BW2003 WORKSHOP
Mathematical, Theoretical and Phenomenological Challenges Beyond the Standard Model Perspectivesof the Balkan Collaborations
This page intentionally left blank
BW2003 WORKSHOP
Mathematical, Theoretical and Phenomenological Challenges Beyond the Standard Model Perspectives of the Balkan Collaborations Vrja&a Banja, Serbia and Montenegro 29 August - 3 September 2003
Editors
G. Djordjevic L. Nesic University of Nis, Serbia and Montenegro
J. Wess Ludwig-Maximillianss University University & Max Planck Institute, Germany
World Scientific NEW JERSEY * LONDON * SINGAPORE BElJlNG * SHANGHAI * HONG KONG - TAIPEI BANGALORE
Published by
World Scientific Publishing Co. Re. Ltd.
5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-PublicationData A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
MATHEMATICAL, THEORETICAL AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL CHALLENGES BEYOND THE STANDARD MODEL Perspectives of the Balkan Collaborations Copyright 0 2005 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Re. Ltd
All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof; may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay acopying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN 981-256-130-7
Printed in Singapore by World Scientific Printers (S)Pte Ltd
V
Preface The Balkan Workshop (BW2003): Mathematical, Theoretical and Phenomenological Challenges Beyond the Standard Model - PERSPECTIVES OF BALKAN COLLABORATIONS - was held from 29 August to 2 September 2003, in VrnjaEka Banja, Serbia, right after the Fifth General Conference of the Balkan Physical Union (BPU5). The main purpose of the workshop was to foster the communication among the researchers in the Balkan region as well as between their international colleagues. This meeting created the opportunity for the researchers working in the general area of high energy physics (HEP) a t different institutions in the Balkan countries to present their work and results. It stands as a logical and natural extension of “Wissenschaftler in globaler Verantwortung (WIGV)” - Scientists in global responsibility initiative - an initiative for the advancement of the scientific contact between Germany and the countries which have emerged from the former Yugoslavia. As expected, a creative and supportive environment facilitated the establishment of new, closer collaborative ties as well as strengthening of the existing regional and interregional collaborations. Attendance of about 50 participants from 17 countries has encouraged closer contacts and cooperation between their faculties, universities and institutions, initiating an exchange of scientific personnel and enabling joint applications for support and participation in international projects. We expect that this scientific integration will have a positive influence on the society in the Balkan/Southeast Europe countries, in general. Between many topics considered during the workshop, we emphasized on: strings and superstrings; supersymmetry and conformal field theory; noncommutative, gauge and string field theories; D-branes and matrix models; cosmology, quantum gravity, extra dimensions, grand unification; particle physics, neutrino physics and various aspect of noncommutative, q-deformed and nonarchimedean models. A few rather poor mathematical topics, but also related to the main scope of the meeting, e.g. integrability of some mechanical systems, were also considered. The invited lectures, ten of which were presented in this volume, gave an excellent review of the “hot” topics in theoretical HEP, Q F T and cosmology. We believe that many readers of this book, as well as the young PhD students who attended the workshop, will benefit a lot from this assembly of excellent papers.
vi
Shorter and more topical papers of other lecturers cover many of all actual problems in theoretical and mathematical problems in HEP. That highlighted the interest of researchers from this region as well as of from about 15 participants from West Europe (mainly from Germany), USA, Russia and South America. In total, more than 80% of the speakers sent their contribution; we would like to thank them for this huge collection. Regrettably, a written document cannot record the stimulating atmosphere and the fruitful informal discussions that took place during lunches and coffebreaks, as well as during a visit to the Serbian orthodox monasteries from Middle Ages, located near VrnjaEka Banja We would like to thank Dragoljub Dimitrijevic for great help in preparing this proceedings. Kind help of Frank Mayer is also warmly acknowledged. We would like to thank also World Scientific Publishing Company (especially to Lance Sucharov, Katie Lydon and Rhaimie Wahap) for their goodwill and interest in publishing this proceedings. Goran Djordjevib LjubiSa NeSi6 Julius Wess NiS, Munich, September 2004
vii
Advisory Committee A. Albrecht (Davis) G. Altarelli (CERN) I. Antoniadis (CERN) E. Arik (Istanbul) TBC C. Bachas (Paris) J . Bagger (Baltimore) S. Bellucci (Frascati) S. Dimopoulos (Stanford) J . Ellis (CERN) B. Guberina (Zagreb) R. Jackiw (MIT) J . Louis (Halle) D. Luest (Berlin) S. Meljanac (Zagreb) L. Mezincescu (Miami) H. Nicolai (Golm) S. Randjbar-Daemi (ICTP) A. Sen (Allahabad) G. Senjanovic (ICTP) E. Sezgin (Texas AM Univ.) I. Todorov (Sofia) J. Wess (Munich) G. Zoupanos (Athens)
Organizing Committee B. Aneva (Sofia) A. Balaz, (Belgrade) G. L. Cardoso (Berlin) G. Djordjevic (Nis, Munich), chairman V. Dragovic (Belgrade, Trieste) L. Moeller (Munich) Lj. Nesic (Nis) A. Nicolaidis (Thessaloniki) C. Sochichiu (Chisinau, F’rascati)
This page intentionally left blank
List of Participants INRNE, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1784 Sofia Bulgaria
[email protected] Gleb Arutyunov Max-Plank-Institut fuer Gravitationphysik Am Muhlenberg 1, D-14476 Golm, Germany
[email protected] Paolo Aschieri Sektion Physik der Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitat Theresienstr. 37, D-80333 Munchen, Germany
[email protected] Borut Bajc Jozef Stefan Institute, Jamova 39, 1001 Ljubljana Slovenia,
[email protected] Antun Balaz Institute of Physics, P.O.Box 57, 11 001 Belgrade Serbia and Montenegro ant
[email protected] .ac.yu Klaus Behrndt Max-Plank-Institut fuer Gravitationphysik Am Muhlenberg 1, D-14476 Golm, Germany
[email protected] Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade, P.O. Box 368 Maja Buric 11 001 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro majabQphy. bg.ac.yu Institut fur Physik, Humboldt University Gabriel Lopes Cardoso Newtonstrasse 15 D-12489 Berlin, Germany
[email protected] Masud Chaichian Helsinki Institut of Physics, P.O. Box 64, FIN-00014 Helsinki, Finland
[email protected] Dragoljub Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences Dimitrijevic P.O. Box 224, 18000 Nis, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] Dragan Djordjevic Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Sciences P.O. Box 224, 18000 Nis, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] Goran Djordjevic Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences P.O. Box 224, 18000 Nis, Serbia and Montenegro gorandj @junis .ni.ac. yu
Boyka Aneva
ix
X
Berkol Dogan
Vladimir Dragovic
Dan Radu Grigore
Sinisa Ignjatovic
Nemanja Kaloper
Ivan Kostov
Dusko Latas
George Lazarides
Katarina Matic
Alejandra Melfo Aleksandar Mikovic
Alexei Morozov
Bogazici University, Department of Physics, Bebek, 80815 Istanbul, Turkey
[email protected] Mathematical Institute Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts P.O. Box 367, 11001 Beograd, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] Department of Theoretical Physics Inst. Atomic Physics, Bucharest-Magurele MG 6, Romania grigoreQtheor1.theory.nipne.ro Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics Mladena Stojanovica 2, Banja Luka Republic of Srpska, Bosnia and Herzegovina
[email protected] Department of Physics, University of California Davis, CA 95616 USA kaloper @physics.ucdavis .edu Service de Physique Theorique, CNRS-URA 2306 C.E.A-Saclay, F-91 191 Gif-Sur-Yvette, F'rance
[email protected] Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade P.O. Box 368, 11 001 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro lat
[email protected] .ac .yu Physics Division, School of Tehnology Aristotle University of Thessaloniki Thessaloniki GR 54124, Greece
[email protected] Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade P.O. Box 368, 11 001 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] CAT, Universidad de Los Andes, Merida, Venezuela
[email protected] Departamento de Matematica e Ciencias de Computacao Universidade Lusofona de Humanidades e Tecnologias Av. do Campo Grande, 376, 749-024 Lisboa, Portugal
[email protected] State Science Center of Russian FederationInstitute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics
xi
B. Cheremushkinskaja, 25 MOSCOW, 117218, Russia
[email protected] Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences Ljubisa Nesic P.O. Box 224, 18000 Nis, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] Argyris Nikolaidis Theoretical Physics Department University of Thessaloniki 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
[email protected] Bojan Nikolic Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade P.O. Box 368, 11 001 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] .ac.yu Institute for Nuclear Research and Nuclear Energy Todor Popov Bulgarian Academy of Sciences Tsarigradsko Chaussee 72, BG-1784, Sofia, Bulgaria
[email protected]. bg Voja Radovanovic Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade P.O. Box 368, 11 001 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] .ac.yu Riccardo Rattazzi Theoretical Physics Division CERN CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
[email protected] Branislav Sazdovic Institute of Physics P.O.Box 57, 11 001 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] .ac.yu Volker Schomerus Service de Physique Theorique, CEA Saclay F-91191 Gif-sur-Yvette CEDEX, France vschomer @aei-potsdam.mpg .de Goran Senjanovic International Centre for Theoretical Physics Trieste, 34 014, Italy
[email protected] Corneliu Sochichiu INFN - Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati Via E. Fermi 40, 00044 Frascati, Italy Didina Serban
[email protected] Service de Physique Thorique CEA/Saclay - Orme des Merisiers F-91191 Gif-sur-Yvette Cedex, France
[email protected]
xii
Sergei Solodukhin International University Bremen School of Engineering and Science P.O.Box 750561, 28759, Bremen, Germany
[email protected] Jelena Stankovic Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences P.O. Box 224, 18000 Nis, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] Gordan Stanojevic Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences P.O. Box 224, 18000 Nis, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] Harold Steinacket Sektion Physik der Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitat Theresienstr. 37, D-80333 Munchen, Germany
[email protected] Svjetlana Terzic Faculty of Sciences and Mathematics Cetinjski put BB, 81000 Podgorica Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] Rudjer Boskovic Institute Tomislav Terzic Theoretical Physics Division P.O. Box 180, HR-10002 Zagreb, Croatia
[email protected] Helsinki Institut of Physics, P.O. Box 64, FIN-00014 Anca Tureanu Helsinki, Finland
[email protected] Mihai Visinescu Department of Theoretical Physics National Institute of Physics and Nuclear Engineering Magurele, P.O.Box MG-6 76900 Bucharest, Romania
[email protected],ro Marko Vojinovic Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade P.O. Box 368, 11 001 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected]. yu Sektion Physik der Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitat Julius Wess Theresienstr. 37, D-80333 Munchen, Germany
[email protected] Marija Zamaklar International Centre for Theoretical Physics Trieste, 34 014, Italy
[email protected]
...
Xlll
Alexei Zamolodchikov
Laboratoire de Physique Mathematique Universite Montpellier 11, P1. E. Bataillon 34095 Montpellier, France zamolodQLPM .univ-montp2 .fr
Guests Martin Huber
Zvonko Maric
Vladimir Kouzminov
Ilija Savic
Metin Arik
European Physical Society 4 rue des Freres Lumieres F-68200 Mulhouse, France
[email protected] Serbian Academy of Arts and Sciences Knez Mihailova 35, 11001, Belgrade Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] ROSTE Regional Bureau for Science in Europe Palazzo Zorzi, Castello 4930 30122 Venice, Italy
[email protected] Serbian Physical Society Pregrevica 118, 11080 Zemun Serbia and Montenegro
[email protected] Bogazici University, Department of Physics, Bebek, 80815 Istanbul, Turkey
[email protected]
CONTENTS
Preface Organizers and Committees List of Participants Conference Photo
V
vii ix xiv
I. Invited Lectures Integrable Structures in the Gauge/String Corespondence G. Arutyunov
3
Fluxes in M-theory on 7-manifolds: Gz-, SW(3)- and SU(2)-structures K. Behrndt, C. Jeschek
16
Noncommutative Quantum Field Theory: Review and its Latest Achievements M. Chaichian
32
Shadows of Quantum Black Holes N . Kaloper
47
Yukawa Quasi-Unification and Inflation G. Lazarides, C. Pallis
56
Supersymmetric Grand Unification: The Quest for the Theory A . Melfo, G. SenjanoviC
71
Spin Foam Models of Quantum Gravity A . Mikovic'
88
Riemann-Cartan Space-time in Stringy Geometry B. Sazdovic'
94
xv
xvi
Can Black Hole Relax Unitarily? S. N . Solodukhin
109
Deformed Coordinate Spaces Derivatives J. Wess
122
11. Short Lectures Deformed Coherent State Solution to Multiparticle Stochastic Processes B. Aneva
131
Non-Commutative GUTS, Standard Model and C, P, T Properties from Seiberg-Witten Map P. Aschieri
142
152
Seesaw, Susy and SO(10) B. Bajc On the Dynamics of BMN Operators of Finite Size and the Model of String Bits S. Bellucci, C. Sochichiu Divergencies in &expanded Noncommutative Yang-Mills Theory M. BuriC and V. Radovanovic'
162
SU(2)
Heterotic String Compactifications with Fluxes G. L. Cardoso, G. Curio, G. Dall'Agata and D. Lust Symmetries and Supersymmetries of the Dirac-type operators on Euclidean Taub-NUT space I. I. Cotciescu, M. Visinescu Real and pAdic Aspects of Quantization of Tachyons G. S. Djordjevic', Lj. NeSiC Skew-Symmetric Lax Polynomial Matrices and Integrable Rigid Body Systems V. DragoviC, B. GajiC
171
181
186
197
208
xvii
Supersymmetric Quantum Field Theories
220
D. R. Grigore Parastatistics Algebras and Combinatorics
231
T. Popov Noncommutative D-branes on Group Manifolds
241
J . Pawelczyk, H. Steinacker High-Energy Bounds on the Scattering Amplitude in Noncommutative Quantum Field Theory
247
A . Tureanu Many Faces of D-branes: from Flat Space, via AdS to pp-waves
258
M.Zamaklar Abstracts and Titles of Reports not Included in the Volume
269
Acknowledgements Sponsors Statement of intention Epilogue
273 275 277 279
This page intentionally left blank
I. INVITED LECTURES
This page intentionally left blank
INTEGRABLE STRUCTURES IN THE GAUGE/STRING CORRESPONDENCE
G. ARUTYUNOV Max-Planck-Institut fur Gmvitationsphysik Albert-Einstein-Institut Am Muhlenberg 1, 0-14476Potsdam, Germany E-mail:
[email protected] We discuss the integrable structures both of the classical closed string sigma model with the Ads5 x S5 taget space and of the planar maximally supersymmetricYangMills theory. By using the Biicklund transformations we show that in the sector of highly energetic and spinning strings the integrable structures of string and gauge theories match precisely up to two loops.
1. Gauge/String Duality
One of the fundamental questions of modern theoretical physics is the connection between gauge and string theories. In 1997 J. Maldacena conjectured a new surprising relation between gauge theories and strings.l According to the AdS/CFT duality conjecture, certain quantum supersymmetric conformal field theories have a dual formulation in terms of a closed superstring theory on the Anti-de-Sitter (Ads) background. To fully appreciate the non-triviality of this statement we recall that closed string theory contains gravity, and now it appears to have an alternative description in terms of a non-gravitational theory! In this lecture we report on a recent exciting progress towards understanding the fundamental example of the gauge/string dual pair, which involves four-dimensional maximally supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory and type IIB superstring propagating in the Ad& x S5 space-time (the product of a five-dimensional Ads space and a five-sphere). Already a first inspection shows that both theories mentioned above possess the same amount of symmetry, which can be taken as an initial evidence that they indeed might relate to each other in a non-trivial way. However, this reasoning is kinematical, and the real question is whether 3
4
these theories also share the same dynamical features. This is much harder to answer. By duality strongly coupled Yang-Mills theory is equivalent to weakly coupled string and vice versa. Because of a lack of adequate theoretical methods we neither have much insight into the strongly coupled regime of the gauge theory, nor on the structure of the spectrum of strings propagating in a curved space-time. Fortunately, due to so far poorly understood reasons, parts of the gauge and the string spectra, both accessible by existing mathematical tools, seem to allow for a direct comparison. The modern development of the gauge/string duality was initiated by Berenstein, Maldacena and Nastase2 (BMN) who noticed that in a certain (Penrose) limit the corresponding string theory becomes solvable and its excitations can be identified with gauge theory operators of a certain type. Later on it became clear that there exists even a larger sector of string state^^^^^^ which is accessible by semiclassical6 methods. In parallel, the recent advances in gauge theory are due to an important observation that the planar JV = 4 super Yang-Mills theory is integrable in the one-loop approximation7t8 and, very likely, at higher loops as well.g 2. Integrable Structure of Gauge Theory
The maximally supersymmetric SYM theory has the following field content: six scalar fields 42, i = 1,.. . ,6, a vector field A,, and four Majorana fermions $,: where T = 1,.. . ,4. All fields are in the adjoint representation of SU(N). The action is
ri)are ten-dimensional Dirac matrices in the Majorana-Weyl Here (P, representation. In what follows it will be convenient to use the ’t Hooft coupling X = g 2 N as a natural loop counting parameter. The theory we consider is known to be finite, i.e. the beta-function vanishes at any loop order. The absence of scale implies that SYM remains conformal even at the quantum level. Supersymmetry together with conformal invariance are combined in a larger superconformal group known as PSU(2,214), which contains the bosonic subgroup S0(4,2) xSO(6): PSU(2,214) 3 Su(2,2)xSU(4)~z S0(4,2)xSO(6)
5
The basic physical quantities of this theory are the local, gauge-invariant composite operators O ( x ) ,i.e. the operators constructed as products of elementary fields. They transform in unitary irreducible representations of the superconformal group. Therefore, to each operator one can associate scaling (conformal) dimension A, the Lorentz spins s1,sa and three additional Dynkin labels ai related to the internal SU(4) symmetry:
[A,s i , ~ 2a ;i, a2, a31 . These are the quantum numbers associated to any highest weight state (also called a superconformal primary state) of a supersymmetry multiplet. An important class of operators we will be concerned in here is
O ( x )= Tr (@pa$@$) + ...,
@1 =
4’
+ i$2,
etc.
The dots indicate arbitrary orderings of the scalars inside the trace. All such operators realize irrep of SU(4) with labels [J2 - J3, J1 - J2, J2 J3]. Note that these operators are holomorphic and their dimension in free theory is
+
A = J1 + J2 + J3.
In general, due to quantum fluctuations, scaling dimensions get shifted from their classical values and acquire an “anomalous” piece. Conformal primary operator 0 is an eigenstate of the dilatation operator D , which is one of the generators of the conformal algebra, and conformal dimension is its eigenvalue
DO = A(& N ) O , k=O
It should be stressed that the existence of anomalous dimensions is one of the most important concepts of conformal field theory as they constitute the spectrum of the theory. At the same time calculation of anomalous dimensions proved to be one of the hardest problems of quantum field theory. Until recently little was known about the general behaviour of anomalous dimensions in super Yang-Mills theory, see however Ref. 10, 11. The major problem arises, even at one loop, due to the complicated mixing between operators differing by the ordering of the scalars inside the trace. However, for the planar case N = 00, a new very important feature arises:’ The problem of diagonalizing the one-loop dilatation operator becomes equivalent to the problem of finding the spectrum of the so-called XXX Heisenberg magnet, the famous integrable short-range spin chain. Moreover, as was conjectured in Ref. 9, the integrability extends to higher loop orders!
6
To convey the basic idea about the spin chain description of gauge theory we restrict ourselves to the simplest case of operators made of two complex scalar fields
... .
n(a:1!@2Jz+
On the space of renormalized fields {Oi} (here index i labels different orderings of scalars inside the trace) the one-loop dilatation operator acts in the non-diagonal fashion
DOi = AijOj. The mixing matrix with elements Aij encodes the Feynman diagrammatics and its eigenvalues are the scaling dimensions of primary operators. The mapping to the XXX spin chain is constructed by identifying the (a1 and $2 fields with ‘hp” and “down” spins (see Fig.1).
Figure 1. Periodic spin chain. The Hamiltonian H acts as 2 J x 2’ matrix, where J = J1 J2 is the length of the chain. We look for the eigenstates of H in a sector with the total spin fixed.
+
Upon this identification the dilatation operator becomes identical to the Hamiltonian of the spin chain. The importance of this observation is difficult to overestimate. For operators of sufficiently small dimensions the mixing matrix can be diagonalized by hand or by a computer. As its rank grows (especially in the thermodynamic limit we are interested in) this becomes rapidly unfeasible. Fortunately integrability saves the day - there is an efficient method, based on existence of local commuting charges, which allows one to determine the spectrum of the Hamiltonian (and simultaneously the one of all the commuting charges). This is so-called algebraic Bethe Ansatz (see Ref. 12 for a comprehensive review). Let us associate to each lattice cite of the periodic spin chain the following Lax operator
7
Here Sf,S3 are the standard spin operators represented by Pauli matrices and cp is a spectral parameter. Matrix L,(cp) is a 2 x 2 matrix in the auxiliary two-dimensional space. The monodromy around the chain is
Using the fundamental commutation relations between the elements of the monodromy operator one can show that the trace of T(cp) is in fact a generating function of commuting charges 5-2
,
[Qk Q m ]
=0.
k=O
Simultaneous eigenstates of Q k can be found by first defining the vacuum state vacuum state 10) (with all spins “up”)
An eigenstate of
Q k
with M = Jz spins down is given by @M = B(cpl)...B(cpM)R
provided the Bethe roots cpj tions
7
= cp(pj) obey the set of algebraic Bethe equa-
where cp(p) = ;cot(ip). The Bethe equations have a beautiful physical interpretation in terms of quasi-particles, called magnons. The state @ M describes an excitation with M magnons, each of them carrying momentum p j . Thus, the Bethe equations can be viewed as quantization condition for the magnon momenta. The total phase gained by the magnon with momentum p j traveling around the chain of length J is equal to the sum of pairwise phase shifts which arise due to its elastic scattering with other M 1magnons. The factorized scattering is one of the remarkable consequences of complete integrability of the model. Further simplification of the Bethe equations occurs in the thermodynamic limit, which amounts to sending the length of the chain J and the number of magnons M = Jz to infinity while keeping the filling fraction
8
9
a= constant. To perform this limit we present the first equation in (1) in the logarithmic form
2nnj + p j =
where the mode (winding) numbers nj define the branch of the log function. Now one can easily recognize on the r.h.s. of this equation the difference analog of derivative. Therefore, in the large J limit the Bethe equations reduce to
Further we assume that the roots c p j condense onto certain smooth contours -+ cp and that
C in the complex plane of the continuous variable cp:
y
y)
the root distribution is described by a density p(cp) = ~~~1 6 (cp normalized as J " d p p(cp) = a. Taking into account that pj -+ 1 in the %. limit we consider we see that Eqs.(2) transform into a singular integral equation
where nC are mode (winding) numbers which are constant on each smooth component of the density support C. From the point of view of soliton theory the density p(cp) describes the continuous spectrum of the model. Thus, in the thermodynamic limit the discrete eigenvalues of the monodromy matrix (the Bethe roots respectively) condense and form the continuous part of the spectrum. Having found the density one can define the generating function of all local commuting charges Qk (resolvent):
In particular, the eigenvalues of the dilatation operator coincide with the value of the second charge Q2. For the simplest ground state solution13 the one-loop gauge theory resolvent was determined in Ref. 14 and it reads as
9
Here and below K(q), E(q) and II(m2,q ) are the standard elliptic integrals of the first, the second and the third kind respectively; the parameters a and b are a = 1/4K(q), b = a/-. Expanding in cp we find explicit form of the first few charges for the ground state solution:
Q6
26 = T K ( ~ )~ 2(8 - 8q
[
+ 3q2)E(q) + (16 - 24q + 18q2 - 5 q 3 ) K ( q ) ],
The gauge theory modulus q is expressed via the filling fraction a through the following transcendental equation
To conclude, the problem of diagonalizing the one-loop dilatation operator is integrable and can be solved by using the algebraic Bethe Ansatz. The spectrum of the theory is encoded in the resolvent whose explicit form for the ground state is Eq.(3). Now we turn our attention to string theory. 3. Integrable Structure of String Theory
String theory we consider can be described by a non-linear two-dimensional sigma model whose target space is a supersymmetric extension of the bosonic Ad& x S5 space-time. Since the corresponding action is highly non-linear and contains fermions, the quantization problem appears to be extremely complicated; at present the full spectrum of the quantum string is beyond our reach. However certain regions of the quantum spectrum can be well approximated by semiclassical string configurations. Typically these configurations are solutions of the classical string equations of motion (supplemented by the Virasoro constraint), which carry “large” energy and spins. Picking one such solution one can approximately determine the string spectrum by performing a semiclassical quantization around it. Thus, we are led to the problem of studying “spinning” strings,i.e. classical strings rotating in the background space-time with large angular momenta. The bosonic sigma model describing propagation of our classical string is a two-dimensional integrable model which can be thought of as a non-trivial
10
matrix generalization of the famous sine-Gordon equation. The action is a sum of S0(2,4) and SO(6) sigma models
\,.
where
Here
X M , M = l , ..., 6 ,
Y M , M = O ,..., 5
are the the embedding coordinates of R6 with the Euclidean metric in L s and with ~ M = N (-1, +1, +I, +1, +1, -1) in LAds respectively; A and i i are the Lagrange multipliers. What are the relevant spinning string configurations? As in the flat space-time the simplest configurations are those corresponding to rigid strings, i.e. to strings whose shape is independent of time. These configurations carry finite energy and can be viewed as solitons (the so-called finite-zone solutions) of the sigma model. A remarkable fact about these solitonic solutions discovered in Ref. 15 is that they are naturally classified in terms of periodic solutions of the Neumann integrable system. This is a finite-dimensional integrable system describing a three-dimensional harmonic oscillator constrained to move on a two-sphere (or a hyperboloid in the non-compact case). Historically this model, discovered by C. Neumann in 1859, is one of the first examples of a completely integrable Hamiltonian system. To see the appearance of the Neumann system we consider the simplest case: string rotates in S5 and is trivially embedded in Ads5 as Y5 iY0 = einT with Yl,...,Y4 = 0. Ansatz for periodic motion with three non-zero angular momentum components Ji reads as:
+
x1+ ix2 = q ( ~ eiwlT, ) ~3 + i xq = z ~ ( GeiwZT ) , ~5 + i& = ~ ( 0eiwzT ) , where
11
Upon substituting this ansatz into the sigma model evolution equations they reduce to the 1-d ( ''mechanical") model (0is time now !)
which is the Neumann integrable system. If the coordinates xi(.) are complex then one gets16 another integrable system known as the NeumannRosochatius model. It is worth noting that the Neumann system inherits its integrable structure from that of the two-dimensional sigma model. Rigid strings appear to be of two types - folded, with the topology of a rod, and circular, with the topology of a circle (see Fig.2).
Figure 2. Folded and circular rigid strings (generically hyperelliptic three-spin solutions). Elliptic two-spin solutions arise when string stretches along the equator in the ("1,121 plane.
The angular momentum components (spins) are
From here one can determine the frequencies wi in terms of spins Ji: wi = Wi(J1,J 2 , J 3 ) .
The general three spin solutions are described in terms of the hyperelliptic functions. Elliptic two spin solutions arise when x3(0) = 0. Explicitly the two-spin solution corresponding to the folded string can be written in
12
terms of Jacobi elliptic functions q ( c r ) =d n ( o 6 , t)
,
22(cr) =
d?sn(cr&,
t) .
(4)
Since we are dealing with closed strings the coordinates xi(.) must obey the periodicity condition: q ( c r 27r) = zi(a). This leads t o the following equation
+
Solving for w’s in terms of spins
the modulus t is then found from
Ji,
2
4
(&) =gX.
J2
(K(t)-E(tJ2-
As was already mentioned in Sect. 1, the rigid strings provide a simple and useful tool to probe matching of the spectra of gauge and string theories. The rigid two-spin solutions are completely described by two integrals of motion which are the spins J1 and J2. However, when we embed a rigid soliton into the two-dimensional sigma model it inherits from its integrable structure an infinite set of local commuting integrals of motion, all of them appear as the non-trivial functions of J1 and 5 2 . How to compute these integrals and compare with the gauge theory charges discussed in the previous section? This problem was completely solved in Ref. 14, 17. An important technical tool which allows to determine the spectrum of commuting integrals is the so-called Backlund transformations. The Backlund transformations transform one solution, X , of the evolution equations into another one, X ( p ) , and they depend continuously on a (spectral parameter) p:
The generating function of the local commuting charges of the sigma model cx)
k=2
can be obtained from the Backlund solution as follows
+
o and = r - (T are the light-cone coordinates. It is a where [ = r very non-trivial problem to solve the Backlund equations (we refrain from presenting them here) and a general solution is unknown. However, the
13
corresponding Backlund solutions X(y) were found14 starting from either two-spin folded (4) or circular string solitons. We will not go into the further details here and refer the reader to the original The final result for an exact generating function of string commuting charges (for the folded two-spin solution) is:14
and z satisfies
Here w1,2 and t are certain functions of 51, J2. Now we are ready to compare the integrable structures of gauge and string theories. 4. Matching the Spectra of Gauge and String Theories
Resolvent (5) provides the “all-loop” result and to compare with our findings in gauge theory one needs to detect from Eq. (5) the “one-loop” contribution. To this end we consider the slightly modified string theory resolvent
where & ( p ) is determined by Eq. (5). Here the string resolvent is viewed as a function of the rescaled spectral parameter ‘p and the so-called BMN coupling constant
We will refer to p and ‘p as to the string and gauge spectral parameters respectively. Clearly, the Backlund resolvent can be expanded in a double series cn k=O
= Q(l’(‘p)
n,k=O
+
+ X 1 2 Q ( 3 ) ( ‘ p ) + O(A’3).
