Lecture Notes in Physics Editorial Board R. Beig, Wien, Austria W. Beiglb¨ock, Heidelberg, Germany W. Domcke, Garching, Germany B.-G. Englert, Singapore U. Frisch, Nice, France P. H¨anggi, Augsburg, Germany G. Hasinger, Garching, Germany K. Hepp, Z¨urich, Switzerland W. Hillebrandt, Garching, Germany D. Imboden, Z¨urich, Switzerland R. L. Jaffe, Cambridge, MA, USA R. Lipowsky, Golm, Germany H. v. L¨ohneysen, Karlsruhe, Germany I. Ojima, Kyoto, Japan D. Sornette, Nice, France, and Los Angeles, CA, USA S. Theisen, Golm, Germany W. Weise, Garching, Germany J. Wess, M¨unchen, Germany J. Zittartz, K¨oln, Germany
The Editorial Policy for Edited Volumes The series Lecture Notes in Physics (LNP), founded in 1969, reports new developments in physics research and teaching - quickly, informally but with a high degree of quality. Manuscripts to be considered for publication are topical volumes consisting of a limited number of contributions, carefully edited and closely related to each other. Each contribution should contain at least partly original and previously unpublished material, be written in a clear, pedagogical style and aimed at a broader readership, especially graduate students and nonspecialist researchers wishing to familiarize themselves with the topic concerned. For this reason, traditional proceedings cannot be considered for this series though volumes to appear in this series are often based on material presented at conferences, workshops and schools.
Acceptance A project can only be accepted tentatively for publication, by both the editorial board and the publisher, following thorough examination of the material submitted. The book proposal sent to the publisher should consist at least of a preliminary table of contents outlining the structure of the book together with abstracts of all contributions to be included. Final acceptance is issued by the series editor in charge, in consultation with the publisher, only after receiving the complete manuscript. Final acceptance, possibly requiring minor corrections, usually follows the tentative acceptance unless the final manuscript differs significantly from expectations (project outline). In particular, the series editors are entitled to reject individual contributions if they do not meet the high quality standards of this series. The final manuscript must be ready to print, and should include both an informative introduction and a sufficiently detailed subject index.
Contractual Aspects Publication in LNP is free of charge. There is no formal contract, no royalties are paid, and no bulk orders are required, although special discounts are offered in this case. The volume editors receive jointly 30 free copies for their personal use and are entitled, as are the contributing authors, to purchase Springer books at a reduced rate. The publisher secures the copyright for each volume. As a rule, no reprints of individual contributions can be supplied.
Manuscript Submission The manuscript in its final and approved version must be submitted in ready to print form. The corresponding electronic source files are also required for the production process, in particular the online version. Technical assistance in compiling the final manuscript can be provided by the publisher‘s production editor(s), especially with regard to the publisher’s own LATEX macro package which has been specially designed for this series.
LNP Homepage (springerlink.com) On the LNP homepage you will find: −The LNP online archive. It contains the full texts (PDF) of all volumes published since 2000. Abstracts, table of contents and prefaces are accessible free of charge to everyone. Information about the availability of printed volumes can be obtained. −The subscription information. The online archive is free of charge to all subscribers of the printed volumes. −The editorial contacts, with respect to both scientific and technical matters. −The author’s / editor’s instructions.
A.C. Kalloniatis D.B. Leinweber A.G. Williams (Eds.)
Lattice Hadron Physics
123
Editors Alex C. Kalloniatis Derek B. Leinweber Anthony G. Williams University of Adelaide School of Chemistry & Physics Adelaide SA 5005 Australia
A. Kalloniatis D. Leinweber A. Williams (Eds.), Lattice Hadron Physics, Lect. Notes Phys. 663 (Springer, Berlin Heidelberg 2005), DOI 10.1007/b103529
Library of Congress Control Number: 2004115525 ISSN 0075-8450 ISBN-10 3-540-23911-1 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN-13 978-3-540-23911-6 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springeronline.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2005 Printed in The Netherlands The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting: Camera-ready by the authors/editor Data conversion by TechBooks Cover design: design & production, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper 54/3141/jl - 5 4 3 2 1 0
Preface
This year marks 30 years since Ken Wilson’s seminal paper of October 1974 formulating non-Abelian gauge theory on a space-time lattice, and proposing its application to the solution of the theory of quark-gluon dynamics, QCD. Since then the field has become vast, with several major symposia and workshops per year on the field of lattice gauge theory. In particular, the 1990s brought overlap fermions and improved operators which overcame two of the major hurdles of lattice field theory – chirality on the lattice and suppression of discretisation errors. It is now a daunting prospect for someone outside the field to quickly become literate and active in the area. The present volume in Lecture Notes in Physics attempts to overcome this state of affairs. In their earliest form, the various contributions in this volume were first presented by their authors in July 2001 at the international workshop on lattice hadron physics, LHP2001, in Cairns, Australia, under the auspices of the Centre for the Subatomic Structure of Matter based at the University of Adelaide in South Australia. Those conference contributions, and those of the other participants at LHP2001 have been presented elsewhere. Nevertheless those participants selected to extend their papers for this volume have put considerable effort into shaping the contributions to be accessible both pedagogically, as well as up to date in light of developments since 2001. They represent a broad spectrum of workers in hadronic physics, from graduate students to senior researchers of many years of experience and a solid body of significant work in hadronic physics. The hope is that precisely this mix of newcomers and established experts in the field has enhanced the pedagogical value of the volume. Thematically, this series of lectures draws upon the developments made in recent years in implementing chirality on the lattice via the overlap formalism, exploiting chiral effective field theory in order to extrapolate lattice results to physical quark masses, new forms of improving operators to remove lattice artefacts, analytical studies of finite volume effects in hadronic observables, studies of quark propagators on the lattice, and state of the art lattice calculations of excited resonances, including the heavy pseudoscalar eta and eta-prime mesons. We trust that these contributions will assist graduate students and experienced researchers in other areas of hadronic physics to appreciate, if not become active in, contemporary lattice gauge theory and it’s application to hadronic phenomena. We thank the contributing authors for the efforts they put in and
VI
Preface
their patience as this volume was put together, and warmly thank John Hedditch for his assistance in the final stages of compilation. Adelaide, January 2005
Alex Kalloniatis Derek Leinweber Tony Williams
Contents
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum C. Allton . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 1 The Quenched Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 2 Results from the Quenched Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 3 Results from Full (Unquenched) Simulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 4 Quantifying Quenching Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 5 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications P.O. Bowman, U.M. Heller, D.B. Leinweber, A.G. Williams, and J.B. Zhang . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Euclidean Green’s Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Gauge Fixing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Staggered Quark Actions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 The Lattice Quark Propagator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Analysis of Lattice Artefacts for Staggered Quarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Overlap Quark Actions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Analysis of Lattice Artefacts for Overlap Quarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 The Quark Propagator in Landau Gauge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Laplacian Gauge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Applications: The Condensate and Running Mass . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Modelling the Mass Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Generalised Spin Projection for Fermion Actions W. Kamleh . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Standard Spin-Projection Trick . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Generalised Spin-Projection Trick . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 The FLIC Fermion Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
17 17 18 23 26 30 32 38 42 47 49 51 56 59 61 65 65 65 66 67 68 69
VIII
Contents
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD D.B. Leinweber, W. Melnitchouk, D.G. Richards, A.G. Williams, and J.M. Zanotti . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction and Motivation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 History of Lattice N ∗ Calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Lattice Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Interpolating Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Operators for Spin- 12 and Spin- 32 Baryons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Survey of Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Appendix − Correlation Matrix Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
71 71 74 75 78 82 92 104 105 110
Hadron Structure and QCD: Effective Field Theory for Lattice Simulations D.B. Leinweber, A.W. Thomas, and R.D. Young . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Effective Field Theory for QCD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Chiral Expansion of the Nucleon Mass . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Other Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
113 113 114 118 123 127 128
Lattice Chiral Fermions from Continuum Defects H. Neuberger . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Infinite Flavor Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Two Dimensional Flavor Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Compactifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Generalization of the Overlap . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 What Next? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
131 131 131 133 141 143 144 144
The Computation of the η and η Mesons in Lattice QCD K. Schilling, H. Neff, and T. Lippert . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Prolegomena: Pseudoscalars in LQCD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 The Real World with n¯ n s¯ s Mixing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 The Three Computational Bottlenecks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Towards Realistic Physics Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
147 147 149 154 157 165 173 174
Contents
IX
Strong and Weak Interactions in a Finite Volume M. Testa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Summation Theorems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 The L¨ uscher Quantization Condition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Matrix Elements of Scalar Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 The Nature of the LL Relation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Summation Theorems, Locality and the LL Formula . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
177 177 179 183 190 191 192 194 197
Hadron Properties with FLIC Fermions J.M. Zanotti, D.B. Leinweber, W. Melnitchouk, A.G. Williams, and J.B. Zhang . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 The Lattice Quark Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Fat-Link Irrelevant Fermion Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Lattice Simulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Scaling of FLIC Fermions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Search for Exceptional Configurations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Octet-Decuplet Mass Splittings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
199 199 200 205 208 210 215 218 223 223
Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 227
List of Contributors
Chris Allton Department of Physics University of Wales Swansea Swansea SA28PP, U.K
[email protected] Patrick Bowman Indiana University Nuclear Theory Center 2401 Milo B. Sampson Lane Bloomington, Indiana 47408, USA
[email protected] Urs M. Heller American Physical Society One Research Road Box 9000 Ridge, NY 11961-9000, USA
[email protected] Alex Kalloniatis Special Research Center for the Subatomic Structure of Matter Department of Physics University of Adelaide Adelaide 5005, Australia
[email protected] Waseem Kamleh Special Research Center for the Subatomic Structure of Matter Department of Physics University of Adelaide Adelaide 5005, Australia
[email protected]
Derek B. Leinweber Special Research Center for the Subatomic Structure of Matter Department of Physics University of Adelaide Adelaide 5005, Australia
[email protected] Thomas Lippert Wuppertal University D42097 Wuppertal Germany
[email protected]. uni-wuppertal.de Wally Melnitchouk Jefferson Lab 12000 Jefferson Avenue Newport News, VA 23606 and Centre for the Subatomic Structure of Matter University of Adelaide Adelaide 5005, Australia
[email protected] Hartmut Neff Department of Physics Boston University Boston MA02215, USA
[email protected] Herbert Neuberger School of Natural Sciences Institute for Advanced Study Princeton, NJ 08540
XII
List of Contributors
and Rutgers University Department of Physics and Astronomy Piscataway, NJ 08855, USA
[email protected] David G. Richards Jefferson Lab 12000 Jefferson Avenue Newport News, VA 23606
[email protected] Klaus Schilling Wuppertal University D42097 Wuppertal, Germany and Department of Physics Boston University Boston MA02215, USA
[email protected]. uni-wuppertal.de Massimo Testa Dip. di Fisica, Univ. di Roma “La Sapienza” and INFN Sezione di Roma Piazzale Aldo Moro 2, I-00185 Rome Italy
[email protected]
Anthony G. Williams Special Research Center for the Subatomic Structure of Matter Department of Physics University of Adelaide Adelaide 5005, Australia
[email protected] Ross Young Special Research Center for the Subatomic Structure of Matter Department of Physics University of Adelaide Adelaide 5005, Australia
[email protected] James Zanotti John von Neumann-Institut f¨ ur Computing NIC Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY D-15738 Zeuthen, Germany
[email protected] Jianbo Zhang Special Research Center for the Subatomic Structure of Matter Department of Physics University of Adelaide Adelaide 5005, Australia
[email protected]
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum C. Allton Department of Physics, University of Wales Swansea, Swansea SA2 8PP, U.K.
Abstract. Lattice QCD has generated a wealth of data in hadronic physics over the last two decades. Until relatively recently, most of this information has been within the “quenched approximation” where virtual quark–anti-quark pairs are neglected. This review presents a descriptive discussion of the effects of removing this approximation in the calculation of hadronic masses.
1 The Quenched Approximation In a quantum field theory involving gauge and fermion degrees of freedom, such as QCD, we have the following path integral formalism for the expectation value of a quantity Ω: 1 ¯ ¯ ¯ A) e−SE (ψ,ψ,A) (1) Ω = DψDψDA Ω(ψ, ψ, Z where Z is the usual path integral and the Euclidean action SE is defined in terms of the usual field strength tensor Fµν , 1 ¯ / + m)ψ(x) + Fµν Fµν . SE = d4 x ψ(x)(D (2) 4 The gauge degrees of freedom, A, are bosonic, but the fermionic degrees of freedom, ψ are fermionic and hence anti-commute. These are difficult to deal with in a computer simulation, but fortunately, since they occur as they can be integrated ψ analytically resulting in the usual determinant factor: 1 ¯ ¯ A)det(D DA Ω(ψ, ψ, / + m) e−SE (ψ,ψ,A) . (3) Ω = Z Simulations of this quantum field theory are performed on a space-time lattice by simply replacing all the continuous derivatives and integrals with finite differences and sums over gauge configurations. Hence, we have on the lattice: Ω =
1 ¯ A) e−Sg det(∆ Ω(ψ, ψ, / + m) Z
(4)
{U }
The (naive) lattice Euclidean action is C. Allton: Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum, Lect. Notes Phys. 663, 1–16 (2005) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2005 www.springerlink.com
2
C. Allton
S = SF + S g =
x
¯ / + m)ψ(x) − 1 ψ(∆ T r(Up + Up† ) 2 g0 p
(5)
where a is the lattice spacing, the link variable Uµ (x) now carries the gauge degrees of freedom, and Up is the trace of the product of link variables around a plaquette, ˆa)Uµ† (x + νˆa)Uν† (x) . (6) Up = Uµ (x)Uν (x + µ This formalism maintains gauge invariance even on a lattice [1]. Variations of the naive lattice action can be made to improve its convergence to the continuum action in two areas: • the naive action suffers from fermion doubling – each lattice quark flavour corresponds to 2d continuum flavours, where d is the space-time dimension; • lattice actions in general suffer from discretisation errors which enter when the continuum derivatives in (2) is replaced by the finite difference in (5). Two methods are generally used to overcome the first difficulty – the Wilson/ clover family of actions, and the staggered action. Both of these actions can be tweaked so that their lattice systematic error (the second difficulty above) are reduced, and then they are termed “improved”. Simulations using the lattice formalism can be performed by replacing the naive sum in (4) with a Monte Carlo estimate. This introduces a statistical error O(1/ Ncf g ) in the estimate of Ω where Ncf g is the number of configurations in the Monte Carlo sum. The lattice prescription of formulating a Quantum Field Theory has a´ priori no model assumptions – it is derived exactly from the full continuum formalism with no approximations. However the parameter values in real computer simulations of lattice QCD are far from their experimental values. This is due to limitations in current computer power! Table 1 lists the values of the parameters in typical lattice simulations along with their experimental values. Thus typical lattice simulations must inevitably rely on some extrapolation of lattice data. Note that the bare lattice gauge coupling, g0 , is not listed in Table 1. This because the information about g0 is contained within the a value, through dimensional transmutation. Our usual intuition about high momentum transfers Table 1. Typical parameter values in current lattice simulations Parameter
Typical Value
Experimental Value
mq
mu , md ≈ 5 MeV
a
> ms /2 ≈ 50 MeV ∼ 0.05−0.20 fm
0
L
2−4 fm
∞
Ncf g
O(100)
∞
Nf
0, 2 or 2 + 1
“2 + 1”
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum
3
(short-distance physics) corresponding to the weakly coupled regime (small values of g0 ) in asymptotically free theories such as QCD, is directly applicable to lattice simulations. So we have g0 → 0 as a → 0. Equations (4 & 5) correctly define the full continuum theory in the limit as the lattice spacing a → 0. However, it is extremely expensive to simulate with (4 & 5). Figure 1 shows the estimated cost of lattice calculations as a function of quark mass using the formula in [2] for the “clover” action. (Actually, the horizontal axis of this plot is MP S , but, from the PCAC relation, we have MP S ∝ √ mq .) 10
Tflop years
8
6
4
2
0
MK
Mπ
0
200
400
600
800
1000
MPS [MeV] Fig. 1. The computer time in Teraflop – years required for a full lattice QCD simulation as a function of pseudoscalar meson mass using the formula for clover actions in [2]. We have assumed (i) a lattice spacing of a = 0.1 f m; (ii) a lattice volume of (3 f m)4 ; and (iii) that 200 configurations in the ensemble sum in (4) are required. The physical points corresponding to the π− and K-mesons are shown by vertical lines
In Fig. 1 we have assumed: (i) a lattice spacing of a = 0.1 f m; (ii) a lattice volume of L4 = (3 f m)4 ; and (iii) that there are Ncf g = 200 configurations in the ensemble sum in (4). (These are very conservative assumptions!) As can be seen, for even modest values of MP S ≈ 12 MK ∼ 250 M eV , full simulations require Tera-scale computing.1 For this reason, [4] introduced the “quenched” approximation where the true QCD vacuum is replaced with one with no quarks present (i.e. Nf = 0 in Table 1). Specifically the quenched approximation is defined as follows: • det(∆ / + m) is replaced by unity, thereby removing the quark-anti-quark loops from the vacuum configurations; • the coupling β = 6/g02 is shifted to try to counteract (as much as is possible) the removal of these q − q¯ pairs. Typically this shift is of the following order 1
Recent advances in lattice actions, e.g. using an improved staggered action, have meant that CPU requirements are not quite so pessimistic [3].
4
C. Allton
β Q ≈ β f ull + 0.6 where β Q,f ull refer to the coupling in the quenched and full theories. In this way the quenched approximation can be viewed as an effective field theory, i.e. it contains a subset of all the interactions, and the couplings of the quenched theory have to be tuned to take care of these missing diagrams. Figure 2 shows the diagrams which are present in both the quenched and full theory, and those which are present only in the full theory.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 2. Diagrams which are present in (a) both quenched QCD and full QCD, and (b) present only in full QCD. The full lines are quarks and the spirals are gluons
Quenched simulations are several orders of magnitude faster than full (unquenched) simulations, and full simulations have only been performed in earnest in the last 5 years or so. Typical statistical and systematic errors of state-of-theart full simulations are of the same order now as quenched simulations’ errors were a decade ago. Particle physics is primarily concerned with the comparison of theory with experiment, and when theoretical calculations have inherent errors, it is crucial to understand and quantify their scale. The main aim of this chapter is to determine the systematic effect introduced in the hadron spectrum by the quenched approximation. We will find that uncovering quenching effects is more difficult than one would first imagine for two reasons: • the quenched approximation proves to be surprisingly successful for many hadronic quantities, i.e. it reproduces much of the hadron spectrum at the 5– 10% level. Assuming that QCD is the theory of the strong interaction implies that removing this approximation makes a relatively small effect!
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum
5
• current full simulations have statistical errors of a few percent (since they are highly cpu-intensive) and so discerning the quenching effects with this relatively noisy data can prove difficult; While the quenched approximation proves to be unintuitively accurate for many hadronic quantities, there are some quantities where it either fails drastically, or has pathologies when the valence quark masses in the hadrons becomes vanishing. Examples of this include: • the η and η mesons are degenerate in the quenched theory, whereas they are not degenerate in full QCD. This is because the quenched theory excludes diagrams involving disconnected q − q¯ loops. (See [5] for a description of lattice simulations of η and η .) • the chiral limit of quenched QCD suffers from “chiral logs” ∼log(mq /Λχ ) where mq is the quark mass and Λχ is a mass parameter proportional to pion decay constant. These logarithms enter the chiral perturbation theory expansion of various hadronic masses in the quenched theory, spoiling their chiral limit [6]. • the hyperfine mass splittings in heavy-mesons in the quenched theory is wrong by up to 10% or more, with the sign of the discrepancy depending on the states considered. This systematic error is greatly reduced when the full theory is considered. We will discuss some of these issues in later sections. The next section briefly reviews the best current results obtained from the quenched approximation. It outlines the accuracy of this approximation for the hadronic spectrum. Section 3 presents recent results from full (i.e. unquenched) simulations and we attempt to uncover estimates of quenching effects in Sect. 4.
2 Results from the Quenched Approximation While there have been many papers published using lattice simulations in the quenched approximation2 we will concentrate on the work of the CP-PACS collaboration who have produced one of the most accurate quenched study of the light hadron spectrum in [7]3 . Their calculations used an improved clover action [9] simulated at volumes of around 2.53 fm3 with several quark masses and lattice spacings. They are thus able to perform continuum (a → 0) and chiral (mq → mu,d ) extrapolations (see Table 1). An impressive summary of their quenched spectrum for the light hadrons is shown in Fig. 3 as the open symbols. Their lattice data are shown after the 2
3
A search on the SPIRES database for “quenched” returns more than 500 papers, and this does not include papers which use quenched simulations but where the authors have not included this word in the paper’s title! Another paper from the CP-PACS Collaboration studies even larger lattice of up to 643 × 112 but the lattice action employed in this work is the pure Wilson action which has O(a) errors [8].
6
C. Allton 1.8 1.6
non-strange sector
strange sector
M [GeV]
1.4
Σ∗
1.2
∆
1.0 0.8
K*
N K
N ∆ rel.dev.
rel. deviation
0.6
1.1 1.0 0.9 0.8
φ
K K* φ
Λ
Σ
{ {
Quenched QCD
Σ
Ω
Ξ
full QCD
Λ
Ξ∗
Ξ
experiment non-strange baryons ms from K ms from φ non-strange baryons ms from K ms from φ
Σ∗ Ξ∗ Ω
1.05 1.00 0.95
Fig. 3. The light hadron spectrum from CP-PACS [7], Tables XV and XII. Both the quenched and full QCD results are shown, together with the experimental value. The two hadrons on the left do not contain strange quarks, whereas the other hadrons do. The lattice spacing was set from the ρ− mass. Two methods were used to set the strange quark mass: from (i) the K and (ii) the φ− mass. The results of both definitions are shown. In the middle and lower plots, the relative deviation (= Mlattice /Mexpt ) is shown. The lower plot is a close-up of the middle plot showing the relative deviation for the strange mesons
appropriate continuum and chiral extrapolations and is taken from table XV of [7]. As can be seen from the middle panel of Fig. 3, discrepancies between the quenched lattice results and the experimental values are O(5−10%). It is important to note that this relatively small difference is only discernible due to the tiny errors in the lattice data of O(1−2%). Quenched calculations of an earlier generation [10], with correspondingly larger errors, were not able to uncover deviations from experimental values. Figure 3 contains two sets of lattice data points: those obtained from the K and φ inputs. These refer to the hadron whose mass was used to set the strange quark mass in the lattice calculation. (The ρ mass was used to define the lattice spacing, a.) The fact that there are differences between these two sets of data is itself an indication of the failure of the quenched approximation, i.e. an exact calculation’s result wouldn’t depend on how the scale was set. The CP-PACS collaboration also find the mass splittings, such as the hyperfine splitting in the meson sector and the splittings in the decuplet (baryon) sector are smaller than experimental values.
