n
in V
ð5:79aÞ ð5:79bÞ
on S
III. Harmonic magnetic eigenvectors: r H0 ¼ 0; r H0 ¼ 0. Such eigenvectors correspond to the zero eigenvalue of (5.71), if it exists. They are non-trivial solutions of r2 H0 ¼ 0 ^ r H0 ¼ 0 n ^ H0 ¼ 0 n
ð5:80aÞ
in V on S
ð5:80bÞ
Such eigenvectors satisfy the same equation and boundary conditions as the magnetostatic field. Non-trivial solutions can exist only if the volume is multiply connected, like a torus. There will be as many independent solutions as the number of parts minus one. Let the boundary consist of P portions; then, there will be P 1 independent harmonic eigenvectors H01 ; H02 ; . . . ; H0P1 . An alternative expansion of a piecewise-continuous vector A in V is therefore the following one, based on the use of the magnetic eigenvectors: A¼
1 X
Am Hm þ
m¼1
1 X m¼1
Bm gm þ
P1 X m¼1
Cm H0m
ð5:81Þ
The expansion coefficients are given by Am ¼ Bm ¼ Cm ¼
Ð ÐV Ð
Hm A dV
V gm A dV 0 V Hm A dV
ð5:82Þ
The last term using harmonic eigenvectors is present only if the volume is multiply connected. If A is solenoidal and tangential to the boundary, it is easily seen that7 ð gm A dV ¼ 0 ð5:83Þ V
The solenoidal eigenvectors of electric and magnetic type are not independent of each other. Indeed, they are related by r Hm ¼ km Em r Em ¼ km Hm
ð5:84Þ
Therefore, every solenoidal electric eigenvector has a corresponding solenoidal magnetic eigenvector and vice versa.
7
The proof is just the same as for (5.77). See footnote 6.
152
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING EXAMPLE 5.2 Compute the electric and magnetic eigenvectors of a lossless rectangular cavity of size a b c. Let us start with the solenoidal electric eigenvectors of (5.72). Notice that (5.72a) is 2 equivalent to solving r2 Em km Em ¼ 0 with the additional condition that r Em ¼ 0. Using the method of separation of variables we obtain mpx npy ppz sin sin a b c mpx npy ppz ¼ Cy;mnp sin cos sin a b c mpx npy ppz ¼ Cz;mnp sin sin cos a b c
Ex;mnp ¼ Cx;mnp cos Ey;mnp Ez;mnp
ð5:85Þ
where the index m has been replaced by the triplet mnp. The corresponding eigenvalues are rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi mp2 np2 pp2 ð5:86Þ þ þ kmnp ¼ a b c In a similar manner, the solution of (5.78) is found to be mpx npy ppz cos cos a b c mpx npy ppz ¼ Dy;mnp cos sin cos a b c mpx npy ppz ¼ Dz;mnp cos cos sin a b c
Hx;mnp ¼ Dx;mnp sin Hy;mnp Hz;mnp
ð5:87Þ
It should be remembered that the class of solutions of (5.85) is related to (5.87) through (5.84), so that the coefficients Cx,mnp determine Dx,mnp and vice versa. Moreover, Cx, mnp must be such as to comply with the condition r Em ¼ 0 and the normalization condition (5.71). The same conditions must be applied to Dx,mnp. Such conditions, however, do not completely determine the three constants – indeed we have one degree of freedom left in the choice of the coefficients. In much the same way as with the resonant modes discussed in Section 5.6, we may further distinguish the solutions in TE and TM eigenvectors, the former being obtained by putting Cz,mnp ¼ 0 in (5.85), the latter by putting Dz,mnp ¼ 0 in (5.87). In this way we obtain the expressions quoted in Table 5.1. Concerning the irrotational eigenvectors, we first need to solve (5.73) and (5.79). The solutions are readily found using the separation of variables method: mpx npy ppz sin sin a b c mpx npy ppz wm ¼ Dmnp cos cos cos a b c vmnp ¼ Cmnp sin
with the same eigenvalues as (5.86): r ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi mp2 np2 pp2 þ þ lmnp ¼ a b c
ð5:88Þ ð5:89Þ
ð5:90Þ
By taking rvmnp and rwmnp we obtain the same expressions as (5.85) and (5.87), replacing Es and Hs with fs and gs, respectively, and with the expressions for the C and D coefficients quoted in Table 5.1.
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
153
Table 5.1 Eigenvectors of a rectangular cavity. The electric field components vary according to (5.85), while the magnetic field components vary according to (5.87).
TE eigenvectors
TM eigenvectors
where
Solenoidal electric eigenvectors rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 2dm dn np Cx;mnp ¼ kmn abc b rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 2dm dn mp Cy;mnp ¼ kmn abc a Cz;mnp ¼ 0 rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dp mpp2 abc ac rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dp npp2 2 Cy;mnp ¼ kmn kmnp abc bc rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dp kmn Cz;mnp ¼ kmnp abc rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi mp2 np2 þ kmn ¼ a b 2 Cx;mnp ¼ kmn kmnp
Irrotational electric eigenvectors rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 8 mp kmnp abc a rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 8 np Cy;mnp ¼ kmnp abc b rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 8 pp Cz;mnp ¼ kmnp abc c 1 for m ¼ 0 dm ¼ 2 for m 6¼ 0 Cx;mnp ¼
5.9.3
1
Solenoidal magnetic eigenvectors rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 2dm dn mpp2 Dx;mnp ¼ kmn kmnp abc ac rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 2dm dn npp2 Dy;mnp ¼ abc bc kmn kmnp rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi kmn 2dm dn Dz;mnp ¼ kmnp abc rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dp np 2 Dx;mnp ¼ kmn abc b rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dp mp 2 Dy;mnp ¼ kmn abc a Dz;mnp ¼ 0
kmnq
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi mp2 np2 pp2 ¼ þ þ a b c
Irrotational magnetic eigenvectors rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dm dn dp mp kmnp abc a rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 8 np ¼ kmnp abc b rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 8 pp ¼ kmnp abc c
Dx;mnp ¼ Dy;mnp Dz;mnp
1
General solution of Maxwell’s equations in a cavity
We are now in a position to solve Maxwell’s equations in a cavity bounded by metal walls by using the field expansions developed in the previous section. It seems reasonable to use the electric and magnetic eigenvectors for expanding the electric and magnetic fields, respectively, since they satisfy the same type of boundary conditions at the metal surface. In this way we expect that the convergence of the respective expansions will be much faster. We are not going into details of the derivation, but simply report the final results. Consider first a cavity V fully enclosed by perfect conducting walls except for the presence of some apertures, where the tangential electric field is non-zero. Suppose also that an electric current density distribution J and a magnetic current distribution JM are present in the cavity. Maxwell’s equations are r H ¼ joeE þ J r E ¼ jomHJM
ð5:91Þ
154
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Expanding E and r H with the electric eigenvectors expansions (5.75) and H and r E in terms of the magnetic eigenvectors expansion (5.81), we obtain E¼
1 X
am Em þ
i¼1
H¼
1 X
bm f m þ
m¼1
Am Hm þ
m¼1
with
1 X
1 X m¼1
P1 X m¼1
Bm gm þ
P1 X m¼1
cm E0m
ð5:92Þ
Cm H0m
ð5:93Þ
þ ð ð 1 k n E H dS þ k H J dV þ jom E J dV m m m m M m 2 k2 km S V V ð 1 bm ¼ f m J dV joe V ð 1 E0 J dV cm ¼ joe V m þ ð ð 1 Am ¼ 2 2 joe n E Hm dS þ joe Hm JM dVkm Em J dV k km S V V ð þ 1 Bm ¼ gm JM dV þ gm n E dS jom V S ð þ 1 H0m JM dV þ H0m n E dS Cm ¼ jom V S
am ¼
ð5:94aÞ ð5:94bÞ ð5:94cÞ ð5:95aÞ ð5:95bÞ ð5:95cÞ
pffiffiffiffiffi where k ¼ o me. Notice that the surface integrals in the above expressions are zero over those portions of S where there is a perfect conductor (thus n E ¼ 0). These expressions for the expansion coefficients show that the EM field is created by the electric and magnetic current densities Ji and Jm, and by the presence of a non-zero tangential electric field on the boundary, i.e. on the apertures where the cavity is connected to the external circuits. The general expressions above can be greatly simplified in most practical cases, as illustrated in the following examples.
5.9.4
Resonances in ideal closed cavities
Consider an ideal simply connected cavity (thus E0 ¼ 0), fully enclosed by a perfect electric conductor (thus n E ¼ 0), the only source being electric currents (JM ¼ 0). Under such hypotheses, the general expansions (5.92)–(5.93) reduce to E¼
1 X
bm f m þ
m¼1
H¼
1 X
am Em
ð5:96Þ
m¼1 1 X
Am Hm
ð5:97Þ
m¼1
where
ð 1 f m J dV joe V ð jom am ¼ 2 2 Em J dV k km V km am Am ¼ jom bm ¼
ð5:98Þ
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
155
The general EM field in the cavity results from the contribution of infinite terms (resonant modes); the ith term becomes infinitely large as the frequency approaches km om ¼ pffiffiffiffiffi me
ð5:99Þ
which represents the resonant frequency of the mth mode. The first term in (5.96) ‘resonates’ at zero frequency, and therefore represents an electrostatic field.
5.9.5
The cavity with one or two outputs
Consider now an ideal simply connected cavity (thus E0 ¼ 0), with no sources inside, fully enclosed by a perfect electric conductor (thus n E ¼ 0) except for two apertures connected to two waveguides. The case of one single output can be derived very easily by simply short-circuiting the second aperture. As sketched in Figure 5.12, we can extend the boundary of the volume so as to include part of the waveguides, in such a way that on the surfaces S1 and S2 we can assume that the EM field is that of the dominant modes of the waveguides.8 This assumption is not strictly necessary but simplifies the analytical treatment by simply neglecting higher order modes on the waveguides. The integrals over the boundary surface S of the cavity reduce to the only portions S1 and S2 where the tangential electric field is not zero. Under the above hypotheses, the general expansions (5.92)–(5.95) reduce to E¼
1 X
am Em
ð5:100Þ
m¼1
H¼
1 X m¼1
with
Bm gm þ
1 X
Am Hm
ð5:101Þ
m¼1
ð km ^ E Hm dS n 2 k2 km S þS ð 1 2 1 ^ E gm dS Bm ¼ n jom S1 þ S2 joe am Am ¼ km am ¼
ð5:102Þ
The tangential electric field on Si (i ¼ 1, 2) in (5.102) can be expressed in terms of the ith waveguide modes. Under the assumption that only the fundamental mode is present on the cross-section Si, we can simply write9 ðiÞ
Et ¼ Vi ei ðiÞ
Ht ¼ Ii hi ¼ Ii ð^ n i Þ ei
ð5:103Þ
where ð^ ni Þ is the unit vector in the direction of the ith waveguide axis, as shown in Figure 5.12, and ei and hi are the electric and magnetic field vectors corresponding to the dominant mode of the waveguide, and Vi and Ii the corresponding equivalent voltage and current. Using the first equation 8 If the reference planes are taken on the waveguide wall where higher order waveguide modes are present, the procedure is more complicated, as it yields an N N matrix representation of the cavity, N being the total number of waveguide modes taken into consideration. Correspondingly one obtains the so-called generalized scattering matrix (GSM), generalized admittance matrix (GAM), and so on. 9 In the most general case, the EM field can be expressed, rather than in terms of only the dominant mode, as a summation over all the waveguide modes. For details, see [9].
156
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 5.12 of (5.103) we obtain
ð S1 þ S2
where we have put
^ E Hm dS ¼ V1 x1m þ V2 x2m n
ð xim ¼
Similarly,
A cavity with two outputs.
ð5:104Þ
ð Si
^ ei Hm dS ¼ n
Si
hi Hm dS
ð5:105Þ
ð S1 þ S2
with
^ E gm dS ¼ V1 B1m þ V2 B2m n
ð Bim ¼
ð5:106Þ
ð Si
^ ei gm dS ¼ n
Si
hi gm dS
ð5:107Þ
The coefficients Ii of the magnetic field over the ith waveguide cross-section can be expressed in terms of the magnetic field itself: ð ð ni Þ ei dS ð5:108Þ Ii ¼ H hi dS ¼ H ð^ Si
Si
Substituting (5.101) into (5.108) and using (5.104)–(5.107), we finally obtain the relationship between the equivalent currents and voltages at the cavity outputs in the form of a 2 2 admittance matrix ½I ¼ ½Y½V ð5:109Þ the matrix elements being expressed as Yij ¼
1 1 X xim xjm 1 X Bim Bjm joe 2 k2 k jom m¼1 m m¼1
ð5:110Þ
The admittance matrix is expressed in the form of a partial fraction expansion, where each term corresponds to a resonant mode (including the static term resonating at DC). Although only one index m has been employed, in practice (5.110) involves a triple summation over three indexes corresponding to the three coordinates. The convergence of such an expansion is rather slow, so alternative expressions should be adopted for practical computations (see [9]).
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
157
The case of a cavity with one input is obtained in a straightforward manner by simply shortcircuiting one opening. The cavity can then be represented as a two-terminal circuit, whose admittance is given by Y11 (or Y22) of (5.110). By some straightforward algebra we find that the input admittance of the cavity is Ycavity ¼
1 X 1 joCm þ joL0 m¼1 1ðo=om Þ2
ð5:111Þ
where m L0 ¼ X ; 1 B2m
Cm ¼ e
x2m 2 km
ð5:112Þ
m¼1
km om ¼ pffiffiffiffiffi me In (5.112) we have simply written zm and xm , instead of z1m and x1m . The above formulae show that the cavity behaves as the parallel connection of the inductor L0 to an infinite number of series resonant LC cells representing the modes of the cavity, as shown in Figure 5.13a. In a dual fashion we can analyze a cavity enclosed by a perfect magnetic conductor. This can be considered as an approximation of dielectric resonators or planar microstrip resonators [10]. In this case, the inherent representation is that of the impedance rather than the admittance matrix. The dual series expansion of (5.111) leads to the equivalent circuit of Figure 5.13b, consisting of a capacitor C0 in series with infinite parallel resonant LC cells representing the mode of the cavity.
5.9.6
Excitation of cavity resonators
As an alternative to apertures in the cavity walls, resonators can be excited by electric or magnetic probes consisting of a small linear current or loop. In both cases the current filament can represent
L0
L1
L2
C1
C2 (a)
C1
C2
L1
L2
C0
(b)
Figure 5.13 Equivalent circuits of a cavity with one aperture: (a) cavity with perfect electric conductor walls; (b) cavity with perfect magnetic conductor walls.
158
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
h (a)
S
Figure 5.14
(b)
Excitation of a cavity with an electric (a) or a magnetic probe (loop) (b).
the inner conductor of a coaxial cable connected to the resonator. Consider first a short linear current I0 impressed along a short segment located near the inner wall of an ideal cavity, as sketched in Figure 5.14a. The cavity is assumed to be lossless and simply connected. Let I be the current flowing in the short filament with cross-section S and length h. If S is very small, we can assume the current density to be constant in the volume v ¼ hS:10 J ¼ J0^t
ð5:113Þ
in v
where J0 ¼ I=S; ^t is the unit vector in the direction of the current. Inserting (5.113) into (5.98), we obtain ð 1 1 bm ¼ f m J dv ¼ hI fmt joe v joe ð jom jom am ¼ 2 2 Em J dv ¼ 2 2 hIEmt k km v k km km Am ¼ am jom
ð5:114Þ
where fmt ¼ Emt ¼
10
1 Sh 1 Sh
ð ð
1 f m ^t dv ffi h v v
Em ^t dv ffi
ðh
1 h
0 ðh
f m ^t dl ð5:115Þ Em ^t dl
0
The volume is indicated here by a small v to avoid confusion with the voltage V.
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
159
where we have assumed fm and Em to be constant in the cross-section S.11 Using (5.96) and (5.114), the voltage across the probe is found to be ! ðh 1 1 X X ^ bm fmt þ am Emt V ¼ E t dl ¼ h 0 m¼1 m¼1 ! ð5:116Þ 1 1 X 1 X 1 2 2 2 f jom E ¼h I 2 mt joe m¼1 mt k2 km m¼1 The resulting impedance is therefore Zin ¼
1 X 1 Lm þ jo 2 joC0 1ðo=o mÞ m¼1
ð5:117Þ
with C0 ¼
2 fmt m¼1 mh2 2 Emt 2 km
h2 Lm ¼
e 1 X
ð5:118Þ
Equation (5.117) represents the series of the capacitor C0 with infinite parallel resonators, as in Figure 5.13b. Consider now the excitation of the cavity through a small current loop of area S, as in Figure 5.14b. In this case the volume integrals appearing in (5.114) can be transformed as follows: ð þ ð ð Em J dV ¼ I Em dl ¼ I r Em dS ¼ Ikm Hm dS ð5:119Þ V
S
S
where I ¼ SJ is the current flowing in the loop. In deriving the above equation we have used Stokes’ theorem and (5.84). Putting ð 1 Hm dS ð5:120Þ Hmn ¼ S S from (5.114) we obtain ð jom jom Em J dV ¼ 2 2 ISkm Hmn 2 k2 km k km V km Am ¼ 2 2 ISkm Hmn k km
am ¼
ð5:121Þ
With the same procedure, we find that bm ¼ 0 since r f m ¼ 0. From (5.93) we can determine the magnetic field in the cavity: H¼
1 X m¼1
Am Hm ¼ IS
1 X
2 km 2 2 k km m¼1
Hmn Hm ðrÞ
ð5:122Þ
11 Notice that such an approximation is valid as long as S is very small compared with the spatial variation of fm and Em, thus for modes up to a certain order m. For very large orders, however, the contribution of the modes tends to become negligible.
160
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 5.15
Equivalent circuit of the loop-coupled cavity of Figure 5.12b.
The voltage induced by the magnetic field flux through the loop is þ ð ð 1 1 X X V ¼ E dl ¼ jom H dS ¼ jom Am Hm dS ¼ jomIS2 m¼1
S
2 km 2 2 k km m¼1
S
2 Hmn
ð5:123Þ
so we obtain the expression for the input impedance: Zin ¼ jomS2
1 X
2 Hmn
m¼1 1ðo=om Þ
2
¼
1 X
joLm
m¼1 1ðo=om Þ
2
ð5:124Þ
with 2 Lm ¼ mS2 Hmn
ð5:125Þ
The equivalent circuit therefore consists of a series of an infinite number of anti-resonant circuits, as shown in Figure 5.15. An alternative simpler approach12 is based on the use of the energy definition (5.4) of the input admittance Yin ¼
2joðWm We Þ 4joðWm We Þ ¼ VV * =2 ðomSHn Þ2
ð5:126Þ
where Hn is the magnetic field in the loop, orthogonal to its plane. The above expression can be specialized to each specific resonant mode of the cavity as long as the frequency is close to its resonant frequency. For example, suppose the loop is located at half the height of the side wall of a circular cylindrical cavity. If the loop is orthogonal to the f direction, it will excite the TM010 mode. Using the expressions relevant to this mode, we obtain pl p201 2 Wm We ¼ ð5:127Þ E02 J12 ðp01 Þ ea 4 o2 m jHn j ¼
1 p01 E0 J1 ðp01 Þ om a
ð5:128Þ
where l is the height of the cavity, a its radius, p01 the first zero of the Bessel function J0 and E0 the (arbitrary) amplitude of the electric field. Inserting the above expressions into (5.126), we obtain Yin ¼
12
See [5], p. 49ff.
1 þ joCp joL0
ð5:129Þ
RESONATORS AND CAVITIES
161
with L0 ¼
mS2 ; pla2
Cp ¼
pla4 e S2 p201
ð5:130Þ
In the proximity of the TM01 resonant mode, we again find that the cavity behaves as a parallel resonant circuit. In wider frequency ranges additional resonant modes should be included in the equivalent circuit of the cavity, leading to the same equivalent circuit of Figure 5.15.
Bibliography 1. J. C. Slater, Microwave Electronics, Van Nostrand, Princeton, NJ, 1950. 2. K. Kurokawa, An Introduction to the Theory of Microwave Circuits, Academic Press, New York, 1969. 3. T. Okoshi, Planar Circuits for Microwave and Lightwaves, Springer Series in Electrophysics, Vol. 18, 1984. 4. K. C. Gupta and M. Abouzhara(eds), Analysis and Design of Planar Microwave Components, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ, 1994. 5. D. Kajfez and P. Guillon, Dielectric Resonators, Artech House, Dedham, MA, 1986. 6. Kai Chang(ed.), Handbook of Microwave and Optical Components, Vol. 1, Ch. 4. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1989. 7. C. A. Balanis, Advanced Electromagnetic Engineering, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1989, Ch. 9. 8. R.E. Collin, Field Theory of Guided Waves, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ, 1991. 9. G. Conciauro, M. Guglielmi and R. Sorrentino, Advanced Modal Analysis, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1999. 10. G. D’Inzeo, F. Giannini, C.M. Sodi and R. Sorrentino, ‘Method of analysis and filtering properties of microwave planar networks’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. MTT26, pp. 462–471, 1978. 11. I. Wolff and N. Knoppik, ‘Rectangular and circular microstrip disk capacitors and resonators’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 22, No. 10, pp. 857–864, 1974. 12. R. Sorrentino, ‘Planar circuits, waveguide models, and segmentation method’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. MTT-33, pp. 1348–1353, 1985. 13. J. K. Kraus, Antennas, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1988.
6
Impedance matching 6.1 Introduction The power transfer between different parts of a microwave circuit, typically from a source to a transmission line or from the latter to an antenna, is limited by unavoidable impedance mismatchings. It is apparent how critical the problem is of designing and building appropriate matching and impedance transforming circuits capable of maximizing the power transfer through the microwave apparatus and optimizing its behaviour from an energy point of view. It must also be considered that the presence of standing waves reduces the power-handling capability of the system and that multiple internal reflections within the circuit deteriorate the quality of the RF signals. An impedance matching network, or more generally an impedance transformer, is used to optimize the power transfer from a source to a load in a prescribed frequency band with a prescribed return loss (or reflection coefficient s11). Equivalently, we may say that such a network ‘transforms’ (or, better, aims to transform) the load impedance into that corresponding to the maximum power transfer. The design of matching networks can be achieved by using various methods and circuit configurations. A first distinction can be obtained between purely reactive, thus lossless, and resistive (lossy) networks. A second classification is between lumped and distributed networks. Finally, the matching network depends on the frequency range of interest; it clearly appears that the complexity increases with the required passband width. Lossless matching networks are the only ones considered in this chapter, as they are the most commonly adopted networks. They can be reduced in practice to three categories: quarter-wavelength transformers, stub networks and lumped L networks. Before going into detail, however, it is important to present a fundamental limitation on the impedance matching.
6.2 Fano’s bound It is worth noting at the outset that there are specific theoretical bounds on wide-band impedance matching. Indeed, when a load is not purely resistive, Fano [1] theoretically determined an upper limit to the product of return loss and bandwidth.
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
164
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Z Lossless matching network
Γ
Figure 6.1
C
R
Matching a complex load to a lossless two-port network.
To illustrate this point, let us consider a load consisting of an RC parallel cell, the matching network being a lossless two-port network as shown in Figure 6.1. Let Gð f Þ be the reflection coefficient at the input of the matching network when the second port is terminated with the RC cell. Fano’s bound states that 1 ð
0
1 ð 1 d f 1 ) RLð f Þd f < 4:343 ln Gð f Þ 2RC RC
ð6:1Þ
0
where RL ¼ 20 log10 ðjGjÞ is the return loss at the input of the matching network.1 If the RC cell is replaced with a generic reactive bipole, the r.h.s. of (6.1) takes a different form, but there always exists an upper limit a on the integral of RL.2 Suppose we want to match a bipole in the frequency band between f1 and f2, using a lossless network. The integral on the l.h.s. of (6.1) can be broken down into the sum of three integrals: ðf1
1 ð
RLðf Þd f ¼
ðf2 RLð f Þd f þ
RLð f Þd f þ f1
0
0
1 ð
RLð f Þd f < a
ð6:2Þ
f2
It follows that ðf2
1 ðf1 ð RLð f Þd f < a RLð f Þd f RLð f Þd f
f1
0
ð6:3Þ
f2
Since the return loss of a passive network is a non-negative quantity, the following inequality holds even more so: ðf2 RLð f Þd f < a
ð6:4Þ
f1
Let RLMIN be the minimum value of the return loss in the frequency interval [f1 f2]. Using (6.4) we may write ðf2 RLMIN ð f2 f1 Þ <
RLð f Þd f < a ) RLMIN < f1
a f2 f1
ð6:5Þ
From Fano’s inequality an important consequence follows: using a lossless matching network, however complex it may be, the best matching (i.e. RLMIN ) is bounded by a value inversely proportional to 1
For the definition of return loss see also Section 8.2. Note that for a purely reactive bipole, such an integral is zero ða ¼ 0Þ. Since any lossless network transforms a reactance into another reactance, the input reflection coefficient in fact stays unitary. 2
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
165
θ = π/2
Z0
ZL
Z1
Figure 6.2
A l/4 transformer.
the prescribed bandwidth. The constant a depends on the bipole to be matched and is independent of the normalization resistance; in other words, it does not change whether the reference impedance is 50 O, 100 O, or any other real value. Many matching networks typically allow only real loads to be matched. A complex load can easily be made real by a suitable parallel reactance. Let ZL ¼ RL þ jXL be the load impedance. The corresponding admittance is ð6:6Þ YL ¼ 1=ZL ¼ ðRL jXL Þ= R2L þ XL2 By parallel connecting the susceptance
B ¼ XL = R2L þ XL2
we obtain a purely real impedance ZL0 given by ZL0 ¼ 1=ðYL þ jBÞ ¼ R2L þ XL2 =RL ¼ jZL j2 =ReðZL Þ
ð6:7Þ
ð6:8Þ
If B > 0 (respectively, B < 0), it can be realized as a lumped capacitor (inductor) or as an open-circuited (short-circuited) stub.3 In a similar manner, a reactive admittance can be reduced to a conductance by adding a suitable series impedance. Once transformed into a resistance or a conductance, the load can be matched to the source using, for example, a quarter-wavelength transformer, as described in the next section.
6.3 Quarter-wavelength transformer The simplest distributed matching network is the l/4 transformer that we considered in Section 4.3. The load impedance ZL is connected to the reference impedance Z0 through a line section of impedance Z1 , as shown in Figure 6.2. At the frequency when the length is l/4, and thus the electrical length y is p/2, the input impedance seen at terminal 1 is Z0 ¼
Z12 ZL
ð6:9Þ
The circuit of Figure 6.2 can thus be used to match a real load ZL to a source Z0 (real) by choosing Z1 to be the geometric mean of ZL and Z0 . Though very simple, this solution is narrow band as the matching is realized only in the proximity of the central frequency f0 corresponding to the line length l being equal to l/4: vp ð6:10Þ f0 ¼ 4l where vp is the phase velocity along the line. 3 The stub is usually 50 O, since this is a value easy to realize. In general the stub length is chosen to be less than l/4, and it is open-circuited (or short-circuited) in order to have B > 0 (B < 0). (See Equations (4.14) and (4.15).)
166
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
In order to evaluate the frequency behaviour of the l/4 transformer, we compute the input reflection coefficient. Using well-known formulae (e.g. (4.5)), we obtain G¼
Zin Z0 ZL Z0 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ ... ¼ Zin þ Z0 ZL þ Z0 þ 2j Z0 ZL tan y
ð6:11Þ
where y ¼ bl ¼
2pl 2pl f ¼ l vp
ð6:12Þ
is the line electrical length. The magnitude of G is r¼h
jZL Z 0 j
i1=2 ¼ " ðZL þ Z 0 Þ2 þ 4Z 0 ZL tan2 y
1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 #1=2 2 Z0 ZL 1 1þ ZL Z0 cos y
ð6:13Þ
Its frequency behaviour is shown in Figure 6.3. The magnitude of G vanishes when the line length is an odd multiple of l/4 corresponding to electrical lengths y ¼ ð2n þ 1Þp=2 with n ¼ 0, 1, 2. . .. On the contrary, when the line length is a multiple of l/2 (thus y ¼ np) the line simply transfers the load impedance ZL to the input, so that the reflection coefficient is given by Gð0Þ ¼
ZL Z0 ZL þ Z0
ð6:14Þ
and is independent of Z1 . In the design of the impedance transformer we need to specify the maximum allowed reflection coefficient rM and the corresponding frequency range. The two quantities are clearly not independent of each other as can be seen from Figure 6.3, which shows that the reflection coefficient stays below rM in the interval p Dy ¼ 2 yM ¼ p2yM ð6:15Þ 2 corresponding to a relative bandwidth w¼
Df Dy 4 ¼ ¼ 2 yM f0 p=2 p
zL - z0 zL + z0
Figure 6.3 Reflection coefficient of a single section l/4 transformer.
ð6:16Þ
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
167
In (6.16) we have assumed that the line is non-dispersive, i.e. that the phase velocity is frequency independent. From (6.13), putting r ¼ rM we find for yM ffi ffi 2r pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2r pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi p M Z0 ZL M Z0 ZL 1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ sin pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi yM ¼ cos ðZL Z0 Þ 1r2M 2 ðZL Z0 Þ 1r2M 1
ð6:17Þ
using the formula cosðaÞ ¼ sinðp=2aÞ. For example, if we need to match a 200 O load to 50 O with a 20 dB maximum reflection coefficient, from the previous equations we obtain pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 50 200 ¼ 100 O rm ¼ 101 ¼ 0:1 0:2 100 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ 1:44 rad ¼ 82:5 ym ¼ cos1 150 10:01 Z1 ¼
ð6:18Þ
Df ¼ 16:7% f0 If the load is ZL ¼ 400 O, a similar computation would show that ym ¼ 1:51 rad ¼ 86:7 , implying a relative bandwidth of 6.6%.
6.4 Multi-section quarter-wavelength transformers A better performance can be obtained by using a multi-section transformer, consisting of a cascade of several l/4 line sections; the additional degrees of freedom available can be used to obtain impedance transformers with improved characteristics in terms of both bandwidth and return loss. Figure 6.4 depicts an impedance transformer consisting of N l/4 line sections of characteristic impedances Zi (i ¼ 1, 2, . . ., N), interposed between the load ZN+1 ¼ ZL and the source Z0. Our objective is to determine the values of Zi (i ¼ 1, 2, . . ., N) such that some prescribed requirements are satisfied in terms of input reflection coefficient, or, equivalently, return loss. The procedure for determining the unknown circuit elements from a prescribed response is called synthesis, in contrast to the opposite procedure, the analysis, consisting of determining the unknown response of the circuit from its element values. Though somewhat simplified, the procedure we will illustrate here is quite similar to the filter synthesis described in the next chapter and is thus also intended as an introduction to the concepts that will be illustrated in greater detail in Chapter 8. Without loss of generality, we can assume that the load impedance ZL is larger than the reference impedance Z0. In other words, the impedance ratio is greater than unity: R¼
θ Γ
Γ0
Z1
ZL > 1 Z0
θ Γ1
Z2
ð6:19Þ
θ Γ2
Z3
θ Γ3
Z0
Figure 6.4
Multi-section quarter-wavelength transformer.
ZN
ΓN
ZL
168
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
If the opposite is true, the synthesis can be reversed taking the load as the reference impedance and Z0 as the load. Equivalently, the synthesis can be performed using the admittances rather than the impedances. As a consequence of condition (6.19), the characteristic impedance of each line is greater than the previous one, Ziþ1 > Zi , and the reflection coefficients at the various junctions Gi ¼
Ziþ1 Zi Ziþ1 þ Zi
ð6:20Þ
are real and positive.4 With reference to Figure 6.4, where Z0 and ZL are supposed to be given, the synthesis procedure can be broken down into the following steps: 1. The analytical expression of the input reflection coefficient of Figure 6.4 is determined. 2. The type of response required is chosen. Two options are normally offered to the designer, namely the maximally flat and the equiripple, or Chebyshev, response. With the former, the input reflection coefficient at the centre frequency f0 is chosen to be zero along with all its derivatives up to the (N 1)th one. These conditions, as we will see, are sufficient to determine the N unknown impedances of the transformer. This type of transformer is called, for reasons that will become clear later on, the binomial transformer. As an alternative, rather than a maximally flat response we may prefer an equiripple response: the input reflection coefficient swings between zero and a maximum value rM in a prescribed frequency band centred at f0. This is the Chebyshev transformer, whose name derives from the fact that Chebyshev polynomials are employed. 3. By equating the expression in step 1 to the analytical expression of the required response in step 2, the N unknown impedances Zi are finally determined. Step 1 requires a considerable amount of algebraic effort. This can be avoided under the assumption that the impedance ratio (6.19) is not too large, so that the impedance ratios between consecutive line sections Zi =Ziþ1 are close to unity. As a consequence, the reflection coefficients (6.20) are so small that we can assume that jGi j2 1
ði ¼ 0; 1; . . . ; NÞ
ð6:21Þ
Under the above hypotheses, the expression for the input reflection coefficient Gin in the impedance transformer of Figure 6.4 can easily be computed using the theory of small reflections. Accordingly, Gin results from the sum of the reflection coefficients (6.20) of the individual discontinuities, each multiplied by the phase term ej2iy corresponding to the distance travelled by the signal from the input to the discontinuity and back to the input, i.e. Gin ¼ G0 þ G1 ej2y þ G2 ej4y þ G3 ej6y þ þ GN ej2Ny ¼
N X
Gi ej2iy
ð6:22Þ
i¼0
4 Note that the quantity (6.20) is not the reflection coefficient when looking to the right from the junction, but the reflection coefficient of the (i + 1)th line with respect to the ith line. The former, in fact, depends on all subsequent discontinuities, while the latter is the ‘local’ refelction coefficient which only depends on the ith and (i + 1)th lines.
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
169
The theory of small reflections is developed by assuming that the reflected signal at the input port results from an infinite number of subsequent local reflections from the various discontinuities. To illustrate the point, consider the simple case of Figure 6.2. Assume a unit voltage impinging on the input port. The sequence of events is schematically illustrated in Table 6.1: 1. A first reflection occurs at port 1, producing a reflected wave of amplitude G0 ¼
Z1 Z0 Z1 þ Z0
while the signal transmitted to line 1 is T01 ¼ G0 þ 1
ð6:23Þ
2. This signal travels along line 1 for an electrical length y, undergoing a phase shift ejy . 3. The signal reaches the second discontinuity Z2 ¼ ZL where it is partly reflected back with reflection coefficient G1 ¼
Z2 Z1 Z2 þ Z1
ð6:24Þ
4. The reflected signal travels back on line 1 undergoing another phase shift ejy . 5. The signal reaches the first discontinuity from the right, where it is partly reflected back to the load. The reflection coefficient is Z0 Z1 ¼ G0 Z0 þ Z1 while the transmission coefficient is T10 ¼ G0 þ 1
ð6:25Þ
The transmitted signal emerges from port 1 towards the source, contributing to an additional reflection term. 6. The signal reflected in step 5 travels towards the load, undergoing another phase shift. The process then repeats from step 4 to step 5 an infinite number of times. As can be seen from Table 6.1, the total signal emerging from port 1, thus the reflection coefficient at port 1, is Gin ¼ G0 þ T10 T01 G1 ej2y þ T10 T01 ðG0 ÞG21 ej4y þ T10 T01 G20 G31 ej6y þ . . . 1 X ¼ G0 þ T10 T01 G1 ej2y ðG0 G1 ej2y Þi
ð6:26Þ
i¼0
The summation in the above formula is the geometrical series 1 X i¼0
xi ¼
1 1x
Therefore Gin ¼ G0 þ
T10 T01 G1 ej2y G0 þ G1 ej2y ¼ j2y 1G0 G1 e 1 þ G0 G1 ej2y
ð6:27Þ
170
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Table 6.1 Derivation of the input reflection coefficient of Figure 6.2. Step
Signal emerging Transmitted/ from port 1 reflected at port 1 G0
1
Signal incident to port 1
2
Signal travels along line 1
3
Signal reflected from load
4
Signal travels along line 1
5
Transmission and reflection at port 1
6
Signal travels along line 1
7
Reflection from load
8
Signal travels along line 1
9
Transmission and reflection at port 1
Signal along line 1
Reflected from port 2
T01
T01 ejy G1 T01 ejy
G1 T01 ej2y T10 G1 T01 ej2y G0 G1 T01 ej2y
G0 G1 T01 ej3y G0 G21 T01 ej3y
G0 G21 T01 ej4y T10 G0 G21 T01 ej4y G20 G21 T01 ej4y G20 G21 T01 ej5y
...
...
using (6.23) and (6.25). As the reader can verify, the above expression for Gin is fully equivalent to (6.11); however, (6.27) lends itself to the approximation for small reflections. If (6.21) holds for both G0 and G1 , then (6.27) can be approximated as Gin ¼
G0 þ G1 ej2y ffi G0 þ G1 ej2y 1 þ G0 G1 ej2y
ð6:28Þ
This formula can be immediately extended to the general case of N line sections so as to obtain (6.22). As already observed, because of assumption (6.19), the coefficients (6.20) in (6.22) are real and positive quantities and coincide with their respective magnitudes ri: Gin ¼
N X i¼0
ri ej2iy
ð6:29Þ
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
171
This expression can be further simplified by the assumption of a symmetrical transformer, i.e. a transformer where r0 ¼ rN ; r1 ¼ rN1 ; ri ¼ rNi Using (6.30), (6.29) becomes
ð6:30Þ
5
Gin ¼ 2ejNy ½r0 cos Ny þ r1 cosðN2Þy þ r2 cosðN4Þy þ . . . 8 ðN1Þ=2 > X > > > ri cosðN2iÞy for N odd > < i¼0 ¼ 2ejNy N=2 > X > 1 > > ri cosðN2iÞy þ rN=2 for N even > : 2 i¼0
ð6:32Þ
Once expression (6.32) for the input coefficient has been obtained (step 1 of the synthesis procedure), we can choose between the maximally flat and the Chebyshev response.
6.4.1
The binomial transformer
The input reflection coefficient is imposed to get a maximally flat behaviour at the centre frequency f ¼ f0, i.e. for y ¼ p=2. We put N 1 þ e2jy GBin ðyÞ ¼ Gð0Þ ¼ Gð0Þ cosN ðyÞejNy ð6:33Þ 2 where G(0) is the reflection coefficient at DC and at all frequencies for which the lines are l/2 long, and given by (6.14). As can easily be verified, for y ¼ p/2, GBin ðyÞ is zero along with its derivatives up to (N 1)th order. In other words, the input reflection coefficient has an Nth- order zero at the centre frequency. It is important to stress that, as we will show below, (6.33) is consistent with the general expression (6.32) obtained under the hypothesis of small reflections. In those cases when such an approximation cannot be applied, (6.33) may give rise to unphysical results. In particular, in order to determine the transformer bandwidth for any transformer ratio R, it is necessary to resort to a rigorous theory, which is beyond our scope. While the interested reader is referred to [3], we limit ourselves to providing the final result. By requiring that the squared magnitude of the reflection coefficient be less than 0.5 (or 3.01 dB), i.e. jGBin ðyM Þj2 ¼ 0:5, we obtain sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi! sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi! 4R p 4R 2N 1 ¼ sin yM ¼ cos1 2N 2 ðR1Þ2 ðR1Þ2 ð6:34Þ sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi! 4 1 2N 4R w ¼ sin p ðR1Þ2 where we have used (6.16). Figure 6.5 shows the relative 3 dB bandwidth of binomial transformers as a function of the impedance ratio R and for a number of sections varying from N ¼ 1 to N ¼ 15. 5
To derive (6.32) we combine the first and last terms and make use of the following property:
r0 þ rN ej2Ny ¼ r0 ð1 þ ej2Ny Þ ¼ 2r0 ejNy cos Ny
ð6:1Þ
We proceed similarly with the other pairs. When N is even, the central term rN=2 ejNy is not combined with another term.
172
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING R = 5.828 (Γ= 0.707)
2 1
∆f/ f0
15
7
8 6
0.1 5 n=1
0
2
4
6
4
3
2
8
10
12
14
log10(R) = log10 [(1 +Γ) / (1 − Γ )]
Figure 6.5
The 3 dB relative bandwidth of binomial transformers.
The characteristic impedances Zi (i ¼ 1 . . . N) of the line sections can be obtained by equating (6.32) and (6.33) and using (6.20). In order to do that, we use the well-known expression of the Nth power of a binomial: N X N i Ni ða þ bÞN ¼ ð6:35Þ ab i i¼0 where
N i
¼
N Ni
¼
N! i!ðNiÞ!
ð6:36Þ
is the binomial coefficient. Using (6.35) and taking into account the symmetry property of the binomial coefficients (6.36), expression (6.33) becomes GBin ðyÞ ¼ Gð0Þ2N ð1 þ e2jy ÞN 8 ðN1Þ=2 > X N > > > cosðN2iÞy > < i i¼0 jNy ¼ 2Gð0Þe N=2 >X > N N 1 > > cosðN2iÞy þ > : 2 N=2 i i¼0 Equating (6.32) to (6.37) we obtain ri ¼ 2N
ZL Z0 ZL þ Z0
N i
for N odd
ð6:37Þ
for N even
¼ rNi
ði ¼ 1 . . . NÞ
ð6:38Þ
As already mentioned, these are approximate formulae that can be applied under the assumption of small reflections. In practice, a good approximation is obtained when ZL < 2Z0 [3]. The design of the maximally flat transformer can be carried out as illustrated in Example 6.1 at the end of the next section.
6.4.2
Chebyshev polynomials; the Chebyshev transformer
Instead of (6.33), an alternative expression for the input reflection coefficient can be adopted in order to obtain an equiripple behaviour in the operating band. To this end, we need to introduce the Chebyshev
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
173
polynomials: they are based on the property that the Nth power of the cosine of an angle y can be expressed as an Nth-degree polynomial of the cosine itself, i.e. cosðNyÞ ¼ TN ½cosðyÞ
ð6:39Þ
where TN is the Nth-order Chebyshev polynomial of the variable x ¼ cosðyÞ. One can easily recognize that T0 ðxÞ ¼ 1;
T1 ðxÞ ¼ x;
T2 ðxÞ ¼ 2x2 1
ð6:40Þ
Moreover, it can be proved that the following recursive relation holds: TN ðxÞ ¼ 2xTN1 ðxÞTN2 ðxÞ
for N > 2
ð6:41Þ
The computation of the Chebyshev polynomial of any order can thus be performed starting from (6.40) and then applying the recursive relation (6.41). In order to understand how we can utilize Chebyshev polynomials to get an equiripple response, we present the following interesting properties: (a) jTN ðxÞj 1 for
jxj 1
(b) jTN ð 1Þj ¼ 1 1 ðodd NÞ (c) jTN ð0Þj ¼ 0 ðeven NÞ (d) limx ! 1 TN ðxÞ ¼ limx ! 1 2N1 xN : In words, when |x| is less than unity, the amplitude of any Chebyshev polynomial swings between the values 1, touching N 1 times the values 1 or 1. Because of (b), the Chebyshev polynomials are 1 or 1 at the boundaries of the interval x ¼ 1. When the argument |x| is greater than 1, the polynomials increase monotonically towards infinity, the faster, the higher the degree N. Chebyshev polynomials of degrees 1 to 4 are shown in Figure 6.6. N=2
N=4
TN (x)
4 3 2
1 1
−1
1
x
−1 N=1
N=3
Figure 6.6 Chebyshev polynomials of degree N ¼ 1, 2, 3, 4.
174
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Because of the above properties, it is easy to see that an equiripple behaviour is obtained by choosing the following expression for the input reflection coefficient: GCheb ðyÞ ¼ Gð0ÞejNy
TN ðcos y=cos ym Þ TN ð1=cos ym Þ
ð6:42Þ
Indeed, when jðcos yÞ=ðcos ym Þj 1, thus for ym y pym, the magnitude of GCheb is between 0 and Gð0Þ rM ¼ ð6:43Þ TN ð1=cos yM Þ For any given N, (6.43) provides the relationship between the transformer bandwidth and the maximum ripple in the band. It also shows that the reflection coefficient is reduced from Gð0Þ ¼ ðR1Þ=ðR þ 1Þ to rM by the factor Gð0Þ ¼ TN ð1=cos yM Þ ð6:44Þ rM As an example, Figure 6.7 shows the frequency behaviours of Chebyshev transformers for 1–4 sections, with impedance ratio R ¼ 20 and relative bandwidth w ¼ 100%. The frequency is normalized with respect to the centre frequency f0. It can be seen that, in the same band 0.5–1.5, the maximum reflection coefficient rM is progressively reduced from6 0.65 to 0.053 when the number of sections is increased from 1 to 4. The ratio (6.44) can be used to determine, for given impedance ratio R, ripple rM and relative bandwidth w, the degree N of the Chebyshev polynomial, thus the number of sections of the transformer. This is shown in Figure 6.8, where the square of (6.44)7 is plotted as a function of the relative bandwidth w, for N ¼ 1. . .15. This diagram is equivalent to Table 6.2 in [4]. 1.0
0.8 N =1
ρ
0.6 2 0.4
3
4
0.2
0.0
0
1
2
2 θ/π
Figure 6.7 Reflection coefficients of Chebyshev transformers up to fourth order vs. the normalized frequency y=ðp=2Þ ¼ f = f0. 6 More precisely, the maximum reflection coefficient is equal to 0.64, 0.302, 0.128 and 0.053 for N = 1, 2, 3 and 4, respectively. 7 2 TN ð1=cos yM Þ represents the improvement in excess loss due to the presence of the transformer, the excess loss being defined as EX ¼ Pav =PL 1 ¼ jGj2 =ð1jGj2 Þ where Pav is the power available and PL the power delivered to the load [4]. The rigorous theory of quarter-wave transformers is indeed based on this quantity rather than on the reflection coefficient. Instead of Equation (6.44) one obtains EXa =EXr ¼ TN2 ð1=cos yM Þ, where EXa is the maximum excess loss and EXr the maximum excess loss in the passband.
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
175
1040
N=15
TN2 (1/cos θM)
1030 11 9
1020 7
1010 5 3 1
100
0
1
2
w = 2 − (4/π)θM
Figure 6.8
Diagram showing TN2 ð1=cos yM Þ in terms of relative bandwidth w ¼ 2ð4=pÞyM .
Once the number of sections has been determined, the characteristic impedances of the various sections can be computed by a procedure similar to that used for the binomial transformer, i.e. by equating expression (6.42) to (6.32). In doing this the nth power of cos y must be expressed as a polynomial in cos y using the following expression: n X n cos½ðn2kÞy cosn ðyÞ ¼ 2n k k¼0
In this way, the Chebyshev polynomials in (6.42) can be expressed as follows: cos y cos y T1 ¼ cos yM cos yM cos y 1 þ cos 2y T2 1 ¼ cos yM cos2 yM cos y cos 3y þ 3 cos y cos y 3 ¼ T3 cos yM cos3 yM cos yM cos y cos 4y þ 4 cos 2y þ 3 1 þ cos 2y T4 4 ¼ cos yM cos4 yM cos2 yM
ð6:45Þ
These expressions can be used to compute the reflection coefficients of the various sections of the transformer up to N ¼ 4. For higher numbers of sections, the reader is referred to [3]. An exact design procedure, not resorting to the theory of small reflections, can also be developed [5].
Table 6.2 Impedances of the two-section transformer in Example 6.1.
Binomial Chebyshev
Z0
Z1
Z2
Z3
1 1
1.414 214 1.420 798
2.828 427 2.815 319
4 4
176
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING |Γ(θ)|
ZL – Z0 ZL + Z0
maximally flat Chebyshev
ρm,maximally flat = 0.33 ρm,Chebyshev = 0.145 O
θ
π/2
θm,Chebyshev =0.159 π
θm,maximally flat = 0.202 π
Figure 6.9 Frequency responses of binomial and Chebyshev l/4 transformers of fifth degree.
Figure 6.9 shows a comparison of the reflection coefficients of a Chebyshev and a maximally flat transformer of degree N ¼ 5 as a function of the electrical length y. Note that the former provides a better matching over a wider bandwidth.
EXAMPLE 6.1 An impedance ZL ¼ 200 O is to be matched to the reference impedance Z0 ¼ 50 O in the frequency band 900–1100 MHz with a minimum return loss of 20 dB. The relative bandwidth and the impedance ratio are w¼
D f 1100900 ¼ 0:2; ¼ f0 1000
R¼
Znþ1 200 ¼4 ¼ 50 Z0
The first step is to determine the required number N of sections. For N ¼ 1,8 and thus for the simple l/4 transformer since for one section there is no difference between binomial and Chebyshev transformers, the minimum in-band return loss is 20.55 dB ðr ffi 0:093 86Þ, which is too close to the specification. We will then choose N ¼ 2. For a binomial transformer, N ¼ 2 yields a maximum return loss of 36.664 dB ðr 0:014 68Þ. This is much better than the requirement and provides some margin against non-idealities of the actual circuit (such as loss, discontinuity effects and fabrication tolerances). In comparison, a Chebyshev transformer with the same number of sections has a minimum in-band return loss of 42.577 dB ðr 0:00743Þ. The second step consists of computing the impedances of the various sections. The physical length of all line sections is l/4 at the centre frequency. Using formulae (6.38) we obtain the characteristic impedances quoted in Table 6.2. Note the closeness of the values obtained for both transformers. Figure 6.10 shows the responses of the ideal binomial (curve 1) and Chebyshev (curve 2) transformers. The Chebyshev version looks more attractive for practical applications. Therefore, 8
See the Mathcad file 01_Multisection_TL_Transformer.MCD.
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
177
consider a microstrip circuit with substrate permittivity er ¼ 4:4 and thickness h ¼ 3 mm. By numerically inverting the analysis formulae (3.181)–(3.183)9 we obtain the widths and lengths of the two transformer sections given in Table 6.3. The response of the microstrip Chebyshev transformer is shown by curve 3 in Figure 6.10. Although this response has been computed10 without including the effect of the step discontinuity between lines 2 and 3, some degradation due to dispersion and loss can nonetheless be observed. The degradation becomes even more serious when the effect of the step discontinuity from w ¼ 3:004 to w ¼ 0:432 is taken into account, as shown by curve 4 in Figure 6.10. The effect of the reactance due to the discontinuities is somehow equivalent to a local alteration of the distributed capacitance and inductance of the microstrips. This means that the discontinuity modifies the effective impedance and electrical length of the two microstrips. The response can partially be realigned by adjusting widths and lengths. By circuit tuning, it was found that it is sufficient to shorten the lengths of the microstrip sections. The optimized lengths are given in the last row of Table 6.3, while the corresponding response of the transformer is shown by curve 5 in Figure 6.10. Although obtained by simulation, these results can be considered to be quite realistic.
0.06 1) Binomial, ideal 2) Chebyshev, ideal 3) Chebyshev, microstrip (no disc.) 4) Chebyshev, microstrip (disc.) 5) Chebyshev, microstrip (disc., opt.)
0.05
ρ
0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0.00 0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
Frequency, GHz
Figure 6.10
Comparison of two-section transformers in Example 6.1.
Table 6.3 Values of two-section Chebyshev transformer discussed in Example 6.1. Normalized impedances Zk Denormalized impedances Zk wk (mm) c 1 lk ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi (mm) ee f f 4f0 c 1 lk;opt ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi (mm) ee f f 4 f0
9
Z0
Z1
Z2
Z3
1 50
1.420 798 71.0399 3.004
2.815 319 140.7659 0.432
4 200
42.137
43.784
41
43.7
See the Mathcad file 02_Microstrip_Analysis_Synthesis.MCD in Chapter 12. See the Ansoft file 03_Multisection_TL_Transformer.adsn.
10
178
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
6.5 Line and stub transformers; stub tuners A simple distributed network able to match complex impedances is the line and single stub circuit shown in Figure 6.11. The matching procedure can be illustrated by the example shown in Figure 6.12, where the load impedance is ZL ¼ ZA ¼ Z0 ð0:5j1:5Þ
ð6:46Þ
In the Smith chart this is represented by the point P corresponding to a reflection coefficient of magnitude 0.745. The transmission line of electrical length y0 connected to the load transforms ZP into ZQ, through a clockwise rotation of an angle 2y0. The line length must be such that the real part of the transformed ^ ¼ 1. In the present admittance YQ ¼ 1=ZQ is equal to Y0 ¼ 1=Z0 , so that the point Q lies on the circle G example, 2y0 ffi 37:3 and the resulting admittance at Q is YQ ¼ ð1 þ j2:236ÞZ01 . The admittance YQ can now be easily matched by parallel connecting a reactive bipole having an opposite susceptance B2. This susceptance can be realized as a lumped capacitor or inductor depending on whether B2 is positive or negative. In this example B2 ¼ ImðYQ Þ ¼ 2:236=Z0
ð6:47Þ
The solution indicated in Figure 6.12 makes use of a stub of impedance Z02 , short- or open-circuited at the other end (a broken line is used to indicate a short or an open circuit). The choice between the two options depends on different practical factors. From a technology point of view, for instance when microstrip technology is employed, short-circuited stubs are generally to be avoided since they require a hole to be drilled in the substrate. From the point of view of circuit sensitivity to fabrication tolerances, the stub should be shorter than l/4. Therefore if B2 < 0 (B2 > 0) one would employ a short-circuited (opencircuited) stub. In the latter case, for example, recalling the input admittance of an open stub (4.15), the length of the stub should be such that Y02 tanðblÞ ¼ B2 ¼ 2:236Y0
ð6:48Þ
Needless to say, the dual circuits of Figure 6.11 can be employed, using series rather than parallel stubs. The design procedure is quite similar and is thus not described here. If the stub is realized in the form of a sliding short circuit, the circuit can be used as a variable impedance tuner commonly employed in laboratory practice. This type of circuit, however, has some serious limitations. Not only does it not allow any complex admittance or impedance to be matched, but also it requires the stub to be located in a position which depends on the load and on the frequency.
θ1 Z 01
P2
P1
ZL
Z02 Open or short-circuit
θ2
Figure 6.11 Line and stub transformer.
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
Figure 6.12
179
Load matching with the circuit of Figure 6.10.
A double-stub tuner, shown in Figure 6.13, partially removes the requirement for variable distance from the load: the matching is obtained only by adjusting the lengths of the stubs, which are placed at a fixed distance d from each other and have the same characteristic impedance Z0 as the source. For simplicity we assume Z0 ¼ 1, and thus all impedances and admittances are considered to be normalized. Suppose the two stubs have lengths l1 ; l2 respectively and the second one is located at a distance l from the load ZL ¼ 1=YL . Figure 6.13b shows the reduced equivalent circuit of the tuner, where the stubs have been replaced by their susceptances: Bi ¼ cotðbli Þ
l
d Y0
Z0=1
Z0=1
Z02
Z01
l2
ði ¼ 1; 2Þ
ð6:49Þ
d ZL
Y0
B2 Z0=1
B1
l1
Open or short-circuit (a)
Figure 6.13
(b)
The double-stub tuner (a) and its reduced equivalent circuit (b).
Y′L
180
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
and the load has been moved to the first stub and transformed into the admittance YL0 ¼
YL þ j tanðblÞ 1 þ jYL tanðblÞ
ð6:50Þ
The matching of the circuit in Figure 6.13b requires the input admittance to be equal to unity: YL0 þ jðB1 þ tanðbdÞÞ þ jB2 ¼ 1 1 þ jðYL0 þ jB1 Þ tanðbdÞ
ð6:51Þ
This complex equation can be solved to give the two stub lengths l1 ; l2 . If we require the real part of the l.h.s. of (6.51) to be equal to unity, then we obtain the condition 2 2 0 G02 L ½1 þ cot ðbdÞGL þ ½cotðbdÞB1 B2 ¼ 0
ð6:52Þ
Since G0L must be real and non-negative, by solving the above equation the following condition is found: 0 G0L 1 þ cot2 ðbdÞ ¼
1 sin2 ðbdÞ
ð6:53Þ
In the Smith chart, Eqn. (6.53) represents the area external to the circle G ¼ 1=sin2 ðbdÞ. Note that the smaller the value of d, the wider the range of loads that can be matched. The complete solution for stub susceptances is found to be qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
B1 ¼ cotðbdÞ 1B0L tanðbdÞ G0L sec2 ðbdÞ½G0L tanðbdÞ2 ð6:54Þ G02 tanðbdÞ B0L þ B1 þ tanðbdÞ 1ðB0L þ B1 Þ tanðbdÞ B2 ¼ L 2 2 0 0 ½GL tanðbdÞ þ ½1ðBL þ B1 Þ tanðbdÞ From (6.54) the stub lengths are computed by inverting (6.49). The limitation expressed by (6.53) can be removed using a triple-stub tuner. The additional stub enables any complex load to be matched. Moreover, the additional degree of freedom can be used to increase the bandwidth. Electronically driven tuners can be realized by loading the stubs with variable loads. A typical implementation consists of using RF MEMS switches to vary the lengths of the stubs [6].
6.6 Lumped L networks The distributed solutions illustrated in previous sections correspond approximately to a simple lumped L network. Depending upon the specific frequency characteristics of the arbitrary impedance to be matched, one of the four circuits shown in Figure 6.14 can be adopted to provide the widest bandwidth. By possibly interchanging the positions of the load and the source, the four networks can be reduced to just two: a series C/shunt L and a series L/shunt C as shown in Figure 6.15a,b, having highpass and lowdpass responses, respectively. Let us consider first the network of Figure 6.15a. By imposing that the input impedance be equal to Z1;a , the matching condition is easily found to be Z1a ¼
Z2a ð1o2 La Ca Þ þ joLa joCa Z2a o2 La Ca
Let us assume Z2a to be real, so that Z2a ¼ R2a and Z1a ¼ R1a . Reordering (6.55), we obtain L o2 La Ca ðR2a R1a ÞR2a þ joCa R1a R2a ¼0 C
ð6:55Þ
ð6:56Þ
IMPEDANCE MATCHING L 1
C
C
2
1
L
(a)
L 2
1
C
(b)
181
C 2
1
L
(c)
2
(d)
Figure 6.14 Lumped L networks: (a) shunt C, series L; (b) shunt L, series C; (c) series L, shunt C; (d) series C, shunt L. This complex equation is satisfied if the network elements are chosen in such a way that, at the working radian frequency o, one has o2 La Ca ¼
R2a R2a R1a
ð6:57Þ
La Ca
ð6:58Þ
R1a R2a ¼
Equation (6.57) can be satisfied only if R1a < R2a so that the network of Figure 6.15a can be used to match a load R2a larger than the source resistance. Moreover, since the r.h.s. of (6.57) is larger than unity, the equation is satisfied only if the working frequency is higher than the resonant frequency: pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð6:59Þ o > oa ¼ 1= La Ca pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi The network therefore has a highpass response. Note that, by interpreting La =Ca as the characteristic impedance of a transmission line, Equation (6.58) is just the same as the matching condition of a quarterwave transformer. Using an identical procedure, for the circuit of Figure 6.15b instead of (6.55) we obtain the matching condition Z2b ð1o2 Lb Cb Þ þ joLb joCb Z2b þ 1
Z1b ¼
ð6:60Þ
which implies that o2 Lb Cb ¼ 1 R1b R2b ¼
R1b R2b
ð6:61Þ
Lb Cb
ð6:62Þ
Also, the network of Figure 6.15b transforms higher into lower resistances (since R1b < R2b ) but, in contrast to Figure 6.14a, it has a lowdpass pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffibehaviour, since the working frequency must be lower than the resonant frequency: o < ob ¼ 1= Lb Cb . The design of a matching L network can also easily be performed by using a Smith chart, where both impedance and admittance circles are shown simultaneously, as in Figure 6.16. As an example, consider a
1 Z1a
Ca La
(a)
Figure 6.15
2
1 Z2a
Z1b
Lb Cb
2 Z2b
(b)
Lumped L networks: (a) high pass; (b) low pass.
182
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
A
+X
–B
Load
G=1
R=1
–X
+B
Z-Chart Y-Chart
Figure 6.16
Matching a load with a lumped L network using the Smith chart.
load RL þ jXL with RL < Z0 , where Z0 is the source impedance. The example applies equally well to any complex load lying on the same constant-R circle. Let us use the network of Figure 6.15b. For simplicity we consider normalized impedances, so that Z0 ¼ 1. Since the load resistance is smaller than the source, we need to connect the load to port 1 and the source to port 2. The series inductor Lb will move P along the constant-R circle R ¼ RL ; its value must be such that the point A lies on the G ¼ 1 circle, i.e. RL þ jXL þ joLb ¼
1 1 þ jBA
Equating the real and imaginary parts of the above equation, we obtain pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi RL ð1 RL Þ XL Lb ¼ o rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 1 BA ¼ RL
ð6:63Þ
ð6:64Þ
The parallel inductor Lb must be chosen in such a way as to move the representative point from A to the centre of the chart ðG ¼ 0Þ, i.e. to compensate for the susceptance BA . Using the second equation of (6.64), we obtain Cb ¼
BA XL þ oLb ¼ o oRL
ð6:65Þ
in agreement with (6.62) when XL ¼ 0. The reader can easily verify that the first equation of (6.64) coincides with (6.61) by putting XL ¼ 0, R1a ¼ RL and R2a ¼ 1. In the general case when the impedance to be matched is complex, as typically happens for active circuits, the networks of Figure 6.15 can be used in combination with proper reactive components capable of compensating for the imaginary part of the load.
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
183
Let ZL ¼ RL þ jXL be the load impedance and Z0 the reference or source impedance. There are four possible cases: 1. RL > Z0 , XL > 0, i.e. high resistance with excess inductance. The latter can be compensated for by series connecting to the load, at port 2 of Figure 6.15a or Figure 6.15b, a capacitor with opposite reactance XL. 2. RL > Z0 , XL < 0, i.e. high resistance with excess capacitance. Same as case 1, but using a series inductor with reactance XL . 3. RL < Z0 , XL > 0, i.e. low resistance with excess inductance. Since RL < Z0 we must use the networks of Figure 6.15 in reversed position, i.e. with the load at port 1 and the source at port 2. Since XL > 0, by using Figure 6.15b we can absorb the reactance into Lb . The inductor is thus replaced by L0 ¼ LXL =o. This is clearly possible under the condition Lb XL =o. 4. RL < Z0 , XL < 0, i.e. low resistance with excess capacitance. Proceeding as in case 3, we can use Figure 6.15a in reversed position, increasing the capacitance to Ca0 ¼ ð1=Ca þ oXL Þ1 , provided that Ca ðoXL Þ1 . Similar to the distributed networks, the lumped L networks described above perfectly match the load at a given frequency. When a broad band is required, multiple cascaded networks, even of different types, can be designed. Fano’s bound expressed by (6.1) is in any case insurmountable. EXAMPLE 6.2 Consider the matching of a real load using a lumped L network with the following design specifications:11 f0 ¼ 1 GHz Z1b ¼ R1b ¼ 50 O;
Z2b ¼ R2b ¼ 200 O
ðR ¼ Z2b =Z1b ¼ 4Þ
From Equations (6.61) and (6.62), it follows that pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi R1b R2b R1b R1b R2b R1b ¼ Lb ¼ ffi 13:783 nH o ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2pf0 rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi r 1 1 R2b 1 1 R2b 1 ¼ 1 ffi 1:378 pF Cb ¼ o R2b R1b 2pf0 R2b R1b pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi The resulting cut-off frequency is fb ¼ ob =2p ¼ 1= 2p Lb Cb ffi 1:155 GHz, which exceeds f by a margin of 155 MHz. The network is perfectly matched at 1 GHz, as expected, and shows a return loss better than 10 dB in the range 0:745 < f < 1:202 GHz. Figure 6.17 shows the return loss with the 10 dB limits marked with squares. Looking at the curve on the Smith chart12 shown in Figure 6.18, we can see that: 1. At DC the input impedance coincides with Z2b ¼ R2b . 2. At 1 GHz the input impedance coincides with Z1b ¼ R1b , as desired and in agreement with the scalar plot. 3. When the frequency approaches infinity, the impedance at port 1 of the network tends to the open circuit because of the presence of the series inductor Lb.
11
See the Ansoft file 02_Lumped_LC_Matching.adsn. Screenshot from the Ansoft program Ansoft Designer Student Version, running the file 02_Lumped_LC_Matching.adsn. 12
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 0
−10 20 log10(ρ)
184
−20
−30
−40 0.0
Figure 6.17
0.5
1.0 Frequency, GHz
1.5
2.0
Reflection coefficient of the lumped L matching network of Example 6.2.
110
90
100
80
70
1.00
120
60 50
130 2.00
0.50
140
40 30
150 160
5.00
0.20
20 10
170
0 Hz 0.00 0.0
180
0.20
0.50
1.00
2.00
5.00
0
∞ Hz
1 GHz
−170
−10
−160
−5.00 −20
0.20
−150
−30 −40
−140 −130
−0.50
−120
1.0
Figure 6.18
−110
−2.00 −1.00 −100
−90 0.0
−80
−70
−50
−60 1.0 ρ
Reflection coefficient of the lumped L matching network of Example 6.2.
IMPEDANCE MATCHING
185
Bibliography 1. R. M. Fano, ‘Theoretical limitations on the broadband matching of arbitrary impedances’, Research Lab. Electronics, MIT Technical Report 41, January 1948. 2. D. M. Pozar, Microwave Engineering, 2nd edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York 1998, pp. 295–297. 3. R. E. Collin, Foundations for Microwave Engineering, McGraw-Hill, New York. 1992. 4. G. Matthaei, L. Young and E. M. T. Jones, Microwave Filters, Impedance Matching Networks, and Coupling Structures, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1964. 5. R. E. Collin, ‘Theory and design of wide-band multisection quarter-wave transformers’, Proceedings of the IRE, pp. 179–185,1955. 6. M. Unluet al., ‘A reconfigurable RF MEMS triple stub impedance matching network’, Proceedings of the 36th European Microwave Conference, Manchester, pp. 1370–1373, 2006.
Simulation files Ansoft files 01_Multisection_TL_Transformer.adsn. Analyzes the two-section transmission line transformer of Example 6.1. 02_Lumped_LC_Matching.adsn. Analyzes the lumped LC matching network considered in Example 6.2.
7
Passive microwave components 7.1 Introduction In contrast with lumped element circuits which comprise a reduced number of elements (resistors, capacitors, inductors, etc.), there exists a large variety of microwave and RF components. They differ from each other depending on the function performed and the technology employed, whether waveguide, coaxial cable, microstrip line or others. Far from providing an exhaustive discussion of the subject (the interested reader is referred to the vast literature on this subject, see for instance [1–3]), we intend here to present a description of some of the most common or most important components from the application or educational points of view. Filters, matching networks and resonators are not considered here; because of their distinct importance they are treated in specific chapters. A possible classification of passive microwave components is based on the number of physical ports and is shown in Table 7.1. The presence of internal losses and the reciprocity of the components are important parameters that affect the performance of microwave components. In the ideal case, most components (except, for example, attenuators) are assumed to be lossless, since power loss is generally an undesirable, though to some extent unavoidable, phenomenon. Both losslessness and reciprocity, as we saw in Chapter 4, imply certain specific properties of the matrix representations (impedance, admittance or scattering) of such components. Special consideration is given to non-reciprocal components, for which Lorentz’s theorem (discussed in Section 2.7.2) does not apply, so that their representative matrices are not symmetrical (Section 4.6). Typical parameters used to characterize the performance of passive components are the insertion loss, the return loss and the isolation between ports of multi-port devices. In addition, the maximum power that the component can stand is an important parameter for high-power applications. It is worth stressing that, in practice, any parameter is frequency dependent and must therefore be specified in connection with a given frequency range.
7.2 Matched loads A matched load or matched termination is employed to absorb all the incident power in such a way as to realize the matching condition. It is thus a one-port device, which ideally exhibits over the operational Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
188
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Table 7.1 Classification of passive microwave components. One-port Two-port
Two-port non- reciprocal Three-port Three-port non- reciprocal Four-port (1 þ N)-port (M þ N)-port
Matched load Movable short Interconnection, bend Attenuator Phase shifter Isolator T, Y junction Wilkinson divider/combiner Circulator Hybrid junction Directional coupler Divider/combiner Multiplexer Multi-beam forming networks
frequency range a null reflection coefficient (G ¼ 0), and thus an input impedance equal to the reference impedance (Zc ¼ Z0 ). Matched loads are extensively and typically used when measuring the scattering parameters of microwave components, in order to realize the matching condition of those ports that are not connected to the source or to the measuring instrument. Matched terminations can be realized in lumped or distributed forms. An example of the latter category in rectangular waveguide technology is shown in Figure 7.1. The load is made of a slab of lossy material located at the centre of the rectangular waveguide (where the electric field of the dominant TE10 mode is maximum) and parallel to it. The slab is tapered in such a way as to create a discontinuity that is as smooth as possible within the maximum allowed length. Normally, the length of the slab is of the order of one guided wavelength. Distributed terminations have the advantage of producing very small reflections but are bulky. Lumped loads are simply realized with a layer of conducting material capable of absorbing the incident power. To minimize reflections, the conductivity of the material is chosen is such a way that the surface impedance is close to the wave impedance of the incident field. Figure 7.2 shows a lumped matched load in coaxial cable technology.
7.3 Movable short circuit A movable short circuit allows an arbitrary reactive load to be realized at the input of a waveguide section. The device consists of a metal sliding block terminating a waveguide stub, so realizing a short-circuited
Figure 7.1
Matched load in rectangular waveguide.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
Figure 7.2
189
Lumped matched load in coaxial cable.
stub whose length can be changed when operating with a micrometer plug. In rectangular waveguide technology, the sliding short can be realized through a sliding contact like that shown in Figure 7.3. The problem in the realization of such a device is that it should ensure the perfect closure of the currents flowing on the upper wall with those on the lower wall of the rectangular waveguide. This requires an excellent contact between the mobile leaf and the waveguide walls, but this would produce rapid wearing of the metal surfaces. To overcome such a difficulty, one has to resort to contactless plungers, such as that depicted in Figure 7.4a. The inner section of the plunger is in loose contact with the waveguide wall so as to realize, rather than a short circuit, a non-zero impedance ZS given by ZS ¼
RS 1 þ joCS RS
ð7:1Þ
Such an impedance results from the parallel contact resistance RS between the movable and fixed walls and the capacitance CS of the gap between them. In order to reduce the impedance seen from the waveguide end, the plunger is shaped in such a way as to realize two l/4 sections with impedances Za and Zb with Za Zb . Because of the well-known properties of l/4 sections, the input impedance is easily
Figure 7.3
Sliding short circuit.
190
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING λ/4
λ/4 micrometric screw
outer conductor inner conductor
(a)
Zs
Zin
Zin
sliding contact
λ/4
λ/4
Za
Zb
Zs
(b)
Figure 7.4
Two-section sliding plunger (a) and its equivalent circuit (b).
found to be Zin ¼
2 Za ZS Zb
ð7:2Þ
By choosing Zb ffi 10Za , a reduction of two orders of magnitudes in the impedance ZS can easily be realized.
7.4 Attenuators An attenuator is a two-port device used to reduce the amplitude of the input signal, ideally without reflections, thus with s11 ¼ 0. Attenuators may be fixed or variable and differ substantially one from each other depending on the technology adopted. Rectangular waveguide attenuators are realized by placing thin slabs of a lossy material along the E plane, thus parallel to the electric field of the dominant mode. The electric currents induced by virtue of Ohm’s law dissipate the EM energy into heat by the Joule effect, so reducing the power travelling along the guide. The variable attenuator in a rectangular waveguide is the rotary attenuator. It consists of a circular waveguide section, interposed within two rectangular waveguides and loaded with a thin slab of resistive material. The latter can be rotated around the longitudinal axis at different angles with respect to the electric field, so as to vary the quantity of dissipated power. It is apparent, in fact, that the power dissipated is maximum when the lossy slab is parallel to the electric field, and minimum when the slab is orthogonal to it. A detailed description of the rotary attenuator can be found in [4]. In microwave integrated circuits (MICs) attenuators may be realized in the form of T or P symmetrical resistive networks, as shown in Figure 7.5. Variable attenuation can be obtained using solid state devices such as PIN diodes or FETs whose resistance can be varied electronically. Let us consider the T attenuator. Its impedance matrix can be readily computed (see Section 4.6.1) as z11 z12 RT2 RT1 þ RT2 ¼ ð7:3Þ z21 z22 RT2 RT1 þ RT2
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
(a)
Figure 7.5
191
(b)
T (a) and P (b) resistive attenuators.
Using Table 4.1, we compute the scattering matrix:
s11 s21
s12 s22
^ T1 þ 2R ^ T2 1 ^ T2 ^ R 1 1 2R R T1 ¼ ^ T1 R ^ T2 ^ T1 þ 2R ^ T2 1 ð7:4Þ ^ T1 þ 1 R ^ T1 þ 2R ^ T2 þ 1 2R R R
where the symbol ^ indicates normalization with respect to the reference impedance Z0. Imposing the condition that the device must be matched at both ports, thus s11 ¼ s22 ¼ 0, we obtain the condition ^2 ^ T2 ¼ 1RT1 R ^ T1 2R
ð7:5Þ
Since both resistances must be non-negative, one can infer that ^ T1 1 or RT1 R0 R
ð7:6Þ
Using condition (7.5) in (7.4), we obtain for s21 ^ T1 1R ^ T1 1þR
ð7:7Þ
L ¼ 20 log10 ðs21 Þ
ð7:8Þ
s12 ¼ s21 ¼ From this equation we can evaluate the attenuation
as a function of the resistance RT1 . From the design point of view, we are interested in evaluating the resistance values for a prescribed attenuation. From (7.5), (7.7) and (7.8) we obtain s21 ¼ 10L=20 1s21 RT1 ¼ Z0 1 þ s21 2s21 RT2 ¼ Z0 1s221
ð7:9Þ
In a similar manner, using the admittance matrix we can obtain the synthesis formulae for the P attenuator: 1 þ s21 1s21 1s221 ¼ Z0 2s21
RP1 ¼ Z0 RP2
ð7:10Þ
192
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING substrate edge
microstrip RΠ1 (71.15 Ω)
1
2
(96.25 Ω) RΠ1
RΠ1
ground connection
3.7 mm
Figure 7.6 Layout of a microstrip attenuator in P configuration. The substrate is h ¼ 0.508 mm thick with dielectric constant er ¼ 9:9. -8
0
20 log10(|s21|)
-10
(8.7 GHz, -9.5 dB)
s11
-12
-20
-14
-30
-16
-40
-18
0
5
10
15
20 log10(|s11|)
s21
-10
-50 20
Frequency, GHz
Figure 7.7
Scattering parameters of the attenuator in Figure 7.6.
As an example, Figure 7.6 shows the layout of a P attenuator in microstrip line, designed to provide an attenuation of 10 dB. The resistors are realized with resistive films similar to the monolithic ones.1 The two resistors RP1 have been connected to ground by wrapping the back metallization around the substrate edge. The circuit response,2 shown in Figure 7.7, is affected by the parasitics associated with the resistors and the ground connection.3 The attenuation (nominally 10 dB) actually decreases with frequency, with a 1
See Section 14.3.3. See the Ansoft file 01_Attenuator.adsn. 3 See again Section 14.3.3. 2
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
a1 Figure 7.8
[S]
b2 = a1e-jθ
S
0 e
e
jθ
193
jθ
0
Two-port representation of an ideal phase shifter.
maximum deviation from the nominal 10 dB attenuation of slightly more than 2 dB at 20 GHz, while the deviation from the nominal value is less than 0.5 dB below 8.7 GHz. As the frequency increases, the matching also deteriorates: nominally infinite, the return loss is only 12 dB at 20 GHz. By replacing the resistors with variable-resistance diodes one can realize a continuously (or analogue) variable attenuation. As an alternative, digital attenuators can be made using various attenuating cells cascaded one after the other and connected via switched lines.4
7.5 Fixed phase shifters The phase shifter is a two-port device used to produce either a fixed or controllable phase shift to the input signal. Phase shifters are used in a variety of communication and radar systems. They are essential components in antenna systems and phased arrays, where the radiating elements must be fed with appropriate phases so as to create the required radiated beam. In general, fixed phase shifters can potentially become variable phase shifters by replacing some fixed reactances with electronically tunable ones. In this section we give only a brief account of fixed phase shift networks, the variable phase shifters being discussed in Section 10.4. The reader is referred to it for more detailed information. In the ideal case, a phase shifter can be defined as a two-port device perfectly matched (s11 ¼ s22 ¼ 0) and without loss (thus js21 j ¼ js12 j ¼ 1), where the output signal undergoes a prescribed phase shift Df with respect to a given reference. The two-port schematic and the scattering matrix of an ideal phase shifter are shown in Figure 7.8. The phase shift of the output signal is usually evaluated with reference to the phase shift of a line section of equal length as the device. Let l be the length of such a line section and b its phase constant; the phase shift is thus evaluated as Df ¼ ybl
ð7:11Þ
Depending on the frequency behaviour of Dfð f Þ, there are two fundamental types of phase shifters: .
The true-phase phase shifter, whose Dfðf Þ is constant with frequency.
.
The true-time-delay or TTD phase shifter, whose Dfðf Þ varies linearly with frequency, so that the device behaves as a delay line.
Depending on the circuit typology, we can have transmission or reflection phase shifters. In the former the phase shift is produced by the transmission of the signal through the device, while in the latter one exploits the phase shift produced by the reflection from a reactive load. We now consider the various typologies.
7.5.1
Loaded-line phase shifters
As shown in Figure 7.9a, the loaded-line architecture consists of a transmission line with characteristic impedance Zc and electrical length y loaded at both ends with identical parallel admittances that can switched between two different states. Let the admittances be Yi ¼ Gi þ jBi where i ¼ 1, 2 denotes the two possible load states. Switching between the two states produces a phase shift in the RF signal travelling 4
See Section 10.3.
194
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
θ
Yi
1
Zc
Yi
L
C/2
(a)
2 C/2
(b)
Figure 7.9
Loaded-line phase shifter (a) and a lumped element realization (b).
along the line. This phase shifter is attractive because of its simplicity of fabrication, but it gives rise to a mismatch that increases with the phase shift required. As a consequence, this configuration is usually limited to applications that require small phase shifts. Figure 7.9b shows the lumped element version of a loaded-line phase shifter. This circuit can be considered asffi a lumped element approximation pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffi of a transmission line length of characteristic impedance ZC ¼ L=C and propagation delay t ¼ LC. This architecture therefore realizes a TTD phase shifter.
7.5.2
Reflection-type phase shifters
To illustrate the behaviour of a reflection-type phase shifter, we use a specific example. Consider a grounded variable capacitor C seen from a reference line of characteristic impedance Z0. The reflection coefficient G¼
^ 1joC ¼ e jf ; ^ 1 þ joC
^ j ¼ 2 tan1 ðoCÞ
ð7:12Þ
^ ¼ CZ0 . The phase is unitary in amplitude and has a phase j depending on the normalized capacitance C difference between the reflected and the incident waves can therefore vary from 0 for zero capacitance (thus when the load is an open circuit) to 180 in the limit when the capacitance becomes infinite (so realizing a short circuit). A phase shifter can thus be obtained using a 90 hybrid junction (see Section 7.7.2) for separating the incident from the reflected signal as shown in the schematic of Figure 7.10. The direct and coupled ports of the coupler are terminated with two identical reactances. If such reactances can be varied simultaneously by a control signal, a tunable phase shifter is obtained. As shown in Section 7.7.2, the signal incident on port 1 is split between port 2 (direct port) and port 3 (coupled port) with equal amplitudes and 90 phase shift. The same behaviour is shown, apart from the relevant index changes, for signals entering the other ports. As a consequence, the signals reflected back into the hybrid junction by the two equal loads at ports 2 and 3 will cancel at port 1 (since they arrive there 180 out of phase) while they sum at port 4 (where they arrive in phase). Depending on the values of the reactances, 1
2 1
4
0°
0° 90° hybrid junction
90° 90° 2
3
jX
Figure 7.10
jX
Schematic of the reflection-type phase shifter.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
195
thus on their reflection coefficients G, the output signal (port 4 of the hybrid junction) undergoes a phase shift j, according to Equation (7.12).
7.6 Junctions and interconnections At low frequencies the interconnections between the components of an electric circuit are normally so small compared with the wavelength that they can be considered as infinitesimal points with no dimensions. At microwave frequencies, on the contrary, the interconnections between physical elements have finite sizes that involve time delay (in the time domain) and phase shift (in the frequency domain) phenomena. In addition, any discontinuity produces local distortions of the EM field distribution. Such distortions can be seen as due to the excitation of higher order modes; they are associated with the storage of reactive energy and, from a circuit point of view, can be modelled as lumped reactances. For the above reasons, even the simplest junction between different transmission lines should properly and accurately be designed in order to minimize unavoidable mismatch and reflections. In all cases one needs to be able to model such reactive phenomena in order to possibly compensate for them. In other cases, as we have mentioned in Chapter 4, reactive phenomena associated with discontinuities are intentionally used to realize specific circuit elements such as inductances or capacitances that, at high frequencies, cannot be realized using conventional geometries. Let us first consider conventional guiding structures such as the coaxial cable or the waveguide. The simplest junction is that between lines with equal geometries but filled with different dielectric materials. The abrupt change of dielectric filling does not alter the cross-sectional distribution of the electric and magnetic fields but only the wave impedance, thus the characteristic impedance, and the phase constant, thus the wavelength and the phase velocity5. Consider a coaxial cable filled with a material of dielectric constant er connected to an identical but empty cable. This type of discontinuity is encountered in coaxial connectors. Since both the characteristic pffiffiffiffi impedance and the wavelength are inversely proportional to er , removal of the dielectric produces an increase of both quantities by the same factor. Assuming that the cable is matched or infinitely long, the discontinuity will produce a reflection coefficient pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffi er 1 11= er G¼ ð7:13Þ pffiffiffiffi ¼ pffiffiffiffi 1 þ 1= er er þ 1 The same problem may arise in the case of a waveguide, e.g. a rectangular waveguide. In such a case, pffiffiffiffi however, the phase constant is not simply proportional to er but depends on the dielectric constant according to the following expression which is valid for the dominant TE10 mode (see (3.133)): qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi kz ¼ o m0 e0 er 1ð fc10 = f Þ2 where fc10 ¼
1 c pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ pffiffiffiffi 2a m0 e 2a er
Removal of the dielectric thus also produces an increase in the cut-off frequency. For suitable values of the frequency and of the waveguide width a it may be that in the empty waveguide the mode is below cut-off, thus evanescent. In such a case, total reflection is produced (jGj ¼ 1). In many practical cases one needs to join cables or waveguides with different cross-sections, as shown by the examples in Figure 7.11. In contrast to the simple dielectric discontinuity that does not alter 5 The two-dimensional boundary value problem associated with computation of the waveguide modes depends on the geometry of the metal boundaries and does not include the dielectric material, as long as the latter uniformly fills the waveguide cross-section. The dielectric constant arises when determining the phase constant kz . See Section 3.2.
196
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.11 Junctions between cables and guides of different cross-sections: (a) step in the inner conductor of a coaxial cable; (b) E plane step in a rectangular waveguide; (c) symmetrical H plane step in a rectangular waveguide. the cross-section, thus the EM field distribution, the step discontinuity gives rise to excitation of higher order modes, which are normally below cut-off. This produces the storage of reactive energy in the proximity of metal edges. Such energy is mainly of electric (or magnetic) type when the electric (or magnetic) field is perpendicular to the edge. Indeed the normal components of the EM field become exceedingly large at very close distances from the metal edge.6 This is why the equivalent circuit contains a capacitor in the first two cases of Figure 7.11 and an inductor in the case of the H plane step – recall the field distributions of the TEM mode in the coaxial cable and that of the TE10 mode in the rectangular waveguide. In the case of the H plane step, one has also to consider that the change in the waveguide width implies a change in the cut-off frequency, with the same possible consequences as for the dielectric step, i.e. that the field is evanescent in the narrower section. One has also to keep in mind that the any step 6
For a detailed description of the phenomena occurring at metal edges see [5, 6].
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
197
Figure 7.12 Rectangular waveguide H plane (a) and E plane (b) junctions and their respective equivalent circuits. discontinuity implies a change in the characteristic impedance, as highlighted in the equivalent circuits of Figure 7.11. In many microwave circuits one needs to join together two or more transmission lines. There are clearly many different configurations. For a rectangular waveguide, typically there are the T junctions, where one branch waveguide is inserted orthogonally to a main waveguide, either in the E or H plane. Correspondingly, we have the E and H plane T junctions shown in Figure 7.12 along with their equivalent circuits. Note that the E plane junction corresponds to the series connection of the branch line, while the H plane junction corresponds to the shunt connection. This is easily understood by focusing attention on the waveguide longitudinal currents, which flow at the centre of the wider waveguide walls. In order to reduce the mismatch, and thus the reflections that a simple junction produces, suitable metal elements (posts, diaphragms, wedges, etc.) can be inserted in the junction region to compensate for the reactances associated with the discontinuity. In a similar fashion, also for printed circuits, such as striplines, mictrostrips, coplanar waveguides, etc., many different junctions and discontinuities are present. Two examples in microstrip line are shown in Figure 7.13.
Figure 7.13
Symmetrical step discontinuity (a) and T junction in mictrostrip line (b) [7].
198
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Besides the junctions between guiding structures of different sizes, great importance has been attached to the so-called transitions, i.e. the junctions between transmission lines of different technologies, such as the interconnections of waveguide to coaxial cable, waveguide to microstrip, microstrip to coaxial cable, microstrip to CPW, etc. Such interconnections (coax connectors can be numbered among them) are necessary in order to join portions of circuits made with different technologies, as typically occurs in the measurement or testing of components. The transitions between lines with totally different configurations, such as a rectangular waveguide and a microstrip line, generally require complicated analyses in order to identify suitable transition geometries capable of transferring the signal from one line to the other with minimum power loss in the given frequency band. Because of the practically unlimited variety of possible solutions, no general criteria can be provided here to help identify such geometries, except that the transition has gradually to convert the field configuration of the dominant mode of one line into that of the other line. Once again we will limit our attention to a few examples that can at least provide an idea of the problems involved.
7.6.1
Guide-to-coaxial cable transition
The transition from a rectangular waveguide to a coaxial cable (sometimes called adapter) is necessary in many practical applications, specifically for measuring waveguide components in a coaxial cable measuring environment. The coupling between the waveguide TE10 mode and the coax TEM mode occurs by extending the cable’s inner conductor into the waveguide. The former can be placed parallel to the E field of the waveguide in order to maximize the interaction between the current flowing in the conductor and the E field of the waveguide. This is the voltage probe depicted in Figure 7.14a. As an alternative, the central conductor can be folded into a ring shape so as to couple with the magnetic field, creating a current probe as depicted in Figure 7.14b. The length of the conductor and its distance from the waveguide wall must be determined in such a way as to optimize the matching, thus maximizing the power transfer from one to the other guiding structure. Accurate design of the transition requires the use of numerical techniques to account for the thickness of the probe, the
(a) voltage probe
(b) current probe
y
y
z
O
x
x
y
O z
Figure 7.14
z
O
y
x
O
x
z
Geometries of the waveguide-to-coax transitions: (a) voltage probe; (b) current probe.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS 0
199
15
-1
10
-2
5
-3
0
-4
-5
-5
-10
-6
-15
s11
-7 -8 15
10 log10(|s11|)
10 log10(|s21|)
s21
-20 20
25
30
35
-25 40
Frequency, GHz
Figure 7.15 Measured scattering parameters of a pair of WR-28-to-coax transitions (both input and output are in coaxial cable).
possible presence of dielectric coating, and other tiny details. A simplified theoretical approach, though not extremely accurate, is presented later in this section. For a more accurate numerical analysis the reader is referred to [8]. As an example of a practical result, Figure 7.15 shows the frequency response of a pair of transitions of the voltage probe type between a coaxial cable and a WR-28 rectangular waveguide. The latter operates in the Ka band, 26.4–40 GHz, has a 7.112 mm 3.556 mm cross-section and fc ¼ 21.08 GHz cut-off frequency. As can be seen, the transition shows a broad-band behaviour with an insertion loss of the order of 0.1–0.2 dB reaching a maximum of about 0.4 dB at the upper frequency edge (the measured values refer to a pair of transitions). The reader should note that at frequencies below the operating frequencies of the waveguide, the return loss is not exactly zero but swings around the zero level assuming positive values also. This of course does not mean that this is an active device, it is simply due to the directivity error of the scalar network analyzer, as discussed in Section 17.6.
From a modelling point of view, the interconnection between a coaxial cable and a waveguide can be treated in a general way as the excitation of a waveguide by a current source.7 To focus the problem, let us assume that a known (or ‘impressed’) current density Ji is present in the waveguide portion between z1 and z2 as sketched in Figure 7.16. The current will excite waveguide modes propagating in the positive z direction for z > z2 and modes propagating in the negative z direction for z < z1. To simplify the formulation and reduce the number of equations, we will use the superscript ‘ þ ’ for the fields in z z2 and ‘’ for the fields in z z1. Using the expansions (3.106) with Vn ðzÞ ¼ Vnþ ejkzn z for z z2 or Vn ðzÞ ¼ Vn ejkzn z for z z1, the EM field can be expressed as
7
The theory presented here follows that in [4] with some small changes.
200
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.16
E t ¼
Excitation of a waveguide by a current source.
1 1 X X Vn ðzÞetn ðx; yÞ ¼ Vn etn ðx; yÞe jkzn z n¼0
n¼0
1 1 X X Vn ^z etn ðx; yÞe jkzn z H In ðzÞhtn ðx; yÞ ¼ t ¼ Zzn n¼0 n¼0
Ez
1 1 2 X 1 X ktn 2 ¼ ktn In ðzÞTnTM ðx; yÞ ¼ j V þ T TM ðx; yÞe jkzn z j oe n¼0 k n n n¼0 zn
Hz ¼
ð7:14Þ
1 1 1 X 1 X 2 ktn Vn ðzÞTnTE ðx; yÞ ¼ k2 V þ T TE ðx; yÞe jkzn z j om n¼0 j om n¼0 tn n n
We have used the superscripts ‘TM’ and ‘TE’ to indicate that the corresponding potential is relative to TM or TE modes, respectively. The above expressions can be put in the simpler form E ¼
1 X ðetn ezn ÞVn e jkzn z n¼0
H ¼
1 X 1 ^z etn þ hzn Vn e jkzn z Zzn n¼0
ð7:15Þ
with ezn ¼ ^z
2 jktn T TM ðx; yÞ kzn n
k2 hzn ¼ ^z tn TnTE ðx; yÞ j om
ð7:16Þ
Notice that the series in (7.15), as far as the z components are concerned, involve only TM or TE terms, respectively. Let us now apply Lorentz’s reciprocity theorem (2.76) to the volume bounded by the crosssections at z ¼ z1 and z ¼ z2 and by the waveguide side walls. We use as the field E1, H1 that radiated
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
201
by Ji, i.e. the field (7.15), and as the field E2, H2 that of the nth waveguide mode for z z1: E2 ¼ ðetn ezn Þe jkzn z 1 ^z etn þ hzn e jkzn z H2 ¼ Zzn
ð7:17Þ
Since no current is associated with the waveguide mode (J2 ¼ 0), the expression of Lorentz’s theorem (2.76) in this case becomes þ ð ðE H2 E2 H Þ dS ¼ Ji E2 dV ð7:18Þ S
V
The surface integral on the l.h.s. of (7.18) vanishes on the waveguide side walls (since the tangential electric field is zero). Moreover, since the modes are orthogonal, only the nth terms in the expansions (7.15) of E and H give a non-zero contribution. Therefore, the surface integral reduces to the two cross-sections at z ¼ z1 and z ¼ z2. Using (7.14) and (7.17) in (7.18), it is immediately found that the integral over the cross-section at z ¼ z1 is also zero, so that the only remaining term of the surface integral is ð ð 2 þ 2 þ ðE H2 E2 H Þ dS ¼ Vn etn ð^z etn Þ ^z dS ¼ V ð7:19Þ Zzn Zzn n S2 S2 where we have taken into account that etn ð^z etn Þ ^z ¼ etn etn and used the orthonormalization property of the vectors etn . We can now compute the amplitude Vnþ of the nth mode for z z2. Inserting (7.19) into (7.18) and using (7.17), we obtain ð Zzn jkzn z2 Ji ðetn ezn Þ dV ð7:20Þ e Vnþ ¼ 2 V In much the same way, if we choose for E2, H2 the forward propagating mode in the region z > z2, we obtain ð Zzn jkzn z1 Ji ðetn þ ezn Þ dV ð7:21Þ e Vn ¼ 2 V Let us now apply the above formulae to characterize the voltage probe, sketched in Figure 7.14a. Under the assumption that the probe radius is very small compared with the wavelength, we can approximate the current density as a straight linear filament of zero thickness, parallel to y, extending into the waveguide by a length h, as schematically shown in Figure 7.17. That is, Ji ¼ ^y
I0 sin½b0 ðhyÞdðxa=2ÞdðzlÞ A
ð7:22Þ
where I0 is the total current flowing through the cross-sectional area A of the wire, b0 is the free space phase constant and d is the Dirac delta function. The probe is assumed to have a sinusoidal current distribution, the current obviously being zero at the end y ¼ h of the probe. Since the current is directed along y, (7.20) shows that only the y component of etn is involved. We observe, however, that in contrast to Figure 7.16, the waveguide is terminated at z ¼ 0 with a conducting wall. To take into account the presence of the metal wall, whose effect is to create a zero tangential electric field in z ¼ 0, we simply add a second current source in z ¼ l having the opposite sign. This additional source is the image of the real source and has the effect of creating the same boundary condition in z ¼ 0 as the electric wall. To include the effect of the electric wall we simply replace (7.22) with Ji ¼ ^y
I0 sin½b0 ðhyÞdðxa=2Þ½dðzlÞdðz þ lÞ A
ð7:23Þ
202
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.17 Modelling the voltage probe of Figure 7.14a. Using the expressions in Table 3.4 for rectangular waveguide modes, to be denoted by the pair of indexes m, n instead of just n, we obtain ð Zzmn I0 mp mp jkzmn l jkzmn l h npy þ Vmn ¼ e sin½b0 ðhyÞ cos Cmn sin e dy 2 a 2 b 0 ð7:24Þ ðh mp mp npy sin sinðkzmn lÞ sin½b0 ðhyÞ cos dy ¼ jZzmn I0 Cmn a 2 b 0 For the TE10 mode, the integral in (7.24) is ðh
sin½b0 ðhyÞdy ¼
0
1cosðb0 hÞ b0
ð7:25Þ
and (7.25) becomes p 1cosðb0 hÞ þ V10 ¼ jZz10 I0 C10 sinðkz10 lÞ a b0
ð7:26Þ
The electric field of the dominant mode is then found to be Eyþ ¼ V10þ ey10 ejkz10 z ¼ 2j
Zz10 I0 1cosðb0 hÞ px jkz10 z sin e sinðkz10 lÞ ab b0 a
ð7:27Þ
The higher order mode amplitudes can also be computed using (7.23). For n 6¼ 0 the integral in (7.24) is ðh
sin½b0 ðhyÞcos
0
npy np=b n ph cos hÞ dy ¼ 2 cosðb 0 b b b0 ðnp=bÞ2
ð7:28Þ
and the voltage expansion coefficients become þ ¼ j Zzmn I0 Cmn Vmn
mp np=b n ph cos hÞ sinðkzmn lÞ 2 cosðb 0 a b b0 ðnp=bÞ2
ð7:29Þ
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
203
In the computation of the EM field of the higher order modes, we may assume that the frequency is such that they are all below cut-off, thus evanescent. In this case, the propagation constants kzmn are imaginary and so are the wave impedances Zzmn. We are going no further into that, since, for simplicity, we are interested here in the dominant mode; this means that we are going to consider only the real power radiated into the waveguide, while the reactive power is associated with the evanescent modes. The real power transported by the fundamental mode is simply computed as follows: P¼
ð ð ð 1 1 a b
þ
2 Z I2 2 Eyþ Hxþ * dS ¼
Ey dx dy ¼ z10 20 ð1cosðb0 hÞÞ sin2 ðkz10 lÞ 2 2Zz10 0 0 abb0
ð7:30Þ
S
The current at the base of the probe (y ¼ 0) is I0 sinb0 h. The real part of the input impedance seen from the coaxial cable can be computed8 as Rin ¼
2P jI0 sin b0 hj2
¼
2Zz10 2 b0 h 2 tan sin ðkz10 lÞ 2 abb20
ð7:31Þ
It is worth noting that the input resistance depends on the various geometrical parameters, in particular the length h of the probe and its distance l from the end wall. Such parameters must be chosen so as to optimize the matching of the waveguide with the cable, i.e. to make the input resistance equal to the characteristic impedance of the cable and to minimize the input reactance. The latter can be evaluated, as mentioned earlier, by computing the reactive energy associated with higher order modes. Such a computation is omitted for brevity.
7.6.2
Coaxial-to-microstrip transition
This is also a transition of practical importance, necessary for the measurement of microstrip circuits. The quasi-TEM nature of the field in the microstrip makes the geometry of the transition almost natural, since it consists of connecting the cable’s central conductor to the microstrip conductor and the cable’s outer conductor to the microstrip ground plane. The in-line configuration is the most common one, though in some applications other geometries, for instance with the cable perpendicular to the microstrip, may be necessary. A pair of in-line transitions in back-to-back position is shown in Figure 7.18. The inner conductor is overlapped and soldered to a portion of the microstrip and suitably shaped in order to reduce the discontinuity. Note the metal flanges supporting the coaxial cable. Figure 7.19 shows the measured frequency behaviour of such a double transition. The performance looks good in a quite broad band, but starts deteriorating above 10 GHz, in agreement with the electromagnetic simulations. The ripple in s11 is due to the internal reflections within the microstrip section comprised between the transitions. The periodicity of the ripple would thus change with the length of the microstrip section.
8
See Equation (5.3). In computing expression (7.31) we have used the following equality: ð1cosaÞ2 ð1cosaÞ2 1cosa a ¼ ¼ ¼ tan2 1cos2 a 1 þ cosa 2 sin2 a
204
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.18 A pair of coax-to-microstrip transitions.
0
0.0
s21
-5
measured simulated
10 log10(|s21|)
-1.0
-10 -15
-1.5
-20
-2.0
s11
-2.5
-25
-3.0
-30
-3.5
-35
-4.0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
10 log10(|s11|)
-0.5
-40
Frequency, GHz
Figure 7.19 Response of a pair of back-to-back coax-to-microstrip transitions.
7.7 Dividers and combiners The linear combination of different signals or, conversely, the subdivision of a signal into different components is normal practice in analogue signal processing at RFs. It should be stressed that division and combining are linear operations, not to be confused with mixing and frequency conversion, which are treated in Chapter 13. Due to the reciprocity, a combiner behaves also as a divider by interchanging outputs with input. They are therefore treated as a unique subject. There is an ample variety of circuits and devices that can be used as dividers and combiners. They also have a variety of names, such as combiner, splitter (divider), hybrid, hybrid junction, directional coupler, with some terminological uncertainties. Here we consider the Wilkinson divider, the hybrid junction (or simply the hybrid) and the directional coupler, but with a word of warning that there is some overlap between the last two categories.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
7.7.1
205
The Wilkinson divider
Due to Wilkinson’s ingenuity, the device he invented [9] is universally known as the Wilkinson power divider or Wilkinson splitter/combiner. In its simplest version it is a three-port circuit capable of splitting the power incident form port 1 into two equal output signals from ports 2 and 3. Conversely, due to the use of a resistor placed between ports 2 and 3, those ports are uncoupled (s23 ¼ 0) so that a signal possibly reflected from an unmatched load at one of those ports does not affect the other port. Figure 7.20 shows the circuit schematic and the layout of the microstrip realization of a two-way Wilkinson divider.9 It consists of two l=4 sections of impedance Zc , connected at one end at port 1; at the other ends (ports 2 and 3), they are connected together through the resistor R. By cascading N levels of Wilkinson dividers, 2N -way dividers can be realized, as in the example of Figure 7.21, which shows an eight-way divider. Inspection of Figure 7.20 reveals that the device is matched at port 1 when pffiffiffi Zc ¼ Z0 2
substrate edge
Zc = /2, /4
1
(a)
ð7:32Þ
2
2 Z0 2
R = 2 Z0
7 mm
1
3
3
2 microstrip transmission lines 1 (b)
1 3
(c)
RF ports film resistors
Figure 7.20 Wilkinson divider: (a) schematic; (b) electrical symbol; (c) layout of a microstrip realization (h ¼ 0.58 mm, er ¼ 9:9).
9 More complicated versions have been developed in order to achieve unequal divisions, or to widen the operational bandwidth by the use of multi-section outputs.
206
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 2
3
4
5 1 6
7
8
9
Figure 7.21
An eight-way power divider using two-way Wilkinson dividers.
In fact, the input impedance at port 1 when ports 2 and 3 are matched (i.e. terminated on the reference impedance) is the parallel of two l=4 Zc sections terminated with Z0 (for symmetry reasons the resistor plays no role), i.e. Zin ¼
1 Zc2 2 Z0
ð7:33Þ
Equation (7.32) follows from the matching condition Zin ¼ Z0 . It can also be shown that the condition for matching at ports 2 and 3 (s22 ¼ s33 ¼ 0) is R ¼ 2Z0
ð7:34Þ
When the matching conditions are satisfied at the frequency when the line sections are l/4 long (thus the electrical lengths are p=2), the Wilkinson divider has the following scattering matrix: 2 0 j 4 ½S ¼ pffiffiffi 1 2 1
3 1 1 0 05 0 0
ð7:35Þ
This expression shows that the device is matched at all ports (s11 ¼ s22 ¼ s33 ¼ 0) and that ports 2 and 3 are uncoupled (s23 ¼ 0). The signal entering in port 1 is equally split between ports 2 and 3, undergoing equal phase shifts of10p=2. Figure 7.22 shows the frequency response11 of the Wilkinson divider of Figure 7.20. Notice that the loss has the effect of increasing the insertion loss above the 3 dB predicted theoretically. The device nevertheless ensures a matching and isolation better than 14 dB over a 40% bandwidth. 10 11
Remember that ejp=2 ¼ j. See the Ansoft file 02_Wilkinson_Divider.adsn.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
-3
20
s21 = s31
10
-4
0
-5
-10 s11
s22=s33
-6
-20
s32 -7 8
Figure 7.22
9
10 Frequency, GHz
11
-30 12
20 log10(|s11|), 20 log10(|s32|), 20 log10(|s22|)
20 log10(|s21|) = 20 log10(|s31|)
-2
207
Response of the Wilkinson divider of Figure 7.20.
Computation of the scattering matrix As a result of symmetry, the scattering matrix (7.35) can be computed by reducing the analysis to two two-port circuits. With reference to Figure 7.23, a symmetry plane can be identified cutting the input line 1 and the resistor R into two halves. The input line can be decomposed as the parallel of two lines of impedance 2Z0 , and the resistor as the series of two resistors of value R=2. Any excitation of the circuit can then be decomposed into an even and an odd mode; correspondingly, the signals at ports 2 and 3 have the same amplitudes and equal or opposite phases respectively. Consider the even excitation first. The symmetry plane behaves as a magnetic wall, i.e. an open circuit. The device reduces to that of Figure 7.23b. The resistance R does not appear as no current flows through it. In the odd mode, the symmetry plane is equivalent to a zero-voltage plane, so that port 1 and the centre of the resistor R are grounded.12 The relevant circuit is shown in Figure 7.23c. Let us now consider both circuits. For simplicity we limit the analysis at the centre frequency, when the line is l=4 long. Even mode Because of the property of quarter-wavelength lines, the matching condition occurs when the line impedance is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffi Zc ¼ 2Z0 Z0 ¼ Z0 2 This condition is the same as (7.32). The scattering matrix of a matched line section of electrical length y ¼ p=2 is simply h i 0 j SðeÞ ¼ ð7:36Þ j 0 where the superscript ‘e’ stands for even. Odd mode With reference to Figure 7.23c, the short circuit at port 1 is transformed by the quarter-wavelength line into an open circuit at port 2. The latter is matched when R ¼ 2Z0 , hence Equation (7.34). The 12
The centre of the resistor R may be considered as an unused fourth port of the device.
