LINEAR
ACCELERATORS
edited by
PIERRE M. LAPOSTOLLE ISR Division, CERN, Geneva, Switzerland
ALBERT L. SEPTIER Institut
NORTH-HOLLAND
PUBLISHING
d’Electroniyue Fondamentale Fault& des Sciences 91 Orsay, France
COMPANY
-
AMSTERDAM
o NORTH-HOLLAND PUBLISHING COMPANY , AMSTERDAM, 1970 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the Copyright owner. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 70-97209 ISBN 7204 0156 9 Printed in The Netherlands
Publishers: NORTH-HOLLAND PUBLISHING COMPANY - AMSTERDAM
Sole Distributors for the Western Hemisphere: WILEY INTERSCIENCE DIVISION JOHN WILEY & SONS, INC. - NEW YORK
Preface
Accelerator science is of relatively recent origin and all the important developments in linear accelerators date from the last decade or two. Although several books exist on circular machines, most of the published material about linear devices has appeared in the form of laboratory reports, very often of an internal nature and not always widely circulated, and in the proceedings of international or national conferences on accelerators. Although the latter constitute an easier source of information, since the communications are grouped together, the material is usually so condensed that it is often only of interest to the specialist. There is a lack of comprehensive and more logical presentation for the student who would like to become acquainted with this field. In the few books which have been written on accelerators in general, there is usually a chapter on linear machines but it is necessarily brief. There exist a few Russian books on the theory of linear accelerators; a book has very recently been published on the big Stanford electron accelerator and in the current issue of Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics (no. 25) a chapter is devoted to ion linear accelerators. There was, however, still a need for a volume which would describe in enough detail theoretical as well as technological aspects of linear accelerators in general and briefly cover the various types constructed and their applications. In order to achieve this aim, two possibilities were available to us: - either to write such a book ourselves after having collected all the available information and had discuss ions with many specialists all over the world; - or to distribute the work between such specialists, asking them to write chapters devoted to their own particular sphere of interest and activity. The second method has been adopted because this seemed to be more reasonable in a field which is in constant evolution, where only those involved are able to judge the relative merits of proposals or achievements described in the literature, pick up the most important concepts and make realistic guesses on possible developments. The drawback in this method was, however, the quasi-impossibility of obtaining a perfect homogeneity in the presentation of the various parts; this book is no proof against such a criticism. Asking the cooperation of almost fifty authors from over three continents also caused difficulties and unavoidable delays. Furthermore, it has to be fully appreciated that, since several phenomena are still
vi
PREFACE
not completely understood, the chapters give a description of the present stage in knowledge only; let us hope that in the years to come more elaborate and exact theories will remove the contradictions which sometimes subsist and give a better description of the experimental observations. It is highly probable that a new edition of this book would include changes in various chapters. We are, nevertheless, convinced that in its present form and despite its imperfections, this book will represent a solid and essential basis for engineers or physicists entering the field of linear accelerators. In this constantly progressing field, a modern and complete documentation is presented either in the developments shown or in the fairly detailed list of references appearing at the end of each chapter. This book should have a chosen place, not only in universities and libraries, but also on the shelves or on the desk of all scientists in laboratories where linear accelerators are either being built or used. We would like to express our thanks to all the authors who agreed to contribute to this volume and to all those who took part in its preparation for their active collaboration. Without their help a succesful book would have been impossible. Geneva - Orsay July 1969
P.M. Lapostolle A.L. Septier
Contents Prefhce
v
Contents vii List of contributors x i x Author index
1181
Subject index
1197
Introduction PART A The history of linear accelerators 1 J.P. BLEWETT 1 Ising's proposal and Wideroe's accelerator 1 2 The accelerators of Beams and of Sloan and Lawrence 4 3 Postwar developments 5 4 The Stanford linear electron accelerators 6 5 SLAC - The Stanford Linear Accelerator Center 9 6 Other linear electron accelerators 10 7 The Berkeley 32-MeV proton linear accelerator 11 8 Other proton linear accelerators 12 9 Heavy ion linear accelerators 13 10 Linear accelerators for high average currents 14 11 Recent developments 15 12 Linear accelerator literature 16 13 Acknowledgments 16
The general theory of linear accelerators
19
H.G. HEREWARD
1 2 3 4 5 6
Phase stability 19 Transverse defocusing 20 Properties of the travelling wave 21 Longitudinal motion 22 Liouville's theorem and adiabatic processes 25 Rf power considerations 28 7 Electron linac structures: periodic structures 30 8 Proton linac structures 33
viii
CONTENTS
Electron Linear Accelerators PART B
THEORY
-- B.l.l
Accelerating structures 39 G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL 1 Introduction 39 2 The principles of periodically-loaded structures 40 3 Principal design parameters 47 4 Traveling-wave accelerators 52 5 Standing-wave accelerators 65 6 Superconducting accelerators 76 7 Analytic and computer techniques for structure design 86 8 Empirical design methods 88 9 Summary of characteristics of accelerating structures of existing electron linacs 107
- B.1.2
Particle dynamics 115 R.H. HELM, R. MILLER 1 Introduction 115 2 Injection dynamics 116 3 Long range transport in electron linacs 128
Beam loading and transient behavior in traveling wave electron linear accelerators 147 ~
J.E. LEISS 1 Introduction 147 2 Nature of the beam loading problem 148 3 Beam loading theory based upon diffusion equation 151 4 Beam loading theory including dispersive effects 158
Beam breakup 173 R.H. HELM, G.A. LOEW 1 Introduction 173 2 Physical manifestations and models of beam breakup 175 3 Regenerative beam breakup 183
ELECTRON LINACS 4 Multisection or cumulative beam breakup 198
5 Discussion of starting conditions 210 6 Proposed remedies for various types of accelerators 215 7 Other electromagnetic instabilities in linacs 218
Problems connected with the measurement of accelerated electron beam characteristics 223 R. BERGERE 1 Tentative classification of methods of measurement 223 2 Time-frequency characteristics associated with the perturbation methods 225 3 Beam characteristics associated with the different lobes of the frequency spectrum 227 4 Quantity of information contained in one measurement 229
TECHNOLOGY - B.2.1
Electron injectors 237 P. BRUNET, X . BUFFET 1 Introduction 237 2 Choice of an injector 239 3 Main other sub-assemblies 251 4 Measurements of injector characteristics 256 5 Example of injector assembly 258
Accelerating structures: technology 265 A.L.ELDREDGE, A.V.LISIN, V.G.PRICE 1 Introduction 265 2 Dimensional requirements 266 3 Fabrication methods 271 4 Microwave tuning 290 5 Cooling and temperature control 301 6 Support structures 306
Radiofrequency problem 315 H.HOGG,J.V.LEBACQZ 1 Introduction 315 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Power requirements 315 Power sources 318 Stability requirements 322 Phasing systems 325 Low energy machines (less than 100 MeV) 329 Medium energy machines (0.1 to 1 .O GeV) 331 High energy machines (above 1.0 GeV) 334
x
B.2.4
CONTENTS
Installations and control 355 L.BURNOD 1 The building 356 2 Principal auxiliary equipment 363 3 Adjustments and controls 374
VARIOUS TYPES
- B.3.1
Use of high energy electron linear accelerators 385 J.BALLAM 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Introduction 385 Form factors 386 Review of medium energy physics achievements 387 Potential of very high energy linacs 388 Positron acceleration and annihilation beams 388 High energy muon beams 391 Secondary beams 393 Neutral K particles of high energy 393 Radiofrequency separated beams 397 Characteristics of high energy electron linacs as related to experimental problems 397 11 Use of detection apparatus at high energy electron linear accelerators 402 12 Review of high energy physics achievements 406 13 Summary 410
B.3.2
High duty factor electron linear accelerators 415 J. HAIMSON 1 Introduction 415 2 General design considerations 416 3 Principal design parameters 440 4 Rf system 442 5 Accelerator waveguides 445 6 Injection system 458
B.3.3
Low energy, high intensity electron accelerators 471 H. LEBOUTET 1 Introduction 471 2 Radiation chemistry 471 3 Radiography 482 4 Flash radiography. Stroboscopic radiography 486 5 Radiotherapy 489
B.3.4
Linear accelerators as injectors for cyclic machines 495 M.C. CROWLEY-MILLING 1 The electron synchrotron 495
ELECTRON LINACS
2 Production of narrow energy spectrum 497 3 4 5 6 7 8
Effect of variation of parameters 501 Emittance 503 Beam loading effects in the synchrotron 504 Debuncher systems 51 1 Examples of electron synchrotron injectors 514 Injection of positrons 520
Positron accelerators 523 F.AMMAN 1 Introduction 523 2 General remarks o n positron linear accelerators 525 3 Positron yields 528 4 Focusing systems 530 5 Matching systems 536 6 Dephasing of the positrons in the matching and focusing systems 541 7 The converter 544 8 Positron accelerator operation and experimental results 546
The racetrack microtron: an electron accelerator ,for medium energies 553 B.H. WIIK, P.B. WILSON 1 Introduction 553 2 Principles of the racetrack microtron 554 3 Design details for a racetrack microtron 559 4 Conclusion 566
Radiofrequency separators 569 B.W. MONTAGUE 1 Introduction 569 2 Basic principles 569 3 The rf separators of Panofsky and Schnell 570 4 Deflecting waves and structures 572 5 Separator optics 578 6 Engineering aspects 580 7 Present status and future developments 580
di
CONTENTS
Proton Linear Accelerators PART C
THEORY Accelerating Structures C .1. l a
Introduction 585 P. LAPOSTOLLE
C.1.lb
Low and medium energies Alvarez structures 587 A. CARNE 1 Introduction 587 2 The Alvarez structure 588 3 Tolerances 593 4 Effect of individual cell tuning errors 593 5 Optimisation 597
C .1.lc
High energy structures 601 E.A.KNAPP 1 Introduction 601 2 n-mode accelerator structures 606 3 Possible cavity configurations using the &mode 606 4 Specific properties of the fn-mode for a biperiodic system 608 5 The side-coupled accelerator structure 609
C .1.1d
Numerical computation of field distributions 617 A. KATZ 1 lntroduction 617 2 Mathematical formulations 617 3 Discretization of the partial derivative equation 620 4 Expression of boundary conditions 623 5 Diagonal dominance of the A matrix 626 6 Error evaluation 626 7 Convergence rate 628 8 External improvements of convergence rate 628 9 Calculation of electrical parameters 630
-
PROTON LINACS 10 Results 631 11 Non-zero modes 633 12 Effects of the stems and of the aperiodicity of the structure 634
C.1. le
Review and survey o f accelerating structures 637 G.DOME 1 2 3 4 5 6
Shunt impedance and transit time factor 637 Travelling versus standing wave operation 659 Some definitions 661 Structures with resonant coupling 665 Structures with non-resonant coupling 709 Comparison of structures for shunt impedance 728
Particle Dynamics at Low Intensity C. 1.2a
Introduction 739 P. LAPOSTOLLE 1 Differences between proton- and electron-dynamics 739
2 Step-by-step computation 740 3 4 5 6 7
C. 1.2b
Numerical methods. Acceleration by a gap 747 A. CARNE, B. SCHNIZER, P. LAPOSTOLLE, M.PROME 1 2 3 4 5
6 7
8 9 10
C.1.2~
Accelerating structure design 740 Field law 742 Phase law 742 Buncher 744 Debuncher 744
Introduction 747 Field representations 749 Series expansions of the fields 752 Voltage, transit time factor and other beam dynamics coefficients 754 Motion of a proton in a spatially homogeneous time-harmonic field. The perturbation parameter K 757 General considerations on perturbation theory. The thin lens approximation 759 Derivation of the non-relativistic difference equations for energy, phase, radial position and velocity across a gap 761 Non-relativistic difference equations for the change of the dynamical quantities in the first half of a gap 764 Relativistic corrections 765 Application to linac design and computation 767
Focusing 785 M.PRO MI^ 1 The need for focusing 785
xiii
xiv
CONTENTS
2 Elements of the periodic structures theory 786 3 Stability diagrams 788 4 High energy focusing 794
C. 1.2d
Nonlinear efects 797 R.L. GLUCKSTERN 1 General considerations 797 2 Longitudinal phase acceptance 797 3 Coupling between longitudinal and transverse oscillation 799 4 Coupling between the two transverse oscillations 801 5 Misalignments and errors 801 6 Misalignments and couplings 803 7 Effect of space charge 803
Particle Dynamics at High Intensity C. 1.3a
Introduction 805 P. LAPOSTOLLE 1 Beam loading 805 2 Transients 806 3 Space charge effects 806 4 Other effects 806 5 Beam break up 807
C.1.3b
Transients and beam loading efect 809 T. NISHIKAWA 1 Various methods of analysis 809 2 Transients calculation by cylindrical waveguide model 810 3 Normal mode analysis 812 4 Results and comparison with measurements 815 5 Field induced by the beam 818 6 Effects of beam loading 819 7 Methods for improvements 822 8 Conclusive remarks 824
C.1 . 3 ~
Space charge efSects 827 R.L. GLUCKSTERN 1 Introduction 827 2 Longitudinal space charge effect 828 3 Transverse space charge effect 830 4 Self-consistent models 831 5 Numerical models 834 6 Limitations 836
PROTON LINACS
TECHNOLOGY C.2.1
Pre-injectors 837 J.HUGUENIN, B.VOSICKI 1 Introduction 837 2 Ion sources 838 3 Optics 852 4 The accelerating tube 853
C.2.2a
Alvarez structure 879 C.S. TAYLOR 1 Introduction 879 2 Lay-out and brief description 880 3 Requirements 881 4 Actual structures 886 5 Buncher and debuncher 893
C.2.2b
High energy structures. Fabrication and tuning 897 E.A.KNAPP
Radiofrequency problems 905 I Introduction 905 2 Accelerating structure as a resonant load 906 3 The power source 925
4 The coupled system - amplifier and accelerating cavity 927 5 Controls and instrumentation 931
Beam monitoring, accelerator shielding and services 935 A. VAN STEENBERGEN 1 Beam monitoring 935 2 Proton linac shielding 950 3 Linac cooling and vacuum requirements 959 4 Description of a typical installation 966
Use of computers,for controls 971 H . BUTLER 1 Introduction 971 2 Tasks for the computer 971 3 Limitations of the computer 972 4 Advantages of a computer 973 5 Survey of applications 974
xvi
CONTENTS
VARIOUS TYPES Injectors for circular accelerators 977 P. LAPOSTOLLE 1 General layout of injection. Injection devices 977 2 Required characteristics 979 3 Typical performances 980 4 Improvement activities 983 5 Injectors for the generation of synchrotrons with several hundred GeV energy 985
Proton linacs for nuclear physics studies 987 J.M.DICKSON 1 Introduction 987 2 Comparison of injector and nuclear physics linacs 987 3 A nuclear physics machine 988 4 Beam quality 990 5 Variable energy 992 6 Polarized beams 993 7 Time-of-flight deflectors 994 8 Operation 994
Meson production
999
D.E. NAGLE
Intense neutron generator l o l l P. TUNNICLIFFE, G. BARTHOLOMEW 1 Introduction 1011 2 Conceptual arrangement of the Chalk River ING project 3 Accelerator 1013 4 Targets 1015 5 Special features and problems of the accelerator 1017
Possibility o f deuteron acceleration 1025 TH. SLUYTERS, M. REGLER 1 Introduction 1025 2 General considerations 1026 3 Acceleration in the CERN proton synchroton linear accelerator 1027
xvii
HEAVY I O N LINACS
Heavy Ion Linear Accelerators PART D
D. 1
Special problems in heavy ion acceleration 1029 CH. SCHMELZER 1 Introduction 1029 2 Requirements on particle energy and beam properties 1030 3 Ion sources 1031 4 Stripping 1034 5 The pressure transparency 1038 6 Heavy ion accelerators 1042
D.2
Existing and proposed heavy ion linear accelerators 1047 D. BOHNE, CH. SCHMELZER
1 Difference between proton and heavy-particle accelerators 1047 2 Existing machines 1051 3 Proposed heavy-ion linacs 1059
D. 3
Radiofiequency focusing in heavy ion linear accelerators 1073 D. BOUSSARD 1 Introduction 1073 2 Grid focusing 1074 3 Alternating focusing 1079
xviii
Superconducting Linear Accelerators PART E
E. 1
The surface impedance of superconducting metals at high frequencies 1089 A. SEPTIER 1 2 3 4 5
E.2
The historical background 1089 The surface impedance of metals at very low temperatures 1090 Macroscopic theories of high frequency conductivity in superconductors 1092 Recent theories of the rf conductivity 1095 The use of superconductors at uhf 1104
Theory and design of superconducting electron linear accelerators 1107 P.B. WILSON 1 Introduction 1107 2 Theory 1109 3 Design 1120 4 Limits on the gradient and current 1131 5 Application to accelerators 1135
E.3
Superconducting proton linear accelerators and particle separators 1141 A. CITRON, H. SCHOPPER 1 Introduction 1141 2 Accelerating structure 1143 3 Injection 1149 4 Beam dynamics 1150 5 Beam loading 1152 6 Parameters, design features and cost estimates 1163 7 Superconducting particle separators 1167
List of Contributors
F. Amman, Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati del CNEN, Frascati, Italy. J.Ballam, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. G. Bartholomew, Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd, Chalk River, Ontario, Canada. R. BergPre, Centre d'Etudes Nucltaires de Saclay, 91 Gif-sur-Yvette, France. J.P. Blewett, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York, U.S.A. D.Bohne, lnstitut fur Angewandte Physik der Universitat Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany. D. Boussard, Centre EuropCen de Recherches NuclCaires, Geneva, Switzerland. P. Brunet, Laboratoire de 1'Acceltrateur Lineaire, Facultt des Sciences, 91 Orsay* France. X. BufSet, Laboratoire de 1'AcceICrateur Lineaire, FacultC des Sciences, 91 Orsay, France. L. Burnod, Laboratoire de I'AccCltrateur LinCaire, FacultC des Sciences, 91 Orsay, France.
H. Butler, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, U.S.A. A. Carne, Rutherford High Energy Laboratory, Chilton, Didcot, Berkshire, England. A. Citron, Institut fur Experimentelle Kernphysik der Universitat Karlsruhe, Karlsruhe,
Germany.
M.C. Crowley-Milling, Daresbury Nuclear Physics Laboratory, Daresbury, Lancashire, England. J.M. Dickson, Rutherford High Energy Laboratory, Chilton, Didcot, Berkshire, England. G. DGme, Centre EuropCen de Recherches Nucltaires, Geneva, Switzerland.
A.L. Eldredge, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A.
R.L. Gluckstern, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts, U.S.A. J.Haimson, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S.A.
xx
LIST OF
R.H. Helm, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. H.G. Hereward, Centre EuropCen de Recherches NuclCaires, Geneva, Switzerland. H. Hogg, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. J.Huguenin, Centre Europten de Recherches Nucltaires, Geneva, Switzerland. A. Katz, Centre d'Etudes NuclCaires de Saclay, 91 Gif-sur-Yvette, France. E.A.Knapp, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, U.S.A. P.M. Lapostolle, Centre EuropCen de Recherches Nucleaires, Geneva, Switzerland. J.V. Lebacqz, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. H. Leboutet, Centre de Recherches Thomson-CSF, Corbeville, 91 Orsay, France. J.E. Leiss, National Bureau of Standards, Washington, D.C., U.S.A. A. V. Lisin, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. G.A. Loew, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. R. Miller, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. B. W. Montague, Centre EuropCen de Recherches NuclCaires, Geneva, Switzerland. D.E. Nagle, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, U.S.A. R.B. Neal, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. T. Nishikawa, University of Tokyo, Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan. V.G.Price, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A. M.Prome', Centre d'Etudes NuclCaires de Saclay, 91 Gif-sur-Yvette, France. M. Regler, Institut fiir Hochenergiephysik der dsterreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Vienna, Austria. Ch. Schmelzer, Institut fur Angewandte Physik der Universitat Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany. B. Schnizer, Centre Europeen de Recherches NuclCaires, Geneva, Switzerland. H. Schopper, Institut fur Experimentelle Kernphysik der Universitat Karlsruhe, Karlsruhe, Germany. A.L. Septier, Institut d'Electronique Fondamentale, FacultC des Sciences, 91 Orsay, France. Th. Sluyters, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York, U.S.A. C.S. Taylor, Centre EuropCen de Recherches NuclCaires, Geneva, Switzerland. P. Tunnicliffe, Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd, Chalk River, Ontario, Canada. A. Van Steenbergen, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York, U.S.A.
CONTRIBUTORS
B. Voiicki, Centre EuropCen de Recherches NuclCaires, Geneva, Switzerland. B.H. Wiik, High Energy Physics Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, California, U.S.A. P.B. Wilson, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California, U.S.A.
xxi
PART A
Introduction
J. P. BLEWETT H. G . HEREWARD
1
The History of Linear Accelerators
I I
J. P. BLEWETT Brookhaven National Laboratory Upton, New York, U.S.A.
To one uninitiated in the accelerator field it would seem reasonable to expect that a linear accelerator is one in which particles are accelerated on a linear path. This is indeed a necessary condition but not a sufficient one. According to custom a linear accelerator is defined as one in which particles move on a linear path but are accelerated by radiofrequency fields, high energies being achieved by repeated acceleration through steps in energy which, individually, are much smaller than the final energy achieved. The term "linear accelerator" is often abbreviated to "linac", a term which now has general acceptance. The idea of reaching high energies by repeated small pushes is as old as the child's swing. As soon as Maxwell made it clear which electromagnetic fields were theoretically possible it must have occurred to many physicists that particles could be accelerated by radiofrequency fields But technology lagged far behind theoretical understanding. The first formal proposal for a linear accelerator seems to have been in 1924. A number of proposals and experimental devices appeared in the following two decades but a linear accelerator useful for research in nuclear physics was not born until after thevast development of microwave devices during World War 11. Then, within three years practical designs were made for both proton and electron linear accelerators. Progress since then has been rapid and extensive.
I
Ising's proposal and Wideroe's accelerator
The early proposal mentioned above was due to G. Ising [I9241 of Stockholm. It was References p . 17
;c) North-HollanrlPubl. Co., Amsterdam I969
1
2
J.P. BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
called "The Principle of a Method for the Production of Canal Rays of High Voltage", and was published in the Arkiv fiir Matematik, Astronomi och Fysik. The principle of the device is indicated in fig. 1 reproduced from Ising's paper.* A positive ion beam (then known as "canal rays") emerged from the discharge tube shown at the left of the figure into a sequence of drift tubes. An electrical wavefront from a spark discharge was applied in sequence to the drift tubes. Transmission lines of increasing length delayed the arrival of the wave so that fields appeared across the gaps between drift tubes at the moment that the positive ions arrived. Thus acceleration should take place at every gap.
QII Fig. 1 . Ising's 1924 design for a linear accelerator.
Ising's paper concludes with the following remarks: "It would be premature to discuss now more closely the details and eventual difficulties of the realization of this idea. I hope to carry out some practical experiments soon... ." The proposal was indeed premature. No record appears of the "practical experiments" and it seems probable that Ising was frustrated by the rudimentary state of the electrical art. Maintenance of a steep wavefront through delay lines is not easy and Ising must have lacked any sort of equipment adequate to observe the propagation characteristics and frequency response of his systems. The first successful linear accelerator was described by R. Wideroe [I9281 in a paper that is one of the most significant in accelerator history. In this paper Wideroe described the first working linear accelerator, evolved the basic theory of the betatron and described an unsuccessful attempt to build a betatron. It was Wideroe's discussion of the linear accelerator in this paper that led E. 0. Lawrence to the invention of the cyclotron. It is of interest that in 1967 this versatile inventor is still at work producing ingenious ideas in the laboratory of the Brown-Boveri Company in Switzerland.
* The writer is indebted to M. S. Livingston and to Dover Publications, Inc. for permission to reproduce figures and text from "The Development of High Energy Accelerators", edited by M. S. Livingston (Dover, 1966). This book includes translations of the papers of Ising and Wideroe. Figures 1 and 2 are reproduced from the translated papers.
A. 1
THE HISTORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
3
Wideroe's paper was entitled "A New Principle for the Generation of High Voltages." His accelerating system was similar in appearance to that of Ising but his drift tubes were connected alternately to a source of high frequency waves and to ground. The lengths of the drift tubes and the frequency were chosen so that ions ating phase. When the field was in the opposite (decelerating) direction the ions were shielded by the drift tubes. The configuration of the system is shown in fig. 2. Rather than a gas discharge ion source, Wideroe used a hot filament source of sodium or potassium ions. Three drift tubes were used, the first and third grounded and the central one excited at a frequency of about 1 MHz to voltages of about 25 kV. An electrical deflecting system was used to measure the energy of the accelerated ions. It was shown that, with an rf voltage of 25 kV, ions could gain up to 50 keV of energy. It was clear that this was a process that could be continued to higher energies.
Fig. 2. Wideroe's linear accelerator and its associated circuits.
Wideroe concluded that the process would be even more effective if ions of higher mass were used. In his words "Caesium ions ... should be favorable in this respect. Assuming an accelerating voltage of .. . 170 kV and five accelerating tubes, a voltage of about 1 MV could be attained." Such heavy ions were not those most desired for studies in nuclear physics where the most important experiments were to be performed with protons, deuterons, alpha particles, or electrons. But, at a given energy the lighter particles travel at much higher speeds and higher frequencies are appropriate for their acceleration. Power generators at such high frequencies were not available in 1928 nor for some years thereafter. So, in spite of this promising beginning, useful linear accelerators were still far in the future.
4
J.P. BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
2 The accelerators of Beams and of Sloan and Lawrence In about 1931 K. H. Kingdon of the General Electric Company suggested an accelerator design to L. B. Snoddy of the University of Virginia. This seems to have been essentially the linear accelerator proposed in 1924 by Tsing although probably neither participant was aware of Ising's paper which had been published in a rather obscure journal. A couple of years later Snoddy together with J. W. Beams reported (Beams and Snoddy [1933]) on a traveling wavefront electron accelerator. In this device a 15 kV impulse was applied in sequence to 15 drift tubes. Electrons at 28 keV injected along the axis of the drift tubes were accelerated to about 90 keV. The work was continued by Beams and H. Trotter 119341 with higher voltage and fewer electrodes. With a 300 kV pulse applied to four electrodes in sequence, electrons were accelerated to 1.3 MeV. The final report from this group (Trotter and Beams [1935]) described the application of a 54 kV pulse from a Marx circuit to a six drift tube system. The peak electron energy reported was 2.5 MeV. As was usual in these early papers the reports reflected increasing optimism on the part of the experimenters. Then, suddenly, there were no more papers. There is no account of any application of the high energy electron beam. Probably the difficulties of maintaining a steep wavefront along what amounted to a loaded transmission line proved to be insuperable. At the University of California, E. 0. Lawrence was inspired by Wideroe's paper not only to invent the cyclotron but, with D. H. Sloan (Sloan and Lawrence [1931]) he constructed a much improved version of Wideroe's linear accelerator. Figure 3 is a sketch of this accelerator. Mercury ions from an arc discharge passed through 30 drift tubes which were connected alternately to the two ends of the inductance in a high frequency (7 MHz) oscillating circuit. Sloan and Lawrence were unable to afford commercially available vacuum tubes in the 20 to 50 kW range; hence they built their own continuously-pumped, water-cooled oscillators. (During the next few years, Sloan with Livingood and others built oscillators for power levels as high as 500 kW cw.) The home-made oscillators sufficed to excite the drift tubes to about 42 kV and the system delivered ions with energies up to 30 times 42 keV or 1.26 MeV. The final energy was measured in an electrostatic deflecting system. Sloan continued this work with W. M. Coates (Sloan and Coates [1934]). In a 36 drift tube accelerator mercury ions were finally accelerated to 2.85 MeV. Coates [I9341 tried bombardment of a number of targets with the mercury ion beam. No nuclear events were reported but X-rays of moderate intensity were observed from some materials. These accelerators, again, were in advance of the electronic art. The lack of sources of high power at very high frequency forced their designers to use heavy ions which were not useful at the energies achieved for nuclear physics. They were soon abandoned in favor of the cyclotron. Other Sloan-Lawrence accelerators were built during the late thirties, for example
A.l
THE HISTORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
5
at Cornell University and in Japan. The Cornell machine accelerated deuterons, the lightest ions accelerated in a linear accelerator up to that time. After the war, heavyion accelerators for higher energies were built for use in nuclear chemistry. They will receive attention later. Here we note only the fact that the first section of the heavy-ion accelerator a t the University of Manchester (Nassibian et al. [1961]) uses the SloanLawrence structure which, for heavy ions at low energies, presents certain advantages over modern designs. In the first section of the Manchester machine ions are accelerated to energies of about I MeV per nucleon.
w Fig. 3. The linear accelerator of Sloan and Lawrence.
3 Postwar developments At the beginning of World War I1 it was clear that useful linear accelerators for either electrons or protons would not be possible until methods were developed for generation and control of radiofrequency power in the megawatt range at frequencies of hundreds or thousands of megahertz. Some of these developments had begun during the late thirties. The invention of the klystron was announced in 1937 and conventional vacuum tubes had been pushed t o higher and higher frequencies by reducing their sizes and hence their power outputs. The major wartime advances were made under the pressure for radar protection for Great Britain and under the expanding pressures for radar for tactical uses and for countermeasures against enemy radar. Most important of the radar power sources
6
J.P.BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
was the multianode magnetron which speedily reached multikilowatt power levels first at 3000 MHz, then at 10000 MHz, and finally at 30000 MHz. Such levels were not maintained continuously but were pulsed at low duty cycles as was appropriate for radar systems. For use at frequencies in the 100 to 1000 MHz range, triodes and tetrodes were developed but could not reach the power levels attainable with magnetrons. Paralleling these advances were major improvements for controlling and monitoring microwave systems. By the war's end it was clear that linear accelerators could be designed for useful operation and several laboratories started immediately on developments that led to the linear accelerators of today. Two of these were particularly important. At Stanford a group under W. W. Hansen proceeded toward construction of an electron machine, a project of which they had dreamed since prewar day. At the University of California design studies began under L. W. Alvarez; these studies were to result in the first successful proton linear accelerator. These two important projects will be presented in some detail in sections 4 and 7.
4 The Stanford linear electron accelerators The interest at Stanford in electron acceleration dates back to the mid-1930's when W. W. Hansen became intrigued with the properties of cavity resonators which could be excited to very high electric fields without the expenditure of unreasonable quantities of radiofrequency power. At the time Hansen's hope was that electrons could easily be accelerated to a few MeV for use in generating X-rays. He studied the then relatively unknown properties of certain cavity resonators which he christened "rumbatrons". In 1938 he became distracted from acceleration of electrons when he participated with the Varian brothers in furthering the development of the klystron. The klystron is an amplifier in which the mechanism of amplification involves "velocity modulation", a process that had been discussed in the literature since 1935. In the klystron, for the first time, cavity resonators were used as the input and output circuits. The first successful operation of klystrons was described in the literature in 1939 (Varian and Varian [1939]). Also collaborating with the Varian brothers were two graduate students, J. R. Woodyard and E. L. Ginzton, both of whom were to take leading roles in Stanford's postwar programs. Several klystrons were built for power applications but, in its wartime applications, the klystron was of primary importance as a source of milliwatts at radar frequencies for use as a signal generator or local oscillator. A second discouraging development was Kerst's successful betatron which appeared in 1939. This was obviously a cheap source of electrons of many tens of MeV. To match its performance a radiofrequency accelerator even using cavity resonators would require enormous quantities of high frequency power at frequencies then unattainable at high power levels. By the end of the war the situation was quite different. Several new power sources
A.l
THE HISTORY O F LINEAR ACCELERATORS
7
were available. Sloan and Marshall had developed a tetrode (the "resnatron", see section 8) specifically for use in electron linacs. The development of the magnetron made linear accelerators feasible for energies higher than the betatron could hope to attain. Billion volt accelerators appeared somewhat remote since 300 or so megawatts of pulsed power appeared to be required and single magnetron outputs had reached only a couple of megawatts. It was not clear then that many magnetrons could be synchronized with the necessary precision. The Stanford group noted the fact that development of power sources was necessary and, in 1946, began to build small linear accelerators using the available magnetrons. Simultaneously E. L. Ginzton, M. Chodorow, S. Sonkin and several others began a program aimed at development of sources for higher power and better stability than seemed possible with magnetrons. Hansen had surrounded himself with an extremely capable group. The work proceeded rapidly and by 1947 a design study was complete and a first accelerator had been built and tested (Ginzton, Hansen and Kennedy [1948]). It was shown that, since the electrons would be traveling over most of their path at extremely relativistic velocities, virtually no focusing would be necessary. A simple accelerating structure was chosen; this was simply a waveguide excited in a transverse magnetic mode (which includes an axial electric field). The phase velocity in the guide was reduced to the velocity of light by loading periodically with iris diaphragms. Frequency was chosen to be about 3000 MHz since power requirements decrease as frequency is increased but this was the highest frequency for which power in the megawatts was available. The accelerator described in this paper was about 9 ft long. In it electrons had been accelerated to 4.5 MeV. This accelerator, later to become known as the "Stanford Mark I", was later extended to 14 ft and reached a peak energy of 6 MeV (Becker and Caswell [I 95 I]). It was powered by a single magnetron which yielded 0.9 MW. Encouraged by this quick success Hansen and his associates submitted to the Ofice of Naval Research in 1948 a proposal for a billion volt accelerator to be 220 ft long. This rather daring proposal was approved with a rapidity that is amazing to present-day proposal writers and construction of the machine (to be called the Stanford Mark 111) was begun in 1949. As a prototype for the 1 GeV machine, a second short accelerator was built. This was the Stanford Mark I1 (Post and Shiren [1955]). It was about 12 ft long and, when eventually supplied with about 20 MW of rf power, it accelerated electrons to almost 40 MeV. A very powerful team attacked the design and construction of the billion volt accelerator. Important technical leadership was provided by R. L. Kyhl. A multiplicity of theoretical problems, many fundamental to the success of the machine, had been under attack for some years by E. L. Chu in collaboration with Hansen. In 1951, Chu produced a 237-page report which contained virtually the whole detailed theory of the electron linear accelerator (Chu [1951]). Two main topics were treated exhaustively, first, the theory of the field patterns in an iris-loaded waveguide and second, the dynamics of electrons in such fields. One of the most important of Chu's
8
J.P. BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
contributions was an analysis of permissible dimensional tolerances in long electron linacs. As a result of his analysis, tolerances of 0.0002 of an inch were set on several important dimensions (diameter of the waveguide, diameter of the hole in the iris, and thickness of the iris). These are unusually severe tolerances and require very refined methods of fabrication. In the search for improved rf sources the Stanford group adopted earlier recommendations made by Hansen who had been confident that the klystron was capable of design for operation at multimegawatt levels. The development of the high-power klystron started in 1946 by Chodorow, Ginzton, Neilsen, and Sonkin [I9531 finally was successful in 1949. Chodorow had analyzed the operation of the klystron when its electrons have relativistic velocities and had shown that it should still be operable. Very long extrapolations were made from the low energy designs of klystrons that had been built previously and many difficulties were discovered and circumvented. It seemed essential to separate the vacuum system of the klystron and the accelerator so that it was necessary to pass the high output power through a "window" which gave endless trouble with rf breakdown. Klystron life initially was short but improved steadily. During the construction of the Mark I11 important changes took place in the staff. In 1949 the group was saddened by the death of Hansen. He was only forty years old. A minor consolation was the fact that he lived long enough to see successful operation of the first high-power klystron. Direction of the Mark I1 and the Mark 111 accelerator projects was undertaken by E. L. Ginzton who brought both machines to successful completion. In 1951 W. K. H. Panofsky moved to Stanford from the University of California. He was to take a leading role in Stanford's future programs. By 1951 30 ft of the 220 ft were completed. The accelerator worked from the moment of the first test. With three klystrons each supplying 8 MW, the 30-ft accelerator produced 75-MeV electrons. Ten-foot sections were added at a rate slowed down by the fact that an active experimental program was started almost immediately. By 1953 the length had reached 210 ft and the electron energy was over 600 MeV. This energy limit was set by the capability of the klystrons to yield output power. The Mark 111 accelerator was described in a 70-page paper in the February, 1955 "Linear Accelerator Issue" of the Review of Scientific Instruments (Chodorow et al. [1955]). This paper includes, in a long footnote, a valuable history of linear accelerator projects at Stanford. The experimental program included R. Hofstadter's historic measurements on the form factors of the proton and the neutron for which he was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1961. Five years later a 90-ft extension was added and the peak energy reached 900 MeV. In 1963 a major improvement program was instituted including dismantling of the whole machine and replacement of the accelerating sections by new units of improved design. This resulted in much improved performance and in 1964 the 300-ft Mark I11 machine reached its present operating energy of 1.2 GeV.
A.l
5 SLAC
THE HISTORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
-
9
The Stanford Linear Accelerator Center
The success of the Mark I11 accelerator soon inspired speculation about a step to even higher energies. Hofstadter was the first to suggest consideration of a machine 10 to 20 times larger than the Mark 111. In 1955 small, informal discussions began of a new "Project M" (whether M stood for "Monster" or "Multi-BeV" is no longer certain). On April 10, 1956 the first official Project M meeting was held at the home of W. K. H. Panofsky. The group included Hofstadter, Ginzton, R. B. Neal who was later to be directly responsible for SLAC's construction, and a number of other Stanford physicists. It was agreed that a possible accelerator might be two miles long for initial operation at 15 GeV with eventual expansion (by addition of more klystrons) to 45 GeV. One year later a "Proposal for a Two-Mile Linear Electron Accelerator" was submitted to three agencies of the U.S. Government. The cost of the 15-GeV accelerator was to be of the order of $100 million. This was sufficiently higher than the cost of any previous accelerator that it caused a considerable amount of excitement in Washington. During the next couple of years panels advisory to the National Science Foundation and to the Atomic Energy Commission recommended construction, as did President Eisenhower. Hearings were held before the Joint Congressional Committee on Atomic Energy. For the first time the nation's program in high energy physics became a political issue and as such it was debated for several years. Finally, the project was approved by the AEC in 1962 and construction commenced. The design study had been directed by Ginzton who resigned in 1961 to become Chairman of the Board of Varian Associates. He was s~~cceeded by Panofsky, under whose capable direction the project moved swiftly toward a successful conclusion. The new accelerator was to be the central facility in a new national laboratory, christened the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC). Its initial energy had been raised to 20 GeV. The machine was to be completed in 1966. In 1962 when the project was initiated the SLAC staff already included 170 people and the design had been worked out in considerable detail. Hence it was possible to proceed directly into construction. The staff was expanded rapidly to about 1000 people and the work moved ahead speedily and on schedule. In May of 1966 the two-mile machine was complete and a beam of electrons traveled through its whole length to emerge with an energy of 10 GeV. Within two weeks this was raised to over 18 GeV, and by January of 1967 the energy passed 20 GeV. During the construction period extensive preparation was made for the experimental program which began as soon as the machine was turned on. A major program is now in progress under the direction of high energy physicists from Stanford and about ten universities throughout the United States. A number of descriptions of the two-mile machine and its operation will be found in the proceedings of accelerator conferences collected at the end of this chapter.
10
J.P. BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
It is also described in the monograph The Stanford Two-Mile Accelerator (Benjamin, New York).
6 Other linear electron accelerators Although, in the writer's opinion, the major contributions to the linear electron accelerator art have been made at Stanford, many other laboratories have played an important part in the development. In the paper of Ginzton, Hansen and Kennedy [1948], the authors note the existence of programs at the General Electric Company in Schenectady, M.I.T., Purdue, the Radiophysics Laboratory in Australia, the Telecommunications Research Establishment (T.R.E.) in England, the University of Virginia, and Yale. Of these the most important were the programs at T.R.E., M.I.T. and Yale. At T.R.E. a group headed by D. W. Fry and including W. Walkinshaw, L. B. Mullett, R. B. R-Shersby-Harvie and others made design studies that paralleled those proceeding at Stanford. Their results confirmed, or, in some cases, preceded the Stanford conclusions. Several electron linear accelerators were built by this group which soon moved to the Atomic Energy Research Establishment (A.E.R.E.) at Harwell. Several lines of investigation not pursued at Stanford were undertaken at A.E.R.E., for example the use of dielectric loading rather than iris loading, and the possibility of saving power in a traveling wave system by feeding back the power emerging at the high energy end of the waveguide to combine with the input power. References to the work at T.R.E. and at A.E.R.E. will be found in the paper of Chodorow et al. 119551. At M.I.T. the attack was led by J. C. Slater, who made an independent and exhaustive analysis of beam dynamics and accelerator structures (Slater [1948]). Under Slater's supervision, A. Kip, W. Bostick, P. Demos and others built a linear accelerator powered by a number of magnetrons and solved successfully the problems of keeping several magnetrons in phase. At Yale, under the direction of H. L. Schultz, a 10-MeV accelerator of a different design was constructed (Schultz and Wadey [1951]). Eight independent cavities operated at 600 MHz were separately driven by eight triodes. The same type of excitation was used more recently in the Los Alamos PHERMEX (Pulsed High Energy Radiographic Machine Emitting X-rays) accelerator (Boyd et al. [1965]). This machine, designed and now in use for flash radiography, includes three cavities excited by separate amplifiers at 50 MHz. Beam currents of 30 amperes are accelerated during pulses of 0.1 or 0.2 microseconds. During the period between 1949 and 1953 studies of electron and proton linear accelerators were carried on in the laboratory of P. Grivet in Paris by a group that included one of the editors of the present volume. Several electron accelerators were built and operated using 3000 MHz magnetrons as power sources; both traveling
A.l
THE HISTORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
11
wave machines (Vastel [1952]) and standing wave machines (Sarazin [1953]) were investigated. This work led to construction of a 5-MeV traveling wave accelerator that found application in French hospitals for use in X-ray therapy. In more recent years electron linac development has taken two directions. Electron linacs of a few tens of MeV have proved very useful in radiography and in medical applications. They have become commercially available from a number of sources. The second direction has been the push to higher energies, for the most part in government-supported institutions. At Orsay (near Paris), for example, a linear accelerator for between 1 and 2 GeV has recently been operated at energies above I GeV. Although conventional in concept this machine has several unconventional and ingenious mechanical design features. At Kharkov, in the U.S.S.R., a series of electron linacs has culminated in a machine operating at 2 GeV.
7 The Berkeley 32-MeV proton linear accelerator The second major postwar development took place at the Radiation Laboratory of the University of California where Alvarez assembled a very able group of physicists and engineers to undertake the design and construction of a proton linear accelerator. A most important achievement and one which later had profound effects on accelerator work both at Berkeley and at Stanford was Alvarez' success in persuading Panofsky to leave the Bell Telephone Laboratories and return to academic life at Berkeley where he remained until his move to Stanford in 1951. The problems in designing a proton linac differ materially from those to be met in an electron linac; in most cases they are more severe. At I MeV the velocity of a proton is less than 5 % of that of light. It is impractical to slow down phase velocities in waveguides to so low a value so some new accelerating system must be invented. At low phase velocities and high frequencies a radial variation in field appears which is quite intolerable at frequencies much above 200 MHz so cavities for acceleration of protons become much bulkier than those for electron acceleration. Finally, although the recently discovered principle of phase stability indicated that protons could automatically stay in phase with accelerating fields up to indefinitely high energies, it was speedily noted that protons stable in phase were automatically unstable in radial motion (in charge-free space) so that very soon after injection it could be expected that the beam would disappear due to radial defocusing. The Berkeley group set about solving these problems. Alvarez already had decided that the accelerating field should be set up in a long cylindrical cavity using the same transverse magnetic mode that is used in the smaller waveguides of the electron linac. The protons would pass along the axis of the cavity through a series of drift tubes of increasing length which would shield them from the rf field when it was in the decelerating phase. This is not the same system as was used by Sloan and Lawrence; in that system the particles passed through a drift tube in one half of an rf period and
12
J.P. BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
fields at half of the gaps were opposite in direction to those at the others. In the Berkeley system protons require a full rf period to pass through a drift tube and all gap fields have the same direction. Operation at reduced frequency was not a bad problem. In fact, it happened that a considerable quantity of war surplus radar components usable at 200 MHz were available and could be adapted to power the new linac. The focusing problem was troublesome. It seemed that it could be solved by inserting dense grids across the upstream end of the bore hole of each drift tube-thin foils would be even better. So an attempt was made to mount beryllium foils less than a micron thick in the appropriate positions. Injection energy was chosen to be 4 MeV (from an electrostatic accelerator of energy higher than had been reached in any such machine then in existence), high enough that scattering in the foils would not be serious. But the foils were quickly destroyed by radiofrequency discharges and had to be replaced by heavy grids. Since these grids intercepted a good deal of charge, they were made rather sketchy and so had poor, though adequate, optical properties. Thus the major problems were solved and a machine 40 ft long was constructed. The rf cavity was a light copper structure about 3 ft in diameter; it was enclosed in a steel vacuum tank. Construction began in 1945 and the first 32-MeV proton beam was observed in 1947. A description of the Berkeley machine appeared in the "Linear Accelerator Issue" of the Review of Scientific Instruments (Alvarez et al. [1955]). This important accelerator has been the prototype for most subsequent proton and heavy ion linear accelerators. Only one basic change has been incorporated in more modern linear accelerators. It was shown at Brookhaven (Blewett [1952]) that alternating-gradient focusing could be used in linear accelerators to provide radial focusing with good beam optics and without interception of beam. The first test of this principle was on the Berkeley linac where electrostatic alternating-gradient focusing was included inside the drift tubes only a few months after announcement of the principle. Since rather large electric fields are necessary, subsequent linac designers have preferred to include magnetic quadrupoles in the drift tubes and to use magnetic alternating-gradient focusing. The historic 32-MeV accelerator at Berkeley was dismantled in 1958 and moved to the University of Southern California.
8 Other proton linear accelerators Until 1967, the highest energy reached in a proton linear accelerator was at the University of Minnesota where J. H. Williams and his associates constructed a machine for a maximum energy of 68 MeV (Day et al. [1958]). This machine differed from the first Berkeley linac in several ways. It was divided into three sections, the first accelerating to 10 MeV, the second to 40 MeV, and the third to 68 MeV. The injection energy was only 500 keV, thus simplifying markedly the problems of the
A.l
THE HISTORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
13
injector. Finally. it was powered by tetrodes nicknamed "resnatrons" and patterned on similar tubes designed before the war for use on electron linear accelerators and improved during the war for use in radar countermeasures. The inventor of the resnatron is D. H. Sloan, who, some years before, had collaborated with Lawrence on a n early linear accelerator. Construction a t Minnesota began in 1949. By 1953 the machine was operating at 40 MeV and experimental programs at both 10 a n d 40 MeV were under way. By 1958 the full energy had been achieved. Since then this machine has been a very useful tool in many studies of nuclear structure. Linear accelerators are more expensive than cyclotrons or synchrotrons; hence very few have been built for use in nuclear physics. The proton linac has, however, found an important application as a n injector for proton sychrotrons. A 20-MeV linac serves as the injector for the 6-GeV Bevatron at Berkeley, a 9-MeV linac is the injector for the 10-GeV "synchrophasotron" at Dubna in the U.S.S.R., a 15-MeV linac injects into the 7-GeV "Nimrod" synchrotron in the U.K., and 50-MeV linacs provide injected protons for the 12.5-GeV ZGS at Argonne, the 28-GeV PS at C E R N , and the 33-GeV A G S at Brookhaven. During the summer of 1967 the Minnesota record was surpassed at Serpukhov in the U.S.S.R. where a 100-MeV linac came into operation. It is now in use as the injector for the Soviet Union's 76-GeV proton synchrotron. All of these machines use cavities and drift tubes similar to those found in the first postwar machine at Berkeley. Modern linacs combine the rf cavity and vacuum tank, using copper-clad steel tanks. Almost all use magnetic alternating-gradient focusing. The problems of rf power sources have largely been solved by industrial developments both in America and in Europe. Relatively reliable sealed vacuum tubes are now available for use around 200 MHz at levels of several megawatts. The largest linac injector under construction in 1967 is the 200-MeV machine which is to be the new injector for the Brookhaven AGS. It is scheduled for completion in 1971. It seems probable that a similar machine will be used as part of the injection system for the 200-GeV synchrotron to be built at Weston, Illinois.
9 Heavy ion linear accelerators For use in nuclear chemistry (for example for production of transuranic elements) several heavy ion linear accelerators have been built. Two virtually identical machines resulted from a design study held in 1953-54 a t Berkeley. The participants were a Yale group headed by R. Beringer and a University of California group headed by C. M. Van Atta. The accelerators were to be capable of accelerating ions in the mass range from helium to argon to energies of about 10 MeV per nucleon. In these machines a first stage of rf acceleration carries ions from a 500-keV injector to energies of I MeV per nucleon. The beamis then passed through a "stripper"
14
J.P. BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
which may be a thin foil or a gas jet. During passage through the stripper the degree of ionization is raised by stripping of electrons from the ions. Subsequent acceleration is more effective because of the higher ionization and the beam is carried through a poststripper cavity to energies of about 10 MeV per nucleon. For heavy ions even lower frequencies are appropriate. The Yale and Berkeley machines are operated at 70 MHz; commercial vacuum tubes at the necessary power levels are available for this range. Because of the lower frequency the accelerating cavities are large in diameter (about 9 ft). The poststripper tank is about 90 ft long. The very large size of these tanks presented some problems in transportation, particularly around the hairpin turns in the road leading up the steep hill to the Berkeley Radiation Laboratory. Fortunately these were overcome and both machines have been in successful operation since 1958 (Hubbard et al. [1961]). Another heavy ion accelerator for essentially the same final energy but built in three tanks has already been mentioned in section 2. This is the accelerator at the University of Manchester whose prestripper accelerator uses the configuration of Sloan and Lawrence. A fourth heavy ion linear accelerator, again for a final energy of 10 MeV per nucleon, was built in the linear accelerator center at Kharkov in the U.S.S.R. during the period between 1958 and 1963.
10 Linear accelerators for high average currents At the Livermore branch of the Lawrence Radiation Laboratory several accelerators have been built for acceleration of continuous proton or deuteron currents of an appreciable fraction of an ampere. The first of these had its design based in 1948 on the maximum frequency for which high-power continuously-operating vacuum tubes were available. This was judged to be about 12 MHz and a tank 60 ft in diameter and 60 ft long was built. The drift tubes were so large that a short section of railroad track was constructed to run directly into the tank to facilitate their installation. The difficulties associated with this operation are easily imagined and it was only as a result of a major effort that continuous currents of 50 mA were accelerated to 10 MeV. Pulsed currents as high as 225 mA were attained. Industrial vacuum tube developments soon made it possible to raise operating frequency to about 50 MHz and the 60 ft tank was abandoned in favor of a series of smaller cavities. In this, the so-called A-48 accelerator, continuous currents of 75 mA of protons at 3.75 MeV or 30 mA of deuterons at 7.5 MeV were achieved. This effort was abandoned in 1958. During the period since about 1960 considerable interest has been manifested both in the United States and in Europe in accelerators to produce intense beams of mesons. Design requirements were for average proton currents of about 1 mA at energies between 500 and 1000 MeV. A lengthy and somewhat heated debate ensued between proponents of linear accelerators (Yale and Los Alamos) and of various
A.l
THE HISTORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
15
sorts of cyclotrons [Oak Ridge, UCLA, and ETH (Zurich)]. In the United States a decision was made in 1967 in favor of Los Alamos and the linear accelerator; construction has been started on a "Los Alamos Meson Physics Facility" (LAMPF). The LAMPF accelerator is to be about 2500 ft long and will have a final energy of about 800 MeV. This machine will incorporate a new feature previously proposed at Brookhaven and at Yale. At an energy between 100 and 200 MeV the drift tube accelerator system loses efficiency until it is equalled by an iris-loaded waveguide system operated at a higher frequency. At Los Alamos the first 100 MeV will be of conventional drift tube design operating at 200 MHz. Above 100 MeV a change will be made to iris-loaded waveguide operating at 800 MHz. The principle of operation in this range is somewhat different from that used in electron linacs; it will be discussed elsewhere in this book (chapter C.l.1~). The most daring proposal for a high current linac comes from the Chalk River Laboratory of Atomic Energy of Canada, Limited. This is for a 1000-MeV linear accelerator to yield a continuous proton current of 65 mA. The purpose of this device is the production of enormous quantities of thermal neutrons, higher by a factor of ten than available from existing nuclear reactors. It has been named the ''Intense Neutron Generator" (ING). In 1966 a proposal was submitted to the Canadian Government. Since ING is estimated to cost about 3 150 million its approval is being considered somewhat deliberately. The I N G would be similar in principle to the LAMPF but would be subdivided into more accelerating sections because of the enormous power requirements. Its target is to be a rapidly flowing eutectic mixture of liquid lead and bismuth; it is in this target that the neutrons are produced. They will be thermalized by a heavy water moderator as in a reactor.
I 1 Recent developments In 1967 three important lines of development were evident. The first was the progress toward higher intensity in both proton and electron linacs. Peak currents of the order of 100 mA were reached in machines of both types. The old grid-focused proton linacs accelerated currents of a few hundred microamperes. With the first alternatinggradient-focused machine at Brookhaven it was hoped that a peak of 5 mA could be reached. That machine now runs at 30 or 40 mA. Peak currents approaching 150 mA have been accelerated in the 50-MeV linac at CERN. Under these conditions beamloading effects begin to appear and space-charge limits are approached. Much theoretical work during the early 1960's at CERN, Brookhaven, Los Alamos, and in the U.S.S.R. has led to a rather complete understanding of beam dynamics under conditions of high charge density. When electron linacs are used for acceleration of beams in the range of hundreds of milliamperes an unpleasant phenomenon appears; modes with transverse fields are
16
J.P. BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
excited and the beam is lost. This phenomenon is now well understood and countermeasures are available. The second important development relates to accelerating structures. The doubly periodic structure (see chs. C . l . 1 ~and C.l.le) has resulted in considerable improvement in stability both in waveguide and in drift tube structures. This development, primarily at Brookhaven, Los Alamos, and CERN, is still in progress at the time of writing. Finally, work now in progress on superconducting resonators is aimed at linear accelerators for continuous operation. From experiments at Stanford, Karlsruhe, Brookhaven and elsewhere it seems that cavity losses can be reduced to negligible levels. Then the operation of linacs in short bursts of high intensity can revert to continuous operation at moderate intensity with consequent major improvement in the linac as a research tool.
12 Linear accelerator literature Until about 1955 progress on linear accelerators was recorded in the open literature. Since that time, however, there has been an increasing trend toward exchanges of reports only among the fraternity of linear accelerator builders. These reports become slightly more available when they are presented at accelerator conferences whose proceedings are published. Much information about linacs is to be found in the proceedings of the six International Accelerator Conferences held in 1956 and 1959 at CERN, in 1961 at Brookhaven, in 1963 at Dubna, U.S.S.R., in 1965 at Frascati, Italy, and in 1967 at Cambridge, Mass. The last of these conferences was held at Yerevan, U.S.S.R., in 1969. Further information will be found in the proceedings of three Accelerator Conferences held in Washington, D.C. in 1965, 1967, and 1969. Beginning in 1961, six Linear Accelerator Conferences have been held in the United States. They were held in 1961 and 1962 at Brookhaven, in 1963 at Yale, in 1964 at MURA, Madison, Wisconsin, in 1966 at Los Alamos, and at Brookhaven in May of 1968. Finally, a good example has been set by the SLAC staff who have prepared for publication a monograph on the two-mile accelerator (see section 5). It is to be hoped that similar publications will eventually become available describing other major accelerator installations.
13 Acknowledgments The author of this chapter is deeply indebted for many helpful comments and suggestions to L. Alvarez, E. L. Ginzton, W. H. K. Panofsky and G. W. Wheeler.
THE HISTORY O F LINEAR ACCELERATORS
References Articles in periodicals and Laboratory Reports
ALVAREZ, L. W., H. BRADNER, J. V. FRANCK,H. GORDON,J. D. COW, L. C. MARSHALL, F. OPPENC. RICHMAN, and J. R. WOODYARD, 1955, Rev. Sci. Instr. 26, 111. HEIMER, W. K. H. PANOFSKY, 1933, Phys. Rev. 44, 784. BEAMS, J. W. and L. B. SNODDY, J. W. and H. TROTTER, 1934, Phys. Rev. 45, 849. BEAMS, BECKER, G . E. and D. A. CASWELL, 1951, Rev. Sci. Instr. 22, 402. BLEWETT, J. P., 1952, Phys. Rev. 88, 1197. and D. VENABLE, 1965, Rev Sci Instr. 36, 1401. BOYD,T. J., Jr., B. T. ROGERS,F. R. TESCHE, M., E. L. GINZTON,I. R. NEILSEN,and S. SONKIN,1953, Proc. I.R.E. 41, 1584. CHODOROW, CHODOROW, M., E. L. GINZTON,W. W. HANSEN, R. L. KYHL,R. B. NEAL,W. K. H. PANOFSKY, and the Staff of the W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, 1955, Rev. Sci. Instr. 26, 134. CHU,E. L., 1951, Report No. 140, Microwave Laboratory, Stanford University. COATES, W. M., 1934, Phys. Rev. 46, 542. DAY,E. A,, R. P. FEATHERSTONE, L. H. JOHNSON,E. E. LAMPI,E. B. TUCKER,and J. H. WILLIAMS, 1958, Rev. Sci. Instr. 29, 457. GINZTON, E. L., W. W. HANSEN, and W. R. KENNEDY, 1948, Rev. Sci. Instr. 19, 89. E. L., W. R. BAKER,K. W. EHLERS,H. S. GORDON,R. M. MAIN,N. J. NORRIS,R. PETERS, HUBBARD, L, SMITH, C. M. VAN ATTA, F. VOELKER,C. E. ANDERSON,R. BERINGER, R. L. GLUCKSTERN, W. J. KNOX,M. S. MALKIN,A. R. QUINTON,L. SCHWARCZ, and G . W. WHEELER,1961, Rev. Sci. Instr. 32, 621. I s r ~ cG., , 1924, Arkiv for Matematik, Astronomi och Fysik 18, 1. NASSIBIAN, G., J. R. J. BENNETT, D. BROADBENT, S. DEVONS, R. W. R. HOISINGTON, and V. E. MILLER, 1961, Rev. Sci. Instr. 32, 1316. POST,R. F. and N. S. SHIREN,1955, Rev. Sci. Instr. 26,205. SARAZIN, A., 1953, Ann. de Radioelectricitt 8, 134 and 228. SCHULTZ, H. L. and W. G. WADEY,1951, Rev. Sci. Instr. 22, 383. J . C., 1948, Rev. Mod. Phys. 20, 473. SLATER, 1931, Phys. Rev. 38, 2021. SLOAN, D . H. and E. 0. LAWRENCE, SLOAN, D . H. and W. M. COATES,1934, Phys. Rev. 46, 539. TROTTER, H. and J. W. BEAMS,1935, Phys. Rev. 47, 641. VARIAN,R. H. and S. VARIAN,1939, J. Appl. Phys. 10, 321. J., 1952, Ann. de Radioelectricite 6, 20. VASTEL, WIDEROE, R., 1928, Archiv fiir Elektrotechnik 21, 387.
Conference Proceedings International Accrlerator Conferences:
CERN Symposiun~on High Energy Accelerators and Pion Physics, 1956, edited by E. Regenstreif (published by CERN, Geneva, Switzerland) 567 pp. lnternational Conference on High-Energy Accelerators and Instrumentation, 1959, edited by L. Kowarski (published by CERN, Geneva, Switzerland) 705 pp. Proceedings of the lnternational Conference o n High Energy Accelerators, 1961, edited by M. H. Blewett (published under the auspices of the Division of Technical Information, U.S. Atomic Energy Commission) 490 pp. Proceedings of the International Conference o n High Energy Accelerators, 1963, edited by A. A. Kolomensky (Atomizdat, Moscow, U.S.S.R ) 1092 pp. These proceedings are partly in Russian and partly in English (see next entry). A two-volume translation into English of all of the papers in the preceding item has been prepared by the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission and is available from the Clearinghouse for Federal Scientific and Technical Information, National Bureau of Standards, U.S. Department of Commerce, Springfield, Virginia.
18
J.P.BLEWETT
INTRODUCTION
Fifth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, 1965, edited by M. Grilli (published by the Comitato Nazionale per 1'Energia Nucleare, Rome, Italy) 752 pp. Sixth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, 1967, edited by R. A. Mack (published as Cambridge Electron Accelerator Report CEAL-2000) 702 pp. (This report is also available from the NBS Clearinghouse.)
. ... ,-
' , ?, . ,
.
.'
.
. ,.,
.'
'
National Accelerator Conferences: The First National Particle Accelerator Conference, 1965, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, 1-1073. U.S. National Particle Accelerator Conference, 1967, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-14, No. 3, 1-1233. Particle Accelerator Conference, 1969, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. (in press). I
Lirieay ~.heleratorConferences: Minute$ gf the Linear Accelerator Conference held at Brookhaven National Laboratory during April, f.961, edited by A. van Steenbergen (published as Brookhaven Accelerator Department Report x.4 AvS-1) 109 pp. (out of print). Minutes of tHe Conference on Linear Accelerators for High Energies, 1962, edited by A. van Steenbergen, H. B. Knowles, S. Ohnuma, and C. K. Sinclair (published as Brookhaven Report BNL 6511) '385 pp. (out of print). Minutes of .the Conference on Proton Linear Accelerators at Yale University, 1963, edited by H. B. Knowles (published by the Physics Department of Yale University, New Haven, Conn. 1964) 479 pp. Minutes of the 1964 Conference on Proton Linear Accelerators held at Midwestern Universities Research Association, 1964, edited by F. E. Mills, C. D. Curtis, D. A. Swenson, and D. E. Young (published as MURA Report No. 714) 629 pp. (This report is available from the Clearinghouse for Federal Scientific and Technical Information, National Bureau of Standards, U.S. Department of Commerce, Springfield, Virginia.) Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference held at the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, 1966, edited by J. W. McDonald (published as Los Alamos Report LA-3609) 516 pp. (This report is also available from the NBS Clearinghouse.) Proceedings of the 1968 Proton Linear Accelerator Conference held at the Brookhaven National Laboratory, 1968, edited by J. W. Bittner [published as Brookhaven Report BNL 50120 (C-54)] 807 pp. (This report is also available from the NBS Clearinghouse.)
2
The General Theory of Linear Accelerators H. G . HEREWARD CERN, Geneva, Switzerlund
I
Phase stability
Linear accelerators range from ones where the particles are accelerated by a succession of distinct gaps to those where a travelling wave produces a smooth, continuous, force. We look first at the elementary principles of the travelling-wave accelerator, for most of its concepts and results can readily be extended to the general case. The first requirement is to have a wave with an electric field component in the direction of the beam, and with a wave velocity equal to the intended speed of the particles. Particles on the appropriate half of the wave will be accelerated, and, if the peak electric field exceeds .a .certain threshold depending on the rate of increase of wave velocity, there will be two phases (fig. 1) at which a particle can stay, moving along with the wave and gaining velocity at the same rate as the wave. In the neighbourhood of cp, there is "phase stability", since a pargcle ahead of it will gain energy more slowly, become slower than the wave, and drift back towards cp,; while a particle which is a little behind receives some extra acceleration and will tend to catch up. The result is that particles which start not too far from cp, - and not too far from the correct velocity - will oscillate about the synchronous phase cp,, gaining energy on the average at the correct rate. The same kind of argument shows that -9, is an unstable point; particles a little way from it will be driven still further away. The principle of phase stability was invented, in connection with the synchrotron, by Veksler [1945], and by McMillan [1945]. The first mentions of it for the linac case seem to be Slater [1946], and Alvarez [1946]. As the velocity of light is approached the particle velocity becomes almost in0 ~Vorth-HollandPubl. Co., Amsterdam
References p. 37
1969
19
20
H.G.HEREWARD
INTRODUCTION
dependent of its energy, and the frequency of these phase oscillations becomes so low that they practically do not occur. Then there is no threshold, and one aims to put all the particles close to the crest of the wave, where they will accumulate the maximum of energy and the minimum of energy spread. In practice proton and heavy-ion linacs operate in the regime of phase oscillations, while electron linacs have vrv c at least over most of their length. This makes an important difference to their operational characteristics: a section of proton linac will only accelerate over the range of energies for which it is designed, and its rf level must be above threshold; while a section of v = c electron linac will accelerate any sufficiently relativistic particle at any rf level.
Fig. 1. The accelerating wave is considered to be moving from left to right. The broken line indicates the field necessary for keeping up with the wave.
2 Tvansverse defocusing This phase stability, or longitudinal focusing, that can be obtained by accelerating on the front of a travelling wave, must unfortunately be paid for in the transverse motion. We shall obtain more detailed formulae in the next sections; for the moment consider the situation in a frame in which the wave and the synchronous particle are at rest, so that the force can be derived from an electrostatic potential. Neglecting the space-charge of the beam itself, and supposing that there is no other charge density within the beam, we have divE = 0 ,
(1)
and multiplied by -elm this can be expressed o:+o;+o:=o,
where o,is the frequency of small-amplitude phase oscillations in the neighbourhood of the synchronous particle. By choosing to work at the phase-stable cp, we make o, real, so the transverse motion must have at least one negative 02, and be unstable. The Lorentz transformation to the laboratory frame changes all frequencies by a factor y-l=J(l -P2), so leaves the relation (2) valid.
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
A.2
21
In practice some means of transverse focusing is provided, but the defocusing contribution of the rf wave is still, in most cases, determined by this equation. A general proof of this incompatibility between longitudinal and transverse stability has been given by McMillan [1950]. I t is mentioned by Alvarez [1946], who proposed to provide focusing by use of thin metal foils in the beam - so that one no longer has divE = 0.Later the foils were replaced by grids. Alvarez et a/. 119551 discuss rf defocusing and the effect of grids or foils in terms of the fields in a single accelerator gap.
At the present day quadrupole magnets are the most important means of focusing in linacs. They are dealt with in chs. B.1.2 and C.1.2~.
3 Properties of the travelling wave The electromagnetic field can be expressed as the sum of a TE field with E, =0, and a T M field with B, =O. In the case of cylindrical symmetry these fields are independent and only the TM is of interest for acceleration. The helix is a structure in which the TE and T M fields are inevitably coupled, but the Bzhas anegligible effect o n the motion (Johnsen and Dahl [1951]). Cylindrical symmetry is also lacking inseveral other types of structure, such as the cross-bar and the multistem (ch. C.l.le), and the input couplers for corrugated waveguide (ch. B.l.l and B.1.2), for reasons connected with power flow; but the field asymmetry in the central region occupied by the beam can be kept small. There are the special structures of ch. D.3, where the asymmetry has a n important effect on the transverse motion; and the unsymmetrical modes which are used in separators (ch. B.3.7), and may cause beam break-up in linacs (ch. B. 1.4), must also be mentioned.
For the TM field with cylindrical symmetry and no sources, we have in polar coordinates ( r , 9, z )
and Maxwell's equations become
-
dB,
az
1 a (rB,) r
dr
z
c-'~,
= cC2 E=
H.G. HEREWARD
22
INTRODUCTION
One can eliminate B, between (5) and (6), and, with (4), obtain the wave equation for Er or E,. The variables can be separated: in particular, if the rf has frequency 0 / 2 n and we consider a wave with phase velocity pc=v we can put E , = f ( r) cos ( a t - o z / o ) and (4), (5), (6) require that f ( r ) shall satisfy
and therefore is
where I, is the modified Bessel function I, ( x ) = 1
+ x2/4 + x4/64 + ... .
(12) The other field components are then given too. In particular, the radial force on a charge e having velocity pc in the z-direction is 1 e(Er - PCB,) = - EI, -
Y
(g)
sin ( w f - o z / u )
with I, ( x ) = x/2
+ x3/16 +
. . a .
(14)
Note that we derived these expressions from the assumptions (3) and Maxwell's equations. Consequently they are valid for a TM wave of velocity PC, with cylindrical symmetry and in empty space, regardless of the ndture of the surrounding rf structure that carries it. f If the wave velocity varies with z one must write
in place of wt - wz/v; then the expressions remain good approximations provided the variation is slow (Chu [1951]). A slow variation of E is also admissible.
