MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS SECOND EDITION Richard W. Baker Membrane Technology and Research, Inc. Menlo Park, California
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS SECOND EDITION Richard W. Baker Membrane Technology and Research, Inc. Menlo Park, California
First Edition published by McGraw-Hill, 2000. ISBN: 0 07 135440 9 Copyright 2004
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England Telephone (+44) 1243 779777
Email (for orders and customer service enquiries):
[email protected] Visit our Home Page on www.wileyeurope.com or www.wiley.com All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except under the terms of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP, UK, without the permission in writing of the Publisher. Requests to the Publisher should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England, or emailed to
[email protected], or faxed to (+44) 1243 770620. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the Publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Other Wiley Editorial Offices John Wiley & Sons Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA Jossey-Bass, 989 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94103-1741, USA Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, Boschstr. 12, D-69469 Weinheim, Germany John Wiley & Sons Australia Ltd, 33 Park Road, Milton, Queensland 4064, Australia John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd, 2 Clementi Loop #02-01, Jin Xing Distripark, Singapore 129809 John Wiley & Sons Canada Ltd, 22 Worcester Road, Etobicoke, Ontario, Canada M9W 1L1 Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Baker, Richard W. Membrane technology and applications / Richard W. Baker.—2nd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-470-85445-6 (Cloth : alk. paper) 1. Membranes (Technology) I. Title. TP159.M4 B35 2004 660 .28424—dc22 2003021354 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0-470-85445-6 Typeset in 10/12pt Times by Laserwords Private Limited, Chennai, India Printed and bound in Great Britain by TJ International, Padstow, Cornwall This book is printed on acid-free paper responsibly manufactured from sustainable forestry in which at least two trees are planted for each one used for paper production.
CONTENTS Preface Acknowledgments for the first edition Acknowledgments for the second edition
ix xi xiii
1.
OVERVIEW OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Introduction Historical Development of Membranes Types of Membranes Membrane Processes References
1 1 1 3 6 14
2.
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY Introduction Solution-diffusion Model Structure–Permeability Relationships in Solution-diffusion Membranes Pore-flow Membranes Conclusions and Future Directions References
15 15 18 48 66 83 84
3.
MEMBRANES AND MODULES Introduction Isotropic Membranes Anisotropic Membranes Metal Membranes and Ceramic Membranes Liquid Membranes Hollow Fiber Membranes Membrane Modules Conclusions and Future Directions References
89 89 90 96 128 132 133 139 154 155
4.
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION Introduction Boundary Layer Film Model
161 161 164
vi
CONTENTS Determination of the Peclet Number Concentration Polarization in Liquid Separation Processes Concentration Polarization in Gas Separation Processes Cross-flow, Co-flow and Counter-flow Conclusions and Future Directions References
172 176 178 182 189 189
5.
REVERSE OSMOSIS Introduction and History Theoretical Background Membranes and Materials Reverse Osmosis Membrane Categories Membrane Selectivity Membrane Modules Membrane Fouling Control Membrane Cleaning Applications Conclusions and Future Directions References
191 191 193 196 205 212 214 215 220 221 231 232
6.
ULTRAFILTRATION Introduction and History Characterization of Ultrafiltration Membranes Concentration Polarization and Membrane Fouling Membrane Cleaning Membranes and Modules System Design Applications Conclusions and Future Directions References
237 237 238 241 251 253 258 262 272 272
7.
MICROFILTRATION Introduction and History Background Applications Conclusions and Future Directions References
275 275 277 295 299 299
8.
GAS SEPARATION Introduction and History Theoretical Background Membrane Materials and Structure Membrane Modules
301 301 303 309 317
CONTENTS
vii
Process Design Applications Conclusions and Future Directions References
317 327 349 351
PERVAPORATION Introduction and History Theoretical Background Membrane Materials and Modules Process Design Applications Conclusions and Future Directions References
355 355 357 363 369 372 388 389
ION EXCHANGE MEMBRANE PROCESSES–ELECTRODIALYSIS Introduction and History Theoretical Background Chemistry of Ion Exchange Membranes Transport in Electrodialysis Membranes System Design Applications Conclusions and Future Directions References
393 393 397 400 404 411 415 422 422
11.
CARRIER FACILITATED TRANSPORT Introduction and History Coupled Transport Facilitated Transport Conclusions and Future Directions References
425 425 431 444 459 460
12.
MEDICAL APPLICATIONS OF MEMBRANES Introduction Hemodialysis Blood Oxygenators Controlled Drug Delivery References
465 465 465 470 472 489
13.
OTHER MEMBRANE PROCESSES Introduction Dialysis Donnan Dialysis and Diffusion Dialysis
491 491 491 493
9.
10.
viii
CONTENTS Charge Mosaic Membranes and Piezodialysis Membrane Contactors and Membrane Distillation Membrane Reactors Conclusions and Future Directions References
496 500 509 518 519
Appendix
523
Index
535
PREFACE My introduction to membranes was as a graduate student in 1963. At that time membrane permeation was a sub-study of materials science. What is now called membrane technology did not exist, nor did any large industrial applications of membranes. Since then, sales of membranes and membrane equipment have increased more than 100-fold and several tens of millions of square meters of membrane are produced each year—a membrane industry has been created. This membrane industry is very fragmented. Industrial applications are divided into six main sub-groups: reverse osmosis; ultrafiltration; microfiltration; gas separation; pervaporation and electrodialysis. Medical applications are divided into three more: artificial kidneys; blood oxygenators; and controlled release pharmaceuticals. Few companies are involved in more than one sub-group of the industry. Because of these divisions it is difficult to obtain an overview of membrane science and technology; this book is an attempt to give such an overview. The book starts with a series of general chapters on membrane preparation, transport theory, and concentration polarization. Thereafter, each major membrane application is treated in a single 20-to-40-page chapter. In a book of this size it is impossible to describe every membrane process in detail, but the major processes are covered. However, medical applications have been short-changed somewhat and some applications—fuel cell and battery separators and membrane sensors, for example—are not covered at all. Each application chapter starts with a short historical background to acknowledge the developers of the technology. I am conscious that my views of what was important in the past differ from those of many of my academic colleagues. In this book I have given more credit than is usual to the engineers who actually made the processes work. Readers of the theoretical section (Chapter 2) and elsewhere in the book will see that membrane permeation is described using simple phenomenological equations, most commonly, Fick’s law. There is no mention of irreversible thermodynamics. The irreversible thermodynamic approach to permeation was very fashionable when I began to work with membranes in the 1960s. This approach has the appearance of rigor but hides the physical reality of even simple processes behind a fog of tough equations. As a student and young researcher, I struggled with irreversible thermodynamics for more than 15 years before finally giving up in the 1970s. I have lived happily ever after.
x
PREFACE
Finally, a few words on units. Because a great deal of modern membrane technology originated in the United States, the US engineering units—gallons, cubic feet, and pounds per square inch—are widely used in the membrane industry. Unlike the creators of the Pascal, I am not a worshipper of mindless uniformity. Metric units are used when appropriate, but US engineering units are used when they are the industry standard.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS FOR THE FIRST EDITION As a school boy I once received a mark of 12 out of a possible 20 in an end-of-term spelling test. My spelling is still weak, and the only punctuation I ever really mastered was the period. This made the preparation of a polished final draft from my yellow notepads a major undertaking. This effort was headed by Tessa Ennals and Cindi Wieselman. Cindi typed and retyped the manuscript with amazing speed, through its numerous revisions, without complaint. Tessa corrected my English, clarified my language, unsplit my infinitives and added every semicolon found in this book. She also chased down a source for all of the illustrations used and worked with David Lehmann, our graphics artist, to prepare the figures. It is a pleasure to acknowledge my debt to these people. This book would have been far weaker without the many hours they spent working on it. I also received help from other friends and colleagues at MTR. Hans Wijmans read, corrected and made numerous suggestions on the theoretical section of the book (Chapter 2). Ingo Pinnau also provided data, references and many valuable suggestions in the area of membrane preparation and membrane material sciences. I am also grateful to Kenji Matsumoto, who read the section on Reverse Osmosis and made corrections, and to Heiner Strathmann, who did the same for Electrodialysis. The assistance of Marcia Patten, who proofed the manuscript, and Vivian Tran, who checked many of the references, is also appreciated.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS FOR THE SECOND EDITION Eighteen months after the first edition of this book appeared, it was out of print. Fortunately, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd agreed to publish a second edition, and I have taken the opportunity to update and revise a number of sections. Tessa Ennals, long-time editor at Membrane Technology and Research, postponed her retirement to help me finish the new edition. Tessa has the standards of an earlier time, and here, as in the past, she gave the task nothing but her best effort. I am indebted to her, and wish her a long and happy retirement. Marcia Patten, Eric Peterson, David Lehmann, Cindy Dunnegan and Janet Farrant assisted Tessa by typing new sections, revising and adding figures, and checking references, as well as helping with proofing the manuscript. I am grateful to all of these colleagues for their help.
1 OVERVIEW OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Introduction Membranes have gained an important place in chemical technology and are used in a broad range of applications. The key property that is exploited is the ability of a membrane to control the permeation rate of a chemical species through the membrane. In controlled drug delivery, the goal is to moderate the permeation rate of a drug from a reservoir to the body. In separation applications, the goal is to allow one component of a mixture to permeate the membrane freely, while hindering permeation of other components. This book provides a general introduction to membrane science and technology. Chapters 2 to 4 cover membrane science, that is, topics that are basic to all membrane processes, such as transport mechanisms, membrane preparation, and boundary layer effects. The next six chapters cover the industrial membrane separation processes, which represent the heart of current membrane technology. Carrier facilitated transport is covered next, followed by a chapter reviewing the medical applications of membranes. The book closes with a chapter that describes various minor or yet-to-be-developed membrane processes, including membrane reactors, membrane contactors and piezodialysis.
Historical Development of Membranes Systematic studies of membrane phenomena can be traced to the eighteenth century philosopher scientists. For example, Abb´e Nolet coined the word ‘osmosis’ to describe permeation of water through a diaphragm in 1748. Through the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, membranes had no industrial or commercial uses, but were used as laboratory tools to develop physical/chemical theories. For example, the measurements of solution osmotic pressure made with membranes by Traube and Pfeffer were used by van’t Hoff in 1887 to develop his limit law, which explains the behavior of ideal dilute solutions; this work led directly to the Membrane Technology and Applications R. W. Baker 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 0-470-85445-6
2
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
van’t Hoff equation. At about the same time, the concept of a perfectly selective semipermeable membrane was used by Maxwell and others in developing the kinetic theory of gases. Early membrane investigators experimented with every type of diaphragm available to them, such as bladders of pigs, cattle or fish and sausage casings made of animal gut. Later, collodion (nitrocellulose) membranes were preferred, because they could be made reproducibly. In 1907, Bechhold devised a technique to prepare nitrocellulose membranes of graded pore size, which he determined by a bubble test [1]. Other early workers, particularly Elford [2], Zsigmondy and Bachmann [3] and Ferry [4] improved on Bechhold’s technique, and by the early 1930s microporous collodion membranes were commercially available. During the next 20 years, this early microfiltration membrane technology was expanded to other polymers, notably cellulose acetate. Membranes found their first significant application in the testing of drinking water at the end of World War II. Drinking water supplies serving large communities in Germany and elsewhere in Europe had broken down, and filters to test for water safety were needed urgently. The research effort to develop these filters, sponsored by the US Army, was later exploited by the Millipore Corporation, the first and still the largest US microfiltration membrane producer. By 1960, the elements of modern membrane science had been developed, but membranes were used in only a few laboratory and small, specialized industrial applications. No significant membrane industry existed, and total annual sales of membranes for all industrial applications probably did not exceed US$20 million in 2003 dollars. Membranes suffered from four problems that prohibited their widespread use as a separation process: They were too unreliable, too slow, too unselective, and too expensive. Solutions to each of these problems have been developed during the last 30 years, and membrane-based separation processes are now commonplace. The seminal discovery that transformed membrane separation from a laboratory to an industrial process was the development, in the early 1960s, of the Loeb–Sourirajan process for making defect-free, high-flux, anisotropic reverse osmosis membranes [5]. These membranes consist of an ultrathin, selective surface film on a much thicker but much more permeable microporous support, which provides the mechanical strength. The flux of the first Loeb–Sourirajan reverse osmosis membrane was 10 times higher than that of any membrane then available and made reverse osmosis a potentially practical method of desalting water. The work of Loeb and Sourirajan, and the timely infusion of large sums of research and development dollars from the US Department of Interior, Office of Saline Water (OSW), resulted in the commercialization of reverse osmosis and was a major factor in the development of ultrafiltration and microfiltration. The development of electrodialysis was also aided by OSW funding. Concurrently with the development of these industrial applications of membranes was the independent development of membranes for medical separation
OVERVIEW OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
3
processes, in particular, the artificial kidney. W.J. Kolf [6] had demonstrated the first successful artificial kidney in The Netherlands in 1945. It took almost 20 years to refine the technology for use on a large scale, but these developments were complete by the early 1960s. Since then, the use of membranes in artificial organs has become a major life-saving procedure. More than 800 000 people are now sustained by artificial kidneys and a further million people undergo open-heart surgery each year, a procedure made possible by development of the membrane blood oxygenator. The sales of these devices comfortably exceed the total industrial membrane separation market. Another important medical application of membranes is for controlled drug delivery systems. A key figure in this area was Alex Zaffaroni, who founded Alza, a company dedicated to developing these products in 1966. The membrane techniques developed by Alza and its competitors are widely used in the pharmaceutical industry to improve the efficiency and safety of drug delivery. The period from 1960 to 1980 produced a significant change in the status of membrane technology. Building on the original Loeb–Sourirajan technique, other membrane formation processes, including interfacial polymerization and multilayer composite casting and coating, were developed for making highperformance membranes. Using these processes, membranes with selective layers as thin as 0.1 µm or less are now being produced by a number of companies. Methods of packaging membranes into large-membrane-area spiral-wound, hollow-fine-fiber, capillary, and plate-and-frame modules were also developed, and advances were made in improving membrane stability. By 1980, microfiltration, ultrafiltration, reverse osmosis and electrodialysis were all established processes with large plants installed worldwide. The principal development in the 1980s was the emergence of industrial membrane gas separation processes. The first major development was the Monsanto Prism membrane for hydrogen separation, introduced in 1980 [7]. Within a few years, Dow was producing systems to separate nitrogen from air, and Cynara and Separex were producing systems to separate carbon dioxide from natural gas. Gas separation technology is evolving and expanding rapidly; further substantial growth will be seen in the coming years. The final development of the 1980s was the introduction by GFT, a small German engineering company, of the first commercial pervaporation systems for dehydration of alcohol. More than 100 ethanol and isopropanol pervaporation dehydration plants have now been installed. Other pervaporation applications are at the early commercial stage.
Types of Membranes This book is limited to synthetic membranes, excluding all biological structures, but the topic is still large enough to include a wide variety of membranes that differ in chemical and physical composition and in the way they operate. In essence, a membrane is nothing more than a discrete, thin interface that moderates the
4
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Symmetrical membranes Isotropic microporous membrane
Nonporous dense membrane
Electrically charged membrane coocoocoocoo-
Anisotropic membranes
coo-
coo-
coo-
coo-
coocoo- coo-
coo-
Supported liquid membrane
Liquidfilled pores Loeb-Sourirajan anisotropic membrane
Thin-film composite anisotropic membrane
Polymer matrix
Figure 1.1 Schematic diagrams of the principal types of membranes
permeation of chemical species in contact with it. This interface may be molecularly homogeneous, that is, completely uniform in composition and structure, or it may be chemically or physically heterogeneous, for example, containing holes or pores of finite dimensions or consisting of some form of layered structure. A normal filter meets this definition of a membrane, but, by convention, the term filter is usually limited to structures that separate particulate suspensions larger than 1 to 10 µm. The principal types of membrane are shown schematically in Figure 1.1 and are described briefly below. Isotropic Membranes Microporous Membranes A microporous membrane is very similar in structure and function to a conventional filter. It has a rigid, highly voided structure with randomly distributed, interconnected pores. However, these pores differ from those in a conventional filter by being extremely small, on the order of 0.01 to 10 µm in diameter. All particles larger than the largest pores are completely rejected by the membrane.
OVERVIEW OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
5
Particles smaller than the largest pores, but larger than the smallest pores are partially rejected, according to the pore size distribution of the membrane. Particles much smaller than the smallest pores will pass through the membrane. Thus, separation of solutes by microporous membranes is mainly a function of molecular size and pore size distribution. In general, only molecules that differ considerably in size can be separated effectively by microporous membranes, for example, in ultrafiltration and microfiltration. Nonporous, Dense Membranes Nonporous, dense membranes consist of a dense film through which permeants are transported by diffusion under the driving force of a pressure, concentration, or electrical potential gradient. The separation of various components of a mixture is related directly to their relative transport rate within the membrane, which is determined by their diffusivity and solubility in the membrane material. Thus, nonporous, dense membranes can separate permeants of similar size if their concentration in the membrane material (that is, their solubility) differs significantly. Most gas separation, pervaporation, and reverse osmosis membranes use dense membranes to perform the separation. Usually these membranes have an anisotropic structure to improve the flux. Electrically Charged Membranes Electrically charged membranes can be dense or microporous, but are most commonly very finely microporous, with the pore walls carrying fixed positively or negatively charged ions. A membrane with fixed positively charged ions is referred to as an anion-exchange membrane because it binds anions in the surrounding fluid. Similarly, a membrane containing fixed negatively charged ions is called a cation-exchange membrane. Separation with charged membranes is achieved mainly by exclusion of ions of the same charge as the fixed ions of the membrane structure, and to a much lesser extent by the pore size. The separation is affected by the charge and concentration of the ions in solution. For example, monovalent ions are excluded less effectively than divalent ions and, in solutions of high ionic strength, selectivity decreases. Electrically charged membranes are used for processing electrolyte solutions in electrodialysis. Anisotropic Membranes The transport rate of a species through a membrane is inversely proportional to the membrane thickness. High transport rates are desirable in membrane separation processes for economic reasons; therefore, the membrane should be as thin as possible. Conventional film fabrication technology limits manufacture of mechanically strong, defect-free films to about 20 µm thickness. The development of
6
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
novel membrane fabrication techniques to produce anisotropic membrane structures was one of the major breakthroughs of membrane technology during the past 30 years. Anisotropic membranes consist of an extremely thin surface layer supported on a much thicker, porous substructure. The surface layer and its substructure may be formed in a single operation or separately. In composite membranes, the layers are usually made from different polymers. The separation properties and permeation rates of the membrane are determined exclusively by the surface layer; the substructure functions as a mechanical support. The advantages of the higher fluxes provided by anisotropic membranes are so great that almost all commercial processes use such membranes. Ceramic, Metal and Liquid Membranes The discussion so far implies that membrane materials are organic polymers and, in fact, the vast majority of membranes used commercially are polymer-based. However, in recent years, interest in membranes formed from less conventional materials has increased. Ceramic membranes, a special class of microporous membranes, are being used in ultrafiltration and microfiltration applications for which solvent resistance and thermal stability are required. Dense metal membranes, particularly palladium membranes, are being considered for the separation of hydrogen from gas mixtures, and supported liquid films are being developed for carrier-facilitated transport processes.
Membrane Processes Six developed and a number of developing and yet-to-be-developed industrial membrane technologies are discussed in this book. In addition, sections are included describing the use of membranes in medical applications such as the artificial kidney, blood oxygenation, and controlled drug delivery devices. The status of all of these processes is summarized in Table 1.1. The four developed industrial membrane separation processes are microfiltration, ultrafiltration, reverse osmosis, and electrodialysis. These processes are all well established, and the market is served by a number of experienced companies. The range of application of the three pressure-driven membrane water separation processes—reverse osmosis, ultrafiltration and microfiltration—is illustrated in Figure 1.2. Ultrafiltration (Chapter 6) and microfiltration (Chapter 7) are basically similar in that the mode of separation is molecular sieving through increasingly fine pores. Microfiltration membranes filter colloidal particles and bacteria from 0.1 to 10 µm in diameter. Ultrafiltration membranes can be used to filter dissolved macromolecules, such as proteins, from solutions. The mechanism of separation by reverse osmosis membranes is quite different. In reverse osmosis membranes (Chapter 5), the membrane pores are so small, from 3 to ˚ in diameter, that they are within the range of thermal motion of the polymer 5A
OVERVIEW OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Table 1.1
7
Membrane technologies addressed in this book
Category
Process
Status
Developed industrial membrane separation technologies
Microfiltration Ultrafiltration Reverse osmosis Electrodialysis
Well-established unit operations. No major breakthroughs seem imminent
Developing industrial membrane separation technologies
Gas separation Pervaporation
A number of plants have been installed. Market size and number of applications served are expanding
To-be-developed industrial membrane separation technologies
Carrier facilitated transport Membrane contactors Piezodialysis, etc.
Major problems remain to be solved before industrial systems will be installed on a large scale
Medical applications of membranes
Artificial kidneys Artificial lungs Controlled drug delivery
Well-established processes. Still the focus of research to improve performance, for example, improving biocompatibility
Na+ (3.7 Å) Sucrose H2O (10 Å) (2 Å)
Hemoglobin (70 Å)
Pseudomonas diminuta Influenza (0.28 µm) virus (1000 Å)
Staphylococcus bacteria (1 µm)
Starch (10 µm)
Microfiltration Conventional filtration
Ultrafiltration
Reverse osmosis 1Å
10 Å
100 Å
1000 Å
1 µm
10 µm
100 µm
Pore diameter
Figure 1.2 Reverse osmosis, ultrafiltration, microfiltration, and conventional filtration are related processes differing principally in the average pore diameter of the membrane filter. Reverse osmosis membranes are so dense that discrete pores do not exist; transport occurs via statistically distributed free volume areas. The relative size of different solutes removed by each class of membrane is illustrated in this schematic
8
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
chains that form the membrane. The accepted mechanism of transport through these membranes is called the solution-diffusion model. According to this model, solutes permeate the membrane by dissolving in the membrane material and diffusing down a concentration gradient. Separation occurs because of the difference in solubilities and mobilities of different solutes in the membrane. The principal application of reverse osmosis is desalination of brackish groundwater or seawater. Although reverse osmosis, ultrafiltration and microfiltration are conceptually similar processes, the difference in pore diameter (or apparent pore diameter) produces dramatic differences in the way the membranes are used. A simple model of liquid flow through these membranes is to describe the membranes as a series of cylindrical capillary pores of diameter d. The liquid flow through a pore (q) is given by Poiseuille’s law as: q=
πd 4 · p 128 µ
(1.1)
where p is the pressure difference across the pore, µ is the liquid viscosity and is the pore length. The flux, or flow per unit membrane area, is the sum of all the flows through the individual pores and so is given by: J =N·
πd 4 · p 128 µ
(1.2)
where N is the number of pores per square centimeter of membrane. For membranes of equal pore area and porosity (ε), the number of pores per square centimeter is proportional to the inverse square of the pore diameter. That is, 4 N =ε· (1.3) πd 2 It follows that the flux, given by combining Equations (1.2) and (1.3), is J =
pε · d2 32 µ
(1.4)
From Figure 1.2, the typical pore diameter of a microfiltration membrane ˚ This is 100-fold larger than the average ultrafiltration pore and is 10 000 A. 1000-fold larger than the (nominal) diameter of pores in reverse osmosis membranes. Because fluxes are proportional to the square of these pore diameters, the permeance, that is, flux per unit pressure difference (J /p) of microfiltration membranes is enormously higher than that of ultrafiltration membranes, which in turn is much higher than that of reverse osmosis membranes. These differences significantly impact the operating pressure and the way that these membranes are used industrially.
OVERVIEW OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
9
The fourth fully developed membrane process is electrodialysis (Chapter 10), in which charged membranes are used to separate ions from aqueous solutions under the driving force of an electrical potential difference. The process utilizes an electrodialysis stack, built on the filter-press principle and containing several hundred individual cells, each formed by a pair of anion and cation exchange membranes. The principal application of electrodialysis is the desalting of brackish groundwater. However, industrial use of the process in the food industry, for example, to deionize cheese whey, is growing, as is its use in pollution-control applications. A schematic of the process is shown in Figure 1.3. Table 1.1 shows two developing industrial membrane separation processes: gas separation with polymer membranes (Chapter 8) and pervaporation (Chapter 9). Gas separation with membranes is the more advanced of the two techniques; at least 20 companies worldwide offer industrial, membrane-based gas separation systems for a variety of applications. Only a handful of companies currently offer industrial pervaporation systems. In gas separation, a gas mixture at an elevated pressure is passed across the surface of a membrane that is selectively permeable to one component of the feed mixture; the membrane permeate is enriched in this species. The basic process is illustrated in Figure 1.4. Major current applications Pick-up solution
Salt solution
Anode feed
Cathode feed C Cathode (−)
A
Na+
C
Na+
A
Na+
C
Na+
C
A
Na+
Na+
A
Na+
C
Na+
A
Na+
Anode (+)
To negative pole of rectifier Cl−
Cl−
Cl−
Cl−
Cl−
Cl−
Cl−
Cl−
Cl−
To positive pole of rectifier
Anode effluent
Cathode effluent
C Cation-exchange membrane
Concentrated effluent
Figure 1.3
Demineralized product
Schematic diagram of an electrodialysis process
A Anion-exchange membrane
10
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Membrane module Feed
Residue
Permeate
Figure 1.4 Schematic diagram of the basic membrane gas separation process
of gas separation membranes are the separation of hydrogen from nitrogen, argon and methane in ammonia plants; the production of nitrogen from air; and the separation of carbon dioxide from methane in natural gas operations. Membrane gas separation is an area of considerable current research interest, and the number of applications is expanding rapidly. Pervaporation is a relatively new process that has elements in common with reverse osmosis and gas separation. In pervaporation, a liquid mixture contacts one side of a membrane, and the permeate is removed as a vapor from the other. The driving force for the process is the low vapor pressure on the permeate side of the membrane generated by cooling and condensing the permeate vapor. The attraction of pervaporation is that the separation obtained is proportional to the rate of permeation of the components of the liquid mixture through the selective membrane. Therefore, pervaporation offers the possibility of separating closely boiling mixtures or azeotropes that are difficult to separate by distillation or other means. A schematic of a simple pervaporation process using a condenser to generate the permeate vacuum is shown in Figure 1.5. Currently, the main industrial application of pervaporation is the dehydration of organic solvents, in particular, the dehydration of 90–95 % ethanol solutions, a difficult separation problem because of the ethanol–water azeotrope at 95 % ethanol. Pervaporation membranes that selectively permeate water can produce more than 99.9 % ethanol from these solutions. Pervaporation processes are also being developed for the removal of dissolved organics from water and for the separation of organic mixtures. A number of other industrial membrane processes are placed in the category of to-be-developed technologies in Table 1.1. Perhaps the most important of these is carrier facilitated transport (Chapter 11), which often employs liquid membranes containing a complexing or carrier agent. The carrier agent reacts with one component of a mixture on the feed side of the membrane and then diffuses across the membrane to release the permeant on the product side of the membrane. The reformed carrier agent then diffuses back to the feed side of the membrane. Thus, the carrier agent acts as a shuttle to selectively transport one component from the feed to the product side of the membrane.
OVERVIEW OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
11
Purified liquid
Feed liquid
Condenser
Condensed permeate liquid
Figure 1.5
Schematic diagram of the basic pervaporation process
Facilitated transport membranes can be used to separate gases; membrane transport is then driven by a difference in the gas partial pressure across the membrane. Metal ions can also be selectively transported across a membrane, driven by a flow of hydrogen or hydroxyl ions in the other direction. This process is sometimes called coupled transport. Examples of carrier facilitated transport processes for gas and ion transport are shown in Figure 1.6. Because the carrier facilitated transport process employs a reactive carrier species, very high membrane selectivities can be achieved. These selectivities are often far larger than the selectivities achieved by other membrane processes. This one fact has maintained interest in facilitated transport for the past 30 years, but no commercial applications have developed. The principal problem is the physical instability of the liquid membrane and the chemical instability of the carrier agent. In recent years a number of potential solutions to this problem have been developed, which may yet make carrier facilitated transport a viable process. The membrane separation processes described above represent the bulk of the industrial membrane separation industry. Another process, dialysis, is not used industrially but is used on a large scale in medicine to remove toxic metabolites from blood in patients suffering from kidney failure. The first successful artificial kidney was based on cellophane (regenerated cellulose) dialysis membranes and was developed in 1945. Over the past 50 years, many changes have been made. Currently, most artificial kidneys are based on hollow-fiber membranes formed into modules having a membrane area of about 1 m2 ; the process is illustrated in Figure 1.7. Blood is circulated through the center of the fiber, while isotonic
12
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Facilitated transport HEM Membrane
O2
O2
[HEM O2]
O2 + HEM
[HEM O2]
[HEM O2]
HEM + O2
Coupled transport HR Cu++
Cu++ Membrane
H+
CuR2
Cu++ + 2HR
CuR2 + 2H+
CuR2 + 2H+
H+
Cu++ + 2HR
Figure 1.6 Schematic examples of carrier facilitated transport of gas and ions. The gas transport example shows the transport of oxygen across a membrane using hemoglobin as the carrier agent. The ion transport example shows the transport of copper ions across a membrane using a liquid ion-exchange reagent as the carrier agent Saline and metabolites
Blood
Blood Dialyser Saline solution
Figure 1.7 Schematic of a hollow fiber artificial kidney dialyser used to remove urea and other toxic metabolites from blood. About 100 million of these devices are used every year
OVERVIEW OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
13
Drug
Drug release rate
saline, the dialysate, is pumped countercurrently around the outside of the fibers. Urea, creatinine, and other low-molecular-weight metabolites in the blood diffuse across the fiber wall and are removed with the saline solution. The process is quite slow, usually requiring several hours to remove the required amount of the metabolite from the patient, and must be repeated one or two times per week. In terms of membrane area used and dollar value of the membrane produced, artificial kidneys are the single largest application of membranes. Following the success of the artificial kidney, similar devices were developed to remove carbon dioxide and deliver oxygen to the blood. These so-called artificial lungs are used in surgical procedures during which the patient’s lungs cannot function. The dialysate fluid shown in Figure 1.7 is replaced with a carefully controlled sweep gas containing oxygen, which is delivered to the blood, and carbon dioxide, which is removed. These two medical applications of membranes are described in Chapter 12. Another major medical use of membranes is in controlled drug delivery (Chapter 12). Controlled drug delivery can be achieved by a wide range of techniques, most of which involve membranes; a simple example is illustrated in Figure 1.8. In this device, designed to deliver drugs through the skin, drug is contained in a reservoir surrounded by a membrane. With such a system,
Membrane
Initial high release of agent that has migrated into membrane on storage
Constant release as long as a constant concentration is maintained in depot Release rapidly declines when device approaches exhaustion
Time Diagram and release curve for a simple reservoir system Foil backing Adhesive
Drug reservoir Membrane
Body
Figure 1.8 Schematic of transdermal patch in which the rate of delivery of drug to the body is controlled by a polymer membrane. Such patches are used to deliver many drugs including nitroglycerine, estradiol, nicotine and scopalamine
14
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
the release of drug is constant as long as a constant concentration of drug is maintained within the device. A constant concentration is maintained if the reservoir contains a saturated solution and sufficient excess of solid drug. Systems that operate using this principle are used to moderate delivery of drugs such as nitroglycerine (for angina), nicotine (for smoking cessation), and estradiol (for hormone replacement therapy) through the skin. Other devices using osmosis or biodegradation as the rate-controlling mechanism are also produced as implants and tablets. The total market of controlled release pharmaceuticals is comfortably above US$3 billion per year.
References 1. H. Bechhold, Kolloidstudien mit der Filtrationsmethode, Z. Physik Chem. 60, 257 (1907). 2. W.J. Elford, Principles Governing the Preparation of Membranes Having Graded Porosities. The Properties of ‘Gradocol’ Membranes as Ultrafilters, Trans. Faraday Soc. 33, 1094 (1937). ¨ 3. R. Zsigmondy and W. Bachmann, Uber Neue Filter, Z. Anorg. Chem. 103, 119 (1918). 4. J.D. Ferry, Ultrafilter Membranes and Ultrafiltration, Chem. Rev. 18, 373 (1936). 5. S. Loeb and S. Sourirajan, Sea Water Demineralization by Means of an Osmotic Membrane, in Saline Water Conversion–II, Advances in Chemistry Series Number 28, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 117–132 (1963). 6. W.J. Kolf and H.T. Berk, The Artificial Kidney: A Dialyzer with Great Area, Acta Med Scand. 117, 121 (1944). 7. J.M.S. Henis and M.K. Tripodi, A Novel Approach to Gas Separation Using Composite Hollow Fiber Membranes, Sep. Sci. Technol. 15, 1059 (1980).
2 MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY Introduction The most important property of membranes is their ability to control the rate of permeation of different species. The two models used to describe the mechanism of permeation are illustrated in Figure 2.1. One is the solution-diffusion model, in which permeants dissolve in the membrane material and then diffuse through the membrane down a concentration gradient. The permeants are separated because of the differences in the solubilities of the materials in the membrane and the differences in the rates at which the materials diffuse through the membrane. The other model is the pore-flow model, in which permeants are transported by pressure-driven convective flow through tiny pores. Separation occurs because one of the permeants is excluded (filtered) from some of the pores in the membrane through which other permeants move. Both models were proposed in the nineteenth century, but the pore-flow model, because it was closer to normal physical experience, was more popular until the mid-1940s. However, during the 1940s, the solution-diffusion model was used to explain transport of gases through polymeric films. This use of the solution-diffusion model was relatively uncontroversial, but the transport mechanism in reverse osmosis membranes was a hotly debated issue in the 1960s and early 1970s [1–6]. By 1980, however, the proponents of solution-diffusion had carried the day; currently only a few die-hard pore-flow modelers use this approach to rationalize reverse osmosis. Diffusion, the basis of the solution-diffusion model, is the process by which matter is transported from one part of a system to another by a concentration gradient. The individual molecules in the membrane medium are in constant random molecular motion, but in an isotropic medium, individual molecules have no preferred direction of motion. Although the average displacement of an individual molecule from its starting point can be calculated, after a period of time nothing can be said about the direction in which any individual molecule will move. However, if a concentration gradient of permeate molecules is formed in the medium, simple statistics show that a net transport of matter will occur Membrane Technology and Applications R. W. Baker 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 0-470-85445-6
16
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Microporous membranes separate by molecular filtration
AND
APPLICATIONS
Dense solution-diffusion membranes separate because of differences in the solubility and mobility of permeants in the membrane material
Figure 2.1 Molecular transport through membranes can be described by a flow through permanent pores or by the solution-diffusion mechanism
from the high concentration to the low concentration region. For example, when two adjacent volume elements with slightly different permeant concentrations are separated by an interface, then simply because of the difference in the number of molecules in each volume element, more molecules will move from the concentrated side to the less concentrated side of the interface than will move in the other direction. This concept was first recognized by Fick theoretically and experimentally in 1855 [7]. Fick formulated his results as the equation now called Fick’s law of diffusion, which states Ji = −Di
dci dx
(2.1)
where Ji is the rate of transfer of component i or flux (g/cm2 · s) and dci /dx is the concentration gradient of component i. The term Di is called the diffusion coefficient (cm2 /s) and is a measure of the mobility of the individual molecules. The minus sign shows that the direction of diffusion is down the concentration gradient. Diffusion is an inherently slow process. In practical diffusion-controlled separation processes, useful fluxes across the membrane are achieved by making the membranes very thin and creating large concentration gradients in the membrane. Pressure-driven convective flow, the basis of the pore flow model, is most commonly used to describe flow in a capillary or porous medium. The basic equation covering this type of transport is Darcy’s law, which can be written as Ji = K ci
dp dx
(2.2)
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
17
where dp/dx is the pressure gradient existing in the porous medium, ci is the concentration of component i in the medium and K is a coefficient reflecting the nature of the medium. In general, convective-pressure-driven membrane fluxes are high compared with those obtained by simple diffusion. The difference between the solution-diffusion and pore-flow mechanisms lies in the relative size and permanence of the pores. For membranes in which transport is best described by the solution-diffusion model and Fick’s law, the free-volume elements (pores) in the membrane are tiny spaces between polymer chains caused by thermal motion of the polymer molecules. These volume elements appear and disappear on about the same timescale as the motions of the permeants traversing the membrane. On the other hand, for a membrane in which transport is best described by a pore-flow model and Darcy’s law, the free-volume elements (pores) are relatively large and fixed, do not fluctuate in position or volume on the timescale of permeant motion, and are connected to one another. The larger the individual free volume elements (pores), the more likely they are to be present long enough to produce pore-flow characteristics in the membrane. As a rough rule of thumb, the transition between transient (solution-diffusion) and permanent ˚ diameter. (pore-flow) pores is in the range 5–10 A The average pore diameter in a membrane is difficult to measure directly and must often be inferred from the size of the molecules that permeate the membrane or by some other indirect technique. With this caveat in mind membranes can be organized into the three general groups shown in Figure 2.2: • Ultrafiltration, microfiltration and microporous Knudsen-flow gas separation membranes are all clearly microporous, and transport occurs by pore flow. • Reverse osmosis, pervaporation and polymeric gas separation membranes have a dense polymer layer with no visible pores, in which the separation occurs. These membranes show different transport rates for molecules as small as ˚ in diameter. The fluxes of permeants through these membranes are 2–5 A also much lower than through the microporous membranes. Transport is best described by the solution-diffusion model. The spaces between the polymer ˚ in diameter and so are within chains in these membranes are less than 5 A the normal range of thermal motion of the polymer chains that make up the membrane matrix. Molecules permeate the membrane through free volume elements between the polymer chains that are transient on the timescale of the diffusion processes occurring. ˚ • Membranes in the third group contain pores with diameters between 5 A ˚ and are intermediate between truly microporous and truly solutionand 10 A diffusion membranes. For example, nanofiltration membranes are intermediate between ultrafiltration membranes and reverse osmosis membranes. These membranes have high rejections for the di- and trisaccharides sucrose and raffi˚ but freely pass the monosaccharide nose with molecular diameters of 10–13 A, ˚ fructose with a molecular diameter of about 5–6 A.
18
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Microfiltration
Nominal pore diameter (Å)
1 000
Microporous Knudsen flow membranes
100
Ultrafiltration Pore-flow microporous membranes
10
Finely microporous Intermediate pore-flow ceramic/carbon solution-diffusion membranes membranes
Nanofiltration
Reverse osmosis
Pervaporation
Gas separation with polymer films
Homogeneous dense membranes solution-diffusion
1 Liquid permeation
Gas permeation
Figure 2.2 Schematic representation of the nominal pore size and best theoretical model for the principal membrane separation processes
In this chapter, permeation through dense nonporous membranes is covered first; this includes permeation in reverse osmosis, pervaporation, and gas separation membranes. Transport occurs by molecular diffusion and is described by the solution-diffusion model. The predictions of this model are in good agreement with experimental data, and a number of simple equations that usefully rationalize the properties of these membranes result. In the second part of the chapter, transport in microporous ultrafiltration and microfiltration membranes is covered more briefly. Transport through these membranes occurs by convective flow with some form of sieving mechanism producing the separation. However, the ability of theory to rationalize transport in these membranes is poor. A number of factors concurrently affect permeation, so a simple quantitative description of the process is not possible. Finally, a brief discussion of membranes that fall into the ‘intermediate’ category is given.
Solution-diffusion Model Molecular Dynamics Simulations The solution-diffusion model applies to reverse osmosis, pervaporation and gas permeation in polymer films. At first glance these processes appear to be very
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
19
different. Reverse osmosis uses a large pressure difference across the membrane to separate water from salt solutions. In pervaporation, the pressure difference across the membrane is small, and the process is driven by the vapor pressure difference between the feed liquid and the low partial pressure of the permeate vapor. Gas permeation involves transport of gases down a pressure or concentration gradient. However, all three processes involve diffusion of molecules in a dense polymer. The pressure, temperature, and composition of the fluids on either side of the membrane determine the concentration of the diffusing species at the membrane surface in equilibrium with the fluid. Once dissolved in the membrane, individual permeating molecules move by the same random process of molecular diffusion no matter whether the membrane is being used in reverse osmosis, pervaporation, or gas permeation. Often, similar membranes are used in very different processes. For example, cellulose acetate membranes were developed for desalination of water by reverse osmosis, but essentially identical membranes have been used in pervaporation to dehydrate alcohol and are widely used in gas permeation to separate carbon dioxide from natural gas. Similarly, silicone rubber membranes are too hydrophobic to be useful in reverse osmosis but are used to separate volatile organics from water by pervaporation and organic vapors from air in gas permeation. The advent of powerful computers has allowed the statistical fluctuations in the volumes between polymer chains due to thermal motion to be calculated. Figure 2.3 shows the results of a computer molecular dynamics simulation calculation for a small-volume element of a polymer. The change in position of individual polymer molecules in a small-volume element can be calculated at short enough time intervals to represent the normal thermal motion occurring in a polymeric matrix. If a penetrant molecule is placed in one of the small-freevolume microcavities between polymer chains, its motion can also be calculated. The simulated motion of a carbon dioxide molecule in a 6FDA-4PDA polyimide matrix is shown in Figure 2.3 [8]. During the first 100 ps of the simulation, the carbon dioxide molecule bounces around in the cavity where it has been ˚ the diameter of the microcavity. placed, never moving more than about 5 A, After 100 ps, however, a chance thermal motion moves a segment of the polymer chains sufficiently for the carbon dioxide molecule to jump approximately ˚ to an adjacent cavity where it remains until another movement of the poly10 A mer chains allows it to jump to another cavity. By repeating these calculations many times and averaging the distance moved by the gas molecule, its diffusion coefficient can be calculated. An alternative method of representing the movement of an individual molecule by computational techniques is shown in Figure 2.4 [9]. This figure shows the movement of three different permeate molecules over a period of 200 ps in a silicone rubber polymer matrix. The smaller helium molecule moves more frequently and makes larger jumps than the larger methane molecule. Helium, with ˚ has many more opportunities to move from one a molecular diameter of 2.55 A,
20
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Cavity size
Jump length l 25
From Smit et al. (1992) Jump
20
Position (Å)
Movement in cavity 15
Movement in cavity
10 Jump length Cavity size
5
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
Simulation time (picoseconds)
Figure 2.3 Motion of a carbon dioxide molecule in a 6FDA-4PDA polymer matrix [8]. Reprinted from J. Membr. Sci. 73, E. Smit, M.H.V. Mulder, C.A. Smolders, H. Karrenbeld, J. van Eerden and D. Feil, Modeling of the Diffusion of Carbon Dioxide in Polyimide Matrices by Computer Simulation, p. 247, Copyright 1992, with permission from Elsevier
˚ Oxygen, position to another than methane, with a molecular diameter of 3.76 A. ˚ has intermediate mobility. The effect of with a molecular diameter of 3.47 A, polymer structure on diffusion can be seen by comparing the distance moved by the gas molecules in the same 200-ps period in Figures 2.3 and 2.4. Figure 2.3 simulates diffusion in a glassy rigid-backbone polyimide. In 200 ps, the permeate molecule has made only one large jump. Figure 2.4 simulates diffusion in silicone rubber, a material with a very flexible polymer backbone. In 200 ps, all the permeants in silicone rubber have made a number of large jumps from one microcavity to another. Molecular dynamics simulations also allow the transition from the solutiondiffusion to the pore-flow transport mechanism to be seen. As the microcavities become larger, the transport mechanism changes from the diffusion process
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
21
From Charati and Stern (1998)
Helium
Methane
Oxygen
20 Å
Figure 2.4 Simulated trajectories of helium, oxygen and methane molecules during a 200-ps time period in a poly(dimethylsiloxane) matrix [9]. Reprinted with permission from S.G. Charati and S.A. Stern, Diffusion of Gases in Silicone Polymers: Molecular Dynamic Simulations, Macromolecules 31, 5529. Copyright 1998, American Chemical Society
simulated in Figures 2.3 and 2.4 to a pore-flow mechanism. Permanent pores ˚ in diameter. form when the microcavities are larger than about 10 A However, molecular dynamics calculations are at an early stage of development. Current estimates of diffusion coefficients from these simulations are generally far from matching the experimental values, and enormous computing power and a better understanding of the interactions between the molecules of polymer chains will be required to produce accurate predictions. Nonetheless, the technique demonstrates the qualitative basis of the solution-diffusion model in a very graphic way. Currently, the best quantitative description of permeation uses phenomenological equations, particularly Fick’s law. This description is given in the section that follows, which outlines the mathematical basis of the solution-diffusion model. Much of this section is adapted from a 1995 Journal of Membrane Science article written with my colleague, Hans Wijmans [10].
Concentration and Pressure Gradients in Membranes The starting point for the mathematical description of diffusion in membranes is the proposition, solidly based in thermodynamics, that the driving forces of pressure, temperature, concentration, and electrical potential are interrelated and that the overall driving force producing movement of a permeant is the gradient in its chemical potential. Thus, the flux, Ji (g/cm2 · s), of a component, i, is
22
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
described by the simple equation Ji = −Li
dµi dx
(2.3)
where dµi /dx is the chemical potential gradient of component i and Li is a coefficient of proportionality (not necessarily constant) linking this chemical potential driving force to flux. Driving forces, such as gradients in concentration, pressure, temperature, and electrical potential can be expressed as chemical potential gradients, and their effect on flux expressed by this equation. This approach is extremely useful, because many processes involve more than one driving force, for example, both pressure and concentration in reverse osmosis. Restricting the approach to driving forces generated by concentration and pressure gradients, the chemical potential is written as dµi = RT d ln(γi ni ) + υi dp
(2.4)
where ni is the mole fraction (mol/mol) of component i, γi is the activity coefficient (mol/mol) linking mole fraction with activity, p is the pressure, and υi is the molar volume of component i. In incompressible phases, such as a liquid or a solid membrane, volume does not change with pressure. In this case, integrating Equation (2.4) with respect to concentration and pressure gives µi = µoi + RT ln(γi ni ) + υi (p − pio )
(2.5)
where µoi is the chemical potential of pure i at a reference pressure, pio . In compressible gases, the molar volume changes with pressure. Using the ideal gas laws in integrating Equation (2.4) gives µi = µoi + RT ln(γi ni ) + RT ln
p pio
(2.6)
To ensure that the reference chemical potential µoi is identical in Equations (2.5) and (2.6), the reference pressure pio is defined as the saturation vapor pressure of i, pisat . Equations (2.5) and (2.6) can then be rewritten as µi = µoi + RT ln(γi ni ) + υi (p − pisat )
(2.7)
for incompressible liquids and the membrane phase, and as µi = µoi + RT ln(γi ni ) + RT ln
p pisat
(2.8)
for compressible gases. Several assumptions must be made to define any permeation model. Usually, the first assumption governing transport through membranes is that the fluids on
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
23
either side of the membrane are in equilibrium with the membrane material at the interface. This assumption means that the gradient in chemical potential from one side of the membrane to the other is continuous. Implicit in this assumption is that the rates of absorption and desorption at the membrane interface are much higher than the rate of diffusion through the membrane. This appears to be the case in almost all membrane processes, but may fail in transport processes involving chemical reactions, such as facilitated transport, or in diffusion of gases through metals, where interfacial absorption can be slow. The second assumption concerns the pressure and concentration gradients in the membrane. The solution-diffusion model assumes that when pressure is applied across a dense membrane, the pressure throughout the membrane is constant at the highest value. This assumes, in effect, that solution-diffusion membranes transmit pressure in the same way as liquids. Consequently, the solution-diffusion model assumes that the pressure within a membrane is uniform and that the chemical potential gradient across the membrane is expressed only as a concentration gradient [5,10]. The consequences of these two assumptions are illustrated in Figure 2.5, which shows pressure-driven permeation of a one-component solution through a membrane by the solution-diffusion mechanism. In the solution-diffusion model, the pressure within the membrane is constant at the high-pressure value (po ), and the gradient in chemical potential across the membrane is expressed as a smooth gradient in solvent activity (γi ni ). The flow that occurs down this gradient is expressed by Equation (2.3), but because no pressure gradient exists within the membrane, Equation (2.3) can be rewritten by combining Equations (2.3) and (2.4). Assuming γi is constant, this gives Ji = −
RT Li dni · ni dx
(2.9)
Solution-diffusion model High-pressure solution
Membrane
Low-pressure solution
Chemical potential mi Pressure p
Solvent activity gi ni
Figure 2.5 Pressure driven permeation of a one-component solution through a membrane according to the solution-diffusion transport model
24
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
In Equation (2.9), the gradient of component i across the membrane is expressed as a gradient in mole fraction of component i. Using the more practical term concentration ci (g/cm3 ) defined as ci = mi ρni
(2.10)
where mi is the molecular weight of i (g/mol) and ρ is the molar density (mol/cm3 ), Equation (2.9) can be written as Ji = −
RTLi dci · ci dx
(2.11)
Equation (2.11) has the same form as Fick’s law in which the term RT Li /ci can be replaced by the diffusion coefficient Di . Thus, Ji = −Di
dci dx
(2.12)
Integrating over the thickness of the membrane then gives1 Ji =
Di (cio(m) − ci(m) )
(2.13)
By using osmosis as an example, concentration and pressure gradients according to the solution-diffusion model can be discussed in a somewhat more complex situation. The activity, pressure, and chemical potential gradients within this type of membrane are illustrated in Figure 2.6. Figure 2.6(a) shows a semipermeable membrane separating a salt solution from the pure solvent. The pressure is the same on both sides of the membrane. For simplicity, the gradient of salt (component j ) is not shown in this figure, but the membrane is assumed to be very selective, so the concentration of salt within the membrane is small. The difference in concentration across the membrane results in a continuous, smooth gradient in the chemical potential of the water (component i) across the membrane, from µi on the water side to µio on the salt side. The pressure within and across the membrane is constant (that is, po = pm = p ) and the solvent activity gradient (γi(m) ni(m) ) falls continuously from the pure water (solvent) side to the saline (solution) side of the membrane. Consequently, water passes across the membrane from right to left. Figure 2.6(b) shows the situation at the point of osmotic equilibrium, when sufficient pressure has been applied to the saline side of the membrane to bring the flow across the membrane to zero. As shown in Figure 2.6(b), the pressure 1
In the equations that follow, the terms i and j represent components of a solution, and the terms o and represent the positions of the feed and permeate interfaces, respectively, of the membrane. Thus the term cio represents the concentration of component i in the fluid (gas or liquid) in contact with the membrane at the feed interface. The subscript m is used to represent the membrane phase. Thus, cio(m) is the concentration of component i in the membrane at the feed interface (point o).
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
25
Dense solution-diffusion membrane Salt solution
Membrane
Water
(a) Osmosis
Chemical potential mi Pressure p Solvent activity gi ni
(b) Osmotic equilibrium mi
p
∆p = ∆p
gi ni
∆(gi ni ) =
ui ∆p RT
(c) Reverse osmosis mi
p
gi ni
o
Figure 2.6 Chemical potential, pressure, and solvent activity profiles through an osmotic membrane following the solution-diffusion model. The pressure in the membrane is uniform and equal to the high-pressure value, so the chemical potential gradient within the membrane is expressed as a concentration gradient
within the membrane is assumed to be constant at the high-pressure value (po ). There is a discontinuity in pressure at the permeate side of the membrane, where the pressure falls abruptly from po to p , the pressure on the solvent side of the membrane. This pressure difference (po − p ) can be expressed in terms of the chemical potential difference between the feed and permeate solutions.
26
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
The membrane in contact with the permeate-side solution is in equilibrium with this solution. Thus, Equation (2.7) can be used to link the two phases in terms of their chemical potentials, that is µi(m) = µi
(2.14)
RT ln(γi(m) ni(m) ) + υi po = RT ln(γi ni ) + υi p
(2.15)
and so On rearranging, this gives RT ln(γi(m) ni(m) ) − RT ln(γi ni ) = −υi (po − p )
(2.16)
At osmotic equilibrium (γi ni ) can also be defined by (γi ni ) = γi ni − γi(m) ni(m)
(2.17)
and, since γi ni ≈ 1, it follows, on substituting Equation (2.17) into (2.16), that RT ln[1 − (γi ni )] = −υi (po − p )
(2.18)
Since (γi ni ) is small, ln[1 − (γi ni )] ≈ (γi ni ), and Equation (2.18) reduces to (γi ni ) =
−υi π −υi (po − p ) = RT RT
(2.19)
Thus, the pressure difference, (po − p ) = π, across the membrane balances the solvent activity difference (γi ni ) across the membrane, and the flow is zero. If a pressure higher than the osmotic pressure is applied to the feed side of the membrane, as shown in Figure 2.6(c), then the solvent activity difference across the membrane increases further, resulting in a flow from left to right. This is the process of reverse osmosis. The important conclusion illustrated by Figures 2.5 and 2.6 is that, although the fluids on either side of a membrane may be at different pressures and concentrations, within a perfect solution-diffusion membrane, there is no pressure gradient—only a concentration gradient. Flow through this type of membrane is expressed by Fick’s law, Equation (2.13). Application of the Solution-diffusion Model to Specific Processes In this section the solution-diffusion model is used to describe transport in dialysis, reverse osmosis, gas permeation and pervaporation membranes. The resulting equations, linking the driving forces of pressure and concentration with flow, are then shown to be consistent with experimental observations. The general approach is to use the first assumption of the solution-diffusion model, namely, that the chemical potential of the feed and permeate fluids are
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
27
in equilibrium with the adjacent membrane surfaces. From this assumption, the chemical potential in the fluid and membrane phases can be equated using the appropriate expressions for chemical potential given in Equations (2.7) and (2.8). By rearranging these equations, the concentrations of the different species in the membrane at the fluids interface (cio(m) and ci(m) ) can be obtained in terms of the pressure and composition of the feed and permeate fluids. These values for cio(m) and ci(m) can then be substituted into the Fick’s law expression, Equation (2.13), to give the transport equation for the particular process. Dialysis Dialysis is the simplest application of the solution-diffusion model because only concentration gradients are involved. In dialysis, a membrane separates two solutions of different compositions. The concentration gradient across the membrane causes a flow of solute and solvent from one side of the membrane to the other. Following the general procedure described above, equating the chemical potentials in the solution and membrane phase at the feed-side interface of the membrane gives (2.20) µio = µio(m) Substituting the expression for the chemical potential of incompressible fluids from Equation (2.7) gives µoi + RT ln(γiLo nio ) + υi (po − pisat ) = µoi + RT ln(γio(m) nio(m) ) + υio(m) (po − pisat ) (2.21) which leads to2 ln(γiLo nio ) = ln(γio(m) nio(m) ) (2.22) and thus nio(m) = or from Equation (2.10) cio(m) =
γiLo γio(m)
· nio
γio ρm · c io γio(m) ρo
(2.23)
(2.24)
Hence, defining a sorption coefficient KiL as γio ρm γio(m) ρo
(2.25)
cio(m) = KiL · cio
(2.26)
KiL = Equation (2.24) becomes
2 The superscripts G and L are used here and later to distinguish between gas phase and liquid phase activity coefficients, sorption coefficients and permeability coefficients.
