Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Related titles: Wood–polymer composites (ISBN 978-1-84569-272-8) Wood–polymer composites are becoming more accepted in advanced engineering applications. The latest generation of wood–polymer composites are being used in automotive, civil and marine engineering. Advances in durability, mechanical properties and materials used in their production have allowed a significant increase in their use in outdoor applications such as decking, fencing, utility poles and exterior woodwork on buildings. Wood–polymer composites also benefit from being more sustainable than other, traditional, composites and possess a consistency in quality that cannot be achieved by wood alone. This book provides a comprehensive survey on major new developments in wood–polymer composites and presents current research from leading innovators around the world. Recycling in textiles (ISBN 978-1-85573-952-9) An increasing amount of waste is generated each year from textiles (including carpets and clothing) and their production. For economic and environmental reasons it is necessary that as much as possible of this waste is recycled instead of being disposed of in landfill sites. On average approximately ten million tonnes of textile waste is currently dumped in Europe and America each year. Recycling in textiles is the first book to bring together textile recycling issues, technology, products, processes and applications for all of those in the industry who are now looking for ways to recycle their textile waste. Design and manufacture of textile composites (ISBN 978-1-85573-744-0) The term ‘textile composites’ is often used to describe a rather narrow range of materials, based on three-dimensional reinforcements produced using specialist equipment. The intention in this book is to describe the broad range of polymer composite materials with textile reinforcements, from woven and non-crimp commodity fabrics to 3D textiles. Whilst attention is given to modelling of textile structures, composites manufacturing methods and subsequent component performance, it is substantially a practical book intended to help all those developing new products with textile composites. Details of these and other Woodhead Publishing materials books can be obtained by: • •
visiting our web site at www.woodheadpublishing.com contacting Customer Services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 893694; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 891358 ext. 130; address: Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Granta Park, Great Abington, Cambridge CB21 6AH, UK)
If you would like to receive information on forthcoming titles, please send your address details to: Francis Dodds (address, tel. and fax as above; e-mail: francis.
[email protected]). Please confirm which subject areas you are interested in.
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites Edited by Vannessa Goodship
Oxford
Cambridge
New Delhi
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Granta Park, Great Abington, Cambridge CB21 6AH, UK www.woodheadpublishing.com Woodhead Publishing India Private Limited, G-2, Vardaan House, 7/28 Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi – 110002, India www.woodheadpublishingindia.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway, NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487, USA First published 2010, Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2010 The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-462-3 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-766-2 (e-book) CRC Press ISBN 978-1-4398-0104-8 CRC Press order number: N10005 The publishers’ policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elemental chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publishers ensure that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by Toppan Best-set Premedia Limited, Hong Kong Printed by TJ International Limited, Padstow, Cornwall, UK
Contents
Contributor contact details Preface
xiii xvii
Part I Management of waste composites
1
1
3
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 2.10
An introduction to composites recycling N. Reynolds and M. Pharaoh, University of Warwick, UK Introduction Composite material types Physical properties Current composite market What is ‘suitability for recycling’? Recycling methods Conclusions References Legislation for recycling waste composites R. Stewart, c/o University of Warwick, UK Legislation Brief history of the European Union Environment Action Programme 6 and the shape of future legislation Next steps for waste management The Waste Framework Directive Environmental Permitting Regulations The Landfill Directive Integrated product policy United Kingdom legislation: The Climate Change Act 2008 End-of-Life Vehicle Directive
3 5 8 12 13 17 18 19 20 20 21 26 28 29 30 30 31 32 33 v
vi
Contents
2.11 2.12 2.13
Waste Electric and Electronic Equipment Regulations Conclusions References
34 35 36
3
Waste management R. Stewart, c/o University of Warwick, UK Introduction The Waste Framework Directive Environmental Permitting Regulations End-of-Life Vehicle Directive Waste Electric and Electronic Equipment Regulations Classification and labelling of waste Conclusions References
39
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8
39 40 44 50 51 55 59 60
Part II Thermal technologies for recycling waste composites
63
4
65
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 5 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites S. J. Pickering, University of Nottingham, UK Introduction The fluidised bed recycling process Properties of the recycled fibre Applications for reuse of the fibre recycled from the fluidised bed process Prospects for commercial operation Current research, future trends and sources of further information and advice References Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites M. Blazsó, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary Introduction Pyrolysis reactions and products of thermoplastics Pyrolysis reactions and products of thermosets Pyrolyser reactors for polymer recycling Pyrolysis of polymer composites Pyrolysis conditions for polymer composites recycling Environmental concern about pyrolysis products of composites Summarizing comments on recycling polymer composites by pyrolysis
65 67 74 83 98 98 100 102 102 104 109 110 112 114 115 116
Contents
vii
5.9 5.10
Acknowledgements References
117 118
6
Catalytic processing of waste polymer composites M. A. Keane, Heriot-Watt University, UK Introduction Waste polymer recycle: motivation Thermal decomposition of waste plastics Catalytic approach to polymer recycling Catalytic treatment of non-halogen containing polymer waste Catalytic treatment of halogenated polymers: focus on polyvinyl chloride Future trends and conclusions Sources of further information and advice References
122
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9 7
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 8
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7
Advanced thermal treatment of composite wastes for energy recovery P. Lettieri, L. Yassin and S. J. R. Simons, University College London, UK Introduction Introduction to waste management Techno-economic analysis of energy from waste advanced thermal processes Sample calculations Conclusions Notation References Fluidized bed pyrolysis of waste polymer composites for oil and gas recovery W. Kaminsky, University of Hamburg, Germany Introduction Pyrolysis Fluidized bed pyrolysis Polymer composite materials Gas and oil recovery Possibilities and limits: future trends References
122 123 127 127 139 141 143 143 144
152
152 156 171 183 187 188 189
192 192 193 194 200 202 209 212
viii
Contents
Part III Mechanical technologies for recycling waste composites 9
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5
10
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7
11
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6 11.7 11.8 11.9 11.10
Mechanical methods for recycling waste composites K. Makenji, University of Warwick, UK Introduction and background Identification of waste plastic materials and fillers Waste preparation, sorting and readiness for end application use Conclusions References
Additives to upgrade mechanically recycled plastic composites R. Pfaendner, Ciba Lampertheim GmbH, Germany Introduction Properties of recycled plastics and recycled composites Additives to upgrade recycled plastics Specific examples of additives for recycled plastic composites Conclusions and future trends List of additives mentioned in Sections 10.3 and 10.4 References
Improving the mechanical recycling and reuse of mixed plastics and polymer composites K. Tarverdi, Brunel University, UK Introduction Thermoplastic and thermosetting polymers Polymer composites Materials recycling Consumer protection The powder impression moulding process Future technologies for converting mixed waste plastic (composites) into products Case studies: recycling archives Sources of further information and advice References
215
217 217 224 225 246 250
253
253 254 258 267 273 273 276
281 281 282 284 286 290 292 296 297 300 301
Contents 12
12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5
Quality and durability of recycled composite materials K. L. Pickering, University of Waikato, New Zealand, and M. D. H. Beg, University of Malaysia Pahang, Malaysia Introduction Recycling thermoset matrix composites Recycling thermoplastic matrix composites Conclusions References
Part IV Improving sustainable manufacture of composites 13
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7 13.8 13.9 13.10 14
14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5 14.6 14.7
Clean and environmentally friendly wet-filament winding N. Shotton-Gale, D. Harris, S. D. Pandita, M. A. Paget, J. A. Allen and G. F. Fernando, University of Birmingham, UK Introduction Resin impregnation modelling The application of selected impregnation models to clean filament winding Clean filament winding: resin impregnation unit Experimental Results and discussion Conclusions Acknowledgements Notation References Process monitoring and damage detection using optical fibre sensors D. Harris, V. R. Machavaram and G. F. Fernando, University of Birmingham, UK Introduction to optical fibres Introduction to chemical process monitoring Hybrid fibre sensors (small-diameter optical fibres) Damage detection using self-sensing composites Conventional optical fibre sensors Sensing strategies using conventional optical fibres Sensors for monitoring strain and temperature
ix
303
303 304 312 323 324
329
331
331 341 349 352 355 357 363 364 364 365
369
369 374 384 385 387 387 407
x
Contents
14.8
Applications of fibre Bragg grating and extrinsic fibre Fabry–Perot interferometric sensors in composites Multi-measurand sensor design Conclusions Acknowledgements References
14.9 14.10 14.11 14.12 15
15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6 15.7 15.8 15.9 15.10 15.11 15.12
New developments in producing more functional and sustainable composites G. F. Smith, University of Warwick, UK Introduction Glass fibre composites Carbon fibre composites Natural fibres Multi-layer, multi-functional composites Sustainability Biomimetics Self-reinforced composites Nanoparticulate composites Hybrid structures Conclusions References
Part V Case studies 16
16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 16.5 16.6 17
17.1 17.2
Designing composite wind turbine blades for disposal, recycling or reuse N. Papadakis, Technological Educational Institution (TEI) of Crete, Greece, C. Ramírez, Centro de Ingeniería Avanzada en Turbomáquinas S.de R.L. de C.V., México and N. Reynolds, University of Warwick, UK Current wind energy market and trends Turbine design and manufacture Usage End of life Conclusions References In-process composite recycling in the aerospace industry K. Potter and C. Ward, University of Bristol, UK Introduction Composite consumption in the aerospace industry
409 414 415 417 417
425 425 426 428 429 433 434 436 436 436 437 438 438
441 443
443 444 451 453 456 456
458 458 459
Contents 17.3 17.4 17.5 17.6 17.7 17.8 17.9 17.10 17.11
18
18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 18.5 18.6 18.7 18.8 18.9 18.10
19
19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 19.5 19.6 19.7 19.8 19.9
Scrap in the aerospace composites industry Composite design and manufacture and their influence on scrap generation Composite design choices and their effect on manufacture Further composite design effects Uncured scrap material and reuse potential Future trends in composites manufacture; impacts on waste generation Conclusions Sources of further information and advice References
Disposal of composite boats and other marine composites M. M. Singh, J. Summerscales, University of Plymouth, UK and K. Wittamore, Triskel Consultants Limited, UK Introduction Market size The design phase The manufacture and marketing phase The use phase End of life Vive la différence? Conclusions Acknowledgements References
Sustainable fibre-reinforced polymer composites in construction M. Fan, Brunel University, UK Basic concept and history Polymer composites in building construction Composites in bridge construction Composites in other constructions Performance in use Construction wastes, reclaim and recycling New development and challenge of construction composites Acknowledgements References
xi 459 464 468 473 477 483 487 490 490
495
495 496 499 500 500 501 514 514 515 515
520 520 525 535 541 543 549 556 561 561
xii
Contents
20
Recycling of concrete P. Purnell, University of Leeds, UK and A. Dunster, BRE, UK Introduction Concrete as a composite Sustainability: incentives for recycling Future trends and drivers Recycling of concrete Recycling of concrete from pre-cast operations End uses (recycled concrete aggregate in readymixed concrete) End uses of recycled concrete aggregate in other construction applications Overall view Sources of further information and advice References
569
Index
593
20.1 20.2 20.3 20.4 20.5 20.6 20.7 20.8 20.9 20.10 20.11
569 570 575 576 577 583 584 586 589 589 589
Contributor contact details
(* = main contact)
Editor
Chapter 4
Dr Vannessa Goodship WMG Department of Engineering University of Warwick Coventry CV4 7AL UK Email:
[email protected]
Dr Stephen Pickering Department of Mechanical, Materials and Manufacturing Engineering University of Nottingham University Park Nottingham NG7 2RD UK Email: Stephen.pickering@ nottingham.ac.uk
Chapter 1 Neil Reynolds* and Dr Mark Pharaoh WMG Department of Engineering University of Warwick Coventry CV4 7AL UK Email: Neil.reynolds@warwick. ac.uk
[email protected]
Chapter 5 Dr Marianne Blazsó Institute of Materials and Environmental Chemistry Chemical Research Center Hungarian Academy of Sciences Pusztaszeri út 59-67 1025 Budapest Hungary Email:
[email protected]
Chapters 2 and 3 Dr Rebecca Stewart, Ph.D, C.Phys. M.Inst.P c/o V. Goodship IARC School of Engineering University of Warwick Coventry CV4 7AL UK Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 6 Professor Mark A. Keane Chemical Engineering School of Engineering & Physical Sciences Heriot-Watt University Edinburgh EH14 4AS UK Email:
[email protected] xiii
xiv
Contributor contact details
Chapter 7
Chapter 10
Dr Paola Lettieri,* Dr Liban Yassin and Professor Stefaan J. R. Simons Centre for CO2 Technology Department of Chemical Engineering University College London Torrington Place London WC1E 7JE UK Email:
[email protected]
Dr Rudolf Pfaendner Ciba Lampertheim GmbH DE-68623 Lampertheim Germany Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 8 Professor W. Kaminsky Institute of Technical and Macromolecular Chemistry University of Hamburg Bundesstraβe 45 20146 Hamburg Germany Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 9 Kylash Makenji, M.Sc. WMG Department of Engineering University of Warwick Gibbet Hill Road Coventry CV4 7AL UK Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 11 Dr Karnik Tarverdi Reader/Director of Extrusion Technology Wolfson Centre for Materials Processing Brunel University Kingston Lane Uxbridge UB8 3PH UK Email: Karnik.Tarverdi@brunel. ac.uk
Chapter 12 Dr Kim L. Pickering* Department of Engineering University of Waikato Private Bag 3105 Hamilton New Zealand Email:
[email protected] Dr Mohammad Dalour Hossen Beg Faculty of Chemical and Natural Resources Engineering University of Malaysia Pahang Lebuhraya Tun Razak 26300 Kuantan, Pahang Darul Makmur Malaysia Email:
[email protected]
Contributor contact details
xv
Chapter 13
Chapter 16
Nick Shotton-Gale, Dee Harris, Surya D. Pandita, Mark Paget, John A. Allen, and Professor Gerard F. Fernando* School of Metallurgy and Materials University of Birmingham Edgbaston Birmingham B15 2TT UK Email:
[email protected]
Dr Nikolaos Papadakis Wind Energy and Power Synthesis Laboratory Technological Educational Institution (TEI) of Crete Estavromenos Heraklion Crete GR 71004 Greece Email:
[email protected] [email protected]
Chapter 14 Dee Harris, Dr Venkata R. Machavaram and Professor Gerard F. Fernando* School of Metallurgy and Materials University of Birmingham Edgbaston Birmingham B15 2TT UK Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 15 Professor G. F. Smith WMG Department of Engineering University of Warwick Coventry CV4 7AL UK Email:
[email protected]
Dr Carlos Ramírez Av. Constituyentes 120 Pte 2do Piso Col. El Carrizal. Cp 76030 Queretaro, Qro. México Centro de Ingeniería Avanzada en Turbomáquinas S.de R.L. de C.V. Email: carlos.ramirez@ warwickgrad.net Neil Reynolds* WMG Department of Engineering University of Warwick Coventry CV4 7AL UK Email: Neil.reynolds@warwick. ac.uk
xvi
Contributor contact details
Chapter 17
Chapter 19
Dr Kevin Potter* and Carwyn Ward Department of Aerospace Engineering Queens Building University Walk University of Bristol Bristol BS8 1TR UK Email:
[email protected]
Dr Mizi Fan Head of Research Civil Engineering School of Engineering and Design Brunel University Uxbridge UB8 3PH UK Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 18
Phil Purnell, Ph.D., B.Eng. Reader (Civil Engineering Materials) School of Civil Engineering University of Leeds Leeds LS2 9JT UK Email
[email protected]
Dr Miggy M. Singh and Dr John Summerscales* Advanced Composites Manufacturing Centre School of Marine Science and Engineering University of Plymouth Plymouth Devon PL4 8AA UK Email:
[email protected] [email protected] Ken Wittamore Triskel Consultants Limited 12 St Fimbarrus Road Fowey Cornwall PL23 1JJ UK Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 20
Andrew Dunster, Ph.D., B.Sc., C.Chem., MRSC Principal Consultant (Materials) BRE Bucknalls Lane Watford Hertfordshire WD25 9XX UK Email
[email protected]
Preface
Research and development into materials and materials science underpin the modern world we live in. However it is a world in which our increasing knowledge and use of advanced materials have enabled us to see the damage being inflicted on the fabric of those materials that make up our natural environment. Material manufacture accounts for a high level of toxic manufacturing emissions, even before the effects of the consumer are felt in the waste stream. Therefore considerable emphasis has been placed on environmental policy makers, materials manufacturers, designers and consumers to consider the effects of their materials, products and lifestyles. It is therefore timely to consider research and current industrial practices which challenge the negative effects of materials in use. Composite materials have a smaller presence in public perception than other waste material types, considered generically as just plastics, ceramics, paper, metal, etc. This is because the quantities of use are smaller, the life cycles much longer, and their general visibility is lower. They have therefore received less attention from those seeking to meet environmental quotas than more noticeable and more easily dealt with material types. However, it is often these ‘invisible’ mixed materials in the waste stream, the left-over residue materials and the difficult to handle wastes that present the greatest challenge and pose the greater environmental risk than those materials more easily reused, recycled or recovered. The area of composite recycling and recovery continues to provide a substantial challenge to the academic community in developing new methods to alleviate environmental effects. Problems, potential solutions and current state of the art are all emphasised in this book. It should provide a good general coverage across the scope of the composite waste field. The legislative guide, in conjunction with the industrial case studies (each operating under their own different legislative pressures and framework), allows a comparison to be made of current and future trends. xvii
xviii
Preface
Insights into current university research by leaders in the composite field, in areas such as cleaner processes, more durable materials, and state of the art disposal methods, all contribute to provide the academic community with a comprehensive guide in which to continue breaking the boundaries in this important area of research. Vannessa Goodship
1 An introduction to composites recycling
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
N. R E Y N O L D S and M. P H A R AO H, University of Warwick, UK
Abstract: This chapter discusses the broad spectrum of physical attributes and mechanical properties of the entire family of polymer composites, which make some an inherently viable recycling proposition whilst leaving others consigned to landfill. All common material types are covered, from the high value speciality polymer matrices such as polyetheretherketone (PEEK) and carbon reinforcements, through to commodity materials such as polypropylene (PP) and glass. The question of what makes a material ‘recyclable’ is considered in terms of ease of recovery, practicalities of the recycling process itself and, importantly, the demand for the resultant recyclate material – effectively, the economics behind recycling these materials. This question inevitably covers some of the existing legislation that drives the economic argument. The effect of parameters such as raw material format, subsequent material processing, resultant reinforcement architecture and in-service usage all have on the economic viability are considered. Key words: polymer composites, recycling.
1.1
Introduction
1.1.1 Why would we want to recycle composites? Composites are generally considered high value, high performance materials that are employed in producing high net worth end products. When considering a typical end-of-life product made using composite materials, if the cost of raw material, the production tooling and the associated manufacturing equipment (including both moulding and finishing processes) are taken into account, it is obvious that such a component represents significant prior investment and embodied energy. Products made using materials of such high intrinsic value can be a wise target for the recycling industry when compared with lower net value materials as the corresponding recyclate material could have a similar high value, depending on the effort required to retrieve and reprocess the material. 3
4
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
1.1.2 Scope
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
The term composite can be used to describe a large number of multi-phase materials, consisting of a wide variety of matrix materials along with a correspondingly large array of different fillers and reinforcements. This book refines that description to only consider polymeric matrixes reinforced with various commonly used fibres. Figure 1.1 shows a scanning electron micrograph of a fractured polypropylene (PP) glass composite test specimen that clearly demonstrates the bi-phase nature of composite materials. In the micrograph, the glass fibres are clearly separately visible (diameter approximately 17 μm) to the PP matrix. This refined description still covers a broad scope of materials with a wide range of material properties, both physical and mechanical. Commonly used examples of polymeric matrix materials include: ‘short’ and ‘long’ fibre reinforced thermoplastic and thermoset compounds (processed using injection or compression moulding); long/continuous fibre reinforced laminates (typically processed using hand lay-up/vacuum bagging or resin transfer moulding (RTM)). The scope also includes newer fibre/resin combinations such as naturally sourced ‘bio-resins’ and natural fibres.
1.1.3 Thermoplastic versus thermosetting The resin chemistry employed in polymer matrix composite materials can be divided into two types, thermoplastic and thermosetting. This distinction has a very large impact on the inherent recyclability of a composite material.
˝50 μm
1.1 Scanning electron microscope image of polypropylene–glass composite fracture surface.
An introduction to composites recycling
5
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
Thermoplastic polymer matrices soften and melt with the application of heat. Any process step throughout a thermoplastic composite’s life cycle, from the initial introduction of reinforcement fibres to the final moulding of a component, takes place with sufficient heating to melt the polymer. Although this ability to melt can limit the application of such composites due to comparatively low maximum in-service temperatures, it does mean that end-of-life thermoplastic composite components can be shredded/ ground and readily re-processed via heating and moulding. The penalty for repeated processing in this manner is only limited degradation in matrix properties and reinforcement fibre damage. However, thermosetting systems undergo a permanent cross-linking reaction when curing that, although resulting in a stiffer (and more brittle) matrix material, cannot be reversed with the application of heat. The application of heat after curing only degrades the cross-linked polymer matrix and will not melt it. This means that practical end-of-life recycling options are limited, and could more properly be defined as ‘reuse’, such as in the case of incineration with energy recovery and also the reuse of thermosetting composite (via regrinding) as a low value filler material.
1.2
Composite material types
The following section covers the more commonly encountered composite materials listed by process method, along with their usual name and acronym. Resin type and fibre type are given, along with the approximate fibre volume fraction most commonly encountered.
1.2.1 Injection moulding Injection moulding is a high pressure (20+ MPa), flow-forming process whereby both the polymer and fibres exhibit bulk flow. Generally used for mass-produced components, the injection moulding process allows for fast cycle times, offering low cost at high volume. Such materials are short fibre reinforced, with predominantly glass fibre, although some carbon fibre materials are used. The fibre length is less than 5 mm once the material is processed, as shear forces in the injection moulding barrel damage the fibres and reduce the overall length. Common thermoplastic resins are polypropylene, polyamides; polyester and vinylester are typically used thermosetting resins. •
Short fibre reinforced thermoplastic injection moulding grades. Fibre volume fraction (v.f.) 20–40%. Despite the shorter fibre lengths (5 mm or less), some grades are referred to as LFT (long fibre technology) due to the preservation of fibre diameter to fibre length ratios of over
6
•
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites 100× when using specific pellets and low shear moulding equipment. Typical applications include automotive (highly integrated front-end carrier). Bulk moulding compound (BMC) or dough moulding compound (DMC). These are thermosetting polyester matrix materials that are loaded with both glass fibres and fillers. Fibre v.f. 12–25%, typical filler fraction by weight (w.f.) 50%. Typical applications include automotive (headlamp reflector), white goods (oven/grill handle) and electrical (insulator).
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
1.2.2 Compression moulding Compression moulding is a high pressure (10+ MPa), flow-forming process whereby the polymer exhibits bulk flow, with limited movement of the fibres as well. The end result is a pseudo-random 3D fibre architecture, with the possibility of resin-rich regions towards component edges and in smaller details (e.g. ribs and bosses). Owing to this risk, these components are generally simpler in geometry when compared with injection moulded parts, although often larger in size and with correspondingly longer cycle times. As the moulding cycle does less damage to fibres, the fibre length can be much greater. Glass is the primary reinforcement to be used, and fewer resins are commonly used than with injection moulding, with the predominant choices being polypropylene (thermoplastic) and polyester/ vinylester (thermoset). •
Sheet moulding compound (SMC). This is a very similar material to BMC type materials utilising highly filled polyester matrices, but with longer fibres (needled, continuous fibre mat). Uncured sheets of prewetted composite material are transferred to a heated matched press tool. Fibre v.f. 15–60%, filler w.f. up to 40%. Large volumes used in automotive (car/truck bonnets, exterior panels, bumper beams, underbonnet components), and other applications include domestic (shower tray, sinks), marine (jet skis, boat parts), electrical (housings, insulator blocks) and transport (rail carriage interior panels). • Glass mat thermoplastic (GMT). This process utilises glass fibres in needled-mat sheets (chopped and continuous) within a thermoplastic matrix (usually PP). The fully consolidated sheets are pre-heated in process ovens, and then transferred (often manually) to a matched press tool. Fibre v.f. 20–40%. Applications include automotive (bumper beams, tailgates), construction and furniture manufacture. • Long fibre technology (LFT). LFT is a successful and more recently used modification of GMT technology. In LFT compression moulding, glass rovings are compounded with PP in an extruder and either imme-
An introduction to composites recycling
7
diately transferred to a compression moulding press as a bulk material (direct extrusion/compression) or granulated and supplied as a pelletised material for subsequent extrusion/compression moulding. Reinforcement v.f. 20–40%. This is typically used for complex parts with high levels of integration such as automotive front end carrier modules and as a replacement for GMT material.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
1.2.3 Laminate processing These materials with very long (effectively continuous) aligned fibre reinforcements provide the highest available mechanical properties, but at a cost of longer cycle times. Both carbon and glass fibres are regularly used, with the most common resin systems used being thermosetting polyesters and epoxies. All of the production routes used for laminate processing have the common feature of maintaining initial reinforcement fibre placement whilst the resin system is either introduced or consolidated throughout manufacture. This means that the reinforcement fibres, which are typically continuous, can be placed exactly in line with the expected in-service loading, tailoring the material directly to the application. However, it must be remembered that loads acting away from the axes of reinforcement fibres are not supported, and failure can occur. Laminate fibre architecture varies from unidirectional (UD), where all of the fibres are aligned in a single direction, to multiply (layered) arrangements such as cross-ply (plies oriented at 0° and 90°) and on to quasiisotropic (a ply stacking sequence of 0°, 45°, 90°, −45°). •
•
Hand lay-up. The simplicity of this technique allows the manufacture of very large structures utilising continuous fibres, usually glass but sometimes carbon. Achievable glass volume fraction is low compared with both RTM and pre-preg processes, with higher porosity and lower quality surface finish. Vacuum-bagging is a common variant of this process whereby the pre-wetted, hand-laid material is enclosed in an evacuated airtight bag during resin cure to aid consolidation and improve part quality. Maximum fibre v.f. 40%. Owing to the low investment costs arising from requiring no capital expenditure on press moulding equipment, and simple single-sided tooling made from cheap materials (e.g. wood, foam), this approach is often used for very large structures such as boat hulls (with or without vacuum bag) and also prototyping/short production runs. RTM. A pressure-assisted resin infusion route that is capable of producing higher quality components than hand lay-up, with higher volume fractions of fibre. A fibre preform is placed in a sealed, matched
8
•
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
•
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites (often steel) mould and the resin is introduced under pressure. The higher part quality and hence part performance combined with the applied resin pressure means that carbon fibre (or other high performance reinforcement) is more regularly used. Maximum fibre v.f. 60%. This is used in niche market automotive for body panels and structural members (e.g. Lotus Elise body and structural front-end, Aston Martin Vanquish A-pillar), light aircraft manufacture and transport (train seats). Vacuum assisted RTM (VARTM). A manufacturing route typically used for smaller volumes or very large parts (e.g. wind turbine blades and boat hulls) that combines the simplicity of hand lay-up techniques with the achievable part quality towards that of RTM. Fibre preforms are laid dry into a single-sided tool with an upper vacuum bag, or a sealed matched tool, and resin is then introduced under vacuum. Maximum fibre v.f. 55–60%. Pre-preg material vacuum bagging or autoclave. Pre-preg (pre-impregnated) material consists of a reinforcement textile (typically woven) fully wetted with a partially (B-stage) cured thermoset resin. When used with the vacuum bag (1 bar, 100 kPa) or autoclave (5+ bar, 0.5 MPa), this technique is capable of producing components of very high fibre volume fraction, so often uses ‘high performance’ fibres such as carbon. Owing to the need for higher temperature and pressures within the processing route, large component size can be difficult to achieve. Maximum fibre v.f. 55–60%. Used for high end applications where specific properties (weight) is an issue such as motorsport and aerospace.
1.2.4 Natural fibre and natural resin materials (biocomposites) Although natural fibre is one of the oldest types of reinforcement used, it is a relatively novel component in terms of use in modern materials. Hemp, kenaf and jute are typical examples and are often added as reinforcements to injection moulding grade thermoplastics (such as PP) as used in non-structural automotive applications such as door inner modules and undershields. Natural resins (biopolymers) represent a new and rapidly developing area of composites research and application, production volumes are very small and these materials are typically employed in non-reinforced applications such as biodegradable packaging (Carus & Gahle, 2008).
