MEMBRANE PROTEIN PURIFICATION AND CRYSTALLIZATION Second Edition A PRACTICAL GUIDE
This Page Intentionally Left Blank...
33 downloads
1409 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
MEMBRANE PROTEIN PURIFICATION AND CRYSTALLIZATION Second Edition A PRACTICAL GUIDE
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
MEMBRANE PROTEIN PURIFICATION AND CRYSTALLIZATION Second Edition A PRACTICAL GUIDE Edited by
CAROLA HUNTE Max-Planck-Institut fur Biophysik Frankfurt am Main, Germany and
GEBHARD VON JAGOW AND HERMANN SCHAGGER Zentrum der Biologischen Chemie Universitatsklinikum Frankfurt Frankfurt am Main, Germany
ACADEMIC PRESS An imprint of Elsevier Science Amsterdam Boston London New York Oxford Paris San Diego San Francisco Singapore Sydney Tokyo
This book is printed o n acid-free paper. @ Copyright 2003,1994, Elsevier Science (USA) All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electromc or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Requests for permission to make copies of any part of the work should be mailed to: Permissions Department, Harcourt, Inc., 6277 Sea Harbor Drive, Orlando, Florida 32887-6777. Explicit permission from Academic Press is not required to reproduce a maximum of two figures or tables from an Academic Press chapter in another scientific or research publication provided that the material has not been credited to another source and that full credit to the Academic Press chapter is given.
Academic Press
An imprint of Elsevier Science 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495, USA http://www.academicpress.com
Academic Press
An imprint of Elsevier Science 84 Theobald's Road, London WCIX 8RR, UK http://www.academicpress.com Library of Congress Control Number: 2002100070 International Standard Book Number: 0-12-361776-6 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 02 03 04 05 06 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
Contributors xv Preface xvii
I
STRATEGIES AND TECHNIQUES
1
Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins GEBHARD VON JAGOW, THOMAS A. LINK, AND HERMANN SCHAGGER I. Introduction 1 11. General Guide for Retaining Catalytic Activity 3
vi
Contents
III. Choice and Sequence of Purification Techniques 4 IV. Choice of Protein Source, Disruption of Cells, and Preparation of Organelles and Membranes 6 V. Protein Assay 7 A. Catalytic Activity and Other Specific Properties 7 B. Determination of Total Protein 8 VI. Solubilization and Stabilization of Membrane Proteins A. Choice of Buffer 9 B. Choice of Detergent 10 C. Protein Stability and Protease Inhibition 16 References 18
9
Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification HERMANN SCHAGGER I. Introduction 19 II. Solubilization-Precipitation 20 A. Differential Extraction 20 B. Phase Separation and Differential Precipitation 24 C. Centrifugation 26 III. Concentration of Samples, Exchange of Buffer, and Exchange of Detergent 26 A. Sample Concentration 26 B. Exchange of Buffer 28 C Removal and Exchange of Detergent 28 IV. Chromatographic Techniques 29 A. Hydroxylapatite Chromatography 30 B. Ion-Exchange Chromatography 35 C. Chromatofocusing 38 D. Metal Chelate Chromatography 43 E. Affinity and Dye-Ligand Chromatography 45 F. Covalent Chromatography 48 G. Hydrophobic Interaction Chromatography 49 H. Gel Filtration 49 References 52
3
Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins ETANA PAD AN, CAROLA HUNTE, AND HELMUT REILANDER I. Introduction
55
Contents
Vll
11. Prokaryotic Expression Systems for Overproduction of Membrane Proteins for Structural Studies 57 A. E. coli Inducible Promoters Used for Overexpression 58 B. Optimizing Expression Levels in E. coli 60 C Inclusion Bodies and Refolding 62 III. Eukaryotic Expression Systems for Overproduction of Membrane Proteins 63 A. Yeast-Based Expression Systems 64 B. Insect Cells as Expression System 70 IV. Use of Fusion Proteins and Affinity Tags for Purification of Membrane Proteins 73 Acknowledgments 77 References 78
A
SDS Electrophoresis Techniques HERMANN SCHAGGER I. Introduction 85 II. Choice of Optimal SDS-Page System and Gel Type 86 A. Wide versus Narrow Molecular Mass Range 86 B. Separation of Proteins with Similar Molecular Masses 86 C. Avoiding Broad Bands 88 D. Analytical versus Preparative Purpose 88 III. Tricine-SDS-PAGE 88 A. Comparison with Laemmli System 89 B. Characteristics of Gel Types 89 C. Gel Preparation 91 D. Sample Preparation and Protein Loading 93 E. Electrophoresis Conditions 95 F. Staining and Drying of High Percentage Polyacrylamide Gels 96 IV. Recovery of Proteins from SDS Gels 97 A. Recovery of Proteins from Fixed and Coomassie-Stained SDS Gels 97 B. Blue-SDS-PAGE 97 C Recovery of Membrane Proteins after Blue-SDS-PAGE 99 V. Processing of Proteins Recovered from Gels for Immunization and Protein Sequencing 100 VI. Electroblotting 101 References 102
C
Blue Native Electrophoresis HERMANN SCHAGGER I. Introduction
105
Vlll
Contents II. Techniques 106 A. Native First Dimension: BN-PAGE 106 B. Native Second Dimension: BN-PAGE + Detergent 116 C. Second or Third Dimension: SDS-PAGE 116 III. AppHcations 119 A. Final Purification of Crude Membrane Proteins for Immunization and Protein Sequencing 120 B. Separation of Native Membrane Protein Complexes from Solubilized Biological Membranes 120 References 129
^
Preparative Isoelectric Focusing IRENE TSIROGIANNI AND GEORGIOS TSIOTIS I. Introduction 131 II. Techniques 133 A. Instruments and Accessories 133 B. Analytical Electrofocusing 134 C. Preparative Flat-Bed Electrofocusing 136 III. Application: Purification of Photosystem I 138 IV. Conclusions 139 References 141
7
Membrane Protein Crystallization CAROLA HUNTE AND HARTMUT MICHEL I. Introduction 143 II. Bottlenecks in Membrane Protein Crystallization A. Starting Material 146 B. Protein Purification and Characterization 147 C. Detergents 151 D. Crystallization 154 E. Conclusion 156 References 156
146
Contents
II Q
ix
DISCUSSION OF SELECTED ISOLATION PROTOCOLS Lipid-Dependent Inactivation and Reactivation of Bovine Complex III HERMANN SCHAGGER I. Introduction 161 II. Lipid-Dependent Inactivation and Reactivation 162 A. Delipidation 162 B. Reconstitution of Lipid-Dependent Catalytic Activity 163 References 165
Q
Purification of an Affinity-Epitope Tagged G-Protein Coupled Receptor CHRISTOPH REINHART, H MARKUS WEISS, AND HELMUT REILANDER I. Introduction 167 II. Production of Recombinant J82-Adrenergic Receptor in Pichia pastoris A. Media for Pichia pastoris 168 B. Growth and Expression of Pichia pastoris Clones 169 III. Preparation of Pichia pastoris Membranes 169 IV. Solubilization of Membranes 170 V. Purification of the j82-Adrenergic Receptor 170 A. Ligand Affinity Chromatography of j52-Adrenergic Receptor 170 B. Anti-FLAG Ml Antibody Affinity Chromatography 171 C. Affinity Chromatography of Biotinylated j52"Adrenergic Receptor by Monomeric Avidin Resin (Optional) 172 D. Analytical Gel Filtration (Optional) 174 VI. Ligand Binding Assays 174 A. Binding Assay on Membranes 174 B. Binding Assay for Solubilized Receptor 175 References 177
10
168
Purification of NhaA Na^/H^ Antiporter of Escherichia Coli for 3D or 2D Crystallization MIRO VENTURI AND ETANA PAD AN I. Introduction 179 11. Growth of Escherichia coli for Production of His-Tagged NhaA in a 10 1 Fermenter 180
Contents
III. Isolation of Membranes from Escherichia coli TA16/pAXH Strain 182 IV. Two-Step Purification of His-Tagged NHaA 183 A. Affinity Purification of His-Tagged NhaA on the Ni^^-NTA Matrix 183 B. Purification of His-Tagged NhaA by Gel Filtration Chromatography 184 V. NhaA Reconstitution into Liposomes and Activity Assay 185 A. Reconstitution by Detergent Dilution 185 B. Reconstitution by BioBeads 187 C. NhaA Activity Assay: ApH Driven ^^Na^ Active Transport 187 VI. Dynamic Light Scattering Experiments 189 Acknowledgments 189 References 190
1 1
Purification of the Cytochrome bci Complex from Yeast HILDUR PALSDOTTIR AND CAROLA HUNTE I. Introduction 191 II. Preparation of Membranes from Saccharomyces cerevisiae 192 III. Cytochrome bc^ Complex Preparation 193 A. Detergent Solubilization of Membranes 193 B. Purification of the Cytochrome bc^ Complex by Anion-Exchange Chromatography 194 C. Size Exclusion Chromatography 196 D. Protein Determination 196 E. Spectroscopic Quantification of the Cytochrome bc^ Complex 197 F. Determination of Cytochrome bc^ Complex Activity 197 G. Analytical Size Exclusion Chromatography 198 H. SDS-PAGE Analysis 198 IV. Conclusions 200 Acknowledgments 201 References 202
III ^ O
CRYSTALLIZATION OF MEMBRANE PROTEINS Antibody Fragment Mediated Crystallization of Membrane Proteins CAROLA HUNTE AND AIMO KANNT I. Introduction 205 II. Production of Antibody Fv Fragments in the Periplasm of E. coli 210
Contents
III. Purification of Fvs by Streptavidin Affinity Chromatography 210 IV. Fv Mediated Crystallization of Cytochrome c Oxidase from P. denitrificans 211 A. Growth of P. denitrificans 211 B. Isolation of Membranes 211 C. Solubilization of Membrane Proteins 212 D. Indirect Immunoaffinity Chromatography 212 E. Detergent Exchange and Size Exclusion Chromatography 212 F. Crystallization of Cytochrome c Oxidase-Fz? Complex 214 V. Fi;-Mediated Crystallization of the Cytochrome hc^ Complex from the Yeast S. cerevisiae 214 A. Co-Complex Formation and Purification 214 B. Crystallization of Cytochrome hc^ Complex: fi;18Ell Co-Complex 215 VI. Conclusions 217 Acknowledgments 217 References 217
13
Crystallization of Wolinella succinogenes Quinol: Fumarate Reductase C. ROY D. LANCASTER I. Introduction 219 II. Preparatory Steps 221 A. Growth of Wolinella succinogenes 111 B. Isolation of Quinol: Fumarate Reductase 222 III. Crystallization of Quinol: Fumarate Reductase 225 IV. Conclusions 226 References 227
14
Ba3-Type Cytochrome c Oxidase from Thermus thermophilus: Purification, Crystallization, and Crystal Transformation TEWFIK SOULIMANE, REINER KIEFERSAUER, AND MANUEL E. THAN I. Introduction 229 II. Fermentation, Purification, and Molecular Characterization 231 A. Fermentation 231 B. Preparation Protocol 231 C. Molecular Characterization 234 III. Crystallization and Initial Crystallographic Characterization 236
XI
Xll
Contents
A. Detergent Exchange 236 B. Crystallization in Sitting-Drops 237 C. Crystallization in Batch 238 D. Initial Crystallographic Characterization 239 IV. Crystal Transformation 240 A. Oil Method 240 B. Transformation and Freezing with the Humidity Machine 243 Acknowledgments 249 References 249
15
Two-Dimensional Crystallization of Membrane Proteins: A Practical Guide WERNER KUHLBRANDT I. Introduction 253 II. Things to Consider Before You Start 254 A. 2D or 3D Crystals? 254 B. Which Membrane Protein Structures Have Been Determined by Electron Microscopy? 254 III. Crystallization Parameters 255 A. The Protein 255 B. The Lipid 260 C. The Detergent 263 D. pH 264 E. Salt Concentration and Ionic Additives 265 F. Nonionic Additives 265 G. Precipitants 265 H. Temperature 266 IV. Methods for Grow^ing 2D Crystals of Membrane Proteins 267 A. 2D Crystallization in Suspension 267 B. 2D Crystallization on a Surface 273 C. 2D Crystallization in situ 276 V. How to Find 2D Crystals 277 VI. Outlook 279 References 280
16
In Cubo Crystallization of Membrane Proteins EHUD M. LANDAU I. Introduction 285 II. Properties of Lipidic Cubic Phases
287
Contents
III. Practical Aspects of Lipidic Cubic Phases 290 A. Setting Up In Cubo Crystallization 290 B. Establishing In Cubo Crystallization Conditions 295 C. Harvesting Single Crystals from the Lipidic Cubic Phase Matrix 296 IV. Mechanism of Crystallization In Cubo 298 V. Summary 300 Acknowledgments 301 References 301
Index 303
xiii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contributors
Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors' contributions begin.
Carola Hunte (55, 143, 191, 205), Dept. of Molekulare Membranbiologie, Max-Planck-Institut fiir Biophysik, 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Gebhard Von Jagow (1), Zentrum der Biologischen Chemie, Universitatsklinikum Frankfurt, 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Aimo Kannt (205), Aventis Pharma Deutschland GmbH, Assay Development/High Throughput Screening, Industriepark Hoechst, H811, 65926 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Reiner Kiefersauer (229), Max-Planck-Institut fiir Biochemie, Am Klopferspitz 18a, 82152 Planegg-Martinsried, Germany, and Proteros biostructures GmbH, Am Klopferspitz 18a, 82152 Planegg-Martinsried, Germany
XVI
Contributors
Werner Ktihlbrandt (253), Max-Planck-Institut fiir Biophysik, Heinrich-Hoffmann-Strasse 7, 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany C. Roy D. Lancaster (219), Max-Planck-Institut fiir Biophysik, Dept. Abteilung Molekulare Membranbiologie, 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Ehud M Landau (285), The Membrane Protein Laboratory, Department of Physiology and Biophysics, Sealy Center for Structural Biology, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, Texas Thomas A. Link (1), Institut fiir Biophysik, J.W. Goethe-Universitat, 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Hartmut Michel (143), Dept. of Molekulare Membranbiologie, Max-PlanckInstitut fiir Biophysik, 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Etana Padan (55, 179), Department of Microbial and Molecular Ecology, Institute of Life Sciences, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 91904 Jerusalem, Israel Hildur Palsdottir (191), Dept. Molekulare Membranbiologie, Max-PlanckInstitut fiir Biophysik, Heinrich-Hoffmann-Strasse 7, 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Helmut Reilander (55,167), Aventis Pharma, Industriepark Hoechst, D-65926 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Christoph Reinhart (167), Max-Planck-Institut fiir Biophysik, Heinrich-Hoffmann-Strasse 7, 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Hermann Schagger (1, 19, 85, 105; 161), Zentrum der Biologischen Chemie, Universitatsklinikum Frankfurt, 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Tewfik Soulimane^ (229), Rheinisch-Westflische Technische Hochschule Aschen, Institut fiir Biochemie, Pauwelsstrasse 30, D-52057 Aachen, Germany Manuel E. Than (229), Max-Planck-Institut fiir Biochemie, Am Klopferspitz 18A, 82152 Planegg-Martinsried, Germany Georgios Tsiotis (131), Division of Biochemistry, Department of Chemistry, University of Crete, GR-71409 Heraklion, Greece Irene Tsirogianni (131), Division of Biochemistry, Department of Chemistry, University of Crete, GR-71409 Heraklion, Greece Miro Venturi (179), Dept. Molekulare Membranbiologie, Max-Planck-Institut fiir Biophysik, Heinrich-Hoffmann-Strasse 7, 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany H. Markus Weiss (167), Novartis Pharm AG, WkL 135.4.83, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland ^Present address: Paul Scherrer Institut, Life Sciences, OSRA/007, CH-5232 Villigen PSI, Switzerland
Preface to the Second Edition
This volume is written as a practical guide for bench scientists. Protocols of general use for membrane protein purification and crystallization are provided, and special precautions for critical steps in handling membrane proteins are suggested. Part I focuses on the principles of available purification techniques, and the unique features encountered when membrane proteins are involved. In Part II, selected isolation protocols for membrane proteins describe in detail some of the most essential isolation techniques, for instance purification of histidine-tagged and affinity-epitope-tagged membrane proteins, ion exchange chromatography, and size exclusion chromatography. Part III is the first compilation in a monograph of successfully used 2Dand 3D-crystallization protocols for membrane proteins. The introduction of crystallization techniques, and the presentation of specific crystallization
XVlll
Preface to the Second Edition
protocols is the most obvious, but not the only change compared to the first edition. In fact, this second edition comprises mainly new contributions. Only four chapters of the first edition, namely "Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins" (Chapter 1), "Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification," (Chapter 2), "SDS-Electrophoresis Techniques" (Chapter 4), and Preparative Isoelectric Focusing" (Chapter 6) have been revised and implemented in the second edition. Chapter 3, "Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins," was introduced to attract attention to the considerable advantages of recombinant technologies. Chapter 5 summarizes recent developments in "Blue-Native Electrophoresis," one of the most convenient and effective techniques for small-scale isolation of native membrane protein complexes. Chapter 7, "Membrane Protein Crystallization," outlines the special requirements for crystallization of membrane proteins. Chapter 8, Part II, gives an "easy-to-use" protocol for reactivation of membrane proteins by addition of detergent-solubilized lipid stock solutions, which often can substitute for more time-consuming reconstitution in lipid vesicles. Chapters 9, 10, and 11 contain isolation protcols for membrane proteins that were selected to examplify essential isolation and reconstitution techniques, and methods for characterization of proteins, which have been successfully crystallized. Part III includes Chapter 12 on "Antibody Fragment Mediated Crystallization of Membrane Proteins," a technique that improves the chances to obtain wellordered membrane protein crystals. A remarkable technical aspect of "Crystallization of Fumarate Reductase," Chapter 13, is the use of preparative native isoelectric focusing, as described in Chapter 6, to obtain this membrane protein in a crystallizable form. Crystallization and crystal transformation are exemplified in Chapter 14. Chapter 15 provides an excellent overview on 2D-crystallization of membrane proteins. Last but not least, a promising approach to crystallize membrane proteins from bicontinuous lipidic cubic phase is described in Chapter 16, "In Cubo Crystallization of Membrane Proteins." We thank the authors for contributing their individual chapters in a form that emphasizes the practical aspects of their techniques, which should be of immediate value for bench scientists.
1
Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins GEBHARD VON JAGOW*, THOMAS A. LINK,** AND HERMANN SCHAGGER* *Zentrum der Biologischen Chemie Universitatsklinikum Frankfurt 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany **Institut fur Biophysik J.W. Goethe-Universitat 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany
I. INTRODUCTION Why is a separate discussion of membrane proteins advisable? What is different when it comes to isolating membrane proteins and water-soluble proteins? Aggregation problems. Membrane proteins tend to form aggregates even in the presence of detergents, which reduces the efficacy of all separation techniques. It is therefore essential to select an effective solubilizing, but non-denaturing, detergent to ascertain (1) the minimum ionic strength the protein requires to be in a homogeneously dissolved state, (2) the maximum ionic strength that will not cause dissociation of labile proteins from complex structures, and (3) the optimum pH for solubilization and protein stability.
Membrane Protein Purification and Crystallization 2/e: A Practical Guide. Copyright 2003, Elsevier Science (USA) All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
Gebhard von Jagow et al.
Interference of detergents with separation techniques. Detergent may restrict the appUcability of certain techniques to membrane protein purification. 1. Methods that differentiate according to molecular mass or size (e.g., gel filtration and centrifugation) have lower resolution because small membrane proteins usually bind more detergent per gram of protein than do larger ones, and differences in size and mass of the protein moiety are masked. 2. Salting out techniques show little discrimination in the presence of neutral detergents. 3. Chromatofocusing and isoelectric focusing in the presence of anionic detergents do not work. Hydroxylapatite and anion-exchange chromatography should not be used in the presence of anionic detergents unless most of the anionic detergent has been replaced with a neutral detergent. 4. Hydrophobic interaction chromatography is problematic with all detergents including neutral ones. Role of detergents in protease degradation. Membrane proteins are best stabilized within membrane structures in which protease attack is slow compared to the rapid degradation often observed after solubilization by detergents. Thus, when working with membrane proteins, it is necessary to add effective protease inhibitors before solubilization. Reversible and irreversible inactivation of proteins by detergents. 1. For some membrane proteins, neither catalytic activity nor structural stability is greatly influenced by delipidating conditions. In these cases, preparation schemes will not differ greatly from those used for watersoluble proteins. 2. Other membrane proteins retain their native structure in the presence of detergents but because of delipidation may lose catalytic activity during the purification process. These delipidated preparations can be ideal for hydrodynamic measurements, protein chemical work, and crystallization attempts. Thus, failure to detect the protein by standard assay is not grounds for despair. Sufficient activity for detection may be restored by replenishing lipid during or before the enzymatic measurements or by using hydrophilic substrate analogs. 3. In some cases, the membrane protein will not only lose catalytic activity during delipidation but structural integrity as well. This is a major problem with membrane proteins but one that can often be overcome by judicious use of detergents. Chances for successful purification are good if a detergent-solubilized membrane protein is obtainable in catalytically active form in the supernatant after centrifugation. Guidelines and rules for preserving catalytic activity are discussed and
CHAPTER 1 Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins
3
summarized here. Detailed examples involving hydroxylapatite and ion-exchange chromatography are given in Chapter 2. The appUcation of detergents in membrane protein purification is a common theme throughout this book. In planning a strategy for membrane protein isolation, it is best to begin by asking fundamental questions about the protein of interest: (1) Is the protein required for functional or protein-chemical analyses? (2) What is known about its abundance and properties? Is the protein required for functional or protein-chemical analyses? This question relates to the quantity of protein to be isolated and hence, on the techniques that may be appropriate. It usually will be necessary to use methods that preserve the native state of the protein in the first steps of the purification. If enzymatic activity is not required, application of denaturing techniques may be advantageous in the final stages when proteins can be identified by apparent molecular masses on SDS-PAGE. Native gel electrophoresis techniques are presently restricted to small-scale preparations and thus will preferentially be used as the last purification step (in fortunate situations as the only purification step). All other methods may be used for small- to large-scale purifications with some differences in cost. Enriching the protein of interest before adding detergents will facilitate purification. If there is a choice, attempts should be made to isolate the protein from sources that contain high levels of it. In all cases, it is recommended that the level of protein be enhanced before adding detergent (such as by using cell culture conditions that favor the expression of the protein of interest or by preparing organelles a n d / o r enriched membranes). Often it is advisable to accept relatively large losses to obtain a suitable starting material. This may ultimately save a purification step in the presence of detergent and may be essential for preserving catalytic activity. What is known about the properties of the protein of interest? The most essential questions are whether a simple enzyme test system is available to follow enrichment during the preparation protocol and whether catalytic activity is retained after solubilization by detergents. It is usually advantageous to perform a series of small-scale preextraction and solubilization experiments to establish conditions under which the protein is in a homogeneously dissolved state, in which catalytic activity is present, and for which optimal enrichment is obtained. This involves testing salt concentrations, pH, protease inhibitors, and protein stabilizing additives.
11. GENERAL GUIDE FOR RETAINING CATALYTIC ACTIVITY A. Dissolve the membrane protein under optimal conditions for stability at a detergent/protein ratio that is not much higher than the minimum
Gebhard von Jagow et al.
detergent:protein ratio required for protein solubilization. {Note: The minimum detergent/protein ratio is also the minimum detergent/ lipid ratio. The latter is the essential ratio for solubilization, but the detergent/protein ratio is usually measured for convenience). B. Keep the time for isolation as short as possible. Perform separations (preferentially) in the cold, and replenish protein stabilizing additives or protease inhibitors whenever these are removed or inactivated (e.g., EDTA protecting against Ca-dependent proteases is removed by hydroxylapatite chromatography, and the protease inhibitor PMSF becomes inactive after some hours in water). C. If possible avoid any purification step that would add new detergent and alter the original detergent/lipid ratio. If this condition cannot be strictly met, keep changes in the detergent/lipid ratio to a minimum. {Note: Ideal conditions in this respect are those in which the protein of interest passes through a column together with detergent and lipid at the original detergent/lipid ratio, while contaminants bind to the support. This "pass-through" mode is especially useful in preliminary column chromatography experiments to optimize binding conditions without losing catalytic activity.) In most cases, the pass-through mode will not yield effective enrichment and the "binding-mode" must be used. The detergent/lipid ratio then cannot be kept constant. Complete delipidation can be avoided, however, by using small volumes of washing buffer and maintaining a low level of detergent concentration in the washing buffer. The detergent concentration in the elution buffer is not critical if the protein elutes as a sharp band with the first few milliliters of elution buffer. Gradient elution will be deleterious for proteins sensitive to delipidation, except with steep gradients. The use of a batch procedure is recommended for proteins highly sensitive to delipidation (see Chapter 2, Section IV,A). Extensive delipidation can also be prevented by adding lipid to the buffers. Optimal stabilization can often be achieved at a ratio of 2 to 3 molecules of detergent per molecule of lipid (see Chapter 8). However, because of solubility problems, higher detergent/lipid ratios are generally required.
III. CHOICE AND SEQUENCE OF PURIFICATION TECHNIQUES A typical membrane protein isolation protocol involves several separate steps that are usually applied in the following order. A. Enrichment without use of detergent. Enriched protein content can be obtained, for example, by choosing an optimal source of the protein or by isolating organelles and membranes during the first stages of the purification. B. Solubilization and precipitation techniques. These approaches pro-
CHAPTER 1 Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins
5
vide some degree of purification. Differential extraction and centrifugation are commonly used methods that are occasionally followed by differential precipitation techniques. These are applicable on a large scale and afford low to medium resolution at low cost. C. Hydroxylapatite or ion-exchange chromatography (large or small scale, medium resolution, low to medium cost). D. Chromatofocusing (small to medium scale, high resolution, medium to high cost); or dye affinity chromatography (small to medium scale, high resolution, medium to high cost); or ligand affinity chromatography (small to medium scale, very high resolution; high cost); or immobilized metal affinity chromatography (small to medium scale, very high resolution when His-tagged proteins are applied, medium cost); or covalent chromatography (small to medium scale, high resolution but restricted applicability, medium cost); or hydrophobic interaction chromatography (small to medium scale, low to medium resolution and restricted applicability, medium cost). E. Blue native electrophoresis (small scale, high resolution, yields highly pure proteins, such as those used for generating antibodies and for protein sequencing, less suitable for enzymatic studies); or native isoelectric focusing (small scale, high resolution, yields highly pure proteins, such as for crystallization); or gel filtration (small to medium scale, low resolution, suitable for enzymatic studies); or density gradient centrifugation (small to medium scale, low resolution; suitable for enzymatic studies). Notes: An exchange of buffer by gel filtration may be necessary for transition from step to step—for example, before anion-exchange chromatography or isoelectric focusing. Hydroxylapatite and anion-exchange chromatography have similar separation properties, so consecutive application of these techniques theoretically may not markedly improve protein enrichment. Nevertheless, combining these large-scale, low-cost methods often proves useful. Direct application of ligand affinity chromatography or another highresolution technique may allow a one-step purification after solubilization. A less costly approach, however, is usually used first to remove contaminants such as lipids and DNA, which helps to avoid damaging the expensive columns. Blue native PAGE, an economical and easy-to-use high-resolution technique, can be employed both for final purification and for single-step protein purification directly after solubilization (see Chapter 5). In the end, high-cost
Gebhard von Jagow et al.
methods may be less expensive than low- or medium-cost procedures if the number of purification steps is reduced and losses in yield and catalytic activity are avoided.
IV. CHOICE OF PROTEIN SOURCE, DISRUPTION OF CELLS, AND PREPARATION OF ORGANELLES AND MEMBRANES Membrane proteins can be prepared from a variety of sources, such as animal cells, plant cells, fungi (yeast), and bacteria. (Methods for optimization of starting materials for preparation of organelles from eukaryotes and for preparation of membrane extracts are described extensively in Guide to Protein Purification, a volume of Methods in Enzymology; see References.) For production and purification of recombinant membrane proteins, see Chapter 3. For affinity-epitope tagging of G-protein coupled receptors, see Chapter 9. Bacterial membrane protein complexes (e.g., the respiratory chain complexes) are simpler in polypeptide composition than the eukaryotic counterparts while performing essentially the same function. Many proteins have been overexpressed in bacteria by the introduction of suitable plasmids containing genes encoding the target proteins. Animal cells are easily obtainable in large quantities from slaughterhouses. Animal cells can be broken easily with a mixer or blender. Unicellular organisms like yeast or bacteria have much more robust cell walls, so cell disruption is more difficult. The following techniques can be used to break down cell walls. Glass bead milling involves agitating the cells together with fine glass beads (e.g.. Bead Beater from Biospec, Bartlesville, OK, or Dyno-Mill from Bachofen Basel, Switzerland), which destroys the cell walls via abrasion. Homogenization requires a cell suspension to be forced through a narrow valve under high pressure. The rapid pressure drop effectively breaks the cells. On a small scale, one can use a French press cell (SLM Aminco makes one), but large-scale preparation requires the use of a homogenizer (e.g., an APV Gaulin mill). Grinding mills, as described by Weiss et al. (1979), very effectively break filamentous fungi (such as Neurospora crassa). Ultrasonication will break the cells of some microorganisms effectively, although care must be taken not to damage the proteins. Osmotic shock can be used to break cells with less robust walls (e.g., animal and plant cells and some gram-negative bacteria).
CHAPTER 1 Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins
7
Repeated freezing and thawing will break the membrane in some cells. However, some proteins are cold-sensitive, and membrane protein complexes may dissociate. Enzymatic lysis. Lysozyme, which catalyzes hydrolysis of j5-l,4-glycosidic bonds, is often used to break open gram-positive bacteria. Zymolyase another polysaccharide hydrolase (produced by Kirin Brewery, Japan, and distributed in the United States by ICN) catalyzes partial breakdown of yeast cell walls. This mild procedure allows isolation of intact organelles. Note: Homogenizers and ultrasonication devices can cause significant heating of the sample, as can heavy agitation (glass bead mills). Sufficient cooling must be provided in these cases. Once the cells are broken, cellular fractions and organelles are generally isolated by differential centrifugation. In many cases, additional purification by sucrose density gradients or silica-sol gradients (e.g., FicoU and PercoU) is necessary to remove contaminating material.
V. PROTEIN ASSAY To monitor the purification at different steps, it is essential to measure a specific protein property (often the catalytic activity of an enzyme is involved) and the total protein concentration at each step. Ideally, if the protein is stable, this will immediately reveal whether a specific procedure has improved the purity of the protein.