28
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
From Theeuwes et al. (1978) (a)
2.5 Water
2.0 Progesterone flux x membrane thickness, Ji • [10−11 × (g • cm/cm2 • s)]
Saturated solution
1.5 1.0 0.5 0
0 4 8 10 12 14 2 6 Progesterone concentration, ∆c (µg/ml) (b)
2.5 Dow 360
2.0 Progesterone flux x membrane thickness, Ji • [10−11 × (g • cm/cm2 • s)]
Saturated solution
1.5 1.0 0.5 0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 Progesterone concentration, ∆c (µg/ml) (c)
2.5 PEG 600
2.0 Progesterone flux x membrane thickness, Ji • [10−11 × (g • cm/cm2 • s)]
Saturated solution
1.5 1.0 0.5 0
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 Progesterone concentration, ∆c (µg/ml) (d)
1.50 Saturated solution
1.25 Progesterone flux x membrane thickness, Ji • [10-11 x (g • cm/cm2 • s)]
1.00 0.75 0.50 Water Silicone oil (Dow 360) Poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG 600)
0.25 0 0
0.2
0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 Fractional progesterone saturation, ∆c /c sat
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
29
On the permeate side of the membrane, the same procedure can be followed, leading to an equivalent expression ci(m) = KiL · ci
(2.27)
The concentrations of permeant within the membrane phase at the two interfaces can then be substituted from Equations (2.26) and (2.27) into the Fick’s law expression, Equation (2.13), to give the familiar expression describing permeation through dialysis membranes: Ji =
Di KiL PL (cio − ci ) = i (cio − ci )
(2.28)
The product Di KiL is normally referred to as the permeability coefficient, PiL . For many systems, Di , KiL , and thus PiL are concentration dependent. Thus, Equation (2.28) implies the use of values for Di , KiL , and PiL that are averaged over the membrane thickness. The permeability coefficient PiL is often treated as a pure materials constant, depending only on the permeant and the membrane material, but in fact the nature of the solvent used in the liquid phase is also important. From Equations (2.28) and (2.25), PiL can be written as PiL = Di · γiL /γi(m) ·
ρm ρo
(2.29)
The presence of the term γiL makes the permeability coefficient a function of the solvent used as the liquid phase. Some experimental data illustrating this effect are shown in Figure 2.7 [11], which is a plot of the product of the progesterone flux and the membrane thickness, Ji against the concentration difference across the membrane, (cio − ci ). From Equation (2.28), the slope of this line is the permeability, PiL . Three sets of dialysis permeation experiments are reported, in which the solvent used to dissolve the progesterone is water, silicone oil and poly(ethylene glycol) MW 600 (PEG 600), respectively. The permeability calculated from these plots varies from 9.5 × 10−7 cm2 /s for water to 6.5 × 10−10 cm2 /s for PEG 600. This difference reflects the activity term γiL in Equation (2.28). However, when the driving force across the membrane is Figure 2.7 Permeation of progesterone through polyethylene vinyl acetate films. The thickness-normalized progesterone flux (Ji · ) is plotted against the progesterone concentration across the membrane, c [11]. The solvents for the progesterone are (a) water, (b) silicone oil and (c) poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG 600). Because of the different solubilities of progesterone in these solvents, the permeabilities calculated from these data through Equation (2.28) vary 1000-fold. All the data can be rationalized onto a single curve by plotting the thickness-normalized flux against fractional progesterone saturation as described in the text and shown in (d). The slope of this line, PiL csat or Di mi ρm /γi(m) is a materials property dependent only on the membrane material and the permeant and independent of the solvent
30
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
represented not as a difference in concentration but as a difference in fractional saturation between the feed and permeate solution, all the data fall on a single line as shown in Figure 2.7(d). The slope of this line is the term PiL csat . This result is also in agreement with Equation (2.29), which when combined with the approximation that, for dilute solutions, the activity of component i can be written as 1 mi ρ o = (2.30) γiL = nisat cisat yields PiL cisat =
Di mi ρm γi(m)
(2.31)
The terms Di mi ρm /γi(m) and, therefore, PiL csat are determined solely by the permeant and the membrane material and are thus independent of the liquid phase surrounding the membrane. Reverse Osmosis Reverse osmosis and normal osmosis (dialysis) are directly related processes. In simple terms, if a selective membrane (i.e., a membrane freely permeable to water, but much less permeable to salt) separates a salt solution from pure water, water will pass through the membrane from the pure water side of the membrane into the side less concentrated in water (salt side) as shown in Figure 2.8. This process is called normal osmosis. If a hydrostatic pressure is applied to the salt side of the membrane, the flow of water can be retarded and, when the applied pressure is sufficient, the flow ceases. The hydrostatic pressure required to stop Osmosis
Osmotic equilibrium
Reverse osmosis Osmotic pressure (∆p)
Water
Salt solution
Hydrostatic pressure (∆ p > ∆p)
Semipermeable membrane
Figure 2.8 A schematic illustration of the relationship between osmosis (dialysis), osmotic equilibrium and reverse osmosis
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
31
the water flow is called the osmotic pressure (π). If pressures greater than the osmotic pressure are applied to the salt side of the membrane, then the flow of water is reversed, and water begins to flow from the salt solution to the pure water side of the membrane. This process is called reverse osmosis, which is an important method of producing pure water from salt solutions. Reverse osmosis usually involves two components, water (i) and salt (j ). Following the general procedure, the chemical potentials at both sides of the membrane are first equated. At the feed interface, the pressure in the feed solution and within the membrane are identical (as shown in Figure 2.6c). Equating the chemical potentials at this interface gives the same expression as in dialysis [cf. Equation (2.26)] cio(m) = KiL · cio (2.32) A pressure difference exists at the permeate interface (as shown in Figure 2.6c) from po within the membrane to p in the permeate solution. Equating the chemical potentials across this interface gives µi = µi(m)
(2.33)
Substituting the appropriate expression for the chemical potential of an incompressible fluid to the liquid and membrane phases [Equation (2.7)] yields µoi + RT ln(γiL ni ) + υi (p − pisat ) = µoi + RT ln(γi(m) ni(m) ) + υi (po − pisat ) (2.34) which leads to υi (po − p ) ln(γiL ni ) = ln(γiL(m) ni(m) ) + (2.35) RT Rearranging and substituting for the sorption coefficient, KiL [Equations (2.10) and (2.25)], gives the expression −υi (po − p ) ci(m) = KiL · ci · exp (2.36) RT The expressions for the concentrations within the membrane at the interface in Equations (2.32) and (2.36) can now be substituted into the Fick’s law expression, Equation (2.13), to yield Di KiL −υi (po − p ) Ji = cio − ci exp (2.37) RT Equation (2.37) and the equivalent expression for component j give the water flux and the salt flux across the reverse osmosis membrane in terms of the pressure and concentration difference across the membrane. There is an analytical expression for Equation (2.37) for a two-component feed mixture that allows the performance of the membrane to be calculated for known permeabilities, Di KiL / and Dj KjL /, and feed concentrations, cio and cjo . However, more commonly
32
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Equation (2.37) is simplified by assuming that the membrane selectivity is high, that is, Di KiL / Dj KjL /. This is a good assumption for most of the reverse osmosis membranes used to separate salts from water. Consider the water flux first. At the point at which the applied hydrostatic pressure balances the water activity gradient, that is, the point of osmotic equilibrium in Figure 2.6(b), the flux of water across the membrane is zero. Equation (2.37) becomes Di KiL −υi (π) Ji = 0 = cio − ci exp (2.38) RT and, on rearranging
υi (π) ci = cio exp RT
(2.39)
At hydrostatic pressures higher than π, Equations (2.37) and (2.39) can be combined to yield Di KiL cio −υi [(po − p ) − π] 1 − exp (2.40) Ji = RT or
Di KiL cio Ji =
−υi (p − π) 1 − exp RT
(2.41)
where p is the difference in hydrostatic pressure across the membrane (po − p ). A trial calculation shows that the term −υi (p − π)/RT is small under the normal conditions of reverse osmosis. For example, in water desalination, when p = 100 atm, π = 10 atm, and υi = 18 cm3 /mol, the term υi (p − π)/RT is about 0.06. Under these conditions, the simplification 1 − exp(x) → x as x → 0 can be used, and Equation (2.41) can be written to a very good approximation as Ji =
Di KiL cio υi (p − π) RT
(2.42)
This equation can be simplified to Ji = A(p − π)
(2.43)
where A is a constant equal to the term Di KiL cio υi /RT . In the reverse osmosis literature, the constant A is usually called the water permeability constant. Similarly, a simplified expression for the salt flux, Jj , through the membrane can be derived, starting with the equivalent to Equation (2.37) Dj KjL −υj (po − p ) Jj = cjo − cj exp (2.44) RT
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
33
Because the term −υj (po − p )/RT is small, the exponential term in Equation (2.44) is close to one, and Equation (2.44) can then be written as Jj =
Dj KjL
(cjo − cj )
(2.45)
or Jj = B(cjo − cj )
(2.46)
where B is usually called the salt permeability constant and has the value B=
Dj KjL
(2.47)
Predictions of salt and water transport can be made from this application of the solution-diffusion model to reverse osmosis (first derived by Merten and coworkers) [12,13]. According to Equation (2.43), the water flux through a reverse osmosis membrane remains small up to the osmotic pressure of the salt solution and then increases with applied pressure, whereas according to Equation (2.46), the salt flux is essentially independent of pressure. Some typical results are shown in Figure 2.9. Also shown in this figure is a term called the rejection coefficient, R, which is defined as cj R= 1− × 100 % (2.48) cjo The rejection coefficient is a measure of the ability of the membrane to separate salt from the feed solution. For a perfectly selective membrane the permeate salt concentration, cj = 0 and R = 100 %, and for a completely unselective membrane the permeate salt concentration is the same as the feed salt concentration, cj = cjo and R = 0 %. The rejection coefficient increases with applied pressure as shown in Figure 2.9, because the water flux increases with pressure, but the salt flux does not.
Hyperfiltration By convention, the term reverse osmosis is used to describe the separation of an aqueous salt solution by pressure-driven flow through a semipermeable membrane. Recently, the same type of process has been applied to the separation of organic mixtures. For example, Mobil Oil has installed a large plant to separate methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) from MEK–oil mixtures created in the production of lubricating oil [14] as described in Chapter 5. Separation of this type of mixture is probably best called hyperfiltration.
34
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
30 From Wijmans and Baker (1995)
Water flux
20 15
5 4
10
3
5
Salt flux
Osmotic pressure ∆p
2 1
Salt flux (g/m2•h)
Water flux (L/m2•h)
25
0
0 100
Salt rejection (%)
80
60
40
20
0
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Applied pressure (psig)
Figure 2.9 Flux and rejection data for a model seawater solution (3.5 % sodium chloride) in a good quality reverse osmosis membrane (FilmTec Corp. FT 30 membrane) as a function of pressure [10]. The salt flux, in accordance with Equation (2.44), is essentially constant and independent of pressure. The water flux, in accordance with Equation (2.43), increases with pressure, and, at zero flux, meets the pressure axis at the osmotic pressure of seawater ∼350 psi
The mathematical description of this process is identical to that of reverse osmosis given in Equations (2.37) and (2.44) and leads to expressions for the solute and solvent fluxes Di KiL −υi (po − p ) Ji = cio − ci exp (2.49) RT
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY and Jj =
Dj KjL
35
cjo − cj exp
−υj (po − p ) RT
(2.50)
With the advent of the personal computer, the numerical solution to these equations is straightforward even for multicomponent mixtures. Figure 2.10 shows an example calculation for the separation of a 20 wt% solution of ndecane in MEK. In these calculations, the ratio of the permeabilities of MEK
MEK flux
15
10
0.5 0.4
n -Decane flux
5
0.3 0.2 0.1
0 0
500
0
500
1000
1500
0 2000
n -Decane flux (kg/m2•h)
MEK flux (kg/m2•h)
20
n -Decane rejection (%)
100
80
60
40
20
0 1000 1500 Applied pressure (psig)
2000
Figure 2.10 Flux and rejection curves calculated using Equations (2.49) and (2.50) for a 20 wt % n-decane solution in methyl ethyl ketone (MEK). MEK is assumed to be 10 times more permeable than n-decane
36
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
and n-decane, Di Ki /Dj Kj , is set at 10. The curves have essentially the same form as the salt solution flux data in Figure 2.9. At high pressures, the rejection approaches a limiting value of 90 %, and the limiting Equations (2.43) for the solvent (MEK) flux and (2.47) for the solute flux apply. Gas Separation In gas separation, a gas mixture at a pressure po is applied to the feed side of the membrane, while the permeate gas at a lower pressure (p ) is removed from the downstream side of the membrane. As before, the starting point for the derivation of the gas separation transport equation is to equate the chemical potentials on either side of the gas/membrane interface. This time, however, the chemical potential for the gas phase is given by Equation (2.8) for a compressible fluid, whereas Equation (2.7) for an incompressible medium is applied to the membrane phase. Substitution of these equations into Equation (2.20) at the gas/membrane feed interface yields3 µoi + RT ln(γiGo nio ) + RT ln
po = µoi + RT ln(γio(m) nio(m) ) + υi (po − pisat ) pisat (2.51)
which rearranges to nio(m) =
γiGo γio(m)
−υi (po − pisat ) po · · nio exp pisat RT
(2.52)
Because the exponential term is again very close to one,4 even for very high pressures (po ), Equation (2.52) reduces to nio(m) =
γiGo nio γio(m)
·
po pisat
(2.53)
The term nio po is the partial pressure of i in the feed gas, pio . Equation (2.53) then simplifies to γiG pi (2.54) nio(m) = (o) · o γio(m) pisat or cio(m) = mi ρm
γiGo pio γio(m) pisat
(2.55)
3 At this point the superscript G is introduced to denote the gas phase. For example γiG , the activity of component i in the gas phase, and KiG , the sorption coefficient of component i between the gas and membrane phases [Equation (2.56)]. 4 In evaluating this exponential term (the Poynting correction), it is important to recognize that υi is not the molar volume of i in the gas phase, but the molar volume of i dissolved in the membrane material, which is approximately equal to the molar volume of liquid i.
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
37
By defining a gas phase sorption coefficient KiG as KiG =
mi ρm γiGo γio(m) pisat
(2.56)
the concentration of component i at the feed interface of the membrane can be written as (2.57) cio(m) = KiG · pio In exactly the same way, the concentration of component i at the membrane/ permeate interface can be shown to be ci(m) = KiG · pi
(2.58)
Combining Equations (2.57) and (2.58) with the Fick’s law expression, Equation (2.13), gives Di KiG (pio − pi ) Ji = (2.59) The product Di KiG is often abbreviated to a permeability coefficient, PiG , to give the familiar expression P G (pio − pi ) Ji = i (2.60) Equation (2.60) is widely used to accurately and predictably rationalize the properties of gas permeation membranes. The derivation of Equation (2.60) might be seen as a long-winded way of arriving at a trivial result. However, this derivation explicitly clarifies the assumptions behind this equation. First, a gradient in concentration occurs within the membrane, but there is no gradient in pressure. Second, the absorption of a component into the membrane is proportional to its activity (partial pressure) in the adjacent gas, but is independent of the total gas pressure. This is related to the approximation made in Equation (2.52), in which the Poynting correction was assumed to be 1. The permeability coefficient, PiG , equal to the product Di KiG can be expressed from the definition of KiG in Equation (2.56) as PiG =
γiG Di mi ρm γi(m) · pisat
(2.61)
In Equation (2.60) the membrane flux, Ji , is a mass flux (g/cm2 · s), whereas the gas separation literature predominantly uses a molar flux, typically expressed in the units cm3 (STP)/cm2 · s. The molar flux, ji , can be linked to the mass flux, Ji , by the expression υG ji = Ji i (2.62) mi
38
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
where υiG is the molar volume of gas i (cm3 (STP)/mol). Similarly the mass permeability unit PiG , defined in Equation (2.60), can be linked to the molar gas 2 3 permeability PG i , usually in the units cm (STP) · cm/cm · s · cmHg, as PiG υiG mi
(2.63)
PiG (pio − pi )
(2.64)
PiG =
Equation (2.60) can then be written as ji =
and combining Equations (2.61) and (2.63) gives PiG =
γiG Di υiG ρ(m) γi(m) pisat
(2.65)
Equation (2.65) is not commonly used as an expression for gas-phase membrane permeability, but is of interest because it shows that large permeability coefficients are obtained for compounds with a large diffusion coefficient (Di ), a limited affinity for the gas phase (large γiG ), a high affinity for the membrane material (small γi(m) ), and a low saturation vapor pressure (pisat ). The molar gas permeation permeability (PiG ) is close to being a materials constant, relatively independent of the composition and pressure of the feed and permeate gases. This is in sharp contrast to the permeability constant for liquids as described in the discussion centered on Figure 2.7 earlier, but, even for gases, the concept of permeability as a materials constant must be treated with caution. For example, the permeability of vapors at partial pressures close to saturation often increases substantially with increasing partial pressure. This effect is commonly ascribed to plasticization and other effects of the permeant on the membrane, changing Di and γi(m) in Equation (2.65). However, significant deviations of the vapor’s activity coefficient, γiG , from ideality can also occur at high partial pressures. Equation (2.65) is also a useful way to rationalize the effect of molecular weight on permeability. The permeant’s saturation vapor pressure (pisat ) and diffusion coefficient both decrease with increasing molecular weight, creating competing effects on the permeability coefficient. In glassy polymers, the decrease in diffusion coefficient far outweighs other effects, and permeabilities fall significantly as molecular weight increases [15]. In rubbery polymers, on the other hand, the two effects are more balanced. For molecular weights up to 100, permeability generally increases with increasing molecular weight because pisat is the dominant term. Above molecular weight 100, the molecular weight term gradually becomes dominant, and permeabilities fall with increasing molecular weight of the permeant. Some data illustrating this behavior for permeation of simple alkanes in silicone rubber membranes are shown in Figure 2.11. As the molecular weight increases from CH4 to C5 H12 , the effect of the decrease in pisat
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY From Wijmans and Baker (1995) C5H12
C6H14
i
Permeability,
C4H10
C8H18
10 000
G
(Barrer)
100 000
39
C3H8 C2H6
C10H22
CH4
1000 Increasing diffusion coefficient Increasing molecular weight 100 0.001
0.01
0.1 1 10 Permeant saturation vapor pressure, pi (atm)
100
1000
sat
Figure 2.11 Permeability coefficient, PiG , of n-alkanes in poly(dimethylsiloxane) as a function of saturation pressure (pisat )
is larger than the effect of increasing size or Di . Above pentane, however, the trend is reversed. Pervaporation Pervaporation is a separation process in which a multicomponent liquid is passed across a membrane that preferentially permeates one or more of the components. A partial vacuum is maintained on the permeate side of the membrane, so that the permeating components are removed as a vapor mixture. Transport through the membrane is induced by maintaining the vapor pressure of the gas on the permeate side of the membrane at a lower vapor pressure than the feed liquid. The gradients in chemical potential, pressure, and activity across the membrane are illustrated in Figure 2.12. At the liquid solution/membrane feed interface, the chemical potential of the feed liquid is equilibrated with the chemical potential in the membrane at the same pressure. Equation (2.7) then gives µoi + RT ln(γiLo nio ) + υi (po − pisat ) = µoi + RT ln(γio(m) nio(m) ) + υi (po − pisat ) (2.66) which leads to an expression for the concentration at the feed side interface cio(m) =
γiLo ρm γio(m) ρo
· cio = KiL · cio
(2.67)
40
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY Feed solution
Membrane
AND
APPLICATIONS
Permeate vapor
mi mj
p g i ni g j nj
Figure 2.12 Chemical potential, pressure, and activity profiles through a pervaporation membrane following the solution-diffusion model
where KiL is the liquid-phase sorption coefficient defined in Equation (2.26) in the dialysis section. At the permeate gas/membrane interface, the pressure drops from po in the membrane to p in the permeate vapor. The equivalent expression for the chemical potentials in each phase is then p o G = µoi + RT ln(γi(m) ni ) + υi (po − pisat ) µi + RT ln(γi ni ) + RT ln pisat (2.68) Rearranging Equation (2.68) gives γiG −υi (po − pisat ) p ni(m) = · · ni · exp (2.69) γi(m) pisat RT As before, the exponential term is close to unity; thus, the concentration at the permeate side interface is ni(m) =
γiG γi(m)
· ni ·
p pisat
(2.70)
The product ni p can be replaced by the partial pressure term pi , thus ni(m) =
γiG γi(m)
·
pi pisat
(2.71)
or, substituting concentration for mole fraction from Equation (2.10), ci(m) = mi ρm ·
γiG pi γi(m) pisat
= KiG pi
(2.72)
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
41
where KiG is the gas-phase sorption coefficient defined in Equation (2.56) in the gas separation section. The concentration terms in Equations (2.67) and (2.72) can be substituted into Equation (2.13) (Fick’s law) to obtain an expression for the membrane flux. Ji =
Di (KiL cio − KiG pi )
(2.73)
However, the sorption coefficient in Equation (2.67) is a liquid-phase coefficient, whereas the sorption coefficient in Equation (2.72) is a gas-phase coefficient. The interconversion of these two coefficients can be handled by considering a hypothetical vapor in equilibrium with a feed solution. This vapor–liquid equilibrium can then be written p o L L o G G µi + RT ln(γi ni ) + υi (p − pisat ) = µi + RT ln(γi ni ) + RT ln pisat (2.74) where the superscripts L and G represent the liquid and the gas phases. By following the same steps as were taken from Equation (2.68) to (2.72), Equation (2.74) becomes γ G pi nLi = Li (2.75) γi pisat Substituting for concentration with Equation (2.10) gives ciL = mi ρ and so ciL =
γiG pi γiL pisat
KiG · pi KiL
(2.76)
(2.77)
This expression links the concentration of component i in the liquid phase, ciL with pi , the partial vapor pressure of i in equilibrium with the liquid. Substitution of Equation (2.77) into Equation (2.73) yields Ji =
Di KiG (pio − pi )
(2.78)
where pio and pi are the partial vapor pressures of component i on either side of the membrane. Equation (2.67) can also be written as Ji =
PiG (pio − pi )
(2.79)
This equation explicitly expresses the driving force in pervaporation as the vapor pressure difference across the membrane, a form of the pervaporation process
42
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
derived first by Kataoka et al. [16]. Equation (2.77) links the concentration of a sorbed vapor in the liquid phase (ciLo ) with the equilibrium partial pressure of the vapor. This is known as Henry’s law and is usually written as5 Hi · ciL = pi
(2.80)
From Equations (2.77) and (2.80) it follows that the Henry’s law coefficient, Hi , can be written as KL γ L pi Hi = iG = i satG (2.81) Ki mi ργi These expressions can be used to write Equation (2.73) as Ji =
PiG (cio Hi − pi )
(2.82)
Ji =
PiL (cio − pi /Hi )
(2.83)
or
Equation (2.79) expresses the driving force in pervaporation in terms of the vapor pressure. The driving force could equally well have been expressed in terms of concentration differences, as in Equation (2.83). However, in practice, the vapor pressure expression provides much more useful results and clearly shows the connection between pervaporation and gas separation, Equation (2.60). Also, PiG , the gas phase coefficient, is much less dependent on temperature than PiL . The reliability of Equation (2.79) has been amply demonstrated experimentally [17,18]. Figure 2.13, for example, shows data for the pervaporation of water as a function of permeate pressure. As the permeate pressure (pi ) increases, the water flux falls, reaching zero flux when the permeate pressure is equal to the feedliquid vapor pressure (pisat ) at the temperature of the experiment. The straight lines in Figure 2.13 indicate that the permeability coefficient (PiG ) of water in silicone rubber is constant, as expected in this and similar systems in which the membrane material is a rubbery polymer and the permeant swells the polymer only moderately. Greenlaw et al. [18] have studied the effect of feed and permeate pressure on pervaporation flux in some detail; some illustrative results are shown in 5 In Equation (2.80), the Henry’s law coefficient Hi has the units atm · cm3 /g. More commonly, Henry’s law is written in terms of mole fraction:
Hi · nLi = pi where Hi has the units atm/mol fraction. Using Equation (2.10), the two coefficients are linked by the expression Hi Hi = mi · pi
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
43
400 From Wijmans and Baker (1993)
60°C
Permeate flux (g/m2•h)
300
200
50°C 100
40°C 6.8
10
15.3
pisat
0 0
5 10 15 Permeate pressure (cmHg)
Figure 2.13 The effect of permeate pressure on the water flux through a silicone rubber pervaporation membrane. The arrows on the lower axis represent the saturation vapor pressures of the feed solution at the temperature of these experiments as predicted by Equation (2.79) [15]
Figure 2.14. As Figure 2.14(a) shows, the dependence of flux on permeate pressure in pervaporation is in accordance with Equation (2.79). The flux decreases with increasing permeate pressure, reaching a minimum value when the permeate pressure equals the saturation vapor pressure of the feed. The curvature of the line in Figure 2.14(a) shows that the permeability coefficient decreases with G decreasing permeate pressure, that is, Phexane decreases as hexane concentration in the membrane decreases. This behavior is typical of membranes that are swollen significantly by the permeant. If, on the other hand, as shown in Figure 2.14(b), the permeate pressure is fixed at a low value, the hydrostatic pressure of the feed liquid can be increased to as much as 20 atm without any significant change in the flux. This is because increased hydrostatic pressure produces a minimal change in the partial pressure of the feed liquid partial pressure (pio ), the true
44
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
(a)
AND
APPLICATIONS
(b)
From Greenlaw et al. (1977)
Hexane flux (kg/m2• h)
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0 0
Saturation vapor pressure of hexane
5 10 15 20 Permeate pressure (cmHg)
25
0
5
10 15 20 Feed pressure (atm)
25
Figure 2.14 The effect of feed and permeate pressure on the flux of hexane through a rubbery pervaporation membrane. The flux is essentially independent of feed pressure up to 20 atm but is extremely sensitive to permeate pressure [18]. The explanation for this behavior is in the transport equation (2.79). Reprinted from J. Membr. Sci. 2, F.W. Greenlaw, W.D. Prince, R.A. Shelden and E.V. Thompson, Dependence of Diffusive Permeation Rates by Upstream and Downstream Pressures, p. 141, Copyright 1977, with permission from Elsevier
driving force shown in Equation (2.79). Thus, the properties of pervaporation membranes illustrated in Figures 2.13 and 2.14 are easily rationalized by the solution-diffusion model but are much more difficult to explain by a pore-flow mechanism, although this has been tried. Evidence for the Solution-diffusion Model In the discussion above, the solution-diffusion model was used to derive equations that predict the experimentally observed performance of the membrane processes of dialysis, gas separation, reverse osmosis, and pervaporation. It was not necessary to resort to any additional process-specific model to obtain these results. This agreement between theory and experiment is good evidence for the validity of the solution-diffusion model. Moreover, the large body of permeability, diffusion, and partition coefficient data obtained over the past 20 years for these membrane processes are in good numerical agreement with one another. This universality and the simplicity of the solution-diffusion model are its most useful features and are a strong argument for the validity of the model. Finally, a number of direct experimental measurements can be made to distinguish between the solution-diffusion model and other models, such as the pore-flow model. One prediction of the solution-diffusion model, controversial during the 1970s, is that the action of an applied pressure on the feed side of the membrane is to
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
45
decrease the concentration of the permeant on the low pressure side of the membrane. This counterintuitive effect is illustrated by Figures 2.5 and 2.6. A number of workers have verified this prediction experimentally with a variety of polymer membranes, ranging from diffusion of water in glassy cellulose acetate membranes to diffusion of organics in swollen rubbers [19–21]. Convincing examples of this type of experiment are the results of Rosenbaum and Cotton shown in Figure 2.15 [20]. In these experiments, four thin cellulose acetate films were laminated together, placed in a high pressure reverse osmosis cell, and subjected
From: Rosenbaum and Cotton (1969)
0.0110
Membrane water sorption (mols/g)
68 atm
0.0105
136 atm
0.0100
0
High pressure surface
0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 Membrane thickness (cm) Low pressure surface
Figure 2.15 Measurements of Rosenbaum and Cotton [20] of the water concentration gradients in a laminated reverse osmosis cellulose acetate membrane under applied pressures of 68 and 136 atm. Reprinted from Steady-state Distribution of Water in Cellulose Acetate Membrane, S. Rosenbaum and O. Cotton, J. Polym. Sci. 7, 101; Copyright 1969. This material is used by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
46
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
to feed pressures of 68 or 136 atm. The permeate was maintained at atmospheric pressure. After permeation through the membrane laminate had reached a steady state, the membrane was quickly removed from the cell, and the water concentration in each laminate measured. As predicted by the solution-diffusion model and shown in Figure 2.15, the applied pressure decreases the concentration of water on the permeate side of the membrane. Also, the concentration difference across the membrane at 136 atm applied pressure is about twice that observed at 68 atm, and the measured concentration on the permeate side is within 20 % of the expected value calculated from Equation (2.36). Another series of papers by Paul and co-workers [4–6,19,22] focuses on the same phenomenon using rubbery membranes and permeation of organic solvents such as hexane, benzene and carbon tetrachloride. Such membranes are highly swollen by the organic solvents and, when operated in reverse osmosis mode, Membrane concentration gradients Concentration
Volume flux (cm3/cm2day)
0
Concentration
0
Concentration
0
From: Paul and Ebra-Lima (1970)
5
Limiting flux
4 Iso-octane 3
Limiting flux
2 Methyl ethyl ketone
1 0
0
100
200 300 Applied pressure (psi)
400
Figure 2.16 Pressure permeation (reverse osmosis) of iso-octane and methyl ethyl ketone through crosslinked 265-µm-thick natural rubber membranes. The change in the concentration gradient in the membrane as the applied pressure is increased is illustrated by the inserts. At high applied pressures, the concentration gradient and the permeation fluxes approach their limiting values [4]. Reprinted from Pressure-induced Diffusion of Organic Liquids Through Highly Swollen Polymer Membranes,” D.R. Paul and O.M. Ebra-Lima, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 14, 2201; Copyright 1970. This material is used by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
47
large concentration gradients develop through the membrane even at relatively modest applied pressures. This means that the concentration in the membrane on the permeate side approaches zero and the flux through the membrane reaches a limiting value as the feed pressure is increased. Representative data are shown in Figure 2.16. Paul and Paciotti [19] took this work a step further by measuring the flux of a liquid (hexane) through a membrane both in pervaporation experiments with atmospheric pressure on the feed side of the membrane and a vacuum on the permeate side, and in reverse osmosis experiments with liquid at elevated pressures on the feed side and at atmospheric pressure on the permeate side. The hexane flux obtained in these two sets of experiments is plotted in Figure 2.17 against the hexane concentration difference in the membrane (cio(m) − ci(m) ). The concentrations, cio(m) and ci(m) , were calculated from Equations (2.26), (2.36) and (2.72). ci 12
(m)
=0
From: Paul and Paciotti (1975)
n -Hexane flux, Ji (cm3/cm2·day)
10
8
6
4
Pervaporation Reverse osmosis
2
0 0
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 Hexane concentration difference in membrane, cio(m) − ci (m)
0.7
Figure 2.17 Flux of n-hexane through a rubbery membrane as a function of the hexane concentration difference in the membrane. Data taken from both reverse osmosis ( ) and pervaporation ( ) experiments. Feed-side and permeate-side membrane concentrations, cio(m) and ci(m) , calculated from the operating conditions through Equations (2.26), (2.36) and (2.76). Maximum flux is obtained at the maximum concentration difference, when the permeate-side membrane concentration (ci(m) ), equals zero [19]. Reprinted from Driving Force for Hydraulic and Pervaporation Transport in Homogeneous Membranes, D.R. Paul and D.J. Paciotti, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed. 13, 1201; Copyright 1975. This material is used by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Ž
ž
48
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Sorption data were used to obtain values for KiL . As pointed out by Paul and Paciotti, the data in Figure 2.17 show that reverse osmosis and pervaporation obey one unique transport equation—Fick’s law. In other words, transport follows the solution-diffusion model. The slope of the curve decreases at the higher concentration differences, that is, at smaller values for ci(m) because of decreases in the diffusion coefficient, as the swelling of the membrane decreases. The results illustrated in Figure 2.16 show that the solvent flux tends towards a limiting value at very high pressures. This value is reached when the concentration of sorbed solvent at the permeate side of the membrane reaches zero, the limiting value.
Structure–Permeability Relationships in Solution-diffusion Membranes In the preceding section the effect of concentration and pressure gradient driving forces on permeation through membranes was described in terms of the solutiondiffusion model and Fick’s law. The resulting equations all contain a permeability term, P , that must be experimentally determined. This section describes how the nature of the membrane material affects permeant diffusion and sorption coefficients, which in turn determine membrane permeability. This is a difficult subject. By analyzing the factors that determine membrane permeability, useful correlations and rules of thumb can be derived to guide the selection of membrane materials with the optimum flux and selectivity properties. Most of the experimental data in this area have been obtained with gas-permeable membranes. However, the same general principles apply to all polymeric solution-diffusion membranes. The problem of predicting membrane permeability can be divided into two parts because permeability is the product of the diffusion coefficient and the sorption coefficient: P =D·K (2.84) The sorption coefficient (K) in Equation (2.84) is the term linking the concentration of a component in the fluid phase with its concentration in the membrane polymer phase. Because sorption is an equilibrium term, conventional thermodynamics can be used to calculate solubilities of gases in polymers to within a factor of two or three. However, diffusion coefficients (D) are kinetic terms that reflect the effect of the surrounding environment on the molecular motion of permeating components. Calculation of diffusion coefficients in liquids and gases is possible, but calculation of diffusion coefficients in polymers is much more difficult. In the long term, the best hope for accurate predictions of diffusion in polymers is the molecular dynamics calculations described in an earlier section. However, this technique is still under development and is currently limited to calculations of the diffusion of small gas molecules in amorphous polymers; the
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
49
10−5
10−6
Gas diffusion coefficient, D (cm2/s)
Hydrogen
Carbon dioxide
10−7 Nitrogen
10−8
10−9
Methane
10−10 0.1
1
10
100
Gas sorption coefficient, K (10−3cm3(STP)/cm2cmHg)
Figure 2.18 Diffusion and sorption coefficients plotted for gases in a family of 18 related polyimides. Data of Tanaka et al. [23]
agreement between theory and experiment is modest. In the meantime, simple correlations based on polymer free volume must be used. As a general rule, membrane material changes affect the diffusion coefficient of a permeant much more than the sorption coefficient. For example, Figure 2.18 shows some typical gas permeation data taken from a paper of Tanaka et al. [23]. The diffusion and sorption coefficients of four gases in a family of 18 related polyimides are plotted against each other. Both sorption and diffusion coefficients
50
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
are fairly well grouped for each gas. However, for any one gas the difference in diffusion coefficient from the highest to lowest value is approximately 100fold, whereas the spread in sorption coefficient is only 2- to 4-fold. Changes in polymer chemistry affect both the sorption and diffusion coefficients, but the effect on the diffusion coefficient is much more profound. More detailed examination of the data shown in Figure 2.18 shows that the relative position of each polymer within the group of 18 is approximately the same for all gases. That is, the polymer with the highest diffusion coefficient for methane also has the highest diffusion coefficient for nitrogen, carbon dioxide and hydrogen. The trend for the solubility coefficients is similar. As a general rule, changes in polymer chemistry and structure that change the diffusion coefficient or sorption coefficient of one gas change the properties of other gases in the same way. This is why membrane permeabilities can be easily varied by orders of magnitude by changing the membrane material, whereas changing membrane selectivities (proportional to the ratio of permeabilities) by more than a factor of two or three is difficult. In the following sections the factors that determine the magnitude of diffusion and solubility coefficients in polymers are discussed. Diffusion Coefficients The Fick’s law diffusion coefficient of a permeating molecule is a measure of the frequency with which the molecule moves and the size of each movement. Therefore, the magnitude of the diffusion coefficient is governed by the restraining forces of the medium on the diffusing species. Isotopically labeled carbon in a diamond lattice has a very small diffusion coefficient. The carbon atoms of ˚ diamond move infrequently, and each movement is very small—only 1 to 2 A. On the other hand, isotopically labeled carbon dioxide in a gas has an extremely large diffusion coefficient. The gas molecules are in constant motion and each ˚ or more. Table 2.1 lists some representative values jump is of the order of 1000 A of diffusion coefficients in different media. Table 2.1 Typical diffusion coefficients in various media (25 ◦ C) Permeant/material Oxygen in air (atmospheric pressure) Salt in water Albumin (MW 60 000) in water Oxygen in silicone rubber Oxygen in polysulfone Sodium atoms in sodium chloride crystals Aluminum atoms in metallic copper
Diffusion coefficient, D (cm2 /s) 1 × 10−1 1.5 × 10−5 6 × 10−7 1 × 10−5 4 × 10−8 1 × 10−20 1 × 10−30
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
51
The main observation from Table 2.1 is the enormous range of values of diffusion coefficients—from 10−1 to 10−30 cm2 /s. Diffusion in gases is well understood and is treated in standard textbooks dealing with the kinetic theory of gases [24,25]. Diffusion in metals and crystals is a topic of considerable interest to the semiconductor industry but not to membrane permeation. This book focuses principally on diffusion in liquids and polymers in which the diffusion coefficient can vary from about 10−5 to about 10−10 cm2 /s. Diffusion in Liquids Liquids are simple, well defined systems and provide the starting point for modern theories of diffusion. An early and still fundamentally sound equation was derived by Einstein who applied simple macroscopic hydrodynamics to diffusion at the molecular level. He assumed the diffusing solute to be a sphere moving in a continuous fluid of solvent, in which case it can be shown that D=
kT 6πaη
(2.85)
where k is Boltzmann’s constant, a is the radius of the solute and η is the solution viscosity. This is known as the Stokes–Einstein equation. The equation ˚ But, is a good approximation for large solutes with radii greater than 5–10 A. as the solute becomes smaller, the approximation of the solvent as a continuous fluid becomes less valid. In this case there may be slip of solvent at the solute molecule’s surface. A second limiting case assumes complete slip at the surface of the solute sphere; in this case D=
kT 4πaη
(2.86)
Thus, the Stokes–Einstein equation is perhaps best expressed as D=
kT nπaη
4≤n≤6
(2.87)
An important conclusion to be drawn from the Stokes–Einstein equation is that the diffusion coefficient of solutes in a liquid only changes slowly with molecular weight, because the diffusion coefficient is proportional to the reciprocal of the radius, which in turn is approximately proportional to the cube root of the molecular weight. Application of the Stokes–Einstein equation requires a value for the solute radius. A simple approach is to assume the molecule to be spherical and to calculate the solute radius from the molar volume of the chemical groups making up the molecule. Using values for the solute radius calculated this way along with measured and known diffusion coefficients of solutes in water, Edward [26]
52
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
From Edward (1970)
Stokes−Einstein coefficient (n)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Molecular radius (Å)
Figure 2.19 Value of the coefficient n in the Stokes–Einstein equation [Equation (2.87)] required to achieve agreement between calculation and experimental solute diffusion coefficients in water. [26]. Reprinted with permission from the Journal of Chemical Education 47, No. 4, 1970, pp. 261–270, Figure 12, copyright 1970, Division of Chemical Education, Inc.
constructed the graph of the coefficient n in the Stokes–Einstein equation, Equation (2.87), as a function of solute radius as shown in Figure 2.19. With large solutes, n approaches 6, that is, Einstein’s application of normal macroscopic fluid dynamics at the molecular level is a valid approximation. However, when ˚ water can no longer be regarded as a the solute radius falls below about 4 A continuous fluid, and n falls below 6. Nonetheless, that an equation based on ˚ level is an macroscopic hydrodynamic theory applies to molecules to the 4 A interesting result. The Stokes–Einstein equation works well for diffusion of solutes in simple liquids but fails in more complex fluids, such as a solution of a high-molecularweight polymer. Dissolving a polymer in a liquid increases the solvent’s viscosity, but the solute’s diffusion coefficient is not significantly affected. For example, as the concentration of poly(vinyl pyrrolidone) dissolved in water is changed from 0 to 20 wt %, the viscosity of the solution increases by several orders of magnitude. However, the diffusion coefficient of sucrose in these solutions only changes by a factor of four [27]. The long polymer chains of dissolved poly(vinyl pyrrolidone) molecules link distant parts of the aqueous solution and change the viscosity of the
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
53
fluid substantially, but, in the fluid immediately surrounding the diffusing sucrose molecule, the effect of polymer chain length is much less noticeable. This result illustrates the difference between the microscopic viscosity in the immediate environment of the diffusing solute and the macroscopic viscosity measured by conventional viscometers. In simple liquids the macroscopic and microscopic viscosities are the same, but in liquids containing dissolved macromolecules, or in gels and polymer films, the microscopic viscosity and the macroscopic viscosity differ significantly. Diffusion in Polymers The concept that the local environment around the permeating molecule determines the permeate’s diffusion coefficient is key to understanding diffusion in polymer membranes. Polymers can be divided into two broad categories—rubbery and glassy. In a rubbery polymer, segments of the polymer backbone can rotate freely around their axis; this makes the polymer soft and elastic. Thermal motion of these segments also leads to high permeant diffusion coefficients. In a glassy polymer, steric hindrance along the polymer backbone prohibits rotation of polymer segments; the result is a rigid, tough polymer. Thermal motion in this type of material is limited, so permeant diffusion coefficients are low. If the temperature of a glassy polymer is raised, a point is reached at which the increase in thermal energy is sufficient to overcome the steric hindrance restricting rotation of polymer backbone segments. At this temperature, called the glass transition temperature (Tg ), the polymer changes from a glass to a rubber. Figure 2.20 shows a plot of diffusion coefficient as a function of molecular weight for permeants diffusing through a liquid (water), two soft rubbery polymers (natural rubber and silicone rubber), and a hard, stiff glassy polymer (polystyrene) [28]. For very small molecules, such as helium and hydrogen, the diffusion coefficients in all of the media are comparable, differing by no more than a factor of two or three. These very small molecules only interact with one or two atoms in their immediate proximity. The local environment for these small solutes in the three polymers is not radically different to that in a liquid such as water. On the other hand, larger diffusing solutes with molecular weights ˚ Such solutes of 200 to 300 and above have molecular diameters of 6 to 10 A. are in quite different local environments in the different media. In water, the Stokes–Einstein equation applies, and the resistance to movement of the solute is not much larger than that of a very small solute. In polymer membranes, however, several segments of the polymer chain are involved in each movement of the diffusing species. This type of cooperative movement is statistically unlikely; consequently, diffusion coefficients are much smaller than in liquid water. Moreover, the differences between the motion of polymer segments in the flexible rubbery membranes and in the stiff polystyrene membrane are large. The polymer chains in rubbers are considerably more flexible and rotate more easily than
54
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY −4
APPLICATIONS
Baker and Lonsdale (1974)
−6 Diffusion coefficient, D (cm2/s)
AND
Water Silicone rubber
−8
−10
Natural rubber
−12 Polystyrene −14
100
101 102 103 104 105 Permeant molecular weight
106
Figure 2.20 Permeant diffusion coefficient as a function of permeant molecular weight in water, natural rubber, silicone rubber and polystyrene. Diffusion coefficients of solutes in polymers usually lie between the value in natural rubber, an extremely permeable polymer, and the value in polystyrene, an extremely impermeable material [28]
those in polystyrene. One manifestation of this difference in chain flexibility is the difference in elastic properties; another is the difference in diffusion coefficient. An example of the change in diffusion coefficient as the matrix material changes is illustrated by Figure 2.21. In this example, the polymer matrix material is changed by plasticization of the polymer, ethyl cellulose, by the permeant, dichloroethane [29]. The resulting change in the diffusion coefficient is shown in the figure. The concentration of dichloroethane in the polymer matrix increases from very low levels (<1 % dichloroethane) to very high levels (>90 % dichloroethane). As the concentration of dichloroethane increases, the polymer changes from a glassy polymer to a rubbery polymer, to a solvent-swollen gel, and finally to a dilute polymer solution. Ethyl cellulose is a glassy polymer with a glass transition of about 45–50 ◦ C. At low concentrations of dichloroethane (below about 5 vol %) in the polymer, the ethyl cellulose matrix is glassy, and the dichloroethane diffusion coefficient is in the range 1 to 5 × 10−9 cm2 /s. As
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
55
From Artsis et al. (1972)
Polymer solution
Dichloroethane diffusion coefficient (cm2/s)
10−6 Polymer gel
10−7
Rubbery polymer
10−8
Glassy polymer
10−9
0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 Volume fraction, dichloroethane
1.0
Figure 2.21 Changes in the diffusion coefficient of dichloroethane in ethyl cellulose as a function of the volume fraction of dichloroethane dissolved in the polymer matrix. Data of Artsis et al. [29]
the dichloroethane concentration increases to above 5 vol %, enough solvent has dissolved in the polymer to reduce the glass transition temperature to below the temperature of the experiment. The polymer chains then have sufficient freedom to rotate, and the polymer becomes rubbery. As the dichloroethane concentration increases further, the polymer chain mobility also increases as does the diffusion coefficient of dichloroethane. At 20 % dichloroethane, the diffusion coefficient is 1 × 10−7 cm2 /s, 100 times greater than the diffusion coefficient in the glassy polymer. Above 20 vol % dichloroethane, sufficient solvent is present to allow relatively large segments of the polymer chain to move. In this range, between 20 and 70 vol % dichloroethane, the matrix is best characterized as a solvent-swollen
56
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
gel, and the diffusion coefficient of dichloroethane increases from 1 × 10−7 to 2 × 10−6 cm2 /s. Finally, at dichloroethane concentrations above 70 vol %, sufficient solvent is present for the matrix to be characterized as a polymer solution. In this final solvent concentration range, the increase in diffusion coefficient with further increases in dichloroethane concentration is relatively small. Figures 2.20 and 2.21 show the significant difference between diffusion in liquids and in rubbery and glassy polymers. A great deal of work has been performed over the last two decades to achieve a quantitative link between the structure of polymers and their permeation properties. No such quantitative structure–property relationship is at hand or even in sight. What has been achieved is a set of semiempirical rules that allow the permeation properties of related families of polymers to be correlated based on small changes in their chemical structures. The correlating tool most generally used is the polymer’s fractional free volume vf (cm3 /cm3 ), usually defined as vf =
v − vo v
(2.88)
where v is the specific volume of the polymer (cm3 /g), that is, the reciprocal of the polymer density, and vo is the volume occupied by the molecules themselves (cm3 /g). The free volume of a polymer is the sum of the many small spaces between the polymer chains in these amorphous, noncrystalline materials. The free volume of a polymer can be determined by measuring the polymer’s specific volume, then calculating the occupied volume (vo ) of the groups that form the polymer. Tables of the molar volume of different chemical groups have been prepared by Bondi [30] and Van Krevelen [31]. By summing the molar volume of all the groups in the polymer repeat unit, the occupied molar volume of the polymer can be calculated. The occupied volume obtained in this way is about 1.3 times larger than the Van der Waals volume of the groups. The factor of 1.3 occurs because some unoccupied space is inevitably present even in crystals at 0 K. The fractional free volumes of a number of important membrane materials are given in Table 2.2. The concept of polymer free volume is illustrated in Figure 2.22, which shows polymer specific volume (cm3 /g) as a function of temperature. At high temperatures the polymer is in the rubbery state. Because the polymer chains do not pack perfectly, some unoccupied space—free volume—exists between the polymer chains. This free volume is over and above the space normally present between molecules in a crystal lattice; free volume in a rubbery polymer results from its amorphous structure. Although this free volume is only a few percent of the total volume, it is sufficient to allow some rotation of segments of the polymer backbone at high temperatures. In this sense a rubbery polymer, although solid at the macroscopic level, has some of the characteristics of a liquid. As the temperature of the polymer decreases, the free volume also decreases. At the glass transition temperature, the free volume is reduced to a point at which the
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
57
Table 2.2 Calculated fractional free volume for representative membrane materials at ambient temperatures (Bondi method) Polymer
Polymer type
Glass transition temperature, Tg ( ◦ C)
Fractional free volume (cm3 /cm3 )
Silicone rubber Natural rubber Polycarbonate Poly(phenylene oxide) Polysulfone 6FDA-ODA polyimide Poly(4-methyl-2-pentyne) (PMP) Poly(1-trimethylsilyl-1-propyne) (PTMSP)
Rubber Rubber Glass Glass Glass Glass Glass Glass
−129 −73 150 167 186 300 >250 >250
0.16 0.16 0.16 0.20 0.16 0.16 0.28 0.34
Glass
Rubber
Polymer volume (cm3/g)
Specific volume ( u) Excess free volume for glass
Free volume
Occupied volume (uo)
Tg Temperature
Figure 2.22 The change in specific volume as a function of temperature for a typical polymer
polymer chains can no longer rotate freely. Segmental motion then ceases, and the remaining free volume elements between the polymer chains are essentially frozen into the polymer matrix. As the polymer temperature is reduced further, its occupied volume will continue to decrease as the vibrational energy of the groups forming the polymer decreases, but the free volume elements remain essentially constant. Therefore, a glassy polymer contains both the normal free volume elements caused by the incomplete packing of the groups making up the polymer chains and the excess free volume elements frozen into the polymer matrix because the polymer chains cannot rotate.
58
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY CH3 C=C CH3
Si
AND
APPLICATIONS
CH3 C=C
n CH3
CH3
C
n CH3
CH3
H
Poly(1-trimethylsilyl-1-propyne) [PTMSP]
Poly(4-methyl-2-pentyne) [PMP]
Figure 2.23 Structure of two high-free-volume substituted polyacetylenes, PTMSP and PMP. The carbon–carbon double bond is completely rigid, and depending on the size of the substituents, rotation around the carbon–carbon single bond can be very restricted also. The result is very stiff-backboned, rigid polymer chains which pack very poorly, leading to unusually high fractional free volumes
The fractional free volume of most materials is quite small and the value depends on the methods used for the calculation. For rubbers, the volume calculated by the Bondi method is generally about 10 to 15 % and for glassy polymers slightly higher, generally in the range 15 to 20 % because of the excess free volume contribution. Recently, a number of substituted polyacetylene polymers with extraordinarily rigid polymer backbones have been prepared. The structures of two such polymers are shown in Figure 2.23. Their glass transition temperatures are very high, and their free volumes are correspondingly unusually high—as much as 25 to 35 % of the polymers’ volume is unoccupied space. Correlation of the permeation properties of a wide variety of polymers with their free volume is not possible [32]. But, within a single class of materials, there is a correlation between the free volume of polymers and gas diffusion coefficients; an example is shown in Figure 2.24 [33]. The relationship between the free volume and the sorption and diffusion coefficients of gases in polymers, particularly glassy polymers, has been an area of a great deal of experimental and theoretical work. The subject has recently been reviewed in detail by Petropoulos [34] and by Paul and co-workers [35,36]. Sorption Coefficients in Polymers The second key factor determining permeability in polymers is the sorption coefficient. The data in Figure 2.18 show that sorption coefficients for a particular gas are relatively constant within a single family of related materials. In fact, sorption coefficients of gases in polymers are relatively constant for a wide range of chemically different polymers. Figure 2.25 plots sorption and diffusion coefficients of methane in Tanaka’s fluorinated polyimides [23], carboxylated polyvinyl trimethylsiloxane [37] and substituted polyacetylenes [38], all amorphous glassy polymers, and a variety of substituted siloxanes [39], all rubbers. The diffusion
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
59
Oxygen permeability (Barrer)
Aitken et al. (1992) TMHFPSF
10.0 HMBIPSF TMPSF
TMPSF-M PSF
1.0 DMPSF-Z 3,4'-PSF
0.1 5.0
6.0 7.0 1/uf (cm3/cm3)
8.0
Figure 2.24 Correlation of the oxygen permeability coefficient for a family of related polysulfones with inverse fractional free volume (calculated using the Bondi method) [33]. Reprinted with permission from C.L. Aitken, W.J. Koros and D.R. Paul, Effect of Structural Symmetry on Gas Transport Properties of Polysulfones, Macromolecules 25, 3424. Copyright 1992, American Chemical Society
coefficients of methane in the different polymers vary by more than 100 000, showing the extraordinary sensitivity of the permeant diffusion coefficients to changes in the packing of the polymer chains and to their flexibility. In contrast, sorption coefficients vary by only a factor of 10 around a mean value of about 15 × 10−3 cm3 (STP)/cm3 · cmHg. The sorption coefficients of gases in polymers remain relatively constant because sorption in polymers behaves as though the polymers were ideal fluids. Gas sorption in a polymer is expressed from Equation (2.57) as ci(m) = KiG pi
(2.89)
By substituting for the sorption coefficient KiG from Equation (2.56), Equation (2.89) can be written as ci(m) = mi ρm
γiG pi γi(m) pisat
(2.90)
From the conversion of concentration to mole fraction [Equation (2.10)], it follows that ci(m) = mi ρm ni(m) (2.91)
60
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
10−4
10−5
Substituted silicone rubber
Substituted polyacetylenes
Methane diffusion coefficient (cm2/s)
10−6
10−7 Carboxylated polyvinyltrimethylsiloxane
10−8
Fluorinated polyimides
10−9
10−10
1
10
100
Methane solubility (10−3 cm3(STP)/cm3cmHg)
Figure 2.25 Diffusion and sorption coefficients of methane in different families of polymer materials. Diffusion coefficients change over a wide range but sorption coefficients are relatively constant. Data from references [23,35–37]
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
61
and so Equation (2.90) can be written as ci(m) γ G pi = ni(m) = i ρ m mi γi(m) pisat
(2.92)
For an ideal gas dissolving in an ideal liquid, γiG and γi(m) are both unity, so Equation (2.92) can be written as ni(m) =
pi pisat
(2.93)
where ni(m) is the mole fraction of the gas sorbed in the liquid, pi is the partial pressure of the gas, and pisat is the saturation vapor pressure at the pressure and temperature of the liquid. To apply Equation (2.93), the gas saturation vapor pressure must be determined. This can be done by extrapolating from available vapor pressure data to the ambient range using the Clausius–Clapeyron equation. For some gases the vapor pressure thereby obtained does not correspond to a stable gas–liquid equilibrium because the gas is supercritical at ambient temperatures. However, the calculated value is adequate to calculate the sorption coefficient using Equation (2.93) [40]. At 25 ◦ C the saturation vapor pressure of methane extrapolated in this way is 289 atm. Thus, from Equation (2.93) the mole fraction of methane dissolved in an ideal liquid is 1/289 or 0.0035. The ideal solubility and measured solubilities of methane in a number of common liquids are given in Table 2.3. Although there is some spread in the data, particularly for small polar solvent molecules such as water or methanol, the overall agreement is remarkably good. A more detailed discussion of the solubility of gases in liquids is given in the book by Fogg and Gerrard [41]. To apply the procedure outlined above to a polymer, it is necessary to use the Flory–Huggins theory of polymer solution, which takes into account the entropy of mixing of solutes in polymers caused by the large difference in molecular size Table 2.3 Mole fraction of methane in various solvents at 25 ◦ C and 1 atm. The solubility of methane in an ideal liquid under these conditions is 0.0035 [40] Liquid Ethyl ether Cyclohexane Carbon tetrachloride Acetone Benzene Methanol Water
Methane solubility (mole fraction) 0.0045 0.0028 0.0029 0.0022 0.0021 0.0007 0.00002
62
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
between the two components. The Flory–Huggins expression for the free energy of mixing of a gas in polymer solution can be written [42] υi pi = RT ln Vi + 1 − (2.94) G = RT ln (1 − Vi ) pisat υj where υi and υj are the molar volumes of the gas i and the polymer j respectively, and Vi the volume fraction of the polymer j occupied by the sorbed gas i. When υi ≈ υj , that is, the gas and polymer molecules are approximately the same size, Equation (2.94) reduces to Equation (2.93), the ideal liquid case. When υi υj , that is, when the molar volume of a gas (υi ) is much smaller than the molar volume of the polymer (υj ), then υi /υj → 0 and Equation (2.94) becomes ln
pi = ln Vi + (1 − Vi ) pisat
(2.95)
Equation (2.95) can be rearranged to Vi =
pi /pisat exp(1 − Vi )
(2.96)
and since Vi is small, exp(1 − V1 ) is approximately exp(1) ≈ 2.72, Equation (2.95) then becomes pi /pisat Vi = (2.97) 2.72 Comparing Equations (2.93) and (2.97), we see that the volume fraction of gas sorbed by an ideal polymer is 1/2.72 of the mole fraction of a gas sorbed in an ideal liquid.6 The results of such a calculation are shown in Table 2.4. In Figure 2.26, the calculated sorption coefficients in an ideal polymer from Table 2.4 are plotted against the average sorption coefficients of the same gases in Tanaka’s polyimides [23]. The calculated values are within a factor of two of the experimental values, which is extremely good agreement considering the simplicity of Equation (2.97). A more detailed discussion of sorption of gases in polymers is given in a review by Petropoulos [34]. As shown above, thermodynamics can qualitatively predict the sorption of simple gases in polymers to within a factor of two. Moreover, Equation (2.97) predicts that all polymers should have about the same sorption for the same gas and that sorption is inversely proportional to saturation vapor pressure. Another way of showing the same effect is to plot gas sorption against some convenient measure of saturation vapor pressure, such as the gas boiling point 6 Vi is the volume fraction of the gas sorbed in the polymer. To calculate the amount of gas sorbed in cm3 (STP)/cm3 , the molar density of the sorbed gas must be known. We assume this density is 1/MW (mol/cm3 ).
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY Table 2.4
63 ◦
Solubility of gases in an ideal liquid and an ideal polymer (35 C)
Gas
Calculated saturation vapor pressure, pisat (atm)
Ideal solubility in a liquid at 1 atm (mole fraction) [Equation (2.93)]
Ideal solubility in a polymer [10−3 cm3 (STP)/cm3 · cmHg] [Equation (2.97)]
N2 O2 CH4 CO2
1400 700 366 79.5
0.0007 0.0014 0.0027 0.0126
2.6 4.8 18.4 29.5
100
Measured gas sorption (10−3cm3(STP)/cm3·cmHg)
CO2
10 CH4
O2
N2
1 1
10
100
Gas solubility in an ideal polymer (10-3cm3(STP)/cm3·cmHg)
Figure 2.26 Average sorption coefficients of simple gases in a family of 18 related polyimides plotted against the expected sorption in an ideal polymer calculated using Equation (2.97). Data from Tanaka et al. [23]
or critical temperature. Figure 2.27 shows a plot of this type for a typical glassy polymer (polysulfone), a typical rubber (silicone rubber), and the values for the ideal solubility of a gas in a polymer calculated using Equation (2.97) [43]. The figure shows that the difference in gas sorptions of polymers is relatively small and the values are grouped around the calculated value. Although all of these predictions are qualitatively correct, the differences between the behavior of an ideal polymer and an actual polymer are important in selecting the optimum material for a particular separation. The usual starting point for this fine-tuning is the dual-sorption model originally proposed by Barrer et al. [44]. This model has since been extended by Michaels et al. [45], Paul et al. [46], Koros et al. [47] and many others.
64
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
100
Solubility (cm3(STP)/cm3•cmHg)
Freeman and Pinnau (1999)
10−1 Silicone rubber
Polysulfone
10−2
10−3 Ideal polymer solubility (Eq. 2.97) N2 O2 CH4
H2
10−4 0
100
CO2
200
300
C3H8 n -C4H10 400
500
Tc (K)
Figure 2.27 Solubilities as a function of critical temperature (Tc ) for a typical glassy polymer (polysulfone) and a typical rubbery polymer (silicone rubber) compared with values for the ideal solubility calculated from Equation (2.97)[43]
According to the dual-sorption model, gas sorption in a polymer (cm ) occurs in two types of sites. The first type is filled by gas molecules dissolved in the equilibrium free volume portion of material (concentration cH ). In rubbery polymers this is the only population of dissolved gas molecules, but in glassy polymers a second type of site exists. This population of dissolved molecules (concentration cD ) is dissolved in the excess free volume of the glassy polymer. The total sorption in a glassy polymer is then cm = cD + cH
(2.98)
The number of molecules (cD ) dissolved in the equilibrium free volume portion of the polymer will behave as in normal sorption in a liquid and can be related to the pressure in the surrounding gas by a linear expression equivalent to Equation (2.89) cD = KD p (2.99) This fraction of the total sorption is equivalent to the value calculated in Equation (2.97). The other fraction (cH ) is assumed to be sorbed into the excess
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
65
free volume elements, which are limited, so sorption will cease when all the sites are filled. Sorption in these sites is best approximated by a Langmuir-type absorption isotherm c bp cH = H (2.100) 1 + bp At high pressures cH → cH , where cH is the saturation sorption concentration at which all excess free volume sites are filled. From Equations (2.99) and (2.100) it follows that the total sorption can be written as c bp cm = KD p + H (2.101) 1 + bp
The form of the sorption isotherm predicted from the dual sorption model is shown in Figure 2.28. Because the expressions for sorption contain three adjustable parameters, good agreement between theory and experiment is obtained. Often, much is made of the particular values of the constants cH , b, and K. However, these constants should be treated with caution because they depend totally on the starting point of the curve-fitting exercise. That is, starting with an arbitrary value of cH , the other constants b and K can usually be adjusted to obtain good agreement of Equation (2.101) with experiment. If the starting value for cH is changed, then equally good agreement between theory and experiment can still be obtained but with different values of b and K [48].
