Edited by Margrit Hanbu¨cken, Pierre Mu¨ller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale
Related Titles ...
44 downloads
1959 Views
42MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Edited by Margrit Hanbu¨cken, Pierre Mu¨ller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale
Related Titles Alkauskas, A., Deák, P., Neugebauer, J., Pasquarello, A., Van de Walle, C. G. (eds.)
Advanced Calculations for Defects in Materials Electronic Structure Methods 402 pages with 118 figures 2011 Hardcover ISBN: 978-3-527-41024-8
Jackson, K. A.
Kinetic Processes Crystal Growth, Diffusion, and Phase Transitions in Materials 453 pages with 291 figures 2010 Hardcover
Zehetbauer, M. J., Zhu, Y. T. (eds.)
Bulk Nanostructured Materials 736 pages with 366 figures and 31 tables 2009 Hardcover ISBN: 978-3-527-31524-6
Cazacu, O. (ed.)
Multiscale Modeling of Heterogenous Materials From Microstructure to Macro-Scale Properties 343 pages 2008 Hardcover ISBN: 978-1-84821-047-9
ISBN: 978-3-527-32736-2
Birkholz, M.
Stallinga, P.
Thin Film Analysis by X-Ray Scattering
Electrical Characterization of Organic Electronic Materials and Devices 316 pages 2009 Hardcover ISBN: 978-0-470-75009-4
Sharing the Planet’s Freshwater Resources 378 pages with 175 figures and 28 tables 2006 Hardcover ISBN: 978-3-527-31052-4
Edited by Margrit Hanbücken, Pierre Müller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn
Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale Simulation, Material Systems and Characterization Techniques
The Editors Dr. Margrit Hanbücken CINaM-CNRS Campus Luminy Marseille, Frankreich Dr. Pierre Müller Université Paul Cézanne Campus Saint-Jérôme Marseille, Frankreich Prof. Dr. Ralf B. Wehrspohn Fraunhofer Inst. für Werkstoffmechanik Halle Halle, Germany
All books published by Wiley-VCH are carefully produced. Nevertheless, authors, editors, and publisher do not warrant the information contained in these books, including this book, to be free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate. Library of Congress Card No.: applied for British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available on the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de. # 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag & Co. KGaA, Boschstr. 12, 69469 Weinheim, Germany All rights reserved (including those of translation into other languages). No part of this book may be reproduced in any form – by photoprinting, microfilm, or any other means – nor transmitted or translated into a machine language without written permission from the publishers. Registered names, trademarks, etc. used in this book, even when not specifically marked as such, are not to be considered unprotected by law. Typesetting Thomson Digital, Noida, India Printing Binding Cover Design Grafik-Design Schulz, Fußgönheim Printed in Singapore Printed on acid-free paper Print ISBN: 978-3-527-41066-8 ePDF ISBN: 978-3-527-63956-4 oBook ISBN: 978-3-527-63954-0 ePub ISBN: 978-3-527-63955-7
V
Contents Preface XV List of Contributors
XVII
Part One Fundamentals of Stress and Strain on the Nanoscale 1 1 1.1 1.1.1 1.1.2 1.1.3 1.2 1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.3 1.2.4 1.3 1.3.1 1.3.2 1.4 1.4.1 1.4.2 1.4.3 1.5 1.5.1 1.5.2 1.5.3 1.5.4 1.5.5 1.6 1.6.1
Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics 3 Frank Glas Basics of Elastic Strain Relaxation 3 Introduction 3 Principles of Calculation 4 Methods of Calculation: A Brief Overview 6 Elastic Strain Relaxation in Inhomogeneous Substitutional Alloys 7 Spinodal Decomposition with No Elastic Effects 8 Elastic Strain Relaxation in an Alloy with Modulated Composition 9 Strain Stabilization and the Effect of Elastic Anisotropy 11 Elastic Relaxation in the Presence of a Free Surface 11 Diffusion 12 Diffusion without Elastic Effects 12 Diffusion under Stress in an Alloy 13 Strain Relaxation in Homogeneous Mismatched Epitaxial Layers 14 Introduction 14 Elastic Strain Relaxation 15 Critical Thickness 16 Morphological Relaxation of a Solid under Nonhydrostatic Stress 17 Introduction 17 Calculation of the Elastic Relaxation Fields 18 ATG Instability 19 Kinetics of the ATG Instability 21 Coupling between the Morphological and Compositional Instabilities 21 Elastic Relaxation of 0D and 1D Epitaxial Nanostructures 22 Quantum Dots 23
VI
Contents
1.6.2
Nanowires 24 References 24
2
Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity 27 Pierre Müller Introduction 27 Theoretical Background 28 Bulk Elasticity: A Recall 28 Stress and Strain Definition 29 Equilibrium State 29 Elastic Energy 30 Elastic Constants 30 How to Describe Surfaces or Interfaces? 31 Surfaces and Interfaces Described from Excess Quantities 34 The Surface Elastic Energy as an Excess of the Bulk Elastic Energy 34 The Surface Stress and Surface Strain Concepts 35 Surface Elastic Constants 37 Connecting Surface and Bulk Stresses 39 Surface Stress and Surface Tension 40 Surface Stress and Adsorption 41 The Case of Glissile Interfaces 42 Surfaces and Interfaces Described as a Foreign Material 42 The Surface as a Thin Bulk-Like Film 43 The Surface as an Elastic Membrane 43 Applications: Size Effects Due to the Surfaces 44 Lattice Contraction of Nanoparticles 44 Effective Modulus of Thin Freestanding Plane Films 46 Bending, Buckling, and Free Vibrations of Thin Films 48 General Equations 48 Discussion 50 Static Bending of Nanowires: An Analysis of the Recent Literature 52 Young Modulus versus Size: Two-Phase Model 52 Young Modulus versus Size: Surface Stress Model 53 Prestress Bulk Due to Surface Stresses 53 A Short Overview of Experimental Difficulties 54 Conclusion 55 References 56
2.1 2.2 2.2.1 2.2.1.1 2.2.1.2 2.2.1.3 2.2.1.4 2.2.2 2.2.3 2.2.3.1 2.2.3.2 2.2.3.3 2.2.3.4 2.2.3.5 2.2.3.6 2.2.3.7 2.2.4 2.2.4.1 2.2.4.2 2.3 2.3.1 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.3.3.1 2.3.3.2 2.3.4 2.3.4.1 2.3.4.2 2.3.4.3 2.3.5 2.4
3 3.1 3.2
Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials 61 Laurent Pizzagalli, Sandrine Brochard, and Julien Godet Introduction 61 The Role of Dislocations 63
Contents
3.3 3.3.1 3.3.2 3.3.3 3.4 3.4.1 3.4.2 3.4.3 3.4.4 3.5 3.5.1 3.5.2 3.5.3 3.5.4 3.6 3.6.1 3.6.2 3.6.3 3.6.4 3.7 3.8
4
4.1 4.2 4.2.1 4.2.2 4.2.3 4.3 4.3.1 4.3.2 4.3.3 4.4 4.4.1 4.4.2 4.4.3 4.5
Driving Forces for Dislocations 63 Stress 64 Thermal Activation 64 Combination of Stress and Thermal Activation 64 Dislocation and Surfaces: Basic Concepts 65 Forces Related to Surface 65 Balance of Forces for Nucleation 66 Forces Due to Lattice Friction 66 Surface Modifications Due to Dislocations 68 Elastic Modeling 68 Elastic Model 68 Predicted Activation Parameters 70 What is Missing? 70 Peierls–Nabarro Approaches 72 Atomistic Modeling 72 Examples of Simulations 73 Determination of Activation Parameters 74 Comparison with Experiments 75 Influence of Surface Structure, Orientation, and Chemistry 76 Extension to Different Geometries 78 Discussion 79 References 80 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations 83 Christine Mottet Introduction 84 Theoretical Models and Numerical Simulations Energetic Models 85 Numerical Simulations 87 Definitions of Physical Quantities 89 Relaxations in Surfaces and Interfaces 91 Surface Reconstructions 92 Surface Alloys: a Simple Case of Heteroatomic Adsorption 94 Heteroepitaxial Thin Films 96 Relaxations in Nanoclusters 98 Free Nanoclusters 99 Supported Nanoclusters 100 Nanoalloys 101 Conclusions 103 References 104
85
VII
VIII
Contents
Part Two Model Systems with Stress-Engineered Properties 5
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.4.1 5.4.2 5.4.3 5.4.4 5.5
6
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.3.1 6.3.2 6.3.3 6.3.3.1 6.3.3.2 6.4 6.5
7 7.1 7.2 7.2.1 7.2.2 7.2.2.1 7.2.2.2 7.2.3
107
Accommodation of Lattice Misfit in Semiconductor Heterostructure Nanowires 109 Volker Schmidt and Joerg V. Wittemann Introduction 109 Dislocations in Axial Heterostructure Nanowires 111 Dislocations in Core–Shell Heterostructure Nanowires 113 Roughening of Core–Shell Heterostructure Nanowires 115 Zeroth-Order Stress and Strain 117 First-Order Contribution to Stress and Strain 120 Linear Stability Analysis 122 Results and Discussion 124 Conclusion 127 References 127 Strained Silicon Nanodevices 131 Manfred Reiche, Oussama Moutanabbir, Jan Hoentschel, Angelika Hähnel, Stefan Flachowsky, Ulrich Gösele, and Manfred Horstmann Introduction 131 Impact of Strain on the Electronic Properties of Silicon 132 Methods to Generate Strain in Silicon Devices 135 Substrates for Nanoscale CMOS Technologies 135 Local Strain 136 Global Strain 139 Biaxially Strained Layers 139 Uniaxially Strained Layers 142 Strain Engineering for 22 nm CMOS Technologies and Below 142 Conclusions 146 References 146 Stress-Driven Nanopatterning in Metallic Systems 151 Vincent Repain, Sylvie Rousset, and Shobhana Narasimhan Introduction 151 Surface Stress as a Driving Force for Patterning at Nanometer Length Scales 152 Surface Stress 152 Surface Reconstruction and Misfit Dislocations 153 Homoepitaxial Surfaces 153 Heteroepitaxial Systems 155 Stress Domains 156
Contents
7.2.4 7.3 7.3.1 7.3.1.1 7.3.1.2 7.3.1.3 7.4 7.4.1 7.4.2 7.5
8
8.1 8.2 8.2.1 8.2.1.1 8.2.1.2
8.2.1.3 8.2.2 8.2.2.1 8.2.2.2 8.2.2.3 8.3 8.3.1 8.3.2 8.3.2.1 8.3.2.2 8.3.2.3 8.3.3 8.3.3.1 8.3.3.2 8.4
Vicinal Surfaces 157 Nanopatterned Surfaces as Templates for the Ordered Growth of Functionalized Nanostructures 158 Metallic Ordered Growth on Nanopatterned Surface 158 Introduction 158 Nucleation and Growth Concepts 159 Heterogeneous Growth 160 Stress Relaxation by the Formation of Surface-Confined Alloys 162 Two-Component Systems 162 Three-Component Systems 162 Conclusion 164 References 165 Semiconductor Templates for the Fabrication of Nano-Objects 169 Joël Eymery, Laurence Masson, Houda Sahaf, and Margrit Hanbücken Introduction 169 Semiconductor Template Fabrication 170 Artificially Prepatterned Substrates 170 Morphological Patterning 170 Silicon Etched Stripes: Example of the Use of Strain to Control Nanostructure Formation and Physical Properties 171 Use of Buried Stressors 171 Patterning through Vicinal Surfaces 173 Generalities 173 Vicinal Si(111) 173 Vicinal Si(100) 173 Ordered Growth of Nano-Objects 175 Growth Modes and Self-Organization 175 Quantum Dots and Nanoparticles Self-Organization with Control in Size and Position 176 Stranski–Krastanov Growth Mode 176 Au/Si(111) System 177 Ge/Si(001) System 179 Wires: Catalytic and Catalyst-Free Growths with Control in Size and Position 179 Strain in Bottom-Up Wire Heterostructures: Longitudinal and Radial Heterostructures 181 Wires as a Position Controlled Template 183 Conclusions 184 References 184
IX
X
Contents
Part Three Characterization Techniques of Measuring Stresses on the Nanoscale 189 9
9.1 9.1.1 9.1.2 9.1.3 9.2 9.2.1 9.2.2 9.2.3 9.2.4 9.2.5 9.3 9.3.1 9.3.2 9.3.3 9.3.4 9.4 9.4.1 9.4.2 9.4.2.1 9.4.2.2 9.4.3 9.4.3.1 9.4.3.2 9.4.3.3 9.4.4 9.5
Strain Analysis in Transmission Electron Microscopy: How Far Can We Go? 191 Anne Ponchet, Christophe Gatel, Christian Roucau, and Marie-José Casanove Introduction: How to Get Quantitative Information on Strain from TEM 192 Displacement, Strain, and Stress in Elasticity Theory 192 Principles of TEM and Application to Strained Nanosystems 192 A Major Issue for Strained Nanostructure Analysis: The Thin Foil Effect 193 Bending Effects in Nanometric Strained Layers: A Tool for Probing Stress 194 Bending: A Relaxation Mechanism 194 Relation between Curvature and Internal Stress 195 Using the Bending as a Probe of the Epitaxial Stress: The TEM Curvature Method 196 Occurrence of Large Displacements in TEM Thinned Samples 197 Advantages and Limits of Bending as a Probe of Stress in TEM 199 Strain Analysis and Surface Relaxation in Electron Diffraction 199 CBED: Principle and Application to Determination of Lattice Parameters 199 Strain Determination in CBED 201 Use and Limitations of CBED in Strain Determination 202 Nanobeam Electron Diffraction 203 Strain Analysis from HREM Image Analysis: Problematic of Very Thin Foils 203 Principle 203 What Do We Really Measure in an HREM Image? 205 Image Formation 205 Reconstruction of the 3D Strain Field from a 2D Projection 205 Modeling the Surface Relaxation in an HREM Experiment 206 Full Relaxation (Uniaxial Stress) 206 Intermediate Situations: Usefulness of Finite Element Modeling 207 Thin Foil Effect: A Source of Incertitude in HREM 207 Conclusion: HREM is a Powerful but Delicate Method of Strain Analysis 208 Conclusions 209 References 210
Contents
10
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.4.1 10.4.2 10.5 10.6 10.7 10.8
11
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.4.1 11.4.2 11.4.3 11.5 11.5.1 11.5.1.1 11.5.1.2 11.5.1.3 11.5.2 11.6 11.7
12
12.1 12.2 12.2.1 12.2.2
Determination of Elastic Strains Using Electron Backscatter Diffraction in the Scanning Electron Microscope 213 Michael Krause, Matthias Petzold, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn Introduction 213 Generation of Electron Backscatter Diffraction Patterns 214 Strain Determination Through Lattice Parameter Measurement 215 Strain Determination Through Pattern Shift Measurement 216 Linking Pattern Shifts to Strain 216 Measurement of Pattern Shifts 219 Sampling Strategies: Sources of Errors 221 Resolution Considerations 222 Illustrative Application 225 Conclusions 229 References 230 X-Ray Diffraction Analysis of Elastic Strains at the Nanoscale 233 Olivier Thomas, Odile Robach, Stéphanie Escoubas, Jean-Sébastien Micha, Nicolas Vaxelaire, and Olivier Perroud Introduction 233 Strain Field from Intensity Maps around Bragg Peaks 234 Average Strains from Diffraction Peak Shift 236 Local Strains Using Submicrometer Beams and Scanning XRD 240 Introduction 240 High-Energy Monochromatic Beam: 3DXRD 241 White Beam: Laue Microdiffraction 243 Local Strains Derived from the Intensity Distribution in Reciprocal Space 248 Periodic Assemblies of Identical Objects with Coherence Length > Few Periods 248 Introduction 248 Reciprocal Space Mapping 249 Applications 251 Single-Object Coherent Diffraction 252 Phase Retrieval from Strained Crystals 254 Conclusions and Perspectives 255 References 256 Diffuse X-Ray Scattering at Low-Dimensional Structures in the System SiGe/Si 259 Michael Hanke Introduction 259 Self-Organized Growth of Mesoscopic Structures 259 The Stranski–Krastanow Process 260 LPE-Grown Si1xGex/Si(001) Islands 261
XI
XII
Contents
12.3 12.3.1 12.3.2 12.3.3 12.4 12.5 12.5.1 12.5.2 12.5.3 12.5.4 12.6
X-Ray Scattering Techniques 262 High-Resolution X-Ray Diffraction 262 Grazing Incidence Diffraction 263 Grazing Incidence Small-Angle X-Ray Scattering 264 Data Evaluation 265 Results 266 The Influence of Shape and Size on the GISAXS Signal 266 HRXRD Measurement of Strain and Composition 269 Positional Correlation Effects in HRXRD 270 Iso-Strain Scattering 271 Summary 273 References 274
13
Direct Measurement of Elastic Displacement Modes by Grazing Incidence X-Ray Diffraction 275 Geoffroy Prévot Introduction 275 Elastic Displacement Modes: Analysis and GIXD Observation 276 Fundamentals of Linear Elasticity in Direct Space 276 Basic Equations 276 Atomic Displacements and Elastic Interactions 277 Greens Tensor in Reciprocal Space 279 Grazing Incidence X-Ray Diffraction of Elastic Modes 280 Diffraction by a Surface 280 Contribution of the Elastic Modes 280 Procedure for Analyzing the Systems 281 Self-Organized Surfaces 282 Force Distribution and Interaction Energy for Self-Organized Surfaces 282 A 1D Case: OCu(110) 283 A 2D Case: NCu(001) 286 Vicinal Surfaces 289 Force Distribution and Interaction Energy for Steps 289 Experimental Results for Vicinal Surfaces of Transition Metals 292 Conclusion 294 References 295
13.1 13.2 13.2.1 13.2.1.1 13.2.1.2 13.2.2 13.2.3 13.2.3.1 13.2.3.2 13.2.3.3 13.3 13.3.1 13.3.2 13.3.3 13.4 13.4.1 13.4.2 13.5
14
14.1 14.2 14.2.1 14.2.2
Submicrometer-Scale Characterization of Solar Silicon by Raman Spectroscopy 299 Michael Becker, George Sarau, and Silke Christiansen Introduction 299 Crystal Orientation 300 Qualitative Maps 300 Quantitative Analysis 302
Contents
14.2.3 14.3 14.3.1 14.3.2 14.3.2.1 14.3.2.2 14.3.3 14.3.4 14.3.4.1 14.3.4.2 14.3.5 14.3.5.1 14.3.5.2 14.3.5.3
14.3.6 14.4 14.4.1 14.4.2 14.4.2.1 14.4.2.2 14.4.2.3 14.4.3 14.4.4 14.5
15 15.1 15.2 15.3 15.3.1 15.3.2 15.3.3 15.4
Comparison with Other Orientation Measurement Methods 306 Analysis of Stress and Strain States 307 General Theoretical Description 307 Quantitative Strain/Stress Analysis in Polycrystalline Silicon Wafers 309 Assumptions 309 Numerical Determination of Stress Components 310 Experimental Procedure to Determine Phonon Frequency Shifts 311 Additional Influences on the Phonon Frequency Shifts 311 Temperature 311 Drift of the Spectrometer Grating 313 Applications 313 Mechanical Stresses at the Backside of Silicon Solar Cells 313 Stress Fields at Microcracks in Polycrystalline Silicon Wafers 315 Stress States at Grain Boundaries in Polycrystalline Silicon Solar Cell Material and the Relation to the Grain Boundary Microstructure and Electrical Activity 316 Comparison with other Stress/Strain Measurement Methods 318 Measurement of Free Carrier Concentrations 318 Theoretical Description 319 Experimental Details 321 Small-Angle Beveling and Nomarski Differential Interference Contrast Micrographs 321 Evaluation of the Raman Data 322 Calibration Measurements 324 Experimental Results 324 Comparison with other Dopant Measurement Methods 328 Concluding Remarks 328 References 329 Strain-Induced Nonlinear Optics in Silicon 333 Clemens Schriever, Christian Bohley, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn Introduction 333 Fundamentals of Second Harmonic Generation in Nonlinear Optical Materials 334 Second Harmonic Generation and Its Relation to Structural Symmetry 336 Sources of Second Harmonic Signals 337 Bulk Contribution to Second Harmonic Generation 338 Surface Contribution to Second Harmonic Generation 341 Strain-Induced Modification of Second-Order Nonlinear Susceptibility in Silicon 343
XIII
XIV
Contents
15.5 15.5.1 15.5.2 15.6
Strained Silicon in Integrated Optics 348 Strain-Induced Electro-Optical Effect 348 Strain-Induced Photoelastic Effect 350 Conclusions 352 References 353 Index
357
XV
Preface The development of future integrated (‘‘smart’’) micro- and nanosystems is generally focusing on further improvements of functionality and performance, enhancement of miniaturization and integration density, and extension into new application fields. In addition to any of these technological developments, reliability, quality, and manufacturing yield are key prerequisites for the development of any complex innovative (‘‘smart’’) micro-/nanosystem application. Consequently, new methods, instruments, and tools adjusted to the specific boundary conditions of the miniaturization level down to the nanoscale have to be provided allowing the investigation and understanding of the microstructure, possible failure processes, and reliability risks. In addition, methods and tools allowing the addressing and measurement of locally affected material properties, such as residual stresses, in combination with the microstructure are required. Such instruments and techniques are required to support a focused and rapid technological development and the time-efficient design of components and smart systems. The particular results of microstructure and stress characterization do not only provide the basis for technological process step improvement but are also required for advanced simulation approaches and models that can be used to consider reliability properties already during the product development stage (‘‘design for reliability’’ concept). Such concepts gain increasing importance since they allow to reduce time-to-market and development cost. Present local stress and strain measurements on the nanoscale are based on special transmission electron microscopy techniques such as CBED, HRTEM-GPA, or holographic dark field technology, special scanning electron microscopy techniques such as EBSD or adapted X-ray diffraction techniques such as coherent X-ray diffraction. This book brings together leading groups in these different disciplines to apply these techniques for local strain and stress measurement and its theoretical background. The book consists of three parts. Part One addresses the fundamentals of stress and strain on the nanoscale including an introduction to thermodynamics, kinetics, and models of elasticity, plasticity, and relaxation. Part Two addresses applications where stress and strain on the nanoscale are relevant such as SiGe devices or nanowires. In Part Three, techniques for measuring stress and strain on the
XVI
Preface
nanoscale are presented such as CBED-TEM, EBSD-REM, different ways to use X-rays, Raman, and nonlinear optical methods. To our knowledge, it is for the first time that this compendium combines theory, measurement techniques, and applications for stress and strain on the nanoscale. We believe that with increasing complexity of nanoscale devices, the increasing amount of the integration of various technologies, and various aspect ratios, it will be crucial to understand in detail processes and phenomena of nanostress. This work was stimulated by the cooperation of the Fraunhofer Society, the MaxPlanck-Society, the Carnot Association, and the CNRS via the CNano-PACA. This book is dedicated to Prof. Ulrich Gösele, who coinitiated this project. February 28, 2011 Halle and Marseille
Ralf Wehrspohn Margrit Hanbücken Pierre Müller
XVII
List of Contributors Michael Becker Max Planck Institute of Microstructure Physics Experimental Department II Weinberg 2 06120 Halle Germany
Marie-José Casanove CNRS-UPS Centre d’Elaboration de Matériaux et d’Etudes Structurales 29, rue Jeanne Marvig, BP 94347 31055 Toulouse Cedex 4 France
Sandrine Brochard Institut PPRIME – CNRS UPR 3346 Département de Physique et de Mécanique des Matériaux Espace Phymat, BP 30179 86962 Futuroscope Chasseneuil Cedex France
Silke Christiansen Max Planck Institute for the Science of Light Guenther-Scharowsky – Str. 1 91058 Erlangen Germany
Christian Bohley Martin-Luther-University Institute of Physics Heinrich-Damerow – Str. 4 06120 Halle Germany and Martin-Luther-University Centre for Innovation Competence SiLi-nano Karl-Freiherr-von-Fritsch-Str. 3 06120 Halle (Saale), Germany
Stéphanie Escoubas Aix-Marseille Université IM2NP, Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Campus de Saint-Jérôme Avenue Escadrille Normandie Niemen, Case 142 13397 Marseille Cedex France and CNRS, IM2NP (UMR 6242) Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Campus de Saint-Jérôme Avenue Escadrille Normandie Niemen, Case 142 13397 Marseille Cedex France
XVIII
List of Contributors
Joël Eymery CEA/CNRS/Université Joseph Fourier CEA, INAC, SP2M 17 rue des Martyrs 38054 Grenoble Cedex 9 France
Angelika Hähnel Max Planck Institute of Microstructure Physics Weinberg 2 06120 Halle Germany
Stefan Flachowsky GLOBALFOUNDRIES Fab 1 Wilschdorfer Landstraße 101 01109 Dresden Germany
Margrit Hanbücken CINaM-CNRS Campus de Luminy, Case 913 3288 Marseille Cedex 9 France
Christophe Gatel CNRS-UPS Centre d’Elaboration de Matériaux et d’Etudes Structurales 29, rue Jeanne Marvig, BP 94347 31055 Toulouse Cedex 4 France
Michael Hanke Paul-Drude-Institute for Solid State Electronics Hausvogteiplatz 5-7 10117 Berlin Germany
Frank Glas CNRS Laboratoire de Photonique et de Nanostructures Route de Nozay 91460 Marcoussis France Julien Godet Institut PPRIME – CNRS UPR 3346 Département de Physique et de Mécanique des Matériaux Espace Phymat, BP 30179 86962 Futuroscope Chasseneuil Cedex France Ulrich Göseley Max Planck Institute of Microstructure Physics Weinberg 2 06120 Halle Germany
Jan Hoentschel GLOBALFOUNDRIES Fab 1 Wilschdorfer Landstraße 101 01109 Dresden Germany Manfred Horstmann GLOBALFOUNDRIES Fab 1 Wilschdorfer Landstraße 101 01109 Dresden Germany Michael Krause Fraunhofer IWM Walter-Hülse – Str. 1 06120 Halle Germany Laurence Masson CINaM-CNRS Campus de Luminy, Case 913 3288 Marseille Cedex 9 France
List of Contributors
Jean-Sébastien Micha INAC/SPrAM UMR 5819 (CEA-CNRS-UJF) CEA-Grenoble 17 rue des Martyrs 38054 Grenoble Cedex 9 France Christine Mottet CINaM – CNRS Campus de Luminy, Case 913 13288 Marseille Cedex 9 France Oussama Moutanabbir Max Planck Institute of Microstructure Physics Weinberg 2 06120 Halle Germany Pierre Müller Aix Marseille Université Center Interdisciplinaire de Nanoscience de Marseille UPR CNRS 3118 Campus de Luminy, Case 913 13288 Marseille Cedex 9 France Shobhana Narasimhan JNCASR Theoretical Sciences Unit Jakkur 560 064 Bangalore India
Olivier Perroud Aix-Marseille Université IM2NP, Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Campus de Saint-Jérôme Avenue Escadrille Normandie Niemen, Case 142 13397 Marseille Cedex France and CNRS, IM2NP (UMR 6242) Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Campus de Saint-Jérôme Avenue Escadrille Normandie Niemen, Case 142 13397 Marseille Cedex France Laurent Pizzagalli Institut PPRIME – CNRS UPR 3346 Département de Physique et de Mécanique des Matériaux Espace Phymat, BP 30179 86962 Futuroscope Chasseneuil Cedex France Anne Ponchet CNRS-UPS Centre d’Elaboration de Matériaux et d’Etudes Structurales 29, rue Jeanne Marvig, BP 94347 31055 Toulouse Cedex 4 France Matthias Petzold Fraunhofer Institute for Mechanics of Materials Halle Walter-Hülse-Str.1 06120 Halle
XIX
XX
List of Contributors
Geoffroy Prévot Université Pierre et Marie Curie-Paris 6 UMR CNRS 7588, Institut des NanoSciences de Paris Campus Boucicaut, 140 rue de Lourmel 75015 Paris France Manfred Reiche Max Planck Institute of Microstructure Physics Weinberg 2 06120 Halle Germany
Houda Sahaf CINaM-CNRS Campus de Luminy, Case 913 3288 Marseille Cedex 9 France George Sarau Max Planck Institute of Microstructure Physics Experimental Department II Weinberg 2 06120 Halle Germany and
Vincent Repain CNRS et Université Paris Diderot Matériaux et Phénomènes Quantiques Bâtiment Condorcet – Case 7021 75205 Paris France Odile Robach CEA-Grenoble INAC/SP2M/NRS 17 rue des Martyrs 38054 Grenoble Cedex 9 France Christian Roucau CNRS-UPS Centre d’Elaboration de Matériaux et d’Etudes Structurales 29, rue Jeanne Marvig, BP 94347 31055 Toulouse Cedex 4 France Sylvie Rousset CNRS et Université Paris Diderot Matériaux et Phénomènes Quantiques Bâtiment Condorcet – Case 7021 75205 Paris France
Max Planck Institute for the Science of Light Guenther-Scharowsky – Str. 1 91058 Erlangen Germany Volker Schmidt Max Planck Institute of Microstructure Physics Experimental Department II Weinberg 2 06120 Halle Germany Clemens Schriever Martin-Luther-University Institute of Physics Heinrich-Damerow – Str. 4 06120 Halle Germany and Martin-Luther-University Centre for Innovation Competence SiLi-nano Karl-Freiherr-von-Fritsch-Str. 3 06120 Halle (Saale), Germany
List of Contributors
Olivier Thomas Aix-Marseille Université IM2NP, Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Campus de Saint-Jérôme Avenue Escadrille Normandie Niemen, Case 142 13397 Marseille Cedex France and CNRS, IM2NP (UMR 6242) Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Campus de Saint-Jérôme Avenue Escadrille Normandie Niemen, Case 142 13397 Marseille Cedex France Nicolas Vaxelaire Aix-Marseille Université IM2NP, Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Campus de Saint-Jérôme Avenue Escadrille Normandie Niemen, Case 142 13397 Marseille Cedex France and CNRS, IM2NP (UMR 6242) Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Campus de Saint-Jérôme Avenue Escadrille Normandie Niemen, Case 142 13397 Marseille Cedex France
Ralf B. Wehrspohn Martin-Luther-University Institute of Physics Heinrich-Damerow – Str. 4 06120 Halle Germany and Fraunhofer Institute for Mechanics of Materials Halle Walter-Hülse-Str. 1 06120 Halle Germany Joerg V. Wittemann Max Planck Institute of Microstructure Physics Experimental Department II Weinberg 2 06120 Halle Germany
XXI
j357
Index a adsorption 41 Asara-Tiller-Grinfeld-method 20 atomistic simulation 72, 87 atomistic valence force field simulations 181
b Beltz and Freund formula 71 biaxially strained layers 139 Bragg-Williams adsorption 41
free surfaces 11 Frenkel-Kontorova-model 92, 152, 153, 154
g geometrical phase analysis 203 Gibbs surface 32 Glissile interfaces 42 Greens function 6 growth modes 175, 176
h c cantilever 53 convergent beam electron diffraction (CBED) 199 cord construction 8 crystal truncation rods 266 curvature method 196
heterogeneous growth 160 Hookean solid 35 Hough transformation 216
i inclusion 5 inhomogeneous substitutional alloys 7
d
k
defect energy 89 density functional theory 83 diffusion 10 dislocations 63 – critical thickness 16, 113 – nucleation 72 distorted wave Born approximation 269
Kikuchi lines 214 Kikuchi pattern 220 Kirchhoff theory 50 Kohn-Sham equation 86
e eigenstrain 4 elastic energy 30 electron backscatter diffraction 215 Eshelbys method 5
f Ficks law 12 finite element methods 52, 158, 271 Fourier method 7
l Langmuir adsorption 41 lattice friction 66 linear stability analysis 9, 122
m mechanical equilibrium 12 Misfit dislocations 15, 153 mixing free enthalpy 8 mobility enhancement 132, 138 modulated composition 9 Monte Carlo simulations 85 morphocompositional instability 22
Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale: Simulation, Material Systems and Characterization Techniques, First Edition. Edited by Margrit Hanbücken, Pierre Müller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn. Ó 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. Published 2011 by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA.
j Index
358
morphological relaxation 17 – strain 17 MOSFET 133
n nanobeam electron diffraction 203 nanoelasticity 27 nanoparticle 44 nanowires 24, 52, 98, 111, 181 nonlinear optics 334 nucleation 66, 159 nudged elastic band 75
o orientation map 214
p Papkovich-Neuber potential 120 Peach-Koehler formula 64 Peierls-Nabarro-theory 72 phase retrieval 254 phonon frequency shifts 311 photoelastic effect 350 piezoresistance coefficients 133 Pikus-Bir hamiltonian 133 prestress 53
strained silicon devices 136, 253, 348 stress domains 156 stress stabilization 11 stress-free strain 4 surface energy 34, 38 surface modifications 68 surface reconstruction 92, 119, 153, 173, 206, 289 surface stress 35, 40, 41, 53, 91, 152, 156
t template fabrication 170 tetragonal strain 16 thin films 46, 96, 140 tight binding second momentum approximation 87 transmission electron microscopy 193 – high-resolution 203 transport flux 12 true fracture strain 62
v Vegards law 10 vicinal surfaces 157 Voronoi area 161
w q
Wafer bonding 172
quantum dots 23, 176, 261, 267
x r Raman-spectroscopy 299 reciprocal space maps 248 roughening 115
s second harmonic generation 334 solar cell 299 spinodal decomposition 8 strain engineering 142, 171 strain relaxation – elastic 3, 9, 11, 15, 18, 195 – plastic 63, 65, 162
x-ray diffraction 240 – 3DXRD 241 – GI-SAXS 266 – grazing incidence 264, 275 – HRXRD 269 – Laue microdiffraction 243 – reciprocal space mapping 249
y yield strength 62
z zero-order Laue zone 200
j1
Part One Fundamentals of Stress and Strain on the Nanoscale
Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale: Simulation, Material Systems and Characterization Techniques, First Edition. Edited by Margrit Hanb€ ucken, Pierre M€ uller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn. 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. Published 2011 by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA.
j3
1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics Frank Glas 1.1 Basics of Elastic Strain Relaxation 1.1.1 Introduction
Although frequently used, the phrase elastic strain relaxation is difficult to define. It usually designates the modification of the strain fields induced in a solid by a transformation of part or whole of this solid. At variance with plastic relaxation, in crystals, elastic relaxation proceeds without the formation of extended defects, thereby preserving lattice coherency in the solid. Elastic strain relaxation is intimately linked with the notion of instability. Indeed, the transformation considered is often induced by the change of a control parameter (temperature, forces applied, flux of matter, etc.). It may imply atomic rearrangements. Usually the realization of the instability is conditioned by kinetic processes (in particular, diffusion), which themselves depend on the stress state of the system. Elastic relaxation may also occur during the formation of part of a system, for instance, by epitaxial growth. The state with respect to which the relaxation is assessed may then exist not actually, but only virtually, as a term of comparison (e.g., the intrinsic state of a mismatched epitaxial layer grown on a substrate). Moreover, it is often only during growth that the kinetic processes are sufficiently active for the system to reach its optimal configuration. In the present introductory section, we give a general principle for the calculation of strain relaxation and briefly discuss some analytical and numerical methods. In the next sections, we examine important cases where elastic strain relaxation plays a crucial part. Section 1.2 deals with strain relaxation in substitutional alloys with spatially varying compositions and with the thermodynamics and kinetics of the instability of such alloys against composition modulations. Section 1.3 introduces a kinetic process of major importance, namely, diffusion, and summarizes how it is affected by elastic effects. Section 1.4 treats the case of a homogeneous mismatched layer of uniform thickness grown on a substrate. Section 1.5 shows how a system with a planar free surface submitted to a nonhydrostatic stress is unstable with respect to Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale: Simulation, Material Systems and Characterization Techniques, First Edition. Edited by Margrit Hanb€ ucken, Pierre M€ uller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn. 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. Published 2011 by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA.