4 Longitudinal motion Following Lloyd Smith [I9591 we use z, rather than t, as the independent variable. The equations of motion for a particle on the axis are
A.2
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
dW dz -
= eE, = e E
23
cos (at -
where W is the total particle energy, mo its rest mass, y, = w/moc2,and we have introduced k = w / c = 2n/lo.We now suppose that there exists a synchronous particle which has velocity equal to that of the wave*, and that d W, = e E cos i p s . dz
(18)
--
The value of E has to be suitably related to the variation of /3, along the accelerator to make this possible. For any other particle (16) gives
where we have put W = W,+ A W and work to first order in A W; and (17) becomest dA W dz
-
-
= eE (cos q - cos cp,)
.
The two first-order differential equations (19) and (20), or their second-order equivalent
govern the longitudinal oscillations. Three aspects repay study, the frequency for small amplitudes, the range of stability, and the effect of variation of coefficients. For small amplitudes the equations may be linearised by putting cp - q, = d i p and working to first order in Aq. Then (20) becomes dW = - e E sin i p s . Aq. dz
--
If the coefficients p,3Y;3 and E sin ips were constant, (19) and (22) would determine simple-harmonic oscillations of Acp and A W with wavelength A, given by
(
1
-
BhZmoc2 - -)I ~ , / 2 n= - keE sin q,
In fact the quantities vary with z ; provided the variation is slow (23) is still a good approximation, and these phase oscillations have a slowly varying wavelength. The
*
With some care it is possible to generalise to a slowly changing ps. t It is mathematically inconsistent t o work to first order in A W and then keep the full nonlinear expression on the right of eq. (20), but in practical cases A W is small compared with the kinetic energy even for particles oscillating to the extreme limits of stability.
H.G. HEREWARD
24
INTRODUCTION
form is
with, in general, A and a slowly varying too. We see that eE sincp, must be negative, corresponding to acceleration on the front of the wave in fig. 1, for otherwise the solutions will be of hyperbolic type. The decreasing frequency of the oscillations with increasing y is also evident from (23). It is convenient to consider such particles as tracing out small ellipses in a Aq, A W plane, with the ratio of axes amplitude of A W amplitude of Acp
=
[eE(- sin g,) j?:y:mOc2/klr.
To investigate the stability limits we again treat the parameters as constants, but instead of linearising we look for a constant of motion with validity extending to large amplitudes. The method is classical: we multiply (21) by dAq/dz, and using primes for d/dz, P s3 Y 3 Acp' Acp" = - keE ( C O S-~coscp,) Acp', moc
,
S
and integrate with respect to z
fP:y: ( A ~ ' ) '= -
4 1
moc keE --
m 0c which can also be written k 2p:y:moc
(Aw
(cos g
(sin cp
-
-
cos p,) dip
g cos cp,
+ C)
) +~eE (sin cp - cp cos cp, + C) = 0.
For each value of the constant C this formula gives a possible trajectory in the cp, A W plane, as illustrated in fig. 2. One sees that the stationary but unstable point at cp = - g, is confirmed, and furthermore that this point determines the limiting amplitude of phase oscillations. The special trajectory obtained by putting C = (sin cp,
-
g, cos 9,)
is a separatrix, and bounds the region of stable oscillations. The maximum stable energy excursion is readily found by putting q=qs on the separatrix: one gets A W = i2 [k-1eEmo~2/ls3ys3(qs cosvs- sinqs)]$. (29) The limiting stable excursion in phase towards the negative side can also be obtained from the separatrix, but only by numerical solution. It is equal to qs for q, small, and only 3 % less at qs = - 30'. The numerical properties of this stable region, particularly its area, have been extensively tabulated, but usually in the notation appropriate to the phase oscillations in synchrotrons (Gumowski [1967]).
A.2
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
25
It is common in the literature to refer to this stable region as a "bucket": the idea is that one can put particles in it, in order to lift them to a higher energy. One is not obliged to fill the bucket with particles. A reasonably compact area that is filled with particles being accelerated is called a "bunch".
The effect of the slow variation with z of the coefficients in the phase-oscillation equation is best discussed in the light of the notions of the next section.
Fig. 2. At the top, the accelerating field as function of phase, the synchronous energy gain WIs shown as a broken line. Next, the effective potential well, obtained by integrating cEz - W's. Bottom, phase-plane trajectories for such a potential, including the separatrix.
5 Liouville's theorem and adiabatic processes The factor j:y: certainly varies along the linear accelerator, and there is often a n interest in considering variable E and cp, too. For some special cases there are still
H.G.HEREWARD
26
INTRODUCTION
explicit solutions of the longitudinal equations, but it is usually more informative to appeal to Liouville's theorem and the notions of adiabaticity. Liouville's theorem states that in a Hamiltonian system the area of phase-space occupied by any set of particles, and the particle density in phase-space in the neighbourhood of any given particle, are constants of motion. Otherwise expressed: the particles move in phase-space like an incompressible fluid. It is proved in textbooks of statistical mechanics (Tolman [1938]). The theorem is more familiar in a phase-space of momenta and coordinates, with time as the independent variable, but nothing prevents us using it in the plane of energy and time (or phase, since o is constant) with z as independent variable. We see that (19) and (20) have precisely the form of canonical equations
if we take as Hamiltonian
H=-
k
,
( A w)' - eE (sin q - cp cos 9,). 2P,3?+0c Therefore Liouville's theorem applies to the motion in the Aq, A W plane. Taken alone, Liouville's theorem is useful mainly for making negative statements. For example: one cannots contrive that the product of energy-spread and phasespread of a bunch decreases steadily along the length of a linac. The concept of phase-space conservation for the transverse motion in accelerators became current during the development of the strong-focusing idea - see, for example Goward [1953]. The formulation in terms of Liouville's theorem for the longitudinal motion in linacs was by the present writer (Hereward [1954]). The idea of an adiabatic process can be illustrated by considering a bunch of particles bounded by one of the oval "trajectories" of fig. 2. If the parameters were constant, they would stay inside this curve, going round with their phase-oscillation frequencies. When the parameters change, the shapes of the curves change too, and the details of the particle motion become quite complicated; but, for sufficiently slow changes, the boundary of the bunch will at each moment be one of the new "trajectories", calculated from the current values of parameters. To illustrate the use of this, consider those particles which enter a linac within one of the small ellipses of eq. (25). With subscript 1 to indicate the beginning of the linac, this ellipse has axis ratio:
And, if the changes are slow enough to be adiabatic, at the end of the linac the same particles will be in an ellipse with axis ratio: AW, A rp2
--
= [eE,(-
sincp,, ,).&
y:,2
moc2/kjt.
(33)
A.2
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
27
With adiabaticity giving us the shape, we appeal to Liouville to tell us the size:
and the amount phase-spread damping follows
The importance of this method lies in its reliability and its generality. For Liouville's theorem a Hamiltonian must exist, but it is not necessary to know it accurately: in contrast, other methods may give quite wrong results for the damping if certain small terms are neglected (Carne et al. [I965]). To use the adiabatic law we need only the equations of motion at the beginning and the end of the process; how they change in between is irrelevant so long as it is slow. If we have sufficient data about trajectory shapes and areas, the method remains usable for non-linear amplitudes.
Fig. 3. The "golf-club" acceptance diagram. Particles coming from outside the bucket pass the unstable fixed point at a ; by the time they come back to this neighbourhood at b the bucket has expanded and they find they are inside.
There is, however, a limit. Particles close to the separatrix pass close to the stagnation point at - cp,, and have a very low phase oscillation frequency: however slowly the parameters change, some of these particles will find it too fast to be adiabatic. The area within the separatrix of fig. 2 is, at constant E and q,, proportional to &*, as one may see from (29); and this typically increases relatively fast at the beginning of a linac. One result of this is the "golf-club" shape of acceptance region computed by R. Taylor [1959]. When the area of a stable region expands, Liouville's theorem indicates that it must acquire the extra area from the surroundings, and the way this takes place is shown in fig. 3.
H.G.HEREWARD
28
INTRODUCTION
6 Rf power considerations The requirements in rf power of linear accelerators are usually enough to make considerations of power economy play a big part in the accelerator design. Since the power dissipated per unit length of a structure is proportional to the square of the rf field in it, a useful characteristic of the structure is the shunt impedance per unit length, defined by
where E is the amplitude of the useful travelling wave. Thus the energy gain of an accelerator, or section of an accelerator, say e v , is given by eV
= eEL
cos cp,
= ~ ( z , P L ) cos + cp,
(37)
where L is its length and P is the power dissipated. Outside the field of linear accelerators the term shunt impedance is conventionally defined somewhat differently; the r.m.s. rather than the peak field is used, making Zs a factor two less. Also our use of E, the useful wave amplitude, in (36) means that any adverse transit-time factor for accelerating gaps is effectively included in our Zs, so does not appear in (37). On the other hand cosp, appears in (37), rather than being assimilated into Zs, because it is not a property of the structure (see also ch. C.l.le).
The cost theorem of Slater [I9481 is based on (37) and the simple assumption that the cost of a linear accelerator can be expressed as the sum of certain fixed costs, a cost proportional to length, and a cost proportional to the rf power required: Cost
=a
+ bL + cP.
(38)
Minimising this with respect to P and L, subject to the energy gain held constant, gives
that is, at the minimum the length-cost and the power-cost are equal. Rather commonly such a calculation yields a short accelerator operating above the electric breakdown limit, showing that in fact minimum cost will be obtained by choosing a field strength as close to the breakdown limit as reliability arguments will permit, and that the length-cost will be greater than the power-cost. Another quantity of great importance is stored energy energy d~ssipatedper radian of rf
Q=-----
A.2
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
29
and the closely related time-constant
Q w
-
stored energy power dissipated
Apart from some special cases, such as superconducting linacs, or others with high beam loading, the installed rf power is not much more than the dissipation at operating level, and the rf supply is usually pulsed, so it will take a time like Q / o at the beginning of each pulse to provide the stored energy of the structure. The value of Q also determines the frequency tolerance; the details are different for different arrangements, but it is always true that a frequency error of one part in Q corresponds to a phase error of one radian after a time equal to one time-constant Q/w; and a phase error of one radian must be regarded as large. It is clear that any change in a structure that just reduces the losses will raise both the Q and the shunt impedance; the reduced power requirement is an advantage, offset a little by the extra filling time. One should also note the advantages of keeping the stored energy low; if one can choose a structure with the same shunt impedance but less stored energy, the power requirement will be the same but the filling time and tolerances will be easier. So, a t constant shunt impedance one prefers a low Q. The quantity ZJQ is independent of the losses, and is frequently used as a factor of merit, to measure how low is the stored energy at given accelerating field level. The perturbation technique, which compares IE l 2 at each measured point with the total cavity stored energy, is essentially a method of obtaining Z,/Q (see ch. B.l.l). The choice of operating frequency is influenced by many practical matters, including the availability of rf power equipment, and has to be considered for particular cases; but it is worth mentioning the scaling laws that apply if one changes the rf wavelength of a linac, keeping its length and energy range constant. Rather obviously: transverse dimensions (including aperture) K A , volume KL', electromagnetic fields KAO, total stored energy c c A 2 . In the skin-effect regime the surface resistance of copper is proportional to Apt, then: surface area rcA, total dissipated power K L ~ , shunt impedance K X * , energy time-constant ~ / w c c A * Q , x A ? The group velocity of a travelling-wave structure scales unchanged, so strict geometric scaling cannot keep Q/w and the propagation time in proportion; one solution is to divide the linac into sections of length proportional to A*. The wavelength for phase oscillations and the accepted energy spread scale like At[eqs. (24) and (29)l. One would like to scale the transverse focusing system in such a way as to keep q (ch. C . 1 . 2 ~ )constant; this would hold constant the ratio between applied focusing and rf defocusing [eq. (2)]. Then the wavelength of the transverse oscillations scales hke I.* and ideally the period of the focusing magnet system should d o the same, but this probably conflicts with the period of the rf structure. By disregarding this limieach tation we can at least have an idea of the trends: the aperture scales with i, transverse acceptance like A+, and the magnet pole-tip field scales unchanged. If the beam emittances are scaled to follow the acceptances, one can keep constant the
30
H.G. HEREWARD
INTRODUCTION
relative strength of space-charge defocusing (both transverse and longitudinal) by scaling the beam current acI1, but the brightness then decreases with increasing I. There is an optimum wavelength if current and brightness are both desired.
7 Electron linac structures: periodic structures An accelerating wave of the form (9) cannot be propagated in a uniform cylindrical metal waveguide, because the boundary condition E,=O on the cylinder wall is incompatible with (1 1) - at least, unless the velocity of the wave is greater than c. The wave may be slowed down by loading the tube with a dielectric (Fry and Walkinshaw [1948]), but practically all existing electron linacs employ disc-loaded waveguide, consisting of metal discs with central holes (irises) equally spaced along the tube (fig. 4), the whole being made of copper. There are several different ways of describing the behaviour of such a structure, and it will be discussed more fully in later chapters, but many of its most interesting features are due to the property - which it shares with most other types of linac structure - of being periodic. We follow Slater [I9481 in giving a general outline of wave propagation in periodic structures, based on Floquet's theorem, and taking the structure to be lossless. This theorem may be stated: in a given mode of oscillation of the structure, at a
Fig. 4. Typical disc-loaded accelerator waveguide. The dimensions (in mm) are those of the Stanford Mark I11 machine.
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
A.2
31
given frequency, the values of the fields are multiplied by a given complex constant when we move down the structure by one period. This results from the fact that if the whole structure is displaced along the z-axis, by one period d, it coincides with the original structure. There are certain intervals of o , called stopbands, where this complex constant is in fact real, and not 1. Then one has "evanescent modes" and there is no propagation. But the pass-bands are the part of the spectrum that interest us: here the complex constant has unity modulus, so can be written as exp(-j$), and $ is interpreted as the phase-shift of the travelling wave per period of the structure. The curve of w as a function of $ is called the dispersion characteristic; in fig. 5 we sketch it for the lowest pass-band of a disc-loaded structure. It is usual to draw such a diagram only for O<$
+
exp(jwt - j$z/d).(some function of z with period d).
(42)
We can apply this to the accelerating field on the axis, and write it, by Fourier expansion :
E,(r
= 0) = exp(jwt - j $ z / d ) . x n
=
C A , exp [jut
-
j ($
A, exp2nnjz/d,
+ 2nn) zld] .
n
The general term is clearly a travelling wave with phase velocity wd/($ + 2nn), so this mode can be regarded as a superposition of many sinusoidal travelling waves, each with its own phase velocity. Linac structures are designed to have one of these phase velocities equal to the velocity of the particles being accelerated, so that the corresponding travelling wave steadily pushes the particles along, and is the wave that we assumed in $9 3-5. All the other Fourier components have phase velocities that are very different: as far as the particle is concerned they are rapidly oscillating fields which can usually be neglected. For the n=O component - the one invariably used in electron linacs - the phase velocity is cod/$. From the usual derivation by superposed waves (Slater and Frank [1947]) it is easy to show that the group velocity is
So, apart from a scale factor the phase velocity is represented by the slope of OA and the group velocity by the slope of the curve at A (fig. 5). The mode with $ = n , called the x-mode, is special; basically because a phase shift of n is the same as multiplication by the real constant - I . The field pattern for
32
H.G.HEREWARD
INTRODUCTION
this mode in disc-loaded guide is sketched in fig. 6. One sees that it has symmetry about the planes through the middle of each cell, and a perfectly conducting surface (Ell=0, B, =0) can be placed at any of these planes without in any way disturbing the field pattern, so it is clear that no energy is being propagated along the guide. More formally, since - $ = $(modulo 2n), this mode is its own reverse-travelling image; it must have v,= - v,, therefore v, = 0. In one respect the n-mode is not exceptional: it has a shunt impedance little different from that of the travelling modes with $ a bit less than n (see ch. C.l.le).
Fig. 5. The variation of o with y ~ ,or dispersion characteristic, for the lowest pass-band of discloaded waveguide. The band-width wz - w l is exaggerated compared with usual electron linac structures.
Fig. 6. The A-mode in disc-loaded guide. In adjacent cells the field patterns are identical but with all signs reversed.
If two waves travelling in opposite directions are superposed, to make standing waves, the reverse wave is useless and the overall shunt impedance is halved. It seems contradictory if this remains true as y~ approaches n, for the y~ = A mode does not suffer this halving. The paradox is resolved by noting that the standing waves with y~ near A consist of long antinodes where the forward and reverse wave are in phase, and both accelerate the particle, interspersed with nodes where they are in antiphase and cancel one another. The argument about the shunt impedance being halved is only valid if the linac is long enough to contain both situations, so is bound to fail, for any finite length, when y~ is close enough to n. At n the whole length can be an antinode in the above sense, whether the linac be short or long.
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
33
8 Proton linac structures In most proton linear accelerators the particles are accelerated by a succession of gaps. Let us suppose the field in one gap given by
EZ( r , z , t ) = F ( r , z ) cos (wt + cp) .
(45)
If the particle velocity does not change much in crossing the gap it is useful to calculate the energy gain eV of a particle which crosses with velocity v. Put z=vt, then
where the integrals are taken from the field-free region before the gap to the one after it. As a n example one may suppose a field that is uniform across the gap a t the aperture radius :
F ( a , z) = V,,/g, - fg < z < +g =0 otherwise; then, at r = a ,
eV
=
eV,,
sin +3
+9
cos y
where 9=og/u. The factor (sin@)/+$ is always less than one and it, or the corresponding factor for other forms of F, is called the transit-time factor. Note that one multiplies F by a cosine and integrates, just as one does in Fourier analysis. In fact the evaluation of energy gain for a gap or succession of gaps is precisely equivalent to evaluating its contribution to the travelling wave component with the particle's velocity. From this follow some properties of gaps which would not otherwise be obvious, such as the I,, radial dependence, the c o s y (from some suitable origin) phase dependence even for unsymmetrical gaps, and others involving the radial forces. But it is usually more convenient to base one's analytic theory of the particle dynamics on the travelling-wave approach, as we have in $5 1-7, and reserve the gap-by-gap technique for numerical work. In the non-relativistic region the rf defocusing is strong, and a proton linac is required to accommodate some means of focusing; in practice this will give a beam of the order of a centimetre diameter. The radial variation of accelerating amplitude, (12), will then be excessive unless a rather low frequency is chosen; a choice of 200 M H z (1.5 m free space wavelength) is rather common for linacs which start at =0.03 to 0.04. With these parameters the well-known Alvarez structure is big enough to have magnetic quadrupoles inside its drift-tubes (Regenstreif [1959]). Around a=0.5 the shunt impedance of an Alvarez structure begins t o fall, and rr-mode structures at a higher f r e q ~ ~ e n cbecome y interesting.
34
H.G.HEREWARD
INTRODUCTION
Disc-loaded guide of the type used for electrons is prohibitively lossy in the region /j < 0.1, essentially because of the large amount of disc surface. Around 8 2 0.4 one may begin to consider it, but the travelling-wave form would require a very low group velocity and very tight tolerances.
Ordinary 71-mode structures have zero group velocity, as discussed in the previous section, and so does the Alvarez structure, as it is zero-mode electrically (it accelerates with its 271-mode component). Structures with zero group velocity have a small mode separation (for a given length of structure), and their field pattern is sensitive to small perturbations such as dimensional errors and beam loading. When losses, transients, or beam loading require power to flow, phase shifts (Hereward and Lapostolle [1955]) appear which are difficult to deal with. In recent years many structures have been invented which retain the advantages of 71- or 2n-mode, but avoid the disadvantages of zero or very low group velocity. They will be dealt with in later chapters, but here we say something about their dispersion characteristics, because they appear to violate the rules. Consider a 7112-mode travelling wave structure. To fix our ideas we can suppose it consists of cells, either coupled together through the beam hole as in a disc-loaded guide, or perhaps through some other hole or slot. The phase shift from a cell to the next-but-one is 71, corresponding to just a sign reversal. The n/2-mode is in the middle of the pass-band, where one may expect the group velocity to be highest* (fig. 5). Such a structure can be used in standing-wave regime by simply keeping it short compared with its attenuation length and reflecting the power from the far end, so as to superpose two oppositely travelling waves, giving the field pattern sketched in fig. 7. The reverse travelling wave dissipates as much power as the forward one, and contributes nothing to the acceleration, so we have lost a factor two in shunt impedance by going from travelling-wave to standing-wave regime. It can be seen in
Fig. 7. The ~/2-modewith a reflected wave, giving a standing-wave pattern.
* In an isolated lossless cavity the electric and magnetic fields are in quadrature, so the Poynting vector (averaged over a cycle) is zero everywhere. Take two such cavities with a hole in the common wall. Their fields will deform and overlap in the region of the hole, and in first approximation E A H will arise from the magnetic field of the first cavity combining with the electric field of the second, and vice versa. In both cases the net Poynting vector, averaged over a cycle, will be proportional to the in-phase components of the E and H, so to the sine of the pha~e~difference between the two cavities.
A.2
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
35
fig. 7 that in this standing-wave situation half of the cells contain practically no field, and it is also possible to ascribe the loss of shunt impedance to this; for a linac in which half the length is unused requires twice as much power for the same energy gain as one in which fields in a useful phase exist along the whole length. The side-coupled structure of Knapp [I9641 is based very directly on these ideas: the alternate, empty, cavities are put off the beam line, so that the whole of the accelerator length can be used for actively accelerating ones, and the shunt impedance per unit length is that of a z-mode structure. The side cavities cannot be eliminated. It is only in the steady state and neglecting losses that they are empty; while the structure is being filled with energy, or power is
is the phase-shift from one to the Fig. 8. Doubly-periodic structure. Above, all cavities equal, next. Below, o n the basis that alternate cavities may be different, a period contains two cavities and ty is the phase shift per period.
flowing along it to supply copper losses or beam-loading, the two travelling waves have different amplitudes and do not cancel precisely in them. On the other hand they can be made considerably different in shape from the main cavities, provided their resonant frequency is not shifted, without altering the essential characteristics of the structure; this makes it quite difficult to decide whether to regard it as a sort of 7112mode or a sort of z-mode structure. To be strict, the mode II/ is given by the phaseshift per structure-repeat period;
36
H.G. HEREWARD
INTRODUCTION
if the side cavities differ from the main cavities, a period must contain one of each. In fig. 8 we show the dispersion characteristic of this structure, first on the basis that all cavities are identical, one cavity is one period; then, by relabelling the $-axis and shifting the curve ABC into the interval - n to n, on the stricter basis. It is seen that this structure has the special property of two curves which cross at n-mode, where there are two solutions at the same frequency, with equal and opposite group velocities. The important physical difference between the two waves is easily seen by crosschecking with the upper part of fig. 8. Whether we are at the double-point or near it, the phase shift between any cavity and its adjacent cavity (of the other kind) is about n/2 for points on the branch aa, about - n/2 for those on bb: this explains how we can have two large and opposite group velocities while always being close to n phase-shift per period. When two independent modes have the same frequency one is free to take other linear combinations of them as the basic modes. It is interesting to recombine the two travelling n-modes, just described, to give the pair that consists of (i) the coupling cavities empty, accelerating cavities excited with n phase difference between adjacent ones; this is the resonant mode that one would use for acceleration, (ii) accelerating cavities empty, coupling cavities excited at n phase difference. Now suppose we alter the geometry a little to raise the resonant frequency of all the accelerating cavities and lower that of the coupling ones. Clearly the modes (i) and (ii) will move apart, and in fact there result two perfectly ordinary x-modes, each with the usual zero group velocity, belonging to separate pass-bands, as indicated by the broken lines on fig. 8. In this state these modes cannot be recombined, to recover the modes with 5x12 between adjacent cavities, because their frequencies are not the same. Many of the compensated or multiply-periodic structures can be derived by reversing the above argument: a succession of resonant accelerating cavities or gaps in n-mode are coupled each to the next by a resonant device, then by tuning these to the same frequency as the gaps the pass-bands join, and it becomes possible to combine them to make a wave with 4 2 from gap to next coupler and 4 2 from coupler to next gap, so a high group velocity. Other structures, typefied by the multistem of Giordano [1966], achieve the same effect at 0- or 2n-mode: by making the coupling impedance resonant another passband appears below the main band, and can be tuned up until the zero modes of the two bands have the same frequency. Then it becomes possible to combine them in quadrature, and the connections are such that the nj2 phase-shift from a gap to the next coupling resonator, and f n/2 from there to the next gap, are of the right sign for the power to flow the same way along the structure. With the discovery and understanding of these new types of structure it is becoming possible to separate the problem of designing cells that makes efficient use of power, energy, and length, from that of coupling them together in a way that is convenient from the point of view of power flow and tolerances.
+
A.2
THE GENERAL THEORY OF LINEAR ACCELERATORS
37
References ALVAREZ, L., 1946, The Design of a Proton Linear Accelerator. Phys. Rev. 70, 799 A. ALVAREZ, L. et al., 1955, Berkeley Proton Linear Accelerator. Rev. Sci. Instr. 26, 1l I. CARNE, A,, P. M. LAPOSTOLLE, M. PROME,1965, Accurate Beam Dynamics Equations in Proton Linear Accelerators. Proc. V International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Frascati 1965, p. 656. CHU,E. L., 1951, The Theory of Linear Electron Accelerators. Report ML 140 of the Stanford University Microwave Laboratory, Stanford, Calif., U.S.A. FRY,D . W. and W. WALKINSHAW, 1948, Linear Accelerators. Rep. Progr. Phys. 22, 102 (see p. 128). GIORDANO, S., 1966, A New Multistem, Drift-tube, Standing-wave, Zero-mode Proton Accelerating Structure. BNL Accelerator Dept. lnternal Report AGSCD-7. See also S. Giordano and J. P. Hannwacker, Studies of Multistem Drift-tube Accelerator Structures. U.S. National Accelerator Conference, Washington 1967, p. 290 and references therein. GOWARD, F. K., 1953, Review of Principles leading to Design of CERN Proton Synchrotron. In Lectures on the Theory and Design of an Alternating-Gradient Proton Synchrotron. CERN P.S. Group, Geneva, Switzerland, p. 23. I., 1967, CPS RF-Bucket, Width, Height and Area. Internal report MPS/Int. R F 67-1, GUMOWSKI, CERN, Geneva, Switzerland. HEREWARD, H . G., 1954, Energy Spread and Phase-Focusing in Particle Accelerators. Internal report CERN/PS/HGH/I ; CERN, Geneva, Switzerland. HEREWARD, H . G . and P. LAPOSTOLLE, 1965, Energy Flow and Transients in the Alvarez Structure. Proc. V International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Frascati 1965, p. 742, and references therein. K. and H . DAHL,1951, An Investigation of a Helix as a Linear Accelerator. Chr. MichelJOHNSEN, sens Inst., Beretn. XIV, 4. KNAPP,E. A,, 1964,800 MeV R F Structures. Conference on Proton Linear Accelerators, Midwestern Universities Research Association, Madison, Wisc. U.S.A., p. 31. See also Knapp ef a/., Accelerating Structure Research at Los Alamos. 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, Los Alamos, New Mexico, U.S.A., p. 83, and references therein. MCMILLAN, E. M., 1945, The Synchrotron - A proposed High Energy Particle Accelerator. Phys. Rev. 68, 143. MCMILLAN, E. M., 1950, The Relation between Phase Stability and First-Order Focusing in Linear Accelerators. Phys. Rev. 80, 493. REGENSTREIF, E., 1959, Le Synchrotron a protons du CERN (2eme partie), CERN 59-26. Or, translated into English, CERN 60-26, P.S. Division, CERN, Geneva, Switzerland, p. 123. SLATEK, J. C., 1946, The Design of Linear Accelerators. Phys. Rev. 70, 799 A. SLATER, J. C., 1948, Design of Linear Accelerators. Rev. Mod. Phys. 20, 473. J. C. and N. H . FRANK,1947, Mechanics (McGraw-Hill, New York), p. 168. SLATER, SMITH,Lloyd, 1959, Linear Accelerators. In Handbuch der Physik, Band XLIV (Springer, Berlin) p. 344. TAYLOR, R., 1959, Acceptance of Axially and Radially Oscillating Particles in the Linac Injector for the Harwell 7 GeV Proton Synchrotron (NIMROD). Report AERE-R 3013, U.K.A.E.A., Harwell, Berks, G.B. R. C., 1938, The Principles of Statistical Mechanics (University Press, Oxford), chs. 11,111. TOLMAN, VEKSLER, V. I., 1945, A New Method of Acceleration of Relativistic Particles. J . Phys. USSR. 9, 153.
PART B
Electron
Linear Accelerators F. AMMAN
J. V. LEBACQZ
J. BALLAM
H. LEBOUTET
R. BERGERE
J. E. LEISS
P. BRUNET
A. V. LISIN
X. BUFFET
G. A. LOEW
L. BURNOD
B. W. MONTAGUE
M. C. CROWLEY-MILLING
R. MILLER
A. L. ELDREDGE
R. B. NEAL
J. HAIMSON
V. G. PRICE
R. H. HELM
B. H. WIIK
H. HOGG
P. B. WILSON
ELA THEORY
1.1
B.l
Accelerating Structures G. A. LOEW
R. B. NEAL
I 1
Stanford Linear Accelerator Center Stanford, California, U.S.A.
Introduction
This chapter is concerned with the theory and design of the structures which provide the accelerating fields for electron linacs. A vast amount of work has been done during the last forty years in this specialized area of electromagnetic theory * but, by necessity, only some of the highlights can be covered here. In principle, the designer of a structure for an electron linac of prescribed energy, current and duty cycle, is confronted with a wide number of basic choices: operation with dc or rf power, low frequency or high frequency, traveling wave or standing wave, with or without feedback, continuous loading or periodic loading, all-metal boundaries or partially dielectric boundaries, constant-impedance or constant-gradient, room temperature operation or cryogenic operation, integral or separate vacuum envelopes, etc. In practice, the choices are not nearly as wide and have evolved only slowly in time. They are influenced by the state of the art and technological advances in other closely associated fields dealing with, for example, rf power sources, new materials and superconductivity. Thus, above dc energies of a few MeV attained with Van de Graaff accelerators (see for example, Buechner et al. [1947]), all electron linacs today derive their accelerating fields from rf power. While available rf power sources from low frequency triodes to lasers in the optical range span a very broad spectrum, most practical
* For early articles and comprehensive reviews, see, for example: Brillouin
[1946], Chu and Hansen [1947], Chu and Hansen [1949], Slater [1950], Fry and Walkinshaw [1948-91, Chu [1951], Chodorow e f al. [1955], Leboutet [1963], Borghi et al. [1966]. References p. 11 1
8 North-Holland Publ. Co., Amsterdam 1969
39
40
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
electron linacs to date have been built for pulsed operation in the range between 700 and 10000 MHz. The study of traveling-wave vs. standing-wave structures in relation to electron linacs has added considerable insight to the understanding of these structures. However, until the recent proof that superconducting structures can be used successfully to accelerate electrons (Smith et al. [1966]), this discussion has been mostly academic and the majority of electron linacs have operated in the travelingwave mode, without feedback. For reasons which will be discussed later in this chapter, it appears that this trend will continue in the future for most short-pulse accelerators operating in the microsecond range at room temperatures. On the other hand, it is likely that cw accelerators of the future will be of the superconducting, standing-wave or feedback type. While several ingenious schemes have been proposed to obtain structures with phase velocities equal to the velocity of light by means of either continuous or periodic ceramic loading (see for example, Lawton and Hahn 119481; Walker and West [1957]), or perhaps with plasmas, almost all electron linacs have or are being built with allmetal periodically loaded structures. The choice between constant-impedance and constant-gradient structures (uniform vs. tapered modular dimensions) is generally made on the basis of the maximum allowable electric field gradient as limited by breakdown and cost considerations. Finally, the choice b=iziral vs. separate vacuum envelopes seems to be one of purely technological preference and has not been based upon any fundamental differences between the accelerators which use one or the other technique. In conclusion, for all the above reasons, the main emphasis of this chapter is placed on the theory and design of all-metal, periodically loaded structures. In addition, since above a few MeV, electrons travel at velocities within a fraction of one percent of the velocity of light, the discussion is restricted to structures with a phase velocity equal to the velocity of light (for lower velocities, see ch. C.l.le).
2 The principles of periodically-loaded structures When an electron or a positron reaches an energy in the range of 10 MeV, it has a value of y z 2 0 where y is the total energy in units of moc2. Its velocity v, given by (1 - -')*c, is then within 0.125 % of the velocity of light. If an rf electric field, acting on this part1 le, is to increase its energy in a cumulative way, it must appear to travel at the same vt >city as the particle, i.e., for all practical purposes, at the velocity of light. There e .-\lo ways in which this effect should, in principle, be obtainable. One is illustrs .d in fig. l a where a sinusoidal electric field wave is propagating in a cylindric . d~avzguidein the TM,, mode. It is representative of a traveling-wave type of structure. ii synchronism between the particles* and the wave crests could be
* In this 4 apter, it ,ill be aswmed that the process of particle bunching, described in ch. B.1.2, has already Liken place and t' ~t these bunches of small phase extent are spaced a free wavelength 1.0 apart.
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
41
obtained, the energy gained by the particles over a length I, neglecting attenuation, would be V = &I. The other is illustrated in fig. 1b which shows an array of "pillbox" cavities. It is representative of a standing-wave type of structure. Each cavity is individually supplied with rf power and resonates in the TM,,, mode. No power is actually flowing in the beam direction. However, if the phases of the individual power sources are arranged as shown, the particles will be submitted to a cumulative force. This results from the fact that the square wave is made to appear to travel in synchronism with the particles. The magnitude of the net accelerating field is reduced slightly
Fig. la. Unloaded TMol cylindrical waveguide showing mode pattern and traveling-wave axial sinusoidal electric field amplitude.
Fig. lb. Chain of independently powered TMolo cavity resonators and example of in;iantaneous axial electric field amplitude along z-axis for 7r/2 phase shitt pcr cavity.
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
42
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
in relation to the square wave amplitude Eo because of two factors. The first is a transit time factor which comes about because the field in the cavity is changing sinusoidally with time while the particles are traversing it; its magnitude can easily be shown to be equal to sin [(rill,) ( d - t ) ] / [ ( n / I , )( d - t ) ] , where d is the distance between cavity centers, t is the drift distance between cavities, and 1, is the guide wavelength. The second factor is due to the fact that the particles are shielded from the field when they pass through the drift tube from one cavity to the next; this factor is simply [1 - ( t l d ) ] . Thus, the energy gained by the particles over a length I would be
V
= Eol [I - (tld)] sin [ n ( d -
t)/A,]/[z(d - t)/A,].
In practice, while both of the above models give good insight into how linear accelerators work, neither is ever built in this simple form. As will be shown below, the uniform waveguide does not work as an accelerator because the velocity of the wave crests, generally called the phase velocity, up, is always greater than the velocity of
L BEAM
Fig. lc. Periodic disk-loaded TMol waveguide and example of traveling-wave axial electric field amplitude along z-axis for 7c/2 phase shift per period.
1 \
I.1
light. The simple array of short cavity resonators is not very desirable because of the excessive complexity and cost due to the numerous individual power feeds. The actual solution is a compromise between the two concepts. It is illustrated by the periodically loaded structure shown in fig. lc. As will be shown later, periodic metal irises of this type do not provide the only method of reducing the phase velocity to the velocity of light but they we the basis of probably the simplest and certainly the almost universally used config 1. .tion fo electron linac structures. 1 he pro .aracteristics of a uniform waveguide are given by the solution of the wavc equatl 11
B.1.1
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
43
where k = w / c and o is the angular frequency. For a waveguide of cylindrical symmetry with coordinates 8, r and z and the TM,, mode which has a component E, in the direction of particle acceleration, the electric and magnetic fields are given by the well-known solutions (see for example, Ramo and Whinnery [1953]): E, = E,Jo ( k , r ) exp [j ( o t - Bz)] E, = jqEo [ l - (wcjw)2]t J , (k,r) exp [j (wt - S z ) ] No = jEoJ, ( k , r ) exp [j ( a t - P z ) ] where J o and J, are Bessel functions, to, is the cut-off frequency, kc = w,/c, fl= o/vp, P2 = k 2- k:, k = w / c and q is the intrinsic impedance of the medium. For these solutions to exist, the propagation constant p must be real; this condition is fulfilled only if up > c.
I
Fig. 2. Brillouin (or
(,I-/$
/
diagram showing propagation characteristics for uniform and periodically loaded structures.
These properties are illustrated by the hyperbola shown in fig. 2. The slope of any line joining the or~ginto a point on the hyperbola gives the value of up for that particular value of w . The slope doldp of the hyperbola at that point is the group velocity v , which, in most cases, is also equal to the energy velocity ( ' -r a deeper insight into this relationship, see Brillouin [1960]). As seen, the group velocity is lower than the velocity of light but as up approaches c from above, u, approaches c from below. As a result, the value of E for a given power input P is relatively low since E 2 is proportional to Plv,. Both these disadvantages lead n t~ rally to the concept of the periodic structure of fig. Ic. It can be seen intu e!y thp the p: iodic obstacles are small, their effect on the fields will be negligible ,ept n -n the guide half-wavelength or a multiple thereof becomes equal to the c .k spac rlg and reflections from successive obstacles add to create a series of sto land* ~ ~ h i are rh
44
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
separated by pass-bands. This causes the hyperbola to have breaks and to fold over as a function of frequency so that v,+O at the boundaries of the pass-bands. As the apertures of the disks become smaller, the stop-bands become wider and the passbands narrower. Intersection of the v p = c line with the lowest pass-band of the w-p diagram can be made to occur where desired. As an example, for a frequency corresponding to a disk spacing d of /1/4 (n/2 phase shift per period) as shown in fig. Ic, the axial field configuration is between a sine wave and a square wave. This field configuration matches the periodic boundary conditions and thus can be Fourier analyzed in terms of space harmonics (sometimes called Hartree harmonics) of relative amplitudes an where n is an integer between - co and co. It can be shown (e.g., see Chu [1951]) that the total E, field in the lowest pass-band can be expressed as
+
where p,=p, + 2nn/d, p, is the propagation constant of the fundamental space harmonic and kfn= k 2 - p:. That these relations hold is a direct consequence of field analysis and of Floquet's Theorem which states that "for a given mode of propagation at a given steady-state frequency, the fields at one cross-section differ from those one period away by only a complex constant." (For a comprehensive discussion, see for example, Watkins [1958].) There are several interesting results which may be obtained from eq. (4). One is that the phase shift per period for the fundamental or n=O space harmonic is pod and that the phase shift per period of any other space harmonic differs from Pod by an integral number of 2n. Thus a _ , , the term which usually has the second largest amplitude, has a phase shift P-,d=p,d-2n and a,,, the term with the third largest amplitude has a value fl+,d=Pod+2n, etc. The successive harmonics are represented by the continuous (solid line) branches shown in fig. 2. At a given frequency w,, the slopes of all these branches are equal. This means that all space harmonics propagate with the same group velocity, dwldp, for a given w,. Each harmonic, however, has a different phase velocity and only one, generally a,, is made synchronous with the electrons and acts cumulatively during the acceleration process. Design optimization of a given structure then consists, among other considerations, in choosing the value of Bod (i.e., 2n/n, where n is the number of disks per wavelength) giving the highest axial field strength for a given input power, and in enhancing the value of a, with respect to all other harmonics, i.e., maximizing the expression a i / x a:. This point will be elaborated further in § 8. Another important result obtainable from eq. (4) is that for a given direction of power propagation, say from left to right, the negative branches ( r = ~ . .., - 3, - 2, - 1) have positive group velocity like the positive branches, but their phase velocities up, are of opposite sign. The n=O branch for the standard disk-loaded waveguide has a propagation from right to left.)
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
45
Structures of this kind where the group and phase velocities for n=O are of the same sign are called forward-wave structures. When the group and phase velocities have opposite signs, they are called backward-wave structures. Forward-wave structures result when the coupling from cell to cell is predominantly electric whereas the coupling for backward-wave structures is predominantly magnetic. As already mentioned, practically all existing electron linacs are of the metal disk-loaded type. However, many other types of structures, both of the forward- and backward-wave type, have been proposed and studied. Some of them are shown in fig. 3. I n summary, even though these structures may present some advantages, none of them have so far proven to be as practicable as the metal disk-loaded waveguide. Another important feature which results from eq. (4) is that when the fundamental harmonic (n=O) is traveling at v , = c , P o = k and kro=O. As a result, J , ( k r o r ) is independent of r and E, has no radial variation. Hence, even for a beam of finite radial dimensions, all electrons are subjected to the same accelerating field and the final energy spectrum is not deteriorated. Referring to fig. 2, it should also be emphasized that there are a n infinity of passbands and stop-bands (only two pass-bands are shown). Some of the higher bands can be traced to branches of the TM,, modes, others to the TE,, modes, and many are actually of the hybrid "HEM" type. These modes are not used for acceleration but they can have very detrimental effects on beam transmission for medium and high current machines. For example, the backward-wave H E M , , mode shown here can be coupled to the beam and amplified, resulting in transverse beam breakup of either the regenerative or cumulative types. These effects are discussed in detail in ch. B. 1.4. The field configurations discussed so far have assumed a steady-state travelingwave with negligible attenuation. More generally, it can be shown that if a structure of length I with input at z = 0 is made resonant by a n appropriate shorting plane at z = / , there will be a n infinity of successive internal reflections. Assuming a reflection coefficient Q for all waves bouncing back inside the structure* at z=O and summing all forward traveling terms of the form exp ( j (cot --P,z) - r z ) and backward traveling terms of the form exp ( j [ o t - P, (I- z) - P,I] - a / - cc (1- z)) where a is the attenuation per unit length, one obtains a steady-state standing-wave field profile of the form n-
Esw
+ oo
C
=
[(2a, ejWt-"')/(I - ~ e - ~ " ' )cosh ] [a ( 1
-
z) + jpn(l - z)] .
(5)
n+-m
It can be recognized that when al=O and n+
ESW =
Q
=0, this expression reduces to
+m
1
2an cos cot cos /In(1 - Z)
n--ao
which is the simple expression for a standing wave in a matched traveling-wave structure which has been shorted a t the end. O n the other hand, it can be shown that
*
Conversely, an incoming wave incident onto the structure at z = 0 will also see a reflection coefficient Q and the transmitted fraction will be proportional to (1 - e2)t
46
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
for a given value of al, the standing-wave structure is critically coupled if the value of Q is adjusted to be equal to e-2a', in which case expression (5) becomes n+
ESW= (1 - e-4a1)-
+ a,
C n+
2a, ejm'-"' cosh [a (1 - z)
+ jpn(1 - z)] .
(7)
- a,
As will be seen later, this expression can be useful in gaining an understanding of standing-wave and superconducting structures. FORWARD-WAVE STRUCTURES
I. DISK-LOADED STRUCTURE
2. VENTILATED STRUCTURE
3. CENTIPEDE STRUCTURE
4. RECTANGULAR SLAB
BACKWARD -WAVE
S.'>UNGLE GYM"
7. RING 8 BAR STRUCTURE
STRUCTURES
6. SLOTTED DISK STRUCTURE
8. LOADED EASITRON
Fig. 3. Periodic structures proposed for electron linacs.
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
47
Before concluding this discussion, it should be recalled that, in principle, there are other methods by which the phase velocity in a waveguide can be reduced to the velocity of light. An obvious technique is to incorporate a continuous cylindrical sleeve of dielectric inside the waveguide until v,=c (see, for example, Flesher and Cohn [1951]). The main disadvantage of this solution is that the field concentration then takes place in the dielectric and not along the beam axis. Another disadvantage is that the internal surface of the ceramic must be covered with a thin metallic coat in order to prevent electron collection on the walls. This disadvantage is also inherent in the periodic ceramic structure first proposed by R.-Shersby-Harvie [I9481 and more recently elaborated by Walker and West [1957].
3 Principal design parameters In this paragraph, the principal parameters which are useful in the design of electron linear accelerators will be defined and briefly discussed. These parameters will be needed in the following sections of this chapter which treat various types of electron linear accelerators. Shunt impedance. The shunt impedance per unit length is the characteristic which measures the excellence of a structure as an accelerator. It will be designated here by the symbol r, and is defined as follows:
where E,, is the amplitude of the space harmonic component of the axial electric field of the wave having a phase velocity equal to and in the same direction as the electron being accelerated and dP/dz is the rf power dissipated per unit length in the structure. Thus, a high value of shunt impedance per unit length is desirable since it means that a high accelerating field can be obtained with a given expenditure of rf power per unit length. As discussed later in 5 8, the measurement of r, takes into account the fact that there are an infinite number of space harmonics in the accelerator structure, only one of which (or two, exceptionally, in the case of the n-mode) travels at the electron velocity and produces useful acceleration over a n extended length. The other space harmonics merely perturb the motion of the electrons as they pass through the accelerator and produce no net effect. However, these harmonics are necessary to satisfy the boundary conditions in the accelerator structure. The factor of merit Q. The "unloaded"* Q is a measure of the merit of an rf cavity as a resonator. It is defined as the ratio of the energy stored in the cavity to the energy lost due to rf dissipation in the cavity per radian of the rf cycle. Since both of these quantities are increased by the same factor if several identical cavities are
* On the other hand, the "loaded" Q, QL, is the effective Q of the cavity considering the added losses due to coupling to external systems and due to beam loading.
48
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
considered together, the definition of Q which is convenient in linear accelerator design may be written: where w is the rf energy stored per unit length, dP/dz is the rf power loss per unit length and o is the angular frequency of the rf power. The ratio ro/Q. This is a very basic parameter in microwave cavities and structures. It may be obtained from eqs. (8) and (9): ro/Q = ~ & / w w .
(10)
Thus, ro/Q is seen to be a measure of the square of the electric field in the structure in terms of the energy stored per unit length of the structure. Since w, the energy stored per unit length is proportional to E& times the crosssectional area of the structure (which is proportional to &'), it is evident from eq. (10) that Thus, for an accelerator structure having a particular geometrical configuration, ro/Q depends only on the operating frequency. The dimensions of the structure are, of course, scaled as o-'.At a given operating frequency, the magnitude of r,/Q is independent of the choice of material from which the cavity is fabricated and of the surface finish of the cavity walls. Group velocity. As discussed in 5 2, the group velocity, v,, is the velocity at which rf energy flows through the accelerator. The group velocity, u,, depends strongly upon the ratio of the diameter, 2a, of the disk aperture to the diameter, 26, of the accelerator cavity. An approximate formula for the normalized group velocity is
where c is the velocity of light and K is a constant depending upon the number of disks per wavelength and the disk thickness and configuration. Group velocity is an important accelerator parameter for three reasons: 1. The "filling time", i.e., the time required to fill the accelerator with rf energy, depends upon the group velocity. For a simple traveling-wave accelerator of length I, the filling time is just l/v,. A high value of group velocity is preferred from the viewpoints of minimizing the time the rf pulse must be on, and of minimizing the transient time due to beam loading (see ch. B.1.3). 2. The power flowing in the structure and the energy stored per unit length of the structure are inter-related through the group velocity as follows:
Since, as previously discussed, w is proportional to E;,, it is clear that a low value of v, is preferred from the viewpoint of obtaining maximum accelerating fields for a given power flow.
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
49
3. As will be shown in 9 4 and Q: 8, the values of r,, Q , and r,/Q depend upon the choice of u, for the accelerator structure. In general, decreasing u, results in an increase in r,, a decrease in Q and thus a n increase in r,/Q. Therefore, a low value of u, is preferred from the viewpoint of obtaining high values of r, and r,/Q. The above considerations indicate that the choice of the group velocity, u,, must be a compromise depending upon the particular requirements of the accelerator being designed. This subject will be discussed further in Q: 4. Frequency. Almost all of the basic accelerator parameters have frequency dependence. The choice of frequency is therefore one of the first and most important tasks when undertaking the design of a new accelerator. Some of the significant considerations in the selection of the operating frequency are as follows: 1. It is desirable that the shunt impedance per unit length, r,, be high so that the amount of rf power required for a given energy gain will not be excessive. The dependence of r , on frequency may be determined using the defining relation, eq. (8). The rf power loss per unit length is proportional to the product of the square of the wall current and the wall resistance, R, per unit length, i.e.,
The axial electric field is proportional to the wall current divided by the radius b of the accelerator structure, i.e.,
and the wall resistance R per unit length is equal to the resistivity Q of the wall material divided by the area of the surface through which the current is flowing. Thus,
where 6 is the skin depth which is given by
and p is the permeability of the walls. Combining the last 4 equations with eq. (8) and noting that h ~ o - 'yield the result
Thus, from the viewpoint of conserving rf power, the operating frequency should be chosen to be as high as practicable. However, since the rf power from available single sources drops off more rapidly with frequency than r, increases with frequency, it is not likely that extremely high frequencies will be advantageous. 2. The diameter of the aperture in the accelerator structure through which the electron ; thus, lower frequencies are preferred from the beam is transmitted varies as 6' viewpoint of accelerating beams through a long accelerator with minimum interception.
50
G.A.LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
3. In some applications, it is desired to obtain very intense (high power) electron beams at a given energy. The use of lower frequencies makes more rf power and stored energy available for conversion to beam power. 4. From scaling arguments, it can be shown that the filling time in an optimized accelerator varies as This is an inducement to use a design frequency as high as practicable to increase the fraction of the rf pulse length available for accelerating electrons. 5. The relative dimensional and frequency tolerances, 6qlq and 6 o / o which must be held in the fabrication and operation of the accelerator are proportional to mi, while the absolute values of 6 q and 6 2 are proportional to o*.Since the degree of difficulty in meeting frequency and fabricational requirements is usually a function of the relative rather than the absolute tolerances, the higher operating frequency ranges are preferred from this point of view. (See Chodorow et al. [1955].) From the above considerations it is obvious that the choice of frequency is not simple or clear-cut. The choice is usually based upon obtaining the best balance among technical and cost factors. As noted in 9 1, virtually all electron linear accelerators built to date have operated at design frequencies between 700 and 10000 MHz. The largest number have been designed to operate at frequencies near 3 000 MHz. Operating mode. As discussed in 9 8, the shunt impedance ro depends not only upon the operating frequency but also upon the operating mode which is defined as the phase shift per cavity of the accelerating structure. Thus, the operating mode is given by
where n is the number of disks per guide wavelength. For ease of measurement, n is usually chosen to be an integral value. Most electron linear accelerators have been designed for n = 2 , 3, or 4 , i.e., for @,=IT, 27113, or 7112. As will be noted in 9 8, the optimumvalue of n decreases as the disk thickness increases. A value of n = 3 ( @ , = 27113) is about optimum for accelerator structures having practical geometries. Attenuation constant. The variation of electric-field strength and rf power flow in an accelerator structure is given by
and
where a ( z ) is the attenuation in nepers per unit length. From eqs. (20) and (21), it follows that the electric field strength and the power flowing in the accelerator at a point distant z from the input are given by
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
51
and z
where E, and Po are the values of electric field and power at the input (z=O). The attenuation constant, z, is defined as the one-way attenuation, expressed in nepers, in an accelerator structure of length I. By this definition,
In a structure of uniform modular dimensions (constant impedance), a is constant thro~~ghout and z = cxl.
(25)
The magnitude of cx is a strong function of the diameter of the disk aperture. Increasing the aperture diameter increases the group velocity and decreases a. Thus, the desired value of z can be obtained by proper selection of the aperture diameter and the distance, I, between feeds. The shunt impedance per unit length, r,, varies slowly with the aperture diameter; thus, it is clear from eqs. (8) and (21) that the electric field strength Eo, varies approximately as (2aP)i. For a given power flow P, IdPldzl can be made large by designing for a high value of a. However, too high a value of a will result in excessive attenuation of the power and thus low fields in the output end of the structure. Too low a value of a will result in low fields throughout and excessive loss of power at the output end of the accelerator (assuming a resistive termination is used). A compromise value of z is clearly required to optimize the electron energy gain in the traveling-wave accelerator structure. The determination of the optimum value of z will be discussed further in Q: 4. Rf pulse length and repetition rate. In many physics applications, it is desirable to have as large a value of beam duty cycle (defined as the product of beam pulse length and pulse repetition rate) as possible in order to improve experimental statistics. The maximum practical value of the beam duty cycle is determined by economic considerations. The rf duty cycle D r f must be larger than the beam duty cycle D B in order to allow time for filling the accelerator with rf energy during each pulse before the electron beam is injected. The ratio of beam to rf duty cycles is given by
where tF and t,, are the filling time and rf pulse length, respectively. For a given beam duty cycle, the required rf duty cycle is obviously reduced by making the filling time as small as practicable.
52
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
From eq. (26) it follows that
Thus, a fractional increase in the rf duty cycle permits an even larger fractional increase in the beam duty cycle. Most electron linear accelerators constructed to date have beam duty cycles between 5 x lo-' and 5 x However, conventional electron linear accelerators with duty cycles of 2% (at 350 MeV) and 5.8 % (at 220 MeV) are now under construction at the Centre d7Etudes NuclCaires de Saclay (France) (Sokolovsky [1966], Leboutet et a]. [1966]) and at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (USA) (Bertozzi et al. [1967]), respectively. A similar accelerator with a duty cycle of 10% (at 250 MeV) is being planned at the Instituut Voor Kernphysisch Onderzoek (Holland) (De Vries [1967]). All three of these machines will be capable of 50 to 100% higher energies when operating at reduced duty cycles. The superconducting electron accelerator discussed in 5 6 and more completely in ch. E.2 has, in principle, sufficiently low rf losses that a duty cycle approaching unity should be feasible. In fact, the promise of high duty cycle at high energies is the main reason for interest in this type of accelerator.
4 Traveling-wave accelerators
,
In the standing-wave accelerator, there is two-way propagation of waves while in the traveling-wave accelerator the wave propagates only one way. In most of the machines which have been constructed to date, the rf structure has served the dual purpose of waveguide and accelerator. This arrangement is mainly a matter of simplicity and economy. It should be remarked that a traveling-wave accelerator does not necessarily dmply power flow along the accelerator. One can construct a traveling-wave acceler,{' ator with isolated, separately fed cavities. In a strict sense, the distinction between the traveling-wave and standing-wave accelerators is whether the fields have only a ej(wt-Bz)or ej(wt+pz) dependence as in the traveling-wave case or a superposition of both of these forms as in the standing-wave case. Nevertheless, because of its obvious advantages, the combined accelerator-waveguide structure has been and will likely remain the most popular form of linear accelerating device for electrons. It is to this type of accelerator that consideration will be given here. Constant impedance accelerator. The traveling-wave accelerator case where the power transferred to the electron beam is negligibly small compared to the rf losses in the walls of the accelerating structure will now be considered. Beam loading in linacs is discussed in ch. B. 1.3. Assume that an amount of rf power Po is introduced at the input of a travelingwave accelerator. If the structure is properly designed, the power will propagate through the structure with a phase velocity equal to the electron velocity which, over
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
53
most of the accelerator length, is essentially the velocity of light. In the discussion which follows, a uniform (constant impedance) rf structure in which the fundamental space harmonic travels a t the velocity of light will, for simplicity, be assumed. From the definition of Q [eq. (9)] and from the relationship between P, kt3, and v, [eq. (13)], the power loss per unit length, the power flow, and the electric field equations may be written:
The above formulations are convenient since w, v,, and Q are parameters which can be readily measured in test cavities as discussed in 5 8. Comparing eqs. (21) and (28), it is noted that
The energy gained by a n electron situated a t a n angle 6 with respect to the crest of the traveling wave can be obtained by integrating eq. (30) over the accelerator length, 1. The result is
V
=
Eol [(I
-
eCr)/z] cos 0
(32)
where T = x l is the total rf attenuation in nepers in the accelerator structure. Using eqs. (8) and (28), eq. (32) may be written completely in terms of measurable quantities:
v = (~T)"(I
- e-')/TI (~,r,l)+ cosO
(33)
where Po is the input rf power. Equation (33) shows that the energy gain depends upon the attenuation parameter, T, which for a fixed accelerator length is a strong function of the aperture diameter of the loading disks in the accelerator structure. Since ro varies very slowly with cavity dimensions, it may be regarded as constant when the energy gain V in eq. (33) is maximized with respect to T. The condition for maximum energy gain is found to be:
which is satisfied for
With this optimum value of T, the energy gain from eq. (33) becomes:
From eq. (36), one would expect that as long as x is decreased to maintain T = 1.26, the energy would increase as l*. However, since r , decreases with increasing v, (i.e.,
54
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
with decreasing a), the energy of the optimized accelerator increases less rapidly than l3 for fixed power input. The dependence of r, upon v,/c is shown in fig. 4. The quantity v/[(P,~,I)~ cos01 from eq. (33) is shown vs. z in fig. 5. The maximum is observed to be quite broad so that it is not necessary to design exactly for z = 1.26 to obtain good results. A lower value of z is preferable in most cases for beam loading considerations (see ch. B.1.3), to reduce filling time, and to relax frequency and dimensional tolerances. It is instructive to calculate what would be gained in energy by extending an optimized accelerator to an infinite length. As 1 becomes very large and M is main-
I
I
I
0.1
0.2
0.3
0 0
0.4
vg/c
Fig. 4. Dependence of shunt impedance per unit length, ro, upon the normalized group velocity v g / c measured for 4 2 mode; 6 is the skin depth.
1
0
~
0.2
1
0.4
~
0.6
0.8
1
1.0
~
1.2
1
1.4
~
1.6
1
1.8
~
2.0
r
Fig. 5. Normalized energy gain in a constant impedance traveling-wave accelerator versus attenuation parameter z.
1
~
1
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
55
tained constant, assuming cosd = 1, eq. (33) becomes:
so that
Thus, the electron energy would be increased only 39% by increasing the length of the optimized accelerator to infinity. Filling time. Using the definition of the attenuation parameter, z = wl/2vgQ,the time required to fill the constant impedance accelerator with rf energy is given by
Thus, the filling time of an accelerator optimized in accordance with eq. (35) is
Energy stored in accelerator. The total amount of rf energy contained in the accelerator, W, at the end of the filling time may be obtained by integrating the energy stored per unit length w [eq. (13)] over the length 1 of the accelerator using eq. (29),
The ratio W/Pot,is the fraction of the input rf energy which remains available in the accelerator after the filling time to accelerate electrons. This ratio shown in fig. 6 vs. z
T Fig. 6. Fraction of the input rf energy remaining in the traveling-wave accelerator structure at the end of the filling time.
56
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
is the upper limit of the conversion efficiency from rf energy to electron beam energy. At T = 1.26, W/P,t, is 0.36. It is clear that, where energy conversion efficiency is the primary criterion, lower values of T are indicated. This will become even more evident when the subject of beam loading is discussed in ch. B. 1.3. Feedback of rf power. During the early British work on linear electron accelerators, a method was proposed by R.-Shersby-Harvie and Mullett [I9491 which provided for feedback of the residual rf power from the end of the accelerator and combination of this power in suitable phase relationship with the input power from the rf source by means of a waveguide bridge circuit. In this manner, the rf power entering the accelerator can be increased t o a value above that available from the source. The principle of rf power feedback is shown in fig. 7. An rf bridge is used to combine the power P, from the external power source with the power fed back from the end of the accelerator. The combined power is then fed into the accelerator. The
4 @
POWER
'4
RESISTIVE LOAD
RF BRIDGE
SOURCE
2's
&PHASE SHIFTER \
Po= P s ( I + g )
II
I
ACCELERATOR
Fig. 7. Schematic diagram illustrating feedback principle. Relations shown represent steady state conditions with correct bridge ratio.
bridge ratio, which will be designated by the symbol g, is defined as the ratio of the powers which the bridge is designed to combine. When the ratio of the feedback power to the source power is equal to the bridge ratio, g, and when the feedback phase is properly adjusted, the power input to the accelerator will be (1 +g) times the source power and the power to the external load will be zero. For example, if the bridge ratio is unity and if the power entering the accelerator is attenuated to one-half by the time it recirculates to the bridge, the steady state power entering the accelerator will be twice the source power. Steady state conditions are not attained instantaneously. Initially, the source power, P,, entering the bridge is divided, a fraction, 1/(1 +g), going to the accelerator and a fraction, g/(l +g), going to the external load. The residual power at the end of the accelerator is combined in the bridge with the source power. With proper phase relations, the result will be an increase in the amount of power entering the accelerator and a decrease in the amount entering the external load. As the recirculation of power proceeds, the power to the accelerator will continue to increase and the power to the
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
57
load will continue to decrease until steady state conditions are reached. When this occurs, the power to the accelerator will be greater than the source power by a factor which depends upon the attenuation in the feedback loop and upon the bridge ratio. If the attenuation in the accelerator structure (including beam loading) and feedback loop is such that the feedback power is equal to the input power, Po divided by x2,(where x23 I ) , then it is clear from fig. 7 that the bridge ratio, g , which will cause the steady state power to the resistive load to be zero is given by
P,(1 + g ) l x 2 = g p , or y = 1/(s2- I ) .
When the condition specified by eq. (42) is met, the steady state power build-up ratio in the accelerator will be
From eq. (43), it is noted that a large build-up ratio results when x2 is small (close to I), i.e., when a large fraction of the input rf power is fed back to the bridge. A graph of POIPSvs. 1 / x 2is shown in fig. 8. I n the same figure, the fractions of the source power which are fed to the accelerator and to the resistive load are shown when the bridge ratio, g , is unity. Comparison of these curves shows that a simple bridge of
Fig. 8. Power build-up ratio vs. fraction of accelerator input power fed back to bridge. Cases shown
are for ideal bridge ratio [y = I/(x2- I ) ] and for unity bridge ratio ( g = 1).
58
G.A.LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
ratio g = 1 can be used over a considerable range of loop attenuation without serious decrease in power build-up. For this reason, the majority of accelerators using the feedback principle have employed bridges of unity ratio. Examples of bridges which have unity ratios are the standard rectangular waveguide "magic tee", the ringcircuit "magic tee", and the short slot hybrid coupler. A bridge having a ratio which is adjustable by a simple mechanical motion (known as the "circular magic tee") was used (Bareford and Kelliher 119531) with the 15 MeV accelerator constructed by Mullard Research Laboratories and installed in 1952 at the British Atomic Energy Research Establishment at Harwell. An adjustable bridge of this type is useful in maintaining maximum accelerator performance over a wide range of beam loading. The use of such a device, however, increases the complexities of accelerator construction and operation. The power build-up in the accelerator with feedback is a stepwise process with intervals between steps equal to the loop transit time. If the ideal bridge ratio given by eq. (42) is used, the build-up process requires a larger number of transits through the loop as the bridge ratio g is increased (and loop attenuation decreased). The number of transits required to build up to a given fraction of the steady state value is roughly proportional to g. For example, when g = 1 (x=2*), the power builds up to 75% of the steady state value after two transits through the loop, whereas when g =4 [ x = (1.25)"], eight transits are required to build up to the 75% level. The actual time to build up the circulating power is roughly independent of the bridge ratio since the transit time decreases as g increases (and x decreases) because of the increased value of group velocity in the accelerator structure. If a bridge of fixed ratio is used, the number of transits required to reach a given fraction of the steady state value is roughly proportional to l / x Z .The transient behavior of POIPSfor a system employing a unity ratio bridge is shown in fig. 9 for three values of x.
NUMBER OF TRANSITS
Fig. 9. Percent of maximum power build-up vs. number of transits around feedback loop. Bridge ratio g = 1 in all cases. Different values of loop attenuation for each curve.
B.1.1
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
59
If the attenuation in the accelerator with feedback is due mainly to rf wall losses, i.e., there is negligible beam loading, the build-up ratio given in eq. (43) can be expressed as
The energy gain can then be obtained by inserting eq. (44) into eq. (33), i.e., (omitting the cos 8 term) :
When z approaches zero, the first term in eq. (45) approaches unity, which is its maximum value. This should be compared with the coefficient of 0.903 given in eq. (36) for the optimum single feed case. Actually, the single feed case without feedback compares more favorably than indicated in the example just given. In the process of making the attenuation parameter r very small, it is necessary to open up the aperture, thereby increasing the group velocity, v,; this causes r,, the shunt impedance per unit length, to decrease as shown in fig. 4 so that the net effect of using small z and feedback may actually be a loss in beam energy compared to the optimized single feed case. On the other hand, at the optimum single feed value of z = 1.26, the use of feedback would change the value of the coefficient in the energy equation from 0.903 to 0.941, an increase of 4%. This relatively small improvement would be obtained by incurring the additional expense and operational complexity resulting from the provision of extra waveguide components in the feedback loop, including the power combining bridge, phase shifters, etc. The above discussion shows that there is little advantage from the viewpoint of energy gain in employing feedback. A more involved analysis leads to the same conclusion in the beam loaded case. The main incentive which led the early British workers to the use of feedback was the less restrictive frequency, temperature, and dimensional tolerances resulting from the lower value of z which is permitted when feedback is employed. This can be understood by the following simple argument. The number of rf cycles introduced into the accelerator structure during the filling time is given by the frequency times the filling time, i.e., n=ft,. A frequency shift 6f (or equivalent temperature or dimensional error) will result in a change 6n in the number of entering cycles, i.e., 6n = t , 6f. But according to eq. (39), t , = 2Qz/cc,; thus, the resulting phase shift in the wave at z = l is
Since the phase shifter in the feedback loop can be adjusted to give optimum input phase conditions, the phase error in the feedback loop does not build up during the many transits around the loop beyond the value given by eq. (46). As an example, compare an accelerator with feedback with z=0.126 with the optimized single feed
60
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
accelerator with r = 1.26. Assume further that v,/c = 0.1 and 0.01, respectively. According to eq. (46), the accelerator without feedback must control the frequency (and associated temperature and dimensional tolerances) 10 times more accurately than the feedback accelerator to maintain beam energy to the same accuracy. For T =0.126 in the feedback case, the coefficient in eq. (45) is very close to unity compared to 0.903 in the case without feedback. However, as may be noted from fig. 4, the value of r, is reduced in the feedback case by about 40% compared to the value in the case without feedback. The net result, in this example, is that the accelerator with feedback has about 90% of the energy of the accelerator without feedback. Feedback found its main use in comparatively short single feed accelerators used for medical and radiographic purposes and employing relatively unstable magnetron oscillators as the power source. Because of the additional mechanical and operational complexities, it has rarely been used in machines having more than a single feed. In recent years, the use of klystron amplifiers fed by frequency-stabilized rf driver systems, the development of more precise fabricational and tuning techniques for accelerator structures, and the employment of accurate temperature stabilized cooling systems have made the use of feedback techniques unnecessary and undesirable. Possibly, the advent of cryogenic accelerators with their inherent low rf losses will again cause accelerator designers to turn to feedback principles. However, at this time, the use of standing-wave structures seems to be favored in the prototype cryogenic machines. (See chs. E.2 and E.3.) The constant gradient accelerator. Because of its uniform modular cross section, the rf power and electric field in a constant impedance accelerator decay exponentially with distance z as shown in eqs. (29) and (30). The electric field is plotted versus zll in the sloping curve of fig. 10. The maximum electric field, which occurs at z=0, is higher than the average field along the length of the structure by a factor which depends upon the value of the attenuation parameter z. This situation can be demon-
Fig. 10. Electric field strength versus normalized distance z/l in constant impedance and constant gradient accelerator structures. r = 0.57.
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
16
strated by a simple rearrangement of eq. (32) as follows (dropping the cosO term):
E o / ( V i l )= T/(I - eCT).
(47)
The ratio of peak to average electric field is shown in fig. 1 1 . By suitable variation of the transverse modular dimensions, it is feasible to design a n accelerator in which the axial electric fields are essentially constant along the length of the structure. This type of structure is called a constant gradient accelerator. By definition, the ratio of peak to average electric field in this structure is unity as shown in fig. 1 1 . The basis for the design of a constant gradient accelerator is provided by
-r =
WtF/20
Fig. 1 I . Ratio of peak to average electric fields in constant gradient accelerator structures.
eq. (8). Since, as noted previously, r , changes but slowly with the modular dimensions of the structure, it can be regarded as a constant.* Then the requirement for constant gradient along the structure becomes dP/dz
= constant.
(48)
Thus, if the rf power input to the accelerator is P, and the power escaping from the accelerator at z = I is P,, then the requirement of eq. (48) is satisfied if the power flow
*
The final results can be corrected for the minor variation of electric field due to the variation in
r,,, if desired. However, it should be noted that the variation of modular dimensions calculated on the assumption of constant ro actually is such as to cause ro to increase slowly with increasing z.
This causes a slight increase in the axial field strength with z at zero beam loading. With a small amount of beam loading, the fields then become nearly constant throughout the accelerator length.
G.A. LOEW, R.B. NEAL
62
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
in the accelerator is given by P = Po - (Po - P,) 211.
