Foreword
Scholars, politicians and pundits spoke of the 1950s as the beginning of the “Atomic Age.” The invention and ...
41 downloads
692 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Foreword
Scholars, politicians and pundits spoke of the 1950s as the beginning of the “Atomic Age.” The invention and use of atomic weapons were dramatic events during a dramatic time of history. The invention and development of semiconductor electronics and, more generally, of information science and technology have been less dramatic. Nevertheless, the growth of these technologies and their impact on world society is truly remarkable. Some scholars, politicians and pundits refer to the present era as the “information age.” Surely this era began with a whimper rather than a bang. In 1943, Thomas Watson Sr. (Chairman, IBM) proclaimed “I think there is a world market for maybe 5 computers.” In 1977, Ken Olsen, Chairman and founder of Digital Equipment Corp. (DEC), said “There is no reason anyone would want a computer in their home.” DEC is not longer in business, having been acquired by Compaq in 1998. Consider an example that demonstrates the accelerated progress of the field. In the late 1960s, the IBM 360 computer was heralded as a revolution in computing. Model 360/65, available around 1970, came with 1 MB or RAM in the form of magnetic core memory. A typical user might have 200 MB of off-line memory, in the form of a dozen or so tape drives, each the size of an armoire. Characteristic processing speeds were the order of microseconds. Today, an individual can purchase more computing power for roughly $200 in the form of a Personal Digital Assistant (PDA) that fits in your pocket. Its processor will work with clock speeds of nearly 1 GHz (nanosecond times scales). For another $100 one can purchase 200 MB of FLASH RAM in the form of a memory stick the size of your thumb. Analysis of the success of digital electronics often mentions Moore’s law: the number of devices on a semiconductor chip doubles every 18 months. It is perhaps less well known that the magnetic recording industry has also followed Moore’s Law, and for the past few years has sustained progress at a faster pace. During the 1990s, the areal density of bits recorded on a disk drive increased at a rate of about 60% per year, equivalent with a doubling time of about 18 months. From 1999 to 2003, the areal density increased at a rate of about 100% per year. This corresponds to a doubling time of 12 months, which is faster than Moore’s Law. This remarkable success of magnetic storage technology derives from a number of results of basic research over the past two decades. The research has been in the fields of physics, materials science, and device engineering, and has had the common themes of magnetism and conduction electron spin. As research and development continue to progress, those researchers on the leading edge are examining broader applications of these new materials and devices.
viii Foreword
For example, the high areal density of recording media has enabled the production of “mini disk drives” with dimensions of a few centimeters and capacities of nearly 100 GB. These are used for playing MP3 music files, among other applications. However, the time required to find and access any particular bit (or string of bits) of data on a disk drive is a few milliseconds, barely faster than access times twenty years ago. In semiconductor technology, high density nonvolatile FLASH memory is inexpensive, and FLASH is one of the fastest growing segments of the integrated semiconductor market. However, this kind of memory requires relatively long times (and high energies) to erase and write, has limited endurance, and individual bits cannot be addressed. It’s natural to ask if a novel device based on magnetism and using spin polarized conduction electrons can be used to make an integrated memory. At low density and bit count, such a Magnetic Random Access Memory (MRAM) would be superior to nonvolatile semiconductor memory. At high density and bit count, MRAM would avoid the slow access times and reliability problems of read heads and would be superior to magnetic media mass storage. The field known as Magnetoelectronics is based on using these novel materials and devices for integrated digital electronics applications. In a broader view, Magnetoelectronics is a novel kind of union of elements of physics, materials science, and electrical engineering. The goal is to create devices and architectures for digital electronics applications. Magnetoelectronics will never replace complementary metal on oxide semiconductor (CMOS) technology, but it recognizes that CMOS has some vulnerabilities. Magnetoelectronics may become established in a vulnerable area, for example as high performance bit addressable nonvolatile RAM. This feat alone would qualify Magnetoelectronics as a successful technology. If it becomes established in broader memory applications, it will qualify as a successful and important technology. Furthermore, the model of uniting elements from several disparate disciplines may become a paradigm for exploiting other vulnerable areas of CMOS. This book is written to be a resource for scientists, engineers and program managers who are becoming involved in Magnetoelectronics. This is an interdisciplinary field, and important contributions have come from the fields of physics, materials science, and electrical engineering. Contributions to new dimensions of Magnetoelectronics are coming from fields related to biology, biophysics, and biochemistry. Readers are expected to come from a variety of backgrounds and to have very different areas of expertise. This book also may be used as a graduate level text for students in any of the disciplines mentioned above. Much of the first chapter, “Introduction to Magnetoelectronics,” is written at an undergraduate level. This chapter is designed to be accessible to graduate students in one particular field, or to readers with advanced training in some specialized area but with little or no knowledge of Magnetoelectronics. It uses simple pictures and heuristic descriptions to introduce basic ideas of magnetism, the transport of spin polarized electrons, the mechanisms by which several magnetoelectronics devices operate, and basic architectures of MRAM. This chapter also provides some background material on the physics of semiconductors and of metals, also
Foreword ix
written at an undergraduate level. This is for the benefit of readers who may have had an undergraduate course in solid state physics in a long-forgotten past. It is also for readers who may never have had a course on this topic. Some other portions of Chapter 1 are “special topics” that are not treated elsewhere in the book, and are presented at the level of a graduate course. Similarly, all of the other chapters are written at a level appropriate for a graduate course. This is also an appropriate level for professional scientists who are moving into this area. This book is a remarkable anthology because each chapter is written by someone who made historically important contributions to the field. Prof. Bernard Dieny (Chapter 2, SpinValves) was a young Ph. D. scientist at IBM Almaden in the late 1980s and early 1990s, where he was involved with the development of the first spin valves and was first author on several seminal papers. Prof. Dieny is presently the director of the SPIN-TEC laboratory at Grenoble, France. Chapter 2 presents a thorough review of spin valve structures and the giant magnetoresistance (GMR) phenomena. Prof. Robert Meservey (Chapter 3, Spin-polarized Tunneling) can be described as a founding father of the field known as the Physics of Spin-Polarized Transport. His experiments at the Francis Bitter Laboratory at MIT in the early 1970s were the earliest demonstrations of spin-polarized transport in the solid state. These experiments were the beginning of a list of accomplishments and achievements in the field. Dr. Jagadeesh Moodera, also from the Francis Bitter Laboratory, is credited with the development of fabrication techniques for highly stable magnetic tunnel junctions that have large and reproducible values of magnetoresistance. While this is only one of his achievements, it continues to have a lasting impact on the field. Chapter 3 presents a broad review of spin-polarized tunneling phenomena. Magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) are an important class of devices and are discussed at length. Dr. James Daughton (Chapter 4, MRAM) can be described as a founding father of magnetic random access memory (MRAM). He was developing MRAM ideas as early as the 1980s, and he moved quickly to adapt MRAM designs to accomodate new spin-valve and MTJ structures. Nevertheless, technologies for MRAM were not developing very rapidly. In the late 1990s, several companies, including Motorola, decided that MRAM was worthy of substantially increased Research and Development. Dr. Saied Tehrani was a leader in the effort to assemble a remarkable group of basic and applied research scientists at Motorola, most of whom had little background in magnetism and magnetic materials. In a few years of dedicated research, this group has succeeded in bringing high performance MRAM chips to market. Chapter 5 discusses all aspects of MRAM technology, including important discussions on scaling for future memory generations. Prof. Paulo Freitas (Chapter 7, Magnetoresistive DNA Chips) has made many contributions to magnetism and magnetic materials. In the late 1990s, Prof. Freitas was one of the first scientists to recognize that biotechnology would be an important applications area for Magnetoelectronics. Similar to the group at Motorola, a relatively short period of a few years of research and development by the group of Prof. Freitas has succeeded in producing several
x Foreword
successful prototype DNA chips. These chips will be brought to market within a short time. Chapter 7 presents the physics and technology of biochips. Of equal importance it also discusses the biochemistry of assay techniques and processes. As for myself (Chapter 1, Introduction to Magnetoelectronics and Chapter 6, Broader Digital Applications of Magnetoelectronics), my Ph. D. thesis work at Cornell with Prof. R. H. Silsbee, who is also a founding father of Spin-Polarized Transport, was the “Spin injection experiment.” Many researchers view our experiment, along with the theoretical framework we developed, as keystones of spin-polarized transport and of Magnetoelectronics. In the early 1990s, I published papers that proposed bit-addressable MRAM and magnetic logic. Around 1992, Dr. Gary Prinz and I had some informal discussions about the fabrication of electronic devices that incorporated a patterned ferromagnetic element, and their use for applications in integrated electronics. We were among the first to used the word “magnetoelectronics,” and perhaps we invented the term. I have a continuing interest in a broad variety of magnetoelctronic device structures and in novel applications. Chapter 6 presents Magnetoelectronics in a perspective of broader applications in digital electronics, discussing topics such as dynamically reprogrammable logic and broad bandwidth analog to digital conversion. Finally, a comment about units should be made. Every research scientist has a preferred system of units. Most conversions between CGS and SI units are familiar, but conversions related to magnetic field may be an exception. The reader may wish to keep in mind the following conversions. In CGS units, an oersted and a gauss are essentially the same and both are commonly used as units of magnetic field. In the SI system, magnetic field is measured in kilo-amperes per meter (kA/m), and the conversion is that 1 kA/m ¼ 4p Oe. If you also remember that 1 tesla is 10,000 gauss, you will probably know all the necessary conversions.
List of Contributors
˚ kerman (231), Freescale Semiconductor, 1300 N Alma School Road, Chandler, AZ 85224, Johan A USA M.D. Amaral (331), Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Faculty of Sciences of the University of Lisbon, Campo Grande, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal J.S. Cabral (331), Bioengineering Research Group, Chemical Engineering Department, Instituto Superior Tecnico, R. Rovisco Pais, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal L.A. Clarke (331), Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Faculty of Sciences of the University of Lisbon, Campo Grande, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal James Daughton (205), NVE Corporation, 11409 Valley View Road, Eden Prairie, MN 55344-3617, USA Mark DeHerrera (231), Freescale Semiconductor, 1300 N Alma School Road, Chandler, AZ 85224, USA B. Dieny (67), SPINTEC, Unite´ de Recherche Associe´e CEA/DSM & CNRS/SPM-STIC, 38054 Grenoble Cedex, France Mark Durlam (231), Freescale Semiconductor, 1300 N Alma School Road, Chandler, AZ 85224, USA Brad Engel (231), Freescale Semiconductor, 1300 N Alma School Road, Chandler, AZ 85224, USA H.A. Ferreira (331), Physics Department, Instituto Superior Tecnico, R. Rovisco Pais, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal and INESC-Microsystems and Nanotechnologies, R. Alves Redol, 9, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal L. Fonseca (331), Bioengineering Research Group, Chemical Engineering Department, Instituto Superior Tecnico, R. Rovisco Pais, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal P.P. Freitas (331), INESC-Microsystems and Nanotechnologies, R. Alves Redol, 9, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal and Physics Department, Instituto Superior Tecnico, R. Rovisco Pais, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal D.L. Graham (331), INESC-Microsystems and Nanotechnologies, R. Alves Redol, 9, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal Jason Janesky (231), Freescale Semiconductor, 1300 N Alma School Road, Chandler, AZ 85224, USA Mark Johnson (1, 273), Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC 20375, USA Fred Mancoff (231), Freescale Semiconductor, 1300 N Alma School Road, Chandler, AZ 85224, USA V. Martins (331), Bioengineering Research Group, Chemical Engineering Department, Instituto Superior Tecnico, R. Rovisco Pais, 1000 Lisbon, Portugal Robert H. Meservey (151), Francis Bitter Magnet Laboratory, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
xii List of Contributors Jagadeesh S. Moodera (151), Francis Bitter Magnet Laboratory, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA Jon Slaughter (231), Freescale Semiconductor, 1300 N Alma School Road, Chandler, AZ 85224, USA Saied Tehrani (231), Freescale Semiconductor, 1300 N Alma School Road, Chandler, AZ 85224, USA
Magnetoelectronics M. Johnson (Editor) Copyright q 2004 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Chapter 1 Introduction to magnetoelectronics Mark Johnson Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC 20375, USA
1.1
Introduction
The hallmark of a ferromagnetic material is that it displays spontaneous magnetization, developing a magnetic moment at temperatures below the characteristic ordering temperature Tc ; and this property can be used to create patterned thin film device components with bistable magnetic states. The magnetization state, with positive or negative orientation along some convenient axis, is stable at room temperature for common ferromagnetic materials. It has long been recognized that these bistable states can be correlated with binary ‘0’ and ‘1’ for digital applications. Early random access memories (RAMs) for computers were built from arrays of magnetic cells. Each cell was a torus of magnetic material, with bistable states described by clockwise or counterclockwise magnetization orientation. Arrays of cells were connected with rows and columns of wires, which were threaded through and around an arm of each torus. Since a magnetic field surrounds a wire that is carrying an electric current, and magnetic flux flows through the center of a wire coil, current pulses applied to the wires of a given row and column would locally apply sufficient magnetic field to the torus at the row/column intersection to set the magnetization state. Equivalently stated, the current pulses could write the bit state of the cell. Similarly, an inductively coupled voltage could be sensed by a wire, when an interrogating current was applied via another wire, for reading out the value of a bit. These toroidal cells were called cores (Campbell-Kelly, 1997), and gave rise to the term core memory. The invention of write and read heads allowed the application of similar principles to magnetic media. Each track on a disk or tape is broken up into bits, and the bistable orientation of the magnetization of the bit determines the binary value, ‘0’ or ‘1’. There are numerous recording schemes, but in one typical scheme each bit is made up of a pair of magnetization domains (a domain is defined as a region with uniform magnetization orientation) with colinear magnetization axes, and the bits are laid out end to end along the tracks. The bit state is determined by parallel or antiparallel orientation of the two domains. The magnetization states are ‘written’ using locally strong fringe fields from the pole faces of a thin film ferromagnetic write head. They are read by sensing the presence (or absence) of magnetic fringe fields associated with antiparallel (or parallel) magnetization of the two domains in the bit. Similar to the readout of early core
2 M. Johnson memories, reading stored values from magnetic media originally involved inductively coupled voltages sensed by a scanning pickup coil that floated above the moving track. Around 1993, this technology was replaced by an approach which used the anisotropic magnetoresistance (AMR) of a thin film ferromagnetic element to detect the magnetic fringe field (refer to Chapter 2). An intrinsic property of ferromagnetic metals, AMR means that the resistance of the material differs slightly when the electrical current is parallel or perpendicular to the material’s axis of magnetization (refer to Chapter 2). This proved to be a much more sensitive technique and, since the change, the density of bit storage in magnetic media has increased faster than Moore’s law. The yearly increase in areal density of 60% was further increased to roughly 100% in 1998 when giant magnetoresistive (GMR) materials were introduced in the magnetoresistive heads. In parallel with the basic research developments in the field of magnetism that were responsible for new magnetic media storage technologies, it was natural to revisit the original idea of ‘core memory’ and ask: Can magnetic materials be used in an electronic device and an integrated architecture in order to create some new kind of device with novel characteristics, useful for digital electronics? This question frames the emerging field that has become known variously as magnetoelectronics, spin electronics or spintronics. One approach, which can be described as conventional, is to incorporate a ferromagnetic component into a device structure and to take advantage of the properties of the ferromagnet for novel functionality. An example is the creation of a nonvolatile memory cell. The bistability of the magnetization orientation, which has nearly infinite durability, provides nonvolatile storage of a binary state. The goal of conventional magnetoelectronics is to identify the performance advantages that a new approach offers, and then to invent and develop appropriate devices and architectures, along with viable manufacturing and materials processing technologies that are compatible with the dominant semiconductor industry, complementary metal oxide semiconductor (CMOS). This approach addresses conventional ideas of information processing and conventional parameters of operation. Nevertheless, binary information is represented by a magnetization orientation rather than a capacitance or voltage, and this category of devices and applications represents a paradigm shift for digital electronics. Another approach, which can be called unconventional, is to address the magnetic moment of an individual electron (equivalently, its quantum mechanical spin), and to manipulate the spin to achieve some novel scheme of information processing. The ‘device’ can be a single electron or a small population of electrons, and the electrons can be itinerant or localized. This approach addresses unconventional ideas of information processing such as ‘quantum computing’ or ‘quantum cryptography’. Here the goal of spintronics is to identify appropriate spin systems that may be viable and to study their relevant characteristics, such as the spin coherence time. The focus of this book is the first approach, conventional magnetoelectronics. However, basic issues and characteristics of spin-dependent transport are often relevant to both subfields, and occasionally reference to more esoteric, unconventional spintronics will be made. The remainder of this introduction gives a brief overview of the first approach.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
3
Between 1995 and 2001, research and development expenditures in the US in the field of magnetoelectronics doubled roughly every 2 years, with the growth rate slowing a little after 2001. Research funding is a complicated, nonlinear phenomenon, and this tremendous rate of increase has, in turn, focussed attention on spintronics. This ‘positive feedback’ has helped to sustain the growth of the field. But there are also objective, intellectually defensible reasons for optimism. From a broad viewpoint, the basic research advances in spin transport and magnetic materials have been applied with great success to the magnetic recording industry, and the idea of extending this success to integrated applications is plausible. In a more focussed view, there are specific characteristics of prototype magnetoelectronic devices that offer significant performance advantages. An analysis of the competition is an appropriate beginning of the overview. The dominant semiconductor technology, based on CMOS field effect transistors (FETs), is successful for a number of reasons that are readily articulated (Keyes, 1989). (i) The output levels are standardized. The HIGH (binary ‘1’) and LOW (binary ‘0’) output levels are pinned to the supply voltage VDD and ground. These stabilized levels can be transmitted to subsequent devices where they are used as inputs. Equivalently and succinctly stated, CMOS FETs have sufficient gain to enable fanout. (ii) The inputs are tolerant of fluctuations. Voltages that fall in a reasonable range of values are accepted as appropriate input levels. Thus, the devices operate using relatively large input margins so that mass replication of devices and massive device integration are possible. (iii) The signal-tonoise ratio is high. Voltage levels are interpreted as ‘l’s’ and ‘0’s’ with a high level of accuracy. (iv) There is good electrical isolation between input and output. (v) The devices are scalable and inexpensive. For these reasons and others, CMOS technology dominates about 99% of the world semiconductor market. Despite all of its success, CMOS devices are far from ideal for memory applications. Storage of a binary value is based on capacitance: A capacitor is either uncharged (‘0’) or charged (‘1’). While Coulomb forces are useful for generating and transmitting the relatively large voltages characteristic of CMOS devices, these same forces are a disadvantage for creating and maintaining bistable storage states. In other words, capacitors tend to leak charge. The strong Coulomb attraction between opposite charges causes leakage current across the capacitor’s dielectric. For high density dynamic random access memory (DRAM), the capacitor at the heart of the memory cell discharges in roughly 10 ms. DRAM is the leading example of volatile memory: stored data must be refreshed every few milliseconds. For these volatile memories, power is dissipated at all times, not only during read and write operations. This high quiescent power can be a performance disadvantage and, furthermore, volatile memories are unreliable to the extent that a power interruption destroys memory. It is relatively simple to articulate the most desirable attributes of an integrated memory cell (Brown and Brewer, 1997). Nonvolatility is at the head of the list, and other attributes include fast write, read, erase, and access times; low operating power; and high durability. The CMOS
4 M. Johnson approach to nonvolatile memory, nonvolatile random access memory (NVRAM), is based on the capacitance of a ‘floating gate’. In a floating gate cell, a thick dielectric layer separates the channel of an FET from its gate, and a small metal island is fabricated inside the dielectric (Sharma, 1997). This island can be uncharged (‘0’), or it can be charged (‘1’) by tunnel injection of electrons from the gate at high voltage. The charge state of the island determines the capacitance between the gate and the channel, and therefore the bit state of the cell can be read out as a voltage level. The dielectric is thick in order to prevent leakage currents, and nonvolatile states are stable for years. A result of the thick dielectric, however, is that charging times (write times) and uncharging times (erase times) are quite long, the order of 10 ms or more and 1 ms or more, respectively. Write and erase processes require relatively high voltage for long times, and the energy associated with writing or erasing a bit is quite high, 1027 and 1025 J, respectively. Furthermore, charge carriers tunneling at high voltage eventually degrade the dielectric, and floating gate cells have limited durability. Inexpensive FLASH memory cells may degrade after 103 cycles, and more expensive electrically erasable programmable read only memory (EEPROM) has a durability of roughly 105 cycles. The performance advantages of the magnetoelectronic approach are now apparent. Because of the intrinsic bistability of ferromagnetic elements, magnetoelectronic devices are natural memory cells. Magnetic switching times (read, write and erase times) are a few nanoseconds, and the energy per bit associated with these processes is about 10210 J. Furthermore, although durability depends on details of the device, it has been shown to be essentially infinite for at least several device prototypes. Thus, the magnetoelectronic paradigm can offer improvements by several orders of magnitude over CMOS floating gate NVRAM in categories of speed, energy consumption and durability. The promise of realizing these advantages has been the true driving force for the field. As magnetoelectronics seeks to generalize its success in magnetic media recording technology by expanding into integrated electronics, research and development in a variety of fields will become important. Physicists, materials scientists and electrical engineers bring unique expertise, and unique backgrounds, to the technology. This volume is written to be a resource for this eclectic group of researchers and engineers. Some topics and issues may seem trivial to some readers, but will be entirely new ground for others. This chapter is written to provide a background for the volume. It anticipates the needs and interests of readers from a wide variety of fields, necessarily having a wide variety of backgrounds. Section 1.3 offers a review of very basic ideas of transport phenomena in semiconductors and metals, and can be skipped by those readers who have had the equivalent of an undergraduate course in solid-state physics. Finally, with the expectation that individual readers will skip selected sections, this chapter has been written with some small amount of redundancy. A few topics and issues are treated briefly at first, and receive deeper attention in a subsequent section.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
1.2
5
What is magnetoelectronics?
To follow the conventional approach of magnetoelectronics, incorporating a ferromagnetic material into an integrated device structure involves four related topics. (i) Ferromagnetic materials are unique because they have the property of spontaneous magnetization. Using magnetic engineering, this property must be used to construct device elements with appropriate, stable magnetization states. (ii) Since the magnetic state is a local property of the material, the ferromagnetic device element must be capable of communicating its state to the outside world, preferably in a nondestructive way. At the core of spintronics is the realization that the ‘spin’ states of itinerant conduction electrons can be used for this function. (iii) For device output to be electronically integrated, the ‘spin’ state must be converted to something that can be manipulated with standard electronics, either a voltage or current. (iv) There is a similar constraint at the input end. The device state (the magnetization state of the ferromagnetic element) must be set by current or voltage levels. (i) Spontaneous magnetization is a gift from nature. This is unlike any other property of other materials classes. Indeed, the spontaneous magnetization of lodestone has been known since ancient times, but a clear and complete theory of ferromagnetism (with, for example, the ability to predict transition temperatures) is lacking today. Some of the details of ferromagnetism will be discussed in later sections, but we can begin by stating that every conduction electron has an associated magnetic dipole moment. In a ferromagnetic material, a fraction of the dipoles in a region called a magnetic domain spontaneously order at room temperature. This is a local property of the material, and this property scales down to small sizes. For digital magnetoelectronic devices, a ferromagnetic component, or device element, is fabricated with a uniaxial anisotropy axis. This means that the spontaneous magnetization will have positive or negative orientation along this axis. The result is the existence of bistable states that take the form of these two stable magnetization orientations. The bistable states are intrinsically nonvolatile. Thus, nonvolatility is an intrinsic property of the material. Figure 1.1(a) shows a patterned ferromagnetic element, which will often be denoted in this chapter as F, and which is typically composed of a transition metal ferromagnet such as Ni, Fe or Co, or alloys such as Ni0.8Fe0.2 (Permalloy). When fabricated with an appropriate anisotropy, the ~ lies along a uniaxial anisotropy axis [^x in Fig. 1.1(a)], and has two stable magnetization M ~ is denoted in orientations, along positive (right) and negative (left) x^ : The vector magnetization M the figure by an arrow. The magnetization is set by an external magnetic field H; and the magnetic characteristic is graphically represented by the hysteresis loop, M vs H; shown in Fig. 1.1(b). ~ is positive, pointing to the right. As the field H is decreased, Starting at the top right ðH q 0Þ; M ~ follows the dotted line, and the dotted arrow denotes H decreasing from positive to negative M ~ still points to the right and the value of M at H ¼ 0 is called the values. At H ¼ 0; M remanent magnetization, Mr : Continuing to follow the dotted line, the field decreases further until ~ reverses orientation and becomes H ¼ 2HC ; the field value defined as the coercive field, where M
6 M. Johnson
(a)
(b)
M
H
M
MR
F x
f M=0 HS
H
(c)
B
H=0
HC
L
Fig. 1.1 An appropriately fabricated, thin ferromagnetic film has bistable magnetization states, with the magnetization oriented to the right or left along an easy magnetization axis x^ : (a) Thin ferromagnetic element F, lithographically patterned with minimum feature size f : (b) The magnetization states are graphically described by a hysteresis loop: an external magnetic field H with magnitude larger than Hs is required to set the orientation to the right, and a magnitude more negative than 2Hs is required to set the orientation to the left. When H is removed, the magnetization remains in the set orientation. The magnetization M at H ¼ 0 is the remanent value, Mr : The coercive field HC is the value of field such that the magnetization is zero, M ¼ 0: Dotted (solid) arrow refers to H decreasing (increasing) from positive (negative) to negative (positive) field values. (c) Dipolar fringe magnetic field B surrounds F in the same way that fields go from North to South pole of a bar magnet. These fields can act to disrupt the magnetization state of F, and are called demagnetizing fields.
negative, pointing to the left, for values H , 2lHC l: The magnetization follows the solid line as field H is increased from negative to positive values. Whereas HC is defined by the value of field for which the magnetization passes through zero, the saturation (or switching) field Hs is the field required to orient the magnetization completely. When fully oriented, the magnetization is said to reach its saturation magnetization value, Ms : For the ideally square hysteresis loop of Fig. 1.1(b), the remanent magnetization is the same as the saturation magnetization, Mr ¼ Ms : The hysteresis loop of Fig. 1.1(b) graphically demonstrates the bistability of element F. Using wording more familiar in digital electronics, F can be described as a latching, two-state system. It is interesting to note that Fig. 1.1(b) describes a magnetic field transducer with a large magnetic field gain. The mean internal field (inside F) is 4pMs ; which is roughly 1 or 2 T. In other words, if one could bore a small hole inside F and install a gaussmeter to measure magnetic field, one would measure a field of value 4pMs : However, a very small external field H < HC can be ~ Because the coercivity of typical F elements is on the order of used to control the orientation of M: 10 Oe, the magnetic field gain is bM ¼ 1000: This is one remarkable property of ferromagnetic materials. While this has long been used as the basis of transformers, it remains a solution in search of broader problems. (ii)
The magnetization state of a ferromagnetic element, such as that depicted in
Fig. 1.1(a), is a local property of the material. For digital applications, each of the binary values ‘0’ and ‘1’ is associated with one of the bistable states, ‘left’ or ‘right’, negative or positive along x^ :
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
7
To be useful, however, the magnetization orientation must be communicated to the external world, preferably in a nondestructive way. An equivalent statement is that the bit value must be sensed by some ‘readout’ process. One plausible technique is to sense the dipolar magnetic fringe fields that the F element generates. Figure 1.1(c) depicts an image that is familiar to everyone, from their earliest introduction to magnetic materials. Just as a macroscopic bar magnet generates magnetic field lines which emanate from the north pole and return at the south pole, a microscopic F element ~ that emanate from one end and close at generates fringe magnetic fields, described by field lines B the other. Within a few nanometers of the end surface of F, the magnitude of B is the same as the mean internal field, B ¼ 4pMs : Within 10– 100 nm of the end, the magnitude has decayed by an order of magnitude, and it further decays to the order of 1–10 Oe at distances of order 1 mm or more. When the magnetization of the element in Fig. 1.1(c) is reversed, the fringe fields are the same but with opposite direction. Sensing these fringe fields is the basis for ‘reading’ information from magnetic media, such as disks. The process is described in Chapter 2 and many details can be found in a number of excellent reviews (Zhu, 2003). The ‘bits’ are laid out, edge to edge, in tracks, and travel underneath a floating read head as the disk spins around. The head is composed of a magnetoresistive element biased by a current. The sensed voltage changes value when the magnetic field detected at the edges of the bits is positive, zero, or negative. Sensing these fringe fields is also the basis of one of the earliest integrated magnetoelectronic devices used in magnetic random access memory (MRAM) prototypes, which will be described in Chapter 4. A second plausible technique utilizes the spin state of the conduction electrons. Related concepts will be described in detail in following sections, but the basic idea can be described in a simple way. It is important to note that the following is a heuristic picture, which merely approximates an accurate model, presented later in the chapter. Figure 1.2(a) shows a ferromagnetic metal F, with uniform magnetization oriented along þ^x; in electrical contact with a nonmagnetic metal N. The magnetic moments of the itinerant conduction electrons in F are aligned along the axis of magnetization, as depicted schematically on the left side of Fig. 1.2(b). For ease of discussion, carriers with spins oriented along the positive (negative) x^ -axis will be called spin-up (spin-down). They can be described as spin-polarized conduction electrons. These electrons move around diffusively and carry with them a marker, their spin orientation, that indicates the magnetization state of F. If the spin state of some of these electrons can be sensed, the bit state of F can be determined. The itinerant conduction electrons native to N are not spin polarized. Their spin orientations are random. For ease of notation, unpolarized electrons on the right side of Fig. 1.2(b) are depicted with no spin axes to indicate random orientation. A bias source causes an electric current to flow from F to N. The current that crosses the interface is composed of spin-polarized electrons, and the polarized electrons can diffuse into N for a relatively large distance before their spin orientation is randomized. Figure 1.2(b) represents a snapshot of the
8 M. Johnson
(a)
F
N
I
(b)
x
Fig. 1.2 Heuristic picture of spin and charge transport in a system with ferromagnetic and nonmagnetic components. (a) Bias current I flows through a ferromagnetic material F in interfacial contact with a nonmagnetic material N. (b) Each electron that contributes to the electric current has a spin. In F, the orientations of the electrons are aligned (signified by parallel arrows) and the current is spin polarized. In the nonmagnetic material, most of the spins have random orientation (signified by the absence of an arrow) but a small number of spin-polarized electrons diffuse into N.
steady-state distribution of conduction electrons in F and N, near the F –N interface, under the bias current conditions of Fig. 1.2(a). Thus, electrons carrying a marker that indicates the magnetization state of F can be driven into a contiguous material by a process that is known as spin injection (Johnson and Silsbee, 1985). (iii)
It is necessary to sense the spin state of these electrons in order to infer the
magnetization state of F and thereby complete the readout process. For integrated electronics, the spin state should be converted to a current or voltage or, equivalently, a characteristic impedance. If we use light polarization as an analogy, then the ferromagnetic element F can be called a spin polarizer, remembering the important distinction that conduction electrons, unlike photons, are particles that move diffusively. Following that analogy, a second ferromagnetic film F2 can be used as a spin analyzer. In Fig. 1.3(a), ferromagnetic polarizer F1, with positive magnetization ~ 1 ¼ þM1 x^ Þ; is in electrical contact with a nonmagnetic region, which in turn is in orientation ðM electrical contact with ferromagnetic analyzer F2. The magnetization orientation of F2 is also positive. A bias source drives a current I through the structure and a voltage V is sensed from
Fig. 1.3 Spin and charge transport in F1– N– F2 and F1–I – F2 systems. (a) In a generalized device, ~2 ~ 1 and M ferromagnetic films F1 and F2 have parallel magnetization axes and magnetization orientations M that can be independently controlled, and F1 and F2 are separated by a thin layer of nonmagnetic metal or a thin, low transmission tunnel barrier. A bias current I flows through the device and the voltage across the ~ 2 parallel. (b) The intermediate layer is a nonmagnetic metal, N. Spin~ 1 and M device, V; is relatively low for M polarized electrons are driven from F1 to N and enter F2 with relative ease (low resistance). (c) The intermediate layer is a tunnel barrier, IT. The wave functions of electrons in F1 and F2 penetrate into the barrier. The overlap of up-spin electron wave functions is relatively large (low resistance tunneling). ~ 1 and M ~ 2 antiparallel. The voltage V across the device is relatively large. (d) The generalized device for M
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
9
(e) The spin-polarized electrons driven from F1 to N enter F2 with relative difficulty (high resistance). (f) The overlap of up-spin electron wave functions in F1 with up-spin electron wave functions in F2 is relatively small (high resistance tunneling). (g) A schematic perspective view of a planar spin valve or MTJ device structure. Typical thickness tN is ,few nm p‘; and typical thickness tI is # 1 nm.