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
4
the development of surface corrugations. Finally, Section 1.6 briefly recalls how the presence of free surfaces in objects of nanometric lateral dimensions, such as quantum dots or nanowires (NWs), permits a much more efficient elastic strain relaxation than in the case of uniformly thick layers. 1.1.2 Principles of Calculation
At given temperature and pressure, any single crystal possesses a reference intrinsic mechanical state E 0 in which the strains and stresses are zero, namely, the state defined by the crystal lattice (and the unit cell) of this solid under bulk form. If the crystal experiences a transformation (change of temperature, phase transformation, change of composition, etc.), this intrinsic mechanical state changes to E 1 , where again strains and stresses are zero (Figure 1.1a). The corresponding deformation is the stress-free strain (or eigenstrain) e*ij with respect to state E 0 ; for instance, for a change of temperature dT, e*ij ¼ dij adT, where a is the thermal dilatation coefficient. If the crystal is mechanically isolated, it simply adopts its new intrinsic state E 1 ; it is then free of stresses. This is not the case if the transformation affects only part of the system. We then have two extreme cases. The transformation is incoherent if it does not preserve any continuity between the crystal lattices of the transformed part and of its environment. If, on the contrary, lattice continuity is preserved at the interfaces, the transformation is coherent. This chapter deals with the second case. Let us call inclusion the volume that is transformed and matrix the untransformed part of the system (indexed by exponents I and M). Coherency is obviously incompatible with the adoption by the inclusion of its stress-free state E 1 , the matrix remaining unchanged. The system will thus relax, that is, suffer additional strains, which in general affect both inclusion and matrix. It is a strain relaxation in the following sense: if one imagines the inclusion having been transformed (for instance, heated) but remaining in its original reference mechanical state E 0 (which restores coherency, since the matrix has not been transformed from state E 0 ), it is subjected to stresses, since forces must be applied at its boundary to bring it from its new intrinsic state E 1 back to E 0 . With these stresses is associated an elastic energy. The coherent deformation of the whole system constitutes the elastic relaxation.
Figure 1.1 (a) Stress-free strain relative to the inclusion. (b) The three stages of an Eshelbys process.
1.1 Basics of Elastic Strain Relaxation
This suggests a way to calculate relaxation, Eshelbys method (Figure 1.1b) [1]: 1)
One applies to the transformed inclusion (state E 1 ) the strain eI* ij , which brings it back to state E 0 . This implies exerting on its external surface (whose external P I normal n has components nj ) the forces 3j¼1 sI ij nj per unit area, where s ij is the stress associated1) with the stress-free strain eI ij .
2)
3)
Having thus restored coherency between inclusion and matrix, one may reinsert the former into the latter. The only change that then occurs is the change of the surface density of forces applied at stage (1) into a body density fi , since the surface of the inclusion becomes an internal interface.2) The resulting state is not a mechanical equilibrium state, since forces fi must be applied to maintain it. One then lets the system relax by suppressing these forces, that is, by applying forces fi , while at the same time maintaining coherency everywhere. One thus has to compute the strain field, in the inclusion (eIr ij ) and in ), solution of the elasticity equations for body forces f , under the the matrix (eMr i ij coherency constraint, which amounts to equal displacements uIr ¼ uMr at the interface.
We may generalize this approach by not differentiating matrix and inclusion. The whole system experiences a transformation producing an inhomogeneous stressfree strain eij ðrÞ (defined at any point r) with respect to initial uniform state E 0 (perfect crystal). One then applies the body forces producing strain eij , namely, P fi ¼ 3j¼1 @s ij =@xj , where sij ðrÞ is the stress associated with strain eij . Finally, one calculates the relaxation field erij , the solution of the elastic problem with forces fi ðrÞ that preserves coherency everywhere (displacements must be continuous). It is important to specify the reference state with respect to which one defines the final state of the system. It is often easier to visualize the relaxed state relative to the uniform state E 0 ; strain is then simply erij. If, on the contrary, the elastic energy W stored in the system is to be calculated, we must take as a reference state for each volume element its intrinsic state after transformation (E 1 ), with respect to which the Ð P total strain is etij ¼ erij eij . Hence, W ¼ ð1=2Þ V 3i; j¼1 etij stij dV, where s tij is the strain associated with etij and where the integral is taken over the whole volume (in the reference state). In case of an inclusion (Figure 1.1), one may easily show that W¼
1 2
ð X 3 I i; j¼1
It eI ij s ij dv
ð1:1Þ
This is a fundamental result obtained by Eshelby [1]. In particular, the total elastic energy depends only on the stress in the inclusion. An example of application to an infinite system with a continuously varying transformation will be given in Section 1.2. Eshelbys method may also be adapted to 1) Via the constitutive relations, for instance, Hookes law in linear elasticity. 2) In the present case (single inclusion), this density is nonzero only in the zero-thickness interface layer, so for a facet x ¼ x0 , one has fi ¼ s I ix dðxx0 Þ.
j5
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
6
other problems. In particular, if the interface between matrix and inclusion does not entirely surround the latter (which happens if the inclusion has a free surface), it is not necessary to apply strain eI ij to the inclusion at stage 1. It suffices to apply a strain that restores the coherency in the interface, which may make the solution of the problem simpler. An example is given in Section 1.4. 1.1.3 Methods of Calculation: A Brief Overview
The problem thus consists in determining the fields relative to stage 3 of the process. One has to calculate the elastic relaxation of a medium subjected to a given density fi of body forces. In addition to numerical methods, for instance, those based on finite elements, there exist several analytical methods for solving this problem, in particular, the Greens functions method [2] and the Fourier synthesis method. In elasticity, Greens function Gij ðr; r0 Þ is defined as the component along axis i of displacement at point r caused by a unit body force along j applied at point r0 . For a solid with homogeneous properties, it is a function Gij ðrr0 Þ of the vector joining the two points. One easily shows that for an elastically linear solid (with elastic constants Cjklm ), the displacement field at stage 3 is ui ðrÞ ¼
ð @Gij Cjklm elm ðr0 Þ ðrr0 Þd r0 @xk j;k;l;m¼1 3 X
ð1:2Þ
where the integral extends to all points r0 of the volume. Greens functions depend on the elastic characteristics of the medium, but, once determined, any problem relative to this medium is solved by a simple integration. However, if the Greens functions for an infinite and elastically isotropic solid have been known since 1882, only a few cases have been solved exactly. If the medium is not infinite in three dimensions, the Greens functions also depend on its external boundary and on the conditions that are imposed to it. For epitaxy-related problems, the case of the half-space (semi-infinite solid with planar surface) is particularly interesting. These functions have been calculated for the elastically isotropic half-space with a free surface (no external tractions) [3, 4]. Muras book gives further details [2]. The method also applies to the relaxation of two solids in contact via a planar interface; in this case, this surface is generally not traction-free and the boundary conditions may be on these tractions or on its displacements. Pan has given a general solution in the anisotropic case, valid for all boundary conditions [5]. In the Fourier synthesis method, one decomposes the stress-free strain distribuÐ tion into its Fourier components: eij ðrÞ ¼ ~eij ðkÞexpðikrÞd k, where k is the running wave vector. In linear elasticity, the solution is simply the sum, weighted by the Fourier coefficients ~eij ðkÞ, of the solutions relative to each periodic wave of wave vector k, which are themselves periodic with the same wave vector. If the system is infinite, the elementary solution is easily determined (see Section 1.2.2). The only nontrivial point is then the integration. This method allows one to treat elegantly the
1.2 Elastic Strain Relaxation in Inhomogeneous Substitutional Alloys
Figure 1.2 Comparison of the elastic relaxation of a truncated square-base pyramidal inclusion in an infinite matrix (a) and in a halfspace (b). Maps in the symmetry plane xz of strain component exx normalized to the intrinsic misfit e0 of the inclusion with respect to the
matrix. Analytical calculation by the Fourier method (see also Ref. [10]). Thick blue lines mark the inclusion contour and the free surface, and the intensity scale is the same for (a) and (b).
stress-free strain discontinuities, as happening at the interface between a matrix and a misfitting inclusion3) having the same elastic constants. The number of problems solved by these methods steadily increases. As for inclusions, let us only mention, in addition to Eshelbys pioneering work on the ellipsoidal inclusion [1], the case of parallelepipedic inclusions in an infinite matrix [6] and in a half-space [7, 8] and that of the truncated pyramidal inclusions in an infinite matrix [9] and in a half-space [10]. These are important for being the shapes commonly adopted by semiconducting quantum dots. For a given inclusion, the elastic relaxation may be deeply modified by a free surface, on which the tractions must vanish (Figure 1.2).
1.2 Elastic Strain Relaxation in Inhomogeneous Substitutional Alloys
As a first example of strain relaxation, we examine the common case of an alloy whose stress-free state (for instance, its lattice parameter) depends on its composition. If composition variations that preserve lattice coherency develop in an initially homogeneous alloy, internal strains and stresses appear. In this case, elucidating strain relaxation amounts to calculating these fields. We shall see that strains may deeply affect the stability of such an alloy. However, the stability is not determined only by elastic effects. To provide a term of comparison, we shall first consider alloys where compositions variations induce no strain (Section 1.2.1), before turning to the calculation of the elastic fields (Section 1.2.2) and to the way in which they alter the alloy thermodynamics (Section 1.2.3). Finally, Section 1.2.4 discusses how the presence of a free surface affects strain relaxation and hence stability. 3) We call misfitting an inclusion (respectively, a layer) having the same crystal structure as the matrix (respectively, substrate) but different lattice parameters.
j7
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
8
gm
gm
(a) h m
gm
(b)
(c) T = T1 ≤ Tc
T = T2 ≥ Tc
0
c
T1 T2
(d)
T1
1
−Τ sm
T T2
g md
d
g mh
h
0
ca
c
c1
M cb 1
0
Figure 1.3 (a) Mixing free enthalpy gm at two temperatures (full lines), with enthalpic and entropic contributions (dashed lines). (b) High temperature case. (c) Low temperature case; tangent construction, equilibrium
cα c 2 c 1s c1 c s2 c β
1 0
cα
I c 1s
M 1 c s2 c β
compositions ca , cb and spinodal compositions c1s , c2s corresponding to inflexion points (circles). (d) Boundaries of miscibility gap (full line) and spinodal gap (dashed lines).
1.2.1 Spinodal Decomposition with No Elastic Effects
Let us consider a bulk binary AB substitutional alloy with atomic concentrations ð1cÞ and c in species A and B.4) With each thermodynamic quantity is associated a mixing quantity, the difference of this quantity between the alloy and the same numbers of its atomic constituents taken as pure solids. In the regular solution model, the mixing free enthalpy (per atom) of the disordered alloy at temperature T is gm ¼ hm Tsm ¼ Vcð1cÞ þ kB T½c ln c þ ð1cÞ ln ð1cÞ, where V is an energy, the interaction parameter (here taken per atom), and kB is the Boltzmanns constant (Figure 1.3a). If V > 0, the alloy tends to decompose, since alloying its constituents produces an energy hm. However, at high temperatures, entropy may prevent decomposition. The equilibrium state of the system at given temperature and pressure is found by minimizing gm at constant numbers of atoms. Depending on temperature T, gm adopts two different forms, with either a single or a double minimum (Figure 1.3a).5) At high T (Figure 1.3b), the mixing free enthalpy gmh of a homogeneous alloy of any composition c1 is less than that of any mixture of two homogeneous alloys of compositions ca and cb into which it might decompose (the latter, gmd , is given by the cord construction), so the alloy is stable. On the contrary, for T Tc0, with Tc0 ¼ V=ð2kB Þ, the tangent construction gives two stable equilibrium compositions ca , cb , into which any alloy with intermediate composition tends to decompose (Figure 1.3c). However, two different behaviors are expected. For an alloy of composition c1 intermediate between the compositions cs1 ðTÞ and cs2 ðTÞ 00 corresponding to the inflexion points of the gm curve (i.e., such that gm ðc1 Þ ¼ ð@ 2 gm =@c 2 Þc¼c1 < 0), decomposition into two alloys is always energetically favorable, 4) This also applies to pseudobinary ternary alloys with two sublattices, one homogeneous and the other mixed, such as alloys of compound semiconductors. 5) In the regular solution model, which we retain in the following calculations, the curve is symmetrical about c ¼ 0:5. In the figure, we illustrate a slightly more general situation highlighting the salient feature of the curve, its double-well.
1.2 Elastic Strain Relaxation in Inhomogeneous Substitutional Alloys
even if these two alloys differ infinitesimally in composition (curve gm is above its cord). Conversely, for an alloy composition such as c2 , between a stable composition 00 and an inflexion point (gm ðc2 Þ > 0), it is only decomposition into two compositions differing by a finite amount that is favored (curve gm is below its cord). The homogeneous alloy is unstable in the first case and metastable in the second. In the ðc; TÞ plane (Figure 1.3d), curves ca ðTÞ, cb ðTÞ enclose the miscibility gap, inside which the spinodal curve, locus of points cs1 ðTÞ, cs2 ðTÞ, separates the metastable (M) and unstable (or spinodal, I) domains. The process through which an alloy quenched below Tc0 starts decomposing via composition variations of arbitrary small amplitude is spinodal decomposition. The same results are obtained by linear stability analysis [11]. This general method consists in studying the instability of a system not against an arbitrary perturbation but against a Fourier component of the latter. If the problem is linear (a linear combination of solutions is a solution, the boundary conditions being themselves linear), global instability is equivalent to the existence of at least one unstable elementary perturbation. Here, we study the instability of an alloy of average composition c1 against a sinusoidal composition modulation of amplitude dc along the direction x: cðxÞ ¼ c1 þ dc sin kx. The mixing free enthalpy of the modulated alloy,Ð found by averaging gm over a modulation wavelength l ¼ 2p=k, is l 00 l1 0 gm ½cðxÞdx ¼ gm ðc1 Þ þ gm ðc1 Þd2c =4 at order 2 in dc . The excess of mixing 00 ðc1 Þd2c =4. We thus recover the previous enthalpy due to modulation is dgmc ¼ gm result, namely, an alloy of average composition c1 is unstable (dgmc < 0) at temper00 ðc1 Þ < 0.6) ature T against a composition modulation of vanishing amplitude if gm The foregoing analysis assumes that fractioning the alloy into two phases or modulating its composition produces no excess energy.7) It is however not generally the case, and this can be taken into account by adding to the energy density of the composition modulation a Landau-type phenomenological gradient term that opposes abrupt composition variations [12]. This produces a critical decomposition wavelength, lower wavelengths being energetically unfavorable. The gradient term may be of purely chemical origin, but, in addition, in alloys with size effects that decompose coherently, stresses appear between regions having different compositions and generate additional elastic energy. The next section describes the modifications of the previous results due to these stresses and to the way in which they relax. 1.2.2 Elastic Strain Relaxation in an Alloy with Modulated Composition
Let us assume, for simplicity, that the alloy is of cubic structure or elastically isotropic and that its intrinsic lattice parameter varies linearly with composition (Vegards law) aðcÞ ¼ a0 ð1 þ gcÞ with a0 ¼ að0Þ and g ¼ ½að1Það0Þ=að0Þ, the relative lattice mismatch between the pure constituents A and B. If the alloy composition lies within
00 6) In the regular solution model, gm ðc1 Þ ¼ 2V þ kB T=½c1 ð1c1 Þ and Tc0 is obtained for c1 ¼ 0:5.
7) In the first case, this corresponds to an interface energy.
j9
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
10
the metastable domain M, one may expect the nucleation of finite volumes of phases with distinct compositions, hence with different lattice parameters, and decomposition may be coherent or not, depending on the size and composition contrast. In the unstable domain I, the transformation into the stable phases may however occur via the amplification of composition modulations starting with zero amplitude (Section 1.2.1). One then expects the decomposition to be coherent, at least at the start of the process. This is the case we treat here. Two major questions then arise. What are the elastic strain fields induced by a given composition distribution? How does the associated elastic energy modify the stability of the alloy? To answer these questions, let us consider again a sinusoidal composition modulation cðxÞ ¼ c1 þ dc sin kx in direction x. From Vegards law, this induces a spatial modulation of intrinsic parameter aðxÞ ¼ a0 ½1 þ gc1 þ ec sin kx with amplitude ec ¼ gdc . As regards elasticity (Section 1.1.2), this corresponds to a stress-free strain modulation eij ðxÞ ¼ dij ec sin kx with respect to the homogeneous state (c1 ).8) From Section 1.1.2, the elastic relaxation with respect to the latter is obtained by P imposing a density of body forces fi ðxÞ ¼ 3j¼1 @s ij =@xj . If the alloy is elastically 9) isotropic, fi ðxÞ ¼ dix ½E=ð12nÞec k cos kx. We look for a relaxation displacement field that is continuous (coherency condition) and has the same wavelength as the perturbation: uri ðxÞ ¼ dix ðA cos kx þ B sin kxÞ. The relaxation strain is then erij ðxÞ ¼ dix djx kðA sin kx þ B cos kxÞ10) and the associated stress srxx ¼ fEð1nÞ= ½ð1 þ nÞð12nÞgerxx ; sryy ¼ srzz ¼ ½n=ð1nÞs rxx ; s rij ¼ 0; if i 6¼ j. From the equilibrium between stresses and forces fi , one gets B ¼ 0 and A ¼ ½ð1 þ nÞ=ð1nÞk1 ec . The relaxation field is thus a tetragonal strain modulation along x in phase with the intrinsic modulation but amplified by factor ½ð1 þ nÞ=ð1nÞ [12]. The relaxed lattice parameter remains equal to aðc1 Þ in the directions normal to x. The elastic energy is that of the total strain fields (etij ¼ erij eij ) (Section 1.1.2). Its density is easily found to be dw ¼ ð1=2ÞE 0 e2c =ð1nÞ, where E 0 ¼ E=N is the Youngs modulus E normalized by Avogadros number N in order to obtain a density per atom. What is the meaning of relaxation here? With respect to the intrinsic (reference) state of each volume element of the modulated alloy, in which elastic energy is zero by definition, there is an increase of elastic energy due to the coherency between these elements. On the contrary, the energy is lower than that in the state where all elements (with different compositions) would adopt the average lattice parameter (virtual reference state at the end of stage 2; Figure 1.4). If, at least during the early stages of decomposition, the system prefers continuous composition variations and coherent relaxation, it is because the formation of finite domains with distinct compositions, which would all adopt their intrinsic lattice parameter, would induce interfacial defects whose cost in energy would be even higher (see also Section 1.4).
8) Such a problem, where the stress-free strain is a pure dilatation, is a thermal stress problem. 9) Its elastic behavior is then governed by two parameters, Youngs ratio n modulus E and Poissons o n, and P strains and stresses s ij o¼ ½E=ð1 þ nÞ eij þ ½n=ð12nÞdij 3m¼1 emm and n are linked by relations P eij ¼ ½ð1 þ nÞ=E sij ½n=ð1 þ nÞdij 3m¼1 s mm . 10) The only nonzero element of the strain tensor is exx .
1.2 Elastic Strain Relaxation in Inhomogeneous Substitutional Alloys
1.2.3 Strain Stabilization and the Effect of Elastic Anisotropy
The total excess of mixing free enthalpy dgm due to modulation is found by adding the elastic relaxation energy dw to the term dgmc calculated in Section 1.2.1 without 00 ðc1 Þ þ 2E 0 =ð1nÞ e2c =4. The taking stresses into account. One finds dgm ¼ g2 gm condition of instability of alloy with composition c1 against modulations of vanishing 00 amplitude thus changes from gm ðc1 Þ < 0 to 00 gm ðc1 Þ þ 2g2 E 0 =ð1nÞ < 0
ð1:3Þ
Since n < 1, the extra term is positive; so the condition for instability is more restrictive in terms of composition. If the mixing enthalpy at low T is a double-well curve (Figure 1.3c), we see that the domain of unstable compositions is reduced and the critical temperature lowered, an effect often called stress stabilization. In the regular solution model, the critical temperature decreases from Tc0 ¼ V=ð2kB Þ to TcC ¼ f1g2 E 0 =ðVð1nÞÞgTc0 . This reduction may reach several hundreds of kelvins in some metallic alloys [12]. The elastic contribution may even be large enough to render negative the calculated TcC , which means that the instability is then totally suppressed (no composition satisfies Eq. (1.3)). The previous calculations, based on isotropic elasticity, do not specify any favored direction of modulation. To extend the calculations to cubic crystals [13], it suffices to replace term g2 E 0 =ð1nÞ in Eq. (1.3) by a modulus Yk^ depending on modulation direction ^k ¼ k=k. In particular, Y100 < Y110 < Y111 if the elastic constants satisfy to 2C44 þ C12 C11 > 0. Modulations then tend to form in the soft directions of type h100i. These considerations are corroborated by the observation in spinodally decomposed alloys of a characteristic microstructure, manifested in the transmission electron microscopy images by a modulated contrast in the soft directions [11, 14]. More generally, in elastically anisotropic materials, the shape of inclusions and their relative disposition tend to be determined by elastic relaxation [11]. 1.2.4 Elastic Relaxation in the Presence of a Free Surface
The presence of a free surface may also deeply affect strain relaxation. In the infinite solid considered so far, the elastic energy of any composition distribution is the sum Ð 0 of those of its Fourier components, which do not interact since V eik r eik r dr ¼ 0 if k 6¼ k0 . This does not necessary hold in a solid bounded by a surface (see Section 1.5). However, this is still true for a planar half-space. Moreover, for a modulation with a wave vector parallel to the surface, the elastic energy may be considerably reduced with respect to the infinite solid. This reduction stems from the extra stress relaxation permitted by the free surface. The optimal modulations have an amplitude that is exponentially attenuated in the direction normal to the surface. Strain stabilization is thus less pronounced than in the bulk and the critical temperature increases accordingly [8]. In the regular solution model, one finds a new critical temperature
j11
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
12
TcI ¼ f1g2 E 0 =ð2VÞgTc0 , such that TcC < TcI < Tc0 [15, 16].11) Composition modulations in directions parallel to the substrate have indeed been observed in epitaxial layers of semiconducting alloys [17, 18]. More generally, the strain relaxation of misfitting inclusions may be strongly affected if they lie close to a free surface, typically within a distance on the order of their dimensions (Figure 1.2) [10].
1.3 Diffusion
Many transformations (such as considered in Section 1.1.1) require a redistribution of matter in the system to become effective. Hence, the realization of the instability is conditioned by kinetic processes, in particular, diffusion. In this sense, the elastic relaxation that accompanies the transformation is also conditioned by diffusion. However, one usually considers that the timescale for diffusion is much longer than that for the mechanical adjustment (relaxation) of the system to the instantaneous distribution of atoms, so the system is continuously in a state of mechanical equilibrium (but of course not in global thermodynamic equilibrium) during the transformation (quasistatic approximation). This is not to say that diffusion and strain relaxation are independent: we shall see in Section 1.3.2 that diffusion is affected by the elastic strain and stress fields. Before this, we briefly consider diffusion without elastic effects. 1.3.1 Diffusion without Elastic Effects
As an example of how diffusion conditions the realization of an instability, consider a bulk alloy AB subject to decomposition (as in Section 1.2), and first ignore the elastic effects. If the homogeneous alloy is quenched below its critical temperature Tc0 , it becomes unstable and tends to decompose (Section 1.2.1). The concentration c of, say, component B becomes nonuniform. According to Ficks law, this induces a diffusive flux of B atoms, JdB ¼ DB rðc=vÞ, where DB > 0 is the diffusion coefficient of B [19] and v is the atomic volume in the homogeneous reference state of the alloy.12) Setting D0 B ¼ DB =v, we have JdB ¼ D0 B rc. Since D0 B > 0, this flux tends to smooth the concentration gradient, which should inhibit the formation of the composition modulation. It is because the B flux is not limited to Ficks diffusive term that the modulation may actually develop. Indeed, generally, to the diffusive flux must be added a transport flux depending on the force FB exerted on each B atom [19]. If this force derives from a potential (FB ¼ rwB ), the Nernst–Einstein equation (demonstrated by canceling the total flux at equilibrium and by using the appropriate statistics) leads to 11) It is obtained for modulations with a z-dependent amplitude, such as will be considered in Section 1.5.5. 12) This appears here since we use, as in Section 1.2.1, the atomic concentration c rather than the number of atoms per unit volume.
1.3 Diffusion
JtB ¼ D0B =ðkB T ÞcFB ¼ D0B =ðkB T ÞcrwB . For instance, in the case of charged particles in an electric field, the transport flux is directly related to the electrostatic force exerted on each particle. Now, if the alloy is ideal, the chemical potential of species B at concentration c is mB ¼ kB T ln c=ceq , where ceq is the equilibrium concentration at temperature T, so the diffusive flux becomes JdB ¼ D0B =ðkB T ÞcrmB and the total flux is JB ¼ JdB þ JtB ¼ D0B =ðkB T ÞcrðmB þ wB Þ ¼ D0B =ðkB T Þcr~ mB , ~B ¼ mB þ wB is a generalized potential, including external forces. where m In the case of the alloy, a similar approach applies, but the definition of the appropriate potential and the generalization of Ficks law require some care. If the alloy is substitutional, A and B share the same crystal lattice and, in the absence of vacancies, any B atom leaving a site must be replaced by an A atom so that the fluxes of A and B are opposite: JB ¼ JA . The B flux then becomes JB ¼ DrðmB mA Þ ¼ DrM, where D is a phenomenological diffusion mobility, mA and mB are the local and concentrationdependent values of the chemical potentials of A and B, and M is the diffusion potential that replaces and generalizes the chemical potential. Since mB mA is the change of free enthalpy when an A atom is replaced by a B atom at the point considered, we have mB mA ¼ @g=@c, where g is the free enthalpy (per atom) of the alloy at composition c. Moreover, by definition of the free enthalpy of mixing gm introduced in Section 1.2, we have g ¼ cm0B þ ð1cÞm0A þ gm , where m0A , m0B are the position-independent chemical potentials of the pure elements. Hence, JB ¼ DrM ¼ Drð@gm =@c Þ ¼ Dð@ 2 gm =@c 2 Þrc. It now becomes clear that in the spinodal domain, which is precisely defined by @ 2 gm =@c 2 < 0 (Section 1.2.1), the diffusion flux of species B does not oppose the gradient (as follows from the sole consideration of Ficks diffusive flux) but actually tends to amplify it. In other words, as expected in this domain, the alloy is unstable against composition modulations of vanishing amplitude. This calculation of the diffusion flux is actually much richer than simply confirming the static analysis carried out in Section 1.2.1. It opens the way to a study of the kinetics of decomposition (provided D is known), since the evolution of the composition profile with time t obeys the usual conservation equation div JB þ @c=@t ¼ 0. The interested reader is referred to, for example, Cahns publications [14]. This general approach also permits to take into account any effect that modifies the energy of the system (e.g., electric or magnetic fields) by simply adding its contribution to the free enthalpy g. In the next section, we show how the effect of elastic strain fields on diffusion can be calculated in this way. 1.3.2 Diffusion under Stress in an Alloy
The elastic contribution to the free enthalpy per atom is simply ½1=2vetij s tij, where etij ¼ eij eij is the strain corresponding to the transformation of a given volume element from its intrinsic state to its final relaxed state (Figure 1.1b and 1.4) and stij is the associated stress (see Section 1.1.2). Since s tij is defined only formally (etij being the strain between the independent stress-free volume elements and the final relaxed coherent state), it is preferable to express the density of elastic energy as a function of the elastic fields describing the transformation of the homogeneous alloy with composition c1 into the modulated and relaxed alloy (the extreme stages of Figure 1.4),
j13
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
14
ε ij* ( x + λ 2 )
a [c ( x + λ 2 )] − ε * ( x + λ 2 ) ij fi
x+λ 2
a (c1 ) = a1
ε ij* ( x ) (*)
homogeneous alloy continuum, no stress
x
a [c ( x ) ]
a1
− fi
ε ijr ( x )
(1), (2)
ε ij = ε ijr , σ ij
− fi
a1
− ε ij* ( x )
elements in their intrinsic state
ε ijr ( x + λ 2)
fi
(3) modulated alloy, not relaxed
ε
modulated alloy, relaxed
t ij
Figure 1.4 Eshelby process for a bulk alloy with modulated composition.
namely, ½1=2v eij eij s ij . Elasticity introduces a complication, namely, nonlocal effects, since the stress and strain at a given point depend not only on local composition (as was the case with the chemical potentials) but also on the whole concentration distribution. Nevertheless, it is possible to express the effect of elasticity as an additional term in the diffusion potential M [20], so that the diffusion equation becomes JB ¼ DrM0 , with M0 ¼
X @Sijkl X @e*ij @gm v sij v sij s kl @c @c @c i; j i; j;k;l
ð1:4Þ
where Sijkl are the elastic compliances. If the latter do not depend on composition, the third term of Eq. (1.4) disappears. If this is the case and if the material is cubic or elastically isotropic, then e*ij ¼ gðcc1 Þdij , where g is the relative lattice mismatch between the pure constituents introduced in Section 1.2.2; so M0 ¼ P P @gm =@cvg k s kk , where k s kk is simply the local dilatation. Note that only nonhomogeneous stresses affect diffusion in this way, although, in addition, stress may affect the elastic constants and the diffusion coefficients. For more details on diffusion under stress, including surface diffusion, see Refs [21–23]. Spinodal decomposition may be studied in this way, considering a possible gradient energy of chemical origin (Section 1.2.1) plus the elastic energy. This leads to different growth rates for perturbations of different wavelengths, with a rather narrow peak centered around a fastest developing wavelength. Experimentally, spinodally decomposed alloys indeed tend to exhibit a microstructure with a fairly well-defined decomposition periodicity [14].