1.3
Physical properties
The mechanical properties of composite materials can vary widely depending on the matrix-reinforcement fibre combination, reinforcement architec-
An introduction to composites recycling
9
ture, fillers and chosen manufacturing process. Consequently a table of outline material properties must have a large variation in quoted values. Such a table is still of use as it allows initial comparison of material properties as well as providing a benchmark against which to measure the success of the recycling process in achieving acceptable material properties.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
1.3.1 Polymer resin matrices As covered in the introduction, the main distinguishing feature of a polymer matrix material relates to the cure chemistry, i.e. thermoplastic and thermosetting. Typical values of selected mechanical properties for some (unreinforced) resins that are commonly used within composite production are given in Table 1.1. The selection is divided into thermoplastic and thermosetting resin types. The modulus and strength data from Table 1.1 are plotted together for each resin in Fig. 1.2. It is obvious from this graph that there is a much wider variation of properties available for the thermoplastics, and particularly that only the very high performance thermoplastic resins such as PEI (polyether imide) and PEEK (polyetheretherketone) compete with the thermosetting polyester and epoxy matrix materials.
1.3.2 Reinforcements Typical properties of individual fibre filaments are given in Table 1.2. It is important to note that these properties are somewhat idealised, and the
Table 1.1 Typical properties of selected commonly used polymer matrices
Material
Tensile modulus (GPa)
Tensile strength (MPa)
Specific gravity
Thermoplastic PP ABS PEI Nylon PET PEEK
1.1 2.3 2.9 2.8 3 3.9
30 45 85 60 70 90
0.90 1.04 1.27 1.13 1.35 1.28
Thermosetting Vinylester Polyester Epoxy
2.9 3.6 3.7
55 68 75
1.15 1.2 1.16
10
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites 100
Tensile strength (MPa)
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20
Thermoplastic resins
10 0
Thermosetting resins 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
Tensile modulus (GPa)
1.2 Tensile strength versus modulus for selected polymer matrices.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
Table 1.2 Typical reinforcement fibre filament properties
Fibre type
Modulus (GPa)
Strength (GPa)
Strain to failure (%)
Specific gravity
Diameter (μm)
E-glass S-glass HM carbon HS carbon Aramid
70 85 500 290 110
2.4 4 4 5.5 3
4.5 5.5 1 2 2.4
2.5 2.5 1.8 1.8 1.5
15 9 4.5 7 12
properties of fibres within a given bundle or tow will vary considerably, giving a more distributed mechanical response when used in bulk within a composite material. A comparison of the commonly used E-glass against the premium high modulus (HM) carbon fibre shows almost an order of magnitude of variation in modulus in favour of the carbon, but at the expense of a correspondingly low strain to failure, which results in a brittle failure mode within a composite material. Figure 1.3 plots filament strength against the strain to failure; the approximate fibre modulii can be observed as the gradients of the individual slopes.
1.3.3 Composite properties Table 1.3 presents average mechanical properties for some of the more commonly encountered composite material types, indicating the chosen fibre type and fibre volume fraction (v.f.). The mechanical performance of
An introduction to composites recycling
11
Filament strength (GPa)
6 5 4 3 2
E-glass S-glass HM carbon HS carbon Aramid
1 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Elongation to failure (%)
1.3 Reinforcement fibre filament strength versus elongation to failure.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
Table 1.3 Mechanical properties of production composites
Processing
Material
Fibre
v.f. (%)
Modulus (GPa)
Strength (MPa)
Specific gravity
Flow (injection)
BMC PP-LFT
Glass Glass
20 30
13 6.5
31 100
1.8 1.12
Flow (compression)
SMC PP-GMT
Glass Glass
30 40
11 5.3
80 100
1.9 1.2
Hand lay
Polyester PP
Glass Glass
40 35
20 15
320 310
1.25 1.2
RTM
Polyester
Glass
55
22
360
1.9
VARTM VARTM (UD)
Epoxy Epoxy
Glass Carbon
55 55
24 130
550 1200
1.9 1.6
Prepreg
Epoxy
Carbon
50
60
890
1.5
the selected composites varies from being only slightly above that expected of unfilled polymer for the low (∼20%) volume fraction, randomly oriented, short fibre reinforced flow forming materials, towards metal-like properties for high v.f. continuous aligned fibre reinforced laminates.
1.3.4 Fillers It is not always possible to make a distinction between fillers and other reinforcements – indeed in some cases fillers are used to directly alter (improve) the performance of the chosen polymer. In other cases, the filler is added as an economic consideration to reduce the volume of polymer needed in a given material system.
12
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Common filler materials are calcium carbonate, talcum powder and mica (Murphy, 2001). Inorganic particulate fillers can have a dramatic effect on the recyclability of composite materials, as they have low value, are hard to separate from the polymer and moreover will not burn. Heavily filled materials such as SMC/BMC (over 40% v.f. filler) are therefore not attractive for some of the recycling/reuse scenarios discussed here.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
1.4
Current composite market
The most recent figures for glass reinforced plastic (GRP) production in Europe show an overall production volume of ∼1 200 000 t in 2007 (Witten, 2008). This represents a yearly growth of over 5% since 2005 (1 060 000 t). Europe produces 31% of the worldwide supply of GRP, and GRP comprises 90% of the world composites market (Bunsell and Renard, 2005). We could therefore estimate that the worldwide production of GRP in 2007 would be approximately 3 600 000 t, and that the global production volume for all polymer matrix composites is nearer to 4 000 000 t. Figure 1.4 shows European GRP production by processing method. It can be seen from this breakdown that the primary thermosetting composite production methods account for more than 70% of total GRP output: compression/injection moulding (SMC/BMC), 26%; open mould methods (hand-lay, spray-up), 30%, RTM and continuous processing methods, ∼20%.
GMT/LFT, 8%
Others, 2% SMC, 19%
Centrifugal casting, 6% Filament winding, 7%
BMC, 7% Pultrusion, 4%
Sheets, 7% Hand lay-up, 20%
RTM, 10% Spray-up, 10%
1.4 European GRP production by process route, 2005–2007 (Witten, 2008).
An introduction to composites recycling
13
Recent figures for the total annual biomaterials usage in Europe amount to approximately 350 000 t, with ∼200 000 t of this total representing natural fibre (NF) reinforced composites (Carus and Gahle, 2008). Over two-thirds of this NF composite usage is composed of wood reinforced plastic compression- and extrusion/injection moulding for the automotive, construction and furniture industries.
1.5
What is ‘suitability for recycling’?
There are many factors which can affect suitability for recycling, but the driving arguments must be ‘is there a market for the recyclate?’ and ‘is the market economically viable?’ Without these drivers in place a recycling plan is almost certain to fail and a material must be considered unsuitable for recycling. Many technical factors affecting the recyclate such as collection, separation and reprocessing, can be overcome, but lack of market demand will stop any further development.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
1.5.1 Economics The basic economic model must consider a number of factors. Many of these factors are closely interlinked, as shown in Fig. 1.5 and described
Financial
Investment Profit Prohibition Subsidy Penalty
Legislation
Local Governmental
Level
Federal (EU) Logistical Economic suitability
Transport infrastructure Buildings and plant
Technical
Recoverability Separation method Virgin material Supply
Confidence Demand
Recyclate
Post-industrial Post-consumer
Virgin material Recyclate
1.5 Schematic showing economic drivers for recycling suitability.
14
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
here. When embarking upon a recycling plan all of the factors need to be considered and some given action whilst others may be ignored. These factors are: technical, logistic, financial, confidence, supply and demand, and legislative.
1.5.2 Technical suitability In many cases it is often down to the simple practicality of the process that can drive the suitability for recycling. This practicality is affected by: waste stream type, recoverability, contamination and reliability of feedstock.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
Waste type There are broadly two types of waste material to be dealt with – post-industrial waste and materials arising from end-of-life components (post-consumer waste). Post-industrial waste can be an attractive area for recycling schemes, as the waste stream has a clear history and contamination can be controlled and minimised, and the waste material is otherwise unaged and pristine. Typically post-industrial recycling can be done in-line with an existing ongoing production process – an example would be the introduction of thermoplastic LFT moulded component waste off-cuts back into a continuous direct extrusion/compression process for re-extrusion. End-of-life waste is obviously difficult to assure and control in terms of age, usage history and contamination. This is one of the biggest problems facing a recycling scheme.
Recoverability This can cover a number of aspects, from the basic recoverability of the composite material within a given component, to resin recovery and fibre recovery. There is a conflict between the economic considerations between producing a component and dealing with the same part once it has reached end-of-life. The drive to cut costs encourages designers to increasingly employ an approach of parts integration whereby a component becomes a multi-material system often assembled in a single step. If this parts integration path is followed without consideration towards design for disassembly, it can result in multi-material components that are very difficult to process at end-of-life. Composite components can be produced with items such as metallic fixing inserts, aesthetic coverings such as paint films, carpet or leather all included in-mould; these present a significant challenge to a prospective dismantler. With one-way assembly methods such as adhesive
An introduction to composites recycling
15
bonding or painting, if the non-composite parts cannot be removed, the resultant recyclate will then be contaminated. Constituent material recoverability can affect the recycling viability of composite materials in different ways. The material architecture as well as material formulation can affect this. Resin recovery from heavily glass filled materials such as SMC is very difficult. Fibre recovery can be much simpler, particularly for glass and carbon fibres, but here the limit can be recyclate market demand. Contamination Although this is a major issue for general plastic recycling, for composite materials this is less so, owing to the fewer material options and grades available, making any sorting easier. Also in the case of end-of-life large scale constructions, such as wind turbine rotor, a large volume is available at a single time (this is also a consideration for feedstock, below).
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
Reliable feedstock Although volumes of composites used are increasing, owing to a wide variety of factors, overall they are still relatively niche compared with mainstream materials. This is exacerbated by the long lifetime of these materials in operation. This could create an unreliable feedstock for longterm planning, but this should change in the future as composites used in long term structures come to their end of life.
1.5.3 Financial suitability: legislative, investment and material costs •
Legislative financial instruments: subsidies/penalties. Governments are able to stimulate markets by legislative means (e.g. Council Directive 1999/31/EC). They can legislate to influence the final recyclate cost and likely demand in two ways: subsidies and penalties (commonly phrased ‘carrot versus stick’). Subsidies are regularly used to stimulate demand, but will often be short-lived, and their subsequent removal can easily destroy demand that has come to rely on the effect of subsidies too much. These subsidies can take two forms, either assistance with plant investment or payments upon recyclate produced. Penalties take the form of financial disincentives such as increased landfill taxes that actively encourage reuse and recycling thus ultimately making disposal economically unviable. Within the economic argument, legislation can have a large effect, as it is used to drive the existence of a market until
16
•
•
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites the infrastructure is in place to create usable volumes at a competitive market price. Additionally, penalties are likely to be much longer lived – indeed indefinite – and so have a more permanent effect on the market than the more transient subsidies. Capital investment. Recycling plant, building and infrastructure all require a large amount of initial investment and securing this can prove very difficult. This can take the form of assistance from local or national government or direct investment from industry. Material costs. Often driving the value of the resultant recyclate is the initial value of the material. Materials with a high initial raw material value such as carbon fibre will often have a strong economic driver for recycling as long as there is potential for a high value recyclate product, even if re-processing costs are high.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
1.5.4 Confidence End user confidence plays a vital part in a recycling programme, particularly with respect to the supply side. This can be seen in the need to guarantee volume of supply to large users, who cannot afford to stop production, and a lack of confidence in ability to supply sufficient reprocessed material can provide problems, particularly for small recyclers.
1.5.5 Supply and demand Demand and confidence are closely interlinked, as one will tend to create the other. It is still important that a need is developed as this demand will create a market and obviously dictates the prices. The market demand for resultant recyclate is of huge importance. Unlike the initial cost, it is often the lower value materials with a high usage volume where the greatest demand exists. Typically here glass reinforced PP has a relatively low initial value but the volumes used make it easy to feed recycled material into the virgin feedstock with no problems.
1.5.6 Legislation Governmental legislation can be employed, not just to provide financial incentives/penalties, but to prohibit current practices (e.g. disposal) thus making reuse and recycling the only option (Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment, Council Directive 2002/96/EC; End-of-Life Vehicles, Council Directive 2000/53/EC). This direct action approach can create supply without necessarily stimulating demand and presents a significant challenge to the recycling industry.
An introduction to composites recycling
1.6
17
Recycling methods
As previously demonstrated, composite materials can offer greatly enhanced performance over commodity materials. They are of relatively high value and their usage pattern as engineering materials is generally in long-lived applications. This longer life cycle means that potential end-of-life scenarios must be judged differently from those commodity materials that are used in higher volume/lower cost applications.
1.6.1 Landfill disposal
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
Once a material is destined for landfill it is considered to be of no value; indeed costs will be then incurred at point of disposal; furthermore this option is growing politically less favourable. Although disposal is a simple process, the inherent environmental durability of composite materials means that they undergo only slow degradation in landfill conditions. On the positive side, the low volumes of composite materials currently used when compared with other material markets means that they make up only very small volumes of landfill waste.
1.6.2 Incineration When combined with energy recovery, incineration can be viewed as a recycling technique as the material has effectively been reused. The potential effectiveness of this as a technique is very dependent on the composition of the composite. High glass filled materials with large inorganic filler content, such as SMC, contain very little inflammable material and will burn poorly and will be therefore of little value. Other materials, such as those with a flammable thermoplastic matrix will burn readily and have a large calorific value.
1.6.3 Chemical techniques These techniques can involve either chemical de-polymerisation of the matrix into oils which also frees the fibres for further recycling, or chemical removal of the matrix which also free up high value fibres, such as carbon. These techniques are still in the developmental stage and hardly employed. They could potentially be of value, but the currently low recycling volumes of composite materials means that to be cost effective, the technique will have to be flexible enough to chemically re-process other materials.
18
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
1.6.4 Thermomechanical processes These processes are the most widely used to re-process both composites and other materials. The techniques are generally confined to thermoplastic resins, as fully cross-linked thermosetting resins are virtually impossible to re-process. Plants performing thermomechanical reprocessing of thermoplastic composites are also able to re-process other thermoplastic (unreinforced) materials, which increases throughput volumes and therefore significantly improves the economic viability of the business.
1.6.5 Mechanical processes
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
Mechanical processing is a low-value option that can be employed in the case of materials where no recycling/reuse approaches exist other than disposal. Materials such as highly filled thermosetting composites can be ground and used as filler in virgin materials. One study found that up to 25% SMC regrind could be introduced into new SMC/BMC formulations without any performance penalty (Murphy, 1998).
1.6.6 Biomaterials Composites made with natural fibres offer similar recycling routes to their inorganically reinforced counterparts. Thermoplastic natural fibre composites can be thermomechanically reprocessed in the same way as other thermoplastic composites. Both thermoplastic and thermosetting natural fibre composites are attractive for incineration with energy recovery due to their lack of inorganic content – they are combustible in their entirety. Using certain biopolymers in conjunction with natural fibres can result in a completely biodegradable composite material system. These biomaterials would be suitable for end-of-life composting, given the correct environmental conditions. This composting can be carried out aerobically as a simple disposal solution or anaerobically in a bio-gasification process – which amounts to a ‘reuse’ scenario, producing useful combustible gases (European Bioplastics Organisation, 2008).
1.7
Conclusions
It is clear that composites offer the design engineer an attractive range of material solutions with a correspondingly wide range of production routes. Material properties can be accurately tailored to design specifications, resulting in parts that are correctly engineered and fit for purpose with minimum material usage (via avoiding the all-too-common approach of
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:49 PM
An introduction to composites recycling
19
over-engineering). By careful selection of material type and corresponding production route, solutions can be formulated that satisfy an extremely broad range of applications and production volumes, from one-off 30 metre long boat hulls to 20 g injection mouldings produced at rates of over 100 000 parts per annum. This design freedom and flexibility has led to an ever-increasing market for composite materials, which now makes the issue of how to deal with end-of-life composites an important consideration. There are a number of recycling routes available now, with many more variants currently under research. As the waste composite material market expands due to increasing production and the advent of legislation prohibiting disposal, economies of scale will come into play that will make hitherto unprofitable recycling schemes viable. However, many recycling schemes are focused on dealing with thermoplastic composite waste. One major hurdle that remains is the lack of ‘true’ recycling routes for waste thermosetting composite materials. Efforts have instead examined ‘reusing’ thermosetting composites due to the difficulties associated with recycling, using routes such as incineration with energy recovery, and shredding and grinding to make low-value filler to be used in the production of other materials. The current optimum solution for thermoset recycling is reinforcement fibre recovery used in conjunction with these thermal and mechanical ‘reuse’ methods.
1.8
References
bunsell a r and renard j (2005), Fundamentals of Fibre Reinforced Composite Materials, CRC Press carus m and gahle c (2008), ‘Natural fibre reinforced plastics – material with future’, Presentation at International Congress – Raw Material Shift & Biomaterials, nova-Institut GmbH, Huerth, available from http://www.eucia.org/ publications/publications council directive 1999/31/EC of 26 April 1999 on the Landfill of Waste council directive 2000/53/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 September 2000 on End-of-Life Vehicles council directive 2002/96/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 January 2003 on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) european bioplastics organisation (2008), ‘FAQ paper on bioplastics’, http:// www.european-bioplastics.org murphy j (1998), The Reinforced Plastics Handbook, Elsevier murphy j (2001), Additives for Plastics Handbook, Edition 2, Elsevier witten e (2008), ‘The composites market in Europe: market developments, challenges, and opportunities’, AVK (Industrievereinigung Verstärkte Kunststoffe), Online report (http://www.eucia.org/publications/news)
2 Legislation for recycling waste composites R. S T E WA RT, c/o University of Warwick, UK
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
Abstract: This chapter first looks at how legislation is passed in the European Union and the relationship between EU and domestic UK laws and policies. EU environmental policy and legislation have been developed and shaped by six environment action programmes for over 30 years. The first batch of environmental legislation put in place the framework for dealing with specific problems such as waste oil. This was built upon by legislation that developed standards for landfills and incinerators for example whilst the third batch of legislations introduced recycling directives which put in place the necessary organisation and finances to assist the recycling of key waste flows such as end-of-life vehicles. Some lack of clarity in the wording of the directives meant that implementation among member states was variable and the current legislation seeks to harmonise and streamline environmental law making it simpler and more enforceable. The chapter then goes on to discuss some of the key pieces of legislation that are likely to be of most relevance to composite materials. A number of key changes have been proposed in some areas, for example, the reduction of carbon dioxide emissions from passenger vehicles and potential areas for further legislation are highlighted. Key words: recycling legislation, environmental legislation, climate change, landfill, EU directives, UK regulations, environmental action programmes, waste management.
2.1
Legislation
Virtually all of the legislation covering the control and management of waste, not just of composite materials, is enshrined in European Union (EU) law and policy which has become transposed into domestic law. It is therefore worth beginning this chapter with a recap of the history and structure of the EU and its relationships with the UK governance with regards to environmental issues. The workings of the EU are complex and this chapter only intends to give a broad-brush outline of how laws and policies are made and how these become transposed into UK laws. The chapter will then go on to discuss the main EU regulations which apply to composite materials and then discuss what is likely to apply to such materials in the future. 20
Legislation for recycling waste composites
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
2.2
21
Brief history of the European Union
The European Union was established in 1993 and was borne out of the 1957 European Economic Community (EEC) which the UK joined in 1973. At the heart of both the EEC and the EU are the founding treaties, beginning with the Treaty of Rome which the UK signed up to in 1973 when it joined the EEC and the Treaty of the European Union (often known as the Maastricht Treaty) which established the EU. Each member state has to ratify the treaty. There have been a number of amending treaties but the founding treaties set out the basis for law in Europe, and this will be discussed further later in the chapter. The Treaty of the European Union divided responsibilities into three ‘pillars’ or areas of policy. Pillar one deals with matters which affect the EC and legislative matters which effectively bind all EU citizens, and pillars two and three are based on intergovernmental cooperation with respect to foreign and security policy and on police, criminal and judicial policies respectively. After significant expansion of the EU, most recently by Bulgaria and Romania in 2007, there are now 27 member states. In response to the enlargement, the EU treaties have most recently been amended by the EU Reform Treaty signed in Lisbon in 2007. The Lisbon treaty provides for a number of reforms but one of those will be to effectively dispense with the pillar system (http://europa.eu/abc/history/index_en.htm). The administration of the European Union is rather complex but the important bodies for the purposes of this section are shown in Fig. 2.1. •
The European Parliament is the only body in the EU which has elected members and together with the Council of the European Union (often just referred to as the Council) they are the main legislators of the EU Council of the European Union
Council of Ministers
Commission
2.1 Main bodies within the EU.
EU Parliament
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
22
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
and are responsible for passing legislation. There are two levels of the council, the Council of the European Union is a fixed composition and is made up of heads of state or government and the president of the EU commission. The composition of the Council of Ministers, however, will vary depending on the issue being discussed. The Council holds the executive power in the EU which it confers to the European Commission. The strength of the Union was increased by the ratification of the Amsterdam Treaty in 1999, which had the effect of increasing the legislative power of the European Parliament and also for overseeing the work of the European Commission. • The European Commission (the Commission) is the executive of the EU and is responsible for the day-to-day running of the EU. It has two main areas of responsibility. Firstly, the Commission drafts legislation and proposes it to the Council or the Parliament who can amend it or pass it as legislation. Secondly, it ensures that the regulations and directives passed by the Council and Parliament are being implemented by the member states and if not, the Commission has the ability to take the non-compliant party to the European Court of Justice for enforcement. Each member state of the Union is represented by a commissioner but their role is not to represent the member state from which they originate but the Union’s interests. The Commission has a great degree of independence in carrying out its functions. As the EU’s executive, the Commission has broad powers to manage the EU’s common policies, such as research and technology, overseas aid, regional development and so on. It also manages the budget for these policies. The Commission is assisted by a civil service made up of 46 directorate generals. • The European Court of Justice (ECJ) is the highest court in the EU and has final say over all other courts on matters to do with EU law. It is completely independent of the bodies shown in Fig. 2.1. In terms of environmental policy and law, it is clear from the explanation of the Commission’s (and its relationship with the Directorate Generals) roles and responsibilities that it is through this arm of the EU that the current and future law and policy for the UK will flow.
2.2.1 The relationship between European Union and United Kingdom law The primary source of European laws are the founding and amending treaties already discussed. However, in and of itself, a ratified treaty does not have a legal standing in UK law and for it to have any legal force it has to be passed by an act of government. This was effectively achieved by the UK’s passing of the European Communities Act (1972), as amended. The
Legislation for recycling waste composites
23
act also instructs courts that priority is given to EC law over UK law which means that UK legislators have to modify domestic laws to align with EC laws even if there is a conflict between the two. The secondary sources of EU law transposed from the treaties consist of regulations and directives which are characterised as follows: •
•
Regulations – these are binding and are directly incorporated into member state law without that member state having to use national legislation to incorporate them into law. If there is a conflict between a regulation and an existing national law, the regulation takes precedence. Directives – a directive sets out the requirements that the legislation should achieve. Whilst there is an obligation on the member state to change its national laws, a directive then leaves it to the member states to implement as it sees fit to meet the requirements. The directive will provide for a set period of time within which implementation has to be achieved via national legislative processes.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
2.2.2 The European Union and the environment The origins of environmental law and policy in Europe lie in the European Community dating back to 1972. The European Community founding treaty, the Treaty of Rome, does not contain any reference to environmental legislation and a number of further amendments, including the Maastricht Treaty (1992) and the Amsterdam Treaty (1999), have been necessary to bring forth the legislation: more than 80% of the UK’s environmental legislation today is drawn from the EU. However, it was in 1972 that the European Community determined that a community environmental policy was needed. The framework which developed and shaped environmental legislation was provided by the Environment Action Programmes (EAPs), of which there are six to date (EAP1 1973, EAP2 1977, EAP3 1983, EAP4 1987, EAP5 1993, EAP6 2002). Each programme is specific to a particular environmental issue and spans a 5–10 year time frame. The EAPs are the main driving force behind today’s and tomorrow’s future environmental policy in the EU and the UK as well as the global agenda. Whilst the environment action programmes are not legally binding, they do clearly set out the aspirations of the community.
2.2.3 Past and present Environment Action Programmes In 1972 the European Community adopted its first EAP covering the period 1972 to 1976 (EAP1 1973). The first EAP set out the principles and priorities that would guide the community’s policies for the future. This was followed by a second five year programme from 1978 to 1982.
24
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
The first and second EAPs set out in some detail a series of actions that should be taken to control a range of pollution problems (EAP1 1973, EAP2 1977). There were 11 principles listed in the first programme in total and it is worth listing them in full, as many of these have been carried forward to subsequent programmes: 1. Pollution is better prevented at source. 2. In decision making processes, environmental effects should be taken into account as soon as possible. 3. Exploitation of natural resources to be avoided if they cause significant harm to the ecological balance. 4. Scientific knowledge should be advanced to help in the protection of the environment. 5. The polluter pays principle. 6. A country’s activities should not degrade the environments of others. 7. The environmental policy of member states must take into account the interests of developing countries. 8. The community should participate in international organisations to promote global environmental policy. 9. Environmental education should be promoted throughout the community. 10. Pollution control should be established at all levels (local, regional, national, community, international). 11. National environmental policy to be harmonised within the community. The third and fourth EAPs running from 1983 to 1993 tried to provide an overall strategy for protecting the environment and natural resources (EAP3 1983, EAP4 1987). The emphasis shifted from pollution control to pollution prevention and the concept of environmental protection was broadened to include land use policy, identifying agriculture as an area in need of more environmental awareness and the integration of environmental concerns into other EU policies. Each programme was a building block on the previous one but much of the focus of the first three programmes was devoted to developing the policies and little attention seems to have been actually given to whether or not the policies were effective or indeed being implemented at all (Hawke 2002). It was not until the fourth EAP that meaningful consideration was given to implementation. The fifth EAP from 1993 to 2000 (EAP5 1993) began to set longer-term objectives and the concept of sustainable development was introduced as well as managing waste not just on a community level but on a global level. The prevailing sustainable objectives from the programme were:
Legislation for recycling waste composites • • • •
25
to maintain the overall quality of life; to maintain continuing access to natural resources; to avoid lasting environmental damage; to consider as sustainable a development which meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.
As with earlier programmes, the fifth programme identified sectors where further work on environmental progress was necessary. These were industry, the energy sector, agriculture, tourism and, for the first time, transport. The EAP identified seven themes of work and began to identify targets that should be achieved in each theme. The guiding principles that came out of the fifth EAP were:
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
• environmental protection targets can only be achieved by involving those policy areas causing environmental deterioration; • replace the command-and-control approach with shared responsibility between the various parties (governments, industry and the public), to obtain commitment to agreed measures. The fifth programme identified that pure reliance on environmental legislation was not a means to an end and a number of policy regulations would be more appropriate: • • • •
Legislation to set environmental standards. Economic instruments to encourage the production and use of environmentally friendly products and processes. Horizontal support measures (information, education, research). Financial support measures (funds).
In effect what this EAP did was to replace the original top-down approach seen in the previous EAPs with a bottom-up one and recognition that in order to increase the level of implementation it would be necessary to get stakeholders to cooperate with one another. Naturally, the outcomes and recommendations of the fifth EAP fed into the sixth (current) generation of action programmes which runs from 2002 until 2012 (EAP6 2002). The sixth EAP entitled ‘Environment 2010: Our Future, Our Choice’ was adopted by the European Parliament and the council of the European Union in 2002. The treaty of Amsterdam (1997) signed previously fed into the sixth EAP with its requirement to give consideration to sustainability. Article 6 of the treaty states that ‘environmental protection requirements must be integrated into the definition and implementation of the Community policies . . . in particular with a view to promoting sustainable development’. There is consequently a greater impetus towards achieving sustainability and an emphasis on extending the
26
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
bottom-up approach and less of a focus on relying on legislation to tackle the environmental issues targeted. The sixth programme proposes a focus on four priority areas: 1. Climate change – cuts to global emissions of 20–40% by 2020. 2. Biodiversity – reduce threats to habitats and the survival of number of species. 3. Environment and health – water, noise and air strategies. 4. Sustainable management of resources and wastes – improve recycling rates and waste prevention strategies.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
The sixth EAP has seven themes running through it, namely: air pollution, the marine environment, sustainable use of resources, prevention and recycling of waste, sustainable use of pesticides, soil protection and urban environment. In previous EAPs there has been a focus on specific types of pollutants such as sulphur dioxide or specific types of activities such as transport or tourism. In this case the strategies are global in nature and arranged into themes instead.
2.3
Environment Action Programme 6 and the shape of future legislation
The EAPs have been setting the EU’s agenda for environmental protection for over 30 years and much legislation has subsequently been created. Regulation is just one of a number of methods that have been employed in trying to implement environmental policies and is generally a means of last resort when voluntary agreements, taxes and subsidies fail to have the desired effect. Whilst regulation is an important tool in bringing about environmental change it also has its limitations as it can be a lengthy process to implement and amend with low enforcement rates. For example, the End-of-Life Vehicle (ELV) Directive (Directive 2000/53/EC) was first conceived in the 1960s with the recovery of valuable metals and the re-sale of component parts. During the mid-1990s, when the fifth EAP was in place, the EU and national leaders put pressure on the automotive industry to sign up to voluntary agreements which would see increases in the rates of recycling and recovery. Such voluntary agreements would also force the automotive industry to accept responsibility for the treatment of ELVs. By this time, priorities had changed towards waste prevention and this led to discussions on an ELV Directive in 1996 but this was not adopted until the year 2000. Ambitious targets in the Directive meant that member states failed to meet the target date for transposition into domestic laws and it was not
Legislation for recycling waste composites
27
until 2003 that the regulations were implemented in the UK, but not in full (ELV Regulations 2003). The remaining provisions of the directive were transposed into UK law in 2005 by the End-of-Life Vehicle (Producer Responsibility) Regulations. More detail on the ELV Directive is given later in the chapter. In light of such slow progress in some areas, the sixth EAP seeks to toughen the EU’s approach on how it regulates and enforces environmental regulation but puts a great deal of effort into pursuing other non-legislative means of achieving the programmes objectives. Article 3 for example, sets out some strategic objectives which are both stick and carrot approaches to address the issues.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
2.3.1 Legislative approaches • Develop and amend existing legislation. • Develop new legislation. • Encourage more effective implementation and enforcement, for example by better inspection procedures. • A systematic review of how legislation is being applied across member states and better exchanges between member states on best practice for implementation.