Gas sorption (c)
Total sorption
Langmuir sorption c ' bp cH = H 1+ bp Henry's law sorption cD = kDp Gas pressure (p)
Figure 2.28 An illustration of the two components that contribute to gas sorption in a glassy polymer according to the dual sorption model. Henry’s law sorption occurs in the equilibrium free volume portion of the polymer. Langmuir sorption occurs in the excess free volume between polymer chains that exists in glassy polymers
66
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Permeation of gases in glassy polymers can also be described in terms of the dual sorption model. One diffusion coefficient (DD ) is used for the portion of the gas dissolved in the polymer according to the Henry’s law expression and a second, somewhat larger, diffusion coefficient (DH ) for the portion of the gas contained in the excess free volume. The Fick’s law expression for flux through the membrane has the form J = −DD
dcD dcH − DH dx dx
(2.102)
Pore-flow Membranes The creation of a unified theory able to rationalize transport in the dense membranes used in reverse osmosis, pervaporation and gas separation occurred over a 20-year period from about 1960 to 1980. Development of this theory was one of the successes of membrane science. The theory did not form overnight as the result of one single breakthrough but rather as the result of a series of incremental steps. The paper of Lonsdale et al. [12] applying the solution-diffusion model to reverse osmosis for the first time was very important.7 Also important was the series of papers by Paul and co-workers showing the connection between hydraulic permeation (reverse osmosis) and pervaporation [4–6, 19] and providing the experimental support for the solution-diffusion model as applied to these processes. Unfortunately no equivalent unified theory to describe transport in microporous membranes has been developed. Figure 2.29 illustrates part of the problem, namely the extremely heterogeneous nature of microporous membranes. All of the microporous membranes shown in this figure perform approximately the same separation, but their porous structure and the mechanism of the separation differ significantly. The nucleation track membrane (Figure 2.29a) and the asymmetric Loeb–Sourirajan membrane (Figure 2.29d) both separate particles by molecular sieving. The cellulose acetate/cellulose nitrate membrane (Figure 2.29c) is a depth filter which captures particles within the interior of the membrane by adsorption. The expanded film membrane (Figure 2.29b) captures particles by both methods. The materials from which these membranes are made also differ, ranging from polyethylene and polysulfone, both hydrophobic, lowsurface-energy materials, to cellulose acetate, a hydrophilic material that often carries charged surface groups. The parameters available to characterize the complexity of microporous membranes are also imperfect. Some widely used parameters are illustrated in Figure 2.30. The membrane porosity (ε) is the fraction of the total membrane 7 This paper was initially submitted by its three industrial authors for publication to the Journal of Physical Chemistry and was rejected as insufficiently fundamental. More than 30 years after it was finally published in the Journal of Applied Polymer Science, it remains one of the most cited papers on membrane transport theory.
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
67
(a) Track etch
(b) Expanded film
(c) Phase separation
(d) Loeb−Sourirajan
Figure 2.29 Scanning electron micrographs at approximately the same magnification of four microporous membranes having approximately the same particle retention. (a) Nuclepore (polycarbonate) nucleation track membrane; (b) Celgard (polyethylene) expanded film membrane; (c) Millipore cellulose acetate/cellulose nitrate phase separation membrane made by water vapor imbibition (Courtesy of Millipore Corporation, Billerica, MA); (d) anisotropic polysulfone membrane made by the Loeb–Sourirajan phase separation process
volume that is porous. Typical microporous membranes have average porosities in the range 0.3–0.7. This number can be obtained easily by weighing the membrane before and after filling the pores with an inert liquid. The average porosity obtained this way must be treated with caution, however, because the porosity of a membrane can vary from place to place. For example, anisotropic membranes, such as the Loeb–Sourirajan phase separation membrane shown in Figure 2.29(d), often have an average porosity of 0.7–0.8, but the porosity of the skin layer that performs the actual separation may be as low as 0.05. The membrane tortuosity (τ ) reflects the length of the average pore compared to the membrane thickness. Simple cylindrical pores at right angles to the membrane surface have a tortuosity of one, that is, the average length of the pore is the
68
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Cross-sections of porous membranes of different tortuosity
Membrane thickness
t = 1.0
t ~ 1.5 − 2.5
t = 1.5
Surface views of porous membranes of equal porosity (e) but differing pore size
d average pore size
d
d
Figure 2.30 Microporous membranes are characterized by their tortuosity (τ ), their porosity (ε), and their average pore diameter (d)
membrane thickness. Usually pores take a more meandering path through the membrane, so typical tortuosities are in the range 1.5–2.5. The most important property characterizing a microporous membrane is the pore diameter (d). Some of the methods of measuring pore diameters are described in Chapter 7. Although microporous membranes are usually characterized by a single pore diameter value, most membranes actually contain a range of pore sizes. In ultrafiltration, the pore diameter quoted is usually an average value, but to confuse the issue, the pore diameter in microfiltration is usually defined in terms of the largest particle able to penetrate the membrane. This nominal pore diameter can be 5 to 10 times smaller than the apparent pore diameter based on direct microscopic examination of the membrane.
Permeation in Ultrafiltration and Microfiltration Membranes Microporous ultrafiltration and microfiltration membranes used to filter particulates from liquids fall into the two general categories illustrated in Figure 2.31. The first category (a) is the surface or screen filter; such membranes contain surface pores smaller than the particles to be removed. Particles in the permeating
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY (a) Screen filtration
69 (b) Depth filtration
Figure 2.31 Separation of particulates can take place at the membrane surface according to a screen filtration mechanism (a) or in the interior of the membrane by a capture mechanism as in depth filtration (b)
fluid are captured and accumulate on the surface of the membrane. These membranes are usually anisotropic, with a relatively finely microporous surface layer on a more open microporous support. Particles small enough to pass through the surface pores are not normally captured in the interior of the membrane. Most ultrafiltration membranes are screen filters. The second category of microporous membranes is the depth filter (b), which captures the particles to be removed in the interior of the membrane. The average pore diameter of a depth filter is often 10 times the diameter of the smallest particle able to permeate the membrane. Some particles are captured at small constrictions within the membrane, others by adsorption as they permeate the membrane by a tortuous path. Depth filters are usually isotropic, with a similar pore structure throughout the membrane. Most microfiltration membranes are depth filters. Screen Filters The mechanism of particle filtration by screen filters has been the subject of many studies because it is relatively easily described mathematically; Bungay has published a review of this work [49]. Ferry [50] was the first to model membrane retention by a screen filter; in his model pores were assumed to be equal circular capillaries with a large radius, r, compared to the solvent molecule radius. Therefore, the total area of the pore is available for transport of solvent. A solute molecule whose radius, a, is an appreciable fraction of the pore radius cannot approach nearer than one molecular radius of the pore overall. The model is illustrated in Figure 2.32. The area, A, of the pore available for solute transport is given by the equation A (r − a)2 = Ao r2
(2.103)
70
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
r a Area available for solvent transport pr2
Solute
Area available for solute transport p(r - a)2
Solvent
Figure 2.32 small pores
Illustration of the Ferry mechanical exclusion model of solute transport in
where Ao is the area of the pore available for solvent molecules. Later, Renkin [51] showed that Equation (2.103) has to be modified to account for the parabolic velocity profile of the fluid as it passes through the pore. The effective fractional pore area available for solutes in this case is
A Ao
a 2 a 4 =2 1− − 1− r r
(2.104)
where (A/Ao ) is equal to the ratio of the solute concentration in the filtrate (c ) to the concentration in the feed (co ), that is,
A Ao
=
c co
(2.105)
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
71
It follows that from Equation (2.105) and the definition of solution rejection [Equation (2.48)] that the rejection of the membrane is a 2 a 4 R= 1−2 1− + 1− × 100 % (2.106) r r The Ferry–Renkin equation can be used to estimate the pore size of ultrafiltration membranes from the membrane’s rejection of a solute of known radius. The rejections of globular proteins by four typical ultrafiltration membranes plotted against the cube root of the protein molecular weight (an approximate measure of the molecular radius) are shown in Figure 2.33(a). The theoretical curves (a) 100
Albumin
g Globulin
20
Pepsin
40
Cytochrome c
Insulin
60 Bacitracin
Rejection, R (%)
80
0 1
0
5
10
20
40
60
80 100
150
Protein molecular weight (1000s) (b) 100
r = 25 Å
Rejection, R (%)
80
r = 50 Å 60
r = 100 Å
40 20 0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Molecular radius of protein, a (Å)
Figure 2.33 (a) Rejection of globular proteins by ultrafiltration membranes of increasing pore size; (b) calculated rejection curves from the Ferry–Renkin equation (2.106) plotted on the same scale [52]
72
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Table 2.5 Marker molecules used to characterize ultrafiltration membranes Species Sucrose Raffinose Vitamin B12 Bacitracin Insulin Cytochrome c Myoglobin α-Chymotrysinogene Pepsin Ovalbumin Bovine albumin Aldolase γ -Globulin
Molecular weight (×1000)
Estimated molecular ˚ diameter (A)
0.34 0.59 1.36 1.41 5.7 13.4 17 25 35 43 67 142 150
11 13 17 17 27 38 40 46 50 56 64 82 84
calculated from Equation (2.106) are shown directly in Figure 2.33(b) [52]. The abscissae of both figures have been made comparable because the radius of gyra˚ A pore size that appears to be reasonable tion of albumin is approximately 30 A. can then be obtained by comparing the two graphs. This procedure for obtaining an approximate pore size from membrane retention measurements shown in Figure 2.33 has been widely used. Globular proteins are usually the basis for this work because their molecular weights and molecular diameter can be calculated precisely. A list of some commonly used molecular markers is given in Table 2.5.
Depth Filters The mechanism of particle capture by depth filtration is more complex than for screen filtration. Simple capture of particles by sieving at pore constructions in the interior of the membrane occurs, but adsorption of particles on the interior surface of the membrane is usually at least as important. Figure 2.34 shows four mechanisms that contribute to particle capture in depth membrane filters. The most obvious mechanism, simple sieving and capture of particles at constrictions in the membrane, is often a minor contributor to the total separation. The three other mechanisms, which capture particles by adsorption, are inertial capture, Brownian diffusion and electrostatic adsorption [53,54]. In all cases, particles smaller than the diameter of the pore are captured by adsorption onto the internal surface of the membrane. In inertial capture, relatively large particles in the flowing liquid cannot follow the fluid flow lines through the membrane’s tortuous pores. As a result, such particles are captured as they impact the pore wall. This capture mechanism is
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
73
Electrostatic adsorption Brownian diffusion
Inertial impaction
Fluid stream lines
Sieving
Fiber cross-section
Figure 2.34 Particle capture mechanism in filtration of liquid solutions by depth microfilters. Four capture mechanisms are shown: simple sieving; electrostatic adsorption; inertial impaction; and Brownian diffusion
more frequent for larger diameter particles. In experiments with colloidal gold particles and depth filtration membranes with tortuous pores approximately 5 µm in diameter, Davis showed that 60 % of 0.05-µm-diameter particles were captured [55]. Nucleation track membranes with 5-µm, almost straight-through pores and no tortuosity retained less than 1 % of the particles. The retention of the small particles by the depth filter was caused by the greater tortuosity which led to inertial capture. The second mechanism is capture by Brownian diffusion, which is more of a factor for smaller particles. Small particles are easily carried along by the moving fluid. However, because the particles are small, they are subject to random Brownian motion that periodically brings them into contact with the pore walls. When this happens, capture by surface adsorption occurs. The third mechanism is capture of charged particles by membranes having surface-charged groups. Many common colloidal materials carry a slight negative charge, so membranes containing an excess of positive groups can provide enhanced removals. Several microfiltration membrane manufacturers produce this type of charged membrane. One problem is that the adsorption capacity of the charged group is exhausted as filtration proceeds, and the retention falls.
74
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY 10−4
Capture by inertial interception
Fractional penetration
10−5
AND
APPLICATIONS
Capture by Brownian diffusion
10−6
10−7 Most penetrating particle 10−8 0.01
Figure 2.35
0.10 Particle diameter (µm)
1.00
Gas-borne particle penetration through an ultrathin PVDF membrane [55,56]
In filtration of gas-borne aerosol particles by microfiltration membranes, capture by adsorption is usually far more important than capture by sieving. This leads to the paradoxical result that the most penetrating particle may not be the smallest one. This is because capture by inertial interception is most efficient for larger particles, whereas capture by Brownian motion is most efficient for smaller particles. As a result the most penetrating particle has an intermediate diameter, as shown in Figure 2.35 [55,56]. Knudsen Diffusion and Surface Diffusion in Microporous Membranes Essentially all industrial gas separation membranes involve permeation through dense polymeric membranes. But the study of gas permeation through finely microporous membranes has a long history dating back to Graham’s work in the 1850s. To date, the only application of these membranes has been the separation of U235 F6 and U238 F6 in the Manhattan project. More recently finely microporous membranes made by carbonizing poly(vinylidene chloride) and other polymers have been developed and taken to the pilot plant scale. If the pores of a microporous membrane are 0.1 µm or larger, gas permeation will take place by normal convective flow described by Poiseuille’s law. As
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
75
the pore radius (r) decreases it can become smaller than the mean free path (λ) of the gas. (At atmospheric pressure the mean free path of common gases ˚ When this occurs the ratio of the pore radius to is in the range 500–2000 A.) the gas mean free path (r/λ) is less than one. Diffusing gas molecules then have more collisions with the pore walls than with other gas molecules. Gas permeation in this region is called Knudsen diffusion. At every collision with the pore walls, the gas molecules are momentarily adsorbed and then reflected in a random direction. Molecule–molecule collisions are rare, so each gas molecule moves independently of all others. Hence with gas mixtures in which the different species move at different average velocities, a separation is possible. The gas flow in a membrane made of cylindrical right capillaries for Knudsen diffusion is given by Equation (2.103) 4rε 2RT 1/2 po − p j= · · (2.107) 3 πm · RT where m is the molecular weight of the gas, j is the flux in gmol/cm2 · s, ε is the porosity of the membrane, r is the pore radius, is the pore length and po and p are the absolute pressures of the gas species at the beginning of the pore (x = 0) and at the end (x = ). The equivalent equation for permeation by Poiseuille flow is j=
r 2 ε [po − p ][po + p ] · 8η · RT
(2.108)
where η is the viscosity of the gas. Equation (2.108) differs from the more familiar Poiseuille equation for liquids by the additional term [po + p ] which arises from the expansion of a gas as it moves down the pressure gradient. Figure 2.36 shows the effect of the ratio r/λ on the relative proportions of Knudsen to Poiseuille flow in a cylindrical capillary [57]. When r/λ is greater than one, Poiseuille flow predominates. Because the mean free path of gases ˚ for Knudsen flow to at atmospheric pressure is in the range of 500–2000 A, predominate and a separation to be obtained, the membrane pore radius must be ˚ less than 500 A. It follows from Equation (2.107) that the permeability of a gas (i) through a √ Knudsen diffusion membrane is proportional to 1/ mi . The selectivity of this membrane (αi/j ), proportional to the ratio of gas permeabilities, is given by the expression mj αi/j = (2.109) mi This result was first observed experimentally by Graham and is called Graham’s law of diffusion. Knudsen diffusion membranes have been used to separate gas isotopes that are difficult to separate by other methods, for example tritium from
76
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
1.4
Gas permeability
1.2 1.0 0.8
Total flow
0.6 Poiseuille flow
0.4 0.2
Knudsen flow
0 0
1
2
3
4 r /l
5
6
7
8
Figure 2.36 Illustration of the proportion of Knudsen to Poiseuille flow as a function of r/λ (after Barrer) [57]
hydrogen, C12 H4 from C14 H4 and most importantly U235 F6 from U238 F6 . The membrane selectivity for U235 F6 /U238 F6 mixtures is only 1.0043, so hundreds of separation stages are required to produce a complete separation. Nevertheless, at the height of the Cold War, the US Atomic Energy Commission operated three plants fitted with microporous metal membranes that processed almost 20 000 tons/year of uranium. ˚ When the pore diameter of a microporous membrane decreases to the 5–10 A range, the pores begin to separate gases by a molecular sieving effect. The difficulty of making these membranes defect-free has so far prevented their application to industrial separations. However, in the laboratory, spectacular sep˚ Figure 2.37 arations have been reported for gases that differ in size by only 0.1 A. shows some data for permeation through microporous silica membranes [58]. No polymeric membranes can match this separation. Surface adsorption and diffusion add a second contribution to gas permeation that can occur in small-pore-diameter membranes. This phenomenon is shown schematically in Figure 2.38. Adsorption onto the walls of the small pores ˚ At this becomes noticeable when the pore diameter drops below about 100 A. pore diameter the surface area of the pore walls is in the range 100 m2 /cm3 of material. Significant amounts of gas then adsorb onto the pore walls, particularly if the gas is condensable. Often the amount of gas sorbed on the pore walls is much greater than the amount of nonsorbed gas. Sorbed gas molecules are mobile and can move by a process of surface diffusion through the membrane according
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
77
1000 He H2
Permeability, P (Barrer)
100
CO2
10
O2 N2
1
0.1 Shelekhin et al. (1992) 0.01 2.4
2.9 3.4 Kinetic diameter (Å)
CH4 3.9
Figure 2.37 Permeability coefficients as a function of the gas kinetic diameter in microporous silica hollow fine fibers [58]. Reprinted from J. Membr. Sci. 75, A.B. Shelekhin, A.G. Dixon and Y.H. Ma, Adsorption, Permeation, and Diffusion of Gases in Microporous Membranes, 233, Copyright 1992, with permission from Elsevier
to a Fick’s law type of expression Js = −Ds
dcs dx
(2.110)
where Js is the contribution to permeation by surface diffusion of the sorbed gas cs and Ds is a surface diffusion coefficient. At room temperature, typical surface diffusion coefficients are in the range 1 × 10−3 –1 × 10−4 cm2 /s, intermediate between the diffusion coefficients of molecules in gases and liquids [59]. Although these coefficients are less than the diffusion coefficients for nonsorbed gas, surface diffusion still makes a significant contribution to total permeation. Some typical results illustrating the effect of surface diffusion are shown in Figure 2.39 for permeation of gases through microporous √ glass [60]. The expected permeability normalized for gas molecular weight, P m, is constant, but only the very low boiling gases, helium, hydrogen and neon, approach this value. As the condensability of the gas increases (as measured by boiling point or critical temperature) the amount of surface adsorption increases and the contribution of surface diffusion to gas permeation increases. For butane, for example, 80 % of the total gas permeation is due to surface diffusion. In experiments with mixtures of condensable and noncondensable gases, adsorption of the condensable gas component can restrict or even completely block permeation of the noncondensable gas [61,62]. This effect was first noticed by Barrer and Pope in experiments with sulfur dioxide/hydrogen mixtures [63]; some of the data are shown in Figure 2.40. Sorption of sulfur dioxide on the pore walls
78
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Mixtures of noncondensable gases (a) Knudsen diffusion
(b) Molecular sieving
Mixtures of condensable and noncondensable gases (c) Knudsen diffusion and surface diffusion
(d) Surface diffusion and capillary condensation
Figure 2.38 Permeation of noncondensable and condensable gas mixtures through finely microporous membranes. With noncondensable gases molecular sieving occurs when the ˚ diameter range. With gas mixtures containing condensable pore wall reaches the 5- to 10-A gases surface diffusion increases as the pore diameter decreases and the temperature decreases (increasing adsorption)
of the microporous carbon membrane inhibits the flow of hydrogen. If adsorption is increased by increasing the sulfur dioxide partial pressure or by lowering the temperature, sufficient sulfur dioxide is adsorbed to cause capillary condensation of sulfur dioxide in the membrane pores, completely blocking permeation of hydrogen. At this point the membrane only permeates sulfur dioxide.
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
79
120 Molecular weight normalized permeability m(cm3(STP)cm/cm2·s·cmHg)
Hwang and Kammermeyer (1975)
C4H10
100
C3H8
80
C3H6
C2H6
60
C2H4 40
N2 Ar
He H2 Ne
Surface diffusion contribution
O2 CH4
D2
20
CO2
Knudsen gas diffusion contribution
0 0
100
200 300 Gas critical temperature (K)
400
Figure 2.39 Molecular-weight-normalized permeability of gases through Vycor microporous glass membranes [60]. Reprinted from Techniques of Chemistry, Vol. VII, Membranes in Separations, S.T. Hwang and K. Kammermeyer; A. Weissberger (ed.); Copyright 1975. This material is used by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Microporous carbonized hollow fibers were developed over a period of 20 years by Soffer, Koresh, and others (64) at Carbon Membranes Ltd. and were brought to the small module scale. Spectacular separations were reported, but the membranes were difficult to make defect-free and were relatively sensitive to fouling and breaking. More recently, Rao, Sirkar, and others at Air Products tried to use microporous membranes to separate hydrogen/light hydrocarbon gas mixtures found in refinery waste gas streams [65,66]. They also used microporous carbon membranes, this time formed by vacuum carbonization of polymer films cast onto microporous ceramic supports. The adsorbed hydrocarbons permeate the membranes by surface diffusion while permeation of hydrogen in the gas phase is blocked by capillary condensation in the membrane pores. The process was tried at the pilot-plant scale, but eventually abandoned in part because of blocking of the membranes by permanently adsorbed higher hydrocarbons in the feed gas. Despite these failures, microporous carbon membranes continue to be a subject of research by a number of groups [67–70]. The selectivities obtained are often very good, even for simple gas mixtures such as oxygen/nitrogen or carbon dioxide/methane. However long-term, it is difficult to imagine carbon membranes
80
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY 1.0
AND
APPLICATIONS
Ash, et al. (1963)
Hydrogen permeability relative to pure gas value
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0 50 100 150 Amount of SO2 sorbed (cm3(STP)/g)
0
Figure 2.40 Blocking of hydrogen in hydrogen/sulfur dioxide gas mixture permeation experiments with finely microporous membranes [63] as a function of the amount of sulfur dioxide adsorbed by the membrane. As sulfur dioxide sorption increases the hydrogen permeability is reduced until at about 140 cm3 (SO2 )(STP)/g, the membrane is completely blocked and only sulfur dioxide permeates. Data obtained at several temperatures fall on the same master curve ( , 0 ◦ C; , −10 ◦ C; , −20.7 ◦ C; , −33.6 ◦ C). Reprinted from R. Ash, R.M. Barrer and C.G. Pope, Flow of Adsorbable Gases and Vapours in Microporous Medium, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A, 271, 19 (1963) with permission from The Royal Society
ž
competing with polymeric membranes for these separations. Carbon membranes are likely to be 10 to 100 times more expensive than equivalent polymeric membranes. This cost differential can only be tolerated in applications in which polymeric membranes completely fail to make the separation. Such applications might be the high-temperature separation of hydrocarbon vapor/vapor mixtures; the chemical and physical stability of ceramic and carbon membranes is a real advantage in this type of separation. Although the literature of gas separation with microporous membranes is dominated by inorganic materials, polymer membranes have also been tried with some success. The polymers used are substituted polyacetylenes, which can have an extraordinarily high free volume, on the order of 25 vol %. The free volume is so high that the free volume elements in these polymers are probably interconnected. Membranes made from these polymers appear to function as finely microporous ˚ diameter range [71,72]. The two most materials with pores in the 5 to 15 A
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
81
widely studied polyacetylenes are poly(1-trimethylsilyl-1-propyne) (PTMSP) and poly(4-methyl-2-pentyne) (PMP), with the structures shown in Figure 2.23. Gas permeabilities in these materials are orders of magnitude higher than those of conventional, low-free-volume glassy polymers, and are even substantially higher than those of poly(dimethylsiloxane), for many years the most permeable polymer known. The extremely high free volume provides a sorption capacity as much as 10 times that of a conventional glassy polymer. More dramatically, diffusion coefficients are 103 to 106 times greater than those observed in conventional glassy polymers. This combination of extraordinarily high permeabilities, together with the very high free volume, hints at a pore-flow contribution. Nonetheless, the ratio of the diffusion coefficients of oxygen and nitrogen (DO2 /DN2 ) is 1.4, a small value for a glassy polymer membrane but still more than would be expected for a simple Knudsen diffusion membrane. These high-free-volume polymers also have unusual permeability characteristics with mixtures of condensable and noncondensable gases. For example, in the presence of as little as 1200 ppm of a condensable vapor such as the perfluorocarbon FC-77 (a perfluoro octane-perfluoro decane mixture), the nitrogen permeability of PTMSP is 20 times lower than the pure nitrogen permeability [71], as shown in Figure 2.41. When the condensable vapor is removed from the feed gas the nitrogen permeability rapidly returns to its original value. The best
Permeation rate relative to pure nitrogen
1.2 FC-77 in N2
N2
N2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
PTMSP film 1200 ppm FC-77
0 0
10
20
30 40 Time (min)
50
60
70
80
Figure 2.41 The change in nitrogen flux through a PTMSP membrane caused by the presence of a condensable vapor in the feed gas [71]. This behavior is characteristic of extremely finely porous microporous ceramic or ultrahigh-free-volume polymeric ˚ membranes such as PTMSP. The condensable vapor adsorbs in the 5- to 15-A-diameter pores of the membrane, blocking the flow of the noncondensable nitrogen gas
82
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
explanation for these unusual vapor permeation properties is that PTMSP, because of its very high free volume, is an ultra-microporous membrane in which poreflow transport occurs. The FC-77 vapor causes capillary condensation in which the pores are partially or completely blocked by the adsorbed vapor, preventing the flow of noncondensed gases (nitrogen) through the membrane. The Transition Region The transition between pore-flow and solution-diffusion transport seems to occur with membranes having very small pores. Ultrafiltration membranes that reject sucrose and raffinose but pass all micro-ions are clearly pore-flow membranes, whereas desalination-grade sodium-chloride-rejecting reverse osmosis membranes clearly follow the solution-diffusion model. Presumably, the transition is in the nanofiltration range, with membranes having good rejections to divalent ions and most organic solutes, but rejection of monovalent ions in the 20–70 % range. The performance of a family of nanofiltration membranes of this type is illustrated in Table 2.6 [73]. The FT30 membrane is clearly a good reverse osmosis membrane, whereas the XP-20 is a very small pore flow ultrafiltration membrane. The XP-45 membrane is intermediate in character. The transition between reverse osmosis membranes with a salt rejection of more than 95 % and molecular weight cutoffs below 50 and ultrafiltration membranes with a salt rejection of less than 10 % and a molecular weight cutoff of more than 1000 is shown in Figure 2.42 [74]. The very large change in the pressure-normalized flux of water that occurs as the membranes become more retentive is noteworthy. Because these are anisotropic membranes, the thickness of the separating layer is difficult to measure, but clearly the permeability of Table 2.6 Rejection of microsolutes by nanofiltration membranes (FilmTec data) [73]. Reprinted from Desalination, 70, J. Cadotte, R. Forester, M. Kim, R. Petersen and T. Stocker, Nanofiltration Membranes Broaden the Use of Membrane Separation Technology, p. 77, Copyright 1988, with permission from Elsevier Solute
NaC1 MgCl2 MgSO4 NaNO3 Ethylene glycol Glycerol Glucose Sucrose
Solute rejection (%) FT-30
XP-45
XP-20
99.5 >99.5 >99.5 90 70 96 99 100
50 83 97.5 <20 24 44 95 100
20 — 85 0 11 15 60 89
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
83
NaCl rejection (%)
80
Reverse osmosis region
104 Ultrafiltration region
60
102
40 Nanofiltration region
20
0
103
0.01
0.1 1.0 10 Water pressure-normalized flux (m3/m2 · bar · day)
10
Molecular weight cutoff (90% retention)
105
100
100
Figure 2.42 Diagram of the region of nanofiltration membrane performance relative to reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration membranes [74]
water through the pores of ultrafiltration membranes is orders of magnitude higher than permeability through dense solution-diffusion reverse osmosis membranes. Gas permeation also places high-free-volume substituted polyacetylene polymer membranes in the transition area between solution-diffusion and pore flow.
Conclusions and Future Directions During the last 30 years the basis of permeation through membranes has become much clearer. This is particularly true for reverse osmosis, gas permeation and pervaporation for which the solution-diffusion model is now almost universally accepted and well-supported by a body of experimental evidence. This model provides simple equations that accurately link the driving forces of concentration and pressure with flux and selectivity. The solution-diffusion model has been less successful at providing a link between the nature of the membrane material and the membrane permeation properties. This link requires an ability to calculate membrane diffusion and sorption coefficients. These calculations require knowledge of the molecular level of interactions of permeant molecules and their motion in the polymer matrix that is not yet available. Only semiempirical correlations such as the dual sorption model or free volume correlations are available. The best hope for future progress towards a priori methods of calculating permeant sorption and diffusion coefficients lies in computer-aided molecular dynamic simulations, but accurate predictions using this technique are years—perhaps decades—away.
84
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
The theory of permeation through microporous membranes in ultrafiltration and microfiltration is much less developed and it is difficult to see a clear path forward. Permeation through these membranes is affected by a variety of hardto-compute effects and is also very much a function of membrane structure and composition. Measurements of permeation through ideal uniform-pore-diameter membranes made by the nucleation track method are in good agreement with theory. Unfortunately, industrially useful membranes have nonuniform tortuous pores and are often anisotropic as well. Current theories cannot predict the permeation properties of these membranes.
References 1. S. Sourirajan, Reverse Osmosis, Academic Press, New York (1970). 2. H. Yasuda and A. Peterlin, Diffusive and Bulk Flow Transport in Polymers, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 17, 433 (1973). 3. P. Meares, On the Mechanism of Desalination by Reversed Osmotic Flow Through Cellulose Acetate Membrane, Eur. Polym. J. 2, 241 (1966). 4. D.R. Paul and O.M. Ebra-Lima, Pressure-induced Diffusion of Organic Liquids Through Highly Swollen Polymer Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 14, 2201 (1970). 5. D.R. Paul, Diffusive Transport in Swollen Polymer Membranes, in Permeability of Plastic Films and Coatings, H.B. Hopfenberg (ed.), Plenum Press, New York, pp. 35–48 (1974). 6. D.R. Paul, The Solution-diffusion Model for Swollen Membranes, Sep. Purif. Meth. 5, 33 (1976). ¨ 7. A. Fick, Uber Diffusion, Poggendorff’s Annal. Physik Chem. 94, 59 (1855). 8. E. Smit, M.H.V. Mulder, C.A. Smolders, H. Karrenbeld, J. van Eerden and D. Feil, Modeling of the Diffusion of Carbon Dioxide in Polyimide Matrices by Computer Simulation, J. Membr. Sci. 73, 247 (1992). 9. S.G. Charati and S.A. Stern, Diffusion of Gases in Silicone Polymers: Molecular Dynamic Simulations, Macromolecules 31, 5529 (1998). 10. J.G. Wijmans and R.W. Baker, The Solution-diffusion Model: A Review, J. Membr. Sci. 107, 1 (1995). 11. F. Theeuwes, R.M. Gale and R.W. Baker, Transference: a Comprehensive Parameter Governing Permeation of Solutes Through Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 1, 3 (1976). 12. H.K. Lonsdale, U. Merten and R.L. Riley, Transport Properties of Cellulose Acetate Osmotic Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 9, 1341 (1965). 13. U. Merten, Transport Properties of Osmotic Membranes, in Desalination by Reverse Osmosis, U. Merten (ed.), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 15–54 (1966). 14. N. Bhore, R.M. Gould, S.M. Jacob, P.O. Staffeld, D. McNally, P.H. Smiley and C.R. Wildemuth, New Membrane Process Debottlenecks Solvent Dewaxing Unit, Oil Gas J. 97, 67 (1999). 15. R.W. Baker and J.G. Wijmans, Membrane Separation of Organic Vapors from Gas Streams, in Polymeric Gas Separation Membranes, D.R. Paul and Y.P. Yampol’skii (eds), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 353–398 (1994). 16. T. Kataoka, T. Tsuro, S.-I. Nakao and S. Kimura, Membrane Transport Properties of Pervaporation and Vapor Permeation in an Ethanol–Water System Using Polyacrylonitrile and Cellulose Acetate Membranes, J. Chem. Eng. Jpn 24, 326 (1991). 17. J.G. Wijmans and R.W. Baker, A Simple Predictive Treatment of the Permeation Process in Pervaporation, J. Membr. Sci. 79, 101 (1993).
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
85
18. F.W. Greenlaw, W.D. Prince, R.A. Shelden and E.V. Thompson, Dependence of Diffusive Permeation Rates by Upstream and Downstream Pressures, J. Membr. Sci. 2, 141 (1977). 19. D.R. Paul and D.J. Paciotti, Driving Force for Hydraulic and Pervaporation Transport in Homogeneous Membranes, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed. 13, 1201 (1975). 20. S. Rosenbaum and O. Cotton, Steady-state Distribution of Water in Cellulose Acetate Membrane, J. Polym. Sci. 7, 101 (1969). 21. S.N. Kim and K. Kammermeyer, Actual Concentration Profiles in Membrane Permeation, Sep. Sci. 5, 679 (1970). 22. D.R. Paul, J.D. Paciotti and O.M. Ebra-Lima, Hydraulic Permeation of Liquids Through Swollen Polymeric Networks, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 19, 1837 (1975). 23. K. Tanaka, H. Kita, M. Okano and K. Okamoto, Permeability and Permselectivity of Gases in Fluorinated and Non-fluorinated Polyimides, Polymer 33, 585 (1992). 24. J.O. Hirschfelder, C.F. Curtis and R.B. Bird, Molecular Theory of Gases and Liquids, John Wiley, New York (1954). 25. R.C. Reid, J.M. Prausnitz and B.E. Poling, The Properties of Gases and Liquids, 4th Edn, McGraw Hill, New York (1987). 26. J.T. Edward, Molecular Volumes and the Stokes–Einstein Equation, J. Chem. Ed. 47, 261 (1970). 27. Y. Nishijima and G. Oster, Diffusion in Concentrated Polymer Solutions, J. Polym. Sci. 19, 337 (1956). 28. R.W. Baker and H.K. Lonsdale, Controlled Release: Mechanisms and Rates, in Controlled Release of Biological Active Agents, A.C. Tanquary and R.E. Lacey (eds), Plenum Press, New York, pp. 15–72 (1974). 29. M. Artsis, A.E. Chalykh, N.A. Khalturinskii, W. Moiseev and G.E. Zaikov, Diffusion of Organic Diluents into Ethyl Cellulose, Eur. Polym. J. 8, 613 (1972). 30. A. Bondi, Physical Properties of Molecular Crystals, Liquids, and Glasses, Wiley, New York (1968). 31. D.W. Van Krevelen, Properties of Polymers, Elsevier, Amsterdam (1990). 32. Y. Kirayama, T. Yoshinaga, Y. Kusuki, K. Ninomiya, T. Sakakibara and T. Tameri, Relation of Gas Permeability with Structure of Aromatic Polyimides, J. Membr. Sci. 111, 169 (1996). 33. C.L. Aitken, W.J. Koros and D.R. Paul, Effect of Structural Symmetry on Gas Transport Properties of Polysulfones, Macromolecules 25, 3424 (1992). 34. J.H. Petropoulos, Mechanisms and Theories for Sorption and Diffusion of Gases in Polymers, in Polymeric Gas Separation Membranes, D.R. Paul and Y.P. Yampol’skii (eds), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 17–82 (1994). 35. M.R. Paxton and D.R. Paul, Relationship Between Structure and Transport Properties for Polymers with Aromatic Backbones, in Polymeric Gas Separation Membranes, D.R. Paul and Y.P. Yampol’skii (eds), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 83–154 (1994). 36. J.Y. Park and D.R. Paul, Correlation and Prediction of Gas Permeability in Glassy Polymer Membrane Materials via a Modified Free Volume Based Group Contribution Method, J. Membr. Sci. 125, 29 (1997). 37. N.A. Plat´e and Y.P. Yampol’skii, Relationship between Structure and Transport Properties for High Free Volume Polymeric Materials, in Polymeric Gas Separation Membranes, D.R. Paul and Y.P. Yampol’skii (eds), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 155–208 (1994). 38. T. Masuda, Y. Iguchi, B.-Z. Tang and T. Higashimura, Diffusion and Solution of Gases in Substituted Polyacetylene Membranes, Polymer 29, 2041 (1988). 39. S.A. Stern, V.M. Shah and B.J. Hardy, Structure–Permeability Relationships in Silicone Polymers, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed. 25, 1263 (1987).
86
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
40. K. Denbigh, The Principles of Chemical Equilibrium, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1961). 41. P.G.T. Fogg and W. Gerrard, Solubility of Gases in Liquids, Wiley, Chichester (1991). 42. P.J. Flory, Principles of Polymer Chemistry, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY, p. 511 (1953). 43. B.D. Freeman and I. Pinnau, Polymer Membranes for Gas Separation, ACS Symp. Ser. 733, 6 (1999). 44. R.M. Barrer, J.A. Barrie and J. Slater, Sorption and Diffusion in Ethyl Cellulose, J. Polym. Sci. 27, 177 (1958). 45. A.S. Michaels, W.R. Vieth and J.A. Barrie, Solution of Gases in Polyethylene Terephthalate, J. Appl. Phys. 34, 1 (1963). 46. K. Toi, G. Morel and D.R. Paul, Gas Sorption in Poly(phenylene oxide) and Comparisons with Other Glassy Polymers, J. Appl. Sci. 27, 2997 (1982). 47. W.J. Koros, A.H. Chan and D.R. Paul, Sorption and Transport of Various Gases in Polycarbonate, J. Membr. Sci. 2, 165 (1977). 48. A. Morisato, B.D. Freeman, I. Pinnau and C.G. Casillas, Pure Hydrocarbon Sorption Properties of Poly(1-trimethylsilyl-1-propyne) [PTMSP] and Poly(1-phenyl-1propyne) [PPP] and PTMSP/PPP Blends, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed. 34, 1925 (1996). 49. P.M. Bungay, Transport Principles–Porous Membranes, in Synthetic Membranes: Science Engineering and Applications, P.M. Bungay, H.K. Lonsdale and M.N. dePintio (eds), D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 109–154 (1986). 50. J.D. Ferry, Ultrafilter Membranes and Ultrafiltration, Chem. Rev. 18, 373 (1936). 51. E.M. Renkin, Filtration, Diffusion and Molecular Sieving Through Porous Cellulose Membranes, J. Gen. Physiol. 38, 225 (1955). 52. R.W. Baker and H. Strathmann, Ultrafiltration of Macromolecular Solutions with High-flux Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 14, 1197 (1970). 53. R.C. Lukaszewicz, G.B. Tanny and T.H. Meltzer, Membrane-filter Characterizations and their Implications for Particle Retention, Pharm. Tech. 2, 77 (1978). 54. T.H. Meltzer, Filtration in the Pharmaceutical Industry, Marcel Dekker, New York (1987). 55. R.H. Davis and D.C. Grant, Theory for Dead End Microfiltration, in Membrane Handbook, W.S.W. Ho and K.K. Sirkar (eds), Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, pp. 461–479 (1992). 56. D.C. Grant, B.Y.H. Liu, W.G. Fischer and R.A. Bowling, Particle Capture Mechanisms in Gases and Liquids: an Analysis of Operative Mechanisms, J. Environ. Sci. 42, 43 (1989). 57. R.M. Barrer, Diffusion in Porous Media, Appl. Mater. Res. 2, 129 (1963). 58. A.B. Shelekhin, A.G. Dixon and Y.H. Ma, Adsorption, Permeation, and Diffusion of Gases in Microporous Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 75, 233 (1992). 59. R. Ash, R.M. Barrer and P. Sharma, Sorption and Flow of Carbon Dioxide and Some Hydrocarbons in a Microporous Carbon Membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 1, 17 (1976). 60. S.T. Hwang and K. Kammermeyer, Techniques of Chemistry, Vol. VII, Membranes in Separations, Wiley, New York (1975). 61. K. Keizer, A.J. Burggraaf, Z.A.E.P. Vroon and H. Verweij, Two Component Permeation Through Thin Zeolite MFI Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 147, 159 (1998). 62. M.H. Hassan, J.D. Way, P.M. Thoen and A.C. Dillon, Single Component and Mixed Gas Transport in a Silica Fiber Membrane, J. Membr. Sci. 104, 27 (1995). 63. R. Ash, R.M. Barrer and C.G. Pope, Flow of Adsorbable Gases and Vapours in Microporous Medium, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 271, 19 (1963). 64. A. Soffer, J.E. Koresh and S. Saggy, Separation Device, US Patent 4,685,940, August 1987.
MEMBRANE TRANSPORT THEORY
87
65. M.B. Rao and S. Sirkar, Nanoporous Carbon Membranes for Separation of Gas Mixtures by Selective Surface Flow, J. Membr. Sci. 85, 253 (1994). 66. M.B. Rao and S. Sirkar, Performance and Pore Characterization of Nanoporous Carbon Membranes for Gas Separation, J. Membr. Sci. 110, 109 (1996). 67. D.Q. Vu, W.J. Koros and S.J. Miller, High Pressure CO2 /CH4 Separations Using Carbon Molecular Sieve Hollow Fiber Membranes, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 41, 367 (2002). 68. N. Tanihara, H. Shimazaki, Y. Hirayama, N. Nakanishi, T. Yoshinaga and Y. Kusuki, Gas Permeation Properties of Asymmetric Carbon Hollow Fiber Membranes Prepared from Asymmetric Polymer Hollow Fibers, J. Membr. Sci. 160, 179 (1999). 69. A.B. Fuertes, Adsorption-selective Carbon Membranes for Gas Separation, J. Membr. Sci. 177, 9 (2000). 70. H. Kita, H. Maeda, K. Tanaka and K. Okamoto, Carbon Molecular Sieve Membranes Prepared from Phenolic Resin, Chem. Lett. 179 (1997). 71. I. Pinnau and L.G. Toy, Transport of Organic Vapors through Poly[1-(trimethylsilyl)1-propyne], J. Membr. Sci. 116, 199 (1996). 72. R. Srinivasan, S.R. Auvil and P.M. Burban, Elucidating the Mechanism(s) of Gas Transport in Poly[1-(trimethylsilyl)-1-propyne] (PTMSP) Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 86, 67 (1994). 73. J. Cadotte, R. Forester, M. Kim, R. Petersen and T. Stocker, Nanofiltration Membranes Broaden the Use of Membrane Separation Technology, Desalination 70, 77 (1988). 74. S. Egli, A. Ruf and F. Widmer, Entwicklung und Charakterisierung von Kompositmembranen f¨ur die Nano- und Ultrafiltration, Swiss Chem. 11(9), 53 (1989).
3 MEMBRANES AND MODULES Introduction The surge of interest in membrane separation processes that began in the late 1960s was prompted by two developments: first, the ability to produce high flux, essentially defect-free membranes on a large scale and second, the ability to form these membranes into compact, high-surface-area, economical membrane modules. These breakthroughs in membrane technology took place in the 1960s to early 1970s, as part of the development of reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration. Adaptation of the technology to other membrane processes took place in the 1980s. Several factors contribute to the successful fabrication of a high-performance membrane module. First, membrane materials with the appropriate chemical, mechanical and permeation properties must be selected; this choice is very process-specific. However, once the membrane material has been selected, the technology required to fabricate this material into a robust, thin, defect-free membrane and then to package the membrane into an efficient, economical, highsurface-area module is similar for all membrane processes. Therefore, this chapter focuses on methods of forming membranes and membrane modules. The criteria used to select membrane materials for specific processes are described in the chapters covering each application. In this chapter membrane preparation techniques are organized by membrane structure: isotropic membranes, anisotropic membranes, ceramic and metal membranes, and liquid membranes. Isotropic membranes have a uniform composition and structure throughout; such membranes can be porous or dense. Anisotropic (or asymmetric) membranes, on the other hand, consist of a number of layers each with different structures and permeabilities. A typical anisotropic membrane has a relatively dense, thin surface layer supported on an open, much thicker microporous substrate. The surface layer performs the separation and is the principal barrier to flow through the membrane. The open support layer provides mechanical strength. Ceramic and metal membranes can be either isotropic or anisotropic. Membrane Technology and Applications R. W. Baker 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 0-470-85445-6
90
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
However, these membranes are grouped separately from polymeric membranes because their preparation methods are so different. Liquid membranes are the final membrane category. The selective barrier in these membranes is a liquid phase, usually containing a dissolved carrier that selectively reacts with a specific permeant to enhance its transport rate through the membrane. Liquid membranes are used almost exclusively in carrier facilitated transport processes, so preparation of these membranes is covered in that chapter (Chapter 11). The membrane classification scheme described above works fairly well. However, a major membrane preparation technique, phase separation, also known as phase inversion, is used to make both isotropic and anisotropic membranes. This technique is covered under anisotropic membranes.
Isotropic Membranes Isotropic Nonporous Membranes Dense nonporous isotropic membranes are rarely used in membrane separation processes because the transmembrane flux through these relatively thick membranes is too low for practical separation processes. However, they are widely used in laboratory work to characterize membrane properties. In the laboratory, isotropic (dense) membranes are prepared by solution casting or thermal meltpressing. The same techniques can be used on a larger scale to produce, for example, packaging material. Solution Casting Solution casting is commonly used to prepare small samples of membrane for laboratory characterization experiments. An even film of an appropriate polymer solution is spread across a flat plate with a casting knife. The casting knife consists of a steel blade, resting on two runners, arranged to form a precise gap between the blade and the plate onto which the film is cast. A typical hand-held knife is shown in Figure 3.1. After casting, the solution is left to stand, and the solvent evaporates to leave a thin, uniform polymer film. A detailed description of many types of hand casting knives and simple casting machines is given in the book by Gardner and Sward [1]. The polymer solution used for solution casting should be sufficiently viscous to prevent it from running over the casting plate, so typical polymer concentrations are in the range 15–20 wt%. Preferred solvents are moderately volatile liquids such as acetone, ethyl acetate and cyclohexane. Films cast from these solutions are dry within a few hours. Solvents with high boiling points such as dimethyl formamide or N -methyl pyrrolidone are unsuitable for solution casting, because their low volatility requires long evaporation times. During an extended solvent evaporation time, the cast film can absorb sufficient atmospheric water to
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
91
5 0 5
5 0 5
Wet wedge film drawdown
ª
trate
Subs
Figure 3.1 A typical hand-casting knife. (Courtesy of Paul N. Gardner Company, Inc., Pompano Beach, FL)
precipitate the polymer, producing a mottled, hazy surface. Very volatile solvents such as methylene chloride can also cause problems. Rapid evaporation of the solvent cools the casting solution, causing gelation of the polymer. The result is a film with a mottled, orange-peel-like surface. Smooth films can be obtained with rapidly evaporating solvents by covering the cast film with a glass plate raised 1 to 2 cm above the film to slow evaporation. When the solvent has completely evaporated the dry film can be lifted from the glass plate. If the cast film adheres to the plate, soaking in a swelling non-solvent such as water or alcohol will usually loosen the film. Solution-cast film is produced on a larger scale for medical applications, battery separators, or other specialty uses with machinery of the type shown in Figure 3.2 [2]. Viscous film is made by this technique. The solution is cast onto the surface of a rotating drum or a continuous polished stainless steel belt. These machines are generally enclosed to control water vapor pickup by the film as it dries and to minimize solvent vapor losses to the atmosphere.
Melt Extruded Film Many polymers, including polyethylene, polypropylene, and nylons, do not dissolve in appropriate solvents at room temperature, so membranes cannot be made by solution casting. To prepare small pieces of film, a laboratory press
92
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Solventladen air
Casting solution
Solventladen Casting air solution
Dry film to take-up Air
Rotating drum
Rotating drum
AND
Stainless steel belt
APPLICATIONS
Stainless steel belt Dry film to take-up Air
Figure 3.2
Machinery used to make solution-cast film on a commercial scale
as shown in Figure 3.3 can be used. The polymer is compressed between two heated plates. Typically, a pressure of 2000–5000 psi is applied for 1–5 min, at a plate temperature just below the melting point of the polymer. Melt extrusion is also used on a very large scale to make dense films for packaging applications, either by extrusion as a sheet from a die or as blown film. Detailed descriptions of this equipment can be found in specialized monographs. A good overview is given in the article by Mackenzie in the Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology [2]. Isotropic Microporous Membranes Isotropic microporous membranes have much higher fluxes than isotropic dense membranes and are widely used as microfiltration membranes. Further significant uses are as inert spacers in battery and fuel cell applications and as the ratecontrolling element in controlled drug delivery devices. The most important type of microporous membrane is formed by one of the phase separation techniques discussed in the next section; about half of the isotropic microporous membrane used is made in this way. The remaining types are made by various proprietary techniques, the more important of which are described below. Track-etch Membranes Track-etch membranes were developed by the General Electric Corporation Schenectady Laboratory [3]. The two-step preparation process is illustrated in Figure 3.4. First, a thin polymer film is irradiated with fission particles from a nuclear reactor or other radiation source. The massive particles pass through the film, breaking polymer chains and leaving behind a sensitized track of damaged polymer molecules. These tracks are much more susceptible to chemical attack than the base polymer material. So when the film is passed through a solution
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
93
Figure 3.3 A typical laboratory press used to form melt-pressed membranes. (Courtesy of Carver, Inc., Wabash, IN)
that etches the polymer, the film is preferentially etched along the sensitized nucleation tracks, thereby forming pores. The exposure time of the film to radiation determines the number of membrane pores; the etch time determines the pore diameter [4]. A feature of the track-etch preparation technique is that the pores are uniform cylinders traversing the membrane at right angles. The
94
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Charged particles
Non-conducting material
‘Tracks’
Step 1: Polycarbonate film is exposed to charged particles in a nuclear reactor
Pores 10 µm Etch bath Step 2: The tracks left by the particles are preferentially etched into uniform, cylindrical pores
Figure 3.4 Diagram of the two-step process to manufacture nucleation track membranes [4] and photograph of resulting structure. (Photograph courtesy of Whatman plc, Maidstone, Kent, UK)
membrane tortuosity is, therefore, close to one, and all pores have the same diameter. These membranes are almost a perfect screen filter; therefore, they are widely used to measure the number and type of suspended particles in air or water. A known volume of fluid is filtered through the membrane, and all particles larger than the pore diameter are captured on the surface of the membrane so they can be easily identified and counted. To minimize the formation of doublet holes produced when two nucleation tracks are close together, the membrane porosity is usually kept relatively low, about 5 % or less. This low porosity results in low fluxes. General Electric, the original developers of these membranes, assigned the technology to a spin-off company, the Nuclepore Corporation, in 1972 [5]. Nuclepore membranes remain the principal commercially available tracketch membranes. Polycarbonate or polyester films are usually used as the base membrane material and sodium hydroxide as the etching solution. Other materials can also be used; for example, etched mica has been used in research studies. Expanded-film Membranes Expanded-film membranes are made from crystalline polymers by an orientation and annealing process. A number of manufacturers produce porous membranes
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
95
by this technique. The original development was due to a group at Celanese, which made microporous polypropylene membranes by this process under the trade name Celgard [6]. In the first step of the process, a highly oriented film is produced by extruding polypropylene at close to its melting point coupled with a very rapid drawdown. The crystallites in the semi-crystalline polymer are then aligned in the direction of orientation. After cooling and annealing, the film is stretched a second time, up to 300 %. During this second elongation the amorphous regions between the crystallites are deformed, forming slit-like ˚ wide, between the polymer crystallites. The pore size of voids, 200 to 2500 A the membrane is controlled by the rate and extent of the second elongation step. The formation process is illustrated in Figure 3.5. This type of membrane is also made from poly(tetrafluoroethylene) film by W.L. Gore and sold under the (a)
Direction of uniaxial stretching Melt extrusion die Drawing Lamellar Interlamellar region Bridging structure Micropores Stretching
(b)
1 µm
Figure 3.5 (a) Preparation method of a typical expanded polypropylene film membrane, in this case Celgard . (b) Scanning electron micrograph of the microdefects formed on uniaxial stretching of films [6]
96
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
trade name Gore-Tex [7]. Expanded film membrane was originally produced as rolled flat sheets. More recently the process has also been adapted to the production of hollow fibers [8]; Membrana produces this type of fiber on a large scale for use in blood oxygenator equipment (Chapter 12) and membrane contactors (Chapter 13). Gore-Tex poly(tetrafluoroethylene) film is widely used as a water-vapor-permeable (that is, breathable) but liquid-water-impermeable fabric. The commercial success of these membranes has motivated a number of other companies to produce similar materials [9,10]. Template Leaching Template leaching is another method of producing isotropic microporous membranes from insoluble polymers such as polyethylene, polypropylene and poly(tetrafluoroethylene). In this process a homogeneous melt is prepared from a mixture of the polymeric membrane matrix material and a leachable component. To finely disperse the leachable component in the polymer matrix, the mixture is often homogenized, extruded, and pelletized several times before final extrusion as a thin film. After formation of the film, the leachable component is removed with a suitable solvent, and a microporous membrane is formed [11–13]. The leachable component can be a soluble, low-molecular-weight solid, a liquid such as liquid paraffin, or even a polymeric material such as polystyrene. A drawing of a template leaching membrane production machine is shown in Figure 3.6.
Anisotropic Membranes Anisotropic membranes are layered structures in which the porosity, pore size, or even membrane composition change from the top to the bottom surface of the membrane. Usually anisotropic membranes have a thin, selective layer supported on a much thicker, highly permeable microporous substrate. Because the selective layer is very thin, membrane fluxes are high. The microporous substrate Hopper
Extruder Heat setting
Drier
Guide rolls
Die
Windup
Extraction
Chill roll
Diluent supply
Figure 3.6 Flow schematic of a melt extruder system used to make polypropylene membranes by template leaching [13]
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
97
provides the strength required for handling the membrane. The importance of anisotropic membranes was not recognized until Loeb and Sourirajan prepared the first high-flux, anisotropic reverse osmosis membranes by what is now known as the Loeb–Sourirajan technique [14]. Hindsight makes it clear that some of the membranes produced in the 1930s and 1940s were also anisotropic. Loeb and Sourirajan’s discovery was a critical breakthrough in membrane technology. Their anisotropic reverse osmosis membranes were an order of magnitude more permeable than the isotropic membranes produced previously from the same materials. For a number of years the Loeb–Sourirajan technique was the only method of making anisotropic membranes, but the demonstrated benefits of the anisotropic structure encouraged the development of other methods. Improvements in anisotropic membrane preparation methods and properties were accelerated by the availability in the late 1960s of the scanning electron microscope (SEM), which allowed the effects of changes in the membrane formation process on structure to be assessed easily. Membranes made by the Loeb–Sourirajan process consist of a single membrane material, but the porosity and pore size change in different layers of the membrane. Anisotropic membranes made by other techniques and used on a large scale often consist of layers of different materials which serve different functions. Important examples are membranes made by the interfacial polymerization process discovered by Cadotte [15] and the solution-coating processes developed by Ward [16], Francis [17] and Riley [18]. The following sections cover four types of anisotropic membranes: • Phase separation membranes. This category includes membranes made by the Loeb–Sourirajan technique involving precipitation of a casting solution by immersion in a nonsolvent (water) bath. Also covered are a variety of related techniques such as precipitation by solvent evaporation, precipitation by absorption of water from the vapor phase, and precipitation by cooling. • Interfacial polymerization membranes. This type of anisotropic membrane is made by polymerizing an extremely thin layer of polymer at the surface of a microporous support polymer. • Solution-coated composite membranes. To prepare these membranes, one or more thin, dense polymer layers are solution coated onto the surface of a microporous support. • Other anisotropic membranes. This category covers membranes made by a variety of specialized processes, such as plasma deposition, in the laboratory or on a small industrial scale to prepare anisotropic membranes for specific applications. Phase Separation Membranes The Loeb–Sourirajan technique is now recognized as a special case of a more general class of membrane preparation process, best called the phase separation
98
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Table 3.1 Phase separation membrane preparation procedures Procedure
Process
Water precipitation (the Loeb–Sourirajan process)
The cast polymer solution is immersed in a nonsolvent bath (typically water). Absorption of water and loss of solvent cause the film to rapidly precipitate from the top surface down
Water vapor absorption
The cast polymer solution is placed in a humid atmosphere. Water vapor absorption causes the film to precipitate
Thermal gelation
The polymeric solution is cast hot. Cooling causes precipitation
Solvent evaporation
A mixture of solvents is used to form the polymer casting solution. Evaporation of one of the solvents after casting changes the solution composition and causes precipitation
process, but sometimes called the phase inversion process or the polymer precipitation process. The term phase separation describes the process most clearly, namely, changing a one-phase casting solution into two separate phases. In all phase separation processes, a liquid polymer solution is precipitated into two phases: a solid, polymer-rich phase that forms the matrix of the membrane and a liquid, polymer-poor phase that forms the membrane pores. Precipitation of the cast liquid polymer solution to form the anisotropic membrane can be achieved in several ways, as summarized in Table 3.1. Precipitation by immersion in a bath of water was the technique discovered by Loeb and Sourirajan, but precipitation can also be caused by absorption of water from a humid atmosphere. A third method is to cast the film as a hot solution. As the cast film cools, a point is reached at which precipitation occurs to form a microporous structure; this method is called thermal gelation. Finally, evaporation of one of the solvents in the casting solution can be used to cause precipitation. In this technique the casting solution consists of a polymer dissolved in a mixture of a volatile good solvent and a less volatile nonsolvent (typically water or alcohol). When a film of the solution is cast and allowed to evaporate, the volatile good solvent evaporates first, the film then becomes enriched in the nonvolatile nonsolvent, and finally precipitates. Many combinations of these processes have also been developed. For example, a cast film placed in a humid atmosphere can precipitate partly because of water vapor absorption but also because of evaporation of one of the more volatile components. Polymer Precipitation by Water (the Loeb–Sourirajan Process) The first phase separation membrane was developed at UCLA from 1958 to 1960 by Sidney Loeb, then working on his Master’s degree, and Srinivasa Sourirajan, then a post-doctoral researcher. In their process, now called the Loeb–Sourirajan technique, precipitation is induced by immersing the cast film of polymer solution
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
99
in a water bath. In the original Loeb–Sourirajan process, a solution containing 20 to 25 wt% cellulose acetate dissolved in a water-miscible solvent was cast as a thin film on a glass plate. The film was left to stand for 10–100 s to allow some of the solvent to evaporate, after which the film was immersed in a water bath to precipitate the film and form the membrane. The membrane was usually post-treated by annealing in a bath of hot water. The steps of the process are illustrated in Figure 3.7. The Loeb–Sourirajan process remains by far the most important membranepreparation technique. The process is part of the overall membrane preparation procedure for almost all reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration and for many gas separation membranes. Reverse osmosis and gas separation membranes made by this technique consist of a completely dense top surface layer (the skin) on top of a microporous support structure. Ultrafiltration membranes, support membranes for solution coating, and interfacial polymerization membranes have the same general anisotropic structure, but the skin layer is very finely microp˚ diameter range. Also, the porous orous, typically with pores in the 10- to 200-A substrate of ultrafiltration membranes is usually more open, often consisting of large finger-like cavities extending from just under the selective skin layer to the bottom surface of the membrane. Scanning electron micrographs of typical sponge-structure reverse-osmosis type and finger-structure ultrafiltration-type membranes are shown in Figure 3.8 [19]. These photographs show how small
Casting
Evaporation
Precipitation
Annealing
Figure 3.7 Process scheme used to form Loeb–Sourirajan water precipitation phase separation membranes [14]
100
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
(a) Sponge structure cast from 22 wt% Nomex in dimethylacetamide
Top skin cross-section
Structure within the membrane 5µ
20 µ Bottom skin cross-section
(b) Finger structure cast from 18 wt% Nomex in dimethylacetamide
Top skin
Top skin cross-section 5µ
20 µ Structure within the membrane
Figure 3.8 Scanning electron micrographs of aromatic polyamide (Nomex, Du Pont) Loeb–Sourirajan membranes cast from 22 and 18 wt% Nomex in dimethylacetamide [19]
changes in the casting solution can produce major differences in membrane properties. Both membranes are prepared from a Nomex (DuPont, Wilmington, DE) polyamide-dimethylacetamide casting solution, but the polymer concentration in the solutions is different. The Loeb–Sourirajan water precipitation membranes shown in Figure 3.8 were made by casting the membranes onto glass plates. This procedure is still used in the laboratory, but for commercial production large casting machines produce rolls of membrane up to 5000 m long and 1 to 2 m wide. A diagram of a small casting machine is shown in Figure 3.9. The polymer solution is cast onto a moving nonwoven paper web. The cast film is then precipitated by immersion in a water bath. The water precipitates the top surface of the cast film rapidly,
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
101 Tensioning roller Fabric roll Spreader roller Squeegee wiper blade
Solution trough Doctor blade
Take-up roll
Adjustable level overflow Gel tank
Rinse tank Flowmeter
Drain
Tap Water
Overflow
Figure 3.9 Schematic of Loeb–Sourirajan membrane casting machine used to prepare reverse osmosis or ultrafiltration membranes. A knife and trough are used to coat the casting solution onto a nonwoven paper web. The coated web then enters the water-filled gel tank, where the casting solution precipitates. After the membrane has formed, it is washed thoroughly to remove residual solvent before being wound up on the take-up roll
forming the dense, selective skin. This skin slows entry of water into the underlying polymer solution, which precipitates much more slowly and forms a more porous substructure. Depending on the polymer, the casting solution, and other parameters, the thickness of the dense skin varies from 0.1 to 1.0 µm. Casting machine speeds vary from as low as 1 to 2 m/min for slowly precipitating casting solutions, such as cellulose acetate, to 10 m/min for rapidly precipitating casting solutions, such as polysulfone. A listing of some typical casting solutions and precipitation conditions for membranes made by the Loeb–Sourirajan technique is given in Table 3.2 [14,20–23]. Since the discovery of the Loeb–Sourirajan technique in the 1960s, development of the technology has proceeded on two fronts. Industrial users of the technology have generally taken an empirical approach, making improvements in the technique based on trial and error experience. Concurrently, theories of membrane formation based on fundamental studies of the precipitation process have been developed. These theories originated with the early industrial developers of membranes at Amicon [19,22,24] and were then taken up at a number of academic centers. Unfortunately, much of the recent academic work is so complex that many industrial producers of phase separation membranes no longer follow this literature.