208
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 2 Z0 2
1
symmetry plan
R 2 Z0
(a) 3
2 Z0
Z0
2 Z0 2
2
2 Z0
2 Z0
1
R/2
1 (b) even
Figure 7.23
Z0
(c) odd
The symmetric Wilkinson divider (a) can be split into its even (b) and odd (c) parts.
scattering matrix can easily be computed by observing that port 1 is short-circuited, thus s11 ¼ 1, and the two ports are decoupled, thus s12 ¼ s21 ¼ 0, while port 2 is matched, thus s22 ¼ 0. In conclusion, the scattering matrix of the odd mode is h i 1 0 ð7:37Þ SðoÞ ¼ 0 0 where the subscript ‘o’ stands for odd. Note that [S(o)] is not unitary (see (4.93)); indeed the circuit is lossy because of the presence of the resistor R/2. We now have all the necessary information to reconstruct the scattering matrix in the general case of arbitrary excitation by superimposing the even and odd mode excitations, i.e. by expressing the wave amplitudes at the three ports in terms of their even and odd components. Recalling that only the even mode is present on input line 1 and that this line is split into the parallel of two lines of impedance 2Z0 , each carrying one-half of the total power, the incident and reflected waves a1 and b1 are related to the even mode wave amplitudes by pffiffiffi pffiffiffi a1 ¼ a1e 2; b1 ¼ b1e 2 ð7:38Þ For ports 2 and 3 we simply have a2 ¼ a2e þ a2o ;
a3 ¼ a2e a2o
b2 ¼ b2e þ b2o ;
b3 ¼ b2e b2o
ð7:39Þ
Using (7.38) and (7.39), we obtain the outgoing wave amplitudes of the device: b a a þ a3 p1ffiffiffi ¼ b1e ¼ s11e a1e þ s12e a2e ¼ s11e p1ffiffiffi þ s12e 2 2 2 2 a1 a2 þ a3 a2 a3 þ s22o b2 ¼ b2e þ b2o ¼ s21e a1e þ s22e a2e þ s22o a2o ¼ s21e pffiffiffi þ s22e 2 2 2 a1 a2 þ a3 a2 a3 s22o b3 ¼ b2e b2o ¼ s21e a1e þ s22e a2e s22o a2o ¼ s21e pffiffiffi þ s22e 2 2 2 Using (7.36) and (7.37), we then obtain the scattering matrix (7.35).
ð7:40Þ
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
209
Figure 7.24 The hybrid ring (or rat-race) (a) and its electrical scheme (b). Reproduced with kind permission of Verigy Germany GmbH.
7.7.2
Hybrid junctions
A hybrid junction or simply a hybrid is a four-port passive component originally conceived in telephony applications in order to employ just one pair of wires in both transmit and receive modes [10]. One port can be internally terminated on a matched load so that the device looks like a three-port rather than a fourport circuit. As a hybrid junction we define (the technical terminology is not consistent throughout the literature) a four-port component with the following properties: 1. All ports are matched (sii ¼ 0, i ¼ 1. . .4). 2. At least one port is isolated from the input port 1 (s14 ¼ 0, if port 4 is the isolated port). pffiffiffi 3. The input power is equally split between the two remaining outputs (js12 j ¼ js13 j ¼ 1= 2). For lossless symmetrical devices, the phase difference between output signals at ports 2 and 3, normally 90 or 180 , characterizes the hybrid junction, so that one usually speaks of 90 or 180 hybrid junctions.13 A typical 180 hybrid is the hybrid ring or rat-race shown in Figure 7.24 along with its electrical scheme. It consists of a closed loop (a circle or other shapes are allowed) 3l=2 long; the ports are located pffiffiffi l/4 from each other. To ensure matching, the characteristic impedance of the ring must be equal to Z0 2, Z0 being the reference impedance. The input signal from port 1 is equally divided between the two half branches of the ring.14 Both portions of the signal reach the other three ports along different paths, thus different phases: they sum at port 2 (both paths are 3l=4 long) and port 4 (the paths are l=4 and l þ l=4 long) but they cancel out at port 3 (the two paths are l=2 and l long, respectively) so that port 3 is isolated from port 1. Moreover, since ports 2 and 4 are 180 out of phase (their distance is l=2) the rat-race is a 180 hybrid. Similarly, it can be seen that ports 2 and 4 are isolated from each other and are in phase when the device is fed from port 3. As a consequence, when two signals enter the rat-race at ports 1 and 3, their sum will appear at port 4 and the difference will appear at port 2. Ports 4 and 2 are therefore indicated as the sum (S) and difference (D) ports, respectively. The Wilkinson divider can be considered as a 0 hybrid, port 4 being the centre of the resistor R. See footnote 12. This qualitative discussion assumes, to a first approximation, that the power absorbed by each port is so small that it negligibly affects the amplitudes of the waves travelling along the ring. 13 14
210
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 12 mm
2
4
20 log10(|s41|) = 20 log10(|s21|)
1
-2
10
s21
-3
s41
0
-4 -10 -5 -20
s11 s31
3
-6
microstrip transmission lines 4
20
8
9
10
11
20 log10(|s11|), 20 log10(|s31|)
substrate edge
-30 12
Frequency, GHz
RF ports
Figure 7.25 Layout and frequency response of a microstrip rat-race. The dielectric substrate is alumina, h ¼ 0:508 mm thick, with er ¼ 9:9. Reproduced with kind permission of Verigy Germany GmbH.
Notice that the device is symmetrical with respect to a plane passing through the middle of ports 2 and 3. As a consequence, the roles of ports 1 and 2, and 4 and 3, can be interchanged. A full analysis of the device can be carried out by exploiting this symmetry. At the centre frequency when the ring length is 3l=2, the scattering matrix can easily be computed as 3 2 0 1 0 1 7 j 6 6 1 0 1 0 7 ð7:41Þ ½S ¼ pffiffiffi 6 7 1 0 15 24 0 1 0 1 0 The usual operating bandwidth of the rat-race is around 20%. Figure 7.25 shows the microstrip layout of a rat-race along with its frequency response.15 Although the rat-race configuration can also be used in rectangular waveguide technology, another type of hybrid junction is usually employed, the so-called hybrid T or magic T. Its geometry is shown in Figure 7.26. Seen from port 1, it consists of an H plane T junction plus an additional E plane T junction. The device’s symmetry with respect to the middle of the guides 1 and 4 allows one to infer its fundamental features. Recalling the field distribution of the dominant TE10 mode of the rectangular waveguide, it is apparent that ports 1 and 4 are isolated (s14 ¼ s41 ¼ 0). The former port indeed has the electric field parallel to the symmetry plane, which thus behaves as a magnetic wall (even symmetry), while port 4 has the field perpendicular to the symmetry plane, which thus behaves as an electric wall (odd symmetry). Less evident is the fact that ports 2 and 3 also are isolated. This condition occurs, in fact, as we will see below, at the condition when ports 1 and 4 are matched. For symmetry reasons, it also appears that s12 ¼ s13 and s22 ¼ s33 ; moreover, the electric field of waveguide 4 is seen from ports 2 and 3 with opposite phases, thus s24 ¼ s34 . Such considerations do not ensure that the device is a hybrid junction, since we also need to impose that the ports are matched. This can be realized in practice by inserting properly shaped metal posts or sheets within the junction in such a way to compensate for the unwanted reactances and ensure the matching of ports 1 and 4, so that s11 ¼ s44 ¼ 0. 15
See the Ansoft file 03_Rat_Race.adsn.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
Figure 7.26
211
The magic T. Reproduced with kind permission of Verigy Germany GmbH.
From these considerations, the scattering matrix of the 2 0 s12 s12 6s s 6 12 22 s23 ½S ¼ 6 4 s12 s23 s22 0 s24 s24
magic T is therefore 3 0 s24 7 7 7 s24 5
ð7:42Þ
0
taking into account the reciprocity of the device (sij ¼ sji ). If we finally assume that the device is lossless, then the scattering matrix
2 be unitary (see Equation (4.93)). In particular, the elements of each row P
must of (7.42) must satisfy sij ¼ 1. Therefore: pffiffiffi 1. For the first and fourth rows we deduce that js12 j ¼ js24 j ¼ 1= 2. 2. Using the previous result, for the second row we obtain js22 j2 þ js23 j2 ¼ 0, thus s22 ¼ s23 ¼ 0. We conclude that ports 2 and 3 also are isolated and matched. For simplicity, we may choose the reference planes at ports 1 and 4 in such a way that s12 and s14 are real.16 The scattering matrix of the magic T can thus be written in the form 3 2 0 1 1 0 7 6 1 7 1 61 0 0 7 ½S ¼ pffiffiffi 6 ð7:43Þ 1 7 26 5 41 0 0 0 1 1 0
7.7.3
Directional couplers
A close relative of the hybrid junction is the directional coupler, one of the most useful devices in microwave circuits and applications. As a reciprocal ideally matched and lossless four-port network with the ports isolated in pairs, it is used to divide or combine RF signals travelling along different lines. It is 16 In Section 4.8 we have shown that a shift in the reference plane produces a phase shift in the scattering parameters.
212
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Input 1
Isolated 4
Figure 7.27
P1
P2
P4
P3
2 Direct
3 Coupled
Schematic of a directional coupler.
essential in the measurement of the scattering parameters of devices as it allows separation of incident from reflected waves travelling along the transmission line, i.e. the waves travelling in opposite directions. This property gives the device its name. Figure 7.27 shows the schematic representation of a directional coupler. The signal entering into port 1 is divided between port 2 (direct port) and port 3 (coupled port), while port 4 is ideally isolated. The following parameters are used to characterize the behaviour: 1. Coupling. Normally, but not always, expressed in dB, the directional coupler measures the ratio between the input and the output power at the coupled port: CdB ¼ 10 log10
P1 P3
¼ js31 jdB
ð7:44Þ
Typical values of CdB are from 3 to 20 dB. The former value corresponds to an equal split of the input signal between ports 2 and 3. The reader may observe that such a coupler is nothing but a hybrid junction. However, a word of warning: higher CdB values correspond to lower coupling levels. A 0 dB coupler would transfer the whole input power to the coupled port (P3 ¼ P1 ). Such a device is used as a crossover. The reader can easily prove that a 0 dB coupler is obtained by cascading two 3 dB couplers. 2. Directivity. The directional coupler measures the device capability to discriminate between incident and reflected waves in the coupled port. It is defined as the ratio, expressed in dB, of the power from port 3 to that from port D ¼ 10 log10
P4 P3 P1 ¼ 10 log 10 log10 ¼ js31 jdB þ js41 jdB P3 P1 P4
ð7:45Þ
In ideal conditions P4 ¼ 0 and the directivity is infinite. Typical values vary from 10 dB for microstrip couplers to 30 dB for waveguide couplers. 3. Isolation. This is a measure of the isolation between the input port and the isolated port: I ¼ 10 log10
P1 P4
¼ js41 jdB
ð7:46Þ
In ideal conditions the isolation is infinite, like the directivity. The previous formulae (7.44)–(7.46) show that coupling, directivity and isolation are not independent of each other, but are related by the following equation: D ¼ CdB I
ð7:47Þ
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
213
The ideal directional coupler has the following properties: 1. All ports are matched to the reference impedance Z0 (usually 50 O). This means that if three ports are terminated with Z0 , the input impedance at the fourth port is Z0 as well. In terms of scattering parameters, this implies17 that sii ¼ 0 (i ¼ 1. . .4). 2. The device is lossless. Its scattering matrix is therefore unitary: ½S½S* T ¼ ½U. 3. The ports are isolated in pairs (1–4 and 2–3), thus s14 ¼ s41 ¼ 0 and s23 ¼ s32 ¼ 0. This implies infinite directivity and isolation. As can be expected, such properties are only approximately verified by actual directional couplers. If we impose properties 1 and 3 along with reciprocity and symmetry, the scattering matrix of an ideal directional coupler is found to have a very simple expression, containing only four complex independent parameters: 3 2 0 s12 s13 0 7 6 6 s12 0 0 s24 7 7 6 ð7:48Þ ½S ¼ 6 0 s34 7 5 4 s13 0 0 s24 s34 0 By further imposing the lossless condition 2, we obtain the following conditions for the scattering parameters: js12 j2 þ js13 j2 ¼ 1 js12 j2 þ js24 j2 ¼ 1 js13 j2 þ js34 j2 ¼ 1
ð7:49Þ
js24 j2 þ js34 j2 ¼ 1 s12 s*24 þ s13 s*34 ¼ 0 s12 s*13 þ s24 s*34 ¼ 0 After simple manipulations, and putting s13 ¼ Cejy13 , we obtain 2
0 6 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi2ffi 6 1C ½S ¼ 6 6 jy13 4 Ce 0
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1C 2 Ce jy13 0
0
0
0 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1C2 e jy34
Ce jy24
0
3
7 7 Ce jy24 7 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi jy34 7 2 1C e 5
ð7:50Þ
0
with the additional condition on the phases y12 y13 y24 þ y34 ¼ p
ð7:51Þ
For simplicity we have set the phase of s12 to zero. This is not a limitation since what matters are the phase differences between the scattering parameters rather than their absolute values. A particularly important and useful category of directional couplers is that of fully symmetrical couplers, for which all ports are indistinguishable from one another. In such cases it is apparent that the transmission from port 1 to 2 is identical to that from 3 to 4; similarly, that from port 1 to port 3 is the same 17
Actually, it can easily be proved that any matched and lossless four-port circuit is a directional coupler [4].
214
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.28
The two-hole coupler.
as that from 2 to 4. As a consequence, y12 ¼ y34 and y13 ¼ y24, and Equation (7.51) becomes p y12 ¼ y13 ð7:52Þ 2 This equation shows that in a fully symmetrical, ideally matched and isolated coupler, ports 2 and 3 are 90 out of phase. A directional coupler can be realized in various technologies by a variety of different configurations. For space limitations, here we just briefly describe the most common ones.
7.7.3.1 Two-hole coupler This is probably the simplest type of coupler. It is instructive to illustrate the principle behind its behaviour. The device consists of two rectangular waveguides set side by side by the broad walls and coupled with a pair of small holes at l/4 distance from one another. See Figure 7.28. Let us consider a wave travelling in the upper waveguide from port 1 towards port 2. At each hole a small portion of the incident power is transmitted into the second waveguide generating two waves travelling in opposite directions, one in the forward direction (towards port 3) and the other in the backward direction (towards port 4). Since the electrical distance between the two holes is p=2, the two forward waves add in phase at port 3, while the backward waves are 180 out of phase, and thus cancel at port 4, which is therefore isolated from port 1. This reasoning implicitly assumes that the amplitude of the wave produced in the second waveguide by the second hole is equal to that generated by the first hole: this is true only to a first approximation by omitting the fact that the first hole actually reduces the power carried by the wave travelling in the first waveguide. The smaller the holes, the better the approximation. In practice the maximum coupling obtainable is about 20 dB. The device is inherently narrow band, the band being centred around the frequency when the hole distance is l=4. Such limitations can be reduced or overcome by using a higher number of holes, which can also be located in different positions along the waveguide walls (both wide and narrow). Multi-hole directional couplers are discussed in [11].
7.7.3.2 Branch-line coupler The branch-line coupler consists of two transmission lines linked by two or more transverse l/4 branches located at l=4 distance one from each other. It can be realized in both waveguide and printed circuit (i.e. microstrip, stripline, CPW, etc.) technologies. The distributed circuit representation and the layout of a microstrip realization are shown in Figures 7.29a,b.18 Note that the circuit is fully symmetric, so, as we have proved before, its scattering matrix is of type (7.48) or, in the lossless case, (7.50). This symmetry also allows us to simplify the analysis. In fact, we may excite the structure at the four ports with signals of 18 The sharp junction discontinuities may alter the performance of the actual device with respect to the ideal behaviour of the circuit in Figure 7.27a. Such effects can be minimized by suitably rounding off the corners of the layout.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
215
7 mm
1
2
4
3
ZS=Z0/ 2, /4 1
2
Z0, /4
Z0, /4
4
3
ZS=Z0/ 2, /4
substrate edge microstrip transmission lines 4
RF ports
(a)
Figure 7.29
(b)
Branch-line coupler: (a) schematic; (b) layout of a microstrip implementation.
the same amplitudes and phases, either equal or opposite, in such a way that on the two symmetry planes an open circuit (even symmetry) or a short circuit (odd symmetry) is realized. Correspondingly, the structure of Figure 7.29 reduces to a bipole loaded with two parallel stubs terminated with an open or a short circuit, as shown in Figure 7.30. Here the indexes ‘e’ and ‘o’ stand for even and odd, respectively. By
1
2 YS
Y0
Y0
YS
4
1
open Y0 open
3
1
YS
Y0 open
ee
open
1 Y0
symmetry planes
YS oe
YS eo
1 Y0
YS oo
Figure 7.30 Reduction of Figure 7.29a to four bipoles by replacing the symmetry planes with magnetic (even symmetry ‘e’ or open circuit) or electric (odd symmetry ‘o’ or short circuit) planes.
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
20 log10(|s21|) = 20 log10(|s31|)
-2
20
-3
10 s31
-4
0 s21
-5
-10
-6
-20
s41 s11
-7
20 log10(|s11|), 20 log10(|s41|)
216
-30 8
9
10
11
12
Frequency, GHz
Figure 7.31
Response of the branch-line coupler of Figure 7.29b.
pffiffiffi choosing the series and shunt branch impedances as Zs ¼ Z0 = 2 and Zp ¼ Z0 we obtain a 3 dB coupler whose scattering matrix is 3 0 j 1 0 7 1 6 6 j 0 0 17 ½S ¼ pffiffiffi 6 7 241 0 0 j 5 0 1 j 0 2
ð7:53Þ
The device constitutes a 90 hybrid junction which splits the power at port 1 into two signals of equal amplitudes and 90 out of phase at ports 2 and 3. We do not need to stress that (7.53) is only valid at the centre frequency when all branches are l=4 long. The operational bandwidth of the device depends on the specifications, but in general we can say that the bandwidth is of the order of 10–15%. As an example, Figure 7.31 shows the computed19 scattering parameters of a microstrip hybrid. Assuming a maximum return loss of 15 dB, the bandwidth is approximately 15%. When wider bandwidths are required, devices with a higher number of branches can be employed.
Computation of the scattering parameters To compute the scattering parameters of the branch-line coupler, we make use of Table 7.2, where the four cases of Figure 7.30 are considered. The second row of the table indicates the relations between the incident and reflected waves at the four ports, depending on the respective symmetry conditions specified in the first row. The third row gives the corresponding input admittances normalized with respect to Y0 . Such values are obtained by taking into account that each stub is l=8 long, so that tanðblÞ ¼ tanðp=4Þ ¼ 1. The fourth row gives the reflection coefficients relating the reflected to the incident waves.
19
See the Ansoft file 04_Branch_Line.adsn.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
217
The scattering matrix of the branch-line coupler is computed by superimposing the four cases, i.e. by exciting the circuit with the sum of the four signals. In this way the outgoing waves are found to be b1 ¼ Gee aee þ Geo aeo þ Goe aoe þ Goo aoo b2 ¼ Gee aee Geo aeo Goe aoe þ Goo aoo
ð7:54Þ
b3 ¼ Gee aee þ Geo aeo Goe aoe Goo aoo b4 ¼ Gee aee Geo aeo þ Goe aoe Goo aoo Taking into account that (as can be easily verified) aee ¼ ða1 þ a2 þ a3 þ a4 Þ=4; aoe ¼ ða1 þ a2 a3 a4 Þ=4;
aeo ¼ ða1 a2 a3 þ a4 Þ=4 aoo ¼ ða1 a2 a3 a4 Þ=4
ð7:55Þ
s12 ¼ ðGee Geo þ Goe Goo Þ=4 s14 ¼ ðGee þ Geo Goe Goo Þ=4
ð7:56Þ
we obtain the first row of the scattering matrix: s11 ¼ ðGee þ Geo þ Goe þ Goo Þ=4; s13 ¼ ðGee Geo þ Goe Goo Þ=4;
The remaining rows are immediately obtained by exploiting the reciprocity and symmetry of the circuit: s11 ¼ s22 ¼ s33 ¼ s44 ; s13 ¼ s31 ¼ s24 ¼ s42 ;
s12 ¼ s21 ¼ s34 ¼ s43 s14 ¼ s41 ¼ s23 ¼ s32
ð7:57Þ
Let us now impose the matching condition s11 ¼ 0 and the condition that ports 1 and 4 are isolated, i.e. s14 ¼ 0. Using (7.57) along with the expressions in Table 7.2, we find that both conditions are satisfied for Ys2 ¼ 1 þ Yp2
ð7:58Þ
Table 7.2 Computing the parameters of the circuits of Figure 7.30 Even–even
Even–odd
Odd–even
Odd–odd
aee ¼ a1 ¼ a2 ¼ a3 ¼ a4
aeo ¼ a1 ¼ a2 ¼ a3 ¼ a4
aoe ¼ a1 ¼ a2 ¼ a3 ¼ a4
aoo ¼ a1 ¼ a2 ¼ a3 ¼ a4
Gee aee ¼ b1 ¼ b2 ¼ b3 ¼ b4
Geo aeo ¼ b1 ¼ b2 ¼ b3 ¼ b4
Goe aoe ¼ b1 ¼ b2 ¼ b3 ¼ b4
Goo aoo ¼ b1 ¼ b2 ¼ b3 ¼ b4
Yin ¼ Yee ¼ j Ys þ Yp
Yin ¼ Yeo ¼ j Ys þ Yp
Yin ¼ Yeo ¼ j Ys þ Yp
Yin ¼ Yoo ¼ j Ys þ Yp
Gee ¼
1jðYs þ Yp Þ 1 þ jðYs þ Yp Þ
Geo ¼
1jðYs þ Yp Þ 1 þ jðYs þ Yp Þ
Goe ¼
1 þ jðYs Yp Þ 1jðYs Yp Þ
¼ 1=Geo
Goo ¼
1 þ jðYs þ Yp Þ 1jðYs þ Yp Þ
¼ 1=Gee
218
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Under such a condition we obtain from the last row of Table 7.2 Gee ¼ ðY2 þ jÞ=Y1 ;
Geo ¼ ðY2 þ jÞ=Y1 ¼ Gee
Goe ¼ ðY2 jÞ=Y1 ¼ Goo ;
Goo ¼ ðY2 þ jÞ=Y1
ð7:59Þ
Finally, from (7.56), s11 ¼ 0; s13 ¼
s12 ¼
Yp Gee þ Goo ¼ ; 2 Ys
Gee Goo 1 ¼ jYs 2
ð7:60Þ
s14 ¼ 0
Note that, as previously demonstrated in the general case, s12 and s31 are 90 out of phase. Comparing (7.60) with (7.50) we conclude that C ¼ Zs =Zp . To obtain a 3 dB coupler, i.e. a coupler such that the input power at port 1 is equally pffiffiffi divided between ports 2 and 3, it suffices to choose of (7.58), Y ¼ 2. The denormalized impedance of the series branch is Yp ¼ 1; thus, because s pffiffiffi therefore Zs ¼ Z0 = 2 and that of the shunt branches is Zp ¼ Z0 . Expression (7.53) for the scattering matrix is finally obtained from (7.59) and (7.60).
7.7.3.3 Coupled-line couplers The distributed coupling between closely spaced printed lines detailed in Section 3.16 enables the realization of another class of fully symmetrical directional couplers, whose scattering matrix is of type (7.50). The basic geometry is shown in Figure 7.32. It consists of a l=4 section of coupled lines connected to four lines with characteristic impedance Z0 . The width of the metal strips and their distance are determined so as to ensure the matching of the device, according to Equation (4.140), and to realize the prescribed coupling C, given by (4.143). Using these equations one can easily obtain the even and odd mode impedances of the coupled lines: rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Z0e 1þC Z0o 1C ^ ^ ð7:61Þ Z 0e ¼ ¼ ¼ ; Z 0o ¼ 1C 1þC Z0 Z0 These values can be used, along with synthesis formulae, to compute the width and spacing of the lines, while their length is determined by the condition that it must equal l=4 at the centre frequency.
3
Z0
Z0 4 d=λ/4
1
Figure 7.32
Z0
Z0 2
Layout of a microstrip coupled-line directional coupler.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
219
s21
0
2
20 log10(|s21|), 20 log10(|s31|)
10 log10(1-C ) -5 20 log10(C) -10
-15
s31
-20 0
1 =
Figure 7.33
2 = f/f0 0
Coupling and transmission coefficient of a 6 dB microstrip coupled-line coupler.
Contrary to what one might expect, the pairs of isolated ports are 1–4 and 2–3; rather than being on the same side of the device, they are located at diagonal positions. In some applications this may create topological difficulties. Normally, the difficulty of realizing metal strips that are too closely spaced (say, below 0.1 mm) does not allow coupling higher than 6 dB. Figure 7.33 shows the behaviour of the coupling C and the transmission coefficient s21 of a coupledline coupler versus the normalized frequency.20 Note that the coupling is maximum at the centre frequency when the coupled section is l=4 long. The drawbacks of limited bandwidth and small coupling, together with the difficulty of the isolated ports being located on opposite sides of the device, are overcome in the Lange coupler [12] shown in Figure 7.34. This employs an interdigitated configuration consisting of interleaved line segments like the fingers of two hands.21 The line between ports 3 and 4 is divided into two segments connected by bonding wires in such a way that ports 1 and 2, which are electrically connected, are on opposite sides of the device. As can be expected, the interdigitated geometry leads to higher couplings than the mere coupled lines. A Lange coupler can indeed realize a hybrid junction (i.e. with 3 dB coupling). There is, however, a price to pay, which is the need for bonding wires (thus additional fabrication cost) and, more importantly, the strict fabrication tolerances: the width and spacing of the interdigitated lines are very narrow (easily less than 0.1 mm) and thus require sophisticated fabrication technologies. Figure 7.35 shows the frequency response22 of the coupler of Figure 7.34. The typical behaviour of the coupling js31 j of such a device is observed: maximum at the centre frequency, then decreasing towards both higher and lower frequencies. Correspondingly, the direct signal amplitude js21 j is minimum at the centre frequency and increases towards the band edges. We also note that the nominal 3 dB coupling is not achieved because of the device loss, without which the js21 j and js31 j curves would touch each other at the centre frequency.
20 See the Ansoft file 05_Directional_Coupler.adsn for the analysis of both an ideal and a microstrip 10 dB directional coupler. 21 The term comes from the Latin digitus, meaning finger. 22 See the Ansoft file 06_Lange_Coupler.adsn.
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
1
4
2 mm
substrate edge 3
2
microstrip transmission lines RF ports
1
bond wires
Figure 7.34 Lange coupler in microstrip technology.
20
-2
10
-3
-4
0
s21
-10
-5
-20
-6 s41
s11 -7
4
8
12
16
-30 20
Frequency, GHz
Figure 7.35
Response of the Lange coupler of Figure 7.34.
20 log10(|s11|), 20 log10(|s41|)
s31 20 log10(|s21|) = 20 log10(|s31|)
220
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
221
7.8 Lumped element realizations The dividers, hybrid junctions and couplers considered so far consist of distributed circuit elements, mostly single or multiple l=4 sections. The hybrid ring, for instance, consists of six l=4 sections, so that its diameter is of the order of l=2. At low frequencies, the size of such components may become significant and often intolerable. Consider for instance the microstrip circuits of Figures 7.20c, 7.25a and 7.29b. They have been designed for a 10 GHz centre frequency and realized on a substratewith a permittivity er ¼ 9:9. The physical length of pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi a l=4 section is lmm ¼ 75=ðf0;GHz ee f f Þ, which is of the order of 2.7 mm. If the centre frequency were 1 GHz, each section would be around 27 mm long and the ring diameter would be over 50 mm. In many practical applications where space occupancy is of critical importance, one has to look for alternative configurations to reduce the circuit size substantially. One possibility consists of employing lumped elements, replacing each distributed line length with a lumped LC section. The latter is chosen in such a way as to approximate the corresponding line length and, in particular, to be equivalent to it at the centre frequency. Substitution of a transmission line length by a lumped LC cell can be implemented in various ways, but, due to space limitations, here we consider just one example. Other cases can be treated in a similar manner. In Figure 7.36, the two-port network consisting of a l=4 transmission line length is replaced by an LC lowdpass P cell. The following discussion can easily be extended to other similar cases (e.g. a T cell). The values of the LC elements of the cell can be determined by requiring that, at the central frequency f0 when the line is l=4 long, both circuits are equivalent, i.e. they cannot be distinguished when measured at the external terminal pairs, hence they have the same admittance matrix. Let us recall the admittance matrix of a line length (4.121): ½Yline ¼
jY0 cos y 1 sin y 1 cos y
ð7:62Þ
where y ¼ bl ¼ ðp=2Þ ðo=o0 Þ and o0 ¼ 2pf0 . The admittance matrix of a P cell is obtained from (4.65)–(4.66), where YA ¼ YB ¼ joC and YC ¼ 1=ðjoLÞ: 1 1o2 LC 1 ½YP ¼ ð7:63Þ 1 1o2 LC joL Equating both matrices (7.62) and (7.63) for y ¼ p=2, i.e. o ¼ o0 , we obtain L and C as functions of the characteristic impedance Z0 and the centre frequency o0 : Z0 o0 1 C¼ Z 0 o0 L ¼
Figure 7.36
Substituting a transmission line length (a) by an LC lowdpass P cell (b).
ð7:64Þ
222
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
C
C L35.35
1
2
L50
L50 L35.35
4
3
C
C
Figure 7.37 Lumped element realization of a branch-line coupler corresponding to Figure 7.29a, with a centre frequency of 500 MHz. In a similar way we can approximate the l=4 section with an LC lowdpass T cell or a l/2 section with a highpass T or P cell. Let us now consider specifically the branch-line coupler of Figure 7.29a consisting of four l=4 sections, two with 50 O characteristic impedance (between the node pairs 1–4 and 2–3) and two with 35.35 O characteristic impedance (between the node pairs 1–2 and 3–4). Let us suppose that we need to realize the coupler at a centre frequency of 500 MHz. Applying (7.64) we get 8 > > < L50O ¼
8 > > > < L35:35O ¼
> > : C50O
> > > : C35:35O
50 ffi 15:92 nH 2p 500 106 1 ¼ ffi 6:37 pF 50 2p 500 106
pffiffiffi 50= 2 ffi 11:25 nH 2p 500 106 1 pffiffiffi ¼ ffi 9 pF 50= 2 2p 500 106
By replacing the line sections with the LC P cells, the circuit of Figure 7.29a reduces to that shown in Figure 7.37, where each capacitor has been obtained as the parallel of two capacitors pertaining to the transmission lines connected to each node: C ¼ C50O þ C35:35O ffi 15:37 pF Figure 7.38 shows the response23 of Figure 7.37. For comparison, the black lines show the response of the ideal distributed branch line of Figure 7.29a with the same centre frequency f0 ¼ 500 MHz. Notice that the lumped circuit exhibits a slightly lower performance (worse matching, higher insertion loss and worse balance between the two outputs 2 and 3 as the frequency departs from f0 ). On the other hand, the lumped version is much smaller than the distributed one. If realized in microstrip with the same substrate, the distributed circuit of Figure 7.29b would have line sections about 54 mm long, while the four capacitors and four inductors can be realized with physical dimensions of the order of 1 mm using SMD technology with a 0402 package.24 In the present case, the lumped circuit has a size of order one-tenth that 23 24
See the Ansoft file 07_Lumped_Branch_Line.adsn. See Section 14.2.1.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS 10
s21
-4
0
ideal distributed lumped
s31 -5
-10 s11
-6
20 log10(|s11|)
20 log10(|s21|), 20 log10(|s31|)
-3
223
-20
-7 400
450
500
-30 600
550
Frequency, MHz
Figure 7.38 Response of the lumped branch line of Figure 7.37 (grey lines) compared with that of the ideal distributed branch line of Figure 7.29b (black lines). Broadside Wavefront
2 p
d sin
p
d 1
Figure 7.39
2
….
N-1
N
A linear array radiating a wavefront at an angle yp < 0.
of the distributed one.25 Two additional parameters to consider are the insertion loss (not included in any of the simulations of Figure 7.38) and the maximum power that can be carried by the circuit. The distributed realization has a superior performance from both points of view.
7.9 Multi-beam forming networks Modern advances in communication technology, such as satellite communications, radar systems, pointto-point communication links and imaging, have spurred the development of antennas made of one- or two-dimensional arrays of radiating elements. By feeding the radiating elements with suitable phases and amplitudes one can achieve a variety of radiation patterns to fit the most sophisticated requirements, such as multi-beam or scanning capabilities, and to be reconfigured according to time-varying requirements. An example is the possible variation of the area covered by satellite antennas. In order to provide such 25 Actually, in the case of the lumped circuit, we should consider not only the size of the components, but also the area occupied by the bonding pads. A rough estimate suggests that the overall size of the circuit in Figure 7.37 is about 5 5 mm.
224
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
capabilities, a microwave feeding network must be designed capable of varying the phases and/or the amplitudes of the signals feeding the array elements. This can be achieved by feeding networks consisting of the devices illustrated in previous sections, such as dividers, hybrids and phase shifters, possibly with control elements (as described in Chapter 10) to achieve the required reconfigurability of the radiated beam. This approach is extremely powerful and flexible, but, in the case of 2-D scanning, also quite expensive: consider that phased array antennas can easily contain several thousand elements. In the case of 1-D scanning, a cheaper approach consists of employing an M N multi-beam forming network (MBFN), where the N outputs are connected to the elements of the linear array. When fed at the ith port (i ¼ 1. . .M), the phase distribution at the N output ports creates a beam directed towards the direction of the angle yi. In this manner, M independent beams are simultaneously created; moreover, by switching among the input ports, a switched-beam rather than continuous-beam scanning is obtained. This solution can be implemented using basically two classes of MBFNs: matrices and lenses. We briefly consider here the most common ones, namely the Butler matrix, the Blass matrix and the Rotman lens.
7.9.1
The Butler matrix26
Consider a linear array of N radiating elements, located at a constant distance d from one another. If each element is fed with a constant phase difference Df with respect to the previous one, the radiated beam will be tilted by an angle yp with respect to the broadside direction, i.e. the direction perpendicular to the array. A Butler matrix can provide a linear phase distribution when the number of elements is a power of 2. The Butler matrix is in fact an N N MBFN where the number N of input and output ports is required to be N ¼ 2n where n is an integer. The Butler matrix can be realized in various technologies from waveguide to printed circuit. Constituting elements are directional couplers, either 90 or 180 hybrids, crossovers and phase shifters. They must be properly connected to get the desired phase distribution at the output ports. Designs exist using either 90 or 180 hybrids. Butler matrices with 90 hybrids do not produce a beam at broadside, i.e. orthogonal to the linear array, whereas those with 180 hybrids produce a broadside beam. The number of couplers employed is the same for both solutions, but the number and position of phase shifters depend on the type of hybrid employed. The phase progression at the output ports is related to the order N of the matrix. A detailed design procedure for both approaches can be found in [13] and [14] for the cases of 90 and 180 hybrids, respectively. Regardless of the kind of coupler, the operating principle is the same for both solutions. Concerning the topology of the device, if N ¼ 2n is the order of the matrix, the number of hybrids used in the network is nN=2. The hybrids are arranged in n columns with N/2 hybrids per column. The number of columns of phase shifter is (n 1) and the number of phase shifters per column is N/2, yielding a total of ðn1ÞN=2 phase shifters. The value of each phase shifter can be calculated by using the formulae given in [13]. By feeding the pth input port (p ¼ 1. . .N) a linear phase distribution at the output ports is obtained so that the main beam is tilted by the angle N þ 12p l p ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; N ð7:65Þ yp ¼ sin1 2N d l is the free space wavelength and d is the distance between adjacent radiating elements. As an example, consider the 4 4 matrix employing 90 hybrids shown in Figure 7.40. A total number of four couplers, arranged in two columns, and two phase shifters are employed. For each input port, the resulting phase distributions at the output ports of the device and the corresponding main beam direction, assuming d ¼ l/2, are given in Table 7.3.
26
Elisa Sbarra and Roberto Vincenti Gatti are gratefully acknowledged for their contribution to this section.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
Figure 7.40
225
Schematic of a 4 4 Butler matrix with 90 hybrid junctions.
Table 7.3 Phase distributions at the output ports of Figure 7.40 and main beam direction yp for d ¼ l/2 Port p
OUT1
OUT2
OUT3
OUT4
45 135 90 180
2 4 1 3
7.9.2
90 0 225 135
135 225 0 90
180 90 135 45
yp 14.47 48.59 48.59 14.47
The Blass matrix27
In contrast to the Butler matrix, the Blass matrix [15] can in principle have any number of input and output ports. It consists of M rows corresponding to the number of beams to be generated and N columns connected to the radiating elements, as sketched in Figure 7.41. The two sets of transmission lines, usually referred to as rows and columns of the matrix, are interconnected at each crossover by a directional coupler. The signal applied at any input port (l.h.s. of Figure 7.41) propagates along the corresponding feed line. At each crossover a small portion of the signal is coupled to each column, ultimately exciting the corresponding radiating element. Each line is terminated with a matched load to absorb the residual signal. By feeding each input port, a different phase distribution is produced along the array, thus a different radiated beam orientation, depending on the various electrical paths. The network is therefore able to generate M different radiated beams whose orientations depend on the selected input port. The coupling coefficients of the directional couplers affect the power distribution among the array elements, thus the beam shape (beamwidth, sidelobe level, etc.). Compared with the Butler matrix, the Blass matrix is much more flexible, since it can generate multiple beams placed in arbitrary directions, covering a wide scanning range. However, part of the input power is lost as it is absorbed by the matched loads at the end of each line. The synthesis procedure can be illustrated with the aid of the schematic of Figure 7.42, where we consider an M N Blass matrix made of ideal transmission lines and directional couplers. For simplicity, we assume the phase shift to be the same for all branches and equal to y. The Blass matrix is identified by the M N complex quantities Xmn ¼ Cmn ejfmn , Cmn being the coupling coefficient of the mnth coupler and fmn the phase of the mnth line length. For the ith (i ¼ 1. . .M) beam to be generated, the N radiating elements must be excited with an appropriate complex signal distribution Oij (j ¼ 1, 2, . . ., N). This 27
Federico Casini is gratefully acknowledged for his contribution to this section.
226
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.41
Schematic of the Blass matrix [16] (copyright EuMA).
identifies the excitation matrix [O]. The synthesis of the Blass matrix consists of computing the coefficients Xmn (m ¼ 1. . .M, n ¼ 1. . .N) for a given excitation matrix Oij. This can be done by a recursive procedure starting with the first element of the array and then proceeding with the following ones, the computation becoming progressively heavier. Consider the signal coming from input 1 that has to generate beam number 1: the only path connecting input 1 to the first radiating element is through the coupler C11 and the phase shifter f11.
Figure 7.42
Schematic for the design procedure of a Blass matrix [16] (copyright EuMA).
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
Figure 7.43 EuMA).
227
Photographs of a Blass matrix in rectangular waveguide technology [16] (copyright
Because of the ideally infinite directivity of the couplers, a simple equation can be written to compute the excitation for node (1,1): jO11 je jffO11 ¼ C11 ejf11
ð7:66Þ
where O11 is the desired excitation for the first radiating element when the first beam is selected. Similarly we compute all C1j and f1j (j ¼ 1. . .N) and in the same manner we can immediately compute C21 and f21. Now consider the path connecting input 2 and output 2 of the network. As can be seen from Figure 7.42, there are two different paths: the primary path crossing node 22 (still to be computed), and a secondary path crossing three nodes of the matrix that have already been computed. Once again, the complex equation associated to the considered node has only one complex unknown, but this time the equation is made up of two different terms, each associated to a different path: jO22 je jffO22 ¼ ejy ½C12 C21 C11 ejðf12 þ f21 Þ þ
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 C ejðf12 þ f22 Þ 1C21 1C12 22
ð7:67Þ
Following the above procedure that accounts for all secondary paths, the synthesis of the ideal multi-beam Blass matrix is obtained. In this way, the excitations produced by each input port are not distorted by the presence of the secondary paths, and so produce almost ideal radiation patterns. Figure 7.43 shows the photograph of a 5 32 Blass matrix realized in rectangular waveguide technology operating at Ku band. The matrix was designed to have the beam oriented at 30 , 35 , 40 , 45 and 50 with respect to the broadside. The matrix was realized as a three-layer machine-drilled aluminium structure. Figure 7.44 shows the measured radiating patterns corresponding to inputs 1, 3 and 5.
7.9.3
The Rotman lens28
A Rotman lens is a planar M N device employed as an MBFN for switched-beam/multi-beam antennas [17]. Scanning is achieved without phase shifters or power dividers, thus strongly reducing the fabrication costs. Normal realizations are either in waveguide or printed circuit technology, the main advantages of the former being the lower loss and higher power-handling capability, while reduced 28
Elisa Sbarra and Roberto Vincenti Gatti are gratefully acknowledged for their contribution to this section.
228
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.44 Measured normalized radiation patterns generated by the Blass matrix of Figure 7.43 (copyright EuMA) [16].
dimensions and lower fabrication costs are typical of the latter. Specific features of the Rotman lens are the wide scanning angle range and the wide operating frequency band. The design procedure for Rotman lenses in microstrip technology is described here. Figure 7.45 shows the layout of the Rotman lens. The main part is a parallel-plate region bounded on the left by the circular profile C1, with radius R and centre Op, and on the right by the profile C2 which has to be determined. The M input ports lie on C1, whereas the N radiating elements are located on the straight profile CA and identified by their coordinates Yn (n ¼ 1. . .N), where the linear array elements are located. N transmission lines of length Wn (n ¼ 1. . .N) connect the points Pn(x, y) on C2
y
Parallel plate region F1 Input profile C1
Wn
•
•
F
•
G
• •
C
F•2
• • P (x,y)• • • W • Wave front •O • x • • • • •C • n
R
F0•
Op
•
0
A
Output profile C2
Figure 7.45
Yn
Radiating elements
Schematic layout of Rotman lens.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
229
with the corresponding radiating elements Yn on CA. Beam steering is achieved by switching among the M input ports. The first step in the design procedure consists of choosing three points, F0, F1 and F2, symmetrically located on the input profile C1, as shown in Figure 7.45. We then need to introduce the following geometrical quantities, shown in the figure: .
G is the distance of F0 from the origin O of the reference system.
.
F is the length of F1O and F2O.
.
a and a are the angular positions of F1 and F2, respectively. The corresponding input ports have coordinates (G, 0), (F cos a, F sin a), (F cos a, F sin a).
.
c is the desired steering angle obtained by feeding the lens from F1.
F1, F2 and F0 are points of perfect focus: by feeding the lens from such points, a phase-error-free excitation is generated at the antenna radiating elements, with steering angles þ c, c and 0 , respectively. The design equations simply consist of imposing that the three rays from F1, F2 and F0 to the radiating elements Yn have the same electrical lengths, apart from the contribution required for the beam tilting in the (0, þ c or c) direction, respectively. As can be easily seen, such conditions are expressed as follows [18]: pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er ðF1 Pn Þ þ ee f f Wn þ Yn sin c ¼ er F þ ee f f W0 pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er ðF2 Pn Þ þ ee f f Wn Yn sin c ¼ er F þ ee f f W0 pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi er ðF0 Pn Þ þ ee f f Wn ¼ er G þ ee f f W0
ð7:68Þ
where er is the substrate dielectric constant and eeff is the effective dielectric constant of the output microstrip lines. F1Pn, F2Pn and F0Pn are the path lengths from the points F1, F2 and F0, respectively, to the point Pn(x, y) on the profile C2. In the above equations, the unknowns are the coordinates of Pn on C2 and the length Wn. By solving (7.68) for n ¼ 1. . .N, one determines the array profile C2 and the line length Wn for Rotman lenses in microstrip technology. This procedure yields a lens with three perfect focal points F1, F2 and F0 corresponding to the steering angles c and 0 . By feeding the lens from a generic input point Cg with angular position g on the profile C1, the main lobe is tilted at the angle y, which is determined from the following formula:
sin y ¼ sin g
sin c sin a
ð7:69Þ
The last design step concerns the plate region side walls. They have to be designed in order to minimize multiple reflections in the parallel-plate region: common solutions consist of the use of properly shaped absorbing material for waveguide lenses or dummy ports terminated on matched loads for microstrip devices. A photograph of a Ku band microstrip Rotman lens operating in the 11.325–11.875 GHz frequency range is shown in Figure 7.46. This is a 7 32 beamforming network realized in microstrip technology. Dummy ports terminated with matched loads are located along the side walls of the parallel-plate regions. The measured radiation patterns of a slotted waveguide antenna fed by the proposed device at centre frequency are shown in Figure 7.47; the optimized output delay lines Wn are designed to produce a 25 –55 scanning angle range.
230
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.46
Ku band microstrip Rotman lens prototype: total dimensions 43 46 cm.
Figure 7.47 Rotman lens radiation patterns measured at centre frequency f0 ¼ 11.575 GHz [19].
7.10 Non-reciprocal components All the components considered so far are made of linear and isotropic materials for which Lorentz’s reciprocity theorem of Section 2.7.2 holds. There is an important class of microwave passive devices that make use of ferrites, ceramic materials with particular magnetic properties and, when subject to a static magnetic field, anisotropic properties as well. Even a concise treatment of EM wave propagation in
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
231
ferrites is beyond the scope of this book, so, due to space limitations, we will present just a sketchy description. The interested reader is directed to the rich literature available on the subject [20–22]. Ferrites are ferrimagnetic materials with magnetic permeabilities of the order of several thousands. They exhibit very low losses (typical resistivity is of the order of 1014 O m) with a dielectric constant between 10 and 15. They are made of oxides of iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), nickel (Ni) and zinc (Zn), or a mixture of them. Their peculiar magnetic properties derive from the presence of a magnetic dipole moment produced by the spins of the electrons. By applying a static magnetic field B0 producing a saturated magnetization Ms of the ferrite, anisotropic behaviour is exhibited concerning the RF magnetic field. The constitutive relation between the RF components of B and H is of the form B ¼ mH
ð7:70Þ
If the static field B0 is parallel to the z axis, the permeability tensor m is expressed as follows: 3 2 mxx mxy 0 7 6 ð7:71Þ m ¼ m0 4 myx myy 0 5 0
0
1
Therefore, the Cartesian components of (7.51) are expressed as Bx ¼ m0 ðmxx Hx þ mxy Hy Þ By ¼ m0 ðmyx Hx þ myy Hy Þ
ð7:72Þ
Bz ¼ m0 Hz The anisotropic behaviour is apparent because the vector B, even though its components are linearly related to those of the magnetic field, has different orientations and amplitudes depending on the direction of H. In particular, if the RF magnetic field H is parallel to the static magnetic field (thus is directed along z), the ferrite behaves as an ordinary non-magnetic material (B ¼ m0 H). If, on the contrary, the magnetic field is directed in another direction, e.g. along the x axis, the magnetic induction has both x and y components. Under some simplifying hypotheses, in particular by neglecting material losses, the elements of the permeability tensor can be written as mxx ¼ myy ¼ 1 þ mxy ¼ myx ¼
oM o0 o20 o2
jooM o20 o2
ð7:73Þ
where oM ¼ jgjMs =m0 o0 ¼ jgjB0 =m0
ð7:74Þ
g is the gyromagnetic ratio given by the ratio between the magnetic dipole moment and the angular momentum of the electron; Ms is the saturated magnetization of the ferrite. The frequency o0 is the Larmor frequency or cyclotron frequency. When the frequency approaches o0 , the elements of the permeability tensor become infinite as the result of a strong interaction between the RF magnetic field and the magnetic dipole moments associated with the electron spins. A specific consequence of the material anisotropy is that Lorentz’s reciprocity theorem does not hold, so that the microwave components containing such materials are not reciprocal: the [Z], [Y] or [S] matrices are thus expected not to be symmetrical.
232
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 7.48
7.10.1
Resonance isolator.
Isolator
The non-reciprocal character typically manifests itself in the isolator. An ideal isolator is a two-port device that allows the RF signal to be transmitted without attenuation from port 1 to port 2, while it inhibits transmission from port 2 to 1 by totally absorbing the incoming RF power. Its scattering matrix is thus 0 0 ½S ¼ ð7:75Þ 1 0 The [S] matrix is clearly non-symmetrical (s12 6¼ s21 ) and non-unitary (½S*T 6¼ ½S1 ); indeed the isolator is a lossy component since it absorbs the power entering from port 2. Put in cascade to a generator, the isolator ensures its matching while protecting it from possible reflections from the load. The isolator can be realized in a rectangular waveguide by exploiting the resonance behaviour of the ferrite at the cyclotron frequency o0. In the resonance isolator sketched in Figure 7.48, one or two ferrite slabs magnetized in the y direction are located at waveguide positions where the RF magnetic field is circularly polarized in the xz plane.29 The forward attenuation of such a device is of the order of 0.02 dB/ mm at a frequency of 10 GHz, while the corresponding backward attenuation is of the order of 0.25–0.40 dB/mm [4]. The isolator can also be realized by employing a circulator, as shown in the next section.
7.10.2
Circulator
The circulator is an n-port device (n usually being 3), ideally without loss and perfectly matched, used to transmit the signal from port i to the next port i þ 1 (or i 1), according to the scheme of Figure 7.49. As a consequence of the above properties, the scattering matrix of an ideal three-port circulator is 2 3 0 0 1 ½S ¼ 4 1 0 0 5 ð7:76Þ 0 1 0
29 Equations (3.132) show that the x and z components of the magnetic field of the dominant TE10 mode are in quadrature. Therefore, the magnetic field is circularly polarized in the xz plane at the x coordinate where the x and z components have the same amplitude.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS 1
233
2 3
Figure 7.49 Symbol of the three-port circulator. antenna
transmitter
receiver
Figure 7.50
Use of an antenna in receive and transmit modes using a circulator. 1
2 3
Figure 7.51
A circulator used to realize an isolator.
This expression implies that the signal entering at port 1 is transferred without attenuation to port 2, that from port 2 to port 3 and that from port 3 to port 1: b1 ¼ a3 b2 ¼ a1 b3 ¼ a2 The scattering matrix (7.76) is clearly unitary. The circulator can have very wide bandwidths, larger than one octave. It can typically be used to allow a transmitter and a receiver to share the same antenna,30 as sketched in Figure 7.50. It can also be used as a wide-band isolator by terminating one of the ports with a matched load, as shown in Figure 7.51. It can easily be proved that any three-port lossless, matched and non-reciprocal network is a circulator.31 Therefore, a circulator can in principle be realized by putting a ferrite sample into a threeport junction and ensuring that the device is matched. The latter is indeed the most critical condition, which is realized using suitably designed matching elements. 30 31
See also Section 15.5.1. It suffices to impose the unitary property on a 3 3 scattering matrix having s11 ¼ s22 ¼ s33 ¼ 0.
234
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Bibliography 1. K. Chang, Handbook of Microwave and Optical Components, Vol. I, Microwave Passive and Antenna Components, pp. 62, 80, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ, 1989. 2. C. G. Montgomery, R. H. Dicke and E. M. Purcell, Principles of Microwave Circuits, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1948. 3. N. Marcuvitz, Waveguide Handbook, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1951. 4. R. E. Collin, Foundations for Microwave Engineering, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1992. 5. R. E. Collin, Field Theory of Guided Waves, IEEE Press Series on Electromagnetic Wave Theory, 2001. 6. J. Van Bladel, Singular Electromagnetic Fields and Sources, Oxford Science Publications, 1991. 7. K. C. Gupta, R. Garg and R. Chadha, Computer-Aided Design of Microwave Circuits, Artech House, Norwood, MA, 1981. 8. M. E. Bialkowski, ‘Analysis of a coaxial-to-waveguide adaptor incorporating a dielectric coated probe’, IEEE Microwave and Guided Wave Letters, Vol. 1, No. 8, pp. 211–214, 1991. 9. E. J. Wilkinson, ‘N-way hybrid power combiner’, IRE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 13, pp. 116–118, 1960. 10. T. H. Lee, Planar Microwave Engineering, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004. 11. R. Levy, ‘Directional couplers’, in L. Young, Advances in Microwaves, Vol. 1, Academic Press, New York, 1966. 12. J. Lange, ‘Interdigitated stripline quadrature hybrid’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. MTT-17, pp. 1150–1151, 1969. 13. H. J. Moody, ‘The systematic design of the Butler matrix’, IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 11, pp. 786–788, 1964. 14. T. M. Macnamara, ‘Simplified design procedures for Butler matrices incorporating 90 hybrids or 180 hybrids’, IEEE Proceedings on Microwaves, Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 134, No. 1, pp. 50–54, 1987. 15. P. S. Hall and S. J. Vetterlein, ‘Review of radio frequency beamforming techniques for scanned and multiple beam antennas’, IEEE Proceedings on Microwaves, Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 137, pp. 293–303, 1990. 16. F. Casini, R. Vincenti Gatti, L. Marcaccioli and R. Sorrentino, ‘A novel design method for Blass matrix beam-forming networks’, Proceedings of the European Microwaves Conference, 9–12 October, pp. 1511–1514, 2007. 17. W. Rotman and R. F. Turner, ‘Wide-angle microwave lens for line source applications’, IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 11, pp. 623–632, 1963. 18. P. K. Singhal, P. C. Sharma and R. D. Gupta, ‘Rotman lens with equal height of array and feed contours’, IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 51, pp. 2048–2056, 2003. 19. R. Vincenti Gatti, L. Marcaccioli, E. Sbarra and R. Sorrentino, ‘Flat Array Antennas for Ku-Band Mobile Satellite Terminals’, International Journal of Antennas and Propagation, Sp. Issue on Active Antennas for Space Applications, Hyndawi Publishing Corporation, Volume 2009 (2009), Article ID 836074, 5 pages. 20. B. Lax and K. J. Button, Microwave Ferrites and Ferromagnetics, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1962. 21. J. Helszajn, Principles of Microwave Ferrite Engineering, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1969. 22. A. J. Baden Fuller, Ferrites at Microwave Frequencies, Peter Peregrinus, London, 1987.
PASSIVE MICROWAVE COMPONENTS
235
Simulation files 01_Attenuator.adsn. Describes the microstrip attenuator of Figure 7.6, producing the plot in Figure 7.7. 02_Wilkinson_Divider.adsn. Analyzes the power dividers in Figure 7.20 as per the result shown in Figure 7.22. 03_Rat_Race.adsn. Simulation of the rat-race of Figure 7.25, with the respective response on the same figure. 04_Branch_Line.adsn. Analysis of the microstrip branch-line couplers (ideal and microstrip) in Figure 7.29b. The result of the simulation is plotted in Figure 7.31. 05_Directional_Coupler.adsn. Analyzes an ideal and a microstrip 10 dB coupler working at 10 GHz. 06_Lange_Coupler.adsn. Simulates the Lange coupler having the layout of Figure 7.34 and the response in Figure 7.35. 07_Lumped_Branch_Line.adsn. Comparison of the lumped branch coupler of Figure 6.37 with a standard transmission line implementation. Produces the curves of Figure 7.38.
8
Microwave filters 8.1 Introduction Microwave filters are fundamental building blocks in many electronic systems, such as cellular phones, wireless communications, radar, etc. The microwave filter discipline is so broad that no single book can cover it. The limited space of one chapter will be sufficient to introduce some basic concepts of microwave filter design and performances. The filter design involves many theoretical approaches: network theory and synthesis, distributed circuit theory, electromagnetic theory. As well as the theory, both practical and technological aspects must be considered. This chapter presents some theoretical fundamentals of microwave filters and some concepts of microwave filter design. Practical examples complete the description. Some of these are intentionally simple in order to point out some common pitfalls in filter design.
8.2 Definitions The need to filter an electrical signal, in order to clean it of many different disturbances, is as old as electromagnetism itself. The oldest filter synthesis techniques were conceived at the beginning of the twentieth century. They were based on the use of cascaded lumped element cells, to reproduce approximately the properties of distributed networks. The filters obtained consisted of cascades of elementary lumped cells, each matched to its two adjacent ones. Moreover, the first (respectively, last) cell matched the source (load). This basic idea is the foundation of the image parameter design method (see [1–3]): the main advantage of the method is its simplicity; the main disadvantage is the limitation in the performances obtainable. Nowadays the image parameter design method is seldom used, its application being limited to special cases such as periodic structures. Nevertheless, it is believed that its basic concepts can still be useful in a number of emerging applications, such as metamaterials and electronic band gap (EBG) structures, without the need for reinventing new methods. The modern filter design approach is based on a different idea, developed between 1920 and 1930. It consists of approximating the response of an ideal filter with mathematical functions which can be realized with real networks. The theoretical foundation of the method is the well-consolidated theory of
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
238
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Loss-free 2-port network Rs [S]
1
Figure 8.1
2
RL
Schematic principle of a filter.
lumped electrical networks. This theory supplies the techniques to identify the physically realizable networks together with the mathematical procedures to synthesize them.1 Here, we consider a filter as a two-port – ideally loss free – placed between a resistive load RL and a source with internal series resistance RS ,2 according to the configuration shown in Figure 8.1. The filter has the function of transferring power from the source to the load with a frequency-dependent attenuation. The frequency ranges of low or high attenuation3 are called passbands or stopbands respectively. Depending on the type of response, filters are classified into four main categories: low pass, high pass, bandpass and bandstop.4 We can characterize the filter by means of the transmission coefficient or scattering parameter s21.5 It can be demonstrated6 that the square amplitude of the transmission coefficient for any lumped network is a rational function of frequency – more precisely, the ratio between two polynomials of the variable o2 : M X 2
js21 j ¼
i¼1 N X
ai o2i ð8:1Þ bi o2i
i¼1
The quantity (8.1) is referred to as the power transfer ratio of the filter or, when expressed in dB, the power gain or, simply, the gain. Since the filter is loss free, conditions (4.99) apply. We rewrite them as js11 j2 ¼ js22 j2 ;
js11 j2 þ js21 j2 ¼ 1
ð8:2Þ
The filter attenuation is measured in dB, and is defined as L ¼ 10 log10 js21 j2 ¼ 20 log10 js21 j
ð8:3Þ
Other parameters can also be used to characterize the filter response: namely, the passband IL (insertion loss) and the RL (return loss). The former quantity is the maximum value of the insertion loss in the passband h i IL ¼ max 10 log10 js21 j2 ¼ LMAX ð8:4Þ
1
The meaning of the word ‘synthesis’ will be made clear later in this chapter. As we saw in Section 4.5, such a source is equivalent to the incident wave on a transmission line having a characteristic impedance equal to RS . 3 The exact definition of the attenuation is given in footnote 5 of this chapter. 4 Also called notch filters in the case of narrow stopbands. 5 Recall that js21 j2 is the ratio between the active power delivered to the load and the incident one (i.e. the available power). Some authors [2, 3] use the power loss ratio PLR , defined as the ratio between the available power and the power delivered to the load. Another widely used quantity is the attenuation, expressed in dB and defined as L ¼ 10 log10 ðPLR Þ. From these definitions, PLR ¼ 1=js21 j2 ; L ¼ 10 log10 ðPLR Þ . 6 See [4]. 2
MICROWAVE FILTERS
239
Conversely, RL is defined as the minimum absolute value (in dB) of the reflection coefficient in the passband h i h i ð8:5Þ RL ¼ min 10 log10 js11 j2 ¼ min 10 log10 ð1js21 j2 Þ From the definitions (8.4) and (8.5), it follows that IL and RL are related by RL ¼ 10 log10 ð110IL=10 Þ
ð8:6Þ
The first step in the filter design process is the approximation. The approximation problem consists of finding the coefficients of the polynomials of Equation (8.1), giving the best match – according to appropriate criteria – between the responses given by (8.1) and the desired one. Once the polynomials have been determined, network theory allows one to synthesize the filter, i.e. to determine the lumped network (including the values of all its elements) having the response given by the function in (8.1). Suitable frequency transforms allow such a procedure to be extended to distributed constant filters, which is the case of interest for microwave applications. Having said that, the most common synthesis procedure for a generic filter starts from a reference lowdpass filter, called the prototype, from which, after suitable transformations, the filter with the desired response can be obtained. In particular instances, different methods are sometimes employed that allow direct synthesis of the microwave filter.
8.3 Lowdpass prototype The prototype is a lumped constant lowdpass filter, having a power transfer ratio js21 j2 approximating the ideal lowdpass response shown in Figure 8.2 as a function of the angular frequency o0. The ideal power transfer ratio equals one or zero depending on whether the angular frequency o0 is smaller or larger than unity, respectively. The corresponding attenuation is zero (or infinite), for o0 < 1 (or o0 > 1), while the power gain is 0 dB (or 1 dB), respectively. The prototype load resistance is assumed to be unitary, without loss of generality: this is equivalent to normalizing all the impedances by RL. The prototype is therefore nothing but a normalized filter, with unitary load resistance and angular frequency. The real filter has cut-off angular frequency equal to o0 and load resistance RL . It is obtained from the prototype by applying the denormalization procedure. The impedance denormalization simply consists of multiplying all impedances by RL. The frequency denormalization, as we will see later in this chapter, consists of scaling all inductances and capacitances of the prototype in such a way that the corresponding reactances at the cut-off frequency remain unchanged. Briefly, all the prototype inductances and capacitances must be divided by o0.
|s21|2 1
O
Figure 8.2
1
ω′
Response of the ideal lowdpass filter.
240
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Five functions like (8.1) are available to approximate the ideal response of Figure 8.2: namely, the Butterworth, Chebyshev,7 Cauer, Bessel and inverse Chebyshev approximations. Here, we will consider the first three, as they are more frequently used with microwave filters.
8.3.1
Butterworth filters
For Butterworth filters, the function (8.1) has the simple form s21; Butterworth ðo0 Þ2 ¼
1 1 þ o0 2N
ð8:7Þ
where N is the filter order and o0 ¼ o=o0 is the normalized angular frequency, so that the cut-off occurs at o0 ¼ 1. We will see later in this chapter that the order of the filter coincides with the number of its elements. As far as the power transfer is concerned, we may note that: .
It is unitary at DC ðo0 ¼ 0Þ.
.
It approaches zero as 1=o0 N when the frequency becomes infinitely large.
.
It equals 1=2 (3.01 dB) at the cut-off angular frequency (o0 ¼ 1) for any order N.
.
All frequency derivatives up to Nth order vanish for o0 ¼ 0. For this reason, Butterworth filters are also referred to as maximally flat.
From Equation (8.6) it follows that Butterworth filters do not present a good matching at the cut-off frequency, where the return loss is only 3.01 dB. For this reason, Butterworth filters are not often used in high-frequency applications.8 Figure 8.3 shows the response of Butterworth filters of orders N ¼ 2 to 7.
8.3.2
Chebyshev filters
The Chebyshev filter offers higher stopband attenuation than its Butterworth counterpart of the same order. Moreover, Chebyshev filters allow the passband attenuation to be controlled as a design parameter. The response is based on the use of Chebyshev polynomials. Such polynomials exploit the property that the cosine of Ny can be expressed as an N-degree polynomial of cosðyÞ, i.e. cosðNyÞ ¼ TN ½cosðyÞ
ð8:8Þ
where TN is the Nth-order Chebyshev polynomial of the variable x ¼ cosðyÞ. We can easily recognize that T0 ðxÞ ¼ 1;
T1 ðxÞ ¼ x;
T2 ðxÞ ¼ 2x2 1
ð8:9Þ
7 We adopt here the most frequently used English transliteration. Other possibilities are Chebysheff or Tchebycheff (German). The latter choice justifies the use of letter T for the homonymous polynomials. 8 A good impedance matching at the ports of the elements of a chain is very important for its performance. To understand this, let us cascade one flat-response amplifier with one filter. The resulting response is reasonably similar to the product of the two responses only if the impedance seen by the amplifier is close to the matched one. A filter return loss of only 3 dB implies that the matching assumption does not hold true, so that the global response of the chain will be quite rippled. The minimum acceptable value for the return loss of the various components depends on the application: as a rule of thumb, from 10 to 12 dB for wide-band components (one octave and more) to 20–25 dB for narrow-band components ðDo=o0 10%Þ.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
241
20 log10[s21(ω)], Butterworth
0 –10 –20 N=2 –30 3
–40 7
–50
6
5
4
–60 0
1
2
3
4
5
ω/ω0
Figure 8.3 Responses of the Butterworth filter for different orders.
Moreover, it is possible to demonstrate the recursive rule TN ðxÞ ¼ 2xTN1 ðxÞ TN2 ðxÞ
ð8:10Þ
The computation of Chebyshev polynomials of any order can thus be performed starting from (8.9) and then applying the recursive relation (8.10). From the point of view of filter design, the interesting properties of Chebyshev polynomials are: (a) jTN ðxÞj 1 for
jxj 1
(b) jTN ðjxj ¼ 1Þj ¼ 1 1 ðodd NÞ (c) jTN ðx ¼ 0Þj ¼ 0 ðeven NÞ (d) limx ! 1 TN ðxÞ ¼ limx ! 1 2N1 xN . Chebyshev polynomials of degrees 1 to 5 are shown in Figure 8.4. Note that, because of property (a), when jxj is less than 1, the Chebyshev polynomial of any degree oscillates between the values 1, touching N1 times the values 1 and 1. Furthermore, because of property (b), the Chebyshev polynomials assume the value 1 or 1 at the extremities of the interval x ¼ 1. The power transfer ratio of Chebyshev filters is expressed as s21;Chebyshev ðo0 Þ2 ¼
1 1 þ e2 TN 2 ðo0 Þ
ð8:11Þ
where N is the filter order, o0 ¼ o=o0 is the normalized angular frequency and e is a parameter determining the maximum passband attenuation. Properties (a), (b) and (c) of Chebyshev polynomials imply the corresponding properties of (8.11): (a0 ) The power transfer ratio oscillates within the interval ½ð1 þ e2 Þ1 ; 1 and the corresponding gain (in dB) ranges from 10 log10 ð1 þ e2 Þ to 0. The quantity RP ¼ 10 log10 ð1 þ e2 Þ is the passband ripple of the Chebyshev response. (b0 ) At the passband edge o0 ¼ 1 the power transfer ratio equals ð1 þ e2 Þ1 for any N.
242
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 8.4
Chebyshev polynomials of degree N ¼ 1, 2, 3, 4, 5.
(c0 ) For o0 ¼ 0, the power transfer ratio equals ð1 þ e2 Þ1 or 1 depending on whether N is even or odd, respectively. (d0 ) For o0 ! 1 the power transfer ratio approaches zero as ðo0 Þ2N e2 22ðN1Þ . The factor ðo0 Þ2N is the same as for Butterworth filters, while the factor9e2 22ðN1Þ is responsible for the higher selectivity of Chebyshev filters. From the property (a0 ), it follows that the parameter e determines the passband gain that oscillates between 1 and ð1 þ e2 Þ1 : for this reason, Chebyshev filters are said to be equiripple (or equal ripple). Figure 8.5 shows some examples of Chebyshev filters having passband ripple RP ¼ 0:5 dB ðe 0:349Þ and order N ¼ 2; 3; . . . ; 7. From consideration (a0 ) and from definition (8.11) it follows that, keeping the order constant, the higher the value of e, the higher the passband ripple and the stopband attenuation as well. Therefore, if we want to increase the stopband attenuation without compromising the passband ripple, we must increase the filter order. This is illustrated in Figure 8.6, which shows the gains of two sets of Chebyshev filters with RP ¼ 0.5 dB (solid lines) and 0.05 dB (dashed lines), and orders N ¼ 5, 7, 9, 11. As anticipated, the filters with lower passband ripple also have lower selectivity. Graphs such as those in Figure 8.6 can be used in the synthesis procedure to determine the order of the filter from its specifications.
9
The factor e2 22ðN1Þ is generally less than 1, unless very small values of e are used.
20 log10[s21(ω)], Chebyshev, RP = 0.5 dB
MICROWAVE FILTERS
243
0 –10 –20 N=2 –30 –40 3 –50
7
6
5
4
–60 0
1
2
3
4
5
ω/ω0
Figure 8.5
Responses of Chebyshev filters with 0.5 dB ripple and orders from 2 to 7. 0 RP = 0.5 dB RP = 0.05 dB
–10
20 log10(|s21(ω)|)
–20 –30 5 –40 5 –50 A –60 –70
11
9
11
9
7 7
–80 0.6
1.0
1.4
1.8
2.2
ω/ω0
Figure 8.6 Responses of odd-order Chebyshev prototypes (N ¼ 5 to 11). The ripple is 0.5 dB (solid lines) and 0.05 dB (dashed lines). EXAMPLE 8.1 Let us determine the order of a Chebyshev lowdpass filter having f0 ¼ 500 MHz cut-off frequency and a minimum stopband attenuation of 50 dB at the frequency of 900 MHz. The first step is the frequency normalization, such that the cut-off angular frequency (o0 ¼ 2pf0 ¼ 2p 5 108 ) corresponds to 1. In this way, the stopband frequency of 900 MHz corresponds to the normalized angular frequency o0 ¼ 900=500 ¼ 1:8. Now, in the diagram of Figure 8.6, let us draw a horizontal line corresponding to the minimum stopband attenuation 20 log10 ðjs21 jÞ ¼ 50 dB and a vertical line crossing the normalized angular frequency o0 ¼ 900=500 ¼ 1:8. The two lines intersect at the point A (1.8; 50). All filters whose responses pass above (below) the crossing point A exhibit a stopband attenuation lower (higher) than the required one. If the required passband ripple is 0.5 dB (0.05 dB) the minimum filter order is 7 (9).
244
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
8.3.3
Cauer filters
The responses of Butterworth and Chebyshev filters are of the all-pole type, since all transmission zeros are located at infinite frequency. Consequently, these filters present a finite attenuation at any finite frequency. The filter selectivity10 can be improved by introducing some transmission zeros at finite frequencies. This idea is applied in Cauer filters, which can be considered as a kind of generalization of Chebyshev filters, obtained by replacing the circular functions with elliptic ones. For this reason, Cauer filters are also known as elliptic filters. The power transfer ratio is s21;Cauer ðo0 Þ2 ¼
1 1 þ e2 FN2 ðo0 Þ
ð8:12Þ
where FN(o0 ) is a rational function having the following properties: (a) Like the Chebyshev polynomials, it oscillates within 1 for jo0 j 1. (b) FN2 ðo0 Þ 1=m0 if o0 2 o1 ¼ 1=m. In the passband (jo0 j 1), Cauer filters show zero attenuation at dN=2e points, while, in the same way as Chebyshev filters, js21 j2 uniformly oscillates between 1 and ð1 þ e2 Þ1 . For even (odd) N we have N/2 ððN þ 1Þ=2Þ attenuation zeros within the interval 0 o0 1. 1=2 In the stopband ðjo0 j 1=m1=2 Þ, js21 j2 oscillates between 0 (infinite attenuation) and 1=ð1 þ em0 Þ. 1=2 At infinite frequency, the power transfer ratio equals 0 ð1=ð1 þ em0 ÞÞ for odd (even) N. Cauer filters allow us to control both the passband (jo0 j 1) and the stopband (jo0 j o1 ) ripples by means of the parameters e and m0 , respectively. Such filters have the drawback that the transmission zeros are located at predetermined frequencies. Another type of filter exists – known as the generalized Chebyshev – exhibiting a uniform passband ripple and having transmission zeros arbitrarily located in the stopband. Unfortunately, since no closed-form expressions exist for the generalized Chebyshev filters, the design can only be performed by numerical methods. Figure 8.7 shows a comparison of fifth-order Butterworth, Chebyshev and Cauer responses. The Butterworth and Chebyshev curves are the same as in Figures 8.3 and 8.5, respectively. Both Chebyshev and Cauer filters have 1 dB passband ripple. It can be seen that the filter selectivity increases from the Butterworth to the Chebyshev to the Cauer. This last has two transmission zeros (attenuation poles) at finite frequencies (oz1 1:13 and oz2 1:51), and a third one at infinity. An expanded view of the passband of the three filters in Figure 8.7 is shown in Figure 8.8. Note that the Butterworth attenuation increases monotonically with the frequency, and reaches the value of 3.01 dB at the cut-off frequency. Both Chebyshev and Cauer attenuations oscillate between 0 and 1 dB, with similar behaviour. In equiripple filters the maximum passband attenuation coincides with the ripple. Now, by virtue of Equation (8.6) which relates the insertion loss and the return loss, passband ripples of 1, 0.5, 0.2, 0.1 and 0.01 dB correspond to return losses of 6.9, 9.6, 13.5, 16.4 and 26.4 dB, respectively. Figure 8.9 shows the return losses of the three filters in Figure 8.8. Note that the uniform passband ripple implies equal local minima of the return loss. The Chebyshev filter is the most frequently used one; compared with the Butterworth, it offers better selectivity and better control of the passband attenuation. The elliptic filter performs better in terms of
10 The selectivity is a parameter determining how fast the filter attenuation increases in the transition from the passband to the stopband.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
245
20 log10[s21(ω)]
0
ω1 = ω0 /0.9
–20
A1 = 20 log10(α1) ≈ –31.6 dB Cauer
–40 Butterworth Chebyshev –60 0
1
2
3
4
5
ω/ω0
Figure 8.7
Responses of fifth-order Butterworth, Chebyshev and Cauer lowdpass filters.
selectivity, but is more difficult to design and realize, therefore its use is limited to the cases where a very sharp selectivity is required to separate closely spaced frequency bands.
8.3.4
Synthesis of the lowdpass prototype
Once the filter response has been selected, be it a Butterworth (Equation (8.7)), Chebyshev (Equation (8.11)) or Cauer (Equation (8.12)) filter, we need to proceed with the filter synthesis: that is, to identify the two-port network of Figure 8.1 possessing such a response.
0 Chebyshev
20 log10[s21(ω)]
Cauer RP = 1 dB
–1
–2
Butterworth
–3 0
1 ω/ω0
Figure 8.8
Expanded view of the passband of Figure 8.7.
246
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 10
0
Butterworth –10
Chebyshev Cauer
–40
20 log10[s11(ω)]
20 log10[s21(ω)]
0 –20
–20
–30
–60 0
1
2
ω/ω0
Figure 8.9
Insertion loss and return loss of the filters plotted in Figure 8.8.
The filter synthesis can be reduced to that of its input impedance11 using a method developed by Darlington. In order to do this, we first need to know the reflection coefficient, which is related to the input impedance by the relation Zin ðqÞ ¼ R0
1 þ s11 ðqÞ 1 s11 ðqÞ
ð8:13Þ
where q ¼ s þ jo is the complex frequency12 and R0 is the normalizing impedance. Note that the prototype has R0 ¼ 1, by definition. The first synthesis step consists of determining s11 from js21 j2 . Let us illustrate the procedure. It can be proved that the scattering parameters of a real network satisfy the relation shk ðjoÞ ¼ s*hk ðjoÞ;
h; k ¼ 1; 2
ð8:14Þ
It follows that js11 ðjoÞj2 ¼ s11 ðjoÞs11 ðjoÞ hence, by Equation (8.2), we have s11 ðjoÞs11 ðjoÞ ¼ 1s21 ðjoÞs21 ðjoÞ ¼ 1js21 j2
ð8:15Þ
By applying a mathematical operation known as analytical prolongation we can extend the validity of Equation (8.15) from the imaginary axis (q ¼ jo) to the whole complex plane (q ¼ s þ jo), so obtaining the Feldtkeller equation s11 ðqÞs11 ðqÞ ¼ 1js21 ðqÞj2
ð8:16Þ
11 It can be proved that for a lumped two-port network the input impedance Zin ðqÞ is a real positive function of the complex frequency q ¼ s þ jo, i.e. it is real for real q and positive for s > 0. 12 The complex frequency coincides with the Laplace transform variable, and is typically indicated by lower case s. Here, lower case q is chosen to avoid confusion with the scattering parameters that are also functions of the complex frequency.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
247
From Equation (8.16) it follows that: 1. The poles of the reflection coefficient coincide with those of the transmission coefficient. 2. The reflection zero frequencies coincide with the frequencies of the unitary transmission coefficient. In the Butterworth case we have N zeros coincident with the origin. In the Chebyshev and Cauer cases, we have N zeros symmetrically placed along the imaginary axis.13 3. The square amplitude of the reflection coefficient includes the poles of both s11 ðqÞ and s11 ðqÞ. We can separate the former from the latter, considering that the poles of s11 ðqÞ present a negative real part. By exploiting the above properties, we can find the poles and zeros of the reflection coefficient, which can then be expressed in the form N Y
s11 ðqÞ ¼ r0 k¼1 N Y
q zk ð8:17Þ q pk
k¼1
where zk and pk are the zeros and poles of s11 , respectively. To complete the description of the reflection coefficient we still need to determine the factor r0. This can be obtained by making Equation (8.16) hold for one convenient value of the q, for instance q ¼ j. Note that (8.16) allows us to find r0 apart from its sign. Equation (8.13) shows that changing the sign of the reflection coefficient corresponds to transforming the input impedance into the input admittance. This is equivalent to swapping the network with its dual network. From a physical point of view, the dual network is obtained from the original one by replacing inductors with capacitors and vice versa, and by replacing series with shunt connections and vice versa. It follows that the dual network exhibits an identical response to the original one, thus a prototype may be equally realized in both forms. The second step of the synthesis procedure consists of determining the network from its input impedance. Without going into details, for our purposes it suffices to say that the procedure consists of N elementary synthesis steps, each reducing the complexity of the network. At each step an elementary term such as sL; sC; sL þ 1=sC; 1=sL þ sC is synthesized as an (inductor, capacitor, series LC cell, parallel LC cell), respectively, and subtracted from the immittance14 being synthesized. The resultant immittance consists of the series (or parallel) of such a term and a residual immittance which is a positive real function of lower order. By successive applications of this procedure, the entire network is synthesized in exactly N steps, giving a ladder network. In the case of all-pole filters (Butterworth and Chebyshev), one of the two ladder networks shown in Figures 8.10a,b is obtained, one being the dual of the other. Such networks are said to be canonical, since they realize the assigned response with the minimum number of elements. In the case of elliptic function filters, the resulting ladder networks have the more complicated structure shown in Figures 8.11a,b. The network in Figure 8.11a (8.11b) derives from Figure 8.10a (8.10b) by replacing the even elements with series (parallel) LC cells. The resonant frequency of each cell realizes one of the finite-frequency transmission zeros of the Cauer filter.
13 For instance, in the Chebyshev response of Figure 8.9, we have that js21 j ¼ 1 (0 dB) at o ¼ 0, 0.588o0, 0.951o0. The figure does not show the negative frequencies; the amplitude response, however, is symmetrical around the y axis. 14 The generic term immittance denotes either the impedance or the admittance.
248
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING L1 1
L3
LN-2
C2
C4
LN CN-1
2 (a)
L2 1
C1
L4
LN-1
C3
CN-2
CN
2 (b)
Figure 8.10 Canonical all-pole lowdpass filters. The source and the load are not shown; the former is to be connected to port 1, the latter to port 2. The cases illustrated here are for odd N. For even N the last element of the network in (a) (resp. (b)) is a capacitor (inductor).
L1
L3
L N-2 L N
C2
C4
C N-1
L2
L4
L N-1
1
2 (a)
L2
L4
L N-1
C2
C4
C N-1
1
2 C1
C3
C N-2
CN
(b)
Figure 8.11 Canonical elliptic lowdpass filters. The source and the load are not shown, as in Figure 8.10. Illustrated here are the cases for odd N. For even N the last element is a resonant circuit.
As given in Table 8.1, closed-form expressions are available for calculating the filters of Figure 8.10 [2]. Note that the filters are symmetrical, i.e. gk ¼ gNk . Tables listing the values obtained from the formulae15 of Table 8.1 are available in some books (see e.g. [2]). As for elliptic filters, unfortunately no closed-form expressions are available. The synthesis thus requires the use of numerical methods. Element values can be found in [4]. At this point, we must observe that even-order Chebyshev and Cauer filters exhibit non-zero DC attenuation, i.e. js21 ð0Þj < 1. At zero frequency (DC) the filters of Figure 8.10 simply correspond to the direct connection of the output with the input port; therefore a non-zero DC attenuation is achieved if and only if the load resistance differs from the source ðRS 6¼ RL Þ. Such a condition is not desirable in practical cases; therefore most Chebyshev and Cauer lowdpass filters are chosen to be of odd order.
15 The interested reader can use the Mathcad file 02_Low_Pass_Prototype_Coefficients.MCD, which automatically computes all the Butterworth and Chebyshev prototype coefficients of arbitrary order and ripple.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
249
Table 8.1 Formulae for the computation of the prototypes in Figure 8.10. g0 ¼ 1
Butterworth
ð2k1Þp ðk ¼ 1; 3; . . . ; NÞ 2N gn þ 1 ¼ 1 8 e > > b ¼ ln coth > > 40 logðeÞ > > > > > > > > g ¼ sinh b > > < 2N > > 2k1 > 2 kp 2 > ¼ sin ¼ g þ sin a p ; b ðk ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; NÞ > k k > > 2N N > > > > > > 2a 4a a > : g1 ¼ 1 ; gk ¼ k1 k ðk ¼ 2; 3; . . . ; NÞ g bk1 gk1 gk ¼ 2sin
Chebyshev
Lk ¼ Ck ¼ gk
ðk ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; NÞ
Table 8.2 Values of the lowdpass filter elements of Examples 8.1 and 8.2. k¼ gk ¼ gNk
1 1.737
R0 gk o0 gk Ck ¼ CNk ¼ o0 R0 R0 gk Lk ¼ LNk ¼ o0 gk Ck ¼ CNk ¼ o0 R0 Lk ¼ LNk ¼
2 1.258
4 1.344
Figure
8.011012
8.561012
8.10a
20.03109
21.40109
27.65109
3 2.638 41.99109
8.011012
16.801012
8.10b
EXAMPLE 8.2 (continued from Example 8.1) We wish to realize the filter of Example 8.1, choosing the first option: RP ¼ 0.5 dB, N ¼ 7. Applying the synthesis formulae for the Chebyshev prototype (second line of Table 8.1), we get the normalized values16 quoted in the second row of Table 8.2. Now, we choose the load and the source impedance of the filter as RS ¼ RL ¼ 50 O. After denormalizing with respect to both frequency and impedance, we get the following values of the prototype elements: Lk ¼ gk
R0 50 ¼ gk ; o0 2p 50 106
Ck ¼ gk
1 1 ¼ gk o0 R0 2p 50 106 50
The values of the ladder network in Figure 8.10a are quoted in the third and fourth rows of Table 8.2. The fifth and sixth rows list the values of the dual filter in Figure 8.10b. Both networks are seen to be symmetrical.
16 Such values can also be computed by means of the Mathcad file 05_Low_Pass_Example2.MCD, annexed with Chapter 9.
250
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
8.4 Semi-lumped lowdpass filters The filters considered so far are realized by using lumped elements. In RF and microwave practice, a circuit element can be considered as lumped if its physical size – defined as the maximum among length, width and depth – is sufficiently smaller than the wavelength. In this definition, the wavelength to be considered is the smallest one, corresponding to the highest frequency of interest. Needless to say, the concept of ‘sufficiently smaller’ is quite vague, the definition depending on the required degree of approximation. As a rule of thumb, an element is considered to be lumped when its size is smaller than one-tenth of the wavelength. For instance, a capacitor of size equal to 1 mm behaves as a lumped element up to the frequency fMAX ¼ v=l ¼ 3 108 =0:01 ¼ 30 GHz. In this example we have assumed propagation in a vacuum (v ¼ 3 108 m=s); should a different dielectric be used, the propagation velocity will be pffiffiffiffi reduced by a factor 1= er and thus the maximum frequency. In the subsequent sections of this chapter, we will discuss the techniques for the synthesis of distributed filters, which are more suited and used practically at microwave frequencies. Within certain frequency limits, however, a simpler approach based on so-called semi-lumped elements can be adopted, where inductors and capacitors are realized with short segments of transmission lines having high and low characteristic impedances, respectively. Consider the two-port network shown in Figure 8.12a. It consists of a transmission line segment having characteristic impedance Z0 , propagation velocity v and physical length l; at the angular frequency o, the phase constant is then b ¼ o/v. Using Equation (4.120), the impedance matrix of the network is 2 3 l l cot o 1=sin o 7 6 z11 z12 v v 7 6 7 ð8:18Þ ¼ j Z0 6 5 4 l l z21 z22 1=sin o cot o v v From Equations (8.18) and (4.60), considering the network identity of Figure 4.15, we obtain the equivalent network of Figure 8.12b. The impedances of the two series branches and of the shunt branch are l lo 1 cos o 1 12 sin2 lo v v2 ¼ j Z0 ¼ j Z0 tan Zseries branches ¼ z11 z21 ¼ j Z0 l lo lo v2 sin o 2 sin cos v v2 v2 l Zshunt branch ¼ z21 ¼ j Z0 cot o v
Z11 – Z21
L
Z 0, v
1
2
(a)
1
2
(b)
1
L 2
C
(c)
Figure 8.12 Transmission line segment: (a) symbol and characteristic parameters; (b) equivalent network; (c) simplified low-frequency equivalent network.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
251
Under the assumption of short transmission line (l l ) ol=v p=2), we can approximate the tangent with its argument. Hence the above expressions simplify to Zseries branches ffi j Z0
lo ; v2
Zshunt branch ffi j Z0
v1 lo
The characteristic impedance and the propagation velocity are related to the distributed inductance L0 and capacitance C0 of the line by Z0 ¼
rffiffiffiffiffiffi L0 ; C0
1 v ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi L0 C0
We then finally obtain the following expressions for impedances of the network in Figure 8.12b: Zseries branches ¼ z11 z12 ¼ j Z0 tan
Zshunt branch ¼ z12 ¼ z21 ¼
l Z0 l o ffij o ¼ joL 2v 2v
j Z0 1 1 ffi ¼ l l joC j o sin o Z0 v v
ð8:19Þ
where we have put L¼
Z0 l L0 ¼ l; 2 2v
C¼
l ¼ C0 l Z0 v
We can easily recognize that the two impedances given by (8.19) represent one inductor having inductance L and one capacitor having capacitance C, respectively. Therefore, if the line length is sufficiently smaller than the wavelength, the simplified equivalent T network of Figure 8.12c approximates the one of Figure 8.12b. Equation (8.19) states that the total inductance (capacitance) of the approximated network equals the global distributed inductance (capacitance) of the transmission line segment. Note also that L (C) increases (decreases) with Z0 . At this point, let us assume that the two ports of the line segment are terminated with impedance ZL. Two interesting cases can be considered, depending on whether the characteristic impedance of the line is much higher or much smaller than the terminating impedance. In the former case (Z0 ZL), the shunt capacitance of the network in Figure 8.12c becomes so small as to be negligible. The equivalent circuit reduces to a series inductance 2L ¼ L0 l. The dual situation occurs when Z ZL : the two series inductors can be neglected and the equivalent circuit reduces to a shunt capacitance C ¼ C0 l. In summary, a short transmission line segment with high (low) characteristic impedance17 is approximately equivalent to a series inductor (shunt capacitor) whose inductance (capacitance) is equal to the line inductance (capacitance) per unit length multiplied by the line length. The design of a semi-lumped lowdpass filter consists of replacing inductors and capacitors in the networks of Figure 8.10 or 8.11(suitably denormalized) with corresponding short segments of high- and low-impedance transmission lines, respectively. Such impedances have to be selected before the physical lengths of the line segments are determined. Although in principle other choices might be possible, in order to simplify the design and to obtain the best stopband performances, the highest (Z0max ) and lowest (Z0min ) impedances that can be realized with the given technology (stripline, microstrip, coplanar line, etc.) are selected. 17
High and low are defined with respect to the terminating impedance.
252
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING ðLÞ
ðCÞ
The lengths of the transmission line lk and lk corresponding to the inductance Lk and capacitance Ck, respectively, are then given by vM ðLÞ ðCÞ lk ¼ max Lk ; lk ¼ Z0min vm Ck ð8:20Þ Z0 Note that unless the line is TEM, the phase velocity depends on the line geometry. Therefore different impedances generally imply different velocities; that is why in expressions (8.20) two velocities (vM ; vm ) have been used, corresponding to the impedances (Z0max ; Z0min ). The dependence of the velocity on the impedance typically occurs in the microstrip.18
EXAMPLE 8.3 Let us design a semi-lumped lowdpass filter in coaxial cable technology, having a Chebyshev response of order N ¼ 15, passband ripple RP ¼ 0.1 dB, cut-off frequency equal to 7.6 GHz (corresponding to the angular cut-off frequency o0 ¼ 2p 7:6 109 rad/s), and load and source impedances R0 ¼ 50 O. We choose to realize the filter starting from the ladder network of Figure 8.10a (inductive input). It follows that the odd index elements are inductors and the even index ones are capacitors. The synthesis formulae of Table 8.1 yield the prototype coefficients listed in the third row of Table 8.2. After frequency (divide all the values by o0 ) and impedance (multiply the inductances and divide the capacitances by R0 ) denormalization, we obtain the values of the lumped filter quoted in the fourth and fifth rows of Table 8.3. As discussed above, the first synthesis step consists of determining the maximum and minimum characteristic impedance allowed by the given technology. To understand this point better, we need to look at the final aspect of the filter, shown in Figure 8.13. Each low-impedance segment (capacitor) consists of a dielectric-filled coaxial cable with outer diameter douter ¼ 7 mm, inner diameter
Figure 8.13
18
Exploded view of the filter discussed in Example 8.3.
See the graphs in Figure 3.25.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
253
Table 8.3 Values of the filter discussed in Example 8.3. k N þ 1k gk ¼ gNk Lk ¼ LNk Ck ¼ CNk lL;k ¼ lL;Nk lC;k ¼ lC;Nk
1 15
2 14
3 13
4 12
5 11
6 10
7 9
8 8
1.21 1.267 — 2.172 —
1.461 — 0.612 — 0.618
2.166 2.268 — 3.888 —
1.646 — 0.689 — 0.696
2.26 2.366 — 4.056 —
1.678 — 0.703 — 0.709
2.28 2.388 — 4.093 —
1.684 — 0.705 — 0.712
nH pF mm mm
dinner;low ¼ 5 mm and dielectric constant er ¼ 6. The outer diameter has been chosen to be equal to that of the connector so as to minimize the resultant discontinuity. The inner diameter is determined by the technological limitations associated with the realization of the pipe-shaped dielectric cladding, which has to provide the necessary mechanical support and remove the heat produced by the dissipation. The minimum allowed thickness of the dielectric pipe is 1 mm. The minimum impedance and the associated propagation velocity are then found to be 60 7 3 108 ffi 8:42 O; vm ¼ pffiffiffi ffi 1:225 108 m=s: Z0min ¼ pffiffiffi ln 5 6 6 The presence of the dielectric pipe along the whole filter is such that the high-impedance segments are non-homogeneous. The outer diameter is still 7 mm, but the inner diameter has to be minimized to get the maximum possible impedance. The technological constraints require dinner;high ¼ 1 mm. The computation of the impedance and the propagation velocity of the high-impedance segments is not straightforward because of the inhomogeneous filling. Without going into detail, we simply report the final results: 60 7 7 3 108 pffiffiffi ln ffi 47:7 < Z0max ffi 71:45 O < 60ln ffi 116:7; pffiffiffi < vM ffi 1:837 108 m=s < 3 108 1 1 6 6 Applying the design formulae in (8.20), we obtain the lengths of the inductive and capacitive segments, given in the last two rows of Table 8.3. Figure 8.13 shows an exploded view of the filter. It includes: .
Two coaxial input and output connectors (C1, C2).
.
The outer conductor of the coaxial cables, realized with two symmetrical parts B1 and B2.
.
The coaxial cable inner conductor (A), consisting of 15 cylindrical elements, alternatively narrow (inductors) and wide (capacitors).
.
The dielectric pipe (D), which mechanically supports the inner conductor, keeping it coaxial with the outer one.
The filter is assembled by inserting A within D, tightening B1 and B2 around D, and finally fixing the two connectors C1 and C2 at the filter ends. The real dimensions of the realized filter differ slightly from those listed in Table 8.3, the symmetry still being preserved. The reason for this discrepancy is that the semi-lumped design is based on approximate design equations. Moreover, parasitic capacitances are present at the junctions between high- and low-impedance sections. All such second-order effects can be compensated for by changing the element lengths, using computer-based simulation and optimization. The total length of the realized filter, including the connectors, is approximately 50 mm.
254
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 0
20 log10(|s21|)
–20
–40
noise floor
measured simulated
–60 lumped-constant –80 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
Frequency, GHz
Figure 8.14
Responses of the filters discussed in Example 8.3.
Figure 8.14 shows the responses of the simulated and realized filter. For comparison, the response of the ideal lumped filter is also plotted, showing an increasing stopband attenuation, which becomes infinitely large as the frequency approaches infinity. The response of the semi-lumped filter, on the contrary, is non-monotonic, since the cascade of transmission line segments has no attenuation poles. Finally, we observe that the measured stopband attenuation flattens to about 43 dB at frequencies higher than 10 GHz. This behaviour is not a characteristic of the filter, rather it is due to the noise floor of the test instrument employed.19 The return loss of the lumped filter is 16.4 dB (corresponding to 0.1 dB passband ripple). The simulated response – after optimization – presents a similar value, while the measured filter is slightly degraded: its return loss is about 13 dB (not shown in the figure).
8.5 Frequency transformations The synthesis of highpass, bandpass and bandstop filters can be obtained by applying to the lowdpass prototype suitable frequency transformations of the type o0 ¼ f ðoÞ
ð8:21Þ
0
20
where o is the prototype frequency and o is the frequency of the desired filter. Equation (8.21), the prototype response is modified to
As a consequence of
js21 ðo0 Þj2 ¼ js21 ½ f ðoÞj2 Correspondingly, the reactances of the various prototype o0 L0 ¼ f ðoÞL; 19
21
ð8:22Þ
elements L0 and C0 become
1 1 ¼ o0 C0 f ðoÞC
ð8:23Þ
See Section 17.6. Here we used the abbreviated form ‘frequency’ instead of ‘angular frequency’ or ‘radian frequency’, for the sake of simplicity. The Greek letter o, however, always denotes the angular frequency. 21 In order to avoid confusion, from this point to the end of the section we will mark the quantities relative to the prototype with a prime 0 ; those without a prime refer to the transformed filter. 20
MICROWAVE FILTERS
255
Therefore, the mapping function f ðoÞ not only has to provide the required frequency mapping, but also must be such that the reactances on the right of (8.23) are physically realizable. An almost trivial frequency transform is the frequency denormalization, already discussed in the previous section. The change in the cut-off frequency from one to an arbitrary value can be seen in fact as a simple frequency transformation. If o0 is the filter cut-off, we have o0 ¼ f ðoÞ ¼
o o0
The reactances (8.23) then become o0 L0 ¼ o
L0 ¼ oL; o0
1 1 1 ¼ ¼ o0 C0 oC0 =o0 oC
As previously found, L ¼ L0 =o0 ; C ¼ C0 =o0 are the inductances and capacitances of the frequency denormalized filter. The frequency transformation affects neither the impedance of the filter, nor the passband and stopband attenuations; in particular, it does not change the passband ripple. In addition to the frequency transformation, the synthesis of any of the filters considered here requires also the impedance denormalization. The order of the two operations does not matter. In the remaining sections, we will clarify the application of the above concepts by means of two examples, both based on the fifth-order Chebyshev prototype with 0.1 dB passband ripple RP. We will denote it as the reference prototype. By applying the synthesis formulae of Table 8.1, we get the reference prototype coefficients: g1 ¼ g5 ¼ 1:147, g2 ¼ g4 ¼ 1:371, g3 ¼ 1:975.
8.5.1
Lowdpass to highpass transformation
Apart from the frequency scaling, the simplest frequency transform is the lowdpass to highpass transformation jo0 ¼
1 jo
ð8:24Þ
Equation (8.24) maps the origin into infinity and vice versa, while the cut-off frequency (unitary) is invariant to the transformation.22 Applying the lowdpass to highpass transformation to the reference prototype, we get the response shown in Figure 8.15. Note that the passband extends from the unit frequency up to infinity, while the stopband23 coincides with the interval [0; 1). Moreover, Figure 8.15 shows an expanded view of the passband gain, plotted on the right y axis. The highpass filter exhibits a uniform passband ripple of 0.1 dB, like the reference prototype it is derived from. From the network point of view, the application of Equation (8.24) to the prototype transforms inductors into capacitors and vice versa. Indeed, the respective impedances become ZL ¼ jo0 L0 ¼
L0 1 ; ¼ jo joC ðHPÞ
ZC ¼
1 jo ¼ ¼ joLðHPÞ jo0 C 0 C0
22 Keep in mind that the frequency response of the filter is defined for both positive and negative values of the frequency. Furthermore, the ideal realization of the filter implies that s21 ðoÞ ¼ s21 ðoÞ* . 23 The cited interval includes both the stopband and the transition band. The exact definition of the respective limits depends on the specified stopband attenuation.
0
0.1
–10
0.0
–20
–0.1
–30
–0.2
–40
–0.3
Highpass 20 log10(|s21|)
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Highpass 20 log10(|s21|)
256
–0.4
–50 0
1
2
3
4
5
ω
Figure 8.15
Response of the highpass filter derived from the reference prototype.
(HP)
C1
(HP)
1
Figure 8.16
(HP)
(HP)
C3
L2
(HP)
CN-2 CN (HP)
(HP)
L4
L N-1
2
Schematic of the lumped highpass filter derived from the network of Figure 8.10a.
where CðHPÞ ¼ 1=L0 and LðHPÞ ¼ 1=C0 are the capacitor and the inductor corresponding to the prototype inductor L0 and capacitor C0 , respectively.24 From the canonical lowdpass filter of Figure 8.10a we obtain the filter in Figure 8.16, where the component values are the reciprocals of those of the prototype:25 ðHPÞ
Lk
¼
1 Ck0
ðeven kÞ;
ðHPÞ
Ck
¼
1 L0k
ðodd kÞ
ð8:25Þ
The filter obtained has unitary impedance and cut-off frequency; if we want the generic impedance R0 and cut-off frequency o0, we need to denormalize the impedance and frequency. From the expression (8.25), we obtain ðHPÞ
Lk
¼
1 R0 ; Ck0 o0
ðHPÞ
Ck
¼
1 1 1 L0k o0 R0
ð8:26Þ
24 It must be pointed out that the prototype synthesis formulae of Table 8.1 assume o0 ¼ 1 and L0 ¼ gk ; C 0 ¼ gk (with the proper index even or odd for inductors and capacitors). 25 Starting from the dual network of Figure 8.10b, we obtain the dual network of Figure 8.16. In this case, the odd elements are shunt inductors and the even elements are series capacitors. Concerning the component values, Equation (8.25) holds true, but with interchanged even and odd indexes. In any case, the frequency transformation conserves the symmetry of the prototype.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
257
EXAMPLE 8.4 The synthesis of a fifth-order highpass filter having 500 MHz cut-off frequency (o0 ¼ 2p 500 106 rad/s) and R0 ¼ 50 O reference impedance. Starting from the prototype and applying Equations (8.26), we get ðHPÞ
C1
8.5.2
ðHPÞ
¼ C5
¼ 5:551 pF;
ðHPÞ
C3
¼ 3:223 pF;
ðHPÞ
L2
ðHPÞ
¼ L4
¼ 11:607 nH
Lowdpass to bandpass transformation
In high-frequency applications the most interesting type of filter is the bandpass filter. This is because bandpass filters are widely employed to separate radio signals into their different frequency components. The lumped element bandpass filter derives from the lowdpass prototype by the application of the following lowdpass to bandpass transform: o0 o o0 ð8:27Þ jo0 ¼ j o2 o1 o0 o pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where o1 ; o2 are the lower limit and upper limit of the passband, and o0 ¼ o1 o2 (not to be confused with the cut-off frequency of the lowdpass filter). Note that o0 is slightly smaller than the centre of the passband ðo2 þ o1 Þ=2. The two values tend to coincide for very narrow-band responses, i.e. for o2 o1 ðo2 þ o1 Þ=2. By inverting Equation (8.27) we obtain a second-order equation that can be solved in order to write o as a function of o0 s ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 0 o ðo o Þ o0 ðo2 o1 Þ 2 2 1 2 0 2 o o ðo2 o1 Þo o0 ¼ 0 ) o ¼ þ o1 o2 2 2 This equation shows that each frequency o0 of the prototype maps into two different frequencies of the bandpass response. Table 8.4 shows the corresponding values of o0 and o. The prototype passband o0 2 ð1; 1Þ maps into the two intervals ðo2 ; o1 Þ and ðo1 ; o2 Þ of the bandpass, while the negative portion (o0 < 1) of the prototype stopband transforms into the intervals (1; o2 ) and (o1 ; 0). Similarly the positive stopband frequencies of the prototype (o0 > 1) map into the two intervals (o2 ; 1) and (o1 ; 0). Note that, in contrast with the lowdpass to highpass transformation, which does not modify the cutoff frequency, Equation (8.27) leads to a non-normalized cut-off frequency. Therefore, the filter values obtained from such a transformation need no frequency denormalization. Figure 8.17 shows the response of the bandpass filter resulting from the application of the transform (8.27) to the reference prototype. The black curve, plotted on the left y axis, is the transmission coefficient, expressed in dB, that is the negative of the attenuation. The grey curve, plotted on the right y axis, is the reflection coefficient in dB, coincident with the negative of the return loss. The attenuation of the bandpass filter uniformly oscillates within the passband o 2 ½o1 ; o1 , with the same RP ¼ 0.1 dB ripple as the reference prototype. The frequency behaviour of the reflection coefficient is somewhat complementary to the attenuation in accordance with relation (8.6). When js21 j ¼ 1 ) IL ¼ 0 dB we have js11 j ¼ 0 ) RL ¼ 1 dB, and when IL ¼ RP dB (which is Table 8.4 Mapped points of the lowdpass to bandpass transformation. o0 o
0 o0
1 o1 ; o2
1 o2 ; o1
1 0, 1
þ1 0, þ 1
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Bandpass, 20 log10(|s21|)
0
10
s21
–10
0
–20
–10
–30
–20
–40
–30
s11
–50
ω1
ω0
Bandpass, 20 log10(|s11|)
258
–40
ω2
ω
Figure 8.17
Bandpass response after the transformation from the reference prototype.
the maximum passband attenuation) we have the minimum passband return loss RL ¼ 10 log10 ð110RP=10 Þ ffi 16:4 dB. Note also that the return loss exhibits a number of spikes (ideally having infinite amplitude) equal to the filter order, which is five in our case. This observation is the basis for a widely used evaluation criterion: a well-designed and realized bandpass filter shows as many return loss spikes as the order of its prototype. We will see shortly that the number of resonators included in a bandpass filter coincides with the prototype order.26 From the network point of view, Equation (8.27) transforms the impedance of one inductor (capacitor) into that of a series (parallel) resonant LC cell, according to jo0 L0 ¼ jo jo0 C0 ¼ jo
L0 1 o20 L0 1 þ ¼ joLLb þ joCLb o2 o1 jo o2 o1
1 o20 C0 1 C0 þ ¼ joCCb þ o2 o1 joLCb o2 o1 jo
These expressions show that the reactances of the inductors (or, respectively, susceptances of the capacitors) are transformed into series (parallel) LC cells. The component values of the series and parallel LC cells are series LC: parallel LC:
LLb ¼ CCb
L0 ; o2 o1 C0 ¼ ; o2 o1
CLb ¼ LCb
o2 o1 1 o20 L0 o2 o1 1 ¼ o20 C0
ð8:28Þ
It can be seen that both cell types have the same resonant frequency 1 1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ o0 LLb CLb LCb CCb 26 Sometimes the prototype order, or the number of resonators, which is the same thing, is simply referred to as the ‘bandpass’ order. This denomination, however, is somewhat improper.
MICROWAVE FILTERS (BP) (BP)
(BP) (BP)
C1 L1
(BP) (BP)
C3 L3
L(BP) 2
1
259
CN LN
C(BP) L(BP) 2 N-1
C(BP) N-1
Bandpass filter derived from the reference prototype.