In particular, the leading term Q(l)(‘p) represent the “one-loop” contribution and should be directly compared to our one-loop gauge theory result W3).
14
A remarkable fact14 is that Q(l)(cp) appears precisely the same (after a certain Gauss-Landen modular transformation which relates the string to the gauge moduli) as the one-loop gauge theory resolvent H(cp) generating the Heisenberg charges: Q q P ) = H(cp). (6) Although derived by using the particular gauge/string theory solutions, this formula is universal and does not depend on particular solutions. It exhibits the matching of the spectra of gauge and string theories at the lowest order of perturbation theory. 5. Discussion In this lecture we confined ourselves to demonstrate the matching of the gauge/string spectra at the one-loop approximation. Recently this relationship between gauge and string theories received further spectacular confirmation. Of course, a question of primary importance is to understand what happens at the higher loop level. Very recently the matching of the spectra of gauge and string theories has been extended to two This became possible due to the important observation18 that the two-loop dilatation operator (and the three-loop as well!) can be emulated by the Hamiltonian of another long-range integrable spin chain known as the Inozemtsev spin chain.22 The situation with the three-loop matching is less clear at p r e s e n t l ’ ~and ~ ~ further work is required to clarify it. It is also interesting to analyze occurrence of finite-dimensional integrable systems inside the two-dimensional string sigma model. The theory of finite zone integration allows one to construct solutions of the original equations of motion starting from the stationary periodic solutions of the hierarchy of the evolution equations generated by the higher Hamiltonians. The stationary solutions themselves should be described in terms of certain finite-dimensional integrable systems (presumably generalizing the Neumann model). One could try to identify them explicitly and relate to the theory of Backlund transformations. Perhaps this would lead t o new insights into the gauge/string duality.
Acknowledgments I would like to thank Goran Djordjevic and all other organizers of the B W2003 Workshop in Vrnjacka Banja (Serbia) in August-September 2003 for an inspiring conference, and their warm hospitality.
15
References 1. J. M. Maldacena, Adw. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 231 (1998), hep-th/9711200. 2. D. Berenstein, J. M. Maldacena and H. Nastase, JHEP 0204, 013 (2002), hepth/0202021. 3. S. Frolov and A. A. Tseytlin, Nucl. Phys. B668, 77 (2003), hep-th/0304255. 4. S. Frolov and A. A. Tseytlin, JHEP 0206, 007 (2002), hepth/0204226. 5. S. F'rolov and A. A. Tseytlin, JHEP 0307, 016 (2003), hepth/0306130. 6. S. S. Gubser, I. R. Klebanov and A. M. Polyakov, Nucl. Phys. B636, 99 (2002), hepth/0204051. 7. J. A. Minahan and K. Zarembo, JHEP 0303, 013 (2003), hep-th/0212208. 8. N. Beisert and M. Staudacher, Nucl. Phys. B670, 439 (2003), hepth/0307042. 9. N. Beisert, C. Kristjansen and M. Staudacher, Nucl. Phys. B664, 131 (2003), hepth/0303060. 10. G. Arutyunov, S. Penati, A. C. Petkou, A. Santambrogio and E. Sokatchev, Nucl. Phys. B643, 49 (2002), hepth/0206020. 11. G. Arutyunov, B. Eden, A. C. Petkou and E. Sokatchev, Nucl. Phys. B620, 380 (2002), hepth/0103230. 12. L. D. Faddeev, hep-th/9605187. 13. N. Beisert, J. A. Minahan, M. Staudacher and K. Zarembo, JHEP 0309, 010 (2003), h e p t h/0306 139. 14. G. Arutyunov and M. Staudacher, JHEP 0403,004 (2004), hep-th/0310182. 15. G. Arutyunov, S. Frolov, J. Russo and A. A. Tseytlin, Nucl. Phys. B671, 3 (2003), hepth/0307191. 16. G. Arutyunov, J. Russo and A. A. Tseytlin, hep-th/0311004. 17. G. Arutyunov and M. Staudacher, Proceedings of the 5th International Workshop on Lie Theory and Its Applications in Physics, Varna, Bulgaria, (2003), hepth/0403077. 18. D. Serban and M. Staudacher, hep-th/0401057. 19. V. A. Kazakov, A. Marshakov, J. A. Minahan and K. Zarembo, h e p th/0402207. 20. M. Kruczenski, hep-th/0311203. 21. M. Kruczenski, A. V. Ryzhov and A. A. Tseytlin, hepth/0403120. 22. V. I. Inozemtsev, Phys. Part. Nucl. 34, 166 (2003); Fiz. Elem. Chast. Atom. Yadra 34, 332 (2003), hepth/0201001.
FLUXES IN M-THEORY ON 7-MANIFOLDS: G2-, SU(3)- AND SU(2)-STRUCTURES
K. BEHRNDT Max-Planck-Institut fur Gravitationsphysik, Albert Einstein Institut A m Muhlenberg 1, 14476 Golm, Germany E-mail: behrndtQaeimpg. de
C. JESCHEK Humboldt Universitat zu Berlin, Institut fur Physik, Newtonstrasse 15, 12489 Berlin, Germany E-mail: jeschekQphysik. hu-berlin. de
We consider compactifications of M-theory on 7-manifolds in the presence of 4form fluxes, which leave at least four supercharges unbroken. Supersymmetric vacua admit G-structures and we discuss the cases of G2-, SU(3)- as well as SU(2)structures. We derive the constraints on the fluxes imposed by supersymmetry and determine the flux components that fix the resulting 4-dimensional cosmological constant (i.e. superpotential).
1. Introduction An essential input in lifting the continuous moduli space might be non-zero fluxes on the internal space. By now one can find a long list of literature about this subject. A starting point was the work by Candelas and Rainel for an un-warped metric which was generalized later in Ref. 2 (for an earlier work on warp compactification see Ref. 3) and the first examples, which preserveN = 1supersymmetry appeared in Ref. 4. The subject was revived around 10 years later by the work of Polchinski and S t r ~ m i n g e rwhere ,~ flux compactifications in type I1 string theory was considered. In the M-theory setting, different aspects are discussed in Refs. 6-14. Fluxes induces a non-trivial back reaction onto the geometry, because for the Killing they appear as specific con-torsion spinor. The resulting spaces are in general non-Kahlerian, which reflects 16
17
the fact that the moduli space is (partly) lifted. In order to see which moduli are fixed, one can deriving the corresponding superpotential as function of the fluxes in a way discussed in Ref. 23, but this approach becomes subtle if the fluxes are not related to closed forms (due to Chern-Simons terms). In this talk we discuss M-theory compactifications in the presence of 4form fluxes, which keep the external 4-d space time maximal symmetric, i.e. either flat or anti deSitter (Ads), where in the latter case the superpotential remains non-zero in the vacuum giving rise to a negative cosmological constant. We start by making the Ansatz for the metric and the 4-form field strength and separate the gravitino variation into an internal and external part. In addition, we have to make an Ansatz for the 11-d Killing spinor, which decomposes into internal 7-d spinors and the external 4-d spinors. In the most general case, the solution will be rather involved and we use G-structure to classify possible vacua (Section 3). These structures are defined by a set of invariant differential forms and are in one to one correspondence to the number of internal spinors, which will enter the 11-d Killing spinor. Using these differential forms, one can formely solve the BPS equations (Section 4), but explicit solutions require the construction of these forms. Note, the case of the G2- and SU(3)-structures have been discussed already before1°-12 and we will be rather short. 2. Warp Compactification in the Presence of Fluxes
In the (flux) vacuum, all Kaluza-Klein scalars and vectors are trivial and hence we consider as Ansatz for the metric and the 4-form field strength
+ habdy"dyb] , P = 5 epLypAdxpA dx" A d x P A d x A + $Fabcd
ds2 = e Z A[ g g d x p d z "
dy" A dyb A dy" A dyd , (1) where A = A ( y ) is a function of the coordinates of the 7-manifold with the metric h a b , m is the Freud-Rubin parameter and the 4-d metric g,$ is either flat or anti deSitter. Unbroken supersymmetry requires the existence of (at least) one Killing spinor 77 yielding a vanishing gravitino variation of 11-dimensional supergravity 0 = dQM = [ a M + 'GRS 4 M rRS where:
+&(rMF-
~ ~ F M ) ] V ,
P E F M N p Q r M N P Q , FM E F M N p Q r N P Q , etC.
Since,
(2)
18
one can bring the variation also in the more common form. Using the convention { F A , r B }= 2vAB with 77 = diag(-, +, + . . . +), we decompose the r-matrices as usual p
L
=y
with p = 0..3, a = 1..7, and .AS&,
- -E,upx^ 1
ra+3 +5
=
= i.$0.$1.$2.$3, 1 = iy1y2y3y4y5y6y7yields €abcdrnnp
ZYY -
(4)
.$58Ya,
abcd
= [a b c d ]
YUPX 7 'YrnnP=Y -7 Y Y Y * (5) 3! 3! The spinors in 11-d supergravity are Majorana and we take all 4-d .$pmatrices are real and T5 as well as the 7-d ya-matrices are purely imaginary and ant isymmet ric. With this notation, we can now split the gravitino variation into an internal and external part. In order to deal with the warp factor, we use 1 ds2 = e2A&2 -+ DM = DM -r i$%vA (6) 2 and find for the external components of the gravitino variation 1 im 1 0 = [V, 8 l F .$,.$5 8 (5 d A -) -e-3A $ ., 8 F ] v , (7) 36 144
+
+
+
7
+
v,
where F = F a b c d Y a b c d , Fa = F a b c d Y b c d , etc. and is the 4-d covariant derivative. In the same way, we get for the internal variation
1 im 1 -ya) - '"j.$'Vp 8 y a - - e-3A .$5 8 Fa]77 , (8) 2 48 4 12 where we eliminated the term N -yaFr] by using Eq. (7). In order to solve these equations, we have to decompose the spinor and introduce the superpotential yielding the negative cosmological constant. The 11-d Majorana spinor can be expanded in all independent spinors as 0 = [W @ (VP' - -aaA
+
N i=l
where and Oi denote the 4- and 7-d spinors, resp. If there are no fluxes, all of these spinors are covariantly constant and N 5 8 gives the resulting extended supersymmetries in 4 dimensions. With non-trivial fluxes one can however impose a relation between the spinors and N does not refer to the number of unbroken supersymmetries (see last Section) , but gives nevertheless a classification of supersymmetric vacua. In fact, with these spinors one can build differential forms that are singlets under a subgroup G c spin(7) and hence define a G-structure, where the number of spinors is directly related to the group G (see next Section). By definition, the spinors
19
are singlets under G and therefore obey certain projector conditions, which annihilate all non-singlet components and, at the same time, can be used to derive simple differential equations for the spinors and constraints on the fluxes (see last Section). If the 4-d spinors are covariantly constant, the resulting vacuum will be a 4-d flat space, but for an anti deSitter vacuum the spinors satisfy
V,€i
N
-i;(W,ij + i T 5 W?) €j .
(9)
Note, the resulting 4-d cosmological constant will be: -IWI2 and we did not take into account a Kahler potential, i.e., our superpotential will not be holomorphic. If there is only a single spinor this equation simplifies to
V,E
N
9, (Wl + i=y5W2)€ ,
and if E is a Weyl spinor it becomes V,E = +,eKI2 WE*with the complex superpotential W = W1 + i W2. If ~i are a set of Weyl spinors, we introduce the superpotential by a 11-d spinor satisfying the equation
[ V , @ F ] q = (T,@W)ij
with:
fj=Wij~i@f?ej*+cc.
(10)
This way of introducing the superpotential might be confusing. Recall, we set constant all 4-d scalars as well as vector potentials and hence the superpotential should just be a number fixing the cosmological constant for the given vacuum. Since we introduced the superpotential in the 11-d Killing spinor equation it will, on the other hand, depend on the fluxes and the warp factor and thus it is in general not constant over the internal space. The correct 4-dimensional superpotential is of course obtained only after a Kaluza-Klein reduction, i.e. after an integration over the internal space and to make this clear we will denote this constant superpotential by W(O).We do not want to discuss issues related to a concrete Kaluza-Klein reduction (over a not Ricci-flat internal space) and want instead determine the flux components that are responsible for a non-zero value of W(O) 3. G-Structures Supersymmetric compactifications on 7-manifolds imply the existence of differential forms, which are singlets under a group G c spin(7) and which define G-structures.a These globally defined differential forms can be constructed as bi-linears of the internal Killing spinors as f?i-Yq...a,f?j,
follow here basically the procedure initiated in the recent discussion by Ref. 17
20
and the group G is fixed by the number of independent spinors 8i which are all singlets under G. E.g. if there is only a single spinor on the 7manifold, it can be chosen as a real G2 singlet; if there are two spinors, one can combine them into a complex SU(3) singlet; three spinors can be written as Sp(2) N SO(5) singlets and four spinors as SU(2) singlets. Of course, all eight spinors cannot be a singlet of a non-trivial subgroup of SO(7) and G is trivial. The 7-dimensional y-matrices are in the Majorana representation and satisfy the relation: ( Y ~ ~ . . . ~=, (-) ) ~ 2 T ~ ~ . . . ~which ,, implies that the differential form is antisymmetric in [i,j ] if n = 1,2,5,6 and otherwise symmetric [we assumed here of course that Bi are commuting spinors and the external spinors are anti-commuting]. This gives the wellknown statement that having only a single spinor, one cannot build a vector or a 2-form, but only a 3-form and its dual 4-form [the 0- and 7-form exist trivially on any spin manifold]. If we have two spinors 6'11p), we can build one vector and one 2-form (and of course its dual 5- and 6-form). Since the spinors are globally well-defined, also the vector field is well defined on X, and it can be used to obtain a foliation of the 7-d space by a 6manifold X 6 . Similarly, having three 7-spinors we can build three vector fields as well as three 2-forms and having four spinors the counting yields six vectors combined with six 2-forms. In addition to these vector fields and 2-forms, one obtains further 3-forms the symmetrized combination of the fermionic bi-linears. We have however to keep in mind, that all these forms are not independent, since Fierz re-arrangements yield relations between the different forms, see Refs. 9, 17 for more details. Using complex notation, we can introduce the following two sets of bilinears [et = (e*)T]:
Ra ,... a k = Oty,,...,,8
and
= 8T
yal...ak8,
where dropped the index i , j which counts the spinors. The associated k-forms becomes now
ak = k!1
and
- ~ ~ ~ . . . ~ ~ e ~ l . " ~ k
1 fik = -f22,1...akea1"'ak. k!
(11)
If the spinors are covariantly constant the group G coincides with the holonomy of the manifold. If the spinors are not covariantly constant, then neither can be these differential forms and the deviation of G from the holonomy group is measured by the intrinsic torsion. In the following we will discuss the different cases in more detail.
21
3.1. G z Strtdures In the simplest case, the Killing spinor is a G2 singlet and reads O = e z6 0 ,
Or
(12)
where is a normalized real spinor. Due to the properties of the 7-d y-matrices (yielding especially OFyaOo = 0), only the following differential forms are non-zero
1 = O,TOo
,
T i f a b c d m n p = 60 TabcdmnpOO .
They are G2-invariant since 00 is a G2 singlet, i.e. it obeys the appropriate projector constraints. Note, the Lie algebra 50(7) is isomorphic to A' and a reduction of the structure group on a general X7 from SO(7) to the subgroup G2 implies the following splitting: SO(7) =
82
@ 8;
.
(14)
This induces a decomposition of the space of 2-forms in the following irreducible G2-modules, R2 = A;
(15)
@
where
A; = {
T X T }= { a E A'I
U J ~ ~E U
Af4 = {Q E A2 I * ('p A-Q) + a = 0)
* ( ~ A - Q-)2 a = 0 } , 82,
with the abbreviation u 1'p = umpmnpand 'p denotes the G2-invariant 3index tensor, which is expressed as fermionic bi-linear in (13). The operator *(pA a ) splits the 2-forms correspondingly to the eigenvalues 2 and -1. These relations serve us to define the orthogonal projections P , onto the k-dimensional spaces:
where .II, = *p. To be concrete, the Gz-singlet spinor satisfies the condition
22
which is equivalent to
,
Tab80 = @abcyc80 Tabcf% = ('@abc TabcdeO =
+ $abcdT d)
(18)
60
( - $abed - 4ip[abcTd])eO 7
where the second and third conditions follow from the first one. These relations can now be used to re-cast the Killing spinor equations into constraints for the fluxes and differential equations for the warp factor as well as the spinor 8. In the generic situation this spinor is not covariantly constant, which reflects the fact that fluxes deform the geometry by the gravitational back reaction. This can be made explicit by rewriting the flux terms as con-torsion termsb v,e = (v, - -41T , ~ " T ~ ~=) oo . Fkom the symmetry it follows that T has 7 x 21 = 7 x (7+ 14) components, but if €J is a G2-singlet the 14 drops out and hence T E A1 @ gi. These components decompose under G2 as
49 = 1 -t- 7
+ 14 + 27 = + + + 7 2 7 , 77
71
714
where ~i are called G2-structures. Since the Killing spinors define p and $, these torsion classes can be obtained from d p and d$ as follows
d p E A4 = A; @ A$ @
d$ E R5 = A$
@
Ai7 , (19)
A:, ,
where the 7 in A$ is the same as in A: up to a multiple. For a general 4-form 0, the different projections are
R(P) =
P
7
W P ) = -&-l P ,
(20)
p27(P)ab = $ ( P c d e { a $ b } C d e ) O
7
where in (-)O we removed the trace. Thus, the different components in the differentials d p can be obtained from dl)
--
where 714 and
1d p
*d$ 727
-
--
,
$(*d$) J ?I,
d7) ,
have to satisfy:
7(27)
93 A
p-1dp,
(dpcde{a$b}cde)O
(21) 7
Az7 = 9 3 A 714 = 0.
bThere is also an ongoing discussion in the mathematical literature, see Ref. 24.
23
3.2. SU(3) Structures Having a G = SU(3), one can find two singlet spinors on X 7 , which are equivalent to the existence of a vector field v. This in turn can be used to combine both spinors into one complex spinor defined as
where the constant spinor 00 is again the Gz singlet and Z is now a complex function. The vector w is globally well-defined and gives a foliation of X7 by a 6-manifold X S and both spinors, 6 and its complex conjugate 8*, are chiral spinors on x6. In this case, we have to distinguish between the forms R and fi as defined in (11) and findlo-12
and all other forms are zero or dual to these ones. The associated 2-form to the almost complex structure on x6 is w and with the projectors (W f i w ) we can introduce (anti) holomorphic indices so that R(370)can be identified as the holomorphic (3,0)-form on XG. There exists a topological reduction from a Gz-structure to a SU(3)-structure (even to a SU(2)-structure). The difficulties arise by formulating the geometrical reduction. Using the vector v the explicit embedding of the given SU(3)-structure in the Gz-structure is:
i
with the compatibility relations e-ZiIm(Z) o ( 3 , O ) A w =
(x+ + i X - ) A w
=0,
24
Now, the projectors (18) for
80
imply for the complex 7-d in ( 2 2 )
+ v a + i'fabcvb'YC)eO , T a b 6 = 5 ( i ( p a b c y c + i(pabcVc + '$abcdvcYd 2 v [ a Y b ] ) e O, 'Yabce = $ ( i ( p a b c + '$abcdYd + 3 i v [ a ( p b c ] d Yd - '$abcdvd 4'&'[abcYd]Vd)eO , 'Yabcde = $(-'$abed - 4'@[abcYd] - 5'$[abcd'Ye]ve 'Yae
=
ez
z ( Y a
-
-
'Yabcdee Yabcdefe
=
5
-4iv[a(pbcd] (-5'$,[abcd'Ye]
= L(-.
ZEabcdefgY'
- 4v[a'$bcd]eYe)e0 - i&abcdefgYgvf
7
- 5v[a'$bcde]
+ EabcdefgvhYj(pghi
- 2 o i v [ a ( p b c d ' Y e ] ) ~ ,O
- i & a b c d e f g v g )00
*
Again, these relations can be used to rewrite the Killing spinor equations in terms of constraint equations- for the fluxes and a differential equation for the warp factor as well as the spinor. The corresponding torsion componentsz5 are now related to the differential equation obeyed by the forms: v,w , R and their dual. As next case one would consider S P ( 2 ) structures implying three (real) singlet spinors. An example is a 7-d 3-Sasaki-space (i.e. the cone yields an 8-d Hyperkahler space with Sp(2) holonomy), with the Aloff-Walach space N1il as the only regular examplesz6 (apart from S7);non-regular examples are in Ref. 27. We leave a detailed discussion of this case for the future and investigate instead the S U ( 2 ) case in more detail.
3.3. SU(2) Structures On any 7-d spin manifold exist three no-where vanishing vector fieldsz8, which implies that one can always define SU(2) structures. The corresponding four (real) spinors can be combined in two complex S U ( 2 ) singlet spinors O 1 p . The three vector fields v,, a = 1 , 2 , 3 can be chosen as Vl = e
1 1
212
= e
2
,
'u3
= (p(Ul,V2),
and they parameterize a fibration over a 4-d base space X,.The embedding of the S U ( 2 ) into the Ga structures is then given by
Since the vector fields are no-where vanishing, we can choose them of unit norm and perpendicular to each other, i.e. ( v , , v ~ ) = hap, and using the 3-form (p, one obtains a cross product of these vectors. One can pick one
25
of these vectors, say v3, to define a foliation by a 6-manifold and on this 6manifold one can introduce an almost complex structure by J = 213 -I ‘p E T * M 6 8 T M 6 . The remaining two vectors, which can be combined into a holomorphic vector‘ v1 iv2 imply that this 6-manifold is a fibration over the base &. On this 4-manifold we can define a basis of anti-selfdual 2-forms whose pullback correspond to the w,. Note, on any general 4-d manifold we have the splitting
+
A~=A:wP., where we can take { w l ,w2, w3) as a basis of A: and this splitting appears in group theory as: 50(4) 2 su(2) @ su(2), which is equivalent to reducing the structure group from SO(4) to SU(2). The 2-forms satisfy the algebraic relations wi2 =2vo1q
wiAwj=O
for,i#j,
and the associating complex structures fulfill the quaternionic algebra (note: the orientation on the 4-fold is negative). We can further split the 2-form bundle into a symplectic 2-form, say w = w3, and the remaining can be combined into complex (2,O)-form. Thus, the subbundle AT decomposes as
A: r X 2 > 0 ~ R ~ . So, besides the symplectic form w , let us introduce the complexified 2-form: x=w1+iw2
which is, with respect to w , a holomorphic (2,O)-form. The SU(2) singlet spinors can again be constructed from the G2 singlet spinor 00 by (29) where v, = vF3;n. Using the expressions from before, it is straightforward to verify the following relations
(v1v2 - iv3)e0= o
,
(vl - iv2)e2= (vl
+ iv2)e1= 0 ,
which imply v,(gff)klel
=ek
,
wek = i e k ,
v,vpek = i € , p x ( a x ) k l e l ,
xek = - i ( a 2 ) k 1 8 ; ,
“Meaning, that it annihilated by the projector: (W - J )
26
where w
= wmnymn, X G Xmnymn and with the Pauli matrices u 3 = ( l0 -1O ) .
(31)
4. BPS Constraints Now we can come back to the BPS equations from Section 2. With the superpotential as introduced before, equation (7) becomes 1 o = f j + [9518( 2-1d A + -)i36m -e-3A ( F IF~) ] q , (33) 144
+
and if: ij = e-+q, equation (8) yields im Ya)ij - i 9 5 y ae - 4 6 o = w 18(vih) +48
-
- e-3A y- 5 B ~ ~ i j (34) . 12
It is useful to decompose the 35 components of the 4-form field strength under Gz as 35 + 1 7 27 with
+ +
where 3(l), F(7)and 3(27) are the projection introduced in Eq. (20). The cases of G2 and SU(3) structures have been discussed already in the literature and we will summarize only the main results.
4.1. G2 Structure In this case, the 11-d spinor is a direct product, i.e. q=E@e,
(36)
and since the 11- and 7-d spinor are Majorana also the 4-d spinor E has to be Majorana (a more detailed discussion is given in Ref. 29). One finds that all internal 4-form components have to vanish
Fabcd = 0 ,
w1 = 0
, m = -36W2.
(37)
27
The Eq. (34) gives a differential equations for the spinor e Z & , which implies
aaz= 0 . The differential equations for 00 fixes the 7-manifold to have a weak G2 holonomy and hence is a Einstein space with the cosmological constant given by the Freud-Rubin ~ a r a m e t e r . ~ ~This > l Oin turn implies, that the 8d space built as a cone over this 7-manifold has Spin(7)holonomy. In fact, after taking into account the vielbeine, this gives the known set of first order 7 differential equations for the spin connection 1-form wab: Wab$9abc = 36 m e b , where m was the Freud-Rubin parameter [note w is here the spin connection and should not be confused with the associated 2-form introduced before]. Using the differential equation for the 7-spinor, it is straightforward to verify that d$=O,
and therefore only dl)is non-zero. The 4-d superpotential is only given by the Freud-Rubin parameter, ie.
which fixes the overall size of the 7-manifold. In the limit of flat 4-d Minkowski vacuum, the Freud-Rubin parameter has to vanish and we get back to the Ricci-flat G2-holonomy manifold. In order to allow for nontrivial fluxes one has to consider SU(3) instead of G2 structures. 4.2. SU(3) Structure
In this case, there is one (complex) 7-d spinor and the 11-d Majorana spinor reads = E 86
+ E*
80*.
(39)
where the 4-d spinors E and E* have opposite chirality (y5e = E ) . More details about this case can be found in Refs. 1 0 , l l . The solution of Eq. (33) read now
w = w1+ i w2= l6e - ( K / 2 + 3 A ) +
[$ 4
(1)
V a a a e 3 ~= + ~ ( 1 ) v a ~ ab ( 2 7 ) v 1b
m=O,
- vaF:;7)vb
+ i v " F p ], (40)
28
and
[the flux components were introduced in (35)]. In addition, one obtains a differential equation for the spinor with the non-trivial torsion components as introduced in Eq. (19)
--
,
dl)
w 2
7A7)
48 w1
-
9 3(l) + $ (PabcvbFi7)+ 27.F;i7)vb . 21,
(43)
To make the set of equations complete, we have to give the differential equations obeyed by the vector field u,which is straightforward if we use the differential equation for the spinor
recall w& = 'p&Uc. Note, unVmun = 0, which is consistent with 1uI2 = 1. Using the decomposition (35) one finds
v [ m u n ]= (drZ64 2 7 1(dd;:
V{,Vn) = --(dmn
+Z
1 + -21' $ " m n a b ) ~ ~ ~ 7 ) ' U C +' U b-'pmn"(d," 4
- V,Vb);Fb(7) ,(45)
1 9) - Zu{m'pn}abu,F~7)
- u(mun})
+ w;w:).F;;7)
- 2dmnF:~7)u"vb. 1
(46)
The first term in the anti-symmetric part is the projector onto the 7,see Eq. (16), and by contracting with 'p and employing Eqs. (41) and (42), one can verify that:" d(e3Av)= 0. One can project the flux components onto X s and using the symplectic 2-form w we can introduce (anti) holomorphic indices. As result, we can define a 3-form H and 4-form G on X S and find for the superpotential
whereas the 4-form has to fulfill the constraint: R 1G = 0 and de3A1w = ~ w ~ H a s w e l l a s u ~ d e ~ ~ = ~ ~ ~ ~ G .
29
4.3. SU(2) Structure Finally, in the SU(2) case we write the 11-d spinor as
7=
Be1 + e 2 B e 2 + c C ,
and we choose chiral4-d spinors with
y~5 E i
'
=Ea.
Eq. (33) gives
1 im 1 W&j* + ( - d A + - + - F ) O j ] . 2 36 144
(49)
If one dos not impose any constraints on the spinors 8 , one finds14
wij with the 4-form
-
eiFej = F
-I
6(4)as derived in (32). Defining the 2-forms:
Gap = V ~ V ~ F m n a b X a b ,
F,p = V z V ; F m n a b W a b ,
we can write Wij as matrix: W ( ~ ~ P Y G , p o ~ ) owith 2 the 0, as Pauli matrices. It would be identical zero if G = 0, but instead we can also impose: ~ ' W i j= 0 so that Wij projects out one of the 4-d spinor as we would need for an N = 1 vacuum. This implies that: det W = 0 which gives one constraint on the complex 2-form G. As next step, the contraction with 6: yields N
m =0,
-
~ A - S2(') I
N
F 1d4),
which implies that: d,A e a p r F p T (with 8, = v,"d,). Finally, one has to contract with Bya as well as with 8tya (with the index a projected onto the base) and if we assume that the dbA = 0 (ie. the warp factor is constant over the 4-d base), we get as further contraints on the fluxes =0,
eyaFe = 0 .
-
These constraints are solved, e.g., if the only non-zero components of the are: v, Avp A w ; ie. are contained in Fap and Gap = 0 (as defined above). These are all constraints on the fluxes, but from the internal variation (34) we get differential equations. Setting, m = 0 and ij = 0, we find
V,&
N
FmnpqynPqei.
If only the components in Fap are non-zero, it is straightforward to further simplify this equation by using the relations in (30). On the other hand,
30
this equation fkes also the corresponding differential equations obeyed by the differential forms.
For the 2-forms eg., our constraints on the fluxes imply that w and X are closed, when projected onto the 4-d base, which is therefore a hyper Kahler space. Unfortunately, we have to leave a detailed analysis of these equaions for the future.
Acknowledgments K. B. is partially supported by a Heisenberg grant of the DFG. C . J. is supported by a Graduiertenkolleg grant of the DFG (The Standard Model of Particle Physics - structure, precision tests and extensions).