102
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Table 3.2 Historically important examples of conditions for preparation of solutionprecipitation (Loeb–Sourirajan) membranes Casting solution composition
Precipitation conditions
Application and comments
22.2 wt% cellulose acetate (39.8 wt% acetyl polymer) 66.7 wt% acetone 10.0 wt% water 1.1 wt% magnesium perchlorate
3 min evaporation, precipitate into 0 ◦ C water, anneal for 5 min at 65–85 ◦ C
The first Loeb–Sourirajan reverse osmosis membrane [14]
25 wt% cellulose acetate (39.8 wt% acetyl polymer) 45 wt% acetone 30 wt% formamide
0.5–2 min evaporation, cast into 0 ◦ C water, anneal for 5 min at 65–85 ◦ C
The Manjikian formulation widely used in early 1970s for reverse osmosis membranes [20]
8.2 wt% cellulose acetate (39.8 wt% acetyl polymer) 8.2 wt% cellulose triacetate (43.2 wt% acetyl polymer) 45.1 wt% dioxane 28.7 wt% acetone 7.4 wt% methanol 2.5 wt% maleic acid
Up to 3 min evaporation at −10 ◦ C, precipitation into an ice bath, anneal at 85–90 ◦ C for 3 min
A high-performance reverse osmosis cellulose acetate blend membrane [21]
15 wt% polysulfone (Udell P 1700) 85 wt% N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone
Cast into 25 ◦ C water bath. No evaporation or annealing step necessary
An early ultrafiltration membrane formulation [22]. Similar polysulfone-based casting solutions are still widely used
20.9 wt% polysulfone 33.2 wt% dimethyl formamide 33.2 wt% tetrahydrofuran 12.6 wt% ethanol
Forced evaporation with humid air 10–15 s. Precipitate into 20 ◦ C water
A high-performance gas separation membrane with a completely dense ˚ nonporous skin ∼1000A thick [23]
Empirical Approach to Membrane Formation by Water Precipitation Over the years several rules of thumb have developed to guide producers of solution precipitation membranes. These rules can be summarized as follows: Choice of Polymer. The ideal polymer is a tough, amophorous, but not brittle thermoplastic with a glass transition temperature more than 50 ◦ C above the expected use temperature. A high molecular weight is important. Commercial polymers made for injection molding have molecular weights in the 30 000
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
103
to 40 000 Dalton range, but, for solution precipitation, polymers with higher molecular weights are usually preferable. If the polymer is crystalline or a rigid glass, the resulting membrane may be too brittle and will break if bent during later handling. The polymer must also be soluble in a suitable water-miscible solvent. Polymers that meet these specifications include cellulose acetate, polysulfone, poly(vinylidine fluoride), polyetherimide and aromatic polyamides. Choice of Casting Solution Solvent. Generally the best casting solution solvents are aprotic solvents such as dimethyl formamide, N -methyl pyrrolidone and dimethyl acetamide. These solvents dissolve a wide variety of polymers, and casting solutions based on these solvents precipitate rapidly when immersed in water to give porous, very anisotropic membranes. Casting solutions using lowsolubility-parameter solvents, such as tetrahydrofuran, acetone, dioxane and ethyl formate, are generally not appropriate. Such casting solutions precipitate slowly and give relatively nonporous membranes. However, small amounts of these solvents may be added as casting solution modifiers (see below). Figure 3.10 illustrates the apparent correlation between solvent solubility parameter and membrane porosity as demonstrated by So et al. [25]. 100 dimethyl acetamide 90
acetic acid dioxane
80 Membrane water content (wt%)
N -methyl dimethyl pyrrolidone sulfoxide dimethyl formamide
ethyl lactate
70
Rapid precipitation
triethyl phosphate
60 50
acetone
40 tetrahydrofuran
30 20
Slow precipitation
ethyl formate propylene oxide
10
From So et al. 1970 0 0 9
10
11
12
Solvent solubility parameter
Figure 3.10 The porosity of cellulose acetate membranes cast from 15-wt% solutions with various solvents. The same trend of high porosity and rapid precipitation with high solubility-parameter solvents was seen with a number of other membrane materials [25]
104
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Increasing the polymer casting solution concentration always reduces the porosity and flux of the membrane. Typical concentrations for porous ultrafiltration membranes are in the range 15–20 wt%. Polymer casting solution concentrations for reverse osmosis or gas separation membranes are higher, generally about 25 wt%, and casting solutions used to make hollow fiber membranes by spinning a hot solution at 60 to 80 ◦ C may contain as much as 35 % polymer. Precipitation Medium. Water is almost always the casting solution precipitation medium. Some work has been done with organic solvents, particularly to form hollow fiber membranes for which the mechanical and safety problems of handling an organic solvent precipitation bath and limiting atmospheric emissions are more easily controlled than in flat sheet casting. In general, the results obtained with nonaqueous precipitation baths have not justified the increased complexity of the process. Organic-based solvent precipitation media such as methanol or isopropanol almost always precipitate the casting solution more slowly than water, and the resulting membranes are usually denser, less anisotropic, and lower flux than membranes precipitated with water. The temperature of the water used to precipitate the casting solution is important; this temperature is controlled in commercial membrane plants. Generally low-temperature precipitation produces lower flux, more retentive membranes. For this reason chilled water is frequently used to prepare cellulose acetate reverse osmosis membranes. Casting Solution Modifiers. Membrane properties are often tailored by adding small amounts of modifiers to the casting solution. The casting solutions shown in Table 3.2 contain two to four components, but modern commercial casting solutions may be more complex. Even though the solution may contain only 5 to 20 wt% modifiers, these modifiers can change the membrane performance significantly. This aspect of membrane preparation is a black art, and most practitioners have their preferred ingredients. Addition of low solubility solvents such as acetone, tetrahydrofuran or dioxane will normally produce denser, more retentive membranes. Increasing the polymer concentration of the casting solution will also make the membrane more dense. Addition of salts such as zinc chloride and lithium chloride usually gives more open membranes. Polymeric additives may also be used—commonly poly(vinyl pyrrolidone) and poly(ethylene glycol); generally these polymers make the membrane more porous. Also, although most of these water-soluble polymers and salts are removed during precipitation and washing of the membrane, a portion remains trapped, making the final membrane more hydrophilic. When developing membranes from a new polymer, practitioners of the empirical approach usually prepare a series of trial casting solutions based on past experience with similar polymers. Membrane films are made by casting onto glass plates and precipitation in a water bath. The casting solutions most likely
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
105
to yield good membranes are often immediately apparent. The rate of precipitation is important. Slow precipitation produces dense, more isotropic membranes; rapid precipitation produces porous, anisotropic membranes. The appearance and mechanical properties of the membrane surface—shine, brittleness and thickness—compared to casting solution thickness also provide clues to the membrane structure. Based on these trials one or more casting solutions will be selected for systematic parametric development. Theoretical Approach to Membrane Formation Over the years several approaches have been used to rationalize the formation of Loeb–Sourirajan (solution precipitation) and other phase inversion membranes. Most have involved the polymer–solvent–precipitation medium phase diagrams popularized by Michaels [22], Strathmann [19,24,26] and Smolders [27–29]. In this approach the change in composition of the casting solution as membrane formation takes place is tracked as a path through the phase diagram. The path starts at a point representing the original casting solution and finishes at a point representing the composition of the final membrane. The casting solution composition moves to the final membrane composition by losing solvent and gaining water. A typical three-component phase diagram for the components used to prepare Loeb–Sourirajan membranes is shown in Figure 3.11. The corners of the Polymer Glassy region
Binodal boundary Metastable region
One-phase gel region
Typical initial casting solution composition
Spinodal boundary
One-phase stable solution region Unstable region Solvent Tie lines
Non-solvent (water)
Figure 3.11 Schematic of the three-component phase diagram often used to rationalize the formation of water-precipitation phase separation membranes
106
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
triangle represent the three pure components—polymer, solvent, and nonsolvent (water); points within the triangle represent mixtures of the three components. The diagram has two principal regions: a one-phase region, in which all components are miscible; and a two-phase region, in which the system separates into a solid (polymer-rich) phase and a liquid (polymer-poor) phase. During precipitation of the membrane casting solution, the solution loses solvent and gains water. The casting solution moves from a composition in the one-phase region to a composition in the two-phase region. Although the one-phase region in the phase diagram is thermodynamically continuous, for practical purposes it can be conveniently subdivided into a liquid polymer solution region, a polymer gel region, and a glassy solid polymer region. Thus, in the low-polymer-concentration region, typical of the original casting solution, the compositions are viscous liquids. But, if the concentration of polymer is increased, the viscosity of compositions in the one-phase region increases rapidly, reaching such high values that the system can be regarded as a solid gel. The transition between the liquid and gel regions is arbitrary but can be placed at a polymer concentration of 30 to 40 wt%. If the one-phase solution contains more than 90 wt% polymer, the swollen polymer gel may become so rigid that the polymer chains can no longer rotate. The polymer gel then becomes a solid polymer glass. During the precipitation process, the casting solution enters the two-phase region of the phase diagram by crossing the so-called binodal boundary. This brings the casting solution into a metastable two-phase region. Polymer solution compositions in this region are thermodynamically unstable but will not normally precipitate unless well nucleated. The metastable region in the phase diagrams of low-molecular-weight materials is very small, but can be large for high-molecular-weight materials. As more solvent leaves the casting solution and water enters the solution, the composition crosses into another region of the phase diagram in which a one-phase solution is always thermodynamically unstable. In this region, polymer solutions spontaneously separate into two phases with compositions linked by tie lines. The boundary between the metastable and unstable regions is called the spinodal boundary. Thus, the membrane precipitation process is a series of steps. First, solvent exchange with the precipitation medium occurs. Then, as the composition enters the two-phase region of the phase diagram, phase separation or precipitation begins. The time taken for solvent–water exchange before precipitation occurs can be measured because the membrane turns opaque as soon as precipitation begins. Depending on the casting solution composition, the time to first precipitation may be almost instantaneous to as long as 30–60 s. Initially, the polymer phase that separates on precipitation may be a liquid or semi-liquid gel, and the precipitation domains may be able to flow and agglomerate at this point. In the final step of the precipitation process, desolvation of the polymer phase converts the polymer to a relatively solid gel phase, and the membrane structure
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
107
is fixed. The solid polymer phase forms the matrix of the final membrane, and the liquid solvent–nonsolvent phase forms the pores. The precipitation behavior of polymer–solvent mixtures is further complicated by slow kinetics caused by the viscosity of polymer solutions and by thermodynamic effects that allow metastable solutions to exist for a prolonged time without precipitating. Much has been made of these effects in a number of theoretical papers, but application to concretely predicting membrane permeation properties has proved difficult. The original approach of Strathmann et al. [24] was to present the process of membrane formation as a line through the phase diagram. This approach is shown in Figure 3.12. During membrane formation, the composition changes from a composition A, which represents the initial casting solution composition, to a composition D, which represents the final membrane composition. At composition D, the two phases are in equilibrium: a solid (polymer-rich) phase, which forms the matrix of the final membrane, represented by point S, and a liquid (polymer-poor) phase, which constitutes the membrane pores filled with precipitant, represented by point L. The position of composition D on the line S-L determines the overall porosity of the membrane. The entire precipitation process is represented by the path A-D, along which the solvent is exchanged by the precipitant. The point B along the path is the concentration at which the
Polymer
S
D Initial casting solution B A
C
Two-phase region Point of solidification
Point of precipitation Solvent
L Non-solvent (water)
Figure 3.12 Membrane formation in water-precipitation membranes was first rationalized as a path through the three-component phase diagram from the initial polymer casting solution (A) to the final membrane (D) [24]
108
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
polymer initially precipitates. As precipitation proceeds, more solvent is lost, and precipitant is imbibed by the polymer-rich phase, raising the viscosity. At some point, the viscosity is high enough for the precipitated polymer to be regarded as a solid. This composition is at C in Figure 3.12. Once the precipitated polymer solidifies, further bulk movement of the polymer is hindered. The precipitation path in Figure 3.12 is shown as a single line representing the average composition of the whole membrane. In fact, the rate of precipitation and the precipitation path through the phase diagram differ at different points in the membrane. When the cast film of polymer solution is exposed to the precipitation medium, the top surface begins to precipitate first. This surface layer precipitates rapidly, so the two phases formed on precipitation do not have time to agglomerate. The resulting structure is finely microporous. However, the precipitated surface layer then becomes a barrier that slows further loss of solvent and imbibition of nonsolvent by the cast film. The result is increasingly slow precipitation from the top surface to the bottom surface of the film. As precipitation slows, the average pore size increases because the two phases formed on precipitation have more time to separate. The differences between the precipitation rates and the pathway taken by different places in the casting solution mean that the precipitation process is best represented by the movement of a line through the phase diagram rather than a single point. This concept was developed in a series of papers on phase-separation membranes by Smolders and co-workers at Twente University [27–29]. The movement of this line is illustrated in Figure 3.13 [27]. At time t2 , for example, a few seconds after the precipitation process has begun, the top surface of the polymer film has almost completely precipitated, and the composition of this surface layer is close to the polymer nonsolvent axis. On the other hand, at the bottom surface of the film where precipitation has only just begun, the composition is close to that of the original casting solution. In Figure 3.13 the precipitation pathway enters the two-phase region of the phase diagram above the critical point at which the binodal and spinodal lines intersect. This is important because it means that precipitation will occur as a liquid droplet in a continuous polymer-rich phase. If dilute casting solutions are used, in which the precipitation pathway enters the two-phase region of the phase diagram below the critical point, precipitation produces polymer gel particles in a continuous liquid phase. The membrane that forms is then weak and powdery. The simplified treatment of membrane formation using the three-component phase diagram given above is about as far as this approach can be usefully taken. Experimental measurement of the path taken by the membrane during the formation process is difficult. Recently, much effort has been made to calculate these pathways through the phase diagrams and to use them to predict the effect of membrane formation variables on the fine membrane structure. As quantitative predictors of membrane performance this approach has failed. However, as a tool to qualitatively rationalize the complex interplay of factors determining membrane performance, the phase diagram approach has proved useful. Many of the
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
109 Polymer
Precipitation path taken by top surface of membrane
t∞ Initial casting solution
t1
t2
t3
t0
Critical point
Solvent
t4
Precipitation path taken by bottom surface of membrane
Non-solvent (water)
Figure 3.13 The surface layer of water-precipitation membranes precipitates faster than the underlying substrate. The precipitation pathway is best represented by the movement of a line through the three-component phase diagram [27]
recent papers describing the application of the phase diagram approach to membrane formation are a heavy read for industrial membrane producers faced with real-world problems. This literature is reviewed in detail elsewhere [27,30–32]. Polymer Precipitation by Cooling Perhaps the simplest solution-precipitation membrane preparation technique is thermal gelation, in which a film is cast from a hot, one-phase polymer/solvent solution. As the cast film cools, the polymer precipitates, and the solution separates into a polymer matrix phase containing dispersed pores filled with solvent. Because cooling is usually uniform throughout the cast film, the resulting membranes are relatively isotropic microporous structures with pores that can be controlled within 0.1–10 µm. The precipitation process that forms thermal gelation membranes can be represented by the phase diagram shown in Figure 3.14 and described in an early Akzo patent of Castro [33]. This is a simplified drawing of the actual phase diagram, which was described later in papers by Lloyd et al. [34], Vadalia et al. [35] and Caneba and Soong [36]. The phase diagram shows the metastable region
110
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
One-Phase Liquid Region
Composition of polymer matrix phase
Initial temperature and composition of casting solution
Temperature
Composition of membrane pore phase
Liquid–liquid region
Spinodal boundary
0
Solid–Liquid region
20
40
60
80
100
Solution composition (% of solvent)
Figure 3.14 Phase diagram showing the composition pathway traveled by the casting solution during precipitation by cooling
between the binodal and spinodal phase boundaries discussed in reference to Figure 3.11, with additional complications caused by the crystalline nature of many of the polymers used to form thermal phase-separation membranes. The pore volume in the final membrane is determined mainly by the initial composition of the solution, because this determines the ratio of the polymer to liquid phase in the cooled film. However, the spatial distribution and size of the pores are determined largely by the rate of cooling and hence, precipitation of the film. In general, more rapid cooling produces smaller membrane pores and greater membrane anisotropy [37,38]. Membrane preparation by thermal gelation is possible with many polymers, but the technique is used mainly to make membranes from polyethylene and polypropylene, which cannot be formed into microporous membranes by standard solution-casting methods. Polymer precipitation by cooling to produce microporous membranes was first developed and commercialized by Akzo [33,37], which continues to market microfiltration polypropylene and poly(vinylidene fluoride) membranes produced by this technique under the trade name Accurel . Flat sheet and hollow fiber membranes are made. Polypropylene membranes are prepared from a solution of polypropylene in N ,N -bis(2-hydroxyethyl)tallowamine. The amine
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
111
and polypropylene form a clear solution at temperatures above 100–150 ◦ C. Upon cooling, the solvent and polymer phases separate to form a microporous structure. If the solution is cooled slowly, an open cell structure of the type shown in Figure 3.15(a) results. The interconnecting passageways between cells are generally in the micrometer range. If the solution is cooled and precipitated (a)
50 µm (b)
20 µm
Figure 3.15 Polypropylene structures. (a) Type I: open cell structure formed at low cooling rates. (b) Type II: fine structure formed at high cooling rates [37]. Reprinted with permission from W.C. Hiatt, G.H. Vitzthum, K.B. Wagener, K. Gerlach and C. Josefiak, Microporous Membranes via Upper Critical Temperature Phase Separation, in Materials Science of Synthetic Membranes, D.R. Lloyd (ed.), ACS Symposium Series Number 269, Washington, DC. Copyright 1985, American Chemical Society and American Pharmaceutical Association
112
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Polymer solution preparation Membrane inspection Water-cooled chill roll
Extraction and after-treatment
Drying
Take-up
Solvent Solvent recovery
Extraction liquid
Figure 3.16 Equipment to prepare microporous membranes by the polymer precipitation by cooling technique [37]. Reprinted with permission from W.C. Hiatt, G.H. Vitzthum, K.B. Wagener, K. Gerlach and C. Josefiak, Microporous Membranes via Upper Critical Temperature Phase Separation, in Materials Science of Synthetic Membranes, D.R. Lloyd (ed.), ACS Symposium Series Number 269, Washington, DC. Copyright 1985, American Chemical Society and American Pharmaceutical Association
rapidly, a much finer structure is formed, as shown in Figure 3.15(b). The rate of cooling is, therefore, a key parameter determining the final structure of the membrane. The anisotropy of the membranes can be increased by cooling the top and bottom surface of the cast film at different rates. A schematic diagram of a commercial-scale thermal gelation polymer precipitation process is shown in Figure 3.16. The hot polymer solution is cast onto a water-cooled chill roll, which cools the solution, causing the polymer to precipitate. The precipitated film is passed through an extraction tank containing methanol, ethanol or isopropanol to remove the solvent. Finally, the membrane is dried, sent to a laser inspection station, trimmed and rolled up. Polymer Precipitation by Solvent Evaporation This technique, one of the earliest methods of making microporous membranes, was used by Bechhold, Elford, Pierce, Ferry and others in the 1920s and 1930s [39–43]. In the simplest form of the method, a polymer is dissolved in a twocomponent solvent mixture consisting of a volatile solvent, such as methylene chloride or acetone, in which the polymer is readily soluble, and a less volatile nonsolvent, typically water or an alcohol. The polymer solution is cast onto a glass plate. As the volatile solvent evaporates, the casting solution is enriched in the nonvolatile solvent, so the polymer precipitates, forming the membrane structure. The process can be continued until the membrane has completely formed, or it
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
113
can be stopped, and the membrane structure fixed, by immersing the cast film in a precipitation bath of water or other nonsolvent. The precipitation process used to form these membranes is much slower than precipitation by immersion into liquid water (the Loeb–Sourirajan process). As a result membranes formed by solvent evaporation are only modestly anisotropic and have large pores. Scanning electron micrographs of some membranes made by this process are shown in Figure 3.17 [44]. Many factors determine the porosity and pore size of membranes formed by the solvent evaporation method. As Figure 3.17 shows, if the membrane is immersed in a nonsolvent after a short evaporation time, the resulting structure will be finely microporous. If the evaporation step is prolonged before fixing the structure by immersion in water, the average pore size will be larger. In general, increasing the nonsolvent content of the casting solution, or decreasing the polymer concentration, increases porosity. It is important for the nonsolvent to be completely incompatible with the polymer. If partially compatible nonsolvents 1 min
3 min
10 min
26 min
10 µm
Figure 3.17 SEM photomicrographs of the bottom surface of cellulose acetate membranes cast from a solution of acetone (volatile solvent) and 2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol (nonvolatile nonsolvent). The evaporation time before the structure is fixed by immersion in water is shown [44]. Reprinted from J. Membr. Sci., 87, L. Zeman and T. Fraser, Formation of Air-cast Cellulose Acetate Membranes, p. 267, Copyright 1994, with permission from Elsevier
114
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
are used, the precipitating polymer phase contains sufficient residual solvent to allow it to flow, and the pores will collapse as the solvent evaporates. The result is a dense rather than a microporous film.
Polymer Precipitation by Absorption of Water Vapor Preparation of microporous membranes by solvent evaporation alone is not widely practiced. However, a combination of solvent evaporation and absorption of water vapor from a humid atmosphere is an important method of making microfiltration membranes. The processes involve proprietary casting formulations not normally disclosed by membrane developers. However, during the development of composite membranes at Gulf General Atomic, Riley et al. prepared this type of membrane and described the technology in some detail in a series of Office of Saline Water Reports [45]. These reports remain the best published description of the technique. Casting solutions used to prepare these membranes are complex and often contain 5 to 10 components. For example, a typical casting solution composition taken from Riley’s report [45] comprises 8.1 wt% cellulose nitrate, 1.3 wt% cellulose acetate, 49.5 wt% acetone (a volatile good solvent), 22.3 wt% ethanol and 14.7 wt% n-butanol (nonvolatile poor solvents), 2.6 wt% water (a nonsolvent), 0.5 wt% Triton X-100 (a surfactant solution modifier), and 1.2 wt% glycerin (a polymer plasticizer). The type of equipment used by Riley et al. is shown in Figure 3.18. The casting solution is cast onto a moving stainless steel belt. The cast film then passes through a series of environmental chambers. Warm, humid air is usually circulated through the first chamber, where the film loses the volatile solvent by evaporation and simultaneously absorbs water. A key issue is to avoid formation of a dense surface skin on the air side of the membrane. Dense skin formation is Doctor blade
Environmental chambers Membrane
Casting solution Take-up roll Stainless steel belt
Figure 3.18 Schematic of casting machine used to make microporous membranes by water vapor absorption. A casting solution is deposited as a thin film on a moving stainless steel belt. The film passes through a series of humid and dry chambers, where the solvent evaporates from the solution, and water vapor is absorbed. This precipitates the polymer, forming a microporous membrane that is taken up on a collection roll [45]
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
115
generally prevented by incorporating sufficient polymer nonsolvent in the casting solution. Polymer precipitation and formation of two phases then occur when even a small portion of the volatile solvent component in the mixture evaporates. The total precipitation process is slow, taking about 10–30 min to complete. Typical casting speeds are of the order of 1 to 5 ft/min. To allow higher casting speeds the casting machine must be very long—commercial machines can be up to 100 feet. The resulting membrane structure is more isotropic and more microporous than membranes precipitated by immersion in water. After precipitation in the environmental chambers, the membrane passes to a second oven, through which hot, dry air is circulated to evaporate the remaining solvent and dry the film. The formed membrane is then wound onto a take-up roll. This type of membrane is widely used in microfiltration. Membranes made by the water vapor absorption-solvent evaporation precipitation process often have the characteristic nodular form shown in Figure 3.19. A discussion of some of the
10 µm
Figure 3.19 Characteristic structure of a phase-separation membrane made by water vapor absorption and solvent evaporation. (Courtesy of Millipore Corporation, Billerica, MA)
116
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
practical considerations involved in making this type of membrane is given in a recent book by Zeman and Zydney [46]. Interfacial Polymerization Membranes The production by Loeb and Sourirajan of the first successful anisotropic membranes spawned numerous other techniques in which a microporous membrane is used as a support for a thin, dense separating layer. One of the most important of these was interfacial polymerization, an entirely new method of making anisotropic membranes developed by John Cadotte, then at North Star Research. Reverse osmosis membranes produced by this technique had dramatically improved salt rejections and water fluxes compared to those prepared by the Loeb–Sourirajan process. Almost all reverse osmosis membranes are now made by the interfacial polymerization process, illustrated in Figure 3.20. In this method, an aqueous solution of a reactive prepolymer, such as a polyamine, is first deposited in the pores of a microporous support membrane, typically a polysulfone ultrafiltration membrane. The amine-loaded support is then immersed in a water-immiscible solvent solution containing a reactant, such as a diacid chloride in hexane. The amine and acid chloride react at the interface of the two immiscible Hexane-acid chloride solution
Aqueous amine solution
Surface of polysulfone support film
Amine coating
Crosslinked amine
Reacted zone
Figure 3.20 Schematic of the interfacial polymerization process. The microporous film is first impregnated with an aqueous amine solution. The film is then treated with a multivalent crosslinking agent dissolved in a water-immiscible organic fluid, such as hexane or Freon-113. An extremely thin polymer film forms at the interface of the two solutions [47]. Reprinted from L.T. Rozelle, J.E. Cadotte, K.E. Cobian, and C.V. Knopp, Jr, Nonpolysaccharide Membranes for Reverse Osmosis: NS-100 Membranes, in Reverse Osmosis and Synthetic Membranes, S. Sourirajan (ed.), National Research Council Canada, Ottawa, Canada (1977) by permission from NRC Research Press
MEMBRANES
MODULES
AND
117
solutions to form a densely crosslinked, extremely thin membrane layer. The first membrane made by Cadotte was based on polyethyleneimine crosslinked with toluene-2,4-diisocyanate, to form the structure shown in Figure 3.21 [47]. The process was later refined by Cadotte et al. at FilmTec Corp. [15,48], Riley et al. at UOP [49], and Kamiyama et al. [50] at Nitto in Japan. Membranes made by interfacial polymerization have a dense, highly crosslinked polymer layer formed on the surface of the support membrane at the interface of the two solutions. A less crosslinked, more permeable hydrogel layer forms under this surface layer and fills the pores of the support membrane. The dense, crosslinked polymer layer, which can only form at the interface, is extremely thin, on the order of 0.1 µm or less, so the membrane permeability is high. Because the polymer is highly crosslinked, its selectivity is also high. Although the crosslinked interfacial polymer layer determines membrane selectivity, the nature of the microporous support film affects membrane flux
CH3 O N
O NH
NHC
NH
NHC NH
N
NH
N
NH
NH NH
N N
N N NH
CH3
NH
NH
NH
N
NH
NH NH
N
C
NH NH
O
C
NH
NH
N CH3
NH
NH
N
N
O N
NH
NH2 NH
C
NH
O
HN
C
NH
O
CH2CH2 groups represented by
Figure 3.21 Idealized structure of polyethyleneimine crosslinked with toluene 2,4-diisocyanate. This was called the NS-100 membrane. The chemistry was first developed by Cadotte to make interfacial reverse osmosis membranes with almost twice the water flux and one-fifth the salt leakage of the best reverse osmosis membranes then available. Even better membranes have since been developed by Cadotte and others [47]
118
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
significantly. The film has to be very finely porous to withstand the high pressures applied but must also have a high surface porosity so it is not a barrier to flow. The first reverse osmosis membranes made by the interfacial polymerization method were five times less salt-permeable than the best cellulose acetate Loeb–Sourirajan membranes but had better water fluxes. Since then interfacial polymerization chemistry has been refined. The first membrane produced by this method (and shown in Figure 3.21) was based on the reaction of a polyethyleneimine (in water) and toluene-2,4-diisocyanate or isophthaloyl chloride (in hexane). These NS-100 membranes had very good permeation properties but were very sensitive to even trace amounts (ppb levels) of chlorine commonly used as an antibacterial agent in water. The chlorine caused chain cleavage of the polymer at the amide bonds resulting in loss of salt rejection. A number of other chemistries have been developed over the years; the FT-30 membrane produced by reaction of phenylenediamine with trimesoyl chloride, also developed by Cadotte when at FilmTec (Dow Chemical), is particularly important. This membrane, which has a high water flux and consistent salt rejections of greater than 99.5 % with seawater [51], made single-pass seawater desalination with anisotropic membranes possible. A more detailed description of the chemistry of interfacial composite membranes is given in the discussion of reverse osmosis membranes in Chapter 5 and in a review by Petersen [48]. Production of interfacial polymerization membranes in the laboratory is relatively easy, but development of equipment to produce these membranes on a large scale required some ingenuity. The problem is the fragility of the interfacial surface film, which cannot be handled once formed. One solution to this problem is illustrated in Figure 3.22. The polysulfone or other material used as the support film is first immersed in an aqueous amine bath. On leaving this bath the membrane passes to a second organic acid chloride bath and then through a drying/curing oven. The transfer rollers are arranged so that the surface layer of the polymer on which the membrane forms never contacts a roller. On leaving the oven, the interfacial membrane is completely formed. This membrane is then coated with a protective solution of a water-soluble polymer such as poly(vinyl alcohol). When this solution is dried, the membrane is wound onto a take-up roll. The poly(vinyl alcohol) layer protects the membrane from damage during subsequent handling as it is formed into spiral-wound modules. When the module is used for the first time, the feed water washes off the water-soluble poly(vinyl alcohol) layer to expose the interfacial polymerized membrane, and the module is ready for use. Interfacial polymerization membranes are widely used in reverse osmosis and nanofiltration but not for gas separation because of the water-swollen hydrogel that fills the pores of the support membrane. In reverse osmosis, this layer is hydrated and offers little resistance to water flow, but when the membrane is dried for use in gas separation the gel becomes a rigid glass with very low gas permeability. This glassy polymer fills the membrane pores and, as a result, defect-free
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
119
Oven
Composite support membrane feed roll
Oven
Take-up roll
Aqueous amine
Organic acid chloride phase Protective coating solution
Figure 3.22 Schematic of the type of machinery used to make interfacial composite membranes
interfacial composite membranes usually have low gas fluxes, although their selectivities can be good.
Solution-coated Composite Membranes Another important group of anisotropic composite membranes is formed by solution-coating a thin (0.5–2.0 µm) selective layer on a suitable microporous support. Membranes of this type were first prepared by Ward, Browall, and others at General Electric [52] and by Forester and Francis at North Star Research [17,53] using a type of Langmuir trough system. In this system, a dilute polymer solution in a volatile water-insoluble solvent is spread over the surface of a water-filled trough. The apparatus used to make small sections of water-cast composite membranes is shown in Figure 3.23. The dilute polymer solution is cast on the surface between two Teflon rods. The rods are then moved apart to spread the film. The thin polymer film formed on the water surface is picked up on a microporous support. The main problem with this method is the transfer of the fragile, ultrathin film onto the microporous support. This is usually done by sliding the support
120
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Layer of polymer solution
Water bath
Movable teflon rods
Figure 3.23 Schematic of the apparatus developed by Ward et al. [52] to prepare watercast composite membranes. Reprinted from J. Membr. Sci., 1, W.J. Ward, III, W.R. Browall and R.M. Salemme, Ultrathin Silicone Rubber Membranes for Gas Separations, p. 99, Copyright 1976, with permission from Elsevier
membrane under the spread film. With care, small pieces of membrane as thin ˚ can be made. as 200 A The water-casting procedure was scaled up to produce continuous composite membrane films at General Electric. Figure 3.24 shows a schematic of the system used to produce composite polycarbonate-silicone copolymer membranes for small air separation units to produce oxygen-enriched air for medical use. The polymer casting solution added to the surface of the water bath spreads as a thin film and is picked up on the moving microporous support membrane. Membranes as thin as 0.1–0.2 µm can be made. This water-casting technique was used at General Electric and its spinoff, the Oxygen Enrichment Company, to make gas separation membranes for several years in the 1970s. The technique has also been adapted to coat hollow fiber membranes for gas separation applications [54,55]. Currently, most solution-coated composite membranes are prepared by the method first developed by Riley and others [45,56,57]. In this technique, a polymer solution is cast directly onto the microporous support. The support must be clean, defect-free and very finely microporous, to prevent penetration of the coating solution into the pores. If these conditions are met, the support can be coated with a liquid layer 50–100 µm thick, which after evaporation leaves a thin selective film 0.5–2 µm thick. A schematic drawing of the meniscuscoating technique is shown in Figure 3.25 [58]. Obtaining defect-free films by this technique requires considerable attention to the preparation procedure and the coating solution.
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
121
Microporous support
Composite membrane
Polymer disolved in waterimmiscible solvent
Water
Figure 3.24 Method developed by Ward, Browall and others at General Electric to make multilayer composite membranes by the water casting technique [55]
The characteristics of the microporous support are very important. Because the selective layer is extremely thin, the support layer can contribute significantly to the total resistance to transport through the membrane. Not only does the resistance of the support decrease the flux through the membrane, but it can affect the separation [32,59]. To achieve the intrinsic selectivity of the selective membrane layer, the flux of the uncoated support material must be at least 10 times that of the coated support. This ensures that more than 90 % of the resistance to flow lies within the selective coating layer. As well as having a high flux, the surface layer of the microporous support material must also be very finely microporous. The pores must be small enough to support the thin selective layer under high pressure, and must also be close together so the permeating components do not take a long tortuous path to reach the pore. When the selective layer is only a few tenths of a micrometer thick this requirement may be difficult to meet. One solution to the problem is an intermediate gutter layer of a highly permeable polymer between the microporous support and the selective layer. The gutter layer material is much more permeable than the thin selective layer and acts as a conduit to transport material to the support membrane pores. Finally, because the selective layer of the composite membrane is often very thin and correspondingly delicate, such membranes are often protected by a sealing layer, also formed from a highly permeable material, to protect the membrane from damage during handling. A schematic of a multilayer composite membrane of this type is shown in Figure 3.26 together with a scanning electron micrograph. A discussion of the issues involved in preparing this type of membrane is found in the review by Koros and Pinnau [32].
122
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Drying oven
Feed roll Applicator system
Variable speed motor-driven take-up roll Dip-coating tank
Microporous substrate
Dip roller Surface coating
Polymer solution
Figure 3.25 Schematic diagram of a film coating apparatus [58]
Other Anisotropic Membranes Most anisotropic membranes are produced by solution precipitation, interfacial polymerization or solution coating. A number of other techniques developed in the laboratory are reviewed briefly below; none are used on a large scale. Plasma Polymerization Membranes Plasma polymerization of films was first used to form electrical insulation and protective coatings, but a number of workers have also prepared selective membranes by this method [60–63]. A simple plasma polymerization apparatus is
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
123 High-flux protective surface layer 1 − 2 µm Selective layer 0.05 − 0.2 µm
High-flux gutter layer 1 − 2 µm
Porous support
Permeate flow
Selective layer
Microporous support
5 µm
Figure 3.26 Schematic and scanning electron micrograph of a multilayer composite membrane on a microporous support. (Courtesy of Membrane Technology and Research, Inc.)
shown in Figure 3.27. Most workers used radio frequency fields at frequencies of 2–50 MHz to generate the plasma. In a typical plasma experiment helium, argon, or another inert gas is introduced at a pressure of 50–100 mTorr and a plasma is initiated. Monomer vapor is then introduced to bring the total pressure to 200–300 mTorr. These conditions are maintained for a period of 1–10 min, during which a thin polymer film is deposited on the membrane sample held in the plasma field.
124
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Gas Transformer
Bell jar Electrodes Porous film
To vacuum pump
Figure 3.27 Simple bell jar plasma coating apparatus
Monomer polymerization proceeds by a complex mechanism involving ionized molecules and radicals and is completely different from conventional polymerization reactions. In general, the polymer films are highly crosslinked and may contain radicals that slowly react on standing. The stoichiometry of the film may also be quite different from the original monomer due to fragmentation of monomer molecules during the plasma polymerization process. The susceptibility of monomers to plasma polymerization or the characteristics of the resulting polymer film are difficult to predict. For example, many vinyl and acrylic monomers polymerize very slowly, whereas unconventional monomers such as benzene and hexane polymerize readily. The vapor pressure of the monomers, the power and voltage used in the discharge reaction, and the type and temperature of the substrate all affect the polymerization reaction. The inert gas used in the plasma may also enter into the reaction. Nitrogen and carbon monoxide, for example, are particularly reactive. In summary, the products of plasma polymerization are ill-defined and vary according to the experimental procedures. However, the resulting films can be very thin and have been shown to be quite selective. The most extensive studies of plasma-polymerized membranes were performed in the 1970s and early 1980s by Yasuda, who tried to develop high-performance reverse osmosis membranes by depositing plasma films onto microporous polysulfone films [60,61]. More recently other workers have studied the gas permeability of plasma-polymerized films. For example, Stancell and Spencer [62] were able to obtain a gas separation plasma membrane with a hydrogen/methane selectivity of almost 300, and Kawakami et al. [63] have reported plasma membranes
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
125
with an oxygen/nitrogen selectivity of 5.8. Both selectivities are good compared to those of other membranes, and the plasma films were also quite thin. However, in both cases the plasma film was formed on a substrate made from a thick (25–100 µm), dense polymer film, so the flux through the composite membrane was still low. Scale-up of plasma polymerization is likely to prove difficult, so the process will remain a laboratory technique until membranes with unique properties are produced.
Dynamically Formed Membranes In the late 1960s and early 1970s, much attention was devoted to preparing dynamically formed anisotropic membranes, principally by Johnson, Kraus and others at Oak Ridge National Laboratory [64,65]. The general procedure is to form a layer of inorganic or polymeric colloids on the surface of a microporous support membrane by filtering a solution containing suspended colloid through the support membrane. A thin colloidal layer is laid down on the membrane surface and acts as a semipermeable membrane. Over time the colloidal surface layer is lost, and membrane performance falls. The support membrane is then cleaned, and a new layer of colloid is deposited. In the early development of this technique a wide variety of support membranes were used. Recently, microporous ceramic or porous carbon tubes have become the most commonly used materials. Typical colloidal materials used to make the selective membrane layer are polyvinyl methyl ether, acrylic acid copolymers or hydrated metal oxides such as zirconium hydroxide. Dynamically formed membranes were pursued for many years for reverse osmosis because of their high water fluxes and relatively good salt rejection, especially with brackish water feeds. However, the membranes proved to be unstable and difficult to reproduce reliably and consistently. For these reasons, and because high-performance interfacial composite membranes were developed in the meantime, dynamically formed reverse osmosis membranes fell out of favor. A small application niche in high-temperature nanofiltration and ultrafiltration remains, and Rhˆone Poulenc continues their production. The principal application is poly(vinyl alcohol) recovery from hot wash water produced in textile dyeing operations.
Reactive Surface Treatment Recently several groups have tried to improve the properties of anisotropic gas separation membranes by chemically modifying the surface selective layer. For example, Langsam at Air Products and Paul et al. at the University of Texas, Austin have treated films and membranes with dilute fluorine gas [66–71]. In this treatment fluorine chemically reacts with the polymer structure. By careful
126
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Table 3.3 Effect of fluorination on the carbon dioxide/methane selectivity of various glassy membrane materials Base polymer
Poly(1-trimethylsilyl-1-propyne) (PTMSP) [69] Poly(phenylene oxide) [71] Poly(4-methyl-1-pentene) [70]
Carbon dioxide/methane selectivity Before fluorination
After fluorination
2.0
48
15 5.4
50–60 30–40
˚ control of the process conditions, the reaction can be limited to a 100- to 200-A surface layer. The dramatic improvements in selectivity produced by this surface treatment are illustrated by the data in Table 3.3. Scaling up this process for safe operation on a large scale will be difficult, but several groups are studying the approach. Ozone has also been suggested as a possible reactive surface treatment agent [72].
Repairing Membrane Defects In preparing anisotropic membranes, the goal is to make the selective layer that performs the separation as thin as possible, but still defect free. Over the past 20 years, a great deal of work has been devoted to understanding the factors that determine the properties and thickness of the selective layer. The selective layer can be dense, as in reverse osmosis or gas separation membranes, or finely ˚ diameter range, as in ultrafiltramicroporous with pores in the 100- to 500-A ˚ tion membranes. In good quality membranes a thickness as low as 500–1000 A can be achieved, but with layers as thin as this, formation of minute membrane defects is a problem. The defects, caused by gas bubbles, dust particles and support fabric imperfections, can be very difficult to eliminate. Such defects may not significantly affect the performance of anisotropic membranes used in liquid separation processes, such as ultrafiltration and reverse osmosis, but can be disastrous in gas separation applications. Browall [55] solved this problem by overcoating defective solution-cast composite membranes with a second thin coating layer of a highly permeable polymer to seal defects, as shown in Figure 3.28. Later Henis and Tripodi [73] showed that membrane defects in anisotropic Loeb–Sourirajan membranes could be overcome in a similar way by coating the membrane with a thin layer of a relatively permeable material such as silicone rubber. A sufficiently thin coating does not change the properties of the underlying selective layer but does plug defects, through which simple convective gas flow can occur. Henis and Tripodi’s membrane is illustrated in Figure 3.29. The silicone rubber layer is many times more permeable than the selective layer and
MEMBRANES Coating layer
AND
MODULES
127 Dust particles causing membrane defect Dust particles
Selective layer Microporous support
Figure 3.28 Method developed by Ward, Browall and others at General Electric to seal membrane defects in composite membranes made by the water coating technique [55] (a) Defective Loeb-Sourirajan anisotropic membrane Defect Selective layer
Porous support layer
(b) Henis and Tripodi silicone rubber-coated membrane Defect sealing layer Defect Selective layer
Porous support layer
Figure 3.29 Schematic of (a) Loeb–Sourirajan and (b) Henis and Tripodi gas separation membranes [73]
128
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
does not function as a selective barrier but rather plugs defects, thereby reducing non-diffusive gas flow. The flow of gas through the portion of the silicone rubber layer over the pore is high compared to the flow through the defect-free portion of the membrane. However, because the area of membrane defects is very small, the total gas flow through these plugged defects is negligible. When this coating technique is used, the polysulfone skin layer of the Loeb–Sourirajan membrane no longer has to be completely defect free; therefore, the membrane can be made with a thinner skin than is possible with an uncoated membrane. The increase in flux obtained by decreasing the thickness of the selective skin layer more than compensates for the slight reduction in flux due to the silicone rubber sealing layer.
Metal Membranes and Ceramic Membranes Metal Membranes Metal membranes, particularly palladium-based, have been considered for hydrogen separation for a long time. In the 1950s and 1960s, Union Carbide installed and operated a palladium membrane plant to separate hydrogen from a refinery off-gas stream [74]. The plant produced 99.9 % pure hydrogen in a single pass through 25-µm-thick palladium membranes. However, even at a feed pressure of 450 psi, the membranes had to be operated at 370 ◦ C to obtain a useful transmembrane hydrogen flux. A further problem was the very high membrane cost; a 25-µm-thick palladium membrane requires approximately 250 g palladium/m2 of membrane. At current palladium costs of US$20/g, the metal cost alone is US$5000/m2 of membrane, which is 50 times the total cost of typical polymeric membranes used for gas separations. Small-scale palladium membrane systems, to produce ultrapure hydrogen for specialized applications, are marketed by Johnson Matthey and Company. These systems use palladium/silver alloy membranes based on those developed by Hunter [75,76]. If noble metal membranes are ever to be used on a large scale their cost ˚ must be reduced. One approach [77,78] is to sputter-coat a 500- to 1000-A film of the metal on a polymer support. Because the film is extremely thin these membranes have extremely high hydrogen fluxes even at room temperature. Another approach, used by Buxbaum [79,80], is to coat a thin layer of palladium on a tantalum or vanadium support film. Tantalum and vanadium are also quite permeable to hydrogen and much less expensive than palladium. These metals cannot be used alone because they easily form an impenetrable oxide surface film. However, protected by a thin palladium layer, these membranes are quite permeable at high temperatures. Edlund [81,82] is pursuing a similar approach. A detailed discussion of hydrogen permeation in metals is given in the book by Alefeld and V¨olkl [83].
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
129
Ceramic Membranes Metal Oxide Membranes Several companies have developed inorganic ceramic membranes for ultrafiltration and microfiltration. These microporous membranes are made from aluminum, titanium or silica oxides. Ceramic membranes have the advantages of being chemically inert and stable at high temperatures, conditions under which polymer membranes fail. This stability makes ceramic microfiltration/ultrafiltration membranes particularly suitable for food, biotechnology and pharmaceutical applications in which membranes require repeated steam sterilization and cleaning with aggressive solutions. Pore diameters in ceramic membranes for microfiltration and ultrafiltration range from 0.01 to 10 µm; these membranes are generally made by a slip coating-sintering procedure. Other techniques, particularly sol-gel ˚ Sol-gel methods, are used to produce membranes with pores from 10 to 100 A. membranes are the subject of considerable research interest particularly for gas separation applications, but so far have found only limited commercial use. A number of reviews covering the general area of ceramic membrane preparation and use have appeared recently [84,85]. In the slip coating-sintering process a porous ceramic support tube is made by pouring a dispersion of a fine-grain ceramic material and a binder into a mold and sintering at high temperature. The pores between the particles that make up this support tube are large. One surface of the tube is then coated with a suspension of finer particles in a solution of a cellulosic polymer or poly(vinyl alcohol) which acts as a binder and viscosity enhancer to hold the particles in suspension. This mixture is called a slip suspension; when dried and sintered at high temperatures, a finely microporous surface layer remains. Usually several slip-coated layers are applied in series, each layer being formed from a suspension of progressively finer particles and resulting in an anisotropic structure. Most commercial ceramic ultrafiltration membranes are made this way, generally in the form of tubes or perforated blocks. A scanning electron micrograph of the surface of this type of multilayer membrane is shown in Figure 3.30. The slip coating-sintering procedure can be used to make membranes with pore ˚ More finely porous membranes are made diameters down to about 100–200 A. by sol-gel techniques. In the sol-gel process slip coating is taken to the colloidal level. Generally the substrate to be coated with the sol-gel is a microporous ceramic tube formed by the slip coating-sintering technique. The solution coated onto this support is a colloidal or polymeric gel of an inorganic hydroxide. These solutions are prepared by controlled hydrolysis of metal salts or metal alkoxides to hydroxides. Sol-gel methods fall into two categories, depending on how the colloidal coating solution is formed. The processes are shown schematically in Figure 3.31
130
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Feed Stream
Alumina is sintered to form a monolithic porous element.
The feed stream flows through the channels.
Permeate Feed stream channels The permeate produced by within the porous alumina the membrane passes relatively structure are lined with a unimpeded through the selective membrane layer. porous layers. Pore diameters range from 0.2 to 5 µm.
Figure 3.30 Cross-sectional scanning electron micrograph of a three-layered alumina membrane/support (pore sizes of 0.2, 0.8 and 12 µm, respectively). (Courtesy of Pall Corporation, Filterite Division, Timonium, MD)
[86–88]. In the particulate-sol method a metal alkoxide dissolved in alcohol is hydrolyzed by addition of excess water or acid. The precipitate that results is maintained as a hot solution for an extended period during which the precipitate forms a stable colloidal solution. This process is called peptization from the Greek pep—to cook (not a misnomer; many descriptions of the sol-gel process have a strong culinary flavor). The colloidal solution is then cooled and coated onto the microporous support membrane. The layer formed must be dried carefully to avoid cracking the coating. In the final step the film is sintered at 500–800 ◦ C. The overall process can be represented as: Precipitation: AI(OR)3 + H2O
AI(OH)3
γ -AI2O3 · H2O (Böhmite) or o-AI2O3 · 3H2O (Bayerite)
Peptization:
AI(OH)3
Sintering:
γ -AI2O3 · H2O
γ -AI2O3 + H2O
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
131
Slip coating - sintering
Sol-gel methods
Inorganic powder
Water/ polymer binders
Particulate sols
Polymeric sols
Alkoxide in alcohol
Alkoxide in alcohol
Hydroxide precipitation
Excess H2O
Clear gel
Coat
Heat 85-95°C colloidal suspension
Acid
Coat
Dry
Coat
Suspension
Dropwise H2O
Dry
Dry
Sinter (500-800°C)
Inorganic membrane
Figure 3.31 Slip coating-sintering and sol-gel processes used to make ceramic membranes
In the polymeric sol-gel process, partial hydrolysis of a metal alkoxide dissolved in alcohol is accomplished by adding the minimum of water to the solution. The active hydroxyl groups on the alkoxides then react to form an inorganic polymer molecule that can then be coated onto the ceramic support. On drying and sintering, the metal oxide film forms. Chemically the polymeric sol-gel process can be represented as: Hydrolysis:
Ti(OR)4 + H2O
Polymerization: nTi(OR)2(OH)2
Ti(OR)2(OH)2 + ROH Ti(OR)2
O
n
+ H2O
O Crosslinking:
Ti(OR)2
O
n
Ti(OH)2 O
Ti(OH) O
132
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Depending on the starting material and the coating procedure, a wide range of membranes can be made by the sol-gel process. The problem of cracking the films on drying and sintering can be alleviated by adding small amounts of a polymeric binder to the coating solution. The coating process may also be repeated several times to give a defect-free film. With care, membranes with pore ˚ range can be made by this method. In principle these sizes in the 10- to 100-A membranes could be useful in a number of processes—membrane reactors, for example. Currently the technology is still at the laboratory stage. Microporous Carbon Membranes The first microporous carbon membranes were produced by Barrer in the 1950s and 1960s by compressing high-surface-area carbon powders at very high pres˚ diameter and sures [89,90]. The resulting porous plugs had pores of 5- to 30-A were used to study diffusion of gases and vapors. More recently, practical ways of producing microporous carbon membranes have been developed by Koresh and Soffer [91], Hayashi et al. [92] and at Air Products by Rao and Sirkar [93]. All three groups are producing extremely finely microporous carbon membranes by pyrolizing preformed polyimide or polyacrylonitrile membranes in an inert atmosphere or vacuum at 500 to 800 ◦ C. Under these conditions the polymer is converted to carbon. Permeation properties show that the carbon membranes ˚ diameter. The Air Products membranes are made have pores from 10 to 20 A as thin films coated onto a ceramic support. The membranes of Koresh and Soffer are made as hollow fine fibers. These membranes are brittle and difficult to produce on a large scale, but have exceptional separation properties for some gas mixtures. Microporous Glass Membranes Microporous glass membranes in the form of tubes and fibers have been made by Corning, PPG, and Schott. Currently only the Corning membranes are still available, under the trade name Vycor . The leaching process used to make this type of membrane has been described by Beaver [94]. The starting material is a glass containing 30–70 % silica, as well as oxides of zirconium, hafnium or titanium and extractable materials. The extractable materials comprise one or more boron-containing compounds and alkali metal oxides and/or alkaline earth metal oxides. Glass hollow fibers produced by melt extrusion are treated with dilute hydrochloric acid at 90 ◦ C for 2–4 h to leach out the extractable materials, washed to remove residual acid, and then dried.
Liquid Membranes Liquid membranes containing carriers to facilitate selective transport of gases or ions were the subject of a considerable research effort in the 1970s and 1980s.
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
133
A number of published reviews summarize this work [95,96]. Although these membranes are still being studied in a number of laboratories, improvements in selective conventional polymer membranes have diminished interest in processes using liquid membranes. The preparation and use of these membranes are described in Chapter 11.