10
M. Johnson
end to end. Conceptually, the nonmagnetic region may be a nonmagnetic metal N, with thickness tN , or a thin, insulating tunnel barrier IT , with thickness tI . Spin and charge transport for the former case are depicted in Fig. 1.3(b). Spin-polarized current is injected from F1 into N. Using converse reasoning or, equivalently, the analogy of light polarizers, polarized spin-up carriers incident on the N –F2 interface are transmitted into F2 with relative ease, and with characteristically high conductance. This argument is easier to understand in a more rigorous way for the case of spin-dependent tunneling (SDT), depicted in Fig. 1.3(c) (Julliere, 1975). Here the quantum mechanical wave function of electrons in F1 and F2 penetrates into the insulating tunnel barrier, IT, and the probability of tunneling is proportional to the wave function overlap. Tunneling from F1 to F2 has a relatively high probability (is characterized by relatively high conductance) because there is a large density of states of carriers with up-spin orientation on both sides of the barrier. A rigorous calculation shows that the tunnel current is proportional to the density of states NðEÞ on both sides of the tunnel barrier. But the Pauli exclusion principle forbids transfer of an up-spin to a down-spin state, so the spin subband densities of states determine the tunnel current. The situation changes for an F1 – N – F2 or F1 – IT – F2 structure with antiparallel magnetization orientations [Fig. 1.3(e) and (f), respectively]. Once again, the tunneling case [Fig. 1.3(f)] is simpler to understand. The tunneling probability is relatively low because the density of states for spin-up carriers is high in F1 but low in F2, and tunneling between F1 and F2 is thereby characterized by a low conductance. The same argument is qualitatively true for transport in the F1–N –F2 structure with antiparallel magnetization orientation [Fig. 1.3(e)]. Up-spin carriers cross the N –F2 interface with relative difficulty, and transport is characterized by a low conductance. Thus, a second ferromagnetic film can be used as a ‘spin analyzer’. Figure 1.3(g) depicts a schematic of a generic magnetoelectronic device cell composed of two planar ferromagnetic ~ 1 is always pinned in one direction and the bit state is stored as the orientation of F2, elements. If M then an F1 –N–F2 or F1–I–F2 structure constitutes a cell in which readout is performed by sensing a relatively low or high resistance for cell states with magnetization orientations that are parallel or antiparallel, respectively. This simple model of a device cell captures the essence of conventional spin electronics. The spin state of an electron is ‘converted’ to a property associated with its charge, and spin becomes a new control parameter that can be manipulated and used to achieve new functionality in a device. In this example, the function is nonvolatile storage of binary information. More generally, any property of the ferromagnetic material, or of the spin state of the carriers, can be modulated with an associated effect on charge transport. Similarly, any useful property of the ferromagnetic material, such as magnetization-dependent strain (known as magnetostriction), becomes available as a control parameter. (iv) At the input end, the device state (the magnetization state of the ferromagnetic element) must be set by an integrated technique, one that uses current or voltage levels. Whereas conventional semiconductor electronics operates with capacitively coupled voltage pulses,
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
11
Word Line Write Wire F H
IW
Fig. 1.4 Binary information input for an integrated device. The external field H that sets the magnetization state of F is applied by inductively coupling a current pulse applied to an integrated, contiguous ‘write wire’.
magnetoelectronics uses inductively coupled current pulses. Figure 1.4 is a perspective view of a ferromagnetic element, such as a component of the spin valve or magnetic tunnel junction (MTJ) of Fig. 1.3(g), along with an integrated write wire. In real applications, cells might be addressed using bit and word lines that also function as write wires. A thin insulating layer separates F from the write wire, which is fabricated with a nonmagnetic metal such as aluminum or copper. When ~ circulates around the write wire with clockwise carrying a write current IW ; a magnetic field H orientation, following the ‘right hand rule’. When the write wire is sufficiently wide to cover the ~ is approximately constant near the surface of the write wire, and of length of F, the magnitude of H F, and H decays with a long length scale in the direction normal to the interface. Thus, current IW provides a nearly homogeneous, local magnetic field that can be used to control the magnetization state of F. Since magnetization reversal in ferromagnetic films is rapid, occurring on a time scale of order 1 ns (Zelakiewicz et al., 2002), short current pulses can be applied through the write wire to set the magnetization state. A bipolar power supply is used to drive the write current. In the example of Fig. 1.4, a current pulse of positive polarity, þ2IW ; corresponds to a ‘0’ and sets the magnetization state negative along x^ and a current pulse of negative polarity, 22IW ; corresponds to a ‘1’ and sets the magnetization state positive. A subtle but important point is that the amplitude of the write pulse is set at þ2IW : This permits unique addressability of individual cells when memory cells are arranged in a two-dimensional array, incorporating an array of rows and columns of write wires. Details of write operations will be discussed in later chapters, but an introductory discussion is fairly simple. The amplitude of the write pulse applied to any row i or column j is set to provide half the required switching field value, aIW ¼ Hs =2; where a is a constant of proportionality for the inductive coupling. The field provided at cell ði; jÞ is then 2aIW ¼ Hs ; which is sufficiently large to orient the magnetization. Meanwhile, the field at any other cell on row i or column j is not adequate to change the existing magnetization state. This is called a ‘half-select’ write process. Having an acquaintance with the four topics discussed above provides a preliminary understanding of the technological underpinnings of ‘magnetoelectronics’. Next, issues related to real device applications can be analyzed.
12 1.2.1
M. Johnson How can spin be used for novel functionality?
This subsection introduces several applications where magnetoelectronics may have an impact, but we begin with a brief discussion that uses a broader viewpoint. The lifeline of a successful technology can be described as follows. It begins with a breakthrough appearance, typically fulfilling some particular need or offering unique advantages over an existing approach. After achieving this foothold, incremental improvements in design, engineering and manufacturing gradually increase the relative share of a market and expand the technology to new applications. The cycle of iterative improvements continues for generations, until the next new approach makes a breakthrough appearance and displaces the established technology from some area of applications. New approaches that seek a foothold are considered disruptive technologies, in contrast with a mature approach that enjoys incremental change. If the new technology succeeds at displacing the established technology from a majority of its applications, then it represents a paradigm shift – a completely new way of achieving a function (Kuhn, 1996). For any disruptive technology to gain a foothold in an established market, it must offer significant performance improvement. Generally speaking, one or more performance metric must improve by an order of magnitude, while all other metrics are competitively equal. The basic characteristics of magnetoelectronic devices can be listed simply. On the positive side, they (1) have intrinsic nonvolatility (equivalently, they are latching), (2) have fast switching speeds, (3) require low energy to switch, (4) can switch repeatedly with high durability, (5) retain their state with long endurance, (6) are scalable to small dimensions, (7) are fabricated from common metallic materials, (8) are not vulnerable to radiation damage, and (9) are lithographically processed with fairly standard techniques. On the negative side, and at the present state of research, they (1) do not have power gain, (2) have limited tolerance to variation of input levels, and (3) require processing steps not typically found on a CMOS production line. Furthermore, (4) scaling has not been successfully demonstrated at size scales below 100 nm. The discussion in the above section has offered an introduction to the positive attributes. The negative characteristics are treated in Section 1.2.2, but are worthy of a few remarks. (1) As mentioned above, a ferromagnetic element can be described as a transducer of magnetic field with magnetic gain, bM : The coercivity HC may be quite small, and the mean internal field 4pMs ; which is also the magnitude of the fringe field near the end of the element, is quite large. Thus, the magnetic gain can be the order of bM ¼ 4pMs =HC , 1000: This gain is similar to that offered by a transformer, which can give a current or voltage gain. Some spintronic devices have been designed in a way to provide current gain (Clinton and Johnson, 1999), however, prototypes that demonstrate significant gain have not been reported. A transformer cannot offer power gain, and there are no prototype spintronic devices that have come close to achieving power gain.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
13
(2) For a given ferromagnetic element, and the associated magnetoelectronic device, the input levels are set by the value of the saturation (or switching) field Hs : For an ensemble of elements, or for a large number of switching events for a single element, this value does not reproduce with arbitrarily good precision. The study of the static and dynamic magnetization states of patterned ferromagnetic elements is presently at the forefront of basic research and is discussed in Chapter 5. An understanding of the key parameters that determine domain formation is crucial to improving the reproducibility of Hs : (3) While the introduction of a ferromagnetic metal, such as Ni, Fe or Co, to a CMOS production line is anathema to most process engineers, the successful introduction of Cu as a metalization layer offers hope for a more generalized acceptance of nonstandard metals. A greater concern is that most ferromagnetic device components are fabricated by dry etch, using new and original recipes uniquely developed for a given ferromagnetic material. These etching processes are nonstandard, and pose a risk of damage to underlying CMOS levels. While the damage may be repaired by a subsequent anneal, care must be taken that the anneal does not damage the magnetic device structure. (4) In many prototype devices, the aspect ratio of the ferromagnetic element [the ratio L=f in Fig. 1.1(a)] has been diminished in an effort to reduce the area of the cell. The consequent removal of shape anisotropy as a source of uniaxial anisotropy has made the reproducibility problems (2) worse. While individual prototypes with critical feature sizes f smaller than 100 nm have demonstrated successful operation, large-scale prototype arrays with such small feature sizes have not yet been demonstrated. Given these attributes, both positive and negative, one must analyze the capabilities and deficiencies of existing semiconductor technology in order to see where magnetoelectronics can make a successful breakthrough. In the subsections below, three applications areas are presented.
1.2.1.1
Nonvolatile random access memory
Because nonvolatility is a characteristic of the bistable states of a ferromagnetic element, magnetoelectronic devices are, intrinsically, nonvolatile storage cells and a natural application for the technology to pursue is integrated memory. The existing CMOS approach is based on the floating gate FET cell, discussed in some detail in Section 1.2.3. Historically, these devices have been called programmable read only memory (PROM), erasable PROM (EPROM), electrically erasable PROM (EEPROM) and other acronyms, but the technology is based on a floating gate. Floating gate technology is highly successful, and has enjoyed many generations of incremental improvement. Some architectures are bit addressable, using one or two FETs for cell isolation and selection, and these memory chips with relatively high performance and low density are used in embedded applications. In other architectures (FLASH), the cells cannot be individually erased, but chips are fabricated with high density and relatively low cost. Cell size can
14
M. Johnson
be as small as 10 – 12f 2 : Some cell designs store 2 bits per cell, allowing cell size to shrink as small as 8f 2 : These inexpensive memories have become popular in consumer electronics (Campardo and Micheloni, 2003). Despite its success, the floating gate approach is made vulnerable by several weaknesses mentioned earlier. To reiterate a few key points, the write times of roughly 10 ms are slow, and the erase times of order 0.1–1 ms are glacially slow. Since the devices are drawing power during write and erase processes, energy consumption for writing and erasing is large. Tunneling at high voltage to move charge on and off the island gradually wears down the dielectric, resulting in poor endurance. Some devices wear out after a few thousand write/erase cycles, and few device designs withstand more than 100 000 cycles. Finally, floating gate cells are susceptible to radiation damage. For nonvolatile memory, magnetoelectronics can offer order of magnitude improvement in all of these performance categories. The write process also accomplishes an erasure, and writing times are on the order of a few nanoseconds, about 103 (105) times faster than floating gate write (erase) times. The operating power is about the same, so energy consumption per write (erase) cycle is smaller by 1023 (1025). Magnetoelectronic cells have nearly infinite durability and endurance, with many prototype designs tested at .1015 cycles. Finally, most spintronic cells are not susceptible to radiation damage. If magnetoelectronic memories can be manufactured with packing densities that are comparable to CMOS, 10 – 12f 2 ; it is plausible that spintronics can make a breakthrough and gain a foothold in the growing nonvolatile memory market.
1.2.1.2
Reprogrammable logic
Application-specific integrated circuits (ASICs), an extension of CMOS into new microprocessor applications, were extremely successful in the 1990s. However, the cost of engineering and manufacturing an individual ASIC chip can be prohibitive. Programmable logic offers a relatively inexpensive and flexible alternative, and has become quite successful in recent years. The typical CMOS approach is known as the field programmable gate array (FPGA). A chip is composed of an array of roughly 100–1000 cells. Each cell has an arrangement of FETs, called a Boolean function unit (BFU). Like any logic gate, the BFU receives two inputs, processes a result and sends out one output. However, the BFU has several additional inputs and the particular Boolean function that the unit performs is defined by values applied to those inputs. The cell contains a look-up table (LUT) which stores the values that will be applied to these controlling inputs. Finally, the cells are connected together by a network of switches. The FPGAs are mass produced, and an engineer modifies the FPGA for a specific application by first determining the function of each cell, second choosing the values for the LUT of each cell, and third designing the connectivity of cells. In most FPGAs, the BFUs are CMOS FETs, the LUTs are SRAM, and the connecting switches are typically either fuses or antifuses. Once the connecting paths are set, for example, by blowing all fuses except those for the desired paths (or by forming ‘antifuses’ along
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
15
a desired path), the chip has been programmed and its function cannot be changed. Furthermore, since SRAM is volatile and loses memory if power is interrupted, FPGAs that are programmed for a specific application must be packaged with a ROM chip having backup LUT data. In competition against ASICs, FPGAs have enjoyed great success, but the approach is vulnerable. FPGAs are programmable, but it would be a much more powerful technology to offer reprogrammable logic. The function of a reprogrammable chip could be changed, and could be changed numerous times. In other words, a hardware upgrade becomes possible by purely using software. Reprogrammability allows circuits to be self-healing. It also allows systems engineers to reprogram circuits to perform new functions, offering endurance and diminishing the size of the required system. The advantages are obvious for remote applications such as a space platform. The magnetoelectronic approach to reprogrammable logic will be discussed in detail in Chapter 6.
1.2.1.3
System on a chip
While CMOS technology has become highly developed, the functions of digital circuit components have become differentiated. Described in more detail in Section 1.2.3, information processing and Boolean logic operations use planar FET cells, whereas memory (DRAM) typically uses ‘vertical’ cells with trenched capacitors. Because the processing steps are quite different, planar and vertical cells are not fabricated on the same chip, and it follows that logic and high density memory cannot easily share the same chip. Static random access memory (SRAM) is a high performance memory that uses planar cells, but the cell size is relatively large, packing densities are small, and SRAM memories have relatively small bit count. One of the challenges of magnetoelectronics is to develop CMOS compatible processing, so that MRAMs can be fabricated on the same chips as planar cells, facilitating the combination of memory and logic on the same chip. Going one step further, proposed ideas for reprogrammable and dynamically programmable logic use the same cell that is used for memory (Johnson, 2000b). Thus, large-scale integration of memory and logic is automatically achieved, and this is important for high performance computing. More specifically, the capacity of high performance on-chip cache memory may be increased by an order of magnitude. Furthermore, sectors of cells can be dynamically apportioned to perform as logic or memory according to changing needs. Finally, many embedded applications involve the acquisition of data from a sensor, with subsequent signal processing and storage of results. Many of the relevant sensors are magnetic, and these can be fabricated on the same chip as the magnetoelectronic logic and memory array, using the same processes (or subsets of the same processes). The result is a true ‘system on a chip’, described in greater detail in Chapter 6, with potential advantages in performance and cost.
16
M. Johnson
1.2.2
What are the key engineering issues magnetoelectronics must solve?
Challenging and important problems exist in a number of subfields of magnetoelectronics. A variety of prototype device structures have demonstrated performance properties that are more than adequate to compete as nonvolatile storage cells: good readout voltage levels, good signal-tonoise ratio, low operating power, good endurance and good durability under a wide range of operating conditions. However, several issues must be overcome before the technology is successful in the market. Even low density memories for embedded applications require capacities of roughly 1 Mb. For a product to reach viability, operating margins must be tight so that manufacturing yields are viable. The fraction of faulty bits must be on the order of one in 105 or better.
1.2.2.1
Margins on input levels
A key margin that limits magnetoelectronic device development is reproducibility of the switching threshold. Successful operation of half-select processes requires that repeated application of single write pulses IW must fail to alter the magnetization state, i.e. fail to ‘disturb’ the bit, but that application of two simultaneous write pulses must create the desired orientation with extremely high probability of success. Referring to Fig. 1.1(b), the hysteresis loop of each element must be sufficiently square that local application of field Hs =2 will not alter the magnetization orientation. Furthermore, the shape and characteristic saturation value Hs of each loop must reproduce within a narrow margin (of order a few percent) for each switching event. A more stringent requirement is that the loops for all elements must be identical within similar margins. Designing appropriate ferromagnetic elements involves basic research on the properties of magnetic materials, and is further discussed in Chapters 4 and 5. Details of the hysteresis loops and of magnetization switching depend on the statics and dynamics of domain formation. These are topics of intense materials research, along with related studies that might lead to the development of single domain elements. One approach involves film growth with a preferred crystallographic direction, in order to use an associated crystallographic magnetization anisotropy. Another uses a bilayer that incorporates a thin antiferromagnetic film to magnetically bias the magnetization of F. Engineering novel write architectures, for example, using sequences of pulses or write pulses from more than two write wires, may also solve this problem.
1.2.2.2
Margins on output levels
Equally important constraints exist on the reproducibility of the output levels. The problem can be illustrated with a simple example. Consider a device with average impedance of 100 V, 10% difference between low and high output levels, and a simple architecture that performs readout by
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
17
comparing output voltage with a standard, threshold value. Even with an infinite signal-to-noise ratio, average device impedance must reproduce within ^5% among all devices. If not, the low level of some devices will be confused with the high level of others. Achieving adequate readout margins involves device engineering and materials research. Spin valves in memory cells have average impedances of about 50 V and magnetoresistive ratios MR ¼ DR=R of roughly 10% (refer to Chapters 2 and 4). These low resistance structures tend to require high bias currents. Resistance drifts related to heating, or long-term irreversible damage resulting from electromigration in the magnetic metal multilayers, can be problems that limit margins. MTJs in memory cells have average impedances of about 10 000 V and magnetoresistive ratios (at low bias) of roughly 40% (refer to Chapters 3, 4 and 5). While the larger MR is favorable for easy discrimination, the device impedance is determined by the thin tunnel barrier that separates the two ferromagnetic layers. The device impedance varies exponentially with tunnel barrier thickness, and thicknesses of only a few monolayers (0.7 –0.9 nm) are required to achieve the relatively low impedance of roughly 10 000 V. Because of the difficulty of controlling the barrier thickness, values of device impedance can vary by 50% or more across an 8 in. wafer for the earliest prototype arrays. Thus, reproducibility of output levels is a problem for both spin valves and MTJs. One approach for solving this problem involves research on materials that are characterized by higher values of polarized current. The transition metal ferromagnets (Fe, Ni, Co and their alloys) have polarizations of approximately 35 –50% (Soulen et al., 1998). Other magnetic materials, including half-metal ferromagnets such as chromium dioxide and Heusler alloys, may have polarizations approaching 100%. Since MR depends sensitively on spin polarization, substantially larger values of MR may be possible for spin valves and MTJs, greatly easing problems with output margins.
1.2.2.3
Scalability
For magnetoelectronic technology to succeed, patterned ferromagnetic elements are required to maintain their characteristics when fabricated with small minimum feature sizes, f : However, all of the factors that affect this scaling are not entirely understood, and this is an area of active research. Thermally stable spontaneous magnetization should persist at dimensions as small as f , 10 nm. The anisotropy energy of an element, which maintains the two stable magnetization states, is proportional to its volume. At small dimensions, this energy may be smaller than the thermal energy kB T; with kB Boltzmann’s constant. ‘Superparamagnetism’ refers to this thermally unstable regime. The high density applications of magnetoelectronics that are planned for the future require that elements must be patterned with feature sizes f comparable with, or smaller than, those that are promised for the CMOS roadmap. The limits of the superparamagnetic regime must be delineated so that the limits of spintronic scaling will be known. While thermal stability imposes a strict limitation on scaling, the dependence of switching field (saturation field) Hs on feature size f is also crucially important. For many materials,
18
M. Johnson
Hs increases as f decreases (Ruhrig et al., 1996; Kirk et al., 1997). This drives up the amplitude of write current and therefore of operating power, and becomes a performance obstacle. There are some materials that show weak dependence of Hs with f ; and continuing research is focussing on the design of elements and architectures that can achieve reliable switching with low power at very small feature sizes.
1.2.3
What is the existing technology where magnetoelectronics seeks to find market entry?
The entry and establishment of magnetoelectronics in integrated digital electronics markets depends on successfully challenging existing CMOS industry. This section provides a brief review of some features of CMOS technology. The CMOS FET is the device at the heart of the technology. The CMOS FET uses supply voltages of few volts, has power gain, and can be fabricated with feature sizes of order f ¼ 100 nm. The industry is divided between memory and digital information processing (logic) applications. The latter requires power gain for device fanout from one logic gate to a series of subsequent gate operations. Memory is typically based on a passive device, a capacitor, similar to the spintronic approach that uses passive magnetoresistive devices.
1.2.3.1
CMOS memory
Three standard CMOS approaches to memory, DRAM, floating gate, and SRAM, are depicted in Fig. 1.5(a)–(c). The architecture for a DRAM cell is shown in Fig. 1.5(a). The two charge states of a single capacitor C, charged or uncharged, store the binary data ‘1’ or ‘0’. A single select transistor, addressed with a word line, is used for both writing and reading the charge state of C. Since leakage currents deplete the charge below a detectable threshold in a time on the order of milliseconds, this memory cell is volatile and circuitry must be provided to read and rewrite (refresh) the charge state of each cell with a period of every few milliseconds. As discussed below, a DRAM cell can be fabricated with small dimensions, cell sizes are as small as 6f 2 ; and DRAMs have correspondingly large packing density. The architecture permits read, write and access times on the order of 10 ns. A floating gate cell is depicted in Fig. 1.5(b). The ‘floating gate’ is a small metal island embedded in the gate dielectric of an FET. The two charge states of the island, charged or uncharged, store the binary data ‘1’ or ‘0’. The states are written by tunneling charge onto the island at relatively high voltage, and are erased by tunneling charge off the island at a higher reverse bias. The gate dielectric is sufficiently thick that charge can be stored on the island for years, and the memory of this cell is nonvolatile. The value of the gate capacitance Cg is a function of the charge state of the gate. Thus, the datum stored in the cell is read by measuring the
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
(a)
19
(b) Word Line
Word Line Floating Gate
Storage Capacitor Bit Line
Drive Line
Bit Line
(c)
(d) TOP VIEW
L
Word Line VDD
f
D
S G
G Bit Line
gate oxide
D
S CROSS SECTION
(e)
select transistor storage capacitor CROSS SECTION
Fig. 1.5 CMOS device structures used in a variety of memory cells. Schematic cell for (a) DRAM, (b) floating gate NVRAM. (c) SRAM cell and logic diagram. (d) Top and cross-sectional views of simplified CMOS FET structure. (e) Cross-sectional view of DRAM cell, showing trenched capacitor.
capacitance Cg using the word and drive lines (Sharma, 1997). The floating gate storage cell is the basis of semiconductor NVRAM. Although writing and erasing are slow, read and access times are fast. Floating gate cells can be fabricated with dimensions as small as f ¼ 100 nm, but scaling is expected to be a problem below f ¼ 45 nm. However, density is often less critical for NVRAM applications and memories are produced using older production lines and larger feature sizes. Cell sizes are roughly 12f 2 ; but some designs fit 2 bits per cell and achieve cell sizes as small as 8f 2 : A static RAM cell is shown in Fig. 1.5(c), along with its associated logic diagram. Each cell has a combination of 4–6 FETs arranged as cross-coupled inverters so that the output is latched
20
M. Johnson
HIGH or LOW. After the bit state has been written, the latched state is maintained by the static supply voltage VDD : If power is interrupted, memory is lost and storage is volatile. On the other hand, the datum does not need to be refreshed as long as the supply voltage is maintained. The read, write and access times are all fast, and SRAM is the high performance, low power memory that is used, for example, as cache memory for your computer’s central processing unit (CPU). CMOS FETs are planar device structures. Figure 1.5(d) shows top and side views of source (S), drain (D) and gate (G) of a simplified device. The source and drain are typically fabricated by doping regions of the substrate with dimensions as small as f : A variety of lithographic techniques can be used to make the channel length L between source and drain smaller than f : Channel lengths have become so small that many FETs operate in a nearly ballistic, rather than purely diffusive, transport regime. The gate dielectric and gate metal G are then fabricated over the channel. As a general rule, current driven through the FET of Fig. 1.5(d) is proportional to f =L: FETs with substantial power gain, used for signal and logical processing, typically have larger dimensions than FETs used as select transistors in memories, which require little gain. By contrast, DRAM cells are not planar structures. Engineers have minimized their size by making vertical capacitors (Sze, 1998). As shown in the cross-sectional drawing of Fig. 1.5(e), a deep trench is etched in the surface of the substrate, the opposing faces are coated with a metal film, and the gap between the metal electrodes is filled with a dielectric. Using this remarkable ‘trenching’ technology involves hundreds of process steps that are uniquely different from the fabrication steps for planar FETs, and separate process lines are built and used for DRAM and for planar FET production. But this approach has resulted in a cell with area dominated by the area of the select transistor. Including pitch, the distance between adjacent cells, DRAM cells are as small as 6f 2 : This is a remarkable achievement when you consider that the smallest possible cell is determined by the area of crossing bit and word lines and has area of 4f 2 : Note that SRAM cells require 4– 6 planar FET devices, and high density cannot be achieved. The high performance of SRAM is achieved by sacrificing density and cost.
1.2.3.2
CMOS logic and signal processing
The CMOS approach to Boolean logic and digital signal processing relies on the power gain of the CMOS FET to swing voltage thresholds and then to pin output values to levels used as inputs at subsequent logic gates. Operations are typically performed with digital voltage pulses and a single logic gate cell is composed of an arrangement of FETs that are linked together in an appropriate way. As an example, one standard arrangement of FETs that operates as an AND gate cell is depicted in Fig. 1.6 (Horowitz and Hill, 1980). As described below, and depicted with the logic diagram in Fig. 1.6(b), this cell is a NAND gate followed by an inverter. Each element FETi is an enhancement mode FET. For a simple understanding of gate operation, consider the FETs to be switches that can be latched ‘on’ or ‘off’ for the duration of the input pulses, depending on the voltage applied to the gate. FET1, FET2 and FET5 are p-channel FETs. A p-channel FET is in
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
21
VDD
(a) FET1
FET2
FET5 y
OUT
A FET3
FET6
B FET4
(b) A OUT B
Fig. 1.6 (a) An arrangement of CMOS FETs that operates as a Boolean AND logic gate. (b) Logic diagram for circuit (a).
the ‘off’ state when the gate voltage is equal to or larger than the source voltage. The impedance switches to a low value, and is therefore in the ‘on’ state, when the gate voltage is lower than a threshold value below the source voltage. A typical threshold value is a few hundred millivolts. FET3, FET4 and FET6 are n-channel FETs. An n-channel FET is ‘off’ when the gate voltage is zero or below ground and ‘on’ when the gate voltage is larger than a threshold value above ground. Voltage pulses of positive or zero amplitude (HIGH or ‘1’; or LOW or ‘0’) are applied simultaneously to the inputs A and B; and the cell operates as an AND gate in the following way. When A and B are HIGH (‘1’ þ ‘1’), FET3 and FET4 are ‘on’, FET1 and FET2 are ‘off’, and consequently the voltage at node y is LOW, i.e. at ground. Since FET6 is ‘off’ and FET5 is ‘on’ the voltage output (OUT) is HIGH (‘1’). When A and B are LOW (‘0’ þ ‘0’), FET3 and FET4 are ‘off’, FET1 and FET2 are ‘on’, and consequently the voltage at node y is HIGH. Since FET5 is ‘off’ and FET6 is ‘on’ the voltage output (OUT) 28 is LOW, at ground (‘0’). When A (or B) is HIGH and B (or A) is LOW (‘1’ þ ‘0’), FET3 and FET2 are ‘on’, FET1 and FET4 are ‘off’, and consequently the voltage at node y is HIGH and the voltage output (OUT) 28 is LOW, at ground (‘0’). The truth table for the above operations therefore corresponds to that of an AND gate. Cells with similar arrangements of FETs form other basic logic gates such as NAND, OR, NOR and XOR. In the example of Fig. 1.6, notice that an arrangement of four FETs (FET1 –FET4) performs the logical operation of a NAND gate and delivers a low or high voltage to node y.
22
M. Johnson
The output is inverted by FET5 and FET6 so that the final output voltage is pinned (for the duration of a clock cycle) at HIGH or LOW voltages, V ¼ VDD or V ¼ 0: The gain of the first four FETs is used to ensure reproducibility of the logical operation, and the gain of the output stage is used to provide voltage levels that are then transmitted, by fanout, to subsequent devices. Although logic gates of this design are the backbone of digital electronic information processing, they suffer from a few disadvantages. Each FET is a planar device and takes up considerable space. Numerous FETs [six in the example of Fig. 1.6(a)] are required to form the logic gate cell, and therefore each cell occupies a large area of the chip. Furthermore, the result of the Boolean process is not stored and must be synchronized with a clock cycle to be used in the next processing step. A goal of high performance computing is the on-chip integration of memory and logic. When memory and logic occupy different chips, the parasitic time delay associated with moving signals between chips, known as latency, degrades speed and performance. High performance memory that is characterized by read, write and access speeds that are comparable with the processor speed is known as cache memory and is fabricated on-chip with the processor. Presently, cache memory uses SRAM, which has sufficiently high performance. Of equal importance, SRAM uses planar FETs and therefore can be fabricated on the same production line, using the same production steps, as the processing cells. The tradeoff, of course, is area: SRAM cells have relatively low density, using 4–6 FETs [Fig. 1.5(c)] and requiring correspondingly large area on the chip. As the performance of DRAM has improved, interest in the possibility of fabricating integrated DRAM cache has grown. Unfortunately, the trenched, vertical cells used by DRAM cannot be fabricated on the same production line used for the planar cells of the CPU. This problem for high performance CMOS computing is presently unresolved, and represents a weakness that may be exploited by an alternative technology. As a general rule, however, the success of CMOS digital electronics is truly remarkable. Within a few years, commercially available chips will be fabricated with minimum features of f ¼ 70 nm and information processing will operate at multi-GHz clock speeds. Those readers who have a background in magnetism must realize that CMOS architecture is so well established that there are large design libraries of CMOS devices, and relatively inexpensive device simulation software is readily available to engineers. Chips can be designed with relative ease. As an alternative technology, magnetoelectronics is not established and has none of these refinements. Since the beginning of the semiconductor industry, pessimists have speculated about the limits of scaling and the ultimate demise of the technology. It is an obvious truth that the industry has always found solutions to the supposed limits and has continued to flourish. Magnetoelectronics will do well if it can identify niche applications where its advantages propel it to dominance. It may then expand its sphere of applications. The crucial point is that magnetoelectronics will succeed if it can coexist with CMOS in a complementary way.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
1.3
23
Spin vs charge
Scientists with a strong background in charge transport, for example, a knowledge of electrostatics, electricity and magnetism, and/or electrical engineering, will find that magnetism and the transport of spin-polarized electrons are quite different from charge transport. Intuition that has developed based on electrostatics will be misleading for spin transport. In this section, a framework for physical insight into spin-polarized transport is developed. Basic concepts of transport in nonmagnetic and ferromagnetic metals are reviewed for the benefit of those coming from a semiconductor background. Basic concepts of semiconductor physics are reviewed for the benefit of those coming from a magnetism background. By the end of the section, the differences between operational principles of semiconductor and spintronic devices should be clear. 1.3.1
Heuristic ideas
Spintronics is based on the ‘coupling’ of electron charge and spin (Johnson and Silsbee, 1985, 1988a). Two fundamental properties reside with each conduction electron, the unit charge e and the unit magnetic moment mB ; the Bohr magneton, which is related to the quantum mechanical spin S by mB ¼ 2ðe"=mcÞS; with m the electron mass and c the speed of light. Here S is dimensionless and has values þ1/2 or 2l/2 for conduction electrons. Note that alternative discussions define S with units, S ¼ þ"=2 or 2"=2: The underlying principle of spin electronics relies on charge–spin coupling: parameters of charge transport, such as voltage or current, are modulated in a device structure by manipulating the spin, using new control parameters such as magnetic field or new materials properties such as magnetization. The charge–spin coupling that resides with individual electrons leads to the false intuition that charge and spin are closely coupled for populations of carriers. In fact, for an ensemble of particles, the coupling is statistical and is generally weak (Johnson and Byers, 2003). There are many possible spin distributions for any single charge distribution. But because of the statistics of large populations, the coupling of charge and spin results in substantial effects that can be used successfully for device modulation. Consider the differences between charge and spin in a heuristic picture of a nonmagnetic metal. Charge comes with two polarities, positive and negative, the basic charge is a monopole, and the unit charge on any electron is neither created nor destroyed. Coulomb interactions are very strong, and charge perturbations are shielded on a very short length scale, the Thomas–Fermi ˚ . These strong interactions lead to conveniently large forces, and screening length, of order 1 A relatively large transport effects (changes of currents or voltages) that are readily observed and easily used to control integrated devices. By contrast, the basic ‘moment’ of a spin is a dipole, not a monopole. The dipolar fields may be strong at very short distances, but moments on two itinerant carriers interact only by mutual
24
M. Johnson
torques that affect their spin orientations. This heuristic description neglects an important effect called the exchange interaction, but it remains correct to say that spin –spin interactions are different from the purely inverse square law of Coulomb charge interactions. The energies involved in spin perturbations (nonequilibrium spin excitations) are small, and the shielding length is long. Thus, spin perturbations can exist in the form of spin accumulation (Johnson and Silsbee, 1987; Johnson, 1993a), a nonequilibrium population of spin-polarized electrons that is pumped by electrical spin injection. This occurs over a long length scale, a spin diffusion pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi length ds ¼ DT2 ; where D is the electron diffusion constant and T2 (or T1 ) the spin relaxation time, of order 1 mm in metal films (Johnson, 1993a). It is conceptually important to note that there is no charge accumulation in metals. Metals cannot sustain a static charge, and the strict boundary condition of current conservation is imposed on charge currents. Any static charge concentrates at the surface of a metal, such as a surface of a capacitor plate. Any dynamic charge dissipates with a characteristic time known as a Maxwell time, many orders of magnitude faster than T2 : A related condition is that electron charge is quantized and never changes: charge is conserved in any sample. By contrast, although electron spin is quantized, spin transport effects are based on spin orientation, and the orientation is a continuous variable (Johnson and Silsbee, 1987): spin orientation is not conserved in any sample. Thus, ordinary electrodes attached to a conducting sample act as sources and sinks for charge current. A ferromagnetic electrode acts as a source for spin current, but spin relaxation is random and the sink for spin orientation is isotropic in a nonmagnetic metal sample. While these are important conceptual differences, it is also important to recognize that all-metal magnetoelectronic devices, MTJs and spin valves, do not operate in a regime sensitive to nonequilibrium effects. These devices are fabricated with layers that have thicknesses less than an electron ballistic mean free path, ‘: Device operation relies on diffusive transport over a very short length, d p ds ; and effects related to spin relaxation are relatively small. For the MTJ, a thin insulating barrier, with thickness dI ; separates two ferromagnetic films having thicknesses of order a few nanometers. The tunnel currents are small and nonequilibrium effects in the F films are negligible. For a CIP spin valve [refer to Fig. 1.3(g)], the thickness, dN ; of the nonmagnetic layer N is a few nanometers, dN , ‘ p ds : Current-perpendicular-to-the-plane (CPP) spin valves are typically multilayered
structures and the current flow is perpendicular to the plane of the layers. This is usually achieved by reducing the lateral dimensions to the order of 100 nm and using high conductivity electrodes on the top and bottom of the multilayer stack. Nonequilibrium spin populations can exist in the N layers and in the F layers, over the short length ds;f < 5 nm (Dubois et al., 1999), in CPP spin valves (Johnson and Silsbee, 1987; Johnson, 1991). However, these spin accumulation effects are smaller than the effects of interfacial spin scattering.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
25
Thus, spin transport devices are designed to operate on spatial scales smaller than relevant nonequilibrium lengths. This contrasts with semiconductor technology, where traditional devices were designed to operate on spatial scales larger than the relevant charge shielding length.