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum
7
A further indication of the failure of the quenched approximation is in the determination of the strange quark mass ms . As mentioned above, this quantity can again be calculated using either the K- or φ-meson as input, but the deviation between the two results is at the 3−4σ level. Moving to the heavy-hadron mass spectrum, a recent publication, using an improved staggered action, studied the splittings in the heavy-meson sector [3]. The left-hand plot in Fig. 7 (taken from [3]) shows the quenched predictions of various splittings from [3]. This clearly shows a discrepancy between the quenched results and experimental values. As we will see in Sect. 3.4, this discrepancy disappears when we remove the quenched approximation.
3 Results from Full (Unquenched) Simulations This section will give a flavour of current full QCD lattice simulations by concentrating on the CP-PACS [7] and UKQCD [11] collaborations’ results for the light hadron spectrum, and the work of [3] for the heavy-meson spectrum. Both the CP-PACS and UKQCD collaborations used two flavours of improved clover fermions whereas the collaboration in [3] used an improved staggered action (which has a cpu advantage over the Wilson action, see Sect. 1 and [12]). Table 2 displays the parameters used in these collaborations’ work. Note that we have differentiated the sea and valence quark masses in this table (cf. Table 1). The sea quarks are those which always appears in quark loops and are not connected to the source/sink operators (e.g. the quark loop in Fig. 2), and the valence quarks are those which enter the source/sink interpolating operators. Table 2. Indicative parameter values used in full QCD simulations by the CP-PACS [7] and UKQCD Collaborations [11] in their study of light hadrons, and in the study of the heavy-meson spectrum in [3] Parameter
CP-PACS [7]
UKQCD [11]
Davies et al. [3]
msea q
0.5ms −1.8ms
0.6ms −2.0ms
0.17ms −0.5ms
i.e. O(50−180) MeV
i.e. O(60−200) MeV
i.e. O(17−50) MeV
0.25ms −2.1ms
0.6ms −2.4ms
0.12ms −ms
i.e. O(25−210) MeV
i.e. O(60−240) MeV
i.e. O(12−100) MeV
a
0.09−0.25 fm
∼0.11 fm
0.09 fm & 0.12 fm
L
∼2.5 f m
∼1.7 f m
∼2.5 fm
Ncf g
O(1000)
O(200)
Nf
2
2
mval q
2+1
8
C. Allton
As can be seen from Table 2, the CP-PACS collaboration have performed QCD simulations at parameter values closer to the experimental values and has larger statistics than the UKQCD collaboration (see also Table 1). However the UKQCD collaboration chose a subset of its parameter values so that the lattice spacing remained fixed as the sea quark mass, msea q , varied. This meant that O(a) effects could more readily be disentangled from dynamical quark effects. Furthermore, the UKQCD lattice action has the technical advantage that it has no O(a) lattice systematic errors. In the simulations of [3] extremely light quarks were able to be studied due to the use of the improved staggered action. (This seems to have become the action of choice for most dynamical simulations.) Also [3] simulates with the more physical value of 2 + 1 quark flavours (see Table 1). Rather than give the full details of the results from these collaboration’s work, a summary is presented in the following. In the next section we attempt to understand the discrepancies between this section’s full QCD results and quenched simulations from Sect. 2. 3.1 Meson Spectrum In Fig. 4 we plot the vector and pseudoscalar meson mass taken from [7] together with the experimental points. In this figure, the lattice spacing, a, was determined from the K and K ∗ meson masses using the method described in [13]. The huge number of data points corresponds to the fact that there are 16 different (β, msea q ) combinations in [7] and that there are 9 different valence quark combinations for each of these (β, msea q ) ensembles. Also plotted are the experimental data points corresponding to the (π, ρ), (K, K ∗ ), and (ηs , φ).4 One of the main points to be taken from this plot is that the systematics involved in lattice simulations are clearly under control. Variations amongst this data in Fig. 4 is < ∼1%, while the lattice spacing and sea quark mass vary by ∼ 0.5−1.8ms . A close around a factor of three: a ∼ 0.09−0.25 fm, and msea q analysis of the data has been used to extrapolate away these residual systematic and a [7] (see also [14]). effects in msea q Figure 3 also shows the hadronic spectrum, including the three mesons, K, K ∗ and φ taken from [7]. These have been obtained by chirally extrapolating data analogous to that in Fig. 4 to the physical quark masses. As can be seen (particularly in the lower panel of Fig. 3) the full QCD simulated results are in very good agreement with experiment. As mentioned above, the K, K ∗ mass is used to set the lattice spacing, a, in Fig. 4 [13]. This means that the lattice data and the experimental K, K ∗ point agree by construction. However, the slope of the lattice data is a real lattice prediction. In the next subsection we study this gradient. 4
Note that ηs is not a physical particle, since there is no pure s − s¯ pseudoscalar meson due to mixing with the u, d quarks. The ηs mass shown here is defined as 2 − Mπ2 which follows from the PCAC relationship MP2 S ∝ mq . Mη2s = 2MK
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum 1.2
9
Mηs , Mφ
MV [GeV]
MK , MK* M π , Mρ 1
0.8 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
MPS2 [GeV2] Fig. 4. The light meson masses from CP-PACS [7] (see also [14]). In this figure, we have set the lattice spacing from the method described in [13]. Also shown are the experimental points
3.2 J -Parameter In this section we analyse the gradient dMV /dMP2 S of the lattice data. The dimensionless quantity used to study this is defined [15] dMV . (7) J = MV dMP2 S K,K ∗ Note that we define the experimental value of the J-parameter by approximating the derivative in (7) by a finite difference: J discrete = MK ∗
MK ∗ − Mρ 2 − M2 . MK π
(8)
Therefore the lattice estimate of J is obtained by taking the derivative in (7) val sea but varying valence quark w.r.t. variations in MP2 S (msea q , mq ) at fixed mq val mass, mq (i.e. the experimental/physical sea quark mass is clearly fixed!). The J-parameter has been studied in both [7] and [11], but we concentrate here on the analysis in [11]. Figure 5 plots the J-parameter from [11]. The Jvalues separately. These J(msea parameter is calculated at each of three msea q q ) sea 2 ≈ 0. values are then extrapolated in mq ∝ MP S to the physical point msea q This extrapolated J value is shown as a banded region in Fig. 5. As can be seen from Fig. 5 the individual J(msea q ) values are significantly smaller than the experimental value. However there is a clear trend in msea q which tends towards the experimental point.
10
C. Allton 0.55
0.5
Experiment
J
0.45
Extrapolated
0.4
0.35
(Quenched)
0.3
0.25
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
(MPS
0.7
0.8
unitary 2
)
0.9
1
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
2
[GeV ]
Fig. 5. J versus (MPunitary )2 using the approaches described in the text from S unitary is the pseudoscalar meson mass comprising of degenerate valence [11]. MP S quarks which are themselves degenerate with the sea quarks. (Note, from PCAC, unitary 2 )2 ∝ msea ) = (MPunitary q .) The quenched data points have been plotted at (MP S S 2 1.3 GeV for convenience. The banded region at the left of the graph is the result of the → 0 for the full QCD data. The experimental value of J = 0.48(2) extrapolation msea q is also shown
3.3 Baryons The vector and pseudoscalar light-meson sector at various quark masses is defined by the plot in Fig. 4. Traditionally, the corresponding plot containing information about the light – baryon sector (specifically the nucleon) is the “Edinburgh” plot where the nucleon mass is plotted against the pion mass (with both masses normalised by the vector meson mass). Figure 6 shows this plot for the the CP-PACS [7] and UKQCD collaborations for their unitary data, i.e. where ≡ msea mvalence q q . As can be seen, there is a relatively large spread in the data, but there is a tendency for the data to approach the experimental point as the quark masses decrease. After this chiral extrapolation is performed, the CP-PACS collaboration [7] obtained the baryonic spectrum seen in Fig. 3. This is an impressive array of data spanning octet and decuplet sectors. As can be seen Fig. 3 the nucleon and ∆ differ from experiment by around 10%, whereas the Ξ, Ξ ∗ (with quark content lss) and particularly the Ω (with quark content sss) are in perfect agreement with experiment. This implies that lattice simulations become more accurate as the strange quark content increases [7]. Since lattice simulations normally have valence quarks which span the mass of the strange (see Table 2), the spectrum calculation of baryons containing purely strange valence quarks requires no valence quark chiral extrapolation. However, the level of chiral extrapolation required obviously becomes more and
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum
11
CP-PACS UKQCD 1.5
MN / MV
Static
1.4
1.3
Experimental 1.2
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
MPS / MV Fig. 6. The “Edinburgh plot” for selected full QCD data from [7, 11]. The lattice data ≡ msea points shown are the unitary points (i.e. mvalence q q ). The experimental point is shown, along with the static limit (mq → ∞)
more significant as the light quark (i.e. u and d) content of the baryon increases. This suggests that chiral extrapolation procedures need more careful consideration in order to resolve the discrepancy above (see [16]). Note that the authors of [7] themselves argue that this discrepancy could be due to finite volume effects which impinge upon baryons composed of light quarks more than those composed of strange quarks. This could presumably also be a factor, particularly since finite volume effects are likely to increase the mass (which is in the direction of the observed discrepancy in Fig. 3) and be most relevant for the lightest baryons. 3.4 Heavy-Meson Mass Splittings There has been a recent study of the heavy-meson spectrum in [3] which uses 2 + 1 flavours of quarks, i.e. 2 light degenerate flavours which play the role of the u and d quarks, and one heavier (but still dynamical) quark which plays the role of the s quark. This is obviously closer to the real world than the simulations of the CP-PACS and UKQCD collaborations (see Tables 1 & 2). We reproduce, in Fig. 7 (taken from [3]) a graph showing the ratio of lattice prediction to experiment for some heavy-meson mass splittings. As can be seen, the lattice results in the full theory (right-hand plot) are within 1σ of their experimental values.
12
C. Allton fψ fK 3MΞ − MN 2MBs − MΥ ψ(1P − 1S) Υ(1D − 1S) Υ(2P − 1S) Υ(3S − 1S) Υ(1P − 1S) 0.9 1 1.1 LQCD/Exp’t (nf = 0)
0.9 1 1.1 LQCD/Exp’t (nf = 3)
Fig. 7. Heavy-meson mass splitting (together with some light hadron quantities) taken from [3]
4 Quantifying Quenching Effects 4.1 Hadron Spectrum In Sects. 2 and 3, we have outlined some results for the hadronic spectrum for both the quenched approximation and full QCD. Comparing these results we note firstly that quenched results are generally within 10% of their experimental value for a wide variety of quantities. This is an unexpectedly good level of agreement which will be discussed later in this section. Studying the light-meson sector, we note that the full theory is able to accurately reproduce the K, K ∗ and φ masses to within around 1%, far better than the quenched theory (see lower panel of Fig. 3). We note, however, that the “chiral” slope, defined via the J-parameter, (7), is still several σ away from its experimental value at the simulated values of msea (see Fig. 5), and that the chiral extrapolation, msea → mu,d is required to make contact with experiment. This situation is mirrored in the baryonic spectrum. Figure 3 shows the remarkable prediction from the CP-PACS collaboration of eight baryonic masses. In general terms, the agreement between theory and experiment is enhanced when the quenched approximation is removed. Note also that there is no discrepancy in the full theory between predictions using the K and φ mesons to set the strange quark mass. The same is not true in the quenched data (see Fig. 3). The level of agreement between the full theory prediction and experiment is most profound for baryons containing the largest strange quark content. We argued in Sect. 3.3 that this could imply that the lattice data at the simulated values of mq (roughly around ms ) are correct, but that the chiral extrapolation procedure mq → mu,d is going astray. As can be seen in Fig. 6, which is roughly the baryonic equivalent of Fig. 4, the chiral extrapolation required to reach the u, d quarks is substantial.
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum
13
Moving to the heavy-meson sector, we summarised in Sect. 3.4 results from [3]. These show excellent agreement between full simulation results and experiment for a variety of quantities, especially splittings in the υ spectrum. A corresponding quenched analysis shows discrepancies of ∼10%. 4.2 Why is the Quenched Approximation So Good? While there are obvious failures in the quenched approximation’s ability to reproduce the real world, it does much better than naive expectations: one would imagine that removing all q − q¯ diagrams from the theory would have a drastic effect on the hadron spectrum. Figure 3 shows that this is not the case. Why then does the quenched approximation perform so well? One can obtain a handle on this issue by studying the static quark potential (which is the quantum mechanical potential between two infinitely heavy quarks). Figure 8 shows UKQCD results for this quantity for both the quenched and full theory [11]. The curve shown in the graph is the “string model”, V (r) = e/r + σ/r + const [17]. Note that the data is defined to agree in value and slope exactly at r = r0 (the hadronic scale defined in [18]) [11]. A close up of the difference between the lattice potential and the string model at short distances is shown in Fig. 9. As can be seen from Figs. 8 & 9, the discrepancy between the quenched and full theories is negligible across the whole range of r except at very small distances where the deviation is discernible, but small. This implies that only physical quantities particularly sensitive to this short-distance scale will be affected by the quenched approximation. Hadronic states are most
2.5
[V(r)V(r0)]*r0
1.5
0.5 5.93 Quenched, 623 5.29, c=1.92, k=.13400 5.26, c=1.95, k=.13450 5.20, c=2.02, k=.13500 5.20, c=2.02, k=.13550 5.20, c=2.02, k=.13565 Model
−0.5
−1.5
−2.5
0
1
2 r/r0
Fig. 8. The static quark potential from the UKQCD Collaboration [11]. The parameters c and k refer to a coefficient of an improvment term in the action and the sea quark mass parameter respectively
14
C. Allton 0.5
[V(r)V(r0)]*r0 string model
5.93 Quenched 5.29, c=1.92, k=.13400 5.26, c=1.95, k=.13450 5.20, c=2.02, k=.13500
−0.5
0
1 r/r0
Fig. 9. The deviation of the static quark potential in Fig. 8 from the string model [11]
sensitive to “medium” distance scales r ∼ r0 ≈ 0.5 f m where (from Fig. 8) the two theories’ data overlay each other. Thus the quenched and full theories should agree at the same level as quarks in QCD can be approximated as moving in a static quark potential. This observation presumably has relevance to the age-old question: Why does the (nonrelativistic) quark model perform so well? It is worth noting that, from Sect. 1, the quenched approximation is defined not just by replacing the quark determinant by unity, but also by renormalising the coupling g0 . In fact, if you attempt to perform quenched and full simulations at the same value of g0 , then the lattice spacing, a (or equivalently the cut-off ∼1/a) will differ by a factor of around four. This is telling us that the virtual quark loops really are affecting the dynamics of the simulation. The apparent contradiction between this fact, and what we have seen above, i.e. that the quenched approximation reproduces the full theory (at the 5−10% level) is resolved as follows. The lattice only actually predicts dimensionless quantities, normally expressed as, e.g. M × a, where M is some mass. In this way the lattice is able to predict dimensionless ratios of physical quantities only, e.g. M1 /M2 . Although switching the quark determinant on and off does directly affect the lattice spacing, and therefore M a, it seems to have little effect on the ratio M1 /M2 . In other words the physical prediction from the lattice of M1 , which can be obtained from M1 /M2 × M2expt , doesn’t seem to be greatly affected by quenching. This is telling us something remarkable: for a wide variety of hadronic masses (and the static quark potential), the removal of virtual quark loops from the theory can be counter-balanced simply by an adjustment in the coupling, g0 .
Quenching Effects in the Hadron Spectrum
15
There is one final reason why quenching has only a modest affect on the hadronic spectrum, compared to other physical quantities. In order to extract a hadron mass from a lattice simulation, the quantity Ω = C(t) is calculated (see (4)) where C(t) is a two-point correlation function between hadronic currents. In Euclidean space-time, we have C(t) → M2 e−M t
as
t→∞
(9)
where M is a matrix element between the vacuum and the hadronic ground state. Lets assume that we are performing a quenched calculation of C(t) and that it has a relative error of ε due to this quenched approximation, i.e. C(t)Q = C(t)f ull (1 + ε) ,
(10)
where C(t)Q,f ull are the quenched and full correlation functions respectively. Because the mass, M , appears in the argument of the exponential, a relatively small adjustment in M can mop up the quenching error ε, whereas a larger relative change would be required of the matrix element, M. Obviously this analysis is a little simplistic but it does illustrate that we can expect quenching errors in matrix elements (such as decay constants) to be larger than in masses.
5 Conclusions Lattice QCD is an approach to solving field theories, such as QCD, which involves no model assumptions. Given a fast enough computer, the lattice can be used to solve QCD on any finite volume and with any non-zero quark mass resulting in an absolute theoretical prediction of QCD. However, in order to make the problem tractable on current computers, certain parameters of QCD need to take non-physical values (see Table 1). The parameter under study in this chapter is the number of quark flavours in the vacuum, Nf . Setting Nf = 0 is called the quenched approximation and corresponds to ignoring virtual q − q¯ pairs in the vacuum. The approximation Nf = 0 is seemingly a particularly brutal approximation and, furthermore, there is little theoretical guidance as to its effect. Thus we are usually forced to “measure” its effect a posteriori by analysing data from lattice simulations. In this chapter we have studied the hadronic spectrum with and without the quenched approximation, in particular light mesons and baryons, and heavymesons. By comparing quenched data with experimental masses, we have shown that quenching effects in the light-hadron spectrum are relatively small (5−10%), with a slightly larger discrepancy in the heavy-meson spectrum. It is only recently that full QCD simulations have been able to produce data with statistical and systematic errors beneath this level. With this new generation of data, we are now able to state that full QCD lattice results have better agreement with experiment than quenched results.
16
C. Allton
We have outlined some reasons why the quenched approximation is so relatively successful, and we have found evidence that the chiral extrapolation techniques currently being used in full QCD simulations require further consideration. In the future, more precise calculations with, and without the quenched approximation will surely enhance our understanding of the underlying physics of QCD.
Acknowledgements The author would like to thank the CSSM in Adelaide for their kind hospitality.
References 1. 2. 3. 4.
5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
K. G. Wilson, Phys. D 10 (1974) 2445. 2 H. Wittig, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 106 (2002) 197–198, hep-lat/0203021. 3 C. T. H. Davies et al., hep-lat/0304004. 3, 7, 8, 11, 12, 13 H. Hamber and G. Parisi, Phys. Rev. Lett 47 (1981) 1792, E. Marinari, G. Parisi and C. Rebbi, Phys. Rev. Lett 47 (1981) 1795, D. Weingarten Phys. Lett 109 B (1982) 57. 3 C. Michael, Phys. Scripta T 99 (2002) 7, hep-lat/0111056. 5 S. Sharpe, Phys. Rev. D 46 (1992) 3146, C. Bernard and M. Golterman, Phys. Rev. D 46 (1992) 853. 5 CP-PACS Collaboration, A.A. Khan et al., Phys.Rev. D 65 (2002) 054505, heplat/0105015. 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 CP-PACS Collaboration, S. Aoki et al., Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003) 034503, heplat/0206009. 5 B. Sheikholeslami and R. Wohlert, Nucl. Phys. B 259 (1985) 572. 5 F. Butler, H. Chen, J. Sexton, A. Vaccarino, D. Weingarten Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 2849, hep-lat/9212031. 6 UKQCD Collaboration, C.R. Allton et al., Phys. Rev. D 65 (2002) 054502, hep-lat/0107021. 7, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14 C. Bernard et al., Nucl. Phys. B (Proc. Suppl.) 106 (2002) 1999. 7 C.R.Allton, V. Gimenez, L. Giusti, F. Rapuano, Nucl. Phys. B 489 (1997) 427– 452, hep-lat/9611021. 8, 9 W. Armour, C.R. Allton, D. Leinweber, A.W. Thomas, R. Young in preparation. 8, 9 UKQCD Collaboration, P. Lacock and C. Michael, Phys. Rev. D 52 (1995) 5213, hep-lat/9506009. 9 A. Thomas et al. Hadron Structure and QCD: Effective Field Theory for Lattice Simulations, Lect. Notes Phys. 663, 113–129(2005). 11 M. L uscher, Nucl. Phys. B 180 (1981) 317. 13 R. Sommer, Nucl. Phys. B 411 (1994) 839, hep-lat/9310022. 13
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications P.O. Bowman1 , U.M. Heller2 , D.B. Leinweber1 , A.G. Williams, and J.B. Zhang1 1
2
Special Research Centre for the Subatomic Structure of Matter and The Department of Physics, University of Adelaide, Australia 5005 American Physical Society, One Research Road, Box 9000, Ridge, NY 11961–9000
Abstract. The quark propagator lies at the core of lattice hadron spectrum calculations as well as studies in other nonperturbative schemes. It manifestly displays dynamical chiral symmetry breaking and can be used to connect nonperturbative methods with perturbation theory. The quark propagator can also provide direct information on lattice simulations and act as a test-bed for improvement. We investigate the lattice quark propagator with standard (Kogut–Susskind) and improved (Asqtad) Staggered actions and with the Overlap action. These actions are seen to have excellent ultraviolet behaviour as well as being useful for studying infrared properties. By using a variety of actions as well as varying the lattice parameters we are able to obtain good control over systematic errors in the quenched case. Gauge dependent quantities from lattice simulations may be affected by Gribov copies. We explore this by studying the quark propagator in both Landau and Laplacian gauges. Laplacian gauges are unambiguous, i.e. free of Gribov copies. Landau and Laplacian gauges are found to produce very similar results for the quark propagator. From the quark propagator we are able to compute the chiral condensate and running quark mass. Results from Staggered and Overlap actions are in excellent agreement. The data is also used to construct ans¨ atze suitable for model hadron calculations as well as adding to our intuitive understanding of QCD.
1 Introduction Quantum Chromodynamics is widely accepted as the correct theory of the strong interactions and the quark propagator is its most basic quantity. In the low momentum region it exhibits dynamical chiral symmetry breaking (which cannot be seen from perturbation theory) and at high momentum it can be used to extract the running quark mass (which cannot be directly measured from experiment). In lattice QCD, quark propagators are tied together to calculate hadron masses and other properties; and the quark propagator is a required input for any number of hadronic models. Lattice gauge theory provides a way to calculate the quark propagator nonperturbatively, providing quantities such the chiral condensate and ΛQCD , and in turn, such a calculation can provide technical insight into lattice gauge theory simulations. Quark propagator studies are now reaching a state of maturity. The quark propagator has now been studied using Clover [1, 2], Staggered [3, 4] and Overlap [5, 6] actions. All these actions have different systematic errors and the P.O. Bowman, U.M. Heller, D.B. Leinweber, A.G. Williams, and J.B. Zhang: Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications, Lect. Notes Phys. 663, 17–63 (2005) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2005 www.springerlink.com
18
P.O. Bowman et al.
combination of these studies gives us an excellent handle on the possible lattice artefacts. As well as a summary of the state of this reseach, in this report we will provide the latest results from improved Staggered and Overlap lattice actions. The quark propagator is gauge dependent and we choose the ever popular Landau gauge and the interesting Laplacian gauge [7, 8]. Laplacian gauge fixing is an unambiguous gauge fixing and, although it is difficult to understand perturbatively, it is equivalent to Landau gauge in the asymptotic region. It has been used to study the gluon propagator [9, 10, 11]. In SU (N) there are various ways to implement a Laplacian gauge fixing. Three varieties of Laplacian gauge fixing are used, and these form three different, but related gauges. The systematic study of the quark propagator on the lattice has also provided fruitful interaction with other approaches to hadron physics, such as instanton phenomenology [12], chiral quark models [13] and Dyson–Schwinger equation studies [14]. The lattice is a first principles approach and has provided valuable constraints for model builders. In turn, such alternative methods, by preserving features of QCD that the lattice lacks, can provide feedback on regions that are difficult to access directly, such as the deep infrared and the chiral limit. This report is organised as follows. In an attempt to make it self-contained we start with a brief discussion of Green’s functions in Euclidean field theory with particular reference to lattice gauge theory. This is followed by an explanation of the gauge fixing we will use, especially Laplacian gauge. As the Staggered formalism is less widely understood than Wilson’s discretisation, it is described before showing some results for the quark propagator in Landau gauge. The Overlap quark formalism is then introduced, with a discussion of the particular issues for the quark propagator with that discretisation followed by a summary of results. Then, results for the quark propagator in the Laplacian gauge are shown. We will then focus on the asymptotic behaviour of the quark propagator to calculate the running mass and chiral condensate. Finally, we suggest a model form for the quark mass function and compare the data with various published models.