References P. Candela and D. J. Raine, Nucl. Phys. B248,415 (1984). B. de Wit, D. J. Smit, and N. D. Hari Dass, Nucl. Phys. B283,165 (1987). B. de Wit and H. Nicolai, Phys. Lett. B148,60 (1984). M. A. Awada, M. J. Duff, and C. N. Pope, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50,294 (1983); B. de Wit, H. Nicolai, and N. P. Warner, Nucl. Phys. B255,29 (1985). 5. J. Polchinski and A. Strominger, Phys. Lett. B388, 736 (1996), hep-
1. 2. 3. 4.
th/9510227. 6. B. Brinne, A. Fayyazuddin, T. Z. Husain, and D. J. Smith, JHEP 03, 052 (2001), hepth/0012194. 7. K. Dasgupta, G. Rajesh and S. Sethi, JHEP 9908, 023 (1999), hepth/9908088; B. S. Acharya and B. Spence, hep-th/0007213. K. Becker and M. Becker, JHEP 11, 029 (2000), hep-th/0010282. 8. P. Kaste, R. Minasian, M. Petrini, and A. Tomasiello, JHEP 09,033 (2002), hep-t h/0206213. 9. J. P. Gauntlett and S. Pakis, JHEP 04, 039 (2003), hep-th/0212008; D. Martelli and J. Sparks, Phys. Rev. D68,085014 (2003), hep-th/0306225; J. P. Gauntlett, D. Martelli, and D. Waldram, Phys. Rev. D69, 086002 (2004), hep-t h/0302158. 10. K. Behrndt and C. Jeschek, JHEP 04, 002 (2003), hep-th/0302047; K. Behrndt and C. Jeschek, hep-th/03llll9. 11. P. Kaste, R. Minasian, and A. Tomasiello, JHEP 07, 004 (2003), hepth/0303127. 12. G. Dall’Agata and N. Prezas, Phys. Rev. D69, 066004 (2004), hepth/0311146. 13. K. Behrndt and M. Cvetic, Nucl. Phys. B676, 149 (2004), hep-th/0308045. K. Behrndt and M. Cvetic, hep-th/0403049.
31
14. K. Behrndt and C. Jeschek, Class. Quant. Gruv. 21, S1533 (2004), hepth/0401019. 15. A. Strominger, Nucl. Phys. B274,253 (1986). 16. K. Becker, M. Becker, K. Dasgupta and P. S. Green, JHEPO304, 007 (2003), hep-th/0301161; K. Becker, M. Becker, K. Dasgupta and S. Prokushkin, Nucl. Phys. B666,144 (2003), hep-th/0304001; K. Becker, M. Becker, P. S. Green, K. Dasgupta, and E. Sharpe, hep-th/0310058. 17. 3. P. Gauntlett, D. Martelli, S. Pakis, and D. Waldram, Commun. Math. Phys. 247,421 (2004), hep-th/0205050. 18. T. Friedrich and S. Ivanov, math-dg/0112201. 19. J. Louis and A. Micu, Nucl. Phys. B626,26 (2002), hep-th/0110187; S. Gurrieri, J. Louis, A. Micu, and D. Waldram, Nucl. Phys. B654, 61 (2003), hep-th/O211102. 20. G. L. Cardoso et al., Nucl. Phys. B652, 5 (2003), hep-th/0211118; G. L. Cardoso, G. Curio, G. Dall’Agata, and D. Lust, JHEP 10,004 (2003), hepth/0306088. 21. G. Dall’Agata, hep-th/0403220. 22. A. R. Frey, hep-th/0404107. 23. S. Gukov, Nucl. Phys. B574,169 (2000), hep-th/9911011; C. Beasley and E. Witten, JHEP 07,046 (2002), hep-th/0203061; G. Curio, JHEP 03,024 (2003), hepth/0212211. 24. T. Friedrich, I. Kath, A. Moroianu, and U. Semmelmann, Journal of Geometry and Physics 2 3 , 4 1 (1997); T. Friedrich and S. Ivanov, [math-dg/0102142]; I. Agricola and T. Friedrich, Class. Quant. Graw. 20,4707 (2003), [mathdg/0307360]; S. Karigiannis, math-dg/0301218. 25. S. Chiossi and S. Salamon, math-dq/0202282. 26. T. Friedrich and I. Kath, Commun. Math. Phys. 133,543 (1990). 27. K. G. C.P. Boyer and B. Mann, Journ. Reine u. Angew. Math. 455, 183 (1994). 28. E. Thomas, Bull. Americ. Math SOC.75,643 (1969). 29. A. Bilal, J.-P. Derendinger, and K. Sfetsos, Nucl. Phys. B628, 112 (2002), hep-th/Oll1274.
NONCOMMUTATIVE QUANTUM FIELD THEORY: REVIEW AND ITS LATEST ACHIEVEMENTS
M. CHAICHIAN
P.
Department of Physical Sciences, and Helsinki Institute of Physics, 0. Box 64, 00014 University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland E-mail:
[email protected]
Some properties of quantum field theories on noncommutative space-time are reviewed. Studying the general structure of the noncommutative (NC) local groups, we present a no-go theorem for NC gauge theories. This no-go theorem imposes strong restrictions on the NC version of the Standard Model (SM) and in resolving the standing problem of charge quantization in noncommutative QED. We also consider the phenomenological implications of noncommutative y on the spectrum of the H-atom and derive a bound on the noncommutativity parameter 8. Finally, in the framework of noncommutative quantum field theories (NC QFT), we show the general validity of the CPT and spin-statistics theorems, with the exception of some peculiar situations in the latter case.
1. Introduction It is generally believed that the notion of space-time as a continuous manifold should break down at very short distances of the order of the Planck length Xp M 1.6 x 10-33cm. This would arise, e.g. from the process of measurement of space-time points based on quantum mechanics and gravity arguments. Arguments for noncommutativity arise also from string theory with a constant antisymmetric background field, whose low-energy limit, in some cases, turns up to be a noncommutative quantum field theory (NC QFT).2 This in turn implies that our classical geometrical concepts may not be well suited for the description of physical phenomena at very small distances. One such direction is to try to formulate physics on some noncommutative space-time. 1-3 If the concepts of noncommutative geometry are used, the notion of point as elementary geometrical entity is lost and one first expectation is that an ultraviolet cutt-off appears. In Ref. 4 this expectation was shown not to be fulfilled in general. Instead, a peculiar 32
33
UV/IR mixing appear^.^ The usual way of constructing a noncommutative theory is through the Weyl-Moyal correspondence: in a NC space-time the coordinate operators satisfy the commutation relation:
where 8’”” is a constant antisymmetric matrix of dimension (length)2. In QFT the operator character of the space-time coordinates (1) requires that the product of any two field operators be replaced by their *-product, or Weyl-Moyal product. The *-product compatible with the associativity of field products is given by:
An important step in constructing a physical noncommutative model is t o develop the concept of local gauge symmetry. Intuitively, because of the inherent nonlocality of noncommutative field theories, the notion of local symmetry in the noncommutative case should be handled with special care. As a result, the pure noncommutative U(1) theory behaves similarly to the usual non-Abelian gauge theories, but now the structure constants depend on the momenta of the fields.6 This feature induces a charge quantization problem,’ in the sense that the electric charges in the noncommutative quantum electrodynamics (NC QED) based on NC U(l) group are quantized only to f 1 , O . The solution of this problem was sought in the construction of a noncommutative version of the Standard Model (NC SM),8 based on a no-go t h e ~ r e m and , ~ is discussed in Section 11. In Section 111 phenomenological implications of the noncommutativity are also addressed on a concrete model of the H-atom, for which we present the noncommutative corrections to the spectrum and, using the data for the Lamb shift, we find a bound on the noncommutativity parameter 0.” In Section IV, we show that a breaking of the spin-statistics relation in NC QFT could occur only in the case of theories with NC time. We also present in Section V a general proof that the CPT theorem remains valid in NC field theories, for general form of noncommutativity, although the individual symmetries C,T and P are broken.”
34
2. Noncommutative Gauge Groups. A No-go Theorem 2.1. Charge Quantization Problem in NC QED In Ref. 7 it was shown that in NC QED based on the NC U(l) group, one can encounter only fields with charge +1:
$74= V ( X ) * $(). 9 Dp$ = a,$ - iA, * 4,
$(XI
+
(3)
fields with charge -1: $(XI
+
$'(.I D,$
= $(XI = a,$
*u - w
+ i$
1
* A,,
(4)
and fields with charge 0:
Xb)
-+
X'(X)
=W
X:)
*X(X) *U-W ,
D,x = a,x
+ i[x,A,]* .
(5)
This immediately raises the question about other known charges, i.e. the fractional charges of quarks. The simple extension
D p ~ ( n=)
- inA,
* $(n) ,
(6)
with $(4--+ $44 = U*"* $'"'
(7)
for the field $ with integral multiple n of a (conventional) unit charge fails to transform covariantly. In conclusion in NC QED, charge is quantized only to 0,fl. A possible way out from this situation is to construct a NC version of the Standard Model, to which end we have to choose the gauge groups and their representations and also define the direct product of group factors. 2.2. A No-go Theorem The following result was partially obtained in Ref. 12 in the framework of noncommutative gauge groups and extended to a no-go theorem in Ref. 9. In general, as discussed in Ref. 13, it is not trivial to define the noncommutative version of usual simple local groups, as the *-product will destroy the closure condition. Consequently, the only group which admits a minimal noncommutative extension is U ( n ) (we will denote its extention by U*(n)). However, the NCSO and U S p algebras have been constructed in a more involved way. l3
35
To define the pure NC U * ( n ) gauge theory we take as generators of the u*(n) algebra: T”, a = ,n2 - 1 ( n x n su(n) generators) and T o = -&lnxn. The u*(n) Lie-algebra is defined with the star-matrix bracket : 1 , e . a
[f,9l* = f
*9
-
9 *f
,
f , 9 E u*(n>.
(8)
The U,(n) gauge theory is described by the u,(n) valued gauge fields: n2-1
G, =
C
G$(x)TA,
(9)
A=O
with the infinitesimal gauge transformation
G,
4
GG = G,
+ i8,X + g[X,G,],
, X E u*(n).
(10)
Under the above tranformation, the field strength G,u = d[,Gv]
+ i9[G,, GI*,
(11)
transforms covariantly:
leaving invariant the action of the pure U*(n) gauge theory:
4n
dDa: n(G,, *G’””)
One peculiar feature to be noticed in the case of the pure U*(n)gauge theory is that, fixing the number of gauge field degrees of freedom (which is n2) the dimension of the matrix representation is automatically fixed, i.e. the gauge fields must be in the n x n matrix form. The main physical implication is that the matter fields coupled to the U * ( n ) gauge theory can only be in fundamental, antifundamental, adjoint and singlet states. Another nontrivial point in the noncommutative gauge theories is to define the direct product of NC gauge groups. In the commutative case, if GI and G2 are gauge groups, then G = G1 x GZ is defined through:
9 = 91 x 92 19) = 9‘1 x 9: 1 g i ,9: E Gi , 9 , g t E G , 9 . 9 ) = (91 x 92) * (9; x 9;) = (91 .9;) x (92 * 9:) *
(14)
In the noncommutative case, let G1 = U*(n) and G2 = U*(m). But now, the group products involve the *-product so that the group elements can not be re-arranged. As a result, the definition of direct product cannot be straightforwardly generalized to the NC case and consequently the matter fields cannot be in fundamental representations of both U,(n) and U*(m).
36
The only possibility left is for a matter field to be in the fundamental representation of a gauge group and the antifundamental representation of another:
9 -+ 9' = u 9 * V - l ,
U E U,(n), V E ~,(rn).
(15)
In the general case of n gauge groups N
the matterfields can be charged under at most two of the U,(ni) factors. 2.3. N C Standard Model. A Solution to the Charge Quantization Problem Based on the above no-go theorem, we have built a noncommutative version of the Standard Model.8 The model is based on the gauge group U,(3)x U,(2) x U,(1)(the general elements of the respective group factors will be denoted by U E U,(3), V E U,(2), II E U,(l)) and comprises: one gauge field, B, , valued in u,(1), four gauge fields of u,(2) :
where d ,i = 1,2,3 are the Pauli matrices and fields of u,(3):
go = 1 z X 2
and nine gauge
R
A=O
where T", a = 1,2,. . , 8 are the Gell-Mann matrices and To = 1 3 x 3 . This choice of the gauge group is due to the fact that there i s no straightforward noncommutative extension of the S U ( n ) groups. However, compared t o the commutative Standard Model, two additional gauge fields have appeared, corresponding to the extra U(1) factors. The reduction of the extra U(1) factors is achieved through a Higgs-type of mechanism, in two stages. First the mechanism is run with the symmetry-reducing scalar field with U1 E U(1)C U,(3)and V1 E U(1)c U,(2).In the second stage, the symmetry is reduced eventually to that of hyper-charge, throught the scalar particle @z(.)
+
s(.)@2.-l()
1
(20)
37
with sEU(l)residual and v ~ U * ( l ) After . the symmetry reduction, two of the gauge fields become massive (Go and W o )and the gauge field corresponding to the residual U ( 1 ) symmetry will be the (masless) hyper-photon Y . When coupling matter fields to the U*(3) x U*(2) x U,(1) theory, we have to keep in mind that, according to Ref. 9, the fields can be only in the fundamental and/or anti-fundamental representation of the group factors. It is interesting to note that the no-go theorem allows six different types of charged particles in the case of three simple group factors and the matter content of the original Standard Model (including the Higgs particle) exhausts those possible types of charges. By properly taking the representations of the matter fields and performing the U(1) symmetry reduction introduced earlier, it is straightforward to show that the couplings of all matter fields to the hyper-photon Y, are realized through the usual hypercharges.' Moreover, after performing the spontaneous symmetry breaking of the original Standard Model, all particles will couple to the photon A, through the usual electric charges, i.e. 1, -1, 0, -I/?, 2/3, so this model provides a solution to the NC charge quantization problem. Another proposal for a noncommutative version of the Standard Model is based on the Seiberg-Witten (SW) map,14 which assigns to commutative gauge configurations the noncommutative equivalent configurations, linked by field-dependent noncommutative gauge transformations. This version of the NC SM is constructed from NC fields realized by SW map as a tower of commutative fields, transforming under G = U(1) x S U ( 2 ) x SU(3). There are no additional U(1) gauge fields, so there is no need for the U(1) factor reduction. The gauge symmetry is considered on Lie algebra level and not Lie group level. Consequently, arbitrary (fractional) U (1) charges are admissible. However, this last point can be considered as a disadvantage: in the NC SM based on the no-go theorem, the U(1) factor reduction fixes the correct (hyper) charges for all SM particles.
3. Lamb Shift in NC QED. Bounds on 8 In this section we focus on the hydrogen atom and, using the non-relativistic limit of NC QED results, we propose the Hamiltonian describing the NC H-atom. Given the Hamiltonian and assuming that the noncommutativity parameter ( & j ) is small, we study the spectrum of H-atom. We show that because of noncommutativity, even at field theory tree level, we have some corrections to the Lamb shift (2+, -+ 2&/2 transition)." Hereafter, we shall consider the electron of the H-atom moving in the
38
external field of the proton. However, similar results (up to a numerical factor) would be obtained by treating the proton as a composite particle, e.g., in the naive quark m0de1.l~The latter analysis infirms the treatment of Ref. 16, where the proton is taken as an elementary particle, thereby obtaining no noncommutative corrections for the H-atom spectrum at tree level. To start with, we propose the following Hamiltonian for the noncommutative H-atom:
with
p i ,3y = ieij , pi,fijl = itisij , bi16j] =0.
(22)
The NC Coulomb potential
Ze2 e Zer V ( r )= --r - -(e 4ti x P) . (-$
+ o(e2),
with e i j = i f i j k e k can be obtained either as the nonrelativistic limit from the NC photon exchange diagram or from the change of variables:
xi = xi+ -eijfij, 2ti
(24)
Pi = Pi 7
where the new variables satisfy the usual canonical commutation relations: [Zi,Zj]
=0
,
[Pi,Pj] =0
,
(25)
[Zi,Pj] =m i j .
Using the usual perturbation theory, the leading corrections t o the energy levels due to noncommutativity, i.e. first order perturbation and in field theory tree level, are:
1 f o r j = l f i a n d f n , l = n34+3)(1+1). The case of our interest, the 2P112--f 2S1p transition (Lamb shift), for the noncommutative H-atom, besides the usual loop effects, depends on the j , quantum number (only for the 2P112 level, as the levels with 1 = 0 are not affected) and is there, even in the field theory tree level. Hence we call it polarized Lamb shift. New transition channels are opened (notation nlp), i.e. 2PG;l2 4 2P://2"and a split of
the usual Lamb shift occurs: 2Pt;:
+ 2S1p
and 2Pz;l2 --$
25'112.
39
One can use the data on the Lamb shift to impose some bounds on the value of the noncommutativity parameter 8. Of course, to do it, we only need to consider the classical (tree level) results, Eq. (26). Comparing these results, the contribution of (26) should be of the order of smaller than the usual one loop result and hence,
The same bound is obtained also from the violation of Lorentz invariance, based on the clock-comparison experiments, which monitor the difference between two atomic hyperfine or Zeeman transition frequencies, searching for variations as the Earth rotates.17
4. Noncommutative Quantum Field Theory and Spin-statistics Theorem Pauli’s spin-statistics relationls is responsible for the entire structure of the matter and for its stability. Experimentally, the relation has been verified to high accuracy. Theoretically up to now there has been no compelling argument or logical motivation for its breaking. However, the violation of Lorentz invariance, as well as the intrinsic nonlocality of noncommutative field theories, may suggest that the (presumably very small, of the order of lPVlm2)breaking of this fundamental theorem, as well as of the CPT theorem, might be possible. Pauli demonstrated18 the spin-statistics relation based on the following requirements: (i) The vacuum is the state of lowest energy; (ii) Physical quantities (observables) commute with each other in two space-time points with a space-like distance; (iii) The metric in the physical Hilbert space is positive definite. In the noncommutative case the physical quantities (observables) which are in general products of several field operators, are no more local quantities and could therefore fail to fulfil the above requirement ii). For instance, taking the normally ordered product : qb2(x) : for a real scalar field with mass rn, its noncommutative version : 4(x) 4(z) : could give a nonvanishing equal-time commutation relation (ETCR). In particular, the matrix element between vacuum and a two-particle state, on a d-dimensional space, when Bose statistics is used, is:”
*
40
-
d
2i
1 (e--ip'x--ipy
+
e--ipx--ip'y
)
G
where wk = ko = and = (kl, ..., kd). The r.h.s. of (28) is nonzero only when Ooi # 0. This holds for observables expressed as any power of both bosonic fields and their derivatives, with *-product analogous to (28), and spinor fields and their derivatives, with anti-commutation relation used in the latter case. The study of NC QFT also showed a violation of both causalitylg and unitarity" conditions, for theories with noncommutative time (Ooi # 0). Indeed, while the low-energy limit of string theory in a constant antisymmetric background field B"", which exhibits noncommutativity, reduces to field theory with the *-product when Ooi = 0, for the case Ooi # 0 there is no corresponding low-energy field theory limit. The field theories with light-like noncommutativity, OpVOp, = 0, i.e. Ooi = --eli, become very interesting from this point of view as they preserve unitarity.21 In this case, however, the microcausality in the sense of ETCR (28) is still violated.ll If the field theory with light-like noncommutativity is indeed the lowenergy limit of string theory, as stated in Ref. 21, it is then intriguing that the theory is unitary but acausal (as it is known that a low-energy effective theory should not necessarily be unitary, as is the case, e.g., for the Fermi four-spinor interaction). 5. CPT Theorem in NC Field Theories
The CPT t h e ~ r e m (see ~ ~ also t ~ ~Ref. 24 for a review) is of a universal nature in that it is valid in all the known field theories. Here we shall recapitulate essential features of the CPT transformation and then extend the CPT theorem to noncommutative field theories. First, we shall summarize the common properties of anti-unitary transformations, including time reversal and CPT transformation. An antiunitary transformation denoted hereafter by 4 is a generalization of complex conjugation and satisfies
(a' ,a')
= (a
,a).
(29)
The transformation of state vectors corresponds to the Schrodinger picture and we can also attribute the same transformation to operators correspond-
ing t o the Heisenberg picture by
(9' ,Q@')
= (a , Q ' 9 ) .
In what follows we shall mainly discuss the latter approach. a) The transformation of operators obeys the following rules: (CIA
+ cgb)'
= clA' (AB)' = B'A',
+ czB'
(linearity) ,
where c1 and c g are c-number coefficients. b) Let us assume that
Q' = EQ,( E = f l ) and that 9 is an eigenstate of Q with the eigenvalue q,
&@==a; then ' 9 is also an eigenstate of Q and QQ' = Eq9'.
5.1. The C P T h n s f o r m a t i o n of Local Elementary Fields
+
In what follows we shall use the symbol exclusively for the C P T transformation and we shall first define it for local elementary fields. Let $Ia, Ga and $ A ~ . . . A ~be local elementary fields representing spinors and tensors, respectively; then the C P T transformation is specified by:25 $I%)
= (iY5)cu&d--2)
7
= $p(--S)(iYdpa
7
' $34
4 A 1 , . . A n (-2)
= (-')n$A1...An(-z)
.
(35)
This set of rules completely specifies the transformation of any local elementary field carrying definite spinor and/or tensor indices. Then the C P T theorem for local field theories can be formulated in the following form: 5 . 2 . C P T Theorem for Local Fields Let $Ia, $a and $A~.,.A,, be local but composite fields representing spinors and tensors, respectively; then they are transformed exactly in the same form as Eq. (35) for local elementary fields. In what follows we shall clarify the significance of this theorem.
42
1) Let us consider local composite scalar fields of which free and interaction Lagrangian densities, as well as interaction Hamiltonian densities, are typical members and we have:
LfI(.
, L,?,,>.(
= Lf(-).
= Lint (-.)
,
HL&) = H i n t ( - . ) .
(36) (37)
In Ref. 25, Eq. (37) has been referred to as the CPT theorem and its proof has been given there so that we skip it. When asymptotic conditions are valid, the CPT invariance of the S matrix follows from it:
s' =s.
(38) 2) Next, let @ A be a local composite vector field and q 5 a~ local elementary vector field, respectively; then a composite scalar field @ = q 5 ~ @is ~ transformed as (36) or (37) and q 5 ~as (35). From the above information we deduce:
'
= -@A(-)
(39) and similarly we can prove Eq. (35) for spinors and tensors. As an example of local composite vector fields we choose the electric current density j ~ ( z ) ; then the conserved electric charge Q transforms as: @A(.)
Q' =
/
d 3 2 j t ( 2 )= -
/
7
d3zjo(-2) = -Q.
3) The energy-momentum vector PA can be expressed as the space integral of the energy-momentum tensor of the second rank. Therefore, we immediately conclude
P!
= PA.
(41) 4) The generators of the Lorentz transformation Mpu can be expressed as the space integral of a tensor of the third rank, so that we have:
M:u
-Adpu. (42) This indicates that the spin of a particle defined in terms of the PauliLubanski operator should reverse its direction under CPT. In general, the CPT transformation of an operator is determined by the tensorial rank of its density. 5 ) We assume the validity of the LSZ asymptotic conditions;26then on the basis of their definition of the asymptotic fields, it is shown straightforward that the CPT transformation turns incoming fields into outgoing fields and vice versa. =
43
5.3. C P T Theorem for Noncommutative Fields
The validity of CPT theorem for noncommutative QED has been discussed in Ref. 27, where it was concluded that CPT is accidentally preserved, although the charge conjugation and time reversal symmetries are broken due to noncommutativity. However, in Ref. 27 the specific version of NC QED of Ref. 7 was studied, where the photon couples only to particles with the electric charges +1,-1 and 0. The latter is usually referred to as the "charge quantization problem". In Ref. 28 the CPT invariance of the noncommutative Yang-Mills theories has been shown using the SeibergWitten map. In the following, we shall show the general validity of the CPT theorem for any noncommutative quantum field theory of the type described in Sect. 11, without reference to any specific model or to the Seiberg-Witten map. Let H ( z ) be the Weyl-Moyal product (2) of field operators representing the interaction Hamiltonian in a noncommutative field theory. It is understood that H ( z ) stands for a normal product in the interaction representation. The CPT theorem is given by
In order to prove it we shall choose as an illustration a n-linear form for H ( z ) ,namely,
H(z)=
c c
fal...an+il,(z>*...*+~n(z)
il.. .in
= eD
. ...2,.
fi ,...in+:,
(21)...~~n(2,)111= ...=In~a: 1
(44)
2,
where ij with j = 1,...,n stand for spinorial or tensorial indices and the coefficients fil...in are so chosen as to make H ( z ) a scalar under proper Lorentz transformations, in the local limit. D stands for the differential operator of the form
with general W. Then the CPT transform of H ( z ) is given by:
44
where f' is given by f!2 1 ...2,. = (-1)W".
21
...2,
(47)
7
and F stands for the number of the Fermi fields involved in H ( z ) . When we reverse the order of multiplication back to the original one in (44), we obtain:
H'(.)
c c ...in4:,
=e
D
fz l... z,4~l(-z~)..,4~,(-z~)121 =...=2,=2
il
=
. ...2.,
...in fz,
(-z)
* ... * 4;,
(-z) = H ().-
.
(48)
21
Thus the CPT theorem is valid not only in local field theories but also in noncommutative field theories. This can be also seen from the fact that, when we expand the interaction Hamiltonian density in powers of 8, the first term is the local limit of the Hamiltonian expressed in terms of the Weyl-Moyal product. It is a local but composite scalar density. The coefficients of other terms are local but composite tensor fields of even ranks obtained by differentiating the fields involved in the first term, an even number of times. Therefore, they transform in the same way as the first term under CPT. From this point of view it is intuitively clear that the Hamiltonian density expressed in terms of the Weyl-Moyal product transforms in the same way as the local ones under CPT. As seen from the proof presented above, the CPT theorem is valid for any form of noncommutativity, including the case Oo2 # 0. Individual discrete transformations P, C and T The individual transformations P, C and T are violated in many cases and we shall comment on them only by comparison with the local (commutative) limit of the noncommutative field theory in question. In the case of only space-space noncommutativity (8'2 = 0), the parity of a noncommutative field theory is the same as for its commutative limit, while charge conjugation and time reversal are broken, even if they hold for the commutative limit. This is due to the fact that C and T imply a complex conjugation, that would change the sign of the phase in (45). In the case of a space-time noncommutative theory (8" # 0) - whose commutative limit is P, C and T invariant - all these discrete transformations are violated, as in the NC QED case.27
6. Conclusions In the framework of noncommutative gauge theories, we present a no-go theorem according to which the closure condition of the gauge algebra im-
45
plies that: 1) the local NC u ( n ) algebra only admits the irreducible n x n matrix-representation. Hence the gauge fields are in nxn matrix form, while the matter fields can only be in fundamental, adjoint or singlet states; 2) for any gauge group consisting of several simple-group factors, the matter fields can transform nontrivially under at m o s t two NC group factors. In other words, the matter fields cannot carry more than two NC gauge group charges. This no-go theorem imposes strong restrictions on the NC version of the Standard Model and in resolving the standing problem of charge quantization in noncommutative QED. Elaborating on the phenomenological implications of noncommutativity we have calculated the noncommutative corrections to the spectrum of the H-atom and obtained a bound on 0 from the data on the Lamb shift. We have found that the CPT theorem is generally valid in NC FT, irrespective of the form of the noncommutativity parameter O p v involved, although Lorentz invariance is violated. The spin-statistics theorem holds in the case of field theories with space-space noncommutativity, which can be obtained as a low-energy limit from the string theory. A violation of the spin-statistics relation in the case of NC time can not be justified, given the pathological character of such theories. The case of light-like noncommutativity (compatible with unitarity) deserves, however, more attention. In conclusion, it is of importance to study further the light-like case, as to determine whether it can indeed be obtained as a low-energy limit of string theory. Questions concerning a possible breaking of the spin-statistics relation are of utmost importance, since such a violation, no matter how small, would have a crucial impact on the structure and the stability of matter in the Universe. The issue, on the other hand, is of fundamental interest by itself, since up to now no theoretical argument or motivation for such a breaking has been presented.
Acknowledgments The financial support of the Academy of Finland under the Project no. 54023 is acknowledged.
References 1. S. Doplicher, K. Fredenhagen and J. E. Roberts, Phys. Lett B331,39 (1994); Comm. Math. Phys. 172, 187 (1995). 2. N. Seiberg and E. Witten, JHEP 9909, 31 (1999), hepth/9908142. 3. A. Connes, Noncommutative Geometry, Academic Press, New York (1994).