A. Catalytic Activity and Other Specific Properties Protein properties suitable for following the purification are (1) catalytic activity, (2) spectroscopically detectable prosthetic groups, (3) specific binding of labeled ligands, and (4) binding of antibodies, directed against the entire protein complex or against individual subunits, after SDS-PAGE (Western blot). Any protein-specific assay may suffer from the problem of protein instability even if one follows precautions for handling membrane proteins. Enzymatic activity may decrease during isolation, prosthetic groups and labeled ligands may dissociate, antibodies may detect a dissociated subunit rather than the holoprotein complex, and characteristic polypeptide patterns observed in gel electrophoresis may disappear. Enzyme assay. Enzymatic assays are highly sensitive and rapid. Typically, subpicomole amounts of enzyme provide sufficient signals in optical assays. Sometimes enzymatic activity is lost during isolation, implying that the enzyme has been denatured. However, the inactivation may be
Gebhard von Jagow et al.
due to a loss of essential coenzymes or associated lipids, so it is reversible if the components are replenished during the assay. An easy way to supply lipid is to add lipid-saturated detergent micelles, as described in Chapter 8. In some cases (e.g., if the assay requires measurement of substrate transport across membranes by carrier proteins), more time-consuming reconstitution into proteoliposomes will be required (Kagawa and Racker, 1971). If catalytic activity using hydrophobic physiological substrates is not restored by replacement of components, it may be advisable to use more hydrophilic artificial substrates. Spectrophotometry. Spectroscopic assays are convenient for proteins that contain prosthetic groups. Although less sensitive than enzymatic assays, the spectroscopic approach offers the advantages of ease and speed. Colored proteins, such as hemoproteins, can be readily identified and monitored during chromatography. Unfavorable conditions often are detected in early stages by changes in extinction coefficients and shifts in absorption maxima. Differentiation of hemoproteins by optical difference spectroscopy requires only nanomole amounts of protein. Other groups, such as iron-sulfur clusters or tyrosine radicals, can be detected by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. Flavins become fluorescent after denaturation at acidic pH. Ligand binding. Binding of specific fluorescent or radioactive ligands or inhibitors is especially useful for observing transport proteins that do not contain prosthetic groups. Antibody analysis. Binding of antibodies to the desired protein permits sensitive and highly specific detection. Often the antibodies have to be raised against one known protein component of a less well-characterized complex or against a short protein sequence stretch that was synthesized according to the DNA sequence (peptide antibody).
B. Determination of Total Protein Ultraviolet spectrophotometry at 280 nm. This method is fast and nondestructive, but it is not very specific. The absorbance of a protein solution varies with the tryptophan content of the protein, but for a 1 m g / m l solution it is usually about 1.0. UV spectroscopy is also sensitive to interference from other absorbing components (buffer, nucleotides, etc.). Biuret methods. The Biuret assay, developed by Itzhaki and Gill (1964), involves formation, under alkaline conditions, of a complex with copper(II) bound to the peptide nitrogens. The main disadavantage is the rather low sensitivity ( ^ 1 mg/ml).
CHAPTER 1 Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins
9
Lowry method. The modification of the original method (Lowry et ah, 1951) by Helenius and Simons (1972) involves the addition of SDS to prevent precipitation of Triton X-100, a detergent often used in membrane protein isolation. In this approach, the copper complex formed under alkaline conditions is used catalytically to reduce phosphomolybdotungstate to heteropolymolybdenum blue (Folin-Ciocalteau reagent). This reaction makes the technique approximately 10-fold more sensitive than the Biuret method. However, it is more sensitive to the amino acid composition of the protein and the lipid content of the sample compared to the Biuret method, and 50% deviations from the real protein concentration are often observed. BCA method. Smith ei ah (1985) improved the Lowry method by substituting bicinchoninic acid (BCA) for the Folin-Ciocalteau reagent. The assay is less sensitive to buffer components and detergents. A microassay has been developed with 10- to 100-fold better resolution than the Lowry test. However, the reaction is very temperature sensitive and must be performed in a water bath under thermostatted conditions. Bradford method. Bradford (1976) used the binding of dyes, such as Coomassie Brilliant Blue G-250, to proteins to estimate protein concentration. This approach is about as sensitive as the Lowry method and as easy to perform. However, it is sensitive to the amino acid composition of the protein. More importantly for membrane proteins, the assay may be biased by the presence of detergent. This can be a major problem when the detergent concentration cannot be determined and corrected (e.g., during gel filtration, where detergent peaks elute according to micellar size).
VI. SOLUBILIZATION AND STABILIZATION OF MEMBRANE PROTEINS A. Choice of Buffer The buffer pH has an important role during protein isolation. The appropriate pH is essential for protein stability and solubility, and it also affects binding and elution properties of many protein separation media. Most useful are the zwitterionic biological buffers developed by Good and Izawa (1972). However, other buffers like phosphate and Tris are also frequently used. Special requirements with individual separation techniques are discussed in Chapters 8 to 11. Detailed information on the properties of buffers for pH values in the 1.5-13 range, along with their effects on protein assays, can be found in Deutscher, 1990. These are the important criteria for selecting a buffer.
10
Gebhard von Jagow et al.
1. The pK of the buffer should be within ±0.5 unit of the desired pH. 2. Potential interactions (beneficial or harmful) with a column matrix must be considered. 3. Whether the buffer is involved with activation or inactivation of enzymes is crucial (metal-dependent enzymes may be deactivated by metal complexing buffers). 4. UV-absorbing buffers should be avoided if a UV detector is to be used. 5. Cost should be considered if scaling up the preparation is desired. The ionic strength is another parameter affecting the solubility of membrane proteins in the presence of detergents. It is a rather freely adjustable parameter, in contrast to pH, which must be chosen according to the stability properties of the protein. The effect of ionic strength on protein solubility is discussed in more detail in Chapter 2.
B. Choice of Detergent Membrane proteins require detergents for extraction from membranes and for solubilization. Detergents are amphiphiUc molecules that form micelles in water. They solubUize proteins by binding to the hydrophobic parts of the proteins on one side and interacting with the aqueous phase on the other side. Properties and uses of detergents in biology and biochemistry have been reviewed (Deutscher, 1990; Neugebauer, 1988). For a detailed discussion of detergents, especially of those used in membrane protein crystallization, see Chapter 7. Detergents may be classified with respect to their hydrophobic and hydrophilic portions. 1. Classification According to Hydrophilic Portion The hydrophilic structures in detergents can be nonionic, anionic, cationic, or zwitterionic (see Table I). Nonionic detergents include the detergents used most often in membrane protein purification, the polyoxyethylene and sugar detergents. Polyoxyethylene detergents contain a polymeric (O—CH2—CH2)„-OH chain of variable length that is neutral at usual pH values and is compatible with all separation techniques. The species with HLB (hydrophilic-lipophilic balance) values ranging from 12 to 14.5 (Table I) are useful for extraction of integral membrane proteins. Those with higher HLB values are "milder" but usually will extract only peripheral membrane proteins. In later stages of purification they may be able to keep integral proteins in the solubilized state. These are fortuitous cases because these detergents barely affect protein-bound lipid, and catalytic activity is well retained.
11
CHAPTER 1 Purification 1Strategies for Membrane Proteins
TABLE 1
Common Detergents''
Detergent
Type
M,
CMC (mM)
N N N N N N N N
540 553 583 1200 625 537 1228 1310
N N N N N N N N N N N
n
HLB
<0.1 -0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.3 0.35 0.06 0.01
120
13.1 13.0 13.6 16.9 13.5 12.4 16.7 15.0
292 320 308 483 511 538 496 524 333 348 878
15 -2 4-9 -0.2 -0.2 0.012 2.5 0.3 -15 -5 3.4
30-100
Z Z Z Z (Z)
615 631 336 364 229
3-10 4-8 3.6 0.33 -1
4-14
-
399 415 538 522
-10 -2 <10 -2
2-5 -10 4 >6
— +
288 365
<10 1.0
60-100 170
Cloud point (°C)
Polyoxyethylene detergents ^12^8
Genapol X-080 (i-CigEg) C12E9 (Thesit) Brij 35 (C12E23) Triton X-100 {i-Cs(l)BgJ Triton X-114 (/-Cg^Ev.s) Tween 20 Tween 80 Glycoside detergents Octyglucoside Decylglucoside Octylthioglucoside Decyl-jS-D-maltoside Dodecyl-j5-D-maltoside Tetradecyl-j5-D-maltoside n-Decylsucrose w-Dodecylsucrose Nonanoyl-N-methylglucamide Decanoyl-N-methylglucamide BigCHAP Zwitterionic detergents CHAPS CHAPSO Sulfobetain SB 3-12 Sulfobetain SB 3-14 LDAO [C12—N+(CH3)2—0-] Bile salts Cholate (Na"', p H > 8) Deoxycholate (Na"^, p H > 8) Taurocholate (Na"^, p H > 8) Taurodeoxycholate (Na^) Ionic detergents SOS CTAB IC16—N^(CH3)3]
120 40 140
58
75 79 65 22
98 98
10
55 83 76
"Type: +, positively charged; —, negatively charged; Z, zwitterionic; N, neutral. M^, Relative molecular mass of monomer; n, aggregation number; HLB, hydrophilic-lipophilic balance.
Sugar detergents have the hydrophobic part linked through a glycosidic bond to a carbohydrate moiety (glucoside, maltside, or other saccharide). All sugar detergents given in Table I can be used for extraction of integral membrane proteins. In some instances, the use of "mild" sugar detergents increases the chance that membrane proteins may be isolated in active form (compared with other detergents, polyoxyethylene
12
Gebhard von Jagow et ah
detergents included). It is often assumed that the mildest detergents are the most expensive, but this is not always the case. Low-cost detergents such as Triton X-100 are mild. Successful isolation of membrane proteins depends on a variety of factors in addition to the detergent used. The neutral detergent BigCHAP has structural similarity to the zwitterionic detergents CHAPS and CHAPSO, and to the anionic bile salts, but it does not contain charged groups. Ionic detergents are thought to be more denaturing than ionic ones, probably because there are two clearly denaturing representatives of this group: the anionic detergent SDS (sodium dodecyl sulfate) and the cationic detergent CTAB (cetyltrimethylammonium bromide). However, this notion is not generally correct. The first preparations of mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes, for example, use the anionic detergents cholate and deoxycholate (see Hatefi, 1978), and the measured specific catalytic activities have not been surpassed by newer isolation procedures using polyoxyethylene and sugar detergents. The essential point again is that appropriate handling during purification can prevent delipidation and maintain protein integrity. Anionic detergents contain carboxylate, sulfate, or sulfonate groups. Carboxylates are useful only in the pH range where they are deprotonated. The use of cholate and deoxycholate (carboxylate) requires solubilization at a pH around 8 and the use of Li"^ or Na^ instead of K"^. This avoids formation of gellike structures. Other members of the group of bile salts (taurocholate and taurodeoxycholate, sulfonates) tolerate lower pH. Zwitterionic detergents contain both a positive and a negative group. LDAO (lauryl dimethylammoiumoxide) is not a true member of this group. Above
pH 7 it has positive and negative charges located on adjacent atoms, and at low pH it is positively charged. 2. Classification According to Hydrophobic Portion
The hydrophobic moiety can be classified with respect to size and flexibility. Most flexible are linear hydrocarbons of different chain length (usually 8-16). In a series of detergents with linear alkyl chains, the species with longer hydrophobic chains usually will have a greater tendency to act as denaturing agents. Less flexible are branched hydrocarbons and aromatic (Triton series) and aliphatic (Tween series) ring systems. Most rigid are the steroid rings of bile salts such as CHAPS, CHAPSO, and BigCHAP. 3. Critical Micellar Concentration The physical properties of detergent solutions can be described by several characteristics, the most important being the critical micellar concentration (CMC), because CMC values can be used to choose the optimal (minimal)
CHAPTER 1 Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins
13
detergent concentration. (Note: From a practical point of view the CMC defines the minimal concentration of free detergent that must be present in washing and elution buffers to keep membrane proteins in solution). The CMC values given in Table I are approximate, since the CMC varies with buffer conditions. It is advisable to test at least 2-fold higher detergent concentrations and either to evaluate the limits empirically or to determine the actual CMC value as described by Chattopadhyay and London (1984). The CMC value also determines whether a detergent can be effectively removed by dialysis. For example, both the size of the Triton X-100 micelle (Mr 90,000) and the low concentration of the monomers (0.3 mM or 0.015%) will exclude effective passage through dialysis membranes. Like other chemical compounds, detergent monomers are soluble in water u p to a certain concentration—that is, u p to the CMC. When the solubility of the detergent in water is exceeded, the insoluble component forms micelles. The CMC is determined mainly by the nature and structure of the detergent. The CMC of a homologous series of detergents with different alkyl chain length (/) follows this equation. log(CMC) =
K-kl
For the alkylglucosides, for example, the values are as follows. Chain length (/) CMC(mM)
8 10 12 14 16 23.2 2.19 0.19 0.017 0.0015 (fco = 2.56;fc= 0.523)
Other factors affecting the CMC are temperature and ionic strength. The CMC increases with increasing temperature, particularly for nonionic detergents, and decreases with increasing ionic strength, particularly for ionic detergents (leading to salting out). The CMC is also influenced by the pH value and by the composition of buffer, in particular by the presence of diand trivalent ions. a. Determination
of CMC
The CMC under the conditions used for protein purification can be easily determined by the dye solubilization method. A simple procedure using the fluorescent dye diphenylhexatriene has been described by Chattopadhyay and London (1984) (also see Fig. 1). h. Critical Micellar Temperature and Cloud Point Micelle formation occurs only above a critical temperature—the critical micellar temperature (CMT). Polyoxyethylene detergents undergo phase separation at a characteristic temperature above the CMT; this temperature is called the cloud point. Although the cloud point of most detergents is too high to be useful, Triton X-114 has a cloud point at 22°C. Therefore, it requires cold
14
Gebhard von Jagow et al. 10^ CPS 15
lOi
51
0.1
FIGURE 1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7 mM LM
Determination of CMC of laurylmaltoside (LM) according to Chattopadhyay and London (1984). Fourteen different dilutions of LM (between 50 and 750 iJiM) in measuring buffer (100 mM NaCl, 20 mM MOPS, pH 7.2) were prepared. To 0.5 ml of each was added 0.5 ^1 of a 10 mM solution of diphenylhexatriene (DPH) in THF, and the mixture was incubated for 30 min at room temperature in the dark. The DPH fluorescence (CPS, counts per second, arbitrary units) was n\easured in 0.5 x 0.5 cm cuvettes at an excitation wavelength of 358 nm and an emission wavelength of 430 nm. The CMC is read at the intercept of the lines through the data points below and above the CMC.
room temperatures to remain in solution. When a Triton X-114 solution is w^armed above 22°C, a detergent-rich phase that contains the membrane protein fraction separates. This technique is used for preparation of native membrane proteins but also for separation of hydrophilic and hydrophobic protein subunits dissociated from multisubunit complexes (see Chapter 2, Section II,B,1). c. Size of Detergent
Micelles
The size of the detergent micelles can be described by the aggregation number, n, which gives the average number of monomers in a micelle. Whereas the aggregation number is a well-defined property for most deter-
CHAPTER 1 Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins
15
gents, the aggregation number (and thus the size of the detergent micelles of steroid detergents) varies with the detergent concentration. Large micelle size will impede separation from the protein by gel filtration, although there are many other useful techniques for detergent removal (see Chapter 2, Section III,C). d, Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance Technical detergents have been ascribed an HLB value. This value ranges from 1 (very hydrophobic) to approximately 20 (very hydrophilic). Useful ranges for membrane protein extraction are HLB values of 12-14.5 for integral membrane proteins and at least 14.5 for peripheral membrane proteins. 4. Criteria for Selecting Detergents a. Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance Values As a general rule, the probability of denaturation increases with decreasing HLB values approching 12. However, HLB values may not be available for all detergents. b. Test for Retention of Structural and Functional Properties The effects of detergents on the desired protein must be checked in a series of small-scale solubilization experiments at different detergent concentrations and buffer compositions. c. Solubilization Efficiency The quantitative analysis of enzymatic activity in the series of preliminary solubilization experiments is best performed before ultracentrifugation and in the supernatant after ultracentrifugation. This will establish whether the protein is present in a dissolved state, although the presence of protein in a heterogeneous, oligodisperse state is not excluded. d. Detergent Compatibility The detergent must be suitable for the temperature, ionic strength, and pH conditions of the desired purification procedure. Reduced Triton X-100 with low UV absorbance at 280 nm (such as Sigma's) may precipitate in the cold. Bile salts (carboxylates) may form gellike structures at low temperatures, especially below pH 8 and in the presence of potassium. e. Effect of Charge Charged detergents may conflict with one or more steps in the purification process (ion-exchange or hydroxylapatite chromatography, chromatofocusing, isoelectric focusing, etc.).
16
Gebhard von Jagow et al.
f. Interference of Aromatic Detergents with Optical Detection of Proteins Detergents containing aromatic ring systems (e.g., the Triton series) have considerable absorbance at 280 nm. This may prevent monitoring of protein elution projfiles as well as hamper detection of the presence of protein by tryptophan fluorescence measurements. g. Other Criteria Other criteria include the size of the micelles (large micelles affect gel filtration more than small ones do), the CMC value (large values allow easy removal by dialysis and gel filtration), and known incompatibilities of the detergent with certain enzymes (e.g. glucosidases). Some detergent preparations contain highly reactive oxidizing impurities that must be removed prior to use (Ashani and Catravas, 1980).
C. Protein Stability and Protease Inhibition 1. General Stability Factors Temperature is one of the most important factors for protein stability. At early stages of a purification protocol it is generally advisable to work at cold room temperature (4°C), since this will minimize proteolysis. Some proteins can be transferred to room temperature (20°C) during later purification steps, whereas other proteins will be more stable at 4°C. Some proteins, however, may even be cold-sensitive, since hydrophobic interactions are weaker at low temperature. Another factor determining stability is pH. Most proteins prefer approximately neutral pH (6-8), whereas others tolerate a greater pH range (5-9). The pH-dependent denaturation may be a problem if pH changes are necessary for elution. However, this is not necessarily a hindrance with isoelectric focusing and chromatofocusing if the protein is stable in the pH range around its pi. In isoelectric focusing the protein can be applied to appropriate areas of a pH gradient gel, and in chromatofocusing the protein remains at a pH that is close to its pi. An increase in ionic strength usually promotes solubilization (salting in) but may favor dissociation of protein subunits. Because the detergent concentration can be reduced by increasing the ionic strength, the stabilizing and destabilizing effects may be balanced. Salting out conditions are generally stabilizing. Addition of sucrose (^250 mM) or glycerol may reduce the amount of detergent needed for solubilization, thereby providing a stabilizing effect. Sucrose and glycerol also stabilize proteins during freezing and help prevent dissociation of multiprotein complexes.
CHAPTER 1 Purification Strategies for Membrane Proteins
17
2. Special Stability Factors a. Stability in the Oxidized or Reduced State A number of proteins are unstable under aerobic conditions, and many redox enzymes are more stable in the reduced state. Exclusion of oxygen during preparation can be rather tedious. Fortunately, in many cases, adding a reducing agent—for example, 2 mM dithionite, DTT, or DTE — to the buffers will suffice. h. Stabilization by Inhibitors The binding of strong inhibitors often increases the stability of protein structures. In many cases, this stabilizing effect has been valuable for membrane protein isolation (see, for example, Riccio et aL, 1975; von Jagow ef ah, 1977). 3. Protease Inhibition Proteolysis is a major problem encountered during the purification of membrane proteins. Most proteases belong either to the serine protease or to the metalloprotease groups. Here are some brief descriptions of protease inhibitors used in the author's laboratory. Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA). To inactivate metalloproteases, most buffers contain some EDTA (0.5 to 5 mM). However, this may also inactivate metal-dependent enzymes. EDTA is removed by hydroxylapatite and may also bind to other chromatography media (e.g., anion exchangers). Diisopropyl fluorophosphate (DFP). The most effective inhibitor of serine proteases is DFP. It is related to chemical warfare agents and is infamous for its high toxicity. Special care must be taken in handling DFP (a gas mask is required). DFP is rapidly destroyed under alkaline conditions. Phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (PMSF). PMSF is a less effective serine protease inhibitor, but it is easier to handle. It also inhibits cysteine proteases. PMSF must be kept as a stock solution in dry alcohols or, as in our laboratory, in DMSO (0.5 M). It is described as an "irreversible" inhibitor, but its effect can be reversed by thiol reagents. In practice, it must be added to the protein before solubilization by detergent. It also must be added (at ^0.2 mM) to the buffers used in protein preparation. PMSF is added shortly before use because it is unstable in water (the half-life is about 100 min). A further disadvantage is the insolubility in water, although higher concentrations can be added to solutions containing the initial detergent-solubilized membranes. In some cases
18
Gebhard von Jagow et al.
it is necessary to add more PMSF to the protein samples before SDS-PAGE because some proteases are highly activated for a short period of time after addition of SDS before they are finally denatured. Calbiochem has introduced 4-(2-aminoethyl)benzenesulfonyl fluoride as a water-soluble, less toxic substitute for PMSF. 6-Aminohexanoic acid. This compound, also called 6-aminocaproic acid, is also an inhibitor of serine proteases. It is commonly used at a concentration of 2 to 5 mM. In blue native electrophoresis (Chapter 5), 6-aminocaproic acid is present at 500 mM as a dielectric compound supporting the solubilizing efficiency of neutral detergents. In electroblotting of SDS-denatured proteins (Chapter 4, Section VI), it is used as the trailing ion (at 300 mM) in the cathode buffer because of its low electrophoretic mobility at pH 8.3.
REFERENCES Ashani, Y., and Catravas, G. N. (1980). Highly reactive impurities in Triton X-114 and Brij 35: Partial characterization and removal. Anal. Biochem. 109, 55-62. Bradford, M. M. (1976). A rapid and sensitive method for the quantitation of proteins utilizing the principle of protein-dye binding. Anal. Biochem. 72, 248-254. Chattopadhyay, A., and London, E. (1984). Fluorometric determination of critical micelle concentration avoiding interference from detergent charge. Anal. Biochem. 139, 408-412. Deutscher, M. P. (ed.) (1990). "Methods in Enzymology,'' Vol. 182 (Guide to Protein Purification). Academic Press, New York. Good, N. E., and Izawa, S. (1972). Hydrogen ion buffers. In "Methods in Enzymolog/' (A. San Pietro, ed.). Vol. 24., pp. 53-68. Academic Press, New York. Hatefi, Y. (1978). Introduction—Preparation and properties of the enzymes and enzyme complexes of the mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation system. In "Methods in Enzymology" (S. Fleischer and L. Packer, eds.). Vol. 53, pp. 3-4. Academic Press, New York. Helenius, A., and Simons, K. (1972). The binding of detergents to lipophilic and hydrophilic proteins. /. Biol. Chem. 247, 3656-3661. Itzhaki, R. P., and Gill, D. M. (1964). A micro-Biuret method for estimating proteins. Anal. Biochem. 9, 401-410. Kagawa, Y., and Racker, E. (1971). Protein measurement with the folin phenol reagent, /. Biol. Chem. 246, 5477-5487. Lowry, O. H., Rosebrough, N. ]., Farr, A. L., and Randall, R. J. (1951). Protein measurement with the folin phenol reagent. /. Biol. Chem. 193, 265-275. Neugebauer, J. (1988). "A Guide to the Properties and Uses of Detergents in Biology and Biochemistry." Calbiochem-Novabiochem Corporation, San Diego, California. Riccio, P., Aquila, H., and Klingenberg, M. (1975). Purification of the carboxyatractylate binding protein from mitochondria. FEBS Lett. 56,133-138. Smith, P. K., Krohn, R. I., Hermanson, G. T., Mallia, A. K., Gartner, F. H., Provenzano, M. D., Fujimoto, E. K., Goeke, N. M., Olson, B. J., and Klenk, D. C. (1985). Measurement of protein using bicinchoninic acid. Anal. Biochem. 150, 76-85. Von Jagow, G., Schagger, H., Riccio, P., Klingenberg, M., and Koib, H. J. (1977). hc^ Complex from beef heart: Hydrod)mamic properties of the complex prepared by a refined hydroxylapatite chromatography in Triton X-100. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 462, 549-558. Weiss, H., von Jagow, G., Klingenberg, M., and Biicher, Th. (1970). Characterization of Neurospora crassa mitochondria prepared with a grind mill. Eur. J. Biochem. 14, 75-82.
2
Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification HERMANN SCHAGGER Zentrum der Biologischen Chemie Universitatsklinikum Frankfurt 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany
I. INTRODUCTION Differential extraction and precipitation of proteins according to their solubility properties constitute the first step in many isolation protocols for membrane proteins. Protein enrichment by these easily performed initial steps is essential for several reasons: (1) early removal of contaminants facilitates large-scale purification, which would otherwise be restricted by the limited capacity for protein of the separation media used in later steps; (2) the spectrum of useful separation techniques is narrow, and protein isolation attempts might end with only partially purified proteins; and (3) even if there are adequate purification techniques available, membrane protein stability is a limiting factor, and the purification protocols is improved if short times and few delipidating purification steps are involved.
Membrane Protein Purification and Crystallization 2/e: A Practical Guide. Copjnight 2003, Elsevier Science (USA) All rights of reproduction in any fonn reserved.
19
20
Hermann Schagger
11. SOLUBILIZATION-PRECIPITATION A. Differential Extraction Differential extraction is described here by using bovine heart mitochondria as an example. About 30% of all mitochondrial proteins are water-soluble proteins, and about 70% are membrane proteins. Water-soluble proteins are obtained by breaking the mitochondria without detergent and then removing of the mitochondrial membranes by ultracentrifugation. Mitochondria are easily broken by, for example, sonication for short times at low power. Membrane proteins can be obtained from the sediment by choosing the appropriate detergent concentration. The solubilization is influenced by factors such as pH, protein concentration, ionic strength, and the presence or absence of sucrose. The effects of these factors were studied by quantifying the levels of complexes II, III, and IV of bovine heart mitochondria in the supernatant after ultracentrifugation. Note: The results obtained with mitochondria concerning the ionic strength dependence of membrane protein solubilization are not directly transferable to bacterial systems. Bacterial membranes are usually effectively solubilized by neutral detergents even at a very low ionic strength. These differences are thought to be due to the different lipid compositions of the membranes, and they are due to the existence of supercomplexes — that is, the physiological associations of complexes I, III, and IV to form a "respirasome" (see Schagger and Pfeiffer, 2000, and Chapter 5). 1. Protocol for Differential Extraction Using Triton X-100 Differential extraction by dodecylmaltoside is very similar, but less detergent is necessary (0.6-0.8 times the gram amount of Triton). a, Preextraction If a new membrane system is being studied, perform preextraction (removal of water-soluble and some easily extractable membrane proteins) first in small-scale experiments. 1. Suspend membranes at twice the desired final protein concentration in water—for example, at 40 mg/ml for the experiment corresponding to Fig. 1. 2. Transfer several identical aliquots (for example, 0.5 ml) to 1 ml tubes. 3. Add 250 fA of a 4-fold concentrated solubilization buffer (e.g., 6% Triton, 80 mM MOPS, pH 7.2) that contains all components except one (NaCl in this case) and mix. 4. Add appropriate different volumes of NaCl (4 M) to the samples. 5. Add water to a final volume of 1 ml for each sample and mix.
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
21
100
< <
Z
cr
LU Q. CO
LU I-
o
a:
Q.
0.5
1,0 NaCI (M)
FIGURE 1
Preextraction at variable ionic strength. Several small aliquots of mitochondria were solubilized as described in the text at a protein concentration of 20 mg/ml in the presence of 1.5% Triton X-100, 20 mM MOPS, pH 7.2, at variable NaCl concentrations. After ultracentrifugation (100,000 g, for 45 min) the percentages of extracted total protein and of complexes II, III, and IV in the supernatant were determined. The boxed area shows the range of NaCl concentration that provides the best reproducibility.
6. Remove part of the sample, for enzymatic or other assay. 7. Centrifuge at 100,000 x g for 45 min. 8. Analyze the protein before centrifugation and in the supernatant after centrifugation As shown in Fig. 1 only 30% of the total mitochondrial protein was extracted at 100 mM NaCl. Despite the presence of 1.5% Triton, these are mainly the water-soluble proteins, but 40% of complex II, one representative of the easily extractable membrane proteins, were also solubilized. Efficient solubilization of such easily extractable membrane proteins, leading to a 20% increase in total protein extracted, was achieved by increasing the NaCl concentration to 600 mM. As solubilization of complexes III and IV began at 700 mM NaCl, it was best to use 600 mM NaCl (at 1.5% Triton and 20 m g / m l protein concentration) for selective solubilization of complex II. However, this is not the most selective preextraction procedure. Improved differentiation of complexes II and III/IV was achieved at lower ionic strength
1 2 3 % TRITON X-100
FIGURE 2
2
3
4
% TRITON X-100
Preextraction at variable Triton concentration. Mitochondria were solubilized at a protein concentration of 20 mg/ml in the presence of (A) 600 mM NaCl, 20 mM MOPS, pH 7.2, or (B) 200 mM NaCl, 20 mM MOPS, pH 7.2, at variable Triton concentrations. The boxed areas show the ranges of Triton concentration for best reproducibility. The symbols used are identical to those of Fig. 1: A denotes total protein; • , complex II; O/ complex III; and • , complex IV.
but increased Triton concentration (Fig. 2). The optimal Triton concentration for preextraction of 40-50% of total protein v^ith low loss of complexes III/IV w^as determined at two NaCl concentrations. At 600 mM NaCl (Fig. 2A), 1.5% Triton X-100 was necessary, whereas 2-2.5% was best at 200 mM NaCl (Fig. 2B). Preextraction at 200 mM NaCl was less sensitive to modest changes in experimental conditions. Note: The required Triton level may be lowered by adding sucrose. In the presence of 300 mM sucrose, a one-third reduction in Triton concentration is possible, but differentiation between complexes II and III/IV is reduced. Enrichment of both complex II and complexes III/IV after preextraction is about 2-fold. Other detergents with HLB values above 14.5 (see Chapter 1, Table I) that are not capable of solubilizing integral membrane proteins, such as Brij 35 (polyoxyethylene laurylether), may nevertheless be useful for preextraction. However, mixing of detergents in the isolation protocol may reduce the reproducibility of the procedure.
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
b.
23
Solubilization
Preextracted mitochondria were used for differential solubilization of integral membrane proteins in the presence of Triton X-100. Preliminary solubilization experiments were performed analogous to the preextraction procedure described above. The best differentiation between complex III and complex IV was obtained at high ionic strength (1 M NaCl), at which a 4-fold enrichment of complex III compared to mitochondria was reached (Fig. 3A). However, this high ionic strength may lead to dissociation of labile subunits. Solubilization at lower ionic strength and in the presence of sucrose (Fig. 3C) was preferred to solubilization without sucrose (Fig. 3B) for isolation of complex III because of the lower detergent concentration required. Other neutral detergents with HLB values in the range 12-14.5 may allow a better differentiation between integral membrane proteins in special cases. Mild forms of anionic detergents, such as bile salts or CHAPS, are well suited for differential extraction. Protein extraction by anionic detergents is less
z < I< z a: LU Q.
D
00
Z LU I-
o
a: CL
1 2
3
4
TRITON X-100
FIGURE 3
Solubilization of integral membrane proteins starting from preextracted mitochondria. Solubilization was performed at a protein concentration of 15 mg/ml and variable Triton concentrations: (A) in the presence of 1 M NaCl, (B) in the presence of 0.5 M NaCl, or (C) in the presence of 0.5 M NaCl and 250 mM sucrose. The symbol O denotes complex III; # , complex IV. Arrows indicate the Triton concentration required for complete solubilization—namely, 3% in B (without sucrose) and 2% in C (with 0.25 M sucrose).
24
Hermann Schagger
influenced by ionic strength than that using neutral detergents because the proteins become negatively charged when detergent is bound. Note: Use the Li"^ or Na"^ forms of bile acids, such as cholic and deoxycholic acid, and choose a pH above 7.5, since at lower pH and low temperature bile salts usually form gellike structures in the presence of other cations. Advantages of bile salts. Differential precipitation by ammonium sulfate and ammonium acetate allow separation of all five multiprotein complexes of the mitochondrial system of oxidative phosphorylation (see Hatefi, 1978). Lipid removal was minimal compared to other preparation methods, and the danger of destroying catalytic activities was lowest. Disadvantages of bile salts. (1) The aggregation state of proteins dissolved by bile salts is not homogeneous. Mixed oligomeric states occur, and separation according to size is restricted. (2) Separation by intrinsic protein charge is, of course, not possible, and chromatography on hydroxylapatite or anion-exchanger resins is possible only after exchange of most of the anionic detergent for a neutral one.