1.3.2
Transport in semiconductors
For readers with a background in magnetism and little knowledge of semiconductors, this subsection provides a simplified presentation of a few of the most basic ideas. Readers with a strong electronics background may wish to skip this subsection. Section 1.3.3 describes basic ideas of transport in metals and, in particular, in ferromagnetic metals. Since there are many important differences, a brief review of semiconductors may serve as a foundation for contrast for any reader. A semiconductor is not an insulator, nor is it a good conductor of electric charge. In a band picture of a solid, each atom in the lattice can donate one or more of its valence electrons to the crystal. Each atom may alternatively accept an electron and donate a hole. The energy states available to each conduction electron are calculated from the periodic electrostatic potential profile of the ionic crystal and form ‘bands’. These states are then filled according to the number of available conduction electrons and the laws of thermal population distribution. It is common to ~ equivalently of the velocity ~v; of the carrier. It plot energy bands as a function of the wavevector k; is also useful to plot the density of energy levels, equivalently called the density of energy states NðEÞ; as a function of carrier energy E: An example of such a plot is shown in Fig. 1.7. By definition, semiconductors and insulators have no partially filled bands. At zero temperature, all of the states in the valence band are full of electrons (fully occupied) and all of the states in the conduction band are empty of electrons (entirely unoccupied). In a semiconductor at nonzero
E
empty electron states in conduction band
states filled with electrons in conduction band
EC µ
empty states (holes) in valence band
Eg EV filled states (electrons) in valence band
N(E)
Fig. 1.7 Energy bands of a semiconductor, density of states NðEÞ as a function of energy E: The chemical potential is in the middle of the gap.
26
M. Johnson
temperature, some carriers at the top of the valence band may be thermally excited into states at the bottom of the conduction band, as shown in Fig. 1.7. Some important terminology can now be introduced. The chemical potential m is the energy required to add one more particle to the system. The Fermi energy EF is defined as the energy of the highest occupied level. In metals, the chemical potential is approximately the same as the Fermi energy. The chemical potential of an insulator or a semiconductor lies between the highest energy of the highest occupied band (the valence energy EV of the valence band) and the lowest energy of the lowest unoccupied band (the conduction energy EC of the conduction band). The difference between the conduction and valence energies is the gap energy, Eg ¼ EC 2 EV : For an insulator, the energy gap Eg is so large that carriers are never excited from the valence band to the conduction band, and the material is electrically ‘insulating’ (nonconducting) precisely because of the complete lack of carriers in the conduction band. In a semiconductor such as silicon or gallium arsenide, the energy gap has value 1.1 and 1.4 eV, respectively. This is more than an order of magnitude larger than kB T even at room temperature, kB T < 25 meV: For pure semiconductors that have not been doped with any impurities (called intrinsic semiconductors), the number of carriers that can be thermally excited is miniscule, and intrinsic semiconductors behave as reasonably good insulators. Returning to the schematic of a semiconductor at finite temperature in Fig. 1.7, the next particle added to the system could go into the top of the valence band or the bottom of the conduction band, with the relevant probabilities determined by thermal statistics. On average, the energy of this next particle is in the gap between the bands, as shown by the location of the chemical potential m in Fig. 1.7. The Fermi energy, however, is the energy of the highest filled band and therefore lies in the valence band. When talking about metals, it is a widespread practice to use the terms chemical potential and Fermi energy synonymously, and this is acceptable. When talking about semiconductors, it is similarly a widespread practice to use these terms synonymously, but this practice is not correct (Ashcroft and Mermin, 1976). The chemical potential is the most relevant term, and it is not identically the same as the Fermi energy. A further complication should be mentioned, which will be relevant in the discussion below. ~ A semiconductor can sustain an internal electric field, for example EðxÞ; that is described by an electrostatic potential fðxÞ: Inside a semiconductor, the position-dependent electrochemical potential is defined as me ðxÞ ¼ m þ efðxÞ: Dilute doping of a semiconductor adds impurity sites that donate conduction electrons (n-type doping) or accept electrons and donate holes (p-type doping) as carriers in the lattice. Doped semiconductors are called extrinsic. The effect of doping is to create and fill a narrow band of states near the conduction (n-doped) or valence (p-doped) band edges, and the chemical potential moves towards this narrow band. For relatively light doping, the chemical potential remains in the gap and, roughly speaking, is not within an energy range kB T of the conduction or valence band energy. For electron doping, for example, EC 2 m . kB T describes a lightly doped system. When EC 2 m is a few times kB T; the thermal distribution of carriers is described by
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
27
Maxwell –Boltzmann statistics, and such a system is called nondegenerate. As the doping is increased, the chemical potential moves closer to the conduction (or valence) band edge. For sufficiently high doping, the chemical potential shifts into the bands, mimicking the situation of metals. When EC 2 m (or lEV 2 ml) is less than kB T; the thermal distribution of carriers is described by Fermi statistics, and such a system is called degenerate. It is relatively common, and approximately correct, to use the terms chemical potential and Fermi energy synonymously for degenerate semiconductors. The response of an insulator to an electric field is a change of the electrostatic polarization of the material, described by the dielectric constant. In a conductor, mobile carriers can move in a way that cancels the perturbation and ‘screens’ the electric field from the crystal. The screening length (Ashcroft and Mermin, 1976) is inversely proportional with the square root of carrier density. This is consistent with intuition: When a high density of carriers is available, an electric field perturbation can be screened within a short distance, but a low density of carriers requires a much larger volume to cancel the field. In metals, carrier densities are on the order of 1022 cm23 and the screening length (the Thomas–Fermi length) ˚ . Extrinsic semiconductors have carrier densities typically in the range is on the order of 1 A 14 18 23 10 –10 cm , and the screening length is much longer. Thus, electric fields can exist in semiconductors over relatively large distances, of order 10– 1000 nm. The ability to sustain an internal electric field is one basis for the operation of semiconductor electronic devices. Such fields can be created in a semiconductor that has a doping profile that changes with position, and these materials are called inhomogeneous semiconductors. In one basic and fundamental example, an n-doped region is brought into contact with a p-doped region. This might be achieved, for example, by a lithographic process in which the semiconductor surface is protected by photoresist, except for a small region which is exposed to an ion implantation process of acceptor ions. In a subsequent step, the surface is protected by photoresist, except for a small contiguous region which is exposed to ion implantation of donors. There may be a small amount of mass diffusion of the donors and acceptors after implantation, but a sharp interface between an n-doped and a p-doped region can be achieved. The doping is relatively light, and the nondegenerate system can be described by Maxwell –Boltzmann statistics. This structure, of course, is called a p –n junction. Far away from the interface, the density of carriers in the conduction (valence) band in the n (p) region is approximately the same as the density of dopants, Nd ðNa Þ. Near the interface, electrons and holes diffuse in order to electrically neutralize the donor and acceptor sites. Some of the sites are neutralized, with the loss of some of the mobile carriers. An equilibrium state is reached when the internal (built-in) electric field in the interface region prohibits further charge flow. The two regions, on either side of the interface, where the number of carriers is reduced is called a ‘space-charge’ region. Since the density of carriers is depleted relative to the value remote from the interface, the space-charge region of the p–n junction is also called a depletion region.
28
M. Johnson
The internal field can be on the order of 105 –107 V/m, sustained over depletion regions with lengths of 10 –100 nm. It is important to recognize that charge neutrality is not maintained in the depletion region; there is net positive charge on one side of the interface, and net negative charge on the other side. This deviation from charge neutrality forces the energy bands to bend, in order to meet at the interface, and also results in the internal electric field characterized by the electric potential fðxÞ: In thermal equilibrium, the chemical potential m is constant on both sides of the interface. The electrochemical potential me ðxÞ ¼ m þ efðxÞ; however, varies smoothly and continuously throughout the depletion region. The ‘built-in’ electric field and associated band-bending have dramatic effects on charge transport. Current rectification is a remarkable example for the case of the p–n junction diode. Detailed treatments of p–n junctions can be found in a variety of texts for equilibrium conditions and under voltage or current bias (Ashcroft and Mermin, 1976; Sze, 1981). In the context of the present discussion, the important observation is that transport characteristics such as net current density or net voltage measured across a device structure are highly nonlinear functions of carrier density and bias conditions. More complicated device structures, such as bipolar transistors, can utilize these nonlinearities so that a small modulation of one device parameter can result in a much larger modulation of another parameter. In this way, semiconductor devices can achieve power gain: the input power of a modulated signal is increased at the output stage, with the power increase provided by a control parameter at a third terminal (Sze, 1981). The ability of an external electric field to penetrate a semiconductor is the basis for another kind of semiconductor electronics technology. When a metal is fabricated on a semiconductor with a thin insulating layer between them (MIS structure), redistribution of charge near the interface can result in bending of the conduction and valence bands and a thin space-charge region, depletion or accumulation, is formed in the semiconductor (Silsbee and Drager, 1997). The conductivity of this layer can be much larger than that of the bulk, and transport between two electrodes, a source and a drain that are laterally defined on either side of the MIS structure, is then dominated by the properties of this layer. Applying a voltage between the metal gate (M) and the bulk semiconductor (S), far away from the interface, results in an electric field that penetrates into the semiconductor. By attracting (repelling) itinerant charge carriers from (to) the bulk to (from) the space-charge region, modulation of the gate voltage causes a modulation of the carrier density in the layer, and a modulation of the conductance between electrodes. Application of gate voltages of a few volts can, remarkably, modulate the source –drain conductance by many orders of magnitude. These FETs are extremely good switches of current or voltage, and the ratio of the conductivity in the ON state compared with that in the OFF state can be 105 or higher. These are active devices and are characterized by power gain. When the switch is set to the ON state, for example, the output voltage can be held to that of the supply voltage, VDD ; with an output impedance sufficiently large that the output voltage can be transmitted to numerous other devices on a line,
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
29
without degradation. As with the bipolar transistor, the power is supplied by the voltage applied to a third terminal, in this case the gate. Early discussions of FETs appeared in the 1950s and 1960s (Shockley, 1952; Dacy and Ross, 1955; Mead, 1966), and several texts provide an excellent discussion of detailed operation (Sze, 1998). The MIS structure that is inherent in the design of the FET is also, intrinsically, a capacitor. This fact is central to a parametric view of CMOS technology. Binary information is encoded in the form of voltages and voltage pulses, with amplitudes of order a few volts. The pulses are routed through transmission lines, and information is processed by triggering switching events in FETs. Inputs for these processes are applied capacitively, and the capacitive coupling leads to some limitations that are inherent in CMOS technology. Circuits are susceptible to parasitic capacitance, so that transmission lines and resistive contacts must be carefully designed to avoid RC degradation of high speed pulses. These problems become particularly important at high frequencies, and parasitic losses are most challenging in chips fabricated with small feature sizes. In other words, RC degradation is an important problem for CMOS scaling to higher densities and higher frequencies. On a related note, capacitors are intrinsically characterized by leakage currents. As discussed in Sections 1.2.1 and 1.2.3, this creates design problems for memory applications. Consider another aspect of an MIS structure with a space-charge region near the insulator– semiconductor interface. The thickness d of this layer can be as thin as a few tens of nanometers, which is roughly the same scale as the de Broglie wavelength of an electron, le : A question naturally arises: are there quantum effects when carriers are confined in an accumulation layer with thickness d < le ? It is well known that the answer is ‘yes’. Using a simple model of the carriers as ‘particles in a box’, the boundary condition d < le quantizes the momentum and energy levels along the dimension perpendicular to the plane of the layer, and the layer is known as a quantum well. The two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG), or two-dimensional electron system (2DES), was one of the great achievements of materials physics and condensed matter physics in the latter part of the twentieth century. 2DEGs were first discovered in MIS accumulation layers (Schrieffer, 1957; Fowler et al., 1966; Ando et al., 1982). Another fabrication technique, which resulted in higher electron mobilities, can be qualitatively described. If one fabricates a thin layer of an intrinsic semiconductor between two insulating layers, the resulting sheet of semiconductor will have few carriers and, therefore, an extremely large sheet resistance per square, Rsq ¼ r=d: A similar sample can be prepared by doping the semiconductor layer. While this increases the number of carriers, it also decreases the mobility because each donor provides a scattering site. The solution for achieving relatively high carrier density and high mobility is to move the dopants away from the semiconducting, quantum well layer. In a typical example, a quantum well layer of GaAs is grown between two insulating layers of AlGaAs. The band gap of AlGaAs is larger than that of GaAs. Dopants added to the AlGaAs layer occupy an energy higher than the conduction band energy of the GaAs. The carriers will diffuse to the GaAs and fill lower energy states in the
30
M. Johnson
conduction band. Thus, the carrier density in the GaAs quantum well is increased, but the impurity scattering sites are in the AlGaAs, remote from the quantum well. Typically, a thin insulating layer of AlGaAs separates the doped AlGaAs from the GaAs quantum well, to ensure that the Coulomb potential of the impurity sites is weak at, and has little effect on scattering in, the quantum well. These 2DEGs are remarkable systems for research, but have not yet found widespread applications. 1.3.3
Transport in metals
In a discussion of transport in metals, the band picture of a solid is still valid. Each atom in the lattice donates one or more of its valence electrons to the crystal. The energy states available to each conduction electron are again calculated from the periodic electrostatic potential profile of the ionic crystal and form ‘bands’. These states are filled as before, using the number of available conduction electrons and the laws of thermal population distribution. Here the key difference between a metal and a semiconductor becomes obvious: By definition, metals have at least one partially filled band. Equivalently stated, the chemical potential m and the Fermi energy EF lie in the middle of a band. The consequences of this difference are dramatic. The density of states for a metal and the filling of those states up to EF are depicted in Fig. 1.8. For a nonmagnetic metal such as copper, silver or gold [Fig. 1.8(a)], the conduction is dominated by electrons in a parabolic, free-electron band. Separate spin subbands for up- and down-spins are shown, because this will be important later, and the Fermi energy is on the order of a few electron volts. In a metal, electrons deep beneath the Fermi surface are ‘locked’ in their eigenstates. There are no empty states available for translation, and these electrons do not contribute to conduction. But there is nothing to prevent the relatively large number of electrons near the Fermi surface from conducting current. In a semiconductor, by contrast, the band gap prevents most carriers from contributing to electronic conduction. Furthermore, in a metal these electrons near EF have a large velocity, the Fermi velocity vF , 108 cm/s, and they can respond easily to an electric field. Thus, the electrical conductivity s (sometimes written as s ; g) of a metal is orders of magnitude larger than that of a semiconductor. It is more common to talk about resistivity r; and room temperature values of r for most common metals are in the range of 1026 V cm, compared with values of order 1021 V cm for a semiconductor (e.g. Si or Ge) with a doping level of order 1016 cm23. Another brief digression may help clarify some common terminology. In a semiconductor, a charge current Jq is caused to flow by the presence of an electric field E or by the presence of a gradient of carrier density, ›n=›x: These partial currents are called drift and diffusion currents, respectively. The former is characterized by a conductivity s that is proportional to the number of carriers and their mobility, mq ¼ etq =mq ; where q refers to electrons or holes, tq is a scattering time, and mq is an effective mass. Note that mq has nothing to do with the chemical potential, m:
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
(a)
g
E
31
g
EF
N (b) E
g g EF
3d 4s
Uex F N (E)
N (E)
Fig. 1.8 Energy bands of metals, density of states NðEÞ as a function of energy E: (a) Nonmagnetic metals have a free-electron, parabolic density of states, which is partially filled. (b) In a transition metal ferromagnet, the 4s and 3d bands are intersected by EF : The 3d band is exchange shifted by energy Uex :
The drift current is characterized by the self-diffusion constant of the carrier, Dq : The relationship between mobilities and diffusion constants is called the Einstein relations. In nondegenerate semiconductors, the Einstein relations are
mq ¼
eDq ; kB T
and they take a slightly different form for degenerate semiconductors (Ashcroft and Mermin, 1976). In metals, recall that charge neutrality is strictly obeyed and there are no gradients of carrier density. The conductivity of a metal is proportional to the density of electrons at the Fermi level, and therefore to the density of states of electrons at the Fermi level, NðEF Þ; and is given by a
32
M. Johnson
different Einstein relation, g / NðEF Þ (Ziman, 1972). The Pauli exclusion principle requires that up- and down-spin electrons be counted separately, and separate spin subbands can be used [Fig. 1.8(a)]. Electrons near the Fermi surface are constantly colliding, scattering and changing their momentum states. However, if the spin orientation remains unchanged during these events, it follows that a unique conductance can be written for both the up- and down-spin electrons (Johnson and Silsbee, 1988a): g" / N" ðEF Þ;
g# / N# ðEF Þ;
ð1:1Þ
as marked in Fig. 1.8(a). Notice that filling of the spin subbands for a nonmagnetic metal is symmetric and g" ¼ g# : Transition metal ferromagnets are quite different from nonmagnetic metals. First, the Fermi level cuts across more than one band. As sketched in Fig. 1.8(b), the Fermi surface intersects a free-electron 4s band. However, it also intersects a 3d band which is not a simple parabola. In a ferromagnetic metal, the 3d up- and down-spin subbands are shifted out of symmetry. Figure 1.8(b) represents a band model of ferromagnetism, and the shift is called an exchange splitting, Uex : In a ferromagnetic material, the ion cores in the lattice have a net, nonzero spin. These magnetic ions can interact with each other when their charge distributions overlap, and this effect is called the exchange interaction. Details of a band model of ferro-magnetism (Stoner, 1948; Ziman, 1972), and of the splitting Uex , are beyond the scope of this discussion, but the model has important ramifications. First, the number of down-spin conduction electrons differs from the number of up-spins, and this difference defines the spontaneous magnetization of the material: M ¼ mB
ð1
½N# ðEÞ 2 N" ðEÞ f ðEÞdE:
ð1:2Þ
0
Here f ðEÞ is the Fermi function which mathematically describes the filling of states pictured in Fig. 1.8. The down-spin subband is called the majority spin subband because it has more electrons and it therefore determines the magnetization direction. The up-spin subband is called the minority spin subband. Note that the choice of up- (down-) spin for the minority (majority) spin subband is arbitrary, and that the direction typically refers to the orientation of the magnetic moment. Second, the density of states at the Fermi level is different for the up- and down-spin subbands, N" ðEF Þ – N# ðEF Þ; and therefore the spin subband conductances are different: g" ðEF Þ – g# ðEF Þ:
ð1:3Þ
It follows that electrical currents carried by the two spin subbands are inequivalent, which is the same as saying that an electrical current in a ferromagnetic material has nonzero spin polarization. For a ferromagnetic material, the differences of band structure for the two spin subbands maintain unique and different conductances g" and g# : It was stated above for a nonmagnetic
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
33
U(r) s r
Fig. 1.9 An electron with spin ~s moves in the periodic potential UðrÞ of a metal with Fermi velocity vF : A weakly relativistic spin&orbit interaction can tip the spin orientation.
material that unique conductances could be defined if the electrons maintained their spin orientation during scattering events. This turns out to be true: spin orientation is robust. The spin orientation of an electron rarely flips, for a subtle but fundamental reason. Changing the orientation of a spin from an initial direction, known as spin relaxation, requires a magnetic torque, and there are few interactions that can provide an appropriate torque. A simple description of the dominant mechanism is aided with the sketch in Fig. 1.9 (Johnson, 2000a). An electron with some given spin orientation (up in Fig. 1.9) travels in a periodic potential UðrÞ which describes the internal periodic electric field of the ion cores (solid dots). During constant motion the electron is in an eigenstate of the periodic potential, moving at weakly relativistic velocity vF : But when the electron scatters and changes its direction (solid arrow), it traverses an effective ‘orbit’ in the vicinity of the ion core during the short time of the scattering event before it enters a new eigenstate. The local electric field transforms, in the rest frame of the electron, as a magnetic field. Since the scattering occurs over a very short time interval, the electron experiences an effective magnetic field pulse. This pulse can act as a torque on the spin and there is a small probability of tipping the spin orientation. The Fermi velocity is only weakly relativistic, and the probability of spin-flip scattering is also weak, of order 1025 –1023 per scattering event. Since electron scattering times are on the order of 10214 s, spin relaxation times in metals (at room temperature) are on the order of 10211 s (Johnson, 1993a). This ‘spin –orbit’ scattering mechanism was independently described by Yafet (1952) and Elliott (1954) and is often known as a Yafet–Elliott mechanism. Spin-flip scattering may also occur in a bulk ferromagnet. In this case, the band structure constrains the number of up- and down-spin electrons at the Fermi surface. However, there are small, local fluctuations in the magnetization that are of thermal origin. These fluctuations are known as magnons, and ‘magnon scattering’ refers to spin-flip scattering as an electron travels through such a region (Kittel, 1971).
1.4
Review of phenomenology
Some of the basic ideas of spin-polarized transport that form the underlying operational principles of magnetoelectronic devices have already been introduced. This section presents an historical review of the research that developed these basic concepts. Some ideas are rigorously described,
34
M. Johnson
however, the goal of the section is to describe basic ideas from a conceptual viewpoint rather than focussing on mathematical formalism. 1.4.1
Spin-polarized currents
The concept that an electric current in a metal could be composed of spin-polarized carriers had its origin about 65 years ago. By calculating scattering rates for spin-up and spin-down itinerant electrons in the exchange-split d-band of transition metal ferromagnets, Mott (1936) deduced that the carriers of an electrical current in a ferromagnetic metal had a net spin polarization P: P ¼ ðJ" 2 J# Þ=ðJ" þ J# Þ ¼ ðg" 2 g# Þ=ðg" þ g# Þ – 0;
ð1:4Þ
where Ji are the spin subband partial currents and gi are the spin subband conductances. Experimentally, the study of the transport of polarized carriers began with low temperature tunneling spectroscopy about 30 years ago. Tedrow and Meservey (Tedrow et al., 1970; Tedrow and Meservey, 1971) fabricated planar tunnel junctions using thin aluminum films, aluminum oxide tunnel barriers, and a ferromagnetic (F) or nonmagnetic (N) metal counterelectrode (refer also to Chapter 3). At a temperature T below the superconducting transition temperature Tc of the aluminum (S), the critical field for magnetic fields applied in the sample plane, HC;3 ; is large. Relatively large in-plane fields, H , HC;3 ; cause a sizable Zeeman splitting of the quasiparticle density of states, Nqp;";# ðEÞ ¼ Nqp ðE ^ mB HÞ; where mB is the Bohr magneton. The tunneling conductance measures single particle tunneling and has peak values at the singularities of the density of states near the gap edge, at energies EF ^ D in zero magnetic field. When the counterelectrode is a nonmagnetic metal such as silver (Tedrow and Meservey, 1971), the tunneling conductance in a field H , HC;3 is symmetric about V ¼ 0 with four peaks at the Zeeman split values eV ¼ ^lD ^ mB Hl: When the counterelectrode is a ferromagnetic metal F such as Fe, Ni or Co, the peaks have asymmetric heights (Tedrow and Meservey, 1973). The tunneling current I is proportional to the density of states at the Fermi level of the counterelectrode, J / NF ðEF Þ: The d-band densities of states at the Fermi level of ferromagnets, Nd;" ðEF Þ and Nd;# ðEF Þ; differ for spin-up and spin-down subbands because of exchange splitting. By deconvolving the measured tunneling conductance, Tedrow and Meservey could deduce the net polarization P of the tunnel current crossing the F –S interface, directly proportional to the asymmetry of the density of states at the Fermi level: P ¼ ½N" ðEF Þ 2 N# ðEF Þ=½N" ðEF Þ þ N# ðEF Þ:
ð1:5Þ
Their experimental results gave values of P < 10 – 45% for transition metal ferromagnets such as nickel, iron and cobalt (Tedrow and Meservey, 1973). These seminal experiments had a broad impact. First, using the reasonable assumption that the polarization of the interfacial tunnel current was comparable with the polarization of the current inside F, they provided both an experimental confirmation of Mott’s theoretical assertion
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
35
and a quantitative estimate of the polarization P. Second, they demonstrated that polarized current could tunnel across a barrier at a boundary of F and maintain its polarization. Third, whereas these initial experiments used a thin superconducting film S as a detector of polarized carriers, it was soon recognized that a second ferromagnetic film F2 could also perform this function. Julliere’s (1975) spin dependent tunneling (SDT) experiments laid the foundation for the MTJ, a magnetoresistive device structure that shows high potential for broad applications. 1.4.2
Spin-dependent tunneling in magnetic tunnel junctions
Of the three significant device families, MTJs, spin valves and fringe field devices, the MTJ is considered to have the highest potential for success in electronics applications. Chapter 3 is dedicated to MTJs, but the basic principles can be described within the context of this historical review. As sketched in Fig. 1.10(a), an MTJ is a sandwich of two thin ferromagnetic films F1 and F2 separated by a very thin dielectric tunnel barrier. Ideally, each ferromagnetic film is a single domain and F1 and F2 are chosen to have different coercivities so that they switch their magnetization orientation at different values of field. Under voltage bias, the current of a tunnel junction is proportional to the density of states at the Fermi level of both electrodes (Simmons, 1963; Duke, 1969): J / NF1 ðEF ÞNF2 ðEF Þ:
ð1:6Þ
As discussed in Section 1.3, the up-spin and down-spin conductances of ferromagnetic metals are independent, and the tunneling current is determined by their parallel contributions. When the magnetization orientations are parallel [Fig. 1.10(b)], the minority spin subband current ðJ" Þ is large because the density of states at EF is large for both F1 and F2. The partial current J" is so large that it dominates transport in the junction, J" q J# : In a simple model where the junction resistance is the parallel combination of an up-spin resistance and a down-spin resistance, the small up-spin resistance effectively ‘shorts out’ the down-spin resistance and carries a relatively high proportion of tunnel current, Jpar < J" : When the magnetization orientations are antiparallel [Fig. 1.10(c)], the up- and down-spin partial currents are the same: J" / NF1;min ðEF ÞNF2;maj ðEF Þ ¼ J# / NF1;maj ðEF ÞNF2;min ðEF Þ: The net current Janti ¼ J" þ J# is smaller than the current that flows between minority spin subbands in the parallel configuration, Janti , Jpar ; and the device configuration with the magnetizations of F1 and F2 antiparallel has a higher resistance than the configuration with magnetizations parallel. SDT between two ferromagnetic materials was first demonstrated by Julliere (1975). His results were confirmed by Maekawa and Gaefert (1982), and this early work
36
M. Johnson
(a) I+ F2 Insulating barrier
V F1 I− x
(b) g
E EF;F,down
g
E
EF;F,up
EF;F,up
F2
F1 N (E)
N (E)
(c) E
g maj,min
E
F2
F1 N (E)
gmin,maj
N (E)
Fig. 1.10 (a) Perspective view of a typical magnetic tunnel junction (MTJ) planar device structure. (b) and (c) Density of states picture describing spin-dependent tunneling (SDT) in the MTJ. A simple understanding requires two rules. (1) Tunnel current (equivalently, the tunnel conductance) is proportional to the density of states at the Fermi level, EF : (2) Spin-up (-down) electrons can only tunnel from and to states in the spin-up (down) subband. (b) When the magnetization orientations are parallel, the tunnel conductance for up-spin electrons is large and completely dominates transport. (c) When the magnetization orientations are antiparallel, the up-spin and down-spin conductances are equal and are smaller than the large up-spin conductance of (b).
was followed by studies of vacuum tunneling related to spin-polarized scanning tunnel microscopy (Weisendanger et al., 1990; Johnson and Clarke, 1990). SDT is typically studied by making magnetoresistance measurements schematically depicted in Fig. 1.11. An external field H applied in the plane of the films [along x^ in Fig. 1.10(a)] ~ 2 of F1 and F2 and to switch the structure ~ 1 and M is used to control the magnetization states M between parallel and antiparallel configurations. In a typical measurement [Fig. 1.11(a)], the field
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
(a)
37
R R0 + ∆R
R0 − HC1
HC2
H
HC2
H
R
(b) R0 + ∆R
R0 − HC1
Fig. 1.11 Quasistatic magnetoresistance characteristic of an MTJ, with field H applied along x^ [Fig. 1.10(a)]. ~ 2 are parallel, which ~ 1 and M (a) The relatively low tunnel resistance R0 is measured when the magnetizations M occurs at large values of lHl: The relatively high tunnel resistance R0 þ DR is measured when the ~ 2 are changing their orientation and become antiparallel. This occurs in the field ~ 1 and M magnetizations M range where the orientations are changing, HC;1 , H , HC;2 : Because of the hysteresis of each film [refer to Fig. 1.l(b)], peaks of magnetoresistance are seen for symmetrically positive and negative field ranges. (b) Memory effect, as described in the text.