46
4. T. Filk, Phys. Lett. B376, 53 (1996); M. Chaichian, A. Demichev and P. Prehajder, Nucl. Phys. B567, 360 (ZOOO), hep-th/9812180. 5. S. Minwalla, M. Van Raamsdonk and N. Seiberg, JHEP 9906, 020 (2000), hepth/9912072. 6. M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari, JHEP 9906, 015 (1999), hep-th/9903107. 7. M. Hayakawa, Phys. Lett. B478, 394 (ZOOO), hep-th/9912094. 8. M. Chaichian, P. Presnajder, M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari and A. Tureanu, Eur. Phys. J. C29, 413 (2003), hepth/0107055. 9. M. Chaichian, P. PreSnajder, M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari and A. Tureanu, Phys. Lett. B526, 132 (2002), hep-th/0107037. 10. M. Chaichian, M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari and A. Tureanu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2716 (2001), hep-th/0010175. 11. M. Chaichian, K. Nishijima and A. Tureanu, Phys. Lett. B568, 146 (2003), h e p t h/0209008. 12. S. Terashima, Phys. Lett. B482, 276 (2000), hep-th/0002119. 13. L. Bonora, M. Schnabl, M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari and A. Tomasiello, Nucl. Phys. B589, 461 (2000), hep-th/0006091. 14. X. Calmet, B. JurEo, P. Schupp, J. Wess and M. Wohlgennant, Eur. Phys. J.C23, 363 (2002), hepph/Olllll5. 15. M. Chaichian, M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari and A. Tureanu, hep-th/0212259. 16. P.-M. Ho and H.-C. Kao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88,151602 (2002), hep-th/0110191. 17. S. M. Carroll, J. A. Harvey, V. A. Kostelecky, C. D. Lane and T. Okamoto, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 141601 (2001), hep-th/0105082. 18. W. Pauli, Phys. Rev. 58, 716 (1940); Progr. Theor. Phys. (Kyoto) 5, 516 (1950). 19. N. Seiberg, L. Susskind and N. Toumbas, JHEP 0006, 044 (2000), h e p th/0005015; L. Alvarez-GaumB and J. L. F. Barbon, Int. J. Mod. Phys A16, 1123 (2001), hep-th/0006209. 20. J. Gomis and T. Mehen, Nucl. Phys. B591, 265 (ZOOO), hep-th/0005129. 21. 0. Aharony, J. Gomis and T. Mehen, JHEP 0009, 023 (2000), hepth/0006236. 22. G. Luders, Dansk. Mat. Fys. Medd. 28, 5 (1954). 23. W . Pauli, Niels Bohr and the Development of Physics, W. Pauli (ed.), Pergamon Press, New York (1955). 24. R. F. Streater and A. S. Wightman, CPT, Spin, Statistics and All That, W. A. Benjamin, Inc., New York (1964), and references therein. 25. K. Nishijima, Fundamental Particles, W. A. Benjamin, Inc., New York (1963). 26. H. Lehmann, K. Symanzik and W. Zimmermann, Nuovo Cimento 1, 1425 (1955); 6, 319 (1957). 27. M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 5265 (2000), hep-th/0001167. 28. P. Aschieri, B. JurEo, P. Schupp and J. Wess, Nucl. Phys. B651, 45 (2003), h e p t h/02052 14.
SHADOWS OF QUANTUM BLACK HOLES
N.KALOPER Department of Physics, University of California Davis, C A 95616, USA E-mail:
[email protected]
We discuss our recent conjecture that black holes localized on a brane in AdSD+I should be interpreted as quantum-corrected D-dimensional black holes, rather than classical ones, in the dual CFT coupled to gravity. Thus in 4D they include the corrections from Hawking radiation.
1. Black Holes in AdS/CFT with a Cutoff: the Role of Tunneling The semi-infinite Randall Sundrum modell is based on a bulk geometry of AdSD+I space ending on a D - 1-dimensional domain wall, or brane. A prototype is the RS2 model where Ads5 ends on a 3-brane, which should model our 3+1 dimensional world. It is natural to ask what is a suitable description of a black hole in this scenario. The attempts to find exact, static, asymptotically flat black hole solutions localized on the brane in AdSD+l>4, with regular horizons both on and off the brane, have been marred with very serious It has even been suggested that static, asymptotically flat, spherical black holes on the brane might not altogether exist in the RS2 model. In contrast, exact static solutions localized on a 2-brane in Ad& have been found in Refs. 7, 8. This is surprising in two ways. First of all, the RS2 model in 5 0 is believed to have a dual description in terms of purely 4 0 physics, as a strongly coupled CFT with a UV cutoff, coupled to weak gravity and perhaps Standard Model-like excitations. One would expect that such a theory should admit the conventional black holes, which are no more difficult t o construct than is usual. On the other hand, the same argument applied to a 3 0 CFT coupled to gravity would suggest that there should not be any black holes to begin with, since as is well known,g there are no black hole solutions of 2 1 Einstein gravity in asymptotically flat spaces. So why do
+
47
48
such objects appear in the variant of RS2 in the 4 0 bulk? In order to resolve this, in the recent work with Emparan and Fabbri," we have proposed a connection between the bulk and dual CFT+gravity interpretation of black holes in RS2, based on a modification of AdS/CFT correspondence" for the RS2 m ~ d e l . ~ ~Our - ~main ' result was the following conjecture:
The black hole solutions localized o n the brane in the AdSD+1 braneworld which are found by solving the classical bulk equations in AdSD+1 with the brane boundary conditions, correspond to quantum-corrected black holes in D dimensions. rather than classical ones. This comes about as follows: according to AdS/CFT, the classical dynamics in the AdSD+1 bulk encodes the quantum dynamics of the dual D-dimensional conformal field theory (CFT), in the planar limit of a large N expansion. Cutting the bulk with a brane introduces a normalizable D-dimensional graviton while on the dual side this same Ddimensional gravity mode is merely added to the CFT, which is also cutoff in the ultraviolet. Then, solving the classical D 1-dimensional equations in the bulk is equivalent to solving the D-dimensional Einstein equations G,, = 87rG~(T,v)CFT,where the CFT stress-energy tensor incorporates the quantum effects of all planar diagrams. These include particle production in the presence of a black hole, and possibly other vacuum polarization effects. We have shown that the conjecture is fully consistent with the existence of black holes in 2+1 CFT+gravity, which emerge solely due to the quantum corrections in the CFT sector of the the0ry.l' In fact, this result provides for an interesting spinoff, showing that in 2 1 dimensions, the quantum dynamics of a CFT naturally serves as a cosmic censor, regulating the (6function) naked singularities, and dressing them in a horizon. Thus the black holes in 2 1 dimensions are generic, once quantum corrections are included. This is true independently of whether the CFT is strongly or weakly coupled, and is more efficient when there is more CFT degrees of freedom. We have also found a consistent reinterpretation of black holes in the physically more relevant case of a 3-brane in AdS5.l' The main point is that the CFT+gravity dual allows us to reinterpret the alleged obstruction for finding a static black hole3 as a manifestation of the backreaction from Hawking effects. As long as the bulk is asymptotically Ads, the conformal
+
+
+
49
symmetry of the dual CFT is valid in the infrared, and so there is no mass gap. Thus any black hole at a finite temperature will emit CFT modes as a thermal spectrum of Hawking radiation, which on the bulk side is captured by a deformation of the bulk geometry close to the brane. Since in the asymptotically flat space Hawking radiation escapes t o infinity, carrying away the black hole energy, the black hole mass must be time-dependent, and hence the geometry is not stationary. The mechanism of the tunneling suppression plays an important role in the determination of the Hawking effects from the bulk side, and we will review this below. We begin with several key aspects of the AdS/CFT d i c t i ~ n a r y . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Since we want to discriminate between classical and quantum effects, we must keep ti in our formulas, while setting c = 1. Then, the 4-dimensional Newton’s constant G4, Planck length l 4 , and Planck mass M4 are related to each other as
ti M4 = -
-e4
G4 = -
M4 l
e4
In Ads braneworlds the 5 0 bulk Newton’s constant and the bulk cosmological constant A5 = -10/L2 together determine the Newton’s constant induced on the D-dimensional brane as 1
G4=-G5.
L
(2)
In light of our discussion from previous sections, this means that we are taking the volume of the Calabi-Yau space to be negligible compared to the volume of the brane throat, which is the opposite limit t o that we worked in previously. The precise details of the dual CFT depend on the specifics of the string/M-theory construction that yield the Ads background. For our purposes here it is enough to determine the effective number of degrees of freedom of the CFT, g*. For D = 4, the dual pair are IIB string theory on Ads5 x S5 of radius L e1,(g,N)1/4 and N = 4 S U ( N ) super Yang-Mills theory, leading to N
where we have used Eq. (2) to get the final expressions, 9%is taken to be a large number, in order to keep small quantum corrections to the supergravity approximation to string/M-theory. For the CFT, this is a large N limit where planar diagrams give the leading contribution. The Planck brane that cuts off the Ads bulk denotes that very high energy states of the dual CFT are integrated out, breaking the conformal invariance of the
50
theory in the UV. However, the breaking washes into the low energy theory only through irrelevant operators, generated by integrating out the heavy CFT states at the scale p u v h/L. In the IR, at energies E < p u v , the effects of the conformal symmetry breaking are suppressed by powers of E / p u v , meaning that the bulk geometry far from the brane is Ads. Cutting off the bulk yields also a normalizable graviton zero mode localized on the brane; this same D-dimensional gravity mode is added to the dual theory. However, note that the CFT cutoff p u v is not equal to the'induced D-dimensional Planck mass. Instead,
-
which is much smaller than the Planck mass on the brane, and is what we would expect for the single throat limit of the "octopus", as discussed previously.
1.1. Resolving the Mystery of the Missing 3 -/- 1 Black Hole As we have said above, as long as the bulk is Ads5 far from the brane, the dual CFT is conformal in the IR, without a mass gap separating the CFT modes from the vacuum. Hence any black hole at a finite temperature will have unrestricted access t o a large number of light CFT modes, and will them with a thermal spectrum, which is precisely the Hawking radiation.a On the bulk side, this must be described by a deformation of the bulk geometry near the brane, which arises because the black hole appears as a source in the classical bulk gravity equations. Computing these effects entails the usual complications involving the choice of the vacuum for a quantum field theory in a black hole background, with the possibilities being (1) the Hartle-Hawking state, (2) the Unruh state, and (3) the Boulware state. Then by our conjecture, the black hole on the RS2 brane must correspond to one of these choices, with the corrections from the backreaction included. This immediately shows why the search for a static, "We should note that a step in this direction for the case of RS2 in Ads5 was made by T. Tanaka,20 and, simultaneously, by R. Maartens and the author, in order t o explain the results of Ref. 3. A naive argument that the bulk dynamics encodes the backreaction from Hawking radiation would lead one to expect that all asymptotically flat branelocalized black holes are time-dependent. This would be in conflict with the exact static 2 1 solutions of Refs. 7, 8. Our conjecture that the classical bulk dynamics encodes all quantum corrections at the level of planar diagrams completely resolves this conflict. These exact solutions in fact strongly support the conjecture as presented in here."
+
51
asymptotically flat black hole solution on the brane has failed so far: the state (1) is not asymptotically flat, ( 2 ) is not static, and (3) does not have a regular horizon. This leads us to considering a radiative solution as the leading-order description of the exterior of a black hole localized on the brane. The detailed description of this geometry on the bulk side would require either the exact bulk solution, which has been missing so far, or a much better approximation than the existing ones. On the side of the 3 f l CFT+gravity, a description at the same level of rigor would require a careful backreaction analysis, where we should start with a classical Schwarzschild black hole and perturb it by means of the (Tpy) in the Unruh state evaluated in the classical background geometry. The far-field outgoing metric encodes the flux of Hawking radiation pouring out of the black hole, which is described by the stress-energy tensor
where u is the retarded null coordinate and L(u) is the flux luminosity. The perturbed geometry is
ds2=-
(1 - 2G4y(u)) du2 2drdu + r2dS22, -
where = -L(u). To check our conjecture, we should recover the relation between L and M from leading-order corrections to the black hole geometry induced from the bulk. The precise calculation would require the detailed matching of the far-field solution (6) to a near horizon one, which should then be matched onto the interior. In order to circumvent these details, we have considered the radiative collapse of a very massive dust cloud, forming a black hole of large mass. This collapsing cloud of dust, whose interior is described by the bulk dynamics encompassing leading order quantum CFT corrections, determined in Ref. 3 can be matched to an outgoing Vaidya metric (6), following the work of Ref. 21. The quantum corrections propagate through the matching regions, and this relates the outgoing flux of radiation to the subleading correction in the interior star geometry, which is c( ( G ~ M J ~ ) as ~ calcu/R~, lated in Ref. 3, r.h.s. of their Eq. (6) (we only consider the limit Q = A = 0 of this equation, which is sufficient for our purposes). Comparing to Eq. (5) we find L G 4 ( M L ) 2 / R t hg,(G4M)2/R:, where Ro is the radius of the matching surface. For a large collapsing mass, this will be near 2 G 4 M , so L hg*/(G4M)2. This corresponds to a flux of Hawking radiation of N
N
-
52
-
g* degrees of freedom of the CFT, at a temperature TH ti/(G4M), as required. Replacing M ( u ) by M is consistent since L c( ti and we are working in an expansion in ti. While this does not reproduce a detailed formula with accurate numerical coefficients, it does give the correct scalings with the black hole and CFT parameters, in complete accord with our conjecture. We should still check the consistency of the matching of geometries across the horizon. A simple way to check this is to compare the quantum trace anomalies of the backreacted states in the exterior and interior. The trace anomaly of the quantum stress tensor is a local geometric quantity independent of which vacuum the field is in.22>23 It has been studied in detail in the AdS/CFT context,24and in particular in the case of Ads braneworlds in Refs. 25-27. It gives us further insight into our problem, in that it provides a simple leading-order consistency check, which a configuration must pass in order to be described by the leading-order effects in the duality pair. In the case of D = 4 N = 4 SU(N) SYM at large N N
Note the absence of the term RPVapRFYap.Ref. 24 showed how this anomaly is precisely reproduced from a computation in the AdSs bulk. This result is perturbatively identical to the familiar quadratic stress-energy correction terms that appear in the effective long distance 3 1 gravity equations in Ads braneworlds,28 which can be checked explicitly recalling g* N2.“J6 The matching to the far-field Vaidya metric (6), is consistent with this form of the anomaly, because the tracelessness of the radiation stress-energy implies R P , , = 0, and so the anomaly vanishes, with no contributions from the R P y a p R P V a p terms. Although this argument by itself does not fully guarantee that the bulk will be free from singularities, it passes the anomaly check with only minimal assumptions which are physically well-motivated. It is now straightforward to correctly interpret the ”no-go theorem” of Ref. 3. The anomaly matching requires that the exterior is radiative, leading to a time-dependent evaporating black hole (6). Therefore, the classical bulk dynamics does require braneworld black holes to be time-dependent. However, this is simply a natural consequence of black hole quantum mechanics, and is generated as a leading order quantum correction. Understanding this picture from the point of view of the full bulk Ads5 spacetime, and in particular the details of the dual description of the Hawking radiation as a classical bulk process represents a very
+
-
53
interesting challenge. In Ref. 10 we have touched upon some aspects of this picture. The mechanism of tunneling ~ u p p r e s s i o nplays ~ ~ a very important role for understanding the difference between the rapidly evaporating large black holes and slowly evaporating small ones. For the small black holes, the description in terms of a 3 1 theory of gravity+CFT breaks down. A black hole of size r H << L is approximated near the horizon by a five-dimensional, static Skhwarzschild solution. Classical radiation into the bulk, and therefore 3 1 Hawking radiation into CFT modes, is suppressed for such light black holes. Namely, while large black holes are shaped like pancakes around the brane, they extend to distances larger than the Ads radius L. Thus they couple to all the CFT modes, including the lightest ones, with M4 couplings, without any suppression. On the other hand, while the small black holes are bulging away from the brane, they are much smaller than the Ads radius, and from the perturbative point of view, they live inside the RS2 "volcano". Hence their classical couplings to all bulk graviton modes are tunneling-suppressed in the sense of Ref. 29, and are exponentially weaker than M4. Thus the radiation rate must go down significantly.b Hence the light black holes evaporate, although more slowly, only via bulk Hawking radiation, where they mostly emit along the brane.30 Since this picture for the evolution of an evaporating black hole is based on specific properties of the UV extension provided by the bulk theory, there is no reason why it should apply to situations that do not have an AdS/CFT dual description.
+
+
2. Conclusions We have reviewed here our recent proposal concerning black holes on branes in Ads space." On the bulk side, this is realized by putting the black hole on a brane in the cutoff AdSD+I bulk, which localizes dynamical gravity. These black holes provide for a dual description of quantum-corrected Ddimensional black holes in CFT+gravity. On the dual side, the quantum Hawking radiation of CFT modes is described as the classical evolution in bThe same effect occurs for a large object on the brane, of mass A4 >> M4 but lower density than a black hole, such as a star. Even if the star had accelerated by being stuck to the brane, the bulk deformation it would cause would have been confined to distances less than L , so its emission would have been tunneling-suppressed. The reason why a black hole radiates in the bulk whereas a star does not is also dual to the problem of the different choices of CFT vacua and boundary conditions for the radiation.
54
the bulk, and the classical bulk point of view may lead to a better understanding of quantum black hole evaporation. In a later we have considered the phenomenological implications of these effects. We expect that many of our results should naturally extend t o any CFT+gravity theory, even if a dual bulk description along the lines of RS2 does not exist. We hope to return t o these questions in the future.
Acknowledgements The author wishes t o express his gratitude t o the organizers of the “BW2003 Workshop” for putting together such a stimulating meeting and for their assistance during the workshop. Particular thanks go t o Goran Djordjevib and Ljubisa Nesib. It is a great pleasure t o thank R. Emparan, A. Fabbri and J. Garcia-Bellido for collaborations which led t o the results presented here and which helped shape author’s thinking on these subjects. Further thanks go to R. Maartens, L. Susskind and T. Tanaka for very useful discussions. The work of NK was supported in part by the DOE Grant DE-FG03-91ER40674, in part by the NSF Grant PHY-0332258 and in part by a Research Innovation Award from the Research Corporation.
References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
10. 11.
12. 13.
L. Randall and R. Sundrum, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 4690 (1999). A. Chamblin, S. W. Hawking and H. S. Reall, Phys. Rev. D61,065007 (2000). M. Bruni, C. Germani and R. Maartens, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 231302 (2001). N. Deruelle, Stars on branes: The view from the brane, gr-qc/0111065. P. Kanti and K. Tamvakis, Phys. Rev. D65, 084010 (2002). R. Casadio, A. Fabbri and L. Mazzacurati, Phys. Rev. D65, 084040 (2002). R. Emparan, G. T. Horowitz and R. C. Myers, JHEP 0001, 007 (2000). R. Emparan, G. T. Horowitz and R. C. Myers, JHEP 0001, 021 (2000). S. Deser, R. Jackiw and G.’t Hooft, Annals Phys. 152, 220 (1984); S. Giddings, J. Abbott and K. Kuchar, Gen. Rel. Grau. 16, 751 (1984); S. Carlip, Quantum Gravity in 2+l Dimensions, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1998). R. Emparan, A. Fabbri and N. Kaloper, Quantum black holes as holograms in A d s braneworlds, hepth/0206155. J. M. Maldacena, Adu. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 231 (1998); S. S. Gubser, I. R. Klebanov and A. M. Polyakov, Phys. Lett. B428, 105 (1998); E. Witten, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 253 (1998); for a review see 0. Aharony, S. S. Gubser, J. M. Maldacena, H. Ooguri and Y. Oz, Phys. Rept. 323,183 (2000). N. Arkani-Hamed, S. Dimopoulos, G. R. Dvali and N. Kaloper, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 586 (2000). J. Maldacena, unpublished; E. Witten, unpublished.
55
14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
H. Verlinde, Nucl. Phys. B580, 264 (2000). S. S. Gubser, Phys. Rev. D63, 084017 (2001). S. B. Giddings, E. Katz and L. Randall, JHEP 0003, 023 (2000). M. J. Duff and J. T. Liu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 2052 (2000). S. B. Giddings and E. Katz, J. Math. Phys. 42, 3082 (2001). N. Arkani-Hamed, M. Porrati and L. Randall, JHEP 0108, 017 (2001). T. Tanaka, Classical black hole evaporation in Randall-Sundrum infinite
braneworld, gr-qc/0203082. 21. N. 0. Santos, MNRAS 216, 403 (1985); A. K. G. de Oliveira, N. 0. Santos and C. Kolassis, MNRAS 216, 1001 (1985). 22. D. M. Capper and M. J. Duff, Phys. Lett. A 5 3 , 361 (1975). 23. S. M. Christensen and S. A. Fulling, Phys. Rev. D15, 2088 (1977). 24. M. Henningson and K. Skenderis, JHEP 9807, 023 (1998). 25. S. de Haro, K. Skenderis and S. N. Solodukhin, Class. Quant. Grav. 18, 3171 (2001). 26. T. Shiromizu and D. Ida, Phys. Rev. D64, 044015 (2001). 27. S. Kanno and J. Soda, Brane world effective action at low energies and AdS/CFT, hep-t h/0205 188. 28. T. Shiromizu, K. I. Maeda and M. Sasaki, Phys. Rev. D62, 024012 (2000). 29. S. Dimopoulos, S. Kachru, N. Kaloper, A. E. Lawrence and E. Silverstein, Phys. Rev. D64, 121702 (2001); Generating small numbers b y tunneling in multi-throat compactifications, hepth/0106128. 30. R. Emparan, G. T. Horowitz and R. C. Myers, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 499 (2000). 31. R. Emparan, J. Garcia-Bellido and N. Kaloper, JHEP 0301, 079 (2003).
YUKAWA QUASI-UNIFICATION A N D INFLATION
G. LAZARIDES AND C. PALLIS Physics Division, School of Technology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece E-mail:
[email protected],
[email protected] We review the construction of a concrete supersymmetric grand unified model, which naturally leads to a moderate violation of 'ksymptotic'' Yukawa unification and, thus, can allow an acceptable b-quark mass within the constrained minimal supersymmetric standard model with p > 0. The model possesses a wide and natural range of parameters which is consistent with the data on the cold dark matter abundance in the universe, b + sy,the muon anomalous magnetic moment and the Higgs boson masses. Also, it automatically leads to a new version of shifted hybrid inflation, which avoids overproduction of monopoles at the end of inflation by using only renormalizable terms.
1. Introduction The most restrictive version of the minimal supersymmetric standard model (MSSM) with gauge coupling unification, radiative electroweak breaking and universal boundary conditions from gravity-mediated soft supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking, known as constrained MSSM (CMSSM)l, can be made even more predictive, if we impose Yukawa unification (W),1.e. ' assume that the three third generation Yukawa coupling constants unify at the SUSY grand unified theory (GUT) scale, MGTJT.The requirement of W can be achieved by embedding the MSSM in a SUSY GUT with a gauge group containing SU(4), and SU(2),. Indeed, assuming that the electroweak Higgs superfields hy", hzw and the third family right handed quark superfields t C ,b" form SU(2), doublets, we obtain2 the 'asymptotic' Yukawa coupling relation ht = h b and, hence, large t a n 0 mt/mb. Moreover, if the third generation quark and lepton SU(2), doublets [singlets] 43 and l3 [b" and T " ] form a SU(4), 4-plet [a-plet] and the Higgs doublet QW which couples to them is a SU(4), singlet, we get h b = h, and the 'asymptotic' relation m b = m7 follows. The simplest GUT gauge group which contains both SU(4), and SU(2), is the Pati-Salam (PS) group
-
56
57
GPS = SU(4), x SU(2), x SU(2), and we will use it in our analysis. However, applying W in the context of the CMSSM and given the experimental values of the top-quark and tau-lepton masses (which naturally restrict t a n p N 50), the resulting value of the b-quark mass turns out to be unacceptable. This is due to the fact that, in the large t a n p regime, the tree-level b-quark mass receives sizeable SUSY correction^^^^^^*^ (about 20%), which have the sign of p (with the standard sign convention7) and drive, for p > [
2.684 GeV 5 mb(MZ) 5 3.092 GeV with a , ( M z ) = 0.1185.
(1)
This is derived by appropriately' evolving the corresponding range of m b ( m b ) in the M S scheme (i.e. 3.95 - 4.55 GeV) up to M z in accordance with Ref. 9. We see that, for both signs of p, W leads to an unacceptable b-quark mass with the p < 0 case being less disfavored. A way out of this m b problem can be found8 without abandoning the CMSSM (in contrast to the usual strategy6~10~11~12) or YU altogether. We can rather modestly correct W by including an extra SU(4)c non-singlet Higgs superfield with Yukawa couplings to the quarks and leptons. The Higgs SU(2), doublets contained in this superfield can naturally develop13 subdominant vacuum expectation values (VEVs) and mix with the main electroweak doublets, which are assumed to be SU(4), singlets and form a SU(2), doublet. This mixing can, in general, violate SU(2),. Consequently, the resulting electroweak Higgs doublets h;w, do not form a su(2)R doublet and also break SU(4),. The required deviation from YU is expected to be more pronounced for p > 0. Despite this, we will study here this case, since the p < 0 case has been excluded14 by combining the Wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe (WMAP) re~trictions'~ on the cold dark matter (CDM) in the universe with the recent experimental results16 on the inclusive branching ratio BR(b 4 sy). The same SUSY GUT model which, for p > 0 and universal boundary conditions, remedies the m b problem leads to a new version17 of shifted hybrid inflation", which avoids monopole overproduction at the end of inflation and, in contrast to the older version1', is based only on renormalizable interactions. In Sec. 2, we review the construction of a SUSY GUT model which modestly violates W, yielding an appropriate Yukawa quasi-unification condition (YQUC), which is derived in Sec. 3. We then describe the resulting CMSSM in Sec. 4 and introduce the various cosmological and phenomenclogical requirements which restrict its parameter space in Sec. 5. In Sec. 6,
58
we delineate the allowed range of parameters for p > 0 and, in Sec. 7, we outline the corresponding inflationary scenario. Finally, in Sec. 8, we summarize our conclusions. 2. The SUSY GUT Model We will take the SUSY GUT model of shifted hybrid inflation" (see also Ref. 19) as our starting point. It is based on Gps, which is the simplest gauge group that can lead to W. The representations under GPS and the global charges of the various matter and Higgs superfields contained in this model are presented in Table 1 , which also contains the extra Higgs superfields required for accommodating an adequate violation of W (see below). The matter superfields are Fi and FF (i = 1 , 2 , 3 ) , while the electroweak Higgs doublets belong to the superfield h. So, all the requirements for exact W are fulfilled. The breaking of GPS down to the standard model (SM) gauge group GSM is achieved by the superheavy VEVs (N MGUT)of the right handed neutrino type components of a conjugate pair of Higgs superfields H", I?. The model also contains a gauge singlet S which triggers the breaking of GPS, a SU(4), 6-plet G which gives2' masses to the right handed down quark type components of H", H " , and a pair of gauge sinfor solving21 the p problem of the MSSM via a Peccei-Quinn glets N , (PQ) symmetry. In addition to Gps, the model possesses two global U ( l ) symmetries, namely a R and a PQ symmetry, as well as a discrete Z:* symmetry ('matter parity'). A moderate violation of exact W can be naturally accommodated in this model by adding a new Higgs superfield h' with Yukawa couplings FF'h'. Actually, (15,2,2)is the only representation, besides (1,2,2),which possesses such couplings to the fermions. In order to give superheavy masses to the color non-singlet components of h', we need to include one more Higgs superfield h' with the superpotential coupling h'h', whose coefficient is of the order of MGUT. After the breaking of Gps to GSM,the two color singlet SU(2), doublets h i , hi contained in h' can mix with the corresponding doublets h l , h2 in h. This is mainly due to the terms h'h' and H'n'h'h. Actually, since
w
H c H c = ( 4 , 1 , 2 ) ( 4 , 1 , 2 )= ( 1 5 , 1 , 1 + 3 ) + . . -, h'h = (15,2,2)(1,2,2)= ( 1 5 , 1 , 1 + 3) + . * * , there are two independent couplings of the type H"A"L'h (both suppressed by the string scale MS M 5 x lo" GeV, being non-renormalizable). One of
59
Table 1. Superfield Content of the Model Superfields
Representations
Global
under Gps ~~
Symmetries
R
PQ
Z;"
0
~
Matter Fields
Higgs Fields
h
(1,212)
0
1
N
(1,1,1)
1/2
-1
0
N
( 1 , L 1)
0
1
0
Extra Higgs Fields
them is between the su(2)R singlets in H'H" and h'h, and the other between the SU(2)R-triplets in these combinations. So, we obtain two bilinear terms h',hl and hhh2 with different coefficients, which are suppressed by M G U T / M ~These . terms together with the terms hih', and hhhh from h'h', which have equal coefficients, generate different mixings between hl , h', and h2, hh. Consequently, the resulting electroweak doublets h;", h5w contain SU(4), violating components suppressed by MGUT/MSand fail t o form a s u ( 2 ) R doublet by an equally suppressed amount. So, YU is moderately violated. Unfortunately, as it turns out, this violation is not adequate for correcting the b-quark mass within the CMSSM for p > 0. In order to allow for a more sizable violation of YU, we further extend the model by including q5 with the coupling q5h'h. To give superheavy masses t o the color non-singlets in 4, we introduce one more superfield 4 with the coupling 64, whose coefficient is of order MGUT.
60
The terms $4 and $H"B" imply that, after the breaking of Gps t o GSM, 4 acquires a superheavy VEV of order MGUT.The coupling &'h then generates SU(2)R violating unsuppressed bilinear terms between the doublets in h' and h. These terms can certainly overshadow the corresponding ones from the non-renormalizable term HcHcK'h. The resulting SU(2), violating mixing of the doublets in h and h' is then unsuppressed and we can obtain stronger violation of W.
3. The Yukawa Quasi-Unification Condition
To further analyze the mixing of the doublets in h and h', observe that the part of the superpotential corresponding to the symbolic couplings i'h', &'h is properly written as mtr (h't7L'c)
+ ptr (~ ' ~ 4 7 L,t )
(2)
where EE is the antisymmetric 2 x 2 matrix with €12 = +1, t r denotes trace taken with respect t o the SU(4), and SU(2), indices and tilde denotes the transpose of a matrix. After the breaking of Gps t o GSM,4 acquires a VEV (4) MGUT. Substituting it by this VEV in the above couplings, we obtain N
tr(h'&'E)
= ?lchi
+ hl,eh; + . .. ,
- = -tr(h'EashE) (4) - tr(h'e4he) d
(3)
(4) = = -(h:ehz
Jz
- k1&!J
,
(4)
where the ellipsis in Eq. (3) contains the colored components of h', h' and a3 = diag(1, -1). Inserting Eqs. (3) and (4) into Eq. (2), we obtain
m%E(hh - alhz) + m($
+ a1i1)eG
with
a1
= -p($)/z/2m.