B. Phase Separation and Differential Precipitation 1. Protocol Usfing Triton X-114/Elevated Temperature The separation of water-soluble proteins from other membrane proteins by phase separation using Triton X-114 at elevated temperature was first described by Bordier (1981). The technique has been reviewed by Pryde (1986). a. Solubilize biological membranes with Triton X-114 at 0-4°C. The solubilizing and denaturing powers of Triton X-114 (which has n = 78 polyoxyethylene groups; HLB 12.4) are somewhat higher than those of Triton X-100 (n = 9-10; HLB 13.5). b. Remove insoluble material by ultracentrifugation at 0-4°C. c. Layer the supernatant over a cushion of 0.25 M sucrose in a centrifuge tube, or add the solution directly to the tube and warm the sample to 30°C. d. Centrifuge the sample at 30°C at low speed (5 min, 2500 g). Watersoluble proteins are in the upper phase, and most membrane proteins are in the detergent-rich lower phase. Note: The cloud point depends on the Triton/protein and Triton/lipid ratios. The lower the ratios, the higher the temperature required. Triton X-114 is more aggressive than Triton X-100. This property may be used for disruption of purified membrane protein complexes and separation of hydrophobic from hydrophilic subunits (described by Payne and Trumpower, 1986).
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
25
2. Protocol Using Triton X-100/Ammonium Sulfate The separation of water-soluble proteins from membrane proteins by phase separation using Triton X-100 and ammonium sulfate as described below was used as the first step in preparation of complex II, an easily solubilizable membrane protein complex (H. Schagger, unpublished results). A 5-fold enrichment was obtained with mitochondria. a. Solubilize all proteins using Triton X-100, or, if easily extractable membrane proteins are of interest, use a preextraction protocol as described above. b. Add cold saturated ammonium sulfate solution slowly with stirring. At about 25% saturation the solution becomes turbid. Stop addition at a saturation of about 40%. c. Centrifuge for 10 min at 10,000 g. A layer of membrane proteins together with all detergent and lipid is then observed on top of the aqueous phase, which contains the water-soluble proteins. d. Prick the upper layer with a Pasteur pipette and separate the aqueous phase from the lipid/detergent phase by suction. e. Remove water-soluble proteins completely by redissolving the membrane protein layer in water (the volume can be smaller than the starting volume) and repeat steps b through d. Note: The degree of ammonium sulfate saturation influences the viscosity of the membrane protein layer. Brittle layers at high saturation are easier to handle. Compared with the Triton X-114 phase separation approach described above, the Triton X-100/ammonium sulfate approach works at low temperature and uses a less aggressive detergent. No protein denaturation was observed. The phase separation properties of several neutral and ionic detergents as a function of salt concentration, and their use for fractionation of membrane proteins, are described by Parish et al. (1986) and Fricke (1993). 3. Differential Precipitation Separation of individual membrane proteins can often be effectively achieved by differential precipitation following protein solubilization by bile salts, by gradually raising the ammonium sulfate or ammonium acetate concentration (see Hatefi, 1978; Deutscher, 1990). The formation of oligomeric structures of individual proteins or groups of proteins usually is detected by the appearance of a slight turbidity. In this case, the aggregated proteins are pelleted by ultracentrifugation and the differential precipitation process continued using the clear supernatant. Neutral detergents usually do not provide effective differentiation between integral membrane proteins in salting out procedures. Limited success
26
Hermann Schagger
has been obtained only after addition of bile salts to a minimal ratio of 1 g of bile salt per 5 g of neutral detergent (H. Schagger, unpublished results).
C. Centrifugation Ultracentrifugation of solubilized biological membranes (at 100,000 g, for 15-60 min) is an essential first step in any purification protocol. Among other things, it removes insoluble components that would impede further purification steps. However, separation of individual membrane proteins usually is performed using density gradients, such as a 10-30% sucrose density gradient, run in a vertical rotor to keep centrifugation times within a tolerable range. The resolving power of sucrose density gradient centrifugation is not very high. Better resolution is possible using gel filtration with choice of the optimal gel medium. Density gradient centrifugation preferentially is used as a final purification step. It separates different oligomeric states of a protein and/or removes contaminating small proteins or dissociated subunits from much larger complexes. There are several advantages of density gradient centrifugation compared to gel filtration: (1) dilution of proteins after centrifugation (about 2-fold) is much less than with gel filtration (up to 10-fold); (2) excess detergent and lipid do not migrate with the protein and thus are easily removed; (3) comparison of protein behavior (stability, solubility, oligomerization, etc.) under different conditions is facilitated because several samples can be analyzed in one centrifugation run.
III. CONCENTRATION OF SAMPLES, EXCHANGE OF BUFFER, AND EXCHANGE OF DETERGENT Sample concentration and/or exchange of buffer and detergent are intermediate steps that may be necessary before additional gel filtration or chromatography steps are used. The extent of sample concentration that is possible is often limited by the final detergent concentration, which should not exceed 5% if gel filtration or chromatography is the next step.
A. Sample Concentration 1. Ultrafiltration Perhaps the most popular method for sample concentration is ultrafiltration. Water and small molecules are driven through a narrow pore membrane either by low gas pressure in stirred cells or by centrifugal force. Choose the membrane according to the nominal cutoff value—that is, the minimal molecular mass of a protein that will be almost completely retained
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
27
by the membrane. The enrichment factor obtainable with membrane proteins usually is low, even if a cutoff value close to the molecular mass of the protein of interest is chosen. Partial removal of excess detergent micelles is possible with large membrane-protein complexes that allow use of membranes with cutoff values of at least 100 kDa. Ultrafiltration can also be used to remove salts from protein solutions (diafiltration). In diafiltration, protein concentration by ultrafiltration is followed by addition of water to adjust the salt concentration in the retentate and then a second ultrafiltration step. Note: Ultrafiltration in stirred cells may lead to partial oligomerization of membrane proteins. A homogeneous protein preparation is more likely to be achieved by ultrafiltration at low centrifugal force. A homogeneous protein solution can also be obtained in concentrated form in the eluate from solid supports (see Section III,C,1)2. Addition of Inert Dry Media Sample concentration can also be achieved through the addition of inert dry media such as Sephadex G-25. These substances absorb water, but even small membrane proteins will not enter the pores because of bound detergent. The approach is simple and fast. It has the disadvantage that removal of the gel by filtration is required; also, protein is partially lost between the residual gel particles. 3. Dialysis against Inert Dry Media An alternative technique involves placing the protein sample in a dialysis bag and then (a) covering the bag with dry Sephadex G-lOO and incubating until sufficient buffer has migrated out of the bag to leave the desired sample volume or (b) placing the bag into a solution of at least 20% PEG (usually PEG 20,000) and dialyzing until adequate volume reduction has occurred. Commercial devices (e.g., Minicon) for small volumes ( < 1 ml) are available from Amicon. 4. Lyophilization There are several reasons why lyophilization of partially purified membrane proteins is generally not advisable as an intermediate step in a purification procedure: (a) salts are not removed by lyophilization unless the buffer contains a volatile compound such as ammonium hydrogen carbonate; on resolubilization in a smaller volume the high salt concentration may then denature the sample, and (b) the catalytic activity of many detergentsolubilized membrane protein complexes is lost during the freezing step (crystallization of water within the complex can dissociate protein subunits).
28
Hermann Schagger
Addition of stabilizing compounds such as 250 mM sucrose or 10% glycerol is not useful if lyophilization is desired.
B. Exchange of Buffer Removal of salts and exchange of buffer is easily achieved by dialysis, by gel filtration, and, as decribed above, by diafiltration. We prefer gel filtration, say, on Sephadex G-25 columns. Gel filtration takes less time than dialysis, and salts are exchanged or removed completely provided that the applied volume does not exceed 10% of the column volume. Situations in which buffer exchanges are particularly important include (a) the complete removal of guanidinium or potassium before SDS-PAGE, which would precipitate SDS and SDS-associated proteins, and (b) the complete removal of phosphate before phospholipid determination. Gel filtration also allows for adjustment of the salt concentration to the desired value, which is critical for the application of proteins to ion exchangers.
C. Removal and Exchange of Detergent 1. Chromatography If the membrane proteins can be bound to solid supports—for example, to ion-exchange media or to hydroxylapatite—removal of excess detergent is easily accomplished. Excess neutral detergent will pass the column unbound. Delipidation can be avoided if the bound protein is eluted directly after binding to the column, without a washing step. Exchange of detergents works similarly. Detergent bound to the membrane proteins usually is replaced by other detergents present in the washing and elution buffers. There is no problem with those membrane proteins that are stable on delipidation, but many membrane proteins will irreversibly denature when washed at low detergent concentration (slightly above the CMC). Notes: Each chromatographic step removes lipid and may lead to a decrease of catalytic activity. Because protein concentrations in the eluate from a column are usually much higher than in the applied sample, the process of detergent exchange may also result in protein concentration. 2. Gel Filtration and Centrifugation Excess detergent is in principle easily removed from large membrane protein complexes (>200 kDa) by gel filtration. However, the removal of pure detergent micelles is usually not at issue but, rather, the removal of larger mixed detergent-lipid micelles (see also below). The exchange of detergents by gel filtration suffers from the same problems. If protein is applied with an excess of lipid-detergent micelles, only the first few fractions may show
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
29
complete detergent exchange. Sucrose density gradient centrifugation can alleviate these problems. Detergent and lipid-detergent micelles stay on top of the density gradient, while proteins are spun down. 3. Dialysis and Precipitation Detergents forming small micelles—for example, the bile salts — are removed effectively by dialysis because the micelles can pass dialysis membranes with cutoff values of about 20 kDa. Detergents forming large micelles can be removed by dialysis only if the CMC of the detergent is high—that is, if a relatively high concentration of the monomeric form is present. Thus, octylglucoside (high CMC) will be removable by dialysis, whereas Triton X-100 and dodecylmaltoside (low CMC) will not (see Chapter 1, Section VI,B). Precipitation of membrane proteins may occur either after removal of detergent or, despite the presence of nondialyzable detergent, at low ionic strength or at p H values close to the isoelectric point. If the p H is moderate, the precipitated membrane proteins will be in the native state. The proteins in these cases precipitate together with bound detergent; excess detergent is removed with the supernatant. The pellet can usually be redissolved after readjusting the pH and adding salt or by adding low amounts of the same or another detergent. Protein precipitation by the addition of PEG (usually PEG 4000 and PEG 6000) is commonly used for removal of excess detergent. 4. Detergent Adsorption to Hydrophobic Surfaces Adsorption of detergents to hydrophobic surfaces such as Amberlite XAD2 (Serva) or Bio-Beads SM2 (Bio-Rad) is useful especially at low detergent concentration. Adsorption may be done in either the batch or the column mode. Note: The amount of adsorbent needed has to be tested on a small scale because membrane proteins will also bind to the adsorbent if the detergent concentration is reduced too much. Protein bound to the hydrophobic surface is lost protein.
IV. CHROMATOGRAPHIC TECHNIQUES The development of a chromatographic procedure for isolation of membrane proteins is described here in detail with hydroxylapatite and Triton X-100. Protocols using other chromatographic media and detergents will differ in some details but will share common ground in matters concerning the best ways to retain the native state of the membrane proteins being purified.
30
Hermann Schagger
A. Hydroxylapatite Chromatography The Triton X-100/hydroxylapatite method is useful for large-scale as well as microscale preparations of membrane proteins, and works best with acidic proteins binding tightly to the Calcium lattice. Advantages include (1) the low cost of the detergent and of self-prepared hydroxylapatite and (2) the greater variability in choosing binding and elution conditions compared to ionexchange methods. Both the phosphate concentration and the general ionic strength influence binding and elution. Phosphate is used for preferential elution of acidic proteins and high ionic strength for preferential elution of basic proteins. (3) Proteins usually can be applied to hydroxylapatite in the presence of moderate salt concentrations—for example, 200 mM NaCl—and need not be desalted as is often required for ion-exchange chromatographies. (4) The Triton X-100/hydroxylapatite method is also useful for the dissociation of complexes by urea or guanidinium chloride and for the isolation of protein subunits (Schagger et ah, 1995). Triton X-100 is not a suitable detergent for crystallization. However, it is possible to replace Triton X-100 after the hydroxylapatite step by other detergents—for example, by dodecylmaltoside (Okun et ah, 2000). A direct combination of dodecylmaltoside and hydroxylapatite is possible, but this combination often is less effective and doubled phosphate concentrations compared to the elution conditions in the presence of Triton X-100 are required. Chromatography at room temperature might then be neccessary, since sodium phosphate precipitates at concentrations above 150 mM at 4°C. The Triton X-100/hydroxylapatite method was used for isolation of various respiratory chain complexes from bovine and yeast mitochondria (Schagger et ah, 1995; Geier et ah, 1992; Brandt et ah, 1989; Okun et ah, 2000). The use of Triton/hydroxylapatite for the lipid dependent deactivation/reactivation of bovine cytochrome bc^ complex (complex III) is exemplified in Chapter 8. 1. Preparation of Hydroxylapatite Preparation of hydroxylapatite essentially follows the procedure of Tiselius et al. (1956), as described by Bernardi (1971), but intermediate Brushite crystals are produced at elevated temperature (70-80°C). Stock solutions used are given in Table I. Hydroxylapatite crystals thus prepared are larger than commercial products and guarantee a higher flow rate with similar binding properties. Hydroxylapatite FPLC columns are commercially available, such as Macro-Prep^^ (BioRad; ceramic hydroxyapatite). a, Procedure for Large-Scale Preparation of
Hydroxylapatite
The following protocol yields 1.5-2 liters of packed hydroxylapatite. 1. Test 4 channels of a multichannel peristalic p u m p for equal flow rates. 2. Add 800 ml of 1 M NaCl to a 25 Uter stainless steel vessel (V2A steel).
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
TABLE I
31
Stock Solutions" Stock
Preparation
Amount needed
0.5MCaCl2-2H2O 0.5MNa2HPO4-2H2O* 1 M NaCl 0.5MNaH2PO4H2O 0.5 M Sodiun\ phosphate (pH 6.8) NaOH^
294 g / 4 liters 356 g / 4 liters 46.7 g/800 ml 69 g / 1 liter
2 x 4 liters 2 x 4 liters 800 ml 1 liter 1 liter
160 g/900 ml
900 ml
^ Analytical grade reagents are used. ''Na2HP04-2H20, which is difficult to dissolve, is added slowly with stirring to warm water. ''Add NaOH with stirring to 800 ml water in a plastic bottle. Cooling in an ice bath is recommended.
3.
4.
5.
6. 7.
8.
with a 3 cm wide opening in the lid) and install a stirrer equipped with large blades. Affix tubing for delivery of CaCl2 and Na2HP04 separately to the lid of the steel vessel to avoid crystallization at the end of the tubing. Agitate the NaCl solution and warm it to 70°C by using a 2000 W heating plate. Feed 2 x 4 liters each of CaCl2 and Na2HP04 solutions at an initial flow rate of 300 ml/hr per each of the 4 tubings into the stirred NaCl solution, and keep the temperature at 70-80°C. After 3 hr, increase the flow rate to 4 x 900 ml/hr. Stir at a rate sufficient to avoid sedimentaion of Brushite crystals. Switch off the heating plate and stirrer. Allow Brushite crystals to settle, remove the supernatant by suction, and wash the sediment with 10 liters of deionized water. Remove the wash water and keep the sediment overnight at room temperature. Next morning, add 10 liters of water, loosen Brushite crystals from the walls, stir, and add 900 ml NaOH solution. Heat the stirred suspension to 90°C within 45-60 min. Reduce the intensity of the heating plate and maintain the temperature at 95°C for 60 min. Turn off the heating plate first, and after 10 min (when the temperature is 85°C) turn off the stirrer. Let the hydroxylapatite completely settle and remove the hot alkaline supernatant. Add 10 liters of deionized water, stir to resuspend, and let settle for 5 min. The formation of a layer of hydroxylapatite is usually observed through the "foggy" supernatant. Remove the supernatant together with the "fines." Add 10 Uters of water and 200 ml of 0.5 M NaH2P04. Heat to 80°C with stirring. Let settle down completely and remove the supernatant.
32
Hermann Schagger
9. Repeat step 8. 10. Repeat step 8, but add 200 ml of 0.5 M sodium phosphate buffer adjusted to pH 6.8. 11. Suspend the hydroxylapatite in 10 mM sodium phosphate buffer and store at 4°C. Note: Column flow rates are best with freshly prepared hydroxylapatite (typically 2 column volumes/hr with a column length of 15 cm and a hydrostatic pressure of 1.5 m). After storage for one month at 4°C the flow rate may drop to one column volume/hr. b. Regeneration of Hydroxylapatite To remove tightly bound proteins from hydroxylapatite, use 0.5 column volume of 1% Triton X-100, 350 mM sodium phosphate, pH 7.2, and 1.5 column volumes of equilibration buffer at room temperature. (The composition of the equilibration buffer varies with the isolation procedure.) The reequilibrated column is then stored at 4°C. Flow rates usually are reduced. 2. General Considerations on Hydroxylapatite Chromatography a. Preparing Hydroxylapatite Columns After packing the column with hydroxylapatite, equilibrate with buffer by passing at least one column volume of phosphate buffer through the column. Because the binding properties of hydroxylapatite are largely independent of the phosphate concentration used for equilibration, preliminary tests of the column can be done with 10 mM phosphate. After binding and elution conditions for the protein of interest are established, the column is equilibrated with washing buffer containing detergent and NaCl plus phosphate. If it is necessary to promote adsorption of weakly binding proteins, use 10 mM MOPS, pH 7.2, in preparing the column. b. Differential Binding and Elution Proteins interact with hydroxylapatite in two different ways. Negative charges on the protein apparently interact preferentially with the Ca^^ surface of hydroxylapatite, whereas positive charges interact with the phosphate groups. As binding to the Ca^"^ surface is the predominant binding mode, hydroxylapatite chromatography has some charcteristics of an anion-exchange medium. The greater variability of hydroxylapatite compared to anion exchangers in terms of binding affinities of various proteins is due to the cation binding properties of the phosphate surface. Phosphate is the primary eluant for elution of acidic and neutral proteins. The interactions of acidic groups of the proteins with the Ca^"^ surface are
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
33
strongly influenced by anions with strong affinity for Ca^ "^ such as phosphate, sulfate, citrate, and EDTA. Phosphate is a preferred eluant because chelators like EDTA and citrate remove Ca^ "^ from the hydroxylapatite and gradually dissolve the column. The range of useful phosphate concentration is 10-500 mM at room temperature and 10-150 mM sodium phosphate or 10-200 mM potassium phosphate at 4-7°C. Note: In the case of mitochondria, it has been found that more than 50% of the total protein elutes from hydroxylapatite at 50 mM phosphate, and more than 70% at 85 mM phosphate. The tight binding of complex III, eluting at 150-200 mM phosphate, is very useful for its purification (Schagger et ah, 1986). About 10-20% of residual mitochondrial protein is found to elute at 300-350 mM phosphate. As expected, increasing the ionic strength of the buffer with salts like NaCl that do not interact with Ca^ "^ has much less effect on the Ca^ "^ protein interaction than does the Ca^^-specific phosphate. However, although high ionic strength alone is not sufficient for elution of acidic and neutral proteins, the phosphate concentration required for elution is reduced at elevated NaCl concentrations. Increasing the ionic strength also affects the interaction of proteins with the phosphate surface of hydroxylapatite. As basic groups of proteins are involved in this interaction, the elution of basic proteins is preferentially promoted. Example: Using a buffer containing 110 mM NaCl and 85 mM phosphate, neither complex III (pJ 5.3) nor cytochrome c (pi 10.7) were eluted from a hydroxylapatite column. At increased ionic strength (250 mM NaCl) and the same phosphate concentration, cytochrome c was eluted, while complex III remained bound. 3. Initial Steps in Purification of Membrane Proteins a. Suspend hydroxylapatite in a 2 to 3-fold volume of 10 mM phosphate, pH 7.0, and prepare seven small hydroxylapatite columns consisting of about 0.5 ml of hydroxylapatite in Pasteur pipettes plugged with small swabs of cotton wool. Note: Do not try to find out binding and elution conditions using a single hydroxylapatite column. Lipid-dependent proteins are usually completely inactivated when several washing and elution buffers are applied sequentially. b. Equilibrate the first column with 10 mM sodium phosphate, pH 7.0, 100-200 mM NaCl, 0.1-0.5% Triton X-100; equilibrate two additional columns with similar buffers containing more phosphate (50,100 mM). c. Apply protein samples (not more than 2 mg protein per ml of
34
Hermann Schagger
hydroxylapatite) to the columns. For the first column the sample should contain catalytically active protein from the supernatant after ultracentrifugation, at 100-200 mM NaCl and 10 mM phosphate. The phosphate concentrations in the samples to be applied to the other two columns have to be raised to 50 and 100 mM, respectively. d. Wash the columns with buffers containing the same salt and phosphate concentrations as used in the applied samples, but add 0.5% Triton X-100. e. Assay the eluates for specific activity. Do you find activity in all eluates or only in those containing the highest phosphate concentration? Note: It may be advantageous if the protein of interest does not bind to hydroxylapatite at 10 mM phosphate because most contaminating protein is retained on hydroxylapatite at low phosphate concentrations. Catalytic activity of proteins that are in the pass-through usually is fully retained because the proteins elute together with bound and free lipid. f. Determine the optimal phosphate concentration. If the protein does bind at a certain phosphate concentration, use a new column (No. 4) and try to find out the highest phosphate concentration that allows binding. g. Estimate the binding capacity using this highest phosphate concentration by loading larger sample volumes to a new column (No. 5). The protein load now can be as large as 10-20 mg per 1 ml hydroxylapatite. The catalytic activity in the eluate will sharply increase when the column is overloaded. Note: Application of a sample at the highest phosphate concentration that allows binding of the desired protein offers the following advantages: (1) Contaminations are effectively removed with the pass-through, and the protein load to the column therefore can be increased considerably. (2) Sample application in the presence of high phosphate serves as a first washing step in the presence of stabilizing lipid-saturated micelles — that is, essentially without delipidation. h. Test the optimal elution conditions. Columns No. 6 and 7 are loaded using the highest feasible phosphate concentration and a high protein load (but not overloaded), and washed using 0.5-2 column volumes of washing buffer (step d) before protein is eluted by the elution buffers (similar to the washing buffer, but the phosphate concentration is 50 or 100 mM higher). Note: After that step the procedure is ready for scaling up. Ideally only the width of the columns but not the height is increased for scaling up. If this is not practicable, the volume of the washing buffer, expressed as column volumes, often has to be reduced for larger preparations. The washing step is the most critical step because free detergent in the
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
35
buffer continuously delipidates the protein. Decreasing the Triton concentration from 0.5% to 0.05% is rarely possible, since contaminating membrane proteins are not sufficiently washed from the column despite use of an appropriate phosphate concentration. If this washing step denatures the protein of interest, switch to a batch procedure, making use of the phosphate concentration limits that were determined above. The detergent concentration in the elution buffer is less critical, because any lipid that might dissociate from the protein will elute together with the protein. However, this is only true if the protein is not retarded on the column and elutes with the first volume of elution buffer. For this reason an instant one-step elution by high phosphate is clearly preferred to a gradient elution. 4. Chromatography versus Batch Procedure The lipid dependence of catalytic activity and structural integrity of many membrane proteins needs a special strategy for membrane protein isolation as described above and in Chapter 1. The ideal purification would be a chromatographic step with the protein of interest obtained in the flowthrough while contaminants are removed by binding to a support. With detergent-labile proteins that bind to a support, the batch procedure is preferred for two reasons. First, batch procedures are usually faster than chromatography (this is a critical matter for membrane proteins not only because of protease activity but also because of the dissociation of labile protein subunits in the presence of detergents). Second, the presence of detergent in the wash buffer will also shift the detergent/phospholipid ratio in the batch procedure, but only once at each washing step, and sufficient lipid usually remains bound to the protein. However, in column chromatography, lipid-detergent micelles will be continuously removed by detergent in the washing solution, and a dangerous degree of delipidation may occur. The extent of delipidation can be reduced by adding lipid to the buffer — for example, with commercially available egg yolk phosphatidylcholine (prepare a 50 mM stock solution: 1 molecule of lipid dissolved by 3-6 molecules of detergent). With membrane proteins that are less sensitive to detergent levels, chromatography is preferred, since greater purity and higher yields are obtainable.
B. ION-EXCHANGE CHROMATOGRAPHY Ion-exchange chromatography is often the method of choice in isolation of water-soluble as well as membrane proteins for a number of reasons, (i) Chromatography media with considerably different binding properties are available at relatively low cost, (ii) High flow rates can often be attained, which allows for large-scale preparations, (iii) The mode of interaction of proteins with the chromatographic medium is well defined, and stable
36
Hermann Schagger
standard binding/elution conditions can be used, (iv) Any neutral detergent capable of solubilizing membrane proteins can be used for purification of membrane proteins by chromatography. 1. Ion-Exchange Media Anion and cation exchangers, based on a variety of matrices, specialized for different pH ranges, and differing in particle size, mechanical stability, flow rate, and loading capacity, are available from many companies (e.g., Pharmacia, Bio-Rad, Serva). These products differ by their functional groups that are attached to the matrices. Anion exchangers, for example, carry positive charges capable of reversibly binding negatively charged counterions. The counterion of the anion exchanger usually is a weakly binding one—for example, CI"—that can be replaced by anions with higher affinity, such as negatively charged amino acids on the protein surface. Based on differences in the functional groups, ion exchangers may be classified into strong and weak exchangers. Strong ion exchangers are fully ionized over the entire operating pH, whereas the degree of ionization of weak exchangers is pH dependent. Weakly binding anion exchangers usually carry diethylaminoethyl (DEAE) or aminoethyl groups, whereas strongly binding anion exchangers carry diethyl-2-hydroxypropylaminoethyl (QAE), triethylaminoethyl (TEAE), or trimethyl aminoethyl groups. Weakly binding cation exchangers may carry carboxyl (C) or carboxymethyl (CM) groups. Strong cation exchangers are characterized by sulfo, sulfomethyl, or sulfopropyl groups. Weak anion exchangers (DEAE- and CM-resins) have often been used for purification of membrane proteins, but strong ion exchangers designed for use in FPLC, such as Mono Q and Mono S (Pharmacia), now are commonly applied. 2. Protein Adsorption and Elution Increasing ionic strength reduces the degree of ionization both of the ion exchanger and of the protein; a lower effective binding affinity results. The effect varies with the counterion used. High-affinity counterions may be used with tightly binding proteins. High affinity Anion exchanger Cation exchanger
Low affinity
I" >N03" >H2P04 > C r >HC03" >CH3COO- > O H - > F Cs+ >Rb+ >K+ ^ N H 4 + >Na-' > H + >Li+
The affinity of proteins for the column phase can also be regulated by
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
37
adjusting the pH. The minimum buffering strength should be 10 mM at a pH differing not more than 0.3 pH units from the pK value. Low buffering strength cannot prevent p H changes that result from ionic strength changes in buffers and may lead to protein denaturation. The pH always should be adjusted at the temperature chosen for the chromatography (pH values measured at 4 and 25°C differ by 0.1-1 pH units for some buffers). Buffers used for anion-exchange chromatography are primarily cationic buffers—for example, Bistris (pK 6.5), imidazole (pK 7.0), triethanolamine {pK 7.8), Tris (pK 8.1), diethanolamine (pK 8.8), or ethanolamine {pK 9.5). Chloride is usually used as counterion. Buffers carrying carboxyl groups are also useful, since they have only small interactions with the solid support material. Buffers used for cation-exchange chromatography commonly are anionic buffers, such as acetate {pK 4.8), citrate (pK^ 3.1; pi
Stability
It is essential to determine the pH- and detergent-dependent solubility and stability of the protein of interest in the supernatant after centrifugation. Knowing the pH stability range is essential for retaining the native state of membrane proteins, but it has little influence on the choice of using either the cation- or the anion-exchange mode. In principle, both modes of interaction can be used because the surface charge of the protein can be positive or negative, depending on the pH. However, protein isoelectric points below 7 are rather common, and membrane protein stability usually is best around neutral pH. This favors the use of anion exchangers, especially of the DEAE-type, and working in the range pH 6-9. Weak cation exchangers would be excluded only if the pH optimum were below pH 6, since the functional groups of the support then would be neutralized; likewise, weak anion exchangers would be excluded only above pH 9. Strong cation and anion exchangers might be used even below pH 6 and above pH 9, although stronger elution conditions might be needed. b. Equilibrating Ion-Exchange Resins Prepare eight 1 ml ion-exchange columns, using a DEAE-type anion exchanger, packed into Pasteur pipettes plugged with small swabs of cotton wool. Equilibrate four of these columns with buffers at an appropriate pH for protein stability but at different ionic strengths (e.g., 0,50,100,200 mM NaCl). Note: Always be sure that the column is at equilibrium by measuring the pH of the eluate. Depending on the pH state of the column material, up to 10
38
Hermann Schagger
column volumes of equilibration buffer will be necessary to achieve the desired pH, especially when low buffer concentration (20-50 mM) is used. Expensive detergents are added to the buffer only after complete equilibration has been achieved, and a small volume thereof is applied to the column to prevent protein aggregation when the sample is run. c. Small-Scale Binding/Elution
Test
Note: As already described for chromatography of detergent-sensitive membrane proteins on hydroxylapatite, do not try to find out binding and elution conditions using a single column. Lipid-dependent proteins are usually completely inactivated when several washing and elution buffers are applied sequentially. 1. Solubilize protein preferentially at low ionic strength. Partition the supernatant after ultracentrifugation (2 mg protein each per 1 ml column), and adjust the different salt concentrations in the samples that were used for equilibrating the series of columns described above. 2. Apply the samples to the individual columns, and wash with buffers of the same salt concentrations to which detergent—say, 0.5% Triton—has been added. 3. Assay the eluates for specific activity. What was the highest NaCl concentration that allowed binding of the protein of interest? 4. Determine the optimal NaCl concentration. If the protein was bound in the presence of 200 mM NaCl, test for the highest NaCl concentration that still allows binding of the desired protein. 5. Estimate the binding capacity on column No. 6, using the highest NaCl concentration for loading of about 10-20 mg protein to the column. What is the percentage of retention of catalytic activity? How many fractions of the eluate contain protein but not significant amounts of catalytic activity? 6. Test the optimal elution conditions. Columns No. 7 and 8 (high protein load but not overloaded; highest feasible NaCl concentration) are washed according to step 2, using 0.5-2 column volumes of washing buffer, and the desired protein is eluted by a buffer with a 50 or 100 mM higher NaCl concentration. Note: Considerations about optimal retention of catalytic activity and for scaling u p are similar for ion-exchange and hydroxylapatite chromatograpy (see Section A).