1.4 Strain Relaxation in Homogeneous Mismatched Epitaxial Layers 1.4.1 Introduction
Knowing which amount of a given material can be deposited coherently on a mismatched substrate is of great importance in the field of epitaxy. For semicon-
1.4 Strain Relaxation in Homogeneous Mismatched Epitaxial Layers
ducting materials in particular, the extended defects that form when plastic relaxation occurs often affect deleteriously the electrical and optical properties of heterostructure-based devices, and great care is usually taken to remain in the coherency domain during growth. In a simple equilibrium picture, the transition between elastic and plastic relaxation is governed by the total energy of the system. It is thus important to analyze elastic strain relaxation in the coherent case. In the present section, we consider the standard case of a layer of uniform thickness, before turning to possible thickness variations in Section 1.5. We consider mismatched heterostructures formed by depositing a homogeneous layer L of uniform thickness t (0 < z < t) onto a semi-infinite planar substrate S (z < 0), both being single crystals. In the spirit of Section 1.1.2, one may consider that in its intrinsic stress-free state, L results from an elastic distortion of S, described by the stress-free strain that transforms the intrinsic lattice of S into that of L [8, 24]. The methods of Section 1.1 may then be applied. We further assume that S and L have the same structure and differ only by the magnitude of their lattice parameters, so the stress-free strain eij is a pure isotropic dilatation, equal to the relative difference between the lattice parameters aL of the layer and aS of the substrate (or lattice mismatch), e0 ¼ ðaL aS Þ=aS (which is positive if the layer is compressed by the substrate).13) If the deposit L extends infinitely parallel to the planar interface (plane xy), the lattice mismatch makes it impossible for S and L to retain their intrinsic bulk stress-free states if the interface is coherent, simply because the spacings of the lattice planes that cross the interface are different for S and L. Hence the necessity of an accommodation of the lattice mismatch, which can take two extreme forms. If the coherency at the interface is preserved, thanks to a deformation of one or both materials, the accommodation is purely elastic. Conversely, accommodation may be realized plastically, via the formation of a network of misfit dislocations at the interface, which thereby becomes incoherent (section 1.1.1). Leaving aside plastic relaxation, the detailed discussion of which falls outside the scope of the present chapter, we shall briefly show how the methods of Section 1.1 give the solution of the elastic problem. 1.4.2 Elastic Strain Relaxation
If the deposit is much thinner than the substrate, one can safely consider (ignoring possible curvature effects) that only the former is strained while the latter retains its bulk lattice. Moreover, the layer has a free surface z ¼ h, so the substrate/layer interface z ¼ 0 does not entirely surround the layer. As mentioned in Section 1.1.2, it is then not necessary to apply strain eij ¼ e0 at stage 1 of the Eshelby process. It suffices to apply a strain that restores lattice continuity across the S/L interface, that is, ð1Þ ð1Þ such that exx ¼ eyy ¼ e0 . This may be achieved by applying forces along x and y on the elementary cubes that compose the layer, but not along z, so at this (modified) 13) The problem is then equivalent to heating or cooling a layer of thickness h of a stress-free half-space of material S.
j15
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
16
Figure 1.5 (a) Tetragonal strain of a unit cell of parameter a subjected to biaxial stress s 0 (here taken negative, corresponding to compression); e0 ¼ ð1nÞs0 =E. (b) Planar (dashed line) and
corrugated (full line) surfaces. (c) Schematics of strain at crests (c) and valleys (v) with respect to intrinsic (i) and tetragonally strained (q) unit cells.
ð1Þ
stage 1, s zz ¼ 0 (Figure 1.5a). Considering, to simplify, an elastically isotropic medium, the equations of elasticity (see footnote 9) indicate that one then has ð1Þ ð1Þ ð1Þ s xx ¼ syy ¼ Ee0 =ð1nÞ ¼ s0 and ezz ¼ 2ne0 =ð1nÞ (all nondiagonal strains and ð1Þ ð1Þ stresses are zero). Because the forces corresponding to sxx , s yy are uniform, they cancel mutually when the layer elements are reassembled at stage 2, so the corresponding density of body forces is zero. Moreover, since there are no forces along z, the layer is entirely free of applied forces at the end of stage (2), so that considering stage (3) becomes irrelevant. This adaptation of Eshelbys method thus offers a particularly simple solution of the problem. To summarize, elastic relaxation affects only the thin layer, which adapts its parameter to that of the substrate in the interface plane and strains tetragonally (extending or contracting, depending on the sign of e0 ) in the normal (z) direction, with an amplification factor ð1 þ nÞ=ð1nÞ with respect to intrinsic strain e0 , since the ð1Þ dilatation along z with respect to the substrate is ezz þ e0 ¼ ½ð1 þ nÞ=ð1nÞe0 . The corresponding elastic energy per unit volume of layer is readily found to be ðE=ð1nÞÞe20 . 1.4.3 Critical Thickness
One of the major issues regarding strain accommodation in heterostructures is to find out which factors determine the mode of relaxation (elastic or plastic). It is usually observed that dislocations do not form until the growing layer reaches some critical thickness hc . Basically, such a critical thickness exists because the energies stored in the system per unit area scale differently with layer thickness h. In the coherent state (elastic relaxation), we have just seen that the energy is uniformly distributed in the layer, so the energy per unit area scales with h. On the contrary, in the plastically relaxed state, the density of dislocations of a given type that accommodates a given mismatch (ensuring that the material passes from the stress-free lattice parameter of the substrate to that of the layer across their interface) is fixed and inversely proportional to the relative mismatch [25]. In this case, as a first approximation, the layer is strained in the vicinity of the interface (because of the nonuniform strain fields of the dislocations) but quickly recover its stress-free parameter away from it, so the elastic energy per unit area does not depend on h.
1.5 Morphological Relaxation of a Solid under Nonhydrostatic Stress
Actually, since the dislocations have a long-range strain field, the elastic energy increases with h, but only logarithmically, much more slowly than in the elastic case (it even saturates when the layer thickness becomes larger the dislocation spacing). In addition, the dislocation cores contribute a constant term to the energy. Hence, the energy stored is larger in the plastic case at low layer thicknesses and in the elastic case at high thicknesses. These considerations are at the origin of the most widely used criterion for calculating hc for a given couple of materials, which consists in comparing the total energies of a given heterostructure in the coherent and plastically relaxed states as a function of thickness and in defining hc as that thickness at which the energy in the former becomes larger than in the latter. This is an equilibrium criterion, equivalent to finding the thickness at which the misfit-induced force acting on a preexisting dislocation tends to pull and extend it into the S/L interface [26–28]. Other criteria are of a kinetic nature and deal with the nucleation of the misfit dislocations or with their motion toward the interface. The critical thickness decreases rapidly when the S/L mismatch increases [26]. In practice, for typical semiconductor materials, hc 10 nm for e0 ¼ 1% and hc 1 nm for e0 ¼ 4%.
1.5 Morphological Relaxation of a Solid under Nonhydrostatic Stress 1.5.1 Introduction
Consider a homogeneous half-space z 0, subjected to a uniform biaxial stress q q (exponent q) s xx ¼ syy ¼ s0 in plane xy and with a planar traction-free surface q z ¼ 0 (s iz ¼ 0; i ¼ x; y; z). Assuming, for the sake of simplicity, that the medium is elastically isotropic, its response (relaxation) to this stress has been calculated in q q another context in Section 1.4.2:14) it is a uniform tetragonal strain exx ¼ eyy ¼ q e0 ; ezz ¼ 2ne0 =ð1nÞ, with e0 ¼ ð1nÞs 0 =E; the nondiagonal terms are zero (Figure 1.5a). It has been known for a few decades that if one abandons the arbitrary constraint that the free surface be planar (Figure 1.5b), the system can relax even more and adopt a different state, with lower elastic energy [29–31].15),16) Why such a morphological (planar ! nonplanar) transformation might reduce the elastic energy is easily understood: at the crests of the surface, the system may deform not only in direction z but also laterally Figure 1.5c), since there is no matter to prevent it from doing so [31]. To confirm the decrease of the total energy, we must however also examine the 14) Whether the stress is applied by a rigid substrate or externally is irrelevant. 15) In Section 1.5.1, we assume that the system remains chemically homogeneous. The coupling between morphological and compositional instabilities is treated in Section 1.5.5. 16) Note that we consider here a true redistribution of matter along the surface with respect to the planar state and not a simple elastic deformation of the planar surface.
j17
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
18
strain in the valleys and allow for the fact that the area of the corrugated surface is larger than that of the planar one. 1.5.2 Calculation of the Elastic Relaxation Fields
In the present case, elastic relaxation stands for the modification of the strain fields accompanying the planar ! nonplanar transformation. Since the latter implies an actual change of shape following a redistribution of matter, Eshelbys method (which deals with the change of intrinsic state of a given volume) is not adapted. Instead, we directly solve the elastic problem, the boundary condition being that the corrugated surface remains traction-free. Since this problem has no exact solution for an arbitrary surface profile, we study the elastic response of the system to an elementary perturbation (in the spirit of the linear stability analysis, Section 1.2.1), namely, a sinusoidal modulation (hereafter, undulation) along x of the position h of the surface along z, hðxÞ ¼ D sin kx, measured with respect to the planar state h ¼ 0 (Figure 1.5b).17),18) Let us look for the fields esij , ssij that have to be added to the q fields to obtain the total (equilibrium) field. Given the symmetry of the problem, no quantity depends on y; hence esiy ¼ ð1=2Þ@usy =@xi . For the same reason, usy ¼ 0, so esiy ¼ 0 for i ¼ x; y; z. The solution of such a plane strain problem is known to derive from an Airy function xðx; zÞ, solution of differential equation @ 4 x=@x 4 þ 2@ 4 x=@x 2 @z2 þ @ 4 x=@z4 ¼ 0, via relations ssxx ¼ @ 2 x=@z2 , s sxz ¼ @ 2 x=@x@z, and s szz ¼ @ 2 x=@x 2 [33]. Setting xðx; zÞ ¼ jðzÞ sin kx, one finds that j must satisfy differential equation d4 j=dz4 2k2 d2 j=dz2 þ k4 j ¼ 0, the general solution of which is jðzÞ ¼ ðA þ BzÞekz þ ðC þ DzÞekz , with A, B, C, and D constants. Since the fields must remain finite for z ! 1, one has C ¼ D ¼ 0. Finally, s sxx ¼ kð2B þ kA þ kBzÞekz sin kx;
sszz ¼ k2 ðA þ BzÞekz sin kx
ð1:5Þ s sxz ¼ kðB þ kA þ kBzÞekz cos kx; ssyy ¼ 2knBekz sin kx since esyy ¼ 0 and hence ssyy ¼ n ssxx þ sszz . A shear strain thus appears in plane xz. The undulated surface with normal ðnx ; 0; nz Þ remains traction-free under total field q s ij ¼ s ij þ s sij . Hence, E s e0 nx þ ssxz nz ¼ 0; sxx ssxz nx þ sszz nz ¼ 0 ð1:6Þ 1n
the stress being calculated in z ¼ 0. We now assume that the amplitude D of the undulation is small compared to its wavelength 2p=k (i.e., kD 1), and compute the fields at first order in kD (even in the case of a sinusoidal perturbation, there is no exact solution at finite amplitude). Then, nx ¼ kD cos kx, nz ¼ 1. From Eqs (1.6) 17) Even in this case, the problem is not linear, due to the boundary conditions. Indeed, the cancellation of the tractions applies to a different surface for each (D, k) couple. The solution for an arbitrary h profile is not found by summing the solutions for each Fourier component of h. 18) One may also consider localized wavelet surface perturbations [32].
1.5 Morphological Relaxation of a Solid under Nonhydrostatic Stress
and (1.5), one gets A ¼ 0; B ¼ Eð1nÞe0 D. By using Eq. (1.5), one obtains the stresses, from which the relaxation strains derive via the appropriate relations (see footnote 9). The nonzero components of this strain field are as the following: 1þn kB½2ð1nÞ þ kzekz sin kx E
ð1:7Þ
eszz ¼
1þn kB½2n þ kzekz sin kx E
ð1:8Þ
esxz ¼
1þn kB½1 þ kzekz cos kx E
ð1:9Þ
esxx ¼
1.5.3 ATG Instability
The elastic energy W of the solid with undulated surface, per unit area of planar (reference state), is easily calculated from the total fields: W ¼ ð1=2Þl1 Ðsurface Ð hðxÞ l q q s s eij þ eij d z. It follows that the variation of elastic energy per 0 dx 1 s ij þ s ij unit area when the system transforms from planar to undulated state is dW ¼
1 2l
1 2l
ðl
ð hðxÞ dx
0
(ð
ð0
l
dx 0
1
1
q q sij esij þ ssij eij þ ssij esij d z
s sij esij d z þ
ðl
ð hðxÞ dx
0
0
q sij esij
q þ ssij eij
)
ð1:10Þ
dz
the second equality being valid at lowest (second) order in kD. Replacing in Eq. (1.10) the s fields by their expressions calculated from Eqs (1.7)–(1.9) via the linear elasticity formulas, we get dW ¼
11þn1 2 Ee ðkDÞ2 2 1n k 0
ð1:11Þ
Since dW < 0, any surface undulation reduces the elastic energy of the system.19) This fundamental result specifies the driving force for the instability. However, an undulation also increases the effective area of the free surface and induces a surface strain. Here, we only consider the first effect, which translates into an excess energy per unit reference area, equal to cdA=A, where c is the surface free energy (assumed to be independent of the slight orientation changes of the surface) Ð l pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi and dA=A is the relative variation of area. The latter equals l1 0 1 þ ðdh=dxÞ2 dx,
19) This is not obvious. If indeed, with respect to the planar state, the elastic energy is reduced at the crests, it increases in the valleys (Figure 1.5c). It is only because the former contribute more than the latter that the global balance is favorable.
j19
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
20
that is, k2 D2 =4 at order 2 in kD. The total energy variation per unit area due to the undulation is thus c 1þnE 1 2 e0 ðkDÞ2 dW 0 ¼ ð1:12Þ 4 1n 2 k The planar surface is unstable with respect to an undulation if dW 0 < 0. This is equivalent to the undulation wavenumber k ¼ jkj being less than the critical value kc ¼ 2ð1 þ nÞð1nÞs20 =ðEcÞ. In other words, there exists a critical wavelength lc ¼ 2p=kc , such that the planar free surface of the biaxially stressed half-space is unstable with respect to any undulation with wavelength larger than lc , with lc ¼ p
1 cE 1n2 s20
ð1:13Þ
The existence of a critical wavelength is due to the fact that the undulation-induced fields (which reduce elastic energy) penetrate the solid over a depth of the order of l (Eqs (1.5) and (1.7)–(1.9)), whereas the excess energy due to the increased area is independent of l. Equation (1.12) indicates that an undulation with a given wavelength is all the more easy to create that s 0 is high and all the more difficult that surface energy is high. This analysis can be generalized. The point is that the stress must be nonhydrostatic. The instability of a solid subjected to such stresses with respect to morphological perturbations of its surface is often called ATG (Asaro–Tiller–Grinfeld) [29, 30]. It has been observed (with millimetric wavelengths) at the surface of 4 He crystals under uniaxial stress [34]. However, the ATG instability is particularly important for epitaxy. One indeed attributes to it the often-observed formation of undulations at the surface or at the interfaces of semiconducting layers mismatched with respect to their substrates [35, 36]. Indeed, as seen in Section 1.4, if the mismatch is e0 , the semi-infinite substrate exerts biaxial strain s 0 ¼ ½E=ð1nÞe0 .20) Hence, the free surface of the layer is unstable against surface undulations with wavelengths larger than the critical value given by Eq. (1.13). For typical strains on the order of a percent, this wavelength is only on the order of a few tens to a few hundreds of nanometers. This is a mode of strain relaxation that differs from the usual tetragonal distortion of uniformly thick layers (Section 1.4) by its morphology and its elastic fields and also from their plastic relaxation, since relaxation remains elastic (no extended defect appears). However, at the atomic scale, the surface undulation of a low-index surface corresponds to the modulation of the spacing of preexisting or newly created surface steps. One may indeed recover the instability by considering, for instance, a vicinal surface, slightly misoriented with respect to a high-symmetry orientation, and hence composed of facets separated by steps. It has been shown that under nonhydrostatic stress, the steps interact attractively and thus tend to accumulate in bunches [37]. 20) In the half-space case, the relaxation fields are attenuated over a distance of the order of l perpendicularly to the interface. Hence, the two problems become similar if h > l, so that the top surface and the interface are elastically decoupled.
1.5 Morphological Relaxation of a Solid under Nonhydrostatic Stress
1.5.4 Kinetics of the ATG Instability
Here also kinetics matter, since they condition the actual formation of the undulation. Srolovitz has treated in a simple fashion two mechanisms whereby a planar surface may undulate, namely, surface diffusion and evaporation/condensation [31]. In both cases, one obtains a mode that develops more rapidly than the others, with a wavelength on the order of lc (as in the case of spinodal decomposition; see Section 1.3.2). This explains simply why if Eq. (1.12) leads to a semi-infinite band ½lc ; þ 1 of unstable wavelengths, the experiments show a rather well-defined wavelength. In the case of epitaxy, one must also take into account the influx of matter from the fluid phase (molecular beams, gas or liquid) in addition to the transport of matter along the surface. This has been done by Spencer et al. [38] who, in addition to substrate rigidity, identify two kinetic factors that tend to inhibit the formation of the undulation, namely, a low temperature (which reduces surface diffusion) and a high growth rate (which buries the undulations before they can develop). 1.5.5 Coupling between the Morphological and Compositional Instabilities
Let us consider a half-space z 0 of a regular solution alloy (A, B) with V > 0 (Section 1.2.1). We know that if its free surface remains planar, it is unstable for T TcI against composition modulations with arbitrary wavelengths, if gradient energy is ignored (Section 1.2.4). We also know that if it remains homogeneous, its planar surface is unstable against undulations with wave vectors k kc , at any T (Section 1.5.3). In both cases, elastic relaxation is of primary importance: it determines TcI and it is the driving force for undulation. In this section, we consider briefly how a possible coupling between the two instabilities affects their respective domains of existence.21) To answer this question, we calculate the elastic relaxation of a layer z 0 of average mismatch e0 with a composition modulation along a direction parallel to the substrate/layer interface, but allowing a z-dependent amplitude; without loss of generality, we then write the modulation g1 ec yðkzÞekz with yð0Þ ¼ 1, so that its stress free strain with respect to the substrate is eij ðx; zÞ ¼ dij e0 þ ec yðkzÞekz sin kx . Assume that its free surface is undulated: z ¼ D sin kx. As in the case of the purely morphological perturbation (Section 1.5.2), the elastic relaxation fields cannot be computed exactly; we limit ourselves to the first order in both kD at ec [24]. The excess of elastic energy (per unit area) of the undulated/modulated state with respect to the planar/homogeneous state is then quadratic in these two variables: 1þnE 1 J2 ð1:14Þ dW ¼ J12 e2c e20 ðkDÞ2 2J1 e0 ðkDÞec þ 1n 2 k 1þn 21) Such a coupling has been observed in mismatched epitaxial alloy layers.
j21
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
22
Figure 1.6 Half-space under biaxial stress. (a) Instability domains with respect to separate lateral composition modulation (C) or surface undulation (M), in plane (wave vector, temperature) (S: stability). (b) Domain of joint morphocompositional instability (MC).
Ð0 where Jn ¼ 1 ½yðuÞn e2u du. In Eq. (1.14), the terms in ðkDÞ2 and e2c correspond respectively to a pure undulation (Eq. (1.12)) and to a composition modulation in a planar half-space [24]. Whatever the sign of product J1 e0 , the cross-product becomes negative with an appropriate choice of the sign of D (the phase of the modulation). The elastic energy of the mixed perturbation is then less than the sum of the two perturbations taken separately. If we assume that yðkzÞ > 0 and that e0 and ec have the same sign, then for x l=4ðmod lÞ, the layer is more mismatched than on average, and it is interesting to have a larger relaxation there, hence also a crest (D > 0). The coupling vanishes if the layer is on average lattice matched to its substrate [15]. To obtain the total excess of free energy, we add to dW the excess free enthalpy of mixing and the excess surface energy, as done respectively in Sections 1.2.3 and 1.5.3 [24]. The conclusion is that not only the instability domains but also the very nature of the instability are modified. We must consider together the two parameters that in the case of uncoupled disturbances ðFigure 1.6a) have critical values separating stable and unstable domains, namely, T and k for the compositional (C) and morphological (M) instabilities, respectively. With coupling (Figure 1.6b), one finds in the ðk; TÞ plane an extended domain of morphocompositional (MC) instability. To each wavenumber k corresponds a critical temperature 1 1 þ n E0 2 k T~ c ðkÞ ¼ TcC þ g 4 1n kB kkc
ð1:15Þ
where TcC is the bulk critical temperature (Section 1.2.3). As usual, this thermodynamical analysis must be completed by a kinetic analysis that will decide if the instability will actually develop, depending on the matter transport mechanisms available [39–41].
1.6 Elastic Relaxation of 0D and 1D Epitaxial Nanostructures
We have seen in Section 1.4 that one way to prevent the formation of dislocations during the growth of a mismatched epitaxial layer on a substrate is to keep the
1.6 Elastic Relaxation of 0D and 1D Epitaxial Nanostructures
layer thickness below its critical value for plastic relaxation. This becomes impractical at high lattice mismatch e0 , since the critical thickness decreases rapidly when e0 increases (Section 1.4.3). In such cases, one may play on the dimensionality and dimensions of the deposit (and sometimes of the substrate) to prevent or hinder dislocation formation. Indeed, when the constraint of infinite lateral extension is lifted, the deposit may recover its intrinsic (stress-free) state even if the interface remains coherent. The lattice planes may then deform continuously from the spacing of the substrate toward the intrinsic spacing of the deposit over some distance from the interface. This is realized in quantum dots and nanowires. 1.6.1 Quantum Dots
Section 1.5 indicates that a mismatched epitaxial layer may reduce its total energy by developing a surface undulation. The same driving force leads to the nucleation of coherent islands (instead of a uniformly thick 2D layer) of a strongly mismatched epitaxial deposit in the Volmer–Weber (VW) or Stranski–Krastanov (SK) growth modes.22) Observed for more than 25 years [42], the SK growth of semiconductors spurred the spectacular development of quantum dot nanostructures.23) Although their origin is the same, the descriptions of the ATG and SK (or VW) instabilities differ in that the ATG instability refers to the development of a smoothly varying surface corrugation (typically realized by step bunching on a singular surface), whereas islands are bound by facets with orientations different from that of the substrate [43]. It is precisely these additional lateral free surfaces that allow an efficient strain relaxation. A similar but weaker effect occurs for quantum wires (1D nanostructures) parallel to the substrate. Elastic relaxation, which affects both island and substrate, may be calculated by the general methods introduced in Section 1.1, the transformed part of the system being the island. If analytical solutions exist for the island buried in a half-space (which is indeed relevant since, in practice, most quantum dots are capped after growth) (see Section 1.1.3 and Figure 1.2), this is not the case for uncapped islands. One then has to resort to numerical methods, such as the finite elements method [44, 45] or the atomistic valence force field method [46]. In addition, approximate analytical solutions have been proposed for the strains or the energy [43, 47–51]. Elastic relaxation of the substrate is also important. Indeed, for an island under compression, the substrate is dilated under the island and compressed in its vicinity. Hence, when a first island has nucleated, it is unfavorable to nucleate another one close to it. This is at the origin of the tendency of the islands to self-organize.
22) These modes differ by the absence (VW) or presence (SK) of a thin wetting layer on the substrate. 23) All dimensions of the islands are nanometric, hence the often-used name 0D nanostructures.
j23
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
24
1.6.2 Nanowires
The same kind of effect occurs in nanowires. Epitaxial NWs growing in a direction perpendicular to their substrate are nowadays fabricated from a large range of elemental and compound semiconductor materials [52]. Similarly to quantum dots, NWs have lateral dimensions ranging from a few nanometers to a few tens of nanometers. At variance with quantum dots, which have inclined facets and nanometric heights, freestanding NWs may extend perpendicularly to the substrate with a uniform diameter and over potentially unlimited lengths (in practice, several microns are easily reached). These 1D nanostructures have remarkable physical properties and many potential applications. For a misfitting layer at the top of a NW, lateral relaxation should be even easier than for a quantum dot, since the effective substrate has the same finite diameter instead of being laterally infinite. The strain relaxation for such relaxation has indeed been calculated [53]. As expected, it is very efficient. For instance, for the same misfitting S/L couple, in the NW, the elastic energy is already only a quarter of its 2D value (for the same volume of layer) when the layer thickness is only 10% of the NW diameter. As a consequence, the critical layer thickness, which is now radius dependent, may be much higher than the 2D value for small, but accessible, NW diameters. Moreover, there exists a critical NW radius under which the critical thickness becomes infinite. Both quantities have been calculated [53]. Finally, a similar effect, albeit somewhat less efficient, operates when a NW is grown on a mismatched substrate. Hence, NWs are nanostructures that allow one to associate with strongly mismatched materials in a way that would not be feasible in the 2D (or even the 0D) geometry.
References 1 Eshelby, J.D. (1957) The determination
2 3
4
5
6
of the elastic field of an ellipsoidal inclusion, and related problems. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 241, 376–396. Mura, T. (1991) Micromechanics of Defects in Solids, Kluwer, Dordrecht. Mindlin, R.D. (1936) Force at a point in the interior of a semi-infinite solid. Physics, 7, 195–202. Mindlin, R.D. (1950) Nuclei of strain in the semi-infinite solid. J. Appl. Phys., 21, 926–930. Pan, E. (2003) Three-dimensional Greens functions in an anisotropic half-space with general boundary conditions. J. Appl. Mech., 70, 101–110. Faivre, G. (1964) Deformations de coherence dun precipite quadratique. Phys. Status Solidi, 35, 249–259.
7 Chiu, Y.P. (1978) On the stress filed
and surface deformation in a half space with a cuboidal zone in which initial strains are uniform. J. Appl. Mech., 45, 302–306. 8 Glas, F. (1987) Coherent stress relaxation in a half space: modulated layers, inclusions, steps, and a general solution. J. Appl. Phys., 70, 3556–3571. 9 Pearson, G.S. and Faux, D.A. (2000) Analytical solutions for strain in pyramidal quantum dots. J. Appl. Phys., 88, 730–736. 10 Glas, F. (2001) Elastic relaxation of truncated pyramidal quantum dots and quantum wires in a half space: an analytical calculation. J. Appl. Phys., 90, 3232–3241.
References 11 Khachaturyan, A.G. (1983) Theory of
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22 23
24
Structural Transformations in Solids, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York. Cahn, J.W. (1961) On spinodal decomposition. Acta Metall., 9, 795–801. Cahn, J.W. (1962) On spinodal decomposition in cubic crystals. Acta Metall., 10, 179–183. Cahn, J.W. (1968) Spinodal decomposition. Trans Metall. Soc. AIME, 242, 166–180. Glas, F. (2000) Thermodynamic and kinetic instabilities of lattice-matched alloy layers: compositional and morphological perturbations. Phys. Rev. B, 62, 7393–7401. Ipatova, I.P., Malyshkin, V.G., and Shchukin, V.A. (1993) On spinodal decomposition in elastically anisotropic epitaxial films of III–V semiconductor alloys. J. Appl. Phys., 74, 7198–7210. Cheng, K.Y., Hsieh, K.C., and Baillargeon, J.N. (1992) Formation of lateral quantum wells in vertical short-period superlattices by strain-induced lateral-layer ordering process. Appl. Phys. Lett., 60, 2892–2894. Glas, F., Treacy, M.M.J., Quillec, M., and Launois, H. (1982) Interface spinodal decomposition in LPE InxGa1xAsxP1y lattice matched to InP. J. Phys. (Paris), 43, C5-11–C5-16. Philibert, J. (1991) Atom Movements Diffusion and Mass Transport in Solids, EDP Sciences, Les Ulis, France. Larche, F.C. and Cahn, J.W. (1982) The effect of self-stress on diffusion in solids. Acta Metall., 30, 1835–1845. Larche, F.C. and Voorhees, P.W. (1996) Diffusion and stress: basic thermodynamics. Defect Diffus. Forum, 129–130, 31–36. Philibert, J. (1996) Diffusion and stresses. Defect Diffus. Forum, 129–130, 3–8. Wu, C.H. (1996) The chemical potential for stress-driven surface diffusion. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 44, 2059–2077. Glas, F. (1997) Thermodynamics of a stressed alloy with a free surface: coupling between the morphological and compositional instabilities. Phys. Rev. B, 55, 11277–11286.