2.3.2 Non-legislative approaches • •
•
•
More integration of environmental protection requirements into the EU policies. Promotion of sustainable production and consumption by, for example, reforming subsidies, promoting of emission trading, reviewing environmentally related taxes and incentives. Improve the environmental performance of enterprises with a view to achieving sustainable production patterns. It is suggested that this may be assisted by an integrated product policy approach which takes into account product life cycle, encouragement for companies to publish independently verified environmental or sustainable development reports and a greater take up of voluntary agreements to achieve environmental objectives. Integrated product policy (IPP) and sustainable development (SD) will be discussed in more detail later in the chapter. Put more effort into informing consumers and purchasers (individuals, enterprises and public bodies) about the environmental impact of the processes and products they come into contact with. Examples of this may be through encouraging the use of eco-labels and the promotion of green public policy.
28
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
• Integration of environmental policy in the financial sector, including for instance agreements on including data on environmental costs in company annual financial reports and using environmental consideration in making lending decisions.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
Article 8 of EAP 6 echoes Article 3’s strategic approach and deals specifically with the priority areas for sustainability and waste management which states the following objectives: – achieving a significant overall reduction in the volumes of waste generated through waste prevention initiatives, better resource efficiency and a shift towards more sustainable production and consumption patterns; – a significant reduction in the quantity of waste going to disposal and the volumes of hazardous waste produced while avoiding an increase of emissions to air, water and soil; – encouraging reuse and for wastes that are still generated: the level of their hazardousness should be reduced and they should present as little risk as possible; preference should be given to recovery and especially to recycling; the quantity of waste for disposal should be minimised and should be safely disposed of; waste intended for disposal should be treated as closely as possible to the place of its generation, to the extent that this does not lead to a decrease in the efficiency in waste treatment operations.
The objectives are to be achieved by; • Development and implementation of a broad range of instruments including research, technology transfer, market-based and economic instruments, programmes of best practice and indicators of resource efficiency; • Developing and implementing measures on waste prevention and management by, inter alia: (a) Measures aimed at ensuring source separation, the collection and recycling of priority waste streams; (b) further development of producer responsibility; (c) development and transfer of environmentally sound waste recycling and treatment technology; • Developing or revising the legislation on wastes, including, inter alia, construction and demolition waste, sewage sludge, biodegradable wastes, packaging, batteries and waste shipments.
2.4
Next steps for waste management
It is clear, therefore, that although further legislation to deal with waste management is inevitable, it is only one of a number of methods that will be employed to implement the EU environmental policy. In April 2006 the Commission produced a mid-term report on the sixth EAP (COM (2007)
Legislation for recycling waste composites
29
225) which outlined what progress had been made since its inception in 2002 and prior to a planned full review in 2010. The mid-term report concluded that ‘the EU was still not yet on the path towards genuine sustainable development’ but had brought about significant improvement in a number of areas. The report outlined areas of the programme where further work was needed and in terms of legislation and policy to deal with the environment it was proposed that more needed to be put in place to deal with waste management. With most relevance to composite materials, the future areas to consider are:
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
The Framework Directive on Waste Environmental Permitting Regulations The Landfill Directive IPP The UK Climate Change Act Carbon dioxide emissions from passenger cars End-of-life vehicles Waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE)
2.5
The Waste Framework Directive
The Waste Directive has been amended a number of times since its introduction in 1975 (Directive 75/442 EEC). However, in response to the thematic strategies adopted in the sixth EAP, a review of the Waste Directive commenced and a proposal was put forward by the Commission in 2005 (COM (2005) 667). After public consultation, the proposal was adopted by the European Council as a directive in October 2008 and member states have until 2010 to transpose it into domestic law (Directive 2008/98/EC). The effect of the new directive will be to repeal the existing waste directive but also the directives on hazardous waste (Directive 91/689 EEC) and waste oils (Directive 75/439 EEC) thereby simplifying the legislation. This directive is the window through which all EU legislation on waste should be read. A significant driver behind updating the directive was the lack of clarity and precision in the definitions used in the 1975 directive. This led to variable implementation and differing interpretation between member states that had to be settled by the European Court of Justice mainly around the definition of waste and the distinction between the terms recovery and disposal (COM (2005) 667). The ethos behind the directive is to promote waste as a secondary resource in order to reduce landfill levels even further and thereby additionally bring about a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. There is a
30
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
strong emphasis on waste prevention and the new directive sets even more ambitious recycling targets of 50% of household waste and 70% of construction waste by 2020. The inclusion of construction waste will have a significant impact on composite materials, with 11% of the UK’s fibre reinforced plastic production being used in the construction industry (Conroy et al. 2006). The language used in the directive has been harmonised with other directives and it harnesses product life-cycle thinking by encouraging producers to prevent waste generation in the first instance, for example. The 1975 directive set out a waste management hierarchy with the first priority being to prevent waste in the first instance, then to recycle and reuse. This hierarchy is the bedrock of sustainable waste management and has been embedded into legislation. The new proposals extend this thinking further and introduce further measures into the hierarchy based on their environmental impact.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
2.6
Environmental Permitting Regulations
The Environmental Permitting Regulations 2007 (SI 3538) came into force in April 2008 and replace around 40 pieces of environmental legislation. A series of guidance documents has also been issued to accompany the regulations (http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/epp/). The Environmental Permitting Regulations bring together a number of pollution control legislations into a single set of regulations. A number of environmental directives such as the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Directive (Directive 2002/96/EC) and the End-of-Life Vehicle Directive (Directive 2000/53/EC) require waste operators to hold an authorised permit which cover their facilities, processes and compliance procedures. The Environmental Permitting Regulations set out the generic and specific terms that must be adhered to along with the reporting, inspection and enforcement procedures. The effect of the regulations is to harmonise environmental permits and reduce bureaucracy especially where more than one waste facility operates from a single site. Subject to public consultation, phase 2 will be rolled out between 2008 and 2011 (http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/epp/deliver.htm#2).
2.7
The Landfill Directive
The 1999 EU Landfill Directive (Directive 1999/31/EC) was transposed into English law through the Landfill (England and Wales) Regulations 2002. It was subsequently amended in 2004 and 2005, which incorporated the council decision in 2003 (Council Decision 2003/33/EC). It is now implemented in the UK through the Environmental Permitting Regulations (SI 3538).
Legislation for recycling waste composites
31
The overall objective of the regulations is to supplement the requirements of the Waste Framework Directive (Directive 2006/12/EC) discussed in the preceding section and prevent, or reduce, the negative effects of landfilling on the environment as well as any risk to human health as a result. The regulations attempt to achieve this through specifying technical standards of landfill sites and operations and setting out requirements for the location, conditioning, management, control, closure and preventative and protective measures. A strategy on biodegradable waste must also be implemented as part of the regulations that provides for the progressive diversion of biodegradable municipal waste from landfill in order for the UK to meet challenging targets: • •
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
•
By 2010 to reduce biodegradable municipal waste landfilled to 75% of that produced in 1995. By 2013 to reduce biodegradable municipal waste landfilled to 50% of that produced in 1995. By 2020 to reduce biodegradable municipal waste landfilled to 35% of that produced in 1995.
The target years for the UK set out above take advantage of the offer in the Directive to member states who landfilled more than 80% of their municipal waste in 1995 to have the flexibility to postpone the deadlines by up to four years.
2.8
Integrated product policy
IPP is a public policy initiative which has been on the EU agenda since roughly the late 1990s and is concerned with the reduction of environmental impact associated with products and services. The purpose of the EU initiative was to harmonise varying environmental product policy strategies that were developing within the Community to minimise the environmental impact of their products at varying stages of the product life cycle: for example, take-back schemes, product labelling, taxes or other economic initiatives. These differing approaches among member states led to a call for harmonisation of such measures across the EU in order to avoid problems that might arise from different policy approaches. Consequently, an IPP green paper was published, promoting common framework within the EU (COM (2001) 68). The European Commission published a green paper on IPP in 2001 (COM (2001) 68) which set out the rationale behind developing the IPP approach to environmental policies and set out possible mechanisms that might be used to achieve ‘greener’ products. Two pilot projects were
32
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
concluded in 2006 which focused on a mobile telephone and a tropical garden chair as example products (IP/06/1233). The work of the Commission has gone on to identify further products that can benefit from environmental improvement which includes passenger cars (Nemry et al. 2008). There is currently no specific legislation governing IPP.
2.9
United Kingdom legislation: The Climate Change Act 2008
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
In addition to complying with EU laws on the environment, the UK has its own domestic laws and in November 2008 it became the first country to introduce a climate change act (The Climate Change Act 2008). The act places legally binding obligations on polluters and sets challenging targets for the reduction in emission of greenhouse gases, meaning this act will have long-term implications for all UK businesses and producers. Key features of the act include: • in comparison to the level of emissions of greenhouse gases in 1990, a reduction of 26% by 2020 and at least 80% by 2050; • introduction of legally binding carbon budgets which cap emissions over five year periods, with three budgets set at a time; • creation of an independent Committee on Climate Change (CCC) to advise on the level of budgets and report to Parliament on progress on an annual basis – the CCC will publish its first progress report in September 2009; • the Government must report on a five yearly basis on the risks to the UK from climate change, and publish a programme setting out how these impacts will be tackled; • Government powers that oblige public bodies to conduct their own risk assessments and formulate action plans that address the risks identified.
2.9.1 Future passenger vehicle emissions The Climate Change Act should ensure that the UK easily meets its EU obligations to comply with vehicle emission standards that will be implemented in 2009 as part of Euro 5 and 2014 under Euro 6 (Regulation 715/2007). In December 2007, the Commission published a proposal to harmonise and reduce carbon dioxide emissions from passenger cars (COM (2007) 856). The Commission proposed a cut to the current 160 g CO2/km level of carbon dioxide emissions to 120 g CO2/km for the whole car industry by 2012.
Legislation for recycling waste composites
33
In December 2008, Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) and the presidency of the European Council came to an agreement on new carbon dioxide emission levels (IPR 43441 2008). The agreement that was finally reached was 130 g CO2/km arising from advances in motor vehicle technology with a further 10% saving from other means such as tyre technology and use of biofuels. The Commission has a long-term objective to reduce carbon dioxide emissions further to an average of 95 g CO2/km across a car fleet by 2020 and has agreed to the industry phasing in steadily reducing values between now and 2015. It has set interim figures of 65% of the fleet by 2012, 75% by 2013, 80% by 2014 with full compliance with 95 g CO2/km by 2015. Any manufacturer who fails to meet these levels will be charged with an excess emission premium of: •
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
•
between 2012 and 2018 • 15 for the first gram • 115 for the second • 125 for the third • 195 for the fourth after 2019 • 195 for every gram over
These proposals will now be put through the legislative process but it is not yet known when a final agreement will be announced. A review of the legislative framework for the automotive industry in Europe has been ongoing since 2005 through the Competitive Automotive Regulatory System for the 21st century (CARS21). It is a high level group set up in 2005 which has objectives of generating recommendations for the short-, medium- and the long-term public policy and regulatory framework for the European automotive industry.
2.10
End-of-Life Vehicle Directive
The fifth EAP (EAP 5 1993), previously discussed in this chapter, began to set longer-term environmental objectives and introduced the concept of sustainable development as well as managing waste not just on a community level but on a global level. The programme stated that the attitude to waste management needed to change and suggested two strategies, one of avoiding waste by improving product design in the first instance but, where waste arises, a second strategy of recycling and reusing the waste. This European Community strategy led almost seamlessly into new legislation on managing of waste streams and from this flowed the End-of-Life Vehicle (ELV) Directive (Directive 2000/53/EC) and which was transposed into UK law on 3 November 2003 (End-of-Life Vehicle Regulations).
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
34
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
The regulations were subsequently amended in 2005 by the End-of-Life Vehicles (Producer Responsibility) Regulations 2005 with further minor revisions in 2008 (Environmental Permitting Regulations 2007, SI 3538). The first focus of the ELV legislation is to prevent waste in the first place and then to consider reuse and recycling as well as other forms of energy recovery. The scope of the legislation is not just contained to the vehicle itself but extends to their components and materials, irrespective of whether or not they were factory fitted to the vehicle. One of the first obligations placed on manufacturers was to stop the use of hazardous waste such as lead and mercury in vehicles made after July 2003. For the first time, the regulations place a requirement on vehicle manufacturers to take back vehicles at the end of their life via authorised treatment facilities (ATF), which would be charged with its environmentally sound recovery. The cost of treatment by the ATFs is to be borne for the large part by the producers rather than by the last keeper or owner and since the regulations were amended in 2005 there is a requirement that authorised treatment facilities are required to provide the service free of charge, effective from 1 January 2007 (where vehicles are largely complete and have not had extra waste added). The original regulations (End-of-Life Vehicle Regulations 2003) set out national targets for reuse and recycling as follows: • No later than 1 January 2006 the reuse and recovery rate for all ELVs will be at least 85% (average weight per vehicle and year). However, the rate for vehicles produced before 1 January 1980 was set at 75%. • By no later than 1 January 2015, all ELVs will need to have a reuse and recovery rate of no less than 95%.
2.11
Waste Electric and Electronic Equipment Regulations
The European Directive on WEEE (Directive 2002/96/EC) was implemented in the UK through the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Regulations 2006 (SI 3289). The regulation finally became effective in August 2007. The regulations are implemented through the Environmental Permitting Regulations 2007 (SI 3538). The aim of the directive is to prevent and minimise WEEE and it puts a responsibility on producers and distributors to pay for the costs associated with the collection, treatment, recycling and recovery of WEEE. To ensure this takes place, the regulations require approved compliance schemes to be established which will finance the collection and treatment of WEEE. The WEEE regulations require all WEEE arising from the business sector to be collected for recycling, reuse and safe disposal. For domestic
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
Legislation for recycling waste composites
35
household WEEE, the regulations set a collection target of 4 kg per head of the population per year. Since August 2005 producers of electrical and electronic goods have had an obligation imposed on them by Regulation 15 to mark their products with a crossed out wheelie bin symbol and a registration number from which the producer can be identified. Further obligations are placed on distributors to provide information to consumers on the environmental impact of the products they purchase. Regulation 10 requires producers to join an approved producer compliance scheme (PCS) which is overseen by the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (BERR). No business is exempt from this, irrespective of its size. The scheme is financed by the producers who are members of the scheme and the levy is dependent on how much of a market share they have, i.e. the more electrical and electronic equipment they produce, the more they pay into the scheme. Distributors must also belong to and fund either a take-back scheme or must offer in-store take-back facilities for domestic consumers. An in-store scheme must allow consumers who are replacing equipment to bring back, free of charge, an old equivalent item even if it was not originally purchased from that distributor. If the distributor has joined a distributor take-back scheme then the consumer can take the WEEE to a designated collection facility (DCF) free of charge. Typically, DCFs will be located at locally run council waste sites. Amendments to the WEEE regulations came into force on 1 January 2008 at the end of the first compliance period which was 1 July to 31 December 2007 (WEEE Amendment Regulations 2007). The amendments include counting of whole appliances for reuse and providing for private households to return WEEE to the system free of charge even where they do not replace it with an equivalent. The Commission proposes to revise the WEEE Directive (URN 08/1516, 2008 and COM (2005) 667) again and overhaul the regulatory framework so that it is easier and cheaper to administer and enforce. In the UK the Environmental Permitting Regulations will be used to achieve this.
2.12
Conclusions
EU environmental policy and legislation have been developed and shaped by six environment action programmes for over more than 30 years. The first batch of environmental legislation put in place the framework for dealing with specific problems such as waste oil. This was built upon by legislation that developed standards for landfills and incinerators, for example, whilst the third batch of legislations introduced recycling directives which put in place the necessary organisation and finances to assist
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
36
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
the recycling of key waste flows such as end of life vehicles. Some lack of clarity in the wording of the directives meant that implementation among member states was variable and the current legislation seeks to harmonise and streamline environmental law making it standardised and more enforceable. The Commission is setting more and more ambitious environmental targets which will see impacts on the composites industry particularly as the mid-term review of the EAP 6 has singled out housing and transport as priority sectors. Both of these sectors use composite materials heavily and it is clear that future management of composite waste is set to become even more regulated. Whilst legislation is an important tool in achieving environmental targets, it is only part of the toolkit for achieving implementation alongside voluntary agreements and economic tools such as taxes for instance. At the core of all environmental legislation surrounding waste is the allimportant waste hierarchy which sets out the preferred routes for dealing with waste. In furtherance of this, all new waste legislation places the onus on producers to apply life-cycle thinking at the conception stage with a view to preventing waste in the first instance. Sitting alongside the legislation to achieve effective waste management are policy initiatives such as the integrated product policy which aim to reduce the environmental impact of products. Ultimately, however, if environmental degradation is to be halted, better use of resources and more efficient waste management will be necessary. The EU is addressing this through its sustainable development strategy and hence the priorities set here are likely to flow down into legislation in the future.
2.13
References
1st environment action programme 1973–1976. Official Journal of the European Communities, C 112, 20.12.1973 2nd environment action programme 1977–1981. Official Journal of the European Communities, C 139, 13.6.1977 3rd environment action programme 1982–1986. Official Journal of the European Union, C 46, 17.2.1983 4th environment action programme 1987–1992. Official Journal of the European Union, C 328, 7.12.87 5th environment action programme 1993–2000. Official Journal of the European Union, C 138, 17.5.1993 6th environment action programme 2001–2010. Official Journal of the European Union, L 242, 10.9.2002 com (2001) 68 – Green paper on Integrated Product Policy com (2005) 667 – Proposal for a directive of the European parliament and of the council on waste
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
Legislation for recycling waste composites
37
com (2007) 225 – Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council and the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on the Mid-term Review of the sixth Community Environment Action Programme com (2007) 856 – Proposal for regulation setting emission performance standards for passenger cars as part of the Community’s integrated approach to reduce CO2 emissions from light duty vehicles conroy a, halliwell s, reynolds t, ‘Composite recycling in the construction industry’, Composites: Part A, 37, 2006 council decision 2003/33/EC establishing criteria and procedures for the acceptance of waste into landfills. Official Journal of the European Communities, L 11/27, 16.1.2003 directive 1999/31/EC on the Landfill of Waste. Official Journal of the European Union, L 182/1, 16.7.1999 directive 2000/53/EC on End-of-Life Vehicles. Official Journal of the European Union, L 269/34, 21.10.2000 directive 2002/96/EC on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment 27 January 2003. Official Journal of the European Union, L 37/24, 13.2.2003 directive 2008/35/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 March 2008 amending Directive 2002/95/EC on the restriction of the use of certain hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment as regards the implementing powers conferred on the Commission. Official Journal of the European Union, L 81/67, 20.3.2008 directive 2008/98/EC on waste. Official Journal of the European Union, L 312, 22.11.2008 directive 75/439/EEC on waste oils. Official Journal, L 194, 25.7.1975 directive 75/442 EEC on waste. Official Journal, L 194, 25.7.1975 directive 91/689/EEC on hazardous waste. Official Journal, L 377, 31.12.1991 european communities act, 1972. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1972/ukpga_ 19720068_en_1 hawke n, Environmental Policy: Implementation and Enforcement, Ashgate 2002 ip/06/1233 – Environment: Commission pilots projects resulting in industry commitments to make greener products. http://europa.eu/rapid/pressReleasesAction.do? reference=IP/06/1233&format=HTML&aged=1&language=EN&guiLanguage =en ipr 43441 – European Parliament press release – MEPs and presidency reach deal on CO2 emissions from cars. http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/expert/ infopress_page/064-43442-336-12-49-911-20081202IPR43441-01-12-2008-2008false/default_en.htm nemry f, leduc g, mongelli i and uihlein a, Environmental improvement of passenger cars (IMPRO – Car). EU Joint Research Centre, Scientific and Technical Report, JRC 40598, EUR 23038 EN 2008 regulation (EC) No 715/2007 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June 2007 on type approval of motor vehicles with respect to emissions from light passenger and commercial vehicles (Euro 5 and Euro 6) and on access to vehicle repair and maintenance information. Official Journal of the European Union, L 171/1, 29.6.2007 statutory instrument 2006, No. 3289. The Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Regulations 2006. http://www.berr.gov.uk/files/file35992.pdf
38
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:37 PM
statutory instrument No. 3538. The Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2007. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2007/uksi_20073538_en_1 the climate change act 2008. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts2008/ukpga_ 20080027_en_1 treaty of amsterdam. Official Journal of the European Union, C 340, 10.11.1997 urn 08/1516, 2008. BERR report. WEEE Regulations – Government consultation on new regulations and further development of the supporting infrastructure to take effect from the 4th compliance period, Jan–31 December 2010. http://www. berr.gov.uk/files/file49460.pdf
3 Waste management R. S T E WA RT, c/o University of Warwick, UK
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
Abstract: EU Directive 75/442 EEC set out the early stages of the current waste management practices by introducing a waste hierarchy (reduce, reuse, recover) and a system of permits for those involved in waste treatment with the conditions for obtaining permits and the requirements placed on waste disposal facilities being strictly regulated (e.g. Directive 96/61/EC, SI 1056). Member states have a further requirement to produce a waste management plan and introduce waste prevention programmes and the 1975 directive also established the ‘polluter pays’ principle. In 1994 this was strengthened through legislation (Directive 94/62/EC) which placed a responsibility on the producer of the waste to bear the costs of collection, sorting or treatment and recycling or recovery. Economic instruments were employed in 1996 through a landfill tax (SI 1527) which was designed to divert waste going to landfill and promote the options set out in the waste hierarchy. Later recycling directives dealing with end-of-life vehicles (Directive 2000/53/EC) and waste electrical and electronic equipment (Directive 2002/96/EC), for example, set out more detail about how waste management facilities should operate and report on their activities. A revised Waste Framework Directive (COM (2005) 667) was proposed in 2005 to harmonise the legislation and in the UK it is being implemented through the Environmental Permitting Regulations (SI No. 3538) which also brings together the various conditions placed on waste operators. In addition to the legislative approaches to waste management already outlined, there are EU (EAP 6) and UK strategies on waste which detail plans on waste management and how the member state can reach targets set out in legislation such as levels of recycling or waste diverted from landfill. There are also public policy tools like the integrated product policy (IPP) which encourages producers to take a life-cycle approach to waste. Key words: waste, waste management, WEEE, ELV, labels, environmental permits, waste hierarchy.
3.1
Introduction
In 1972 the European Community determined that a community environmental policy was needed and waste management would be central to it. The framework which developed and shaped environmental legislation and policy came in the form of a series of Environment Action Programmes (EAP), of which there are six to date (EAP1 1973, EAP2 1977, EAP3 1983, EAP4 1987, EAP5 1993, EAP6 2002). Each programme is specific to a particular environmental issue and spans a 5–10 year time frame. The 39
40
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
current programme in operation is EAP 6 which identifies waste as one of its priority areas. The programme is thematically based with one specific theme being devoted to waste prevention and recycling. The year on year increase in waste generation has resulted in the European Union (EU) consuming natural resources at an unsustainable rate and therefore managing the remaining resources is paramount. Managing waste is a key feature in the EU strategy for sustainable development (COM (2001) 264) and this chapter will look at the requirements and obligations placed on those involved in generating, collecting, treating and disposing of waste. The waste management procedures most relevant to composites will be explored in more detail.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
3.2
The Waste Framework Directive
The Waste Directive has been amended a number of times since its introduction in 1975 (Directive 75/442 EEC) and most recently in 2008 (Directive 2008/98/EC) which gives member states until 2010 to transpose it into domestic law. The founding directive from 1975 established some of the key criteria on waste management and these have been built on progressively. Article 3 of the directive established the ‘waste hierarchy’ which is a list of options for dealing with waste in order of preference. This hierarchy has been pivotal in shaping waste management strategy, practice and environmental law for the last three decades. The waste hierarchy consists of: • • • •
prevent waste from being generated in the first place; reduce the quantities of waste; recycle and reuse waste; energy recovery.
The directive also required member states to set up ‘competent authorities’ to be responsible for the planning, organisation, authorisation and supervision of waste disposal operations. In the UK this function is now performed by the Environment Agency. Once established, the authorities were required to make waste management plans which set out the type and quantity of waste for disposal as well as associated costs and technical requirements for doing so. The competent authorities were given responsibility for granting permits to any undertaking or holder processing waste. To obtain a permit, the waste operator had to demonstrate how the waste would be disposed of without causing harm to human life or the environment. This obligation meant providing technical details and safety precautions taken to protect human health and the environment but also a requirement to provide the competent authority with information on the origin, destination, treatment, type and quantity of the waste. To ensure
Waste management
41
waste operators complied with the criteria detailed in the permit they would be subject to inspection by the authority. In turn, the competent authority would have to report back to the EU Commission on how it was implementing the directive. The burden of costs associated with disposing of waste were placed upon the waste producer and the ‘polluter pays’ principle was firmly established, the more waste a producer created, the more they would pay to have it disposed of. An example of this is the Landfill Tax Regulations (SI 1527) which will be discussed later in the chapter. In 2006 the founding directive was amended (Directive 2006/12/EC), putting in place the essential requirements for the management of waste and adding a definition of waste as well as adding an aspiration for the EU as a whole to become self sufficient in waste disposal, but creating a specific aim for member states to achieve this. The latest amendment to the Waste Framework Directive took place in 2008 (Directive 2008/98/EC) and the following areas were addressed:
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
•
• • • • •
The introduction of an environmental objective, focusing specifically on reducing the environmental impact of waste and the life cycle of waste; Clarification on recovery and disposal; Clarification of the conditions for mixing of hazardous waste; Introduction of a procedure which clarifies when waste ceases to be waste for a particular waste stream; Introduction of minimum standards for a number of waste management operations; Introduction of a requirement to develop national waste prevention programmes.
The language used in the directive has been harmonised with other directives and it harnesses product life-cycle thinking by encouraging producers to prevent waste generation in the first instance for example. The 1975 directive set out a waste management hierarchy with the first priority being to prevent waste in the first instance, then to recycle and reuse. This hierarchy is the bedrock of sustainable waste management and has been embedded into legislation. The new proposals reinforce the waste hierarchy of prevention, reuse, recycling, recovery (including by energy recovery) and safe disposal. Not only is there a requirement for member states to produce waste management plans but a new requirement for waste prevention plans has been introduced. A report by the Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) sets out when each obligation has to be met by the UK (http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/waste/thematicstrat/ revised-wfd-transposition-implementation-dates.pdf). Both the Disposal of Waste Oil Directive (Directive 75/439/EEC) and the Hazardous Waste
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
42
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Directive (Directive 91/689/EEC) have been subsumed into the Waste Framework Directive (Directive 2008/98/EC) in order to simplify the legislation. In terms of the requirement for a waste operator to have a permit issued by the competent authority, each revision of the Waste Framework Directive has added details to this requirement and this has been supplemented by other supporting legislation such as the Waste Management Licensing Regulations (SI 1056). The 2008 amendment to the directive goes further than previous revisions by introducing minimum standards for permits designed to ensure that waste is treated in an environmentally sound manner. The Waste Framework Directive (Directive 2008/98/EC) defines waste as ‘any substance or object which the holder discards or intends or is required to discard’ and management as ‘the collection, transport, recovery and disposal of waste, including the supervision of such operations and after-care of disposal sites’. These definitions mean that environmental rules for dealing with waste apply not only to waste disposal facilities themselves but also to recovery and recycling operations as well as to waste brokers, dealers and carriers. A waste broker is a third party who makes arrangements for others to handle, transport, dispose of or recover waste rather than doing it themselves and a waste dealer is a type of broker who sells on the waste. The Environmental Protection Act (1990) also imposes a Duty of Care on the handling of waste, which affects anyone who: • • • • • • •
produces; imports; stores; transports; treats; recycles; or disposes of controlled waste.
Under the Duty of Care, businesses producing, carrying, storing or treating waste must meet guidelines to ensure that waste management facilities do not pollute the environment or cause harm to human health. The primary onus of responsibility for the handling of waste is on the waste producer, who must ensure that waste is stored securely and transferred to an ‘authorised’ person only.