C. Chromatofocusing Chromatofocusing is a high resolution column chromatography method that separates proteins according to isoelectric point (Giri, 1990). It combines
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
39
the high capacity of anion-exchange chromatography with the excellent resolution of isoelectric focusing techniques. Complications in chromatofocusing that arise with membrane proteins often involve protein aggregation and denaturation. Aggregation is favored by the fact that chromatofocusing requires working at low ionic strength and at pH values close to the isoelectric point of the protein throughout the protocol. The potential for denaturation is high for delipidation-sensitive proteins, because (i) the desired protein on the column will be exposed to several column volumes of eluting buffer with detergent, and (ii) a switch to a batch procedure similar to anion-exchange or hydroxylapatite chromatography is not possible without sacrificing the focusing and concentrating properties of the method. 1. Gel Media and Buffers Standard chromatofocusing media from Pharmacia are PBE 94 for the range pH 9-4 and PBE 118 for the range 11-8. This means that PBE 94 is used for proteins with isoelectric points between 4 and 9, whereas PBE 118 is used for more basic proteins. FPLC columns—for example. Mono P HR 5/5 and 5/20—for the range pH 9-4 are available. "Start" buffers are used for equilibration of the chromatofocusing medium to establish the high pH limit of the column. Start buffers usually are low concentration cationic buffers (see Table II). The choice of appropriate pH depends on the isoelectric point of the protein of interest. Proteins will bind to the column if their isoelectric points are lower than the pH of the column. "Elution" buffers contain a selected range of buffering constituents. Polybuffer 74, Polybuffer 96, and Pharmalyte pH 8-10.5 are characterized by a uniform buffering capacity over the specified pH range (pH 4-7, 6-9, and 8-10.5, respectively). The pH of Polybuffers 74 and 96 usually is adjusted by HCl to the desired lower pH limit. Acetate may be used for titration of Polybuffer 96. 2. Differential Binding and Elution The chromatofocusing media (polybuffer exchangers) are similar to the media used in anion-exchange chromatography. However, in contrast to anion exchangers, the charged groups have a wide range of pK values, which provide consistent buffering capacity across a broad pH range. Binding and elution of protein is dependent, of course, on pH, ionic strength, and temperature. However, because chromatofocusing is performed at a fixed temperature and the ionic strength is kept low and fairly constant, the only variable parameter is the change of pH during the chromatography. If protein aggregation occurs, the ionic strength may be increased (e.g., by adding NaCl up to 50 mM), with some loss of resolution.
40
Hermann Schagger
TABLE II
Buffers and Gels for Chromatofocusing in Different pH Ranges"^ Approximate volume (in column volumes)
pH range
Gel
Start buffer
Eluent
Dilution factor
Dead volume
Gradient Total volume volume
10.5-9^
PBE 118
—
—
—
—
—
10.5-8
PBE 112
1.5
11.5
13.0
PBE 118
1:45
2.0
11.5
13.5
9-8''
PBE 94
1:45
1.5
10.5
12.0
9-7
PBE 94
1:10
2.0
12.0
14.0
9-6
PBE 94
pH 8.0, Pharmalyte pH 8-10.5-HCl pH 7.0, Pharmalyte pH 8-10.5-HCl pH 8.0, Pharmalyte pH 8-10.5-HCl pH 7.0, Polybuffer 96HCl pH 6.0, Polybuffer 96-CH3COOH
1:45
10.5-7
1:10
1.5
10.5
12.0
8-7
PBE 94
1.5
9.0
10.5
PBE 94
1:13
3.0
9.0
12.0
8-5"
PBE 94
1:10
2.0
8.5
10.5
7-6
PBE 94
pH 7.0, Polybuffer 96HCl pH 6.0, Polybuffer 96-CH3COOH pH 5.0, 30% Polybuffer 96-CH3COOH + 70% Polybuffer 74-CH3COOH pH 6.0, Polybuffer 96-CH3COOH
1:13
8-6
pH 11, 25 mM triethylamine-HCl pH 11, 25 mM triethylamine-HCl pH 11, 25 mM triethylamine-HCl pH 9.4, 25 mM ethanolamine-HCl pH 9.4 25 mM ethanolamine-HCl pH 9.4, 25 mM ethanolamineCH3COOH pH 8.3, 25 mM Tris-HCl pH 8.3, 25 mM Tris-CHsCOOH pH 8.3, 25 mM Tris-CHaCOOH
1:13
3.0
7.0
10.0
7-5
PBE 94
pH 5.0, Polybuffer 74-HCl
1:8
2.5
11.5
14.0
7-4
PBE 94
pH 4.0, Polybuffer 74-HCl
1:8
2.5
11.5
14.0
6-5
PBE 94
pH 5.0, Polybuffer 74-HCl
1:10
2.0
8.0
10.0
6-4
PBE 94
pH 4.0, Polybuffer 74-HCl
1:8
2.0
7.0
9.0
5-4
PBE 94
pH 4.0, Polybuffer 74-HCl
1:10
3.0
9.0
12.0
pH 7.4, 25 mM imidazoleCH3COOH pH 7.4, 25 mM imidazole-HCl pH 7.4, 25 mM imidazole-HCl pH 6.2, 25 mM histidine-HCl pH 6.2, 25 mM histidine-HCl pH 5.5, 25 mM piperazine-HCl
"Reprinted from Chromatofocusing with Polybuffer'^ and PBE'™^ with permission from Pharmacia. '' Degas all buffers before use. ''Gradients ending at pH 9 are not recommended since 9 is above the pH of Pharmalyte pH 8-10.5. ''PBE 118 and Pharmalyte pH 8-10.5 also cover this range, as do PBE 94 and Polybuffer 96. "Mixing gives the best results. Polybuffer 74 works better than Polybuffer 96 when used alone. The figures given for gradient volume are approximate and will vary with the exact conditions chosen. The dilution factor given is not critical, and the best conditions will be found by experience.
In ion-exchange chromatography an external pH gradient formed by a gradient mixer may be used for protein desorption. As the pH changes in the mobile phase, proteins are partitioned into that phase and are eluted. In chromatofocusing, no preformed pH gradient is required. The pH gradient within the solid support is self-generating. If a buffer at one pH (e.g., the high
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
41
pH start buffer) is used to adjust the pH of the column and a second buffer (a low pH Polybuffer) is then applied, the functional groups of the support will be gradually titrated by the Polybuffer from the top of the column down to the bottom of the column. Proteins will desorb from those areas where the pH is reduced to a value close to the isoelectric point of the protein, and they will rebind to lower regions of the column material that are at higher pH. This continuous desorption and rebinding leads to the focusing and concentration of the protein within a narrow pH range. Chromatofocusing therefore separates proteins according to their isoelectric points: a protein will elute when the pH at the bottom of the column is close to its isoelectric point. At higher ionic strength, proteins will elute earlier than predicted from their isoelectric points. Formation of a linear pH gradient throughout the column is required for optimal resolution. This is achieved by use of gel media and elution buffers with a broad buffering range. 3. General Protocol for Chromatofocusing By way of example, consider a protein with an isoelectric point of 7.4. The special requirements for this protein are represented in brackets. It is likely that the best separation for this special case will be attained in the range 7-8. The isoelectric point(s) of the protein(s) of interest should roughly fall in the middle of the pH gradient. The limits of the self-developing pH gradient are set by the pH of the start buffer (step e) and that of the elution buffer (step h). a. Determine the isoelectric point (see Chapter 6) of the protein to be purified [in this example, pi = 7A]. b. Select an appropriate chromatofocusing medium, start buffer, and elution buffer [medium: PBE 94 is suitable for pi 7.4; start buffer: Tris-HCl is adjusted to pH 8.4 — that is, usually 0.4 pH units higher than the desired pH limit value; eluting buffer: Polybuffer 96 adjusted to pH 7 with HCl]. c. Degas all buffers to remove CO2. Bicarbonate ions cause fluctuations in the pH gradient that develops during step h. d. Pack the chromatofocusing medium into a suitable column. Long, thin columns with a bed height of 15-30 cm give best results. e. Equilibrate the column with a "high pH" start buffer [Tris-HCl, pH 8.4]. Use 10-15 column volumes; the column is determined to be equilibrated when the pH of the eluate equals the pH of the start buffer. f. Apply a small volume of eluting buffer to the column (0.5-1 column volume). This reduces pH fluctuations, so the proteins are never exposed to extremes of pH.
42
Hermann Schagger
g. Apply proteins at low ionic strength to the column, ideally in the elution or start buffer. Diluted protein may be used, but it is undesirable to apply a volume exceeding 50% of the column volume. Up to 10 mg protein per milliliter of column medium usually is appropriate. h. Wash the column with a "low pH" elution buffer [e.g., Polybuffer 96 adjusted to pH 7 with HClj. A narrow pH gradient (pH 7-8) is then generated within the column, and proteins elute in the order of decreasing isoelectric points. A total gradient volume corresponding to 10.5 column volumes will be required when using diluted Polybuffer 96 as suggested in Table II. [A protein with pJ 7.4 will therefore elute after application of about 5 column volumes.] Usually the pH range is chosen so that the protein of interest elutes after one-third to one-half of the gradient. Such large volumes may be detrimental for membrane proteins (see below). 4. Consideration of Membrane Protein Specialities Knowledge of the isoelectric point of the protein to be purified helps in selection of the appropriate chromatofocusing media and buffers. However, determination of the isoelectric point of membrane proteins by isolectric focusing often is impeded by protein aggregation (especially if the protein requires some ionic strength—say 50 mM NaCl—to be kept in solution). In those cases, the binding/elution behavior is studied by pilot experiments on a small scale. This also enables determination of an approximate value for the isoelectric point. a. Determining Approximate Isoelectric Point Pack five small PBE 94 columns, and equilibrate three columns over the ranges pH 7-4, 6-4, and 5-4 by washing with the start buffers (pH 7.4, 6.2, and 5.5) listed in Table II. Add small volumes of the appropriate elution buffer (diluted Polybuffer 74 adjusted to pH 4) to the column. Apply the sample (supernatant after ultracentrifugation; low ionic strength; 2-5 mg protein per ml of PBE 94) and elute with several column volumes of diluted Polybuffer 74 (see Table II). Most proteins will bind to at least one of the columns. If the protein of interest is in the flow-through, use PBE 94 columns again, but use start buffers at pH 9.4 and 8.3 and Polybuffer 96, adjusted to pH 6, as the eluent. The use of PBE 94 and the two Polybuffers covers the range 9-4 and is suitable for the large majority of proteins. Note: Because addition of detergent to the elution buffer is necessary (e.g., 0.05-0.5%), membrane proteins may be delipidated and denatured when several column volumes of elution buffer are applied before elution occurs. Catalytic activity, however, should at least be retained in those cases where the protein being isolated does not bind to the column—that is, when the pH
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
43
of the starting buffer is too "acidic." The pH that results in elution is close to the pi of the protein. Proteins in the flow-through are not concentrated, but the eluate may be applied to another column equilibrated with a starting buffer at higher pH. b. Adjusting Conditions for Optimal Chromatofocusing After the pilot experiments an approximate value of the isoelectric point is known, and it is possible to decide whether a switch to PBE 118 might be advantageous or if the pH limits should be changed in order to obtain a narrow, high-resolution pH gradient. If PBE 94 is the optimal medium, the lowest pH of the start buffer that led to binding of the protein is chosen for equilibration. Sample application in elution buffer is especially recommended for membrane proteins because this reduces the dead volume—that is, the volume of detergent-containing elution buffer that has to be applied before the pH in the eluent starts to decrease. Notes: To reduce the volume of elution buffer and the amount of detergent passing the bound protein, adjust the pH of the start buffer to the most acidic value that still allows binding of the protein of interest, and use more concentrated Polybuffers. Only the latter will impair the resolution. In case of aggregation of membrane proteins, it may be necessary to solubilize the protein in the presence of, for example, 50 mM NaCl and to adjust the start and elution buffers to the same ionic strength. This will cause proteins to elute earlier than expected from their isoelectric points and may lead to some loss of resolution.
D, Metal Chelate Chromatography Immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) was introduced by Porath et al. (1975). The separating principle is the variable affinity of different proteins for immobilized metal ions. This is a high-resolution method offering manifold applications, especially the purification of Histidine-tagged proteins (see Chapter 10). Special features of the method related to its applicability to membrane protein purification are as follows: (1) protein adsorption usually is performed in the range pH 6.0-8.5; (2) the separation is optimal in the presence of 0.1-1.0 M NaCl, which reduces the danger of aggregation of membrane proteins; (3) neutral detergents do not interfere with protein binding and elution; (4) the technique allows use of a wide variety of buffer compositions so that conditions can be optimized in terms of resolution and protein stability. For a recent example of isolation of a highly active 1000 kDa membrane multiprotein complex after His-tagging one of the 40 protein subunits, see also Kashani-Poor et al, 2001.
44
Hermann Schagger
1. Gel Media A standard medium from Pharmacia is Chelating Sepharose Fast Flow. For FPLC applications Chelating Superose columns (Pharmacia) are available. In both cases iminodiacetic acid is coupled to the gel matrix. Other commercially available chromatographic supports for IMAC include (i) immobilized iminodiacetic acid and immobilized tris(carboxymethyl)ethylenediamine coupled to different matrices from Pierce; (ii) iminodiacetic acid-agarose and iminodiacetic acid-epoxy-activated Sepharose 6B from Sigma; (iii) zinc chelate affinity adsorbent from Boehringer Mannheim; and (iv) TSKgel Chelate-5PW from Toyo Soda. These media are activated for protein binding by equilibration with buffers containing appropriate metal ions. The affinity of proteins for the column usually is highest after saturation with Cu^"^. Other ions are effective in the following descending order: Cu^"^ > Ni^"^ > Zn^"*^ > Co^"^ > Fe^"^ > Ca^"^. Ni^^ is commonly used for purification of Histidine-tagged proteins, while Fe^ "^ is preferentially used for purification of phosphoproteins because of its high affinity for phosphate groups. Ca^"^ will work only with proteins with high affinity to Ca^"^ itself. Unfortunately, it is difficult to predict which metal ion will prove most appropriate. Some proteins will bind only to Cu^"^. Others bind so strongly that difficulties with elution may occur, and thus use of the weaker binding Ni^"^ or Zn^"^ is advisable. Dilute protein solutions can be applied without loss of resolution. The affinity of individual proteins for the solid support depends on the number and accessibility of specific amino acid residues on the protein surface. The affinity of amino acids for the metal ions decreases in the order His > Trp > Cys > Tyr. 2. Differential Binding and Elution a. Column Preparation and Protein Binding 1. Cast a column, usually 10-30 cm in length, wash with 2 column volumes of distilled water, and then saturate the column with divalent metal ions (e.g., 0.1 M NiS04 dissoved in water; ^ 3 column volumes). 2. Wash the gel with 3-5 column volumes of water. 3. Equilibrate the gel with at least 2 column volumes of a start buffer, which ideally allows binding of the protein of interest, with weaker binding proteins being found in the flow-through. This is especially helpful for membrane proteins, since only small volumes of a washing buffer containing detergent have to be applied next, thus avoiding delipidation and denaturation. Commonly used start buffers are adjusted to the pH range 5.5-8.5—for example, 10-100 mM Sodium phosphate, 50-100 mM Sodium acetate.
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
45
or 25 mM Sodium borate. It is common to include salt 100-500 mM to eliminate any ion exchange effect and to improve solubility of the membrane protein. Add a neutral detergent when membrane proteins are involved—for example, 0.1% dedecylmaltoside or 0.05-0.1% Triton X-100 — and add the eluent ion (see below) at the highest concentration that still allows binding of the desired protein. This leads to flowthrough of all weaker binding proteins, and the protein load per milliliter of column material can be raised considerably. Protein load. By way of example, Kashani-Poor et al., 2001, could load 35 mg of a total mitochondrial extract per 1 ml of Chelating Sepharose Fast Flow medium after addition of 60 mM of the eluent imidazole to the start/equilibration buffer and to the protein sample. Almost all contaminating protein was in the flow-through. Essentially the total protein binding capacity of the column (about 4 mg/ml) was free for the desired protein (complex I), which was then eluted by raising the imidazole concentration in the elution buffer to 140 mM. Chelating agents such as EDTA or citrate should not be included in any buffer. 4. Washing buffer usually is identical to start/equilibration buffer. Elution is achieved by using competitive elution (see below), by reducing pH (most proteins elute between pH 6 and 4; sodium acetate, citrate, or phosphate can be used), or by adding chelating agents such as EDTA (50 mM), which will strip the metal ions from the gel together with the protein. This method does not resolve different proteins. 5. Elute the desired protein by using a modified washing buffer with increased concentration of the competitive eluent—for example, 140 mM imidazole if the imidazole concentration in the washing buffer was 60 mM. Commonly applied concentrations of competitive eluents are up to 500 mM imidazole, up to 50 mM histidine, or up to 2 M ammonium chloride.
E. Affinity and Dye-Ligand Chromatography Affinity chromatography, including chromatographic procedures that use highly specific ligands covalently linked to a solid matrix, is one of the most powerful techniques for isolation of proteins (Hermanson et ah, 1992; Jacoby, 1984; Deutscher, 1990). Despite this fact, single-step purifications using affinity chromatography are not common. Usually a low-cost technique is used first to avoid potential damage to the expensive affinity column. 1. Chromatography Media A wide spectrum of affinity columns having different immobilized groupspecific ligands may be purchased from various suppliers. Alternatively,
46
Hermann Schagger
specific column materials can be constructed, starting with commerially available nonactivated matrices containing spacer arms or with preactivated matrices ready for binding individual Ugands. Commercially available ligands covalently bound to matrices include (1) mono- and group-specific low molecular mass ligands—for example, steroids for purification of steroid receptors, biotin and avidin for biotin-binding and biotin-containing proteins, enzyme cofactors and analogs, vitamins, certain amino acids, "biomimetic dyes," and boronic acid derivatives; and (2) mono- and group-specific macromolecular ligands—for example, protein A and G for purification of immunoglobulins, monoclonal antibodies for purification of antigens, antigens for isolation of specific antibodies, lectins for purification of glycoproteins, and many more. Immobilized biomimetic dyes for dye-ligand chromatography are widely used not only for isolation of nucleotide-containing proteins but also for many other proteins (see Table III). However, the binding properties of a particular protein cannot be predicted. Kits for identification of suitable adsorbents are available from Sigma and Amicon. The more specific the ligand is to a particular procedure, the more likely it will not be commercially available and thus will need to be coupled to a preactivated support by the investigator (see Table IV). Small ligands usually require matrices with extended spacer arms to allow access of the protein. The protein-ligand interaction must be reversible under nondenaturing conditions; dissociation constants normally range from 10"''^ to 10"^ M. Detailed discussion of the properties of gel matrices, choice of spacer between gel matrix, and activation and coupling chemistry is beyond the scope of this book. For descriptions of these techniques, see, for example, Hermanson et al. (1992), as well as product information sheets of the suppliers.
TABLE III
Selected Immobilized Biomimetic Dyes and Boronic Acid Derivatives'"
Protein isolated
Product
Manufacturer/ supplier
Dehydrogenases (especially NAD^), kinases and phosphatases, other proteins, removal of albumin IgG from serum
Blue Sepharose C1-6B Affi-Gel Blue Gel Fractogel TSK AF-Blue DEAE Affi-Gel Blue Gel CM Affi-Gel Blue Gel Red Sepharose C1-6B Fractogel TSK AF-Red Affi-Gel 601 (phenyl boronate) Fractogel TSK AF-Phenylboronate
Pharmacia Bio-Rad Merck Bio-Rad Bio-Rad Pharmacia Merck Bio-Rad Merck
Dehydrogenases (NAD"^ and NADP"^), many other proteins Sugars, glycoproteins, nucleotides
"Blue and red gels usually contain Cibacron Blue F3G-A and Procion Red HE-3B dyes. These and many more immobilized dyes are available from many other suppliers. Reactive dye-ligand tests are available (e.g., from Sigma).
CHAPTER 2
TABLE IV
Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
47
Selection of Commercially Available Activated Matrices
Ligand(s) to be coupled -SH, —NH2, —OH Also from proteins, peptides, carbohydrates Primary amines and thiols, also from proteins -SH Low M^, thiols and proteins Thiol proteins -NH2 Proteins Proteins / peptides Primary amines (especially proteins) Primary amines (especially low M^)
Primary amines, amino acids, peptides
—CHO Aldehydes (also high M^) —COOH Amino acids, ketoacids, carboxylic acids
Product
Manufacturer/ supplier
Epoxy-activated Sepharose 6B Epoxy-activated Eupergit C Epoxy-activated Separon HEMA
Pharmacia Rohm Pharma Anachem/Tessek
Tresyl-activated Sepharose 4B Fractogel TSK AF-Epoxy 650 FMP-activated Avid gel
Pharmacia Merck BioProbe International
Thiopropyl Sepharose 6B Activated Thiol-Sepharose 45" Affi-Gel 501 (organomercurial support)
Pharmacia Pharmacia Bio-Rad
CNBr-activated Sepharose 4B Activated CH-Sepharose 4B Act-Ultrogel AcA 22/glutaraldehyde Affi-Gel and 15/N-hydroxysuccinimide Reacti-Gel (GX) / carbonyldiimidazole Reacti-Gel (HW-65F) / carbondiimidazole Reacti-Gel (25DF) / carbonyldiimidazole Reacti-Gel (GF-2000)/carbonyldiimidazole Fractogel TSK AF-CDI 650 CM BioGel A Fractogel TSK CM-650 CH-Sepharose 4B EHC-Sepharose 4B
Pharmacia Pharmacia IBF Bio-Rad Pierce Pierce Pierce Pierce Merck Bio-Rad Merck Pharmacia Pharmacia
Agarose-adipic acid hydrazide
Pharmacia
AH-Sepharose 4B EAH-Sepharose 4B Affi-Gel 102 Aminoethyl BioGel P-100 Fractogel TSK AF-Amino 650
Pharmacia Pharmacia Bio-Rad Bio-Rad Merck
'^ See also Section IV,F on covalent chromatography.
The choice of a preactivated matrix (Table IV) that allows coupling of the desired ligand at mild conditions is essential for pH-sensitive small ligands and for protein ligands that are more prone to denaturation. 2. Protein Adsorption and Elution The choice of adsorption and eluting conditions depends of the nature and strength of the ligand-protein interaction. Adsorption and desorption are
48
Hermann Schagger
influenced by ionic strength, pH, temperature, reducing or oxidizing conditions, and the presence or absence of competing ligands. Any of these factors may be altered to promote protein elution. For example, selective elution by competing ligands (nucleotides) has been used for purification of dehydrogenases bound to biomimetic dye-containing columns, and glycoproteins have been removed from lectin columns by sugars. For a recent purification of a membrane protein complex (chloroplast ATP synthase) by dye-ligand chromatography, see Seelert et al, 2000.
F. Covalent Chromatography In principle, any of several functional groups can be used for covalent attachment of proteins to solid supports. However, the harsh conditions necessary to then remove the protein from the column would likely destroy the protein. The only functional group on the protein that is useful for covalent attachment is the sulfhydryl group of cysteine, which reacts with disulfide groups of the support. The disulfide bond thus formed between protein and support is easily split by reducing agents. Before using this approach in a purification protocol, the stability should be tested in the presence of the desired reducing agent. Note: Covalent chromatography will be possible only if at least one—SH group is present on the protein surface and accessible to the support. 1. Thiol Gel Media Thiol Gel Media are available from several companies either in the activated disulfide form [e.g.. Activated Thiopropyl Sepharose 6B and Activated Thiol Sepharose 4B (Pharmacia)], or in the thiol form [e.g., cysteamine agarose, cysteine agarose, and glutathione agarose (Sigma) and N-acetylhomocysteine agarose (Bio-Rad)]. Supports are activated, or reactivated after use, by disulfides, such as 2,2'-dipyridyl disulfide. 2. Description of the Chromatographic Procedure a. Equilibrate the gel in start buffer without detergent (use neutral or slightly acidic pH; choose an ionic strength based on the conditions necessary for protein solubilization and include 1 mM EDTA to trap transition metal ions). Most proteins carrying thiol groups on the surface will bind at pH 8. Selective binding of proteins that have thiol groups with low pX is possible at lower pH (pH range 8-4). b. Pack the column and wash with start buffer containing detergent. c. Prepare homogeneously solubiUzed membrane proteins by methods described above (supernatant obtained after ultracentrifugation). Remove thiols such as glutathione by gel filtration, and apply the sample to the column.
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
49
d. Wash with start buffer in the presence of 0.05-0.5% detergent. The danger of membrane protein denaturation will increase with the volume of buffer used and with the concentration of detergent. In some cases, a batch procedure is advisable (see Section A,3)e. Elute with start buffer containing detergent and 5-25 mM L-cysteine, or 50 mM glutathione, or 20-50 mM dithiothreitol.
G. Hydrophobic Interaction Chromatography The difference between hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) and reversed phase chromatography (RFC) is related to the density of hydrophobic ligands on the surface of the adsorbents (Builder, 1993). The surface of RFC adsorbents can be regarded as a continuous hydrophobic phase; in HIC the hydrophobic Ugand density is much lower. The interaction of hydrophobic domains of proteins with the adsorbent therefore is much higher in RFC, and more drastic conditions for protein elution are required. This will often result in protein denaturation. RFC is especially useful for separation of membrane protein fragments. The various media used in HIC differ in ligand type and degree of substitution of the surface. HIC media are available from many suppliers; the particular material that will allow binding and elution of a given protein under mild conditions must be identified empirically. Froteins are adsorbed to hydrophobic matrices at salt concentrations that are high but below those required for protein precipitation. HIC therefore would be ideal following a salt precipitation step. Desorption usually is achieved by reducing the salt concentration. The strength of hydrophobic interaction also decreases with decreasing temperature and in general with increasing pH. Examples for sucessful application of HIC to membrane proteins are rare because detergents bind very strongly to the matrix. One example is the isolation of cytochrome F-450, described by Kastner and Neubert (1990). The essential steps in the procedure are as follows: (1) removal of most of the detergent by hydroxylapatite chromatography before the HIC step; (2) binding of proteins to Fhenyl-Sepharose or Octyl-Sepharose (Fharmacia) at high phosphate concentration; and (3) elution of proteins at reduced salt concentration and increased detergent concentration.
H. Gel Filtration Gel filtration media are porous beads into which sufficiently small molecules can penetrate. Larger molecules are excluded from the beads, and during gel filtration they pass through the column in the liquid phase (void volume) outside the beads and are therefore eluted earliest. From a practical point of view, the void volume is that volume of buffer that passes through
50
Hermann Schagger
the column first and cannot contain any protein regardless of protein size. Void volumes are typically about 20% of the total column volume. By way of example, consider a mixture of proteins of widely different sizes applied to a 100 ml column. The first 20 ml (void volume) will contain no protein. The next fractions will contain the largest proteins and also protein aggregates, except huge aggregates that cannot even pass between the gel particles in the liquid phase and that remain at the top of the column. Thereafter, proteins that can penetrate the gel beads (i.e., are in the separation range of the particular gel filtration medium being used) emerge from the column. The extent of penetration and retardation on the column depends on the size and shape of the protein. Except perhaps for proteins that have quite asymmetrical shapes, molecules are eluted in the order of decreasing size. 1. Separation Range in the Presence of Detergents The separation range of gel filtration media usually is specified for water-soluble proteins. The behavior of membrane proteins solubilized by detergents on gel filtration columns usually is completely different, owing to the effect of detergent binding to the proteins. Separation ranges of selected gel filtration media are compared in Table V for situations involving no detergent, Triton X-100, and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). 2. Gel Filtration for Separation of SDS-Denatured Proteins a. Concentrate the protein—for example, in the SpeedVac centrifuge or by lyophilization (after SDS-precipitating ions like potassium ions and salts in general have been removed by dialysis against water) — or precipitate the protein directly by adding an equal volume of acetone (first test a small aliquot to see if precipitation occurs), centrifuge, wash the pellet with a small volume of water to remove acetone, and centrifuge again. Note: If acetone precipitation works (the higher the protein concentration, the better) this method is preferred, since not only salt is removed with the supernatant but also detergent. b. Dissolve sedimented proteins to a maximal concentration of 10 m g / m l by incubating for 15-30 min at ^40°C in 5% SDS, 1% mercaptoethanol. Note: Do not heat the sample because many membrane proteins irreversibly aggregate at elevated temperature. c. Perform the gel filtration in the presence of 0.5% SDS at room temperature. The column should be at least 1 m long. The optimal sample volume to be applied is 1-2% of the column volume. Typical gel filtration columns for 5-20 kDa and 10-50 kDa proteins are Sephadex G-50 sf and Sephadex G-lOO, respectively. Sephadex G-50 sf: Proteins with molecular masses at or above 30 kDa will elute at the void volume together with aggregated proteins.
CHAPTER 2
TABLE V
51
Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
Separation Ranges of Selected Gel Filtration Media GeV
No detergent total range^ (kDa)
Sephadex G-50 sf Sephadex G-lOO Sephacryl S-200 Sephadex G-150 Sephadex G-200 Ultrogel AcA 34 Sephacryl S-300 Ultrogel AcA 22 Sepharose C1-6B
1.5-30 4-150 5-250 5-300 5-600 20-350 10-1500 100-1200 10-4000
Triton X-100 special range' (kDa)
SDS special range (kDa) 5-20 10-50
10-50^*
50-200"
200-1000
''Sephadex, Sepharose, and Sephacryl media are available from Pharmacia, Ultrogel AcA from IBF and Serva. The useful range of media from other manufacturers and suppliers (e.g., Merck and Bio-Rad) for separation of membrane proteins can be easily estimated by comparing the fractionation range for water-soluble proteins with those given above. '' The total range for separation of water-soluble proteins also seems valid for protein separation in the presence of SDS. ^ The special range refers to the molecular masses of the protein moiety, since the precise degree of Triton binding is rarely known. ''Considering bound Triton, the lower total mass in fact is 100 instead of 10 kDa, and the upper total mass is 150 instead of 50 kDa. " The narrow pore size distribution of Ultrogel AcA results in high resolution over the indicated special range.
Smaller proteins will be separated from one another if the differences in molecular mass are about 10 kDa. Sephadex G-lOO: Proteins larger than 70 kDa and aggregates will be in the void volume. Proteins smaller than 10 kDa will appear as extremely broad peaks. 3. Gel Filtration of Native Membrane Proteins The separation of native membrane proteins is impeded by protein-bound detergent that masks differences in molecular mass. The resolving power is low, even with the optimal gel filtration medium. It is mainly used as a final purification step to remove contaminating small proteins and excess detergent. Note: Gel filtration usually is performed at 4°C, using columns with a length of at least 1 m. The detergent concentration should be kept well above the critical micelle concentration [e.g., use 0.05% Triton (CMC 0.015% at salt concentrations typically used) or 0.1% dodecylmaltoside (CMC 0.01%)] to avoid oligomerization of membrane protein. The ionic strength of the buffer must be above the solubility limit of the protein of interest (usually 20-200
52
Hermann Schagger
mM NaCl). The volume of sample should not be larger than 1-3% of the column volume. Keep the detergent concentration of the sample below 5% and the protein concentration below 10 mg/ml. Regarding resolution limits, small membrane proteins (e.g., 10 kDa) usually elute with the detergent micelles of dodecylmaltoside or Triton X-100. The separation of a 40 kDa and a 10 kDa membrane protein in the presence of Triton is in fact a separation of 130 kDa and 100 kDa protein-detergent complexes (40 kDa plus 90 kDa of bound detegent versus 10 kDa plus 90 kDa). The best gel filtration medium for such separation problems is, theoretically, Sephadex G-200. However, this material is often difficult to work with. With some loss of resolution, other gel filtration columns can be used, such as Ultrogel AcA 34, Sephadex G-150, or Sephacryl S-300, each of which has its own separation characteristics (see Table V).