H begins at a (negative) value sufficiently large that it saturates the magnetizations of both films so that they are aligned parallel, for example along 2^x; and the resistance R0 represents the relatively low tunnel resistance described by Fig. 1.10(b). As the field increases to zero there are no changes in resistance because both F1 and F2 are in remanent states and their magnetization orientations have not changed. As H is further increased, the MTJ resistance increases over the field range HC;1 , H , HC;2 where the magnetization orientations are changing, with the peak value R ¼ ~ 1 and M ~ 2 are antiparallel. In the example of Fig. 1.11(a), R0 þ DR occurring when magnetizations M ~ 1 has reversed its F1 has a lower coercivity and the high resistance state is reached when M
38
M. Johnson
~ 2 is unchanged. When H is increased to H . HC;2 ; the magnetizations M ~ 1 and magnetization and M ~ M2 are once again parallel, now along þ^z; and the resistance reduces to the low value R0 : When the field is decreased from H q HC;2 to H p 2lHC;2 l; the same magnetoresistive peak [dotted line in Fig. 1.11(a)] is observed in the negative field range, 2lHC;2 l , H , 2lHC;1 l; because of the symmetric hysteresis of the films. The hysteresis and remanent properties of the ferromagnetic films are also used to ~1 demonstrate a memory effect, shown in Fig. 1.11(b). The external field H is increased until M ~ ~ reverses orientation, magnetizations M1 and M2 are antiparallel, and the tunnel resistance is maximum, R ¼ R0 þ DR: In this configuration, the external field can be reduced to zero and the relative orientation will remain antiparallel because F1 and F2 are in their remanent states. In fact, the antiparallel configuration and the high resistance value are maintained until the field H is ~ 1 to its original configuration, parallel reversed and set to the coercive value required to reorient M ~ 2 : The bistability exhibited by the memory effect characterized in Fig. 1.11(b) is a with M fundamental property used in digital applications, as will be discussed in detail in several following chapters. The magnitude of SDT effects was first calculated by Julliere, a result that is still commonly used. Solving for changes of tunnel conductance G; Julliere predicted the magnetoresistive ratio MR ¼ DG=G of an MTJ to be DG 2P1 P2 ¼ ; G 1 þ P1 P2
ð1:7Þ
~ 1 and M ~ 2 parallel, and P1 and P2 are the where G is the interfacial tunnel conductance for M polarizations of current that are characteristic of F1 and F2 (Julliere, 1975). For transition metal ferromagnets, P1 ; P2 , 0:5 and DG=G < 40%; a value that is confirmed by experiment. In the limit of perfect polarization, P1 ; P2 ! 1; Eq. (1.7) predicts DG ¼ G: In other words, Gpar 2 Ganti ¼ Gpar and it follows that Ganti ¼ 0: This result is consistent with the simple model of Fig. 1.10. For a half-metal ferromagnet, there are no available states in the antiparallel configuration and tunneling is forbidden: J ¼ 0; Ganti ¼ 0: Equation (1.7) is often written as Ranti 2 Rpar DR 2P1 P2 ¼ ¼ R Ranti 1 2 P1 P2
ð1:8Þ
in order to emphasize the divergence predicted for P ! 1: Such a divergence has not been experimentally observed. 1.4.3
Spin injection and diffusion in nonmagnetic metals
Continuing with the historical review, the tunneling experiments of Meservey et al. and Julliere also led to a fundamental question: Could a spin-polarized current, equivalently denoted as a magnetization current of oriented dipoles, JM ¼ ðJ" 2 J# Þ=ðJ" þ J# Þ; penetrate a nonmagnetic
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
39
material and maintain its polarization over some nonzero penetration depth? The prevailing view in the 1970s was ‘No’. This belief was based on the observation that the RKKY interaction, a coupling between dilute magnetic impurities in a nonmagnetic metal host that is mediated by conduction electrons, has a length scale of order 1 nm. It was believed that a spin-polarized current injected into a nonmagnetic metal N would have a comparably small penetration depth. The contrary view was presented by Aronov, who argued that the penetration depth was relatively long and proposed that a current JM could be injected successfully into nonmagnetic metals (Aronov, 1976a), semiconductors (Aronov and Pikus, 1976) and superconductors (Aronov, 1976b). At about the same time, Silsbee was studying spin diffusion in nonmagnetic metals using transmission electron spin resonance (TESR) (Silsbee et al., 1979). Stimulated by Meservey’s observation of interfacial spin tunneling, thin ferromagnetic films F1 and F2 were deposited on either side of a high purity nonmagnetic metal foil N. The trilayer sample was mounted in a spectrometer where the foil separated the ‘transmit’ and ‘receive’ cavities. Using standard TESR techniques, resonantly tuned microwaves applied to the transmit cavity in the presence of a ~ within a skin depth saturating, dc external field H creates a nonequilibrium spin population M of N. These polarized spins diffuse across the sample and, when the sample thickness d is less than a spin depth, d , ds (known as the TESR ‘thin limit’), microwave photons can be detected in the receive cavity. Comparing the transmission amplitude for foil samples with and without ferromagnetic film coatings, the transmission of the coated samples was substantially enhanced (Silsbee et al., 1979).
1.4.3.1
Spin injection and accumulation
Silsbee explained these results as an enhanced transfer of spin-polarized electrons across the F1–N interface. This was followed by their diffusion across the metal foil, and then enhanced transmission at the second, N–F2 interface. He proposed that similar transport phenomena would occur in a dc, electrically biased experiment. Silsbee’s (1980) model can be explained with a simple pedagogical geometry [Fig. 1.12(a)] and a microscopic transport model [Fig. 1.12(b) and (c)]. A bias current I driven through a single domain ferromagnetic film F1 and into a nonmagnetic metal sample N carries magnetization across the interface (with area A) and into N at the rate JM ¼ P1 mB I=e; where I=e is the number current and P1 is the fractional polarization of carriers. This is the process of spin injection. The sample thickness d is typically larger than an electron mean free path but smaller than a spin depth, d , ds ; (the same TESR ‘thin limit’ mentioned above). In the steady state, JM is constantly adding magnetization to the sample region, and relaxation at the rate 1=T2 is steadily removing magnetization by randomization processes. The nonequilibrium magnetization ~ ¼ IM T2 =Ad that results is a balance between these source and sink rates and is called M ~ / spin accumulation. It represents a difference in spin subband chemical potential in N, M EF;n;" 2 EF;n;# [Fig. 1.12(b) and (c)], and is depicted as dark gray shading in Fig. 1.12(a).
40
M. Johnson
(a) N F1
F2
I Z d
(b)
F1
N
E E F;n + eV0
F2 (Z=0)
g
g
E
E
)
E
EF;n;
E F;n
F2 (Z=
E F;n + eVs
E F;n
EF;n;
~ M
N (E)
N (E)
(c)
F2, F1 parallel
F1 E F;n + eV0 E F;n
N (E)
g
E
EF;n; EF;n;
N (E)
F2 (Z=
F2 (Z=0)
N g
E
)
E
E E F;n
E F;n − eVs
~ M
F2, F1 antiparallel
Fig. 1.12 Microscopic transport model of spin injection, accumulation and detection. (a) Cross-sectional schematic view of trilayer, three-terminal device with ferromagnetic spin injecting film F1, nonmagnetic layer N with thickness d q ‘; and ferromagnetic spin detecting film F2. (b) Transport described by density of states ~ 2 parallel. When bias current I flows across the F1– N interface, the chemical potential of ~ 1 and M models, for M F1 is raised by a small amount, eV0 ; in order to overcome finite interfacial resistance. Bias current I is a spin~ in N. When polarized current and generates a nonequilibrium spin population (spin accumulation), M; ~ drives a clockwise current in the detection arm, and a positive current is impedance Z [Fig. 1.12(a)] is zero, M detected by ammeter Z: When impedance Z is infinite, the chemical potential of F2 rises to align with EF;n;" ~ 1 and M ~ 2 antiparallel. The spin and a positive voltage Vs is measured by voltmeter Z: (c) Transport for M ~ drives a counterclockwise current in the accumulation in N is the same as in (b). When impedance Z is zero, M detection arm, and a negative current is detected. When impedance Z is infinite, the chemical potential of F2 lowers to align with EF;n;# and a negative voltage 2Vs is measured.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics 1.4.3.2
41
Spin detection at an N –F interface
A second ferromagnetic film F2 can be added, fabricated to be in interfacial contact with the sample region and connected to ground through a low impedance current meter [Z ¼ 0 in Fig. 1.12(a)]. A positive (negative) current Is / EF;n;" 2 EF;n (where EF;n is the average chemical potential of the two spin subbands) is driven across the N –F2 interface when F1 and F2 are parallel (antiparallel). Conceptually, this induced electric current is the converse of the injection process and is an interface effect: A gradient of spin subband chemical potential across the N –F2 interface causes an interfacial electric field that drives an electrical current, either positive or negative depending on the sign of the gradient, across the interface. This is an emf source and current conservation demands that a clockwise, or counterclockwise, current results in the detecting loop. If F2 is connected to ground through a high impedance voltmeter [Z ¼ 1 in Fig. 1.12(a)], ~ x is developed at the N –F2 interface. Here P2 is then a positive (negative) voltage eVs ¼ P2 mB M= the fractional polarization efficiency of the N–F2 interface, x is the Paul susceptibility, and eVs is recognized as the effective Zeeman energy of a spin-polarized electron in the presence of the ~ x associated with the nonequilibrium magnetization. The voltage Vs is directly effective field M= related to the interfacial, spin subband electrochemical potential gradient described above. The high impedance Z ! 1 forces the interfacial current flow to vanish, and the rise (or fall) of electrochemical potential of F2 is the mechanism that stops the current flow. ~ could be destroyed by Following the phenomenology of TESR, Silsbee noted that M application of an external, perpendicular magnetic field, H’ : Discussed in detail below, the amplitude of a Lorentzian feature, DVðH’ Þ; would be proportional to the spin-coupled voltage of ~ / T2 : Furthermore, anticipating techniques that later the accumulated spins, DVðH’ Þ ¼ Vs / M would be used in giant magnetoresistance (GMR), Silsbee predicted that manipulating the ~ 1 and M ~ 2 between parallel and antiparallel would give a measurement magnetization orientations M ~ decays exponentially away of 2Vs : When the sample thickness is larger than ds ; the value of M from the F1 –N interface and Vs is smaller than its value in the thin limit, Vs ðdÞ ¼ Vs;0 e2d=ds :
1.4.3.3
Formal theory
Three related phenomena form the cornerstones of magnetoelectronics: SDT (Tedrow and Meservey, 1973; Julliere, 1975), GMR (Binasch et al., 1989; Baibich et al., 1988) and spin injection (Silsbee, 1980; Johnson and Silsbee, 1985). Each of the two former topics has had some device applications, and each is the focus of a later chapter. Spin injection has been an important research technique, and it may have relevance for future generations of spin-injected semiconductor devices, or spin-injected all metal devices. It is presented with some depth in the following subsections, and some issues related to spin injection in semiconductors will be included in Chapter 6.
42
M. Johnson
The spin injection experiment (Johnson and Silsbee, 1985, 1988b,c) was important for several reasons. First, it demonstrated that spin-polarized carriers can be driven into a nonmagnetic material N over the relatively long length scale of ds : The accompanying theory (Johnson and Silsbee, 1988a) introduced the idea of separate resistances in a nonmagnetic material for up- and down-spin carriers. Second, it showed that spin-polarized carriers in N can create a voltage at a second N –F interface. In other words, information about spin states can be transformed into electronic information (a voltage or current). Indeed, the spin injection experiment was the first demonstration that the resistance of an F1 –N–F2 structure is modulated by the relative ~ 1 and M ~ 2 : Third, it provided direct measurements of spin relaxation magnetization orientations M times and spin diffusion lengths in metals. All of these are concepts central to magnetoelectronics, and they underpinned the later experiments that developed GMR and spin valve effects. More recently, the spin injection technique has been generalized and applied to novel materials systems, such as superconductors and semiconductors. The theory of spin injection and spin diffusion in nonmagnetic metals (N) begins with the realization, discussed in Section 1.4.1, that spin scattering events in N are rare. Transport in metal ferromagnets had long been modeled by using independent conductances for the up-spin and down-spin subbands (Mott, 1936). Because populations of up- and down-spin carriers in N mix weakly, separate up- and down-spin conductances can be introduced to describe transport in a nonmagnetic metal, as well as in the ferromagnetic metal (Johnson and Silsbee, 1988a). Referring again to Fig. 1.12(b) and using the simplifying assumption that spin relaxation in the ferromagnet is rapid so that its magnetization remains in equilibrium, EF;f;" ¼ EF;f;# ¼ EF;n þ eV0 ; (the general case of arbitrary spin relaxation in F is treated as a special topic in Section 1.5) the electric current from F1 to N is Je ¼ ð1=eÞ½g" ðEF;f1;" 2 EF;n Þ þ g# ðEF;f1;# 2 EF;n Þ ¼ ðg" þ g# ÞV0 : In the schematic representation of Fig. 1.12(b), the up-spin conductance g" dominates, but both spin conductances contribute and the magnetization current is JM ¼ ðmB =eÞ½g" ðEF;f1;" 2 EF;n Þ 2 g# ðEF;f1;# 2 EF;n Þ ¼ ðmB =eÞðg" 2 g# ÞV0 : The ratio of JM to Je is JM g 2 g# mB m ¼ P1 B ¼ " Je g" þ g# e e
ð1:9Þ
and this defines the interfacial spin polarization coefficient P1 ; under the assumptions of no interfacial spin scattering.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
43
A current is driven across the N–F2 interface, for the low impedance case ðZ ¼ 0Þ; because of a gradient of spin subband electrochemical potential associated with the spin accumulation: Je ¼ ð1=eÞ½g" ðEF;n;" 2 EF;f2 Þ þ g# ðEF;n;# 2 EF;f2 Þ ~ 1 mB M ðEF;n 2 EF;f2 Þðg" þ g" Þ þ ðg" 2 g" Þ : ¼ e x
ð1:10Þ
For the high impedance case, the spin-coupled voltage Vs that is a measure of the spin accumulation is found by setting Je ¼ 0 in Eq. (1.10): Vs ¼
~ P2 mB M ; e x
ð1:11Þ
where P2 is defined in analogy with P1 as the ratio of the difference and sum of spin-up and spin-down conductances. A device schematic for the spin valve, developed a few years after spin injection, is similar to the pedagogical schematic of Fig. 1.12(a). However, a few key differences are worth describing. As shown in the schematic of Fig. 1.13(a), the typical current-in-the-plane (CIP) spin valve involves diffusive transport in the plane of a trilayer sandwich F1–N –F2. The electrons move between regions of all three layers, and the magnetoresistance is measured as a voltage, across the length of the sandwich, that differs when the magnetizations M1 and M2 are varied between parallel and antiparallel. The CPP geometry is essentially the same as that of spin injection. Spin valves and GMR multilayers are fabricated with F and N layers having a thickness on the order of (or less than) an electron mean free path, ‘: The spin-dependent voltage Vs in a spin injection sample is related to the nonequilibrium spin accumulation. While these effects can be seen in thin N films, dN # ‘ (Johnson, 1991), the three-terminal geometry of Fig. 1.12(a) is more easily realized with thicker N layers, dN . ‘: The magnetoresistance DR in GMR systems derives predominantly from spin-dependent scattering at or near the F –N interfaces. If the layer thicknesses of a CIP spin valve are much larger than ‘n and ‘F ; the interfacial spin-dependent scattering is only a small fraction of all scattering events and DR is negligibly small. To maintain interfacial scattering as a large component of all scattering, the layer thicknesses must be kept small and the F –N interfaces must be clean and devoid of oxides. The standard formalism used to describe GMR adopted the Johnson–Silsbee idea of using separate spin subband conductances for F and N (Johnson and Silsbee, 1988a). A heuristic picture of the ‘two-current’ model is shown in Fig. 1.13, and is conceptually similar to the model of SDT (refer to Figs 1.10 and 1.11). When the magnetizations of adjacent F layers are parallel [Fig. 1.13(b)], up-spin electrons have a high conductance and dominate transport. When the magnetizations of adjacent F layers are antiparallel [Fig. 1.13(c)], the up- and down-spin conductances are equal and their parallel sum is less than the high up-spin conductance of Fig. 1.13(b). GMR and spin valve effects are discussed in detail in Chapter 2.
44
M. Johnson
(a)
N F1
F2 V
I
t
F1
(b)
N
E
F2 E
g
g
E
EF;f = EF;n
N (E)
N (E)
F2, F1 parallel gmin,n,min > g maj,n,maj
(c)
F1
N
E
g
F2 E
E
g
EF;f = EF;n
N (E)
N (E)
F2, F1 antiparallel
g min,n,maj = g maj,n,min < g min,n,min
Fig. 1.13 Microscopic transport model of spin transport in a current-in-the-plane (CIP) spin valve. (a) Cross-sectional schematic view of trilayer, two-terminal device with ferromagnetic film F1, nonmagnetic ~ 1 and M ~ 2 are parallel. The up- and layer N ðtN , ‘Þ; and ferromagnetic F2. (b) Transport when M down-spin subband conductances, g" and g# ; are independent. The g" ‘channel’ is large and dominates ~ 2 are antiparallel. ~ 1 and M conductance, resulting in a relatively low resistance. (c) Transport when M The g" and g# ‘channels’ are the same, and each is relatively small. The result is a relatively high resistance.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
45
Two experimental transport techniques can be used measure spin injection effects. A unique test for the direct observation of spin accumulation is a demonstration of the Hanle (1924) effect, the zero frequency analogue of TESR. A transverse, external magnetic field H’ causes the spins to precess and, for sufficient field, the polarization is dephased and destroyed. The field dependence of the spin-coupled voltage Vs detected at the second ferromagnetic electrode F2 is found by solving the Bloch equations with transverse field and a diffusion term (Johnson and Silsbee, 1985, 1988a). For the quasi-one-dimensional wire geometry discussed below, it has the form: Vs ¼
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi P1 P2 "2 p 2 IT2 expð2Lx f ðH’ Þ= DT2 Þ½F1 ðH’ Þ; F2 ðH’ Þ; 2 p e m kF 2Ads
ð1:12Þ
where 1 gH’ T2 f ðH’ Þcos½gðH’ Þ 2 sin½gðH’ Þ ; F1 ðH’ Þ ¼ f ðH’ Þ f ðH’ Þ 1 gH’ T2 cos½gðH’ Þ þ f ðH’ Þsin½gðH’ Þ ; F2 ðH’ Þ ¼ f ðH’ Þ f ðH’ Þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðd= DT2 ÞgH’ T2 ; f ðH’ Þ ¼ 1 þ ðgH’ T2 Þ2 ; gðH’ Þ ¼ f ðH’ Þ
ð1:13aÞ ð1:13bÞ
where g is the gyromagnetic ratio, mp the electron effective mass, kF the Fermi wavevector, D the electron diffusion constant, A the cross-sectional area of the sample, 2Ads the approximate volume the spins occupy when they diffuse equally along ^^x; and Lx the length between injector and detector. Functions F1 ðH’ Þ and F2 ðH’ Þ determine the shape of Vs ðH’ Þ; either ‘absorptive’ or ‘dispersive’ for parallel or crossed injector and detector polarizations, respectively. In the limit d , ds ; the amplitude Rs of ‘absorptive’ Hanle data can be expressed simply as (Johnson, 1994a) Vs rd2 ¼ Rs ¼ P1 P2 s ; Ie Vol
ð1:14Þ
where r is the sample resistivity. Relaxation time T2 is measured from the lineshape, and the polarizations P1 (and P2 ) of injected (and detected) current are the sole fitting parameters. ~ 1 and M ~ 2 between parallel In-plane magnetic fields that flip the magnetizations M and antiparallel can also be used to measure spin accumulation, and the resistance difference is DR ¼ 2Rs : For the ‘wire’ geometry treated below, Eq. (1.14) has a particularly simple interpretation when the probe separation is Lx ¼ ds : Apart from a factor of 2 that arises from self-diffusion of spins along the ^x-axis, the result is Rs < P1 P2 R:
ð1:15Þ
The ‘spin-coupled resistance’ related to spin accumulation is simply proportional to the ohmic resistance, and the constant of proportionality is the product of the fractional, interfacial spin polarizations of injector and detector.
46
M. Johnson
1.4.3.4
Spin injection experiments on bulk metal wires
The first experimental spin injection geometry consisted of a ‘wire’ of bulk, high purity aluminum about 100 mm wide and 50 mm thick (Johnson and Silsbee, 1985, 1988a), sketched in Fig. 1.14. An array of ferromagnetic pads, about 15 mm wide by 45 mm long, were fabricated, by photolithography and liftoff, as electrodes on the top surface, with interprobe spacings x in multiples of 50 mm. The F electrodes were e-beam deposited from a single source of Ni0.8Fe0.2 in a pressure of 1026 Torr after cleansing the Al surface with an Ar ion mill, and the films had a thickness of about 60 nm. The nonlocal geometry used in the experiment can be discussed with the aid of Fig. 1.14(b). The quasi-one-dimensional wire extends along the x^ -axis. A narrow ferromagnetic electrode F1 spans the width of the wire near its center, at x ¼ 0: When bias current I is injected at F1 and grounded at the left end of the wire, x ¼ 2b; there is a linear voltage drop from x ¼ 0 to 2b: This is depicted by the regularly spaced equipotential (dotted) lines in Fig. 1.14(b). However, there is no net current flow in the region x . 0 and the wire is at a constant potential from x ¼ 0 to x ¼ b: A voltage measurement between the end of the wire and a narrow electrode that spans the wire at x ¼ Lx is necessarily a null measurement, V ¼ 0: (a)
injector x=0
100 µ
50 µm
x=Lx
m
detector
Lx
W
(b) x = −b
y x
x=0
x=b
I F1 injector
F2 detector V
I+
Fig. 1.14 (a) Perspective sketch of nonlocal, quasi-one-dimensional geometry used in original spin injection experiment (Johnson and Silsbee, 1985, 1988b). High purity Al was cold rolled into a foil about 50 mm thick. Narrow ‘wires’ were cut, fixed to a substrate, and annealed. The injector and detector were lithographically patterned ferromagnetic films F1 and F2. (b) Top view. Dotted lines represent equipotentials characterizing electrical current flow. Gray shading represents diffusing population of nonequilibrium spin-polarized electrons injected at x ¼ 0; with darker shades corresponding to higher density of polarized electrons.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
47
Spin-polarized electrons injected at F1 diffuse equally along ^^x; and this isotropic diffusion may not be obvious. Charge and spin are coupled at the F1 –N interface, IM / Ie ; because these two properties reside with the same carrier. However, after the first scattering event inside N the coupling is removed. Charge and spin transport in N are statistical events described by ensembles of particles. The coupling is weak: the probability that any particular electron that was injected at the F –N interface with a specified spin orientation will contribute to the electric current in N is negligible. Equivalently stated, the electric field associated with bias current I is weak and selfdiffusion of the nonequilibrium spin is symmetric, with each polarized electron performing a random walk along the x^ -axis (Johnson and Silsbee, 1985; Johnson and Byers, 2003). The density of diffusing spin-polarized electrons is depicted in Fig. 1.14(b) by the shaded region, with darker shades representing higher density. When the electrode at x ¼ Lx is also a ferromagnetic film, F2, a potentiometric measurement V records a spin-dependent voltage that is ~ 2 is parallel (antiparallel) with M ~ 1: relatively high (low) when the magnetization orientation M Since V ¼ 0 in the absence of nonequilibrium spin effects, this is truly a nonlocal measurement that uniquely discriminates against any background voltages. The ideal geometry of Fig. 1.14(b) is achieved when the electrodes have negligible width [they are drawn as lines in Fig. 1.14(b)] and have uniform contact across the width of the wire. Departures from ideality result in a small, spinindependent baseline voltage V – 0: For an effective measurement, it is necessary to choose F1 and F2 to have slightly different coercivities, HC;1 – HC;2 ; for example, by using different materials or by using the same material but slightly different shapes for the two electrodes. Thus, in any given measurement the detected voltage V as a function of externally applied field H should be positive whenever the magnetizations of F1 and F2 are aligned and negative over a field range HC;2 2 HC;1 ; when antialigned. For the geometry of Fig. 1.14, spin diffusion lengths can be determined by measuring VF2 as a function of injector –detector separation, Lx : Figure 1.15(a) shows magnetotransport data for a sample with Lx ¼ 300 mm at T ¼ 4 K, plotting R ¼ Vs =I vs magnetic field Hy : An in-plane field H ¼ Hy is used to control the relative ~ 1 and M ~ 2 of F1 and F2. The field Hy is swept along the easy axis of F1 magnetization orientations M and F2 [refer to Fig. 1.14(b)] from positive to negative values. The region 2 80 , H , 30 Oe ~ 1 and M ~ 2 are reorienting between parallel and represents the region where magnetizations M antiparallel and the detected voltage Vs drops from positive to negative. In the region ~ 1 and M ~ 2 return to parallel and the original, positive 2 200 , H , 2 80 Oe the orientations M voltage is regained. A field sweep from negative to positive values shows the same feature in the field range 2 30 , H , 200 Oe, as expected for the hysteresis of the ferromagnetic films. Figure 1.15(b) shows similar data for a sample with Lx ¼ 50 mm at T ¼ 27 K. The coercive fields HC;1 and HC;2 of F1 and F2 are marked, and the detected voltage Vs is again observed to be ~ 1 and M ~ 2 are antiparallel. The spin accumulation Rs is identified as half the negative when M difference of the dip. The spin accumulation at Lx ¼ 50 mm [Fig. 1.15(b)] is larger than that for Lx ¼ 300 mm [Fig. 1.15(a)], and measurements of Rs ðLx Þ; at constant temperature and adjusted for
48
M. Johnson
(a) 0.4 0.2
0.0
--0.2 --0.4 --200
0
200
400
600
Field (Oe) (b) 2
1
0
--1 --150 --100
--50
0
50 H C1H C2 150
Field (Oe)
Fig. 1.15 (a) Example of data from bulk Al wire sample, presented in units of resistance as R ¼ V=I: External field is applied along y^ -axis, in the plane of F1 and F2, starting at Hy ¼ 600 Oe, sweeping down and stopping ~ 1 and M ~ 2 change their relative orientation from parallel to at Hy ¼ 2220 Oe. The dip occurs when M antiparallel. A similar dip occurs for symmetric positive field when Hy is swept from negative to positive. Lx ¼ 300 mm, T ¼ 4:3 K. (b) Similar data for a sample with Lx ¼ 50 mm, T ¼ 27 K. The field is swept from Hy ¼ 2140 Oe up to Hy ¼ 125 Oe.
sample-to-sample variations of P1 and P2 ; resulted in a determination of a long spin diffusion length (at 4 K), ds < 0:3 mm. As described above, spin injection, detection, accumulation and relaxation are directly and quantitatively measured by the Hanle effect. In the geometry of Fig. 1.14, a field applied along the x^ - or z^-axis is perpendicular to the orientation of the injected spins and causes them to precess (Johnson and Silsbee, 1988a). Since the spins are moving diffusively, those that enter the detector
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
49
film at any given time have a distribution of arrival times and, because of spin precession, a distribution of accumulated phase angle. In the limit of zero external field, all spins have zero phase and the signal has maximum value. At a sufficiently large magnitude of field, the distribution of accumulated phase angle will span 2p radians, and the detected signal is reduced to zero. This process is equivalently described as a one-dimensional random walk (Johnson and Silsbee, 1985). This is the same physics as TESR, but performed at zero frequency, and the half width at half maximum (hwhm) of an observed Lorentzian signal is a measure of the transverse spin relaxation time, DH ¼ ðgT2 Þ21 : In the limit T2 ! 1; the polarized spins remain coherent as the field increases and coherent precession would be observed in the form of a periodic spin-coupled resistance. A direct analogue in TESR is the observation of periodic transmission maxima associated with ballistic electrons, and these are called Larmor waves (Janossy and Monod, 1976). In the limit T2 ! 0; the linewidth of an absorptive Hanle feature broadens in field, Hhwhm ! 1: An example of the Hanle effect from an Al wire sample is shown in Fig. 1.16, presented in units of resistance, R ¼ Vs =I: For this sample, the injector and detector have magnetization anisotropies such that their easy magnetization axes are oriented perpendicular to each other and the resulting lineshape, dispersive in appearance, is fit using Eqs (1.12) and (1.13b). For these data, Lx ¼ 300 mm, T ¼ 4:3 K, and the deduced fitting parameters are P ¼ 5:0% and T2 ¼ 10 ns (when the injector and detector are fabricated from the same material, P ¼ P1 ¼ P2 ). In Fig. 1.16, note that the voltage Vs is bipolar. At H ¼ 0; injected spins are oriented at 908 to the detector, and Vs ¼ 0: As H increases with positive values the injected spins precess in a direction that brings them into alignment with the detector and Vs is positive. When H decreases, with negative values, the precession brings the injected spin orientation into antialignment with the detectors and Vs is negative. In general, the Hanle data are fit to a mixture of absorptive and dispersive contributions, using a linear combination of Eqs (1.13a) and (1.13b) to represent the relative orientation between injector and detector. Figure 1.17 presents more typical data, from a sample with Lx ¼ 50 mm and T ¼ 21 K. The uniaxial magnetization anisotropy axes of F1 and F2 were not perfectly parallel
0.4 0.2 0.0 --0.2 --0.4 --30
--20
0 --10 Field (Oe)
10
20
30
Fig. 1.16 Example of Hanle data, with dispersive lineshape, from bulk Al wire sample, presented in units of resistance as R ¼ V=I: Lx ¼ 300 mm, T ¼ 4:3 K. Solid line is fit to Eqs (1.12) and (1.13b): T2 ¼ 10 ns, P ¼ 0:050:
50
M. Johnson
3
R (nΩ)
2
1
0
120
80
40
0
40
80
120
Field (Oe)
Fig. 1.17 Example of Hanle data having absorptive lineshape, with small admixture of dispersive character. Lx ¼ 50 mm, T ¼ 21 K. Solid line is fit to Eqs (1.12) and (1.13): T2 ¼ 7:0 ns, P ¼ 0:075:
causing the small symmetry deviation from a Lorentzian lineshape. The deduced fitting parameters are P ¼ 7:5%; T2 ¼ 7:0 ns, z ¼ 0:84 and j ¼ 20:39; where z and j are the fractional contributions of absorptive and dispersive components (Johnson and Silsbee, 1988a). In these early experiments on bulk Al wires, the deduced values of P ranged from 5 to 8%, much lower than typical polarization values of 40–50% generally associated with transition metal ferromagnet films. Because the ‘wire’ samples were bulk Al, the lithographic processing resulted in a highly faceted surface along with the presence of oxides and other contaminants. Although the Al surface was cleansed with an Ar ion mill before deposition of the Py films, it is likely that the interface quality was poor, and the value of P was therefore diminished from ideality. An important impact of this first spin injection experiment was the demonstration that the polarization state of an itinerant electron in a nonmagnetic metal could be converted into a voltage. For the sample with Lx ¼ 50 mm, for example, the resistance of the segment of the Al wire between F1 and F2 was 220 nV at 4 K. The data of Fig. 1.15, with amplitude Rs ¼ 2:8 nV, correspond to a resistance modulation DR=R ¼ 2Rs =R ¼ 2:5%; slightly larger than the early spin valve results that were reported a few years later (Binasch et al., 1989). At 4 K the value of 2Rs =R in this sample was about 4%. As a technique for the study of spin transport, spin injection is highly sensitive for the detection of polarized electrons. The noise floor of the data of Fig. 1.17 represents the threshold of detection, corresponding to about one nonequilibrium spin out of 1012 equilibrium spins. Given the sample volume, typical data (on the order of 1 nV in Fig. 1.17) represent a population of roughly 106 nonequilibrium spins, a detection sensitivity that is several orders of magnitude better than that of TESR.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics 1.4.3.5
51
Quantitative analysis of T2
The dominant spin relaxation mechanism in metals is the weakly relativistic spin –orbit interaction, derived independently by Yafet (1952) and Elliott (1954) and introduced earlier in Section 1.3. An electron with spin ~s moves in a periodic potential UðrÞ with a weakly relativistic Fermi velocity vF (refer to Fig. 1.9). In the rest frame of the electron, any scattering event that changes the electron trajectory is a perturbation of the periodic electric field, which transforms as a magnetic field (Johnson, 2000a). This effective magnetic field ‘pulse’ can exert a torque on the spin. Formally, the effect derives from a term in the Dirac equation (Yafet, 1952): h ð7U £ p~Þ·~s; 4m2 c2
ð1:16Þ
with m the electron mass and c the speed of light. From inspection of Eq. (1.16), any scattering event that changes the momentum p~ can couple weakly to the spin. While scattering events with impurities, phonons, grain boundaries and surfaces can affect ~s with different strength, the parameter c2Y / t=T1 is a property of a given material and is relatively large (small) for high Z (low Z) elements. Here t is a mean scattering time given by Matthiessen’s rule, 1=t ¼ ð1=tin þ 1=timp Þ; T1 is the longitudinal spin relaxation time, and we note that the transverse and longitudinal times T2 and T1 are the same in metals. The probability of flipping a carrier spin, per scattering event and averaged over all scattering events, is determined experimentally and given by the ratio a ¼ t=T1 ; t=T2 : From the spin injection experiment, values of T2 for a number of samples and a range of temperature were deduced from fits to Hanle data. These compared well with values of T2 ðTÞ measured on Al foils by TESR. At low temperature (4 K), scattering is dominated by impurities and surfaces, and the ratio aAl ¼ 0:001 was found (Johnson and Silsbee, 1988b). 1.4.3.6
Spin injection in thin metal films
Spin injection has become an important research technique because it offers the ability to study spin relaxation in novel systems. For example, relaxation times in thin metal films are very short. TESR requires the detection of a broad lineshape at high magnetic field and background effects related to cyclotron orbits interfere with the measurement. The thin film sandwich geometry of Fig. 1.18 was developed for spin injection studies in metal films and the structure became known as the ‘bipolar spin switch’ (Johnson, 1993a,b). Spinpolarized carriers are injected through two identical ‘window’ junctions F1 into the sample N of thickness d; and they diffuse across the sample thickness. The ferromagnetic electrode F2 measures the nonequilibrium electrochemical potential in N, EF;n;# and the voltmeter V compares this with the average electrochemical potential EF;n detected by electrode N0 . ~ 1 and M ~ 2 are set in a remanent state in the x – z plane, the Hanle When magnetizations M effect can be demonstrated by biasing the sample with current I and measuring VðHy Þ:
52
M. Johnson
N N’
V F1 F2
I d z
y x
Fig. 1.18 Perspective sketch of thin film geometry known as ‘bipolar spin switch’ (Johnson, 1993b). Spinpolarized electrons are injected from F1 through two parallel ‘windows’ and diffuse across the sample volume. Detecting film F2 measures the spin subband chemical potential of the ‘spin accumulation’ relative to the ~ 2 are fixed in the x – z ~ 1 and M chemical potential averaged over both spin subbands. For the Hanle effect, M plane and external field Hy is applied along the y^ -axis.