3.2.1 Licensing of waste operations To comply with the permitting requirements of the Waste Framework Directive previously discussed, the UK implemented the Waste
Waste management
43
Management Licensing Regulations (WMLR) in 1994 (SI 1056 as amended). The Waste Management Licensing Regulations set out the procedure for obtaining a licence and also identified a number of activities that are excluded from requiring a licence or that are exempt from licensing. If an activity is exempt it probably needs to be registered by the competent authority, i.e. the Environment Agency in the UK. The types of waste treatment activities that required a licence include: landfilling; disposal of waste using plant equipment (incineration, shredding, sorting); • treatment, keeping or disposal of controlled waste on land; • treatment, keeping or disposal of controlled waste by mobile plant; • treatment, keeping or disposal of controlled wastes in a manner likely to cause detriment to the environment or human health.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
• •
In order to be granted a licence certain criteria have to be met such as demonstrating technical competence underpinned by a formal training certificate in waste management. Applicants also have to demonstrate evidence of financial provisions for the activities covered by the permit and adequate security, typically in the form of insurance in case of seepages into the water course, for example, but also a requirement for the waste site itself to be secure from the public. However, the Waste Management and Licensing Regulations have now been superseded by the Environmental Permitting Regulations (SI No. 3538). It is not only waste management operations that require a permit to operate but also the installations themselves and this is detailed in the Directive on Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC), (Directive 96/61/EC). The directive has been amended a number of times and as a result was codified in 2008 (Directive 2008/1/EC). Codification means bringing all amendments to a given law adopted at different times into one law. The IPPC Directive establishes an approach for pollution prevention from stationary ‘installations’ involved in industrial and agricultural processes. The purpose of the directive is to achieve a high level of environmental protection using measures to prevent or, where that is not practicable, to reduce emissions to air, water and land from industrial processes. An installation is classed as a stationary technical unit. The IPPC Directive is based on a number of core principles which are an integrated approach, use of best available techniques, flexibility and public participation. The directive requires industrial and agricultural activities to have a permit which can be granted only if certain environmental conditions are met, meaning that the industries themselves take responsibility for
44
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
preventing and reducing any pollution they cause. The types of industry covered include the waste management industry. In order to receive a permit, an industrial or agricultural installation must comply with certain obligations such as: • use the best available techniques (BAT) as pollution-prevention measures; • prevent all large-scale pollution; • prevent, recycle or dispose of waste in the least polluting way possible; • use energy efficiently; • prevent accidents and limit the consequences if they do happen; • restore sites to their original state when the activity is over.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
Those applying for a permit have to give information on how they will implement the obligations outlined above such as the proposed waste management techniques and how emissions will be monitored. Like the Waste Management and Licensing Regulations, IPPC is implemented in the UK under the Environmental Permitting Regulations 2007.
3.3
Environmental Permitting Regulations
The Environmental Permitting (EP) Regulations 2007 came into force in April 2008. A series of guidance documents has also been issued to accompany the regulations along with a core guidance document (http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/epp/). This regime streamlines and combines waste management licensing (WML) and pollution prevention and control (PPC) to create a single environmental permit with a common approach to permit applications, maintenance, surrender and enforcement. The EP Regulations bring together a number of pollution control legislations into a single set of regulations and replaces around 40 pieces of individual environmental legislation. A number of environmental directives such as the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Directive (Directive 2002/96/EC) and the End-of-Life Vehicle Directive (Directive 2000/53/ EC) are set out in separate guidance documents which outline measures that are specific to these waste streams. These will be considered in more detail later in the chapter. The EP Regulations set out the generic and specific terms that must be adhered to, along with the reporting, inspection and enforcement procedures. The effect of the regulations is to harmonise environmental permits and reduce bureaucracy especially where more than one waste facility operates from a single site.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
Waste management
45
Waste activities are classed as low, medium and high risk and where the risks are low the EP Regulations commit the operator to complying with a standard package of rules. These standard rules define how a waste operator must carry out particular activities such as limiting the types of waste that can be brought on to a site. Low to medium risk activities would include waste transfer stations and civic amenity sites. Activities involving waste can be undertaken only by competent persons and under the previous Waste Management and Licensing Regulations (SI 1056) operators had to demonstrate this by obtaining a Certificate of Technical Competence. However, the EP Regulations have identified that different types of waste facility present different levels of environmental risk and therefore allow for different levels of competency demonstrations through an industry-approved scheme, i.e. proportional to the level of risk presented. There is the requirement that whatever the level of competency attained, it must be continual in nature and therefore there is an ongoing two yearly assessment. The Waste Management Licensing Regulations (SI 1056) set out a number of exemptions for the requirement to have a waste management licence. The EP Regulations have made changes to the list of exemptions and a number of operations that did not previously require a permit will now do so under the new scheme; these are detailed in schedule 3 of the regulations. An exemption allows certain waste management operations to be carried out without needing an environmental permit and exemptions are designed to provide a lower level of regulation for low risk activities. Under the new proposals businesses may need to renew and re-register exemptions more frequently to ensure waste registers are up to date. It is proposed that there will be a charge for the registration of all exempt waste operations and a requirement for exemptions to be re-registered every three years. This is to cover the cost to the Environment Agency of regulating the exemptions. The public consultation closed in October 2008 and any proposed changes will be brought on stream in 2009 as set out in a review document issued by the Environment Agency (http://www. environment-agency.gov.uk/business/topics/waste/32158.aspx). Part 4 of the EP Regulations deals with enforcement and this can consist of the issuing of an enforcement notice to those who contravene the conditions set out in their permit or a suspension notice if there is a risk of serious pollution. Suspension and enforcement notices set out the reasons behind issuing the notice, what steps must be taken to remedy the breach of the environmental permit and dealing with the pollution and a timeframe for complying. Breaches of the environmental permit can lead to criminal convictions and depending on the offence, a person can be fined up to £50 000 or imprisoned for up to 12 months.
46
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
The second phase of the environmental permitting programme will extend the regulations to include: • • • • •
discharge consenting; groundwater authorisations; water abstraction and impoundment; radioactive substances regulation; licensing of some waste carriers and brokers.
Subject to public consultation, phase 2 will be rolled out between 2008 and 2011 (http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/epp/deliver.htm#2).
3.3.1 Activities requiring an environmental permit
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
In line with the previous legislation the following activities require an environmental permit: • Installations carrying out activities as set out in schedule 1 of the EP Regulations. These will include activities from the energy sector such as refining, production and processing of metals, surface treatment of metals and plastics, production of cement and lime, mineral fibre production, ceramics, and chemicals. Waste management is also covered by the regulations and EP permits are also required by these activities, and include incineration (and co-incineration), disposal of waste by landfill, recovery of waste, fuel from waste. An installation is any stationary technical unit which carries out one or more of the activities listed in schedule 1. • Waste operations. Any disposal or recovery of waste which is not exempt in the EP Regulations. The list of exempt operations has changed under the EP Regulations compared to the WMLR. • Mobile plant carrying out the activities or waste operations as above. By definition a mobile plant is not stationary and therefore can not be described as a facility.
3.3.2 Landfill Directive The EP Regulations provide separate guidance on specific waste streams which detail additional measures that must be complied with. The Landfill Directive (Directive 1999/31/EC) is an example of this; it was transposed into English law through the Landfill Regulations 2002 (SI 1559). Landfill is defined as ‘waste disposal site for the deposit of waste onto or into land’ and the overall objective of the regulations is to prevent or reduce the negative effects of landfilling on the environment as well as any risk to
Waste management
47
human health posed as a result. The directive also requires member states to implement a strategy on biodegradable waste that provides for the progressive diversion of biodegradable municipal waste from landfill in order for the UK to meet challenging targets: By 2010 to reduce biodegradable municipal waste landfilled to 75% of that produced in 1995; • By 2013 to reduce biodegradable municipal waste landfilled to 50% of that produced in 1995; • By 2020 to reduce biodegradable municipal waste landfilled to 35% of that produced in 1995.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
•
The regulations attempt to achieve this through specifying technical standards of landfill sites and operations and setting out requirements for the location, conditioning, management, control, closure and preventative and protective measures. A timetable has been set for existing sites to be brought up to the standards or they must be closed. UK landfill sites must be licensed by the Environment Agency and require a permit to be able to deal with waste of a particular type. The Landfill Directive supplements the requirements of the IPPC Directive which lists non-inert landfill as an activity that requires sites above a certain size to be permitted (Directive 96/61/EC). This is now achieved through the Environmental Permitting Regulations in the UK (SI 3538). There are three categories of landfill sites and they may only be licensed for a particular type of disposal: • hazardous waste as set out in the Hazardous Waste Directive (Directive 91/689/EEC); • non-hazardous waste; • inert waste (waste that does not undergo significant change). Landfill operators must demonstrate that measures are in place to prevent cross-contamination between differently classified sites where they are near to each other. A ban on the practice of co-disposal of hazardous waste and nonhazardous waste has been in place since 2004. From October 2007 there has been a requirement to treat all non-hazardous waste before it is landfill except if treatment is not technically feasible or where treatment would not reduce the quantity of the waste or its environmental impact. The regulations define treatment as ‘ “treatment” means physical, thermal, chemical or biological processes (including sorting) that change the characteristics of waste in order to reduce its volume or hazardous nature, facilitate its handling or enhance recovery.’ The proposed treatment must conform to three set criteria:
48
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
• it must be a physical, thermal or chemical treatment of a biological process which includes sorting; • it changes the waste’s characteristics; and • it does so to reduce its volume or hazardous nature, facilitates handling or enhances recovery. In order to be granted and maintain a permit, a landfill operator must comply with strict reporting and inspection procedures. The permit will set down conditions that have to be met by the landfill operator such as steps that must be taken by that operator to ensure they only accept waste that has been treated or does not need to be treated. The operator is restricted in what types of waste it may accept into the landfill, for example, liquid, tyres, explosive materials and hospital waste are banned but it is the responsibility of the waste holder to ensure it is correctly identified using the List of Wastes Regulations (SI 895) codes. Any waste going to a landfill site must comply with the waste acceptance criteria set out in the directive and the Council Decision of 2003 (CD 2003/33/EC). These are procedures that operators must follow and cover basic characterisation of the waste (source, origin, appearance, list of waste code), compliance testing and on-site verification of the original characterisation. The waste acceptance criteria are set out for each class of landfill. The operator must also show evidence of how it intends to comply with all the sections of the directive including the waste acceptance criteria but also the obligations on record keeping and monitoring and a detailed environmental risk assessment. The cost that the landfill operator charges must reflect the costs of operating the site but also need to include an element of the costs likely to be incurred by closure of the site after 30 years in service.
Landfill Allowances and Trading Scheme So that the UK could meet the targets for diverting municipal waste away from landfills set out in the Landfill Directive, the Waste Emissions and Trading Act was passed by Parliament in 2003. The act puts an obligation on Waste Disposal Authorities (WDA) to reduce the amount of biodegradable municipal waste (BMW) it landfills. Each WDA is given a tradable allowance and they are allowed to landfill up to the number of allowances they have. One allowance is equal to one tonne. The criteria for trading are set out in the Landfill Allowances and Trading Scheme Regulations 2004 (SI 3212). This was the world’s first trading scheme for municipal waste allowances and the scheme will operate between 2005/6 and 2019/20. Each WDA is given an annual figure for the amount of BMW it is allowed to landfill for that year. Under the Landfill Allowances and Trading
Waste management
49
Scheme (LATS) the WDA is able to use the allowance flexibly and may: • • •
save or bank allowances to use in future years; buy and sell them; borrow up to 5% from the next year’s allocation.
A searchable register of LATS activity has been set up to facilitate trade and there are clear reporting and monitoring requirements.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
Landfill tax Part of the toolkit of waste management and environmental legislation is the use of economic instruments and the landfill tax is an example of this which is implemented by the Landfill Tax Regulations (SI 1527) and the Landfill Tax (Qualifying Material) Order (SI 1528). The tax is regulated by HM Revenue and Customs. The Landfill Tax Regulations were amended in 2008 (SI 770). Landfill tax is a tax on the disposal of waste and it aims to encourage waste producers to produce less waste, recover more value from waste, for example through recycling or composting, and to use more environmentally friendly methods of waste disposal. Landfill tax applies to all waste: • • • •
disposed of by way of landfill; at a licensed landfill site; on or after 1 October 1996; unless the waste is specifically exempt.
The site falls within the scope of the tax if there is a licence or permit authorising disposals. Liability for tax on disposal rests with the licence holder of a landfill site and any waste deposited in it, including waste that the site itself produced, will be liable to tax. The tax is chargeable by weight and there are two rates, a standard rate for active waste and a lower rate for inactive waste (rocks and soil for example). Rates for 2008/09 are: • •
Active waste – £32/tonne (+ VAT) Inactive waste – £2.50/tonne (+ VAT).
The rate for active waste increased by £8/tonne per annum from 1 April 2008 and will remain at this level until April 2010 when it will increase to £48 + VAT per tonne. The rate for inactive waste increased to £2.50 + VAT per tonne on 1 April 2008. The Government has announced that the rate will be frozen at £2.50 per tonne in 2009–10. The rates were set out in the UK’s 2008 Finance Bill. Landfill operators can apply to have tax-free status for any part of a site that is not used for landfill, but is instead used for;
50 • • • • •
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites recycling waste; incinerating waste; sorting waste pending its disposal or transfer; storing inactive waste for use in landfill restoration; sorting material to obtain the above.
Tax credits are available for waste that landfill operators send: • •
for recycling, incineration or reuse; to another landfill site.
The rules for doing so have been changed with the implementation of the Landfill Tax (Amendment) Regulations (SI 770) which limits the maximum credit a landfill site operator can claim, in respect of qualifying contributions made against their annual landfill tax liability to 6.0% from the previously higher level of 6.6%.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
3.4
End-of-Life Vehicle Directive
The End-of-Life Vehicle (ELV) Directive (Directive 2000/53/EC) was transposed into UK law in 2003 by the End-of-Life Vehicle Regulations (SI 2635) and is now regulated through the EP Regulations 2007 (SI 3538). The EP Regulations widen out the scope of the ELV Directive by applying to all end-of-life vehicles rather than just to those listed in Annex IIA of the directive. Hence, in the UK the regulations apply to commercial vehicles such as buses and coaches. The first focus of the ELV legislation is to prevent waste in the first place and then to consider reuse and recycling as well as other forms of energy recovery. The scope of the legislation is not just contained to the vehicle itself but extends to its components and materials, irrespective of whether or not they were factory fitted to the vehicle. If the regulations can discourage waste being created, it is anticipated that they will soon force manufacturers to design not just for disassembly but with the whole life cycle in mind. In terms of preventing waste, one of the first obligations placed on manufacturers was to stop the use of hazardous waste such as lead and mercury in vehicles made after July 2003. Under the reporting requirements of the regulations manufacturers must publish reports to consumers on: •
the design of vehicles and their components with a view to their recoverability and recyclability; • the environmentally sound treatment of end-of-life vehicles in particular the removal of all fluids and dismantling; • the development and optimisation of ways to reuse, recycle and recover end-of-life vehicles and their components; • the progress achieved with regard to recovery and recycling to reduce the waste to be disposed of and to increase the recovery and recycling rates.
Waste management
51
For the first time, the regulations place a requirement on vehicle manufacturers to take back vehicles at the end of their life via authorised treatment facilities (ATF) who would be charged with its environmentally sound recovery. Typically it is the ATF that would issue the last keeper with a certificate of destruction allowing it to be deregistered but there is also scope within the regulations for dealers or producers to be authorised, providing they could prove the vehicle was indeed transferred to the ATF. The cost of treatment by the ATFs is to be borne for the large part by the producers rather than by the last keeper or owner and since the regulations were amended in 2005 there is a requirement that ATFs are required to provide the service free of charge, effective from 1 January 2007 (where vehicles are largely complete and have not had extra waste added). The original Regulations (End-of-Life Vehicle Regulations 2003 SI 2635) set out national targets for reuse and recycling as follows:
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
• No later than 1 January 2006 the reuse and recovery rate for all ELVs will be at least 85% (average weight per vehicle and year). However, the rate for vehicles produced before 1 January 1980 was set at 75%. • By no later than 1 January 2015, all ELVs will need to have a reuse and recovery rate of no less than 95%. In order to assist ATFs and to meet national targets for reusing and recovering components, producers are charged under the regulations to label each component according to a set material and component coding standard so that it can be readily identified. Further, manufacturers must provide sufficient instructions or guidance so that assemblies and subassemblies can be efficiently dismantled.
3.5
Waste Electric and Electronic Equipment Regulations
The European Directive on Waste Electric and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) (Directive 2002/96/EC) was implemented in the UK through the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Regulations 2006 (SI 3289) although it should have been implemented earlier in 2005. The regulation finally became effective in August 2007. The regulations are now implemented in the UK through the Environmental Permitting Regulations (SI 3538). The aim of the directive is to prevent and minimise WEEE and it puts a responsibility on producers and distributors to pay for the costs associated with the collection, treatment, recycling and recovery of waste electric and electronic equipment. To ensure this takes place, the regulations require approved compliance schemes to be established which will finance the collection and treatment of WEEE.
52
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
The WEEE regulations require all WEEE arising from the business sector to be collected for recycling, reuse and safe disposal. For domestic household WEEE, the regulations set a collection target of 4 kg per head of the population per year. There are 10 categories of WEEE covered by the regulations along with set national targets for each category;
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
• • • • • • • • • •
large household appliances; small household appliances; IT and telecommunications equipment; consumer equipment; lighting equipment; electrical and electronic tools; toys, leisure and sports equipment; medical devices; monitoring and control instruments; automatic dispensers.
Schedule 2 of the directive gives many specific examples of the types of products included and these range from toasters to dialysis machines. Since August 2005 producers of these goods have had an obligation imposed on them by Regulation 15 to mark their products with a crossed out wheelie bin symbol and a registration number from which the producer can be identified. Further obligations are placed on distributors to provide information to consumers on the environmental impact of the products they purchase.
3.5.1 Approved schemes Regulation 10 requires producers to join an approved producer compliance scheme (PCS) which is overseen by the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (BERR). No business is exempt from this, irrespective of its size. The scheme is financed by the producers who are members of the scheme and the levy is dependent on how much of a market share they have, i.e. the more electrical and electronic equipment they produce, the more they pay into the scheme. The operators of the scheme are responsible for implementing systems that enable reuse of parts as well as the best methods of treatment, recycling and recovery. The recording and reporting of these activities are stringent but are intended as a means of monitoring standards and ensuring the UK achieves the targets set out in the regulations. Reports need to be made on an ongoing basis for each compliance period, of which there are currently three between 1 July 2007 and 31 December 2009. As with producers, distributors must also belong to and fund either a distributor take-back scheme or must offer in-store take-back facilities for
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
Waste management
53
domestic consumers. An in-store scheme must allow consumers who are replacing equipment to bring back, free of charge, an old equivalent item even if it was not originally purchased from that distributor. If the distributor has joined a distributor take-back scheme then the consumer can take the WEEE to a designated collection facility (DCF) free of charge. Typically, DCFs will be located at local run council waste sites. Even those who import electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) into the UK are affected by the regulations as they are covered by the definition of a producer. It is for importers and manufacturers to determine which will hold responsibility as the registered producer for the purposes of the regulations, but according to Flynn (2007), it is likely that the Environment Agency will deem the importer responsible where the manufacturer is not UK based. WEEE can only be processed by an approved authorised treatment facility (AATF) that has the correct type of waste management licence. The processes and procedures used by the ATF to sort, dismantle and treat WEEE are also closely regulated and are administered by the Environment Agency. The regulations set out best practice that must be followed in processing techniques. Post-processing materials such as plastic and metal can then be transferred to a reprocessor and, in turn, be put back into the recycling chain as new products.
3.5.2 Integrated product policy Integrated product policy (IPP) is a public policy initiative which has been on the EU agenda since roughly the late 1990s and is concerned with the reduction of environmental impact associated with products and services. The purpose of the EC initiative was to harmonise varying environmental product policy strategies that were developing within the Community to minimise the environmental impact of their products at varying stages of the product life cycle: for example, take-back schemes, product labelling, taxes or other economic initiatives. These differing approaches among member states led to a call for harmonisation of such measures across the EU in order to avoid problems that might arise from different policy approaches. Consequently, an IPP green paper was published promoting a common framework within the EU (COM (2001) 68). IPP requires all, from government and other major stakeholders through to the supply chain and the consumer, to be mindful of every stage of the products life cycle in order to promote sustainability. All products cause some form of environmental degradation, be that during manufacturing, in use or during their disposal. When considering the life cycle of a product, account needs to be taken of potential environmental harm through all the areas of the cycle right from the extraction of
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
54
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
natural resources, through the design process, manufacturing and assembly stages and on to marketing, distribution, sale and use and finally to their eventual disposal as waste. Clearly, depending on the product there may be a highly complex mix of contributors through the supply and demand chain during the life-cycle process and IPP seeks to place an onus on each to think about and improve their individual environmental performance. The IPP applies a number of techniques to encourage compliance and monitor the objectives set out in the policy, for example economic instruments such as taxes and subsidies, substance bans, voluntary agreements, environmental labelling and product design guidelines. The European Commission published a green paper on IPP in 2001 (COM (2001) 68) which set out the rationale behind developing the IPP approach to environmental policies and set out possible mechanisms that might be used to achieve ‘greener’ products. Two pilot projects were concluded in 2006 which focused on a mobile telephone and a tropical garden chair as example products (IP/06/1233). The work of the Commission has gone on to identify further products that can benefit from environmental improvement which includes passenger cars (Nemry et al. 2008). There is currently no specific legislation governing IPP but it is undoubtedly going to feature much more prominently in the future which was echoed in the mid-term report of the sixth EAP. IPP is, however, already being incorporated into other legislation and it is certain to do so further as regulations are amended and further regulation should not be ruled out. For example, the End-of-Life Vehicle Directive (Directive 2000/53/EC) and the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Directive (Directive 2002/96/EC) can be considered to be examples of IPP. Both directives place a requirement on producers to prevent waste in the first instance through the design of their products and with a view to their recyclability.
3.5.3 Sustainable development One of the objectives of the sixth EAP which implements the EU waste strategy was to decouple economic growth from environmental degradation and to bring about a situation where resources were used more efficiently and waste management was improved so that more sustainable patterns in production and consumption were established. This philosophy is aligned with the EU strategy on sustainable development which was published in 2001 (COM (2001) 264) and updated in 2005 (COM (2005) 658). The strategy is based on seven key challenges, and most relevant to this discussion are: • •
to limit climate change; to limit the adverse effects of transport;
Waste management
55
• to promote more sustainable modes of production and consumption and breaking the link between economic growth and environmental degradation; • more responsible management of natural resources. A progress report on the sustainable development strategy in 2007 (COM (2007) 642) indicated that positive progress had been made towards reducing greenhouse gas emission, for example, through the reduction in vehicle emissions but that the UK was still not on a path towards sustainable transport, with demand for transport growing at 1.3% per year. The rate of sustainable products and services is on the rise but the Commission intends to take further action including adopting an IPP approach and supporting research. Member states are reported to be updating national strategies to align with the EU sustainable development strategy and hence the priorities set here are likely to flow down into legislation in the future.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
3.6
Classification and labelling of waste
The Environmental Protection Act (1990) sets out the duty of care obligations (DoC) for those who handle waste and it requires that any waste be properly described. Accurate descriptions of waste are at the core of waste management and any movement of waste needs to be accompanied by a waste transfer note that provides details about the waste according to a standardised code. Other types of labelling are used to assist in recycling and disassembly operations or to provide the consumer with information about the environmental impact of the products they purchase or use.
3.6.1 European Waste Catalogue The descriptions of waste are standardised by the European Waste Catalogue (COM 94/3/EC and COM 2000/532/EC) which enables waste to be recorded, monitored and controlled across Europe. The Catalogue is a standard set of descriptions and 6 digit codes for waste streams from each industry sector encompassing hazardous and non-hazardous waste. The European Waste Catalogue (EWC) has been transposed into domestic law by the List of Wastes Regulations (SI 895) and the Hazardous Waste Regulations (SI 894). The regulations are set out in chapters 1 to 20 depending on the industry or process that generated the waste. For example, chapter 19 deals with wastes from waste management facilities, off-site waste water treatment plants and the preparation of water intended for human consumption and water for industrial use and chapter 20 deals with municipal wastes. Each chapter has a sub-chapter code and within each
56
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
sub-chapter is a code for a specific waste stream. If the waste is hazardous it is marked with an asterisk. To assign the correct code to the waste it will be necessary to know: • • • • • •
the type of industry that produced the waste; what activity resulted in the waste being produced; a description of the waste; the constituents of the waste; the concentration of any dangerous substances; if there are any hazards associated with the waste.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
The chapters of the list are set out according to business types but certain industries such as car manufacturing use a number of different processes and will need to code their waste based on multiple chapter headings. As an example, waste carbon fibres would have a waste code of 04 02 21 which is derived from chapter 04 wastes from the leather, fur and textile industries, sub-chapter 02 wastes from the textile industry, followed by 21 which is the code for the specific waste stream, i.e. wastes from unprocessed textile fibres.
3.6.2 Recycling labels Both legislation and increasing environmental awareness have forced through the requirement for increased waste prevention and minimisation as well as life-cycle thinking. In order to improve the processes of recycling and reuse it is crucial to clearly identify waste and waste streams. In many instances producers are responsible for taking back products at the end of their lives through legislative tools such as the Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Regulations 1997 (SI 648), so it is in industry’s interests to implement easier methods of identification and sorting to meet ever more ambitious targets. For example, the 2008 amending regulations (SI 413) require 81% of glass packaging to be recycled by 2010. As a result, the use of recycling symbols is common but there is not a systematic regulated approach bar a few exceptions such as the wheelie bin sign required by the WEEE directive (SI 3289). The symbols typically fall into three categories that will signify if the material can be recycled, show what the material is and show whether or not it is compliant with a recognised compliance scheme. Environmental claims about products are addressed through ISO 14021 which attempts to harmonise information on self-declared environmental or ‘green’ claims. The standard outlines conditions for using certain selfdeclared claims such as whether or not an item is recyclable and the use of symbols and logos such as the Mobius loop.
Waste management
57
Recyclability symbols Probably the most familiar symbol that denotes if an item can be recycled is the Mobius loop shown in Fig. 3.1. The symbol is intended for use only on goods that are capable of being recycled, if a facility exists, but it has no precise meaning and is often misused. The Mobius loop with a percentage sign indicates that the product contains the given percentage of recycled content which is more meaningful than the empty loop. Material-specific symbols
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
There are a number of labels in common use to identify what a product is made of and some also denote if it is recyclable. Examples of this are given in Fig. 3.2 for glass, steel and aluminium. The composition of plastic materials are described by a series of numbered Mobius loop symbols developed by the Society of the Plastics Industry (SPI) and are known as resin identification codes. Usually below the symbol is a shorthand version of the name of the resin the item was made from as shown in Fig. 3.3. Eco-label scheme The eco-label was introduced to the European Union in 1992 (Regulation EEC 889/92) and seeks to encourage businesses to provide goods and services that have a reduced environmental impact. It is a market-based initiative and its function is to stimulate the supply and demand of green and
X%
3.1 The Mobius loop.
alu RECYCLABLE STEEL
3.2 Recycling and material identification symbols for glass, steel and aluminium.
58
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
1 PETE
Polyethylene terephthalate
2 HDPE
High density polyethylene
3 V
Polyvinyl chloride
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
4 LDPE
Low density polyethylene
5 PP
Polypropylene
6 PS
Polystyrene
7 OTHER Any other plastic 3.3 Resin identification codes. Note: PETE, V and OTHER can also be known as PET, PVC and O, respectively.
Waste management
59
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
3.4 European eco-label symbol.
environmentally friendly products that are licensed by the scheme. The scheme also allows the consumer to take into consideration the environmental impact a product has before they choose to buy it. The eco-label scheme is therefore putting into practice the IPP approach and using lifecycle thinking to reduce the environmental impact of goods. Licensed products are permitted to use the flower symbol shown in Fig. 3.4. The product types and specific criteria are set out in the regulation and the amending regulation (Regulation EC 1980/2000). The scheme is open to any product and service, except food, drink, pharmaceuticals and medical devices. Furthermore, the flower cannot be awarded to substances that are toxic, carcinogenic or dangerous to the environment or to goods that could be harmful to the consumer in their normal use.
3.7
Conclusions
Waste management in the UK is framed by European Union and domestic environmental strategies, direct regulation, environmental taxes, trading schemes as well as self regulation and voluntary agreements all of which are necessary to bring about sustainability. The waste hierarchy set out in the Waste Framework Directive and EU environmental strategy ultimately determines the economics and practices in waste management through a number of routes including: • • • • •
preventing waste being produced; decoupling economic growth from waste generation; recovering resources from waste; only landfilling waste for which there is no market; setting of progressively stricter emissions levels;
60 • • •
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites setting up networks of appropriate waste management facilities; generating markets for reused, recycled and recovered products; waste resource trading and treatment internationally.