(49)
With the substitution, P,/Po =e-2', eq. (49) becomes
Two equivalent expressions for dP/dz may be obtained from eqs. (49) and (50):
and
While the power dissipated per unit length, dP/dz, in a constant gradient structure is constant over the length of the structure, dP/dz is far from being constant in the constant impedance structure, as shown by eqs. (28) and (29). In fact, the ratio of power loss at the input end to that at the output end of an optimized (z= 1.26) constant impedance structure is about 12 to 1. Such a large variation of power dissipation complicates the problem of maintaining the temperature constant over the entire accelerator structure. Variation of group velocity. Eliminating dP/dz between eqs. (28) and (52), substituting eq. (50) for P, and solving for v, yields:
Eq. (53) shows the required variation in v, to produce a constant gradient characteristic. It may be noted from eqs. (50) and (53) that P and v, decrease in the same linear manner and by the same ratio between z = 0 and z = I. Filling time. The filling time of the constant gradient accelerator may be found by integrating dt=dz/u, between the limits 0 and 1 using eq. (53) for v,:
Comparing eqs. (39) and (54), one notes that the filling times of the constant impedance and the constant gradient accelerators are equal if the two machines are designed to have the same values of the attenuation parameter, z. Energy stored. The energy stored in the accelerator structure at the end of the filling time may be obtained by integrating w =Plugfrom z = 0 to z = 1 using eqs. (50) and (53) for P and v,, and eq. (54). The result is:
A comparison of eqs. (41) and (55) shows that the stored energies in the constant
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
63
impedance and constant gradient accelerators are also equal when both have the same attenuation parameter, 7. While the simple expression 7 = ccl is suitable to define s in the constant impedance accelerator since cc is constant throughout, it is not suitable in the constant gradient case where cc varies with z. A more general definition suitable for both types of accelerators is given by eqs. (39) and (54): 7 =
wtF/2Q
(56)
where it is assumed that Q is the "average" value in each structure. Like r,, Q in the constant gradient structure varies slowly with the cavity dimensions and it is usually satisfactory to regard it as constant. Electric Jield strength and energy gain. The axial field strength in the constant gradient accelerator may be obtained using eqs. (8) and (52). It is given by E
=
[(I
-
eC2') P,r,/l]*
(57)
and is constant throughout the accelerator length (for negligible beam loading). The energy gain is obtained by integrating the electric field over the accelerator length, I.e., V = [(I - e-") ~ , r , l ] + .
(58)
A comparison of the unloaded energies of theconstant impedance accelerator [eq. (33)] and the constant gradient accelerator [eq. (58)] is shown in fig. 12 vs. s. It may be noted that the energy gain in the constant gradient accelerator is slightly higher than that of the constant impedance accelerator for all values of 7 but the advantage is greater for the higher values of s. Other characteristics of the constant gradient accelerator with negligible beam loading are given by Neal [1953]. Beam loading in the constant gradient accelerator is studied by Neal [I9581 and a comparison of the constant gradient and constant impedance accelerators under beam loading conditions is given by Neal [1961]. Design details of the constant gradient sections of the Stanford two-mile electron linear accelerator are given by Borghi et a/. [1966]. Several other advantages of the constant gradient structure are discussed in the above references. Among its advantages, not yet mentioned, relative to the constant impedance structure, are its lower sensitivity to frequency deviations, its higher maximum conversion efficiency (ratio of maximum electron beam power to input rf power), its lower beam-loading derivative, and its decreased susceptibility to beam breakup phenomena (see ch. B. 1.4). Multiplefeed accelerator. Because of the limited amount of power available from a single rf source and the impossibility of extending the accelerator length indefinitely, all electron linacs with output energies above about 50 MeV have used multiple feeds. Indeed, many lower energy accelerators designed for heavy beam loading are provided with multiple feeds. The multiple feed accelerator is usually comprised of N identical
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
61
single feed accelerators in tandem, each fed by an identical rf power source. From either eq. (33) or eq. (58) the energy gain from one of these single feed sections may be written V
=
K (~,r,2)+
(59)
where K is a function of z. When N of these sections are joined in proper phase to form a single accelerator, the total energy gain V;. is given by V,
=NK
where P, length.
( ~ , r , l ) += K [(NP,) r, ( N l ) l t
= NP,
=K
(P,J-,L)+
(60)
is the total input rf power and L = NI is the total effective accelerator
CONSTANT
GRADIENT
CONSTANT IMPEDANCE STRUCTURE
Fig. 12. Comparison of the unloaded energies of the constant impedance and the constant gradient structures versus T = WIF/ZQ.
From eq. (60), it is clear that a given total energy V, can be obtained from an accelerator having a shunt impedance per unit length r , for a specific product of total power P, and total length L. For example, a high total power and a short length, or conversely, a low total power and a long length may be used. The values of P, and L are usually chosen on the basis of economic considerations. In general, minimum total cost results when the cost associated with supplying rf power is equal to the cost associated with providing the accelerator length. In some machines such as the SLAC two-mile accelerator, a low power to length ratio has purposely been chosen (Borghi ~t al. 119661) in the initial design in order to provide for later increase in energy by adding more power sources along the length. Fortunately, the curve of cost vs.
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
65
power/length is flat enough that little penalty is paid for a reasonable deviation from the optimum P,/L ratio. For a given total power P,, the selection of the number of individual power sources and the number of rf feeds depends upon several considerations: 1. As discussed previously, the shunt impedance per unit length, r , , is increased moderately as the group velocity is decreased. Therefore, closely spaced feeds which require low group velocity (high a ) structures are favored from the viewpoint of obtaining high shunt impedance. 2. It is generally more economical to provide a given total rf power from a small number of high power rf sources than from a large number of low power rf sources. The reason for this fact is that the cost of a microwave tube depends more strongly upon the number of steps required in its fabrication and processing than upon its physical size and power output. 3. If the feeds are too closely spaced, it may be necessary to split the power from each rf source (if the number of sources is chosen on the basis of consideration No. 2 above) into two or more parts. Such splitting leads to increased cost and complexity of the waveguide system. 4. A large number of feeds increases the costs of the instrumentation and control system and increases operation difficulties. 5. The accelerator aperture is decreased as the feed interval decreases for a fixed value of T. This may lead to problems with beam transmission through a long accelerator. Consideration (I) above favors a large number of feeds while considerations (2) to ( 5 ) favor a small number of feeds. The final choice of feed interval must be based upon a detailed study of economic and technical factors. Various accelerators have been designed with feed intervals ranging from about 1 to 10 meters.
5 Standing-~~ave accelerators Elementary considerations. The traveling-wave accelerator utilizes an axially nonresonant waveguide in the sense that the wave travels in only one direction. O n the other hand, the standing-wave accelerator makes use of a waveguide which is axially resonant so that there are waves traveling in two directions. In the simple travelingwave case, the accelerator waveguide can either be terminated with a matched resistive load or if the rf pulse length is not greater than twice the filling time (i.e., twice the time required for the wave to propagate the length of the section at the group velocity), the wave can simply be allowed to reflect from the end of the accelerator guide without affecting the performance of the accelerator or the power source. The fields in the traveling-wave accelerator may be considered as building up "in space" while those in the standing-wave accelerator build up "in time". In the traveling-wave case, the rf pulse must be on for a period of time to "fill" the accelerator with energy flowing
G.A. LOEW, R.B.NEAL
66
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
at the group velocity in the structure before the electron beam is turned on. Analogously, in the standing-wave accelerator, a period of time must be allowed for the fields to build up in the resonant structure to essentially equilibrium values before the electrons are injected. A simple example is helpful in gaining insight into the behavior of the standingwave accelerator. Consider an accelerator containing a forward wave with a fundamental space harmonic of amplitude A which has a phase velocity equal to the electron velocity and a backward wave with a fundamental space harmonic of amplitude B which has the same (but negative) phase velocity. For generality, it will be assumed that A f B , due, for example, to lossy conditions at the end of the structure. For simplicity, other space harmonics which have no net effect on the electron energy gain will be neglected. The two waves under consideration are then given by expressions of the form
E,
= A sin ( o t - Poz)
(61)
and When both of these waves are present, a standing wave which is a combination of E, and EB will be set up, i.e.,
E = E,
+ EB = ( A - B) (sin o t c o ~ / ? ~-z (A ) + B) (cos o t sin Poz).
(63) By differentiation of eq. (63), it can easily be shown that successive maxima and minima of the standing-wave pattern occur at one-quarter wavelength intervals along the length of the structure. They are given by
and are located at E,,,:
P,z
= (2n
+ 1) 7c/2
(66)
wheren=O, l , 2 , 3,.... Figures 13a and 13b show the forward and backward waves at successive points in time to, t,, t,, and t,. Figure 13c shows the combination of these waves forming a standing-wave pattern with maxima and minima given by eqs. (64) and (65) located at fixed values of pOzas given by eqs. (66) and (67). Now suppose that an electron traveling at essentially the velocity of light is injected into the accelerator in which the standing-wave field of eq. (63) exists. This electron will reach a point distant z from the input at a time Substituting eq. (68) into eq. (63) and integrating the resulting expression over the
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
67
accelerator length, I, yields the energy gain of the electron V
= A1
sin of, - Bl (sin Pol/Pol)[sin (Pol
+ wt,)] .
In order for the accelerator structure to be axially resonant, it is necessary that its length be an integral number of half-wavelengths, i.e., POI=Nn. With this substitution, eq. (69) becomes : Vs,
= A1
sin of,.
(70)
Maximum energy is obtained if the electron is injected into the accelerator when s h o t , = 1, i.e., at, = (4m l)n/2 where m = 0, 1, 2, 3,. . . . This situation is illustrated in fig. 13c. The electron is injected at a time to and a t
+
-
FORWARD WAVE
s--- BACKWARD WAVE
ELECTRON POSITIONS AT J , " . ' .
tn
tl
(2
FIELD ENVELOPE
t,
STANDING WAVE
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
0
TI2
7T
3T/2
2lT
5lT/2
37T
7T/2
I 87T
Poz
Fig. 13. (a) Combination of forward wave of amplitude A and, (b), backward wave of amplitude B in a n accelerator structure. The resultant standing-wave pattern is shown in (c). Successive points in time are indicated as t o , t ~t t,, ts. The standing wave has maxima of amplitude I A f BI and minima of amplitude \ A - BI at fixed positions as indicated. The average accelerating field amplitude is equal to A.
68
G.A. LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Poz=O and sees the field J A - B ( . At time t,, the electron has reached the point P,z=~1/2 and sees the field ( A + BJ. In general, the electron is subjected to the fields denoted by the top curve of fig. 13c which has an average value of A as shown in the figure and as given by eq. (70). From the above discussion, it is clear that only the wave having a phase velocity equal to and in the same direction as the accelerated electron contributes to the energy gain. The ratio of peak field in the structure to the average accelerating field is ( A + B)/A. In general, when A z B, this ratio is ~ 2 This . is a disadvantage when high accelerating fields are required because of the increased possibility of internal arcing. The use of the TC mode improves this situation somewhat because in this mode, all the cavities are fully excited and, as discussed later in this §, both the forward and backward traveling powers carry a space harmonic (n = 0 and n = - 1, respectively) which is synchronous with the electrons. In this case, the ratio is about 1.6 to 1. Steady-state operation. Consider further the simple traveling-wave structure with attenuation parameter z and assume that the wave is reflected at the output end. The resulting backward wave will return to the input end undergoing further attenuation in field strength by a factor e-" except in the TC mode, this backward wave is not useful in accelerating electrons in the forward direction. At the input end, the backward wave will be partially reflected and partially transmitted out through the input coupler toward the rf source. If the length of the accelerator section is an integral number of half-wavelengths, the wave reflected at the input end will have the correct phase to contribute to the acceleration of electrons. The above process of reflection at each end of the section will continue until equilibrium is reached. If the input coupler is correctly matched for this resonant condition, none of the backward power will, after steady state is reached, pass out through the input coupler toward the source; all of the input power will be absorbed in the structure. The general behavior is quite similar to that of the feedback accelerator discussed in $ 4 except that in this case the accelerator structure itself rather than an external feedback loop serves to return the residual rf power to the input end. Following the same reasoning used in the feedback case, the power build-up becomes
which is the expression analogous to eq. (44). The steady state energy gain is therefore given by a slightly modified form of eq. (49," i.e.,
+
where the symbols have the same meaning as before and where the (1 e-2T)-) term accounts for the attenuation of the wave going in the backward direction through the accelerator section.
* Equation (72)can also be obtained by integrating the expression for the field ESW given by eq. (7), using only the fundamental space harmonic. In this case a0 = (2aroPo)t and PO= (1 - Q ~ Ps ) where for critical coupling Q is adjusted to be equal to e-2az.
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
69
From eq. (72) it is obvious that the standing-wave accelerator gives a slightly higher energy gain than the corresponding structure used as a traveling-wave accelerator. However, this is accomplished only at the expense of a n increased filling time due to the required multiple reflections in the structure in the standing-wave case. The relative energy gain of these accelerator types will be further discussed later in this section. The limiting values of the energy gain in the standing-wave accelerator for very large and very small T are found from eq. (72) to be: V,,,
= (2~~r,l/.c)'
(73)
which, as expected, is the same as the limiting value of energy gain in the single feed case given by eq. (33), and Vr+,
= (Psrol/2)'.
(74)
Equation (74) states that, when the attenuation in the structure is very low, only one half the power from the source is effective in accelerating electrons (except in the n mode case); the other half is expended in maintaining the backward traveling wave which does not contribute to the energy gain. Shunt impedance and related design considerations. The value of the shunt impedance r, depends upon the mode of operation. As shown in 5 8, the maximum value of r, in a simple periodic disk-loaded structure operating as a traveling-wave accelerator occurs for a phase shift per cavity between rr/2 and 2n/3, the larger phase shift being favored as the disk thickness increases. When the structure is operated as a standing-wave accelerator, the number of space harmonics is doubled due to the presence of the backward wave. As the operating frequency approaches the upper cut-off frequency (n mode), the forward and backward space harmonics coalesce and the fields add in phase to give resultant fields with twice the amplitude of the individual harmonics. For this reason, the n mode* has a higher effective shunt impedance than any of the other operating modes as shown in fig. 27. Although the n mode is preferred from the viewpoint of obtaining maximum shunt impedance in a resonant structure, there are a number of problems which are to some extent all related to the fact that group velocity is 0 at n mode (see also ch. C. I . l b). For a given number of cavities in a n accelerator structure, the separation of modes is greatest in the center of the pass-band (n/2 mode) and least at the edges of the passband (0 and rr modes). The mode separation can be calculated using the results of coupled circuit theory obtained by Nagle [1964]. The dispersion relation for a linear array of N coupled circuits is &cot
=
1 + y cos(nq/N)
(75)
* Another way of looking at the rr mode is that both the ao space harmonic of the incident wave and the a 1 space harmonic of the reflected wave travel forward, in synchronism with the electrons. Thus, in this case, the shunt impedance r x to be substituted into eq. (74) is the sum of ro and r-1 or 2ro since when they coalesce, ro = r - I . The rr-points plotted in fig. 27 which can be substituted into eq. (74) are by definition only valid for standing-wave operation (see also ch. C.l.le, 5 1.5).
70
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
where y is the coefficient of coupling between circuits, q is the number of the mode with resonant frequency w,, and w , is the resonant frequency of the individual circuits. In general, nq/N is the phase shift per cell. Thus, the zero, n/2, and n modes occur for q=O, N/2, and N, respectively. Altogether, there are N+ 1 resonances." The separation of the lower and upper cut-off frequencies (0 and n modes) defines the bandwidth (BW) of the structure. From eq. (75) the bandwidth for small y is found to be
Thus, y is the normalized bandwidth of the coupled resonators. For the present discussion concerning the n mode, the separation of the N mode ( n ) and the ( N - I) mode is pertinent. From eq. (75) this separation is found to be
whereas the separation of the n/2 mode from its nearest neighbors is
Thus, for a given structure, the separation of modes near the 4 2 mode is 2N/n times as great as the separation near the n mode. Operation at a particular mode without excitation of its neighboring modes requires that the Q of the structure be sufficiently high to prevent overlapping of the mode resonances. From eqs. (77) and (78) the requirements for the n and 7112 modes are clearly
and
For example, if Q = lo4 and y = lo-', the number of cavities in the n mode structure cannot exceed z 16 without giving concern with respect to mode interaction. For the same Q and y, the 7112 mode structure can have z 157 cavities without overlapping of modes. Thus, the number of cavities in the n mode is much more severely limited than for the n/2 mode (and, in general, for other modes not too distant from the center of the pass-band). In a long accelerator utilizing the n mode, the number of feed points must be correspondingly increased. In the n mode structure, the phase shift from cavity to cavity is n radians in the lossless case. However, in the practical case with loss, energy must be supplied through excitation of adjacent modes to compensate for the losses and there are resultant phase changes in the cavities. Thus, strictly speaking, operation in the 71 mode is not possible. The phase deviation from n radians per cavity is given by (Nagle [1964],
* Equation (75) is valid for coupled cavities with half-cavity terminations in which case there are N full cavities and two half cavities giving N 1 resonances. When full-cavity terminations are used, there are N cavities and N resonances. In the latter case, the cosine term in eq. (75) becomes cos [zql(N 1)l.
+
+
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
71
Knapp [1964], and Smith [1966]):
Thus, the phase shift over the entire length of the structure is A@,,,
.,
= (1 - Y)+
WQY.
(82)
For the same values of Q and y as in the previous exampIe and for N = 16, the net phase shift is ~ 2 . radians 5 which is obviously excessive. To reduce the phase shift to a tolerable level, the value of the coupling coefficient y (i.e., the bandwidth) of the structure would have to be increased. This would, in turn, lead to a decrease in the shunt impedance of the structure. The n-mode structure is similarly quite sensitive to beam loading variations and to dimensional errors. On the other hand, the n/2 mode is much less sensitive to these effects and to cavity losses. For this mode, the effect of losses in the structure and the effect of beam loading in a correctly phased section is merely a reduction of field strength without change of phase. It is for these reasons that most resonant accelerators now under construction or under consideration utilize the n/2 structure. Means have been devised to improve the shunt impedance of this mode so that it approaches that of the n mode. One technique consists of using a linear bi-periodic disk-loaded structure with alternate long and short spacings between disks (Giordano [1965]). The short cavity is adjusted to have the same resonant frequency as the long cavity. The end terminations are placed so that the null in the standing-wave pattern occurs in the short cavities and the amplitude of the synchronous space harmonic is thereby increased. Another technique (Knapp [1964]) completely removes the resonant coupling cavity from the beam line and places it at the side of the structure where it now serves to couple two adjacent in-line cavities through slots in the mutual outer walls (see ch. C. 1. lc). Thus, the structure as a whole operates in the n/2 mode, but the in-line cavities are effectively operating in the n mode. While this structure is mechanically complicated, it has an even higher shunt impedance than the linear biperiodic structure (see also ch. C. 1. le). Pulsed operation of standing-wave accelerators. The values of accelerating field given in eqs. (72)-(74) for a standing-wave accelerator are for steady state conditions. Actually, most accelerators are run with short rf pulses and the fields in the cavities must build up from zero to the steady state values. The fields in a low loss structure build up .according to the expression given by Slater [I 9501:
EIE, = 1 - e p m ( / 2 Q ~
(83)
where E/E, is the ratio of instantaneous field strength to the steady state value, and QLis the loaded Q of the cavity. When impedance relations are adjusted for maximum steady state power transfer from the source to the cavity, Q,=+Q, The build-up of fields under these conditions is shown in fig. 14 where E/E, is plotted against ot/Q,. At ot/Q, = 2 the field has risen to 86.5 percent of the steady state value. For example,
72
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
with w= 1.79 x 10" radianslsec (corresponding to A,= 10.5 cm) and Qo= 17000, this occurs at a time t z 1.9 microseconds. At ot/Q, = 1 the fields have reached 63.2 percent of the final values. Therefore, if the beam is injected at tz0.95 microseconds and is on for one microsecond, the output electron energy at the end of the pulse will be about 1.37 times as high as at the beginning. Beam loading considerations have been neglected in this discussion and will tend to moderate the energy rise as rf power is transferred to the beam during the pulse. Another way in which the output electrons could be made more nearly monoenergetic might be to vary the relative phase angle 0 between the electrons and the wave during the pulse such that E cosB remains substantially constant.
Fig. 14. Buildup in resonant cavity under matched conditions
(QL = +Qo).
The feeding of rf power into a resonant structure such as a standing-wave accelerator requires considerable care. The steady state impedance of the cavity as viewed from the position of the detuned short is given approximately by Slater [1950]:
where Z is the impedance, Z, the characteristic impedance of the waveguide, Q,,, the external Q of the cavity which represents the losses from the cavity to the external waveguide, Qo the unloaded Q, o the angular frequency at which the measurement is being made, and coo the resonant frequency of the structure. At resonance, eq. (84) states that Z/Zo = Q0/Qe,,. The standing-wave ratio in the input waveguide will then be Zo/Zor Z/Zo, whichever is greater than unity. These two conditions correspond to "undercoupling" and "overcoupling", respectively, of the waveguide and cavity. When Z = Z o (i.e., Q, = Q,,,), the cavity is said to be "critically coupled". In this case, the cavity is perfectly "matched" to the waveguide at resonance; the standing-wave ratio is unity and none of the input power is reflected.
B.I.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
73
Equation (84) gives the cavity impedance under steady state conditions. However, during build-up of power in the cavity, the impedance varies, starting at zero at t=O and approaching the steady state value as t approaches infinity. During this transient period the impedance is given by (Slater [1950]):
z/zo
-
[I
Q,:
When Qo = Q,,,
Z / Zo
-
(1
- e-"~t"2Q~]/[~,'
= 2Q,,
- e-wo'/Qo
+
Q,:
ep"ot/2Q~].
(85)
this becomes
)/(I
+ eCmotiQ0).
(86)
A plot of Z / Z o ~ ~ n d these e r conditions is shown in fig. 14. It may be noted that the impedance builds up even more slowly than the fields. For example, at wot/Qo=2, it has risen to 76.2% of the steady state value. As just noted, the accelerator sections appear as short circuits at the beginning of the rf pulse. A self-excited oscillator cannot easily be used to supply power to such a load as it cannot start well when confronted with a short-circuited load (A. Sarazin [1953]; J.Vaste1 [1952]). A power amplifier can supply power, but at the beginning of the pulse all of the incident power will be reflected, and some of the power will continue to be reflected during the entire transient period. There are several disadvantages to this behavior: 1) the varying load causes the amplifier power output to vary during the pulse; 2) the changing power output may contribute to a greater energy spread in the accelerated electrons; 3) the reflected power may cause excessive electric gradients in the transmission line resulting in damage to such components as rf windows, etc. (see also ch. C.2.3). There are several ways in which the effective load as seen by the power source may be altered. All of these ways result in some loss in useful power. For example, resistive material (pads) can be added in the transmission line which at least partially isolate the cavities from the power source. T o be effective, this method will result in the loss of a fraction of the incident power. A better method, in principle, consists of the use of a unidirectional power absorber such as a ferrite isolator in the line. Such a device appears as an attenuator of large magnitude for waves propagating in the opposite direction, i.e., for reflected power traveling toward the power source. Thus, it can effectively decouple the load from the source without excessive loss of forward power. Rf isolators which are capable of handling several megawatts of incident peak power are available commercially. Such devices, however, are not yet capable of handling the highest powers ( > 2 0 megawatts) which have been used with accelerators. At these power levels, the isolators would probably have to be designed to operate in high vacuum. Comparison of energy gains ,from standing-wave and traveling-w,ave accelerators. Equation (33) gives the steady state energy gain obtained from a constant impedance traveling-wave accelerator having a n attenuation parameter T ; eq. (72) gives the steady state gain obtained when the same structure is operated as a standing-wave accelerator. Operation in the standing-wave mode gives higher steady state energy gains than operation in the traveling-wave mode for all values of z. The factor of
74
G.A. LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
improvement is (1 -e-4')-t, i.e., the square root of the build-up factor given in eq. (71). The relative improvement is greater at the lower values of z. The higher energies obtainable by operating the accelerator in a standing-wave rather than in a travelingwave mode are achievable only at the expense of significantly longer filling times. The normalized steady state energy gains for traveling-wave and standing-wave operation in the same accelerator structure are shown in fig. 15.
Fig. 15. Normalized steady state energy gains for traveling-wave and standing-wave operation in the same constant impedance accelerator structure versus attenuation parameter .r.
As noted earlier, the n mode has the highest shunt impedance of all the operating modes because of the coalescence of the forward and backward space harmonics. It is therefore of interest to compare the energy gain of a standing-wave accelerator operating in this mode with the energy gain of a traveling-wave accelerator operating in the 2x13 mode which is near optimum for traveling-wave operation. In making this comparison, it will be assumed that the same length of each type of accelerator is supplied with the same amount of rf power, that each is operating at P= 1.0 with the same disk aperture, and that the difficulty in supplying power to the standing-wave structure has been overcome by the use of idealized lossless isolators or other suitable devices. The ratio of the energy of the standing-wave accelerator given by eq. (74) [modified by the transient build-up factor given in eq. (83)] to the energy of the traveling-wave accelerator given by eq. (33) (with the 1 -e-" term replaced by 1 - e - ~ ~ g t l l = 1- e - < ~ f / 2 Qto~ ~show build-up during the filling time) is: = 3 2 ) [(I - e-wf'Qsw)/(l- e-Wt12QTW)] (rsw / rTW )+ VSW/VTW
(87)
where the subscripts SW and TW have been added to quantities pertaining to the standing-wave and traveling-wave cases, respectively. It has been assumed that matched conditions exist at steady state for the standing-wave accelerator (i.e., Q=2Q,)
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
75
and that difficulties with adjacent mode interactions can be overcome. The value of tz 1.26 should be used to optimize the steady state energy of the traveling-wave accelerator. I n using eq. (87). the value of t in the numerator is allowed to run from 0 to cc but the value of t in the denominator runs only from 0 to I/v, a t which time the traveling-wave structure is completely filled with energy. T o go further, experimental values of the shunt impedance r and Q are needed. The following values have been measured at Stanford for the TC mode (standing-wave) and 2 ~ 1 3(traveling-wave) cases at a frequency of 2856 MHz. -- -
Mode n
-
--
--
--
-
--
8,
t
d
2u
2b
Q
r (MQlrn)
1.0
0.230
2.068"
0.8225"
3.232"
17200
100
oK/c
0
t~ (psec) -
In the above table, P, is the phase velocity divided by the velocity of light, t is the disk thickness, d t h e spacing between disk centers, 2a the diameter of the disk aperture, 26 the inside diameter of the cavity, v,/c the normalized group velocity, and t , the filling time. The value of r used for the 2 ~ 1 3mode is that measured for the fundamental (n=O) space harmonic. For the n mode, the value of r used is the sum of the values measured for the n=O and n = - 1 space harmonics (see footnote on p. 69). Using the above tabulated values of r and Q for the two modes of operation, the energy build-ups (V/Vq,,,,, ,,,) vs. time are plotted in fig. 16 for the standing-wave (T mode) and traveling-wave (2x13 mode) cases. In addition, the energy ratio of the two accelerators (Vsw/VTw)vs. time is plotted in the same figure. It is noted that, except a t very low values of t when the standing-wave structure has a slight margin, the traveling-wave structure builds up more quickly than the standing-wave structure. At the end of the filling time of the traveling-wave structure, its energy is about 12% h ~ g h e rthan the energy of the standing-wave structure at the same time. The travelingwave structure continues to have higher energy up to a pulse length of ~ 3 . psec 5 when the two accelerators have equal energies. A t steady state in the standing-wave structure, its energy is about 3 % higher than the energy of the traveling-wave structure. F o r the assumed values of z, w , v, and Q(,,,,,. the length of each of the two 3 of the standing-wave structures is 4.9 meters which is equivalent to ~ 9 cavities structure. However, according to eq. (79), (using Q,= 17200 and assuming y ~ 0 . 0 1 ) the TC mode standing-wave structure should not have more than ~ 2 cavities 0 in order to avoid interactions with adjacent modes. Thus, to achieve the performance calculated in the above example, the n mode accelerator would have to be divided into 5 o r more independent lengths (each about 1 meter long) and each length must have a n independent rf feed. The resulting complications and cost of these independent feeds greatly favor the choice of a traveling-wave structure.
76
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Fig. 16. Comparison of energies of standing-wave and traveling-wave accelerators versus time during build-up of fields. n mode and 2n/3 mode operation are assumed for the standing-wave and travelingwave accelerators, respectively. Other assumptions: equal power to each accelerator, B = 1.0,f = 2856 MHz, and same disk aperture. Shunt impedances, ro/Q and v g / c included in calculation are experimentally obtained.
6 Superconducting accelerators As noted earlier in this chapter, the acceleration of electrons to useful energies by means of accelerators operating in the usual temperature ranges requires the supplying of peak rf power measured in megawatts. The cost of power sources having the needed capacity and the cost of the power being consumed limits the beam duty cycle that can feasibly be achieved to values which are usually quite low as pointed out in 9 3. The application of accelerators to various industrial and research tasks is complicated or greatly limited by low duty cycle. In recent years, the possibility of operating accelerators at extremely low temperatures near absolute zero where the electrical conductivity of certain materials such as niobium and lead is very high, has been investigated; e.g., see Banford and Stafford [1961], Wilson [1963], Wilson et al. [1963], Wilson and Schwettman [1965], Schwettman et al. [1965], Smith et al. [1966], Schwettman et al. 119671, and Weaver et al. 119671. The low rf losses at these depressed temperatures and the consequent low peak power requirements indicate that duty cycles approaching unity may be practicable. Only a few remarks on this new and promising
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
77
application of cryogenics will be given for completeness in this chapter. A detailed account of this work and a complete bibliography is given in Part E of this book. The rf power required to accelerate electrons to a given energy is inversely proportional to the Q of the accelerating structure. At temperatures near absolute zero, the theoretical Q dependence is given by (Wilson and Schwettman [1965]):
where 28 is the gap in the energy spectrum of the superconductor, T is the absolute temperature, u the operating frequency, and k is Boltzmann's constant (1.38 x 10-l6 erg/deg C). Values of Q near lo9 have been measured at 2856 MHz at temperatures between 4.2"K and 2°K (Wilson and Schwettman [1965]) for electroplated lead cavities in the TE,, mode. Because of the exponential dependence shown in eq. (88), the theoretical Q increases rapidly with decreasing T. In principle, an order of magnitude improvement in Q can be obtained by reducing the temperature 1 to 2 degrees at these low levels. The actual improvement is limited by the residual resistance of the electroplated surface. According to eq. (88) the Q of a superconducting cavity varies as w p 2 at a given temperature. This behavior is different from that experienced at room temperatures where, as discussed in 5 3, Q varies as w - ' . Since the ratio r , , / Q , which is a purely geometrical factor independent of surfaces losses, is proportional to w , the shunt impedance r , in a superconducting cavity varies as u p ' .Thus, the use of low frequencies is favored with superconducting accelerators whereas higher frequencies are advantageous for accelerators operating at room temperatures. The decrease in frequency is limited by the increasing cross section of the accelerator structure. It appears that practicable structure sizes will set the lower frequency limit to a few hundred megahertz. The energy gains from a traveling-wave and a standing-wave accelerator in the case of negligible beam loading are given by eqs. (33) and (72), respectively. For superconducting accelerators, where z is very small, these equations become:
,
where P, is the source power and P, is the power dissipated in the accelerator structure of length I. Thus, for the same energy gain, it appears that the power dissipated in the standing-wave structure must be twice that dissipated in the traveling-wave structure, assuming both structures have the same lengths and shunt impedances. In actual fact, as already noted, it is possible to make up for this disadvantage by using the TC mode or the n/2 mode in a bi-periodic structure for which the shunt impedances are considerably increased. From another viewpoint, for a given net energy gain, the ratio of peak to average fields in the standing-wave structure is up to two times as high as
78
G.A. LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
this ratio in the traveling-wave structure. This consideration gives an advantage to the traveling-wave structure for superconducting accelerator applications. However, because of the inherently very low rf losses, traveling-wave superconducting accelerators must employ the feedback principle in order to utilize fully the available rf power and achieve high accelerating efficiency. Traveling-wave superconducting structure with feedback. The unloaded energy of the traveling-wave accelerator with optimum feedback is given by eq. (45). Equation (45) is valid in the room temperature case where the attenuation in the feedback loop is usually negligible compared to the attenuation in the accelerator structure itself. This is not true in the case of the superconducting accelerators unless the feedback loop is refrigerated along with the accelerator structure. If the attenuation in the feedback loop is y nepers, the no-load energy with optimum feedback is given by * g optimum; VTWFB = (27)* [(I - e-')/TI [l - e-2(T+y)]-t(P,r,l)* (i=o
)
The bracketed term which gives the energy build-up ratio due to feedback is reduced by the loop attenuation y. When y is negligible, eq. (91) becomes identical to eq. (45). When the beam current is turned on, the beam energy decreases from the no-load value in accordance with the equation:
where Vn= ~ / ( ~ , r , l ) and * in= (i2r,l/~,)) are the normalized beam energy and beam current, respectively. When z and y are small, eq. (92) may be written:
( r and y small)
The conversion efficiency defined as v ] = Vi/P,, i.e., the fraction of the input rf power which is converted to beam power, can be obtained by multiplying Vn by in as follows:
Curves of Vn and q are shown in fig. 17 vs. in. Two sets of curves are shown in fig. 17. One set is based on y/z= lo4 [case (a)] which is typical of feedback through a loop which is at room temperature while the accelerator structure is supercooled.
*
A more complete t r z a t m n t of the traveling-wave superconducting accelerator with feedback with derivations of the basic equations presented here is given by Neal [I9681 (see also ch. E.2).
B.l.1
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
79
The other set is based on y / z = 0 . 1 [case (b)] which is a rough approximation* for the case where the feedback loop as well as the accelerator structure are supercooled. From a comparison of these curves, several observations may be made. For fixed rf power input, the theoretical no-load energy is about 95 times higher for case (b) where y / =~ 0.1 than for case (a) where y / z = lo4. As the beam current increases, u] increases much more rapidly for case (b) than for case (a) and approaches 100% for relatively small values of current. Similarly, the beam energy for case (b) drops off much more rapidly with increasing current. At higher values of beam current, the
q [CASE (b)]
Fig. 17. Normalized beam energy (Vn) and beam conversion efficiency (u) for traveling-wave superconducting accelerator with optimum feedback versus normalized beam current (in). Accelerator nepers. Feedback loop attenuation parameter, y =- 5 x 10-3 attenuation parameter, .r = 5 x nepers [case (a)] and y = 5 x nepers [case (b)).
values of beam energy and u] for both cases approach the same values. Case (b) is obviously superior where the attainment of high energy is paramount. However, the very large value of the beam loading derivative in this case requires that the current be maintained constant with high accuracy in order to achieve energy stability.
* At room temperatures, the attenuation in nepers per unit length is typically 50 to 100 times as high in the accelerator structure as in a similar length of ordinary waveguide. Because of the presence of bends and the re-combining bridge in the feedback loop, the more conservative estimate of 10 is being used in this example.
80
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
The above discussion is based upon optimum feedback which implies a bridge ratio which can be varied to suit any degree of beam loading. When a fixed bridge ratio g is utilized, the general expression for beam energy is: 1-
eCY[(I - e-')/(2z)*] in
(TWFB) (g fixed)
(95)
where Vn and in are the normalized beam energy and beam current as previously defined. The conversion efficiency q is given, as previously stated, by the product of V, and in. Unlike the case with optimum feedback where q continues to approach unity as in increases, for fixed bridge ratio g there is a value of beam current which results in maximum q. The condition for q,,, (for small z) is:
When the condition of eq. (96) is met, the conversion efficiency becomes:
At maximum conversion efficiency the beam energy is reduced to one-half of the no-load value. In general, the beam energy is given by:
is the beam current resulting in maximum where Vo is the no-load energy and iqmax conversion efficiency. The normalized beam energy V, and beam conversion efficiency q are plotted in fig. 18 vs. in for 3 values of the bridge ratio g (g= lo4, lo5, and 9.08 x lo5). The latter value of g gives maximum no-load energy. For ease of comparison, the same values 17. It o f z a n d y ( z = 5 ~ 1 0 - ~y=5x10~8)havebeenassumedasforcase(b)offig. ; is noted that a large bridge ratio results in a high value of the no-load energy and a high value of beam loading derivative. Also, for large g, the conversion efficiency q peaks at a lower value of beam current and the maximum efficiency is less than for smaller values of g. The dashed lines in fig. 18 represent the values of Vn and q for the optimum feedback case. They are the envelopes of all the possible cases of fixed g. The total power dissipated in the accelerator and in the feedback loop including the accelerator is just P, (1 - q). The fraction of the rf power which is dissipated in the accelerator structure alone during operation at maximum efficiency can be found by setting eq. (89) equal to one-half of the no-load energy obtained from eq. (95). The result is
Filling time of traveling-wave structure. An analysis of the transient build-up of the superconducting accelerator with feedback (see Neal [1968]) shows that the number
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
81
of transits around the loop required to build up to the fraction (1 - l/e), i.e., to 63.2% of the magnitude of the steady state electric field in the accelerator structure is
Since the time for a single transit is very close to I/v, and since from eqs. (25) and (3 l), 1jvg=(2Q/w) T, the filling time of the structure is given by
When the structure is designed for negligible beam loading, the relationship giving maximum energy and conversion efficiency is (1 129)= z y. Thus, the filling time for this case is (2Q/w) ~g = (Q/w) [z/(z + y)]. For heavier design loading, (I/&) 9 ( 2 y) and thus, the filling time approaches (2Q/w) (2zg).
+
0
2
4
6
8 n
10
+
12
14
16
Fig. 18. Normahzed beam energy (V,,) and beam conversion efficiency (11) for traveling-wave superconducting accelerator with feedback versus normalized beam current (;,,). Curves are shown for 3 fixed bridge ratios. Accelerator attenuation parameter, r = 5 x nepers. Feedback loop attenuation parameter, y 5 x 10 nepers.
-
Using eqs. (95) and (96), the filling time may alternately be written:
Thus, the filling time is reduced as the beam current giving maximum conversion efficiency is increased (and the corresponding beam energy decreased). As an example, nepers, Q = lo9, and w=1.79x 10'' assume g = lo5, r = 5 x l o p 7 nepers, y = 5 x rad/sec ( f = 2856 MHz). Then, from eq. (96) one obtains in(,",.<,, = 3.17. Inserting this
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
82
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
value of normalized current in eq. (95) yields Vn/,(qmax,=0.285. Using the above values in eq. (102), the filling time is found to be %0.010 seconds. Since, as shown previously, Vnin= y % 1 for inb 1 , it is clear that under these conor, equivalently, as i ~ ~ m a x , . ditions the filling time varies as v,"(,_~~, The dependence of filling time upon frequency may be determined by recalling that Q K C I -at~ superconducting temperatures, and from the definitions given previ. from eq. (102), t , ~ o - ~The . rapid increase of filling ously, Vn/in=V / i r o l ~ oThen, time as the frequency is decreased, together with the increasing cross section of the structure, will likely be the principal factors limiting the minimum frequency. Standing-wave superconducting structure. The standing-wave superconducting structure will now be examined following the results of Wilson and Schwettmann [1965]. The energy gain in this case in the presence of beam loading is given by:
where j? is the coupling coefficient between the transmission line and the accelerator structure. The first term on the right in eq. (103) is the no-load energy ;the second term is the reduction in no-load energy due to beam loading. Again, for convenience, eq. (103) will be written in normalized form as follows:
) ~ in= [ ( i 2 r o l ) / ~ s ]The t . conversion efficiency is then given by where Vn= V / ( ~ , r , l and y
=
ViIP, = Vni, = [(28)'/(1
+ P)] in - [i,2/2(1+ P)]
The condition for maximum q is:
When the condition of eq. (106) is satisfied, the conversion efficiency and beam energy become :
Thus, at maximum conversion efficiency, the beam energy has been reduced by beam loading to one-half of the no-load value. In general, as in the traveling-wave case, the beam energy can be written as:
where Vo is the no-load energy and iqmax is the beam current which results in y,,,. The power dissipated in the structure at maximum conversion efficiency may be found by equating eqs. (90) and (108). The result is: PdlPSl(,_,,, = PI(1 + PI2.
(110)
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
83
From the conservation of total power, the power reflected (P,) from the input coupler back towards the rf source may be found as follows: prlps
=
1 - qmax - PdIP, = 1 - [Pl(l
+ P)] - [Pl(l + b)'] = I/(' + P)' .
(111)
Normalized values of beam energy (V,), beam current (i,), beam conversion efficiency (rl), power dissipated in accelerator structure (Pd/P,), and reflected power (P,/P,) vs. coupling coefficient P, all at maximum conversion efficiency, are shown in fig. 19. The maximum efficiency obtainable improves as P increases. Other advantages of high P are the smaller fraction of the source power reflected and the smaller fraction of the power dissipated in the accelerator structure. A disadvantage of increasing is the decreasing magnitude of Vn at q,,.
Fig. 19. Normalized values of beam energy (Vn), beam current (in), beam conversion efficiency (q), power dissipated in accelerator structure (Pd/Ps), and reflected power (Pr/Ps) in superconducting standing-wave accelerator versus coupling coefficient 8, all at maximum beam conversion efficiency.
Filling time of standing-)cave structure. For P$1, most of the power is transferred to the beam and the power dissipated in the structure given by eq. (110) becomes Pd/P,z 1/P. Thus, the loaded Q , Q,, becomes
Combining eqs. (1 12) and (90) yields the result
The time to fill the structure to I - l/e, i.e., to 63.2% of the magnitude of the steady
84
G.A. LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
state field, is 2Q,/w. Thus, the time to fill to this level is:
Comparing eqs. (102) and (114) one notes that, for equal beam energies, currents, lengths, and r o l e , the filling time of the standing-wave structure is twice that of the traveling-wave structure with feedback. The basic reason for this result is that the standing-wave accelerator is filled by successive reflections in the accelerator structure itself, whereas the traveling-wave structure is filled by successive feedback of the power through the external loop in which the transit time is negligible compared to the one-way transit time in the accelerator structure. ~ ~equi, As in the traveling-wave case, for in% 1 , the filling time varies as v , ( , _ [or, ]. with other parameters fixed, t, K o- 2. valently, as i , ~ r n , x ,Also,
0
2
4
6
8 in
10
12
14
16
Fig. 20. Normalized beam energy (Vn) and beam conversion efficiency ( q ) for standing-wave superconducting accelerator versus normalized beam current ( i n ) . Curves are shown for 3 fixed values of the coupling coefficient /3.
Comparison of traveling-wave and standing-wave designs. The normalized beam energy Vn and beam conversion efficiency q in the standing-wave accelerator are plotted in fig. 20 vs. in for 3 values of the coupling coefficient 0 (P= 1, 10, and 50). Also shown in this figure with dashed lines are the envelopes of the Vnand q families representing the maximum possible values of these variables at each value of in. The envelopes of the entire family of g values for the traveling-wave accelerator with feedback and the fl values of the standing-wave accelerator are plotted together in fig. 21. As noted above, these curves represent the maximum possible values of Vn and q at each value of in and hence are useful in the theoretical comparison of the
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
85
various possible designs. It is noted that the traveling-wave accelerator with feedback excels with respect to the maximum beam energy obtainable. At light loading it also has a higher conversion efficiency than the standing-wave accelerator. With increasing beam loading, the energies and efficiencies of both of these basic types approach equality. The advantages relating to higher energy and higher efficiency stem solely from the reduced loss in the feedback loop compared to the "internal" feedback through the accelerator structure in the standing-wave accelerator. If T = y , i.e., if the losses in the feedback loop are equal to the internal losses, the two accelerator types have the same maximum values of Vn and q at all values of in. However, the advantage of reduced ratio of peak to average fields for the traveling-wave accelerator with feedback still remains even if T = y.
Fig. 21. Comparison of maximum values of normalized beam energy (V,,) and beam conversion efficiency ( q ) versus normalized beam current (in)for superconducting traveling-wave and standingwave accelerators. For traveling-wave accelerator, accelerator attenuation parameter s = 5 x nepers. nepers and feedback loop attenuation parameter y = 5 x
In summary, the superconducting traveling-wave accelerator with feedback has the theoretical advantages of somewhat higher energies and efficiencies at light loading as noted above and also the advantage of reduced ratio of peak to average fields in the accelerator cavities. The latter characteristic may be a definite advantage if the maximum energy gradient obtainable is limited by either the critical magnetic field for the superconductor or by field emission. In addition, for equal beam energies and currents, the traveling-wave accelerator with feedback has one-half the filling time of the standing-wave accelerator. This characteristic may become important if unity duty
86
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
cycle is not feasible, or if it becomes desirable to turn off the rf power periodically, e.g., while the beam is being switched from one research area to another. The practical realization of a superconducting accelerator with feedback may turn out to be quite complicated due to the requirement to supercool the external feedback loop. Also, careful attention must be given to the elimination of rf reflections in the loop in order to prevent the buildup of a backward wave of significant amplitude. This backward wave builds up at the expense of the forward wave and hence would result in a reduction of beam energy and conversion efficiency. A tuner in the feedback loop might be needed to compensate for residual reflections. Ideally, this tuner would be automatically controlled from a signal derived from the backward wave.
7 Analytic and computer techniques for structure design Once a particular linac among the various types described in earlier paragraphs is selected for construction, the next step is to translate the design requirements into an actual structure. This task would be greatly simplified if at this point the designer could call upon a comprehensive theory capable of yielding a set of precise physical dimensions corresponding to the specified field requirements, or vice-versa, if given a set of structure dimensions, the theory could yield the corresponding fields. In practice, none of the structures used for electron linacs, even the simple disk-loaded waveguide, lend themselves to a straightforward field analysis. Almost all known analytic and computer techniques have to make use of simplifying models or assumptions. In view of these difficulties, designers generally content themselves with less information. This includes expressions for the dispersion relation, i.e., o-p diagram, and values of the shunt impedance and sometimes of the Q of the structure in terms of the physical dimensions. It is beyond the scope of this chapter to give a comprehensive description of all the various available theories and structures to which they have been applied. In general, it can be said that the value of these theories and numerical methods increases with the complexity of the structure, not only because of the need for physical understanding but because of the increased cost of making numerous cold tests, as described in the next section. A number of examples of different approaches will appear in later chapters of this book. Basically, these can be divided into two categories: direct field analyses and equivalent circuits. Some authors use a combination of the two. The simplest field analysis is that of the single frequency, isolated "pillbox" resonators described in 3 2. Using the simple model of fig. l b and the field expressions for a TM,,, cavity (see Ramo and Whinnery [1953]), one can obtain the following expressions for the shunt impedance and Q of the structure: r 08
n
9688, [I - (tld)] sin [(rill,) (d - t)] 2.618, [I - (tld)]
+
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
87
and
where
fl, w 6
A, t
d n
is the is the is the is the is the is the is the
phase velocity in the structure divided by c, angular frequency, skin depth, guide wavelength, disk thickness, period of the structure, and number of disks per wavelength.
In the next section these expressions are plotted and compared with experimental results. Much more sophisticated field analyses can be found for example in Chu and Hansen [1947], Chu [1951], Watkins [1958], Bevensee [I9641 and Helm [1966]. All these theories make use of Maxwell's equations and the wave equation and attempt to find solutions in terms of the boundary conditions. In one typical procedure, the field functions are represented in terms of cavity modes and the problem is solved by matching tangential field components (H, and E,) in the plane of transverse loading (the iris in the case of the disk-loaded waveguide). In another procedure, the fields in the "free" region of the structure ( r < a for the disk-loaded waveguide) are represented in terms of space harmonics (see eq. 4) and the solution is obtained by matching tangential field components ( H , and E,) across the boundary with the standing-wave region of the structure ( a < r < b for the disk-loaded waveguide). In each case the exact solution is obtained in the form of a determinantal equation resulting from an infinite set of simultaneous equations. This solution can either be derived by purely algebraic analysis or by variational methods. The equivalent circuit analysis can assume two forms. One of them is exemplified by the approach taken by Slater [I9501 and Watkins [I9581 and is illustrated in fig. 22a. It can be shown that if the large boxes represent sections of unperturbed lossless guide or transmission line of phase shift Dd and the small boxes are infinitely short shunt elements representing obstacles such as disks, then
where Y,, = - jY,cotpd Y,, = Y12 = jY, cscfld Y,,=-jY,cotpd.
The new phase shift bod per section including the shunt element can be shown to be
88
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
given by the expression cos pod = cos pd - 3b0 sin j?d .
(119)
Knowing or making certain assumptions about the dependence of b, and P on frequency, one can obtain the dispersion diagram, i.e., the plot of w vs. Do. The other equivalent circuit analysis is exemplified by the approach taken by Nagle [1964], Smith [I9661 and Nagle et al. [1967]. It is illustrated by fig. 22b. For such an array, it is also possible to solve the circuit equations by a matrix formulation and to calculate the dispersion diagram and other properties of the structure such as the tolerances to errors in drive frequency or cavity dimensions and the transient response. The coupling factor k, resonant frequency, shunt impedance and quality i
-inp y12
Yl I
--ik+l
-in+,
y12
y22
Fig. 22a. Two-terminal-pair network. The large boxes represent sections of unperturbed guide or transmission line, the small boxes represent the susceptance of a shunt element such as the disk in a disk-loaded waveguide.
factor Q which depend on the details of the field distribution within individual cavities are obtained by computation or direct measurement. Examples of such individual cavity field calculations are given by Dahl et al. 119661 (Jessy and Messymesh programs), Hoyt [I9661 (LALA program), and more details appear in ch. C. 1.ld. Further refinements of all these techniques used by Nagle [I9641 and Nishikawa et al. [I9661 lead to derivations applicable to bi-periodic structures which operate at n/2 phase shift per cavity. These structures will be used in standing-wave proton linacs and in superconducting accelerators and are discussed in greater detail in later chapters.
C C C Fig. 22b. Array of coupled circuits representing equivalent circuit of coupled resonator chain.
8 Empirical design methods In spite of the progress made during the last few years in developing better theories and computer programs to design accelerator structures, the final determination of the dimensions and other figures of merit is still being done empirically, by measure-
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
89
ments. These measurements comprise cold tests performed on short cavity stacks or on final prototypes as well as beam tests t o check final performance. A coniplete description of such measurements is beyond the scope of this chapter and again, only some of the highlights will be covered here. For simplicity, the discussion will be limited t o the design of standard disk-loaded waveguides although most techniques are also applicable to any of the other types of structures. Choice of dimensions. The modular dimensions of the disk-loaded waveguide which can be adjusted to achieve the design parameters described in 9 3 are shown in figs. 23a and 23b: the cylindrical guide diameter 2b, the disk-hole diameter 2a, the periodic length d, the disk thickness t , edge radius q and aperture width s. There are many further possible variations to this simple configuration as for example those shown in figs. 23c and 23d and others where one rounds off the corners between
o
CAVITY D I M E N S I O N S
c ) " C O N I C A ~ AND ' " A N T I C O N I C A ~ 'D I S K S
I
b)
d)
DISK D I M E N S I O N S
DISKS WITH
I
DRIFT - T U B E S
Fig. 23. Sketches of disk-loaded waveguide showing dimensions and possible design variations.
cylinders and disks. The "anti-conical" disks and drift tubes provide a slight improvement in effective shunt impedance because of a n increase in the transit time factor of eq. (1). O n the other hand, this improvement is accompanied by a n increase in the peak to average field ratio which can become detrimental if the structure is to operate close to the breakdown point. Rounding of the corners tends to transform each cylindrical cavity into a sphere which can also be shown to have a somewhat higher shunt impedance. However, the incremental fabrication cost due to these refinements cannot, in general, be justified for electron linacs because the improvements are of the order of only a few percent.
90
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
As has been discussed in $ 2 and $ 3, the first basic parameter choices are the frequency, the phase shift per cavity (or operating mode) and the attenuation. The lower cut-off frequency of the disk-loaded waveguide, or "zero mode" frequency, is strongly dependent upon the waveguide diameter 2b (,f,z0.766c/2b) whereas the bandwidth and thus the group velocity and attenuation depend primarily on the ratio a/b at given values of Q and t. Fixing the frequency o, or free space wavelength 1, and the phase shift @, per cavity fixes the distance between disk center lines at d=@,c/o,. Thus, these choices are all interdependent. In early traveling-wave accelerators, a value of @, = n / 2 or four disks per wavelength was generally chosen for ease of measurement. More recently, the value of @, = 2n/3 has often been preferred, because, as will be shown below, an improvement of 10% in shunt impedance can
Fig. 24. Instantaneous traveling-wave configurations of the electric field for 0, z/2,2z/3 and TC phase shift per cavity.
thereby be gained. The 71 mode has often been proposed for standing-wave accelerators because this mode has the highest shunt impedance of all. However, as already discussed in 5 5, its low (nominally zero) group velocity and resulting poor mode separation and h g h sensitivity to fabricational tolerances have led designers to prefer structures withdouble periodicities (see ch. C.l.le and E.2 and E.3). The phase shift per cavity in those designs is really n / 2 although in some cases, half the cavities may not be on-axis with the electron beam. Figure 24 shows sketches of the various traveling-wave field configurations at an instant of time. These patterns are deformed
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
91
as they slide down the waveguide but reappear in the same configuration, shifted by one cavity, at an instant t = @,/o,later. In addition to the choice of the above dimensions, another decision which has to be made at the outset of a design is whether the structure shall be of the constantimpedance or constant-gradient type. The relative advantages of these structures have already been discussed in 4 4. For the constant-impedance structure, the transverse cross section is constant as a function of length and only one set of dimensions need be determined. For the constant-gradient structure, the dimensions 2a and 26 vary gradually along the length of the structure and several sets of measurements and interpolations must be made. Often, for reasons of simplicity and economy, the variation is obtained in steps of successive uniform sections of guide joined by matching transitions. Examples of accelerators utilizing these various structures will be given at the end of this chapter. Special precautions must be taken in all these cases to avoid creating possible trapped resonances at higher modes of the H E M , , type which are likely to be amplified and cause beam breakup. Cold tests. Whether one or several sets of transverse dimensions must be obtained, short test cells are generally used to determine these dimensions and to measure the various design parameters such as the phase velocity up, the group velocity o,, r / Q , Q and the space harmonic amplitudes a,. Comprehensive treatments of these measurements are given by Chodorow et al. [1955], Ginzton [1957], Gallagher [1960], and Borghi et al. [1966]. For the tests to be valid, the test cells must be terminated by shorting planes located in planes of symmetry to which the electric field vector is normal in such a way that the standing wave "trapped" between them is an exact representation of the instantaneous traveling wave one wishes to study. The dashed lines in fig. 24 show such planes. With n cavities terminated in this manner one obtains ( n + I ) resonances corresponding to the frequencies for which the stack length is equal to an integral number of half-wavelengths. Careful stacking and alignment are essential to obtain good and uniform electrical contact. Figure 25 shows a typical cold test setup comprising disassembled cavity samples, a resonant stack and the objective Brillouin diagram for a phase velocity vp=c and three disks per wavelength at J'=2856 MHz. For example, with a stack of six cavities, one gets seven resonant frequencies. These are generally sufficient, after two or three iterations, to obtain the entire Brillouin diagram and the final dimensions yielding the proper phase shift ( 2 ~ 1 3per ) cavity at the desired frequency (2856 MHz) for up=c. For typical bandwidths rarely exceeding 3 %, the dispersion diagram can, in general, be assimilated to a sinusoidal curve and the group velocity u,=dw/db can be derived with fair accuracy (see Robson [1956]). Special care should be taken in verifying that the disk aperture edges have been properly formed. It is possible to do this by utilizing a steel ball (fig. 23b) or a more sophisticated contour plotter. Errorsin h or s can cause significant errors i n 5 up and v,. Careful attention should also be given to the temperature and degree of humidity under which cold test measurements are carried out. Knowing these, final corrections
92
G.A.LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Fig. 25. Typical experimental setup showing cavity stack used for cold tests.
can always be made using simple relationships such as the equality between A2b/2b, A f / f and g A T where g is the expansion coefficient of copper and AT is the temperature difference. Another useful rule of thumb is that translation from air at 26OC (79°F) and 40% humidity to vacuum results in a relative frequency change of 3 x The determination of the shunt impedance r, for the fundamental space harmonic component generally requires the successive measurements of three quantities: ( Y / Q ) ~a ,g / x a: and Q. The quantities ( r / Q ) , (where the index T denotes the sum over all space harmonic components) and a i / x a: are measured by perturbation
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
93
techniques. The perturbing objects can be dielectric rods, metallic plungers or beads of either material. If one uses a resonant stack, the perturbed quantity is the resonant frequency which is given by the general expression (see Slater [1950]):
where the integral represents the change in magnetic and electric energy due to the perturbing object of volume Av, and W, is the energy stored in the cavity. The factor k depends upon the shape of the object. Using eq. (120) the quantity ( r / Q ) , can easily be obtained from the frequency perturbation A,df caused by a cylindrical coaxial dielectric rod of constant cross
Fig. 26. Example of three-cavity stack resonating in 2x13 mode with illustration of how first three space harmonics add and subtract to give cavity field observed by bead measurement. The perturbation A f is proportional to Ec2.
94
G.A. LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
section A, of length equal to that of the cavity stack and of relative dielectric constant & :
Similarly, it is possible to measure the detailed axial electrical field profile, E,, by means of the frequency perturbation caused by a short bead drawn along the axis of the test stack. Thus, since E: (z)ccAf (z), it can be shown that [Af (z)lt cos p,z dz
(a:/C a:) = (2/10) 0
0
Then,
Sometimes, the dielectric rod measurement is bypassed entirely and the value of 130
I ,--T
I
POINT FOR n = O AND - I SPACE HARMONICS
-\"s x, s> O EXPERIMENTAL POINTS TAKEN FOR Xo= 10.5crn
\
, ,
Fig. 27. Theoretical and experimental curves of normalized shunt impedance (rod) vs. number disks per wavelength (n) for various values of t/10 at Bw= 1 .
B.1.1
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
95
a i / o w is obtained directly by getting an absolute calibration of the bead in a cavity of known r / Q . Figure 26 shows a typical example of how the space harmonics add and subtract to give the standing-wave field E, in a three-cavity stack, as predicted by eq. (6). The final measurement to perform is that of Q. It is the most delicate because it depends so strongly on the state of the metal surface and on good contact between cavities. The simplest technique is to perform two successive measurements of Q as defined byfldf, one with a stack of m cavities, the other with 2n1 cavities. The losses in the end-plates can then be eliminated by using the expression:
Q
Q,Qd2Qm - Q z J .
( 124)
Fig. 28. Theoretical and experimental curves of Q vs. number of disks per wavelength (n) for various
values of t/Ro at 8,
=-
I.
Final verifications of this Q measurement can always be made after the entire accelerator section is fabricated and its insertion loss can be measured. The next few figures summarize the results of a large number of these experiments. Figures 27 and 28 show comparisons between theoretical and experimental values of shunt impedance ( r , ) and Q as a function of number of disks per wavelength (n). The theoretical values, obtained from eqs. (1 15) and (1 16), are higher than the experimental values because of the assumed idealized value of copper conductivity and the fact that the "pillbox" model does not take into account a finite iris aperture. Agree-
96
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL'>
ment between the trends of these curves, however, is quite good and emphasizes two important facts. One is that the maximum shunt impedance for a traveling-wave accelerator is in the neighborhood of n=3, or 2n/3 phase shift per cavity, the other is that the highest shunt impedance is obtained for the n mode or standing-wave case where the synchronous shunt impedance is the summation of both the n=O and n = - 1 space harmonics. The disadvantages of this mode have already been discussed in detail in 9 5. The accuracy of the n mode point is somewhat in question because of the difficulties involved in the space harmonic and Q measurements for this case. Figure 29 summarizes the design parameters of the SLAC constant-gradient continuous taper structure. It shows the range of variation of 2a, 2b, r , and v,/c. Similar plots
Fig. 29. Variation of 26, 2a, v,/c and the shunt impedance ro (corrected for the fundamental space harmonic) as a function of length (zll) along SLAC 3.05 meter constant-gradient section for
t l l o = 5.57 x
have been obtained by other designers at Varian Associates (Palo Alto, California) and C.S.F. (Corbeville, France) for other constant-gradient accelerators using discontinuous tapers. (For parameter ranges, see table 1.) The coupler problem. One of the cavity configurations most commonly used to couple power into and out of an accelerator structure is shown in figs. 30a and 31a. In this design, the transition from the rectangular waveguide is made by means of a matching iris, the exact size and plane of which are adjusted to obtain the correct
Y
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
97
match. The coupler cavity is a regular accelerator cavity. the fields of which are in the proper phase relationship with those in the rest of the structure to produce acceleration. In other designs, particularly those originating at C.S.F. (France) (see fig. 30b), the coupler cavity is different from the other cavities in that it is much narrower and does not contribute substantially to electron acceleration. Its advantage is that the standing-wave pattern set up in the cavity can perhaps be controlled more closely and the distance over which it acts on the incoming electrons can be shortened. This feature is often important in buncher design. Another variation of this type with similar advantages is the "door-knob" coupler.
I
Input RF
Accelerating
I
w,
Aperture
Matching and Tuning Plunger
a ) SLAC DESIGN
b ) C.S.F. DESIGN
Fig. 30. Coupler designs.
One feature that most of these couplers seem to have in common is that the lateral aperture introduces both a n amplitude asymmetry and a phase shift in the axial electric field Ez as a function of the transverse coordinate x. (See fig. 3 1 a,) The asymmetry can be of the order of 10"/,nd the phase shift of the order of 1.5" over the beam aperture. It can induce beam rotation in low energy sections when magnetic focusing is used (Bergkre et al. [1965]). T o understand the effect of these asymmetries on the beam, let the spatial variation of E, be of the form EZ = [ E Z , ,
+ ( A E / 2 a ) x] exp [ j ( A @ / 2 n )x]
( 1 25)
where AE and A@ are the amplitude and phase variations in the x-direction over the
98
G.A. LOEW, R.B. NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
aperture diameter 2a averaged from 0 to d, the cavity length. Then, to firs^. order, dE,/ax
=j
(A@/2a)E,,
exp [j(A@/2a)x ]
+ (AEI2a) exp [j(A@/2a)x ] .
(126)
From Maxwell's equations, By and hence the Lorentz force F, are bo:h in time quadrature with dE,/ax. Referring to fig. 31b, the deflecting force F:, caused by the
RECTANGULAR WAVEGUIDE
(1
CROSS-SECTION OF COUPLER CAVITY r
'i /-
ACCELERATING FORCE
DEFLECTING FORCE DUE TO AMPLITUDE ASYMMETRY
DEFLECTING FORCE DUE TO PHASE ASYMMETRY
b )
FORCE COMPONENTS DUE TO AMPLITUDE A N D PHASE ASYMMETRY I N T H E COUPLER CAVITIES
MATCHING IRIS
X
c )
COUPLER OFFSET TO CORRECT A M P L I T U D E ASYMMETRY
Fig. 31. Effects of coupler design and example of technique used to correct for amplitude asymmetry effect.
B.1.1
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
99
phase asymmetry and proportional to (A@/2a)E,, , is in phase with the accelerating force F,; it produces a net deflection on a bunch traveling on the crest of the wave. On the other hand, the force F:, caused by the amplitude asymmetry and proportional to 1/2a(AE/Ez,,) E,,,, is in quadrature with the accelerating force F,; its effect, as shown in an exaggerated form in fig. 31b is to spread transversely a bunch traveling on the accelerating wavecrest. Using simple electrodynamics, it can be shown that the transverse momentum Gp, imparted to an electron traveling at an angle 8 with respect to the accelerating wavecrest through the coupler cavity of length d is given by 6p,
=
[eE,, ,id/4rrac] [ A @ cos 0 + (AEIE,, ,) sin 81 .
(127)
In a short accelerator, these effects are of no serious consequence because the angle 8 can be monitored and kept close to zero and the steering effect can be compensated for. In a long accelerator where several beams of different energies may be accelerated simultaneously by different numbers of klystrons, the difficulties may be more serious. To remedy these difficulties, several measures can be taken. One of them consists of offsetting the coupler cavity as shown in fig. 31c. By a proper adjustment of the offset (of the order of 2 to 4 mm at S-band), the value of AE/E can be reduced to 0.1% or less. The phase shift across the axis could in principle be eliminated by feeding the coupler symmetrically from both sides or be compensated for by tilting the coupler cavity by an appropriate angle with respect to the axial direction of the rest of the section. Since these solutions pose difficult fabrication problems, a simpler technique was used at SLAC. It consists of feeding successive accelerator sections from alternate sides and furthermore, of letting the effect of the input and output couplers partially cancel each other by having them on the same side. (For further details and results see Borghi et al. [I9661 and SLAC-50 [1965].) With these remedies, steering effects can be kept to a minimum. Matching and tuning. If the process of machining parts and fabricating an accelerator structure could be controlled with perfect accuracy, a section such as the one shown in fig. 32 would be ready for use immediately after manufacturing. In practice, such a control is difficult and uneconomical. As discussed in ch. B.2.2, most manufacturers prefer to build their structures to relaxed tolerances and end up correcting the imperfections through final tuning and matching. The process of t~lning is intended to adjust the phase shift of every cavity to the design value. It generally consists of changing the cavity dimensions by adjusting the degree of insertion of a small tuning plunger or by applying a controlled external mechanical pressure to impart a permanent deformation to the cavity wall. Matching is done by adjusting the dimensions of the coupler cavities described in the previous section of this chapter so as to insure a low standing-wave ratio at the input and output of the structure. As will be shown briefly below, one of the main difficulties stems from the fact that the two processes are not independent. The problem of tuning and matching an accelerator section can best be ~lnderstood in the broader context of the general problem of measuring impedances at microwave
100
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Fig. 32. SLAC ten-foot constant gradient accelerator section.
frequencies through one or several junctions. The junctions in this case are the couplers. The main tool for these measurements is the Smith chart. Comprehensive descriptions of the pertinent techniques can be found, for example, in Deschamps [1953], Chodorow et al. [1955], Mallory [1955], Wentworth and Barthel [1956], Ginzton [1957], Gallagher [1960], BelbCoch [1961], Westbrook [I9631 and Borghi et al. [1966]. The most fundamental idea, common to all these references is the following: the
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
101
D METER
0GENERATOR
{kt, SLOTTED
MOVABLE SHORT
LOAD
\ OUTPUT COUPLER
DETUNING PLUNGER
l NPUT COUPLER
a ) ILLUSTRATION OF VARIOUS ASPECTS OF NODAL
SHIFT TECHNIQUE
MATCHED LOAD PHASE
BRIDGE
I
I I
I I
L------
GENERATOR
\-h&
MICROMETER
//
INPUT COUPLER
b ) PHASE AND AMPLITUDE
/
BEAD ON THREAD
/
U
WEIGHT
OUTPUT COUPLER
M E A S U R E M E N T OF F I E L D
Fig. 33. Experimental set-ups used for matching, tuning and checking field uniformity of accelerating structure.
102
G A L O E W , R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
impedance of a network measured directly is related to the impedance of the same network as seen through a junction by a bilinear and conformal transformation which characterizes the junction. Consequently, the corresponding plots on a Smith chart obey the rules of conformal mapping, namely, that circles transform into circles and angles are preserved. Referring to fig. 33a, the goal of the matching and tuning operation is to obtain a V.S.W.R. equal to unity when the detuning plunger is removed and the output coupler is connected to the load. This condition can fail to be realized for several reasons: mismatch of the output coupler; mismatch of the input coupler; or internal reflections due to imperfections of the periodic structure. All three conditions must be cured individually since compensating one with the other would not result in a uniformly traveling wave of maximum possible amplitude. The measurement is greatly simplified when the frequency is such that the phase shift per cavity is a submultiple of 2n, typically n/2 or 2x13. The input impedance can be measured for two possible conditions. The first consists of connecting the output coupler to a movable short and of measuring the input impedance for known displacements of the movable short, typically 418 or 4/12. The points a, b, c, d, e, f which, seen beyond the output coupler, lie equally spaced on the rim of the chart (see fig. 34a), transform to a circle of reduced size (dependent on the loss in the structure) when referred to a plane corresponding to the matching iris of the input coupler (generally obtained by detuning the coupler cavity with a plunger). The transformation through the output coupler only has the effect of reshuffling the points on the rim of the chart. For a mismatched but perfect periodic structure, two useful points, (I) and (S), can be obtained through this construction. (M) being the geometric center of the circle, the iconocenter (I), constructed as shown, is the input impedance obtained if the output coupler is connected to the matched load. (S), the so-called Smith center, represents the input impedance that would be obtained if a matched load were placed in the periodic structure, downstream of the input coupler. It is obtained by drawing the line MC which intersects the circle at o, and o,,, (where o designates the V.S.W.R.) and finding the point (S) which verifies the relation CS=(o,,,/o,,,)~ [or, conversely, ( o ~ ~ ~ cif Tthe~ circle , ~ ) does ~ not encompass the center of the chart]. With a little experience, the experimenter can deduce from the location of (S) whether the coupler is under- or overcoupled. The proper action, namely increasing or decreasing the size of the matching iris, will then produce a match, i.e., bring points (M), (I) and (S) to the center of the chart. If there were no other unknown, the entire procedure would be straightforward. The difficulty arises from the fact that very often the periodic structure has irregularities which create unknown reflections which add to the remain unknowns is the coupler cavity itself, the size and phase shift of which depends on the aperture of the matching iris. This interaction significantly complicates the entire procedure, particularly for designs with phase shifts per cavity other than n/2.