(5)
So, we get two pairs of superheavy doublets with mass m. They are predominantly given by
The orthogonal combinations of h l , h', and hz, hh constitute the electroweak doublets
The superheavy doublets in Eq. (6) must have vanishing VEVs, which readily implies that ( h i ) = - a l ( h l ) , (ha) = al(h2). Equation (7) then
61
+
gives (h;") = (1 la112)1/2(h1), (h;") = (1+ l a 1 1 ~ ) l / ~ ( hFrom 2 ) . the third generation Yukawa couplings y33F3hFi1 2yi3F3h'Fi, we obtain
where p = yi3/y33. From Eqs. ( 8 ) and (9), we see that YU is now replaced by the YQUC,
h t : h b : h, = ( l + c ) : (1 - c ) : (1+3c), with 0 < c = p a l / & <
1 . (10)
For simplicity, we restricted ourselves to real values of c only which lie between zero and unity. 4. The resulting CMSSM
Below MGUT,the particle content of our model reduces t o this of MSSM (modulo SM singlets). We assume universal soft SUSY breaking scalar masses mo, gaugino masses M1/2and trilinear scalar couplings A0 at MGUT. Therefore, the resulting MSSM is the so-called CMSSM' with p > 0 and supplemented by Eq. (10). With these initial conditions, we run the MSSM renormalization group equations ( R G E s ) ~ between ~ MGUTand a common SUSY threshold MSUSYN (m;,m;2)1/2 ( i 1 , 2 are the stop mass eigenstates) determined in consistency with the SUSY spectrum. At MSUSY,we impose radiative electroweak symmetry breaking, evaluate the SUSY spectrum and incorporate the SUSY correction^^>^>^ to the b and T masses. Note that the corrections to the T mass (almost 4%) lead14 to a small reduction of tanp. From MSUSYto M z , the running of gauge and Yukawa coupling constants is continued using the SM RGEs. For presentation purposes, M1/2 and mo can be replaced22 by the lightest SUSY particle (LSP) mass, m ~ s p and , the relative mass splitting between this particle and the lightest stau ?2, A, = (mq - ~ L S P ) / ~ L S P . For simplicity, we restrict this presentation to the A0 = 0 case (for A0 # 0 see Refs. 8 and 23). So, our input parameters are mLSp and A,. For any given m b ( M Z ) in the range in Eq. (1) and with fixed mt(mt)= 166 GeV and m,(Mz) = 1.746 GeV, we can determine the parameters c and tan@ at MSUSYso that the YQUC in Eq. (10) is satisfied.
62
5. Cosmological and Phenomenological Constraints Restrictions on the parameters of our model can be derived by imposing a number of cosmological and phenomenological requirements (for similar recent analyses, see Refs. 11, 12 and 24). These constraints result from: Cold dark matter considerations. In the context of CMSSM, the LSP can be the lightest neutralino. It naturally arises25 as a CDM candidate. We require its relic abundance, &ph2, not t o exceed the 95% c.1. upper bound on the CDM abundance derived15 by WMAP: RCDMh2
5 0.13.
(11)
We calculate S2Lsph2 using micrOMEGAs26, which is certainly one of the most complete publicly available codes. It includes all possible coannihilation processes27 and one-loop QCD corrections2' to the Higgs decay widths and couplings to fermions. Branching ratio of b + sy. Taking into account the recent experimental results16 on this ratio, BR(b --f sy), and combining' appropriately the experimental and theoretical errors involved, we obtain the following 95% c.1. range: 1.9 x
5 BR(b + sr) 5 4.6 x l o p 4 .
(12)
We compute BR(b --+ sy) by using an updated version of the relevant calculation contained in the micrOMEGAs package26. In this code, the SM contribution is calculated following Ref. 29. The charged Higgs ( H * ) contribution is evaluated by including the next-to-leading order (NLO) QCD corrections3' and tan ,B enhanced contribution^^^. The dominant SUSY contribution includes resummed NLO SUSY QCD corrections3', which hold for large tanp. Muon anomalous magnetic moment. The deviation, Sap, of the measured value of a, from its predicted value in the SM, aEM,can be attributed to SUSY contributions, calculated by using the micrOMEGAs routine31. The calculation of aEMis not yet stabilized mainly because of the instability of the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution. According to the most up-to-date e ~ a l u a t i o n there ~ ~ , is still a considerable discrepancy between the findings based on the e+e- annihilation data and the ones based on the r-decay data. Taking into account these results and the experimental m e a ~ u r e r n e n tof~ ~a,, we get the following 95% c.1. ranges: -0.53 x 10-l'
-13.6 x 10-l'
5 Sap 5 44.7 x 10-l' , 5 Sap 5 28.4 x 10-l' ,
e+e--based ; -r-based.
(13) (14)
63
2.0
1.6
$3.0
0.6
0.0 300
200
300
400
600
600
700
Figure 1. The various restrictions on the m ~ -~Afzp plane for p > 0, A0 = 0 and a S ( M z )= 0.1185. From left to right, the solid lines depict the lower bounds on m L S p from baP < 44.7 x 10-lo, BR(b + sy) > 1.9 x lop4 and m h > 114.4 GeV and the upper bound on m ~ s from p R ~ s p h<~0.13 for m b ( M z ) = 2.888 GeV. The dashed [dotted] line depicts the bound on m L S p from R ~ s p < h ~ 0.13 for m b ( M z ) = 2.684 [3.092] GeV. The allowed area for m b ( M z ) = 2.888 GeV is shaded.
Following the common practice24, we adopt the restrictions to parameters induced by Eq. (13), since Eq. (14) is considered as quite oracular, due to poor r-decay data. 0 Collider bounds. Here, the only relevant collider bound is the 95% c.1. LEP bound34 on the mass of the lightest CP-even neutral Higgs boson h: rnh
2 114.4 GeV.
(15)
The SUSY corrections to mh are calculated at two loops by using the FeynHiggsFast program35 included in the micrOMEGAs code26. 6. The Allowed Parameter Space
We will now try to delineate the parameter space of our model with p > 0 which is consistent with the constraints in Sec. 5. The restrictions on the mLSp plane, for Ao = 0 and the central values of a , ( M z ) = 0.1185 and rnb(Mz) = 2.888 GeV, are indicated in Fig. 1 by solid lines, while the upper bound on m ~ s pfrom Eq. ( l l ) , for r n b ( M ~= ) 2.684 [3.092] GeV, is depicted by a dashed [dotted] line. We observe the following:
64
3000
2500
2000
c3 v u) 1600 u)
Q
E 1000 500
-
0 'LOO
200
300
400
600
600
700
Figure 2. The mass parameters m~ and Msusy as functions of mLSp for various values of A,, which are indicated on the curves. We take p > 0, A0 = 0, m b ( M ~=) 2.888 GeV and cu,(Mz) = 0.1185.
3000
2500
0
'LOO
200
300
m,B
400
600
600
700
(GeV)
Figure 3. The mass parameters m A and Msusy versus m ~ for~ p p> 0, A0 = 0, A, = 1, a,(Mz) = 0.1185 and with m b ( M z ) = 2.684 GeV (dashed lines), 3.092 GeV (dotted lines) or 2.888 GeV (solid lines).
65
0
The lower bounds on mLSp are not so sensitive to the variations of mb(MZ)* The lower bound on mLSp from Eq. (15) overshadows all others. The upper bound on mLSp from Eq. (11) is very sensitive to the variations of mb(MZ). In particular, one notices the extreme sensitivity of the almost vertical part of the corresponding line, where the LSP annihilation via an A-boson exchange in the s-channel is36 by far the dominant process, since mA, which is smaller than 2 m ~ s pis , always very close to it as seen from Fig. 2. This sensitivity can be understood from Fig. 3, where V Z A is depicted versus mLSp for various mb(MZ)’s. We see that, as mb(MZ) decreases, mA increases and approaches 2 m ~ s p .The A-pole annihilation is then enhanced and RLsph2 is drastically reduced causing an increase of the upper bound on mLsp. For A?2 < 0.25, bino-stau c~annihilations~~ take over leading to a very pronounced reduction of R ~ s h2, p thereby enhancing the upper limit on mLSp.
For p > 0, a,(Mz) = 0.1185 and mb(MZ) = 2.888 GeV, we find the following allowed ranges of parameters: 176 GeV 5 mLSp
5 615 GeV,
0 5 A, 585tanP559, 0.145~50.17.
5 1.8,
7. The Inflationary Scenario One of the most promising inflationary scenarios is hybrid inflation37, which uses two real scalars: one which provides the vacuum energy for inflation and a second which is the slowly varying field during inflation. This scheme is naturally i n ~ o r p o r a t e din~ ~ SUSY GUTS, but in its standard realization has the following problem39: if the GUT gauge symmetry breaking predicts monopoles (and this is the case of Gps), they are copiously produced at the end of inflation leading to a cosmological catastrophe4’. One way to remedy this is to generate a shifted inflationary trajectory, so that GPS is already broken during inflation. This could be achievedl8 in our SUSY GUT model even before the introduction of the extra Higgs superfields, but only by utilizing non-renormalizable terms. However, the introduction of 4 and 4 very naturally gives rise17 to a shifted inflationary path with the use of renormalizable interactions only.
66
7.1. The Shifted Inflationary Path The superpotential terms which are relevant for inflation are given by
W = r;S(H"I? - M 2 ) - pSq52 + m&
+ X$H"H",
(17)
where M , m MGUT N 2.86 x 10l6 GeV, and K , p and X are dimensionless coupling constants with M , m, K , X > 0 by field redefinitions. For simplicity, we take p > 0. (The parameters are normalized so that they correspond to the couplings between the SM singlet components of the superfields.) The scalar potential obtained from W is given by N
+ 12pS4 - mr$I2 + Im4 + X H c 8 c \ 2 + x6l2 ( 1 ~ ~ +1 21 1 ~ 1 ~ ) + D - terms. (18)
V = I K ( H ' P - M 2 ) - ,@b2l2
+
(Ks
Vanishing of the D-terms yields H" * = ei'HC (H", H c lie in their right handed neutrino directions). We restrict ourselves to the direction with 2f) = 0 which contains the shifted inflationary path and the SUSY vacua (see below). Performing appropriate R and gauge transformations, we bring S , H" and H c to the positive real axis. From the potential in Eq. (18), we find that the SUSY vacuum lies at
HCHC
-2M2
II
(z)2
7
1 = - (I2<
4
2
J1-), = -.J"P (2) M '
(19)
with 5' = 0 and 6 = 0, where E = pX2M2/tcm2 < 1/4. The potential possesses a shifted flat direction (besides the trivial one) at
-+) H'H" M2 with S
2
=
2K2(&+1)+$ 2(K2 X2)
+
,
p / z ,(3
K
= --s, X
(20)
> 0 and a constant potential energy density VOgiven by
which can be used as inflationary path. VO# 0 breaks SUSY on this path, while the constant non-zero values of H", H" break the GUT gauge symmetry too. The SUSY breaking implies the existence of one-loop radiative correction^^^ which lift the classical flatness of this path, yielding the necessary inclination for driving the inflaton towards the SUSY vacuum. The one-loop radiative corrections to V along the shifted inflationary trajectory are calculated by using the Coleman-Weinberg formula42:
67
where the sum extends over all helicity states i, Fi and Mi2 are the fermion number and mass squared of the ith state, and A is a renormalization mass scale. In order to use this formula for creating a logarithmic slope which drives the canonically normalized real inflaton field (T = d m S / X towards the minimum, one has first to derive the mass spectrum of the model on the shifted inflationary path. This is a quite complicated task and we will skip it here.
7.2. Inflationary Observables The slow roll parameters are given by (see e.g. Ref. 43)
where the primes denote derivation with respect to the real normalized inflaton field (T and mp 21 2.44 x 10l8 GeV is the reduced Planck scale. The conditions for inflation to take place are E 5 1 and lql 5 1. Calculating the number of e-foldings NQ that our present horizon scale suffered during inflation, we obtain the following relation (see e.g. Ref. 43):
where uf [(TQ] is the value of o at the end of inflation [when our present horizon scale crossed outside the inflationary horizon] and T, N lo9 GeV is the reheat temperature taken to saturate the gravitino c o n ~ t r a i n t ~ ~ . The quadrupole anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background radiation can be calculated as follows (see e.g. Ref. 43):
which is its central value from the cosmic Fixing ( ~ T / T )E Q6.6 x background explorer (COBE)45 (assuming that the spectral index n = l ) , we can determine one of the free parameters (say ,6) in terms of the others (m, K and A). For instance, we find ,6 = 0.1, for m = 4.35 x 1015 GeV and IC = X = 3 x In this case, the instability point of the shifted path lies at (T, 2 3.55 x 10l6 GeV, af 21 1.7 x 1017 GeV and OQ N 1.6 x 10l8 GeV43. Also, M 21 2.66 x 10l6 GeV, NQ 21 57.7 and n N 0.98. Note that the slow roll conditions are violated and, thus, inflation ends well before reaching the instability point at ( T ~ We . see that the COBE constraint can be easily satisfied with natural values of the parameters. Moreover, superheavy SM
68
non-singlets with masses << MGUT,which could disturb the unification of the MSSM gauge coupling constants, are not encountered.
7.3. Supergravity Corrections Here, inflation takes place at quite high u ’ s . So, supergravity (SUGRA) corrections are important and could easily invalidate inflation, in contrast to the standard hybrid inflation case, where they can be kept46 under control. This catastrophe can be avoided by invoking a specific Kahler potential (used in no-scale SUGRA models) and a gauge singlet 2 with a similar Kahler potential, as is suggested in Ref. 47. Assuming a superheavy VEV for 2 via D-terms, one can achieve an exact cancellation of the inflaton mass corrections on the shifted path. So, inflation remains intact, but gets considerably corrected via the kinetic terms of (T. We find that, for the (T’S under consideration, the SUGRA corrections have only a small influence on (TQ if we use the same input values for the free increases parameters as in the global SUSY case. On the contrary, (ST/T)Q considerably. However, we can easily readjust the parameters so that the is now N 6.6 x COBE constraint is again met. For instance, (ST/T)Q obtained with m = 3.8 x 1015 GeV keeping K = X = 3 x lop2, p = 0.1 as in global SUSY. In this case, ( T ~N 2.7 x 10l6 GeV, ( ~ N f 1.8 x 1017 GeV and (TQ N 1.6 x lo1* GeV. Also, M 2: 2.6 x 1OI6 GeV, NQ 2: 57.5 and n 2: 0.99.
8. Conclusions We have reviewed the construction of a SUSY GUT model based on the PS gauge group which naturally yields a YQUC, allowing an acceptable b-quark mass within the CMSSM with p > 0. We found that there exists a wide and natural range of parameters consistent with the data on the CDM abundance in the universe, b + sy, the muon anomalous magnetic moment and the Higgs boson masses. Moreover, the model gives rise to a new version of the shifted hybrid inflationary scenario, which avoids overproduction of monopoles at the end of inflation by using only renormalizable interactions.
Acknowledgments We would like to thank M.E. Gbmez, R. Jeannerot and S. Khalil for fruitful and pleasant collaborations from which this work is culled. This work was supported by European Union under the RTN contracts HPRN-CT-200000148 and HPRN-CT-2000-00152.
69
References 1. G. L. Kane, C. Kolda, L. Roszkowski and J. D. Wells, Phys. Rev. D49, 6173 (1994), hepph/9312272. 2. G. Lazarides and C. Panagiotakopoulos, Phys. Lett. B337, 90 (1994), hepph/9403316; S. Khalil, G. Lazarides and C. Pallis, ibid. 508, 327 (2001), hep-ph/0005021. 3. L. Hall, R. Rattazzi and U. Sarid, Phys. Rev. D 50, 7048 (1994), hepph/9306309; M. Carena, M. Olechowski, S. Pokorski and C. E. M. Wagner, Nucl. Phys. B426, 269 (1994), hepph/9402253. 4. D. Pierce, J . Bagger, K. Matchev and R. Zhang, Nucl. Phys. B491,3 (1997), hepph/9606211. 5. M. Carena, D. Garcia, U. Nierste and C. E. M. Wagner, Nucl. Phys. B577, 88 (2000), hep-ph/9912516. 6. S. F. King and M. Oliveira, Phys. Rev. D63,015010 (200l), hepph/0008183. 7. S. Abel et al. (SUGRA Working Group Collaboration), hep-ph/0003154. 8. M. E. G6mez, G. Lazarides and C. Pallis, Nucl. Phys. B638, 165 (2002), hepph/0203131. 9. H. Baer, J. Ferrandis, K. Melnikov and X. Tata, Phys. Rev. D66, 074007 (2002), hepph/0207126. 10. T. Blaiek, R. DermEek and S. Raby, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 111804 (2002), hepph/0107097; Phys. Rev. D65, 115004 (2002), hepph/0201081. 11. D. Auto et. al., J . High Energy Phys. 06, 023 (2003), hep-ph/0302155. 12. U. Chattopadhyay, A. Corsetti and P. Nath, Phys. Rev. D66, 035003 (2002), hepph/0201001; C. Pallis, Nucl. Phys. B678, 398 (2004), hep-ph/0304047. 13. G. Lazarides, Q. Shafi and C. Wetterich, Nucl. Phys. B181, 287 (1981); G. Lazarides and Q. Shafi, ibid. B350, 179 (1991). 14. M. E. G6mez, G. Lazarides and C. Pallis, Phys. Rev. D67, 097701 (2003), hepph/0301064; C. Pallis and M.E. G6mez, hep-ph/0303098. 15. D. Spergel et al., Astrophys. J . Suppl. 148, 175 (2003), astro-ph/0302209. 16. R. Barate et al. (ALEPH Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B429, 169 (1998); K. Abe et al. (BELLE Collaboration), ibid. 511, 151 (2001), hep-ex/0103042; S. Chen et al. (CLEO Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 251807 (2001), hepex/0108032. 17. R. Jeannerot, S. Khalil and G. Lazarides, J . High Energy Phys. 07, 069 (2002), hep-ph/0207244. 18. R. Jeannerot, S. Khalil, G. Lazarides and Q. Shafi, J. High Energy Phys. 10, 012 (2000), hepph/0002151. 19. G. Lazarides, hepph/0011130; R. Jeannerot, S. Khalil and G. Lazarides, hepph/0106035. 20. I. Antoniadis and G. K. Leontaris, Phys. Lett. B216, 333 (1989). 21. G. Lazarides and Q. Shafi, Phys. Rev. D58,071702 (1998), hepph/9803397. 22. M. E. G6mez, G. Lazarides and C. Pallis, Phys. Rev. D61, 123512 (2000), hepph/9907261; Phys. Lett. B487, 313 (2000), hepph/0004028. 23. M. E. G6mez and C. Pallis, hepph/0303094 (in the SUSYO2 Proceedings). 24. J . Ellis, K. A. Olive, Y. Santoso and V.C. Spanos, Phys. Lett. B565, 176
70
25.
26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
31. 32. 33. 34.
35. 36. 37. 38. 39.
40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47.
(2003), hepph/0303043; A. B. Lahanas and D. V. Nanopoulos, ibid. 568,55 (2003), hep-ph/0303130; H. Baer and C. Balbs, JCAP 05, 006 (2003), hepph/0303114; U. Chattopadhyay, A. Corsetti and P. Nath, Phys. Rev. D68, 035005 (2003), hepph/0303201. H. Goldberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 1419 (1983); J. R. Ellis, J. S. Hagelin, D. V. Nanopoulos, K. A. Olive and M. Srednicki, Nucl. Phys. B238, 453 (1984). G. BBlanger, F. Boudjema, A. Pukhov and A. Semenov, Comput. Phys. Commun. 149, 103 (2002), hep-ph/0112278. J. Ellis, T. Falk, K. A. Olive and M. Srednicki, Astropart. Phys. E13, 181 (2000); ibid. 15, 413 (2001), hepph/9905481. A. Djouadi, J. Kalinowski and M. Spira, Comput. Phys. Commun. 108, 56 (1998), hepph/9704448. A. L. Kagan and M. Neubert, Eur. Phys. J. C7, 5 (1999), hepph/9805303; P. Gambino and M. Misiak, Nucl. Phys. B611,338 (2001), hepph/0104034. M. Ciuchini, G. Degrassi, P. Gambino and G. Giudice, Nucl. Phys. B527, 21 (1998), hepph/9710335; G. Degrassi, P. Gambino and G. F. Giudice, J . High Energy Phys. 12, 009 (2000), hepph/0009337. S. Martin and J. Wells, Phys. Rev. D64, 035003 (2001), hep-ph/0103067. M. Davier, hepex/0312065 (to appear in the SIGHAD03 Proceedings). G. W. Bennett et al. (Muon 9-2 Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. E89, 101804 (2002); ibid. 89, 129903 (2002), hepex/0208001. ALEPH, DELPHI, L3 and OPAL Collaborations, The LEP Higgs working group for Higgs boson searches, hepex/0107029; LHWG-NOTE/2002-01, [http://lephiggs.web.cern.ch/LEPHIGGS/papers/July2002SM/index.html] . S. Heinemeyer, W. Hollik and G. Weiglein, hepph/0002213. A. B. Lahanas, D. V. Nanopoulos and V. C. Spanos, Phys. Rev. D62,023515 (ZOOO), hepph/9909497. A. D. Linde, Phys. Rev. D49, 748 (1994), astro-ph/9307002. E. J. Copeland, A. R. Liddle, D. H. Lyth, E. D. Stewart and D. Wands, Phys. Rev. D49, 6410 (1994), astro-ph/9401011. G. Lazarides and C. Panagiotakopoulos, Phys. Rev. D52, 559 (1995), hepph/9506325; R. Jeannerot, S. Khalil and G. Lazarides, Phys. Lett. B506, 344 (2001), hepph/0103229. T. W. B. Kibble, J. Phys. A9, 1387 (1976). G. Dvali, R. Schaefer and Q. Shafi, Phys. Rev. D73, 1886 (1994), hepph/9406319. S. Coleman and E. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. D7, 1888 (1973). G. Lazarides, Lect. Notes Phys. 592, 351 (2002), hep-ph/0111328; hepph/0204294. M. Yu. Khlopov and A. D. Linde, Phys. Lett. B138, 265 (1984); J. Ellis, J. E. Kim and D. V. Nanopoulos, ibid. 145, 181 (1984). C. L. Bennett et al., Astrophys. J . L1, 464 (1996), astro-ph/9601067. G. Lazarides, R. K. Schaefer and Q. Shafi, Phys. Rev. D56, 1324 (1997), hepph/9608256. C. Panagiotakopoulos, Phys. Lett. B459, 473 (1999), hep-ph/9904284.
SUPERSYMMETRIC GRAND UNIFICATION: THE QUEST FOR THE THEORY
A. M E L F O ( ~ )G. , SENJANOVIC(~) ('1 Centro d e Fisica Fundamental, Universidad de Los Andes, Mkrida, Venezuela (2) International
Centre for Theoretical Physics, 34100 Trieste, Italy
With the advent of neutrino masses, it has become more and more acknowledged that SO(10) is a more suitable theory than SU(5): it leads naturally t o small neutrino masses via the see-saw mechanism, it has a simpler and more predictive Yukawa sector. There is however a rather strong disagreement on what the minimal consistent SO(10) theory is, i.e. what the Higgs sector is. The issue is particularly sensitive in the context of low-energy supersymmetry.
1. Introduction Supersymmetric Grand Unification has been one of the main extensions of the Standard Model (SM) for now more than two decades. Today, however, it is in search of a universally accepted minimal, consistent model. With the growing evidence for neutrino masses,' it is becoming more and more clear that the SU(5) theory is not good enough: it contains too many parameters in the Yukawa sector. The situation is much more appealing in the SO( 10) scenario, which is custom fit to explain small neutrino masses in a simple and fairly predictive manner. The main dispute lies in the breaking of SO(10) down to the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM), in the delicate question of the choice of the Higgs superfields. Roughly speaking, there are two schools of thought: one that sticks to the small representations, which guarantees asymptotic freedom above MGUT,but must make use of higher dimensional operators, suppressed by M p l ; one that argues in favor of the renormalizable theory only, even at the price of becoming strong between MGUT and the Planck scale. Each program has its pros and cons. The first one in a sense goes beyond grand unification by appealing to the string picture in order to provide additional horizontal symmetries needed to simplify the theory plagued by many cou71
72
plings. The second one is based on pure grand unification, with the hope that the Planck scale physics plays a negligible role. It is the second one that we discuss at length in this talk.
2. Why grand unification and why supersymmetry ?
No excuse needs to be offered for the natural wish to unify the strong and electro-weak interactions. This appealing idea has two important generic features: proton decay and the existence of magnetic monopoles. They are by themselves sufficient reason to pursue the unification scenario. There are three important reasons to incorporate low-energy supersymmetry in this program: i) the hierarchy problem of the Higgs mass, ii) the gauge coupling unification, and iii) the Higgs mechanism in the form of radiative symmetry breaking. Let us briefly discuss them. 0
0
0
Supersymmetry per se says nothing about the smallness of the Higgs mass (the hierarchy problem), it just keeps the perturbative effect small, the way that chiral symmetries protect small Yukawa couplings. The old feelings that this might not be such a big deal, since the cosmological constant does not get protected in a similar way, are becoming more widespread today. Gauge coupling unification of the MSSM is a rather remarkable phenomenon, but its meaning is not completely clear. Namely, if one believes in a desert between MWand M G ~ T then , this becomes a crucial ingredient. The desert is a property of the minimal gauge group, SU(5), which is not a good theory of neutrino masses. In SO(lO), on the other hand, supersymmetry is not essential at all; the theory works even better without supersymmetry since then it predicts intermediate scales in the range lo1' - 1014GeV, ideal for neutrino masses via the see-saw mechanism13and for lept~genesis.~ It is worth stressing though that supersymmetric grand unification was anticipated already in 1981, and it gave a rationale for a heavy top quark with a mass around 200GeV (needed to increase the p parameter and help change sin2Bw from its then accepted value of 0.20 to the current 0.23). Radiative symmetry breaking and the Higgs mechanism. The tachyonic property of the Higgs mass term has bothered people for a long time. It is of course purely a question of taste, for either sign of M$ is equally probable. Since the charged sfermion mass terms are definitely not tachyonic, in supersymmetry one could
73
ask why is the Higgs scalar so special. The answer is rather simple: if the nature if the scalar mass terms is determined by some large scale, and if all m2 > 0, it turns out that the Higgs doublet coupled to the top quark rather naturally becomes tachyonic at low scales due to the large top Yukawa coupling. This was kind of prophetic more than twenty years ago, and it could be a rationale for such a heavy top quark. Admittedly a little fine-tuning is still needed between the so-called p term and the stop mass, but wether this is a small or a large problem is still disputable. Suppose we accept low energy supersymmetry as natural in grand unification. We then face the task of identifying the minimal consistent supersymmetric grand unified theory and then hope that it will be confirmed by experiment. Due to the miraculous gauge coupling unification in the MSSM, we are then tempted to accept the idea of the desert. Since the desert is a natural property of SU(5), it is not surprising that SU(5) was considered for a long time the main candidate for a supersymmetric GUT. Why not stick to this idea? The point is that SU(5), at least in its simplest form, favors massless neutrinos. Higher dimensional operators can only provide small neutrino masses, not large enough to explain Amzdot I I 10-'eV2 and especially Am; I I10-3eV2. While we can try to remedy this in one way or another, the fact is that the realistic theory needs too many parameters to be predictive. Let us try to justify this claim by analyzing SU(5) in some detail.
3. Supersymmetric SU(5) The minimal Higgs sector needed to break the symmetry completely down U ( l ) e mx s U ( 3 ) , consists of the adjoint 2 4 and ~ two fundamentals 5 8 and 5 ~ The . Higgs superpotential is quite simple
td
+ X ( 2 4 ~ +) @~ H
W H =m(24p)
5H
+a 5 H 2
4 S ~H
(1)
and so is the Yukawa one WY = Y d 1oF 5 F 5 H
+ y.u 1oF 1oF 5 H
(2)
since the charged fermions belong to 5~ and 1 0 ~ . The above theory is usually called the minimal supersymmetric SU(5) theory. It apparently has a small number of parameters: 3 real
Yd
(after diagonalization)
74
0
0 0
2 x 6 = 12 real yu (yu is a symmetric matrix in generation space) 2 real p , m (after rotations) 2 x 2 = 4 real A, a
In total, 21 real parameters. The trouble is that the theory fails badly.5 Neutrinos are massless, and thus Ve = 1; furthermore, the relations me = md at MCUT fail, except for the third generation. The most conservative approach would be to blame the failure in the absence of higher dimensional operators, this way no change in the structure of the theory is needed. Neutrino masses are then given by the Weinberg-type operator
W," = y v
5 5 5 5
H
MPl
(3)
giving 0
6 x 2 = 12 new real parameters in yv.