REFERENCES Bernardi, G. (1971). Chromatography of proteins on hydroxylapatite. In "Methods in Enzymolo g / ' (W. B. Jacoby, ed.). Vol. 22, pp. 325-339. Academic Press, New York. Bordier, C. (1981). Phase separation of integral membrane proteins in Triton X-114. /. Biol. Chem. 256,1604-1607. Brandt, U., Schagger, H., and von Jagow, G. (1989). Purification of cytochrome-c oxidase retaining its pulsed form. Eur. J. Biochem. 182, 705-711. Builder, S. E. (1993). "Hydrophobic Interaction Chromatography—Principles and Methods," Code No. 18-1030-90. Pharmacia. Deutscher, M. P. (ed.) (1990). "Methods in Enzymology," Vol. 182 (Guide to Protein Purification). Academic Press, New York. Fricke, B. (1993). Phase separation of nonionic detergents by salt addition and its application to membrane proteins. Anal. Biochem. 212,154-159. Geier, B. M., Schagger, H., Brandt, U., Colson, A.-M., and von Jagow, G. (1992). Point mutation in cytochrome b of yeast ubihydroquinone:cytochrome-c oxidoreductase causing m)ocothiazol resistance and facilitated dissociation of the iron-sulfur subunit. Eur. J. Biochem. 208,375-380. Giri, L. (1990). Chromatofocusing. In "Methods in Enzymology," Vol. 182 (M. P. Deutscher, ed.. Guide to Protein Purification), pp. 380-392. Academic Press, New York. Hatefi, Y. (1978). Introduction—Preparation and properties of the enzymes and enzyme complexes of the mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation system. In "Methods in Enzymology," (S. Fleischer and L. Packer, eds.). Vol. 53, pp. 3-4. Academic Press, New York. Hermanson, G. T., Mallia, A. K., and Smith, P. K. (1992). "Immobilized Affinity Ligand Techniques." Academic Press, New York. Jacoby, W. B. (ed.) (1984). "Methods in Enzymology," Vol. 104 (Enzyme Purification and Related Techniques, Part C). Academic Press, New York. Kashani-Poor, N., Kerscher, S., Zickermann, V., and Brandt, U. (2001). Efficient large scale purification of His-tagged proton-translocating NADH:ubiquinol oxidoreductase (complex I) from the strictly aerobic yeast Yarrowia lipolytica. Biochem. Biophys. Acta. 1504, 363-370. Kastner, M., and Neubert, D. (1990). Isolierung von Cytochrom P-450 aus Marmorset-Leber. In "Membranproteine," pp. 109-122. Pharmacia. Okun, J. G., Zickermann, V., Zwicker, K., Schagger, H., and Brandt, U. (2000). Binding of detergents and inhibitors to bovine complex I—A novel purification procedure of bovine complex I retaining full inhibitor sensitivity. Biochem. Biophys. Acta., in press.
CHAPTER 2 Techniques and Basic Operations in Membrane Protein Purification
53
Parish, C. R., Classon, B. J., Tsagaratos, J., Walker, I. D., Kirszbaum, L., and McKenzie, I. F. C. (1986). Fractionation of detergent lysates of cells by ammonium sulfate induced phase separation. Anal Biochem. 156, 495-502. Payne, W. E., and Trumpower, B. L. (1986). A simple, one-step purification for cytochrome h from the hc^ complexes of bacteria. In "Methods in Enzymology'' (S. Fleischer and B. Fleischer eds.). Vol. 126, pp. 325-331. Academic Press, New York. Porath, J., Carlsson, J., Olsson, I., and Belfrage, G. (1975). Metal chelate affinity chromatography, a new approach to protein purification. Nature (London) 258, 598-599. Pryde, J. B. (1986). Triton X-114: A detergent that has come in from the cold. Trends Biochem. Sci. 11,160-163. Schagger, H., Brandt, U., Gencic, S., and von Jagow, G. (1995). Ubiquinol-Cytochrome c reductase from human and bovine mitochondria. In "Methods in Enzymology" (G. M. Attardi and A. Chomyn, eds.). Vol. 260, pp. 82-96. Academic Press, New York. Schagger, H., Link, T. A., Engel, W. D., and von Jagow, G. (1986). Isolation of the eleven protein subunits of the hc^ complex from beef heart. In "Methods in Enzymology" (S. Fleischer and B. Fleischer, eds.). Vol. 126, pp. 224-237. Academic Press, New York. Schagger, H., and Pfeiffer, K. (2000). Supercomplexes in the respiratory chains of yeast and mammalian mitochondria. EMBO J. 19,1777-1783. Seelert, H., Poetsch, A., Rohlfs, M., and Dencher, N. A. (2000). Dye-ligand chromatographic purification of intact multisubunit membrane protein complexes: application to the chloroplast R-'-FoFi-ATP synthase. Biochem. J. 346, 41-44. Tiselius, A., Hjerten, S., and Levin, O. (1956). Protein chromatography on calcium phosphate column. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 65,132-155.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
3
Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins ETANA PAD AN Microbial and Molecular Ecology Institute of Life Sciences Hebrew University of Jerusalem 91904 Jerusalem, Israel
CAROLA HUNTE Molekulare Membranbiologie Max-Planck-Institut fur Biophysik 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany
HELMUT REILANDER Aventis Pharma, Industriepark Hoechst 65926 Frankfurt am Main, Germany
I. INTRODUCTION The investigation of membrane proteins has become an active area in biochemical and biomedical research. For many experimental approaches, large quantities as well as high concentration of protein are needed. Structural analysis by NMR or x-ray crystallography requires, for example, several milligrams of functional protein in concentrated solutions ('^0.25 mM). However, membrane proteins often exist in their native membranes at low abundance. NhaA, the sodium/proton antiporter of Escherichia coli, comprises for instance less than 0.2% of the total membrane proteins (Taglicht et ah, 1991). Therefore, strong overexpression is needed to attain a high cellular concentration of the protein of interest. While for many soluble proteins
Membrane Protein Purification and Crystallization 2/e: A Practical Guide. Copyright 2003, Elsevier Science (USA) All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
55
56
Etana Padan et al
suitable overexpression systems are used routinely, high-level production of membrane proteins is still challenging. Overexpression of both homologous as well as heterologous proteins is often deleterious to the membrane and thus to the growth of the host organism (Miroux and Walker, 1996). A variety of expression systems for membrane proteins in bacteria, as well as in eukaryotic cells, has been developed to overcome these difficulties. Crucial steps in the production of membrane-bound proteins are not restricted to transcription and translation but include the insertion into and the folding of the protein within the membrane. The latter processes are often the rate-limiting steps in production. If correct insertion and folding fail, large quantities of inactive and partly aggregated protein are produced and accumulate within the cell. Although membrane protein insertion and folding follows general principles (Popot, 1993; Popot et ah, 1994), differences in the mechanisms between the prokaryotic and the eukaryotic systems are evident (Dobberstein, 1994). The insertion of a prokaryotic membrane protein is a co-translational process (deGier and Lurirink, 2001). The co-translational insertion of a protein into the membrane involves the signal recognition particle and its receptor (MacFarlane and Mueller, 1995; Seluanov and Bibi, 1997). A membrane potential is needed for correct membrane protein insertion in E. coli, a requisite not known for eukaryotic systems (Bassilana and Gwidzek, 1996; Wickner and Lodish, 1985). To date it is assumed that eukaryotic membrane proteins are cotranslationally inserted into the ER membrane, where they subsequently fold into their final three-dimensional conformation (Borel and Simon, 1996; Do et ah, 1996; Wessel and Spiess, 1988). In many cases, this process is supported by specialized folding proteins, so-called chaperones, like the BiP ("heavy chain binding protein" a member of the Hsp 70-heat shock protein family), the disulfide-isomerase and/or calnexin (Bergeron et al,, 1994; Hartl et ah, 1994; Helenius et al., 1992). In general, molecular chaperones prevent false intraand/or intermolecular interactions during the complicated folding process of proteins (Bergeron et al, 1994; Hartl et al, 1994; Gething and Sambrook, 1992). In only a few cases, there is exact knowledge of when and/or which chaperones are needed for correct folding of membrane proteins. NinaA, which acts as a peptidyl prolyl cis/trans isomerase, has been found to be absolutely essential for production of functional rhodopsin 1 and 2 in the eye of Drosophila melanogaster (Baker et al, 1994; Ondek et al 1992). In the absence of the ninaA protein, the rhodopsins aggregate and accumulate in the ER (Baker et al, 1994). If such specialized chaperones are needed for the correct production and, in particular, for the correct folding of recombinant membrane proteins, heterologous production appears to be very difficult to achieve. Here, the coproduction of specific chaperones might be a solution, which could finally lead to the design of a specialized host cell system (Lenhard and Reilander, 1997).
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
57
Posttranslational modifications should be considered when producing a recombinant protein. Almost all eukaryotic membrane proteins that have been detected in the plasma membrane are glycosylated. Glycosylation of a protein might be important for its function and/or required for its correct folding, for the assembly of subunits, and also as a signal to guide the protein to the proper subcellular location (Geisow, 1992). Additional posttranslational modifications—for example, phosphorylation or palmitylation of receptors—are of functional importance. If posttranslational modifications are an absolute prerequisite for the proper function of a membrane protein, heterologous production can only take place in an expression system that is capable of performing these kind of modifications. Then, prokaryotic expression systems have to be excluded, and production of the respective protein has to be performed in an eukaryotic system (Geisse et ah, 1996). High-level production of active eukaryotic membrane proteins in E. coli, the most widely used bacteria, is still a challenge. This heterologous expression system often results in low yield, or the proteins tend to form insoluble inclusion bodies with inactive protein. Inclusion bodies also form during both homologous as well as heterologous overexpression of prokaryotic proteins in prokaryotic systems. Refolding of functional proteins from inclusion bodies has been described for very few membrane proteins (see Section II,C). In comparison to natural protein sources, expression systems for recombinant proteins offer an enormous potential for selective alteration of the protein structure to improve its properties for various aims. Removal of internal proteolysis or glycosylation sites will reduce heterogeneity of the product. Furthermore, protein or peptide fusions can be added to the protein of interest to facilitate its detection and purification. Expression constructs can be tailored to increase solubility, stability, and yield of the protein.
11. PROKARYOTIC EXPRESSION SYSTEMS FOR OVERPRODUCTION OF MEMBRANE PROTEINS FOR STRUCTURAL STUDIES Various strategies have been exploited in bacteria to achieve overexpression of membrane proteins: (1) use of strong promoters along with the proper transcription initiation and translation signals for overexpression; (2) exploitation of tightly regulated promoters to attain high biomass of bacteria before induction, followed by a limited induction time to obtain high amounts of the protein before the death of the bacteria; (3) use of leaky promoters without induction combined with low temperature to allow sufficient time for insertion and folding processes (Grisshammer and Tate, 1995); and (4) refolding proteins from inclusion bodies.
58
Etana Padan et ah
The advantages in bacterial expression systems are as follows. 1. Bacterial protein expression is cheaper and faster than eukaryotic systems. 2. Overexpression is obtained without any posttranslational modification that can introduce heterogeneity, potentially harmful for crystallization. However, for proteins that require posttranslational modifications for proper folding and activity, eukaryotic expression systems are needed (see Section III). 3. Escherichia coli is the most frequently used bacteria for protein production due to its highly developed molecular genetics. Furthermore, advancing the understanding of the fundamental aspects of E. coli physiology—that is, protein folding, protein excretion, transcription, and translation—will continue to fuel progress in optimizing this organism for protein expression. This section is limited to expression systems developed in £. coli.
A, E. coli Inducible Promoters Used for Overexpression Plasmid-based inducible promoter systems have been constructed in E. coli using bacterial, phage, and chimeric promoters (Table I). One of the most widely used expression systems in E. coli is based on the T7 RNA polymerase (Studier et ah, 1990). The coding sequence of the enzyme is cloned into the E. coli chromosome downstream of an inducible promoter—for example, the IPTG inducible lac promoter from the excision-deficient A-lysogen DE3 (often used is the UV5 lac promoter that is insensitive to catabolite repression, [see Grossman et ah, 1998)]. The target gene is introduced into this bacteria on a plasmid positioned downstream to the T7 promoter. Therefore, target gene expression via the T7 RNA polymerase is inducible by IPTG. Other variations on this theme exist (for examples see Table I and Durbin, 1999). A thorough study of overexpression of several membrane proteins using this system and the E. coli strain BL21 (DE3) showed cell-toxicity caused by overexpression (Miroux and Walker, 1996). Mutants, C41 (DE3), C43 (DE3), surviving the toxicity were selected and shown to overproduce the proteins without toxic effect. Although neither the mechanism of toxicity nor the relevant mutations are known, the mutations are claimed to reside in the T7 RNA polymerase and to balance its activity with respect to translation. The procedure used for selection of these mutants could be employed to tailor expression hosts in order to overcome toxic effect caused by the T7 RNA polymerase based overexpression systems. The RNA polymerase of phage T7 is inhibited by the phage lysozyme (review by Durbin, 1999). Therefore, cotransformation of cells with one plasmid encoding lysozyme (pLysS and pLysE) and a second plasmid encoding the target protein has been advocated to suppress basal expression toxicity.
CHAPTER 3
TABLE I
Controlled Expression Syst ems Used in E. coli
Promoter used f or^ overexpression of the target gene cloned on plasmid
Regulatory manifold^
Induction
Level
Ref.
JpjQd
Very high XlOO
[1]
Temperature shift to 42°C
Moderately high
PL(^)
T7 RNA polymerase expressed from the lac promoter or derivatives in the presence of lacl^ (overexpressed repressor) The PL promoter in the presence of a)cV'S57 temperature sensitive repression The proU promoter Mutated 77 RNA polymerase in strain BL21 (DE3)'^; balancing transcription translation Lad, lacl^ repression (/l)cP^857 repression
araBAD
AraC repressor
Temperature shift to 42°C L-arabinose
tet
Tet repressor
Anhydrotetracycline
17 RNA polymerase
lac, tac, trc
59
Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
NaCl IPTG
[2] [3]
IPTG
Moderately high Moderately high Fine-tuning (but see (5) and below) Very high
[4]
[5] [6]
''In addition to the promoter, other regulatory signals can be manipulated; DNA sequences important for transcription a n d / o r translation. ''Can be on the chromosome or plasmid. ^The site of the mutation has not yet been proven. The strains were successfully used to overexpress membrane proteins (Besette et ah, 1999; Miroux and Walker, 1996). '^IPTG, isopropyl jS-D-thiogalactoside. [1] For review, see Stevens, 2000; [2] Bhandri and Gowri-shankar, 1997; [3] Mulroony and Washell, 2000; Fiermont et al, 2001; [4] Brosius, 1999; [5] Guzman et a/., 1995; [6] Lutz and Bujard, 1997.
Various derivatives of the lac promoters are used for overexpression in addition to the native lacV (Table I). These are hybrids constructed from the — 35 consensus sequence of the trp promoter and the —10 of the lacV spaced by 16 bp in the case of tacV or by 17 bp in the case of trcV, Expression plasmid systems based on the lac promoter are notoriously leaky. Repression is often incomplete due to a combination of plasmid copy number effects and the absence of secondary operators required for the full range of gene control in
60
Etana Padan et al.
the natural lac operon (review by Durbin, 1999). This problem is often overcome by the use of overexpressed repressor LacI^ or Lacl^l and/or the addition of an operator. Background expression levels should be lower in systems based on positive rather than negative control of expression. Recently, expression plasmids based on the araBAD promoter (FaraSAD) have been constructed (Guzman et al, 1995). Because the ara system can be induced by arabinose and is repressed by either catabolite repression in the presence of glucose or competitive binding of the anti-inducer fucose, these plasmids have very low background levels of expression. In addition, gene expression can be turned on and off rapidly by changing the sugars in the medium. Ideally, one would like to be able to modulate the level of gene expression. Guzman et al. (1995) presented evidence that the pBAD vectors are suitable to express at intermediate levels. However, intermediate levels of gene expression in cultures do not always mean that gene expression is uniform with respect to individual cells. In extreme cases, either every cell in the culture makes the same percentage of the fully induced level, which is observed in the culture, or the culture consists of a mixture of fully induced and completely noninduced cells. In the latter case, the intermediate expression levels observed in the culture reflect the proportion of cells that are fully induced, rather than intermediate expression in any individual cell. The latter alternative was found correct using Aequorea victoria green fluorescent protein (GFP) as a reporter (Siegele and Hu, 1997). Expression in cultures grown at low concentrations of arabinose is bimodal, consistent with an autocatalytic mechanism for induction of transcription of ParaSAD due to active uptake of the inducer. This phenomenon is analogous to the autocatalytic induction of the lac operon (Novick and Weiner, 1957). Expression from the lac promoter can be modulated using different concentrations of the membrane-permeable inducer IPTG in a lacY~ strain, where in the absence of an inducible transport system the level of expression in individual cells in the population is relatively homogeneous. Plasmids with promoters controlled by lac repressor have been used to modulate expression of genes over a 20- to 250-fold range (Hashemzadeh-Bonehi et al., 1998; Malony and Rotman, 1973; Prinz et al., 1997). The importance of performing such experiments with other systems should be emphasized. A recent review (Baneyx, 1999) describes the potential use for protein overexpression of other E. coli promoters, upstream and downstream sequences involved in transcription or translation, and the recent advancements in manipulating the copy number of the target gene (Baneyx, 1999).
B. Optimizing Expression Levels in E. coli Having a good nontoxic expression plasmid does not automatically guarantee that the protein is produced in large quantities. To achieve this goal
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins TABLE II
61
E, coli Genotypes Relevant for Overexpression Relevant genotype
Relevant phenotype
endA Ion ompT argJJ ileY leuU proL extra copies of genes encoding tRNAs frequently limiting translation trxB, gor
Endonucleasel" Lon cytoplasmic protease" OmpT outer membrane protease" ArgU^, IleU"^, leuU"^, for AT-rich genomes ArgU^ and ProL"^ for GC-rich genomes"
dsbC (engineered in a trxB cytoplasm) met lacY lac operator
Thioredoxin reductase ", glutathion reductase " allow disulfide bond formation in the cytoplasm [1] Disulfide bond isomerase" [2] Methionine auxotrophe allows high specific activity labelling with ^^S methionine or selenomethionine for crystallography Lac permease" allows fine tuning with lac derived promoters [3] Addition for tight control with lac repressor
"For codon usage problems, it is also possible to systematically mutate the offending codons to synonymous codons of E. coli. [1] Prinz et al, 1997; [2] Bessette et al, 1999; [3] Hashemzadeh-Bonehi et al, 1998.
it may be necessary to prevent mRNA degradation, to remove undesirable features in the coding sequence that impede translation, to prevent proteolytic degradation, or to assist in protein folding. Hence, in every case of overexpression, empirical trials need to be performed for optimization, altering expression conditions, and observing the yield, solubility, and stability of the recombinant protein. The conditions that should be optimized are temperature, inducer concentrations, and media. In some cases, supplements of salts or trace elements (Zn^"^, Cu^"^, Ca^"^, Fe^"^, Fe^"^) and potential cofactors or prosthetic groups (e.g., heme, FAD, FMN, tetra hydro-biopterine) are needed. Host strain genotype is also important for obtaining optimal expression levels (Table II). Many E. coli strains have been developed for this purpose. The properties manipulated are high competence (usually patented); End A" for cloning expression constructs (endonuclease I is an enzyme that rapidly degrades plasmid DNA); Lon protease"; or OmpT protease" (these proteases can degrade recombinant proteins). Efficient production of heterologous proteins in E. coli is frequently Umited by the rarity of certain tRNAs that are abundant in the organisms from vvrhich the heterologous proteins are derived. Forced high-level expression of heterologous proteins can deplete the pool of rare tRNAs and stall translation. Strains are engineered to contain extra copies of genes that encode the tRNAs that most frequently limit translation of heterologous protein in E. coli.
62
Etana Padan et al.
Availability of tRNAs allows high-level expression of many heterologous recombinant genes. These can be of high significance for genes derived from AT-rich or GC-rich genomes. Factors involved in protein folding are recruited now to improve overexpression and combat the problem of inclusion body formation. These include chaperones and peptidyl propyl cis/trans isomerases (for further reading, see Baneyx, 1999). Disulfide bonds do not form in the cytoplasm of wild-type E. coli strains, since this environment is reducing, trx^ encodes thioredoxin reductase, a protein responsible for the reduction of oxidized thioredoxins; gov encodes glutathion reductase. Deletion of these genes appears to facilitate accumulation of proteins containing structural disulfide bonds in the cytoplasm (Prinz et al., 1997; Venturi ei al., 2002). Another option is to direct the disulfide bond containing domain to the periplasm. There the environment is oxidizing and contains enzymes catalyzing the formation and rearrangement of disulfide bonds (Cornelis, 2000).
C. Inclusion Bodies and Refolding Overexpression of native proteins, but especially of heterologous recombinant proteins, leads to the formation of insoluble protein aggregates in the cytoplasm known as inclusion bodies. Current estimates are that 15-20% of human gene constructs expressed in E. coli are soluble, 20-40% form inclusion bodies, and the remainder do not express significantly or are degraded (for a recent review, see Rudolph and Lilie, 1996). Inclusion bodies are formed in both eukaryotes and prokaryotes, and there is no direct correlation between the propensity of their formation and intrinsic properties of the protein. For proteins containing disulfide bonds, inclusion body formation can be anticipated because the reducing cytosol inhibits disulfide bond formation (Hauke et al, 1998). Two strategies exist for dealing with inclusion bodies: (1) Minimize or avoid them by increasing the fraction of the protein that remains soluble. This involves modifications in the expression system (both host and vector) (review in Rudolph and Lilie, 1996; Hauke et al, 1998; Stevens, 2000); induction at lower temperatures; lowering the concentration of inducing agent; altering the media composition (e.g., adding sucrose or polyols); coexpressing chaperones and other in vivo folding enhancers; expressing the protein as a fusion with a "solubilizing partner" such as GST, MBP, thioredoxin, or NusA (see below). (2) Since inclusion bodies contain almost exclusively aggregates of the overexpressed protein, driving protein expression to inclusion body formation can be advantageous. Proteins in inclusion bodies are generally protected from proteolytic degradation. The use of inclusion body routes is especially attractive for the production of proteins that are toxic to host cells. Properly folded proteins can be produced from these inclusion bodies using a variety of
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
63
solubilization and in vitro refolding schemes (for review, see Hauke et ah, 1998). Partial success at in vitro refolding has been obtained with hydrophobic interaction chromatography. Unfortunately, refolding screens must still be developed, especially as different proteins have highly variable refolding efficiencies. During generic refolding processes, severe heterogeneity problems can arise owing to the formation of multiple refolded species and aggregates. Hence, efforts aimed at recombinant protein refolding should probe as many factors as possible to maximize the probability of obtaining properly folded protein in its native conformation. Very few membrane proteins were produced by overexpression in E. coli as inclusion bodies and successfully refolded. These include two transport proteins from the mitochondrial inner membrane that appear ready for crystallization attempts (Fiermonte et ah, 1993; 2000) and a G-protein coupled receptor (Echtay et ah, 2000; Kiefer et ah, 1996,1999, 2000). Immobilization on nickel chelating chromatography material was succesfuUy used for refolding Toc75, the translocase of the chloroplast outer envelope, and LHC2, a pigment binding oligomeric assembly (Rogl et ah, 1998).
III. EUKARYOTIC EXPRESSION SYSTEMS FOR OVERPRODUCTION OF MEMBRANE PROTEINS Many eukaryotic expression systems have been tested for heterologous production of membrane proteins, including several single cell yeasts (Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Schizosaccharomyces pombe, and Pichia pastoris), insect cells, and mammalian cells (for reviews, see Grisshammer and Tate, 1995; Reilander et ah, 1999; Schertler, 1992). For the investigation of structure/function relationship of a protein by site-directed mutagenesis, transient expression of the modified protein in mammalian cell lines is the method of choice. It allows fast evaluation of the different altered protein isoforms. The most commonly used cell lines are those from Chinese hamster ovary (CHO), baby hamster kidney (BHK), human embryonic kidney (HEK) 293, and NIH3T3. Transient and stably transfected mammalian cell lines are also well suited for functional investigation of different receptor subtypes as well as for establishment of search systems for new receptor ligands by "high-throughput-screening" (HTS) a n d / o r ultra-HTS (UHTS) approaches (Stratowa et ah, 1995). Due to the presence of intact signalling pathways in most of the mammalian cell lines, analysis of signal transduction of receptors can easily be performed (Wilson et ah, 1999). However, for large-scale production and purification of membrane proteins, mammalian cell systems are less suited. These aims can be achieved by the Pichia pastoris system and the insect cell/baculovirus system, which will be introduced in more detail in this section.
64
Etana Padan et al.
A. Yeast-Based Expression Systems Yeast-based expression systems are very attractive for heterologous production of membrane proteins. They are easy to manipulate and grow to high cell yield at low cost. Yeasts have been used in fermentation and food industry for decades and have been proven safe. Contrary to E. coli, yeasts have the potential to perform posttranslational modifications, which in some cases are needed for production of functional protein (Buckholz, 1993; Cereghino and Cregg, 1999, 2000; GeUisen and HoUenberg, 1997). Besides the classical expression system of S. cerevisiae, several other yeast systems have recently become popular. These include Schizosaccharomyces pombe, P. pastoris, P. methanolica, Hansenula polymorpha, Kluyveromyces lactis, Yarrowia lipolytica, or Candida utilis. However, only S. cerevisiae, Sz. pombe, and P. pastoris, have been tested for production of membrane proteins [for example: G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs); see Reilander et ah, 1999 and a multidrug transporter (MRPl) (Cai et al., 1991)]. S. cerevisiae is the best characterized eukaryotic organism in terms of molecular genetics, cell biology, and physiology. Its complete genome sequence has been recently published (Goffeau et ah, 1996), and there are many ongoing studies to elucidate the function of newly discovered genes. A multitude of different strains including protease-deficient strains as well as a variety of expression vectors comprising yeast episomal plasmids (Yeps) and yeast integrating plasmids (Yips) are commercially available and allow easy genetic manipulations. The internal GPCR signal pathway, for example, has been modified and adapted to create a host for high-throughput screening of GPCRs (Pausch, 1997). However, S. cerevisiae has some limitations as a host: (1). It does not produce high cell densities, (2) during fermentation, plasmids, especially Yeps, may be unstable, and (3) glycoproteins may be incorrectly glycosylated—for example, hyperglycosylated. The fisson yeast Sz. pombe is phylogenetically as related to S. cerevisiae as it is to mammalian cells. It has many properties in common with higher eukaryotic organisms (Giga-Hama and Kumagai, 1997). A range of different expression vectors for Sz. pombe have recently become commercially available, some of which are based on the thiamine-repressible nmtl promoter {nmtl, no message in thiamine) (Maundrell, 1993). However, the biotechnological application of this yeast lags behind that of S. cerevisiae and P. pastoris. 1. Pichia pastoris as an Expression System The use of yeast as an expression system commenced when Phillips Petroleum converted the methylotrophic yeast P. pastoris into a producer of recombinant proteins. P. pastoris is one of about a dozen yeast species that can use methanol as its sole energy and carbon source. The metabolic pathway
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
65
needed for methanol consumption involves a set of different enzymes where alcohol oxidase I (AOXl) catalyzes the first step. The expression of the AOXl gene is tightly regulated and specifically induced by methanol. More than 30% of the cell protein is AOXl when the cells grow on methanol in a fermenter. The first steps of the methanol utilizing pathway take place in specialized organelles, the peroxisomes. This compartmentalisation prevents possible oxidative damage to the cell from the production of hydrogen peroxide. In most cases, expression of foreign genes in P. pastoris was accomplished by using the strongly regulated promoter derived from the AOXl gene (Higgins and Cregg, 1998). Other vectors that use the promoter of the constitutive glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAP) gene (Waterham et ah, 1997) were constructed. Strains and vectors are commercially available (Invitrogen). P. pastoris is always used in combination with vectors for genomic integration. After transformation and integration of the linearized recombinant vectors, the resulting recombinant yeast clones are extremely stable even when induced. The techniques for molecular genetic manipulation of P. pastoris are very similar to those of S. cerevisiae. Additionally, P. pastoris has a strong preference for respiratory growth, a property that facilitates growth to extremely high cell densities of up to 500 g per liter culture medium. To date, more than 100 different proteins have been successfully produced in P. pastoris, including membrane-bound receptors (GPCRs) and transporters (Cereghino and Cregg, 1999, 2000). Four different methods are available for the transformation of P. pastoris. Although more laborious than the others but best characterized is the spheroblast method that produces transformants at high frequency. The other three methods rely on intact untreated cells. The most common whole-cell method of transformation is based on electroporation, which results in almost as many recombinants as the spheroblast method. The other two transformation procedures have the advantage that they do not need special equipment. Both of these methods, the PEG-transformation as well as the LiCl-method, result in the generation of an adequate number of transformants (Cregg and Russell, 1998). To date, all P. pastoris strains available are derivatives of the NRRL-Y11430 strain (Table III). To allow for selection of transformants that carry a vector containing the histidinol dehydrogenase gene (HIS4), most strains bear a mutation in HIS4. These strains are able to grow on complex media, but for their growth in minimal medium, histidine has to be supplemented. The most commonly used host for transformation is strain GS115, which posesses a wild type AOXl and grows rapidly on methanol (Muf^ phenotype). In contrast, the strain KM71 has a reduced growth rate on methanol (Mut^, methanol utilization slow), since the chromosomal AOXl gene was largely deleted and replaced by the S. cerevisiae ARG4 gene. The slow growth of this strain on
66
Etana Padan et al.
TABLE III
P. pastoris Strains Strain GS115 X33
KM71
KM71H
SMD1168 SMD1168H
SMD1163
Genotype (application) his4 (selection of vectors containing HIS4) wild type (selection of vectors containing the zeocin resistance gene) aoxl::ARG4 his4 arg4 (selection of vectors containing HIS4 resulting in clones with Mut^ phenotype) aoxl::ARG4 arg4 (selection of vectors containing the zeocin resistance gene resulting in clones with Mut^ phenotype) Apep4his4 (selection of vectors containing HIS4) Apep4 (selection of vectors containing the zeocin resistance gene) Apep4 his4 Aprbl (selection of vectors containing HIS4)
Phenotype
Ref.
Mut+His"
[1]
wild type
[2]
Mut^His"
[31
Mut'His + protease-deficient
[2]
Mut+His"; protease-deficient Muf^His^; protease-deficient
[4]
Mut+His"; protease-deficient
[5]
[2]
Adapted and expanded according to Higgins and Cregg (1998). [11 Cregg et al, 1985; [21 Invitrogen; [3] Cregg and Madden, 1987; [4] White et al, 1995; [5] Gleeson et al, 1998.
methanol relies on the activity of a second alcohol oxidase gene, AOX2, which is present in the P. pastoris genome. A0X2 has an explicitly lower activity compared to AOXl. With many expression vectors it is possible to replace the AOXl gene in the GS115-related strains with an expression casette by homologous recombination resulting in a Mut^ phenotype. Proteolysis is a problem during production of recombinant proteins, especially membrane proteins (Weiss et al, 1995). The vacuolar proteases play a major role in this proteolysis. Therefore, the use of the protease-deficient strains SMD1168 or SMD1163 (Table III) is highly recommended. The PEP4 gene encodes for the vacuolar proteinase A, which is required for the activation of several other vacuolar proteases. The PRBl gene codes for proteinase B. SMD1163, a strain bearing the double mutation pep4 prbl, shows a significant reduction in protease activities and, therefore, provides an optimal environment for production of sensitive proteins. The strains X33, KM71H, and SMD1168H (Table III), which all bear no mutation in the HIS4 gene, are designed for transformation with expression vectors conferring resistance either to Zeocin or Blasticidin.