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.1.1
RADIALLY
-.-- TolmO
S C A L E D PARAMETERS
q= Lo.0
103
5
8
a
a
' i ' ' h Y " i
s '
, , , , , a , , ,b,
8
rb ' i ' k b ' m
Fig. 34a. Nodal shift plot obtained with movable short at output coupler. I n example shown, neither input nor output coupler is matched.
104
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
IMPEDANCE OR ADMITTANCE COORDINATES
Fig. 34b. Nodal shift plot obtained with detuning plunger inside structure. Points C, 1 , 2, 3, 4 . . . correspond to perfectly matched and tuned structure. Points C, l', 2', 3', 4' ... represent imperfect tune with perfect match. Points C, I", 2", 3" ... represent perfect tune with imperfect match.
B.I.1
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
105
At this point, one can consider the second type of measurement which consists of moving the d e t ~ ~ n i nplunger g inside the structure as shown in fig. 33a. If the coupler is perfectly matched and all cavities have 120" of phase shift (see the 2x13-mode example of fig. 34b), pulling the plunger away from the coupler causes the plotted null points to rotate clockwise by 240 electrical degrees on the Smith chart for each cavity length through which the plunger is moved. Starting with the reference point at C obtained by detuning the coupler cavity, points 1, 2, 3, 4 ... move clockwise from 0" to 120" (&I3 or 240" on the chart), from 120" to 240°, from 240" to 0°, and so on. For the first cavities, the V.S.W.R. is nearly infinite and the points are almost on the rim of the chart. Farther down the section, the V.S.W.R. decreases because of the net attenuation. Thus, the plotted points move toward the center of the chart. When a systematic phase shift error exists because of an inaccurate choice of frequency, or a systematic error in fabrication, points 1, 2, 3, 4 . . . appear for example as l', 2', 3', 4' ... . If on the other hand, the coupler is mismatched, the points appear as 1 ",2", 3", 4". .. . At this stage, it is essential to proceed carefully, by successive iterations. Three techniques can be used. The first is to match and tune the coupler by itself using the method suggested by Kyhl [1960], and described by Westbrook [1963]. The second is to assume that at least cavity No. 1 beyond the coupler has the correct phase shift and obtain the iconocenter for points C, I and 2 using the technique described by Wentworth and Barthel [1956]. The point obtained for the plunger in cavity ( 1 ) indicates whether the size of the coupler cavity is approximately correct. Point (2) indicates if the matching iris has approximately the correct width. Having made the proper iterative corrections, it is then possible to move the plunger down the entire structure and tune all cavities for 120" phase shift. The third method is to obtain the impedance circle and Smith center (S), as described earlier, for points such as 8". 9", 10". Moving farther along in the structure is necessary because the first points are still on the rim of the chart and point (S) is hard to obtain from a , and a,,,. The operation of bringing point (S) to the center of the chart is then achieved by iteratively matching the coupler and tuning the successive intermediate cavities. This process is sometimes simplified by replacing the detuning plunger by a partially matched load which reduces the size of the circle and facilitates finding the Smith center (S) (see Gallagher [1960]). The exact choice between these various techniques varies from one laboratory to another and depends, among other factors, on the number of accelerator sections to be fabricated and the degree of control exercised over the manufacturing process. Thus, for example, if the resonant frequency of every cavity is verified and adjusted before final assembly, some of the above steps can be eliminated. Special care must also be taken that the above measurements are performed in a carefully controlled environment. Further details on these techniques can be found in ch. B.2.2. After matching and tuning, it is often of interest, as a final check, to obtain a complete traveling-wave field plot for the entire accelerator section. This plot can be
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
0.24
90
0.22
80
0.20
70
0.18
60
0.16
50
0.14
40
0 12
30
0 10
20
0.08
10
0 0.2 CENTER OF CAVITY
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6 ,1.8 2.0 CE~TER OF Dl SK
2.2
2.4
8"
0
Fig. 35. Amplitude and phase of traveling axial electric field given by measurement of amplitude (SLAC 2x13-mode cavity, where d = cavity and phase of square root of bead reflection coefficient (T). length, t = disk thickness.)
obtained by drawing a small metallic or dielectric needle through the structure as shown in fig. 33b. The relative field amplitude is obtained by measuring either the reflection coefficient caused by the wave reflected from the bead, or the phase shift across the section caused by the forward-scattered wave from the bead. The phase of the field can be measured by noting the phase of the reflection coefficient of the reflected wave. Figure 35 shows the amplitude and phase of the traveling-wave field in a SLAC 2x13-mode cavity. It is seen that the phase is fairly "stationary" in the middle of the cavity but varies rapidly through the disk. Similarly, the amplitude undergoes maxima and minima. These are of course due to the space harmonics. It is interesting to note that one can also recheck the relative amplitude of the space harmonics by using both these amplitude and phase plots. Thus, applying eq. (4) on axis ( r = O ) and integrating over the length of one cavity, one obtains
ai/x
a: can be obtained to a few percent accuracy by calculating only Generally, three or four terms. An example which gives further insight into how three of these space harmonics add and subtract is shown in fig. 36. Notice that if P0d=2rc/3, p,z
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.l.l
107
can be rewritten as (1 + 3n)P,z. At z =+d, a,, and a _ , are normal to a,. At z= +d they are again collinear but a,, and a _ ,are of opposite sign to a,. This final field amplitude and phase plot can be of particular help and interest in a constant-gradient structure where doubt may remain, until final assembly, as to whether the desired field uniformity has been achieved.
@
DWELL POINT;z=O;
Po z
a QUADRATURE POINT ; z @
DISK EDGE POINT; z =
=O
$ ; Po z = 3 0 "
9 ; Poz = 6 0 "
Fig. 36. Illustration of how space harmonics add and subtract in a typical SLAC section. It is assumed here that all an vectors are positive.
9 Summary of characteristics of accelerating structures of existing electron linacs To conclude, it seems instructive to show, through some concrete examples, how the theory and design of electron linac structures described in this chapter have in practice
108
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Summary of accelerating structure characteristics for selected electron linacs(') --- - --
Linac identification -
-
--
Type of construction Operating frequency (MHz)
-
-
-
-
-
17 MeV 150 MeV M.I.T. N.B.S. (Cambridge, U.S.A.) (Maryland, U.S.A.) ----Constant Standing-wave impedance --
2802
1299
7
9
Number of sections Length of sections, I (m) Phase shift per cavity Field attenuation, nl (nepers) Shunt impedance for fundamental space harmonic, ro (megohms/m)
0.36 44 (31
Number of constant group velocity segments within one section
1
1
Group velocity (v,/c)
0
0.0048
Q Filling time (4) (psec)
Waveguide diameter, 2b (cm)
Iris aperture diameter, 2a (cm)
Disk thickness (cm) Klystron peak output power rating (MW) Average number of accelerator sections per klystron Rf duty cycle Average energy gradient at nominal operating level (keV/cm)
0.3175
1.341
0.25 (Magnetron)
5
113 (3 Magnetrons/section)
1
-
2.4
x
2.18 27
x
w 70
I . Quantities in brackets indicate that more than one value or range of values are applicable. 2. Some of the numbers given in this column were actually published for the 360-MeV Kharkov accelerator. It is believed that these numbers are the same for the 2-GeV machine.
--
--
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
-
--
-
-
P A
450 MeV Adone mjector (Frascat~,Italy) -
-
Approximately constant gradlent -
--
-
-
57.3 +56.8 50.7 -+ 56.1 49.8+56.8
(0.54,0.57, 1.19)
2.3 GeV (Orsay, France)
2 GeV ( 4 (Kharkov, U.S.S.R.)
20 GeV SLAC (Stanford, U S.A.)
Approximately constant gradient
Constant impedance
Constant gradlent
-
--
-
-
45 old (42, 52) - new
43 1: 3
(52 ; . 60)
3 - old 6-new
I
Continuous taper
0.375
0.83
3.09
2.622 + 1.9235
unknown
0.5842
-
= 0.93-
old
8.1968+8.210 8.415 + 8.2276 8.4546+8.2100
unknown
2.0338 +2.0892 2.8385 +2.1747 2.9565 -+2.0892
(2.7 + 1.9)- old (2.96 -t 2.11) ) (2.8 -t 1.82) \ - new
0.5842
109
0.3000
3. In this column, the shunt impedance includes the contribution of both the n = O and n = - l space harmonics. 4. For the standing-wave case, the filling time is defined as 2 Q ~ / w Q/co where QI. is the loaded Q . For the traveling-wave cases, it is defined as /lug.
-
110
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
been applied. Ten years ago, a compilation of all electron linac structures would have been a fairly easy task. Today it is not feasible because of the multitude and variety of accelerators that have been built. Furthermore, certain special types of electron linacs will be described in later chapters of this book and will not be covered here. For this reason table 1 presents the characteristics of only a few selected accelerating structures. This selection has been made to obtain a fairly representative coverage of designs in terms of time of construction, countries, types, etc. Low energy and/or high intensity, high duty cycle machines such as the A.L.S. (Saclay, France), and M.I.T. (Cambridge, U.S.A.) accelerators presently under construction and superconducting accelerators in the planning stage are not included here (see ch. B.3.2). The 17 MeV M.I.T. accelerator in the first column is included because it was one of the early operational machines (see Demos et al. [1952]) and it offers an interesting contrast in that it is the only accelerator operating in the standing-wave 7c mode, all others in this table being of the traveling-wave type. The 150 MeV N.B.S. (Maryland, U.S.A.) accelerator was built by the High Voltage Engineering Corp., Burlington, Mass. A comprehensive description was given by Leiss [1966]. It provides a typical example of an L-band accelerator. The 450 MeV Adone Injector, built by Varian Associates, Palo Alto, California, was designed for electron as well as for positron acceleration. The injector and the first three sections are built for high current acceleration, the last eight sections for high energy gain. This difference in purpose explains the difference between the two types of structures. (See, for example, Nunan 119651 and Haimson [1965].) The 2.3 GeV Orsay linac was built in two stages. The first part consisting of 22 sections and giving an energy of 1.25 GeV has been operational since approximately 1959. (See, for example, Z'Onde Electrique [1963].) The second part, an extension installed upstream of the first part, became operational in 1968. Similarly to the Adone Injector, it contains seven sections for high current acceleration designed for positron generation followed by eight sections for high energy gain. (For a description of this extension, see MClard [1967].) The 2 GeV Kharkov accelerator was perhaps the first linac of the new generation of extra long machines. Some of its characteristics were very similar to the earlier 360 MeV Kharkov accelerator. Both these machines are described in some detail by Val'ter et a/. [1963]. Finally, the last column contains some of the characteristics of the 20 GeV SLAC accelerator, which became operational in 1966. It has been described in numerous documents (for example, see Borghi et al. [I9661 or Neal [1967]). It is believed to be the first accelerator in which the constant gradient field was obtained by a smooth continuous tapered structure. Its energy can be gradually expanded to 40 GeV by increasing the number and power output of the klystrons. The SLAC accelerator was in many ways the logical outcome of experience gained at Stanford over a period of twenty years with shorter accelerators and particularly with the 1.2 GeV Mark 111 (see Chodorow et al. [1955]). This machine originally operated in the 7112 constant-
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
111
i m p e d a n c e traveling-wave mode a n d w a s later c o n v e r t e d to o p e r a t e w i t h S L A C - t y p e (2x13, c o n s t a n t gradient) sections. P l a n s a r e presently being m a d e to rebuild i t i n t o a
I
G e V superconducting accelerator. W h i l e this t a b l e illustrates a wide variety o f designs, t h e f e a t u r e m o s t striking to
be t h e a m a z i n g similarity between the structures used i n a l l these accelerators. Aside from the L-band N.B.S. m a c h i n e , t h e range of variation of t h e v a r i o u s p a r a m e t e r s is extremely n a r r o w . It seems to illustrate t h e f a c t that d u r i n g any given period o f time, all designers, regardless of geographical location, use the best k n o w n ideas until a new d r a s t i c technological jump is made. W h e t h e r the advent of the reader
may
well
t h e s u p e r c o n d u c t i n g linac is i n f a c t this drastic j u m p will b e f o r t h e historians to decide
at a l a t e r date. References
BANFORD, A. P. and H. G. STAFFORD, 1961, J. Nucl. Energy, Part C 3, 287. BAREFORD, C. F. and M. G. KELLIHER, 1953, Philips Tech. Rev. 15, No. 1 , pp. 1-26. BELBEOCH, R., 1961, Problemes PosCs par I'Adaptation du Coupleur d'EntrCe d'une Structure en Guide Chargk par des Iris, Rapport LAL-13, Laboratoire de I'AcceICrateur Lineaire, Orsay, France. B~.RGERE, R., H. BEIL,and A. VEYSSIERE, 1965, Rapport CEA, R 2843. Centre d'Etudes Nucltaires, Saclay, France. BERTOZZI, W., J. HAIMSON, C. P. SARGENT, and W. T U T C H I N E T 1967, ~ , The MIT High Duty, High Intensity 400 MeV Linear Electron Accelerator, IEEETrans. Nucl. Sci. NS-14, No. 3, pp. 191-196. BEVENSEE, R. M., 1964, Electromagnetic Slow Wave Systems (John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, London and Sydney). BORGHI, R. P., A. L. ELDREDGE, G. A. LOEW,and R. B. NEAL,1966, In: Young, L., ed., Advances in Microwaves 1 (Academic Press, New York and London), pp. 1-73. BRILLOUIN, L., 1946, Wave Propagation in Periodic Structures, 2nd ed. (Dover Publ. Inc., McGrawHill Book Co., Inc., New York). BRILLOUIN, L., 1960, Wave Propagation and Group Velocity (Academic Press, New York and London). BUECHNER, W. W., R. J. VANDE GRAAFF, A. SPERDUTO, L. R. MCINTOSH, and E. A. BURRILL, 1947, Rev. Sci. Instr. 18, No. 10, pp. 754-766. CHODOROW, M.. E. L. GINZTON, W. W. HANSEN, R. L. KYHL,R. B. NEAL,and W. K. H. PANOFSKY, 1955, Rev. Sci. Instr. 26, No. 2, pp. 134-204. 1947, J. Appl. Phys. 8, 996. CHU,E. L. and W. W. HANSEN, 1949, J. Appl. Phys. 20, 280. CHU,E. L. and W. W. HANSEN, CHU,E. L., 1951, The Theory of Linear Electron Accelerators, Report No. 140, Microwave Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, California. DAHL,P. F., K. JELLETT, G. PARZEN,S. GIORDANO, and J. P. HANNWACKER, 1966, Linac Cavity Field Calculations, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, pp. 115-1 18. P. T., A. F. KIP, and J . C. SLATER, 1952, J. Appl. Phys. 23, No. 1, 53-65. DEMOS, DESCHAMPS, G. A,, 1953, J. Appl. Phys. 24, 1046. D E VRIES,C., 1967, Existing and Proposed Linear Electron Accelerators at the Institute for Nuclear Research, Amsterdam, Proceedings of the Meeting on the Use of Electron Linear Accelerators for Nuclear Structure Study (to be published), Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati (Italy). G. T. and G. 1. COHN,1951, Dielectric Loading for Waveguide Linear Accelerators, TransFLESHER, actions of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers, 70, pp. 887-893. FRY,D. W. and W. WALKINSHAW, 1948-9, Rep. Progr. Physics 12, 102-132. W. J., 1960, Measurement Techniques for Periodic Structures, M Report NO. 205, GALLAGHER, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California.
112
G.A.LOEW, R.B.NEAL
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
GINZTON, E. L., 1957, Microwave Measurements (McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., New York). S., 1965, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, pp. 213-216. GIORDANO, J., 1965, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, pp. 499-507. HAIMSON, HELM,R., 1966, Computer Study of Wave Propagation, Beam Loading and Beam Blowup in the SLAC Accelerator, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, pp. 254-266. HOYT,C. H., 1966, Designing Resonant Cavities with the LALA Computer Program, Proceedmgs of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, pp. 119-124. KNAPP,E., 1964, 800 MeV R F Structures, Proceedings of the 1964 Linear Accelerator Conference, MURA 714, pp. 31-59. (Available from the Clearinghouse for Federal Scientific and Technical Information, National Bureau of Standards, U.S. Department of Commerce, Springfield, Virginia). KYHL,R. L., 1960, Department of Electrical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts (private communication). LAWTON, E. J. and W. C. HAHN,1948, J. Appl. Phys. 19, 648. LEBOUTET, H., 1963, Problemes Physiques de la Construction de 1'Accelerateur 1 GeV, I'Onde Electrique, No. 435, Vol. 43, 599. H., G. AZAM,R. BENSUSSAN, G. BLAISE, M. DELMON, J. P. MANGIN, J. SOFFER, 1966, Some LEBOUTET, Characteristic Problems of the New High Duty Cycle Saclay Electron Linac, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, pp. 426-434. LEISS,J. E., 1966, The NBS Linac, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, pp. 20-27. L'ONDEELECTRIQUE, 1963, L'Acctltrateur Lineaire D'Orsay, Vol. 43, No. 435. MALLORY, K. B., 1955, A Comparison of the Predicted and Observed Performances of a Billion-Volt Electron Accelerator, HEPL Report No. 46, W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California. MELARD, L., 1967, Note Technique No. 83.A.8, Sections Accelbatrices D'Orsay, LM/MLN No. 016167, Laboratoire de 1'Acci.Ierateur LinCaire Service "Faisceau", Orsay, France. NAGLE,D. E., 1964, Coupled Resonator Model of Linear Accelerator Tanks, Proceedings of the 1964 Linear Accelerator Conference, MURA 714, pp. 21-30. (Available from the Clearinghouse for Federal Scientific and Technical Information, National Bureau of Standards, U S . Department of Commerce, Springfield, Virginia.) NAGLE,D. E., E. A. KNAPP,and B. C. KNAPP,1967, A Coupled Resonantor Model for Standing Wave Accelerator Tanks, University of California Los Alamos ScientificLaboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico (to be published). NEAL,R. B., 1953, A High Energy Linear Electron Accelerator, M. L. Report No. 185, Microwave Laboratory, W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California, pp. 255-266. NEAL,R. B., 1958, Theory of the Constant Gradient Linear Electron Accelerator, M. L. Report No. 513, Microwave Laboratory, W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California. NEAL,R. B., 1961, Comparison of the Constant Gradient and Uniform Accelerator Structures, M Report No. 259, W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California. NEAL,R. B., 1967, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-14, No. 3, pp. 705-720. NEAL,R. B., 1968, Consideration of the Use of Feedback in a Traveling Wave Superconductmg Accelerator, TN-68-1, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. NISHIKAWA, T., S. GIORDANO, and D. CARTER, 1966, Rev. Sci. Instr. 37, No. 5, pp. 652-661. NUNAN, C. S., 1965, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, pp. 465-469. 1953, Fields and Waves in Modern Radio, 2nd ed. (John Wiley and RAMO,S. and J. R. WHINNERY, Sons, Inc., New York; Chapman and Hall, Ltd., London). ROBSON, P. N., 1956, Fourier Series Representations of Dispersion Curves for Circular Corrugated Waveguide Used in Traveling-Wave Linear Accelerators, Report No. 5 105, Metropolitan-Vickers Electrical Company, Ltd., Manchester, England.
B.l.l
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
113
SARAZIN, A,, 1953, Annales de Radioelectricit6 8, 134. R.-SHERSBY-HARVIE, R. B. and L. B. MULLETT, 1949, Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) B62, 270. R.-SHERSBY-HARVIE, R. B., 1948, Nature 162, p. 890. H. A,, P. B. WILSON,and G. Y. CHURILOV,1965, Measurements at High Electric SCHWETTMAN, Field Strengths on Superconducting Accelerator Cavities, Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators (Frascati), Comitato Nazionale per I'Energia Nucleare, Rome, Italy, pp. 690-692. H. A,, J. P. TURNEAURE, W. M. FAIRBANK, T. I. SMITH,M. S. MCASHAN, P. B. WILSON, SCHWETTMAN. 1967, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-14, No. 3, pp. 336-344. and E. E. CHAMBERS, SLAC-50, 1965, Consolidation of Results of Preliminary Beam Tests with Sectors 1 and 2, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California. SLATER, J . C., 1950, Microwave Electronics (D. Van Nostrand Company, Inc., New York), Chapters 4 and 5. SMITH,T. I., 1966, Standing Wave Modes in a Superconducting Linear Accelerator, HEPL 437, High Energy Physics Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, California. SMITH,T. I., H. A. SCHWETTMAN, W. M. FAIRBANK, and P. B. WILSON,1966, Stanford's Superconducting Accelerator Program, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, pp. 491 -493. SOKOLOVSKY, A,, 1966, The New High Duty Cycle High Current 600 MeV Electron-Positron Linear Accelerator of Saclay, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, pp. 417-425. VAL'TER, A. K., I. A. GRISHAEV, E. V. EREMENKO, V. V. KONDRATENKO, G. A. ZEITLENOK, G. F. KUZNETSOV, L. M. LEVIN,1. F. MALYSHEV, V. V. RUMYANTSEV, A. N. SEMENOV, F. F. TURKIN,and V. K. KHOKHLOV, 1963, The 2 GeV Traveling-Wave Linear Accelerator, International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Dubna, U.S.S.R., Conf-114, Book 1, pp. 520-525. VASTEL, J., 1952, Annales de Radioelectricite 6, 20. WALKER, G. B. and N. D. WEST, 1957, IEEE Proceedings 104C. p. 381. D. A,, 1958, Topics in Electromagnetic Theory (John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York; WATKINS, Chapman and Hall, Ltd., London), Chapter 1. WEAVER, J. N., T. I. SMITH,and P. B. WILSON,1967, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-14, No. 3, pp. 345-349. 1956, IRE Transactions on Microwave Theory and TechWENTWORTH, F. L. and D. R. BARTHEL, niques, M T T 4 , p. 173. WESTBROOK, E., 1963, Microwave Impedance Matching of Feed Waveguides to the Disk-Loaded Accelerator Structure Operating in the 2n/3 mode, TN-63-103, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. WILSON,P. B., 1963, Nucl. Instr. Methods 20, 336. and W. M. FAIRBANK,1963, Status of Research at Stanford WILSON,P. B., H. A. SCHWETTMAN University on Superconducting Electron Linacs, Proceedings of the International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Dubna (Atomizdat, Moscow, 1964), p. 535. 1965, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, pp. 1045-1052. WILSON,P. B. and H. A. SCHWETTMAN,
ELA THEORY
1.2
B.l
Particle Dynamics R. H. HELM R. MILLER Stanford Linear Accelerator Center Stanford, California, U.S.A.
1 Introduction 1.1 Summary and scope
Although the particle dynamics of electron linacs and proton linacs are in principle completely analogous, great quantitative and practical contrasts arise from the vastly greater charge-to-mass ratio of the electron. Thus to gain an energy increment equal to its rest energy in an accelerating gradient of 50 kV/cm, an electron would travel only about 10 cm, while a proton would require nearly 200 m. Consequently in an electron machine even of modest energy, the particles are highly relativistic over most of the length; transverse rf forces virtually disappear because of the cancellation of electric and magnetic forces at relativistic velocities, and longitudinal bunching motions become negligible because of the increasing "longitudinal mass" proportional to Y 3 ; the problems of acceleration and beam transport are essentially decoupled. The high elm of the electron also has consequences in the injection region. The rapid initial acceleration of the electrons is accompanied by the possibility of rather efficient capture and bunching in constant phase-velocity sections, and this property is often exploited to greatly simplify buncher design. Although bunchers employing tapered phase-velocity sections have higher theoretical capture efficiencies, they are rather inflexible in operation and are seldom used. Thus the concepts of synchronous phase velocity and synchronous phase angle often are irrelevant in electron machines. The present chapter, which is concerned with the particle dynamics of electron linacs specifically, is divided into the following topics: (1) Injection dynamics, including general philosophy of buncher design, gun 0 Norfh-HollunilPubl. Co., Amsferdam 1969
References p. 145
115
R.H. HELM, R. MILLER
116
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
optics, prebunching, longitudinal and transverse motion in the capture region, and focusing. (2) Asymptotic high energy dynamics. (3) External focusing requirements for high energy transport, especially in very long machines. (4) Transverse perturbing effects such as misalignments and stray magnetic fields.
1.2 Units and conventions Dimensional equations will be expressed nominally in MKS units. However it will be convenient to introduce several special definitions which will simplify the equations of motion; in particular the symbol p (and its rectangular components p,, p,, p,) will designate normalized momenta, i.e.,
P
--YB
-
(1)
and normalized field quantities d and B? will be defined by
d
e~/rnc~
(2)
The scale factors mc=O.5ll MeVlc, mc2/e=0.51 1 MV, and mc/e= 1.705 x lo-' weber/m= 1.705 kG-cm will be useful occasionally. Note that 8 and 99 have units of (length)-'. The symbols y and P have their usual significance as normalized energy and velocity. The coordinate system will always be chosen such that the z-axis is the accelerator symmetry axis.
2.1 Longitudinal motion As stated in ch. B.l.l, the longitudinal electric fields in a periodic traveling wave accelerator structure having cylindrical symmetry can be written* Q)
E,
= exp j ( a t -
k,z) n=-m
- jEn& (k,,r) exp (- 2jnnzld)
(4)
where d is the periodic length, k, is the propagation constant of the fundamental space harmonic, and
k& = k 2 - ( k , + 2nr1/d)~,
*
k = 2n/A
For a discussion of the fields in periodic structures see Slater [I9501or Chu [1951].
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
B.1.2
117
In addition, when d = n / k , and IE(_n-,,I = IE,,], eq. (4) is the expansion for a standing wave in a periodic structure with a period which is an integer submultiple of d (i.e., n,n / 2 , ... mode). If the origin of z is chosen to be a plane of symmetry of the structure, the E,, are $1 real. The gain in energy per unit length in the paraxial approximation is just e times the real part of EZ,so dy/d:
b,J, ( k ~sin) (0 + 2 x n z l d )
=n
where t',, = eE,/mc2 and
Bp is the
normalized phase velocity and has been included in the integrand to cover structures in which the phase velocity is a slow function of position. While eqs. (5) and (6) are suitable for numerical integration of the longitudinal motion of low current beams in either traveling wave or standing wave accelerators, considerable physical insight can be gained by making simplifying assumptions or approximations which permit analytic solutions. The first of these is that B=Bp so that 8 does not vary rapidly over wide ranges. In this case, the force from the n=O space harmonic dominates the motion of the particle, since the forces from all other space harmonics oscillate rapidly with a sin ( 0 + 2nnzld) dependence. This approximation which is excellent in the relativistic limit is only fair in the injection region. The equations resulting from neglecting the other space harmonics and assuming that r, r', and 4' are first order quantities are*
These can be combined into a form which is integrable for ,!Ip and t', constant:
Integration by inspection and substitution of y2 = p 2 f 1 yields the equation for the particle orbits in phase space
where A is the constant of integration.
*
The reference of phase 0 is such that the electric field is 0 for 0 =O.
R.H.HELM, R. MILLER
118
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Plots of eq. (9) due to Slater [I9481 are given in figs. 1 and 2 for Bp < 1 and Pp= 1 respectively.* It follows from the symmetry of the cosine that orbits are symmetrical about Q = O (the phase stable field null); a particle which passes through a point (p,, 0) will also pass through the point (p,, - B), if it stays within the structure. It is evident from eq. (8) that phase extrema, Q = Om, occur when PP= ( y 2 - I)) y = P. Thus, for bound orbits
+
and
k cos 8 - cos 8, = -Pp&o
+ I)* - (1 - pi)+ - bpP] .
Fig. 1. Longitudinal phase space for Bp< 1.
"
*
- Fig. 2.
Longitudinal phase space for 8, = 1.
A very complete discussion of this analytic solution is given by DGme [1960].
-'
PARTICLE
B.1.2
DYNAMICS
119
2.1.1 Phase velocity less than c Consider the case when p, < c shown in fig. 1. Each value of cos 8, gives a different orbit. If cosO,< - 1 then the orbit is not closed and if the initial momentum PO corresponds to ljp, the particle will continually advance with respect to the wave as in orbit u2. If cosB,= - 1, the particle velocity p will approach the phase velocity p, as the phase approaches _+n. The point @=/I,, 8= +z) is a point of unstable equilibrium. In this case, however, since the force from the fundamental space harmonic vanishes, it is not valid to neglect the fields from the other space harmonics. When 1 >cosO,> - I the particles execute an oscillatory motion in P and 0. It can be shown that for small excursions in p and 0 the orbits approximate ellipses centered around (/I=flp, tI=O). If an ensemble of particles with a relatively large phase extent d(Ir and small momentum extent dp, enters such a structure, then after traversing $ of a phase oscillation it will have a small phase extent AO, and large momentum extent Ap,. If the ratio of phase excursion to momentum excursion in the structure is QZ/p2 the bunching action can be described (Miller et al. [1965]) in the small orbit limit by
A03
AP, =
2 do,
AP, .
Thus if (HJP~)<(AO,/A~,), phase compression, or bunching, occurs. In practical bunchers the phase compression is never as great as indicated by eq. (1 l), since the higher order terms cause the period of phase oscillation to increase with increasing amplitude which has the effect of introducing an “S” curve distortion in the emittance area of the buncher. In addition space charge forces and the second order radial variation of E, degrade the bunching action. Space charge forces in linear accelerator bunchers are best treated by computer studies such as those discussed by Haimson (19651 and Haimson and Mecklenburg [ 19671. 2.1.2 Phase velocity equals c When /I, = I, dQ/dz is always negative [see eq. (7b)], and the orbits become open-ended as shown in fig. 2. Equation (10) for the orbits in phase space becomes coso-coso,=;
(12)
(p2+q+-P 0
where Q,,, has been renamed 0, to emphasize that it corresvonds threshold for capture is cos0-cos 0,=2, or Q,(thresh.)/k = +[(Pi + I)* - PO1 *
to D=CO.
The
(13)
R.H.HELM. R.MILLER
120
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
Of particular interest is a field strength just twice the threshold. For this case a particle entering the structure with a phase 8, =0, has an asymptotic phase 8, = - n/2, the point of maximum acceleration. In addition dO,/d8,
= sin @,/sin8, = 0
and d28,/d0g
= (sin Om)-'
is minimized for the case 8, = - 4 2 . Thus, this case gives both maximum energy and maximum phase compression. In the limit of small phase interval one finds the asymptotic phase interval for this case given by A8, =$(A80)2. To relate this ideal case to the real world consider 80 keV electrons. Then
If I =I0 cm, then E, = 185 kV/cm, which is a reasonable field strength, and injection of sub-relativistic electrons into a velocity of light structures is often done. However, since the required field goes as 111, this is not feasible for wavelengths appreciably below 10 cm. In order to observe how rapidly the electrons approach their asymptotic phase, consider eq. (1 2) for the case p 9 1. Then
so when the electrons have reached 5 MeV/c in the case cited above, they are within 5" of their asymptotic phase, and their energy gain is essentially linear. 2.1.3
Variable 8,
When 8, is restricted to values appreciably less than optimum for a velocity of light structure, or when it is desired to capture a very high percentage of the incoming electrons, it may be desirable to build a structure in which fl, and perhaps 8, are functions of z. In such structures the particles normally enter with a velocity equal to or slightly less than the velocity of the wave. The particles begin to oscillate in phase about a reference particle whose phase is either constant or slowly varying in the range from 0 to -7112. In this quadrant the particles gain energy, which causes the amplitude of the phase oscillation to decrease. If, in addition, the field 8,is also increased, the phase oscillation amplitude decreases even more. Using tapered fields and phase velocities, Chodorow et al. [1955] have shown that it is possible to capture as much as 95% of the entering electrons. The first order bunching action can be observed by expanding the longitudinal coordinates about the coordinates, 8(,,, y(,,, of a particular reference particle:
B.1.2
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
121
Inserting these in eqs. (7) yields =-
o
o;,, = k y l ( y ;
( C O S B ~(,,,)
-
I)-+.
Combining eqs. (1 5 ) one finds (Miller [1964])
Thus for - (7r/2)< O,,, < 0 the particles execute damped harmonic motion around the reference particle. Defining the frequency and damping coefficient in the normal manner, W, =
[ k (?:,, - l)-QB, cos O,,,]"
cc, = +y(,,(y:o, 2
2
SZz = W ,
- I)-'
Bo sin 8(,,
(17)
- CIz2
and assuming that o,and cc, are slowly varying quantities, one finds the solution Z
when a,Gw, the amplitude of the phase oscillation is proportional to [(yf0, -
I)* 8ocos v(,,]-"
=P,: ( 6 , cos u(,,)-'.
Thus the phase oscillation amplitude decreases as the momentum p(,, and field 8,,, increase.
2.2 Transverse motions
2.2.1
Phase space
The ease with which a relativistic particle beam can be transported over long distance, the precision with which the beam energy can be measured and the precision with which scattering angles can be determined in a physics experiment all depend on the transverse phase space area (or emittance) of the beam. Since. as will be shown, the radial forces due to rf field in a linear accelerator vanish as y - 2 , the emittance of an electron linear accelerator is largely determined in the electron gun and transrelativistic regions of the accelerator. In this chapter, the following general definition of phase space volume will be employed :
R.H. HELM, R. MILLER
122
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
where (x, p,), (y, p,), and (8, y) are conjugate coordinate pairs appropriate to a Hamiltonian system in which the independent variable is the longitudinal coordinate, z. According to Liouville's Theorem, the coordinates of a given set of particles are contained in a volume which is invariant provided that only non-dissipative forces act on the particles. In beam transport it often happens that one or more components of the motion are decoupled from other motions, so that phase volumes are conserved in certain sub-spaces; e.g., the projected phase plane areas ux
=
[I
dx dpx,
uy =
jI
dy dpY,
u,
=
jj
do dy
(19)
might all be conserved. Frequently the coupling between different components is weak enough to permit the use of perturbation calculations in which such subspace projections of the phase volume are conserved as a first approximation. Because of the conservation, whether exact or approximate, the concept of emittance, defined as the phase space occupied by the beam emitted from a source, is useful as a figure of merit. For example, a small transverse emittance implies that the beam may be focused in such a way as to have simultaneously a moderate size and a very small transverse momentum, so that it may consequently be transmitted for long distances without further focusing. Small transverse emittance also implies that the beam may be focused to very small size without excessive angular spread - a desirable property for allowing a small target size for physics experiments. The concept of phase space is also useful in specifying the properties of a beam transport system. Here the admittance, the maximum phase space which can be transmitted through the system, serves as a figure of merit. Clearly, the emittance of the beam to be transmitted imposes a lower limit on the required transport system admittance. It is customary to describe the emittance and admittance in terms of equivalent ellipsoids in phase space. This is a useful convention because of the convenient properties of the quadratic form in linear transformations. As a simple illustration of phase space quantities, consider the transmission through a channel of constant aperture, a, in the absence of transverse forces; for simplicity, consider only the x component of motion. The transformation through the channel is p, x where
= pxo = constant = xo
+
CPXO
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
B.1.2
123
and y = ( Y 2 - I)* is the scalar momentum. In fig. 3 the vertical lines x, = +a represent the limits in phase space imposed at the entrance to the channel, and the diagonal lines s,+~p,,= + a represent the limits at any later point. Thus the parallelogram 1234 represents the admittance of the channel; any point within this parallelogram represents the coordinates (x,, p,,) of a n injected particle which can be transmitted from z, t o z. The inscribed ellipse, by convention, is usually designated as the admittance; the area of the ellipse is u = nu
2
I[.
Fig. 3. Transverse phase space acceptance in a n unfocused channel.
Emittances of typical injectors are found to be on the order of or less than 0.01n rnc.cm corresponding to n milliradian.cm a t 5 MeV. Consider a hypothetical linac mc.cm, radial aperture a = 1 cm, with injection at 5 MeV, injector emittance 0 . 0 1 ~ and accelerating to 500 MeV in 100 m. The admittance at the 5 MeV point then would be uz0.02n mc.cm; hence, in principle, if the injector emittance were matched to the adnittance ellipse by suitable initial focusing, no additional focusing along the 100 m length would be required. Even in a machine such as SLAC (3 km, 20 GeV) little or no focusing would be required, theoretically, beyond initial matching. On the other hand, several linacs are designed to produce and accelerate positrons (see ch. B.3.5) in which case, because of the large emittance inherent in the electromagnetic shower production process, it is desirable to attain much larger admittance. Typical design admittances for positron accelerators are in the range of about 0.171 t o .rr, in mc.cm units. Further, as will be seen, rather large admittance is also
124
R.H.HELM, R. MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
desirable for transport of the normal electron beams, because of the various perturbing effects. 2.2.2 Electron gun The minimum emittance an electron gun can have is determined by the area and temperature of the cathode. The electron emitted from the cathode have a mean square transverse velocity due to thermal energy given by (0,') =
kT/m
so the emittance due to thermal velocities is U, = nr,
( m k ~ ) ~
(22)
where r, is the cathode radius. For thermionic emitters kTvaries from 0.1 eV for oxide cathodes to 0.2 eV for pure metal emitters, so a gun with a radius of 1 cm has emittance due to thermal velocities of z 5 x 10-47c mcecm. In practical guns for electron linear accelerators aberrations, rather than thermal velocities, probably dominate the emittance. One important aberration is produced by the use of an intercepting control grid to vary the current from the gun. Each of the apertures of the grid acts as a tiny lens introducing a range of transverse momenta to the particles which pass through it. Assuming round apertures in an infinitely thin grid and using a cylindrical coordinate system with z normal to the grid surface and r the distance from the center of the aperture, the transverse momentum impulse given to a particle passing through the aperture at radius r is
when 8, and 8, are the normalized electric field on either side of the grid. If r, is the radius of the beam at the grid and ra is the radius of the apertures in the grid, the increase in emittance caused by the grid is
If E, =400 V/cm, E, = lo4 Vlcm, r,= I cm and r, =0.03 cm, /?=0.02, then A M ,% 1.4 x 10-'n mc.cm. For these values which are fairly typical much of the operation of the grid controlled gun used at the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (Miller et al. [1967]) this grid aberration is more important in the emittance than thermal velocities. In addition to this aberration there are normally spherical aberrations associated with the electrostatic and magnetic focusing in the gun region. 2.2.3 Transverse motion in rf fields Application of V.E=O and V x H=aD/dt to eq. (4) for the longitudinal electric
B.1.2
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
125
field produces the equations for the radial electric and azimuthal magnetic field respectively in a n accelerator structure: m
where k,, = k z + 2rrnld. The term j (dE,,/dz) in eq. (24) represents the fringing fields which arise at the input and output of the structure and whenever E n is a function of i as in tapered bunchers. Expanding J , ( k r n r )for kr,r-@ 1, and considering only the n=O space harmonic, one obtains for the radial equation of motion
where p r = p r f = p y r f . It is instructive to evaluate eq. (26) for certain simple cases where approximations permit integration. First consider the case where p,= 1, so that
Then eq. (26) becomes
It has been shown that a sub-relativistic electron entering a velocity of light structure with the appropriate field strength, rapidly approaches a n asymptotic phase of - n/2, and gains energy linearly after a short distance. Since the radial force in the interior (where d6,ldrzO) is proportional to y - 2 cos8 it is reasonable to integrate eq. (27) by assuming the radius is constant, r = r o , in the region where the radial force acts. Thus in the impulse approximation for entrance fringing field and capture region of a velocity of light accelerator, Do being the initial electron velocity: Ap,=
[(I
+
io) oo sin
- sin 0,
I
.
For 8,% O and 0, z -7r/2, this is a divergent lens of focal length
Since the initial momentum po is typically between t m c and mc, the focal length is ap-
R.H. HELM. R. MILLER
126
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
proximately 8,' which is the distance in which an electron on the crest increase its energy by its rest energy, mc2. In typical low duty-cycle electron accelerators this is typically about 5 cm. It should be noted that because of this short focal length the thin lens or impulse approximation used to obtain it is not very good, and consequently eq. (28) may appreciably underestimate the change in radial momentum. The thin lens approximation can be made with better accuracy for the typical prebuncher cavity. Equation (27) is easily integrated to give Prebuncher : Ap, z
k&,lr, 2 - --
1 - /I:
B;-
-
COS 80
where do is the phase when the electron reaches the middle of the gap, and I is the gap length. The focal length for small 0 is Prebuncher: f z
28; (1 - B;)-"~; kb,l k2,l' -
-
-
This is exactly twice what might be called the longitudinal focal length: the drift distance at which particles with 0 , 4 1 cross in phase the particles with 8 , =O. The average radial momentum imparted to the electrons by the rf fields in the injection region can easily be compensated for by suitable magnetic focusing elements. Of greater significance is the fact the radial momentum inparted is phase dependent, and consequently increases the projection on the transverse plane of the volume occupied by the beam in phase space. Since the bunching process is quite nonlinear, and the longitudinal phase area becomes quite convoluted, this increase in projected transverse emittance is essentially irreversible. The increase in emittance is 71 times the product of the beam radius and Ap, for an electron at the edge of the bunch. Thus for the capture region of a velocity of light section the increase in transverse phase area is
/3,
= I: d u
FZ
+nb,r;(l
+ Do) Ad,
(32)
and for a prebuncher
where A8 is half the phase interval of the incoming bunch. Since the increase in emittance is proportional to r 2 it is important to focus the beam to a small diameter in the bunching regions where the beam is at a phase-stable, radially defocusing phase. For long tapered bunchers in which PzP, and 8,zO the radial equation of motion (26) can be written in a form which is very similar to eq. (16) for the longitudinal motion: r" - y (y2 - I)-' 6, (sin 8) r' - $k (y2- 1)-t b, (COS 8) r
=0.
(34)
B. 1.2
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
127
Evidently the radial oscillation frequency is related to the longitudinal oscillation frequency by
so in region of phase stability around 0 = 0, the radius grows approximately exponentially by a factor of e in roughly of a phase oscillation.
+
2.2.4
Magnetic ,focusing
I n almost all electron linear accelerators some focusing is required to counteract the effects of space charge forces, rf forces and non-zero transverse emittance of the beams. The predominant choice is to focus with axial magnetic field devices which are more convenient in the transrelativistic region than either electrostatic lenses (except in the gun itself) or magnetic quadrupoles. Since it is clearly undesirable, except in special cases such as hollow beams, to have the magnetic field penetrate the cathode, it will be assumed here that the magnetic field at the cathode is essentially zero. The focusing action of a n axial magnetic field is second order, and arises because, as a consequence of the divergence vanishing, there must be radial fields in the region where the beam enters the axial field. This produces a n azimuthal force causing the beam to begin to spiral. The resultant azimuthal velocity rd' and the axial field produce a n inward radial force. Taking the approach similar to that used by Pierce [I9491 and Chodorow and Susskind [1964], one can set the moment of the force around the axis of cylindrical symmetry equal to the rate of change of the angular momentum:
which can be written
The left side of eq. (36) is just the magnetic flux through the cylindrically symmetric surface generated by revolving the electron path around the beam axis. Since V . B =0, it follows that the differential of the magnetic flux within the path is drC/ = 2nd (ymr 4le). Integrating this gives the azimuthal velocity
which is known as Busch's theorem. Neglecting thermal velocities, and assuming that the magnetic field is zero a t the cathode and the B, is independent of radius, one
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
finds
This azimuthal velocity produces a radial force Fr = er$/3,
=-
e2r~;/(2ym).
The rate of change of radial momentum is dpr/dt = F,
+ ymrd2,
and it follows that
Accordingly, using a normalized magnetic field g = e B / m c , the radial equation of motion (26) can be modified to account for an axial magnetic field
3 Long range transport in electron linacs 3.1 Asymptotic high-energy motion
In the previous section it has been shown that electrons which are captured by the accelerating wave become highly relativistic within a few rf wavelengths. Longitudinal bunching motion then damps out rapidly and transverse rf forces become quite small. To show the asymptotic behavior more clearly, it will now be convenient to express the equations of motion in slightly different form. 3.1.1 ParaxiaZ3eZd expansion
Consider an ideal circularly symmetric accelerating field in which all components are independent of the azimuthal angle 4 . Let space charge be ignored. The symmetry is such that
and the longitudinal electric field is of the general form EZ( r , z , t ) = E, ( z , t )
+ r2-E2( z , t ) + r4E4(z, 2) + -...
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
B.1.2
129
It follows from the longitudinal wave equation, (V2- c - 2 ( d 2 / a t 2 ) ) ~ Z =that 0,
where the operator
E (z,t)
= E,
K
and the axial electric field E are defined by
(0, Z , 1 ) .
(44)
Note that E ( z , t ) is the total field along the axis including space harmonics and fringe fields. The divergence equation,
gives by direct integration
Similarly, from one of the curl equations, (V x B),
1 =
a
r dr
(rB4) =
--
1 aEz c ot
it follows that
3.1.2 Longitudinal motion Let the longitudinal coordinates be expanded about the coordinates of a particular reference particle : Y
=
Y ( o ) + Y ( I ) f...
O = Gt0) + O ( , ,
+...
(47a)
(47'3)
where subscript (0) denotes the reference particle and subscript ( I ) denotes first order
130
R.H. HELM, R. MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
deviations; 8 is the phase variable defined previously in eq. (6) as
where pp is the normalized phase velocity of the "synchronous" or parasynchronous space harmonic. The transverse coordinates r, r' and 6' are assumed to be first-order quantities so that e.g.
p , ~ p = ( -lf 2 ) + . Using the field components [eq. (41) through (46)] and separating the equations of motion into zeroeth and first orders, one finds
As has been shown previously in 3 2, solution of the zero-order eqs. (49), for a suitable captured particle under typical conditions in an electron linac, leads to an essentially linear increase of energy vs. z. Thus for large energies,
so that in the usual case where pp=.1 the phase motion damps out rapidly. The first-order bunching motion may be described by combining eqs. (50);
Equation (51) expresses the familiar phase-stability of a bunch which is ahead of the accelerating crest of the parasynchronous space harmonic so that adla0 is negative. The asymptotic phase angle in electron linacs is usually adjusted to place the bunch essentially on the accelerating crest where d b / a 8 = 0 ; the first order bunching motion then damps as B;,,K:,y at high energy. The non-synchronous space harmonics introduce an oscillatory force term in eq. (51) which in analogy with alternating gradient focusing theory results in a net converging phase focusing; however it may be shown that this effect is very weak.* Thus it may be concluded that in a long ideal accelerator, the energy is essentially
where 8, is the asymptotic phase angle relative to the phase-stable null and b, is the amplitude of the space harmonic for which P p g1. A bunch of effective width do,,
* See e.g. Makhnenko et al. [I9651 in which the alternating gradient effect of a reflected wave is considered.
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
B.1.2
131
centered at 8, = -fn would have an inherent spectrum width of Ayly
r1
- cos+AO,
r $ (A0,)2.
A typical bunch width of A@, GZ 5" then would imply a spectrum of z 0.1 %. In actual machines the limiting spectrum width is likely to be dominated by transient rf and beam loading phenomena (see ch. B.1.3) and by the precision and stability of phasing.
3.1.3 Transverse motion The radial Lorentz force of the fields given by eqs. (41) through (46), to first order in r, r', and 4' is
The azimuthal force is F,
=e [ E + v
x B ] , = 0. Noting that
along a particle trajectory, and using the identity
resulting from the definitions of 0 and 6,one may obtain
In order to obtain linear equations of motion it will be convenient to use cartesian coordinates rather than cylindrical. Neglecting external focusing fields, one then has *
where ( is either x or y. The second term on the right in eq. ( 5 3 ) , proportiona1 to y e 2 and in quadrature with the acceleration, is essentially the usual rf focusing effect which leads to radial instability in the phase-stable region (dd/aO
*
= - 456'.
The derivation of eqs. (53) and (54) is essentially that of Panofsky [1963].
(54)
132
R.H.HELM, R.MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
The 8'term, being a total derivative along the particle trajectory, essentially vanishes for the parasynchronous component. However, the effects of nonsynchronous space harmonics and fringe fields may not be entirely negligible. For example, the fringe field at the entrance or exit of an accelerator section, by a simple impulse integration of eq. (54), yields y A ( ' = -it A b which is equivalent to a thin lens of focal length
+
where the (converging) sign applies at entrance, the - (diverging) sign applies at exit, and (8)is the effective acceleration within the structure. Thus the final exit from the machine is equivalent to a diverging lens of focal length (Panofsky 119631)
or twice the length of the entire machine. The effect is thus very small. Similarly a short field-free gap within the machine (e.g., between sections) is optically equivalent to an alternating-gradient doublet which however would be negligible compared to ordinary beam-transport lenses. In order to treat the periodic components of the force term, one may use a smoothforce approximation analogous, e.g., to that of Symon et al. [1955]. Equation (54) then may be approximated as*
where ( ) denotes an average over a period of the fluctuating force term. It is interesting to note that the force term in eq. (56) is equivalent to an axial magnetic focusing field [compare eq. (40)] of magnitude
As an example, the space harmonics in a 2x13-mode travelling wave accelerator typically amount to ( ( E 2 ) - ( ~ ) ~ ) ~ % 0 . 3 5 ( Ethen ) ; an accelerating gradient of (E) z 6.6 MV/m (2MVlft) would yield Be, z 77 gauss which is quite negligible. On the other hand, in standing-wave machines such as the proposed superconducting linacs (see ch. E.2), because of the backward wave, one has typically ( ( E 2 ) - ( ~ ) 2 ) * ~ 0 . 7 ( ~ )A . somewhat optimistic assumption of a gradient of 20 MV/m (6 MV/ft) then yields Be,=470 gauss, which is comparable to external focusing fields and therefore is strong enough to be interesting. It is interesting to note that the alternating gradient focusing effect of the space harmonics implies that, in principle, simultaneous radial and phase stability are possible without external focusing. In fact several authors t have suggested analogous
* Helm [1963e]. See also Makhnenko et al. [1965], in which the effect of a reflected wave is treated explicitly and experimental confirmation is given. t Mullet [1953], Makhnenko et al. [1965].
B.1.2
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
133
schemes employing either the reflected wave, nonsynchronous frequencies, or periodic modification of the structure to make the wave alternately lag or lead the bunch. The present chapter is concerned primarily with t6e more conventional structures in which t o a sufficiently good approximation the rf forces vanish, and in the absence of external focusing one has
=
(yx')' (yy')' E 0 provided that y2% 1. Thus the transverse momenta yx' and yy' are constants of the motion under these conditions. The transverse displacement of a uniformly accelerated, initially diverging electron then is
x-x
J
y
oz
(
~ --
4
0
Y. Yo
in-
This slow logarithmic divergence of the orbits is sometimes interpreted in terms of a n effective or "contracted" length,
defined such that x-x, =x&,. The contracted length typically is much smaller than the physical length; for example in the SLAC machine, acceleration from 35 MeV to 20 GeV in an actual length of 3000 m represents a contracted length of 33 m.
3.2 External focusing
From the preceding sections, a few pertinent conclusions may be drawn regarding the motion of highly relativistic electrons (y 7 10, BE 1) in an ideal accelerator: (1) There is no first-order coupling between longitudinal and transverse motions. (2) The motion is longitudinally neutral; bunching action virtually ceases; energy spread depends primarily on the second-order effects of bunch width and on transient rf and beam-loading effects. (3) Transverse rf forces essentially vanish so that the transverse momentum (in the absence of external focusing) may be considered a constant of the motion; hence divergence angles decrease as y-' and transverse displacements increase only logarithmically. In real accelerators, however, the transverse position and quality of the beam are affected by numerous small perturbations such as stray magnetic fields, misalignments, rf asymmetry effects, scattering by residual gas, and in some cases a transverse instability, "beam breakup" (see ch. B.1.4) resulting from electromagnetic interaction with the accelerator structure. In addition, the finite phase space volume of the injected
134
R.H.HELM. R.MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
beam limits the distance the beam can travel before filling the entire radial aperture, even in an ideal accelerator. External focusing provides a practical means of containing the initial phase space, and has the additional advantage of suppressing the various perturbing effects to a considerable extent. Some difficulty arises from the beam deflections caused by misalignment of focusing lenses, which therefore must be aligned to very close tolerances. 3.2.1
General considerations in focusing systems
The minimal requirement of the transport system is that the admittance be sufficient to contain the emittance of the injector. In short machines producing energies up to perhaps a few hundred MeV, the focusing may be provided by a few short solenoids or quadrupole multiplet lenses, or by a continuous axial magnetic field over the entire machine. At higher energies, strong-focusing quadrupoles usually are used. Solenoidal focusing offers several conveniences including less critical adjustment and alignment tolerances, and (in the continuous axial field) absence of any stop-band. Quadrupoles however become much more economical, for a given admittance, at energies above a few tens of MeV. Detailed analysis of external focusing systems is beyond the scope of the present article. For general references on high energy beam transport theory and extensive bibliographies, see Banford [1966], Septier [1961], Steffen [1965], Courant and Snyder [1958], De Raad [1963], and Bell [1953]. Analysis of some particular focusing systems for electron linacs is given, e.g., by Lobb [1963], Wiedemann [1968], Helm et al. [1968], Brechna et al. [1968], Helm [I9621 and Helm [1963b]. Some practical aspects of focusing are discussed in ch. B.2.4 of the present book. See also ch. B.3.5, on positron acceleration. Several computer programs are available to perform functions such as tracing of phase space ellipsoids, transport matrices and/or rays through complicated systems, and the automatic fitting of various parameters such as field strengths, drift lengths, etc., to satisfy specified conditions on beam envelopes and transport matrix elements. Computer methods are particularly useful in solving matching problems and determining properties such as admittances and error tolerances. Among the more versatile of the digital computer programs are the tracking and matching program, "TRAMP" (Gardner and Whiteside [1963]),and the SLAC program "TRANSPORT" (Moore et al. [1964]; Brown [1967]; Brown and Kear [to be published]). Analogue methods of considerable power are described by Steffen [I9651 and by Hanford and Aspley 119671.
3.2.2 Typical quadrupole systems In formulating linac beam transport it is convenient to employ the transverse co, p,, as described above in the section on phase space. In a system ordinates x , ~ , y,
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
B.1.2
135
in which x and y motions are not coupled we may define a 2 x 2 transport matrix, M , by
For example the matrix for drift o r accelerator sections, representing the transformation from z , to z , is simply
where
5,as defined previously z
"
C(Z,z0) =
J dzf/p(z') = 20
[eq. (20)] is
I (z - z,)/p 1 In 8
(constant energy),
YfP -
-
(uniform acceleration).
Yo+Po
The matrix for a quadrupole of length AZ (at constant energy) is
where k2 =P-' (d.%,/dx), 4 = k AZ, c = c o s 4 , s = s i n 4 , [,= [, = (Ilkp) tan$4, and p/f=kps. If the gradient ad,/ax is negative, then k = j Ikl, the trigonometric functions become hypertrigonometric, and the lens is defocusing. In t h e y plane the equations are the same except with
thus a quadrupole is always focusing in one plane and defocusing in the other. In the thin lens approximation ( 4 1 ) we have [,= z $ A Z / p and p/f= (aB',/dx)AZ- Q, i.e. the matrix is that of a thin lens of focal length f = p / Q located at the geometric center of the quadrupole. The quantity of Q (gradient x length) is a convenient measure of the q ~ ~ a d r u p ostrength. le Properties of complicated systems are formed by the usual rules of matrix algebra, as discussed in the references cited above. In principle, the spacing of focusing elements may be increased-with increasing energy [see e.g., eq. (21)l. However, a n essentially periodic array is indicated in cases where large admittance is required, and also where low-energy partially accelerated beams are to be transmitted. Figures 4a,b,c illustrate typical cells which may be used in periodic systems. The "FODO" o r AG singlet system is well known to be the most efficient in terms of magnet and power costs, for a given admittance. O n the other hand, the multiplets such as doublets and triplets closely approximate simple converging lenses, which greatly facilitates empirical focusing adjustments. In addition, the relatively large number of independently sup-
[,
136
R.H. HELM, R. MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
ported quadrupoles, in the FODO case, tends to complicate support and alignment problems. The multiplet configurations also are especially compatible with the "instrumentation package" concept in which functions such as focusing, steering, and sensing of beam position and intensity are localized in interchangeable modules. This has obvious conveniences in support and alignment, operation, and maintenance. In a comparison between different multiplets, doublets are rather asymmetric optically in that the equivalent planes are considerably displaced, upbeam in the FD plane and downbeam in the DF plane; triplets are more symmetric in this respect and quadruplets can be made to have complete rotational symmetry. Doublets, because of an inherently larger beat factor, also may have slightly lower admittance for a given number of multiplets per unit length. In the matter of alignment tolerances,
Fig. 4. Typical quadrupole focusingcells. (a) AG singlet system. (b) Doublet system. (c)Triplet system.
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
B.1.2
137
doublets are most sensitive to angular (skew) misalignment of the entire multiplet, while triplets for example are most sensitive to a n internal misalignment, non-collinearity of the individual quadrupoles; thus with suitable prealignment on a common support structure the triplet may be able to tolerate less precise alignment of the common support. However, doublets have a considerable cost advantage over more complicated multiplets, and this may allow the builder to design around the apparent theoretical disadvantages. For example, suitable attention to location and stability of steering coils can essentially obviate the doublet alignment problem.
3.3 Misalignments and other beam perturbations The effect of small forces which deflect the beam from its ideal orbit may be described by introducing p e r t ~ ~ r b a t i o ninto s the beam transport theory. In a system consisting of a number of transport elements, the effect of the nth element may be represented as a n inhomogeneous transformation
where 9, is the (perturbed) column vector comprising the phase space coordinates of a beam particle; A(n, j ) is the matrix representing the transformation from z j to z,; and 65, is the orbit displacement due to the non-ideal forces within the nth element. Equation (61) has the formal solution
where x, = A (n, 0) x, is the unperturbed solution, and the net displacement given by
5,
is
Orbit deflections associated with a given set of elementary perturbations thus may be calc~datedwith the aid of the methods discussed in the references cited above in subsection 3.2.1. Analysis of error effects in several periodic fhcusing systems for electron linacs are given, e.g., by Helm [1963a, c, d l and Helm et al. [1968]. In the remainder of this section we consider some of the specific sources of beam perturbations. 3.3.1
Misalignments and errors in quadrupoles
Focusing elements may be afflicted by transverse and axial misalignment and lens strength errors.
138
R.H. HELM, R. MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
a. Transverse parallel displacement: Figure 5a shows schematically a lens whose optic axis is transversely displaced from the reference (beam) axis in the (x, z ) plane. Assume that the lens may be represented by a 2 x 2 matrix M(mij).Then by considering the inhomogeneous transformations between the beam axis and the optic axis of the lens, one may show that the beam perturbation in the notation of eq. (61) is
where
E
is the parallel displacement. In the thin lens limit eq. (64) reduces to
which is simply the impulse-approximation result for a displaced lens. In a periodic FODO channel, for example, the spacing half-period is typically where f here is
LOCATION
I
I
L-J
Fig. 5. Misalignment components in beam transport elements. (a) Transverse displacement. (b) Skewness or transverse rotation. (c) Longitudinal displacement. (d) Axial rotation; (xo, yo) quadrupole symmetry axes; ( x , y) transverse reference axes.
the quadrupole focal length; then the orbit displacement arising from a misalignment, E , of a given lens, amounts to z E at the next lens. An alignment tolerance E < a thus is desirable in order to avoid the necessity of extensive steering. b. Transverse angular misalignment: Figure 5b represents a lens which is rotated in the (x, z ) plane; E' is the displacement of the ends relative to the center of the lens.
B.1.2
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
In this case the result analogous to eq. (64) is, to first order in
139
E',
where AZ is the length of the lens. In the case of a single quadrupole [eq. (60)] using small-angle approximations we find
i.e., the effect becomes very small in the thin-lens limit (AZ/f-+O). c. Longitudinal displacement: The perturbation due to an error in longit~~dinal position (fig. 5c) of a lens may be found by a fictitious transformation to the correct position. The result is
where x is the unperturbed beam at the input end of the lens. For a quadrupole this becomes
d. Axial rotation: Rotation of a quadrupole about the beam axis (fig. 5d) couples the x and y motions. Carrying out the rotational transformation to first order in the error, $, one finds
where M and N are the transformation in the x and y planes, respectively and x and y are defined at the input end of the lens. For a quadrupole, the dominant effect in the thin lens approximation is
with an analogous result for the y perturbation. e. Quadrupole strength error: An error in field may be expressed as
140
R.H.HELM, R. MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
For a quadrupole the dominant effect is
The strength error might result from a defect in construction or from incorrect excitation current. It will be noticed that the last three types of errors listed above -axial displacement and rotation, and quadrupole strength - are "second order" in the sense that they depend on the product of the error with the transverse dimensions of the beam. Consequently the magnitude of the beam perturbation from these effects will be reduced somewhat if an optimum phase-space match is maintained along the focusing channel. 3.3.2 Multiplet errors
If quadruple multiplets are assembled on a common supporting structure, certain correlations appear among the errors in individual elements. Figure 6 illustrates some
REFERENCE AXIS
REFERENCE AXIS
Fig. 6 . Special error components in doublets and triplets. (a) Parallel displacement (doublet or triplet). (b) Skewness ( x or y rotation) (doublet or triplet). (c) Non-collinearity.
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
B.1.2
141
of the special error components associated with doublets and triplets. Note that doublet skew (transverse rotation) and triplet non-collinearity both are equivalent to a net magnetic dipole deflection. On the other hand, triplet skew introduces no net dipole; hence triplets are rather insensitive to this kind of misalignment. One may derive the orbit perturbation due to multiplets by combining the individual quadrupole terms given above, using eq. (63). 3.3.3
Accelerator misalignment
The misalignment effects to be considered here are associated with the accelerator structure itself as distinguished from the special problems of focuslng element misalignments discussed in previous sections. Some of the sources of accelerator misalignments are fabrication errors, limitations of alignment precision, thermal gradients, mechanical loading by waveguide and water connections, seismic activity and earth settlement. Alignment methods involving various combinations of stretched wires, conventional optical and laser technique are used. The practical problems of support and alignment are discussed in ch. B.2.4. The main effect of random short-range misalignments is simply a loss in effective aperture. So long as the amplitudes of such misalignments are limited to perhaps 10% of the accelerator aperture, losses of electron beams should be negligible in the presence of moderate external focusing. In the case of positron beams, however, transmission is limited by transverse four-dimensional admittance, proportional to fourth power of effective aperture, so that appreciable losses may result unless the short-range mis-alignments are kept small. Longer-range misalignments may be compensated by periodically located magnetic steering coils, which also are necessary for final correction of stray magnetic fields as discussed in the next section. However the energy dependence of such steering might be undesirable. For example, the capability of multiple time-interlaced beams at different energies could require that the steering be pulsed. This consideration was one of the motivations at SLAC for development of the laser-interferometric alignment system (Herrmannsfeldt [1965a]) which provides an essentially straight reference axis through the entire machine. Another effect of misalignments is the introduction of transverse components of the rf accelerating field, which can deflect the beam slightly. As an example, consider an independently powered, misaligned but internally straight section of accelerator, as shown schematically in fig. 7. The net deflecting impulse, resulting from the combined action of the misaligned E-field and the fringe field lens effect (eq. 55), is given in first approximation by
A rough estimate of the maximum deflection may be found by comparing 6p, to the
142
R.H. HELM, R. MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
t-ransverse momentum acceptance of the transport system, and is given by Sx z n a 2 S p , / ~ .
As a numerical example, assume a relative misalignment E, - E, =0.2 cm, acceleration b=O.l cm-', aperture a = 1 cm, and admittance U=O.ln mc.cm; we then find 6 ~ ~ 0cm, . 1 which may be interpreted as the amount of beam motion produced by turning the accelerating field on or off in the misaligned section.
Fig. 7. Beam-optical equivalent of misaligned accelerator section; fringe fields represented by thin lenses.
3.3.4 Stray magnetic$elds
To estimate the effect of magnetic fields along the accelerator axis, consider the equation of motion of an electron in the absence of other transverse forces:
where 99 = eB/mc. The y ' g , term is negligible. The formal solution is:
where [(z, z,)is defined by eq. (20). As an example, consider the effect of a uniform transverse field ~29on a relativistic beam with uniform energy gradient in the absence of focusing. The magnetic deflection of an electron initially on the axis is
For parameters typical of SLAC, namely z = 3 x lo5 cm, mc28=0.06 MeV/cm, y g yo, and a magnetic field comparable to the earth's field, e.g., B=0.5 gauss, we find Axz750 cm, i.e., the average transverse field would have to be reduced by a factor of lo4 to keep the deflection to % 1 mm; the tolerable field would be x6 x gauss, averaged over the whole machine. The effect of external focusing in the presence of a uniform stray magnetic field
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
B.1.2
143
may be estimated by comparing the transverse magnetic impulse, 6p,=&z, to the momentum acceptance which may be approximated as Ulna. Then very roughly the magnetic field tolerance is
d 7 U/(naz) If U/nazO.I mc and z = 3 x lo5 cm, we have B = ( m c / e ) . 9 7 6 x gauss. Tolerances on random, local, short-range fields will of course be somewhat larger. See, e.g., Stepanov [I9601 ; Helm [1963d]. I n practice, the stray magnetic fields are compensated by various combinations of degaussing wires, magnetic shielding (Herrmannsfeldt [I 965bl; Herrmannsfeldt and Salsburg [1964]) and discrete steering coils.
3.3.5 Coupler asymmetry* The coupling of rf power into the disk-loaded accelerator is usually accomplished through side slots in the end cavities of the 10-foot structure. (See fig. 30, ch. B.I.1.) The asymmetry of these couplers introduces transverse gradients in the accelerating field, which can deflect the beam in the manner of a n rf separator. The transverse impulse imparted by one coupler is related to the vector potential A, and the electric field E, accelerating the beam particle by
in which the integral extends over the region of the perturbation (essentially the coupler cavity) and k is the rf wave number. The complex amplitude of the field acting on the particle at a particular point in the cavity is of the form:
where both the field amplitude E ( x ) and the phase angle A ( x ) of the electron relative to the accelerating crest depend on x, the transverse coordinate in the coupler cavity. The real part of eq. (73) is then essentially
Az[(iIg) 6pXc= - k ax sin A,
+
(&dA)
ax
cos A,
]
where ( ) refers to the effective value of the quantity in question over the coupler cavity of length Az, and A, is the phase angle when the electron is at the center of the cavity. Thus a n amplitude asymmetry would produce a dispersive effect proportional t o
* See e.g., Helm
[1960].
144
R.H. HELM, R. MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
the bunch width, while a transverse phase variation of the field would produce a uniform deflection of the whole bunch, in phase with the accelerating field. The effect of these momentum impulses repeated coherently in each powered accelerator section of length AL is equivalent to a uniform magnetic deflecting field of magnitude
Hence the results obtained above for stray magnetic fields apply directly. As an example, consider a 2x13 mode S-band accelerator for which k = 2 n / A ~ 0 . 6 cm-' and Az=cell length E 3.5 cm; assume the section length is AL= 300 cm, and take 6=0.13 cm-' and A,zO. In typical uncompensated couplers measured at SLAC the phase asymmetry adlax has been found to be on the order of 0.75" per cm. We then find the equivalent deflecting field to be B, ~ 0 . 0 gauss, 5 which as has been seen would produce many centimeters of beam deflection in a long unfocused machine. In similar couplers the amplitude asymmetry may be on the order of 2% per cm. For a bunch length of 0.1 radian, the relative deflection between the leading and 8 trailing edges of the bunch would be equivalent to a deflection field B, ~ 0 . 0 0 gauss; appreciable dilution of the transverse phase space could result. Methods of compensating for coupler asymmetry are discussed in ch. B. I. 1, 5 8. 3.3.6 Scattering by residual gas
The residual gas in the accelerator can spread the beam by single and multiple nuclear coulomb scattering - processes which do not conserve beam phase space. Nuclear form factors and recoil corrections can be neglected because the momentum transfers involved are small. The coulomb scattering cross section for single scattering in small-angle approximation (Rossi [1952]) may be written
where Z is the atomic number of the residual gas, r, =e2/mc2=2.81 x 10-l3 cm is the classical electron radius, 8 is the polar scattering angle, and
is the minimum effective scattering angle for a screened coulomb field in the FermiThomas model. If it is assumed that the transverse momentum acceptance, proportional to ye,, is independent of z, the total fraction of electrons lost is simply given by
where N, is the total number of gas atoms per unit area.