2 Euclidean Green’s Functions Quantum field theories may be defined by a path integral over a function space. If the coupling of a given theory is weak, α 1, then it can be expanded in terms of its bare n-point functions in a perturbative series. Perturbation theory is extremely successful in Quantum Electrodynamics and is useful in the high energy regime of Quantum Chromodynamics, but no matter what the coupling, some features of a theory will not appear at any finite order in perturbation theory. If the coupling that characterises a theory is strong, which is the case in QCD at intermediate to low energies, then the perturbative series will converge poorly, or not at all. So to make the most out of QFT we need nonperturbative methods. Lattice gauge theory provides a direct method for summing the functional path integral. In fact, it is the only way to sum the functional integral that
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
19
does not require us to mutilate the theory in a way that will have unpredictable results. It involves approximations, like any other practical method in QFT, but they are systematically removable. It is this possibility of controlling the systematic errors that makes lattice gauge theory invaluable. Although the real, four-dimensional world is, at least locally, a Minkowski space, much work in quantum field theory is done in Euclidean space. This is not an approximation, but a complete transformation of a theory from one geometry to the other [15]. This may be a temporary measure, with a further Wick rotation back to Minkowski space to obtain physical answers, or it may be possible to extract observable quantities directly from the Euclidean form of the theory. Quantum Chromodynamics is perfectly well defined in Euclidean space and as we shall at no stage find it necessary to explicitly rotate to Minkowski space, we shall restrict ourselves to Euclidean space from the start. Suppressing spin and colour indices, continuum QCD is described by a generating functional 4 1 (1) DψDψDAe−SG [A]−SF [ψ,ψ,A]+ d xηψ+ηψ+Jµ Aµ Z[η, η, J] = Z[0] built from a gluonic action SG [A] =
1 2
2 d4 xTr Fµν (x)
(2)
where the field strength tensor is
Fµν (x) = ∂µ Aν (x) − ∂ν Aµ (x) + ig Aµ (x), Aν (x) , a fermionic action
(3)
SF [ψ, ψ, A] =
d4 xψ(x)(γµ Dµ + m)ψ(x)
(4)
where the covariant derivative is Dµ = ∂µ + igAµ ,
(5)
and source terms η, η and Jµ . The Euclidean γ matrices are hermitian and satisfy {γµ , γν } = 2δµν . With these conventions, γ5 ≡ γ1 γ2 γ3 γ4 . One representation is
0 iσi 1 0 0 1 γi = γ4 = γ5 = (6) −iσi 0 0 −1 1 0 where the σi are the Pauli matrices. The generating functional has the normalisation (7) Z[0] = DψDψDAe−SG [A]−SF [ψ,ψ,A] , i.e., Z with all sources set to zero. For the moment, we have ignored all issues of gauge-fixing. From this generating functional all physical quantities can be obtained.
20
P.O. Bowman et al.
The elements of the field theory – the n-point Green’s functions – are constructed from (1) by differentiating the generating functional with respect to the sources, then setting those sources to zero. For example, the two-point fermion Green’s function – the quark propagator – is δ δ Z S(x, y) = δη(x) δη(y) η=0,η=0 1 = DψDψDAµ ψ(x)ψ(y)e−SQCD Z[0] = ψ(x)ψ(y) .
(8)
Although there is no known method to directly solve these equations, they can be cast into a form suitable for numerical methods by replacing continuous spacetime with a (four dimensional) grid or lattice. This reduces the number of degrees of freedom of the system from infinity to merely a very large number. On the lattice the gauge fields, Aµ , are replaced by parallel transport operators or links 1 Aµ (x + atˆ µ)dt ∈ SU(N) (9) Uµ (x) = P exp iag 0
eiagAµ (x)
(10)
where P denotes path ordering and µ ˆ is a unit vector in the xµ direction. The lattice spacing, a, is the distance between sites on the lattice. It is the smallest unit of length in a lattice regularised theory. So Uµ (x) is the link connecting lattice sites x and x + aˆ µ. Taking the inverse of a link reverses its direction, and ˆ), where we have dropped since they are unitary, we see that: Uµ† (x) = U−µ (x + µ the lattice spacing, a, as implied. The gauge fields are replaced by link variables for the purpose of maintaining explicit gauge invariance on the finite lattice. It can be shown that the trace of any closed loop of links is gauge invariant, and it is from such elements, called Wilson loops, that a lattice gauge action can be built. The most basic Wilson loop (1×1) is called the plaquette, and it is defined to be ˆ)Uµ† (x + νˆ)Uν† (x) . Pµν (x) = Uµ (x)Uν (x + µ
(11)
The plaquette also provides us with one lattice version of the field strength tensor and the simplest lattice gauge action – called the Wilson gauge action – can be written: β 1 W † SG [U ] = Tr 1 − Pµν + Pµν (12) N 2 plaquettes
= SG + O(a2 ) .
(13)
The coupling constant of the theory has been absorbed into the parameter,
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
β=
2N g2
21
(14)
1 ). giving (13) a form that emphasises the analogy with statistical physics (cf. kT All lattice quantities are related to their continuum counterparts by terms proportional to some power of the lattice spacing, a, thus recovering continuum QCD in the limit a → 0. This means that there are many formally equivalent ways to define any one lattice quantity. Lattice fermion actions are constructed by a suitable discretisation of the covariant Dirac operator. The simplest is
Dµ (x, y) =
1 (Uµ (x)δy,x+ˆµ − Uµ† (x − µ)δy,x−ˆµ ) , 2a
(15)
which is equivalent to (5) up to terms of O(a2 ). This “na¨ıve” Dirac operator is, however, problematic on a finite lattice. We will return to this point later. However the discretisation is accomplished, the fermion action may be written in terms of a fermion matrix ψ α (x)Kαβ (x, y, U )ψβ (y) (16) SF [ψ, ψ, U ] = x,y
where the fermion and antifermion fields, ψ and ψ respectively, dwell on the lattice sites x and y. Our lattice gauge theory is now defined by the generating functional 1 Z[η, η, J] = (17) DψDψDU e−SG [U ]−SF [ψ,ψ,U ]+ x ηψ+ηψ+Jµ Uµ Z[0] in terms of the link variables, Uµ . The measure, DU = dUµ (x)
(18)
x,µ
which properly defines integration over a compact group element is called the Haar measure [16]. The discretisation acts as an ultraviolet cutoff, pmax = πa , so loops will be finite if perturbation theory is applied to the lattice generating functional. Furthermore, the lattice formulation maintains exact gauge invariance, unlike field theory with a na¨ıve UV cutoff [17]. The elements of the gauge field, the links, are elements of the compact group SU (N) and are bounded above and below. If we limit ourselves to nonperturbative methods, gauge fixing is not required for the calculation of physical observables in this formalism. Calculations may be performed using lattice perturbation theory or strong coupling expansions, but the most important method is Monte Carlo integration. Equation (17) resembles a statistical system and once the Grassman variables have been integrated out (see below) we may apply standard statistical methods. The functional integral is estimated by an average over a statistical ensemble of gauge configurations, Uµ (x). These configurations are generated with
22
P.O. Bowman et al.
the Boltzmann distribution given by the exponential of the action. This is a form of importance sampling and is essential for the Monte Carlo integration to converge on a practical number of configurations. As the action is positive semi-definite, statistical uncertainty in the resulting expectation values vanishes like one over the square-root of the number of configurations. This is a generic feature of Monte Carlo methods. We will now briefly discuss the calculation of the quark propagator (8). Making a the change of variables
ψ → ψ = ψ − ηK −1
ψ →ψ =ψ−K
−1
η
we can rewrite the fermionic part of the generating functional as −1 1 Z[η, η] = Dψ Dψ e x −ψ Kψ e x ηK η . Z[0]
(19) (20)
(21)
Under the rules of Grassman integration the measure is invariant under the above transformation, which enables us to write Z[η, η] =
−1 1 det Ke x ηK η . Z[0]
(22)
In the interacting theory, the fermion matrix K is a function of the gauge links. Returning to the full theory, we can write −1 1 Z[η, η, J] = (23) DU det K[U ]e−SG [U ]− x ηK η+Jµ Uµ Z[0] and
δ2 Z δη(x)δη(y)
= η=0,η=0
1 Z[0]
DU K[U ]−1 det K[U ]e−SG [U ] .
(24)
Thus we see that the calculation of the quark propagator amounts to the inversion of the fermion matrix T ψ(x)ψ(y) =
N 1 K(x, y, U (i) )−1 , N i=1
(25)
where the functional integral is estimated by a finite sum over an ensemble of (i) gauge configurations, {Uµ } which have themselves been generated with the distribution det K[U ] exp −SG [U ]. Computing the determinant of the fermion matrix, det K, in (24) is incredibly expensive. For this reason, most lattice simulations use the ansatz det K = 1 (26) which is equivalent to ignoring all fermion loops in the theory. This is called the quenched approximation.
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
23
3 Gauge Fixing We will briefly discuss gauge fixing on the lattice, its necessity and application. More thorough discussion can be found in [18, 19] and references contained therein. Continuum gauge fields, Aµ , are acted upon by gauge transformations, G(x) ∈ SU(N) such that † Aµ (x) → AG µ (x) = G(x)(Aµ (x) + i∂µ )G (x) ,
(27)
under which the action (2), is invariant. The link variables obey the simple gauge transformation law UµG (x) = G(x)Uµ (x)G†µ (x + µ ˆ) . (28) which leaves the lattice QCD action unchanged. This is equivalent to (27) up to terms of O(a2 ). In continuum QCD, gauge symmetry leaves the generating function illdefined and gauge fixing is required. This is usually accomplished through the Fadde’ev–Popov procedure, which ensures that only gauge fields satisfying some gauge condition are included in the functional integral, but also introduces new particles called ghosts. These ghosts are unphysical in that they do not appear in the spectrum. One of the celebrated facts of lattice gauge theory, at least in this formulation, is that gauge fixing is unnecessary for calculating observable quantities; (17) is finite. Gauge fixing is, however, necessary for various tasks including the study of gauge dependent quantities, such as the quark propagator. We consider the quark propagator in Landau and Laplacian gauges. Landau gauge fixing is performed by enforcing the Lorentz gauge condition, µ ∂µ Aµ (x) = 0 on a configuration by configuration basis. This can be achieved in the continuum through the minimisation of the L2 norm 2 AG F G [A] = d4 xTr . (29) µ (x) µ
On the lattice this may be formulated as the maximisation of a functional such as, 1 F= Tr Uµ (x) + Uµ† (x) , (30) 2 x,µ which is equivalent to the continuum condition up to O(a2 ), or FImp =
1 4 1 G Uµ (x)UµG (x + µ Tr Uµ (x) + Uµ† (x) − ˆ) + h.c. . 2 x,µ 3 12u0
(31)
(where “h.c.” means hermitian conjugate) which has O(a4 ) errors. The meanfield or tadpole factor
14 1 ReT rPµν u0 = , (32) 3
24
P.O. Bowman et al.
compensates for leading errors in lattice perturbation theory [20]. In this work, configurations generated using the Wilson gauge action will be gauge-fixed using the standard functional, (30) and configurations generated with the improved action will be gauge-fixed with the improved functional, (31). For any given configuration there are, in general, many local extrema of the gauge fixing functional. This was first noticed by Gribov [21] and is true in the continuum and on the lattice for any local gauge fixing functional. This means that the gauge fixed configuration is not uniquely defined. The literature on these “Gribov copies” is huge; see [22, 23, 24] for some recent additions. This ambiguity remains a largely “in principle” problem as it has never been demonstrated to affect QCD. The ghost propagator has been shown to be sensitive to Gribov copies in SU (2) lattice gauge theory [25] and various effects have been attributed to Gribov copies in various models [26]. Despite these problems we persist in studying gauge dependent quantities in Landau gauge, primarily because it is easy to compare results with those derived in the same gauge from other methods. An alternative, which has recently received considerable attention is Laplacian gauge [7]. Laplacian gauge is a nonlinear gauge fixing that respects rotational invariance, has been seen to be smooth, yet is free of Gribov ambiguity. It is also computationally cheaper then Landau gauge. There is, however, more than one way of obtaining such a gauge fixing in SU (N). The three implementations of Laplacian gauge fixing employed here are (in our notation): 1 ∂ 2 (I) gauge (QR decomposition), used by Alexandrou et al. [9]. 2 ∂ 2 (II) gauge, where the Laplacian gauge transformation is projected onto SU(3) by maximising its trace [11]. 3 ∂ 2 (III) gauge (Polar decomposition), the original prescription described in [7] and tested in [8]. All three versions reduce to the same gauge in SU (2). The gauge transformations employed in Laplacian gauge fixing are constructed from the lowest eigenvectors of the covariant lattice Laplacian ∆(U )(x, y)ij v(y)sj = λs v(x)si , (33) y
where ∆(U )(x, y)ij ≡
j
2δ(x − y)δ ij − Uµ (x)ij δ(x + µ ˆ − y) − Uµ (y)†ij δ(y + µ ˆ − x) , µ
(34) i, j = 1, . . . , N for SU (N) and s labels the eigenvalues and eigenvectors. Under gauge transformations of the gauge field, Uµ (x) → UµG (x) = G(x)Uµ (x)G† (x + µ) ,
(35)
the eigenvectors of the covariant Laplacian transform as v(x)s → G(x)v(x)s
(36)
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
25
and this property enables us to construct a gauge fixing that is independent of our starting place in the orbit of gauge equivalent configurations. The three implementations discussed differ in the way that the gauge transformation is constructed from the above eigenvectors. In all cases the resulting gauge should be unambiguous so long as the Nth and (N+1)th eigenvectors are not degenerate and the eigenvectors can be satisfactorily projected onto SU (N). For SU (2) the eigenvectors of the covariant Laplacian are related such that they form the columns of a matrix proportional to an element of SU (2); the projection is thus trivial. This is not the case for SU (N), N > 2. In that case we can think of the projection method as defining its own, unambiguous, Laplacian gauge fixing. In the original formulation [7], ∂ 2 (III) in our notation, the lowest N eigenvectors are required to gauge fix an SU (N) gauge theory. These form the columns of a complex N × N matrix, M (x)ij ≡ v(x)ji
(37)
which is then projected onto SU (N) by polar decomposition. Specifically, it is possible to express M in terms of a unitary matrix and a positive hermitian matrix: M = U P . This decomposition is unique if P = (M † M )1/2 is invertible, which will be true if M is non-singular, i.e., if the eigenvectors used to construct M are linearly independent. The gauge transformation G(x) is then obtained by factoring out the determinant of the unitary matrix G† (x) = U (x)/ det[U (x)] .
(38)
The gauge transformation G(x) obtained in this way is used to transform the gauge field (i.e., the links) to give the Laplacian gauge-fixed gauge field. G(x) can be uniquely defined by this presciption except on a set of gauge orbits with measure zero (with respect to the the gauge-field functional intregral). Note that if we perform a random gauge transformation Gr (x) on the initial gauge field used to define our Laplacian operator, then we will have v(x)s → v (x)s = Gr (x)v(x)s and M (x) → M (x) = Gr (x)M (x). We see that P ≡ (M † M )1/2 → P = P and hence G(x) → G (x) = G(x)G†r (x). When this is applied to the transformed gauge field it will be taken to exactly the same point on the gauge orbit as the original gauge field went to when gauge fixed. Thus all points on the gauge orbit will be mapped to the same single point on the gauge orbit after Laplacian gauge fixing and so it is a complete (i.e., Gribov copy free) gauge fixing. This method was investigated for U (1) and SU (2) [8]. It is clear that any prescription for projecting M onto some G† (x), which preserves the property G(x) → G (x) = G(x)G†r (x) under an arbitrary gauge transformation Gr (x), will also be a Gribov copy free Laplacian gauge fixing. Every different projection method with this property is an equally valid but distinct form of Laplacian gauge fixing. The next approach was used in [9], and we shall refer to it as ∂ 2 (I) gauge. There it was noted that only N − 1 eigenvectors are actually required. To be
26
P.O. Bowman et al.
concrete, we discuss N = 3. First, apply a gauge transformation, G(x)1 , to the first eigenvector such that
G(x)1 v(x)1 1 = ||v(x)1 || (39) and
G(x)1 v(x)1 2 = G(x)1 v(x)1 3 = 0 ,
(40)
where subscripts label the vector elements, i.e., the eigenvector – with dimension 3 – is rotated so that its magnitude is entirely in its first element. Another gauge transformation, G(x)2 , rotates the second eigenvector, v(x)2 , such that
G(x)2 v(x)2 2 = (v22 )2 + (v32 )2 , (41) and
G(x)2 v(x)2 3 = 0 .
(42)
This second rotation is an SU (2) subgroup, which does not act on v12 (x). The gauge fixing transformation is then G(x) = G(x)2 G(x)1 . Compare this to QR decomposition, where a matrix, A, is rewritten as the product of an orthogonal matrix and an upper triangular matrix. The gauge transformations are thus like Householder transformations. In addition, we explore a third version, ∂ 2 (II) gauge, where G(x) is obtained by projecting M (x) onto SU (N) by trace maximisation. M (x) is again composed of the N lowest eigenvectors and the trace of G(x)M (x)† is maximised by iteration over Cabbibo–Marinari subgroups.
4 Staggered Quark Actions Consider the na¨ıve quark action (15) at tree-level, i.e., with Uµ (x) = 1 everywhere. In momentum space, the propagator is 1 γ sin(p µ µ ) + m0 µ
S0 (p) = where the lattice momentum 2πnµ pµ = Lµ
nµ ∈
−Lµ Lµ , 2 2
(43)
(44)
covers the first Brillouin zone. In the massless case, this propagator has a pole at pµ = 0, π for each µ. So a mode with momentum near zero will describe a low momentum continuum quark, but so will a mode with momentum near π. That means the na¨ıve quark action describes 2d = 16 species of degenerate fermions. This is the (in)famous “doubling problem.” Note that QCD only has asymptotic freedom for Nf < 33 2 , and 16 flavours is rather close to this transition. Another consequence of doubling is the loss of the axial anomoly. In continuum QCD, the
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
27
axial symmetry is broken by quantum effects, but on the lattice the doublers of the na¨ıve quark action conspire such that the symmetry breaking terms exactly cancel. As with gauge actions, there are many possible lattice fermion actions that reduce to the desired continuum action. The best known solution to the doubling problem is the Wilson fermion action, which uses a chiral symmetry breaking term to give the doublers mass of O(a−1 ) (the cutoff). This is described in many places [16]. Here we will briefly discuss the other main type of lattice fermion action, the Kogut–Susskind or Staggered action. This presentation follows that of [16, 27]. The principle observation that leads to the staggered formalism is that the doubling problem occurs at the edge of the Brillouin zone. If the available momenta only spanned half the Brillouin zone, there would be no problem. The difficulties lie in recovering the correct theory in the continuum limit. Halving the Brillouin zone is equivalent to doubling the “effective” lattice spacing, so imagine a situation where the field of a particular fermion species is spaced out by two links in every direction. We shall see how it is possible to reduce the 2d Dirac spinors – each with 2d/2 components – to 2d/2 by distributing the degrees of freedom across the hybercube. This process is called “spin diagonalisation.” For concreteness, we shall restrict ourselves to d = 4 (Euclidean) space-time dimensions. Consider the local change of variables ψ(x) = Γ (x)χ(x) ψ(x) = χ(x)Γ † (x)
(45)
where Γ (x) is a unitary 4 × 4 matrix that satisfies Γ † (x)γµ Γ (x + µ) = ηµ (x) .
(46)
Γ (x) = γ1x1 γ2x2 γ3x3 γ4x4
(47)
This is accomplished by
where the staggered phases are: ηµ (x) = (−1)
ν<µ xν
. Explicitly
η1 (x) = 1 η2 (x) = (−1)x1 η3 (x) = (−1)x1 +x2 η4 (x) = (−1)x1 +x2 +x3 Note that (45) is satisfied if χ is a Grassman variable with just one component (although it could have more). We can now write the Kogut–Susskind action S=
1 ηµ (x)χ(x)Dµ χ(x) + m χ(x)χ(x) 2 x,µ x
(48)
28
P.O. Bowman et al.
where D is the lattice covariant derivative given in (15). The Dirac structure has been completely absorbed into the staggered phases, η. To see more clearly what has been done, consider the Staggered action in terms of the hypercubes. We re-label the position vector xµ = 2hµ + ρµ where hµ = 0, . . . ,
Lµ 2
(49)
− 1 and ρµ = 0, 1. Then we define χρ (h) = χ(x)
(50)
giving us a relationship between the single component Grassman fields on a lattice with spacing a and 16 component Grassman fields on a lattice with spacing 2a. From these components one then constructs the four flavoured3 , four component Dirac fields by taking the appropriate linear combinations: (Γρ )αf χρ (h) , (51) ψαf (h) = N ρ
where the Γρ are now
Γρ = γ1ρ1 γ2ρ2 γ3ρ3 γ4ρ4
(52)
and N is a normalisation. So spin-diagonalisation has reduced our 16 Dirac fields to four distributed around a hypercube and the continuum spin-flavours are reconstructed from linear combinations of the staggered. One major advantage of the staggered formulation over the Wilson is that it retains a U(1) × U(1) chiral symmetry. It is not the same symmetry as continuum QCD, but it protects the theory from additive mass renormalisation and ensures that the pion is a genuine Goldstone boson. We will work mostly in momentum space, so it will be necessary to construct the Fourier transform of the Staggered action. In analogy to the “blocking” we performed in coordinate space, we write kµ =
2πnµ Lµ
| nµ = 0, . . . , Lµ − 1
(53)
as kµ = pµ + παµ , where pµ =
2πmµ Lµ
|
mµ = 0, . . . , αµ = 0, 1,
(α is like ρ above) and define 3
k
≡
1 V
k.