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
67
The most commonly used vectors for heterologous production of proteins in P. pastoris are shuttle vectors (Table IV). Some vectors bear the wild-type HIS4 gene and the bacterial ampicillin resistance gene as selectable markers. The HIS4-based vectors are in general large (up to 10 kb), and the multiple cloning site is not very convenient. The AOXl promoter region present on these vectors is followed by a multiple cloning site suited for insertion of the foreign gene followed by the AOXl transcriptional termination sequence. The 3' flanking region of the AOXl gene contains the HIS4 selection marker, which is needed for screening the integration of the expression cassette at the AOXl locus by gene replacement. Furthermore, it contains sequences required for replication and propagation of the vectors in E. coli (for example, the pPIC9 vector). Generation of recombinant strains bearing multicopy integrations of the expression plasmid in the genome has been shown to result in an increased production of heterologous protein via a gene dosage effect. Special vectors that carry a second selection marker in addition to HIS4 were designed for this application. They contain the E. coli kanamycin gene of transposon 903 inserted between HIS4 and the 3' flanking region of AOXl (for example, the pPIC9K vector). This marker allows identification of recombinant clones bearing multicopy integration of the expression cassettes by screening for increased resistance to geneticin (G418). In the first step Pichia transformants are selected on histidine-deficient medium and then screened for their level of resistance to G418. However, the addition of the kanamycin gene increases the size of these already large plasmids and may yield unstable vectors. Smaller vectors were constructed using a single selectable marker active both in E. coli as well as in P. pastoris. To date, two selection markers are used for this purpose: the ble gene from Streptoalloteichus hindustanus, conferring resistance to Zeocin (pPICZ series) (Higgins et ah, 1998), and the hsd gene from Aspergillus terreus, conferring resistance to Blasticidin S (pPIC6 series). In these vectors, the respective resistance genes are preceded by a S. cerevisiae TEFl gene promoter needed for transcription in P. pastoris and the synthetic EM7 promoter needed for transcription in E. coli. The genes are followed by the 3' transcription processing sequences of the S. cerevisiae CYCl gene. Direct selection of hyperresistant transformants with multicopy integration events has been claimed but not clearly proven. These vectors have several advantages; they are small and contain an extended multiple cloning site, which in most cases allows C-terminal fusion of a c-myc-tag and a His6-tag to the foreign gene. Some of these vectors have special features. The so-called E-series of vectors are designed for directional cloning by rapid Cre-based recombination (pPICZ-E and pPICZa-E). In several vectors the S. cerevisiae a-factor prepro-signal sequence has been included to allow N-terminal fusion to the foreign gene. Although these vectors were constructed for the production of secreted proteins, GPCRs fused to this sequence showed a higher production level (Schiller et ah, 2000, 2001; Weiss et al, 1995).
68
Etana Padan et al.
TABLE IV
P. pastoris Expression Vectors for Intracellular Production or Secretion Selection marker in yeast
Properties
Ref.
Intracellular pHIL-D2 pA0815
HIS4 HIS4
pPIC3.5
HIS4
pPIC3.5K
HIS4 and kan"^
pPICZ A, B, C
ble'
pPICZ-E
ble'
pPIC6 A, B, C
bsd'
pHWOlO pGAPZ A, B, C
HIS4 ble'
AOXl-promoter AOXl-promoter; BamHl and Bglll restriction sites for in vitro multimerization of the expression cassette A0X2-promoter; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene AOXl-promoter; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene; G418selection for multicopy clones AOXl-promoter; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene; Zeocin-selection; BamHl and Bglll restriction sites for in vitro multimerization of the expression cassette; His6 and c-myc epitope tags (optional) AOXl-promoter; vector designed for in vitro recombination (echo-cloning system); zeocin-selection AOXl-promoter; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene; blasticidin-selection; BamHl and Bglll restriction sites for in vitro multimerization of the expression cassette; His6 and c-myc epitope tags (optional) GAP-promoter GAP-promoter; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene; zeocin-selection; BamHl and Bglll restriction sites for in vitro multimerization of the expression cassette; His6 and c-myc epitope tags (optional)
[1] [2]
[3] [3]
[41
[1]
[1]
[5] [1]
Secretion pHIL-Sl
HIS4
pPIC9
HIS4
AOXl-promoter; PHOl-signal sequence; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene A0X2-promoter; S. cerevisiae a-factor signal sequence; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene
[1]
[3]
69
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
TABLE IV
Continued Selection marker in yeast pPIC9K
HIS4 and kan'
pPICZaA, B, C
ble'
pPICZa-E
hie'
pPIC6a A, B, C
bsd'
pGAPZaA, B, C
ble'
Properties
Ref.
AOXl-promoter; S. cerevisiae a-factor signal sequence; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene; G418-selection for multicopy clones AOXl-promoter; S. cerevisiae a-factor signal sequence; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene; zeocin-selection; BamHl and Bglll restriction sites for in vitro multimerization of the expression cassette; His6 and c-myc epitope tags (optional) AOXl-promoter; S. cerevisiae a-factor signal sequence; vector designed for in vitro recombination (echo-cloning system); zeocin-selection AOXl-promoter; S. cerevisiae a-factor signal sequence; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene; blasticidin-selection; BamHl and Bglll restriction sites for in vitro multimerization of the expression cassette; His6 and c-myc epitope tags (optional) GAP-promoter; S. cerevisiae a-factor signal sequence; multiple cloning site for insertion of the foreign gene; zeocin-selection; BamHl and Bglll restriction sites for in vitro multimerization of the expression cassette; His6 and c-myc epitope tags (optional)
[3]
[6]
[1]
[1]
[1]
Adapted and expanded according to Higgins and Gregg (1998). [1] Invitrogen; [2] Thill et ah, 1990; [3] Scorer et ah, 1993; [4] Higgins et al, 1998; Scorer et al, 1993; [5] Waterham et al, 1997; [6] Higgins et al, 1997.
For constitutive production of foreign proteins the GAP promoter (Waterham et al., 1997) has recently been inserted in pPICZ vector backbone. The GAP promoter is a convenient alternative to the AOXl promoter as long as the expressed products are not toxic to the cell. As yet, membrane proteins have not been produced by these vectors.
70
Etana Padan et al.
As in S. cerevisiae, linearized vectors are used for the generation of stable transformants via homologous recombination fostered by sequences shared between vector and genome. Even in the absence of an antibiotic selective pressure, such transformants are stable. The vectors mentioned above carry at least one genomic DNA fragment (the promoter) with a unique restriction site that can be cleaved and used to direct the vector to integrate into the P. pastoris genome via a single crossover. Vectors that contain the HIS4, therefore, can be forced to insert into the P. pastoris genomic his4 locus. Vectors that bear in addition the 3'AOXl sequences can be integrated in the genome by single crossover at either the AOXl or the HIS4 locus, but they can also replace the AOXl completely by a double crossover event. Recombinant clones resulting from such an event (replacement) show a His"^ Mut^ phenotype. Multiple integrations of the expression cassette occur sponataneously at low frequency (1-10% of His"^ transformants). Detection for these events is possible by screening for clones showing hyperresistance on G418 or Zeocin. As mentioned above, when the AOXl promoter is used for transcriptional control of the foreign gene, a major advantage of P. pastoris is that it can be grown to extremely high cell densities in fermenters. The AOXl promoter is induced by methanol and repressed in the presence of excess glycerol. A standard fermentation protocol is to grow the recombinant cells with an amount of glycerol, just enough to get very high cell density. When glycerol is exhausted, protein production is induced by supplementation of methanol to the medium. The advantage of Muf^ transformants is their faster growth on methanol. However, the concentration of methanol must be tightly controlled to avoid enrichment of toxic formaldehyde, the product of the first enzymatic step in the metabolism of methanol. Mut^ strains grow slowly on methanol because they lack AOXl and their growth relies on AOX2. In principal, cultivation of a Mut^ strain is similar to that of Mut^ strains, but lower methanol feed rates are needed to maintain a methanol concentration of 0.2-0.8% in the fermenter. Alternatively, Mut^ strains can be grown in a mixed glycerol/methanol medium (Stratton et al., 1998).
B. Insect Cells as Expression System Different insects cell lines for stable or transient transfection with appropriate vectors are available. Stably transformed insect cells have a number of potential benefits over mammalian cell-based expression systems (McCarroU and King, 1997; Pfeifer, 1998). These include lower growth temperature, less complex growth conditions, the possibility for a long-term continuous culture, growth in large fermenters, and the possibility of protein production in a null background. Vectors, which allow quick selection of stable cell clones, were constructed for transfection of Spodoptera frugiperda (Sf9 and Sf21 cell lines), Trichoplusia ni ("high five" cell lines), and Mamestra brassicae cell lines. Most commonly, baculovirus immediate early (ie) promoters from Bombyx mori
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
71
multicapsid nuclear polyhedrosis virus (BmMNPV), Autographa californica (AcMNPV), and Orgyia pseudotsugata (OpMNPV) are used to drive transcription of the foreign gene (Jarvis et ah, 1990; Jarvis and Finn, 1996). Other widely used insect promoters include that of actin, of Drosophila melanogaster metallothionein, of Drosophila hsp70, and of copia, which function in the cell lines, albeit at a much lower level. The latter promoters have been mainly used for production of proteins in Drosophila, Schneider S2 and S3 cell lines, and mosquito cells. A variety of selection systems can be applied for the stable transformation of insect cells. They are based on genes conferring resistance to geneticin (G418), hygromycin B, methotrexate, and, recently, Zeocin and Blasticidin. The procedure for the generation of stably transformed insect cells is easy. Cells are seeded into small dishes and transfected with the appropriate recombinant vector using standard transfection methods such as calcium phosphate precipitation, electroporation, or liposome-mediated transfection. After a growth phase of 1-2 days to ensure expression of the resistance gene, selective pressure is applied by administration of the respective antibiotic. Nonresistant (i.e. nontransfected) cells die, and individual recombinant cell clones can be picked for further amplification. One of the most commonly used applications of stably transfected insect cells is the production of receptors or receptor subunits. Since in most cases insect cells do not appear to produce homologous endogenous receptors, the respective proteins are produced in an extremely low background. The insect/baculovirus-expression system has also proven to be successful for overproduction and characterization of several membrane proteins. The recombinant membrane proteins produced in the insect cells are subjected to posttranslational modifications such as glycosylation, phosphorylation, and palmitoylation. Most importantly, simultaneous infection of insect cells with several recombinant baculoviruses is possible. This opens the way for the production of complex multisubunit proteins or for enhancement of production levels of certain proteins by coproduction with a set of appropriate chaperons. 1. The Baculovirus Expression System The baculoviridae comprise a large family of occluded viruses, which are pathogenic for arthropods belonging to the insect orders Lepidoptera, Diptera, and Hymenoptera (Miller, 1996). In the last decade, baculoviruses, especially the Autographa californica nuclear polyhedrosis virus (AcMNPV), have been developed to a popular and versatile expression system (Kost and Condreay, 1999). The virus can be propagated easily in a multitude of cell lines, from which Spodoptera frugiperda (Sf9 and Sf21 cell lines), Trichoplusia ni ("high five" cell lines), and Mamestra brassicae are most frequently used (Hink et ah, 1991). As most baculoviruses, the AcMNPV has a complex, biphasic life cycle with
72
Etana Padan et al.
two distinct morphological virus types (Miller, 1996). The so-called budded virus form comprises a single enveloped virus, whereas the so-called occluded virus form comprises multiple virus particles that become embedded in a protein matrix composed almost exclusively of one protein called polyhedrin. The development of the expression system was based on the dispensibility for in vitro propagation of at least two very "late" viral gene products: the plO and the polyhedrin gene. Both genes are under control of strong promoters, which were used for the design of expression vectors. However, most baculovirus expression vectors use the polyhedrin gene promoter and locus for insertion of foreign DNA. "Early" promoters have also been used for the heterologous production of proteins but were found to be less effective (Jarvis et al, 1996). The manipulation for direct cloning of the baculovirus genome, a closed, circular, double-stranded DNA molecule of about 130 kb, is a difficult task. Therefore, recombinant transfer vectors containing the flanking region of the polyhedrin gene were constructed for cloning of the foreign gene. The recombinant virus is generated by homologous recombination with these vectors. The viral DNA and the recombinant transfer vector are cotransfected, and the expression cassette recombines into the virus genome, replacing its wild-type polyhedrin gene. The efficiency of this technique is less than 1%, and the screening for recombinant virus, which is performed by plaque assays a n d / o r hybridizations, is tedious and time-consuming (Luckow and Summers, 1988). By using linearized virus DNA for cotransfection, the efficiency was raised to about 30% recombinants per virus progeny. For this approach a unique Bsw36I restriction site was introduced at the polyhedrin locus of wild-type baculovirus DNA (Kitts et ah, 1990). A further development was the use of the baculovirus designated BacPAK6 for cotransfection. This virus DNA contains the E. coli lacZ gene at the polyhedrin locus and two additional Bsu36l sites in the polyhedrin flanking regions (Kitts and Possee, 1993). After Bsu36l digestion the virus DNA is not only linearized but two genomic fragments are removed. One disrupts a gene essential for replication of the virus. Restoration of this gene is only possible after recombination of the linearized and substracted virus genome with the respective polyhedrin-flanking region in the recombinant cotransfected transfer vector. The selection of recombinant baculovirus is based on LacZ (blue/white assay). Recombinant baculoviruses form white plaques on a background of blue plaques. Due to these modifications the efficiency of the system was raised to 80-90% recombinants per virus progeny. The system is commercially available (BaculoGold, Pharmingen). An alternative system is based on linearized BacPAK6 DNA (Orbigen). To increase expression, the gene encoding for protein disulfide isomerase has been inserted at the plO locus of the virus (Sapphire Baculovirus DNA). This might be advantageous for the production of membrane proteins. Another popular system is based on a site-specific transposition of an expression cassette into a baculovirus, which propagates in E. coli (Luckow et
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
73
al, 1993, Invitrogen). Here, the complete baculovirus genome replicates as a large and stable, low-copy number bacmid (pMON14272) in E. coli. This was achieved by recombination of a mini-F replicon into the polyhedrin locus of the virus. Additionally, the target site for the Tn7 transposon, a kanamycin resistance gene, and the lacZoc peptide coding region originating from a pUC-based vector have been introduced into the bacmid. The attachment site for the Tn7 transposon (mini-affTn7) was inserted corresponding to the N-terminus of the lacZoc region without disrupting the reading frame. Transposition of an expression cassette is performed in the E. coli DHlOBac strain harbouring the bacmid as well as the tetracyclin-resistant helper plasmid pMON7124, which in-trans supplies proteins necessary for transposition. The cells are transformed with an ampicillin-resistant vector that contains the foreign gene cloned under the transcriptional control of the polyhedrin promoter and the gentamycin acetyltransferase gene flanked by the left and right arms of Tn7. The mini-Tn7 in the so-called pFastBac vectors, which also contain the inserted foreign gene, can transposit to the vmni-attTn? attachment site on the bacmid. This transposition disrupts the lacZa peptides so that colonies, which contain a recombinant bacmid, are white in a background of blue colonies. Recombinant transformants are selected for in the presence of kanamycin, tetracyclin, gentamycin, X-Gal, and IPTG. The bacmids are isolated from the transformants and directly used for transfection of insect cells, eliminating the need for a tedious screening of positive plaques. In addition, the time required to generate, identify, and characterize a recombinant baculovirus with the transposition-based baculovirus system is reduced to about a week as opposed to six weeks with the former approach. For the procedures introduced here, different vectors are available, some of which also allow fusions to signal sequences, different tags (His-tag, c-myc-tag), as well as other proteins (GST). Some vectors allow simultaneous production of two or three proteins from one expression cassette via multiple promoters and multiple cloning sites.
IV. USE OF FUSION PROTEINS AND AFFINITY TAGS FOR PURIFICATION OF MEMBRANE PROTEINS Peptide affinity tags and fusion proteins are valuable tools that allow efficient and standardized purification of recombinant proteins. These affinity markers are attached to the target protein by gene fusion, thereby adding specific properties to the recombinant protein that can be exploited for protein purification via affinity chromatography, as well as for easy detection and immobilization. Affinity chromatography systems are designed to be highly specific and fast. They allow protein purification with high-yield, highenrichment, and often mild-purification conditions. In general, affinity tags
74
Etana Padan et al.
and fusion proteins can be added to the amino(N)-terminus or the carboxyl(C)-terminus of the protein. Alternatively, the DNA encoding the respective affinity marker may be introduced within the coding sequence of the target protein, a so-called internal fusion. The latter approach requires information about the secondary structural elements and the topology of the target. In some cases, linker regions have to be included to ensure accessibility of the affinity marker. The introduction of a tag or a fusion protein should affect neither the activity or structure of the protein of interest nor interfere with targeting, folding, or membrane insertion of the protein. In some cases, destabilization of the product and low yield are provoked, since the marker may disturb folding processes of the protein or increase its susceptibility to proteolytic degradation. The prediction of disadvantageous side effects is difficult, and, in practice, each affinity system has to be established empirically. Therefore, it is recommended to prepare different gene arrangements with respect to type and location of the tag and the length of the linker region. Short affinity tags are less likely to interfere with structure and function of the target protein and might be preferred for this reason. However, a stabilizing effect of larger fusion proteins has been reported and might be desirable. The insertion of a highly specific protease cleavage site between protein and affinity tag or fusion domain allows the removal of the attached marker after protein purification. The most common examples of affinity tags and fusion proteins used for membrane proteins will be described in this section. A general requirement for this application is tolerance to detergents. The Hzs-tag is probably the most widely applied affinity tag. Six or 10 consecutive histidine residues are fused to either the N- or the C- terminus of the protein. The tagged protein can be purified by immobilized metal-affinity chromatography (IMAC, Hochuli et ah, 1988). For this purpose metal-chelating matrices, which are loaded with transition metal ions (Co^"^, Ni^"^, Cu^^, Zn^), are used. The hybrid protein binds by interaction of the histidine imidazole groups with the free ligand binding sites in the coordination sphere of the metal ions. After applying the protein mixture to the column, unbound material is washed off with an appropriate buffer. The specifically bound protein is eluted by adding free imidazole to the elution buffer or by lowering the pH. This rapid method allows 100-fold enrichments in a single purification step and results in u p to 95% purity of the affinity-tagged protein (for review, see Bornhorst and Falke, 2000). It has been applied for purification of recombinant proteins from a number of different expression systems. The most commonly used H/s-tag consists of six histidine residues. Longer histidine stretches allow more stringent washing conditions and might help to reduce impurities. However, the longer the tag, the higher the risk that it interferes with the protein function. Affinity matrices are commercially available—for example, Nickel-nitrilotriacetic acid (Ni^"^-NTA, Qiagen) or cobaltcarboxymethylaspartate (Co^'^-CMA or Talon, Clontech). The binding affinity
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
75
is very high compared to other affinity systems. IMAC materials are reusable, since the metal ions can be stripped off and reloaded for regeneration. A binding capacity of standard affinity matrices of 5-10 mg of protein per ml of matrix is described. Furthermore, the matrices tolerate the presence of detergents and can be used easily for the purification of membrane proteins as, for example, the sodium/proton antiporter from E. coli (Olami et ah, 1997), the plant plasma membrane H"^-ATPase (Jahn et ah, 2001), and the trehalose/ maltose ABC transporter (Greller et ah, 2001). Remarkably, the siderophore receptor FhuA located in the outer membrane of E. coli was successfully purified with an internal H/s-tag. A hexahistidine peptide was inserted in a loop that was known to be surface exposed. This approach allowed purification of the receptor to homogeneity in large quantities and consequently its crystallization suitable for x-ray analysis (Ferguson et ah, 1998). Rogl et ah (1998) succeeded in refolding the chloroplast light-harvesting complex II from inclusion bodies, while the protein was immobilized on an IMAC matrix. In addition, the His-tag is often used in multiaffinity fusion systems, in which several tags or fusion proteins are attached to the same protein (Bornhorst and Falke, 2000). The Strep-tag is another useful but, until today, less well-known affinity marker. The short peptide consists of nine amino-acids and binds to streptavidin, allowing one-step purification of the fusion protein via streptavidin affinity chromatography (for review, see Skerra and Schmidt, 2000). The Sfrep-tag binds to the biotin binding pocket of streptavidin and permits very gentle elution of the recombinant protein from the affinity matrix by competitive displacement. Already small amounts of biotin or analogues thereof are sufficient for efficient elution without changing the overall buffer conditions with respect to pH or ionic strength. This second specificity-conferring step enables purity grades of over 99% in one step. While the original Sfrep-tag with the sequence Ala-Trp-Arg-His-Pro-GlnPhe-Gly-Gly (Schmidt and Skerra, 1993) can only be used as C-terminal fusion, the slightly modified version Strep-tag II (Asn-Trp-Ser-His-Pro-GlnPhe-Glu-Lys) allows in addition N-terminal and internal addition of the affinity tag. Affinity matrices can either be custom-made by coupling commercially available streptavidin to a variety of matrices or they can be obtained ready-made. Strep-Tactin columns (IBA) consist of an engineered streptavidin mutant with optimized binding properties for the Strep-tag II (Voss and Skerra, 1997) immobilized to various matrices, enabling affinity purification via gravity flow, FPLC, or HPLC. Binding of Strep-tagged proteins to streptavidin matrices is highly specific. Thus, it is an attractive alternative to Hfs-tagged proteins when problems with unspecific contamination cannot be solved. Specific elution of the protein from streptavidin matrices is most often performed with desthiobiotin. Biotin itself binds irreversibly to tetrameric streptavidin and thus does not allow the reversible use of the affinity matrix. To avoid contamination with endogenous biotin or biotin-carrying proteins.
76
Etana Padan et al.
extracts can be pretreated with avidin that will irreversibly bind and thereby mask biotin, while the Strep-ieig is not recognized. The Strep-tag system has been used for the purification of a variety of recombinant proteins, although applications described up to now comprise mainly proteins from bacterial sources. It seems to be a promising approach for membrane protein purification, since the streptavidin affinity matrix tolerates various detergents, the binding properties are highly specific, and the elution conditions are very mild. The betaine carrier BetP from Corynebacterium glutamicum was successfully purified by streptavidin affinity chromatography (Riibenhagen et ah, 2000). Furthermore, the Strep-tag has already been proven to be suitable for the purification of multisubunit membrane protein complexes, as, for example, the cocomplex of cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans with the specifically bound antibody fragment carrying the Strep-tag (Ostermeier et ah, 1995). 3D crystals of this protein preparation (Ostermeier et ah, 1995) led to the structure determination of the P. denitrificans cytochrome c oxidase (Iwata et ah, 1995). The Flag-tag is an epitope tag that can be used for membrane protein purification. This peptide consists of eight amino acid residues (Asp-Tyr-LysAsp-Asp-Asp-Asp-Lys) and forms the epitope for a set of different monoclonal antibodies. The monoclonal antibody Ml reacts specifically with the Flag-tag at the free N-terminus of the protein, and the binding is calcium dependent. Therefore, Flag-tagged proteins can be bound to a mAB Ml affinity matrix in the presence of calcium and eluted by adding EDTA to the buffer. Furthermore, the N-terminal specificity offers an elegant method to select for recombinant proteins with correctly processed leader sequences (see Chapter 9) or for selection of homogenous products after cleavage of Nterminal fusions. The mAB M2 binds to the Flag-epitope at the N- or C-terminus of the protein, but the binding is not calcium dependent. Elution of protein bound to mAB M2 affinity columns can be achieved by pH shift or by competition with the free Flag-peptide. Antibodies as well as specific affinity matrices are commercially available (Eastman Kodak). In vivo biotinylation can be exploited for protein purification. Biotinylation occurs in all eukaryotic and prokaryotic organisms, and the number of different endogenous biotinylated proteins is low. The protein of interest is fused to a Bio-tag that provides the biotin (vitamin H) accepting domain either in peptide or protein domain format. The highly specific interaction of biotin with streptavidin or avidin allows selective purification of the marked protein. The system can be used in principal for all expression systems and different biotin acceptor domains have been successfully introduced. Biotinylated proteins bind to monomeric avidin with a dissociation constant of about 10"^ M compared to 10"^^ for the tetrameric form. Therefore, immobilized monomeric avidin is often used as affinity matrix, and elution can be easily accomplished by competitive elution with low concentrations of biotin (for review, see Cull and Schatz, 2000). This system was used, for example, for the
CHAPTER 3 Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
77
purification of the jS2-adrenergic receptor, which was fused to a 75 amino acid biotinylation domain of Propionibacteriutn shertnanii and expressed in Pichia pastoris (see Chapter 9). The rat neurotensin receptor expressed in E. coli was purified most efficiently with a 13-amino-acid-long Bzo-tag at its C-terminus (Tucker and Grisshammer, 1996). Various fusion proteins — for example, the maltose-binding protein (MBP), the jS-galactosidase (GAL), thioredoxin (TRX), glutathione S-transferase (GST), or protein A—have been attached to proteins to facilitate purification. The fusion of larger domains offers the advantage of not only providing an affinity marker but it often stabilizes the recombinant protein by preventing degradation or promoting solubility. The N-terminal fusion of thioredoxin was essential for stabilizing the membrane-bound protein cytochrome b (5), whereas the C-terminal Hzs-tag was used for purification (Begum et ah, 2000). Again, a stabilizing effect of thioredoxin was reported for the production of the rat neurotensin receptor expressed in E. coli (Tucker and Grisshammer, 1996). In addition, thioredoxin can be directly applied for purification by either using its inherent thermal stability or by introducing secondary affinity properties to thioredoxin—for example, with in vivo biotinylation (for review, see LaVaUie et ah, 2000). Hybrid proteins containing the MBP fusion can be easily purified by affinity chromatography using immobilized amylose matrix (for review, see Sachdev and Chirgwin, 2000). This method has been successful for the purification of membrane proteins (Hampe et ah, 2000; Henderson et ah, 2000). GST fusion proteins are commonly used for protein purification from E. coli sources. The corresponding affinity matrix is glutathione-agarose. Bound protein can be eluted by adding glutathione to the buffer. No standard protocols can be applied, but conditions for purification have to be carefully optimized (for review, see Smith, 2000). A truncated form of the human Na"^/glucose cotransporter was expressed and purified from E. coli using a GST fusion vector and glutathione affinity chromatography (PanayotovaHeiermann et ah, 1999). When constructing the expression cassette for the hybrid protein, it is advisable to include a short sequence for a specific protease site between the target protein and the affinity fusion protein. Specific proteases such as thrombin, factor Xa, or Tobaco Etch Virus (TEV) protease (Dougherty et al., 1989) are used for the selective removal of the fusion partner, a step that might be exploited for purification.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Thanks are due to Danieli Tsafi (Protein Expression Facility), Institute of Life Sciences, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Givat Ram for help and advice, and to the support by the BMBF and International Bureau of the BMBF at the
78
Etana Padan et al.
DLR (German-Israeli Project Cooperation of Future-oriented Topics) and the Israel Science Foundation. Financial support by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (SFB 472) to C.H. is acknowledged.
REFERENCES Baker, E. K., CoUey, N. J., and Zuker, C. S. (1994). The cyclophilin homolog NinaA functions as a chaperone, forming a stable complex in vivo with its protein target rhodopsin. EMBO ]. 13, 4886-4895. Baneyx, F. (1999). Recombinant protein expression in Escherichia coli. Curr. Opin. Biotech. 10, 411-421. Begum, R. R., Newbold, R. J., and Whitford, D. (2000). Purification of the membrane binding domain of cytochrome b(5) by immobilised nickel chelate chromatography. /. Chromatogr. B 737,119-130. Bergeron, J. J. M., Brenner, M. B., Thomas, D. Y., and Williams, D. B. (1994). Calnexin: a membrane-bound chaperone of the endoplasmic reticulum. Trends Biochem. Sci. 19,124-128. Bessette, P. H., Aslund, P., Beckwith, J., and Georgiou, G. (1999). Efficient folding of proteins with multiple disulfide bonds in the Escherichia coli cytoplasm. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 96, 13703-13708. Bhandri, P., and Gowrishankar, J. (1997). An Escherichia coli host strain useful for efficient overproduction of cloned gene products with NaCl as the inducer. /. Bacteriol. 79, 4403-4406. Borel, A. C., and Simon, S. M. (1996). Biogenesis of polytopic membrane proteins: Membrane segments of P-glycoprotein sequentially translocate to span the ER membrane. Biochemistry 35,10587-10594. Bornhorst, J. A. and Falke, J. J. (2000). Purification of proteins using polyhistidine affinity tags. Methods Enzym. 326, 245-254. Brosius, J. (1999). Expression vectors employing the trc promoter. In "Gene Expression Systems" (J. M. Fernandez and J. P. Hoeffler, eds.), pp. 45-64, Academic Press, New York. Buckholz, R. G. (1993). Yeast systems for the expression of heterologous gene products. Curr. Opin. Biotechn. 4, 538-542. Cai, D., Daoud, R., Georges, E., and Gros, P. (201). Functional expression of multidrug resistance protein 1 in Pichia pastoris. Biochemistry 40, 8307-8316. Cereghino, G. P., and Cregg, J. M. (1999). Applications of yeast biotechnology: Protein production and genetic analysis. Curr. Opin. Biotechn. 10, 422-427. Cereghino, G. P., and Cregg, J. M. (2000). Heterologous protein expression in the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 24, 45-66. Cornelis, P. (2000). Expressing genes in different Escherichia coli compartments. Curr. Opin. Biotech. 11, 450-454. Cregg, J. M., Barringer, K. J., Hessler, A. Y., and Madden, K. R. (1985). Pichia pastoris as a host system for transformations. Mol. Cell Biol. 5, 3376-3385. Cregg, J. M., and Madden, K. R. P. (1987). In "Biological Research on Industrial Yeasts" (G. G. Stewart, R. D. Russell, and R. R. Hiebsch, eds.). Vol. II, 1-18. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida. Cregg, J. M., and Russell, K. A. (1998). Transformation. In "Methods in Molecular Biology" (D. R. Higgins and J. M. Cregg, eds.). Vol. 103, pp. 27-39. Humana Press Inc., Totowa, New Jersey. Cull, M. G., and Schatz, P. J. (2000). Methods Enzym. 326, 430-458. Davies, A. H. (1994). Current methods for manipulating baculoviruses. Bio/Technology 12, 47-50. de Gier, J. W. and Luirink, J. (2001) Biogenesis of iner membrane proteins in Escherichia coli. Mol. Microbiol 40, 314-322. Do, H., Falcone, D., Lin, J., Andrews, D. W., and Johnson, A. E. (1996). The cotranslational integration of membrane proteins into the phospholipid bilayer is a multistep process. Cell 85, 369-378.