B.1.2
PARTICLE DYNAMICS
145
The momentum acceptance is estimated as yom= Ulna, where U is the admittance and a IS the aperture rad~us.If U =O. 1rc mc.cm and a= I cm, then y o m =O. I . Let the residual gas be nitrogen at l o p 6 torr which e.g. would be N s z 2 x l o t 6 atoms/cm2 for the 3 km length of the SLAC machine. The fraction lost by single scattering then would be 1.0 x which is negligible. O n the other hand, if it is assumed that 0,=0, then the total fraction of electrons undergoing any single scattering (based o n = 2'11 37 = 0.014) would be fzO.OOS=j%.
Since this number may be interpreted as the total probability of single scattering for a given electron, it is concluded that the effects of plural and multiple scattering must be negligible also.
References BANFORD, A. P., 1966, The Transport of Charged Particle Beams (E. and F. N. Spon, Ltd., London). BELL,J. S., 1953, Basic Algebra of the Strong Focussing System, T/R I1 14, Atomic Energy Research Establishment (Harwell, Berks., England). BRECHNA, H., K. E. BREYMAYER, K. G . CARNEY,H. DESTAEBLER, R. H. HELM,and C. T. HOARD, 1968, The Stanford Two-Mile Accelerator (W. A. Benjamin, Inc., New York), ch. 16. BROWN,K. L., 1967, A First- and Second-Order Matrix Theory for the Design of Beam Transport Systems and Charged Particle Spectrometers, Report No. SLAC-75, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. BROWN,K. L. and B. K. KEAR,TRANSPORT/360, Report No. SLAC-91, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California (to be published). and CHODOROW, M., E. L. GINZTON,W. W. HANSEN, R. L. KYHL,R. B. NEAL,W. K. H. PANOFSKY, the Staff of the W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, 1955, Rev. Sci. Instr. 26, 134. CHODOROW, M. and C. SUSSKIND,1964, Fundamentals of Microwave Electronics (McGraw-Hill, Inc., New York), 5 2.5. CHU,E. L., 1951, The Theory of Linear Accelerators, ML Report No. 140, W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California. COURANT, E. D. and H. S. SNYDER, 1958, Theory of the Alternating Gradient Synchrotron, Ann. Phys. 3, 1 4 3 . D ~ M EG., , 1960, Electron Bunching by liniform Sections of Disk-Loaded Waveguide. Part A: General Study, M-242-A, W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California. J. W. and D . WHITESIDE, 1963, NIRL/M/44. GARDNER, J., 1965, lEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, 996. HAIMSON, HAIMSON, J. and B. MECKLENBURG, 1967, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-14, No. 3, 586. HANFORD, R. N. and R. J. ASPLEY,1967, A Small Versatile Analogue Computer for Particle Tracks and Beam Envelopes, Proceedings of the International Conference on Magnet Technology, Oxford, p. 707. HELM,R. H., 1960, A Note on Coupler Asymmetries in Long Linear Accelerators, M Report No. 167, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. HELM,R. H., 1962, Discussion of Focusing Requirements for the Stanford Two-Mile Accelerator, Report No. SLAC-2, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California. HELM,R. H., 1963a, Misalignment and Quadrupole Error Effects in a Focusing System for the Two-Mile Accelerator, Report No. SLAC-11, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. HELM,R. H., 1963b, Optical Properties of Quadrupole Multiplets for Sector Focusing in the Two-
146
R.H.HELM, R. MILLER
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
Mile Accelerator, Report No. SLAC-14, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. HELM,R. H., 1963c, Misalignment and Quadrupole Error Problems Affecting the Choice of Multiplet Type for Sector Focusing of the Two-Mile Accelerator, Report No. SLAC-15, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. HELM,R. H., 1963d, Effects of Stray Magnetic Fields and R F Coupler Asymmetry in the Two-Mile Accelerator with Sector Focusing, Report No. SLAC-20, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. HELM,R., 1963c, Notes on Electromagnetic Forces in Linear Accelerators, Report No. SLAC-TN63-107, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. 1968, The Stanford Two-Mile Accelerator HELM,R. H., G. A. LOEW,and W. K. H. PANOFSKY, (W. A. Benjamin, Inc., New York), ch. 7. HERRMANNSFELDT, W. B. and B. L. SALSBURG, 1964, Rev. Sci. Instr. 35, 906(N). HERRMANNSFELDT, W. B., 1965a, Linac Alignment Techniques, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, p. 9. HERRMANNSFELDT, W. B., 1965b, The Magnetic Shielding System for the Stanford Two-Mile Accelerator, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, p. 929. LOBB,D. E., 1963, The Generation and Acceleration of Positrons, SAL-2, Saskatchewan Accelerator Laboratory, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada. MAKHNENKO, L. A,, V. I. PAKHOMOV, and K. N. STEPANOV, 1965, High Frequency Focusing in Linear Accelerators, Zh. Techn. Fiz. 35, No. 4, pp. 618-622. MILLER,R. H., A Linear Accelerator for Submillimeter Wave Generation, ML-1244, W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California, October 1964. MILLER,R. H., R. F. KOONTZ,D. D. TSANG,1965, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3, 804. 1967, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-14, No. 3, 98. MILLER,R. H., J. BERK,T. 0. MCKINNEY, MOORE, C. H., S. K. HOWRY,and H. S. BUTLER,1964, TRANSPORT - A Computer Program for Designing Beam Transport Systems, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. MULLET, L. B., 1953, AERE-GP/M-147 (Harwell, Berks., England). PANOFSKY, W. K. H., 1963, Note on Radial Beam Dynamics, Report No. SLAC-TN-63-89, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. J. R., 1949,Theory and Design of Electron Beams, 2nd. ed. (D. Van Nostrand Co., Princeton, PIERCE, New Jersey), 5 4.4. DE RAAD,B., 1963, CERN 63-3, 27. Ross~,B. B., 1952, High Energy Particles (Prentice-Hall, New York), p. 65. SEPTIER, A., 1961, Strong Focusing Lenses, Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics 14 (Academic Press, New York). SEPTIER, A. S., 1967, Focusing of Charged Particles 2 (Academic Press, New York and London). SLATER, J. C., 1948, Rev. Mod. Phys. 20, 473. J. C., 1950, Microwave Electronics (D. Van Nostrand, Princeton, New Jersey), ch. VIII SLATER, and ch. XI. STEFFEN, K. G., 1965, High Energy Beam Optics (Interscience Publishers Div. of John Wiley and Sons, New York). STEPANOV, K. N., 1960, Concerning the Motion of a Highly Relativistic Electron in a Linear Accelerator Under the Action of an Accidental Perturbation, Zh. Techn. Fiz. 30, No. 8, pp. 975-980. SYMON, K. R., D. W. KERST,L. W. JONES,L. J. LASLETT, and K. M. TERWILLIGER, 1955, Phys. Rev. 103, 1837 (see Appendix A). WIEDEMANN, H., 1968, Strong Focussing in Linear Accelerators, DESY 6518, Deutsches ElektronenSynchrotron, Hamburg.
ELA
1.3
THEORY
B.l
Beam Loading and Transient Behavior in Traveling Wave Electron Linear Accelerators* J. E. LEISS National Bureau of Standards, Washit~gton,U . S . A .
In the linear accelerator the transfer of energy from the accelerator to the beam, known as beam loading, can be so efficient that the behavior of the accelerator can not be even qualitatively described without consideration of beam loading. The energy of the particle beam can easily be changed by a factor of two or more due to beam loading, and changes in the radiofrequency power density at some points in the accelerating waveguides of an order of magnitude are observed. The tightly bunched characteristic of the accelerated particle beam in the linear accelerator together with the pulsed nature of these beams on the narrow band-pass characteristic of the accelerating waveguides produce a number of effects which have become important in modern linear accelerators. These effects include transient phase and amplitude oscillations in the rf transmitted down the waveguide, limitation on the amount of beam which can be accelerated in very short beam pulses, excitation by the bunched beam of spatial harmonics in the waveguide, and beam excitation of the waveguide at frequencies of other pass-bands leading to deterioration of beam optics in general and deflection of the beam into the waveguide walls in some cases. Theseeffects will be increasingly important in the next generation of linear accelerators, especially for accelerators designed for accelerating beams of tens of amperes in short nanosecond bursts, and for accelerators designed for extremely small energy spreads.
* Work supported in part by U S . Atomic Energy Con~mission,Division of Research. Contribution of National Bureau of Standards, not subject to copyright. North-Holland Publ. Co., Amsterrlum 1969
References p. 172
147
148
J.E.LEISS
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
This chapter is concerned primarily with traveling wave, disk-loaded electron linear accelerators, although the general techniques should be applicable to other accelerators. Most of the examples to be presented have been calculated for traveling wave accelerators whose structure does not change down the length of the waveguide, although references will be made to calculation for other accelerator structures. The chapter is divided into several parts. First a general discussion of the linear nature of the beam loading problem will be presented which indicates the general applicability of the superposition theorem to linear accelerator beam loading calculations. In this discussion situations where the superposition theorem is not applicable will be discussed to indicate where more detailed (and much more difficult) calculations are called for. In $3, beam loading theory based upon the power diffusion equation will be presented, first in the steady state case and second for the transient case. In this treatment all effects due to the dispersive nature of the accelerating waveguide, the bunched nature of the electron beam and electron transit time are ignored. This is the most common approach to beam loading in linear accelerators and gives reliable results where dispersive effects and effects due to the bunched nature of the particle beam can be ignored. In 8 4 we present a more general approach to linear accelerator behavior based upon filter theory which allows inclusion of dispersive effects and effects due to the bunched nature of the particle beam. Examples are presented which illustrate various effects.
2 Nature of the beam loading problem When particles are accelerated in a linear accelerator there is necessarily a transfer of energy from the accelerating field to the particle beam. This results in a reduction and redistribution of the total accelerating field in the waveguide. As a consequence subsequent particles traveling down the waveguide will in general experience less energy gain than the first particles accelerated. This effect, the interaction of the accelerator beam with longitudinal accelerating fields, and the resultant reduction in the energy gain of later beam particles is known as beam loading. Other forms of interaction of the beam with the accelerating structure are possible and observed. Effects associated with interaction of the beam with transverse deflecting modes in the waveguide are known as the phenomena of "beam breakup" and are treated in chapter B. 1.4. Most analyses of beam loading in linear electron accelerators assume the problem to be completely linear. Four basic linearity assumptions are involved: 1. Linearity with respect to particle motion in time. 2. Linearity with respect to the fields in the waveguide. 3. Independence of the power supplied from external power sources from effects due to beam loading.
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
149
4. Linearity of the interaction of the beam with the waveguide. For most of the path of a beam in the linear electron accelerator, the beam particles are highly relativistic and therefore travel at essentially the velocity of light. Thus the time at which each beam particle arrives at a given point is independent of the presence of other beam particles. This insures the first of the above linearity assumptions over most of the linear accelerator. During the first stage of acceleration, while the electron velocity is changing, this assumption is not valid, and beam loading calculations for this case must be treated specially, usually by numerical iteration procedures. Fortunately, for the traveling wave linear electron accelerator, the influence of beam loading on the accelerating fields near the front of an accelerating section are small. This coupled with the short distance in which the electrons reach essentially the velocity of light results in the failure of the linearity assumptions in this region being a small effect, which effects are largely compensated by a change of a few degrees in the phase at which electrons are injected. For the standing wave accelerator, where the change in the fields at the front of the first accelerator section due to beam-loading are greater, failure of this linearity assumption would be correspondingly greater. The second assumption of linearity with respect to the fields In the waveguide assumes that rf fields within the waveguide, once generated, are transmitted through the waveguide as if the beam were not present. This assumption is valid as long as the beam does not detune the waveguide. Various estimates of electron beam currents at which this detuning effect will become important indicate that the assumption is valid for present day traveling wave accelerators. For very high current linear accelerators (20 ampere or more in the beam pulse) or for accelerators requiring extremely fine tuning (e.g. the cryogenic linear accelerator) this assumption may no longer be valid. No reliable estimates of detuning effects which take into account the bunched nature of the beam or the influence of space harmonics have been made. For this report linearity with respect to the fields will be assumed. The third assumption, that the radiofrequency power supplied from external power sources is independent of beam loading is automatically insured for a properly terminated traveling wave linear accelerator, since all power in the accelerating structure flows away from the power source. In some traveling wave accelerators, unused rf power from one accelerator section has been used to power a second accelerator section. In these cases, the influence of beam loading on the power fed to the second section must be considered; however this constitutes no essential complexity in calculations. For the standing wave accelerator, where isolation between the power source and the accelerating waveguide is not provided, this assumption can be very invalid, depending upon the nature and location of the coupling of power to the waveguide, the type of rf power sources used, etc. Strictly speaking, as long as the first linearity assumption is satisfied, which is assured for the electron linear accelerator except near the injection point, failure of this assumption constitutes not so much a failure of linearity as an added complexity to calculations. For the heavy particle
150
J.E.LEISS
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
linear accelerator however, where the particle velocity can change in the accelerator section, the effect is nonlinear. Since this chapter is concerned primarily with the traveling wave accelerator, this assumption will be made throughout this report. The fourth assumption of linearity of the interaction of the beam with the waveguide is equivalent to Ohm's Law. It corresponds to the statement that the shunt impedance of the waveguide is independent of the magnitude of the beam current and should be valid as long as the second linearity assumption holds true. The linearity of the beam loading problem for the traveling wave electron linear accelerator is worth emphasizing. It considerably eases the complexity of computations, reduces the problems of operating accelerators, and also allows a considerably greater degree of beam loading than normally encountered in particle accelerators. An example of how these linearity conditions can break down with greatly added complexity is illustrated by the electron synchrotron or by the race-track microtron. For these accelerators, the linearity conditions for the particles within the accelerating cavities are valid; however since the particles travel within a magnetic guide field in going between cavities, there is a correlation between particle momentum and transit time to the cavity. This therefore causes a breakdown of the first linearity condition, with consequent phase pulling in the cavities and, unless corrected, instabilities. Thus even though the cavity Q in the synchrotron is often much lower than in the traveling wave linac, beam loading effects are usually much more serious for the synchrotron despite the help of synchrotron phase focussing. The extreme linearity of the beam loading problem for the traveling wave electron linear accelerator implies that the superposition theorem can be used extensively in analyses. The fields in the waveguides can be thought of as composed of two parts; fields from the external rf power source, and fields excited by the beam itself. These fields and their phases can be treated quite independently. The energy gain of the beam from the rf power source, and the energy loss due to beam loading, since they are integrals over the fields in the waveguide, can also be treated independently. The above discussion implies that the rf fields induced by beam loading and the energy loss caused by beam loading in the traveling wave linear electron accelerator are properties of the accelerating structure itself and are completely independent of the magnitude of external power sources, their phase, etc. except for the first accelerator section where these linearity conditions break down as previously discussed. These properties of the electron linear accelerator are often not apparent in the expressions usually written for beam loading.
independent of those induced by other portions of the pulse. Considerable use of this fact will be made in calculating linac beam loading behavior when dispersive effects are included.
8.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
151
3 Beam loading theovy based upon difusion equatiorz 3.1 Steady state The most common approach to beam loading in traveling wave linear accelerators is to start with the power diffusion equation (3.1):
where P is the rf power density, I is the field attenuation factor. E is the electric field strength, and i is the instantaneous beam current averaged over the rf structure of the beam. The term iE is introduced to represent beam loading. Using the definition of shunt impedance, r, of the wave guide,
eq. (3.1) can be converted to an equation for the electric field in the waveguide, assuming that the particle beam bursts are at the crest of the rf field throughout the waveguide :
From eq. (3. I) one obtains an expression for the electric field. E, as a function of Z, E(Z) = E , e-l" - ;,-(I - e-'Z).
(3.4)
Eq. (3.4) is a steady state equation. E, is the peak electric field at the beginning of the waveguide corresponding to an input power Po. It is multiplied by an attenuation factor e-lZ and reduced by a beam loading term -ir(l -e-IL). Eq. (3.4) can be thought of as two fields: the usual term from the power source looks like Eoe-I", the beam loading term is -ir(l -e-IZ), and the sum of these fields is the field which particles in the waveguide see. This separation into two fields is a natural result of the ppplicability of the superposition theorem as discussed previously. Eq. (3.4) was developed assuming that the particle beam bursts entered the waveguide at the crest of the rf field. This is often not the case. If the beam bursts enter at angle @ with respect to the peak rf field from the power source, the field the beam particles see w~llbe
E ( Z ) = E , cos (D e-IL - ir(I
-
e-").
(3.5)
(The second term in eq. (3.5) does not exhibit a phase factor since it is automatically synchronized to the particle beam.) The energy gain V of the beam is obtained by integration of eq. (3.5) over the length L of the waveguide section.
152
J.E. LEISS
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
which can be written as V = (2rLpO)*cos @
Eq. (3.6) can be expressed in the convenient form (Leiss [1958a])
where
is the energy gain for beam particles riding on the rf wave crest (@ =0) in the absence of beam loading, and
is the beam current corresponding to maximum efficiency for transfer of power from the rf source to the particle beam. At current i, the energy gain of the beam given by eq. (3.7) is +Voor one half of its unloaded value, and the fraction of the rf power from the power source, p,, transferred to the beam is given by
Equations (3.5) to (3.10) represent the basic design equation required for most constant structure traveling wave linear electron accelerators. For a given length accelerator section, L, and given input power Po (which are the two dominant cost considerations in an accelerator facility), the one remaining parameter available to optimize the beam loading properties of the accelerator is the attenuation length, IL. Figure 1 illustrates the relative dependence of p,, i, and Vo upon the attenuation length, ZL, of the waveguide. The unloaded energy of the accelerator, V,, has a maximum value at ZL = 1.24. This led in early traveling wave linacs, where maximum energy gain was the dominant desire, to the choice of this value for ZL. Most linacs presently being built use values of attenuation length between 0.4 and 0.7. While this leads to some loss in unloaded energy of the accelerator, the reduction in beam loading, the smaller filling time of the waveguide, and the reduced sensitivity to errors greatly favor the smaller attenuation lengths. Figure 2 illustrates the large redistribution in power which can occur in the waveguide due to beam loading. Three cases are shown, first the case of no beam current, second the normal accelerating condition where the beam is phased to ride on the crest of the rf wave from the power source, @=O, and third the case where the
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
153
beam is back phased, @ = 18O0, so that the beam loading wave adds to the field from the rf power source.
3.2 Transient solutions For most existing traveling wave electron linacs the filling time, t,, for rf power to travel the length of the waveguide is a n appreciable fraction of the rf pulse length
Fig. I . Plot of the variation of p,,, im and VOversus waveguide attenuation length IL for a constant structure traveling wave accelerator assuming input power PIJand guide length are held constant. This figure illustrates that although Vo reaches a maximum value at IL = 1.24, beam loading considerations favor smaller values of IL. from the power source. Additionally, as will be seen below, if the beam is turned on after the waveguide is filled with rf, there is a n additional transient beam loading period of one filling time during which the energy of the accelerated beam is changing because of transients. Thus the transient regime can account for a large fraction of the
J.E. LEISS
154
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
total rf pulse length with a resulting deterioration of the energy spectrum of the accelerated beam. In the section below we will develop methods for calculation of this transient behavior of the traveling wave electron linac in the approximation where dispersive effects and effects due to the bunched nature of the electron beam can be neglected. The differential equation for the field, eq. (3.3), derived previously from the power diffusion equation, eq. (3.1), implicitly assumed that the amplitude of the fields in the waveguide were time independent. Therefore solutions obtained were for the steady
( I N PHASED)
.2
.I
0
.3 .4 .5 FRACTION O F GUIDE L E N G T H
Fig. 2. Variation of rf power density along constant structure waveguide (IL =0.5). Three cases are shown, no beam current, beam current im with p-0, and beam current im with 01 = 180" (backphased condition). For high current accelerators where back-phased operation is used for low energy operation, it is important to design waveguide cooling and rf terminating loads with these high powers at the end of the waveguide in mind.
state. We can remove this restriction by explicitly recognizing the time dependence of the fields in eq. (3. I). Doing this the resulting field equation, analogous to eq. (3.3) is (Neal [1957]) vg
aE(Z,t) dE(Z,t) -
az +
-
-
at
=-
lvgE(Z,t)- Zvgri (t)
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
155
where E ( Z , t ) is the electric field strength in the waveguide at point Z and time t , v, is the group velocity of the waveguide, and i(t) is the instantaneous beam current in the waveguide at time t averaged over the rf cycle and assumed independent of Z. As in the development of eq. (3.3) it is assumed in eq. (3.1 1) that the beam bursts travel a t the crest of the rf wave. This restriction will be removed later as before. We solve eq. (3.1 1) by the use of Laplace transforms with respect to time. The notation is 9E ( Z , t ) = J," E ( Z , t ) e-P' dt, wherep is the Laplace variable. We assume that for t
which has the solution (Leiss [1958b])
where we have again inserted a phase factor cos @ just as in developing eq. (3.5). Thus eq. (3.13) represents the field which the beam particles would see. The gain in electron energy in passing through the waveguide is given by L
V (r)
=
S
E (Z, t ) d Z .
0
This integral can be easily performed on E ( Z , P ) with the result
where t , is the filling time of the waveguide Llv,. The inverse transforms of eqs. (3.13) and (3.14) give the electric field in the waveguide at any point and the energy gain respectively as a function of a time, once the input rf signal from the power source, E(0, t ) and the beam current i ( t ) are specified. T o illustrate these solutions two examples will be calculated. Use will be made of the unit step function U ( t - 6 ) which has the value zero for t < 6 and value I for t 3 6.
156
J.E. LEISS
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Example I E (0, t ) = E, U ( t ) ,
i ( t ) = 0, all t .
From eqs. (3.13) and (3.14) E (2, P) = E (0, P ) COS gj e-'Z
e-Z~/"g
v,E (0, p) cos Q, [I - e-IL e-'fP]. V ( P )= P + 10, -
-
These have the solution E ( Z , t ) = E , cos Q, e - " ~( t - zlv,)
E ( Z , t ) is a sharp wavefront E, e-IZ moving down the waveguide with the group velocity u,. V ( t ) has the behavior
Example 2
E ( 0 , t ) = 0 , all t ,
i ( t ) = i,U(t)
.
Evaluating eq. (3.14) and applying the inverse transform for this case yields for the energy gain
V (t)=
ri, ((1 - I L ) ( 1 - e-'"gt) - Iv,t e-I""' I - e - I L [I - e-'"g(t-tf) - Iv,(t - t,) e-'"g(t-tf)] U ( t - t,)) .
-
(3.20)
In the steady state, t > t,, the sum of the two solutions given by these examples, eq. (3.18) plus (3.20), reduces to the steady state solution found previously, eq. (3.6). The two examples given above allow a large class of solutions to the transient beam loading problem. Since the energy gains from the fields produced by the rf power source and from the fields induced by beam loading are independent, we can generate different solutions corresponding to different magnitudes of beam current and different beam turn-on times by suitable sums of these solutions and time shifts. An example of one such set of beam loading solutions is given in fig. 3.
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
157
Figure 3 illustrates the degree to which energy spread due to transient beam loading can be overcome by turning on the beam current during the rf filling time. This example is calculated for the beam current corresponding to maximum power transfer t o the beam, i,, and for different beam turn-on times after rf turn-on. It illustrates that by suitable timing of beam turn-on the energy spread of the beam caused by transients can be greatly reduced.
Fig. 3. Plot of relative energy gain in the transient region versus time in units of the rf filling time tr for a specific accelerator (IL := 0.6, i = it,,). The parameter 6 is the fraction of a filling time after rf turn-on at which beam is started. These solutions are the sum of eqs. (3.18) and (3.20) with a time shift of 6te in the beam loading term (3.20).
3.3 Other waveguide structures The expressions developed above have been calculated for the case of waveguides whose structure is constant throughout the length of the guide. Many linear electron accelerators are now built with "constant gradient" waveguides whose structure are
158
J.E. LEISS
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
not constant with length, but rather change t o compensate for attenuation or a certain amount of beam loading. These waveguides are usually of two forms. In the first and most common case the parameters of the guide are not changed continuously, but rather the waveguide is composed of short sections of constant structure waveguide with suitable matching elements. For this case beam loading theory can be calculated using the expressions given above, taking the fields from one element of the guide, with appropriate amplitude change for shunt impedance change, as the input field for the next element of the waveguide. In the second case of constant gradient waveguide the pxameters of the guide are changed continuously. For this case the differential equation for the field, eq. (3.3) or eq. (3.1 1) must now include the variation in shunt impedance r, group velocity, u,, and attenuation constant, I, with Z. Transient beam loading calculations for this case, similar to those developed above for the constant structure waveguide, have been developed by Burnod [ I 9611. The largest influence of the constant gradient structure on the effects thus far considered is an enhanced influence of beam loading upon the rf field toward the end of the accelerating guide (Haimson [1965]). For large beam currents, these fields can be so large as to exceed the voltage breakdown limits of the structure and thus lead to serious sparking.
4 Beam loading theory including dispersive eflects The previous analysis rests upon assumptions which are strictly valid only for a continuous wave accelerator. These assumptions are that the rf field in the accelerator is at one precise frequency, and that sharply rising waveforms are transmitted in the accelerator without distortion. Due to the pulsed nature of these accelerators, the first of these assumptions is necessarily incorrect since frequency spreads are inherent in switching transients. The second assumption can not be strictly true since the accelerator waveguide is essentially a band pass filter. It is still true, however, to the extent that the frequency spread in the rf pulse is all contained within the band pass of the accelerator, and to the extent that the phase shift varies linearly with the frequency over the frequency range of interest. It is further assumed in the previous analysis, although reasonably well hidden, that the particle beam contains only one frequency component. Due to the very tight phase bunching in linear accelerators, this assumption is substantially incorrect. The beam is in fact very rich in frequency structure and is tightly bunched in space. In this seciion we present an approach to the calculation of linear accelerator performance based upon very general properties of wave propagation in coupled periodic systems and upon the linearity conditions discussed previously (Leiss [I 9621, Leiss et al. [I 9621). Two general classes of solution to the linear accelerator problem will be presented ;
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
159
however the method of calculation of both will be the same. In the first solution the specific dispersive properties of the narrow band-pass accelerator structure are included as well as the bunched nature of the particle beam. In the second treatment. the dispersive properties of the waveguide are ignored, but the bunched nature of the particle beam is retained. For this second type solution, the linear accelerator theory resulting corresponds essentially to the solutions found from the power diffusion equation as regards the fundamental accelerating mode. For higher spatial harmonics and for excitation of other waveguide pass bands the beam loading predictions are different. A signal of constant frequency in any linear system can be thought of as passing from one point (a) to another point (b) in the system by means of a complex phase shift o r propagation constant T,.,(w) such that (signal b) = efra."'"'(signal a ) . The real part of f ( w ) indicates any attenuation of the signal, while the imaginary part indicates the signal phase shift. The general nature of the dispersion diagram for a disk-loaded waveguide is indicated in fig. 4. The imaginary part P, of the complex phase shift, f, in the waveguide is plotted against frequency w for unit length of the waveguide. (In the convention indicated in fig. 4 and in the treatment which follows the unit length of waveguide is taken as twice the distance between loading disks.) A t a given frequency within a pass-band, the propagation constant f ( o ) can have several values:
and ,
=
( )+4
,
for p < 0
(4.2)
where T,,,(w) is the complex phase shift for 0<8<2n in the 111th frequency passband and f,, ( w ) is the complex phase shift for - 271 < 8 < 0. In practice the pass-bands are usually quite narrow compared to the spacing between pass-bands. Thus one can safely examine accelerator performance by examining effects in different pass-bands separately. It is for this reason that we have written T ( w ) in the form T,,,(w). In principle, for a given value of n, T ( w ) is a continuous function over all frequencies and the subscript m is misleading. It is a general r e s ~ ~of l t Floquet's theorem (Slater [1948]) for wave propagation in uniform periodic structures that the value of a wave at any point q in the s t r u c t ~ ~ r e E,,(w) is related to the wave E,(o) at the beginning of the structure by the relation
-,
m
Eq(w) = E, (o)
1
n= m
A,, , ( a ) e-qrm3n("'
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
Fig. 4. The imaginary part, 8, of the complex phase shift T ( o ) for a typical disk-loaded waveguide structure plotted against frequency w. Three of the many pass bands are illustrated. Particle accel. midband frequency, wo, and half pass band eration is usually in the region marked by r ~ , o ( w )The w care indicated. It is worth noting that the frequency scale in this plot is greatly distorted, the band width usually being much smaller than the separation between pass bands.
where w
Gq( w ) =
2
Am, ( w ) e-qrm,n(w) .
n=00
The coefficients A,,,(w) are determined by the necessity of matching boundary conditions on the walls of the waveguide. The coefficient A,, ,(w) is usually approximately one, and coefficients for other values of n small. We will assume A,,,(w)= 1, although we will point out specific cases where this approximation is not good. We will also deal only with the accelerating pass-band for which m = 0. For convenience we will drop the subscript m. In most of the work we will deal only with the fundamental space harmonic for which n =O. In this case we will refer to T0,,(w) as r (w). With these simplifications
8.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
161
however it should be remembered that complete solutions even for one pass-band are a sum over all spacial harmonics n. From eq. (4.4) we see that the function G,(w) completely determines pulse transmission in the waveguide. Gq(w)is the response in frequency at any point of the waveguide to a delta function impulse in time a t the entrance to the waveguide. Knowing T ( w ) one can apply inverse Laplace transforms to determine G q ( t ) ,the response at point q as a function of time to a delta function input at point q = O . Applying the superposition theorem then allows one to determine the waveguide response for an arbitrary input rf waveform. Thus formally,
represents the response a t point q of the waveguide to an arbitrary signal E,(t) at q = O . ( E , ( t ) is not necessarily the signal applied from the power source but is related to the signal from the power source by the response of the input coupler of the waveguide. We assume here that this coupling is perfect and that E,(t) is the applied signal.) There are two approaches to the problem a t this point. One may attempt to calculate an equivalent filter circuit which accurately represents the disk-loaded waveguide, or alternatively attempt to find some convenient analytic expression which fits experimental phase shift and attenuation information within the pass band and to analytically continue this function into the frequency range outside the pass-band. We adopt this latter approach to develop a form of T ( w ) suitable for studying dispersive effects. For the usual disk-loaded constant structure accelerator waveguide one may write as a good approximation
where w , is the midband frequency, o, is the frequency difference between the midband frequency and the edge of the pass band (fig. 4), and r , is the attenuation coefficient a t the midband frequency w,. Letting iw = p , the Laplace transform variable, the expression for T ( w ) given by eq. (4.8) leads to
which has the inverse transform
where J2,( ) is the Bessel function of the first kind and order 24.
J.E.LEISS
162
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
A second approximation to r ( w ) which ignores dispersive effects is to express r ( w ) in a Taylor's series expansion around some assumed operating frequency w,. For convenience we expand around (iw,):
where
a (iw) Since we are seeking the solution without dispersion we retain only the first two terms of this expansion. Higher terms imply dispersion. With this form of r ( w ) we find the expressions for Gq(p) and Gq(t) to be GOq
(p ) =
-Carp-
(i-,
-
r,/r'dl
(4.12)
( ) is used to identify this second solution in which dispersion where the superscript is neglected. The interpretation of G: (t), eq. (4.13) in terms of a delta function pulse moving down the waveguide is apparent.
4.1 Pulse transmission in the waveguide As indicated in eq. (4.7), one can determine, using Gq(t), the response of the waveguide to any input rf signal, Eo ( t ) , at any point and time by a simple folding integral. We will illustrate this below for the two expressions Gq(t) and G: (t) given by eqs. (4.10) and (4.13) respectively. We assume an input rf signal at the front of the waveguide given by
a simple cosine wave of frequency w,, starting at t=O. For this case
Using eq. (4.10) for G,(t) the solution of eq. (4.15) which includes dispersive effects is Eq(t) = Z , (t) cos (w,t - xq - cp)
(4.16)
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
B.1.3
163
where
tan cp = Y / X
and W..t
From eqs. (4.16) to (4.20) one sees that when dispersive effects are included there is in general both phase and amplitude modulation of the rf wave. For the special case of w o - w,=O, which corresponds to linear accelerators operating in the 7112 mode, Y and therefore tan cp is always zero. Thus in the special case of the 7112 mode there is no phase modulation of the rf wave, just amplitude modulation. This is not too surprising since as can be seen from eq. (4.10) for G,(t), w o is the natural ringing frequency of the waveguide to a shock excitation. Using eq. (4.13) for G: ( t ) ,the solution ofeq. (4.15) which ignores dispersive effects is
E,0 ( t ) = e-OLaqcos ( o a t - /j,q), = z,0( 1 )
E,O(~)=O,
t
< ql-9
cos(o,t - P,q) t>yr;
where we have separated f, into its real and imaginary parts,
From eq. (4.21) it is d e a r that there is no phase or amplitude modulation in this case, just a pulse traveling in the waveguide with time delay T:, attenuation constant sc,, and phase shift fl, per unit distance in the waveguide. Figures 5 and 6 show rf pulse transmission calculated for an S band waveguide designed to operate in the 2x13 mode (o,- wo)/wc=+.This waveguide has 86 cavities, w,/2n= 19.66 M H z and an attenuation length of 0.739 nepers in the 2n/3 mode. Similar calculations for a constant gradient waveguide have been made by Helm. Plots similar to fig. 5 for this case are shown in Helm [1966]. In fig. 5 the amplitude Zq(t), eq. (4.21), is plotted against w,t at different points in the waveguide. The other curves shown correspond to solutions given by Leks et a/. [I9621 in which the rise time of the input pulse is varied. Fig. 6 indicates the variation of Z q ( t ) and E,(t) with q for this same waveguide for the specific time o c t = 8 2 . The dotted curve is the amplitude Z , ( t ) and the solid curve is E,(t). The difference between the two is caused by transients in phase.
J,E.LEISS
164
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
,'
'0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
TIM in micro seconds from r t turn on.
I0
120
IN
140
150
160
170
180
190
200
Fig. 5. Pulse transmission (Leiss et al. [1962])in a specific 2n/3 mode S-band accelerator of 86 disks for different values of input risetime, plotted against time in units of act.The amplitude Z(q, t ) is shown for the signal at different points in the waveguide. The solid curve corresponds to the solutions found in eqs. (4.16) to (4.20). Z q O ( t is ) calculated using eq. (4.21). Dispersive calculations similar to these but for a constant gradient waveguide are given in Helm [1966].
4.2 Energy gain at vanishing beam current In this section we calculate the energy gain of an electron in the linac waveguide for the case where the beam current is vanishingly small, i.e. where beam loading can be neglected. We assume the electrons to be completely relativistic. To determine the transit time of signals thus far it has not been necessary to know the longitudinal dimensions of the waveguide, only the dispersive properties. We establish the connection between unit distance in the waveguide and particle transit
(transit time of particle to point q) =- q
(4.23)
One can use any frequency o in eq. (4.23) as long as the appropriate value of
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
165
Fig. 6. Similar t o fig. 5 but indicating the variation in rf amplitude with distance down the waveguide for a specific time o,,t 82. The dotted curve is the amplitude Z,(t). The solid curve is the field E,(t) which synchronous particles would see. The difference between the two is caused by phase oscillations.
-
$ , is used. It is generally convenient to use the operating frequency
w, of the accelerator. Thus referring t o eq. (4.22), if n + $, - =0, the particle motion is synchronous with the wave motion. For accelerators operating in the n/2 mode (wo=w,), t j O = O ; while for operation in the 2x13 mode tjo = n/3. If an electron enters the beginning of the waveguide, q = O , a t time t , it will arrive at point q at time t +q(n+tjo)/w,. The energy gain, V ( t ) , by an electron in passing through the waveguide is given by the integral over the waveguide of the field which the electron sees.
where q, is the length of the waveguide.
166
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
J.E.LEISS
As an example we calculate the electron energy gain using ~ : ( t of ) eq. (4.21). vO(t) =
f
e-@.. cos [coat
+ q (n+ (1.,
- &,)I dq,
1
<
(
-
" + '0
(4.25)
the integral being taken between 0 and t/[TA - (n+ $,)/ma],
Evaluating eqs. (4.25) and (4.26) for the special case of synchronous particle and wave, rc + $O - Pa =0, the expressions for the energy gain become
Tlme m mvro r c c o o h from r f turn an.
2
1
0
10
20
3
33
40
4
50
5 60
6
70
7
80
.8
I
I1
90
00
9 !I 110
10
I I 120
11
I 130
I 1 140
12
11
150
1.3
11
160
14
!I 170
I5
1 1 I80
16
1 190
I
200
Fig. 7. Relative energy gain V ( t )at vanishing current plotted versus time in units of actfor the same waveguide as figs. 5 and 6. The large oscillations observed in the rf signal are largely removed by the integration over the waveguide. The dotted curve indicates the results if dispersion is neglected. Results calculated for a similar constant gradient waveguide are shown in Helm [1966].
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
167
where t,=q,fL is the rf filling time of the waveguide and q,(z+ $,)/w, is the electron transit time through the waveguide. If we ignore the electron transit time, which is usually much less than t,, these solutions are the same as the transient solutions found previously using the power diffusion equation, eq. (3.19), for the same example. Fig. 7 illustrates V ( t ) for the same waveguide whose pulse transmission was illustrated in figs. 5 and 6. Both the dispersive solution found using eq. (4.10) and the non-dispersive solution using eq. (4.13) for G,(t) are shown. The severe oscillations in the rf pulse transmission have largely vanished in the electron energy gain; however they still constitute an appreciable source of energy spread, especially for lower frequency L band accelerators which usually have a smaller band pass in the accelerating mode.
4.3
Linear accelerators with beam loading
In this section we consider the case of the heavily beam-loaded linear accelerator, where the rf waves generated by the electron beam cannot be ignored. We consider only the case where the electrons are completely relativistic. We also assume that the number of electrons in the beam is not so great as to effect the tuning of the waveguide. With these conditions, the superposition theorem holds for the linac behavior. Thus if we can determine a solution of the beam loading problem for a delta function current pulse with no external rf fields present, the general solution can be generated by suitable folding integrals using this delta function solution. There are two essential parts to the solution of the delta function current problem. The first of these is the frequency dependence of the coupling of the beam to the waveguide and the second is the transmission of induced waves in the waveguide once they are generated. For the second of these questions the function G,(t) previously determined clearly gives the solution. The coupling of the beam to the waveguide is not well known. We represent this coupling, a t arbitrary point u in the waveguide by a function K,(w). Because of the periodic nature of the waveguide, it is clear that K,(w) must be a periodic function of u. We will ignore this variation of K,(w) with space and will assume K,,(w)=K(o) independent in shape of position in the waveguide. By the linear nature of the problem we know there is a function K ( t ) in time corresponding to K ( w ) . K ( t ) is found from K ( w ) by letting the Laplace transform variable p = i w in K ( w ) and taking inverse transforms. While we have assumed K ( t ) to be independent in shape of position in the waveguide, we know that in time it is synchronized to the time at which the current pulse
168
J.E. LEISS
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
passes point u. Consider a unit delta function current pulse entering the waveguide at time t=O. .This current pulse will arrive at some point u at time u ( n +t,ho)/o. As the current pulse passes point u it induces a signal in the waveguide and consequent forward and backward waves are transmitted to other points of the waveguide. We represent the signal generated by this current pulse, R , ( t ) , by
where the star implies the Faltung or convolution integral defined by
We wish to know the rf wave at a point q due to the interaction of the current pulse with the waveguide at all points u. If q > u the wave which reaches point q is a forward-going wave. If q
for the forward-going wave, and
for the backward-going wave. The boundary condition t - u ( n + $,)/w 2 0 in eqs. (4.31) and (4.32) merely states that rf waves cannot originate from points u which the electron current pulse has not yet reached. We have also written R,(t) as R f ( t ) and R,b(t) to indicate a possible difference between the source terms for forward-going and backward-going waves. Using eq. (4.29), eqs. (4.31) and (4.32) can be written as
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
169
and
In the paper Leiss et al. [I9621 the coupling function K(w) was assumed to be independent of frequency and equal to a constant K for K b respectively corresponding to forward or backward going waves. For this assumption
~ ' ( t=) K' b; (t)
(4.35)
with a corresponding expression for backward-going waves. In a somewhat different approach than by Leiss et al. [I9621 to the transient beam loading problem, Epsztein and Mangin [1966] have developed a different form of eqs. (4.33) and (4.34). It has been shown by Lapostolle (private communication) that the treatment of Epsztein and Mangin is equivalent to a different form of K(w),
which has the inverse transform K ( t ) = J, (o,t).
(4.37)
Using a coupled resonator model, Helm ([I9661 and private communication) has shown that the form of K ( t ) given by Epsztein and Mangin, eq. (4.37), is a better approximation to K(t) than that of Leiss and Schrack [1962]. The difference in the two forms of coupling between the beam and the waveguide, eq. (4.35) and eq. (4.37) can be shown by examining the convolution K' (t) * Gq-,(t) indicated in eq. (4.33) and the expression for G,(t), eq. (4.10). Using eq. (4.35) for Kf ( t ) , ~ ' ( t ) *G,-,
=Kf
2 iq - 1 ' J~(~-U)(WC') e i ~ w o t - n i q - u ) ~ e-+row.t t
(4.38)
and using eq. (4.37) for Kit),
k"(')* G,-.(')
= J2(,-.)
( w )e
i[wot - n(q - u ) l
- +aowcr
The ( q - u ) / t factor between eqs. (4.38) and (4.39) leads to a large difference in the predictions of beam loading for very short beam pulses (Epsztein et al. [1966]). This will be discussed more below. Equation (4.33) represents the induced wave due to a single delta function current pulse entering the waveguide at time t=O. The induced wave due to arbitrary current pulses can be found by folding the actual current pulse with E:(t). We will consider one special case. We would like to determine the beam-loading wave for a series of delta function current pulses occurring at repetition rate w. For this case the folding of E;(t) with the true current distribution reduces to a summation of time delayed waves
170
J.E.LEISS
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
of the form given by eq. (4.33). If the first current pulse enters the waveguide at t =0, then the kth current pulse will enter the waveguide at t = ( 2 ~ / 0 k. ) Thus the forwardgoing wave ~ , ' ( t )for this repetitive pulse situation is
+
where t - u(n IjO)/O- 2nklo 3 0. We would like to know the change in energy of a beam particle due to this beaminduced wave. For a particle in the kmth pulse, the particle passes point q of the waveguide at time
The beam induced rf at this time at point q is
The energy change vfm,of the kth particle is obtained by integrating eq. (4.41) over the length of the waveguide.
where
vim represents the energy loss due to rf fields in the waveguide induced
by the beam. To this should be added the energy gain of the beam due to rf from the power source, eq. (4.24), to obtain the total beam energy change in the waveguide. Detailed evaluations of eqs. (4.41) and (4.42) are very lengthy. For the form of K ( t ) given by eq. (4.35), results of such calculations using both the dispersive and non-dispersive forms of Gq(t) can be found in Leiss et a/. [1962]. Except for effects which occur for extremely short beam bursts, the beam loading effects found are essentially the same as those calculated from the power diffusion equation. For extremely short high intensity beam bursts, large effects are predicted (Leiss et a/. [1962], Leiss [1966]) resulting in substantially greater beam loading than would be predicted by the power diffusion equation. Epsztein and Mangin [I9661 however, whose treatment is equivalent to the use of eq. (4.37) for K ( t ) have evaluated their results for very short beam bursts and do not observe this large beam loading effect
B.1.3
BEAM LOADING AND TRANSIENT BEHAVIOR
171
for short pulses. The implication of their result therefore is that one delta function burst of charge passing through the waveguide could completely deplete the energy stored in the waveguide in this spatial mode. On geometrical grounds alone this is hard to believe. The difference between the various predictions of beam loading for very short beam bursts is important since it directly affects the maximum short pulse beam currents which are possible with traveling wave electron linear accelerators. The predictions are affected in a major way by the form of the function K ( t ) which expresses the coupling of the beam to the waveguide. The final resolution of this question will probably be determined experimentally; however the necessary experiments will be difficult.
4.4 Beam excitation of other spatial modes in the waveguide We have thus far neglected the influence of all spatial harmonics in the waveguide except that represented by T o ,,(w), eqs. (4.1) and (4.2). The response function G," ( t ) for these spatial harmonics is simply related to G,(t) by [neglecting the coefficient A 0, Aw)l
G l ( t ) = G q ( t )e-4in"q,
n integer.
(4.43)
It is usually argued that these spatial harmonics are incoherent with the beam pulses and have very little average effect. Fur rf in the waveguide from an external power source, this can be shown to be true (Leiss et al. [1962], Slater [1948]); however for beam induced rf waves it is not true in all cases. An evaluation (Leiss et al. [1962]) for beam energy loss due to excitation of thenth spatial harmonic, either forward-going or backward-going waves shows that there is transient beam loading due to excitation of these spatial harmonics. The time for this transient effect to become incoherent depends upon the group velocity in the waveguide. For typical cases of 7r/2 or 2x13 mode waveguides, this transient effect will last about 100 rf cycles. In the special case however of accelerators operating with zero group velocity, the excitation of these spatial harmonics is completely coherent with excitation of the fundamental harmonic for both forward and backward-going waves. In this special case beam loading, even in the steady state, will be about twice as large as that predicted if one considers only the fundamental forward-going wave. The most important spatial harmonic to consider is the case of n = - I, eq. (4.2). For this mode (Helm, private communication) A,,, (o)=A,, - (w). Thus for very short beam bursts (less than about 100 rf cycles) beam loading energy loss due to excitation of this mode will be twice that of the fundamental mode. The coefficients A,,,(w) of other modes are usually so small that excitation of these modes is a small effect.
,
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
References BURNOD, L., 1961, Regime transitoire dans les accklerateurs lineaires, LAL-17, Ecole Normale Superieure. EPSZTEIN, B., and J. P. MANGIN,Transients in Electron Linacs, Proc. 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, 332. J., 1965, Absorption and Generation of Radio-Frequency Power in Electron Linear AccelHAIMSON, erator Systems, Nucl. Instr. Meth. 33, 93. HELM,R., 1966, Computer Study of Wave Propagation, Beam Loading and Beam Blowup in the SLAC Accelerator, Proc. Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, 254. Le~ss,J. E., 1958a, Behavior of Linear Electron Accelerators with Beam Loading, NBS Internal Report. LEISS,J. E., 1958b, Transient Beam Loading in Linear Electron Accelerators, NBS Internal Report. LEISS,J. E., 1962, R F Transients in Linear Electron Accelerator Waveguides, NBS Internal Report. LEISS,J. E., and R. A. SCHRACK, 1962, Transient and Beam Loading Phenomena in Linear Electron Accelerators, NBS Internal Report. LEISS,J. E., 1966, Electron Linear Accelerators as Sources of High Intensity Neutron Bursts, Conference on Intense Neutron Sources, Conf.-660925, 605. NEAL,R. B., 1957, Transient Beam Loading in Linear Electron Accelerators, M.L. Report no. 388. SLATER, J. C., 1948, The Design of Linear Accelerators, Rev. Mod. Phys. 20, 473.
ELA
1.4
THEORY
B.l
Beam Breakup* R. H. HELM G . A. LOEW Stanford Linear Accrlc~ratorCenter Stanford, California, U.S.A.
I
Introduction
The phenomenon of beam breakup, alternatively known as beam blowup or pulse shortening, made its appearance at two successive stages in the development of electron linacs. The first manifestation dates back to 1957 when the effect was observed in England*", and shortly after, in the U.S.A., in various short, commercially built linacs +. As will be discussed below, this effect is of the regenerative type. The second manifestation came with the turn-on of the long machines such as possibly the DESY injector (see Crowley-Milling [1962]) and certainly the 2-GeV Kharkov linac (see Valter et al. [1965]) and the SLAC two-mile accelerator. Clear-cut experimental evidence and identification at SLAC of this second effect, of the multisection-type, dates back to April 1966 (see Neal and Panofsky [1966]). Since then, practically all workers in the field and particularly those involved in the design and construction of the new high duty cycle, long conventional or superconducting machines are intensely concerned with this problem. Table 1 s~~mmarizes the present status of the various types of instabilities. While much progress has been made in the last two years in understanding the mechanism of these instabilities and in proposing
* **
Work supported by the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission. The authors of this chapter havenot been able to find any reference in the literature dating back to 1957. The earliest British written account of beam breakup was reported in 1958 and published by Boag and Miller [1959]. The effect, however, was not understood by these authors who ascribed it to a n "unstable space charge disturbance". t A table summarizing the chronology of appearance of some of the U.S.A. linacs exhibiting beam breakup can be found in Haimson [1965]. 0 North-Holland
References p. 219
Publ. C o . , Amsfcrdam 1969
173
Known types of linac instabilities --
Mode
Pulse length
Mechanism
regenerative backward-wave oscillator
w l to
psec
< 2 psec (transient) Transverse deflecting HEM11
multi-section amplifier
-
I > 500 mA
Examples of accelerators commercial accelerators (Hughes, Arco, Varian, Metropolitan Vickers, Vickers Armstrong)
unknown
(steady-state)
MIT ALS (Saclay, France)
staggering and modification of accelerator sections solenoidal and quadrupole focusing
LASL (proton accelerator)
focusing and tapered phase velocity structures
--
Other instabilities such as coupling with resistive wall
solenoidal focusing modification of structure
-
P ?
F
8
modification of structure quadrupole focusing
SLAC
w I msec
cw
Remedies
5 m A < I < 100 mA Kharkov
m 10 psec
(transient to steady-state)
-
Current threshold I
-
-
-
-
unknown
Stanford superconducting accelerator
feedback focusing
several amperes
not yet built
not yet investigated -
-
m
F M CI
20 Z
BEAM BREAKUP
8.1.4
175
some remedies, the field is still in a state of flux and some work remains to be done to tie together the various theories and available experimental evidence. T o guide the reader, the subjects covered in the main paragraphs of this chapter are listed below: Physical manifestations and models of beam breakup, Analysis and experimental evidence of the regenerative type of beam breakup, Analysis and experimental evidence of the cumulative, multisection-type of beam breakup, Discussion of starting conditions, Proposed remedies for various types of accelerators, Other linac instabilities.
2 Physical manifestations and models of beam breakup 2.1 Description of mechanisms While the mechanism of beam breakup varies from one linear accelerator to another, the basic physical manifestation of the phenomenon illustrated in fig. 1 is the same for
Fig. 1. Oscillograms of beam pulses below and above beam breakup threshold.
all. As seen from the three video pulses, the injected beam pulse length, shown here to be 1.5 psec for the top pulse, is shortened erratically when the beam current is increased above a certain value. The shortening becomes more pronounced as the injected current is increased. In a short, single-section machine, this pattern of beam pulses can be observed at the output of the accelerator. Typically, for a section of the order of a few feet long and a pulse length in the microsecond range, the phenomenon appears for current amplitudes in the 500 mA range. For a multisection accelerator, the above pattern of pulses can be observed at any location along the accelerator and the onset of beam breakup is determined by the beam current transmitted through that point. Typical thresholds are in the 10 m A range.
176
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
As stated above, beam breakup was first discovered in short, high-current accelerators. After a period of bewilderment, workers in the field, both in England and in the U.S.A. (see M.L. Report No. 581 [1959], Kelliher and Beadle [1960], Nygard and Post [1961], Crowley-Milling et al. [1961], and Brown et al. [1961]), began to recognize the similarity of the phenomenon with backward-wave oscillations observed and generated in microwave tubes. Careful investigations of the disk-loaded accelerator structure showed that, above the TM,, accelerating mode, there are many other propagating modes, some of which exhibit transverse deflecting properties. The first mode is "TM,,-like" and will hereafter be called HEM,, because of its mixed or hybrid "E" and "H" nature. (Also see chapter B.3.7.) The o-p or dispersion diagram, the Q and the interaction impedance of this mode differ somewhat from one accelerator structure to another but the overall microwave and deflecting properties are roughly the same. In all cases, the longitudinal electric field is zero on the axis and changes sign across it. Although there is no harmonic relationship, the ratio of the frequency at which beam breakup occurs to the fundamental accelerator frequency is of the order of 312. Thus, for example, in an S-band accelerator such as the one at SLAC, operating at 2856 MHz, beam breakup occurs in the neighborhood of 4140 MHz. A further description of these properties will appear below. Both the regenerative and cumulative types of beam breakup are caused by interaction with the HEM,, mode. Both instabilities start from noise which consists of or results in a small transverse modulation of the electron bunches at the breakup frequency. However, the growth mechanisms are different. Regenerative breakup occurs in one section. Its mechanism is illustrated in fig. 2a. Consider a noise-generated INPLJT COUPLER
OUTPUT COUPLER
AXIS
T;
ELECTRON BUNCHES
-
HEM,, ENERGY FLOW
Fig. 2. (a) Single accelerator section showing regenerative instability. (b) Multisection accelerator showing cumulative instability build-up.
BEAM BREAKUP
B.1.4
177
H E M , , wave traveling with a phase velocity in the same direction as the electrons but slightly slower than they so that the electrons slip ahead by 180" in their travel along the accelerator section. Initially, the phase of the wave is such that the force on the electron bunches is strongly deflecting. Depending on their phase and on the plane of polarization of the wave, the electrons are deflected to either one side or the other in that plane. As they are deflected, they also slip ahead in phase and in the latter part of the section, they find themselves in a longitudinally decelerating field to which they give up energy. Either because of reflections or because the HEM,, mode is usually of the backward-wave type, this energy may travel back upstream where it reinforces the original deflecting field. Above a certain starting current and pulse length, the generated power may exceed the power losses (see Wilson [1963]) and both the field and the deflection grow exponentially. As a result, the beam is lost. In contrast, the cumulative, multisection-type of breakup is illustrated in fig. 2b. Here, because of the same small initial transverse modulation of the electron bunches or initial cavity excitation, the early accelerator sections individually undergo oscillations at some HEM,, resonant frequency. As a result, the next electron bunches which see this field receive an additional amount of transverse momentum which over a given distance translates itself into displacement modulation. This modulation further excites the resonant fields in the downstream cavities and these, in turn, deflect the bunches even more until finally they scrape the accelerator walls. Tndependently of the initial phase, the asymptotic phase for maximum build-up is intermediate between the phase of maximum momentum transfer and maximum field excitation. Within each beam pulse, the effect is coherent and cumulative as a function of length and time. As an example, the beam profiles along the SLAC accelerator appear as shown in fig. 3. The ordinates of the dots represent the amount of charge transmitted past the
1
0
1
5
1
10
1
15
1
1
20 25
SECTOR NUMBER
1
30
Fig. 3. Examples of beam profiles along SLAC accelerator at 2 GeV energy and 1.5 psec pulse length for three different currents: 5 mA (below breakup threshold), 21 mA (spontaneous breakup) and 27 mA (breakup stimulated through external excitation). Sector length is approximately 100 meters.
178
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LZNACS: THEORY
end of each of the thirty 333-foot accelerator sectors. In the lower trace (5 mA), the beam current from the injector is at a level below the breakup threshold for this particular set of energy, pulse length, and focusing conditions and no current is lost along the accelerator. In the middle trace (21 mA), the injected current has been increased to a level above the natural breakup threshold. As can be seen, the current transmitted past sector 20 becomes erratic and an increasingly large fraction of the electron bunches is lost to the accelerator walls and to the beam collimators. Thus, bunches which are transmitted beyond sector 20 correspond to increasingly earlier parts of the injected pulse. In the upper trace (27 mA), the injected current has been further increased and, in addition, a few milliwatts of cw power at 4140 MHz have been injected onto the beam by means of an in-line cavity located forty feet downstream of the injector. It is seen that breakup now occurs as early as sector 14 and that the external stimulation causes the breakup pattern to be less erratic, the amplitude of the driving term of the breakup mode having been stabilized. The effect of external stimulation will be discussed in greater detail in a later section of this chapter.
2.2 Properties of the HEM,, mode
It is interesting to note that progress in understanding the basically undesirable beam breakup effect was greatly aided by work in a parallel field, namely that of rf separators, where the HEM,, mode is used for constructive purposes. Hence, a wealth of information on the HEM,, mode in disk-loaded waveguides can be found in the literature on this subject. For a complete bibliography, the reader is referred to such articles as Saxon et al. [1963], Altenmueller et al. [1964], Hahn and Halama [1966], Garault (to be published), and chapter B.3.7 of this book. Only some of the salient properties relevant to beam breakup will be discussed here. The general remarks on the TM,,-type mode in periodic structures made in chapter B. 1.1 are also applicable to the HEM,, mode. Hence, the mode has a dispersion diagram of the general form shown in fig. B.l.l (2) and it is relevant to associate with it the concepts of space harmonics, shunt impedance, Q and r / Q . As will be seen, the definition of shunt impedance must be modified slightly since the axial electric field intensity vanishes on axis and has a specific transverse polarization. The detailed properties of the HEM,, mode in a particular disk-loaded structure depend, of course, on its modular dimensions. A typical Brillouin diagram measured in an experimental accelerator used by Jarvis et al. [I9651 is shown in figs. 4a and 4b. Both the lower and upper passband branches are shown. The dimensions given in the caption follow the same nomenclature as indicated in fig. B.l.l (23a). The phase velocity, as usual, is designated by v, and the propagation constant as 8. Similar diagrams have been plotted for numerous other accelerators of uniform modular dimensions (see for example Artemov et al. [1967)]. In the case of constant-gradient
BEAM BREAKUP
B.1.4
179
accelerator sections of the SLAC type where the modular dimensions are tapered (see fig. B.1.1 (29)), the w-/? diagram changes as a function of cavity location. A family of curves is shown in fig. 5. As will be shown later, beam breakup in this structure can be excited at several frequencies. These frequencies correspond to resonances taking place when the phase shifts of the first few cavities add up to a multiple of n. The lowest resonance occurs at ~ 4 1 3 9 . 6MHz for which the phase shift
4300
n 4
,
n -
3rr
2
PHASE S H I F T PER CAVITY
n
(pd)
a) LOWER PASSBAND
PHASE S H I F T PER CAVITY
(od)
b l UPPER PASSBAND
Fig. 4. Typical Brillouin (or ~0-b) diagram, reproduced from Jarvis et a / . [I9651 showing propagation characteristics of HEM11 mode in disk-loaded waveguide (2b = 7.842 cm, 2a = 2.214 cm, d = 2 cm, operating frequency = 2998 MHz).
180
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
a/3
n/2
2 ~ / 3
PHASE SHIFT PER CAVITY
5a/6
n
(Pod)
Fig. 5. Brillouin (or w-8) diagram for the HEM11 mode at five locations along SLAC ten-foot accelerator section.
of the first cavity is shown to be 0.765~.As the wave at this frequency progresses along the guide, the phase shift per cavity reaches n and a cut-off is reached. The resultant experimentally measured electric field intensity is shown in fig. 6 and the approximate electric and magnetic field pattern for z-phase shift per cavity is shown in fig. 7. Figure 8, in turn, gives several of the lowest resonances in the SLAC structure. The plot in fig. 8a was obtained by measuring the VSWR looking into the section input. The amplitude and phase distributions of the first three resonances shown in fig. 8b were obtained from a calculation based on a model of the interaction of an electron beam with a series of coupled resonators, which will be discussed later in this chapter. Similar dispersion diagrams and field patterns have been obtained by other designers of non-uniform accelerator sections and examples can be found in chapter B.3.2 and MClard [1967]. Using the general principles of periodic structures presented in chapter B. 1.1, $2, it can be shown (e.g., see Hahn and Halama 119651) that the longitudinal electric field component E, of the HEM,, mode in the central region of a lossless iris-loaded waveguide is given by
B.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
181
where 4, r and z are the usual cylindrical coordinates, a, and P, are the a m p l i t ~ ~ and de propagation constant of the nth space harmonic, a is the iris radius and k,?,,+pi= k 2 where k = o l c . Expressions for the other field components will be given in later sections of this chapter. As will be seen, the expression for the transverse shunt impedance r,, relevant in calculating the transverse deflection in the r-direction, is given by
Notice the difference between this expression and eq. B. 1.1 (8). The other parameters which will be of interest later in this chapter are Q and r J Q . Numerical values can be obtained either from calculations or from experiments using microwave cold tests o r I
I FREQUENCY = 4139.7 MHz
I 10
I 20
DISTANCE FROM INPUT COUPLER CAVITY ( CENTIMETERS )
Fig. 6. Measured electric field variation in the first 8 cavities of a SLAC ten-foot accelerator section when excited at 4139.7 MHz through the input coupler.
B FIELD LINES
E F I E L D LINES
Fig. 7. Approximate electric and magnetic HEM11 field patterns for n-phase shift per cavity shown here in y-polarization.
182
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW 32 30 28 26 24 22 20 18
16 14 12 10 8 6
4 2 4140
4150
0 )
4160 FREOUENCY IMHzI
4170
VSWR LOOKING INTO SECTION INPUT
SECOND MODE
AMPLITUDE
W
AMPLITUDE
W
53
t
0
a
.;
0
! PHASE
"-."
:-
10
20
0
10
20
0
20
10
CAVITY NUMBER
CAVITY NUMBER
CAVITY NUMBER
(A)
(B)
(C)
b ) EXAMPLES OF COMPUTED AMPLITUDE AND PHASE DISTRIBUTION
Fig. 8. Measured and computed HEM~I-moderesonances in SLAC constant-gradient section. The double dips in the measured curve are due to a slight difference between the vertical and horizontal resonant frequencies. This difference is caused by slight mechanical asymmetries.
deflection tests with actual beams. It is interesting to note that the value of Q which is relevant to the beam breakup effect is the loaded Q and that its value depends on the orientation and configuration of the accelerator coupler (see figs. B. 1.1 (30) and (3 1)). If the coupler orientation is taken to be in the x-direction, Q, is greater than Q, because for the y-polarization no power can in principle couple into the external system unless there is some imperfection or asymmetry in the structure. In fact, in the
B.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
183
limit, Q, is equal to the unloaded Q , whereas Q, depends on the coupling coefficient and the impedance seen through the coupler. Associated with these differences, there can also exist a slight difference between the beam breakup frequencies in the x- and y-direction (see fig. 8a). Further evidence for these facts will be presented later in this chapter. A typical setup used to detect the signals carried by the beam is shown in fig. 9. Such microwave cavities can also be used on the beam centerline to impart an initial external excitation to the electron bunches and thereby to study the mechanisms responsible for starting beam breakup. It should also be noticed that, if for example as
HORIZONTAL
Fig. 9. Cavities used in beam breakup experiments at SLAC (4140 MHz).
at SLAC, beam breakup appears at 4140 MHz for electrons bunched at 2856 MHz, the growing sinewave representing the envelope of their displacement appears also at the difference frequency, 4140 - 2856 = 1284 MHz, at the difference between the third harmonic of 2856 and 4140, namely 4428 MHz and a t 4428 - 2856 = 1572 MHz (etc. ...). Hence, while the basic microwave interaction takes place only at 4140 MHz, the other frequencies are always present on the beam and can be detected by resonant cavities similar to those of fig. 9.
3 Regenerative beam breakup 3.1
The interaction mechanism
The interaction responsible for the dipole type of beam breakup may first be illustrated by the example of a simple cylindrical cavity in which a T M , field is excited. The
,,
184
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
field components in such a cavity may be written as J, (kr) cos $ B, K - i [J, (kr)/(kr)]sin 4 B , oc - iJ; ( k r ) cos 4 E, = E, = B, = 0 E,
K
or near the axis, if the polarization is in the x-direction,
where k = wlc, and a factor ei"' is understood. A relativistic electron traversing the cavity of length I near the axis receives a transverse momentum impulse
and gives the cavity an energy increment of
where v is the electron velocity and y = [1 - ( V / C ) ~ ] - * . Thus, the electron receives a transverse momentum impulse in leading quadrature with the electric field and imparts to the field an increment of energy which is positive if the transverse displacement is opposite in sign to the electric field. Now suppose one considers a disk-loaded accelerator structure as consisting of a string of suchcavities coupled together by axial holes, with appropriate phase shifts from cavity to cavity. The presence of the holes will introduce transverse components of E-field and longitudinal B-field, as is known from the theory of rf deflectors (chapter B.3.7); however, eq. (4) still represents the dominant transverse effect. Assume that one of the space harmonics of the deflecting HEM,, mode is approximately synchronous with a beam of electrons traveling along the axis. Figure 10 shows a sketch of the Lorentz force field [E+(v/c)x B] for this mode in the plane of maximum deflection; the field is presumed to propagate as exp [iw(t- z/vp)]where the phase velocity u p is slightly less than the electron velocity. Electrons which enter the structure at maximum deflecting phase, located at points 1 or 3 in the sketch, will be deflected into a retarding field and thus will transfer energy to the field as they slip forward in space. Electrons which enter the structure at intermediate phase angles such as at point 2 will in general also transfer a positive (or zero) amount of energy to the field. The amplification will be maximized if the total phase slip through the structure is
* Gaussian units are used throughout this section, unless otherwise noted.
8.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
185
approximately n. In a dispersive structure, there will in general be some frequency a L t which the phase slip is optimized and it is near this frequency that breakup is mos likely t o occur. Now if, in addition to the amplifying mechanism which has been described, there exists a feedback mechanism, regeneration can occur and the amplification may be greatly enhanced. Then if the beam current exceeds a certain threshold, the power generated by the beam will exceed the power flowing out of the structure (e.g., by wall loss), and any initial noise signal will start the regenerative oscillation building up continually until the field is so great that the beam is deflected into the walls. As has been discussed previously, a feedback mechanism may be supplied either by the backward-wave characteristic which is typical of the H E M , , mode (figs. 4 and 5 ) , or by reflections from the ends of the structure.
---
LORENTZ FORCE ELECTRON TRAJECTORIES
Fig. 10. Schematic representation of the Lorentz force near the axis in the HEM11 mode, in a system co-moving with the wave. 1-l', 2-2' and 3-3' represent trajectories of electrons which enter the structure at phase points 1, 2 or 3, travel slightly faster than the phase of the wave, and leave the structure at phase points l', 2', 3'.
3.2 Backward-wave oscillator breakup Starting current analysis. Analysis of the backward-wave oscillator mechanism for beam breakup has been carried out by Wilson [I9631 and extended by Cheng [I9641 and Chu [1966]. The basic assumptions in this type of treatment are: 1. That the wave propagation of the HEM,, traveling-wave mode is characterized by a well defined, negative, group velocity v,= - Iv,l; the propagation constant is given to first order by
where fi=w/v,, v, is the phase velocity, o, is the frequency for which v,=c, and P o = wo/c.
186
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
2. That the wave propagates with forward phase velocity (backward group velocity) and is totally absorbed at the ends of the structure, i.e., the possibility of resonant buildup is ignored. 3. That the longitudinal bunch structure is incoherent with the breakup frequency, and may be ignored. 4. That the accelerator structure has longitudinally uniform properties. The starting current for backward-wave oscillations was estimated by the above authors by equating the power generated by the beam to the power propagating in the wave. The power generated, time-averaged over an rf cycle, is given in terms of the current density, J, by
beam
or L
where I. is the beam current, L is the length of the accelerator section, [ 1, denotes evaluation along an electron trajectory for which t = z + j', dzl/v(z') and where t = z at z=0. The x in eq. (7) is the first moment of the beam current density, i.e., the deflection which arises from the rf field; it is given by integration of eq. (4):
where the longitudinal momentum p is given by r n ~ ( ~ I)* ' in the first order paraxial approximation (p,
then combination of eqs. (7), (8) and (9) yields
where A(z)= j",b(z')'dz, and 6j3=w(l/vP- l/v)=(oo-o)(l/v,- l/c)-k(c/v- 1). Equation (10) may be evaluated in zero order approximation on the assumption that p(z) and E(z, z) are constant; the result is
B.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
187
where a = L6P is the phase slip parameter, and g , (cr), as defined by Wilson [1963], is g 2 (a)
= +(I
-
cos cr
-
+a sin a)/(cr/7~)~ .