Similarly, we must add higher dimensional operators to (2),
(we have omitted SU(5) indices, and represented contraction with indices in 2 4 with ~ a bracket). This means 0
9x 2x2
+ 6 x 2 x 2 = 60 real parameters
and then most predictability is gone. What remains? First, mb = mT is still there, still a success. Gauge couplings unify as we know, but the GUT scale is not predicted precisely as often claimed in the literature. The point is that, for the sake of consistency, one should add higher dimensional operators to (l),so that one expects AWH = CI-
Tr24; MP1
(33-24:)' +cz
Mp1
(5)
and if the coupling X in (1) were to be small, these terms would become important. But X is a Yukawa type coupling, i.e. it is self-renormalizable, so it can be naturally small. This point is worth discussing further. At the renormalizable tree level, one gets the same masses for the color octet and the s U ( 2 ) ~triplet in 2 4 ~ :m8 = m3. This is almost always assumed when the running from MGUT to MW is studied. Now, if X is small, the ci terms in ( 5 ) can dominate; if so, one gets m3 = 4mg. This
75
fact alone suffices to increase MGUT by an order of magnitude above the usually quoted value MSUT N 10l'GeV (calculated with ci = 0). Similarly, the masses of the colored triplets T and T in 5H and S H would get increased by a factor of about 30, and the d = 5-induced proton life-time by about lo3. More precisely, one obtains
where the superscript
denotes the tree-level value m3 = ma. In this case
ma
N
M&JT MP1
so that
With MSUT N 101'GeV, this means
MGUT N lOM&,, , mT
N
32mT. 0
(10)
It should be stressed that X small is natural technically, as much as a small electron Yukawa coupling. Taking X N 0(1)and ruling out the theory would be equivalent to finding that the SM does not work with all the Yukawa couplings being of order one, and insisting on this as if you didn't know fermion masses. Taking into account non-renormalizable interactions can thus save the theory. It is important to recall that without them, the minimal SU(5) does not make sense anyway, predicting as it does m, = 0 and md = me;once this is corrected the theory is still valid. Of course, if one prefers the renormalizable theory, one needs new states such as 45H (in order to correct md = me),or 1 5 to~ give neutrino masses, or three (at least two) singlet right-handed neutrinos. This introduces even more uncertainties in the computations of MGUT and ~ p In . short, the minimal realistic supersymmetric SU(5) theory is not yet ruled out. It is indispensable to improve the experimental limit on ~p by two-three orders of magnitude. Grand unification needs desperately a new generation of proton decay experiments.
76
In the supersymmetric version of SU(5), there is yet another drawback.
As much as the MSSM, it allows for the d = 4 proton decay through terms like
AW = mX' 1 0 S ~F S F
(11)
which contains both
+
A' (vcDcDc QLD") (12) This is a disaster (unless A' 5 10-l'). A way out is assumed through the imposition of R-parity, or equivalently matter parity M : F -+ -F, H -+ H , where F stands for the fermionic (matter) superfields and H for the Higgs ones. Grand unification ought to do better than this, and SO(10) does it as we shall see. In any case, SU(5) does a poor job in the neutrino sector and in the charged fermion sector it is either incomplete or it has too many parameters. One would have to include extra horizontal symmetries, and this route is in some sense beyond grand unification and often needs strings attached. If we stick to the pure grand unification, we better move on to SO(10). 4. Towards unification: Pati-Salam symmetry Quark-Lepton unification can be considered a first step towards the complete SO( 10) unification of a family of fermions in a single representation. Many interesting features of SO(10) GUTS, such as a renormalizable seesaw and R-parity conservation, are already present in partial unification based on the Pati-Salam group GPS = SU(4), x S u ( 2 ) ~ x S u ( 2 ) ~so , it is instructive to review the situation there. Later, when we turn to SO(lO), decomposition of representation under the Pati-Salam subgroup will prove to be the most useful. To simplify the discussion, imagine a two-step breaking of the PS symmetry down to the MSSM
- -
s u ( 2 ) L x s u ( 2 ) R x su(4)c
su(2)L x s u ( 2 ) R x U(1)B-L x S u ( 3 ) ~ SU(2)L x W(1)y x SU(3),.
(13)
The first steps breaks GPS down to its maximal subgroup, the LR (LeftRight) group,8 and it is simply achieved through the vev of and adjoint representation (the numbers in parenthesis indicate the GPS representations)
A = (15,1,1).
(14)
77
In turn, the breaking of the L R group can be achieved by having s U ( 2 ) ~ triplets fields, with B - L = 2, acquiring a vev. Triplets will couple to ferniions and give a mass to right-handed neutrino, providing the see-saw mechanism at the renormalizable level. Right-handed doublets could also do the job, but then non-renormalizable operators have to be invoked, which means effective operators resulting from a new theory at a higher scale, but this theory we will discuss explicitly in the next section. There is a more profound reason for preferring the triplets. They have an even B - L number, and thus preserve matter parity as we defined above. This in turn means R-parity is not broken at a high scale. But then it can be easily shown that it cannot be broken afterwards, at the low energy supersymmetry breaking or electroweak scale. More precisely, a spontaneous breakdown of R-parity through the sneutrino VEV (the only candidate) would result in the existence of a pseudo-Majoron with its mass inversely proportional to the right-handed neutrino mass. This is ruled out by the Z decay ~ i d t h . ~ ? This l O fact is completely analogous to the impossibility of breaking R-parity spontaneously in the MSSM, where the Majoron is strictly massless. In terms of PS representations, the LR triplets are contained in the fields
C(3,1, lo), Z(3,1, fO), Cc(1,3, CO), zc(l,3,lO).
(15)
The matter supermultiplets are
$J(2,1,4), &(I, 2,a)
(16)
and the minimal light Higgs multiplet is
@,
231).
(17)
The most general superpotential for the fields (15) is
+
W = mTrA2 + M T r ( C Z + CcCc) TT(CAC- C,AC,)
(18)
where we assume the following transformation properties under Parity C4C,,
Z-C,,
A + -A.
(19)
We choose A to be a parity-odd field in order to avoid flat directions connecting left- and right-breaking minima. It is straightforward to show that the SM singlets in A , C, and C, take vevs in the required directions to achieve the (in principle two-step) symmetry breaking
=Mc
=Mr,
=Mr,
(20)
78
with
As discussed in detail in,l1?l2the SU(2)~-breakingvev lies in a flat direction that connect them with charge-breaking vacua. It can be eliminated if the soft breaking terms break also su(2)R. If not, one would have to appeal to operators coming from a more complete theory as studied in the next section. The interesting point here is that the breaking in the minimal model leaves a number of fields potentially light.13 There is a larger, accidental S U ( 3 ) symmetry broken down to SU(2) by the right-handed triplet fields, hence five Nambu-Goldstone bosons. But the gauge symmetry s u ( 2 ) R x U ( ~ ) B - Lis broken down to U(l)y, so that three of them are eaten, leaving us with states S$+, 8$+ that acquire a mass only at the scale of supersymmetry breaking. These states are common in supersymmetric theories that include the Left-Right group, and have been subject of experimental search.14 In a similar way, a color octet in A has a mass of order M:/M,, and could in principle be light. The unification constraints give the interesting possibility 103GeV 5 M R
< 107GeV
10"GeV
5 M, 5 10I4GeV
opening up the possibility of the LHC discovering them at the TeV scale. For larger M R , which would be necessary if one wants to fit neutrino masses without additional fine-tuning, these particles become less accessible to experiment. However, the large number of fields in this theory implies the loss of perturbativity at a scale around lOM,, and non-renormalizable effects suppressed by this new fundamental scale can be shown to guarantee that they have comparable masses.12 Namely, if these effects are included, the only consistent possibility is the single-step breaking
MR N M,
I IlOl0GeV
(22)
Surely the most interesting feature of a low scale of PS symmetry breaking is the possibility of having U ( ~ ) B - Lmonopoles, with mass r n =~ lOM,. If produced in a phase transition via the Kibble mechanism, the requirement that their density be less than the critical density then implies M, 1012GeV. We see that the single-step breaking at M , M R lOl0GeV (in a theory including non-renormalizable terms) offers the interesting possibility of potentially detectable intermediate mass monopoles, as long as one manages to get rid of the false vacuum problem of supersymmetric theories.
- -
<
79
One final note about PS symmetry and neutrino masses. In LR theories the see-saw mechanism is in general non-canonical, or type 11. That is, there is a direct left-handed neutrino mass from the induced vev of the left-handed triplet fields in C (which we shall call A ) 1571671791
N<
A
>2L
M&/MR.
Namely, in non- supersymmetric theories the symmetry allows for a coupling in the potential
A V = XA+2A"+ M2A2
(23)
resulting in
In supersymmetry such terms are of course not present, but one could have interactions with, for example, a heavy field S transforming as (1,1,3) under GPS
W = 42S+ AA'S
+MS2.
(25)
Integrating out S would then give a contribution
1
AW = -A+2Ac M producing the required small vev. Or one could have a couple of heavy fields X = (2,2, TO) and
8 = (2,2, lo), which through terms like
W = $AX
+ +AcX + MXX
(27)
would give the same effect. These representations in fact are the ones appearing in the minimal SO(10) theory of the next section. The absence of the S,X, 8 fields in the minimal PS theory guarantees a type I see-saw at the supersymmetric level. Breaking of supersymmetry can generate a nonvanishing but negligible vev for A:"
which contributes by a tiny factor (m3p/Mc)25 to the usual see-saw mass term m, 2~ m&/m,,. In short, the minimal PS model has a clean, type I see-saw. In spite of providing only a partial unification, PS theory has interesting features, namely potentially light states and the possibility of intermediate monopoles, that could be a way of differentiating it from other theories at
80
a high scale. We are however interested in grand unification, so let us move on. 5. SO(10) grand unified theory
If not for anything else, but for the fact that matter parity is a finite gauge rotation, SO(10) would be a better candidate for a supersymmetric GUT. But, as is well known, it also unifies a family of fermions, has charge conjugation as a gauge transformation, has right-handed neutrinos an through the see-saw mechanism leads naturally t o small neutrino masses. And, most important, at the renormalizable level, if one is willing to accept large representations, it has fewer parameters than SU(5). We will elaborate on this point as we go along. The issue here, and the main source of dispute among the experts in the field, is the choice of the Higgs sector. Before deciding on this, a comment on d = 4 proton decay in the MSSM is in order. The basic problem is the impossibility of distinguishing the leptonic and the Higgs doublets, both being superfields. This persists in SU(5) where you have both 5~ and 5~ superfields. In SO(10) fermions belong t o 1 6 and ~ the "light" Higgs to 1 0 ~ This . difference should be taken seriously, and all efforts should be made t o maintain it. Not all researchers agree on this. Certainly not the people who pursue minimality by choosing mall representations, like the set ( 45H, 1 6 ~i ,6 ~ ) , in order t o break SO(10) down to S U ( 3 ) , x s U ( 2 ) x~ U(1)y. This way, through ( 1 6 ~ = ) ( 1 6 ~ #) 0, matter parity will be broken at MGUT;hence the catastrophic d = 4 proton decay. One is then forced t o postulate extra discrete symmetries in order to save the theory. In any case, more flavor symmetries are needed, since both the symmetry breaking and the fermion masses need higher-dimensional, Planck suppressed operators whose number is rather large (at least thirteen complex couplings in W H ,the Higgs superpotential). The Yukawa superpotential takes the form
wy= ylo 1 6 r~ l o H +- 1 [c1(i6Fri6F) ( 1 6 ~ r i 6 +~ c) 1 ( 1 6 ~ I ' 1 6 ~( i)6 H r T G ) MP1 ~ 3 1 6 ~ r 45H ~ 116 0~+~ . (29) At MGUT,one arrives at the prediction
81
which works very well as we know. Also, the see-saw takes the so-called type I form. From (29), mvR N
c4- M ~ U T 21
MPl
1012 -
GeV
(31)
which fits nicely the light neutrino masses. The type I1 contribution, obtained when 1 6 gets ~ a small vev N M w ,
is too small to explain either atmospheric or solar v data (maybe relevant for small mass splits in the case of degenerate neutrinos). Once flavor symmetries are added, one can do the texture exercise and look for the most appealing model. But this program goes beyond the scope of grand unification. We ought to try to construct the minimal realistic supersymmetric GUT without invoking any new physics.
5.1. The pure renormalixable supersymmetric S O ( l 0 ) Such a theory is easily b ~ i l t ~ ’with - ~ ~ large representations in the Higgs sector
+ --
2108, 1 2 6 ~ 1 2 6 ~1oH , with this content the theory is not asymptotically free any more above kfGuT,23 and the s o ( 1 0 ) gauge couplings becomes strong at the scale Ap 5 1 0 M ~ u The ~ . Higgs superpotential is surprisingly simple
+ m126126H126H + rnlo(10H)~+ ~ ( 2 1 0 ~ ) ~
W H = m210(210H)~
+
+
+ ~ 1 2 6 ~ 1 2 6 H 2 1 0~~ ~ 1 0 ~ 1 2 6 ~ Z2 i1! 01 ~0 ~ ~ 2 1. 0(33) ~ With ( 2 1 0 ~ # ) 0 and ( 1 2 6 ~ = ) (126~) # 0, SO(10) gets broken down to the MSSM, and then ( 1 0 ~ completes ) the job in the usual manner. The Yukawa sector is even more simple W Y = 16F(?/lO1OH
+ ?/126mH)16F
with only 3 real (say) ylo couplings after diagonalization, and 6 x 2 symmetric ?/I26 couplings, 15 in total. From the a and B terms on gets
+
WH = ... a(27 2, 1)lO (2, 27 15)126 f (1,1,15)210 +5(2,2,1)10 ( 2 , 2 , 1 5 ) m (1,1,15)210 f
+
(34) =
12
(35)
82
Now, the success of gauge coupling unification in the MSSM favors a single step breaking of SO(lO), so that ((1,1,15)210) N MGUT. In other words, the light Higgs is a mixture24 of (at least) (2,2,1)10 and ( 2 , 2 , 1 5 ) m ; equivalently ( ( 2 , 2 , 1 5 ) m ) = ((272,l)lO).
(36)
Since ( 2 , 2 , 1 5 ) m is an adjoint of SU(4),, being traceless it give me = -3md, unlike ((2,2,1)10), which implies me = md. In other words, the ( 1 0 ~ must ) be responsible for the mb 2: m, relation at MGUT, and the (126~) for the m, N 3m, relation a t MGUT. In this theory, the GeorgiJarlskog program becomes automatic. ~ Of course, we don’t know anymore why mb N m,, or why 1 0 dominates; admittedly a loss. But not all is lost. Since ( 1 0 ~ = ) ((2,2,1)) is a Pati-Salam singlet, the difference between down quark and charged lepton mass matrices must come purely from (126H)
Md
- Me
0: Y126
.
(37)
Suppose the see-saw mechanism is dominated by the so-called type 11: this is equivalent t o neutrino masses being due t o the triplet (3,1,m)126, with
In other words
or
MvmMd-Me.
(40)
Let us now look a t the 2nd and 3rd generations first. In the basis of diagonal M e , and for the small mixing Cde
obviously, large atmospheric mixing can only be obtained for mb N m,.25 Of course, there was no reason whatsoever to assume type 11 see- saw. Actually, we should reverse the argument: the experimental fact of mb N m, at MGUT,and large Oatrn seem t o favor the type type I1 see-saw. It can be shown, in the same approximation of 2-3 generations, that type I cannot dominate: it gives a small Oatm.26This gives hope t o disentangle
83
the nature of the see-saw in this theory. As a check, it can be shown that the two types of see-saw are really inequivalent.26 The three generation numerical studies supported a type I1 see- saw. with the interesting prediction of a large 613 and a hierarchical neutrino mass spectrum.27 Somewhat better fits are obtained with a small contribution of 1 2 0 H 28 or higher dimensional operators.2g Type 1can apparently be saved with CP phases, see Ref. 30 (for earlier work on type I see Ref. 31.). 5.2. Unification constraints
It is certainly appealing to have an intermediate see-saw mass scale M R , between 1 O I 2 - 1015GeV or so. In the non-renormalizable case, with 1 6 ~ and Z H ,this is precisely what happens: MR N cM&T/Mpl 21 c(1013 1014)GeV.In the renormalizable case, with 1 2 6 ~and 1268,one needs to perform a renormalization group study using unification constraints. While this is in principle possible, in practice it is hard due to the large number of fields. The stage has recently been set, for all the particle masses were c ~ m p u t e d ,and ~ ~ the > ~ preliminary ~ studies show that the situation may be under control.34 It is interesting that the existence of intermediate mass scales lowers the GUT scale32>35(as was found before in models with 5 4 H and 4 5 H ) 3 6 , allowing for a possibly observable d = 6 proton decay. Notice that a complete study is basically impossible. In order to perform the running, you need to know particle masses precisely. Now, suppose you stick to the principle of minimal fine-tuning. As an example, you fine-tune the mass of the W and 2 in the SM, then you know that the Higgs mass and the fermion masses are at the same scale
-
mH
=
-mw, .\/A
m f = -mw Yf
9
,
9
where X is a 44 coupling, and yf an appropriate fermionic Yukawa coupling. Of course, you know the fermion masses in the SM model, and you know mH zmw. In an analogous manner, at some large scale mG a group G is broken and there are usually a number of states that lie at mG, with masses
mi = aimG
,
(43)
where ai is an approximate dimensionless coupling. Most renormalization group studies typically argue that ai N 0 ( 1 ) is natural, and rely on that heavily. In the SM, you could then take mH N mw, m f N mw; while reasonable for the Higgs, it is nonsense for the fermions (except for the top
84
quark). In supersymmetry all the couplings are of Yukawa type, i.e. selfrenormalizable, and thus taking ai = 0(1)may be as wrong as taking all yf 21 O(1). While a possibly reasonable approach when trying to get a qualitative idea of a theory, it is clearly unacceptable when a high-precision study of M G ~ is T called for. 5.3. Proton decay
As you know, d = 6 proton decay gives r p ( d = 6) cx M&,T, while (d = 5 ) gives r p ( d = 5 ) cx M&,T. In view of the discussion above, the highprecision determination of rp appears almost impossible in SO(10) (and even in SU(5)). Preliminary studies 37 indicate fast d = 5 decay as expected. We are ignoring the higher dimensional operators of order MGUT/MP~ N If they are present with the coefficients of order one, we can forget almost everything we said about the predictions, especially in the Yukawa sector. However, we actually know that the presence of 1/Mpl operators is not automatic (at least not with the coefficients of order 1). Operators of the type (in symbolic notation)
are allowed by SO(10) and they give
These are the well-known d = 5 proton decay operators, and for c N 0(1) they give rpN 1023yr. Agreement with experiment requires c5
(46)
Could this be a signal that 1/Mp1 operators are small in general? Alternatively, you need to understand why just this one is to be so small. It is appealing to assume that this may be generic; if so, neglecting 1/Mpl contributions in the study of fermion masses and mixings is fully justified. 5.4. Leptogenesis
The see-saw mechanism provides a natural framework for baryogenesis through leptogenesis, obtained by the out-of-equilibrium decay of heavy right-handed neutrino^.^ This works nicely for large M R , in a sense too nicely. Already type I see-saw works by itself, but the presence of the type I1 term makes things more complicated. One cannot be a priori sure
85
whether the decay of right-handed neutrinos or the heavy Higgs triplets is responsible for the asymmetry, although the hierarchy of Yukawa couplings points towards UR decay. In the type I1 see-saw, the most natural scenario is the VR decay, but with the triplets running in the This and related issues are now under i n v e ~ t i g a t i o n . ~ ~
6. Summary and Outlook We have argued in favor of SO(10) as the minimal consistent supersymmetric grand unified theory. It includes all the interesting features of Left-Right and Pati-Salam symmetries, it is the ideal setting for a see-saw mechanism, and has the MSSM with automatic R-parity as the low energy limit. It can give connections with low energy phenomenology, such as the one relating b - r unification with neutrino mixings, besides being able to provide realistic charged fermion spectrum. As a gauge symmetry accommodating all fermions of one generation in a single representation, there is little doubt on the convenience of SO(10). The question of the Higgs sector is the one unsolved: one can choose between two different approaches. One can insist on perturbativity all the way to the Planck scale and choose small representations, using then 1/Mpl operators to generate the physically acceptable superpotential; it is then necessary to use textures to simplify the theory. In this sense, this programme appeals to physics beyond grand unification. The other approach is to stick to the pure SO(10) theory, at the expense of using very large representations. The couplings then become strong at AF = OMG GUT, but the theory has the advantage of requiring only a small number of couplings, and is a complete theory of matter and non-gravitational interactions. The important question is rather if these versions of the theory can be tested in the near future. Work is in progress by several groups on the possibility of establishing testable constraints on neutrino masses and mixings, proton decay, and the implementation of the leptogenesis scenario. In the pure SO(10) approach, with less parameters, proving the theory wrong might be just a question of time.
7. Acknowledgements We wish to acknowledge many discussions and enjoyable collaboration in the subjects of this talk with Charan Aulakh, Borut Bajc, F'rancesco Vissani, Andrija Raiin, Pave1 Fileviez-PQrez and Thomas Hambye. And we thank the organizers of BW2003, in particular Goran Djordjevic, for a
86
stimulating conference and a good time in VrnjaEka Banja. A. to say hvala, bre.
M. wishes
References 1. For some recent reviews see e.g. B. Bajc, F. Nesti, G. Senjanovic and F. Vissani, “Perspectives in neutrino physics,” Proceedings of 17th Rencontres de Physique de la Vallee d’Aoste, La Thuile, 9-15 Mar 2003, M. Greco ed., page 103-143; S. M. Bilenky, C. Giunti, J. A. Grifols and E. Masso, Phys. Rept. 379 (2003) 69; V. Barger, D. Marfatia and K . Whisnant, J. Mod. Phys. E 12 (2003) 569. A. Y. Smirnov, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A19 (2004) 1180. 2. S. Dimopoulos, S. Raby, F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. D24 (1981) 1681. L.E. IbAiiez, G.G. Ross, Phys. Lett. B105 (1981) 439. M.B. Einhorn, D.R. Jones, Nucl. Phys. B196 (1982) 475. W. Marciano, G. SenjanoviC, Phys. Rev. D25 (1982) 3092. 3. P. Minkowski, Phys. Lett. B67 (1977) 421. T.Yanagida, proceedings of the Workshop on Unified Theories and Baryon Number in the Universe, Tsukuba, 1979, eds. A. Sawada, A. Sugamoto, KEK Report No. 79-18, Tsukuba. S. Glashow, in Quarks and Leptons, CargZse 1979, eds. M. L6vy. et al., (Plenum, 1980, New York). M. Gell-Mann, P. Ramond, R. Slansky, proceedings of the Supergmvity Stony Brook Workshop, New York, 1979, eds. P. Van Niewenhuizen, D. Freeman (North-Holland, Amsterdam). R. Mohapatra, G. SenjanoviC, Phys. Rev. Lett. 44 (1980) 912. 4. M. Fukugita and T . Yanagida, Phys. Lett. B174 (1986) 45. 5. M. S. Chanowitz, J. R. Ellis and M. K. Gaillard, Nucl. Phys. B128, 506 (1977). A. J. Buras, J. R. Ellis, M. K. Gaillard and D. V. Nanopoulos, Nucl. Phys. B135 (1978) 66. 6. R. N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. D34 (1986) 3457. A. Font, L. E. IbGiez and F. Quevedo, Phys. Lett. B228 (1989) 79. S. P. Martin, Phys. Rev. D46 (1992) 2769. 7. J. C. Pati and A. Salam, Phys. Rev. D10 (1974) 275. 8. R. N. Mohapatra and J. C. Pati, Phys. Rev. D11 (1975) 2558. G. SenjanoviC and R. N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. D12 (1975) 1502. G. Senjanovit, Nucl. Phys. B153 (1979) 334. 9. C.S. Aulakh, K. Benakli, G. SenjanoviC, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79 (1997) 2188. 10. C. S. Aulakh, A. Melfo, A. R&in and G. SenjanoviC, Phys. Lett. B459 (1999) 557. 11. R. Kuchimanchi and R. N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. D48 (1993) 4352 [arXiv:hepph/9306290]. 12. A. Melfo and G. Senjanovic, Phys. Rev. D68 (2003) 035013 [arXiv:hepph/0302216]. 13. C. S. Aulakh, B. Bajc, A. Melfo, A. Rasin and G. Senjanovic, Phys. Lett. B460 (1999) 325 [arXiv:hep-ph/9904352]. 14. D. Acosta et al. (CDF Collaboration], arXiv:hepex/0406073. P. Achard et al. [L3 Collaboration], Phys. Lett. B576 (2003) 18 [arXiv:hep-ex/0309076]. Phys. Lett. B577 (2003) 93 [arXiv:hep-ex/0308052].
87
15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28.
29. 30. 31.
32. 33.
34. 35. 36. 37.
38.
39.
M. Magg and C. Wetterich, Phys. Lett. B94 (1980) 61. R. N. Mohapatra and G. Senjanovic, Phys. Rev. D23 (1981) 165. G. Lazarides, Q. Shafi and C. Wetterich, Nucl. Phys. B181 (1981) 287. C. Wetterich, Nucl. Phys. B187 (1981) 343. C.S. Aulakh, R.N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. D28 (1983) 217. T. E. Clark, T. K. Kuo and N. Nakagawa, Phys. Lett. B115 (1982) 26. D. Chang, R. N. Mohapatra and M. K. Parida, Phys. Rev. D30 (1984) 1052. X. G. He and S. Meljanac, Phys. Rev. D41 (1990) 1620. D. G. Lee, Phys. Rev. D49 (1994) 1417. D.G. Lee and R. N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. D51 (1995) 1353. C. S. Aulakh, B. Bajc, A. Melfo, G. SenjanoviC and F. Vissani, Phys. Lett. B588, 196 (2004). C. S. Aulakh, arXiv:hepph/0210337. K. S. Babu and R. N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70,2845 (1993). B. Bajc, G. SenjanoviC and F. Vissani, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90 (2003) 051802. B. Bajc, G. SenjanoviC and F. Vissani, arXiv:hep-ph/0402140. H. S. Goh, R. N. Mohapatra and S. P. Ng, Phys. Lett. B570 (2003) 215. H. S. Goh, R. N. Mohapatra and S. P. Ng, Phys. Rev. D68 (2003) 115008. S. Bertolini, M. F'rigerio and M. Malinsky, arXiv:hepph/0406117. W. M. Yang and Z. G. Wang, arXiv:hep-ph/0406221. B. Dutta, Y. Mimura and R. N. Mohapatra, arXiv:hep-ph/0406262. B. Dutta, Y. Mimura and R. N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. D69 (2004) 115014. K. Matsuda, Y . Koide and T. Fukuyama, Phys. Rev. D64 (2001) 053015. T. Fukuyama and N. Okada, JHEP 0211 (2002) 011. L. Lavoura, Phys. Rev. D48 (1993) 5440. B. Brahmachari and R. N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. D58 (1998) 015001. K. Y. Oda, E. Takasugi, M. Tanaka and M. Yoshimura, Phys. Rev. D59 (1999) 055001. B. Bajc, A. Melfo, G. SenjanoviC and F. Vissani, Phys. Rev. D70 (2004) 035007. T. Fukuyama, A. Ilakovac, T. Kikuchi, S. Meljanac and N. Okada, arXiv:hep ph/0401213. C. S. Aulakh and A. Girdhar, arXiv:hep-ph/0204097. C. S. Aulakh and A. Girdhar, arXiv:hep-ph/0405074. H. S. Goh, R. N. Mohapatra and S. Nasri, arXiv:hepph/0408139. C. S. Aulakh, B. Bajc, A. Melfo, A. %in and G. SenjanoviC, Nucl. Phys. B597 (2001) 89. H. S. Goh, R. N. Mohapatra, S. Nasri and S. P. Ng, Phys. Lett. B587 (2004) 105. T.Fukuyama, A. Ilakovac, T. Kikuchi, S. Meljanac and N. Okada, JHEP 0409 (2004) 052. T. Hambye and G. Senjanovib, Phys. Lett. B582 (2004) 73. S. Antusch and S. F. King, Phys. Lett. B597 (2004) 199. P.J. O'Donnell and U. Sarkar, Phys. Rev. D49 (1994) 2118. E.Ma and U. Sarkar, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 5716. G. Lazarides and Q. Shafi, Phys. Rev. D58 (1998) 071702. P. Fileviez-Pkrez, T. Hambye and G. Senjanovit, work in preparation.
SPIN FOAM MODELS OF QUANTUM GRAVITY
A. MIKOVIC Departamento de Matemdtica e CiEncias de Computaczo Universidade Lusdfona de Humanidades e Tecnologias Av. do Camp0 Grande, 376, 1749-024 Lisbon, Portugal E-mail: amikovicQu1usofona.pt We give a short review of the spin foam models of quantum gravity, with an emphasis on the Barret-Crane model. After explaining the shortcomings of the Barret-Crane model, we briefly discuss two new approaches, one based on the 3d spin foam state sum invariants for the embedded spin networks, and the other based on representing the string scattering amplitudes as 2d spin foam state sum invariants.