Hollow Fiber Membranes The membrane preparation techniques described so far were developed to produce flat-sheet membranes. However, these techniques can be adapted to produce membranes in the form of thin tubes or fibers. An important advantage of hollow fiber membranes is that compact modules with very high membrane surface areas can be formed. However, this advantage is offset by the generally lower fluxes of hollow fiber membranes compared to flat-sheet membranes made from the same materials. Nonetheless, the development of hollow fiber membranes by Mahon and the group at Dow Chemical in 1966 [97] and their later commercialization by Dow, Monsanto, Du Pont, and others represents one of the major events in membrane technology. A good review of the early development of hollow fiber membranes is given by Baum et al. [98]. Reviews of more recent developments are given by Moch [99] and McKelvey et al. [100]. The diameter of hollow fibers varies over a wide range, from 50 to 3000 µm. Fibers can be made with a uniformly dense structure, but preferably are formed as a microporous structure having a dense selective layer on either the outside or the inside surface. The dense surface layer can be either integral with the fiber or a separate layer coated onto the porous support fiber. Many fibers must be packed into bundles and potted into tubes to form a membrane module; modules with a surface area of even a few square meters require many kilometers of fibers. Because a module must contain no broken or defective fibers, hollow fiber production requires high reproducibility and stringent quality control. The types of hollow fiber membranes in production are illustrated in Figure 3.32. Fibers of 50- to 200-µm diameter are usually called hollow fine fibers. Such fibers can withstand very high hydrostatic pressures applied from the outside, so they are used in reverse osmosis or high-pressure gas separation applications in which the applied pressure can be 1000 psig or more. The feed fluid is applied to the outside (shell side) of the fibers, and the permeate is removed down the fiber bore. When the fiber diameter is greater than 200–500 µm, the feed fluid is commonly applied to the inside bore of the fiber, and the permeate is removed from the outer shell. This technique is used for low-pressure gas separations and for applications such as hemodialysis or ultrafiltration. Fibers with a diameter greater than 500 µm are called capillary fibers. Two methods are used to prepare hollow fibers: solution spinning and melt spinning [98,99]. The most common process is solution spinning or wet spinning, in which a 20–30 wt% polymer solution is extruded and precipitated
134
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
1000 − 3000 µm diameter
1000 µm
500 − 2000 µm diameter 300 − 400 µm diameter
50 − 200 µm diameter
High-pressure gas separation or reverse osmosis hollow fine fiber, shell-side feed 500 − 2000 psig
Medium-pressure gas separation fiber, bore-side feed 100 − 150 psig
Hemodialysis capillary fiber, bore-side feed 0 − 5 psig
Ultrafiltration capillary fiber, bore-side feed 10 − 50 psig
Figure 3.32 Schematic of the principal types of hollow fiber membranes
into a nonsolvent, generally water. Fibers made by solution spinning have the anisotropic structure of Loeb–Sourirajan membranes. This technique is generally used to make relatively large, porous hemodialysis and ultrafiltration fibers. In the alternative technique of melt spinning, a hot polymer melt is extruded from an appropriate die and is then cooled and solidified in air prior to immersion in a quench tank. Melt-spun fibers are usually denser and have lower fluxes than solution-spun fibers, but, because the fiber can be stretched after it leaves the die, very fine fibers can be made. Melt-spun fibers can also be produced at high speeds. The technique is usually used to make hollow fine fibers for high-pressure reverse osmosis and gas separation applications and is also used with polymers such as poly(trimethylpentene), which are not soluble in convenient solvents and are difficult to form by wet spinning. The distinction between solution spinning and melt spinning has gradually faded over the years. To improve fluxes, solvents and other additives are generally added to melt spinning dopes so spinning temperatures have fallen considerably. Many melt-spun fibers are now produced from spinning dopes containing as much as 30 to 60 wt% solvent, which requires the spinner to be heated to only 70–100 ◦ C to make the dope flow. These fibers are also often cooled and precipitated by spinning into a water bath, which also helps to form an anisotropic structure. The first hollow fiber spinneret system was devised by Mahon at Dow [97]. Mahon’s spinneret consists of two concentric capillaries, the outer capillary
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
135
having a diameter of approximately 400 µm, and the central capillary having an outer diameter of approximately 200 µm and an inner diameter of 100 µm. Polymer solution is forced through the outer capillary, while air or liquid is forced through the inner one. The rate at which the core fluid is injected into the fibers relative to the flow of polymer solution governs the ultimate wall thickness of the fiber. Figure 3.33 shows a cross-section of this type of spinneret, which is widely used to produce the large-diameter fibers used in ultrafiltration. Experimental details of this type of spinneret can be found elsewhere [101–103]. A complete hollow fiber spinning system is shown in Figure 3.34. Polymer solution injection port
Injection port for bore-forming fluid (water, oil, air, etc.) Capillary tube
Orifice
Figure 3.33 Twin-orifice spinneret design used in solution-spinning of hollow fiber membranes. Polymer solution is forced through the outer orifice, while bore-forming fluid is forced through the inner capillary
Spinneret
Evaporation gap
Take-up Washing
Heat treatment
Coagulation bath
Figure 3.34 A complete hollow fiber solution-spinning system. The fiber is spun into a coagulation bath, where the polymer spinning solution precipitates forming the fiber. The fiber is then washed, dried, and taken up on a roll
136
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
The evaporation time between the solution exiting the spinneret and entering the coagulation bath is a critical variable, as are the compositions of the bore fluid and the coagulation bath. The position of the dense anisotropic skin can be adjusted by varying the bath and bore solutions. For example, if water is used as the bore fluid and the coagulation bath contains some solvent, precipitation will occur first and most rapidly on the inside surface of the fiber. If the solutions are reversed so that the bore solution contains some solvent and the coagulation bath is water, the skin will tend to be formed on the outside surface of the fiber, as shown in Figure 3.35. In many cases precipitation will begin on both surfaces of the fiber, and a dense layer will form on both inside and outside surfaces. This ability to manipulate the position of the dense skin is important because the skin should normally face the feed fluid. Generally, the spinning dope used in solution spinning has a higher polymer concentration and is more viscous than the casting solutions used to form equivalent flat sheet membranes. This is because hollow fiber membranes must be able not only to perform the separation required but also to withstand the applied pressure of the process without collapsing. The mechanical demands placed on the microporous substructure of hollow fiber membranes are more demanding than for their flat-sheet equivalents. Consequently, a finer, stronger, and higher density microporous support structure is required. Because more concentrated casting solutions are used, the thickness of the skin layer of hollow fiber membranes is also greater than their flat-sheet equivalents. Usually lower membrane fluxes result. However, the low cost of producing a large membrane area in hollow fiber form compensates for the poorer performance. Hollow fiber spinning dopes and preparation procedures vary over a wider range than their flat-sheet equivalents, but some representative dopes and spinning conditions taken from the patent literature [98,103,104] are given in Table 3.4. Recently some interest in forming more complex hollow fibers has developed; for example, composite hollow fibers in which the microporous shell of the fiber provides the mechanical strength, but the selective layer is a coating of a
Inside precipitation
Outside precipitation
Outside and inside precipitation
Figure 3.35 Depending on the bore fluid and the composition of the coagulation bath, the selective skin layer can be formed on the inside, the outside or both sides of the hollow fiber membrane
MEMBRANES
AND
Table 3.4
MODULES
137
Preparation parameters for various hollow fiber membranes
Casting dope 37 wt% polysulfone (Udel P3500) 36 wt% N-methyl pyrrolidone 27 wt% propionic acid (spun at 15–100 ◦ C)
Bore fluid Water
Precipitation bath ◦
Water 25–50 C
10 wt% dimethyl 40 wt% dimethyl 25 wt% formamide in formamide in polyacrylonitrile-vinyl water 4 ◦ C water acetate copolymer 68 wt% dimethyl formamide 7 wt% formamide (spun at 65 ◦ C) 69 wt% cellulose triacetate (spun at 200 ◦ C) 17.2 wt% sulfolane 13.8 wt% poly(ethylene glycol) (MW 400)
Air
Membrane type Gas separation fiber αO2 /N2 5.2, ≈50 µm diameter, anisotropic outside-skinned fibers, finely microporous substrate [103] Ultrafiltration capillary membrane, inside skin, 98 % rejection to 110 000 MW dextran [104]
No precipitation Early (Dow) bath used; fiber 80-µm-diameter forms on fine fiber reverse cooling. osmosis membrane Solvents [98] removed in later extraction step
different material. Ube, Praxair, Air Products and Medal all produce this type of fiber for gas separation applications. Various techniques are described in the patent literature [105–107]. A device proposed by Air Products is shown in Figure 3.36. The preformed hollow fiber support membrane is drawn through a volatile solution of the coating polymer. The thickness of the film formed on the outer surface of the fiber is controlled by the concentration of polymer in the casting solution and the diameter of the orifice in the coating die. The solvent is evaporated and the fiber wound up. Another method of producing composite hollow fibers, described by Kusuki et al. at Ube [108] and Kopp et al. at Memtec [109], is to spin double-layered fibers with a double spinneret of the type shown in Figure 3.37. This system allows different spinning solutions to be used for the outer and inner surface of the fibers and gives more precise control of the final structure. Often, two different polymers are incorporated into the same fiber. The result is a hollow fiber composite membrane equivalent to the flat sheet membrane shown in Figure 3.26. A reason for the popularity of composite hollow fiber membranes is that different polymers can be used to form the mechanically strong support and the selective layer. This can reduce the amount of selective polymer required. The tailormade polymers developed for gas separation applications can cost as much as
138
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Controlled diameter orifice
Hollow fiber delivery spool
Drying tunnel
Oven
Drying tunnel
Take-up spool
Figure 3.36 Apparatus to make composite hollow fiber membranes by coating a hollow fiber support membrane with a thin selective coating [105]
Bore fluid
Inner casting solution
Outer casting solution Bore fluid
Spinneret head: section view
Spinneret cross-section
Figure 3.37 A double capillary spinneret sometimes used to produce two-layer hollow fibers. After Kopp et al. [109]
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
139
US$5–10/g. Single-layer hollow fiber membranes contain 10–20 g of polymer per square meter of membrane, for a material cost alone of US$50–200/m2 . Thus, using a composite structure consisting of a relatively inexpensive core polymer material coated with a thin layer of the expensive selective polymer reduces the overall membrane material cost significantly.
Membrane Modules Industrial membrane plants often require hundreds to thousands of square meters of membrane to perform the separation required on a useful scale. Before a membrane separation can be performed industrially, therefore, methods of economically and efficiently packaging large areas of membrane are required. These packages are called membrane modules. The development of the technology to produce low-cost membrane modules was one of the breakthroughs that led to commercial membrane processes in the 1960s and 1970s. The earliest designs were based on simple filtration technology and consisted of flat sheets of membrane held in a type of filter press: these are called plate-and-frame modules. Membranes in the form of 1- to 3-cm-diameter tubes were developed at about the same time. Both designs are still used, but because of their relatively high cost they have been largely displaced in most applications by two other designs—the spiral-wound module and the hollow fiber module. Despite the importance of membrane module technology, many researchers are astonishingly uninformed about module design issues. In part this is because module technology has been developed within companies, and developments are only found in patents, which are ignored by many academics. The following sections give an overview of the principal module types, followed by a section summarizing the factors governing selection of particular types for different membrane processes. Cost is always important, but perhaps the most important issues are membrane fouling and concentration polarization. This is particularly true for reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration systems, but concentration polarization issues also affect the design of gas separation and pervaporation modules. Plate-and-frame Modules Plate-and-frame modules were one of the earliest types of membrane system. A plate-and-frame design proposed by Stern [110] for early Union Carbide plants to recovery helium from natural gas is shown in Figure 3.38. Membrane, feed spacers, and product spacers are layered together between two end plates. The feed mixture is forced across the surface of the membrane. A portion passes through the membrane, enters the permeate channel, and makes its way to a central permeate collection manifold.
140
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY Metal spacer
Permeable membrane
APPLICATIONS
Pressure shell
Wire screen Paper
AND
Product manifold Product
Heat seal Permeate outlet Product
Feed gas passed through shell Septa stacked and spaced by internal metal strip. Stack joined by staybolts
Figure 3.38 Early plate-and-frame design developed by Stern et al. [110] for the separation of helium from natural gas. Reprinted with permission from S.A. Stern, T.F. Sinclaire, P.J. Gareis, N.P. Vahldieck and P.H. Mohr, Helium Recovery by Permeation, Ind. Eng. Chem. 57, 49. Copyright 1965, American Chemical Society and American Pharmaceutical Association
Plate-and-frame units have been developed for some small-scale applications, but these units are expensive compared to the alternatives, and leaks through the gaskets required for each plate are a serious problem. Plate-and-frame modules are now only used in electrodialysis and pervaporation systems and in a limited number of reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration applications with highly fouling feeds. An example of one of these reverse osmosis units is shown in Figure 3.39 [111]. Tubular Modules Tubular modules are now generally limited to ultrafiltration applications, for which the benefit of resistance to membrane fouling due to good fluid hydrodynamics outweighs their high cost. Typically, the tubes consist of a porous paper or fiberglass support with the membrane formed on the inside of the tubes, as shown in Figure 3.40. The first tubular membranes were between 2 and 3 cm in diameter, but more recently, as many as five to seven smaller tubes, each 0.5–1.0 cm in diameter, are nested inside a single, larger tube. In a typical tubular membrane system a large number of tubes are manifolded in series. The permeate is removed from each tube and sent to a permeate collection header. A drawing of a 30-tube system is shown in Figure 3.41. The feed solution is pumped through all 30 tubes connected in series.
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
141 Permeate
Feed
Tension nut
Retentate
Pressure tube
Support plate Membrane envelope
O-ring seal Permeate channel
Tension rod End plate
Figure 3.39 Schematic of a plate-and-frame module. Plate-and-frame modules provide good flow control on both the permeate and feed side of the membrane, but the large number of spacer plates and seals lead to high module costs. The feed solution is directed across each plate in series. Permeate enters the membrane envelope and is collected through the central permeate collection channel [111]
Spiral-wound Modules Spiral-wound modules were used in a number of early artificial kidney designs, but were fully developed for industrial membrane separations by Gulf General Atomic (a predecessor of Fluid Systems, Inc.). This work, directed at reverse osmosis membrane modules, was carried out under the sponsorship of the Office of Saline Water [112–114]. The design shown in Figure 3.42 is the simplest, consisting of a membrane envelope of spacers and membrane wound around a perforated central collection tube; the module is placed inside a tubular pressure vessel. Feed passes axially down the module across the membrane envelope. A portion of the feed permeates into the membrane envelope, where it spirals towards the center and exits through the collection tube. Small laboratory spiral-wound modules consist of a single membrane envelope wrapped around the collection tube, as shown in Figure 3.42. The membrane area of these modules is typically 0.2 to 1.0 m2 . Industrial-scale modules contain several membrane envelopes, each with an area of 1–2 m2 , wrapped around the central collection pipe. The multi-envelope design developed at Gulf General Atomic by Bray [113] and others is illustrated in Figure 3.43. Multi-envelope
142
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Figure 3.40 Typical tubular ultrafiltration module design. The membrane is usually cast on a porous fiberglass or paper support, which is then nested inside a plastic or steel support tube. In the past, each plastic housing contained a single 2- to 3-cm-diameter tube. More recently, several 0.5- to 1.0-cm-diameter tubes, nested inside single housings, have been introduced. (Courtesy of Koch Membrane Systems)
designs minimize the pressure drop encountered by the permeate fluid traveling towards the central pipe. If a single membrane envelope were used in a largemembrane-area module, the path taken by the permeate to reach the central collection pipe would be several meters long, depending on the module diameter. Such a long permeate path would result in a large pressure drop in the permeate collection channel. By using multiple short envelopes the pressure drop in any one envelope is kept at a manageable level. The standard industrial spiral-wound module has an 8-in. diameter and is 40 in. long. Twelve-inch-diameter modules up to 60 in. long have been made and offer some economy of scale. There is, therefore, a trend towards increasing the module diameter for larger plants. The approximate membrane area and number of membrane envelopes used in industrial 40-in.-long spiral-wound modules are given in Table 3.5. Four to six spiral-wound membrane modules are normally connected in series inside a single pressure vessel (tube). A typical 8-in.-diameter tube containing six modules has 100–200 m2 of membrane area. An exploded view of a membrane tube containing two modules is shown in Figure 3.44 [115]. The end of each module is fitted with an anti-telescoping device (ATD) which is designed to
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
143
Tube sheet Manifold outlet
U-bend Outlet Support tube
Permeate manifold Inlet
Figure 3.41 Exploded view of a tubular ultrafiltration system in which 30 tubes are connected in series. Permeate from each tube is collected in the permeate manifold
prevent the module leaves shifting under the feed-to-residue pressure difference required to force feed fluid through the module. The ATD is also fitted with a rubber seal to form a tight connection between the module and the pressure vessel. This seal prevents fluid bypassing the module in the gap between the module and the vessel wall. In some applications of reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration spiral-wound modules in the food industry, it may be desirable to allow a small portion of the feed solution to bypass the module to prevent bacteria growing in the otherwise stagnant fluid. One way of achieve this bypass is by perforating the ATD as illustrated in Figure 3.45 [115]. Hollow Fiber Modules Hollow fiber membrane modules are formed in two basic geometries. The first is the shell-side feed design illustrated in Figure 3.46(a) and used, for example, by Monsanto in their hydrogen separation systems and by Du Pont in their reverse osmosis systems. In such a module, a loop or a closed bundle of fibers is contained in a pressure vessel. The system is pressurized from the shell side; permeate passes through the fiber wall and exits through the open fiber ends. This design is easy to make and allows very large membrane areas to be contained in an economical system. Because the fiber wall must support considerable hydrostatic pressure, the fibers usually have small diameters and thick walls, typically 50-µm internal diameter and 100- to 200-µm outer diameter.
144
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY Spiral-Wound Module
AND
APPLICATIONS
Membrane
Feed spacer Perforated permeate collection pipe
Feed flow Membrane
w
te
flo
ea
Residue flow
m er
P
Permeate spacer Membrane envelope
Spiral-Wound Module Cross Section Permeate spacer
Outer cover Feed spacer
Permeate collection tube
Permeate flow Arrows indicate permeate flow
Figure 3.42 Exploded view and cross-section drawings of a spiral-wound module. Feed solution passes across the membrane surface. A portion passes through the membrane and enters the membrane envelope where it spirals inward to the central perforated collection pipe. One solution enters the module (the feed) and two solutions leave (the residue and the permeate). Spiral-wound modules are the most common module design for reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration as well as for high-pressure gas separation applications in the natural gas industry
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
145 Collection pipe Glue line
Glue line
Module
Glue line
Membrane envelope
Spacer
Membrane envelope
Membrane envelope
Figure 3.43 Multi-envelope spiral-wound module [113], used to avoid excessive pressure drops on the permeate side of the membrane. Large-diameter modules may have as many as 30 membrane envelopes, each with a membrane area of 1–2 m2 Table 3.5 Typical membrane area and number of membrane envelopes for 40-in.long industrial spiral-wound modules. The thickness of the membrane spacers used for different applications causes the variation in membrane area Module diameter (in.) Number of membrane envelopes Membrane area (m2 )
4 4–6 3–6
6 6–10 6–12
8 15–30 20–40
12 30–40 30–60
The second type of hollow fiber module is the bore-side feed type illustrated in Figure 3.46(b). The fibers in this type of unit are open at both ends, and the feed fluid is circulated through the bore of the fibers. To minimize pressure drop inside the fibers, the diameters are usually larger than those of the fine fibers used in the shell-side feed system and are generally made by solution spinning. These so-called capillary fibers are used in ultrafiltration, pervaporation, and some lowto medium-pressure gas applications. Feed pressures are usually limited to below 150 psig in this type of module. In bore-side feed modules, it is important to ensure that all of the fibers have identical fiber diameters and permeances. Even fiber variation as small as ±10 % from the average fiber can lead to large variations in module performance [116,117]. The flow of fluid through the fiber bore is proportional to the fiber
146
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Concentrate port Product port Spiral module with ATD End cap
Adaptor from module to end cap Feed port
Snap ring
Module interconnector
Product port
End cap
Snap ring
Figure 3.44 Schematic of a spiral-wound module [115] installed in a multimodule pressure vessel. Typically four to six modules are installed in a single pressure vessel. Reprinted from Reverse Osmosis Technology, B.S. Parekh (ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York (1988), p. 81, by courtesy of Marcel Dekker, Inc. Bypass flow
Bypass flow
End cap Cartridge housing
Feed port Direction of feed
Clamp RO cartridge Anti-telescoping device
Chevron seal
Figure 3.45 By perforating the antitelescoping device, a small controlled bypass of fluid past the module seal is achieved to eliminate the stagnant area between the reverse osmosis module and the pressure vessel walls. This device is used in food and other sanitary applications of spiral-wound modules [115]. Reprinted from Reverse Osmosis Technology, B.S. Parekh (ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York (1988), p. 359, by courtesy of Marcel Dekker, Inc.
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
147
(a) Shell-side feed Residue
Hollow fibers Feed
Permeate (b) Bore-side feed Permeate
Feed
Residue
Hollow fibers
Figure 3.46 Two types of hollow-fiber modules used for gas separation, reverse osmosis, and ultrafiltration applications. Shell-side feed modules are generally used for high-pressure applications up to 1000 psig. Fouling on the feed side of the membrane can be a problem with this design, and pretreatment of the feed stream to remove particulates is required. Bore-side feed modules are generally used for medium-pressure feed streams up to 150 psig, for which good flow control to minimize fouling and concentration polarization on the feed side of the membrane is desired
148
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
diameter to the fourth power, whereas the membrane area only changes by the second power. The effect is particularly important in the production of nitrogen from air and in hollow-fiber kidney modules, in which high levels of removal of the permeable component in a single pass are desired. If the fibers have different diameters, a few overly large or overly small fibers can significantly affect the removal achieved by the module. Concentration polarization is well controlled in bore-side feed modules. The feed solution passes directly across the active surface of the membrane, and no stagnant dead spaces are produced. This is far from the case in shell-side feed modules in which flow channeling and stagnant areas between fibers, which cause significant concentration polarization problems, are difficult to avoid [118]. Any suspended particulate matter in the feed solution is easily trapped in these stagnant areas, leading to irreversible fouling of the membrane. Baffles to direct the feed flow have been tried [119,120], but are not widely used. A more common method of minimizing concentration polarization is to direct the feed flow normal to the direction of the hollow fibers as shown in Figure 3.47. This produces a cross-flow module with relatively good flow distribution across the fiber surface. Several membrane modules may be connected in series, so high feed solution velocities can be used. A number of variants on this basic design have been patented [121,122] and are reviewed by Koros and Fleming [123]. A second problem in shell-side feed hollow fine fibers is permeate side parasitic pressure drops. The permeate channel in these fibers is so narrow, and presents such a resistance to fluid passage, that a significant pressure drop develops along the length of the permeate channel, reducing the pressure difference across the membrane that provides the driving force for permeation. In applications involving separation of mixtures of relatively impermeable components, such as oxygen and nitrogen in air, the pressure drop that develops is small
Vessel
Concentrated water
Resin layer
O-ring End plate
Feed water
Product water
End plate
Hollow fiber O-ring
Figure 3.47 A cross-flow hollow fiber module used to obtain better flow distribution and reduce concentration polarization (the Tyobo Hollosep reverse osmosis module). Feed enters through the perforated central pipe and flows towards the module shell
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
149
and unimportant. But in separations of more permeable gas mixtures, such as hydrogen or carbon dioxide from methane, the pressure drop can be a significant fraction of the total applied pressure. Permeate-side pressure drops also tend to develop in spiral-wound modules. However, because the permeate channels are wider in this type of module, pressure drops are usually smaller and less significant. The greatest single advantage of hollow fiber modules is the ability to pack a very large membrane area into a single module. The magnitude of this advantage can be gauged by the membrane area per module data shown in Table 3.6. This table shows the calculated membrane area contained in an 8-in.-diameter, 40-in.long module; a spiral-wound module of this size would contain about 20–40 m2 of membrane area. The equivalent hollow fiber module, filled with fibers with a diameter of 100 µm, will contain approximately 300 m2 of membrane area, 10 times the area in a spiral-wound module. As the diameter of the fibers in the module increases, the membrane area decreases. Capillary ultrafiltration membrane modules have almost the same area as equivalent-sized spiral-wound modules. Table 3.6 also shows the huge numbers of hollow fibers required for highsurface-area modules. A hollow fine fiber module with an area of 300 m2 will contain 1000 km of fiber. Expensive, sophisticated, high-speed automated spinning and fiber handling and module fabrication equipment is required to produce these modules. A typical hollow fiber spinning operation will have 50–100 spinnerets. In general the capital investment for a hollow fine fiber production plant is so large that the technology can only be considered when large numbers of modules are being produced on a round-the-clock basis. The technology is maintained as a trade secret within the handful of companies that produce this type of module. A clue to the type of machinery involved can be obtained from the patent literature. Figure 3.48, for example, shows a module winding machine from an old Du Pont patent [124]. Fibers from several bobbins are wound around a porous paper sheet, laying down the bundle that ultimately becomes the module insert. Table 3.6 Effect of fiber diameter on membrane area and the number of fibers in a module 20 cm (8 in.) in diameter and 1 m (40 in.) long. Twenty-five percent of the module volume is filled with fiber. A spiral-wound module of this size contains approximately 20–40 m2 of membrane area and has a packing density of 6–13 cm2 /cm3 Module use
Fiber diameter (µm) Number of fibers/module (thousands) Membrane area (m2 ) Packing density (cm2 /cm3 )
High-pressure reverse osmosis and gas separation 100 1000 315 100
Low-pressure gas separation
Ultrafiltration
250 250 155 50
1000 2000 10 2.5 32 16 10 5
500 40 65 20
150
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Resin applicator
Central distributor tube
AND
APPLICATIONS
Web Web feeder
Revolving permeator
Hollow fiber bobbin
Figure 3.48 Hollow fiber module winding apparatus from a 1972 Du Pont patent [124]. Machines of this general type are still used to produce hollow fiber modules
Vibrating and Rotating Modules In all of the module designs described thus far, the fluid to be separated (gas or liquid) is pumped across the surface of the membrane at high velocity to control concentration polarization. A few vibrating or rotating modules, in which the membrane moves, and moves much faster than the fluid flowing across its surface, have been developed. One such design, a vibrating module, from New Logic International, is shown in Figure 3.49 [125,126]. Vibration of the membrane at high speed creates interior agitation directly at the membrane surface. These modules have proved to be able to ultrafilter extremely concentrated, viscous solutions that could not be treated by conventional module designs. Currently the modules are extremely expensive—in the range US$2000–5000/m2 membrane—compared to alternative designs. This limits their application to high-value separations that cannot be performed by other processes.
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
151 Feed fluid in Permeate fluid out
Plate-and-frame module stack 1 − 2 inches Process out
Process out
Direction of movement
Torsion spring (bar)
Vibration drive motor
Seismic mass Rubber isolation mount
Figure 3.49 New Logic International vibrating plate-and-frame module design [125]. A motor taps a metal plate (the seismic mass) supported by a rubber mount at 60 times/s. A bar that acts as a torsion spring connects the vibrating mass to a plate-and-frame membrane module, which then vibrates by 1–2 in. at the same frequency. By shaking the membrane module, high turbulence is induced in the pressurized feed fluid flowing through the module. The turbulence occurs directly at the membrane surface, providing good control of membrane fouling
Module Selection The choice of the most suitable membrane module type for a particular membrane separation must balance a number of factors. The principal module design parameters that enter into the decision are summarized in Table 3.7. Cost, always important, is difficult to quantify because the actual selling price of the same module design varies widely, depending on the application. Generally, high-pressure modules are more expensive than low-pressure or vacuum
152
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Table 3.7 Parameters for membrane module design Parameter
Hollow fine Capillary Spiral-wound Plate-and-frame fibers fibers
Tubular
Manufacturing cost (US$/m2 )
5–20
10–50
5–100
50–200
50–200
Concentration polarization fouling control
Poor
Good
Moderate
Good
Very good
Permeate-side pressure drop
High
Moderate
Moderate
Low
Low
Suitability for high-pressure operation
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Marginal
Limited to specific types of membrane material
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
modules. The total volume of product likely to be produced to satisfy a particular application is a key issue. For example, spiral-wound modules for reverse osmosis are produced by three or four manufacturers in large volumes, resulting in severe competition and low prices. Similar modules used in ultrafiltration are produced in much lower numbers and so are much more expensive. Hollow fiber modules are significantly cheaper, per square meter of membrane, than spiral-wound or plate-and-frame modules but can only be economically produced for very high volume applications that justify the expense of developing and building the spinning and module fabrication equipment. This cost advantage is often offset by the lower fluxes of the membranes compared with their flat-sheet equivalents. An estimate of module manufacturing cost is given in Table 3.7; the selling price is typically two to five times higher. Two other major factors determining module selection are concentration polarization control and resistance to fouling. Concentration polarization control is a particularly important issue in liquid separations such as reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration. In gas separation applications, concentration polarization is more easily controlled but is still a problem with high-flux, highly selective membranes. Hollow fine fiber modules are notoriously prone to fouling and concentration polarization and can be used in reverse osmosis applications only when extensive, costly feed solution pretreatment removes all particulates. These fibers cannot be used in ultrafiltration applications at all. Another factor is the ease with which various membrane materials can be fabricated into a particular module design. Almost all membranes can be formed into plate-and-frame, spiral-wound and tubular modules, but many membrane materials cannot be fabricated into hollow fine fibers or capillary fibers. Finally, the suitability of the module design for high-pressure operation and the relative
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
153
magnitude of pressure drops on the feed and permeate sides of the membrane can be important factors. The types of modules generally used in some of the major membrane processes are listed in Table 3.8. In reverse osmosis, the commonly used modules are spiral-wound. Plate-andframe and tubular modules are limited to a few applications in which membrane fouling is particularly severe, for example, in food applications or processing heavily contaminated industrial wastewater. The hollow fiber reverse osmosis modules used in the past have now been almost completely displaced by spiralwound modules, which are inherently more fouling resistant, and require less feed pretreatment. For ultrafiltration applications, hollow fine fibers have never been seriously considered because of their susceptibility to fouling. If the feed solution is extremely fouling, tubular systems are still used. Recently, however, spiral-wound modules with improved resistance to fouling have been developed; these modules are increasingly displacing the more expensive tubular systems. This is particularly the case with clean feed solutions, for example, in the ultrafiltration of boiler feed water or municipal water to make ultrapure water for the electronics industry. Capillary systems are also used in some ultrafiltration applications. Table 3.8 processes
Module designs most commonly used in the major membrane separation
Application
Module type
Reverse osmosis: seawater
Spiral-wound modules. Only one hollow fiber producer remains
Reverse osmosis: industrial and brackish water
Spiral-wound modules used almost exclusively; fine fibers too susceptible to scaling and fouling
Ultrafiltration
Tubular, capillary and spiral-wound modules all used. Tubular generally limited to highly fouling feeds (automotive paint), spiral-wound to clean feeds (ultrapure water)
Gas separation
Hollow fibers for high volume applications with low flux, low selectivity membranes in which concentration polarization is easily controlled (nitrogen from air) Spiral-wound when fluxes are higher, feed gases more contaminated and concentration polarization a problem (natural gas separations, vapor permeation)
Pervaporation
Most pervaporation systems are small so plate-and-frame systems were used in the first systems Spiral-wound and capillary modules being introduced
154
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
For high-pressure gas separation applications, hollow fine fibers have a major segment of the market. Hollow fiber modules are clearly the lowest cost design per unit membrane area, and their poor resistance to fouling is not a problem in many gas separation applications because gaseous feed streams can easily be filtered. Also, gas separation membrane materials are often rigid glassy polymers such as polysulfones, polycarbonates and polyimides, which are easily formed into hollow fine fibers. Spiral-wound modules are used to process natural gas streams, which are relatively dirty, often containing oil mist and condensable components that would foul hollow fine fiber modules rapidly. Spiral-wound modules are much more commonly used in low-pressure or vacuum gas separation applications, such as the production of oxygen-enriched air or the separation of organic vapors from air. In these applications, the feed gas is at close to ambient pressure, and a vacuum is drawn on the permeate side of the membrane. Parasitic pressure drops on the permeate side of the membrane and the difficulty in making high-performance hollow fine fiber membranes from the rubbery polymers used to make them both work against hollow fine fiber modules for such applications. Pervaporation operates under constraints similar to those for low-pressure gas separation. Pressure drops on the permeate side of the membrane must be small, and many pervaporation membrane materials are rubbery, so both spiral-wound modules and plate-and-frame systems are in use. Plate-and-frame systems are competitive in this application despite their high cost, primarily because they can be operated at high temperatures with relatively aggressive feed solutions, conditions under which spiral-wound modules might fail.
Conclusions and Future Directions The technology to fabricate ultrathin high-performance membranes into highsurface-area membrane modules has steadily improved during the modern membrane era. As a result the inflation-adjusted cost of membrane separation processes has decreased dramatically over the years. The first anisotropic membranes made by Loeb–Sourirajan processes had an effective thickness of 0.2–0.4 µm. Currently, various techniques are used to produce commercial membranes with a thickness of 0.1 µm or less. The permeability and selectivity of membrane materials have also increased two to three fold during the same period. As a result, today’s membranes have 5 to 10 times the flux and better selectivity than membranes available 30 years ago. These trends are continuing. Membranes with an effective thickness of less than 0.05 µm have been made in the laboratory using advanced composite membrane preparation techniques or surface treatment methods. As a result of these improvements in membrane performance, the major factors determining system performance have become concentration polarization and membrane fouling. All membrane processes are affected by these problems, so
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
155
membrane modules with improved fluid flow to minimize concentration polarization and modules formed from membranes that can be easily cleaned if fouled are likely to become increasingly important development areas.
References 1. H.A. Gardner and G.G. Sward, Physical and Chemical Examination of Paints, Varnishes, Lacquers, and Colors, 11th Edn, H.A. Gardner Laboratory, Maryland (1950). 2. K.J. Mackenzie, Film and Sheeting Material, in Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, 4th Edn, Vol. 10, p. 761 (1992). 3. R.L. Fleischer, H.W. Alter, S.C. Furman, P.B. Price and R.M. Walker, Particle Track Etching, Science 172, 225 (1972). 4. M.C. Porter, A Novel Membrane Filter for the Laboratory, Am. Lab. November (1974). 5. J.E. Gingrich, The Nuclepore Story, The 1988 Sixth Annual Membrane Technology/Planning Conference, Cambridge, MA (1988). 6. H.S. Bierenbaum, R.B. Isaacson, M.L. Druin and S.G. Plovan, Microporous Polymeric Films, Ind. Eng. Chem. Proc. Res. Dev. 13, 2 (1974). 7. R.W. Gore, Porous Products and Process Therefor, US Patent 4,187,390 (February, 1980). 8. J.J. Kim, T.S. Jang, Y.D. Kwon, U.Y. Kim and S.S. Kim, Structural Study of Microporous Polypropylene Hollow Fiber Membranes Made by the Melt-Spinning and Cold-Stretching Method, J. Membr. Sci. 93, 209 (1994). 9. K. Okuyama and H. Mizutani, Process for Preparing Air-permeable Film, US Patent 4,585,604 (April, 1986). 10. Y. Mizutani, S. Nakamura, S. Kaneko and K. Okamura, Microporous Polypropylene Sheets, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 32, 221 (1993). 11. C.C. Chau and J.-H. Im, Process of Making a Porous Membrane, US Patent 4,874, 568 (October, 1989). 12. T. Ichikawa, K. Takahara, K. Shimoda, Y. Seita and M. Emi, Hollow Fiber Membrane and Method for Manufacture Thereof, US Patent 4,708,800 (November, 1987). 13. G. Lopatin, L.Y. Yen and R.R. Rogers, Microporous Membranes from Polypropylene, US Patent 4,874,567 (October, 1989). 14. S. Loeb and S. Sourirajan, Sea Water Demineralization by Means of an Osmotic Membrane, in Saline Water Conversion-II, Advances in Chemistry Series Number 28, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 117–132 (1963). 15. J.E. Cadotte, Evolution of Composite Reverse Osmosis Membranes, in Materials Science of Synthetic Membranes, D.R. Lloyd (ed.), ACS Symposium Series Number 269, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 273–294 (1985). 16. W.J. Ward, III, W.R. Browall and R.M. Salemme, Ultrathin Silicone Rubber Membranes for Gas Separations, J. Membr. Sci. 1, 99 (1976). 17. P.S. Francis, Fabrication and Evaluation of New Ultrathin Reverse Osmosis Membranes, Offices of Saline Water Report, NTIS# PB-177083 (February, 1966). 18. R.L. Riley, H.K. Lonsdale, C.R. Lyons and U. Merten, Preparation of Ultrathin Reverse Osmosis Membranes and the Attainment of Theoretical Salt Rejection, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 11, 2143 (1967). 19. H. Strathmann, K. Kock, P. Amar and R.W. Baker, The Formation Mechanism of Anisotropic Membranes, Desalination 16, 179 (1975). 20. S. Manjikian, Desalination Membranes from Organic Casting Solutions, Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. Dev. 6, 23 (1967).
156
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
21. C.W. Saltonstall, Jr, Development and Testing of High-retention Reverse-osmosis Membranes, International Conference PURAQUA, Rome, Italy (February, 1969). 22. A.S. Michaels, High Flow Membrane, US Patent 3,615,024 (October, 1971). 23. I. Pinnau and W.J. Koros, Defect Free Ultra High Flux Asymmetric Membranes, US Patent 4,902,422 (February, 1990). 24. H. Strathmann, P. Scheible and R.W. Baker, A Rationale for the Preparation of Loeb–Sourirajan-type Cellulose Acetate Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 15, 811 (1971). 25. M.T. So, F.R. Eirich, H. Strathmann and R.W. Baker, Preparation of Anisotropic Loeb–Sourirajan Membranes, Polym. Lett. 11, 201 (1973). 26. H. Strathmann and K. Kock, The Formation Mechanism of Phase Inversion Membranes, Desalination 21, 241 (1977). 27. J.G. Wijmans and C.A. Smolders, Preparation of Anisotropic Membranes by the Phase Inversion Process, in Synthetic Membranes: Science, Engineering, and Applications, P.M. Bungay, H.K. Lonsdale and M.N. de Pinho (eds), D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 39–56 (1986). 28. F.W. Altena and C.A. Smolders, Calculation of Liquid–Liquid Phase Separation in a Ternary System of a Polymer in a Mixture of a Solvent and Nonsolvent, Macromolecules 15, 1491 (1982). 29. A.J. Reuvers, J.W.A. Van den Berg and C.A. Smolders, Formation of Membranes by Means of Immersion Precipitation, J. Membr. Sci. 34, 45 (1987). 30. M. Mulder, Basic Principles of Membrane Technology, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht (1991). 31. I. Pinnau and W.J. Koros, A Qualitative Skin Layer Formation Mechanism for Membranes Made by Dry/Wet Phase Inversion, J. Polym. Sci., Part B: Polym. Phys. 31, 419 (1993). 32. W.J. Koros and I. Pinnau, Membrane Formation for Gas Separation Processes, in Polymeric Gas Separation Membranes, D.R. Paul and Y.P. Yampol’skii (eds), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 209–272 (1994). 33. A.J. Castro, Methods for Making Microporous Products, US Patent 4,247,498 (January, 1981). 34. D.R. Lloyd, J.W. Barlow and K.E. Kinzer, Microporous Membrane Formation via Thermally-induced Phase, in New Membrane Materials and Processes for Separation, K.K. Sirkar and D.R. Lloyd (eds), AIChE Symposium Series 261, AIChE, New York, NY, p. 84 (1988). 35. H.J.C. Vadalia, H.K. Lee, A.S. Meyerson and K. Levon, Thermally Induced Phase Separations in Ternary Crystallizable Polymer Solutions, J. Membr. Sci. 89, 37 (1994). 36. G.T. Caneba and D.S. Soong, Polymer Membrane Formation Through the Thermalinversion Process, Macromolecules 18, 2538 (1985). 37. W.C. Hiatt, G.H. Vitzthum, K.B. Wagener, K. Gerlach and C. Josefiak, Microporous Membranes via Upper Critical Temperature Phase Separation, in Materials Science of Synthetic Membranes, D.R. Lloyd (ed.), ACS Symposium Series Number 269, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, p. 229 (1985). 38. D.R. Lloyd, S.S. Kim and K.E. Kinzer, Microporous Membrane Formation in Thermally Induced Phase Separation, J. Membr. Sci. 64, 1 (1991). 39. H. Bechhold, Kolloidstudien mit der Filtationmethode, Z. Physik. Chem. 60, 257 (1907). 40. W.J. Elford, Principles Governing the Preparation of Membranes Having Graded Porosities. The Properties of ‘Gradocol’ Membranes as Ultrafilters, Trans. Faraday Soc. 33, 1094 (1937).
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
157
41. H.F. Pierce, Nitrocellulose Membranes of Graded Permeability, J. Biol. Chem. 75, 795 (1927). 42. J.D. Ferry, Ultrafilter Membranes and Ultrafiltration, Chem. Rev. 18, 373 (1936). 43. R. Zsigmondy and W. Bachmann, Uber Neue Filter, Z. Anorg. Chem. 103, 119 (1918). 44. L. Zeman and T. Fraser, Formation of Air-cast Cellulose Acetate Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 87, 267 (1994). 45. R.L. Riley, H.K. Lonsdale, L.D. LaGrange and C.R. Lyons, Development of Ultrathin Membranes, Office of Saline Water Research and Development Progress Report No. 386, PB# 207036 (January, 1969). 46. L.J. Zeman and A.L. Zydney, Microfiltration and Ultrafiltration, Marcel Dekker, New York (1996). 47. L.T. Rozelle, J.E. Cadotte, K.E. Cobian and C.V. Kopp, Jr, Nonpolysaccharide Membranes for Reverse Osmosis: NS-100 Membranes, in Reverse Osmosis and Synthetic Membranes, S. Sourirajan (ed.), National Research Council Canada, Ottawa, Canada, pp. 249–262 (1977). 48. R.J. Petersen, Composite Reverse Osmosis and Nanofiltration Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 83, 81 (1993). 49. R.L. Riley, R.L. Fox, C.R. Lyons, C.E. Milstead, M.W. Seroy and M. Tagami, Spiral-wound Poly(ether/amide) Thin-film Composite Membrane System, Desalination 19, 113 (1976). 50. Y. Kamiyama, N. Yoshioka, K. Matsui and E. Nakagome, New Thin-film Composite Reverse Osmosis Membranes and Spiral Wound Modules, Desalination 51, 79 (1984). 51. R.E. Larson, J.E. Cadotte and R.J. Petersen, The FT-30 Seawater Reverse Osmosis Membrane-element Test Results, Desalination 38, 473 (1981). 52. W.J. Ward, III, W.R. Browall and R.M. Salemme, Ultrathin Silicone Rubber Membranes for Gas Separations, J. Membr. Sci. 1, 99 (1976). 53. R.H. Forester and P.S. Francis, Method of Producing an Ultrathin Polymer Film Laminate, US Patent 3,551,244 (December, 1970). 54. M. Haubs and W. Hassinger, Coated Fibers, US Patent 5,344,702 (September, 1994). 55. W.R. Browall, Method for Sealing Breaches in Multi-layer Ultrathin Membrane Composites, US Patent 3,980,456 (September, 1976). 56. R.L. Riley, H.K. Lonsdale and C.R. Lyons, Composite Membranes for Seawater Desalination by Reverse Osmosis, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 15, 1267 (1971). 57. F.-J. Tsai, D. Kang and M. Anand, Thin Film Composite Gas Separation Membranes: On the Dynamics of Thin Film Formation Mechanism on Porous Substrates, Sep. Sci. Technol. 30, 1639 (1995). 58. I. Pinnau, Ultrathin Ethyl Cellulose/Poly(4-methyl pentene-1) Permselective Membranes, US Patent 4,871,378 (October 1989). 59. I. Pinnau, J.G. Wijmans, I. Blume, T. Kuroda and K.-V. Peinemann, Gas Separation Through Composite Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 37, 81 (1988). 60. H. Yasuda, Plasma Polymerization for Protective Coatings and Composite Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 18, 273 (1984). 61. H. Yasuda, Composite Reverse Osmosis Membranes Prepared by Plasma Polymerization, in Reverse Osmosis and Synthetic Membranes, S. Sourirajan (ed.), National Research Council Canada, Ottawa, Canada, pp. 263–294 (1977). 62. A.R. Stancell and A.T. Spencer, Composite Permselective Membrane by Deposition of an Ultrathin Coating from a Plasma, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 16, 1505 (1972). 63. M. Kawakami, Y. Yamashita, M. Iwamoto and S. Kagawa, Modification of Gas Permeabilities of Polymer Membranes by Plasma Coating, J. Membr. Sci. 19, 249 (1984).
158
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
64. K.A. Kraus, A.J. Shor and J.S. Johnson, Hyperfiltration Studies, Desalination 2, 243 (1967). 65. J.S. Johnson, K.A. Kraus, S.M. Fleming, H.D. Cochran and J.J. Perona, Hyperfiltration Studies, Desalination 5, 359 (1968). 66. M. Langsam, Fluorinated Polymeric Membranes for Gas Separation Processes, US Patent 4,657,564 (April, 1987); M. Langsam and C.L. Savoca, Polytrialkylgermylpropyne Polymers and Membranes, US Patent 4,759,776 (July, 1988). 67. M. Langsam, M. Anand and E.J. Karwacki, Substituted Propyne Polymers I. Chemical Surface Modification of Poly[1-(trimethylsilyl)propyne] for Gas Separation Membranes, Gas Sep. Purif. 2, 162 (1988). 68. J.M. Mohr, D.R. Paul, I. Pinnau and W.J. Koros, Surface Fluorination of Polysulfone Anisotropic Membranes and Films, J. Membr. Sci. 56, 77 (1991). 69. J.M. Mohr, D.R. Paul, Y. Taru, T. Mlsna and R.J. Lagow, Surface Fluorination of Composite Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 55, 149 (1991). 70. M. Langsam, Fluorinated Polymeric Membranes for Gas Separation Processes, US Patent 4,657,564 (April, 1987). 71. J.D. Le Roux, D.R. Paul, M.F. Arendt, Y. Yuan and I. Cabasso, Surface Fluorination of Poly(phenylene oxide) Composite Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 90, 37 (1994). 72. P.W. Kramer, M.K. Murphy, D.J. Stookey, J.M.S. Henis and E.R. Stedronsky, Membranes Having Enhanced Selectivity and Methods of Producing Such Membranes, US Patent 5,215,554 (June, 1993). 73. J.M.S. Henis and M.K. Tripodi, A Novel Approach to Gas Separations Using Composite Hollow Fiber Membranes, Sep. Sci. Technol. 15, 1059 (1980). 74. R.B. McBride and D.L. McKinley, A New Hydrogen Recovery Route, Chem. Eng. Prog. 61, 81 (1965). 75. J.B. Hunter, Silver–Palladium Film for Separation and Purification of Hydrogen, US Patent 2,773,561 (December, 1956). 76. J.B. Hunter, A New Hydrogen Purification Process, Platinum Met. Rev. 4, 130 (1960). 77. R.W. Baker, J. Louie, P.H. Pfromm and J.G. Wijmans, Ultrathin Composite Metal Membranes, US Patent 4,857,080 (August, 1989). 78. A.L. Athayde, R.W. Baker and P. Nguyen, Metal Composite Membranes for Hydrogen Separation, J. Membr. Sci. 94, 299 (1994). 79. R.E. Buxbaum, Composite Metal Membrane for Hydrogen Extraction, US Patent 4,215,729 (June, 1993). 80. R.E. Buxbaum and T.L. Marker, Hydrogen Transport Through Non-porous Membranes of Palladium-coated Niobium, Tantalum, and Vanadium, J. Membr. Sci. 85, 29 (1993). 81. D.J. Edlund and D.T. Friesen, Hydrogen-permeable Composite Metal Membrane and Uses Thereof, US Patent 5,217,506 (June, 1993). 82. D.J. Edlund, D. Friesen, B. Johnson and W. Pledger, Hydrogen-permeable Metal Membranes for High-temperature Gas Separations, Gas Sep. Purif. 8, 131 (1994). 83. G. Alefeld and J. V¨olkl (eds), Hydrogen in Metals—Basic Properties, SpringerVerlag, Berlin (1978). 84. R.R. Bhave (ed.), Inorganic Membranes: Synthesis Characterization and Applications, Chapman Hall, New York (1991). 85. K. Keizer, R.J.R. Uhlhorn and T.J. Burggraaf, Gas Separation Using Inorganic Membranes, in Membrane Separation Technology, Principles and Applications, R.D. Nobel and S.A. Stern (eds), Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 553–584 (1995). 86. T.J. Burggraaf and K. Keizer, Synthesis of Inorganic Membranes, in Inorganic Membranes Synthesis, Characteristics, and Applications, R.R. Bhave (ed.), Chapmann Hall, New York, pp. 10–63 (1991).
MEMBRANES
AND
MODULES
159
87. A. Larbot, J.P. Fabre, C. Guizard and L. Cot, Inorganic Membranes Obtained by Sol-Gel Techniques, J. Membr. Sci. 39, 203 (1988). 88. M.A. Anderson, M.J. Gieselmann and Q. Xu, Titania and Alumina Ceramic Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 39, 243 (1988). 89. R. Ash, R.M. Barrer and C.G. Pope, Flow of Adsorbable Gases and Vapours in a Microporous Medium, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 271, 19 (1963). 90. R.M. Barrer and T. Gabor, Sorption and Diffusion of Simple Gases in Silica–Aluminum Cracking Catalyst, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 265, 267 (1960). 91. J.E. Koresh and A. Soffer, Molecular Sieve Carbon Selective Membrane, Sep. Sci. Technol. 18, 723 (1983). 92. J. Hayashi, H. Mizuta, M. Yamamoto, K. Kusakabe and S. Morooka, Pore Size Control of Carbonized BPDA-pp ODA Polyimide Membrane by Chemical Vapor Deposition of Carbon, J. Membr. Sci. 124, 243 (1997). 93. M.B. Rao and S. Sircar, Nanoporous Carbon Membranes for Separation of Gas Mixtures by Selective Surface Flow, J. Membr. Sci. 85, 253 (1993). 94. R.P. Beaver, Method of Production Porous Hollow Silica-rich Fibers, US Patent 4,778,499 (October, 1988). 95. R.W. Baker and I. Blume, Coupled Transport Membranes, in Handbook of Industrial Membrane Technology, M.C. Porter (ed.), Noyes Publications, Park Ridge, NJ, pp. 511–558 (1990). 96. E.L. Cussler, Facilitated and Active Transport, in Polymeric Gas Separation Membranes, D.R. Paul and Y.P. Yampol’skii (eds), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 273–300 (1994). 97. H.I. Mahon, Permeability Separatory Apparatus, Permeability Separatory Membrane Element, Method of Making the Same and Process Utilizing the Same, US Patent 3,228,876 (January, 1966). 98. B. Baum, W. Holley, Jr and R.A. White, Hollow Fibres in Reverse Osmosis, Dialysis, and Ultrafiltration, in Membrane Separation Processes, P. Meares (ed.), Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 187–228 (1976). 99. I. Moch, Jr, Hollow Fiber Membranes, in Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, 4th Edn, John Wiley-InterScience Publishing, New York, Vol. 13, p. 312 (1995). 100. S.A. McKelvey, D.T. Clausi and W.J. Koros, A Guide to Establishing Fiber Macroscopic Properties for Membrane Applications, J. Membr. Sci. 124, 223 (1997). 101. T. Liu, D. Zhang, S. Xu and S. Sourirajan, Solution-spun Hollow Fiber Polysulfone and Polyethersulfone Ultrafiltration Membranes, Sep. Sci. Technol. 27, 161 (1992). 102. S.H. Lee, J.J. Kim, S.S. Kim and U.Y. Kim, Morphology and Performance of a Polysulfone Hollow Fiber Membrane, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 49, 539 (1993). 103. R.F. Malon and C.A. Cruse, Anisotropic Gas Separation Membranes Having Improved Strength, US Patent 5,013,767 (May, 1991). 104. S. Takao, Process for Producing Acrylonitrile Separation Membranes in Fibrous Form, US Patent 4,409,162 (October, 1983). 105. P.S. Puri, Continuous Process for Making Coated Composite Hollow Fiber Membranes, US Patent 4,863,761 (September, 1989). 106. H.-D. Sluma, R. Weizenhofer, A. Leeb and K. Bauer, Method of Making a Multilayer Capillary Membrane, US Patent 5,242,636 (September, 1993). 107. M. Haubs and W. Hassinger, Method and Apparatus for Applying Polymeric Coating, US Patent 5,156,888 (October, 1992). 108. Y. Kusuki, T. Yoshinaga and H. Shimazaki, Aromatic Polyimide Double Layered Hollow Filamentary Membrane and Process for Producing Same, US Patent 5,141, 642 (August, 1992). 109. C.V. Kopp, R.J.W. Streeton and P.S. Khoo, Extrusion Head for Forming Polymeric Hollow Fiber, US Patent 5,318,417 (June, 1994).
160
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
110. S.A. Stern, T.F. Sinclaire, P.J. Gareis, N.P. Vahldieck and P.H. Mohr, Helium Recovery by Permeation, Ind. Eng. Chem. 57, 49 (1965). 111. R. G¨unther, B. Perschall, D. Reese and J. Hapke, Engineering for High Pressure Reverse Osmosis, J. Membr. Sci. 121, 95 (1996). 112. J.C. Westmoreland, Spirally Wrapped Reverse Osmosis Membrane Cell, US Patent 3,367,504 (February, 1968). 113. D.T. Bray, Reverse Osmosis Purification Apparatus, US Patent 3,417,870 (December, 1968). 114. S.S. Kremen, Technology and Engineering of ROGA Spiral-wound Reverse Osmosis Membrane Modules, in Reverse Osmosis and Synthetic Membranes, S. Sourirajan (ed.), National Research Council Canada, Ottawa, Canada, pp. 371–386 (1977). 115. B.S. Parekh (ed.), Reverse Osmosis Technology, Marcel Dekker, New York (1988). 116. R.O. Crowder and E.L. Cussler, Mass Transfer in Hollow-fiber Modules with Nonuniform Fibers, J. Membr. Sci. 134, 235 (1997). 117. J. Lemanski and G.G. Lipscomb, Effect of Fiber Variation on the Performance of Counter-current Hollow-fiber Gas Separation Modules, J. Membr. Sci. 167, 241 (2000). 118. J. Lemanski and G.G. Lipscomb, Effect of Shell-side Flows on the Performance of Hollow-fiber Gas Separation Modules, J. Membr. Sci. 195, 215 (2002). 119. R. Prasad, C.J. Runkle and H.F. Shuey, Spiral-wound Hollow Fiber Cartridge and Modules Having Flow Directing Baffles, US Patent 5,352,361 (October, 1994). 120. R.C. Schucker, C.P. Darnell and M.M. Hafez, Hollow Fiber Module Using Fluid Flow Control Baffles, US Patent 5,169,530 (December, 1992). 121. T.J. Eckman, Hollow Fiber Cartridge, US Patent 5,470,469 (November, 1995). 122. R.P. de Filippi and R.W. Pierce, Membrane Device and Method, US Patent 3,536, 611 (October, 1970). 123. W.J. Koros and G.K. Fleming, Membrane Based Gas Separation, J. Membr. Sci. 83, 1 (1993). 124. P.R. McGinnis and G.J. O’Brien, Permeation Separation Element, US Patent 3,690, 465 (September, 1972). 125. B. Culkin, A. Plotkin and M. Monroe, Solve Membrane Fouling with High-shear Filtration, Chem. Eng. Prog. 94, 29 (1998). 126. O. Al Akoum, M.Y. Jaffrin, L. Ding, P. Paullier and C. Vanhoutte, An Hydrodynamic Investigation of Microfiltration and Ultrafiltration in a Vibrating Membrane Module, J. Membr. Sci. 197, 37 (2002).
4 CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION Introduction In membrane separation processes, a gas or liquid mixture contacts the feed side of the membrane, and a permeate enriched in one of the components of the mixture is withdrawn from the downstream side of the membrane. Because the feed mixture components permeate at different rates, concentration gradients form in the fluids on both sides of the membrane. The phenomenon is called concentration polarization. Figure 4.1 illustrates a dialysis experiment in which a membrane separates two solutions containing different concentrations of dissolved solute. Solute (i) diffuses from right to left; solvent (j ) diffuses from left to right. Unless the solutions are extremely well stirred, concentration gradients form in the solutions on either side of the membrane. The same phenomenon occurs in other processes that involve transport of heat or mass across an interface. Mathematical descriptions of these processes can be found in monographs on heat and mass transfer, for example, the books by Carslaw and Jaeger [1], Bird et al. [2] and Crank [3]. The layer of solution immediately adjacent to the membrane surface becomes depleted in the permeating solute on the feed side of the membrane and enriched in this component on the permeate side. Equivalent gradients also form for the other component. This concentration polarization reduces the permeating component’s concentration difference across the membrane, thereby lowering its flux and the membrane selectivity. The importance of concentration polarization depends on the membrane separation process. Concentration polarization can significantly affect membrane performance in reverse osmosis, but it is usually well controlled in industrial systems. On the other hand, membrane performance in ultrafiltration, electrodialysis, and some pervaporation processes is seriously affected by concentration polarization. Figure 4.1 also shows the formation of concentration polarization gradients on both sides of the membrane. However, in most membrane processes there is a bulk flow of liquid or gas through the membrane, and the permeate-side composition Membrane Technology and Applications R. W. Baker 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 0-470-85445-6
162
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
J( i ) Feed
Permeate
Component( i )
Component( j )
J( j )
Figure 4.1 Concentration gradients formed when a dialysis membrane separates two solutions of different concentrations
depends only on the ratio of the components permeating the membrane. When this is the case, concentration gradients only form on the feed side of the membrane. Two approaches have been used to describe the effect of concentration polarization. One has its origins in the dimensional analysis used to solve heat transfer problems. In this approach the resistance to permeation across the membrane and the resistance in the fluid layers adjacent to the membrane are treated as resistances in series. Nothing is assumed about the thickness of the various layers or the transport mechanisms taking place. Using this model and the assumption that concentration polarization occurs only on the feed side of the membrane, the flux Ji across the combined resistances of the feed side boundary layer and the membrane can be written as Ji = kov (cib − cip )
(4.1)
where kov is the overall mass transfer coefficient, cib is the concentration of component i in the bulk feed solution, and cip is the concentration of component i in the bulk permeate solution. Likewise, the flux across the boundary layer is also Ji and can be written as Ji = kb (cib − cio )
(4.2)
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
163
where kb is the fluid boundary layer mass transfer coefficient, and cio is the concentration of component i in the fluid at the feed/membrane interface, and the flux across the membrane can be written as Ji = km (cio − cip )
(4.3)
where km is the mass transfer coefficient of the membrane. Since the overall concentration drop (cib − cip ) is the sum of the concentration drops across the boundary layer and the membrane, a simple restatement of the resistances-in-series model using the terms of Equations (4.1–4.3) is 1 1 1 = + kov km kb
(4.4)
When the fluid layer mass-transfer coefficient (kb ) is large, the resistance 1/kb of this layer is small, and the overall resistance is determined only by the membrane. When the fluid layer mass-transfer coefficient is small, the resistance term 1/kb is large, and becomes a significant fraction of the total resistance to permeation. The overall mass transfer coefficient (kov ) then becomes smaller, and the flux decreases. The boundary layer mass transfer coefficient is thus an arithmetical fix used to correct the membrane permeation rate for the effect of concentration polarization. Nothing is revealed about the causes of concentration polarization. The boundary layer mass-transfer coefficient is known from experiment to depend on many system properties; this dependence can be expressed as an empirical relationship of the type kb = constant Qα hβ D γ T δ . . . ..
(4.5)
where, for example, Q is the fluid velocity through the membrane module, h is the feed channel height, D is the solute diffusion coefficient, T is the feed solution temperature, and so on. Empirical mass-transfer correlations obtained this way can be used to estimate the performance of a new membrane unit by extrapolation from an existing body of experimental data [4–7]. However, these correlations have a limited range of applicability and cannot be used to obtain a priori estimates of the magnitude of concentration polarization. This approach also does not provide insight into the dependence of concentration polarization on membrane properties. A more detailed and more sympathetic description of the mass-transfer approach is given in Cussler’s monograph [8]. The second approach to concentration polarization, and the one used in this chapter, is to model the phenomenon by assuming that a thin layer of unmixed fluid, thickness δ, exists between the membrane surface and the well-mixed bulk solution. The concentration gradients that control concentration polarization form in this layer. This boundary layer film model oversimplifies the fluid hydrodynamics occurring in membrane modules and still contains one adjustable parameter,
164
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
the boundary layer thickness. Nonetheless this simple model can explain most of the experimental data.