25 Hirth, J.P. and Lothe, J. (1982) Theory of
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
Dislocations, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York. Fitzgerald, E.A. (1991) Dislocations in strained-layer epitaxy: theory, experiment, and applications. Mater. Sci. Rep., 7, 87–142. Matthews, J.W. and Blakeslee, A.E. (1974) Defects in epitaxial multilayers. 1. Misfit dislocations. J. Cryst. Growth, 27, 118–125. People, R. and Bean, J.C. (1985) Calculation of critical layer thickness versus lattice mismatch for GexSi1x/Si strained-layer heterostructures. Appl. Phys. Lett., 47, 322–324. Asaro, R.J. and Tiller, W.A. (1972) Interface morphology development during stress corrosion cracking: Part I. Via surface diffusion. Metall. Trans., 3, 1789–1796. Grinfeld, M.A. (1986) Instability of the separation boundary between a non-hydrostatically stressed elastic body and a melt. Sov. Phys. Dokl., 31, 831–834. Srolovitz, D.J. (1989) On the stability of surfaces of stressed solids. Acta Metall., 37, 621–625. Colin, J., Grilhe, J., and Junqua, N. (1997) Localized surface instability of a nonhomogeneously stressed solid. Europhys. Lett., 38, 307–312. Love, A.E.H. (1944) A Treatise on the Mathematical Theory of Elasticity, 4th edn, Dover, New York. Thiel, M., Willibald, A., Evers, P., Levchenko, A., Leiderer, P., and Balibar, S. (1992) Stress-induced melting and surface instability of 4He crystals. Europhys. Lett., 20, 707–713. Cullis, A.G., Robbins, D.J., Pidduck, A.J., and Smith, P.W. (1992) The characteristics of strain-modulated surface undulations formed upon epitaxial Si1xGex alloy layers on Si. J. Cryst. Growth, 123, 333–343. Ponchet, A., Rocher, A., Emery, J.-Y., Starck, G., and Goldstein, L. (1993) Lateral modulations in zero-net strained GaInAsP multilayers grown by gas source molecular-beam epitaxy. J. Appl. Phys., 74, 3778–3782.
j25
j 1 Elastic Strain Relaxation: Thermodynamics and Kinetics
26
37 Tersoff, J. (1995) Step bunching instability
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
of vicinal surfaces under stress. Phys. Rev. Lett., 75, 2730–2733. Spencer, B.J., Voorhees, P.W., and Davis, S.H. (1992) Morphological instability in epitaxially strained dislocation-free solid films: linear stability theory. J. Appl. Phys., 73, 4955–4970. Huang, Z.-F. and Desai, R.C. (2001) Instability and decomposition on the surface of strained alloy films. Phys. Rev. B, 65, 195421. Huang, Z.-F. and Desai, R.C. (2002) Epitaxial growth in dislocation-free strained alloy films: morphological and compositional instabilities. Phys. Rev. B, 65, 205419. Spencer, B.J., Voorhees, P.W., and Tersoff, J. (2001) Morphological instability theory for strained alloy film growth: the effect of compositional stresses and species-dependent surface mobilities on ripple formation during epitaxial film deposition. Phys. Rev. B, 64, 235318. Goldstein, L., Glas, F., Marzin, J.-Y., Charasse, M.N., and Le Roux, G. (1985) Growth by molecular beam epitaxy and characterization of InAs/GaAs strainedlayer superlattices. Appl. Phys. Lett., 47, 1099–1101. M€ uller, P. and Sa ul, A. (2004) Elastic effects on surface physics. Surf. Sci. Rep., 54, 157–258. Christiansen, S., Albrecht, M., Strunk, H.P., and Maier, H.J. (1994) Strained state of Ge(Si) islands on Si: finite element calculations and comparison to convergent beam electron-diffraction measurements. Appl. Phys. Lett., 64, 3617–3619. Ponchet, A., Lacombe, D., Durand, L., Alquier, D., and Cardonna, J.-M. (1998)
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
Elastic energy of strained islands: contribution of the substrate as a function of the island aspect ratio and inter-island distance. Appl. Phys. Lett., 72, 2984–2986. Lin, Y.-Y. and Singh, J. (2002) Selfassembled quantum dots: a study of strain energy and intersubband transitions. J. Appl. Phys., 92, 6205–6210. Daruka, I. and Barabasi, A.-L. (1997) Dislocation-free island formation in heteroepitaxial growth: a study at equilibrium. Phys. Rev. Lett., 79, 3708–3711. Gippius, N.A. and Tikhodeev, S.G. (1999) Inhomogeneous strains in semiconducting nanostructures. J. Exp. Theor. Phys., 88, 1045–1049. Tersoff, J. and Tromp, R.M. (1993) Shape transition in growth of strained islands: spontaneous formation of quantum wires. Phys. Rev. Lett., 70, 2782–2785. Wang, Y.W. (2000) Self-organization, shape transition, and stability of epitaxially strained islands. Phys. Rev. B, 61, 10388–10392. Zinovyev, V.A., Vastola, G., Montalenti, F., and Miglio, L. (2006) Accurate and analytical strain mapping at the surface of Ge/Si(001) islands by an improved flat-island approximation. Surf. Sci., 600, 4777–4784. Dick, K.A. (2008) A review of nanowire growth promoted by alloys and nonalloying elements with emphasis on Au-assisted III–V nanowires. Prog. Cryst. Growth Ch., 54, 138–173. Glas, F. (2006) Critical dimensions for the plastic relaxation of strained axial heterostructures in free-standing nanowires. Phys. Rev. B, 74, 121302.
j27
2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity Pierre M€uller
2.1 Introduction
Understanding the relationship between the structure and the shape of a piece of matter and its mechanical properties has always been one of the primary goals of material science. Over the past decades, the rapid progress in the development of new materials with a size of a few nanometers has opened a new field of scientific and technological interest. From a fundamental viewpoint, one of the key features of nanosized material is their high surface/bulk ratio with the consequence that materials in small dimensions behave differently from their bulk counterpart. From a technological viewpoint, nanomaterials are promising building blocks in future devices, but the stresses they develop can be detrimental to their reliability or can be used to modify their physical properties. Thus, for both fundamental and technological applications, there is a growing interest in the study of the mechanics of nanosized objects. For instance, it has been found that the elastic modulus, which measures the proportionality between the applied stress and the measured strain, is size dependent for dimension smaller than roughly 200 nm. However, according to the authors, calculated or measured elastic moduli have been reported to increase or decrease with the size of the object. From an experimental viewpoint, this discrepancy may come from the difficulty of manipulation and the lack of characterization of such small objects, as well as from the uncertainty of the complex boundary conditions between a nanosized object and the micronic-sized tool used to measure its elastic properties. From a theoretical viewpoint, there are still some difficulties to perfectly describe elasticity at the nanoscale. Most of the models used for describing the mechanical properties of a body are based on the classical linear and infinitesimal theory of elasticity of continuum mediums [1, 2]. In such models, a macroscopic object is considered as a continuum medium, the surface of which is a simple boundary at which external forces are applied. It means that the classical macroscopic theory ignores surface effects since it does not attribute any specific elastic properties to the surface. However, because of the missing bonds, there is a redistribution of
Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale: Simulation, Material Systems and Characterization Techniques, First Edition. Edited by Margrit Hanb€ ucken, Pierre M€ uller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn. 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. Published 2011 by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA.
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
28
electronic charges close to the surface that modifies the local binding properties so that the surface layers cannot have the same elastic properties as the underlying bulk. This means that because of the reduced coordination of surface atoms, a small piece of matter cut in a homogeneous body is not homogeneous. The simpler way to describe this inhomogeneity is to divide the object into a bulk core and a surface zone with different elastic properties. We will show that when such specific surface properties are considered, the elastic behavior of a finite-size body results from a subtle interplay between its bulk and surface properties and thus depends on the absolute size of the object. Our goal in this chapter is to describe the elastic properties of nanoscale objects from the point of view of surface physicists. In other words, our purpose is to properly introduce surface effects on elastic classical theory.1) This chapter is divided into two parts. The first part emphasizes the theoretical background. It begins by a few results valid for the bulk (Section 2.2.1), followed by a description of the surface elastic properties (Section 2.2.2) in the Gibbs meaning (Section 2.2.3) and then in the twophase models (Section 2.2.4). The second part concerns applications. We will describe how surface stress may induce spontaneous deformation of nanoparticles (Section 2.3.1), may modify the effective modulus of freestanding thin films (Section 2.3.2), and may play a role for the static bending of thin films (Section 2.3.3) and nanowires (Section 2.3.4). A short conclusion will sum up the main effects the surfaces induce on the elastic properties of nanoscale objects. Again, our goal is not to review all recent results, since in particular the number of papers devoted to the study of the mechanical properties of nanosized objects is increasing exponentially, but essentially to underline the fundamentals of nanoelasticity.
2.2 Theoretical Background 2.2.1 Bulk Elasticity: A Recall
The classical theory of elasticity treats solids as continuum mediums in which the deformation is described by continuum fields such as the displacement vector ~ u ð~ rÞ and the strain tensor eð~ r Þ, while internal forces are described by the stress tensor sð~ r Þ. Within linear infinitesimal elasticity, the equilibrium deformation field is a solution of a second-order equation that has to be solved with boundary equations expressed in terms of external forces applied at the free surface of the body. In this section, we will recall some classical results valid for bulk elasticity but necessary as a prerequisite before studying surface elasticity in Section 2.2.2. 1) The limit of the description is that it is necessary to be able to discriminate surface from bulk. Such models thus cannot be used to describe the elastic properties of aggregates formed only by a few atoms, for which it is no more possible to attribute to the atoms a surface or a bulk character.
2.2 Theoretical Background
2.2.1.1 Stress and Strain Definition If a continuum medium is strained, a point in the body is displaced from its initial r þ~ u . The vector ~ up offfiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi components ui ¼ xi0 xi is called the position ~ r to ~ r0 ¼~ two points of displacement vector. The distance d‘ ¼ dx12 þ dx22 þ dx32 between pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi infinitesimal vicinity d~ x before deformation becomes d‘0 ¼ dx102 þ dx202 þ dx302 with dxi0 ¼ dxi þ dui after deformation. For small displacements, this distance can P be written as d‘02 ¼ d‘2 þ 2 i; j eij dxi dxj , where the quantity 1 @ui @uj eij ¼ þ ð2:1Þ 2 @xj @xi
is called the bulk strain tensor. When the body is strained, there develop forces tending to restore its initial configuration. These internal forces are transmitted across the surface that bounds the volume. The forces ~ F dS exerted on the faces of an elemental cube centered on the considered point can be written for a face i as [1, 2] X Fi ¼ sij nj ð2:2Þ j
where sij are the components of the so-called stress tensor and ~ n is a unit vector directed toward the exterior of the face i (see Figure 2.1). Notice that in the framework of infinitesimal elasticity, the stress and strain definitions do not make a distinction between the deformed and the nondeformed configuration of the body. This is not the case for large deformation [1, 2]. 2.2.1.2 Equilibrium State From Eq. (2.2), the Hforce component Fi (i ¼ 1; 2; 3) on a volume V bounded by a P surface S is Fi ¼ j s ij nj dS. It can be transformed into a volume integral
Figure 2.1 Action of the components s ij of the bulk stress tensor applied on the three front faces of an elementary cube cut in a piece of matter. Each face normal to xj axis bears a triplet
s ij . The first index i ¼ 1; 2; 3 gives the direction xi where the stress acts. On the back faces of the cube, there are identical stresses of opposite sign.
j29
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
30
ÐP Fi ¼ Ð j ð@s ij =@xj ÞdV, and so taking into account the Newtons second law Fi ¼ rðd2 ui =dt2 ÞdV (valid for a body of density r), we get X @sij j
@xj
¼r
d2 u i dt2
ð2:3Þ
which is called the elastodynamic equation. At equilibrium, it reads X @sij j
@xj
¼0
ð2:4Þ
Note that we have neglected all forms of body forces.2) 2.2.1.3 Elastic Energy Under the action of external forces ~ F applied to the surface S of an elastic body of volumeHV, the surface points are displaced by d~ u, so the work of the external forces is Fd~ u dS. Using the expression of Fi given in Eq. (2.2), we have dW ¼ H ~ P dW ¼ j s ij nj dui dS. This surface integral can be transformed into a volume integral by means of the divergence theorem, so from Eqs (2.1) and (2.4), we have dW ¼
ðX
ð sij deij dV þ
i; j
r
d2 ui dui dV dt2
ð2:5Þ
The first part of (2.5) is the elastic contribution due to the elastic deformation and the second part is the variation of the total kinetic energy during the time dt. We will denote bulk elastic energy by ðX dW bulk ¼ sij deij dV ð2:6Þ i; j
2.2.1.4 Elastic Constants In linear elastic theory, each stress component is assumed to be proportional to each strain component. Taking into account the tensorial nature of both strain and stress fields, this linear dependence (Hookes law) can be written as X sij ¼ Cijkl ekl ð2:7Þ k;l
where the material constants Cijkl are called elastic (or stiffness) constants.
2) Body forces are proportional to the body mass. They include gravitational forces, magnetic forces, and inertial forces. They can be written as a volume integral over the body. In contrast, in the context of the classical elastic theory, surface forces result only from the physical contact of the body with another body and are thus expressed as a surface integral over the whole area of the body.
2.2 Theoretical Background
Using (2.7), after integration with respect to strain, Eq. (2.6) becomes ð 1 X dW bulk ¼ Cijkl eij ekl dV 2 i;j;k;l
ð2:8Þ
Depending on the crystal symmetry, one can further reduce the number of elastic constants. The maximum number of elastic constants is required for triclinic crystals, where it is 21. For isotropic bodies, it is 2. In this latter case, Hookes law reads ! X E n X sij ¼ l ekk dij þ 2meij or sij ¼ ekk dij ð2:9Þ eij þ 1þn 12n k k when using the Lame (l and m) or Hooke (E and n) constants, respectively. Note that the dilatation of a isotropic cube, uniformly loaded by pressure P, is X k
ekk ¼
3ð12nÞ P E
where K ¼ E=3ð12nÞ is the bulk elastic modulus. 2.2.2 How to Describe Surfaces or Interfaces?
In classical elastic theories of the previous section, surfaces solely serve to define boundary conditions but have no specific properties. In Section 2.2.3, we will see that as any extensive thermodynamic potentials (e.g., U, F, G, etc.), the elastic energy can be seen as a contribution from two homogeneous phases plus an interfacial term that contains all the elastic properties of the interfacial zone. The localization and the description of this interfacial zone are discussed in this section. Consider a slab of thickness e in which, because of the missing bonds at the surface, any extensive quantity must continuously vary with the altitude z (see Figure 2.2). The central problem is how to discriminate bulk from surface contributions.
Figure 2.2 A slab of thickness e in which an extensive quantity continuously varies with the altitude. The extensive quantity (let us say a stress parallel to the surface) is represented by a double array whose length varies when approaching each surface.
j31
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
32
Figure 2.3 At the interface between two materials, A and B, extensive quantities are modified from their bulk values by an excess amount gðzÞ (shaded) owing to the presence of
the interface (Figure 2.3a). In the Gibbs model, the whole excess quantity will be ascribed to the dividing surface separating two bulk materials (Figure 2.3b).
A first approach uses the concept of excess quantity [3]. More generally, let us consider two homogeneous phases A and B separated by a planar interface SAB and let us consider an extensive quantity G whose density gðzÞ varies across the interface (z is the axis perpendicular to the interface). In the bulk, far from the interface, g-profile is homogeneous. The interface modifies g by an excess quantity that corresponds to the shaded area in Figure 2.3a. The so-defined excess quantities is 2z 3 ðB ð2:10Þ g interf SAB ¼ SAB 4 gðzÞdzgA ðj0 zA ÞgB ðzB z0 Þ5 zA
where gi are the bulk density in each phase (i ¼ A; B), SAB the interfacial area, and g interf the interfacial excess quantity per unit interface area. This definition does not depend upon the values of zA and zB provided they are, respectively, lower and higher than jA and jB . Some well-known interfacial excess quantities are the number of particles in excess at the surface, the surface entropy, or even the mass excess of the interfacial zone. Gibbs [3] proposed, for a pure substance in contact with the vacuum, to choose the localization of the dividing surface j0 to the mathematical plane for which there is no surface excess of mass3) (Figure 2.4). In the case of a multicompound substance, the dividing surface can be fixed to the mathematical plane for which the surface excess mass of one species is zero. In this case, a surface excess remains for the other components j. Once the position of the Gibbs surface is defined, the system is modeled as a bulk material with unaltered properties up to the dividing surface at which is added some excess quantity completely assigned to the Gibbs dividing surface (Figure 2.3b and Figure 2.5a). In this ideal scheme, the volume of the interfacial zone between the ideal bulk and the vacuum is zero (Figure 2.3a). Notice that elastic deformations change the position of the Gibbs surface [4].
3) It is sometimes called the Gibbs equimolar dividing surface.
2.2 Theoretical Background
Figure 2.4 The location of the Gibbs dividing surface is chosen at theÐmathematical plane j0 for which the surface excess number of a given specie vanishes (Nsurf ¼ nðzÞdzNA NB ¼ 0).
An alternative choice is to attach the dividing surface to a given piece of matter (Figure 2.5b) and, for instance, to treat the surface layers as a coating thin film with elastic properties different from those of the underlying bulk. The thickness of the film is thus arbitrary defined by the position of the dividing surface. The two models must not be confused, even when the surface film is one monolayer thick. Indeed, these two idealized schemes (Figure 2.5a and b) correspond to different definitions of associated thermodynamics quantities. For instance, when using the ideal Gibbs dividing surface, the surface energy c and the surface stress sab components are perfectly defined as excess quantities, which is not the case for the two-layer models (surface film plus bulk-like phase) for which the energy and the stress of the surface layer, respectively, are Elayer ¼ Ebulk þ c and tab ¼ s ab þ sab , where Ebulk and sab , respectively, are the energy and the stress of a bulk-like monolayer. For very thin films, the two surface zones shown in Figure 2.2 may overlap, making it impossible to define excess quantities with respect to the (nonexistent) bulk. Thus, the idealization of the dividing surface is valid only if the body is much larger than several atomic layers.
Figure 2.5 Two approaches to distinguish surfaces from the bulk. (a) Gibbs model in which surface excesses are ascribed to a mathematical plane (the dividing surface). (b) The surface can also be modeled as a thin film of thickness e. These models represent the variation in Figure 2.2.
j33
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
34
2.2.3 Surfaces and Interfaces Described from Excess Quantities
Here, we will consider Gibbs model (Figure 2.5a). For the sake of simplicity, we will write x x1 ; y x2 ; z x3 , with this last axis normal to the surface. Moreover, in what follows, Latin indices (i; j ¼ 1; 2; 3) describe bulk properties, while Greek indices (a; b ¼ 1; 2) describe surface properties. 2.2.3.1 The Surface Elastic Energy as an Excess of the Bulk Elastic Energy The elastic energy (Eq. (2.6)) is an extensive quantity that may be present in excess at the interface between two homogeneous materials as defined by Eq. (2.10). This excess quantity is defined as the difference between the elastic energy of the whole system and the sum of the elastic energies of the two homogeneous materials (see Figure 2.3): zðB
dW
interf
¼ zA
X
s ij ðzÞdeij ðzÞdV
ij
X
sAij deAij V A
ij
X
sBij deBij V B
ð2:11Þ
ij
where sij ðzÞ and eij ðzÞ are the bulk stress and strain profiles across the interface, while s nij and s nij (with n ¼ A; B) are the homogeneous stress and strain tensors in the two homogeneous materials A and B separated by the interface (normal to the axis z). The interfacial quantity is the shaded area in Figure 2.3. Equation (2.11) can be simplified when considering two physical conditions. i) The first condition is mechanical equilibrium that states that in absence of body forces, Eq. (2.4) gives (since there is only one variable z ¼ x3 ) @s i3 ¼ 0; @x3
i ¼ 1; 2; 3 8 x3
ð2:12Þ
This means that the normal components of the stress tensor are homogeneous in the whole material: siz ðzÞ ¼ sAiz ¼ sBiz
ð2:13Þ
ii) The second condition is a nongliding condition4) that states that any infinitesimal change of the strain tensor components parallel to the interface must be the same in the whole material: deab ðzÞ ¼ deAab ¼ deBab
ða; b ¼ 1; 2Þ
Using conditions (2.13) and (2.14), Eq. (2.11) becomes [5] X X dW interf =SAB ¼ sab deab þ siz deiz ab
i
4) Glissile epitaxy will be treated in Section 2.2.3.7.
ð2:14Þ
ð2:15Þ
2.2 Theoretical Background
where sab
2z 3 ðB 1 4 ¼ AB sab ðzÞdVsAab V A sBab V B 5 S
ð2:16Þ
zA
and 2z 3 ðB 1 4 A A B B5 ei3 ¼ AB ei3 ðzÞdVei3 V ei3 V S
ð2:17Þ
zA
These equations suggest that we define the interfacial stress tensor 0 1 s11 s12 0 ½s ¼ @ s21 s22 0 A 0 0 0 and the interfacial 0 0 ½e ¼ @ 0 e31
strain tensor 1 0 e13 0 e23 A e32 e33
ð2:18Þ
ð2:19Þ
Notice that interfacial stress and interfacial strain are orthogonal tensors since sij eij ¼ 0. 2.2.3.2 The Surface Stress and Surface Strain Concepts Let us now consider the case where the phase B is vacuum so that s Bi3 ¼ 0 at mechanical equilibrium. In this case, Eq. (2.15) becomes X dW surf ¼ SAB sab deab ð2:20Þ ab
where sab
2z 3 ðB 1 4 ¼ A sab ðzÞdVsAab V A5 S
ð2:21Þ
zA
now defines the surface stress as an excess quantity that generally is nonzero even if there is no stress in the bulk. Surface stress components may be positive (tensile) or negative (compressive). Note that for a Hookean solid, the total elastic energy of a semi-infinite solid is the sum of a bulk elastic energy (Eq. (2.8)) and a surface elastic energy (Eq. (2.20)): ð ðX 1 X dW el ¼ dW bulk þ dW surf ¼ Cijkl eij ekl dV þ sab eab dS ð2:22Þ 2 i;j;k;l ab For illustrative purposes, Figure 2.6 shows the calculated bulk energy versus normal deformation ezz (Figure 2.6a) and then versus in-plane deformation exx
j35
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
36
Figure 2.6 (a) Elastic energy versus strain ezz for a bulk material (circles), an unrelaxed slab (squares), and a relaxed slab (diamonds). (b) Elastic energy versus strain exx for a bulk material (circles), an unrelaxed slab (squares),
and a relaxed slab (diamonds). Note that when the elastic relaxation of the slab is properly taken into account, the parabola DE ðexx Þ is shifted but not the parabola DE ðezz Þ. It means that the components siz ¼ 0.
(Figure 2.6b). Three calculations have been performed: for a bulk material, for an unrelaxed slab of n layers, and for an elastically relaxed slab (ab initio calculations by Wien code [6], cubic material). For the slab, two calculations have been performed: the first one is for an unrelaxed slab and the second one for a relaxed slab. Figure 2.6 shows that (i) for such small deformations, Hookes law is valid (quadratic shape of the bulk energy); (ii) for unrelaxed slab, the surface stress shifts the parabola of the bulk energy that, according to (2.22), now contains a quadratic term and a linear term and roughly scales Ce2 þ se; and (iii) for an elastically relaxed slab, the bulk parabola is shifted for the in-plane deformation but remains centered on zero for the normal deformation. This last point (iii) simply illustrates that at mechanical equilibrium, surface stress components siz must be zero, so surface stress can be considered as a degenerated two-dimensional second rank tensor of order 2 (in the referential of the flat surface): s s ð2:23Þ ½s ¼ 11 12 s21 s22 Notice that Eq. (2.20) implies that the surface stress is the isothermal work per unit area against surface deformation at constant number of surface atoms. It must not be confused with the work done per unit area against surface creation at constant strain obtained by reversible cleavage, which is called surface energy (at least for pure materials). Figure 2.7 shows the main differences between surface stress and surface energy. The surface energy c is associated with breaking bonds. It can be calculated, at least at 0 K, by counting the broken bonds (and thus by adding interatomic potentials). The surface energy is a scalar quantity that scales as energy per unit area. The surface stress, which is a tensor, is associated with the work against surface deformation, and it is the result of forces acting at the material surface (and thus calculated as a sum of the first derivatives of the interatomic potentials). More precisely, if the surface is
2.2 Theoretical Background
Figure 2.7 Difference between surface stress and surface energy. The surface stress originates from an elastic deformation and thus from bond stretching. It is an excess of stress at the surface (double arrows). Surface energy originates from
a cleaving process and thus from breaking bonds. It is thus calculated as the sum of bonds (A is the surface area and ni the number of ith neighbors whose bonding energy ji are sketched by the arrows).
divided into parts by a curved boundary, where ~ n is the unit vector normal to the P boundary in the surface plane, the surface stress tensor gives the force fi ¼ j sij nj exerted across the boundary curve. 2.2.3.3 Surface Elastic Constants If a stress-free system is deformed in a direction parallel to the surface, a bulk stress will appear. For small deformations, Hookes law is valid, so the total energy of a piece of the deformed matter (with surface and bulk contributions) is (up to the second order in strain) E ¼ E0 þ A0 c0 þ A0
X
s0;ab eab þ
ab
V0 X Cijkl eij ekl 2 ijkl
ð2:24Þ
where E0 is the cohesive energy, A0 c0 the surface energy, and the last term the elastic energy shared in its surface and bulk contributions (see Eqs (2.8) and (2.20)). (A0 is the area of the free undeformed surface and s0;ab the surface stress components.) Equation (2.24) can be compared with the energy stored by an equivalent volume but without any surface: E bulk ¼ E0 þ
V0 X bulk C eij ekl 2 ijkl ijkl
Comparing Eqs (2.24) and (2.25), we obtain A0 c0 ¼ EE bulk e¼0
ð2:25Þ
ð2:26Þ
j37
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
38
which defines the surface energy c0 A0 as the surface excess of the cohesion energy measured at zero strain. In the same way, we obtain @E @E bulk A0 s0;ab ¼ ð2:27Þ @eab @eab e¼0 which defines the surface stress as the surface excess of the first derivative of the cohesion energy versus bulk deformation. Finally, the comparison of Eqs (2.24) and (2.25) gives 2 h i @ E @ 2 E bulk surf bulk A0 Cijkl ¼ ¼ V0 Cijkl Cijkl ð2:28Þ @eij @ekl @eij @ekl e¼0 surf which now defines the surface elastic constants Cijkl as the surface excess of the second derivative of the cohesion energy versus strain. The surface elastic constants measure how the surface stress changes with strain. Note that
i) From Eq. (2.28), the surface elastic constants can, in principle, be negative. It does not violate thermodynamic stability. Indeed, a surface cannot exist on its own, but must be supported by a bulk material. In other words, it is the total energy (surface plus volume) that ensures solid stability. ii) Since, at equilibrium, the components of the stress tensor perpendicular to the surface must be zero, every bulk elastic constants has not an excess at the surface. Table 2.1 lists the independent surface elastic constants for different plane point groups as reported by Shenoy [7] X sab ¼ s0ab þ Sabcd ecd ð2:29Þ cd
Table 2.1 Surface elastic constants.
Point group
Independent constants
Constraints
1, 2
All the 9 Sabcd
No
1 m, 2 mm
S1111 ; S1122 ; S1212 ; S2211 ; S2222
S1112 ¼ S1211 ¼ S1222 ¼ S2212 ¼ 0
4
S1111 ; S1112 ; S1211 ; S1212 ; S1122
S1122 ¼ S1211 ; S2211 ¼ S1122 S2212 ¼ S1112 ; S2222 ¼ S1111
4 mm
S1111 ; S1122 ; S1212
S1112 ¼ S1211 ¼ S1222 ¼ S2212 ¼ 0 S2211 ¼ S1122 ; S2222 ¼ S1111
3,6
S1111 ; S1112 ; S1122
S1211 ¼ S1112 ; 2S1212 ¼ S1111 S1122 S1222 ¼ S1112 ; S2211 ¼ S1122 S2211 ¼ S1122 ; S2222 ¼ S1111
3 m, 6 mm
S1111 ; S1122
S1112 ¼ S1211 ¼ S1222 ¼ S2212 ¼ 0 2S1212 ¼ S1111 S1122 S2211 ¼ S1122 ; S2222 ¼ S1111
Adapted from Ref. [7].
2.2 Theoretical Background Table 2.2 Relations between surface quantities.
Euler
Lagrange
Excess energy
AðeÞcE ðeÞ A0 c0 þ A0 s0 e þ
Surface energy
cE ðeÞ c0 þ ðs0 c0 Þe þ
Surface stress
E sE ðeÞ c0 þ @c @e
e¼0
A0 C0surf e2 2
ðC0surf s0 Þe2 2
þ C0surf s0 e
A0 cL ðeÞ A0 c0 þ A0 s0 e þ cL ðeÞ c0 þ s0 e þ E sL ðeÞ @c @e
e¼0
A0 C0surf e2 2
C0surf e2 2
þ C0surf e
Adapted from Ref. [5].
meaning Sabcd ¼
1 @ 2 W surf s0 dcd S @ eab @ecd ab
in agreement with the simplified expression s ¼ s0 þ C0surf s0 e, given in Table 2.2 for isotropic surface stress. In Table 2.2 are shown the most useful relations valid for isotropic stresses and strains written in Eulerian (the reference state is the deformed state) and Lagrangian (the reference state is the undeformed state) coordinates. 2.2.3.4 Connecting Surface and Bulk Stresses At mechanical equilibrium, the forces exerted by the surface to the underlying substrate must be equal and opposite to the distributed forces exerted by the bulk on the surface. It follows that the presence of surface stress results in nonclassical boundary conditions valid at equilibrium. Mechanical equilibrium is achieved on much smaller timescales than shape equilibrium that needs mass transport. Mechanical equilibrium can thus be derived at constant surface shape. In other words, mechanical equilibrium is achieved when the first variation of W el (given by (2.22)) with respect to a variation of displacement dui vanishes. The first variation is ðX ðX ðX @ekl dW el ¼ Cijkl dui dV þ Cijkl ekl dui nj dS þ sab eab dS @xj ijkl i; j;k;l ab ð2:30Þ
Note that the last integral can be written as5) ð ½divS s þ ðs : kÞ~ n d~ u dS
ð2:31Þ
5) For this purpose, it is enough to replace in (2.30) the strain components by the expressions of e in terms of the derivative of the displacement field (see Eq. (2.1)) and then to use the divergence theorem.
j39
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
40
where for the sake of readability, we avoid index notation and use the surface divergence operator divS, the curvature tensor k, and: for tensor product. Finally,~ n is a unit vector normal to the surface. Since at equilibrium the first variation dW el must vanish for any arbitrary value of P d~ u , one obtains (with Eq. (2.7) and in absence of body forces) fi ¼ j @sij =@xj ¼ 0 in n at the surface or more precisely @sab =@xa ¼ sa3 the bulk and s ij nj ¼ divS s þ ðs : kÞ~ and s ij ni nj ¼ sab kab . It is more convenient to project the last equations on the threeaxis surface ~ x i to get 8 @s11 @s12 > > s13 ¼ þ ðaÞ > > @x1 @x2 > > > > < @s21 @s22 s23 ¼ þ ðbÞ @x1 @x2 > > > > > s11 s12 > > ðcÞ > : s33 ¼ R1 þ R2
ð2:32Þ
where Ri are the principal curvatures. Parts (a) and (b) in Equation (2.32) mean that, at the surface, the surface stress variation must be compensated by bulk shearing stresses. Moreover, note that the last equation is the Gibbs–Thomson equation, giving the Laplace overpressure in a curved crystal. Obviously, it reads s 33 ¼ 0 for a free planar surface. For completeness, Weissm€ uller and Cahn [8] have derived a general expression for the mean stress in microstructures due to interfacial stresses. 2.2.3.5 Surface Stress and Surface Tension Using Eq. (2.15), the excess of internal energy at the free surface of a body becomes dU surf ¼ T dSsurf þ
X ab
sab deab A þ
X
mi dNisurf
ð2:33Þ
i
where Ssurf is the surface entropy, Nisurf the number of particles in excess at the surface of chemical potential mi , and A the surface area [5]. Using the Euler integral of the surface excess energy [5] in the form P U surf ¼ TSsurf þ cA þ i mi Nisurf , we obtain the Gibbs–Duhem equation valid for a free surface [5] dc ¼
X X
Ssurf dT þ sab cdab deab Cn dmn A n ab
ð2:34Þ
where Cn is the surface number density of particles n of chemical potential mn . One of the derivatives of c stemming from Eq. (2.34) gives the so-called Shuttleworth equation that connects surface stress and surface energy: @c sab ¼ cdab þ ð2:35Þ @eab m ;T;eiz n
2.2 Theoretical Background
Equation (2.35) is obtained using the deformed surface (Eulerian coordinates) as a reference state. If the undeformed state is used (Lagrangian coordinates), the Shuttleworth relation becomes @c sab ¼ ð2:36Þ @eab m ;T;eiz n
Bottomley et al. [9] discuss the compatibility of the Shuttleworth equation with the Hermann formulation of thermodynamics. In response to Bottomley, subsequent works [10–13] clarified and validated the Shuttleworth relation. 2.2.3.6 Surface Stress and Adsorption Another derivative of c stemming from (2.34) gives the so-called Gibbs adsorption isotherm @c ¼ Cn @mn T;eij
which shows how the surface energy varies with respect to the chemical potential mn . Using this expression, the Shuttleworth Eq. (2.35) gives the surface stress change with respect to the chemical potential as @sab @Cn ¼ Cn dab ð2:37Þ @mn T;eij @eab For a Langmuir adsorption, the surface coverage q linearly depends on the pressure P by means of q P ¼ expðj=kT Þ 1q P1
ð2:38Þ
where P1 is a constant and j the interaction energy between the adsorbate and its substrate.6) In this case, using the Gibbs adsorption isotherm and Eq. (2.37), the surface stress and the surface energy change with coverage become [5] Dc ¼
kT lnð1qÞ and a2
Dsab ¼ Dcdab þ
q @j a2 @eab
ð2:39Þ
where 0 < q < 1. Some examples of the so-calculated surface stress change are shown in Figure 2.8a in case of Langmuir adsorption, where Eq. (2.39) is valid, and also in case of Bragg–Williams adsorption, where adsorbate–adsorbate interactions play a role (see Ref. [15]). The surface stress change induced by an adsorbate can be measured. Consider a sheet (or a cantilever), a face of which is exposed to foreign molecules. Owing to the 6) Notice that Cn ¼ Nn =A, where Nn is the number of adsorbed atoms and A the surface area, whereas qn ¼ Nn =N, where N is the number of surface sites. At the same, the chemical potential is defined as m ¼ kT lnðP=P1 Þ.
j41
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
42
Figure 2.8 Surface stress versus adsorption: (a) Surface stress variation calculated for Langmuir adsorption and Bragg–Williams adsorption. Adapted from Ref. [15]. (b) Surface
stress variation measured for C/Ni(1000) and Co/Pt(111). Adapted from Ref. [14]. (c) Surface stress variation versus coverage for Fe/W(001). Adapted from Ref. [18].
adsorption, the two sides of the sheet are no more in the same state of stress (see Eq. (2.39)), so the sheet spontaneously bends. The radius of curvature RðqÞ is simply related to the surface stress difference by means of the Stoney formula [16] valid for thin isotropic sheets characterized by their Young modulus E and Poisson ratio n: 1 6ð1nÞ ¼ DsðqÞ RðqÞ Eh2
ð2:40Þ
Since the surface stress varies with the adsorbed coverage q, the measurement of the coverage variation of the radius of curvature gives access to sðqÞ when the surface stress of the bare sheet (before adsorption) is known. Note that for very thin films, the Stoney formula needs to be corrected [17]. Many experimental results on surface stress change with adsorption have been published (for a review, see Ref. [14]). For example, Figure 2.8b shows the surface stress change induced by carbon atoms adsorbed on Ni(001) surface. Figure 2.8b shows the surface stress change experimentally recorded for Fe/W(110) by Sander et al. [18]. In this last case, the sudden variations of surface stress versus coverage are associated with the appearance of successive surface phases. The case of nonhomogeneous adsorption has been studied by Bar et al. [19]. 2.2.3.7 The Case of Glissile Interfaces To be complete, notice that for glissile epitaxies, the description of stresses at the interface requires two interfacial tensors. One reflects the straining at constant deformation in both phases, while the other reflects the alteration of the interface structure at constant average strain [20, 21]. 2.2.4 Surfaces and Interfaces Described as a Foreign Material
When using two-phase models (see Section 2.2.2), the surface is considered as a foreign thin film coating an underlying material. The basic equations consist of classical elastic equations valid for the bulk coupled to elastic equations valid for the film. Generally, the surface film cannot glide on the underlying bulk.