(12)
The power generation is maximized when the phase slip parameter is 2 ~ 2 . 6 5 ,for which g, (a) = 1 .O4. The power propagated by the wave is related to the field by the definition of shunt impedance given in eq. (2), as follows:
where Q is the quality factor. In Wilson's approximation the geometric factor r,/Q may be written
where /I,, = 3.82 is the first root of J,( P ) ; J0(pl1)= -0.403; q =impedance of free space (4771~in gaussian units, or 377 ohms); 1,/1= 1 is the ratio of the effective TM,,, cavity length I, to the actual disk spacing, I; and g , =sin (+wl,/v)/(+wl,/u) is the cavity coupling coefficient which takes into account the fact that the peak cavity field is greater than the effective field along an electron trajectory. By equating the power flow P , given by eq. (13) to the previous estimate of the beam power P,, one can find the starting current for regenerative backward-wave oscillation :
The effect of wall losses has been investigated by Wilson [I9631 who estimates that for an attenuation on the order of 1 neper, the starting current is increased by about 70%. The effect of acceleration in an active section has also been estimated by Wilson, retaining the assumption that the electron velocity is constant and equal to c ; it is then found that the starting current as given by eq. (1 5) should be modified by a factor F,(p/p,), where p and p, are the final and initial longitudinal momenta and
Note that in eq. (15), p is defined as final momentum. For large argument, Fa=$. As a numerical example, consider a typical S-band accelerator with four disks per
*
Equation (14) generally agrees with experimental values of r,/Q to within a factor of about 2.
188
R.H.HELM, C.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
wavelength for which the synchronous frequency in the TM,, (accelerating) mode is 2856 MHz; then I=2.63 cm. Assume a I-meter section (L=100 cm) with final energy z 15 MeV and p, 4 p . Experimentally, the synchronous frequency in the deflecting mode in such a structure is ~ 4 2 5 MHz 0 and the group velocity is v,/c % -0.02. The geometric factor r,i/Q according to eq. (14) is ~ 2 0 ohms. 0 Using Wilson's correction for acceleration but neglecting attenuation, one then finds 4 ~ 6 mA 6 for the current required for the oscillations to build up in infinite time. In similar structures, breakup is actually observed at about 100 mA after several microseconds, so that the above estimate is qualitatively correct. Chu [I9661 included the effect of axial magnetic focusing and calculated an improvement factor which in the limit of high focusing field becomes
where Is(0) is the starting current in the absence of focusing and PL is the Larmor wave number defined by /?, =$eB,/pc. If one takes L = 1 m and pcle = 6 MV = 2 x 1o4 gauss cm, an axial field of B,z 1500 gauss would be required to produce an improvement factor of 2. Estimate of growth rate. Wilson [I9631 and Chu [I9661 have given estimates of the rate of buildup of the backward-wave oscillations, using the simple model which was applied to the starting current analysis in the previous section. Chu's result may be stated as
-
Thus, the fields tend to build up exponentially at a rate proportional to the amount by which the actual current I exceeds the starting current Is. As a typical example, consider an experiment performed by Jarvis et al. [I9651 using a short section of S-band, 2x15-mode accelerator (see fig. 4). The synchronous frequency in the accelerating mode was 2998 MHz and the disk spacing was I= 2 cm; the total length was L=90 cm. In the deflecting mode the synchronous frequency was found to be 4433.2 MHz and the group velocity was -0.038~. A beam of electrons of about 5 MeV was injected into the section; the section was not excited by any accelerating field except by beam induction. Pulse shortening was observed (see fig. 11) at 4.3 psec (the longest available beam pulse) at a beam current of z 312 mA; the onset shortened to about 3 psec at 350 mA and to about 1 psec at 440 mA. Application of eq. (14) gives r , i / Q ~ 2 3 5ohms, and eq. (15) then yields Is % 130 mA for the starting current. Alternatively, one may extrapolate the data on breakup time vs. current by using eq. (17) and assuming that the amplification factor required to produce breakup is relatively independent of current. In this way an estimate of 200 to 250 mA is found, indicating that the crude theory leading to eq. (15) may be somewhat conservative. Jarvis et al. [I9651 also measured the frequency of the rf associated with the breakup, and quoted a value of 1 . 1 7 for ~ the phase slip parameter, a value which is to be com-
8.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
189
pared with the value 0.8171 which maximizes the g, function. They suggest that this discrepancy may be a result of resonance in the structure, since the ends were not well terminated except at a particular polarization. BWO tratisient analysis. The theory outlined in the preceding section is put in a more self-consistent form if one develops a "wave equation" which describes the phenomenon. We note that Poynting's theorem applied to a direrential length of the waveguide results in an equation of energy conservation:
aujat
+ a q a z + ( W I Q )u = aPblaz
where the symbols are as defined previously. Using the expressions given in the previous section, one can then infer the differential equation
beam current, mA
Fig. 11. Typical illustration of regenerative beam breakup showing plot of pulse length before breakup versus beam current (reproduced from Jarvis et al. [1965]).
where X is defined by x= x ei("'-Pz) and is given explicitly by
x = ie J d z ' J E(itl, c
e i ~ A ( z ) - A i z 9 z , dzrt ~
P(.'>
in terms of A ( z ) as in eq. (10). The stability of the system may be investigated by looking for eigensolutions of the form X = t ( z ) eiA(')+"; the eigenfunctions then are solutions of
subject to the boundary conditions X(0, z) = 0, X' ( 0 , z)=O, and E ( L , z)=0 which
190
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
are equivalent to t ( 0 ) = tl(0)= tl'(L)=O. In the special case of a coasting beam [p(z)=constant], 5 has solutions of the form epzsuch that
The general solution for t is a linear combination of the three solutions corresponding to the three roots of eq. (21). Application of the three boundary conditions 5(0)= 5' (0) = 5'' (L) = 0 then yields a determinantal equation which relates the growth rate A to the beam current I,. Hirakawa [I9641 obtained an equivalent result by a much more rigorous method which also includes the case of axial magnetic focusing. He gives numerical results, based on the analogous problem in conventional backward-wave oscillators, which seem to agree at least qualitatively with experimental observations on the regenerative beam breakup. Bjorkholm and Hyneman [I9651 obtained essentially the real part of eqs. (1 8) and (19) and gave computer results which show very nicely the asymptotic eigenfunction behavior of the fields and deflections above the breakup threshold. They also reported that they obtained good quantitative agreement with experimental breakup data on a particular machine (see also fig. 13). A very similar formulation is given by Voskresensky and Koroza [1965], Voskresensky et al. [1966a], and Voskresensky and Serebriakov [1967]. The latter paper gives numerical solutions for the eigenfunction problem including the case of axial magnetic focusing, and indicates that the breakup growth at a particular beam current can be completely suppressed if a sufficiently large focusing field is used.
3.3 Standing-wave breakup In the foregoing discussion it has been assumed explicitly that the fields propagate as pure traveling waves without reflections from the ends of the structures. In actual linacs, however, this is seldom the case; the rf couplers are generally not well matched for the transverse mode and in fact are usually completely decoupled at some particular polarization. Furthermore, if one considers machines which were built before the early 1960's, one finds that most of these operated at the n/2 accelerating mode in which the synchronous point in the deflecting mode was about 3x14; the group velocity was relatively high, the sections were rather short (particularly in machines designed for high-beam currents) and the round-trip attenuation (wL/Qv,) was small (typically a few tenths of a neper). Thus, the buildup of regenerative oscillations was probably affected by standing waves in the guide. On the other hand, in more recent machines in which the accelerating mode is usually 2x13, the synchronous point in the deflecting passband is near the n mode. Thus, the breakup phenomenon in this case can only build up through a standingwave effect.
B.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
191
Starting current. The case of regenerative breakup in standing-wave proton linacs has been analyzed by Gluckstern [1964], Gluckstern et al. [1965], and Gluckstern and Butler [1965]. Wilson [I9671 has considered electron linacs with particular reference t o superconducting machines (see chapter E.2). A simple calculation of the starting current, equivalent to Wilson's treatment, is given here. In analogy with eq. (9), let the field be defined such that
where the forward and backward waves are assumed to have equal amplitudes, i.e., (Ef( = I Eb( ; the phase relation between E, and E, and the normal mode constraints on /I depend on the boundary conditions at the ends of the structure, which in general are not well defined. The mechanism of energy dissipation is now just the wall loss given by
in which the cross terms between the forward and backward waves vanish through integration because they contain factors of exp (f2ipz). The power generated by the beam is given formally by eqs. (7) and (8), with the field defined by eq. (22). In this case the contribution of the backward wave does not vanish exactly, but may be shown to be quite small compared to the forward-wave contribution.* Thus if one again considers the constant energy case, eq. (1 1) applies and one has
By equating Pb to Pw one obtains the starting current for regenerative standing wave oscillations :
Here also the effect of acceleration may roughly be taken into account by multiplying expression (24) by the factor F, ( p l p , ) given by eq. (1 6). (Gluckstern [I9641 calculates a slightly different factor which, however, gives very similar numerical results.)
* The case of the n-mode resonance is excluded for the moment.
** Equation (24) differs formally from the result of Wilson [I9671 by a factor of 2. This is because here we use the "local" shunt impedance defined by r , = lE12/(toU/Q)at any point in the structure, while Wilson uses an effective "standing-wave" shunt impedance equivalent to (rL)sw = I EfI2LIPa.
R.H. HELM, G.A.LOEW
192
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
In the special case of the z-mode, it may be shown that, because the forward wave is coherent with a space harmonic of the backward wave, the starting current given by eq. (24) should be reduced by a factor of two. In general, the normal mode constraints on the propagation constant P are such that the phase slip function g , ( L 6P) is not exactly maximized. However, because the mode spacing is typically IP j + - Pjl = z / L , it may be shown that there is always at least one mode for which g, is within ~ 7 0 % of its maximum value. The effect of a "resonance" such that the breakup frequency is a harmonic of the beam bunching frequency has been considered. Estimates by Gluckstern [I9641 and numerical computations by Gluckstern and Butler [I9651 show that the breakup threshold would be reduced by no more than 30% to 50% by a bunching resonance. It should be realized, however, that the starting noise might be enhanced very greatly, since a misalignment of the beam would be equivalent to a transverse modulation as a result of the resonance. Estimate of growth rate. To estimate the rate of buildup of the standing-wave oscillations, one should note that energy conservation in a differential length of the structure, in the absence of power propagation, may be expressed as aU/at +(o/Q) U = aP,/az. In terms of the preceding theory (eqs. (22) through (24)), this expression results in
Thus
E I o e"
where
A=
2Q
(10
-
I).
Is
This estimate is valid only if the growth rate, A, is much smaller than the mode spacing, i.e., if
Otherwise the traveling-wave type of analysis, which has been discussed earlier, is more appropriate.
3.4 Transient coupled resonator formulation The transient theory which was outlined in a previous section of 8 3, may be inadequate under certain conditions. For example, the group velocity may vary appreciably within the frequency band associated with the transient phenomenon. In particular, the assumption of a well-defined group velocity breaks down completely if the synchronous frequency in the deflecting band is near the z-mode, as is the case for the 2x13 accelerating mode.
BEAM BREAKUP
8.1.4
193
The method of expansion of the fields into coupled-resonator normal modes* is one means of solving the n-mode difficulty, but it is not readily adaptable to transient traveling-wave problems. We give here a slightly different and less rigorous but very adaptable version of the coupled resonator formulation. Let the accelerator structure be represented as a linear lattice of loosely coupled resonant cavities (cells) (see fig. 12). The fields in a given cell, say the nth cell, may be represented as a n expansion in the normal cavity modes (Slater [1950]). Assume (a) that only the solenoidal fields are relevant, and (b) that for frequencies near a particular passband the fields may be characterized by a single (perturbed) mode. Thus, in terms of Fourier-transformed** quantities, the vector potential in the nth cell may be defined as
with
For convenience, the characteristic mode function is assumed to be normalized:
) proceeding in analogy Starting with the wave equation (V2 + w ~ / c A~ = ) - ( 4 ~ 1J~and
rEXTEbJJ; nth 7
n- I , n
COUPLING
Fig. 12. Typical unit cells and geometric nomenclature in coupled resonator formulation. 1
* See, e.g., Gluckstern [1964], Gluckstern and Butler [1965], Gluckstern et a / . [1965], and Gluckstern et al. [1966].
**
The Fourier transform of a function A ( t ) will be denoted A ( w ) .
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
194
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
with Slater [I9501 we find the dispersion equation
( - w2 + iww,,/~.+ o:) A. - ~'(K."-'A.-,
+ K."'~A,,+,)= 47rc I - Rd cell
~ .
(27)
Here the right-hand side and the first three terms on the left follow directly from Slater's theory, with
J
cell
J
wall
where 6=~(21zow,)-~is the skin depth; the terms in K,"" arise from boundary matching at the holes, and may be treated by small-hole coupling theory * (see, e.g., Bevensee [1964]). If the properties of adjacent cells are nearly the same, we may assume that K,"' ' = K,", ,. The dispersion equation may also be interpreted phenomenologically. Thus, if we consider a structure which is uniform so that K,"" =K,"-' K, it is evident that in the case of J=O, eq. (27) has solutions of the form ei("'*"') where 0 =Dl, the complex phase shift per cell, is given by
-
+ iwwn/Qn- w2)/w2. In the usual case where 1 Kl < 1, Q91, and Iw - wnl/on'? IKI, we may write K cos f3 = +(mi
(284
Thus, to the extent that the attenuation term may be neglected and that K and onare independent of frequency, the relation of o to 0 is a simple cosine curve with K as the relative half-bandwidth and wn as the midband frequency. Nishikawa et al. [I9661 give analogous relations between the coupling parameters and the dispersion curve in the case of biperiodic structures. It will be assumed that the current J consists of a beam of electrons traveling in the +z direction with velocity v, so that
and
where t e ( z ) = ~ ~ z ' / v ( z land ) ; that the wave function $, appropriate to the HEM,, mode, may be represented near the axis by
* The characteristic frequency wn will also be perturbed by a fraction on the order of Knn*l, but this need not be expressed explicitly here.
BEAM BREAKUP
B.1.4
195
Substituting eqs. (29) and (30) in (27), keeping only terms of first order in (w - on)/wn, w/Qn and K,"", imposing causality and reality conditions, and transforming back to the time domain, we find
where A, is evaluated along the electron trajectory and the explicit time dependence has been expressed in terms of the starting time, T = t - J ' , dz'/u(z'); the other definitions are:
+
6tn,+z(ln +In_+ ,)/(un v,, ,) is the electron transit time per cell ; q is the impedance of free space (4nlc in gaussian units or 377 ohms); I(T) is the beam current; xn(z) is the centroid of the beam in the nth cell;
The transverse momentum impulse per cell is (Panofsky and Wenzel [1956])
so that the beam displacement is given by
where the half-integer subscripts refer to values at cell boundaries, approximated by averages of the adjacent mid-cell values. The longitudinal momentum p (z) is assumed to be determined by the fields in the accelerating (TM,,) mode. The form factor F, is related to the transverse shunt impedance, given by eq. (2), as follows: ~ (ril/Q>, = 2 r l ( w , / ~ )F?
.
(35)
Equations (31) and (34) describe the transient coupled-resonator formulation of beam breakup, subject to arbitrary initial and boundary conditions. For example, the following typical boundary conditions could be specified at the output boundary, n=N:
A
(T - S t + )
=A
)
(shorting plane at z N ++);
196
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
AN+ (Z - dtN++)= AN+ (Z or AN+,(z)
-
0
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
+ StN++)
(longitudinal short in N
(shorting plane at zN);
+ 1 cell).
Equivalent specifications for the input boundary are analogous. Beam boundary conditions might include static misalignment, arbitrary transverse rf modulation, or the effect of the breakup interaction in preceding accelerator sections. Typical initial conditions might be A,(O) = 0 for all n. The coupled resonator formulation in general cannot be solved analytically. By introducing suitable restrictions or limiting approximations, one can go either to the normal mode theory (see, e.g., Gluckstern [1964]), or to the continuous transmission
I
II 21 C E L L NUMBER, n
31
Fig. 13. Computed regenerative breakup in a short uniform n/2-mode linac with characteristic impedance terminations.Beam current: 350 mA; all other conditions as described by Bjorkholm and Hyneman [1965]. The small ripples arise from excitation of a field component with backward phase velocity.
BEAM BREAKUP
B.1.4
197
line formulation discussed previously (eqs. (18) and (19)). Numerical computations are required, except in rather trivial cases, in order t o describe the breakup under highly transient conditions. A computer solution of an approximate form of the coupled resonator breakup equations is described by Helm [1966]. Figure 13 shows the result of a typical computation for the structure described by Bjorkholm and Hyneman [1965]. This was a uniform n/2 mode, 2856 MHz accelerator, 0.8 m in length, with injection energy of 80 keV; the measured parameters in the HEM band were w0/2n = 4250 MHz, t),(wo)z -0.019c, Q = 9800; derived parameters used in the present calculation were toJ2nz4285 MHz, w , ~ , " " / 2 n z -50.6 MHz, and r,/Q=30.8 ohms/cm (by eq. (14)). The computed results at a beam current of 350 mA closely match Bjorkholm and Hyneman's computation at 175 mA, the discrepancy apparently arising from an error of a factor of two in Bjorkholm and Hyneman's calculation of the stored energy. Figure 14 shows a computation for the same structure, with boundary conditions of
1
I
0.6 psec
II 21 CELL NUMBER, n
31
Fig. 14. Computed regenerative breakup in a short n/2-mode linac with shorted ends. All other conditions the same as in fig. 13. Note characteristic normal mode pattern.
198
R.H. HELM, G.A. LOEW
ELECTRON LTNACS : THEORY
mid-iris shorting planes rather than characteristic impedance terminations. Here the breakup shows a characteristic normal mode standing-wave pattern. Figure 15 shows a similar computation for the SLAC structure described in chapter B.l.l, fig. 29 and in this chapter, 5 2, figs. 5, 6 and 8. In this case a shorting plane is assumed at the input boundary, and downstream termination results from the tapered structure becoming cut-off, for the dominant breakup frequency, at about the 10th cell. The field pattern and asymptotic frequency (w4148.4 MHz) are quite close to one of the normal modes of the structure as shown in fig. 8.
I
0
I
I
I
20 CELL NUMBER
'10
I
I
I
30
Fig. 15. Computed regenerative breakup in first 30 cells of the SLAC tapered structure for 3 A beam.
4 Multisection or cumulative beam breakup 4.1 Analysis of multisection beam breakup As has been discussed in 5 2, the rnultisection type of beam breakup results from the cumulative interaction of the beam with an entire array of separate accelerator sections which are electrically isolated, the signal being carried from section to section by the beam. The effect manifests itself at beam currents well below the threshold for regenerative breakup. This effect may be divided roughly into two parts: 1. In the first few sections of the machine, where the energy is low, regeneration may be important. In this case the interaction should be treated in detail by use of one of the transient theories outlined previously. This effect appears to be especially
BEAM BREAKUP
B.1.4
199
relevant in machines such as the 2-GeV Kharkov linac which have rather long uniform sections in which the regenerative starting current at injection energy may be of the order of a few tens of milliamperes. 2. In the remainder (whichmight actually include the entire machine), regeneration is unimportant and we may employ a much simpler model. Such a model assumes that the effect of an entire accelerator section, or even a group of several sections, is equivalent t o an impulse at a single point. This description applies particularly to machines such as SLAC, which use tapered sections in which the synchronous length at any frequency is very short. Only the latter case will be considered in detail here, although one must remember that the impulse model may not be strictly valid in the first few accelerator sections. Sitigle cavity model. We assume that the field in the H E M , , passband in a given accelerator section may be expanded in normal modes*, each characterized by a n , a characteristic mode pattern frequency oJ,a phase shift per cell O ~ = f l ~ Iand the field associated with the jth mode is now given in the nth cell of the section by
where *,, u' and r are as defined earlier (9 3 and fig. 12). For example, in a periodic structure of N identical cells terminated by mid-iris shorting planes, we would have f l j l = d j = , j n / ~where O < j < N; X: K sin(/?-4) O j ; the frequency spectrum o'=o(/?j) would be determined by the o-fl curve. In aperiodic structures, the mode pattern, frequency spectrum and phase shift may be determined by rf measurements (see fgs. 5, 6 and 8 ; also see Altenmueller et al. [1966], Loew [1967]) or by computer techniques (Helm [ I 9661). The mode functions will be assumed to be normalized:
Xi
I n analogy with the Slater theory used in the previous section, the following differential equation is now found:
Here an impulse approximation has been used; the beam deflection xn(r) has been assumed to vary only slightly over the length of one accelerator section and has been replaced by a mean value x ( z , 7 ) . It may be shown that FJ, the form factor for the entire section, is given by
where Fn, the form factor for one cell, has been defined by eq. (32), 46 is an arbitrary
*
See, e.g., Nagle [I9641 and Nishikawa [1965].
R.H. HELM, G.A. LOEW
200
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
phase angle which should be chosen to maximize the interaction, and t,=J:; dzlu. The value of Qj, the unloaded Q of the structure, is given by
l / Q j = C (x3"Qn. n
(40)
For a uniform structure, Qj= Q, by virtue of eq. (37). The transverse momentum impulse, found by integrating (e/c)dA,/dx along an electron trajectory, may be shown to be
It will be convenient to define a new field variable V j ( z ) such that
oi
is the "ringing" frequency defined by wd = w j [1 - ( 1 / 2 ~ j ) ~ ] $It. follows where from eqs. (38) and (41) that
and
where the total shunt impedance R{ is defined by
R { / Q ~= 2~ ( ~ / (d~ )j .~ ) ~
(45)
Equations (43) and (44) describe the equivalent thin-cavity initeraction of an accelerator section. In general R, is related to the shunt impedance per unit length by an effective length L',,:
where r , may be estimated, e.g., by eq. (14). In a uniform structure, the effective length is typically L,, =+T2L (or T 2 L at n. mode) where T=(sin +cr)/(+cr), L= total length, and cr is the total phase slip of the beam relative to the wave. In non-uniform structures the effective length may be found by rf measurements or by computer methods (Helm [1966]). Computer solution of multisection breakup. An actual multisection accelerator consists of many successive beam transport elements such as drift and accelerator sections, lenses, and the deflecting "cavities" described above. The most straightforward method of numerical analysis of the cumulative breakup is to ray-trace each beam bunch through the system. For this analysis, it is convenient to modify the
BEAM BREAKUP
B.1.4
201
preceding results slightly. Let us drop the normal mode index j and replace w j and w { (which are practically equal) by w , , noting that different modes may be treated by superposition of distinct "cavities" rewritten as
in the computation. Equation (44) may be
I
V(T)
=
C1
S
I ( t ' ) X ( Z ,t') exp [iG,
0
(T
- t')] dt'
(46)
where the initial condition V(O)=O
has been assumed; 6 ,= w , (1 +i/2Q) and C , = ~ ? R , / ~ C QNow, . if we express the beam current explicitly as a series of deltafunction bunches, i.e.,
where to is the bunching period, then by using (46) the following recursion relationship may be found:
in which for convenience the functional time dependences have been redefined as bunch number m rather than mt,. The beam transformation for the mth bunch from a point z- just ahead of the "cavity" t o z,, just beyond the "cavity", is
Thus eqs. (48) and (49) represent the effect of a single "cavity" located a t point z, in a form ideal for iterative solution by computer. The effects of other beam transport elements are described by well-known transformations (see, e.g., in chapter B.1.2). A computer program which simulates arbitrary configurations of individual "cavities", accelerator and drift sections, lenses and other components has been used extensively in analyzing the multisection breakup a t SLAC. Examples of computer results and comparison with experiment are given in 4 4.2 (see also Helm et al. [I9681 and Farinholt et al. [1967]). Asymptotic transient behavior. Considerable insight into the behavior of the multisection breakup may be gained by use of a very simple model employed by Panofsky [1966] (see also Voskresensky et al. [1966b]). A number of assumptions are made in this model : (1) All the interacting "cavities" are assumed identical and only a single resonant mode w, is considered. (2) The beam current I is taken to be constant for T > O , and zero for 760. (3) The beam bunching is considered incoherent with the breakup frequency, i.e., o,/o, is not a ratio of small integers. (4) Variations in the amplitudes of fields and deflections are "slow" compared to the frequency w,. ( 5 ) The motion is relativistic, so that u z c and p z m c y . (6) The relative growth in deflection amplitude per accelerator section is small.
202
R.H.HELM. G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
We consider only the component of the deflection which has frequencies near o,, and write
x ( z , z)
= Re ( X
( z , 7) exp [ia ,z])
(50)
where X is a slowly varying complex amplitude. Then, going to a continuous approximation by defining Ap, ( z , z ) = L (dldz) p, ( z , T ) , where L is the spacing between cavities, using eqs. (41) and (46), and neglecting focusing, we find
2 az ( y
z)
= - iCI
j
X ( z , r') drf where
C=
ew:~, 4 r n c ' ~ c' ~
0
A term containing Jb X* ( z , t ') exp [- 2iw, t'ldt' has been neglected because of the rapidly varying phase factor in the integrand. Equation (51) is exactly equivalent to the result of Panofsky [1966]. To obtain an asymptotic solution of eq. (51), we first take the Laplace transform,
where s is the transform variable and X ( z ; s) is the transform of X ( z , t). In the special case when y is a linear function of z, eq. (52) has solutions in Bessel functions of complex arguments. However, in order to retain generality, it is convenient to consider y as slowly varying (but otherwise arbitrary) and use the WKB approximation for the harmonic oscillator with slowly varying parameters. The solution is of the form
X ( Z ; S ) cc (sly)* exp [+ i ( i ~ l l sg)(~z ) ]
(53)
where 2
g (z)=
J Y - + ( ~ 'dzf ) . 20
The asymptotic solution may be found by performing the inverse transformation by the method of "steepest descent". The result corresponding to the boundary condition X ( z o , z ) =6(z), x l ( z o , z ) = 0 is (see Panofsky [1966])
x ( z , z ) = Re ( X exp [ i ~T ,] ) z X,
exp {(I
-
i/43)Fe + (io, - o , / 2 ~z ))
+ C.C.
(55)
where
g is defined by eq. (54) and X ~ C C I ~ ~ - ~ Equation ~ * ~ - *(55) . is asymptotic in the sense that Fe& 1 is assumed. Because expression (55) is asymptotic, extrapolation to T = O is not vslid and the coefficient X o is not equal to X ( z o , T). Also, because the
BEAM BREAKUP
8.1.4
203
result represents the impulse response of the system, it may not apply at late times for which w , ~ / 2 Q ?F,. Within these limitations, eq. (55) describes the essential features of the multisection breakup and is a valuable guide to the scaling laws in the parameters I , T, and y(z). Numerical solutions of eq. (51) are given by Bander [1966]. Comparison of the present results with experimental data is given in a later part of this section. Effect of.focusitig. Panofsky [I9661 extended the smooth-force treatment to include the effect of external focusing. By an obvious modification, eq. (52) becomes
where k is the betatron wave number of the focusing system. The WKB solution is analogous to eq. (53); however, the inverse Laplace transformation becomes impossible in closed form. By expanding and keeping only terms of first order in k 2 , Panofsky obtained an expression formally the same as eq. (55) but with a modified e-folding factor given by
where K (z)
-J
,.
?*(z') k 2 ( 2 ' ) dz'
and the other quantities are as defined previously. Comparison with computer calculations indicates that the above expression is correct in the limit of very weak focusing. Steady-state solution. In long duty-cycle machines such as the proposed superconducting linacs * and several normal-conducting machines ** now under construction, the pulse lengths will be long compared to the decay time (2Q/o,) of the breakup mode. Hence the analytic results in the last two sections, which represent essentially the impulse response, are no longer valid. In special cases one may find solutions which are valid from short times up to z $2Q/w, (see Leboutet [I 966]), but computer solutions seem to be more useful in treating this intermediate region. However, we may readily find steady-state solutions (Helm [1967]; Wilson [1967]; Panofsky and Bander [1968]). Let us redefine the complex amplitude X ( z , co) such that
where w l = o , +6w is a constant driving frequency. We assume that I ( c o ) = I =
* **
See chapters E.2 and E.3. See chapter B.3.2.
201
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
constant. Equation (51) then yields
which is formally the same as (52). The solution is given by (53) with s replaced by i 6w - w1/2Q. It may be shown that the maximum value of the e-folding factor occurs for 6 0 = - ( o , / 2 ~ ) J + ; we then find
X (z)K y-* exp [(I - i
44)Fss]
where
and g ( z ) is defined by eq. (54). Focusing may be taken into account in the same approximation as was used previously in the transient case. The result is that the e-folding factor F,', in the presence of focusing is
4.2
Experimental evidence and comparison with theory
As this book is being written, most of the available quantitative experimental evidence against which the above analytic and computational studies can be verified stems from SLAC. Hence the comparison between theory and experiments which is presented below is entirely restricted to the transient type of breakup. As will be seen, however, agreement is close enough to warrant confidence in the general theories that have been developed. Figure 16 shows three examples of beam profiles at the end of the SLAC accelerator for a 1.6 psec pulse. As seen, at 35 mA, below the breakup threshold, the maximum beam spot diameter is of the order of 0.5 cm. For this current and with the degree of focusing that is used along the machine, the electrons do not strike the accelerator walls. When the current is increased to 45 mA, breakup appears at first in the vertical plane. As has been discussed earlier, this is due to the fact that in the SLAC accelerator sections, the couplers are in the horizontal plane and the value of Q, is roughly 1.5 times higher than that of Q,. At higher currents yet (75 mA), the direction of breakup becomes random. A large fraction of the electrons in the late part of the pulse strike the walls before they reach the end of the machine. Breakup occurs before multiple rf reflections have time to build up in each accelerator section because the one-way travel time in the resonant part of the SLAC sections is of the
B.1.4
BEAM BREAKCP
205
order of 50 nsec. Under these conditions, a number of frequencies are probably excited and carried by the beam. As has been discussed above, the asymptotic solution proposed by Panofsky and others gives easily understandable scaling laws in the absence of focusing. These have been verified under a number of conditions. For example, for constant acceleration (g= y'z and z$z,), the dominant term in the exponential of eq. ( 5 5 ) can be integrated, giving the relation
where the various parameters have been defined earlier and where it is assumed that the beam begins to scrape the accelerator walls (I.D. = 1.7 c m ) when the defection J * has grown with respect to the initial value yo by an e-folding of the order of 15. Notice that for a typical SLAC pulse (1.5 psec). the loss term wri2Q which must be subtracted from the dominant term is of the order of 2-5 depending on the exact Q
Fig. 16. Beam profiles at the end of the SLAC accelerator for three different currents (Energy: 16 GeV, beam pulse width: 1.6 psec). The large grid width is 1 cm. (a) Current below breakup, 35 mA, (b) current for predominantly vertical breakup, 45 mA, (c) current where breakup begins to occur in random direction, 75 mA.
* Earlier in this chapter, the breakup coordinate is referred to as x, with the understanding that x could be any transverse direction. From here on, note is taken of the fact that the predominant polarization at SLAC is y, or vertical.
206
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Fig. 17. Beam breakup current vs inverse length in the case of weak focusing. The deviation from a straight line of the computed curve is due to the inclusion of some focusing in the calculation. Pulse length, 1.5 psec. Energy gradient, 2.2 MeV/m. Betatron wavelength, = 900 m. Sector length, w 100 m.
I
2
3
4
5
6
ENERGY G R A D I E N T ( M e V / m e t e r )
Fig. 18. Beam breakup current vs energy gradient in the case of weak focusing. Uniform acceleration. Pulse length, 1.5 psec. Accelerator length, 3050 m. Betatron wavelength, w 1500 m.
BEAM BREAKUP
B.1.4
207
that is assumed. For a constant pulse length r, it is seen that the plots of I vs. l/z and dyldz would be straight lines. The results were verified under weak focusing conditions, shortly after turn-on of the accelerator. They are shown in figs. 17 and 18. In the presence of medium or strong focusing, the simple scaling laws break down and one must resort to the computer studies. Experimental data can be taken and presented in a variety of ways. For example, fig. 19 gives a plot of transmitted charge
-COMPUTED - -- COMPUTED - - - COMPUTED
I NORMAL MODE 2 NORMAL MODES 3 NORMAL MODES
.+..*.. EXPERIMENTAL
.+..+. EXPERIMENTAL
0
0 2
0 4
0 6 PULSE
0 8 WIDTH,
10
12
CHARGE CURRENT
14
16
psec
Fig. 19. SLAC beam breakup charge and current vs time to breakup. The experimental points were obtained in August 1967 under the strongest available focusing conditions and at an energy of 16 GeV.
per pulse or current vs. time to breakup. The experimental points were obtained under the strongest focusing conditions presently usable on the machine. These conditions include a system of singlets every 40 feet in the first six sectors ( ~ 6 0 meters) 0 of the accelerator and of strong doublets at the end of each sector from there on. With this system, which came into final operation roughly one year after SLAC turn-on, the corresponding betatron wavelengths are approximately 150 and 400 meters, respectively. Notice that for a pulse length of 1.6 psec, the maximum current transmitted t o date is approximately 42 mA, still somewhat short of the 50 mA current originally
208
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
specified but more than twice as large as the current obtained when the machine was first turned on (see for example Neal and Panofsky [I9661 or Altenmueller et al. [1966]). This improvement is entirely due to the new focusing system. The computed curves were obtained by successively including 1, 2 or 3 of the normal modes in the
/ I
M E A S U R E D AT SECTOR 21 M E A S U R E D A T SECTOR 29
A X
S E C T O R LENGTH I
I
- I00
meters
I
Fig. 20. Transverse beam envelope amplitude ( y ( as a function of ( 1 ~ ) )Energy . gradient: 5.25 MeV/m, beam pulse width: 1.6 psec, medium focusing.
calculation. It is seen that the effect of additional modes is increasingly marked as the pulses become shorter. In the limit of very short pulses or in the case of bunching at low subharmonics, a large number of the normal modes act cooperatively and it becomes difficult to obtain computer agreement with experiment. Figure 20 shows a set of curves of beam breakup "gain" giving the transverse beam
BEAM BREAKUP
B.1.4
209
envelope amplitude 14'1 as a function of ( I Z ) ~ .The experimental points were derived indirectly from the amplitudes of 4140 MHz signals induced by the beam in cavities of the type illustrated in fig. 9 and installed at the ends of sectors 5, 13, 21 and 29. In all cases, a constant external excitation of microwave power at 4140 MHz was injected onto the beam a t the beginning of the accelerator. While the curves are almost straight lines as predicted by the scaling law given in eq. (65), there are four distinct plots depending on the value of z that was used. The computer results show very good agreement. Two different values of R,/Q were assumed and the computed points were normalized to the experimental points in the lo-' cm range.
30
20
0 MEASURED
10
A COMPUTED
PULSE LENGTH = I 5p see
I
0
I I I I I I Ol-rr 0 2 7 ~ 0 3 ~0 4 7 0 5 7 0 6 7 ~ BETATRON PHASE SHIFT PER SECTOR ( k B S )
Fig. 21. Beam breakup current vs betatron phase shift per sector. These data were taken at Sector 19 in February 1967, before installation of the 40-foot singlets.
The effect of focusing can be clearly recognized if, for example, one measures the beam breakup current at a given value of z and .t while varying the energy gradient and the quadrupole current. Figure 21 shows a set of curves of current a t breakup vs. betatron phase shift per sector, k,S, where S is the length of a sector. The value of k,S was measured experimentally. I t could also be computed. A reasonable approximation is given by c o s k s S z 1 -S/2fwhere f is the focal length of the quadrupole
210
R.H.HELM. G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
doublets. Results for four different values of energy gradient are shown in fig. 21. The agreement between experiment and computation is excellent.
5 Discussion of starting conditions Both the regenerative and the cumulative multisection types of beam breakup are triggered by an initial excitation which manifests itself in a small transverse modulation of the electron bunches at the breakup frequency. The amplitude yo of this modulation is then caused to grow according to the mechanisms and laws which have been described earlier in this chapter. From the speculative as well as the remedial poinl: of
SHOCK EXCITATION BY OFF AXIS BUNCH
- -.
ON AXlS TRANSVERSE SHOT NOISE FROM GUN \.hAVhVn HEM,, COMPONENT OFF AXlS LONGITUDINAL SHOT NOISE FROM GUN
?VnAL
'#-
kT THERMAL CAVITY EXCITATION
EXTERNAL NOISE SOURCE (KLYSTRON)
.$.+
Fig. 22. S c h e m a t i c i l l u s t r a t i o n s of p o s s i b l e initial b e a m b r e a k u p e x c i t a t i o n s
view, it is desirable to understand the origins of this initial excitation. Intuitively, three possible sources come to mind. They are illustrated in fig. 22. The first is shock excitation due to the beam current Z for which the equivalent source power would be proportional to 1'. The second is gun shot noise (transverse or longitudinal) for which the noise power would be proportional to I. The third is rf excitation of the accelerator cavities, either thermal or generated by the klystrons, for which the noise power would be independent of I. Before entering into a discussion of these effects, two points should be made. The first is that, as this book is being written, a definitive answer to these questions has not yet been found. The second is that independently of the nature of the answer, it can be asserted that it would take a very significant
B.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
211
reduction in noise power before the effect on the breakup threshold would become noticeable. Hence, in the cumulative case, assuming an exponential growth of the deflection of the form =y,eF, it is easily seen that a reduction in noise power R in dB corresponds to a relative increase, T, in beam breakup threshold given by
Thus, for example, letting R%20 dB and F= 20, it is seen that T= 1.39, giving less than 40% improvement in current. The discussion which appears below is based exclusively on experiments carried out at SLAC. The only other published measurements on the subject can be found in Jarvis et 01. [1965] and Vishnyakov et 01. [1967a]; their results however, giving rf
COMPUTED POWER INDUCED BY l 8 m A BEAM, ARBITRARI L Y NORMALIZED
4 1 4 0 MHz POWER AT KLYSTRON OUTPUT R E W I R E D TO AFFECT PULSE SHORTENING A T THE END OF SECTOR 19 BEAM ENERGY 2 2 GeV BEAM CURRENT
* )
I
,
, I , [
I8mA
l , l , 1 , 1 , 1 , {
I
1-4 1-8 2 - 4 2-8 3-4 5 8 4 4 4-8 5-4 5 - 8 6-4 6 - 8 SECTOR-KLYSTRON NUMBER I
40
1000
2 0 0 0 DISTANCE,FEET
Fig. 23. Power at 4140 M H z injected into SLAC accelerator as a function of klystron position. For each point, the corresponding klystron was removed and the injected power was increased until pulse shortening observed at Sector 19 was affected. (Data taken in February 1967, before completion of installation of 40-foot singlets; beam accelerated up to 2.2 GeV; beam current: 19 mA).
212
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
starting levels below watts, are difficult to compare with the SLAC results because of differences in experimental setups. Two basic types of experiments have been carried out at SLAC, the first to obtain an order of magnitude of the noise power, the second to understand its origin. Figure 23 shows measured and computed levels of power at 4140 MHz injected into the SLACcaccelerator sections through the output waveguides of the high power klystrons. The level of recorded power injected a t a given location is that which was required to affect the breakup threshold at sector 19. Near the beginning of the
9-
.8-
SHOT NOISE
w
5-
KLYSTRONS OR OTHER R F EXCITATION
2
o
z
W
a
3-
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
BEAM CURRENT, mA
Fig. 24. Relative noise source power as a function of beam current at Sector 29 (Energy: 16 GeV, beam pulse length: 1.6 psec). Graph shows experimental points and curves corresponding to three main hypotheses.
accelerator, i.e., at about the 120 MeV point, this level is of the order of 10 pwatts. This value sets an upper limit to the allowable noise power from the klystrons, above which the klystrons certainly become the dominant driving source. On the other hand, it is not clear what exact fraction of this 10 pwatt injected power actually acts on the beam because the transmission loss of the rectangular waveguide and the coupling coefficient of the accelerator coupler are not exactly known and vary somewhat along
B.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
213
the machine. Given a n arbitrary normalization, the agreement between computation and measurement is reasonable. The results of the second type of experiment are given in fig. 24. The object of this experiment was t o obtain a plot of relative noise power as a function of beam current in order t o determine which of the mechanisms illustrated in fig. 22 is dominant. The experiment was p2rformed as follows. Forty feet downstream of the injector, power Po a t 4140 MHz was injected into a C-band cavity (fig. 9). A t the end of sector 5 , roughly 500 meters downstream, beam-induced power P, was extracted from a similar cavity. In the absence of any external excitation, this induced power P, was measured for a given beam current. Then, the injected power Po was increased until P, was roughly doubled. This measurement was repeated over a range of current. Because that fraction of injected power Po which actually acts on the electrons must be of the same order of magnitude as the natural noise power carried by the beam, a relative, normalized measure of noise can be inferred. The results shown in fig. 24 d o not allow one to distinguish whether the noise power is quadratic with current (shock excitation) or linear (shot noise). However, it can be concluded with fair certainty that this power is not independent of current, and hence, that neither klystron noise nor cavity thermal excitation are dominant. This conclusion is further confirmed by two facts. One is an experiment in which the first ten high power klystron outputs were fitted with 40 dB filters at 4140 and 4428 MHz: no visible effect on the breakup threshold was found. The second is a simple estimate of thermal noise excitation. Assuming that initial noise of energy kT is responsible for setting up fields in one accelerator section with a value of R J Q of 400 ohms, the resultant transverse momentum is approximately
Using kT=0.4 x lop2' joule at 300°K one obtains p,, = 2 x 10-lo MeV/c. Comparing this value with a normal transverse momentum acceptance of approximately 0.2 MeVlc at the end of the accelerator, it is seen that a gain of lo9 would be required. This value is two orders of magnitude greater than the present estimate. Additional information about the nature of the noise source a t 4140 MHz can be gained by counting the number of pulses of induced power as a function of pulse height. Two cases are shown in fig. 25. If the normal beam modulation is due to the statistical noise in gun emission, the current amplitude should exhibit a half gaussian distribution. Since the pulse height distribution is proportional to the square of the current amplitudes, it should have an exponential distribution. This seems to be borne out by fig. 25a. The sharp peak in fig. 25b was obtained in the presence of some external stimulation injected onto the beam downstream of the injector. This result strengthens the shot noise hypothesis. This hypothesis is further strengthened by the fact that an improvement in beam breakup threshold of about 12% was found by increasing the cathode filament power from the temperature-limited to the space-
214
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
Fig. 25. Number of counts vs pulse height of rectified 4140 MHz power induced in a cavity, 500 meters downstream of the injectcr. (a) Spontaneous beam breakup, 23 mA, (b) Stimulated beam breakup, 18 mA.
charge-limited region. Unfortunately, under normal conditions, the SLAC gun is already operating under space-charge-limited conditions and straightforward improvements do not seem easily obtainable. Using the usual formulas for temperature-limited shot noise power in a band-width f/Q, the transverse and longitudinal effects shown in fig. 22 can be lumped to express the initial "equivalent" mean square deflection:
8.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
215
where f is the breakup frequency and r is the radius of the beam whose center of charge is offset by 6. Taking an equivalent lumped value for the bracket of (0.1 ~ r n ) ~ , one finds a value of yo of the order of cm, in good agreement with the lo6 to 10' beam breakup gain which would cause the beam radius to grow to 1 cm over the length of the accelerator. This initial level of excitation, however, is of the same order of magnitude as that which can be computed for shock excitation due to initial misalignment. Assuming a time to breakup As= 1.6 psec, an initial misalignment 6=0.01 cm and a breakup frequencyf'=4140 MHz, the equivalent noise modulation can be estimated roughly as
Experimentally, however, it has been found that the sensitivity of the breakup threshold to steering at the beginning of the accelerator is not as large as expected. Admittedly, these experiments and others using chopped beams at a subharmonic frequency are not yet conclusive. In conclusion, it must be said that an overall understanding of the beam breakup excitation problem has not yet been obtained.
6 Proposed remedies for various types of' accelerators As discussed in the introduction of this chapter, the problem of beam breakup has now been recognized as a limiting factor in the design of many of the new linacs. Unless an unforeseeable breakthrough is made, electron and possibly also proton linac instabilities will have t o be coped with whenever a given combination of current, pulse length and accelerator length is exceeded. The remedies that suggest themselves depend to a considerable extent on the type of linac under consideration, and on its economics. The types of remedies which will be discussed below can be divided into two categories: rf cures and focusing cures. lmprovements to be expected from an initial noise reduction have been described earlier. As discussed, knowledge in this area is still incomplete but as this book is written, the expectations are limited.
6.1 Rf cures Rf cures, in turn, can be divided into two sub-categories: structure modifications and feedback or rf cancellation. Because beam breakup is caused by interaction with the H E M , , mode, one of the most obvious remedies is t o attempt to change its propagation characteristics. One such remedy is to resort t o "Q-spoiling" techniques, i.e., selectively coupling power out of the H E M , , fields, for example by using large cut-off holes a t both ends of the
216
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
accelerator structure. Another remedy is to displace the o-B diagram of the HEM,, mode by modifying the modular dimensions of the cavities or perturbing their symmetries, e.g., by means of radial slots (see Levin et al. [1967]). In short accelerators, one can shorten the effective length of each section by using several shorter sub-sections (see for example Vishnyakov et al. [1967b]) or by brea!
CHANGE IN RESONANT FREQUENCY OF SECTORS 1.2 ( M H z )
Fig. 26. Computed improvement in beam breakup current threshold obtained by "detuning" the 4140 MHz mode in Sectors 1 and 2. Only the first few cavities in each 10-foot section would be afected. Focusing as presently available at SLAC. (Pulse width: 1.6 psec, beam energy: 16 GeV).
B. 1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
217
velocity taper will perform the same function, namely prevent breakup at the design current. The idea of feedback or rf cancellation which has been described in great detail in Altenmueller et a/. [1966], basically consists of deriving a signal at the H E M , , frequency from the beam, amplifying it and reinjecting it onto the beam at the proper amplitude and phase to cancel out the transverse modulation which generated the signal in the first place. While this idea has been demonstrated to work in principle at SLAC, in practice the expense and operational complexity appear to be prohibitive. This seems to be generally true for all short pulse accelerators where breakup never gets beyond the transient regime: rf cancellation is difficult because the amplifiers must have huge gains ( 380 dB) and extremely short group delays ( < 50 nanoseconds). On the other hand, rf cancellation schemes may be more effective for cw superconducting accelerators described in part E of this book.
6.2 Focusing Straightforward magnetic focusing schemes have the advantage that they are "brute force" and leave slightly less uncertainty as to their result than the microwave schemes described above. An additional advantage of brute force focusing schemes is that they should also suppress other types of transverse instabilities (see 5 7). In short accelerators, one generally uses solenoidal focusing over the entire accelerator. Calculations of the improvements to be expected have for example been made by Chu [1966]. In longer accelerators, above a certain energy, it is practical to use strong focusing quadrupoles. As has been discussed in paragraph 4 and illustrated in figs. 19 and 21, the beneficial effect of strong focusing along the SLAC accelerator has been amply demonstrated. The described new deployment of quadrupoles is shown to have doubled the current obtainable before breakup. Builders of other long accelerators will no doubt d o well to reserve ample space along beam centerlines in order to include or add such quadrupoles if beam operation actually reveals lower breakup thresholds than predicted by design and theory. The use of sextupoles, octupoles and time-varying quadrupoles has also been suggested and considered. Non-linear focusing is expected to produce "Landau damping", i.e., H E M , , phase reversal and mixing as a function of length by causing electron bunches at different radial distances from the axis to cross over a t different distances downstream of the magnet. Time-varying quadrupoles are expected to produce the same effect as a function of time within each beam pulse. Computer calculations have shown, however, that neither one of these schemes is promising. On the one hand, t o be effective, appreciable focusing changes would be necessary over each e-folding distance to reduce the beam breakup gain; on the other hand, if such focusing changes are too large, either in space or in time, the resulting over- or under-focusing spoils the beam transmission through the accelerator.
218
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
7 Other electromagnetic instabilities in linacs Only the instabilities associated with the deflecting (HEM,,) mode have been considered in detail here, but it must be remembered that there are other types of interactions which might limit the beam current even if the HEM,, excitation were somehow eliminated. Some of these possibilities are briefly considered.
7.1 Longitudinal instability Interaction of the beam with the normal accelerating mode (TM,,) can lead in principle to excitation of longitudinal oscillations of the bunches. Analysis of this effect, e.g., by Wilson [I9631 and Cheng [I9641 in analogy with conventional backward-wave oscillator theory, indicates that starting currents would be greater than 100 A. Because the phase oscillations are subject to damping associated with the "longitudinal mass", proportional to y3, there should be no cumulative effect in multisection machines.
7.2 Higher order modes The beam may also interact with various higher transverse modes. For example, if we designate modes according to the dominant closed-cavity configuration in a given cell, then types such as the TM,,, and TM,, (dipole) or TM,,, (quadrupole) might have a significant effect. In general, however, the coupling is expected to be much less than in the case of the TM,,, mode, because the transit angle per cell is large at the higher frequencies and the fields are less effectively concentrated near the beam axis. In fact, the modes of quadrupole and higher azimuthal symmetry have vanishingly small field at the axis and can only couple through misalignments or finite beam size.
,
7.3 Resistive-wall effect The resistive wall phenomenon has been studied extensively in connection with circular machines. (See e.g., Morton et al. [I9661 and Courant and Sessler [1966].) In this effect the passage of a beam bunch induces a "wake field" which decays asymptotically as (at)-*, where o is the conductivity of the wall and t is time after the passage of the bunch. This theory has not been developed explicitly for disk-loaded waveguides, but Sessler [I 9661 has considered the case of a relativistic beam traveling in a thick-walled cylindrical pipe, and finds an equation of motion given by
BEAM
B.1.4
BREAKUP
219
where a=wall conductivity=0.5 x 1O’8 set-’ for Cu; r. =classical electron radius= 2.8x IO-l3 cm; b=radius of the pipe; and the other quantities are as defined previously. For the boundary condition x(0, t) =a(~), ~‘(0, T)=O, this equation has the asymptotic solution x (z, T) cc z -l/zot-9/10
exp 5 { (;$$ (;J+}
(71)
where y’=dy/dz=constant and y$>yo. Using SLAC parameters with a rough guess of 6=2 cm, and assuming an amplification of e4.6= 100 corresponding to growth from an initial misalignment of 0.01 cm, one finds a current on the order of I .3 A to produce beam loss at z= 3 km. Thus, the limiting current for the “wake field” breakup is probably at least an order of magnitude greater than for the HEM,, effect.
References ALTENMUELLER, 0. H., R. R. LARSEN, and G. A. LOEW, 1964, Rev. Sci. Instr. 35,438. ALTENMUELLER, 0. H., E. V. FARII\‘HCLT, Z. D. F ARKAS, W. B. HERRMANNSFELDT, H. A. HOGG, R. F. KOONTZ, C. J. KRUSE, G. A. LOEW, and R. H. MILLER, 1966, Beam Breakup Experiments at SLAC, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico, pp. 267-272. ARTEMOV, V. J., Y. M. B AZAJEV, V. I. B ELOGLAZOV, V. A. VISHNYAKOV, I. A. GRISHAEV, P. S. GOROHOVATSKY, A. S. DOVBUSH , Y. I. D~BROLYBOV, G. K. DEMYANENKO, A. I. ZYKOV, G. I. IVANOV, V. M. KOBEZSKY, B. B. KONDRATENKO, L. A. MAKHNENKO, V. B. MYFEL,~. 1. MYAKOTA, V. V. PETRENKO, B. A. PONOMARENKO, V. 1. P OPENKO, K. S. RUBSOV, and V. A. SKUBKO, 1967, The 360 MeV and 2 GeV Electron Accelerators of the Ukrainian Physical-Technical Institute, Proceedings of the 1967 Sixth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, CEAL2000, Cambridge Electron Accelerator, Cambridge, Massachusetts, pp. 408-412. B ANDER, M., 1966, Solution of the Beam Break-Up Equation, TN-66-28, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California. (See also Panofsky and Bander [1968]). B ERTOZZI, W., J. HAIMSON, C . P . SARGENT, and W. TURCHINETZ, 1967, IEEE Trans. NucI. Sci. NS-14, No. 3, pp. 191-196. B EVENSEE, R. M., 1964, Electromagnetic Slow Wave Systems (John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, London and Sydney). B JORKHOLM, J. E., and R. F. HYNEMAN, 1965, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, ED-12, 281. BOAG, J. W.,andC. W. MILLER, 1959,TechnicalAspectsofa High-Current Electron-PulseGenerator, Proceedings of the Second International Conference, Geneva, Switzerland (Pergamon Press, London, New York, Paris and Los Angeles). BROWN, K. L., A. L. ELDREDGE, R. H. HEIM, J. H. JASBERG, J. V. LEBACQZ, G. A. LOEW, R. F. MOZLEY, R. B. NEAL, W. K. H. PANOFSKY, and T. F. TURNER , 1961, Linear Electron Accelerator Progress at Stanford University, 1961 International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Brookhaven National Laboratory, New York. CHENG, G. H. H., 1964, Pulse Shortening in Electron Linear Accelerators, M. S C. Thesis, University of California, Berkeley, California. C HU, E. L., 1966, A Crude Estimate of the Starting Current for Linear Accelerator Beam Blowup in the Presence ofan Axial Magnetic Field, TN-66-l 7, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center,stanford California. C OURANT, E. D. and A. M. SESSLER, 1966, Rev. Sci. Instr. 36, No. 11, 1579. C ROWLEY-MILLING, M. C., T. R. JARVIS, C. W. MILLER, and G. SAXON, 1961, Nature 191, 48
220
R.H.HELM, G.A.LOEW
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
CROWLEY-MILLING, M. C., 1962, A 40-MeV Electron Accelerator for Germany, AEI Engineering 2, No. 2. FARINHOLT, E. V., R. H. HELM,H. A. HOGG,R. F. KOONTZ,G . A. LOEW,and R. H. MILLER,1967, Progress Report on Beam Break-Up at SLAC, Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Cambridge Electron Accelerator, Cambridge, Massachusetts, CEAL-2000, pp. 90-98. Y., Hybrid EH Guided Waves and Their Application to R F Separators of Very High GARAULT, Energy Particles (to be published in Advances in Microwaves). GLUCKSTERN, R. L., 1964, Transverse Beam Blow-up in Standing Wave Linacs, Proceedings of the MURA Conference on Linear Accelerators, Stoughton, Wisconsin, p. 186. Also published as Internal Report AADD-38, Accelerator Dept., Brookhaven National Laboratory, July 1964. R. L., H. S. BUTLER,and K. JACOBS,1965, Interaction of a Bunched Beam with GLUCKSTERN, Transverse Modes in R F Cavities, Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Frascati, Italy. R. L., and H. S. BUTLER, 1965, lEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3; p. 607. GLUCKSTERN, GLUCKSTERN, R. L., D. E. NAGLE,and W. M. VISSCHER, 1966, A Note on Transverse Beam Instabilities in Multisection Linacs, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Labcratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico; pp. 281-283. 1965, Rev. Sci. Instr. 36, 1788. HAHN,H. and H. J. HALAMA, 1966, Nucl. Instr. Methods 45, 141. HAHN,H. and H. J. HALAMA, HAIMSON, J., 1965, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, No. 3; pp. 996-1011. HELM,R. H., 1966, Computer Study of Wave Propagation, Beam Loading and Beam Blowup at the SLAC Accelerator, Proceedings of the 1966 Linear Accelerator Conference, LA-3609, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico; pp. 254-266. HELM,R. H., 1967, Preliminary Estimate of Beam Blowup for a Superconducting Electron Linac, TN-67-6, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. HELM,R. H., G . A. LOEW,and W. K. H. PANOFSKY, 1968, SLAC Handbook (W. A. Benjamin, Inc., New York) Chapter 7. HIRAKAWA, H., 1964, Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 3, No. 1, 27. 1965, Proc. IEEE (London) 112, No. 9; JARVIS, T. R., G. SAXON,and M. C. CROWLEY-MILLING, p. 1795. KELLIHER, M. G., and R. BEADLE, 1960, Nature 187, 1099. LEBOUTET, H ., 1966, Auto-deflexion du Faisceau d'un Acctltrateur LinBaire, Rapport Interne, INT. 2217-HL/ml/md, CSF, France. LEVIN,V. M., V. L. SMIRNOV, and L. P. FOMIN, 1967, On the Possibility of Production of Large Pulse Currents in Linear Electron Accelerators Using Homogeneous Structure, Proceedings of the 'Sixth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Cambridge Electron Accelerator, Cambridge, Massachusetts, CEAL-2000, pp. A-39-41. LOEW,G. A,, 1967, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-14, No. 3; pp. 529-540. M.L. Report No. 581, 1959, W. W. Hansen Laboratories of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California. MELARD, L., 1967, Note Technique No. 83.A.8, Sections Accel6ratrices d'Orsay, LM/MLN No. 016167, Laboratoire de I' AccClCrateur Lintaire Service "Faisceau", Orsay, France. MORTON, P. L., V. K. NIELand A. M. SESSLER, 1966, J. Appl. Phys. 37, No. 10, 3875. NAGLE,D. E., 1964, Coupled Resonator Model of Linear Accelerator Tanks, Minutes of 1964 Conference on Proton Linear Accelerators, MURA-714; p. 21. NISHIKAWA, T., 1965, Normal Mode Analysis of Standing Wave linacs - Field Excitation and Beam Loading in Linac Cavities, Internal Report AADD-87, Accelerator Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, November 1965. NISHIKAWA, T., S. GIORDANO, and D. CARTER, 1966, Rev. Sci. Instr. 37, No. 5, 652. NEAL,R. B., and W. K. H . PANOFSKY, 1966, Science 152, 1353. NYGARD, J. C., and R. F. POST,1961, Nucl. Instr. Methods 2, 126. PANOFSKY, W. K. H., and W. A. WENZEL,1956, Rev. Sci. Instr. 27, 967. PANOFSKY, W. K. H., 1966, Transient Behavior of Beam Break-Up, TN-66-27, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California. (See also Panofsky and Bander [1968]). PANOFSKY, W. K. H., and M. BANDER, 1968, Rev. Sci. Instr. 39, No. 2, 206.
B.1.4
BEAM BREAKUP
221
SAXON, G., T . R. JARVIS, and I. WHITE,1963, Proc. lEEE (London) 110 (8); p. 1365. SESSI-ER, A,, 1966, Lecture given at the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford, California (unpublished). SLATER, J. C., 1950, Microwave Electronics (D. Van Nostrand Co., New York). VALTER, A. K., I. A. GRISHAEV,E. V. EREMENKO, J . I. DOBROLYBOV, A. I. ZYKOV,V. V. KONDRATENKO, G . F. KUZNETZOV,J. M. BAZAJEV,F. A. GOROSHOVATSKY, V. B. MUFEL, N. I. MOTCHESHNIKOV, V. V. PETRENKO, V. I. KOLOSOV, N . A. KOVALENKO, G . A. ZEITLENOK, V. M. E. G . KOMAR,V. V. RUMJANTZEV, F. F. T U R K I and N V. K. CHOCHLOV, LEVIN,I. F. MALISHEV, 1965, 2-GeV Traveling Wave Electron Accelerator, Fifth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Frascati, Italy; pp. 233-238. VISHNYAKOV, V.A.,A. I. ZYKOV,1. A.GRISHAYEV, and V. M. GRIZ:-IKO, 1967a, Effect of an External R F Source on the Stability of the Current Pulse in a Linear Accelerator, No. 306/VE-069, Physics and Engineering lnstitute of the Academy of Sciences, Kharkov, U.S.S.R. and V. M. GRIZHKO,1967b, Increasing the VISHNYAKOV, V. A,, A. I. ZYKOV,I. A. GRISHAYEV, Current Pulse Limit in a Linear Electron Accelerator, No. 308/VE-071, Physics and Engineering lnstitute of the Academy of Sciences, Kharkov, U.S.S.R. and L. A. M A K H N ~ N K1967c, O, Questions VISHNYAKOV, V. A., A. I . ZYKOV,I. A. GRISHAYEV, Concerning the Increase of the Limiting Current in Multisection Linear Accelerators, No. 3091 VE-072, Physics and Engineering lnstitute of the Academy of Sciences, Kharkov, U.S.S.R. G. V., and V. I. KOROZA,1965, The Transverse Motion of the Particles in Linear VOSKKESENSKY, Electron Accelerator Caused by the Action of Nonsymmetric Wave, Proceedings of Fifth lnternational Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Frascati, Italy. G . V., V. I. KOROZA,and Y. N. SEREBRYAKOV, VOSKRESENSKY, 1966a, Transverse Instabilities of a Beam in a Linear Accelerator Prior to Increa5ing Injection Current, Uskoriteli (Accelerators), Vol. 8, Moscow lnstitute of Engineering Physics, Atomizdat, Moscow, U.S.S.R. G . V., V. I. KOROZA, and Y. N. SEREBRYAKOV, 1966b, Toward the Investigation ofthe VGSKRESENSKY, Radial Instability of a Beam in a Linear Electron Accelerator, Uskoriteli (Accelerators), Vol. 9, Moscow Institute of Engineering Physics, Atomizdat, Moscow, U.S.S.R. 1967, Dynamics of Transverse Instability of a Beam VOSKRESENSKY, G . V., and Y. N. SEREBRYAKOV, in Linear Electron Accelerator, Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on High Energy Accelerators, Cambridge Electron Accelerator, Cambridge, Massachusetts, CEAL-2000; p. A-46. WILSON, P. B., 1963, A Study of Beam Blowup in Electron Linacs, HEPL-297 (Rev. A), High Energy Physics Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, California. WILSON,P. B., 1967, A Simple Analysis of Cumulative Beam Break-Up For the Steady-State Case, HEPL-TN-67-8, High Energy Physics Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, California.
ELA THEORY
1.5
B.l
Problems connected with the Measurement of Accelerated Electron Beam Characteristics R. BERGERE Centre d2Etudes Nucleaires de Saclay 91 Gif-sur-Y v e t t France
A detailed description of the possible methods for measuring accelerated electron beam parameters can, of course, not be given in such a short chapter. In particular, we shall not discuss the technological problems raised by different types of measuring instruments. More details will be given in chapter B.2.4. Moreover, the references are mainly cited as typical examples and do not constitute an exhaustive bibliography on the subject. This chapter merely proposes a classification of certain general problems encountered whenever accelerated electron beam characteristics are to be measured: dectrical characteristics (mean current, peak current I,(t) during length of pulse, total charge of elementary electron bunch, density distribution along accelerating sinusoidal electric field, etc.); geometrical characteristics (position of center of gravity for a cylindrical slice of accelerated charges with reference to linac axis, charge density distribution within such a slice, etc.); mechanical characteristics (beam emittance, energy spectrum of accelerated electrons).
I
Tentative classlJication of methods of measurement
Two types of measuring instruments can at once be discerned; those converting all the available beam energy into signal energy and those doing so only partially. (0North-Holland
Publ. Co., Amsterdam 1969
Refer~ncesp. 234
223
224
R. BERGERE
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
Hence we can classify the measuring methods according to the same criteria and discuss in the following subsections four groups of methods.
1.1 Total interception of electron beam
For instance, we can measure a beam current by means of total interception in a Faraday cup (Brown et al. [1956], Kretschko et al. [1962], Isabelle [1963]); also the magnetic analysis of an electron beam energy spectrum, where all the electrons not falling within the energy interval (E-AE, E+AE) are absorbed in the analysing instrument itself. Clearly, in most such measurements the total electron beam energy is not exclusively converted into signal energy but is partly lost due to radiation and heating effects in the measuring device itself.
1.2 Partial interception of electron beam Partial interception is here defined as the passage of an electron beam through a thin screen or detector of thickness Ax, atomic number 2, atomic mass A and M g/cm2 in which an energy loss of AE occurs. Upon traversing such a screen, the mean energy loss due to radiation and ionization is respectively (dE/dx), Ax and ( d E / d ~ Ax. )~ The (dE/dx), Ax energy has been used to operate Cerenkov and beam position monitors whereas the (dE/dx), Ax part has often been used in current monitors (Tautfest et al. [1955], Taimuty et al. [1961], Vanhuyse et al. [1962]), position monitors (Okabe et al. [1965]) and even energy monitors (by means of secondary electron emission). Unfortunately the angular dispersion given by
(where 0 is the angle between electrons emerging from such a thin monitor and the linac axis, and 8, =2.5 x ZM*/EA*) prohibits the installation of such monitors at the end of each section in a linac. For Ax=O.l mm A1 screen, we have for 15 MeV radians. electrons 6, =2.2 x
1.3 Real-photon emission Using standard notation we can write: fi,=flc (c, is the electron velocity) and Y =(I - P 2 ) -+. Let cb,, and cfl, be the parallel and perpendicular components of the acceleration
B.1.5
MEASUREMENT PROBLEMS
225
with respect to the velocity flc. For a n electron having velocity Be. the radiated power due to real photon emission can then be written as:
For linear accelerations (i.e. p,=O) this radiated power is practically zero. Such real photon emission caused by periodic transversal deflections (magnetic ondulator) o r similar, non-periodic phenomena (magnetic deflections) can provide information concerning the beam current, the energy or the phase bunching of the electrons (T.I.D. [1962], Motz [1964]). We can add to this method the backscattering of visible photons after antiCompton interaction with accelerated electrons, the energy of the photons being shifted towards higher energies, by a n amount depending on the electron energy (Kulikov et a/. [1964]).
1.4 Perturbation of associated Coulomb field These methods d o not intercept the electron beam at all. They merely detect the perturbations in the propagation of the Coulomb fields associated with accelerated electrons by means of appropriately chosen electrodes. Such methods can in fact be used for observing the evolution of beam characteristics, section by section, perturbing the electron beam itself as little as possible. The remainder of this paper will essentially consider the latter methods only.
2 Time-fvequency characteristics associated with the perturbation methods T o a n electrode, at rest in the laboratory system, the more a n electron is relativistic, the more its associated Coulomb field, moving with the electron along the Oz axis, will appear to be concentrated in the transverse plane (xOy). Thus the observed electric field EL associated with an electron having a velocity r = 6,=PC at the moment t in the laboratory system can be written as:
where (1) refers to an observation at a distance Ay from the electron trajectory and (2)
226
R. BERGERE
ELECTRON LINACS : THEORY
to an observation at a distance Az along the accelerator axis from the actual electron position. It follows that the fields interacting with an electrode placed at a transverse distance Ay from the electron beam ought to exhibit the same time and frequency structure as the accelerated beam current i,(t) itself, at least for frequencies smaller than y/lc/Ay (for 50 MeV electrons at Ay=3 cm, ypc/Ay= loi2 Hz). Moreover, it can be shown (Bergkre et al. 119621) that the Lorentz-Fitzgerald contraction just compensates for the increase in field strength given by equation (1). Thus, in practice, the potential difference created across the electrode, or the magnetic flux created inside it, will reflect the electrical or (and) geometrical characteristics of the electron beam without providing us with any information as to the energy spectrum of the latter. In fact, an observer looking at the beam passing from one section to the other, would observe a succession of elementary electron bunches of duration Az at the accelerating frequency v = z-' (AT z). If these bunches had been accelerated from t = - oo (fig. 1) onwards, the current could then have been written as: +m ib(t) = C j ( t - nz) = n=-m
or putting J ( f ) the Fourier transform of the current j(t) representing a single bunch:
Figure 2 shows that we obtain a repetition of pulses having a width At (At S z and a few nanosec< At
Fig. I
Fig. 2
B.1.5
MEASUREMENT PROBLEMS
227
I, where a+r
If e(t) represents the envelope of the above pulse and E ( f ) its Fourier transform, we can write the accelerated current during a given pulse as + a
i,(t)= e(t)
I, ( j ' )z
j ( t - nz) n=-m
J(nv) E ( f - nv),
T-' n=-w
Taking also into account the repetition frequency F = T - ' of e(t) we can finally write the observed accelerated current i,(t) as a Fourier series obtained by sampling, at the repetition frequency F the envelope I,(f)
= K(TT)-'
+m
1
J(nv)E ( f
-
nv).
n= -w
This corresponds to a very narrow energy concentration in the different lobes (fig. 3) since At T around the harmonics nv of the accelerating frequency. We shall call the lobe [O] the video frequency lobe, the one around f= v , lobe [I], and the one around f=nv, lobe [n].