Figure 8.18
Remember also that o0 is the frequency corresponding to o0 ¼ 0 in the lowdpass prototype. At the resonant frequency o ¼ o0, the series (parallel) LC cells become short circuits (open circuits). The same things happens with the originating elements of the prototype: at zero frequency (o0 ¼ 0) the prototype inductors (capacitors) become short circuits (open circuits). The above considerations imply that a bandpass filter includes as many resonators as the order of its prototype, the term resonator being used to designate both series and parallel LC cells. This result is even more general and can also be applied to distributed filters. In such a case the term resonator will denote distributed elements or a combination of lumped and distributed elements, such as capacitive coupled lines, open-circuit and short-circuit stubs, capacitively loaded stubs, etc. While the lowdpass to bandpass transform does not need a frequency denormalization, the impedance denormalization is still needed. This simple operation consists of multiplying all inductances and dividing all capacitances – of both the series and parallel LC cells – by the given source and load resistance R0. At the end of the procedure, starting from the reference filter of Figure 8.10a, we obtain the filter shown in Figure 8.18, with the component values ðBPÞ
gk R0 ; o2 o1
ðBPÞ
Lk
¼
Ck
ðBPÞ Lk
o2 o1 R0 ¼ ; o20 gk
¼
ðBPÞ Ck
o2 o1 1 o20 gk R0
ðodd kÞ
1 gk ¼ o2 o1 R0
ðeven kÞ
ð8:29Þ
EXAMPLE 8.5 The synthesis of a bandpass filter with 500–700 MHz passband (o1 ¼ 2p 500 106 , o2 ¼ 2p 700 106 ) and R0 ¼ 50 O impedance, starting from the reference prototype (Chebyshev, N ¼ 5; RP ¼ 0:1 dB). The filter schematic is shown in Figure 8.18. The component values must be computed by applying Equations (8.29) to the prototype coefficients. Table 8.5 lists the resulting values.
Table 8.5 Values of the bandpass filter discussed in Example 8.5. k gk ¼ gNk ðBPÞ Lk ðBPÞ
Ck
¼
ðBPÞ LNk ðBPÞ
1
2
3
4
5
1.147
1.371
1.975
1.371
1.147
3.316
78.583
3.316
45.63
45.63
¼ CNk
1.586
21.824
0.921
21.824
1.586
Series or parallel LC
S
P
S
P
S
nH pF
260
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
8.5.3
Lowdpass to bandstop transformation
The bandstop filter – also known as a notch in the case of a very narrow passband – shows high attenuation in a small portion of the frequency band and low attenuation elsewhere. As its name suggests, it is used to eliminate unwanted signals falling within a given bandwidth. Thus, the operation of the bandstop filter is the opposite of the bandpass one. The lowdpass to bandstop transformation is jo0 ¼ j
o2 o1 o o 0 2 o2
ð8:30Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where o1 ; o2 are the lower and upper edges of the stopband, and o0 ¼ o1 o2 approximates the centre of the stopband in the narrow-band case, as pointed out in Section 8.5.2 for the bandpass filter. Equation (8.30) can also be derived by consecutively applying the highpass and bandpass transformations described earlier. In other words, Equation (8.30) follows from (8.27) by substituting jo0 with 1=ðjoÞ. Applying the same procedure in Section 8.5.2, we find that Equation (8.30) maps: .
the stopband edges (o ¼ o1 ; o2 ) into the prototype cut-off frequencies (o0 ¼ 1; 1);
.
the ‘centre’ frequency (o ¼ o0 ) into the prototype infinite frequency (o0 ¼ 1);
.
the minimum and maximum frequencies (o ¼ 0; 1) into the prototype zero frequency (o0 ¼ 0).
Figure 8.19 shows the transmission and reflection coefficients (both in dB) of a bandstop filter derived from the reference prototype. Again, the passband ripple (return loss) is RP ¼ 0.1 dB (16.4 dB), as in the prototype. From the network point of view, applying the same procedures used in Sections 8.5.1 and 8.5.2, we find that Equation (8.30) transforms the series inductors (shunt capacitors) of the prototype into parallel (series) LC cells. Both transformed cells resonate at the frequency o0. Consequently, starting from the
Bandstop, 20 log10(|s21|)
–10
s21
0
–20
–10
–30
–20
–40
–30
Bandstop, 20 log10(|s11|)
10
0
s11 –50
Figure 8.19
ω1 ω0 ω
ω2
–40
Response of a bandstop filter derived from the reference prototype.
MICROWAVE FILTERS (SB)
(SB)
L1
(SB)
1
C1
Figure 8.20
261
(SB)
L3
LN
(SB) C3 (SB) L2 (SB) C2
(SB) CN (SB) LN-1 (SB) CN-1
2
Lumped constant bandstop filter.
network of Figure 8.10a, we obtain the filter of Figure 8.20, having the following component values (denormalized): ðSBÞ
o2 o1 gk R0 ; o20
ðSBÞ
1 1 o2 o1 gk R0
Lk
¼
ðSBÞ Lk
1 R0 o2 o1 gk ðSBÞ ¼ ; Ck ¼ o2 o1 gk o0 2 R0
Ck
¼
ðodd kÞ ð8:31Þ
ðeven kÞ
EXAMPLE 8.6 The synthesis of a bandstop filter having 1.9–2.1 GHz stopband limits (o1 ¼ 2p 1:9 109 , o2 ¼ 2p 2:1 109 ), source and load impedance R0 ¼ 50 O, starting from the reference prototype. The filter has the schematic shown in Figure 8.20. Its components are computed by applying Equations (8.31) to the prototype coefficients. The resulting values are quoted in Table 8.6.
8.5.4
Richards transformation
All the filters considered so far, with the exception of the semi-lumped filters discussed in Section 8.4, are built from lumped constant elements. Therefore, those filters require – by definition – the use of elements having a much smaller size than the minimum wavelength. The high-frequency applications, which this book is focused on, involve quite small wavelengths, so that in most instances the lumped hypothesis cannot be applied. In Section 8.4 we found that a maximum frequency of 30 GHz requires components smaller than 1 mm if the dielectric is air or a vacuum ðer ¼ 1Þ. This is quite an optimistic consideration, since common dielectric materials have much higher permittivities (usually in the range 2–10) than a vacuum; the maximum allowed size is therefore pffiffiffiffi reduced by the factor 1= er.
Table 8.6 Component values of the filter described in Example 8.6. k
1, 5
2, 4
3
gk ¼ gNk
1.147
1.371
1.975
0.457
29.017
0.788
nH
13.878
0.219
8.058
pF
P
S
P
ðSBÞ
¼ LNk
ðSBÞ
¼ CNk
Lk
Ck
ðSBÞ
ðSBÞ
Series or parallel LC
262
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The above considerations suggest the use of distributed constant elements for the realization of microwave filters. The main difference between a distributed and a lumped filter is that the former is characterized by trigonometric, thus periodic, functions of o, while the latter depends on rational functions of o. Hence the responses of distributed filters exhibit periodic or pseudo-periodic behaviour. Consequently, it is impossible to realize a distributed constant filter with a genuine lowdpass response, because spurious passbands arise as the frequency increases over some critical values. The Richards transformation, also known as the periodic transformation, allows the lowdpass or highpass lumped filters to be transformed into distributed filters; in other words, into filters built with transmission line segments. The Richards transformation can be conveniently written as po jo0 ¼ ja tan ð8:32Þ 2 o0 where o0 is called the Nyquist frequency and a is a design parameter. Although a could be taken equal to 1, it can be used to facilitate the synthesis of the transformed filter as it affects both the passband width and the impedance level of the transformed filter. When its argument varies in the interval ðp=2; p=2Þ, the tangent assumes all the real values from 1 and þ1, and is periodic with period p. It follows that Equation (8.32) maps the whole o0 axis (1; þ1) into the infinite intervals ðo0 ; þ o0 Þ;
ðo0 ; 3o0 Þ;
...;
½ð2k 1Þo0 ; ð2k þ 1Þo0
where k is any positive or negative integer, including zero. In particular, the key frequencies in the prototype response are mapped as follows: o0 ¼ 0 ! o ¼ 0; 0
2o0 ;
4o0 ; . . . ; 2ko0
o ¼ 1 ! o ¼ o0 ; 3o0 ; 5o0 ; . . . ; ð2k þ 1Þo0 1 1 o0 ¼ 1 ! o ¼ 2o0 tan1 þk p a
ð8:33Þ
Therefore, the frequency response obtained from the Richards transformation is periodic with period 2o0 . The third equation of (8.33) suggests the usefulness of the parameter a to determine, along with o0 , the passband edges of the transformed filter. Indeed a can be used to modify the width of the first passband (k ¼ 0) keeping the frequency periodicity (2o0 ) unchanged. Application of the transformation (8.32) to the lowdpass and highpass prototype27 yields the responses shown in Figure 8.21. The solid (dashed) curve represents the response obtained from the highpass (lowdpass) prototype. Both are periodic with period 2o0 , as anticipated. The dashed curve in Figure 8.21 can represent either a periodic lowdpass or a periodic bandstop response, since it allows DC to be transmitted. Similarly, the solid curve, which stops DC, can represent either a periodic highpass or a bandpass response. In any case, all the passbands and stopbands are centred around an integer multiple of o0. When wide stopband widths are required, filters with different combinations of the parameters a and o0 need to be cascaded in order to match the specifications. When lowdpass or bandpass responses are required with wide stopband widths, many filters, with different combinations of the parameters a and o0 , may need to be cascaded. In such instances, the filter realizing the passband is called the main filter, while the additional cascaded filters are the cleaning filters.
27 In both cases we have used a reference prototype as defined in Section 8.5: Chebyshev, with N ¼ 5 and passband ripple RP ¼ 0.1 dB.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
263
highpass:
0
ω'→ -cot(0.5π ω/ω0)
20 log10(|s21|)
–20
–40
–60
lowpass: ω'→tan(0.5π ω/ω0)
–80 0
Figure 8.21 prototypes.
1
2
3 ω/ω0
4
5
6
Responses of the Richards-transformed filters obtained from the lowdpass and highpass
From the network point of view, Equation (8.32) transforms one inductor (capacitor) into one short-circuit (open-circuit) stub.28 The electrical length of the stub equals p=2 (90 ) at the angular frequency o0. Indeed, by applying the Richards transformation to the inductor impedance and to the capacitor admittance, we get po po jo0 L0 ¼ jaL0 tan ¼ j Z0;L tan ) Z0;L ¼ aL0 2 o0 2 o0 po 1 po 1 jo0 C 0 ¼ jaC 0 tan tan ð8:34Þ ¼j ) Z0;C ¼ 0 2 o0 Z0;C 2 o0 aC As anticipated, the parameter a affects the impedances of the stubs. This impedance modification is the network counterpart of the modification of the passband limits, stated by Equation (8.33). Note that as a consequence of the same Richards transform being applied to all circuit elements, all stubs have the same l/4 electrical length at the frequency o0. For this reason the filters obtained from the Richards transformation are said to be commensurate, and the corresponding responses are periodic. The lowdpass of Figure 8.10a and the highpass of Figure 8.16 (derived from the former) generate the two networks of Figures 8.22a,b, respectively. Finally, after impedance denormalization, Equation (8.34) gives the impedance values of the Richards filters ðLPÞ
Z0;k ¼ agk R0 ðHPÞ
Z0;k ¼
R0 gk a
ðodd kÞ; ðodd kÞ;
ðLPÞ
Z0;k ¼ ðHPÞ
Z0;k ¼
R0 agk
ðeven kÞ
aR0 gk
ðeven kÞ
ð8:35Þ
28 Recall that a stub is a one-port distributed circuit consisting of a length of transmission line terminated at the far end with an open or a short circuit. Correspondingly, the stub is said to be open- or short-circuited.
264
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING (LP)
Z0,1
(LP)
(LP)
Z0,3
(LP)
Z0,N-2 Z0,N-2
1
2
(LP)
Z 0,2
(HP)
Z 0,1
(LP)
(HP)
Z 0,N-1
(HP)
Z 0,3
(a)
(LP)
Z 0,4
(HP)
Z 0,N-2 Z 0,N-2
1
2
(HP)
Z 0,2
(HP)
Z 0,4
(HP)
(b)
Z 0,N-1
Figure 8.22 Commensurate distributed constant filters: (a) pseudo-lowdpass network; (b) pseudohighpass network.
8.6 Kuroda identities The networks shown in Figure 8.22 theoretically offer the advantage of not requiring the use of lumped elements. Their realization is, however, problematic for two reasons. The first is that they make use of series stubs, which are in practice difficult if not impossible to realize in circuit configurations such as coaxial cable, stripline and microstrip, where a common ground plane exists. On the contrary, series stubs can be realized in rectangular waveguide technology or in two-conductor transmission lines (e.g. coplanar strips). The second difficulty in the realization of the networks in Figure 8.22 is due to the presence of electrical nodes connecting three transmission lines. In practice such nodes cannot be realized physically because of the finite physical size of the actual transmission lines,29 which thus need to be separated by suitable circuit elements. The filter we are considering, however, operates at high frequencies, so that any separating element of finite length would produce phase shifts of the signal, potentially compromising the filter performance. In order to realize the filters of Figure 8.22 physically, we need to introduce some suitable modifications in order to separate the stubs with transmission line segments without altering the filter response, at least the amplitude response. To this end, two approaches are available. The first one, discussed in this section, is based on the Kuroda identities; the second one relies on impedance and admittance inverters and will be presented subsequently in Section 8.7. The Kuroda identities state the equivalence between two networks. There are four Kuroda identities [2], but two of them are sufficient for our needs. Let us consider the two networks shown in Figure 8.23. Network (a) consists of a shunt open stub cascaded with a transmission line segment; network (b) consists of a transmission line segment followed by a series open-circuit stub.30 We can 29 Keep in mind that, by definition, a transmission line, thus a stub, has zero (or very small) transverse dimensions (1-D element). Consequently the length – from port to port – of the two filters in Figure 8.22 is ideally zero. 30 In the literature, the Kuroda identities are sometimes expressed in terms of lumped networks. In this case, inductors (capacitors) replace short-circuit (open-circuit) stubs, and the segment of transmission line with characteristic impedance Zl is replaced by a unit element having the same impedance. The unit element is the inverse Richards transformation of the transmission line length; it is a mathematical entity with no physical lumped element counterpart.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
265
Z s,b Z l,a 1
Z l,b 2
1
2
Z s,a (a)
(b)
Figure 8.23 The first Kuroda identity.
easily demonstrate that the two two-port networks (a) and (b) are equivalent if all their elements have the same electrical length and if the following equalities hold:31 Zl;b ¼
1 1 þ Zl;a Zs;a
1
;
Zs;b ¼ Zl;a Zl;b
ð8:36Þ
Conditions (8.36) constitute the first Kuroda identity. By inverting (8.36), we obtain the second Kuroda identity: Zl;a ¼ Zl;b þ Zs;b ;
Zs;a ¼
1 1 Zl;b Zl;a
1
ð8:37Þ
which simply corresponds to interchanging ports 1 and 2 in both circuits of Figure 8.23. In practice, Kuroda identities allow us to interchange the respective positions of a line segment with a stub, simultaneously replacing a series short-circuit stub with a shunt open-circuit stub and vice versa. In this manner, as we will see shortly, it is possible to transform the network in Figure 8.22a into another one, containing only shunt open-circuit (or series short-circuit) stubs, separated by line segments. Note preliminarily that the amplitude response32 of the filter does not change if we insert any section of matched transmission line33 between the filter input and the source or between the output and the load. The insertion of a matched line causes a phase shift in s21, but does not affect its amplitude. By exploiting this property, we can insert34 bN=2c transmission line segments – all with the same characteristic impedance Z0;1 ¼ Z0;2 ¼ Z0;4 ¼ Z0;5 ¼ R0 and with the same electrical length as the stubs – at both ports of the network in Figure 8.22a. By successive applications of the Kuroda identities, the transmission line sections can be moved within the filter separating consecutive stubs. At the same time all stubs become of the same type, either series or shunt. The procedure is better explained using a specific example.
31 For this purpose it is sufficient to write the ABCD matrices of the three fundamental elements: transmission line segment, series stub and shunt stub. The ABCD matrices of networks (a) and (b) are then obtained as the products of two 2 2 matrices, each correspoding to the proper circuit element. The Kuroda identities are obtained by simply equating the two resulting ABCD matrices. 32 The amplitude response is the only one specified in most cases. In some special applications the phase response (particularly the group delay) is also specified. 33 The term matched denotes here a transmission line having characteristic impedance equal to the source and load impedance R0. We also assume that the load and source have the same impedance. 34 The function bxc returns the lower integer part of x. It is sometimes written as floor(x).
266
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
EXAMPLE 8.7 The synthesis of a periodic lowdpass filter of order N ¼ 5, using only shunt stubs. We will start from the lumped prototype of Figure 8.10b, which is the dual of Figure 8.10a.35 After applying the Richards transformation, we get the network in Figure 8.24a. The filter amplitude response will not change if we insert at each filter end bN=2c ¼ 2 line segments with impedance equal to R0: Figure 8.24b shows the resulting network. The first application of the Kuroda identities affects the outer stubs of the filter (positions 1 and 5) and generates the network in Figure 8.24c. The second – and final – application of the Kuroda identities involves all the series stubs of the network in Figure 8.24c, and produces the final network shown in Figure 8.24d. ZS2
ZS4
1
2
(a) ZP1 ZS2 Z01
ZP3
ZP5
ZS4
Z02
Z04
Z05
1
(b)
2
ZP1 Z′P1 Z01
ZS2
ZP3
ZP5
ZS4
Z′02
Z′P5 Z′04
Z 05
1
2
(c)
ZP3 Z′01
Z′′02 Z′′04 Z′05
1
2
Z′′P1 Z′P2
ZP3
Z′P4
(d)
Z′′P5
Figure 8.24 Use of the Kuroda identities relevant to Example 8.7: (a) original fifth-order filter; (b) add ½N=2 ¼ 2 transmission line segments at both filter ends; (c) apply the Kuroda identity (Figure 8.23) to the two networks consisting of the line Z0;2 with the parallel stub ZP1 , and of the line Z04 with the parallel stub ZP5 ; (d) apply the Kuroda identity at the four line segments with series stub 0 0 0 0 Þ; ðZ02 ; ZS2 Þ; ðZS4 ; Z04 ½ ðZ01 ; ZP1 Þ; ðZP5 ; Z05 Þ obtaining all parallel stubs. 35 This change in the starting point is required because we need the central element to be a shunt stub. Therefore, if N ¼ 3, 7, 11. . . (N ¼ 5, 9, 13. . .) the starting point is the lumped prototype in Figure 8.10a (8.10b). If we want series stubs only, we must swap the prototype choice.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
267
8.7 Immittance inverters An ideal impedance inverter K, or K inverter, is a two-port network behaving at all frequencies like a l=4 line with impedance Z0 ¼ K: we say that K is the constant of the impedance inverter K. With reference to Figure 8.25a, from the above definition it follows that, when port 2 of the inverter is terminated with the impedance Z2 , the impedance seen at port 1 is Z1 ¼
K2 Z2
ð8:38Þ
In a dual way, we can define the admittance inverter J as a two-port network such that, when port 2 is terminated with the admittance Y2 , the admittance seen from port 1 is
Y1 ¼
J2 Y2
ð8:39Þ
For the sake of simplicity, in the rest of the chapter we will use the generic term immittance inverter to denote either the impedance inverter K or the admittance inverter J. From the above property, it can be seen that the chain or ABCD matrix of an impedance inverter is
A C
0 B ¼ j=K D
jK 0
ð8:40Þ
Similarly, it is found that the impedance and admittance matrices are given by
0 ½Z ¼ jK
jK ; 0
0 ½Y ¼ jJ
jJ 0
ð8:41Þ
If an admittance inverter is considered, Equation (8.40) holds true by just replacing K with 1=J. It is easily recognized that Equations (8.38) and (8.39) directly follow as a consequence of (8.40). The immittance inverter is a loss-free network, since the determinant of the matrix (8.40) is unitary. Properties (8.38) and (8.39) can be summarized by saying that the impedance (admittance) inverter has the basic property of presenting an input impedance equal to the reciprocal of the output one, multiplied by K2 (J2). For instance, if port 2a in Figure 8.25 is terminated by a capacitor C, the input impedance – given by (8.38) – is Z1 ¼
K2 ¼ joK 2 C 1=ðjoCÞ
Therefore, the impedance inverter transforms the output capacitor into an input inductor, having inductance L ¼ K 2 C. In the same way, it can be shown that the inductor is transformed into a capacitor, and an open-circuit stub into a short-circuit stub with the same electrical length (and vice versa).
268
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 8.25 Immittance inverters: (a) defining networks; (b) equivalent networks for the impedance inverter; (c) equivalent networks for the admittance inverter; (d) l=4 transmission line impedance inverter. If we terminate the impedance inverter with the series of two impedances Z2,a and Z2,b, the resulting input impedance is Z1 ¼
K2 1 Z2;a Z2;b ) Y1 ¼ ¼ 2 þ 2 Z1 Z2;a þ Z2;b K K
This expression corresponds to the parallel connection of two admittances Z2;a =K 2 and Z2;b =K 2 . Therefore, we can say that the impedance inverter transforms the series connection into a parallel one and vice versa. An important consequence of Equation (8.38) is the equivalence between the two networks of Figure 8.25b, where the immittances Yp, Zs are related by Equation (8.38). The equivalence can be proved by computing the chain matrix of the circuit on the left of Figure 8.25b as the product of three factors: two impedance inverters (first and third factors) and the shunt bipole Yp:
0 j=K
jK 0
1 Yp
0 1
0 j=K
jK 0
1 K 2 Yp ¼ 0 1
ð8:42Þ
MICROWAVE FILTERS
269
The chain matrix of the network on the right of Figure 8.25b is
1 Zs 0 1
ð8:43Þ
Apart from the sign, the matrix (8.43) coincides with (8.42) when Zs ¼ K 2 Yp . The sign inversion implies a p (180 ) phase shift and can be represented by interchanging the output terminals. Such a phase shift is due to the presence of two K inverters, each providing a p/2 phase shift. As in most cases, the phase shift can be neglected if we are not interested in the phase response. By a similar procedure the identity can be proved between the networks in Figure 8.25c. A series impedance Zs can therefore be replaced by a shunt admittance Yp ¼ Zs =K 2 placed between two impedance inverters and vice versa. It is worth observing that the K inverter can also be used to scale Yp by any arbitrary factor A2, simply by changing K into K/A. The equivalences of Figures 8.25b,c can be used to obtain filters with shunt-only (or series-only) elements separated by immittance inverters. This is another way, in addition to the use of Kuroda identities, to overcome the difficulties associated with realization of the networks of Figure 8.22. As an example, Figure 8.26 shows an Nth-order passband prototype realized with N series inductors Li ði ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; NÞ and N þ 1 impedance inverters Ki;i þ 1 ði ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; N þ 1Þ. Since an inverter changes the impedance level by a factor K 2 (or the admittance by a factor J 2 ), the additional degrees of freedom introduced by the addition of the inverters can be exploited to determine arbitrarily the inductance values as well as the impedance level at the source or load terminals. To this end, the impedance inverters have the values indicated in the figure (see [2]). As an alternative, one may arbitrarily fix the values of the inverters, assuming for instance all unitary values: Ki;i þ 1 ði ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; N þ 1Þ. In conclusion, the use of immittance inverters allows us to: 1. Separate contiguous filter elements, thus removing one of the obstacles to realization. 2. Obtain series-only or shunt-only filters, removing the realization problems associated with the networks of Figure 8.22. 3. Alter the impedance levels of the whole filter or of some sections, in such a way as to obtain elements easier to realize. Point 3 specifically distinguishes the immittance inverter technique from that based on the Kuroda identities, as the latter, though mathematically more elegant, often yield impedance values that are difficult or impossible to realize. The inverters, on the contrary, allow for a much higher flexibility. There are several ways to realize an inverter practically. The most obvious one is the quarterwavelength transmission line, shown in Figure 8.25d, with characteristic impedance Zc ¼ K or Zc ¼ 1/J. Note that no physical network can behave as an ideal impedance inverter, but can only represent an approximation valid in a limited frequency band. Other possible realizations of immittance inverters are in the form of T and P networks. By recalling expressions (8.41) and Equations (4.60) and (4.67), it can be seen that any symmetrical lossless T network realizes an impedance inverter if the impedance of the two series branches is the opposite of the shunt
L1 1
K 0,1 =
K0,1
RS L1 , g 0 g1
L2 K1,2
Kk ,k +1 =
LN-1 K2,3
Lk Lk +1 g k g k +1
LN KN-1,N
( k = 1,
, N − 1) ,
KN,N+1
KN −1,N =
2
RL LN g N g N +1
Figure 8.26 Lowdpass filter with series inductors and impedance inverters.
270
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
2 branch, in such a way that Z11 ¼ Z22 ¼ 0. The resulting impedance inverter is K 2 ¼ Z12 . In a dual fashion, from (8.41) and (4.67) it appears that a P network realizes an admittance inverter if the admittance of the shunt branches is equal to that of the series branch, so that Y11 ¼ Y22 ¼ 0. The resulting admittance 2 inverter is J 2 ¼ Y12 . Such networks cannot be physically realized by themselves, because they involve negative-value elements. However,such elements can be realized virtually, by ‘absorbing’ them within the external circuit. For instance, a negative-value inductor –L1, in series with a positive-value inductor L2, is equivalent to one single inductor, with L2 L1 . The resulting inductor is physically realizable, provided that L2 > L1 . This technique can be applied, for instance, to transform the filter of Figure 8.16 into a filter with series inductors and impedance inverters as shown in Figure 8.26. Apart from the phase, the two filters are fully equivalent in terms of amplitude response. The following example, Example 8.8, illustrates in detail the procedure to obtain a filter made of lines and series stubs only. With a dual procedure, omitted here, a filter made of lines and shunt stubs only can easily be obtained.
EXAMPLE 8.8 The synthesis of a distributed bandpass filter with series open-circuit stubs only, by applying the impedance inverters. The filter uses the reference prototype (Chebyshev, N ¼ 5, RP ¼ 0.1 dB) as starting point. A further specification is that the first passband extends from 2.5 to 7.5 GHz. The reference lowdpass prototype is shown in Figure 8.27a, while its values are listed in the third and fourth rows of Table 8.7. The next step consists of applying the lowdpass to highpass transformation. The resulting network is shown in Figure 8.27b, the element values being listed in the fifth and sixth rows of Table 8.7. Now we apply the Richards transformation (8.32) and impose the passband limits to coincide with the required ones. First of all, since the passband is to be centred on o0 , we have o0 ¼ 2p½ð2:5 þ 7:5Þ=2 109 ¼ 10p 109 rad=s. Once the central frequency has been determined, the parameter a is found by imposing the lower limit of the passband to map into the unitary frequency of the prototype: p p 2p 2:5 109 ) 1 ¼ a tan 1 ¼ a tan )a¼1 9 2 2p 5 10 4 Note that in the upper limit of the passband, we have p 2p 7:5 109 ¼ 1 tan 2 2p 5 109 We have now obtained the network of Figure 8.27c, with the component values listed in the seventh and eighth rows of Table 8.7. As seen in Section 8.5, any bandpass or bandstop filter, obtained from the Richards transformation, is a ladder network with series and parallel resonators in alternate positions.36 By placing an impedance inverter between two adjacent resonators, we obtain a filter with all the resonators of the same type. In our case, if we insert one series open-circuit stub between two impedance inverters with K ¼ 1, we obtain the equivalent of a parallel short-circuit stub with the same characteristic impedance as the original stub. By applying this concept, we obtain the filter of Figure 8.27d, with the component values listed in the ninth and tenth rows of Table 8.7. At this point we must point out that the network of Figure 8.27d is not canonical (like that of Figure 8.27c), since it contains N þ ðN1Þ ¼ 9 elements. The insertion of the impedance inverters, 36
This consideration applies to any type of filter, concentrated or distributed. In the lumped element (distributed element) filters, the resonators are series or parallel LC cells (open-circuit or short-circuit stubs).
MICROWAVE FILTERS
271
in fact, introduces a certain amount of redundancy in the network. Such redundancy can be exploited to satisfy particular design constraints. For instance, we may wish to realize the filter with all equalimpedance stubs. The 11th and 12th rows of Table 8.7 show how to change the impedance inverter constants, so that all inner stub impedances are equal to the outer ones (g1). The distributed network of Figure 8.27d is still ideal, because it includes the impedance inverters that are ideal elements by definition. As anticipated, a transmission line segment is one possible (approximate) realization of the impedance inverter. In contrast with the ideal case, the transmission line segment behaves as an impedance inverter only at the centre frequency where its electrical length equals p=2. Let us now replace the ideal impedance inverters in Figure 8.27d with transmission lines l=4 long at 5 GHz and having Z0 ¼ K. The filter obtained has no ideal elements, but its response is degraded. In particular the passband ripple increases, and consequently the return loss decreases. We can compensate for this effect by optimizing the line and stub impedances. The last two rows of Table 8.7 provide the optimized filter values. Figure 8.28 shows the responses of all the filters discussed in this example. Three pairs of curves are plotted, one for the transmission and one for the reflection coefficient. The thick black curves refer to the filters in Figures 8.27c,d with ideal impedance inverters. Clearly, the responses of these two filters are coincident. The thin black (thick grey) curves are those of the filter with the transmission line segments before (after) optimization. Finally, all the filters discussed in this example are symmetrical, like the prototype they are derived from. Moreover, all the values listed in Table 8.7 are normalized to the reference impedance. If a different impedance level R0 is needed, it is sufficient to multiply all the values by R0.
Table 8.7 Values for Example 8.8. k
1, 5
2, 4
3
gk
1.147
1.371
1.975
ðLPÞ
Lk
g1
ðLPÞ
Ck
ðHPÞ
Ck
g2 1=g1
ðHPÞ
Lk
ðSeriesOpenStubÞ
Zk
1=g3 1=g2
1=g1
ðShuntShortStubÞ
Zk
ðSeriesOpenStubÞ
g3
1=g3 1=g2
Zk
g1
g2
g3
K
1
1
1
g1 rffiffiffiffiffi g1 ffi 0:915 g2
g1
g1
g1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi 0:697 g2 g3
g5 g1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi g3 g4 g2 g3
0.530
0.530
0.53
1.152
1.122
1.122
ðSeriesOpenStubÞ Zk
K ðSeriesOpenStubÞ
Zk
ðTransmissionlinesÞ
Zk
272
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING L1
L3
L5
C2
1
(HP)
C4
(HP)
C1
2
(HP)
C3
C5
L(HP) L(HP) 2 4
1
(HP)
Z 0,1
(HP)
(a)
2
(b)
(HP)
Z 0,3
Z 0,5
1
2
(c) (HP)
(HP)
Z 0,2 (HP)
(HP)
Z′0,1
(HP)
Z′0,2
K1
1
Z 0,4
K2
(HP)
(HP)
Z′ 0,3
Z′0,4
K3
Z′ 0,5
K4
2
(d)
Figure 8.27 Application of the impedance inverters to the filter synthesis: (a) lowdpass prototype; (b) highpass prototype; (c) Richards-transformed canonical network; (d) final network with series stubs only. Ideal impedance inverters λ/4 lines λ/4 lines, optimized
0
20
20 log10(|s21|)
–20
0
–30 –20
–40 –50
s11 → –40
–60 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Frequency, GHz
Figure 8.28
Responses of the filters discussed in Example 8.8.
20 log10(|s11|)
← s21
–10
MICROWAVE FILTERS
273
Z sa,2 Z sa,4
1
2 (a) Z pc,1 Z pc,3 Z pc,5
Zl 1
Zl 2
Zl 3
Zl 4
1
2
Z s1
Z s2
Z s3
Z s4
(b)
Z s5
Figure 8.29 Schematic synthesis of line-coupled stub filters: (a) canonical ladder network; (b) transformed network by means of l=4 transmission line impedance inverters.
8.7.1
Filters with line-coupled short-circuit stubs
We can design distributed filters having N l=4 short-circuit stubs, separated by (N 1) l=4 transmission lines, by applying a procedure quite similar to the one discussed in Example 8.8. The only necessary change is the starting point, which must be the lumped network of Figure 8.10b, instead of Figure 8.10a. Figure 8.29 shows the network obtained at the last two synthesis steps: Figures 8.29a,b correspond to Figures 8.27c,d, respectively. Alternatively, the same result can be achieved by deriving the dual network of Figure 8.27d: shortcircuit shunt stubs will replace the open-circuit series stubs, and the values listed in Table 8.7 are considered as normalized admittances, instead of impedances. A third option consists of the application of the synthesis formulae of Table 8.8, from [2]. Their derivation, not discussed here, is based on the same principles illustrated in Example 8.8. Table 8.8 Synthesis formulae for the short-circuit stub filter [2]. Passband limits ðf1 ; f2 Þ Impedance inverter constants (coincident with the characteristic impedances of the connecting lines) sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 gk gk þ 1 ZN1;N 1 1 g0 gN1 Z1;2 1 1 g2 Zk;k þ 1 ¼ ; ¼ ; ¼ 2 g0 g1 g0 2 g1 gN þ 1 R0 g0 2 g1 R0 R0 k¼2;...;N1 Characteristic impedances of the shunt stubs sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2ffi g0 g1 f1 1 2 2 Zs;1;1 ¼ Z1;2 þ tan p Z1;2 R0 f2 þ f1 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2ffi sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2ffi g0 g1 pf1 g0 g1 pf1 1 1 2 2 þ Zk;k þ 1 þ Zk1;k Zs;k;k þ 1 ¼ Zk1;k þ tan tan Zk;k þ1 R0 f2 þ f1 R0 f2 þ f1 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 gN gN þ 1 g0 g1 f1 g0 g1 f1 2 1 2 KN1;N þ KN1;N Zs:N;N ¼ tan p þ tan p R0 f2 þ f1 R0 f2 þ f1
274
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The result obtained using the design formulae of Table 8.8 is considerably more accurate than that obtainable by the simple procedure of Example 8.8. Despite this, an optimization is usually required in order to compensate for the approximations inherent in the realization of the impedance inverters and for the non-idealities of real transmission lines.
EXAMPLE 8.9 Line-coupled short-circuit stub filters typically lend themselves to passbands of the order of one octave. The design procedure discussed above is illustrated here for the example of a microstrip bandpass filter. Let the passband be 12–24 GHz, the filter order N ¼ 5, the passband ripple RP 0.044 dB (corresponding to 20 dB return loss). The reference impedance is R0 ¼ 50 O. The prototype coefficients are quoted in the second row of Table 8.9. The computation of the parameter a gives ! p p 2p 12 109 ¼ a tan ) a ffi 0:577 1 ¼ a tan 2 2p 12 þ2 24 109 3 With the procedure schematized in Figure 8.29, we obtain a symmetrical filter with five shunt shortcircuit stubs, separated by four transmission line segments. Lines and stubs have 90 electrical length (l=4 physical length) at the passband centre frequency of 18 GHz. A procedure similar to the one used in Example 8.8 gives the values (denormalized with respect to 50 O) listed in the third and fourth rows of Table 8.9. Since a l/4 transmission line is a rough and narrow-band approximation of an ideal impedance inverter, the values resulting from the above procedure are inaccurate and need to be corrected by numerical optimization. The optimized values are quoted in the fifth and sixth columns of Table 8.9. As a reference, the values obtained by the synthesis formulae of Table 8.8 are quoted in the last two columns of Table 8.9. Such values are considerably more accurate than those obtained from the simple synthesis method employed in Example 8.8. Figure 8.30 shows the layout of the microstrip filter. As we will explain later, the dimensions of the filter have been modified to compensate for the discontinuity effects. The substrate is h ¼ 508 mm thick with relative permittivity er ¼ 9:9. The ground connections of the stubs are realized by means of rectangular pads, placed on the substrate border and connected to the ground plane by gold ribbons. Looking at the optimized values in Table 8.9, we can see that the Table 8.9 Parameter values of Example 8.9. k Prototype coefficients
gk
Synthesized values
ðstubÞ Zk
1, 5
ðOÞ
2, 4
0.973
1.372
1.803
50 a=ðg1 Þ
50 a=ðg2 Þ
50 a=ðg3 Þ
ffi 29:67
Optimized values
Values from Table 8.8
3
ffi 21:04
ffi 16:01
ðlineÞ Zk
ðOÞ
50
50
50
ðstubÞ Zk
ðOÞ
58.51
29.55
29.85
ðlineÞ Zk
ðOÞ
42.29
40.86
40
ðstubÞ
ðOÞ
66
34
35
ðlineÞ
ðOÞ
42.2
40
40
Zk Zk
MICROWAVE FILTERS
275
outer stubs (k ¼ 1, 5) have roughly twice the impedance of the inner ones (k ¼ 2, 3, 4). This suggests the configuration shown in Figure 8.30, where the inner stubs are realized with two parallel twiceimpedance stubs. The resulting filter presents all the stubs having approximately the same impedance. Also, the lines have approximately the same impedance, as we recognize from Table 8.9. Similar impedances imply similar microstrip widths. The low dispersion in the width values minimizes the sensitivity of the filter with respect to manufacturing tolerances. It is worth observing the different physical lengths of the stubs. This might seem to be in contrast with what we have noted above, since all the stubs should have about the same length since they are all l=4 long at 18 GHz and their impedances and effective permittivities are very close. However, the parasitic reactances associated with the different junctions (T junctions for the outer stubs and crosses for the inner ones) produce different effects and require different compensations. This makes the inner stubs longer than the outer ones. The former have thus been folded in order to place the short-circuit end at the substrate border.37 Figure 8.31 shows the simulated38 response of the filter in Figure 8.30 compared with the ideal line counterpart, using the values listed in the last two rows of Table 8.9. Note that: (a) The transmission coefficient of the microstrip filter is lower than its ideal counterpart. The reasons for this are the finite conductivity of the metal and the non-zero conductivity of the substrate. Furthermore, the attenuation excess is higher in the proximity of the two passband corners39 (12 and 24 GHz). As a secondary effect, the filter loss smoothes the passband return loss peaks (s11 ! 0). (b) The microstrip filter shows a spurious passband around twice the passband centre frequency (f0 ¼ 18 GHz, spurious passband: 34–40 GHz). In the proximity of the spurious passband, the filter should ideally present an infinite attenuation. Indeed, when f ¼ 2 f0 , the stubs are l=2 long and a transmission zero would be expected. Surprisingly, this is not the case with our filter. This is due to the already mentioned effect of the junction discontinuities. The different stubs present, after compensation, similar electrical lengths in the proximity of f0 , but not at 2 f0 . On the other hand, since the lines are also l/2 at 2f0 , they can be seen, apart from a 180 phase shift, as straight connections. Hence, around 2f0 all the stubs, the load and the source are approximately connected together in parallel. As a consequence, as explained next, the resulting susceptance becomes very small or even zero in the proximity of 2 f0 . To clarify this point, consider for simplicity two parallel stubs having slightly different lengths. Both stubs present low reactances around 2 f0 where they are l=2 long, but since their lengths are different, an intermediate frequency fz 2 f0 exists where they have opposite susceptance, so that a parallel resonance (zero susceptance) occurs, thus a high reactance; finally, the filter will exhibit a low attenuation. Figure 8.32 plots the reactances of two equal-length parallel stubs, along with the reactances of two slightly different stubs. It can be seen that around f0 the responses of the two configurations (parallel stubs of unequal or equal lengths) can hardly be distinguished. On the contrary, around 2 f0 , the former (equal-length stubs) present a low impedance, while the latter (unequal lengths) present a high impedance.
37 A different grounding tecnique, such as the plated via hole, would make this arrangement unnecessary, allowing the stub to be grounded at any point of the substrate, not just close to the border. 38 Though only simulated, such results are quite realistic, in the authors’ opinion. 39 It is possible to demonstrate that the filter loss is proportional to the filter group delay (increasing at the passband P edges) by the factor Nk¼0 gk (increasing with N), and by the factor Q1 ðf2 f1 Þ=ðf2 þ f1 Þ, where Q is the quality factor of the filter resonators and f1 ; f2 are the passband limits.
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 7 mm
1
2
1 2
RF ports substrate border microstrip lines ground connections
Figure 8.30
Layout of the filter discussed in Example 8.9.
ideal lines microstrip 0
10
s11 →
0
–20
–10 s21
←
–30
s21
–20
–40
–30
–50
–40 0
4
8
12
16
20
24
28
32
36
40
Frequency, GHz
Figure 8.31
Responses of the filters discussed in Example 8.9.
20 log10(|s11|)
–10
20 log10(|s21|)
276
Stub reactance
MICROWAVE FILTERS
277
0 a) = λ/4 b) > λ/4 c) < λ/4 d a//a) e b//c) 0
1
2
ω/ω0
Figure 8.32 Reactances of some combinations of short-circuit stubs: curve a, single l=4 stub at the angular frequency o0 ; curve b, single stub slightly longer than l=4 at o0 ; curve c, single stub slightly shorter than l=4 at o0 ; curve d, two parallel stubs both l=4 at; curve e, two parallel stubs, one slightly shorter and the other slightly longer than l=4 at o0 .
8.7.2
Parallel-coupled filters
All the distributed filters considered so far have the same basic structure consisting of stubs and transmission lines in alternate positions. The stubs can be series or parallel, short circuit or open circuit. Stubs and lines all have the same electrical length. The stubs can be viewed as resonators and the lines – or, more generally, the impedance inverters – as coupling elements. This schematization applies to many microwave filters. A microwave filter in fact often consists of N resonators, separated by N 1 coupling elements. Sometimes, two further coupling elements are placed between the source and the first resonator, and between the last resonator and the load. This general structure has many possible realizations; a classical one is the parallel-coupled filter, also known as the edge-coupled filter, which is probably the most popular and cheapest microwave bandpass filter. It can in fact be entirely manufactured using printed circuit technology requiring no ground connections (no via holes, no metal ribbons) unlike the short-circuit stub filter of Example 8.9; moreover, if well designed, it does not require any tuning after fabrication. Figure 8.33 shows a microstrip edge-coupled filter (substrate thickness h ¼ 254 mm and relative permittivity er ¼ 9:9). Two schematizations are possible for the edge-coupled filter: 1. N resonators, each consisting of a l/2 transmission line section open-circuited at both ends and coupled with the adjacent resonator for a l=4 portion of its length. The filter shown in Figure 8.33 has N ¼ 5. 2. N þ 1 cascaded two-port networks of the type shown in Figure 4.25b.40 40
Figure 4.25b shows the schematic of a coupled-line two-port network, together with its line and stub equivalent network. The figure is replicated below. All elements have the same electrical length.
278
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 20 mm s 1
2
l
w 1 2
RF ports substrate border microstrip lines ground connections
Figure 8.33
Parallel-coupled microstrip filter.
The edge-coupled filter is a commensurate filter like all the distributed filters considered so far. To avoid any geometrical misalignment of the input and output ports in the filter, which could be a problem in practical applications, the filter layout, as shown in Figure 8.33, includes two bends – one at the input, one at the output – to align the filter ports. Many methods are available for the synthesis of edge-coupled filters. The most frequently used method relies on the design formulae in [10]. Such formulae have been derived by a method based on impedance inverters and are given in Table 8.10. Note that the filter is symmetrical as a consequence of the symmetry of the original prototype. The formulae are claimed to be accurate if the filter fractional bandwidth 2ðf2 f1 Þ=ð f2 þ f1 Þ ¼ ð f2 f1 Þ= f0 is less than 30%. Indeed, wide-band filters require strongly coupled lines (especially the end ones), implying very narrow line spacings. The widest realizable fractional bandwidth therefore depends on the available technology.
EXAMPLE 8.10 41 We illustrate here the design of the filter in Figure 8.33. The passband limits are 9–11 GHz, the source and load impedances are R0 ¼ 50 O, the order is N ¼ 5, and the return loss is 20 dB. The second row of Table 8.11 shows the prototype coefficients.42 The third and fourth rows list the even and odd mode impedances Z0e;k and Z0o;k , computed with the design formulae of Table 8.10. All N þ 1 ¼ 6 coupled-line sections are l=4 at the centre frequency f0 ¼ ð f1 þ f2 Þ=2 ¼ 10 GHz. As in any impedance-inverter-based design, such values are approximate and need an adjustment. The fifth and sixth rows of Table 8.11 list the resulting values. Once the impedances are known, the dimensions of the coupled microstrip sections can be determined by making them have the same even mode impedance, odd mode impedance and electrical length, as required. The last constraint, however, cannot be satisfied in a strict sense,
41 42
See Mathcad file 03_Microstrip_Edge_Coupled_Filters.MCD. The same as those in Example 8.9, given in the second row of Table 8.9.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
279
because, as we know, even and odd modes of coupled microstrips have different permittivities, thus different phase velocities. Fortunately, however, the difference is relatively small and the physical length43 can be computed using either the arithmetic or geometric mean of the two effective permittivities, with similar results. The seventh, eighth and ninth rows of Table 8.11 list the geometrical dimensions wk ; sk ; lk of six l=4 coupled sections of the filter. The electrical parameters of the microstrips do not coincide with the values of the fifth and sixth columns of Table 8.11. Moreover, the segments are slightly shorter than what we could expect considering an electrical length of 90 at 10 GHz. The reasons for such small differences are as follows: 1. The open ends of each coupled-line section are not perfect open circuits. Rather, they present a parasitic capacitive reactance due to the fringing field at the end of the line. This fringing field has the effect – usually denoted as end effect – of producing an increase in the effective length of line, and a decrease in the line impedance44 as well. 2. The junctions between lines of different width (step discontinuities) produce parasitic reactances. 3. The input and output bends at the filter constitute small discontinuities that slightly modify the filter response and must be compensated for. 4. There are different propagation velocities of the even and odd modes. See also footnote 42. Figure 8.34 shows the response of the filter of Figure 8.33 (black curves) together with its ideal counterpart (grey curves). We can observe a similar behaviour as for the filter in Example 8.9: .
The passband attenuation of the microstrip filter is higher than the ideal case, particularly at the passband corners.
.
Unlike the ideal filter, the microstrip filter shows a spurious response around 2f0 . As shown in [8] and [9], this is essentially due to the different phase velocities between the even and odd modes. Nevertheless, even in filters realized with pure TEM lines (coaxial cable, stripline) the end effect is different for both modes. As a consequence, a spurious passband at 2 f0 is present in any edge-coupled filter and the selectivity of the filter upper band edge f > f2 is lower than in the ideal case. Techniques to minimize the spurious passband can be developed, e.g. [11].
For instance, the two inner sections of our filter have w ¼ 0.3 mm and s ¼ 0.443 mm. The associated even and odd mode effective permittivities are ee f f ;e ¼ 6:9; ee f f ;o ¼ 5:73. Calculating the length based on the arithmetic or geometric mean of the two permittivities, we get 43
lartm ¼ vartm =ð4 f0 Þ ¼ c ½0:5ðee f f ;e þ ee f f ;e Þ0:5 ð4f0 Þ1 ffi 2:985 mm or lgeom ¼ vgeom =ð4f0 Þ ¼ c ðee f f ;e ee f f ;e Þ0:25 ð4f0 Þ1 ffi 2:985 mm respectively. 44 The end effect is local. It can be modelled by a lumped capacitor at the open end of the coupled lines. Clearly, the shorter the line, the more pronounced the end effect.
280
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Table 8.10 Synthesis formulae for edge-coupled filters. Passband limits ðf1 ; f2 Þ Impedance inverters rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi K0;1 2 f1 þ f2 g0 g1 ¼ p R0 f2 f1 Kk;k þ 1 1 f1 þ f2 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi gk gk þ 1 ðk ¼ 1; . . . ; N1Þ ¼ p f2 f1 R0 rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi KN;N þ 1 2 f1 þ f2 gN gN þ 1 ¼ p R0 f2 f1 Even and odd mode impedances " " 2 # 2 # R0 R0 R0 R0 ; Z0o;k ¼ R0 1 ðk ¼ 0; . . . ; NÞ þ þ Z0e;k ¼ R0 1 þ Kk;k þ 1 Kk;k þ 1 Kk;k þ 1 Kk;k þ 1
Table 8.11 Values of the filter in Figure 8.33. k gk Z0e,k Z0o,k Z0e,k Z0o,k wk sk lk
1, 6
2, 5
3, 4
0.973 95.04 37.76 88 33 0.28 0.075 2.541
1.372 67.47 40.05 73.2 45.4 0.3 0.337 2.515
1.803 62.05 41.98 74.5 51.7 0.3 0.443 2.519
O O O O mm mm mm
0
10
s11
0
–20
–10 ideal microstrip s21
–30
–20
–40
–30
–50
–40 8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
Frequency, GHz
Figure 8.34
Response of the filter of Figure 8.33.
24
20 log10(|s11|)
20 log10(|s21|)
–10
MICROWAVE FILTERS
C2
C1
l
0
1
2
C3
3
CN–1 CN
N-1
N
1
N+1
2
Figure 8.35
8.7.3
281
Comb-line filter.
Comb-line filters
These are another very popular class of filters. A comb-line filter consists of a sequence of N equal-length coupled resonators made of TEM or quasi-TEM lines, just like the parallel-coupled filter, except that each resonator is short-circuited at one end and grounded at the other end through a capacitor. The filter schematic is shown in Figure 8.35. Input and output are realized through two further non-resonating line sections (0 and N þ 1) coupled to the first and last resonators respectively, realizing at the same time a suitable impedance transformation at each port. In contrast to the parallel-coupled filter, and due to the presence of the capacitors, the electrical length l of the resonators has to be less than l=4 at the centre frequency, a typical value being l=8 or less. Since the second passband occurs when the resonators are more than half a wavelength long, in addition to having a reduced size this type of filter exhibits an extremely wide upper stopband, typically four times the centre frequency or even more. Comb-line filters can be realized using different technologies, such as TEM rectangular lines, stripline or microstrip line. A comb-line filter realized with cylindrical rods in a metal cavity is sketched in Figure 8.36. The gaps between the end of the rods and the cavity wall provide the end capacitances; the latter can be tuned with the screws usually inserted through the cavity wall. Printed circuit technology, mostly microstrip, employs either gap capacitors or discrete surface-mountable capacitors, the latter being especially useful when high capacitances are required. The behaviour of the comb-line filter can easily be analyzed by neglecting any coupling between nonadjacent lines, so that the filter can simply be considered as consisting of N þ 1 pairs of coupled lines (six in the case of Figure 8.36). As described in Section 3.16.2, the coupled-line model is fully characterized in terms of the self- (C 0 i ) and mutual capacitances (C0 i;i þ 1 ) of the lines, as shown in Figure 8.37 in the case of rectangular TEM bars. The filtering properties of the comb-line filter can more easily be understood on the basis of its equivalent circuit. The network identity of Figure 4.25c for the outer pairs of lines, (0 to 1) and (N to N þ 1), and that of Figure 4.25d for the inner pairs can in fact be used to transform Figure 8.34 into the equivalent circuit of Figure 8.38, where all lines and stubs have the same length l. Notice that the filter exhibits transmission zeros for l ¼ l=4 and l ¼ l=2 and that the stubs have an inductive behaviour as long as l < l=4; they resonate with the lumped capacitances at a frequency which is the lower, the higher the capacitance. If the latter were removed (i.e. C ¼ 0) then the resonance would occur at l ¼ l=4 but the circuit would become an all-stop structure. The comb-line filter can be designed using the formulae quoted in Table 8.12, which have been derived from those in [2]. Such formulae are based on the simplified frequency transform quoted in Table 8.12. The characteristic impedances Rak ðk ¼ 1; . . . ; NÞ of the inner lines (considered as uncoupled) affect the unloaded Q factors of the resonators, thus the filter loss. Usually, Rak is chosen to be the same for all inner lines f Rak ¼ Ra 8k 2 ½1; . . . ; N g. A proper choice of Ra must be made depending on the
282
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING tuning screw locking bolt
l
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
end capacitance RF coaxial connectors
(a)
symmetry planes
b/2
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
b/2
(b) symmetry planes
b/2
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
b/2
(c)
Figure 8.36 Comb-line filter realized with TEM coaxial lines: side view (a) and top view of a filter employing cylindrical rods (b) or rectangular bars (c).
technology employed. As is known, for example, for an air-filled coaxial line, the minimum loss is obtained when45 Ra 76:7 O. Once the lowdpass prototype parameters g0 ; g1 . . . and frequency band have been chosen, Table 8.12 0 returns the self- Ck0 and mutual Ck;k þ 1 capacitances of Figure 8.37 and the end capacitances Ck of 0 Figure 8.38. Depending on the technology employed, Ck0 and Ck;k þ 1 can then be used to compute the cross-sectional dimensions of the coupled lines by appropriate synthesis formulae [2]. Eventually, a fine optimization of the whole structure using full wave models is necessary to compensate for spurious phenomena and the various approximations involved.
45 For any given outer diameter b, the loss is minimum when the ratio of the inner to the outer diameter is lnð3:591Þ ffi 76:71 e0:5 . b=a ffi 3:591; consequently, the minimum loss impedance is Zminloss ¼ 60 e0:5 r r
MICROWAVE FILTERS
283
Table 8.12 Comb-line filter design formulae. ð f1 ; f2 Þ w ¼ 2ð f1 f2 Þ=ðf1 þ f2 Þ 2 f f0 f0 ¼ w f0 y0 < p=2 at f0 ¼ ð f1 þ f2 Þ=2 Ra R0
Passband limits Fractional bandwidth Lowdpass to bandpass transform Line electrical length Isolated line characteristic impedance Reference impedance Normalized parameters b0j ¼
cotðy0 Þ þ y0 sin2 ðy0 Þ R0 ; 2 Raj
j ¼ 1; . . . ; N
Normalized end impedances and inverters rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi K 1 gk gk þ 1 K 0 k k þ 1 k¼1;...;N1 ¼ k;k þ 1 ¼ ; w b0k b0k þ 1 R0 pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Line-to-ground capacitances v ¼ 1= m0 e0 er ¼ c= er R0T1 ¼
RT1 g0 g1 ¼ ; R0 w b01
C0 0 ¼
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 1 1 ; vR0 R0 T1
C0 1 ¼
R0 TN ¼
RTN gN gN þ 1 ¼ R0 w b0 N
1 R0 1 tanðyÞ 1 þ 0 0 þ C0 0 vR0 Ra1 R T1 K 1;2
1 R0 1 1 C0 k k¼2;...;N1 ¼ 0 þ 0 tanðyÞ vR0 Rak K k1;k K k;k þ 1 C0 N þ 1 ¼
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 1 1 ; vR0 R0 TN
C0 N ¼
1 R0 1 tanðyÞ 1 þ 0 0 þ C0 N þ 1 vR0 RaN R TN K N1;N
Mutual capacitances C 0 0;1 ¼
1 tanðyÞ 1 1 C0 0 ; C 0 k;k þ 1 k¼1;...;N1 ¼ ; C 0 N;N þ 1 ¼ C 0 N þ 1 vR0 K 0 k;k þ 1 vR0 vR0
End capacitances Cj ¼
1 cotðy0 Þ ; Raj 2p f0
j ¼ 1; . . . ; N
Characteristic impedances of the equivalent circuit of Figure 8.37: Zi;i ¼
1 ; vC0 i
i ¼ 0; . . . ; N þ 1 Zi;i þ 1 ¼
C'i-2, i-1
1 ; vC0 i;i þ 1
i ¼ 0; . . . ; N
C'i-1,i
C'i, i+1
i-1 C'i-1, i-1
i
C'i+1,i+2 i+1
C'i, i
C'i+1, i+1 ground
Figure 8.37 Line-to-ground and mutual capacitances in coupled coaxial TEM rectangular bars (transverse cross-section).
284
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Z 1,2
Z 2,3
Z N-1,N
Z 0,1
1
Figure 8.38
Z N,N+1
C1
C2
C3
Z 0,0
Z 1,1
Z 2,2
C N-1
Z 3,3
CN
2
Z N-1,N-1 Z N,N Z N+1,N+1
Equivalent network of the comb-line filter of Figure 8.37.
EXAMPLE 8.11 We illustrate here the design of a comb-line filter of order N ¼ 5 with Chebyshev response,46 with 26 dB return loss, 9.75–10.25 GHz passband, source and load impedances R0 ¼ 50 O. Assume the filter lines to be l=8 (y0 ¼ p=4 electrical length) at the centre frequency f0 ¼ ð f1 þ f2 Þ=2 ¼ ð9:75 þ 10:25Þ=2 ¼ 10 GHz. The chosen level for the characteristic impedance of all inner lines is Ra ¼ 75 O. The second column of Table 8.13 gives the coefficients gk of the lowdpass prototype. The third and fourth columns give the normalized self- and mutual capacitances of the filter lines, while the lumped end capacitances are quoted in the fifth column. Finally, the characteristic impedances of the equivalent circuit of Figure 8.38 are quoted in the sixth and seventh columns. The coaxial TEM realization is depicted in Figure 8.39, where rectangular bars are used as transmission lines, whereas coaxial input and output ports are applied to the first and last nonresonating lines. The lumped capacitances Ck are realized by the gaps between the bar ends and the outer wall of the filter. To a first approximation they can be calculated as parallel-plate capacitances, i.e. neglecting the edge effect. A comparison between the synthesized equivalent circuit simulation and the EM full wave response of the designed structure is shown in Figure 8.40. Figure 8.41 shows the broad-band response of the filter. Notice that the spurious-free stopband extends up to 40 GHz (four times larger than the filter centre frequency).
Table 8.13 Values of the synthesized filter of Example 8.11. k
gk
0 and 6 1 and 5 2 and 4 3
1 0.7563 1.3049 1.5773
1 Ck0 e1 0 er
0 1 1 Ck;k þ 1 e0 er
5.7452 3.3339 4.4762 4.5762
1.7946 0.3252 0.2252
Ck ðpFÞ
Zk;k ðOÞ
Zk;k þ 1 ðOÞ
0.212 0.212 0.212
65.57 113.00 84.16 82.32
209.91 1158.5 1673.0
46 See the Ansoft file 01_Combline_Filter_Example_11.adsn for analyzing the circuit model of the described filter. Also, the Mathcad file 07_CombLine_Filter_Synthesis.MCD (annexed to Chapter 15) implements the comb-line filter synthesis.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
285
0
10
–20
0
–40
←
CKT
–60
–20
EM s11 →
–80
–100
–10
s21
9
10
11
20 log10(|s11|)
20 log10(|s21|)
Figure 8.39 Coaxial TEM realization of Example 8.11: (a) bottom view; (b) side view; (c) perspective view of the disassembled structure.
–30
12
–40
Frequency, GHz
Figure 8.40
Circuit (CKT) and electromagnetic (EM) simulation of the filter in Example 8.11.
286
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 0
20 log10(|s21|)
–20
–40
–60
–80
–100 0
10
20
30
40 *
50
Frequency, GHz
Figure 8.41 Broad-band simulation of the filter in Example 8.11.
Bibliography 1. O. J. Zobel, ‘Theory and design of uniform and composite electric-wave filters’, Bell System Technical Journal, Vol. 2, No. 1, 1923. 2. G. Matthaei, L. Young and E. M. T. Jones, Microwave Filters, Impedance Matching Networks, and Coupling Structures, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1964. 3. R. E. Collin, Foundations for Microwave Engineering, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1992. 4. A. Zverev, Handbook of Filter Synthesis, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1967. 5. P. I. Richards, ‘Resistor transmission line networks’, Proceedings of the IRE, Vol. 30, pp. 217–220, 1948. 6. J. D. Rhodes, Theory of Electrical Filters, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1976. 7. I. Hunter, Theory and Design of Microwave Filters, IEE Electromagnetic Wave Series No. 48, London, 2001. 8. G. Bianchi, R. Sorrentino, M. Salerno and F. Alessandri, ‘Image parameter design of parallel coupled microstrip filters’, Proceedings of the 18th European Microwave Conference, Stockholm, Sweden, 1988. 9. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Design and Simulation, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007. 10. S. B. Cohn, ‘Parallel-coupled transmission-line resonator filters’, IRE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, April, pp. 223–231, 1958. 11. I. J. Bahl, ‘Capacitively compensated high performance parallel coupled microstrip filters’, IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium Digest, Vol. II, pp. 679–682, 1989.
Simulation files Ansoft files 01_Combline_Filter_Example_11.adsn. Analyzes the circuit of the comb-line filter described in Example 8.11.
MICROWAVE FILTERS
287
Mathcad files 02_Low_Pass_Prototype_Coefficients.MCD. Computes the Butterworth and Chebyshev lowdpass prototype coefficients for any order and passband ripple. 03_Microstrip_Edge_Coupled_Filters.MCD. Implements the complete automatic synthesis of microstrip edge-coupled filters, from the specification to the impedances to the microstrip dimensions.
9
Basic concepts for microwave component design 9.1 Introduction This chapter deals with the preliminary concepts needed to explain control and active components, including integrated circuits, nonlinear components, subsystems and test instruments. We will define here the main linear, noise and nonlinear performances of two-port networks. Moreover, many high-frequency components and subsystems consist of many cascaded networks. Therefore, we will give the fundamentals of the method of analysis, based on reducing two cascaded networks into one, in terms of gain, noise and power. It has to be considered that the next applications of the reduction should allow calculation of any cascaded chain with arbitrary numbers of components. Most of the results presented, although widely used in engineering practice, involve approximations; this will be pointed out as much as possible. Finally, Sections 9.6 and 9.7 explain the basic working principles of the most frequently used semiconductor devices, together with their electrical models.
9.2 Cascaded linear two-port networks This section deals with the linear performances of cascaded two-port networks and presents the fundamental equations that determine the linear performances of the resulting chain. A more complex combination can be analyzed in terms of two networks by progressively replacing two cascaded networks with an equivalent one. Within this context, we will consider two networks as equivalent if they present the same network parameters, in particular the scattering matrix.1 Figure 9.1 shows two linear two-port networks, connected in cascade (a), together with their equivalent network (b). The superscripts ‘A’ and ‘B’ denote the parameters of the first and second elements of the cascade, respectively, while ‘A; B’ denotes the parameters of the equivalent network. Furthermore, we will refer to port 1 of network A and port 2 of network B as the external ports, while port 2 of network A and the port 1 of network B will be the interfacing ports. 1
From the identity of the scattering matrix, the identity of all the other matrices of all the possible network representations ([Z], [Y], [ABCD], etc.) follow, if the latter exist. Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
290
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
[S(A)] 1
1
[S(B)] 2
1
[S(A,B)] 2
2
(a)
1
1
2
2
(b)
Figure 9.1 Cascaded linear two-port networks: (a) schematic of the structure; (b) equivalent network. In terms of S parameters, the network in Figure 9.1 gives 8 ðAÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ > ¼ s11 a1 þ s12 a2 > > b1 > > > ðAÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ > > ¼ s21 a1 þ s22 a2 > b2 > > > > ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ > b1 ¼ s11 a1 þ s12 a2 > > > > ðBÞ > ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ > > b2 ¼ s21 a1 þ s22 a2 > > > > > < bðAÞ ¼ aðBÞ 2 1 ðAÞ ðBÞ > > a ¼ b > 2 1 > > > ðA;BÞ > ðAÞ > > b1 ¼ b1 > > > > ðA;BÞ ðBÞ > > b2 ¼ b2 > > > > > ðAÞ > > a1A;B ¼ a1 > > > > : ðA;BÞ ðBÞ a2 ¼ a2
ð9:1Þ
The first two (respectively, the third and fourth) equations of system (9.1) constitute the relation between the incident and reflected waves of network A (B). Moreover, the wave reflected from port 2 of network A coincides with the wave incident on port 1 of network B, and vice versa, as the fifth and sixth equations state. Finally, port 1 (2) of the equivalent network coincides with port 1 of network A (port 2 of network B), and similarly with the corresponding waves, according to the last four equations of system (9.1). In order to determine the scattering parameters of the cascaded network, we have to substitute the fifth and sixth equations into the first four of system (9.1). In this way, we remove the quantities aA2 ; bA2 ; aB1 and bB1 , and can express the remaining waves of networks A and B as " # " # 8 ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ > > bðAÞ ¼ sðAÞ þ s12 s21 s11 aðAÞ þ s12 s11 s22 s12 þ sðAÞ sðBÞ aðBÞ > > 1 11 1 12 12 2 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ > < 1 s22 s11 1 s22 s11 " # > ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ > > s21 s21 s12 s21 s22 ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ > > b ¼ a þ þ s : 2 22 a2 ðAÞ ðBÞ 1 ðAÞ ðBÞ 1 s22 s11 1 s22 s11 Finally, after simplifying the second coefficient in the first of the above equations, and considering the last four equations of system (9.1), we get the scattering parameters of the equivalent network: 3 2 ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ s12 s21 s11 s12 s12 ðAÞ 2 ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ 3 6 s11 þ 7 1 sA22 sB11 1 sA22 sB11 7 6 h i s12 s11 7 6 ðA;BÞ 4 5 ð9:2Þ ¼6 S ¼ 7 7 6 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ s21 s21 s12 s21 s22 4 s21 s22 ðBÞ 5 þ s22 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ 1 s22 s11 1 s22 s11
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
291
Before considering the consequences of identities (9.2) in more detail, we need to consider some important simplified cases: ðAÞ
ðBÞ
1. One of the interfacing ports is perfectly matched, i.e. s22 ¼ 0 or s11 ¼ 0, and the cascaded twoport networks assume the scattering matrix 3 2 ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ s12 s21 s11 ðAÞ ðBÞ h i sðAÞ ¼0 6 sðAÞ þ s s 11 12 12 7 7 1 sA22 sB11 SðA;BÞ 22¼ 6 5 4 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ s21 s21 s22 or h
2 ðAÞ s i sðBÞ ¼0 6 11 SðA;BÞ 11¼ 6 4 ðAÞ ðBÞ s21 s21
3
ðAÞ ðBÞ
s12 s12 ðBÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ
s12 s21 s22
ðBÞ þ s22 ðAÞ ðBÞ 1 s22 s11
7 7 5
respectively. Thus, if port 2 of network A (port 1 of network B) is perfectly matched, it follows that the input (output) reflection coefficient of the resulting network equals the one of network A (B). Furthermore, in both cases, the forward and reverse transmission coefficients of the resulting network coincide with the products of the corresponding coefficients of the two networks. ðAÞ
ðBÞ
2. One of the two networks is unilateral, i.e. s12 ¼ 0 or s12 ¼ 0, and identities (9.2) simplify to 3 2 ðAÞ s11 0 h i sðAÞ ¼0 6 7 7 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ SðA;BÞ 12¼ 6 s12 s21 s22 4 s21 s21 ðBÞ 5 þ s 22 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ 1 s22 s11 1 s22 s11 or
2
ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ
s s s11 ðAÞ 6 s þ 12 21 ðAÞ ðBÞ h i sðBÞ ¼0 6 11 1 s22 s11 6 ðA;BÞ 12 S ¼ 6 ðAÞ ðBÞ 6 s21 s21 4 ðAÞ ðBÞ
1 s22 s11
3 0 7 7 7 7 7 ðBÞ 5 s22
Therefore the other network does not affect the reflection coefficient corresponding to the external port of the unilateral network, and the resulting network is still unilateral. Similar ðAÞ ðBÞ consequences can be derived if we consider the dual case – which is s21 ¼ 0 or s21 ¼ 0 – just by swapping the port index. ðAÞ
ðBÞ
3. One of the interfacing ports is perfectly matched, i.e. s22 ¼ 0 or s11 ¼ 0, and both networks are unilateral, i.e.
ðAÞ s12
¼
ðBÞ s12
¼ 0. The resulting scattering parameters simplify to 2 3 ðAÞ h i s11 0 ðA;BÞ 5 ¼4 S ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ s21 s21 s22
Note that this expression holds true if just one of the interfacing ports is matched; it is not necessary for both ports to match. 4. Both the networks are passive and loss free, thus the network scattering parameters are related as 2 2 2 2 ðAÞ ðAÞ ð AÞ ð AÞ ð AÞ ð AÞ ð AÞ ð AÞ s12 ¼ s21 ; s12 ¼ s21 ¼ 1 s11 ¼ 1 s22 ) s11 ¼ s22
292
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
and ðBÞ
ðBÞ
s12 ¼ s21 ;
2 2 2 2 ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ s12 ¼ s21 ¼ 1 s11 ¼ 1 s22 ) s11 ¼ s22
From the relation between the transmission and reflection coefficients, we can also write 8 8 h i h i ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ > > > > s ¼ r exp jj ¼ r exp jj s > 11 > 11 11 11 > > > > > > h i h i < < ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ s22 ¼ rðAÞ exp jj22 s22 ¼ rðBÞ exp jj22 and > > > > > > qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi h qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi h i i > > > > 2 2 ðAÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðBÞ > > : s12 ¼ s21 ¼ 1 ½rðAÞ exp jj21 : sðBÞ 1 ½rðBÞ exp jj21 12 ¼ s21 ¼ where all the variables rðAÞ ; jð11AÞ ; jð21AÞ ; jð22AÞ ; rðBÞ ; jð11BÞ ; jð21BÞ ; jð22BÞ are real quantities and rðAÞ ; rðBÞ are also non-negative. Substituting the above quantities into expressions (9.2), we obtain the magnitude of the transmission coefficients of the cascaded networks qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiqffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 1 ½rðAÞ 1 ½rðBÞ ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ h i s12 ¼ s21 ¼ ð AÞ ð BÞ 1 rðAÞ rðBÞ exp j j22 þ j11 Now, for any possible combination of the values jð22AÞ ; jð11BÞ the denominator of the expression above is bounded within the limits nh io ð AÞ ð BÞ 1 rðAÞ rðBÞ 1 rðAÞ rðBÞ exp j j22 þ j11 1 þ rðAÞ rðBÞ Hence, the cascaded two-port networks have a resulting magnitude of transmission coefficient bounded within the limits qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiqffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiqffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 2 2 1 ½rðAÞ 1 ½rðBÞ 1 ½rðAÞ 1 ½rðBÞ ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ ¼ s ¼ s s ¼ s21;max 12 21 21;min 1 þ rðAÞ rðBÞ 1 rðAÞ rðBÞ The quantity " 20 log10
ðA;BÞ
s21;max ðA;BÞ
s21;min
#
¼ 20 log10
1 þ rðAÞ rðBÞ 1 rðAÞ rðBÞ
ð9:3Þ
is the ratio between the maximum and the minimum possible amplitude of the transmission coefficient of the cascaded two-port networks when the phases of the reflection coefficients of the interfacing ports vary arbitrarily. It is possible to demonstrate that the resulting network is loss free, like its two components. Thus the minimum amplitude of the transmission coefficient is associated with the maximum reflection coefficient amplitude, hence vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi n ðAÞ 2 on ðBÞ 2 offi u rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2ffi u 1 r 1 r t ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ s11;max ¼ s22;max ¼ 1 s21;min ¼ 1 2 ð A Þ ð B Þ ½1 þ r r vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi u u1 þ 2rðAÞ rðBÞ þ rðAÞ 2 rðBÞ 2 1 þ rðAÞ 2 þ rðBÞ 2 rðAÞ 2 rðBÞ 2 ¼ t 2 2 1 þ 2rðAÞ rðBÞ þ ½rðAÞ ½rðBÞ vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi u u þ 2rðAÞ rðBÞ þ rðAÞ 2 þ rðBÞ 2 rðAÞ þ rðBÞ rðAÞ rðBÞ 1 ðAÞ t ¼ ¼ ffi r þ rðBÞ ð9:4Þ 2 2 1 þ rðAÞ rðBÞ 1 þ 2rðAÞ rðBÞ þ ½rðAÞ ½rðBÞ
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
293
Table 9.1 Worst case mismatch combinations of two passive, loss-free, cascaded two-port networks having the same reflection coefficients. rðAÞ ¼ rðBÞ 0.891 0.794 0.708 0.631 0.562 0.501 0.447 0.398 0.355 0.316 0.251 0.200 0.158 0.126 0.100 0.056 0.032 0.018 0.010
20 log10 rðAÞ
ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ s11;max ¼ s22;max
i h ðA;BÞ 20 log10 s11;max
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 14 16 18 20 25 30 35 40
0.993 0.974 0.943 0.903 0.854 0.801 0.745 0.687 0.630 0.575 0.473 0.384 0.309 0.248 0.198 0.112 0.063 0.036 0.020
0.057 0.228 0.508 0.890 1.366 1.926 2.560 3.257 4.009 4.807 6.511 8.318 10.195 12.116 14.066 19.007 23.988 28.982 33.980
Table 9.1 shows the results obtained from the worst case mismatch, obtained from the combination of the reflections from the two networks, in the special case of rðAÞ ¼ rðBÞ . The second and fourth columns of the table present the return loss corresponding to the reflection coefficient of the single and cascaded networks, respectively. In engineering practice, it is often assumed that the components to be cascaded are perfectly matched. Under this simplified hypothesis, assuming N components and denoting their scattering parameters with an index from 1 to N, the scattering matrix of the cascaded network is an immediate consequence of Equation (9.2) 3 2 N Y ðk Þ s12 7 0 h i 6 7 6 k¼1 7 ð9:5Þ Sð1...NÞ ¼ 6 N 7 6Y 5 4 ðk Þ s21 0 k¼1
The approximate equation (9.5) neglects the effect of the mismatch between the interfacing ports. Any couple of mismatched interfacing ports contributes to the transmission coefficient by the factor ðkÞ ðk þ 1Þ
½1 s22 s11 1 . Furthermore, the mismatch on the interfacing ports modifies the reflection coefficients of the two-port resulting from two cascaded networks. The approximation involved with the assumption (9.5) consists of replacing (9.2) with 3 2 3 2 ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ h i s12 s11 0 s12 s12 ðA;BÞ 5 5¼4 ð9:6Þ ¼4 S ðA;BÞ ðA;BÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ s21 s22 s12 s12 0
294
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
amplitude error |S22aS11b| arg(S22aS11b)
phase error unit circle
Figure 9.2
Graphical vector representation of the denominator of the terms of matrix (9.2).
Comparing (9.6) with (9.2), and focusing on the forward transmission coefficient, we recognize that the approximated approach neglects the denominator of all the terms of the matrix (9.2) ðAÞ ðBÞ
1 s22 s11
ð9:7Þ
Figure 9.2 shows a graphical representation of that neglected factor. ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ It can be seen that, for any given value of the amplitude s22 s11 , the factor 1 s22 s11 can assume2 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ any amplitude within the limits 1 s22 s11 ; 1 þ s22 s11 , and any phase within the limits ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ tan 1 s22 s11 ; tan 1 s22 s11 . Now, in engineering practice, the amplitude3 – but not the phase – of the network reflection coefficients is usually specified. Moreover, the specification of the transmission coefficient phase is seldom used, as well. The reason for this is because it is difficult to control the phase of the transmission coefficient in the production of the network, and the reflection coefficient phase presents even more difficulties. For instance, if a transmission line is present on the signal path, any variation Dl in its length will cause a variation of bDl on the phase of the transmission coefficient, and double the quantity on the reflection coefficient phase. Examples 9.1 and 9.2 below clarify the effects of the phase shift due to the impedance mismatch.
EXAMPLE 9.1 PHASE MISMATCH CAUSED BY IMPEDANCE MISMATCH Let us consider the simple assembly illustrated in Figure 9.3a. It consists of a Wilkinson power divider (DIV), whose two outputs feed the two external ports (P2 and P3 ) of the assembly through two cables (CB1 and CB2 ). Such an assembly is typically used when a single source (connected to port P1 ) has to deliver its signal to two different loads (connected to P2 and P3 ).
h i h i ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ The minimum or the maximum of the amplitude occurs for arg s22 s11 ¼ p or arg s22 s11 ¼ 0, while the h i ðAÞ ðBÞ phase is minimum or maximum for arg s22 s11 ¼ p=2, respectively. 2
3
In most cases, instead of the reflection coefficient, the return loss is specified: RL ¼ 20 log10 ðjskk jÞ.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN CB1
Γ1 P1
P2
2
1
3
(a)
P3
Γ2
DIV
CB2
[S(A1)] 2 P1
295
1
1
[S(B1)] 2
P2
CB1 Γ2
(b)
P1
1
[S(B2)]
Γ1 2
[S(A2)]
1
2
P3
CB2
(c)
Figure 9.3 Networks discussed in Example 9.1: (a) block diagram of the assembly; (b) equivalent two-port for the path P1–P2; (c) equivalent two-port for the path P1–P3.
Let us assume that DIV is anpffiffiideal Wilkinson4 power divider with a single section. Two ffi transmission lines with Z0 ¼ 50 2 ffi 70:7 O and the same length connect node 1 with nodes 2 and 3, while an ideal 100 O resistor is placed between nodes 2 and 3. Moreover, the two transmission lines are l=4 at the centre of the operating frequency of the component. That component is electrically and mechanically symmetrical, thus s12 ¼ s21 ¼ s13 ¼ s31 ; s22 ¼ s33 . Figure 9.4 shows the response of the component, assuming a centre frequency of 7.5 GHz. It can be seen that the one-section Wilkinson divider works ideally (s11 ¼ s22 ¼ s33 ¼ s32 ¼ 0; js21 j2 ¼ js31 j2 ¼ 0:5) only at the centre frequency (7.5 GHz in our case). If we accept a return loss5 of about 15.18 dB and an isolation6 of 14.69 dB, the working bandwidth of the components equals one octave (5 to 10 GHz in our case). Now, if CB1 is identical to CB2 , then the symmetry of the assembly follows from the symmetry of DIV. In practical cases, none of these two assumptions is rigorously true. Furthermore, in most cases, the cables are specified in terms of return loss and insertion loss in the frequency band of interest. Sometimes, the maximum difference between the amplitude and/or the phase of the transmission coefficient is also specified. 4 Section 7.7.1 describes the Wilkinson power divider. The shape of the symbol in Figure 9.3 indicates the internal structure of the component. 5 Here, the term return loss denotes the lowest of the quantities 20 log10 ðjs11 jÞ and 20 log10 ðjs22 jÞ ¼ 20 log10 ðjs33 jÞ. Over the considered bandwidth, the worst case input return loss is 20 log10 ðjs11 jÞ ffi 15:18 dB, while the worst case output return loss is 20 log10 ðjs22 jÞ ¼ 20 log10 ðjs33 jÞ ffi 29:16 dB. 6 Here, by the term isolation, we mean the attenuation between the output ports, port 2 and port 3, i.e. the quantity 20 log10 ðjs32 jÞ.
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING -3.0
10 s21
20 log10(|S21|)
-3.1
0
-3.2
-10 s32 s11
-3.3 -3.4
-20
s22
-3.5
-30 -40
5
Figure 9.4
6
7 8 Frequency, GHz
9
10
20 log10(|s11|), 20 log10(|s22|), 20 log10(|s31|)
296
Response of the ideal single section Wilkinson divider.
In order to focus on the impedance mismatch effects, we will consider DIV as ideal, while CB1 and CB2 are loss free, their transmission coefficients have the same phase, and their return loss is no higher than 20 dB. Furthermore, the two cables have a physical length l ¼ 400 mm and a dielectric constant7er ¼ 2:2. To simplify our analysis, we will assume that the two cables are ideal transmission lines, and that the cause of the finite return loss is the characteristic impedance different from 50 O. The cables present the maximum impedance mismatch (are perfectly matched) when their length equals odd (even) multiples of l=4. ðCB1Þ ðCB2Þ Denoting Z0 and Z0 as the characteristic impedances of CB1 and CB2 , respectively, the maximum amplitude of the reflection coefficients that those lines present to DIV are h h ðCB1Þ i2 ðCB2Þ i2 ½Z ðCB1Þ 2 2 2 Z0 0 Z0 50 50 50 50 rmax;1 ¼ ðCB1 ; rmax;2 h ¼ h i i ðCB1Þ 2 ðCB2Þ 2 ½Z0 Þ 2 2 2 Z0 þ 50 þ 50 þ 50 Z0 50
A return loss of 20 dB corresponds to a reflection coefficient of 20 logðrÞ ¼ 20 ) r ¼ 0:1. Thus the cable impedance can assume any value within the interval h i2 ðCB1Þ Z0 502 0:1 h ; i ðCB1Þ 2 Z0 þ 502
h h
ðCB2Þ
i2
Z0
502
Z0
þ 502
i ðCB2Þ 2
0:1
Solving for the characteristic impedances, the above inequalities give pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðCB1Þ ðCB2Þ 45:227 ffi 50 9=11 Z0 ; Z0 50 11=9 ffi 55:277 Then, the worst case is when one cable has the minimum impedance and the other has the maximum: ðCB1Þ
Z0
7
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ 50 9=11;
Corresponding to Teflon-isolated coaxial cables.
ðCB2Þ
Z0
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ 50 11=9
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN 20
-2.5
s21
-3.0
10
s31 -3.5
0
-4.0
-10
s11 s22
s33
-4.5
-5.0 5
Figure 9.5
6
7 8 Frequency, GHz
9
20 log10(|skk|)
20 log10(|s21|), 20 log10(|s31|)
297
-20
-30 10
Simulated response of the network in Figure 9.3a.
The three-port network in Figure 9.3a can be considered as two separate two-port networks, as illustrated in Figures 9.3b,c, respectively. Also, we will neglect the effect of the different loading of the third port of the divider; in other words, we will consider G2 ¼ 0 (G1 ¼ 0) when analyzing the transmission from P1 to P2 (P1 to P3 ). This assumption corresponds to considering DIV as presenting infinite isolation (s23 ¼ 0), while this is true only at the centre frequency. ðAÞ ðBÞ With these different assumptions, we have that the factor 1 s22 s11 has an amplitude bounded within the interval 29:16 20 Amplitude mismatch 2 1 10 20 10 20 ;
1 þ 10
29:16 20 20 10 20
ffi ½0:997; 1:003
corresponding to a maximum amplitude imbalance of 10 log10 ð1:003=0:997Þ ffi 0:061 dB between the paths P1–P2 and P1–P3. The effect of the mismatch on the phase is
29:16 20 29:16 20 Phase mismatch 2 tan 1 10 20 10 20 ; tan 1 10 20 10 20 ¼ ½ 0:2 ; 0:2 The maximum imbalance condition occurs when one port is at its possible minimum and the other is at its maximum; this is why the maximum imbalance variation is double the corresponding mismatch interval. Thus, the maximum phase imbalance is 0:4 . It is possible to describe the network in Figure 9.3a as a circuit simulator.8 Figure 9.5 shows the predicted response of the subsystem. Note that the output return loss (corresponding to s22, s33) is worse
8
See the Ansoft file 01_Power_Divider_with_Cables.adsn.
298
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 5
0.5
4
20 log10(|s21/s31|)
20 log10(|s21/s31|)
2 1
-0.5
(180/π) arg(s21/s31)
0 -1
-1.0
(180/π) arg(s21/s31)
3
0.0
-2 -3 10
-1.5 5
6
7 8 Frequency, GHz
9
Figure 9.6 Amplitude and phase matching between the two output ports P2, P3 of the assembly in Figure 9.3.
than that between the power divider and the cables: the peak over the frequency is about 18.25 dB, in good agreement with expression (9.4) ðAÞ r þ rðBÞ ðA;BÞ Output return loss ¼ 20 log10 s11;max ¼ 20 log10 1 þ rðAÞ rðBÞ 0 ¼ 20 log10
@ 10
29:16 20
1 þ 10
þ 10
20 20
29:16 20 20 10 20
1 A ffi 17:47
Furthermore, the transmission coefficient amplitude of the path P1 to P2 differs slightly from that of the path P1 to P3, as expected. More precisely, Figure 9.6 shows the amplitude (left y axis) and the phase (right y axis) matching between the two paths. The resulting peak quantities are 0:2 dB and 1:1 respectively, significantly higher than the values above derived from analytic considerations ð0:06 dB; 0:4 Þ. The reason for such a discrepancy is due to the approximation ignoring the effect of the mismatched cable loading of the output ports of the power divider. This simplification is equivalent to assuming G1 ¼ G2 ¼ 0, as already pointed out. The circuit simulation can also be used to analyze the assembly under the simplifying hypotheses involved with the analytic considerations.9 The resulting amplitude and phase imbalance is 0.05 dB and 0.3 , a little bit less than the worst possible case. Finally, note that both the amplitude and the phase imbalance increase when passing from the centre frequency to the extremes of the frequency band. This is a straightforward consequence of the decreasing output return loss of the power divider.
9
See the Ansoft file 02_Power_Divider_with_Cables_more_Ideal.adsn.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
299
EXAMPLE 9.2 MISMATCH RESONANCES The factor (9.7) also plays an important role when the interfacing ports of the two cascaded networks present high values of the reflection coefficient. A typical case is two cascaded filters, which occurs when the second filter is used to clean the spurious passband of the first. In this case, the two filters present a common stopband: in that frequency range, the two reflection coefficients of the ðAÞ ðBÞ interfacing ports have amplitudes close to 1: s22 s11 1. Therefore, if some frequencies h i ðAÞ ðBÞ exist, such that arg s22 s11 ¼ p, then the denominator of the cascaded filters’ transmission coefficient approaches zero, and – simultaneously – the numerator tends to zero as well.10 Consequently, the cascaded filters’ transmission coefficient assumes the form 0=0, and could assume finite non-zero values, despite both filters having s21 0. Under these conditions, the response of the cascaded filters presents some low-attenuation peaks, which we will refer to as mismatch resonances. Here, we will examine an example of such a phenomenon by means of a simple ideal case. The two filters considered in this example are purely ideal; no details about their physical realization will be given. Figure 9.7a shows two cascaded filters with an interposed 50 O transmission line. The presence of the line models any possible physical connection between the two filters, like a printed circuit trace, coaxial cable, male–female connector couple, and so on. As we know, the transmission line can be considered as a part either of the first or the second filter: the result is a modification of the phase but not of the amplitude of the network. The first (second) filter of the network in Figure 9.7a is a bandpass (lowdpass) filter, denoted as BPF (LPF). Figure 9.7b shows the detailed structure of the two filters. BPF is a commensurate Richards filter with three stubs: two open circuit in series and one short circuit in parallel. Its prototype is a third-order Chebyshev one with 0.2 dB ripple: the coefficients are g0 ¼ g4 ¼ 1; g1 ¼ g3 ¼ 1:228; g2 ¼ 1:153. The passband extends from 1.95 to 2.05 GHz, thus f0 ¼ 2 GHz; D f ¼ 100 MHz. Application of the Richards transformation11 gives
po po
tan tan 1 po 2 o0 2 o0 3
¼j ¼j ffi j 39:29 10 tan p o1 p f0 Df =2 jo0 2 o0 tan tan 2 o0 2 f0 From the parameter a and the prototype coefficients12 we obtain the characteristic impedance of the three stubs
p f0 Df =2 g1 ffi 1562:155; Z0;1 ¼ Z0;3 ¼ 50 tan 2 f0
p f0 Df =2 g2 ffi 2:264 Z0;2 ¼ 50 tan 2 f0
Figure 9.8 (solid lines) shows the amplitude response of the ideal Richards filter. It is known that it presents spurious passbands at odd integer multiples of f0. A loss-free two-port network (like a filter is, ideally) has js21 j2 ¼ js12 j2 ¼ 1 js11 j2 ¼ 1 js22 j2 , hence if js11 j ¼ js22 j ! 1 then js21 j ¼ js12 j ! 0. 11 See Section 7.5.4. 12 See Section 7.3.4. 10
300
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING BPF
Z0=50Ω
P1
LPF P2
(a) BPF Z0,1
LPF Z0,3 Z0=50Ω
L1
L3 C2
P1
L5
L7
C4
C6
7
P2
Z0,2 (b)
Figure 9.7 Cascaded bandpass with lowdpass filter: (a) block diagram; (b) electric circuit with the internal structure of the filters.
The LPF has to clean the spurious response of the BPF, ensuring a minimum stopband rejection of more than 70 dB up to 10 GHz and beyond, although it also slightly increases the overall lowdpass selectivity. The LPF is then a lumped Chebyshev lowdpass one, with a cut-off frequency fT ¼ 2:05 GHz, passband ripple of 0.2 dB, and order N ¼ 7. The prototype coefficients are g0 ¼ g4 ¼ 1;
g1 ¼ g7 ¼ 1:372;
g2 ¼ g6 ¼ 1:378;
g3 ¼ g5 ¼ 2:276;
g4 ¼ 1:5
10
0
20 log10(|s21|)
-40
-10
lowdpass, s21
-20
-60 lowdpass, s11
bandpass, s11
20 log10(|s11|)
0
-20
-30
-80 bandpass, s21
-40
-100 0
2
4 6 Frequency, GHz
8
10
Figure 9.8 Amplitude responses of the filters in Figure 9.7. Solid lines represent the bandpass filter (BPF), dashed lines represent the lowdpass filter (LPF).
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN 20 log10(|s21,assembly |) 20 log10(|s21,bandpass s21,lowdpass|) 20 log10(|s11,assembly |)
0
10 0
mismatch resonance
-40
-10
-60
-20
-80
-30
-100
20 log10(|s11|)
-20 20 log10(|s21|)
301
-40 0
Figure 9.9
2
4 6 Frequency, GHz
8
10
Amplitude response of the filter assembly in Figure 9.7.
From the prototype coefficients, we obtain the ladder network components13 g1 g3 L1 ¼ L7 ¼ 50 ¼ 5:327 nH; L3 ¼ L5 ¼ 50 ¼ 5:327 nH 2pfT 2p fT C2 ¼ C6 ¼
1 g2 ¼ 2:14 pF; 50 2pfT
C4 ¼
1 g4 ¼ 2:329 pF 50 2pfT
Figure 9.8 (dashed curves) shows the transmission and reflection coefficient amplitude of the LPF. Figure 9.9 shows the amplitude response14 of the network in Figure 9.7. In detail: .
The grey solid curve (right y axis) is the reflection coefficient: the resulting passband return loss is about 11.3 dB better than the worst case given by Equation (9.4) ðA;BÞ rðBPFÞ þ rðLPFÞ s11;max ¼ 1 þ rðBPF Þ rðLPF Þ rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Ripple BPF Ripple LPF 10 10 þ 1 10 1 10 rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffirffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi 0:406 ) return loss 7:82 dB ¼ Ripple BPF Ripple LPF 10 10 1 þ 1 10 1 10
.
The black solid curve (left y axis) is the transmission coefficient of the network in Figure 9.7.
.
The black dashed curve (left y axis) is the product of the two transmission coefficients of the two filters, BPF and LPF.
Comparing the two latter curves, we can see that they are not coincident, because of the factor (9.7). In particular, at the frequency of 2.362 GHz, the combination of the two filters presents a local minimum attenuation of 36.3 dB, rather than of 65.1 dB, as one might expect considering the attenuation of the two filters only. This is exactly a mismatch resonance, as predicted at the beginning of this example. 13 14
For the synthesis of lumped lowdpass Chebyshev filters, see the Mathcad file 05_Low_Pass_Example2.MCD. See the Ansoft file 03_Filter_Assembly.adsn.
302
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
9.3 Signal flow graphs Signal flow graphs (SFGs) are useful tools for representing and analyzing microwave networks. They are graphical representations of the scattering parameters, and are built from two simple construction rules: 1. The graph resulting from an N-port network has 2N nodes: N for the incident waves and as many for the reflected waves at the corresponding port. 2. The graph resulting from an N-port network has N 2 branches. Each branch is directed from the node representing the incident wave ak ðk ¼ 1; . . . ; NÞ to the one representing the reflected wave bk ðk ¼ 1; . . . ; NÞ. The weight of the branch from node ah to node bk is equal to skh ðh; k ¼ 1; . . . ; NÞ. The weight of the branch is a complex function of the frequency. SFGs can thus be used for networks with an arbitrary number of ports. Figure 9.10a is the signal flow of a two-port network. The SFG resulting from a plurality of networks, somehow reciprocally connected, is obtained by combining all the SFGs of the different networks and reducing the four nodes, relative to the waves at two interfaced ports, to two nodes. If port n of network A is connected to port m of network B, the nodes ð AÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ an ; bm will become the same node, and the same thing happens with bn ; am . Applying this procedure to the network in Figure 9.1, we obtain the SFG in Figure 9.10b. After drawing the couples of coincident nodes as a single node, the resulting final SFG is the one shown in Figure 9.10c. After obtaining the SFG of the arbitrarily complex network, we need to compute the transfer ratio from the generic nodes ah* to bk* ; in other words, we have to determine the scattering matrix of the
s21
a1
b2
s11 (a)
s22
b1
a2
s12
network A a
(A) 1
s11(A) b1(A) (b)
s21
(A)
(B)
(A)
s22
s11 (B)
s12(A) a2(A) = b1 b2(A) = a1(B)
a1
(A)
s11(A) (c)
b1
(A)
network B s21(B) b2(B)
b2(A) = a1(B)
s21 (A) s22
s12(B) b2
(B)
s22
a2(B)
(B)
(B)
(B) s11(B) s22 (A) s12(B) s12 a2(B) a2(A) = b1(B)
Figure 9.10 Signal flow graphs of: (a) a two-port network; (b) two cascaded two-port networks; (c) simplified graph resulting from (b).
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
303
network. This result can be achieved without any empirical or heuristic method, by applying Mason’s rule. It is possible to demonstrate [1] that the scattering parameter from node ah* to node bk* is h i h i P P P P P1 1 Lð1Þð1Þ þ Lð2Þð1Þ þ P2 1 Lð1Þð2Þ þ Lð2Þð2Þ þ P P P sh*;k* ¼ 1 Lð1Þ þ Lð2Þ Lð3Þ þ ð9:8Þ where: .
.
.
.
The terms P1 ; P2 . . . are the paths from node ah* to node bk* . A path is a set of consecutive branches with the same direction, starting from ah* and arriving at bk* such that any node cannot be touched more than once. The value associated with each path is the product of all its branches. For instance, considering the SFG in Figure 9.10c, and focusing on the nodes aA1 ; bA1 , we have the two paths P1 ¼ sA11 ; P2 ¼ sA21 sB11 sA12 . P The term Lð1Þ is the sum of all first-order loops, defined as the product of the consecutive and codirectional branches, beginning from and ending on the same node. example as PIn the same considered in the previous point, we have only one first-order loop, Lð1Þ ¼ sA22 sB11 . P The terms LðkÞ ðk > 1Þ are the sum of all the kth-order loops, defined as the product of any non-touching first-order loop. P The terms LðkÞðlÞ are the sum of all the kth-order loops not touching the path l.
The SFG in Figure 9.10c has no term of the latter two types; it is therefore easy to apply Mason’s rule to it and reobtain formula (9.1).
9.4 Noise in two-port networks In communication and test equipment, the useful signal is the one that must be transmitted, received, measured, and so on. On the other hand, we define as noise any unwanted signal added to the useful ones. Two main types of signal sources have to be considered: voltage and current noise sources. Noise can be produced either by other electric/electronic equipment which is placed close to the circuit of interest, or by other causes inherent to the devices of the circuit itself. Sometimes noise is simply due to signals considered useful by other users. A typical case occurs when multiple radio emissions in the same frequency band are present in the same space region, and cause reciprocal co-channel interference with each other. Here, we will focus our attention on the noise inherent in the electronic devices themselves. We will see that any real device embodies voltage and/or current noise sources. A voltage (current) noise source is a generator producing a random variable stimulus. Due to its random characteristic, instant-by-instant determination of the noise is impossible; therefore a statistical approach is required.
9.4.1
Noise sources
Given a random varying voltage vn ðtÞ or current in ðtÞ, we can characterize the noise sources in terms of the Fourier transform of the respective time domain expressions: þð1
Vn ð f Þ ¼
þð1
vn ðtÞexpð j2pftÞ dt; 1
In ð f Þ ¼
in ðtÞexpð j2pftÞ dt 1
304
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
We define the voltage noise density of a noise source in terms of the active power dissipated on a resistor ideally in parallel with the source, within a unit bandwidth. If Vn ð f Þ is the voltage noise density, R is the resistance of the resistor and Pdissipated ð f1 ; f2 Þ is the power dissipated on the resistor in the frequency range ð f1 ; f2 Þ, we have 1 R
ð f2
jVn ðf Þj2 d f ¼ Pdissipated ðf1 ; f2 Þ
ð9:9Þ
f1
If an infinitely narrow band is considered, in other words, for the limit as f1 tends to f2, Equation (9.9) becomes jVn ð f Þj2 ¼ R lim
df !0
Pdissipated ðf d f ; f þ d f Þ 2d f
ð9:10Þ
This equation defines the voltage noise source. Note that the dependence on the load resistance present in Equation (9.10) is only apparent because of the inverse proportionality between power and resistance. Furthermore, if the voltage noise density is constant within a 1 Hz band, it equals the square root of the normalized power in that band. In a similar way, we can define the current noise density as jIn ðf Þj2 ¼
Pdissipated ðf d f ; f þ d f Þ 1 lim d f ! 0 R 2d f
ð9:11Þ
Because of the random characteristic of the noise sources, the functions Vn ðf Þ; In ð f Þ are not directly observable or measurable. Rather, their square amplitude is the only measurable quantity, although the functions themselves are sometimes used in calculations, as intermediate quantities. The simplest case to consider is the resistor. Physical resistors produce random fluctuating voltages, due to the agitation of free charges inside the material of the resistors themselves. As we will see shortly, the power noise associated with these fluctuations is proportional to the absolute temperature of the resistor. The physical root cause of this behaviour is the increasing agitation of the resistor electron with temperature. For this reason the resistor noise is sometimes referred to as thermal noise.15 A detailed explanation of the physics of the phenomenon is beyond the scope of this book, so we will limit ourselves to some fundamental concepts, without giving a demonstration, although it exists. For our applications it is sufficient to know that any resistor has an associated noise source, as Figure 9.11 shows. Any real resistor can be schematized with an ideal noise-free resistor, having the same resistance in series with a noise voltage generator, as Figure 9.11b shows. For the noise source, its square amplitude density is ðresistorÞ 2 V ð f Þ ¼ 4 K T R n
ð9:12Þ
where K ¼ 1:374 10 23 J=K is the Boltzmann constant, T is the absolute temperature of the resistor and R is the resistance of the resistor. Moreover, the amplitude distribution of the voltage noise is Gaussian. More precisely, if we consider a frequency interval ð f1 ; f2 Þ, the observed voltage across the resistor is a random signal, having a Gaussian distribution with zero mean and standard deviation pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi svn ¼ 2 K T R ð f2 f1 Þ ð9:13Þ
15 The thermal noise concept is wider than that of resistor noise. For instance, an antenna surrounded by a homogeneous gas at a temperature T picks up noise with a power density K T. It is well known that a directional antenna pointing towards the ground receives higher noise than the same antenna directed towards the sky. Also the noise floor of the Universe corresponds to the absolute temperature of 3 K.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
305
R (a) Vn
R (b) R
(c)
in
Figure 9.11 Noise associated with resistors: (a) real resistor; (b) ideal resistor with a series voltage noise source; (c) ideal resistor with shunt current source.
As a consequence of Equations (9.9) and (9.12), we have that any real resistor produces noise, with an associated available power of Resistor noise power ¼ K T B
ð9:14Þ
where B ¼ f2 f1 is the bandwidth considered. Note that the noise power of a resistor depends only on the bandwidth, and not on any particular allocation of it. At the standard temperature of 17 C, corresponding to T ¼ 290:15 K, the resistor noise power density (i.e. the power within 1 Hz bandwidth) is 3:987 10 21 W=Hz, corresponding16 to 113.994 dBm/MHz. Figure 9.11c shows an alternative model for the noisy resistor, which is totally equivalent to the one in Figure 9.11b. Applying the Norton transformation to the latter network, we obtain the first, i.e. in ¼ vn R 1 . The current noise density for the network in Figure 9.11c is then ðresistorÞ 2 1 I ð f Þ ¼ 4 K T ¼ 4 K T G n R
ð9:15Þ
The equivalent network in Figure 9.11b (or c) applies to any resistor included in any circuit model of real capacitors, inductors and stubs, although any ideal purely reactive bipole is noise free. The resistor noise presents a flat voltage density over the frequency. Noise presenting such a characteristic is referred to as white noise. More complicated functions describe the noise associated with more complex devices, such as diodes, transistors, tubes, and so on. Active and nonlinear devices usually include noise contributions that are not white; the most relevant of these noise terms is the flicker noise, which presents a voltage noise density inversely proportional to the square root of the frequency.
9.4.2
Representation of noisy two-port networks
Any two-port network includes all the noise sources associated to all its components: their combination can be schematized with only two noise sources, either at the same port or at both ports of the network. In this regard, it must be considered that two correlated noise excitations are equivalent to a single one equal to their sum. In other words, two correlated noise sources follow the same superimposition rule as for the 16
The thermal noise density is usually rounded to 114 dBm/MHz.
306
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
usual deterministic excitations. Conversely, the contributions of non-correlated17 noise sources sum quadratically. The equivalent of two voltage (current) noise generators in series (parallel) having a voltage (current) density of Vn1 ð f Þ; Vn2 ð f Þ ðIn1 ðf Þ; In2 ð f ÞÞ is equivalent to a single generator having a voltage or current density of qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi or jVn1 ð f Þj2 þ jVn2 ð f Þj2 jIn1 ð f Þj2 þ jIn2 ð f Þj2 The expression for the resulting source is purely real. This is not surprising, in that the only meaningful quantity associated with noise is the power or the normalized power. The effect of all the combined noise sources that could be present inside a two-port network is taken into account by adding a noise term to each equation of the network. Among the many possibilities, we will consider the impedance, admittance and ABCD matrices, which give respectively
V1 ¼ z11 I1 þ z12 I2 þ vn1 V2 ¼ z21 I1 þ z22 I2 þ vn2
ð9:16Þ
I1 ¼ y11 V1 þ y12 V2 þ in1 I2 ¼ y21 V1 þ y22 V2 þ in2
ð9:17Þ
V1 ¼ AV2 þ BI2 þ vn I1 ¼ CV2 þ DI2 þ in
ð9:18Þ
Figure 9.12a shows a noisy two-port network; Figures 9.12b–d show the resulting equivalent networks, obtained from Equations (9.16) to (9.18). All the noise-free two-port networks in Figure 9.12 have the same network parameters as the originating noisy two-port network in Figure 9.12a, apart from the noise, of course. This approach allows us to move the noise sources out of the network, with remarkably simple calculations.
9.4.3
Noise figure and noise factor
From a black-box point of view, the noise factor (F) is the parameter that characterizes the noise performances of the two-port in networks. Figure 9.13a shows a power generator at the input (port 1) of a noisy two-port network. The source model used in Figure 9.13a indicates the noise associated with the series resistance, which is inherently present within the generator. However, for our subsequent considerations a Norton – rather than a Thevenin – schematization is more convenient to use: Figure 9.13b shows the result. As usual, the components of the two schematizations in Figures 9.13a,b are related as Is ¼
Vs ; Rs þ jXs
Gs þ jBs ¼
1 Rs þ jXs
The network in Figure 9.13c derives from the one in Figure 9.13b, by applying the equivalent network in Figure 9.12d – which is based on the ABCD matrix – to the noisy two-port network. The noise-free
17 The hypothesis of non-correlated noise sources applies in most cases. So do all the resistors in a network – including the parasitic ones associated with other components. Sometimes, active device models use both correlated and non-correlated noise sources.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN I1 V1
307
I2 V2
2
1 noisy network
(a)
I1
Vn1
V1
Vn2
I2
2
1
V2
noise-free network (b)
I2
I1 in1
V1
2
1
in2
V2
noise-free network (c) I1 V1
I2
Vn in
1
2
V2
noise-free network (d)
Figure 9.12 Representations of noisy two-port networks: (a) noisy two-port network; (b) representation of (a) based on the impedance matrix; (c) representation of (a) based on the admittance matrix; (d) representation of (a) based on the ABCD matrix.
two-port network in Figure 9.13c can be modelled as a controlled source with finite input and output impedance, as Figure 9.13d shows. As a first step in our analysis,18 we will determine the parameters of the equivalent noise-free twoport network of Figure 9.13d. The input admittance Yin , presented by that network to the load, is obtained from the ABCD matrix, combined with the condition imposed by the load impedance 8 V1 ¼ AV2 þ BI2 > ( > < V1 ¼ ð A Zload þ BÞI2 I1 D C Zload ) I1 ¼ CV2 þ DI2 ) ¼ Yin ¼ > V B A Zload 1 I1 ¼ ð C Zload þ DÞI2 > : V2 ¼ Zload I2
ð9:19Þ
18 The reader should keep in mind that all the network and noise parameters are functions of the frequency. The dependence is not explicitly indicated, in order to obtain more compact expressions.