Current and future environmental policy is likely to put ever-increasing targets and challenges on waste management and in response better and more efficient regulation has come on stream to assist the waste management industry. There is also an onus on those dealing with waste at whatever point in its life cycle to use the best available techniques.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
3.8
References
1st environment action programme 1973–1976. Official Journal of the European Communities, C 112, 20.12.1973 2nd environment action programme 1977–1981. Official Journal of the European Communities, C 139, 13.6.1977 3rd environment action programme 1982–1986. Official Journal of the European Union, C 46, 17.2.1983 4th environment action programme 1987–1992. Official Journal of the European Union, C 328, 7.12.87 5th environment action programme 1993–2000. Official Journal of the European Union, C 138, 17.5.1993 6th environment action programme 2001–2010. Official Journal of the European Union, L 242, 10.9.2002 com (2001) 68 – Green paper on Integrated Product Policy com (2001) 264 – A Sustainable Europe for a Better World – A European Union Strategy for Sustainable Development com (2005) 658 – On the review of the Sustainable Development Strategy. A platform for action com (2007) 642 – Communication from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament Progress report on the sustainable development strategy 2007 com 2000/532/EC Commission Decision of 3 May 2000 replacing Decision 94/3/EC establishing a list of waste com 94/3/EC Commission Decision establishing a list of wastes. Official Journal, L 5, 7.1.1994 council decision 2003/33/EC establishing criteria and procedures for the acceptance of waste into landfills. Official Journal of the European Communities, L 11/27, 16.1.2003 directive 1999/31/EC on the Landfill of Waste. Official Journal of the European Union, L 182/1, 16.7.1999 directive 2000/53/EC on End-of-Life Vehicles. Official Journal of the European Union, L 269/34, 21.10.2000 directive 2002/96/EC on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment 27 January 2003. Official Journal of the European Union, L 37/24, 13.2.2003 directive 2006/12/EC on waste. Official Journal of the European Union, L 114/9, 27.4.2006
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:42 PM
Waste management
61
directive 2008/1/EC concerning integrated pollution prevention and control (Codified version) 2008. Official Journal, L 24, 29.1.2008 directive 2008/98/EC on waste. Official Journal of the European Union, L 312, 22.11.2008 directive 75/439/EEC, Disposal of Waste Oil, Official Journal, L 194/23, 1975 directive 75/442 EEC on waste. Official Journal, L 194, 25.7.1975 directive 91/689/EEC on hazardous waste. Official Journal, L 377, 31.12.1991 directive 94/62/EC on packaging and packaging waste, Official Journal, L 365, 31.12.1994 directive 96/61/EC. Integrated Pollution and Prevention Control. Official Journal, L 257, 10.10.1996 environmental protection act 1990. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1990/Ukpga_ 19900043_en_1.htm flynn b, ‘WEEE, the way to go’, The New Law Journal, 157, issue 7258, 2007 ip/06/1233 – Environment: Commission pilots projects resulting in industry commitments to make greener products. http://europa.eu/rapid/pressReleasesAction.do? reference=IP/06/1233&format=HTML&aged=1&language=EN&guiLanguage =en nemry f, leduc g, mongelli i and uihlein a. Environmental Improvement of Passenger Cars (IMPRO – Car). EU Joint Research Centre, Scientific and Technical Report, JRC 40598, EUR 23038 EN 2008 regulation (eec) No 1980/2000 on a Revised Community eco-label award scheme. Official Journal, L 237, 21.09.2000 regulation (eec) No 880/92 on a Community eco-label award scheme. Official Journal, L 099, 11.04.1992 statutory instrument No. 1528, The Landfill Tax (Qualifying Material) Order 1996 statutory instrument 2002 No. 1559. The Landfill (England and Wales) Regulations 2002. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2002/20021559.htm statutory instrument 2003 No. 2635. End-of-Life Vehicle Regulations 2003. http:// www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2003/20032635.htm statutory instrument 2006, No. 3289. The Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Regulations 2006. http://www.berr.gov.uk/files/file35992.pdf statutory instrument 895. List of Wastes Regulations. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/ si2005/20050895.htm statutory instrument No. 1056. The Waste Management Licensing Regulations, 1994. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si1994/Uksi_19941056_en_2.htm#fnf010 statutory instrument No. 1527. The Landfill Tax Regulations, 1996. http://www. opsi.gov.uk/si/si1996/Uksi_19961527_en_1.htm statutory instrument No. 3212. The Landfill Allowances and Trading Scheme Regulations 2004. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2004/20043212.htm statutory instrument No. 413. The Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) (Amendment) Regulations 2008 statutory instrument No. 648. The Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Regulations 1997 statutory instrument No. 770. The Landfill Tax (Amendment) Regulations 2008 statutory instrument No. 894. The Hazardous Waste Regulations 2005. http:// www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2005/20050894.htm statutory instrument No. 3538. The Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2007. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2007/uksi_20073538_en_1
4 Thermal methods for recycling waste composites S. J. P I C K E R I N G, University of Nottingham, UK
Abstract: This chapter describes a thermal process based on a fluidised bed for the recycling of glass and carbon fibre from thermoset composites. The process is particularly suitable for producing high quality fibre from contaminated or mixed materials. The chapter will describe the fluidised bed process, and detail the quality of the fibres that are recovered. Applications for the reuse of the fibre that have been investigated will then be explained and the prospects for commercial scale operation considered. Current and future research directions will be outlined; other relevant research activities will also be mentioned.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Key words: recycling, composite materials, carbon fibre, glass fibre, fluidised bed.
4.1
Introduction
The aim of recycling processes is to reduce environmental impact by reusing materials in a more sustainable way. In general, it makes sense to try to recover as much economic value from a material in a recycling operation since the value of a material represents to a large extent the input of resources needed to produce the material or the scarcity of the material. Recycling processes in which a more valuable recyclate is produced are therefore likely to reduce environmental impact the most and they are also more likely to be cost effective. Polymer composites made from thermoplastic matrices can be recycled directly by remelting and remoulding into high value materials (Goodship 2007). However, recycling polymer composites based on thermoset matrices is much more difficult as the polymer cannot be remoulded (Pickering 2006). Recycling processes have therefore been developed to separate and recover valuable materials from thermoset composites that have the potential to be reused. A number of recycling technologies have been proposed and developed for thermoset composite materials and these are summarised in Fig. 4.1. There are fundamentally two categories of process: those that involve mechanical comminution techniques to reduce the size of the scrap to 65
66
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites Recycling routes for thermoset composites
Thermal processes
Mechanical recycling
Powdered fillers
Fibrous products
Combustion with energy recovery (and material utilisation)
Fluidised bed thermal process
Clean fibres and fillers with energy recovery
Pyrolysis and other thermo/chemical processes
Fibres and chemical products
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.1 Potential recycling processes for thermoset composite materials.
produce recyclates; and those that use thermal and/or chemical processes to break the scrap down into materials and energy. Mechanical recycling techniques can recycle all of the composite material, but the recyclate does not usually provide the same function as the original material and so there is a reduction in value. The simplest thermal process is combustion with energy recovery. Whilst this is a robust process capable of dealing with a wide range of different materials, only the energy value in the scrap composite is recovered. Pyrolysis and other chemical processes have the advantage of being able to recover material from the polymer separated from the inorganic components of the composites, such as glass and carbon fibre and fillers. In some pyrolysis processes the fibres recovered are contaminated with char and in general the processes are less tolerant of mixed and contaminated materials. In a thermoset composite the most valuable constituent within the material is usually the reinforcement fibre, particularly in the case of carbon fibre composites, where the value of the carbon fibre is typically an order of magnitude greater than that of the polymer. In the fluidised bed thermal process the aim is to recover high grade fibres from scrap glass fibre or carbon fibre reinforced thermoset composites. This is done by removing the polymer from the fibre by an oxidative thermal process to yield clean fibres. The process also has the advantage of being very tolerant to mixed and contaminated materials and so it is particularly suitable for recycling waste composites from end-of-life products. This chapter will describe the fluidised bed process, and detail the quality of the fibres that are recovered. Applications for the reuse of the fibre that have been investigated will then be explained and the prospects for commercial scale operation considered.
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
4.2
67
The fluidised bed recycling process
4.2.1 Description of the process Fluidised bed technology has a wide range of applications in combustion and process engineering. It is particularly suitable for solids processing where good mixing and close temperature control are required. It is used widely for the combustion of solid fuels and in the chemical industry for gas–solid reactions (Kunii and Levenspiel 1993). In research conducted at the University of Nottingham, a fluidised bed process has been developed for recycling thermoset composite material. The process aims to remove the thermoset polymer from the reinforcement fibres by a thermal oxidative process, leaving clean fibres which are then suitable for recycling back into composite material. The general principles of fluidisation are described below, followed by a detailed description of the process.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.2.2 Principles of a fluidised bed Fluidisation is a technology in which a bed of solid particles is transformed into a fluid-like state through suspension in a fluid, usually a gas. The solid particles rest on a porous air distributor plate inside a containment vessel. The distributor plate allows the gas to pass into the bed from a plenum chamber below. It may be made from a sintered porous material but more usually a solid plate with a number of small holes or air nozzles is used. At low air velocities through the bed the particles remain stationary as the aerodynamic drag on the particles is low and air only percolates through the inter-particle voids. With increasing velocity, the particles start moving apart and vibrate owing to increase in drag. This leads to bed expansion and an increase in pressure drop. Increasing the velocity above a critical value, which is generally known as the minimum fluidisation velocity, results in the particles being held in suspension in the gas flow and the weight of the entire bed of particles is balanced by the upward drag. As the air velocity increases further, no increase in pressure drop is observed as the bed expands continuously, allowing more air to pass through. A typical transition from a packed bed to fluidisation with increasing air velocity is depicted in Fig. 4.2. The suspended particles behave as fluid. At higher velocity, bubbles start forming at the distributor, then rise through the bed and burst at the upper sand surfaces. Good mixing is attained in this stage, which promotes uniformity in the bed temperature and composition. Higher velocities cause bubble growth and fluctuations in bed pressure drop. When the air velocity exceeds the particles’ terminal velocity, the bed upper surface disappears and entrainment becomes appreciable. At a still higher velocity, all the
68
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Pressure drop across bed
Minimum fluidising velocity
Gas velocity
4.2 Relationship between air flow velocity and pressure drop in a packed bed and fluidised bed.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
particles are carried out of the bed with the air, which is similar to pneumatic transport of fine particles.
4.2.3 Fluidised bed recycling process The basic principle of the fluidised bed recycling process is shown in Fig. 4.3. The fibres are recovered from the composite by removing the polymer matrix by heat in a bed fluidised with air. Once the polymer has been removed from the fibres and any mineral fillers that may also be present in the composite, they are carried out of the fluidised bed (elutriated) in the gas stream and can be separated from the gas in a cyclone or other gas–solid separation device. At the temperature at which the fluidised bed operates, the polymer does not fully oxidise and so, after separation of the fibres and fillers, the gas stream passes through to a secondary combustion chamber where high temperature combustion achieves full oxidation. Energy in the form of heat can then be recovered from the high temperature exhaust gases and, if necessary, any pollutants can be scrubbed before being emitted to atmosphere. In general, thermoset polymers contain mainly carbon, hydrogen and oxygen and so the products of full oxidation are carbon dioxide and water, which can be emitted directly to the atmosphere. Some composites may contain halogenated resins for fire retardancy and, in this case, the flue gas would require scrubbing to remove the resulting acid gases before being emitted to atmosphere. The process therefore recovers reinforcement fibres and fillers in a clean form for reuse. The polymer is fully oxidised and its energy value is recovered.
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites Scrap FRP
Fluidised bed
69
Clean flue gas
Fibres and fillers carried in gas flow
Separation of fibres and fillers
Recovered fibres
Secondary combustion chamber
Recovered fillers
Heat recovery
Recovered energy
4.3 Diagram showing principle of fluidised bed recycling process (FRP = fibre reinforced polymer).
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Clean flue gas
Scrap FRP
Afterburner
Cyclone (to separate fibres)
Induced draught fan Recovered fibres Air preheating elements
Fluidised bed Air distributor plate
Air inlet
4.4 Diagram of the fluidised bed recycling process test facility.
4.2.4 Process operation Figure 4.4 shows a schematic representation of the fluidised bed recycling process. Fluidising air, preheated typically to 450–550 °C, is introduced into a bed of silica sand, with particle diameter typically 0.85 mm and with a fluidising velocity in the region of 1 m/s. At this condition the fluidised bed is in the bubbling regime where there is very good mixing and uniformity of temperature in the bed. The process has been developed on a laboratory pilot scale in which the fluidised bed is 300 mm in diameter (Pickering et al. 2000). In this test rig, electric heaters are used to preheat the air.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
70
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
However, in a commercial scale process heat could be recovered from the gases downstream of the secondary combustion chamber. The temperature of the fluidised bed is chosen to be high enough to give rapid decomposition of the polymer but not too high that the fibres are degraded significantly. For polyester resins a temperature of 450 °C has been found to be suitable, whereas epoxy resins are more stable thermally and generally require a higher temperature of 550 °C for processing at a practical rate. The process is suitable for the processing of both glass fibre and carbon fibre reinforced composites. Carbon fibres are made of graphite and oxidise at high temperature in air. It has been found that at a fluidised bed temperature of 550 °C epoxy resin decomposes rapidly, but given the residence time of the fibres in the fluidised bed, of about 20 minutes, there is little oxidation of the carbon fibre as indicated by a reduction in fibre diameter. Scrap composite material is fed into the bubbling fluidised bed and at high temperature the thermoset resin rapidly decomposes. From thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) of the decomposition of epoxy resin, it is understood that there are two stages in the decomposition of the resin (Jiang et al. 2005). Initially a fast devolatilisation stage takes place in which the resin loses about 50% of its mass and the remaining polymer is in the form of char. This is followed by a slower char oxidation stage. Once the char residue has reduced to about 3% of the weight of the original polymer, the fibres become released from each other due to the mechanical agitation in the fluidised bed and they can then be elutriated. The rate of elutriation depends on the concentration of fibres in the fluidised bed as well as the operating parameters of the bed. It is found that if the concentration of fibre in the bed is too high that fibre agglomeration can take place and this results in large clumps of agglomerated fibre remaining in the bed. It is also observed that longer fibres agglomerate much more easily than shorter fibres (Jiang et al. 2005). Research is currently in progress to obtain a better understanding of this phenomenon and of the parameters controlling the rate at which material can be processed. The clean fibres are released and elutriated into the air stream. The fibres are then separated from the air in a cyclone and collected for recycling. If the composite contains a mineral filler in addition to glass or carbon fibre, the fibres can be separated from the fillers by means of a rotating screen positioned above the fluidised bed as shown in Fig. 4.5. The filler particles pass through the screen and can be separated from the gas stream with a cyclone. The fibres are collected on the screen and are removed continuously by a counter-current of air as shown in Fig. 4.5.
4.2.5 Waste preparation The composite material being recycled must be reduced in size so that it can be fed into the process. The fluidised bed process recovers the rein-
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
71
Gases + fillers Secondary air inlet Hot gases + fibres + fillers
Rotating screen
Secondary air outlet
Fibre collection bin
Secondary air extraction
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.5 Rotating screen to separate fibres from fillers.
forcement fibres in the form of short individual filaments. The length of these must be limited to prevent agglomeration in the fluidised bed and also materials handling and processing problems during reuse. This is done by ensuring that the fragments of composite fed into the process do not contain fibres longer than about 30 mm. When scrap composite contains continuous reinforcement this means that the dimensions of the fragments fed into the fluidised bed should have a maximum dimension less than 30 mm. Several methods can be used to prepare the waste. For scrap from manufacturing operations it is usually necessary to cure the waste if required as uncured composite material is very difficult to reduce in size. Waste in the form of thin sheets, for example prepreg, can easily be chopped up in a conventional granulator of the type commonly used in the plastics industry. Figure 4.6 shows a laboratory granulator manufactured by the Zerma company. Larger granulators are available for processing large quantities of waste. The waste circulates within the granulator and is repeatedly cut by the knives until it is small enough to pass through the holes in the screen. The size that the waste is reduced to is generally determined by the size of the holes in the screen. But composite in which the fibres are highly aligned tend to shred into fragments of high aspect ratio. These may pass end-on through the screen and so the length of the fibres in the granulate may be significantly longer than the size of the holes in the screen. Scrap end-of-life components may be large in size and have thick crosssections and larger machines may be needed to process this material. The
72
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites Scrap feed
Rotor knife – 30x
150 rpm Stationary blades Perforated mesh
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.6 Laboratory granulator.
initial size reduction may be done in large, slow-speed shredding machines. These often use two counter-rotating shafts with knives mounted to grip and cut the material as shown in Fig. 4.7. These machines are usually single pass and there is no screen to control the output size, the main purpose being to give an initial size reduction before further processing. Very large shredders which are capable of taking components of 1–2 m in width in which the thickness of the composite could be in excess of 25 mm are available. Following the initial size reduction, a further reduction could be done in a granulator. Alternatively, hammer mills, have been shown to be very effective in reducing the size of composites. Here the action is by impact rather than cutting and it has been found that whilst the polymer is pulverised into a powder, the fibre fragments usually retain some integrity and a useful fibre length. In a hammer mill the output size is also determined by a mesh screen.
4.2.6 Tolerance to contamination Components made using composites often involve a number of different materials bonded or moulded together. For instance a composite component may be made of two skins of a glass reinforced thermoset, one or both with a painted surface, moulded or bonded to a foam or aluminium honeycomb core with metal inserts at fixing points. Such a mixture of
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
73
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.7 Twin screw shredder with counter-rotating shafts.
materials is difficult to separate and one of the advantages of the fluidised bed process is that it is tolerant of mixtures of different material and contamination in the composite feed. Any organic material in the feed is fully decomposed in the fluidised bed. This means that contamination from paints, foam cores or thermoplastics is not a problem and tests have shown that in small quantities these do not affect the process. So for instance, the thermoplastic backing film on a prepreg does not have to be removed before the material is shredded and fed into the fluidised bed. In general thermoplastics can be recycled by remoulding and this is generally the most suitable recycling method for these materials. So it would be expected that significant quantities of thermoplastic would have been separated from the carbon fibre composite before feeding into the fluidised bed. It is also found that any metals in the fluidised bed fall to the bottom of the bed during processing and can be recovered. Contamination from metals could result from metal inserts for attachment points, aluminium honeycomb cores, wiring and even metals electroplated onto the composite; all of these have been tested in the fluidised bed. So whilst it would be envisaged that large metal pieces would be removed from the waste, metals that are intimately mixed with the composite can be separated in the fluidised bed process. In a commercial scale process the bed material could be continuously removed and regraded to remove these metal pieces.
74
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
The fluidised bed process is therefore particularly well suited to dealing with waste composites from end-of-life parts where the waste may not only be a mixture of different materials, but there may also be contamination that has arisen during service. Tests have shown that clean, good quality glass and carbon fibres can be recovered from end-of-life components, in which there were mixtures of materials, in both the aerospace and automotive industries.
4.3
Properties of the recycled fibre
4.3.1 Physical form The fibres are elutriated from the fluidised bed in the form of short individual filaments. These are separated from the gas stream in a cyclone and collected in a bin. As the fibres are in a fluffy form the bulk density is very low, typically in the order of 50 kg/m3. However, the fibres can easily be compressed for packaging for further processing. Some fluffy carbon fibres are shown in Fig. 4.8.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.3.2 Fibre length distribution The fibre length distribution of the recycled fibres depends on the fibre length distribution of the fibres in the waste feed and also on degradation in fibre length that takes place in the fluidised bed. Measuring the input fibre length in feed material is not easy as the size-reduced composite feed will contain irregularly shaped fragments in which there will be a distribution of fibre lengths. The most practical way is to separate the fibres from a sample of waste by burning off the polymer and then using an image
4.8 Recycled carbon fibre in a fluffy form.
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
75
30
25
Mass (%)
20
15
10
5
0
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
0
2
4
6 8 Fibre length (mm)
10
12
14
4.9 Typical length distribution for recycled glass fibres recovered from an SMC. The scrap fed into the fluidised bed had a maximum particle size of about 15 mm (Pickering et al. 2000).
analysis technique to measure fibre lengths. Figure 4.9 shows a typical fibre length distribution of the recycled glass fibre from a polyester/glass sheet moulding compound (SMC) feed. The scrap fed into the fluidised bed had a maximum particle size of about 15 mm. An investigation of carbon fibre length degradation in the fluidised bed process has been undertaken in which pieces of composite with fibres of uniform known length were fed into the process. The fibre length distribution and mean fibre length of the recycled fibres was then measured. Figure 4.10 shows the fibre length distribution in the recycled fibre, when fragments of carbon fibre composite with a uniform fibre length of 10 and 20 mm were fed into the fluidised bed. It is found that the amount of fibre degradation in the fluidised bed depends on the initial length of the fibres. Longer fibres have a greater tendency to break and hence have a greater length degradation. This is illustrated in Fig. 4.11, which shows the degradation in mean fibre length as a function of input fibre length. The figure expresses the length degradation in terms of mean fibre length based on fibre weight and also on fibre number. Mean fibre length by weight is considered to be a more meaningful quantity than mean fibre length based on fibre number as it represents the fibre length with most of the mass. In contrast the fibre length distribution by fibre number can be distorted by a large number of very short fibres, which have little mass.
76
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites Initial fibre length = 20 mm
16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
Mass fraction (%)
Mass fraction (%)
Initial fibre length = 10 mm
16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 Recovered fibre length (mm)
0
5
10
15
20
Recovered fibre length (mm)
Length degradation (%)
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.10 Recycled fibre length distributions for two different initial fibre lengths (Yip et al. 2002). 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
Ln Lw
5
10
15
20
25
30
Initial fibre length (mm)
4.11 Average recovered fibre length degradation (by number, Ln, and by weight, Lw) versus initial fibre length (Yip et al. 2002).
4.3.3 Properties of recycled glass fibre Visualisation Glass fibres recycled from polyester or vinylester composites are found to be clean with very little residual polymer remaining. Figure 4.12 shows a scanning electron micrograph of some recycled glass fibres. Mechanical properties The mechanical properties of the recycled fibres are measured by single fibre tensile tests according to BS ISO 11566. The tests are done by mounting individual fibres with adhesive across a hole in a cardboard frame. After mounting the frame in a tensile testing machine the cardboard is cut so that fibres can be pulled to failure. Glass and carbon fibres are brittle and the tensile strength is affected by the number of microscopic flaws in the surface.
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
77
JK 08
100 μm × 100
10 KV
22 mm
4.12 Scanning electron micrograph of recycled glass fibres. 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5
Virgin fibre
Weibull scale parameter (GPa)
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
With longer gauge lengths the fibres will be more likely to have large flaws and so lower tensile strengths are obtained. Gauge lengths of 6 and 10 mm are typically used for the recycled fibres. For brittle materials there is a distribution in tensile strength and so a minimum of 20 fibres are tested. The results are analysed using Weibull statistical analysis and the tensile strength reported as the Weibull modulus. It is found that the modulus of recycled glass fibres is not affected by the recycling process and, for E-glass, the modulus is approximately 70 GPa. However, the tensile strength decreases significantly and the strength degradation is greater at higher processing temperatures. Figure 4.13 shows the tensile strength of recycled glass fibres at different temperatures in the
450 °C
1.0 550 °C 0.5
650 °C
0.0
4.13 Tensile strength of virgin and recycled glass fibre. The recycled fibre was recovered from the fluidised bed process operating at temperatures of 450, 550 and 650 °C (Pickering et al. 2000).
78
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
fluidised bed. Polyester and vinylester polymers decompose rapidly at a temperature of 450 °C. Consequently, operating the fluidised bed at this temperature will result in the recycled fibres having a tensile strength about half that of virgin fibre. The reasons for the reduction in strength are not certain (Pickering et al. 2000), but are believed to be due to a combination of mechanical damage to the fibre surface due to the agitation in the fluidised bed, annealing of the fibre causing stress relaxation at high temperature and also chemical diffusion of sodium ions from the surface of the glass with replacement with smaller hydrogen ions, resulting in tensile stresses in the fibre surface.
4.3.4 Properties of recycled carbon fibre Visualisation The recycled carbon fibres are also found to have a clean fibre surface with only a few traces of polymer residue, as shown in Fig. 4.14.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
5 μm
T600s
5 μm
×10 000
5 μm
T600s
MR60H
×10 000
5 μm
×10 000
MR60H
×10 000
4.14 Scanning electron micrographs of virgin (upper) and recycled (lower) carbon fibres.
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
79
Oxidation and fibre diameter As the fluidised bed process takes place at temperature in air there is likely to be some oxidation of the carbon fibres. It is known, however, that graphite oxidises relatively slowly in air at temperatures of 500–600 °C (Yin et al. 1994) and it is found that the diameter of the fibres is not significantly reduced during processing in the fluidised bed. Measurements of fibre diameter show reductions of a few tenths of a micron. Tests undertaken by TGA show virgin carbon fibres exposed to air for 20 minutes at 550 °C experience a weight loss in the region of 2% (Wong et al. 2006) as shown in Fig. 4.15. The residence time of the fibres in the fluidised bed is in the order of 20 minutes, but the fibres are not exposed to air throughout that time as they initially have a protective covering of polymer, so less oxidation would be expected. Exposure of carbon fibre to a temperature of 550 °C in air for periods of up to an hour or more show noticeable pitting of the fibre surface as shown in Fig. 4.16 (Wong et al. 2006). However, this is not observed in any fibres recycled from the fluidised bed process.
The tensile strength and modulus of the recycled carbon fibre vary depending on the grade, and several different grades of fibre have been processed in the fluidised bed. The mechanical properties are measured by the same method as glass fibres by single fibre tensile tests according to BS ISO 11566. Tests were undertaken with a gauge length of 6 mm. A measurement of fibre diameter is also necessary to determine the tensile strength and
100 98 96 Weight (%)
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Mechanical properties
94 92 90 88 86
T600s T600s
MR60H MR60H
84 0
20
40
60
80
Heat treatment duration (min)
4.15 Loss of weight of virgin carbon fibre exposed to air at 550 °C (taken from thermogravimetric analysis) (Pickering et al. 2006).