This is demonstrated in a gold film ‘bipolar spin switch’ sample with the data of Fig. 1.19 (Johnson, 2002a). Since injector and detector had shape anisotropies along orthogonal axes, Eq. (1.13b) is used to fit the dispersive lineshape and the result, with T2 ¼ 80 ps, is also plotted in Fig. 1.19 as a solid line. Using Eq. (1.14) with r ¼ 1:0 £ 1026 V cm, d ¼ 200 nm,
40
R S (µΩ)
35 30 25 20 15 –2000
–1000
0
1000
2000
Field (Oe)
~ 1 and Fig. 1.19 Example of Hanle data from thin film Au sample, showing dispersive line achieved when M ~ 2 have relative orientation of approximately 908. Solid line is the fit to Eqs (1.12) and (1.13): T2 ¼ 80 ps. M T ¼ 4:3 K.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
53
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Vol ¼ 10210 cm3, ds ¼ DT2 ¼ 1:8 mm, and noting the amplitude is 2Rs for dispersive lineshapes [Eq. (1.13b)], the value P1 ¼ P2 ¼ 25% is derived for the polarization of injector and detector. This is in reasonable agreement with values cited in the literature (Soulen et al., 1998). Whereas the dispersive Hanle data from the bulk Al wire (Fig. 1.16) were characterized by a bipolar voltage, the data of Fig. 1.19 are offset by a baseline resistance of about 28 mV. The likely source is a slight lithographic misalignment of the two detecting electrodes, N0 and F2. Of greater interest is a comparison of the magnitudes of the spin accumulation effects observed in Figs 1.16 and 1.19, the order of 1 nV in the former and 10 mV in the latter. The dramatic difference of four orders of magnitude is a graphic demonstration of the inverse scaling of spin ~ / 1=Vol; and the volume of the thin film sample is orders of magnitude accumulation, Vs / M smaller that that of bulk wire. Also of interest is the observation that the data of Fig. 1.19 are not symmetric about H ¼ 0; as is seen (and predicted) with a purely dispersive Hanle effect in bulk Al. A similar shift was observed for an absorptive Hanle feature in data taken on a thin Nb film (Johnson, 1994a). According to one theory, this shift is caused by a transfer of spin magnetization between the nonequilibrium spin-polarized electrons and the nuclei (Johnson, 2000c). Sometimes known as Overhauser coupling, a hyperfine contact interaction between conduction electrons and nuclei allows the transfer of spin angular momentum from a population of conduction electrons, each of which has a large magnetic moment, to the population of nuclei, each of which has a much smaller moment. The induced nuclear magnetization would appear as an effective magnetic field, thereby adding a small bias field to the observed results. These effects would be expected in thin film samples, where the injected nonequilibrium spin-polarized electron population is relatively large. Overhauser coupling to the nuclear spin system has been demonstrated in semiconducting samples by optical pumping of spin-polarized electrons (Lampel, 1968). ~ 1 and M ~2 An in-plane external field Hz can be used to manipulate the magnetizations M between parallel and antiparallel. The electrochemical potential of electrode F2 (Fig. 1.18) then rises or falls to line up with the nonequilibrium electrochemical potential EF;n;" or EF;n;# and the detected resistance difference DR is identified as DR ¼ 2Rs e2d=ds ; as discussed above. Experiments of this kind were performed on Au and Nb thin film samples, and the thickness d was varied so that a measurement of DRðdÞ would determine the spin depth ds : For Au (Nb), values ds ¼ 1:5 ^ 0:4 mm ðds ¼ 0:75 ^ 0:2 mmÞ and aAu ¼ 0:002 ðaNb , 0:00002Þ were found at low temperature ðT < 10 KÞ: For Au films, the deduced value of T1 ¼ 46 ps differs from the value deduced from Hanle data, T2 ¼ 80 ps, by a factor of roughly 2. This is reasonable agreement, but the discrepancy is not yet understood. Thus, these transport measurements give a value aAu ¼ 0:0015 ^ 0:0005: Further measurements on Au films were performed by using a novel, optical technique to measure the longitudinal relaxation time (Elezzabi et al., 1996). The value T1 ¼ 45 ps was found at room temperature. However, the resistivity of the Au sample was larger than that of the sample in the transport study, and the value of aAu was therefore smaller, aAu ¼ 0:0005: The difference between values of aAu could be related to differences of technique. It also suggests that the
54
M. Johnson
probability of spin scattering varies for different kinds of scattering events, differing for phonons and impurity scattering. The magnitude of DR observed in the transport measurement using in-plane fields deserves comment. The Hanle data were fit using two free parameters, T2 to fit the lineshape and P to fit the magnitude. The reasonable values T2 ¼ 80 ps and P ¼ 0:25 were deduced. The amplitude of dispersive Hanle data (Fig. 1.19) should be the same as the magnitude DR of the dip observed when ~ 1 and M ~ 2 are switched from parallel to antiparallel by an in-plane field, 2Rs : However, the latter M magnitude was substantially larger, DR q 2Rs ; for both Au and Nb sample sets. Rigorous attempts have not succeeded in explaining this result (Hershfield and Zhao, 1997). One proposed explanation ~ is relevant for the case of in-plane fields, and is smaller than is that a dynamic susceptibility, xðMÞ; the static Pauli susceptibility that is relevant for the Hanle effect (Cullen and Chui, 1995). Recently, spin injection has been applied to thin film aluminum mesoscopic structures and the inverse scaling of spin accumulation has been confirmed in samples with lateral dimensions as small as 200 nm. Several experiments are reviewed in Zutic, 2004. One set of experiments used the original Johnson–Silsbee geometry with a 50 nm thick Al wire, about 200 nm wide, and ferromagnetic injectors and detectors fabricated from cobalt thin films. The deduced fractional efficiency of injected polarization of roughly 11%, for interfaces that included aluminum oxide tunnel barriers, is the same order as the value P ¼ 6.5 ^ 1.5% that was observed for Permalloy electrodes (and no tunnel barriers) in the original spin injection experiment. At low temperature, 4 K, a spin relaxation time of about T1 < 100 ps was deduced, slightly longer than the value of T1 for Au films deduced from Hanle data (Fig. 1.19). These recent experiments included application of a transverse magnetic field and the observation of the Hanle effect. The Hanle data has an absorptive lineshape, and can be fit to Johnson–Silsbee theory, Eqs (1.12) and (1.13). The observation and quantitative description of spin accumulation effects in mesoscopic samples confirms the validity of Johnson-Silsbee theory over a range of 8 decades. Theory predicts that spin injection in mesoscopic devices could achieve values of a spin accumulation transresistance as large as 10 ohms in structures with characteristic dimensions of order 100 nm. Although not sufficiently large to compete with MTJs, spin injection devices that are shrunk to these small dimensions would have values of DR that are larger than CPP spin valves, which are considered to be competitive for future generations of read heads.
1.4.3.7
Further analysis of T2
Shortly after the spin injection results on thin Au films, values of ds ¼ 0:5 mm and aAg ¼ 0:005 for thin Ag films were deduced from GMR measurements using F/N multilayers (Yang et al., 1994). In this CPP GMR geometry, interfacial spin relaxation at the Py/Ag interfaces may contribute to the relatively high spin flip probability. By contrast, interfacial spin scattering at Py/Au interfaces is negligible, which is why substantial GMR effects have not been observed in samples using
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
55
Au layers. Considering this difference and variations of technique, the values of aAg and aAu are comparable, and are marginally larger than the value aAl ¼ 0:001 for aluminum. Since Ag and Au have a large value of Z but Al has a low value, these results would seem to be in contradiction with the Yafet –Elliott theory. An understanding of the apparent discrepancy came with the realization that polyvalent metals, such as aluminum, have nonspherical Fermi surfaces. A careful study of the Fermi surface showed that spin hotspots exist near degeneracy points and Brillouin zone boundaries (Fabian and Das Sarma, 1998). High spin relaxation rates that dominate spin relaxation processes are associated with these hotspots. Thus, while t=T1 is indeed roughly 0.0001 over most of the aluminum Fermi surface, the experimental value a ¼ 0:001 is an average over all of the Fermi surface, including the rapid hot spot relaxation. 1.4.4
Spin valves and giant magnetoresistance
Returning to the historical review of spin transport phenomena, following the SDT work of the 1970s and the spin injection work of the early 1980s, GMR effects were empirically discovered in the late 1980s in trilayer sandwich structures (Binasch et al., 1989) and, independently, in multilayers (Baibich et al., 1988). Related to GMR, coupling of the magnetization orientations of thin ferromagnetic films was studied in F –N–F trilayers and (F–N) multilayers. The basic idea of the ‘exchange bias’ at a ferromagnet/antiferromagnet interface was known for decades (Meiklejohn and Bean, 1956; Malozemoff, 1987). Grunberg showed that exchange bias could be used to couple the magnetization orientations of two thin Fe films separated by a thin N layer (Grunberg et al., 1986). It was later discovered that the magnetoresistance of a trilayer Fe – Cr –Fe sample was slightly larger than the expected AMR of the F layers (Binasch et al., 1989). At about the same time, Baibich et al. (1988) fabricated Fe/Cr multilayers and discovered that the low temperature magnetoresistance was much larger than the intrinsic AMR of the Fe layers. These three experiments launched the subfield known as GMR, which is discussed in detail in Chapter 2. Parallel developments were made with tunneling devices. Research on Josephson junctions for applications of superconducting logic led to new techniques for the fabrication of high quality tunnel junctions. Traditional junction fabrication used the native oxide of a superconducting metal electrode, such as Nb, as the tunnel barrier between top and bottom electrodes. These barriers suffered from poor reproducibility, poor thermal cycling, and high probability of pinhole shorts. In a new technique (Gurvitch et al., 1983), a thin film of Al (roughly 1 nm thick) was deposited on the bottom Nb electrode. The Al film wetted the surface such that a continuous, pinhole-free film was reliably formed for thicknesses that corresponded to only a few atomic layers. The Al film was then oxidized, and the top electrode was fabricated on top of the Al2O3 barrier. The resulting tunnel junction had remarkably reproducible and robust characteristics. In the late 1980s, Julliere’s idea of SDT between two ferromagnetic materials was revived for an application to scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). Chromium dioxide (CrO2) is
56
M. Johnson
a half-metallic ferromagnet, having one spin subband that lies almost entirely below the Fermi level. The transport current comes almost entirely from one spin subband and, therefore, the spin polarization is close to 100%. Single crystal chromium is antiferromagnetic, and a vicinal surface of a Cr sample has atomic plateaus with local spin ordering that alternates between up and down. An STM tip was fashioned from a CrO2 crystal and was scanned over a vicinal Cr surface in UHV (Weisendanger et al., 1990). A variation of the tunneling current was periodic with alternating plateaus, and the amplitude of the variation could be fit to a model of SDT. In a conceptually similar experiment (Johnson and Clarke, 1990), a single crystal of Ni was polished and mounted on an STM tip assembly. A portion of a small Permalloy torus was wrapped with 170 turns of wire. Current applied to the wire at audio frequency f modulated the magnetization in the Permalloy torus. Low frequency feedback was applied to maintain the Ni tip at constant height over the Permalloy surface, and modulation of the tunnel current at f was detected. The modulation amplitude was analyzed using a model of SDT, and tunnel conductance modulations DG=G of 14 –35% were observed at room temperature. Spin-polarized scanning tunnel microscopy continues as an important research technique (Wulfhekel and Kirschner, 1999). The Josephson junction fabrication technique became important to the field of spindependent transport when it was applied to the fabrication of planar MTJs (Moodera et al., 1995). Thin, pinhole-free Al films could be prepared on surfaces of transition metal ferromagnet films. After oxidation of the Al to form the tunnel barrier, a top ferromagnetic electrode was added and the resulting MTJs had high ratios of magnetoresistance at room temperature, DR=R ¼ 12%: Of equal importance, the characteristics of these devices were very reproducible and the structures did not degrade in ambient conditions. MTJs are highly promising for a variety of applications, and they are discussed in detail in Chapter 3.
1.4.5
The beginnings of magnetoelectronics
Magnetoelectronics is devoted to the invention and development of electronic device structures that incorporate a magnetic element. Applications in integrated digital electronics are the focus of this volume, but magnetoelectronics includes applications as magnetic field sensors. Magnetoelectronics as a field of applications developed from a number of important experiments. Numerous ideas for MRAM were proposed in the 1960s, and Chapter 4 reviews several of these concepts. Daughton and Pohm (Pohm et al., 1988) pioneered early ideas of block addressable, nonvolatile, magnetoresistive random access memories (MRAMs) in the 1980s. In the early 1990s, Prinz (1990) popularized the concept of magnetoelectronics by studying hybrid ferromagnetic –semiconductor structures, and Johnson proposed a bit addressable nonvolatile magnetic RAM (Johnson, 1993b) along with magnetoelectronic logic applications (Johnson, 1994b). By the late 1990s there were major MRAM research efforts in a variety of industrial and academic laboratories.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
57
The technology for magnetic field sensors used as read heads for data stored on magnetic media involved inductive pickup until the 1990s. The invention and development of magnetoresistive read heads using the AMR of a thin ferromagnetic film was a paradigm shift for the recording industry (refer to Chapter 3). After their introduction in 1993, the density of data stored on magnetic disks (areal bit density) began to increase at a yearly rate of about 60%. Of equal importance, this shift to a magnetoresistive technology enabled the industry to take advantage of GMR materials, whose MR ratios of roughly 10% are four or five times larger than AMR ratios of 2–2.5%. When GMR read heads replaced AMR heads in 1998, the bit density began to increase at a yearly rate of 100%. A disk drive bought in 2003 has a GMR head with MR of 15% or more. It is likely that future generations of read heads will use MTJs, starting around 2005. Areal bit densities of several hundred Gb/in.2 can be expected by 2007.
1.5
Special topic
There is presently a high degree of interest in studies of spin injection from ferromagnetic metals to nonmagnetic metals, and from ferromagnetic semiconductors to nonmagnetic semiconductors. An issue of focussed interest is the relevance of the relative resistance of the magnetic and nonmagnetic materials, and the efficiency of spin injection across the magnetic/nonmagnetic interface. The goal of this book is to clearly present basic concepts of the physics that underlies magnetoelectronics, and narrowly defined issues have been avoided. However, the question of ‘conductance mismatch’ at a ferromagnet/nonmagnet (F/N) interface continues to cause confusion. A theoretical treatment of this topic is given in this section, with some depth, in order to clarify the issue (Johnson, 2002b,c; Johnson and Byers, 2003). The tensor formalism of Johnson and Silsbee (1987) was developed for diffusive charge and spin transport in three dimensions. In this section, vector quantities will be denoted with bold face in order to avoid confusion with tensor notation. Following an entropy production argument, currents of charge ðJq Þ; heat ðJQ Þ; and magnetization ðJM Þ in a bulk ferromagnetic (F) or nonmagnetic (N) metal are related to gradients of voltage ð7VÞ; temperature ð7TÞ; and magnetization potential ð7 2 H p Þ by the general equations of motion (Johnson and Silsbee, 1987): 0 1 B B B B a00 k2 T 2 B C B B JQ C ¼ 2gB B @ A B eEF B JM B @ pmB e 0
Jq
1
a00 kB2 T eEF a0 kB2 T e2 m T kB 2 p0 B EF e
1 pmB C0 1 e C 7V 2 C C m k T C CB 7T C p0 B B CB @ A; C e EF C C 7 2 Hp A m2B z 2 e
ð1:17Þ
with g ¼ 1=r the bulk conductivity. The magnetization potential H p is defined as ~ x 2 H ¼ M= ~ x (with x the susceptibility) for the relevant case of zero 2H p ; M=
58
M. Johnson
~ ¼ M 2 M0 ; with M0 the thermal external field H: The nonequilibrium magnetization, M equilibrium value (M0 ¼ 0 in N), arises from transport effects such as spin injection. For the simple case 7T ¼ 0; 7ð2H p Þ ¼ 0; Eq. (1.17) gives JM ¼ ðpmB =eÞJq : Here p ¼ ðJ" 2 J# Þ=ðJ" þ J# Þ ¼ ðg" 2 g# Þ=ðg" þ g# Þ is the fractional spin polarization of carriers defined earlier in this chapter, J" and J# are the spin subband partial currents, and g" and g# are the spin subband conductivities (note that g and s are synonymous). Recalling earlier remarks about the Einstein relations, the conductivity and current density are proportional to the density of states at EF ; Ji / Ni ðEF Þ: In a nonmagnetic material N, the spin subband densities of states at the Fermi level are equal, N" ðEF Þ ¼ N# ðEF Þ; the spin subband conductivities are equal, g" ¼ g# ; and pn ¼ 0:
ð1:18Þ
In a ferromagnetic metal, N" ðEF Þ – N# ðEF Þ and pf – 0; so that values of pf for transition metal ferromagnets vary from 0.1 to 0.45 (Soulen et al., 1998). The other kinetic coefficients Lij in Eq. (1.17) have been estimated from a free electron model. The fractional polarization constant p0 would be associated with spin flow driven by thermal gradients, and constants a0 and a00 can be related to the thermal conductivity k and thermopower e (Johnson and Silsbee, 1987). Finally, L33 ¼ zðmB =eÞ2 describes self-diffusion of nonequilibrium spins and z < 1 (z ¼ 1 for noninteracting electrons). Thus, a current of spin-polarized electrons in a nonmagnetic material is given by JM;n ¼ g
m2B 7ðH p Þ: e2
ð1:19Þ
The same approach can be applied to a discrete system, and interfacial currents of charge ðIq Þ; heat ðIQ Þ; and magnetization ðIM Þ are related to differences, across an interface, of voltage ðDVÞ; temperature ðDTÞ; and magnetization potential ðDð2H p ÞÞ: 0 B 1 B B B k2 T 2 B C B B IQ C ¼ 2GB B @ A B ee B IM B @ hmB e 0
Iq
1
kB2 T ee akB2 T e2 m T kB 2 h0 B e e
1 hmB C0 1 e C DV 2 C C m k T C CB h0 B B DT C CB @ A; e e C C C D 2 Hp A m2B j 2 e
ð1:20Þ
with G ¼ l=Ri the intrinsic conductance of the interface. The kinetic coefficients L013 ¼ L031 are identified in a manner similar to those of Eq. (1.17). Polarization parameter h describes the fractional polarization of current crossing the interface, h ¼ ðI" 2 I# Þ=ðI" þ I# Þ ¼ ðG" 2 G# Þ= ðG" þ G# Þ: The interface may be characterized by spin asymmetry and, in general, h # pf : Note that elsewhere in the chapter the parameter P is commonly used, even though h may be strictly correct.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
59
Using these equations of motion, Eqs (1.17) and (1.20), charge–spin coupling effects at the interface between a ferromagnetic and nonmagnetic material can be studied. The consequences of ‘resistance mismatch’ at an F –N interface were first derived by Johnson and Silsbee (1987), and the physical principles are described with the aid of Fig. 1.20. Equation (1.17) is written for transport in F and N, and Eq. (1.20) is written for the interface region, defined as a volume with a thickness of an electron mean free path ‘ on either side of the physical interface, x ¼ 0 ^ ‘ [Fig. 1.20(a)]. Far away from the interface, the current in F is polarized with the value in bulk, JM;f ¼ pf ðmB =eÞJq : The current in N, far from the interface, is unpolarized, JM;n ¼ 0: At the interface (x ¼ 0 in Fig. 1.20), polarized current JM is injected into N and creates spin ~ The density M ~ n in N decays exponentially away from the interface with accumulation M: characteristic length ds;n ; driven by self-diffusion and the L33 term of Eq. (1.20). This term also
(a) F
N
Jq µ JM = pf B Jq e
Jq
JM=?
JM= 0 H*
(b) Hf*(x=0)
Hn*(x=0) δs,n
δs,f
x
x=0 (c) slope
V(x) ρf
JqReff
slope ρ
n
JqRi
x (d)
JM pf
x
Fig. 1.20 Flow of charge and spin currents, Jq and JM ; near the interface between a ferromagnetic metal and ~ nonmagnetic material. (a) Model system. x ¼ 0 at the F –N interface. (b) Magnetization potential, H p / M: (c) Voltage. The self-diffusion of nonequilibrium spins, back across the interface, creates an effective interface resistance, Reff : (d) Spin-polarized current. JM is reduced from value in bulk of F by the backflow of polarized spins, an effect determined by ‘resistance mismatch’.
60
M. Johnson
~ back across the interface into F, where the nonequilibrium spin density drives the diffusion of M ~ xÞn ~ Mf decays with characteristic length ds;f : The associated magnetization potentials, Hnp ¼ ðM= p ~ xÞf ; are shown in Fig. 1.20(b). Since xf differs from xn ; it follows that and Hf ¼ ðM= p Hn ðx ¼ 0Þ – Hfp ðx ¼ 0Þ: The back diffusion of nonequilibrium spins has several consequences. Away from the interface, current flow is ohmic and a plot of VðxÞ shows slopes proportional to rf and rn in F and N, respectively [Fig. 1.20(c)]. Since both charge and spin reside on the same carrier, the backflow of polarized spins across the F –N interface is also a backwards flow of charge. This negative charge current must be overcome by the imposed current Jq ; causing the appearance of an effective interface resistance, Reff ¼ ½ pf ðmB =eÞHfp =Jq ; in addition to the intrinsic interface resistance Ri [Fig. 1.20(c)]. Furthermore, the backflow of polarized spins cancels a portion of the imposed polarized current JM;f : As JM approaches the interface, the fractional polarization is diminished from the bulk value, pf [Fig. 1.20(d)]. Rigorous expressions for JM are readily found. Assuming T is constant, and using the conditions that Jq and JM are continuous, a general form for the interfacial magnetization current is (Johnson and Silsbee, 1987, 1988d) hmB 1 þ Gðpf =hÞrf ðj 2 h2 Þ=ðzf 2 p2f Þ ; J JM ¼ e q 1 þ Gðj 2 h2 Þ½ðrn =zn Þ þ rf =ðzf 2 p2f Þ
ð1:21Þ
where rf ¼ df rf ; rn ¼ dn rn and recall j; zf ; zn < 1: Interfacial spin transport is governed by the relative values of the intrinsic interface resistance Ri ¼ 1=G; and the resistances of a length of normal and of ferromagnetic material equal to a spin depth, rn and rf : Typical values for metal films are rf < 20 mV cm £ 5 nm , 10211V cm2 (Dubois et al., 1999) (nearly temperature independent), and rn < 2 mV cm £ 1 mm , 2 £ 10210 V cm2 at cryogenic temperature (Johnson, 1993a) (somewhat smaller at room temperature). The interface resistance Ri may be determined by a tunnel barrier, by a pinhole in a poorly conducting interface layer, or by a contact resistance Rc : The latter represents the low resistance limit, and a typical value for Rc can be found from the contact resistance measured between two copper layers making contact in a patterned structure, Rc < 1029 V cm2 (Bussman et al., 1998). Since all of these values fall within a range of two decades, all terms in Eq. (1.21) are expected to be important for the general case. For the limiting case G ! 1; Eq. (1.12) takes the simplified form (Johnson and Silsbee, 1987): JM ¼ p f
mB 1 ; Jq e 1 þ ðrn =rf Þð1 2 p2f Þ
ð1:22Þ
and the injected polarization is reduced from that in the bulk of F by the factor: ½1 þ ðrn =rf Þð1 2 p2f Þ21 ¼ ð1 þ M 0 Þ21 :
ð1:23Þ
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
61
Using the above estimates for rf and rn ; M 0 can be as large as M 0 , 20 and consequently JM may be reduced to a small fraction of pf : But this is valid only for the condition Ri p rn ; rf (Johnson and Silsbee, 1988d). In the opposite regime, Ri q rf ; rn ; transport is dominated by Ri ; Eq. (1.21) reduces to JM ¼ hðmB =eÞJq
ð1:24Þ
and the polarization is given by the interfacial parameter h: Issues related to the effects of ‘resistance mismatch’ on the efficient injection of polarized electrons at an F –N interface have caused some confusion that can be clarified by discussing Eqs (1.21)–(1.24). The case where N is a semiconductor (Rashba, 2000) has been a focus of debate, but questions also arise when N is a nonmagnetic metal (Johnson, 2002d). The result for infinite interface conductance, Eqs (1.22) and (1.23), has been used to argue that the polarization of current driven across the interface between a ferromagnetic metal and a nonmagnetic semiconductor will be negligibly small because the mismatch factor M 0 is so large. However, the intrinsic interface resistance at such an interface is never zero and application of the infinite interface conductance form is not valid. The general result described by Eq. (1.21) must be used for this system. The simple expression that represents the opposite limit, Eq. (1.24), may be used in the typical case where the interface resistance Ri (determined, for example, by a Schottky barrier or a thin tunnel barrier) is larger than rf and rn : A variety of calculations have been used to show that a tunnel barrier employed at the ferromagnetic metal/semiconductor interface will promote efficient spin injection (Rashba, 2000; Hu and Matsuyama, 2001), and recent experiments have demonstrated that a Schottky barrier also permits efficient spin injection (Zhu et al., 2001). However, the conditions imposed by Eq. (1.21) merely require that Ri be sufficiently large to block diffusion back across the F –N interface. It must be emphasized that the presence of a high quality tunnel junction or Schottky barrier is not required for efficient spin injection. Effects of ‘resistance mismatch’ are negligible whenever the intrinsic interface resistance Ri is the dominant resistance, regardless of the detailed origin of Ri : This is almost always the case in real systems. The fully general expression for the interfacial magnetization current, Eq. (1.21), must also be used for spin injection across a ferromagnetic metal/nonmagnetic metal interface. The intrinsic interface resistance Ri cannot be approximated as zero because the unit resistances rn and rf are typically so small that the contact resistance Rc of the interface cannot be neglected, rf , 10211 V cm2, rn , 2 £ 10210 V cm2 p Rc < 1029 V cm2. In summary, the effects of resistance mismatch are almost always negligible. If spin injection experiments show weak effects, effects of resistance mismatch can almost certainly be eliminated as a cause. A variety of other issues may be relevant, and other causes must be considered.