308
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING noisy resistor Xs
Rs
Vnr
+ Vs
1
2
Zoad
2
Zoad
2
Zoad
noisy network (a)
Is
Bs
Gs
inr
1 noisy network
(b) Vn Is
Bs
Gs
inr
in
1 noise-free network
(c)
Vn Is
Bs
Gs
inr
in
Zout 1
Zin Vi
AvVi
2
Zoad
noise-free network (d)
Figure 9.13 Signal power source connected to a noisy two-port network: (a) Thevenin equivalent circuit for the power source; (b) Norton equivalent circuit for the power source; (c) noise representation based on the ABCD parameters; (d) quasi-unilateral equivalent of a noise-free two-port network.
Similarly, combining the ABCD matrix with the input termination due to the source admittance, we obtain the output impedance Zout of the noise-free two-port network 8 V1 ¼ AV2 þ BI2 > > < V2 Zs D B I1 ¼ CV2 þ DI2 ) AV2 þ BI2 ¼ Zs CV2 þ Zs DI2 ) Zout ¼ ¼ > A Zs C I2 > : V1 ¼ Zs I1
ð9:20Þ
Finally, the open-circuit transfer ratio Av is 8 > < V1 ¼ AV2 þ BI2 V2 1 I1 ¼ CV2 þ DI2 ) V1 ¼ AV2 ) ¼ Av ¼ > A V 1 : I2 ¼ 0 Note that the two-port network could be non-unilateral: this means that Yin and Av could depend on Zload .
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
309
The second step is to compute the contribution of each generator on the input voltage. The voltages produced by the different generators are 1 . Signal current: Vsignal;1 ¼ Is Yin þ Ys 1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi . Resistor noise current: Vnr;1 ¼ 4 K T Gs Yin þ Ys Ys Vn Yin þ Ys 1 . Input noise current: V 0 n;1 ¼ In Yin þ Ys All these individual contributions must be summed using the rules described in Section 9.4.1. In this regard, we will assume that the resistor noise is not correlated with the two-port noise sources. For the two-port network current noise, we will assume that it is partly correlated with the voltage noise. Thus, that noise current is the sum of two terms, one correlated with the noise voltage and one uncorrelated .
Input noise voltage: Vn;1 ¼
In ¼ In;corr þ In;uncorr Furthermore, we can write that the correlated current equals the noise voltage, multiplied by the complex quantity Gg þ jBg, which has the dimension of an admittance; thus
In ¼ Gg þ jBg Vn þ In;uncorr Considering this assumption, and the expressions for the various noise terms, the resulting noise voltage across the input port is h 2 2 i 1 Vn;total 2 ¼ ð9:21Þ 4 K T Gs þ Ys þ Gg þ jBg jVn j2 þ In;uncorr 2 jYin þ Ys j The signal power source includes the thermal noise associated with its conductance; thus any physically existing signal generator is always noisy. The resulting signal to noise ratio (S=N) depends on the bandwidth considered. We can characterize the intrinsic S=N of the signal generator by assuming that it is terminated on its conjugated19 impedance, and considering a narrow bandwidth d f across the signal frequency. The S=N inherent in the power source is I 2 1 s 2 Gs ð9:22Þ S=Ninput ¼ K T df It is easy to see that the ratio (9.22) is independent of the source loading, therefore, in particular, it coincides with the input S=N of the network in Figure 9.13a. The effect of the two-port network on the noise can be characterized by computing S/N at the output, assuming the same narrow bandwidth d f : 2 1 Vsignal;1 2 A2 Zload Vsignal;1 2 v Zload þ Zout ReðZload Þ ð9:23Þ ¼ S=Noutput ¼ 2 Vn;total 2 d f 1 Vn;total 2 A2 Zload d f v Zload þ Zout ReðZload Þ
19 The conjugated matching allows the maximum power transfer ratio. Furthermore, under this condition, the voltage across (the current through) the load equals half of the open- (short-)circuit voltage (current) of the power source.
310
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Note that the output S=N depends neither on the noise-free two-port network parameters, nor on the output impedance, in that these parameters affect both the signal and the noise by the same multiplying factor.The noise factor is defined as the ratio of the two ratios (9.22) and (9.23). It is important to clarify that the only input noise to consider is the thermal one associated with the real part of the generator’s immittance, ignoring any other noise contribution: F¼
Ys þ Gg þ jBg 2 jVn j2 þ In;uncorr 2 S=Ninput ¼ 1þ S=Noutput 4 K T Gs
ð9:24Þ
Due to non-correlation between the input and the network noises, the output S/N is always lower (i.e. worse) than the input one. Hence F 1, with the equality applying only for ideal noise-free networks, such as networks with all purely reactive elements. The noise factor (9.24) can be rewritten by using transformed quantities, in order to obtain a more compact and meaningful expression, particularly for high-frequency networks. Exploiting the expressions for the resistor noise (9.12) and (9.15), we can define one equivalent noise resistance for the voltage noise source and one equivalent noise conductance for the uncorrelated noise source Vn;uncorr 2 ¼ 4 K T Rn ;
In;uncorr 2 ¼ 4 K T Gu
ð9:25Þ
Substituting definitions (9.25) into the noise factor (9.24), we obtain F ¼ 1þ
2
2 i G u Rn h þ Gg þ Gs þ Bg þ Bs Gs Gs
ð9:26Þ
The noise factor depends on the noise parameters of the two-port network and on the source impedance. The minimum value of F is the one with the source admittance equal to its optimum value Ys;opt ¼ Gs;opt þ jBs;opt . In order to determine the optimum source admittance, we will begin by considering that the quantity (9.26) is the sum of four non-negative terms, namely 1;
2 Rn Gg þ Gs ; Gs
2 Bg þ Bs ;
Gu Gs
The third term is easily minimized (vanishes) by assuming Bs;opt ¼ jBg . Under this condition, the noise factor (9.26) simplifies to F ¼ 1þ
2 G u Rn Gg þ Gs þ Gs Gs
Now, the noise factor is still positive – more precisely, greater than 1 – and depends solely on the source admittance Gs . Moreover, F tends to infinity for Gs tending either to zero or to infinity. Therefore the optimum source conductance is obtained by minimizing (vanishing) the derivative of F with respect to Gs . The result is
2 Gu Rn rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 d 1þ Gg þ Gs þ Gu R G G n s g Gu Gs Gs ¼ ¼ 0 if G ¼ G ¼ þ G2g s s;opt dGs G2s Rn Hence Ys;opt ¼
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Gu þ G2g jBg Rn
ð9:27Þ
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
311
The minimum noise factor of the two-port network is obtained by substituting the admittance (9.27) into expression (9.26)
Fopt ¼ 1 þ 2Rn Gg þ Gs;opt
ð9:28Þ
Finally, we can rewrite the noise factor in terms of the optimum admittance and minimum noise figure. Inverting Equations (9.27) and (9.28), Gs;opt ¼
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Gu Gu þ G2g ) ¼ G2s;opt G2g ; Rn Rn
Gg ¼
Fopt 1 Gs;opt 2Rn
Substituting the above expressions into Equation (9.26) we get F ¼ Fopt þ
2
2 i Rn h Gs Gs;opt þ Bs Bs;opt Gs
ð9:29Þ
Note that all three expressions (9.24), (9.26) and (9.29) are functions of six real variables: ðGs ; Bs ; Gg ; Bg ; jVn j2 ; jIn;corr j2 Þ, ðGs ; Bs ; Gg ; Bg ; Rn ; Gu Þ and ðGs ; Bs ; Gs;opt ; Bs;opt ; Rn ; Fopt Þ, respectively. Furthermore, the source conductance and susceptance are always present. In most cases, a logarithmic parameter is used to characterize the noise of two-port networks: that parameter is the noise figure (NF) defined as NF ¼ 10 log10 ðFÞ
ð9:30Þ
Another parameter used to describe the noise in two-port networks is the noise temperature Tnoise , obtained by considering the network as noise free, and attributing the increased output noise to a higher temperature of the input resistance. Figure 9.14a,b show the connections used for the definition of Tnoise . In both these figures the resistor R terminates the input port (1) of a two two-port network. In Figure 9.14a we have the two-port network of interest, with the resistor temperature at its physical value T. The twoport network in Figure 9.14b has the same parameters as the one in Figure 9.14a, but is noise free; its input resistor has the temperature Tnoise . The noise temperature is such that the output noise of both the combinations is the same, thus K T GA F ¼ K Tnoise GA
KT
R
1
(b)
2
K T GA F
2
K TnoiseGA
noisy 2-port network
(a)
K Tnoise
GA, F
R
1
GA, F=1
noise-free 2-port network
Figure 9.14 Setup for the noise temperature definition: (a) noisy two-port network with input resistor at the physical temperature; (b) noise-free two-port network with input resistor at the noise temperature.
312
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Sout, Nout
Sin, Nin Zs
+ 1
Vs
GA, F
2
Zoad
(a)
PAV
GA
GA PAV K T B GA F
KTB (b)
Figure 9.15
K T B (GA F -1)
Noisy two-port network (a) and its equivalent block diagram (b).
Therefore Tnoise ¼ F T
ð9:31Þ
Observations: (a) The signal generator considered in the noise factor definition is quasi-ideal, in that it has a finite associated series resistance, and all its noise is due to that resistance. This is not always the case, because most of the real generators have higher associated noise. For instance, if we look at port 2 of any network in Figure 9.13, we can still see a signal generator with a finite series resistance, but its noise is higher than K T B. (b) The definitionof the noise factor– and thus of the noise figure– in terms of a ratio between S/N ratios could cause some misunderstanding. Therefore we must make it clear that the noise produced by any physical two-port network is additive rather than multiplicative. In other words, the two-port network adds noise to the thermal noise floor, and the first – although defined in terms of it – is independent of the latter. Figure 9.15 shows a useful schematization for noisy two-port networks. The configuration in Figure 9.15a comprises one signal power generator and one terminated noisy two-port network. For the available signal power, the two-port network presents at its output port (2) that of thegenerator PAV multiplied byits availablegain GA .On the other hand, independently of the available input noise density, the network adds its own contribution equal to K T ðGA F 1Þ. If the input noise density equals the thermal one, the total output noise is K T GA F. (c) Let us assume the generator in Figure 9.15a has a noise power density equal to K T while the twoport network is a resistive attenuator20 at the same temperature as the generator. Under these assumptions, looking at port 2 of the network, we can still see a power generator with non-zero series resistance at the same temperature as the input generator. Consequently, the attenuator output noise density is K T, as for the input generator. On the other hand, the available signal power at the attenuator output equals that of the input generator multiplied by the attenuator available gain, which is less than 1. If we compute the ratio between input and output S=N, we can 20
For instance, one of the networks described in Section 7.4.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
Figure 9.16
313
Schematic for the computation of the noise factor of two cascaded two-port networks.
see that the noise factor of the attenuator equals the reciprocal of its available gain. Therefore, the noise figure of a resistive attenuator is equal to its attenuation.21 The same consideration also applies to many passive matched two-port networks, like lossy transmission lines, filters in their passband, and so on.
9.4.4
Noise factor of cascaded networks
An important application of the schematization in Figure 9.15 is in the analysis of cascaded noisy networks. Figure 9.16 shows two cascaded two-port networks. By definition, the noise factor Fcascaded of the resulting two-port network is the ratio between the input and output S/N, when the input noise is the thermal one Fcascaded ¼
Sin =Nin Sout =Nout
Travelling along the cascade, from the input of the first22 network to the output of the second, we have: .
Sin PAvailable ¼ Nin K T B where PAvailable is the available power of the generator;
.
.
S2 PAvailable GA;1 ¼ N2 K T B GA;1 F1 Sout PAvailable GA;1 GA;2
¼ Nout K T B GA;1 F1 GA;2 þ K T B GA;2 F2 1
Hence Fcascaded ¼ F1 þ
21
F2 1 GA;1
ð9:32Þ
Both these two positive quantities are expressed in dB. When two-port networks are cascaded, common engineering practice defines the network closest to the signal generator (load) as the first (last). 22
314
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Equation (9.32) states that the noise factor of the second network contributes to the global noise factor by the term ðF2 1Þ=GA;1 that can be set below any given low value, by providing a sufficient gain of the first network. Under this condition, the noise factor of the first network mainly determines the global one; that is why, when two amplifier stages are cascaded, the stage with the lowest noise must be used as the first one.
9.4.5
Noise bandwidth
The noise can also be used to define a special characteristic of filters or, more generally, of linear two-port networks with frequency-dependent response, known as noise bandwidth (NBW). Figure 9.17 shows the setup for the definition of NBW. The noise generator NG is placed at the input of the filter FILT, which has the output terminated on the termination TERM. The output impedance of NG, the reference impedance of FILT and the impedance of TERM all have the same value Z0 . If Vn ðf Þ is the voltage noise density of NG, the available total noise power at the output of NG is PnAV
1 ¼ 4ReðZ0 Þ
1 ð
jVn ð f Þj2 d f 0 ðFILTÞ
The noise power transferred to the termination is affected by the filter transmission coefficient s21 PðTERMÞ n
1 ¼ 4ReðZ0 Þ
1 ð
ðFILTÞ 2 jVn ð f Þj2 s21 ð f Þ d f
as
ð9:33Þ
0
If Vn ðf Þ ¼ Vn0 is constant over the frequency (white noise), the total noise power on the termination is PðTERMÞ ¼ n
jVn0 j2 4ReðZ0 Þ
1 ð
ðFILTÞ 2 s21 ð f Þ d f
0
Let us consider the special case of an ideal filter, having the rectangular response
js021 ð f Þj ¼ 2
8 > ðFILTÞ >
NBW 2 NBW j f f 00j < 2 j f f 00j <
> > :0
ð9:34Þ
ðFILTÞ 2 where gðFILTÞ is the maximum s21 ð f Þ over the frequency.
If FILT has the response (9.34), the output noise power on the termination is 0
¼ PðTERMÞ n
jVn0 j2 4ReðZ0 Þ
1 ð
js0 21 ð f Þj d f ¼ 2
0
Pin NG
Figure 9.17
jVn0 j2 ðFILTÞ NBW g 4ReðZ0 Þ
Pout FILT
TERM
Setup for the noise bandwidth definition.
ð9:35Þ
0
1.0
-10
|s21|2
1.5
20 log10(|s21|) → 0.5
-20
315
20 log10(|S21|)
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
2
← |s21|
0.0 0.5
-30 1.5
1.0 f/f0
Figure 9.18
Response and noise bandwidth of a bandpass filter.
The generic noise power (9.33) coincides with the one in the case of the rectangular filter (9.35) if ðTERMÞ
Pn
ðTERMÞ0
¼ Pn
, which implies that NBW ¼
1 ðFILTÞ 2 max s21 ðf Þ
1 ð
ðFILTÞ 2 s21 ð f Þ d f
ð9:36Þ
0
In other words, the noise bandwidth of a given filter FILT is the passband of a rectangular filter, having a passband gain equal to the maximum of FILT and transferring the same noise power to the output. Definition (9.36) applies to any filter response with a finite passband extension, thus lowdpass and bandpass. In these two cases, the parameter f 0 0 is defined as: .
Low pass: f 0 0 ¼ NBW=2. In this way, the function (9.34) defines an ideal lowdpass response extending from zero (DC) to NBW.
.
Bandpass: f 0 0 ¼ f0 . Thus the ideal response (9.34) presents the same centre frequency as FILT.
Figure 9.18 shows the amplitude response in dB (grey curve, right y axis), the power response (black line, left y axis) of a bandpass filter, together with the associated ideal response23(9.34) (dashed curve, left y axis). The specific filter analyzed is a lumped third-order Chebyshev one, with 0.5 dB of passband ripple and a minimum insertion loss of 1 dB, thus gðFILTÞ ¼ 10 1=10 ffi 0:794. The relative equal-ripple bandwidth24 is Df = f0 ¼ Do=o0 ¼ 2=15 ffi 0:133, the relative 3 dB bandwidth is about 0.19 and NBW= f0 ffi 0:196. Thus, the 3 dB bandwidth is wider than the equal-ripple one – as expected – and the noise bandwidth is wider than both.
23
See the Mathcad file 06_Band_Pass_Noise_Bandwidth.MCD. The equal-ripple bandwidth is defined for lossy-free filters, while the 3 dB and the noise bandwidths require no assumption of filter dissipation loss. 24
316
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
x
Figure 9.19
1
fnon-linear (x)
2
y
Nonlinear instant relation between two variables.
9.5 Nonlinear two-port networks The majority of electrical networks are nonlinear, although their workings can be considered as linear for practical uses. The degree of nonlinearity in high-frequency networks depends on their type. Purely passive components25 exhibit nonlinear behaviour only when the applied power approaches the components’ safety limits. Components including semiconductors or other types of active devices could present significant nonlinear effects even if the input power is quite lower than the maximum. Other types of components, such as detectors, mixers and frequency multipliers, are inherently nonlinear and base their workings on the nonlinearity itself. Whether the nonlinear products are undesired side effects, or constitute the main reason for the component working, some general rules are the basis for both the analysis and design of components. This section deals with instantaneous nonlinear two-port networks, presenting some general concepts and definitions, useful for analysis and design at both the component and system levels. An important property of linear networks is that their response to a sinusoidal excitation is a sinusoid with the same frequency. For instance, if we apply a sinusoidal voltage across a linear bipole, the resulting current is sinusoidal and has the same frequency as the voltage. Conversely, the response of nonlinear networks to sinusoidal excitations is not sinusoidal, as we will see shortly. We can consider the excitation as the input signal of the network, and the response as the output. The case of the two-port network, with the wave incident on one port considered as the input and the wave reflected from the other port as the output, is particularly interesting for high-frequency applications. Given a linear two-port network, if the incident wave on port 1 is a1 ðtÞ ¼ a1;0 cosð2pf0 tÞ then the resulting reflected wave to port 2 is b2 ðtÞ ¼ a1;0 js21 ð f0 Þjcosf2pf0 t þ arg½s21 ð f0 Þg Therefore, there is a frequency-dependent relation between the input and output amplitude and the phase. We define a network as instantaneous if the relation between the input and output is independent of the frequency and the added phase is zero. In our example, the two-port network is instantaneous if js21 ð f0 Þj and arg½s21 ð f0 Þ are independent of f0 and arg½s21 ð f0 Þ ¼ 0. In general, high-frequency two-port networks are simultaneously non-instantaneous and nonlinear. Despite this, a wide approach to analysis and synthesis is based on the separation of the network into simpler subnetworks of two types: linear non-instantaneous or nonlinear instantaneous ones. Here, we will limit consideration to nonlinear instantaneous networks of one single input and one single output. Figure 9.19 shows a block diagram representation of a nonlinear input/output relation. The letter x denotes the input or the independent variable, while the output or the dependent variable is indicated with y. The scheme of Figure 9.19 is quite general, in that x and y could represent voltages, currents, incident or
25
Like those described in Chapter 6.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
317
reflected waves. Moreover, those quantities could be at the same port of a bipole or at different ports of a two-port network. As is well known, under some conditions26 which we will assume to be satisfied, a nonlinear function can be approximated by the Taylor series fnonlinear ðxÞ ffi
n X
ck ðx x0 Þk ¼ c0 þ c1 ðx x0 Þ þ c2 ðx x0 Þ2 þ c3 ðx x0 Þ3 þ
ð9:37Þ
k¼0
with ck ¼
1 d k fnonlinear ðxÞ k! dxk x¼x0
The Taylor approximating polynomial (9.37) has a wide range of applicability in high-frequency nonlinear networks. One of the few cases where it does not work is when abruptly quasi-discontinuous nonlinear functions have to be considered. Therefore, very general nonlinear functions can be studied by means of their Taylor approximating polynomials. Subsequent subsections explore the results of sinusoidal excitations of nonlinear networks, exploiting the series expansion in (9.37).
9.5.1
Harmonic and intermodulation products
The present section examines the output of a nonlinear instantaneous network when the input is a single sinusoid or the sum of two sinusoids of different frequency. The trigonometric identities (A.76) to (A.79) show that the expression ½a cosðaÞ þ b cosðbÞk includes terms of the type am bn cosðma nbÞ with m; n ¼ 0; 1; . . . ; k; m þ n k , at least for k 5. Moreover, it is possible to demonstrate that such an assertion holds true for any k, although nonlinearities with order higher than 5 are of limited interest in this context. Equation (9.37) states that the output of the generic nonlinear block in Figure 9.19 is the sum of some powers of the input, multiplied by a constant coefficient. Therefore, if the input is a pure sinusoid, or a combination of two sinusoids, substitution of expressions (9.34) to (9.36) into the function (9.33) results in a combination of many sinusoidal components. Sections 9.5.2 and 9.5.3 will examine these two cases in more detail.
9.5.2
Harmonic distortion
We will consider here the nonlinear response to a purely sinusoidal excitation, showing that the resulting waveform includes components with frequency equal to multiple integers of the one in the excitation. Let us examine the first four terms of Equation (9.37) when the input is a sinusoidal term x ¼ V1 cosðo1 t þ j1 Þ
ð9:38Þ
26 Let f ðxÞ be a function defined over an interval A. For a given x0 2 A let the nth derivative d n f ðxÞ=dxn exist for x ¼ x0 and, furthermore, d n 1f ðxÞ=dxn 1 exist for any x 2 A. Then the following identity applies:
f ðxÞ ¼
n X 1 k d f ðxÞ=dxk x¼x0 ðx x0 Þk þ Rn ðx x0 Þ k! k¼0
where the remainder Rn ðx x0 Þ is an infinitesimal term of order higher than ðx x0 Þn or, equivalently, lim ½Rn ðx x0 Þ=ðx x0 Þn ¼ 0
x ! x0
318
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The terms for the second member of expression (9.37) coincide with the first one of the identities (A.82) to (A.84), if we assume a ¼ V1 ; a ¼ o1 t þ j1 ;
b¼0
ð9:39Þ
Substituting (9.39) into (9.37), truncated at the fourth-degree term, and applying the identities (A.82) and (A.85), we get
1 3 3 yðtÞ ffi c0 þ c2 V12 þ c4 V14 þ c1 V1 þ c3 V13 cosðo1 t þ f1 Þ 2 8 4
1 1 1 þ c2 V12 þ c4 V14 cos½2ðo1 t þ f1 Þ þ c3 V13 cos½3ðo1 t þ f1 Þ 2 2 4 þ
1 c4 V14 cos½4ðo1 t þ f1 Þ 8
ð9:40Þ
The first, second, third, fourth and fifth terms of Equation (9.40) are the DC, fundamental, second harmonic, third harmonic and fourth harmonic, respectively. More generally, considering all the terms in the series (9.37), it is possible write yðtÞ ffi
n X
hk cos½ðo1 t þ j1 Þk
ð9:41Þ
k¼0
Thus, the response of a nonlinear network to a sinusoidal excitation is a periodic waveform having the same fundamental frequency as the excitation, but including new sinusoidal components whose frequency is an integer multiple of the fundamental. Those multiple frequency components are the harmonics of the sinusoidal excitation: their frequency is double, triple, quadruple, or any integer multiple of the input one. These distortion products are referred to as the second, third, fourth or the nth harmonic, respectively. Truncation of the series (9.37) to the kth-order term results in a waveform with harmonics up to the same order k. Inspection of expression (9.40) suggests that, for small values of the excitation amplitude V1 , the amplitude of the kth-order harmonic tends to zero as V1k . This assertion holds true for any considered maximum degree in the powers of the series (9.37). For instance, when truncating to fourth order, the amplitudes of the various harmonics, from zero to the fourth, as in Equation (9.40), are: 1 3 . h0 ¼ c0 þ c2 V 2 þ c4 V 4 1 1 2 8 3 3 . h1 ¼ c1 V1 þ c3 V 1 4 1 1 2 . h2 ¼ c2 V þ c4 V 4 1 1 2 2 1 . h3 ¼ c3 V 3 1 4 1 . h4 ¼ c4 V 4 1 8 For all these amplitudes, we have that hk tends to zero as the kth power of the input peak amplitude V1k . Figure 9.20 shows the spectra of the pure sinusoidal input and of the distorted output. Note also that the odd (even) degree term ck xk of the power series (9.33) creates odd (even) harmonics, and affects the amplitude of all the odd (even) harmonics up to order k. In particular, evenorder nonlinearities produce DC components (zero-order harmonic). Furthermore, a generic function f ðxÞ is defined as even or odd if f ðxÞ ¼ f ð xÞ or f ðxÞ ¼ f ð xÞ, respectively. In even (odd) functions having the polynomial form (9.37), only the even-order (odd-order) terms are nonzero. Therefore, even and odd nonlinear characteristics produce harmonics of the same type.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
319
x,amplitude
fundamental
O
Frequency
f1 = ω1/2π y,amplitude fundamental 3rd harmonic
DC
2nd harmonic 4th harmonic 5th harmonic f1 = ω1/2π
O
Figure 9.20
9.5.3
2 f1
3 f1
4 f1
5 f1
Frequency
Spectrum of a pure sinusoidal input (x) and the corresponding distorted output (y).
Intermodulation distortion
After considering the nonlinear response to a pure sinusoid, we next examine what happens with a dual tone excitation. Because of the involved complexity of the expressions, we will limit our developments to third order. Nevertheless, some qualitative considerations will be exposed in general cases. A dual tone excitation corresponds to the superimposition of two sinusoidal waveforms, each with arbitrary amplitude, frequency and phase. The relative expression is x2 tone ðtÞ ¼ V1 cosðo1 t þ f1 Þ þ V2 cosðo2 t þ f2 Þ
ð9:42Þ
Again, substituting expression (9.42) into (9.37) – truncated at the term with degree 3 – and applying the identities (A.76) to (A.77), we obtain
1 1 3 3 y2 tone ðtÞ ffi c0 þ c2 a2 þ c2 a2 þ c1 a þ c3 a2 b þ c3 a3 cosðaÞ 2 2 2 4
3 3 þ c1 þ c3 a2 b þ c3 ab2 cosðbÞ þ c2 ab cosða þ bÞ þ c2 ab cosða bÞ 2 4 þ
3 3 3 c3 ab2 cosða þ 2bÞ þ c3 ab2 cosða 2bÞ þ c3 a2 b cosð2a þ bÞ 4 4 4
þ
3 1 1 c3 a2 b cosð2a bÞ þ c2 a2 cosð2aÞ þ c2 b2 cosð2bÞ 4 2 2
þ
1 1 c3 a3 cosð3aÞ þ c3 b3 cosð3bÞ 4 4
where a ¼ V1 ; a ¼ o1 t þ f1 ; b ¼ V2 ; b ¼ o2 t þ f2 .
ð9:43Þ
320
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The output waveform (9.43) is the sum of a DC component plus 12 sinusoidal terms, with their frequencies related to the input ones. We can find: 1. Six terms consisting of two sinusoids at the same frequency as the input, together with the respective second and third harmonics ðo1 ; o2 ; 2o1 ; 2o2 ; 3o1 ; 3o2 Þ. 2. Two terms having frequency equal to the sum of and the difference between the input ones ð o1 o2 ; o1 þ o2 Þ. These terms are generated by the quadratic term of the series (9.37) and their amplitude c2 V1 V2 is proportional to both the amplitudes of the input tones. They are denoted as second-order intermodulation products (IM2). 3. Four terms with their frequencies equal to the sum of one input frequency, plus or minus the second harmonic of the other. The relative frequencies are ð o1 þ 2o2 ; o1 2o2 ; 2o1 þ o2 ; 2o1 o2 Þ, with the respective amplitudes 3 4 1 c3 V1 V22 ; 3 4 1 c3 V1 V22 ; 3 4 1 c3 V12 V2 ; 3 4 1 c3 V12 V2 . These components are generated by the cubic nonlinearity, and are denoted as third-order intermodulation products (IM3). The intermodulation (or intermodulation distortion) is denoted by the acronym IMD. Generalizing the considerations of points 2 and 3, we have that a nonlinearity of order k produces intermodulation products of kth order. The respective expressions are constants multiplying terms of the type V1m V2k m cos½m ðo1 t þ j1 Þ ðk mÞ ðo2 t þ j2 Þ where m ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; k 1. Figure 9.21
x, amplitude
O
Frequency
f1 f2 y, amplitude
f1 f2
O f2 f1 2 f1 f2
2 f2 f 1
2 f1 2 f2 f2 f1
3 f1
3 f2
Frequency
2 f1 f2 2 f2 f1
Figure 9.21 Spectrum of a dual tone signal with intermodulation. Black lines with solid arrows are the original components of the signal, grey lines are the second-order products, and black lines with open arrows are the third-order products.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
321
shows the intermodulation spectrum obtained from a nonlinear characteristic with second- and thirdorder terms.
9.5.4
Gain compression
So far, we have considered generic nonlinear characteristics and derived the implications of the nonlinearities themselves on combinations of sinusoidal excitations. Now, we will examine the special and important case of the black box of Figure 9.19 representing a two-port network. Furthermore, we will assume that both the input and the output of that network are impedance matched, in order to consider the nonlinear effects separately from the mismatching ones. Under these assumptions, the input and output variables ðx; yÞ can be assumed to represent the input and output voltages of the twoport network. Finally, the two-port network considered is basically linear; the nonlinearities are side effects with increasing importance with high-level signals. Typical examples of such types of networks are amplifiers,27 but also switches, or, more generally, all the control components28 using semiconductor devices like variable attenuators and phase shifters.29 Thus our two-port networks will be excited with sinusoidal signals, and the main output spectral components will be those at the same frequency as the input. For brevity, we will refer to the two-port networks described above as quasilinear. Almost all quasi-linear networks exhibit a compression characteristic, in that for low-amplitude sinusoidal input signals the output is still sinusoidal with the same frequency and amplitude proportional to the input one. Although we did not give a precise definition of low amplitude, we will refer to this working condition as a small signal. In quasi-linear networks under small-signal operation and single tone excitation, the level of the nth harmonic is proportional to the input level raised to the nth power, as in the coefficients hk listed in Section 9.5.2. As the input amplitude rises above a certain limit, the fundamental component of the output increases less than the input, and the harmonic level no longer follows the law described above. This condition is defined as the compression region of the two-port network operation. At high compression level the fundamental output amplitude tends to a constant, almost independently of the input one, defined as the saturation amplitude. Increasing the input amplitude will cause first a decrease in the output fundamental below the saturation amplitude – such a condition represents the overdrive operation – and then permanent damage to the two-port network. As a general rule, it is quite difficult to predict the harmonic amplitudes under high compression and, for stronger reasons, under saturation or overdrive operation. Let us begin by considering a polynomial characteristic of degree 3 fthird order ðxÞ ¼ c0 þ c1 x þ c2 x2 þ c3 x3 As in Section 9.5.2, the coefficient c0 produces a DC output voltage, independently of the input signal. Since real high-frequency quasi-linear networks are normally AC coupled, the eventual DC component is not transmitted. Therefore, we can assume c0 ¼ 0 with no lack of accuracy:
c2 c3 ð9:44Þ fthird order; no DC ðxÞ ¼ c1 x þ c2 x2 þ c3 x3 ¼ c1 x þ x2 þ x3 c1 c1 We can immediately recognize that for sufficiently small values of x, the first-order term dominates the remaining ones, thus lim
x!0 27
fthird order; no DC ðxÞ ¼ c1 x
See Chapter 11. See Chapter 10. 29 Other types of networks (like detectors, mixers and frequency multipliers) are inherently nonlinear, in that their working principles rely on nonlinear effects. 28
322
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING y=x+c3x3, c3>0
ynon-linear(x)
-0.5
3
0.5
c1 (-c3)
y=x
-0.5
x O
-0.5
3
0.5
c1 (-c3)
-0.5
y=x+c3x3, c3<0 y=x+c2x2+c3x3, c3<0
Figure 9.22
Cubic and associated nonlinear functions.
Hence, within this context, the coefficient c1 is the small-signal gain30(ssg) of the two-port network, representing the ratio of the output and input fundamental levels, under small-signal operation. Let us apply a sinusoidal input signal to our quasi-linear two-port network xðtÞ ¼ V cosðotÞ
ð9:45Þ
The resulting output signal will be yðtÞ ¼ V
c1 þ
3 c3 V 2 4
cosðotÞ þ
1 1 c2 V cosð2otÞ þ c3 V 2 cosð3otÞ 2 4
ð9:46Þ
We can now examine the compression effect, qualitatively introduced at the beginning of this section, in a more quantitative manner. As anticipated, we need to model an output fundamental increasing less than the input, for relatively high input amplitudes. In other words, the considered network presents a reduced gain for high input amplitudes. From the input (9.45) and output (9.46) signal expressions, we have the fundamental gain or large-signal gain
3 G1 ¼ 20 log c1 þ c3 V 2 dB 4
ð9:47Þ
If we want G1 to decrease with the input amplitude A, we must set c1 and c3 to have opposite signs. Therefore, we will assume c1 > 0; c3 < 0 . Note also that the second-order nonlinearity does not affect the fundamental output amplitude, and therefore has no impact on the compression. Thus, in order to examine the implications of the compression in more detail, we will simplify the characteristic (9.44) by removing the second-order coefficient c2 . Figure 9.22 shows the simplified function in both the cases of c1 > 0; c3 < 0 (thin black dashed line) and c1 > 0; c3 > 0 (thin black solid line). Note that the first case presents a negative compression, in that increasing input amplitude causes an increasing output to input amplitude ratio. 30
Sometimes, SSG is defined in terms of logarithmic units: SSG ¼ 20 log10 ðssgÞ.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
323
Note also that for positive x, our curve ( c1 > 0; c3 < 0 ) reaches a maximum, then monotonically decreases up to zero and below. Moreover, the curve is anti-symmetrical (or odd). We can find the position of the maximum and minimum of the function from the vanishing derivative
d fthird order; no DC ðxÞ c3 2 d fthird order; no DC ðxÞ ¼ c1 1 þ 3 x ¼ 0 ) x ¼ Vcritical ð9:48Þ dx dx c1 where Vcritical
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 c1 ¼ 3 c3
Note that the argument of the square root is positive, because c1 and c3 have opposite sign. The relative maximum and minimum of the function are obtained by substituting the derivative zeros (9.48) into the pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffi function itself. The resulting values are ð 3=4Þc1 c1 =c3 . The cubic function represents the quasi-linear characteristic in a realistic way, provided that the input signal instantaneous amplitude does not exceed the limits (9.48). For higher absolute values, it is more pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi realistic to replace the function with its local maximum and minimum for x > c1 =ð3c3 Þ and pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi x < c1 =ð3c3 Þ, respectively. The new definition of the nonlinear transfer characteristic is then 8 rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 c1 > 3 > > x þ c x j x j c 1 3 > > 3 c3 > > > rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi > rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi < 2 1 c1 1 c1 fsaturating ðxÞ ¼ ð9:49Þ c1 x > > c 3 3 3 c3 3 > > > > rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi > > 2 1c 1c > > : c1 1 x < 1 3 3 c3 3 c3 Figure 9.22 also shows the curve (9.49), represented by the thick black line. Both the functions (9.47) and (9.49) are anti-symmetrical (or odd), i.e. f ðxÞ ¼ f ð xÞ. Therefore they produce only even-order distortion; in other words, they distort the positive half wave of the input signal in the same way of the negative one.31 Figure 9.22 also shows the function (9.47) and its saturated counterpart, after the addition of a small second-order coefficient. The result is a slightly non-symmetrical transfer characteristic, with consequent generation of second-order distortion, without significantly affecting the compression performances, as we will see shortly. The function (9.49) is continuous in all of its derivatives (which are non-zero up to third order) within the interval ½ Vcritical ; Vcritical , where Vcritical is defined by Equation (9.48). Within that interval, the function satisfies the requirements for the expansion in a Taylor series, and the series coincides with the originating polynomial c1 x þ c3 x2 . The higher order derivatives of the function (9.49) present a discontinuity at jxj ¼ Vcritical , vanishing for jxj > Vcritical and also being non-zero32 for jxj Vcritical . Outside the above-mentioned interval, the Taylor expansion is therefore no longer applicable. Nevertheless, in many cases, it is still possible to find approximating polynomials for a saturating characteristic of the type (9.49), by applying curve-fitting methods.33 This possibility extends the applicability of the considerations of Sections 9.5.1 to 9.5.4 to the characteristic (9.49). However, if the input signal remains pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi within the limit jxj c1 =ð3c3 Þ, the curve (9.49) is not distinguishable from its originating thirdorder polynomial. 31
See the curves in Figure 9.23, obtained for a purely sinusoidal waveform. For instance, d 2 ðc1 x þ c3 x3 Þ=dx2 ¼ dðc1 þ 3c3 x2 Þ=dx ¼ 6c3 x, which is non-zero 8x „ 0. Conversely, for pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi jxj > c1 =ð3c3 Þ, the function (9.49) is constant; thus all its derivatives – including the second one – vanish. 33 See the Mathcad file 07_Saturation_Polynomial_Curve_Fit.MCD. 32
324
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING y(t) ysat 2 V=∞ (square wave)
4 1
V/Vcritical=0.5
ωt=2π
ωt=π
-ysat
Figure 9.23 Output waveforms resulting frompincreasing signals applied to the ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi amplitude sinusoidal pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi nonlinear characteristic (9.48)ð Vcritical ¼ 3 0:5 c1 =c3 ; ymax ¼ 2=31:5 c1 c1 =c3 Þ. After clarifying the limitations on the applicability of the function (9.44), we can reconsider the amplitude of the output fundamental signal (9.46). Its explicit expression is h1 ¼ c1 V þ
3 c3 V 3 4
ð9:50Þ
The amplitude (9.50) is zero for two values of the input amplitude, precisely V ¼ 0 and pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi V ¼ ð4c1 Þ=ð3c3 Þ. The first of these zeros is quite obvious, corresponding to no input signal. pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi However, for positive input amplitudes, 0 < V < ð4c1 Þ=ð3c3 Þ, the fundamental output amplitude h1 initially increases up to a maximum, and then decreases down to zero. The abscissa of that maximum coincides with the positive zero of the derivative of the function (9.50) with respect to V: dðh1Þ 2 ¼0)V¼ dA 3
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi c1 c3
ð9:51Þ
The input amplitude (9.51) slightly exceeds34 the limits (9.48) for the validity of the characteristic (9.44). Thus, we can give three different estimates of the maximum fundamental output amplitude associated with the characteristic (9.48): 1. The most conservative one is based on the maximum validity range of the polynomial (9.44), and gives rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 c1 c1 3 c1 ¼ h1max;1 ¼ h1 V ¼ 3 c3 c3 4
34
The maximum input amplitude is obtained from the vanishing derivative of the output fundamental amplitude, pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi and is V ¼ ð2=3Þ c1 =c3 ffi 0:667 c1 =c3 , while the range (9.48) gives V c1 =ð3c3 Þ ffi 0:577 c1 =c3 .
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
325
2. A more realistic value, assuming the input amplitude (9.51), is rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 c1 4 c1 ¼ c1 h1max;2 ¼ h1 V ¼ 3 9 c3 c3 3. The third is obtained by using the function (9.49) instead of (9.44). Expression (9.50) is no longer valid. The maximum amplitude of the output fundamental spectral component must be calculated by more complicated considerations. Figure 9.23 shows the output waveform generated by the nonlinear characteristic (9.49) when its input signal is sinusoidal with increasing amplitude. pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi The input and output normalizing parameters used for that graph are Vcritical ¼ c1 =ð3c3 Þ; pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ysat ¼ ð2c1 =3Þ c1 =ð3c3 Þ respectively. It can be seen that, for very high input amplitude ðV ! 1Þ, the output signal tends to approximate a square wave having peak amplitude pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð2c1 =3Þ c1 =ð3c3 Þ. The amplitude of the fundamental component of that waveform is 4=p times its peak amplitude, therefore the saturated fundamental amplitude becomes pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi h1max;3 ¼ ½ð8c1 Þ=ð3pÞ c1 =ð3c3 Þ. Determinations 1 and 2 are quite close, while 3 is a little higher
20 log10 h1max;2 =h1max;1 ffi 0:226 dB; 20 log10 h1max;3 =h1max;1 ffi 1:075 dB As discussed, it is possible to find different values for the amplitude of the fundamental spectral component of the output signal in saturated operation. Moreover, the most optimistic value h1max,3 is calculated by assuming that the input amplitude can be arbitrarily increased without damaging the network, and this is not true, of course. A more significant and more univocally determinable parameter is the so-called 1 dB compression point (1dBCP). As seen many times within this section, for increasing input amplitudes V the output fundamental h1 increases less than proportionally to V; rather, the ratio h1=V decreases monotonically with V. Equation (9.47) defines the large signal gain G1 . The third member of that equation is obtained by assuming the characteristic (9.44). Since we assumed c1 > 0; c3 < 0 , G1 decreases with V until the argument of the logarithm is positive. The difference between large- and small-signal gain (expressed in dB) is a meaningful indicator of how much the network is operating under nonlinear conditions:
3 c3 2 SSG G1 ¼ G1 ðV ¼ 0Þ G1 ¼ 20 log 1 þ V 4 c1 The input amplitude which causes the large-signal gain to decrease by 1 dB with respect to the smallsignal one is, by definition, the input 1 dB compression point amplitude. From the definition, it follows immediately that V1dBCP ¼
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1=20
4 c1 c1 10 1 ffi 0:3808 c3 3 c3
ð9:52Þ
Note that the value (9.52) is within the valid range of the polynomial (9.44). The output fundamental amplitude h11dBCP corresponding to the input V1dBCP is the output 1 dB compression point amplitude. Substituting the value (9.52) into expression (9.50), we obtain h11dBCP ¼ h1ðV ¼ V1dBCP Þ ffi 0:339 c1
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi c1 c3
ð9:53Þ
326
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Our simplified cubic and cubic-saturated models do not allow a unequivocal definition of the saturated output level; nonetheless, it is still possible to find relations between the saturated and the 1 dB compression point
h1max;1 ffi 2:13 dB; 20 log h11dBCP
20 log
h1max;2 h11dBCP
ffi 2:35 dB;
20 log
h1max;3 h11dBCP
ffi 3:2 dB
Note that, whatever the definition of the saturated amplitude, the difference between the saturation and the 1 dB compression level is independent of the polynomial coefficients. The assumption 20 logðh1max =h11dBCP Þ 2:5 dB usually gives reasonable accuracy. Most frequently, the compression parameters are used for power – normally expressed35 in dBm rather than voltages. Although we defined the saturated amplitude and the 1 dB compression points in terms of voltage amplitude, a simple relation exists between the two definitions:
1 h12max . Saturated output power, Psat;dBm ¼ 10 log þ 30 10 2 R0 ! 2 1 V1dBcp . Input 1 dB compression power, I1 dBdBm ¼ 10 log þ 30 10 2 R0 2
.
Output 1 dB compression power, O1 dBdBm ¼ 10 log10
1 h11dBcp 2 R0
! þ 30
In these expressions, R0 is the matching resistance of the two-port quasi-linear network. The factor 1=2 is present in the argument of the logarithm because h1; V are peak voltage amplitudes, while the powers are RMS. The additional term þ 30 is to convert the power into dBm.
9.5.5
Intercept points
Compression on the output signal, generation of harmonics, and intermodulation products are phenomena related to the nonlinear nature of a two-port network. In principle, all three phenomena could be used to characterize the network from a nonlinear point of view. However, we have to consider that the model of Figure 9.19 alone is accurate in a few cases of high-frequency two-port networks. The main reason for this lack of accuracy is in the limited bandwidth of the physically existing quasi-linear networks. Looking at the output spectrum in Figure 9.20, we can recognize that the second harmonic falls within the network nominal bandwidth only if its extension is no smaller than an octave: wider bandwidths are required for not filtering out the higher order harmonics. Similar considerations apply to the IM2 products, shown in Figure 9.21. Differently from that, IM3 products fall within the component bandwidth – for any extension of it – providing that f1, f2 fall within the bandwidth and are sufficiently close.36 Therefore, the two-tone excitation can ’ be used to characterize the nonlinear performance of narrow-bandwidth networks. The power in dBm coincides with 10 times the decimal logarithm of the power in mW: PdBm ¼ 10 log10 ðPmW Þ: For instance, let us consider a narrow-band amplifier whose working bandwidth is 0.95–1.05 GHz. Any in-band signal has the second harmonic within the range 1.0–2.1 GHz, well out of the amplifier bandwidth; the higher order harmonics are out of band, for even stronger reasons. The IM2 ðf1 þ f2 Þ product minimum frequency is a little higher than 1.9 GHz ðf1 ¼ 0:95 GHz; f2 ’ 0:95 GHzÞ. The IM2 ðf1 f2 Þ product maximum frequency is 0.1 GHz ðf1 ¼ 0:95 GHz; f2 ¼ 1:05 GHzÞ. Hence all the second-order distortion products are strongly attenuated at the output. Differently, by choosing ð f1 ¼ 0:99 GHz; f2 ¼ 1:01 GHzÞ, some of the IM3 products fall within the network bandwidth, indeed 2f1 f2 ¼ 0:97 GHz and 2 f2 f1 ¼ 1:03 GHz. 35 36
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
327
A typical dual tone test uses two narrow-spaced sinusoidal signals having the same amplitude. Moreover, in this context we are not interested in the phase of the signals. Hence, the input signal assumes expression (9.42) with the simplifications V1 ¼ V2 ¼ V;
j1 ¼ j2 ¼ 0
The second simplification is always possible, with a proper choice of the time origin, providing that the phases j1 ; j2 are constant. The input signal is x2-tone ðtÞ ¼ V ½cosðo1 tÞ þ cosðo2 tÞ From Equation (9.43), we obtain the IM3 products 3 IM3 ¼ c3 V 3 cos½ðo1 þ 2o2 Þt þ cos½ðo1 2o2 Þt þ cos½ð2o1 þ o2 Þt þ cos½ð2o1 o2 Þt 4 ð9:54Þ All the four IM3 products have the same amplitude, proportional to the cube of the input one; the two underlined terms are the in-band ones. Expression (9.43) has been derived assuming a cubic characteristic of the network. However, all the odd-order terms generate products having frequency equal to o1 2o2 and 2o1 o2 , with amplitude proportional to c5 V 5 ; c7 V 7 . . . . As we know, at low amplitudes the lower order terms dominate. Therefore Equation (9.54) supplies a low-amplitude approximation of the amplitude of the spectral lines at o1 2o2 and 2o1 o2 . Let us focus on one of these two components, with amplitude 3 ð9:55Þ im3 ¼ c3 V 3 4 Figure 9.24 shows the typical compression curves of a quasi-linear two-port network. The power compression curve (thick black) is the fundamental power versus the input one, under a single tone excitation. The IM3 curve (thick grey) is the power of one of the two spectral lines, o1 2o2 or 2o1 o2, versus the power of one of the two equal-amplitude input tones. This curve is close to the
IP2
Output power, 10 dB/div.
1 dB
IP3
1dBCP
fundamental
IM2
IM3 Input power, 10 dB/div.
Figure 9.24 Compression curves of a quasi-linear two-port network.
328
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
approximation (9.55) (thin black) up to the 1 dB compression point. Figure 9.24 also shows the IM2 curve (thick light grey), although this is less interesting because of the considerations at the beginning of this section.37 Furthermore, Figure 9.24 includes the small-signal approximations (thin black) of the three curves, extended up to high input power operation. An interesting parameter for characterizing the nonlinear performances of a two-port network is the third-order intercept point (IP3), defined as the hypothetical point where the small-amplitude IM3 crosses the fundamental one. The input amplitude VIP3, making the amplitude (9.54) equal to the smallsignal fundamental out amplitude, is sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi 4 c1 ð9:56Þ im3 ¼ c1 V ) VIP3 ¼ 3 c3 From the amplitude (9.55), we can easily define the corresponding powers, expressed in dBm: .
Input third-order intercept point
IIP3dBm ¼ 10 log10 .
Output third-order intercept point OIP3dBm ¼ 10 log10
2 1 VIP3 þ 30 2 R0
2
1 VIP3 þ 20 log10 jc1 j þ 30 2 R0
The factor 1=2 is for the peak-to-RMS conversion, and the additional term þ 30 is peculiar to the dBm unit, as explained in the 1 dB compression point definitions. In a similar way, it is possible to define the second-order intercept points (IIP2, OIP2), although they are less interesting, particularly for narrow-band networks. From the values of (9.56) and (9.52) it is possible to find a relation between IIP3 and I1dB !
V1dBcp 0:3808 20 log10 ð9:57Þ ¼ 20 log10 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ IIP3 I1dB ffi 9:6 dB VIP3 4=3
9.5.6
Saturation and intercept point of cascaded two-port networks
Sections 9.2 and 9.4.4 dealt with the performances of two cascaded two-port linear networks, in terms of S parameters and noise performances. Here, after defining the principal nonlinear parameters of quasilinear networks, we will examine the nonlinear performances of cascaded networks. Figure 9.25 shows two two-port networks (A and B) in cascade. Each of the two networks consists of three cascaded networks,: two of them linear with a nonlinear one in between. The schematization used in Figure 9.25 somehow resembles the schematic of a single transistor amplifier.38 Looking at network A, the linear network AðA;IÞ and AðA;0Þ could be the input and output matching networks of the amplifier. ðA;IÞ P ðAÞ k and AðA;0Þ could be the nonlinear controlled The nonlinear network k ck x between A generator, contained within the nonlinear model of the transistor.39 The similarity between the schematization in Figure 9.25 and a single transistor amplifier can be increased by considering each reactive linear element of the transistor model as embodied in one of the two of AðA;IÞ and AðA;0Þ .
37
See also Section 9.5.4. See Chapter 11, in particular Section 11.2. 39 See Section 9.6. 38
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN Network A
Network B
[S(A,l)] IN
1
329
2
[S(A,O) ]
(A)
Σk ck x k 2 1
2
1
Figure 9.25
[S
(B,I)
(B)
]
2
1
Σk c k x k 2 1
[S
(B,O)
]
2
1
OUT
Cascaded quasi-linear two-port networks.
The model in Figure 9.25 is more general than a single transistor amplifier, because it can represent any nonlinear non-instantaneous two-port network. On the other hand, networks A and B in Figure 9.25 are purely unilateral, i.e. there is no backward transmission from the output to the input, although it is possible to remove this limitation by making the model more complicated. In any case, the combination of the three subnetworks modelling network A can be used to model: . The input matching, under small-signal operation, by means of AðA;IÞ . . The output matching, under small-signal operation, by means of AðA;0Þ . . The ripple on SSG, by means of AðA;IÞ and AðA;0Þ . . . .
ðAÞ
The distortion performances, through the coefficients ck .
The dependence of the compression characteristic on the frequency, by means of AðA;0Þ . The attenuation of the out-of-band distortion products, by means of AðA;0Þ .
Conversely, the representations in Figure 9.25 cannot model: .
The variation of the input and output matching with the signal amplitude.
.
The variation of the transmission coefficient phase with the signal amplitude, known as amplitude modulation to phase modulation (AM–PM) conversion.
Despite these limitations, the model in Figure 9.25 is sufficiently accurate in the majority of practical cases. In subsequent considerations, we will simplify the analysis of the configuration in Figure 9.25 by ðA;IÞ
assuming perfect input and output matching: s11
ðA;OÞ
¼ s22
ðB;IÞ
¼ s11
ðB;OÞ
¼ s22
¼ 0. For the dependence of ðAÞ
ðBÞ
the nonlinear performances on the frequency, we will consider the coefficients ck ; ck as functions of ðA;OÞ
the frequency, although not explicitly indicated, while s21 ðA;OÞ s21
ðB;OÞ
¼ s21
¼ 1. This last assumption is
ðB;OÞ s21
equivalent to considering ck;A ; ck;B as constant and ¼ as functions of the frequency if the phase of those transmission coefficients is zero. In other words, this model neglects the effects of the phase shift on the different spectral components. The variation of the SSG with frequency can be ðA;IÞ
ðB;IÞ
ðAÞ
ðBÞ
modelled either with variables s21 ; s21 and constants ck ; ck , or vice versa. We will choose the ðA;IÞ ðB;IÞ ðA;IÞ ðB;IÞ latter option, with s21 ¼ s21 ¼ 1. The phase shift associated with s21 or s21 modifies the phase of the input or output spectral components, respectively. A phase shift in the input signal corresponds to a translation of the time origin, if the input is a single or a double tone. For the output, a phase shift is not relevant in this context, in that we are dealing with the amplitudes of the various spectral components.
330
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Σk ck(A)xk yA y x
IN
Figure 9.26
s11=s22=0 |s21 |=1 2 1
xB
Σk ck(B)xk y x
OUT
Simplified version of the configuration in Figure 9.25.
In our simplifying hypotheses, the structure in Figure 9.25 simplifies to that of Figure 9.26, consisting of one linear all-pass network placed between two nonlinear networks. The linear network is perfectly matched and loss free; its transmission coefficient could present a frequency-dependent phase. A first approximate idea of the nonlinear performances of the structure in Figure 9.26 can be obtained by using a piecewise approximation of the compression curve of each subnetwork h i 8 ðaÞ ðaÞ ðaÞ > Pin Psat;in < Pin þ SSGðaÞ ðaÞ Pout ¼ ð9:58Þ h i ða ¼ A; BÞ > ðaÞ ðaÞ : PðaÞ P > P out in sat;in where: .
The generic index ða ¼ A; BÞ denotes one of the two networks.
.
SSGðaÞ ¼ 20 log10 ½c1 is the small-signal gain, in dB.
.
2 Psat;out ¼ 10 log10 f½h1ðaÞ max =2R0 g þ 30 is the saturated output power, in dBm.
.
Psat;in ¼ Psat;out SSGðaÞ is the input power level generating the saturated output power in a linear network having the same SSG.
ðaÞ
ðaÞ ðaÞ
ðaÞ
Output power, 10 dB/div.
Figure 9.27 shows the compression curve of a quasi-linear network (thick line), together with its piecewise-linear approximation (9.58).
Psat,out
Psat,in Input power, 10 dB/div.
Figure 9.27
Compression curve (thick line) and its approximating piecewise-linear curve (thin line).
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
331
The chain in Figure 9.26 saturates if one of its nonlinear subnetworks A or B does. Denoting the overall input power – in dBm – as PIN, network A saturates if PIN > Psat;out;A SSGA . On the other hand, ðBÞ if network A operates linearly, the input power of network B is Pin ¼ PIN þ SSGðAÞ . Therefore, B ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ saturates if PIN > Psat;out SSG SSG . The saturation therefore occurs in the chain of Figure 9.26 ðBÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ if the overall input power exceeds the lower of the two limits PðAÞ SSGðBÞ . sat;out SSG ; Psat;out SSG The saturated input power of the chain is then h i ðA þ BÞ ð AÞ ðBÞ Psat;in ¼ min Psat;out SSGðAÞ ; Psat;out SSGðAÞ SSGðBÞ ð9:59Þ Since we have neglected the mismatch, the SSG of the chain is the sum of the corresponding quantities of networks A and B: h i ðAÞ ðBÞ SSGðA þ BÞ ¼ SSGðBÞ þ SSGðAÞ ¼ 20 log10 c1 c1 The saturated output power is h ðA þ BÞ ðA þ BÞ ð AÞ Psat;out ¼ Psat;out þ SSGðA þ BÞ ¼ min Psat;out þ SSGðBÞ ;
ð BÞ
Psat;out
i
ð9:60Þ
The saturated output power of each nonlinear network can be determined by applying any of the values discussed in Section 9.5.4, h1max,1, h1max,2, or h1max,3; the resulting 1 dB compression point will be 2.13, 2.35 or 3.2 dB lower. A more accurate analysis can be performed by computing the 1 dB compression point of the chain in Figure 9.26. In this regard, it is useful to recall that the input instant amplitude (9.51), relative to the 1 dB compression point, is within the limits (9.47) allowed for the validity of the polynomial (9.44) rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi c1 1 c1 c1 ffi 0:5773 V1dBcp ffi 0:3808 < 3 c3 c3 c3 Hence, we can use the polynomial (9.44) to model the quasi-linear networks A and B. Moreover, in Section 9.5.4, we observed that the 1 dB compression point is barely affected by the second-order ðAÞ
ðBÞ
coefficient, therefore we can assume c2 ¼ c2 ¼ 0. Hence, neglecting the frequency-dependent phase shift introduced by the linear network placed between A and B, we can write 8 ðAÞ ð AÞ y ¼ c1 xin þ c3 x3in > > < A ðBÞ ðBÞ yout ¼ c1 xB þ c3 x3B > > : xB ¼ yA where the superscript ‘A’ or ‘B’ denotes the quantities relative to network A or B, as usual. Removing the intermediate variable xB from the above system of equations, and after some manipulations, we get the output yout as a function of the input xin h i3 h i2 h i2 h i3 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ yout ¼ c1 c1 xin þ c3 c1 þ c1 c3 x3in þ3 c1 c3 c3 x5in þ3c1 c3 c3 x7in þ c3 c3 x9in The resulting nonlinear characteristic is a ninth-order polynomial. Nevertheless, we can treat the terms with order higher than degree 3 as negligible, because of the relatively small amplitude of the input signal. The result is h i3 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAÞ ðBÞ ðAþBÞ ðAþBÞ 3 yout ffi c1 c1 xin þ c3 c1 þ c1 c3 x3in ¼ c1 xin þc3 xin ð9:61Þ
332
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The approximate characteristic (9.61) of the structure in Figure 9.26 has the same form as Equation (9.44). Therefore, we can compute the input and output 1 dB compression point by applying Equations (9.51) and (9.52) vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1
u ðAþBÞ u ð AÞ ð BÞ u u c u c1 c1 u ðAþBÞ V1dBcp ffi 0:3808t 1ðAþBÞ ¼ 0:3808u t ðAÞ ðBÞ h ðAÞ i3 ðBÞ ¼ 0:3808u t cð3AÞ c3 c3 c1 þ c1 c3 ðAÞ c1
½cð1AÞ
2 ðBÞ c3
ðBÞ c1
ðAþBÞ
Hence, the input sinusoidal amplitude V1dBcp causing 1 dB of compression in the chain is related to the corresponding quantities of networks A and B as h i2 ðAÞ 2 2 2 V1dBcp;AþB ffi V1dBcp;A þ c1 V1dBcp;B ðAÞ
where c1 is the SSG, in linear units, of network A. ðA þ BÞ Similarly, the output amplitude h11dBcp of the chain at 1 dB of compression is h
i ðA þ BÞ 2
h11dBcp
h i 2h i2 h i2 ðBÞ ð AÞ ð BÞ ffi c1 h11dBcp þ h11dBcp
From the above voltage amplitudes, we obtain the corresponding powers in dBm, which are more frequently used in engineering practice: " ðA þ BÞ I1dBdBm
¼ 10 log10 10
ðAÞ
I1dBdBm 10
O1dBdBm þ SSGðBÞ 10
" ðA þ BÞ O1dBdBm
¼ 10 log10 10
ðBÞ
þ 10
I1dBdBm SSGðAÞ 10
ðAÞ
#
ðBÞ
þ 10
O1dBdBm 10
ð9:62Þ
# ð9:63Þ
At about the third-order intercept point of the chain, we have to compute the intermodulation products resulting from an equal-amplitude dual tone excitation. Let the input signal be xIN ¼ V ½cosðo1 tÞ þ cosðo2 tÞ Then the output of the nonlinear network A coincides with the input of B and is ðAÞ
ð AÞ
yA ¼ xB ¼ c1 V ½cosðo1 tÞ þ cosðo2 tÞ þ c3 V 3 ½cosðo1 tÞ þ cosðo2 tÞ3 Applying the identity (A.77) to the last term, this equation becomes 9 ð AÞ 1 ð AÞ ð AÞ yA ¼ xB ¼ c1 V þ c3 V 3 ½cosðo1 tÞ þ cosðo2 tÞ þ c3 V 3 ½cosð3o1 tÞ þ cosð3o2 tÞ 4 4 3 ð AÞ þ c3 V 3 cos½ð2o1 o2 Þt þ cos½ð2o1 þ o2 Þt þ cos½ðo1 2o2 Þt þ cos½ðo1 þ 2o2 Þt 4
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
333
The above signal contains the amplified input signal (first term), together with the harmonic (second term) and intermodulation (third term) products. Let us consider the spectral components at the frequency of the input signal and the in-band40 intermodulation components, which have angular frequencies 2o1 o2 ð AÞ and o1 2o2 . The signal output from network A is then the sum of the useful term (I) c1 V ½cosðo1 tÞ þ ðAÞ 3 cosðo2 tÞ, plus the partial intermodulation product (II) c3 V ð3=4Þ fcos½ð2o1 o2 Þt þ ðAÞ ð AÞ cos½ðo1 2o2 Þtg and additional other terms (III) c3 V 3 ð1=4Þ ½cosð3o1 tÞ þ cosð3o2 tÞ þ c3 V 3 ð3=4Þ fcos½ð2o1 o2 Þt þ cos½ðo1 2o2 Þtg. We can approximate the signal output from B by assuming that the network linearly amplifies signals I and II, and generates intermodulation from I. This assumption corresponds to neglecting the intermodulation generated by the intermodulation products. This approach is equivalent to the one used to derive the combined characteristic (9.60), where we neglected polynomial terms higher than degree 3, as we will see shortly. Under our approximation, the overall output signal is ð AÞ ð BÞ
yOUT ¼ yB ffi c1 c1 V ½cosðo1 tÞ þ cosðo2 tÞ 3 ð AÞ ð BÞ h ð AÞ i 3 ð BÞ þ c3 V 3 fcos½ð2o1 o2 Þt þ cos½ðo1 2o2 Þtg þ c3 c1 þ c3 4 Again, we have the amplified input signal, the in-band intermodulation products and other additional – not explicitly written – distortion products. More precisely, the amplitudes of the first two terms are smallsignal approximations of the true quantities. The input third-order intercept point corresponds to the input amplitude which makes the two above quantities equal. That is, h i 3 ðAÞ ðBÞ h ðAÞ i3 ðBÞ h ðA þ BÞ i3 4 ðAÞ ðBÞ ðA þ BÞ ðA þ BÞ 2 c3 ¼ c1 c1 VIP3 ) VIP3 ¼ c3 c1 þ c1 VIP3 4 3
ðAÞ ðBÞ
c1 c1 h i3 ðAÞ ðBÞ ð AÞ ð BÞ c3 c1 þ c1 c3
The input amplitude corresponding to the third-order intercept point is then h
i ðA þ BÞ 2
VIP3
¼
h i h i2 h i 3 c3 3 h ðAÞ i2 c3 ð AÞ 2 ðAÞ ð BÞ 2 þ c1 ¼ VIP3 þ c1 VIP3 ð A Þ ð B Þ 4c 4 c ðAÞ
ðBÞ
1
1
Passing from the voltage input amplitude to the input and output power in dBm, we have ðAÞ
ðA þ BÞ IIP3dBm
ðBÞ
¼ 10 log10 10
IIP3dBm 10
¼ 10 log10 10
OIP3dBm þ SSGðBÞ 10
þ 10
IIP3dBm SSGðAÞ 10
ðAÞ
ðA þ BÞ OIP3dBm
!
ðBÞ
þ 10
OIP3dBm 10
ð9:64Þ
! ð9:65Þ
Note the analogy between formulae (9.64) and (9.65) and the corresponding formulae (9.62) and (9.63). Indeed, it is also possible to derive IIP3 and OIP3 for the cascaded networks, starting from I1dB and O1dB and considering the simple relation (9.57).
40 The considered product is in band, providing o1, o2 are in band and sufficiently close to each other. See also footnote 36.
334
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Observations: (a) The compression point and the saturated power of two cascaded two-port networks can be computed by applying any of the Equations (9.60), (9.63) or (9.65), since Psat , O1dB and OIP3 are related as explained in Sections 9.5.4 and 9.5.5. Equation (9.60) gives a more optimistic41 and less realistic result than the other two, which are equivalent; nonetheless, it is useful to dimension the saturated power and the gain of the cascaded components. For instance, let us consider that ðAÞ the two cascaded networks in Figure 9.26 are two amplifier stages. Let Pout;sat ¼ þ 5 dBm be the saturated output power of the first stage, while SSGðBÞ ¼ 8 dB is the linear power gain of the second stage. Equation (9.60) states that stage A or B determines the saturation of the chain if ðAÞ
ðBÞ
ðAÞ
ðBÞ
Pout;sat þ SSGðBÞ ¼ 13 < Pout;sat or Pout;sat þ SSGðBÞ ¼ 13 > Pout;sat. Thus if the saturated outðBÞ
put power of the second stage Pout;sat is lower than 13 dBm, we have early saturation of the chain, ðBÞ
due to the low-power output stage. Conversely, if Pout;sat > 13 dBm, there is no appreciable ðBÞ Pout;sat
improvement in respect of the limit case ¼ 13 dBm, with an associated higher power supply consumption of amplifier B. Therefore, the parameters of our components will be ðBÞ
ðAÞ Pout;sat ¼ þ 5 dBm; SSGðBÞ ¼ 8 dB; Pout;sat ¼ þ 13 dBm. Assuming O1dB ¼ Pout;sat 2:5, as stated at the end of Section 9.5.4, we obtain O1dBðAÞ ¼ þ 2:5 dBm, O1dBðBÞ ¼ þ 11:5 dBm. Applying Equation (9.63), we get
2:5 þ 8 11:5 ðA þ BÞ OIP3dBm ¼ 10 log10 10 10 þ 10 10 ¼ þ 8:49 dBm
which is about 3 dB lower than the one obtained from Equation (9.60), as expected. (b) Although Equations (9.63) and (9.65) are more accurate than (9.60), they still involve many approximations. In particular, the influence of the output loading on the compression characteristic is not considered. In real cases, the input impedance of the second stage is different from a perfectly matched resistor, thus the network A operates under conditions which are different from those used to test its nonlinear performance. Moreover, the linear path between the two nonlinear networks in Figure 9.25 is assumed to have no dispersion. Again, this is not true in most of the cases; rather, all the distortion products at the output of A propagate with different attenuation and velocity. Consequently, they are present at the input of B with different phase and amplitude than we assumed to derive Equations (9.63) and (9.65). Finally, it must be stressed that the model used in Figure 9.26, even after removing the latter approximation, does not take the AM–PM conversion into account.
9.6 Semiconductors devices 9.6.1
Basic semiconductor physics
Figure 9.28 shows the structure and the electrical symbol of the four basic semiconductor devices: (a) junction diode, (b) bipolar junction transistor (BJT), (c) field effect transistor (FET) and (d) metal oxide field effect transistor (MOSFET, or more briefly MOS). Semiconductor devices use material with a high degree of purity, including very small and accurately controlled low impurities. The addition of such substances is usually named doping, the added impurities are the dopant, while the pure semiconductor material is referred to as intrinsic or pure. The atom of the 41 Equation (9.60) is derived by assuming a piecewise-linear approximation of the compression curve: there is no gain compression until the output power reaches the saturated value.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
cathode
p
n
anode
c
335
a
(a) e emitter
p
n
n
c
collector b
(b)
base
source
drain
gate
s
P
g
(c)
source
drain
gate
oxide n bulk
d
n
p
n
s
d
g
(d)
Figure 9.28 Semiconductor devices: simplified cross-section (left) and electrical symbol (right): (a) junction diode; (b) BJT; (c) junction FET; (d) MOSFET. intrinsic semiconductor – generally silicon (Si) or germanium42 (Ge) – is tetravalent. Thus, in its pure state, each atom will form four covalent bonds with four neighbouring atoms – all of the same type. The resulting material will assume a crystal structure, with a regular tetrahedron as the elementary cell. The electron couples constituting the covalent bond are strongly tightened, therefore the electrical conductivity of an intrinsic semiconductor is quite low.43 Implantation of the pure semiconductor with low concentrations of pentavalent atoms (phosphorus (P), arsenic (As), antimony (Sb)) perturbs the original regular crystalline structure. Indeed, the fifth electron of the dopant is free from bonds; thus it is available for electrical conduction. The above described operation is n-type doping, the low-concentration dopant (of the order of one atom in 108 of the pure semiconductor) is the n-dopant. The dopant ions, placed within the crystal reticule, are the donor ions. 42 Other more complex materials, like gallium arsenide (GaAs), indium phosphide (InP), aluminium gallium arsenide (AlGaAs), or silicon–germanium (Si–Ge) are in use, particularly for extremely high-frequency devices. However, we will limit our description to the simplest case, since the basic working principle of the different devices does not change with the material used. 43 The resistivity of intrinsic silicon and germanium is about 10 3 O m and 5 10 4 O m. By comparison, the resistivity of copper is 1:7 10 8 O m, four orders of magnitude lower.
336
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Similarly, p-doping is possible and consists of adding trivalent dopant (aluminium (Al), gallium (Ga), indium (In)) to the intrinsic semiconductor. In this case, where the trivalent atom is present, one of the four covalent bonds is not saturated. This is equivalent to having one free hole, i.e. one possibility to receive free electrons, available from the covalent bond breaking caused by the thermal agitation. Equivalently, we can consider the p-doped semiconductor as containing positive free charges – known as holes – available for electrical conduction. The absolute value of the hole charge is the same as that of the electron. Finally the ions of the p-dopant are acceptor ions. The free charges in the semiconductor are often called carriers. The electrons (holes) in the n- (p-)region are the majority carriers, while the holes (electrons) are the minority carriers.
9.6.2
Junction diode
The left side of Figure 9.28a schematizes the structure of a junction diode, which is the simplest semiconductor device. Such a device basically consists of a semiconductor crystal: one portion of it is ndoped, and the remaining part is p-doped. The boundary between the two differently doped portions is the junction. Both the n- and p-zones present one metal contact: the cathode and the anode, respectively. Figure 9.29 (top) shows the charge distribution along the diode, in the absence of an external voltage applied to the electrodes. Such a distribution is the result of two contrasting actions. From one side, the electrons of the n-zone tend to migrate towards the p-zone, in order to recombine with the holes, and vice versa. However, this process cannot proceed indefinitely, due to the opposition of the charge concentration around the junction, caused by the recombination itself. Therefore, the charge density along the diode rðxÞ assumes the type of shape shown in Figure 9.29. The consequent electrical static potential can be obtained by solving Poisson’s equation d 2 VðxÞ rðxÞ ¼ dx2 e
ð9:66Þ
where e is the dielectric constant of the material. donors acceptors electrons holes
n zone
p zone
ρ(x)
V(x)
δx
barrier x 0
Figure 9.29 Charge density distribution and electrostatic potential of a p–n junction diode with no applied external bias.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
337
Equation (9.66) is a linear second-order equation, thus two conditions must be specified for the solution; here it is assumed that limx ! 1 VðxÞ ¼ 0 and limx ! 1 ½dVðxÞ=dx ¼ 0. The plot in Figure 9.29 shows the potential VðxÞ (bottom curve) obtained by applying Equation (9.66) to the charge distribution rðxÞ (top curve). It can be seen that, sufficiently far from the junction, the electrostatic potential tends to zero in the p-zone and to a finite value – named the barrier – in the n-zone. The positive potential in the n-zone prevents any further migration of electrons towards the p-zone and of holes from the n-zone. Equilibrium is achieved when the forces associated with the chemical bond energy become equal to the electrostatic ones. If no external electric field is applied to the diode, the region across the junction presents no carrier: that region is the depleted zone or the depletion zone of the diode. If we apply a positive voltage between the anode and cathode, some holes will move to the n-zone and some electrons will migrate to the p-zone. This is because the applied voltage opposes the electrostatic voltage. The consequence is a positive current flowing from the anode towards the cathode. This type of diode biasing – positive anode to cathode voltage – is commonly referred to as forward bias. If the applied positive voltage exceeds the barrier, the depleted zone will disappear, and the diode behaves approximately like a resistor, in that any further increase of the forward bias will cause a proportional increase of the current. The ratio between the latter two quantities is the series resistance of the diode, which mainly depends on the contact resistance associated with the electrode metallization. Conversely, if we apply a negative voltage between the anode and cathode – or an inverse bias – then no current flows, because the superimposition of the external voltage on the electrostatic potential increases the effect of the latter, widening the depleted zone. Briefly, a forward- (inverse-)biased diode allows (prevents) the current from flowing through the diode itself. As shown, the reverse-biased diode approximates an open circuit. However, the effect of the depleted zone must be considered too. Looking at curve rðxÞ in Figure 9.29, we can see that it presents two local extremes across the junction: a local maximum in the n-zone and a local minimum in the p-zone.44 Let the distance between those local maxima, along the x axis, be dx as indicated in Figure 9.29. Note also that dx monotonically increases with depletion width. Thus, the charge distribution across the junction resembles that of a parallel-plate capacitor, having its positive (negative) electrode placed in the same position as the positive (negative) local maximum of rðxÞ. Therefore, in the reverse bias, the diode is approximately equivalent to a capacitor, whose capacitance – the junction capacitance – is directly proportional to the junction area and inversely proportional to dx. Consequently, the junction capacitance decreases with the amplitude of the reverse bias, because this widens the depleted zone and thus dx as well. The junction capacitance effect is usually relevant in high-frequency networks. According to the considerations presented so far, a reverse-biased junction is a DC open circuit. However, the charge distribution in Figure 9.29 is a first-approximation model, in that minority carriers are present in the neighbourhood of the junction, although in low concentration. The external applied field moves these carriers, generating a leakage current. At increasing reverse voltages, the velocity of the minority carriers increases and so does their kinetic energy. At high reverse-biased voltages, the kinetic energy of some of the carriers becomes sufficient to create new electron–hole pairs in the collision with some atoms of the reticule, further increasing the current, the carrier energy, and so on. In addition, the newly created electron–hole pairs are also able to create other pairs, after colliding with the atoms of the reticule. This process is known as avalanche, and causes an abrupt increase in the diode current; it occurs if the external applied field rises above a critical limit. The reverse voltage VBREAK , corresponding to that limit, is the breakdown of the junction. The application of a reverse voltage higher than VBREAK could destroy the device, if no current limitation is present on the voltage generator. Breakdown is inherent in
44 The two maxima of opposite sign have the same value if the diode is perfectly anti-symmetrical along the junction.
338
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
any semiconductor junction device – like all the devices in this section – and assumes relevant importance in high-power applications. With more complex analysis, we find that a junction with a pure metal and a p- or n-doped semiconductor (Schottky junction) exhibits an external behaviour similar to the p–n junction. In addition, the Schottky junction is widely used in high-frequency devices. The rectifying properties of a metaldoped semiconductor junction suggest that the electrode metallizations of a semiconductor device need suitable treatment, in order to avoid forming a rectifying junction with the semiconductor. An in-depth description of the semiconductor device realization process is well beyond the purpose of this book. Therefore we will limit ourselves to mentioning, without any further description, the difference between ohmic and rectifying metal–semiconductor junctions.
9.6.3
Bipolar transistor
Figure 9.28b (left) shows the simplified cross-section of a BJT. It has two p–n junctions; thus n–p–n and p–n–p transistors are possible. For high-frequency applications, n–p–n BJTs are almost exclusively used, therefore we will examine this case only.45 Looking at the structure in Figure 9.28b, we can see three doped zones, two n and one p between them. Each of the three doped zones presents its own metallization, which is the corresponding electrode: from left to light we have the emitter (e), the base (b) and the collector (c). Furthermore, the base region (p) is much thinner than the remaining two (both n). There are four possible combinations for the bias of base–emitter (b–e) and base–collector (b–c) junctions: 1. Active region, b–e is forward biased and b–c is reverse biased. 2. Saturation, both b–e and b–c are forward biased. 3. Interdiction, both b–e and b–c are reverse biased. 4. Inverse active, b–e is reverse biased and b–c is forward biased. Bipolar transistors used in amplifiers and oscillators operate in the active region, saturation and interdiction are used for switches, while inverse active conditions have few or no applications in RF=mWcircuits. Figure 9.30 shows a BJT biased to operate in the active region. For the diode, because of the forward bias, we have a current Ie flowing in the emitter. A small percentage of this current Ib passes through the base, as in a simple diode. Differently from the case of the diode, however, and because the base region is very thin, the majority of the electrons coming from the emitter migrate directly to the collector, attracted by the positive voltage. This happens because the b–c junction is reverse biased, thus a high electrostatic potential is present in the collector; this lets the electrons pass, but hinders the holes from doing the same, as discussed for the diode. Kirchhoff’s law, applied to the network in Figure 9.30, implies that emitter, base and collector currents are related as Ie ¼ Ic þ Ib Furthermore, we have just seen that the majority of the charges moved by the forward bias of the e–b junction flow through the collector; then I e ¼ a Ic
with
a<1 a 1
45 Figure 9.28b shows the n–p–n symbol; the p–n–p one is obtained by swapping the n- with the p-zones. Similarly, the p–n–p symbol is obtained from the one in Figure 9.28b (right) by inverting the direction of the arrow.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN Ie
e
c
339
Ic +
+ Vbe
b Ib
Vcb
Figure 9.30 BJT biasing in the active region. Combining the two equations above, we obtain Ib ¼ Ie Ic ¼ Ic
1a a ) Ic ¼ Ib ¼ b I b a 1a
The parameter b ¼ a=ð1 aÞ is the forward current gain of the BJT; its value ranges around 100 in highfrequency devices. The considerations above lead to the conclusion that an active biased BJT behaves like a currentcontrolled current generator (CCCS),46 in which the emitter, base and collector are the common, input and output electrode, respectively. We obtain such a schematization by considering that a small variation of Ib around its resting point causes a proportional variation of Ic , through the constant b. Let the variations of Ib and Ic be the input and output signals of the CCCS, respectively. Moreover, looking at the currents in Figure 9.30, we recognize that the BJT small-signal equivalent CCCS is inverting. Finally, we have to point out that the b–e junction conducts, being forward biased; thus our CCCS has a low associated input resistance. This discussion, based on direct currents, does not exhaust the BJT working principle, from our limited point of view. The high-frequency operation of the BJT also depends on several parasitic elements, like the ones inherent with the finite size of the devices, the finite mobility47 of the carriers, the b–e junction capacitance (b–e is reverse biased), the interelectrode capacitances and the terminal inductances.
9.6.4
Junction field effect transistor
Figure 9.28c shows the FET, which is the third device to consider. The structure in Figure 9.28c (left) consists of a single junction between the gate (g) electrode and the source (s) and drain (d) electrodes. The semiconductor region between the source and drain electrodes is normally referred to as the channel.48 This latter, being doped, is conductive, due to the free charges generated by the doping. However, by reverse biasing the g–s junction, we find that the channel is progressively emptied of its carriers, as Figure 9.31 shows. The channel depletion monotonically increases with the negative g–s voltage amplitude: increasing it above a critical value Vp – named the pinch-off – means no free charge is present inside the channel, and consequently the source becomes isolated from the drain. Therefore, modulation of the reverse bias g–s voltage causes a corresponding modulation of the channel resistance. 46 The term current-controlled current generator is equivalent to current-controlled current source, which is more consistent with the acronym CCCS. However, in this context, the word ‘source’ also denotes the name of one electrode of some semiconductor devices (FETand MOSFET), as we will see shortly. Therefore, we used the word ‘generator’ in order to avoid any confusion. 47 The mobility of a free charge m is defined as the ratio between its speed vd and the accelerating field E applied to it: m ¼ vd =E. The electrons present a higher mobility than the holes, which is why n–p–n BJTs are preferred to p–n–p ones, for their better high-frequency performances. Typical electron mobility for Si at room temperature (300 K) is melectron 1 m2 =V=s, while for the holes we have about half of that value, mhole 0:5 m2 =V=s. 48 Figure 9.28c shows one n-channel device, in that the channel is n-doped; a p-channel FET is also possible, but has very few uses in high-frequency circuits, due to the lower mobility of the holes. See also footnote 45. The electrical symbol for the p-channel is the same as the one in Figure 9.28c (right), but with the arrow in the opposite direction.
340
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Vgs
+ s
g p
Vgs ≤ Vp
d n Vp < Vgs < 0
depleted region limits
Figure 9.31
Cross-section of an FET, with different gate bias conditions.
Thus, in the small-signal regime, i.e. with small variations of the voltage between the junction and its resting points, the FET is equivalent to an inverting voltage-controlled current generator (VCVS).49 The common terminal is the source, the input and output ones are the gate and drain, respectively. Differently from the BJT, the low-frequency input impedance of an FETis high, since the g–s junction is reverse biased. As seen for the BJT, the high-frequency behaviour of the FET also depends on some parasitic elements, principally the capacitance of the reverse-biased g–s junction. The above device is the depletion FET. An alternative device to consider is the enhancement FET, in which the channel has a low doping level. In the enhancement FET, increasing the g–s junction forward bias progressively increases the channel conduction. Most high-frequency FETs, however, are of depletion n-channel type; therefore we will consider this case only. The described device is based on a p–n junction, and therefore is sometimes also referred to as a junction field effect transistor(JFET). Other types of FETs are possible, like the MOSFET, considered in the subsequent section, or the MESFET, considered in Chapter 14. The metal epitaxial field effect transistor (MESFET) is a variant of the JFET, with a Schottky junction replacing the p–n junction between the gate and source. Such a device is particularly important for microwave applications.
9.6.5
Metal oxide field effect transistor
The industrial production of MOSFETs began around 1960, since when the device has assumed an increasing importance. The importance of the MOSFET, in high-frequency applications, comes from the integratedcircuit technique, in particular because of the necessity to integrate analogue and digital circuitry on the same chip. Developments in high-density digital integrated circuits are pushing analogue highfrequency engineers to use the same process for their designs. In particular, modern digital circuits use complementary metal oxide semiconductor(CMOS) devices in their very large-scale integration(VLSI) circuits. CMOS technology allows the realization of complementary n-channel and p-channel transistors, i.e. transistors having the same structure but opposite types of doping. CMOS digital circuits have a dominant importance, because they require virtually no current from the supply, except when changing state. This fundamental property, combined with the market demand for smaller products and with an increasing number of functions, leads to the increasing use of mixed analogue/digital integrated circuits. Consequently, the MOSFET is assuming a growing importance for the analogue high-frequency engineer. Figure 9.28d (left) shows the cross-section of one n-channel enhancement-type MOSFET, which is the most used type in high-frequency applications. Similar to what we did with the BJTand JFET, we will limit our consideration to the n-channel MOSFET or, in short, the nMOSFET. Again, the p-channel MOSFET (or pMOSFET) has the same structure as the n-channel one, but with n- and p-doped zones 49 Again, the term generator is used instead of source, in order to avoid any confusion with the electrode name. See also footnote 46.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
341
swapped: all the considerations for the nMOSFET apply to the pMOSFET, just by inverting the signs of the voltages and currents. The structure in Figure 9.28d has four electrodes: source, gate and drain, like the JFET, plus the bulk (b). This fourth electrode is placed below the semiconductor material of the device, or the substrate: the bulk (b), which is normally connected to the lowest potential of the network (the ground in most cases). The n-type zones below the source and drain present a high doping level. As in the JFET, the region below the gate is the channel. The thin oxide layer below the gate is an almost ideal dielectric, thus no direct current can pass through the gate, except for a small leakage current of the order of 10 18–10 16 A. Compared with the JFET, the DC gate current of the MOSFET is smaller by orders of magnitude. Similar to what we have seen with the JFET, the control electrode of the MOSFET is the gate, which controls the source to drain conduction by injecting or removing charges. Looking at the structure in Figure 9.28d, we can see that the gate consists of a planar metallization, placed above a dielectric layer. Furthermore, the semiconductor has a significantly lower resistivity than the oxide; consequently, the gate and source terminal pair behave approximately like a capacitor. Figure 9.32 shows the bias schematic for a MOSFET. If a small positive voltage Vgs is applied between the gate and source (Figure 9.32a), some holes in the p-zone are pushed towards the bulk. Under this condition, there is no d–s current. By increasing Vgs up to a given threshold VT (Figure 9.32b), there will be enough electrons to be attracted to the region under the oxide: we have an inversion of the carrier type in the channel region immediately underneath the oxide. Thus, despite its original p-type, this part of the channel behaves as if it was n-type. Consequently, from source to drain, we have a continuous region populated by negative carriers, which makes the d–s current Ids flow. Further increasing Vgs above VT, the number of electrons below the oxide, and the d–s conduction, will both increase as well. The device described above is an enhancement type. A depletion type is also possible, just by placing a highly doped region below the oxide, which allows the d–s conduction without any positive Vgs . In this Vds +
g
+
s
Vgs > VT
d
oxide ++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++
n
n p
b (a)
Vds
Id
+ +
s Vgs > V T
g
d
oxide ----------------
n
b
++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++
n
p
(b)
Figure 9.32 MOSFET bias schematic: (a) gate voltage below the threshold (no drain current); (b) gate voltage above the threshold (free electrons below the oxide).
342
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
case, the control voltage Vgs must be negative, in that it has to remove the carriers from the channel and modulate the d–s conduction. In the small-signal regime, the MOSFET works as an inverting VCVS: the common terminal is the source, the input and output ones are the gate and drain, respectively. The low-frequency MOSFET input impedance is higher than that of the JFET. For the high-frequency operation of the MOSFET, the g–s capacitance is particularly important.
9.7 Electrical models of high-frequency semiconductor devices This section deals with the representations of the parameters of semiconductor devices, which are needed for RF and microwave (RF/mW) component analysis and design. For simplicity our discussion is limited to one- and two-port devices, although most of the concepts can be used to model devices with an arbitrary number of ports. Also, most of the proposed representations are not restricted to semiconductor devices, instead most of them can be used for many types of n-port networks. Modern designs are computer based, thus most of the discussed techniques are computer oriented, although some simplified models can be used for initial first-approximation analytic considerations.
9.7.1
Linear models
Most of the characterization of semiconductor devices has an experimental base, although some models can be directly derived from the physics of the devices.50 The simplest case that we can consider is the one for a linear device. Any semiconductor device is inherently nonlinear, but if the amplitudes of the involved RF/mW signals are sufficiently small, it can approximately be considered as linear. The small-signal analysis of a device operating on a given bias working point is equivalent to linearizing the various nonlinear characteristics of the device around that working point. In other words, a device is considered as linear if all its nonlinear characteristics are replaced by linear functions. Figure 9.33 shows a typical setup for the measurement of a linear operating transistor. The transistor is the block indicated by device under test(DUT). Terminal 1 (2) of the DUT could be the base or gate (collector or drain), while the common terminal – emitter or source – is connected to ground. Transistors need a proper DC bias in order to operate as active devices, so the test setup includes two generators with the respective T-bias networks. Each T-bias consists of one series capacitor (C1 ; C2 ) and one shunt inductor (L1 ; L2 ). The capacitors C1 ; C2 have capacitances that are large enough to present a negligible reactance in the RF band of interest. Thus, C1 ; C2 pass the RF signal between the network analyzer(NWA)51 and the DUT, while preventing the direct current from reaching the RF ports of the NWA. Conversely, the inductors pass direct current and present high RF impedances. An ideal T-bias allows the DC generator to bias the DUT without influencing the transmission of the RF signal through the RF path. Practical T-bias networks are not ideal, but their effect on the measurement can be virtually eliminated by means of proper calibration techniques.52 Finally, the two DC generators supply the bias needed by the DUT. In the case of the n–p–n junction, n-channel depletion JFETor n-channel enhancement MOSFET, we have respectively that ‘input terminal bias’ is a positive current generator, a negative voltage generator or a positive voltage generator.
50 The use of physics-based semiconductor models is unusual, due to the complexity of the calculations involved, the lack of accuracy generally inherent with them, and sometimes because some physical and/or chemical parameters of the device are only known approximately. 51 A description of NWA operation can be found in Section 17.6. 52 See Sections 17.6.1 and 17.6.2.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
RF port 1
343
RF port 2 Network Analyzer
Tee-bias 1
Tee-bias 2 1 DUT 2
C1
C L2 2
L1
Input terminal bias
Output terminal bias RF path DC path
Figure 9.33
Setup for a two-port linear semiconductor device.
The setup of Figure 9.33 can be reduced to the case of a one-port device – like the diode – just by ignoring one of the two device ports, T-bias, DC generators and NWA RF ports. Similarly the test setup can be extended to a multi-port DUT. Also, if some of the DUT ports need no bias, the relative generator and T-bias can be eliminated, and the unbiased port will be directly connected to the NWA. Once the NWA is calibrated, it is able to measure the biased DUT over a discrete frequency range; the measured data at each frequency can be sent to a computer and stored in a file. There are many possible ways to arrange the measured data in a file, but one of them is particularly important because of its wide use as a file exchange format, particularly for computer-aided engineering(CAE) programs. This format is known as the Touchstone format,53 which consists of a text (ASCII) file containing one header line, some possible comment lines and one data line per test frequency point. The data line has nine (three) columns for a two-port (one-port) network. Moreover, each data line contains vector information on the measured parameters. Any text line beginning with an exclamation mark (!) is a comment, and therefore is ignored by the CAE program. The header specifies the data format and has the following general form: # FREQ_UNIT S FORMAT R IMPEDANCE where: .
FREQ_UNIT is the frequency unit (Hz, kHz, MHz, GHz).
.
FORMAT specifies the scattering parameter format (RI, MA, dB).
.
IMPEDANCE indicates the normalizing impedance of the parameters.
53
The Touchstone file was originally a proprietary file format for the eponymous frequency domain linear circuit simulator from EEsof, launched in 1984. Touchstone is a registered trademark of Agilent Technologies, Inc.
344
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Therefore, the Touchstone file can be used to store scattering parameters, and also impedance and admittance parameters, although the first type of data is more frequently used, particularly because S parameters are the ones directly measured by the NWA. To simplify the description of the data line, we will describe the case of a two-port network, and of scattering parameters, giving some generalizations later. Each data line includes nine numbers: the first is the frequency and the following four couples represent one of the network complex parameters s11, s21, s12, s22, respectively, and in this order. Each couple of numbers is the complex value of the respective parameter, in the format specified by FORMAT, i.e. Reðshk Þ jshk j
Imðshk Þ ðh; k ¼ 1; 2Þ
180 argðshk Þ ðh; k ¼ 1; 2Þ p
20 log10 ðjshk jÞ
180 argðshk Þ ðh; k ¼ 1; 2Þ p
ðFORMAT ¼ RIÞ ðFORMAT ¼ MAÞ ðFORMAT ¼ MAÞ
In the latter two cases, the second number is the angle of the complex number, expressed in degrees. If the data represent impedance or admittance parameters, the same structure applies, but with shk replaced by zhk or yhk. In the case of a one-port, the data lines contain three numbers, for instance Reðs11 Þ Imðs11 Þ. The complex representation of the network parameters is needed for those calculations involving the measured device; this implies the use of a vector NWA. If scalar data are available, say js11 j js21 j js12 jjs22 j, they can still be used by replacing the missed phase with dummy numbers, for instance all zeros.54 Such a Touchstone file is still usable by the CAE program, but the resulting computations are quite inaccurate. Sometimes, the S parameter files include the noise parameters55 of the DUT, which have the same complex form as the network parameters in the same file. Table 9.2 shows the Touchstone file of a microwave transistor, also including the noise parameters. A more sophisticated modelling approach than the S parameter table is the derivation of a linear network. The linear model response provides an accurate replica of the originating file. Such linear networks are known as equivalent linear circuits or linear models of the device. The component values of the linear model are computed by exploiting computer optimization programs, and by imposing the S parameters of the network to be as close as possible to the measured data, stored in a Touchstone file. Such a procedure is known as curve fitting. Some techniques are available for facilitating the optimization, usually by supplying approximate initial values of the parameters; they are referred to as parameter extraction techniques.56 The device linear model generally includes many passive linear elements and one controlled generator which is absent in the case of the diode. The type of controlled generator reflects the 54 The addition of the dummy numbers is necessary to keep the number of numbers per line, in order to retain compatibility with the standard. 55 The noise parameters of a two-port network were defined in Section 9.4; Section 17.6.3 describes their measurement techniques. 56 A simple example of the parameter extraction technique is the computation of the resistance in the model in Figure 9.34a from low-frequency scattering parameters. Let us assume that the diode has been measured with the setup in Figure 9.33, and one of the two electrodes (say the cathode) is grounded. The resulting DUT is then a one-port network. From the measured s11 (reflection coefficient) we can compute the corresponding impedance z11 ¼ R0 ð1 þ s11 Þ=ð1 s11 Þ, and from the lowest frequency value of it impose that Rd þ Rs ¼ z11 ðf ¼ fmin Þ, where fmin is the lowest possible measurement frequency. The resistance obtained is the sum of the contact and junction resistances. The first is smaller than or comparable with the latter if the diode is forward or reverse biased. The value Rd þ Rs resulting from the reverse bias is not very meaningful. It could be some tens to millions of the forward bias value, and is totally masked from the other impedances of the model.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
345
Table 9.2 Scattering parameters of a microwave FET (GaAs MESFET). ! Transistor measured on 5 May 1997 ! Grounded Source, bias: Vds¼3V, Ids¼10mA # GHz S MA R 50 !FREQ S11-------------- S21------------- S12------------ S22-------2 0.98 –29 3.23 157 0.06 72 0.65 –16 3 0.94 –43 3.13 145 0.08 65 0.64 –24 4 0.92 –57 3.00 135 0.10 56 0.60 –32 5 0.90 –70 2.84 125 0.12 49 0.59 –38 6 0.89 –80 2.67 117 0.14 43 0.58 –44 7 0.87 –91 2.53 108 0.15 36 0.57 –50 8 0.84 –100 2.38 99 0.15 30 0.54 –55 9 0.83 –107 2.23 92 0.16 26 0.54 –58 10 0.82 –116 2.12 86 0.17 23 0.53 –64 !FREQ dB(Fmin) Gamma_opt 2 0.55 0.85 21 4 0.60 0.75 40 6 0.8 0.69 55 8 1.0 0.62 70 10 1.3 0.56 85
Rn/50 (noise parameters) 0.5 0.4 0.4 0.3 0.3
low-frequency behaviour of the device type, for instance we have VCCS for FET, or CCCS for BJT; alternatively a VCCS with a low input resistance can be used for the BJT. Some passive lumped or distributed elements surround the controlled generator and model the high-frequency behaviour of the device. Although most of these elements have a physical explanation, their value is generally obtained by curve fitting. Additional passive elements – usually reactive – can be added to the model, in order to take the package into account. Figure 9.34a,b show one possible linear model for the diode (a) and the FET (b), respectively. Note that the anode–cathode DC resistance in the model of Figure 9.34a equals Rd þ Rs and represents the incremental ratio between the voltage and current variations in the diode. The capacitor Cd mainly represents the junction capacitance, the elements Cp and Ls model the finite length of the device, but can be also used to model the effect of some low-parasitic packages. Figure 9.34b shows the linear model of a chip MESFET, but it could be applied to any FET in a chip. The network consists of a VCCS – whose gain or transconductance is gm – surrounded by some elements, each modelling different parasitic effects: .
Cgs , the gate–source junction plus the interelectrode, the first contribution usually dominating, since the junction is moderately reverse biased for normal FET operation.
.
Cgd , mainly the gate–drain interelectrode capacitance, since the relative junction is strongly reverse biased, in that the drain voltage is positive with respect to the source, which is positive with respect to the gate.
.
Cds , the drain–source interelectrode capacitance.
.
Lg ; Ls ; Ld , the finite device size, in combination with Cgs ; Cds ; Cgd .
.
t, the propagation time of the signal from the gate to the source.
346
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Cp Cd Cathode Rs
Rd
Ls
Anode
(a) Lg (130 pH) Rg (0.1Ω)
Cgd (54 fF)
Gate
Ld (160 pH) R d (0.1 Ω) Drain
+ vi -
Cgs (243 fF)
gm •vi (t -τ) (g m =40 mS) Rds (277Ω) (τ =0)
Cds (92 fF)
Ri (3.8 Ω)
Rs (0.1 Ω) L s (36 pH) (b)
Source
Figure 9.34
Linear models for semiconductor devices: (a) diode; (b) FET.
.
Rg ; Rs ; Rd , the contact resistance of the respective electrode.
.
RI , the resistance presented by the channel, which is partially pinched.
Figure 9.34b also shows the numerical value of the model components (numbers in brackets), as obtained by curve fitting with the scattering parameters in Table 9.2. Figure 9.35 shows the scattering parameters of Table 9.2 (solid curves) together with the ones obtained from the network in Figure 9.34b (dashed curves). Figure 9.35 uses a special mixed type of vector representation: the lower half – used for the reflection coefficients – is a standard Smith chart, the upper half – for the forward transmission coefficient – is a polar chart of radius r ¼ 4. The reverse transmission coefficient has a small radius, and is barely distinguishable from the centre of the plot. Such a compact representation is possible when the reflection and transmission coefficients lie on opposite halves of the complex plane. The linear model cannot be more accurate than the S parameters it is computed from. However, some considerations can justify the work needed for computation of the model parameters: 1. The linear model is a compact representation of the scattering parameters. As a comparison, Table 9.2 (excluding the noise parameters) comprises 9 9 ¼ 81 real numbers,57 while the corresponding linear model in Figure 9.34b is defined by its 13 component values. 2. The linear model can easily be used for statistical analysis, just by adding statistical variability to its parameters. 3. Extraction of the linear model is the first step towards computation of the nonlinear model.
57
Nine frequency points, each with nine real numbers, as the FET is a two-port.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
347
Figure 9.35 Scattering parameters of a microwave chip GaAs MESFET. Sold lines, measured as in Table 9.2; dashed lines, modelled as in Figure 9.32b. The model in Figure 9.34b can also be used for bipolar transistors, with minor modifications, by connecting one resistor Rbe in parallel with Cgs and short-circuiting RI . The active component of the model becomes a VCCS having finite input resistance Rbe and transconductance gm ; this is equivalent to a CCVS with the same input resistance and current gain b ¼ gm Rbe . If a packaged device must be characterized, rather than a chip one, the models in Figure 9.34 are not sufficiently accurate, due to the parasitics introduced by the package itself. Basically, a package includes a number of terminals – at least one per electrode of the device – to be soldered on the printed circuit board, one or more bonding wires connecting each electrode to the respective terminal(s). Furthermore, the terminals come out from a dielectric package surrounding and protecting the chip with its bond wires.58 Bond wires and terminals introduce additional series inductance to each device electrode, while the mutual couplings between the different wires and terminals generate additional interelectrode coupling capacitance. All these effects can be included in the model, by embedding the models in Figure 9.34 into a more complex network including additional elements to model the package. Figure 9.36 shows such an arrangement for a packaged BJT; other similar combinations can be used for different types of devices.
58
Some more details on packages can be found in Chapter 14.
348
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING chip network C bc (125 fF)
R b(6.38 Ω) b′
Rc (13.6Ω) c′
+ vi C be (854 fF)
-
gm •v i (t - τ) R be (1618 Ω) (g m =63.3 mS) (τ =1.33 ps)
R ce (43.6 k Ω)
Cce (100 fF)
R e(1.85 Ω)
(a)
e’
C bc1(54 fF)
L b1 (0.96 nH)
L b2 (0.59 nH)
base
chip network b′
C be (495 fF)
e′
Lc1 (0.39 nH)
c′
L e2 (0.26 nH)
Lc2 (0.26 nH) collector
C ce (243 fF)
L e1 (0.65 nH)
(b)
emitter
Figure 9.36
BJT linear models: (a) in-chip; (b) packaged.
The numbers in brackets in Figure 9.36 represent the values obtained by curve fitting with the S parameters of the bipolar transistor MBC13900, manufactured by Freescale Semiconductor. Table 9.3 lists the scattering parameters of the transistor, biased for a collector–emitter voltage of 2 Vand a collector current of 1 mA, as supplied by the manufacturer.59 The curve fitting of the model60 with the data in Table 9.3 gives the response shown in Figure 9.37 (grey lines), while the data are the black lines in the same figure.
9.7.2
Nonlinear semiconductor models
Linear analysis and models do not provide any information about the effect of the excitation amplitude on the network or system response. In other words, the linear network response is, by definition, independent of the power of the applied signal, while networks including semiconductor devices produce nonlinear distortion, as is known. Linear models do not present such distortions, therefore nonlinear models and analysis are required when nonlinear performances – such as harmonic or intermodulation products, compression, output power, etc. – have to be predicted. Diode and/or transistor nonlinear models will be part of the circuit description within a nonlinear simulator. Such a description will include the nonlinear device itself, its matching networks, bias 59 Data taken from the component data sheet, Document Number MBC13900/D Rev. 1.1, 06/2005, Table 7, p.13. Copyright of Freescale Semiconductor, Inc. 2008. Used with permission. 60 See the Ansoft file 04_BJT_Linear_Model.adsn.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
349
Table 9.3 Scattering parameters of the bipolar transistor MBC13900. ! MBC13900, Common Emitter, 2V 1mA # GHz S MA R 50 ! S11----------- S21------------ S12--------------S22---------0.1 0.973 –6 3.754 175 0.008 86 0.997 –3 0.5 0.961 –33 3.366 153 0.038 71 0.968 –12 0.9 0.895 –57 3.341 135 0.065 56 0.910 –22 1.0 0.868 –63 3.256 131 0.070 53 0.915 –24 1.5 0.766 –91 2.688 111 0.091 38 0.851 –33 1.9 0.721 –114 2.610 94 0.100 26 0.788 –39 2.0 0.706 –119 2.501 91 0.102 23 0.780 –41 2.4 0.649 –140 2.280 77 0.104 15 0.731 –47 3.0 0.628 –166 1.984 58 0.105 2 0.667 –56 3.5 0.606 173 1.717 45 0.099 –3 0.650 –62 4.0 0.606 155 1.478 33 0.094 –10 0.640 –68 4.5 0.611 138 1.421 21 0.089 –12 0.604 –74 5.0 0.610 122 1.309 9 0.085 –11 0.581 –81
Figure 9.37 Scattering parameters of the BJT MBC13900. Black lines, data measured by the manufacturer (as per Table 9.3); grey lines, response of the model in Figure 9.35. networks together with the respective DC generators, stimulus generators with given frequencies and powers, and load. This setup makes prediction of the power effects possible. The accuracy of the results depends on which one of the models is used. However, the nonlinear analysis is more critical than the linear one: small inaccuracies in the models can lead to gross mistakes in the final result.
9.7.2.1 Diode nonlinear models The simplest device for nonlinear modelling is the diode. Figure 9.38 shows the schematic of a diode nonlinear model. This model is derived from the linear one in Figure 9.34a by replacing the linear resistor Rd with the nonlinear element D, and the linear capacitor Cd with a combination of the linear ðCd;lin Þ and the nonlinear ðCJ Þ capacitor.
350
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
C d,lin
Cp
CJ D Cathode Idi
Anode Rs
Ls
- V di + - Vd +
Figure 9.38
Diode nonlinear model.
The instantaneous current through the device D is related to the voltage across its terminals as
Vdi Idi ðVdi Þ ¼ IS exp 1 ð9:67Þ n VT where: .
IS is the saturation current of the diode, or the reverse current for high-amplitude negative Vdi .
.
VT ¼ K T q 1 , where q ¼ 1:6022 10 19 C is the electron charge, K ¼ 1:374 10 23 J=K is the Boltzmann constant61 and T is the absolute temperature.
.
n is an ideality factor which usually ranges from 1 to 2.