CHAPTER 3
Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
79
Dobberstein, B. (1994). Protein transport. On the beaten pathway. Nature 367, 599-600. Doring, F., Theis, S., and Daniel, H. (1997). Expression and functional characterization of the mammalian intestinal peptide transporter PepTl in the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 232, 656-662. Dougherty, W. G., Gary, S. M., Parks, T. D. (1989) Molecular genetic analysis of a plant virus polyprotein cleavage site—a model. Virology 171, 356-364. Durbin, R. (1999). Gene expression systems based on bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase. In ''Gene Expression Systems'' (J. M. Fernandez and J. P. Hoeffler, eds.), pp. 9-44. Academic Press, New York. Echtay, K. M., Winkler, E., and Klingenberg, M. (2000). Coenzyme Q is an obligatory cofactor for uncoupling protein function. Nature 408, 609-613. Ferguson, A. D., Breed, J., Diederichs, K., Welte, W., and Coulton, J. W. (1998). An internal affinity-tag for purification and crystallization of the siderophore receptor FhuA, integral outer membrane protein from Escherichia coli K-12. Protein Science 7, 1636-1638. Fiermonte, G., Dolce, V., Palmieri, L., Ventura, M., Runswick, M. J., Palmieri, F., and Walker, J. E. (2000). Identification of the human mitochondrial oxodicarboxylate carrier: Bacterial expression, reconstitution, functional characterization, tissue distribution and chromosomal location. /. Biol. Chem. In press. Fiermonte, G., Walker, J. E., and Palmieri, F. (1993). Abundant bacterial expression and reconstitution of an intrinsic membrane-transport protein from bovine mitochondria. Biochem. ]. 294, 293-299. Geisow, M. J. (1992). Glycoprotein glycans-roles and controls. Trends Biotechn. 10, 333-335. Geisse, S., Gram, H., Kleusner, B., and Kocher, H. P. (1996). Eukaryotic expression systems: a comparison. Protein Expr. Purif. 8, 271-282. Gellissen, G., and HoUenberg, C. (1997). Application of yeasts in gene expression studies: A comparison of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Hansenula polymorpha, and Kluyveromyces lactis — a review. Gene 190, 87-97. Gething, M.-J., and Sambrook, J. (1992). Protein folding in the cell. Nature 355, 33-45. Giga-Hama, Y., and Kumagai, H. (1997). Foreign gene expression in fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg and Landes Bioscience, Georgetown, Texas. Goffeau, A., Barrel, B. G., Bussey, H., Davis, R. W., Dujon, B., Feldmann, H., Galibert, F., Hoheisel, J. D., Jacq, C , Johnston, M., Louis, E. J., Mewes, H. W., Murakami, Y., Philippsen, P., Tettelin, H., and Oliver, S. G. (1996). Life with 6000 genes. Science 274, 546-567. Greller, G., Riek, R., and Boos, W. (2001). Purification and characterization of the heterologously expressed trehalose/maltose ABC transporter complex of the hyperthermophilic archaeon Thermococcus litoralis. Eur. ]. Biochem. 268, 4011-4018. Grisshammer, R., and Tate, C. G. (1995). Overexpression of integral membrane proteins for structural studies. Quart. Rev. Biophysics 28 (3), 315-422. Grossman, T. H., Kawasaki, E. S., Punreddy, S. R., and Osburne, M. S. (1998). Spontaneous cAMP-dependent derepression of gene expression in stationary phase plays a role in recombinant expression instability. Gene 209, 95-103. Guzman, L. M., Belin, D., Carson, M. J., and Beckwith, J. (1995). Tight regulation, modulation, and high-level expression by vectors containing the arabinose pBAD promoter. /. Bacteriol. 177, 4121-4130. Hampe, W., Voss, R. H., Haase, W., Boege, F., Michel, H., and Reilander, H. (2000). Engineering of a proteolytically stable human beta(2)-adrenergic receptor/maltose-binding protein fusion and production of the chimeric protein in Escherichia coli and baculovirus-infected insect cells. /. Biotech. 77, 219-234. Hartl, F.-U., Hlodan, R., and Langer, T. (1994). Molecular chaperones in protein folding: the art of avoiding sticky situations. Trends Biochem. Sci. 19, 20-25.
80
Etana Padan et ah Hashemzadeh-Bonehi, L., Mehraein-Ghomi, F., Mitsopoulos, C , Jacob, J. P., Hennessy, E. S., and Broome-Smith, J. K. (1998). Importance of using lac rather than ara promoter vectors for modulating the levels of toxic gene products in Escherichia coli. Mol. Microbiol. 30, 676-678. Hauke, L., Schwarz, E., and Rudolph, R. (1998). Advances in refolding of proteins produced in £. coli. Curr. Opin. Biotech. 9, 497-501. Helenius, A., Marquardt, T., and Braakman, I. (1992). The endoplasmic reticulum as a proteinfolding compartment. Trends Cell Biol. 2, 227-231. Henderson, P. J. P., Hoyle, C. K., Ward, A. (2000). Expression, purification and properties of multidrug efflux proteins. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 28, 513-517. Higgins, D. R., Busser, K., Comiskey, J., Whittier, P. S., Purcell, T. J., and Hoeffler, J. P (1998). Small vectors for expression based on dominant drug resistance with direct multicopy selection. In "Pichia Protocols'' (D. R. Higgins and J. M. Cregg, eds.). Vol. 103, pp. 44-53. Humana Press, Totowa, New Jersey. Higgins, D. R., and Cregg, J. M. (1998). Introduction to Pichia pastoris. In ''Pichia Protocols'' (D. R. Higgins and J. M. Cregg, eds.). Vol. 103, pp. 1-15. Humana Press, Totowa, New Jersey. Hink, W. F., Thomsen, D. R., Davidson, D. J., Meyer, A. L., and Castellino, F. J. (1991). Expression of three recombinant proteins using baculovirus vectors in 23 insect cell lines. Biotechnol. Prog. 7, 9-14. Hochuli, E., Bannwarth, W., Dobeli, H., Gentz, R., and Stiiber, D. (1988). Genetic approach to facilitate purification of recombinant proteins with a novel metal chelator adsorbent. Bio/ Technology 6,1321-1325. Iwata, S., Ostermeier, C , Ludwig, B., and Michel, H. (1995). Structure at 2.8 A resolution of cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans. Nature 376, 660-669. Jahn, T., Dietrich, J., Andersen, B., Leidvik, B., Otter, C , Briving, C , Kuhlbrandt, W., and Palmgren, M. G. (2001). Large scale expression, purification and 2D crystallization of recombinant plant plasma membrane H^-ATPase. /. Mol. Biol. 309, 465-476. Jarvis, D. J., Weinkauf, C , and Guarino, L. A. (1996). Immediate-early baculovirus vectors for foreign gene expression in transformed or infected insect cells. Protein Expr. Purif. 8,191-203. Jarvis, D. L., and Finn, E. E. (1996). Modifying the insect cell N-glycosylation pathway with immediate early baculovirus expression vectors. Nature Biotech. 14,1288-1292. Jarvis, D. L., Fleming, J.-A. G. W., Kovacs, G. R., Summers, M. D., and Guarino, L. A. (1990). Use of early baculovirus promoters for continuous expression and efficient processing of foreign gene products in stably transformed lepidopteran cells. Bio/Technology 8, 950-955. Kiefer, H., Krieger, J., Olsewski, J. D., von Heijne, G., Prestwich, G. D., and Breer, H. (1996). Expression of an olfactory receptor in Escherichia coli: Purification, reconstitution, and ligand binding. Biochemistry 35, 16077-16084. Kiefer, H., Maier, K., and Volgel, R. (1999). Refolding of G-protein-coupled receptors from inclusion bodies produced in Escherichia coli. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 27, 908-912. Kiefer, H., Vogel, R., and Maier, K. (2000). Bacterial expression of G-protein-coupled receptors: Prediction of expression levels from sequence. Receptors and Channels 7,109-119. Kitts, P. A., Ayres, M. D., and Possee, R. D. (1990). Linearization of baculovirus DNA enhances the recovery of recombinant virus expression vectors. Nucleic Acids Res. 18, 5667-5672. Kitts, P. A., and Possee, R. D. (1993). A method for producing recombinant baculovirus expression vectors at high frequency. BioTechniques 14, 810-817. Kleymann, G., Ostermeier, C , and Ludwig, B. (1995). Engineered Fv fragments as a tool for the one-step purification of integral multisubunit membrane-protein complexes. Bio/Technol. 13, 155-160. Kost, T. A., and Condreay, J. P. (1999). Recombinant baculoviruses as expression vectors for insect cells and mammalian cells. Curr. Opin. Biotechn. 10, 428-433. LaVallie, E. R., Lu, Y., Diblasio-Smith, E. A., Cllins-Racie, L. A., and McCoy, J. M. (2000). Thioredoxin as a fusion partner for production of soluble recombinant proteins in Escherichia coli. Methods Enzym. 326, 322-340.
CHAPTER 3
Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
81
Lenhard, T., and Reilander, H. (1997). Engineering the folding pathway of insect cells: Generation of a stably transformed insect cell line showing improved folding of a recombinant membrane protein. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 238, 823-830. Luckow, V. A., Lee, S. C. Barry, G. P., and Olins, P. O. (1993). Efficient generation of infectious recombinant baculoviruses by site-specific transposon-mediated insertion of foreign genes into a baculovirus genome propagated in Escherichia coli. ]. Virol. 67, 4566-4579. Luckow, V. A., and Summers, M. D. (1988). Trends in the development of baculovirus expression vectors. Bio/Technology 6, 47-55. Lutz, R., and Bujard, H. (1997). Independent and tight regulation of transcriptional units in Escherichia coli via the Lac R/0, the Tet R/0 and Ara C/I1-I2 regulatory elements. Nucleic Acid Res. 25, 1203-1210. MacFarlane, J., and Miiller, M. (1995). The functional integration of a polytopic membrane protein of Escherichia coli is dependent on the bacterial signal-recognition particle. Eur. ].Biochem. 233, 766-771. Maloney, P. C., and Rotman, B. (1973). Distribution of suboptionally induced jS-D-galactosidase in Escherichia coli. J. Mol. Biol. 73, 77-91. Maundrell, K. (1993) Thiamine-repressible expression vectors pREP and pRIP for fission yeast. Gene 123,127-130. McCaroU, L., and King, L. A. (1997). Stable insect cell cultures for recombinant protein production. Curr. Opin. Biotechn. 8, 590-594. Miller, L. K. (1996). Insect viruses. In ''Fields Virology'' (B. N. Fields, D. M. Knipe, and P. M. Howley, et ah, eds.), pp. 533-556. Lippincott-Raven Publishers, Philadelphia. Miroux, B., and Walker, J. E. (1996). Over-production of proteins in mutant hosts that allow synthesis of some membrane proteins and globular proteins at high levels. /. Mol. Biol. 260, 289-298. Mulrooney, S. B., and Waskell, L. (2000). High-level expression in Escherichia coli and purification of the membrane-bound form of cytochrome b^. Protein Expr. Pur. 19,173-178. Novick, A., and Weiner, M. (1957). Enzyme induction as an all-or-none phenomenon. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 43, 553-5555. Olami, Y., Rimon, A., Gerchman, Y., Rothman, A., and Padan, E. (1997). Histidine 225, a residue of the NhaA-Na^/H"^ antiporter of Escherichia coli is exposed and faces the cell exterior. /. Biol. Chem. 272,1761-1768. Ondek, B., Hardy, R. W., Baker, E. K., Stamnes, M. A., Shieh, B.-H., and Zuker, C. S. (1992). Genetic dissection of cyclophilin function—saturation mutagenesis of the Drosophila cyclophilin homolog ninaA. /. Biol. Chem. 267,16460-16466. Panayotova-Heiermann, M., Leung, D. W., Hirayama, B. A., and Wright, E. M. (1999). Purification and functional reconstitution of a truncated human Na^/glucose cotransporter (SGLTl) expressed in E. coli. FEBS Lettr. 459, 386-390. Panke, O., Gumbiowski, K., Junge, W., Engelbrecht, S. (2000). F-ATPase: Specific observation of the rotating c subunit oligomer of EFoE. Febs Lett. 472, 34-38. Pausch, M. H. (1997). G-protein-coupled receptors in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: High-throughput screening assays for drug discovery. Trends Biotechn. 15, 487-494. Pfeifer, T. A. (1998). Expression of heterologous proteins in stable insect cell culture. Curr. Opin. Biotechn. 9, 518-521. Popot, J.-L. (1993). Integral membrane protein structure: Transmembrane a-helices as autonomous folding domains. Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 3, 532-540. Popot, J.-L., de Vitry, C., and Atteia, A. (1994). Folding and assembly of integral membrane proteins: an introduction. In "Membrane Protein Structure: Experimental Approaches" (S. H. White, ed.), pp. 41-96. Oxford University Press, Oxford, England. Prinz, W. A., Aslund, F., Holmgren, A., and Beckwith, J. (1997). The role of the thioredoxin and glutaredoxin pathways in reducing protein disulfide bonds in the Escherichia coli cytoplasm. /. Biol. Chem. 272, 15661-15667.
82
Etana Padan et al Reilander, H., Reinhard, C , and Szmolenszky, A. (1999). Large-scale expression of receptors in yeasts. In ''G Protein-Coupled Receptors'' (T. Haga and G. Berstein, eds.). Vol. 1, pp. 281-322. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, London, New York, Washington, D.C. Reilander, H., and Weiss, H. M. (1998). Production of G protein-coupled receptors in yeast. Curr. Opin. Biotechnol 9, 510-517. Rogl, H., Kosemund, K., Kiihlbrandt, W., and CoUinson, I. (1998). Refolding of Escherichia coli produced membrane protein inclusion bodies immobilized by nickel chelating chromatography. FEES Lettr. 432, 21-26. Romanos, M. (1995). Advances in the use of Pichia pastoris for high-level gene expression. Curr. Opin. Biotech. 6, 527-533. Rudolph, R., and Lilie, H. (1996). In vitro folding of inclusion body proteins. The FASEB ]. 10, 49-56. Riibenhagen, R., Ronsch, H., Jung, H., Kramer, R., and Morbach, S. (2000). Osmosensor and osmoregulator properties of the betaine carrier BetP from Corynebacterium glutamicum in proteoliposomes. /. Biol. Chem. 275, 735-741. Sachdev, D., and Chirgwin, J. M. (2000). Fusions to maltose-binding protein: Control of folding and solubliUty in protein purification. Methods Enzym. 326, 312-322. Schertler, G. F. X. (1992). Overproduction of membrane proteins. Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 2, 534-544. Schiller, H., Haase, W., Molsberger, E., Janssen, P., Michel, H., and Reilander, H. (2000). The human ETg endothelin receptor heterologously produced in the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris shows high-affinity binding and induction of stacked membranes. Receptors and Channels 7, 93-107. Schiller, H., Molsberger, E., Janssen, P., Michel, H., and Reilander, H. (2001). Solubilization and purification of functional human ETg endothelin receptor produced by high-level fermentation in Pichia pastoris. Receptors and Channels. In press. Schmidt, T. G., and Skerra, A. (1993). The random peptide library-assisted engineering of a C-terminal affinity peptide, useful for the detection and purification of a functional Ig Fv fragment. Protein Eng. 6,109-122. Schmitt, J., Hess, H., and Stunnenberg, H. G. (1993). Affinity purification of histidine-tagged proteins. Mol Biol. Rep. 18, 223-230. Scorer, C. A., Buckholz, R. G., Clare, J. J., and Romanos, M. A. (1993). The intracellular production and secretion of HIV-1 envelope protein in the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris. Gene 136, 111-119. Seluanov, A. and Bibi, E. (197) FtsY, the prokaryotic signal recognition particle receptor homologue, is esential for biogenesis of membrane proteins. /, Biol. Chem. 272, 2053-2055. Siegele, D. A., and Hu, J. C. (1997). Gene expression from plasmids containing the araBAD promoter at subsaturating inducer concentrations represents mixed populations. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94, 8168-8172. Skerra, A., and Schmidt, T. G. M. (2000). Use of the strep-tag and streptavidin for detection and purification of recombinant proteins. Methods Enzym. 326, 271-304. Smith, D. B. (2000). Generating fusions to glutathione S-transferase for protein studies. Methods Enzym. 326, 254-270. Stevens, R. C. (2000). Design of high-throughput methods of protein production for structural biology. Structure 8, R177-R185. Stratowa, C , Himmler, A., and Czerilofsky, A. P. (1995). Use of a luciferase reporter system for characterizing G-protein-linked receptors. Curr. Opin. Biotech. 6, 574-581. Stratton, J., Chiruvolu, V., and Meagher, M. (1998). High-cell-density fermentation. In: "Pichia Protocols" (D. R. Higgins and J. M. Cregg, eds.). Vol. 103, pp. 107-120. Humana Press, Totowa, New Jersey. Studier, F. W., Rosenberg, A. H., Dunn, J. J., and Dubendorff, J. W. (1990). Use of T7 RNA polymerase to direct expression of cloned genes. Methods Enzymol. 185, 60-89.
CHAPTER 3
Production and Purification of Recombinant Membrane Proteins
83
Taglicht, D., Padan, E., and Schuldiner, S. (1991). Overproduction and purification of a functional Na'^/H'^ antiporter coded by nhaA (ant) from Escherichia coli. ]. Biol. Chem. 266,11289-11294. Thill, G. P., Davis, G. R., Stillman, C., Holtz, G., Brierley, R., Engel, M., Buckholz, R., Kennedy, J., Provow, S., Vedvick, T., and Siegel, R.S. (1990). In: Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium on Genetics of Microorganisms (H. Heslot, J. Davies, J. Florent, L. Bobichon, G. Durand, and L. Penasse, eds). Vol. 2, pp. 477-490. Societe Fran^aise de Microbiologie, Paris. Tucker, J., and Grisshammer, R. (1996). Purification of a rat neurotensin receptor expressed in Escherichia coli. Biochem. J. 317, 891-899. Venturi, M., Seifert, C., and Hunte, C. (2002). High level production of functional antibody Fab fragments in an oxidizing bacterial cytoplasm. /. Mol. Biol. 315,1-8. Voss, S., and Skerra, A. (1997). Mutagenesis of a flexible loop in streptavidin leads to higher affinity for the Strep-tag II peptie and improved performance in recombinant protein purification. Prot. Engin. 10, 975-982. Waterham, H. R., Digan, M. E., Koutz, P. J., Lair, S. V., and Gregg, J. M. (1997). Isolation of Pichia pastoris glyceraldehyd-3-phosphate dehydrogenase gene and regulation and use of its promoter. Gene 186, 37-44. Weiss, H. M., Haase, W., Michel, H., and Reilander, H. (1995). Expression of functional mouse 5-HT5A serotonin receptor in the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris: Pharmacological characterization and localization. FEBS Lett. 377, 451-456. Weiss, M., Haase, W., Michel, H., and Reilander, H. (1998). Comparative analysis of two mammalian G-protein-coupled receptors, the mouse 5HT5A and the human P2 adrenergic receptor, produced in the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris. Biochemical ]. 330,1137-1147. Wessel, H. P., and Spiess, M. (1988). Insertion of a multispanning membrane protein occurs sequentially and requires only one signal sequence. Cell 55, 61-70. White, C. E., Hunter, M. J., Meininger, D. P., White, L. R., and Komives, E. A. (1995). Large-scale expression, purification and charcterization of small fragments of thrombomodulin: The roles of the sixth domain and of methionine 388. Protein Eng. 8,1177-1187. Wickner, W. T., and Lodish, H. F. (1985). Multiple mechanisms of protein insertion into and across membranes. Science 230, 400-407. Wilson, S., Slemmon, J. R., Gulp, J. S., Hellmig, B. D., McNulty, D. E., Ames, R. S., Sarau, H. M., Foley, J. J., Park, J. E., Chambers, J. K., Muir, A. I., Stadel, J. M., and Bergsma, D. J. (1999). Screening orphan receptors for native ligands. In "G Protein-Coupled Receptors'' (T. Haga and G. Berstein, eds.). Vol. 1, pp. 97-114. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, London, New York, Washington, D.C.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
4
SDS Electrophoresis Techniques HERMANN SCHAGGER Zentrum der Biologischen Chemie Universitatsklinikum Frankfurt 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany
I. INTRODUCTION Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) has become a valuable means for separation of proteins, and several electrophoresis systems that provide excellent resolution are available (see Hames and Rickwood, 1998). The Laemmli system (Laemmli, 1970) has advantages for separation of large proteins, and the Tricine-SDS-PAGE system (Schagger and von Jagow, 1987) is particularly useful for small proteins and peptides. These two electrophoresis systems cover the entire molecular mass range. Adjusting electrophoresis conditions for the special requirements of membrane proteins largely circumvents problems such as membrane protein aggregation during incubation in SDS and low recovery during electroelution and electroblotting.
Membrane Protein Purification and Crystallization 2/e: A Practical Guide. Copyright 2003, Elsevier Science (USA) All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
85
86
Hermann Schagger
11. CHOICE OF OPTIMAL SDS-PAGE SYSTEM AND GEL TYPE A. Wide versus Narrow Molecular Mass Range Wide molecular mass ranges usually are best covered by using acrylamide gradient gels and the Tris-glycine system according to Laemmli (1970). If there is no protein of interest larger than 100 kDa, the Tricine system described below is preferred. If there is a narrow molecular mass range of proteins to be separated, gradient gels should not be used. Although protein bands are usually sharper in acrylamide gradient gels compared with uniform gels, the resolution is lower because the separation distances between bands are decreased. The best gel systems and gel types for different separation problems are presented in Table I. Note: Use the Laemmli system if two proteins to be separated have similar molecular masses above 30 kDa; use the Tricine system for smaller proteins. If both systems show equal resolution, use the Tricine system for the advantages in electroelution and electroblotting.
B. Separation of Proteins with Similar Molecular Masses If the optimal gel/system is still not sufficient for resolving two proteins, one can often take advantage of the variable migration behavior displayed by individual proteins under special conditions. TABLE I
Gels and Systems for Optimal Separation Protein range
M, limits (kDa)
Optimal gel/system
Wide
6.0-250 2.5-200 2.5-100 1.0-70
8-16% gradient/Laemmli" 4-20% gradient/Laemmli 10% uniform/Schagger'' 16% uniform/Schagger
Mj. optimum (kDa) Narrow
50-100 40-80 30-60 5-50 2-30 1-20
8% 10% 12% 10% 16% 16%
uniform/Laemmli uniform/Laemmli uniform/Laemmli uniform/Schagger uniform/Schagger uniform/Schagger^
''LaemmU(1970). ''Schagger and von Jagow (1987). Concentration of cross-linker is doubled; gels without urea have nearly the same resolution as those with 6 M urea.
CHAPTER 4 SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
87
1. Effect of Acrylamide Concentration Some proteins, especially membrane proteins, show anomalous migration behavior in SDS gels. Such proteins may bind an unusual ratio of SDS molecules per amino acid residue or may have hydrophobic stretches that do not completely unfold. These characteristics are reflected in a change in the apparent molecular mass in gels differing in acrylamide concentration. If circumstances require separation of proteins having similar electrophoretic mobilities, run samples at acrylamide concentrations above and below the "optimal" acrylamide concentration for the given molecular mass (as deduced from Table I). If one protein has anomalous migration behavior, it typically will shift to higher apparent molecular masses at higher acrylamide concentration, and the apparent molecular mass will approach the true molecular mass. For determination of molecular mass by a Ferguson plot, see Ferguson (1964) and Hames and Rickwood (1998). 2. Effect of Cleavage of Internal Disulfide Bridges To ascertain whether either of the two proteins to be separated may contain internal disulfide bridges, incubate samples in SDS in the presence or absence of reducing agents (DTT, DTE, mercaptoethanol). Differences in migration distances, corresponding to a 1-3 kDa shift in the apparent molecular mass, are often observed. 3. Use of Urea to Alter Electrophoretic Mobilities Unusual migration of individual proteins, especially of small watersoluble and membrane proteins, can be induced by including 6-8 M urea in the gels. This presumably reflects changes in SDS binding or conformation of the SDS-denatured protein in the presence of urea, to an extent dependent on the specific protein involved. Some proteins display a reduced relative electrophoretic mobility and higher apparent molecular mass, whereas others seem to be only slightly affected. A side effect of electrophoresis in urea, relevant to all proteins, is the generally reduced migration distances that are observed. This effect may be helpful for increasing the resolution of small proteins. Note: Several complications arise when urea is used. First, urea gels are not suited for determination of molecular mass. Addition of 8 M urea may cause extreme retardation, especially of small proteins (<5 kDa), with extensive broadening or complete loss of bands. Using 6 M urea often leads to bands that seem to have twice the apparent molecular masses (dimerization?), but further oligomerization rarely occurs. Second, it is well known that urea may block N-terminal amino acids and inhibit N-terminal protein sequencing. This reaction is pH dependent and proceeds more slowly at low pH. If urea is necessary for separation, the
88
Hermann Schagger
Tricine system should be used, because the pH is lower than in the Laemmli system and because 1 M Tris in the gel effectively removes cyanate, which is the N-terminal-reactive species originating from urea. N-terminal blocking was not evident when the Tricine system was used, in spite of the fact that no effort had been made to remove cyanate (such as with a mixed-bed ionexchange resin). 4. Effect of Partial Substitution of Protein-Bound SDS by Coomassie Dye Proteins can be separated and visualized during electrophoresis by using Coomassie blue-SDS-PAGE (see Section IV,B). In this technique proteins migrate as blue bands because part of the SDS bound to the protein is replaced by Coomassie dye. This exchange of ligands leads to slight (but measurable) alterations in electrophoretic mobility for individual proteins when the SDS concentration in the cathode buffer is reduced from 0.1% to 0.05%. The changes are more pronounced if the SDS concentration in the cathode buffer is further reduced; however, broadening and aggregation of membrane proteins often occur.
C. Avoiding Broad Bands In uniform Laemmli gels at concentrations of acrylamide above 12%, a broadening of bands for small proteins ( < 15 kDa) often occurs. In these cases, switch to the Tricine system.
D. Analytical versus Preparative Purpose The choice of electrophoresis system depends on whether the experiment is designed for analysis (where proteins are to be fixed and stained within the gel) or for further studies that involve removal of protein from the gel. In the former case, there is a wide latitude in the choice of the optimal electrophoresis system and gel type. High acrylamide concentrations and highly crosslinked gels may be used. On the other hand, if the proteins must be removed from the gel, some restrictions come into play. For example, efficient electroblotting of larger membrane proteins may require the use of lower acrylamide concentrations, with some loss of optimal resolution. In this situation TricineSDS-PAGE has the advantage over the Laemmli system for two reasons: lower percentage acrylamide gels yield comparable resolution, and the running pH is lower than in the Laemmli system, which is advantageous for electroblotting (see below and also Section V).
III. TRICINE-SDS-PAGE Tricine-SDS-PAGE is a high-resolution system for proteins in the range from 1 to 30 kDa, and perhaps u p to 100 kDa. It offers advantages for
CHAPTER 4
SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
89
preparative isolation, electroelution, and electroblotting, not only of small proteins but also of larger membrane proteins. It is a valuable approach for preparing proteins and fragments for N-terminal protein sequencing without using glycine and urea. The theoretical background of the method is described by Schagger and von Jagow (1987).
A. Comparison with Laemmli System For direct comparison of the Laemmli and Tricine systems in resolving lower molecular weight peptides, 10% acrylamide gels and a set of small proteins were used (Fig. 1). The data indicate that a 10-20% Laemmli gradient gel is required to achieve the same resolution in the low molecular mass range as afforded by a uniform 10% Tricine gel. Using homogeneous 15% Laemmli gels instead generally leads to broadening of bands in the low molecular mass range. On the other hand, Laemmli gels are clearly preferred when large proteins are involved.
B. Characteristics of Gel Types As indicated below, the Tricine system using 10% poly acrylamide gels covers the molecular mass range from 1 to 100 kDa (Fig. 2). These gels have
kDa
FIGURE 1
17.2 14.6
-
2.55
—
Resolution of CNBr fragments of myoglobin in 10% T, 3% C gels using the Trice genls using the system of pagesTricine-SDS-PAGE system (lane 1) and the Laemmli system (lane 2). Reprinted from Schagger and von Jagow (1987), with permission from Analytical Biochemistry.
90
Hermann Schagger kDa
FIGURE 2
1
2
3
4
kC)a
Tricine-SDS-PAGE of proteins using different gel types: lane 1, 10% T, 3% C; lane 2, 16.5% T, 3% C; lane 3,16.5% T, 6% C; lane 4,16.5% T, 6% C plus 6 M urea. Reprinted from Schagger and von Jagow (1987), with permission from Analytical Biochemistry.
a total (T) concentration of acrylamide plus bisacrylamide of 10%. The cross-linker (C) concentration is 3% thereof, so the absolute bisacrylamide concentration in these gels, designated as "10% T, 3% C" gels, is 0.3%. This is the system of choice if resolution of proteins is sufficient, because no "spacer" gel is needed, electrophoresis times are short, staining is rapid, electroblotting efficiency is high, and heat production is low so that thick preparative gels can be used. An alternative system involves use of higher levels of acrylamide, such as "16.5% T, 3% C" gels; this provides higher resolution in the low^ molecular mass range, sharper bands, and improved mechanical stability. Gels that are 16.5% T, 6% C, are used for special applications in peptide separation; they are somewhat brittle and require a special procedure for drying.
CHAPTER 4 SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
91
C. Gel Preparation 1. Chemicals SDS, Tricine p.A., urea p.A., glycerol p.A., acrylamide 2 x recrystallized, bisacrylamide 2 x recrystallized, and Serva blue G are obtained from Serva. All other chemicals are from Sigma. 2. Casting Gels The most convenient gels for casting are uniform 10% gels, overlaid by a 4% stacking gel. If the sample contains no protein of interest with a molecular mass of less than 5 kDa, use 16% gels cast the same way. For resolution of smaller peptides, however, insert a 10% spacer gel (1-1.5 cm long) between the stacking and separating gels as described in the protocol below. The spacer and separating gels are best polymerized together, but a step-by-step polymerization also works well. 3. Protocol Gels are usually cast at room temperature. The following protocol, with or without a spacer gel; is used in the authors laboratory for standard gels. The size of the glass plates and the thickness of the spacers depend on the specifics of the application. The volumes given in Table III are sufficient for casting two analytical gels (14 x 14 x 0.07 cm) or one semipreparative gel (14 X 14 X 0.16 cm). a. Liquify 1% agarose in a boiling water bath or microwave oven. b. Apply thin strings of 1% agarose to the two glass plates at the position of the spacers. c. Mount the spacers on the glass plate, which usually has "ears," and put the other plate on top, completing the sandwich. d. Use two strong document clamps to fix the glass plates together at the lower edges. When this is done correctly, there is enough space between the clamps to grasp the plates with one hand, and potential small gaps between adjoining spacers can be seen and corrected. e. Clamp the sides with two more clamps. Stand the sandwich upright on the legs of the two lower clamps. f. Prepare a separating gel solution (e.g., for a 16.5% T, 3% C gel) according to Tables II and III, and add the polymerization starters ammonium persulfate and tetramethylethylenediamine, with stirring, at the concentrations given in Table III. At these levels of starters, polymerization will not begin until about 10 min has passed. g. Pour the mixture between the glass plates. When a 10% spacer gel is used, fill the plates with separating gel solution to 3 cm below the top;
92
Hermann Schagger
TABLE II
Stock Solutions for Tricine-SDS Page" Buffer
Tris (M)
Tricine (M)
pH
SDS (%)
Anode (10 x) Cathode (10 x) Gel buffer (3 x)
1.0 1.0 3.0
— 1.0 —
8.9'' 8.25^ 8.45''
— 1.0 0.3
AB-mix''
Acrylamide (g/100 ml)
Bisacrylamide (g/100 ml)
S (49.5% T, 3% C) H (49.5% T, 6% C)
48 46.5
1.5 3.0
"* Acrylamide-bisacrylamide stock solutions are kept at 7°C; all other stock solutions are kept at room temperature. ''Adjusted with HCl. ^No correction of the pH, which is approximately pH 8.25. ''AB-mix S, Standard acrylamide-bisacrylamide stock solution; AB-mix H, acrylamide-bisacrylamide mixture with high cross-linker concentration: % T, total concentration of both monomers (acrylamide and bisacrylamide); % C, percentage of cross-linker relative to the total concentration.
TABLE III
Composition of Stacking, Spacer, and Separating Gels Separating gel
AB-mix S'^ AB-mix H'^ Gel buffer (3 x ) Glycerol Urea Add water to a final volume of Polymerization by APS (10%)'' TEMED'^
Stacking gel
Spacer gel
10% T 3%C
16.5% T 3% C
16.5% T 6% C
16.5% T 6% C +6M urea
1 ml — 3 ml — — 12 ml
3 ml — 5 ml — — 15 ml
6 ml — 10 ml 3g — 30 ml
10 ml — 10 ml 3g — 30 ml
10 ml 10 ml 3g — 30 ml
10 10 — 11 30
90 fA 9 fil
80/il 8/il
150/il 15/il
100/xl 10^1
100/xl 10 fA
100 iul lO^^l
'^See Table II. ^APS (10%), Ammonium persulfate solution (10%), freshly prepared. ^' TEMED, Tetramethylethylenediamine.
ml ml g ml
CHAPTER 4 SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
93
when the spacer gel is omitted, leave 1.5-2 cm at the top. In the latter case, skip step h. h. Prepare a spacer gel solution according to Table III. This mixture differs from the 10% separating gel mix only by the omission of glycerol. Add polymerization starters, then pipet a 1-1.5 cm overlay onto the separating gel before this is polymerized. {Note: Acrylamide and bisacrylamide are highly neurotoxic. When handling these chemicals, wear gloves! Pipetting by mouth is prohibited—use a pipetting aid!) Carefully
overlay with a few drops of water. i. Prepare the 4% stacking gel solution (Tables II and III) without starters. j. After polymerization of the gel mixture(s) occurs (usually within 10-20 min), remove water, add starters, pipet in the stacking gel, and insert the comb so that about 1 cm of stacking gel is below the bottom of the comb. k. Remove the comb 5-10 min after polymerization; overlay the gel with water and store at 4-7°C until use. Replenish the water layer every few days. Note: The cross-linker concentration (3% C) in the standard AB-mix (Table II) is similar to that in the acrylamide-bisacrylamide stock solution used in the Laemmli system (30.8% T, 2.6% C). AB-mix H with doubled cross-linker concentration makes gels more brittle; however, there are advantages in separation of small proteins (<5 kDa).