62
M. Johnson
References Ando, T., Fowler, A.B., and Stern, S. (1982). Electronic properties of two-dimensional systems. Rev. Mod. Phys. 54, 437. Aronov, A.G. (1976a). Spin injection in metals and polarization of nuclei. Pis’ma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 24, 37 [Sov. Phys. JETP Lett. 24, 32]. Aronov, A.G. (1976b). Spin injection in a superconductor. Sov. Phys. JETP 44, 193. Aronov, A.G. and Pikus, G.E. (1976). Spin injection into semiconductors. Sov. Phys. Semicond. 10, 698. Ashcroft, N.W. and Mermin, N.D. (1976). Solid State Physics, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Philadelphia, PA. In particular, see Chapters 17 and 29. Baibich, M.N., Broto, J.M., Fert, A.F., Nguyen Van Dau, F., Petroff, F., Eitenne, P., Creuzet, G., Friederich, A., and Chazelas, J. (1988). Giant magnetoresistance of (001)Fe/(001)Cr magnetic superlattices. Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 2472. Binasch, G., Grnberg, P., Saurenbach, F., and Zinn, W. (1989). Enhanced magnetoresistance in layered magnetic structures with antiferromagnetic interlayer exchange. Phys. Rev. B 39, 4828. Brown, W.D. and Brewer, J.E. (1997). Nonvolatile Semiconductor Memory Technology: A Comprehensive Guide to Understanding and Using NVSM Devices, Wiley/IEEE Press, New York. Bussman, K., Cheng, S.F., Prinz, G.A., Hu, Y., Gutmann, R., Wang, D., Beech, R., and Zhu, J. (1998). CPP giant magnetoresistance of NiFeCo/Cu/CoFe/Cu multilayers. IEEE Trans. Magn. 34, 924. Campardo, G. and Micheloni, R. (2003). Special issue on Flash memory technology. Proc. IEEE 91(4), 483. Campbell-Kelly, M. (1997). Computer: A History of the Information Machine (The Sloan Technology Series), Basic Books, New York. In particular, see Chapter 7. Clinton, T.C. and Johnson, M. (1999). Nonvolatile switchable Josephson junctions. J. Appl. Phys. 85, 1637. Cullen, J. and Chui, S.T. (1995). Spin transmission in metallic trilayers. Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 2118. Dacy, G.C. and Ross, I.M. (1955). The field-effect transistor. Bell Syst. Tech. J. 34, 1149. Duke, C.B. (1969). Tunneling in Solids. Solid State Physics, Supplement 10, Academic Press, New York. Dubois, S., Piraux, L., George, J.M., Ounadjela, K., Duvail, J.L., and Fert, A. (1999). Evidence for a short spin diffusion length in permalloy from the giant magnetoresistance of multilayered nanowires. Phys. Rev. B 60, 477. Elezzabi, A., Freeman, M.R., and Johnson, M.B. (1996). Direct measurement of the conduction electron spinlattice relaxation time T1 in gold. Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3220. Elliott, R.J. (1954). Theory of the effect of spin – orbit coupling on magnetic resonance in some semiconductors. Phys. Rev. 96, 266. Fabian, J. and Das Sarma, S. (1998). Spin relaxation of conduction electrons in polyvalent metals: theory and a realistic calculation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5624. Fowler, A.B., Fang, F.F., Howard, W.E., and Stiles, J.P. (1966). Magneto-oscillatory conductance in silicon surfaces. Phys. Rev. Lett. 16, 901. Grunberg, P., Schreiber, R., Pang, Y., Brodsky, M.B., and Sowers, H. (1986). Layered magnetic structures: evidence for antiferromagnetic coupling of Fe layers across Cr interlayers. Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 2442. Gurvitch, M., Washington, M.A., and Huggins, H.A. (1983). High-quality refractory Josephson tunneljunctions utilizing thin aluminum layers. Appl. Phys. Lett. 42, 472. Hanle, W. (1924). Z. Phys. 30, 93.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
63
Hershfield, S. and Zhao, L.H. (1997). Charge and spin transport through a metallic ferromagneticparamagnetic –ferromagnetic junction. Phys. Rev. B 56, 3296. Horowitz, P. and Hill, W. (1980). The Art of Electronics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. In particular, see Chapter 8. Hu, C.-M. and Matsuyama, T. (2001). Spin injection across a heterojunction: a ballistic picture. Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 066803. Janossy, A. and Monod, P. (1976). Investigation of magnetic coupling at interface of a ferromagnetic and paramagnetic metal by conduction electron-spin resonance. Solid State Commun. 18, 203. Johnson, M. (1991). Analysis of anomalous multilayer magnetoresistance within the thermomagnetoelectric system. Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 3594. Johnson, M. (1993a). Spin accumulation in gold films. Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 3594. Johnson, M. (1993b). Bipolar spin switch. Science 260, 324. Johnson, M. (1994a). Spin polarization of gold films via transport. J. Appl. Phys. 75, 6714. Johnson, M. (1994b). The all-metal spin transistor. IEEE Spectrum 31(5), 47. Johnson, M. (2000a). Spin injection: a survey and review. J. Supercond. Incorp. Novel Magn. 14, 273. Johnson, M. (2000b). Magnetoelectronic memories last and last…. IEEE Spectrum 37(2), 33. Johnson, M. (2000c). Dynamic nuclear spin polarization by spin injection. Appl. Phys. Lett. 77, 1680. Johnson, M. (2002a). Spin injection in metals and semiconductors. Semicond. Sci. Technol. 17, 298. Johnson, M. (2002b). Overview of spin transport electronics in metals. Proc. IEEE 91, 652. Johnson, M. (2002c). Charge – spin coupling at a ferromagnet– nonmagnet interface. J. Supercond. Incorp. Novel Magn. 16, 679. Johnson, M. (2002d). Spin accumulation in mesoscopic systems. Nature 416, 809. Johnson, M. and Byers, J. (2003). Charge and spin diffusion in mesoscopic metal wires and at ferromagnet / nonmagnet interfaces. Phys. Rev. B 67, 125112. Johnson, M. and Clarke, J. (1990). Spin-polarized scanning tunneling microscope: concept, design, and preliminary results from a prototype operated in air. J. Appl. Phys. 67, 6141. Johnson, M. and Silsbee, R.H. (1985). Interfacial charge –spin coupling; injection and detection of spin magnetization in metals. Phys. Rev. Lett. 55, 1790. Johnson, M. and Silsbee, R.H. (1987). A thermodynamic analysis of interfacial transport and of the thermomagnetoelectric system. Phys. Rev. B 35, 4959. Johnson, M. and Silsbee, R.H. (1988a). Coupling of electronic charge and spin at a ferromagnetic – paramagnetic interface. Phys. Rev. B 37, 5312. Johnson, M. and Silsbee, R.H. (1988b). The spin injection experiment. Phys. Rev. B 37, 5326. Johnson, M. and Silsbee, R.H. (1988c). Electron spin injection and detection at a ferromagnetic – paramagnetic interface. J. Appl. Phys. 63, 3934. Johnson, M. and Silsbee, R.H. (1988d). Ferromagnet –nonferromagnet interface resistance. Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 377. Julliere, M. (1975). Tunneling between ferromagnetic films. Phys. Lett. 54A, 225. Keyes, R.W. (1989). Physics of digital devices. Rev. Mod. Phys. 61, 279. Kirk, K.J., Chapman, J.N., and Wilkinson, C.D.W. (1997). Switching fields and magnetostatic interactions of thin film magnetic nanoelements. Appl. Phys. Lett. 71, 539. Kittel, C. (1971). Introduction to Solid State Physics, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY. Kuhn, T.S. (1996). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 3rd edn. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
64
M. Johnson
Lampel, G. (1968). Nuclear dynamic polarization by optical electronic saturation and optical pumping in semiconductors. Phys. Rev. Lett. 20, 491. Maekawa, S. and Gaefert, U. (1982). Electron-tunneling between ferromagnetic-films. IEEE Trans. Magn. 18, 707. Malozemoff, A.P. (1987). Random-field model of exchange anisotropy at rough ferromagnetic – antiferromagnetic interfaces. Phys. Rev. B 35, 3679. Mead, C.A. (1966). Schottky barrier gate field-effect transistor. Proc. IEEE 54, 307. Meiklejohn, W.H. and Bean, C.P. (1956). New magnetic anisotropy. Phys. Rev. 102, 1413. Moodera, J.S., Kinder, L.R., Wong, T.M., and Meservey, R. (1995). Large magnetoresistance at room temperature in ferromagnetic thin film tunnel junctions. Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3273. Mott, N.F. (1936). Prot. R. Soc. A 153, 699. Pohm, A.V., Huang, J.S.T., Daughton, J.M., Krahn, D.R., and Mehra, V. (1988). The design of a one megabit non-volatile MR memory chip using 1.5 £ 5 micron cells. IEEE Trans. Magn. 24, 3117. Prinz, G.A. (1990). Hybrid ferromagnet semiconductor devices. Science 250, 1092. Rashba, E.I. (2000). Theory of electrical spin injection: tunnel contacts as a solution of the conductivity mismatch problem. Phys. Rev. B 62, 16267. Ruhrig, M., Khamsehpour, B., Kirk, K.J., Chapman, J.N., Aitchison, P., McVitie, S., and Wilkinson, C.D.W. (1996). The fabrication and magnetic properties of acicular magnetic nano-elements. IEEE Trans. Magn. 32, 4452. Schrieffer, J.R. (1957). Mobility in inversion layers: theory and experiment. In Semiconductor Surface Physics, (Ed. R.H. Kingston). University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PA, p. 55. Sharma, A.K. (1997). Semiconducting Memories; Technology Testing and Reliability, IEEE Press, New York. Shockley, W. (1952). A unipolar field effect transistor. Proc. IRE 40, 1365. Silsbee, R.H. (1980). Bull. Magn. Res. 2, 284. Silsbee, R.H. and Drager, J. (1997). Simulations for Solid State Physics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. Silsbee, R.H., Janossy, A., and Monod, P. (1979). Coupling between ferromagnetic and conduction-spinresonance modes at a ferromagnetic – normal-metal interface. Phys. Rev. B 19, 4382. Simmons, J. (1963). J. Appl. Phys. 34, 1793. Soulen, R.J., Byers, J.M., Osofsky, M.S., Nadgorny, B., Ambrose, T., Cheng, S.F., Broussard, P.R., Tanaka, C.T., Nowak, J., Moodera, J.S., Barry, A., and Coey, J.M.D. (1998). Measuring the spin polarization of a metal with a superconducting point contact. Science 282, 5386. Stoner, E.C. (1948). Repts. Prog. Phys. 11, 43. Sze, S.M. (1981). Physics of Semiconductor Devices, 2nd edn. Wiley, New York. In particular, see Chapter 2. Sze, S.M. (1998). Modern Semiconductor Device Physics, Wiley, New York. In particular, see Chapter 3. Tedrow, P.M., Meservey, R., and Fulde, P. (1970). Magnetic field splitting of the quasiparticle states in superconducting aluminum films. Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 1270. Tedrow, P.M. and Meservey, R. (1971). Spin-dependent tunneling into ferromagnetic nickel. Phys. Rev. Lett. 26, 192. Tedrow, P.M. and Meservey, R. (1973). Spin polarization of electrons tunneling from films of Fe, Co, Ni, and Gd. Phys. Rev. B 7, 318. Weisendanger, R., Guntherodt, H.J., Guntherodt, G., Gambino, R.J., and Ruf, R. (1990). Observation of vacuum tunneling of spin-polarized electrons with the scanning tunneling microscope. Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 247.
Introduction to magnetoelectronics
65
Wulfhekel, W. and Kirschner, J. (1999). Spin-polarized scanning tunneling microscopy on ferromagnets. Appl. Phys. Lett. 75, 1944. Yafet, Y. (1952). Calculation of the g factor of metallic sodium. Phys. Rev. 85, 478. Yang, Q., Holody, P., Lee, S.-F., Henry, L.L., Lolee, R., Schroeder, P.A., Pratt, W.P. Jr., and Bass, J. (1994). Spin flip diffusion length and giant magnetoresistance at low temperatures. Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 3274. Zelakiewicz, S., Krichevsky, A., Johnson, M., and Freeman, M.R. (2002). Time-resolved Kerr measurements of magnetization switching in a crossed-wire ferromagnetic memory element. J. Appl. Phys. 91, 7331. Ziman, J.M. (1972). Principles of the Theory of Solids, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. In particular, see Chapters 7 and 10. Zhu, H.J., Ramsteiner, M., Kostial, H., Wassermeier, M., Schonherr, H.P., and Ploog, K.H. (2001). Roomtemperature spin injection from Fe into GaAs. Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 016601. Zhu, J.-G. (2003). New heights for hard disk drives. Mater. Today 6(7/8), 22. Zutic, I., Fabian, J., and Das Sarma, S. (2004). Spintronics: fundamentals and applications. Rev. Mod. Phys. 76, 323.
Magnetoelectronics M. Johnson (Editor) Copyright q 2004 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Chapter 2 Spin valves B. Dieny SPINTEC, Unite´ de Recherche Associe´e CEA/DSM & CNRS/SPM-STIC, 38054 Grenoble Cedex, France
2.1
Introduction
In the past 30 years, tremendous technological progress has been achieved in the development of ultrahigh vacuum equipment for the preparation of thin films and multilayers, in tools for their structural characterization, and for the measurement of their physical properties. Although interest in the properties of magnetic thin films and multilayers is not new (Ne´el, 1954, 1955, 1962, 1965, 1967, 1968), these advances have launched an intense activity in the field, stimulated by interests in both basic science as well as applications, particularly in magnetic storage (Thompson and Best, 2000), magneto-optic recording (Tsunashima, 2001) and more recently in non-volatile memories or reprogrammable logic (Johnson, 2000). A wealth of new phenomena has been discovered in these artificially made material systems. They include anomalous elastic properties, magnetic anisotropy perpendicular to the plane of the layers (den Broeder et al., 1991), enhanced magnetooptical Kerr rotation (Carcia et al., 1985; den Broeder et al., 1987), existence of an oscillatory exchange-like coupling between ferromagnetic layers separated by a non-magnetic layer (Parkin et al., 1990) and, among the most attractive for applications: giant magnetoresistance, GMR (Baibich et al., 1988; Binasch et al., 1989) and tunnel magnetoresistance, TMR (Moodera et al., 1995). The main applications of magnetic thin films and multilayers concern media for magnetic or magneto-optical recording, soft and hard magnetic thin films, magnetostrictive materials for actuators, magnetoresistive materials for magnetic field sensors and magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) for non-volatile memories or logic gates. The present chapter is devoted to spin valves (Dieny et al., 1991a–d) which represent a particular class of systems exhibiting GMR at low fields. These systems were discovered in 1990 and have been the object of an exponentially growing interest since 1994 when they became identified as the most promising candidates for magnetoresistive read-back heads used in magnetic hard disk drives. This application is clearly the most demanding in terms of performance. Spin valves reached market in 1998 when they were introduced for the first time in disk drives by IBM. Since then, this technology became the standard for read-back heads. Spin valves can be viewed as sensitive magnetic field sensors. As such, they may also be used in other applications: measurements of
68
B. Dieny
electrical current, position or rotation encoders, magnetoresistive compass and magnetoresistive heads for videotapes or other storage media of lower density than hard disk drives. Prior to the discovery of GMR, the main magnetoresistive effect known in magnetic transition metals (Fe, Ni, Co and many of their alloys) at room temperature was the ‘anisotropic magnetoresistance’ (AMR) (Mc Guire and Potter, 1975). This effect is a consequence of an anisotropic mixing of spin-up and spin-down conduction subbands induced by the spin –orbit interaction (Campbell, 1970). Its manifestation is a dependence of the electrical resistivity on the relative angle between the direction of the sense current and the local magnetization. In the vast majority of cases, the resistivity is lower when the current flows perpendicular to the magnetization than when it flows parallel to it. The effect can be of the order of 3–5% in bulk NiFe or NiCo alloys at room temperature. In thin films, it tends to drop significantly when the thickness of the layer becomes lower than a few tens of nanometer because of the increasing role of the electron scattering at the outer surfaces of the film. This AMR reduction in very thin films, however, has been drastically limited by improving the structural quality of the film thus favoring specular reflection rather than diffuse scattering at outer boundaries (Dieny et al., 2000a,b). AMR thin films were used in magnetoresistive heads from 1992 to 1998. The introduction of AMR films in magnetic recording technology in 1992 has constituted a major breakthrough which actually led to a doubling in the rate of increase of storage areal density per year (from 30 to 60%/year). The first evidence of enhanced magnetoresistance in multilayers consisting of magnetic layers separated by non-magnetic spacer layers was obtained by Binasch et al. (1989) in antiferromagnetically coupled Fe/Cr/Fe sandwiches grown by molecular beam epitaxy (MBE). However, the first observation of really GMR in such multilayers is due to Baibich et al. (1988) who reported a decrease of resistivity in MBE-grown (Fe/Cr) multilayers by a factor 2 at 4.2 K in a field of 20 kOe. A model for the physical origin of the GMR in terms of spin-dependent scattering of the conduction electrons at the interfaces between Fe and Cr associated with a change in the relative orientation of the magnetization in the successive ferromagnetic layers under application of a magnetic field has also been proposed by the same authors (Baibich et al., 1988). This interpretation is widely accepted by the scientific community as the dominant contribution to GMR in these systems. A significant step towards applications of GMR in devices was achieved by Parkin et al. (1990). They demonstrated that GMR could be observed in sputtered multilayers and that the GMR amplitude could be even larger in sputtered samples than in their MBE-grown counterparts. Spin valves were discovered in 1990 (Dieny et al., 1991a– d). They offered the best field sensitivity at low fields since in contrast to the previously studied GMR multilayers, in which the ferromagnetic layers are coupled antiferromagnetically through the spacer layer, spin valves essentially consist of two uncoupled ferromagnetic layers separated by a noble metal spacer layer. The magnetization of one layer is free to rotate under application of a weak magnetic field while the other is pinned in a fixed direction.
Spin valves 69 Since 1989, GMR has stimulated numerous studies oriented either towards a basic understanding of the phenomenon or towards the optimization of the magnitude and sensitivity of the magnetoresistive response for magnetic field sensors. For read-head applications, other requirements for GMR materials are very low magnetostriction, good resistance to corrosion and good thermal stability up to 2508C. In the last 10 years, very significant progress was achieved in the preparation and optimization of spin valves in terms of magnetic and transport properties. These advances will be explained in detail in this chapter. They have dealt with (i) improving the overall structural quality of the stacks by appropriate choice of buffer layers, (ii) improving the biasing of the pinned layer on one hand, by using antiferromagnetic material with higher Neel temperature, and offering higher exchange bias energy, on the other hand, by using synthetic pinned layers, (iii) optimizing the thickness of each individual layer, most importantly those which are in the active part of the spin valve: the free layer, the non-magnetic spacer layer, the inner pinned layer, (iv) introducing nano-oxide layers (NOLs) at appropriate locations in the stack to favor specular reflection of the electrons in the active part of the spin valve, (v) reducing the shunting of the current in the parts of the stack which do not contribute to the GMR, and (vi) designing new spin valve stacks (e.g. dual spin valves, spin-filter spin valves) with more active interfaces or thinner free layer to increase the GMR sensitivity. At the present time, a GMR amplitude of 20% is achieved in spin valves. However, unless a new breakthrough occurs, such as the discovery of an antiferromagnetic insulator which would provide good exchange bias and specular reflection, the present performance is close to the ultimate limit. This is not in terms of amplitude but in terms of a compromise between amplitude and magnetic properties that are suitable for read-head applications. As a result, there is currently a significant evolution in research and development in the field of magnetoresistive materials. In the past, the vast majority of the studies on the transport properties in magnetic multilayers have dealt with the ‘current-in-plane’ (CIP) geometry. This means that the transport measurements are performed in a standard four-point probe geometry, the four contacts being made at the surface of the film so that the current essentially flows parallel to the plane of the layers. More recently, a growing interest is focused on the ‘current-perpendicularto-plane’ (CPP) geometry in which the current flows perpendicular to the interfaces (Pratt et al., 1991; Gijs et al., 1993). From a practical point of view, measuring the CPP GMR in metallic multilayers at room temperature requires one to pattern the multilayer in the form of a submicron pillar sandwiched between a bottom electrode and a top electrode. Reducing the lateral dimension of the pillar is important in order to have a measurable and usable resistance of the stack (typically 10 –30 V). Furthermore, in the perspective of application as read heads, this will allow higher spatial resolution of the reading process. There are several advantages of the CPP geometry over the CIP geometry for read heads, as will be explained later in more detail: The width of the read gap can be decreased, allowing an increase in the spatial resolution along the track; the amplitude of CPP GMR can be larger than in CIP; the heat evacuation from the sensor is better in CPP than in CIP, allowing more current to flow through the sensor during the reading process and resulting in
70
B. Dieny
an increase in the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR); and the design and technology required for CPP heads at very small dimensions (150 nm and below) are simpler than in CIP. Research efforts in this field are currently focusing on increasing the CPP resistance and magnetoresistance of metallic stacks by using laminated layers which allow an increase in the number of interfaces, or inserting discontinuous NOLs at appropriate locations to locally confine the current paths throughout the structure. Concerning CPP transport studies, MTJs also represent a large field of activity. The discovery of large magnetoresistance at room temperature in MTJs (Moodera et al., 1995; Miyazaki and Tezuka, 1995) has stimulated tremendous interest in these systems. Three main applications of MTJ are investigated. One is a storage unit in magnetic random access memories (MRAMs) (Tehrani et al., 1999; see also Chapters 4 and 5), another is a basic element of reprogrammable logic gates (Johnson, 2000; see also Chapter 6), and a third one is a magnetoresistive sensor for CPP read heads (Nakashio et al., 2001). The requirements of the properties, especially the product of resistance and area ðRAÞ are different for these various applications. Among these three areas of research and development, the most advanced is the field of MRAM which should reach market by the end of 2004. For sensor applications, the main source of noise in tunnel junctions is the shot noise. This can be reduced only by decreasing the RA product of the junctions, which implies making thinner tunnel barriers. Many attempts have been made towards the goal of achieving an RA product below 1 V mm2 with large TMR amplitude. These attempts have not been successful so far. Considering the intense activity in the field, however, new insulating or semiconductor materials may be discovered in the near future, having a narrower band gap which would allow the fabrication of low resistance tunnel barriers. Tunnel junctions would then offer a superior SNR than metal-based CIP or CPP sensors. This chapter has the following organization: After this introduction, the physical origin of GMR will be briefly explained in Section 2.2 and the differences between the magnetotransport properties in CIP and CPP geometry will be outlined. Section 2.3 presents the basic properties of spin valves. The dependence of the GMR on the thickness of the various layers will be discussed and the quantitative interpretation of the GMR based on the semiclassical theory initiated by Camley and Barnas (1989) and Barnas et al. (1990) for CIP and Valet and Fert (1993) for CPP will be explained. Section 2.4 will address the various spin-valve improvements which have allowed an increase of a factor of 4 in the GMR amplitude and an optimization of the magnetic properties of both the soft and the pinned layers. In Section 2.5, based on the semiclassical modeling of GMR, we will discuss things that could be done to further increase the GMR amplitude along with the consequences on the magnetic properties. Section 2.6 deals with a currently very active field of investigation: spin valves in CPP heads. Section 2.7 addresses the implementation of spin valves in CIP and CPP heads and the present trends in magnetoresistive heads.
Spin valves 71
2.2 2.2.1
Giant magnetoresistance Giant magnetoresistance effect
GMR has been observed in many multilayered structures of the form BtB =ðFtF =NMtNM Þn =CtC ; where B and C, respectively, designate a buffer and capping layer, F is a transition metal magnetic layer (Fe, Co, Ni or their alloys), NM is a non-ferromagnetic transition metal or a noble metal (V, Cr, Nb, Mo, Ru, Re, Os, Ir, Cu, Ag, Au), and tB ; tC ; tF represent the thickness of the corresponding elements. In magnetic multilayers, the thickness of each individual layer is typically in the nanometer range. The amplitude of the GMR depends considerably on the pair of (F, NM) materials and on the thicknesses of the various layers. It ranges from a tenth of a percent in V- or Mo-based multilayers to more than 100% in (Fe/Cr) (Fullerton et al., 1993) or Co/Cu multilayers (Mosca et al., 1991; Parkin et al., 1991). It has been shown in all of these structures that the GMR is associated with a change in the relative orientation of the magnetizations of the successive ferromagnetic layers. The GMR multilayers can be classified in three categories according to how the magnetic configuration between the various layers is controlled: (i)
Antiferromagnetically coupled multilayers: Typical examples are the Fe/Cr and Co/Cu multilayers previously mentioned, and (NiFe/Ag) (Rodmacq et al., 1993). In these multilayers, the interlayer coupling oscillates from antiferromagnetic to ferromagnetic as a function of the spacer layer thickness. Therefore, the GMR can only be observed in the range of thickness for which the coupling is antiferromagnetic. These multilayers offer large GMR amplitude. However, except for (NiFe/Ag) multilayers in which a saturation field of 100 Oe can be achieved, the fields required to overcome the antiferromagnetic coupling is generally too large (several kOe) to make these systems usable in magnetoresistive heads. Another drawback is that the magnetoresistance response is a symmetric function of the applied field in these systems, which requires that the magnetoresistive element be biased with a relatively
large field in order to obtain a linear response. This adds a complication to the realization of the sensor. (ii) Multilayers with double coercivity: A typical example is the (Ni80Fe20/Cu/Co/Cu) multilayer (Shinjo and Yamamoto, 1990). Since the Permalloy layers are softer than the Co ones, their magnetizations switch at different fields and therefore there are ranges of field in which the magnetizations in the successive magnetic layers are in parallel alignment (above the coercive fields of the two types of layers), and other ranges where they are in antiparallel alignment (between the coercive fields). These systems can also exhibit large GMR [16% variation in resistance between 0 and 50 Oe at 300 K in NiFe/Cu/Co/Cu multilayers (Sato, 1993)]. However, they have not been implemented in GMR heads because at low fields, when a minor loop is performed on the soft layers, the MR response depends on the magnetic history of the pinned layer. In particular, when the free layer switches,
72
B. Dieny
the resistance can increase or decrease depending on the direction of the magnetization of the pinned layer. Furthermore, the domain state of the pinned layer is poorly controlled in this type of system, and the hardness of the pinned layer often reduces the softness of the soft layer because of magnetostatic interactions between the two types of layers. (iii) Spin valves: These systems will be presented in more detail in the following section. They essentially consist of two magnetic layers separated by a non-magnetic spacer layer. The magnetization of one layer is pinned by exchange interaction with an adjacent antiferromagnetic layer whereas the magnetization of the other layer is free to rotate in an applied field (Dieny et al., 1991a–d). Since the two layers are very weakly coupled, the change from parallel to antiparallel magnetic configuration can occur in small fields giving these systems a large sensitivity. Several reviews on the physics of GMR have already been published (Fert and Bruno, 1992; Vouille et al., 1999; Tsymbal and Pettifor, 2001). The reader is therefore encouraged to consult these reviews for a deeper understanding of the physics of this effect. Only the main ideas will be surveyed here. The basic origin of the GMR is described as follows. In transition metals and in particular in ferromagnetic transition metals, the electrons which participate to the conduction of the electrical current are s, d and hybridized sd electrons. Two families of these electrons can be distinguished according to the projection of their spin along the local magnetization: the spin " electrons (respectively, the spin # electrons) conventionally have the z-component of their spin parallel (respectively, antiparallel) to the local magnetization. In this description, the z-axis is chosen as the quantization axis and is parallel to the local magnetization. The spin " electrons (respectively, the spin # electrons) are also named majority (respectively, minority) electrons. At a temperature sufficiently low compared to the Curie temperature, these two species of electrons can be considered as carrying electrical current in parallel. This ‘twocurrent model’ (Mott and Wills, 1936) is justified because the spin –orbit coupling is weak in these relatively light elements and because magnon scattering is negligible at low temperature. All other scattering events are unable to perturb the spin state of the electrons. Furthermore, in ferromagnetic transition metals, the spin " and spin # electrons have very different scattering rates (Fert and Campbell, 1976; Dorleijn and Miedema, 1975, 1977; Gurney et al., 1993), regardless of the nature of the scattering centers (for example, magnetic impurities; structural defects such as dislocations, stacking faults or grain boundaries; or even phonons). The spin dependence of the scattering rates results from the difference of the density of available states at the Fermi energy into which the electrons can be scattered. The difference in the spin " and spin # density of states is itself a consequence of the d-band exchange splitting, characteristic of the magnetism of transition metals, as described by the well-known Stoner model (Stoner, 1938). As an example, in Permalloy (Ni80Fe20), the mean free path of spin " electrons has been estimated to be at least five times longer than that of spin # electrons (Fert and Campbell, 1976).
Spin valves 73 Let us then consider a magnetic multilayer consisting, for example, of Co layers alternating with Cu layers. We assume that the relative orientation of the magnetization in the successive Co layers can somehow be changed from parallel to antiparallel. Figure 2.1 depicts the potential presented to conduction electrons as they move through the multilayered structure.
Co/Cu majority electrons : parallel magnetic configuration Co
Cu
Co
Cu
(a)
Co/Cu minority electrons : parallel magnetic configuration
(b)
Co/Cu majority electrons : antiparallel magnetic configuration
(c)
Co/Cu minority electrons : antiparallel magnetic configuration U(x,z) (d) x
z
Fig. 2.1 Schematic representation of the potential Uðx; zÞ presented to majority (spin " ) and minority (spin # ) conduction electrons in (Co/Cu) multilayers. The z-direction is perpendicular to the interface, the x-direction is in the plane of the layers. The electrons experience a spin-dependent lattice potential modulation due to the matching between electron bands in adjacent layers, which leads to reflection and refraction effects. They are also scattered by random interfacial and bulk localized scattering centers (represented by localized potential peaks). (a) and (b) correspond to the case where the magnetizations in the Co layers are parallel, (c) and (d) are for the antiparallel magnetic configuration. Adapted from Vouille et al. (1999).