1. Introduction The spin foam models originate from the Ponzano-Regge model of 3d Euclidian quantum gravity.I The idea there was to use the simplical complex, i.e. the spacetime triangulation, whose triangles had integer lengths, which were proportional to the spins of the S U ( 2 ) group. Then the 3d gravity path integral (PI) was defined as a sum over the spins of the products of the 6 j symbols which were associated to the tetrahedrons of the simplical complex. A length cut-off was introduced in order to regularize the path integral. Since 3d gravity is a topological theory, the corresponding path integral would be a topological invariant of the 3d manifold. However, the Ponzano-Regge path integral was not a topological invariant , because the topological invariance required the quantum S U ( 2 ) group at a root of unity, which was discovered by Turaeev and Viro.’ Still, the idea of the Ponzano-Reggemodel was useful, because the model can be understood as a path integral for the SU(2) BF t h e ~ r yThis . ~ then inspired Ooguri to consider a 4d version of the model, as a PI for the 4d S U ( 2 ) BF t h e ~ r yIn . ~this case the areas of the triangles are integer valued, i.e. proportional to the spins. The PI was formally topologically invariant, but divergent. A well-defined topological invariant was obtained by Crane, 88
89
Yetter and K a ~ f f m a n ,who ~ replaced the S U ( 2 ) group by the quantum S U ( 2 ) group at a root of unity, so that the S U ( 2 ) spins become bounded by a maximal spin. However, the corresponding invariant was not new, contrary to the 3d case, since it gave a signature of the 4-manifold. At the same time, Baez proposed the idea of the spin foams,6 as a way of understanding the results of loop quantum g r a ~ i t y from , ~ a spacetime perspective, i.e. a spin foam is a time evolution surface of a spin network, so that the spins are naturally associated to the faces of the spin foam. Given that the Einstein-Hilbert (EH) action of GR can be understood as a constrained BF theory, this then prompted Crane and Barrett to look for a constrained version of the CYK topological spin foam state 2. The Barret-Crane Model
The EH action can be written as the SO(3,l) BF theory action
where F a b = d @ a b + @ z A @ c a is the curvature two-form for the spin connection and the two-form B-field is constrained by
0,
Bab
= E,bcdec A ed ,
(2)
where the are the tetrad one-forms. The BF theory path integral can be written as
where 1 and f are the edges and the faces of the dual two-complex F for the simplical complex T ( M ) ,while A are the triangles of T . The variables A l and BA are defined as A and B respectively, while Ff = Jf F . By performing the B integrations one obtains
sa
which can be defined as
90
where gf =
n,,,, 91. By using the well-known identity a(g) = EdimAXA(9) 7
(6)
A
where A’s are the irreducible representations (irreps) of the group and x’s are the characters, one obtains
z= Af+i
ndimAfnA,(Af,Ll), f
(7)
V
where A, is the vertex amplitide associated to the 4-simplex dual to the vertex u. This amplitude is given by the evaluation of the corresponding 4-simplex spin network, known as the 15j symbol. The sum (7) is called a spin foam state sum, because it is a sum of the amplitudes for the colored two complex F , i.e. a spin foam. One can now conjecture that exists a quantization procedure such that the quantities BA become the 4d rotations algebra operators J A , since the 4d rotation group irreps are labelling the triangles A, or the dual faces f. Then one can show that the constraint (2) becomes a constraint on the representations labelling the triangles A, given by8lg pbcdj J ab cd
-0*
(8)
In the Euclidian case the irreps are given by the pairs of the SU(2) spins ( j , j ’ ) , so that the constraint (8) implies j = j’. In the Minkowski case, requiring the hermiticity of the B operators implies that one needs the unitary irreps of the Lorentz group. These are infinite-dimensional irreps and they are given by the pairs ( j , p ) ,where j is the S U ( 2 ) spin and p is a continuous label. The constraint (8) implies that A = ( 0 , p ) or A = ( j ,0). One can argue that the spacelike triangles should be labelled by the ( 0 , p ) irreps, while the time-like triangles should be labelled by the ( j , O ) irreps. Since a spacetime triangulation can be built from the spacelike triangles, Barrett and Crane have proposed the following spin foam state sum (integral) for the quantum general relativityg
U
where A, is an amplitude for the corresponding 4-simplex spin network, given by
91
This is as an integral over the fifth power of the hyperboloid H = S0(3,1)/S0(3) of a propagator K p ( z y) , on that space. The propagator is given by
The expression (9) is not finite for all triangulations, but after a slight modification, consisting of including a non-trivial edge amplitude &I, . . . ,p 4 ) , the partition function becomes finite for all non-degenerate triangulations. lo This was a remarkable result, because it gave a perturbatively finitea quantum theory of gravity, which was not based on string theory. The main difficulties with the BC type models are: 1) It is difficult to see what is the semi-classical limit, i.e. what is the corresponding effective action, and is it given by the EH action plus the O(Zp) corrections, where Zp is the Planck length. 2) Coupling of matter: since matter couples to the gravitational field through the tetrads, one would need a formulation where a basic field is a tetrad and got the B 2-form. In the case of the YM field, the coupling can be expressed in terms of the B field,’l so that one can formulate a BC type m o d e l ~ . ~However, ~J~ for the fermions this is not possible, and a tetrade based formulation is necessary. In Ref. 11 an algebraic approach was proposed in order to avoid this problem, and the idea was to use a result from the loopquantum gravity, according to which the fermions appear as free ends of the spin networks. Hence including open spin networks gives a new type of spin foams,14and this opens a possibility of including matter in the spin foam formalism. However, what is the precise form of the matter spin foam amplitudes remains an open question.
3. New Directions Given the difficulties of the BC model, we have proposed two new directions how to use the spin foam state sum formalism in order to arrive at a desirable quantum theory of gravity. In Ref. 15 it was proposed to use the 3d spin foam state sum invariants in order to define the relevant quantities in the loop quantum gravity formalism. The idea is to use the representation of a quantum gravity state a Zdepends ~ ~on a triangulation, in accordance with the fact that 4d gravity is nontopological, and hence one should also sum over the triangulations in order t o obtain a well-defined quantity. How to do this it is not clear a t present, so that one can obtain only the perturbative results.
92
I*)
in the spin network basis
I@) =
c Ir)(rl@).
(12)
Y
The expansion coefficients are then invariants of the embedded spin networks in the spatial manifold C, and can be formally expressed as
where A is a 3d complex S U ( 2 ) connection, W,[A] is the spin network wave-functional (generalization of the Wilson loop functional) and f [A] is a holomorphic wave-functional satisfying the quantum gravity constraints in the Ashtekar representation. In the case of non-zero cosmological constant A, a non-trivial solution is known, i.e. the Kodama wavefunction
@[A]= e x2 JE T T ( A A ~ A + ; A A A A A ,)
(14)
while in the X = 0 case a class of formal solutions is given by
i.e. a flat-connection w a v e f u n c t i ~ n In . ~ ~the X = 0 case one can show that the corresponding spin network invariant is given by a 3d spin foam state sum for the quantum SU(2) at a root of unity.lS In the X # 0 case, it is conjectured that the corresponding spin network invariant is given in the Euclidian gravity case by the Witten-ReshetikhinTuraeev invariant for q = e 2 n i / ( k + 2where ), k E N and X = k/l:, while in the Minkowski case, the invariant is given by an analytical continuation of the Euclidian one, as k -+ik.16 In Ref. 17 it was proposed to use the 2d spin foam state sums in order to define a string theory as a quantum theory of gravity. The main idea is to use the string theory formal expression for the scattering amplitude of n gravitons (or any other massless string modes), given as
A(m, ...,P,) = where
s,
d a
.
do,
( m ). . . Vpn( 0 ; 2 ) ) ,
(Q1
(16)
93
and argue that (16) should represent a 2d BF theory ivarisnt for the 0, spin network embedded in the string world-sheet manifold C. The B F theory group is given by the group of isometries of the spacetime background metric, and in Ref. 17 a simple possibility for the amplitude was considered
where the isometry group was taken to be SU(2). Then the labels p l , . . . , p , become the SU(2) spins, and there is a maximal spin, because the PI (18) becomes a state sum for the quantum S U ( 2 ) a t a root of unity. Because the B F theory is a topological theory, one can expect that the amplitude (18) will correspond to a topological string theory.
Acknowledgments This work is supported by the FCT grants POCTI/FNU/49543/2002 and POCTI/MAT/45306/2002.
References 1. G. Ponzano and T. Regge, Spectroscopy and Group Theortical Methods in Physics, ed F. Block et al, North-Holland, Amsterdam (1968). 2. V. G. Turaeev and 0. Y. Viro, Topology 31,865 (1992). 3. D. V. Boulatov, Mod. Phys. Lett. A7, 1629 (1992). 4. H. Ooguri, Mod. Phys. Lett. A7,2799 (1992). 5. L. Crane, D. N. Yetter and D. H. Kauffman, Knot Theor. Ramif. 6, 177 (1997). 6. J. Baez, Lect. Notes Phys. 543, 25 (2000). 7. C. Rovelli, Living Rev. Rel. 1, 1 (1995). 8. J. W. Barrett and L. Crane, J. Math. Phys. 39,3296 (1998) 9. J. W. Barrett and L. Crane, Class. Quant. Grav. 17,3101 (2000). 10. L. Crane, A. Perez and C. Rovelli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87,181301 (2001). 11. A. MikoviC, Class. Quant. Grav. 19,2335 (2003). 12. A. Mikovik, Class. Quant. Grav. 20, 239 (2003). 13. D. Oriti and H. Pfeiffer, Phys. Rev. D66, 124010 (2002). 14. A. MikoviC, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A18S2,83 (2003). 15. A. MikoviC, Class. Quant. Grav. 20, 3483 (2003). 16. L. Smolin, Quantum Gravity with a Positive Cosmological Constant, hepth/0209079. 17. A. MikoviC, String Theory and Quantum Spin Networks, hep-th/0307141.
RIEMANN-CARTAN SPACE-TIME IN STRINGY GEOMETRY
B. SAZDOVIC Institute of Physics, P. 0.Box 57, 12001 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro E-mail: [email protected]. yu We consider the classical equations of motion for the string propagating in the target space. It is known that, in the case of Riemann space time, the world-sheet is a minimal surface. It is specified by the requirement that all mean extrinsic curvatures, corresponding to the normal vectors, are zero. The presence of the antisymmetric field in the string action, leads to the space-time torsion and the target space becomes of the Riemann-Cartan type. We define the mean torsion, and its orthogonal projection as the dual mean extrinsic curvature. In this language, the world-sheet is C-dual surface, which means that mean extrinsic curvature is equal to dual mean extrinsic curvature. The string feels the group manifold as RiemannCartan type space-time. The metric tensor is the well known Killing group metric and topological Wess-Zumino term is origin of the parallelizing torsion. We apply above consideration to this particular example.
1. Introduction
We will investigate bosonic string propagation in space-time M D(G,,, B,, , a), defined by x , depended background gravitational field G,,, antisymmetric tensor field B,, = -B,, and dilaton field a. By X,(T,(T) ( p , v = O , l , ...,D - l), we denote position of the string and by E“ = {to= T,E l = o} the coordinates of the world-sheet. The bosonic string action1
(1) has been investigated in the literature.2 Here, gup is intrinsic world-sheet metric and R(2)is corresponding two dimensional scalar curvature. As a preparation, let us first consider the point particle case. Then, instead of world-sheet we have world-line parameterized by one parameter, 94
95
tff
-+ r , so that &xi' -+ x p . Consequently, only the first term, with the background field G,,, survives in the action (1) and we obtain
S = K,
[drG,,(x)xpx".
(2)
J
The equation of motion is
2 + rrgkPxu = D,Y
=0,
(3)
where
is Christoffel connection. So, the test particle in external gravitational field follows geodesic line. It feels the target space as Riemann space-time of general relativity, VD= (M D ,r, G ) . We will try to understand: how test string feels the external spacetime M D , which we shall call the stringy ~pace-time.~ For better understanding, we will first introduce general space-time geometry and investigate string equations of motion.
2. Affine Space-time The metric tensor G,, and the affine connection "I?&, generally are independent variables. They define the afine space-time A D = (G,,, 'I?&). The metric tensor defines the scalar product of the vectors V . U =
VPG,,U". The affine connection, defines the rule for vector parallel transport V p ( x ) -+ "yr = V p + "6Vp where "6VC" = -"I?raVPdxo.
(5)
The covariant derivative is a difference of two vectors at the same point x dx: one living in this point and the other parallely transported from the point x
+
"DV'" = V'(X + dx) -
"7;"= dVI"-
O W / "
3 "D,V'dd'
,
(6)
where "D,VP = a,V, + Ol?;,VP. The rule for the parallel transport of the covector U,(z), "SUP = 'I'$,UpdxU, can be obtained from the invariance of the vector product under parallel transport, "6(VpU,) = 0. In the Riemann space-time connection is symmetric, r$ = I?$p. The metric postulate, DG,, = 0, is satisfied, which means that lengths do not change during the parallel transport.
96
In the affine space-time, the antisymmetric part of the connection defines the torsion
and a covariant derivative of the metric tensor defines the nonmetricity
A
Figure 1. Geometrical meaning of the torsion.
Let us explain their geometrical meaning. Interpretation of the torsion is illustrated in the Fig. 1. Here, iY(5;) are the positions of the tangent vectors tY(t;) after parallel transport along the geodesics l z ( l , )-, respectively, where we used AB = d l l = d i l = CD2 and AC = dCz = dlz = BD1. In fact, the torsion measures the non-closure of the curved rectangle ABCD
z'(D2) - z'(D1) = O T p p , , t:tz d l l d l z .
(9)
To understand the meaning of nonmetricity, we can compare the square of the vector Vp at the point x, V z ( x )= G,,(z)VP(z)V"(z),with its parallel transport to the point z + d z , ' y ? ( z + d z ) = G,,(z+dz)"y;" "l$ Because '. the scalar product is invariant under parallel transport, we have "SV2= "Vi?(z+ d x ) - V 2 ( z )= "DG,,V"V"
3
- ~ z P ~ Q ~ ~(10) ~ V ~ V
So, in affine space-time, after parallel transport the metric tensor is not equal to the local one. The nonmetricity measures the breaking of the metric postulate.
97
Following Ref. 4,we can decompose the connection Christoffel connection, contortion and nonmetricity
in terms of the
With the help of the Schouten braces, {ppu} = upp + pup - ppu, the Christoffel connection can be expressed as rp,pa = id+Gpoj and the contortion OKpPois defined in terms of the torsion OKppo= ~ o T { o p p ) . The first and third terms in Eq. (11) are symmetric in p , indices. ~ In the second term we can separate symmetric and antisymmetric parts, O K p p o = oKp(p,) ioTppo which produces
+
3. Induced and Extrinsic Geometry The geometry of world-sheet embedded in curved ~pace-time,~ has been generalized for the space-times with nontrivial torsion and n~nmetricity.~ We will shortly repeat the main results. 3.1. Induced Metric Tensor and Induced Connection The geometry of the world-sheet is defined by world-sheet metric tensor Gap and world-sheet connection O r & . We are interested in the case when this geometry of the world-sheet is induced from the space-time. The world-sheet induced metric tensor is defined by the requirement that world-sheet intervals measured by the induced and space-time metrics have the same lengths, so that
Gap = G p y d a ~ p d p ~ u .
(13)
The infinitesimal parallel transport of the world-sheet tangent covector V p , along world-sheet line from the point (" to the point (" d(", (Fig. 2), produces the covector = VF "6V;, where
'7:
+
+
Generally, it does not belong to the world-sheet. The best we can do is to relate the projections of the vectors VF and O q L . The induced connection, O r & , defines the rule for the parallel transport of the world-sheet covector v, = VFd,xp, along the same world-sheet
98
\
\
M D
Figure 2.
The parallel transport of the world-sheet tangent covector.
+
line, to the projection "v& = dffxP(t d ( ) " v ; . relations o
x = ,qff
21,
+ O6vff,
So, from the standard
Obv, = oI'&vpdtY,
(15)
we find the expression for the induced connection ffP = G
~
O r r
~
~
~
~
(16) ~
where OD, V P = & X " ~ D ~ VisP space-time covariant derivative along world-sheet direction.
3.2. Second Fundamental Form
Vk,
The parallel transport of the covector orthogonal to the world-sheet = "6V;, where "bVk = O r "PP V*dxp " = (Fig. 3), produces V>&xpd
Vk +
aax"(t
+ d t ) " ? ~=~
1 - 0
I -
io
vllff - v biapdt',
(17)
defines second fundamental form (SFF) O b i f f p = n ~ G P v o D p d a x=u -daxV0Dp(GP,nr),
(18)
where nr (i = 2,3, ..., D - 1) are local unit vectors, normal to the worldsheet. In the spaces with nonmetricity there are two sets of SFFs as well as two sets of the induced connections and induced covariant derivatives. We
G
99
\ MD
/ Figure 3. The parallel transport of the world-sheet orthogonal covector.
will use the variables defined above, because these two sets of variables are equal up to terms with nonmetricity. The induced connection and the SFF are projections of the space-time covariant derivative of the world-sheet basis vectors dffxP,to the worldsheet and its normal, respectively. Consequently, we have the generalization of the Gauss-Weingarten equation
oDpdaxP = ol?&dyxp + "bhP nf .
(19)
In analogy with the general rule for connection decomposition we can decompose the induced connection and SFF Ory,ap
= ry,olp
1
+ OKyap + z o Q { y a p }
1
=hap
+ 'Kim' + z1o Q { i a p } .
(20) Here, the indices for induced variables can be obtained by the rules Tia = n f d a x v T p v , for T = { O T a p r , OQapy, 'Tia', OQiap}, and we also have OKyap = :oT{yap}, biap = nfGpvDpdax", and O K i f f p = ;oT{iap}. 3.3. Mean Extrinsic Curvature The curvature of the normal section ti,as a space-time curve, is orthogonal projection of the covariant derivative along the curve, "ki = OD,tPGPvn:, or explicitly
"ki = Obipa tatP= Obi(pff) tat'.
(21)
100
It depends on the direction of the world-sheet tangent vector t". The i-th mean extrinsic curvature (MEC) is mean value of the ith normal section curvature, with fixed normal n:. It is well defined in Euclidean spaces. In Minkowski spaces the curvature (21) is divergent in the light-like directions. For the time-like region we define regularized mean curvature "lcfl(a)da,
("lc;,(a)= "66cosh2(a) -
"61sinh2(a)) ,
(22) where principal curvatures X i are eigenvalues of the quadratic forms "b& with respect to the metric Gap. For the space-like normal section we have "lctl(a)= "66 sinh2(a)- "6f cosh2(a) and similar expression as Eq. (22). We define the MEC as a mean value of the time-like mean curvature with sign and space-like mean curvature with sign " - "
+,
1 1 lim -["H;,(A) - " H i , ( h ) ]= - ( O K ; 2 2
A+w
+OK;)
= "Ha.
(23)
The condition for nontrivial solutions of the eigenvalue problem, det ( "b& " K ~ G= ~0 produces ~ ) " ~ 6 =, ~"Hi f J("Hi)2 - OKi. Here
detabha -
io i
is just the MEC of the expression (23) and OKi = - tc0 fiC1(no summation over i) is Gauss curvature. For "6; = "6;= "6' the line curvature does not depend on the tangent vector direction, "lcf,(a)= Ai = O H , , , and " k ~ , ( a= ) -"tea = "Hi,. Consequently, the MEC has the same interpretation + ( O H ; , - O H : , ) = "62 = "Hi. The surface defined by the equation "Ha = 0 is the minimal ~ u r f a c e . ~
4. C-duality The above considerations are torsion independent, because the antisymmetric part of the SFF disappears from Eqs. (21) and (24). In Ref. 3 we investigated the case when the torsion is present and the SFF is not symmetric in a, /3 indices
Let us first generalize the eigenvalue problem. We introduce the dual eigenvalue problem, such that linear transformation of the vector v a
101
with operator "b& is proportional to the two dimensional dual vector *u, = G G E f f p up ObiP
UP = * K Z
*u,.
(26)
d(*Hi)2 +
The dual eigenvalues, *fig,l = *Hi f O K i , are solutions of the condition det(*bi - * k i E ~ ) = 0. ~ In Panalogy with the previous case, we will call them dual principal curvatures, and the variable
det O b i p
the dual mean extrinsic curvature (DMEC). Here OKi = * figi * rc1i (no summation over i) is the same Gauss curvature as before.
-
What is the geometrical meaning of the DMEC? In the case when ty and are world-sheet tangent vectors, (Fig. l), we can rewrite Eq. ( 9 ) in the form
ti
Here, dP12 = a d e t ( % ) d l l d & is area of the parallelogram, spanned by the vectors d t y = tyd-tl and dtg = t g d t z . The variable O T P does not depend on the directions ty and t;, and on the lengths del and d&. So, we will call it the mean torsion. Its normal projection, the extrinsic mean torsion
is exactly the same variable as DMEC, defined in (27). If we introduce a dual SFF
we can reformulate the dual eigenvalue problem ( 2 6 ) as an ordinary one (*bhp - * K ~ G ~ ~=)0.V " Let us introduce transformation which interchanges the roles of the symmetric and the antisymmetric parts of the SFF and maps SFF to dual SFF, "bLp 4 *b"&. It relates MEC and DMEC, allowing the exchange of the mean curvature and mean torsion. We called it C-duality (Curvature duality) .3 The conditions for self-dual and self-antidual configurations
102
define C-dual and antidual surfaces. In the torsion free case, they turn to the standard minimal surface O H i = 0.
5. String Equations of Motion For u2 # 0 ( a ,
= a,@), the equations of motion for the action (1)are6 [PI = vFokx, + *r;puaf2pdFxu = 0 , (32)
[iF]E
+ ~2 ( D r , ~ , ) & d ‘ d=~0~. ~
(34)
We used a tangent basis where the light-cone components of the vector V, have the form V* = .&(Vo h+Vl). The world-sheet covariant derivative denoted by 8,. The expression
+
*r$,, = r;,
up f PTpuB& + --,a,,
(35)
a2
which appears in the [PIequation, transforms as a connection under spacetime general coordinate transformations. The first term r;, is the Christoffel connection, D, is the corresponding covariant derivative and Bpvp
= D,B,p
+ D,Bp, + DpB,,
(36)
is field strength of the antisymmetric tensor. The projection operator in the second term is defined as PTPu= G,, Let us apply the general considerations to the string case. Instead of mark the O , the mark * indicates the presence of dilaton field @, and lower indices f indicate the presence of the antisymmetric field B,, in the corresponding two forms of connections (35). The stringy torsion and the stringy nonmetricity take the forms
y.
*T*& = f2PTP,B“PU
1 *Qfppo
= 2D+(apao).
(37)
The form of Eq. (36) suggests that B,, is a torsion p ~ t e n t i a l .In ~ the presence of the dilaton field @, the metric G,, is not compatible with the stringy connection *r&,and during stringy parallel transport, the length deformation depends on the vector field a,.
103
6. Classification of the Space-times With the help of the field equations (32)-(34), we can make the space-time clas~ification,~ depending on the background fields. We will see that the probe string feels torsion and nonmetricity, which is not the case for the probe particle. 6.1. Riemann and Riemann- Cartan Space-time In the absence of the dilaton field a, the action is conformaly invariant. The field F and the corresponding equation [iF]are absent. Both intrinsic world-sheet metric tensor and intrinsic connection are equal to the induced ones from the space-time, up to the conformal factor. There are two forms of connection I'$, = I?$, fBE, and corresponding two forms of covariant derivative D+. The torsion T*Z, = f2Bg,, is proportional to the field strength of the antisymmetric tensor. The orthogonal projection of the [J,] equation obtains the form of selfduality condition
and world-sheet is C-dual (antidual) surface. The string with background fields G,, and B,, feels the target space as Riemann-Cartan space-time.
VD Figure 4. Classification of space-time. A D is a s n e space-time, S D is stringy spacetime, S D is stringy torsion free space-time, UD is stringy Riemann-Cartan space-time and VD is R i e m a n n space-time.
104
For B,, = 0, the last equation turns to the standard condition of minimal surface
H a,
1 -G"Pbb, = 0 . (39) 2 The string with background field G,, feels the target space as R i e m a n n space-time of general relativity and does not see torsion and nonmetricity.
6 . 2 . Stringy Space-time In the presence of the dilaton field CP, the theory loses conformal invariance. We found the relations between intrinsic and induced metric tensors and connections 1 ap - S X:, - $Aa GapGy6X6 - -*QIYap1, w;p = *ry gap = .;Gap,
+
2
(40) where A, = 4 , In and a; = Gapa,ap is a length of the world-sheet projection of the vector field a,. The string propagating in the presence of all three background fields G,,, B,, and Q,, feels both space-time torsion and nonmetricity. The corresponding target space we call stringy space-time. The normal projection of the [J,] equation takes the form
6,
so that the world-sheet is stringy C-dual surface. For B,, = 0, Eq. (41) turns to the stringy minimal surface condition
1 * H . - -Gap *bipa = 0 ,
"2 because all stringy MECs vanish.
7. String Propagation on the Group Manifold
We are going to apply above results to the case where the group manifold takes the role of the curved space-time. Let us put dilaton field CP to zero, Q, = 0. Instead of the string coordinate x, we introduce group manifold coordinates q a . We also substitute spacetime metric G,, with the Cartan one Yap = E&,"E*pb&b
where
,
Ef," are qa depending vielbeins on the group manifold.
(43)
105
Christoffel connection takes the form
and does not depend on the f indices. Instead of the connections (35) we obtain
rZP7= rZ7fT;,
= ya6E$6dpE!&3ab,
(45)
where Tap7
= aa7p-y
1 + 8 y T a p + ap7-p = F5fabcEzaEipE$, .
(46)
The fields r a p and ~~p~ have the roles of antisymmetric field B,, and its field strength BPup. Note that Wess-Zumino-Novikov-Wittenaction (Eq. (3.29) of Ref. 8)
exactly coincides with the action (1),if we substitute space-time with group manifold and put 6, = 0. The second term in Eq. (47) is topological WessZumino term.g The principal differences between space-time and group manifold cases are group conditions on the vielbeins ap~ga aa~g= p fabCEqaEip>
(48)
and on the antisymmetric tensor ~~p (46). The group manifold is space with nontrivial torsion
TfQp7= f2~;,,
(49)
and vanishing nonmetricity, Q& = 0. The Riemann curvature is different from zero, but generalized Riemann-Cartan curvature vanishes, so that the torsion parallelizes the m a n i f ~ l d . ~ 8. The Geometry Induced from the Group Manifold Following the general case, we can define two-dimensional induced metric and induced connection from the group manifold. We will change the notation. Let (P (to= T , E l = a) be the coordinates of two-dimensional world-sheet and a, = the corresponding derivatives. We will use the local space-time basis, relating with the coordinate one by
&
106
the vielbein Zz = {apqa,nF}. Here, dpq" = {Ga,q'a} is the local worldsheet basis and n: (i = 2,3, ..., D - 1) are local unit vectors, normal to the world-sheet . It is useful to introduce the quantities
(50)
u*i = t,Epanq.
u*p = t,E&dpq",
Here, t , are generators of the gauge group G , with normalization (t,, t b ) &b = -atr{t,tb} and ( x , Y )is the Cartan inner product. Starting with the definition of the induced metric (13), we obtain ~
p
=u TapapqQauqP = (u*p,v*u)
>
=
G p i = r a p a p q a niP -- ( u f p , U k i ) .
(51) In analogy with (16), the induced connection is defined by the expression
qfU = G"'~uqaTapD*oa,qP
=
(.$,
apUh7)
,
(52)
+
where D*,VP = d,q"D*,V - a,q"(daVP rtraV.) is the group manifold covariant derivative along world-sheet direction. The second fundamental form, with the help of Eq. (18), takes the form &ipu
= nqy,pa uq7D*r~p9 = ( U h i , a p v * u ) .
(53)
Consequently, we are ready to calculate mean extrinsic curvature and dual mean extrinsic curvature
(54)
*H*.a -=
1 &PU apu
=
1 &PU 1 T(u+i,-a u u * p ) = m ( u & i ,d-u*+-a+u*-).
2 Gb*'
d=
(55) The equations of motion in the form of self-duality conditions turn into the expression
1 H+i f *H*i = - ( ~ * i ,
G
~ T U * * )= 0 .
(56)
Because the inner product with all u*i vanishes, it follows that d,u** = 0. In terms of the group elements g, we have u + = ~ gd,g-l, u - = ~ g-'d,g, and the equations of motion obtain the standard forms LL(g8,g-l)
=0 ,
a+(g-ld-g) = 0 .
(57)
107
9. Conclusions We investigated the space-time geometry felt by the bosonic string propagating in nontrivial background. Particularly, we were interested in the case when group manifold takes the role of the space time and the action turns to the Wess-Zumino-Novikov-Witten one. We introduced affine space-time and defined torsion and nonmetricity. We also obtained expressions for the stringy torsion and stringy nonmetricity (37) originating from the antisymmetric tensor field B,, and dilaton fields @, respectively. We considered induced and extrinsic geometry, when the surface is embedded into space-time with torsion and nonmetricity. We introduced Cduality which maps MEC to DMEC and defined C-dual surface by the conditions O Hi = f* Hi. We made space-time classification depending on the background fields. The [ PI equation defines world-sheet as a stringy C-dual surface. In two particular cases -the vanishing torsion and the vanishing nonmetricitythe field equations turn to the equations of stringy minimal world-sheet *Hi = 0 and C-dual world-sheet Hi = f*HTirrespectively. In the case of Riemann space-time, when both torsion and nonmetricity vanish, they turn to the equations of minimal world-sheet Hi = 0. Using the above results, we investigated bosonic string propagation on group manifold. We offered the geometrical interpretation of the group manifold felt by the string. We found that the antisymmetric tensor field, which corresponds to the Wess-Zumino topological term, is the origin of the group manifold torsion. This field also parallelizes the manifold. The string feels the group manifold as a Riemann-Cartan space-time. In this language, the standard equations of motion (57) have the form of C-duality Hi f *Hi= 0. The difference between left and right chirality equations is a consequence of a nontrivial torsion. Acknowledgements This work is supported in part by the Serbian Ministry of Science, Technology and Development under contract No. 1486. References 1. M. B. Green, J. H. Schwarz and E. Witten, Superstring Theory, Cambridge University Press (1987); J. Polchinski, String Theory, Cambridge University Press (1998).
108
2. E. S. F’radkin and A. A. Tseytlin, Phys.Lett. B158, 316 (1985); Nucl.Phys. B261, 1 (1985); C. G. Callan, D. Friedan, E. J. Martinec and M. J. Perry, Nucl.Phys. B262, 593 (1985); T. Banks, D. Nemeschansky and A. Sen, Nucl.Phys. B277, 67 (1986); A. A. Tseytlin, Int. J . Mod. Phys. A4, 1257 (1989). 3. B. SazdoviC, hep-th/0304086. 4. M. BlagojeviC, Gravitation and gauge symmetries, IoP Publishing, Bristol (2002); F. W. Hehl, J. D. McCrea, E. W. Mielke and Y. Ne’eman, Phys. Rept. 258,1 (1995). 5. B. M. Barbashov and V. V. Nesterenko, Introduction to relativistic string theory, World Scientific, Singapore (1990); D. Sorokin, Phys. Rept. 329, 1 (2000). 6. B. SazdoviC, hep-th/0304085. 7. T. L. Curtright and C. K. Zachos, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53,1799 (1984); S. Mukhi, Phys.Lett. B162,345 (1985). 8. B. SazdoviC, Phys. Rev. D62,045011 (2000). 9. J. Wess and B. Zumino, Phys. Lett. B37,95 (1971); E.Witten, Comm. Math. Phys. 92,455 (1984). I
CAN BLACK HOLE RELAX UNITARILY?