Equation (9.67) is also known as Shockley’s equation; it can be derived from physical considerations of the semiconductor diode, particularly in the case of n ¼ 1. For the needs of high-frequency circuit analysis, however, this equation is just a mathematical instrument to model the current–voltage relation of the diode. The parameters Is ; n are computed by curve fitting with experimental data. In this respect, it is useful to measure the direct current of the diode at different bias voltages. Under this condition, the external voltage Vd is externally accessible, rather than the internal one Vdi . The two quantities are related as Vd ¼ Vdi þ Rs Idi
ð9:68Þ
Equation (9.68) is valid only for purely DC voltages and currents, in that it neglects the currents flowing through the parasitic capacitances. Conversely, Equation (9.67) refers to the current through D; in this regard, it is more general and applies to instant excitations. Substituting Equation (9.68) into (9.67) we obtain the DC relation of the nonlinear diode model
Idi Vd ðIdi Þ ¼ n VT ln þ 1 þ Rs Idi ð9:69Þ IS The function (9.69) has three arbitrary parameters ð n; IS ; Rs Þ, which could be determined from a minimum number of three different values of the diode current, measured at three different bias voltages. In general, more than three measured couples of ðVd ; Idi Þ are used for the curve fitting, in order to achieve a better accuracy. Moreover, Rs could also be available from the linear model obtained from
61
See also Section 9.4.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
351
Id , mA 4 measured Eq.(9.69) Eq.(9.71)
2
0 -5
0
1
Vd , Volt
-2
-4
Figure 9.39
Diode direct current vs. voltage.
high-frequency linear measurements. In general the two values are not coincident. The choice between the value obtained from high-frequency linear and DC measurements needs some trade-off; sometimes an intermediate value is assumed. Figure 9.39 plots the function (9.68) with the parameters obtained by curve fitting62 (grey line) together with some measured data (black dots).63 An alternative way to determine the parameters of Equation (9.69) consists of deriving them from the parameters Rd and Rs of the linear model in Figure 9.34a. This method needs the extraction of some parameter sets for the linear model at different direct currents, and also Rs must hold constant for the different cases. This way, the series resistance Rs of the nonlinear model is coincident with the Rs of the different linear models. Now, if we differentiate the function (9.67) with respect to the voltage, we obtain the differential conductance of the nonlinear device D, which equals the reciprocal of Rs , by definition. Thus
1 qIdi IS Vdi ¼ ¼ exp ð9:70Þ Rd qVdi n VT n VT If two values of the linear resistance Rd;1 ; Rd;2 have been extracted at two different direct currents Idi;1 ; Idi;2 , it is possible to determine the corresponding voltages64 Vdi;1 ; Vdi;2 , by inverting Equation (9.67)
Idi;1 Idi;2 þ 1 ; Vdi;2 ¼ n VT ln þ1 Vdi;1 ¼ n VT ln IS IS Substituting these couples of values into (9.70), we obtain 8
3 2 Idi;1 > >
> n V ln þ 1 T > 6 7 > 1 IS IS > 7 ¼ IS exp ln Idi;1 þ 1 ¼ IS Idi;1 þ IS ¼ Idi;1 þ IS > ¼ exp6 < 4 5 n VT n VT Rd;1 n VT IS n VT IS n VT > > > > > > 1 ¼ Idi;2 þ IS > : Rd;2 n VT Is ¼ 0:1995 10 12 ; n ¼ 1:9271; Rs ¼ 2:864 O. See the SIMetrix file 10_Diode_I_V_Curve.sxsch. 64 Again, voltage Vdi across the nonlinear device D is not accessible from outside the diode. 62 63
352
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Dividing the first of the above equations by the second one term by term, we obtain the saturation current
Rd;2 Idi;1 þ IS Rd;2 Rd;2 Rd;2 Rd;2 1 ¼ ) Idi;1 þ IS ¼ Idi;2 þ IS ) IS ¼ Idi;2 Idi;1 1 Rd;1 Idi;2 þ IS Rd;1 Rd;1 Rd;1 Rd;1 Once IS is known, n is easily obtained as 1 Idi;1 þ IS Idi;1 þ IS ¼ )n¼ Rd;1 n VT VT Rd;1 If more than two sets of data are available, a more reliable parameter extraction is possible, using optimization procedures that minimize the error. So far, we have described how to derive the nonlinear model from many linear models obtained at different bias points. The opposite is also possible, by linearizing the nonlinear elements around their working points, and this holds true for any semiconductor device, not just for diodes only. Equation (9.67), combined with (9.68), describes quite accurately the direct current in the forward bias. For negative bias, Equation (9.67) predicts that the negative current increases monotonically with the inverse voltage, and reaches the asymptotic limit IS . This is not the case for a real diode, due to the breakdown, as described in Section 9.6.2. Therefore, for reverse bias, the current through D follows a different equation
Vdi þ VBREAK VBREAK 1þ ð9:71Þ Idi ðVdi < 0Þ ¼ IS exp VT VT where VBREAK is the breakdown voltage of the diode. If the reverse voltage across the internal diode D equals the breakdown value ðVdi ¼ VBREAK Þ, the negative current reaches the value Idi ðVdi ¼ VBREAK Þ ¼ IS VBREAK VT 1 . In general VBREAK is not directly measurable, in that the application of voltages close to VBREAK can easily cause excessive current with permanent damage to the device. Rather, increasing reverse voltages are applied to the diode until the inverse current reaches a value that is measurable, but not destructive to the device, for instance 1 mA. Let Vd;B and Idi;B be the applied voltage and the diode current under that condition. The negative voltage across the internal diode will be Vdi;B ¼ Vd;B Rs Idi;B . From Equation (9.71), we get
Idi;B VBREAK VBREAK ¼ VT ln 1 ð9:72Þ Vdi;B IS VT Once IS has been found, the only remaining unknown in the transcendental equation (9.72) is VBREAK , which can be found by applying numerical methods.65 For instance, let us consider the diode used for the grey curve in Figure 9.39, and assume that we measured Vdi;B ¼ 5 V; Idi;B ¼ 1 mA . Then the numerical solution of Equation (9.71) gives VBREAK ffi 4:422 V. Figure 9.39 (black dashed curve) plots the inverse current of this diode.66 As seen in Section 9.6.2, a reverse-biased diode exhibits a voltage-dependent capacitance, provided that the reverse voltage amplitude is well below the breakdown. In that condition, the current (both DC and AC) through the internal diode D of the model in Figure 9.38 is very low, and the effect of the junction capacitance becomes dominant. The model in Figure 9.38 includes three capacitors: Cp for the package and the coupling between the two leads, Cd;lin for the interelectrode capacitance, and Cj to take the junction capacitance into account. The first two are linear elements, thus their capacitance is independent of the voltage; the last is nonlinear in that it presents a voltage-dependent capacitance. The junction 65
See Mathcad file 08_Diode_Breakdown.MCD. In the SIMetrix file 10_Diode_I_V_Curve.sxsch, the value for the breakdown parameter is slightly different (BV ¼ 4.195), because the SPICE implemented in that program is more complex than we described, in order to take some additional effects into account. 66
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
353
capacitance decreases as the voltage applied to the diode becomes more negative, as seen in Section 9.6.2. A well-known and accurate formula for the junction capacitance is Cj ðVdi Þ ¼
Cj0 1
Vdi Vf
g
ð9:73Þ
where: .
Cj0 ¼ Cj ðVdi ¼ 0Þ is the zero-bias junction capacitance.
.
Vf is the built-in potential of the junction.
.
g is the capacitance slope parameter.
From Equation (9.72) it follows that the junction capacitance tends to zero at high reverse voltages. Usually, Cj reduces to negligible values at voltage amplitudes much smaller than the breakdown. Nevertheless, the total capacitance in parallel with the internal diode is always non-zero, due to the interelectrode capacitance Cd;lin . Thus the total capacitance in parallel with the internal diode is Cj ðVdi Þ ¼
Cj0 1
Vdi Vf
g þ Cj;lin
ð9:74Þ
The total capacitance given in (9.73) is the nonlinear counterpart of the capacitance Cd present in the model of Figure 9.34a. The four parameters Cj0 ; Vj ; g; Cj;lin can be computed if four values of Cd have been extracted at four different reverse bias points. Let Vtest;k be the DC voltages and Cj ðVtest;k Þ the corresponding capacitance of the linear model, with k ¼ 1; 2;3; 4. By substituting the four couples of measured values into Equation (9.74), we obtain a nonlinear system of four equations with the four unknowns Cj0 ; Vj ; g; Cj;lin :
Cj0 g þ Cj;lin Cj Vtest;k ¼ ðk ¼ 1 . . . 4Þ V 1 Vtest;k j which can be solved with numerical methods. If more than four points are available, a curve-fitting procedure can be implemented, resulting in a more accurate result. An efficient way to compute the junction capacitance parameters can be found in [4], which also describes a method for the direct high-frequency measurement of Cj .
9.7.2.2 FET nonlinear nodels It is possible to obtain the transistor nonlinear models by applying the same basic concepts described for the diode. Basically, the starting point is the linear equivalent circuit. Nonlinear elements replace the linear ones in modelling the effects that are more related to semiconductor devices, while keeping unchanged the secondary parasitic elements, like interelectrode capacitance, bond wire inductances, contact resistances. Figure 9.40a shows the nonlinear model of a high-frequency FET; the typical application of such a model isin chipdepletion devices.The model of a packaged device requires additional linear elements, asin the linear case shown in Figure 9.34b. The network is analogous to its linear counterpart in Figure 9.34b: .
The linear elements Lg ; Rg ; Ls ; Rs ; Ld ; Rd ; RI ; Cds are unchanged,
.
The nonlinear VCCS Ids ðvI ; vds Þ replaces the linear one gm vI and the drain–source resistance Rds .
.
The gate–source and gate–drain capacitances Cgs ; Cds are nonlinear, representing junction capacitances; for this same reason, two diodes Dgs ; Dds are in parallel with the corresponding junction capacitances.
354
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Dgd L g Rg
Gate
Ld Rd
Cgd(vds -v i ) + vi Dgs
Drain
+
Cgs (vi ) -
vds Ids(v,v i ds )
- Cds
+
+
Vgs -
Ri
Vds -
Rs Ls Source
(a)
Rd Gate
+ + Vgs -
(b)
+ vds
vi Ids(v,v i ds)
Rs
-
Drain + Vds -
Source
Figure 9.40 Nonlinear equivalent circuit of a FET: (a) complete model; (b) simplified DC model.
The nonlinear capacitances Cgs ; Cds and the associate diodes follow the same equations (9.73) and (9.67), respectively, as for the diode. As can be seen, the capacitance at high levels of reverse bias tends to zero; the residual value due to the interelectrode capacitance can be modelled by two linear capacitors in parallel with the nonlinear ones, although Figure 9.40a does not show them. In the normal operation of a depletion FET, both the gate–source and gate–drain junctions are reverse biased, thus the effect of the interdicted diodes Dgs ; Dds is negligible, unless one of the two junction voltages approaches breakdown. The procedure to compute the parameters of the nonlinear model in Figure 9.40 consists of four main steps: 1. The transistor is measured – usually in the common source condition (source to ground) – at different bias combinations ðVds ; Vgs Þ. The extraction of the linear model for each bias condition is helpful but not essential. 2. The DC curves Ids ðVds ; Vgs Þ of the FET are measured. 3. The nonlinear model parameters are computed by minimizing the deviation between the S parameters measured in step 1 and the ones obtained by linearizing the nonlinear model under the same bias conditions. This step requires the application of numerical methods and sometimes of optimization programs. The linear elements Lg ; Rg ; Ls ; Rs ; Ld ; Rd ; RI ; Cds obtained from the linear models computed at the different bias conditions – if available – constitute a good starting point for the nonlinear model.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
355
4. More than the minimum deviation on the S parameters, we also impose that the DC curves obtained from the nonlinear model must be as close as possible to the measured ones. Requirement 3 is sometimes in contrast with 4. In this case, the result is a convenient compromise between the two needs, depending on the application of the model. The extracted nonlinear parameters are such as to minimize the deviation between the S parameters of the nonlinear model and ones measured at the same bias condition. Also, the DC curves of the nonlinear model have to be as close as possible to those of the real device. The nonlinear parameter extractions of capacitors Cgs ; Cds needs a curve-fitting procedure with the linear values obtained at different bias conditions, exactly as described for the diode. Figure 9.41 shows the DC curves of the same GaAs MESFET presenting the S parameters shown in Figure 9.35 and the linear model of Figure 9.34b. The dots represents the measured points, the solid lines are the values obtained from the model, whose parameters have been optimized to fit with the experimental data. The curves in Figure 9.41 have a drain–source voltage continuously varying from 0 to 4 V, while the gate–source voltage equals 0, 0.2 and 0.4 V. Normally the Vgs usable range extends from zero to the pinch-off voltage Vp of the FET: above zero the gate–source is conducting, with a consequent risk of damage; below Vp the drain–source current vanishes, so any further reduction of Vgs produces no appreciable modulation of Ids. Looking at the curves in Figure 9.41, we see that: .
For small Vds (say Vds < 0:5) Ids increases proportionally to Vds , with a slope which decreases with Vgs . That Vds region is sometimes referred to as the triode operation region of the FET, from the homonym thermionic tube device having similar DC curves.
.
For Vds around 1 V, the curves show a knee.
.
For higher Vds, Ids is almost constant, barely depending on the drain–source voltage: again, some authors use another tube device analogy, and name this the pentode region of the FET. Sometimes, the pentode region is also referred to as the current saturation region. Figure 9.41 indicates both the triode and pentode regions, although such delimitation is somewhat qualitative.
measured model (∂Ids/∂Vds) Vds
60 50 triode
pentode region Vgs = 0 V
Ids , mA
40 30
-0.2 V
20 10
-0.4V
0 0
1
2
3
4
5
Vds , V
Figure 9.41
DC curves of the GaAs MESFET presenting the scattering parameters of Figure 9.35.
356
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Such behaviour is common to all the transistors considered in this book (BJT, JFET, MESFET, HEMTand MOSFET) and is due to the velocity saturation of the semiconductor carriers. To explain such an effect, we must consider that the carrier mobility67 is not constant, rather it depends on the applied electric field and decreases with it. Thus, if the external field exceeds a critical limit, there is no further increase in the carrier velocity or the velocity is saturated, and the same thing happens with the current. In normal operation, the drain–source voltage falls into the current saturation region; for example, in the FET of Figure 9.41, Vds could range from 2 to 4 V. From a DC point of view, if the FEToperates with its junctions reverse biased – as it usually does – the nonlinear model in Figure 9.40a simplifies to that in Figure 9.40b. In the simplified network we removed the two diodes Dgs and Dgd because they are reverse biased, and therefore do not conduct any appreciable direct current. Moreover, we removed all the capacitors and short-circuited all the inductors and the two gate resistors Rgs and RI , because there is no direct current flowing through the gate. We can now exploit the simplified circuit in Figure 9.40b to explore some details about the nonlinear generator Ids ðvI ; vds Þ. Many authors [5–7] have proposed mathematical expressions for this element, with differing complexity, accuracy and computational difficulty. The Curtice quadratic [7] model gives one of the simplest equations for the drain current: (
2
b vI Vp ð1 þ l vds Þ tanhða vds Þ vI > Vp ð9:75Þ Ids ðvI ; vds Þ ¼
0 vI Vp Note that the variables vI ; vds represent internal voltages of the model, and differ from their external counterparts Vgs ; Vds because of the voltage drop on the resistors Rs ; Rd . Equation (9.75) states that Ids vanishes if the internal control voltage vI becomes lower than the pinchoff voltage Vp . On the other hand, if Vgs is such that vI Vp , this implies that Ids ¼ 0, and consequently the voltage across Rs vanishes. Thus Equation (9.75) also implies that Ids ¼ 0 for Vgs Vp. In normal operation ðvI ; Vgs > Vp Þ, Equation (9.75) is the product of three factors. The third term, tanhða vds Þ, models the knee on the drain current due to carrier velocity saturation.68 The second factor ð1 þ l vds Þ models the slight slope of Ids in the current saturation region. The factor b ðvI Vp zÞ2 describes the dependence of the drain–source current on the gate–source voltage. At relatively high values69 of Vds we have tanhða vds Þ 1, and if the parameter l is such that l vds 1, Equation (9.75) simplifies to the classical equation of the FET in the drain current saturation region
2 Ids ðvI ; vds Þ ffi b vI Vp ¼ Idss
2 vI 1 Vp
ð9:76Þ
where Idss ¼ b Vp2 is the saturation current of the FET, i.e. the current70vI ¼ 0. If we require the model current to present a minimum deviation from the measured values, it is possible to compute the parameters b; Vp ; l; a. The computation has to take into account the voltage drop on the resistors Rs ; Rd . Alternatively, it is possible to impose Rs ¼ Rd ¼ 0: this simplifies the analysis, but also degrades the overall accuracy of the model, particularly at high frequencies. Assuming Rs ¼ Rd ¼ 0, and applying the curve fitting with the DC curves of the FET in Figure 9.41, give the parameter values b ¼ 66 mA V2 , Vp ¼ 0:724 V, l ¼ 0:047 per V, a ¼ 1:494 per V. Similar to what was discussed for the diode, an alternative possibility to determine b; Vp ; l; a consists of deriving the small-signal parameters of the nonlinear model, and requiring that they coincide with the values of the linear model at various bias conditions. This result can be achieved by deriving the 67
See footnotes 46 and 49. The function tanh(x) is zero for x ¼ 0, monotonically increases with x, and asymptotically tends to 1 when x tends to infinity. 69 For example, Vds > 2 V for the FET with the DC curves in Figure 9.41. 70 Manufacturers generally specify Idss as the current for Vgs ¼ 0, which is much easier to measure. 68
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
357
transconductance and the output resistance of the generator described by Equation (9.74), with the assumptions vI ; Vgs > Vp , tanhða vds Þ 1: gm;nonlinear ¼
qIds ðvI ; vds Þ ¼ 2b vI Vp ð1 þ l vds Þ qvI
2 1 qIds ðvI ; vds Þ ¼ ¼ b vI Vp l Rds;nonlinear qvds
ð9:77Þ ð9:78Þ
The linearized parameters gm;nonlinear ; Rds;nonlinear are functions of the bias condition, and must be as close as possible to the corresponding linear parameters gm ; Rds of the linear model obtained at the same conditions. For each couple of Vgs;k ; Vds;k , the corresponding couple of the internal voltage is71 vI;k ¼ Vg;ks þ Ids;k Rs ; vds;k ¼ Vds;k ðRd þ Rs Þ Ids , where the subscript k ¼ 1 . . . N scans the measured points. Now, substituting the values vI;k ; vds;k into Equations (9.76), (9.77) and equating them to the corresponding linear gm ; Rds, we obtain a system of 2N equations in the three unknowns b; Vp ; l. Hence one single measurement point is not sufficient for solving the system, while two points are too many. Consequently, curve fitting is the most advisable method. The Statz model [6] uses a slightly more sophisticated equation for the drain current 8
2 >
< b vI Vp
ð1 þ l vds Þ tanhcubic ða vds Þ vI > Vp ð9:79Þ Ids ðvI ; vds Þ ¼ 1 þ y vI Vp >
: 0 vI Vp where
8 vds 3 > > > <1 1a 3 tanhcubic ða vds Þ ¼ > > > :1
3 vds < a
3 vds a
Comparing Equation (9.79) with (9.75), we can see that the first models a dependence on the saturation current by the gate voltage. Moreover the Statz model replaces the hyperbolic tangent with a piecewise polynomial equation in the velocity saturation model, with a certain reduction in the required computer resources.
9.7.2.3 MOSFET nonlinear models A complete description of the various MOSFET nonlinear models is given in [3], [8] and [9]. For our needs, we will limit ourselves to presenting some basic descriptions of the concepts that will be used to describe the MOSFET operation in some high-frequency circuits. The nonlinear equivalent circuit of Figure 9.40 is basically valid for the MOSFET too, with minor modifications. Figure 9.42 shows a simplified version of the MOSFET nonlinear model under the hypothesis of the substrate connected to the source.72 Comparing the network in Figure 9.42 with the one in 9.40a, we see that: .
The two diodes Dgs ; Dgd from the gate to the source and to the drain disappear, in that the MOSFET has no junction between those two couples of electrodes.
.
A new diode Dds is present between the drain and the source. This diode really models the junction between the drain and the substrate, which is assumed to be connected to ground, like the source.
71 72
Keep in mind that if the linear model is known, Rs and Rd are known as well. As we assumed in Section 9.6.5.
358
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Cgd (vds -v i )
L g Rg
Gate
+ + Vgs -
vi Cgs(vi) -
Ld Rd Drain
+ vds Cds Ids(v,v i ds ) -
Rs
+ Dds
Vds -
Ls Source
Figure 9.42
Nonlinear equivalent circuit for a MOSFET.
.
The drain–source capacitance is nonlinear, in that it includes the drain–bulk junction capacitance.
.
The resistor RI is short-circuited.
Note also that the capacitances Cgs ; Cgd remain nonlinear, despite no longer being junction capacitances. A sufficiently accurate drain–source current law for the MOSFET is 8 v2ds 2 > > b v ð V Þ v ðvI > VTH ; vds vI VT Þ > I TH ds > 2 > < ð9:80Þ Ids ðvI ; vds Þ ¼ b > ðvI VTH Þ2 ðvI > VTH ; vds > vI VT Þ > > >2 > : 0 vI VTH where VTH is the threshold voltage of the device, and plays a similar role as the pinch-off voltage for the MESFET. The DC characteristic curves of a MOSFET resemble those of the MESFET. Equation (9.79) implies that the drain–source current exhibits a triode region, a knee and a pentode region. The transition between triode and pentode operation occurs close to the carrier velocity passing from the linear ðvI > VTH ; vds vI VT Þ to the saturated ðvI > VTH ; vds > vI VT Þ regime. All the techniques for the nonlinear parameter extraction described for the MESFET remain valid, thus we will not repeat them.
9.7.2.4 BJT nonlinear models The main nonlinear model for the bipolar transistors is the Gummel–Poon model, as described in depth in [3] and [10]. For our needs, we will just present a basic description of the concepts that will be used to describe the MOSFET operation in some high-frequency circuits. Figure 9.43 shows the nonlinear equivalent network of a bipolar transistor. The two diodes Dbe ; Dbc with the associated junction capacitances Cbe ; Cbc model the base–emitter and base–collector junctions, respectively. The nonlinear controlled generator and the base current follow the laws 2Is exp nFvbeVT vcb rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Ic ¼ ð9:81Þ 1 þ VAF 1 þ 1 þ 4 IIKFs exp nFvbeVT
Ic vbe Ib ¼ þ Ise exp bF nE VT
ð9:82Þ
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
Icc /βR Lb Rb
Base
Dbc Iee /βF
Ld Rd
Cbc
Dbe
359
Collector
Cbe
Ic
Cce
Rs Ls Emitter
Figure 9.43 BJT nonlinear equivalent circuit. 8 7
Ibe = 50 µA
6 40 µA
I ce , mA
5 30 µA
4 3
20 µA
2 10 µA
1 0
0
1
2
3
4
5
Vce, V
Figure 9.44
DC curves of the bipolar transistor MBC13900.
The parameters Is ; Ise ; nF ; nE play a similar role to the saturation current and ideality factor that we already met in describing the diode. The parameter bF is the forward current gain of the transistor, while IKF models the effective current gain Ic =Ib decreasing at high collector currents. The parameter 1=VAF introduces a slope in the collector current, similar to l in the Curtice FET model. Figure 9.44 shows the DC curves73 of the bipolar transistor MBC13900, manufactured by Freescale Semiconductor, as obtained from the nonlinear model supplied by the manufacturer itself.74 Once again, the curves present triode and pentode regions, as with FETs, with the transition region – the knee – located around Vce 0:4. Also, the techniques for the extractions of the BJT nonlinear parameters are essentially the same as for the FET, with just minor modifications.
73
See the SIMetrix file 11_MBC13900_DC_Curves.sxsch. Model parameters taken from the component data sheet, Document Number MBC13900/D Rev. 1.1, 06/2005, Table 9, pp. 18–19. Copyright of Freescale Semiconductor, Inc. 2008. Used with permission. 74
360
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Bibliography 1. G. Gonzelez, Microwave Transistor Amplifiers, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1984, pp. 80–87. 2. H. A. Haus, W. R. Atkinson, G. M. Branch, W. B. DavenportJr, W. H. Fonger, W. A. Harris, S. W. Harrison, W. W. McLeod, E. K. Stodola and T. E. Talpey, ‘Representation of noise in linear twoports’, Proceedings of the IRE, Vol. 48, pp. 69–74, 1960. 3. P. Antognetti and G. Massobrio, Semiconductor Device Modeling with SPICE, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1988. 4. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Simulation and Design, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007, Chapter 7, pp. 420–428. 5. A. Materka and T. Kacprzak, ‘Computer calculation of large-signal GaAs FET amplifier characteristics’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 33, No. 2, pp. 129–135, 1985. 6. H. Statz, P. Newman, I. W. Smith, R. A. Pucel and H. A. Haus, ‘GaAs FET device and circuit simulation in SPICE’, IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, Vol. ED-34, No. 2, pp. 160–169, 1987. 7. W. R. Curtice, ‘GaAs MESFET modeling and nonlinear CAD’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 36, No. 2, pp. 220–230, 1988. 8. N. Camilleri, J. Costa, D. Lovelace and D. Ngo, ‘Silicon MOSFET, the microwave device technology for the 90’s’, IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium Digest, June 1993, p. 545. 9. D. P. Foty, MOSFET Modeling with SPICE: Principles and Practice, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ, 1997. 10. H. K. Gummel and H. C. Poon, ‘An integral charge control model of bipolar transistors’, Bell System Technical Journal, Vol. 49, May/June, p. 827, 1970.
Related files Ansoft files 01_Power_Divider_with_Cables.adsn. Simulates the assembly in Figure 9.3a, to compute amplitude and phase imbalance between the two output ports. 02_Power_Divider_with_Cables_more_Ideal.adsn. As previous file, but under the simplifying hypothesis that the power divider is perfectly matched. 03_Filter_Assembly.adsn. Analyzes the filter assembly in Figure 9.7. 04_BJT_Linear_Model.adsn. Analyzes the BJT linear model in Figure 9.36, together with the scattering parameters of Table 9.3.
Mathcad files 05_Low_Pass_Example2.MCD. Implements the synthesis formulae for the lowdpass filter in Figure 9.7. 06_Band_Pass_Noise_Bandwidth.MCD. Computes the noise bandwidth of bandpass filters obtained from various approximations. Dissipation loss effects are also included. 07_Saturation_Polynomial_Curve_Fit.MCD. Computes the polynomial approximation of a saturated response.
BASIC CONCEPTS FOR MICROWAVE COMPONENT DESIGN
361
08_IP3_Cubic.MCD. Implements some basic calculations on the single tone and dual tone response of a nonlinear function. 09_Diode_Breakdown.MCD. Computes the diode breakdown parameters, starting from the experimental data.
Simetrix files 10_Diode_I_V_Curve.sxsch. Analyzes the diode to obtain the DC curve in Figure 9.39. 11_MBC13900_DC_Curves.sxsch. Analyzes the bipolar transistor MBC13900, to obtain the DC curves in Figure 9.44.
10
Microwave control components 10.1 Introduction This chapter describes high-frequency components that use diodes and transistors in a passive manner. In other words, the semiconductor devices in the components described do not operate to increase the signal energy, rather they work to modify some signal parameters. Furthermore, the components discussed in this chapter have the common characteristic of not producing nonlinear distortions at high frequency, at least in principle. The importance of the control components comes from their wide use in communication equipment and test instruments. Section 10.2 deals with the switch, which is probably the simplest control component, presenting diode, FET and MEMS components. Section 10.3 illustrates some variable attenuators. Section 10.4 describes the most frequently used types of phase shifters. Within this chapter we will use the words ‘reference impedance’ and ‘50 O’ as synonymous, unless specified differently, since 50 O is the most commonly used impedance.
10.2 Switches Microwave/RF switches are components having n þ 1 RF ports and m control ports. The DC voltage or currents at the different control ports determine the configuration of the connections between the different RF ports. Figure 10.1 shows the electrical symbols for the most common types of switches: in all these components one specific RF port can be connected to one of the remaining ones. In the general case, the connected port is selectable among n, by means of a suitable combination of control voltages: we have the single pole, n throw (SPnT), whose symbol is the one in Figure 10.1c. The simplest SPnT is the single pole, single throw (SPST), having n ¼ 1; Figure 10.1a shows the relative symbol. The RF port P1 is connected or not to the RF port P2 , depending on the combinations of the voltages/currents applied to the control ports V1 to Vm . In the remaining part of this section we will refer to the used combinations of the voltages/currents applied to the control ports as the control stimulus. At this point, we will clarify the meaning of the words connected and non-connected, using the SPST as a reference. In this regard, we will define the SPSTas a linear, passive and reciprocal two-port network.
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
364
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
P2
P1
(a)
V1
Vm
P2 P1
P3
(b)
V1
Vm
P2
P3 P1
P4
Pn + 1
(c)
V1
Vm
Figure 10.1 Symbols for some switches: (a) SPST; (b) SPDT; (c) SPnT.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
365
Furthermore, we will assume that such a network has two working states, low and high attenuation, which are determined by the control stimulus. In the low-attenuation state, the transmission coefficient amplitude is as close to 1 as allowed by the component performances;1 consequently, reflection coefficients present small amplitudes.2 Conversely, the insertion loss in the high-attenuation state is quite high, of the order of 40 dB or more. The reflection coefficient could present either high or low amplitude. In the first case, the reflection coefficient amplitude approaches unity, in the latter case there is a good matching, similar to the lowattenuation state. Those two cases define the reflective or absorptive switch, respectively. The low- and high-attenuation states are sometimes referred to with ON and OFF, respectively. Other possible eponyms for low and high attenuation are transmitting and isolating state, respectively. We will also use this shorter denomination in the case where there is no possibility of confusion with the eponymous states of the switching elements. Also, we will say that in the low- (respectively, high-) attenuation state the RF port P2 is connected to (not connected to, or isolated from) port P1 . The extension of the above concepts to the general case proceeds as follows: (a) SPnT is a linear, passive and reciprocal ðn þ 1Þ-port network, having n meaningful working states, denoted by superscripts 1 to n, respectively. (b) One and only one RF port can be connected to all the remaining ones. Let the first be P1 and the others P2 to Pn þ 1 . We will refer to P1 as the common port, while P2 to Pn þ 1 will be the selectable ports. Sometimes the common port and the selectable port are named ‘input port’ and ‘output port’, respectively, but this is improper, because generators and loads can be connected at any port of the switch. (c) Depending on the control stimulus, SPnT assumes the state k among the possible nðk ¼ 1 . . . nÞ. We will refer to the port Pk þ 1 as the activated or the selected one. In this particular state, the insertion loss between P1 and Pk þ 1 is small, and the return loss at ports P1 and Pk þ 1 , together with the insertion loss from P1 to all other ports but Pk þ 1 , is high: ðk Þ ðk Þ ðk Þ ðkÞ 0 sk þ 1;1 1; s1;1 sk þ 1;k þ 1 0; sm þ 1;1 m6¼k
(d) As can be seen, in any state k the common port P1 and the connected (or the active, or the transmitting) port Pk þ 1 are always impedance matched: all the remaining ports – which are isolated – could be matched or not. In the first (latter) case we have an absorptive (reflective) switch. Some mixed combinations are also possible, with some of the ports P2 to Pn þ 1 presenting low reflection in any state, while the remainder do not. Furthermore, absorptive switches usually present higher ON insertion loss and/or lower OFF insertion loss than their reflective counterparts.3 Further clarifying, we have four main specifications for an SPnT: 1. Insertion loss in the ON state, defined as the insertion loss between the common port P1 and the activated port Pk ðk ¼ 2; . . . ; n þ 1Þ . It is possible that different ports have different specifications of the insertion loss. Sometimes, the insertion loss in the low attenuation is simply referred to as the insertion loss.
1 The insertion loss in the low attenuation results from many factors, such as the maximum working frequency, the relative bandwidth, the required isolation in the high-attenuation state and the technology used. The ON insertion loss of semiconductor-device-based SPST typically falls within the range 1–3 dB. 2 The return loss is usually better than 10 dB in the low-attenuation state. 3 Realized with the same technology, frequency range, switching speed, and so on.
366
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 2. Isolation, defined as the insertion loss in the OFF state between port P1 and any of the nonactivated ports Pm þ 1 ðm 6¼ kÞ. The isolation could differ from port to port, as with the insertion loss, and also could change with the selected port. 3. Maximum input power, defined either as the maximum applicable rate without permanently damaging the component, or as the value that guarantees a specified distortion or compression level. The 1 dB compression point is often specified.4 Note that any of the SPnT ports can be used as input or output, at least in principle. For instance, SPnT can be used to select one of the n signals present at the ports P2 to Pn þ 1 , and to deliver it to port P1 , or to distribute the signal at port P1 to one of P2 to Pn þ 1 . The maximum power could depend on the RF port used as input, and could also assume different values in the low- to high-attenuation states. Also, during the transition from low to high attenuation and vice versa, the internal elements of the switch could assume critical states that consistently reduce the power handling. For this reason, the maximum power is normally specified assuming that the switch changes its state with zero power applied (cold switching). The maximum RF power tolerated by SPnT while commuting (hot switching) is quite low, unless the component is specifically designed for that operation. 4. Switching time, defined as the difference tON tDRIVE , where tON denotes the instant when the switch RF output power reaches its steady state value, and tDRIVE is the instant when all the control voltages/currents definitively reach their final value, after the commutation. Sometimes, it is also defined as tDRIVE tOFF switching time, but normally the commutation from low to high attenuation is faster than the opposite case.5
The simplest switch type after the SPST is the single pole, double throw (SP2T) or (SPDT), whose symbol is shown in Figure 10.1b. The importance of the SP2T comes from its wide use as an antenna duplexing device in transmitter–receivers6 and as a building block of more complex control components, such as step attenuators and binary phase shifters.7 From a realization point of view, SPnT generally consists8 of n identical SPSTs, with all their ports P1 connected together, while the ports P2 of the SPST becomes the ports P2 ; P3 ; . . . ; Pn þ 1 of the SPnT. Figure 10.2a shows the connection of n SPSTs to form one SPnT. The above-mentioned n SPSTs are known as the branches of the SPnT. Because of its internal structure, one SPnT can be described in terms of its SPST. Compared with a standalone SPST, the SPnT branch has the additional requirement of presenting a high impedance9 to port P1 when not selected;10 this minimizes the disturbance caused by the non-activated branches on the activated one. Figure 10.2b shows the typical internal structure of an SPST branch. It consists of a series of a switching element (SW1 ) and m shunt switching elements (SW2 to SWm ). A further series element could be present at ports P2 ; P3 ; . . . ; Pn þ 1 : this is not essential for our description, therefore Figure 10.2 does not show it. SW1 can only assume high or low impedance;11 correspondingly SW2 to SWm behave like low or high impedance. The control quantities V1 to Vm must be such as to set the corresponding elements in the described conditions. 4
See Section 9.5.5 for the definition of the 1 dB compression point. The switch is fully transmitting when all of its components reach the corresponding condition. In the ON–OFF transition, the switch is (at least) partially isolating when just a few of its elements begin to assume the condition. Hence the transition OFF–ON (ON–OFF) is determined by the slowest (fastest) device and/or control signal. 6 See Section 15.5.1. 7 See Sections 10.3 and 10.4 below. 8 Other configurations are possible, like multiple cascaded SPDTs. For example, one SP4T can be obtained by cascading one SPDT with two other SPDTs. 9 Ideally, open circuit. 10 Keep in mind that only one of the ports P2 to Pn þ 1 is activated, all the remaining ones being in the OFF state. 11 Excluding the switching transients. 5
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
P1
1
SPST1
2
P2
1
SPST2
2
P3
1
SPSTn
2
Pn+1
(a)
SPnT
1
P1
367
SW 1
TL1
TL2 SW2
V1
TL3 SW3
V2
TLm
2
P2 , P3 ,.. Pn+1
SWm
V3
Vm
(b)
Figure 10.2
SPnT structure: (a) schematic of the principle; (b) electrical diagram of one SPDT cell.
The network in Figure 10.2b comprises transmission lines and switching elements together with their associated control components, although these are not shown. Many physical devices can be used to realize the switching elements: electronic devices like diodes and transistors, or electromechanical devices. In the first (latter) case some bias networks (electrostatic, electromagnetic or piezoelectric actuators) complete the SPST structure. The most frequently used electronic switching elements are PIN diodes, gallium arsenide MESFETs and MOSFETs.12 Figure 10.3 shows the schematics of some SPST realizations, employing the switching elements that subsequent sections will describe. The SPSTs in Figure 10.3 have one series (SW1 , D1 , Q1 ) and two shunt elements (SW2 , SW3 , D2 , D3 , Q2 , Q3 ); other realizations could present more shunt elements and/or an additional series element close to the RF port P2 . Finally, the schematics in Figure 10.3 include the bias networks needed for the different switching devices. Sections 10.2.1 and 10.2.2 below describe the PIN diode and FET switches, while Section 10.2.3 deals with special electromechanical switches, known as MEMS.
12 Recently, other materials have replaced or been used in combination with arsenide (phosphorus) and gallium (aluminium, indium). Also, more sophisticated and better performing devices (HFET, HEMT, PHEMT) have replaced the MESFET. However, the new devices operate in the same way as the MESFET used as the base for our description.
368
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING TL 1
SW 1
P1
TL 3
TL 2 SW2
P2
SW3
(a) C1 V1 L2
D1
TL1
P1
TL2A
TL2B
D2
L1
TL3
C2
P2
D3
(b)
TL1
Q1
P1
TL2
Q2
TL3
R1
R2
V1
P2
Q3 R3
V2
(c)
C1 V2 L2 C3
P1
SW1 L1
V1
TL1
TL2A SW2
TL2B
TL3
C2
P2
SW3
C4 (d)
Figure 10.3 (d) MEMS.
10.2.1
SPST with three switching elements: (a) ideal elements; (b) PIN diodes; (c) FETs:
PIN diode switches
The acronym PIN derives from the device structure. It derives from that of the standard p–n (PN) diode, illustrated in Figure 9.28a, with the addition of a layer of intrinsic13 (I) material, placed between the p- and n-zones. PIN diodes present static DC characteristic similar to those of normal junction diodes, which follow relation (9.68). Let us initially consider a normal PN diode, and assume it is biased with a direct current Id0 with a superimposed small sinusoidal current of amplitude is and frequency fs (with os ¼ 2pfs ). The total 13
Not doped.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
369
current flowing through the diode is then Id ðtÞ ¼ Id0 þ is cos ðos tÞ
ð10:1Þ
Substituting expression (10.1) into the diode equation (9.68), we obtain the voltage across the diode Id0 is þ cos ðos tÞ þ 1 þ Rs Id0 þ Rs is cos ðos tÞ ð10:2Þ Vd ðtÞ ¼ n VT ln IS IS The voltage (10.2) is non-sinusoidal, but it is still periodic with the same fundamental frequency fs as the current (10.1). Hence, expanding the function (10.2) in Fourier series, we obtain all the harmonics of the diode voltage.14 In our simplified case, is Id0 , we can approximate Equation (10.2) by a small-signal expression. Rearranging expression (10.2), and applying the approximation x 1 ) ln ð1 þ xÞ x, we obtain the small-signal approximation of the diode voltage Id0 n VT Vd ðtÞ ffi n VT ln þ 1 þ Rs Id0 þ þ Rs is cos ðos tÞ ð10:3Þ IS Id0 þ IS The sum of the first two terms of Equation (10.3) equals the DC voltage corresponding to the direct current Id0 . The third term of Equation (10.3) is proportional to the applied sinusoidal current, by the ðDiodeÞ constant RIncremental ¼ n VT =ðId0 þ IS Þ þ Rs . That constant is the incremental resistance of the diode, biased with the direct current Id0 . It coincides with the derivative of the diode voltage (9.69) with respect to the current ðDiodeÞ
RIncremental ¼
@Vd n VT ¼ þ Rs @Id Id þ IS
ð10:4Þ
Equation (10.4) states that the diode incremental resistance decreases with the forward bias current. This conclusion is valid for PIN diodes as well. The two bias conditions that are of interest for the operation of a diode as a switching element are (i) strong forward bias and (ii) reverse bias. In case (i) a forward current much higher than the saturation current flows through the diode, and its incremental resistance becomes h i Id0 IS n VT ðDiodeÞ ðDiodeÞ RIncremental;ON þ Rs ; lim RIncremental ¼ Rs ð10:5Þ Id0 ! 1 Id0 In case (ii), due to the reverse bias, the diode current is close to zero, and the incremental resistance approximates as ðDiodeÞ
I ¼0
RIncremental d0¼
n VT n VT þ Rs Is Is
ð10:6Þ
Assuming the parameters of the diode described in Section 9.7.2 Is ¼ 0:1995 10 12 ; n ¼ 1:9271; Rs ¼ 2:864 OÞ and a forward bias current of 20 mA and zero reverse current, 14 Equivalently, expression (10.2) can be considered as a function of the variable is cos ðos tÞ and expanded in a Maclaurin series
Vd ðtÞ ¼
1 X
ak is k cosk ðos tÞ
k¼0
where ak ¼ ðk!Þ 1 d k ½n VT lnðId0 =IS þ x þ 1Þ þ Rs Id0 þ Rs x=dxk Thus, a1 ¼ n VT =ðId0 þ IS Þ þ Rs , a2 ¼ 0:5 n VT ðId0 þ IS Þ 2 , and so on. Then it is possible to derive the Fourier coefficients from the Maclaurin series by expressing the terms cosk ðos tÞ as combinations of harmonics cosðm os tÞ ðm ¼ 0; . . . ; kÞ .
370
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
expression (10.4) gives ðDiodeÞ
RIncremental;ON 5:3 O;
ðDiodeÞ
RIncremental;OFF 2:5 1011 O
If the signal current varies sufficiently fast, i.e. for high values of fs , expression (10.4) is no longer valid for PIN diodes, and so it is with its approximations (10.5) and (10.6). The intrinsic region, placed between the P- and N-regions of the PIN diode, causes a lack of validity in Equation (10.4), but still PIN diodes exhibit variable incremental resistance that decreases with the forward direct current. We will not describe the PIN diode physics in depth.15 For our needs it is sufficient to say that, at high frequencies, PIN diodes approximate linear variable resistors much better than PN or Schottky diodes. More precisely, PIN diodes are characterized by the parameter t, called carrier lifetime, which increases with the thickness of the I-region. PIN incremental resistance follows Equation (10.4) only if the current variations are slower than t. In particular, if the current is a direct current with a superimposed sinusoid, like Equation (10.1), then (10.4) is valid only if fs 1=t. Nevertheless, even if fs > 1=t, the two equations (10.5) and (10.6) remain qualitatively valid, in that: (a) Forward-biased PIN diodes present a low incremental resistance, which decreases as the forward current increases, although not proportionally to 1=Id0 and differently from what Equation (10.5) states. Furthermore, Equation (10.5) approximates the ON resistance of the junction diode for small signals, i.e. for Is tending to zero. As Is increases, the nonlinear behaviour of the diode becomes more relevant and consequently the linear approximation loses accuracy. A remarkable property of PIN diodes is the high linearity in the high conduction (or briefly ON) state. If ðDiodeÞ fs 1=t then RIncremental stays almost constant with Is , much more than happens for a junction diode. The DC control current of the PIN diode can be smaller – sometimes by orders of magnitude – than the high-frequency current. (b) Inverse-biased PIN diodes present high incremental resistance16 that is almost independent of the applied reverse voltage, providing that this is higher than a specified limit, which depends on the device. At low frequency the diode is interdicted until the anode–cathode voltage is negative all the time. The second important property of the PIN diode is that it stays in the low conduction (or shortly OFF) state if the anode–cathode voltage becomes positive for short time intervals, in some cases just slightly shorter than half a sine cycle. The concepts (a) and (b) are summarized by saying that PIN diodes present a kind of inertia in the I–V characteristic. The device incremental resistance is not affected by the amplitude of rapidly varying excitations superimposed on the DC bias, rather it tends to remain constant and only depends on the DC bias itself. Such incremental resistance exhibits high linearity with respect to rapid variable excitations, provided that their spectral energy is non-negligible only for f 1=t. The main drawback of the lifetime carrier mechanism is the relatively slow response of the PIN diode to the switching command: PIN SPnT switching time ranges from fractions of a microsecond to a few microseconds. We can now again consider the linear equivalent circuit of the diode, shown in Figure 9.32a. When the diode is strongly forward biased, its series resistance practically coincides17 with Rs , thus the network resulting from the combination of Cd , Rd , Rs almost coincides with Rs only. The maximum working
15
The interested reader can find some more details in [1–3]. ðDiodeÞ Equation (10.4) gives RIncremental;OFF 2:5 1011 O for the diode described in Section 9.7.2, as we have seen. However, the high-frequency OFF incremental resistance is difficult to evaluate, because some other parasitic effects mask it, like the residual capacitance. ðDiodeÞ 17 From Equation (10.4) we have that Rd ¼ RIncremental Rs ¼ n VT =ðId þ IS Þ, which can be arbitrarily reduced by increasing the forward current Id . 16
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
371
frequency is such that the reactance associated with Ls at that frequency equals Rs ðPIN Þ
fMAX;ON ¼
Rs 2p Ls
ð10:7Þ
Since, usually, the value of (10.7) falls well below the parallel resonance of Ls with Cp , it is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðPIN Þ fMAX;ON ¼ Rs =ð2p Ls Þ 1= 2p Ls Cp In the OFF state, the diode assumes a high series resistance, and the junction capacitance tends to zero due to the wide depleted region across the junction: the linear model in Figure 9.34a simplifies to the capacitor Cp . Usually a resistor is considered in parallel with the capacitor, because no device in any state is purely reactive, and PIN diodes are no exception. Thus, the maximum usable frequency in the OFF state for a given device depends on the circuit impedance R0 and is such that the capacitance reactance equals the latter ðPIN Þ
fMAX;OFF ¼
1 2p Cp R0
ð10:8Þ
Hence, in the ON (OFF) state the PIN diode model is an RL series (RC parallel) cell. SPnT uses the diodes in both the states, thus the maximum working frequency is the lowest value between the ones given by Equations (10.7) and (10.8). The true limit is even lower, due to additional parasitic effects,18 and depends on the accepted maximum insertion loss, minimum return loss and minimum isolation. The minimum usable frequency for a PIN diode is the reciprocal of the carrier lifetime, as seen, with a margin depending on the required linearity. From the considerations so far, it follows that the PIN diode conduction can be changed by applying either a DC voltage or a current to the device. However, although full voltage control is theoretically possible, it is too critical for practical reasons. Indeed, the DC curve in Figure 9.39 presents the wellknown knee, positioned around Vd ¼ 1 V. The voltage to apply to make the diode conducting is slightly higher than the knee value, but a small change in the voltage in that region causes large current variations that can even melt the device. Furthermore, the knee position is also temperature dependent, which makes PIN voltage driving almost impossible. On the other hand, the incremental resistance is easily expressed in terms of the direct current, and if the forward current is above the knee, the voltage across the device is almost constant, even under large variations of such a current. The opposite happens for the OFF state: a small reverse voltage is sufficient, but the corresponding current – negative but very small – is difficult to impress because of the high associated voltage, which can be close to or higher than the breakdown voltage. Thus PIN driving is a mix of current and voltage, to set the device in the ON and OFF condition, respectively. Returning to the schematic in Figure 10.3b, we are now in a position to explain the role of all the components. The inductors L1 , L2 (capacitors C1 , C2 ) provide a low- (high-)impedance path for the direct current and a high (low) impedance for the RF signal. In particular, the capacitor C1 minimizes the sensitivity of driving port V1 to any RF impedance associated with the driving generator, by grounding it at RF. The network configuration makes the DC anode–cathode voltage across D1 always the opposite to that across D2 , D3 . Applying a positive current19 to the port V1 , the diodes D2 , D3 conduct, and their anode–cathode voltage becomes slightly higher than the knee value.20 This small voltage becomes negative across D1 and is sufficient to put and keep it in the OFF state, for property (a) of the PIN diodes. Therefore a positive current injected into port V1 puts the SPST in the isolated state. From the same kind of consideration, we can see that a negative current through V1 sets D1 ON and D2 , D3 OFF, and thus the
18
For instance, bond wires, package parasitics and bias network residual reactance. Of the order of some tens of milliamps. 20 About 1 V, assuming a device with the curve in Figure 9.39. 19
372
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
SPST in the low-attenuation21 state. Thus a purely current driving realizes a mixed current–voltage driving, due to the voltage stabilization operated by the ON diodes. The bias elements (L1 , L2 , C1 and C2 ) have a highpass behaviour, from the point of view of the RF transmission from P1 to P2 , determining a lower limit on the SPST frequency range, together with t. Figure 10.4 shows a PIN diode SPDT, suitable for a frequency range from 2 to 20 GHz. More precisely, Figure 10.4a is the electrical diagram, which includes two SPSTs of the type shown in Figure 10.3b; here the two inductors L1 of each SPST simplify to one. The driving ports are doubled and renamed as I1 and I2 , considering that the driving excitation is a current. A positive (negative) I1 combined with a negative (positive) I2 enables the RF transmission from P1 to P3 (P2 ). The schematic in Figure 10.4a corresponds to the layout in Figure 10.4b, where: .
The shunt diodes D2A , D3A , D2B and D3B are chip devices, having a size of about 0.4 0.4 mm, with a thickness of about 0.1 mm.
.
The series diodes D1A and D1B are beam-lead devices.
.
The capacitors C1A , C2A , C1B and C2B are chip devices, having a size of about 0.5 0.5 mm, with a thickness of about 0.1 mm.
.
L1 , L2A and L2B are spiral inductors, realized with a wire of diameter of 50–100 mm, wound around a centre diameter of about 0.2 mm; the number of turns is some units.
.
All the transmission lines are realized with microstrips on a substrate having approximately the same thickness as the diodes. The substrate permittivity is such that the lines are slightly wider than the capacitors, in order to allow their assembly.22
Figure 10.4c shows the equivalent network of a shunt diode in the OFF state and of the wires connecting the device to the lines. The component references are those of the diode D3B , but we have the same network for all the shunt diodes. The bond wires that connect the shunt diodes to the lines have a typical diameter of 25 mm, a height above the ground that is slightly greater than the chip thickness, and a length slightly greater than half the chip length. The specific series inductance and the shunt capacitance of each wire are23 2 3 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 m0 4 h h e0 m0 Lw ¼ ln 2 þ 15; Cw ¼ ð10:9Þ 2 2p Lw d d where d and h are the diameter and height above ground of the wire. With our parameters, we have 2 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi3 2 6 50 10 6 7 4 150 10 Lw ¼ 2 10 ln 2 þ 2 15 ffi 0:6 nH=mm; 50 10 6 150 10 6
Cw ffi 0:017 pF=mm
Two wires – each about 0.3 mm long – connect the diode to its two adjacent lines, so we have a wire inductance Lwire ¼ Lw l ffi 0:09 nH, while the associated capacitance is Cwire ¼ Cw l ffi 0:01 pF. 21 Here we have used the words ‘isolated’ and ‘transmission’ – rather than ‘OFF’ and ‘ON’ – to denote the SPST state, in order to prevent any confusion with the diode states, as sometimes happens. 22 For instance, if the substrate thickness is h ¼ 127 mm and the relative permittivity is er ¼ 2:35, Equation (3.181) gives w ffi 380 mm. A thicker substrate could be used to avoid the capacitor being wider than the line, but involves geometrical discontinuities between the shunt diode anodes and the lines. Such discontinuities can compromise the RF performance of the switch, and can be removed only with complicated and expensive mechanical machining of the ground plane. 23 See [4], equation (7.10).
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS IA
IB C1A
C1B
P1 L2A TL3A’
C2A
P2
TL1A
TL1B D1A
D3A
L2B
TL0
TL2A’’
TL2A’
3A
373
TL2B’’
TL2B’
TL3B’’
C2B TL3B’
P3
D1B
D2A
L1
D2B
D3B
(a) I1
I2
P1 C1A
microstrip substrate limit
C1B
TL 0 L2A
P2 TL3A’
TL 2A’
3A
C2A
D3A
L2B
TL 2A’’
TL 1A D2A
TL 2B’’
TL 1B D1A
D1B L1
TL 2B’
TL 3B’ P3
TL 3B’’
D2B
D3B
C2B
GND
(b)
Plane of simmetry
TL2B’
L(3B) L(3B) wire wire
TL3B’’
(D3B)
COFF,3B
(c)
GA
VOFFSET
VCNTRL VBUFF
+ vin
IA gmVb,1
-
GB
VOFFSET VNOR
(d)
+ vin
-
IB gm Vb,2
Figure 10.4 PIN diode SPDT: (a) electrical diagram; (b) layout; (c) parasitic associated with OFF shunt diodes: (d) driver. Passing from a distributed to a lumped24 network, we have the network in Figure 10.4c, where the ðD3BÞ capacitance COFF is the sum of the OFF capacitance of the diode D3B plus those of the two bond wire couples. PIN diodes of the type we are considering – working up to 20 GHz – have a typical ðD3BÞ OFF capacitance of 0.05 pF, thus COFF ffi 0:06 pF. Then the T network consisting of the inductors ð3BÞ ðD3BÞ Lwire and the capacitor COFF can be seen either as a third-order lumped lowdpass filter or approximately as a transmission line. The cut-off frequency25 of the filter is h i ð3BÞ ðD3BÞ 0:5 fcð3BÞ ¼ ð2pÞ 1 Lwire COFF ffi 68:5 GHz
24 This approximation is valid in this context if we assume a wavelength much smaller than the size of the device and its wires, i.e. 0:6 mm l=4 ) f 125 GHz. This condition is well satisfied in our case. 25 The formula can be obtained by applying the image parameter filter design concepts. The interested reader can find the details in [5].
374
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Table 10.1 Performances of the SPDT in Figure 10.4. Specification
Value
unit
Frequency range Insertion loss at 2 GHz Insertion loss at 12 GHz Insertion loss at 20 GHz Return loss Isolation Maximum input continuous power Input power at 1 dB compression (pulsed) Switching time (90% of the final output power)
2–20 1.5 1.5 2 12 60 0.5 4 150
GHz dB dB dB dB dB W W ns
having the characteristic impedance ð3BÞ
Z0
¼
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðD3BÞ ðD3BÞ 2Lwire =COFF ffi 2 0:09 10 9 =0:06 10 12 ffi 55 O
ð3BÞ
Since Z0 is close to 50 O, the combination of the parasitic elements realizes a good impedance ð3BÞ matching, provided that the maximum frequency of the SPDT is much lower than fc , as it is in our case. Table 10.1 summarizes the fundamental performances26 of the SPDT in Figure 10.4. Note that the destructive input power is smaller than the one causing 1 dB of compression. This means that heating of the devices due to the dissipation loss causes permanent damage to them, at a given input value, which generates a compression of less than 1 dB. For this reason, the 1 dBcp is measured in a pulsed condition, in order to minimize the device heating; the typical pulse width is 1 ms, with a duty cycle of 1%. Figure 10.4d shows the principle of the driver for the control ports of the switch. Such a schematic derives from two considerations: .
The currents I1 , I2 have two possible values each, and the sign of I1 is always opposite that of I2 .
.
An external user is normally interested in changing the SPDT state by using a digital signal, not in taking care of the internal driving signals of the switch. Moreover, one single digital signal (bit) should be sufficient to address the two possible states of the SPDT.
The external digital control signal of the SPDT is VCNTRL and it can be 1 or 0; correspondingly P1 is connected to P3 or P2. The logic gates GA and GB are a buffer and a NOR port, respectively.27 They remove the variations that the external digital control voltage could have. Reasonable values for the output voltages28 VBUFF and VNOR of GA and GB could be 0.5 V and 4.5 V (4.5 V and 0.5 V) when VCNTRL ¼ 1 ð0Þ . The SPDT driving means that IK ðK ¼ A; BÞ has to bias two diodes (D2K , D3K ) when positive and only one diode (D1K ) when negative. Now, assuming that all the diodes present the same incremental resistance at the same DC bias value, with a required forward current for the ON state of
26
The Ansoft file 01_PIN_SPDT.adsn provides a first-level simulation of the SPDT in Figure 10.4 The output of a buffer coincides with the input, but, for each logic state, the output voltage is independent of the input, which can vary within an allowed low or high range. The NOR port behaves with the same modality as the buffer, with the difference that the output voltage corresponds to the logic negation of the input, i.e. it is low (high) when the input is high (low). 28 In order to give a simple description of the circuit we will assume some practical values for the quantities involved with it. However, the numbers used are realistic, but they refer to no real case. 27
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
375
20 mA per diode, then this must be I1 ¼ 40 mA;
I2 ¼ 20 mA when VCNTRL ¼ 1 ) VBUFF ¼ 4:5 V;
I1 ¼ 20 mA;
I2 ¼ 40 mA when VCNTRL ¼ 0 ) VBUFF ¼ 0:5 V;
VNOR ¼ 0:5 V VNOR ¼ 4:5 V
Thus the output current excursion for each of the two VCVSs is 60 mA, while the voltage excursion at the output of the logic gates is 4 V: then the transconductance has to be gm ¼ 60=4 ¼ 15 mS. Finally the two voltage sources VOFFSET have to shift the characteristic from the gate outputs to the diodes, so as to obtain the above currents. From I1 ¼ 15 10 3 VNOR ¼ 15 10 3 ðVBUFF VOFFSET Þ it follows that VOFFSET ¼ 4:5 40=15 ffi 1:83 V: The driver of Figure 10.4c has many simplifications, useful for describing the working principles and giving an idea of how it is possible to realize a digital controlled switch.29
10.2.2
FET switches
Figure 10.3c shows the schematic of an FET SPST with one series and two shunt transistors. These devices exhibit a variable resistance – between the drain and source – controlled by the DC voltage applied between the gate and source. Thus, FET switches uses the channel resistance to realize controlled variable impedances. At microwave frequencies, the GaAs MESFET30 is the most used device type, while at RF the Si MOSFETs are also used. MESFETs are depletion devices, while MOSFETs could be either depletion or enhancement devices, though the latter case is more frequent. For the switch operation, the main difference between enhancement and depletion devices is the control voltage range. Both MESFET and MOSFET switching elements operate in the triode region, thus with relatively small drain–source voltages.31 Any violation of such a condition makes the device resistance depend on both Vgs and Vds , with consequent nonlinear distortions on the RF signal. Let us assume that MESFET and MOSFET DC curves follow Equations (9.75) or (9.79) and (9.80) respectively. In the linear current region we have that ðMESFET Þ
a vds
1;
ðMOSFET Þ
vds
vI VT
ð10:10Þ
Note that the internal gate–source voltage vI results from the superimposition of the externally applied DC gate–source voltage on the RF voltage resulting from the FET parasitic capacitances. In normal cases the external DC voltage dominates. From the first condition of (10.10) it follows that we can approximate the hyperbolic tangent with its argument h i ðMESFET Þ ðMESFET Þ tanh a vds ffi a vds
29 The switching time has been intentionally omitted from the discussion. We will limit ourselves to mentioning that ON diodes – particularly PIN ones – store carriers that must be removed by fast switching to OFF. The circuit in Figure 10.4c is not able to remove the stored charges, due to the high output impedance inherent in the current generators. Some real drivers approximate current generators with voltage generators having high output resistance, and bypass the latter with suitable speed-up capacitors. 30 Herein ‘GaAs’ and ‘MESFET’ also denote the more evolved materials (AlGaAs, InAsS, InP, etc.) and devices (HEMT, PHEMT, HFET, etc.), which present the same principle of operation. 31 For instance, the FET with the DC curves in Figure 9.41 works reasonably well as a linear switching element if jvds j < 0:5 V.
376
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING ðMESFET Þ
ðMESFET Þ
Moreover, a vds 1 usually implies that also l vds 1, since usually it is l < a. Thus, in ðMESFET Þ 0 we can approximately rewrite the MESFET equation (9.75) as the gate–source range Vp vI h i h i2 ðMESFET Þ ðMESFET Þ ðMESFET Þ ðMESFET Þ ffi b a vI vI ; a vds Vp a vds
ð10:11Þ
Similarly, for the MOSFET, in the triode region Equation (9.80) simplifies to h i h i ðMOSFET Þ ðMOSFET Þ ðMOSFET Þ ðMOSFET Þ ðMOSFET Þ ¼ b vI vI ; vds VTH vds Ids
ð10:12Þ
ðMESFET Þ
Ids
From Equations (10.11) and (10.12) we can compute the corresponding drain–source incremental resistance h i ðMESFET Þ ðMOSFET Þ ðMOSFET Þ h i2 @I v ; v I ds ds 1 ðMESFET Þ ¼ ffi b vI Vp a ð10:13Þ ðMESFET Þ ðMESFET Þ @vds rds ðMOSFET Þ
1 ðMOSFET Þ
rds
¼
@Ids
h
ðMOSFET Þ
vI
ðMOSFET Þ
; vds
ðMOSFET Þ
@vds
i
h i ðMOSFET Þ ¼ b vI VTH
ð10:14Þ
Note that both the incremental resistances (10.13) and (10.14) depend only on the internal gate–source voltage vI, as needed for a linear operation of the switch. Equation (10.13) states that the MESFET drain–source incremental resistance reaches its minimum ðMESFET Þ
value rds;min
ðMESFET Þ 2
¼ b ½VP
ðMESFET Þ
a when vI
¼ 0, increasing with the negative gate–source
ðMESFET Þ vI
voltage, up to infinity for
Vp. ðMOSFET Þ ¼ VTH Þ down to zero The MOSFET small-signal channel resistance ranges from infinity ðvI ðMOSFET Þ
ðvI ! 1Þ. The ideally zero minimum channel resistance is a peculiarity of the MOSFET with respect to the MESFET. However, real devices have neither zero short-circuit nor infinite short-circuit resistance, due to second-order effects, just electrode resistances and leakage currents, at least. Differently from PIN diodes, FETs have three electrodes: the variable resistance is present between the drain and source, while the control voltage is applied between the gate and source. Similar to what we did for the PIN diode, we can still obtain simple equivalent networks for the drain–source bipole, although the FET model is more complicated than the PIN one. Looking between the drain and source, one can see a parallel RC or series RL in the OFF or ON state, respectively. Compared with the PIN diode, the FET presents three main advantages: (a) The control electrode (gate) is separated from the variable resistance, used as a switching element. This simplifies the bias network design. However, it must be considered that the parasitic capacitances Cgs , Cgd introduce an AC coupling – increasing with the frequency – of the gate with the source and drain. (b) The gate–source control voltage is applied across a reverse-biased junction (MESFET) or on a DC insulated electrode (MOSFET). Thus, an FET switch driver must supply no direct current.32 By comparison, the PIN requires current in the ON state. (c) FET operation does not depend on carrier lifetime Thus the minimum working frequency is theoretically zero, and the switching speed is higher than with the PIN.
32
Some small current is required to charge/discharge the gate parasitic capacitors in the state change transients.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
377
And three disadvantages: (d) The FET presents higher (lower) ON (OFF) resistance than the PIN, and consequently FET switches present a higher insertion loss (lower isolation) in the transmitting (isolating) state. (e) Parasitic reactance associated with the FET is higher than with the PIN, thus FET SPnTs have lower maximum working frequency. (f) FET switches generally have lower maximum power handling than PIN ones, in respect of both nonlinear distortions and risk of damage. Figure 10.3c shows the basic schematic of one SPST branch realized with an FET. The bias network is simpler than the one in Figure 10.3b, and consists of one resistor per switching element. Applying zero voltage on the control port V1 and, simultaneously, a value lower than the pinch-off33 on V2 , we have that Q1 conducts and Q2 , Q3 do not.34 In that condition a low attenuation occurs between the RF ports P1 , P2 . The opposite happens when swapping the control voltages, with a consequent high attenuation from P1 to P2 . The determination of the bias resistances R1 to R3 is the result of a compromise between contrasting requirements. The gate is not fully isolated from the drain, rather parasitic capacitances Cgs , Cgd provide a frequency-increasing coupling. Thus a high-frequency signal is present – and dissipated – on the control ports: this crosstalk degrades both the insertion loss and the isolation. Therefore the achievement of the best high-frequency performances implies the use of high-value bias resistors, to minimize the crosstalk. On the other hand, bias resistances must be low enough to charge and discharge the gate parasitic capacitances rapidly, in order to achieve the high switching speed allowed by FET technology. The exact prediction of those performances requires circuit simulations. Nevertheless, some initial ideas can be obtained from relatively simple considerations. Note that the gate capacitance increases with the gate–source voltage, as in Equation (9.73). Therefore, the gate presents the maximum capacitance to ground when the FET is in the conduction state. Typical numbers for a switch operating up to 20 GHz could be Cgs Cds 0:2 pF. Then, the bias resistance has to charge a total capacitance of about 0.4 pF: if R1 ¼ R2 ¼ R3 5 kO we have a time constant of t ¼ Cgs þ Cds Rk 1 ns, which guarantees a settling time of less than 5 ns.35 To put some numbers on the RF performances, an ore resistor with R ¼ 5 kO provides an attenuation of 20 log10 ð5000=100 þ 1Þ ffi 34 dB if placed between a 50 O source and load.36 In the switch case, each couple of gate bias resistors connected to the same driving pad generates a parasitic RF path. That path comprises the FET parasitics from the drain to the gate, from the gate to ground, the two resistors themselves and the RF impedance to ground provided by the driver that applies the control voltage. The last is difficult to determine and is also not repeatable; nonetheless it is certainly different from an open circuit and thus provides an additional – although difficult to predict – attenuation in the parasitic path. Therefore, considering the two resistors and the additional attenuations provided by the above-mentioned elements, each parasitic path generates a crosstalk of the order of twice the case of the 5 kO resistor between the 50 O source and load, with some margin, i.e. in excess of 2 34 ¼ 68 dB. Such attenuation is low enough not to degrade insertion loss and isolation, which is around 40 dB, as is typical for FET switches. 33 The pinch-off voltage used for the Curtice (Equation (9.75)) or Statz model (Equation (9.79)) is around 1 V for the GaAs MESFET; for instance, the example considered in Section 9.7.2.2 has Vp ¼ 0:724 V. However, the drain–source current (and thus the drain–source conductance) does not completely vanish for Vgs ¼ Vp , differently from what the Curtice and Statz models – which are approximate – predict. Usually, the DC gate–source voltage to apply to completely interdict the MESFET falls within the range 2 to 5 V. 34 Here we are considering depletion devices. The enhancement case is similar, just replacing zero voltage with a voltage above threshold and the pinch-off voltage with zero. 35 See [6]. 36 This isolation is the approximated one between the gate and the control port, not the one for the switch.
378
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 10.5
GaAs MMIC SPDT: (a) schematic; (b) layout.
The worst case isolation occurs when the parasitic contribution is in phase with the switch main path. If we assume that, without considering the bias network, the isolation is 40 dB, the worst case isolation will be 10 log10 ð10 4 þ 10 6:8 Þ 39:993 dB. The resulting degradation is only 0.007 dB with respect to the ideal bias network case. The parasitic transmission due to the bias network becomes dominant when the main isolation tends to infinity. The parasitic path due to the bias elements also affects the insertion loss in the transmitting state. Assuming that the switch is ideal (0 dB of insertion loss in the transmitting state), the additional loss caused by the signal crosstalk in the bias network is 10 log10 ð1 10 6:8 Þ 6:9 10 7 dB. The transmission lines TL1 to TL3 could have a characteristic impedance of 50 O or higher. The first case occurs when the wire inductance compensates the capacitance to ground of the switching element, as we see for PIN diodes. That condition is generally not verified with FETs, because they present higher parasitic capacitance than the PIN in the OFF state, as already mentioned. Moreover, FET switching elements are frequently used in MMIC or IC technology, where almost no connection inductance is present. Therefore, the lines TL1 to TL3 work like semi-lumped inductors,37 to compensate the parasitic capacitance of Q2 , Q3 in their OFF state; thus the characteristic impedance of those lines is the highest possible. Figure 10.5 shows a schematic (a) and the layout (b) of a GaAs MMIC SPDT. It consists of two identical SPSTs, each with one series and three shunt switching transistors. The subscript ‘A’ (‘B’) denotes the components of the SPST from the RF port P1 to P2 (P3 ). The control voltage V2 (V1 ) applied to the gate of the series FET Q1A (Q1B ) is also applied to the gates of the shunt transistors Q2B to Q4B (Q2A to Q4A ). Moreover, V1 and V2 are complementary in that, when the first is zero, the second assumes a value well below the pinch-off, and vice versa. This arrangement guarantees that one and only one port between the ports P2 , P3 is connected to P1 , as needed.
37 The inductor approximation technique by means of high-impedance lines is based on the semi-lumped concepts discussed in Section 8.4
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS 0
379
0 low attenuation→ -2 simulation measurement
-20
-4
-30
-6
-40
-8
← high attenuation
-50
-10 0
Figure 10.6 Figure 10.5.
20 log10(|S21|), ON
20 log10(|S21|), OFF
-10
2
4
6
8 10 12 Frequency, GHz
14
16
18
Predicted (solid lines) and measured (dashed lines) insertion loss of the SPDT in
The transmission lines TL1 to TL3 are narrow microstrips ðw ¼ 10 mmÞ on the GaAs substrate ðh ¼ 100 mm; er ¼ 12:5Þ: Equation (3.183) gives Z0 ffi 92:8 O. The layout in Figure 10.5b shows how such lines have been folded, in order to minimize the chip size, which is about 1 2:8 mm. For the same reason, also the bias resistors R1 to R4 have a snake-like shape. The shunt transistors Q2 to Q4 connect to ground by means of the four via holes G1 to G4: G2 (G3) is shared between Q2 and Q3 (Q3 and Q4 ). Finally, the RF pads of the ports P1 to P3 present two side via holes with two ground probes for the on-wafer RF test.38 Figure 10.6 shows the simulated (solid lines) and measured insertion loss and isolation of the switch in Figure 10.5. The return loss at the two connected ports is better than 10 dB, although not shown. The measured input power for 1 dB compression is around 23 dBm, while the switching time is lower than 5 ns. Comparing these data with those in Table 10.1, we see that the PIN diode SPDT performs better in all the RF situations except the low-frequency limit, while the FET SPDT presents a remarkably shorter switching transient, as expected. However, some FET switches may exhibit long tail effects on the switching transient. Increasing the gate voltage in a series FET from the pinch-off up to zero allows the respective channel to conduct. Unfortunately, at the beginning of the state change, some of the electrons passing through the channel could be trapped in the substrate. In this case, some small portions of the channel remain pinched off – and the series FET does not fully conduct – until all the trapped electrons are liberated. The time needed for complete transmission of the switch could be slightly smaller than 1 s for the insertion loss being within 0.01 dB of its steady state value.39
10.2.3
MEMS switches
MEMS stands for microelectromechanical systems. They are miniaturized 3-D devices based on the mechanical movement of a thin elastic membrane or beam which enables or prevents the propagation of the RF signal along a planar transmission line.40 The latter is most often a coplanar waveguide (CPW) or a 38
See Section 14.5.2. See [7, 8]. 40 MEMS have been developed since the 1970s as mechanical sensors. Their use in high-frequency applications is much more recent and is distinguished by the RF prefix. 39
380
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
microstrip line and the membrane is in the form of a bridge or a cantilever. The term MEMS switch normally refers to switches where the movable membrane has two fixed positions, namely the up state (membrane suspended) and the down state (membrane collapsed onto the transmission line). In a MEMS varactor, on the contrary, the distance between the movable membrane and the transmission line can be varied in a continuous fashion, so as to realize a variable capacitor. Actuation of MEMS switches can be achieved by various mechanisms, i.e. by electrostatic, electromagnetic, piezoelectric or thermal effects. Although the electrostatic actuation requires high voltages (of the order of 20–80 Vor more), it is actually the most common technique in use today. This is because of the very simple actuation mechanism, the high performance and reliability, the virtually zero power consumption, the small electrode size and the relatively short switching time. We will therefore consider here only electrostatic-actuated devices. There is an ample variety of configurations and geometries that have been proposed and developed for RF MEMS switches. We consider here only the basic and more common configurations that lead to the following categorization: 1. Series and shunt MEMS switches. In the former case, the movable beam is located above an interrupted signal line. In the up state, an open circuit is realized which provides excellent isolation up tovery high frequencies (typical values are 60 dB at 1 GHz and 20 dB at 30 GHz). When the beam is in the down position, the two ends of the interrupted line are electrically connected, resulting in a low insertion loss, typically as low as 0.2 dB in the 0–40 GHz frequency band. In MEMS shunt switches the movable beam is used to short-circuit the transmission line by connecting the centre conductor to ground. In the up state they are extremely low loss (0.05–0.1 dB in the 0–60 GHz frequency band), since the beam hardly affects RF propagation along the line. When the switch is activated (down state), the beam short-circuits the RF signal to ground. This results in a very high insertion loss in a frequency range around the resonant frequency of the bridge (see below). 2. Capacitive and ohmic switches. The contact between the beam and the centre conductor can be either capacitive or resistive (ohmic) depending on whether a dielectric layer (usually a thin passivation layer) is employed to cover the RF signal line. Table 10.2 lists the main performances of the two solutions. 3. Cantilever and bridge (or clamped–clamped) MEMS. The suspended beam may be anchored to the substrate at one end (cantilever beam) or at both ends (clamped–clamped beam). The bridge armatures can be oriented in-line or broadside with respect to the transmission line axis. As an example, Figure 10.7a shows an in-line cantilever beam in coplanar waveguide technology, whereas a broadside clamped–clamped beam is shown in 10.7b. In both examples, the reader can observe underneath the bridges the metal pads used for electrostatic actuation.
Table 10.2 Comparison between ohmic and capacitive switches (after [10], reproduced by permission of Cambridge University Press). Ohmic Contact
On state with metal-to-metal ohmic contact Dependence Insertion loss depends on the contact resistance Operational Broad frequency coverage frequency range (DC–40 GHz) Contact lifetime Short
Capacitive OFF state with capacitive coupling Isolation depends on capacitive ratio between ON and OFF states Not suitable for frequencies lower than 4 GHz Long
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
381
Figure 10.7 In-line MEMS cantilever beam (a) and broadside MEMS clamped–clamped beam (or bridge) (b) in coplanar waveguide technology, with actuation pads.
This electrostatic actuation is realized by applying a voltage between the beam or membrane and the electrode underneath. The resulting attractive electrostatic force causes the beam to deflect towards the electrode. Using very simple mechanical models, it is found that as soon as the deflection exceeds onethird of the original beam height g0 , the bridge becomes unstable and collapses onto the down-state position. The corresponding voltage is indicated as the pull-in voltage Vpull-in . In some instances, the voltage is applied directly to the centre CPW conductor. This considerably lowers the device complexity since no separate bias circuitry is required to drive the switches, but clearly implies reduced potentialities and creates the need to separate the DC from the RF signals. The pull-in voltage of a simple clamped–clamped beam with central actuation can be expressed as: sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 8kg30 Vpull-in ¼ ð10:15Þ 27e0 A where e0 is the vacuum permittivity, A is the overlapping area between the two electrodes, g0 is the initial air gap and k is the spring constant of the movable electrode. With respect to conventional solid state devices, such as PIN diodes or MESFETs, MEMS switches offer numerous advantages, especially for RF and millimetre-wave applications: they show indeed a very low power consumption and high linearity. Typically, they have cut-off frequencies of the order of tens of terahertz and show no intermodulation effects. In addition, low insertion loss and high isolation up to 30 GHz can be achieved by a single MEMS switch. The drawbacks of this technology are essentially due to the limited switching speed, high actuation voltages and, presently, its unachieved full commercial maturity, thus limited reliability. Because of the mechanical inertia, the switching time can hardly be reduced to less than 1 ms. As far as reliability is concerned, the most common failure mechanisms are due to dielectric charging, high current densities and increased temperature in the contact area. RF MEMS can easily be integrated with passive devices, but monolithic integration with active devices is still a problem. Packaging is another critical aspect of this technology, mainly because of the high sensitivity of the suspended membrane to high temperature variations and substrate deformations that may occur when using standard packaging processes. A comparison between MEMS and alternative solid state switches is presented in Table 10.3. The CPW is the printed transmission line technology most suited to the RF MEMS switches since both conductors are located on the same plane. Therefore, we now illustrate in some detail the most popular CPW switches, namely the shunt capacitive and the series ohmic switches.
382
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Table 10.3 Comparison of the performance of RF MEMS, PIN and FET switches (after [10]). RF MEMS Insertion loss (dB) Isolation (dB) Linearity (IP3) (dBm) Actuation voltage (V) Switching speed Power consumption Power handling (dBm)
Figure 10.8 attenuation.
0.2–0.5 45 > 65 20–80 < 35 ms 10 nW 38
GaAs FET 0.7–1 25–41 24–70 3–5 < 5 ns < 5 mW 33
GaAs PHEMT 0.6–0.9 28–45 55–72 2–6 < 5 ns < 5 mW 33
GaAs PIN diode 0.3–0.6 11–22 58 5 < 50 ns > 10 mW 36
Si PIN diode 0.4–0.8 12–25 50 5 < 100 ns > 10 mW 38
Capacitive MEMS shunt switch on CPW transmission line: (a) low attenuation; (b) high
10.2.3.1 Clamped–clamped beam shunt capacitive MEMS switch Figure 10.8 shows a clamped–clamped beam shunt capacitive MEMS switch based on CPW technology in the up and down positions. The centre conductor is covered by a thin passivation layer, whose dielectric constant and thickness are er and td . Notice that no actuation pads are present in this example: the switch is actuated by applying a voltage DV directly between the bridge and the centre conductor. Typical parameters are: dielectric thickness around td ¼ 100–200 nm, dielectric constant er ¼ 4:0 7:8, bridge height g ¼ 1–5 mm, bridge length around L ¼ 250–800 mm and bridge width w ¼ 25–180 mm. When no voltage is applied, the bridge stands above the line (up state) at a height g0 and the switch is in the ON state. By applying a voltage greater than the pull-in (DV Vpull-in ), the bridge collapses onto the CPW central conductor, so increasing the bridge capacitance Cb by a factor of 10–100. Such a capacitance has the effect of short-circuiting the microwave signal to ground (OFF state). The switch behaviour can be characterized in terms of two simple equivalent circuits depending on its state, as shown in Figure 10.9. Such equivalent circuits can be derived41 on the basis of simple physical considerations and most often show very good agreement with the measurements. When the membrane is in the up state, the equivalent circuit simply consists of a shunt capacitor Cup. Its value can be calculated by a simple parallel-plate capacitance model plus a parasitic fringing capacitance: Cup ¼ e0
A g0 þ
td þ C fringing er
ð10:16Þ
where A ¼ w W is the overlapping area between the bridge and the RF line and the fringing capacitance C fringing is of the order of 20–30% of the total capacitance. This parasitic capacitance can be calculated more accurately by using electromagnetic simulators. 41
See [11].
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
383
RF signal Z0
Cup Z0
RF signal
(a)
Z0
Lb Cdown Z0 Rb
(b)
Figure 10.9 Equivalent circuits of the clamped–clamped beam capacitive shunt: (a) CPW switch in the up state (low attenuation); (b) down state (high attenuation). An ideal switch would exhibit zero up-state capacitance: typical values of Cup are of the order of a few tens of femtofarads. Such values are so small that the conduction current flowing through the bridge armature is small enough to be negligible and the equivalent circuit only contains the shunt capacitance Cup . When the membrane collapses into the down state, the bridge capacitance strongly increases from Cup to Cdown . An RF electrical current flows along the bridge with associated resistance Rb and inductance Lb . The bridge capacitance can be expressed simply as Cdown ¼ e0 er
A td
ð10:17Þ
In the down state the fringing capacitance can be neglected because of the small dielectric thickness. On the contrary, the actual capacitance is in practice much lower than predicted by (10.17) because the surface roughness and the imperfect bridge flatness produce small air gaps between the bridge and the passivation layer. Lb and Rb should be calculated by using a parameter fitting from full wave simulations or measured data. Typical Lb values are of the order of a few picohenries, while Rb is of the order of 0.1–0.3 O. Note that in the down state the bridge behaves as a series resonator with impedance given by Zb ¼ Rb þ joLb þ
1 joCdown
ð10:18Þ
At the resonant frequency f0 of the shunt switch f0 ¼
1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2p Lb Cdown
ð10:19Þ
the bridge impedance reaches its minimum value Rb and the switch exhibits its maximum isolation. By properly designing the bridge geometry (thus Lb and Cdown ) it is possible to place the resonant frequency in the required operational band so as to obtain very good isolations even at millimetre-wave frequencies. Typical responses of a shunt switch in the up and down positions are shown in Figure 10.10, which also shows a photograph of the structure.
10.2.3.2 Clamped–clamped series MEMS switch In the clamped–clamped beam series switch, the metal membrane is isolated from the coplanar ground planes and suspended above a gap created in the signal line. A series switch in the up and down state is shown in Figure 10.11. Notice, in this case, the presence of the metal pads used for applying the actuating voltage between the bridge and the electrodes underneath. When the beam is in the up state (Figure 10.11a), the gap provides a very high and wide-band isolation from DC up to 40 GHz. In the down state (Figure 10.11b) the beam creates a short circuit across the gap and the RF signal is allowed to propagate along the CPW. The series switch behaviour can be modelled in terms of the two equivalent circuits shown in Figures 10.12a and 10.12b for the down state and up state respectively.42 42
See [11].
384
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 10.10 Shunt capacitive MEMS switch: (a) photograph; (b) measured performance of (a) in up state; (c) measured performance in the down state [12]. (Reproduced by permission of EuMA.)
Figure 10.11
Coplanar ohmic contact series switch: (a) down state; (b) up state.
RF signal Coff RF signal (a)
Z0
Z1 Cp
Ron
Coff Z0
Z0
Z1 Cp
R on Z0
(b)
Figure 10.12 Equivalent lumped element circuits of the clamped–clamped beam series ohmic contact switch: (a) down state; (b) up state.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
385
Figure 10.13 Capacitive MEMS switch: (a) photograph; (b) measured performance in the up state; (c) measured performance in the down state [3]. (Reproduced by permission of EuMA.) Cp is the series capacitance across the gap and Z1 is the short line section constituted by the beam connecting the two centre conductor ends. The element Ron is the down-state contact resistance between the metal beam and the centre conductor. The most critical aspect of the series switch is the minimization of this series resistance, which can significantly deteriorate the insertion loss. Different solutions for improving the metal-to-metal contacts have been proposed, such as the use of small dimples in the beam bottom surface or the use of noble metals and alloys covering the contact areas. In the up state, the series resistances Ron are replaced by the series capacitances Coff between the open ends and the beam. Such capacitance is the main limiting factor of the isolation of the series switch. Series ohmic contact MEMS switches are often realized by using cantilever beams placed in line with respect to the transmission line. This has the advantage of halving the contact resistance Ron , but, on the other hand, cantilever beams are more difficult to manufacture. As an example, the photograph and the response of a typical series ohmic switch are shown in Figure 10.13.
10.2.4
Alternative multi-port switch structures
This section gives a brief description of some possible configurations of switching networks, at both the circuit and subsystem level. Figure 10.14a shows the schematic of an absorptive SPST. As anticipated, the adjective ‘absorptive’ denotes a switch whose ports are always matched, independently of the selected one. That network has a structure similar to the one in Figures 10.2b and 10.3a. Apart from the number of shunt switching elements – which has no conceptual meaning in this context – the main difference
386
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 50 Ω P1
SW1
TL1
TL3
TL2 SW2
SW4
P2
SW3
(a)
P1
P2 (b)
TL2 SW1
TL1 TL3
P3
SW2
Figure 10.14 Alternative switch configurations: (a) absorptive SPDT sections; (b) SPDT realized with shunt elements only. consists of the addition of the series element SW4 , shunted by a 50 O resistor. In the transmitting state SW1 , SW4 (SW2 , SW3 ) are ON (OFF), thus the 50 O resistor is bypassed and has no influence. In the isolated state SW1 , SW4 (SW2 , SW3 ) are OFF (ON), thus, looking at port P2 , we ideally see a 50 O resistor in series with a short-circuit stub TL3. Now, if TL3 is much shorter than a quarter of wavelength, and the ON impedance of SW4 is negligible, or if these elements are such as to compensate each other, then P2 presents an impedance close to 50 O. In other words, P2 is always matched in both the transmitting and isolating state: the SPST in Figure 10.14a is absorptive. If we replace the network in Figure 10.2b with the one in Figure 10.14a the network resulting from Figure 10.14a is an absorptive SPnT. The main drawback of the network in Figure 10.14a is related to the 50 O bypassed switching element SW4 : it presents finite ON resistance and its OFF resistance is closer to 50 O than to infinity. This worsens the insertion loss, without significantly increasing the isolation. All the SPnTs presented so far include series switching elements, which are needed to make the disabled ways present an open circuit at the junction point. The main drawback of the series element is that it ideally has to be totally floating from ground. No electrical conduction path should be present between any of its two terminals and ground: neither AC nor DC, and in no state. Generally, low electrical conduction involves low thermal conduction as well. Thus it is difficult to remove the heat produced by RF and DC power dissipated inside the series switching element. This condition impacts on the maximum non-destructive power43 for the SPnT. The SPDT configuration in Figure 10.14b circumvents this problem by eliminating the series elements. Such a configuration is based on the short- to open-circuit transformation operated by a l=4 transmission line; therefore it is suitable for narrow bandwidths. In order to explain how the circuit works, we will initially assume that: .
The transmission line TL1 is infinitely short.
.
TL2 , TL3 are 50 O l=4 transmission lines at the centre of the working frequency band f0 .
.
The switching elements SW1 , SW2 are ideal, presenting a short circuit (open circuit) in the ON (OFF) state.
43 For instance, the destructive power of the SPDT in Figure 10.4 is not enough to produce 1 dB of compression. In other words, the switch is damaged by a power which is in the quasi-linear range of the component.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS R s= 0.1 Ω 1Ω 2Ω 10
← s21
0
387
-20 0
-10
In-band return-loss -6
-20
s11 →
-60 -80
20 log10(|s31|)
s31→
-4
-40 20 log10(|s11|)
20 log10(|s21|)
-2
-100
-8
-30
-10
-40
-120 2
4
6
Figure 10.15
8
10 12 14 16 Frequency, GHz
18
20
22
24
Quasi-ideal performances of the SPDT in Figure 10.8b.
The SPDT has two possible states: (I) SW1 ON with SW2 OFF; or (II) SW1 OFF with SW2 ON. In condition (I), P2 is isolated from P1 , and, at f0 , TL1 transforms the short circuit produced by SW1 into an open circuit on the common port. This way, P3 is connected to P1 by a simple matched line, with no effect from SW1 and SW2 . If we consider condition (II), we have the same result, just by swapping P2 and P3 . Therefore SPDT in Figure 10.8b has zero insertion loss and infinite isolation in the ideal case and at the centre frequency. As the frequency moves from f0 the unselected way presents a non-zero impedance to the common port, degrading the insertion loss and return loss. Moreover, the switching elements are also non-ideal; rather, they present finite impedances in both of their states, further degrading the performance of the component. In real implementations of the circuit, the transmission line TL1 has the same electrical length and characteristic impedance – lower than 50 O – as TL2 and TL3 . This arrangement improves the matching of the network in a finite frequency bandwidth. The optimum characteristic impedance ZOPT of the lines, for any required bandwidth, can be found by optimization. Note that the result depends only on the relative bandwidth and not on the centre frequency. Figure 10.15 shows the simulated response44 of the SPDT in Figure 10.14b optimized to work in the frequency range 6–18 GHz, with the resulting ZOPT ¼ 33:7 O. The presented curves are obtained by assuming the lines are loss free, the OFF switching element is an ideal open circuit, and the ON impedance is a pure resistance of 0.1, 1 and 2 O. Note that the in-band return loss is slightly better than 17 dB. The achievable return loss of the structure and the optimum line impedance are decreasing functions of the working fractional bandwidth Df = f0 : Figure 10.16 shows those two parameters as obtained by optimization. The performances of a real component are worse than Figure 10.15 shows, due to the finite impedance of the switching elements, the transmission line loss and the bias networks. Nonetheless,
44
See the Ansoft file 02_Shunt_Only_SPDT.adsn.
388
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 70 60 In-band Return-Loss 50 40 30 Z OPT 20 10 0 20
40
60
80
100
120
Percent relative bandwidth (100 ∆f/f0 )
Figure 10.16
Optimum parameters for the SPDT in Figure 10.8.
by using PIN diodes as switching elements, reasonable performances across the whole frequency range 6–18 GHz could be: .
maximum insertion loss: 1.5 dB
.
minimum return loss: 14 dB
.
minimum isolation: 25 dB
.
maximum input power: 5 W (non-destructive).
A further advantage deriving from the elimination of the series element is the simplification of the bias network. Figure 10.17 shows some switch architectures using SPDT as building blocks. The configuration in Figure 10.17a uses three SPDTs to realize one SP4T. It can be seen that P1 can be connected to any of P2 to P5 by properly setting SPDT1 to SPDT3. SP4T has four different states. The architecture in Figure 10.11a has three SPDTs, each having two states: the total number of states is then 23 ¼ 8. This discrepancy is only apparent because the network in Figure 10.11a has some redundant states: when SPDT1 is in position 1 (2) the selected port can be only P2 or P3 (P4 or P5), regardless of the position of SPDT3 (SPDT2). However, such state redundancy can be used to increase the isolation at some ports. The configuration in Figure 10.17b uses three reflective SPDTs and two 50 O terminations to realize one absorptive SPDT. All of SPDT1 to SPDT3 are in the same position 1 or 2. In the first (latter) case P2 (P3 ) is selected and P3 (P2 ) is terminated on 50 O: therefore all the ports are matched, independently of the state, as needed. The additional SPDT present in both the paths from P1 to P2 and P3 increases the insertion loss and also the isolation of the architecture. The configuration in Figure 10.17c is known as a transfer switch; it uses four SPDTs, all with the same control. All of SPDT1 to SPDT4 are in the same position 1 or 2. In the first (latter) case P1 is connected to P2 and P3 to P4 (P1 is connected to P3 and P2 to P4). Summarizing, we can say that any couple of non-adjacent ports of the transfer switch can be connected to its left or right neighbour. Figure 10.18 shows one important application of the transfer switch. The proposed arrangement works as a bidirectional amplifier, in that the input can be one between P1 and P2 while the other is the
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
SPDT1
P1
(a)
SPDT3
1
P2
1
2
P3
2
1
P4
SPDT2
2
P5
50 Ω
2
389
SPDT3
P2 SPDT1
P1
1 1 2 2
SPDT2
P3
50 Ω 1
(b)
P2 1
SPDT1 P1
2
1
SPDT2
2
SPDT3
P3 1
2 (c)
1
SPDT4
P4
Figure 10.17 Special multi-port switch connections: (a) SP4T formed with a branched chain of three SPDTs; (b) absorptive SPDT comprising three reflective SPDTs and two matched terminations; (c) transfer switch. output. Thus, we can amplify from P1 to P2 , or vice versa, by selecting the SPDT position. The architecture in Figure 10.18 requires that the transfer switch isolation be higher than the amplifier gain by a safe margin, in order to avoid instabilities.45
10.3 Variable attenuators Section 6.4 describes fixed attenuators, also providing an analysis and synthesis formulae. Here we will deal with variable attenuators that present a variable attenuation, which depends on some control variables. 45
See Section 8.4.
390
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
1
P1
2
SPDT2
SPDT3
1
2 P3
SPDT1 2
1
1 SPDT4
AMP1
Figure 10.18
Transfer switch application for a bidirectional amplifier.
High-frequency equipment widely uses variable attenuators to change the output power in RF sources, or to adjust the dynamic range in receivers. Also, variable attenuators have more similarities with switches than with fixed attenuators, which is why we placed such components in this chapter. The two main types of variable attenuators are: .
Continuously variable attenuators, which realize any attenuation within a specified range, with a monotonic relation with one control voltage or current.
.
Step-controlled attenuators (SCAs), which have finite attenuation values, usually set by a digital control word.
Continuously variable attenuators employ PIN diodes (FETs) as current (voltage) variable resistors, similar to the switches described in Section 10.2. The main difference between an SPST and a continuously variable attenuator is that the latter uses all the conduction states of its semiconductor devices, not just the fully conducting and fully interdicted ones. The equivalent networks to consider for the attenuator devices are the linear ones, discussed in Section 9.7.1. The model in Figure 9.34a is suitable for the PIN diode as it is. On the other hand, the FETworks with no DC drain–source voltage in switch and variable attenuators, which then have zero transconductance; this type of operation defines the so-called cold FET. The cold FET linear model derives from the one of Figure 9.34b, after eliminating the VCCS. Attenuator device models cannot be simplified to the simple series or parallel networks considered for the switch, at least not in intermediate conduction states. The effect of all the parasitic elements can be precisely evaluated by computer simulations. However, we can say that variable attenuators employ variable resistors, therefore they work until the parasitic reactance is negligible with respect to the incremental resistance of each device. Section 10.2.1 discussed the relation between incremental resistance and DC (gate–source voltage) current in PIN diodes (FETs). For PIN diodes, we need to add that semiconductor manufacturers provide devices specifically tailored for applications in continuous variable attenuators. The peculiar characteristic of such diodes is their incremental resistance vs. the DC curve, which is as smooth as possible, with no high-slope regions. This minimizes the criticality in the DC setting. The main drawback of attenuator PIN diodes is their relatively slow response to variations in the attenuation-setting DC curves: PIN attenuators are typically one order of magnitude slower than their switch counterparts operating at the same frequency and power.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS (T1)
(T3)
RV
P1
391
RV
P2
(T2) RV
(a) (Π2)
RV
P1
(Π 1)
3) R(Π V
RV
P2
(b) C5
P1
TL1
50 Ω
C50Ω,1 L4 C2
D1
L1
I2 C50Ω,2 50 Ω
TL2
C3
L2
D2
L3
L5
L6
D3
P2
L7
I1 C1
(c)
P1
TL1
50 Ω
C4
TL2
Q1 Q2 R1
(d)
V1
TL3
50 Ω Q4
TL4
P2
Q3 R2
R3
R4
V2
Figure 10.19 Variable attenuators: (a) ideal T network; (b) ideal P network; (c) PIN diode realization; (d) FET realization.
In principle, a continuously variable attenuator is nothing more than a fixed attenuator – in T or P configuration – where controlled variable resistors replace fixed ones. Under this concept, the schematics in Figures 7.5a,b transform into the ones in Figures 10.19a,b. From a realization point of view, each variable resistor in such ideal schematics is one PIN diode or one FET with the associated bias networks. Figures 10.19c,d show two realizations of the T attenuators, based on the PIN and FET, respectively. ðT1Þ ðT2Þ ðT3Þ The diodes D1 , D2 and D3 in Figure 10.19c correspond to RV , RV and RV , respectively, in Figure 10.19a. The various inductors deliver the current to the three diodes as: .
L1 , L2 and L3 for D1
.
L4 for D2
.
L5 , L6 and L7 for D3.
392
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The inductances and parasitic impedances of these inductors have a minimum impact on the transmission of the RF signal, similar to the switches discussed in Section 10.2.1. Again, the capacitors C2 and C3 prevent the current to one diode from flowing in other ones or in the RF ports, while C1 , C4 and C5 dampen the residual RF signal on the driving ports to ground. As noted in Section 7.4, T or P attenuators are symmetrical, and so ideally should the network be in Figure 10.13c. Thus D1 should be identical to D3 and their currents should be identical as well. For this reason, the schematic in Figure 10.19c assumes that one single generator supplies the current for the two shunt diodes. The inductors L3 , L5 supply additional RF isolation in the DC path from D1 to D3 . As discussed in Section 10.2.2 for the FET SPST, bias networks introduce crosstalk, which compromises the maximum isolation. Applying the same considerations to the attenuator, we find that bias network crosstalk – which is frequency dependent by definition – compromises the attenuation flatness, particularly at high attenuation. In real cases, D1 and D3 are not perfectly identical; then the lower impedance device would absorb the majority of the current, degrading the circuit symmetry. A simple way to ameliorate this malfunctioning is to add two resistors46 in series with L3 and L5 . The added resistor also provides additional attenuation for the bias network crosstalk. The network in Figure 10.19c presents two RC series cells in shunt with D1 and D3 ; their presence is a consequence of the required resistances at the different attenuations. The two capacitors in series with these resistors are large enough to ensure that the latter are parallel with the series diodes at high frequencies,47 while insulating the resistors from the DC path. Equations48 (7.9) give RT1 ðAÞ ¼ RT3 ðAÞ ¼ 50
1 10 0:05A ; 1 þ 10 0:05A
RT2 ðAÞ ¼ 100
10 0:05A 1 10 0:1A
ð10:20Þ
where A is the attenuation in dB. Now, from Equation (10.20) it follows that RT1 ðA ¼ 0Þ ¼ RT3 ðA ¼ 0Þ ¼ 0; lim RT1 ðAÞ ¼ lim RT3 ðAÞ ¼ 50;
A!1
A!1
lim RT2 ðAÞ ¼ 1
A!0
lim RT2 ðAÞ ¼ 0
ð10:21Þ
A!1
Therefore, the incremental resistance of D2 ranges over all its possible range, from zero to infinity, and the minimum resistance of the devices used determines the upper limit on A. On the other hand, the incremental resistance of D1 and D3 has a much narrower variation range, from zero to 50 O, and its minimum possible value affects the minimum achievable attenuation. Moreover, the useful range of the direct current on D1 and D3 is quite limited, making the setting of a proper value a quite difficult task. The two 50 O resistors alleviate this difficulty, because, now, the parallel resistor of 50 O with the incremental resistance of D1 and D3 , not the latter alone, must be equal to 50 O at the maximum attenuation. Consequently, the two series diodes can use the whole current range, consistently reducing the criticality of the current driving. The main drawback of the added components is the parasitic reactance they involve, which reduces the maximum working frequency of the attenuator. Note that the absorptive SPST in Figure 10.14a also uses a similar configuration in the last series switching element. The variable FET attenuator in Figure 10.19d has a structure similar to the SPST in Figure 10.3c. The main variations consist of the addition of the series FET Q4 close to the RF port P2 , and the two 50 O resistors, placed between the source and drain of the two series elements. The bias configuration in Figure 10.19d is almost the same as the one in Figure 10.3c. The same voltage V1 drives the gates of both Q1 and Q4 ; the considerations on the bias resistors presented in Section 10.2.2 hold true, and will not be
46 The best solution should consist of separating the currents supplied to D1 and D3. This solution, however, complicates the circuit driving, in that it requires three nonlinear dependent currents, instead of two. 47 If flow is the minimum working frequency, then 2p flow C50 O 1=50 must apply. 48 Derived assuming a generic normalization resistance, not simply 50 O as we have now.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
393
repeated. The two 50 O resistors in parallel with the series elements work to extend the usable range of the source–drain incremental resistance, in the same way as discussed for the circuit in Figure 10.19c. By comparing PIN and FET continuously variable attenuators, we obtain more or less the same pros and cons as for switches. PINs have better minimum insertion loss, higher maximum attenuation and higher power handling. FETs have faster response and absorb no power from the driver. By comparing SPST and continuously variable attenuators, realized with the same technology and working at the same frequencies, we find that the attenuator has higher minimum attenuation than the absorptive SPST, which is higher than in the reflective SPDT. Moreover, continuously variable attenuators have lower power handling than their switch counterparts, particularly at intermediate attenuation. Indeed, device junctions can rectify RF signals and self-bias the device itself, modifying its incremental resistance. A description of continuously variable attenuators is not complete without considering the problem of DC driving. A detailed examination of the problem and of possible circuit solutions is well beyond the purposes of this book. Nevertheless, some brief considerations will give a picture of the difficulties, and justify the exploration of different attenuator architectures, where possible. Series and shunt elements have to realize precise resistance values at each attenuation, as in Equations (10.15). Given the required incremental resistance, the device characteristic determines the corresponding control quantity. For PIN diodes, inverting Equation49 (10.4) and substituting the result into (10.20), 1 0 B I1 ¼ 2B @
C n VT IS C A; 1 10 0:05A 50 Rs 1 þ 10 0:05A
I2 ¼
n VT IS 10 0:05A 100 Rs 1 10 0:1A
ð10:22Þ
The factor 2 in the first equation of (10.22) takes into account that the current I1 drives both the series diodes D1 , D3 in Figure 10.13c. From a similar procedure, inverting Equation (10.13) or (10.14), and substituting the result into (10.20), we obtain the voltages for the attenuator in Figure 10.19d, realized with a MESFET or MOSFET ðMESFET Þ
V1
1 ¼ sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi þ Vp ; 1 10 0:05A a b 50 1 þ 10 0:05A
ðMOSFET Þ
V1
¼
1 1 þ 10 0:05A þ VTH ; b 50 1 10 0:05A
ðMESFET Þ
1 ¼ sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi þ Vp 10 0:05A a b 50 1 10 0:1A
ðMOSFET Þ
¼
V2
V2
1 1 10 0:1A þ VTH b 50 10 0:05A
ð10:23Þ
ð10:24Þ
where we have considered that V2 drives two transistors (Q2 and Q3 ) whose parallel realizes the shunt resistance RT2. Although Equations (10.4), (10.13) and (10.14) are quite approximate, none of the relations (10.17) to (10.19) give linear or simple driving laws. Furthermore, all the latter three equations contains nonlinear parameters of the devices, thus the driving curves can vary from piece to piece. Figure 10.20a shows a block diagram of a possible analogue driver, where two nonlinear transfer characteristics y1 and y2 generate the driving quantities from the external control voltage. The design, setup and alignment of the driver in Figure 10.20a are quite difficult. Furthermore, the differences from device to device may require manual adjustments to each individual attenuator, on a case-by-case basis. Additional difficulties for the attenuator driving arise from the temperature dependence of the relations (10.22) to (10.24). Equation (10.22) explicitly includes the temperature-dependent factor 49 Equation (10.4) is not rigorously valid for PIN diodes. Nevertheless, it has a simple analytic form and gives a qualitatively valid relation between the current and incremental resistance of the device.
394
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
VCONTROL= vin
y1 (vin)
V1, or I1
y2 (vin)
V2, or I2
(a)
DWCONTROL
ROM 1
D/A 1
V1, or I1
ROM 2
D/A 1
V2 , or I2
ROM1
D/A1
V1, or I1
ROM2
D/A1
V2, or I2
(b)
VCONTROL
A/D
(c) analog signals
digital signals
Figure 10.20 Variable attenuator drivers: (a) full analogue; (b) for digital control; (c) digital with analogue input control. VT , and the parameters a; b; Vp ; VTH , of Equations (10.23) and (10.25), which are temperature dependent as well. Figure 10.20b shows a less critical solution, assuming that the attenuator control is a digital word rather than a continuously varying voltage. The combination of such a driver with a continuously variable attenuator realizes an SCA. Each digital control word corresponds to a nominal attenuation. Typically 00 . . . 0 ð11 . . . 1Þ corresponds to the minimum (maximum) attenuation with a linear staircase relation. The two digital-to-analogue converters (DACs) or (D/As) D=A1 , D=A2 generate the corresponding series and shunt driving quantity required. Two read-only memories ROM1 , ROM2 implement the nonlinear relations (10.22) to (10.24): their input (address) is the external control word, while the output (data) is the binary representation of the corresponding driving quantity. The main advantage of the digital solution is that any adjustment requires changed data to be stored in memory, rather than substitution of the components as in the analogue case. Normally, a computer-aided alignment procedure finds the optimum data to store in the ROM, by setting a value, measuring the attenuator and adjusting – if needed – before storing. One additional advantage of the digital solution with respect to the analogue one is the possibility to implement temperature-dependent look-up tables, by including in the ROM address some bits connected to a temperature sensor.50
50
See [9] for more details.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS 1
395
s11(RV) s 12 (RV) s21(RV) s 22 (RV)
RV, 2
(a) hybrid1 1
P1
hybrid2 2
0°
1
RV,1
90° 90°
50Ω 3
0°
4
2
0°
50Ω
90° 90°
3
0°
4
P2
RV,2 (b)
P1 s21(R1)
0.5
a1
0.5
s22 (R1) j
0.5
s11(R1)
j
0
0.5 0.5
b1 0.5
s12(R 1) s21 (R2)
P2 0.5
b2
0.5
0
j
0.5
Figure 10.21 graph of (b).
j
0.5
s11(R 2) 0.5
(c)
s22(R2)
s12 (R2)
a2 0.5
Shunt resistor only attenuator: (a) basic cell; (b) matched attenuator; (c) signal flow
Figure 10.20c shows a digital configuration emulating an analogue one. One analogue-to-digital converter (ADC) or (A/D) transforms the external continuously varying control voltage into a corresponding digital word. From the output of the A/D up to RF devices the diagram in Figure 10.20c coincides with the one in Figure 10.20b. The configuration in Figure 10.14c circumvents the difficulties involved with the analogue nonlinear transfer characteristic, but realizes a staircase rather than a true continuous relation between the control voltage and attenuation. When digital or pseudo-linear control is not acceptable, and the high-frequency bandwidth is relatively narrow, a solution with shunt elements only – and thus with a single driving quantity – can be used. If we simply remove the series resistors from the T attenuator we obtain the simple two-port network in Figure 10.21a. Its scattering matrix derives from Equation (7.4) with the simplification RT1 ¼ RT3 ¼ 0 1 s11 ðRV Þ s12 ðRV Þ 50 2RV ¼ ð10:25Þ s21 ðRV Þ s22 ðRV Þ 2RV þ 50 2RV 50 From this equation it follows that the network in Figure 10.21a achieves any transmission coefficient between zero and one when the shunt resistance varies from zero to infinity. Unfortunately, the reflection
396
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
coefficient is also a function of the shunt resistance, and becomes unitary if RV ¼ 0. Inverting the relation between s21 and RV in Equation (10.25) and substituting the result into s11 in the same equation, we obtain s11 ¼ 1 s21
ð10:26Þ
which implies that the return loss decreases with the attenuation and becomes better than 10 dB, i.e. js11 j 10 0:5 ffi 0:316 when s21 1 10 0:5 ffi 0:684, corresponding to a maximum attenuation of A ¼ 20log10 ðjs21 jÞ ffi 3:3 dB. Such an attenuator should have quite a few applications because of its poor impedance matching and/ or limited attenuation range. Figure 10.20b shows an arrangement with two attenuators of the type in Figure 10.20a, placed between two 90 hybrid couplers. That configuration inherently provides low (ideally zero) reflection coefficients at the RF ports P1 and P2 as can easily be demonstrated by analyzing the SFG of the network, shown in Figure 10.20c. The reflection coefficient at P1 is, by definition, the ratio of the reflected (b1 ) and incident (a1 ) waves to that port, when the incident wave on P2 is zero. From a1 to b1 we have two paths, each having three branches. The resulting reflection coefficient is then pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð10:27Þ s11 ¼ 0:5 s11 RV;1 0:5 þ j 0:5 s11 RV;2 j 0:5 ¼ s11 RV;1 s11 RV;2 The anti-symmetry of the network implies that the reflection coefficient at P2 is s22 ¼ s22 RV;2 s22 RV;1
ð10:28Þ
Equations (10.27) and (10.28) imply that if RV;1 ¼ RV;2 then s11 ¼ s22 ¼ 0. Thus, if the two shunt resistors are identical, ports P1 , P2 of the network in Figure 10.20b are perfectly matched. For the transmission coefficient, we still have two paths, each having three branches, which give pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi s21 RV;1 þ s21 RV;2 ð10:29Þ s21 ¼ 0:5 s21 RV;1 j 0:5 þ j 0:5 s21 RV;2 0:5 ¼ j 2 Thus, the resulting transmission coefficient is the arithmetic mean of those of the two unmatched attenuators.51 If RV;1 ¼ RV;2 from Equation (10.29) it follows that the attenuation of the network in Figure 10.20b coincides with that of the circuit in Figure 10.20a, apart from the dissipation loss of the two hybrids, which have been not considered. The derivation of Equations (10.28) and (10.29) implies no assumptions on the S parameters of the two two-port networks placed between the two hybrids. Then, in the arrangement of Figure 10.20b, with two identical two-port networks placed between the two 90 hybrid couplers: .