74
B. Dieny
In addition to the spin-dependent density of scattering centers (narrow, pointed peaks in Fig. 2.1) located at the interfaces and in the bulk of the layers, the conduction electrons also experience a spin-dependent modulation of the lattice potential. This results from the difference in the positions of the bottoms of the conduction bands with respect to the Fermi energy in the successive layers. In the case of (Co/Cu) multilayers, for instance, the matching of the conduction bands is very good for spin " electrons and these carriers are presented with a nearly flat potential throughout the structure. In contrast, a strong mismatch exists for spin # electrons, resulting in large potential steps at the Co/Cu interfaces for these electrons. These lattice potential modulations cause reflection and refraction of the electrons. Furthermore, it will be important to understand that they play a very different role in the CIP and CPP geometry. In the CIP geometry, the presence of potential wells, for example, for minority electrons in Cu in parallel magnetic configuration [Fig. 2.1(b)], leads to channeling effects: The electrons which propagate within the Cu layers bounce back and forth between the two (Cu/Co) interfaces and remain confined in these layers while drifting along the electrical field. In contrast, the electrical field is perpendicular to the interface in the CPP geometry. Therefore, the electrons are forced to pass these potential steps. This effectively results in additional spin-dependent interfacial resistance related to the height of the potential steps (Vedyaev et al., 1995; Barnas and Fert, 1995). In the case of periodic multilayered structures with extremely good structural quality, quantum interference may take place between the successive quantum wells leading to oscillations of conductance as a function of the thickness of the layers. However, these effects, which frequently occur in semiconductor multilayers, are much more difficult to observe in metallic multilayers due to the short Fermi ˚ ) compared to that in semiconductors (tens to hundreds of A ˚ ). wavelength in metals (a few A We therefore will not address them further here. The origin of the GMR can now be simply understood, as a first step, by only considering the spin-dependent scattering effects. These have been shown to represent the main contribution to the GMR in spin valves. At saturation, the magnetization orientations of the magnetic layers are parallel. The spin " electrons are then weakly scattered in all layers [Fig. 2.1(a)] and can therefore carry a lot of current with relatively low resistance. In contrast, the spin # electrons are strongly scattered in the magnetic layers so that they weakly participate to the conduction of the current [Fig. 2.1(b)]. Within the assumption that the mean free paths of the electrons are much longer than the thickness of the various layers, and if r " and r# designate the resistivity of the spin " and spin # electrons, respectively, the resistivity of the multilayer in this parallel configuration ðrP Þ can be estimated in a simple resistor model as rP ¼ r " r# =ðr " þ r# Þ (Baibich et al., 1988; Edwards et al., 1991; Mathon, 1991). In contrast, in the antiparallel magnetic configuration, electrons of both species are alternately strongly and weakly scattered as they cross the successive ferromagnetic layers [Fig. 2.1(c) and (d)]. The resistivity of the multilayer in this antiparallel configuration ðrAP Þ becomes rAP ¼ ðr " þ r# Þ=4: The GMR amplitude is then given by Dr=rP ¼ ð1 2 aÞ2 =4a; where a ¼ r " =r# : This expression is valid for CIP as well as for CPP transport in the limit that the layers
Spin valves 75 are thin compared to the spin " and # electron mean free paths, and neglecting the effects of the modulation of the lattice potential. This expression shows the key role played by the spin scattering asymmetry in the origin of the GMR. While the above model gives a good description of the basic GMR mechanism, various theories have addressed a detailed and complete interpretation of GMR in magnetic multilayers. A very comprehensive review of these theories has been written by Tsymbal and Pettifor (2001). They can be distinguished in two classes. The simplest theories, ‘semiclassical’, use the spindependent resistivities of the various materials and the spin-dependent interfacial resistances as input parameters (Camley and Barnas, 1989; Dieny, 1992; Dieny et al., 1992; Barthelemy and Fert, 1991; Hood and Falicov, 1992; Hood et al., 1994). The former parameters have been determined through extensive studies carried out more than 20 years ago to explain the anisotropic MR of ferromagnetic transition metals (Dorleijn, 1976; Campbell and Fert, 1982). The spindependent interfacial resistances have been determined from CPP measurements, most often at low temperature, and can be adjusted from their fit to the experimental data. Values of these parameters can be found in several reviews of CPP GMR (Gijs and Bauer, 1997; Bass and Pratt, 1999; Barthelemy et al., 1999). These theories then calculate the CIP transport properties (resistance and magnetoresistance amplitude) by using an adaptation of the Boltzmann theory of transport to the present case of magnetic multilayers. Theories in the second class start from a more basic point of view. Through tight binding or first principle models, they recalculate the electronic structure of the multilayered stack and, from this electronic structure, derive the transport properties. These theories are clearly more rigorous than the first ones but are unfortunately more difficult to handle and require long computation times, especially for the ab initio theories. In that respect, mainly the semiclassical theories have been used and have proven to be quite successful in explaining most of the general trends of the transport properties in spin valves. These include, for example, the dependence on the thickness of the various layers, the effect of inserting NOLs at particular locations to enhance the specular reflection, or the effect of inserting a conductive layer behind the free layer in spin-filter spin valves. In the following section, we will therefore present the basis of the semiclassical theory of CIP GMR. This theory has been extensively used to interpret the CIP GMR properties of magnetic multilayers and spin valves in particular. 2.2.2
Semiclassical theory of CIP giant magnetoresistance
The aim of this approach is to relate the microscopic transport parameters, the spin-dependent electron mean free paths and coefficients of interfacial transmission/reflection, to the macroscopic measurable quantities R and DR=R: The microscopic parameters are presumed to be weakly dependent on the thickness of the layers, so that once they have been determined by adjusting the calculated resistance and magnetoresistance to the experimental data on a few series of samples, the theory can then be used in a predictive way, or at least as a guideline for the optimization of
76
B. Dieny
the properties of spin valves. In this approach, the conduction electrons are described as a free electron gas submitted to scattering potentials randomly distributed in the interior of the layers and at the interfaces. Furthermore, the modulation of the lattice potential can lead to interfacial spindependent specular reflections, and these are taken into account. The theory is an extension of the Fuchs –Sondheimer theory which assumes parallel conductivity of the two species of conduction electrons. It is based on a semiclassical description of the electrons in metals in the presence of an external electrical field using a statistical distribution function. This distribution is written as the sum of two components: f s ð~r; ~vÞ ¼ f0s ð~r; ~vÞ þ gs ð~r; ~vÞ; in which f0s ð~r; ~vÞ represents the equilibrium Fermi –Dirac distribution and gs ð~r; ~vÞ is the perturbation to the equilibrium distribution induced by the applied electrical field. Superscript s refers to the electron spin, and ~r and ~v are, respectively, the position and velocity of the electrons. We then consider a multilayered stack consisting of layers in the x – y plane having a thickness ti : N is the total number of layers. The electric field is assumed to be applied along the x-axis parallel to the plane of the layers. The z-axis is perpendicular to plane. In this CIP geometry, the electric field is uniform in the structure. Furthermore, all scattering events in the metal layers occur at the Fermi energy so that the perturbation gs ð~r; ~vÞ only depends on the z-coordinate and on the direction of the velocity v: In steady state and in the relaxation time approximation, the perturbation gs ðz; vÞ is a solution of the Boltzmann equation:
›gs ðz; vÞ gs ðz; vÞ eE ›f 0 ðvÞ ¼ ; þ s mvz ›vx ›z t vz where e and m denote the charge and effective mass of the electrons. ts are the spin-dependent relaxation times related to the mean free paths ls by ts ¼ ls =vF ; where vF is the Fermi velocity. Within each layer, the solution gs ðz; vÞ of the Boltzmann equation takes a simple form: gs^ ðz; vÞ ¼ eEts vx
›f ð Þ z : 1 2 Asð^Þ exp 7 s ›1 t lvz l
ð2:1Þ
In this expression, the signs ^ refer to whether the z-component of the electron velocity is positive or negative. The Asð^Þ ’s are integration constants which need to be determined by using boundary conditions at each interface and at the outer surfaces. These boundary conditions relate the distribution of velocity of the electrons on both sides of the interface via spin-dependent coefficients of transmission T s and reflection Rs : These coefficients are defined to mean that an electron impinging on an interface has a probability T s of being coherently transmitted, Rs of being specularly reflected and consequently ð1 2 T s 2 Rs Þ of being diffusely scattered. The boundary conditions between layers i and i þ 1 are then given by gsiþ1;þ ¼ Tis gsi;þ þ Rsi gsiþ1;2 ;
ð2:2Þ
gsi;2 ¼ Tis gsiþ1;2 þ Rsi gsi;þ :
ð2:3Þ
Spin valves 77 At the outer surfaces, the same relations are used except that only the reflection terms must be kept since the conduction electrons cannot be transmitted outside the metal. By using relations (2.1), (2.2), and (2.3), the perturbation gs ðz; vÞ can be calculated in a self-consistent way throughout the multilayered stack. The local density of current at a given point z induced by the electrical field is then obtained by integrating, over all directions of velocity, the following Ð P expression, jðzÞ ¼ e s¼";# vx gs ðvz ; zÞd2 V; which yields jðzÞ /
2ti ti s s 2 Ai;2 exp s dm: ð1 2 m Þ 2 2 Ai;þ exp lsi m li m 0
X ð1 "#;i
2
ð2:4Þ
In this expression, m represents the cosine of the angle between the electron velocity and the normal to the film. From the expression of the current density, the local magnetic field generated by the sense current can be calculated. Let j be the average current density through the structure ( j in A/m2) and D the total thickness of the stack (in meters). The magnetic field due to the sense current at point z is then given by BðzÞ ðteslaÞ ¼ 2
ðD m0 jD þ m0 jðzÞdz with m0 ¼ 4p £ 1027 : 2 0
ð2:5Þ
As will be shown further, in magnetoresistive heads used in computer disk drives, current density of the order of 2 £ 107 A/cm2 can flow through the sensor. The magnetic field due to the sense current can then reach several millitesla. This has a quite significant impact on the magnetic properties of the sensor and in particular on its bias point. It is therefore quite important to take into account the field generated by the sense current. Furthermore, the total conductance is given by integrating the local current density over the entire thickness of the stack. The integration leads to two terms: G ¼ G0 2 G1
ð2:6Þ
with G0 ¼ e 2
N N X X lsi nsi ti ¼ rsi ti ; v m F i i¼1;"# i¼1;"#
ð2:7Þ
where rsi are the resistivity of each spin channel and G1 ¼
ð 3lsi X 1 2ti ti 2 s s d m ð1 2 m Þ m A 1 2 exp 1 2 exp þ A : i;þ i;2 4rsi "#;i 0 lsi m lsi m
ð2:8Þ
The first term ðG0 Þ gives the same conductance as if the various layers were simply carrying the current in parallel. The second term ðG1 Þ contains all finite size effects and in particular the change of conductance responsible for the GMR. This term must be calculated in the parallel and
78
B. Dieny
antiparallel magnetic configurations. The magnetoresistance is then given by DG ¼ Gparallel 2Gantiparallel ¼ Gantiparallel 2 Gparallel : 1 1 Since all layer thickness appear in t=l ratios in Eq. (2.8), it is clear that the characteristic scaling lengths in CIP transport are the mean free paths. This represents a significant difference with CPP transport, as will be further discussed below. At this stage, we point out that the current and therefore the CIP conductance are linearly related to the perturbation induced by the electrical field gs ð~r; ~vÞ: Therefore, from a basic point of view, DG is the macroscopic quantity most directly related to the MR of spin-valve structures (Dieny, 1992; Dieny et al., 1992). Other quantities such as DG=G; DR=R or DR are influenced not only by the intrinsic magnetoresistance of the structure but also by extrinsic effects, such as shunting of the current by outer layers, which affect the overall conductance of the structure. The point of view is different if one thinks in terms of the specific application of GMR to magnetoresistive sensors. As will be explained in more detail in Section 2.6, it is then DR which determines the amplitude of the readout signal and DR=R which gives the SNR. We point out that since R ¼ G21 ; the various quantities DG=G and DR=R are related to each other by DR=Rparallel ¼ DG=Gantiparallel : Several refinements have been brought to the semiclassical theory presented above. The dependence of the coefficients of interfacial transmission and reflection on the angle of incidence of the conduction electrons has been introduced. These coefficients are assumed to vary according to TðmÞ ¼ ðT0 Þ1=m with m ¼ cos u; where u is the angle between the electron velocity and the 2 normal to the interface, and RðmÞ ¼ ðR0 Þm : The improvement has been shown to bring the results of the semiclassical theory very close to those of the more elaborate quantum mechanical theories (Camblong and Levy, 1992). Furthermore, in order to take the columnar structure of the samples into account, an anisotropy in the mean free path was introduced. The electrons propagating with in-plane velocity undergo scattering at grain boundaries, whereas those propagating perpendicular to the interfaces do not experience this scattering. This leads to a slightly longer mean free path perpendicular to the plane than in the plane. Introducing a mean free path lgr associated with the scattering at grain boundaries, the mean free path for an incidence u is given by (Rijks, 1996) 1 1 sin u : ¼ s þ lgr ls ðuÞ l ð0Þ Another source of anisotropy in the mean free path is the AMR in the magnetic layers which leads to longer (respectively, shorter) mean free paths when the electrons propagate perpendicular (respectively, parallel) to the magnetization. This has been taken into account by some authors (Rijks et al., 1995) and it leads to a slight anisotropy in the GMR, i.e. a difference in the relative variation of resistance between the parallel and antiparallel magnetic configurations depending on the direction of the current (parallel or perpendicular) relatively to the magnetization direction. Shown below are a few general trends of CIP GMR which can be simply understood in model systems using the semiclassical theory. We first consider a simple sandwich consisting of
Spin valves 79 two ferromagnetic layers separated by a non-magnetic spacer layer, F tF =NM tNM =F tF ; in which the relative orientation of the magnetization in the two ferromagnetic layers can be changed from parallel to antiparallel. The parameters chosen in the calculation are representative of the case of NiFe/Cu/NiFe sandwiches. We investigate the dependence of the magnetoresistance on the thickness of the magnetic layers and non-magnetic spacer layer. We, furthermore, make several assumptions on the degree of specular reflection at the outer boundaries of the sandwich in order to discuss the influence of this reflection or diffuse scattering on the magnetotransport properties. The results are shown in Figs 2.2 and 2.3.
(a)
0.3 0.25
G (Ω 1)
0.2 p=1
0.15 0.1
p=0
0.05 (b)
0 p=1
∆G (Ω 1)
0.003 0.002 p=0 0.001
(c)
0 p=1
∆R/Rp (%)
10
5 p=0 0 0
50
100 150 200 250 300 tF (nm)
Fig. 2.2 Calculated transport properties: (a) conductance, (b) absolute change of sheet conductance and (c) relative magnetoresistance ratio normalized by the resistance in parallel magnetic configuration Rp for a sandwich of composition F tF /NM 2 nm/F tF as a function of the thickness of the ferromagnetic layers. ¼ 7 nm; lNiFe ¼ The chosen parameters are representative of the case of NiFe/Cu/NiFe sandwiches: lNiFe " # NiFe=Cu NiFe=Cu ¼ T# ¼ 0:9: The coefficient of specular reflection p at outer boundaries 0:8 nm; lCu ¼ 12 nm; T" varies from 0 to 1 by step of 0.25.
80
B. Dieny
20 p=1 ∆R/Rp (%)
15
10
5
0
p=0 0
50 tNM (nm)
100
150
Fig. 2.3 Magnetoresistance versus thickness of the non-magnetic spacer layer for the trilayer structure of composition F 3 nm/NM tNM /F 3 nm. The parameters in the calculation are the same as in Fig. 2.2.
The conductance in Fig. 2.2(a) increases approximately linearly with the thickness of the layers. This reflects the fact that in CIP, at the lowest order of approximation, the layer can be considered as carrying the current in parallel so that the dominant term in the conductivity is the expression given in Eq. (2.7). However, even though this lowest level of approximation is sufficient to approximate the variation of the conductance, it cannot explain the magnetoresistance. Indeed, if the layers and the two spin channels are simply assumed to carry the current in parallel in a resistor model, no change in resistance would occur between the parallel and antiparallel magnetic configurations. To explain CIP GMR, the finite size effects must be taken into account. As will be shown later, this constitutes a major difference with CPP transport. Figure 2.2(a) also demonstrates sensitivity to the specular reflection coefficient. It shows that the conductance is slightly lower when the scattering is diffusive on the outer boundary, due to a locally reduced conductivity caused by the scattering at these outer boundaries. Figure 2.2(b) and (c) shows the magnetoresistance in two different forms. The absolute change of conductance DG [Fig. 2.2(b)] increases qualitatively as ð1 2 expð2tF =l"F ÞÞ versus tF for p ¼ 0 and as ð1 2 expð2tF =l#F ÞÞ for p ¼ 1: It is interesting to note that all curves reach the same asymptotic value independent of the degree of specular reflection at outer surfaces. Similarly, if a buffer or a capping layer were added to the sandwich structure, the same asymptotic DG would be obtained, therefore, reiterating that DG is the quantity that intrinsically characterizes the magnetoresistance of the sandwich. In contrast, the relative magnetoresistance exhibits a maximum which shifts towards lower thickness as the specular reflection at the outer surfaces increases. In correlation, the MR ratio increases and is maximum for perfect specular reflection.
Spin valves 81 Here, too, the variation of MR can be qualitatively described by
DR ¼ R
DR ¼ R
DR R
DR R
1 2 exp
0
0
!!
l"F t 1þ F trest
1 2 exp
2tF
2tF
l#F t 1þ F trest
for p ¼ 0;
ð2:9Þ
for p ¼ 1:
ð2:10Þ
!!
These expressions simply result from the equality DR=Rparallel ¼ DG=Gantiparallel and the observation that the conductance increases linearly with the thickness of the tF layer. trest represents an effective thickness related to the equivalent conductance of the sandwich without the considered F layers. The decay lengths l"F and l#F are related to the corresponding mean free paths l"F and l#F (Dieny, 1992; Dieny et al., 1992). They are usually shorter than the corresponding mean free paths by a factor of the order of 2 because of the averaging over all incidence of conduction electrons. In these curves, increasing the specular reflection has the same effect on the MR ratio as increasing the number of repeats has in ðF=NMÞn multilayers. This is because the specular reflection introduces a mirror symmetry in the structure. As a result, a sandwich of composition F tF =NM tNM =F tF with purely specular reflection at outer boundaries ðp ¼ 1Þ would have the same magnetoresistance ratio as a multilayer consisting of an infinite number of repeats of ðF 2tF =NM tNM Þ: The shift in the position of the maximum in DR=R as p varies from 0 to 1 [Fig. 2.1(c)] and the correlated change in the characteristic lengths of the exponential variation in the phenomenological formula given above for DR=RðtF Þ can be qualitatively understood as follows. The GMR amplitude is related to the differences of overall scattering which occur for spin " and spin # electrons in the structure. For the following discussion, let us assume that the spin " electrons have the longer mean free path and consider an F tF =NM 2 nm=F tF sandwich with diffuse scattering at outer boundaries ð p ¼ 0Þ: If tF , l"F ; the incoming electrons entering the F layer from the spacer are very rapidly scattered at the outer surface. This reduces their ‘scattering contrast’ with spin # electrons. When the thickness of the ferromagnetic layer becomes of the order of the mean free path, the GMR amplitude reaches maximum. For larger thickness, a portion of the current is shunted in a part of the sandwich which is inactive from the point of view of the GMR leading to an hyperbolic decrease of the MR ratio for further increases in thickness. If we now assume specular reflection at the outer boundaries, the situation is very different. Since the incoming spin " electrons are reflected without losing momentum at the outer boundaries, the constraint is now on spin # electrons. The magnetic layer must be thick enough to scatter them efficiently. If not, they
82
B. Dieny
can conduct more current and the ‘scattering contrast’ with the spin " electrons is again diminished. Figure 2.3 shows the calculated variation of the GMR in a series of F 3 nm=NM tNM =F 3 nm sandwiches in which the thickness tNM of the non-magnetic spacer layer is varied. The GMR decreases monotonically with increasing non-magnetic spacer layer thickness. Qualitatively, this decrease can be described by
DR ¼ R
2tNM exp DR lNM : t R 0 1 þ NM trest
ð2:11Þ
The numerator shows that the number of electrons traversing from one ferromagnetic layer to the other through the spacer decreases exponentially with increasing thickness of this layer, with a characteristic length lNM related to the mean free path in this layer. The denominator is related to the increased shunting of the current in the spacer layer as its thickness increases. Other examples of the use of semiclassical theory of transport will be shown later in this chapter. We now discuss the main differences between CIP and CPP transport in these metallic multilayers. 2.2.3
Current perpendicular to plane giant magnetoresistance
In the CPP geometry, the current flows perpendicular to the plane of the layers as illustrated in Fig. 2.4. In the simplest approximation, the various layers can be considered as carrying the current in series. In the absence of a spin-flip mechanism during scattering, the transport properties can be described in a very simple two-channel resistor model. A resistor network for a sandwich "ð#Þ F tF =NM tNM =F tF is shown in Fig. 2.5, where rF are the spin-dependent resistivities in the "ð#Þ F layers, and ARF=NM are the spin-dependent interfacial resistances, per unit area, at the F/NM interfaces. In CPP, it is quite common to express the value of CPP resistance in terms of the product of area £ resistance. This comes from the fact that the resistance of a homogeneous pillar of section A varies as the product of the resistivity times the thickness of the pillar divided by the I I V I
I
V
I
CPP
CIP
Fig. 2.4 Schematic representation of the difference between CPP and CIP transport geometries. In the CPP geometry, the multilayered structure is sandwiched between bottom and top electrodes.
Spin valves 83
(a) Parallel magnetic configuration : rF↑tF
↑ ARF/NM
rNMtNM
↑ ARF/NM
rF↑tF
rF↓tF
↓ ARF/NM
rNMtNM
↓ ARF/NM
rF↓tF
(b) Antiparallel magnetic configuration : rF↑tF
↑ ARF/NM
rNMtNM
↓ ARF/NM
rF↓tF
rF↓tF
↓ ARF/NM
rNMtNM
↑ ARF/NM
rF↑tF
Fig. 2.5 Two-channel resistance network which can be used to model the CPP GMR in F tF /NM tNM /F tF sandwiches: (a) parallel magnetic configuration; (b) antiparallel magnetic configuration.
area. The best way to describe the intrinsic properties of the material independently of geometrical consideration is therefore to give the value of its resistance £ area product. It is interesting to note that this simplest approximation can already explain the CPP GMR, which was not the case for the CIP GMR. The CIP GMR requires consideration of finite size effects and, in particular, the influence of the electron mean free paths. This is not the case for CPP GMR. The mean free paths are no longer characteristic lengths in CPP transport. They play an indirect role through the spin-dependent resistivities but do not determine how the CPP GMR varies as a function of the thickness of the various layers. The serial resistance network has been successfully used to interpret a number of experimental results obtained primarily at low temperature (Pratt et al., 1991; Lee et al., 1992, 1993, 1995; List et al., 1995; Piraux et al., 1996; Doudin et al., 1996 and for reviews: Bass and Pratt, 1999; Fert and Piraux, 1999). A summary of the characteristic transport parameters determined at low temperature is given in Table 2.1. These parameters are defined by introducing the following notations: "ð#Þ
ð2:12Þ
"ð#Þ
ð2:13Þ
rF ¼ 2rpF ½1 2 ðþÞb; rN ¼ 2rpN ; "ð#Þ
ARF=NM ¼ 2ARpF=NM ½1 2 ðþÞg:
ð2:14Þ
Parameters b and g; with values between 2 1 and 1, characterize the scattering asymmetry in the bulk and at the interface between the successive layers, respectively. The measurable resistivities of the ferromagnetic metal rF and of the non-magnetic metal rN and the measurable F/NM interfacial resistance are related to these parameters by the following relations:
rF ¼ rpF ð1 2 b2 Þ;
rN ¼ rpN ;
ARF=NM ¼ ARpF=NM ð1 2 g2 Þ:
Table 2.1 summarizes the results obtained by different groups using various preparation techniques. A sizeable spread in the results is observed reflecting the variation in the density of
Table 2.1 Characteristic parameters of CPP transport deduced from low temperature measurements of the CPP GMR in (Co/Cu) and (NiFe/Cu) based multilayers prepared under various conditions Sputtered multilayers, 4.2 K (MSU) (Bass and Pratt, 1999)
MBE-grown multilayers, 4.2 K (List et al., 1995)
Grooved substrates, 4.2 K (Oepts et al., 1996)
Electrodeposited nanowires, 77 K (Piraux et al., 1996)
Electrodeposited nanowires, 20 K (Doudin et al., 1996)
3.1
1.3 – 3.3
rpCu (mV cm)
0.6 ^ 0.1
1.3 ^ 0.3
0.39 ^ 0.07
rpCo (mV cm) bCo ARpCo/Cu (mV mm2) gCo/Cu
6.6 ^ 0.5
3.0 ^ 0.6
4.2 ^ 0.7
18 ^ 2
0.38 ^ 0.6 0.38 ^ 0.03 0.71 ^ 0.05 15.9
0.48 ^ 0.04 0.43 ^ 0.04 0.71 ^ 0.02
0.27 ^ 0.03 0.25 ^ 0.04 0.50 ^ 0.09
0.36 ^ 0.04 0.30 ^ 0.05 0.85 ^ 0.10 26.3
rpNiFe (mV cm) bNiFe ARpNiFe/Cu (mV mm2) gNiFe/Cu
0.73 0.54 0.70
lsf Cu (nm)
0.8 ^ 0.1 140 ^ 20 59 ^ 18
lsf Co (nm) lsf NiFe (nm)
0.8 ^ 0.1
5.5
Adapted from Fert and Piraux (1999) and Tsymbal and Pettifor (2001).
4.3 ^ 1
51 –57 0.46 ^ 0.05 0.3 – 1.1 0.55 ^ 0.07
Spin valves 85 defects in these different structures. However, some general trends clearly arise. For example, scattering asymmetry at the Co/Cu interface ðgCo=Cu Þ is larger than in bulk Co ðbCo Þ: By contrast, NiFe seems to have comparable scattering asymmetry in the bulk and at NiFe/Cu interfaces. From these parameters, it is possible to point out the important role played by interfaces, particularly in the CPP GMR. In the resistor network model, the contribution from the bulk scattering balances the contribution from the interfacial scattering for a characteristic thickness tFp given by brpF tFp ¼ 2ARpF=NM (assuming that the layer is delimited by two interfaces). This leads to values for Co and p p NiFe of tCo < 20 nm and tNiFe < 6:5 nm; respectively. The resistor model has been able to explain a large number of results, especially at low temperature, in Co-based multilayers having relatively thin layers. However, strong deviations from this model were observed in NiFe-based systems. Similarly, the resistor model cannot explain the different magnetoresistive properties obtained in multilayers in which the ordering of the layers is changed, for example, interleaved (Co 1 nm/Cu 2 nm/Co 6 nm/Cu 2 nm)4 multilayers compared to separated (Co 1 nm/Co 20 nm)4/(Co 6 nm/Cu 20 nm)4 multilayers (Bozec et al., 2000). The main difference between these two situations is described as follows. In the antiparallel magnetic configuration of the interleaved multilayers, every other Co layer has a down magnetization. In the separated multilayers, by contrast, one half of the stack has magnetization up and the other half has the magnetization down. These deviations from the simple resistor network are mainly caused by spin relaxation and spin accumulation effects, which play a very important role in CPP transport (Valet and Fert, 1993). Interfacial spin accumulation can be understood in a simple way by looking at Fig. 2.6. In bulk magnetic materials, as already discussed, the two spin channels do not carry the same amount of current because the two species of electrons have different scattering rates. Consider an interface separating two magnetic semi-infinite layers (Fig. 2.6) having antiparallel magnetic configuration, and suppose a current is flowing from right to left, i.e. electrons are drifting from left to right. We further assume that the spin " (majority electrons) are less scattered than the spin # electrons ðb . 0Þ: For simplicity, we adopt the convention that the magnetization is parallel to the spin of the majority electrons. In the left ferromagnetic layer, far from the interface, the current is mainly carried by spin " electrons. The spin " current is given by j" ¼ ðJ=2Þð1 þ bÞ; where J is the total current density. The spin # electrons carry a smaller current j# ¼ ðJ=2Þð1 2 bÞ: Figure 2.6 has been drawn assuming b ¼ 0:7; a value close to that determined for Permalloy (Table 2.1). On the right-hand side, the magnetization is down and the roles of spin " and spin # electrons are inverted. More spin # electrons flow away from the interface than spin " electrons. Within each spin channel, there is therefore a clear unbalance between the number of electrons moving towards (on the left) and away from (on the right) the interface per unit time. This results in a spin accumulation which consists (Fig. 2.6) of a local excess of spin " electrons around the interface and a correlated local deficit in spin # electrons. In steady state, this spin accumulation does not increase with time because it is counterbalanced by spin-flip processes. Due to spin –orbit interaction and magnons, the electrons can undergo scattering events which modify their spin.
86
B. Dieny
(a)
∆µ
Direction of electron drift
lFsf lFsf z J(1 + β)
j↑
jσ
(b)
J/2
J(1
β)
j↓
lFsf lFsf z
Fig. 2.6 Illustration of the phenomenon of spin accumulation at a single interface separating two ferromagnetic layers of opposite magnetization. The electrons drift from left to right (the current flows from the right). The plot is drawn assuming that the spin " (majority electrons) are less scattered than the spin # electrons ðb . 0Þ: The large arrows represent magnetization orientation. (a) The spatial variation of the difference in chemical potential Dm ¼ m" 2 m# between the two species of electrons. Dm . 0 means an accumulation of spin " electrons at the interface. (b) The spatial variation in current density for each spin channel. The gradient of current reflects the spin relaxation which takes place within the characteristic spindiffusion length scale lsf F : Adapted from Valet and Fert (1993).
We recall that magnons are also named spin waves and represent elementary excitations of the magnetization. The characteristic length scale over which the electrons maintain their spin orientation in a given material is the spin-diffusion length lsf : In a ferromagnetic material, the latter is related to the spin-flip relaxation time tsf via 1 ðlsf Þ2
¼
1 1 þ # 2; 2 " ðl Þ ðl Þ
where the ls are given by ls ¼ ½ 13 ðvF ls Þtsf 1=2 :
ð2:15Þ
vF is the Fermi velocity and ls are the elastic mean free paths. Values of the spin-diffusion lengths in various commonly used materials at low temperature are given in Table 2.1. The balance between the spin accumulation and spin relaxation leads to local variations in the difference Dm of electrochemical potential of spin " and spin # electrons as illustrated in Fig. 2.6(a). The result is a small non-equilibrium local magnetization near the interface,
Spin valves 87 proportional to the current (Valet and Fert, 1993). The Valet and Fert theory addresses the effect of spin accumulation in detail, using a relatively simple macroscopic model based on two basic equations: 2erp
›js ðms 2 m2s Þ ¼2 ; ›z ðlsf Þ2
ð2:16Þ
js ¼
1 ›ms : ers ›z
ð2:17Þ
Here, e represents the absolute value of the electron charge, and the resistivities rp and rs are given by relations (2.12) and (2.13). The first equation describes spin relaxation effects, whereas the second is a generalized form of Ohm’s law. A result of these equations is that Dm obeys a simple diffusion equation within each layer, having the general solution: Dm ¼ A exp
z lsf
z þ B exp 2 : lsf
The constants A and B must be determined by interfacial boundary conditions as in the semiclassical model of CIP GMR. These boundary conditions express the continuity of the current for each spin channel through the interfaces and in the presence of spin-dependent interfacial resistance ARs ; the electrochemical potential must fulfill the equation: s 2 ms ðz ¼ zþ 0 Þ 2 m ðz ¼ z0 Þ ¼
ARs s j ðz ¼ z0 Þ: e
Using these equations, it is possible to calculate the CPP resistance and CPP magnetoresistance of any magnetic multilayered stack, taking into account spin-flip processes (Strelkov et al., 2003). The failure of the simple resistor network to explain the CPP GMR of NiFe-based multilayers and multilayers in which the ordering of the layer is changed can be understood in terms of spin relaxation effects. In both types of systems, the length scale over which electrons propagating perpendicular to the plane experience a change from up magnetization to down magnetization is longer than the spin-diffusion length. This is true in NiFe-based systems because of the relatively short spin-diffusion length in NiFe (5.5 nm at 4.2 K) (Steenwyk et al., 1997). It is also true in the separated (Co 1 nm/Cu 20 nm)4/(Co 6 nm/Cu 20 nm)4 multilayers because the spin-diffusion length in Co and Cu is not long compared to the total thickness of the stack. Furthermore, some additional spin-flip scattering may take place at Co/Cu interfaces (Eid et al., 2002). A dependence of the interface resistance on the proximity of the other interfaces has also been proposed as an alternative explanation to the observed difference between interleaved and separated multilayers (Bozec et al., 2000). Based on the Valet and Fert theory, we now discuss the influence of parameters such as layer thickness on the CPP properties of magnetic sandwiches inserted between thick Cu electrodes.
88
B. Dieny
Consider the model system Cu=F tF =NM 3 nm=F 5 nm=Cu; where F represents Ni80Fe20 or Co. In the following calculations, the values listed in the fifth column of Table 2.1 (Piraux et al., 1996) were used for NiFe and Co. Figure 2.7 shows the variation of MR versus the thickness of the ferromagnetic layer in terms of the absolute MR [Fig. 2.7(a)] and relative MR ratio [Fig. 2.7(b)]. With NiFe, a clear maximum in DR=R is observed versus tNiFe at a thickness slightly larger than the spin-diffusion length lsf NiFe ¼ 4:3 nm; while ADR increases and reaches an asymptotic value for tNiFe q lsf NiFe : The absolute MR magnitude is quite large, much larger than in Co/Cu/Co sandwiches of the same thickness. This comes from the large contribution of the bulk spindependent scattering in NiFe, which is much larger than the bulk contribution in Co. The decrease in DR=R at thicknesses larger than lsf NiFe is caused by the serial contribution of the resistance of a part of the NiFe layer which is further from the other NiFe layer than lsf NiFe : This portion contributes little to the MR and a dilution of the DR=R results for large tF :
(a)
0.008 NiFe tF/Cu 3nm/NiFe 5nm A.∆R (Ω.µm2)
0.006
(b)
0.004
Co tF/Cu 3nm/Co 5nm
0.002
=0.25
0
NiFe tF/Cu 3nm/NiFe 5nm ∆R/Rp (%)
100
50 Co tF/Cu 3 nm/Co 5nm γ = 0.25 0
0
10
20 30 tF (nm)
40
50
Fig. 2.7 Calculation of CPP magnetoresistance of NiFe tF /Cu 3 nm/NiFe 5 nm and Co tF /Cu 3 nm/Co 5 nm sandwiches inserted between Cu electrodes versus thickness of one of the ferromagnetic layers. (a) Absolute magnetoresistance £ area product. (b) Relative MR ratio, DR=R; at 77 K. The calculated resistances and MR are those of the sandwich itself, i.e. without considering the additional resistance of the electrodes. The dotted curve is calculated using the same parameters as for Co/Cu/Co except that the interfacial scattering asymmetry has been reduced from 0.85 to 0.25 to show the role of the relative influence of bulk and interfacial scattering on the shape of these curves.
Spin valves 89 In a Co/Cu/Co sandwich, DR=R decreases monotonically versus tCo [Fig. 2.7(b)]. This is caused by the dominant role of interfacial spin-dependent scattering in this system. The dotted curves in Fig. 2.7 were calculated using the same parameters for the Co/Cu/Co particular sandwich with the sole difference that the parameter g has been reduced from 0.85 to 0.25. A maximum in DR=R versus tF is then seen [Fig. 2.7(b)]. ADR also reaches an asymptotic value but more slowly than with NiFe because of the longer spin-diffusion length in Co. It is interesting to note that ADR in CPP transport as the same functional form ð1 2 expð2t=lÞÞ; as DG in CIP transport. However, the characteristic length in CPP transport is the spin-diffusion length compared to the elastic mean free path in CIP transport. Figure 2.8 shows the dependence of CPP MR on the thickness of the non-magnetic spacer layer, which is Cu in our own model system.
(a)
0.006
A.∆R (Ω.µm2)
NiFe tF/Cu 3nm/NiFe 5nm 0.004
0.002 Co tF/Cu 3nm/Co 5nm γ=0.25
(b)
0
∆R/Rp (%)
NiFe tF/Cu 3nm/NiFe 5nm 100
50 Co tF/Cu 3nm/Co 5nm γ=0.25 0
0
10
20 30 tNM (nm)
40
50
Fig. 2.8 Calculation of CPP magnetoresistance of NiFe 5 nm/Cu tNM /NiFe 5 nm and Co 5 nm/Cu tNM /Co 5 nm sandwiches inserted between Cu electrodes versus thickness of the non-magnetic spacer layer. (a) Absolute MR. (b) Relative MR ratio, DR=R; T ¼ 77 K. The dotted curve is calculated using the same parameters as for Co/Cu/Co except that the interfacial scattering asymmetry has been reduced from 0.85 to 0.25.
90
B. Dieny
The CPP magnetoresistance ADR decreases monotonically versus the thickness of the non-magnetic spacer layer, having the approximate form expð2t=lÞ with the characteristic decay length represented by the spin-flip diffusion length in Cu, lsf Cu : In order to get a large CPP GMR amplitude, the spin-diffusion length in the spacer must be much larger than the thickness of this layer. In that respect, pure Cu is a good spacer layer. The spin-diffusion length of Au is shorter because Au has a higher atomic number, larger spin orbit interactions and shorter spin relaxation time (see Chapter 1). Certain types of impurities such as Mn and Pt have been shown to dramatically shorten the spin-diffusion length in Cu or Ag (Yang, 1994). While these experiments confirmed details of CPP theory, the presence of such impurities must be avoided between the free and pinned layers. The exponential decrease of ADR versus tNM can be compared to a corresponding exponential decrease of DG in CIP GMR where the characteristic length is related to the elastic mean free path in Cu. Concerning the MR ratio [Fig. 2.8(b)], DR=R exhibits a steeper decrease versus tNM than ADR due to the combined effect of spin relaxation, which leads to the exponential decrease of ADR; and to the series addition of an increasing amount of spacer layer resistance. This causes a dilution effect and leads to a further hyperbolic decrease of the magnetoresistance. Again this can be compared to the variation of DG=G given by relation (2.11) (we remind that DG=Gparallel ¼ DR=Rantiparallel ). In this latter case, the variation was also a combination of an exponential and a hyperbolic decrease in GMR, the hyperbolic decrease arising from the increasing parallel shunting of the current in the spacer layer. In concluding this section, the above discussions have shown the intrinsic differences between CIP and CPP transport. The CIP GMR cannot be modeled by a simple parallel resistor network. The lowest order of approximation requires inclusion of finite size effects for which the characteristic lengths are the spin-dependent elastic mean free paths. In contrast, CPP transport can be described in the lowest order of approximation by a two-channel serial resistance network. Finite size effects can play an important role when the thickness of the layers becomes larger than the spin-diffusion lengths.