S . N. SOLODUKHIN School of Engineering and Science, International University Bremen, P.O. Box 750561, Bremen 88759, Germany E-mail: [email protected] We review the way the BTZ black hole relaxes back to thermal equilibrium after a small perturbation and how it is seen in the boundary (finite volume) CFT. The unitarity requires the relaxation t o be quasi-periodic. It is preserved in the CFT but is not obvious in the case of the semiclassical black hole the relaxation of which is driven by complex quasi-normal modes. We discuss two ways of modifying the semiclassical black hole geometry to maintain unitarity: the (fractal) brick wall and the worm-hole modification. In the latter case the entropy comes out correctly as well.
1. Introduction Any thermodynamical system initially in equilibrium at finite temperature and then perturbed tends to return to the equilibrium if the perturbation is not too big and does not last too long. The important parameter which characterizes this process is the relaxation time T.' In fact, the process of relaxation back to the equilibrium is a particular and most easily tractable example of more general phenomenon of the thermalization, when system initially far from being thermal gets thermalized to a state characterized by certain temperature. The way how the thermalization goes for different systems is an important and still poorly understood problem. Gravitational physics gives yet another example of system which behaves thermally. This system is the black hole. The black hole formation can be viewed as another example of the thermalization: non-thermal collapsing body and the flat space-time geometry in the beginning transform to (thermal) black hole state in the end of the gravitational collapse. On the other hand, the already formed and stayed in equilibrium black hole can be perturbed by exciting a pulse of matter field in the exterior of black hole. The subsequent relaxation is very well studied in the literature and is known to be characterized by the 109
110
so-called quasi-normal modes. These modes are eigen values of the radial Schrodinger type equation subject to certain boundary conditions. These are dissipative boundary conditions saying that the perturbation should leave the region through all possible boundaries. In general, there are two such boundaries: black hole horizon and spatial infinity. Formulated this way, the boundary value problem is not self-adjoint so that the quasi-normal modes are typically complex w = W R - i w with ~ a negative imaginary part. In most cases there is a discrete set of such modes parameterized by integer number n. The imaginary value of the lowest ( n = 1) quasi-normal mode sets the relaxation time T = l / w ~ . In fact, what we have said in the beginning about the relaxation of any system back to thermal equilibrium should be made more precise: the system should be in infinite volume. In finite volume and if the evolution of the system is unitary, any perturbation once created never leaves the system so that the complete returning to the initial unperturbed state is not possible. Thus information about the perturbation never disappears completely and always can be restored. The characteristic time during which the perturbation (as well as the whole state of the system) is guaranteed to come back is set by the Poincark recurrence time. All this means that the characteristic frequencies which run the perturbation of unitary system in finite volume should be real and discrete. Depending on these frequencies the evolution of the perturbation is quasi-periodic or even chaotic. But it can never be dissipative. Thus, strictly speaking for the thermalization we need infinite volume. Of course, nothing is infinite in the real world. The system still may be considered as thermal during the interval of time which is considerably less than the Poincark recurrence time. What this implies for the black holes? More specifically, for asymptotically Ads black holes the state of thermal equilibrium of which is well defined and can last infinitely long? Such a black hole can be viewed as system put in the box with the size set by the Ads radius. So one would have to expect this black hole to behave as any other system in the finite volume and in particular to show the Poincark recurrences (for the discussion of this in de Sitter space, see Ref. 2). This however does not happen in the semiclassical black hole: the complex quasi-normal modes are always there. The presence of these modes is related to the very existence of the horizon. Once there is black hole horizon there will always be complex frequencies which govern the time evolution of the perturbation. This problem is a manifestation of the long-time debated issue of whether the black hole evolution is actually unitary (see Refs. 2, 3).
111
A refreshed look at the whole issue is offered by the AdS/CFT correspondence (see review in Ref. 4 ) . According to this correspondence the gravitational physics in the bulk of asymptotically Ads space has a dual description in terms of a Conformal Field Theory (CFT) living on the boundary. Thus, the black hole in the bulk corresponds to a thermal CFT. The relaxation of the black hole than has a dual description as relaxation of the CFT after a perturbation driven by certain conformal operator has been applied to the system. The quasi-normal modes thus set the time scale for the relaxation in the boundary CFT.5 The effect of the finite size however is rather delicate issue. It has been studied in Ref. 6 and is reviewed in section 3 of this note. The similar conclusions have been made in Ref. 7. The recent reviews on the issue of black hole relaxation and unitarity are Ref. 8 and Ref. 9. 2. Relaxation in Black Hole: Quasi-normal Modes
We consider (2+1)-dimensional BTZ black hole with metric given by ds2 = - sinh' y dt2
+ dy2 + cosh2y d+2 ,
(1)
where for simplicity we consider non-rotating black hole and set the size of the horizon r+ = 1 and Ads radius I = 1. The coordinate is periodic with period L so that the boundary has topology of cylinder and L sets the finite size for the boundary system. A bulk perturbation @(m,s) of mass m and spin s should satisfy the quasi-normal boundary condition, i.e. it should be in-going at the horizon and have vanishing flux at the infinity. The latter condition comes from the fact that in the asymptotically Ads space-times the effective radial potential is growing at infinity so that there can be no propagating modes as well as no leakage of the energy through the boundary. The relevant radial equation takes the form of the hypergeometric equation, which is exactly solvable. The quasi-normal modes in general fall into two setsloill
+
27r
w = -m-
L
where the left- and right-temperatures TL = TR = 1/2n and ( h ,h) have the meaning of the conformal weights of the dual operator O(h,h),corresponding to the bulk perturbation @ ( m , s ) , with h 71 = A(m), h - h = s and A(m) is determined in terms of the mass m.
+
112
For comparison, in the case of global anti-de Sitter space the horizon and respectively the quasi-normal modes are absent. But, instead, one can define the normalizable modes which form a discrete set of real frequenciesI2 w = 2nm/L
+ 4n(n + h)/L,
n EN,
(3)
where the size of the boundary is also set to be L as in the black hole case. 3. Relaxation in CFTz
The thermal state of the black hole in the bulk corresponds to the thermal state on the CFT side. In fact, the boundary CFT factorizes on left- and right-moving sectors with temperature TL and TR respectively. The bulk perturbation corresponds to perturbing the thermal field theory state with operator C7(h,~).The further evolution of the system is described by the so-called Linear Response Theory (see Ref. 1). According to this theory one has to look at the time evolution of the perturbation itself. More precisely, the relevant information is contained in the retarded correlation function of the perturbation at the moments t and t = 0 (when the perturbation has been first applied). Since the perturbation is considered to be small, the main evolution is still governed by the unperturbed Hamiltonian over the thermal state so that the correlation function is the thermal function at temperature T. Thus, the analysis boils down to the study of the thermal 2-point function of certain conformal operators. Such a function should be double periodic: with period 1/T in the direction of the Euclidean time and with period L in the direction of the compact coordinate 4. This can be first calculated as a 2-point function on the Euclidean torus and then analytically continued to the real time.
3.I. Universality In general the correlation function on torus can be rather complicated since its form is not fixed by the conformal symmetry. The conformal symmetry however may help to deduce the universal form of the 2-point function in two special cases: when size L of the system is infinite (temperature T is kept finite) and when inverse temperature is infinite (the size L is finite). The universal form of the (real time) 2-point function in the first case is
113
which for large t decays exponentially as e-2rrT(h+h)t. The information about the perturbation is thus lost after characteristic time set by the inverse temperature. It is clear that this happens because in infinite volume the information may dissipate to infinity. In the second case correlator
has the oscillatory behavior. Notice that the oscillatory behavior in the second case should have been expected since the system lives on the circle. The perturbation once created at the moment t = 0 at the point q5 = 0 travels around the circle with the speed of light and comes back to the same point at t = L. Thus, the information about the perturbation is never lost. The correlation function (5) as a function of time represents a series of singular picks concentrated at t = &4 n L , n E N. In fact, this behavior should be typical for any system with unitary evolution in finite volume. It is interesting to see what happens in the intermediate regime when both L and 1/T are kept finite. In this case the behavior of the correlation functions is not universal, may depend on the (se1f)interaction in the system and is known only in some cases. We consider two instructive examples: the free fermion field and the strongly coupled CFT which is dual to the gravity on Ad&.
+
3.2. Intermediate Regime: Free Fermions The two point function of free fermions on the torus is known explicitly (e.g. Ref. 13). The real time correlation function is
+
were w = i(t 4) and u characterizes the boundary conditions for +(w). For finite temperature boundary conditions we have u = 3,4. Using the properties of &functions, it is then easy to see that (6) is invariant under shifts w + w 1/T and w -+ w iL. It is then obvious that the resulting real time correlator (6) is a periodic function o f t with period L. Zeros of the theta function Bl(wT[iLT)are known13 to lie at w = m/T+inL, where m, n are arbitrary relative integers. Therefore, for real time t , the correlation function (6) is a sequence of singular peaks located at (t 4) = nL. Using the standard repre~entation'~of the &functions, we also find that in the
+
+
+
114
limit LT -+ rn the correlation function (6) approaches the left-moving part of (3) with h = 1 / 2 that exponentially decays with time,
TT
(1(I(w)1(I(0))3(4) = 4 sinh TT(t + 4) [l f 2e-TLT cosh 27rT(t
+ 4 ) + . .I
. (7)
In the opposite limit, when LT -+ 0, it approaches the oscillating function (5). A natural question is how the asymptotic behavior (7), when size of the system is taken to infinity, can be consistent with the periodicity, t -+ t L , of the correlation function (6) at any finite L? In order to answer this question we have to observe that there are two different time scales in the game. The first time scale is set by the inverse temperature 7 1 = 1/T and is kept finite while the second time scale is associated with the size of the system 1-2 = 1/L. When L is taken to infinity we have that 72 >> 7 1 . Now, when the time t is of the order of 7 1 but much less than 1-2 the asymptotic expansion (7) takes place. The corrections to the leading term are multiplied by the factor e-TLT and are small. The 2-point function thus is exponentially decaying in this regime. It seems that the system has almost lost information about the initial perturbation (at t = 0). But it is not true: as time goes on and approaches the second time scale t 72 the corrections to the leading term in (7) become important and the system starts to collect its memory about the initial perturbation. The information is completely recovered as t = 72 and the time-periodicity is restored. This example is instructive. In particular, it illustrates our point that there can be thermalization in the finite volume for relatively small intervals of time, i.e. when t << 1-2.
+
-
3.3. Strongly Coupled CFT2 Dual to Ad& As an example of a strongly coupled theory we consider the supersymmetric conformal field theory dual to string theory on Ad&. This theory describes the low energy excitations of a large number of D1- and D S - b r a n e ~It . ~can be interpreted as a gas of strings that wind around a circle of length L with target space T 4 . The individual strings can be simply- or multiply wound such that the total winding number is k = I,where c >> 1 is the central charge. The parameter k plays the role of N in the usual terminology of large N CFT. According to the prescription (see Ref. 4),each AdS space which asymptotically approaches the given two-dimensional manifold should contribute to the calculation, and one thus has to sum over all such spaces. In the case of interest, the two-manifold is a torus ( ~ , 4 )where , 1/T and L are
115
the respective periods. There exist two obvious Ads spaces which approach the torus asymptotically. The first is the BTZ black hole in Ads3 and the second is the so-called thermal Ads space, corresponding to anti-de Sitter space filled with thermal radiation. Both spaces can be represented (see Ref. 14) as a quotient of three dimensional hyperbolic space H 3 , with line element 12
ds2 = -(dzdZ
Y2
+dy2),
y
> 0.
In both cases, the boundary of the three-dimensional space is a rectangular torus with periods L and 1/T. We see that the two configurations (thermal AdS and the BTZ black hole) are T-dual to each other, and are obtained by the interchange of the coordinates T H q5 and L t) 1/T on the torus. In fact there is a whole SL(2, Z) family of spaces which are quotients of the hyperbolic space. In order to find correlation function of the dual conformal operators, one has to solve the respective bulk field equations subject to Dirichlet boundary condition, substitute the solution into the action and differentiate the action twice with respect to the boundary value of the field. The boundary field thus plays the role of the source for the dual operator O(,,h). This way one can obtain the boundary CFT correlation function for each member of the family of asymptotically Ads spaces. The total correlation function is then given by the sum over all SL(2,Z) family with appropriate weight. However, for our purposes it is sufficient to consider the contribution of only two contribution^'^
( O ( t ,~ ) o (0)) o ,= e-"TZ(O
o')BTZ
+ e-'Aa
(O O ' ) A d S
,
(9)
where SET,= - h L T / 2 and S A d S = -kn/2LT are Euclidean actions of the BTZ black hole and thermal AdS3, respectively.16 On the Euclidean torus ( )BTZ and ( ) A d s are T-dual to each other. Their exact form can be computed ex~licit1y.l~ For our purposes it is sufficient to note that the (realtime) 2-point function coming from the BTZ part is exponentially decaying, ( )BTZ e-2?rhTt even though it is a correlation function in a system of finite size L. On the other hand, the part coming from the thermal Ads is oscillating with period L, as it should be for a system at finite size. Thus, the total 2-point function (9) has two contributions: one is exponentially decaying and another is oscillating. So that (9) is not a quasi-periodic function of time t. This conclusion does not seem to change if we include sum over SL(2, Z) in Eq. (9). There will always be contribution of the BTZ black hole that is exponentially decaying. This can be formulated also in N
116
terms of the poles in the momentum representation of 2-point function (see Refs. 11, 18). The poles of ( )BTZ are exactly the complex quasi-normal modes (2) while that of ( )Ads are the real normalizable modes (3). Depending on the value of LT, one of the two terms in Eq. (9) dominates.16 For high temperature (LT is large) the BTZ is dominating, while at low temperature (LT is small) the thermal AdS is dominant. The transition between the two regimes occurs at 1/T = L. In terms of the gravitational physics, this corresponds t o the Hawking-Page phase t r a n ~ i t i 0 n . l ~ This is a sharp transition for large k, which is the case when the supergravity description is valid. The Hawking-Page transition is thus a transition between oscillatory relaxation at low temperature and exponential decay at high temperature.
3.4. The Puzzle and Resolution Thus, the AdS/CFT correspondence predicts that the CFT dual to gravity on Ad& is rather peculiar. Even though, it is in finite volume, the relaxation in this theory is combination of oscillating and exponentially decaying functions. This immediately raises a puzzle: how this behavior is consistent with the general requirement for a unitary theory in finite volume to have only quasi-periodic relaxation? A resolution of this puzzle was suggested in Ref. 6. It was suggested that additionally to the size L there exists another scale in the game. This scale appears due to the fact that in the dual CFT at high temperature the typical configuration consists of multiply wound strings which effectively propagate in a much bigger volume, Leff kL. The gravity/CFT duality however is valid in the limit of infinite k in which this second scale becomes infinite. So that the exponential relaxation corresponds to infinite effective size Leff that is in complete agreement with the general arguments. At finite k the scale Leff would be finite and the correlation function is expected to be quasi-periodic with two periods: 1/L and l/Leff. The transition of this quasi-periodic function to combination of exponentially decaying and oscillating functions when Leff is infinite then should be similar to what we have observed in the case of free fermions when L was taken to infinity. N
4. Black Hole Unitarity: Finite k
That relaxation of black hole is characterized by a set of complex frequencies (quasi-normal modes) is a mathematically precise formulation of the lack of unitarity in the semiclassical description of black holes. The unitarity prob-
117
lem was suggested to be resolved within the AdS/CFT correspondence. l5 Indeed, the theory on the boundary is unitary and there should be a way of reformulating the processes happening in the bulk of black hole space-time on the intrinsically unitary language of the boundary CFT. The analysis of the relaxation is helpful in understanding how this reformulation should work. Before making comments on that let us note that the loss of information in semiclassical black hole is indeed visible on the CFT side. It is encoded in that exponentially decaying contribution to the 2-point correlation function. For the CFT itself this however is not a problem. As we discussed above, the finite size unitarity is restored at finite value of k. This however goes beyond the limits where the gravity/CFT duality is formulated. Assuming that the duality can be extended to finite k an important question arises: What would be the gravity counter-part of the duality at finite k ? Obviously, it can not be a semiclassical black hole. The black hole horizon should be somehow removed so that the complex quasinormal modes (at infinite k) would be replaced by real (normal) modes when k is finite. Below we consider two possibilities of how it may happen.
4.1. Fractal Brick Wall
It was suggested in Ref. 7 that the quantum modification of the black hole geometry, needed for the restoring the PoincarC recurrences, can be modeled by the brick wall. Here we elaborate on this interesting idea. The brick wall is introduced by placing a boundary at small distance E from the horizon and cutting off a part of the space-time lying inside the boundary. The effect of the boundary on the quantum fields is implemented by imposing there the Dirichlet boundary condition. Originally, the brick wall was introduced by 't Hooft2' for regularizing the entropy of the thermal atmosphere out-side black hole horizon. With this regularization the quantum entropy S, correctly reproduces the proportionality of the black hole entropy to the horizon area A rf-'. Assuming that E is taken to be of the order of the Planck length, so that Newton's constant is G c d P 2 , one can argue that the black hole entropy is correctly reproduced in this approach. Later on it was, however, realized that the brick wall divergence is actually a UV divergence. One can introduce a set of the Pauli-Villars fields with masses set by parameter p, which plays the role of the UV regulator. Taking into account the contribution of the regulator fields in the entropy of the quantum atmosphere the brick wall can be removed.21 The entropy then is proportional to certain power of the UV regulator, S,
-
-
-
-
118
In our story of black hole relaxation the brick wall indeed gives the wanted effect: once the brick wall has been introduced the quasi-normal modes disappear completely and are replaced by a set of the real (normal) modes. This happens because the effective infinite size region near horizon is now removed and the whole space is the finite size region between the brick wall and the boundary at spatial infinity. In such a system we expect periodicity with the period set by the brick wall parameter E as tbw l/Tln(l/c). This periodicity shows up in the boundary CFT correlation functions rather naturally. Indeed, these correlation functions are constructed from the bulk Green’s function which describes propagation of the perturbation between two points on the boundary through the bulk. In the present case the perturbation from a point 4 on the boundary goes along null-geodesic through the bulk, reflects at the brick wall and returns to the same point 4 on the boundary. The time which the perturbation travels gives the periodicity for the boundary theory and it equals tbw. Matching tbw and l/Leff gives the relation between brick wall regulator E and parameter k of the large N boundary CFT. This probably should be enough for the explaining and reproducing the second time scale of the boundary CFT from the gravity side. The time tbw is however much smaller than the Poincar6 recurrence time which is A expected t o be of the order, tp e: . So how t o get this time scale in the model with the brick wall? We notice that the brick wall should not be ideally spherical. The possible complexity of the shape is not restricted. It may even be fractal. In order to serve as a regulator for the quantum entropy calculation brick wall should just stay at mean distance E from the horizon, but its shape can be arbitrary. For the recurrence time the shape is however crucial. In the absence of the spherical symmetry the perturbation emitted from the point 4 on the boundary (which is still a circle) at spatial infinity goes along null-geodesic through the bulk, reflects from the brick wall, goes back and arrives at completely different point 4’ on the boundary at spatial infinity. Only after a number of back and forth goings between two boundaries the perturbation can manage to arrive on the boundary at the same point where it was initially emitted. This number can be very large and it sets the periodicity for the boundary theory. The emerging geometric picture is standard set up for the system having classical chaos. Indeed, generic deviations from the spherical symmetry of one of the boundaries leads to chaotic behavior of the geodesics. This means that the 2-point functions on the boundary would generically have chaotic time evolution. The optical volume V between two boundaries N
N
119
seems to be the right quantity to measure the size of the phase space of the chaotic geodesics. Since S, V the recurrence time t p ev gives the right estimate for the Poincark time. In this picture the information sent to black hole eventually comes back. The characteristic time during which it should happen is set by the Poincark recurrence time t p . The classical chaos of the geodesics manifests in the (normal) frequencies. The latter are the eigenvalues of the Laplace-type operator considered on the classical geometry. As we know from the relation between classical and quantum chaos, the chaos of the geodesics in the classical system manifests in that the eigen values of the quantum problem are randomly distributed. Thus, the normal frequencies will be random numbers. This again means that the 2-point function on the boundary (we expect that the normal modes are still poles in the momentum representation of the correlation function) is chaotic function of time. The irregularity of the shape of the brick wall may actually be physically meaningful. It can model the fluctuating quantum horizon. It may also be a way of representing the so-called stretched horizon (see Ref. 2 2 ) . N
N
4.2. Worm-hole Modification: BTZk
The horizon can be removed in a smooth way by modifying the black hole geometry and making it looks like a worm-hole. As an example we present here a modification of the BTZ metric ( l ) , 1 ds2 = -(sinh2 y -) dt2 d y 2 cosh2 y d 4 2 , k2 which we call BTZk. The horizon which used t o stay at y < 0 disappears in metric (10) if k is finite. The whole geometry now is that of worm-hole with the second asymptotic region a t y = -m. The two asymptotic regions separated by horizon in classical BTZ metric can now talk to each other leaking the information through the narrow throat. The metric (10) is still asymptotically AdS although it is no more a constant curvature space-time. The Ricci scalar 2 R=[(k2 1) 3k4 sinh4 y 5k2 sinh2 y] (11) (k2 sinh2 y 1)2
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+
approaches value -6 at infinite y and -2(k2 1) at y = 0 where the horizon used to stay. The normal frequencies in the space-time with metric (10) are real and are determined by the normalizability and the Dirichlet boundary condition at both spatial infinities. Since the space-time (10) is asymptotically AdS one can use the rules of the AdS/CFT duality and
120
calculate the boundary correlation function. Technically it is more difficult than in the standard BTZ case since (10) is not maximally symmetric space. But the result should be a periodic in time function with the period set by parameter k. It would be interesting to do this calculation and see if this correlation function makes sense from the point of view of the expected behavior of the boundary CFT a t finite k. One can calculate the entropy of the thermal atmosphere in the metric (10). It is now finite with no need for introducing the brick wall. The entropy then behaves as S, kA that is the right answer for the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of BTZ black hole. Thus, the modification (10) gives us the right entropy and solves the unitarity problem. N
Acknowledgments
I would like t o thank D. Birmingham and I. Sachs for enjoyable collaboration and many useful discussions. I also thank G. Arutyunov, J. Barbon, A. Morozov and N. Kaloper for important discussions. References 1. A. L. Fetter and J. D. Walecka, Quantum Theory of Many-Particle Systems, McGraw-Hill Book Company (1971). 2. L. Susskind, hep-th/0204027. 3. S. W. Hawking, Phys. Rev. D14, 2460 (1976). 4. 0. Aharony, S. S. Gubser, J. Maldacena, H. Ooguri and Y. Oz, Phys. Rev. 323,183 (2000). 5. G. T. Horowitz and V. E. Hubeny, Phys. Rev. D62, 024027 (2000). 6. D. Birmingham, I. Sachs and S . N. Solodukhin, Phys. Rev. D67, 104026 (2003). 7. J. L. F. Barbon and E. Rabinovici, JHEP 0311,047 (2003). 8. I. Sachs, Fortsch. Phys. 52,667 (2004). 9. J. L. F. Barbon and E. Rabinovici, Fortsch. Phys. 52,642 (2004). 10. V. Cardoso and J. P. S. Lemos, Phys. Rev. D63, 124015 (2001); D.Birmingham, Phys. Rev. D64,064024 (2001). 11. D. Birmingham, I. Sachs and S. N. Solodukhin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 8 8 , 151301 (2002). 12. V. Balasubramanian, P. Kraus and A. E. Lawrence, Phys. Rev. D59, 046003 (1999). 13. P.Di Francesco, P. Mathieu and D. Senechal, Conformal Field Theory, New York, USA: Springer (1997). 14. S. Carlip and C. Teitelboim, Phys. Rev. D51,622 (1995).
15. J. M. Maldacena, hepth/0106112. 16. J. M. Maldacena and A. Strominger, JHEP 9812,005 (1998).
121
17. L. Chekhov, hep-th/9811146; E. Keski-Vakkuri, Phys. Rev. D59, 104001 (1999). 18. U. H. Danielsson, E. Keski-Vakkuri and M. Kruczenski, Nucl. Phys. B563, 279 (1999). 19. S. W. Hawking and D. N. Page, Commun. Math. Phys. 87,577 (1983). 20. G. 't Hooft, Nucl. Phys. B256,727 (1985). 21. J. G. Demers, R. Lafrance and R. C. Myers, Phys. Rev. D52, 2245 (1995). 22. N. Iizuka, D. Kabat, G. Lifschytz and D. A. Lowe, Phys. Rev. D68, 084021 (2003).
DEFORMED COORDINATE SPACES DERIVATIVES
J. WESS Universitat Munchen, Fakultat fur Physik Theresienstr. 37, 0-80333 Munchen, Germany and Max- Planck- Institut f u r Physik Fohringer Ring 6, 0-80805 Munchen, Germany E-mail: [email protected] The concept of derivatives on quantum spaces is worked out in detail. Special example of the @-deformedcoordinate space is analysed. It is shown that it is possible t o construct a deformed Lorentz symmetry for this space. Fields are defined in such a way that they transform with respect to the deformed symmetry.
1. Introduction
This lecture is based on joint work with Marija Dimitrijevi6, Laxisa Jonke, Frank Meyer, Lutz Moller, Efrossini Tsouchnika and Michael Wohlgenannt.' The aim of this lecture is to clarify the concept of derivatives on quantum spaces.2 These derivatives are an essential input for the construction of deformed field equations such as the deformed Klein-Gordon or Dirac equation^.^ These deformed field equations are in turn the starting point for field theories on quantum spaces. For a given coordinate space there are in general many ways t o define derivatives.* We shall try to develop a general concept of such derivatives into which all the different sets of derivatives fit and that allows us by adding additional requirements - usually based on symmetries - to reduce the number of possible derivatives. 2. Deformed Coordinate Spaces Let me first remind you of the concept of deformed coordinate spaces (DCS) which we will use as quantum spaces. DCS are defined in terms of coordi122
123
nates F , p = 1. . . n and relations. Examples of such relations are 1. Canonical relations5
[P, 27 = i P V ,
(1)
for constant 0 it leads to the so called &deformed coordinate space (0-DCS). 2. Lie-type relations6 where the coordinates form a Lie algebra = iCf”P,
[F, 27
(2)
Cr” are the structure constants. Among these is the r;-deformed quantum space (K-DCS).~ 3. Quantum group relations: 2Pg” = -RP”,$PP“ 1
(3)
9
where the R-matrix defines a quantum group.8 These are the q-deformed spaces (q-DCS). The DCS is the algebra d n , this is the factor space of the algebra freely generated by the elements ri-p divided by the ideal generated by the relation^.^ We not only consider polynomials in d, but formal power series as well. In short all polynomials of the coordinates 2” that can be transformed into each other by using the relations are linearly dependent. For the examples listed it can be shown that the dimensions of the vector spaces of polynomials with given degree are the same as for commuting coordinates. This is the socalled Poincark-Birkhoff-Witt property.1°
3. Derivatives Derivatives are maps of the DCS
5:dn+d*.
(4)
They are usually defined by maps on the coordinates, and therefore on the free algebra defined by them. To define a map on the factor space DCS, derivatives have to be consistent with the relations defining the DCS. They also should lead to a Leibniz rule. A very general ansatz for the action of a derivative on the coordinates is:
[&, 2 7
= 5(;
+
c
A;p’-.pJ
j
5 .. . P1
*
(5)
124
The coefficients AY’””3 are complex numbers. They have to be chosen such that Eq. ( 5 ) is consistent with the relations. Having found such coefficients a Leibniz rule can be derived because ( f i j )can be computed from Eq. ( 5 ) , f and ij are elements of A,. Maps can also be defined on the set of derivatives:
E : 6-+Sl,
6;
= E/(6)&.
(6)
The matrix E depends on the derivatives 8 only, not on the coordinates. Because the derivatives 8 are maps on DCS the new derivatives will be as well. If E is invertible and if the matrix E starts with the Kronecker symbol as derivative-independent term we obtain from Eq. (6) again derivatives in the sense of Eq. (5). All derivatives satisfying the consistency condition that have been found up to now are related by such transformations. We shall discuss the 8-DCS here, this is the simplest case. The relations (1) are consistent with
[a,, ?”I
= 6;
.
(7)
A short calculation shows: ( p y- y p - ip”)= ( p p- p
af
p
-~ 2. 9P”
)af .
(8)
This is sufficient t o prove consistency. Eq. (7) leads to the Leibniz rule by applying Eq. (7) to the product of the two functions f i j
4 ( f i j ) = (&,f)ij + f ( 8 P i j )
*
(9)
A short calculation shows that
[6&]
=0
(10)
is compatible with the relations (7). We can assume that the derivatives commute and define an algebra that way. The Leibniz rule (9) can be algebraically formulated as a comultiplication:
A i P = 6,, @ 1 + 1 8
aP.
It is compatible with the Lie algebra (10): [A6P,A&] = 0 , (12) and it is coassociative. Thus, Eqs. (10) and (11) define a bialgebra, the q-deformed bialgebra of translations in the 8-DCS.
125
Other sets of derivatives can be obtained from bp by a transformation (6). In general, such derivatives will not have defining relations that are linear in 8 such as Eq. (7). They will also have more complicated comultiplication rules. Thus the definition (7) singles out a specific type of derivatives. Moreover they will transform linearly under a &deformed orthogonal or Lorentz group. We shall now show that.
4. Deformed Symmetry Algebra
A deformed orthogonal group or a deformed Lorentz group will be a deformation of the transformations
where wpu are the parameters of the infinitesimal orthogonal or Lorentz transformations. The corresponding Lie algebra satisfies:
[L, 1s: = L x , t , (w x w’),