80
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites 5 μm
5 μm
4.16 Pitting of the surface of carbon after 60 minutes heating in air (Wong et al. 2006).
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Table 4.1 Measured tensile properties of carbon fibre (single fibre tensile tests) recycled in the fluidised bed process
Fibre type
Tensile strength (GPa)
% tensile strength retention in recycled fibre
Tensile modulus (GPa)
Toray T600s virgin Recycled at 550 °C
4.84 3.18
66
208 218
Toray T700 virgin Recycled at 550 °C
6.24 2.87
46
219 205
Hexcel AS4 virgin Recycled at 550 °C
4.48 2.78
62
231 242
Grafil MR60H virgin Recycled at 550 °C
5.32 2.63
49
227 235
Grafil 34–700 virgin Recycled at 450 °C
4.09 3.05
75
242 243
modulus of the fibre from the tensile tests and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used to do this. Table 4.1 shows tensile test results for a range of different fibre types. In each case a sample of virgin fibre was tested for comparison. The results show that the modulus of the recycled fibres is similar to that of the virgin fibre, but there is a significant decrease in tensile strength. The tensile strength reduction appears to be less at lower temperatures in the fluidised bed. But for carbon fibre processed at 550 °C, the practical processing temperature, there is a strength reduction of a third to half the virgin tensile strength. It is perhaps not surprising that the modulus of the fibre does not
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites 250
6.0 5.5
200
5.0 4.5
150
4.0 100
3.5 3.0
50
2.5 2.0 –10
Tensile strength
Tensile modulus (GPa)
Tensile strength (Weibull scale) (GPa)
81
Tensile modulus 0
0
10 20 30 40 50 Heat treatment duration (min)
60
70
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.17 Effect of duration of heat treatment (in air at 550 °C) on tensile strength and tensile modulus of carbon fibre (Pickering et al. 2006).
change during recycling as the processing temperatures in the fluidised bed are well below the temperature at which the fibre was graphitised during manufacture. The reduction in tensile strength may be due to a number of factors including the effect of oxidation and mechanical damage due to abrasion with sand particles in the fluidised bed. It is clear from Fig. 4.16 that the effect of prolonged oxidation in air produces noticeable pits in the surface of the carbon fibre. These are not visible after exposure for 10 minutes but oxidation will nevertheless be taking place and these flaws produced will act as crack initiators and reduce the tensile strength. Figure 4.17 shows the effect of exposure to air at 550 °C on the mechanical properties of virgin carbon fibre. Whilst the modulus remains constant, there is a steady reduction in tensile strength and after about 60 minutes the strength of the fibre is similar to that recycled in the fluidised bed. The residence time of the carbon fibre in the fluidised bed is in the order of 20 minutes and the reduction in strength of the virgin fibre after 20 minutes exposure to air is not as much as that recycled in the fluidised bed. It is therefore suggested that the additional loss in strength observed in the recycled fibre is due to mechanical damage to the fibre surface caused by abrasion in the fluidised bed. Surface chemistry The mechanical properties of a carbon fibre reinforced composite are strongly controlled by the interfacial adhesion between the fibre and the matrix, which is determined to a large extent by the surface chemistry of
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
82
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
the fibre. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) has been used to study the surface of the carbon fibre, and it identifies and quantifies the elemental composition and functional groups present. The interfacial adhesion to a resin can be measured by a fibre pull-out test in which a small bead of resin (about 50–80 μm in diameter) is cast onto a fibre. A tensile test is then undertaken to measure the force needed to pull the fibre through the bead from which the interfacial shear stress (IFSS) can be calculated. The oxygen to carbon (O/C) ratio on the surface of recycled carbon fibre and IFSS of the virgin and recycled fibres are tabulated in Table 4.2. In both cases the virgin fibres have a higher O/C ratio than the recycled fibres and there is a decrease of 36% in the O/C ratio on the surface of the recycled T600s fibre. This is probably due to the removal of the oxygen-containing groups present in the surface sizing. However, there is only a reduction in the IFSS of 13% compared with the virgin T600s fibre. For the MR60H fibre, although a 22% drop in O/C ratio is measured, the recycled fibre shows a 28% increase in IFSS. The exact reason for this phenomenon is unknown although the scatter in the results may indicate that it is of less significance. Table 4.3 shows the functional groups present on the surface of the virgin and recycled T600s carbon fibre as derived from the XPS data. A significant increase in carboxyl group is found on the recycled fibre. However, there is a 22% and 36% reduction in the hydroxyl and carbonyl functional groups respectively and this might account for the 13% reduction in IFSS. There is no clear correlation between the functional groups and heating duration, but overall, the surface chemistry on the virgin and heat-treated fibres is quite similar. Table 4.2 Oxygen/carbon ratio and interfacial shear strength of carbon fibres Virgin T600s O/C ratio Interfacial shear strength (MPa)
Recycled T600s
Virgin MR60H
Recycled MR60H 0.195
0.25
0.16
0.25
52.7 (±11.6)
46.1 (±10.0)
46.5 (±8.2)
59.8 (±8.4)
Table 4.3 Proportions of functional groups on surface of carbon fibre (Wong et al. 2006) Functional group
Recycled
Virgin
10 min
60 min
Total carbon (graphitic + aliphatic) C–OH C=O COOH Carbonate
69.5 21.7 3.53 4.54 1.4
64.6 27.7 5.48 2.16 0
68.6 20.5 3.87 4.54 1.40
60.1 23.3 6.36 6.04 1.08
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
83
Table 4.4 Electrical resistivity of carbon fibres Electrical resistivity, ×10−3 Ω cm Fibre type
Virgin fibre
Recycled fibre
MR60H T700
1.68 ± 0.17 1.51 ± 0.15
1.46 ± 0.17 1.50 ± 0.12
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Electrical resistivity The electrical resistivity of recycled carbon fibre has been measured to establish whether any changes take place during the fluidised bed processing. Resistivity was determined using a single filament resistance method in which the voltage drop along a fibre passing a known current is measured. The results of measurements on two types of fibre are shown in Table 4.4. The T700s fibre showed no change in resistivity but a 13% reduction was observed from the recycled MR60H. It is noted that the resistivity of the virgin MR60H fibre is slightly higher than that of the recycled fibres of virgin T700 fibre. It is possible that this is due to a surface treatment on the fibre that was removed during the recycling process. So the apparent decrease in resistivity or increase in conductivity may not be real. Nevertheless the conclusion of this test is that the recycled fibres have electrical conductivity at least as good as virgin fibre.
4.4
Applications for the reuse of fibre recycled from the fluidised bed process
4.4.1 The form of the recyclate The physical form of the recycled fibre from the fluidised bed process is a fluffy mass of individual short glass or carbon filaments. This is generally unlike any form of commercially available virgin fibre product. Glass and carbon fibres are manufactured as continuous fibre and they are produced in the form of continuous roving, each roving containing several thousand filaments, to which a size and/or binder has been applied to hold the fibres together to assist handling and processing. Manufacturing processes using glass and carbon fibre are thus designed for continuous rovings or, in some cases, chopped rovings. In reusing recycled fibre, an important issue is thus to identify ways in which the fluffy fibres can be processed. The reuse applications described in this chapter were investigated for recycled glass and carbon fibre from the fluidised bed recycling process. However, they are also applicable to recycled fibres produced from other composites
84
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
recycling processes in which the fibres are in the form of short individual filaments, such as described in George and Carberry (2007). There are a number of existing commercial applications in which fibres are processed as short fibres in a generally dispersed form and these may be appropriate for recycled fibre. Two examples are short fibre moulding compounds (Monk, 1997), such as bulk moulding compounds (BMC) or SMC, and non-woven fabrics or mat which in low areal density form are often known as veil or tissue. In the former, the fibres are used for their structural reinforcement properties. Non-woven fabrics may also be used to provide reinforcement, but they also have other applications, such as surfacing veil, to provide improved surface finish.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.4.2 Reuse as a reinforcement Glass and carbon fibre are principally used as structural reinforcement in polymer composites and potential routes for reusing the recycled fibre in thermoset composites are shown in Fig. 4.18. At low volume fractions, BMCs have fibre volume fractions in the order of 10%. These are manufactured by blending chopped virgin rovings into a resin and filler mix to give a product with a 3D fibre dispersion. BMCs do not have high strength or stiffness and are used for semi-structural applications, such as equipment enclosures. Recycled fibre could be used directly in a BMC by blending the fluffy fibre with the resin and filler in the same way that virgin fibre is used. SMCs have higher fibre volume fractions in the region of 20–30%. They are manufactured in sheet form and have a predominantly 2D random fibre architecture and are used for semi-structural applications where better stiffness and strength are needed. They are produced by chopping continuous
Random
Recycled fibres
Non-woven mat BMC/ low value Low volume fraction ~10%
SMC/ prepreg Intermediate volume fraction 10– 40%
Thermoplastic injection moulding Intermediate volume fraction 20– 40%
Aligned
High volume fraction 30– 60% Intermediate aligned material
Wet processing techniques
Dry processing techniques
4.18 Potential routes for processing recycled carbon fibre as a structural reinforcement.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
85
rovings and placing them randomly on a film of resin and filler. Typical applications are in the automotive industry for body panels. To use recycled fibre in an SMC, it is unlikely that the fluffy material could easily be processed directly and laid down in a measured way on to the resin film. An appropriate method of manufacture could be to process the recycled fibre into a non-woven mat first and then use this mat to manufacture an SMC. Higher strength and stiffness composites required higher fibre volume fractions and these are usually achieved by aligning the fibres in the composite so that a higher packing density can be achieved. Manufacturing methods for achieving this include the use of prepreg and filament winding techniques where fibre volume fractions of up to 60% can be achieved. Prepreg is manufactured by laying down continuous rovings, either directly or as a woven fabric, onto a resin film. To use recycled fibre in a prepreg such as this would require the fluffy discontinuous fibres to be processed into an aligned form. Glass and carbon fibre are also used as reinforcement in thermoplastic composites and there are numerous different processing techniques. Short fibres can be compounded with a thermoplastic to produce pellets suitable for injection moulding. Continuous fibre can be processed as a woven textile impregnated with a thermoplastic to produce a high fibre volume fraction composite.
4.4.3 Processing recycled fibre into a non-woven mat Wet processing techniques, based on paper making technology exist for the conversion of chopped continuous rovings into a non-woven fabric in which the fibres are dispersed into a random, predominantly 2D structure of short individual filaments. The technique involves dispersing the fibre in a large volume of water in which dispersion agents and viscosity modifiers have been added. The fibre concentration in the resultant slurry is typically less than 1% by volume. The slurry is then passed through a mesh where the liquid drains through and the fibres are laid down to form the non-woven fabric. A binder is usually added to hold the fibres together after drying. A commercial pilot plant was used to process recycled carbon fibre and high quality non-woven mats were produced with areal densities ranging from 10 to 100 g/m2 (Pickering et al. 2006). This demonstrated that the recycled fibres from the fluidised bed could be processed using an existing commercial process into a high quality product.
4.4.4 Reuse of recycled glass fibre Two applications of the use of recycled glass fibre from the fluidised bed process have been demonstrated: substituting recycled glass fibre for virgin
86
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
glass fibre in a BMC and for the manufacture of glass fibre veil. In both these demonstrations the recycled glass fibre had a mean fibre length of 5.6 mm (by weight) and the size distribution is shown in Fig. 4.9.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
BMC Recycled glass fibre was substituted for virgin fibre in a BMC (Kennerley et al. 1998). The BMC was based on polyester resin with a fibre volume fraction of 13%, and the formulation is given in Table 4.5. The virgin glass fibre had a uniform length of 6 mm. A series of mixes were produced in which the virgin fibre was substituted with proportions: 0%, 25%, 50%, 75% and 100% of recycled fibre. The recycled fibre was E-glass processed in the fluidised bed at 450 °C. This was found to have the same tensile modulus as virgin glass fibre but the tensile strength was 49% of that of virgin fibre. The fibre was recycled from an SMC in which there was over twice as much filler as glass fibre by weight. After separation of the fibre from the filler, the fibre product used in the BMC had a purity of 92%, although the ratios of recycled fibre substituted for virgin in the BMC did not take account of fibre purity. Test plaques of the BMC were moulded and the mechanical properties tested using standard techniques. The results in Fig. 4.19 show no significant reduction in the tensile stiffness with substitution of up to 100% of the virgin glass fibre with recycled fibre. Tensile strength shows no significant change with substitution of up to 50% recycled fibre, although there is a reduction of about 50% in strength with 100% recycled fibre substitution. Impact strength shows steady reduction with increasing recycled fibre content, a reduction of about 30% is shown with substitution of 50% recycled fibre. A batch of BMC with 50% substitution of recycled fibre was made in which the recycled fibre had been treated with a silane solution in an attempt to improve the fibre to resin bonding by replacing the sizing present on the virgin fibre. However, no significant change was found in any of the properties measured. Fibre to matrix bonding would be expected Table 4.5 BMC formulation Parts by weight Polyester resin Shrink control agent Calcium carbonate filler Aluminium trihydrate Mould release agent
66.7 33.3 136.2 109.0 6.5
Glass fibre
13% volume fraction
30 20 10 0
0
20
40
60
80
Charpy impact strength (kl/m2)
15
10
5
0
100
Non-virgin reinforcement (%)
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
87
20
40 Tensile modulus (GPa)
Ultimate tensile strength (MPa)
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
0
20
40
60
80
100
Non-virgin reinforcement (%)
20
15
10
5
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
Non-virgin reinforcement (%)
4.19 Tensile strength, tensile stiffness and impact strength of BMC made with replace of virgin reinforcement with recycled glass fibre (solid markers represent samples in which the recycled glass fibre had been treated with a silane sizing agent) (Kennerley et al. 1998).
to influence the strength of the BMC, but no effect was observed, even on impact strength which was found to be most sensitive to substitution of recycled fibre. It is thus concluded that the reduction in tensile strength is more significant than the removal of the size during the recycling process in influencing the properties of BMC containing recycled glass fibre. A demonstrator component was made with a BMC containing recycled glass fibre. The component was an automotive headlamp moulding and 50% of the reinforcement was substituted with recycled fibre; the total glass content of the BMC was 18% by weight. Apart from the use of recycled fibre no changes were made to the BMC formulation, the compounding or the moulding procedures. The mechanical properties of the component were not significantly different to the control, although impact strength was slightly reduced. The electrical properties were unchanged.
88
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
10
No treatment Silane treated
8 6 4 2 0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Proportion of reclaimed fibres (%)
Breaking length (km)
A glass fibre veil, or tissue, was also made using recycled fibre (Pickering et al. 2000). Veil with an areal density in the range 60–80 g/m2 was manufactured using a wet technique in the laboratory. Quantities of glass fibre were dispersed in water containing dispersion aids and viscosity modifiers to give a slurry containing 0.2% fibre by weight. The slurry was then passed through a mesh on which the fibres were collected to produce the veil. After draining the liquid from the veil, an acrylic binder was applied by dipping in a liquid emulsion and the veil was then dried and the binder cured in an oven. The veil had a final binder content of 18–24% by weight. Veils were made in which the virgin glass fibre was substituted with proportions of recycled fibre of 50% and 100%. The virgin fibre used was uniformly chopped to 18 mm in length as this is the length used for a commercial grade of veil used as a benchmark. Two batches of recycled glass fibre were used which had been processed in the fluidised bed at 450 and 550 °C. The strength of the veil was measured and expressed in terms of breaking length – the vertical length of fibre which would break under its own weight. The results are shown in Fig. 4.20. Increasing the proportion of recycled fibres decreased the strength of the veil. Veil with a complete replacement of the virgin fibres by fibres processed at 450 °C had a breaking length that was approximately 50% that of virgin fibre veil. This agrees with the results of single fibre testing in which fibres processed at 450 °C retained about 50% of the virgin tensile strength. For the sample of veil made with recycled fibres processed at 550 °C the veil strength was 40% of the virgin value, although the fibres at 550 °C retained only 20% of the strength of virgin fibres. It appears therefore that veil strength does not depend on fibre strength alone, but is also a function of fibre length and binder content.
Breaking length (km)
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Veil
10
No treatment Silane treated
8 6 4 2 0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Proportion of reclaimed fibres (%)
4.20 Effect of proportion of recycled glass fibre on the breaking strength of glass fibre veil (LH diagram for fibres recycled at a processing temperature of 450 °C and RH for fibres processed at 550 °C) (Pickering et al. 2000).
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
89
4.4.5 Reuse of recycled carbon fibre Reuse applications for recycled carbon fibre from the fluidised bed process include conversion to a veil for use in electromagnetic shielding, compounding with a thermoplastic for use in injection moulding and the manufacture of thermoset moulding compounds based on epoxy resin and these will be described. To achieve the best structural properties from a carbon fibre composite, high fibre volume fractions are required and these can be achieved with aligned fibre. The problems in aligning carbon fibre will be discussed and some initial investigations of a technique for aligning recycled carbon fibre presented.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Electromagnetic shielding As carbon fibre is electrically conductive, a veil applied to the surface of an otherwise non-conducting material, such as a glass fibre reinforced composite, can be used to provide shielding protection for electromagnetic radiation. Carbon fibre is commonly used as a conducting filler in thermoplastics for the same purpose. As recycled carbon fibre can easily be converted into a non-woven fabric or veil, the potential for using a surfacing veil on a glass reinforced thermoset made from recycled carbon fibre to provide electromagnetic shielding has been investigated (Wong et al. 2005). In the investigation a glass reinforced polyester resin composite was manufactured with a layer of carbon fibre veil moulded onto one surface. The veil was made from recycled and virgin carbon fibre (Toray T600SC) of varying fibre length and with areal densities ranging from 20 to 100 g/m2. The attenuation of electromagnetic radiation at frequencies from 30 MHz to 1.5 GHz through the composite was tested according to standard ASTM 4395-99. The recycled carbon fibre had a mean fibre length of 16.4 mm by weight and had an electrical conductivity measured to be 0.5% lower than virgin fibre. Figure 4.21 shows the shielding effectiveness of the different carbon fibre veils. The attenuation increases with increasing areal density of the veil from about 30 dB for a 20 g/m2 veil to 50 dB for a 100 g/m2 veil made from virgin fibre with a uniform fibre length of 14.4 mm, close to the mean length for the recycled fibre veil. The veils made from recycled fibre are shown to have a slightly lower shielding effectiveness that peaks at 40 dB for a 80 g/m2 veil. Figure 4.22 shows the shielding effectiveness for veils with different lengths of virgin fibre. It can be seen that fibre lengths less than about 14 mm give similar shielding but veils with longer fibre give slightly lower shielding. This is understood to be due to the longer fibres being more difficult to disperse, which gives the veil less homogeneity. This is also the reason for the recycled fibre veil having slightly lower
90
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Average shielding effectiveness (dB)
60 50 40 30 20 Virgin fibre Recovered fibre
10 0 0
20
40 60 80 Veil areal density (g/m2)
100
120
Average shielding effectiveness (dB)
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.21 Average shielding effectiveness of glass reinforced composite with a layer of recycled or virgin carbon fibre veil with different fibre loadings (Wong et al. 2005).
50 45 40
6.4 mm 9.6 mm
35
14.4 mm 19.2 mm
30
28.8 mm
25 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Veil areal density (g/m2)
4.22 Average shielding effectiveness of glass reinforced composite with a layer of virgin carbon fibre veil made with different fibre lengths and at different areal density (Wong et al. 2005).
shielding effectiveness as the recycled fibre contains a proportion of longer fibres up to 30 mm in length. The results of the tests show that recycled fibre has good potential for use as a veil for electromagnetic shielding applications but that it is desirable not to have any fibres longer than about 10–15 mm as these may hinder fibre dispersion.
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
91
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Compounding in thermoplastics Short carbon fibres are compounded with thermoplastics to make fibre reinforced polymers suitable for injection moulding. If milled carbon fibre is used, where the fibre length is a few tenths of a millimetre, the main benefit is to make the thermoplastic electrically conducting and this has application to reduce static or provide electromagnetic screening. Longer fibre lengths of a few millimetres provide better mechanical properties where the carbon fibre also acts as a reinforcement. Recycled carbon fibre is suitable for this application as the carbon fibre in the polymer is in the form of dispersed short fibres and an investigation to compound recycled fibre with polypropylene for injection moulding has been undertaken (Wong et al. 2007a). There were two stages in the investigation: firstly the recycled carbon fibre was compounded with the polypropylene in a twin screw compounder to produce pellets for injection moulding with a carbon fibre volume content of 30%. Then the material was injection moulded into test specimens and the mechanical properties measured. Polypropylene is a non-polar polymer and does not bond well to carbon fibre. So the investigation considered the use of maleic anhydride grafted polypropylene (MAPP) as a coupling agent. This was compounded to the polypropylene before the addition of the recycled carbon fibre. One of the problems faced was how to introduce the recycled carbon fibre into the compounding machine. Virgin carbon fibre can easily be fed in either as continuous tow, or discrete carbon fibre pellets that have been manufactured by chopping virgin tow and adding a binder. The fluffy recycled fibre could not be used in this way and the method adopted for the trial was to convert the carbon fibre into a non-woven mat and then cut the mat into small pellets of about 5 mm in size and feed these directly into the compounder. Some of the key results obtained from the investigation are given in Table 4.6. A range of different coupling agents were added in different proportions and the results shown for the G3003 MAPP at 5% addition to the polypropylene gave some of the best properties. Carbon fibre clearly has a strong reinforcing effect in polypropylene but the addition of a coupling agent further significantly increases the tensile and impact strength and also improves the tensile stiffness by a smaller amount. The effect of the coupling agent is shown in Fig. 4.23, in which SEM images of the fracture surfaces are shown. The polypropylene with the coupling agent can be seen to adhere much better to the surface of the carbon fibre than that without. The material with the coupling agent gave properties that compared very favourably with those of commercially available grades of polypropylene reinforced with 30% volume fraction of carbon fibre. This
92
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Table 4.6 Mechanical properties of polypropylene reinforced with recycled carbon fibre
Tensile strength (MPa) Tensile stiffness (GPa) Impact strength (kJ/m2)
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
5 μm
Polypropylene (PP)
PP + 30% recycled carbon fibre
PP with 5% G3003 + 30% recycled carbon fibre
29 1.7 No break
51 14.7 12.7
125 16 26
10 μm
4.23 Scanning electron micrographs of recycled carbon fibre from a fracture surface for a polypropylene/carbon fibre composite with no coupling agent (left hand image) and with the addition of 5% (wt) of a maleic anhydride–polypropylene coupling agent (right hand image) (Wong et al. 2007a).
demonstrates the potential for the use of recycled fibre compounded with thermoplastics.
Thermoset composites The most common applications for carbon fibre as a structural reinforcement involve its use at high fibre volume fraction in thermoset polymer composites and epoxy resin is the most common polymer used. As described earlier, the highest fibre volume fractions (up to 60%) are achieved by using highly aligned continuous fibre and when producing components using prepreg these volume fractions can be achieved at relatively low moulding pressures of less than 10 bar.
93
100 80 60 40 20 0 0.1
0.2 0.3 0.4 Fibre volume fraction LRCF--16.4 mm
0.5
Tensile strength (MPa)
Recycled carbon fibre cannot yet be processed in an aligned form and so current research for the reuse of recycled carbon fibre to make high volume fraction structural composites has focused on the use of the fibre in the form of a non-woven mat. An investigation to determine the best properties that could be achieved with a non-woven mat made from recycled carbon fibre is reported in Wong et al. (2007b). The aim of this study was to attempt to produce a composite which could outperform aluminium as a structural material that had the potential to be used in the aircraft industry for semistructural components in non-safety critical applications. The composite was made by compression moulding layers of non-woven recycled carbon fibre mat interleaved with a fire-retardant epoxy resin film. Plaques 2.5 mm thick were moulded with fibre volume fractions from 20 to 40%. Two grades of non-woven mat were used; both were made from recycled carbon fibre but one had a mean fibre length of 8.7 mm and the other a mean fibre length of 16.4 mm. The tensile strength and stiffness of the composites produced are shown in Fig. 4.24. It can be seen that the tensile properties increased significantly as the fibre volume fraction increased from 20 to 30% but the rate of increase in stiffness is reduced from 30 to 40% and strength decreases. This is understood to be due to increased fibre damage associated with higher moulding pressure at 40% fibre volume fraction and also the difficulty of achieving proper wet-out of the fibre with resin at higher fibre volume fractions due to the decreased permeability of the mat. Figure 4.24 also shows that better properties were achieved for the composite made from the mat with shorter carbon fibre. Analysis showed that both mats had some degree of fibre alignment; this was greater in the mat with shorter fibres and would explain the better properties
Tensile stiffness (GPa)
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
350 300 250 200 150 100 0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
Fibre volume fraction SRCF--8.7 mm
Aligned
Random
4.24 Tensile properties of an epoxy recycled carbon fibre composite (LRCF – long recycled carbon fibre, SRCF – short recycled carbon fibre). The solid and dotted lines represent the theoretical stiffness prediction for randomly distributed and perfectly aligned fibres (Wong et al. 2007b).
30
250 30 vol% fibre
Strength 25
200
Stiffness 30 vol% fibre
20
150 31 vol% fibre
15
100 10 50
5 0
0 Density kg/m3
Specific tensile stiffness (MPa m3/kg)
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites Specific tensile strength (kPa m3/kg)
94
SFL 1.42
LFL 1.42
2024-T4 2.77
GRP 1.69
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.25 Specific tensile properties of recycled carbon fibre epoxy composites with long carbon fibre (LFL) and short carbon fibre (SFL) compared with aluminium (grade 2024-T4) and a glass reinforced epoxy composite (GRP) (Wong et al. 2007b).
achieved. Despite the problems in manufacturing with a non-woven mat, good mechanical properties were achieved at 30% volume fraction and Fig. 4.25 compares the specific tensile strength and stiffness for the carbon fibre composites with a typical grade of aluminium and a glass fibre composite. Allowing for the reduced density of the carbon fibre composite then, with the properties achieved, it can be shown that for an application in which bending stiffness is the design criterion, a 35% reduction in weight could be achieved compared with aluminium by using the recycled carbon fibre composite with 30% fibre volume fraction. This demonstrates the potential for the use of recycled carbon fibre processed into a non-woven mat. Thermoset moulding compounds using glass fibre with lower fibre volume fractions are used in large quantities in automotive and industrial products. Recycled carbon fibre could be used in similar bulk and sheet moulding compounds to give improved properties and research work is being undertaken to investigate the potential for these materials (Pickering et al. 2006). The aim of the research is to develop BMC and SMC moulding compounds using recycled carbon fibre and epoxy resin with mechanical properties typically double those that can be achieved with glass fibre at similar fibre volume fractions, as shown in Fig. 4.26. At the time of writing the results of this research have not been published but it is understood that the properties aimed for have been exceeded.
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
95
250 UTS (MPa) Modulus (GPa)
UTS/modulus
200
150
100
50
0 Existing BMC Existing SMC Carbon SMC Recycled CF- Recycled CFBMC SMC
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.26 Target properties for BMC and SMC made with recycled carbon fibre and epoxy resin (Pickering et al. 2006).
The BMCs have fibre volume fractions of 10% and typically 50% filler and can be processed in a similar way to glass fibre BMC. The SMCs are based on non-woven recycled carbon fibre mat and it is found that this does not allow the material to flow during compression moulding to the same extent that can be achieved with a conventional glass fibre SMC. Whilst controlling the viscosity and filler loading of the SMC can improve flow, the presence of a random array of individual fibres in the non-woven mat makes fibre flow much more difficult that in a conventional SMC where the fibre is in the form of discrete bundles that can move more easily over each other.
Achieving high fibre volume fraction – fibre alignment In the investigations in which composites were made from non-woven recycled carbon fibre mat (Wong et al. 2007b) moulding pressure was not measured directly but subsequent work has shown that the moulding pressures required to achieve particular fibre volume fractions when moulding a non-woven mat are given generally by the curve shown in Fig. 4.27. It shows that pressures in excess of 60 bar are needed to achieve fibre volume fractions of 30% and that fibre volume fractions of 10% require moulding pressures of about 5 bar. In contrast, when moulding conventional prepregs,
96
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites 20 Compaction pressure (MPa)
18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0
10
20 30 Fibre volume (%)
40
50
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.27 The pressure required (determined by measurement) to compress a non-woven recycled carbon fibre mat with a random fibre orientation to achieve a composite with varying fibre volume fraction.
fibre volume fractions of 60% can be achieved with moulding pressures in the order of 5 bar. A composite with aligned fibres will give better mechanical properties in the alignment direction but an equally important effect is that alignment allows higher fibre volume fractions to be achieved and these also give better mechanical properties. Methods of aligning short fibres have been developed in the past (Bagg et al. 1969; Edwards and Evans 1980) and a feasibility study was undertaken to investigate whether recycled carbon fibre could also be aligned (Jiang et al. 2006). In this investigation a slurry of dispersed fibre was fed through a narrow convergent slot onto the inside of a rotating drum lined with a fine mesh. The fibres were aligned as the slurry passed through the convergent slot and they were then laid down tangentially on the inside of the rotating drum. The liquid was centrifuged out through the mesh leaving an aligned fibre mat on the inside of the drum. A series of trials were undertaken with fibres of different length and then the aligned mat was moulded into a composite. A diagram of the test facility is shown in Fig. 4.28. Figure 4.29 shows an image of the aligned mat and the results of the testing of the composites manufactured are given in Table 4.7. Predictions of the expected stiffness of the composites manufactured were made by modelling assuming that, at the fibre volume fraction achieved, all the fibres were perfectly aligned in one direction. These predictions were then compared with the stiffness measurements and it was found that tensile stiffnesses between 80 and 90% of the theoretical maximum had been achieved. It was also noted however, that at a moulding pressure of 5 bar a fibre volume fraction of only 14% was achieved, whereas a fibre volume
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites Containment Rotating drum with mesh screen
97
Carbon fibre slurry feed
50 cm 30 cm
Alignment box Convergent nozzle
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.28 Diagram of fibre alignment test rig (Jiang et al. 2006).
4.29 An image of the alignment of fibres in the mat produced in the fibre alignment test rig (Jiang et al. 2006).
fraction approaching 60% can be achieved with unidirectional prepreg at the same pressure. The image of the aligned mat in Fig. 4.29 shows that most of the fibres appear to be aligned, although a significant proportion are misaligned and it is apparent therefore that this misalignment has a bigger effect on fibre volume fraction than on tensile stiffness.
98
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Table 4.7 Flexural properties of aligned recycled carbon fibre/epoxy resin composites. The volume fraction of the carbon fibre was 14% Flexural strength (MPa)
Flexural modulus (GPa)
Fibre length (mm)
L
T
L
T
5 20 Continuous fibre (calculated)
361 ± 20 273 ± 31
142 ± 4.5 128 ± 17
26.7 ± 0.8 23.7 ± 1.0 29.5
9.3 ± 0.5 9.2 ± 0.8 3.5
4.5
Prospects for commercial operation
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
An assessment of the likely commercial viability of a recycling operation for glass fibre reinforced composites based on the fluidised bed process is described in Pickering et al. (2000). The assessment was carried out for plants sized to process from 1000 to 20 000 tonnes of scrap composites and the following were among the assumptions made: • • •
Scrap producers paid the avoided landfill price to send the material to the recycling plant. The plant was a stand alone operation, equipped with the gas clean-up necessary to process halogenated polymers. The recycled glass fibre would be sold at 80% of the price of virgin fibre.
The analysis showed that a plant would need to process in the region of 10 000 tonnes per year to break even and it was considered that there was not sufficient scrap available within easy transport distance to make a viable operation in the UK. The value of carbon fibre is typically at least ten times that of glass fibre and so it is likely that a plant recycling carbon fibre could break even at a significantly lower throughput. Hence, current research is focused on recycling carbon fibre composites.