2.3 2.3.1
Basic properties of spin valves Spin valves
The simplest spin valves comprise two ferromagnetic layers (F1 and F2) separated by a nonmagnetic spacer layer (NM). The magnetization of F2 is pinned by coupling with an adjacent antiferromagnetic layer using the so-called exchange anisotropy phenomenon. Figure 2.9(a) and (b) shows the room temperature hysteresis loop and magnetoresistance of a sample of structure Ta 5 nm/NiFe 6 nm/Cu 2.2 nm/NiFe 4 nm/FeMn 7 nm/Ta 5 nm (Dieny et al., 1991a).
Spin valves 91
1
M (10
3
emu)
(a)
(b)
0 1
4
∆R/R (%)
3 2 1 0 (c)
200
0
200 400 H(Oe)
600
800
4
∆R/R (%)
3 2 1 0
40
20
0 20 H(Oe)
40
Fig. 2.9 (a) Hysteresis loop; (b) magnetoresistance of a spin-valve sample of composition Ta 5 nm/NiFe 6 nm/Cu 2.2 nm/NiFe 4 nm/FeMn 7 nm/Ta 5 nm; (c) magnetoresistance observed when a minor loop is performed on the nominally free layer (T ¼ 300 K).
The hysteresis loop of this structure consists of two loops. The first one is centered at 6 Oe, has a coercivity of less than 1 Oe, and corresponds to the reversal of the free NiFe layer. The second has a coercivity of 100 Oe and a loop shift of 420 Oe which is associated with the reversal of the magnetization of the NiFe layer that is exchange coupled to FeMn (pinned layer). When the field is swept between ^ 1 kOe, the magnetizations of the NiFe layers change from parallel (below 4 Oe and above , 600 Oe) to antiparallel (between 8 and ,250 Oe). The 6 Oe loop shift of the nominally free NiFe layers [Fig. 2.9(c)] indicates the presence of a slight ferromagnetic coupling through the Cu spacer layer. The magnetoresistance curve of Fig. 2.9(b) exhibits a very sharp rise corresponding to the switching of the free layer, followed by a gradual decrease to zero as the magnetization of the pinned layer reverses. The interesting feature of spin valves is that the change in the relative orientation between the magnetization in the magnetic layers does not rely
92
B. Dieny
on the existence of an antiferromagnetic coupling through the spacer, but on the existence of asymmetric pinning forces acting on the magnetization of the two ferromagnetic layers. This allows the realization of very high magnetoresistance sensitivity at low fields. The denomination ‘bottom’ and ‘top’ spin valves has been introduced to specify whether the antiferromagnetic pinning layer and its adjacent ferromagnetic pinned layer are deposited before the free layer (at the bottom of the stack) or after the free layer (at the top of the stack). 2.3.2 2.3.2.1
Magnetic properties Exchange anisotropy
The phenomenon of exchange anisotropy was discovered by Meiklejohn (1962) but a quantitative understanding has not yet been achieved. Reviews of the topic have been published by Kools (1996), Nogues and Schuller (1999), and Berkowitz and Takano (1999). The ferromagnetic/ antiferromagnetic coupling causes both enhanced coercivity and a loop shift. The intrinsic anisotropy of the antiferromagnetic material and the thickness of the antiferromagnetic layer (AF) are dominant factors, but in polycrystalline samples, the grain size, the homogeneity in the distribution of grain size and the coupling between grains, all play significant roles. Indeed, in order to observe a large pinning of the magnetization in the ferromagnetic layer, it is important that the magnetization of the antiferromagnetic layer is not dragged by the torque exerted by the magnetization of the ferromagnetic layer, across the interface, as the latter switches. The energy barrier due to the magnetocrystalline anisotropy in each antiferromagnetic grain is defined as Ea ¼ KV ¼ KAtAF ; where K is the anisotropy per unit volume, A is the area of the grain, and tAF is the thickness of the antiferromagnetic layer. The coupling energy between the ferromagnetic layer and the antiferromagnetic layer is given by Eexb ¼ JA; where J is the coupling per unit area. Taking into account the thermal activation of the antiferromagnetic grains, the condition of stability of the spin lattice in the antiferromagnetic layer for a certain duration tstability is written as KAtAF . JA þ Ln
tstability kB T; t0
where t0 is the attempt time of the order of 1029 s. For a typical device lifespan of 10 years, the factor Lnðtstability =t0 Þ is of the order of 40. This qualitative argument shows that increasing the stability of the antiferromagnetic layer can be achieved by increasing its anisotropy, its thickness or the grain size. Alternatively, improving the coupling between grains would lead to an effect comparable with increasing the grain size. In spin valves for read-head applications, the qualities that are required of antiferromagnetic layer are that it must provide a sufficiently large exchange field ðHexb . 500 OeÞ at the operating temperature (typically 1008C), it must be highly resistive in order to reduce parasitic shunting of
Spin valves 93
Fig. 2.10 Temperature dependence of the exchange energy in spin-valve structures with different biasing layers (Nozieres et al., 2000).
the current in CIP geometry, it must have sufficiently low processing temperature in order not to perturb the structural integrity of the stack, and it must be corrosion resistant and thermally stable. Furthermore, as will be explained in Section 2.6, if the antiferromagnetic layer is metallic, it must be thin enough to maintain a read gap width as small as possible. Oxide antiferromagnetic materials such as NiO, a-Fe3O4, Fe2O3 have been implemented in spin valves, but they have not provided good pinning properties despite large GMR amplitude (Sakakima, 1999). The most widely used antiferromagnetic layers are Mn-based alloys, in particular ordered alloys such as Pt50Mn50, which provide a large bias field with a high blocking temperature. Figure 2.10 shows the exchange bias energy of a variety of antiferromagnetic materials as a function of temperature (Nozieres et al., 2000). NiMn is seen to be a good candidate but it usually leads to lower MR amplitude than PtMn-based spin valves. The exchange bias field ðHexb Þ is a parameter that results from a balance between the volume Zeeman energy supplied by the applied field to the free layer magnetization and the surface energy of coupling with the adjacent antiferromagnetic layer. It scales as the inverse of the pinned layer thickness. For optimizing the magnetic properties, it is therefore better to reduce the thickness of the pinned layer. However, for maximizing the GMR amplitude, there is an optimum thickness below which the GMR drops, as explained in the discussion of Fig. 2.2. In this respect, increasing the specular reflection at the interface between the pinned layer and the AF layer is beneficial since this reduces the optimum thickness of the pinned layer and therefore leads to a larger Hexb of the pinned layer. 2.3.2.2
Interlayer coupling
In spin valves, the interlayer coupling between the free and the pinned layers causes a shift in the hysteresis loop of the free layer. There are three main contributions to this interlayer coupling:
94
B. Dieny
Fig. 2.11 Structure of the ferromagnetic/non-magnetic spacer/ferromagnetic sandwich which leads to the onset of the orange peel coupling. When the magnetizations of the two ferromagnetic layers are parallel, magnetostatic charges of opposite sign appear symmetrically on opposing interfaces (see, for example, the encircled area). In contrast, if the magnetizations are antiparallel, charges of the same sign are facing each other leading to an increase in energy. This results in an effective ferromagnetic coupling between the two magnetic layers.
(1) At very low thickness, direct coupling through pinholes in the non-magnetic spacer layer may occur. The thickness below which this coupling becomes dominant clearly depends on the roughness of the layers and on the degree of interdiffusion between the magnetic and nonmagnetic spacer material. Use of an optimized buffer, such as a NiFeCr-based alloy instead of Ta, has allowed a reduction of the critical thickness from about 1.8 nm down to 0.8 nm. (2) Another source of ferromagnetic coupling which is often encountered in multilayers, and particularly spin valves of average crystallographic quality, is caused by the orange peel mechanism initially described by Ne´el (1962). In multilayers, the roughness of the interfaces is often correlated from one interface to another by the very fact that the thickness of the layers is uniform (cf. Fig. 2.11). Dipolar interactions between the magnetostatic charges which then appear on the interfaces give rise to a ferromagnetic coupling between the magnetic layers. Quantitatively, describing the interfacial roughness as a sinusoidal function of amplitude h (2h being the peak to peak roughness), and wavelength L (typically of the order of the grain size), one can show, using Ne´el’s model, that the resultant dipolar coupling between the magnetic layers across a non-magnetic layer of thickness tNM is given in CGS units by (Schulthess and Butler, 2000) pffiffiffi pffiffiffi 2 h2 2 22 2ptNM Ms exp : J ¼ 2p L L
ð2:18Þ
In general, this coupling is weaker than the direct coupling due to pinholes and usually manifests itself at greater thicknesses, i.e. at tNM of the order of 2–10 nm. (3) A third contribution to the interlayer coupling observable in spin valves of high structural quality is the oscillatory RKKY (Ruderman–Kittel –Kasuya– Yosida) coupling (Ruderman and Kittel, 1954; Kasuya, 1956; Yosida, 1957). This results from a spin polarization of the electrons of the non-magnetic layer induced by a contact interaction with the magnetic layers. In bulk non-magnetic metals, a ferromagnetic impurity (e.g. a Mn impurity) placed in a Cu matrix polarizes the sea of conduction electrons in the Cu in the vicinity of the Mn ion.
Spin valves 95 The densities of all the spin " and spin # electrons, not just the electrons near the Fermi energy, instead of being equal, are slightly different in the vicinity of the impurity. The resulting spin polarization oscillates with a wave vector 2kF (where kF is the Fermi wave vector) and attenuates as 1=r3 ; where r is the distance from the impurity. If a second magnetic impurity is found at a certain distance from the first, the reciprocal coupling effect between the conduction electrons of the matrix and this second impurity give rise to an indirect coupling between the spins of the two impurities. The coupling may be ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic, depending on the distance between them. The same coupling mechanism occurs in multilayers. In this case, the oscillatory polarization of the electrons of the nonmagnetic interlayer is induced by magnetic atoms situated at the F/NM interface. The resultant coupling may be ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic, depending on the thickness of the spacer layer. Theoretical models relate the period of the oscillations with certain details of the Fermi surface (Bruno and Chappert, 1991, 1992; Deaven et al., 1991). In samples of very good structural quality, the superposition of a number of periods of oscillation may be observed. Figure 2.12 shows the variation of the loop shift of the free layer in sputtered spin valves of the composition NiFeCr 6 nm/NiFe 4 nm/CoFe 1 nm/Cu tCu /CoFe 2 nm/Ru 0.9 nm/CoFe 2.5 nm/ PtMn 10 nm. By optimizing the growth conditions, the RMS roughness of these samples has been reduced to less than 0.2 nm. This permits the observation of the oscillatory RKKY coupling, even though it is not obtained with non-optimized conditions such as, for instance, when Ta buffer layers are used. Good control of the Cu thickness then allows an adjustment of the bias point of the spin valve, as will be explained in Section 2.6.
100 80 60 Ferro
He (Oe)
40 20 0 20
Antiferro
40 60 0
0.5
1 1.5 2 Cu thickness (nm)
2.5
3
Fig. 2.12 Loop shift of the free layer versus thickness of the non-magnetic spacer layer in spin valve of the composition NiFeCr 6 nm/NiFe 4 nm/CoFe 1 nm/Cu tCu /CoFe 2 nm/Ru 0.9nn/CoFe 2.5 nm/PtMn 10 nm. From M. Li, S. Liao, C. Horng, K. Ju, Headway Technologies.
96
B. Dieny
2.3.3
CIP transport properties
2.3.3.1
Influence of the thickness of the ferromagnetic layer
Figure 2.13 shows the magnetoresistance variation as a function of thickness of the free layer, for a series of three spin valves of the composition Si/SiO2/F tF /Cu 2.5 nm/NiFe 5 nm/FeMn 10 nm, and having different free layer material F ¼ Ni80Fe20, Co and Fe (Dieny et al., 1991a–d). The general shape of these curves is consistent with the prediction of the semiclassical theory for the case of weak specular reflection at the buffer/free layer and pinned layer/AF interfaces (see Fig. 2.2). The increase in GMR at low ferromagnetic thickness is due to decreased scattering of the spin " electrons at the substrate/free layer interface, therefore increasing the scattering contrast between spin " and spin # electrons. The decrease in GMR at larger thickness is associated with increased shunting of the current in the portion of the free layer which does not contribute to the magnetoresistance because it is further from the pinned magnetic layer than the spin " mean free path. It is interesting to note in Fig. 2.13 that the maximum in MR occurs at lower thicknesses for Fe than for Co or NiFe. This can be explained as a change in the fractional contributions between bulk and interfacial scattering for these various materials. NiFe and Co have been shown to have a significant contribution to the GMR from the bulk of the layer in addition to the contribution arising from the interfacial spin-dependent scattering. This was confirmed by measurements performed in CPP transport (see Table 2.1). The case of Fe provides a contrast. Although less data are available concerning the determination of the bulk and interfacial scattering parameter in this material, bulk scattering seems to have less spin asymmetry than is the case for NiFe or Co (Gijs et al., 1993). This can be understood by considering the band structures of these various materials. In the simple sd model, Ni and Co are strong ferromagnets which means that their majority d-band
Fig. 2.13 Magnetoresistance at room temperature as a function of the thickness of the nominally free layer for spin valves of the composition F tF /Cu 2.5 nm/NiFe 5 nm/FeMn 10 nm, with F ¼ Ni80Fe20, Co and Fe (Dieny et al., 1991a – d). The solid lines are fits of the experimental data according to the phenomenological expression [Eq. (2.9)] given in the text. Open diamonds: Fe, open circles: Co, closed squares: NiFe.
Spin valves 97 is considered as completely filled. Therefore, there is a large difference in the density of spin " and spin # empty states at the Fermi energy into which the electrons can be scattered. The result is a large bulk scattering asymmetry in these materials. By contrast, Fe is a weak ferromagnet which means that both spin " and spin # d-subbands are only partially filled, there is less difference between the corresponding density of empty states at Fermi energy, and it follows there is a weaker bulk scattering asymmetry. The relatively larger role of interfacial scattering in Fe-based spin valves may explain the occurrence of the maximum at lower thickness. An alternative explanation may be based on larger specular reflection at the substrate Fe interface. However, the structural quality of these samples was not optimized, and therefore it is not likely that specular reflection occurred here. The variations of GMR versus the thickness of the magnetic layer can be very well accounted for by the semiclassical theory of GMR presented in Section 2.2 and such a calculation is shown in Fig. 2.14. In particular, the shift in the position of the maximum of DR=RðtF Þ for Fe, for which the spin asymmetry of the interfacial scattering is dominant, is well reproduced. We point out that the CIP GMR in these samples is extremely sensitive to the transmission of the majority electrons through the ferromagnetic/spacer layer interfaces. The main difference in the calculated GMR between NiFe and Co samples comes from a change in transmission coefficient from 95% for Co to 85% for NiFe. Indeed, any reduction in the transmission of spin " electrons leads to a reduction in the spin-dependent scattering contrast, which results in a lower GMR. The large spin " transmission at Co/Cu interface can be attributed to the very good electronic band matching
5 4
∆R/Rp (%)
Co 3
NiFe
2 Fe 1 0
0
10
20
30 tF (nm)
40
50
Fig. 2.14 Semiclassical calculation of GMR for the same spin valves shown in Fig. 2.13, with composition F tF /Cu 2.5 nm/NiFe 5 nm/FeMn 10 nm. In contrast to Fig. 2.12, the full lines are here the results of the semiclassical theory [Eqs (2.7) and (2.8)] whereas the full lines of Fig. 2.13 are phenomenological fits using " ¼ 0:85; Eq. (2.9). The parameters used in the calculation are: l"NiFe ¼ 7 nm; l#NiFe ¼ 0:7 nm; TNiFe=Cu # " # " # " TNiFe=Cu ¼ 0:30; lCo ¼ 9 nm; lCo ¼ 0:9 nm; TCo=Cu ¼ 0:95; TCo=Cu ¼ 0:30; lFe ¼ 4:5 nm; l#Fe ¼ 4:5 nm; " # ¼ 0:70; TFe=Cu ¼ 0:30: NiFe and Co have both bulk and interfacial spin-dependent scattering whereas TFe=Cu the GMR of Fe arises only from the interfacial contribution.
98
B. Dieny
between Co and Cu majority electrons. The relatively poor transmission at NiFe/Cu interface may be attributed to the interdiffusion of Ni and Cu at the interface, which tends to form solid solution. Furthermore, the formation of an interfacial NiFeCu alloy leads to the development of a significant density of interfacial spin waves since the Curie temperature of NiCu alloys decreases rapidly with increasing Cu content. These spin waves contribute to the interfacial electron scattering. In the case of Fe, the lower transmission of spin " electrons can be attributed to the poor structural quality of the interface due to the mismatch between bcc Fe and fcc Cu.
2.3.3.2
Influence of the thickness of the non-magnetic spacer layer
Figure 2.15 shows the variation of the GMR amplitude in a series of spin valves in which the spacer layer thickness was varied. Both Cu and Au spacer layers were used. The lines are fits of the experimental data according to Eq. (2.11) and they combine an exponential decay with a hyperbolic decay. The former is associated with the decreasing fraction of electrons that traverse the spacer layer as its thickness increases, whereas the latter is due to the increased shunting of the current in the spacer layer. The decay lengths found for Cu and Au are lCu ¼ 6 nm and lAu ¼ 5 nm, respectively. These decay lengths are related to the electron mean free path in the spacer layer. The larger decay length found for Cu compared with that for Au is consistent with the lower resistivity of Cu compared to Au: rCu < 5 mV cm, rAu < 7 mV cm, at 300 K. Besides the shorter decay length, the GMR amplitude is lower for the Au than for the Cu spacer layer. This can be explained as a lower transmission of spin-up electrons at Co/Au and NiFe/Au interfaces due to a larger lattice mismatch between the magnetic elements and Au than is the mismatch with Cu. It may also reflect that larger spin– orbit scattering rates are expected from the heavier element, which leads to more spin-flip scattering in the spacer layer.
Fig. 2.15 Magnetoresistance at room temperature as a function of thickness of the noble metal spacer in spin valves of the composition: Si/SiO2/Co 7 nm/NM tNM /NiFe 5 nm/FeMn 8 nm/NM 1.5 nm with NM ¼ Cu and Au. The solid lines represent fits according to Eq. (2.11) (Dieny et al., 1991a– d).
Spin valves 99 Ag has also been used as spacer layer (Dieny et al., 1991a–d). The corresponding GMR amplitudes are intermediate between those of Cu and Au for Ag thickness larger than 5 nm. However, it has been shown that, at room temperature, Ag does not wet at all on Co or NiFe surfaces. Ag grows as three-dimensional islands leading to a very strong ferromagnetic coupling between the free and pinned magnetic layers, up to Ag thickness of the order of 5 nm. Ag is therefore not a suitable spacer for spin valves grown at room temperature. However, antiferromagnetically coupled (NiFe 2 nm/Ag 1 nm) multilayers exhibiting large GMR amplitude and relatively low saturation field (100 Oe) can be obtained by cooling the substrate to liquid nitrogen temperature during growth (Rodmacq et al., 1993). Once the growth is completed, these multilayers can withstand annealing temperatures up to 2508C. In conclusion, in order to increase the GMR amplitude in spin valves, the spacer layer thickness must be reduced as much as possible. However, due to the increasing parallel coupling between the free and pinned layers at low spacer layer thickness, a compromise must be found between a large GMR amplitude and a coupling that is too large. This compromise is usually obtained for Cu spacer layer thickness between 1.8 and 2.2 nm.
2.3.3.3
Influence of temperature on the CIP GMR
The GMR in magnetic multilayers and spin valves, in particular, decreases with increasing temperature. It drops typically by a factor of 2 or 3 as the temperature is raised from 4 to 300 K. As an example, Fig. 2.16 shows the thermal variation of the GMR in two series of spin valves having Cu and Au as the non-magnetic spacer material (Dieny et al., 1991a–d). The GMR decreases almost linearly with temperature and extrapolates to zero amplitude for the same temperature, T0SV ; independent of the thickness of the spacer layer and composition. On the other hand, the characteristic temperature T0SV strongly depends on the nature of the magnetic materials comprising the free and pinned layers. There is a positive correlation between the value of T0SV and the Curie temperature Tc of these magnetic materials (higher Tc correlates with higher T0SV ). Two main contributions to the thermal decrease of GMR have been identified: (1) Inelastic scattering by phonons. Phonon scattering does not affect the spin of the electrons. However, it is spin dependent because of the spin dependence of the density of states at the Fermi energy. If the spin asymmetry associated with this scattering is different from the scattering asymmetry due to structural defects, then phonon scattering may influence the thermal variation of GMR. Furthermore, the phonon scattering shortens the mean free paths, in particular in the spacer layer. This reduces the flow of electrons between the free and pinned layer and further reduces the GMR. Phonon scattering alone, however, cannot explain the decrease by a factor of 2 of the GMR between 4 and 300 K, even if the phonon scattering is considered to be spin dependent. Indeed, for sputtered samples,
100 B. Dieny
Fig. 2.16 Temperature dependence of the GMR amplitude for two series of spin valves of the composition: glass/Co 7 nm/NM tNM /NiFe 5 nm/FeMn 8 nm/NM 1.5 nm, where NM is either (a) Cu or (b) Au (Dieny et al., 1991a –d).
the resistivities of the various materials comprising the spin valve typically vary by 50% in this temperature range. Shortening the mean free path in a 2.5 nm thick Cu spacer layer from 30 to 20 nm only leads to a small change in the GMR amplitude, of the order 10%, according to the semiclassical theory. Similarly, taking into account the thermal variation of mean free paths in the other layers explains variations of the order of 10 –20% but not a factor of 2 or 3. Therefore, another contribution to the thermal decrease of GMR must be put forward. (2) Magnon scattering, either in the bulk of the ferromagnetic layer or at the interfaces. The importance of this contribution at room temperature depends on how high the Curie temperature of the magnetic element is. For Co or Co12x Fex ð0 , x , 0:3Þ alloys (Tc Co ¼ 1394 K, Tc Fe ¼ 1043 K), the density of magnons at room temperature remains relatively low. In contrast, room temperature for Permalloy Ni80Fe20 (Tc Permalloy ¼ 595 K) corresponds to Tc =2: Magnon scattering then plays a significant role. Contrary to phonons, scattering by magnons causes spin flip of conduction electrons, leading to a mixing between the two spin current channels. In the framework of the semiclassical theory of transport, this spin mixing can be described by adding an interband mixing term in the
Spin valves
101
Boltzmann equation:
›gs ðz; vÞ gs ðz; vÞ gs ðz; vÞ 2 g2s ðz; vÞ eE ›f 0 ðvÞ þ þ ¼ ; mvz ›vx ›z ts vz t"# vz
ð2:19Þ
in which t"# represents the spin-flip relaxation time. Magnon scattering naturally explains the correlation observed between T0SV (the rate of decrease of the GMR with temperature) and the Curie temperature of the magnetic element. Magnon scattering can also play a very important role at interfaces. In the presence of interfacial roughness and interdiffusion, a significant weakening of the exchange stiffness may occur in the interfacial region. These effects lead to reduced interfacial magnetic moment. They are more pronounced with Ni80Fe20/Cu interfaces but are present, although weaker, at Co/Cu interfaces (Nozieres et al., 1993). At room temperature, a large density of interfacial magnetic fluctuations is present in these magnetically weakened regions. They can cause spin-flip scattering and thus reduce the GMR amplitude. A quantitative analysis of the thermal variation of GMR based on the semiclassical theory of GMR including spin flip, in several series of spin valves comprising Ni80Fe20 and Co ferromagnetic layers and Cu and Au spacer layers can be found in Dieny et al. (1995). 2.3.3.4
Angular variation of GMR
In the vast majority of magnetic multilayers, the CIP resistance is maximum in the antiparallel magnetic configuration and decreases in the parallel magnetic configuration. The opposite behavior has been observed in a few cases prepared to purposely validate the basic understanding of GMR. In these structures, layers having opposite scattering rates (for instance, l" . l# in the free layer and l" , l# in the pinned layer) were prepared (Renard et al., 1996; Vouille et al., 1997) so that the ‘short circuit effect’ by one species of electrons leads to the low resistance state in the antiparallel magnetic configuration. The question to be addressed by the angular variation of GMR is the following: how does the resistance vary as a function of the angle between the magnetization orientation in the free and pinned layers, between these extremum values corresponding to parallel and antiparallel magnetic configurations. This angular variation was investigated by various authors, both experimentally (Chaiken et al., 1990; Dieny et al., 1991a– d; Steren et al., 1995) and theoretically (Vedyaev et al., 1994; Wang et al., 1996; Vedyaev et al., 1997; Blaas et al., 1999; Coehoorn, 2000). When a rotating field of the order of a few tens of oersteds is applied to a spin valve, the magnetization of the free layer rotates with the field whereas the magnetization of the pinned layer remains pinned in a fixed direction. At most, it may oscillate slightly around the exchange bias field Heb : If Heb is sufficiently large compared to the amplitude of the rotating field, these oscillations are negligible. There are then two contributions to the variation in resistance as a function of the direction of the field. One is the AMR which varies as the cosine squared of the angle between the magnetization
102 B. Dieny
Fig. 2.17 Relative change of resistance versus cosine of the relative angle between the magnetizations of the two NiFe layers in Si/NiFe 6 nm/Cu 2.6 nm/NiFe 3 nm/FeMn 6 nm/Ag 2 nm. The inset shows the orientation of the current J; exchange anisotropy field Hex ; applied field H and magnetizations M1 (free layer) and M2 (pinned layer) of the two ferromagnetic layers (Dieny et al., 1991a– d).
of the free layer and the current, and the other is the GMR. As shown in Fig. 2.17, by subtracting the AMR contribution from the total magnetoresistance, it was found that the GMR varies according to RðuÞ ¼ RP þ ðRAP 2 RP Þ
ð1 2 cos uÞ ; 2
ð2:20Þ
where RP and RAP are the resistances of the spin valve in parallel and antiparallel magnetic configuration, respectively (Dieny et al., 1991a– d), and u ¼ u1 2 u2 is the relative angle between magnetization orientations. From a theoretical point of view, it was shown that the conductance, rather than the resistance, is expected to vary as cos u (Vedyaev et al., 1994, 1997; Coehoorn, 2000). This was experimentally observed in the angular variation of GMR in NiFe/Ag/Co/Ag multilayers (Steren et al., 1995). The difference between the two descriptions, one with a cos u resistance variation, the other with a cos u conductance variation, only involves a second-order term in the GMR ratio. Therefore, the difference is negligible if the GMR amplitude is small, but may become sizeable if the value of GMR is relatively large, as is the case for the NiFe/Ag/Co/Ag multilayers (Steren et al., 1995). The free electron theory also predicts a strong deviation from linearity in the presence of interfacial potential steps due to lattice potential modulation (Vedyaev et al., 1994). So far, these deviations have not been observed experimentally, reinforcing the picture that spin-dependent scattering effects play the primary role in the origin of GMR, rather than lattice potential modulation effects. The angular variation of GMR has also been investigated in the CPP geometry. Stronger deviations from linearity were observed in this case (Dauguet et al., 1996). Finally, an additional, small anisotropy in the GMR amplitude was observed by several groups (Dieny et al., 1995; Miller et al., 1999). This phenomenon consists of a difference in the change of resistance between parallel and antiparallel magnetic configurations depending on
Spin valves
103
whether these configurations correspond to the two magnetizations being parallel or perpendicular to the sense current. Measuring this effect requires that the direction of the pinned layer is reoriented between the measurements, to be parallel or perpendicular to the sense current. This can be done by annealing the spin valve above the blocking temperature of antiferromagnetic pinning layer and then cooling down in a magnetic field applied in the desired direction. The GMR ratio was found slightly larger (by about 5% in relative value) when the magnetizations are perpendicular to the current than when they are parallel to it (Dieny et al., 1995). This effect is another manifestation of the dependence of the mean free path on the angle between electron velocity and magnetization which gives rise to the AMR. Because of this anisotropy in mean free path, the scattering asymmetry also depends on the angle between electron velocity and magnetization, thus leading to the observed anisotropy in the GMR. These effects have been interpreted within the semiclassical theory of GMR (Rijks et al., 1995).
2.4
Spin-valves optimization
Since their discovery in 1990, the magnetic and transport properties of spin valves have been considerably improved especially in terms of magnetic stability of the pinned layer and MR amplitude. The overall structural quality of the stack has been highly improved by using appropriate buffer layer such as NiFeCr alloys. The pinning strength has been enhanced because of the use of antiferromagnetic layers having higher Neel temperature and by the introduction of the so-called synthetic pinned layer. The GMR amplitude has been raised up to 20% by introducing interfacial CoFe layers, by improving the overall structural quality of the stack thus reducing the scattering of the majority electrons (supposed to be more weakly scattered than the minority electrons), and by enhancing the specular reflection of electrons around the active part of the spin valve so as to favor the mobility of the weakly scattered electrons in the parallel magnetic configuration as much as possible. In the following of this section, these various improvements are reviewed in more detail. 2.4.1
Structural improvements achieved with NiFeCr buffer layers
In the first spin valves, Ta was most often used as buffer layer because it provides a (111) texture to Permalloy and to the other fcc layers deposited in the stack. When FeMn is used as the antiferromagnetic pinning layer, the (111) texture allows one to get a larger pinning energy. Furthermore, Ta has relatively good wetting properties on SiO2. The roughness of the layers is relatively low (RMS , 0.3 nm). The grain size is of the order of 10 nm for typical spin valves. Spin valves grown on Ta have provided GMR amplitude in the range 4 –10%. In later work, NiFeCr buffer layers were introduced as buffer layers. These alloys were already used as buffers in magnetoresistive heads based on the AMR of thin NiFe films. They have been shown to favor the specular reflection of conduction electrons at the interfaces of the NiFe
104 B. Dieny layer thus limiting the drop of AMR amplitude when the thickness of the layer was reduced below 10 nm (Dieny et al., 2000a,b). Because of the use of these buffer layers, AMR amplitudes of the order of 4% at room temperature were achieved using Permalloy films 6 nm thick. The most suitable compositions of these alloys are in the range (Ni80Fe20)60Cr40 –Ni60Cr40. These alloys have very good lattice matching with Permalloy. As shown in Fig. 2.18 (Bozorth, 1951), they remain in the fcc phase up to 40 at% Cr content. Furthermore, Fe and Cr are known to have low surface tension and therefore to offer very good wetting properties on most substrates, in particular Al2O3 or SiO2. As a result of the good lattice matching and wetting, the roughness of the layers is very low (RMS , 0.2 nm) and the grain size can be very large. As an example, Fig. 2.19 presents a transmission electron microscope cross-sectional view of a spin valve grown on NiFeCr buffer inserted between Permalloy shields in a magnetoresistive heads. The spin valve is isolated from the shields by alumina layers. Figure 2.19 shows that the grain size is very large in these structures, of the order of 50 nm, which is about five times larger than with Ta buffer. This grain size is much larger even than the thickness of the spin valve. The active part of the spin valve, which is comprised of the free layer/ non-magnetic spacer/inner pinned layer (NiFe 4 nm/CoFe 1 nm/Cu 2 nm/CoFe 2 nm in the example of Fig. 2.19), almost appears as an epitaxial single crystal. As a result of this structural improvement, the overall resistivity of the stack in parallel magnetic configuration is reduced. The transmission of the weakly scattered electrons through the interfaces between the ferromagnetic layers and the non-magnetic spacer is increased, thus enhancing the flow of electrons between the free and pinned layers. Furthermore, as will be explained further in more detail, the lower roughness of the interfaces also enhances the specular reflection of conduction electrons on both sides of the active part of the spin valves, i.e. at the buffer/free layer interface and inner pinned layer/Ru interface when a synthetic pinned layer is used (see Section 2.4.2), or pinned layer/antiferromagnetic layer when a simple pinned layer is used. Besides the direct impact of the structural improvements on the transport properties, the larger grain size has also allowed a decrease in the thickness of the antiferromagnetic layer while maintaining sufficient pinning properties. For instance, with PtMn the increase in grain size has allowed a decrease of the lower thickness limit down to 8 nm with NiFeCr buffer as compared to 14 nm with Ta buffer. Reducing the AF layer thickness reduces the shunting of the current in this inactive part of the spin valve, therefore increasing the MR ratio. As a result of these structural improvements, the GMR amplitude of spin valves has been increased from the range 4–10% to the range 12 –15% as illustrated in Fig. 2.20. 2.4.2
Improvement in the pinning related to the use of a synthetic pinned layer
Spin valves with a synthetic antiferromagnetic pinned layer (SyAP) (Heim et al., 1994) provide a stronger pinning of the pinned layer. They are of the form buffer/F/Cu/AP1 tAP1