Lµ −1 2
(54) (55)
Then
In modern parlance the term “taste” is used to label the would-be degenerate fermion fields, “flavour” referring to the staggered fields themselves [30].
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
= k
(56)
p α =0 µ
eik·x χ(k) =
χ(x) =
1
29
k
ei(p+πα)·x χα (p) .
(57)
p α
Using δ αβ = Πµ δαµ βµ | mod 2 1 if ν < µ θν (µ) = , 0 otherwise
(58) (59)
we can define (γ µ )αβ = (−1)αµ δ α+θ(µ),β
(60)
{γ µ , γ ν }αβ = 2δµν δ αβ
(61)
where the γ µ satisfy
γ †µ
=
γ Tµ
=
γ ∗µ
= γµ ,
(62)
forming a “staggered” Dirac algebra. Putting all this together, we can derive a momentum space expression for the KS action, χα (p) i (γ µ )αβ sin(pµ ) + mδ αβ χβ (p) . (63) S= p αβ
µ
This will be very convenient as it casts the action into a familiar form. The quark action that will be of particular interest to us is the Asqtad quark action [28]. It is a type of fat-link Staggered action using three-link, five-link and seven-link terms to cancel O(a2 ) errors and improve flavour symmetry. There are a number of ingredients to this improvement. In the standard KS action, the derivative term is estimated by a simple nearest-neighbours finite difference. This can be improved by the addition of a three-link, next-to-nearest-neighbours piece, called the Naik term [29]. The coefficients are chosen to eliminate O(a2 ) errors, improving the rotational symmetry of the action. This resulting action is 9 1 Uµ (x)δy,x+ˆµ − Uµ† (x − µ)δy,x−ˆµ ηµ (x)χ(x) 2 x,y,µ 8 1 † U3µ (x)δy,x+3ˆµ − U3µ − (x − 3µ)δy,x−3ˆµ χ(y) + m χ(x)χ(x) 24 x
S=
(64)
Such an action was tested in [27]. Flavour symmetry breaking in this action is still large, but this can be reduced by “fattening” with three, five and seven link terms [28, 31]. The result of this fattening is to reduce the coupling of the quarks to hard gluons with momentum of the order of the cutoff, as this type of gluon
30
P.O. Bowman et al.
exchange results in the flavour-changing interactions that give rise to flavour symmetry breaking. These terms can, however, introduce errors into the lowmomentum behaviour of the quark propagator, but these are compensated for by the addition of a planar five-link Lepage term [32]. All coefficients are tadpole improved, producing the rather sophisticated Asqtad (a2 , tadpole improved) action. At tree-level (i.e. no interations, links set to the identity), the staples in this action make no contribution, so the action reduces to the Naik action. We can perform the same analysis as above to derive the momentum space action which has the tree-level form
9 1 sin(pµ ) − sin(3pµ ) + mδ αβ χβ (p) . χα (p) i (γ µ )αβ sin(pµ ) S= 8 24 p µ αβ
(65)
5 The Lattice Quark Propagator Equation (25) says that the quark propagator is calculated by inverting the fermion matrix. The calculation proceeds thus: 1 A statistical ensemble of lattice gauge configurations is generated by some method, in this case the pseudo heat-bath algorithm. All configurations used here will be quenched (see above). 2 Each configuration is rotated to the desired gauge: Landau or Laplacian. 3 On each configuration, the quark propagator is calculated by S(x, y)K(y, z) = δ(x, z) (66) y
where K is the fermion matrix for either the regular Kogut–Susskind quark action or the Asqtad quark action. The inversion is computed by a suitable method, in this case a multi-mass conjugate gradient algorithm [33]. 4 The propagator is Fourier transformed to momentum space. 5 The result is averaged over all gauge configurations in the ensemble. All quantities calculated on the lattice are dimensionless. While it is possible (in some ways, even preferable) to calculate dimensionless ratios, e.g. ratio of the pion mass to that of the rho: mπ /mρ , we will be mostly interested in dimensionful quantities. To set the scale, the relevant quantity is the cutoff, that is, the lattice spacing, a. Note that it is the coupling, β, that is set in the lattice simulation, not the lattice spacing itself. The lattice spacing must be deduced from some physical quantity such as mρ . We will use the static quark potential [34]. All the simulations discussed will be quenched, as described above. Since the quenched approximation will have a different effect on different quantities, it will also introduce some ambiguity into any determination of that lattice spacing. For this reason, it must be remembered that there is a ∼10% systematic uncertainty
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
31
on all quantities mentioned here in physical units. This is in addition to the quoted statistical uncertainty. In the continuum, Lorentz invariance allows us to decompose the full propagator into Dirac vector and scalar pieces, so in momentum space
or, alternatively,
S −1 (p2 ) = iA(p2 )γ · p + B(p2 )
(67)
S −1 (p2 ) = Z −1 (p2 )[iγ · p + M (p2 )] .
(68)
This is the bare propagator which, once regularised, is related to the renormalised propagator through the renormalisation constant S(a; p2 ) = Z2 (a; µ)S ren (µ; p2 ) ,
(69)
where a is some regularisation parameter, e.g. lattice spacing. Asymptotic freedom implies that, as p2 → ∞, S(p2 ) reduces to the free propagator S −1 (p2 ) → iγ · p + m0 ,
(70)
where m0 is the bare quark mass. From (63) we can see that, in momentum space, the tadpole improved, treelevel form of the KS quark propagator is (including spinor indices, but omitting colour) −1 Sαβ (p; m) = u0 i (γ µ )αβ sin(pµ ) + mδ αβ (71) µ
where pµ is the discrete lattice momentum given by −Lµ Lµ 2πnµ pµ = , nµ ∈ . Lµ 4 4
(72)
Assuming that the full propagator retains this form (in analogy to the continuum case) we write −1 (p) = i (γ µ )αβ sin(pµ )A(p) + B(p)δ αβ Sαβ µ
=Z
−1
(p) i
(γ µ )αβ sin(pµ ) + M (p)δ αβ
.
(73)
µ
For the KS action, it is thus convenient to define qµ ≡ sin(pµ ) .
(74)
We can then decompose the inverse propagator 1 Tr{γ · qS −1 } 16Nc iq 2 Z(q) M (q) = Tr{S −1 } , 16Nc
Z −1 (q) =
(75) (76)
32
P.O. Bowman et al.
where the factor of 16 comes from the trace over the spin-flavour indices of the staggered quarks and Nc from the trace over colour. In actual fact we are able to construct these quantities without inverting the propagator; the above is intended as an instructive example. See the appendix in [3] for details. Note that the decomposition means that we cannot directly measure either of the invariants at zero four-momentum. Comparing (68) and (73) we see that dividing out q 2 in (75) is analagous to dividing out p2 in the continuum and ensures that that Z has the correct asymptotic behaviour. So by considering the propagator as a function of qµ , we ensure that the lattice quark propagator has the correct tree-level form, i.e., 1 (77) S tree (qµ ) = iγ · q + m and hopefully better approximates its continuum behaviour. This is the same philosophy that has been used in studies of the gluon propagator [35, 36] and Clover and Overlap quark propagators [1, 2, 5, 6]. Turning now to the Asqtad action, from (65) we see that the quark propagator with this action has the tree-level form 1 −1 Sαβ (p; m) = u0 i (γ µ )αβ sin(pµ ) 1 + sin2 (pµ ) + mδ αβ , (78) 6 µ so we repeat the above analysis, this time defining 1 2 qµ ≡ sin(pµ ) 1 + sin (pµ ) . 6
(79)
The asymptotic behaviour of the quark propagator, on the lattice and in the continuum, will be discussed in more detail later.
6 Analysis of Lattice Artefacts for Staggered Quarks The quark propagator has been calculated using the Kogut–Susskind and Asqtad actions on Wilson gauge configurations at β = 5.85 and using the Asqtad action on O(a2 ) improved gauge configurations at β = 4.38 and 4.60. Details are given in Table 1. The bare quark masses were chosen to be the same in physical units on each lattice, but differences between the actions will mean that the running masses will not quite match at finite lattice spacing. The √lattice spacings quoted were determined from the static quark potential using σ = 440 MeV [34]. 6.1 Tree-Level Correction As mentioned above, the idea of “kinematic” or “tree-level” correction has been used widely in studies of the gluon propagator [35, 36] and the quark propagator [1, 2, 5, 6] and we investigate its application to our quark propagators.
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
33
Table 1. Details of the lattice simulations Gauge Action
β
Dimensions
a (fm)
Masses (ma)
Wilson
5.85
163 × 32
0.130
0.0125, 0.025, 0.0375, 0.05,
4.60
12 × 24
0.0625, 0.075 Improved
3
0.124
0.012, 0.018, 0.024, 0.036, 0.048, 0.072
Improved
4.60
163 × 32
4.38
16 × 32
0.124
0.012, 0.018, 0.024, 0.036, 0.048, 0.072, 0.108, 0.144
Improved
3
0.166
0.016, 0.024, 0.032, 0.048, 0.064, 0.096, 0.143, 0.191, 0.278
To help us understand the lattice artefacts, we separate the data into momenta lying entirely on a spatial cartesian direction (squares), along the temporal direction (triangles), the four-diagonal (diamonds) or some other combination of directions (circles). All the figures are shown in physical units, as this makes it easiest to compare results from the different lattices. For the moment we shall restrict ourselves to Landau gauge. The Z function is plotted for the KS action in Fig. 1 for a representative quark mass, comparing the results using p and q. Firstly, we comment on the general features of this function. Z is reasonably flat in the ultraviolet, reaching a value around one. This agrees with our expectation from continuum perturbation theory. The function has a dip in the infrared, which has also been seen in Dyson–Schwinger equation studies [37]. In the top of Fig. 1 we see substantial hypercubic artefacts (in particular look at the difference between the diamond and the triangle at around 2.5 GeV). We can suggest that this is caused by violation of rotational symmetry because the agreement between triangles and squares suggests that finite volume effects are small in the region of interest. In the plot below, where q has been used, we see some restoration of rotational symmetry. The same study is made for the Asqtad action in Fig. 2. The general properties are the same as for the KS action except that the infrared dip is more pronounced. The data is significantly smoother and rotational symmetry is much better. Nevertheless there are some signs of rotational symmetry breaking when p is used, and this is almost entirely eliminated when q is the abscissa. The analysis of Sect. 5 does not indicate any preferred momentum variable for the mass function. The question is, “What choice of momentum variable results in the most rapid convergence to the continuum limit?” To explore this we show the quark mass function at two lattice spacings in Fig. 3. The effect is not strong, and for the finer lattice there is negligible asymmetry in any case, but the “action momentum”, q, does improve rotational symmetry on the coarser lattice compared with the standard momentum, p. As remarked above,
34
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 1. Z function for quark mass ma = 0.05 (m 76 MeV) for the KS action in Landau gauge. Top figure is plotted using the standard lattice momentum, p and the bottom uses the “action” momentum, q. Note that this choice affects only the horizontal scale
one choice of bare mass will produce somewhat different running masses in the interacting theory, and this accounts for the slight mismatch between these two mass functions. 6.2 Comparison of the Actions In Fig. 4 the mass function is plotted, in Landau gauge, for both actions with quark mass ma = 0.05. We see that the KS action gives a much larger value for M (0) than the Asqtad action, which is consistent with the mass difference seen in spectroscopic calculations [27]. The KS action also approaches asymptotic behaviour more slowly. The mass function from the Asqtad action shows
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
35
Fig. 2. Z function for quark mass ma = 0.05 (m 76 MeV) for the Asqtad action in Landau gauge. Top figure is plotted using the standard lattice momentum, p and the bottom uses the “action” momentum, q
better rotational symmetry. The relative improvement between the two actions increases as quark mass decreases. Next, we look at the effect of improving the gauge action. In Fig. 5 we show the mass function from the Asqtad quark action and the Wilson gauge action with standard gauge fixing (top) and the Symanzik improved gauge action with O(a2 ) improved gauge fixing (bottom). We see that improving the gauge action does indeed improve the quark propagator, both by providing smoother configurations and because the improved quark action is able to take advantage of the improved behaviour of the gluon action. This suggests that the improvement terms in the Asqtad action are effective at removing O(a2 ) errors.
36
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 3. Choice of momentum: Asqtad quark mass function at β = 4.60 (a 0.124 fm) and β = 4.38 (a 0.167 fm) for bare quark mass m 114 MeV. Top figure uses the na¨ıve lattice momentum, while the bottom figure uses the momentum determined from the tree-level behaviour of the action
6.3 Finite Volume The calculation of any lattice quantity may be affected by the necessarily finite volume. All of the lattices used here are asymmetric in that they are longer in one direction, which we arbitrarily call the time direction. As we have seen above, this asymmetry can be useful in detecting finite volume artefacts. Another way is to perform the calculation on two or more lattices of different size but with fixed lattice spacing. We have done this for the quark propagator and the results are shown in Fig. 6. The change in volume has had a negligible effect on the mass function, from which we deduce that, on the lattices used in this study, finite volume effects are small. There is, however, a significant change in the infrared behaviour of the Z function. It would appear that some of the suppression could be an artefact. The quark mass may have some affect on both of these statements.
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
37
Fig. 4. Mass function for quark mass ma = 0.05 (m 76 MeV), KS action (top) and Asqtad action (bottom) in Landau gauge
Fig. 5. O(a2 ) errors: Asqtad quark mass function for mass m 57 MeV, with the Wilson gauge action at β = 5.85 (a 0.13 fm) (top) and O(a2 ) improved gauge action at β = 4.60 (a 0.124 fm) (bottom) in Landau gauge
38
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 6. Finite volume effects: Asqtad quark mass (top) and Z (bottom) functions for mass m 57 MeV, with the O(a2 ) improved gauge action at β = 4.60 (a 0.124 fm) in Landau gauge. Comparison on 123 × 24 lattice (open circles) and 16 × 32 lattice (filled squares)
7 Overlap Quark Actions Another way of constructing quarks on the lattice is by the overlap fermion formalism [38, 39, 40, 41]. Overlap fermions are free from doublers, that is, there is only one continuum fermion for each lattice fermion, and they realise an exact chiral symmetry even at non-zero lattice spacing. A consequence of this is that they must be O(a) improved, since any O(a) error would necessarily violate chiral symmetry [42]. This lattice realisation of chiral symmetry is called the Ginsparg–Wilson relation [43]. An overlap-Dirac operator is constructed in the following fashion: the massless coordinate-space overlap-Dirac operator can be written in dimensionless lattice units as [41]
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
39
1 [1 + γ5 Ha ] , (80) 2 where Ha is an Hermitian operator that depends on the background gauge field and has eigenvalues ±1. Any such D(0) is easily seen to satisfy the Ginsparg– Wilson relation (81) {γ5 , D(0)} = 2D(0)γ5 D(0) D(0) =
and, provided that its Fourier transform at low momenta is proportional to the momentum space covariant derivative, will satisfy a lattice form of chiral symmetry. It immediately follows from (80) that D† (0)D(0) = D(0)D† (0) = and that
1 † [D (0) + D(0)] 2
(82)
D† (0) = γ5 D(0)γ5 .
(83) −1 It also follows easily that {γ5 , D (0)} = 2γ5 and by defining D (0) ≡ [D−1 (0) − 1] we see that the Ginsparg–Wilson relation can also be expressed in the form −1 (0)} = 0 . (84) {γ5 , D −1
With a suitable choice of Ha (x, y), or kernel, (80) represents a single, massless Dirac fermion. The standard choice of kernel is the sign function of the Hermitian Wilson Dirac operator, Hw , Ha = (Hw ) ≡ Hw /|Hw | = Hw /(Hw† Hw )1/2 ,
(85)
where Hw (x, y) = γ5 Dw (x, y), Dw being the usual (non-Hermitian) Wilson-Dirac operator. However, in the overlap formalism the Wilson mass parameter mw is large and enters the Wilson-Dirac operator with a negative sign. The Wilson mass acts here as a regulator and is chosen such that mw a ∈ (m1 a, m2 a)
(86)
The condition mw a > m1 a ensures that the Wilson operator has zero-crossings and, in turn, that D(0) has nontrivial topological charge. At tree-level, m1 a = 0 and numerical studies have found that in the interacting case, m1 mc , where mc is the usual critical mass for Wilson fermions [44]. The constraint mw a < m2 a arises from the fact that Wilson doublers reappear above this point. At tree-level m2 a = 2. In summary, we use here Hw (−mw ) = γ5 Dw (−mw ). The mean-field improved Wilson-Dirac operator can be written as
Dw (x, y) = (−mw a) + 4r δx,y 1 (r − γµ )Uµ (x)δy,x+ˆµ + (r + γµ )Uµ† (x − aˆ − µ)δy,x−ˆµ 2 µ u0 Uµ (x) = δx,y − κ δy,x+ˆµ (r − γµ ) 2κ u0 µ µ) Uµ† (x − aˆ . (87) + (r + γµ ) δy,x−ˆµ u0
40
P.O. Bowman et al.
The negative Wilson mass (−mw a) is then related to κ by κ≡
u0 , 2(−mw a) + (1/κc )
(88)
and mean-field improvement means that we can use the tree-level value κc = 18 . The Wilson parameter is typically chosen to be r = 1 and we will also use r = 1 here in our numerical simulations. With this choice for the sign function, we have the overlap operator † −1/2 1 , 1 + Dw Dw Dw 2
D(0) =
(89)
and it’s not immediately obvious what connection this has with a Dirac particle. In coordinate space the Wilson-Dirac operator has the form Dw = ∇ / + (r/2)∆ + (−mw a), where ∇µ is the symmetric dimensionless lattice finite difference operator, and ∆ is the dimensionless lattice Laplacian operator. Setting the links to the identity, i.e. the free field, gives ←
→
← →
Dw = (1/2)( ∂ µ + ∂ µ )γµ + (r/2)(− ∂ µ ∂ µ ) + (−mw a) ,
(90)
where the partial derivatives are the forward and backward lattice finite difference operators, f (x) − f (x + a) a → f (x − a) − f (x) . ∂ µ f (x) = a ← ∂µ
f (x) =
Hence we have from (89) that ∇ / + (r/2)∆ − mw a 1 1+ D(0) = 2 (mw a)2 + O(∂ 2 ) →
∇ / , 2mw a
(91)
where the last line is a limit approached when operating on very smooth functions such that only first powers of derivatives are kept. The reason for needing a negative Wilson mass (−mw a) is now apparent, i.e., it is needed to cancel the 1 in D(0). We see that at sufficiently fine lattice spacings and for pa 1 Dc (0) ≡ 2mw D(0) ,
(92)
where Dc (0) in the continuum limit becomes the usual fermion covariant deriv/ as a → 0. To extract ative contracted with the γ-matrices, i.e., Dc (0) → ∇ the propagator for a massless external quark it is necessary to make a simple subtraction
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
41
1 1 −1 1 −1 D (0) . D (0) − 1 = = 2mw 2mw 2mw (93) This definition of the massless overlap quark propagator follows from the overlap formalism and ensures that the massless quark propagator anticommutes with γ5 , i.e., {γ5 , S bare (0)} = 0 just as it does in the continuum [41]. In order to complete the discussion we now generalise the above to the massive case. This is done by simply adding a bare mass to the inverse of the massless propagator, (94) (S bare )−1 (m) ≡ (S bare )−1 (0) + m . c−1 (0) ≡ Dc−1 (0) − S bare (0) ≡ D
It is conventional to define the dimensionless overlap mass parameter µ≡
m 2mw
(95)
c−1 (µ) in analogy with (93) and then define D c−1 (µ) , S bare (m) ≡ D
(96)
c−1 (µ) is a generalisation of D c−1 (0) to the case of nonzero mass. Extending i.e., D the analogy with the massless case we introduce D(µ) and D(µ), which are generalised versions of D(0) and D(0), through the definitions c−1 (µ) ≡ D
1 −1 D (µ) 2mw
−1 (µ) ≡ and D
1 −1 D (µ) − 1 . 1−µ
(97)
We can now use (94) and the above definitions to obtain an expression for D(µ). From (94), (95) and (97) we see that we must have D(µ) = D(0) + µ. Inverting this gives
−1 1 −1 D (µ) − 1 = D(0) +µ (98) 1−µ and so
−1
−1 D−1 (µ) = (1 − µ) D(0) +µ + 1 = D(0) + 1 D(0) +µ . Inverting gives
−1 D(µ) = D(0) + µ D(0) +1
(99)
−1 and also D(0) = D(0) D(0) +1 (100)
and so finally
−1 D(µ) = (1 − µ)D(0) + µ D(0) + 1 D(0) +1 1 = (1 − µ)D(0) + µ = [1 + µ + (1 − µ)γ5 Ha ] . 2
(101)
We have recovered the standard expression for D(µ) found, for example, in [41] and elsewhere. We see that the massless limit, m → 0, implies that µ → 0 and −1 (0) and D c−1 (µ) → D c−1 (0). For non-negative bare −1 (µ) → D D(µ) → D(0), D
42
P.O. Bowman et al.
mass m we require µ ≥ 0. In order that the above expressions and manipulations be well-defined we must have µ < 1. Hence, 0 ≤ µ < 1 defines the allowable range of bare masses. Due to the square-root in (89), the Overlap operator at any one point on the lattice depends on every point on the lattice. This makes it particularly expensive to calculate. Instead we approximate the sign function with the optimal rational polynomial approximation of Zolotarev [45, 46]. A 14th order polynomial is seen to be sufficient. As the approximation can be poor when the argument is near zero, the lowest 10–20 eigenvectors are first projected out and handled exactly. The speed with which the Overlap operator can be evaluated is strongly dependent on the density of low-lying eigenmodes and some improvement can be made through different gauge actions [47] and different Overlap kernels [48, 49].
8 Analysis of Lattice Artefacts for Overlap Quarks The quark propagator has been calculated using the Overlap-Dirac operator with the Wilson kernel on O(a2 ) improved gauge configurations at β = 4.286 and 4.60. There are also preliminary results from an ensemble with β = 4.80. These lattices were selected to have the same physical volume of approximately 1.53 × 3.0 fm4 . Details are given in Table 2. Again, the bare quark masses were chosen to be the same in physical units on each lattice, but at these couplings the resulting running masses will be slightly different. According to (95), the chosen mass parameters, µ, approximately correspond to bare masses in physical units of m = 106, 124, 142, 177, 212, 266, 354, 442, 531 and 620 MeV. For the regulator mass in the Wilson-Dirac operator κ = 0.19163 was used for all three lattices, corresponding to mw a = 1.391. Table 2. Details of the lattice simulations with the Overlap quark action β
Dimensions
a (fm)
Mass Parameter (µ)
4.286
83 × 16
0.190
0.0368, 0.0429, 0.0490, 0.0613, 0.0735,
4.60
12 × 24
0.0919, 0.1226, 0.1532, 0.1839, 0.2145 3
0.124
0.024, 0.028, 0.032, 0.040, 0.048, 0.060, 0.080, 0.100, 0.120, 0.140
4.80
163 × 32
0.093
0.018, 0.021, 0.024, 0.030, 0.036, 0.045, 0.060, 0.075, 0.090, 0.105
8.1 Tree-level Correction The tree-level form of the overlap quark propagator was derived in the appendix of [5]. It can also be deduced by calculating the quark propagator on a trivial configuration (i.e., by setting all links to the identity). The result is shown in Fig. 7.