Boundary Layer Film Model The usual starting point for the boundary layer film model is illustrated in Figure 4.2, which shows the velocity profile in a fluid flowing through the channel of a membrane module. The average velocity of the fluid flowing down the channel is normally of the order 1–5 m/s. This velocity is far higher than the average velocity of the fluid flowing at right angles through the membrane, which is typically 10–20 µm/s. However, the velocity in the channel is not uniform. Friction at the fluid–membrane surface reduces the fluid velocity next to the membrane to essentially zero; the velocity increases as the distance from the membrane surface increases. Thus, the fluid flow velocity in the middle of the channel is high, the flow there is often turbulent, and the fluid is well mixed. The velocity in the boundary layer next to the membrane is much lower, flow is laminar, and mixing occurs by diffusion. Concentration gradients due to concentration polarization are assumed to be confined to the boundary layer. Figure 4.1 shows the concentration gradients that form on either side of a dialysis membrane. However, dialysis differs from most membrane processes in that the volume flow across the membrane is usually small. In processes such as reverse osmosis, ultrafiltration, and gas separation, the volume flow through the membrane from the feed to the permeate side is significant. As a result the permeate concentration is typically determined by the ratio of the fluxes of the components that permeate the membrane. In these processes concentration polarization gradients form only on the feed side of the membrane, as shown in Figure 4.3. This simplifies the description of the phenomenon. The few membrane processes in which a fluid is used to sweep the permeate side of the membrane, Laminar boundary layer
Fluid velocity profile
Turbulent region d Membrane
Laminar boundary layer
Figure 4.2 Fluid flow velocity through the channel of a membrane module is nonuniform, being fastest in the middle and essentially zero adjacent to the membrane. In the film model of concentration polarization, concentration gradients formed due to transport through the membrane are assumed to be confined to the laminar boundary layer
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
165
to change the permeate-side concentration from the value set by the ratio of permeating components, are discussed in the final section of this chapter. In any process, if one component is enriched at the membrane surface, then mass balance dictates that a second component is depleted at the surface. By convention, concentration polarization effects are described by considering the concentration gradient of the minor component. In Figure 4.3(a), concentration polarization in reverse osmosis is represented by the concentration gradient of salt, the minor component rejected by the membrane. In Figure 4.3(b), which illustrates dehydration of aqueous ethanol solutions by pervaporation, concentration polarization is represented by the concentration gradient of water, the minor component that preferentially permeates the membrane. Volume flow
Jv (a)
Component enriched at membrane surface (for example, salt in desalination of water by reverse osmosis)
ci p < ci b
ci o ci b ci p
(b)
Component depleted at membrane surface (for example, water in dehydration of ethanol by pervaporation)
ci p
ci p > ci b ci b
ci o Bulk of feed
Boundary layer
Membrane selective layer
Permeate
Figure 4.3 Concentration gradients formed as a result of permeation through a selective membrane. By convention, concentration polarization is usually represented by the gradient of the minor component—salt in the reverse osmosis example and water in the pervaporation example (dehydration of an ethanol solution)
166
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
In the case of desalination of water by reverse osmosis illustrated in Figure 4.3(a), the salt concentration cio adjacent to the membrane surface is higher than the bulk solution concentration cib because reverse osmosis membranes preferentially permeate water and retain salt. Water and salt are brought toward the membrane surface by the flow of solution through the membrane Jv .1 Water and a little salt permeate the membrane, but most of the salt is rejected by the membrane and retained at the membrane surface. Salt accumulates at the membrane surface until a sufficient gradient has formed to allow the salt to diffuse to the bulk solution. Steady state is then reached. In the case of dehydration of ethanol by pervaporation illustrated in Figure 4.3(b), the water concentration cio adjacent to the membrane surface is lower than the bulk solution concentration cib because the pervaporation membrane preferentially permeates water and retains ethanol. Water and ethanol are brought towards the membrane surface by the flow of solution through the membrane. Water and a little ethanol permeate the membrane, but most of the ethanol is retained at the membrane surface. Ethanol accumulates at the membrane surface until a sufficient gradient has formed to allow it to diffuse back to the bulk solution. An equal and opposite water gradient must form; thus, water becomes depleted at the membrane surface. The formation of these concentration gradients can be expressed in mathematical form. Figure 4.4 shows the steady-state salt gradient that forms across a reverse osmosis membrane. The salt flux through the membrane is given by the product of the permeate volume flux Jv and the permeate salt concentration cip . For dilute liquids the permeate volume flux is within 1 or 2 % of the volume flux on the feed side of the membrane because the densities of the two solutions are almost equal. This means that, at steady state, the net salt flux at any point within the boundary layer must also be equal to the permeate salt flux Jv cip . In the boundary layer this net salt flux is also equal to the convective salt flux towards the membrane Jv ci minus the diffusive salt flux away from the membrane expressed by Fick’s law (Di dci /dx). So, from simple mass balance, transport of salt at any point within the boundary layer can be described by the equation Jv ci − Di dci /dx = Jv cip
(4.6)
where Di is the diffusion coefficient of the salt, x is the coordinate perpendicular to the membrane surface, and Jv is the volume flux in the boundary layer generated by permeate flow through the membrane. The mass balance equation (4.6) can be integrated over the thickness of the boundary layer to give the well-known polarization equation first derived by Brian [9] for reverse osmosis: c io − c ip = exp(Jv δ/Di ) (4.7) c ib − c ip In this chapter, the term Jv is the volume flux (cm3 /cm2 · s) through the membrane measured at the feed-side conditions of the process. 1
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
167
In the boundary layer Jvci − Di dci = Jvcip dx Selective layer
ci o ci b
Porous support layer
Permeate flux Jv · ci b
Turbulent well mixed bulk solution d
ci p
Laminar mass-transfer boundary layer
Figure 4.4 Salt concentration gradients adjacent to a reverse osmosis desalination membrane. The mass balance equation for solute flux across the boundary layer is the basis of the film model description of concentration polarization
In this equation, cio is the concentration of solute in the feed solution at the membrane surface, and δ is the thickness of the boundary layer. An alternative form of Equation (4.7) replaces the concentration terms by an enrichment factor E, defined as cip /cib . The enrichment obtained in the absence of a boundary layer Eo is then defined as cip /cio , and Equation (4.7) can be written as 1/Eo − 1 = exp(Jv δ/Di ) 1/E − 1
(4.8)
In the case of reverse osmosis, the enrichment factors (E and Eo ) are less than 1.0, typically about 0.01, because the membrane rejects salt and permeates water. For other processes, such as dehydration of aqueous ethanol by pervaporation, the enrichment factor for water will be greater than 1.0 because the membrane selectively permeates the water. The increase or decrease of the permeate concentration at the membrane surface cio , compared to the bulk solution concentration cib , determines the extent of concentration polarization. The ratio of the two concentrations, cio /cib is called the
168
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
concentration polarization modulus and is a useful measure of the extent of concentration polarization. When the modulus is 1.0, no concentration polarization occurs, but as the modulus deviates farther from 1.0, the effect of concentration polarization on membrane selectivity and flux becomes increasingly important. From the definitions of E and Eo , the concentration polarization modulus is equal to E/Eo and, from Equations (4.7) and (4.8), the modulus can be written as c io exp(Jv δ/Di ) = c ib 1 + Eo [exp(Jv δ/Di ) − 1]
(4.9)
Depending on the enrichment term (Eo ) of the membrane, the modulus can be larger or smaller than 1.0. For reverse osmosis Eo is less than 1.0, and the concentration polarization modulus is normally between 1.1 and 1.5; that is, the concentration of salt at the membrane surface is 1.1 to 1.5 times larger than it would be in the absence of concentration polarization. The salt leakage through the membrane and the osmotic pressure that must be overcome to produce a flow of water are increased proportionately. Fortunately, modern reverse osmosis membranes are extremely selective and permeable, and can still produce useful desalted water under these conditions. In other membrane processes, such as pervaporation or ultrafiltration, the concentration polarization modulus may be as large as 5 to 10 or as small as 0.2 to 0.1, and may seriously affect the performance of the membrane. Equation (4.9) shows the factors that determine the magnitude of concentration polarization, namely the boundary layer thickness δ, the membrane enrichment Eo , the volume flux through the membrane Jv , and the diffusion coefficient of the solute in the boundary layer fluid Di . The effect of changes in each of these parameters on the concentration gradients formed in the membrane boundary layer are illustrated graphically in Figure 4.5 and discussed briefly below. Of the four factors that affect concentration polarization, the one most easily changed is the boundary layer thickness δ. As δ decreases, Equation (4.9) shows that the concentration polarization modulus becomes exponentially smaller. Thus, the most straightforward way of minimizing concentration polarization is to reduce the boundary layer thickness by increasing turbulent mixing at the membrane surface. Factors affecting turbulence in membrane modules are described in detail in the review of Belfort et al. [10]. The most direct technique to promote mixing is to increase the fluid flow velocity past the membrane surface. Therefore, most membrane modules operate at relatively high feed fluid velocities. Membrane spacers are also widely used to promote turbulence by disrupting fluid flow in the module channels, as shown in Figure 4.6 [11]. Pulsing the feed fluid flow through the membrane module is another technique [12]. However, the energy consumption of the pumps required and the pressure drops produced place a practical limit to the turbulence that can be obtained in a membrane module.
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
169
Increasing turbulence, reduces d decreases concentration polarization
Boundary layer thickness (d) d
Membrane enrichment (Eo)
Increasing membrane enrichment (Eo) increases concentration polarization
Increasing Eo
Membrane flux (J v)
Increasing flux increases concentration polarization
Increasing J v Increasing solute diffusion coefficient decreases concentration polarization
Solute diffusion coefficient (Di )
Increasing Di
Figure 4.5 The effect of changes in boundary layer thickness δ, membrane enrichment Eo , membrane flux Jv , and solute diffusion Di on concentration gradients in the stagnant boundary layer
The membrane’s intrinsic enrichment Eo also affects concentration polarization. If the membrane is completely unselective, Eo = 1. The relative concentrations of the components passing through the membrane do not change, so concentration gradients are not formed in the boundary layer. As the difference in permeability between the more permeable and less permeable components increases, the intrinsic enrichment Eo achieved by the membrane increases, and the concentration gradients that form become larger. As a practical example, in pervaporation of organics from water, concentration polarization is much more important when the solute is toluene (with an enrichment Eo of 5000 over water) than when the solute is methanol (with an enrichment Eo less than 5). Another important characteristic of Equation (4.9) is that the enrichment Eo produced by the membrane, not the intrinsic selectivity α, determines the
170
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Figure 4.6 Flow dynamics around the spacer netting often used to promote turbulence in a membrane module and reduce concentration polarization
membrane separation performance and the concentration polarization modulus. Enrichment and intrinsic selectivity are linked but are not identical. This distinction is illustrated by the separation of hydrogen from inert gases in ammonia plant purge gas streams, which typically contain 30 % hydrogen. Hydrogen is 100 to 200 times more permeable than the inert gases nitrogen, methane, and argon, so the intrinsic selectivity of the membrane is very high. The high selectivity means that the membrane permeate is 97 % hydrogen; even so, the enrichment Eo is only 97/30, or 3.3, so the concentration polarization modulus is small. On the other hand, as hydrogen is removed, its concentration in the feed gas falls. When the feed gas contains 5 % hydrogen, the permeate will be 90 % hydrogen and the enrichment 90/5 or 18. Under these conditions, concentration polarization can affect the membrane performance. Equation (4.9) shows that concentration polarization increases exponentially as the total volume flow Jv through the membrane increases. This is one of the reasons why modern spiral-wound reverse osmosis membrane modules are operated at low pressures. Modern membranes have two to five times the water permeability, at equivalent salt selectivities, of the first-generation cellulose acetate reverse osmosis membranes. If membrane modules containing these new membranes were operated at the same pressures as early cellulose acetate modules, two to five times the desalted water throughput could be achieved with the same
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
171
number of modules. However, at such high fluxes, spiral-wound modules suffer from excessive concentration polarization, which leads to increased salt leakage and scale formation. For this reason, modern, high permeability modules are operated at about the same volume flux as the early modules, but at lower applied pressures. This reduces energy costs. The final parameter in Equation (4.9) that determines the value of the concentration polarization modulus is the diffusion coefficient Di of the solute away from the membrane surface. The size of the solute diffusion coefficient explains why concentration polarization is a greater factor in ultrafiltration than in reverse osmosis. Ultrafiltration membrane fluxes are usually higher than reverse osmosis fluxes, but the difference between the values of the diffusion coefficients of the retained solutes is more important. In reverse osmosis the solutes are dissolved salts, whereas in ultrafiltration the solutes are colloids and macromolecules. The diffusion coefficients of these high-molecular-weight components are about 100 times smaller than those of salts. In Equation (4.9) the balance between convective transport and diffusive transport in the membrane boundary layer is characterized by the term Jv δ/Di . This dimensionless number represents the ratio of the convective transport Jv and diffusive transport Di /δ and is commonly called the Peclet number. When the Peclet number is large (Jv Di /δ), the convective flux through the membrane cannot easily be balanced by diffusion in the boundary layer, and the concentration polarization modulus is large. When the Peclet number is small (Jv Di /δ), convection is easily balanced by diffusion in the boundary layer, and the concentration polarization modulus is close to unity. Wijmans et al. [13] calculated the concentration polarization modulus using Equation (4.9) as a function of the Peclet number Jv δ/Di that is, the varying ratio of convection to diffusion. The resulting, very informative plot is shown in Figure 4.7. This figure is divided into two regions depending on whether the concentration polarization modulus, cio /cib , is smaller or larger than 1. The polarization modulus is smaller than 1 when the permeating minor component is enriched in the permeate. In this case, the component becomes depleted in the boundary layer, for example, in the dehydration of ethanol by pervaporation shown in Figure 4.3(b). The polarization modulus is larger than 1 when the permeating minor component is depleted in the permeate. In this case, the component is enriched in the boundary layer, for example, in the reverse osmosis of salt solutions shown in Figure 4.3(a). As might be expected, the concentration polarization modulus deviates increasingly from unity as the Peclet number increases. At high values of the ratio Jv δ/Di , the exponential term in Equation (4.9) increases toward infinity, and the concentration polarization modulus cio /cib approaches a limiting value of 1/Eo . A striking feature of Figure 4.7 is its asymmetry with respect to enrichment and rejection of the minor component by the membrane. This means that, under comparable conditions, concentration polarization is much larger when the minor
172
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Concentration polarization modulus (cio/ci b)
104 3
10
10−3 Intrinsic enrichment Eo
10−1 1
10 1
10−2
Component rejected by membrane
10
−1
10
102
10−2
Component enriched by membrane
103
−3
10
104
10−4 10−5 10−6
APPLICATIONS
10−4
Wijmans et al. (1996)
102
AND
Eo = 105 10−5
10−4
10−3 10−2 10−1 Peclet number, Jvd/Di
1
10
Figure 4.7 Concentration polarization modulus cio /cib as a function of the Peclet number Jv δ/Di for a range of values of the intrinsic enrichment factor Eo . Lines calculated through Equation (4.9). This figure shows that components that are enriched by the membrane (Eo > 1) are affected more by concentration polarization than components that are rejected by the membrane (Eo < 1) [13]
component of the feed is preferentially permeated by the membrane than when it is rejected. This follows from the form of Equation (4.9). Consider the case when the Peclet number Jv δ/Di is 1. The concentration polarization modulus expressed by Equation (4.9) then becomes c io 2.72 exp(1) = = c ib 1 + Eo [exp(1) − 1] 1 + Eo (1.72)
(4.10)
For components rejected by the membrane (Eo ≤ 1) the enrichment Eo produced by the membrane lies between 1 and 0. The concentration polarization modulus cio /cib then lies between 1 (no concentration polarization) and a maximum value of 2.72. That is, the flux of the less permeable component cannot be more than 2.72 times higher than that in the absence of concentration polarization. In contrast, for a component enriched by the membrane in the permeate (Eo ≥ 1), no such limitation on the magnitude of concentration polarization exists. For dilute solutions (cib small) and selective membranes, the intrinsic enrichment can be 100 to 1000 or more. The concentration polarization modulus can then change from 1 (no concentration polarization) to close to zero (complete concentration polarization). These two cases are illustrated in Figure 4.8.
Determination of the Peclet Number Equation (4.9) and Figure 4.7 are powerful tools to analyze the importance of concentration polarization in membrane separation processes. However, before
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION (a)
173
Component rejected by membrane
(b)
Component enriched by membrane
cip > ci b Eo > 1
cio
Eo = 0 Eo = 1 ci b
ci b Eo = 1
cip < ci b
Eo = ∞
Eo < 1
Figure 4.8 Concentration gradients that form adjacent to the membrane surface for components (a) rejected or (b) enriched by the membrane. The Peclet number, characterizing the balance between convection and diffusion in the boundary layer, is the same Jv δ/Di = 1. When the component is rejected, the concentration at the membrane surface cio cannot be greater than 2.72 cib , irrespective of the membrane selectivity. When the minor component permeates the membrane, the concentration at the membrane surface can decrease to close to zero, so the concentration polarization modulus becomes very small
these tools can be used, the appropriate value to be assigned to the Peclet number Jv δ/Di must be determined. The volume flux Jv through the membrane is easily measured, so determining the Peclet number then becomes a problem of measuring the coefficient Di /δ. One approach to the boundary layer problem is to determine the ratio Di /δ experimentally. This can be done using a procedure first proposed by Wilson [14]. The starting point for Wilson’s approach is Equation (4.8), which can be written as 1 1 ln 1 − (4.11) − Jv δ/Di = ln 1 − E Eo The boundary layer thickness δ in Equation (4.11) is a function of the feed solution velocity u in the module feed flow channel; thus, the term δ/Di can be expressed as Di (4.12) = ko un δ
174
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
where u is the superficial velocity in the feed flow channel and ko and n are constants. Equation (4.11) can then be rewritten as 1 Jv 1 ln 1 − (4.13) − = ln 1 − E Eo ko un Equation (4.13) can be used to calculate the dependence of pervaporation system performance on concentration polarization. One method is to use data obtained with a single module operated at various feed solution velocities. A linear regression analysis is used to fit data obtained at different feed velocities to obtain an estimate for ko and Eo ; the exponent n is adjusted to minimize the residual error. Figure 4.9 shows some data obtained in pervaporation experiments with dilute aqueous toluene solutions and silicone rubber membranes [15]. Toluene is considerably more permeable than water through these membranes. In Figure 4.9, when the data were regressed, the best value for n was 0.96. The values of Eo , the intrinsic enrichment of the membrane, and ko obtained by regression analysis are 3600 and 7.1 × 10−4 , respectively. The boundary layer coefficient, Di /δ is given by Di = 7.1 × 10−4 u0.96 (4.14) δ where u is the superficial velocity in the module. 0 3000
−4
1500
−8
1000 −12
800
−16
−20
60 °C data 45 °C data 0
1
2
Enrichment, E
104 × ln (1−1/E )
2000
600
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
J T/u 0.96 × 107
Figure 4.9 Derivation of the mass transfer coefficient by Wilson’s method. Toluene/water enrichments are plotted as a function of feed solution superficial velocity in pervaporation experiments. Enrichments were measured at different feed solution superficial velocities with spiral-wound membrane modules [15]
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
175
A second method of determining the coefficient (Di /δ) and the intrinsic enrichment of the membrane Eo is to use Equation (4.11). The term ln(1 − 1/E) is plotted against the permeate flux measured at constant feed solution flow rates but different permeate pressures or feed solution temperatures. This type of plot is shown in Figure 4.10 for data obtained with aqueous trichloroethane solutions in pervaporation experiments with silicone rubber membranes. The coefficients Di /δ obtained at each velocity in Figure 4.10 can then be plotted as a function of the feed superficial velocity. The data show that the ratio Di /δ varies with the superficial velocity according to the equation Di /δ = 9 × 10−4 u0.8
(4.15)
From Equations (4.14) and (4.15), the value of the term Di /δ at a fluid velocity of 30 cm/s is 1.6–1.8 × 10−2 cm/s. Based on a trichloroethane diffusion coefficient in the boundary layer of 2 × 10−5 cm2 /s, this yields a boundary layer thickness of 10–15 µm. This boundary layer thickness is in the same range as values calculated for reverse osmosis with similar modules.
0 −2 5000 45 cm/s 2000
−6
1500
30 cm/s
−8 −10
1000
Enrichment, E
104 × ln (1−1/E )
−4
15 cm/s
−12
800
−14
700
−16 0.0
0.2
0.4 0.6 0.8 Permeate flux, J v (10−5 cm3/cm2 • s)
1.0
1.2
Figure 4.10 Trichloroethane enrichment [ln(1 − 1/E)] as a function of permeate flux Jv in pervaporation experiments with silicone rubber membranes in spiral-wound modules using solutions of 100 ppm trichloromethane in water [15]. Feed solution flow rates are shown
176
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Concentration Polarization in Liquid Separation Processes The effect of concentration polarization on specific membrane processes is discussed in the individual application chapters. However, a brief comparison of the magnitude of concentration polarization is given in Table 4.1 for processes involving liquid feed solutions. The key simplifying assumption is that the boundary layer thickness is 20 µm for all processes. This boundary layer thickness is typical of values calculated for separation of solutions with spiral-wound modules in reverse osmosis, pervaporation, and ultrafiltration. Tubular, plate-and-frame, and bore-side feed hollow fiber modules, because of their better flow velocities, generally have lower calculated boundary layer thicknesses. Hollow fiber modules with shell-side feed generally have larger calculated boundary layer thicknesses because of their poor fluid flow patterns. Table 4.1 shows typical enrichments and calculated Peclet numbers for membrane processes with liquid feeds. In this table it is important to recognize the difference between enrichment and separation factor. The enrichments shown are calculated for the minor component. For example, in the dehydration of ethanol, a typical feed solution of 96 % ethanol and 4 % water yields a permeate containing about 80 % water; the enrichment, that is, the ratio of the permeate to feed concentration, is about 20. In Figure 4.11, the calculated Peclet numbers and enrichments shown in Table 4.1 are plotted on the Wijmans graph to show the relative importance of concentration polarization for the processes listed. Table 4.1 Representative values of the concentration polarization modulus calculated for a variety of liquid separation processes. For these calculations a boundary layer thickness of 20 µm, typical of that in most spiral-wound membrane modules, is assumed Process
Typical enrichment, Eo
Typical flux [in engineering units and as Jv (10−3 cm/s)]
Diffusion Peclet Concentration coefficient number, polarization (10−6 cm2 /s) Jv δ/Di modulus [Equation (4.9)]
Reverse osmosis Seawater desalination Brackish water desalination
0.01
30 gal/ft2 · day(1.4)
10
0.28
1.3
0.01
50 gal/ft2 · day(2.3)
10
0.46
1.5
0.01
30 gal/ft2 · day(1.4)
20
0.1 kg/m2 · h(0.003)
20
0.0003
1.0
2000
1.0 kg/m2 · h(0.03)
20
0.003
0.14
1000
60 mg/cm2 · min(0.001)
10
0.0002
0.8
Ultrafiltration Protein separation
0.5
5.6
70
Pervaporation Ethanol dehydration VOC from water Coupled transport Copper from water
177 10−3
Coupled transport
Pervaporation (dehydration)
10−2
Reverse osmosis
10−1
1
1
10−1 10
10−2 10
−3
10−5
Pervaporation (VOC from water) 10−4
105 10−3
102
103
104 10−2
10−1
1
p
Ultrafiltration
102 10
o
103
Intrinsic enrichment, Eo (ci /ci )
Concentration polarization modulus, (ci /ci ) o b
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
10
Peclet number, Jvd/Di
Figure 4.11 Peclet numbers and intrinsic enrichments for the membrane separation processes shown in Table 4.1 superimposed on the concentration polarization plot of Wijmans et al. [13]
In coupled transport and solvent dehydration by pervaporation, concentration polarization effects are generally modest and controllable, with a concentration polarization modulus of 1.5 or less. In reverse osmosis, the Peclet number of 0.3–0.5 was calculated on the basis of typical fluxes of current reverse osmosis membrane modules, which are 30- to 50-gal/ft2 · day. Concentration polarization modulus values in this range are between 1.0 and 1.5. Figure 4.11 shows that ultrafiltration and pervaporation for the removal of organic solutes from water are both seriously affected by concentration polarization. In ultrafiltration, the low diffusion coefficient of macromolecules produces a concentration of retained solutes 70 times the bulk solution volume at the membrane surface. At these high concentrations, macromolecules precipitate, forming a gel layer at the membrane surface and reducing flux. The effect of this gel layer on ultrafiltration membrane performance is discussed in Chapter 6. In the case of pervaporation of dissolved volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from water, the magnitude of the concentration polarization effect is a function of the enrichment factor. The selectivity of pervaporation membranes to different VOCs varies widely, so the intrinsic enrichment and the magnitude of concentration polarization effects depend strongly on the solute. Table 4.2 shows experimentally measured enrichment values for a series of dilute VOC solutions treated with silicone rubber membranes in spiral-wound modules [15]. When these values are superimposed on the Wijmans plot as shown in Figure 4.12, the concentration polarization modulus varies from 1.0, that is, no concentration polarization, for isopropanol, to 0.1 for trichloroethane, which has an enrichment of 5700.
178
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Table 4.2 Enrichment factors measured for the pervaporation of VOCs from dilute solutions with silicone rubber spiral-wound modules Enrichment (Eo )
Solute Trichloroethylene Toluene Ethyl acetate Isopropanol
Concentration polarization modulus, cio/ci b
1
5700 3600 270 18
Ethyl acetate
Isopropanol
Eo = 100
Toluene
E
o = 1
00
10−1
Trichloroethylene
E
o
E
o =
=1
00
00
0
10−2 10−4
0
10−3
10
00
0
10−2
Peclet number, Jvd/Di
Figure 4.12 A portion of the Wijmans plot shown in Figure 4.7 expanded to illustrate concentration polarization in pervaporation of dilute aqueous organic solutions. With solutes such as toluene and trichloroethylene, high intrinsic enrichments produce severe concentration polarization. Concentration polarization is much less with solutes such as ethyl acetate (enrichment 270), and is essentially eliminated with isopropanol (enrichment 18) [15]
Concentration Polarization in Gas Separation Processes Concentration polarization in gas separation processes has not been widely studied, and the effect is often assumed to be small because of the high diffusion coefficients of gases. However, the volume flux of gas through the membrane is also high, so concentration polarization effects are important for several processes. In calculating the expression for the concentration polarization modulus of gases, the simplifying assumption that the volume fluxes on each side of the
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
179
membrane are equal cannot be made. The starting point for the calculation is the mass-balance Equation (4.6), which for gas permeation is written Jvf ci −
Di dci = Jvp cip dx
(4.16)
where Jvf is the volume flux of gas on the feed side of the membrane and Jvp is the volume flux on the permeate side. These volume fluxes (cm3 /cm2 · s) can be linked by correcting for the pressure on each side of the membrane using the expression Jvf po = Jvp p (4.17) where po and p are the gas pressures on the feed and permeate sides of the membrane. Hence, po Jvf = Jvf ϕ = Jvp (4.18) p where ϕ is the pressure ratio po /p across the membrane. Substituting Equation (4.18) into Equation (4.16) and rearranging gives −Di
dci = Jvf (ϕ cip − ci ) dx
Integrating across the boundary layer thickness, as before, gives Jvf δ cio /ϕ − cip = exp cib /ϕ − cip D
(4.19)
(4.20)
For gases, the enrichment terms, E and Eo , are most conveniently expressed in volume fractions, so that c i p po c ip Eo = = ϕ (4.21) p c i o c io and E=
c i p po c ip · = ·ϕ p c i b c ib
Equation (4.20) can then be written as Jvf δ 1 − 1/Eo exp = Di 1 − 1/E
(4.22)
(4.23)
which on rearranging gives E/Eo = cio /cib =
exp(Jvf δ/Di ) 1 + Eo [exp(Jvf δ/Di ) − 1]
(4.24)
180
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
APPLICATIONS
CO2/CH4
1.0 O2/N2 Concentration polarization modulus ci /ci o b
AND
Eo = 1
H2/N2
0.8
H2O/CH4
VOC/Air
0.6
0.4
Eo = 10
Eo = 100
0.2
Eo = 1000
0.1 10
100
1000
10 000
Peclet number (J v f d/ D i ) × 104
Figure 4.13 A portion of the Wijmans plot shown in Figure 4.7 expanded to illustrate concentration polarization in some important gas separation applications
Equation (4.24) has the same form as the expression for the concentration polarization modulus of liquids, Equation (4.9). Equation (4.24) can be used to calculate the expected concentration polarization modulus for some of the better-known gas separation applications. The results of the calculations are tabulated in Table 4.3 and shown on a Wijmans plot in Figure 4.13. To obtain agreement between these calculations and industrial experience [16,17], it is necessary to assume the boundary layer thickness in gases is far greater than in liquids. In the calculations of Peclet numbers listed in Table 4.3 a boundary layer thickness of 2000 µm is used, 100 times larger than the value used in similar calculations for the Peclet number for liquid separation processes given in Table 4.1. A boundary layer thickness this large does not seem physically reasonable and in some cases is more than the membrane channel width. The reason for this huge difference between gases and liquids may be related to the difference in the densities of these fluids. Channeling, in which a portion of the feed gas completely bypasses contact with the membrane through some flow maldistribution in the module, can also reduce module efficiency in a way that is difficult to separate from concentration polarization. Channeling is much more noticeable in gas permeation modules than in liquid permeation modules.
O2 /N2 in air (5 % O2 ) VOC from air (1 % VOC) H2 /N2 ammonia purge gas (20 % H2 ) CO2 /CH4 natural gas (5 % CO2 ) H2 O/CH4 natural gas (0.05 % H2 O)
Gas separation process
2.9 0.32
40/10 35/5 30/1
50
5
10 0.74
6.8
10/1
100
0.68
Volume flux at feed pressure, Jvf −3 (10 cm3 /cm2 · s)
10/1
Pressure feed/permeate (atm/atm)
10
Pressure-normalized flux, P / [10−6 cm3 (STP)/ cm2 · s · cmHg]
500
20
100
50
7
Membrane selectivity, α
18.2
4.5
3.6
8.3
3.9
Enrichment, Eo
10
5
20
10
20
Feed gas diffusion coefficient at feed pressure (10−3 cm2 /s)
148
126
286
1360
68
Peclet number, Jvf δ/Di (×104 )
0.80
0.96
0.93
0.58
0.98
Concentration polarization modulus [Equation (4.24)]
Table 4.3 Calculated Peclet numbers for several important gas separations. The boundary layer thickness is assumed to be 2000 µm. Permeant diffusion coefficients in the gas boundary layer are taken from tables for ambient pressure diffusion coefficients in Cussler [8] and corrected for pressure. Membrane enrichments Eo are calculated using Equation (4.21)
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION 181
182
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Cross-flow, Co-flow and Counter-flow In the discussion of concentration polarization to this point, the assumption is made that the volume flux through the membrane is large, so the concentration on the permeate side of the membrane is determined by the ratio of the component fluxes. This assumption is almost always true for liquid separation processes, such as ultrafiltration or reverse osmosis, but must be modified in a few gas separation and pervaporation processes. In these processes, a lateral flow of gas is sometimes used to change the composition of the gas on the permeate side of the membrane. Figure 4.14 illustrates a laboratory gas permeation experiment using this effect. As the pressurized feed gas mixture is passed over the membrane surface, certain components permeate the membrane. On the permeate side of the membrane, a lateral flow of helium or other inert gas sweeps the permeate from the membrane surface. In the absence of the sweep gas, the composition of the gas mixture on the permeate side of the membrane is determined by the flow of components from the feed. If a large flow of sweep gas is used, the partial (a)
Feed
Membrane Sweep gas (helium) (b)
Feed boundary layer
Permeate boundary layer
Permeate gas activity profile Permeate concentration gradient No sweep gas flow
Some sweep gas flow Large sweep gas flow
Figure 4.14 (a) Flow schematic of permeation using a permeate-side sweep gas sometimes used in laboratory gas separation and pervaporation experiments. (b) The concentration gradients that form on the permeate side of the membrane depend on the volume of sweep gas used. In laboratory experiments a large sweep-gas-to-permeate-gas flow ratio is used, so the concentration of permeate at the membrane surface is very low
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
183
pressure of the permeating components on the permeate side of the membrane is reduced to a low value. The difference in partial pressure of the permeating gases from the feed to the permeate side of the membrane is thereby increased, and the flow across the membrane increases proportionately. Sweep gases are sometimes used in gas permeation and pervaporation laboratory experiments. The sweep gas is generally helium and the helium/permeate gas mixture is fed to a gas chromatograph for analysis. The drawback of using an external permeate-side sweep gas to lower the partial pressure on the permeate side of the membrane for an industrial process is that the sweep gas and permeating component must subsequently be separated. In some cases this may not be difficult; some processes that have been suggested but rarely used are shown in Figure 4.15. In these examples, the separation of the sweep gas and the permeating component is achieved by condensation. If the permeating gas is itself easily condensed, an inert gas such as nitrogen can be used as the sweep [18]. An alternative is a condensable vapor such as steam [19–21]. In the examples illustrated in Figures 4.14 and 4.15, the sweep gas is an inert gas that is unlike the permeating components. However, the sweep gas could be a mixture of the permeating components at a different composition. An example of this type of process is shown schematically in Figure 4.16, which illustrates the separation of nitrogen from air using a membrane that preferentially permeates oxygen. The feed air, containing approximately 20 vol% oxygen, is introduced under pressure at one end of the module. The permeate gas at this end of the module typically contains about 50 vol% oxygen (at a lower pressure). As the feed gas travels down the membrane module it becomes increasingly depleted in oxygen (enriched in nitrogen) and leaves the module as a residue gas containing 99 % nitrogen. The permeate gas at this end of the module contains about 5 vol% oxygen and 95 vol% nitrogen. If this gas is directed to flow counter to the incoming feed gas, as shown in Figure 4.16, the effect is to sweep the permeate side of the membrane with a flow of oxygen-depleted, nitrogen-enriched gas. This is beneficial because the oxygen gradient through the membrane is increased, which increases its flux through the membrane. Simultaneously the nitrogen gradient is decreased, which decreases its flux through the membrane. An opposite negative result would result if the permeate gas were moved in the same direction as the feed gas (that is co-flow). This would have the effect of sweeping the permeate side of the membrane with oxygen-enriched gas. The cross-, co- and counter-flow schemes are illustrated in Figure 4.17, together with the concentration gradient across a median section of the membrane. It follows from Figure 4.17 that system performance can be improved by operating a module in an appropriate flow mode (generally counter-flow). However, such improvements require that the concentration at the membrane permeate surface equals the bulk concentration of the permeate at that point. This condition cannot be met with processes such as ultrafiltration or reverse osmosis in which the permeate is a liquid. In these processes, the selective side of the membrane faces the
184
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY Gas mixture (A,B)
AND
APPLICATIONS
Component B
Inert gas (N2) Condenser Separation of a condensable vapor (A) from a mixture using an inert gas sweep (e.g. N2) [18]
Two-phase separator
Component A
Gas mixture (A,B)
Component B
Steam Condenser
Gas A
Evaporator Separation of a noncondensable gas (A) from a mixture using a condensable vapor sweep (e.g. steam) [19]
Two-phase separator
Organic mixture (A,B)
Component B
Steam Condenser
Liquid A
Figure 4.15
Evaporator Three-phase separator
Separation of an organic vapor mixture with an immiscible sweep gas (e.g. steam) [20,21]
Sweep gas systems proposed for industrial processes
feed solution, and a microporous support layer faces the permeate. Concentration gradients easily build up in this boundary layer, completely outweighing the benefit of counter-flow. Thus, counter-flow (sweep) module designs are limited to gas separation and pervaporation processes. In these processes the permeate is a gas, and permeate-side concentration gradients are more easily controlled because diffusion coefficients in gases are high.
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
185
20 % O2 80 % N2
1 % O2 99 % N2
Mole fraction O2: 0.5 Mole fraction N2: 0.5
Mole fraction O2: 0.05 Mole fraction N2: 0.95
Figure 4.16 An illustration of a counter-flow module for the separation of nitrogen from air. Directing the permeate to flow counter to the feed sweeps the permeate side of the membrane with a flow of oxygen-depleted gas. This increases the oxygen flux and decreases the nitrogen flux through the membrane
(a) Cross-flow Feed
Residue
Feed boundary layer
Permeate boundary layer
Permeate (b) Co-flow Feed
Residue
Concentration gradients of the more permeable component
Permeate
Co-flow (c) Counter-flow Feed
Cross-flow
Residue
Counter-flow Permeate
Membrane
Figure 4.17 (a) Cross-, (b) co- and (c) counter-flow schemes in a membrane module and the changes in the concentration gradients that occur across a median section of the membrane
The benefit obtained from counter-flow depends on the particular separation, but it can often be substantial, particularly in gas separation and pervaporation processes. A comparison of cross-flow, counter-flow, and counterflow/sweep for the same membrane module used to dehydrate natural gas is shown in Figure 4.18. Water is a smaller molecule and much more condensable than methane, the main component of natural gas, so membranes with a water/methane selectivity of 400–500 are readily available. In the calculations shown in Figure 4.18, the membrane is assumed to have a pressure-normalized
186
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY (a) Cross-flow module
1MMscfd 1000 psia 1000 ppm H2O
114 m2
AND
APPLICATIONS
Dry gas 100 ppm H2O
Permeate gas 50 psia 6 140 ppm H2O
(b) Counter-flow module
1MMscfd 1000 psia 1000 ppm H2O
61 m2
Dry gas 100 ppm H2O
Permeate gas 50 psia 13 300 ppm H2O
(c) Counter-flow/sweep module
1 MMscfd 1000 psia 1000 ppm H2O
20 m2
Dry gas 100 ppm H2O
Permeate gas 50 psia 13 000 ppm H2O
Figure 4.18 Comparison of (a) cross-flow, (b) counter-flow and (c) counter-flow sweep module performance for the separation of water vapor from natural gas. Pressurenormalized methane flux: 5 × 10−6 cm3 (STP)/cm2 · s · cmHg; membrane selectivity, water/methane: 200
methane flux of 5 × 10−6 cm3 (STP)/cm2 · s · cmHg and a water/methane selectivity of 200. Counter-flow/sweep modules have a substantial advantage in this separation because the separation is completely pressure-ratio-limited.2 2 The importance of the pressure ratio in separating gas mixtures can be illustrated by considering the separation of a gas mixture with component concentrations (mol%) nio and njo at a feed pressure of po . A flow of component across the membrane can only occur if the partial pressure of component i on the feed side of the membrane, nio po , is greater than the partial pressure of component i on the permeate side of the membrane, ni p . That is
nio po > ni p It follows that the maximum enrichment achieved by the membrane can be expressed as po ni ≤ ni o p
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
187
In the cross-flow module illustrated in Figure 4.18(a) the average concentration of water on the feed side of the membrane as it decreases from 1000 to 100 ppm is 310 ppm (the log mean). The pooled permeate stream has a concentration of 6140 ppm. The counter-flow module illustrated in Figure 4.18(b) performs substantially better, providing a pooled permeate stream with a concentration of 13 300 ppm. Not only does the counter-flow module perform a two-fold better separation, it also requires only about half the membrane area. In the case of the counter-flow/sweep membrane module illustrated in Figure 4.18(c) a portion of the dried residue gas stream is expanded across a valve and used as the permeate-side sweep gas. The separation obtained depends on how much gas is used as a sweep. In the calculation illustrated, 5 % of the residue gas is used as a sweep; even so the result is dramatic. The concentration of water vapor in the permeate gas is 13 000 ppm, almost the same as the perfect counter-flow module shown in Figure 4.18(b), but the membrane area required to perform the separation is one-third of the counter-flow case. Mixing separated residue gas with the permeate gas improves the separation! The cause of this paradoxical result is illustrated in Figure 4.19 and discussed in a number of papers by Cussler et al. [16]. Figure 4.19(a) shows the concentration of water vapor on the feed and permeate sides of the membrane module in the case of a simple counter-flow module. On the high-pressure side of the module, the water vapor concentration in the feed gas drops from 1000 ppm to about 310 ppm halfway through the module and to 100 ppm at the residue end. The graph directly below the module drawing shows the theoretical maximum concentration of water vapor on the permeate side of the membrane. This maximum is determined by the feed-to-permeate pressure ratio of 20 as described in the footnote to page 186. The actual calculated permeate-side concentration is also shown. The difference between these two lines is a measure of the driving force for water vapor transport across the membrane. At the feed end of the module, this difference is about 1000 ppm, but at the permeate end the difference is only about 100 ppm. Figure 4.19(b) shows an equivalent figure for a counter-flow module in which 5 % of the residue gas containing 100 ppm water vapor is expanded to 50 psia and introduced as a sweep gas. The water vapor concentration in the permeate gas at the end of the membrane then falls from 1900 ppm to 100 ppm, producing a dramatic increase in water vapor permeation through the membrane at the residue end of the module. The result is a two-thirds reduction in the size of the module.
This means that the enrichment can never exceed the pressure ratio of po /p , no matter how selective the membrane. In the example above, the maximum water vapor enrichment across the membrane is 20 (1000 psia/50 psia) even though the membrane is 200 times more permeable to water than methane.
1000 ppm 100 ppm
Water vapor driving force
Residue
1000 ppm
Feed
100
200
2000
20 000
Sweep flow 0.05 MMscfd
100 ppm
Distance through module Residue
Water vapor driving force
Theoretical maximum water vapor concentration
310 ppm
20 m2
Actual water vapor concentration
Permeate 0.07 MMscfd 50 psia 13 000 ppm H2O
Feed 1 MMscfd 1000 psia 1000 ppm H2O
Residue 0.93 MMscfd 1000 psia 100 ppm H2O
AND
Figure 4.19 The effect of a small permeate-side, counter-flow sweep on the water vapor concentration on the permeate side of a membrane. In this example calculation, the sweep flow reduces the membrane area by two-thirds
Distance through module
Actual water vapor concentration
Theoretical maximum water vapor concentration (20x feed concentration)
310 ppm
Residue 0.932 MMscfd 1000 psia 100 ppm H2O
(b) Counter-flow with sweep
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Feed
200
2000
20 000
Permeate 0.068 MMscfd 50 psia 13 300 ppm H2O
Feed 1 MMscfd 1000 psia 1000 ppm H2O
Permeate water vapor concentration (ppm)
61 m2
Permeate water vapor concentration (ppm)
(a) Simple counter-flow — no sweep
188 APPLICATIONS
CONCENTRATION POLARIZATION
189
Conclusions and Future Directions Few membrane processes are unaffected by concentration polarization, and the effect is likely to become more important as membrane materials and membrane fabrication techniques improve. As membrane flux and selectivity increase concentration polarization effects become exponentially larger. In the laboratory, concentration polarization is controlled by increasing the turbulence of the feed fluid. However, in industrial systems this approach has practical limits. In ultrafiltration and electrodialysis, for example, liquid recirculation pumps are already a major portion of the plant’s capital cost and consume 20 to 40 % of the power used for the separation. The best hope for minimizing concentration polarization effects lies in improving membrane module design, understanding the basis for the choice of channel spacer materials, and developing methods of controlling the feed fluid flow in the module. Unfortunately, this type of work is generally performed in membrane system manufacturing companies and is not well covered in the open literature.
References 1. H.S. Carslaw and J.C. Jaeger, Conduction of Heat in Solids, Oxford University Press, London (1947). 2. R.B. Bird, W.E. Stewart and E.N. Lightfoot, Transport Phenomena, Wiley, New York (1960). 3. J. Crank, The Mathematics of Diffusion, Oxford University Press, London (1956). 4. M.C. Porter, Concentration Polarization with Membrane Ultrafiltration, Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. Dev. 11, 234 (1972). 5. J.V. Lepore and R.C. Ahlert, Fouling in Membrane Processes, in Reverse Osmosis Technology, B.S. Parekh (ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, pp. 141–184 (1988). 6. S.R. Wickramasinghe, M.J. Semmens and E.L. Cussler, Mass Transfer in Various Hollow Fiber Geometries, J. Membr. Sci. 69, 235 (1992). 7. L. Mi and S.T. Hwang, Correlation of Concentration Polarization and Hydrodynamic Parameters in Hollow Fiber Modules, J. Membr. Sci. 159, 143 (1999). 8. E.L. Cussler, Diffusion Mass Transfer in Fluid Systems, 2nd Edn, Cambridge University Press, New York, NY and Cambridge, UK (1997). 9. P.L.T. Brian, Mass Transport in Reverse Osmosis, in Desalination by Reverse Osmosis, U. Merten (ed.), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 161–292 (1966). 10. G. Belfort, R.H. Davis and A.L. Zydney, The Behavior of Suspensions and Macromolecular Solutions in Cross Flow Microfiltration, J. Membr. Sci. 1, 96 (1994). 11. A.R. Da Costa, A.G. Fane and D.E. Wiley, Spacer Characterization and Pressure Drop Modeling in Spacer-filled Channels for Ultrafiltration, J. Membr. Sci. 87, 79 (1994). 12. M.Y. Jaffrin, B.B. Gupta and P. Paullier, Energy Savings Pulsatile Mode Crossflow Filtration, J. Membr. Sci. 86, 281 (1994). 13. J.G. Wijmans, A.L. Athayde, R. Daniels, J.H. Ly, H.D. Kamaruddin and I. Pinnau, The Role of Boundary Layers in the Removal of Volatile Organic Compounds from Water by Pervaporation, J. Membr. Sci. 109, 135 (1996). 14. E.E. Wilson, A Basis for Rational Design of Heat Transfer Apparatus, Trans. ASME 37, 47 (1915).
190
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
15. R.W. Baker, J.G. Wijmans, A.L. Athayde, R. Daniels, J.H. Ly and M. Le, The Effect of Concentration Polarization on the Separation of Volatile Organic Compounds from Water by Pervaporation, J. Membr. Sci. 137, 159 (1997). 16. K.L. Wang, S.H. McCray, D.N. Newbold and E.L. Cussler, Hollow Fiber Air Drying, J. Membr. Sci. 72, 231 (1992). 17. O. L¨udtke, R.D. Behling and K. Ohlrogge, Concentration Polarization in Gas Permeation, J. Membr. Sci. 146, 145 (1998). 18. F.E. Frey, Process for Concentrating Hydrocarbons, US Patent 2,159,434 (May, 1939). 19. R.J. Walker, C.J. Drummond and J.M. Ekmann, Evaluation of Advanced Separation Techniques for Application to Flue Gas Cleanup Processes for the Simultaneous Removal of Sulfur Dioxide and Nitrogen Oxides, Department of Energy Report, DE85102227 (May, 1985). 20. A.E. Robertson, Separation of Hydrocarbons, US Patent 2,475,990 (July, 1969). 21. R.W. Baker, E.L. Cussler, W. Eykamp, W.J. Koros, R.L. Riley and H. Strathmann, Membrane Separation Systems, Noyes Data Corp., Park Ridge, NJ, p. 155 (1991).
5 REVERSE OSMOSIS Introduction and History Reverse osmosis is a process for desalting water using membranes that are permeable to water but essentially impermeable to salt. Pressurized water containing dissolved salts contacts the feed side of the membrane; water depleted of salt is withdrawn as a low-pressure permeate. The ability of membranes to separate small solutes from water has been known for a very long time. Pfeffer, Traube and others studied osmotic phenomena with ceramic membranes as early as the 1850s. In 1931 the process was patented as a method of desalting water, and the term reverse osmosis was coined [1]. Modern interest dates from the work of Reid and Breton, who in 1959 showed that cellulose acetate films could perform this type of separation [2]. Their films were 5–20 µm thick so fluxes were very low but, by pressurizing the feed salt solution to 1000 psi, they obtained salt removals of better than 98 % in the permeate water. The breakthrough discovery that made reverse osmosis a practical process was the development of the Loeb–Sourirajan anisotropic cellulose acetate membrane [3]. This membrane had 10 times the flux of the best membrane of Reid and Breton and equivalent rejections. With these membranes, water desalination by reverse osmosis became a potentially practical process, and within a few years small demonstration plants were installed. The first membrane modules were tubular or plate-and-frame systems, but Westmoreland, Bray, and others at the San Diego Laboratories of Gulf General Atomics (the predecessor of Fluid Systems Inc.) soon developed practical spiral-wound modules [4,5]. Later, Du Pont [6], building on the earlier work of Dow, introduced polyaramide hollow fine fiber reverse osmosis modules under the name Permasep . Anisotropic cellulose acetate membranes were the industry standard through the 1960s to the mid-1970s, until Cadotte, then at North Star Research, developed the interfacial polymerization method of producing composite membranes [7]. Interfacial composite membranes had extremely high salt rejections, combined with good water fluxes. Fluid Systems introduced the first commercial interfacial composite membrane in 1975. The construction of a large seawater desalination plant at Jiddah, Saudi Arabia using these membranes was a milestone in reverse Membrane Technology and Applications R. W. Baker 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 0-470-85445-6
192
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
osmosis development [8]. Later, at FilmTec, Cadotte developed a fully aromatic interfacial composite membrane based on the reaction of phenylene diamine and trimesoyl chloride [9,10]. This membrane has become the new industry standard. The most recent development, beginning in the mid-1980s, was the introduction of low-pressure nanofiltration membranes by all of the major reverse osmosis companies [11,12]. These membranes are used to separate trace amounts of salts and other dissolved solutes from already good-quality water to produce ultrapure water for the electronics industry. An important recent advance by Grace Davison working with Mobil Oil, now ExxonMobil, is the development of a reverse osmosis (hyperfiltration) process to separate a solution of methyl ethyl ketone and lube oil. A plant installed at a Beaumont, Texas, refinery in 1998 was the first large-scale use of pressure-driven membranes to separate organic solvent mixtures. Currently, approximately one billion gal/day of water are desalted by reverse osmosis. Half of this capacity is installed in the United States, Europe, and Japan, principally to produce ultrapure industrial water. The remainder is installed in the Middle East and other desert regions to produce municipal drinking water from brackish groundwater or seawater. In recent years, the interfacial composite membrane has displaced the anisotropic cellulose acetate membrane in most applications. Interfacial composite membranes are supplied in spiral-wound module form; the market share of hollow fiber membranes is now less than Desalination capability of cellulose acetate film demonstrated Breton and Reid - 1959 Asymmetric cellulose acetate membrane developed Loeb and Sourirajan - 1962 First practical spiral-wound module General Atomics - 1963 First commercially successful hollow fiber module Du Pont - 1967 Interfacial composite membrane developed Cadotte - 1972 Low pressure nanofiltration membrane widely available Fluid Systems, Nitto Denko, FilmTec - 1986 1960
1970 First commercial interfacial composite Riley at Fluid Systems Jiddah seawater plant installed - 1975
Figure 5.1
1980
1990 First fully aromatic thin film composite (FT-30) Cadotte - 1978
2000
Grace-Davison and Mobil install first large hyperfiltration solvent separation plant Beaumont Texas refinery - 1998
Milestones in the development of reverse osmosis
REVERSE OSMOSIS
193
10 % of new installed capacity and shrinking [13]. Tubular and plate-and-frame systems, which are only competitive for small niche applications involving particularly highly fouling water, have less than 5 % of the market. Some of the milestones in the development of the reverse osmosis industry are summarized in Figure 5.1.
Theoretical Background Salt and water permeate reverse osmosis membranes according to the solutiondiffusion transport mechanism are described in Chapter 2. The water flux, Ji , is linked to the pressure and concentration gradients across the membrane by the equation Ji = A(p − π) (5.1) where p is the pressure difference across the membrane, π is the osmotic pressure differential across the membrane, and A is a constant. As this equation shows, at low applied pressure, when p < π, water flows from the dilute to the concentrated salt-solution side of the membrane by normal osmosis. When p = π, no flow occurs, and when the applied pressure is higher than the osmotic pressure, p > π, water flows from the concentrated to the dilute salt-solution side of the membrane. The salt flux, Jj , across a reverse osmosis membrane is described by the equation Jj = B(cjo − cj )
(5.2)
where B is the salt permeability constant and cjo and cj , respectively, are the salt concentrations on the feed and permeate sides of the membrane. The concentration of salt in the permeate solution (cj ) is usually much smaller than the concentration in the feed (cjo ), so equation (5.2) can be simplified to Jj = Bcjo
(5.3)
It follows from these two equations that the water flux is proportional to the applied pressure, but the salt flux is independent of pressure. This means that the membrane becomes more selective as the pressure increases. Selectivity can be measured in a number of ways, but conventionally, it is measured as the salt rejection coefficient R, defined as cj R = 1 − × 100 % (5.4) cjo The salt concentration on the permeate side of the membrane can be related to the membrane fluxes by the expression cj =
Jj × ρi Ji
(5.5)
194
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
where ρi is the density of water (g/cm3 ). By combining equations (5.1) to (5.5), the membrane rejection can be expressed as ρi · B R= 1− × 100 % (5.6) A(p − π) The effects of the most important operating parameters on membrane water flux and salt rejection are shown schematically in Figure 5.2 [14]. The effect of feed pressure on membrane performance is shown in Figure 5.2(a). As predicted by Equation (5.1), at a pressure equal to the osmotic pressure of the feed (350 psi), the water flux is zero; thereafter, it increases linearly as the pressure is increased. The salt rejection also extrapolates to zero at a feed pressure of 350 psi as predicted by Equation (5.6), but increases very rapidly with increased pressure to reach salt rejections of more than 99 % at an applied pressure of 700 psi (twice the feed solution osmotic pressure). The effect of increasing the concentration of salt in the feed solution on membrane performance is illustrated in Figure 5.2(b). Increasing the salt concentration effectively increases the osmotic pressure term in Equation (5.1); consequently, at a constant feed pressure, the water flux falls with increasing salt concentration at a feed pressure of 1000 psi. The water flux approaches zero when the salt concentration is about 10 wt%, at which point the osmotic pressure equals the applied hydrostatic pressure. The salt rejection also extrapolates to zero rejection at this point but increases rapidly with decreasing salt concentration. Salt rejections of more than 99 % are reached at salt concentrations below 6 %, corresponding to a net applied pressure of about 400 psi. The effect of temperature on salt rejection and water flux illustrated in Figure 5.2(c) is more complex. Transport of both salt and water represented by Equations (5.1) and (5.3) is an activated process, and both increase exponentially with increasing temperature. As Figure 5.2(c) shows, the effect of temperature on the water flux of membranes is quite dramatic: the water flux doubles as the temperature is increased by 30 ◦ C. However, the effect of temperature on the salt flux is even more marked. This means that the salt rejection coefficient, proportional to the ratio B/A in Equation (5.6), actually declines slightly as the temperature increases. Measurements of the type shown in Figure 5.2 are typically obtained with small laboratory test cells. A typical test system is illustrated in Figure 5.3. Such systems are often used in general membrane quality control tests with a number of cells arranged in series through which fluid is pumped. The system is usually operated with a test solution of 0.2 to 1.0 % sodium chloride at pressures ranging from 150 to 600 psi. The storage tank and flow recirculation rate are made large enough that changes in concentration of the test solution due to loss of permeate can be ignored. Some confusion can occur over the rejection coefficients quoted by membrane module manufacturers. The intrinsic rejection of good quality membranes measured in a laboratory test system might be in the range 99.5 to 99.7 %, whereas
REVERSE OSMOSIS
195 100
60
99
40
98
97
20
Salt rejection (%)
Water flux (gfd)
(a) 25 °C, 3.5% NaCl 80
∆p 200
400 600 Feed pressure (psi)
800
Water flux (gfd)
(b) 25 °C, 1000 psi 80
100
60
99
40
98
20
97
0
0
2
4 6 NaCl concentration (%)
8
(c) 3.5 % NaCl, 1000 psi 80
Water flux (gfd)
96 1000
96 10
100
60
99
40
98
20
97
0 10
20
30 40 50 Feed water temperature (°C)
Salt rejection (%)
0
Salt rejection (%)
0
96 60
Figure 5.2 Effect of pressure, feed salt concentration and feed temperature on the properties of good quality seawater desalination membranes (SW-30) [14]
196
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY P
AND
APPLICATIONS
Pressure gauge
Bypass Flowmeter
Fresh feed water
Pump
Membrane test cells
Drain
Figure 5.3 Flow schematic of a high-pressure laboratory reverse osmosis test system
the same membrane in module form may have a salt rejection of 99.4 to 99.5 %. This difference is due to small membrane defects introduced during module production and to concentration polarization, which has a small but measurable effect on module rejection. Manufacturers call the module value the nominal rejection. However, manufacturers will generally only guarantee a lower figure, for example, 99.3 % for the initial module salt rejection to take into account variations between modules. To complicate matters further, module performance generally deteriorates slowly during the 1- to 3-year guaranteed module lifetime due to membrane compaction, membrane fouling, and membrane degradation from hydrolysis, chlorine attack, or membrane cleaning. A decrease in the membrane flux by 20 % over the 3-year lifetime of typical modules is not unusual, and the rejection can easily fall by 0.2–0.3 %. Reverse osmosis system manufacturers allow for this decline in performance when designing systems.
Membranes and Materials A number of membrane materials and membrane preparation techniques have been used to make reverse osmosis membranes. The target of much of the early work was seawater desalination (approximately 3.5 wt% salt), which requires membranes with salt rejections of greater than 99.3 % to produce an acceptable permeate containing less than 500 ppm salt. Early membranes could only meet
REVERSE OSMOSIS
197
this target performance when operated at very high pressures, up to 1500 psi. As membrane performance has improved, this pressure has dropped to 800–1000 psi. Recently, the need for desalination membranes has shifted more to brackish water feeds with salt concentrations of 0.2–0.5 wt%. For this application, membranes are typically operated at pressures in the 150–400 psi range with a target salt rejection of about 99 %. With the growth of the electronics industry the demand for ultrapure water to wash silicon wafers has increased. The feed to an ultrapure water reverse osmosis plant is often municipal drinking water, which may only contain 100 to 200 ppm dissolved salts, mostly divalent ions. The target membrane performance in this case may be 98–99 % sodium chloride rejection but more than 99.5 % divalent ion rejection. These membranes are operated at low pressures, typically in the 100–200 psi range. Many manufacturers tailor the properties of a single membrane material to meet the requirements of different applications. Invariably a significant trade-off between flux and rejection is involved. A brief description of the commercially important membranes in current use follows. More detailed descriptions can be found in specialized reviews [13,15,16]. Petersen’s review on interfacial composite membranes is particularly worth noting [17]. Cellulosic Membranes Cellulose acetate was the first high-performance reverse osmosis membrane material discovered. The flux and rejection of cellulose acetate membranes have now been surpassed by interfacial composite membranes. However, cellulose acetate membranes still maintain a small fraction of the market because they are easy to make, mechanically tough, and resistant to degradation by chlorine and other oxidants, a problem with interfacial composite membranes. Cellulose acetate membranes can tolerate up to 1 ppm chlorine, so chlorination can be used to sterilize the feed water, a major advantage with feed streams having significant bacterial loading. The water and salt permeability of cellulose acetate membranes is extremely sensitive to the degree of acetylation of the polymer used to make the membrane [2,18,19]. The effect of degree of acetylation on salt and water permeability is illustrated in Figure 5.4 [20]. Fully substituted cellulose triacetate (44.2 wt% acetate) has an extremely high water-to-salt permeability ratio, reflecting its very high selectivity. Unfortunately the water permeability is low so these membranes have low water fluxes. Nonetheless, cellulose triacetate hollow fine fiber membranes are still produced for some seawater desalination plants because salt rejections of about 99.5 % with a seawater feed are attainable. However, most commercial cellulose acetate membranes use a polymer containing about 40 wt% acetate with a degree of acetylation of 2.7. These membranes generally achieve 98–99 % sodium chloride rejection and have reasonable fluxes. The permeability
198
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
16 Water permeability, (10−7g/cm·s)
14
Lonsdale et al. (1965)
12 10 8 6 4 2
Water to salt permeability ratio (g/cm3)
0 106
105
104
103
102 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 Acetyl content (wt %)
Figure 5.4 Permeabilities of cellulose acetate to water and sodium chloride as a function of acetyl content at 25 ◦ C. Data from Lonsdale et al. [20]
data shown in Figure 5.4 can be replotted to show expected salt rejections, as shown in Figure 5.5. The data in Figure 5.5 show that thick films of cellulose acetate made from 39.8 wt% acetate polymer should reject 99.5 % sodium chloride. In practice, this theoretical rejection is very difficult to obtain with practical thin membranes [21]. Figure 5.6 shows the salt rejection properties of 39.8 wt% acetate membranes made by the Loeb–Sourirajan process [22]. The freshly formed membranes have very high water fluxes of almost 200 gal/ft2 · day (gfd) but almost no rejection of sodium chloride. The membranes appear to have a finely microporous structure and are permeable to quite large solutes such as sucrose. The rejection of these membranes can be greatly improved by heating in a bath of hot water for a few minutes. Apparently, this annealing procedure, used with all cellulose acetate membranes, modifies the salt rejection layer of the membrane by eliminating the micropores and producing a denser, more salt-rejecting skin. The water flux decreases, and the sodium chloride rejection increases. The temperature of this
REVERSE OSMOSIS
199
Water permeability (g/cm•s)
10−5
Solute rejection 99.9 %
10−6
Solute rejection 99 %
37.6 % Ac 43.2 % Ac
10−7 10−13
10−12
33.6 % Ac
39.8 % Ac 10−11
10−10
10−9
10−8
Sodium chloride permeability (g/cm • s)
Figure 5.5 Water permeability as a function of sodium chloride permeability for membranes made from cellulose acetate of various degrees of acetylation. The expected rejection coefficients for these membranes, calculated for dilute salt solutions using Equation (5.6), are shown 200
Sourirajan (1970) 300
Permeate flux (gal/ft2 • day)
80 °C 200 85 °C
100
Permeate flux (L/m2 • h)
75 °C
150
100 50
90°C 95 °C
0 20
40
60
80
0 100
Salt rejection (%)
Figure 5.6 The effect of annealing temperatures on the flux and rejection of cellulose acetate membranes. The anealing temperature is shown on the figure. (Cellulose diacetate membranes tested at 1500 psig with 0.5 M NaCl) [22]. Reprinted with permission from Elsevier
200
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
annealing step determines the final properties of the membrane. A typical rejection/flux curve for various annealed membranes is shown in Figure 5.6. Because their properties change on heating, cellulose acetate membranes are generally not used above about 35 ◦ C. The membranes also slowly hydrolyze over time, so the feed water is usually adjusted to pH 4–6, the range in which the membranes are most stable [23]. Throughout the 1960s considerable effort was expended on understanding the Loeb–Sourirajan membrane production process to improve the quality of the membranes produced. The casting solution composition is critically important. Other important process steps are the time of evaporation before precipitation, the temperature of the precipitation bath, and the temperature of the annealing step. Most of the early membranes were made of 39.8 wt% acetate polymer because this material was readily available and had the most convenient solubility properties. By the 1970s, however, a number of workers, particularly Saltonstall and others at Envirogenics, had developed better membranes by blending the 39.8 wt% acetate polymer with small amounts of triacetate polymer (44.2 wt% acetate) or other cellulose esters such as cellulose acetate butyrate [24]. These blends are generally used to form current cellulose acetate membranes. Goodquality blend membranes with seawater salt rejections of 99.0–99.5 %, close to the theoretical salt rejection determined by thick film measurements, can be made, but the flux of these membranes is modest. However, most applications of cellulose acetate membranes do not require such high salt rejections, so the typical commercial cellulose acetate membrane has good fluxes and a sodium chloride rejection of about 96 %. Noncellulosic Polymer Membranes During the 1960s and 1970s the Office of Saline Water sponsored development of noncellulosic reverse osmosis membranes. Many polymers were evaluated as Loeb–Sourirajan membranes but few matched the properties of cellulose acetate. Following the development of interfacial composite membranes by Cadotte, this line of research was abandoned by most commercial membrane producers. Nonetheless a few commercially successful noncellulosic membrane materials were developed. Polyamide membranes in particular were developed by several groups. Aliphatic polyamides have low rejections and modest fluxes, but aromatic polyamide membranes were successfully developed by Toray [25], Chemstrad (Monsanto) [26] and Permasep (Du Pont) [27], all in hollow fiber form. These membranes have good seawater salt rejections of up to 99.5 %, but the fluxes are low, in the 1 to 3 gal/ft2 · day range. The Permasep membrane, in hollow fine fiber form to overcome the low water permeability problems, was produced under the names B-10 and B-15 for seawater desalination plants until the year 2000. The structure of the Permasep B-15 polymer is shown in Figure 5.7. Polyamide membranes, like interfacial composite membranes, are susceptible to degradation by chlorine because of their amide bonds.