2.2 Theoretical Background
2.2.4.1 The Surface as a Thin Bulk-Like Film In unorthodox approaches, the system (solid þ surface) may be considered as a composite material constituted by two different materials.7) As an illustration, let us consider the flexural rigidity (defined as the force torque required to bend a system to a unit curvature). For a single material, the flexural rigidity depends on the elastic modulus and the second moment of inertia of the sheet. For a multilayered composite, the flexural rigidity can be written as a function of the flexural rigidity of each of its layers. In a similar way, the flexural rigidity of a piece of body separated by a bulk core surrounded by a surface zone can be calculated by attributing specific elastic properties to the surface considered as a layer film with specific elastic constants and a given thickness. Notice again that this layered material (body þ surface) simply is a pileup of bulk-like materials without any specific mechanical interfacial properties in the Gibbs meaning. Such models will be discussed in detail in Section 2.3.4. 2.2.4.2 The Surface as an Elastic Membrane The main difference from the previous case is that now the film modeling the surface is considered to be an elastic membrane, that is, a material of negligible thickness and negligible flexural rigidity8) bonded to a bulk substrate material. For the sake of simplicity, both materials (core þ membrane) are generally assumed to be isotropic and described by two Lame constants li ¼ E i ni =ðð12ni Þð1 þ ni ÞÞ and mi ¼ E i =ð2ð1 þ ni ÞÞ, with i ¼ surf for the membrane and i ¼ bulk for the bulk material. The stress tensor (of components tij ) characterizing the surface is defined by constitutive equations that ensure that the tractions transmitted by the membrane to the volume are equal and opposite to the force distribution in the bulk at which is added a displacement gradient which can be neglected when Lagrange and infinitesimal strains can be confused: [23–25] ( P surf 0 surf t þ t0 Þ k e t0 Þeab þ t0 ð@u a =@xb Þ ab ¼ t dab þ ðl kk dab þ ðm 0 t a3 ¼ t ð@u3 =@xa Þ
ð2:41Þ
where refer to the up and down surfaces that, because of the deformation, cannot be in the same state of stress (Figure 2.9). In our context, the Lame coefficients of the up and down surfaces are identical. The quantity t0, called residual surface stress, under unconstrained conditions [23–25] may originate from thermal or mechanical treatment and thus is unrelated to s or c. The previous definition (Eq. (2.41)) of t can be formally compared to the expression of s given in Eq. (2.29), meaning the sum of a stress in absence of deformation and a linear function of strain. Beyond the formal equivalence, let us note that the physical meaning of the various components of Eqs (2.29) and (2.41) are not the same since 7) One can thus distinguish three-phase model for plate (a core plus two opposite surfaces) from twophase models valid for cylindrical or spherical objects (a core plus one surface). 8) Steigman and Ogden [22] took into account the flexural rigidity of the surface layers. In this case, there will be additional equilibrium equations, meaning that bending couples must vanish on the edge of the surface.
j43
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
44
Figure 2.9 Sketch of the bulk stress variation (black arrows in the bulk) inside a curved sheet at which adds the surface stress (red arrows at the surface). Inset: Expression of the variation s xx ðzÞ versus the second derivative of the profile.
surface stress tensor ½s is a true excess tensor (in the Gibbs meaning), but not ½t except for some peculiar choice of the dividing surface.
2.3 Applications: Size Effects Due to the Surfaces
We will describe in turn how surface stress (i) induces spontaneous deformation of nanoparticles (Section 2.3.1), (ii) modifies the effective modulus of freestanding thin films (Section 2.3.2), and (iii) plays a role on the static bending of thin film (Section 2.3.3). At the same, we will consider the static bending of nanowires (Section 2.3.4). Generally, we will use approaches expressed in terms of surface stress, but in some cases (according the state of the art) we will also use two-phase models. 2.3.1 Lattice Contraction of Nanoparticles
Following Ref. [26], let us take a free cubic crystal A with a rectangular shape of basis ‘x ‘y and height ‘z . We will note sA and s0A , respectively, the surface stresses of the basal and lateral faces of the crystal. Let us now consider a virtual homogeneous deformation described by the bulk tensor eij. The elastic energy due to this deformation is W ¼ W bulk þ W surf
ð2:42Þ
where, according to (2.6) and (2.20), W bulk ¼
E‘1 ‘2 ‘3 ð1nÞðe211 þe222 þe233 Þþ2nðe11 e22 þe11 e33 þe22 e33 Þ 2ðð1þnÞð12nÞÞ ð2:43Þ
and W surf ¼ 2s‘1 ‘2 ðe11 þe22 Þþ2s0A ‘3 ½‘1 ðe11 þe22 Þþ‘2 ðe22 þe33 Þ
ð2:44Þ
2.3 Applications: Size Effects Due to the Surfaces
The equilibrium strains are obtained by minimizing Eq. (2.42) with respect to strain. At equilibrium and for a square-shaped crystal ‘1 ¼ ‘2 ‘, ‘3 ¼ h, we get 1n 2sA 2s0A 13n 1n 4s0A 2sA 2n eq eq eq þ e11 ¼ e22 ¼ ; e33 ¼ h ‘ 1n ‘ h 1n E E ð2:45Þ For a free cubic crystal, h ¼ ‘ and sA ¼ s0A , there is simply [26] eeq ¼ 4
12n sA E ‘
ð2:46Þ
A generalization of Eq. (2.46) valid for various shapes has been given in Ref. [27]. Injecting the equilibrium strain (2.46) into the total elastic energy (2.42) gives a negative value that for a freestanding cubic crystal reads W ¼ 6sA ‘2 eeq . The negative sign means that due to its own surface stress, a small crystal is spontaneously deformed. Thus, it has a different crystallographic parameter compared to a large crystal (the deformation scales as ‘1 ). If the surface stress is positive (respectively, negative), then the crystallographic parameter is smaller (respectively, greater) than the crystallographic parameter of the mother phase. The measurement of such size-induced lattice contraction has been used to determine a mean value of the isotropic surface stress of cubic crystal [28–30]. More recent works [31] consider crystalline spheres (diameter D) cut in cubic crystals of compressibility K. In this case, (2.46) becomes e ¼ 4KsA =3D. In the absence of reliable values for surface stresses, the authors use asymptotic behaviors of surface energy combined with the Shuttleworth relation (2.35). In this way, the asymptotic form sA ¼ ½ð3c0 aÞ=8K1=2 (where a is an atomic unit and c0 the usual surface energy of the material) is more or less justified. The so-calculated deformations e ¼ ð4K=3DÞ½ð3c0 aÞ=8K1=2 can be compared to experimental ones measured for various materials. The results are shown in Figure 2.10. Experiments and calculation clearly show the size effect. The deformations are negative, so the intrinsic surface
Figure 2.10 Lattice contraction (in %) of nanoparticles. Adapted from Ref. [31].
j45
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
46
stress of these metals is positive and leads to a crystal contraction with respect to the mother phase. Notice that at the nanometer scale, deformations of a small percentage can be reached. Obviously, for such values, linear elasticity may become questionable. Let us stress again that two main assumptions have been used, isotropic surface stress and homogeneous deformation of the nanocrystal, so that only mean values of surface stress can be obtained by such methods. 2.3.2 Effective Modulus of Thin Freestanding Plane Films
Consider a nonsupported film (‘2 ¼ ‘2 ! 1, ‘3 ¼ h0 ) submitted to its own surface stress. The film is assumed not to bend. For the sake of simplicity, we will consider cubic crystals so that, at equilibrium, from (2.45) eq
eq
e11 ¼ e22 ¼ e ¼
2sA h0 Y
and
e33 ¼
2nsA n ¼ e Eh0 1n
ð2:47Þ
where Y0 ¼ E=ð1nÞ is the usual elastic modulus defined as Y0 ¼ ð1=2Þðd2 =de2 Þ ðW Bulk =V0 Þ in absence of any surface stress (W Bulk ¼ Y0 V0 e2 is the bulk elastic energy). In other words, (2.47) implies that because of its own surface stress, the film is, at equilibrium, deformed with respect to its bulk counterpart, so that the thickness of the film is no more h0 but h0 ð1 þ e33 Þ and the initial surface area A0 becomes A0 ð1 þ eÞ2 . The total elastic energy per unit of nondeformed area (see Eq. (2.22)) of the system now becomes W Y0 h0 e2 þ 4sA e A0
ð2:48Þ
where the quadratic term due to bulk elasticity and the linear term due to surface stress again appear. The factor of 4 rises for the two in-plane directions and the two surfaces. It is now possible to define an effective elastic modulus in presence of surface stress as Yeff ¼ ð1=2Þðd2 =de2 ÞðW=VÞ, where now V ¼ h0 A0 ð1 þ eÞ2 ð1 þ ezz Þ is the volume after spontaneous deformation and W is given by (2.48). It is found that at mechanical equilibrium and up to the first order in 1=h0 , Yeff Y0 þ
2sA ð2gÞ h0
ð2:49Þ
where g ¼ n=ð1nÞ scales as 1/2 for usual values of n. Equation (2.49) states that, due to surface stress, one can define an effective elastic modulus, the value of which varies as the reciprocal of the film thickness. Freestanding thin films with positive (respectively, negative) surface stress have a larger (respectively, lower) effective modulus than the material from which they have been cut. This simple model has been extended and checked by Streitz et al. [32], who take into account higher order elastic effects by means of Y0 ðeÞ ¼ Y0 ð1BeÞ and
2.3 Applications: Size Effects Due to the Surfaces Table 2.3 Values determined from simulations of the (001) surfaces of various metals [32].
Y0 (eV/A3)
B
2g
sA (eV/A2)
s1 (eV/A2)
s1 2sA B þ ð4g3Þ þ sA
0.968 1.542 0.623 0.628
13.10 14.70 13.73 14.61
1.25 1.08 1.36 1.58
0.056 0.047 0.050 0.077
0.14 0.07 0.19 0.38
1.13 1.44 0.97 1.51
Cu Ni Ag Au
sA ðeÞ ¼ sA þ s1 e, so the total elastic energy now becomes W 2 3 B 4sA e þ ðY0 h0 þ 2sA þ 2s1 Þe2 þ Y0 h0 3 g þ 2s1 e3 A0 3 2 2
ð2:50Þ
Equation (2.49) then up to the first order in 1=h0 becomes Yeff Y0 þ
2sA s1 B þ ð4g3Þ þ h0 sA
ð2:51Þ
While in the linear approximation the elastic nature of the freestanding film (softer or stiffer than that of its bulk counterpart) depends only on the sign of the surface stress of the body (see Eq. (2.49)), it is no longer the case when nonlinear effects are taken into account (see Eq. (2.51)). More generally (for more complex shapes), it can be shown that the effective Young modulus depends on the third-order bulk and elastic constants [27]. Streitz et al. [32] used (2.51)9) to calculate the equilibrium strain and the effective modulus for various metals for which they calculate surface stress sA , the usual Young modulus Y0 , and the higher order elastic constants B and s1 . The results of their calculations are shown in Table 2.3. It appears that B is positive, scales as s1 =sA , and is greater than unity. It follows that the leading term in Eq. (2.51) is not the surface stress by its own, but it is the coupling between the higher order constants (s1 and B) and the surface stress sA by means of DY 2sA B=h0 . The strain (calculated from the formula given in footnote 9) and the effective modulus (calculated from Eq. (2.51)) with the data given in Table 2.3 are shown in Figure 2.11, in which the same quantities calculated by molecular dynamics simulations are also shown [32]. There is an excellent agreement but notice that the sizes at which the surface effect cannot be negligible are at the nanoscale. As a conclusion, the elastic modulus of a freestanding thin film is actually determined by nonlinear elastic properties of its bulk and surface (for a complete discussion, see Ref. [33]). 9) Note that the equilibrium strain is not given by Eq. (2.47), but by eeq 2sA =ð4h0 þ 2s1 þ h0 Y0 Þ. Moreover, note that (2.49) cannot be recovered by simply putting B ¼ 0 and s1 ¼ 0 in (2.51) because both expressions are not at the same order in strain.
j47
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
48
Figure 2.11 (a) Strain versus thickness calculated for various metals. Adapted from Ref. [32]. (b) Corresponding effective modulus. Adapted from Ref. [32].
2.3.3 Bending, Buckling, and Free Vibrations of Thin Films 2.3.3.1 General Equations We will now consider bending, buckling, and free vibrations of thin films when incorporating surface elasticity effects. The main formulation consists of adding surface forces and bending moments due to surface stress to the equations of the classical description of a plate. Indeed, let us consider a thin asymmetric, isotropic sheet of thickness e. The faces 1 and 2, respectively, bear surface stress s1ab and s2ab . These surface stresses generate two moments, a first moment (a force) and a second moment (a torque). Ð e=2 surf ¼ e=2 ½s1ab dðx3 þ e=2Þ þ s2ab dðx3 e=2Þdx3 , so using the The first moment is Nab sifting properties of the Dirac function dðxÞ, we get surf þ Nab ¼ s1ab þ s2ab ¼ Dsab
ð2:52Þ
þ This moment, which depends on the total surface stress Dsab , is equivalent to a resultant force per unit length applied on the medium plane. This results in the strength of the medium plane. Ð e=2 surf ¼ e=2 ½s1ab dðx3 þ e=2Þ þ s2ab dðx3 e=2Þx3 dx3 can also The second moment Mab be calculated: surf Mab ¼ ðs1ab s2ab Þe=2 ¼ Ds ab e=2
ð2:53Þ
which depends on the differential surface stress Ds ab . This moment is a torque that bends the sheet (Figure 2.12). Let us recall that because of the bending, the stresses are not constant in the bulk but vary with the altitude (see Figure 2.9). The total moments in the presence of bulk stress and surface stresses are the sum of the bulk and surface moments and can be written as
2.3 Applications: Size Effects Due to the Surfaces
Figure 2.12 Sketch of the decomposition of the differential of surface strain in the first moment applied in the medium plane and a second moment that is a couple that tends to bend the sheet.
e=2 ð surf Nijtot ¼ Nij þNab
e=2 ð
þ sij dx3 þDsab ;
¼
surf Mijtot ¼ Mij þMab
e=2
¼
s ij x3 dx3 þDs ab e=2
e=2
ð2:54Þ
The equations of motion for the body (see Eq. (2.3)) of the plate are @sij d2 ui þ fi ¼ r 2 @xj dt
ð2:55Þ
Equation (2.55) accounts for the body forces (e.g., gravity, see footnote 2) of components fi . Again, r is the density and ui the components of the displacement field. Equation (2.55) can be multiplied by dx3 or x3 dx3 and then integrated to get the equations of motion governing the resultant moments [34, 35]. @Nia up þ si3 s down þ i3 @xa
e=2 ð
e=2 ð
fi dx3 ¼ e=2
@Mib e up þ Ni3 þ si3 þ s down i3 @xb 2
r e=2
d2 ui dx3 dt2 e=2 ð
e=2 ð
fi x3 dx3 ¼ e=2
ð2:56Þ
r e=2
d2 u i x3 dx3 dt2
ð2:57Þ
up si3
where and s down are the stress at the up and down surfaces, respectively. i3 The mechanical equation valid for the upper and lower surfaces (respectively, labeled ( þ ) and ()) reads @s bi @xb
s u i3 ¼ r€ i
€ . Obviously, at equilibrium this latter equation is where we write d2 u=dt2 ¼ u Eq. (2.32). The previous mechanical equation can be inserted into Eqs (2.56) and (2.57) to obtain @ ðNia þ Dsbiþ Þ þ @xa
e=2 ð
e=2 ð
€ 2i Þ r:€ u i dx3 þ rð€ u 1i þ u
fi dx3 ¼ e=2
e=2
ð2:58Þ
j49
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
50
@ e Mab þ Ds ai Na3 þ @xb 2
e=2 ð
e=2 ð
fi x3 dx3 ¼ e=2
r:€ u a x3 dx3 þ e=2
e 1 € a € u 2a r u 2 ð2:59Þ
At equilibrium (no time dependence) and in absence of body forces, these equations become @ ðNia þ Dsbiþ Þ ¼ 0 @xa
ð2:60Þ
@ e Mab þ Ds ai ¼ Na3 @xb 2
ð2:61Þ
These equilibrium equations have to be solved with well-defined boundary conditions. 2.3.3.2 Discussion Most of the surface stress-induced modifications of the usual behavior of thin plates [34–41] have been studied with a surface modeled as a foreign membrane [23–25]. However, owing to the analogy between Eqs (2.29) and (2.39), the results are comparable to those obtained with the true surface stress in the Gibbs meaning. Usually two assumptions can be found in the literature. The first, the thin film assumption, is that s33 is zero inside the whole film.10) The second assumption is a þ þ s linear variation of s 33 in the film as, for instance, s33 ¼ ð1=2Þðs 33 33 Þ þ þ1 ð1=hÞðs33 s33 Þx3 . Here, we will illustrate only surface effects in the framework of the thin film approximation and Kirchhoff theory11) [34–38]. For this purpose, consider an isotropic material (bulk and surfaces) in which an infinitely long (in the x2 direction) sheet of finite width ‘ in direction x1 and thickness e is cut. The (dimensionless) results of Ref. [38] are shown in Figure 2.13 for the maximum deflection, the load at which the sheet buckles, and the frequency of vibration. The materials constants are E ¼ 5:625 1010 N=m2 , n ¼ 0:25, r ¼ 3 103 kg=m3 , l0 ¼ 7 103 N=m, m0 ¼ 8 103 N=m (the Lame coefficients of surfaces), and the residual surface stress t0 ¼ 110 N=m (more details can be found in Ref. [35]). It is easy to see in Figure 2.13 that the static as well as the dynamic response of a sheet depends on its surface properties. Obviously, the thinner the sheet, the proportionally greater the surface effects. Notice that the surface may help or oppose the external stress according to the sign of the stress ½t (given by Eq. (2.41)) at the surface. For the thinner sheets, surface stress effects can become so important that nonlinear 10) At mechanical equilibrium, s33 must vanish at the free surfaces. 11) In the classical thin plate description, two theories can be encountered: the Kirchhoff plate theory and the Mindlin plate theory that differs only by the assumptions on the asymptotic form of the displacement fields.
2.3 Applications: Size Effects Due to the Surfaces
Figure 2.13 Surface effect on bending, buckling, and free vibration of a sheet with edges at x1 ¼ 0 and x1 ¼ ‘ and t0 ¼ 110 N=m and h0 ¼ 106 m. Adapted from Ref. [35]. (a) P ¼ 100ð1n2 ÞP0 E versus H for a simply supported sheet. P ¼ P0 sinðpx1 =‘Þ is the transverse load and H the reduced sag (w=h0 ). (b) N ¼ 12ð1n2 ÞT=Eh versus log h0 (h0 in meter) for a simply supported sheet at both
edges submitted to a pair of compressive forces of amplitude T. A strong negative surface stress may the sheet buckled without any external stress. (c) Reduced frequency of vibration versus the reduced sag (w=h0 ) for a simply supported sheet submitted to vertical displacement, u3 ¼ U sinðpx1 =‘Þ. Notice that t ¼ 0 means no surface effects (t0 ; l0 ; m0 ¼ 0).
elasticity effects may play a role. However, the result is that the size-dependent behavior originates from the strain dependence of the surface stress, that is, from the surface elastic constants. In other words, the usual results of the thin plate are recovered for zero or constant surface stress. It is only when surface elastic constants are introduced that there can be a stiffening or a softening of the material, as more recently confirmed by the analytical calculations of Refs [42, 43]. Again, the surface effect is significant for film thinner than 10 nm. A simple proof of this conclusion is given in Ref. [44]. The energy of vibration (per unit length) of a rectangular beam (length L, height 2h, width ‘) prestressed by its surface stress can be written as the sum of its bulk and surface energies [1, 44] (s is the surface stress assumed to be isotropic): ðL ðL
1 002 02 W¼ EIy Fy d x þ ‘sy02 d x 2 0
ð2:62Þ
0
where E is the bulk Young modulus, I the moment of inertia, F a bulk compressive force that prestress the sample and, at equilibrium, balance the forces exerted by the surfaces, and yðx; tÞ the vertical deflexion (the primes denote the derivatives with respect to x). Since the equilibrium requires F ¼ 2s‘, the total energy (2.62) is independent of surface stress. When taking into account surface elasticity by means of s ¼ s0 þ Ssurf e, where Ssurf is surface elastic constant and e hy00 the strain at the surfaces, a term Ð L a surf e2 dx adds to (2.62), so 0 ‘S ðL
1 EI þ 2Ssurf ‘h2 y002 d x W¼ 2 0
ð2:63Þ
j51
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
52
We can define an effective modulus Eeff ¼ E þ
2Ssurf ‘h2 I
ð2:64Þ
which depends on the shape (via I) and the surface elasticity (via Ssurf ). The frequency of vibration of the cantilever v2 ¼ v20 ð1 þ ð2Ssurf ‘h2 =EIÞÞ [44] does not depend on s, but only on the strain dependence of the surface stress, that is, on surface elasticity.12) Notice that more recently finite element method calculations have confirmed this result [45]. 2.3.4 Static Bending of Nanowires: An Analysis of the Recent Literature
Static and dynamic bending tests have been widely reported for nanowires [46–49]. The experiments are complex. In particular, it is generally hard to control the boundary conditions, so there is a wide scattering in the experimental data (see Section 2.3.5). However, most of the experiments show that the elastic behavior of a nanowire is different from the elastic behavior of its bulk counterpart (or mother phase), affecting the size-dependent modulus that can be softer or harder than the modulus of the bulk material. Again, this size effect essentially comes from the surface/bulk ratio. Notice that for rectangular wires, the presence of two pairs of free surfaces gives additional effects due to edges and corners. In the following section, we will study only the simpler case of cylindrical wires. 2.3.4.1 Young Modulus versus Size: Two-Phase Model For nanowires, most previous works use a two-phase model in which the wire is divided in a cylindrical core of radius r0 surrounded by a shell of thickness e, so that the diameter of the whole wire is D ¼ 2ðr0 þ eÞ. The core and the shell are, respectively, characterized by their elastic modulus E0 and Es . The flexural rigidity of the nanowire is written as EI ¼ E0 I0 þ Es Is , where I0 and Is are the moment of inertia of cross section of the core and the sheet. Using the expression of the inertia momentum, the effective modulus of the wire is [48] Es E ¼ E0 1 þ 8 1 ðg3g2 þ 4g3 2g4 Þ E0
where g ¼ e=D. A fit of the experimental data gives the surface thickness e and the ratio Es =E0 . However, this phenomenological ratio cannot be simply interpreted in terms of elastic constants.
12) Some authors omit F and thus find that Eeff depends on s, which is clearly wrong [44].
2.3 Applications: Size Effects Due to the Surfaces
He and Lilley [40] have extended this approach to different boundary conditions and different geometries (rectangular or circular cross section). However, their approach is slightly different since they introduce an additional distributed transverse force due the stress jump across the surface Ds ij ni nj ¼ sab Kab (ni are the components of the unit vector normal to the surface and Kab the curvature tensor so that sab Kab simply is the Laplace overstress) written as s0 y00 ðxÞ for an isotropic surface stress (yðxÞ is the transverse displacement). The equilibrium equation EIy00 00 ðxÞ ¼ 2Ds0 y00 ðxÞ is thus solved for different boundary conditions: a cantilever (submitted to a concentrated load force at its end), a simply supported wire, and a clamped wire (submitted to a concentrated load force applied to the middle of the wire). The main result is that a positive surface stress s0 opposes concave curvature of the mean plane of the wire and enhances convex curvatures. For positive surface stress, the cantilever behaves as a softer material, while a simply supported or clamped sheet behaves as a stiffer material (compared to its bulk counterpart). This result could illustrate why quantifying the mechanical properties at the nanoscale is so challenging. Indeed, the effective modulus appears to depend on the boundary conditions! However, as shown in Section 2.3.3.2 and Ref. [44], this analysis neglects the prestress effect the surface stress (considered as a membrane) induces, so the true equilibrium equation should be EIy00 00 ðxÞ ¼ Fy00 ðxÞ þ 2Ds0 y00 ðxÞ, where at equilibrium the compressive axial force due to surface stress is F ¼ 2D‘s0 . This prestress effect thus should modify the surface stress effect in the absence of surface elasticity (see Section 2.3.4.3). 2.3.4.2 Young Modulus versus Size: Surface Stress Model Cuenot et al. [46] have reported effective modulus measured for ZnO nanowires: the smaller the diameter of a nanowire, the greater its effective modulus. To interpret these experimental results, the total bending energy due to a force F applied on the wire inducing a deflection d is [46] U ¼ Fd þ ð1=2Þkd2 þ spDDLð1nÞ, where the first term is the work of the applied force F, the second term the bulk elastic energy depending on the stiffness modulus k of the bulk material of the wire, the last term the work against surface deformation, where s is the surface stress (assumed to be isotropic), and DL ¼ ð12=5Þðd2 =LÞthe extension of the wire. For clamped wires, the total energy becomes U ¼ Fd þ ð1=2Þkeff d2 , where keff ¼ kþð24=5ÞsðpD=LÞð1nÞ. For the geometry of the wire, E ¼ ðL3 =192IÞk, where I ¼ pD4 =64 is the moment of inertia of the section, so Cuenot et al. [46] define an effective modulus Eeff ¼ E þð8=5Þsð1nÞðL2 =D3 Þ. Again, even if experimental data are well fitted by the model, the model neglects the prestress bulk induced by the surface stress (see footnote 12). 2.3.4.3 Prestress Bulk Due to Surface Stresses We have seen that most of the recent works neglect the bulk stress initially induced by the surface stresses. The effect of this prestress has been properly taken into consideration by Wang et al. [50] in the case of pure bending of nanowires. For this purpose, they consider an isotropic nanowire of thickness h, width b, and length ‘ and isotropic surface stress s. The authors (i) calculate the bulk stress (supposed to be
j53
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
54
homogeneous) due to the surface stress (as in Section 2.3.1), (ii) calculate the strain field in the bulk and at the surface, the (iii) the strain-dependent surface stress, and (iv) the bulk and surface elastic energies. Let us underline that the authors allow the nanowire to relax axially at its ends. They can thus define an effective Youngs modulus that can be expressed as 2 2 ! 6 2 s ‘ 2 b ð2:65Þ Eeff ¼ E þ Esurf þ 2n þ2 h b h h h where Esurf , a surface Youngs modulus, is a combination of the surface elastic constants. This equation can be formally compared to Eqs (2.49) and (2.51) obtained for thin freestanding planar films (that are not allowed to bend) or to Eq. (2.64) obtained from vibration properties. The main conclusion is that Youngs modulus can be considerably affected by the surface properties. It is modified not only by the absolute size of the nanowire but also by its aspect ratio. More precisely, for positive elastic constants and positive surface stress, the effective Youngs modulus decreases with the decrease in the nanowire thickness or the increase in its aspect ratio. Let us underline that this result has been obtained for free boundary conditions. It could be different for clamped conditions (see the discussion in Section 2.3.5). Again, Eq. (2.65) predicts that stress effects play a role only at the nanoscale (roughly for thickness smaller that 20 nm) [50]. 2.3.5 A Short Overview of Experimental Difficulties
We cannot end this short review of surface effects on elastic properties of nanoscale objects without any analysis of the experimental uncertainties that concern the sample preparation, the sample characterization, the mechanical system used to excite the nano-object, and even the simple definition of the object geometry. We list below some of the experimental difficulties. Most of the methods used to fabricate micro- or nanoscale objects employed techniques that potentially affect the mechanical behavior by ions implantation, surface amorphization, surface roughness, or even dislocation implantation [51]. The mechanical probe is generally larger than the size of the object [47–60], so the mechanical properties of the whole system (probe þ object) should be checked. Furthermore, the boundary conditions (clamping, simply supported, free boundary) are difficult to define accurately and to reproduce from one experiment to another. It is all the more important that, as numerically shown by Park and Klein [61], effective Youngs modulus depends on the boundary conditions. For instance, they [61] found (for gold) that increasing the nanowire aspect ratio leads to an increase (respectively, decrease) in Eeff for clamped (respectively, free ended) nanowire. This can be easily understood since the clamped condition prevents the axial relaxation due to surface stress. The experimental difficulties due to the boundary conditions can be
2.4 Conclusion
partially overpassed by using acoustic methods that simply excite the vibrational modes [62, 63] without contact. It is sometimes difficult to accurately characterize the geometry of a nano-object (for instance, the diameter of a nanowire is not necessarily constant on its whole length). An error of 5% on the nanowire scales leads to an uncertainty of 25% on the effective Young modulus. Since plastic properties are also size dependent [52, 53], the knowledge of the dislocation density may be crucial. Indeed, the mechanical properties cannot be the same if the object already contains a dislocation that can move under the external force or if it is necessary to create the dislocation before activating it. All these limitations may be at the origin of the large dispersion of the available experimental results and even at the origin of several systematic errors. For instance, most of the theoretical calculations predict size effects at the nanometer scale, while a few experiments show size effects that already occur at some hundred of nanometers! May be some of these experimental results have not been obtained with a well-defined system. For instance, the Young modulus of a vibrating cantilever has been found to decrease [56], increase [64], or to be constant [60] according to the cantilever diameter,13) while Raman scattering of nanoparticles does not put in evidence any size dependence of the Young modulus [62, 63]. The analysis of the mechanical properties of cantilevers with varying width seems to be a necessary challenge [65].