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
43
Fig. 7. Tree-level propagator: This figure shows the Dirac vector part of the Overlap propagator, qµ (open circles) as a function of the momentum, pµ calculated on the trivial configuration. The line shows the ideal, continuum case. For comparison, the same part of the Asqtad (Naik) propagator is also shown (open triangles)
It can be seen from Fig. 7 that q approaches p for small momenta, which is necessary for the Overlap operator to describe a Dirac fermion, and q takes a single value for each p, which means that there are no doublers. In the large momentum region, p and q diverge rapidly, which means that – unlike the staggered case – the choice of kinematic momentum can strongly affect the propagator. Unfortunately, for the Overlap propagator we do not see the clear restoration of rotational symmetry when the kinematic momentum is used. For this reason, we need to be a little more sophisticated in our approach to tree-level correction. The question is: for what choice of momentum does the Overlap quark propagator most rapidly approach its continuum form? To answer this we show the quark Z function for each of the lattice spacings available in Fig. 8. The data has been cylinder cut which trims some of the most obvious lattice artefacts. This is useful for when comparing two data sets and is explained in [36]. The three data sets do indeed appear to be converging to a common result when considered as a function of q, while there is a lack of consensus as a function of p. We also show a direct comparison with the Asqtad results in Fig. 10. For closest agreement, the kinematic momenta for the respective actions should be used. As with the Asqtad action, the tree-level analysis does not suggest an optimal choice of momentum variable for the quark mass function. Once again, we shall take an empirical approach, testing the p and q. Figure 9 shows M as a function of p and of q for each lattice spacing. We see better agreement between the results for different lattice spacings when the standard lattice momentum, p is used. It goes without saying that the choices converge in the continuum limit. In fact, at β = 4.80 the difference is quite small.
44
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 8. Z function for the Overlap action at each lattice spacing for one quark mass (m 106 MeV). Data has been cylinder cut. In the top figure the kinematic momentum derived from the tree-level form of the action, q, is used, while in the bottom figure the standard lattice momentum, p, is used. Greatest consistency between the results for the different lattice spacings is seen when q is used
8.2 Comparison with the Asqtad Action We have calculated the quark propagator using Asqtad and Overlap quark actions on one common set of gauge configurations, 123 × 24 at β = 4.60. This allows us to closely study differences induced only by choice of quark action. In all cases, we show results using 50 configurations for the Overlap action and 100 configurations for the Asqtad action. Figure 10 shows Z for the two actions at comparable masses (approximately 110 MeV). As these are bare quantites, they have been normalised at 3 GeV for the purpose of close comparison. While the Asqtad action produces a Z with near perfect rotational symmetry, the Overlap action shows some clear rotation
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
45
Fig. 9. Mass functions for the Overlap quark propagator for fixed bare mass at each lattice spacing. The top figure uses the standard lattice momentum and the bottom figure uses the action-derived momentum. Convergence appears to be most rapid using the standard lattice momentum, p. Data has been cylinder cut
symmetry breaking. This is consistent with the O(a4 ) improvement of the Asqtad action. Nonetheless, the two are in good agreement. Tree-level correction is an important ingredient in producing this agreement. Figure 11 shows the mass function for the two actions at comparable quark masses while Fig. 12 shows a comparison in the chiral limit. Both of the calculations were performed on the same gauge configurations. At finite quark mass the two actions are in excellent quantitative agreement and both show good rotational symmetry and ultraviolet behaviour. In the chiral limit there is good qualitative agreement, the chiral extrapolation probably accounting for the small difference.
46
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 10. Comparison between Asqtad and Overlap actions for comparable quark masses (∼110 MeV). The Z function is shown for β = 4.60 on the 123 × 24 lattice using the kinematic momenta of the respective actions. The data sets have been cylinder cut and normalised at 3 GeV
Fig. 11. Mass functions for the Asqtad and Overlap quark actions for comparable quark masses (ma = 0.072 and µ = 0.024). Data is from the 123 × 24 lattice at β = 4.60. For the Asqtad action, the mass function is shown as a function of q, while for the Overlap action we have used p. The Asqtad result represents 100 configurations while the Overlap results comes from 50 configurations. They are in good agreement and both actions show good ultraviolet behaviour
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
47
Fig. 12. Mass functions in the chiral limit for the Overlap (filled squares) and Asqtad (open circles) quark actions. Data is from the 123 × 24 lattice at β = 4.60 and has been extrapolated to the chiral limit with a straight line fit. The Overlap result was extrapolated from rather heavier quarks than the Asqtad
9 The Quark Propagator in Landau Gauge Now informed by the previous sections as to the strengths and weaknesses of our simulations, we shall draw some conclusions as to the overall behaviour of the quark propagator in Landau gauge. In all cases the quark Z function is supressed in the infrared. For the lightest masses we see little mass dependence – see Fig. 13 – but for heavier masses Z does start to flatten out. Unfortunately, data for the widest range of masses is only available for the small lattices and as we saw in Fig. 6 the quark Z function suffers from some finite size effects at this volume. In any case, at small quark masses the infrared behaviour of Z deviates significantly from it’s perturbative form. By affecting the propagator’s analytic properties, non-trivial behaviour in Z could indicate confinement. One possible quark confinement scenario is that Z vanishes at the mass shell, preventing a pole [50]. Calculations on a larger volume may help to shed light on this matter. The quark mass function manifestly shows dynamical mass generation, with a dramatic infrared enhancement starting around 1.5 GeV. A sample of mass functions is shown in Fig. 14. One question that is often asked about quarks is, “How light is ‘light’ ?”. For our lightest quark masses we see that while the asymptotic value of M (p) is proportional to the bare quark mass, the infrared value is independent of the bare quark mass. One measure of this can be seen in Table 4. In this regime dynamical chiral symmetry breaking clearly dominates. As the bare quark mass increases, explicit chiral symmetry breaking takes over. The infrared behaviour becomes modified and the mass function eventually becomes flat. This transition occurs around the strange quark mass. This transition deserves further study. For the mass function there are no noticeable finite volume effects on the lattices studied.
48
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 13. Mass dependence: Comparison of the Landau gauge quark Z functions for three bare quark masses. The data is for the Asqtad action with quark masses ma = 0.036, 0.075 and 0.144. Data has been cylinder cut. We see that over this range of values the mass dependence of the Z function is very weak
Fig. 14. Mass dependence: Comparison of the Landau gauge quark mass functions for a selection of bare quark masses. The data is for the Overlap action with quark masses µ = 0.024, 0.032, 0.048, 0.080 and 0.120. Data has been cylinder cut. We see that the mass function clear displays dynamical mass generation, but flattens out as the quarks become heavy
To study the chiral limit we extrapolate the mass function to zero bare quark mass using a quadratic fit. The result is shown in Fig. 15. At large momenta the mass function should go like the running mass, so we expect that the chiral extrapolation should follow a straight line in this region. In the infrared however, some nonlinear behaviour is expected, but we have no detailed knowledge of what form it should take. The quadratic fit does a good job of describing the
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
49
Fig. 15. Chiral limit: Landau gauge quark mass function extrapolated to the chiral limit by quadratic fit to the Asqtad mass function at each quark mass. At large momentum, the mass function is zero, consistent with a massless quark, but is steeply enhanced in the infrared
data over a wide range of momenta, however there is some indication of more complicated behaviour for the lowest masses at the lowest momenta. A recent Dyson–Schwinger equation study suggests that the infrared enhancement of the mass function should be occur more rapidly (as a function of momentum) in the chiral limit [37]. In other words, the peak should be narrower. The small difference between the Asqtad and Overlap results in this region may support that conclusion. This will be studied in more detail in a future publication.
10 Laplacian Gauge Now we will consider the quark propagator in the Laplacian gauges as well as Landau gauge. This was first done in [3]. The results shown here are from the Asqtad action. 10.1 Comparitive Performance of Landau and Laplacian Gauges Figure 16 shows the mass function for the Asqtad action in ∂ 2 (I) and ∂ 2 (II) gauges and it should be compared with the equivalent Landau gauge result at the bottom of Fig. 5. We see firstly that these three gauges give very similar results (we shall investigate this in more detail later) and secondly that they give similar performance in terms of rotational symmetry and statistical noise. Looking more closely, we can see that the Landau gauge gives a slightly cleaner signal at this lattice spacing. ∂ 2 (III) was seen in [3] to be a numerically poor algorithm. The gauge fixing procedure failed for four of the configurations and eight of the remaining
50
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 16. Mass function for quark mass ma = 0.036 (m 57 MeV), Asqtad action in ∂ 2 (I) and ∂ 2 (II) gauges. Figure 19 shows a direct comparison with Landau gauge
configurations produced Z and M functions with pathological negative values. We have seen that this type of gauge fixing fails to produce a gluon propagator that has the correct asymptotic behaviour [11]. We are dealing with matrices with vanishing determinants, which are destroying the projection onto SU (3). We expect the degree to which this problem occurs to be dependent on the simulation parameters and the numerical precision used (in this work the gauge transformations were calculated in single precision). 10.2 Gauge Dependence Now we investigate the quark mass and Z functions in Landau, ∂ 2 (I) and ∂ 2 (II) gauges. Figure 17 shows the Z function for the Asqtad action in Landau, ∂ 2 (I) and ∂ 2 (II) gauges. They are in excellent agreement in the ultraviolet, but differ
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
51
Fig. 17. Comparison of the quark Z functions for the Asqtad action for quark mass ma = 0.036. Data has been cylinder cut
significantly in the infrared. The Z function in the Laplacian gauges is more strongly infrared suppressed than in the Landau gauge. There is a small difference in Z(q 2 ) between ∂ 2 (I) and ∂ 2 (II) gauges. In all cases the quark Z function demonstrates little mass dependence. Deviation of Z from its asymptotic value of 1 is a sign of dynamical symmetry breaking, so we expect the infrared suppression to go away in the limit of an infinitely heavy quark. The two are the same, to within errors, although if we look at the lowest momentum data we see that the point for the low mass lies below the high mass one. Figure 18 shows Z in ∂ 2 (II) gauge for three quark masses. Again, the data are consistent, to within errors, but there is a systematic ordering of lightest to heaviest. Compare with Fig. 13. We conclude from this that the behaviour is consistent with expectations, dependence on the quark mass – if any – is very weak. One possible explanation is that all the masses studied are light – less than or approximately equal to the stange quark mass – and that heavier masses will affect the Z function more clearly. The mass functions in Landau, ∂ 2 (I) and ∂ 2 (II) gauges – shown in Fig. 19 – agree to within errors. The level of agreement is greater than that reported in [3], which further suggests that they are the same in the continuum limit.
11 Applications: The Condensate and Running Mass As we have already remarked, although the quark propagator is gauge dependent, and hence not observable, certain gauge invariant quantities can be extracted from it directly. In the continuum, the quark mass function has the asymptotic form, dM −1 c
m ln(q 2 /Λ2QCD ) +
(102) M (q 2 ) 2 = dM 2 q →∞ q 2 ln(q /Λ2 ) QCD
52
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 18. Comparison of the quark Z functions for three quark masses ma = 0.012, 0.075 and 0.144, with the Asqtad action in ∂ 2 (II) gauge. Data has been cylinder cut. As in Landau gauge, Z shows little sensitivity to changing quark mass over this range
Fig. 19. Comparison of the quark mass functions for the Asqtad action, ma = 0.036. Data has been cylinder cut
(see equation (6.15) in [50]) where m is the RGI (renormalisation group invariant) mass and the anomalous dimension of the quark mass is dM = 12/(33 − 2Nf ) for Nf quark flavours (zero here). In this form the fact that the mass function is independent of the choice of renormalisation point is manifest. The first term in (102) is of nonperturbative origin and, in the chiral limit, a non-zero value for c indicates the spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry. In this case it is related to the usual chiral condensate by c −
ψψ 4π 2 dM , 2 3 [ln(µ /Λ2QCD )]dM
(103)
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
53
Fig. 20. Fit of the asymptotic form of the mass function (102) to the Asqtad lattice data in the chiral limit. In the infrared, this form diverges rapidly
where µ2 is a choice of renormalisation point. The second term in (102) comes from perturbation theory (one-loop) and breaks chiral symmetry explicitly. The RGI quark mass in (102) can be replaced by the running quark mass, m = m(µ2 )[ln(µ2 /Λ2QCD )]dM
(104)
which can, in turn, be related the bare quark mass through some renormalisation condition. Equation (102) has been fit to the data from the chiral extrapolation of the Asqtad action, shown in Fig. 20. For that action the fit region corresponds to 1.9–2.9 GeV, which includes 51 data points, a fit region chosen to minimise χ2 . We use ΛMOM QCD at 691 MeV. This was computed by taking the ALPHA result of ΛMS QCD = 239 MeV [51] and converting it to the MOM scheme as described in [52]. With good enough data, it would be possible to simultaneously fit for the quark mass (or chiral condensate) and ΛQCD , but it is difficult to extract a quantity on which there is only a logarithmic dependence. A finer lattice would be necessary, so that more ultraviolet physics could be sampled, with more configurations to improve the statistics. From (103), we find for the condensate, (−ψψ)1/3 = 274(24) MeV , at the renomalisation point µ = 2 GeV; the quoted error is purely statistical. It is remarkable that the asymptotic form provides such a good description of the lattice data from ∼1 GeV. Having fit the asymptotic form to the quark mass function we should also be able to calculate the quark mass, but there is one piece of information missing from Table 3. The effect of the bare quark mass on physical quantities is theory dependent; we have no a priori knowledge of where the physical point lies. We can
54
P.O. Bowman et al.
Table 3. Results for the fit to (102). The fit region corresponds to 1.9–2.9 GeV, which includes 51 data points, and was chosen to minimise χ2 /d.o.f. In the chiral limit this gives a value for the condensate of (−ψψ )1/3 = 274(24) MeV at the renomalisation point µ = 2 GeV am
a3 c
m (MeV)
χ2 / d.o.f.
0
0.018(6)
0
0.52
0.012
0.019(3)
28(2)
0.57
0.018
0.014(12)
44(5)
0.54
0.024
0.0096(47)
59(3)
0.52
0.036
0.0026(104)
90(5)
0.49
0.048
0.086(3)
137(4)
0.46
0.072
0.130(3)
204(5)
0.40
0.108
0.190(3)
300(5)
0.31
0.144
0.251(5)
397(8)
0.25
match a physical quantity to its real world value and thus extract the relevant bare mass for that particular action, with those particular lattice parameters. In this case we choose the Asqtad quark action on the 163 × 32 lattice at β = 4.60 and set the “physical” bare quark mass by extrapolation to the physical pion mass. We fit the five lowest π masses to the form √ amπ = a2 Bm , (105)
Fig. 21. m2π versus m for the Asqtad quark action and a fit to (105)
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
55
the lowest order result from chiral perturbation theory. For the higher masses, the data deviates from this form due to the contribution from higher order terms; in the heavy quark limit mπ ∝ m. The U(1) chiral symmetry of staggered quarks ensures that there is no additive mass renormalisation. To find the physical point we find the bare mass corresponding to mπ = 140 MeV for each jackknife bin and get am = 0.00215(1). Then we fit the lowest four RGI masses in Table 3 to the form am = Aam (106) and find A = 1.57(16). Putting these together we get m = 5.3(6) MeV . The RGI quark mass in (102) is related to the running quark mass through (104). Thus by choosing the renormalisation point µ = 2 GeV and inserting ΛMS QCD = 239 MeV, we get m(µ = 2 GeV)MS = 3.1(4) MeV ,
or with ΛMOM QCD = 691 MeV,
m(µ = 2 GeV)MOM = 4.0(5) MeV . This result compares favourably with the Particle Data Group’s number for the average of the up and down quark masses [53], m(µ = 2 GeV)MS = 2.5 − 5.5 MeV . The curious behaviour of the condensate term at small masses is easily explained. The asymptotic behaviour of the quark mass function quickly becomes dominated by the explicit chiral symmetry breaking mass; at the same time, large fluctuations make the mass function relatively noisy at these masses. Together, that means that sensitivity of the fit to the first term in (102) is lost. At larger masses, the signal becomes cleaner and statistical errors shrink, restoring stability to the fits. One way of countering this effect is to fix ac at each light mass to some reasonable value given the chiral and heavy quark values. The resulting RGI masses are consistent with the ones in Table 3, so we expect the systematic error from this effect to be small. This calculation is, of course, quenched. There are also systematic errors associated with the extrapolations. A more sophisticated approach, such as an extrapolation motivated by finite-range regulated [54] staggered chiral perturabtion theory [55], is certainly to be desired. Such an approach could also provide a handle on the uncertainty associated with quenching. Finally, we should realise that this is a rather audacious approach: we are exploiting ultraviolet physics on a relatively coarse lattice. It is very encouraging, however, that we are able to get such a promising result with such modest resources. The choices of improved quark and gauge actions are essential to this.
56
P.O. Bowman et al.
12 Modelling the Mass Function The QCD Green’s functions continue to provide a fruitful area of interaction between various hadronic methods. As stated above, the quark propagator is used in a number of nonperturbative schemes; see [12, 13, 14, 56, 57, 58, 59] for a few examples. As a first principles approach, lattice QCD can provide valuable input, and by exploiting the strengths of other approaches we can gain insight to possible difficulties of current lattice simulations. With these things in mind we attempt to model the lattice data and to compare the data directly to other models. We look once again at the Asqtad data for the 163 × 32, β = 4.60 ensemble. A fit to the mass function for each bare mass was performed using the ansatz M (q 2 ) =
cλ2(α−1) +m . q 2α + λ2α
(107)
This is the same as the ansatz used in [3], but written slightly differently: in this case c has dimension [mass3 ]. This model was used to approximate derivatives of the quark propagator in a study of the quark-gluon vertex [60]. Fit results are shown in Table 4 and sample fits are shown in Fig. 22. From these we can see that this three-parameter form does indeed describe the data well, across the whole range of quark masses studies (m 0 → 230 MeV). Also, to make some assessment of the dependence of the chiral limit result to our extrapolation, we use both a linear and a quadratic extrapolation and compare the fit results. The two results agree, but statistical errors are large. At the smallest masses there is a lot of noise in the lowest momentum points, resulting in some uncertainty in this important region. The existence of a “light quark regime,” where the low momentum physics is essentially independent of the quark mass, has Table 4. Best-fit parameters for the ansatz (107), in Landau gauge. The first set of data at zero mass is for a linear extrapolation, the second for a quadratic extrapolation am
a3 c
λ (MeV) m (MeV) α
M (0) (MeV) χ2 / d.o.f.
linear quadratic 0.012 0.018 0.024 0.036 0.048 0.072 0.108 0.144
0.042(3) 0.040(3) 0.043(2) 0.044(2) 0.045(2) 0.046(2) 0.050(3) 0.059(2) 0.071(5) 0.090(9)
757(48) 719(50) 777(35) 795(28) 820(29) 802(27) 838(27) 946(29) 997(27) 1100(32)
289(22) 302(33) 308(19) 311(13) 313(11) 353(10) 370(9) 397(12) 478(4) 547(4)
0 0 25(2) 37(2) 49(2) 70(3) 92(3) 138(5) 199(6) 255(10)
1.43(9) 1.47(11) 1.51(2) 1.50(2) 1.48(2) 1.31(1) 1.28(1) 1.30(8) 1.12(3) 1.01(5)
0.21 0.72 0.70 0.65 0.60 0.53 0.48 0.44 0.37 0.35
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
57
Fig. 22. Modelling the mass function: sample fits of the ansatz (107). The ansatz is fit to data in chiral limit (top) and for am = 0.144 (bottom). In both cases this ansatz provides an excellent description of the data. The fit parameters are given in Table 4
already been remarked upon. Table 4 would suggest that this regime ends where the asymptotic mass is around 70 MeV. In this model, α is acting as a function of the bare mass, controlling the dynamical symmetry breaking. The model gives a value for the quark mass at zero four-momentum of around 300 MeV, consistent with the idea that this should be the constituent quark mass. Although this model does not have the correct asymptotic behaviour, this is simple to correct. As the model ansatz falls away faster than q −2 , the correct asymptotic behaviour, (102), can be added on. Such an ansatz does not, however, improve the overall fit to this data. More points in the ultraviolet are required. In [57] a model quark propagator was used as input for the Fadde’ev equation, which was used for the calculation of electromagnetic form factors. One of the ans¨ atze considered was
58
P.O. Bowman et al.
q 2 + c22 c23
2 1 − e−y M (q 2 ) = c1 y y=
(108) (109)
which was fit to some earlier lattice data [3] with c3 fixed at 1 GeV. This model has the advantage of being an entire function. We have performed a fit of this generalised form – where c3 is determined by the fit – to this newer data, the results of which are shown in Fig. 23. It is clear that this describes the data well, and so may find more general application.
Fig. 23. Fit to the mass function in the chiral limit using (109). This ansatz has the virtue of being analytic everywhere. Parameters were determined by least χ2 fit. c1 = 440(32) MeV, c2 = 539(18) MeV, c3 = 831(40) MeV, χ2 /d.o.f = 0.89
In [56] the authors suggested a novel form of the quark mass function which actually vanishes at zero four-momentum. The ansatz 1 − 1 − q 2 Q2 (q 2 ) 2 , (110) M (q ) = Q(q 2 ) where
−ψψ 16π 2 −q2 /λ2 e , (111) 2Nc λ4 is based on the Constrained Instanton Model and QCD sum rules with nonlocal condensates. In Fig. 24 we show two versions, one using the values for the parameters published in [56] and one where the parameters have been determined by best fit to the lattice data. This form is not favoured by the lattice data. It is fascinating that such a form should be consistent with the phenomenological constraints discussed in [56] and demonstrates the utility of the first-principles calculations presented here. Q(q 2 ) =
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
59
Fig. 24. Fit to the mass function in the chiral limit using (110). The long dashes are for the parameters of [56]: λ = 554 MeV, ψψ 1/3 = −225 MeV, χ2 /dof = 6.2; short dashes are for a best fit to the data: Λ = 719(31) MeV, ψψ 1/3 = −246(5) MeV, χ2 /d.o.f = 4.1
Finally, we consider the instanton model of Diakonov. There the quark mass function takes the form [12] M (q) = M (0)F 2 (z)
K1 (z) F (z) = 2z I0 (z)K1 (z) − I1 (z)K0 (z) − I1 (z) z ρ z =q 2
(112) (113) (114)
where the I’s and K’s are the modified Bessel functions. The parameters M (0) = 350 MeV and ρ−1 = 600 MeV are derived from the standard values of the instanton ensemble. This two parameter form has a good correspondance with the lattice data, as shown in Fig. 25, without any fit parameters. Asymptotically, for this model M (q) ∼ q −6 . There is also good agreement between these results and recent Dyson– Schwinger equation studies [14, 37, 59]. In return, some studies suggest that the mass function should be somewhat narrower in the chiral limit than the results presented here [37, 57]. Better control of the chiral extrapolation is clearly necessary, and studies in this area are underway. Other discrepancies may be due to the quenched approximation and calculations with dynamical configurations are also now underway.