REVERSE OSMOSIS OC
201 CONH
OC
NH
CONH
NH
SO3Na
x
Figure 5.7 fibers [27]
y
Aromatic polyamide used by Du Pont in its Permasep B-15 hollow fine
SO3Na
CH2CH
CH3 SO2
O
OH
C CH3
CH2CH
x
O
y
R SO3Na
x
Figure 5.8 Membranes based on sulfonated polysulfone and substituted poly(vinyl alcohol) are produced by Hydranautics (Nitto) for nanofiltration applications
Loeb–Sourirajan membranes based on sulfonated polysulfone and substituted poly(vinyl alcohol) produced by Hydranautics (Nitto) have also found a commercial market as high-flux, low-rejection membranes in water softening applications because their divalent ion rejection is high. These membranes are also chlorineresistant and have been able to withstand up to 40 000 ppm · h of chlorine exposure without degradation.1 The structures of the polymers used by Hydranautics are shown in Figure 5.8. Interfacial Composite Membranes Since the discovery by Cadotte and his co-workers that high-flux, high-rejection reverse osmosis membranes can be made by interfacial polymerization [7,9,10], this method has become the new industry standard. Interfacial composite membranes have significantly higher salt rejections and fluxes than cellulose acetate membranes. The first membranes made by Cadotte had salt rejections in tests with 3.5 % sodium chloride solutions (synthetic seawater) of greater than 99 % and fluxes of 18 gal/ft2 · day at a pressure of 1500 psi. The membranes could also be operated at temperatures above 35 ◦ C, the temperature ceiling for Loeb–Sourirajan cellulose acetate membranes. Today’s interfacial composite membranes are significantly better. Typical membranes, tested with 3.5 % sodium chloride solutions, 1 The ability of a reverse osmosis membrane to withstand chlorine attack without showing significant loss in rejection is measured in ppm · h. This is the product of chlorine exposure expressed in ppm and the length of exposure expressed in hours. Thus, 1000 ppm · h is 1 ppm chlorine for 1000 h or 10 ppm chlorine for 100 h or 1000 ppm chlorine for 1 h, and so on.
202
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
have a salt rejection of 99.5 % and a water flux of 30 gal/ft2 · day at 800 psi; this is less than half the salt passage of the cellulose acetate membranes and twice the water flux. The rejection of low-molecular-weight dissolved organic solutes by interfacial membranes is also far better than cellulose acetate. The only drawback of interfacial composite membranes, and a significant one, is the rapid, permanent loss in selectivity that results from exposure to even ppb levels of chlorine or hypochlorite disinfectants [28]. Although the chlorine resistance of interfacial composite membranes has been improved, these membranes still cannot be used with feed water containing more than a few ppb of chlorine. The chemistry and properties of some of the important interfacial composite membranes developed over the past 25 years are summarized in Table 5.1 [10,12,29,30]. The chemistry of the FT-30 membrane, which has an all-aromatic structure based on the reaction of phenylene diamine and trimesoyl chloride, is widely used. This chemistry, first developed by Cadotte [9] and shown in Figure 5.9, is now used in modified form by all the major reverse osmosis membrane producers. For a few years after the development of the first interfacial composite membranes, it was believed that the amine portion of the reaction chemistry had to be polymeric to obtain good membranes. This is not the case, and the monomeric amines, piperazine and phenylenediamine, have been used to form membranes with very good properties. Interfacial composite membranes based on urea or amide bonds are subject to degradation by chlorine attack, but the rate of degradation of the membrane is slowed significantly if tertiary aromatic amines are used and the membranes are highly crosslinked. Chemistries based on all-aromatic or piperazine structures are moderately chlorine tolerant and can withstand very low level exposure to chlorine for prolonged periods or exposure to ppm levels
CO
NH NHCO
CONH
NH
CO NH
COOH
CO
CO
NH
Figure 5.9 Chemical structure of the FT-30 membrane developed by Cadotte using the interfacial reaction of phenylene diamine with trimesoyl chloride
REVERSE OSMOSIS Table 5.1
203
Characteristics of major interfacial polymerization reverse osmosis membranes
Membrane
Developer
NS100 Polyethylenimine crosslinked with toluene 2,4-diisocyanate
Cadotte [29] North Star Research
PA 300/RC-100 Epamine (epichlorohydrinethylenediamine adduct) crosslinked with isophthalyl or toluene 2,4-diisocyanate
Riley et al. [30] Fluid Systems, San Diego
NF40 and NTR7250 Piperazine crosslinked with trimesoyl chloride
Cadotte FilmTec [10] and Kamiyama Nitto Denko [12]
FT-30/SW-30 m-Phenylenediamine crosslinked with trimesoyl chloride
Cadotte FilmTec [10]
Properties The first interfacial composite membrane achieved seawater desalination characteristics of >99 % rejection, 18 gal/ft2 · day at 1500 psi with seawater The PA 300, based on isophthalyl chloride, was introduced first but RC-100, based on toluene 2,4-diisocyanate, proved more stable. This membrane was used at the first large reverse osmosis seawater desalination plant (Jiddah, Saudia Arabia) The first all-monomeric interfacial membrane. Only modest seawater desalination properties but is a good brackish water membrane. More chlorine-tolerant than earlier membranes because of the absence of secondary amine bonds An all-aromatic, highly crosslinked structure giving exceptional salt rejection and very high fluxes. By tailoring the preparation techniques, brackish water or seawater membranes can be made. Seawater version has a rejection 99.3–99.5 % at 800 psi. Brackish water version has >99 % salt rejection at 25 gal/ft2 · day and 225 psi. All the major reverse osmosis companies produce variations of this membrane
204
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
for a few days. Early interfacial composite membranes such as the NS100 or PA300 membrane showed significant degradation at a few hundred ppm · h. Current membranes, such as the fully aromatic FilmTec FT-30 or the Hydranautics ESPA membrane, can withstand up to 1000 ppm · h chlorine exposure. A number of chlorine tolerance studies have been made over the years; a discussion of the literature has been given by Glater et al. [31]. Heavy metal ions such as iron appear to strongly catalyze chlorine degradation. For example, the FT-30 fully aromatic membrane is somewhat chlorine resistant in heavy-metal-free water, but in natural waters, which normally contain heavy metal ions, chlorine resistance is low. The rate of chlorine attack is also pH sensitive. Other Membrane Materials An interesting group of composite membranes with very good properties is produced by condensation of furfuryl alcohol with sulfuric acid. The first membrane of this type was made by Cadotte at North Star Research and was known as the NS200 membrane [32]. These membranes are not made by the interfacial composite process; rather a polysulfone microporous support membrane is contacted first with an aqueous solution of furfuryl alcohol and then with sulfuric acid. The coated support is then heated to 140 ◦ C. The furfuryl alcohol forms a polymerized, crosslinked layer on the polysulfone support; the membrane is completely black. The chemistry of condensation and reaction is complex, but a possible polymerization scheme is shown in Figure 5.10. These membranes have exceptional properties, including seawater salt rejections of up to 99.6 % and fluxes of 23 gal/ft2 · day at 800 psi. Unfortunately, they are even more sensitive to oxidants such as chlorine or dissolved oxygen than the polyamide/polyurea interfacial composites. The membranes lose their excellent properties after a few hundred hours of operation unless the feed water is completely free of dissolved chlorine and oxygen. A great deal of work was devoted to stabilizing this membrane, with little success. Later, Kurihara and co-workers [33] at Toray produced a related membrane, using 1,3,5-tris(hydroxy ethyl) isocyanuric acid as a comonomer. A possible reaction scheme is shown in Figure 5.11. This membrane, commercialized by Toray under the name PEC-1000, has the highest rejection of any membrane developed,
CH2
O
CH2OH
+ H2SO4
Figure 5.10
O
CH2
O
CH2
SO3H
O
Formation of the NS200 condensation membrane
CH2
REVERSE OSMOSIS
205 CH2CH2OH N
O N HOCH2CH2
O N
O
+ CH2OH
O
CH2CH2OH
+
H2SO4
CH2CH2 N
O H2C
O
CH2CH2
N
O N CH2CH2OCH2CH2
O HO3S CH2
N
O
O
CH2
N
O N
O
CH2CH2O
Figure 5.11 Reaction sequence for Toray’s PEC-1000 membrane
with seawater rejections of 99.9 % and fluxes of 12 gal/ft2 · day at 1000 psi. The membrane also shows the highest known rejections to low-molecular-weight organic solutes, typically more than 95 % from relatively concentrated feed solutions [34]. Unfortunately these exceptional selectivities are accompanied by the same sensitivity to dissolved oxidants as the NS200 membrane. This problem was never completely solved, so the PEC-1000 membrane, despite its unsurpassed properties, is no longer commercially available.
Reverse Osmosis Membrane Categories Reverse osmosis membranes can be grouped into three main categories: • Seawater and brackish water desalination membranes operated with 0.5 to 5 wt% salt solutions at pressures of 200–1000 psi. • Low-pressure nanofiltration membranes operated with 200–5000 ppm salt solutions at pressures of 100–200 psi. • Hyperfiltration membranes used to separate solutes from organic solvent solutions. Seawater and Brackish Water Desalination Membranes The relative performances of membranes produced for the desalination market are shown in Figure 5.12, a plot of sodium chloride rejection as a function of
206
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
99.99 Riley (1991) Crosslinked polyether (Toray PEC-1000)
99.98
NaCl rejection (%)
99.95
Cellulose triacetate
99.9 99.8
Minimum rejection for single-stage seawater operation
Crosslinked fully aromatic polyamide (SWC, SW-30)
99.5 99.3 99 98
Other thin-film interfacial composite membranes (NS100, PA 300 type)
Linear fully aromatic polyamide (PermaSep)
Asymmetric cellulose diacetate membranes
95 90 0.01
0.1
1.0
10
Flux (m3/m2•day)
Figure 5.12 Performance characteristics of membranes operating on seawater at 56 kg/cm2 (840 psi) and 25 ◦ C [13]
membrane flux. The figure is divided into two sections by a dotted line at a rejection of 99.3 %. This salt rejection is generally considered to be the minimum sodium chloride rejection that can produce potable water from seawater in a practical single-stage reverse osmosis plant. Membranes with lower sodium chloride rejections can be used to desalinate seawater, but at least a portion of the product water must be treated in a second-stage operation to achieve the target average permeate salt concentration of less than 500 ppm. Two-stage operation is generally not competitive with alternative desalination technologies. As Figure 5.12 shows, Toray’s PEC-1000 crosslinked furfuryl alcohol membrane has by far the best sodium chloride rejection combined with good fluxes. This explains the sustained interest in this membrane despite its extreme sensitivity to dissolved chlorine and oxygen in the feed water. Hollow fine fiber membranes made from cellulose triacetate by Toyobo or aromatic polyamides by Permasep (Du Pont) are also comfortably in the one-stage seawater desalination performance range, but the water fluxes of these membranes are low. However, because large-surface-area, hollow fine fiber reverse osmosis modules can be
REVERSE OSMOSIS
207
produced very economically, these membranes remained competitive until 2000, when DuPont finally ceased production. Currently, all new seawater desalination plants are based on interfacial composite membranes of the fully aromatic type, such as the SW-30 membrane of FilmTec (Dow) or the SWC membrane of Hydranautics (Nitto). Even the best Loeb–Sourirajan cellulose acetate membranes are not suitable for one-stage seawater desalination because their maximum salt rejection is less than 99 %. Brackish water generally has a salt concentration in the 2000–10 000 ppm range. Groundwater aquifers with these salt levels must be treated to make the water useful. The objective of the desalination plant is to convert 80–90 % of the feed water to a desalted permeate containing 200–500 ppm salt and a concentrated brine that is reinjected into the ground, sent to an evaporation pond, or discharged to the sea. In this application, membranes with 95–98 % sodium chloride rejection are usually adequate. For this reason some brackish water plants still use cellulose acetate membranes with salt rejections of 96–98 %, although interfacial composite membranes are more common. The fluxes and rejections of the composite membranes at the same operating pressures are usually greater than those of cellulose acetate membranes. Therefore, composite membranes are always preferred for large operations such as municipal drinking water plants, which can be built to handle the membrane’s chlorine sensitivity. Some small system operators, on the other hand, still prefer cellulose acetate membranes because of their greater stability. The membranes are often operated at higher pressures to obtain the required flux and salt rejection. The comparative performance of high-pressure, high-rejection reverse osmosis membranes, medium-pressure brackish water desalting membranes, and lowpressure nanofiltration membranes is shown in Table 5.2. Generally, the performance of a membrane with a particular salt can be estimated reliably once the Table 5.2 Properties of current good-quality commercial membranes Parameter
Seawater membrane (SW-30)
Brackish water membrane (CA)
Nanofiltration membrane (NTR-7250)
Pressure (psi) Solution concentration (%) Rejection (%) NaCl MgCl2 MgSO4 Na2 SO4 NaNO3 Ethylene glycol Glycerol Ethanol Sucrose
800–1000 1–5
300–500 0.2–0.5
100–150 0.05
99.5 99.9 99.9 99.8 90 70 96 — 100
97 99 99.9 99.1 90 — — 20 99.9
60 89 99 99 45 — — 20 99.0
208
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
performance of the membrane with one or two marker salts, such as sodium chloride and magnesium sulfate, is known. The rejection of dissolved neutral organic solutes is less predictable. For example, the PEC-1000 membrane had rejections of greater than 95 % for almost all dissolved organics, but the rejections of even the best cellulose acetate membrane are usually no greater than 50–60 %. Nanofiltration Membranes The goal of most of the early work on reverse osmosis was to produce desalination membranes with sodium chloride rejections greater than 98 %. More recently membranes with lower sodium chloride rejections but much higher water permeabilities have been produced. These membranes, which fall into a transition region between pure reverse osmosis membranes and pure ultrafiltration membranes, are called loose reverse osmosis, low-pressure reverse osmosis, or more commonly, nanofiltration membranes. Typically, nanofiltration membranes have sodium chloride rejections between 20 and 80 % and molecular weight cutoffs for dissolved organic solutes of 200–1000 dalton. These properties are intermediate between reverse osmosis membranes with a salt rejection of more than 90 % and molecular weight cut-off of less than 50 and ultrafiltration membranes with a salt rejection of less than 5 %. Although some nanofiltration membranes are based on cellulose acetate, most are based on interfacial composite membranes. The preparation procedure used to form these membranes can result in acid groups attached to the polymeric backbone. Neutral solutes such as lactose, sucrose and raffinose are not affected by the presence of charged groups and the membrane rejection increases in proportion to solute size. Nanofiltration membranes with molecular weight cut-offs to neutral solutes between 150 and 1500 dalton are produced. Typical rejection curves for low molecular weight solutes by two representative membranes are shown in Figure 5.13 [35]. The rejection of salts by nanofiltration membranes is more complicated and depends on both molecular size and Donnan exclusion effects caused by the acid groups attached to the polymer backbone. The phenomenon of Donnan exclusion is described in more detail in Chapter 10. In brief, charged groups tend to exclude ions of the same charge, particularly multivalent ions while being freely permeable to ions of the opposite charge, particularly multivalent ions. Some results obtained by Peters et al. that illustrate the type of results that can be produced are shown in Figure 5.14 [36], in which the permeation properties of neutral, positively charged and negatively charged membranes are compared. The neutral nanofiltration membrane rejects the various salts in proportion to molecular size, so the order of rejection is simply Na2 SO4 > CaCl2 > NaCl The anionic nanofiltration membrane has positive groups attached to the polymer backbone. These positive charges repel positive cations, particularly divalent
REVERSE OSMOSIS
209
100
Solute rejection (%)
80
NF-70
60 40 NTR-7450 20 0 0
50 100 150 Solute molecular weight (MW)
200
Figure 5.13 Rejection of neutral solutes by two membrane types spanning the range of commonly available nanofiltration membranes [35]
cations such as Ca2+ , while attracting negative anions, particularly divalent anions such as SO4 2− . The result is an order of salt rejection CaCl2 > NaCl > Na2 SO4 The cationic nanofiltration membrane has negative groups attached to the polymer backbone. These negative charges repel negative anions, such as SO4 2− , while attracting positive cations, particularly divalent cations such as Ca2+ . The result is an order of salt rejection Na2 SO4 > NaCl > CaCl2 Many nanofiltration membranes follow these rules, but oftentimes the behavior is more complex. Nanofiltration membranes frequently combine both size and Donnan exclusion effects to minimize the rejection of all salts and solutes. These so-called low-pressure reverse osmosis membranes have very high rejections and high permeances of salt at low salt concentrations, but lose their selectivity at salt concentrations above 1000 or 2000 ppm salt in the feed water. The membranes are therefore used to remove low levels of salt from already relatively clean water. The membranes are usually operated at very low pressures of 50–200 psig.
Hyperfiltration Organic Solvent Separating Membranes A promising new application of reverse osmosis in the chemical industry is the separation of organic/organic mixtures. These separations are difficult because of the high osmotic pressures that must be overcome and because they require
210
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Salt rejection (%)
100
AND
APPLICATIONS
Neutral membrane Na2SO4
80
• Simple size discrimination • Rejection is Na2SO4 > CaCl2 > NaCl
60 CaCl2 40
NaCl
20 0
0.005 0.01 0.015 Salt concentration (mol/L)
0.02
Salt rejection (%)
100 80
CaCl2
60
NaCl
Anionic membrane (fixed positive charges) • Rejects Ca2+ • Preferentially permeates SO42−
40
• Rejection is CaCl2 > NaCl > Na2SO4
Na2SO4
20 0 0
0.005 0.01 0.015 Salt concentration (mol/L)
0.02
Salt rejection (%)
100
Cationic membrane (fixed negative charges)
Na2SO4
80
• Rejects SO42−
60 NaCl
• Preferentially permeates Ca2+ • Rejection is Na2SO4 > NaCl > CaCl2
40 20
CaCl2
0 0
0.005 0.01 Salt concentration (mol/L)
0.015
Figure 5.14 Salt rejection with neutral, anionic and cationic nanofiltration membranes showing the effect of Donnan exclusion and solute size on relative rejections. Data of Peters et al. [36]
membranes that are sufficiently solvent-resistant to be mechanically stable, but are also sufficiently permeable for good fluxes to be obtained. Nonetheless this is an area of keen industrial interest, and from 1988 to 2002 more than 70 US patents covering membranes and membrane systems for these applications were issued. Developing membranes for processing organic solvent solutions is more difficult than conventional reverse osmosis because different membranes must be
REVERSE OSMOSIS
211
developed for each category of solvent. In the 1980s, Nitto Denko developed polyimide-based ultrafiltration membranes that found a small use in the recovery of acetone, toluene, ethyl acetate and hexane and other solvents from waste paint and polymer solutions [37]. These were microporous membranes with a molecular weight cut-off of 2000–6000. The first dense, solution-diffusion, hyperfiltration membranes did not appear until the late 1990s. Kiryat Weitzman, Ltd, now part of Koch (Abcor), produced crosslinked silicone composite membranes that have some uses in the hyperfiltration of nonpolar solvents [38,39]. The flux of different simple solvents through these membranes is shown in Figure 5.15. These membranes can be used as nanofiltration membranes to separate large dyes or catalyst solutes from solvents. However, because the membranes are made from rubbers that are easily swollen and plasticized by most solvents, they show poor selectivity when used to separate simple solvent mixtures. The first, and currently only, successful solvent-permeable hyperfiltration membrane is the Starmem series of solvent-resistant membranes developed by W.R. Grace [40]. These are asymmetric polyimide phase-inversion membranes prepared from Matrimid (Ciba-Geigy) and related materials. The Matrimid polyimide structure is extremely rigid with a Tg of 305 ◦ C and the polymer remains glassy and unswollen even in aggressive solvents. These membranes found their first large-scale commercial use in Mobil Oil’s processes to separate lube oil from methyl ethyl ketone–toluene solvent mixtures [41–43]. Scarpello et al. [44] have also achieved rejections of >99 % when using these membranes to separate dissolved phase transfer catalysts (MW ∼ 600) from tetrahydrofuran and ethyl acetate solutions.
Normalized flux (arbitrary units)
3
Paraffins 2 Alcohols Ketones 1
Acetates 0 0
2
4 6 8 Number of carbon atoms in solvent
10
Figure 5.15 Normalized flux of homologous solvent series versus the number of carbon atoms in the solvent molecules (MFP-60 Kiryat Weitzman membranes) [39]
212
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
100
Rejection (%)
90
Adipic acid
n -Butyric acid pKa
80
Phenol
70 60
pKa
50
pKa 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
pH
Figure 5.16 Effect of pH on rejection of organic acids. Solute rejection increases at the pKa as the acid converts to the ionized form. Data from Matsuura and Sourirajan [46,47] 100 PEC-1000
Solute rejection (%)
80 FT-30 60 Aramide 40
20 Cellulose acetate Phenol
Aniline
Acetic acid
Ethanol
Acetone
Ethylene glycol
Caprolactam
NaCl
0
Figure 5.17 Organic rejection data for the PEC-1000 membrane compared to FT-30, anisotropic aramide and anisotropic cellulose membranes [28]
Membrane Selectivity Rautenbach and Albrecht [45] have proposed some general guidelines for membrane selectivity that can be summarized as follows: 1. Multivalent ions are retained better than monovalent ions. Although the absolute values of the salt rejection vary over a wide range, the ranking for the
REVERSE OSMOSIS
213
different salts is the same for all membranes. In general, the order of rejection of ions by reverse osmosis membranes is as shown below. For cations: Fe3+ > Ni2+ ≈ Cu2+ > Mg2+ > Ca2+ > Na+ > K+
(5.7)
For anions: PO4 3− > SO4 2− > HCO3 − > Br− > Cl− > NO3 − ≈ F−
(5.8)
2. Dissolved gases such as ammonia, carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, oxygen, chlorine and hydrogen sulfide always permeate well. 3. Rejection of weak acids and bases is highly pH dependent. When the acid or base is in the ionized form the rejection will be high, but in the nonionized form rejection will be low [46,47]. Data for a few weak acids are shown in Figure 5.16. At pHs above the acid pKa, the solute rejection rises significantly, but at pHs below the pKa, when the acid is in the neutral form, the rejection falls. 4. Rejection of neutral organic solutes generally increases with the molecular weight (or diameter) of the solute. Components with molecular weights above 100 are well rejected by all reverse osmosis membranes. Although differences between the rejection of organic solutes by different membranes are substantial, as the data in Figure 5.17 show, the rank order is generally consistent between membranes. Caprolactam rejection, for example, is better than ethanol rejection for all reverse osmosis membranes. The dependence of solute rejection on molecular weight is shown for three different membranes in Figure 5.18. 5. Negative rejection coefficients, that is, a higher concentration of solute in the permeate than in the feed are occasionally observed, for example, for phenol and benzene with cellulose acetate membranes [48].
Membrane Modules Currently, 8-in.-diameter, 40-in.-long spiral-wound modules are the type most commonly used for reverse osmosis. Five to seven modules are housed inside a filament-wound, fiber-glass-reinforced plastic tube. Larger modules, up to 12 in. diameter and 60 in. length, are produced by some manufacturers but have not been widely adopted. The module elements can be removed from the pressure vessels and exchanged as needed. A photograph of a typical skid-mounted system is shown in Figure 5.19. A typical spiral-wound 8-in.-diameter membrane module will produce 8000–10 000 gal/day of permeate, so the 75-module plant shown in Figure 5.19 has a capacity of about 700 000 gal/day.
214
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY 11
100 9 6 6
10
4
APPLICATIONS
19 13
10 12
7
AND
14
15
18 20 22 21 17
16
13
8 8
80 7 4
Rejection (%)
1 13
60 6
8
2
40
7 5
1
3
20
2
Rautenbach and Albrecht (1989) 0
0
50
100 Molecular weight
Number
Name
Number
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Formaldehyde Methanol Acetonitrile Acetaldehyde Formic acid Ethanol Acetic acid Urea Ethylene glycol Methyl ethyl ketone Glycine
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
150
200
Name Ethyl acetate Phenol n-Methyl-2-pyrrolidone e-Caprolactam D,L-aspartic acid Tetrachloroethylene o-Phenyl phenol Butyl benzonate Trichlorobenzene Dimethyl phthalate Citric acid
Figure 5.18 Organic solute rejection as a function of solute molecular weight for three representative reverse osmosis membranes [45]: the interfacial composite membranes, ( ) PA300 (UOP) and () NTR 7197 (Nitto), and the crosslinked furfuryl alcohol membrane ( ) PEC-1000 (Toray). Reprinted from R. Rautenbach and R. Albrecht, Membrane Processes, Copyright 1989. This material is used by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Ž
ž
REVERSE OSMOSIS
215
Figure 5.19 Skid-mounted reverse osmosis plant able to produce 700 000 gal/day of desalted water. Courtesy of Christ Water Technology Group
Hollow fine fiber modules made from cellulose triacetate or aromatic polyamides were produced in the past for seawater desalination. These modules incorporated the membrane around a central tube, and feed solution flowed rapidly outward to the shell. Because the fibers were extremely tightly packed inside the pressure vessel, flow of the feed solution was quite slow. As much as 40–50 % of the feed could be removed as permeate in a single pass through the module. However, the low flow and many constrictions meant that extremely good pretreatment of the feed solution was required to prevent membrane fouling from scale or particulates. A schematic illustration of such a hollow fiber module is shown in Figure 3.47.
Membrane Fouling Control Membrane fouling is the main cause of permeant flux decline and loss of product quality in reverse osmosis systems, so fouling control dominates reverse osmosis system design and operation. The cause and prevention of fouling depend greatly on the feed water being treated, and appropriate control procedures must be
216
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
devised for each plant. In general, sources of fouling can be divided into four principal categories: scale, silt, bacteria, and organic. More than one category may occur in the same plant. Fouling control involves pretreatment of the feed water to minimize fouling as well as regular cleaning to handle any fouling that still occurs. Fouling by particulates (silt), bacteria and organics such as oil is generally controlled by a suitable pretreatment procedure; this type of fouling affects the first modules in the plant the most. Fouling by scaling is worse with more concentrated feed solutions; therefore, the last modules in the plant are most affected because they are exposed to the most concentrated feed water. Scale Scale is caused by precipitation of dissolved metal salts in the feed water on the membrane surface. As salt-free water is removed in the permeate, the concentration of ions in the feed increases until at some point the solubility limit is exceeded. The salt then precipitates on the membrane surface as scale. The proclivity of a particular feed water to produce scale can be determined by performing an analysis of the feed water and calculating the expected concentration factor in the brine. The ratio of the product water flow rate to feed water flow rate is called the recovery rate, which is equivalent to the term stage-cut used in gas separation. product flow rate Recovery Rate = (5.9) feed flow rate Assuming all the ions remain in the brine solution, the concentration factor is given by 1 Concentration factor = (5.10) 1 − recovery rate The relationship between brine solution concentration factor and water recovery rate is shown in Figure 5.20. With plants that operate below a concentration factor of 2, that is, 50 % recovery rate, scaling is not normally a problem. However, many brackish water reverse osmosis plants operate at recovery rates of 80 or 90 %. Salt concentrations on the brine side of the membrane may then be far above the solubility limit. In order of importance, the salts that most commonly form scale are: • • • •
calcium carbonate; calcium sulfate; silica complexes; barium sulfate;
Concentration factor
REVERSE OSMOSIS 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
0
217
10
20
30
40 50 60 Recovery rate (%)
70
80
90
100
Figure 5.20 The effect of water recovery rate on the brine solution concentration factor
• strontium sulfate; • calcium fluoride. Scale control is complex; the particular procedure depends on the composition of the feed water. Fortunately, calcium carbonate scale, by far the most common problem, is easily controlled by acidifying the feed or by using an ion exchange water softener to exchange calcium for sodium. Alternatively, an antiscalant chemical such as sodium hexametaphosphate can be added. Antiscalants interfere with the precipitation of the insoluble salt and maintain the salt in solution even when the solubility limit is exceeded. Polymeric antiscalants may also be used, sometimes in combination with a dispersant to break up any flocs that occur. Silica can be a particularly troublesome scalant because no effective antiscalant or dispersant is available. The solubility of silica is a strong function of pH and temperature, but in general the brine should not exceed 120 ppm silica. Once formed, silica scale is difficult to remove. Silt Silt is formed by suspended particulates of all types that accumulate on the membrane surface. Typical sources of silt are organic colloids, iron corrosion products, precipitated iron hydroxide, algae, and fine particulate matter. A good predictor of the likelihood of a particular feed water to produce fouling by silt is the silt density index (SDI) of the feed water. The SDI, an empirical measurement (ASTM Standard D-4189-82, 1987), is the time required to filter a fixed volume of
218
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Feed supply
Shutoff valve
Pressure regulator
P
Pressure gauge (test run at 30 psig) Millipore filter holder (0.45 µm - 47 mm diameter Millipore filter) Graduated cylinder (measure rate with stop watch)
(1)
Measure the amount of time required for 500 ml of feed water to flow through a 0.45 micrometer Millipore filter (47 mm in diameter) at a pressure of 30 psig.
(2)
Allow the feed water to continue flowing at 30 psig applied pressure and measure the time required for 500 ml to flow through the filter after 5, 10 and 15 minutes.
(3)
After completion of the test, calculate the SDI by using the equation below.
SDI = where SDI Tt Ti
Tf
= = = =
100 (1 − Ti/Tf)
Tt
Silt Density Index Total elapsed test time (either 5, 10 or 15 minutes) Initial time in seconds required to collect the 500 ml sample Time in seconds required to collect the second 500 ml sample after test time Tt (normally after 15 minutes).
Figure 5.21 The silt density index (SDI) test [49]. Reprinted with permission from Noyes Publications
REVERSE OSMOSIS
219
water through a standard 0.45-µm pore size microfiltration membrane. Suspended material in the feed water that plugs the microfilter increases the sample filtration time, giving a higher SDI. The test procedure is illustrated in Figure 5.21 [49]. An SDI of less than 1 means that the reverse osmosis system can run for several years without colloidal fouling. An SDI of less than 3 means that the system can run several months between cleaning. An SDI of 3–5 means that particulate fouling is likely to be a problem and frequent, regular cleaning will be needed. An SDI of more than 5 is unacceptable and indicates that additional pretreatment is required to bring the feed water into an acceptable range. The maximum tolerable SDI also varies with membrane module design. Spiral-wound modules generally require an SDI of less than 5, whereas hollow fine fiber modules are more susceptible to fouling and require an SDI of less than 3. To avoid fouling by suspended solids, some form of feed water filtration is required. All reverse osmosis units are fitted with a 0.45-µm cartridge filter in front of the high-pressure pump, but a sand filter, sometimes supplemented by addition of a flocculating chemical such as alum or a cationic polymer, may be required. The target SDI after filtration is normally less than 3–5. Groundwaters usually have very low SDI values, and cartridge filtration is often sufficient. However, surface or seawater may have an SDI of up to 200, requiring flocculation, coagulation, and deep-bed multimedia filtration before reverse osmosis treatment. Biofouling Biological fouling is the growth of bacteria on the membrane surface. The susceptibility of membranes to biological fouling is a strong function of the membrane composition. Cellulose acetate membranes are an ideal nutrient for bacteria and can be completely destroyed by a few weeks of uncontrolled bacterial attack. Therefore, feed water to cellulose acetate membranes must always be sterilized. Polyamide hollow fibers are also somewhat susceptible to bacterial attack, but thin-film composite membranes are generally quite resistant. Periodic treatment of such membranes with a bactericide usually controls biological fouling. Thus, control of bacteria is essential for cellulose acetate membranes and desirable for polyamides and composite membranes. Because cellulose acetate can tolerate up to 1 ppm chlorine, sufficient chlorination is used to maintain 0.2 ppm free chlorine. Chlorination can also be used to sterilize the feed water to polyamide and interfacial composite membranes, but residual chlorine must then be removed because the membranes are chlorine-sensitive. Dechlorination is generally achieved by adding sodium metabisulfate. In ultrapure water systems, water sterility is often maintained by UV sterilizers. Organic Fouling Organic fouling is the attachment of materials such as oil or grease onto the membrane surface. Such fouling may occur accidentally in municipal drinking
220
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Polyelectrolyte
1 Multilayer filter Polyelectrolyte
AND
APPLICATIONS
3 Dechlorination, 2 activated carbon or Multilayer NaHSO3 shock pretreatment filter Cartridge filter 1-5 µm
Acid Chlorine
RO plant
Permeate
Retentate Surface intake
Sea well intake
Acid NaHSO3
Figure 5.22 Flow scheme showing the pretreatment steps in a typical seawater reverse osmosis system [50]
water systems, but is more common in industrial applications in which reverse osmosis is used to treat a process or effluent stream. Removal of the organic material from the feed water by filtration or carbon adsorption is required. An example of a complete pretreatment flow scheme for a seawater reverse osmosis plant is shown in Figure 5.22 [50]. The water is controlled for pH, scale, particulates and biological fouling. The feed water is first treated with chlorine to sterilize the water and to bring it to a pH of 5–6. A polyelectrolyte is added to flocculate suspended matter, and two multilayer depth filters then remove suspended materials. The water is dechlorinated by dosing with sodium bisulfite followed by passage through an activated carbon bed. As a final check the pH is adjusted a second time, and the water is filtered through a 1- to 5-µm cartridge filter before being fed to the reverse osmosis modules. Obviously, such pretreatment is expensive and may represent as much as one-third of the operating and capital cost of the plant; however, it is essential for reliable long-term operation.
Membrane Cleaning A good pretreatment system is essential to achieve a long reverse osmosis membrane life, but pretreatment must be backed up by an appropriate cleaning schedule. Generally this is done once or twice a year, but more often if the feed is a problem water. As with pretreatment, the specific cleaning procedure is a function of the feed water chemistry, the type of membrane, and the type of fouling. A typical cleaning regimen consists of flushing the membrane modules by recirculating the cleaning solution at high speed through the module, followed by a soaking period, followed by a second flush, and so on. The
REVERSE OSMOSIS
221
chemical cleaning agents commonly used are acids, alkalis, chelatants, detergents, formulated products, and sterilizers. Acid cleaning agents such as hydrochloric, phosphoric, or citric acids effectively remove common scaling compounds. With cellulose acetate membranes the pH of the solution should not go below 2.0 or else hydrolysis of the membrane will occur. Oxalic acid is particularly effective for removing iron deposits. Acids such as citric acid are not very effective with calcium, magnesium, or barium sulfate scale; in this case a chelatant such as ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) may be used. To remove bacteria, silt or precipitates from the membrane, alkalis combined with surfactant cleaners are often used. Biz and other laundry detergents containing enzyme additives are useful for removing biofoulants and some organic foulants. Most large membrane module producers now distribute formulated products, which are a mixture of cleaning compounds. These products are designed for various common feed waters and often provide a better solution to membrane cleaning than devising a cleaning solution for a specific feed. Sterilization of a membrane system is also required to control bacterial growth. For cellulose acetate membranes, chlorination of the feed water is sufficient to control bacteria. Feed water to polyamide or interfacial composite membranes need not be sterile, because these membranes are usually fairly resistant to biological attack. Periodic shock disinfection using formaldehyde, peroxide or peracetic acid solutions as part of a regular cleaning schedule is usually enough to prevent biofouling. Repeated cleaning gradually degrades reverse osmosis membranes. Most manufacturers now supply membrane modules with a 1- to 2-year limited warranty depending on the application. Well designed and maintained plants with good feed water pretreatment can usually expect membrane lifetimes of 3 years, and lifetimes of 5 years or more are not unusual. As membranes approach the end of their useful life, the water flux will normally have dropped by at least 20 %, and the salt rejection will have begun to fall. At this point operators may try to ‘rejuvenate’ the membrane by treatment with a dilute polymer solution. This surface treatment plugs microdefects and restores salt rejection [51]. Typical polymers are poly(vinyl alcohol)/vinyl acetate copolymers or poly(vinyl methyl ether). In this procedure the membrane modules are carefully cleaned and then flushed with dilute solutions of the rejuvenation polymer. The exact mechanism of rejuvenation is unclear.
Applications Approximately one-half of the reverse osmosis systems currently installed are desalinating brackish or seawater. Another 40 % are producing ultrapure water for the electronics, pharmaceutical, and power generation industries. The remainder are used in small niche applications such as pollution control and food processing. A review of reverse osmosis applications has been done by Williams et al. [52].
222
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Desalination cost ($/1000 gal)
50
AND
APPLICATIONS
Strathmann (1991)
Electrodialysis Ion exchange
Reverse osmosis
10
5 Multi-effect evaporation
1
1
5 10 Salt concentration (g/L)
50
100
Figure 5.23 Comparative costs of the major desalination technologies as a function of salt concentration. These costs should be taken as a guide only; site-specific factors can affect costs significantly [53]
The relative cost of reverse osmosis compared with other desalting technologies (ion exchange, electrodialysis, and multi-effect evaporation) is shown in Figure 5.23. The operating costs of electrodialysis and ion exchange scale almost linearly in proportion to the salt concentration in the feed. Therefore, these technologies are best suited to low-salt-concentration feed streams. On the other hand, the cost of multi-effect evaporation is relatively independent of the salt concentration and is mainly proportional to the mass of water to be evaporated. Thus, desalination by evaporation is best performed with concentrated salt solution feeds. Reverse osmosis costs increase significantly with salt concentration but at a lower rate than electrodialysis does. The result is that reverse osmosis is the lowest-cost process for streams containing between 3000 and 10 000 ppm salt. However, site-specific factors or plant size often make the technology the best approach for more dilute feed water or for streams as concentrated as seawater (35 000 ppm salt). The approximate operating costs for brackish and seawater reverse osmosis plants are given in Table 5.3. These numbers are old, but improvements in membrane technology have kept pace with inflation so the costs remain reasonably current.
REVERSE OSMOSIS
223
Table 5.3 Operating costs for large brackish water and seawater reverse osmosis plants [49]. Capital costs are approximately US$1.25 per gal/day capacity for the brackish water plant and US$4–5 per gal/day capacity for the seawater plant
Energy (US$0.06/kWh) Chemicals Labor Maintenance Membrane replacement Amortization (12 %/20 years) Total
Brackish water (US$/1000 gal product)
Seawater (US$/1000 gal product)
0.36 0.09 0.12 0.05 0.10 0.48 1.20
1.80 0.14 0.19 0.22 0.90 1.75 5.00
Brackish Water Desalination The salinity of brackish water is usually between 2000 and 10 000 mg/L. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommendation for potable water is 500 mg/L, so up to 90 % of the salt must be removed from these feeds. Early cellulose acetate membranes could achieve this removal easily, so treatment of brackish water was one of the first successful applications of reverse osmosis. Several plants were installed as early as the 1960s. The osmotic pressure of brackish water is approximately 11 psi per 1000 ppm salt, so osmotic pressure effects do not generally limit water recovery significantly. Limitations are generally due to scaling. Typical water recoveries are in the 70–90 % range, which means the brine stream leaving the system is up to 10 times more concentrated in calcium, sulfate and silica ions present in the feed. If scaling occurs, the last modules in the system must be replaced first. A simplified flow scheme for a brackish water reverse osmosis plant is shown in Figure 5.24. In this example, it is assumed that the brackish water is heavily contaminated with suspended solids, so flocculation followed by a sand filter and a cartridge filter is used to remove particulates. The pH of the feed solution might be adjusted, followed by chlorination to sterilize the water to prevent bacterial growth on the membranes and addition of an anti-scalant to inhibit precipitation of multivalent salts on the membrane. Finally, if chlorine-sensitive interfacial composite membranes are used, sodium sulfite is added to remove excess chlorine before the water contacts the membrane. Generally, more pretreatment is required in plants using hollow fiber modules than in plants using spiral-wound modules. This is one reason why hollow fiber modules have been displaced by spiral-wound systems for most brackish water installations. A feature of the system design shown in Figure 5.24 is the staggered arrangement of the module pressure vessels. As the volume of the feed water is reduced as water is removed in the permeate, the number of modules arranged in parallel is also reduced. In the example shown, the feed water passes initially through
224
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Pretreatment unit Antiscalent Cl2 pH sodium adjustment hexametaphosphate
Membrane modules
Flocculation Cartridge filter Feed water
Settler Sand filter
Suspended solids
Concentrated brine
Pump 400-600 psig
Treated water
Figure 5.24 Flow schematic of a typical brackish water reverse osmosis plant. The plant contains seven pressure vessels each containing six membrane modules. The pressure vessels are in a ‘Christmas tree’ array to maintain a high feed velocity through the modules
four modules in parallel, then through two, and finally through a single module in series. This is called a ‘Christmas tree’ or ‘tapered module’ design and provides a high average feed solution velocity through the modules. As the volume of the feed water is reduced by removing water as permeate, the number of modules arranged in parallel is reduced also. The operating pressure of brackish water reverse osmosis systems has gradually fallen over the past 20 years as the permeability and rejections of membranes have steadily improved. The first plants operated at pressures of 800 psi, but typical brackish water plants now operate at pressures in the 200- to 300-psi range. Capital costs of brackish water plants have stayed remarkably constant for almost 20 years; the rule of thumb of US$1.00 per gal/day capacity is still true. Accounting for inflation, this reflects a very large reduction in real costs resulting from the better performance of today’s membranes.
Seawater Desalination Seawater has a salt concentration of 3.2–4.0 %, depending on the region of the world. Because of this high salinity, only membranes with salt rejections of 99.3 % or more can produce potable water in a single pass. Application to seawater desalination of the first-generation cellulose acetate membranes, with rejections of 97–99 %, was limited. With the development of the polyamide hollow fine fibers and interfacial composites, suitable seawater membranes became available, and many plants have been installed. In general, membranes are not
REVERSE OSMOSIS
225
Pressure (psi)
800 600
Osmotic
400 Net driving 200 0 0
10
20 Recovery (%)
30
40
Figure 5.25 Effect of water recovery on the seawater feed osmotic pressure and net driving pressure of a plant operating at 1000 psi
competitive for large seawater desalination plants—multistage flash evaporation is usually used for plants larger than 10 million gal/day capacity. Often these plants are powered by waste steam from an adjacent electric power generation unit. A number of these very large plants have been installed in the Middle East. In the 1–10 million gal/day range membranes are more competitive, and the flexibility of membrane systems as well as their easy start-up/shut-down and turndown capability are advantages. Early seawater reverse osmosis plants operated at very high pressures, up to 1500 psi, but as membranes improved, operating pressures dropped to 800–1000 psi. The osmotic pressure of seawater is about 350 psi, and the osmotic pressure of the rejected brine can be as much as 600 psi, so osmotic pressure affects the net operating pressure in a plant markedly. This effect is illustrated in Figure 5.25. Typical seawater plants do not operate at a recovery rate of more than 35–45 % because of the high brine osmotic pressure; at this modest recovery rate, more than half of the feed water leaves the plant as pressurized brine. Because of the high pressures involved in seawater desalination, recovery of compression energy from the high-pressure brine stream is almost always worthwhile. This can be achieved with a hydro-turbine linked to the high-pressure feed water pump, lowering total power costs by as much as 30 %. Raw seawater requires considerable pretreatment before it can be desalinated (Figure 5.22), but these pretreatment costs can be reduced by using shallow seafront wells as the water source. The SDI of this water is usually quite low, and little more than a sand filter may be required for particulate control. However, sterilization of the water and addition of antiscalants will still be necessary. Ultrapure Water Production of ultrapure water for the electronics industry is an established and growing application of reverse osmosis [54,55]. The usual feed is municipal
226
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Table 5.4 Ultrapure water specifications for typical wafer manufacturing process and levels normally found in drinking water Ultrapure water Resistivity at 25 ◦ C (megohm-cm) TOC (ppb) Particles/L by laser >0.1 µm Bacteria/100 mL by culture Silica, dissolved (ppb) Boron (ppb) Ions (ppb) Na+ K+ Cl− Br− NO3 − SO4 2− Total ions
18.2 <5 <100 <0.1 <3 <1 <0.01 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.1
Typical drinking water — 5000 — <30 3000 40 3000 2000 10 000 — — 15 000 <100 000
drinking water, which often contains less than 200 ppm dissolved solids. However, the electronics industry requires water of extraordinarily high purity for wafer production, so extensive treatment of municipal water is required. Table 5.4 shows the target water quality required by a modern electronics plant compared to that of typical municipal drinking water. The first ultrapure water reverse osmosis system was installed at a Texas Instruments plant in 1970 as a pretreatment unit to an ion exchange process. These systems have increased in complexity as the needs of the industry for better quality water have increased. The flow scheme for a typical modern ultrapure water treatment system is shown in Figure 5.26. The plant comprises a complex array of operations, each requiring careful maintenance to achieve the necessary water quality. As the key part of the process, the reverse osmosis plant typically removes more than 98 % of all the salts and dissolved particulates in the feed water. Because the feed water is dilute, these systems often operate at very high recovery rates—90 % or more. Carbon adsorption then removes dissolved organics, followed by ion exchange to remove final trace amounts of ionic impurities. Bacterial growth is a major problem in ultrapure water systems; sterility is maintained by continuously recirculating the water through UV sterilizers and cartridge microfilters.
Wastewater Treatment In principle, pollution control should be a major application for reverse osmosis. In practice, membrane fouling, causing low plant reliability, has inhibited its widespread use in this area. The most common applications are special situations
Booster pump
Ultraviolet sterilizer
Feed water
Softener
Ultraviolet sterilizer
Ultraviolet sterilizer
Scale inhibitor
O3
Recirculated water
Cartridge filter 0.04 µm
Storage tank
Cartridge filter 0.2 µm
Distribution pump
Figure 5.26 Flow schematic of an ultrapure water treatment system [54]
Cartridge filter 0.45 µm
Primary mixed bed ion exchange unit
Polishing mixed bed ion exchange unit
Cartridge filter 0.45 µm
Carbon filter
RO high pressure pump
Reverse osmosis unit
To point of use
REVERSE OSMOSIS 227
228
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Rinse Tanks Hot nickel plating bath 27 wt% nickel
Part conveyor belt
Drag out
Rinse tanks
Filters
30 ppm rinse water
Reverse osmosis unit Nickel concentrate ~5 wt%
Figure 5.27 Flow scheme showing the use of a reverse osmosis system to control nickel loss from rinse water produced in a countercurrent electroplating rinse tank
in which the chemicals separated from the water are valuable. An example is the recovery of nickel from nickel-plating rinse tanks, shown schematically in Figure 5.27. Watts nickel-plating baths contain high concentrations of nickel and other plating chemicals. After plating, a conveyor belt moves the parts through a series of connected rinse tanks. Water circulates through these tanks to rinse the part free of nickel for the next plating operating. A typical countercurrent rinse tank produces a waste stream containing 2000–3000 ppm nickel; the water is a pollution problem and valuable material is lost. This is an ideal application for reverse osmosis because the rinse water is at nearly neutral pH, in contrast to many plating rinse waters which are very acidic [56,57]. The reverse osmosis unit produces permeate water containing only 20–50 ppm nickel that can be reused and a small nickel concentrate stream that can be sent to the plating tank. Although the concentrate is more dilute than the plating tank drag-out, evaporation from the hot plating bath tank compensates for the extra water. In the early days of membrane development, membranes were expected to be widely used in the tertiary treatment of water to produce drinking water from sewage. At a cost of US$2–3 per 1000 gal, this idea makes good economic sense in many water-limited regions of the world. However, psychological barriers have inhibited its widespread adoption. A few small plants have been introduced in Japan and at least one large plant in the US. This plant, called Water Factory 21,
REVERSE OSMOSIS
229
is in Orange County, California, an arid region where the principal local surface water source, the Colorado River, has a total salinity of 750 ppm. Operation of this 5-million-gal/day system is described in detail by Nusbaum and Argo [58]. The system treats secondary sewage to produce good-quality water, which is reinjected into the aquifer below the county. The water is then mixed with natural groundwater before being removed and used as a drinking water supply elsewhere in the county. Apparently, confusing the source of the water supply in this way makes the process acceptable. Nanofiltration Nanofiltration membrane usually have high rejections to most dissolved organic solutes with molecular weights above 100–200 and good salt rejection at salt concentrations below 1000–2000 ppm salt. The membranes are also two- to five-fold more permeable than brackish and sea water reverse osmosis membranes, so they can be operated at pressures as low as 50–150 psig and still produce useful fluxes. For these reasons, their principal application has been in the removal of low levels of contaminants from already relatively clean water. For example, nanofiltration membranes are widely used as point-of-use drinking water treatment units in southern California and the southwestern United States. The water in this region contains on the order of 700 ppm dissolved salt and trace amounts of agricultural run-off contaminants. Many households use small 0.5-m2 spiral-wound nanofiltration modules (under-the-sink modules) to filter this water using the 30- to 50-psig tap water pressure to provide the driving force. On a larger scale, similar membranes are used to soften municipal water by removing sulfate and divalent cations or as an initial pretreatment unit for an ultrapure water treatment plant. Organic Solvent Separation The use of membranes to separate organic solvent solutions is still at a very early stage. One application that has already become commercial is the separation of small solvent molecules from larger hydrocarbons in mixtures resulting from the extraction of vacuum resid oil in refineries [41–43]. Figure 5.28(a) shows a simplified flow diagram of a refining lube oil separation process–these operations are very large. In a 100 000–200 000-barrel/day refinery, about 15 000–30 000 barrels/day of the oil entering the refinery remain as residual oil. A large fraction of this oil is sent to the lube oil plant, where the heavy oil is mixed with 3–10 volumes of a solvent such as methyl ethyl ketone and toluene. On cooling the mixture, the heavy wax components precipitate out and are removed by a drum filter. The light solvent is then stripped from the lube oil by vacuum distillation and recycled through the process. The vacuum distillation step is very energy intensive because of the high solvent-to-oil ratios employed.
230
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
(a) Conventional solvent dewaxing process Rotary-drum filter
Residual oil
Recycled solvent Solvent recovery train
Wax
Dewaxed lube oil/ solvent mixture Lube oil
(b) Mobil Oil's solvent dewaxing process Rotary-drum filter Residual oil High-pressure pump
Wax
Solvent recovery Reverse osmosis modules Lube oil
Figure 5.28 Simplified flow schemes of (a) a conventional and (b) Mobil Oil’s membrane solvent dewaxing processes. Refrigeration economizers are not shown. The first 3 million gallon/day commercial unit was installed at Mobil’s Beaumont refinery in 1998. Polyimide membranes in spiral-wound modules were used [41–43]
A hyperfiltration process developed by Mobil Oil, now ExxonMobil, for this separation is illustrated in Figure 5.28(b). Polyimide membranes formed into spiral-wound modules are used to separate up to 50 % of the solvent from the dewaxed oil. The membranes have a flux of 10–20 gal/ft2 day at a pressure of 450–650 psi. The solvent filtrate bypasses the distillation step and is recycled directly to the incoming oil feed. The net result is a significant reduction in the refrigeration load required to cool the oil and in the size and energy consumption of the solvent recovery vacuum distillation section. ExxonMobil is now licensing this technology to other refineries. Development of similar applications in other operations is likely. Initially, applications will probably involve relatively easy separations such as the separation of methyl ethyl ketone/toluene from lube oil described above or soybean oil from hexane in food oil production. Long-term, however, the technology may become sufficiently advanced to be used in more important refining operations, such as fractionation
REVERSE OSMOSIS
231
of linear from branched paraffins, or the separation of benzene and other aromatics from paraffins and olefins in the gasoline pool.
Conclusions and Future Directions The reverse osmosis industry is now well established. The market is divided between three or four large manufacturers, who between them produce 70 % of the membrane modules, and a much larger number of system builders. The system builders buy modules almost as commodities from the various suppliers according to their particular needs. A handful of companies serving various niche markets produce both modules and systems. Total membrane module sales in 1998 were about US$200 million worldwide; system sales were another US$200 million. Short-term prospects for future growth are good. The demand for reverse osmosis systems to produce ultrapure water for the electronics and pharmaceutical industries is very strong. Municipalities in arid regions of the world are also continuing to buy brackish water and some seawater desalination units. The industry is extremely competitive, with the manufacturers producing similar products and competing mostly on price. Many incremental improvements have been made to membrane and module performance over the past 20 years, resulting in steadily decreasing water desalination costs in inflation-adjusted dollars. Some performance values taken from a paper by Furukawa are shown in Table 5.5. Since 1980, just after the introduction of the first interfacial composite membranes, the cost of spiral-wound membrane modules on a per square meter basis has decreased seven-fold. At the same time the water flux has doubled, and the salt permeability has decreased seven-fold. Taking these improvements into account, today’s membranes are almost 100 times better than those of the 1980s. This type of incremental improvement is likely to continue for some time. The key short-term technical issue is the limited chlorine resistance of interfacial composite membranes. A number of incremental steps made over the past 10–15 years have improved resistance, but current chlorine-resistant interfacial composites do not have the rejection and flux of the best conventional membranes. Table 5.5
Advances in spiral-wound module reverse osmosis performance
Year
Cost normalized (1980 US$)
Productivity normalized (to 1980)
Reciprocal salt passage normalized (to 1980)
Figure of merita
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000
1.00 0.65 0.34 0.19 0.14
1.00 1.10 1.32 1.66 1.94
1.00 1.56 2.01 3.52 7.04
1.0 2.6 7.9 30.8 99.3
a Figure of merit = (productivity) × (reciprocal salt passage/cost). Source: Dave Furukawa.
232
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
All the major membrane manufacturers are working on this problem, which is likely to be solved in the next few years. Three longer-term, related technical issues are fouling resistance, pretreatment, and membrane cleaning. Current membrane modules are subject to fouling by particulates and scale; this fouling can only be controlled by good (and expensive) feed water pretreatment and by membrane cleaning. In some large potential reverse osmosis markets, such as municipal wastewater reclamation and industrial process water treatment, the complexity, expense, and low reliability due to membrane fouling limit expansion significantly. A further long-term area of research is likely to be the development of reverse osmosis membranes to recover organic solutes from water. This chapter has focused almost entirely on the separation of ionic solutes from water, but some membranes (such as the PEC-1000 membrane) have excellent organic solute rejections also. The PEC-1000 membrane was chemically unstable, but it demonstrated what is achievable with membranes. A stable membrane with similar properties could be used in many wastewater applications.
References 1. A.G. Horvath, Water Softening, US Patent 1,825,631 (September, 1931). 2. C.E. Reid and E.J. Breton, Water and Ion Flow Across Cellulosic Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 1, 133 (1959). 3. S. Loeb and S. Sourirajan, Sea Water Demineralization by Means of an Osmotic Membrane, in Saline Water Conversion II, R.F. Gould (ed.), Advances in Chemistry Series Number 38, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 117–132 (1963). 4. J.C. Westmoreland, Spirally Wrapped Reverse Osmosis Membrane Cell, US Patent 3,367,504 (February, 1968). 5. D.T. Bray, Reverse Osmosis Purification Apparatus, US Patent 3,417,870 (December, 1968). 6. C.P. Shields, Five Years Experience with Reverse Osmosis Systems using DuPont Permasep Permeators, Desalination 28, 157 (1979). 7. J.E. Cadotte, Evaluation of Composite Reverse Osmosis Membrane, in Materials Science of Synthetic Membranes, D.R. Lloyd (ed.), ACS Symposium Series Number 269, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC (1985). 8. A. Muirhead, S. Beardsley and J. Aboudiwan, Performance of the 12,000 m3 /day Sea Water Reverse Osmosis Desalination Plant at Jeddah, Saudi Arabia (Jan. 1979–Jan. 1981), Desalination 42, 115 (1982). 9. R.E. Larson, J.E. Cadotte and R.J. Petersen, The FT-30 Seawater Reverse Osmosis Membrane-element Test Results, Desalination 38, 473 (1981). 10. J.E. Cadotte, Interfacially Synthesized Reverse Osmosis Membrane, US Patent 4,277,344 (July, 1981). 11. P. Eriksson, Water and Salt Transport Through Two Types of Polyamide Composite Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 36, 297 (1988). 12. Y. Kamiyama, N. Yoshioki, K. Matsui and K. Nakagome, New Thin Film Composite Reverse Osmosis Membranes and Spiral Wound Molecules, Desalination 51, 79 (1984).