The reflection coefficient at the RF ports P1 , P2 is zero.
.
The magnitude of the transmission coefficient from P1 , P2 equals that of the two identical two-port networks.
These properties have important applications in amplifiers, as Section 11.5.4 will show. The configuration with 90 hybrids has the important property of requiring one single control voltage or current, while guaranteeing good impedance matching. Its main drawback is the need for two hybrid couplers, which are significantly larger than the conventional series elements, introduce additional loss and – above all – are inherently limited in bandwidth. Section 6.7 illustrates two types of 90 hybrids which are widely used in engineering practice: the branch line and the Lange coupler,52 which have a fractional bandwidth53 of about 20% and 100%, respectively. 51 The Ansoft file 03_Shunt_Resistor_Attenuator.adsn provides a simple description of the attenuator in Figure 10.15b, assuming a coupled line realization of the hybrids. 52 See Section 7.7.3 53 The fractional bandwidth is defined as 100 Df =f0 , where D f ¼ f2 f1 , f0 ¼ ðf2 þ f1 Þ=2 and f1 ; f2 are the limits of the bandwidth.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
P1
SW1
SW3
RT,1
RT,3
RT,2
397
P2
SW2 (a) SW2
P2
P1 R Π,1
R Π,2
SW1
R Π,3 SW3
(b)
AdB 1
1
P2
P1 2
(c)
Figure 10.22
2
vCONTROL
Binary attenuators: (a) T cell; (b) P cell; (c) switched cell.
The combination of a continuously variable attenuator with a digital driver, like that in Figure 10.20b, is an SCA, as anticipated. Here, however, we will consider other attenuator circuits which inherently have discrete attenuation values; all of them are combinations of fixed attenuators and switches. Figure 10.22 shows three configurations of attenuators with only two possible attenuation values, or binary attenuators. All of them exhibit an attenuation variable from a minimum (ideally zero) and a specified maximum (ideally flat over the frequency) value. In more detail, Figure 10.22 shows: (a) Binary T attenuator. The two switching elements SW1 and SW3 are always in the same state, which is opposite to that of SW2 . If SW1 ¼ SW3 ¼ ON and SW2 ¼ OFF then the two series resistors RT,1, RT,3 are short-circuited and the shunt resistor RT,2 is disconnected from ground, working like an open circuit. The insertion loss in this condition is ideally zero, but in real cases is higher, due to the parasitic elements in the resistors and switching elements with the associated bias networks. Under the opposite condition, SW1 ¼ SW3 ¼ OFF and SW2 ¼ ON , the series resistors are not bypassed and the shunt resistor is connected to ground. Thus, the attenuator works like a passive fixed one. The series resistance of SW2 sets a lower limit on the effective shunt resistance, thus an upper limit on the attenuation. The parasitic-caused loss sets a lower limit on the minimum attenuation. (b) Binary P attenuator. This is the dual of (a), with a consequent opposite switch actuation logic. The same considerations for the parasitic effect apply, and will not be repeated.
398
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING (c) Switched binary attenuator. Two SPDTs sharing the same control signal select two possible paths between the two RF ports: one path has one attenuator with attenuation AdB , the other path is a direct connection between the two switches. If the two SPDTs are in position 1, the attenuation between the two RF ports is AdB plus the one resulting from the two switches. In the non-attenuating position (both SPDTs in position 2), the insertion loss is the sum of those of the two SPDTs. In the attenuated position (1), there is, however, a parasitic transmission via the non-selected ports of the SPDT, due to the finite isolation of the latter. That parasitic transmission has to present an attenuation much greater than AdB , otherwise the relative attenuation between the two states is not controllable.54 Therefore the isolation of each SPDT must be much higher than AdB =2. This configuration offers the maximum design flexibility: the fixed attenuator could be of any type, the switching elements do not affect the attenuation flatness, and there is no theoretical limit on the maximum attenuation, provided there is enough isolation in the switches. The main drawback is the presence of two SPDTs on the signal path, even at no nominal attenuation. The associated loss is between 2 and 6 dB, depending on the switch technology and on the required maximum attenuation.55
The binary switches can be used as standalone, when only one selectable attenuation is needed, or in combination with other similar components, to build a multiple step attenuator. Figure 10.23a shows an arrangement with N cascaded binary attenuators, each of them having a separate control signal, or bit. All the cells in this schematic are of the type in Figure 10.22c, although any of the three solutions of Figure 10.22 could be used. Thus the schematic in Figure 10.23a is a purely conceptual representation: each cell has two states, one with minimum attenuation (ideally zero) and one with a specified attenuation; furthermore, there is one single command signal per cell. Let us assign the logical values 0 and 1 to each control quantity VCNTRL;k ðk ¼ 1; 2; . . . ; N Þ . If VCNTRL;k ¼ 1 or 0 the SPDT of the kth cell is in position 1 or 2, and thus in the first (latter) case we insert an attenuation of 2k 1 AdB (0) inside the path from P1 to P2 . The two extreme conditions are VCNTRL;1 ; VCNTRL;2 ; . . . ; VCNTRL;N ¼ 0; 0; . . . ; 0 and VCNTRL;1 ; VCNTRL;2 ; . . . ; VCNTRL;N ¼ 1; 1; . . . ; 1. In the first case, the only loss in the RF path is the one coming from the switches;56 in the latter case, there is an additional loss of ! N X N 1 k1 AdB ¼ 2N 1 AdB AMAX ¼ AdB þ 2AdB þ þ 2 AdB ¼ 2 ð10:30Þ k¼1
Also, it is easy to recognize that, by changing the control bits, it is possible to obtain 2N discrete attenuation values bound between zero and AMAX , and spaced by the step AdB . Furthermore, the resulting attenuation is proportional to the digital word VCNTRL;1 ; VCNTRL;2 ; . . . ; VCNTRL;N , which therefore assumes the function of a digital control word. The architecture in Figure 10.23a is elegant, requires no complicated drivers, is inherently temperature stable and produces lower nonlinear distortion than the solutions based on continuously variable attenuators. Its main drawback is its minimum insertion loss, caused by 4 N cascaded SPDTs, or by 3 N resistor-removing switching elements. That loss depends on many factors, like the technology used, the working frequency and the maximum attenuation; as a rule of thumb, we can assume from 1 to 7 dB per binary cell. 54 Crosstalk varies with frequency, therefore it causes frequency-dependent variations on the attenuation, degrading the flatness over frequency. 55 Maximum attenuation affects the switch isolation, as shown. The higher the attenuation, the higher the required isolation, then the higher the number of switching elements and, finally, the higher the insertion loss. Therefore binary cells with small values of AdB require low isolation from the switches, and potentially allow low attenuation in the minimum loss state. 56 Or, more generally, the residual minimum attenuation of all the binary cells, if some of them have the configuration in Figure 10.16a or 10.16b.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS A dB
399
2 N-1AdB
2•A dB
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
P1
P2
VCONTROL,1
(a)
VCONTROL,2 2
3 •AdB
3•2• AdB
2•AdB
2•2•A dB
2
1
P1 4
1 2 3
VCONTROL,N
A dB
2 3
4
1
4
1 2 3
2
1•2•AdB
2 3
P2 4
VCONTROL,1 VCONTROL,2 VCONTROL,3 VCONTROL,4
(b)
Figure 10.23
Multi-bit digital attenuators: (a) with binary cells; (b) with quaternary cells.
The configuration in Figure 10.23b works in the same way as the one in Figure 10.22a, at least from an external point of view, but alleviates the minimum loss problem by halving the number of switches along the chain. The building block of the architecture in Figure 10.23b is a four-state (or quaternary) attenuator, rather than a binary one, and has two control bits. One quaternary cell is equivalent to two cascaded binary cells, both realizing all the integer multiples from zero to three of an assigned attenuation. Therefore, the configuration in Figure 1023b derives from the one in Figure 10.23a by regrouping two adjacent binary cells into a quaternary one. The minimum loss in the solution in Figure 10.17b is slightly higher than the one in Figure 10.17a, because the SP4T has higher loss than the SPST realized with the same technology. Figure 10.24 shows the attenuation of a 4-bit SCA, implementing the architecture in Figure 10.23b, with two quaternary cells, each with PIN diode SP4T. The working frequency range is 2–20 GHz and the displayed attenuation is normalized to the reference 0 dB state. In the minimum attenuation, the insertion loss of the attenuator is about 6, 5 and 7 dB at 2, 12 and 20 GHz, while the return loss is better than 12 dB in all the states. The 1 dB compression input power is about 1 W ( þ 30 dBm) and the switching time is less than 150 ns, from 50% of the control bit voltage to 90% of the RF output power. The whole discussion on variable attenuators pointed out some key aspects of their working principles and characteristics: 1. A variable attenuator realizes some attenuation values from zero to an assigned maximum. The zero attenuation state is characterized by a non-zero insertion loss, thus a minimum insertion loss has to be specified for the component. 2. The attenuation at each state differs from the nominal value and is frequency dependent as well. Therefore attenuation error and flatness over the frequency must be specified.
400
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 0 -4
20 log10(|s21/s21,REF|)
-8 -12 -16 -20 -24 -28 -32 2
Figure 10.24
4
6
8
10 12 14 Frequency, GHz
16
18
20
Measured response of a 4-bit SCA, having the configuration of Figure 10.23b.
3. Variable attenuators based on continuously variable high-frequency devices are inherently temperature dependent, and this behaviour needs to be specified. 4. The SCA implementing the architectures in Figure 10.23 could be non-monotonic. For instance, let us consider the first case, and assume we pass from the attenuation of ð1 þ 2 þ 22 þ þ 2N 2 ÞAdB to the next step, which is 2N 1 AdB . The two values are obtained by totally different chains. If the cells from 1 to N 1 present higher attenuation than their nominal value, the last cell presents lower attenuation than the nominal one. In this case, it could happen that the attenuation decreases instead of increasing, passing from the first to the second state. The monotonic behaviour is a requirement to be specified, if needed. 5. As for any component employing semiconductor devices, variable attenuators produce nonlinear distortion. A maximum input power exists that guarantees a specified distortion level, and a nondestructive limit exists as well. 6. Variable attenuators require a finite settling time, as any variable-state component. 7. Variable attenuators vary not only the amplitude but also the phase of the transmission coefficient with the control signal. If not specified otherwise, the phase variation is virtually out of control. Attenuators with constant phase for different attenuations are known as phase invariant. The design of a phase-invariant attenuator is particularly difficult, especially in the case of the continuously variable type. A relatively easier possibility consists of using a solution based on binary cells similar to the one in Figure 10.23c. They can be made phase invariant by inserting an additional two-port network in one of the two paths, in order to make the argðs21 Þ of the two paths as similar as possible. Furthermore, the two SPDTs have to be symmetrical with respect to the two selectable ports. This way, the argðs21 Þ of the binary cell does not change with the switch position, i.e. with the attenuation, and so it is for the complete attenuator, as required for a phase-invariant one.
10.4 Phase shifters Section 7.5 deals with fixed phase shifters, which are two-port networks presenting a controlled phase of the transmission coefficient over the frequency. Here, we will deal with variable phase shifters that are
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
401
required when signals travelling along different paths must be aligned in time. An important application of variable phase shifters is the phased array antenna;57 in that application, the radiation diagram of the antenna rotates if the RF signals of the different radiating elements are properly delayed. In the rest of the section, the denomination ‘phase shifter’ will be used instead of ‘variable phase shifter’ for brevity and since there will be no possibility of confusion with the circuits considered in Section 7.5. By definition, a phase shifter is an N-state two-port network which is ideally matched and loss free in all its N states. Denoting the phase shifter states by superscripts ‘(1)’ to ‘(N)’, we have ð1Þ
ð1Þ
ð2Þ
ð2Þ
ðN Þ
ðN Þ
s ¼ s ¼ s ¼ s ¼ ¼ s11 ¼ s22 ¼ 0 11 22 11 22 ð1Þ ð1Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ ðN Þ ðN Þ s12 ¼ s21 ¼ s12 ¼ s21 ¼ ¼ s12 ¼ s21 ¼ 1
ð10:31Þ
Assuming state (1) as the reference, we have that the transmission coefficient phase in the various states, normalized to the reference, assumes a known frequency dependence. That is, we have h i ð2Þ ð1Þ Arg s21 =s21 ¼ f2 ð f Þ h i ð3Þ ð1Þ Arg s21 =s21 ¼ f3 ð f Þ ð10:32Þ .. . h i ðN Þ ð1Þ Arg s21 =s21 ¼ fN ð f Þ We can classify the phase shifters according to their phase characteristics fk ð f Þ, obtaining: I. True phase, if fk ð f Þ is a constant over the frequency. II. True delay, or true time delay (TTD), if fk ð f Þ is proportional to the frequency. As their names suggest, true-phase (true-delay) phase shifters realize a phase shift (delay) that is constant with frequency and can be set with suitable driving quantities. Another possible classification of phase shifters is based on their circuit configuration: III. Transmission phase shifter, which is a linear loss-free matched two-port network having one or more variable elements. IV. Reflection phase shifter, which is a special case of a transmission phase shifter with a structure including one 90 hybrid. It exploits one 90 hybrid coupler to transform the reflection coefficient s11 of two identical bipoles into the transmission coefficient s21 ¼ js11 . The transmission coefficient obtained then has the same magnitude as the bipole reflection coefficient (which is unitary if the bipole is reactive) and the same phase (besides a constant difference of p=2). V. Analogue or continuously variable phase shifters, which are characterized by the fact that the phase shift can assume any intermediate value between a minimum and maximum value. Typical cases of analogue phase shifters employ varactors: when the reverse diode voltage – which is the control voltage of the phase shifter – varies within a given interval, the varactor capacitance, and thus the relative phase characteristic, uniformly and continuously vary from zero to the maximum. Figure 10.30b shows the schematic of a phase shifter using two varactors.
57
See Section 15.5.1.1.
402
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING L
L
P1
P2 C
(a)
L
2L
2L
L
P1
P2 C
C
C
(b)
Figure 10.25 True-delay transmission phase shifter: (a) elementary cell; (b) multiple cascaded cells. VI. Digital or stepped phase shifters, if the phase shift can assume only n discrete values. VII. Binary phase shifters, which are special cases of digital phase shifters, having an integer power of two different states, n ¼ 2N BIT , where the integer number N_BIT is the number of bits of the digital control word. All the configurations III to VII can realize any of the responses I and II. However, this section shows only some of the possibilities.
10.4.1
True-delay and slow-wave phase shifters
Figure 10.25a shows a simple transmission-type phase shifter. Its two identical capacitors are variable with an external control. We can consider the network in Figure 10.25a as a lumped approximation of a transmission line segment. The lumped nature of the network, however, introduces a cut-off frequency. pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi The characteristic impedance, propagation delay and cut-off frequency are equal to Z0 ¼ 2 L=C , pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi 0:5 58 t ¼ 2 L C and 2pfT ¼ ðL CÞ respectively. Now, with a proper choice of L, and if C varies within a sufficiently narrow interval, Z0 is such as to hold the network matched, the delay varies pffiffiffiffi proportionally to C and the cut-off frequency remains above the maximum working frequency. For instance, if L ¼ 0.46 nH and C 2 ½0:1; 0:5 pF, we have Z0 2 ½95:92; 42:9 O;
t 2 ½9:59; 21:45 ps;
fT 2 ½23:47; 10:49 GHz
59
A circuit analysis of the network with the above values shows that the return loss is always better than 10 dB, from zero up to 8 GHz. Choosing the minimum capacitance as the reference state, the expected relative delay of the network is Dt ¼ tðC ¼ 0:5 pFÞ tðC ¼ 0:1 pFÞ ffi 21:45 9:59 ffi 11:86 ps. Figure 10.26 shows the result obtained from the circuit analysis. The transmission delay of the network in Figure 10.25a can be increased by cascading multiple cells, then obtaining the network in Figure 10.25b. A variation of the same concept is to use one of the lowdpass filters presented in Chapter 8. A Chebyshev filter60 could be one possibility. It presents a good matching, but also large variations of the group delay, within its passband. Therefore, only the first lower portion of the passband can be used in this application. Conversely, we have the Bessel filter, which exhibits a flat group delay, but a poor passband matching. For opposite reasons, we arrive at the same conclusion: that is, to use filters having a cut-off frequency much higher than the maximum working frequency of the phase shifter. 58
The cut-off frequency considered here is the image parameter value. See [5]. See the Ansoft file 04_True_Delay_Phase_Shifter.adsn. 60 See the Mathcad file 08_Chebysheff_Lowpass_Filter_Delay.MCD. 59
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
403
20 C=0.5 pF
Relative delay, ps
16
C=0.4 pF 12 8
C=0.3 pF
4
C=0.2 pF
0
C=0.1 pF
-4 0
2
Figure 10.26
P1
4 6 Frequency, GHz
8
10
Relative delay of the phase shifter in Figure 10.25a. Ll Cl
Ll CS Cl
Figure 10.27
Ll CS Cl
Ll CS Cl
Ll
P2
CS
Slow-wave phase shifter.
The networks in Figure 10.25 usually have a smaller length61 than transmission lines presenting the same delay. The apparent increase in the component length can be thought of as due to a reduction in the wave propagation inside the component itself, with respect to the transmission line. For this reason these types of networks are also referred to as slow-wave phase shifters. Alternatively, slow-wave phase shifters can be seen as variants of the loaded-line phase shifter, described in Section 6.5.1. It consists of a transmission line periodically loaded with electronically tunable reactive loads, which affect the phase velocity of the travelling signal. The loads are usually realized as parallel capacitors connected through diodes or MEMS switches. Figure 10.27 shows the lumped element circuit model of a capacitively loaded slow-wave phase shifter, the transmission line being represented by the distributed inductance Ll and capacitance Cl . When put at a distance d which is small with respect to the wavelength, the capacitors realize a distributed capacitance CS =d that adds up to the distributed line capacitance. The phase constant thus becomes pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi b ¼ o Ll ðCl þ CS =d Þ ð10:33Þ The periodic load therefore has the effect of reducing the phase velocity of the signal, producing, with respect to the unloaded case, a phase shift rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi CS 1 1þ 1 ð10:34Þ Df ¼ lDb ¼ bl l d Cl pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi where bl ¼ o Ll Cl . The capacitance CS can vary in a continuous or discrete fashion, by employing, for example, varactor diodes, semiconductor switches or MEMS switches. 61
But also higher loss, due to the higher current densities involved with the reduced size.
404
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
As observed for the circuit in Figure 10.25a, the added capacitance simultaneously modifies the phase velocity and the characteristic impedance of the line, so producing a mismatch of the device. A possible countermeasure consists of simultaneously loading the line with series inductors in such a way as to keep the same L/C ratio as the unloaded line. This is, of course, at the price of a more complicated device.62 Depending on whether the loading capacitance is allowed to vary in a discrete or continuous fashion, the reflection architecture is amenable for realizing digital or analogue phase shifters.
10.4.2
Reflection phase shifters
The schematic in Figure 10.28a shows the principle of a reflection phase shifter. In practical realizations, the 90 hybrid coupler can assume the aspect of a Lange or branch-line coupler, as explained in Sections 6.7 and 6.8. The choice between the two cases depends on the available technology and on the required bandwidth. We can analyze the network in Figure 10.28a by means of its corresponding SFG in Figure 10.28b. Using the same method as for the variable attenuator in Figure 10.21b, we obtain pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi s11 ¼ 0:5 G1 0:5 þ j 0:5 G2 j 0:5 ¼ G1 G2 ð10:35Þ s21 ¼
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi G1 þ G2 0:5 G1 j 0:5 þ j 0:5 G2 0:5 ¼ j 2 s22 ¼ s11 ¼ G2 G1
ð10:36Þ ð10:37Þ
Thus, if the two bipoles are identical ðG1 ¼ G2 ¼ GÞ, it follows that the network in Figure 10.28a is perfectly matched ðs11 ¼ s22 ¼ 0Þ, and the transmission coefficient coincides with the bipole reflection coefficient multiplied by the imaginary unit ðs21 ¼ j GÞ. The multiplying coefficient j comes from the 90 phase shift of the hybrid, and has no effect on the amplitude of the transmission coefficient, while making argðs21 Þ ¼ argðGÞ þ p=2. Moreover, if the bipoles are purely reactive ðjGj ¼ 1Þ, then the phase shifter in Figure 10.27a is loss free ðjs21 j ¼ 1Þ, as in an ideal phase shifter. Therefore, varying one or more components inside both the bipoles, we change the phase of the transmission coefficient in the network. Figure 10.27c shows a simple case where the two reactive bipoles consist of variable capacitances.63 The reflection coefficient of a capacitor, having capacitance C, connected to ground is GC ¼
ZC R0 ðjoCÞ 1 R0 ¼ ¼ expðjjÞ ZC þ R0 ðjoCÞ 1 þ R0
with
j ¼ 2tan 1 ðR0 C oÞ
ð10:38Þ
The reflection coefficient has unitary amplitude, as expected. The reflected wave has the same amplitude as the incident one, while its phase presents an additional shift, tending to zero or to p for zero or infinite capacitance, respectively. Therefore, by varying C within an interval, we have a corresponding variation in the phase shift of the network in Figure 10.28c. Such a phase variation is frequency dependent, because it is the reflection coefficient (10.38). Nevertheless, a careful choice of the capacitance variation range can optimize the phase flatness over the frequency range of interest. Figure 10.29 shows the relative phase shift of the network when C ranges from 0.1 to 0.589 pF, using C ¼ 0:1 pF as reference. It can be seen that the simple ideal network approximately realizes a true-phase response within the frequency range 10–15 GHz.
62 63
See [13]. See the Mathcad file 09_Reflection_Phase_Shifter.MCD and the Ansoft file 05_Reflection_Phase_Shifter.adsn.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS P1
1
P2
3
0°
405
0° 90° 90°
Γ1
2
Γ2
4
(a)
P1 0.5
a1 j
b1
0.5
a1
0.5 j
0.5
b1 (b)
P1
Γ1
0.5
Γ2
0.5
P1
1
P2
3
0°
0° 90° 90°
2
4
C
C
(c)
Figure 10.28 shifter.
Reflection phase shifter: (a) basic configuration; (b) SFG; (c) variable-capacitor phase
The phase shifters in Figures 10.25a, 10.27 and 10.28c use variable capacitors to implement variable reactive elements. One possible way to realize variable-voltage-controlled capacitors is to exploit the junction of a reverse-biased diode. To this end, manufacturers provide specially tailored devices, known as varactors, or sometimes varicaps (from the contraction of variable reactors, or variable capacitors). Varactors are diodes designed to present a controlled C–V characteristic following Equation (9.74), with precise and stable parameters ð Cj0 ; Vj ; g; Cj;lin Þ and with a series resistance as small as possible. Figure 10.30b shows a phase shifter deriving from, and more realistic than, the one in Figure 10.28c, which is also shown in Figure 10.30a as a reference. The network working frequency range is 6–18 GHz.
406
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Relative phase shift, deg
112.5 90.0
C = 0.589 pF
67.5
C = 0.369 pF
45.0
C = 0.247 pF
22.5
C = 0.164 pF
0.0
C = 0.1 pF
-22.5 10
11
1
P2
3
0°
1
P1
2
0° hybrid1
4
C
15
4
hybrid1
CL1
90° 90° 2
14
Relative phase shift of the network in Figure 10.28c.
Figure 10.29
P1
12 13 Frequency, GHz
TLA,2
C
P2
3
TLA,1 TLB,1
TLB,2
TLA,3 TLB,3
(a)
DV,A
DV,B LBias,A LBias,B
CBias,A
C Bias,B
(b)
V1 Figure 10.30
Variable-capacitance reflection phase shifter: (a) principle; (b) circuit implementation.
A complex network, including one varactor DV;K with its bias elements CBias;K ; LBias;K and three transmission lines TLK;1 ; TLK;2 ; TLK;3 (with K ¼ A or B), replaces each capacitor to ground. The bias network operates in the same way as already seen for PIN diode switches and attenuators. The capacitors CBias;K provide a low impedance to ground at high frequencies, while being a DC open circuit, the inductors LBias;K feed the DC voltage to the varactor anodes while minimizing the RF leakage to the driving port. The two short-circuit stubs TLK;2 work as RF elements, and simultaneously provide a DC return for the varactors. The three transmission lines not only flatten out, but also reduce, the phase shift produced by the varactor capacitance.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
407
Table 10.4 Optimized values of the phase shifter in Figure 10.24b. TL1;K TL2;K TL3;K CV ¼ ½0:04; 0:517 pF
Z0 ¼ 46:4 O Z0 ¼ 113 O Z0 ¼ 33:8 O
yð f ¼ 12 GHzÞ ¼ 54:9 yð f ¼ 12 GHzÞ ¼ 102 yð f ¼ 12 GHzÞ ¼ 21:2
112.5 0.517 pF
Phase shift, deg
90.0 67.5
0.344 pF
45.0
0.221 pF
22.5
0.124 pF Cv = 0.04 pF
0.0 -22.5 6
8
Figure 10.31
10
12 14 Frequency, GHz
16
18
Phase shift of the circuit in Figure 10.30b.
Instead of an ideal hybrid coupler, the network in Figure 10.24b uses a matched coupled-line section, having Z0e ¼ 137 O; Z0o ¼ 2500=Z0e ffi 18:25 O and being l/4 at the centre of the working frequency of 12 GHz. This latter circuit element is a first-order model for a Lange coupler, ignoring the mode dispersion, the dissipation loss and the bond wire inductance. The three transmission line parameters and the capacitance range are computed by a circuit optimization, producing the results in Table 10.4. Figure 10.31 shows the phase response64 of the optimized network, normalized to the minimum capacitance (0.04 pF) state.
10.4.3
Stepped phase shifters
One possibility of realizing stepped phase shifters is to use a continuously variable phase shifter – for example, the circuit of Figure 10.30b – in combination with a D/A-based driver. The N BIT-bit digital control word at the A/D input transforms into one of the 2N BIT possible control voltages, and then the corresponding phase shift, which can thus assume 2NB discrete values. This configuration is the phase shifter counterpart of the variable attenuator using the driver of Figure 10.20b. Alternatively, it is possible to implement the variable reactance required for the circuits of Sections 10.4.1 and 10.4.2 with multiple switched reactive elements. The solution inherently realizes – frequency by frequency – only discrete reactances and consequently phase shifts. A discrete variable reactance can be realized with multiple switchable series or parallel reactive elements, which could be capacitors, inductors or combinations of the two. Figures 10.32a,b show a series and parallel switchable capacitor, respectively. By replacing the capacitors in Figure 10.32 with inductors, resonating cells or 64
See the Ansoft file 06_Analog_Phase_Shifter.adsn.
408
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
(a)
(b)
Figure 10.32 Switched capacitor realization of variable capacitances: (a) series configuration; (b) parallel configuration. transmission lines, we obtain variable inductors, reactive LC bipoles or stubs, respectively. This possibility increases the design flexibility. The capacitors in Figure 10.32 can be inserted or removed by means of electrically controlled switching elements: namely, PIN, FET or MEMS devices. They are no different from those considered in Sections 10.2, and no further description is required. Stepped phase shifters can also be realized with groups of n two-port networks, selectable through couples of SPnT. If n ¼ 2, or n ¼ 4, these configuration are the counterparts of the attenuators in Figure 10.23a, or 10.23b, respectively.
10.4.4
Binary phase shifters
All the configurations described in Section 10.4.3 can also be used to realize binary phase shifters, as a consequence of the fact that binary phase shifters are particular cases of the stepped ones. However, the peculiarity of the binary phase shifter is that the number of its states is an integer power of 2: that is, n ¼ 2N BIT , where the integer number N BIT is the number of bits. Furthermore, the difference between the phase shift at the next two states is constant. This property can be exploited to realize the phase shifter by cascading N BIT cells, each with two phase shifts (or with 1 bit). Figure 10.33a shows the structure of a two-state (1-bit) binary phase shifter. The two two-port networks NTA , NTB placed between the two SP2Ts are ideally impedance matched. The two SP2Ts are impedance matched too, and their transmission coefficient phase from the common to the selected port does not change from position 1 to 2. This latter assumption is always satisfied, in that we can consider any phase difference between the SPDT paths as belonging65 to NTA or NTB. Under these hypotheses, the S parameters of the phase shifter, when the two SPDTs are in position 1 or 2, are respectively " ð1Þ ð1Þ # s11 s12 0 1 ðSPDT1;position 1Þ ðAÞ ðSPDT2;position 1Þ s21 s21 ¼ s ð1Þ ð1Þ 1 0 21 s21 s22 65
In addition, SPDTs are usually symmetrical, e.g. Figures 10.4b, 10.5b, and 10.14b.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
409
φA- φB= ∆φ NTA φA,1
1
1
P1
P2 φB,1
2
SPDT1
(a) φA,1 - φB,1 = ∆φ 1
P1 2
(b)
φA,1 φB,1
φA,2- φB,2 = 2•∆φ 1
1
2
2
V1
φA,2 φB,2
2
NTB
SPDT2
V1 φA,N_BIT - φB,N_BIT = 2
•∆φ
N_BIT-1
1
1
2
2
V2
φA,N_BIT φB,N_BIT
1
P2 2
VN_BIT
TL2 TL1
TL3
∆l/2
1
1
P1
P2 2
TL4
2
SPDT1
(c)
Figure 10.33
SPDT2 V1
Binary phase shifters: (a) single bit cell; (b) multi-bit architecture; (c) TTD binary cell. "
ð2Þ
s11
ð2Þ
s21
ð2Þ
s12
ð2Þ
s22
#
¼
0 1 ðSPDT1;position2Þ ðBÞ ðSPDT2;position2Þ s s21 s21 1 0 21
The relative phase shift is then " # " # " # ð1Þ ðSPDT1;position 1Þ ðAÞ ðSPDT2;position 1Þ ðAÞ s21 s21 s21 s21 s ¼ jA jB ¼ Dj arg ð2Þ ¼ arg ðSPDT1;position 2Þ ðBÞ ðSPDT2;position 2Þ ¼ arg 21 ðBÞ s21 s21 s21 s21 s21
ð10:39Þ
where fA ; fB are the transmission coefficient phases of the two two-port networks placed between the two SPDTs. Equation (10.39) states that a proper design of the two fixed two-port networks allows us to obtain any required phase characteristic from the phase shifter in Figure 10.33a: true phase or true delay. The configuration in Figure 10.27 may also be employed to realize a binary phase shifter by cascading slow-wave sections, each section realizing the appropriate bit. Similarly, 1-bit phase shifters can also be obtained from any of the configurations in Figures 10.25 and 10.30b. In this latter case the control voltage has to assume two different values. Compared with these cases, the design of the network in Figure 10.33a is simpler, and gives better phase accuracy, because the two networks NTA , NTB can be synthesized independently of each other. On the other hand, the two SP2Ts in the architecture in Figure 10.27a make the insertion loss more critical than in the other solutions.
410
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 10.34
Photograph of a binary TTD MEMS phase shifter.
Figure 10.33b shows N BIT cascaded binary cells, realizing a multiple bit phase shifter. The relative phase shift of each cell is double (half) that of its adjacent one towards the RF port P1 (P2 ). Note the similarity of the structure in Figure 10.33b with the one for the attenuator in Figure 10.23a. in From similar considerations66 as those used for the attenuator, we conclude that the architecture Figure 10.33b has n ¼ 2N BIT states with a relative phase shift from zero up to 2N BIT 1 Df, with a step of Df. Again, Df could be either constant or proportional to the frequency, for a true-phase or a true-delay response. Figure 10.33c shows one particular 1-bit TTD cell, known as a switched-line phase shifter. Conceptually, it consists of two pieces of matched transmission lines, of different length, placed between two SP2Ts. The phase shift produced is proportional to the difference Dl between the physical length of the delay (TL1 ,TL2 and TL3 ) line and that of the reference line (TL4 ). Clearly, the longest line needs to be folded in order to reach the same SP2Ts as the shortest one, which is why Figure 10.33c represents the longest line with three cascaded segments. Figure 10.34 shows the layout of a 3-bit phase shifter employing three cascaded cells of the type in Figure 10.33c. The SP2Ts use MEMS devices. The labels on the first cell (on the left) indicate the four transmission lines (TL1 to TL4 ) and the control voltages (V1a and V1b ). The RF ports of the chip are indicated by P1 and P2 . The component in Figure 10.34 is designed to operate in the Ka band (centre frequency is 20 GHz). The simulated response is shown in Figure 10.35. As the linear phase variation shows, the device is a TTD. Due to reactive parasitic phenomena, the device does not operate properly above 24 GHz. Figure 10.36 shows an alternative example of a binary phase shifter cell, obtained by switching between a lowdpass (lag) and a highdpass (lead) filter. There are many possible design techniques for this network, from network synthesis to circuit optimization. We will present a simple method, based on a simple combination of filter synthesis and computer optimization.67 ðLPÞ ðHPÞ Let f1 ; f2 be the limits of the working frequency bandwidth and fT ; fT the cut-off frequencies of the lowdpass and highpass filter, respectively. Since the network must be impedance matched over all the ðLPÞ ðHPÞ frequency range in both its states, then fT f2 and fT f2 must apply. We will use a Chebyshev ðLPÞ ðHPÞ ¼a prototype with the same order and ripple for both the filters, and set fT = f2 ¼ f1 = fT with a 1. This way, the lowdpass maps f2 to the same prototype frequency as the highpass does with f1. Then, we will choose a passband ripple that is satisfactory for our impedance matching
66 67
Just swapping the relative attenuation and the relative phase. See the Mathcad file 10_Lowpass_Highpass_Pase_Shifter.MCD and the Ansoft file 07_PH22d5.adsn.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
411
450
Phase shift, °
360
270
180
90
0 15
Figure 10.35
17
19 21 Frequency, GHz
23
25
Simulated response of the MEMS phase shifter in Figure 10.34. L1
L3 C2
1
LN CN-1
1
P2
P1 2
2
C1
C3 L2
CN LN-1
vCNTRL
Figure 10.36
Highpass, lowdpass binary phase shifter.
requirements, for instance RP ¼ 0:01 dB, corresponding to a return loss68 of about 26.4 dB. Finally, we set an odd number for the filter order; for simplicity our choice will be N ¼ 3. Now we have only the design parameter a, and therefore we can scan it to find the required phase shift in the frequency range of interest. Let us assume: .
f1 ¼ 1 GHz;
.
N ¼ 3;
.
Df ¼ 22:5 .
f2 ¼ 2 GHz
RP ¼ 0:01 dB
68 The final return loss of the cell derives from the combination of the filters with the two SPDTs. Precisely two cascaded two-ports each having a return loss of 10, 15, 20 and 25 present additional phase ripples of 5.7 , 1.8 , 0.6 and 0.2 ; see Equation (9.7) and relative comments in Section 9.2.
412
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
By scanning a from unity to increasing values, we obtain the optimum value aDf ¼ 4:101. From this, and applying the synthesis procedures69 for the lowdpass ðL1 ¼ L3 ¼ 0:61 nH; C2 ¼ 0:377 pFÞ and highpass ðC1 ¼ C3 ¼ 20:747 pF; L2 ¼ 33:633 nHÞ filters, the resulting phase shift presents a maximum error of 0.7 over the whole frequency range.
10.4.5
Final considerations on phase shifters
Now we can focus on the deviations of the real phase shifter from the ideal case: 1. No phase shifter presents a perfect impedance match, even within its working bandwidth. Therefore we need to specify a minimum in-band return loss. 2. Real phase shifters present a non-zero insertion loss, which also varies with the frequency and from state to state. Therefore, we will have to have an insertion loss mask and a specified insertion loss variation with the state. The counterpart of this latter parameter in variable attenuators is that they change their phase at different attenuation. This behaviour is usually non-specific, and often also not well known. 3. The relative phase characteristic, in both the true-phase and true-delay cases, is not uniform with the frequency. Consequently, the mean, maximum and minimum, phase shift or delay value must be specified over the frequency for each state. Sometimes RMS error is also specified. Furthermore, the interactions between the unmatched phase shifter and its unmatched generator and load cause additional phase ripple, as addressed in Section 9.2. 4. Phase shifters present nonlinear distortions like any component with semiconductor devices. At high input power, we have both amplitude compression and phase variations. Therefore, a further specification is the maximum input power (operational and not damaging). 5. Similar to switches and attenuators, phase shifters do not react to their driving signal instantaneously. We then have a specified settling time for a giver phase error. 6. Finally, all the specifications 1 to 5 are also temperature dependent, and there are, of course, working and surviving temperature ranges for the phase shifter.
Bibliography 1. G. Hiller, ‘Designing with PIN diodes’, MA-COM Application Note AG-312. 2. R. H. Caverly and G. Hiller, ‘Distortion properties of MESFET and PIN diode microwave switches’, IEEE MTT-S Symposium Digest, pp. 533–535, 1992. 3. R. H. Caverly, ‘Distortion modeling of PIN diode switches and attenuators’, IEEE MTT-S Symposium Digest, pp. 957–960, 2004. 4. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Simulation and Design, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007, Chapter 7, pp. 420–428. 5. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Simulation and Design, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007, Chapter 2, pp. 57–63. 6. G. Bianchi and G. Pinto, ‘DC-18 GHz Ga-As MMIC SPST and SPDT’, Military Microwave Conference, Brighton, UK, 1992. 69
See Chapter 7.
MICROWAVE CONTROL COMPONENTS
413
7. M. Golio, The RF and Microwave Handbook, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 2001, Chapter 8.7. 8. ‘Agilent FET switch speed and settling time’, Application Note #57 – Rev. A, July 2002. 9. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Simulation and Design, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007, Chapter 7, pp. 432–434. 10. S. Lucyszyn, Advanced RF MEMS, Cambridge University Press, 2010. 11. M. Rebeiz, RF MEMS Theory, Design and Technology, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ, 2003. 12. S. Di Nardo, P. Farinelli, F. Giacomozzi, G. Mannocchi, R. Marcelli, B. Margesin, P. Mezzanotte, V. Mulloni, P. Russer, R. Sorrentino, F. Vitulli and L. Vietzorreck, ‘Broadband RF-MEMS based SPDT’, Proceedings of the 36th European Microwave Conference, Manchester, UK, September 2006. 13. A. Ocera, P. Mezzanotte and R. Sorrentino, ‘Design of tunable phase shifters by the image parameter method’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. MTT-54, No. 6, pp. 2383–2390, 2006.
Related files Ansoft files 01_PIN_SPDT.adsn. Provides a first-level simulation of the SPDT in Figure 10.4, to compute insertion loss, isolation and return loss. 02_Shunt_Only_SPDT.adsn. Provides a first-level simulation of the SPDT in Figure 10.8, to compute insertion loss, isolation and return loss for different values of the diode ON resistance. 03_Shunt_Resistor_Attenuator.adsn. Provides a simple description of the attenuator in Figure 10.15b, assuming a coupled-line realization of the hybrids. It allows computation of the attenuation and return loss for any incremental resistance of the diode. 04_True_Delay_Phase_Shifter.adsn. Analyzes the phase shifter in Figure 10.19a and produces the curves in Figure 10.20. 05_Reflection_Phase_Shifter.adsn. Analyzes the phase shifter in Figure 10.21c and produces the curves in Figure 10.22. 06_Analog_Phase_Shifter.adsn. Analyzes the phase shifter in Figure 10.24b and produces the curves in Figure 10.25. 07_PH22d5.adsn. Analyzes the lowdpass, highpass phase shifter in Figure 10.27.
Mathcad files 08_Chebysheff_Lowpass_Filter_Delay.MCD. Performs some analyses and optimizations on the application of a Chebyshev filter as a delay line. 09_Reflection_Phase_Shifter.MCD. The equivalent of Ansoft file 05 above, implemented with a mathematical rather than circuit analysis method. 10_Lowdpass_Highpass_Pase_Shifter.MCD. Analyzes, optimizes and synthesizes the lowdpass, highpass phase shifter in Figure 10.27.
11
Amplifiers 11.1 Introduction This chapter deals with transistor-based RF and microwave amplifiers. Such devices are sometimes referred to as solid state amplifiers (SSAs), in order to distinguish them from vacuum tube device circuits. High-frequency amplifiers are too wide a topic for one single chapter, and probably for one single book as well. Here, we will limit our descriptions to the main concepts and to the most used configurations. The largest part of this chapter (Sections 11.2 to part of 11.4) describes the classical one-transistor amplifier with one input and one output matching network. In this architecture there are three important cases: generic or small-signal amplifiers, low-noise amplifiers and power amplifiers. Small-signal and low-noise amplifiers assume a linear operation of the transistor. In the first case, what matters is the gain, thus the best possible impedance matching of the transistor input and outputs. In lownoise amplifiers, the input is matched for the minimum noise figure, all the gain optimization relying on the output. Power amplifiers use the transistor in the nonlinear region, the output matching tries to exploit best the transistor power and any improvement in the gain is based on the input only. Sections 11.2 and 11.3 deal with small-signal and low-noise amplifiers respectively. In order to clarify the design concepts expressed in these sections, Section 11.4 presents the design of a trial amplifier, step by step. Section 11.5 discusses some techniques for power amplifier design. Section 11.6 describes some non-classical amplifier configurations, which are particularly suitable for integrated circuit technology. Section 11.7 completes the chapter describing two amplifiers taken from real engineering practice
11.2 Small-signal amplifiers Figure 11.1 shows the basic structure of a typical high-frequency amplifier. The active device Q1 assumes the symbol of a FET, but it could also be a bipolar or MOS device, with minor changes, limited to the DC circuitry. For the active device connection, the most used one is the common source/common emitter, although common base/gate or common drain/collector are sometimes also used. Furthermore, most of the real amplifiers use one single active device, but some applications employ multiple devices in Darlington or cascode connection.
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
416
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING input matching
L gg Input
1
2
C dd L dd
R gg
R dd
+ Vgg input bias
Figure 11.1
output matching
Q1
C gg
1
2
Output
+ V dd output bias
Principle of a single stage high-frequency amplifier.
We will begin our descriptions by referring to the configuration in Figure 11.1 as it is, because it is the simplest one. Subsequent sections will discuss some variants. Beginning with Q1 , we can see two bias networks, one at the input and one at the output, each consisting of one capacitor, one inductor and a voltage generator1 with a series resistor. The capacitors present infinite impedance at DC and negligible impedance at RF, and the opposite applies for the inductors. This way, the two DC generators can bias the respective transistor electrodes neither disturbing the high-frequency elements nor being disturbed by them. The two DC generators Vgg ; Vdd , combined with their respective series resistors Rgg ; Rdd , are the Thevenin models of any real voltage or current source. The two matching networks modify the impedances of the transistor as seen by the input and output into values as close as possible to 50 O. In many real cases, matching and bias networks are not distinct, rather they share one or more component that simultaneously performs matching and bias functions. Amplifier design normally has two phases: choice of the most appropriate device; and matching/bias network design. The decision about the best transistor for a given application is based not only on electrical parameters, but also on cost considerations. Usually the best performing devices present the highest cost. On the other hand, better performing transistors could require simpler – thus cheaper – matching networks, lower criticality in production, and so on. The first evaluation of a potential device relies on the manufacturer’s data, which are generally sufficient for the complete design. Few particularly critical applications require a more accurate device characterization: in these cases the designer may need to measure the transistor and extract a specifically tailored model. The matching network design is strictly related to the required performances of the amplifier. Design techniques are available for maximum gain, best gain flatness over the frequency, best impedance matching, minimum noise figure, maximum power, maximum linearity, and combinations of these. Besides those purely electrical performances, the yield of the amplifier in production is assuming a growing importance. From the design point of view, this implies that the network must present minimum sensitivity of its performance to the component tolerances. This additional requirement stimulated the CAE techniques known as yield analysis and yield optimization.
11.2.1
Gain definitions
There are three main definitions of the amplifier power gain that are in use in engineering practice: 1. Transducer power gain: (GT ) is the ratio between the power delivered to the load (PL) and the one available from the generator (PAVS ).
1 In this chapter we will always use the word ‘generator’, instead of ‘source’, in order to avoid confusion with the eponymous FET electrode, as in Section 10.2.
AMPLIFIERS
417
2. Operating power gain: (GP ), also known simply as power gain, is the ratio between the power delivered to the load (PL ) and the one at the amplifier input (Pin ). 3. Available power gain: (GA ) is the ratio between the available powers of the amplifier (PAVN ) and of the generator (PAVS ). Thus, in formulae, GT ¼
PL ; PAVS
GP ¼
PL ; PIN
GA ¼
PAVN PAVS
ð11:1Þ
Figure 11.2a shows the generic diagram of a transistor connected to an input generator and an output load. The generator and load reflection coefficients are Gs ; GL respectively, while the superscript ‘(Q)’ denotes the transistor parameters. The generator and load in Figure 11.2a could embed their respective matching networks, because of the generic value assumed for Gs and GL . Figures 11.2b,c show the signal flow graphs (SFGs) corresponding to the schematic of Figure 11.2a, assuming that the generator is terminated with a generic load Gl . We will use those graphs to derive the explicit expressions of the power gains (11.1). Beginning with Figure 11.2c, the power delivered from the generator to the load equals the square amplitude of the incident wave 1 2 2 jbs j Pl ¼ jal j2 ¼ ð11:2Þ 1Gs Gl Γin
Γout
(Q)
[S ] generator
(a)
1
Γs
load
2
ΓL
transistor
(Q) a1 s21
bs
b2
s11(Q) Γs
s22(Q) ΓL b1
(b)
a2
al
bs
Γs
(c)
(Q)
s12
Γl
bl
Figure 11.2 Structures for the computation of the power transfer ratio of a two-port network: (a) electrical schematic; (b) amplifier signal flow graph; (c) generator signal flow graph.
418
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The third term of Equation (11.2) is easily obtained by applying Mason’s rule to the SFG of Figure 11.2c. The available power, by definition, is the power delivered to a load conjugated/matched to the generator. Thus Equation (11.2) returns the generator available power after the substitution Gl ¼ G*s , where the asterisk denotes the complex conjugate:2 PAVS ¼
1 1jGs j2
jbs j2
ð11:3Þ
The power delivered to the load is the difference between the amplifier output reflected and incident wave square amplitude ð11:4Þ PL ¼ jb2 j2 ja2 j2 ¼ jb2 j2 1jGL j2 The terms (11.3) and (11.4) involved with the transducer power gain definitions include the variables bs to b2 . The ratio between these two variables can be computed by analyzing the SFG in Figure 11.2b. The definitions given in Section 9.3 involve the following contributions to the transfer ratio (9.8): ðQÞ
.
The only path from bs to b2 is P1 ¼ s21 .
.
.
There are no first-order loops that do not touch P1 . X ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ There are three first-order loops; their sum is Lð1Þ ¼ s11 Gs þ s22 GL þ s21 GL s12 Gs . X ðQÞ ðQÞ The only second-order loop is Lð2Þ ¼ s11 Gs s22 GL .
.
There are no higher order loops.
.
Hence, the output reflected wave is ðQÞ
b2 ¼
s21 bs ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ 1 s11 Gs þ s22 GL þ s21 GL s12 G þ s11 Gs s22 GL
ð11:5Þ
Substituting Equations (11.3) to (11.5) into the first equation of definitions (11.1), we have 2 ðQÞ 2 jb j2 1jGs j2 s21 1jGs j PL 2 GT ¼ ¼ 1jGs j2 ¼ h i PAVS jbs j2 1 sðQÞ G þ sðQÞ G þ sðQÞ G sðQÞ G þ sðQÞ G sðQÞ G 2 s L L 12 s s 22 L 11 22 21 11 Rearranging the denominator, we obtain the more compact formula 2 ðQÞ 2 1jGL j2 s21 1jGs j G T ¼ h 2 ih i ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ 1s11 Gs 1s22 GL s12 Gs s21 GL ðQÞ
ð11:6Þ ðQÞ
Further forms of the transducer power gain can be obtained by replacing s11 or s22 with the reflection coefficients indicated in Figure 11.2a as Gin and Gout respectively. From (9.2) we have ðQÞ
Gin ¼ s11 þ
ðQÞ ðQÞ
s21 s12 GL ðQÞ
1s22 GL
;
ðQÞ
Gout ¼ s22 þ
ðQÞ ðQÞ
s21 s12 Gs ðQÞ
1s11 Gs
ð11:7Þ
The conjugate of a complex number is defined as ða þ jbÞ* ¼ conjða þ jbÞ ¼ a jb, see also the definition associated with the identity (B.5). It is also ða þ jbÞ* ða þ jbÞ ¼ a2 þ b2 . 2
AMPLIFIERS
419
2 ðQÞ Dividing and multiplying the denominator of Equation (11.6) by the factor 1s22 GL , and rearranging the expression, we obtain 2 1jG j2 1jGs j2 ðQÞ L GT ¼ 2 s21 2 ðQÞ sðQÞ G sðQÞ G 1s22 GL s 21 L ðQÞ 12 1s11 Gs ðQÞ 1s22 GL By virtue of the first equation in (11.7), we can write the second term of the second denominator as ðQÞ
ðQÞ
s12 Gs s21 GL ðQÞ
1s22 GL
ðQÞ ðQÞ ¼ Gin s11 Gs ¼ Gin Gs s11 Gs
Then, the transducer gain becomes GT ¼
1jGs j2 ðQÞ 2 1jGL j2 s21 2 ðQÞ j1Gin Gs j2 1s G 22
ð11:8Þ
L
2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ With a similar procedure, but inserting 1s11 GS instead of 1s22 GL , we obtain 1jGs j2 ðQÞ 2 1jGL j2 GT ¼ 2 s21 ðQÞ j1Gin GL j2 1s11 Gs
ð11:9Þ
The three expressions (11.6), (11.8) and (11.9) give three points of view about the effect of the various reflection coefficients on the transducer power gain. As for the other two power gain definitions, we have that the amplifier input power is the difference between the generator available power and the reflected power. Considering this, the first two equations of (11.1) give GP ¼
PL PAVS PL PAVS 1 ¼ ¼ GT ¼ GT PIN PIN PAVS PIN 1jGS j2
Substituting these expression into Equations (11.8) and (11.9), we obtain GP ¼
2 1jG j2 2 1jG j2 1 ðQÞ ðQÞ L L s ¼ s 21 2 2 21 j1Gout GL j2 ðQÞ ðQÞ j1Gin Gs j2 1s22 GL 1s11 GS 1
ð11:10Þ
The amplifier available power is the one delivered to a matched load; hence, the available power gain coincides with the value given by Equation (11.9) when GL ¼ G*out . Thus 1jGs j2 ðQÞ 2 1 GA ¼ 2 s21 ðQÞ 1jGout j2 1s11 Gs
ð11:11Þ
All the expressions derived for the transistor power gain apply to any linear two-port network as well, simply by replacing the transistor S parameters with those of the network. In particular, if we replace the scattering parameters of the transistor with those of the complete amplifier, and put Gs ¼ GL ¼ 0, expressions (11.9) to (11.11) give the amplifier gain on the 50 O generator and source: ðAmpÞ 2 2 s 21 ðAmpÞ GT ¼ GP ¼ s21 ; GA ¼ 1jGout j2
420
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
where the superscript ‘(Amp)’ denotes the amplifier scattering parameters, which are combinations of the input matching network, transistor and output matching network by the next applications of Equation (9.2).
11.2.2
Stability
An important property of non-unilateral transistors is their potential instability. Particular combinations of input and output terminating impedances may cause the transistor to oscillate. Oscillators are the topic of Chapter 12 which shows how to exploit transistor instability for design purposes. Here, we will limit ourselves to showing how to recognize if a two-port network is stable or not, and what the fundamental stabilization techniques are. A generic two-port network is unconditionally stable if, on terminating its port 1 (respectively, 2) with any passive bipole, the impedance seen at port 2 (1) is still that of a passive bipole.3 A unstable twoport network does not necessarily oscillate, but it could oscillate in some specific cases, as discussed in Chapter 12. We can define the stability condition of the transistor, in reference to Figure 11.2a, by applying expressions (11.7). Assuming that the terminating bipoles are passive, then jGs j 1;
jGL j 1
The transistor is unconditionally stable if, for any phase of the terminating reflection coefficients, the values resulting from Equations (11.7) have magnitude no greater than 1: ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ s21 s12 GL ðQÞ s21 s12 Gs ð11:12Þ 1; s22 þ 1 s11 þ ðQÞ ðQÞ 1s GL 1s Gs 22
11
Instead, if the inequalities (11.12) are not satisfied for at least one couple of values ðGs ; GL Þ, then the transistor is potentially unstable. In general, physical devices satisfy the condition (11.12) only in some frequency bands. The terminating reflection coefficients that are stable or unstable for the device define the input and output stability region. We can determine the stability regions by finding their limit values, in mathematical terms, by solving Equations (11.12) with the equals sign. The two inequalities (11.12) have the same structure: we can obtain each of them from the other by swapping the index 1 and 2 of the scattering parameters and Gs for GL. For this reason, we will develop our calculations on the first inequality, the other case being analogous. Starting from the first inequality (11.12) with the equals sign, and squaring both terms, we have i ðQÞ h s 1sðQÞ G þ sðQÞ sðQÞ G 2 L L 11 22 21 12 ¼1 ðQÞ 1s22 GL which is equivalent to 2 h i 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ s11 þ s21 s12 s11 s22 GL ¼ 1s22 GL which can be rewritten in a more compact way as 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ s11 D GL ¼ 1s22 GL
3 We can define a passive bipole in terms of its immittance ½ReðZÞ; ReðYÞ 0 or reflection coefficient ðjGj 1Þ, where clearly Z, Y and G are the impedance, admittance and reflection coefficients of the bipole.
AMPLIFIERS
421
where ðQÞ ðQÞ
ðQÞ ðQÞ
D ¼ s11 s22 s21 s12
ð11:13Þ
is the determinant of the transistor scattering matrix. For any complex number Z this is jZ j2 ¼ Z Z * , thus ðQÞ
ðQÞ*
ðQÞ
ðQÞ*
½s11 D GL ½s11 D* G*L ¼ ½1s22 GL ½1s22 G*L Expanding the above expression, and regrouping terms in GL, we can write 2 h 2 h i i ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ 2 ðQÞ s11 þ s22 s11 D GL þ s22 s11 D* G*L þ jDj s22 GL G*L ¼ 1 After dividing both sides by the coefficient of GL G*L , this equation becomes h
2 i h i* ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ* 1s11 s22 s11 D GL þ s22 s11 D G*L * þ GL GL ¼ 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ jDj2 s22 jDj2 s22
Adding the term 2 2 h i h i* ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ* s22 s11 D s22 s11 D jDj2 s22 to both sides, we get h i h i* h i h i* ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ* s22 s11 D s22 s11 D s22 s11 D GL þ s22 s11 D G*L þ þ GL G*L 2 2 2 ðQÞ 2 ðQÞ jDj s22 jDj2 s22 2 h i h i* ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ* 1s11 s22 s11 D s22 s11 D ¼ 2 þ 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ jDj2 s22 jDj2 s 22
which can be rearranged as 9 8h 9 8h 2 i* i h i h i* ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ* > > > => = < sðQÞ < sðQÞ 1s11 s22 s11 D s22 s11 D 22 s11 D 22 s11 D 2 þ G L 2 þ G*L ¼ 2 þ 2 2 > > > ;> ; jDj2 sðQÞ : jDj2 sðQÞ : jDj2 sðQÞ ðQÞ 22 22 22 jDj2 s 22
Note that the first term of the above equation is the product of two complex conjugate numbers, which can be replaced with the square amplitude of those numbers themselves, giving 2 h 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ* i* ðQÞ ðQÞ* 2 ðQÞ s22 s11 D 1 s s s D 11 22 11 2 þ GL ¼ 2 þ 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ jDj2 s22 jDj2 s22 jDj2 s22 It is possible to write the above equation in a more compact way, by reducing the second term to a single fraction
422
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
2 h 2 2 2 2 h i i h ðQÞ ðQÞ* i* ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ 2 2 ðQÞ s22 s11 D D D j j j j s11 s22 þ s11 s22 þ s22 s11 D s22 s11 D* 2 þ GL ¼ 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ jDj2 s22 jDj2 s 22
Exploiting the identity jZ j2 ¼ Z Z * again, we can rewrite the numerator of the second term as 2 h h i h i 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ* i* ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ* s22 s11 D s þ s11 s22 s s s s s s s 11 22 12 21 11 22 12 21 2 þ GL ¼ 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ jDj2 s22 jDj2 s 22
h
i h i ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ* ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ s11 s22 s11 s22 s12 s21 s11 s22 s11 s22 s12 s21 þ 2 2 ðQÞ jDj2 s22 Expanding the products of the numerator of the second term and simplifying opposite terms, we get finally 2 2 h ðQÞ ðQÞ* i* s22 s11 D sðQÞ sðQÞ 12 21 ð11:14Þ 2 þ GL ¼ 2 ðQÞ 2 ðQÞ jDj2 s22 jDj s22 Equation (11.14) describes a circle in polar coordinates, in the plane of the complex variable GL, with centre and radius respectively ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ * s s 12 21 s s D CL ¼ 22 11 2 ; rL ¼ ð11:15Þ 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ jDj2 s22 jDj2 s22 This circle delimits the stability region of the load reflection coefficient: it is the load stability circle or the output stability circle. With the same calculations,4 and starting from the second inequality (11.12), we derive the centre and radius of the input stability circle ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ* ðQÞ s12 s21 s11 s22 D* Cs ¼ ð11:16Þ 2 ; rs ¼ 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ jDj2 s11 jDj2 s11 The scattering parameters of the transistor are complex functions of the frequency, and thus the stability circles are frequency dependent as well. All the points on the external perimeter of the output (input) stability circle represent values of the output (input) reflection coefficients, making the reflection coefficient seen at the transistor input (output) have unitary amplitude. The identification of the stable regions depends on determining if the stable points are the ones inside or outside the stability circle. In this regard, the centre of the Smith chart is a useful marker. Let us consider the output stability, and assume that the transistor input reflection coefficient has ðQÞ amplitude not greater than one s 1 . This means that a 50 O termination ðGL ¼ 0Þ on the 11
transistor output represents a stable load, by definition of s11; then the Smith chart origin is a stable point for the output. Consequently, if the output stability circle surrounds the centre of the Smith chart, the 4
Or swapping the index 1 and 2 in the scattering parameters of Equation (11.15).
AMPLIFIERS
423
ðQÞ unstable region is outside that circle, and vice versa. Conversely, if s11 > 1, the output stable points are external or internal to the stability circle, depending on whether the latter encircles the centre of the ðQÞSmith chart or not. Applying the same considerations to the input stability, we obtain that if s 1 sðQÞ > 1 the input stable points are internal (external) or external (internal) to the input 22 22 stability circle if that includes the point GS ¼ 0 or not. Under this hypothesis, the reference reflection coefficients are stable points by definition: in other words, the transistor is stable on 50 O. ðQÞ ðQÞ Most transistors present s11 1; s22 1, and thus they are stable on 50 O for both input and output. ðQÞ ðQÞ If s11 j 1; s22 j 1 and the stability circles are totally outside the unit ratio Smith chart, it follows that any passive termination is stable for the device: in this case the transistor is unconditionally stable. We can plot the stability circles5 at all the frequencies of interest and check the stability of the device: the further their distance from the Smith chart external circumference ðjGj ¼ 1Þ, the more stable the device. The Kurokawa criterion provides an alternative method for the stability analysis. It is possible to demonstrate that the transistor is unconditionally stable if its scattering parameters satisfy the inequalities ðQÞ ðQÞ 1s11 s22 þ jDj2 K¼ > 1; jDj < 1 ð11:17Þ ðQÞ ðQÞ 2s12 s21 where D is the determinant (11.13) of the transistor scattering matrix. Again, we can plot6 the quantities K and D: the transistor is stable according to whether the first (latter) quantity is greater (smaller) than 1. In principle, to speak about different degrees of stability on an unconditionally stable device could sound like nonsense. However, this is not the case, due to differences from device to device, temperature variations and the uncertainty of the transistor parameters due to measurement errors. Slightly different assemblies could also modify the transistor scattering parameters. In normal engineering practice, designers allow some margin on the stability, in order to override the above-mentioned tolerance effects. So far we have described the stability analysis of a transistor, but the relative considerations apply to any linear two-port network: all the expressions (11.15) to (11.17) remain valid, just by replacing the transistor scattering parameters with those of the network. In particular, the stability analysis applies to the amplifier in Figure 11.1. Any two-port, obtained by cascading an arbitrary number of purely reactive networks at the input and output of the transistor, conserves the stability properties of the transistor itself: the cascade is unconditionally stable or not; so is the transistor. This assertion can easily be justified by considering that: 1. A two-port network consisting of an arbitrary number of purely reactive two-port networks is still purely reactive, or loss free. 2. If the transistor is unstable, values of GS or GL exist inside the unit ratio Smith chart that violate one of the conditions (11.12). Any purely reactive two-port network moves the unstable points from inside the unit ratio Smith chart to different zones on the same chart. 3. The consequence of 1 and 2 is that an amplifier having the structure of Figure 11.1, with arbitrarily complex purely reactive matching networks, has the same transistor stability.7
5 All the microwave circuit simulators usually include a stability circle plotting capability. Usually, they also mark the stable region, inside or outside the circle. 6 All the microwave circuit simulators are capable of plotting K and D. 7 In considerations 1 to 3, we assumed that the bias network has no influence at high frequencies.
424
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Most real transistors are not unconditionally stable, therefore they must be stabilized, and purely reactive matching networks are not allowed. In a few cases it could be possible that potentially unstable amplifiers, employing unstable transistors and loss-free matching networks, are usable. This happens when the amplifier is intended to operate with specified input and output impedances, falling well inside the stability regions. Such a condition, however, does not occur frequently. Unstable amplifiers are critical for normal use, in that the effective input and output reflection coefficients are only approximately known. Stabilization of the amplifier requires the insertion of resistances inside the matching networks. The amplifier must be unconditionally stable at any frequency, not just in the working band. Outof-band instabilities8 can lead to out-of-band oscillations that intermodulate with the wanted signal producing spurs, or even saturate the amplifier and totally degrade its gain. In addition, terminating impedances at out-of-band frequencies are generally more uncertain than in-band ones, which increases the out-of-band stability requirements.
11.2.3
Matching networks
Having defined the power gain, we can now describe the matching networks which maximize the power transfer from the generator to the transistor, and from this to the load. Chapter 6 presents the most important matching networks and techniques. Matching networks for amplifier applications, however, need careful attention and approaches. Usually the input generator and the output load are resistive, while the transistor presents reactive and frequency-dependent impedances at its electrodes. If we look at the matching network from the active device (a) or from the opposite side (b), we have two different but equivalent descriptions of their operation: (a) The input (output) network transforms the generator (load) impedance in the conjugate of the transistor input (output) one. (b) The input (output) network transforms the transistor input (output) in the conjugate of the generator (load) impedance one. This second definition could omit the adjective ‘conjugate’, since load and generator are usually resistive, as written above. The matching network design can use many different methods and circuit topologies: the result could be a lumped,9 distributed or mixed, purely reactive or lossy network, with low-pass or bandpass response. One of the key parameters for the matching network design is the working bandwidth of the amplifier. As a general rule, wider bandwidths require more complicated networks. Usually, amplifier designers prefer reactive to resistive matching, due to the signal loss involved with the latter. However, Fano’s equations10 state an insurmountable limit for the return loss achievable for a given transistor impedance with a loss-free network. Therefore reactive matching networks are advisable, in principle, until the required combination of return loss and bandwidth is incompatible with the Fano limits. In any case, we must consider that complex matching networks potentially give better matching, as close as possible to the Fano limit, but also are usually more critical and tolerance sensitive. One additional case, which requires resistive matching, occurs when the transistor is potentially unstable, if the amplifier must be absolutely stable. Sections 11.2.4, 11.3 and 11.5 subsequently present some considerations of the matching network design oriented towards maximum gain, minimum noise figure, maximum output power and amplifier stability. 8
Typically, they occur at lower frequencies, where the transistor gain is higher. Sometimes lumped elements (capacitors and inductors) are semi-lumped elements, obtained by applying the method described in Section 6.5. 10 See Section 6.2. 9
AMPLIFIERS
11.2.4
425
Maximum gain impedance matching
In order to examine the effect of the matching networks, we initially assume their removal. The network in Figure 11.1 simplifies to the transistor with its bias networks, which do not affect the RF signal, by hypothesis. Denoting the transistor parameters with superscript ‘(Q)’, Equation (11.6) with Gs ¼ GL ¼ 0 then gives the power gain of the simplified amplifier 2 ðQÞ GT;mismatched ¼ s21 ð11:18Þ In this simplified configuration, the transistor input does not absorb all the power available from the generator, because of its non-zero reflection coefficient. The ratio between the available power from the generator and the one absorbed by the transistor input is PAV;generator ¼ Pin;transistor
1 2 ðQÞ 1s11
ð11:19Þ
Similarly, the output mismatch prevents the transistor output from transferring all its available power to the load. The ratio between the power available from the transistor output and the one transferred to the load is PAV;transistor ¼ Pload
1 2 ðQÞ 1s22
ð11:20Þ
After the transistor is input and output matched, the two ratios (11.19) and (11.20) become unitary. ðQÞ Assuming that the two matching networks are loss free and that the transistor is unilateral ðs12 ¼ 0Þ, the matched power gain increases by the two above-mentioned ratios, becoming 2 1 1 ðQÞ GT;matched ¼ ð11:21Þ 2 s21 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ 1s11 1s22 It is also possible to derive Equation (11.21) from (11.9). From assuming the transistor to be unilateral, it ðQÞ ðQÞ follows that that GIN ¼ s11 ; GOUT ¼ s22 , and therefore Equation (11.9) becomes 1jGS j2 ðQÞ 2 1jGL j2 GT ¼ 2 s21 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ 1s11 GS 1s22 GL
ð11:22Þ
From Equation (11.22), it follows that the maximum transducer gain is achieved when the factors 2 ðQÞ 2 ðQÞ 1jGs j2 Þ 1s11 Gs ; 1jGL j2 1s22 GL are at their maximum. Now, the two above-mentioned quantities are functions of the complex variables Gs ; GL and have the form 1jGj2 j1s Gj
2
¼
1jGj2 j1jsj jGjexpf j ½argðGÞ þ argðsÞgj2
with
0 jGj 1
ð11:23Þ
For any given jGj, the denominator of the factor (11.23) is minimum – then the whole function is 2 maximum –2when argðGÞ ¼ argðsÞ. Under this condition, the factor (11.23) becomes 1jGj 1jsj jGj , which is a function of the real variable jGj, rather than of the complex variable G. Moreover, lim 1jGj2 ð1jsj jGjÞ2 ¼ 1 and lim 1jGj2 ð1jsj jGjÞ2 ¼ 0 jG j ! 0
jG j ! 1
426
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Thus the maximum of the factor (11.22) falls somewhere within the range 0 jGj 1, and can be computed by the vanishing derivative i d h 1jGj2 ð1jsj jGjÞ2 ¼ 2ðjGjjsjÞð1jsj jGjÞ3 ¼ 0 if d jGj
jGj ¼ jsj ðQÞ*
ðQÞ*
Therefore, the first and third factor of the gain (11.22) reach their maxima when Gs ¼ s11 ; GL ¼ s22 ðQÞ 2 1 ðQÞ 2 1 and those maxima are equal to 1s11 ; 1s22 , respectively. The more the transistor is mismatched, the higher is the increase of gain produced by the matching networks. Equation (11.21) gives the absolutely maximum power gain achievable with perfectly matched devices using loss-free matching networks. Such a condition is theoretically possible at discrete frequencies by means of one of the networks described in Chapter 6, dimensioned to transform ðQÞ ðQÞ s11 ; s22 into 50 O at the frequency of interest. However, real transistors are never unilateral, rather their reverse transmission coefficient is nonzero, although its amplitude is smaller than that of the forward transmission coefficient.11 One consequence of this situation is that the input (output) reflection coefficient of the transistor depends on the impedance closing the output (input). The transistor [S] parameters are, by definition, ðQÞ ðQÞ measured with the ports terminated on 50 O. Then s11 ðs22 Þ is the input (output) reflection coefficient of the transistor, when the output (input) is closed on 50 O. Therefore, if we begin by matching the input, ðQÞ we have to design a network that transforms s11 into 50 O. Now, if we consider the effect of the input ðQÞ matching network, we can see that the output reflection of the device is no longer s22 . Nevertheless, we still could match the new output reflection coefficient into 50 O. Unfortunately, the output matching network modifies the transistor input reflection coefficient, degrading the input matching. To correct ðQÞ this, it should be possible to modify the input matching network in order to take the modified s11 ðQÞ into account, but this will change s22 , and so on. We get the same conclusion if we start from the output matching. Considering that one possibility to match a bilateral transistor is to proceed back and forth by modifying the input and output matching networks, such a procedure normally converges after some iterations and could be quite tedious, particularly for broad-band amplifiers. A more efficient and scientific approach is simultaneous conjugate matching. Equations (9.2) or (11.7), specialized to our case, give the input and output reflection coefficients of the transistor, which are respectively ðQÞ
ðQÞ
GIN ¼ s11 þ
ðQÞ ðQÞ
s21 s12 GML ðQÞ 1s22 GML
;
ðQÞ
ðQÞ
GOUT ¼ s22 þ
ðQÞ ðQÞ
s21 s12 GMS ðQÞ
1s11 GMS
ð11:24Þ
where GMS ; GML are the reflection coefficients presented to the transistor input and output by the respective matching networks. Input and output are simultaneously matched if GMS ¼ G*IN ;
11
GML ¼ G*OUT
For example, Table 9.2 gives . ðQÞ ðQÞ s12 s21
f ¼2 GHz
. f ¼10 GHz ðQÞ ðQÞ 53:8s12 s21 ffi 12:5
and the transistor in Table 9.3 has . ðQÞ ðQÞ s12 s21
f ¼1 GHz
. f ¼10 GHz ðQÞ ðQÞ 46:5s12 s21 ffi 15:4
ffi
ffi
ð11:25Þ
AMPLIFIERS
427
Combining the coefficients (11.24) with conditions (11.25), and after some manipulation, we obtain the reflection coefficients present at the transistor terminals for simultaneous matching qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi B1 B21 4jC1 j2 B2 B22 4jC2 j2 ; GML ¼ ð11:26Þ GMS ¼ 2C1 2C2 where 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ B1 ¼ 1 þ s11 s22 jDj2 2 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ B2 ¼ 1 þ s22 s11 jDj2 C1 ¼
ð11:27Þ
ðQÞ ðQÞ* s11 s22 D ðQÞ
ðQÞ*
C2 ¼ s22 s11 D and D is the quantity (11.13). The two equations in (11.26) return two different values each; however, only one of them has amplitude less than 1, and therefore is the good one. Moreover, if the transistor is potentially unstable, then both couples of values in (11.26) have unitary amplitude.12 This prevents design of the conjugate matching network, as we can easily demonstrate. Let us consider for instance the output matching network in the schematic of Figure 11.1. Let Gload be the generator reflection coefficient, clearly with jGload j < 1, and let us denote the scattering parameters of the output matching network by the superscript ‘(out)’. Neglecting the bias network, or considering it as part of the matching network, Equation (9.4) gives the maximum amplitude of the reflection coefficient seen by the transistor output ðoutÞ s22 þ jGload j Gout;P1 ðoutÞ 1 þ s22 jGload j where the equals sign applies for purely reactive matching networks ðoutÞ only. The above relation implies that Gout;P1 ¼ 1 if and only if s22 ¼ 1. Again, this is possible only if ðoutÞ ðoutÞ the matching network is loss free, and implies that s21 ¼ s12 ¼ 0. In other words, there is no transmission between the two ports of the network. Thus, a matching network can present a purely reactive load to the transistor only by isolating it from the load, and then transferring no power at all. Equivalently, we could assume that the load is purely resistive – any series reactance is considered as part of the matching network – and normalize the S parameters on the load resistance. In this case, the reflection coefficient seen by the transistor output coincides with the input one of the matching network, and has unitary amplitude only if the two ports of the matching network are isolated. Note that we assumed a generic value for the load reflection coefficient: the load impedance has no effect on our considerations, unless it is purely reactive by itself; in that case no active power transfer is possible to the load, independently of any other circumstances. The same considerations apply to the input matching network. The conclusion is that simultaneous conjugate matching is impossible if the transistor is potentially unstable. Once the reflection coefficients GMS ; GML are known, by means of Equations (11.26) and (11.27) we can dimension the matching network in the same way as for a unilateral transistor having G*MS ; G*ML as input and output reflection coefficients, respectively. 12
See the Mathcad file 07_Simultaneously_Conjugated_Matching.MCD.
428
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Substituting the coefficients (11.26) into the gain (11.6), we obtain the maximum transducer power gain of a non-unilateral perfectly matching transistor
GT;MAX
2 ðQÞ 2 1jGML j2 s21 1jGMS j ¼ 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ 1 s11 GMS þ s22 GML þ s12 s21 GMS GML þ s11 GMS s22 GML
ð11:28Þ
As can be seen, the coefficients GMS ¼ G*IN and GML ¼ G*OUT given by Equations (11.26) are not physically realizable if the transistor is unstable; then the maximum gain (11.28) is not achievable. The maximum gain for a potentially unstable transistor can be found by combining Equations (11.17) and (11.26) with (11.28), and after some manipulation the resulting expression is GT;MAX ¼
js21 j2 js12 j
2
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðK K 2 1Þ
ð11:29Þ
The transducer power gain (11.29) is a monotonically decreasing function of the stability factor, and reaches its maximum at the minimum stability condition ðK ¼ 1Þ. The resulting value is the maximum stable gain GMSG ¼
js21 j2 js12 j2
ð11:30Þ
The value in (11.30) is the maximum theoretically achievable by the amplifier in Figure 11.1, if the matching networks present the minimum possible dissipation loss needed for transistor stabilization. Amplifiers employing potentially unstable transistors need to be stabilized, particularly when the termination impedances are not exactly known, or are variable.13 In the latter case, one of the possible terminating impedances could be such that the reflection coefficient seen by the transistor comes from the stability region, with the consequent risk of oscillations. Stabilization prevents the use of purely reactive matching networks, in that they can move the unstable regions from one portion of the Smith chart to another, always remainining within the unit circle ðjGj ¼ 1Þ. Instead, we need to push the unstable regions out of the Smith chart. Thus, lossy matching networks are required. Therefore, input and/or output matching networks must include resistors: they could be either lumped or loss elements in non-ideal reactive elements. Fano limits do not apply to resistive matching networks. Therefore any return loss is theoretically achievable over arbitrarily wide bandwidths. On the other hand, good matching is obtained at the expense of amplifier gain, since resistive matching networks absorb part – sometimes relevant – of the power. The gain with simultaneous matching is the maximum possible: as the generator (load) reflection coefficient differs from GMS ðGML Þ, the gain decreases accordingly. The terminating reflection coefficients producing the same gain constitute loci in the G plane, having the form of circles, known as constant gain circles. The complete treatment of the gain circles involves many cases: input and output, transducer, available and operating power gain with unilateral, bilateral stable and unstable transistors. The interested reader can find more details in [1]; also most of the high-frequency circuit simulators can plot all the gain circles. Here, we will limit our presentation – without demonstrations – to the case of the available gain of a perfectly output matched amplifier, with a bilateral stable transistor. Under these assumptions, the available and transducer power gain coincide. The constant available loci are circles in the input reflection
13 Several factors determine the impedance variability, like realization tolerances or variable working conditions. Amplifiers connected to multiple sources and/or loads, selectable by means of switches, is a typical case of variable termination.
AMPLIFIERS coefficient plane ðGS Þ having centre and radius vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi u 2 GA ðQÞ* ðQÞ * u12K sðQÞ sðQÞ GA þ sðQÞ sðQÞ 2 GA 4 2 s11 s22 D t 12 21 12 21 2 ðQÞ ðQÞ ðQÞ s21 s21 s21
; RA ¼ CA ¼ 2 GA ðQÞ 2 G 1 þ 2 s11 jDj2 ðQÞ A 2 ðQÞ 1 þ s11 2 jDj s21 ðQÞ s21
429
ð11:31Þ
where GA is the available gain obtained when the input reflection coefficient moves around the circle. Constant gain circles give an intuitive representation of the gain sensitivity to the input output reflection coefficients: a Smith chart region populated with many (few) gain circles indicates a high (low) sensitivity. Normally, the transistor forward transmission coefficient and maximum gain decrease with frequency, with a slope of about 20 dB/decade. This behaviour has two main effects on the matching network design: 1. If caution is not used, the amplifier gain tends to increase at low frequency. Sometimes, the lowfrequency gain could be higher than the in-band value. Under this condition, out-of-band signals – including noise – can reduce the amplifier’s dynamic range, by causing intermodulation with the useful signals. The extreme case is that relatively strong low-frequency input signals saturate the amplifier, totally compromising its working. Therefore, high-pass matching networks are preferable in respect of low-pass ones, because the lack of mismatch associated gain decreases the gain at frequencies lower than the minimum operating one, contrasting the natural increase of the transistor gain. 2. The natural decrease of the gain at low frequencies, combined with the limits on wide-band impedance matching stated by the Fano inequalities, lead to an interesting design strategy for broad-band amplifiers. The transistor is matched at the maximum frequency only; at lower frequencies, a controlled mismatching compensates for the device gain increase and flattens it out.
11.3 Low-noise amplifiers Amplifiers add noise to the amplified signal. It is important that the added noise is as low as possible, particularly if the signals to be amplified are weak. We can express this concept in quantitative terms, by saying that the noise figure14 of the amplifier must be kept to a minimum. The noise factor of a generic linear two-port network is given by Equation (9.29). We can rewrite it as F ¼ Fmin þ
2 Rn YS Yopt ReðYS Þ
ð11:32Þ
where YS is the admittance terminating the network input. The second term in the final member of Equation (11.32) is always non-negative, because so the noise resistance Rn and the generator admittance ReðYs Þ are. Thus, the noise factor reaches its minimum Fmin if the above-mentioned term vanishes, which means YS ¼ Yopt . The parameter Rn determines how fast the noise factor increases for a given deviation of the generator admittance from Yopt . Note that the noise factor depends on the input admittance only, not on the output. All the above considerations apply to any linear two-port network, in particular to transistors and amplifiers. However, in the case of a complete amplifier, the only relevant parameter is the noise figure on 50 O, since that is the working impedance. The case of a single transistor is different, because the 14
See Section 9.4.2 for the definition of noise figure and noise factor.
430
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Noise figure meter
SPDT 1
C gg
Γs Stub tuner
Cdd
DUT
Ldd
Lgg
2 Rdd
Rgg
+ +
Vdd
Vgg output bias input bias
Network analyzer
Figure 11.3
Setup for the measurement of transistor noise parameters.
complete noise parameter set is needed to get the best noise performance in the complete amplifier. Design of a low-noise amplifier (LNA) having the configuration of Figure 11.1 consists of designing an input matching network that presents an admittance to the transistor input as close as possible to Yopt . Equation (11.32) suggests a method for the measurement of the noise parameters of a two-port network, and of a transistor in particular, based on multiple noise factor measurements with different input impedances. Figure 11.3 shows the test set needed to implement the noise parameter measurement of the transistor.15 The noise figure meter measures the transistor noise figure with different input loads, provided by the stub tuner. The network analyzer measures the impedance presented to the transistor input. The two T-bias networks16 do not affect the measurement because they are calibrated out. Possible differences in the two paths of the SPDT are also taken into account by specific calibration techniques. The measurement procedure consists of the following steps: 1. With the SPDT in position 1, modify the generator admittance by means of the stub tuner, to minimize the noise figure measured by the noise figure meter. The corresponding noise factor is Fmin . 2. Keep the stub tuner in the condition found in 1 and the SPDT in position 2. The admittance measured by the network analyzer is Yopt . 15 Section 17.6 describes network analyzer noise and the noise figure meter, while Section 6.5 describes the matching network with line and stub. The stub tuner has the structure of Figure 6.11, stub and line impedances are usually 50 O, but the stub length y2 and its position along the line y1 vary with micrometric adjustments. The most sophisticated devices include computer-controlled motors to change y1 and y2 . Sometimes, a double stub tuner is used, which has two variable stubs in fixed positions, like the one in Figure 6.13. Both types of devices are capable of presenting any real part immittance, at least in principle. 16 Bias networks are sometimes referred to as T-bias, in this context.
AMPLIFIERS
431
3. Normally 1=Yopt is different from 50 O. In order to exploit this difference, measure the noise figure on 50 O, F50 O . Set SPDT in position 2, and adjust the stub tuner to minimize the reflection coefficient measured by the network analyzer. In that condition, move the SPDT to position 1: the measured noise factor coincides with F50 O . 4. Equation (11.32) states that the noise resistance is a function of the parameters taken at the points 1 to 3, i.e. R0 Rn ¼ ðF50 O Fmin Þ 1R0 Yopt 2 Note that when the SPDT is in position 2, the voltage Vdd is applied to the network analyzer test port. This could be dangerous for the instrument, depending on the voltage and the instrument type itself. Therefore, it is advisable to switch Vdd off, before setting the SPDT on position 2. We can develop more considerations of the low-noise amplifier by expressing the noise factor in terms of reflection coefficients rather than admittances. The generator and the optimum admittances are related to their respective coefficients as Ys ¼
1 1Gs ; R0 1 þ Gs
Yopt ¼
1 1Gopt R0 1 þ Gopt
Substituting the above expressions into Equation (11.32), we obtain Gopt Gs 2 Rn F ¼ Fmin þ 4 R0 1jGs j2 1 þ Gopt 2
ð11:33Þ
For any noise factor F > Fmin, Equation (11.33) returns the values of the reflection coefficient Gs that produce F. All the values of Gs corresponding to a constant F > Fmin lie on circles, known as constant noise circles. With a procedure similar to the one used for the stability circles we can determine centre CF and radius RF of the constant noise circles, finding Gopt 2 FFmin R0 1þ 1 þ Gopt 4 Rn 2 vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi FFmin R0 2 1 þ Gopt u u 1Gopt 4 Rn u RF ¼ 2 t1 þ FFmin R0 FFmin R0 1 þ Gopt 2 1þ 1 þ Gopt 4 Rn 4 Rn CF ¼
ð11:34Þ
As seen for the constant gain circle, a region of the plane Gs densely populated by noise circles denotes a high sensitivity of the noise factor to the input reflection coefficient. Notice that GMS does not coincide with Gopt , therefore the input matching network designed for the minimum noise factor does not give the maximum gain, and vice versa. Thus, input matching network design can pursue the minimum noise, the maximum gain or a compromise between them. However, the lack of gain associated with the minimum noise figure involves an input mismatch. For instance, if the gain associated with Gopt is 1 dB lower than the maximum, then the input return loss for the minimum noise is 10 log10 ð1101=10 Þ 6:9 dB. This relatively bad input matching could compromise the performance of a chain including the amplifier, due to the amplitude and phase ripple associated with the input mismatch, as discussed in Section 9.2. A common technique for moving the maximum gain point closer to the minimum noise one consists of adding a series inductor to the ground connection of the source or emitter. The stabilization – if needed – of a transistor for LNA application has to be done preferably with resistors in the output matching network, rather than in the input one. Equation (9.32) together with some
432
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
simplified considerations gives a reasonable justification for that criterion. Let us initially cascade a resistive attenuator to the transistor input: the resulting noise factor from Equation (9.32) is Fattenuator þ transistor ¼ Fattenuator þ
Ftransistor 1 GA;attenuator
Passing from the noise factor to the noise figure, and remembering that resistive attenuators have the noise figure coincident with the attenuation (both in dB), we get NFattenuator þ transistor ¼ ILattenuator þ NFtransistor
ð11:35Þ
where ILattenuator is the attenuation in dB of the attenuator. Equation (11.35) states that an attenuator cascaded with the input of a linear two-port network increases the resulting noise figure by its attenuation. Now, in order to evaluate the effect of the loss in the output matching network, let us decide to connect the same attenuator as above in cascade with the transistor output. The resulting noise figure will be h i NFtransistor þ attenuator ¼ NFtransistor þ 10 log10 1 þ 10ILattenuator =10 1 10ðGA;transistor NFtransistor Þ=10 ð11:36Þ Both Equations (11.35) and (11.36) present an additional positive term to the transistor noise figure. Thus, the noise figure (11.36) is smaller than the noise figure (11.35) if h i 10 log10 1 þ 10ILattenuator =10 1 10ðGA;transistor NFtransistor Þ=10 < ILattenuator which occurs if GA;transistor > NFtransistor . Therefore, attenuation in the output degrades the noise performances of the amplifier less than the same attenuation placed in the input, if the gain of the transistor exceeds its noise figure. Note that the transistor gain considered in Equation (11.36) includes the contribution of the matching networks, thus it is typically higher than the noise figure. However, in all these considerations we used the same input and output attenuation: transistor stabilization on the input matching could require quite different attenuation than in the output. The last aspect to consider is the bias point of the transistor. The noise parameters of the transistor are bias dependent, like the scattering parameters. Usually, the bias point giving the minimum possible noise figure is different from the one giving the maximum gain, and from the one giving the maximum power as well. Consequently, the choice of bias point is the result of a compromise among the various performances, similar to the input reflection coefficient.
11.4 Design of trial amplifier This section presents the application of the concepts discussed in Sections 11.2 and 11.3 to the design of a trial amplifier. The transistor of our amplifier is a MESFET having the scattering parameters listed in Table 9.2. First of all we will examine the stability of the transistor over all its specified frequency range, from 2 to 10 GHz. Equation (11.17) applied to the parameters in Table 9.2 gives17 K < 1 over all the frequency range, with a minimum K ¼ 0:11. Equivalently, we can examine the stability circles18 plotted in Figure 11.4. They invade the upper half of the Smith chart, particularly the output ones that occupy almost all the inductive portion of the Smith chart. 17 See the Mathcad file 07_Simultaneously_Conjugated_Matching.MCD and the Ansoft file 01_Unilateral_ and_Bilateral_Matching.adsn, graph ‘A_Stabilities’. 18 See the Ansoft file 01_Unilateral_and_Bilateral_Matching.adsn, graph ‘H_Minimum_Noise_Figures’.
AMPLIFIERS
433
Figure 11.4 Input (black) and output (grey) stability circles of the transistor having the scattering parameters as in Table 9.2. The next step in our design consists of stabilizing the transistor. As a first attempt, we can see the effect of a resistive attenuator placed at the input and at the output of the transistor. From the analysis of the two cascaded components, it follows that the minimum input (output) attenuation for critical stability is 2 (10). This result is in good agreement with the disposition of the transistor stability regions, and confirms that the output is more critical for the stability. Equation (11.35) implies that 2 dB of attenuation at the transistor input degrades its noise figure exactly by the same amount: NFattenuator þ transistor ¼ 2 þ NFtransistor We can approximately predict the noise figure degradation due to a 10 dB output attenuator, by means of Equation (11.36). Assuming some reasonable numbers, like GA;transistor 12 dB and NFtransistor 1 dB, the result is h i NFtransistor þ attenuator ¼ NFtransistor þ 10 log10 1 þ 1010=10 1 10ð122Þ=10 ffi NFtransistor þ 2:79 Thus the configuration with resistors in the input matching network is more promising, in terms of gain (8 dB better) and in terms of noise figure (0.79 dB better) than the one with resistors in the output matching network. Moreover, the output power will also be higher, due to the absence of losses from the transistor output to the load. Let us momentarily consider the transistor and the input stabilizing elements, by ignoring bias and matching networks, and short-circuiting the source inductor Ls1. The subnetwork that we initially consider consists of the transistor together with the resistors Rg1 ; Rg2 and the capacitors Cg1 ; Cg2 . The resulting two-port network has the node n1 as input and the collector of Q1 as output. For the capacitors, Cg2 ¼ 10 pF is large enough to consider the node n3 as a high-frequency ground, Cg1 ¼ 1 pF gives a relatively low impedance at 8 GHz, while reducing the low-frequency gain.19 The low RF impedance to 19 The reactance associated with 10 pF at 2 and 10 GHz is 1=ð2p 2 109 10 1012 Þ ffi 8 O and 1:6 O respectively; the series reactance associated with 1 pF is 10 times higher.
434
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 11.5 Input stability circles of the transistor of Table 9.3, with (black) and without (grey) stabilization resistors at the input.
ground of the node n3 allows us to use it to inject the gate bias voltage, with a minimum perturbation of the high-frequency working of the matching network, while Cg1 isolates the gate from the amplifier input at DC. The values Rg1 ¼ 10 O; Rg2 ¼ 150 O have been found by tuning. them up to reach stability while minimizing the loss. By comparison, formulae (7.9) give20 for a 50 O T-type attenuator Rg1 ffi 5:7 O; Rg2 ffi 215 O: our network has slightly lower series and shunt resistance, then comparable attenuation as well. Figure 11.5 shows the effect of Rg1 ; Rg2 ; Cg2 on the input stability circles that fall completely outside of the Smith chart, so the output ones do too, although they are not shown. Figure 11.6 shows the electrical schematic of the complete amplifier. 20
See Mathcad file 08_Passive_T_Attenuator.MCD.
AMPLIFIERS
435
NT2 : output bias and matching NT1 : input stabilization, bias, and matching TL g1
Input TL g2
n1Cg1 n2 Rg1 Rg2 n3
TLd1
Q1
n4
TLd2
n6 Cd1
Output
TLd3 Z g1
Ls1
Zg1
Cg2
n5 Cd2
+ Vdd
+ Vgg
Figure 11.6
Electrical diagram of the amplifier.
After stabilizing the transistor, we can consider the conjugate matching coefficients, in particular the values at 8 GHz. Figure 11.7 shows the scattering parameters of the stabilized transistor, their complex conjugates and the conjugate matching coefficients. Note that the latter two couples are slightly different, since the two-port network is non-unilateral. Figure 11.8a shows the constant gain and constant noise figure circles as black and grey curves, respectively. As anticipated in Section 11.3, the input reflection for the maximum gain is different from the one for the minimum noise. More precisely, the minimum noise figure of 4.3 dB corresponds to a gain slightly higher than 7.4 dB, while the maximum gain of 9.3 dB corresponds to a noise figure slightly higher than 5.5 dB. The input matching design can pursue the minimum noise, the maximum gain or any compromise between them. In particular, the input return loss for the minimum noise is about 10 log10 ð110ð7:49:3Þ=10 Þ ffi 4:5 dB, which is critical in most applications. The addition of one inductor in series with the source moves the optimum gain closer to the optimum noise, and a better compromise is achievable. The schematic in Figure 11.6 shows that component, labelled as Ls1 . The source series inductor is a form of feedback that reduces not only the transistor gain, but also the instability, then, after less attenuation is required in the matching networks, partially compensates the lack of gain. The choice of Ls1 is the result of some attempts with some values, each of them considering the positions of GMS ; Gopt ; GT;max ; and minðKÞ, where the last parameter indicates how much loss is required to stabilize the transistor. A good solution was found to be Ls1 ¼ 200 pH. This choice allows a reduction in the series and increases the shunt resistance in the input matching network: their values become Rg1 ¼ 5 O; Rg2 ¼ 300 O. Figure 11.8b shows the gain and noise circles of the two-port network consisting of the transistor with the added series source inductor and the stabilizing elements. Comparing Figure 11.8b with Figure 11.8a, we can see that GMS ; Gopt are now closer, the minimum noise figure being 2.8 dB instead of 4.3 dB, due to the reduced input attenuation, and the maximum gain being 8.8 dB instead of 9.3 dB. Summarizing, the source inductor improved the minimum noise figure by 1.5 dB while degrading the maximum gain by 0.5 dB only. The new gain–noise compromises are 8.8 or 7.7 dB of gain with 3.6 or 2.8 dB of noise figure. The input return loss for the minimum noise is then 10 log10 ð110ð7:78:8Þ=10 Þ ffi 6:5 dB, or 2 dB better than without the inductor, but still not good enough for many applications. Therefore we decided to pursue the maximum gain (perfect input matching) and accept the noise figure of 3.6 dB, 0.8 worse than in the optimum case. At this point, the design of the matching networks is quite straightforward. Beginning with the input, looking at the node n1, we have GMS ¼ 0:025 þ j 0:738, corresponding to the admittance YMS ¼ 5:69 103 j 0:019. The imaginary part of YMS can be realized with either a shunt inductor or a short-circuit stub shorter than l=4. We chose the second option, with characteristic impedance Z0 ¼ 70 O, its electrical length at 8 GHz being found by imposing the stub susceptance to be equal to the imaginary part of YMS . Therefore
436
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 11.7 Reflection coefficients of the transistor in Figure 11.6 together with its stabilization elements. Input at the node n1, output at the transistor drain, and Rg1 ¼ 10 O; Rg2 ¼ 150 O; Cg1 ¼ 1 pF; Cg2 ¼ 10 pF; Ls1 ¼ 0. ½ j Z0 tanðyÞ1 ¼ j ImðYMS Þ ) y ¼ tan1 ð1=0:019 1=70Þ, corresponding to an electrical length of 37.66. After connecting the parallel short-circuit stub, the imaginary part of YMS vanishes, and the resulting 0 ¼ 1=ReðYMS Þ ¼ 175:62 O. That resistive value can be easily matched with a l=4 impedance is ZMS 0 transmission line transformer, whose characteristic impedance is the geometric mean of ZMS and 50 O: the resulting value is 93.7 O. With reference to Figure 11.6, the characteristic impedance and electrical length of TLg1, TLg2 are 93:7 O; 90 and 70 O; 37:66 , respectively. The amplifier now includes the complete input matching and bias network. Considering the two-port network having the amplifier input as input and the transistor collector as output, we have GMS ¼ 0:406 þ j 0:537, corresponding to an impedance of ZMS ¼ 42:58 þ j 83:82. As in the input matching network, the impedance to be realized is inductive. In this case, we will use a series inductor, instead of a shunt one, realized with a short high-impedance line, applying the semi-lumped concepts.21 We will use 21
See Section 7.5.
AMPLIFIERS
437
Figure 11.8 Constant gain (black) and constant noise (grey) circles of the transistor in Figure 11.6 together with its stabilizing elements. The input of the two-port network is the node n1, the output is the transistor drain Cg1 ¼ 10 pF; Cg2 ¼ 10 pF: (a) Rg1 ¼ 10 O; Rg2 ¼ 150 O; Ls1 ¼ 0; (b) Rg1 ¼ 5 O; Rg2 ¼ 300 O; Ls1 ¼ 200 pH.
438
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 8
10
2.0
10
6
0 -5
s22 4
0 NF
NF, dB
20 log10(|s21|)
s11
-10 -15
K 2
-5
-20
1.5
K
s21
5
20 log10(|s11|), 20 log10 (|s11|)
5
-25 0
-10 6
7
8 Frequency, GHz
Figure 11.9
9
-30
1.0
10
Performances of the amplifier in Figure 11.6.
a 90 O transmission line (TLd1 ), tuning its length until GMS falls on the zero-reactance line, obtaining an 0 0 ffi 42:58. Note that ZMS does not electrical length of about 40 . The resulting transistor impedance is ZMS exactly coincide with ReðZMS Þ, due to the unwanted shunt reactance associated with the semi-lumped inductor. Before completing the matching network design by adding a l=4 transformer (TLd2 ), we need to add the bias network. For this reason, we place a 1 pF capacitor ðCd1 Þ between the transformer and the amplifier output. This element involves a slight modification of both TLd1 and TLd2, with the resulting characteristic impedances and electrical lengths 90 O; 41 and 35:5 O; 90 , respectively. The addition of a drain bias element completes the amplifier. That structure consists of the l=4 90 O line TLd3 and the 10 pF capacitor to ground Cd2 . For the same reasons as for the input matching network, the node n5 is a high-frequency ground. Thus, TLd3 transforms the low impedance on n5 into high impedance in shunt with the node n6 . The consequent effect on the output matching network is negligible at 8 GHz, while the direct current can flow from the bias port Vdd to the transistor drain. Figure 11.9 shows the performances of the complete amplifier. Note that the stability factor is always greater than 1, at 8 GHz the gain22 is 8.8 dB and the noise figure is 3.6, as expected. Moreover, the minimum noise figure is reached at around 9 GHz, due to the better noise input matching at that frequency. Finally, the amplifier presents the maximum gain at a frequency slightly lower than 8 GHz, despite the use of high-pass elements in the matching networks, due to the natural high-frequency roll-off of the transistor gain. Figure 11.10a shows one of the possible physical layouts23 of the amplifier, realized with hybrid technology on an alumina substrate, having er ¼ 9:8; h ¼ 254 mm. The transistor and the capacitors are chip devices, connected to the microstrip lines by means of bond wires.24 The resistors are realized directly on the substrate, using thin-film technology. Via holes realize all the required ground connections. All the transmission lines used for the amplifier have five different characteristic impedances: 93.7, 90, 70, 50 and 35.5 O. A numerical inversion of the analysis formula (3.224) gives the corresponding From 7.5 to 8.5 GHz, 7:9 < 20 log10 ðs21 Þ < 8:9 and 3:5 dB < NF < 4:2 dB. See also the Ansoft file 02_Bilateral_Matching_Layout.adsn. 24 The bond wires add a series inductance, which can be characterized as shown in the reference [2]. 22 23
AMPLIFIERS
439
Figure 11.10 Physical realizations of the schematic in Figure 11.6: (a) straightforward solution; (b) more compact configuration.
widths 0.044, 0.05, 0.11, 0.254 and 0.477 mm. Entering these widths into Equation (3.182), we get the effective relative dielectric constants of 6.1, 6.1, 6.4, 6.8 and 7.2. From the electrical length at a specified frequency, and the effective permittivity, we obtain the physical length of all the transmission lines lphysical ¼
lelectrical ð f0 Þ 75 1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 90 f0 ee f f
Once all the physical lengths for all the transmission lines are determined, the amplifier design is still not complete, because of the parasitic effects associated with T junctions, step discontinuities, finite impedance of the via holes, bond wire inductance,25 and so on. The final design step consists of 25
The scattering parameters of the transistor include the bond wires, but this is not the case with the capacitors.
440
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
analyzing the circuit26 and modifying the microstrip parameters until the response of the circuit is reasonably close to the ideal case. The layout in Figure 11.10a has a total size of 11 7 mm, including two 50 O lines at input and output. Figure 11.10b shows a more sophisticated realization with a more compact layout, having a size of 7 5 mm: it is derived from the one in Figure 11.10a by folding TLg1 and replacing the output transformer TLd2 with a semi-lumped realization of the network in Figure 6.15a. For the latter element, TL0d2 is the combination of TLd1 and the transmission line corresponding to Lb , and the 50 O open stub TL0d2 realizes a capacitive impedance to ground, corresponding to Cb .
11.5 Power amplifiers The definition of a power amplifier (PA) is somewhat arbitrary. A widely used – although not rigorous – criterion is that a power amplifier is an amplifier whose output power is close to its 1 dB compression point. Under that condition, the nonlinear aspects of the active device are not negligible. By contrast, Sections 11.2 to 11.4 assumed that the transistor is a purely linear device. These sections limit consideration to the influence of DC generators and bias networks as elements of the matching networks, with possible side effects on the gain and noise figure. Moreover, the only effect of the bias point is to change the scattering and noise parameters of the transistor. Finally, the transistor DC power is solely dependent on the DC bias point, not on the RF signal amplitude. The main limitation of this approach is that it gives no idea of how to determine the maximum RF output that the amplifier is able to deliver. In the present section we will examine some of these missed aspects, analyzing how transistor characteristics, working point and load impedance determine the amplifier output power. Subsequently, some basic concepts on the different working classes of power amplifiers will be given. Complex amplifier configurations complete the section.
11.5.1
Output power optimization with negligible transistor parasitics
This section describes some basic techniques to get the maximum RF output power from a given transistor. The concepts presented follow from analyzing how transistors convert DC into RF power, and the associated limitation factors. Moreover, this section assumes that the transistor output current is nonzero for the entire cycle of the RF signal. Such operation is usually referred to as class A. Momentarily we will use this denomination for brevity. Section 11.5.5 below deals with the different output current waveform types, or amplifier classes. In order to investigate the effects of transistor characteristics, DC working point and output load, we will initially consider the structure in Figure 11.11 derived from the one in Figure 11.1. As in the original network, the symbol for the transistor in Figure 11.11 is one FET, but it represents a generic device. In the BJT case, base current Ib , collector current Ice and collector–emitter voltage Vce replace gate–source voltage Vgs , drain current Ids and drain–source voltage Vds , respectively. In the following considerations, the variables Vds;ce ; Ids;ce will denote the generic drain–source or collector–emitter voltage and current, respectively. Similarly, the variable xin represents either the gate–source voltage or the base current, depending on the actual case.
26
See the Ansoft file 02_Bilateral_Matching_Layout.adsn.
AMPLIFIERS
441
+ Ldd
Vq
Isupply
Cdd
ILOAD
I ds , Ice Cgg ZS
Vgs, I b
Vds, Vce Q1
VLOAD RLOAD
L gg +
VRF
Figure 11.11
Vgg
Conceptual configuration of a single transistor amplifier.
Compared with the network in Figure 11.1, the one in Figure 11.11 has some simplifications and additional specifications: 1. The two resistors in series with the two DC generators are not indicated. 2. The bias networks are purely ideal, in that the two inductances Lgg ; Ldd and the two capacitances Cgg ; Cdd assume infinite value. This way, the inductors (capacitors) offer zero (infinite) DC impedance and infinite (zero) impedance at high frequencies. 3. Input and output matching networks are not indicated. 4. The input sinusoidal RF generator with its series impedance Zs delivers enough power to the transistor input to modulate the output current sufficiently. 5. The resistor RLOAD models the impedance – assumed to be resistive – that the output matching network presents to the transistor output. 6. The transistor is purely unilateral, and no reactive parasitic elements connect with its output. 7. The transistor DC curves are perfectly horizontal in their pentode region. In a MESFET or BJT, this means that l ¼ 0 or VAF ¼ 1, respectively, as from the model equations (9.75), (9.79) or (9.81). 8. The triode region of the device degenerates into the single point Vds;ce ¼ 0. In a MESFET modelled by Equation (9.75) or (9.79), this is equivalent to assuming the parameter a tends to infinity. 9. The Ids;ce corresponding to equal increments of xin are equispaced. In other words, we will assume the transistor output current is linearly dependent on the input excitation, Ids;ce ¼ B1 xin þ B0 , where B1, B0 are two constants. 10. The transistor input behaves like a linear network. Assumptions 1, 3 and 4 are just to simplify our description, and have no important implication. The simplification 2 implies no lack of generality, in that any non-ideal element in the bias networks can be considered as being part of the corresponding matching network. The remaining hypotheses are needed to allow a relatively easy analytical treatment of the problem.