13 Conclusions We have seen that the Overlap and Asqtad actions provide a quark propagator with excellent rotational symmetry, scaling and ultraviolet behaviour. Both are
60
P.O. Bowman et al.
Fig. 25. The quark mass function in the chiral limit from the instanton model of [12] compared with our data. There has been no fit, instead we have used the published parameters M (0) = 350 MeV and ρ−1 = 600 MeV
therefore suitable for quark propagator studies. Results from the two actions are in good agreement. Overall the Landau gauge results shown in this work are consistent with the results of earlier studies [1, 2]. For the purpose of a detailed study of the quark propagator, the actions employed in the present work are, however, clearly superior to the Clover action. Quark-gluon vertex studies should derive great benefit from the use of Overlap and/or Asqtad actions. Our results show that the quark mass function in Landau gauge has a large enhancement near zero four-momentum and drops rapidly to something like its expected asymptotic behaviour by around 2 GeV. The mass function is – to within statistics – the same in ∂ 2 (I) and ∂ 2 (II) gauges as it is in Landau gauge. We observe somewhat greater noise in the Laplacian gauges at these lattice spacings. The wavefunction renormalisation, Z appears to be infrared suppressed. It exhibits a weak mass dependence, but finite volume effects may be significant with the present simulation parameters. The infrared dip is even stronger in the Laplacian gauges. ∂ 2 (I) and ∂ 2 (II) differ by a small amount. Dynamical chiral symmetry breaking is manifest in the quark propagator, but the other striking feature of QCD, confinement, is not so obvious4 . By matching the tree-level corrected quark propagator to its continuum asymptotic form we have been able to extract quenched estimates of the isospinaveraged chiral condensate and running quark mass. Both results are consistent with those from other studies and can be greatly improved upon by using finer lattices. With good enough data we could also calculate ΛQCD . Most importantly, the techniques used are immediately applicable to unquenched data, when it is available. We have also proposed a simple model for the mass function, and given 4
As this article was being completed a discussion of this issue appeared [61].
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
61
a brief example of the light that this line of research can shed on other hadronic calculations. In this work the chiral limit was obtained by simple linear and quadratic extrapolations, which may provide a source of systematic error. Both the Asqtad and Overlap actions provide the possibility of studying the propagator at very light masses, but larger lattices are required to properly pin-down the correct behaviour. It will be very interesting to compare this behaviour with recent DSE results [37]. All the data shown here in this work was quenched, but calcuations with dynamical configurations are underway and a detailed study of the effects of unquenching will be forthcoming.
Acknowledgements The authors wish to thank Jonivar Skullerud, Constantia Alexandrou and Waseem Kamleh for useful discussions, as well as the organisers of the Lattice Hadron Physics workshop (Cairns, 2001). We also thank Ryan Coad for careful reading of the manuscript and constructive feedback. Generous grants of supercomputer time from the Australian Partnership for Advanced Computing (APAC) and the Australian National Computing Facility for Lattice Gauge Theory are gratefully acknowledged. This work was supported in part by the Australian Research Council.
References 1. J-I. Skullerud, A.G. Williams: Quark Propagator in Landau Gauge, Phys. Rev. D 63, 054508 (2001) 17, 32, 60 2. J-I. Skullerud, D.B. Leinweber, A.G. Williams: Nonperturbative Improvement and Tree-level Correction of the Quark Propagator, Phys. Rev. D 64, 074508 (2001) 17, 32, 60 3. P. O. Bowman, U.M. Heller, A.G. Williams: Lattice quark propagator with staggered quarks in Landau and Laplacian gauges, Phys. Rev. D 66, 014505 (2002) 17, 32, 49, 51, 56, 58 4. P. O. Bowman, U. M. Heller, D. B. Leinweber, A.G. Williams: Modelling the quark propagator, hep-lat/0209129 17 5. F. D. R. Bonnet, P. O. Bowman, D. B. Leinweber, A. G. Williams, J. Zhang: Overlap Quark Propagator in Landau Gauge, Phys. Rev. D 65, 114503 (2002) 17, 32, 42 6. J. B. Zhang, F. D. R. Bonnet, P. O. Bowman, D. B. Leinweber, A. G. Williams: Scaling behavior of the overlap quark propagator in Landau gauge, hep-lat/0301018 17, 32 7. J. C. Vink, U-J. Wiese: Gauge Fixing on the Lattice without Ambiguity, Phys. Lett. B 289, 122 (1992) 18, 24, 25 8. J. C. Vink: Investigation of Laplacian Gauge Fixing for U(1) and SU (2) Gauge fields, Phys. Rev. D 51, 1292 (1995) 18, 24, 25 9. C. Alexandrou, Ph. de Forcrand, E. Follana: The Gluon Propagator without lattice Gribov copies, Phys. Rev. D 63, 094504 (2001) 18, 24, 25 10. C. Alexandrou, Ph. de Forcrand, E. Follana: The Gluon Propagator without lattice Gribov copies on a finer lattice, Phys. Rev. D 65, 114508 (2002) 18 11. P. O. Bowman, U. M. Heller, D. B. Leinweber, A.G. Williams: Gluon propagator on coarse lattices in Laplacian gauges, Phys. Rev. D 66, 074505 (2002) 18, 24, 50
62
P.O. Bowman et al.
12. D. Diakonov: Instantons at Work, hep-ph/0212026 18, 56, 59, 60 13. E. R. Arriola, W. Broniowski: Spectral quark model and low-energy hadron phenomenology, Phys. Rev. D 67, 074021 (2003) 18, 56 14. M. A. Pichowsky: Recent Advances in Dyson–Schwinger Studies, Plenary talk at NSTAR 2002, Workshop on the Physics of Excited Nucleons, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, 9–12 Oct 2002, nucl-th/0302026 18, 56, 59 15. Rudolf Haag: Local Quantum Physics, (Springer–Verlag 1993) 19 16. Heinz J. Rothe: Lattice Gauge Theories: An Introduction, (World Scientific, Singapore 1997) 21, 27 17. Taizo Muta: Foundations of Quantum Chromodynamics, 2nd edn. (World Scientific, Singapore 1998) 21 18. F. D. R. Bonnet, P. O. Bowman, D. B. Leinweber, D. G. Richards, A.G. Williams: Aust. J. Phys. 52, 939 (1999); Nucl. Phys. B (Proc. Suppl.) 83–84, 905 (2000) 23 19. P. O. Bowman: On Improvement in the Study of the Lattice Gluon Propagator. PhD Thesis, University of Adelaide, Adelaide (2000) 23 20. G. P. Lepage, P. B. Mackenzie: Phys. Rev. D 48, 2250 (1993) 24 21. V.N. Gribov: Nucl. Phys. B 139, 1 (1978) 24 22. K. Langfeld: The Gribov problem and its solution from a toy model point of view, hep-lat/0301007 24 23. A. G. Williams: Lattice QCD, gauge fixing, and the transition to the perturbative regime, hep-lat/0212038 24 24. D. H. Adams: Gauge fixing, families index theory, and topological features of the space of lattice gauge field, Nucl. Phys. B 640, 435 (2002) 24 25. A. Cucchieri: Nucl. Phys. B 508, 353 (1997) 24 26. M. N. Chernodub, E.-M. Ilgenfritz, A. Schiller: Monopoles, confinement and the photon propagator in QED3 , hep-lat/0208028 24 27. MILC collaboration (C.W. Bernard et al.): Quenched hadron spectroscopy with improved staggered quark action, Phys. Rev. D 58, 014503 (1998) 27, 29, 34 28. K. Orginos, D. Toussaint, R. L. Sugar: Variants of fattening and flavor symmetry restoration, Phys. Rev. D 60, 054503 (1999) 29 29. S. Naik: , Nucl. Phys. B 316, 238 (1989) 29 30. Q. Mason, P. Lepage, P. Mackenzie, H. Trottier, J. Hein, C. Davies, E. Follana: Taste-changing in staggered quarks, hep-lat/0209152arXiv:hep-lat/0209152. 28 31. J.-F. Laga¨e, D. K. Sinclair: Improved staggered quark actions with reduced flavour symmetry violations for lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. D 59, 014511 (1999) 29 32. G. P. Lepage: Flavor-Symmetry Restoration and Symanzik Improvement for Staggered Quarks, Phys. Rev. D 59, 074502 (1999) 30 33. B. Jegerlehner: Krylov space solvers for shifted linear systems, hep-lat/9612014 30 34. F. D. R. Bonnet, D.B. Leinweber, A. G. Williams, J.M. Zanotti: Symanzik improvement in the static quark potential, hep-lat/9912044 30, 32 35. D. B. Leinweber, J. I. Skullerud, A. G. Williams, C. Parrinello: Asymptotic scaling and infrared behavior of the gluon propagator, Phys. Rev. D 60, 094507 (1999); erratum Phys. Rev. D 61, 079901 (2000) 32 36. F. D. R. Bonnet, P.O. Bowman, D. B. Leinweber, A.G. Williams, J.M. Zanotti: Infinite Volume and Continuum Limits of the Landau Gauge Gluon Propagator, Phys. Rev. D 64, 034501 (2001) 32, 43 37. M. S. Bhagwat, M. A. Pichowsky, C. D. Roberts, P.C. Tandy: Analysis of a quenched lattice QCD dressed-quark propagator, nucl-th/0304003 33, 49, 59, 61 38. H. Neuberger: Vector-like gauge theories with almost massless fermions on the lattice, Phys. Rev. D 57, 5417 (1998) 38
Quark Propagator from LQCD and Its Physical Implications
63
39. H. Neuberger: Phys. Lett. B 427, 353 (1998) 38 40. M. L¨ uscher: Exact chiral symmetry on the lattice and the Ginsparg–Wilson relation, Phys. Lett. B 428, 342 (1998) 38 41. R. G. Edwards, U. M. Heller, R. Narayanan: A study of chiral symmetry in quenched QCD using the Overlap Dirac operator, Phys. Rev. D 59, 094510 (1999) 38, 41 42. F. Niedermayer: Exact chiral symmetry, topological charge and related topics, Nucl. Phys. B (Proc. Suppl.) 73, 105 (1999) 38 43. P. H. Ginsparg, K. G. Wilson: Phys. Rev. D 25, 2649 (1982) 38 44. R. G. Edwards, U. M. Heller, R. Narayanan: Spectral flow, chiral condensate and topology in lattice QCD, Nucl. Phys. B 535, 403 (1998) 39 45. E.I. Zolotarev: Zap. Imp. Akad. Nauk. St. Petersburg, 30 (1877) 42 46. S. J. Dong et al.: Chiral logs in quenched QCD, hep-lat/0304005 42 47. R. G. Edwards, U. M. Heller: Are topological charge fluctuations in QCD instanton dominated?, Phys. Rev. D 65, 014505 (2002) 42 48. T. A. DeGrand: A variant approach to the overlap action, Phys. Rev. D 63, 034503 (2001) 42 49. W. Kamleh, D. Adams, D. B. Leinweber, A. G. Williams: Accelerated Overlap Fermions, Phys. Rev. D 66, 2002 (014501) 42 50. C. D. Roberts, A. G. Williams: Dyson–Schwinger Equations and their Application to Hadronic Physics, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 33, 477 (1994) 47, 52 51. S. Capitani et al.: Non-perturbative quark mass renormalization in quenched lattice QCD, Nucl. Phys. B 544, 669 (1999) 53 52. D. Becirevic et al.: Asymptotic behaviour of the gluon propagator from lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. D 60, 094509 (1999) 53 53. K. Hagiwara et al.: 2002 Review of Particle Physics, Phys. Rev. D 66, 010001 (2002) 55 54. D. B. Leinweber, A. W. Thomas, R. D. Young: Physical nucleon properties from lattice QCD, arXiv:hep-lat/0302020; R. D. Young, D. B. Leinweber, A. W. Thomas: Convergence of chiral effective field theory, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 50, 39 (2003) 55 55. C. Aubin, C. Bernard: Staggered chiral perturbation theory, arXiv:hep-lat/0308036 55 56. A. E. Dorokhov, W. Broniowski: Vanishing dynamical quark mass at zero virtuality?, Phys. Rev. D 65, 094007 (2002) 56, 58, 59 57. M. Oettel, R. Alkofer: Nucleon form factors from a covariant quark core: limits in their description, Eur. Phys. J. A 16, 95 (2003) 56, 57, 59 58. D. Jarecke, P. Maris, P.C. Tandy: Strong decays of light vector mesons, Phys. Rev. C 67, 035202 (2003) 56 59. C. S. Fischer, R. Alkofer: Non-perturbative propagators, running coupling and dynamical quark mass of Landau gauge QCD, hep-ph/0301094 56, 59 60. J. I. Skullerud, P. O. Bowman, A. Kızılers¨ u, D. B. Leinweber, A.G. Williams: Nonperturbative structure of the quark gluon vertex, JHEP 04, 047 (2003) 56 61. R. Alkofer et al.: Analytic properties of the Landau gauge gluon and quark propagators, hep-ph/0309077 60
Generalised Spin Projection for Fermion Actions W. Kamleh CSSM Lattice Collaboration, Special Research Centre for the Subatomic Structure of Matter and Department of Physics and Mathematical Physics, University of Adelaide 5005, Australia. Abstract. The majority of compute time doing lattice QCD is spent inverting the fermion matrix. The time that this takes increases with the condition number of the matrix. The FLIC (Fat Link Irrelevant Clover) action displays, among other properties, an improved condition number compared to standard actions and hence is of interest due to potential compute time savings. However, due to its two different link sets there is a factor of two cost in floating point multiplications compared to the Wilson action. An additional factor of two has been attributed due to the loss of the so-called spin projection trick. We show that any split-link action may be written in terms of spin projectors, reducing the additional cost to at most a factor of two. Also, we review an efficient means of evaluating the clover term, which is additional expense not present in the Wilson action.
1 Introduction The FLIC(Fat Link Irrelevant Clover) action [1] has become of interest recently as an alternative to standard actions (such as Wilson or Clover) due to its superior condition number [2]. This allows for more efficient fermion matrix inversion [1], which is used in the calculation of propagators and dynamical configurations, and in evaluating the matrix sign function in the overlap fermion formalism [3, 4]. Hence, actions with an improved condition number have the potential to save significant compute time. To begin, we review the spin-projection trick [5] for the Wilson action, which utilises projection operators in spinor space to reduce the computation required to evaluate the Wilson action. We then generalise this trick to the broader class of split-link actions. Finally, we examine the FLIC action specifically, and discuss a similar trick for reducing the cost of evaluating the clover term.
2 Standard Spin-Projection Trick The Wilson operator 1 Dw = ∇ /+ ∆+m 2
(1)
can be written as
W. Kamleh: Generalised Spin Projection for Fermion Actions, Lect. Notes Phys. 663, 65–69 (2005) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2005 www.springerlink.com
66
W. Kamleh
1 (1 − γµ )Uµ (x)ψx+µ + (1 + γµ )Uµ† (x) ψx−µ 2 µ = (4 + m)ψx − Uµ (x)Γµ− ψx+µ + Uµ† (x)Γµ+ ψx−µ , (2)
(Dw ψ)x = (4 + m)ψx −
µ
where we have defined the spin projectors Γµ± =
1 1 ± γµ . 2
If we now examine, for example, Γ2± we see that 1 1 ψ ∓ ψ4 ψ ψ 2 ψ 2 ± ψ 3 Γ2± ψ 3 = ±ψ 2 + ψ 3 . ψ4 ∓ψ 1 + ψ 4
(3)
(4)
Similar expressions for µ = 1, 3, 4 allow us to deduce that we only need to evaluate the action of the links on the upper half (in spinor space) of Γµ± ψx∓µ , as the lower components are equal to the upper components multiplied by ±1 or ±i. In doing so we can halve the number of floating point multiplications needed in the evaluation of Dw , and also reduce intermediate memory usage. This trick can be applied in any of the standard representations for the Euclidean-space γ matrices.
3 Generalised Spin-Projection Trick We now consider the case where there are two sets of links, Uµ (x) for the naive Dirac operator ∇ / and Uµ (x) for the irrelevant Wilson term (denoted by ∆ to indicate that it contains only the links U ). In the case of a FLIC action the irrelevant links are APE-smeared, but what follows is perfectly general and does not depend upon any particular relationship between U and U . Now our “splitlink” operator is # $ 1 (Dsplit ψ)x = ∇ / + ∆ + m ψ 2 x 1 Uµ (x) − γµ Uµ (x) ψx+µ + U †µ (x) + γµ Uµ† (x) ψx−µ =− 2 µ +(4 + m)ψx .
(5)
We can observe that our projectors do not present themselves immediately as they did before. At this point, compared to the standard Wilson action, we must perform four times as many floating point multiplications, two for the split links, and two for the loss of the spin projectors. However, we have 1 = Γµ+ + Γµ− and γµ = Γµ+ − Γµ− ,
(6)
Generalised Spin Projection for Fermion Actions
67
which implies 1 Uµ (x) − Uµ (x) Γµ+ ψx+µ + Uµ (x) + Uµ (x) Γµ− ψx+µ 2 µ † + U µ (x) + Uµ† (x) Γµ+ ψx−µ + U †µ (x) − Uµ† (x) Γµ− ψx−µ +(4 + m)ψx . (7)
(Dsplit ψ)x = −
It is now clear that by defining symmetrised and anti-symmetrised links, Uµ+ (x) =
1 1 Uµ (x) + Uµ (x) and Uµ− (x) = Uµ (x) − Uµ (x) 2 2
(8)
we can write (Dsplit ψ)x = −
Uµ− (x)Γµ+ ψx+µ + Uµ+ (x)Γµ− ψx+µ
µ
+Uµ+† (x)Γµ+ ψx−µ + Uµ−† (x)Γµ− ψx−µ + (4 + m)ψx .
(9)
Immediately we see that the Wilson spin projection trick is simply a special case of the split link trick where U = U . The same saving in multiplications that we received in the Wilson case applies here, so we have in principle a factor of two compared to the Wilson action because U − is not zero. In actuality, efficient cache usage will reduce this to less than a factor of two.
4 The FLIC Fermion Action The FLIC action is a split-link action with clover term [6], /+ Dflic = ∇
$ 1 # csw ∆ − σ·F +m, 2 2
(10)
where 1 1 † [γµ , γν ], Fµν (x) = Cµν (x) − Cµν (x) , 2 2 1 Cµν (x) = Uµν (x) + U−νµ (x) + Uν−µ (x) + U−µ−ν (x) . 4 σµν =
(11) (12)
APE-smearing [7, 8, 9, 10] is carried out on the individual links in the irrelevant operators by making the replacement α Uµ (x) → Uµ(α) (x) = P (α − 1)Uµ (x) + Uν (x)Uµ (x + aeν )Uν† (x + aeµ ) . 6 ±ν=µ
(13) Here P denotes projection of the RHS of (13) back to the SU (3) gauge group. That is, each link is modified by replacing it with a combination of itself and the
68
W. Kamleh
surrounding staples to give a set of “fat links”. The means by which one projects back to SU (3) is not unique. If Xµ (x) is the smeared link before projection, that (α) is Uµ (x) ≡ PXµ (x), then we choose [11, 12] Uµ(α) (x) =
1 1
det Wµ (x) 3
Wµ (x), where
Wµ (x) = Xµ (x)[Xµ† (x)Xµ (x)]− 2 . 1
(14) (15)
As the process of APE-smearing removes short-distance physics, it is preferable to only smear the irrelevant operators. Here α is the smearing fraction and nape is the number of smearing sweeps (13) we perform. Finally, as in [1], we can perform tadpole or mean-field improvement (MFI) [13] to bring our links closer to unity. This consists of updating each link with a division by the mean link, which is the fourth root of the average plaquette, % u0 =
& 14 1 ReTrUµν (x) . 3 x,µ<ν
(16)
For completeness, we review a (well-known) similar trick for the clover term that exploits the structure of σµν . In the evaluation of the clover term, we note that in the chiral representation of γ matrices,
0 1 1 0 γ5 = , (17) γ4 = 1 0 0 −1 the matrix σµν satisfies the following (in 2 × 2 block notation), ψ −ψ ψ ψ ψ −ψ σ12 = σ34 , σ13 = σ24 and σ14 = σ23 . χ χ χ −χ χ χ (18) So we have, for example,
ψ ψ (F12 − F34 )σ12 ψ . (19) + F34 σ34 = F12 σ12 (F12 + F34 )σ12 χ χ χ This means that if we store the combinations F12 ± F34 , F13 ± F24 , F14 ± F23 we can halve the number of floating point multiplications needed in the evaluation of the clover term, further improving the computational efficiency of the FLIC action.
5 Conclusion We have presented a generalised version of the spin-projection trick which is applicable to any split-link action. This allows us to halve the number of floatingpoint multiplications the evaluation of the action of the links upon the fermion
Generalised Spin Projection for Fermion Actions
69
field. We have also recalled some symmetries of σµν in the chiral γ matrix representation which allow us to perform a similar cost reduction in the evaluation of the clover term. The results presented here reduce the cost of evaluating the FLIC action to about twice that of the standard Wilson action. The exact difference will vary depending upon the base architecture, but on our architecture we have verified that the cost of FLIC is almost exactly twice that of the Wilson, including the cost of the clover term. Additionally, the formulation of the split link action in (9) allows groups who have efficient code for the Wilson action to simply implement efficient code for the FLIC action. Given the benefits of the FLIC action [1, 2] we hope that this work encourages groups to consider using the FLIC action for their calculations.
Acknowledgements The author wishes to thank Urs Heller, Robert Edwards and Herbert Neuberger for discussions at Cairns in 2001 that led to this investigation. Additional thanks go to Patrick Bowman for helpful discussions immediately after Cairns, and to Tony Williams and Derek Leinweber for valuable discussions and their contribution to the manuscript. Thanks also go to David Richards for correspondence. This work was supported by the Australian Research Council.