D. Sample Preparation and Protein Loading Mix solutions or suspensions of membrane proteins (or of water-soluble proteins) with stock solutions A-D (Table IV). Use 3 volumes of sample and 1 volume of buffer; however, samples that have been highly concentrated or pelleted should be incubated with the diluted buffers A/4 or B/4. Incubate for 30 min at 40°C. Apply to the gel sample volun\es that are as small as possible. Thus, if the gel well is on the order of 5 x 0.7 mm, the sample size ideally is 5 jA or less. Using small sample volumes (and low SDS concentrations) is particularly important when proteins smaller than 5 kDa are involved. 1. Restrictions to Protein Load by SDS and Volume Limits Stacking, especially of small proteins, and separation of the bulk of free SDS within the stacking gel, works best at low SDS/protein ratios. However, the presence on nonprotein compounds—for instance, detergents and lipids — often requires addition of high amounts of SDS, so a standard incubation solution with high SDS content is recommended (Table IV). Starting with biological membranes having high lipid/protein ratios, such as mitochondria, high SDS/protein ratios must be used (about 500 /ig of SDS per
94
Hermann Schagger
TABLE IV
Stock Solutions for Protein Incubation in SDS Stock
Composition
Application
A (standard)
12% SDS (w/v), 6% mercaptoethanol, 30% glycerol (w/v), 0.05% Serva blue G, 150 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.0 Stock A, but without mercaptoethanol Stock A and B, but without glycerol
Low-density samples
C and D-^
A/4 and B/4
Stock A and B, but diluted with 3 volumes of water
Low-density samples High-density samples (in >20% glycerol; from sucrose density gradients; in > 4 M urea) Pelleted samples
" Buffers C and D were introduced because with high-density samples there is often retention of proteins on the walls of the gel well, resulting in uneven penetration of proteins into the gel.
10 jUg of total mitochondrial protein). The solubilization of 10 jUg of mitochondrial proteins therefore requires addition of a minimum of 15 /il of buffers A/4 or B/4. This volume of 16 jA is the maximum volume applicable to a 5 X 0.7 mm gel well if high-quality resolution is to be maintained, and 10 fig of mitochondrial protein therefore is the maximum load in this special case. Note: The concentration of SDS in the sample should be at least 4 times the concentration of the detergent present in the sample. Using lower ratios may lead to broadening or loss of bands and appearance of multiple bands representing different unfolded states of the proteins. 2. Temperature Effects on SDS-Denatured Membrane Proteins Incubation of the sample in SDS at a temperature above 90°C is widely used for water-soluble proteins; however, this "boiling" can lead to considerable problems with membrane proteins. Incubation at temperatures above 40-50°C may lead to aggregation and complete loss of membrane proteins from the sample. We assume that hydrophobic intramolecular domains are unfolding at high temperatures and intermolecular hydrophobic interactions are developing during cooling. A 30 min incubation in SDS at 40°C, as used in the standard protein incubation, usually is sufficient for membrane and water-soluble proteins. Prolonged incubation or repeated freezing and thawing may lead to further broadening of membrane protein bands. This can cause problems in analysis of the gels, since membrane protein bands are
95
CHAPTER 4 SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
generally broader than bands for water-soluble proteins, and they are often poorly stained by Coomassie dyes. Note: Incubation in SDS solution is ineffective at acidic p H and at temperatures below 20°C.
E. Electrophoresis Conditions The specific conditions for electrophoresis are, of course, dependent on the apparatus, acrylamide concentration, temperature, gel length, and thickness. Table V lists voltage parameters for a number of situations. Some experimental hints are as follows. Do not overestimate the capacity of heat distribution when using a cooled apparatus. The increased resistance at lower temperature must be compensated by increasing the voltage, and hence more heat is produced. "Smiling" of bands, separation of the gel from the glass plates, and cracking of the glass plates may occur. The electrophoresis conditions (Table V) refer to "room temperature" without intensive cooling. Gels may warm to about 40°C during the run. The initial voltage for each run is 30 V until the sample completely enters the stacking gel. The quality of the stacking effect improves with increasing voltage during the passage through the stacking gel; however, the maximum voltage is limited by increased heat production (see Table V). Approaching the end of the run, voltage can be gradually raised to shorten the total time of electrophoresis. The initial high-voltage step as proteins move through the stacking gel is recommended even for gels that are run overnight at reduced voltage. Finally,
TABLE V
Maximal Voltage Settings for Different Gel Types Small-pore- gel
Voltage setting
Gel type
Length (cm)
Thickness (mm)
Initial" (V)
End of run^ (V)
1. 10% T 2. 10% T 3. 16.5% T
12 12 12
0.7 1.6 0.7
250 180 280
4. 16.5% T
12
1.6
180 130 200 100 90
Time 4hr 6hr 6hr Overnight Overnight
"Initial voltage settings (after sample penetration at 30 V) are maximal settings for the given gel length and thickness. Use lower settings for preliminary trials and control the temperature of the glass plates. With shorter as well as thicker gels the voltage must be reduced to avoid cracking of the glass plates. ^ After the electrophoresis run is more than half completed, the voltage setting can be gradually increased to the maximal values listed.
96
Hermann Schagger
fast runs give better results than overnight runs; 10% gels are not run overnight because of considerable band broadening by diffusion.
F. Staining and Drying of High Percentage Polyacrylamide Gels The Coomassie staining procedure, some details of which are given in Table VI, works well for membrane proteins. Peptides in the range 1-2 kDa, however, need a special pretreatment because they are not effectively fixed in the gel by methanol (or by trichloroacetic acid). For the small peptides use the following protocol: 1. Incubate the gel for 60 min in IM potassium phosphate, 5% glutaraldehyde, pH 7.2. (Note: SDS-protein complexes precipitate in the presence of potassium ions; this stabilizes the complexes in the gel until fixation by glutaraldehyde occurs). 2. Continue with the standard staining procedure (Table VI), but avoid overnight destaining in 10% acetic acid, which may lead to the disappearance of stained peptide bands. Gels with high acrylamide and high cross-linker concentration are brittle and need special handling to prevent cracking during drying procedures. To
TABLE VI
Coomassie Blue Staining of High Percentage Acrylamide Gels'*
Fixation:
50% methanol/10% acetic acid
Staining:
10% acetic acid/0.025% SBG^
Destaining:
10% acetic acid
Gel (0.7 mm)
Time (min)
10% T 16.5% T 10% T 16.5% T 10% T 16.5% T
15 30 15-30 30-60 2 X 15^ 2 x30^
"Fixation in 50% methanol removes protein-bound SDS with concomitant shrinking of the gels. Staining without methanol has several advantages: (1) gels swell again and thereby rapidly take up the dye, and thus separate fixation and staining steps consume much less time, even with high percentage acrylamide gels, than does a one-step fixation/staining procedure with the dye in the fixing solution; (2) in the absence of methanol, Coomassie blue will bind to proteins that would otherwise stain poorly and not be detected; (3) low dye concentration can be used, proteins are detected during staining, and the staining step may be shortened. '' SBG (Serva blue G 250) is synonymous with Coomassie blue G 250. ''Destaining is enhanced by changing the 10% acetic acid solution (perhaps more than once) at the indicated intervals.
CHAPTER 4 SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
97
reduce cracking, shrink the stained gels by incubation in 50% methanol, 2% glycerol (30-60 n\in), then dry under vacuum at elevated temperature. Note: Do not use a liquid nitrogen trap when drying these gels because of the danger of explosion of methanol in the presence of condensed oxygen!
IV. RECOVERY OF PROTEINS FROM SDS GELS Most water-soluble, but only some membrane proteins, can be recovered from methanol-fixed and Coomassie-stained SDS gels as described in Section A. This is the simplest and most effective way. Only nonextractable membrane proteins are processed as described in Section B.
A. Recovery of Proteins from Fixed and Coomassie-Stained SDS Gels 1. Remove acetic acid from a Coomassie-stained gel strip completely by repeated incubation in water. 2. Transfer the strip to 0.05% SDS, 20 mM ammonium hydrogen carbonate (about 10-fold volume of the gel-strip; pH is around 9-10), and let the proteins diffuse out of the gel for two days at room temperature (depends on protein size, acrylamide concentration, and thickness of the gel). 3. Collect the solution of extracted proteins, and concentrate by SpeedVac centrifugation. 4. Fix, and restain the gel-strip as summarized in Table VI. Comparison of an original gel-strip and the restained gel-strip will show whether the desired proteins are extractable this way. If they are extractable, apply steps 1 to 3 with protein bands excised from preparative gels. If the desired proteins are not extractable, follow protocol B and C.
B. Blue-SDS-PAGE Coomassie blue-SDS-PAGE was developed for direct visualization of proteins and peptides during electrophoresis (Schagger et ah, 1988). Since proteins are stained during the run, and any fixation step is avoided, protein recovery is almost quantitative for water-soluble and membrane proteins. The Coomassie blue-SDS-PAGE approach is derived from published electrophoretic techniques, including Tricine-SDS-PAGE (Schagger and von Jagow, 1987) and SDS-PAGE according to LaemmH (1970). However, two small but important modifications have been introduced: (1) the SDS concentration in the cathode system of either electrophoresis system is reduced from 0.1 to 0.05% SDS; and (2) 25 mg of highly pure Coomassie dyes (Serva blue G, R, or W) is added per liter of cathode buffer.
98
Hermann Schagger
A
B
FIGURE 3
kDa
B
Comparison of protein band intensities obtained by direct staining during Coomassie blue-SDS-PAGE (right) and after conventional restaining of the same gels (left). (A) Proteins in the range 17-68 kDa were resolved by Coomassie blue-SDS-PAGE based on the Laemmli system in a 12% T, 3% C gel. (B) Proteins in the range 1.45-17 kDa were resolved by Coomassie blue-SDS-PAGE based on the Tricine system in a 16.5% T, 6% C gel. The minimal load of each protein and peptide was 0.27 ^g/mm^. The highest load was 2.2 jUg/mm^ in A and 0.82 /zg/mm^ in B. Reprinted from Schagger et at. (1988), with permission from Analytical Biochemistry.
The reduction of SOS concentration allows the dye to bind to proteins despite the presence of SDS, and the proteins migrate as blue bands through the gel (Fig. 3). The migration velocities of proteins usually are similar to those of standard SDS-PAGE, but occasionally inversal of the running distances of two proteins with similar migration velocities was observed. Staining intensities of bands during Blue-SDS-PAGE are much lower compared to conventional fixation and staining, because of the competitive binding of SDS and Coomassie dye and the background of free Coomassie dye. Notes: Detection of blue protein bands (on a light screen) is best after fast runs. Stop the run earlier than usual, because the sharpness of the bands and the detection will decrease with the running distance. The detection limit is
CHAPTER 4 SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
99
about 1 fig protein, loaded onto a 5 x 0.7 mm gel well. Cut bands out of the gel shortly after the run because the bands disappear with time due to diffusion. Excise the most essential bands first, since after the first cut, protein bands directly below and above the cut may no longer be detectable.
C. Recovery of Membrane Proteins after Blue-SDS-PAGE 1. Electroelution Protein electroelution from blue SDS gels is performed at room temperature, using an electoelutor/concentrator made according to Hunkapiller et ah (1983). The H-shaped elution chamber comprises two vertical tubes connected by a horizontal tube. The lower ends, sealed with dialysis membranes (cutoff value of 2 kDa), dip into the electrode buffer in the anodic and cathodic compartments of the electrophoresis tank. The electrode buffer is 100 mM NH4HCO3, 0.05% SDS. a. Use preferentially Laemmli gels because of their low ionic strength, which facilitates electroelution. b. Squeeze blue bands from blue SDS-PAGE through a syringe into the cathodic arm of the elutor chamber (only half-filled if Tricine gels were used), and cover the gel debris with the electrode buffer. c. Fill the residual chamber with 50 mM NH4HCO3 without SDS and electroelute at no more than 50 V for several hours. Protein, SDS, and Coomassie dye will be retained by the anodic dialysis membrane. d. Salt can be removed by dialysis at room temperature. SDS and salt can be removed by acetone precipitation (see Section V,3). 2. Elution by Diffusion The elution by diffusion technique is preferred for the recovery of proteins at the microscale (1-10 jUg) level, but it also works on a larger scale. With 0.7 m m gels it is not necessary to mash the gel pieces. Almost complete elution within 24 hr is usually achieved for the following protein sizes and acrylamide concentrations.
Gel type 16.5% T, 6% C 16.5% T, 3% C 10% T, 3% C
Protein size < 10 kDa < 20 kDa < 50 kDa
Time <24hr <24hr <24hr
a. Excise blue protein bands and incubate in a less than 10-fold volume of 0.05% SDS. b. Concentrate the eluate by SpeedVac centrifugation to the volume of the piece of gel.
100
Hermann Schagger
c. Dialyze to remove salt or add acetone to precipitate the protein (see Section V,3)-
V. PROCESSING OF PROTEINS RECOVERED FROM GELS FOR IMMUNIZATION AND PROTEIN SEQUENCING 1. Immunization Proteins recovered from fixed and Coomassie-stained SDS gels are almost free of salt, contain low amounts of SDS, and can be directly used for immunization or after concentration (SpeedVac). Proteins recovered from blue SDS gels by electroelution or diffusion should be dialyzed before immunization to remove lots of salt. 2. Protein Fragmentation and Protein Sequencing Use dialyzed protein samples before performing cleavage by proteases or with chemicals. The removal of salt facilitates separation of fragments by SDS-PAGE. The dialyzed sample can be used directly or after dilution with water for proteolytic fragmentation, since some specific proteases tolerate low SDS concentrations (0.05-0.1%). For chemical cleavage, dry aliquots by SpeedVac centrifugation. a. CNBr-cleavage usually is performed after resolubilization in, for example, 50-100 fil 80% formic acid. Formic acid can be removed after fragmentation in a desiccator over KOH. b. To cleave at tryptophan residues, resolubilize the sample with a small volume of 0.6% o-iodosobenzoic acid (at least 2 g / g protein) in 80% acetic acid followed by incubation for 24 hr at room temperature in the dark. This is a modification of the procedure developed by Mahoney et ah (1981). Acetic acid is removed by lyophilization after dilution with 9 volumes of water. c. Redissolve the dried samples by addition of a minimal volume of water or 0.5% mercaptoethanol, and separate the fragments by Tricine-SDSPAGE or by HPLC procedures (see Matsudaira, 1993). 3. Protein Precipitation from SDS Solutions a. Precipitate SDS-solubilized proteins by adding an equal volume of acetone, and store at — 20°C overnight. b. If salt has precipitated with the protein, try to redissolve the salt at room temperature or add 50% acetone. Notes: High salt concentrations are best reduced by dialysis before acetone precipitation. This precipitation method is applied only when removal of SDS is absolutely required. It works well with proteins that are larger than 20 kDa
CHAPTER 4 SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
101
and that are present in a reasonable concentration (say 0.1-1 mg/ml), but it usually fails with small proteins and peptides. In any case, an electrophoretic test of pellet and supernatant using a small aliquot is recommended. Dry completely both the pellet and the acetone supernatant in a water bath before redissolving and assaying by SDS-PAGE. 4. Removal of Proteins from PVDF Membranes Extract PVDF-bound proteins repeatedly with small volumes of 90% formic acid. The recovery (20-100%) is protein specific and depends of the protein load. Best extraction is achieved when the protein load is so high that protein stain is also detectable on the back side of the membrane—that is, when all binding surface is occupied. Recovery is better with membranes that the manufacturer has not specified for use in protein sequencing.
VI. ELECTROBLOTTING The semidry electroblotting method presented here (Schagger and von Jagow, 1991) is a modification of the procedure described by Kyhse-Andersen (1984). The modification compensates for the higher ionic strength of TricineSDS gels compared to Laemmli gels. Transfer of large membrane proteins from Tricine gels (running pH 8.5) is better than from Laemmli gels of equal acrylamide concentration (running pH 9.5), because the effective electrophoretic mobility of aminocaproic acid (pK 10.7) is so strongly reduced in the Tricine system that it migrates more slowly than even large membrane proteins (this is a stacking effect within a high percentage acrylamide gel). A further advantage of Tricine gels compared to Laemmli gels is the lower acrylamide concentration needed for separation. Note: The lower the acrylamide concentration of the gel, the better the transfer of proteins. A 40 kDa membrane protein, for example, may not be efficiently transferred at an acrylamide concentration above 10%. 1. Buffers for Electroblotting Cathode buffer: 300 mM 6-aminocaproic acid, 30 mM Tris (the pH is around 9.2; do not adjust the pH!). This is the lower buffer. Anode buffer: 300 mM Tris, 100 mM Tricine (the pH is around 8.7; do not adjust the pH!). This is the upper buffer. For binding of peptides ( < 5 kDa) to PVDF membranes, 20% methanol is added to the anode buffer, and PVDF membranes specified for protein sequencing purposes are used. 2. Electroblotting Assembly Invert the polarization or sequence within the electroblotting assembly if the lower electrode is the anode in your apparatus.
102
Hermann Schagger
a. Soak a 3 mm stack of papers with cathode buffer and place it on the lower electrode. b. Place the gel on top (without preincubation in any buffer). c. Cover the gel with a PVDF membrane (wetted with methanol p.A. and then incubated in anode buffer). d. Put a 3 mm stack of papers soaked with anode buffer on top of the PVDF membrane. e. Avoid expansion of the gel during protein transfer by placing a 5 kg load on top. 3. Transfer Conditions Transfer conditions for different gel types are as follows. The current should always be limited to 2 mA/cm^. The actual voltage generally is lower than the limit set (usually 7-11 V). Doubled thickness of the gel requires doubled transfer times. Gel type 10% T 16.5% T
Gel size (mm) 0.7x100x100 0.7x100x100
Voltage limit (V) Current limit (mA) Time (hr) 20 200 1.5 20 200 2.5
4. Staining of Proteins Transferred to PVDF Membranes a. Stain wet PVDF membranes for 5 min in 25% methanol p.A., 10% acetic acid p.A., 0.02% Serva blue G, R, or W. b. Reduce the degree of background stain by destaining in 25% methanol, 10% acetic acid (5 min, until the protein bands are clearly detected). c. After 5 min of incubation in distilled water, dry the PVDF membranes. The PVDF-bound proteins are then ready for N-terminal sequencing.
REFERENCES Ferguson, K. A. (1964). Starch gel electrophoresis—Application to the classification of pituary proteins and polypeptides. Metabolism 13 (No. 10, Part 2), 985-1002. Hames, B. D., and Rickwood, D. (eds.) (1998). "Gel Electrophoresis of Proteins—A Practical Approach.'' IRL Press, Oxford. Hunkapiller, M. W., Luijan, E., Ostrander, F., and Hood, L. E. (1983). Isolation of microgram quantities of proteins from polyacrylamide gels for amino acid sequence analysis. In ''Methods in Enzymology" (C. H. W. Hirs and S. N. Timasheff, eds.). Vol. 91, pp. 227-236. Acadenuc Press, New York. Kyhse-Andersen, J. (1984). Electroblotting of multiple gels: A simple apparatus without buffer tank for rapid transfer of proteins from polyacrylamide to nitrocellulose. /. Biochem. Biophys. Methods 10, 203-209. Laemmli, U. K. (1970). Cleavage of structural proteins during assembly of the head of bacteriophage T4. Nature (London) 227, 680-685.
CHAPTER 4 SDS Electrophoresis Techniques
103
Mahoney, W. C, Smith, P. K., and Hermodson, M. A. (1981). Fragmentation of proteins with o-iodoxybenzoic acid as a reactive contaminant that modifies tyrosyl residues. Biochemistry 20, 443-448. Matsudaira, P. T. (ed.) (1993). "A Practical Approach to Protein and Peptide Purification for Microsequencing.'' Academic Press, New York. Schagger, H., and von Jagow, G. (1987). Tricine-sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis for the separation of proteins in the range from 1 to 100 kDa. Anal. Biochem. 166, 368-379. Schagger, H., and von Jagow, G. (1991). Blue native electrophoresis for isolation of membrane protein complexes in enzymatically active form. Anal. Biochem. 199, 223-231. Schagger, H., Aquila, H., and von Jagow, G. (1988). Coomassie blue-sodium dodecyl sulfatepolyacrylamide gel electrophoresis for direct visualization of polypeptides during electrophoresis. Anal. Biochem. 173, 201-205.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
5
Blue Native Electrophoresis HERMANN SCHAGGER Zentrum der Biologischen Chemie Universitatsklinikum Frankfurt 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany
I. INTRODUCTION There are several options to perform native electrophoresis, and the blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis approach (BN-PAGE; Schagger and von Jagow, 1991; Schagger et ah, 1994) seems to be the best at eliminating common problems that arise when isolating membrane proteins: the tendency of membrane proteins to form aggregates and the danger of denaturation by extremes of pH or by detergent-dependent delipidation. This technique is described in detail following the brief discussions of alternate methods. Native electrophoresis often means using a standard SDS-electrophoresis protocol, such as the Laemmli Tris/glycine system (Laemmli, 1970), but omitting SDS from sample preparation and electrophoresis buffers or replac-
Membrane Protein Purification and Crystallization 2/e: A Practical Guide. Copyright 2003, Elsevier Science (USA) All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
105
106
Hermann Schagger
ing SDS with milder neutral detergents. These systems work with watersoluble proteins, but usually not with membrane proteins, which aggregate before entering the gel or are denatured by the detergent present in the gel. The running pH 9.5 in the Laemmli system guarantees that all proteins with isolectric points below pi 9.5 run to the anode, but it restricts the application to rather pH insensitive proteins and complexes. Colorless native PAGE (CN-PAGE; Schagger et al, 1994), which uses the same buffers and electrophoresis conditions as BN-PAGE but not Coomassie dyes, suffers from more protein aggregation than BN-PAGE. Additionally this technique is restricted to acidic proteins, since the running pH is 7.5. Another colorless PAGE that uses the buffers of BN-PAGE but introduces the anionic detergent taurodeoxycholate to induce a charge shift on the proteins is not restricted to acidic proteins (Schagger and von Jagow, 1991). This approach offers advantages for resolution of small proteins, but detergent-labile protein subunits usually dissociate from membrane protein complexes. Native isoelectric focusing (lEF without urea) of membrane proteins differs from lEF of water-soluble proteins only by the use of detergents. Examples of successful applications, such as, isolation of photosystem I and fumarate dehydrogenase in a form suitable for 3D-crystallization, are described in Chapters 6 and 13. This technique seems to work well with those membrane proteins that are soluble at very low ionic strength.
11. TECHNIQUES A. Native First Dimension: BN-PAGE BN-PAGE has been developed for the separation of membrane proteins and multiprotein complexes in the molecular mass range from about 10 kDa to 10,000 kDa (Schagger and von Jagow, 1991; Schagger et al, 1994; Schagger, 2000). The original protocols and related techniques were continuously improved and expanded as summarized here. It should be noted that a new buffer system is introduced for BN-PAGE. Bistris is now generally replaced by imidazole, which does not disturb protein determinations, and proteins now are preferentially solubilized at low ionic strength (50 mM NaCl) instead of using 500 mM aminocaproic acid. The basic principles of BN-PAGE, however, are unchanged. Mild neutral detergents are used for membrane protein solubilization, and Coomassie blue G 250 is added to the supernatant after centrifugation. This dye seems to bind to the surface of all membrane proteins but not to all water-soluble proteins. Binding of a large number of anionic dye molecules is the basis for the following useful effects.
CHAPTER 5 Blue Native Electrophoresis TABLE I
107
BUFFERS AND STOCK SOLUTIONS FOR BN-PAGE" Solution
Composition
Deep blue cathode buffer B^
50 mM Tricine, 7.5 mM imidazole (resulting pH around 7.0), and 0.02% Coomassie blue G 250 Similar to cathode buffer B but lower dye concentration (0.002%) 75 mM imidazole/HCl (pH 7.0), 1.5 M 6-aminocaproic acid'' 25 mM imidazole/HCl (pH 7.0) Suspended in 500 mM 6-aminocaproic acid 48 g acrylamide and 1.5 g bisacrylamide per 100 ml
Slightly blue cathode buffer B/IO*" Gel buffer (3 x); triple concentrated Anode buffer 5% Coomassie blue G 250 AB-mix (acrylamide-bisacrylamide mixture; 49.5% T, 3% O"
"Imidazole is introduced instead of previously used bistris because bistris disturbed many commonly used protein determinations. The imidazole concentrations required to obtain the desired pH are half the previous bistris concentrations. ^Stir cathode buffer B for several hours, and store it at room temperature. During prolonged storage at low temperature Coomassie dye forms aggregates, which can prevent proteins from entering the gel. ^Cathode buffer B/10 and all other solutions are stored at 7°C. ''6-aminocaproic acid is not essential for BN-PAGE, but it improves protein solubility, and it is an efficient and cheap serin protease inhibitor. We did not observe protease degradation after BN-PAGE when the gels (protected by the glass plates) were stored for several days at 4°C. ^ %T, Total concentration of acrylamide and bisacrylamide monomers, %C, percentage of crosslinker to total monomer.
1. Coomassie dye binding shifts the isoelectric points of proteins to the negative. All proteins, even basic ones like cytochrome c, therefore migrate to the anode at the running pH 7.5. However, BN-PAGE does not separate according to the charge/mass ratio. The separating principle is the decreasing pore size of the acrylamide-gradient gel, which leads to a mass-dependent reduction of the protein migration velocity and to an almost complete stop at a mass-specific pore size limit. 2. The negative charges on the surfaces of individual proteins repel each other and reduce the danger of membrane protein aggregation considerably. 3. Membrane proteins with bound Coomassie dye are water-soluble. Therefore there is no need for the presence of detergent in the gel, and the risk of denaturation of detergent-sensitive membrane proteins is minimized. 4. Native proteins are visible as blue bands migrating through the gel. This staining of proteins in the native form facilitates excision of specific bands and recovery of native proteins by electroelution.
108
Hermann Schagger
TABLE II
GEL TYPES Molecular mass range (kDa)
Sample gel (% T)
Gradient separation gel (% T)
50-10,000 50-3000 50-1000 10-500
2.5-3.0'' 3.5 4.0 4.0
3^13 4->13 5->13 6^18
"The lowest polymerizing acrylamide concentration (which varies with the lot of acrylamide used) is required for complexes as large as 10,000 kDa. Use "analytical gels'' with dimensions 14 X 14 X 0.16 cm (sample wells 0.5 or 1 cm) or "preparative gels" with dimensions 14 X 14 X 0.3 cm (one 14 cm sample well). Gradient gel preparation is exemplified in Table III.
1. Materials Dodecyl-j8-D-maltoside, Triton X-100, and 6-aminocaproic acid can be purchased from Huka; acrylamide and bisacrylamide (the commercial twice crystallized products) and Coomassie blue dyes can be purchased from Serva; and digitonin can be purchased from Roth. All other chemicals can be purchased from Sigma. 2. Stock Solutions and Buffers The detergents dodecyl-j8-D-maltoside, Triton X-100, and digitonin are stored as 10% stock solutions. Digitonin, which precipitates at 4°C and also partly at room temperature, is redissolved by heating shortly before use. Stock solutions of Tricine (1 M), 6-aminocaproic acid (2 M), imidazole (1 M), and imidazole/HCl (1 M; pH 7.0) are stored at 7°C. Buffers for BN-PAGE and further stock solutions are listed in Table I. 3. Gel Types BN-PAGE separates proteins in the molecular mass range from 10 kDa to 10,000 kDa. A selection of gel types for optimal resolution of specific molecular mass ranges is given in Table II. Use only gradient gels overlaid with a large-pore sample gel.
4. Choice of Detergent and Detergent/Protein Ratio for BN-PAGE Any neutral detergent, and also mild anionic detergents like taurodeoxycholic acid, can be used for solubilization of biological membranes. We preferentially use dodecyl-j8-D-maltoside, Triton X-100, and digitonin. Digitonin usually retains physiological protein-protein interactions best, and
109
CHAPTER 5 Blue Native Electrophoresis TABLE III
GRADIENT GEL PREPARATION" Gradient separation gel
AB-mix Gel buffer (3 x ) Glycerol Water APS10%^ TEMED Total volume
Sample gel 4% T
5%T
13% T
0.5 ml 2 ml
1.88 ml 6 ml
—
—
3.9 ml 5 ml 3g 3 ml 75/il 7.5 fA 15 ml
3.5 ml 50 fA 5fil 6 ml
10 ml 100/^1 10 fi\ 18 ml
''Volumes for one analytical gel (14 x 14 x 0.16 cm). Linear gradient separation gels are cast at 4°C and maintained at room temperature for polymerization. The volume of the 5% T solution is larger than that of the 13% T solution containing glycerol. This assures that the two solutions initially are not mixed when the connecting tube is opened. The sample gel is cast at room temperature. After removal of the combs, gels are overlaid with gel buffer (1 x) and stored at 4°C. ''APS10% is 10% aqueous ammonium persulfate solution, freshly prepared.
it is especially useful for isolation of physiological supercomplexes. DodecyljS-D-maltoside and Triton X-100, in contrast, usually split the supercomplexes into separate complexes. As a first rule of thumb, bacterial membranes are solubilized by using a detergent/protein ratio of 1 g Triton or 0.75 g dodecylmaltoside or 2 g digitonin per gram of total protein. Mitochondrial membranes require a doubled detergent/protein ratio. However, as a second general rule, don't use a single detergent/protein ratio for first trials, but solubilize several aliquots with increasing amounts of detergent—for example, to obtain Triton/protein ratios of 0.4, 0.75, 1.5, 3.0 (g/g) for bacterial membranes — so at least one detergent/protein ratio is below the solubilization limit. At least one of the higher detergent/protein ratios should then guarantee complete solubilization with low risk of dissociation of subunits. Native electroblotting after BN-PAGE and antibody detection reveals which minimal detergent/protein ratio is required to solubilize and detect the desired protein, and it might also indicate detergent or detergent/ protein-dependent variations of the running distance of the interesting protein in BN-PAGE. Since BN-PAGE separates according to molecular mass, such variations of running distance can provide first hints for a transition from dimeric to monomeric state, for association or dissociation of unknown protein components, and for dissociation of subunits from subcomplexes.
110
Hermann Schagger
A
B Triton X-100/prottln
DDM/protein OJ
1.6
{gig)
0.4
0.6
0.8
10
1.2
14
16
2.4
(gig)
Lmj%
DDM 1J
Comptex
DIgltonIn 10
4.
15
2.0
i
3.0
4.0
8.0
^
(9
^
hlilatVi I1IH2
- ^ tMor»
HI—
^: i i i i ^ i l
iiiia
ig)
— llMon
CHAPTER 5 Blue Native Electrophoresis
111
5. General Scheme of Sample Preparation for BN-PAGE and Preparation of a Molecular Mass Standard from Bovine Heart Mitochondria Many special protocols for the sample preparation for BN-PAGE have been described: from isolated bovine and yeast mitochondria (Arnold et ah, 199