3 Beam characteristics associated with the diferent lobes of the frequency spectrum We now give a classification of the main electron beam characteristics which can be obtained from information contained in a typical frequency spectrum (fig. 3).
Fig. 3
228
R. BERGERE
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
3.1 The envelope (TT)-' ~ ( 0 J) ( f ) This curve indicates the form of the Fourier transform J ( f ) and hence of the associated current j(t) in the elementary electron bunch. The precise form of the latter can therefore be found if the former is known. But this corresponds to the electron density distribution d(q) within an elementary electron bunch, with respect to the phase of the sinusoidal accelerating field E, exp [2rcj(t-zc-') t-'1. However it turns out to be very difficult indeed to measure all the lobes involved with the same detection efficiency. This results in a somewhat distorted curve J ' ( f ) instead of the ideal one. Nonetheless the zero cross-over points f,,.f2, f , can still provide us with the required information on d(q). For instance, a rectangular elementary electron bunch of duration Az will have a frequency spectrum such that f , / v = z / A z and f2=2f,. Similarly, a dumb-bell shaped bunch will have its cross-over points spaced as shown in fig. 3 (Bergbre et al. [1964]).
3.2 Lobe [0]
The appropriate detection of the amplitude and phase pertaining to the different components in each lobe will allow us to investigate the evolution of the corresponding beam parameter during a current pulse. For instance, the peak current Ip(t) or the transverse space coordinates of the center of gravity of the charges x,(t) and y,(t). Clearly the OA, component on the axis f=O will allow us to measure the average values involved. For a rectangular pulse At we have OB, = l/At (= 1 MHz if At= 1 psec) as shown in fig. 3. In fact, if we call 6 the desired time resolution of our detecting device and its associated circuits, the latter must have a bandwidth of at least E - ' (&
3.3 Lobe [l] This lobe can be used to measure peak values of I, ( t ) , x, (t) and y, (t), provided we have a bandwidth of 2 6 - I at our disposal. A classical set of cavities with a given Q-factor and tuned to the fundamental frequency v will not, in general, be capable of a time resolution E better than Qlnv or 30 nanoseconds for Q = 300. Further, if due to temperature changes, such a cavity becomes attuned to 27cv0 =coo say, such that coOz=2z+q, the response of the cavity will suffer amplitude and
MEASUREMENT PROBLEMS
13.1.5
229
phase distortions having periodic surges with a period 2n~lcpwith an overall attenuation in exp [ - nt/Qr] (Bergkre [1966]). Such cavity detectors, when used for instance as current monitors, deliver a power of P, (v, t ) = h 1; ( t ) and consequently must be followed by a linear detector dehvering a current i,(t)=(P,)*=k)l,(t) so as to provide us with a correct shape of the lookedfor peak current. A non-periodic loop detection of the field B,(v)would have less galn but a much improved band-width. Apart from the amplitude already known from lobe [O], the correct exploitation of information in lobe [I] further allows us to find the precise position at any time t of the elementary electron bunch with respect to the phase of the accelerating sinusoidal field (Brunet [1963]). This specific information, for example, when averaged over A t , can then be used to stabilize the electron position a t the maximum value of the accelerating field. If phase or frequency modulation detectors, with a time resolution < E , are associated with the above observations, it then becomes possible to observe the evolution of the bunch position during the pulse itself (Bergkre [1966]). The transverse mean position of a bunch of accelerated electrons during a pulse of length At has thus been measured a t Stanford (Larsen [1965]) by observing the induced phases and amplitudes of the corresponding fields at f = v in a TM,,, cavity.
3.4
Lobes [2], [3],
... [n]
The exploitation of the information contained in any of these lobes is analogous to the one given for lobe [I] provided the following two conditions are satisfied: 1) The function,j, (t) must remain relatively stable, e.g., for a n elementary rectangular electron bunch we get for lobe [3], sin 37c (Az/z) A3A; ~ 2 1 , ---371 ( A T / ~ ) -
a value which varies even for constant I,, whenever the phase extension Acp = ~ ( A T / T ) of the bunch itself varies. 2) The transverse dimensions of the beam must remain small compared with A,= czln. This is generally the case for lobes [2], [3] and even [4].
4
Quantity of information contained in one measuwmenf
Most detectors mentioned above are characterized by stating their respective sensitivities (the derivative of their output signal with respect to the value to be measured dS(t)/dI,, 1; (dS' (t)/dx,(t)), ... . This specification however turns out to be totally insufficient in o u r case. Nearly all our measurements are taken under severe radiation
'
R. BERGERE
230
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Fig. 4
conditions, hence the measuring device is mostly to be found at the end of a long transmission line. Thus a pulse S ( t ) of duration At can only be observed through a transmission line having a global bandwidth B and an inherent noise N ( t ) . Thus the available quantity of useful information is given by
Q
=B
At log [ 1
+ S(t)/N(t)]
A somewhat more detailed investigation of this formula shows that the quantity of informationtavailable due to an analysis of the signal originating from lobes [0], [I] or [3] does in fact depend on the choice of the lobe. In fact, we can subdivide the noise N ( t ) in the following groups (Berghe [1966]): N , ( I ) , noise induced in detector itself, N,(t), noise induced in transmission line, N M ( t ) , noise induced in the final stage measuring device, N,,(t), the thermal noise of the complete set of measuring devices. But the noises N,(t), N M ( t ) and NT ( t ) are directly coupled to the operating
MEASUREMENT PROBLEMS
B.1.5
231
Hod.
1 I
I
1
I
I
1.6
I
I
I 91
I
I
Fig. 5
conditions of the linac itself and hence possess a certain correlation in time as well as in frequency with the signal S ( t ) . For instance, we can consider N , ( t ) as the superposition of a noise [ N , ( t ) ] , , , coming from leaks in the UHF pilot and (or) klystrons, and a noise [N,(t)],,, coming from the switching of the modulators. The time and frequency correlations of these noises with respect to the signal are given in fig. 4 and 5. Clearly we can increase the amount of information available by exploiting these time and frequency correlations to the full. The method will be best illustrated by considering some specific examples as applied to the 45 MeV linac a t Saclay.
4.1 Exploitation of time correlations Consider a signal in the video-frequency band So ( t ) completely buried in the transmission line noise [ N , ( ? ) ] , , final stage noises [ N , ( t ) ] , and thermal noise N , , ( t ) (cf. fig. 6a).
232
R. BERGERE
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
If we insert a delay time 0, just after the detecting electrode, and hence inject the signal S o ( t ) into the transmission line at a later instant, the noises [ N T ( t ) l 0and [N, ( t ) ] , will have been attenuated by a factor exp ( - cc0) already. The signal-to-noise ratio then becomes (fig. 6b):
Fig. 6
4.2 Exploitation of frequency correlations in lobes [O] and [I]
The basis of such an exploitation is given by the following relation which is experimentally observed l [ N ~ ( t ) l o ,+~ I~[ ~N lT ( ~ ) I I , U H F I .
Suppose we have three loops detecting a weak signal at the accelerating frequency I.. Such a signal IS, (t)l can be detected immediately after the loop itself and be transmitted by a coaxial cable having a proper noise [N,(t)], (fig. 7a). It can just as well be transmitted through a wave guide which constitutes in fact a high-pass filter transmitting only [N, ( t ) ] , . Putting the extremity of the transmission line and all the final measuring devices into a Faraday cage (fig. 7b) eliminates [NM( t ) ] , and [NM( t ) ] ,as well. The signal-to-noise ratio for an electrode having the same sensitivity as before can now be written as:
a
( t ) + CNM (t)lo + [NT(t)lo
MEASUREMEhT PROBLEMS
B.1.5
233
4.3 Exploitation of frequency correlation in lobe [I] and higher order lobes We were able to show that for very weak signals (positron current, field emission currents, etc.) the signal-to-noise ratio could be appreciably improved by considering the signal detected in lobes [2] o r [3] rather than in [I] (see fig. 5). Since IS, ( t ) l = IS, ( t )I z IS, ([)I but the corresponding UHF noises are such that [N,],< [N,], 6 [N,], this improvement was realized by transmitting the signal through high-pass wave guides with the respective cuts-off > I : and > 2 v . Figure 8 shows the gain in information when detecting the envelope of a very weak signal (a photon pulse created by electrons hitting a target) first in lobe [I] @a), then [2] (8b) and finally [3] (8~).
Fig. 7
Thus we see that the quantity of information available for evaluation depends rather on the signal-to-noise ratio of the complete system (detecting electrode+ transmission l i n e ~ m e a s u r i n gdevices) than on the sensitivity a of the detecting electrode alone. Of course, we could increase a by improving the gain of the coupling between electrode and beam. This is what happens when we detect a signal S, ( t ) by means of a U H F cavity instead of with a non-periodic loop. Unfortunately, a simultaneous decrease in the bandwidth B leaves us with practically no increase in information at all (except when looking for mean values). When trying to improve the measurements made on the evolution of a beam characteristic during a pulse length A t , the best approach seems to be an increase of the quantity of information available by appropriate shielding of transmission and
234
R. BERGERE
ELECTRON LINACS: THEORY
Fig. 8
measuring devices, rather t h m an increase in sensitivity a t the expense of bandwidth of the detecting electrode as such. References B E R G ~ RR., E , 1966, Etude des proprietks du faisceau d'electrons d'un accelerateur lineaire au moyerl des champs BlectromagnCtiques associks a ce faisceau, Doctoral Thesis, Paris Orsay. R., E. DELEZENNE and A. VEYSSI~RE, 1962, Etude de moniteurs de courant pour un accelkBERG~RE, rateur lineaire d'electrons, Nucl. Instr. Meth. 15, 327.
B.1.5
MEASUREMENT PROBLEMS
235
BERGERE, R., A. VEYSSI~RE and S. ROLAND,1964, Ondes millimetriques rayonnees par le faisceau d'electrons d'un accelerateur lintaire a electrons, Proc. 5eme Congres Tubes Hyperfrequences, Paris. BESS,L., 1. OVADIA and J. VALASSIS, 1959, External Beam Current Monitor for Linear Accelerators, Rev. Sci. Instr. 30, 985. 1956, Faraday Cup Monitors for High Energy Electron Beams, BROWN,K. L., and G. W. TAUTFEST, Rev. Sci. Instr. 27, 696. BRUNET, P., 1963, Etude et realisation d'un systeme de reglage automatique des phases hyperfrequences sur un accelerateur lineaire. Rapport LAL-31, Ecole Normale Superieure. ISABELLE, D . B., 1962, La mesure de I'intensite de courant produit par un accelerateur linkaire, Onde ~ l e c t r i q u eno. 421 354. ISABELLE,D. B., 1963, Beam Current Monitors for a High Energy Linac, SLAC report no. 25, part I. JOHNSON, K., T. KLIPPERT and W. J. RAMLER, 1961, A Non-intercepting Accelerator Beam Position Sensor, Nucl. Instr. Meth. 14, 125. KRETSCHKO, J., D. HARDER and W. POHLIT,1962, Absolutme~sungder Teilchenflussdichte schneller Elektronen mit einem Faraday-Kafig, Nucl. Instr. Meth. 16, 29. KULIKOV, 0. F., Y. Y. TELNOV, E. I. FILIPPOVand M. N. YAKIMENKO, 1964, Compton Effect on Moving Electrons, Phys. Letters 13, 4. LARSEN, R. S., and H. A. WOODS,1965, Position Monitoring Electronics for the Stanford Linear Accelerator, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12, 862. MOTZ,H., 1964, Application de la radiation d'un ondulateur a la mesure de la focalisation d'un linac, Conferences INSTN, Saclay. MOTZ,H., 1956, Cerenkov and Ondulator Radiation, Trans. I.R.E., PGAP 4, 374. 1965, Beam Position Monitors for Accelerators, Rev. Sci. Instr. 36, 97. OKABE,S.. and T. TABATA, TAIMUTY, S. I., and B. S. DEAVER, 1961, Transmission Current Monitor for High Energy Electron Beams, Rev. Sci. Instr. 32, 1098. G. W., and H. R. FESTER,1955, A Non-saturable High-energy Beam Monitor. Rev. Sci. TAUTFEST, Instr. 26, 229. T.I.D. REPORT,1962, Linear Electron Accelerator Studies. Statute report, Stanford University no. 14 180. VANHUYSE, V. I., E. D. WATTECAMPS, R. E. VAN DE VIJVER,and G . I. VANPRAET,1962, Secondary Emission Beam Monitor for 0.5 to 3.5 MeV Electrons, Nucl. Instr. Meth. 15, 59.
ELA
2.1
TECHNOLOGY
B.2
Electron Injectors P. BRUNET X. BUFFET Laboratoire de I'Acctle'rateur Lintaire Faculte' des Sciences, 91-Orsay, France
I 1.1
Introduction Definition
The injector is the linac section where electrons are so produced and injected into the linac proper as to enable their capture and acceleration. It includes the following main elements : ( I) an electron gun (the source); (2) a more or less sophisticated structure for bunching (one bunch per T or 1) and accelerating the electrons to a velocity Be = ve/cz 1 ; (3) a focusing system acting in opposition to the radial deflection forces on the low energy electron beam. The end of the injector is not well defined in terms of physics, but it may be defined in terms of the structure as the place where 1 - P e < l o p 3 (P,% l), which corresponds to about 12 MeV. The structure at this point is considered the end of the injector.
1.2 Main characteristics and quality (a) The average energy V of the electrons. At the injector end, V is about 12 MeV, so that the electrons are synchronous with the wave in the following sections. (b) Intensity of the beam injected into the accelerator. In this chapter we consider only injectors for a linac of low or medium current, that is, currents lying in the range O North-HollandPubl. Co., Amsterdam 1969
Refermces p. 263
237
238
P.BRUNET, X.BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
O< IOU,< 500 mA (at the injector end) with a range of pulse widths 0.5 ,us< z< lops. (c) Beam intensity acceptance of the injector. The ratio A = I,,,/I,,, defines the quality of the injector in terms of captured electrons: A 3 40% means a good injector; A 2 60jl/,, a very good injector. , be as small as possible. It is (d) Phase spread of the bunches. The spread A C ) ~ ~should in fact constant through the entire linac where u, =c=constant, and the minimal "current-energy" spectrum width at the end of the linac is ( ~ 4 ) ~ / 8 .
A4,,, < 10": good injector + A V / V < 0.4% Aq5,,, < 5": very good injector + A V/V < 0.1%. (e) Radial emittance R (see fig. 1). The radial emittance can be defined as the surface surrounding all the abscissa points r (distance from the axis) and the ordinate p, (radial momentum). If R is small at the injector end, a narrow beam can be obtained through the entire linac (see chapter B.1.2). This provides the following main ad-
Fig. 1. Typical radial emittance surface.
Fig. 2. Emittance limits for a good injector ( V rn 12 MeV).
ELECTRON INJECTORS
B.2.1
239
vantages: (1) all electrons in a given transverse section are subject to the same field (narrow spectrum), (2) all electrons are captured by the linac (good transmission and no structural damage). For a good injector, the output emittance may be inscribed in a rectangle (fig. 2): r= f2.5 mm, p,= k2.5 x 10-3p, at 12 MeV. (f) Energy dispersion at the end of the injector. In fact, A V is conserved through the entire linac and can provide a substantial relative spread of the spectrum in short accelerators. On the other hand, for good focusing, A V/ V should be small before the end of the injector. A V / V < 10%: good injector
A V /V < 5% : very good injector.
2
Choice of an injector
2.1
Buncher design
The buncher is designed so as to produce a beam having the most favorable representative phase volume. The action of the structure on the particles is essentially characterized by the time variation of the accelerating field along the axis of propagation:
The functions E(z) or ~ ( z and ) B,(z) can be defined as generating functions for the electron phase and energy in the buncher. cx=eEl/rnoc2,cj?, is the phase velocity of the wave, y = rn/rno. The volume that best characterizes the beam during bunching can be defined in the orthogonal coordinate system 0 4 , Oy, Or, Op,, 0 8 , Op,; z is the independent variable along the propagation axis. The trajectories in this space are determined by a system of coupled differential equations whose solution is almost impossible in practice. The following simplifying assumptions are therefore made in order to uncouple the longitudinal and transverse momenta: the generating functions depend only on the variable z in the neighborhood of the axis, and the diameter of the beam is constant throughout the structure. The latter assumption requires focusing fields computed a posteriori, since the electron energy is known at all points in the buncher. 2.1.1
Choice of theoretical cc (z) and 3/, ( z ) functions
The practical determination of the accelerating field and the phase variation in the structure is generally made by successive approximations. The first step consists of
240
P. BRUNET, X. BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS : TECHNOLOGY
selecting simple generating functions consistent with the initial energy of the electrons : bw(0) will be of the same order of magnitude but greater than P,(O) (see fig. 3). For be(0)=0.6, b,(z) can thus be taken equal to 1 after the beginning of the buncher (curves 1). For lower Pe(0) velocities, it is suitable to consider a function bw(z) that starts with a value less than 1 and increases to 1 (curves 2). In such cases, the order of magnitude of a(z) will be known a priori; it will be such that the velocity of the electrons at z, is sufficient : be(z,) 0.9 : y (z,) = y (0)
+ kzle~,/m0c2.
Fig. 3. Theoretical Bw(z),a(z), q5 (z) generating functions.
The coefficientk is less than 1 and expresses the electron lag behind the wave, characteristic of electrons that cannot acquire the maximal energy during the bunching. With a somewhat arbitrary choice of the a and b, functions, the equations of motion are solved by computer; this involves the numerical determination of the functions $, [z, $,(0), y (O)] and y [z, $,(0), y (O)] on the basis of the following equations :
1d V -
-
e dz
= E, (z) sin 4 (z);
The functions $,(z) and y (z) are computed step by step, with the step A z chosen so as to provide the accuracy desired.
ELECTRON INJECTORS
B.2.1
241
For a pair of values [q5,(0), y(O)] corresponding to the initial conditions for an electron, the functions 4,(z) and y(z) are then known at all points in the buncher. For other initial 4,(0) and y(0) values the evolution of the beam in the buncher can be found by repeating the computation. The initial condition q5,(0) is assigned a certain number of values between 0 and 2n; the initial condition y (0) is assigned discrete values corresponding to the highvoltage range of the gun.
2.1.2 Representations of' the movement (a) The first possible representation follows directly from the computed results: q5,= 4,(z) and De=De(z), see fig. 4. This representation has the advantage of per-
1
\d(o) = constant
z )
Fig. 4. Electron velocity and phase first
representation.
Fig. 5. Electron velocity and phase second representation.
mitting a comparison of the phase velocity and the electron velocity. It also reveals the phase limit towards which the bunches tend. It is then possible to modify the a and p, functions in order to improve the efficiency of the buncher. (b) The second representation consists of plotting the output energies and phases as a function of the corresponding input values (fig. 5). It is then easy to compute the bunching rate, the phase spread of the bunches, their positions with respect to the wave, and the energy dispersion of the bunch at the injector end. It is extremely important to make sure that the solution found by this method is
242
P.BRL.NET, X.BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
highly efficient for a substantial range of Eo and y (0) values. For example, the bunching should remain correct when Eo is varied between 110 and 150 kV/cm and the high gun voltage between 80 and 120 kV. 2.1.3
Effects due to the intensity
It is interesting to estimate the effects of certain phenomena that can become very important at high beam intensities. (a) Beam loading modifies E(z) in the structure. In a cross section traversed by a beam at Be = 1, the power due to the rf source and the beam are independent: the two effects (fields and energy) add to each other linearly. In the general case where the wave and the beam are synchronous, the accelerating field Eo and the field induced by the beam Ei are opposite in phase at all times. Conversely, in a buncher, where the bunches phase varies as a function of z and the accelerating field, the amplitude and phase of Z(z) and Ei (z) depend on E, (z). The modification of the field in the structure, small in the initial cavities, has almost no effect on the efficiency of rapid bunching, but the phase limit and the energy of the bunches are changed. In a long buncher where the bunching is slow, beam loading also affects the efficiency of the bunching. It is relatively simple to compute the field Ei(z) by assuming that at all points z the total charge of the bunch is concentrated in the phase of the central electron. Under the additional assumption that the movement is synchronous, the term corresponding to beam loading can be introduced into the energy equation in the following form : 1 dV(z) --
= Eo (z)
sin 4 (z) - Ei (z, I) cos 8(z)
e dz where O(z) is the phase shift between the given electron and the center of the bunch. (b) The space charge couples the longitudinal and transverse motions. The forces increase rapidly during the bunching; with increasing energy they then decrease when the bunching is achieved. Introduction of the space charge forces into the computation of the trajectories involves serious problems and requires a certain number of assumptions. Indeed the field acting on an electron during formation of the bunch depends on the beam intensity, the instantaneous length A4(z) and the energy of the bunch, and the distribution of the charges in the bunch volume. This leads us to assume firstly that the diameter of the bunch and its charge distribution do not vary during the motion. A distribution function and a constant beam diameter are then chosen. The (accelerating or decelerating) field acting on a given electron in the bunch can then be computed as a function of I, A$(z) and the phase difference between the electron and the center of the bunch (- + A 4 < O < ++A4).
ELECTRON INJECTORS
B.2.1
243
For example, the space charge field acting o n the electrons a t the edge of the bunch (8= k t A 4 ) in the course of the bunching can be as high as about 106 V/m, with I = l A, V = 1.5 MeV, A4=4" for a beam diameter of 3 mm. In order to take the intensity effects into account in the bunching computation, it becomes necessary to use a more elaborate program capable not only of computing the individual electron trajectories but also the global development of the bunch length A4(z), the position O(z) of a given electron in the bunch, and the space charge field E,,. This field for example is found by the computer as a function of A4(z), 0, y and 1. Thus the computer now processes the more complete equations: I dV(z) e dz -
2.1.4
=
E , (z) sin 4 (z)
-
E, (z, I ) cos O(z)
+ E,, (A4,O, y, I )
sin 0 (z) (sin O(z)l -
Effect of' the space harmonics
Up to now we have considered the buncher as a structure to be designed in conformity with the theoretical generating functions (amplitude and phase). It is known that because of the geometric discontinuities in the iris diaphragms, these theoretical functions are modified by space harmonics. It is therefore appropriate to measure the real functions a(z) and B,(z), either for a mock-up or for a structure already realized. This measurement can be made by a perturbation method. By moving a n obstacle along or parallel to the buncher axis, the values of the reflection coefficient Q and of the phase shift Y between the incident and reflected waves are measured as a function of z. This gives the functions: E(z)
=
kgk(z) and
@,(z)
= +Y(z)
(Steele [1966]) which leads to the actual functions: a ( z ) = s(,,,,,~
Q* (z) -
Qfa,
and
P,(Z)
=
2n
----
-
A, d@, (z)/dz
'
These functions (cf. fig. 6) are introduced into the program either by tables of numerical values, by approximations in terms of analytic functions of z, or by the coefficients of the first harmonics after expansion in a Fourier series. It can easily be seen that the effect of these harmonics is small in a normal linac section where the electrons already have a velocity very close to c. In particular, the energy gained is almost unaffected. In a buncher the problem is found on the level of the input coupler. The waves there are generally semi-stationary (the phase varies very little over a length > 1 cm in zones where the amplitude of the field is already high), that is, j, is very much greater than its rated value.
244
P. BRUNET, X. BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
The electrons, rather than being captured in this zone by the field, rapidly slip behind the wave and are sometimes slightly dispersed in phase. The intended perfect synchronism between the wave and the electrons is destroyed, and the velocity P,(z) is at all times less than p, = (z) (Haimson [1965b]). It should be noted that the induced field Ei(z) is modified in the same way as E(z), with their relative amplitude remaining the same.
Fig. 6. Actual electric field and phase variations according to Haimson [1965b].
2.1.5
Transverse motion
Upon leaving the gun the beam has a certain emittance surface in the (r,p,) plane. This emittance, possibly deformed by an optical system before the buncher, could extend beyond the diameter of the allowed beam zone of the structure. In addition to this divergence, due essentially to the gun emission, we have the defocusing effect of the space charge and the sf field in the structure. These effects decrease fairly
B.2.1
ELECTRON INJECTORS
245
rapidly with the energy: The radial force of the space charge acting on an electron located at the edge of the bunchers of diameter 2r can be written as follows:
Similarly, the force due to the rf field can be maximized by the following expression:
This makes it necessary to provide focusing forces for assuring a beam of small size. The computation for the magnetic fields needed to compensate exactly the defocusing forces is not easy. It would be necessary to solve an equation of the following type:
where the last term represents the external magnetic focusing force. We therefore generally limit ourselves to determine these forces by excess as a function of the development of the bunches (fig. 7) and provide a system of coils and solenoids giving the most reliable and flexible focusing possible.
Fig. 7. Typical axial magnetic field pattern.
When interested in high beam intensities, we could be tempted to allow the beam to spread radially during the bunching, so as to decrease the axial space charge forces. But it would then be necessary to take into account the variations of E ( z ) as a function of the distance r to the beam axis during the computation for the bunching. It is then possible to set up a program (SLAC) operating in terms of the quantities 4, y, r andp,.
2.2 Various types of rf buncher structures 2.2.1
General properties
A buncher is characterized by the parameters V, A V / V , A 4 , defined in section 1.2, to
246
P.BRUNET, X. BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
which the bunching efficiency b can be added: b = A ~ i n / A 4 0 u where ,, is the phase domain that at the input includes all the electrons found in A$,,, at the end; b is a function of 4 and Ac$,,. The values that will be given are the maximal values of b as a function of 4 . For comparison, b will be given for Acji, = 60". All the parameters are of course coupled; however it may be possible to separate them for individual optimization, by complicating the technology according to the following general remarks : The theoretical (Dame [1960], Hirel [1961], Lapostolle [1966]) and practical (section 2.1) computations show that the electrons can be coupled to the rf wave with p w = l or P w < l . In the first case, b is small, but there are no phase oscillations; in the second case, b can be very much greater, but 8, is greater than 8, at certain points; this leads to phase oscillations that are smaller in amplitude and frequency the closer PWis to 1 . The phase oscillations are disturbing to the extent that they increase A V / V and reduce the operating range. (a) In a long buncher (1 to 2 m) of low field, "time" is available to finely control the bunching process by shaping the a(z) and Bw(z) functions. Moreover, low gun voltages can be used along with low rf powers; this would simplify the technology and therefore lower the cost. On the other hand, a non-relativistic beam must be controlled over a long distance, that is, the rf defocusing forces and possible longitudinal and radial space charge effects must be compensated (compare this situation with the conditions found in the case of proton linacs). Moreover, the beam loading increases rapidly and considerably perturbs the functions a(z) and P,(z). Thus, this solution is limited to currents of the order of hundreds of mA. (b) In a short buncher (about 10 cm) having high field, the electrons are accelerated very rapidly; after several centimeters, it is no longer possible to control the bunching. It is therefore necessary to study the configuration of the fields in the input coupler (Haimson [1965b]) in great detail; the technology becomes complicated when the gun voltage and the rf fields (which are moreover limited by the breakdown voltage) increase, and the cost increases rapidly. For reasons opposite to the preceding case, this type of buncher is more suitable for medium and high currents; in particular, the beam loading can be neglected during the bunching. It is important that A V/ V be small throughout the bunching. This in fact provides the following advantages : (1) Good beam geometry, since the magnetic focusing systems are chromatic. (2) A cumulative process, since all the electrons in a well-focused beam remain on the axis and are subject to the same electric field. (3) Reduction in the interaction with the deflecting modes, when the electrons remain on the axis. The acceptance A can be artificially increased by providing a prebunching cavity and A+,,, artificially reduced by limiting A$in using an rf chopper (section 3). The optimal phase limit is near 7112 ( V maximum and A V / V minimum) but some-
B.2.1
ELECTRON INJECTORS
247
what less, so that the slower electrons precede the bunch; this narrows the A 4 due to slipping. The phase limit can be controlled by a buncher consisting of several structures whose phases can be shifted with respect t o each other. 2.2.2
Special properties. Performances
Let us now review four types of structures used in existing linacs (see also ch. B.3.4). (a) pw= constant = 1 : This solution, which is the easiest to handle theoretically, is the least used. It consists of directly injecting the electrons from the gun into a standard linac section. The electrons are captured only if cr is large, and A is better the higher U , (Lapostolle [1966]). However, bunching occurs only if the initial velocity of the electrons cp, is very much less than c ; in fact, at the limit, for fi,= 1, a 360' phase would be acceptable, and A4,,, would be 180". The values used in practice are: 80 < U, < 150 kV,
0.5 < /I, < 0.64
and
3 < cr < 4 (U,: gun voltage).
This system is used a t Stanford (M.111) (S-band) with a prebunching cavity. It operates a t U,= 80 kV using a 3 m section identical to those of the SLAC but mounted backwards in order to obtain high input fields (a,= 3). The a(z) then rapidly decreases with increase in z. The theoretical curves then give A=40% and b=7.5. The NBS injector also operates according t o this principle, with a prebunching cavity and a 2.5 m constant-impedance section: U, = 150 kV,
cr = 4 (L band).
The theoretical curves for the section alone, considered as buncher, give (Leiss [1959, 19661):
A > 50% and
b
=6
(A$,,,
=
10").
The value of b is small, but thanks to the high values of cc and U , this injector conserves its properties u p to currents of several amperes. The experimental performances of these two injectors have to the best of our knowledge not been published. (b) pw< 1 varying slowly, U, ION, (C.S.F.) : The electrons can be captured with U, and x very much lower, if p, < I . Azam, Mangin and Tronc (C.S.F.) systematically studied the low-U, bunchers and built the Saclay linac (ALS) injector in this form (Mangin and Tronc [1964, 19651). Capture conditions: If U, decreases, p,, must be decreased, as the maximum current lies in the neighborhood of /3,,=/3,,; the optical properties of the gun a t 25 kV and the difficulties involved in realizing the structures a t pw<0.3 determine the lower limit.
248
P.BRUNET, X.BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
For a given structure, the influence of Uo and a, is expressed in terms of their product S : there exists a threshold value So below which A=O. Above So, A increases linearly, then passes through a maximum >50% and decreases asymptotically to 50% (see fig. 8). Bunching: In the light of the general remarks above, it would be advantageous to use a large a to realize short bunchers; however this presents two difficulties.
Fig. 8. General buncher intensity acceptance versus gun high voltage and electric field magnitude.
Technologically, high fields cannot be maintained in a structure having low P,; indeed, E,(r) is then minimal on the axis, and the ratio E,(max)/E,(r=O) increases when b, decreases (Tronc [1966]): it is equal to 1 for P,= 1 and about 4 for bW=0.3 (see fig. 9). The allowable maximal a before breakdown is therefore three to four times lower than for a standard section. Moreover, a high a would lead to rapid variation of p, ( z ) and therefore to structural discontinuities that are difficult to make consistent with good rf adaptation.
Fig. 9. Longitudinal electric field radial distribution.
Moreover, if low AV/V is desired in order to limit the phase oscillations, the acceleration must be very progressive; this requires a long buncher and a low field. A compromise must be made between the longitudinal compression, which is maximal in the neighborhood of 4=O, and the energy gain, which is maximal for 4 =n/2. For the Saclay linac, the value +=60° (which is not critical) was chosen for
B.2.1
ELECTRON INJECTORS
249
the synchronous electrons; this gives the B,(z) and a(z) functions taking into account the limitations mentioned above. The following values were adopted for the ALS buncher ( n / 2 mode, S-band): 35 k V < U o < 4 0 kV a(z)=0.7 and almost constant 0.45 < /lw (z) < 0.99 total length 1.5 m V = 5 MeV A V/V: 25% of the injected electrons in A V/V= 3%, 50% in A V/V= 10% b= 15+A~,,,=4" A z 4 0 % to 50%. The main characteristics were verified by tests (with a prebunching cavity): I = 2 0 mA, i n p ~ power: ~t P = 0 . 8 MW V = 6 MeV, A V / V= 1.2% at half height A4,,,=4.5" for 50% of the electrons 90% of the electrons pass through a 3 mm iris, (pr/pz),,,ax< The adjustments are not critical, and V is independent of P to the first order, since the variation of 4 compensates that of cx. The bunching continues in the first standard section, which according to our definition is still part of the injector. The phase limit can then be controlled by the phase shifter of the section input.
(c) P,,, variable by levels, U , average =80 k V (SLAC). Beyond P,=0.5, it is easier t o capture the electrons. Starting with the solution (a), the team of Miller (SLAC) has improved h and solved the phase limit problems by providing a very short buncher (I wavelength) before the Pw= 1 structure [P, = constant = 0.75, a t low field (a = 0.6)] (Miller [I 9651). At the output of the buncher the electrons are grouped with a A4 already relatively small and only slightly accelerated (2 to 300 keV). All the electrons, subject to a high field (a = 2.5) in the following section at p, = 1, are captured and rapidly reach their phase limit, which can be optimized by the section phase shifter. This solution is a good improvement upon (a). The value of U , is moderate, which in particular permits the use of a triode gun. The rf power to be controlled in the buncher itself is low (0.6 kW), and the next section is a standard one. However, the low-field problems are still present, though over a very much shorter length. In particular, the output performance may no longer be adequate for I>300 mA. The buncher section has the following theoretical performances: 40% < A < 50% h=15 V= 35 MeV. A V/V< 1%, without beam loading.
P. BRUNET, X. BUFFET
250
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
Systematic tests were carried out with a short, 0.5-m section and a prebunching cavity. The following performance has been published (Miller [1965]): I = 5 mA480% of the current in A4,,,= 1.2" 1=117mA+llOmA in 5.1" V= 6 MeV, A V/ V at half height = 1.8% beam diameter: 90% of the electrons within 5 mm (~rlpz)max= 3 x
a,
(d) varying rapidly, U , high (Varian). In order to take advantage of high fields while preserving the condition P, =/I,, it is necessary to start with a high value of U,; Haimson and Numan (Varian) studied solutions of this type systematically for medium and high current accelerators and applied them in particular to the accelerator of the University of Saskatchewan (Canada) and that of the University of Frascati (Italy) (Haimson [I 962, l965aI). Starting with 0.55
B.2.1
ELECTRON INJECTORS
251
3 Main other sub-assemblies In section 2.2 we saw that good rf structures have bunching factors b of about 10 to 12. Since high-performance accelerators must operate with bunches of about 5", only phases of 50" to 60" ( A = 15%) can be accepted a t the input. Two problems are involved in obtaining short and very clean bunches (no shadow electrons between the bunches) containing the most electrons possible: (a) to increase A , that is, t o prebunch the electrons before the structure input without changing the energy, (b) t o eliminate the electrons that arrive outside A 4 i , (rf chopping). Lastly, the gun must be designed after selection of the injector type and optimization of A.
3.1 Rf prebuncher Prebunching is obtained by acavity followed by adrift space that acts as the input cavity of a klystron (Warnecke and GuCnard [I 9531). This prebunching cavity is supplied at the same frequency as the structure. The electrons are accelerated o r decelerated according to the phase of the applied rf voltage (U,). After a drift distance D, the fastest electrons reach up the slowest; this results in a longitudinal compression, called "prebunching". Let @, be the rf phase at the time t , when the electron crosses the cavity gap; @, the rf phase at the time t2 when the electron reaches the end of the drift space D ; @,, the rf phase at the time to that the central electron (the electron a t 0 voltage) arrives at the end of D. Then
where Do = vo/c. with o, the velocity of the electrons leaving the gun, P = vlc, with u the velocity of the electrons after the cavity, and 2, is the free space wavelength. Knowing U, D and U, ( U = U o + U , sin@,), we can compute fi and @,. Let us note that if @, = - @;, @, - @, # -(@; - a o ) for relativistic electrons. The compression will be greater the higher the ratio (U,/U,)D. (We generally use the standardized ratio R = x D U , / ~ o A o U ocalled the bunching parameter.) The curves below, given by Haimson [1962], show @, - @, =f (@,) and the current I, =J (@, - @,). With R = 2, we can bunch 50% of the electrons emitted by the gun (@, from -90% to $90:';) in a A 4 , , of 30". This improves the acceptance by a factor of 6, which is substantial. However, the modulation introduced in the electron velocities remains a t the input of the structure and causes perturbations in the input conditions (see section 2.1).
252
P. BRUNET, X.BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
In view of the value of R, it is advantageous to increase D and decrease U,/Uo; but the repulsive forces between electrons, neglected in the previous computation, can then become preponderant and damage the bunching. For the same reason (radial repulsion), D should not be very long if good optical conditions are desired. On the other hand, the elongation of D necessitates very narrow tolerances for the modulation of the gun voltage. Indeed, it is important that the prebunched electrons at all times have the same phase at the input of the bunching structure, so as to
<
R. 2.0
R
s
2.5
LG* BUNCH WIDTH
18' BUNCH WIDTH
> . DC
\
BEAM LEVEL
-do+-+-60 o I
-180
I
60
1
ao
62 - 0 0,
' 3 2 - '30 > Fig. 10. Departure-arrival phase relationship for prebunched electron beam .Current-arrival phase relationship for prebunched electron beam.
benefit from ideal bunching and limit-phase conditions. The curves of section 2 show that the maximum allowable shift is 10". Since a small variation Avo in vo at the structure input leaves the shape of the prebunch unaltered to the first order, the 10" tolerance can be reduced to the phase of the central electron (@,). A@,/@, = - A/3,/P0
with A@, = 10"
= 2rcj36
rad.
Withthe previous orders of magnitude, @, x Ion, A@, < 10°leadstoAPo/Po< 5 x Example of a compromise: R= 2, D = 30 cm, Lo = 10 cm, Po =0.6+U,/Uo=60,/,, input P= 3 kW.
ELECTRON INJECTORS
8.2.1
253
3.2 Rf chopper In order to design a phase gate with adjustable width and position it is possible to introduce a radial displacement depending on the phase, limiting it by an iris that blocks the undesirable part of the beam. Several systems have been developed: 3.2.1
Dejecting cavity
A rectangular rf cavity (TM,,, mode) displaces the electrons radially to the distance L, according to the function d = ( k ~ * ~ / psin@ , ) where P is the input power of the cavity; p,, the longitudinal momentum of the electron at the gun output; @, the phase of the electron with respect to the rf wave. The electrons pass without deflection two times per period (@ = O and @ = n). If fchoPper = $facce,eratOr a slot located at L perpendicular to the radial motion can select a bunch of width A 4 once per period in L P ~ Q is the geometric width of the slot. A$ is such a way that A ~ = Q ~ , / ~ where adjusted by the parameter P (attenuator) and 4 (phase shifter) at the cavity input. In addition to the use of a frequency 4f of fixed phase with respect to f this system has the disadvantage of causing maximum dispersion of the electrons. Indeed, the p, vanishes for the selected electrons, but Ap,/A@ is maximum. Haimson [I9621 uses a variant that provides the electrons with radial "polarization" at the gun output, by a fixed magnetic deflection d m ; the cavity, which then operates at the frequency f, returns the electrons to the axis once per period. Thewidth A 4 is controlled by P or dm;the phase @, by a phase shifter at the cavity input. The electrons are accepted in the neighborhood of p,=O and A p , / A 4 = O . The input power of such a cavity is of the order of several kilowatts.
Fig. 1 1 . Chopping mechanism for a T M m cavity with "polarization".
254
P.BRUNET, X.BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
3.2.2 'Keyhole' (Mangin [Sept. 19651)
C.S.F. has also perfected a chopping system : It consists of two coupled parallelepiped rf cavities operating at the frequency of the accelerator in the TE,,, mode; they are mounted on the same axis 0,. Only the fields Ex and H, exist in the neighborhood of the beam (x=y=O). If a continuous magnetic field B, is applied, the entire beam moves uniformly in the z-direction but describes a circle in the plane perpendicular to 0,; in this way, a phase condition between the two cavities is realized such that the beam out of the second cavity is centered on the 0, axis and parallel to it. The electron trajectory projection on the plane separating the two cavities is a circle centered on 0,. The angular position of an electron on this circle is its rf phase, to within a constant. In order to select the electrons included in an interval 4,-6, =A$, it suffices to make a V-shaped orifice in the wall (angular opening A$). The corner of the V is on the 0, axis; where one makes a cylindrical hole for the passage of the beam when chopping is not used ("keyhole"). This system is used in the ALS with A$ = 90". Disadvantages: A$ cannot be adjusted, and the powers involved are relatively k-igh (10 kW for U , = 40 kV, B, = 600 to 1000 gauss). Advantages: The beam leaves withp,=O, and the apparatus is short (10 to 15 cm). The radial repulsive forces of the electrons are low since r is increased, and they are compensated by B,. The rf chopping suffices for providing bunches that are as short as wanted. This solution, which in itself is very simple, is not realistic for the normal intensities required in classical accelerators; the situation is quite the opposite for a cw (superconductivity) accelerator with a current equal to 1 mA.
3.3 Electron gun
Electron guns used in standard accelerators are characterized by their high-quality optics and their flexibility rather than by their emission power (perveance of about 0.1 x is generally sufficient). We shall not discuss the design of a gun in detail here, but rather review the requirements for a good gun.
3.3.1 Electron dynamics The most important parameter is the voltage U,; e U , is in fact the initial energy of the electrons entering the rf structure. It should be sufficiently high for the electron velocity to be of the order of the lowest phase velocity that can practically be realized in rf structures (=0.3c-+30 kV), but it must also be sufficiently low so as t o allow a
ELECTRON INJECTORS
B.2.1
255
subsequent velocity modulation sufficient for the bunching (0.8c+ 150 kV): 30 kV < U , < 150 kV. But U, must also be absolutely constant throughout the pulse (modulation) and from pulse to pulse (jitter), so that the initial velocities are the same for all the emitted electrons. The computations of section 3.1 show that the following condition must be satisfied: dfio/fio<5 x But
Afi/b = dxlx ( I
+ x),
x = eU,/nz,c
2
Thus dfi/fiz dx/x here, where x 4 1. AU,/U, < 0.5%. The beam geometry, which will exert a n influence throughout the length of the linac, is also very important. It can be described in the following way: (1) The position of the cross-over, which must be located beyond the anode for controlling the beam by an appropriate focusing system. (2) The diameter of the cross-over (= 5 mm). (3) A perfect symmetry of revolution and constant density: i z r 2 , which in particular implies a homogeneous emissive surface of revolution and excludes direct emission from a filament. The beam geometry is conserved throughout the range of current variation. It is also appropriate that the sides of the current pulse be as short as possible in order to avoid injection of low-velocity electrons into the buncher; these electrons will generally be rejected, but can increase the space charge in the initial cavity and consequently in the bunch. 3.3.2 Gun operation
For correct adjustment of the linac, provision must be made for adjusting the emitted gun current from 0 to I,,,,, and the voltage U, by f 10% about the theoretical value; these two adjustments should be as independent as possible from each other. It is also useful to be able to adjust the width of the current pulse and, in particular, to provide very short pulses (nanosec) o r very short pulse trains within the rf acceleration pulse for precise measurement of flight times. Only triode guns provide the necessary theoretical flexibility in the supply of current pulses perfectly homothetic to the pulses applied to its control grid; the current adjustment is thus independent of U,. Some triode guns have been used successfully (NBS, SLAC, 28 MeV C.S.F. Saclay). However, substantial technological difficulties occur, particularly with respect to the grid modulator, whose potential is at the high level of the cathode; other producers (VARIAN) prefer to separate the amplitude and current-pulse width parameters, using a diode gun followed by deflecting plates that cut the sides of the pulse (an example will be described in section 5). The current is made relatively independent of U, by operating the cathode in a n emission zone limited by the temperature; for this it is important that the temperature be perfectly controlled.
256
P. BRUNET, X. BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
4 Measurements of injector characteristics 4.1 Electron energy V and A V/ V
This is the classical measurement by a deflecting magnet and an analysis slot (momentum spectrometer).
4.2 Phase acceptance
When the buncher is preceded by one or several prebuncher items it is possible to determine the phase acceptance of the buncher and the phase dispersion of the electrons entering the buncher. The output intensity of the buncher is plotted as a function of the relative rf phase between the buncher and the prebuncher (Haimson [1962]) (fig. 12). This graph provides the following : A@, = buncher acceptance, A@,,, =prebuncher emittance and the optimal relative phase shift between the two.
Fig. 12. Buncher phase acceptance and prebuncher phase emittance measurement.
4.3 Bunch phase spread 4.3.1
Measurement by defection
a) Use is made of a deflecting cavity similar to the rf chopper (section 3.2) or a
ELECTRON INJECTORS
B.2.1
257
progressive wave deflecting structure. All electrons within a A 4 such that A4 = R I D , where D is the maximal deflection, pass through a slot of width Q. By varying 4 all the electrons are caused to pass in front of the slot. Measurement of the intensity at the slot provides a curve I =f (4). Let x be the radial displacement, and p2 the longitudinal momentum, then:
If p, is constant, the curve i(4) represents the phase distribution in the bunch; if p is not constant however, the total width of the bunch is obtained t o within A 4 (Chehab [1967]). Advantage: The measurement is precise. The correction could be made if p, is simultaneously measured by a momentum spectrometer (if the spectrometer is placed in front of the deflecting element, a debunching phenomenon occurs that can falsify the measurement of A4; if it is placed after the slot R, the deflection can falsify the p, measurement). Accuracy of the order of one degree can easily be obtained over the entire width. If the same rf power source is used for supply of the injector and the deflecting element, the phase and amplitude jitter does not d i s t ~ ~ the r b measurement. The phase modulation also does not disturb it, provided that the modulation period is large compared with the buncher filling time. Disadvantage: The measurement is long. It involves a verification after an adjustment. The speed c o ~ ~be l d increased by remote-control phase scanning (fast scanning that is nevertheless slow compared to the pulse width, using for instance ferrite phase shifter with electronic scanning). The curve i(4) can thus be displayed on an oscilloscope. The operator observes its change as a function of the parameter adjustments. b) A faster measurement can be done on the basis of the same principle. Coupling two deflecting elements so that the deflection planes are perpendicular in space and the rf waves applied to them are 90" out of phase, we have:
x = ( k L / p , ) pi cos 4
=
R cos 4,
y
= (kLlp,)
pi sin 4
=R
cos(4
+ n/2).
Electrons having the same energy are inscribed on a circle as a function of 4. The arc of the circle is the direct phase dispersion of the bunch. The radius of the circle is inversely proportional to p,. The bunch energy and phase dispersion can thus be directly displayed on a luminescent screen. In particular, this provides the phase and energy distributions directly. This very attractive method has been used, particularly by Gallagher and Haimson, who has described it in detail (Haimson [Aug. 19651). However its accuracy is limited to that of readings on a luminescent screen. Absolute measurement of the energy is very difficult.
258
P. BRUNET. X.BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
4.3.2 Measurement by analysis of the harmonics
Let I, = I, (sinn$)/n$ be the amplitude of the nth harmonic. a) Accurate measurement. Bergkre [I9661 measured the amplitudes up to the 26th harmonic accurately and thus determined the shape of the bunch with a high degree of accuracy. Difficulty: Measurement of the amplitudes at very different frequencies i.e. coupling wiih very broad band, accurate continuous attenuation, and so on. b) Fast measurement. 4 can be theoretically determined if we limit ourselves to 2 harmonics sufficiently separated (for example, the fundamental and the fifth harmonic (Miller et al. [1965]). With good bunches (dispersion less than lo0), the measurement of A 4 requires a highly precise amplitude measurement (A$=6"+AA/A=O.O1 dB for a A4 accuracy of lo), but this method is very useful for fast adjustment of an injector. Indeed, if I,/I, decreases, the bunch shrinks. Moreover, the very simple equipment (occupying only a few centimeters along the beam axis) required for the measurement does not destroy the beam and can serve as a permanent check.
4.4 Output emittance
It is very interesting to know the radial emittance of the beam, mainly for a long accelerator, since it influences the entire subsequent optical system. Unfortunately, the required measurement is also very difficult. Miller et al. [I9651 have suggested a method assuming a radially symmetric beam: Two parallel slots separated by a distance L can be displaced perpendicularly to the beam. Let x, be the abscissa of the first and x, of the second. The transverse momentum p, of the electrons that traverse the slots is (x, -x,)p,/L where p, is the longitudinal momentum. Displacing x, for each position of x,, we obtain two extremes, pk and pi, between which a certain percentage of the electrons are found. 'By doing this measurement for each value of x,, we obtain a series of closed curves inscribed in each other and containing 50%, 70%, 90%, and so on, of the current. The corresponding surface is the emittance of the beam portion considered.
5
Example of injector assembly
5.1 On-line injectors
A linear accelerator consists of an injector, N more or less identical accelerating sections, and a zone in which the beam is used. There are generally several operational modes and zones. They can be distributed along the main unit (Orsay) or grouped at the end of the linac (SLAC). In order to minimize the transient beam loading effect and make easier the adjustment procedure, it is convenient to operate a linac at an
ELECTRON INJECTORS
B.2.1
259
energy rate per unit length close to the maximum, i.e. not t o use the total length of the machine a t low energy. So, several injectors which generate several independent beams may be installed along the accelerator, taking advantage in this way of one of the most interesting features of linacs. The injectors, distributed along the linac, must allow for free passage of the main beam. Various solutions are possible: 5.1.1
On-axis injectors
The possible structures with v g # c d o not perturb the high energy beam, but it is appropriate t o remove all orifices less than 15 mm. The collimators are then adjustable and remote-controlled; the gun is retractable. An annular cathode has been suggested for the SLAC, but has not yet been realized. At Orsay, the C.S.F.-type gun (section 2.2), located between two valves can be disassembled and replaced through a tube in about one hour (including the pumping time). Design work is being done on a remote-controlled gun retractable under vacuum. 5.1.2
Ofllaxis injectors
On-axis injection requires fairly uncomplicated, low-voltage injectors (cathode in air). Another solution involves placing the injector off the main linac axis and deflecting its beam onto this axis using a bending magnet. However, in this case, the magnet causes debunching. An injector of this type is planned for the SLAC.
5.2
The Orsay injector No. 1
The Orsay linac includes 3 injectors: (1) the main injector I, ; (2) an injector before sector 5 , 1 , ; ( 3 ) an injector before sector 9, I,. I, and I, are of the C.S.F. type (see section 2.2) with a removable 30-kV gun. 1, enables injection of currents from 0 to 100 mA into the last 5 sectors and thus provides up to 1.3 GeV in the end room. I, placed a t the beginning of the last group, supplies the electrons of the ACO storage ring. The performance of this sector is not critical, since a current of 50 mA theoretically enables the ring to be filled by a few pulses, and the ring accepts a A V/ V of 3%. The injector No. I must on the other hand have a very high performance. Two operating modes are planned : (a) High-energy electrons: Very good definition, that is, the following characteristics at the linac end: V = 2.3 GeV unloaded energy Energy A V/ V < 1% under permanent operating conditions Current 0 < I < 200 mA. (b) High intensity beam for bombarding an electron-positron converter placed
260
ELECTRON LINACS : TECHNOLOGY
P. BRUNET, X. BUFFET
at the end of sector 2 (after 7 sections), that is, having the following characteristics at the converter : Energy 275 < V < 400 MeV A V/V < 1.5% under permanent operating conditions Current 100 mA < I < 400 mA. For (a) and (b) operations, the injector must have the following characteristics: (a) 20 2.5% 6 A4Jout (do) Current (mA) 0-300 Beam diameter (90%) (mm) 5 Total angular opening (rad) 2 x Energy V (MeV) A (50%)
v/v
(b) 15 5% 10 200-600
8 5x
Description of injector No. I This injector includes three main parts (fig. 13): (1) a Varian pre-injector, (2) a 2meter section (buncher), (3) a measurement unit.
R f Switch
R f Buncher Structure
Phase shifter
I
Fig. 13. Orsay injection 1: block diagram.
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
Gun modulator 1 k R modulator load Electron gun Chopper cavity Lens 1 Deflecting plates Lens 2 Prebuncher cavity Collimator 1 Vacuum valve
11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
Lens 3 Bridge coil Collimator 2 Rf buncher structure Solenoid coils Deflecting structure Intensity monitor Position monitor Bending magnet Faraday cup
21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28.
Lens (LO) 12 mm collimator Vacuum valve Phase reference rf cavity (section phasing) First standard section Remote controlled collimator Intensity monitor Position monitor
B.2.1
ELECTRON INJECTORS
261
a) The Variun pre-injector (ref. 2 and 4) consists of the following: A Variun Type M. I V gun. This is a diode gun; the tungsten cathode is indirectly heated by bombardment at 3 kV. The gun emission is controlled by the bombardment current which is regulated. It is fed in parallel through a 1000-52 resistor by a conventional delay line modulator. Main characteristics: 60kV
262
P. BRUNET, X. BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
Unloaded energy = 23 MeV Energy at I = 1 A : 12 MeV. The section is surrounded by a system of solenoids that provides the appropriate axial magnetic field B, (fig. 14). c) The buncher section is followed by a drift space of 2 meters including the measurement instruments in the following order: A dejecting structure (mode-TM,,) with a power of 2 MW which can deflect 25-MeV electrons by as much as 30 milliradians.
501.1) 1
b l .2
Fig. 14. Actual relative magnetic field pattern of Orsay injection.
A 3-cavity position monitor: 2 TM,,, rectangular cavities (horizontal and vertical position) and a TM,,, cylindrical cavity (phase reference). The associated electronic equipment enables reading of the average beam position (mm), and oscilloscope display of the output signal of each cavity before and after the phase comparator. An intensity monitor: This is a ferrite-core transformer with a pulse amplifier for low currents. The current pulse can be displayed on the oscilloscope. Through associated electronic equipment the average current can be directly read in PA. A 60" bending mugnet enables measurement of the energy of the electrons leaving the injector. A fixed analysis slot corresponding to a AV/V of 0.5% is placed in the horizontal focal plane and followed by a Faraday cup under vacuum. An auxiliary degaussing coil is located on the magnet. For the bunch measurement, a four-jaw adjustable collimator placed at the end of the first linac section and followed by an intensity monitor identical to that at the injector end is associated to the deflecting structure; this provides a maximal deflection of
ELECTRON INJECTORS
B.2.1
263
24 cm for 25-MeV electrons. A fixed 12-mm collimator placed at the beginning of the first linac section serves to prevent damage to its structure during the bunch measurement. (The following section could be supplied so as to compensate for the energy loss suffered by the analyzed electrons passing through it.) The drift space also includes a lens (Lo) that adapts the injector emittance to the admittance of the next linac section and an isolation valve. It should be noted that 2-m drift spaces after the bunching section is possible only if the beam energy at the section output is high enough for the space charge and velocity dispersion effects to be very small. For an energy of 15 MeV and an energy dispersion of 5 x the increase in the bunch length is not greater than k0.7" in phase after 2 m. d) Rj' drive: The injector unit is supplied by a single klystron (C.S.F. x438, 25 MW-13 kW). An initial 10-dB coupler enables 20 MW to bedirected to the buncher and 2 MW to the structure. Two 22-dB couplers are located near the chopper cavity and the prebuncher cavity on the decoupled path. A phase shift free attenuator and a remote-control attenuation free phase shifter (360") are located on each of the cavity paths. Finally, a 360" phase shifter and a wave guide mechanical switch (for shunting the power through a load when the bunches are not being measured) are located before the structure. The decoupling of the switch is > 70 dB; this completely avoids perturbing the beam during normal operation. Injector No. 1 can be controlled as an independent accelerator (energy, current, bunch). After finding a good adjustment, one turns off the deflecting structure and magnet supply currents, rigorously cancelling out the possible magnetic field. The beam is injected into the accelerator. Two adaptation parameters are then available: (1) A phase shifter at the klystron input adjusts the phase of the current to the rest of the accelerator. (2) The lens Lo adapts the injector emittance to the accelerator acceptance.
References BERGERE, R., 1966, Etudes des proprietes du faisceau d'electrons d'un accelerateur lineaire au moyen des champs electromagnttiques associes a ce faisceau (Study of the properties of a linear accelerator electron beam by the electromagnetic fields associated with this beam). Rapport C.E.A., R 3126. R., 1967, Mesure de I'extension en phase des paquets d'electrons (Measurement of the CHEHAB, phase spread of the electron bunches). Laboratoire de I'Acctltrateur Lineaire, Orsay (France). Rapports LAL 1180 et 1193. G., D~ME , 1960, Electron bunching by uniform sections of disk loaded wave guide. Project M. Report N' 242-H, Stanford University (December 1960). I~AIMSO J.,N ,1962, Some aspects of electron beam optics and X-ray production with the linear accelerator. IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-9 121 p. 32 (April 1962). MAIMSON, J., 1965a, A comparison of theoretical and actual beam performance of a 140 MeV linear accelerator at the University of Saskatchewan (Saskatoon, Canada). IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12 [3] p. 547 (June 1965). HAIMSON, J., 1965b, Space harmonics, space charge and transient field effects in high current electron linear accelerators. Varian (August 1965).
264
P.BRUNET, X. BUFFET
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
HIREL,R., 1961, A study of the electron bunching problem. Project M, Report No. 269, Stanford University (June 1961). LAPOSTOLLE, P., 1966, Introduction a 1'6tude des accCl~rateurslineaires (Introduction to the design of linear accelerators). Course given at the INSTN, Saclay (France) CERN report 1966-20. LEISS,E., 1959, Injection systems for linear electron accelerators. National Bureau of Standards, Washington, D.C. (January 1959). LEKS,E., 1966, The NBS linac. Linear Accelerator Conference, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory (Oct. 1966), LA 3609, p. 20. MANGIN, J. P. and D. TRONC,1964, Phases et vitesses d'6lectrons semi relativistes dam un champ Clectrique alternatif. Application aux bunchers (Semi-relativistic electron phases and speeds in an alternating electric field. Application to bunchers). Rapport interne 2035, C.S.F., Domaine de Corbeville. 91 - Orsay (France) (Sept. 1964). J. P., 1965, Principe d'un hacheur de faisceau (Principle of a beam chopper). Rapport MANGIN, interne 2074 (Sept. 1965). C.S.F., Domaine de Corbeville. 91 - Orsay (France). MANGIN, J. P. and D. TRONC,1965, Traitement par machine arithmetique de calculs sur structures acceleratrices (Digital computer processing for accelerating structures). C.S.F., CEPEC, Orsay (France). Rapport interne 2077 (Oct. 1965). MILLER,R. H. et al., 1965, The Slac injector. IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. NS-12 131, p. 804 (June 1965). STEELE, C., 1966, A non-resonant perturbation theory. IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Techniques, MTT-14, pp. 70-74 (Feb. 1966). TRONC,D., 1966, Groupeurs d'accelkrateurs lineaires sous forte puissance H F (High rf power linear accelerator bunchers). Rapport interne 2738 (April 1966) C.S.F., Domaine de Corbeville. 91 Orsay (France). VARIAN Associates, 1965, Technical Description of Orsay injection system (Oct. 1965). WARNECKE, R. and P. GUBNARD, 1953, Tubes i modulation de vitesse (Speed modulation tubes) (Edition Gauthier et Villars).
ELA
2.2
1
TECHNOLOGY
B.2
Accelerating Structures
A. L. ELDREDGE* A. V. LTSIN
V. G . PRICE Stanford Linear Accelerator Center Stanford, California, U.S.A.
I
Introduction
The performance that can be achieved in an accelerator is determined by a number of factors. Included among these are the shunt impedance, the operating vacuum level, the conformance of cavity dimensions to design values and the material, surface finish and Q of the cavities comprising the accelerator. Each of these factors depends upon the methods and materials used in the construction. An improvement in accelerator performance has been observed over the past two decades as a result of the many innovations in fabrication techniques and the refinements in materials that have taken place during this period. Early accelerator parts, for example, were made of brass and were soft-soldered together. The performance obtained was relatively poor. In later machines, copper of increasingly higher purity has been used resulting in lower surface resistivity and hence lower losses. With better machining and assembly procedures, the surfaces have become cleaner and smoother permitting a higher permissible gradient for a given cavity geometry. Some of the accelerators built in recent years(e.g. SLAC) are large and sophisticated. It has been essential in the construction of these machines to select and develop economic methods and tooling to reduce costs. This will be particularly true with new
*
Presently at Varian Associates
$ North-Holland Publ. C o . , Amsterdam 1969
References p . 312
266
A.L. ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS : TECHNOLOGY
cryogenic accelerators now in the design stage. These machines require the development of new techniques to offset the very high cost of materials. The fabrication methods used successfully in the construction of accelerators at several centers are discussed in this chapter. Although the techniques used at Stanford are emphasized because of the first-hand experience of the authors, the methods used at some other locations are included where documented information has been available. No attempt was made to review the techniques used, for example, in the Russian accelerators, because of insufficient information. The reader is referred to ch. B.l.l and ch. B.3.2 for additional discussion of accelerator fabrication methods. To construct an accelerator capable of optimum performance from the standpoint of freedom from inherent phasing errors, it is necessary to make tuning adjustments to correct for the effects of machining tolerances or minor errors in design or manufacture. The relationship between these errors and the performance that would be obtained without tuning is given. It may be seen that although tuning adjustments must be made, it is necessary to maintain very small dimensional tolerances to limit the amount of the adjustment. The boundary walls of the SLAC cavities are deformed mechanically in the tuning operation. The apparatus used for this deformation is described. The dimensions of accelerator cavities vary with temperature. Consideration is given in this chapter to the significance of precise control of the metal temperature in reducing energy loss to a minimum. The problems of steering and focusing the beam in a linear accelerator are simplified if careful attention is given to the system of support and alignment. A description of the methods of support and alignment used at accelerator centers such as SLAC and Orsay is provided. Pre-operational tests on the SLAC accelerator sections were made at high rf power levels to outgas the section and to measure performance prior to installation. The apparatus used in these tests is described.
2 Dimensional requirements Optimum performance of an accelerator is possible only when a precise phase relationship is maintained between the driving rf field and bunched electrons throughout the acceleration length. In a disk-loaded waveguide, this relationship is strongly dependent upon the dimensions of the cavities which form the accelerator, and any errors in these dimensions that are uncompensated by tuning can cause a fractional loss in energy. The cavity dimensions will be incorrect for the design frequency if errors have been made in machining, fabrication, or in the choice of operating temperature. The subject of cavity dimensional tolerances has received detailed treatment by Post [1950], Chu [1951], Neal [1953], Chodorow et al. [1955], Chu and Ginzton [1955], Slater [I 9481, and Shersby-Harvie [1948].
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
267
It is not possible to machine or fabricate parts with zero tolerance, hence, a basic problem in accelerator design is to specify the permissible tolerances. This specification is a compromise between high cost of fabrication and the allowable fractional loss of energy. The best performance is achieved usually at the lowest cost by making tuning adjustments to compensate for dimensional errors rather than by machining to ultra-close tolerances. However, to reduce the amount of time-consuming tuning work and the degree to which the cavities must be deformed to make them meet electrical specifications, the untuned cavity dimensions must be very nearly correct. Fabrication errors can be systematic or random. Systematic errors result from poor design, improperly calibrated tools and measuring equipment, and temperature deviation. Small systematic errors which remain undetected during the fabrication of single section accelerators can be compensated for by adjusting either the operating temperature or the frequency. Random errors result from human error and the accuracy, precision, and reliability of measuring instruments. Chu [I9511 shows that deviations from design dimensions in accelerator cavities may be analyzed by treating the deviations as shunt susceptances on an otherwise uniform transmission line. These susceptances decrease the amplitude of the rf field and produce phase shift errors. Both of these effects cause a reduction from the design value in the energy gained by the accelerated electrons. However, the fractional loss of energy due to the phase shift error can often be offset, in part, by adjusting the driving frequency to correspond to the average resonant frequency of the cavities. Neal [I9531 derives eq. (1) which assumes that the frequency has been chosen to produce a zero net phase shift error in an accelerator section.
where @,=probable phase error in radians for one cavity due to dimensional errors N =number of cavities in an accelerator section fed from one source V =energy of the electrons r = o t f / 2 Q= the attenuation parameter in nepers o = 2nf, =the radian frequency Q =the cavity loss factor t , =the accelerator section filling time f, =the operating frequency in the fundamental space harmonic mode. The first bracketed expression in eq. (1) gives the fractional electron energy loss as a function of attenuation in the accelerator section. The second bracketed expression gives the fractional energy loss due to random phase shift deviations when the net phase shift error over the accelerator section is zero. As z, the attenuation parameter, approaches zero the fractional energy loss approaches +N@:. The value of 0: is equal to the sum of its constituent parts, one for each cavity
268
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
dimension, namely: 0:
=
@ti=
+ @tZb) + @td)+ 0;).
PI
The dimensions, q,, are identified in fig. 1. The phase shift Oqiresulting from an error in dimension q iis just the variation of electrical length of the cavity, i.e.: O ,(radians)
=S
61 (2nd) (<) 271
=
where 1, is the guide wavelength and n is the number of disks per wavelength. Converting S/2,/Agin eq. (3) into an equivalent expression which includes afo/dqisimplifies the evaluation of (3) since afo/aqican be determined most readily by measurement on test samples. From the expression for group velocity,
it follows that
where c is the velocity of light. Replacing Sf, by (afo/aqi)Sqigives
Inserting eq. (6) in eq. (3), gives
where for electron velocities approaching the speed of light,
P,
= l,/Ao x 1.
Fig. 1. Longitudinal cross section of an accelerator section showing dimensional notation. In the constant-gradient accelerator these dimensions are different for each cavity.
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
269
1
INPUT
CAVITY NUMBER
OUTPUT
Fig. 2. Rate of change of cavity resonant frequency with change in dimension 2a, as a function of distance from the input end of the accelerator section, in a constant-gradient accelerator.
0 INPUT
10
20
30
40 50 CAVITY NUMBER
60
70
80
90 OUTPUT
Fig. 3. Rate of change of cavity resonant frequency with change in dimension 26, as a function of distance from the input end of the accelerator section. in a constant-gradient accelerator.
Chu [I9511 determined values of dfo/dqifrom the test sections used in developing the original Stanford Mark 111 I GeV accelerator. Borghi and Jeong [I9631 measured similar values using test sections developed for the SLAC accelerator. The Borghi and
270
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
TABLE1 Dimensional phase errors (prior to tuning) Accelerator
Mark 111 (Stanford)
Group velocity ratio
Disks per wavelength
Cavities per feed
Attenuation (neper)
0.01
4
115
0.90
Feature
2a 26 d t
SLAC input
average
output
Jeong values are plotted in figs. 2 and 3 for each cavity in a constant gradient accelerator section. Using input, average, and output values from figs. 2 and 3, the fractional energy losses (without tuning) for both Mark 111 and SLAC are listed in table 1. The importance of precise dimensions and close working tolerances can be demonstrated by relaxing the tolerances on 6(2b), used to calculate 6 V / V in table I , from 0.0002 inch to 0.001 inch. With the latter tolerance the fractional loss of energy (without any subsequent tuning adjustment) would have been 12% for Mark 111, while the average for SLAC would have been 8%. Fabrication of accelerator cavities to the close tolerances described above requires special facilities in the machine shop. The production area must be air-conditioned and relatively dust-free. The machines must use cutting oils that are temperature controlled and the cutting surfaces of the tools must generally be diamond-tipped to minimize wear. Because of tool wear it is necessary to make dimensional checks on the cavity parts soon after they are machined to make possible early detection and correction of error. The temperature of the parts is lowered significantly by the evaporation of the solvent used to clean off the cutting oil in preparation for their dimensional check. The use of temperature-controlled plates allows parts to come to thermal equilibrium before their dimensions are measured.
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
271
for the SLAC and Mark 111 accelerators -
- - --
--
Dimension (inch)
-
-
Tolerance Derivative (inch) (MHz/0.001 in.)
Phase error (radians x
Phase error summation
C Hgi2 X
9i
10-6
Fractional energy loss
s v/v
0.6 %
0.2 %
0.5 %
1.9
Accurate and precise instruments must be provided to test the conformity of machined accelerator parts to the design dimensions within the allowable tolerances. Typical of these instruments are optical, pneumatic and electronic comparators and the master references used in their calibration. The pneumatic comparator, or air gage, described by Polk [I9551 and Busch [I9661 is the working instrument used adjacent to the production facility at SLAC. The air gage illustrated in fig. 4 has a least count of 50 microinches. The comparison of master setting rings with precision gage blocks is accomplished with an electronic instrument as shown in fig. 5. This comparison checks the manufacturers' calibration data and gives an indication of any wear of the reference rings. The manufacturers of the gage blocks and of the setting rings each have company master references that are checked periodically at the U.S. Bureau of Standards. Busch [I 9661 reports the Bureau of Standards' measurements in the range of 1 inch is within 0.000000 1 inch of the international standard.