References 1. CSSM Lattice, J. M. Zanotti et al.: Phys. Rev. D 65, 074507 (2002), hep-lat/ 0110216. 65, 68, 69 2. W. Kamleh, D. H. Adams, D. B. Leinweber, and A. G. Williams: Phys. Rev. D 66, 014501 (2002), hep-lat/0112041. 65, 69 3. H. Neuberger: Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 4060 (1998), hep-lat/9806025. 65 4. R. G. Edwards, U. M. Heller, and R. Narayanan: Nucl. Phys. B 540, 457 (1999), hep-lat/9807017. 65 5. M. G. Alford, T. R. Klassen, and G. P. Lepage: Nucl. Phys. B 496, 377 (1997), hep-lat/9611010. 65 6. B. Sheikholeslami and R. Wohlert: Nucl. Phys. B 259, 572 (1985). 67 7. M. Falcioni, M. L. Paciello, G. Parisi, and B. Taglienti: Nucl. Phys. B 251, 624 (1985). 67 8. APE, M. Albanese et al.: Phys. Lett. B 192, 163 (1987). 67 9. F. D. R. Bonnet, D. B. Leinweber, A. G. Williams, and J. M. Zanotti: (2001), hep-lat/0106023. 67 10. M. C. Chu, J. M. Grandy, S. Huang, and J. W. Negele: Phys. Rev. D 49, 6039 (1994), hep-lat/9312071. 67 11. Y. Liang, K. F. Liu, B. A. Li, S. J. Dong, and K. Ishikawa: Phys. Lett. B 307 (1993) 375, hep-lat/9304011. 68 12. W. Kamleh, D. B. Leinweber, and A. G. Williams: In preparation. 68 13. G. P. Lepage and P. B. Mackenzie: Phys. Rev. D 48, 2250 (1993), hep-lat/9209022. 68
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD D.B. Leinweber1 , W. Melnitchouk2 , D.G. Richards2 , A.G. Williams1 , and J.M. Zanotti3 1
2 3
Department of Physics and Mathematical Physics and Special Research Centre for the Subatomic Structure of Matter, University of Adelaide, 5005, Australia Jefferson Lab, 12000 Jefferson Avenue, Newport News, VA 23606, USA John von Neumann-Institut f¨ ur Computing NIC, Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY, D-15738 Zeuthen, Germany
Abstract. We review recent developments in the study of excited baryon spectroscopy in lattice QCD. After introducing the basic methods used to extract masses from correlation functions, we discuss various interpolating fields and lattice actions commonly used in the literature. We present a survey of results of recent calculations of excited baryons in quenched QCD, and outline possible future directions in the study of baryon spectra.
1 Introduction and Motivation One of the primary tools used for studying the forces which confine quarks inside hadrons, and determining the relevant effective degrees of freedom in strongly coupled QCD, has been baryon and meson spectroscopy. This is a driving force behind the current experimental N ∗ programme at Jefferson Lab, which is accumulating data of unprecedented quality and quantity on various N → N ∗ transitions [1]. The prospects of studying mesonic spectra, and in particular the role played by gluonic excitations, has been a major motivation for future facilities such as CLEO-c [2], the anti-proton facility at GSI (PANDA) [3], and the Hall D programme at a 12 GeV energy upgraded CEBAF [4]. With the increased precision of the new N ∗ data comes a growing need to understand the observed spectrum within QCD. QCD-inspired phenomenological models, whilst successful in describing many features of the N ∗ spectrum [5], leave many questions unanswered. One of the long-standing puzzles in baryon spectroscopy has been the low mass of the first positive parity excitation of the nucleon, the N ∗ (1440) Roper resonance, compared with the lowest lying odd parity excitation. In valence − quark models with harmonic oscillator potentials, the J P = 12 state naturally + occurs below the N = 2, 12 excitation [6]. Without fine tuning of parameters, valence quark models tend to leave the Roper mass too high. Similar difficul+ + ties in the level orderings appear for the J P = 32 ∆∗ (1600) and 12 Σ ∗ (1690) resonances, which have led to speculations that the Roper resonances may be more appropriately viewed as hybrid baryon states with explicitly excited glue field configurations [7], rather than as radial excitations of a three-quark configuration. Other scenarios portray the Roper resonances as “breathing modes” of D.B. Leinweber, W. Melnitchouk, D.G. Richards, A.G. Williams, and J.M. Zanotti: Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD, Lect. Notes Phys. 663, 71–112 (2005) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2005 www.springerlink.com
72
D.B. Leinweber et al.
the ground states [8], or states which can be described in terms of meson-baryon dynamics alone [9]. Another challenge for spectroscopy is presented by the anomalously small mass of the odd parity Λ(1405) hyperon. This is alternatively interpreted as a true three-quark state, or as a hadronic molecule arising from strong coupled ¯ ,. . . states [10]. In fact, the role played by Goldchannel effects between Σπ, KN stone bosons in baryon spectroscopy has received considerable attention recently [11, 12, 13]. Mass splittings between states within SU (3) quark-model multiplets provide another important motivation for studying the baryon spectrum. The dynamical origin of hyperfine splittings in quark models has traditionally been attributed to the colour-magnetic one gluon exchange mechanism [14]. On the other hand, there have been attempts recently to explain the hyperfine splittings and level orderings in terms of a spin-flavour interaction associated with the exchange of a pseudoscalar nonet of Goldstone bosons between quarks [15]. Understand− − ing the mass splitting between the J P = 12 N ∗ (1535) and 32 N ∗ (1520), or − − between the 12 ∆∗ (1620) and 32 ∆∗ (1700), can help identify the important mechanisms associated with the hyperfine interactions, and shed light on the spin-orbit force, which has been a central mystery in spectroscopy [16]. In va− − lence quark models, the degeneracy between the N 12 and N 32 can be broken by a tensor force associated with mixing between the N 2 and N 4 representations − of SU (3) [5], although this generally leaves the N 32 at a higher energy than − − − the N 12 . In contrast, a spin-orbit force is necessary to split the ∆ 32 and ∆ 12 states. In the Goldstone boson exchange model [15], both of these pairs of states are degenerate. Similarly, neither spin-flavour nor colour-magnetic interactions is able to ac− count for the mass splitting between the Λ(1405) and the J P = 32 Λ∗ (1520). A splitting between these can arise in constituent quark models with a spin-orbit interaction, but the required strength of the interaction leads to spurious mass splittings elsewhere [5, 17]. In fact, model-independent analyses of baryons in the large Nc limit [18] have found that these mass splittings receive important contributions from operators that do not have a simple quark model interpretation [18], such as those simultaneously coupling spin, isospin and orbital angular momentum, as anticipated by early QCD sum-rule analyses [16]. Of course, the coefficients of the various operators in such an analysis must be determined phenomenologically and guidance from lattice QCD is essential. The large number of “missing” resonances, predicted by the constituent quark model and its generalisations but not observed experimentally, presents another problem for spectroscopy. If these states do not exist, this may suggest that perhaps a quark–diquark picture (with fewer degrees of freedom) could afford a more efficient description. Alternatively, the missing states could simply have weak couplings to the πN system [5]. Apart from these long-standing puzzles, interest in baryon spectroscopy has been further stimulated with the recent discovery of the exotic strangeness
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
73
S = +1 Θ+ pentaquark [19], which has a minimum 5 valence quark (uudd¯ s) content. Postulated long ago, the Θ+ appears to have eluded searches until now, and understanding its properties and internal structure has become a major challenge for spectroscopy. A consistent description of the baryon spectrum within low-energy models requires a satisfactory resolution of the old questions of spectroscopy, as well as insight into the new puzzles. On both of these fronts real progress may only come with the help of first-principle calculations of the spectrum in lattice QCD, which at present is the only method capable of determining hadron properties directly from the fundamental quark and gluon theory. Considerable progress has been made in the past few years in calculating hadronic properties in both quenched and full QCD, with the ground state masses now understood at the few percent level. Compared with simulations of hadron ground state properties, however, the calculation of the excited nucleon spectrum places particularly heavy demands on lattice spectroscopy. The excited nucleon states are expected to be large, with the size of a state expected to double with each increase in orbital angular momentum. Lattice studies of the excited nucleon spectrum therefore require large lattice volumes, with correspondingly large computational resources. Furthermore, the states are relatively massive, requiring a fine lattice spacing, at least in the temporal direction. Recent advances in computational capabilities and more efficient algorithms have enabled the first dedicated lattice QCD simulations of the excited states of the nucleon to be undertaken. Of course, the calculation of the hadronic spectrum faces a formidable challenge in describing excited state decays, which is relevant in both full and quenched QCD. Lattice studies of excited hadrons are possible because at the current unphysically large quark masses and finite volumes used in the simulations many excited states are stable [20]. Contact with experiment can be made via extrapolations incorporating the nonanalytic behaviour predicted by chiral effective field theory. The rest of this review is laid out as follows. After briefly reviewing in Sect. 2 the history of lattice calculations of the excited baryon spectrum, in Sect. 3 we outline the basic lattice techniques for extracting masses from correlation functions, including variational methods and Bayesian statistics. Section 4 describes the construction of a suitable basis of interpolating fields for any baryon we may wish to investigate. Section 5 outlines the simplest interpolating fields for spin-1/2 and spin-3/2 baryons, and how these can be used in the construction of lattice correlation functions. In Sect. 6, we present a survey of recent N ∗ results for both positive and negative parity baryons. Finally, in Sect. 7 we discuss conclusions of the existing studies, and speculate on future directions for the study of baryon spectra. Some technical aspects of the correlation matrix formalism for calculating masses, coupling strengths and optimal interpolating fields are described in the Appendix.
74
D.B. Leinweber et al.
2 History of Lattice N ∗ Calculations The history of excited baryons on the lattice is rather short, although recently there has been growing interest in finding new techniques to isolate excited baryons, motivated partly by the experimental N ∗ programme at Jefferson Lab. An attempt to determine the first positive-parity excitation of the nucleon using variational methods was made by the UKQCD collaboration [21]. A more detailed analysis of the positive parity excitation of the nucleon was performed by Leinweber [22] using Wilson fermions and an operator product expansion spectral ansatz. DeGrand and Hecht [23] used a wave function ansatz to access P wave baryons, with Wilson fermions and relatively heavy quarks. Subsequently, Lee and Leinweber [24] introduced a parity projection technique to study the − negative parity 12 states using an O(a2 ) tree-level tadpole-improved Dχ34 quark action, and an O(a2 ) tree-level tadpole-improved gauge action. Following this, Lee [25] reported results using a D234 quark action with an improved gauge ac+ − tion on an anisotropic lattice to study the 12 and 12 excitations of the nucleon. An anisotropic lattice with an O(a) improved quark action was also used by Nakajima et al. [26] to study excited states of octet and decuplet baryons. The RIKEN-BNL group [27] has stressed the importance of maintaining chiral symmetry on the lattice. At finite lattice spacing the Wilson fermion action is known to explicitly break the chiral symmetry of continuum QCD. A solution to this problem is provided through the introduction of a fifth dimension, which allows chiral symmetry to be maintained even at non-zero lattice spacing [28]. The resulting domain wall fermion action was used in [27] to compute the masses − + of the N 12 and N 12 excited states. The analysis has recently been extended + by studying the finite volume effects of the first N 12 excited state extracted using maximum entropy methods [29]. A nonperturbatively O(a)-improved Sheikholeslami-Wohlert (SW) [30], or − clover, fermion action was used by Richards et al. [31] to study the N 12 and − ∆ 32 states. By appropriately choosing the coefficient of the improvement term, all O(a) discretisation uncertainties can be removed, ensuring that continuumlike results are obtained at a finite lattice spacing. For more details on O(a)improvement, see the contribution by Zanotti et al. in this lecture series. − The BGR collaboration [32] has been investigating the masses of the N 12 + and N 12 excited states calculated with chirally improved (CI) and Fixed Point (FP) fermions. Both of these actions offer the advantage of improved chiral properties over traditional Wilson-style fermions, without the cost associated with Ginsparg-Wilson fermions, which possess an exact analogue of chiral symmetry. The CSSM Lattice Collaboration has used an O(a2 ) improved gluon action and the O(a)-improved Fat Link Irrelevant Clover (FLIC) fermion action [33] to perform a comprehensive study of the spectrum of positive and negative parity baryons [34, 35]. Excited state masses in both the octet and decuplet multiplets ± ± ± ± ± ± have been computed, including the N 12 , N 32 , Σ 12 , Λ 21 , Ξ 12 , ∆ 12 and ± ∆ 32 baryons. The formulation of FLIC fermions and a review of its scaling and
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
75
light quark mass phenomenology is reviewed by Zanotti et al. in this lecture series. Constrained-fitting methods originating from Bayesian priors have also recently been used by Lee et al. [36] to study the two lowest octet and decuplet positive and negative parity baryons, using overlap fermions with pion masses down to ∼180 MeV. These authors have addressed the difficult issue of contamination of the first excited state of the nucleon with quenched η N artifacts [37]. While these authors claim to have observed the Roper in quenched QCD, it remains to be demonstrated that this conclusion is independent of the Bayesianprior assumed in their analysis [22]. It would be interesting to examine these correlation functions using correlation matrix techniques or alternative Bayesian techniques such as the Maximum Entropy Method. As mentioned in Sect. 1, we are currently seeing intense interest in exotic pentaquark spectroscopy, and recently the first lattice studies of 5-quark states have appeared [38, 39, 40]. Here the unique advantage of lattice QCD can come to the fore, in predicting, for instance, the parity and spin of the lowest lying pentaquark state, which are as yet undetermined experimentally. The first two of these early studies have used the standard Wilson gauge and fermion action, on lattice sizes of L = 1.2–2.7 fm [38], and L = 2.2 fm [39], while the third used domain wall fermions with a Wilson gauge action on a L = 1.8 fm lattice. The main challenge here has been the construction of lattice operators for states with 4 quarks and an antiquark, which can be variously constructed in terms of (qqq)(q¯ s) “nucleon-meson” [38] or (qq)(qq)¯ s “diquark-diquark-¯ s” [39, 40] operators. While two of these studies [38, 39] appear to favor negative parity for the lowest lying pentaquark state, it is not clear that this state is a new resonant combination of KN in S wave. The most recent study [40] reports an even parity ground state, and moreover identifies the Roper resonance as a pentaquark state. The relatively small volumes, limited set of interpolating fields, and naive linear extrapolations means that these results must be regarded as exploratory at present. New studies using the FLIC fermion action with several different interpolating fields are currently in progress [41]. We are clearly witnessing an exciting period in which the field of baryon spectroscopy on the lattice is beginning to flourish.
3 Lattice Techniques 3.1 Spectroscopy Recipe The computation of the spectrum of states in lattice QCD is in principle straightforward. The building blocks are the quark propagators ij Sαβ (x, y) = 0|ψαi (x)ψ¯βj (y)|0 ,
(1)
computed on an ensemble of gauge configurations, composed of gauge field links Uµ (x) exp{iagAµ (x)}. The calculation then proceeds as follows:
76
D.B. Leinweber et al.
1. Choose an interpolating operator O that has a good overlap with P , the state of interest, 0 | O | P = 0 , and ideally a small overlap with other states having the same quantum numbers. 2. Form the time-sliced correlation function G(t, p) = O(x, t)O† (0, 0)e−ip·x , x
which can be expressed by a Wick expansion in terms of the elemental quark propagators of (1). 3. Insert a complete set of states between O and O† . The time-sliced sum puts the intermediate states at definite momentum, and one finds d3 k e−ip·x 0|O(x, t)|P (k)P (k)|O† (0, 0)|0 G(t, p) = 3 2E(k) (2π) x P
| 0 | O | P |2 e−iEP (p)t , = 2 EP (p) P
where the sum over P includes the contributions from two-particle and higher states. 4. Continue to Euclidean space t → −it, giving G(t, p) =
| 0 | O | P |2 e−EP (p)t . 2 EP (p)
(2)
P
At large Euclidean times, the lightest state dominates the spectral sum in (2), and we can extract the ground state mass. The determination of this ground state mass for the states of lowest spin has been the benchmark calculation of lattice QCD since its inception. However, our goal is to build up a more complete description of the baryon spectrum, ultimately determining not only the masses of some of the higher spin particles, but also the masses of the radial excitations. In the remainder of this section, we will address two issues that are crucial to attaining this goal: the application of variational techniques to isolate the higher excitations in (2), and the use of the appropriate statistical fitting techniques to reliably extract the energies of those excitations. In the following section, we will describe the construction of the nucleon interpolating operators. 3.2 Fitting Techniques Variational Methods To confidently extract other than the lowest-lying state in (2), it is crucial to have more than a single interpolating operator Oi in order to appeal to variational
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
77
methods to determine the spectrum of states [42, 43]. Our aim is to measure every element of the matrix of correlators ' ( † Oi (x, t)Oj (0) . (3) Gij (t) = x
We now consider the eigenvalue equation G(t)u = λ(t, t0 )G(t0 )u ,
(4)
for some eigenfunction u of G−1 (t0 )G(t), with t0 fixed. For the sake of illustration, we will consider a simple system with only two independent states, and a 2 × 2 matrix of correlators. Then the eigenvalues of (4) satisfy λ+ (t, t0 ) = e−(t−t0 )E0 , λ− (t, t0 ) = e−(t−t0 )E1 ,
(5)
and we have an exact separation between the energies of the two states, with coefficients growing exponentially with t0 . For the physical case of more than two states, there are exponential corrections arising from the states of higher energy. Ideally, to suppress the contribution of these higher energy states we would wish to choose t0 to have as large a value as possible. However, increasing t0 comes at the price of increasing statistical noise, and therefore we are generally obliged to take t0 close to the origin. In practice, it is usual to adopt a variation of the above method, and not to attempt to diagonalise the transfer matrix at each time slice, but rather to choose a matrix of eigenvectors V (t0 ) for some t0 close to the source that diagonalises G(t0 )−1 G(t0 +1). For the case of a 2×2 matrix with only two states, the diagonal elements of the matrix V (t0 + 1)−1 G(t0 )−1 G(t)V (t0 + 1) are indeed equivalent to the eigenvalues of G(t0 )−1 G(t0 +1). A more pedagogical discussion of these concepts can be found in the Appendix. The efficacy of this method relies on having a basis of correlators that can delineate the structure of the first few states, together with sufficiently high-quality statistics that the elements of the correlator matrix can be well determined. In the case of the glueball spectrum, the computational cost is dominated by the cost of generating the gauge configurations, and the overhead of measuring extra correlators is negligible. Furthermore, we are able to improve the statistical quality of the data by using translational invariance to average over the position of the source coordinate in (3.1). Variational techniques have been essential, and very successful, in the extraction of the glueball spectrum [44, 45]. In the case of operators containing quark fields, there is generally a considerable computational cost associated with the measurement of additional correlators. We will discuss the construction of such operators in the next section, but
78
D.B. Leinweber et al.
it is straightforward to see how this cost arises. Recall that the basic building blocks of spectroscopy are the quark propagators of (1), which satisfy ij jk (x, y)Sβγ (y, z) = δ ik δαγ δxz . Mαβ
(6)
where M is the fermion matrix of the fermion action ψ M ψ. The propagator is usually obtained by standard sparse matrix inversion methods, such as conjugate gradient. These methods are applicable to a fixed source vector on the right hand side of (6), and additional correlators require the inversion of M for additional source vectors. A corollary of this is that the matrix of correlators is obtained for fixed source coordinate, and therefore we cannot in general use translational invariance to average over the source coordinate in the manner of glueball calculations. Bayesian Statistics Given the computational cost of measuring additional correlators, it is important to extract the greatest possible information from the those that are measured. Furthermore, it is vital that the fitting procedure be as reliable as possible, in particular by ensuring that the extracted masses are not adversely affected by contamination from higher excitations. Historically, lattice calculations employed maximum likelyhood fits to correlators such as (2), using a single or at most two states in the spectral sum. An acceptable χ2 /d.o.f. would only be obtained if the fitted data were restricted to large temporal separations, in which one or two states did indeed dominate the spectral sum. Thus the fits ignored the data at small temporal separations, which we have already seen has the largest signalto-noise ratio. It is natural to ask whether one can extract useful information from the data at small values of t, and a means of so doing is provided through the use of Bayesian Statistics. We will return to a further discussion of the the Bayesian approach in our survey of results.
4 Interpolating Fields The variational techniques and fitting methods described above require a suitable basis of interpolating fields from which operators can be constructed which mimic the structure of each of the states to be extracted. In order to do so, we firstly have to consider the possible quantum numbers by which states are classified, and the extent to which they remain good quantum numbers in lattice calculations. We then have to consider the spatial structure of the states, and in particular their spatial extents, and whether we can construct interpolating operators that reflect the structure, through the use of, say, smeared interpolating fields. We will begin this section by detailing the quantum numbers with which states are classified, namely flavour and parity, and the degree to which they are good quantum numbers on the lattice. We will then proceed to discuss the use of
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
79
spatially extended interpolating operators, known as smearing. Finally, we will describe the operators that have been employed thus far in lattice calculations, and discuss these in terms of continuum quark model operators. 4.1 Continuum and Lattice Symmetries Baryon states are classified by their flavour structure, either according to SU (2) (isospin), or SU (3) (strangeness), parity, and total spin. In nearly all lattice calculations of the hadron spectrum, exact isospin symmetry is imposed so the mu = md , and electromagnetic effects are ignored. Thus the flavour structure of baryon states composed of light (u, d, s) quarks is specified according to Total Isospin I, I3 , and the strangeness S, and the naming of baryon states follows from this labeling, as detailed in Table 1. Table 1. The table shows the flavour classification of baryon states constructed from light (u, d, s) quarks, together with a representative flavour structure in terms of three valence quarks for the case I3 = I I 1/2 3/2 0 1 1/2 0
S
Baryon
0 0 −1 −1 −2 −3
N ∆ Λ Σ Ξ Ω
Flavour Structure (I3 = I) udu − | duu ) | uuu 1 √ (| uds − | dus ) 2 | uus | uss | sss
1 √ (| 2
The flavour structure is straightforward to implement in the calculation of the correlation functions by only including the appropriate contractions in the Wick expansion of (3.1). 4.2 Angular Momentum and Lattice QCD More delicate is the identification of the spin of particles in a lattice calculation. For the discussion of the spectrum, we are principally interested in the study of states at rest, for which the relevant continuum symmetry for classifying states is their properties under rotations, described by the group SU(2). The irreducible representations of SU(2) are labeled by the total spin J, and the projection of spin along a particular axis, say J3 , in the manner of isospin. We have already seen that we can impose exact isospin symmetry in our calculations, but the use of a hypercubic lattice has the consequence that we no longer have exact three-dimensional rotational symmetry, but rather the symmetries of the threedimensional cubic group of the three-dimensional spatial lattice, the octahedral group O [46].
80
D.B. Leinweber et al.
In contrast to the continuum rotation group, O is a finite group. It contains a total of 48 elements, and has a total of five single-valued irreducible representations (IR), corresponding to states of integer spin, and only three double-valued IRs, corresponding to states of half-integer spin. Thus each lattice IR is an admixture of different values of J, listed for the double-valued representations in Table 2 [47]. Table 2. Irreducible representations of the octahedral group, listing the number of elements and the spin content Representation G1 G2 H
Dimension
Spin (J)
2 2 4
1/2, 7/2, 9/2, . . . 5/2, 7/2, 11/2, . . . 3/2, 5/2, 7/2, . . .