4.6
Current research, future trends and sources of further information and advice
Current research is focusing on the recycling of carbon fibre composites since the higher value of carbon fibre makes a commercially viable recycling operation a more easily achievable goal. Further development of the fluidised bed process is taking place to identify the optimum processing conditions that can achieve high recycled fibre quality whilst maximising the throughput of carbon fibre.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
99
Of equal importance is research to develop the applications for recycled fibre. This is applicable not only to recycled fibre from the fluidised bed process but for recycled fibre from other composites recycling processes, many of which produce a fibre output that is best utilised as short individual fibre filaments. Applications for the recycled fibre processed directly in its raw form are limited; it has been shown that low fibre volume fraction moulding compounds can be made relatively easily, but, based on carbon fibre, these are new materials and new markets must be developed. Achieving fibre alignment is a key goal for two reasons: it will allow composites with high fibre volume to be manufactured from recycled carbon fibre giving high grade structural properties, and it will also allow recycled carbon fibre to be converted into prepreg materials for which there are existing markets and which is an easy to use and well-understood material. Developing fibre alignment processes is the subject of ongoing research led by the University of Nottingham (www.nottingham.ac.uk/afrecar). The aim is to achieve a degree of alignment that will allow high fibre volume fractions to be achieved in composites and to demonstrate applications in the automotive and aerospace industries. It is recognised that the fluidised bed process is limited in that there is no recovery of material from the polymer and research is currently in progress at the University of Nottingham to develop new recycling processes in which chemical products can be recovered from the polymer. Feasibility studies have already been carried out which demonstrate the potential of using supercritical fluids, and in particular supercritical propanol, as a means of recovering chemicals whilst also yielding very high quality recycled carbon fibre (Jiang et al. 2007, 2009). Research is currently in progress to develop this recycling process at a larger scale at the University of Nottingham (www.nottingham.ac.uk/afrecar). Other carbon fibre recycling activities As the market for carbon fibre increases, particularly for use in the aerospace industry, and as environmental concerns are increasing, the need for recycling, research and development into carbon fibre recycling is taking place in a number of places around the world. Key work is ongoing in three places and further information is available in the references and on the internet as described: •
Adherent Technologies Inc. in New Mexico, USA, have developed a tertiary process for recycling carbon fibre with recovery of chemical products from the polymer (Allred et al. 2002). www.adherenttech.com • Recycled Carbon Fibre Ltd in Birmingham, UK, are a company commercially developing carbon fibre recycling operations based on a proprietary pyrolysis process. www.recycledcarbonfibre.com
100 •
• •
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
Hadeg Recycling GmbH in Stade, near Hamburg in Germany, are involved in a range of different carbon fibre recycling activities including pyrolysis. www.hadeg-recycling.de Recycling operations are also being developed at CFK-Valley in Stade. www.cfk-valley.com Research in carbon fibre recycling is also being undertaken locally to Stade at the Technical University of Hamburg-Harburg (Schulte et al. 2007).
Whilst these activities are based on different recycling technologies the issues faced in using the recycled carbon fibre are broadly similar. The problems faced and potential applications for use of recycled carbon fibre described in Section 4.4 are not only applicable to the recycled carbon fibre from the fluidised bed process but more generally to the carbon fibre output from these and other recycling processes.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
4.7
References
allred r e, gosau j m and shoemaker j m (2002), ‘Recycling process for carbon/ epoxy composites’, Composites in Manufacturing, 18(2): May 13. bagg g e g, evans m e n, et al. (1969), ‘The glycerine process for the alignment of fibres and whiskers’, Composites, 1(2): 97–100. edwards h and evans n p (1980), ‘A method for the production of high quality aligned short fibre mats and their composites’, Economic Computation and Economic Cybernetics Studies and Research, 2: 1620–1635. george p e and carberry w l (2007), ‘Recycled carbon fibre performance in epoxy and polycarbonate matrices’, Composites Innovation Conference 2007 – Improved Sustainability and Environmental Performance, organised by NetComposites, Barcelona, Spain, 4–5 October. goodship v (2007), An Introduction to Plastics Recycling, 2nd edition, Smithers Rapra. jiang g, wong k h, pickering s j, rudd c d and walker g j (2005), ‘Study of a fluidised bed process for recycling carbon fibre from polymer composites’, Proceedings of 7th World Congress of Chemical Engineering, Glasgow, 10–14 July. jiang g, wong k h, pickering s j, walker g s and rudd c d (2006), ‘Alignment of recycled carbon fibre and its application as a reinforcement’, Proceedings of SAMPE Fall Technical Conference, Dallas, USA, 6–9 November. jiang g, pickering s j, lester e, blood p and warrior n (2007), ‘Recycling carbon fibre/epoxy resin composites using supercritical propanol’, 16th Intl Conference on Composite Materials, Kyoto, Japan, 8–13 July. jiang g, pickering s j, lester e h, turner t a, wong k h and warrior n a (2009), ‘Characterisation of carbon fibres recycled from carbon fibre/epoxy resin composites using supercritical n-propanol’, Composites Science and Technology 69: 192–198. Doi:10.1016/j.compscitech.2008.10.007 kennerley j r, kelly r m, fenwick n j, pickering s j and rudd c d (1998), ‘The characterisation and reuse of glass fibres recycled from scrap composites by the action of a fluidised bed’, Composites Part A, 29A: 839–845.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Thermal methods for recycling waste composites
101
kunii d and levenspiel o (1993), Fluidization Engineering, 2nd Edition, Butterworth-Heinemann. monk j f (1997), Thermosetting Plastics: Moulding Materials and Processes, 2nd Edition, Longman. pickering s j (2006), ‘Recycling technologies for thermoset composites – current status’, Composites: Part A, 37: 1206–1215. Doi: 10.1016/j.compositesa.2005. 05.030 pickering s j, kelly r m, kennerley j r, rudd c d and fenwick n j (2000), ‘A fluidised bed process for the recovery of glass fibres from scrap thermoset composites’, Composites Science and Technology, 60: 509–523. pickering s j, turner t a and warrior n a (2006), ‘Moulding compound development using recycled carbon fibres’, Proceedings of SAMPE Fall Technical Conference, Dallas, USA, 6–9 November. schulte k et al. (2007), ‘Optimisation of a pyrolysis process for recycling of CFRPs’, 16th Intl Conference on Composite Materials, Kyoto, Japan, 8–13 July. wong k h, jiang g z, pickering s j and rudd c d (2005), ‘Effects of fibre length and loading on electromagnetic shielding of thermoset composite reinforced with virgin or recovered carbon fibres’, 15th Intl Conference on Composite Materials, Durban, South Africa, 27 June to 1 July. wong k h, jiang g, pickering s j, rudd and walker g s (2006), ‘Characterisation of recycled carbon fibre: mechanical properties and surface chemistry’, Proceedings of SAMPE Fall Technical Conference, Dallas, USA, 6–9 November. wong k h, pickering s j and brooks r (2007a), ‘Recycled carbon fibre reinforced polypropylene composites: effect of coupling agents on mechanical properties’, Composites Innovation Conference 2007 – Improved Sustainability and Environmental Performance, organised by NetComposites, Barcelona, Spain, 4–5 October. wong k h, pickering s j, turner n a and warrior n a (2007b), ‘Preliminary feasibility study of reinforcing potential of recycled carbon fibre for flame-retardant grade epoxy composite’, Composites Innovation Conference 2007 – Improved Sustainability and Environmental Performance, organised by NetComposites, Barcelona, Spain, 4–5 October. yin y, binner j p b, cross t e and marshall s j (1994), ‘Oxidation behaviour of carbon fibres’, Journal of Materials Science, 29: 2250–2254. yip h l h, pickering s j and rudd c d (2002), ‘Characterisation of carbon fibre recycled from scrap composites using a fluidised bed process’, Plastics, Rubber and Composites, 31(6): 278–282. Doi: 10.1179/146580010225003047
5 Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites M. B L A Z S Ó, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
Abstract: Pyrolysis is a suitable process for recycling polymer composites because the thermal decomposition products of the polymer matrix evaporate, and thus the reinforcement materials can be recovered and reused. The products of pyrolysis carried out at an appropriate temperature are monomers and other valuable chemicals. This chapter describes the pyrolysis reactions and products of frequently used thermoplastics and thermosets in polymer composites. Published results on pyrolysis of various polymer composites are discussed in order to understand the requirements of successful plastic composite recycling by pyrolysis. The environmental concern related to pyrolysis of flame retardants containing polymer composites is also touched upon and some methods are referred to for decreasing or eliminating toxic and harmful compounds from the pyrolysis products of halogenated flame retardants. Key words: plastics composites, recycling of composite reinforcement, pyrolysis of polymer matrix.
5.1
Introduction
Thermal methods are successfully applied for waste elimination in general. Among them, combustion has been the most commonly used traditional method to reduce the quantity of discarded objects and garbage. However, in the twenty-first century, uncontrolled combustion is strictly banned worldwide because of environmental pollution from the harmful combustion products and carbon dioxide emissions. In up-to-date incineration plants solid wastes are effectively converted to energy and potential harmful products are trapped in various cleaning units and filters. Nevertheless, most of the value of recyclable materials is lost under combustion in incinerators, and an important part of the polymers used in composites is built not only from hydrocarbons but also from amides and nitriles emitting huge amounts of nitrogen oxides (NOx) in addition to carbon dioxide. Therefore pyrolysis is a more adequate thermal treatment technology for waste polymer matrix composites in which the material is heated in a low oxygen environment. Pyrolysis is a thermally initiated chemical process that generally decomposes the organic molecules to smaller ones in an inert atmosphere. The 102
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
103
term ‘pyrolysis’ is often misunderstood as meaning a high temperature reaction resulting only in gases and char, but it also means thermolysis of organic macromolecules in the temperature range from 250 to 800 °C resulting in gaseous, liquid and solid products. Above 800 °C carbonization of the organic material occurs, which is applied as a utilization technology mostly for biomass waste. Composites with polymer matrix material are produced for various applications and thus a range of different resins can be found in waste composites. The reinforcement part is typically inorganic material, fibres or ground substance. In special cases, polymer is used as the strengthener as well such as Kevlar. The pyrolysis process is a particularly good thermal recycling method for waste polymer composites because the matrix resin is decomposed to valuable feedstock or fine chemicals which evaporate, while the reinforcement is obtained as the solid residue. The preservation of the original quality of the latter is a crucial point of the pyrolytic recycling technology of polymer matrix composites, the main purpose of which is often the recycling of the valuable fibre or powder strengthener. The thermal decomposition of the polymer matrix of the composite should not differ from that of the polymer alone because matrix and reinforcement materials are separate and distinct on a macroscopic level within the composite. Obviously heat transport may be altered by an inorganic material of quite different heat conductivity from that of the polymer, resulting in differences in the heating rate and temperature gradient in the pyrolyser. Pyrolysis of the organic macromolecules is initiated by a primary intramolecular endothermic chemical reaction of the following types: 1. rearrangement of chemical bonds followed by elimination of small molecules, and/or separation of the macromolecule in two parts; 2. scission of chemical bonds followed by the stabilization of the unstable fragments. The temperature necessary for the initiation reaction depends on the activation energy of the chemical change (reactions of type 1 occur at around 300 °C, and of type 2 at above 500 °C). Initiation of the thermal decomposition may occur due to defect points of the polymer (structural error, oxidized moieties, etc.) that can reduce thermal stability of the polymer. In polymers of flexible macromolecular chain (thermoplastics) the unstable species formed by initiation are generally macroradicals which are either depolymerized in a free radical chain reaction, producing monomers and oligomers, or transferred to another macromolecule or to another part of the same macromolecule. In the case of radical transfer the polymeric radical is divided into two parts: a smaller
104
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
molecule and a smaller radical, and at the end of the radical chain reaction a series of product of broad volatility range is obtained. In network or cross-linked polymers (thermosets) both types of pyrolysis reaction require higher temperatures because of limited flexibility of the macromolecular segments. Catalysts may facilitate thermal decomposition of polymers by conducting the pyrolysis process through reactions requiring less energy. Thus catalytic pyrolysis generally lowers the optimal temperature of polymer decomposition, and at the same time the products could be different from those obtained without catalyst. Technically catalytic pyrolysis is carried out either in one step or in a coupled arrangement of a pyrolyser and a catalytic converter. Although thermal catalysis proved to be a successful option for utilizing waste polyethylene, this method is not often used for more complicated wastes such as composites.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
5.2
Pyrolysis reactions and products of thermoplastics
Polypropylene (PP) and polyamides (PA66, PA6, PA12, PA46) are the most used matrices for thermoplastic composites. Polyesters (polyethylene terephthalate (PET), polybutylene terephthalate (PBT), polyphenylene oxide (PPO)), polycarbonate (PC) and thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU) are also used as matrix material. These polymers liquefy on heating and freeze to a solid state when cooled; they can be remelted. The reinforcement is introduced under melting of the matrix material. Heat-resistant thermoplastics, such as polyetheretherketone (PEEK), polyether sulphone (PES), polyimide (PI), polyetherimide (PEI) and polyphenylene sulphide (PPS) furnish advanced properties to their composites. The basic thermal decomposition records of thermoplastic polymers applied frequently in polymer composites are shown in Table 5.1. The data have been collected from published works in which thermogravimetric measurements were performed in an inert atmosphere and at a heating rate of 10 °C/min.
5.2.1 Polypropylene PP starts to decompose at around 400 °C, when heated slowly (at a rate of 10 °C/min) in a thermogravimeter. The volatile formation is fastest at 470 °C and the total mass of the polymer is volatilized by 500 °C. This means that no solid residue is left after pyrolysis of PP, hence pyrolysis is a promising method for recycling either fibreglass or mineral reinforced PP composites. The surface of glass fibres or other strengtheners is cleaned by the pyrolysis process, which occurs at moderate temperature and does not seriously
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
105
Table 5.1 Thermal decomposition data published on some thermoplastics applied as polymer matrix in composites. Data are taken from thermogravimetric measurements in an inert atmosphere, generally at 10 °C/min heating rate
Thermoplast
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
PP PA6 PA66 PA12 PET PBT TPU PPO PES PEEK PPS PC Kevlar
Decomposition range (°C) 400–500 370–490 390–490 390–500 360–490 340–470 250–400
550–640 450–700 420–600 520–800
Mass loss rate (DTG) max. (°C)
Residual mass (wt %)
470 461 454 465 429 405 330 550 570 590 600 520 600
0 0 0 1 11 3 5 54 48 55 22 34
Reference Czégény et al. (2002) Czégény et al. (2002) Bozi et al. (2008) Czégény et al. (2002) Jakab et al. (2005) Balabanovich (2004) Font et al. (2001) Montaudo et al. (1994a) Montaudo et al. (1994a) Day et al. (1990) Montaudo et al. (1994b) Bozi et al. (2007) Czégény et al. (2002)
influence the original quality of the fibre. In this way pyrolysis may compete with other fibreglass recycling methods (Cunliffe et al., 2003). We may expect that the chemical process of PP thermal decomposition is not altered in the presence of the strengthener if it is sufficiently inert in the pyrolysis processes. Glass is a generally used vessel material in moderate temperature thermal studies of organic substances. Carbon has been observed to have a significant influence on PP decomposition only when the studied carbon black contained non-negligible amounts of functional groups and organic compounds (Jakab and Omastová, 2005). The volatilized pyrolysis products of PP are propylene oligomers produced through a series of free radical chain reactions. The pyrolysis conditions (heating rate, pyrolysis temperature, residence time of the evolved products) influence the product distribution, which is generally composed of some light hydrocarbon gases, a major part of gasoline volatility liquids (including propylene trimer, 2,4-dimethylheptene; tetramer, 2,4,6-trimethyldecene; and pentamer, 2,4,6,8-tetramethyltridecene) and an important amount of higher oligomers of lower volatility. From the point of view of recycling of the whole composite the formula with PP matrix and strong PP fibre strengthener is exceptionally beneficial, resulting in the same pyrolysis products from matrix and strengtheners. Catalytic thermal decomposition of PP may lead to more valuable products of narrower volatility range and of higher storage stability (Ali et al., 2002); however, the separation of the catalyst from the recycled
106
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
strengthener or a tar-like deposit on the surfaces often observed in catalytic processes of hydrocarbons should be taken into account. The use of AlCl3 as catalyst mixed with the polymer in a batch reactor or in a fluidized bed reduces the process temperature dramatically (Kaminsky and Nuñez Zorriqueta, 2007). The use of a small amount of AlCl3 (0.1%) produces products at 400 °C similar to those obtained at 500 °C in a non-catalytic process from PP, but it is possible to pyrolyse PP at 300 °C when the amount of catalyst is higher. The increase of the amounts of catalyst then leads to an increase of light oil fraction (
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
5.2.2 Polyamides The generally observed thermal decomposition reaction of aliphatic polyamide (PA) is the scission of amide groups through cis elimination (Blazsó, 2006), resulting in smaller molecules composed of the aliphatic segment of the polyamide (of 4, 6 and 12 carbon atoms in PA46, PA66 and PA12, respectively) terminated by vinyl, amino or nitrile groups. Exceptionally, from PA6 nearly exclusively its cyclic monomer, ε-caprolactame, is formed by pyrolysis through rearrangement of two neighbouring amide groups along the macromolecular chain. From other aliphatic polyamides, cyclic diamides and lower volatility compounds involving amide groups are also formed; thus the various nitrogen-containing pyrolysis products are distributed over a rather wide volatility range. In this way it is not easy to find utilization of PA pyrolysis products. A promising perspective is that of the catalytic modification of pyrolysis products: for instance Bozi et al. (2008) demonstrated that protonic Y zeolite denitrogenates the pyrolysis oil components of PA66 and transforms the hydrocarbon part of their molecules into aromatic compounds. In aromatic polyamide macromolecular chain (aramide) the amide linkages are attached directly to two aromatic rings, either at 1,4 (Kevlar) or 1,3 positions (Nomex). Decomposition of aramide occurs simultaneously with melting at above 500 °C, thus it could not be used as a polymer matrix in composites. But as it is a fibre-forming polymer of excellent high tensile strength, it is often used as reinforcement. Aramide’s value is closely related also to high thermal stability and fire resistance: it can easily survive high temperatures without damage for short periods of time. However, aramide fibre may lose its original exceptional quality under extended heat treatment.
5.2.3 Terephthalic polyesters Polyester thermal decomposition is assisted by a six atom rearrangement of the carboxylic ester linkage and the carbon atoms of the alcohol that
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
107
leads to pyrolysis products with carboxyl and vinyl group. The vapour of terephthalic acid is condensed as a solid material that should be taken into consideration in pyrolysis technology of plastic wastes containing terephthalic polyesters. At above 300 °C carboxylic acids are generally decarboxylated evolving carbon dioxide. Consequently the main component of the gaseous pyrolysis products of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) between 380 and 450 °C is carbon dioxide, and the compounds of the pyrolysis liquid are terephthalic and benzoic acid vinyl esters. A non-negligible amount of char (about 10 wt%) is also formed. The thermal decomposition reactions in polybutylene terephthalate (PBT) are similar to those in PET, but PBT pyrolysis takes place at a lower temperature (Kelsey et al., 2005). Moreover, less benzoic acid ester and more acidic compounds are obtained because of the easy cleavage of ester groups producing butadiene. The consequence of butadiene evolution should be that the pyrolysis residue of PBT is negligible, because phenylene fragments of phthalic acid decarboxylation can be stabilized by the hydrogen atoms from the butylene moieties, resulting in volatile compounds (benzene and biphenyl), instead of forming a solid char. In this way from the point of view of strengthener recycling by pyrolysis, PBT is a more suitable matrix in polymer composites than PET.
5.2.4 Polycarbonate In polycarbonate the carbonate groups are attacked first by pyrolysis. Generally bisphenol A moieties are joined by carbonate in the polymer chain and the oxygen atoms are firmly bonded to the phenol ring. The thermal scission occurs at the carbonyl group, and accordingly, the main volatile products of polycarbonate are carbon oxides and bisphenol A at around 500 °C. At higher temperatures phenol and isopropenylphenol are also formed as the dimethylmethylidene segment is cut off the aromatic ring by the scission of the bond between an aromatic and an aliphatic carbon atom. Polycarbonate pyrolysis residue is roughly 20 wt%; the char formation is the result of a lack of enough hydrogen atoms in this aromatic polymer, preventing the coupling of the aromatic radicals during pyrolysis.
5.2.5 Polyphenylether, polyethersulphone, polyetheretherketone and polyphenylenesulphide Experimental observations proved that the main thermal decomposition product of aromatic polyethers is phenol, while ketone and sulphone chain segments eliminate carbon monoxide and sulphur dioxide, respectively (Montaudo et al., 1994a; Perng et al., 1999; Samperi et al., 2007). Some benzophenone and bis(phenoxy)benzophenone also evolves from PEEK,
108
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
indicating that the carbonyl group is eliminated only partially (Day et al., 1990). PPS undergoes cyclization, branching and cross-linking through the formation of aromatic thiols when heated to temperatures exceeding 300 °C (Halasa, 1999). Above 600 °C sulphur is extruded from the carbonaceous residue of PPS (Montaudo et al., 1994b). The solid residue of pyrolysis is a rather important part of these aromatic polymers because hydrogen abstraction by the small thermal fragment radicals results in a carbonized network structure of low H/C atomic ratio.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
5.2.6 Thermoplastic polyurethane Lattimer et al. (1998) observed that the thermal decomposition of polyurethane composed of aliphatic polyester soft segments starts first with dissociation of the urethane linkage to form products with isocyanato and hydroxyl end groups. The ester chain segments produce cyclic oligomers. In polyether-based urethane similar decomposition of urethane linkages to isocyanate and alcohol was a primary degradation pathway, taking place about 250 °C (Lattimer and Williams, 2002). For both polymers, intramolecular exchange to produce cyclic, low molecular weight urethanecontaining oligomers was observed. The recovery of the diisocyanate from polyurethane by pyrolysis is strongly influenced by the pyrolysis conditions. In analytical pyrolysers of fast heating rate and short residence time, diisocyanate has been found to be a major pyrolysis product of various polyurethanes by Ohtani et al. (1987), while this reactive product may disappear from the pyrolysate because of the secondary reactions in a larger-scale reactor heated at a lower rate. Polyurethane studied by Font et al. (2001) decomposed in a thermogravimeter in the range 250–400 °C, with maximal weight loss rate at 330 °C leaving no more than 5 wt% residues. A varnish based on the same TPU decomposed similarly up to 450 °C at which temperature a second step of decomposition was observed. The complex pyrolysis process of polyurethane foam was also reported by Dick et al. (2001). The thermogravimetric mass loss curve of the foam studied shows more than one step of fast volatilization in the temperature range from 250 to 550 °C and no residue is left above 550 °C.
5.2.7 Polyimide and polyetherimide These polymers are synthesized in the presence of strengtheners in composites because they do not melt as thermoplasts but should not be cured as thermosets. The cleavage of imide ring in PI occurs at 500 °C and the rate of pyrolysis is the fastest around 580 °C (Hatori et al., 1996). Carbonization is a slow process losing hydrogen atoms first then nitrogen as well, continuing over 1200 °C with 52 wt% residue left. Aromatic
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
109
hydroxyl, amino and nitrile compounds are the most important volatile products of PI pyrolysis. Owing to the lower stability of the polyether segment in PEI this polymer starts to decompose at a lower temperature than polyimide and the fastest rate is also lower (Guo et al., 2007). At 800 °C 50 wt% residue was observed but the carbonization had not terminated.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
5.3
Pyrolysis reactions and products of thermosets
Polyesters, vinyl esters, phenolic, epoxy, melamine and silicon resins are the standard matrix materials of thermoset composites. These composites are produced by curing the prepolymer mixed with the reinforcement because the thermosetting polymers do not melt after the network structure has been developed. The thermal decomposition of a macromolecular network generally occurs at a higher temperature than that of a chain polymer of similar composition for at least two major reasons. The movement of the segments within a three-dimensional network is restricted, so decomposition reactions going through bonding rearrangement of neighbouring parts of the macromolecule cannot take place as easily as in a chain polymer. In other cases when the thermal decomposition takes place by radical scission, a much faster initiation reaction is required in a network for the effective formation of fragment molecules by radical chain reaction than in a linear polymer chain because of the high probability of termination of the radical decomposition process by recombination of the radicals that are not able to escape from the cage of the network structure from which they originated.
5.3.1 Unsaturated polyester and vinyl ester resins Thermoset polyesters applied in composites are made of the unsaturatedtype polyester macromolecules that are capable of being cured. Curing occurs through coupling pairs of reactive carbon–carbon double bonds with the help of a hardener (i.e. a reactive monomer, such as styrene). Catalyst and accelerator are usually added to accelerate the curing process. The cross-link density of the three-dimensional network formed by curing is determined by the frequency of the unsaturated groups in the polyester macromolecular chain. Ortho- and isophthalic acids are predominantly the dicarboxylic acid constituent of thermoset polyesters, with butane- and butenediol alcoholic components. In vinyl esters the reactive groups are at the ends of the polyester macromolecular chain, thus fewer cross-links are formed by curing. Typical polyester thermosets of composites have been subjected to pyrolysis at 600 °C by Evans et al. (2000) and the volatile products were identified
110
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
by pyrolysis-GC/MS (gas chromatography/mass spectroscopy). Most chemical compounds could be related directly to the diacid and diol building units of the polyester and to the styrene cross-links.
5.3.2 Epoxy resin
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
In the macromolecule of epoxy resins the ether bonding between aromatic and aliphatic carbons is cleaved at the earliest stage of thermal decomposition, producing volatile compounds between 300 and 400 °C and releasing bisphenol A, irrespective of the nature of the hardener. At above 600 °C the bisphenol segment is also detached at the isopropylidene group, resulting in phenol and methyl-, ethyl- and isopropenylphenol pyrolysis products. Epoxy resins do not leave noteworthy solid residues following pyrolysis. In composites constructed for application in electric and electronic devices epoxy resins are flame retarded partly replacing bisphenol A by tetrabromobisphenol A. Among the pyrolysis products of such composites are small amounts of bromo-, dibromo-, tribromo- and tetrabromobisphenol A; moreover bromo- and dibromophenols are present (Blazsó, 2006).
5.3.3 Phenolic resin Methylene groups join phenolic rings similarly along the polymer chain and at the cross-links in the cured network of phenolic resins. During thermal decomposition radical scission occurs at the methylene bridges and the stabilization of the radicals proceeds through hydrogen abstraction. Relatively small amounts of volatile compounds can be formed from this resin of low H/C atomic ratio; accordingly the solid residue of pyrolysis is as large as 30–50 wt% (Horikawa et al., 2003). Phenol and cresol isomers are the main products of pyrolysis evolved between 450 and 620 °C (Blazsó, 2006). From a linear phenol–formaldehyde chain polymer (Novolak) dimeric products of thermal decomposition are also formed, namely isomers of methylenebis(methylphenol) and their methyl and dimethyl derivatives (Blazsó and Tóth, 1991; Sobera and Hetper, 2003).
5.4
Pyrolyser reactors for polymer recycling
Thermal decomposition reactions may be carried out in different types of reactor in an inert atmosphere. The reactor chosen should conform to the special requirements of polymer composite recycling, as pyrolysis conditions are limited by the type of pyrolyser. Pyrolyser reactor types utilized worldwide in waste plastics recycling systems are comprehensively described in an overview by Scheirs (2006).
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
111
5.4.1 Fixed bed reactor Plastic waste is first converted to the molten phase in the reaction vessel purged continuously with an inert gas, then heated slowly to the pyrolysis temperature. Soaking is prolonged after the final temperature is reached until no more pyrolysis vapours are evolved. The molten plastic may be stirred to prevent hot-spots. It is essential to remove the carbonaceous char and other solid residue from the pyrolysis chamber to prevent the formation of a thermal insulator layer on the walls that would lower the heat transfer to the plastic in the next batch.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
5.4.2 Rotary kiln The waste plastics introduced in the rotary kiln furnace are conveyed through the reactor by the rotation and incline of the reaction chamber. The rotary motion also homogenizes the mixture, which is necessary for obtaining a uniform temperature. In this continuous feed furnace plastics are heated relatively slowly to the temperature of the kiln depending on the heat conductivity of the waste. Rotary kilns have a long retention time (of one hour or longer). The residue of pyrolysis is burned in a combustion chamber, which is installed at the end of the rotary kiln. Flue gas can be suitably used as fuel for heating the furnace.
5.4.3 Screw pyrolyser In the horizontal furnace a screw conveyer works at an adjustable speed to obtain the required retention time of the waste plastics to reach completed pyrolysis. Coke is removed during operation; nevertheless, the heat transfer is slow in this pyrolyser. In the Haloclean pyrolyser (Hornung et al., 2003), specially designed for recycling plastics from electronic scrap, different heating zones are independently controlled.
5.4.4 Fluidized bed reactor An excellent heat and mass transfer is the main advantage of this reactor that is utilized mostly for incineration. A constant temperature throughout the reactor is an additional reason for applying fluidized bed for pyrolysis of polymers. For pyrolysis of plastic waste an inert fluidizing gas and sand or quartz sand bed is applied and continuous polymer waste feed and continuous coke removal is possible. Catalytic pyrolysis can be performed as well using a solid catalyst as bed material (Ali et al., 2002); moreover, steam can be also used as fluidizing gas (Kaminsky and Hartmann, 2000).