442
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Ice , Ids
Ice , Ids
Increasing Ib , Vgs
Ix = Vq /R LOAD + Iq 2I q Iq α
Vq
χ
β
β
t
α, χ
2 Vq Vce, Vds Vx = Vq + Iq R LOAD V ce, Vds
α β, χ
t
Figure 11.12 DC curves of the transistor used in Figure 11.11 (upper left), output current (upper right) and voltage (lower left) waveforms of the same transistor. Figure 11.12 shows the DC curves of our hypothetical quasi-ideal device, based on assumptions 7 to 9. The transistor derived from those hypotheses is an almost ideal VCCS or CCCS. The non-ideality is that it can only supply positive currents and only if a positive voltage is present on its output terminal. Therefore, the network in Figure 11.11 behaves as a linear one until the transistor output voltage and current are non- negative. Under this condition, we can analyze the circuit by superimposing the effects due to DC and RF generators. It is possible to replace the second part of hypothesis 6 with the assumption that the output matching network – combined with the transistor parasitics – presents a resistive impedance to the transistor-controlled generator. According to assumptions 4 and 8 to 10, the transistor output current is the sum of a DC term due to the input bias, plus one sinusoidal term due to the RF generator, i.e. Ids;ce ðtÞ ¼ Iq þ Ipeak sinðo0 tÞ
ð11:37Þ
The term Iq in the above expression is the quiescent current of the amplifier, defined as the one that Vq supplies in the absence of an RF input signal. Our approximated model is valid until Ids;ce 0, therefore the quiescent current must not be less than the RF peak current, Iq Ipeak . Under this hypothesis, the direct current of a class A amplifier is independent of the input signal, and thus from the output power. The DC block capacitor Cdd allows only high-frequency current to flow through. Then the current through RLOAD , which coincides with the one through Cdd , is ILOAD ðtÞ ¼ ILOAD;peak sinðo0 tÞ
ð11:38Þ
The current supplied by the DC generator Vq, which coincides with the one through the inductor Ldd , is the sum of the quantities (11.37) and (11.38). Moreover, no RF current can flow through the inductor Ldd , because of specification 2. Thus Isupply ðtÞ ¼ Ids;ce ðtÞ þ ILOAD ðtÞ ¼ Iq þ ðIpeak þ ILOAD;peak Þ sinðo0 tÞ ¼ Iq
ð11:39Þ
Equation (11.39) implies that Ipeak ¼ ILOAD;peak , consequently the load current in Equation (11.38) becomes ILOAD ðtÞ ¼ Ipeak sinðo0 tÞ ð11:40Þ The load voltage equals the current (11.40) multiplied by the resistance RLOAD itself. Then, applying the superimposition of the effects due to Vq and VLOAD to the transistor output voltage, we have Vds;ce ðtÞ ¼ Vq RLOAD Ipeak sinðo0 tÞ
ð11:41Þ
AMPLIFIERS
443
Similar to what was considered for Equation (11.37), our model is valid until Vds;ce 0. Thus, RLOAD Ipeak Vq must apply and consequently the load peak voltage must not be greater than Vq as well. Extracting the factor Ipeak sinðo0 tÞ from Equation (11.41) and substituting the result into (11.38), we obtain the relation between the transistor output current and voltage Ids;ce ðtÞ ¼ Iq þ
Vq Vds;ce ðtÞ RLOAD RLOAD
ð11:42Þ
Expression (11.42) is the well-known load line equation, which describes a straight line passing through the point ðVq ; Iq Þ. The intersections of the load line with the coordinate axes Vds;ce ðIds;ce Þ are found by imposing Ids;ce ¼ 0 ðVds;ce ¼ 0Þ; then the resulting values are Vx ¼ RLOAD Iq þ Vq ðIx ¼ Iq þ Vq R1 LOAD Þ. Figure 11.11 shows three load lines, together with the corresponding transistor voltage and currents, for three cases: (a) RLOAD < Vq =Iq . In this case the quiescent current is the limiting factor for the RF output peak voltage, which has a maximum value of Iq RLOAD . The corresponding RF output power is PLOAD;a ¼ ðIq RLOAD Þ2 =ð2 RLOAD Þ ¼ 0:5 Iq2 RLOAD . Therefore, the amplifier output power increases with the load resistance. (b) RLOAD > Vq =Iq . In this case, the load peak voltage limitation comes from the output supply voltage. The maximum output peak voltage equals Vq , with a resulting power of PLOAD;b ¼ 0:5 Vq2 R1 LOAD . The output power decreases with the load resistance, opposite to case (a). (c) RLOAD ¼ RLOAD;w ¼ Vq =Iq . In this case the two limiting factors (a) and (b) give the same result. The maximum power is PLOAD;w ¼ 0:5 Iq2 RLOAD ¼ 0:5 Vq2 R1 LOAD ¼ 0:5 Vq Iq . Combining the three output power expressions, obtained for (a) to (c), we get
PLOAD;max
8 2 Iq RLOAD > > > > > 2 > > > > < I2R Vq2 Vq Iq q LOAD ¼ ¼ ¼ > 2 2 R 2 LOAD > > > > 2 > V > q > > : 2 RLOAD
Vq RLOAD < Iq
Vq RLOAD ¼ Iq
Vq RLOAD > Iq
ð11:43Þ
Equation (11.43) states that the optimum load for the maximum output power is the one as in case (c). Thus, in our simplified hypotheses, the output matching network designed to maximize the output power has to transform the 50 O into RLOAD;w ¼ Vq =Iq . Under this condition, Vds;ce ranges from zero to 2 Vq , and this maximum must be lower than the device breakdown, with some margin. Therefore the DC voltage applied to the transistor output electrode has to be smaller than half of the breakdown voltage of the drain–gate or collector–base junction. Similarly, the output current voltage is a sinusoid with zero as the minimum and 2 Iq as the maximum. Thus, the quiescent current needs to be lower than the maximum allowed current for the transistor, as specified by the manufacturer. Note that, if the load resistance becomes higher than RLOAD;w , then the positive peak of Vds;ce becomes higher than 2 Vq , with a consequent risk of permanent damage to the device. From Equation (11.39) and subsequent considerations, it follows that the DC output current from the generator Vq coincides with Iq, independently of RLOAD . The DC power absorbed from the amplifier – also known as DC input power – is then PDC ¼ Vq Iq
ð11:44Þ
444
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The quantity in (11.44) neglects the RF and DC power absorbed from the input, which is usually a small fraction of PDC itself. One important performance of PAs is their capability to deliver high RF power with a DC power consumption that is as small as possible. The quantitative parameter for this characteristic is the drain or collector efficiency or, more briefly, the efficiency, defined as Z¼
PLOAD PDC
ð11:45Þ
Another important definition is the power added efficiency (PAE), which takes the RF input power into account
PLOAD PIN PLOAD G1 1 P PLOAD ¼ ¼ 1 Z ð11:46Þ PAE ¼ PDC PDC GP The reason for the adjective ‘added’ is because the definition of PAE removes the input contribution to the RF power; PAE tends to Z when the operating power gain tends to infinity. Usually both the quantities in (11.45) and (11.46) are expressed in per cent. In our case, Equations (11.43) and (11.44) give maximum RF power and DC power of the amplifier. In the best case, for RLOAD ¼ RLOAD;w ¼ Vq =Iq and with the output current at its maximum swing, we also have the maximum efficiency of 50%: Zmax ¼
Vq Iq =2 ¼ 50% Vq Iq
The total DC input power is equal to the sum of the RF power delivered to the load plus the one dissipated by the transistor. This latter is
PLOAD Z ð11:47Þ PDC ¼ 1 Vq I q Ptransistor ¼ PDC PLOAD ¼ 1 100 PDC From Equations (11.43) to (11.47) it follows that the amplifier efficiency vanishes if there is no input signal. Under that condition, the transistor power dissipation is at its maximum, Ptransistor;max ¼ Vq Iq , and decreases up to half this value when the RF output power is at its absolute maximum. Note that a PA with RLOAD ¼ RLOAD;w ¼ Vq =Iq presents a low-output return loss. In our simplified model, the transistor DC curves are perfectly horizontal; then the associated device output resistance Rds;ce ¼ ð@Ids;ce =@Vds;ce Þ1 becomes infinite. Consequently, the corresponding reflection coefficient is always unitary (return loss equal to 0 dB), independently of any finite load resistance. In real cases the situation is less critical, but the small-signal return loss obtained from a maximum power design is always poor, as Section 11.5.2 points out.
11.5.2
Output power optimization in presence of transistor parasitics
The considerations based on hypotheses 1 to 10 give some general ideas about PA design. Unfortunately, no practical case satisfies those assumptions. In particular, transistors present parasitics associated with their output and an input junction. The transistor output parasitic reactances introduce a phase shift between the output voltage and current, while the input junction makes the transistor working point change with input power. We will describe both these effects by means of a trial amplifier operating at 1 GHz, and based on the transistor27 MBC13900. Figure 11.13 shows the schematic of a simple amplifier operating at 1 GHz and designed with the method described in Section 11.5.1. Thus, a 50 O RF generator directly connects to the base through the 27
See Section 9.7.
AMPLIFIERS +
Vq = 5 V
L dd = 1µH Iq = 5 mA
Cgg = 1 nF
vLOAD
Cdd = 1 nF
Rs = 50 Ω VRF
445
RLOAD= Vq / I q = 1 kΩ
Ib0 = 33 µA
(a)
Vq = 10 V
Rdd= 1 kΩ
+
Ldd= 1 µH vLOAD
Cgg = 1 nF
Cdd = 1 nF
Rs = 50 Ω VRF
RLOAD= Vq / Iq = 1 kΩ
Ib0 = 33 µA
(b)
Rdd= 1 kΩ Rgg2 = 4.92 kΩ
L dd= 1 µH
Vq = 10 V +
Iq = 5 mA
Rgg1 = 1 kΩ L gg = 1 µH Rs = 50 Ω
vLOAD
Cdd = 1 nF
RLOAD = Vq / Iq = 1 kΩ
Cgg = 1 nF
VRF Collector current servo controller LPF1
(c)
i
Iq = 5 mA +
Cdd = 1 nF Cgg = 1 nF
G•vin
+ Vref = H•Iq vLOAD
RLOAD= Vq / Iq = 1 kΩ
Rs = 50 Ω VRF
H•i
Ldd = 1 µH
Vq = 5 V
+ vin -
+
Ib0
(d)
Figure 11.13 PAs designed with the method of Section 11.5.1: (a) with open-loop bias; (b) with collector DC power limitation; (c) as (b) but with self-stabilizing collector current; (d) with automatic collector current control.
446
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
DC blocking capacitor Cgg ¼ 1 nF, which presents a negligible reactance of less than 0.16 O at 1 GHz. The absence of an input matching network has negligible effect on the output power. Its only effect is that a relevant portion of the input power is reflected back to the generator, with a consequent gain reduction. On the other hand, we are assuming that the input power is sufficient to drive the transistor at the desired level. The only input bias element is the current generator Ib0 ¼ 33 mA, which determines the quiescent current Iq ¼ 5 mA while behaving like an open circuit at 1 GHz. The DC collector voltage is Vq ¼ 5 V. From the considerations developed in Section 11.5.1, it follows that the maximum output load is RLOAD ¼ Vq =Iq ¼ 1 kO. The output matching28 is needed to transform 50 O into 1 kO The simplest possibility is the l/4 transmission line transformer, discussed in Section 6.3. Unfortunately, the required pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi characteristic impedance is Z0 ¼ 1000 50 ffi 223:6 O, which is too high to be realized in most technologies.29 More practical solutions30 could be: 1. The lumped network in Figure 6.15a ðCa ¼ 0:73 pF; La ¼ 36:513 nHÞ. 2. The lumped network in Figure 6.15b ðCb ¼ 0:694 pF; Lb ¼ 34:683 nHÞ. 3. The distributed network in Figure 6.11ðZ 01 ¼ Z 02 ¼ 50 O; y1 ¼ 77:4 ; y2 ¼ 13:24 Þ. Port 1 of networks 1 and 2 connects with the 50 O load, while port 2 is connected to the transistor collector through the capacitor Cdd ¼ 1 nF; the opposite connection applies to network 3. Furthermore, networks 1 and 3 present high attenuation at low frequency, compensating the natural roll-off of the transistor gain, as discussed in Section 11.2. On the other hand, we are considering PAs, which tend to operate in the nonlinear regime: then, the low-pass nature of network 2 could be useful for filtering out the harmonics. In any case, the resistor RLOAD in Figure 11.13 schematically represents the 50 O load with its matching network. We will consider neither the response of the latter nor its filtering effect on the output signal. For the output bias network, the inductor Ldd ¼ 10 mH (capacitor Cdd ¼ 1 nF) ensures high (low) reactance at 1 GHz, enough to approximate RF open (short) circuit. Figure 11.14 (dashed curves) shows the computed output waveforms31 of the amplifier in Figure 11.13, with three different available input powers: 36 dBm (linear operation), 10 dBm (moderate compression) and 4 dBm (saturation). Note that the output waveform increasingly differs from a sinusoid at high amplitudes. The output voltage vLOAD across the resistor RLOAD differs from the collector–emitter voltage by the voltage across Cdd , which is almost constant and equal to Vq . At the maximum input power vLOAD presents a more pronounced saturation in the lower than the upper waveform. The positive peak exceeds Vq , in qualitative agreement with the assumptions of Section 11.5.1. They imply that the collector–emitter voltage is non-negative and can reach any positive amplitude due to the extra voltage produced by Ldd . In real cases the minimum collector voltage is typically less than 1 V, and the maximum is limited by the collector–emitter breakdown. The waveforms in Figure 11.14 correspond to the load curves of Figure 11.15 (solid black lines). Figure 11.15 also includes the transistor DC curves, the ideal load line32 (11.42) and two hyperbolas, 28
See the Ansoft file 03_Matching_Networks_1000_to_50_Ohm.adsn. Figures 3.32 and 3.36 show a maximum realizable characteristic impedance about 200 O for stripline and microstrip, respectively. For the coaxial cable, a diameter ratio follows from Equation (3.208) as pffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffi b=a ¼ expð2pZ0 m0:5 e0:5 Þ ¼ expð223:6=60Þexpð er Þ ffi 41:5 expð er Þ 29
In the most favourable case of er ¼ 1, and assuming b ¼ 10 mm, we have a ¼ 0.24 mm, which is very critical to realize. 30 See the Ansoft file 03_Matching_Networks_1000_to_50_Ohm.adsn. 31 See the SIMetrix file 15_MBC13900_LOAD_ Line_1GHz.sxsch. 32 See the SIMetrix file 14_MBC13900_LOAD_Line.sxsch, which performs a low-frequency (1 MHz) analysis of the amplifier, in order to eliminate the effects of the transistor parasitic reactance.
AMPLIFIERS
447
0.4 0.2
PAV,in = -36 dBm
0.0 -0.2 -0.4 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Load voltage, V
8 4
PAV,in= -10 dBm
0 -4 -8 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
8 4
PAV,in= -4 dBm
0 -4 -8 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Time, ns
Figure 11.14 Output voltage of the amplifiers in Figures 11.13a (dashed) and Figure 11.13c (solid), for three different available input powers.
Ptransistor = 50 mW
15
100 mW Ibe = 75 µA
-4 dBm 60 µA 10 45 µA Ice , mA 35.3 µA
small signal load line 5
30 µA
PAV,in = -36 dBm 15 µA -10 dBm 0 0
5
10 V ce , V
Figure 11.15
ideal load line 15
Load lines of the amplifiers in Figures 11.13a (black) and Figure 11.13c (grey).
448
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Vce Ice ¼ Ptransistor , where Ptransistor is the power dissipated by the transistor, equal to 50 and 100 mW. Each point on a given hyperbola represents the corresponding transistor power dissipation. Beginning from the lower input power, we can see that the load curves are similar to ellipses rather than straight lines, due to memory effects in the transistor output reactance that introduce phase shifts between the collector voltage and current. As the driving level increases, the load lines become more distorted and move away from the ideal line, moving towards higher transistor dissipation. Consequently, the direct current of the amplifier increases at high driving levels. In general cases, on amplifiers operating in the compression region, the direct current changes, decreasing or increasing. It depends on the input driving power because of the base–emitter (gate–source) junction33 in the BJT (MESFET), which rectifies the input RF signal. The rectification produces direct currents (voltages) that are superimposed on the ones impressed by the input bias network, and modifying the amplifier direct current. The transistor working area moving towards higher power could be dangerous for the transistor, especially for the BJT. Indeed, BJT collector current for a given base current increases with transistor temperature. Therefore, a high input RF level could spark off a destructive process: the current increases for the high driving, the transistor temperature increases consequently, by causing a further current rise, and so on. Figure 11.13b shows a simple solution for this problem: the DC generator Vq0 ¼ 10 V in series with the resistor Rdd ¼ 1 kO replaces the DC generator Vq ¼ 5 V. At low input RF power, when the direct current is 5 mA, the voltage drop on Rdd is 5 V, thus the voltage applied to the collector is 5 V, as in the amplifier in Figure 11.13a. Therefore, at low RF power the two amplifiers in Figures 11.13a,b are totally equivalent. Now, the combination of Vq0 in series with Rdd is a generator having an available power of PAV;DC ¼ 0:25 V q0 2 =Rdd ¼ 25 mW. That maximum power is transferred to the load (the amplifier) when its equivalent load resistance is equal to Rdd . This condition verifies when the collector voltage and current are 5 V and 5 mA, respectively. In other words, the transistor absorbs a maximum power of 25 mW with no input signal; in all other conditions, the power dissipated on the transistor is equal or lower. This solution guarantees transistor safety, but at the expense of the overall efficiency of the amplifier, in that Rdd dissipates about34 the same power as the amplifier. The efficiency of the amplifier in Figure 11.13b is half the one in Figure 11.13a. The amplifier in Figure 11.13c presents an improved base bias scheme with respect to the arrangement in Figure 11.13b. The two resistors Rbb1 ; Rbb2 form a voltage divider that increases the base current monotonically with the collector voltage, which decreases with the collector current itself. This way, the bias scheme realizes a kind of automatic stabilization of the collector current. Clearly, the inductor Lbb isolates the voltage divider from the base at RF, preventing the latter from loading the transistor input. Figure 11.13d proposes a more sophisticated approach to transistor biasing. The controlled generators CCVS1 and VCCS1 , together with the low-pass filter LPF1, form a servo-control loop with Q1 . The output voltage of CCVS1 is proportional to the amplifier current, LPF1 eliminates the alternate components of that voltage, and the error amplifier VCCS1 drives the base of Q1 with a current proportional to the difference between its two input voltages. If the loop is stable, these two voltages are ðAmpÞ close, then H IDC ffi Vre f , and consequently ðAmpÞ
IDC
ffi
Vre f H
ð11:48Þ
were H is the gain of CCVS1 and Vre f is a suitable DC voltage. Equation (11.48) states that the direct current of the amplifier in Figure 11.13c depends only on two parameters of the automatic control circuit, not on the RF power. In other words, the servo control compensates the self-biasing of the transistor input junction. 33
This is in direct opposition with assumption 10 in Section 11.3.1. The power dissipated on Rdd is exactly the same as on the amplifier in the case of no input signal, when Iq ¼ 5 mA. As can be seen, high RF input levels affect Iq and thus the percentage power on Rdd . 34
15
20
10
19
5
18
0
17
-5 -10 -15 -20 -40
16
(a) (b) (c) (d)
Output power
449
Gain, dB
Output power, dBm
AMPLIFIERS
15
Gain
14 13
-35
-30
-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
Input power, dBm
Figure 11.16 Compression curves of the amplifiers in Figure 11.13a (thick solid), Figure 11.13b (dashed) and Figure 11.13c (thin solid).
The configuration in Figure 11.13d applies also to FET amplifiers; in this case a VCVS replaces VCCS1 . The grey lines in Figure 11.15 are the load lines of the amplifier in Figure 11.13d, computed35 for the same frequency (1 GHz) and input power (36, 10 and 4 dBm) as for the amplifier in Figure 11.14a. Note that all the load lines of the amplifier in Figure 11.13d remain more or less concentric and closer to the ideal one, different from the case of the amplifier in Figure 11.13a. Figure 11.14 shows the output waveforms of the amplifiers in Figures 11.13a (dashed lines) and Figure 11.13d (solid lines) at the same three input power levels as for the load lines. Figure 11.14 does not show the output waveforms of the amplifier in Figures 11.13b,c, which are close36 to the ones of the amplifier in Figure 11.13d. Figure 11.16 shows the compression curves37 of the amplifiers in Figure 11.13a (solid thick), Figure 11.13b (dashed), Figure 11.13c (solid thin) and Figure 11.13d (solid thick with square). The three black curves are the fundamental output power versus the available power from the input generator, while the grey lines are the differences between these quantities, namely the transducer power gains of the amplifiers. The small-signal performances of the three amplifiers are coincident, say up to an input power of 15 dBm. At higher power the curves diverge. Furthermore, the amplifier in Figure 11.13b presents an oversaturation characteristic: the fundamental output power decreases – instead of increasing – as the input power exceeds 6 dBm. This behaviour makes the input driving of the input amplifier quite critical, as it almost prevents the saturated output power from being achieved. However, by modifying the values of the amplifier in Figure 11.13b from Vq0 ¼ 10 V; Rdd ¼ 1 kO to Vq0 ¼ 5 V; Rdd ¼ 0 the amplifier gradually transforms into the one in Figure 11.13a; intermediate combinations of Vq0 ; Rdd give the corresponding intermediate compression curves. The solution in Figure 11.13c eliminates the oversaturation from the output power compression curve, but does not alleviate the efficiency reduction related with the collector series resistance. 35
See the SIMetrix file 17_MBC13900_LOAD_Line_1GHz_DC_Servo.sxsch. See the SIMetrix file 16_MBC13900_LOAD_Line_1GHz_RL.sxsch. 37 See the SIMetrix files 18_MBC13900_1GHz_PS.sxsch, 19_MBC13900_1GHz_RL_PS.sxsch, 20_MBC13900_ 1GHz_RL2_PS.sxsch and 21_MBC13900_1GHz_DC_Servo_PS.sxsch, which analyze the compression curves of the amplifiers from Figures 11.13a–d. 36
450
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The amplifier in Figure 11.13a has the highest output power ðPout;saturated;a ffi 12:3 dBmÞ among the ones in Figure 11.13. On the other hand, the amplifier in Figure 11.13d is the one working closer to the conditions of Section 11.5.1, its saturated output power being Pout;saturated;c ffi 9:7 dBm, while the value predicted from the simplified model of Section 11.5.1 is Pout;max;c ¼ 10 log10 ðVq Iq =2Þ þ 30 ¼ 10 log10 ð5 53 =2Þ þ 30 ffi 11 dBm. The 1.3 dB missed output power is due to the transistor parasitic reactance and to the minimum collector–emitter voltage, which is about 0.42 V, as in the abscissa of the highest power load (grey) line in Figure 11.15. The transistor parasitic reactance makes the 1 kO resistor not the optimum one, while the minimum collector–emitter voltage reduces the output voltage swing by twice its value. Considering this, the expected output power is P0out;max;c ¼ 10 log10 ½0:5 ðVq 0:42ÞIq þ 3 ffi 10:6 dBm. The high power of the amplifier in Figure 11.13a – higher than the limit (11.43) – is achieved at the expense of higher collector current, and the risk of transistor damage is also present. The configuration in Figure 11.13d is likely to be the best compromise among output power, current consumption and transistor safe operation. However, besides circuit complexity, the main drawback of that solution is its settling time. A detailed description of the automatic current control is beyond the scope of this text, but we will present some qualitative considerations of the dynamic performance of the system. The schematic in Figure 11.13d is purely conceptual, since the real controlled generators typically use operational amplifier circuits, present offset, drift over time and temperature, their frequency responses are low-pass type and therefore interact with the response of LPF1, and so on. The gain G of VCCS1, together with the cut-off frequency and response of LPF1, are the design parameters of the automatic control, and determine value, precision, stability and settling time of the amplifier current. The current control loop analysis is a finite bandwidth feedback system, and thus it presents a finite settling time, typically ranging from hundreds of nanoseconds to milliseconds. Therefore, the amplifier is not immediately operating after switching on the power supply. Moreover – and probably more important – if the RF input signal amplitude experiences a sudden change, a transient irregularity will affect the output until the loop sets, particularly when passing from linear to nonlinear operation or vice versa. Figure 11.17 shows the envelopes of input and output waveforms of the amplifier in Figure 11.13d. Here, the term envelope denotes the curve passing through the local maxima and minima of an oscillating waveform. In more quantitative terms, let us consider the most general RF waveform, having both amplitude and phase modulation vRF ðtÞ ¼ aðtÞcos½o0 t þ yðtÞ where aðtÞ; yðtÞ present slower fluctuations with respect to the RF oscillation period T0 ¼ 1= f0 ¼ 2p=o0 , or, equivalently, their spectral components have a much narrower bandwidth than f0 . It is always possible to write vRF ðtÞ in such a way that the amplitude coefficient aðtÞ is non-negative jaðtÞjaðtÞ vRF ðtÞ ¼ jaðtÞjcos o0 t þ yðtÞ þ p 2jaðtÞj This expression points out that the modulated RF signal consists of oscillations having a time-varying amplitude jaðtÞj, which is the envelope of the signal. Figure 11.17 shows the envelopes of the RF signals – instead of the signals themselves – because the RF signals are not distinguishable, having 500 oscillations during the time span of 500 ns. The parameters38 of the control loop are H ¼ 103 ; G ¼ 100 mS, and LPF1 is a first-order low-pass filter with a cut-off frequency of about 16 kHz. The output signal envelope in Figure 11.17 needs about 400 ns to reach its steady state shape; before that time, undesired amplitude modulation is present. Therefore, the amplifier in Figure 11.13d is not suitable for RF signals having fast amplitude modulating signals. 38
See the SIMetrix file 22_MBC13900_1GHz_DC_Servo_Burst.sxsch.
AMPLIFIERS
451
Figure 11.17 Response of the amplifier in Figure 11.13c to a stepped increase in RF input amplitude: input and output envelope.
11.5.3 Load pull Sections 11.5.1 and 11.5.2 considered the theoretical maximum output power in a simplified amplifier and some deviations from ideality, respectively. The present section completes the discussion, describing a general method to find the optimum load that gets the maximum power from a given transistor, at specified frequency and bias conditions. This method is known as load pulling, and can be applied not only to maximize the output power, but also to other nonlinear performances, like linearity, efficiency, harmonic content, and so on. Furthermore, the load pull can be based on either measurements or simulations. Figure 11.18 shows the experimental load-pull setup. Two DC generators and T-bias determine the required transistor DC working point, with negligible RF effects. Again, the bias networks are generic and the transistor can be a bipolar or field effect device, although a MESFET symbol is used. One RF generator drives the transistor input through the RF path of the input T-bias. In some cases, an input matching network is placed between the RF generator and transistor input. Unilateral design is only one possible for such a network, in that the output load of the transistor is variable by definition, as we will see shortly. In any case, the input RF generator – matched or not – has enough power to drive the transistor. The transistor output is connected to a variable load through the RF path of the output T-bias. The variable load consists of one stub (or double stub) tuner, one SPDTand one directional coupler. The SPDT and directional coupler present a negligible attenuation. A matched power meter terminates the stub tuner, making the resulting impedance not purely reactive, while measuring the transistor output power. A spectrum analyzer,39 connected to the coupled port of the directional coupler, picks up a small fraction (of the order of 10 to 30 dB) of the transistor output signal. It also checks for possible transistor oscillations. A vector network analyzer40 is also connected to the SPDT, and measures the impedance seen by the transistor. One ammeter, measuring the drain current, completes the setup. 39 40
See Section 17.4. See Section 11.6.2.
452
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Spectrum analyzer
Cgg
RF generator
L gg
SPDT 1
C dd A 1
DUT
L dd 2
Rgg
Rdd
A3 Directional coupler
ΓL Stub tuner
Power meter
+
Vgg input bias
Ammeter
+
Vdd
A2
output bias
Figure 11.18
Network analyzer
Test setup for the transistor load pull.
The load-pull measurements includes two steps: 1. With the SPDT in position 1, the RF input power and the stub tuner are adjusted to maximize the power measured by the power meter. Once a maximum has been found, the output spectrum must contain the input frequency and its harmonics. Any different spectral component reveals the presence of oscillations. If this is case, the load found must be rejected, because the oscillations corrupt the useful signal and give an optimistic measured power. Once we find an oscillation-free optimum load, we lock the tuner and record output power, harmonic levels and transistor current. After that, the drain DC generator is switched off ðVdd ¼ 0Þ, before passing to the next step. 2. With the SPDT in position 2 and the output transistor unbiased, the network analyzer measures the complex reflection coefficient presented to the transistor output as in the previous step. This requires the two paths A1–A3 and A2–A3 to be either equal or accurately calibrated out. As in step 1, we record the measured reflection coefficient at the test frequency. The generation of theoretically arbitrary reflection coefficients requires the SPST to present a low insertion loss, otherwise the impedance that the transistor sees is independent of the stub tuner regulations. Therefore electromechanical devices are the preferred choice. The result of this test procedure is the optimum load impedance for the maximum output power at a given frequency. Alternatively, the same procedure can be applied to optimize the efficiency, the linearity or any other nonlinear performance, including combinations. Once the optimum load is known, the matching network has to transform the 50 O into that load. Sometimes, the load-pull procedure includes additional steps, in order to determine the transistor nonlinear performances for a load impedance that is slightly different from the optimum. The result is a nonlinear performance as a tabular function of the load impedance or reflection coefficient, which are complex variables. Contour plots are the most used representation for this two-variable function. Depending on the nonlinear performance of interest, we have plots of output power, efficiency, 1dBCP, and so on. In modern and sophisticated load-pull test sets, the stub tuner includes motorized computerdriven controls. A computer program oversees the whole measurement procedure, generating output load and contour plots. Figure 11.19 shows the load-pull contour plot of the amplifier in Figure 11.13a; the normalization impedance for that Smith chart is Rnorm ¼ RLOAD;opt ¼ Vcc =Iq ¼ 1 kO, the approximated optimum load given by the method of Section 11.5.1. The marked points on each line represent constant load reflection
AMPLIFIERS
Figure 11.19
453
Load-pull contours of the amplifier in Figure 11.13a.
coefficients giving the same output power. Clearly, the load-pull measurements are finite in number, and consequently the contour lines are piecewise linear. A Smith chart region densely populated with contour lines denotes a high sensitivity of the nonlinear performance to the output load. The effective optimum load impedance in Figure 11.19 is ZLOAD;opt ¼ ð0:472 þ j 0:198ÞRnorm ¼ ð472 þ j 198Þ O, while ZLOAD ¼ Rnorm ¼ 1 kO corresponds to an output power approximately 1.5 dB lower than the maximum. The reactive part of ZLOAD;opt somehow compensates for the transistor parasitic reactance, and the real part is lower than Vcc =Iq ¼ 1 kO, due to the collector mean current increasing at high output power, as pointed out in Section 11.5.2. Note also that the optimum load in Figure 11.19 lies on the inductive half plane of the Smith chart, in that it compensates for the transistor output capacitance. The load-pull method is quite general: for instance, it could also be used to find the load for the maximum linear gain. In this case, the contour lines are the constant output gain circles. A more recent design method is based on nonlinear simulations with suitable transistor nonlinear models. Some methods reproduce the test bench in Figure 11.18 on the simulator, finding the optimum load and sometimes the load contours. After that the output matching network design continues exactly as with the experimental load-pull design method. Such a method is sometimes referred to as simulated load pulling. In other cases, the designer describes the whole amplifier in the nonlinear simulator, including the input matching network, transistor nonlinear model and output matching network. The parameters of the last element are then tuned and/or optimized until the optimum is achieved. Both experimental and computer simulation design methods present advantages and disadvantages. The experimental method is usually more accurate and less flexible, in that the obtained optimum load refers to a well-defined performance, which is not well related to the other ones: for instance, the optimum
454
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
load for power could be quite different from the one for the efficiency. Moreover, the amplifier nonlinear performances do not exclusively depend on the fundamental frequency load. Rather, the harmonic load is also influential, and this is difficult to control independently from the one at the fundamental frequency. However, some electronic computer-controlled variable loads have the capability to generate arbitrary loads at different harmonics, though they are of course quite expensive. On the contrary, simulation is more flexible, in that the same nonlinear model can be used to optimize any nonlinear performance. Moreover, the complete amplifier analysis automatically takes the harmonic load into account. The main disadvantage of the simulation is its lower precision inherent in the nonlinear simulation itself; sometimes it does not even converge, particularly in high-compression conditions. As a final observation on the nonlinear design of the output matching network, we have to note that the optimum output power load does not coincide with the conjugate load considered in Section 11.2.3. In this regard, let us again consider the transistor DC curves in Figure 11.15. As we found, the load resistance from case (c) is RLOAD ¼ 1 kO. On the linear side, linearizing the DC curve in the working point Vq ¼ 5 V; Iq ¼ 5 mA, we get the small-signal output resistance of the transistor Rce ffi DVce =DIc ffi 6:57 kO, as Figure 11.15 shows. The corresponding return loss is 20 log10 ½jðRLOAD Rce Þ= ðRLOAD þ Rce Þj ffi 2:66 dB, better than the one obtained from the simple model of Section 11.2.3, but not good enough. In more realistic analyses and in practical cases, the small-signal output return loss of a power amplifier typically ranges from 4 to 8 dB.
11.5.4
Balanced amplifiers
Figure 11.20a shows an amplifier configuration known as a balanced amplifier. It consists of two ideally identical amplifiers placed between two hybrid couplers. Compared with single amplifiers, the balanced amplifier ideally exhibits the same gain and double the power: the real resulting gain and output power are lower than the ideal case, due to the losses in the hybrid couplers. Typical hybrid couplers present a dissipation loss in the range of 0.1–0.5 dB. The resulting balanced amplifier presents a gain of 0.2–1 dB lower and an output power of 2.9–2.5 dB higher than its two single amplifiers. Together with increasing output power, balanced amplifiers could have additional advantages depending on the hybrid coupler type, like better impedance matching, higher stability and reduction of some nonlinear distortion products. The networks in Figure 11.20a labelled HYB1 and HYB2 are hybrid couplers, and their fourth port is terminated with the matched impedance. Their scattering matrix is 2 3 0 1 e jj h i h i ð11:49Þ SðHYB1Þ ¼ SðHYB2Þ ¼ a 4 1 0 0 5 e jj 0 0
The phase f may assume the values pffiffiffi 0; p=2 or p for a 0 , 90 or 180 hybrid, respectively. In the ideal case of a loss-free coupler, a ¼ 1= 2. The terminated hybrids can be more synthetically represented with the structures in Figure 11.20b, which shows the same S parameters as in Equation (11.49). The two amplifiers A1 and A2 are identical in the ideal case, but not in practice. The superscript in ðA1Þ brackets denotes the S parameters of the component itself: for instance, s21 will denote the forward transmission coefficient of amplifier A1. Figure 11.20c shows the SFG corresponding to the network in Figure 11.20b. The scattering parameters of the balanced amplifier can be found by analyzing that graph. The input reflection coefficient is, by definition, the ratio between the input reflected and incident waves, with no incident wave on the output. Under these conditions, there are two paths, of three branches each, from a1 to b1 : ðA1Þ ðA2Þ they are, respectively, a; s11 ; a and a e jj ; s11 ; a e jj . The input reflection coefficient of the balanced amplifier is then h i b1 ðA1Þ ðA2Þ ðA1Þ ðA2Þ ¼ a s11 a þ a e jj s11 a e jj ¼ 2a2 s11 þ e j2j s11 s11 ¼ a 1 a2 ¼0
AMPLIFIERS 1
2
0
1
0
π−φ
455
2 π−φ
φ
φ
0
0
4
3
4
1
√0.5 2
3
3
(a)
√0.5⋅exp(jφ)
√0.5⋅ exp(jφ) √0.5 2
3
1
(b)
(A1)
s21
0.50.5
a1
s11(A1) s22(A1) 0.5
0.5
exp(jφ)
b1
0.5 0.5
0.5
s
Figure 11.20
0.5
0.5
0.5
exp(jφ)
s11(A2) s22(A2)
(c)
exp(jφ)
(A1) 12
s21(A2) 0.5
0.5
s12
(A2)
0.50.5 exp(jφ)
0.50.5
Balanced amplifier: (a) block diagram; (b) equivalent diagram; (c) SFG.
The remaining three scattering parameters can be found with the same procedure, resulting in h i 3 2 ðA1Þ ðA2Þ ðA1Þ ðA2Þ s12 þ s12 e jj s11 þ e j2j s11 h i 7 6 ð11:50Þ SðBALAMPÞ ¼ a2 4 h 5 i ðA1Þ ðA2Þ ðA1Þ jj j2j ðA2Þ s21 þ s21 e s22 þ e s22 ðA1Þ
ðA2Þ
ðA1;A2Þ
If the two single amplifiers are identical, i.e. if shk ¼ shk ¼ shk for h; k ¼ 1; 2, then Equation (11.50) simplifies to 2 3 ðA1;A2Þ jj j2j ðA1;A2Þ h i 1 þ e ½ s 2s e 11 12 5 ð11:51Þ SðBALAMPÞ ¼ a2 4 ðA1;A2Þ jj ðA1;A2Þ 2s21 e ½1 þ e j2j s22 The forward gain amplitude of the balanced amplifier, as coming from Equation (11.51), is then ðBALAMPÞ s ¼ 2a2 sðA1;A2Þ : each decibel of dissipation loss in the hybrid couplers affects the balanced 21 21 amplifier gain by 2 dB.
456
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Note that we assume the two couplers are identical and the two amplifiers are potentially different. This is equivalent to assuming that the two amplifiers are identical and using two different scattering matrices for the two couplers, in order to model any imbalance between the two paths of the balanced amplifier. pffiffiffi If the two hybrid couplers are loss free, a ¼ 1= 2, then Equation (11.51) further simplifies to 3 2 1 þ e j2j ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ e jj s12 s11 h i 6 7 2 7 ð11:52Þ SðBALAMPÞ ¼ 6 5 4 j2j 1 þ e ðA1;A2Þ jj ðA1;A2Þ e s21 s22 2 Equation (11.52) states that the full–ideal balanced amplifier has the same amplitude gain as that of its two single amplifiers. Let us apply the models in Section 9.5 to analyze the nonlinear performance of the ideal balanced amplifier. Following the method described there, we will assume that A1 and A2 are perfectly matched and unilateral. Under these assumptions, the ratio of output to input voltage of the amplifiers coincides with their transmission coefficient. Let the balanced amplifier input voltage be vin ðtÞ ¼ Vi0 cosðot jÞ ðA1;A2Þ The constant j ¼ arg s21 has been added in order to simplify the expressions for output signals, and the origin of the time axis changed accordingly. HYB pffiffiffi 1 distributes the input voltage to the amplifier inputs. The input voltage amplitude equals Vi0 = 2 for both amplifiers, due to the power division factor of the hybrid coupler. Furthermore, the input signal of A2 is phase shifted by f. Then the input voltages of the amplifiers A1 ; A2 are respectively 1 ðA1Þ vin ðtÞ ¼ pffiffiffi Vi0 cosðot fÞ; 2
1 ðA2Þ vin ðtÞ ¼ pffiffiffi Vi0 cosðotf þ jÞ 2 ðA1;A2Þ
Let us assume that A1 ; A2 have the voltage transfer characteristic (9.44), with s21 ¼ c1 e jj . If the input voltage is low enough to keep the amplifiers within their monotonic region,41 then the two amplifier output voltages are 2 3 Vi0 Vi0 Vi0 ðA1Þ vout ðtÞ ¼ c1 pffiffiffi cosðotÞ þ c2 pffiffiffi cos2 ðotÞ þ c3 pffiffiffi cos3 ðotÞ 2 2 2 2 3 Vi0 Vi0 Vi0 ðA2Þ vout ðtÞ ¼ c1 pffiffiffi cosðot þ fÞ þ c2 pffiffiffi cos2 ðot þ fÞ þ c3 pffiffiffi cos3 ðot þ fÞ 2 2 2 Expanding the cosine powers, and eliminating the constant terms from the quadratic coefficient, we get " 3 #
3 Vi0 3 Vi0 c2 Vi0 2 1 V ðA1Þ pffiffiffi cosð2otÞ þ c3 pi0ffiffiffi cosð3otÞ cosðotÞ þ vout ðtÞ ¼ c1 pffiffiffi þ c3 pffiffiffi 4 2 2 4 2 2 2 " 3 # 2 3 Vi0 3 Vi0 c2 Vi0 1 Vi0 ðA2Þ p ffiffi ffi p ffiffi ffi p ffiffi ffi þ c3 cosðot þ fÞ þ vout ðtÞ ¼ c1 cosð2ot þ 2fÞ þ c3 pffiffiffi cosð3ot þ 3fÞ 2 4 2 4 2 2 2 The pffiffiffioutput hybrid combines the two signals at the output of A1 ; A2 by multiplying their amplitudes by 1= 2 and phase shifting the components of the first by f. The resulting output voltage of the balanced amplifier is then 41
pffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi From Equation (9.48) it follows that this condition occurs if Vi0 = 2 c3 =3c1 , see also Figure 9.22.
AMPLIFIERS ðBALAMPÞ
vout
3 c2 ðtÞ ¼ c1 þ c3 Vi02 Vi0 cosðot þ jÞ þ pffiffiffi Vi02 ½cosð2ot þ jÞ þ cosð2ot þ 2jÞ 8 4 2 1 3 þ c3 Vi0 ½cosð3ot þ jÞ þ cosð3ot þ 3jÞ 16
457
ð11:53Þ
The voltage large-signal gain of the balanced amplifier is the coefficient of the fundamental frequency component of the output signal c1 þ ð3=8Þc3 Vi02 ; this has the same form as Equation (9.50), but with the coefficient c3 =2 replacing c3 . Consequently, the resulting 1 dB compression point of the balanced amplifier is " rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 # 1 c1 1 ðBALAMPÞ þ 30 ð11:54Þ I1dBdBm ¼ 10 log10 0:538 c3 2 R0 while the 1 dB compression power of the single amplifiers is " rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 # 1 c1 1 ðA1;A2Þ I1dBdBm ¼ 10 log10 þ 30 0:3808 c3 2 R0
ð11:55Þ
The I1dB point of the balanced amplifier is 3.01 dB higher than those of its two amplifiers, and the same applies to the output 1 dB compression point, saturated power, intercept points, and so on. After deriving the general properties of the balanced amplifier, we can consider the three relevant cases used, classified according to the particular phase f of the hybrid coupler: 1. Hybrid coupler in phase or 0 balanced amplifier, f ¼ 0. Equations (11.51) and (11.52) give the scattering matrix of the in-phase balanced amplifier 2 3 3 pffiffiffiffiffi 2 ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ a¼1= 0:5 ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ h if¼0 s s s s 11 12 11 12 5 ¼ 4 5 SðBALAMPÞ ¼ 2a2 4 ð11:56Þ ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ s21 s22 s21 s22 In the ideal case, the balanced amplifier exhibits the same scattering parameters as its two single amplifiers. For the nonlinear performances, Equation (11.53) implies that the output signal has single tone excitation
3 c2 V 2 c3 Vi03 ðBALAMPÞ ðtÞ ¼ c1 þ c3 Vi02 Vi0 cosðotÞ þ pi0ffiffiffi cosð2otÞ þ vout cosð3otÞ ð11:57Þ 8 2 2 4 2 Compared with the single amplifiers, the 0 balanced amplifier has the second and third harmonics attenuated by 3.01 and 6.02 dB, respectively, for the same input signal. More generally, considering a higher order polynomial for the voltage transfer, we have that the kth harmonic is attenuated by the factor 0:5k1. The main advantage of the 0 balanced amplifier is that its hybrid couplers can easily be realized in printed circuit technology and with multi-octave working bandwidths, for instance with Wilkinson dividers.42 2. Hybrid coupler in quadrature, j ¼ p=2, or 90 balanced amplifier. The scattering matrix is 2 3 3 pffiffiffiffiffi 2 ðA1;A2Þ a¼1= 0:5 ðA1;A2Þ 0 js12 0 s12 f¼0 2 5 ¼ 4 5 ð11:58Þ SBalancedAmpli fier ¼ 2a 4 ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ s21 0 js21 0 42
See Section 7.7.1.
458
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Equation (11.58) shows the main advantage of the 90 balanced amplifier: its input and output reflection coefficients are zero, independently of the ones of A1 ; A2 , provided that the latter are equal. This remarkable property of the 90 balanced amplifier has many applications, in LNAs, broad-band amplifiers and PAs, with the output matched for the maximum power. All these three types of amplifiers present mediocre input or output impedance matching: LNAs because Gopt 6¼ GMS ; broad-band amplifiers because their input is matched at the highest frequency only, to compensate the transistor gain roll-off with frequency; and PAs because the load for maximum power is different from the one for impedance matching. In all three cases the 90 balanced configuration provides a perfect impedance matching. The main drawback of this solution with LNAs is that the input coupler degrades the noise figure by its loss. That degradation is of the order of 0.1–0.5 dB, as anticipated in the initial part of this section. The 90 balanced connection can be considered as a kind of lossy matching technique. The power reflected by the two single amplifiers dissipates on the hybrid couplers’ terminations. As a side effect, the balanced amplifier shows a better stability than the single amplifiers. The Kurokawa conditions (11.17) applied to the scattering parameters (11.58) give, in the ideal case, ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ 1 ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ s21 s21 s12 þ s12 ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ K¼ > 1; jDj ¼ s12 s21 <1 2 ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ < 1, as it is in most practical cases.43 Both these conditions are satisfied if s12 s21 The signal output with a sinusoidal input excitation is 3 c2 p ðBALAMPÞ 2 ðtÞ ¼ c1 þ c3 Vi0 Vi0 sinðotÞ Vi02 cos 2ot þ ð11:59Þ vout 8 4 4 Then, the quadrature configuration attenuates the second harmonic by 6.02 dB and cancels the third harmonic. Clearly, this does not mean that it cancels all the third-order distortion products. In this regard, it must be considered that the fundamental frequency amplitude of the signal (11.59) includes third-order distortion. 3. Hybrid in phase opposition or 180 balanced amplifier f ¼ p. The scattering matrix is pffiffiffiffiffi " " ðA1;A2Þ # # ðA1;A2Þ a¼1= 0:5 ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ h i s s11 s12 s 11 12 ðBALAMPÞ 2 ¼ 2a S ¼ ð11:60Þ ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ ðA1;A2Þ s21 s22 s21 s22 The output signal for a single tone excitation is 3 1 c3 3 ðBALAMPÞ V cosð3otÞ ðtÞ ¼ c1 þ c3 Vi02 Vi0 cosðotÞ vout 8 4 2 i0
ð11:61Þ
Expression (11.61) is similar to (11.57) but with the second harmonic cancelled. More generally, the 180 balanced structure cancels all the even-order linearities. We can see this by considering the most general polynomial voltage transfer characteristic for the single amplifiers. The signals output on the amplifiers are then ðA1Þ
vout ðtÞ ¼
vin ðtÞ k ck pffiffiffi ; 2 k¼1
1 X
ðA2Þ
vout ðtÞ ¼
where vin ðtÞ is a generic input signal, sinusoidal or not. 43
See for instance the transistor data in Tables 9.2 and 9.3.
vin ðtÞ k ck pffiffiffi 2 k¼1
1 X
AMPLIFIERS
459
The balanced amplifier output is then ðA1Þ ðA2Þ 1 1 vout ðtÞ vout ðtÞ X ð1Þk 1 vin ðtÞ k X pffiffiffi pffiffiffi vout ðtÞ ¼ ck pffiffiffi ¼ c0k ½vin ðtÞk ¼ 2 2 2 k¼1 k¼1 with c0k
ð1Þk 1 ¼ ck ðk þ 1Þ=2 ¼ 2
(
ðeven kÞ
0 ð1kÞ=2
2
ck
ðodd kÞ
thus the even-k terms of vout ðtÞ are zero. Notice that the distortion-cancelling properties of the 90 and 180 balanced amplifiers rely on specific amplitude and phase relations. Therefore, real amplifiers exhibit that performance if and only if the two single amplifiers remain equal and the matrix (11.49) holds true to cancel at the harmonic, not just at the fundamental working frequency.
11.5.5
PA classes
The amplifiers considered in the previous sections of this chapter use the transistor as a linear controlled generator for the complete signal cycle, at least in principle. Such a type of working defines a class A amplifier. Sections 11.5.1 and 11.5.2 showed that class A amplifiers have a theoretical maximum possible efficiency of 50%. This efficiency is possible if and only if the transistor is ideal in the sense of Section 11.3.1, the load impedance is RLOAD ¼ Vq Iq1 , and the output peak amplitude is Vq. The considerations in Section 11.5.1 also suggest that the efficiency can be improved by keeping the transistor output voltage low when the current is low and vice versa. From this it follows that one possibility to improve the efficiency is to cut off the transistor output current for part of the RF signal period. Figure 11.21 (top left graph, grey curve) shows the transfer characteristic from the input excitation to the output transistor current of a PA having the schematic as in Figure 11.11.44 As usual, the input excitation is Vgs or Ibe, depending on the transistor being an FET or a BJT, and the corresponding output current is Ids or Ice. In the remainder of this section we will replace the real curve with a piecewise-linear approximation, as shown in Figure 11.21 (top left graph, black curve). The approximating piecewise line has the breaking point xmin . Any input higher (lower) than that limit produces a corresponding linearly increasing (zero) output current. In quantitative terms, our current transfer characteristic is
0 ðxin xmin Þ ð11:62Þ ids;ce ¼ ðxin xmin ÞGL ðxin > xmin Þ where xin ¼ vgs or xin ¼ ibe for the FET or BJT, respectively. The factor GL represents the linear gain of the transistor in the given representation and network embodiment. The input transistor excitation is a sinusoid with a superimposed DC bias xin ðtÞ ¼ xDC xpeax cosðo0 tÞ
ð11:63Þ
The corresponding output current has one of the shapes in the upper right corner of Figure 11.21. Each of those three curves – labelled A, B or C – represents a particular amplifier operation, known as class A, class B or class C. Here, we will analyze these operation classes, assuming for the transistor the same hypotheses as in Section 11.5.1, particularly hypothesis 6. 44
The Mathcad file 09_Class_A_B_C.MCD contains some analyses of the PA considered in this section.
460
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING (xin - x min) G L ids,ce
ids,ce
Isat
(iii)
(i) A Isat /2 C B
B
A
C xmin
t C
B
xin = vgs, vbe
C
B t
B
A
θc (ii)
xin
Figure 11.21 Class A, B and C amplifier diagrams: (i) typical output current transfer characteristic of a microwave transistor; (ii) input excitations; (iii) output current. Substituting Equation (11.63) into (11.62), we obtain ( 0 ðxin xmin Þ ids;ce ðtÞ ¼ ðxDC xmin ÞGL ðxpeak xmin ÞGL cosðo0 tÞ ðxin > xmin Þ
ð11:64Þ
In one period ð0 o0 t < 2pÞ of the RF signal, we can replace the conditions xin > xmin ; or xin xmin, = ½pyc =2; p þ yc =2, respectively, where the parameter yc is the with o0 t 2 ½pyc =2; p þ yc =2 or o0 t 2 conduction angle, given by
xmin xDC yc ¼ 2p 2cos1 ð11:65Þ xpeax The transistor output current minimum and maximum limits are respectively Imax ¼ ðxDC þ xpeax xmin ÞGL ;
Imin ¼ ðxDC xpeax xmin ÞGL
ð11:66Þ
Combining Equations (11.64) to (11.66), in order to eliminate the quantities xmin ; GL ; xDC ; xpeax ; Imin , we obtain
8 yc > >
cos þ cosðo0 tÞ > > yc yc 2 > >
; p þ I t 2 p o > 0 < max yc 2 2 cos 1 ids;ce ðtÞ ¼ ð11:67Þ 2 > > >
> > yc yc > > :0 = p ; p þ o0 t 2 2 2
AMPLIFIERS
461
I ds,ce(t) Imax Isat θsat
θc
0
π
2π
ω0 t Imin
Figure 11.22
Transistor output current in a class A, B or C amplifier.
The transistor output current follows the law (11.67) until the corresponding voltage reaches negative values along a portion of the RF cycle. This occurs when the load resistance exceeds a given value, and causes the positive peaks of ids;ce to clip at the value Isat , as we will see later in this section. The black curve in Figure 11.22 is a graphical representation of the waveform (11.67) when yc < 2p, the dashed curve representing the case of yc ¼ 2p. We have a waveform like the one shown by the grey solid line in Figure 11.22 when Imax > Isat , although we will not discuss this case in depth. Combining selected parts of the first and third curves, we obtain the remaining case ðyc ¼ 2p; Imax > Isat Þ. The conduction angle defines the operation class of the amplifier. Assuming no saturation on the positive current peak, i.e. Imax Isat , we have: .
Class A, yc ¼ 2p. This is the case for all the amplifiers considered in Sections 11.2 to 11.5.1. In other words, class A amplifiers work with the input signal falling entirely within the linear region of the transistor transfer characteristic. Equivalently, we can say that the conduction angle of class A amplifiers equals 2p. The amplifier discussed in Section 11.5.1 works with the input signal placed right in the middle of the transistor linear region, xDC ¼ ðxmax þ xmin Þ=2; xpeak ðxmax xmin Þ=2. When the latter inequality is satisfied with the equals sign, the class A amplifier exhibits its maximum efficiency and output power, as pointed out in Section 11.5.1.
.
Class B, yc ¼ p. The transistor output current is non-zero for exactly half a cycle of the RF signal. Class B is the limit case for an amplifier with no drain/collector current without an input RF signal.
.
Class AB, p < yc ¼ 2p. Pure class B operation is quite theoretical, due to the lack of transistor gain in the low-current region. Figure 11.21 shows a representation of that phenomenon: the grey curve in Figure 11.21(iii) is the response of the non-ideal transfer characteristic in Figure 11.21(i), grey curve, to the input excitation (B) of Figure 11.21(iii). For this reason, the input working point of class AB amplifiers is not exactly placed on the conduction knee ðxmin Þ, but shifts towards a slightly higher value. This improves the gain flatness in the low input amplitude range, but also generates a small quiescent current flow in the absence of the input signal. Thus, class AB amplifiers present a conduction angle p < yc < 2p, intermediate between classes B and A.
462
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Vq
+
Output matching network
Isupply L dd
Cdd
IAC
I FUNDAMENTAL n:1
VAC
Ids , Ice Cgg
Vds , Vce Q1 ZLOAD
Vgs, Ib Lgg
ZS
C3
CN
L2
L3
LN
LN+1
T1
50Ω
T1
50Ω
2
RLOAD = n 50 Ω 2 f0
+ V RF
C2
3 f0
N f0
Vgg
(i)
Vq +
Isupply Ldd
L 2 I LOAD
C2
Ids , Ice Cgg
Vds , Vce Q1
Vgs , Ib
ZS
Lgg
VRF
Vgg
RLOAD
C1
+ (ii)
Vq
+
Output matching network
Isupply Ldd
Cdd
L3
Vds , Vce Q1
C3
IFUNDAMENTAL n:1
VAC
Ids , Ice Cgg
Vgs, Ib
ZS
Lgg
VRF
Vgg
CN
L2
LN
LN+1
RLOAD = n2 50 Ω +
(iii)
C2
2 f0
N f0
Figure 11.23 Schematics of PA principle: (i) class A, B or C; (ii) class E; (iii) class F.
.
Class C, yc < p: Small conduction angles minimize the amplifier’s efficiency at the expense of its linearity, as we will see shortly.
Class B and C amplifiers produce periodic non-sinusoidal output transistor current, differently from class A ones. For this reason, the output matching network of class B or C amplifiers not only presents a specific impedance to the transistor at the fundamental frequency, as usual, but also has additional requirements at harmonic frequencies. Figure 11.23(i) shows the principle of a class B or C amplifier. The output
AMPLIFIERS
463
matching network includes: .
One ideal transformer, to translate the 50 O load into any different required resistance.
.
A plurality (ideally an infinite number) of series LC cells each resonating at one harmonic frequency, in order to shunt all the current harmonics to ground.
.
The inductor LN þ 1, which parallel resonates with all the LC cells at the fundamental frequency, in order to cancel their reactance.
By removing all the series LC cells and the shunt inductor LN þ 1, the schematic in Figure 11.23 simplifies to that in Figure 11.11. Thus, the schematic in Figure 11.23 is a generalization of that in Figure 11.11, which is why the caption in Figure 11.23 describes a class A, B or C amplifier. From a more quantitative point of view, the transformer ratio n transforms the 50 O load into any required resistance RLOAD n¼
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi RLOAD =50
ð11:68Þ
The inductances of the series LC cells relate to the respective capacitances as Lh Ch ¼ ðko0 Þ2 ;
h ¼ 2; 3; . . . ; N
ð11:69Þ
At the fundamental frequency all those cells are below their resonant frequency, thus they present a capacitive reactance, and the same thing applies to the resulting bipole. Consequently, the inductor LN1 can resonate out the reactance of the LC series cells. The admittance that the matching network presents to the transistor output is YLOAD ð joÞ ¼
N N X X 1 jCh o 1 1 ¼ þ þ ¼ ZLOAD ð joÞ h¼1 1Lh Ch o2 jLN þ 1 o RLOAD h¼1
jCh o 1 1 þ
2 þ jL R o N þ1 LOAD o 1 ho0
At the fundamental frequency, it must be equal to the reciprocal of the optimum resistance. From YLOAD ð jo0 Þ ¼ 1=RLOAD it follows that LN þ 1 ¼
N X Ch o20 1h2 h¼1
!1 ð11:70Þ
The transistor output waveforms of the amplifier in Figure 11.23 can be computed by the same considerations as used in Section 11.5.1. The amplifier in Figure 11.23 differs from that in Figure 11.11 because, in the first, the transistor output current is non-sinusoidal and the load impedance is frequency dependent. However, the transistor output current is periodic, with the same period as the input signal; thus, we can expand it in a Fourier series, obtaining ids;ce ðtÞ ¼
1 X
ik cosðko0 tÞ
k¼0
with
i0 ¼
o0 2p
2p o ð0
Ids;ce ðtÞ dt 0
and
ih ¼
o0 p
2p o ð0
Ids;ce ðtÞcosðko0 tÞ dt ðh ¼ 1; 2 . . .Þ 0
ð11:71Þ
464
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Now, since the matching network shunts all the harmonics to ground, the first two terms of series (11.71) are of particular interest. The respective amplitude coefficients are
yc 2p p yc þ 2o o o 0 0 0 ð ð cos þ cosðo0 tÞ o0 o0 2
dt i0 ¼ Ids;ce ðtÞ dt ¼ Imax yc 2p 2p 1 cos 0 yc p 2 o0 2o0 p y yc p c yc o0 þ o0 þ ð 2o0 ð 2o0 cos o0 Imax 1 2
¼ dt þ cosðo0 tÞ dðo0 tÞ Imax yc yc 2p 2p cos 1 p yc 1 p yc cos 2 2 o0 2o0 o0 2o0 ð11:72Þ
yc
cos Imax I 1 yc yc 2 yc þ max
sin p þ ¼ sin p yc yc 2p 2p 2 2 cos 1 1 cos 2 2
yc yc yc 2sin cos Imax 2 2
¼ yc 2p cos 1 2
yc 2p p yc o o0 þ ð0 ð 2o0 cos þ cosðo0 tÞ o0 o0 2
Ids;ce ðtÞcosðo0 tÞ dt ¼ Imax cosðo0 tÞ dt i1 ¼ yc p p cos 1 0 yc p 2 o0 2o0 yc p p þ yc o0 þ o0 ð 2o0 ð 2o0 Imax yc Imax cosðo0 tÞ dðo0 tÞ þ cos2 ðo0 tÞ dðo0 tÞ cos p 2 p yc yc p p o0 2o0 o0 2o0
¼ yc 1 cos 2 yc yc p p p þ yc o0 þ o0 þ o0 ð 2o0 ð 2o0 ð 2o0 yc 1 1 cos cosðo0 tÞ dðo0 tÞ þ cosð2o0 tÞ dðo0 tÞ þ dðo0 tÞ 2 2 2 yc yc yc p p p Imax o0 2o0 o0 2o0 o0 2o0
¼ yc p 1 cos 2
yc yc yc 1 yc sin p þ sin p þ ½sinð2p þ yc Þsinð2pyc Þ þ cos Imax 4 2 2 2 2
¼ yc p cos 1 2
yc yc 1 yc 2 cos sin þ sinðyc Þ þ Imax 2 2 2 2
¼ yc p cos 1 2 yc 1 Imax 2 2 sinðyc Þ
ð11:73Þ ¼ yc p 1 cos 2
AMPLIFIERS
465
Note that the quantity Imax is the positive peak of the transistor output current, as Figure 11.22 shows. The inductor Ldd transmits the continuous current while presenting infinite impedance at the fundamental frequency, and at its harmonics a fortiori. On the contrary, the capacitor Cdd stops the direct current while passing the RF current. Therefore, the only component of the transistor output current to pass through Ldd is the DC one, and thus the DC generator supplies the current isupply ¼ i0. Then, the current balance at the transistor output implies that iAC ðtÞ ¼ ids;ce ðtÞisupply ¼
1 X
ik cosðko0 tÞi0 ¼
k¼0
1 X
ik cosðko0 tÞ
k¼1
By hypothesis, the output matching network shunts to ground all the current harmonics except the fundamental. The voltage across the transformer input is then vAC ðtÞ ¼ RLOAD i1 cosðo0 tÞ ¼ n2 50 i1 cosðo0 tÞ The voltage across Cdd is constant and equal to Vq , as a consequence of the infinite value of Cdd itself, hence the transistor output voltage is vds;ce ðtÞ ¼ Vq þ vAC ðtÞ ¼ Vq þ RLOAD i1 cosðo0 tÞ The idealized transistor amplifies only if vds;ce 0, thus the maximum peak-to-peak excursion of the output voltage is 0 vds;ce ðtÞ 2Vq . Consequently, it must be jRLOAD i1 j Vq . The resistance for the maximum output power is then Vq ð11:74Þ RLOAD;PMAX ¼ i1 If the load resistance exceeds the limit (11.12), the transistor will work differently from our hypothesis. In particular, when vds;ce becomes negative, the transistor can supply no current, and saturation occurs on the latter, as Figure 11.12 shows (upper left graph, grey line). The RF output power is maximum when the transistor output voltage swing is maximum, which occurs if the load resistance assumes the value in (11.74). Note that the optimum load resistance depends on the conduction angle. The RF power delivered to the load is 32 yc 1 sinðy Þ c 7 RLOAD 6 7 6Imax 2 2
¼ 5 yc 2 2 4 p 1 cos 2 2
PLOAD ¼ RLOAD
i12
ð11:75Þ
Substituting Equation (11.74) into (11.75), we obtain the maximum RF power deliverable to the load
PLOAD;MAX
yc 1 Imax 2 2 sinðyc Þ
¼ Vq yc 2p 1 cos 2
ð11:76Þ
Note that, if yc ¼ 2p, Equation (11.76) coincides with the second value of Equation (11.43), as expected.
466
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 1.2
100
1.0
90
70 0.6
η ( θ c)
60
η(θc)
Pout(θc)/Pout(2π)
80 0.8
0.4 50 Pout (θc)/Pout(2π)
0.2
40
0.0 0
90
180
270
30 360
-1
180 π θc , deg.
Figure 11.24 Maximum output power (black) and maximum power added efficiency (grey) for the amplifier in Figure 11.23. The power delivered from the output DC voltage generator is
PDC ¼ Vq i0 ¼ Vq
Imax 2p
yc cos
yc yc 2 sin 2 2
yc cos 1 2
ð11:77Þ
The resulting efficiency is Z¼
1 RLOAD Imax yc sinðyc Þ 1 sinðy Þ yc c
yc yc yc 2 Vq 2p 2 yc cos 1 cos 2sin 2 2 2
ð11:78Þ
Figure 11.24 plots the quantities (11.76) and (11.78) as the black and grey lines, respectively. The output power is normalized to the power of a class A amplifier having the same transistor maximum current. Figure 11.24 shows that Z increases for small conduction angles, up to a theoretical 100% at yc ¼ 0. On the other hand, the output power decreases with the conduction angle as well and vanishes if yc ¼ 0. Observations: (a) From the considerations developed so far, it follows that the conduction angle is a function of the input peak amplitude xpeak and mean value xDC , where the latter depends on the input bias. Furthermore, the combination of Vq ; RLOAD and yc determines the maximum peak output current without saturation, maximum output power and efficiency. (b) The maximum theoretical efficiency of class A, B and C amplifiers is 50%; 50p=2 ffi 78:54% and 100%, providing that their load resistances assume the value in (11.74). Classes A and B present the same maximum output power, while a 100% efficiency in class C implies zero output power. Assuming a conduction angle of yc ¼ 2p=3 (120 ), a class C amplifier presents an
AMPLIFIERS
467
efficiency of 89.68%, while its output power equals 61.2% of a class A amplifier having the same maximum current. (c) For a given Imax , Equation (11.76) reaches its maximum if yc ffi 4:278 ð245:1 Þ, which is PLOAD;MAX ð4:278Þ PLOAD;MAX ð4:278Þ ¼ ffi 1:073 PLOAD;MAX ðpÞ PLOAD;MAX ð2pÞ with the associated efficiency Zðyc ¼ 4:278Þ ffi 65%. (d) The input amplitude required to drive the amplifier is proportional to the xpeak value associated with a given output power. Substituting Equation (11.65) into (11.66), we obtain the input peak level as a function of output current peak and conduction angle xpeax ¼
1 I max yc GL 1 cos 2
Assuming yc ¼ 2p; yc ¼ p and yc ¼ 2p=3, we have the values for class A, B and one case of C operation xpeax;A ¼
1 Imax ; 2 GL
xpeax;B ¼
Imax ; GL
xpeax;C ¼ 2
Imax GL
Class A, B and C amplifiers require input excitation amplitudes that are in the ratio of 1, 2 and 4, in order to produce the respective maximum output power. Despite this, class C power is 61.2% of class A or B power. Consequently, small conduction angles are possible only if the transistor has enough gain, otherwise the power consumed to produce the driving signal compromises the overall efficiency. (e) Equation (11.74) with yc ¼ p gives the output power of a class B amplifier as a function of the input excitation amplitude PLOAD;B ¼
RLOAD;B G2L x2peak 8
Thus, a purely ideal class B amplifier is linear, in that its output power at the fundamental frequency is proportional to the square amplitude of the input sinusoid. This characteristic is peculiar to class A and B amplifiers: any conduction angle different from 180 or 360 leads to a nonlinear relation between input and output power. In particular, class C amplifiers produce no output signal until the input positive peak exceeds xmin. The Fourier coefficients (11.71) for class B amplifiers are
ih;B
o0 ¼ p
2p o ð0
0
Imax ¼ 2p
o0 Ids;ce ðtÞcosðo0 tÞ dt ¼ p
1 2ðp
Imax cos½ðh þ 1Þx dx þ 2p
3 2p
and vanish for odd h.
3p 2ð o0
Imax cosðo0 tÞcosðho0 tÞ dt 1p 2o0
1 2ðp
cos½ðh1Þx dx ¼ 3 2p
Imax 1 þ ð1Þh p 1 h2
468
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
(Q1)
vds,ce1 ids,ce 2 1
Vgs1, Ib1
nin VRF
Q1
Tin
(Q1)
Vgs2 , Ib2
(Q2)
2
iout= [i ds,ce - i ds,ce ] n out
1 1
j Zout
50 Ω
nout
(Q2) vds,ce2 ids,ce
3 Tout
Q2
3 +
+
Vgg
(a)
nout
nin
j Zin
50Ω
2
Vq
Iout(t) AB B O
T/2
t T
(b)
Figure 11.25
Push–pull amplifier: (a) schematic diagram; (b) output current waveform.
Thus, class B amplifiers present only even-order nonlinear distortion, which can be cancelled with a 180 balanced configuration. Moreover, even-order intermodulation products are unlikely to fall in the working bandwidth,45 particularly in narrow-band circuits: in this case the output filter cancels both the even harmonics and the intermodulation products. However, it must be considered that real class B amplifiers produce output current waveforms like the grey curve in Figure 11.21(iii), rather than half sinusoids, due to the drop in transistor gain at low output currents. Therefore, real class B amplifiers are not linear and produce odd harmonics as well, although relatively small amounts of quiescent current (class AB) can alleviate the problem, particularly with the 180 balanced configuration. (f) So far, we have compared different amplifiers using the same transistor by assuming they present the same maximum instantaneous current. A different comparison, based on device dissipation, is possible. Clearly, this criterion results in more efficient amplifiers presenting lower transistor dissipation to produce the same output RF power, or, equivalently, they produce more RF power for a given device power. No conduction angle is preferable in respect of the transistor voltage swing, in that the maximum power is always achieved when vds;ce swings from zero to 2Vq : Equations (11.74), (11.76) and (11.78) follow exactly from this assumption. From observation (e) it follows that class B amplifiers are particularly suitable for application in 180
balanced amplifiers; Figure 11.25 shows one implementation of such a configuration. In that network the two ideal transformers Tin and Tout – having transformer ratios nin and nout respectively – replace the two 180 hybrids of Figure 11.20a. 45
See Section 9.5.
AMPLIFIERS
469
If nin ¼ nout ¼ 1 the scattering matrix of Tin and Tout is almost coincident with Equation (11.48); the only difference is that s23 ¼ s32 6¼ 0. However, the transmission between ports 2 and 3 of the transformers is not relevant for the subsequent considerations of this section. If nin ; nout 6¼ 1, Tin and Tout match the input and output 50 O into the required impedance in combination with the two reactances Zin ; Zout . The circuit in Figure 11.25a consists of two identical amplifiers – built around the transistors Q1 and Q2 respectively – biased for class B operation. The input transformer excites the amplifier inputs with two signals having the same amplitude but opposite phase. Then, the output currents of the two transistors are half sinusoids with a reciprocal phase shift of half a period. Expanding the transistor output currents as a Fourier series and using the coefficients as in observation (c), and considering that the odd coefficients are zero, we have ðQ1Þ
ids;ce ðtÞ ¼
1 X GL xin GL xin GL xin 2 cosðo0 tÞ þ cosð2ko0 tÞ p 2 p 14k2 k¼1
The output current from the transistor Q2 has a similar expression, but with the time shifted by half a period
T p ðQ2Þ ¼ Ids;ce;1 t ids;ce ðtÞ ¼ Ids;ce;1 t 2 o0
X
1 GL xin GL xin p GL xin 2 p cos 2ko t ¼ cos o0 t þ 0 p 2 p 14k2 o0 o0 h¼1 ¼
1 X GL xin GL xin GL xin 2 cosð2ko0 t 2kpÞ cosðo0 t pÞ þ p 2 p 1 4k2 h¼1
¼
1 X GL xin GL xin GL xin 2 cosð2ko0 tÞ þ cosðo0 tÞ þ p 2 p 1 4k2 h¼1
The push–pull amplifier output current is then h i ðQ1Þ ðQ1Þ iout ðtÞ ¼ ids;ce ðtÞ ids;ce ðtÞ n2 2 ¼ n22 GL xin cosðo0 tÞ
ð11:79Þ
Expression (11.79) states that the current flowing in the load is purely sinusoidal, and its amplitude is proportional to that of the input signal. Of course, this applies similarly to the output voltage, and to the ðQ1Þ ðQ2Þ transistor output voltages ids;ce ðtÞ; ids;ce ðtÞ, due to the output transformer. Therefore the push–pull class B amplifier is linear and distortion free, and both of its transistors work as in a conventional single-ended configuration: the output current waveform is a half sinusoid, while the voltage is sinusoidal. Note that this result is achieved without any filtering structure in the output matching network, differently from the network in Figure 11.23(i). As can be seen, for each half cycle one of the two transistors supplies the current to the load. This kind of operation resembles that of two woodcutters using a two-handled saw to fell a tree: for this reason the configuration in Figure 11.25a is also known as push–pull. Compared with each of its two single-ended amplifiers, the circuit in Figure 11.25 absorbs double the supply current and – neglecting the output transformer loss – delivers double the RF power. Therefore the push–pull class B amplifier has the same efficiency as the single-ended one. The 180 balanced (or push–pull) class B amplifier is the most efficient solution among all the possible linear amplifiers. So far, we have considered the effects of the drop in gain in the low-current region of the transistor, already mentioned within the description of class AB operation. If the input bias of the transistors Q1 ; Q2 falls somewhere around the point marked B in Figure 11.21(i), the transistor output current waveform differs from a half sinusoid. Rather, it is distorted, mainly in the proximity of zero current, as the grey curve in Figure 11.21(iii) shows. If the transistor’s working point is too close to point C in
470
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Figure 11.21(iii) – or, equivalently, if the quiescent current is too low – then the above-mentioned distortion becomes relevant, and the load current assumes the shape shown in Figure 11.25(ii) by the grey curve, marked as B. That waveform is a sinusoid, distorted in the zero- crossing region: for this reason it is referred to as crossover distortion. Crossover distortion compromises the linearity and causes odd-order nonlinear distortion in the amplifier. Class AB operation, with a judicious choice of quiescent current, can alleviate the problem, while minimizing degradation of the efficiency. The technique consists of ðQ1Þ ðQ2Þ producing ids;ce ; ids;ce that are both non-zero in a proper interval across t ¼ T=2. This way, both the transistors contribute to the output current when working in the respective low-output-current region, with the gain increasing by a factor of 2. Class A to C amplifiers have one common working principle: part of the output bias generator power produces RF power on the load at the fundamental frequency, while the transistor dissipates the remaining part. Therefore, amplifier efficiency is maximum when the transistor dissipation is minimum, and the latter is the average over one period of the product of transistor output voltage and current: ðQ1;Q2Þ PDISSIPATED
ðT 1 ðQ1;Q2Þ ðQ1;Q2Þ ¼ v ðtÞids;ce ðtÞ dt T ds;ce 0
The transistor dissipation can be increased by ensuring that vds;ce is low when ids;ce is high and vice versa. In the ideal case, the transistor dissipation is zero. This occurs if vds;ce > 0 ðids;ce > 0Þ implies that ids;ce ¼ 0 ðvds;ce ¼ 0Þ. The basic idea behind class D operation is that abrupt variations in vds;ce and/or ids;ce from zero to their maximum reduce the time when they are both non-zero, thus minimizing the transistor dissipation. The schematic showing the principle of a class D amplifier is very similar to the one in Figure 11.25, with the addition of a low-pass or bandpass network between the reactance Zout and the 50 O load. The two transistors are biased in order to have no quiescent current without input signal, similar to class B or C. The input signal is strong enough to overdrive the two transistors that essentially work as switches: in the OFF (ON) state this is vds;ce > 0; ids;ce ¼ 0 ðvds;ce ¼ 0; ids;ce > 0Þ. The transistors of an ideal class D amplifier change their ON/OFF state in a very short time; in other words, their transition time is zero. Under that hypothesis, in the first half of the cycle, for 0 < t < T=2, Q1 is OFF and Q2 is ON. The opposite happens in the second half of the cycle, for T=2 < t < T. Hence, at any instant ðQ1Þ ðQ1Þ ðQ2Þ ðQ2Þ vds;ce ids;ce ¼ vds;ce ids;ce ¼ 0, the two transistors dissipate no power. During the transition time, of course, the transistor output voltage and current are both non-zero, with a consequent power dissipation in the device. Without the need for further analyses, we can state that the current to the load is periodic with the same period as the exciting signal. The above-mentioned output low-pass or bandpass filter eliminates the harmonics, so that the output signal is sinusoidal. Therefore, an ideal class D amplifier presents unitary efficiency (PAE ¼ 100%), until the transition time becomes negligible. Thus the transistor transition time must be zero, or at least much shorter than the fundamental period. This requirement limits the maximum frequency for class D operation to a few tens of megahertz. Figure 11.23(ii) shows a more interesting solution for RF/microwave applications, known as a class E amplifier. The schematic does not explicitly show the output transformer matching the 50 O load into the required impedance, but we will assume it is present if needed. The basic idea is to use the capacitor C1 across the output of the transistor to minimize the effects of the finite transition time of the transistor. The complete analysis of the circuit is too long to fit in this chapter,46 so we will mention just the assumptions made and the final design equations: 1. The inductor Ldd is large enough that only the direct current isupply flows through it. 2. The loaded quality factor of the resonant circuit consisting of L2 and C2 is high enough to ensure that the current iLOAD is sinusoidal with the same period as the exciting signal. This also implies 46
The interested reader can find more details in [3, 4] and references therein.
AMPLIFIERS
471
Q1 ON
vout Q1 OFF
vds,ce
ids,ce 0
1 Time, ns
Figure 11.26
2
Class E amplifier waveforms.
that the resonant circuit removes all the harmonics. However, the resonant frequency of the network is slightly different from o0 , as we will see shortly. 3. The transistor Q1 works like a perfect switch: in the OFF (ON) state its output current (voltage) is zero. 4. The transistor output capacitance, if any, is independent of the voltage, and is lower than C1 , which represents the combined added and transistor output capacitance. Under these hypotheses, the operation of a class E amplifier is relatively straightforward. Figure 11.26 shows the waveforms relative to one simulated circuit.47 When the switch is ON, vds;ce ¼ 0, and all the direct current from the power supply flows through the transistor. As soon as the switch becomes OFF, the direct current begins to charge the capacitor C1, but the resonant circuit makes the voltage go back to zero. With a proper design of the circuit, vds;ce becomes zero immediately before the transistor goes ON again, thus minimizing the transistor power dissipation during the transient. It is possible to demonstrate that the amplifier efficiency is maximum if in the state change instant the transistor output voltage and its time derivative are zero vds;ce ðt ¼ T=2Þ ¼
dvds;ce ðt ¼ T=2Þ ¼0 dt
This result can be achieved with the value combination L2 ¼ QL
RLOAD ; o0
C1 ¼
p2 p 1 þ1 ; 2 RLOAD o0 4
C2 ¼
1 1:42 1 þ QL 2:08 o20 L2
ð11:80Þ
where the design parameter QL is the loaded quality factor of the resonant circuit consisting of L2 and C2 .
47
See the SIMetrix file 24_Class_E_GHz.sxsch.
472
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING With the values from (11.78), we get: .
Z ¼ 100%.
.
Output power: PLOAD ¼
p2
Vq2 Vq2 8 ffi 0:577 þ 4 RLOAD RLOAD
Class B amplifiers have PLOAD ¼ 0:5Vq2 =RLOAD . .
Transistor peak voltage: 1
Vds;ce;peak ¼ 2p sin
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi! 4 Vq ffi 3:56Vq p2 þ 4
Class A to C amplifiers have Vds;ce;peak ¼ 2Vq . .
Transistor peak current: " Ids;ce;peak ¼ isupply
.
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
# p2 1 1þ þ 1 1 2QL 4
If QL tends to infinity, and since isupply ¼ PLOAD =Vq , we have Ids;ce;peak ffi 2:86PLOAD =Vq , thus class B amplifiers present a peak current of Imax ¼ 4PLOAD =Vq .
Normally, the filtering action of the resonator L2 ; C2 is not sufficient to attenuate the harmonics as required. Therefore one additional low-pass or bandpass filter is often placed between the resonator and the load. This modifies the circuit waveforms, and usually requires an adjustment of the values of C1 ; C2 ; L2 , normally performed with CAE tools. Figure 11.23(iii) shows the principle of a class F amplifier. Its output matching network shunts to ground all the harmonics but the third one; at that frequency it presents a high impedance to the transistor, unlike class A to C amplifiers. From a conceptual point of view, the parallel resonator L3 ; C3 in Figure 11.23(iii) replaces the series resonator L3 ; C3 in Figure 11.23(i). The transistor output voltage of class F amplifiers is then the sum of two sinusoidal components, one at the fundamental frequency and one at the third harmonic. The resulting waveform resembles a square wave. Consequently, vds;ce is higher (lower) when ids;ce ¼ 0 ðids;ce > 0Þ, with a resulting increased efficiency. Figure 11.27 shows the typical waveforms of a class F amplifier.48 Class F operation requires a conduction angle slightly smaller than p, in order to ensure that a third harmonic is present49 on the output current and that ids;ce ¼ 0 when vds;ce > 0, for a higher efficiency. The transistor behaves as a variable-current generator, producing a waveform similar to class B operation. The output matching network makes the load current sinusoidal, and the parallel resonator L3 ; C3 provides a third harmonic on the transistor output voltage. If this component has 1/9 the fundamental amplitude, and the proper phase, it flattens the output voltage and reduces its maximum amplitude by a factor of 8/9, as Figure 11.27 shows (black solid line in the upper plot). This allows an increase in the load resistance by the reciprocal of the same factor, and hence an increase in the maximum swing of vds;ce (grey solid line in the upper plot of Figure 11.27). Consequently, 48
See the Mathcad file 10_Class_C_F.MCD. Keep in mind that yc ¼ p implies that all the even-order harmonics of the output current are zero, as in observation (e) of this section. 49
AMPLIFIERS
473
Vq + R LOAD i1 cos(ω 0 t) Vq + RLOAD [ i1 cos(ω0 t) - (i3 /9) cos(3ω0t)] Vq + (8/9) i1 RLOAD
vds,ce (t)
RLOAD(i3 /9) cos(3ω 0t)
Vq - (8/9) RLOAD i1
ids,ce (t)
0
1
2
ω0 t/(2 π)
Figure 11.27
Class F amplifier waveforms.
the output power and efficiency increase by the same factor, becoming respectively 9 Vq 9 Vq i2 9 9p ; PLOAD;F ¼ RLOAD;F 1 ¼ Vq Imax ; PAEF ¼ ffi 88:3% RLOAD;F ¼ ¼ 8 i1 4 Imax 32 2 32 Class F is a kind of enhancement of class B that theoretically increases output power and efficiency by about 10% through careful design of the output matching network and the transistor working point. Moreover, class F operation relies on a precise third-harmonic value, therefore it works in a narrow range of the input power. Note that the load of a class F amplifier differs from the class B one mainly in its impedance on the third harmonic. That difference increases the maximum output power and efficiency by about 10%; it is reasonable to assume that the wrong third-harmonic impedance could decrease the above parameters by the same quantity. This gives a still approximate, but more precise, idea than the one in Section 11.5.3 of the importance of the harmonic impedance on amplifier performance.
11.5.6
Amplifier linearization
The description of class A to F amplifiers, given in Section 11.5.5, shows that linearity and efficiency are difficult to conciliate. Furthermore, when a low distortion level is required, the amplifier must work in class A or B and well below its maximum power, with a consequent degradation of its efficiency. This section presents some configurations to increase PA linearity by keeping the efficiency constant and/or vice versa. The overall result is lower distortion with a given DC power, although with a more complex circuit than the one in Figure 11.1. The various proposed configurations achieve this result by applying different approaches. Solutions in Sections 11.5.6.1 and 11.5.6.2 correct the PA nonlinearity by adding suitable amounts of distortion, while the one in Section extends the efficient working of the PA over a relatively wide output power range. Finally Sections 11.5.6.4 and 11.5.6.5 present two ways to use saturated amplifiers to produce signals with controlled time-variable amplitude.
11.5.6.1 Predistortion The discussion in Section 9.5 pointed out that the distortion level at the output of a nonlinear two-port is an increasing function of the ratio between the actual and the 1 dB compression power of the network.
474
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Predistorter D1
Input
1
2
D2 R1
1
Figure 11.28
4
3 R2
2
5
Output
3
Amplifier linearization based on predistortion.
Amplifiers are no exception to this rule. More quantitatively, Equation (9.56) states that the input power for the third-order intercept is 9.6 dB lower than the one corresponding to 1 dB of compression. Therefore, if the input power equals I1dBdBm the third-order distortion products of the amplifier are 9:6 2 ¼ 19:2 dB below the carriers. If, for instance, a distortion level of 40 dB is required, the input power must be ð4019:2Þ=2 ¼ 10:4 dB below P1dBdBm. Considering that the saturated power is about 2.5 dB higher than the 1 dB compression point, the corresponding output power is 10:4 þ 2:5 ffi 13 dB below the maximum considered in Sections 11.4 and 11.5: the efficiency becomes 5% of the maximum value (11.78). Figure 11.28 shows a conceptually simple solution to increase the linear range of the amplifier closer to the 1 dB compression point. The basic idea is to place a nonlinear two-port between the RF generator and the amplifier input, to compensate the transfer characteristic of the amplifier itself. The network within the dashed rectangle in Figure 11.28 is one of many possible implementations of the predistorter. Its working principle can easily be explained by considering the diode I–V curve in Figure 9.37. Neglecting the breakdown, the diode current presents a knee for forward voltages VTH that is about 1 V in the graph of Figure 9.39. In order to develop simple expressions, we will approximate the diode characteristic with a two-segment piecewise-linear curve: the diode current is zero when its forward voltage is less than VTH ; above that limit, the diode is constant and equal to VTH . With this assumption, the voltage transfer characteristic from nodes 2 to 3 becomes 8
R2 R1 þ R2 8 > > > V2 < VTH < R2 V ðjV V j < V Þ < R þ R V2 R1 2 2 3 TH 1 2
V3 ¼ R1 þ R2 ¼ : > R 1 þ R2 > V2 VTH ðjV2 V3 j VTH Þ > V2 VTH : V2 VTH R1 Thus, the predistorter exhibits a low gain A1 A2 R2 =ðR1 þ R2 Þ when the input amplitude is less than VTH ðR1 þ R2 Þ=A1 and a high gain A1 A2 elsewhere. The two amplifiers A1 ; A2 are supposed to be linear for any input power within the operative range; their gains are additional parameters to adjust the predistorter characteristic. In real networks, the transition between low gain and high gain is not abrupt as in our simplified analysis, rather the transition zone presents a smoothed knee.50 By experimenting with the design parameters A1 ; A2 ; R1 =R2 it is possible to shape the predistorter characteristic to be the complement of the PA one. Figure 11.29 shows the compression characteristics of a PA (thick grey), predistorter (thin black) and their combination (thick black). As reference, Figure 11.29 also shows the linear characteristic (black dashed). The predistorter increases its gain in correspondence to the PA compression: the negative compression of the first compensates the latter. Of course, no predistortion can increase the PA saturated power, but it can improve the overall linearity up to an input level close to the saturation point, as in Figure 11.29. 50
See the SIMetrix file 23_Diode_Predistorter_Curve.sxsch.
AMPLIFIERS predistorter
475
linear
Output power, dBm
linearized
power amplifier
Input power, dBm
Figure 11.29
PA, predistorter and global compression curves.
TL 1
5
3 1 6
3
φ PH1
1
IN
2 DIV1
7
φ PH2
ATT2
AMP2
ATT1
TL 2
2
COUP1
4
OUT COUP2
COUP3
AMP1
Figure 11.30
Feedforward linearization of a PA.
The application of a properly designed predistorter51 can increase the linear range of the PA up to few decibels below the 1 dB compression point, with third-order distortion products in the range of 40 dB. As a drawback, the predistortion technique requires that the low- to high-gain transition occurs at a precise level which depends on the I1dB and SSG of the PA. Both these two parameters vary with frequency, temperature and from piece to piece: the network adjustment could be critical.
11.5.6.2 Feedforward Figure 11.30 shows a distortion-reducing configuration based on adding to the output signal the opposite of the distortion products of the PA. This solution is known as feedforward. The following considerations are a simplified analysis of the block diagram in Figure 11.30, under the hypothesis that all the blocks are perfectly impedance matched. The block AMP1 is the PA to be linearized. The diagram also includes one additional amplifier (AMP2 ), three directional couplers (COUP1 , COUP2 and COUP3 ), two phase shifters (PH1 ; PH2 ), two attenuators (ATT1 ; ATT2 ), two transmission lines (TL1 ; TL2 ) and one power divider (DIV1 ) used as a power adder. 51
See the Mathcad file 11_Predistortion.MCD.
476
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The coupled output ports of COUP1 and COUP2 provide an attenuated sample of the input and output signals of AMP1 , respectively; the difference between a proper combination of these two signals is the amplifier distortion. Let the input voltage be VIN ; then the resulting amplifier output is qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðAMP1Þ V2 ¼ j 1c21 s21 VIN þ DIST ðAMP1Þ
where s21 is the transmission coefficient of AMP1 , c1 is the coupling coefficient of COUP1 and DIST is the nonlinear distortion of the PA. In the block diagram in Figure 11.30 there are two signal paths from the input to node 6. One of them includes AMP1 , and therefore transmits the associated distortion. The other path consists of linear networks only: COUP1 , COUP2 , PH1 and ATT1 . The characteristics of the various block are such that the two above-mentioned paths present the same amplitude gain and a relative phase shift of 180 , and this occurs if qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðTL1Þ ðDIV1Þ ðAMP2Þ ðPH1Þ ðATT1Þ ðDIV1Þ c1 s21 s13 ¼ j 1c21 s21 c2 s21 s21 s12 ð11:81Þ where .
c2 is the coupling coefficient of COUP2 .
.
s12 and s12 respectively.
.
s21 ; s21 ; s21 respectively.
ðDIV1Þ
ðTL1Þ
ðDIV1Þ
ðAMP2Þ
are the transmission coefficients of DIV1 from its ports 2 to 1 and 3 to 1,
ðPH1Þ
ðATT1Þ
and s21
are the transmission coefficients of TL1 , AMP2 , PH1 and ATT1 ,
This way, the signal at node 6 is proportional to the PA nonlinear distortion: ðPH1Þ ðATT1Þ ðDIV1Þ s21 s12 DIST
V6 ¼ c2 s21
AMP2 , ATT2 and PH2 amplify the error signal V6 and send it to the output in phase opposition to the PA nonlinear distortion, in order to cancel it. The nonlinear distortion of AMP1 is then present on the PA output (node 2) itself and on the power divider common port (node 6). If the two paths from nodes 2 and 6 to the output have the same gain amplitude and are 180 out of phase, the result is cancellation of the distortion at the output. The distortion cancellation implies that qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðPH1Þ ðATT1Þ ðDIV1Þ ðPH2Þ ðATT2Þ ðAMP2Þ ðTL2Þ s21 s21 s12 s21 s21 s21 c2 ¼ 1c22 s21 1c23 ð11:82Þ ðPH2Þ
ðATT2Þ
ðAMP2Þ
ðTL2Þ
; s21 and s21 are the transmission coefficients of PH2 , ATT2 , AMP2 and TL2 , where s21 ; s21 respectively, and c3 is the coupling factor of COUP3 . Equations (11.81) and (11.82) relate the transmission coefficients of the various blocks in ðAMP1Þ and Figure 11.30. These relations must be verified within the PA working bandwidth, with s21 ðAMP2Þ varying over the frequency. Consequently, TL1 and TL2 could not be simple transmission lines: in s21 the general case, they are linear two-port networks with a specified transmission coefficient phase (or ðATT1Þ ðATT2Þ and s21 could be frequency dependent. group delay) over the frequency. Similarly, s21 Furthermore, it is required that the amplifier AMP2 operates linearly. In respect of this consideration, the choice of the coupling coefficient c2 results from a compromise between two opposite requirements. High c2 implies high attenuation on the direct path, and thus high loss on the PA output power. Conversely, low c2 implies high attenuation from the output to AMP2 to the overall output, and therefore higher output power required from AMP2 . For example, if c2 ¼ 100:5 ð10 dBÞ, and neglecting the loss due to TL2 and the direct path of COUP2 , the loss from AMP1 to the overall output is 10 log10 1c23 ffi 0:46 dB. Correspondingly, the
AMPLIFIERS
477
linear output power of AMP2 must be 10 dB higher than the distortion power produced by AMP1. If the feedforward correction has to work up to the 1 dB compression output power of AMP1 O1dBðAMP1Þ , then the corresponding third-order distortion is about 18.2 dB lower than O1dBðAMP1Þ . Thus, the linear range of AMP2 should be no lower than O1dBAMP1 18:2 þ 10 dB ¼ O1dBAMP1 8:2 dB. At this level, if, for instance, O1dBðAMP2Þ ¼ O1dBðAMP1Þ , AMP2 itself produces third-order intermodulation products at a level of 2 8:2 18:2 dB ¼ 34:6 dB below O1dBðAMP1Þ. COUP3 attenuates them by an additional 10 dB. The resulting distortion on the feedforward system is then 44.6 dBc below the carrier. The overall DC output power of this specific feedforward-corrected amplifier is twice that of a single amplifier; in addition the output power is 0.45 dB lower than AMP1 itself. Nevertheless, the solution is still convenient if linearity is a requirement. By comparison, a simple amplifier with no correction requires an output 1 dB compression power of O1dBðAMP1Þ þ ð44:6 18:2Þ=20:45 2 dB ¼ O1dBðAMP1Þ þ 12:3 dB: the corresponding DC power is 101:23 =2 ffi 8:49 times higher than the solution in Figure 11.30. The simplified description of the feedforward working principle pointed out, however, that the distortion cancellation relies on equal-amplitude gain and phase of different RF paths. Each of them can vary over frequency, temperature, time and from piece to piece. Therefore, some parameters of the correction branches are adjustable, usually PH1, ATT1 , PH2 and ATT2 . Sophisticated implementations of the feedforward configuration include automatic computer control of those components, which periodically measures the distortion and applies the required adjustments.
11.5.6.3 Doherty amplifier Figure 11.31 shows an arrangement known as the Doherty amplifier,52 from the name of its inventor. The network in Figure 11.31 resembles the 90 balanced amplifier, but it works differently, as we will see shortly. The diagram in Figure 11.31a includes one main amplifier, AMP1 , operating at low input power, and one peak amplifier, AMP2 , which adds its contribution only at high input power. AMP1 operates in ðAMP1Þ class B53 and then behaves as linear from a small input power up to a maximum PIN;max . AMP2 operates in ðAMP1Þ ðAMP1Þ class C, and its output current is zero if PIN < PIN;max . Therefore, in the range of 0 < PIN < PIN;max , the Doherty amplifier works like the schematic in Figure 10.32b: the output of the inoperative AMP2 is an open circuit, and the l/4 transmission line presents a resistive load of 4RLOAD to the output of AMP1 . The ðAMP1Þ latter is designed such that the resistance 4RLOAD equals the best value (11.74) when PIN ¼ PIN;max ; in ðAMP1Þ this condition AMP1 presents its maximum efficiency of 78.54%. Let Imax be the output current peak of AMP1 in this condition. By virtue of Equations (11.72) and (11.73)
y ¼p yc yc c 1 1 cos cos V 2 2 q ðAMP1Þ p ¼ 1 Vq ¼ i1 Imax p¼ yc 1 4RLOAD yc 1 2 RLOAD sinðyc Þ sinðyc Þ 2 2 2 2 ðAMP1Þ
the corresponding output power is POUT ¼ Vq2 =ð8RLOAD Þ. ðAMP1Þ As PIN increases above PIN;max , AMP1 saturates if AMP2 is not present. Instead, at that point, AMP2 ðAMP2Þ begins to deliver RF output power, increasing with PIN . At the input power PIN ¼ PIN;max the peak amplifier gets close to saturation. If the two amplifiers present the same maximum power, at that point they deliver the same signal to the load, because the two paths from the input to the load (node 5) have the same phase.54 Therefore, we can consider the two amplifiers as delivering half of the current to the load. Thus each of them sees a resistance equal to 2RLOAD as Figure 11.31c shows. In this condition AMP1 52
More details about the Doherty amplifier can be found in the references [5] and [6]. The main amplifier can also work in class A, with subsequent minor modifications which remain qualitatively valid. 54 Each path includes one amplifier and a 90 phase shift. 53
478
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 1
√0.5
4
2
-j √0.5
5 TL1 Z 0 = 2 R LOAD θ= π/2
1
R LOAD
3 (a)
2
in
Z L= 4 RLOAD 1
√0.5
4
2
-j √0.5
5 TL 1 Z 0 = 2 R LOAD θ=π/2
1
RLOAD
3 (b)
2
in
ZL= 2 RLOAD 1
√0.5
4
2
-j √0.5
1
5 TL1 Z0= 2 RLOAD θ=π/2
3 (c)
in
2 R LOAD
2 R LOAD 2
Z L = 2 RLOAD
Figure 11.31 Doherty amplifier: (a) schematic; (b) equivalent circuit for low-output-power operation; (c) equivalent circuit for high-power operation. ðAMP1Þ
works linearly up to a current peak equal to 2Imax , due to reduced load resistance from 4RLOAD to ðAMP2Þ ðAMP1Þ 2RLOAD . Its maximum output power is then POUT ¼ Vq2 =ð4RLOAD Þ ¼ 2POUT . In the same time, AMP2 delivers the same power to the load, by hypothesis. The total maximum power is than POUT;max ¼ ðAMP1Þ ðAMP1Þ 4POUT;1 POUT;max ¼ 4POUT , corresponding to an input power of 4PIN;max . Thus, the Doherty amplifier ðAMP1Þ efficiency monotonically increases with input power from zero ðPIN ¼ 0Þ to 78.54% ðPIN ¼ PIN;max Þ, then it stays almost constant for another 6 dB of increasing input level. More precisely, the efficiency in the higher range is ideally higher than 78.54%, in that it results from a combination of two amplifiers, one class B and one class C. Therefore, the Doherty configuration offers nearly the same efficiency as class B, but for a wider output power range, still ensuring the linearity.
AMPLIFIERS 4
479
5 DET1
LPF1 Vcc
1
IN
2
3
OUT
COUP1 (a)
AMP1
AMP2
envelope
carrier RF signal
(b)
Figure 11.32 PA architecture with envelope elimination and restoration: (a) block diagram; (b) waveforms.
11.5.6.4 Envelope elimination and restoration The idea behind envelope elimination and restoration is to use a saturated PA to amplify an RF signal having a time-varying amplitude. The advantage of using a saturated amplifier is that it can be a highly efficient class C, D, E or F one. Figure 11.32a shows the conceptual block diagram of such a solution, and Figure 11.32b shows the main associated waveforms. The power amplifier AMP1 has enough gain so that its output amplitude is constant for any amplitude of the input signal within a specified range. The detector DET1 in combination with the low-pass filter LPF1 produces an output DC voltage proportional to the envelope of the RF input signal or to the square55 of it. That voltage (node 5) is then used as the drain/collector voltage of AMP1 , usually after amplifying it with a high-efficiency, low-frequency amplifier. This way, the PA works always at its maximum power, with a consequent high efficiency. Besides complexity, the main critical point of the architecture in the figure is the unwanted phase modulation associated with the change in PA drain/collector voltage, which adds undesired phase modulation to the output signal. Furthermore, the high gain required to saturate the PA for a wide range of input amplitudes can introduce further phase modulation and overdrive56 phenomena, with a reduction in the output power over the highest range of the input amplitude. 55 56
For a detailed explanation of the detector working, see Section 13.2. See the dashed curve in Figure 11.16.
480
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING 1
Vpeak cos(ω 0 t+φ1)
φ1
√2 Vpeak A(t) cos[ ω 0t + θ(t)] 1 2
IN
φ2
Vpeak cos( ω 0t+φ2 ) 2
A(t) θ(t) ROM1
D/A1
LPF1
ROM2
D/A 2
LPF2
Figure 11.33 LINC block diagram.
11.5.6.5 LINC The acronym LINC stands for linear amplification with nonlinear components; it allows the application of two saturated amplifiers to generate an arbitrarily modulated RF signal. Figure 11.33 shows the principle of such a configuration. The power divider DIVIN distributes the input signal to the phase shifters PH1 and PH2 that feed the two power amplifiers AMP1 and AMP2 . Both AMP1 and AMP2 work in saturation, therefore their output power is constant and independent of the input one. On the contrary, the phase of the two output signals changes according to the respective input phase shift. The Wilkinson divider DIVOUT combines the two amplifiers’ output signals to the output. Assuming that the two amplifiers are equal, and that DIVOUT is ideal, the global output voltage is Vpeak Vpeak vRF ðtÞ ¼ pffiffiffi cos½o0 t þ f1 ðtÞ þ pffiffiffi cos½o0 t þ f2 ðtÞ 2 2
ð11:83Þ
where Vpeak is the output peak voltage of the two amplifiers, o0 is the angular frequency of the RF signal, and j1 ðtÞ; j2 ðtÞ are the phase shifts of PH1 and PH2 , respectively. We can see intuitively that if f1 ðtÞ ¼ f2 ðtÞ, the schematic in Figure 11.33 coincides with a 0
balanced amplifier with a phase shifter at the input: that configuration can only produce phase modulation. Similarly, if f1 ðtÞ ¼ f2 ðtÞ, the resulting output phase is always zero, for symmetry reasons. In this second case, the output amplitude can vary from zero to 2Vpeak , when f1 ðtÞf2 ðtÞ ¼ 2f1 ðtÞ varies from zero to p. More quantitatively, manipulations based on Equations (A.86) to (A.93) allow us to rewrite expression (11.83) as vRF ðtÞ ¼ aðtÞ cos½o0 t þ yðtÞ
ð11:84Þ
with qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi aðtÞ ¼ fcos½f2 ðtÞf1 ðtÞ þ 1g2 þ sin2 ½f2 ðtÞf1 ðtÞ;
yðtÞ ¼ tan
1
sin½f2 ðtÞf1 ðtÞ cos½f2 ðtÞf1 ðtÞ þ 1
AMPLIFIERS
481
Expression (11.84) reveals that the output signal of the arrangement in Figure 11.33 presents both amplitude and phase modulation. Conversely, it is also possible to determine the phase shifts to apply, in order to get the required modulation. Inverting the coefficients of expression (11.84), we have 2 1 A ðtÞ 1 þ yðtÞ; j2 ðtÞ ¼ j1 ðtÞ2 tan1 ftan½yðtÞ þ j1 ðtÞg j1 ðtÞ ¼ cos1 ð11:85Þ 2 2 Thus, from the required amplitude aðtÞ and phase yðtÞ, Equation (11.85) returns the corresponding phase shifts to apply. In principle, Equation (11.85) could be implemented with analogue nonlinear networks that use aðtÞ; yðtÞ as input and j1 ðtÞ; j2 ðtÞ as output quantities to control two continuously variable phase shifters. However, analogue implementation is critical for many reasons: namely, component tolerances, stability over time and temperature, circuit complexity, and so on. Moreover, the phase shifter control law itself is nonlinear.57 For these reasons, Figure 11.33 proposes a digital approach: aðtÞ; yðtÞ are two digital words, and the read-only memories ROM1 and ROM2 numerically implement the relations (11.85). The two digital-to-analogue converters D=A1 and D=A2 transform the respective input digital words into proportional voltages. Finally, the two low-pass filters LPF1 and LPF2 smooth the staircase D/A output voltages, by eliminating its high-frequency components.58 One of the additional advantages of the digital solution, in comparison with the analogue one, is that it can easily implement any complicated function, including the nonlinear control law of the phase shifter. The LINC architecture allows the use of saturated – thus potentially highly efficient – amplifiers to generate arbitrarily modulated RF signals. The main drawback of this solution is that it relies on the phase and amplitude matching between the two paths from the input to the output. This requires that the two amplifiers have the same saturated power and the same transmission coefficient phase, that the two branches of DIVOUT are amplitude and phase matched ðs12 ¼ s13 Þ, and that the two phase shifters present the same phase with the same control voltage. The two branches of DIVIN must be phase matched only: small variations in their output power are cancelled by the saturated amplifiers. Note that all the above requirements apply for all the phase shift combinations, over frequency, temperature and time, and from piece to piece. Phase accuracy is particularly difficult to maintain under the various conditions.