2.4 Conclusion
A great deal of research has been done on the elastic properties of nanoscale materials. Like many other properties, the mechanical properties of small objects deviate from those of macroscopic objects of the same material. The overall elastic behavior of nanosized objects is size dependent. This size dependence originates from proportionally greater surface effects. Indeed, the surface has bond length and strength different from the volume, so a nanoscale object must, at least, be divided into a bulk core and a surface zone with different properties. The surface zone can be described in various ways. The best one consists of using the concepts of dividing surface and surface excess. The main advantage is that the so-defined quantities are perfectly defined from a thermodynamic viewpoint. Other choices are possible, but in all the cases the localization of the dividing surface should be specified before any calculation. In some cases, it is easier to split the dividing surface into two surfaces separated by a distance that defines the surface thickness. When specific elastic properties are attributed to surfaces, the elastic behavior of a finite-size body results from a subtle interplay between its bulk and surface properties and thus depends on the absolute size of the object. Such size dependence becomes significant when at least one dimension becomes smaller than, let us say, a few tens of nanometers.
13) But obviously the effect depends on the sign and the value of the surface stress of the material.
j55
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
56
Most of the mechanical characteristics of nanoscale objects can be inferred from models coming from surface physics in which the surface is characterized by an excess of stress in the Gibbs meaning. More precisely, it is possible to show with these models that because of surface stress, the crystallographic parameter, the Young modulus, the flexure rigidity, and so on of nanoscale structures differ from those of bulk (infinite) materials. However, surface stress alone is not enough to explain all the experimental occurrences. In particular, surface elastic constants have to be introduced since the stiffening effect is essentially due to the strain dependence of the surface stress. Moreover, at the nanoscale surface stress may induce huge bulk strain, so the whole mechanical behavior can no more be described by linear elasticity theory. In some cases, the surface stress effect, by its own, is less important than the nonlinear behavior it induces in the bulk [66]! Finally, notice that since surface effects are dominant at the nanoscale, the elastic properties also depend on the shape of the objects. It is clearly put in evidence in Ref. [27] in the case of Cu. For nanowires, the Young modulus increases as the wire becomes thinner, while for a freestanding film, it decreases. Again, let us underline that mechanical tests at the nanoscale are still a challenge. In particular, since most of the tools used for the stress measurements are at the macroscale, it is generally hard to control the boundary conditions. At the same, it is difficult to simply control the initial state (surface roughness, defects density, and even geometrical data as initial curvature or size) with a good accuracy. It results in a wide scattering in the experimental data, so efforts have to be made to access better data even if some statistical attempts to go round these intrinsic limitations have been explored [67]. From a theoretical viewpoint, let us notice again that the models coming from surface physics cannot be applied to the smallest sizes at which it is no more possible to divide the piece of matter into a core and a surface zone. In this case, it is necessary to resort to atomistic approaches expressed in terms of spring models, pseudopotentials, or ab initio calculations [66, 68] or may be to use nonlocal elasticity [69]. Moreover, let us notice that strained nanowires may be morphologically unstable. Such instabilities are beyond our scope of this book, but the reader can refer to Refs [70–72].
Acknowledgment
I wish to acknowledge Ezra Bussmann, Raymond Kern, and Andres Saul for fruitful discussions.
References 1 Landau, L. and Lifshitz, E. (1970)
Theory of Elasticity, Pergamon Press, Oxford.
2 Timoshenko, S. and Goodier, J. (1951)
Theory of Elasticity, McGraw Hill, New York.
References 3 Gibbs, J.W. (1928) The Collected Works of
4
5
6 7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
J.W. Gibbs, Longmans, Green and Company, New York, p. 1928. Nozieres, P. and Wolf, D.E. (1988) Interfacial properties of elastically strained materials. Z. Phys. B, 70, 507–512. M€ uller, P. and Saùl, A. (2004) Elastic effects on surface physics. Surf. Sci. Rep., 54, 157–258. Saùl, A. and M€ uller, P. (2011) in preparation. Shenoy, V. (2005) Atomistic calculations of elastic properties of metallic fcc crystal surfaces. Phys. Rev. B, 71, 094104. Weissm€ uller, J. and Cahn, W. (1997) Mean stresses in microstructures due to interface stresses: a generalization of a capillary equation for solids. Acta Mater., 45, 1899–1906. Bottomley, D.J. (2009) Incompatibility of the Shuttleworth equation with Hermanns mathematical structure of thermodynamics. Surf. Sci., 603, 97–101. Ibach, H. (2009) Comments on the article entitled Incompatibility of the Shuttleworth equation with Hermanns mathematical structure of thermodynamics. Surf. Sci, 603, 2352. Marichev, V. (2008) Comment on Incompatibility of the Shuttleworth equation with Hermanns mathematical structure of thermodynamics. Surf. Sci, 602, 1131. Erickson, J. and Rusanov, A. (2009) Comments on Incompatibility of the Shuttleworth equation with Hermanns mathematical structure of thermodynamics. Surf. Sci., 603, 2348. Hecquet, P. (2010) Comments on the article entitled Incompatibility of the Shuttleworth equation with Hermanns mathematical structure of thermodynamics. Surf. Sci, 613, 1234–1248. Ibach, H. (1997) The role of surface stress in reconstruction, epitaxial growth and stabilization of mesoscopic structures. Surf. Sci. Rep., 29, 195–263. Yang, Z., Wang, Z., and Zhao, Y. (2008) Surface stress induced by adatoms on solid surfaces. Int. J. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul., 9, 323–329.
16 Stoney, G. (1909) The tension of metal
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
films deposited by electrolysis. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 82, 172. Freund, L., Floro, J., and Chason, E. (1999) Extension of the Stoney formula for substrate curvature to configurations with thin substrates and large deformations. Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 1987–1991. Sander, D., Schmidtthals, C., Enders, A., and Kirschner, J. (1998) Stress and structure of Ni monolayers on W(110): the importance of lattice mismatch. Phys. Rev. B, 57, 1406. Bar, B., Altus, E., and Tadmor, E. (2010) Surface effects in non-uniform nanobeams: continuum vs. atomistic modelling. Int. J. Solids Struct., 47, 1243–1252. Sanfeld, A. (1987) Sur quelques difficultes conceptuelles relatives a la tension de surface des solides. J. Chimie. Phys., 84, 12–15. Cahn, J. and Larche, F. (1982) Surface stress and the chemical equilibrium of a small crystal. II. Solid particles embedded in a solid matrix. Acta Metall, 30, 51–56. Steigman, D. and Ogden, R. (1999) Elastic surface–substrate interactions. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 455, 437–474. Gurtin, M. and Murdoch, A. (1975) A continuum theory of elastic material surfaces. Arch Ration. Mech. Anal., 57, 291–323. Gurtin, M. and Murdoch, A. (1975) Addenda to our paper: a continuum theory of elastic material surfaces. Arch Ration. Mech. Anal., 59, 389–390. Gurtin, M. and Murdoch, A. (1978) Surface stress in solids. Int. J. Solids Struct., 14, 431–440. Kern, R. and M€ uller, P. (1997) Elastic relaxation of coherent epitaxial deposits. Surf. Sci., 392, 103–133. Dingreville, R., Qu, J., and Cherkaoui, M. (2005) Surface free energy and its effect on the elastic behavior of nano-sized particles, wires and films. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 53, 1927–1854. de Planta, T., Ghez, R., and Piaz, F. (1964) On surface stress of small particles. Helv. Phys. Acta, 47, 74–81.
j57
j 2 Fundamentals of Stress and Strain at the Nanoscale Level: Toward Nanoelasticity
58
29 Vermaak, J.S., Mays, C.W., and Kuhlman-
43 Lu, C., Lim, C., and Chen, W. (2009) Size-
Wilsdorf, D. (1968) On surface stress and surface tension. Surf. Sci., 12, 128–135. Solliard, C. and Flueli, M. (1985) Surface stress and size effect on the lattice parameter in small particles of gold and platinum. Surf. Sci., 156, 487–494. Jiang, Q., Liang, L., and Zhao, D. (2001) Lattice contraction and surface stress of fcc nanocrystals. J. Phys. Chem. B, 105, 6276–6281. Streitz, F., Cammarata, R., and Sieradzki, R. (1994) Surface stress effects on elastic properties. I. Thin metal films. Phys. Rev. B, 49, 10699–10705. Zhang, T., Wan, Z., and Chan, W. (2010) Eigenstress model for surface stress of solids. Phys. Rev. B, 81, 195427. He, L., Lim, C., and Wu, B. (2004) A continuum model for size-dependent deformation of elastic films of nano-scale thickness. Int. J. Solids Stuct., 41, 847–857. Lim, C. and He, L. (2004) Size-dependent nonlinear response of thin elastic films with nano-scale thickness. Int. J. Mech. Sci., 46, 1715–1726. Duan, H., Wang, J., Huang, Z., and Karihaloo, B. (2005) Size-dependent effective elastic constants of solids containing nano-inhomogeneities with interface stress. J. Mech.Phys. Solids, 53, 1574. Lu, P., He, L., Lee, H., and Lu, C. (2006) Thin plate theory including surface effects. Int. J. Solids Struct., 43, 4631–4647. Huang, D. (2008) Size-dependent response of ultra-thin films with surface effects. Int. J. Solids Struct., 45, 568–579. Dingreville, R. and Qu, J. (2008) Interfacial excess energy, excess stress and excess strain in elastic solids: planar interfaces. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 56, 1944–1954. He, J. and Lilley, C. (2008) Surface effect on the elastic behaviour of static bending nanowires. Nano Lett., 8, 1798–1802. Guo, J. and Zhao, Y. (2005) The sizedependent elastic properties of nanofilms with surface effects. J. Appl. Phys., 98, 074306. Zhao, X. and Rajapaske, R. (2009) Analytical solutions for a surface-loaded isotropic elastic layer. Int. J. Eng. Sci., 47, 1433–1444.
dependent elastic behaviour of FGM ultrathin films based on generalised refined theories. Int. J. Solids Struct., 46, 1176–1194. Gurtin, M., Markenscoff, X., and Thurston, R. (1976) Effect of surface stress on the natural frequency of thin crystals. Appl. Phys. Lett., 29, 529–532. Ricci, A. and Ricciardi, C. (2010) A new finite element approach for studying the effect of surface stress on microstructures. Sens. Actuators A Phys, 159, 141–148. Cuenot, S., Fretigny, C., DumoustierChampagne, S., and Nysten, B. (2004) Surface tension effect on the mechanical properties of nanomaterials measured by atomic force microscopy. Phys. Rev. B, 69, 165410. Kis, A., Kasas, S., Babic, B., Julij, A., Benoit, W., Briggs, G., Sch€onenberger, C., Catsicas, S., and Forr, L. (2002) Nanomechanics of microtubes. Phys. Rev. Lett., 89, 248101. Chen, C., Shi, Y., Zhang, Y., and Yan, Y. (2006) Size-dependence of Youngsmodulus in ZnO nanowires. Phys. Rev. Lett., 96, 075505. Liang, H., Upmanyu, M., and Huang, H. (2005) Size-dependent elasticity of nanowires: nonlinear effects. Phys. Rev. B, 71, 241403. Wang, Z., Zhao, Y., and Huang, Z. (2010) The effects of surface tension on the elastic properties of nanostructures. Int. J. Eng. Sci., 48, 140–150. Shim, S., Bei, H., Killer, M., Pharr, G., and George, E. (2009) Effects of focused ion beam milling on the compressive behaviour of directionally solidified micropillars and the nanoindentation response of an electropolished surface. Acta Mater., 57, 503. Kiener, D., Grosinger, W., Dehm, G., and Pippan, R. (2008) A further step towards an understanding of size-dependent crystal plasticity: in situ tension experiments of miniaturizes single-crystal copper samples. Acta Mater., 56, 580. Uchic, M., Dimiduck, D., Florando, J., and Nix, W. (2004) Sample dimensions influence strength and crystal plasticity. Science, 305, 985–988.
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
References 54 Ying, G., Duan, H., Sun, X., Zhang, Z.,
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
Xu, J., Li, Y., Wang, J., and Yu, D. (2006) Surface effects on elastic properties of silver nanowires: contact atomic-force microscopy. Phys. Rev. B, 73, 235409. Stan, G., Ciobanu, C., Parthangal, P., and Cook, R. (2007) Diameter-dependent radial and tangential elastic moduli of ZnO nanowires. Nano Lett., 7, 3691–3695. Nam, C., Jaroenapibal, P., Tham, D., Luzzi, D., Evoy, S., and Fisher, J. (2006) Diameter-dependent electrochemical properties of GaN nanowires. Nano Lett., 6, 153–157. Zhu, Y., Xu, F., Qin, Q., Fung, W., and Lu, W. (2009) Mechanical properties of vapour–liquid synthesized silicon nanowires. Nano Lett., 9, 3934–3938. Agrawai, R., Peng, B., Gdoutos, E., and Espinosa, H. (2008) Elasticity size effects in ZnO nanowires: a combined experimental–computational approach. Nano Lett., 8, 3668–3672. Gordon, M., Baron, T., Dhalluin, F., Gentille, P., and Ferret, P. (2009) Size effects in mechanical deformation and fracture of cantilevered silicon nanowires. Nano Lett., 9, 525–529. Heidelberg, A., Ngo, L., Wu, B., Phillips, M., Sharma, S., Kamins, T., Sader, J., and Boland, J. (2006) A generalized description of the elastic properties of nanowires. Nano Lett., 6, 1101–1105. Park, H. and Klein, P. (2008) Surface stress effects on the resonant properties of metal nanowires: the importance of finite deformation kinematics and the impact of residual surface stress. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 56, 3144–3166. Portales, H., Goubet, N., Saviot, L., Aditchev, S., Murray, D., Mermet, A., Duval, E., and Pileni, M. (2008) Probing atomic ordering and multiple twinning in metal nanocrystals through their vibrations. PNAS, 105, 14784.
63 Ikezawa, M., Okuno, T., and Masumoto, Y.
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
(2001) Complementary detection of confined acoustic phonons in quantum dots by coherent phonon measurement and Raman scattering. Phys. Rev. B, 64, 201315(R). Chen, Q., Shi, Y., Zhang, Y., Zhu, J., and Yan, Y. (2006) Size dependent of Young modulus in ZnO nanowires. Phys. Rev. Lett., 96, 175505. Li, X. and Peng, X. (2008) Theoretical analysis of surface stress for a microcantilever with varying widths. J. Phys. D Appl. Phys., 41, 065301. Sun, C. and Zhang, H. (2003) Sizedependent elastic moduli of platelike nanomaterials. J. Appl. Phys., 93, 1212–1215. Deng, X., Joseph, V., Mai, W., Wang, Z., and Wu, C. (2009) Statistical approach to quantifying the elastic deformation of nanomaterials. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 106, 11845–11850. Guo, J. and Zhao, Y. (2005) The sizedependent elastic properties of nanofilms with surface effects. J. Appl. Phys., 98, 074306. Lim, C. (2010) On the truth of nanoscale for nanobeams based on nonlocal elastic stress field theory: equilibrium, governing equation and static deflection. Appl. Math. Mech. Eng. Ed., 31, 37–54. Glas, F. (2006) Critical dimensions for the plastic relaxation of strained axial heterostructures in free-standing nanowires. Phys. Rev. B, 74, 121302. Schmidt, V., McIntyre, P., and G€osele, U. (2008) Morphological instability of misfitstrained core–shell nanowires. Phys. Rev. B, 77, 235302. Colin, J., Grilhe, J., and M€ uller, P. (2009) Nanostructures instabilities induced by anisotropic epitaxial stress. Phys. Rev. E, 80, 052601.
j59
j61
3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials1) Laurent Pizzagalli, Sandrine Brochard, and Julien Godet 1) This chapter is dedicated to Pierre Beauchamp, who has not only guided the authors into the complex and tortuous world of dislocations for the past 10 years but has also showed them a fair way to behave as a scientist.
3.1 Introduction
The past two decades have witnessed an amazing development in the fabrication of systems characterized by one or several dimensions in the nanoscale. These so-called nanostructures include, for instance, nanospheres, nanowires, and nanopillars. An intensive research is being done looking for potential applications in various domains such as mechanics, electronics, optoelectronics, photonics, phononics, and so on. The mechanical characterization of these nanomaterials constitutes an important part of this research, since it has been shown that size reduction is often accompanied by large variations in common properties such as strength, hardness, or ductility [1]. For instance, an interesting and intriguing phenomenon is the apparent increase of the ductility range for nanoscale systems compared to the bulk material. Many experiments suggest that nanomaterials could exhibit specific and unusual mechanical properties [2–5], which explains the current interest in the research community and the large number of dedicated studies. Several limits are commonly used to define the different regimes of the response of a material submitted to a mechanical stress. Among these, the elastic limit, also known as the yield strength, defines the point at which the deformation of the material becomes irreversible, that is, plasticity occurs. Figure 3.1 shows the variation of the yield strength as a function of size for different kinds of nanoscaled systems made of silicon. Obviously, the onset of plasticity is different here compared to bulk materials, with a dramatic increase of strength for smaller sizes. Several mechanisms have been proposed for explaining experimental observations [1].
Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale: Simulation, Material Systems and Characterization Techniques, First Edition. Edited by Margrit Hanb€ ucken, Pierre M€ uller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn. Ó 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. Published 2011 by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA.
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
62
Figure 3.1 Variation of the yield stress (left) and true fracture strain (right) as a function of the size for different nanomaterials. Courtesy of W.W. Gerberich et al. [11]
The determination of the yield strength is difficult in general, since it is associated with the onset of plasticity. Usually, the elastic limit and the yield strength correspond to the deviation from linearity in the measured stress–strain curve, although other choices can be made depending on the material. In bulk materials, it depends on the sensitivity of the measurement. In fact, the irreversible displacement of dislocations present in the material may occur even for very low deformation, in the apparent elastic regime. It is therefore difficult to define the onset of plasticity in bulk materials from macroscopic measurements. Its determination is also difficult in the case of nanomaterials, since specific apparatus and techniques are needed for measurements. Additional insights can be obtained from several theoretical approaches, which do not suffer from the same limitations. The issue of the onset of plasticity has been largely examined in the framework of elasticity theory [6–9]. Numerical simulations at the atomistic level also allow reproducing mechanical tests, although they are generally restricted to systems with dimensions closer to tens of nanometers rather than micrometers. In this chapter, we describe the elastic and atomistic modeling of the onset of plasticity in nanomaterials. Note that we focused on systems including surfaces and for which one or several dimensions are in the nanoscale. This definition not only includes nanopillars and nanowires (1D) and nanospheres (0D) but also supported thin films (2D). Conversely, we did not consider systems characterized by interfaces such as embedded defects (aggregates of point defects, dislocations). Another important issue is the mono- or polycrystalline nature of the nanomaterial. In fact, it has been shown that the plastic properties of nanopillars could strongly depend on their internal structure [10]. For the sake of simplicity, here we focus on monocrystalline materials.
3.3 Driving Forces for Dislocations
3.2 The Role of Dislocations
The plastic deformation in crystalline materials can be associated with different mechanisms, all involving an irreversible displacement of the matter. The latter can result from the motion of individual atoms (diffusion) or from the collective displacement of atoms in dislocation form. For polycrystalline materials, the plastic deformation can also be due to the rotation and motion of grains. Here, we will consider only the plastic deformation through dislocation nucleation and displacement prior to the failure of the material (fracture). Useful basic information and theory of dislocations in bulk materials can be found in well-known textbooks [8, 9]. In usual bulk materials, the onset of plastic deformation is characterized by the displacement of the dislocations originally present. Depending on the conditions, the later stages of the deformation correspond to the generation of new dislocations, typically through multiplication. Several kinds of mechanisms have been identified [8, 12], the most common one being the Frank–Read and Bardeen–Herring sources, the multiplication by double cross-slip, or the nucleation from surfaces and interfaces. However, it is not clear whether the first mechanisms could be dominant in nanomaterials. In fact, these systems are characterized by one or several dimensions in the nanoscale, which is likely to impede such sources. Furthermore, these mechanisms require the presence of initial defects, usually in very low concentration in nanomaterials. As a consequence, although original multiplication mechanisms specific to nanomaterials have been postulated [13], dislocation nucleation is expected to be the main process in these systems, an assumption supported by experimental observations [14–16] and the obvious fact that the surface/volume ratio is much higher in nanomaterials than in bulk materials. Even in the case where dislocations are present in the system, it has been proposed that these dislocations are first annihilated by escaping to free surfaces, followed by the nucleation of new dislocations [17]. In the following, we focus on the mechanism of dislocation formation from an infinite surface. We first describe the two main forces that will act on a dislocation and the specific case of a dislocation in the vicinity of a surface. The elastic and atomistic modeling of the dislocation nucleation process is then described. Finally, we discuss how these results can be extended to more complex geometries (nanowires) and propose some perspectives.
3.3 Driving Forces for Dislocations
The elastic field associated with dislocations is slowly decaying from the dislocation core according to an inverse power law. Consequently, a dislocation in a real material is expected to interact with many defects (other dislocations, grain boundaries, point defects, surfaces, etc.), all of them exerting a force on the dislocation. However, for our purpose, we first focus on a single isolated dislocation in an otherwise perfect
j63
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
64
bulk material. In this case, there are two factors that may change the dislocation configuration in the crystal. 3.3.1 Stress
When a dislocation of Burgers vector b with the dislocation line j is displaced in the field of a local stress s, there is a change of energy proportional to the product between the stress and the area swept by the dislocation displacement. Following the definition of a force acting on a dislocation given by Hirth and Lothe [8], it is therefore possible to define a force Fs acting on an infinitesimal dislocation segment of length l, with the following expression: Fs ¼ ðsbÞ j l
ð3:1Þ
which is well known as the Peach–Koehler formula (see Ref. [18] for instance for an explained derivation). This is the driving force for displacing dislocations due to the local stress, and in extenso in a material submitted to a mechanical action. 3.3.2 Thermal Activation
Temperature is the other important factor since it allows overcoming the energy barriers between two different dislocation configurations. Several kinds of thermally activated mechanisms, such as dislocation displacement and unpinning or dislocation core transformations, have been observed or postulated [19]. A usual framework for studying thermally activated mechanisms in materials science is the transition state theory, in particular in its harmonic approximation [20]. Such an approach has been shown to be valid as long as energy barriers are not too small or, equivalently, temperatures are not too high, which is generally the case for dislocations. It is essential to emphasize that thermal activation does not favor any specific direction, conversely to the mechanical driving force. The displacement of a dislocation under the sole action of temperature is equivalent to a random walk. Also, thermal activation is essentially restricted to spatially localized mechanisms, that is, involving a limited number of atoms. In fact, the probability to perform a specific collective displacement of atoms by thermal motion is rapidly decreasing as a function of the number of atoms. 3.3.3 Combination of Stress and Thermal Activation
Temperature and stress, combined together, will help to overcome the energy barrier associated with a change in the dislocation configuration, leading to a displacement or to a core transformation. The relative importance of each factor depends on the investigated mechanisms. The energy barrier can be overcome, thanks to stress.
3.4 Dislocation and Surfaces: Basic Concepts
For instance, the critical stress required for displacing a dislocation without any thermal activation, that is, at 0 K, is called the Peierls stress. The latter is an important quantity that is usually determined by numerical simulations or by interpolating measurements at finite temperature. Conversely, mechanisms leading to transformation of dislocation cores can be activated only by temperature. Several regimes can therefore be obtained for a single material, depending on the magnitudes of stress and temperature. Typically, stress is the main driving force in many systems such as metals for an isolated dislocation. But in materials with a high lattice friction such as covalent or geophysical systems, the weight of thermal activation in dislocation-related mechanisms grows. In the case of dislocation nucleation, we will see that both temperature and stress are important.
3.4 Dislocation and Surfaces: Basic Concepts
To study the formation of a dislocation from a surface, it is helpful to first examine the situation where the dislocation is already present in the system and still in interaction with the surface, that is, close enough. 3.4.1 Forces Related to Surface
The presence of a surface introduces an additional complexity in the study of dislocations. In fact, it is well known that there is a long-range interaction on the dislocation due to the surface [9]. This interaction can be understood by considering that the self-energy of a dislocation is decreasing when the dislocation is brought closer to the surface. Alternatively, one can consider that there is relaxation of the stress field of the dislocation by the surface, thus lowering the energy. Another possible subtle effect is the relaxation of the surface stress by the dislocation. The total energy change is equivalent to an attractive force between the dislocation and the surface. The interaction force between the surface and a dislocation can be derived in the most simple cases using the concept of an image dislocation located in a symmetric position relative to the surface. For a straight edge dislocation with a line parallel to the surface, this force is inversely proportional to the dislocation–surface distance d, and is equal to Fi Kb2 ¼ l 4pd
ð3:2Þ
where K is a function of the elastic constant parameters depending on the dislocation character. Due to this force, a dislocation segment of length l is drawn closer to the surface. In the specific case of interest here, we consider a half-loop dislocation whose two ends are in connection with the surface (Figure 3.2). This is equivalent to a pinning of the half-loop dislocation by the surface. Therefore, in addition to image interactions, there is an additional line tension force exerted on the half-loop
j65
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
66
Figure 3.2 Schematic representation of a circular half-loop dislocation of Burgers vector b nucleated from a surface and propagating in a slip plane (white), making an angle q with the surface normal n. Edge and screw components
of the Burgers vector are be and bs , relative to the dislocation front. Fs and Fs are forces acting on the dislocation associated with surface interaction and stress, respectively.
dislocation that tends to bring the dislocation closer to the surface. In the following, the total force resulting from the interaction of a half-loop dislocation and the surface is called Fs . 3.4.2 Balance of Forces for Nucleation
We now analyze the balance of forces exerted on a spherical half-loop dislocation of radius R, as represented in Figure 3.2. The force Fs due to the surface tends to bring the dislocation closer to the surface, thereby reducing R. Conversely, for the appropriate stress direction, the force Fs associated with stress relaxation tends to propagate the dislocation into the material, thus increasing R. Because these forces are opposed, there is no possible stable configuration. The energy of the half-loop dislocation as a function of R is schematically represented in Figure 3.3. Depending on the value of the stress applied on the dislocation, there are two possible regimes. For low or moderate stress, the energy first increases until it reaches a maximum, defining an unstable equilibrium configuration, and then decreases. This maximum, characterized by an energy Ea and a radius Rc , has to be overcome by thermal activation for nucleating a propagating dislocation. Otherwise, for stress higher than a given value s c , the stress contribution is large enough for the energy barrier to vanish, the dislocation formation process becoming athermal. s c is the critical stress for nucleating dislocation, comparable to the Peierls stress for displacing dislocation in bulk materials. 3.4.3 Forces Due to Lattice Friction
Up to now, we have discussed the balance of forces for dislocation nucleation from the surface without taking into account the lattice friction of the materials. In fact, to propagate into a material, a dislocation must overcome the lattice resistance, whose
3.4 Dislocation and Surfaces: Basic Concepts
Energy variation
σ < σc
Ea
Rc σ >σc
Half-loop dislocation radius Figure 3.3 Possible energy variations as a function of the radius of a nucleated half-loop dislocation, and definition of the activation parameters for stresses lower than the critical stress sc .
magnitude depends on the nature of the material itself. In fcc metallic systems, this resistance is very low and additional barriers in the energy variation can be safely neglected (Figure 3.4). Conversely, in covalent systems, the lattice friction may be very large and these energy barriers could be in the same range or even larger than the activation energy due to surface forces. Then, they have to be considered in the mechanism of dislocation formation from the surface of covalent materials (Figure 3.4). In any case, it is clear that the nucleation of a half-loop dislocation from a surface is possible only if stress and temperature reach values required for dislocation propagation in the bulk.
Energy variation
Covalent
fcc metal
Half-loop dislocation radius Figure 3.4 Examples of possible energy variations as a function of the radius of a nucleated halfloop dislocation, taking into account the lattice friction for fcc metallic and covalent materials.
j67
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
68
3.4.4 Surface Modifications Due to Dislocations
In addition to the above-discussed interaction, a dislocation will change the surface state when it is nucleated or when it leaves the material, which involves an energy variation. The most important (and often visible) surface modification is the creation of a step or a decrease/increase of the height of an existing step. This modification is bounded by the two surface points pinning the half-loop dislocation. The change of the step height is given by ðbe nÞ, be being the edge component of the Burgers vector and n the surface normal (Figure 3.2). Defining the angle q between the surface normal n and the dislocation slip plane, the step height change is be cosðqÞ. 3.5 Elastic Modeling 3.5.1 Elastic Model
We aim at determining the energy of the configuration represented in Figure 3.2 in the case of an isotropic medium, relatively to the same system but without the dislocation. In early analyses of dislocation nucleation at surface, it was usually assumed that the self-energy of the half-loop dislocation is simply half the self-energy of a full circular dislocation loop [7–9, 21, 22]. A more accurate formulation has been proposed by Beltz and Freund, who introduced a correction factor m in the logarithmic part of the energy [23]. The self-energy of the circular half-loop is therefore given by mb2 ð2nÞ 8maR R ln 2 U¼ 8ð1nÞ b
ð3:3Þ
In (3.3), m is the shear modulus, n is the Poisson coefficient, a ¼ b=r0 is a nondimensional factor defining the unknown dislocation core radius r0 , and m is a geometrical parameter that depends on the Poisson coefficient, the system geometry (angle between surface and slip plane), the shape of the loop, and the Burgers vector orientation. m is necessarily bounded by 0 and 1, but is generally not known. In their seminal work, Beltz and Freund proposed an expression for m in the case of a circular half-loop in a slip plane perpendicular to the surface [23]. The total energy of the system should also include the energy gained by enlarging the dislocation loop, that is, the work associated with stress relaxation. This quantity is proportional to the area swept by the dislocation that is pR2 =2 in the case of a circular half-loop, yielding 1 W ¼ pR2 sb 2
ð3:4Þ
3.5 Elastic Modeling
In the framework of linear isotropic elasticity theory, the latter quantity can also be expressed as a function of the applied deformation e. In the case of an uniaxial deformation, s ¼ 2mð1 þ nÞse, s being the Schmid factor, and W is now given by W ¼ mbð1 þ nÞpR2 s e
ð3:5Þ
A third possible contribution to the total energy is related to surface modifications after dislocation formation. Since the step height change is given by be cosðqÞ, the corresponding energy variation is Es ¼ 2Rbe cosðqÞcs
ð3:6Þ
cs is equivalent to a surface energy in the case of a high step. When a single step is created in coherence with the crystal structure, be cs is a step energy. Note that very small energy contributions due to dislocation pinning points at the surface are neglected here. Finally, we have to consider the situations where single partial dislocations are nucleated from the surface. In such case, the propagation of dislocation into the crystal is accompanied with the formation of a stacking fault. Defining the stacking fault energy cf , the additional contribution is 1 Ef ¼ pR2 cf 2
ð3:7Þ
Combining (3.3) and (3.4) or (3.5) and (3.6) and eventually (3.7) provides the total energy EðR; sÞ (or EðR; eÞ) associated with the formation of a half-loop dislocation of radius R from a surface for a stress s (or an applied deformation e). It is quite instructive to plot the different contributions to the total energy as a function of R, as shown in Figure 3.5. Here we have selected realistic values for the
Figure 3.5 Variation of the different energy contributions from the elastic model (described in the text) as a function of the radius of a nucleated half-loop dislocation, using realistic values for the different parameters. Inset shows these variations for a very small radius.
j69
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
70
different parameters entering into Eqs (3.3)–(3.7). These correspond to a nucleated partial dislocation with a leading 90 orientation, in aluminum, leaving a step on the surface. For large R, it appears that the step energy Es is negligible compared to the other contributions. The energy cost Ef for stacking fault creation in the case of partial dislocations, quickly increasing due to the R2 dependence, is also emphasized. The inset in Figure 3.5 shows the energy variation for small values of R. A local minimum is present in the total energy curve, because of the R lnR dependence on UðRÞ. This minimum occurs for R values typically lower than the core radius r0 , where the validity of elasticity theory is obviously questionable. Therefore, this minimum has no physical meaning within the framework of the elastic model. 3.5.2 Predicted Activation Parameters
Knowing the expression of the total energy, it is straightforward to determine the activation parameters Ea and Rc as a function of the stress or the deformation. Rc corresponds to the maximum energy, which is obtained when @EðRÞ=@R ¼ 0 or mb2 ð2nÞ 8maRc 1 þ ðcf 2mbð1 þ nÞseÞpRc be cosðqÞcs ¼ 0 ln b 8ð1nÞ ð3:8Þ
in the case of an applied deformation e. There is no analytical solution, and Rc has to be determined numerically. Once Rc ðeÞ is known, Ea ðeÞ ¼ EðRc ; eÞ is easily computed. Figure 3.6 shows the variation of Rc ðeÞ and Ea ðeÞ as a function of e using the same parameters as in Figure 3.5. In the regime of small deformation, both the predicted activation energy and the critical radius are large, suggesting that a thermally activated dislocation nucleation is highly unlikely. An increase of the applied stress leads to a sharp decrease of both quantities, approximately according to a 1=e relation. It is difficult to set a defined boundary, but one can reasonably consider that the onset of plasticity by half-loop dislocation nucleation would occur when Ea becomes lower than about 2 eV. In fact, a rough estimation of the time required to activate one event at room temperature for such an activation energy is on the order of the duration of a usual deformation experiment. For high applied stresses, both activation energies and critical radius are predicted to decrease. Finally, when the strain (or equivalently the stress) is larger than the athermal threshold, defined in Section 1.4.2, the activation energy vanishes. 3.5.3 What is Missing?