3 Fabrication methods Early development work in the field of linear electron accelerators took place at a number of centers. Outstanding leaders at these centers include D. W. Fry at AERE,
272
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
W. W. Hansen at Stanford, J. C. Slater at MIT, T. Nishikawa in Japan, C. F. Bareford at Mullard and H. Leboutet at CSF. A design team led by Fry of the Atomic Energy Research Establishment, working at Malvern, England, produced a small 0.5 MeV standing wave linear accelerator in November 1946. Later, a two-meter long machine operated at 3.5 MeV. These
Fig. 4. Pneumatic comparator (air gage) used for checking dimensions of machined parts. The 2a dimension is being measured in the disk shown. The rate-of-flow of air between the disk and the air spindle1 ocated the position of the float in the vertical tube. Master setting rings are used to calibrate the go and no-go indicators.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
273
accelerators, described by Fry et al. 119471, Mullett and Loach [1948], R. ShersbyHarvie [I9481 and Fry [1952], were made with copper cups clamped together to form a disk-loaded circular waveguide structure. The cups were soft-soldered together for added strength. In these accelerators, the power loss was twice as high as the theoretical value because of the poor joints. Two accelerators made by Mullard Research Laboratories (see Bareford and Kelliher [1953]) used the basic Fry design with improved fabrication techniques. Instead of machining the cups, cold pressings were
Fig. 5. Electronic comparator used to calibrate the inside diameter of master setting rings with precision gage blocks.
274
A.L. ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
made from high conductivity copper strips five inches wide and 0.25-inch thick using a 75 ton press. The pressings were machined within 0.01 inch of the final dimensions after which they were stress-relieved at 800°C in an atmosphere of 90% N, and 10% Hz. This process was used to help free the copper surface of oxygen. The cups (see fig. 6) were then cleaned and brazed together at 780°C using copper-silver eutectic rings in nitrogen and hydrogen atmosphere. With this improved technique the power attenuation was reduced to 25% above the theoretical value. Slater designed a standing wave accelerator which was 21 feet long (see Demos et al. [I9521 and Slater [1948]). It was divided into seven sections, each sub-divided into four parts. Two of the sub-sections contained six cavities, the third was made up of four cavities, and a four-inch drift tube completed the section. The three subsections and drift tube were bolted together using O-rings to make the vacuum seals. VACUUM PUMP-OUT HOLES
\
,,qGAPS FOR SOLDER
Fig. 6. Cross section of the Mullard Research Laboratories' accelerator. One of the 316 cups forming an accelerator section is illustrated in (a). A part of a brazed section is shown in (b).
The disks and cylinders forming the sub-sections were individually machined and then joined together by silver brazing in a hydrogen atmosphere. Q-values of 17000 to 18000 were obtained. Slater found that frequent tuning adjustments were required until water cooling was added to the cavities. Metropolitan Vickers of England has used a fabrication method (see Miller 119541) wherein the cavity elements were machined from solid copper with tolerances of +0.0003 inch on the internal dimensions. The cavities were brazed as a stack with a eutectic alloy in an oven with an inert atmosphere. Short accelerator sections were bolted together and then placed in a vacuum envelope. Hansen's first accelerator, a unit three feet long, later extended to a length of nine feet, demonstrated that a traveling wave electron linear accelerator could operate satisfactorily (see Ginzton et al. [I9481 and also Becker and Caswell [1951]). A
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
275
second accelerator, 14 feet long, designated Mark 11, proved that one could hope to reach really high energies by means of a linear electron accelerator. The Mark 11 was built as a prototype unit for the Mark TI1 I-GeV accelerator contemplated by Hansen and his associates. Hansen soft soldered disks into a honed tube to form the disk-loaded structure in his first accelerator. The disks were soldered in place by feeding solder into the disktube interface through holes drilled in the tube. The resulting relatively low unloaded Q from I000 to 3000 led to high rf losses. The Stanford group next developed a technique of shrink-fitting disks into a tube to form a disk-loaded structure. This approach avoided the lossy solder joint. The Mark 11 accelerator which resulted, consisted of seven sub-sections. Each sub-section was two feet long and was constructed of annealed brass tubing into which brass disks were inserted. All interior surfaces of the cavities were plated with 0.001 inch of silver prior to assembly. The outside diameter of each disk was gold plated and the inside surface of the tube received a flash of gold prior to assembly in order to insure good electrical contact. The assembly was made by mounting the disks on a grooved invar mandrel using split spacer rings. It was cooled in liquid nitrogen and then inserted into the brass tube, pre-heated to increase the disk-to-tube clearance. Unloaded Q values for the accelerator cavities formed in this way were observed to be between 9100 and 9600. Good electrical contact and vacuum tight joints were obtained between sub-sections by the use of lapped butt joints backed up by an O-ring. A guard vacuum was pumped in the space between the O-ring and the butt joint. A matching termination for the accelerator was made by nickel plating the inside surfaces of the last subsection to increase its rf losses. Detailed reports of the Stanford Mark I1 accelerator can be found in Post [1950], and Post and Shirzn [1955]. Selenium copper (99.4% C u and 0.6% Se) was chosen for the disk material for the I GeV Mark 111 accelerator because i t is easily machined and yet has an electrical conductivity nearly equal to that of pure copper. The disk material was annealed, machined, and then gold plated (0.002 inch) on the outside diameter. The tubing into which the disks were inserted was made of oxygen-free high-conductivity copper. Two foot lengths of the tubing were annealed, sized, straightened and the outside diameter machined. Flanges were then soldered to the tube end, the tubes bored and honed, and the inside flash plated with gold. Following the procedure used for Mark 11, the tubes were placed in a steam jacket heated to approximately 230°F. Disks, held at the correct spacing by split rings and bushings on a grooved invar mandrel, were cooled in liquid nitrogen and then inserted into the heated tube. At assembly temperatures, the clearance between the disks and the tube was about 0.012 inch. When at equal temperature, the disk diameter was 0.003 inch bigger than the inside diameter of the tube. The resulting interference fit created a gold diffusion bond and resulted in good rf contact between the disks and the tube. The unloaded Q for cavities made in this way was found to be in the range of 7000 to 10000. Five such assemblies were placed end-to-end and clamped together by means of tie rods to form
276
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS : TECHNOLOGY
a 10-foot long accelerator section. Quarter-inch diameter copper tubing was softsoldered to the outside surface of the assembly for water cooling. The input and output couplers were fabricated as separate assemblies and bolted onto the flanges at the ends of the accelerator sections. The accelerator sections were supported at every sub-section flange from an I-beam which was 20 feet long. This beam supported two accelerator sections. The original Mark 111 installation is shown in fig. 7. Detailed reports of this accelerator can be found in Neal [1953], Chodorow et al. [1955], and Mallory [1955].
Fig. 7. The 310-foot Mark 111 linear electron accelerator at Stanford University. The Mark 111 was later rebuilt to incorporate SLAC constant-gradient accelerator sections.
8.2.2
ACCELERATING
STRUCTURES
277
The electroforming process for fabricating accelerator sections was developed at Stanford (see Pope [1957]). The first accelerator section made by that method was used in an accelerator constructed for the Stanford Medical School. Early accelerators made at Varian Associates used electroformed disk-loaded waveguide obtained from Stanford. However, in 1959 a technique using machined OFHC' disks and cylinders, silver-brazed in a hydrogen furnace, was adopted by Varian Associates and continues to be used to the present day. The outside walls and the end surfaces of the Varian cylinders are plated with the silver brazing material prior to stacking. This insures
Fig. 8. Section of linear accelerator made by Varian Associates. This is fabricated from disks and cylinders which are plated with silver brazing material prior to assembly and brazing. The entire assembly is surrounded by a vacuum envelope.
good contact between the disks and cylinders as well as between the cooling tubes and the outside of the disk-loaded waveguide. An accelerator section produced by Varian Associates with this method is shown in fig. 8. Further illustration of the technique is given in Haimson [1965]. The cavity walls of this section do not form the vacuum envelope; instead they contain vacuum pumpout holes. The entire assembly is placed within a cylinder which serves both as a vacuum envelope and as the support structure. The advantage of surrounding the accelerator structure with a vacuum
278
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
Fig. 9. Components of the CSF linear accelerator. These are forged, machined, and then clamped together with alignment rods, of which one is shown here. Screws for tuning each cavity are illustrated.
Fig. 10. A short section of the CSF linear accelerator prior to insertion in a vacuum envelope
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
279
manifold is that the pumping speed at each cavity is essentially equal, resulting in a uniform vacuum level throughout the accelerator section. Compagnie Generale de Telegraphie Sans Fil in France has made accelerator structures from forgings of oxygen-free high conductivity copper (Leboutet [1963], Jean [1961]). The forgings form two half cavities with a separating disk as shown in fig. 9. The forgings are stored for several months prior to any machining to permit stresses to be relieved. The half cavities are then machined, and the two ears in the forgings are bored accurately with respect to the machined inside dimensions of the disks and half cylinders and are then fitted with alignment rods. Cavity alignment is provided and maintained by these rods which are also used to clamp the cavities together. The edges of the cylinders are indium-coated to provide good electrical contact between cavity halves. The clamped assembly is supported in a stainless steel ELECTROFORMED COPPER
/ '
'MACHINED
CYLINDER
Fig. 11. Cross section of an accelerator section made by Mitsubishi Electric Corporation. The disks and cylinders are stacked, clamped, and electroformed at room temperature. Aluminum etching is not required.
cylinder which serves as the vacuum envelope. Holes drilled through the wall of the half cylinder permit vacuum pumpout of the cavities. Figure 10 shows a short accelerator coupler section assembly with alignment rods prior to insertion into the vacuum jacket. Tanaka [I9611 describes a three meter long, 6 MeV linear accelerator fabricated by an electroforming method by Mitsubishi Electric Corporation of Japan for the lnstitute for Nuclear Study of the University of Tokyo. This accelerator was built to be used as an injector for a 1 GeV electron synchrotron. The electroforming method using aluminum spacers, etched out after completion of the copper walls, is similar to that described by Pope. A description of the method is found in Tanaka et a/. [1961]. The Tanaka accelerator was fabricated with tolerances on the inside cavity dimension of 6 (2a) = 0.00024 inch, 6 (26) = 0.0004 inch, 6 (d) = 0.0004 inch and 6 ( t )= 0.00024 inch. This accelerator operated in the n/2 mode with unloaded cavity Q
280
A.L. ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
values greater than 10000. The contour of the disk hole was held within f0.00008 inch. It was found that a variation of 0.0016 inch2 in a cross-sectional area of the contour resulted in a cavity frequency change of 4.8 MHz. This accelerator had a phase error of about 3.4 x l o p 3 radians as a result of the machining tolerances. Nishikawa [I9641 describes an improved electroforming technique used at Mitsubishi Electric Corporation for making accelerator structures. Copper disks and cylinders are machined and then assembled on a jig. The cylinders have a knife edge machined around the periphery to prevent virtual leaks and to insure good rf contact. The outside of the assembly is then electroplated to form an integral, vacuum-
Fig. 12. Photograph of the ML-300 accelerator built for the University of Tokyo by Mitsubishi Electric Corporation.
tight structure. A cross section of such an assembly is shown in fig. 11. This method is reported to reduce or eliminate the need for tuning because the parts are never subjected to high temperatures, which tend to distort the accurately machined dimensions. An advantage of the new Mitsubishi technique over previous methods is that there are no aluminum spacers to be etched out upon completion of electroforming. Q values of 13000 were reported for accelerator cavities fabricated in this way. A special edition of the Mitsubishi Denki Giho (Volume 42, February 1968) describes in detail the ML-300 electron linear accelerator made for the University of Tohoku in Japan. This S-band accelerator, illustrated in fig. 12, produces a 300 MeV
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
281
beam at 350 milliampere peak current. Five klystrons, operating at 250 kV and 270 amperes peak and 3.8 microseconds pulse width are used to drive the accelerator. The accelerating structure of this machine is described by Ikeda et al. [1968]. The construction technique is the same as that described by Nishikawa.
SLAC accelerator fabrication technique
A review of various methods used to fabricate accelerator sections was carried out at SLAC. Some of the techniques described above were believed to have potential disadvantages, such as virtual leaks, deterioration of the electrical contact between
Fig. 13. Copper disks and aluminum spacers used in the fabrication of accelerator sections by the electroforming process. After plating, the aluminurnspacers must beetched out with sodium hydroxide.
cavities and creep of the copper parts under high clamping forces. It was concluded that brazing or electroforming were the most promising techniques. Extensive work with both brazing and electroforming methods demonstrated that satisfactory accelerator sections can be made either way. Figure 13 shows the parts used for electroforming. The first step in the electroforming method of fabrication is the assembly of a ten-foot array consisting of copper disks and aluminum spacers shown in the figure. After the parts are assembled in a V-block, a mandrel is inserted through the holes to position the parts and hold the
282
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
assembly together. The assembly work is then carried out under water to eliminate air pockets and to reduce the possibility of solution leakage into the assembly. After assembly, the array is chemically cleaned and a thickness of 318 inch of copper is electroformed over it. Figure 14 shows an assembly in a copper sulfate electroforming bath. During this procedure, the mandrel is held horizontal with the assembly half submerged in the solution. The assembly is rotated at approximately 30 rpm and an agate burnisher continuously smooths the surface of the plated copper. After the outer wall has been electroformed, the aluminum spacers are removed by etching in a
Fig. 14. An accelerator section being electroformed.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
283
sodium hydroxide solution and the assembly is again chemically cleaned. This procedure yields an all-copper accelerator section fabricated to very close dimensions. A comparison of the crystalline structure of copper electroformed by this technique with that of OFHC" copper produced by the usual mill fabrication procedures shows that the metallurgical properties are very similar. Nine days are required to deposit the 318 inch wall thickness. The electroforming process was used to produce a number of 10-foot sections which exhibited excellent microwave characteristics. Figure 15 shows a n electroformed accelerator section prior to etching. In spite of excellent results with the electroforming technique, brazing was selected as the preferable way of fabricating the 10000 feet of accelerator needed for SLAC. The brazing method was chosen because it takes less time than electroforming
Fig. 15. Accelerator section made at SLAC by the electroforming method. Rectangular waveguide transition pieces are brazed to the assembly at each end adjacent to the coupling irises.
- it requires only a few hours to braze an assembly. This shorter time permitted greater flexibility in the production schedule. It is significant to note that the cost of the electroforming technique was found to be nearly the same as the cost of the brazing technique. A study of various brazing methods used by others in the past led to the development of a special furnace incorporating a moving oxygen-hydrogen fired split-ring burner and a water-cooled cylinder illustrated in schematic form in fig. 16. The cylinder contains a reducing atmosphere in which a brazed accelerator section is cooled. The copper disks and cylinders shown in fig. 17 are cleaned according to the process in table 2 and are stacked on a granite V-block inclined at 1 5 " to the horizontal as shown at the right of fig. 16. A thin washer of brazing alloy (melting point 783 "C)
284
A.L. ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS : TECHNOLOGY
Fig. 16. Schematic of the special SLAC brazing furnace used in the fabrication of accelerator sections. The granite V-block used in stacking disks and cylinders is shown in the partially raised position.
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.2.2
285
Fig. 17. Copper disks and cylinders and the brazing washers used in the fabrication of SLAC accelerator sections.
Cleaning process for accelerator disks and cylinders at SLAC lmmerse parts for 5 minutes in Enthone Emulsion Cleaner No. 62 at room temperature.* h. lmmerse parts for 3 minutes in a n air-agitated tap water rinse.* c. Repeat h. d. Soak parts for 5 minutes in Enthone S-64 at 190°F.* P. Immerse parts for 3 minutes in an air-agitated tap water rinse.* Inspect for water breaks. f: Repeat cJ. g. Dip parts for 5-10 seconds in a solution of 8 oz/gal of Enthone Compound 36 at room temperature.** h. lmmerse parts for 3 minutes in a n air-agitated tap water rinse.* i. Repeat h. j . Dip parts for 20 seconds in a 25 % by volume solution of hydrochloric acid at room temperature.** k . lmmerse parts for 3 minutes in an air-agitated tap water rinse.* I. Repeat k . rn. Dip parts for 20 seconds in an 8 oz/gal solution of potassium cyanide at room temperature.* n. lmmerse parts for 3 minutes in an air-agitated tap water rinse.* o . Repeat n. p. lmmerse parts for at least 30 seconds in distilled water at room temperature. Water to have a minimum resistivity of 400000 ohms.** q. Immerse parts for at least 30 seconds in distilled water at 170°F. Water to have a minimum resistivity of 400000 ohms. Use a polyvinyl coated high temperature lining. r. Dry in pressurized air warmed to 150°F. Interior of drying oven constructed of stainless steel. 0,
* Use a stainless steel tank
**
Use a polyvinyl coated tank
286
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS : TECHNOLOGY
is inserted between each disk and cylinder. The dimensions of each cavity in a 10-foot section of the SLAC constant-gradient accelerator differ as listed in table 3. Therefore, the disks and cylinders are numbered to simplify their proper placement along the stack. Figure 18 illustrates the placement of these parts at the beginning of a stacking operation. After an assembly is complete, the V-block is oriented vertically and a support mandrel is inserted through the disk holes. A spring-loaded mechanism applies a compressive force to the stack. The assembly is then transferred into the furnace by means of a crane, the water-cooled cylinder is moved to its fully raised position and the TABLE3 Cavity dimensions 2a and 2b (in inches) for the SLAC constant gradient accelerator --
Cavity Input Coupler 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Cavity
Cavity
58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 Output Coupler 86
-
Beam entrance aperture into coupler. The center for boring the half-wall of the input coupler cavity opposite the input waveguide has been displaced 0.1550 inch in a direction away from the waveguide. The purpose of this displacement is to compensate for the opening in the wall which allows power to flow into the cavity from the waveguide. The symmetry of the fields in the coupler cavity is thus approximltely restored. The corresponding displacement for the output cavity is 0.0800 inch. a
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
287
split-ring burner is closed around the section. The accelerator section now hangs as a plumb-bob; any movement is damped by a water baffle. The ring burner is raised to the uppermost end of the section and is ignited to start the brazing operation (see fig. 19). When the melting point of the brazing alloy is reached, the burner and the cylinder move down the section by means of two sets of lead screws, successively
Fig. 18. The disks, cylinders, and brazing washers being stacked in the V-block preparatory to brazing.
melting the brazing alloy at one joint after another. The travel speeds of the burner and the cylinder are independently variable permitting the burner-to-cylinder spacing, and thereby the heat input to the accelerator section, to be varied. A reducing gas flows into the cylinder and through the section to prevent oxidation during brazing and cooling of the section. A period of 25 to 30 minutes is required from the initiation
288
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
Fig. 19. SLAC accelerator section being brazed in the flame furnace. The cylinder shown at the top of the figure travels downward with the ring burner and shields the hot copper with a reducing atmosphere.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
289
of the heating cycle to its completion. The section cools sufficiently t o be removed from the furnace two and one half hours after the heating cycle is finished. Input and output couplers for each accelerator section are made up as subassemblies. Each of these consists of the input or output waveguide, the end flange and approximately eight inches of disk-loaded waveguide. These units are brazed together in a hydrogen retort furnace prior to final assembly as the ring burner will not pass over the waveguide and coupler portion.
Fig. 20. Ten-foot SLAC accelerator section mounted o n its extruded aluminum strongback.
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
290
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
The straightness of a 10-foot assembly after brazing is found typically to be within 0.010 inch. Phase shift deviations up to 30" have been observed after brazing. Upon completion of the disk-to-cylinder braze, the water jacket is assembled and brazed (with a lower melting-point alloy) to the accelerator section. The section is then placed upon its supporting structure and tuned. A completely assembled and tuned accelerator section can be seen in fig. 20. After tuning, the sections are processed and tested at high power. After satisfactory completion of high power test, four accelerator sections along with vacuum manifolding, rectangular waveguide, water lines, degaussing wires, and magnetic shielding are mounted on a 40-foot long support girder and are then installed in the accelerator housing.
4
Microwave tuning
Tuning adjustments are made to correct those random and systematic errors which remain after the machining and fabrication of an accelerator is completed. Random errors are usually corrected by deformation of the cavity walls or by the use of tuning plugs. Systematic errors can be corrected by adjustment of the operating temperature or driving frequency to achieve maximum energy gain. The tuning methods adopted by various accelerator builders are those best suited to the particular fabrication approaches used. The method used by CSF (see Jean [1963]) in the construction of an accelerator at Orsay, France, illustrates one approach while that used by SLAC shows another. These two methods are discussed in the following paragraphs. Tuning adjustment of the Orsay accelerator cavities, which were machined to a tolerance of f0.0004 inch, was done in air at room temperature (20f 0.1 "C).The adjustments were made at a frequency which resonated a special reference cavity made of OFHC' copper in TE,,, mode. The reference cavity and the accelerator cavities
TUNING
-
TRY
-.
Fig. 21. Field pattern for Orsay half-cavities tuned to 4 2 mode of operation.
Fig. 22. Field pattern for Orsay half-cavities tuned to n/2 mode of operation. Cavities 1 , 2 and 3,4 have been separated to add cavities 5, 6 and 7, 8.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
291
are held at the same ambient conditions during tuning. Two half cavities, illustrated in fig. 9, are assembled together as shown in fig. 21. A tuning plug, inserted into one of the holes in the cavity walls (other holes remain as vacuum pump-out orifices), is adjusted until the assembly resonates with 4 2 radians phase shift per cavity, the mode of operation selected for the completed accelerator sections. There is no electromagnetic field at the symmetry plane separating the half cavities. Therefore, the first set of tuned half cavities can be separated and then two untuned half cavities can be inserted between them as shown in fig. 22. When the new pair of half cavities is tuned to the n / 2 mode, the electric field configuration will be as shown in the figure. This pair of tuned half cavities is then set aside to be replaced by a new pair of cavities to be tuned. This process continues until all cavities of a given inside diameter and alb ratio have been tuned. In the tuning process, the cavities are held together with the same force as used when the cavities are clamped together into a completed 6.1 meter long section (see fig. 23). Input and output couplers (illustrated in fig. 30 of ch. B. 1 .I) are attached to an assembly of tuned cavities. These are mounted upon a support structure and are matched to the section. The section is terminated in a matched load and the impedance looking into the input coupler is plotted on a Smith chart over a range of frequencies near the operating frequency. Prior to tuning, the couplers have a VSWR of about 1.4: 1. An iris in the rectangular waveguide and a movable terminating short are adjusted until the input VSWR is less than 1.3: 1 over a f2 M H z range. Once the couplers are tuned, any defective cavities in a section are located by a frequency domain reflectometry technique. The output of a frequency-swept signal generator is applied through a slotted line to an accelerator section which is terminated in a matched load. A discontinuity from a defective cavity in the accelerator section produces a reflection which adds vectorially to the incident signal. The phase relationship of the reflection varies with signal frequency and with distance to the discontinuity. As the frequency is swept, the display of the detected output will show ripples resulting from the vector addition of the signals. The height of the ripples represents the magnitude of the discontinuity and their number along the abscissa of the display is a measure of the distance from the discontinuity to the detector. The ripple-to-ripple spacing represents a phase shift of n radians along the line. By varying the frequency shift Af, the number of ripples in the display can be varied and a full-width display can be made equivalent to the length of an accelerator section. A defective cavity is seen on the display as a step in an otherwise smooth ripple pattern. Measurement of the cavity fields and the phase shift per cavity is simplified by the presence of the vacuum pumping holes in the cavity walls. A coupling loop inserted a small distance into each cavity through these holes is used to sample the fields. With this loop, the attenuation along the section can be readily calculated. The phase shift per cavity is determined by shorting the output coupler and then observing the standing wave pattern resulting when a signal is applied. If the input frequency is shifted, the reflected and incident signals are of opposite phase at each even numbered
292
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
cavity. It is therefore possible to verify that the cavities have remained tuned throughout the assembly operation. A section is considered acceptable if its filling time is found to be less than one microsecond, if the cavities are not defective, and if the input VSWR is less than 1.3: 1. The attenuation of a 6.1 meter section is of the order of 7 to 8 dB.
Fig. 23. Assembled 6.1 meter section of the Orsay accelerator.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
293
An approach, quite different from that used zt Orsay, was adopted to match the coupler cavities and tune the accelerator sections at SLAC. The differences arose from the different construction methods used and from the need for economy when a large number of sections are to be tuned. At Orsay a stainless steel tube serves both as a n alignment support and also as a vacuum envelope for the cavities. At SLAC, on the other hand, disks and cylinders are brazed together to form their own vacuum envelope. The SLAC cavities, therefore, d o not have the convenient vacuum holes ~ ~ s e ffor u l t ~ ~ n i nasg in the Orsay machine - instead, tuning must be accomplished by cavity wall dimpling. Some novel means for squeezing cavity walls inward and deforming them outward (e.g., using pellets shot from a projector) were in use at Varian Associates in 1959. In subsequent Varian Associates accelerators, the cavities are tuned with either inward or outward wall deformation by inserting a tuning tool through convenient vacuum pumping holes. At SLAC, the 2b dimension of the cavities is purposely machined about 0.001 inch oversize to circumvent the need for outward deformation with vacuum-tight cavities. The coupler and its matching iris form a matching junction between a rectangular waveguide and the periodic structure of the accelerator. This junction must be matched before one can proceed to adjust the phase length of the other cavities in the accelerator. Matching the junction between different transmission lines is a problem for which standard solutions exist. In the usual case, impedance measurements are made in one transmission line while moving the position of a short circuit by discrete amounts in the other transmission line. The results are plotted on a Smith chart and the proper adjustments are made (Gallagher [1960]). I n the disk-loaded structure, the design phase shift per cavity is known and by detuning successive cavities, a n effect equivalent to movinga short a known amount on a uniform line is obtained. When one uses oversized cavities, as at SLAC, however, this standard technique does not work because of lack of exact knowledge of the phase shift in each cavity. A method suggested by Kyhl and reported by Westbrook [196314 was found to match the oversized and undercoupled coupler cavities used a t SLAC. It should be understood that the dimensions of the iris and cavity for a properly matched coupler have to be determined only once. Thereafter, the couplers for the remaining accelerating sections can be machined accurately to those same dimensions. The need for adjusting the phase length of the first cavity remains, however. The coupler cavity is made to be oversized as well as undercoupled. The procedure used for matching these couplers to the rectangular waveguide and to a n oversized accelerator section operating with 2n/3 radians phase shift per cavity is as follows: a. Detune the coupler cavity with a metallic plunger and determine the "detuned short" positions in the input waveguide for each of three frequencies: The frequency for the 2n/3 mode, the frequency for the n/2 mode and the arithmetic mean of these frequencies.
*
See ch. B.I.1, section 8, Matching and Tuning, for further discussion.
294
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
b. Retract the detuning plunger so as to detune the next cavity in the series. c. At the mean frequency given in step a, deform mechanically the first cavity to bring the input impedance point one quarter of a guide wavelength away from the "detuned short" position for this frequency. d. Leaving the detuning plunger in position, take impedance data at the n/2 mode and the 2n/3 mode frequencies. If the coupling is correct, the data points will fall on a Smith chart plot as shown in fig. 24. The data points will actually fall as in fig. 25 because the coupler cavity is undercoupled.
(INPUT CAVITY DETUNED)
f
FREQ.
SECOND CAVITY DETUNED
2T/3
Fig. 24. Smith chart plot, first cavity properly coupled and tuned.
" DETUNED
SHORT ( I N P U T CAVITY DETUNED)
"
<120°
4 +
7 T / 2 FREQ.
FREQ.
SECOND CAVITY DETUNED
Fig. 25. Smith chart plot, first cavity tuned, but undercoupled.
e. The coupling aperture should next be opened a small amount by machining, and the new dimensions measured and recorded. This will detune the first cavity slightly, in addition to increasing the coupling. f. Repeat steps c, d and e, until, at some repetition of step d, the coupling is found to be correct. The coupler is now both tuned (i.e., the phase length is correct) and matched. Measure the input coupling aperture dimensions and use these dimensions in the machining of subsequent couplers. Experience at SLAC with irises & inch thick in the coupler cavity proved that proper dimensions for the iris could be machined. This eliminated any need to make manual
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
Fig. 26. Cut-away illustration of the SLAC semi-automatic accelerator tuning machine.
295
296
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
modifications of the iris in the tuning process. Instead, it was necessary only to dimple the coupler cavity to adjust its phase length to the correct value. A mechanism was designed for tuning the cavities of the SLAC accelerator sections semi-automatically on a production line basis (see Borghi et al. [1966]). This machine, illustrated schematically in fig. 26 and in close-up in fig. 27, permits an operator to select any cavity in an accelerator section to make measurements, to determine the
Fig. 27. SLAC accelerator section tuning machine with an accelerator section in place. Notice the indentation marks made by the tuning machine.
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.2.2
297
correction required and then to indent the walls of the cavity at four places to effect the required cavity volume change. Accelerator sections tuned in air at room temperature require corrections to be made in the measurement data (see Haimson, ch. B.3.2) to account for humidity and temperature. This problem is circumvented in the SLAC accelerator where provision is made for tuning the sections while evacuated and at a temperature of 113 f0.1 "F to simulate operating conditions. The SLAC tuning machine is instrumented to measure and record continuously the metal temperature at one position on a section. Periodic measurements of the temperature at other points on a section are also recorded. A schematic diagram of the reduced pressure boiling apparatus used to supply constant temperature water to the accelerator section being t ~ ~ n eisdshown in fig. 28.
-
LEGEND
---
COOLING
TUNING ROOM
WATER
OUT
WATER LINES VACUUM LINES CONTROL AIR LINES
'
EQUIPMENT ROOM
Fig. 28. Schematic diagram of the water temperature control system for the SLAC accelerator tuning machine.
A schematic diagram of the electronic portion of the SLAC accelerator tuning system is shown in fig. 29. The precision phase standard is a device which steps through, upon command, three pre-set positions in sequence giving phase reference for the movement of the shorting plunger through three cavities in the accelerator section under test. The phase bridge, utilizing a double side-band suppressed-carrier technique, compares the signal reflected from the calibrated reference branch with that from the movable short in the accelerator. This system, accurate to approximately 0.1 ", is not sensitive to changes in attenuation in either the test or reference branch.
298
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
After calibration of the branches of the phase bridge, the cavities are tuned by activating the hydraulic plungers and observing a direct-reading display of phase shift. Taking into account the permanent set characteristics of the copper cavity walls, the indentation continues until each cavity's phase shift does not deviate more than k2.5" from the desired value. Before tuning, the cavities were found to be
P
PRECISION MOVABLE SHORT WlTH THREE PRE-SET POSITIONS O., 120., 240.
TUNER
GENERATOR
STRIPLINE PHASE DEVIATION INDICATOR
1-
10 db DIRECTIONAL COUPLER
TUNER
TEST ACCELERATOR SECTION WlTH MOVABLE SHORT
Fig. 29. Schematic diagram of the electronic portion of the SLAC accelerator tuning machine.
+
+ AFTER TUNING
.. .....................:-. . ... ......... ....... ..... .....-
_ ........::.:..:
0 INPUT
10
20
30
40 50 CAVITY NUMBER
60
70
80 OUTPUT
Fig. 30. Accelerator structure tuning plot (typical) for both tuned and untuned SLAC accelerator sections. Conditions: Water temperature, inlet 113.1 OF, outlet 112.9OF, vacuum less than 25 microns, and frequency 2856 MHz.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
299
typically 10" too long, corresponding to their oversize construction. After tuning, the cavities were typically within f 1 " of the proper values as shown in fig. 30. A measuring station, used for quality control of the tuning operation performed in the machine described above, was established to monitor the phase length of each cavity, the gradient along the axis, the match of each coupler, and the attenuation of each cavity. A typical reflection-coefficient plot for an accelerator section is shown in fig. 31. Inspection of plots such as this reveals any internal mis-matches in a section and indicates cavity-by-cavity attenuation. Measurements at the quality control station were also made with the accelerator section evacuated and at the operating temperature of 1 13 0. l OF.
0
10
I
I
20
30
INPUT
I
40 50 C A V I T Y NUMBER
I
60
70
80 OUTPUT
Fig. 31. Typical input reflection coefficient plot using a movable short circuit for a tuned SLAC accelerator section. Conditions: water temperature, inlet 113.1 OF, outlet 112.9"F, vacuum less than 25 microns, and frequency 2856 MHz.
High power tests of accelerator sections
The SLAC accelerator sections were tested at high power levels (15 MW peak and 15 kW average) primarily to outgas them prior to installation into the accelerator system. The test stands used for this purpose were instrumented to measure several parameters of performance during and after the outgassing process. The rf input power is measured and recorded because the performance of each accelerator section must be assured over a wide range of power levels. Rf attenuation, phase shift and freedom from electrical discharge are all functions of the input rf power level. The electrical or multipactor discharge phenomenon is observed within the accelerator section particularly during the initial processing. Byproducts of this discharge are substantial outgassing and X-radiation, monitored at two points near the ends of the section.
300
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
This discharge is more pronounced in the region from about 150 to 200 kW peak power and prior to completion of the processing it is usually possible to get an increase in the gas pressure in the section by reducing the input rf power to this range. Processing continues until operation is possible with negligible outgassing or arcing at any power input up to the maximum available level. This typically requires less than one hour. The vacuum level in the accelerator at the end of the process is approximately I x lo-' torr at full operating power. The technique used in measurement of the rf attenuation of the accelerator sections during high power testing is shown in block diagram form in fig. 32. Precision variable attenuators are connected as shown to directional couplers at the input and
REFERENCE VOLTAGE DISPLAY ERROR VOLTAGE
DETECTOR AMPLIFIER
AMPLIFIER SERVO SYSTEM
t PRECISION VARIABLE ATTENUATOR HIGH POWER
]+\
---
t PRECISION VARIABLE ATTENUATOR
4
MICROWAVE SOURCE
A
-
-.-A+
DIRECTIONAL COUPLER
Fig. 32.
System
RF LOAD
ACCELERATOR SECTION UNDER T E S T
+-A-
DIRECTIONAL COUPLER
diagram for detection of changes in the attenuation of SLAC accelerator with the level of rf power.
sections
output ports of an accelerator section under test. A servo system adjusts the input attenuator to keep its signal output constant within 0.1 dB as the power into the accelerator section is varied. An attenuator at the output of the section is ganged to the input attenuator and tracks it within 0.1 dB. This second attenuator is coupled to a recorder. Variations in the attenuation of an accelerator section are thus observed as changes in the signal level at the output attenuator. High power processing continues until no variations greater than 0.2 dB are observed. The high power test facility is also equipped to measure the variation in phase shift through an accelerator section as the input power is changed. Signals sampled
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
301
from the input and output of the accelerator section are fed into the two ports of a slotted line terminated by well-matched impedances. A special carriage on the slotted line is provided with two probes axially displaced by a quarter guide wavelength. The pulsed outputs of the crystal detectors in these probes are fed into a gated differential amplifier where the gating period has a width of microsecond, adjustable to occur within the central portion of the 2.5 microsecond microwave pulses from the high power source. When the pulsed outputs of the crystal detectors are equal within the gating period, the output of this amplifier is zero. The output of the amplifier is used as an error signal to drive a servo system which moves the carriage along the slotted section. Movement of the carriage is thus proportional to changes in phase shift in the accelerator section resulting from variations in input power level. Processing is incomplete if any more than a one-quarter degree variation of phase shift is observed when changes in power level are made. Variations in phase greater than this amount are indications of multipactor phenomena.
+
5 Cooling and temperature control T o maintain the precise dimensions necessary for optimum operation of an accelerator, close temperature control during operation is required. Without close temperature control, the operating frequency must be varied to correct for the effects of input power, changes in beam loading or ambient temperature changes. The primary factors which affect the accelerator temperature include distribution of rf power loss, variation in the coolant temperature and characteristics of the heat transfer mechanism from the accelerator section. The operating temperature of an accelerator is generally determined by choosing the lowest temperature which is economically practical. The size of heat exchange equipment and the complexity of the cooling system increase with decrease in the operating temperature. The lowest possible temperature attainable without refrigeration is determined by the temperature differential required to remove the heat generated in an accelerator and by ambient temperature and humidity. The rf power loss determines the amount of heat generated in a n accelerator section. This loss occurs in a thickness in the cavity walls known as the skin depth. The temperature rise in the skin depth during the pulse in a pulsed accelerator is generally low for typical operating power levels. This temperature rise occurs in such a small volume that the accelerator cavity dimensions are not significantly affected. The cavity dimensions are determined by the volume-averaged cavity wall temperature. This temperature depends upon the coolant temperature and the temperature drops across the coolant film and across the cavity wall. In the SLAC accelerator, with approximately 13.5 kW of heat dissipation, the temperature drop through the wall is less than 4°F; it is 6 t ° F across the coolant film. A more significant temperature variation in the SLAC accelerator occurs circum-
302
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
ferentially. The wall temperature midway between cooling tubes is approximately 2°F higher than it is at a cooling tube. To maintain a constant temperature in the accelerator section, it is necessslry to decrease the temperature of the coolant as the rate of heat deposition increases. The distribution of heat deposition along an accelerating structure is determined by the type of structure. For example, in a structure with a constant gradient, the dissipation is uniform along the length while in a constant attenuation structure the heat deposition rate decreases exponentially from the rf input to the output. The temperature control systems for the accelerator must therefore be tailored to the type of structure to be cooled. When compensation is made for beam loading the heat deposition distribution will change, although this is generally a small effect. The efficiency of the heat removal system is affected by the intimacy of the contact between the coolant and the accelerator. If the contact is very intimate, then variations in contact will have small effect on the accelerator temperature. Coolant properties, the flow configuration, and corrosion product build-up on the surfaces all affect the heat transfer efficiency. The increase of temperature of the coolant as it flows along the accelerator must be considered. The coolant flow rate is determined by the need for temperature uniformity, the flow configuration, the cost of pumping, corrosion, and erosion. A high coolant flow rate will give a small coolant temperature rise. A high velocity will yield high heat transfer coefficients resulting in a small temperature drop between the surface being cooled and the coolant. On the other hand, high flow rates increase the pumping and heat exchanger costs and operating costs, and lead to the possibility of erosion. The most desirable and reliable heat transfer characteristics occur with turbulent flow - which generally means high velocities. Low velocities will generally result in poor heat transfer coefficients and may actually aggravate corrosion problems. The acceptable coolant velocity range depends on the coolant and materials used for construction of the flow passages. For water flowing over a relatively soft cuprous material surface, it is desirable to keep velocities below 7 feet per second to minimize erosion and above I foot per second to minimize the pitting type of corrosion associated with static water conditions. Water is generally used as a coolant because of its low cost. It is relatively stable in a radiation environment, has good heat transfer characteristics, and is not too corrosive. However, water dissociation by radiation to hydrogen peroxide and free hydrogen can lead to oxidation of water cooling passages. The liberation of free hydrogen may also create a safety problem. Along a well-aligned accelerator with low beam interception, radiation levels are usually low with little water dissociation. Induced radioactivity in the water is generally not a problem either. Other heat transfer fluids have been considered for cooling accelerators but economic considerations and the fear of radiation damage to the coolant have led to the widespread use of water.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
303
Historically, accelerator sections since the time of Slater and Hansen have required a cooling jacket of one type or another to remove the heat generated by rf losses. The early Stanford accelerator sections were cooled by water flowing through small tubing which was soft soldered to the outside surface of the section. CSF has cooled its accelerator sections by passing water through the alignment rods which serve to align the cavities and to clamp them together. In recent years, the desire for higher performance has required closer control of the accelerator section temperature. This has been achieved by using higher cooling water flow rates and by placing the cooling water into more intimate thermal contact with the accelerator structure. High flow rates and intimate contact have been attained by flowing the cooling water directly over the outside surfaces of the accelerator section. This technique was used in Stanford's medical accelerator and later in the Mark IV accelerator. Tn both cases, water flowed in an annular space between the accelerator section and a stainless steel jacket. Applied Radiation Corporation (see fig. 33) has used a similar annular water jacket on some of their accelerator sections. Caution must be used with this type of water jacket since overpressure may deform the walls of the cavities and thereby detune them.
Fig. 33. An accelerator constructed by Applied Radiation Corporation.
304
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
The SLAC water jacket The accelerator sections at SLAC are cooled by eight cooling tubes brazed longitudinally to the outside surface forming eight parallel flow passages. The eight coolingtube design was selected over the coaxial water-jacket design because it simplified construction and resulted in lower cost. It also provided the accessibility that was needed for tuning. The cooling tubes were made of OFHC@copper to allow the use of hydrogen brazing processes for attaching the tubes to the accelerator section. Heat generation along a constant gradient accelerator section is uniform. However, temperature uniformity requirements cannot readily be met by flowing cooling water along the accelerator section from one end to the other. A constant wall temperature can be maintained under this condition by varying the heat transfer characteristics along the cooling tubes. The appropriate variation can be obtained by varying the tube size or the tube-to-accelerator contact area along the accelerator section. An approximately constant temperature can be attained by using an extremely high flow rate. Such solutions are costly. Therefore, at SLAC, a counter-flow arrangement was developed with the tubes manifolded so that the flow through alternate tubes is in opposite directions. With this arrangement the temperature rise of the accelerator wall under one tube is compensated by the temperature rise in the opposite direction under adjacent tubes. This yields an average wall temperature in the longitudinal direction which is constant within 1 O F . To simplify the manifolding problem, each tube is bent unto a U or hairpin shape and the supply and return manifold connections are made at the center of the accelerator section. The cooling assembly is illustrated in fig. 34. Each accelerator section is supplied by water flowing at thirteen gallons per
Fig. 34. Cooling water tubes on a SLAC accelerator section. This configuration maintains a temperature along the constant-gradient accelerator section uniform within f0.6"F for fixed power input.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
305
minute. The accelerator operating temperature is maintained nominally at I 13 "F. For economic reasons temperature control of the accelerator sections by automatic adjustment of the inlet water temperature as a function of i n p ~ power ~t level was not provided. Instead the inlet water temperature is held constant, with provision made for manually adjusting the temperature. SLAC is operating at present with one klystron supplying power to four accelerator sections. Under this power input condition, the accelerator temperature varies by approximately 3 ' F from zero power to full power if the inlet water temperature is not varied with power level. The few accelerator sections which receive full klystron power are "metal temperature controlled", i.e., the water inlet temperature is adjusted automatically to maintain a constant accelerator section temperature. The design criteria and characteristics for the SLAC accelerator cooling system are listed tables 4 and 5. A copper, silver and indium alloy was used to braze the cooling system to the TABLE4 Water-jacket design criteria for the SLAC accelerator sections The water jacket shall be capable of removing up to 13.5 kW of heat from each ten-foot long by four-inch diameter accelerator section. The nominal accelerator operating temperature will be 113 "F (45°C). The temperature of each cavity shall be maintained within *0.6"F of the desired temperature. The longitudinal temperature variation shall not exceed the above limit at all heat dissipation levels from 0 to 13.5 kW. The longitudinal heat input distribution is uniform, corresponding to a constant gradient accelerator section. The water flow rate through each accelerator section water jacket will be constant at 13 gallons per minute. The water jacket must allow space for the input and output waveguide and for tuning and yet be able to remove the heat generated in each cavity of the section. The water jacket must operate reliably and without maintenance for at least ten years.
Water-jacket characteristics for the SLAC accelerator 5ections - -- - - -
--
-
Eight OFHC" copper cooling tubes, &inch outside diameter by 0.080-inch thick wall bent into the shape of a hairpin are used. The cooling tubes are brazed to the outside of the accelerator section using a 24.0 U/;; copper, inch along the full length 61.5 % silver and 14.5 % indium alloy. The width of the braze joint is of each tube. The cooling tubes are manifolded at the center of each accelerator section creating eight parallel flow passages. The cooling water velocity is six feet per second and the Reynolds' number is 20000. The pressure drop is 2 psi. The cooling water temperature rise is 7.1 "F and the accelerator section average to water inlet temperature difference is 1 1 "F when the accelerator section receives full klystron power.
306
A.L. ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
accelerator sections. Each of the U shaped cooling tubes was bent and machined to conform to the curvature of the accelerator section outside diameter. In this way, a uniform 2%-inch-wide braze joint was obtained between the cooling tube and the accelerator section. Two cooling tubes are supplied with water from each feed tube coming from the manifold. Each manifold supplies water to four feed tubes. The water flow from the manifold divides in a tee and one half goes to each cooling tube. While the velocity in the co'oling tubes is approximately six feet per second, it is not possible to maintain a velocity which will not lead to erosion in the tees. To give the tees a hard erosion resistant surface, they were electroless nickel plated and fired prior to installation in the water-jacket assembly. Connections to the input and output manifolds are made by flexible metal hose to minimize the possibility of external forces being applied to the accelerator section. The SLAC accelerator cooling system consists of two water circuits. The primary cooling water circulates in a closed system and cools the accelerator sections. A secondary circuit cools the primary circuit water and is in turn cooled in a cooling tower. The two circuit cooling system was chosen so that any radioactivity in the cooling water would be contained. A closed system also makes the maintenance of high purity water easier. Cooling water for the SLAC accelerator is maintained at a high degree of purity and cleanliness by filtering and demineralizing. Distilled and demineralized water is used for makeup. Specific conductivity readings of water samples taken from the SLAC accelerator cooling system have been found to be approximately 5 megohmcentimeters. It is believed that the low conductivity values are obtained through the use of compatible materials in the water cooling system, by filtering and by demineralizing. It is felt that only by this means can corrosion and the formation of scale deposits be reduced to a minimum. The eight cooling-tube design was verified by experiment to be adequate to maintain the accelerator section temperature at the desired uniformity.
6 Support structures In a multi-section accelerator, the support structure must allow for the alignment and support of each accelerator section. In the CSF design (see Jean [1963]) rods provide the cavity-to-cavity alignment. The rods are, in turn, supported at intervals from a concentric cylinder which serves both as a strongback and as the vacuum envelope. The cylinder is supported on screw jacks. Horizontal adjustment is provided by a cross-slide. The jacks themselves, provide vertical adjustment. The Varian accelerator sections are supported by a concentric cylindrical strongback which also serves as the vacuum envelope. The accelerator sections are sup-
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
307
ported from the strongback by means of screws. The screws are used to align the accelerator section within the strongback. Alignment is made optically to a wire stretched tightly on the axis of the accelerator section. The screws are welded to the strongback to form a vacuum tight enclosure after the accelerator section has been aligned within the strongback. Completed assemblies, when used in a multi-section machine, are s~~pported on jacks and are aligned using optical tooling. In Stanford's early machines, cavity-to-cavity alignment and sub-section straightness was achieved by machining accurately the inside diameter of the tube into which the disks were placed. Reamed holes and mating dowels, accurately located in the flanges of each sub-section provided the alignment of adjacent ends of sub-sections. Sub-sections were held firmly together by means of four stainless steel tie rods which were secured in the couplers at each end of an accelerator section. Turnbuckles were used to adjust the tension in the tie rods. The accelerator sections were supported on an I-beam by means of cradles at each sub-section flange. These cradles supported the weight of the accelerator sub-sections, but did not otherwise constrain them, allowing free expansion with changes in thermal conditions. The I-beams were supported on steel columns which were imbedded in concrete four feet below the laboratory floor. In order to prevent shifting of the accelerator due to distortion of the floor from the weight of concrete shielding blocks, the steel
HOR. a V E R T ADJUSTING MECHANISM
6 " DIA. S T E E L PlPE
LABORATORY FLOOR
CORRUGATED PlPE
EARTH F I L L CONCRETE
STABILIZING F I N S
Fig. 35. Diagram of the Stanford Mark 111 accelerator mounting supports illustrating the method of isolating the supports of the accelerator from the laboratory floor.
308
A.L. ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
columns were isolated from the floor and earth immediately under the floor. The I-beam position was made adjustable both horizontally and vertically by means of screws. A cross-sectional view of such a support is shown in fig. 35. The overall alignment of Stanford's Mark 111 accelerator was originally done by placing an illuminated target in each coupler in succession and sighting down the beam line on the target with a transit. Subsequent realignment was made by measuring from the outside surface of the accelerator sections to a wire tightly stretched parallel to the accelerator axis. The catenary sag was computed for each measurement location and a correction applied to the vertical measurement. OUTPUT WAVEGUIDE
Fig. 36. Illustration of the SLAC ten-foot accelerator section and strongback assembly.
The disks and cylinders for the SLAC accelerator sections are machined so that the inside and outside diameters are concentric within 0.0005 inch. As described earlier, the parts are stacked in a V-block, thereby providing alignment between adjacent cavities. As a result of brazing, the accelerator sections are fully annealed and are so weak that they cannot support their own weight when mounted horizontally. Therefore, immediately after attachment of the water cooling tubes, the ten-foot sections are permanently mounted onto their supporting structure. The supporting structure consists of a strongback and mounting brackets which attach the accelerator section to the strongback at four points. The strongback and mounting brackets are designed to protect the accelerator sections and their input and output waveguides
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
B.2.2
309
both during processing of the accelerator sections and in the final installation. The support structure has to accommodate forces caused by movement of the input waveguide relative t o the accelerator which might result from earth movement. The supporting structure is shown schematically in fig. 36. The design criteria for the accelerator supporting structure are listed in table 6. Differential thermal expansion between the accelerator sections and its supporting structure could cause high stresses and subsequent deformation in the accelerator. T o minimize such stresses the supporting brackets which tie the accelerator section to the strongback are made to be flexible in the direction of the accelerator axis. These flexible supports, however, have to be stiff in the transverse directions to carry transverse loads from the waveguide with a minimum of deflection. Aluminum was chosen as the support structure material because it is non-magnetic, has good fabricating qualities, and is reasonable in cost. The strongback is extruded from 6063 alloy and then heat-treated. The end support bracket assemblies are made of a support clamp, a mounting plate and a flexible section. The support clamp grasps the ends of the accelerator section and extends out to support the waveguide flanges and thereby transmit external forces directly t o the strongback. The flexible section consisted of two flexible aluminum sheets riveted to upper and lower mounting blocks and a spring-tempered phosphor bronze plate column. Such a n assembly is shown schematically in fig. 37. The plate column ends are rounded so that the column TABLE 6 Design criteria for SLAC accelerator support structure -
1 . The structure shall be made of non-magnetic material. 2. The structure shall be maintenance free. 3. The structure shall support a 10-foot-long accelerator section in the correct position within ! 0.010 inch vertically and :i-_0.008inch horizontally and shall not permit a twist of the section greater than 0.2 milliradian during operation. 4. The structure shall satisfy criterion 3 under the following loads o n the accelerator section. a. !- 500 pounds vertically b. : 300 pounds horizontally c. - 7600-inch pound moment about the accelerator axis 5. The structure shall satisfy criterion 3 while allowing for a & 0.275-inch differential thermal expansion in the axial direction between the accelerator section and its strongback. 6. During handling and installation, the axial differential expansion could be as great as A0.375 inch. The loads in 4 above should not produce deflections greater than twice those given in 3 above. 7. The supports are to be capable of withstanding shock loads of two times the static design loads without permanent deformation. 8. All supports shall be elastic so that after being subjected to the most severe conditions above, the structure would always return to its original position after removing the loads. 9. The supports shall satisfy all the above criteria after 600 differential thermal expansion cycles of 0.375 inch. 10. The axial force on the accelerator section, as produced by a resisting force to the 0.375-inch deflection, shall not exceed 750 pounds. 11. Each ten-foot-long accelerator assembly shall provide accurate and easily accessible reference points for alignment of the accelerator sections on a 40-foot long girder.
+
310
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
can roll on mounting blocks. The column is inserted with a compressive preload to insure that there will be no separation between the plate column and the mounting blocks when a transverse force which tends to twist the accelerator section is applied at the waveguide flange. The mounting plates for the end supports are bolted to the ends of the strongback. The mounting plate at one end of each accelerator section contains holes for holding optical alignment targets. Prior to assembly onto the strongback the optical tooling holes and the four-inch hole for clamping around the accelerator section were jig bored, thereby assuring accurate location with respect to the accelerator section. The intermediate supports each contain a flexible section similar to that used in the end supports. They bolt to the water-jacket spacer ring and to the strongback. 0.375 INCH MAXIMUM A X I A L DEFLECTION
PLATE COLUMN
F L E X I B L E SHEET
LOWER MOUNTING BLOCK
Fig. 37. Illustration of the SLAC flexible support assembly used to compensate for relative length changes between the accelerator and its supports along the direction of the beam.
At assembly, the accelerator ends are mounted on their support brackets and the intermediate support brackets are adjusted until the four accelerator section support points are in line within 0.002 inch. The full length of the accelerator was found to lie within k0.010 inch. For a complete description of the SLAC accelerator section support structure, see Skarpaas [1967]. Four accelerator sections are placed end-to-end on a 40-foot long support girder.
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
311
Fig. 38. SLAC accelerator sections mounted on a support girder. The sections are first aligned with respect to the girder and then the girder is aligned by means of the jackscrews and Fresnel zone-plate to a laser beam. The support girders are evacuated.
312
A.L.ELDREDGE ET AL.
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
The accelerator section ends are aligned relative to each other by means of a ring which fits into a groove machined to be concentric with the beam hole at each end of the accelerator sections. A four-telescope stand and a matching four-alignment target stand is used to locate the accelerator sections on the girder in the correct position relative to a laser alignment target located inside the girder. Two telescopes sighting onto alignment targets placed in the optical tooling holes of the accelerator sections are used to place the accelerator sections in a straight line. The position of the accelerator sections on the support girder is adjusted both horizontally and vertically by means of screws. A complete assembly on its support girder is illustrated in fig. 38. When installed in the Accelerator Housing, the girders are supported on jacks. The floor jacks carry the weight of the girder and allow vertical adjustments to be made. A wall jack anchors the girder to the wall to provide both longitudinal and transverse stability. The correct girder position is determined by a laser alignment system as described by Herrmannsfeldt et al. [1968]. A complete description of the accelerator assembly and installation process can be found in Lisin [1967].
References BAREFORD, C. F., and M. G. KELLIHER, 1953, Philips Tech. Rev. 15, 1-26. BECKER, G. E., and D. A. CASWELL, 1951, Rev. Sci. Instr. 22, 402-405. G. A. LOEW,and R. B. NEAL,1966, In: Young, L., ed., Advances BORGHI, R. P., A. L. ELDREDGE, in Microwaves 1 (Academic Press, New York and London), pp. 1-73. BORGHI, R. P., and D. H. JEONG,1963, Gradient Measurements for the SLAC Accelerator Structure, Report No. SLAC-TN-63-60,Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California. B u s c ~ , T . ,1966, Fundamentals of Dimensional Metrology (Delmar Publishers, Inc., Albany, New York). R. L. KYHL,R. B. NEAL,and W. K. H. PANOFSKY, CHODOROW, M., E. L. GINZTON, W. W. HANSEN, 1955, Rev. Sci. Instr. 26, 134-204. CHU,E. L., 1951, The Theory of Linear Electron Accelerators, Report No. 140, Microwave Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, California. CHU,E. L. and E. L. GINZTON,1955, Choice of Wavelength and Characteristic Parameters in the Design of Linear Electron Accelerators, Report No. 274, Microwave Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, California. DEMOS, P. T., A. F. KIP, and J. C. SLATER, 1952, J. Appl. Phys. 23, 53-65. FRY,D. W., 1952, Philips Tech. Rev. 14, 1-32. FRY,D. W., R. B. R. SHERSBY-HARVIE, L. B. MULLETT,and W. WALKINSHAW, 1947, Nature 160, 351-353. 1948-9, Reports on Progress in Physics 12, 102-132. FRY,D. W., and W. WALKINSHAW, GALLAGHER, W. J., 1960, Measurement Techniques for Periodic Structures, M Report No. 205, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California. GINZTON, E. L., 1957, Microwave Measurements (McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., New York). GINZTON, E. L., W. W. HANSEN, and W. R. KENNEDY, 1948, Rev. Sci. Instr. 19, 89-108. HAIMSON, J., 1965, Nucl. Instr. and Methods 33, 93-106. HERRMANNSFELDT, W. B., M. J. LEE,J. SPRANZA, and K. TRIGGER, 1968, Applied Optics 7,995-1005. IKEDA, S., Y. OTSUBO, and Y. 1 1 ~ 01968, , Mitsubishi Denki Giho 42, 287-292. JEAN,R., 1961, Accel6rateurs Lintaires d'Electrons, Centre de Physique Electronique et Corpusculaire, Compagnie Generale de Telegraphic Sans Fil, 91 - Orsay, France.
B.2.2
ACCELERATING STRUCTURES
313
JEAN,R., 1963, L'Onde Electrique 63, 623-631. KNAPP,E. A., B. C. KNAPP,and J. M. POTTER,1968, Rev. Sci. Instr. 39, 979-991. LEBOUTET, H., 1963, L'Onde Electrique 63, 599. LISIN,A. V., 1967, Girder Assembly and Installation, Report No. SLAC-TN-67-17, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California. MALLORY, K . B., 1955, A Comparison of the Predicted and Observed Performances of a Billion-Volt Electron Accelerator, HEPL Report No. 46, High Energy Physics Lab, Stanford University, Stanford, California. MILLER, C. W., 1954, Inst. Elect. Eng. Proc. 101, Pt. 1, 207-219. MILLER, C. W., 1953, Nature 171, 297-298. MULLETT, L. B., and B. G . LOACH,1948, Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) 61, 271-284. NEAL,R. B., 1953, A High Energy Linear Electron Accelerator, Report No. 185, Microwave Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, California, pp. 255-266. NISHIKAWA, T., 1964, Fabrication and Measuring Methods for Disk-Loaded Waveguides, Minutes of the 1964 Linear Accelerator Conference, Midwestern Universities Research Association, pp. 75-83. POLK,L., 1955, A Review of Pneumatic Dimensional Gages, Proceedings of the Symposium on Engineering Dimensional Metrology (London, 1955), pp. 205-224. POPE,J. A,, 1957, Plating 44, 1291-1296. POST,R. F., 1950, A 50-MeV Linear Electron Accelerator (Doctoral Dissertation), Stanford University, Stanford, California. POST,R. F., and N . S. SHIREN,1955, Rev. Sci. Instr. 26, 205-209. SHERSBY-HARVIE, R. B. R., 1948, Nature 162, 890. R . B. R., 1948, Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) 61, 255-270. SHERSBY-HARVIE, SHERSBY-HARVIE, R. B. R., and L. B. MULLETT,1949, Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) 62, 270-271. SKARPAAS, K., 1967, Elasticity Theory and Design of Flexible Supports for the Stanford Two-Mile Linear Accelerator, Report No. SLAC-TN-67-9, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California. J. C., 1948, Rev. Mod. Phys. 20, 473-518. SLATER, J., 1961, J. Phys. Soc. Japan 16, 2081-2090. TANAKA, J . , T. NISHIKAWA, A. MIYAHARA, K. KOBAYASHI, M. ARATANI, S. HIRATA,E. YAMAZAKI, TANAKA, K. KONDO,S. IKEDA, and M. KAWASHIMA, 1962, Applied Physics in Japan 31, 146-154. E., 1963, Microwave Impedance Matching of Feed Waveguides to the Disk-Loaded WESTBROOK, Accelerator Structure Operating in the 2n/3 Mode, Report No. SLAC-TN-63-103, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford University, Stanford, California.
ELA T E C H N O L O G Y
B.2
Radiofrequency Problems *
2.3
H. HOGG J. V. LEBACQZ
I I
Stanford Linear Accelerator Center Stanford, California. U.S.A.
Introduction
Chapters B. I . I-B. I .S have dealt with the interaction between charged particles and the rf fields propagating along linear accelerator structures. In this chapter we shall be concerned with the problems involved in supplying rf power to the accelerating structures. The first part of the chapter will be devoted t o a general discussion of power requirements, types of rf sources and power amplifiers. rf stability considerations, phasing requirements and phasing systems which are presently in use. The latter part of the chapter will consider in more detail some of the specialized problems of low-, medium- and high-energy machines, and will describe the solutions adopted on some machines.
2 Power requirements Under negligible beam-loading conditions, the energy transferred to optirnallyphased electrons in a linear accelerator is given by
Vo = K, (P,L~,)+
(1)
where K, is a constant whose value will be discussed below, PT is the total rf input power, L is the total accelerator length and r, is the shunt impedance per unit length.
* Work supported
b y the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission.
,O ~Vorth-Holland Publ. Co., Amsterdam I969
References p. 353
315
H.HOGG, J.V.LEBACQZ
316
ELECTRON LINACS: TECHNOLOGY
When the electron current is significant, the reduction in available energy due to beam loading must be taken into account. More exact formulations for two special cases are worthy of note. These are (i) the constant impedance accelerator structure (in which all cavities forming the periodic slow-waveguide structure have identical dimensions) and (ii) the constant gradient accelerator structure, wherein cavity dimensions are tapered in such a manner that the axial fields of the space harmonic which interacts cumulatively with the electron beam remain constant along the length of the accelerator. Neal [I9611 has shown that, for the constant impedance structure,
v = (~T)+(P,L~,)*[{1 - exp(-
z)}/z]- iroL [ l - (1 - exp(- z)}/z]
and for the constant gradient structure,
V
=
(1 - exp (- ~ T ) ) * ( P , L ~ , ) + $ir,L [ l - (25 exp(- 22))/{1- exp ( - 22))] (3)
where i is the peak beam current and z is the attenuation parameter, equal to the voltage attenuation per unit length multiplied by the length of accelerator between successive rf feed points. Equations (2) and (3) permit the calculation of the total rf input power requirements, once the basic beam energy and beam current specifications have been set, and the type of accelerating structure has been decided upon. Energy and current specifications depend upon the research applications of the accelerator and upon economic and land-availability boundary conditions. Most electron accelerators use diskloaded circular waveguide as the accelerator structure. Prior to the construction of the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC), an extensive investigation of alternative slow-waveguiding structures was made. In all cases examined, it was found that high values of r , could be obtained only at the cost of high group velocity v,. This is undesirable, for reasons which will be discussed below. Moreover, the disk-loaded waveguide has the advantages of mechanical rigidity, good thermal dissipation, and relative ease of fabrication. For a detailed discussion of accelerating structures, the reader is referred to ch. B. 1.1. However, those parameters which are most influential in the determination of rf power requirements will be briefly mentioned here. A high value of shunt impedance r, is always desirable. Since r, varies directly as the square-root of frequency, power economy is improved by making the operating frequency as high as possible. The filling time t, of an accelerator section is proportional to f -". Therefore, higher rf frequencies reduce t, and increase the duration of the rf pulse length available for electron acceleration. On the other hand, accelerator cavity dimensions scale inversely with frequency, making the aperture available for the beam progressively smaller as the frequency is raised, so that alignment, steering and focusing problems rapidly become prohibitively difficult in a long machine.
B.2.3
RADIOFREQUENCY PROBLEMS
317
Considerations of paramount importance in the choice of operating frequency are the availability. cost, and reliability of oscillators o r amplifiers at the required frequency and power levels. In a long machine, the power input at each accelerator feedpoint which is required to achieve a given beam energy depends on the spacing between the feed-points. This spacing is determined by the choice of attenuation parameter z. In its turn, T is selected after consideration of its effect on a number of accelerator performance factors. Lower values of T increase the conversion efficiency of rf power to beam power, and decrease the beam-loading derivative, the filling time, the energy lost by the beam in traversing a n idle accelerator section and the energy sensitivity to frequency shifts (Neal [1961]). Increasing z raises the beam energy. A compromise choice has therefore to be made. In a radiographic machine, special criteria apply for optimizing T to yield maximum X-ray output. Once T has been decided upon, the length between feed-points is determined from the value of the voltage attenuation coefficient for the structure to be used. This coefficient, which is inversely proportional t o the group velocity, should be high enough to ensure that the rf power requirement per feed-point is a practicable quantity i.e., at the chosen operating frequency, the peak power, pulse length and pulse repetition frequency should lie comfortably within the state-of-the-art performance contours for the type of amplifier to be used. Additionally, of course, the power should not be so high as to cause breakdown problems in the feed line or the front of the accelerator structure itself. The adoption of a high attenuation coefficient (and therefore low group velocity) also has the advantage of increasing the shunt impedance and therefore the beam energy achieved. There are other boundary conditions to be considered, however. It is in general more economical t o use a small number of high power amplifiers than a large number of low power amplifiers. The cost reduction per megawatt applies not only to the amplifier tubes themselves, but also to associated equipment, such as modulators, instrumentation and waveguide. Notwithstanding the increase in conversion efficiency, close-spacing of accelerator feed-points is limited by considerations of increased costs imposed by the need for larger numbers of components, and increased complexity of construction and operation. The foregoing remarks point up some of the many interrelated factors to be considered in arriving at a preliminary estimate of the rf power requirements of a linear accelerator. In many cases analytical optimization is not possible; selections depend on experience and engineering judgment. However, many precedents have been set by the larger machines in operation around the world today. The most important relates to the selection of S-band (around 3 GHz) as the operating frequency band. There are many reasons for this choice, including power breakdown levels in waveguide, the ratio of wavelength to standard machining tolerances, the wealth of experience accrued in radar development, and the pioneering work on S-band linear accelerators done by W. W. Hansen and his associates at Stanford. -
318
H.HOGG,
J.V.LEBACQZ
ELECTRON
LINACS:
TECHNOLOGY
3 ” Power sources The choice of rf power sources for use in linear accelerators depends upon many factors. Among these are frequency of operation of the machine, requirements of peak and average power, and requirements of stability. In the case of amplifiers, the gain of the source is also an important factor in the overall design of the machine, and should be taken into account in preliminary investigations. In addition to these general requirements, there are also practical considerations which may influence the selection of one type ofrf source against another. Among these should be included tube efficiency, overall system efficiency, tube and system reliability, and the probable effect of the type of tube on overall system cost, both initial and operational. In general, three classes of amplifiers can be considered for use with electron linacs (the case of protons is discussed in ch. C.2.3 and C.3.2): triodes, amplitrons, and klystrons. The magnetron is also used as a power source in linear accelerators, but generally its use is limited to single section machines since the magnetron is an oscillator and cannot readily be phase-locked with other magnetrons. The basic characteristics of these four types of tubes as they apply to linear accelerators are reviewed below. 3.1 Magnetrons
.
A magnetron is an rf oscillator consisting of a cylindrical cathode mounted coaxially inside a cylindrical anode. A coupled-cavity resonant circuit is machined around the inner surface of the anode cylinder. In operation, the superposition of rf fields upon a uniform axial magnetic field and a dc radial electric field between cathode and anode results in the buildup of a rotating electron cloud which transfers the dc energy to the rf fields in the cavities, and hence to the load. ‘+ The magnetron has the high efficiency of crossed-field devices, dc to rf conversion &@ciencies being typically between 50% and 60%. As mentioned above, however, it ,,ha,s some of the basic disadvantages of loaded oscillators, making it difficult to I achieve adequate stability of power and frequency. Various means such as strapping d.,:the cavities have been devised to improve stability. In general, however, the output .,frequency is sensitive to both anode current and output load characteristics. By careful. choice of the operating conditions - magnetic field, anode voltage and anode c&?&t - it is possible to obtain frequency stabilities between 40 and 80 kHz for magnetrons operating in the 3000 MHz range with power outputs up to 4 MW at duty cycles of approximately 0.001. Many magnetrons are mechanically tunable, permitting the use of a slow AFC system to maintain the correct accelerator operating frequency as load conditions or attitude are changed (as, for instance, is the case for radiographic and medical machines which may be designed to be rotated).
8.2.3
RADIOFREQUENCY
PROBLEMS
319
3.2 Triodes Triodes can be used as amplifiers, but their practical range of operation in the megawatt region is probably limited to less than 800 MHz, although some triodes with inbuilt cavities (coaxitrons) show promise for long pulse operation at these power and frequency levels. Generally, however, triodes are employed only in very low frequency applications (80 to 200 MHz). Triode systems show good efficiency, but the gain is usually low (IO to 1.5 dB per stage). The phase and amplitude stability are good.
3.3 Amplitrons The amplitron is an efficient crossed-field amplifier with high phase stability. It consists essentially of a digital line anode wrapped around a cylindrical cathode. The electron cloud filling the interaction space between cathode and anode resembles that of a magnetron. The interaction efficiency is very high, and overall amplitron efficiencies between 60::) and 80% have been reported. The phase stability of the device is generally excellent. being of the order of less than + degree per percent variation in beam current. The total phase shift with beam on and off is only 10” to 25”, depending on the specific design. Unfortunately, the amplitron suffers from several major disadvantages when considered for use in linear accelerators. Drive signals can propagate through the line with only minimal attenuation when the beam voltage is not applied. Similarly, the reflected energy from the load can also travel backwards through the amplitron and a