11.5.7
Additional PA issues
This section completes the discussion on PAs, mentioning two additional important points, namely stability and spectral regrowth. Section 11.2.2 has already considered amplifier stability, supplying some important tools like stability circles and the Kurokawa criterion. Both these methods could apply to PAs, at least in principle. In practice, however, PAs are inherently nonlinear; definitions of large-signal scattering parameters are then possible, but neither unique or so meaningful. Consequently, the calculation of stability circles and/or the Kurokawa parameters is difficult and the result is not very meaningful. Moreover, in the highcompression regime the transistor behaves quite differently from its linear model. Some imperfectly designed PAs present instabilities, typically in the form of a tendency to oscillate at frequencies lower than the working range. The elimination of the instability in PAs is a cumbersome task for the designer. Theoretical analyses do not give reliable results, unless very accurate – and maybe specially tailored as well – nonlinear models are available for the transistor. The alternatives to the theoretical approach are long and patient experimental adjustments of the circuit on the test bench. As a general rule, the stabilizing elements are lumped and/or distributed resistors, preferably placed in the input matching network so as not to affect the output power. This criterion is diametrically opposite to the one given in Section 11.3 on LNAs, in that the PA (LNA) optimizes the power transfer from the transistor (generator) to the load (transistor). 57 58
See Section 10.4. See [8] for further details.
482
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Normalized PA spectra, dBm/Hz
20 f1 f0
0
B C
f2
-20 ∆f
2 f1 - f2
-40
2 f2 - f1
-60
-80 0.5
Figure 11.34
1.0 f/f0
1.5
Spectral re-growth in PA output spectrum.
Spectral regrowth is inherent in any nonlinear component when its input spectrum has energy spread over a relatively wide frequency range. Spectral regrowth in PAs is particularly of interest, because its reduction is expensive in terms of efficiency and/or circuit complexity, as we will see shortly. Typical wide-band signals are RF signals modulated with complex schemes, particularly with high-speed digital transmissions, such as WCDMA.59 One other typical case is when the nonlinear component deals with adjacent multiple modulated carriers. Figure 11.34 shows a typical wide-band input (grey) and output (black) spectrum of a PA.60 The useful spectrum occupies the bandwidth Df located across the centre frequency f0. We can consider that spectrum as the superimposition of many tones having frequencies within the range ð f0 D f =2; f0 þ D f =2Þ; Figure 11.34 reveals the components at frequencies f1 and f2. Now each couple of such discrete approximated lines produces intermodulation products at the nonlinear component output. In particular, if the nonlinearity is of third order, the intermodulation products ð2 f1 f2 ; 2 f2 f1 Þ have a frequency close to f0 and fall on the sides of the useful frequency range, disturbing the adjacent channels. The only way to reduce the side emission is to increase the linearity. As we know, linear operation requires that the component works at an output power much lower than its compression point. This implies overdimensioning of the component with associated high DC consumption. The PA is usually the last link in the chain, thus the one handling the highest RF and DC power: any increase in its maximum output power implies large amounts of additional DC power. This consideration justifies a specific discussion of spectral regrowth dealing in PAs, and emphasizes the importance of the techniques discussed in Section 11.5.6. Section 9.5.6 defined the AM–PM conversion referring to generic two-port nonlinear networks. PAs pertain to that class of components and present AM–PM conversion, which could be relevant in the power range around 1dBCP.
11.6 Other amplifier configurations This section deals with amplifier configurations that are different from the classical one of Figure 11.1. Most of the solutions presented are widely used in MMIC and or RFIC technology. 59 60
Wide-band Code Division Multiple Access; it is the modulation scheme used for UMTS. See the Mathcad file 12_Spectral_Regrowth.MCD.
AMPLIFIERS
1
IN
Vgg
Q1
RF
LF
4
L1
Ldd
L gg
5
483
OUT
Vdd
3 2
(a) RF
IN
G
D + v Cgs - in
OUT
gmvin
Q1
(b)
Figure 11.35
11.6.1
Feedback amplifier: (a) principle; (b) simplified small-signal equivalent network.
Feedback amplifiers
Feedback is widely used in low-frequency amplifiers for its associated advantages, like flattening of the frequency response, reduction of distortion, low sensitivity of the amplifier performance to the transistor parameters, and so on. Microwave applications of feedback amplifiers are less common, but still the technique offers some benefits that we will briefly discuss here. Detailed analyses of the various feedback configurations can be found in electronics books;61 for our needs it is sufficient to recall some basic principles. Feedback consists of injecting a portion of the output signal of the amplifier to its input. We get positive or negative feedback if the injected signal produces an output in phase or in phase opposition to the original output signal. Due to the phase relation between the output and injected signal, negative feedback reduces the overall gain and its dependence on the amplifier. On the contrary, positive feedback increases the overall gain, and causes instability if the gain from the input to the injected signal (the loop gain) is unitary. Figure 11.35a shows the principle of a microwave feedback amplifier. It includes the input ðC1 ; C2 ; Lgg Þ and output ðC3 ; C4 ; C5 Ldd Þ bias networks. The usual considerations on the bias networks apply to these elements: all the capacitors (inductors) are open (short) circuits for the direct current and short (open) circuits at RF. Moreover, since the gate absorbs no current from Vgg , in some case it is possible to replace the inductor Lgg with a cheaper high-value resistor. A complete analysis of the circuit in Figure 11.35a is possible, but its results are complicated and probably not very meaningful. However, a simplified approximate equivalent network allows more practical analyses that are valid qualitatively in the real case. The results obtained from the simplified model are the starting point for a computer circuit analysis and optimization of the amplifier. The simplified network in Figure 11.35b is derived from the one in Figure 11.35a by eliminating the bias networks, replacing the transistor with its simplified linear model, and short-circuiting the feedback inductors ðLF ; L1 Þ. 61
The interested reader can find more details about feedback and its effects on amplifiers in [9].
484
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
The amplifier in Figure 11.35b clearly presents feedback, operated by the resistor RF . Moreover, the drain signal voltage is 180 out of phase with respect to that of the gate, hence the feedback is negative. From relatively simple calculations, we obtain the forward transmission and the two reflection coefficients of the network in Figure 11.35b s21 ð joÞ ¼
2R0 ðRF gm 1Þ 2R0 þ RF þ R20 gm
1 R0 ðR0 þ RF Þ 1 þ jo Cgs 2R0 þ RF þ R20 gm
s11 ð joÞ ¼
RF R20 gm joR0 ðR0 þ RF ÞCgs 2R0 þ RF þ R20 gm þ joR0 ðR0 þ RF ÞCgs
s22 ð joÞ ¼
RF R20 gm joR0 ðR0 RF ÞCgs 2R0 þ RF þ R20 gm þ joR0 ðR0 þ RF ÞCgs
ð11:86Þ
where R0 is the reference impedance. The transmission coefficient has the form of a first-order low-pass function, with the low-frequency coefficient s21 ð0Þ ¼
2R0 ðRF gm 1Þ 2R0 þ RF þ R20 gm
js21 ð0Þj monotonically increases with RF and tends to 2R0 gm for RF tending to infinity, which corresponds to applying no feedback. This confirms that the feedback is negative in the amplifier of Figure 11.35b. At very low frequencies, the reflection coefficients (11.86) simplify to s11 ð jo ¼ 0Þ ¼
RF R20 gm ; 2R0 þ R20 gm þ RF
s22 ð jo ¼ 0Þ ¼
RF R20 gm 2R0 þ R20 gm þ RF
ð11:87Þ
From both the equations in (11.87) it follows that the amplifier in Figure 11.35b is perfectly matched at low frequency if RF ¼ R20 gm . Under this condition, the amplifier gain is s21 ð joÞ ¼
1 R0 gm s21 ð0Þ ¼ R0 Cgs 1 þ j o 1 þ jo oT 2
ð11:88Þ
Equation (11.88) describes a low-pass behaviour, with the DC gain s21 ð0Þ ¼ 1R0 gm and the first1 order angular cut-off frequency oT ¼ 2R1 0 Cgs . Therefore, the transistor transconductance has to be sufficient to generate enough gain, and the gate–source capacitance needs to be such that oT is much higher than the required bandwidth. If we consider a 50 O working impedance, and the transistor in Figure 9.32b, we have RF ¼ 100 O; s21 ð0Þ ¼ 1. In other words, the resulting amplifier has unitary gain. In cases like this, it is possible to increase RF in order to increase the gain at the expenses of degradation in the port matching. Note that this assertion is not in contrast with the considerations in Section 11.2, because of the reduction in gain involved with feedback: increasing RF corresponds to reducing the feedback amount. Now we can describe the role of the feedback inductors. LF reduces the feedback at high frequencies by increasing the feedback impedance from the drain to the gate, in order to compensate for the natural roll-off of the transistor. L1, in combination with the transistor output capacitance, provides additional input/output phase shift. This transforms the feedback at high frequencies, from negative to positive, with a further increase in the gain. A properly designed feedback amplifier can exhibit higher gain than a transistor at high frequencies, despite the absence of matching networks. An additional advantage of the configuration in Figure 11.35a is that negative feedback improves the stability. Positive feedback occurs only in the upper frequency range, where the transistor presents the
AMPLIFIERS
485
lowest gain, and therefore is less liable to instability. Consequently, the two-port network in Figure 11.35a usually has better stability – higher K – than its transistor. The configuration in Figure 11.35a is also suitable for realizing wide-band amplifiers,62 with working bandwidths wider than 100% and with a maximum frequency of 18 GHz. Both monolithic and discrete realizations of feedback amplifiers are possible. However, the feedback inductances are typically fractions of nanohenries, thus critical for discrete realizations, particularly at the highest frequencies.63 MMIC technology allows the realization of semi-lumped inductors with almost arbitrarily low values and minimum interconnection-related parasitics. In this sense MMIC is the technology of choice in high-frequency feedback amplifiers.
11.6.2
Distributed amplifiers
The travelling wave amplifier (TWA), also known as the distributed amplifier, was originally developed around 1948 as a wide-band amplifier for the vertical channel of oscilloscopes.64 The original circuit used valve devices (pentodes) and had a maximum frequency of 140 MHz. In the early period of MMIC technology, around 1980, the TWA awakened interest among designers, because of the possibility it offered to realize broad-band amplifiers, with bandwidths from a few hundred megahertz up to 20 GHz or more. The minimum frequency of the TWA is ideally zero, but the bias networks determine its real value. Figure 11.36a shows the small-signal principle of a TWA, without the bias networks. It includes a number N of FETs, which are represented by a simplified linear equivalent circuit consisting of a VCCS with input and output capacitance. Each FET input and output terminal connects to the corresponding terminal of the adjacent FET terminal via two series inductors. Starting from the input, the inductors Lg , together with the capacitors Cgs , form a ladder LC network, comprising N equal cascaded cells, each having the schematic of Figure 11.36b, with L ¼ Lg ; C ¼ Cgs . Such a ladder network is the lumped approximation of a transmission line having the characteristic pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi impedance Zg ¼ 2 Lg =Cgs . If both ends of that line are matched, i.e. Zg ¼ Rg ¼ R0 ¼ 50 O, a forward wave propagates from the amplifier input to the termination Rg . Consequently, the voltages across the gate–source junctions of the N transistors have thepsame amplitude and a progressive delay from the first ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi to the last one: the first transistor has a delay tg ¼ 2Lg Cgs, the second has double that quantity, the third three times, and so on. pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi On the output, we have another lumped line, having characteristic impedance Zd ¼ 2Ld =Cds . The line is matched if Zd ¼ Rd ¼ R0 . In the following considerations, we will denote the two lumped transmission lines as the gate line and drain line. Q1 injects a current proportional to the input incident wave into the drain line. That current propagates through the drain line in both directions, towards the output and the drain termination Rd. The path from the input to Q1 to the drain terminations includes one section of the gate line and one of the drain line; its delay is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð11:89Þ t1;RD ¼ 2Lg Cgs þ 2Ld Cd The path from input to output passing Q1 includes one section of the gate line and N 1 sections of the drain line, with the resulting delay pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð11:90Þ t1;OUT ¼ 2LgCgs þ ðN1Þ 2Ld Cds
62 The Ansoft file 04_Feedback_SSA.adsn provides a simple design of such an amplifier, with a gain of about 6 dB from 2 to 10 GHz. See also [10, 11] for other designs. 63 In the circuit analyzed in the Ansoft file 04_Feedback_SSA.adsn, LF ¼ 1 nH and L1 ¼ 0:47 nH, with a maximum frequency of 10 GHz. Higher maximum frequency involves lower inductance values. 64 See [12, 13].
486
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Ld
Ld
Ld
Ld
Ld
Ld
OUT
Rd G1
D1
Cgs Lg
+ vin -
G2
Cds
Lg
Cgs
Lg
GN
D2 + vin -
g mvin
g mvin
Cds
Cgs
Lg
Lg
DN + vin -
gm vin
Cds
Lg
IN
Rg
(a)
Lg , Ld Lg , Ld 1
2 Cgs, Cds
(b) TLd01
Ldd
Vdd
TLd12
TLd23
TLd34
TLd45
TLd56 OUT
dd2
Rdd
TLd1
TLd2
TLd3
TLd4
TLd5
dd1
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
TLg12
TLg23
TLg34
TLg45
TLg56
IN
Cgg1
TLg01
Rg Rgg
(c)
Vdd
Cgg2
Figure 11.36 TWA: (a) principle; (b) lumped transmission line cell (low pass); (c) complete schematic of a five-transistor distributed amplifier. Considering the contributions of the other transistors, both the delays from the input to the gate and from the drain to the drain terminations increase with the transistor index. For the kth transistor we then have pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð11:91Þ tk;RD ¼ k 2Lg Cgs þ 2Ld Cds while the delay from the input to output is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi tk;OUT ¼ k 2Lg Cgs þ ðN kÞ 2Ld Cds
ð11:92Þ
The gate and the drain line have the same propagation constant if pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2Lg Cgs ¼ 2Ld Cds
ð11:93Þ
The input/output delay is independent of the transistor pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi tk;OUT ¼ N 2Ld Cds ¼ N 2Lg Cgs
AMPLIFIERS
487
In other words, all the transistor current contributions are in phase at the amplifier output. Conversely, the delays to the terminal vary from transistor to transistor, therefore the current sum on the drain termination tends to cancel. Under the condition (11.93), a forward wave from the drain termination to the output corresponds to a forward wave from the input to the gate termination. With the approximations involved in the lumped approximation transmission lines, the TWA gain is js21 j ¼ N
gm R0 2
ð11:94Þ
The gate and drain lines are lumped ladder low-pass networks,65 which present a cut-off frequency fT ¼
1 1 1 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ¼ ¼ 2p 2Lg Cgs 2p R0 Cgs 2p R0 Cds
ð11:95Þ
The ladder networks approximate a transmission line up to fT that also coincides with the maximum working frequency of the amplifier. The schematic in Figure 11.36a implies a direct connection of gates and sources to the inductors of the respective lines. Discrete realizations always present additional series elements between the transistor terminal and the junction between the two inductors: at least a bond wire in hybrid technology, or a bond wire and package lead with package devices. The series-added element degrades the amplifier performance – particularly the maximum frequency – making monolithic realization more convenient. In this regard, Equation (11.95) implies that the TWA’s maximum frequency decreases linearly with the transistor capacitance and thus with the transistor periphery.66 On the other hand, Equation (11.94) states that the gain is directly proportional to the transconductance and then to the transistor periphery. The FET periphery determination is based on the maximum amplifier frequency, by Equation (11.95), while the number of transistors follows from the gain, by Equation (11.94). Thus, many transistors – each with a low individual gain – contribute to the overall gain; this is how the denomination ‘distributed amplifier’ arose. Figure 11.36c shows the complete schematic of a real TWAwith five transistors. The inductors of the gate and drain lines are realized with high-impedance lines, applying the semi-lumped technique. Since Cgs Cds ,67 the distributed capacitance on the drain inductors is higher than on the gate ones, so as to compensate for the difference. Thus, the drain inductors are realized with lower impedance lines than the gate ones. If we consider the complete transistor model – which includes some resistors – and the dissipation loss of the transmission lines, we find that the gain has a negative slope with the frequency. The additional lines TLd1 to TLd5 introduce resonance peaks that compensate for the losses, making the gain flat or even slightly increase with frequency. The drain bias network consists of three capacitors Cdd1 to Cdd3 and one inductor Ldd ; it applies the voltage Vdd to all the drains, without sending DC to the output and to the drain termination. The gate bias network is simpler, consisting of two capacitors Cgg1 , Cgg2 and one resistor Rgg. Such a simplification is possible because there is no current flowing through the gate–source junctions. Again, the same voltage Vgg applies to the gates of all the transistors and is DC isolated from the RF input. The bias networks present a high-pass behaviour and determine the minimum frequency of the TWA, which is zero in principle. Figure 11.37 shows the layout of a monolithic realization of a TWA having the schematic in Figure 11.36c; the die has a size of 2.2 1.7 mm. Note that the components described in Section 14.3 realize all the circuit elements: printed resistors, overlap capacitors, spiral inductors, via hole, etc. The five transistors are four-finger 4 50 mm devices. Many of the transmission lines are folded, to minimize the circuit size. Note also that TLg12 , TLg23 , TLg34 , TLg45 have neither the same length nor double TLg01 and TLg56 , differently from the principle in Figure 11.36a. The reason for the difference comes from 65
More precisely, they are constant-k low-pass filters with T sections, see [14] for more details. The FET periphery is a parameter that quantifies the size of the transistor. See Section 14.3.6 for further details. 67 For instance, in the model of Figure 9.34b, Cgs ¼ 243 fF; Cds ¼ 92 fF. 66
488
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Layout of a 2–18 GHz GaAs MMIC TWA, having the schematic of Figure 11.36c.
Figure 11.37 10
20 log10(|s21 |), dB
8
6
best case nominal
4 worst case measured 2 0
Figure 11.38
2
4
6
8 10 12 Frequency, GHz
14
16
18
20
Simulated (black) and measured (grey) gain of the amplifier in Figure 11.37.
a circuit optimization to flatten the gain over the frequency, taking all the parasitics into account: bends on the lines, couplings between adjacent lines, parasitics associated with the passive components, bias networks and the complete model of the transistor. Figure 11.38 shows the simulated and measured gain of the amplifier in Figure 11.37. The two dashed curves are the minimum and maximum simulated gain when the circuit parameters vary within their tolerance range. Note also that the gain has a slightly positive slope with the frequency, to compensate the loss of the passive68 components of the chain where it is placed. 68 Transmission lines and passive components usually exhibit higher loss at high frequency. See also Chapters 3 and 10.
AMPLIFIERS
11.6.3
489
Differential pairs
In modern high-density assemblies, it frequently happens that amplifiers are placed near potential sources of disturbance, like crystal oscillators. The output frequency of those devices is normally some tens of megahertz. Nonetheless, their harmonic content could still be relevant at microwave frequencies. The injection of such disturbances in the amplifier input can degrade the overall system performance, particularly with high-sensitivity receivers.69 The ports of the amplifier considered so far have one common terminal to ground. Consequently the rejection of disturbances can only rely on the shielding of the amplifier input from the various critical zones of the PCB. Differential amplifiers have a greater immunity to disturbing signals, because their ports are couples of terminals with opposite signal with respect to ground, and, clearly, the output difference is proportional to the input one. Consequently, the output tends to cancel any externally induced EM field, which tends to excite the same disturbing signal on the two input terminals. A typical implementation of the differential amplifier is the differential pair (DP), also known as the emitter-coupled pair. The DP is an important building block in RFICs and this section will examine its amplifier application, although it can also work as an oscillator or mixer.70 We will mainly consider BJT-based circuits, like the one in Figure 11.39. Nonetheless, the general conclusions hold true also for FET implementations, albeit with different formulae. First we will examine the static nonlinear transfer characteristic of the DP, then the high-frequency linear operation. A complete analysis involving nonlinear and high-frequency effects requires computer simulation and suitable models.71 Application of the model in Section 9.7.2.4 (DC) to the analysis of the circuit in Figure 11.39 leads to complicated and not very meaningful expressions. Thus, in order to simplify the calculations reasonably and to obtain understandable results, the model needs the following simplifications: .
Both IKF and VA are infinite.
.
bF 1 so that Ib is negligible in respect of Ic and then Ie ¼ Ic þ Ib ffi Ic .
.
Transistor Q1 is identical to Q2 .
.
1 1. The base–emitter junctions of Q1 and Q2 are forward biased, such that exp Vbe;k n1 F VT
With these assumptions for the transistor Q3 and its associated circuitry, we can write ( " ðQ3Þ # ) " ðQ3Þ # Vbe Vbe ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ 1 ffi Is exp ðQ3Þ I0 ¼ Ie ffi Ic ¼ Is exp ðQ3Þ nF VT nF VT From this, it follows that the base–emitter voltage of the transistor Q3 is " # ðQ3Þ Ic ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ Vbe ffi nF VT ln ðQ3Þ Is ðQ3Þ
The voltage balance in the mesh including Vbe , Vee , Re and the base–emitter junction of Q3 imply that ðQ3Þ
Vbe
ðQ3Þ
¼ Vb
ðQ3Þ
Vee Re3 IeðQ3Þ ffi Vbe
Vee Re IcðQ3Þ
69 Consider, for instance, that the sensitivity of a GSM receiver is about 103 dBm. This means that the minimum signal to the input of the receiver LNA is even lower, due to the loss of the components between the antenna and LNA. 70 See Sections 12.5.6, 12.8.3 and 13.3.9. 71 For static, linear RF and large-signal RF analysis of a DP based on the BJT used in Section 9.7, see the files 25_MBC13900_Differential_Pair.sxsch (SIMetrix), 05_BJT_Differential_Pair.adsn (Ansoft) and 26_MBC13900_ Differential_Pair_Spectrum.sxsch (SIMetrix), respectively.
490
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Vcc plane of symmetry
(Q2)
(Q1)
Rc =R c
Rc =R c
(2)
(2)
Vin(1)
Vout
Q1 Q2
(Q2)
(Q1)
Vout
Rc (1) Vin
(1) Vout
Rc (2)
Vout
Q1
(2)
Vin
Q2
(2)
Vin
I0 (Q3)
Ic Q3
= I0 (Q3)
Vb
(b)
Re (a)
Vee
(Q2)
(Q1)
Rc
(1)
(1) Vin
Vout
Rc (2)
Vout
Q1
(2)
Vin
Q2 I0 /2
I0 /2
(c)
(Q2)
(Q1)
Rc
(1)
(1) Vin
Vout
Rc (2)
Vout
Q1
(2)
Q2
Vin
(d)
Figure 11.39 DP: (a) BJT implementation; (b) linear equivalent circuit of (a); (c) even mode decomposition of (b); (d) odd mode decomposition of (b). Then, combining the two above equations, we have " # ðQ3Þ Ic ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ Re Ic þ nF VT ln ðQ3Þ ffi Vb Vee Is
ð11:96Þ ðQ3Þ
ðQ3Þ
ðQ3Þ
Now, the first term of Equation (11.96) is the voltage drop across Re , while the term nF VT ln½Ic =Is represents the base–emitter voltage of Q3 . The second term has a logarithmic dependence on the collector ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ current of the same transistor, and a convenient design can make nF VT ln½Ic =Is Re Ic . Thus, ðQ3Þ the collector current of Q3 is almost constant and slightly smaller than the value ½Vc Vee =Re , which depends on one resistance and two applied voltages. Therefore, the transistor Q3 and the associated circuitry behave like a current generator, with a current liable to be changed by changing the voltage applied to its base.
AMPLIFIERS
491
This current generator is one of the many possible implementations; the interested reader can find more circuits in [11]. ðQ3Þ One single generator having current Ic can then replace Q3 , Re and the two voltage generators Vee , ðQ3Þ Vb in the circuit in Figure 11.39a. The emitter and collector voltages of Q1 and Q2 are ( " ðQkÞ # ) " ðQkÞ # Vbe Vbe ðQkÞ ðQkÞ ffi Ic ¼ Is exp ðQkÞ Ie 1 ffi Is exp ðQkÞ ðk ¼ 1; 2Þ ð11:97Þ nF VT nF VT The sum of the emitter currents of Q1 and Q2 equals the collector current of Q3 , thus ( " ðQ1Þ # " ðQ2Þ #) Vbe Vbe þ exp ðQ2Þ I0 ¼ Ie;1 þ Ie;2 ¼ Is exp ðQ1Þ nF VT nF VT
ð11:98Þ
The base–emitter voltages of Q1 and Q2 relate to the input voltages as ðQ1Þ
Vbe
ðQ2Þ
Vbe
ð1Þ
ð2Þ
¼ Vin Vin ¼ DVin
ð1Þ ð2Þ The quantity DVin ¼ Vin Vin is the differential input voltage. ðQ1Þ ðQ2Þ ðQ2Þ to (11.98), assuming nF ¼ nF ¼ nF and eliminating Vbe , we
ð11:99Þ
Substituting Equation (11.99) in-
obtain " ðQ1Þ #
V DVin DVin I0 ¼ Is exp be exp þ 1 ¼ IcðQ1Þ exp þ1 nF VT nF VT nF VT ðQ1Þ
A similar relation can be obtained by eliminating Vbe . Rearranging the expressions, we have IcðQ1Þ ¼
I0
; DVin þ1 exp nF VT
ðkÞ
ðkÞ ðkÞ
The output voltages are Vout ¼ Vcc Rc Ic ð1Þ
Vout ¼ Vcc
IcðQ2Þ ¼
I0
DVin þ1 exp nF VT
ðk ¼ 1; 2Þ, thus
Rc I0
; DVin exp þ1 nF VT
ð1Þ
ð2Þ
Vout ¼ Vcc
Rc I0
DVin exp þ1 nF VT
ð11:100Þ
ð2Þ
Then, the differential output voltage DVout ¼ Vout Vout as a function of the differential input is Rc I0 Rc I0
DVin DVin 1 þ exp 1 þ exp nF VT nF VT
1 DVin 1 DVin Rc I0 exp Rc I0 exp 2 nF VT 2 nF VT
¼ 1 DVin 1 DVin 1 DVin 1 DVin exp exp þ exp þ exp 2 nF VT 2 nF VT 2 nF VT 2 nF VT
1 DVin 1 DVin exp exp 2 nF VT 2n V
F T
¼ Rc I0 1 DVin 1 DVin exp þ exp 2 nF VT 2 nF VT
1 DVin ¼ Rc I0 tanh 2 nF VT
DVout ¼
ð11:101Þ
492
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Vcc , Vdd
Vout,2 (BJT)
Rc I0
Vcc - Rc I0
Vout,1 (BJT) ∆Vin
-Rc I0
∆Vout BJT (FET)
A v V in 0.5
-A v = (n F VT )-1 I0 Rc, (2 β I0)
Figure 11.40
Rd
Transfer characteristics of the amplifier in Figure 11.39a.
Figure 11.40 plots the transfer characteristics72 from the differential input to the single-ended outputs (11.100) and to the differential output (11.101). Note that all three curves resemble the function (9.48) plotted in Figure 9.20. The differential input to differential output is specifically interesting for the disturbance rejection associated with it, as mentioned at the beginning of this section. Expanding expression (11.101) as a Maclaurin series, we get DVout ¼
1 Rc I0 1 Rc I0 1 Rc I0 DVin þ DVin3 DVin5 þ . . . 2 nF VT 24 ðnF VT Þ3 240 ðnF VT Þ5
ð11:102Þ
Expression (11.102) reveals that the DP has no even-order distortion,73 like the 180 balanced amplifier. The small-signal voltage gain at low frequency is the first-order coefficient of the above expression, which ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ ðQ3Þ is proportional to the current I0 ¼ Ie ffi Ic that monotonically increases with the voltage Vbe : SSVGDP ¼ lim
DVin ! 0
DVout 1 Rc I0 ¼ 2 nF VT DVin
ðQ3Þ
Thus, Vbe is a control voltage for the amplifier gain; this is an additional interesting feature of the circuit in Figure 11.39a. Truncating the polynomial (11.102) at the third-degree term, and applying Equation (9.51) to it, we approximate the DP 1 dB compression input peak voltage qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðDPÞ V1dB ¼ 4 ð1101=20 ÞnF VT An exact numerical computation74 gives a slightly higher value 1.08 times the value above, corresponding to 0.671 dB.
72 The SIMetrix file 25_MBC13900_Differential_Pair.sxsch provides a DC analysis of the transfer characteristic of a DP having the schematic in Figure 11.39a and employing the bipolar transistor considered in Section 9.7.4.2. 73 See the SIMetrix file 26_MBC13900_Differential_Pair_Spectrum.sxsch. 74 See the Mathcad file 13_Tanh_and_Cubic_1dBCP.MCD.
AMPLIFIERS
493
DPs can also work with FETs, and exhibit similar behaviours than BJT-based ones. The calculation of the FET DP transfer characteristic requires a procedure similar to the one used for deriving Equation (11.101): .
Q1 , Q2 are field effect devices. Source, gate and drain replace emitter, base and collector, ðQ1Þ respectively, and also the corresponding voltages and currents. Two drain resistors Rd ; ðQ2Þ ðQ1Þ ðQ2Þ Rd ¼ Rd replace the collector resistors Rc ; Rc ¼ Rc . Furthermore, we will denote the positive supply voltage by Vee instead of Vcc .
.
Equation (9.74) with a tending to infinity (full pentode operation) and l ¼ 0 (perfectly horizontal DC curves) applies to Q1 and Q2 .
With these assumptions, an FET DP has the differential input to output characteristic rffiffiffiffi
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 8 I0 I0 > 2 > b 2 DV DV < R DV j j > d in in in < b b DVout ¼ r ffiffiffiffi
> jDVin j I0 > > : Rd I0 jDVin j DVin b
ð11:103Þ
A comparison between Equations (9.75) and ((9.80) reveals that a MESFET and MOSFET have the same DC behavior in the pentode region. Thus, Equation (11.103) also applies to MOSFET DPs, after replacing b with b/2. The maximum output swing is Rd I0 and can be as large as Vdd , assuming that Rd I0 ¼ Vdd . Figure 11.40 also plots Equation (11.103) in the case of maximum output swing (thick grey curve). Analytic expansion of the function (11.103) – dueptoffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi its piecewise definition – as a Maclaurin series is pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi only possible within the range I0 =b DVin I0 =b: sffiffiffiffiffiffi sffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi b b b b ð11:104Þ DV 3 þ Rd DV 5 þ . . . DVout ¼ Rd 2bI0 DVin þ Rd 2 2I0 in 16I0 2I0 in From the series (11.104) follows that FET DPs have only odd-order distortion, like a BJT, and this holds pitffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi true also if jDVin j > I0 =b, because of the odd symmetry of the function (11.103): 8DVin 2 R; pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi DVout ðDVin Þ ¼ DVout ðDVin Þ. The first-order coefficient Rd 2bI0 is by definition the small-signal voltage difference gain of an FET DP. It decreases with I0 , as with a BJT, but with a square root – rather than linear – law. Figure 11.39b shows the small-signal network equivalent to the DP in Figure 11.39a. This representation assumes the usual linear simplifications (i), (ii) and one additional simplifying hypothesis (iii): (i) Short (open) circuits replace the DC voltage (current) generators. (ii) The linear model or S parameter sets replace the respective transistor. (iii) The current generator based on transistors Q3 is assumed to be ideal. The application of Bartlett’s theorem to the symmetric network in Figure 11.39b allows a straightforward analysis. With simple manipulations, it is possible to show that any input excitation of the DP is the superimposition of even and odd mode ones 8 ð1Þ ð2Þ ð1Þ > V V V Vin;2 SVin DVin > ð1Þ > ¼ þ < Vin ¼ in þ in þ in 2 2 2 2 2 2 ð2Þ ð1Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ > > ð2Þ Vin V V V SVin DVin > : Vin ¼ þ in þ in in ¼ 2 2 2 2 2 2
494
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING ð1Þ
ð2Þ
ð1Þ
ð2Þ
The quantities SVin ¼ Vin þ Vin ; DVin ¼ Vin Vin are the common and the differential input voltages, respectively. We define the condition with the same voltage simultaneously applied to the ð1Þ ð2Þ two inputs ½Vin ¼ Vin ; DVin ¼ 0 as even, or symmetrical, or common-mode excitation. The opposite ð1Þ ð2Þ case ½Vin ¼ Vin ; SVin ¼ 0 defines the odd, or anti-symmetrical, or differential-mode excitation. The applicability of the effect of superimposition follows from the linearity of the network. Thus the output resulting from any input situation is the sum of the response to even and odd mode excitation. The network in Figure 11.39b presents a plane of symmetry: it then consists of two mirror symmetric halves, each with some nodes intersecting the symmetry plane. For Bartlett’s theorem, in the even (odd) excitation, analyzing the full network is equivalent to separately analyzing the half networks, where the nodes intersecting the symmetry plane are left open (shorted to ground). Thus, in the symmetric and anti-symmetric excitation, the network in Figure 11.39b simplifies to the ones in Figures 11.39c,d, respectively. Figure 11.39c shows that the DP has no common-mode gain, in that the emitter has infinite impedance to ground. On the other hand, in the differential mode, the DP is equivalent to two separated amplifiers, each including one transistor, as Figure 11.39d shows. All the considerations developed in Sections 11.2 and 11.3 therefore remain applicable.
11.6.4
Active loads
The technology of integrated circuits (ICs) usually allows the realization of inductors, but they present low Q factors and occupy large areas of the chip. For instance, the inductor Ldd in Figure 11.37 is considerably larger than a transistor. For this reason, IC designers try to use as few inductors as possible. The need for inductors comes from matching and bias networks. The design techniques to eliminate inductors are combinations of: .
Accepting some interstage mismatch, and avoiding accumulation of the resulting gain ripple, with maxima and minima conveniently located. Normally, the interconnections inside the IC are very short, so the frequency distance between two mismatch gain peaks is relatively high.
.
Using the transistor periphery as a design parameter, in order to minimize the impedance mismatch between the interfacing ports of two adjacent stages.
.
Putting the matching network outside the chip, for instance in the module that includes and encloses the chip.
.
Using resistors instead of inductors in bias networks, wherever this is possible – in practice in gate/base bias.
.
Replacing the drain/collector bias inductor with a current generator, similar to the one in Figure 11.39a. Transistor-based current generators in this application are known as active loads.75
Current generators behave similarly to inductors, presenting high RF impedance and allowing direct current to flow; their application as DC-feed elements in bias networks is attractive in terms of chip area occupation. However, the price to pay for the reduction in size is a reduction in amplifier efficiency by around 50%. The reason for this degradation is because active loads have no reactive energy to accumulate and return to the network, differently from inductors. To see this, it is sufficient to reconsider the network in Figure 11.11 and replace the drain inductor Ldd with a current generator Iq. The latter works if the voltage across its terminals Vq Vds;ce is higher than a specified value, which is zero in the ideal case. This means that the drain/collector voltage can swing from zero to Vq. Thus the load peak voltage is Vq =2, with a peak current of Iq. The resulting maximum RF output power is PDC ¼ Vq Iq =4 (with a load
75
One simple current generator is the current mirror, described in the reference [15].
AMPLIFIERS
495
ZF (CF) I1
I2
I1
V1
V2 = V1AV
I2
V1
AV
V2 = V 1 A V AV
(a) C4
Vdd L4
Q2
C5
P2
L3 C1
P1
Q1
L1
Vg2 C3
Vg1 (b)
C2
Z d1 Cgd
P1
G1 + vin -
(c)
Cgd D1
gm vin
S1
Rds
G2
D1 + vin -
gm vin
P2
Rds
S2
Figure 11.41 Cascode configuration: (a) Miller’s theorem; (b) electrical diagram of two FETs in cascode connection; (c) approximated linear equivalent network of (b). resistance then of 0:5 Vq =Iq ) and the DC power is PDC ¼ Vq Iq . Then the maximum efficiency of a class A PA with active load is 25%, one-half of the solution with the inductor as drain/collector DC feed.
11.6.5
Cascode configuration
Figure 11.41b shows a cascode configuration consisting of one common source/emitter transistor (Q1 ) followed by a common gate/base one (Q2 ). Figure 11.41b also includes the transistor bias networks. Compared with a single transistor, the cascode employing two transistors with the same type as the single one has lower input capacitance (i), higher output resistance (ii) and slightly lower transconductance (iii). Here, we will give some qualitative justifications of these assertions, using a simplified linear FET model. The same considerations apply to the BJT case, with minor modifications. The FET linear model in Figure 9.34b includes three capacitors Cgs ; Cds and Cgd . Cgs and Cds approximately coincide with the input and the output capacitance, respectively, while Cgd contributes to increase both. The validity of this assertion is based on the network equivalence in Figure 11.41a, known as Miller’s theorem.76 The block with the symbol of an amplifier in Figure 11.41a is a linear two-port network presenting a voltage gain AV with given input and output terminations. On the left of Figure 11.41a, the feedback 76
See [16].
496
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
bipole ZF is connected between the input and output of AV . The input generator and the amplifier output deliver the currents V1 V1 V2 V1 ð1 AV ÞV1 þ ¼ þ Zin ZF Zin ZF
1 1 V2 V2 V2 V1 V2 AV I2 ¼ þ ¼ þ ZL ZF ZL ZF I1 ¼
where Zin ; ZL are the input and the termination impedances of the amplifier, respectively (not shown in Figure 11.41a). Therefore, the feedback impedance increases the input and output current with the terms 1 ð1AV ÞZF1 V1 and ð1A1 V ÞZF V2 . Thus, from the input and output current point of view, the presence of the feedback bipole is equivalent to shunting the amplifier input and output with two bipoles, having 1 impedance ð1AV Þ1 ZF and ð1A1 V Þ ZF . In other words, the two networks on the left and right sides of Figure 11.41a are equivalent. Note that the feedback bipole also affects the voltage gain AV if the input generator or the amplifier output impedances are non-zero: the AV value to consider is the one with the actual terminations, including ZF . Applying Miller’s theorem to Cgd in the model of Figure 9.34b, and neglecting the gain modification due to the feedback bipole, we have ZF ¼ ð jo Cgd Þ1 , with the associated increase in input and output capacitance DCin ¼ ð1AV ÞCgd and DCout ¼ ð1A1 V ÞCgd . The exact determination of the voltage gain AV involves the analysis of a complex network; however, some simplifying hypotheses give a qualitative expression. The first transistor in Figure 11.41c uses a simplified version of the model in Figure 9.34b, with only the transconductance, the output resistance, and Cgd . Zd1 representing the output termination of Q1 : in Figure 11.41c it is the input impedance of the common gate Q2 , but we can use a generic value to analyze the single common source stage. In this simplified hypothesis,77 AV ¼ gm Rds jjZd1 , then the approximate FET input and out capacitance are respectively
1 Cin Cds þ ð1 þ gm Rds jjZd1 ÞCgd ; Cout Cds þ 1 þ ð11:105Þ Cgd gm Rds jjZd1 The values in (11.105) depend on the impedance Zd1 of the output termination of the transistor Zd1. As a reference, the low-frequency conjugate matching ðZd1 ¼ Rds Þ and the parameters of the model in Figure 9.34b give Cin 243 þ 299 fF; Cout 92 þ 64 fF. Thus, the Miller capacitance Cgd contributes to the overall input capacitance by about 55%. Equation (11.41) highlights that minimization of Zd1 minimizes the feedback contribution to the input capacitance: this is exactly what the common gate Q2 provides. Further simplifying the second transistor model, and considering its transconductance and output resistance only, its input impedance is Zd1 ¼
Rds þ RL 1 þ gm Rds
where RL is the resistance terminating the drain of Q2 . Again assuming RL ¼ Rds , and from the parameters in Figure 9.32b, Zd1 ffi 45:9. With this drain impedance, the input capacitance of Q1 becomes Cin 243 þ 139 fF, which is about 70% of the standard common source. A relative simple analysis of the network in Figure 11.41c, with all capacitances removed, shows that the DC output impedance of the cascode is Rds ð2 þ gm Rds Þ, which is higher than Rds, as anticipated. Similarly, the equivalent cascode transconductance is ½1ð2 þ gm Rds Þ1 gm . Assuming the model parameters in Figure 9.32b, we have ð2 þ gm Rds Þ1 ffi 0:076; then the transconductance 1 1 The quantity Rds jjZd1 ¼ ðR1 denotes the impedance resulting from the parallel connection of the ds þ Zd1 Þ two bipoles. 77
AMPLIFIERS
497
of the cascode is slightly smaller than that of the single transistor in the common source configuration. The considerations developed so far show the qualitative trend of the cascode configuration. Nevertheless, they give a good design starting point, despite the many approximations with them. Clearly, accurate and reliable predictions require circuit simulation78 and suitable models, as usual. The application of a cascode in amplifiers having the structure in Figure 11.1 could be problematic, due to the difficulty of matching the high cascode output resistance. On the other hand, different amplifier types take advantage of that characteristic. One typical case is the TWA: the output resistances of its transistor cause dissipation loss in the output line, and consequently a drop in the gain at high frequency. Increasing the transistor output resistance means reducing the loss along the drain line, and facilitates the achievement of a flat gain over the frequency. It is implicit from our – albeit approximate – analysis that the connection between the drain of Q1 and the gate of Q2 in the circuit of Figure 11.41b has to be as short as possible. Also, the gate of Q2 needs to see a low RF impedance to ground. Consequently, IC technology is particularly suitable for the cascode.
11.7 Some examples of microwave amplifiers This section presents two practical amplifier realizations with relatively high performances. The first one is a millimetre-wave amplifier, the second is a low-noise amplifier. Both the circuits use as many printed circuit elements as possible, in order to reduce the number of components and consequently the assembly time. Apart from the cost reduction, printed circuit elements are attractive also because they generally offer more constant and predictable performances than their discrete counterparts.
11.7.1
Two-stage millimetre-wave amplifier
The amplifier presented in this section is realized in hybrid microwave integrated circuits (MICs) technology; it uses two identical transistors to realize two cascaded stages. The working frequency bandwidth ranges from 34 to 36 GHz, with a nominal gain of 13 dB. Its design is a compromise among port impedance matching, noise figure and output power. Figures 11.42a,b show the electrical diagram and the layout of the amplifier, respectively. The input matching network of Q1 has the same principle79 as in Figure 6.11, with the coupled line section CL1 working as both a l=4 transformer and DC block. CL1 is a coupled-line section having even and odd mode impedance Z0e ; Z0o respectively, and electrical length80 of about p/2 at the centre frequency of 35 GHz. For the network identity in Figure 4.25b, at 35 GHz, CL1 is equivalent to a single transmission line having a characteristic impedance of Z0 ¼ ðZ0e Z0o Þ=2. The combination of the open stub ST1, resistors R1 to R3, transmission line TL1 and capacitor C1 works as the gate bias network of Q1 and as part of its input matching network. It cancels the input susceptance of Q1 ; then CL1 matches a resistive impedance into 50 O. The capacitor C1 is a short circuit to ground at RF, but allows the DC voltage Vg1 to reach the gate of Q1 . The combined action of C1 and R3 ensures a sufficient decoupling between the DC gate bias port and the RF input port of the amplifier. The 78 See the Ansoft file 06_Cascode.adsn for the analysis of the scattering parameters of a cascode using two transistors having the model in Figure 9.32b. 79 In this case, the gate of Q1 and the amplifier input connect to ports 2 and 1 of the matching network, respectively. The stub cancels the transistor input reactance and the line works as a standard l=4 transformer, placed between the resistive load and the source. 80 For microstrip coupled lines there is no precise definition of the electrical length, because the two modes propagate with different velocity. However, it is possible to use an equivalent propagation velocity equal to the arithmetic or geometric mean between the even and odd mode propagation velocity, if the two values are not too different.
498
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Vdd,1
C2
TL1
R4 Q1
CL2
R1
CL1
C4
TL4
TL2
ST1 IN
Vdd,2
TL3 R3
Vgg,1
TL 8
ST2 TL 5
TL9
TL 6 Q2 R5
OUT
CL3
TL7
R2
R6
R7
Vgg,2
C1
C3
(a)
Carrier
C2 ST1 CL1
Q1
IN
R1 TL3
Vgg,1 R3
Vdd,1 TL4
ST2
C1
Q2
R4 TL5
TL2 CL2 R2
C4
substrate
Vgg,2
R5 TL7 R7
Vdd,2 TL9 TL 8 CL 3
OUT
R6
C3
(b)
Figure 11.42
Millimetre-wave (34–36 GHz) amplifier: (a) electrical diagram; (b) layout.
input bias and matching network include three resistors (R1 to R3 ), which increases the input return loss and improves the stability, but degrades the noise figure. The capacitor C4 shorts one terminal of the transmission line TL9 to ground. Thus, TL9 behaves like an RF short-circuit stub, and also provides a path to the drain of Q2 for its DC voltage Vd2 . The output matching network works similarly to the input one: TL9 and C4 cancel the output reactance of Q2 , and the coupled lines CL3 provide DC isolation and complete the matching, passing from a resistive value to 50 O. The output matching and bias network is the only one without resistors, in order to minimize the loss on the output power, although Q2 is matched for the maximum gain and not for the maximum power. The interstage matching network essentially consists of two cascaded networks of the abovedescribed type. The additional resistor R4 completes the amplifier stabilization. The microstrip elements of the amplifier’s matching networks are realized on three alumina rectangles having h ¼ 254 mm and er ¼ 0.9: Figure 11.42b indicates them with three dashed rectangles. All the resistors are thin-film ones, and the transistors and capacitors are chip devices connected with
AMPLIFIERS
499
16
20 log10(|s21|)
14
12 simulation 10 measurement 8
6 32
Figure 11.43
33
34 35 36 Frequency, GHz
37
38
Simulated (solid) and measured (dashed) gain of the amplifier in Figure 11.39.
gold bond wires. The three alumina rectangles and the chip devices are brazed on one metal carrier that works as a common ground plane and mechanical support as well. The carrier size is about 6 4 mm. Figure 11.43 shows the simulated (thick curve) and the measured (thin curve) SSG of the amplifier. The difference between the two curves is less than 2 dB over all the frequency range 32–38 GHz and becomes less than 1 dB in the specified bandwidth 34–36 GHz. Within this latter range, the measured amplifier exhibits an input and output return loss of better than 10 dB, a noise figure of about 5 dB and saturated output power of about 10 mW (þ 10 dBm).
11.7.2
Low-noise amplifier
Figure 11.44 shows the schematic of an LNA81 working in the frequency range from 10 to 12 GHz. It is realized with surface mount device (SMD) technology on a soft microstrip substrate ðh ¼ 508 mm; er ¼ 3:5Þ with a via hole to ground. The matching/bias networks of this amplifier use basically the same philosophy and the same circuit elements as the ones for the amplifier in Section 11.7.1. Differently from that case, the present LNA includes radial stubs (RS1, RS2) as RF short circuits to ground. Radial stubs behave approximately like open stubs with low characteristic impedance. For our needs it is sufficient to remember that radial stubs present a low impedance to ground over a wider range than conventional l/4 open stubs. Furthermore, the capacitors C1 , C2 (C3 , C4 ) complete the RF decoupling of the input (output) DC bias port from the corresponding RF port. The resistors R1 , R2 stabilize the amplifier by providing a suitable dissipation loss at the transistor input and output. Figure 11.45 shows a photograph of the realized amplifier. Note that Q1 presents a non-negligible series impedance to ground, due to three contributions: the bond wires connecting the chip terminal to the leads inside the transistor package, the non-zero length of the leads and the via hole inductance. Therefore, our circuit exploits the connection parasitics to implement the series source inductance technique discussed in Sections 11.3 and 11.4. Figure 11.46 shows the measured performances of the amplifier. In the nominal range of 10–12 GHz, we have a gain of about 12 dB, an input and output return loss of better than 10 dB, and a noise figure of 81 The amplifier described in this section is the property of RF Microtech. Photograph, descriptions and data are published by permission.
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING R2
TL9
RS2
TL 6 TL1
TL 7
OUT
Q1
TL5 C1
TL3 R1 RS1
C2
Figure 11.44
Figure 11.45
CL2
LNA schematic.
Photograph of the LNA having the schematic in Figure 11.44.
15
s21
10
2.0
10
1.5
0
NF
5
1.0
s11
0
-5 9
Figure 11.46
10
11 12 13 Frequency, GHz
NF, dB
s22 -10
0.5
-20
0.0
-30
20 log10(|s11|), 20 log10 (|s11|)
Vgg
TL4
Vdd C4
TL2
IN CL1
TL10 C3
TL 8
20 log10(|s 21|)
500
14
Measured performances of the LNA in Figure 11.45.
AMPLIFIERS
501
better than 0.85 dB with a minimum of 0.58 dB at 10.6 GHz. Note the effectiveness of the source inductance in optimizing the compromise between noise figure and input return loss.
Bibliography 1. G. Gonzalez, Microwave Transistor Amplifiers Analysis and Design, Prentice Hall, New York, 1984, sections 3.4 to 3.8, pp. 102–125. 2. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Simulation and Design, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007, section 7.2.1, pp. 423–426. 3. J. Rogers and C. Plett, Radio Frequency Integrated Circuit Design, Artech House, Norwood, MA, 2003, Chapter 10, pp. 349–400. 4. N. O. Sokal and A. D. Sokal, ‘Class E: a new class of high efficiency tuned single-ended power amplifiers’, IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits, Vol. SC-10, No. 3, pp. 168–176, 1975. 5. W. H. Doherty, ‘A new high efficiency power amplifier for modulated waves’, Proceedings of the IRE, Vol. 24, No. 9, pp. 1163–182, 1936. 6. R. J. McMorrow, D. M. Upton and P. R. Maloney, ‘The microwave Doherty amplifier’, IEEE MTT Symposium Digest, pp. 1653–1656, 1994. 7. D. R. Cox, ‘Linear amplification with nonlinear components’, IEEE Transactions on Communications, December, pp. 1942–1945, 1974. 8. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Simulation and Design, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007, Chapter 8, pp. 462–484. 9. K. B. Niclas, W. T. Wilser, R. B. Gold and W. R. Hitchens, ‘The matched feedback amplifier: ultrawide-band microwave amplification with GaAs MESFET’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. MTT-28, pp. 285–2945, 1980. 10. A. M. Pavio, S. D. Carter and P. Saunier, ‘A monolithic multi-stage 6-18 GHz feedback amplifier’, IEEE Microwave and Millimeter-Wave Symposium, 1984, pp. 45–48. 11. P. R. Gray, P. J. Hurst, S. H. Lewis and R. G. Meyer, Analysis and Design of Integrated Circuits, John Wiley & Sons Inc, New York, 2001, Chapter 8, pp. 553–622. 12. E. L. Ginzton, W. R. Hewlett, J. H. Jasberg and J. D. Noe, ‘Distributed amplification’, Proceedings of the IRE, August, pp. 956–969, 1948. 13. N. B. Schrock, ‘A new amplifier for milli-microsecond pulses’, The Hewlett-Packard Journal, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 1–4, 1943. 14. G. Bianchi and R. Sorrentino, Electronic Filter Simulation and Design, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007, section 2.3, pp. 57–66. 15. P. R. Gray, P. J. Hurst, S. H. Lewis and R. G. Meyer, Analysis and Design of Integrated Circuits, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 2001, Chapter 4, pp. 253–298. 16. J. M. Miller, ‘Dependence of the input impedance of a three-electrode vacuum tube upon the load in the plate circuit’, Scientific Papers of the Bureau of Standards, Volume 15, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, 1920, pp. 367–385.
Related files Ansoft files 01_Unilateral_and_Bilateral_Matching.adsn. Analyzes the unilateral and bilateral matching of the transistor having the scattering parameters as in Table 9.3. The unilateral device is an ideal twoport network having the same scattering parameters as the bilateral one, except for the backward transmission coefficient, which is zero.
502
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
02_Bilateral_Matching_Layout.adsn. Generates a microstrip layout from the optimized design obtained in file 01. 03_Matching_Networks_1000_to_50_Ohm.adsn. Provides various impedance matching networks for the amplifier in Section 11.5.1. 04_Feedback_SSA.adsn. Analyzes a simplified feedback amplifier, based on the transistor model in Figure 9.32b. 05_BJT_Differential_Pair.adsn. Provides the high-frequency scattering parameters of the amplifier in Figure 11.39a, from the differential input to the differential output. 06_Cascode.adsn. Compares the single FET with the cascode scattering parameters, assuming that the single and the cascode ones are of the same type as the linear model in Figure 9.35a.
Mathcad files 07_Simultaneously_Conjugated_Matching.MCD. Provides some support calculations for amplifier 1. 08_Passive_T_Attenuator.MCD. Synthesizes the resistors of a T attenuator. 09_Class_A_B_C.MCD. Performs numerical computations of most of the parameters discussed in Section 11.5.5. 10_Class_C_F.MCD. Performs numerical computations of most of the parameters discussed in Section 11.5.5. 11_Predistortion.MCD. Analyzes a simple predistortion amplifier linearization, as in Section 11.5.6.1. 12_Spectral_Regrowth.MCD. Computes the spectral regrowth associated with a cubic compressing characteristic. 13_Tanh_and_Cubic_1dBCP.MCD. Computes the 1 dB compression point of cubic and hyperbolic tangent compressing curves.
SIMetrix files 14_MBC13900_LOAD_Line.sxsch. Simulates a quasi-static load line of the amplifier in Figure 11.13a by means of a low-frequency (1 MHz) transient analysis. 15_MBC13900_LOAD_ Line_1GHz.sxsch. Simulates the load curves at 1 GHz of the PA in Figure 11.13a at different output powers. 16_MBC13900_LOAD_Line_1GHz_RL.sxsch. Simulates the load curve at 1 GHz of the PA in Figure 11.13b at different output powers. 17_MBC13900_LOAD_Line_1GHz_DC_Servo.sxsch. Simulates the load curve at 1 GHz of the PA in Figure 11.3d at different output powers. 18_MBC13900_1GHz_PS.sxsch. Simulates the compression curve of the PA in Figure 11.13a. 19_MBC13900_1GHz_RL_PS.sxsch. Simulates the compression curve of the PA in Figure 11.13b. 20_MBC13900_1GHz_RL2_PS.sxsch. Simulates the compression curve of the PA in Figure 11.13c. 21_MBC13900_1GHz_DC_Servo_PS.sxsch. Simulates the compression curve of the PA in Figure 11.13d. 22_MBC13900_1GHz_DC_Servo_Burst.sxsch. Analyzes the RF burst response of the amplifier in Figure 11.13d. 23_Diode_Predistorter_Curve.sxsch. Computes the transfer characteristic of a diode predistorter of the type considered in Section 11.5.6.1. 24_Class_E_GHz.sxsch. Simulates voltage and current waveforms of a quasi-ideal class E amplifier. 25_MBC13900_Differential_Pair.sxsch. Generates the static transfer characteristics of a BJT DP. 26_MBC13900_Differential_Pair_Spectrum.sxsch. Computes the output spectrum of the same DP as in file 24, with a sinusoidal input.
12
Oscillators 12.1 Introduction Oscillators produce the high-frequency signals that the other microwave components process. Therefore, oscillators are probably the most important high-frequency components: without them there is no RF and no microwaves. From the conceptual point of view, oscillators consist of a series or parallel resonant circuit, which is the resonator, and some active circuitry that compensates for the resonator loss. Section 12.2 deals with the general working principles of the oscillators. Sections 12.3 and 12.4 analyze the negative resistance and the positive feedback approaches, respectively. Section 12.4 also shows the equivalence between these two approaches. Section 12.5 considers the most common oscillator configuration, presenting some analytic techniques which are suitable for the simplest cases. Section 12.6 illustrates a trial design in order to clarify the concepts and the implications involved with the previous sections. Section 12.7 illustrates the principal oscillator specifications and their relations with the design parameters. Section 12.8 presents some circuits that are widely used in engineering practice. The description of a real oscillator design, presented in Section 12.9, completes the chapter.
12.2 General principles As anticipated in the introduction, the resonator is one of the two main oscillator elements. Chapter 5 described resonators in depth, while here the word ‘resonator’ denotes a reactive bipole, presenting a zero for the imaginary coefficient of its immittance at a certain frequency f0, known as the resonant frequency of the resonator. We have a series or parallel resonator in the case of a reactance or susceptance zero, respectively. In ideal resonators, not only the imaginary coefficient of the immittance but also its real part are zero at the resonant frequency. The resonator is also known as the resonating circuit, while the parallel resonator is also referred to as the anti-resonant circuit. Also, some authors use the words ‘resonator’ and ‘tank’ interchangeably. Figure 12.1 shows two of the simplest series (a) and parallel (b) resonating circuits: one or the other of these two RLC bipoles can approximate any arbitrarily complex reactive bipole realizing a resonator, in the neighbourhood of its resonant frequency.1 Note also that the network in Figure 12.1a is the dual of the 1
See also Chapter 5 and [1].
Microwave and RF Engineering Roberto Sorrentino and Giovanni Bianchi © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-470-75862-5
504
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Cs
Ls
Rs Lp
Cp
Rp
(a)
(b)
Figure 12.1
Resonating circuit: (a) series; (b) parallel.
one in Figure 12.1b. Thus the equation for the latter also applies to the first, by swapping voltages across with currents through, and, consequently, Cs ; Ls ; Rs with Lp ; Cp ; R1 p , respectively. For this reason, we will derive all the expressions for the anti-resonant circuit; the other case is obtained by duality. The circuit in Figure 12.1b includes no current generator, thus the sum of the currents through the three components Lp ; Cp and Rp is zero. From this, the voltage vðtÞ across the parallel RLC circuit follows the differential equation 1 Lp
ðt vðtÞ dt þ 1
1 dvðtÞ vðtÞ þ Cp ¼0 Rp dt
Differentiating both sides, we have 1 1 dvðtÞ d 2 vðtÞ þ Cp vðtÞ þ ¼0 Lp Rp dt dt2
ð12:1Þ
Equation (12.1) is a homogeneous linear second-order differential equation, its general solution being a linear combination of particular ones of the type eat . The substitution vðtÞ ¼ eat into Equation (12.1) gives 1 at a at e þ e þ a2 Cp eat ¼ 0 Lp Rp
ð12:2Þ
The function eat is always non-zero, therefore Equation (12.2) implies that 1 a þ þ a2 Cp ¼ 0 Lp Rp Thus, we have an ordinary second-degree equation in the variable a, which has the solutions s ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 1 1 1 ð12:3Þ a¼ 2Rp Cp 2Rp Cp Lp Cp The general solution of Equation (12.1) is a linear combination of two functions of the type eat , where a is given by Equation (12.3), and assumes the form vðtÞ ¼ v1 expða1 tÞ þ v2 expða2 tÞ
ð12:4Þ
As anticipated, a1 ; a2 are the two values obtained from expression (12.3) considering the signs ‘ þ ’ and ‘’, respectively. Note that the function (12.4) is the solution of Equation (12.2) in all the cases, with the exception of a1 ¼ a2 , which occurs when Lp ¼ 4R3p Cp . However, we will ignore this single exception, in that it is not interesting for our considerations, as we will see shortly. The determination of the coefficients v1 ; v2 follows from the initial conditions on the function and its derivative with respect to time. If they are both zero, i.e. vðt ¼ 0Þ ¼ dvðtÞ=dtjt¼0 ¼ 0, the function (12.4) degenerates into vðtÞ ¼ 0. In all the other cases, we have a non-trivial evolution over time. The simplest
OSCILLATORS initial condition to consider consists of assuming a non-zero initial voltage dvðtÞ ¼0 vðtÞjt¼0 ¼ v0 ; dt t¼0
505
ð12:5Þ
Imposing the condition (12.5) on Equation (12.4) gives 8 vðt ¼ 0Þ ¼ v1 þ v2 ¼ v0 > < > dvðtÞ ¼ a1 v1 expða1 tÞ þ a2 v2 expða2 tÞj ¼ a1 v1 þ a2 v2 ¼ 0 : t¼0 dt t¼0 The above two equations form a non-homogeneous linear system with the two unknowns v1 ; v2 , and their solution is v1 ¼
a2 v0 ; a2 a1
v2 ¼
a1 v0 a1 a2
Finally, substituting the above coefficients into Equation (12.4), and rearranging the result, we get the solution t ð12:6Þ vðtÞ ¼ A exp sinðO t þ fÞ t where V0 A ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ; L 1 4CppR2 p
t ¼ 2Cp Rp ;
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 1 O¼ ; Lp Cp ð2Cp Rp Þ2
1
j ¼ tan
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi! 4Cp R2p 1 Lp
Let us define the (angular) resonant frequency o0 ¼ 2pf0 and the quality factor Q, sffiffiffiffiffiffi Cp 1 o0 ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ; Q ¼ Rp Lp Lp Cp
ð12:7Þ
Note that the resonant frequency (12.7) coincides with the susceptance zero of the circuit in Figure 12.1a, as expected. Moreover, the quality factor Q is the ratio between the susceptance of one of the reactive elements o0 Cp ¼ ðo0 Lp Þ1 and the conductance at the resonant frequency.2 The parameters of Equation (12.6) can be rewritten in terms of the resonant frequency and quality factor as pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 4Q2 1 2Q 2Q ð12:8Þ 4Q2 1 A ¼ v0 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ; t ¼ ; O¼ o0 ; f ¼ tan1 o0 2Q 4Q2 1 Assuming non-zero initial conditions different from (12.5), the resonator voltage over time always assumes the form (12.6), but with different values of A and f. The same applies to the response of the antiresonant circuit to a current step applied to its terminals. Similar results also arise from any finite and time-limited excitation. If jQj > 0:5 – lower values are of no interest in this context – then radian frequency O is a real number, and the function (12.6) describes oscillations having an exponential envelope with the time constant t. The first three plots of Figure 12.2 – a, b and c – show the three important cases of vðtÞ, when Q > 0:5; Q < 0:5; Q ¼ 1. In these plots, the function (12.7) is a thick solid curve, while the thin dashed lines show the envelope A expðt=tÞ. Strictly speaking, the waveforms in Figure 12.2 are not periodic, in that their peak amplitude varies over time, with the exception of the case in Figure 12.2a (Q ¼ 1). 2
See also Section 5.3.
506
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING Q=∞ 0
t
(a) Q<0
0
t
(b)
Q > 0.5
0
t
(c) amplitude-depending Q 0
t
(d)
Figure 12.2 Switch-on transients of a resonant circuit: (a) infinite Q (no resistance); (b) negative Q; (c) positive Q; (d) amplitude-depending Q.
All physical resonators present finite and positive Q. The case of infinite quality factor denotes the ideal resonator, consisting of purely reactive elements ðRp ¼ 1Þ. Clearly, ideal resonators and purely reactive elements as well are not realizable. If, absurdly, they were, they would still be of no practical use, because any attempt to couple them externally causes energy transfer from inside to outside the resonator. In other words, any load somehow applied to the resonator introduces a parallel resistance, Q becomes finite and the oscillation amplitude decays over time. Oscillation negative-Q resonators increase their amplitude over time. This implies that the resonator energy also increases over time, and thus that energy feeds to the resonator externally. In other words, a resonator with negative quality factor has to include active elements. Thus, negative-Q resonators produce increasing amplitude oscillations starting from any non-zero initial condition or from finite excitations. This mechanism realizes oscillator startup, and the initial resonator stimulus could be a switch-on transient of the oscillator, or even the circuit noise. Oscillators, however, have to produce waveforms with amplitude and frequency ideally constant over time. None of the conditions considered so far give satisfactorily working oscillators. Finite-Q resonators do not behave as oscillators: positive and negative ones exhibit exponentially decaying and increasing oscillation amplitude over time, respectively. In the first case the oscillation is simply extinguished; the second case involves arbitrarily high voltages, and is then not realizable. On the other hand, a loss-free resonator is still not adequate, despite its theoretically constant amplitude, because any perturbation applied to the resonator (variations in the load, noise, disturbances) can cause amplitude variations, and the circuit is incapable of restoring the initial condition.
OSCILLATORS
507
Id (1) (2)
∆ Id
(3)
Lb
(4)
Cb
+ Vb
Vd
t
Id
+ Vd
(2)
R NEG
Lp
Cp
Rp
-
(1)
(1) (4)
Vd
(a)
(b)
Figure 12.3
∆Vd
Oscillator with negative resistance element: (a) schematic; (b) voltages and currents.
Therefore oscillators require a combination of Q < 0:5; Q > 0:5 and Q ¼ 1 for small, large and steady state amplitudes. Moreover, Q1 has to decrease monotonically with oscillation amplitude, in order to stabilize the oscillation amplitude. This way, the negative Q increases the oscillation amplitude from an initial non-zero arbitrarily small perturbation. As the amplitude increases, any further increase becomes progressively more difficult. At a given amplitude vosc , Q becomes infinite, causing the amplitude neither to increase nor decrease; vosc is then the equilibrium point of the system. As the oscillation amplitude – for any external or internal perturbation – increases above (respectively, decreases below) vosc , then Q becomes positive (negative), compensating the effect of the perturbation. Figure 12.2 – plot d – shows a typical oscillator startup waveform. Initially the amplitude increases exponentially, as with negative Q. Consequently, Q becomes less negative, making the amplitude increment less evident. Finally, the oscillation amplitude stabilizes and Q becomes infinite. At this point, for any increment (decrement) of the output amplitude, Q assumes finite positive (negative) values, opposing the variation and stabilizing the amplitude. We define the initial part of the oscillator switch-on transient, when it works as a negative-Q resonator, as the startup. The time when the oscillation reaches and keeps constant amplitude is the steady state. Figure 12.3a shows the principle of a circuit implementing the mechanism described above. That oscillator comprises the anti-resonant circuit Lp ; Cp ; Rp and the active device RNEG with its associated bias elements Vb ; Lb ; Cb , which produces the amplitude-dependent negative resistance. In our simple schematization, the resistor Rp represents the loss in the resonator and the effect of any load coupled to it; Lb ðCb Þ presents very high (low) impedance at the oscillation frequency.3 In addition, we will assume that RNEG presents no parallel susceptance. This involves no loss of generality, in that any non-zero parallel susceptance can be considered as included in the resonator, by modifying some of the values Lp ; Cp ; Rp . Figure 12.3b shows the Id –Vd characteristic of the device RNEG , one portion of the curve presenting a negative slope that corresponds to an incremental negative resistance. For the same reasons as considered in Section 11.5.1, the voltage Vd can swing from Vb down to zero and up to a positive value Vmax , which depends on Rp . If Vmax 2Vp then the voltage across RNEG is a sinusoid with both mean and peak values equal to Id –Vd. We will not describe the internal structure of the
3
Similar to the components Ldd and Cdd in Figures 11.11 and 11.13.
508
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
active device; however, the characteristic in Figure 12.3b resembles that of a tunnel, Gunn or IMPATT diode.4 Figure 12.3b also shows four different possible sinusoidal voltages across RNEG , having increasing amplitude, and labelled (1) to (4). The negative conductance DId =DVd monotonically increases with the oscillation peak-to-peak amplitude DVd : it is negative for (1) and (2), zero for (3) and positive for (4). Consequently, the resonator sees the active devices as conductance that is negative for small DVd , decreases with DVd and becomes positive for DVd > DVdð3Þ. The current in the active device has a nonlinear dependence on the voltage. Nonetheless, it is still possible to use the parameter DId =DVd as a large-signal conductance, in order to develop some qualitative considerations.5 Thus, the resulting resonator parallel resistance is approximately 1 R1 eq ¼ ðRp þ DId DVd Þ. If Req is negative for small values of DVd , then the circuit in Figure 12.3a satisfies one of the conditions required to operate as an oscillator: the small-amplitude Q is negative. Then oscillations with angular frequency O will arise from any non-zero initial condition and exponentially increase their amplitude. As DVd approaches DVd;g ; R1 eq vanishes, and the resonator Q becomes infinite, stabilizing the oscillation amplitude6 at a value close to DVd;g : any variation of DVd above or below that value is contrasted by the Q variations associated with the function Id ðVd Þ. In the steady state condition Q tends to infinity, thus the oscillation frequency O coincides with o0 ¼ ðLp Cp Þ1 . If the active device characteristic is such that DId =DVd < R1 p , even for small DVd , then stable oscillations cannot take place. Nevertheless, it is still possible to circumvent the obstacle, by inserting a transformer between Cb and the resonator, in order to increase the negative conductance seen by the resonant circuit.7 Therefore an active device having the characteristic of the form in Figure 12.3b is suitable for working as a negative resistance in an oscillator employing a parallel resonating circuit. For duality reasons, series resonating circuits require a negative resistance – rather than a negative conductance – decreasing with oscillation amplitude.
12.3 Negative resistance oscillators This section shows that a negative conductance device in parallel with an anti-resonant circuit restores the energy lost at each cycle due to the loss internal to the resonator and to the energy transfer to the load. Moreover, we have seen that a negative conductance that decreases with the oscillation amplitude stabilizes the amplitude itself. By duality, the same considerations apply to a negative resistance in series with a series resonant circuit. The present section analyzes the more general case of both resonator and active device presenting complex impedance, deriving the conditions for the oscillations in a more formal way.8 Figure 12.4a shows the principle of a negative resistance oscillator. The resistor RL is the load, which is somehow coupled to the resonator. The two-port includes the resonator and its coupling/matching networks to load and the active circuit, and is placed between those elements. Any non-zero series reactance of the load is considered as part of its coupling network to the resonator. The active circuit has complex admittance with negative real part. The two-port network also includes the bias elements for the active device, which are not explicitly represented in Figure 12.4a. Figure 12.4b shows the equivalent circuit of the schematic in Figure 12.4a. The bipole YðoÞ is the complex admittance presented from the resonator to the active circuit. The current generator cðtÞ provides 4 The SIMetrix file 07_Negative_R_I_V_Curve.sxsch provides a macroscopic model of an Id ðVd Þ characteristic of the type plotted in Figure 12.3b. 5 Section 12.4 provides more rigorous analyses. 6 See the SIMetrix file 09_Negative_R_Oscillator.sxsch, which provides a switch-on transient analysis of an oscillator having the configuration in Figure 12.3a. 7 Equivalently, we can also say that the transformer decreases the conductance seen by RNEG. 8 See also [2].
OSCILLATORS
509
Y(ω)
resonant circuit with matching and coupling networks
RL load
active circuit -G + jB
(a) + i(t) c(t) (b)
Figure 12.4
Y(ω)
v(t)
I(t)
Y′ = -G′ + jB′
-
Negative resistance oscillator: (a) principle; (b) equivalent network.
the initial stimulus that triggers the oscillations: we will use it to describe the network voltages and currents, assuming no steady state impressed current. If the network in Figure 12.4b produces periodic oscillations with constant amplitude, as required for an oscillator, then the voltage across the active device and the linear bipole is vðtÞ ¼ A cosðot þ jÞ ¼ RefA exp½ jðot þ jÞg ¼ RefVg
ð12:9Þ
where j represents slow fluctuations of the phase over time. The active device current is IðtÞ ¼ G0 A cosðot þ fÞB0 A sinðot þ fÞ ¼ RefY 0 Vg
ð12:10Þ
Computation of the resonator current requires the calculation of the derivative of the function (12.9) with respect to time dvðtÞ dA d½cosðot þ fÞ dA dðot þ fÞ ¼ cosðot þ fÞ þ A ¼ cosðot þ fÞA sinðot þ fÞ dt dt dt dt dt dA df ¼ cosðot þ fÞA sinðot þ fÞ o þ dt dt dA df Re exp½ jðot þ fÞg þ A o þ ¼ Re j exp½ jðot þ fÞg dt dt The quantities A; o; f; t are real, and given two arbitrary complex numbers z1 ; z2 , then Reðz1 Þ þ Reðz2 Þ ¼ Reðz1 þ z2 Þ, hence dvðtÞ dA df ¼ Re exp½ jðot þ fÞ þ Re jA o þ exp½ jðot þ fÞ dt dt dt dA df exp½ jðot þ fÞ þ jA o þ ¼ Re exp½ jðot þ fÞ dt dt df 1 dA ¼ Re j o þ þ A exp½ jðot þ fÞ dt A dt Now, differentiation over time in the time domain corresponds to multiplication by the factor jo in the frequency domain. Thus, we can consider the factor
510
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING dj 1 dA oþ þ dt jA dt
as a generalization of the angular frequency that takes into account the amplitude and phase fluctuations. The generalized angular frequency coincides with o in the case of zero fluctuations. Application of the generalized angular frequency to YðoÞ consists of operating the substitution dj 1 dA j oþ þ ! jo dt A dt The first-order Taylor series of the resonator admittance is " # df j dA dYðoÞ df j dA df j dA 2 ¼ YðoÞ þ þo Y oþ dt A dt do dt A dt dt A dt where oðxÞ denotes an infinitesimal term9 of higher order than x. Assuming slow amplitude and phase fluctuations, i.e. dj 1 dA ; o dt A dt then the Taylor series gives a good approximation of the resonator admittance:
df j dA dGðoÞ df 1 dA dGðoÞ 1 dA dBðoÞ df ffi GðoÞ þ þ BðoÞ þ j BðoÞ þ Y oþ dt A dt do dt A dt do A dt do dt Thus, the resonator current is iðtÞ ¼ RefY Vg
dGðoÞ df dBðoÞ 1 dA ¼ GðoÞ þ þ A cosðot þ fÞ do dt do A dt
dGðoÞ 1 dA dBðoÞ df þ A sinðot þ fÞ BðoÞ do A dt do dt
ð12:11Þ
The impressed current cðtÞ is the sum of the resonator and active circuit current cðtÞ ¼ IðtÞ þ iðtÞ ¼ RefðG0 þ jB0 ÞVg þ RefY Vg Expanding the expression for cðtÞ, we have
dGðoÞ df dBðoÞ 1 dA þ A cosðot þ fÞ cðtÞ ¼ GðoÞG0 þ do dt do A dt
dGðoÞ 1 dA dBðoÞ df þ A sinðot þ fÞ BðoÞ þ B0 do A dt do dt
ð12:12Þ
Multiplying both terms of Equation (12.12) once by cosðo t þ jÞ, once by sinðo t þ jÞ and integrating the results over one oscillation period T0 ¼ 2p=o0 , we obtain 8
ðt > > dGðoÞ df dBðoÞ 1 dA T0 > 0 > > cðtÞcosðot þ fÞ dt ¼ GðoÞG þ þ A > > do dt do A dt 2 < tT0 ð12:13Þ t
ð > > dGðoÞ 1 dA dBðoÞ df T0 > 0 > > cðtÞsinðot þ fÞ dt ¼ BðoÞB þ A > > do A dt do dt 2 : tT0
9
Equivalently, limx ! 0 ½oðxÞ=x ¼ 0.
OSCILLATORS
511
where we have assumed that both j and A need a much longer time than T0 to produce relevant fluctuations: j and A behave approximately like constants, during the integration time. The two equations in (12.13) constitute one linear non-homogeneous system with two unknowns, ð1=AÞdq=dt; dj=dt, that can be found by solving the system. For our needs, it is sufficient to solve the system (12.13) in a situation close to steady state, rather than in the general case. In that condition the two integrals in the first terms of system (12.13) vanish, because the oscillation period is close to T0 and c(t) is zero as well. Then, the solution of the system is 8 dYðoÞ2 1 dA dBðoÞ > dGðoÞ > > ½GðoÞ þ G0 þ ½BðoÞ þ B0 ¼ < do A dt do do ð12:14Þ 2 > > > dYðoÞ df ¼ dGðoÞ ½GðoÞ þ G0 dGðoÞ ½BðoÞ þ B0 : do dt do do Equations (12.14) determine the conditions for the presence of stable oscillations together with their amplitude and frequency. In the true steady state, there are neither amplitude nor phase fluctuations, and the impressed current is zero. Then df 1 dA ¼ ¼ dt A dt
ðt
ðt cðtÞcosðot þ fÞ dt ¼ tT0
cðtÞsinðot þ fÞ dt ¼ 0 tT0
Under these conditions, Equations (12.14) simplify to GðoÞG0 ¼ 0 BðoÞ þ B0 ¼ 0
ð12:15Þ
Equations (12.15) express the conditions for free steady state oscillations, and determine the respective amplitude A0 and angular frequency o0. If the amplitude A has a small deviation dA from its steady state value A0 , it affects the active circuit admittance, but not that of the resonator, which is linear by definition. Then the quantities of Equations (12.15) become 8 @G0 @G0 > > dA ¼ dA < Gðo0 ÞG0 ðA0 þ dAÞ ¼ Gðo0 ÞG0 ðA0 Þ @A @A ð12:16Þ 0 0 > > : Bðo0 Þ þ B0 ðA0 þ dAÞ ¼ Bðo0 Þ þ B0 ðA0 Þ þ @B dA ¼ @B dA @A @A where the partial derivatives in the terms of Equations (12.16) are evaluated at the point A ¼ A0 . Substituting the quantities (12.15) into the first equation of (12.14), and considering that A ¼ A0 þ dA and A0 is constant, thus dA=dt ¼ dðdAÞ=dt, we obtain a differential equation for dA
dYðoÞ2 1 dðdAÞ dBðoÞ @G0 dGðoÞ @G0 dA þ ¼0 do @A do @A do A dt
ð12:17Þ
The stability of the oscillation amplitude implies that dA decays over time, and this is possible if and only if
@G0 dBðoÞ @B0 dGðoÞ > 0 @A do @A do
ð12:18Þ
Equations (12.15) and (12.18) give the conditions to be satisfied in the design of a negative resistance oscillator. They generalize and formalize the concepts discussed in Section 12.2. The condition (12.15) has a clear interpretation: in the steady state the resonator admittance has to be equal and opposite to that of the active element.
512
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
If the active element has no susceptance, we can see that conditions (12.15) and (12.18) coincide with the corresponding ones of Section 12.2: .
The second equation in (12.15) simplifies to BðoÞ ¼ 0, which means that the resonator has zero susceptance at the oscillation frequency. Thus the resonator behaves like an anti-resonant circuit, and its resonant frequency coincides with the oscillation one.
.
Anti-resonant circuits present negative (positive) susceptance below (above) their resonance, thus in the neighbourhood of o0 this is dBðoÞ=do > 0. From this condition and from Equation (12.18) it follows that @G0 =@A < 0. Thus, the negative conductance absolute value must decrease with the oscillation amplitude.
.
The first equation in (12.15) gives BðoÞ þ B0 ¼ 0. This means that in the regime condition the active circuit exactly compensates the resonator loss, or that the Q resulting from the combination of the two bipoles is infinite.
.
From the last two points, it follows that the negative conductance amplitude is higher than, equal to or lower than the resonator conductance at oscillation amplitudes lower than, equal to or higher than the stable value A0 , respectively. This way, the active circuit tends to correct any positive or negative deviation of A from A0 .
All the considerations and equations of this section also apply to a series resonator, just by swapping the electrical quantities and the respective dual ones: current with voltage, admittance with impedance, susceptance with reactance, conductance with resistance, series with parallel, and vice versa.
12.4 Positive feedback oscillators Positive feedback is a method – alternative to the negative resistance – for oscillator analysis and design. The main difference between the two design methods consists of their applicability: the most convenient one depends on the specific circuit, models and CAE program. However, despite their different points of view, the two methods give identical results when both are applicable. This section presents the basic principle of positive feedback, using the intuitive approach as in Section 12.2, showing the equivalence of the two methods. Figure 12.5 shows the block diagram of a feedback system, without specifying the quantities at the input and output of its various blocks: they could be voltages, currents or convenient linear combinations of them. The diagram in Figure 12.5 includes three blocks: one adder, one amplifier and one selective network. The amplifier gain av ðoÞ is the forward gain of the loop, while bðoÞ is the feedback gain. The adder
a v(ω) IN
OUT
u
β(ω)
Figure 12.5
Block diagram of a feedback system.
OSCILLATORS
513
output is the sum of its two inputs, the amplifier gain is frequency dependent in the general case, and the selective network presents a gain peak in a narrow band, as its symbol suggests. Under proper conditions the arrangement in Figure 12.5 works as an oscillator, and the quantity applied to the node IN plays the same role as the excitation current in the diagram of Figure 12.4b. From an intuitive point of view, we can consider that the feedback introduces a portion of the amplified input signal back to the system input. The path from IN to the injection point u presents a gain equal to the product of the forward gain and the feedback gain GL ðoÞ ¼ av ðoÞbðoÞ
ð12:19Þ
The quantity (12.19) is the loop gain of the block, and is the gain from the node IN to node u when the mesh is cut at the point marked with a cross. Each time the signal loops, the adder output increases by a quantity that increases with the open-loop gain: this process is known as regeneration. If one frequency o0 exists such that arg½GL ðo0 Þ ¼ 0, three cases are possible that correspond to the three conditions of Section 12.2 on the quality factor: 1. jGL ðo0 Þj < 1: the output signal consists of damped oscillations having exponentially decaying amplitude over time. This case corresponds to 0:5 < Q < 1. 2. jGL ðo0 Þj ¼ 1: in this case the output signal consists of constant-amplitude oscillations, and corresponds to Q ¼ 1. 3. jGL ðo0 Þj > 1: all the regenerative contributions are in phase and present increasing amplitude over time. Thus, the oscillator produces oscillations at a frequency close to o0 and with exponentially diverging amplitude, no matter how small the initial input signal, as for 1 < Q < 0:5. In more quantitative terms, the application of Mason’s rule to the diagram in Figure 12.5 gives the closed-loop gain OUT av ðoÞ av ðoÞ ¼ ¼ GCL ðoÞ ¼ IN 1av ðoÞbðjoÞ 1GL ðoÞ
ð12:20Þ
If GL ðo0 Þ ¼ 1, then the function (12.20) becomes infinite. This is equivalent to saying that a non-zero signal at the angular frequency o0 is present at the output even with zero input signal. Therefore the loop gain of the diagram in Figure 12.5 must be unitary (higher than 1), in order to fulfil the condition for stable oscillations (startup). From this two relations follow: jGL ðo0 Þj 1;
arg½GL ðo0 Þ ¼ 0
ð12:21Þ
Conditions (12.21) are equivalent to 20 log10 ½jGL ðo0 Þj 0;
arg½GL ðo0 Þ ¼ 0
ð12:22Þ
Conditions (12.21) with the equals sign, obtained for the positive feedback oscillator, correspond to the ones in (12.15), derived for the negative resistance oscillator. Usually the feedback network is passive and linear, and so it is for its transfer function bðoÞ. Consequently, the first condition in (12.21) requires the amplifier gain to decrease with the output amplitude. Usually amplifiers naturally satisfy such a condition, as discussed in Chapter 11. The intuitive concepts above correspond to the Nyquist stability criterion, which we can shortly describe as follows. First, a system is stable in the strict sense if its response to any time- and amplitudelimited excitation tends to zero, within a finite time. An oscillator is an unstable system by definition.
514
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
Then, it is required to extend the function (12.20) from the purely imaginary variable jo to the complex variable10 s ¼ s þ jo. Circuit theory states that the network function of a lumped element network is a rational function of the variable s, with real coefficients. Furthermore, if the network includes distributed elements, they can be approximated by finite numbers of lumped elements, at least in the frequency band of interest. Now, the closed- and open-loop gains are network functions, hence they are real rational functions of the variable s, either approximately or exactly, depending on whether the network includes distributed elements or not. The poles of GCL ðsÞ determine the stability of the system, and coincide with the zeros of 1GL ðsÞ, unless some of them cancel with the zeros of aðsÞ, which is unlikely. System theory tells us that the system is unstable if the poles of its transfer functions fall in the right half plane of the variable s, or, equivalently, if their real part is positive. Assuming that GCL ðsÞ has no positive real part poles, as it does normally, the Nyquist criterion states that the system is unstable if its loop gain, evaluated on the whole imaginary axis 1 < o < 1, describes a curve encircling the critical point 1 þ j0. The Nyquist plot is a Cartesian diagram that plots the imaginary coefficient of the loop gain versus its real part, equivalently. It can also be seen as a polar representation of the loop gain, as we can see in Figure 12.13, which is the Nyquist diagram of the oscillator presented in Section 12.6. The real nature of the transfer function coefficients implies that GL ðoÞ ¼ conj½GL ðoÞ, and thus the Nyquist diagram is symmetrical in respect of the real axis, as Figure 12.13 also shows. Now, if the loop gain encircles the critical point, this means that the function GL ðoÞ crosses the real axis to the right of the critical point. This also means that a frequency o0 exists such that the loop gain fulfils conditions (12.21). As a final remark on the Nyquist criterion, note that it is normally used to check the stability of feedback systems; on the contrary, in the oscillator context, it is used to make sure that the system is unstable. Moreover, feedback is usually negative in feedback systems. Thus the block diagram considered in the system theory has a 180 phase inversion in the direct path: this corresponds to considering bðoÞ instead of bðoÞ, while the critical point becomes 1 þ j0. Sometimes, Equations (12.21) or (12.22) are also referred to as the Barkhausen oscillation criterion. Figure 12.6a shows a simple feedback oscillator. The input voltage generator VIN represents the initial condition of the circuit, and is used for intermediate calculations, but does not physically exist. The transfer function from the input to the output voltage is VOUT ¼ VIN
a0 RP
1 Ra0F
1 joLp
þ
1 joLp
1 Rp
þ
þ 1 Rp
1 RF
þ
þ joCp
1 RF
1
þ joCp
1
ð12:23Þ
The function (12.23) has the same structure as the function (12.18), the forward gain and the open-loop gain being av ðoÞ ¼
a0 RP
1 1 1 þ þ þ joCp joLp Rp Rp
1
;
GL ðoÞ ¼
a0 RF
1 1 1 þ þ þ joCp joLp Rp Rp
1
Figures 12.6b,c clarify the physical meaning of the above parameters: .
av ðoÞ is the voltage gain from VIN to VOUT when the loop is open by cutting the mesh m1 and connecting the right terminal of the feedback resistor RF to ground. Note that this connection makes the resistor left terminal equal to zero, as required to disable the feedback.
10 Such a complex variable is sometimes referred to as the Laplace variable, from the well-known eponymous transformation.
OSCILLATORS
515
RF
a0
Rp +
Lp
VOUT
Cp
VIN (a)
RF
a0
Rp +
Lp
VOUT
Cp
VIN (b)
RF V1 Lp
Rp
a0
Cp
VOUT
(c)
RF
Lp
Rp
a0
Cp
VOUT
(d)
(e)
Figure 12.6 Basic oscillator: (a) principle; (b) loop forward gain; (c) open-loop gain; (d) negative resistance analysis; (e) SFG corresponding to (d).
.
GL(o) is the loop gain as obtained by cutting the mesh m1 and calculating the voltage gain from the right side (V1 ) to the left side (VOUT ) of the cut.
.
1 bðoÞ ¼ GL ðoÞa1 v ðoÞ ¼ RP RF is the feedback gain.
The loop gain presents zero phase for o ¼ o0 ¼ ðLp Cp Þ0:5, the corresponding amplitude is GL ðo0 Þ ¼ av Rp ðRp þ RF Þ1 , and the first condition in (12.21) requires that av
Rp þ RF Rp
ð12:24Þ
The factor Rp ðRp þ RF Þ1 is the voltage gain from V1 to the amplifier input in Figure 12.6c, computed at the frequency o0. At that frequency the resonating circuit admittance is purely real, and the passive
516
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
network behaves like a voltage divider having the series resistor RF and the shunt resistor Rp. Therefore, the maximum open-loop gain is higher or lower than 1 if the amplifier voltage gain exceeds or does not the reciprocal of the voltage divider ratio. In other words, the circuit in Figure 12.6a works as an oscillator if the small-signal voltage gain of the amplifier is higher than the resistive loss.11 We can reconsider the network in Figure 12.6a from the negative resistance point of view. There are many possible ways to carry out such an analysis; here we will begin by writing the time domain differential equation of the network, then we will apply Miller’s theorem. Equation (12.23) can be rearranged as
1 1av av 1 þ joLp þ ð12:25Þ þ ð joÞ2 Lp Cp VOUT ðoÞ ¼ joLp VIN ðoÞ Rp RF Rp Equation (B.18) implies that the factor j2p f ¼ jo in the Fourier domain corresponds to the derivative in the time domain. Thus, from Equation (12.25), it follows that the differential equation with the corresponding time domain voltage functions vIN and vOUT is 1 1av dvOUT ðtÞ d 2 vOUT ðtÞ av Lp dvIN ðtÞ þ ¼ Lp vOUT ðtÞ þ þ Lp Cp RF Rp Rp dt dt2 dt If the input voltage is zero, as assumed, the above differential equation simplifies to 1 1av dvOUT ðtÞ d 2 vOUT ðtÞ þ ¼0 Lp þ Lp Cp vOUT ðtÞ þ Rp dt dt2 RF
ð12:26Þ
Equation (12.26) has the same form as (12.1), but with a different first-order coefficient. Therefore, the output voltage of the oscillator in Figure 12.6a coincides with the function (12.6), just by replacing the resistance Rp with the equivalent parallel resistance RP in the expressions for its parameters sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi! sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 4Cp R2P V0 1 1 1 A ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ; t ¼ 2Cp RP ; O ¼ ; j ¼ tan1 2 L Lp Lp Cp ð2Cp RP Þ 1 p 2 4Cp RP
1 o0 ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ; Lp Cp
sffiffiffiffiffiffi Cp Q ¼ RP Lp
where
RP ¼
1 1a0 þ RF Rp
¼
RF jjRp 1a0
ð12:27Þ
The third term of Equation (12.27) highlights that the circuit in Figure 12.6a behaves like an anti-resonant circuit Lp ; Cp ; Rp with the additional shunt resistance ð1a0 Þ1 RF . This resistance is exactly the one resulting from the combination of the feedback resistor and the amplifier, as a consequence of Miller’s theorem.12 Note that ð1a0 Þ1 RF is negative if and only if a0 is greater than 1. Also, at high output amplitudes, the amplifier compression reduces the gain, and consequently the negative conductance, stabilizing the oscillation amplitude. We can get the same result by analyzing the network in Figure 12.6a as Figure 12.6d suggests. By cutting the mesh m3, it is possible to consider separately the admittances of the resonator and that of the active device. On the right of the cut we have one RLC parallel resonator, having admittance YLC . Miller’s 11 The SIMetrix file 08_Positive_Feedback_Oscillator.sxsch analyzes the schematic in Figure 12.6a in the time domain showing the oscillation arising. The saturating amplifier characteristic is modelled with the hyperbolic tangent transfer characteristic. 12 See also Section 11.6.5.
OSCILLATORS
517
theorem applied to the subnetwork on the right of the cut implies that, looking at the right of the cut, we will see the negative resistance RIN. From Equation (12.15), it follows that stable steady state oscillations occur if the resonator admittance is the opposite of the active device one YLC ðo0 Þ þ YIN ðo0 Þ ¼ 0
ð12:28Þ
Note that, for the circuit in Figure 12.6d, Re½YLC ðo0 Þ þ YIN ðo0 Þ ¼ R1 P and Im½YIN ðo0 Þ ¼ 0. Now, the criterion developed in Section 12.2 implies that the circuit in Figure 12.6a behaves like an oscillator at the frequency o0 if R1 P is negative for small output amplitudes and increases towards positive values. Therefore the complex equation (12.28) corresponds to the two scalar conditions Re½YLC ðo0 Þ þ YIN ðo0 Þ 0;
Im½YLC ðo0 Þ þ YIN ðo0 Þ ¼ 0
ð12:29Þ
The first condition in (12.29) applies with the equals or less than sign in the steady state or startup condition, respectively, while the second condition in (12.29) has to be satisfied for any output amplitude. From the first condition in (12.29) and Equation (12.26) it follows that for oscillation startup and stabilization, a0 ðRp þ RF ÞR1 p : this coincides with the inequality in (12.24), hence positive feedback and negative resistance points of view give the same result when applied to the same circuit. Conditions (12.29) can be rewritten as jYLC ðo0 ÞYIN ðo0 Þj 0;
arg½YLC ðo0 ÞYIN ðo0 Þ ¼ 0
ð12:30Þ
The inequality in (12.30) has the same form as relations (12.21): both include one condition on the amplitude and another on the phase of the quantity of interest. The separation between resonator and active device in Figure 12.6d also offers an alternative analysis possibility. Considering the reflection coefficients, rather than admittances, the network in Figure 12.6d corresponds to the SFG in Figure 12.6e, where GLC (GIN ) is the reflection coefficient of the resonator (active device). The simple diagram in Figure 12.6e is a loop, and its gain is the product of its two branches GL ðoÞ ¼ GLC ðoÞGIN ðoÞ
ð12:31Þ
The loop gain (12.31) is the quantity (12.19) expressed in terms of incident and reflected waves, and the SFG in Figure 12.6e corresponds to the generic diagram of Figure 12.5. The conditions (12.21) and (12.22), applied to the reflection coefficients, become respectively jGLC ðo0 ÞGIN ðo0 Þj 1;
arg½GLC ðo0 ÞGIN ðo0 Þ ¼ 0
20 log10 ½jGLC ðo0 ÞGIN ðo0 Þj 0;
arg½GLC ðo0 ÞGIN ðo0 Þ ¼ 0
ð12:32Þ ð12:33Þ
The same conditions, with the equals sign, can be derived by considering that the reflection coefficients relate to the respective admittances as GLC ¼
1R0 YLC 1R0 YIN ; GIN ¼ 1 þ R0 YLC 1 þ R0 YIN
Now, from condition (12.15) it follows that YLC ðoÞ þ YIN ¼ 0, then GLC GIN ¼
1R0 YLC 1R0 YIN 1R0 YLC 1 þ R0 YLC ¼ ¼1 1 þ R0 YLC 1 þ R0 YIN 1 þ R0 YLC 1R0 YLC
as anticipated. Observations: (a) All the conditions (12.22), (12.30) and (12.33) have the form jHðo0 Þj 0; arg½Hðo0 Þ ¼ 0, where the generic function HðoÞ represents one of GL ðoÞ, ½YLC ðoÞ þ YIN ðoÞ, or GLC ðoÞGIN ðoÞ. In the remaining part of this chapter, we will address the first and second condition of the couple as the amplitude and phase conditions, respectively. Note that the phase
518
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING condition determines the oscillation frequency, while the amplitude condition is a requirement for the energy that the active device must supply in order to sustain the oscillation. (b) Conditions (12.21), (12.29) and (12.33) are rigorously derived for the steady state operation of the oscillator, where the first of them apply with the equals sign. In that case the three conditions are totally interchangeable and give the same result. The addition of the inequality sign in the amplitude condition is based only on qualitative considerations. (c) The assumption of different negative resistance, gain or reflection coefficient in the active device, for different output amplitudes, involves nonlinear operation of the device. In the steady state, the oscillator active device works under compression, with the consequent generation of harmonics. Conversely, resistance, gain and reflection coefficient are inherently parameters of linear devices. Amplitude-depending linear parameters are an artifice which can be useful for practical design purposes. It consists of ignoring all the harmonics and considering thePratio between the fundamental components. For instance, if the amplifier P input signal is k vin;k cosðko0 t þ fin;k Þ, the output is k vout;k cosðko0 t þ fout;k Þ, with nonnegative amplitude coefficients, and the corresponding amplitude-dependent linear gain is ðvout;1 =vin;1 Þexp½ jðfout;k fin;k Þ. (d) The active device of the oscillator in Figure 12.6a has no reactance, thus b; YIN ; and GIN are independent of the frequency. Consequently, the network fulfils more restricting conditions than (12.22), (12.30) and (12.33): at the angular frequency o0, not only does arg½Hðo0 Þ ¼ 0, but also jHðo0 Þj is a maximum. In such cases, during startup, as the output amplitude increases, jHðo0 Þj decreases, tending to Hmax , while arg½Hðo0 Þ holds at zero. (e) In general, if the active device includes reactive elements, arg½Hðo0 Þ ¼ 0 does not imply that jHðo0 Þj is a maximum. Moreover o0 depends on the transistor gain, i.e. on its compression degree. Hence, during startup the oscillation pseudo-period is not constant.
Linear design of oscillators must fulfil one of the condition couples (12.22), (12.30) or (12.33), depending on the particular design approach. At the desired oscillation frequency, the linear analysis of the circuit must satisfy the phase condition. Furthermore, the circuit must respect the amplitude condition within a certain margin, in order to take into account temperature variations, differences from device to device and assembly tolerances. Passing from the startup to the steady state, a simple choice consists of assuming that jHðo0 Þj decreases while arg½Hðo0 Þ stays constant: this implies that the final output frequency coincides with the one obtained from the linear analysis. Unfortunately, this assumption is true only if the active device has no reactive elements, which happens in no practical high-frequency case. In general, assuming the inequality for the amplitude condition, Equations (12.22), (12.30) or (12.33) satisfy the phase relation at different frequencies. The simplified analysis of the standard oscillator configurations, the application of the three design methods to a trial oscillator design and their comparison with a nonlinear approach will clarify the point in the next two sections.
12.5 Standard oscillator configuration The configuration in Figure 12.6a is quite ideal, requiring an ideal voltage amplifier. An additional drawback of this solution is the loading effect on the resonator due to the feedback resistor that degrades Q, as we will see in Section 12.7. In real oscillators one transistor replaces the ideal amplifier and the feedback elements are usually reactive ones: the transistor parasitic capacitances work as feedback elements in many cases.
OSCILLATORS
519
Figure 12.7 shows some of the most widely used configurations for transistor oscillators. For the sake of simplicity, all the schematics in Figure 12.7 omit the output network and use FETs, although the standard configurations may also use bipolar devices. This section presents some linear analyses of the standard configurations, based on the application of simplified linear models for the transistor. Real circuits involve more complex models for both the
Ld M
Q1 Lp
Rp
Cp
+ Vdd
(a)
Q1 + Lg
Lp
Rp
Lp2
Rp
Cp
Cp Vdd
(b)
Q1 M
+ Lp1
Vdd
(c)
Q1 Lp
Rp
Q1 Ls Cs Rs
Cp1 + Cp2
Vdd
(d)
Cp1
Rp + Vdd
Cp2
(e)
Lp
Rp
Cp
Cd
Cp
Rp Lp
Lp
Q2
Q1
Cd
Q1
Rp Cp/2 Rp
Cd
Lp
Cd Q2
+ I0 (f)
+
Vdd
I0
Vdd
(g)
Figure 12.7 Standard oscillator configuration: (a) inductive coupled; (b) inductive gate feedback; (c) Hartley; (d) Colpitts; (e) Clapp; (f) cross-coupled differential oscillator; (g) alternative configuration for (f).
520
MICROWAVE AND RF ENGINEERING
transistor and the resonator. Nevertheless, the approximate analysis results are useful starting points for design. Sections 12.5.1 to 12.5.5 present the calculation of the loop gain for all the circuits in Figure 12.7. The technique used to open the loop consists of cutting the connection between the gate and the control port of the linear VCCS of the transistor model, placing an AC generator across the VCCS control port and computing the resulting voltage between the disconnected gate and the source. The voltage loop gain is the ratio between the latter and the first of the quantities mentioned above. Since all the standard oscillators shown in Figure 12.7 use lumped elements only – including the elements of the transistor model – the resulting open-loop gain is always a rational function of the variable jo. Consequently, the loop voltage gain has the form GL ðoÞ ¼
Nu ðjoÞ De ðjoÞ
ð12:34Þ
P P where Nu ðjoÞ ¼ k bk ðjoÞk ; De ðjoÞ ¼ k ak ðjoÞk are polynomials of the variable jo, with real coefficients ak ; bk 2 R. In order to determine if the circuit works as an oscillator, we need to check if the function (12.34) satisfies conditions (12.21). Here, we will introduce a formal method for such verification. After separating the real and imaginary parts of both numerator and denominator, the function (12.34) becomes Nu ðjoÞ Re½Nu ðjoÞ þ jIm½Nu ðjoÞ GL ðoÞ ¼ ¼ De ðjoÞ Re½De ðjoÞ þ jIm½De ðjoÞ The real (imaginary) parts of the numerator and denominator comprise the even- (odd-)order monomials of the respective polynomials X X X b ðjoÞk ¼ b ðjÞk ok ¼ b ð1Þk=2 ok Re½Nu ðjoÞ ¼ Nu;r ðjoÞ ¼ k;even k k;even k k;even k X X X Re½De ðjoÞ ¼ De;r ðjoÞ ¼ a ðjoÞk ¼ b ðjÞk ok ¼ b ð1Þk=2 ok k;even k k;even k k;even k X X X Im½Nu ðjoÞ ¼ Nu;i ðjoÞ ¼ j k;odd bk ðjoÞk ¼ b ðjÞk1 ok ¼ b ð1Þk ok k;odd k k;odd k X X X Im½De ðjoÞ ¼ De;i ðjoÞ ¼ j k;odd ak ðjoÞk ¼ a ðjÞk1 ok ¼ a ð1Þk ok k;odd k k;odd k Using these quantities, multiplying the numerator and denominator of the function (12.34) for the complex conjugate of the denominator and simplifying, we obtain Nu;r ðjoÞDe;r ðjoÞ þ Nu;i ðjoÞDe;i ðjoÞ þ j½Nu;i ðjoÞDe;r ðjoÞNu;r ðjoÞDe;i ðjoÞ GL ðoÞ ¼ ½De;r ðjoÞ2 þ ½De;i ðjoÞ2 Starting with the phase condition, the argument of the function (12.34) vanishes if ½Nu;i ðjoÞDe;r ðjoÞNu;r ðjoÞDe;i ðjoÞ ¼ 0
ð12:35Þ
Equation (12.35) is generally a high-order polynomial and thus has many solutions o0 , which can be analytically computed in a few special cases. In more general cases, a solution is possible with numerical methods, or by introducing some simplifications in the network. Substituting one solution into the function (12.34), we obtain GL ðo0 Þ ¼
Nu;r ðjo0 ÞDe;r ðjo0 Þ þ Nu;i ðjo0 ÞDe;i ðjo0 Þ ½De;r ðjo0 Þ2 þ ½De;i ðjo0 Þ2
¼ Re½GL ðo0 Þ
ð12:36Þ
This expression is real by definition of o0 . However, the oscillation conditions (12.21) state a stricter requirement: the loop gain must be not only real, but also positive and no smaller than 1, at the oscillation frequency. This eliminates the solutions of Equation (12.35) with GL ðo0 Þ ¼ Re½GL ðo0 Þ < 1 from the list of the potential oscillation frequency.
OSCILLATORS
521
If one unique o0 exists such that Re½GL ðo0 Þ 1, then it is the oscillation frequency of the circuit. If more than one such solution exists, the circuit presents more true possible oscillation frequencies. In this case, the output frequency can jump from one value to another, after an abrupt change of the load impedance, switching the oscillator off and on again, for temperature changes, and so on. Such a malfunctioning is sometimes referred to as mode jumping, and must absolutely be avoided.
12.5.1
Inductively coupled oscillator
The inductively coupled oscillator is the simplest to analyze among the ones in Figure 12.7a. Figure 12.8 shows the various simplification steps needed to calculate the loop gain, in order to determine the oscillation conditions. Figure 12.8a shows the complete electrical diagram of the oscillator, including the output bias network ðVdd ; Ldd ; Cdd Þ and load ðRdd Þ. We will assume the bias inductor (capacitor) presents a much higher (lower) impedance than the load resistor, at the oscillation frequency. Therefore, the linear equivalent circuit of Figure 12.8b replaces Ldd and Cdd with the open circuit and short circuit, respectively. Moreover, a simplified linear model – consisting of a VCCS with transconductance gm and input capacitance Cgs – models the transistor. Figure 12.8c shows the next step, which consists of opening the loop by cutting the mesh m1 inside the transistor, breaking the connection between the gate and the VCCS control pin. One AC voltage generator connects to the VCCS control port. The desired loop gain is the ratio between the voltage across the transistor input capacitance and the impressed AC voltage. The load resistor in Figure 12.8b is in series with a current generator, which does not affect the network equations, so Figure 12.8c short-circuits that resistor. Also, the inductor Ld is the only component directly connected to the current generator, hence Figure 12.8c inverts the terminals of both those components with respect to Figure 12.8c. This double inversion does not alter the network equations, but allows a further simplification in the circuit, as Figure 12.8d shows: the mutually coupled inductors Lp ; Ld are replaced by their equivalent network consisting of three single inductors in a T connection. Similar to RLOAD in Figure 12.8b, Ld is now in series with a current generator, and can be short-circuited, as Figure 12.8e shows. The final transformation consists of passing from the Norton configuration of the current generator in parallel with the inductor M to the Thevenin equivalent one. The current generator gm vi with impedance jo M transforms into a voltage generator jo M gm vi , with the same impedance in series, as shown in Figure 12.8f. Note that the new network in the figure has two inductors M; Lp M in series: they are equivalent to a single one, having inductance L ¼ M þ Lp M �