In order to use the elastic model, one has to determine two parameters: m that is a geometrical factor and a that is linked to the dislocation core radius. In the original
3.5 Elastic Modeling
Figure 3.6 Variation of the activation energy Ea (left scale) and critical radius Rc (right scale) as a function of the resolved shear strain se for similar parameters than in Figure 3.5. Open symbols are data obtained from atomistic calculations. For small deformations (left gray
area), a thermal activation of the nucleation mechanism is unlikely. For large deformations (right gray area), the validity of the elastic model is questionable. Inset recalls the definition of Ea and Rc , as in Figure 3.3.
formulation of Beltz and Freund, m was determined for a specific geometry and it varies from 0.5 to 0.6 for a Poisson ratio ranging from 0 to 0.5. However, the extent of variation in a general case is not known. Besides, it is not possible to determine accurately a, which is often set to values between 2 and 4 in elasticity studies. Unknowns m and a are not independent in (3.3), meaning that only the product ma has to be determined. Such a feat could be achieved using numerical simulations at the atomistic level, as will be shown in the following section. Moreover, this elastic model is built on several assumptions. For instance, in the Beltz–Freund derivation of (3.3), the half-loop dislocation is assumed to be perfectly circular. However, in the general case, a full dislocation loop is likely to adopt an elliptical shape, since edge and screw dislocation segments have different energies and mobilities. An elliptical half-loop dislocation could be taken into account in the elastic model, with the transformation R2 ! eR2 in (3.5) and (3.7), and R ! eR in (3.6). The parameter e defines the ellipticity of the loop. Other assumptions concern the determination of the resolved shear stress on the dislocation from the applied deformation, or conversely. There are two issues here. One is related to the use of linear isotropic elasticity theory, which could not be well suited for strongly anisotropic materials, or for large applied deformations. The other is the inhomogeneous character of the stress depending on the system geometry. In fact, the presence of an initial step on the surface obviously changes the stress distribution. As shown by several authors, there is a stress increase in the vicinity of the step [24, 25]. This is expected to favor dislocation formation and is not taken into account in the elastic model, which assumes an homogeneous stress distribution.
j71
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
72
Finally, one has to keep in mind that the validity of the elastic model becomes questionable when Rc is on the same order than the unknown dislocation core radius r0 . Therefore, it is doubtful that it could be used for determining sc , the critical stress for which the energy barrier is vanishing. In this particular case, it appears necessary to use atomistic modeling. The latter could also be necessary for investigating systems with a large lattice friction. Indeed, the modification of the atomic environment at the surface is expected to change this lattice friction, which may be locally higher than that in the bulk. Therefore, an additional energy barrier for the very first steps of dislocation nucleation, due to the surface (or the step), could be the critical factor. Additional effects like surface or step reconstructions are also expected to influence the nucleation process. These atomistic effects are clearly not described in the elastic model. 3.5.4 Peierls–Nabarro Approaches
It is possible to make more accurate investigations of the dislocation nucleation process by incorporating selected information at the atomic scale. The well-known Peierls–Nabarro approach allows solving some of the previous issues, however at the expense of an increased complexity. Hence, extensions of the original 1D Peierls–Nabarro model [26, 27] have been developed for dealing with similar 2D and 3D problems [28–30]. The dislocation nucleation from a surface has been investigated by Li and Xu using a general variational boundary integral formulation of Peierls–Nabarro model [31]. This framework allows to deal with complex system, but requires the use of numerical simulations like finite element calculations. Li and Xu showed that an increase of the step height leads to a large reduction in the activation energy and studied the influence of slip plane and step inclinations. Compared to the above elastic model, the stress inhomogeneity is taken into account in these calculations. Also, there are no limitations regarding the shape of the dislocation loop. Partial information on the dislocation core is included in the calculations through empirical models or from generalized stacking fault surfaces determined with atomistic simulations. Nevertheless, it is of interest to note that the dislocation core is still approximately described within these approaches, and that the influence on the nucleation process of atomistic details of the surface and step cannot be dealt with.
3.6 Atomistic Modeling
In order to remove the limitations reported in the previous section and to determine the input parameters in the elastic model, theoretical investigations can be made by using atomistic simulation methods. Within this framework, the description of the dislocation nucleation process is done at the atomistic level, which allows access to the very beginning of a half-loop dislocation formation. Generally, one can also expect
3.6 Atomistic Modeling
a better accuracy than with elasticity theory. Unfortunately, it is not all rosy. The first downside of these methods is the usually large computational effort, which results in strong limitations in the size of the considered system and in the timescale for dynamic simulations. This aspect is especially important for first-principles calculations, for which simulations typically include only few hundreds of atoms, with durations on the order of picoseconds. Other methods such as classical molecular dynamics allow to deal with much bigger systems with larger timescale, although the characteristic duration of such a simulation is typically in the nanosecond range. Classical simulations also generally imply an undefined loss of accuracy compared to first-principles calculations. The second downside of atomistic simulations is that the general nature of the elastic treatment is lost. In fact, it is more difficult to determine a general behavior since the investigated process can depend on the atomistic details of the input system, such as the structure of the surface or a step. More simulations are then required to study the possible configurations. 3.6.1 Examples of Simulations
Most of the few atomistic investigations of dislocation nucleation from surfaces are recent and are focused on simple materials. The aim appears to be a full understanding of the process rather than to numerically reproduce experiments made with real and complex systems. The nucleation of a half-loop dislocation in a ductile simple fcc metal like aluminum has been studied by the authors. Classical molecular dynamics simulations at RT of a stressed Al(100) slab showed the formation of a half-loop partial dislocation from steps initially built on the surface (Figure 3.7) [32]. The nucleation started at an imposed tensile strain of about 6% (with an orientation perpendicular to the surface step), the dislocation gliding in the (111) plane in the continuity of the surface step. Analyses of the dislocation revealed a 90 orientation as expected, since it corresponds to the largest Schmid factor. An equivalent result was obtained in copper by Zhu et al. [33], as they investigated the formation of a half-loop partial dislocation from the flat (001) surfaces of a h100i square section nanowire under compressive stress, and for Al and Ni in the case of dislocation nucleation from surfaces at crack tips [34]. Covalent systems have also been considered, aiming at a better understanding of the mechanisms relaxing the high stresses that may occur in the thin layers of semiconductor devices [35]. For instance, Izumi and Yip have studied the formation of a dislocation in silicon from a sharp corner, which is equivalent to a high and straight step [36]. The nucleated dislocation exhibits a half-hexagonal shape, which is characteristic of deep Peierls valleys as expected in covalent materials, and glides in the dense h111i planes. Similar results were obtained for smaller steps by the present authors (Figure 3.8). We have also shown that depending on the range of applied strain and temperature, both partial and perfect dislocations could be nucleated [37, 38], a situation equivalent to what is observed in bulk silicon [8, 39].
j73
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
74
Figure 3.7 Snapshot of a molecular dynamics run at RT showing the formation of a half-loop partial dislocation in a Al(100) slab, leaving a stacking fault connecting with a step on the surface. Only atoms in a nonbulk environment
are represented to ease the visualization. With the chosen color code, the dislocation core and stacking fault are represented by blue atoms, whereas atoms forming the surface step are red.
3.6.2 Determination of Activation Parameters
The usual and most appealing simulation framework for investigating thermally activated atomistic processes is molecular dynamics [40, 41], since it allows mimicking the dynamical behavior of the system within various conditions. However, due to computing limitations, the timescale of simulations is severely restricted, which
Figure 3.8 Snapshot of a molecular dynamics run at 600 K showing the formation of a half-loop dislocation in a Si(100) slab, starting from a (111) edge. Only atoms in a nonbulk environment are represented to make the visualization easier.
3.6 Atomistic Modeling
prevents an efficient exploration of the onset of plasticity. In fact, the latter occurs, thanks to a single event, the first nucleated dislocation being usually followed by many others. In an experiment, the probability to observe this initial process is not negligible at moderate stress due to macroscopic timescale. With molecular dynamics, very high stresses, close to the athermal threshold, have to be reached for making the activation possible in the simulations. As a consequence, only a very small stress range could be investigated, and this approach appears to be not suited for a quantitative determination of the activation energy. Alternative methods to investigate activated processes with high-energy barriers (i.e., rare events) are available. Among the many different flavors of transition-state determination techniques, a chain-like method such as nudged elastic band (NEB) [42] is a favorite nowadays since it is fast, easy to use, and implemented in several computational packages. In an NEB calculation, a set of image configurations allowing to transform a given system from an initial to a final state are first built, and the consecutive images are then linked by springs in configurational space. The relaxation of these images leads to the minimum energy path (MEP), from which the activation energy can be easily deduced. Note that the use of such a method for dislocation nucleation is somewhat tricky [43, 44]. Figure 3.6 shows the critical radii and activation energies determined by NEB calculations for four different applied strains, in the case of an (001) aluminum surface including a one-layer width step. These values have been used for fitting the elastic model described above, considering that the dislocation half-loop may be elliptical. The best fit is reached for ma ¼ 1 and an ellipticity factor e ¼ 1:05, both reasonable numbers. In fact, using m 0:5, a value close to the one given in the original paper from Beltz and Freund, the core radius factor a is found to be about 2. Besides, e is close to 1, justifying the use of the circular half-loop approximation in this specific case. This point is confirmed by the analysis of the shape of the half-loop dislocation, which can be accessed from NEB calculations. Finally, this result indicates that the developed elastic model is sound and captures most of the physical aspects underlying the nucleation of half-loop dislocation from surfaces, at least for fcc metals. It is worth to mention two shortcomings of the approach. First, although a constant applied stress is assumed in the elastic model, atomistic simulations have been performed with a constant applied strain. In the latter, the resolved shear stress is expected to decrease when a dislocation is formed and propagates through the system, a property that is not included in the elastic model. Second, an NEB calculation is intrinsically static, that is, it only allows computing the internal energy barrier and not the free energy barrier. Vibrational contributions, which are known to be important for many dynamical systems, and inertia effects are not accessible with the NEB method, unlike molecular dynamics. It is difficult to estimate the importance of both issues on the activation energy and the critical radius curves. 3.6.3 Comparison with Experiments
Ideally, the next step would be a thorough comparison of predictions given by the theoretical approaches with available experimental data. Unfortunately, such a feat is
j75
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
76
difficult to achieve. We have already mentioned that the true onset of plasticity is difficult to measure in nanoscaled systems. Furthermore, the modeling corresponds to an ideal material that can be relatively far from the real material. For instance, it is well known that most of the mechanical tests of nanopillars have been performed with samples prepared using a focused ion beam technique, which tends to leave a nonnegligible concentration of Ga atoms in the surface. Nevertheless, theoretical approaches are expected to provide the correct orders of magnitude when compared to experiments. Navarro et al. have recently examined the onset of plasticity from gold surfaces with nanoindentation [45]. The measured shear stress are 2.1 and 1.6 GPa for flat and stepped surfaces, respectively. In the case of Al investigated here, the computed values for the elastic limit correspond to yield strengths of few GPa, thus in the same range. Generally, it seems that theoretical data are overestimated compared to experiments, typically by a factor of 2 or 3. The most likely explanation for this discrepancy is the difference in space and timescales between numerical simulations and experiments. In fact, due to computer limitations, molecular dynamics calculations are usually limited to tens of nanoseconds. Accordingly, the strain/strain rates used in the numerical simulations are unrealistically high [33]. Since the nucleation of the initial dislocation is a stochastic event, the associated onset of plasticity is most likely to occur during an experiment time on the order of a second. As a result, higher stress is required in simulations for initiating plasticity. This issue is known for the investigation of dislocation mobility in bulk materials [46, 47] and has been recently examined for the nucleation of dislocations in nanomaterials [33, 43]. Another possible discrepancy origin is the difference in dimensions between simulations and experiments. For instance, periodic boundary conditions are mostly used for modeling infinitely long nanowires from a small system. The number of possible nucleation sites is, therefore, much smaller than that in a real sample, which makes the dislocation nucleation less likely in simulations. These aspects should be kept in mind when comparing modeling with experiments. 3.6.4 Influence of Surface Structure, Orientation, and Chemistry
In the elastic model described in the previous section, we have considered the general case of a surface, with a step of arbitrary height or without. Nevertheless, a step is generally used in atomistic studies, for it has been shown not only to decrease the amount of strain required for dislocation nucleation but also to localize the nucleation event. Now, since the elastic model has been fitted by considering stepped surfaces, the stress modification due to the step is taken into account, although it is not explicitly included in the model. Test simulations, performed for flat surfaces, suggest that this effect could amount to several tens of electron volts for large applied strains. Recently, Li and Xu have investigated the effect of step height and angle relative to the surface using a Peierls–Nabarro framework [31]. A significant reduction of the required stress is obtained when the step height increases, this effect being stronger for low angles. This result was recently confirmed by atomistic
3.6 Atomistic Modeling
simulations in metallic systems [43]. These investigations also revealed a nonmonotonous behavior between mono- and multilayer steps, which seems to be linked with the atomic structure of the step. In a covalent material like silicon with a strong directional bonding, such an effect is expected to be even more important. In these materials, dislocation cores are usually complex [39] and several step geometries are possible. Godet et al. have shown that the initial formation of the core would depend on the step geometry [48]. Other aspects such as the influence of kinks on the steps and of the surface chemistry have not been extensively studied. Atomistic simulations aiming at the formation of dislocations from steps with kinks suggested that kinks are not favorable nucleation sites [32]. This point is supported by experimental evidences that dislocation nucleation is easier from straight than irregular steps (B. Pichaud, private communication). The structure of the surface has also been shown to have a paramount importance for the nucleation process. In fact, first-principles simulations of silicon surfaces under stress [49] revealed that while dislocation formation succeeded from bare reconstructed surfaces, the nucleation is hindered when the surface is passivated with hydrogen (Figure 3.9). This result obviously calls for additional investigations. Finally, there have been very few investigations of the influence of the surface orientation regarding the dislocation formation process. Different orientations would mean the selection of different slip planes, as well as different step geometries. Although the atomic structure is not taken into account in their analysis, Li and Xu have shown that when the angle between the surface and the slip plane is smaller,
Figure 3.9 Successive steps (from left to right) of the first-principles relaxation of a stressed silicon slab. At the top, a single dislocation is nucleated at the step edge and propagates toward the opposite surface. At the bottom, the
presence of hydrogen atoms passivating the surface prevents the dislocation formation at the surface, which occurs by homogeneous nucleation into the slab.
j77
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
78
Figure 3.10 Snapshot of a thin buckled Al slab after the nucleation and propagation of several partial dislocations, resulting from the modeling of a delamination process. Only atoms in a nonbulk environment are shown for clarity. Courtesy of J. Durinck et al. [51]
dislocation nucleation becomes easier. In the different context of brittle-to-ductile transition, an atomistic study of dislocation emission from crack tip also pointed to a significant effect of the surface orientation [50].
3.7 Extension to Different Geometries
The elastic and atomistic modeling of the onset of plasticity described in the previous sections deals with flat surfaces, eventually containing steps, under the action of a unixial stress (strain), which is rather typical of epitaxial thin films. However, there are other configurations for which the dislocation nucleation from surfaces is expected to be the main plastic mechanism. For instance, molecular dynamics studies of the buckling of metallic thin films revealed the nucleation of many dislocations from the surface (Figure 3.10). Other cases include the nucleation of dislocation from crack tip [52]. The process of dislocation nucleation from surfaces has recently regained attention with the development of nanowire/nanopillar deformation tests [11, 53–57]. Most of the investigations performed with atomistic simulations focused on cylindrical nanowires with diameters usually lower than 10 nm. For fcc metals, a general result of these simulations is the nucleation of dislocations from the surface [58–60]. For such small diameters, the curvature of the surface wire is large and is clearly expected to play a significant role in the process of nucleation. This aspect is not included in the model described in the previous sections, and to our knowledge no attempts have been made to develop an appropriate framework. Nevertheless, experimentally investigated metallic nanopillars have much larger diameters, generally greater than 200 nm. In this case, the surface curvature is small and large flat terraces are likely to exist. The model of surface nucleation should therefore be appropriate. Atomistic simulations have also been performed for small nanowires made of covalent materials, with a focus on the size effect in the brittle-to-ductile transition [61, 62]. Conversely to metals, very thin covalent nanowires can be synthesized.
3.8 Discussion
Although almost spherical nanowires have been studied, reconstructed facets should be predominant for low-diameter nanowires. The influence of the nanowire section shape then becomes another factor to consider [63]. Note that in the case of a nonrealistic square Cu nanowire, the onset of plasticity has been predicted to occur from dislocation nucleation at the edge rather than at the surface [33].
3.8 Discussion
In this chapter, we have investigated the onset of plasticity in single-crystalline materials having one or several nanometric dimensions, in the framework of elasticity theory and atomistic simulations. The elastic modeling of the nucleation of a dislocation from a surface allows a qualitative description of the process. This model requires to be fitted on atomistic simulations, and one may wonder whether its use is judicious if these simulations have to be performed for each new system. However, it has been shown that only one parameter has to be fitted, and that the resulting value was close to what could be expected. Accordingly, one can tentatively assume that the proposed elastic model could be used for investigating the dislocation nucleation process in other metals like Au, Ag, Pb, or Ni, simply by using the correct physical data and the same fitted parameter. Conversely, for other families of materials such as bcc metals or covalent systems, further atomistic investigations are certainly required. We have discussed in the preceding sections several issues that tend to make harder the numerical determination of quantities such as the critical stress corresponding to the onset of plasticity in experiments. Yet, the effect of the large differences in timescale and space scale between experiments and simulations has been examined by several authors, and ways to solve the problems have been proposed. Therefore, it should be possible to use the model described here to compute critical stresses for different systems, apply the proposed corrections, and compare with available experiments. To our knowledge, such a systematic comparison remains to be made. Besides, yield stress estimations proposed in experimental papers are usually derived from crude assumptions. For the specific case of nanowires and nanopillars, the effect of size should be examined. In particular, for the smaller ones, it would be necessary to take into account the surface curvature. This is especially important for nanowires with midrange diameters, too large to be dealt with atomistic simulations, but for which these effects could be important. Finally, in experiments, the onset of plasticity due to the nucleation of an initial dislocation is often followed by the formation and propagation of other dislocations in adjacent planes. A similar avalanche mechanism, spanning a very short time, is seen in atomistic simulations. The formation of these successive dislocations seems to be easier, thanks to a dynamical and geometrical effect. Nevertheless, a full understanding of this process is still lacking, which would certainly help for a better comparison between experiments and simulations.
j79
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
80
Acknowledgments
This chapter is essentially based on research works made by the authors and by Pierre Hirel during his PhD. D. Rodney, B. Devincre, J. Bonneville, B. Pichaud, L. Kubin, J. Rabier, A. Pedersen, and J. Grilhe are gratefully acknowledged for fruitful discussions.
References 1 Zhu, T. and Li, J. (2010) Ultra-strength 2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
materials. Prog. Mater. Sci., 55, 710. Uchic, M.D., Dinmiduk, D.M., Florando, J.N., and Nix, W.D. (2004) Sample dimensions influence strength and crystal plasticity. Science, 305, 986. Kizuka, T., Takatani, Y., Asaka, K., and Yoshizaki, R. (2005) Measurements of the atomistic mechanics of single crystalline silicon wires of nanometer width. Phys. Rev. B, 72, 035333. Michler, J., Wasmer, K., Meier, S., € Ostlund, F., and Leifer, K. (2007) Plastic deformation of gallium arsenide micropillars under uniaxial compression at room temperature. Appl. Phys. Lett., 90, 043123. Gerberich, W.W., Michler, J., Mook, W.M., € Ghisleni, R., Ostlund, F., Stauffer, D.D., and Ballarini, R. (2009) Scale effects for strength, ductility, and toughness in brittle materials. J. Mater. Res., 24 (3), 898. Frank., F.G. (1950) The origin of dislocations, in Symposium on Plastic Deformation of Crystalline Solids, Carnegie Institute of Technology, Pittsburg, CA, p. 89. Matthews, J.W., Blakeslee, A.E., and Mader, S. (1976) Use of misfit strain to remove dislocations from epitaxial thin films. Thin Solid Films, 33, 253. Hirth, J.P. and Lothe, J. (1982) Theory of Dislocations, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York. Nabarro, F.R.N. (1967) Theory of Crystal Dislocations, Oxford University Press, London. Maaß, R., Van Petegem, S., Zimmermann, J., Borca, C.N., and Van Swygenhoven, H. (2008) On the initial
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
microstructure of metallic micropillars. Scr. Mater., 59, 471. Gerberich, W.W., Michler, J., Mook, € W.M., Ghisleni, R., Ostlund, F., Stauffer, D.D., and Ballarini, R. (2009) Scale effects for strength, ductility, and toughness in brittle materials. J. Mater. Res., 24, 898. Frank, F.C. and Read, W.T., Jr. (1950) Multiplication processes for slow moving dislocations. Phys. Rev., 79, 722. Weinberger, C.R. and Cai, W. (2008) Surface-controlled dislocation multiplication in metal micropillars. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 105 (38), 14304. Han, X., Zheng, K., Zhang, Y., Zhang, X., Zhang, Z., and Wang, Z.L. (2007) Lowtemperature in situ large-strain plasticity of silicon nanowires. Adv. Mater., 19 (16), 2112. Scandian, C., Azzouzi, H., Maloufi, N., Michot, G., and George, A. (1999) Dislocation nucleation and multiplication at crack tips in silicon. Phys. Status Solidi A, 171 (1), 67. Pichaud, B., Burle, N., Texier, M., Alfonso, C., Gailhanou, M., ThibaultPenisson, J., Fontaine, C., and Vdovin, V.I. (2009) Dislocation nucleation in heteroepitaxial semiconducting films. Phys. Status Solidi C, 6 (8), 1827. Greer, J.R. and Nix, W.D. (2006) Nanoscale gold pillars strengthened through dislocation starvation. Phys. Rev. B, 73, 245410. Phillips, R. (2001) Crystals, Defects and Microstructures: Modelling across Scales, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Caillard, D. and Martin, J.L. (2003) Thermally Activated Mechanisms in Crystal
References
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
Plasticity, Pergamon Materials Series, Pergamon. Vineyard, G.H. (1957) Frequency factors and isotope effects in solid state rate processes. J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 3, 121. Kamat, S.V. and Hirth, J.P. (1990) Dislocation injection in strained multilayer structures. J. Appl. Phys., 67 (11), 6844. Zou, J. and Cockayne, D.J.H. (1996) Nucleation of semicircular misfit dislocation loops from the epitaxial surface of strained-layer heterostructures. J. Appl. Phys., 79 (10), 7632. Beltz, G.E. and Freund, L.B. (1993) On the nucleation of dislocations at a crystal surface. Phys. Status Solidi B, 180, 303. Smith, E. (1968) The stress concentration at a step on the surface of a brittle crystalline solid. Int. J. Eng. Sci., 6, 9. Brochard, S., Beauchamp, P., and Grilhe, J. (2000) Stress concentration near a surface step and shear localization. Phys. Rev. B, 61 (13), 8707. Lu, G. (2005) The Peierls–Nabarro model of dislocations: a venerable theory and its current development, in Handbook of Materials Modeling. Volume I: Methods and Models, vol. 2.20 (ed. S. Yip), Springer, pp. 1. Schoeck, G. (2005) The Peierls model: progress and limitations. Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 400–4001, 7. Rice, J.R. and Beltz, G.E. (1994) The activation energy for dislocation nucleation at a crack. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 42 (2), 333. Lu, G., Bulatov, V.V., and Kioussis, N. (2003) A nonplanar Peierls–Nabarro model and its application to dislocation cross-slip. Philos. Mag., 83 (31–34), 3539. Denoual, C. (2007) Modeling dislocation by coupling Peierls–Nabarro and elementfree Galerkin methods. Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng., 196, 1915. Li, C. and Xu, G. (2006) Critical conditions for dislocation nucleation at surface steps. Philos. Mag., 86 (20), 2957. Hirel, P., Brochard, S., Pizzagalli, L., and Beauchamp, P. (2007) Effects of temperature and surface step on the incipient plasticity in strained aluminium
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
studied by atomistic simulations. Scr. Mater., 57, 1141. Zhu, T., Li, J., Samanta, A., Leach, A., and Gall, K. (2008) Temperature and strain-rate dependence of surface dislocation nucleation. Phys. Rev. Lett., 100, 025502. Warner, D.H. and Curtin, W.A. (2009) Origins and implications of temperaturedependent activation energy barriers for dislocation nucleation in face-centered cubic metals. Acta Mater., 57, 4267. Izumi, S., Miyake, T., Sakai, S., and Ohta, H. (2005) Application of threedimensional dislocation dynamics simulation to the STI semiconductor structure. Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 395, 62. Izumi, S. and Yip, S. (2008) Dislocation nucleation from a sharp corner in silicon. J. Appl. Phys., 104, 033513. Godet, J., Hirel, P., Brochard, S., and Pizzagalli, L. (2009) Evidence of two plastic regimes controlled by dislocation nucleation in silicon nanostructures. J. Appl. Phys., 105, 026104. Godet, J., Hirel, P., Brochard, S., and Pizzagalli, L. (2009) Dislocation nucleation from surface step in silicon: the glide set versus the shuffle set. Phys. Status Solidi A, 206 (8), 1885. Rabier, J., Pizzagalli, L., and Demenet, J.-L. (2010) Dislocations in silicon at high stress, in Dislocation in Solids, vol. 16 (eds L. Kubin and J.P. Hirth), Elsevier, Chapter 93, pp. 47. Allen, M.P. and Tildesley, D.J. (1989) Computer Simulation of Liquids, Clarendon Press, Oxford. Thijssen, J.M. (2000) Computational Physics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Jonsson, H., Mills, G., and Jacobsen, K.W. (1998) Nudged elastic band method for finding minimum energy paths of transitions, in Classical and Quantum Dynamics in Condensed Phase Simulations (eds B.J. Berne, G. Ciccotti, and D.F. Coker), World Scientific, Chapter 16, pp. 385. Brochard, S., Hirel, P., Godet, J., and Pizzagalli, L. (2010) Elastic limit for surface step dislocation nucleation in face-centered cubic metals: temperature
j81
j 3 Onset of Plasticity in Crystalline Nanomaterials
82
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
and step height dependence. Acta Mater., 58, 4182. Zhu, T., Li, J., Samanta, A., Kim, H.G., and Suresh, S. (2007) Interfacial plasticity governs strain rate sensitivity and ductility in nanostructured metals. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, 104 (9), 3031. Navarro, V., Rodrıguez de la Fuente, O., Mascaraque, A., and Rojo, J.M. (2008) Uncommon dislocation processes at the incipient plasticity of stepped gold surfaces. Phys. Rev. Lett., 100, 105504. Domain, C. and Monnet, G. (2005) Simulation of screw dislocation motion in iron by molecular dynamics simulations. Phys. Rev. Lett., 95, 215506. Rodney, D. (2007) Activation enthalpy for kink-pair nucleation on dislocations: comparison between static and dynamic atomic-scale simulations. Phys. Rev. B, 76, 144108. Godet, J., Pizzagalli, L., Brochard, S., and Beauchamp, P. (2004) Theoretical study of dislocation nucleation from simple surface defects in semiconductors. Phys. Rev. B, 70, 54109. Godet, J., Brochard, S., Pizzagalli, L., Beauchamp, P., and Soler, J.M. (2006) Dislocation formation from a surface step in semiconductors: an ab initio study. Phys. Rev. B, 73, 092105. Hess, B., Thijsse, B.J., and Van der Giessen, E. (2005) Molecular dynamics study of dislocation nucleation from a crack tip. Phys. Rev. B, 71, 054111. Durinck, J., Coupeau, C., Colin, J., and Grilhe, J. (2008) Molecular dynamics simulations of buckling-induced plasticity. Appl. Phys. Lett., 93, 221904. Zhu, T., Li, J., and Yip, S. (2004) Atomistic study of dislocation loop emission from a crack tip. Phys. Rev. Lett., 93 (2), 025503. Nix, W.D., Greer, J.R., Feng, G., and Lilleodden, E.T. (2007) Deformation at the nanometer and micrometer length scales: Effects of strain gradients and dislocation starvation. Thin Solid Films, 515, 3152. Volkert, C.A. and Lilleodden, E.T. (2006) Size effects in the deformation of
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
sub-micron Au columns. Philos. Mag., 86, 5567. Mook, W.M., Lund, M.S., Leighton, C., and Gerberich, W.W. (2008) Flow stresses and activation volumes for highly deformed nanoposts. Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 493, 12. Ho Oh, S., Legros, M., Kiener, D., and Dehm, G. (2009) In situ observation of dislocation nucleation and escape in a submicrometre aluminium single crystal. Nat. Mater., 8, 95. € Ostlund, F., Rzepiejewska-Malyska, K., Leifer, K., Hale, L.M., Tang, Y., Ballarini, R., Gerberich, W.W., and Michler, J. (2009) Nanostructure Fracturing: Brittle-to-Ductile Transition in Uniaxial Compression of Silicon Pillars at Room Temperature. Adv. Funct. Mater., 19, 2439. Park, H.S., Gall, K., and Zimmerman, J.A. (2006) Deformation of fcc nanowires by twinning and slip. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 54, 1862. Rabkin, E., Nam, H.-S., and Srolovitz, D.J. (2007) Atomistic simulation of the deformation of gold nanopillars. Acta Mater., 55, 2085. Deng, C. and Sansoz, F. (2009) Fundamental differences in the plasticity of periodically twinned nanowires in Au, Ag, Al, Cu, Pb and Ni. Acta Mater., 57, 6090. Kang, K. and Cai, W. (2007) Brittle and ductile fracture of semiconductor nanowires: molecular dynamics simulations. Philos. Mag., 87 (14–15), 2169. Wang, Z., Zu, X., Yang, L., Gao, F., and Weber, W.J. (2007) Atomistic simulations of the size, orientation, and temperature dependence of tensile behavior in GaN nanowires. Phys. Rev. B, 76, 045310. Justo, J.F., Menezes, R.D., and Assali, L.V.C. (2007) Stability and plasticity of silicon nanowires: the role of wire perimeter. Phys. Rev. B, 75, 045303.
j83
4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations Christine Mottet
Atomic structure of materials reveals usually significant deviations compared to perfect periodic bulk crystals. Condensed matter is made of defects, some of them being essential for physical properties such as doping in semiconductors (extrinsic defects), other ones such as vacancies, dislocations, or grain boundaries are key elements for mechanical properties of materials, especially in the plastic domain. Defects come from the elaboration mode and thermal treatment of the materials. When the dimensions of the system decrease, the surface and interfaces become important, and the structure can be modified in the vicinity of these extended defects. The cut bonds at the surface or the epitaxial relation at the interface may not only induce stress and strain in the neighborhood of the defect but also possible reorganization, both atomically and chemically in case of alloys. Such structural modifications have a stronger impact when the size of the system is reduced at the nanoscale, as in clusters or nanoparticles. Nowadays, experimental improvements make it possible to elaborate and characterize nanomaterials. In parallel, theory and especially atomistic models based on numerical simulations (semiempirical potentials or ab initio methods in the density functional theory, DFT) made significant progress in describing the relaxation processes leading to energy optimization. As a consequence, we know that such defects are associated with lattice deformations and reconstructions, or even chemical rearrangements minimizing the total energy of the system but not necessarily its stress. In case of pure systems such as surface or clusters, we show that energy minimization can lead to relatively high-stressed systems as in the case of the (1 2) reconstructed metallic surfaces or in the case of small icosahedral clusters with high compression in their core. In contrast, in alloy surfaces and nanoalloys, we usually find that the release of the stress coming from the size mismatch between the two components is a driving force for stabilization of the system. This chapter will develop different aspects of the atomistic approach by numerical simulations of relaxations at the nanoscale in five sections. After a short introduction, the theoretical models and basic numerical simulations will be described in Section 4.2. Then, the relaxations in surfaces and interfaces (surface reconstructions, alloy surfaces, and heteroepitaxial thin films) will be discussed in
Mechanical Stress on the Nanoscale: Simulation, Material Systems and Characterization Techniques, First Edition. Edited by Margrit Hanb€ ucken, Pierre M€ uller, and Ralf B. Wehrspohn. Ó 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. Published 2011 by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA.