REVERSE OSMOSIS
233
13. R.L. Riley, Reverse Osmosis, in Membrane Separation Systems, R.W. Baker, E.L. Cussler, W. Eykamp, W.J. Koros, R.L. Riley and H. Strathmann (eds), Noyes Data Corp., Park Ridge, NJ, pp. 276–328 (1991). 14. J.E. Cadotte, R.J. Petersen, R.E. Larson and E.E. Erickson, A New Thin Film Sea Water Reverse Osmosis Membrane, Presented at the 5th Seminar on Membrane Separation Technology, Clemson University, Clemson, SC (1980). 15. Z. Amjad (ed.), Reverse Osmosis, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York (1993). 16. B. Parekh (ed.), Reverse Osmosis Technology, Marcel Dekker, New York (1988). 17. R.J. Petersen, Composite Reverse Osmosis and Nanofiltration Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 83, 81 (1993). 18. S. Rosenbaum, H.I. Mahon and O. Cotton, Permeation of Water and Sodium Chloride Through Cellulose Acetate, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 11, 2041 (1967). 19. H.K. Lonsdale, Properties of Cellulose Acetate Membranes, in Desalination by Reverse Osmosis, M. Merten (ed.), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 93–160 (1966). 20. H.K. Lonsdale, U. Merten and R.L. Riley, Transport Properties of Cellulose Acetate Osmotic Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 9, 1341 (1965). 21. R.L. Riley, H.K. Lonsdale, C.R. Lyons and U. Merten, Preparation of Ultrathin Reverse Osmosis Membranes and the Attainment of Theoretical Salt Rejection, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 11, 2143 (1967). 22. S. Sourirajan, Reverse Osmosis, Academic Press, New York (1970). 23. K.D. Vos, F.O. Burris, Jr and R.L. Riley, Kinetic Study of the Hydrolysis of Cellulose Acetate in the pH Range of 2–10, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 10, 825 (1966). 24. W.M. King, D.L. Hoernschemeyer and C.W. Saltonstall, Jr, Cellulose Acetate Blend Membranes, in Reverse Osmosis Membrane Research, H.K. Lonsdale and H.E. Podall (eds), Plenum Press, New York, pp. 131–162 (1972). 25. R. Endoh, T. Tanaka, M. Kurihara and K. Ikeda, New Polymeric Materials for Reverse Osmosis Membranes, Desalination 21, 35 (1977). 26. R. McKinney and J.H. Rhodes, Aromatic Polyamide Membranes for Reverse Osmosis Separations, Macromolecules 4, 633 (1971). 27. J.W. Richter and H.H. Hoehn, Selective Aromatic Nitrogen-containing Polymeric Membranes, US Patent 3,567,632 (March, 1971). 28. R.J. Petersen and J.E. Cadotte, Thin Film Composite Reverse Osmosis Membranes, in Handbook of Industrial Membrane Technology, M.C. Porter (ed.), Noyes Publications, Park Ridge, NJ, pp. 307–348 (1990). 29. J.E. Cadotte, Reverse Osmosis Membrane, US Patent 4,039,440 (August, 1977). 30. R.L. Riley, C.E. Milstead, A.L. Lloyd, M.W. Seroy and M. Takami, Spiral-wound Thin Film Composite Membrane Systems for Brackish and Seawater Desalination by Reverse Osmosis, Desalination 23, 331 (1977). 31. J. Glater, S.K. Hong and M. Elimelech, The Search for a Chlorine-Resistant Reverse Osmosis Membrane, Desalination 95, 325 (1994). 32. J.E. Cadotte, Reverse Osmosis Membrane, US Patent 3,926,798 (December, 1975). 33. M. Kurihara, N. Harumiya, N. Kannamaru, T. Tonomura and M. Nakasatomi, Development of the PEC-1000 Composite Membrane for Single Stage Sea Water Desalination and the Concentration of Dilute Aqueous Solutions Containing Valuable Materials, Desalination 38, 449 (1981). 34. Y. Nakagawa, K. Edogawa, M. Kurihara and T. Tonomura, Solute Separation and Transport Characteristics Through Polyether Composite (PEC)-1000 Reverse-Osmosis Membranes, in Reverse Osmosis and Ultrafiltration, S. Sourirajan and T. Matsuura (eds), ACS Symposium Series Number 281, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 187–200 (1985).
234
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
35. B. Van der Bruggen, J. Schaep, D. Wilms and C. Vandecasteele, Influence of Molecular Size, Polarity and Charge on the Retention of Organic Molecules by Nanofiltration, J. Membr. Sci. 156, 29 (1999). 36. J.M.M. Peters, J.P. Boom, M.H.V. Mulder and H. Strathmann, Retention Measurements of Nanofiltration Membranes with Electrolyte Solutions, J. Membr. Sci. 145, 199 (1998). 37. A. Iwama and Y. Kazuse, New Polyimide Ultrafiltration Membranes for Organic Use, J. Membr. Sci. 11, 279 (1982). 38. C. Linder, M. Nemas, M. Perry and R. Katraro, Silicone-derived Solvent Stable Membranes, US Patent 5,265,734 (November 1993). 39. D.R. Machado, D. Hasson and R. Semiat, Effect of Solvent Properties on Permeate Flow Through Nanofiltration Membranes. Part I: Investigation of Parameters Affecting Solvent Flux, J. Membr. Sci. 163, 93 (1999). 40. L.S. White, I.-F. Wang and B.S. Minhas, Polyimide Membranes for Separation of Solvents from Lube Oil, US Patent 5,264,166 (November 1993). 41. L.S. White and A.R. Nitsch, Solvent Recovery from Lube Oil Filtrates with Polyimide Membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 179, 267 (2000). 42. R.M. Gould and A.R. Nitsch, Lubricating Oil Dewaxing with Membrane Separation of Cold Solvent, US Patent 5,494,566 (February 1996). 43. N. Bhore, R.M. Gould, S.M. Jacob, P.O. Staffield, D. McNally, P.H. Smiley and C.R. Wildemuth, New Membrane Process Debottlenecks Solvent Dewaxing Unit, Oil Gas J. 97, 67 (1999). 44. J.T. Scarpello, D. Nair, L.M. Freitas dos Santos, L.S. White and A.G. Livingston, The Separation of Homogenous Organometallic Catalysts using Solvent Resistant Nanofiltration, J. Membr. Sci. 203, 71 (2002). 45. R. Rautenbach and R. Albrecht, Membrane Processes, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Chichester (1989). 46. T. Matsuura and S. Sourirajan, Reverse Osmosis Separation of Phenols in Aqueous Solutions Using Porous Cellulose Acetate Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 15, 2531 (1972). 47. T. Matsuura and S. Sourirajan, Physiochemical Criteria for Reverse Osmosis Separation of Alcohols, Phenols, and Monocarboxylic Acid in Aqueous Solutions Using Porous Cellulose Acetate Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 15, 2905 (1971). 48. H.K. Lonsdale, U. Merten and M. Tagami, Phenol Transport in Cellulose Acetate Membranes, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 11, 1877 (1967). 49. R.G. Sudak, Reverse Osmosis, in Handbook of Industrial Membrane Technology, M.C. Porter (ed.), Noyes Publications, Park Ridge, NJ, pp. 260–306 (1990). 50. K. Marquardt, Sea Water Desalination by Reverse Osmosis, GVC/VDI Gesellschaft Verfahrenstechnik und Chemieingenieurwesen Seawater Desalination-Water Pretreatment and Conditioning, VDI Verlag, D¨usseldorf (1981). 51. A. Ko and D.B. Guy, Brackish and Seawater Desalting, in Reverse Osmosis Technology, B.S. Parekh (ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, pp. 141–184 (1988). 52. M.E. Williams, D. Bhattacharyya, R.J. Ray and S.B. McCray, Selected Applications of Reverse Osmosis, in Membrane Handbook, W.S.W. Ho and K.K. Sirkar (eds), Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, pp. 312–354 (1992). 53. H. Strathmann, Electrodialysis in Membrane Separation Systems, in Membrane Separation Systems, R.W. Baker, E.L. Cussler, W. Eykamp, W.J. Koros, R.L. Riley and H. Strathmann (eds), Noyes Data Corp., Park Ridge, NJ, pp. 396–420 (1991). 54. G.A. Pittner, High Purity Water Production Using Reverse Osmosis Technology, in Reverse Osmosis, Z. Amjad (ed.), Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York (1993).
REVERSE OSMOSIS
235
55. C.F. Frith, Jr, Electronic-grade Water Production Using Reverse Osmosis Technology, in Reverse Osmosis Technology, B.S. Parekh (ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, pp. 279–310 (1988). 56. A. Golomb, Application of Reverse Osmosis to Electroplating Waste Treatment, in Reverse Osmosis and Synthetic Membranes, S. Sourirajan (ed.), National Research Council Canada, Ottawa, Canada, pp. 481–494 (1977). 57. A. Golomb, Applications of Reverse Osmosis to Electroplating Waste Treatment, AES Research Project 31, 376 (1970). 58. I. Nusbaum and D.G. Argo, Design and Operation of a 5-mgd Reverse Osmosis Plant for Water Reclamation, in Synthetic Membrane Processes, G. Belfort (ed.), Academic Press, Orlando, FL, pp. 377–436 (1984).
6 ULTRAFILTRATION Introduction and History Ultrafiltration uses a finely porous membrane to separate water and microsolutes from macromolecules and colloids. The average pore diameter of the membrane ˚ range. The first synthetic ultrafiltration membranes were is in the 10–1000 A prepared by Bechhold from collodion (nitro cellulose) [1]. Bechhold was probably the first to measure membrane bubble points, and he also coined the term ‘ultrafilter’. Other important early workers were Zsigmondy and Bachmann [2], Ferry [3] and Elford [4]. By the mid-1920s, collodion ultrafiltration and microfiltration membranes were commercially available for laboratory use. Although collodion membranes were widely used in laboratory studies, no industrial applications existed until the 1960s. The crucial breakthrough was the development of the anisotropic cellulose acetate membrane by Loeb and Sourirajan in 1963 [5]. Their goal was to produce high-flux reverse osmosis membranes, but others, particularly Michaels at Amicon, realized the general applicability of the technique. Michaels and his coworkers [6] produced ultrafiltration membranes from cellulose acetate and many other polymers including polyacrylonitrile copolymers, aromatic polyamides, polysulfone and poly(vinylidene fluoride). These materials are still widely used to fabricate ultrafiltration membranes. In 1969, Abcor (now a division of Koch Industries) installed the first commercially successful industrial ultrafiltration system equipped with tubular membrane modules [7] to recover electrocoat paint from automobile paint shop rinse water. The economics were compelling, and within a few years many similar systems were installed. Shortly thereafter (1970), the first cheese whey ultrafiltration system was installed. Within a decade, 100 similar systems had been sold worldwide. These early systems used tubular or plate-and-frame modules, which were relatively expensive, but lower cost designs were gradually introduced. Hollow fiber (capillary) modules were first sold by Romicon in 1973, and spiral-wound modules, adapted to ultrafiltration applications by Abcor, became a commercial item by 1979–1980. Over the last 20 years, the ultrafiltration industry has grown steadily. The principal problem inhibiting wider application of the technology is membrane fouling. The problem is controlled, but not eliminated, by module Membrane Technology and Applications R. W. Baker 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 0-470-85445-6
238
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
Membrane Filter GmbH commercializes UF membranes - 1926
AND
Amicon markets laboratory-scale UF membranes, develops polysulfone, PVDF membranes - 1966
Abcor installs commercial tubular UF plant (electrocoat paint) - 1969
Bechhold prepares collodion membranes of graded pore size, measures bubble points and uses the term ultrafilter - 1907
1900
1910
1920
Zsigmondy and Bachmann patent collodion filters - 1918
APPLICATIONS
Abcor commercializes spiral-wound UF modules - 1980
1930
1940
1950
1960
Loeb-Sourirajan develop anisotropic RO membranes - 1963
1970
1980
1990
2000
First commercially significant ceramic membrane introduced - 1988
Amicon makes first UF hollow fibers - 1967
Romicon introduces hollow fiber capillary UF plants - 1973
Figure 6.1 Milestones in the development of ultrafiltration
and system design and by regular membrane cleaning protocols. Development of membranes with surface properties designed to minimize fouling has also helped. Recently, several companies have developed ceramic-based ultrafiltration membranes. Although much more expensive than their polymeric equivalents, these have found a place in applications that require resistance to high temperatures or require regular cleaning with harsh solutions to control membrane fouling. Some of the milestones in the development of ultrafiltration membranes are charted in Figure 6.1.
Characterization of Ultrafiltration Membranes Ultrafiltration membranes are usually anisotropic structures made by the Loeb–Sourirajan process. They have a finely porous surface layer or skin supported on a much more open microporous substrate. The finely porous surface layer performs the separation; the microporous substrate provides mechanical strength. The membranes discriminate between dissolved macromolecules of different sizes and are usually characterized by their molecular weight cut-off, a loosely defined term generally taken to mean the molecular weight of the globular protein molecule that is 90 % rejected by the membrane. Ultrafiltration and microfiltration are related processes—the distinction between the two lies in the pore size of the membrane. Microfiltration membranes have larger pores and are used to separate particles in the 0.1–10 µm range, whereas ultrafiltration is generally considered to be limited to membranes with pore diameters from 10 ˚ to 1000 A.
ULTRAFILTRATION
239
Batch stirred cell Safety valve Ultrafiltration cell
Pressure source
Reservoir
Magnetic stirrer
Filtrate
Flow recirculation system: flow-through cells Bleed
Pressure gauge
Pressure gauge
Safety valve Control valve
Ultrafiltration cell Heat exchanger Flow meter
By-pass valve
Pump
Reservoir
Back-up reservoir
Nitrogen cylinder
Figure 6.2 Laboratory ultrafiltration test systems
Laboratory-scale ultrafiltration experiments are performed with small, stirred batch cells or flow-through cells in a recirculation system. Diagrams of the two types of system are shown in Figure 6.2. Because ultrafiltration experiments are generally performed at pressures below 100 psi, plastic components can be used. Stirred batch cells are often used for quick experiments, but flow-through systems are preferred for systematic work. In flow-through systems, the feed solution can be more easily maintained at a constant composition, and the turbulence at the membrane surface required to control membrane fouling is high and easily reproducible. This allows reliable comparative measurements to be made.
240
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
The cut-off of ultrafiltration membranes is usually characterized by solute molecular weight, but several other factors affect permeation through these membranes. One important example is the shape of the molecule to be retained. When membrane retention measurements are performed with linear, watersoluble molecules such as polydextran, poly(ethylene glycol) or poly(vinyl pyrrolidone), the measured rejection is much lower than the rejection measured for proteins of the same molecular weight. It is believed that linear, watersoluble polymer molecules are able to snake through the membrane pores, as illustrated in Figure 6.3. Protein molecules, however, exist in solution as tightly wound globular coils held together by hydrogen bonds. These globular molecules cannot deform to pass through the membrane pores and are therefore rejected. Some results showing the rejection of different molecules for a polysulfone ultrafiltration membrane are listed in the table accompanying Figure 6.3 [8]. The membrane shows significant rejection to globular protein molecules as small as pepsin (MW 35 000) and cytochrome c (MW 13 000) but is completely permeable to a flexible linear polydextran, with an average molecular weight of more than 100 000. The pH of the feed solution is another factor that affects permeation through ultrafiltration membranes, particularly with polyelectrolytes. For example,
Linear molecule
Globular molecule
Skin of UF membrane Porous substructure
Globular Proteins Solute MW (1000s) Rejection (%)
Linear Polymer
Pepsin
Cytochrome c
Polydextran
35 90
13 70
100 0
Figure 6.3 Ultrafiltration membranes are rated on the basis of nominal molecular weight cut-off, but the shape of the molecule to be retained has a major effect on retentivity. Linear molecules pass through a membrane, whereas globular molecules of the same molecular weight may be retained. The table shows typical results obtained with globular protein molecules and linear polydextran for the same polysulfone membrane [8]
ULTRAFILTRATION
241
poly(acrylic acid) is usually very well rejected by ultrafiltration membranes at pH 5 and above, but is completely permeable through the same membrane at pH 3 and below. This change in rejection behavior with pH is related to the change in configuration of the polyacid. In solutions at pH 5 and above, poly(acrylic acid) is ionized. In the ionized form, the negatively charged carboxyl groups along the polymer backbone repel each other; the polymer coil is then very extended and relatively inflexible. In this form, the molecule cannot readily permeate the small pores of an ultrafiltration membrane. At pH 3 and below, the carboxyl groups along the poly(acrylic acid) polymer backbone are all protonated. The resulting neutral molecule is much more flexible and can pass through the membrane pores.
Concentration Polarization and Membrane Fouling A key factor determining the performance of ultrafiltration membranes is concentration polarization, which causes membrane fouling due to deposition of retained colloidal and macromolecular material on the membrane surface. A number of reviews have described the process in detail [9–13]. The pure water flux of ultrafiltration membranes is often very high—greater than 1 cm3 /cm2 · min (350 gal/ft2 · day). However, when membranes are used to separate macromolecular or colloidal solutions, the flux falls within seconds, typically to 0.1 cm3 /cm2 · min. This immediate drop in flux is caused by the formation of a gel layer of retained solutes on the membrane surface due to concentration polarization. This gel layer forms a secondary barrier to flow through the membrane, as illustrated in Figure 6.4 and described in detail below. This first decline in flux is determined by the composition of the feed solution and its fluid hydrodynamics. Sometimes the resulting flux is constant for a prolonged period, and when the membrane is retested with pure water, its flux returns to the original value. More commonly, however, a further slow decline in flux occurs over a period of hours to weeks, depending on the feed solution. Most of this second decrease in flux is caused by slow consolidation of the secondary layer formed by concentration polarization on the membrane surface. Formation of this consolidated gel layer, called membrane fouling, is difficult to control. Control techniques include regular membrane cleaning, back flushing, or using membranes with surface characteristics that minimize adhesion. Operation of the membrane at the lowest practical operating pressure also delays consolidation of the gel layer. A typical plot illustrating the slow decrease in flux that can result from consolidation of the secondary layer is shown in Figure 6.5 [14]. The pure water flux of these membranes is approximately 50 gal/min but, on contact with an electrocoat paint solution containing 10–20 % latex, the flux immediately falls to about 10–12 gal/min. This first drop in flux is due to the formation of the gel layer of latex particles on the membrane surface, as shown in Figure 6.4. Thereafter, the flux declines steadily over a 2-week period. This second drop in flux is caused by slow densification of the gel layer under the pressure of the
242
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Colloidal or particulate material
BULK SOLUTION
Surface fouling
Internal membrane fouling
Figure 6.4 Schematic representation of fouling on an ultrafiltration membrane. Surface fouling is the deposition of solid material on the membrane that consolidates over time. This fouling layer can be controlled by high turbulence, regular cleaning and using hydrophilic or charged membranes to minimize adhesion to the membrane surface. Surface fouling is generally reversible. Internal fouling is caused by penetration of solid material into the membrane, which results in plugging of the pores. Internal membrane fouling is generally irreversible
system. In this particular example, the densified gel layer could be removed by periodic cleaning of the membrane. When the cleaned membrane is exposed to the latex solution again, the flux is restored to that of a fresh membrane. If the regular cleaning cycle shown in Figure 6.5 is repeated many times, the membrane flux eventually does not return to the original value on cleaning. Part of this slow, permanent loss of flux is believed to be due to precipitates on the membrane surface that are not removed by the cleaning procedure. A further cause of the permanent flux loss is believed to be internal fouling of the membrane by material that penetrates the membrane pores and becomes lodged in the interior of the membrane, as illustrated in Figure 6.4. Ultrafiltration membranes are often used to separate colloids from water and microsolutes. In this case the tendency is to use relatively high-molecular-weight cut-off membranes, but the higher fluxes of these membranes can be transitory because they are more susceptible to internal fouling. A membrane with a lower molecular weight cut-off, even
ULTRAFILTRATION
243 12
Permeate flux (gal/min)
10
8
6
4
2
0
Membranes cleaned
0
10
20
30
40
Time (days)
Figure 6.5 Ultrafiltration flux as a function of time of an electrocoat paint latex solution. Because of fouling, the flux declines over a period of days. Periodic cleaning is required to maintain high fluxes [14]. Reprinted from R. Walker, Recent Developments in Ultrafiltration of Electrocoat Paint, Electrocoat 82, 16 (1982) with permission from Gardner Publications, Inc., Cincinnati, OH
though it may have a lower pure water flux, often provides a more sustained flux with the actual feed solutions because less internal fouling occurs. As described above, the initial cause of membrane fouling is concentration polarization, which results in deposition of a layer of material on the membrane surface. The phenomenon of concentration polarization is described in detail in Chapter 4. In ultrafiltration, solvent and macromolecular or colloidal solutes are carried towards the membrane surface by the solution permeating the membrane. Solvent molecules permeate the membrane, but the larger solutes accumulate at the membrane surface. Because of their size, the rate at which the rejected solute molecules can diffuse from the membrane surface back to the bulk solution is relatively low. Thus their concentration at the membrane surface is typically 20–50 times higher than the feed solution concentration. These solutes become so concentrated at the membrane surface that a gel layer is formed and becomes a secondary barrier to flow through the membrane. The formation of this gel layer on the membrane surface is illustrated in Figure 6.6. The gel layer model was developed at the Amicon Corporation in the 1960s [8]. The formation of the gel layer is easily described mathematically. At any point within the boundary layer shown in Figure 6.6, the convective flux of solute to the membrane surface is given by the volume flux, Jv , of the solution through the membrane multiplied by the concentration of the solute, ci . At steady state, this
244
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
cgel Jv Jv ci Jw ci b
Di
dci dx
Js (= Jv ci)
Turbulent, well mixed bulk solution
Laminar boundary layer (thickness d)
Gel layer
Membrane
Figure 6.6 Illustration of the formation of a gel layer of colloidal material on the surface of an ultrafiltration membrane by concentration polarization
convective flux within the laminar boundary layer is balanced by the diffusive flux of retained solute in the opposite direction. This balance is expressed by the equation dci Jv ci = Di (6.1) dx where Di is the diffusion coefficient of the macromolecule in the boundary layer. Once the gel layer has formed, the concentrations of solute at both surfaces of the boundary layer are fixed. At one surface the concentration is the feed solution concentration cib ; at the other surface it is the concentration at which the solute forms an insoluble gel (cgel ). Integration of Equation (6.1) over the boundary layer thickness (δ) then gives cgel Jv δ = exp (6.2) c ib Di where cgel is the concentration of retained solute at the membrane surface where the solute gels and cib is the concentration in the bulk solution. In any particular ultrafiltration test, the terms cib , cgel , Di and δ in Equation (6.2) are fixed because the solution and the operating conditions of the test are fixed. From Equation (6.2) this means that the volume flux Jv through the membrane is also fixed and quite independent of the intrinsic permeability of the membrane. In physical terms, this is because a membrane with a higher intrinsic permeability only causes a thicker
ULTRAFILTRATION
245
gel layer to form on the surface of the membrane. This lowers the membrane flux until the rate at which solutes are brought toward the membrane surface and the rate at which they are removed are again balanced, as expressed in Equation (6.1). The formation of a gel layer of colloidal material at the ultrafiltration membrane surface produces a limiting or plateau flux that cannot be exceeded at any particular operating condition. Once a gel layer has formed, increasing the applied Pressure: p1
p2
p3
p4
c gel
c gel
cio cio ci b
ci b
ci b
ci b
Membrane
Gel layer
Membrane pure water flux
Membrane flux J w
Membrane flux with a macromolecular solution
p1
p2
p3
p4
Applied pressure, p
Figure 6.7 The effect of pressure on ultrafiltration membrane flux and the formation of a secondary gel layer. Ultrafiltration membranes are best operated at pressures between p2 and p3 at which the gel layer is thin. Operation at high pressures such as p4 leads to formation of thick gel layers, which can consolidate over time, resulting in permanent fouling of the membrane
246
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
pressure does not increase the flux but merely increases the gel thickness. This is also shown in Equation (6.2), which contains no term for the applied pressure. The effect of the gel layer on the flux through an ultrafiltration membrane at different feed pressures is illustrated in Figure 6.7. At a very low pressure p1 , the flux Jv is low, so the effect of concentration polarization is small, and a gel layer does not form on the membrane surface. The flux is close to the pure water flux of the membrane at the same pressure. As the applied pressure is increased to pressure p2 , the higher flux causes increased concentration polarization, and the concentration of retained material at the membrane surface increases. If the pressure is increased further to p3 , concentration polarization becomes enough for the retained solutes at the membrane surface to reach the gel concentration cgel and form the secondary barrier layer. This is the limiting flux for the membrane. Further increases in pressure only increase the thickness of the gel layer, not the flux. Experience has shown that the best long-term performance of an ultrafiltration membrane is obtained when the applied pressure is maintained at or just below the plateau pressure p3 shown in Figure 6.7. Operating at higher pressures does not increase the membrane flux but does increase the thickness and density of retained material at the membrane surface layer. Over time, material on the membrane surface can become compacted or precipitate, forming a layer of deposited material that has a lower permeability; the flux then falls from the initial value. A series of experimental results obtained with latex solutions illustrating the effect of concentration and pressure on flux are shown in Figure 6.8. The point at which the flux reaches a plateau value depends on the concentration of the latex in the solution: the more concentrated the solution, the lower the plateau flux. The exact relationship between the maximum flux and solute concentration can be obtained by rearranging Equation (6.2) to obtain Jmax = −
D (ln cib − ln cgel ) δ
(6.3)
where Jmax is the plateau or limiting flux through the membrane. Plots of the limiting flux Jmax as a function of solution concentration for latex solution data are shown in Figure 6.9 for a series of latex solutions at various feed solution flow rates. A series of straight line plots is obtained, and these extrapolate to the gel concentration cgel at zero flux. The slopes of the plots in Figure 6.9 are proportional to the term D/δ in Equation (6.3). The increase in flux resulting from an increase in the fluid recirculation rate is caused by the decrease in the boundary layer thickness δ. Plots of maximum flux as a function of solute concentration for different solutes using the same membrane under the same conditions are shown in Figure 6.10 [15]. Protein or colloidal solutions, which easily form precipitated gels, have low fluxes and extrapolate to low gel concentrations. Particulate
ULTRAFILTRATION
247
100
Ultrafiltration flux (gal/ft2 · day)
80
Pure water flux 1 % latex concentration
60
5% 40 10 % 15 % 20 %
20
0
0
20
40 60 Applied pressure (psi)
80
100
Figure 6.8 The effect of pressure on membrane flux for styrene–butadiene polymer latex solutions in a high-turbulence, thin-channel test cell [13] 140 Recirculation rate: 40 gpm
Ultrafiltration flux (gal/ft2 · day)
120 100 80 20 gpm 60 40
10 gpm
20 0
5 gpm 1
2
3
5 7 10 20 30 Latex concentration (vol%)
cgel
50 70 100
Figure 6.9 Ultrafiltration flux with a latex solution at an applied pressure of 60 psi (in the limiting flux region) as a function of feed solution latex concentration. These results were obtained in a high-turbulence, thin-channel cell. The solution recirculation rate is shown in the figure [13]
248
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
280 Electro deposition primer
Ultrafiltration flux (gal/ft2 · day)
240 200 160 120
Human albumin
80
Styrene– butadiene latex
40 Gelatin 0
1
2
3
5 7 10 20 Solids concentration (wt %)
30
50
80
Figure 6.10 Effect of solute type and concentration on flux through the same type of ultrafiltration membrane operated under the same conditions [15]. Reproduced from M.C. Porter, Membrane Filtration, in Handbook of Separation Techniques for Chemical Engineers, P.A. Schweitzer (ed.), p. 2.39, Copyright 1979, with permission of McGraw-Hill, New York, NY
suspensions, pigments, latex particles, and oil-in-water emulsions, which do not easily form gels, have higher fluxes at the same concentration and operating conditions and generally extrapolate to higher gel concentrations. Studies of concentration polarization such as those illustrated in Figures 6.8–6.10 are usually performed during the first few hours of the membrane use. Compaction of the secondary membrane layer has then only just begun, and membrane fluxes are often high. Fluxes obtained in industrial processes, which must operate for days or weeks without cleaning, are usually much lower. The gel layer model described above is very appealing and is widely used to rationalize the behavior of ultrafiltration membranes. Unfortunately a number of issues cannot be easily explained by this simple form of the model: • The flux of many macromolecular colloidal and particulate solutions is too high (sometimes by an order of magnitude) to be rationalized by a reasonable value of the diffusion coefficient and the boundary layer thickness in Equation (6.2). • In the plateau region of the flux–pressure curves of the type shown in Figure 6.8, different solutes should have fluxes proportional to the value
ULTRAFILTRATION
249
of their diffusion coefficients D in Equation (6.3). This is not the case, as shown in Figure 6.10. For example, latex and particulate solutes with very small diffusion coefficients typically have higher ultrafiltration limiting fluxes than protein solutions measured with the same membranes under the same conditions. This is the opposite of the expected behavior. • Experiments with different ultrafiltration membranes and the same feed solution often yield very different ultrafiltration limiting fluxes. But according to the model shown in Figure 6.6 and represented by Equation (6.2), the ultrafiltration limiting flux is independent of the membrane type. Contrary to normal experience that falling bread always lands jam-side down, the trend of these observations is that experiment produces a better result than theory predicts. For this reason the observations are lumped together and called the flux paradox [9]. The best working model seems to be that, in addition to simple diffusion, solute is also being removed from the membrane surface as undissolved gel particles by a scouring action of the feed fluid [16]. This explains why protein solutions that form tough adherent gels have lower fluxes under the same conditions than pigment and latex solutions that form looser gels. The model also explains why increasing the hydrophilicity of the membrane surface or changing the charge on the surface can produce higher limiting fluxes. Decreased adhesion between the gel and the membrane surface allows the flowing feed solution to remove gel particles more easily. Figure 6.11 illustrates how turbulent eddies caused by the high velocity of the solution passing through the narrow channel of a spiral-wound module might remove gel particles from the membrane surface. Because of the high velocity of the feed solution and the feed spacer netting used in ultrafiltration modules, the feed liquid is normally very turbulent. Although a relatively laminar boundary layer may form next to the membrane surface, as described by the film model, periodic turbulent eddies may also occur. These eddies can dislodge gel from the membrane surface, carrying it away with the feed solution. The most important effect of concentration polarization is to reduce the membrane flux, but it also affects the retention of macromolecules. Retention data obtained with dextran polysaccharides at various pressures are shown in Figure 6.12 [17]. Because these are stirred batch cell data, the effect of increased concentration polarization with increased applied pressure is particularly marked. A similar drop of retention with pressure is observed with flow-through cells, but the effect is less because concentration polarization is better controlled in such cells. With macromolecular solutions, the concentration of retained macromolecules at the membrane surface increases with increased pressure, so permeation of the macromolecules also increases, lowering rejection. The effect is particularly noticeable at low pressures, under which conditions increasing the applied pressure produces the largest increase in flux, and hence concentration polarization, at the membrane surface. At high pressure, the change in flux with
250
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
Feed spacer material
1000 µm
Apparent laminar boundary layer (20 µm) Gel layer (5 – 10 µm) Membrane
Figure 6.11 An illustration of the channel of a spiral-wound module showing how periodic turbulent eddies can dislodge deposited gel particles from the surface of ultrafiltration membranes
Rejection (%)
100 80 60 40
Dextran-40
Dextran-80
Dextran-20 20 0
0
20
40 60 Pressure (psi)
80
100
Figure 6.12 Rejection of 1 % dextran solutions as a function of pressure using Dextran 20 (MW 20 000), Dextran 40 (MW 40 000), and Dextran 80 (MW 80 000). Batch cell experiments performed at a constant stirring speed [17]
increased pressure is smaller, so the decrease in rejection by the membrane is less apparent. Concentration polarization can also interfere with the ability of an ultrafiltration membrane to fractionate a mixture of dissolved macromolecules. Figure 6.13 [8] shows the results of experiments with a membrane with a molecular weight
ULTRAFILTRATION
251
Fractional rejection of human serum albumin
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4
0.2
0.1 5
10
50 (Concentration of
100
g -globulin)−1
500 (wt%)−1
Figure 6.13 The retention of albumin (MW 65 000) in the presence of varying concentrations of γ -globulin (MW 156 000) by a membrane with a nominal molecular weight cut-off based on one-component protein solutions of MW 200 000. As the concentration of γ -globulin in the solution increases, the membrane water flux decreases, and the albumin rejection increases from 25 % at 0.01 wt% γ -globulin to 80 % rejection at 0.1 wt% γ -globulin [8]
cut-off of about 200 000 used to separate albumin (MW 65 000) from γ -globulin (MW 156 000). Tests with the pure components show that albumin passes through the membrane almost completely unhindered, but rejection of γ -globulin is significant. However, addition of even a small amount of γ -globulin to the albumin causes almost complete rejection of both components. The increased rejection is accompanied by a sharp decrease in membrane flux, suggesting that rejected globulin forms a secondary barrier layer. The secondary layer is eliminated only at very low γ -globulin concentrations, resulting in partial fractionation of the two proteins. Unfortunately, at such low dilutions the separation is no longer of commercial interest. Because of the effect of the secondary layer on selectivity, ultrafiltration membranes are not commonly used to fractionate macromolecular mixtures. Most commercial ultrafiltration applications involve processes in which the membrane completely rejects all the dissolved macromolecular and colloidal material in the feed solution while completely passing water and dissolved microsolutes. Efficient fractionation by ultrafiltration is only possible if the species differ in molecular weight by a factor of 10 or more.
Membrane Cleaning Several cleaning methods are used to remove the densified gel layer of retained material from the membrane surface. The easiest is to circulate an appropriate cleaning solution through the membrane modules for 1 or 2 h. The most common ultrafiltration fouling layers—organic polymer colloids and gelatinous
252
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
materials—are best treated with alkaline solutions followed by hot detergent solutions. Enzymatic detergents are particularly effective when the fouling layer is a proteinaceous gel. Calcium, magnesium, and silica scales, often a problem with reverse osmosis membranes, are generally not a problem in ultrafiltration because these ions permeate the membrane (ultrafiltration of cheese whey, in which high calcium levels can lead to calcium scaling, is an exception). Because many feed waters contain small amounts of soluble ferrous iron salts, hydrated iron oxide scaling is a problem. In the ultrafiltration system these salts are oxidized to ferric iron by entrained air. Ferric iron is insoluble in water, so an insoluble iron hydroxide gel forms and accumulates on the membrane surface. Such deposits are usually removed with a citric or hydrochloric acid wash. Regular cleaning is required to maintain the performance of all ultrafiltration membranes. The period of the cleaning cycle can vary from daily for food applications, such as ultrafiltration of whey, to once a month or more for ultrafiltration membranes used as polishing units in ultrapure water systems. A typical cleaning cycle is as follows: 1. Flush the system several times with hot water at the highest possible circulation rate. 2. Treat the system with an appropriate acid or alkali wash, depending on the nature of the layer. 3. Treat the system with a hot detergent solution. 4. Flush the system thoroughly with water to remove all traces of detergent; measure the pure water flux through the membrane modules under standard test conditions. Even after cleaning, some degree of permanent flux loss over time is expected. If the restoration of flux is less than expected, repeat steps 1–3. Ultrafiltration systems should never be taken off line without thorough flushing and cleaning. Because membrane modules are normally stored wet, the final rinse solutions should contain a bacteriostat such as 0.5 % formaldehyde to inhibit bacterial growth. In addition to regular cleaning with chemical solutions, mechanical cleaning of the membrane may be used, particularly if chemical cleaning does not restore the membrane flux. Early electrocoat paint systems used 1-in.-diameter tubular membrane modules. These tubes could be effectively cleaned by forcing sponge balls with a slightly larger diameter than the tube through the tube—the balls gently scraped the membrane surface, removing deposited material. Sponge-ball cleaning is an effective but relatively time-consuming process, so it is performed rather infrequently. However, automatic equipment for sponge-ball cleaning has been devised and has found a limited use. Backflushing is another way of cleaning heavily fouled membranes. The method is widely used to clean capillary and ceramic membrane modules that can withstand a flow of solution from permeate to feed without damaging the
ULTRAFILTRATION
253
membrane. Backflushing is not usually used for spiral-wound modules because the membranes are too easily damaged. In a backflushing procedure a slight over-pressure is applied to the permeate side of the membrane, forcing solution from the permeate side to the feed side of the membrane. The flow of solution lifts deposited materials from the surface. Backflushing must be done carefully to avoid membrane damage. Typical backflushing pressures are 5–15 psi. One method of achieving a backflushing effect used with capillary ultrafiltration modules is initiated by closing the permeate port from the membrane module, as shown in Figure 6.14 [18]. In normal operation a pressure drop of 5–10 psi occurs between the feed and residue side of a membrane module. This pressure difference is required to drive the feed solution through the module. If the permeate port from the module is closed, the pressure on the permeate side of the membrane will increase to a pressure intermediate between those of the feed and residue streams. This produces a slight positive pressure difference at one end of the module and a slight negative pressure difference on the other end of the module, as shown in Figure 6.14(b). The pressure difference sets up a backflushing condition in which permeate-quality water that has permeated one-half of the module becomes a backflushing solution in the other half of the module. Deposited materials lifted from the membrane surface in the back-flushed area are swept away by the fast feed flow. If the direction of the feed flow is reversed, as shown in Figure 6.14(c), the other half of the module is then backflushed. This in-situ backflushing technique is used in capillary ultrafiltration modules in which the feed-to-residue pressure drop is quite large. An advantage of the procedure is that it can be done without stopping normal operation of the ultrafiltration system. Because of the challenging environment in which ultrafiltration membranes are operated and the regular cleaning cycles, membrane lifetime is significantly shorter than that of reverse osmosis membranes. Ultrafiltration module lifetimes are rarely more than 2–3 years, and modules may be replaced annually in cheese whey or electrocoat paint applications. In contrast, reverse osmosis membranes are normally not cleaned more than once or twice per year and can last 4–5 years.
Membranes and Modules Membrane Materials Most of today’s ultrafiltration membranes are made by variations of the Loeb–Sourirajan process. A limited number of materials are used, primarily polyacrylonitrile, poly(vinyl chloride)–polyacrylonitrile copolymers, polysulfone, poly(ether sulfone), poly(vinylidene fluoride), some aromatic polyamides, and cellulose acetate. In general, the more hydrophilic membranes are more foulingresistant than the completely hydrophobic materials. For this reason water-soluble
254
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
(a) Normal operation Feed
Permeate
0 5 10152025 Permeate pressure Flow
Flux
Feed pressure 0 5 101520 25 Residue
Pressure (psi)
(b) Normal flow back flushing Feed
Permeate closed
0 5 10152025 Permeate pressure Feed pressure
Backwashed region of membrane
Flux Flow
Flux 0 5 10152025 Pressure (psi)
Residue (c) Reverse flow back flushing Permeate closed Backwashed region of membrane
0 5 10152025 Flux Feed pressure Permeate pressure
Flow Flux
0 5 10152025 Pressure (psi)
Figure 6.14 Backflushing of membrane modules by closing the permeate port. This technique is particularly applicable to capillary fiber modules
polymers such as poly(vinyl pyrrolidone) or poly(vinyl methyl ether) are often added to the membrane casting solutions used for hydrophobic polymers such as polysulfone or poly(vinylidene fluoride). During the membrane precipitation step, most of the water-soluble polymer is leached from the membrane, but enough remains to make the membrane surface hydrophilic.
ULTRAFILTRATION
255 26
Negatively charged membrane surface
24
Paint flux (gal/ft2· day)
22 20 18 16 14
Slightly positively charged surface
12 10
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Time (weeks)
Figure 6.15 Effect of membrane surface charge on ultrafiltration flux decline. These membranes were used to ultrafilter cathodic electrocoat paint, which has a net negative charge. Electrostatic repulsion made the negatively charged membrane significantly more resistant to fouling than the similar positively charged membrane [13]
The charge on the membrane surface is important. Many colloidal materials have a slight negative charge from carboxyl, sulfonic or other acid groups. If the membrane surface also has a slight negative charge, adhesion of the colloidal gel layer to the membrane is reduced, which helps to maintain a high flux and inhibit membrane fouling. The effect of a slight positive charge on the membrane is the opposite. Charge and hydrophilic character can be the result of the chemical structure of the membrane material or can be applied to a preformed membrane surface by chemical grafting or surface treatment. The appropriate treatment depends on the application and the feed solution. The importance of membrane surface characteristics on performance is illustrated by Figure 6.15. The feed solution in this example was a cathodic electrocoat paint solution in which the paint particulates had a net positive charge. As a result, membrane flux declined rapidly with the positively charged membranes but much more slowly with essentially identical membranes that had been treated to give the surface a net negative charge [13]. Ultrafiltration Modules The need to control concentration polarization and membrane fouling dominates the design of ultrafiltration modules. The first commercially successful
256
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
ultrafiltration systems were based on tubular and plate-and-frame modules. Over the years, many improvements have been made to these module designs, and they are still used for highly fouling solutions. The lower cost of spiral-wound and capillary modules has resulted in a gradual trend to replace tubular and plate-and-frame systems with these lower-cost modules. In relatively non-fouling applications, such as the use of ultrafiltration as part of a treatment train to produce ultrapure water, spiral-wound modules are universally used. Spiral-wound and capillary modules are also used in some food applications, such as ultrafiltration of cheese whey and clarification of apple juice. Because of their large diameter, tubular ultrafiltration modules can be used to treat solutions that would rapidly foul other module types. In a number of demanding applications, such as treatment of electrocoat paint, concentration of latex solutions, or separation of oil–water emulsions, the fouling resistance and ease of cleaning of tubular modules outweighs their high cost, large volume, and high energy consumption. In a typical tubular module system, 5- to 8-ft-long tubes are manifolded in series. The feed solution is circulated through the module array at velocities of 2–6 m/s. This high solution velocity causes a pressure drop of 2–3 psi per module or 10–30 psi for a module bank. Because of the high circulation rate and the resulting pressure drop, large pumps are required, so tubular modules have the highest energy consumption of any module design. Most tubular ultrafiltration plants use 30–100 kWh of energy per 1000 gallons of permeate produced. At an electrical energy cost of US$0.06/kWh, this corresponds to an energy cost of US$2–6 per 1000 gallons of permeate, a major cost factor. The diameter of the early tubular membrane modules was 1 in. Later, more energy-efficient, higher-membrane-area modules were produced by nesting four to six smaller-diameter tubes inside a single housing (see Chapter 3). Typical tubular module costs vary widely but are generally from US$200 to 500/m2 . Recently ceramic tubular modules have been introduced; these are more expensive, typically from US$1000 to 2000/m2 . This high cost limits their use to a few applications with extreme feed operating conditions. Plate-and-frame units compete with tubular units in some applications. These modules are not quite as fouling resistant as tubular modules but are less expensive. Most consist of a flat membrane envelope with a rubber gasket around the outer edge. The membrane envelope, together with appropriate spacers, forms a plate that is contained in a stack of 20–30 plates. Typical feed channel heights are 0.5–1.0 mm, and the system operates in high-shear conditions. Plate-andframe systems can be operated at higher pressures than tubular or capillary modules—operating pressures up to 150 psi are not uncommon. This can be an advantage in some applications. The compact design, small hold-up volume, and absence of stagnant areas also makes sterilization easy. For these reasons plateand-frame units are used in several types of food industry operations, particularly
ULTRAFILTRATION
257
Figure 6.16 Horizontal DDS plate-and-frame ultrafiltration system. Courtesy of Alfa Laval Nakskov A/S, Naksvov, Denmark
in Europe where Rhˆone Poulanc and De Danske Sukkerfabrikker (DDS) [now Alfa Laval] pioneered these applications in the 1970s. A photograph of an Alfa Laval plate-and-frame system is shown in Figure 6.16. Capillary hollow fiber modules were introduced by Romicon in the early 1970s. A typical capillary module contains 500–2000 fibers with a diameter of 0.5–1.0 mm housed in a 30-in.-long, 3-in.-diameter cartridge. Modules have a membrane area of 2–10 m2 . Feed solution is pumped down the bore of the fibers. Operating pressures are quite low, normally not more than 25 psi (to avoid breaking the fibers). This low operating pressure is a disadvantage in the treatment of some clean feed solutions for which high-pressure operation would be advantageous. The normal feed-to-residue pressure drop of a capillary module is 10–15 psi. Under these conditions, capillary modules achieve good throughputs with many solutions. High-temperature sanitary systems are available; this, combined with the small hold-up volume and clean flow path, has encouraged the use of these modules in biotechnology applications in which small volumes of
258
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
expensive solutions are treated. A major advantage of capillary fiber systems is that the membrane can be cleaned easily by backflushing. With capillary modules it is important to avoid ‘blinding’ the fibers with particulates caught at the fiber entrance. Prefiltration to remove all particulates larger than one-tenth of the fiber’s inside diameter is required to avoid blinding. The use of spiral-wound modules in ultrafiltration applications has increased recently. This design was first developed for reverse osmosis modules in which the feed channel spacer is a fine window-screen material. In ultrafiltration a coarser feed spacer material is used, often as much as 45 mil thick. This coarse spacer prevents particulates from lodging in the spacer corners. However, prefiltration of the ultrafiltration feed down to 5–10 µm is still required for long-term operation. In the past, spiral-wound modules were limited to ultrafiltration of clean feed waters, such as preparation of ultrapure water for the electronics or pharmaceutical industries. Development of improved pretreatment and module spacer designs now allows these modules to be used for more highly fouling solutions such as cheese whey. In these food applications, the stagnant volume between the module insert and the module housing is a potentially unsterile area. To eliminate this dead space, the product seal is perforated to allow a small bypass flow to continuously flush this area. In the last few years a number of companies, most notably New Logic International (Emeryville, CA), have introduced plate-and-frame modules in which the membrane plate is vibrated or rotated. Thus, control of concentration polarization at the membrane surface is by movement of the membrane rather than by movement of the feed solution [19]. Moving the membrane concentrates most of the turbulence right at the membrane surface, where it is most needed. These modules achieve very high turbulence at the membrane surface at a relatively low energy cost. The fluxes obtained are high and stable. Vibrating–rotating modules are considerably more expensive than cross-flow modules so the first applications have been with high-value, highly fouling feed solutions that are difficult to treat with standard modules.
System Design Batch Systems The simplest type of ultrafiltration system is a batch unit, shown in Figure 6.17. In such a unit, a limited volume of feed solution is circulated through a module at a high flow rate. The process continues until the required separation is achieved, after which the concentrate solution is drained from the feed tank, and the unit is ready to treat a second batch of solution. Batch processes are particularly suited to the small-scale operations common in the biotechnology and pharmaceutical industries. Such systems can be adapted to continuous use but this requires automatic controls, which are expensive and can be unreliable.
ULTRAFILTRATION
259
Feed tank
Membrane modules Feed pump
Concentrate Permeate
Figure 6.17 Flow schematic of a batch ultrafiltration process
The easiest way to calculate the performance of a batch system is to assume the membrane is completely retentive for the solute of interest. That is, cp R= 1− =1 (6.4) cb where cp is the solute concentration in the permeate and cb is the solute concentration in the feed. It follows that the increase in concentration of the solute in the feed tank from the initial concentration cb (o), to the concentration at time t, cb (t) is proportional to the volume of solution remaining in the feed tank, that is, V(o) cb (t) = cb (o) V(t)
(6.5)
where the volume of solution removed in the permeate is V(o) − V(t) . If, as is often the case, the membrane is slightly permeable to the solute (R < 1), the concentration ratio achieved can be written as cb (t) V(o) ln (6.6) = R ln cb (o) V(t) When the rejection coefficient equals one, Equation (6.6) reduces to Equation (6.5). A plot of the concentration ratio of retained solute as a function of the volume reduction for membranes with varying rejection coefficients is shown in Figure 6.18. This figure illustrates the effect of partially retentive membranes on loss of solute.
260
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
10
cb(t ) cb(o)
6 5
Concentration ratio
8
4
R
=
R
3
0
1.
.8
=0
R=
0.6
R=
2
0.4
R = 0.2 1
0
20
40
60
80
90
Volume reduction (1−V(t )/V(o))%
Figure 6.18 Increase in concentration of the retained feed solution as a function of volume reduction of the feed for membranes of different solute rejections. The difference between these lines and the R = 1 line represents loss of solute through the membrane
Continuous Systems Continuous ultrafiltration processes, in which modules are arranged in series to obtain the separation required in a single pass, are relatively common. This is because high feed solution flow rates are required to control concentration polarization; a single-pass process would not achieve the required removal under these conditions. Solution velocities in ultrafiltration modules are 5–10 times higher than in reverse osmosis. For these reasons, feed-and-bleed systems are commonly used in large ultrafiltration plants. Figure 6.19 shows one-, two- and three-stage feed-and-bleed systems. In these systems a large volume of solution is circulated continuously through a bank of membrane modules. Concurrently, a small volume of feed solution enters the recirculation loop just before the recirculation pump, and an equivalent volume of more concentrated solution is removed (or bled) from the recirculation loop just after the membrane module. The advantage of feed-and-bleed systems is that a high feed solution velocity through the modules is easily maintained independent of the volume of solution being treated. In most plants the flow rate of solution in the recirculation loop is 5–10 times the feed solution flow rate. This high circulation rate means that the concentration of retained material in the circulating solution is close to the concentration of the bleed solution and is significantly higher than the feed solution concentration. Because the flux of ultrafiltration membranes decreases with increasing concentration, more membrane area is required to produce the required separation than in a batch or a once-through continuous system operated at the same feed solution velocity.
ULTRAFILTRATION
261 Permeate
One-stage feed-and-bleed
Feed
Bleed (concentrate)
Permeate
Permeate
Two-stage feed-and-bleed
Feed
Bleed (concentrate)
Permeate
Permeate
Permeate
Three-stage feed-and-bleed Feed Bleed (concentrate)
Figure 6.19 One-, two- and three-stage feed-and-bleed systems. In general, the most efficient design is achieved when all stages have approximately the same membrane area. As the number of stages is increased, the average concentration of the solution circulating through the membrane modules decreases, and the total membrane area of the system is significantly less than for a one-stage design
To overcome the inefficiency of one-stage feed-and-bleed designs, industrial systems are usually divided into multiple stages, as shown in Figure 6.19. By using multiple stages, the difference in concentration between the solution circulating in a stage and the feed solution entering the stage is minimized. The following numerical values illustrate this point. In this example, the membrane is assumed to be completely retentive and the goal is to concentrate the feed solution
262
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
from 1 to 8 %. If this is done in a one-stage feed-and-bleed system, the average concentration of the solution passing through the modules is 8 %, and the flux is proportionately low. In a more efficient two-stage feed-and-bleed system, the first stage concentrates the solution from 1 to 3 %, and the second stage concentrates the solution from 3 to 8 %. Approximately three-quarters of the permeate is removed in the first stage, and the rest in the second stage. Because the modules in the first stage operate at a concentration of 3 % rather than 8 %, these modules have a higher membrane flux than in the one-stage unit. In fact, the membrane area of each stage is about equal although the volume of permeate produced by each stage is very different. The two-stage feed-and-bleed design has about 60 % of the area of the one-stage system. The three-stage system, which concentrates the solution in three equal-area stages—from 1 to 2 % in the first stage, from 2 to 4 % in the second stage, and from 4 to 8 % in the third stage—is even more efficient. In this case the total membrane area is about 40 % of the area of a one-stage system performing the same separation. Because of the significantly lower membrane areas of multistage feed-andbleed systems, most large plants have between three and five stages. The limit to the number of stages is reached when the reduction in membrane area does not offset the increase in complexity of the system. Also, because of the high fluid circulation rates involved in feed-and-bleed ultrafiltration plants, the cost of pumps can rise to 30 to 40 % of the total cost of the system. Electricity to power the pumps is a significant operating expense.
Applications In the 1960s and early 1970s it was thought that ultrafiltration would be widely used to treat industrial wastewater. This application did not materialize. Ultrafiltration is far too expensive to be generally used for this application, however, it is used to treat small, concentrated waste streams from particular point sources before they are mixed with the general sewer stream. Ultrafiltration is also used if the value of the components to be separated is sufficient to offset the cost of the process. Examples exist in food processing, in which the ultrafiltered concentrate is used to produce a high-value product, or in the production of ultrapure water in the electronics industry. The cost of ultrafiltration plants varies widely, depending on the size of the plant, the type of solution to be treated, and the separation to be performed. In general, ultrafiltration plants are much smaller than reverse osmosis systems. Typical flow rates are 10 000–100 000 gal/day, one-tenth that of the average reverse osmosis plant. Rogers [20] compiled the costs shown in Figure 6.20 that, adjusted for inflation, still seem reasonable. For typical plants treating 10 000–100 000 gal/day of feed solution, the capital cost is in the range US$2–5 gal/day capacity. The typical breakdown of these costs is shown in Table 6.1 [21]. Operating costs will normally be US$3–4/1000 gal/day capacity,
ULTRAFILTRATION
263 Purchase price ($/gpd of feed)
100
10
High solids loading low flux
1 Low solids loading high flux 0.1
1
100 1000 10 000 10 Plant capacity (1000 gal/day of feed)
Figure 6.20 Purchase price in 2003 US dollars for ultrafiltration plants as a function of plant capacity. Data of Rogers corrected for inflation [20]. Reprinted from Synthetic Membrane Processes, A.N. Rogers, Economics of the Application of Membrane Processes, p. 454, G. Belfort (ed.), Copyright 1984, with permission from Elsevier
Table 6.1 Typical ultrafiltration capital and operating cost breakdown [21] Capital costs Pumps Membrane modules Module housings Pipes, valves, frame Controls/other Total Operating costs Membrane replacement Cleaning costs Energy Labor Total
% 30 20 10 20 20 100 30–50 10–30 20–30 15 100
with membrane module replacement costs about 30–50 %, and energy costs for the recirculation pumps 20–30 %, depending on the system design. The current ultrafiltration market is approximately US$200 million/year but because the market is very fragmented, no individual segment is more than about US$10–30 million/year. Also, each of the diverse applications uses membranes, modules, and system designs tailored to the particular industry served. The result is little product standardization, many custom-built systems, and high costs compared to reverse osmosis. The first large successful application was the recovery
264
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY
AND
APPLICATIONS
of electrocoat paint in automobile plants. Later, a number of significant applications developed in the food industry [22,23], first in the production of cheese, then in the production of apple and other juices and, more recently, in the production of beer and wine. Industrial wastewater and process water treatment is a growing application, but high costs limit growth. Early plants were all tubular or plate-and-frame systems, but less expensive capillary and specially configured spiral-wound modules are now used more commonly. An overview of ultrafiltration applications is given in Cheryan and Alvarez’s review article [23] and Cheryan’s book [24]. Electrocoat Paint In the 1960s, automobile companies began to use electrodeposition of paint on a large scale. The paint solution is an emulsion of charged paint particles. The metal piece to be coated is made into an electrode of opposite charge to the paint particles and is immersed in a large tank of the paint. When a voltage is applied between the metal part and the paint tank, the charged paint particles migrate under the influence of the voltage and are deposited on the metal surface, forming a coating over the entire wetted surface of the metal part. After electrodeposition, the piece is removed from the tank and rinsed to remove excess paint, after which the paint is cured in an oven. The rinse water from the washing step rapidly becomes contaminated with excess paint, while the stability of the paint emulsion is gradually degraded by ionic impurities carried over from the cleaning operation before the paint tank. Both of these problems are solved by the ultrafiltration system shown in Figure 6.21. The ultrafiltration plant takes paint solution containing 15–20 % solids and produces a clean permeate containing the ionic impurities but no paint particles, which is sent to the counter-current rinsing operation, and a slightly concentrated paint to be returned to the paint tank. A portion of the ultrafiltration permeate is bled from the tank and replaced with water to maintain the ionic balance of the process. Electrocoat paint is a challenging feed solution for an ultrafiltration process. The solids content of the solution is high, typically 15–20 wt%, so a gel layer easily forms on the membrane. The gel formation results in relatively low fluxes, generally 10–15 gal/ft2 · day. However, the value of the paint recovered from the rinse water and elimination of other rinse-water cleanup steps made the ultrafiltration process an immediate success when introduced by Abcor. Tubular modules were used in the first plants [7] and are still installed in many electrocoat operations, although capillary and some spiral-wound modules are used in newer plants. The first electrocoat paint was anionic because the latex emulsion particles carried a negative charge. These emulsions were best treated with membranes having a slight negative charge to minimize fouling. Cationic latex paints carrying
ULTRAFILTRATION
265
Chromate/phosphate cleaning steps
Rinse tanks
Electro paint tank
Ultrafiltration system
Bleed
Figure 6.21 Flow schematic of an electrocoat paint ultrafiltration system. The ultrafiltration system removes ionic impurities from the paint tank carried over from the chromate/phosphate cleaning steps and provides clean rinse water for the counter-current rinsing operation
a positive charge were introduced in the late 1970s. Ultrafiltration of these paints required development of membranes carrying a slight positive charge. Food Industry Cheese Production Ultrafiltration has found a major application in the production of cheese; the technology is now widely used throughout the dairy industry. During cheese production the milk is coagulated (or curdled) by precipitation of the milk proteins. The solid that forms (curd) is sent to the cheese fermentation plant. The supernatant liquor (whey) represents a disposal problem. The compositions of milk and whey are shown in Table 6.2. Whey contains most of the dissolved salts and sugars present in the original milk and about 25 % of the original protein. In the past, whey was often discharged to the sewer because its high salt and lactose content makes direct use as a food supplement difficult. Now about half of the whey produced in the United States is processed to obtain additional value and avoid a troublesome waste disposal problems. The traditional cheese production process and two newer processes using ultrafiltration membranes are shown in Figure 6.22. The objective of the two membrane processes shown in Figure 6.22 is to increase the fraction of milk proteins used as cheese or some other useful product and to reduce the waste disposal problem represented by the whey. In the MMV
266
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY Table 6.2
Component (wt%)
Milk
Whey
Total solids Protein Fat Lactose/other carbohydrates Ash
12.3 3.3 3.7 4.6 0.7
7.0 0.9 0.7 4.8 0.6
MMV process
Whey separation process
Milk
Milk
Milk
Curds
Whey
APPLICATIONS
Composition of milk and cheese whey
Conventional process
Coagulation
AND
Ultrafiltration
Filtrate d