112
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
5.5
Pyrolysis of polymer composites
The most important factor in pyrolysis technologies is the ability to recycle both polymer matrix and reinforcement of composites; however, the optimal pyrolysis conditions for obtaining a high quality of both kinds of recycled materials may be contradictory. This setback can be critical for a polymer matrix that generates solid pyrolysis residue on one hand, and for a thermally vulnerable strengthener on the other hand. Pyrolysis as a recycling option of polymer composites is still at the stage of rapid development, and industrial scale applications will be available only in the future. Pyrolysis reactors are mostly modelled in laboratory equipment or in pilot plant for the time being in order to aid understanding of the principal factors controlling the processes and for finding the optimal parameters to obtain recycled products of required quality and quantity at the same time.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
5.5.1 Fibreglass reinforced thermoset composites Fibreglass and orthophthalic polyester composite cured with styrene has been pyrolysed in a laboratory stainless steel autoclave at five temperatures between 300 and 700 °C for 30 min by Torres et al. (2000). The composite contained 50 wt% calcium carbonate filler as well. The weight of the pyrolysis liquid and gas obtained was nearly equal to the weight of the pyrolysed thermoset polyester material. The recovered glass fibre was covered by a black layer, the total amount of which was about 3 wt%. The aromatic character of the organic pyrolysis liquid corresponded to the polymer constituents of the composite. Over 90 wt% of the gas products – as expected from aromatic polyester – were carbon oxides. Cunliffe and Williams (2003) carried out similar laboratory experiments in a fixed bed reactor pyrolysing automotive waste polyester composite at 450 °C. In addition to the pyrolysis oil and gas, a considerable amount of organic solid material was obtained, which proved to be phthalic acid anhydride, the main pyrolysis product of orthophthalic acid ester. In the pyrolysis oil the styrene content was relatively high. In the solid residue the contribution of char was as much as 26 wt%. The glass fibre was cleaned after pyrolysis via oxidation of the carbon deposit and separated from the filler sieving the recovered solid residue. The glass fibres have successfully been reused in polyester composites. A series of fibre-reinforced polymeric waste have been investigated by Cunliffe et al. (2003) performing thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and bench-scale pyrolysis experiments. The pyrolysis of the various polymer matrices was generally a single stage process between 250 and 500 °C. The maximal rate of thermal decomposition of unsaturated
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
113
polyester, vinylester, phenolic and epoxy resin thermoset matrices was found at around 400 °C. However, composites with phenolic and epoxy resin matrices continued to lose mass steadily after polymer decomposition had ended. This decomposition between 600 and 800 °C was related to carbonization of the remaining solids. The mass loss rate (DTG) maximum obtained for glass fibre reinforced polypropylene in this work was at 470 °C, matching the temperature obtained for polypropylene alone by Czégény et al. (2002) seen in Table 5.1, demonstrating that glass fibre does not influence polymer decomposition. The results of TGA measurements were compared with those from a static-bed reactor and it was concluded that the findings derived from the TGA were applicable to the larger reactor system.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
5.5.2 Epoxy resin/carbon fibre composites Jiang et al. (2007) compared the thermal and thermo oxidative decomposition of an epoxy resin/carbon fibre composite using thermogravimetry. The weight loss due to volatilization of thermal decomposition products from the epoxy resin occurred from 300 to 460 °C with a maximum at 420 °C both in argon and in air. A further two additional weight loss steps were observed in air only: the first started at 460 °C and ended at 580 °C, corresponding to a mass loss of 15%, and the last one between 600 and 750 °C agreed with the mass ratio of the carbon fibre (58%). Both related reactions were oxidation as proved by the simultaneous plot of the molecular ion curve of carbon dioxide evolution recorded by mass spectrometry. The first reaction was attributed to the oxidation of the char left on the fibre surface after epoxy pyrolysis. Carbon fibre with epoxy resin matrix has been heated in a microwave cavity in nitrogen atmosphere by Lester et al. (2004). The polymer content was volatilized nearly totally; however, the products condensed in the immediate environment around the heated composite material. The carbon fibres recovered were better cleaned and retained better strength than those recovered after fluidized bed combustion.
5.5.3 Nanocomposites The increased interest in research and development of polymer nanocomposites will undoubtedly soon raise the problem of recycling both polymer matrix and nanoparticulates of high value of these composites. Carbon nanotubes appear to offer potential for new application of polymer composites that could be not only a mechanically reinforced material but also a conductive and flame retardant one. The thermal characterization data
114
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
on polymer composites with carbon nanotube indicate that – in contrast to conventional composite strengtheners – particles of a dimension of less than 100 nm are not always inert in pyrolysis reactions. Nanoparticles were found to cause a shift of the starting decomposition temperature of isotactic polypropylene (iPP) to 50 °C higher at carbon nanotube content of 5 wt%. The stabilization effect of carbon nanoparticles were explained by a barrier effect, which hindered the diffusion of the degradation products from the bulk of the polymer to the gas phase (Vassiliou et al., 2008). Flame retardant activity of polyamide 6 nanocomposite with multiwall carbon nanotube has been observed but nanoparticles merely acted as inert filler with respect to thermal decomposition in this case (Schartel et al., 2005). The same research group investigated the thermal decomposition of polycarbonate nanocomposite with similar carbon particles and observed a decrease of thermal stability by 100 °C with 15 wt% nanoparticles (Schartel et al., 2008).
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
5.5.4 Catalytic pyrolysis of composites A catalytic conversion process proved to be effective for recycling plastics and composites used in automotive and aerospace parts (Allred and Busselle, 2000). A variety of polymers and composites are converted into low molecular weight hydrocarbons at temperatures near 300 °C that can then be reused as chemicals, fuels or monomers. Metal, glass, fillers and fibres are separated from the hydrocarbons during the process and can be reclaimed for reuse. After catalytic pyrolysis of carbon/epoxy composites only 0.2% residual resin was left on the recovered carbon fibre showing a reduction of tensile strength of 9% (Allred et al., 2001). Research studies of catalytic modification of PP and polyamide pyrolysate are mentioned above (Bozi et al., 2008). Catalytic pyrolysis can be performed in a fluidized bed pyrolysis reactor as well using a solid catalyst as bed material (Ali et al., 2002). Catalysts are applicable also for eliminating polluting components of electronic and electric equipment waste pyrolysis product: for instance a diminished formation of bromoaromatic compounds takes place in pyrolysis with sodium-zeolites (Blazsó, 2005).
5.6
Pyrolysis conditions for polymer composites recycling
In order to decompose completely the polymer matrix and obtain a cleaned strengthener material at the same time, the pyrolysis temperature is essential, as are also the time of heating up and the residence time of the volatile
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
115
pyrolysis products in the hot reactor. Intramolecular reactions within the solid plastic are favoured by a slow heating rate. In some cases this can result in network formation that is carbonized at higher temperatures and char is formed. Fast evaporation of volatile pyrolysis products at a high heating rate and simultaneous sweeping of gaseous phase inhibit the recondensation of reactive compounds that would also lead to char formation. Consequently a high heating rate to the temperature necessary for the fast decomposition of the polymer matrix and short residence time of the evolved pyrolysis product in the reaction zone are recommended. Although pyrolysis reactions occur first in thermal treatments of solids performed in any atmosphere, further reactions take place in a reactive atmosphere. In air the valuable pyrolysis products of polymer composites are burned and only the heating energy can be recuperated while the reinforcement becomes free of char (Pickering et al., 2000). It was found that low combustion temperatures are necessary in order to maximize residual strength of fibres. A successful elimination of the polymer char from the surface of composite strengtheners can be performed by introducing air in the pyrolyser after the volatile pyrolysis products of the polymer matrix have been already flushed out of the furnace (Pickering, 2006). An atmosphere of reduced pressure also helps a cleaner recovery of filler or strengtheners from polymer composite waste. Under vacuum the diffusion of the product molecules from the decomposing solid phase is enhanced, and moreover the products are fast eliminated from the reaction zone. Roy et al. (1999) successfully cleaned the carbon black of waste tyre and obtained a pyrolysis oil rich in isoprene and limonene in a vacuum pyrolysis reactor. Introduction of steam in the reaction zone of the pyrolyser unit involves a reaction of water with the primary pyrolysis products and also contributes to the fast decomposition of the polymer matrix. In several cases steamassisted pyrolysis has led to more valuable products than pyrolysis in an inert atmosphere (Simon et al., 1996).
5.7
Environmental concern about pyrolysis products of composites
Polymer composites used in electronic and electric equipment generally contain flame retarding additive that may influence their recycling possibilities. In addition to the modification of pyrolysis temperature a more serious probable change, namely char formation, should be taken into consideration in the case of intumescent flame retardants. From environmental aspects halogenated flame retardant additives should be
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
116
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
examined as possible source of harmful pyrolysis or combustion products when thermal recycling of the polymer matrix is considered. Several studies have been carried out in order to understand the evolution of toxic compounds from flame retarded polymers and to develop methods reducing that risk. Waste plastics collected from a waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE) processing plant has been pyrolysed in a fixed bed pyrolyser heated gradually to 600 °C by Hall and Williams (2007). Chlorinated and brominated organic compounds have been detected in the pyrolysis oil while some hydrogen halogenide was present in the gas. The solid residue was high in both metal and halogen content. An epoxy matrix of a printed circuit board emitted polybrominated dibenzodioxins and dibenzofurans under pyrolysis and combustion as well (Moltó et al., 2008). The source of these toxic compounds was the bromo- and dibromophenols present in significant amounts among the pyrolysis products of the waste board flame retarded with tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBA) segment of epoxy resin. TBBA flame retardant component of polycarbonate decomposed differently from the TBBA units of epoxy, leading to products of higher bromination level at 550 °C (Bozi et al., 2007). A considerable amount of bromo-, dibromo- and tribromobisphenol A was formed at 450 °C pyrolysis from an epoxy resin with woven glass fibre strengthener flame retarded with brominated epoxy units (Blazsó et al., 2002). When this printed circuit board material was pyrolysed with sodium hydroxide, an enhanced bromomethane evolved, and a depressed brominated phenol and bisphenol formation was observed. A diminished production of bromophenols took place in pyrolysis with sodium-zeolites as well. Hornung et al. (2003) reported debromination of pyrolysis oil of electronic waste plastics with the polypropylene as a reductive agent. The level of bromophenol contamination was suppressed to an acceptable level and hydrogen bromide evolved. Braun and Schartel (2008) observed char formation in a glass-fibre reinforced PBT, although the phosphorous flame retardants influenced the decomposition of PBT only slightly.
5.8
Summarizing comments on recycling polymer composites by pyrolysis
From the viewpoint of pyrolysis the differences of thermoplastic and thermoset composites are not as distinctive as from that of material reutilization. The thermoset composites which cannot be reused directly can be
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
117
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
Table 5.2 Typical practical characteristics of polymer matrices and of their pyrolysis products
Polymer
Atomic ratio H/C
Pyrolysis (°C)
Char (%)
Character of liquid
TPU Polyester Epoxy PBT PET PA6 PA12 PP PC Phenolics PPO PEEK
1.6 0.9 1.1 1.0 0.8 1.8 1.9 2.0 0.9 1.0 0.7 0.6
300–370 370–460 370–460 370–430 400–460 430–490 440–490 450–500 480–570 450–580 520–580 560–620
5 26 15 3 11 0 0 0 22 30–50 54 55
Aliphatic ester/aromatic Aromatic Alkylphenol Aromatic acid/aliphatic Aromatic ester Aliphatic Aliphatic Aliphatic Alkylphenol Methylphenol Phenol Phenol
easily recycled in to feedstock compounds by pyrolysis in several cases. Since the thermal decomposition reactions and the nature of their products is strictly related to the polymer chemical composition and structure (as it was demonstrated in sections 5.2 and 5.3), the physical characteristics such as melting ability is of marginal importance from the aspect of pyrolytic recyclability. Pyrolysis temperature should be chosen to be high enough for fast decomposition of the given polymer but not too high for avoiding aromatization and carbonization. Char formation is related to the amount of available hydrogen atoms for stabilizing radicals formed by bond scissions in the pyrolysis reactions. Thus the molar ratio of H and C atoms in the macromolecule of polymer matrix is indicative of char-forming ability, namely considerable char formation takes place below H/C value of unity, meaning that the polymer is dominated by aromatic structures. In Table 5.2 the optimal temperature range of pyrolysis for obtaining valuable pyrolysis products from frequent polymer matrix of composites is indicated. The H/C atomic ratio of a given polymer together with the dominating nature of the pyrolysis products could be a basis of predicting the formation of char, as demonstrated by the char deposition ratios in Table 5.2.
5.9
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Hungarian National Research Fund (OTKA) contract no. K68752.
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
118
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
5.10
References
ali s, garforth a a, harris d h, rawlence d j, uemichi y (2002), ‘Polymer waste recycling over used catalysts’, Catal Today, 75, 247–255. doi: 10.1016/ S0920-5861(02)00076-7 allred r e, busselle l d (2000), ‘Tertiary recycling of automotive plastics and composites’, J Thermoplast Compos Mater, 13, 92–101 allred r e, gosau j m, shoemaker j m (2001), ‘Recycling process for carbon/epoxy composites’ in: 46th International SAMPE Symposium, 2001 balabanovich a i (2004), ‘Poly(butylene terephthalate) fire retarded by bisphenol A bis(diphenyl phosphate)’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 72, 229–233. doi: 10.1016/j. jaap.2004.07.001 blazsó m (2005), ‘In situ modification of pyrolysis products of macromolecules in an analytical pyrolyser’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 74, 344–352. doi: 10.1016/ j.jaap.2004.11.034 blazsó m (2006), ‘Composition of liquid fuels derived from the pyrolysis of plastics’ in Scheirs J, Kaminsky W (Editors) Feedstock Recycling and Pyrolysis of Waste Plastics, Wiley, Chichester, pp. 315–344 blazsó m, tóth t (1991), ‘Sequence of phenolic units in phenol–formaldehyde polycondensates studied by pyrolysis–gas chromatography/mass spectrometry’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 19, 251–263. doi: 10.1016/0165-2370(91)80047-C blazsó m, czégény z, csoma c (2002), ‘Pyrolysis and debromination of flame retarded polymers of electronic scrap studied by analytical pyrolysis’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 64, 249–261. doi: 10.1016/S0165-2370(02)00035-9 bozi j, czégény z, blazsó m, mészáros e (2007), ‘Thermal decomposition of flame retarded polycarbonates’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 79, 337–345. doi: 10.1016/ j.jaap.2007.01.001 bozi j, czégény z, blazsó m (2008), ‘Conversion of the volatile thermal decomposition products of polyamide-6,6 and ABS over Y zeolites’, Thermochim Acta, 472, 84–94. doi: 10.1016/j.tca.2008.03.018 braun u, schartel b (2008), ‘Flame retardancy mechanisms of aluminium phosphinate in combination with melamine cyanurate in glass-fibre-reinforced poly (1,4-butylene terephthalate)’, Macromol Mater Eng, 293, 206–217. doi: 10.1002/ mame.200700330 cunliffe a m, williams p t (2003), ‘Characterisation of products from the recycling of glass fibre reinforced polyester waste by pyrolysis’, Fuel, 82, 2223–2230. doi: 10.1016/S0016-2361(03)00129-7 cunliffe a m, jones n, williams p t (2003), ‘Recycling of fibre-reinforced polymeric waste by pyrolysis: thermo-gravimetric and bench-scale investigations’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 70, 315–338. doi: 10.1016/S0165-2370(02)00161-4 czégény z, jakab e, blazsó m (2002), ‘Thermal decomposition of polymer mixtures containing poly(vinyl chloride)’, Macromol Mater Eng, 287, 277–284. doi: 10.1002/1439-2054(20020401)287 day m, cooney j d, wiles d m (1990), ‘The thermal degradation of poly (aryl-ether-ether-ketone) (PEEK) as monitored by pyrolysis-GC/MS and TG/MS’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 18, 163–173. doi: 10.1016/0165-2370(90) 80005-9 dick c, dominguez-rosado e, eling b, liggat j j, lindsay c i, martin s c, mohammed m h, seeley g, snape c e (2001), ‘The flammability of urethane-modified polyiso-
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
119
cyanurates and its relationship to thermal degradation chemistry’, Polymer, 42, 913–923. doi: 10.1016/S0032-3861(00)00470-5 evans s j, haines p j, skinner g a (2000), ‘Pyrolysis-gas-chromatographic study of a series of polyester thermosets’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 55, 13–28. doi: 10.1016/ S0165-2370(99)00064-9 font r, fullana a, caballero j a, candela j, garcia a (2001), ‘Pyrolysis study of polyurethane’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 58–59, 63–77. doi: 10.1016/S0165-2370 (00)00138-8 guo w, chuang t-h, huang s-t, leu w-t, hsiao s-h (2007), ‘Thermal degradation behaviour of aromatic poly(ester–imide) investigated by pyrolysis–GC/MS’, J Polym Res, 14, 401–409. doi: 10.1007/S10965-007-9123-9 halasa e (1999), ‘Poly(phenylene sulfide). Part I. Preparation and properties’, Polimery, 44, 79–86 hall w j, williams p t (2007), ‘Analysis of products from the pyrolysis of plastics recovered from the commercial scale recycling of waste electrical and electronic equipment’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 79, 375–386. doi: 10.1016/j.jaap.2006.10.006 hatori h, yamada, y shiraishi m, yoshihara m, kimura t (1996) ‘The mechanism of polyimide pyrolysis in the early stage’, Carbon, 34, 201–208. doi: 10.1016/00086223(96)00189-3 horikawa t, ogawa k, mizuno k, hayashi j, muroyama k (2003), ‘Preparation and characterization of the carbonized material of phenol–formaldehyde resin with addition of various organic substances’, Carbon, 41, 465–472. doi: 10.1016/ S0008-6223(02)00352-4 hornung a, balabanovich a i, donner s, seifert h (2003), ‘Detoxification of brominated pyrolysis oils’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 70, 723–733. doi: 10.1016/ S0165-2370(03)00049-4 jakab e, omastová m (2005), ‘Thermal decomposition of polyolefin/carbon black composites’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 74, 204–214. doi: 10.1016/j.jaap.2005.02.001 jakab e, bhaskar t, sakata y (2005), ‘Pyrolysis of halogen-containing polymer mixtures’ in Müller-Hagedorn M, Bockhorn H (Editors), Feedstock Recycling of Plastics, Universitätsverlag Karlsruhe, pp. 163–168 jiang g, pickering s j, walker g s, bowering n, wong k h, rudd c d (2007), ‘Soft ionisation analysis of evolved gas for oxidative decomposition of an epoxy resin/carbon fibre composite’, Thermochim Acta, 454, 109–115. doi: 10.1016/ j.tca.2007.01.003 kaminsky w, hartmann f (2000), ‘New pathways in plastics recycling’, Angew Chem Int Ed, 39, 331–333 kaminsky w, nuo˜ez zorriqueta i-j (2007), ‘Catalytical and thermal pyrolysis of polyolefins’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis 79, 368–374. doi: 10.1016/j.jaap.2006.11.005 kelsey d r, kiibler k s, tutunjian p n (2005), ‘Thermal stability of poly(trimethylene terephthalate’, Polymer, 46, 8937–8946. doi: 10.1016/j.polymer.2005.07.015 lattimer r p, williams r c (2002), ‘Low-temperature pyrolysis products from a polyether-based urethane’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 63, 85–104. doi: 10.1016/ S0165-2370(01)00143-7 lattimer r p, polce m j, wesdemiotis c (1998), ‘MALDI-MS analysis of pyrolysis products from a segmented polyurethane’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 48, 1–15. doi: 10.1016/S0165-2370(98)00092-8 lester e, kingman s, wong k h, rudd c, pickering s, hilal n (2004), ‘Microwave heating as a means for carbon fibre recovery from polymer composites: a
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
120
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
technical feasibility study’, Mater Res Bull, 39, 1549–1556. doi: 10.1016/j. materresbull.2004.04.031 moltó j, font r, gálvez a, conesa j a (2008), ‘Pyrolysis, combustion of electronic wastes’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 84, 68–78. doi: 10.1016/j.jaap.2008.10.023 montaudo g, puglisi c, rapisardi r, samperi f (1994a), ‘Primary thermaldegradation processes of poly(ether-sulfone) and poly(phenylene oxide) investigated by direct pyrolysis mass-spectrometry’, Macromol Chem Phys, 195, 1225–1239. doi: 10.1002/macp.1994.021950410 montaudo g, puglisi c, samperi f (1994b), ‘Primary thermal-degradation processes occurring in poly(phenylenesulfide) investigated by direct pyrolysis mass-spectrometry’, J Polym Sci A, 32, 1807–1815. doi: 10.1002/pola. 1994.080321002 ohtani h, kimura t, okamoto k, tsuge s, nagataki y, miyata k (1987), ‘Characterization of polyurethanes by high-resolution pyrolysis–capillary gas chromatography’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 12, 115–133. doi: 10.1016/0165-2370(87) 85061-1 perng l h, tsai c j, ling y c (1999), ‘Mechanism and kinetic modelling of PEEK pyrolysis by TG/MS’, Polymer, 40, 7321–7329. doi: 10.1016/S0032–3861(99) 00006–3 pickering s j (2006), ‘Recycling technologies for thermoset composite materials – current status’, Composites A, 37, 1206–1215. doi: 10.1016/j.compositesa.2005.05. 030 pickering s j, kelly r m, kennerley j r, rudd c d, fenwick n j (2000), ‘A fluidised-bed process for the recovery of glass fibres from scrap thermoset composites’, Compos Sci Technol, 60, 509–523. doi: 10.1016/S0266-3538(99)00 154-2 roy c, chaala a, darmstadt h (1999), ‘The vacuum pyrolysis of used tires: end-uses for oil and carbon black products’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 51, 201–221. doi: 10.1016/S0165-2370(99)00017-0 samperi f, puglisi c, ferreri t, messina, cicala g, recca a, restuccia c l, scamporrino a (2007), ‘Thermal decomposition products of copoly(arylene ether sulfone)s characterized by direct pyrolysis mass spectrometry’, Pol Deg Stab, 92, 1304–1315. doi: 10.1016/j.polymdegradstab.2007.03.015 schartel b, pötschke p, knoll u, abdel-goad m (2005), ‘Fire behaviour of polyamide 6/multiwall carbon nanotube nanocomposites’, Eurn Polym J, 41, 1061– 1070. doi: 10.1016/j.eurpolymj.2004.11.023 schartel b, braun u, knoll u, bartholmai m, goering h, neubert d, potschke p (2008), ‘Mechanical, thermal, and fire behaviour of bisphenol a polycarbonate/ multiwall carbon nanotube nanocomposites’, Polym Eng Sci, 48, 149–158. doi: 10.1002/pen.20932 scheirs j (2006), ‘Overview of commercial pyrolysis processes for waste plastics’ in Scheirs J, Kaminsky W (Editors) Feedstock Recycling and Pyrolysis of Waste Plastics, Wiley, Chichester, pp. 383–433 simon c m, kaminsky w, schlesselmann b (1996), ‘Pyrolysis of polyolefins with steam to yield olefins’, J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 38, 75–87. doi: 10.1016/ S0165-2370(96)00950-3 sobera m, hetper j (2003), ‘Pyrolysis–gas chromatography–mass spectrometry of cured phenolic resins’, J Chromatogr A, 993, 131–135. doi: 10.1016/S00219673(03)00388-1
Pyrolysis for recycling waste composites
121
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:58 PM
torres a, de marco i, caballero b m, laresgoiti m f, legarreta j a, cabrero m a, gonzález a, chomón m j, gondra k (2000), ‘Recycling by pyrolysis of thermoset composites: characteristics of the liquid and gaseous fuels obtained’, Fuel, 79, 897–902. doi: 10.1016/S0016-2361(99)00220-3 vassiliou a, biklaris d, chrissafis k, paraskevopoulos k m, stavrev s y, docoslis a (2008), ‘Nanocomposites of isotactic polypropylene with carbon nanoparticles exhibiting enhanced stiffness, thermal stability and gas barrier properties’, Compos Sci Technol, 68, 933–943. doi: 10.1016/j.compscitech.2007.08.019
6 Catalytic processing of waste polymer composites M. A. K E A N E, Heriot-Watt University, UK
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
Abstract: The increase in plastic waste represents a serious environmental issue. Plastics consumption continues to grow and while plastic recycle has seen a significant increase since the early 1990s, consumption still far exceeds recycle. Waste plastic can, however, serve as a potential resource and, with the correct treatment, can be reused or serve as hydrocarbon raw material or as a fuel. An overview of the existing waste plastic treatment technologies is provided with an analysis of the available literature on thermal degradation. Thermal pyrolysis results in a random scissioning of the polymer chains generating products with varying molecular weights. Catalytic degradation provides control over the product composition/distribution and serves to lower significantly the degradation temperature. Fundamental aspects of catalysis are presented with a discussion of the correlation of catalyst structure with performance, placing a particular emphasis on the role of zeolites as catalytic materials that have been widely used to promote polymer degradation. Polyvinyl chloride (PVC), highly versatile with manifold applications, is non-biodegradable and bears a high Cl content (56% of the total weight). Waste PVC incineration is very energy demanding and can result in the formation of toxic chloro-emissions with adverse ecological, environmental and public health impacts. The Cl component must be removed from any waste PVC-derived gas or oil before it can be used. The potential of a catalytic dechlorination unit operation to facilitate PVC recycle is discussed with reference to the pertinent, albeit limited, available literature. Key words: waste polymers, heterogeneous catalysis, zeolites, thermal pyrolysis, catalytic recycling, PVC recycle.
6.1
Introduction
In any progressive approach to waste minimisation, disposal is only an option where the ‘four Rs’, i.e. reduction, reuse, recycling and (energy) recovery options, have been exhausted (McEldowney and McEldowney, 1996). The accepted waste minimisation ‘hierarchy’ is illustrated in Fig. 6.1, which identifies the route to responsible waste management. Catalysis is an integral component in any green processing technology, serving as an important tool to support sustainable development. The deployment of catalysts ensures lower operating temperatures and/or pressures and a 122
Catalytic processing of waste polymer composites
123
Waste minimisation Source reduction
Recycling (on/off-site)
Product changes Source control Use and reuse Reclamation • Product substitution • Return to original process • Resource recovery • Product conservation • Raw material substitute for • By-product another process • Change product composition
Good operating practices Input material changes Technology changes • Procedural measurement • Purification • Process changes • Loss prevention • Substitution • Equipment/piping/layout changes • Material handling • Additional automation • Changes in operational settings • Waste stream segregation • Product scheduling
Saturday, August 06, 2011 3:21:59 PM
6.1 The hierarchy of waste minimisation.
higher selectivity to the target product with a resultant reduction in fuel usage and waste production. Sustainable development is essential to deal with the challenges of a fast-changing world, where the demands on natural resources, the needs of a growing population and the accumulation of waste will inevitably impose restrictions upon how businesses operate. Where a manufacturing process is energy intensive, a controlled recycle/reuse is an effective means of decreasing overall negative environmental impacts (Anastas and Lankey, 2000). The emergence of ‘environmental catalysis’ as a discipline has focused on the development of catalysts to either decompose environmentally unacceptable compounds or provide alternative catalytic syntheses of important compounds without the formation of environmentally unacceptable by-products. This chapter focuses on the former option and considers the role of heterogeneous catalysis in a chemical processing of waste polymers, setting out the advantages of the catalytic approach.
6.2
Waste polymer recycle: motivation
Plastics are synthesised from non-renewable resources and are generally non-biodegradable or the biodegradation process is very slow. As a consequence, waste plastic represents a serious environmental threat that is not addressed by recourse to landfill. However, waste plastic can be viewed as an enormous potential resource which, with the correct treatment, can be reused or serve as hydrocarbon raw material or as a fuel (Williams, 1988).
Management, recycling and reuse of waste composites
The scale and range of plastic goods production have led to a diversity of waste streams with the potential for an impending ‘waste plastic mountain’. An average increase in global plastic production of c.10% has been recorded since 1950 with current production close to 250 million tonnes (Plastics Europe, 2007). The versatility and low prices associated with plastic products are the reasons for commercial success. Despite the unstable price of crude oil and petroleum feedstock, the plastics market remains robust. It has been estimated that annual consumption of plastic products in Western Europe approaches 100 kg per person to give a total of over 39 million tonnes, which translates into an estimated c.22 million tonne waste stream (Plastics Europe, 2004). Virgin plastics consumption is illustrated in Fig. 6.2 where a consistent increase is evident from 1995 to 2002. Up to 60% of all waste plastic generated in Europe is still sent to landfill; incineration with energy recovery represents the principal alternative, accounting for c.23% of the plastic waste (Aguado et al., 2006). The extent of polymer recycle falls somewhere between 5 and 25% of total plastic waste (Karagoz et al., 2003a). In the UK, while plastic consumption continues to increase, the ratio of recycle to consumption has also shown an increase (British Plastics Federation, 2004) as illustrated in Fig. 6.3. Nevertheless, consumption still far exceeds recycle. The management of plastic waste is a press