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
84
Section 4.3, before dealing with the relaxations in nanoclusters (unsupported pure clusters, supported clusters, and nanoalloys) in Section 4.4. The last section will stand for conclusions.
4.1 Introduction
In linear elasticity theory, the stress and strain relation described under the form of the Hookes law is based on the continuum concept for the matter that has been well represented using a tensorial notation, as introduced by the French mathematician Augustin Louis Cauchy (1789–1857). It has been able to describe most of the elastic deformation both in macroscopic and in microscopic systems. However, going to smaller and smaller systems sizes up to the nanometer scale, it becomes more evident that the description at the atomic level is more relevant. In particular, when the atomic structure is sensibly modified compared to the bulk periodic structure, we can expect that in the vicinity of the perturbations, the elastic theory fails. In the following, we will show, however, that the linear elasticity theory reproduces well the strain at a certain distance of the stressed region but not necessarily exactly in the center of the defect. So we find that the two aspects, continuum theory and atomistic description, are essentially complementary. The concept of relaxation in physics is not exactly the same as in current life. In the occidental way of life, the relaxation represents a process or state with the aim of recreation through leisure activities or idling, the opposite of stress or tension. In the oriental civilization, the relaxation could be associated with meditation as taught by Zen masters. In physics, the relaxation is a response to external (or internal) stress (or strain). It implies both the time-dependent process of this mechanical perturbation that we will rather call dynamical relaxation, involving the physical and atomistic mechanism the system uses to reach its relaxed state, and the final relaxed state that we will essentially consider here. When a load is applied to a system as in the traction experiment, the system is strained because of the external stress and the atomic positions may change. We will not consider the way they will move (the dynamics) but their final configuration in the final relaxed state, whatever the way this state has been reached. Even if a system is free of external stress, this does not mean it is free of strain. Indeed, because of defects such as surfaces, interfaces, grain boundaries, or dislocations, a system can be strained by itself, without any load applied. In such cases, the system presents some deviations compared to the bulk periodic structure. This will be described at the atomic level by numerical simulations. The strain pattern is controlled by the energy minimization. The system optimizes its energy by moving some of its atoms (optimizing the bond length as a function of the local environment and in particular the number of near neighbors) and by exchanging atoms of different species in the case of alloys. For example, some surfaces are reconstructed in order to compensate their lack of bonds, such as the famous (7 7) reconstruction of the Si(111) surface [1] or the Au(111) surface reconstruction [2].
4.2 Theoretical Models and Numerical Simulations
4.2 Theoretical Models and Numerical Simulations
Modelization of the energy of the system is the crucial point in order to perform realistic and reliable simulations. There are different approaches with different degrees of accuracy corresponding to different levels of description of the electronic structure from the first-principles methods using the density functional theory to semiempirical potentials fitted to experimental properties or, eventually, on ab initio calculations if experimental data do not exist. In parallel to the energetic model, we will illustrate the basic statistical thermodynamic methods in numerical simulations, that is, molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo simulations, to describe the equilibrium configuration corresponding to the minimum energy state in the fundamental state (at OK) or at finite temperature. 4.2.1 Energetic Models
According to the first principles, the Schr€odinger equation for a system of N electrons moving in the electrostatic field created by M atomic nuclei is written as HV ¼ EV
ð4:1Þ
where H is the Hamiltonian operator, E is the energy, and Vðr1 ; . . . ; rN ; R1 ; . . . ; RM Þ is the wave function, which depends on the electrons ri and nuclei Ri positions. The Born–Oppenheimer (adiabatic) approximation consists in separating the movement of the electrons from those of the nuclei, knowing the electron mass is much less than the nuclei one. Thus, the electrons in their fundamental state follow the nuclei in such a way that V can be written as V ¼ WðR1 ; . . . ; RM ÞYðr1 ; . . . ; rN Þ
ð4:2Þ
and the wave function of the electrons comes from the resolution of the Schr€ odinger equation in the field of the nuclei He YðrÞ ¼ Ee YðrÞ
ð4:3Þ
where the electrons Hamiltonian He is the sum of three contributions He ¼ T þ V þ U
ð4:4Þ
with the kinetic energy T T¼
1X rY* ðrÞrYðrÞdr 2
ð4:5Þ
the potential V that represents the interaction of the electrons in the potential of the nuclei X VðrÞ ¼ vðrÞY* ðrÞYðrÞdr ð4:6Þ
j85
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
86
and the Coulomb interaction of the electrons between each other U U¼
1X 1 Y* ðrÞY* ðr 0 ÞYðrÞYðr 0 Þdr dr 0 2 jrr 0 j
ð4:7Þ
The coupling of N electrons by the Coulomb repulsion and the exchange interaction coming from the Pauli exclusion lead to a complex system that is essentially impossible to resolve without approximation. There are two kinds of approximations: the Hartree–Fock method, where the N electrons problem is transformed into N coupled equations with one electron in an effective potential via a Slater determinant, and the density functional theory from the Hohenberg and Kohn theorem (1964) [3]. We will briefly describe the second method, the most used at present. According to the remarkable theorem of Hohenberg and Kohn [3], the energy of a free electron gas in interaction in an external potential vðrÞ is a functional F½nðrÞ of their density nðrÞ, with the minimal value corresponding to the fundamental state. The functional F½nðrÞ, independent of vðrÞ, is defined, according to Kohn and Sham [4], as F ½nðrÞ ¼ Ts ½nðrÞ þ
1 2
ðð
nðrÞnðr 0 Þ dr dr 0 þ Exc ½nðrÞ rr 0
ð4:8Þ
where Ts ½nðrÞ is the kinetic energy of an electron gas without interaction with density nðrÞ, the second term is that of Hartree (mean field approximation) to treat the Coulomb interaction, and the last term is that of exchange and correlation that takes into account all that has been neglected before. The variational problem of the Schr€odinger equation can be solved as a system of one electron in an effective potential 1 r2 þ Veff ðrÞ yi ðrÞ ¼ ei yi ðrÞ ð4:9Þ 2 with the effective potential ð nðr 0 Þ 0 Veff ¼ vðrÞ þ dr þ Vxc ðnðrÞÞ jrr 0 j
ð11Þ
where Vxc ðnðrÞÞ is the exchange and correlation contribution to the potential. This system of Kohn–Sham equations can be solved in an iterative way: starting with a density nðrÞ using monoelectronic functions yi ðrÞ on a given set of wave functions, we calculate the effective associated potential and we solve the Kohn–Sham equations by diagonalization of the matrix. The eigenvectors give the new wavefunctions yi ðrÞ and thus the new density nðrÞ. The energy is integrated numerically over all the k vectors of the Brillouin zone and the self-consistent process is followed up to the convergence of the energy. The two principal exchange and correlation functionals, widely used, are the local density approximation (LDA), which corresponds approximately to a homogeneous electron gas with a sum of local contributions. It is quite correct when the variations
4.2 Theoretical Models and Numerical Simulations
in the density are weak. The second one is the generalized gradient approximation (GGA), which is better in the case where the density can fluctuate as in the vicinity of defects (surfaces) or open systems (molecules). Anyway, ab initio methods in general are time consuming and can be used efficiently only on very small systems (less than hundreds of atoms) or low symmetry, and using a quite poor statistic or a quite short time of dynamics. For larger-scale systems, always keeping the atomistic description, we can use semiempirical potentials and in particular many-body potentials for metallic systems. We will describe briefly the tight binding second moment approximation (TB-SMA) model. In this model, the main features of the cohesion of transition metals are well reproduced by the bandwidth of the density of states [5], which we approximate by a rectangular shape with the same width [6]. By this way, the band energy term at site i can be written simply sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi X ð4:11Þ Eib ¼ j2 e2qðrij =r0 1Þ j
where j is an effective hopping integral, rij is the distance between the atoms at sites i and j, r0 is the first-neighbor distance in the metal. The summation goes over all the neighbors up to the cutoff distance rc . The total energy of a system of N atoms is written as a sum of the band energy term (attractive part) and a repulsive term of the Born–Mayer type X Eir ¼ A epðrij =r0 1Þ ð4:12Þ j
where the parameters (j; A; q; p) are fitted to different experimental values: bulk cohesive energy (eB ), lattice parameter (a), and elastic constants (B, C44 , C0 ) [7] of the metal. This many-body potential is comparable to other well-known methods such as the embedded atom method (EAM) [8] or the corrected effective medium (CEM) theory [9, 10]. Although not as precise as the ab initio methods [11, 12], the TB-SMA approach describes quite correctly, at least qualitatively if not quantitatively, the relaxation and/or some of the possible reconstructions of the low-index surfaces [13]. 4.2.2 Numerical Simulations
The archetypal methods used in numerical atomistic simulations are essentially of two kinds, the molecular dynamics (MD) and the Monte Carlo (MC) simulations, which are well described by Frenkel and Smit [14], and Allen and Tildesley [15]. A lot of other methods have been developed, mainly to overcome the time limitation of the MD simulation to describe real time-dependent processes. The idea of these methods (accelerated dynamics [16], ART [17], NEB [18], or dimer method [19]) is to accelerate the dynamics by the study of the whole energy landscape [20] and in particular the determination of the saddle points in order to cross the energy barriers more efficiently and in an acceptable simulation timescale. We will not describe all these
j87
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
88
more sophisticated methods but give here only the essential elements to give a first insight into the basic atomistic simulation methods (MD and MC simulations). Moreover, in the large majority of the examples given hereafter, we will concentrate on the final relaxed states, obtained from a local relaxation of the atomic positions starting from a configuration that is near the final one. This does not require to perform a full dynamical relaxation process because we are less interested by the relaxation mechanism than by the description of the final relaxed state. In the case of the nanoalloys, some of the atomic structures are coming from global optimization methods [21] that are efficient methods to find the lowest energy structure (global minimum) in the whole energy landscape [20]. In MD simulations, the Newton equations Fi ðtÞ ¼ m
dEpot d2 ri ðtÞ ¼ drij dt2
ð4:13Þ
give, by integration using the Verlet algorithm [22], the atomic positions ri ðtÞ ri ðt þ dtÞ ¼ 2ri ðtÞri ðtdtÞ þ
Fi ðtÞ 2 dt þ eðdt4 Þ m
ð4:14Þ
and the atomic velocities vi ðtÞ ¼
ri ðt þ dtÞri ðtdtÞ 2dt
ð4:15Þ
We can deduce from the velocities, the kinetic energy Ecin ¼
N X 1 i¼1
2
mi vi ðtÞ2
ð4:16Þ
and the temperature T of the system thanks to the equipartition principle N X 3 1 NkT ¼ mi vi ðtÞ2 2 2 i¼1
ð4:17Þ
where k is the Boltzmann constant. We can let the system evolve in the microcanonical ensemble keeping constant the total energy (kinetic þ potential), the number of particles, and the volume of the system. Looking for the equilibrium state, we can perform quenched MD in order to search for the potential energy minimum: the velocity of an atom i is set to zero each time Fi vi < 0. Equilibrium state at finite temperature can be reached if the MD simulation is sufficiently long in time in order to explore the phase space according to the ergodicity principle. The MC simulations are the other great family of statistical simulation methods to determine the equilibrium state of one system in terms of atomic structure and chemical arrangement. Based on the Metropolis algorithm [23], it makes successive random trials modifying the atomic configuration of the system following a Markov
4.2 Theoretical Models and Numerical Simulations
chain. The probability of acceptance of a given configuration is defined by a Boltzmann canonical distribution PðCÞ / eEC =kt
ð4:18Þ
and the probability of transition from one initial configuration C to a final one C0 is defined by n o PðC0 Þ ð4:19Þ WðC ! C0 Þ ¼ min 1; ¼ min 1; eðEC0 EC Þ=kT PðCÞ which means that the new configuration C0 is accepted if its energy is lower than the energy of the initial configuration. If its energy is higher, the new configuration is accepted with the probability eDE=kT . Performing average of the energy over a large quantity of sampled configurations allows to characterize the equilibrium state of the system. 4.2.3 Definitions of Physical Quantities
The pertinent physical quantities used in order to describe the state of the system are essentially the defect energies extended to surfaces, interfaces, adatoms, vacancies or impurities, the surface stress, and the local pressure or stress on an atomic site. The defect energy (surface, interface, and adsorption) is defined by the cost in energy of the system with the defect in the final state compared to the equivalent system without defect in the initial state, normalized by the number of atoms concerned with this kind of defect (Nnorm ). The initial and final states are represented schematically in Figure 4.1. The defect energy is written as Edefect ¼
Efinal Einitial Nnorm
ð4:20Þ
The term equivalent means notably that we keep the same number of atoms and the same nature of atoms in the final and the initial state. In that way, the surface energy is defined by the cost in energy to separate a bulk in two pieces creating a surface on each side. It is given by c¼
Eslab NEcoh 2Nsurf
ð4:21Þ
where Eslab is the energy of a system of N atoms with periodic conditions in two directions and no periodic condition in the third direction (see Figure 4.2). The slab is constituted of p layers of Nsurf atoms on each, which leads to two surfaces of Nsurf atoms. Ecoh is the cohesion energy. The interface energy writes b¼
A B Eslab N A Ecoh N B Ecoh A B Nsurf þ Nsurf
ð4:22Þ
j89
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
90
Figure 4.1 Schematic representation of the creation of surfaces, interface, and adatoms adsorption on a surface in final state compared to an equivalent system in initial state. Nnorm gives the relevant number of atoms to normalize the defect energy. A B A where Ecoh and Ecoh are the cohesion energies of the two materials and N A (Nsurf ) and B B N (Nsurf ) are the number of A or B atoms in total (or at the surface). The adhesion energy is slightly different from the interface energy as the initial state is composed of two slabs of A and B with their respective surfaces. Then, it is written as
W¼
A B Eslab Eslab Eslab A B Nsurf þ Nsurf
ð4:23Þ
The adsorption energy of Nads adatoms, for a coverage y ¼ Nads =Nsurf , is written as Eads ¼
y y¼0 Eslab Eslab mNads Nads
ð4:24Þ
where m is the atomic potential (energy in the gas phase).
z
y x
Figure 4.2 Schematic view of a slab used in numerical simulation to represent a surface (in fact, two surfaces).
4.3 Relaxations in Surfaces and Interfaces
Then, we can also determine the vacancy energy in a system of N atoms: ðN1Þ
Ev ¼ Eslab
ðN1Þ ðNÞ Eslab N
ð4:25Þ
And finally the solution energy of an atom B in a matrix of A is written as AðBÞ
Esol
AðBÞ
A ¼ Eslab þ mA Eslab mB
ð4:26Þ
where the initial state is a slab of A and one atom of B and the final state, the same slab where one A atom has been replaced by a B atom and the A atom in gas phase. The surface stress is a quantity related to the stress tensor in bulk but which concerns the surface. A thermodynamic definition is given by M€ uller and Sa ul [24] on the basis of an interfacial excess quantity. Choosing the z-axis as the normal of the surface, the surface stress tensor is symmetric and comprises only two nonzero components: s xx and s yy . with the The Shuttleworths equation links the surface stress component s surf ij surface energy c ssurf ¼ ij
1 @ðcAÞ @c ¼ c0 @ij þ A @eij @eij
ð4:27Þ
where A is the surface area and c0 the surface energy of the initial surface (before the deformation). The local pressure, in an atomistic model, represents the pressure localized on each atomic site. It corresponds to the trace of the stress tensor P¼
1X sij 3 i
ð4:28Þ
It derives from the energy of the system using the definition of the hydrostatic pressure as given by Kelires and Tersoff [25]: Pi ¼
rij dEi dEi ¼ d ln Vi 3 drij
ð4:29Þ
where Ei is the energy of the system at site i, Vi is the atomic volume, and rij is the distance between the atom at site i and their neighbors j.
4.3 Relaxations in Surfaces and Interfaces
Surfaces and interfaces are the place of atomic relaxations because of the modification in the local environment of the atoms located at the surface (broken bonds) or at an interface (change in the nature and the distances of near neighbors). As a consequence, the surfaces and interfaces can reorganize their structure in order to minimize their energy, leading to surface reconstruction or interfacial dislocations.
j91
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
92
We will consider in the following examples of surface reconstruction, surface with foreign adsorption (alloy surfaces), and heteroepitaxial thin films. 4.3.1 Surface Reconstructions
Because of the broken bonds at the surface, the interatomic distances of the surface atoms are modified as compared to the ones in the bulk. For example, it is well known that the metallic surfaces undergo an inward relaxation that is well reproduced by many-body potentials [26] at the difference of the pair potentials that give essentially an outward relaxation. Sometimes, the surface atoms can even reorganize their structure in order to minimize the surface energy. It is the case for the well-known gold(111) herringbone reconstruction [27, 28] as displayed by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) pictures in Figure 4.3. Such reconstruction is well explained using a 2D Frenkel–Kontorova model by a spontaneous formation of stress domains including long-range elastic interactions [28]. We will concentrate here on another surface reconstruction, the (1 2) missing row reconstruction that concerns the (110) surface of the 5d transition metals. In the S. Oliviers thesis, directed by A. Saùl in Marseille [29], the author studied theoretically the influence of the stress on metallic surface reconstruction. The author first calculated in ab initio the surface energy gain to reconstruct the (1 2) (110) surface into the missing row (1 2) structure. The author found as illustrated in Figure 4.4 that only the 5 d Ir, Pt, and Au metals reconstruct (Dc < 0) in good agreement with the experiments. Then, the author wanted to determine a criterion, beyond the energetic one that supposes to know the final reconstructed structure, in order to predict if the surface is susceptible or not to undergo the reconstruction. The author performed a detailed description of the surface stress tensor of the unreconstructed surface as compared to the reconstructed one. As mentioned before, the z
Figure 4.3 Figures reproduced from Barth et al. [27].
4.3 Relaxations in Surfaces and Interfaces
100
Δγ(1x2 – 1x1)
50
US 0
mJ/m2
TM
–50
–100
–150
Pt
Au
Ir
Pd
Ag
Figure 4.4 Surface energy difference between the (1 2) (110) reconstructed surface and the (1 1) (110) surface for the late-transition metals calculated using the density functional theory and the PWSCF (Plane-Wave
Cu
Rh
Ni
Self-Consistent Field) code [30] with a slab of 12 atomic planes (diamonds) or a slab of 18 atomic planes (circles and continuous line). Reproduced from Ref. [29].
components are necessarily vanished by definition at the surface and there are only the s xx and s yy that are nonzero. Looking for a general criterion to separate the 3d and 4d metals (which do not reconstruct) from the 5d metals (which do reconstruct), the author first considered general tendencies as observed on other types of surfaces. For example, the Au(111) surface has the tendency to densify in the herringbone reconstruction, in order to compensate the lack of bonds. But this is clearly not the case here as the surface suppresses itself some rows leading to an even more open surface. Then, the author researched if the reconstruction was a way to release the surface stress as compared to the unreconstructed surface. The results show no clear difference in behavior between the 5d metals and the others, and even some possible increase in some surface stress components on the reconstructed surface. So, such criterion, which is not necessarily sufficient, but can be sufficient in some cases as we will see hereafter, is not a good criterion in that case. The best criterion the author obtained comes from the derivation of the surface energy as a function of the strain; in other words, the Shuttleworth equation as expressed before. In the graph of Figure 4.5, we see how the 5d metals are well separated from other transition metals, in order to discriminate the metals with tendency to reconstruct the (110) surface. Finally, it has also been checked that the driving force for this reconstruction comes from the electronic structure and in particular the relativistic effects in what concerns the 5d transition metals.
j93
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
94
100 75
Ni
50
Δγ(1×2 – 1×1)
25
Rh
Cu
0
Pd
Ag
–25 –50
Ir Au
–75 –100 –125
Pt
–150 –175 –200 –1000 –500
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500 3000
δγ/δε××, 1×1 Figure 4.5 Same as Figure 4.4 for a slab of 18 atomic planes but plotted as a function of the derivative of the surface energy as a function of the deformation in the x-direction, in the unreconstructed (1 1) structure. Reproduced from Ref. [29].
4.3.2 Surface Alloys: a Simple Case of Heteroatomic Adsorption
The adsorption of Ag atoms on a surface of Cu(111) leads to interesting superstructures because of the strong size mismatch. The first modelization of an Ag monolayer deposited on Cu(111) substrate by quenched molecular dynamics simulation in the TB-SMA potential (as described in Section 1.1.2) showed that the system adopts a p(10 10) superstructure in good agreement with low-energy electron diffraction (LEED) experiments [31]. The atomistic simulations show beyond the periodicity an original motif with a strong corrugation of the surface layer extended in the substrate on the first 10 surface layers [32]. This corrugation is well illustrated by the local pressure map as depicted in Figure 4.6a and b, where the gray scale represents the pressure scale from tensile zones (in white) to black zones (in black). Such picture is directly comparable to the atomic elevation map of the Ag surface atoms (see Figure 4.7a) and the STM image [33] (Figure 4.7b). However, the STM images suggest other possible structures because of the bright atoms inside the dark triangles. Such STM picture is better represented with a structure where four or five atoms have been removed in the Cu layer in order to release the local pressure in compression to the Cu layer (Figure 4.6b without Cu vacancies: we observe black zones in compression that disappear with the introduction of Cu vacancies in Figure 4.6d). In that case, the stress release by the introduction of Cu vacancies consisting in the formation of partial dislocation loops is a way not only to reduce the local pressure but
4.3 Relaxations in Surfaces and Interfaces
Figure 4.6 Local pressure maps in the Ag (a) and (c) and Cu (b) and (d), layers for the (10 10) superstructure of Ag/Cu(111), without (a) and (b) and with five Cu vacancies (c) and (d). The gray scale is chosen such that the white/black atoms are the most tensile/
compressed ones with the following extreme values: In the Ag layer, Pmin ¼ 88 kbar and Pmax ¼ 19 kbar; and in the Cu layer Pmin ¼ 77 kbar and Pmax ¼ 84 kbar. Adapted from Ref. [32].
Figure 4.7 Height elevation maps in the Ag layer of the Ag/Cu(111) (10 10) superstructure (a) and with five vacancies (c). Black and white colors are associated with the
deepest and highest elevations with the typical extreme values: Hmin ¼ 0.033 nm, and Mmax ¼ 0.075 nm; adapted from Ref. [32] In (b) we recall the STM image from Ref. [33].
j95
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
96
also to minimize the surface energy leading to the stabilization of a new superstructure in perfect agreement with STM observations. 4.3.3 Heteroepitaxial Thin Films
The last example of extended surface and interface is taken from a thin metallic film epitaxially grown on a MgO(100) substrate. Obviously, we do not consider the growth mode but only the structure of the film in a state we will consider as an equilibrium state. Such system has been both experimentally [34, 35] and theoretically studied [36], and here again the confrontation of the two approaches is stimulating. In that case, we also compared the atomistic approach with the continuous elastic theory to see to which extent the analytical elastic theory can be used. In that system, as previously, the size mismatch leads to a deformation of the deposit that prefers to rearrange by introducing interfacial dislocations in order to release the elastic deformation. The difference with the preceding case is that the MgO(100) substrate is rigid (an approximation of our model), which prevents any deformation (or even vacancy formation) in the substrate. However, because of the different nature of the two materials (a metal and an oxide), such hypothesis is legitimate in a first approximation, but we should go beyond in further studies using a new energetic model for the oxide and the metal–oxide interaction. The metal is modeled within the TB-SMA as in the preceding case and the oxide is kept rigid, as mentioned above. The metal–oxide interaction is modeled via a potential energy surface approach fitted on ab initio calculations [37]. When considering a thin film of Ag on epitaxy on the MgO(100) substrate, the minimum energy structure corresponds to a partially relaxed film with interfacial dislocations, whose periodicity depends slightly on the film thickness. Figure 4.8 illustrates the propagation of the stress across a 20 monolayer (ML) film starting from the interface with the MgO(100) substrate where are located the core of the dislocations, up to the surface that we can see with a top view. We can distinguish the compressive zones in red and tensile zones in blue. Such motif at the surface is susceptible to change as a function of the film thickness, as shown in Figure 4.9, where thinner films display smaller motifs. In this figure, we also compare the stress profile using an elastic model and the atomistic model. In conclusion, we notice that the two models reach their best agreement for the thicker film (20 ML), where the elastic model is almost as precise as the atomistic model. For 7 and 5 ML, the agreement is still good, far from the dislocation core, but we clearly see that the elastic model fails to describe the stress on top of the dislocation core, which is not so surprising taking into account the approximations of the model. Finally, let us mention the experimental study by grazing incidence small-angle X-ray scattering [34] that shows the self-organization of Co nanoparticles on a silver surface patterned by a buried dislocation network, which is a nice confirmation of what we have obtained in theory. Moreover, by calculating the adsorption energy of one Co atom on top of different sites on the nanostructured Ag surface, we show a clear correlation between the stress corrugation and the amplitude of the adsorption
4.3 Relaxations in Surfaces and Interfaces
Figure 4.8 Top view and side view in the (010) plane of the atomic stress map of the Ag nanostructured film. Color code from red (dark) to blue (light) corresponds to compressive to
tensile atomic sites. Because of its exponential decay, the stress field at the top surface is barely visible and, hence, a different color scale has been used. Adapted from Ref. [34].
Figure 4.9 Top panel represents the map of the surface atomic stress (same color code as Figure 4.8) for different film thicknesses. Bottom panel gives the corresponding stress
graph along the [100] direction (x ¼ y). Circles for the atomistic calculations and full lines for the elastic theory calculations. Adapted from Ref. [36].
j97
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
98
1 20 ML 10 ML
σsurf (GPa)
0.5 0 −0.5 −1 0.04
0
0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0.8
1
ΔE
Co ads
(meV)
0.02 0.00 −0.02 −0.04 −0.06
0.4 0.6 (x=y)/Λ along [100]
Figure 4.10 Surface atomic stress (top graph) and adsorption energy of a Co atom for different film thicknesses: 10 ML (circles) and 20 ML (squares) along the [100] direction (x ¼ y). L is the length of the nanostructure.
energy (Figure 4.10), which is a good indication of the probable nucleation and growth of Co nanoparticles on it.
4.4 Relaxations in Nanoclusters
Because of their surface, nanoparticles undergo a surface stress in tension that is compensated by a core stress in compression leading to a total pressure equal to zero, as long as the nanoparticles are free from interaction with the exterior (under ultravacuum conditions). Their equilibrium shape respects the Wulff theorem up to quite small sizes if we include the edges and the corner energies in the Wulff description, as we have checked by comparing the results given by atomistic calculations and the thermodynamic approach [38]. As a function of their size, when the size becomes sufficiently small, they can change in structure in order to minimize the surface energy when the internal core pressure is not so high compared to the surface energy gain. The main result of the comparative study using thermodynamic and atomistic approach [38] is that not only edge effects but also mainly surface stress effects leading to a Laplace overpressure inside the particle have to be taken into account in order to validate the Wulff theorem for sizes smaller than 10 nm.
4.4 Relaxations in Nanoclusters
j99
In the following, we will see the example of Pd-free nanoclusters and the possibility of stress release by vacancy introduction. As most of the nanoparticles are deposited on a support or included in a matrix, we will study the effect of the cluster environment on the structure and morphology of nanoparticles. We concentrate here on the case of metallic nanoparticles supported on a MgO(100) substrate. Finally, we will consider the alloy effect on bimetallic nanoclusters (called nanoalloys) where the misfit between the two elements is at the origin of the stabilization of new structures that does not exist in pure systems. 4.4.1 Free Nanoclusters
It is well known that nanoparticles, and especially metallic nanoparticles, undertake new structures and notably the fivefold symmetry as their size decreases [39, 40]. This change in structure at small size results from an optimization of their surface by minimization of the surface energy forming only pseudo (111) facets in the icosahedral structure, whereas the fcc truncated octahedron, which is the optimized morphology taking into account the Wulff theorem, displays necessarily both (100) and (111) facets (see Figure 4.11). As the (111) facet is more dense, its surface energy is lower than more open (100) facet. However, the structural transformation from face-centered cubic (FCC) structure to fivefold symmetry structure is accompanied by an internal strain as illustrated in Figure 4.11. In this figure, the three morphologies are displayed with the two FCC ones and the icosahedron one. The first FCC structure
Cuboctahedron
Wulff polyhedron
Vacancy formation energy
Atomic shells pressure
Energy
3
1.7
1.6
1.5 0
5
10
15
20
Ev(core)/Ev(bulk)
800
Pd
Pressure (Kbar)
Energy (eV/at.2/3)
Icosahedron
Pd 600 400 200 0 200 0
N1/3 Figure 4.11 Energy, atomic shell pressure, and vacancy formation energy of Pd clusters under three different structures schematically represented: the cuboctahedron, the Wulff polyhedron, and the icosahedron. Their energy is compared with open blue circles for
5
10
N1/3
15
20
Pd 2 1 0 –1 –2 0
5
10
N1/3
cuboctahedra, open black squares for the Wulff polyhedra, and red diamonds for icosahedra. The local pressure and vacancy formation energy are calculated for cuboctahedra and icosahedra only because they have exactly the same number of atoms to be compared.
15
20
j 4 Relaxations on the Nanoscale: An Atomistic View by Numerical Simulations
100
is the cuboctahedron that has the same number of atoms as the icosahedron, each (100) facet is transformed in two (111) facets leading to 20 pseudo (111) facets in the icosahedral structure. This structure has six fivefold symmetry axis crossing two vertices. The second FCC structure is called the Wulff polyhedron because it optimizes the extension of the facets according to the Wulff construction that links the surface energy to the distance of the facet to the center of the particle. The extension of the (111) facets and the reduction of the (100) ones in the Wulff polyhedron compared to the cuboctahedron makes the Wulff polyhedron much more stable. The energy per cluster is reported in Figure 4.11 and we notice that the icosahedron is stable only at very small size. The critical size of transition from one structure to another is very sensitive to the metal itself and the icosahedron is stable on a larger range of size in Cu [40]. Looking at the local pressure on each concentric layer of the icosahedron as compared to the cuboctahedron (Figure 4.11), we clearly see that the icosahedron is highly compressed in its core whereas the equivalent cuboctahedron undergoes only a slight tension/compression at the vicinity of the surface, with an oscillating profile in order to cancel the total pressure