Thus in any lattice calculation at a fixed value of the lattice spacing, we will aim to construct operators transforming irreducibly according to one of the IRs of Table 2, and extract the spectrum of states within each of these IRs. We will only be able to identify the angular momentum of the various states when we look for commonality between the masses extracted from the various IRs in the approach to the continuum limit. Thus, for example, the continuum state of spin 5/2 has two degrees of freedom associated with G2 , and the remaining four degrees of freedom associated with H. So far, most lattice calculations have employed local, S-wave propagators for the quarks, and as we shall see later, have employed operators transforming according to the IRs G1 , for spin 12 , or H, for spin 32 , and have implicitly assumed that these states with these spins are indeed the lightest states in their respective representations, as observed in the physical hadron spectrum. The technology required to construct general baryon interpolating operators transforming irreducibly under O has now be developed [48, 49], and a preliminary attempt at the spectrum using P -wave quark propagators has been made in [50]. 4.3 Parity The remaining symmetry that we must consider is parity, corresponding to the spatial-inversion operator Is . Clearly, this is a good symmetry on our hypercubic lattice, yielding the point group Oh , with 96 elements, and an additional subscript g or u on our irreducible representations corresponding to positive- and negativeparity representations respectively. One subtlety arises when one considers the determination of the spectrum on a lattice with either periodic or anti-periodic boundary conditions in the temporal direction. In that case, we have for identical source and sink.
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
G(t) =
O+ (x, t)O+ (0)
x
−→
81
|AP+ |2 e−MP+ t ±
P+
|AP− |2 e−MP− (Nt −t) ,
(7)
P−
where O+ is an interpolating operator designed to isolate states of positive parity propagating in the forward time direction, Nt is the temporal extent of the lattice, AP is the amplitude of a state P , and the subscripts + and − denote contributions of states of positive or negative parity respectively. As discussed further in Sect. 5.1, a similar expression may be obtained for the opposite parity states. Thus we see that a complete delineation of the states on a periodic lattice only occurs as Nt → ∞. The superposition of results from periodic and antiperiodic boundary conditions can be used to eliminate the second term of (7). Alternatively, a fixed boundary condition can be used to eliminate the second term of (7) by preventing states from crossing the temporal boundary of the lattice. 4.4 Smearing and Extended Interpolating Fields It is common to perform some smearing in the spatial dimensions at the source to increase the overlap of the interpolating operators with the ground states. Here we describe one such technique to do this: gauge-invariant Gaussian smearing [51]. The source-smearing technique [51] starts with a point source, ψ0 αa (x, t) = δ ac δαγ δx,x0 δt,t0
(8)
for source colour c, Dirac γ, position x0 and time t0 , and proceeds via the iterative scheme, ψi (x, t) = F (x, x ) ψi−1 (x , t) , x
where 1 F (x, x ) = (1 + α)
) δx,x
* 3 α
† Uµ (x, t) δx ,x+µ + Uµ (x − µ . + , t) δx ,x−µ 6 µ=1
Repeating the procedure N times gives the resulting fermion source, ψN (x, t) = F N (x, x ) ψ0 (x , t) .
(9)
x
The parameters N and α govern the size and shape of the smearing function. The propagator S is obtained from the smeared source by solving ab bc Sβγ = ψαa , Mαβ
(10)
for each colour, Dirac source c, γ respectively of (8) via a standard matrix inverter such as the BiStabilised Conjugate Gradient algorithm [52].
82
D.B. Leinweber et al.
5 Operators for Spin- 12 and Spin- 32 Baryons We will now see how the considerations described above apply to the construction of operators for the spin- 21 and spin- 23 baryons. Initially we will construct the operators based on analogy with the construction of the interpolating operators of the continuum, first for spin 12 and then for spin 32 . We will then briefly describe the construction of the operators that transform irreducibly under the lattice symmetries directly, without reference to the continuum discussion. 5.1 Spin- 12 Baryons: General Considerations Following standard notation, we define a two-point correlation function for a spin- 21 baryon B as GB (t, p) ≡ e−ip·x Ω |χB (x)χ ¯B (0)| Ω (11) x
where χB is a baryon interpolating field and where we have suppressed Dirac indices. All formalism for correlation functions and interpolating fields presented in this article is carried out using the Dirac representation of the Dirac γ-matrices. The choice of interpolating field χB is discussed in Sect. 5.2 below. The overlap of the interpolating field χB with positive or negative parity states |B ± is parameterised by a coupling strength λB ± which is complex in general and which is defined by + , MB + + Ω | χB (0) | B , p, s = λB + u + (p, s) , (12) EB + B + , MB − − Ω | χB (0) | B , p, s = λB − γ5 uB − (p, s) , (13) EB − where MB ± is the mass of the state B ± , EB ± = MB2 ± + p 2 is its energy, and β αβ uB ± (p, s) is a Dirac spinor with normalisation uα . For B ± (p, s)uB ± (p, s) = δ large Euclidean time, the correlation function can be written as a sum of the lowest energy positive and negative parity contributions
GB (t, p) ≈ λ2B +
(γ · p + MB + ) −E + t (γ · p − MB − ) −E − t e B + λ2B − e B , 2EB + 2EB −
(14)
when a fixed boundary condition in the time direction is used to remove backward propagating states. The positive and negative parity states are isolated by taking the trace of GB with the operator Γ+ and Γ− respectively, where
1 MB ∓ Γ± = γ4 . (15) 1± 2 EB ∓ For p = 0, the energy EB ∓ = MB ∓ , so that Γ∓2 = Γ∓ and the Γ∓ are parity projectors In this case, positive parity states propagate in the (1, 1) and (2, 2) elements of the Dirac γ-matrix of (14), while negative parity states propagate in the (3, 3) and (4, 4) elements, and the masses of B ∓ may be isolated.
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
83
5.2 Spin- 12 Baryons: Interpolating Fields There are two types of interpolating fields which have commonly been used in the literature. The notation adopted here is similar to that of [53]. To access the positive parity proton we use as interpolating fields T χp+ (16) 1 (x) = abc ua (x) Cγ5 db (x) uc (x) , and T χp+ 2 (x) = abc ua (x) C db (x) γ5 uc (x) ,
(17)
where the fields u, d are evaluated at Euclidean space-time point x, C is the charge conjugation matrix, a, b and c are colour labels, and the superscript T denotes the transpose. These interpolating fields transform as spinors under a parity transformation. That is, if the quark fields qa (x) (q = u, d, · · · ) transform as x) , (18) Pqa (x)P † = +γ0 qa (˜ where x ˜ = (x0 , −x), then Pχp+ (x)P † = +γ0 χp+ (˜ x) . For convenience, we introduce the shorthand notation abc a b c bb T cc (x, 0) tr S (x, 0)S (x, 0) G(Sf1 , Sf2 , Sf3 ) ≡ Sfaa f3 f2 1 (x, 0) Sfbb2 T (x, 0) Sfcc3 (x, 0) , + Sfaa 1
(19)
(x, 0) are the quark propagators in the background link-field configuwhere Sfaa 1−3 ration U corresponding to flavours f1−3 . This allows us to express the correlation functions in a compact form. The associated correlation function for χp+ 1 can be written as ' ( $ # p+ −ip·x −1 , Su dC G (t, p; Γ ) = e tr −Γ G Su , CS , (20) 11
x
where · · · is the ensemble average over the link fields, Γ is the Γ± projection = Cγ5 . For ease of notation, we will drop the angled operator from (15), and C brackets, · · · , and all the following correlation functions will be understood to be ensemble averages. For the χp+ 2 interpolating field, one can similarly write $ # −1 , γ5 Su γ5 dC , (21) Gp+ e−ip·x tr −Γ G γ5 Su γ5 , CS 22 (t, p; Γ ) = x
while the interference terms from these two interpolating fields are given by
84
D.B. Leinweber et al.
Gp+ 12 (t, p; Γ ) =
x
Gp+ 21 (t, p; Γ ) =
# $ −1 , Su γ5 dC e−ip·x tr −Γ G Su γ5 , CS ,
(22)
# $ −1 , γ5 Su dC e−ip·x tr −Γ G γ5 Su , CS .
(23)
x
The neutron interpolating field is obtained via the exchange u ↔ d, and the strangeness –2, Ξ interpolating field by replacing the doubly represented u or d quark fields in (16) and (17) by s quark fields. The Σ and Ξ interpolators are discussed in detail below. As pointed out in [22], because of the Dirac structure of the “diquark” in the parentheses in (16), in the Dirac representation the field χp+ 1 involves both products of upper × upper × upper and lower × lower × upper components of = spinors for positive parity baryons, so that in the nonrelativistic limit χp+ 1 O(1). Here upper and lower refer to the large and small spinor components in the standard Dirac representation of the γ-matrices. Furthermore, since the “diquark” couples to total spin 0, one expects an attractive force between the two quarks, and hence better overlap with a lower energy state than with a state in which two quarks do not couple to spin 0. The χp+ 2 interpolating field, on the other hand, is known to have little overlap with the nucleon ground state [22, 54]. Inspection of the structure of the Dirac γ-matrices in (17) reveals that it involves only products of upper × lower × lower 2 2 components for positive parity baryons, so that χp+ 2 = O(p /E ) vanishes in the nonrelativistic limit. As a result of the mixing of upper and lower components, the “diquark” term contains a factor σ · p, meaning that the quarks no longer couple to spin 0, but are in a relative L = 1 state. One expects therefore that two-point correlation functions constructed from the interpolating field χp+ 2 are dominated by larger mass states than those arising from χp+ 1 at early Euclidean times. While the masses of negative parity baryons are obtained directly from the (positive parity) interpolating fields in (16) and (17) by using the parity projectors Γ± , it is instructive nevertheless to examine the general properties of the negative parity interpolating fields. Interpolating fields with strong overlap with the negative parity proton can be constructed by multiplying the previous p+ positive parity interpolating fields by γ5 , χp− 1,2 ≡ γ5 χ1,2 . In contrast to the posip− tive parity case, both the interpolating fields χp− 1 and χ2 mix upper and lower p− p− components, and consequently both χ1 and χ2 are O(p/E). − Physically, two nearby J P = 12 states are observed in the excited nucleon spectrum. In simple quark models, the splitting of these two orthogonal states is largely attributed to the extent to which the wave function is composed of scalar diquark configurations. It is reasonable to expect χp− 1 to have better overlap with scalar diquark dominated states, and thus provide a lower effective mass in the moderately large Euclidean time regime explored in lattice simulations. If the correlator is larger, then this would be effective mass associated with the χp− 2 1 p− evidence of significant overlap of χ2 with the higher lying N 2 − states. In this
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
85
event, a correlation matrix analysis (see Appendix) can be used to isolate these two states [32, 34]. Interpolating fields for the other members of the flavour SU (3) octet are constructed along similar lines. For the positive parity Σ 0 hyperon one uses [53] / . T 1 T √ u (x) = (x) Cγ s (x) d (x) + d (x) Cγ s (x) u (x) , (24) χΣ abc 5 b c 5 b c 1 a a 2 . / 1 uTa (x) C sb (x) γ5 dc (x) + dTa (x) C sb (x) γ5 uc (x) . (25) χΣ 2 (x) = √ abc 2 Interpolating fields for accessing other charge states of Σ are obtained by d → u or u → d, producing correlation functions analogous to those in (20) through (23). Note that χΣ 1 transforms as a triplet under SU (2) isospin. An SU (2) singlet interpolating field can be constructed by replacing “ + ” −→ “ − ” in (24) and (25). For the SU (3) octet Λ interpolating field (denoted by “Λ8 ”), one has T T 8 1 χΛ 1 (x) = √ abc 2 ua (x) Cγ5 db (x) sc (x) + ua (x) Cγ5 sb (x) dc (x) 6 − dTa (x) Cγ5 sb (x) uc (x) , (26) . T T 8 1 χΛ 2 (x) = √ abc 2 ua (x) C db (x) γ5 sc (x) + ua (x) C sb (x) γ5 dc (x) 6 / (27) − dTa (x) C sb (x) γ5 uc (x) , which leads to the correlation function 8
GΛ 11 (t, p; Γ ) =
1 −ip·x e 6 x # $ # $ −1 + 2 G Ss , Su , CS −1 uC dC ×tr −Γ 2 G Ss , Sd , CS $ # $ # −1 + 2 G Su , Ss , CS −1 uC dC +2 G Sd , Ss , CS $ # $ # −1 − G Su , Sd , CS −1 sC sC − G Sd , Su , CS , (28) 8
8
8
Λ Λ and similarly for the correlation functions GΛ 22 , G12 and G21 . The interpolating fields for the SU (3) flavour singlet (denoted by “Λ1 ”) are given by [53]
T T 1 χΛ 1 (x) = −2 abc − ua (x) Cγ5 db (x) sc (x) + ua (x) Cγ5 sb (x) dc (x) − dTa (x) Cγ5 sb (x) uc (x) , (29) . T Λ1 T χ2 (x) = −2 abc − ua (x) C db (x) γ5 sc (x) + ua (x) C sb (x) γ5 dc (x) / − dTa (x) C sb (x) γ5 uc (x) , (30)
86
D.B. Leinweber et al. 8
1
Λ where the last two terms are common to both χΛ 1 and χ1 . The correlation function resulting from this field involves quite a few terms, 1
GΛ 11 (t, p; Γ ) = −ip·x cc T C −1 S bb γ5 + γ5 S aa CS cc T C −1 S bb γ5 e tr −Γ γ5 Ssaa CS d d u u s x cc T C −1 S bb γ5 + γ5 S aa CS cc T C −1 S bb γ5 + γ5 Ssaa CS d d s u u cc T C −1 S bb γ5 + γ5 S aa CS cc T C −1 S bb γ5 + γ5 Suaa CS d d u s s ucc T C −1 − γ5 Ssaa γ5 tr Sdbb CS dcc T C −1 − γ5 Suaa γ5 tr Ssbb CS aa bb cc T −1 − γ5 Sd γ5 tr Su CSs C .
(31)
In order to test the extent to which SU (3) flavour symmetry is valid in the baryon spectrum, one can construct another Λ interpolating field composed of the terms common to Λ1 and Λ8 , which does not make any assumptions about the SU (3) flavour symmetry properties of Λ. We define . / c 1 uTa (x) Cγ5 sb (x) dc (x) − dTa (x) Cγ5 sb (x) uc (x) , (32) χΛ 1 (x) = √ abc 2 . / T c 1 T √ u χΛ (x) = (x) C s (x) γ d (x) − d (x) C s (x) γ u (x) , (33) abc b 5 c b 5 c 2 a a 2 to be our “common” interpolating fields which are the isosinglet analogue of χΣ 1 and χΣ 2 in (24) and (25). Such interpolating fields may be useful in determining the nature of the Λ∗ (1405) resonance, as they allow for mixing between singlet and octet states induced by SU (3) flavour symmetry breaking. To appreciate the structure of the “common” correlation function, one can introduce the function abc a b c bb T cc G(Sf1 , Sf2 , Sf3 ) = (x, 0) tr S (x, 0)S (x, 0) Sfaa f3 f2 1 (x, 0) Sfbb2 T (x, 0) Sfcc3 (x, 0) , (34) −Sfaa 1 which is recognised as G in (19) with the relative sign of the two terms changed. c With this notation, the correlation function corresponding to the χΛ 1 interpolating field is . # $ 1 −ip·x ΛC −1 , Su sC e tr −Γ G Sd , CS G11 (t, p; Γ ) = 2 x $/ # −1 +G Su , CSs C , Sd , (35) c
and similarly for the correlation functions involving the χΛ 2 interpolating field.
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
87
5.3 Spin- 32 Baryons In this section we extend the discussion from the previous section to the spin- 32 baryon sector. The mass of a spin- 32 baryon on the lattice is obtained from the two-point correlation function Gµν [35, 55], Gµν (t, p; Γ ) = tr [Γ Gµν (t, p)] , where αβ Gµν (t, p) =
β e−ip·x Ω| T χα µ (x) χν (0) |Ω ,
(36) (37)
x 3 and χα µ is a spin- 2 interpolating field, Γ is a matrix in Dirac space with α, β Dirac indices, and µ, ν Lorentz indices. The interpolating field operator used in the literature for accessing the isospin- 12 , spin- 32 , positive parity (charge +1) state is [35, 56, 57]
1 χpµ = abc uT a (x) Cγ5 γ ν db (x) gµν − γµ γν γ5 uc (x) . (38) 4
As pointed out in Sect. 5.1, all discussions of interpolating fields are carried out using the Dirac representation of the γ-matrices. This exact isospin- 12 interpolating field has overlap with both spin- 23 and spin- 12 states and with states of both parities. The resulting correlation function will thus require both spin and parity projection. The charge neutral interpolating field is obtained by interchanging u ↔ d. This interpolating field transforms as a Rarita-Schwinger operator under parity transformations. That is, if the quark field operators transform as in (18), then † N x) , PχN µ (x)P = +γ0 χµ (˜ and similarly for the Rarita-Schwinger operator Puµ (x)P † = +γ0 uµ (˜ x) ,
(39)
which will be discussed later. The computational cost of evaluating each of the Lorentz combinations in (38) is relatively high – about 100 times that for the ground state nucleon [24]. Consequently, in order to maximise statistics it is common to consider only the leading term proportional to gµν in the interpolating field, χpµ −→ abc uT a (x) Cγ5 γµ db (x) γ5 uc (x) . (40) This is sufficient since we will in either case need to perform a spin- 32 projection. In order to show that the interpolating field defined in (40) has isospin 12 , we first consider the standard proton interpolating field given in (16) which we know to have isospin 12 . Applying the isospin raising operator, I + , on χp , one finds
88
D.B. Leinweber et al.
I + χp = abc (uT a Cγ5 ub )uc = abc (uT a Cγ5 ub )T uc = −abc (uT a Cγ5 ub )uc = 0. Similarly, for the interpolating field defined in (40), one has I + χpµ = abc (uT a Cγ5 γµ ub )γ5 uc = abc (uT a Cγ5 γµ ub )T γ5 uc = −abc (uT a Cγ5 γµ ub )γ5 uc =0, where we have used the representation-independent identities Cγµ C −1 = −γµT , Cγ5 C −1 = γ5T , and the identities which hold in the Dirac representation: C T = C † = C −1 = −C with C = iγ2 γ0 and γ5T = γ5 . We note that χ ¯pµ , corresponding to χpµ in (40), is ¯a γ5 (d¯b γµ γ5 C u ¯cT ) , χ ¯pµ = abc u
(41)
so that χpµ χ ¯pν = abc a b c (uTα a [Cγ5 γµ ]αβ dbβ )γ5 ucγ u ¯cγ γ5 (d¯bβ [γν γ5 C]β α u ¯Tαa ) T → γ5 Su γ5 tr γ5 Su γ5 (Cγµ Sd γν C)
T
+γ5 Su γ5 (Cγµ Sd γν C) γ5 Su γ5 ,
(42)
where the last line is the result after performing the Grassman integration over the quark fields with the quark fields being replaced by all possible pairwise contractions. In deriving the ∆ interpolating fields, it is simplest to begin with the state containing only valence u quarks, namely the ∆++ . The interpolating field for the ∆++ resonance is given by [57] χ∆ µ
++
(x) = abc uT a (x) Cγµ ub (x) uc (x) ,
(43)
which transforms as a pseudovector under parity. The interpolating field for a ∆+ state can be similarly constructed [55], + 1 abc T a 2 u (x) Cγµ db (x) uc (x) + uT a (x) Cγµ ub (x) dc (x) . χ∆ µ (x) = √ 3 (44) Interpolating fields for other decuplet baryons are obtained by appropriate substitutions of u, d → u, d or s fields. To project a pure spin- 32 state from the correlation function Gµν , one needs to use an appropriate spin- 32 projection operator [58],
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
1 1 3/2 Pµν (p) = gµν − γµ γν − 2 (γ · p γµ pν + pµ γν γ · p) . 3 3p
89
(45)
The corresponding spin- 12 state can be projected by applying the projection operator 1/2 3/2 = gµν − Pµν . (46) Pµν To use this operator and retain all Lorentz components, one must calculate the full 4×4 matrix in Dirac and Lorentz space. However, to extract a mass, only one pair of Lorentz indices is needed, reducing the amount of calculations required by a factor of four. The results from [35] which are summarised in Sect. 6.4 are calculated from the third row of the Lorentz matrix and using the projection Gs33 =
4
s G3µ g µν Pν3 ,
(47)
µ,ν=1
to extract the desired spin states, s = 12 or 32 . Following spin projection, the resulting correlation function, Gs33 , still contains positive and negative parity states. The interpolating field operators defined in (38) and (40) have overlap with both spin- 32 and spin- 12 states with positive and negative parity. The field χµ transforms as a pseudovector under parity, as does the Rarita-Schwinger spinor, uµ . Thus the overlap of χµ with baryons can be expressed as M3/2+ 3 Ω|χµ |N 2 + (p, s) = λ3/2+ uµ (p, s) , (48) E3/2+ M3/2− 3 − γ5 uµ (p, s) , (49) Ω|χµ |N 2 (p, s) = λ3/2− E3/2− M1/2+ 1 γ5 u(p, s) , (50) Ω|χµ |N 2 + (p, s) = (α1/2+ pµ + β1/2+ γµ ) E1/2+ M1/2− 1 − u(p, s) , (51) Ω|χµ |N 2 (p, s) = (α1/2− pµ + β1/2− γµ ) E1/2− where the factors λB , αB , βB denote the coupling strengths of the interpolating field χµ to the baryon B. For the expressions in (50) and (51), we note that the spatial components of momentum, pi , transform as vectors under parity and commute with γ0 , whereas the γi do not change sign under parity but anti-commute with γ0 . Hence the right-hand-side of (50) also transforms as a pseudovector under parity in accord with χµ . Similar expressions can also be written for χ ¯µ , M3/2+ 3 N 2 + (p, s)|χ ¯µ |Ω = λ∗3/2+ u ¯µ (p, s) , (52) E3/2+
90
D.B. Leinweber et al.
N
3 2−
N
1 2+
N
1 2−
(p, s)|χ ¯µ |Ω =
−λ∗3/2− -
(p, s)|χ ¯µ |Ω = − (p, s)|χ ¯µ |Ω =
M3/2− u ¯µ (p, s)γ5 , E3/2−
M1/2+ ∗ ∗ u ¯(p, s)γ5 (α1/2 + pµ + β1/2+ γµ ) , E1/2+
M1/2− ∗ ∗ u ¯(p, s)(α1/2 − pµ + β1/2− γµ ) . E1/2−
(53)
(54)
(55)
Note that we are assuming identical sinks and sources in these equations. However, calculations often use a smeared source and a point sink in which case λ∗ , α∗ and β ∗ are no longer complex conjugates of λ, α and β but are instead replaced by λ, α and β. We are now in a position to find the form of (37) after we insert a complete set of intermediate states {|B(p, s)}. The contribution to (37) from each intermediate state considered is given by 3
3
¯ν |Ω Ω|χµ |N 2 + (p, s)N 2 + (p, s)|χ M3/2+ = +λ3/2+ λ3/2+ uµ (p, s)¯ uν (p, s) E3/2+ M3/2+ (γ · p + M3/2+ ) E3/2+ 2M3/2+ pµ γν − pν γµ + , 3M3/2+
= −λ3/2+ λ3/2+ −
2pµ pν 2 3M3/2 +
1 gµν − γµ γν 3
Ω|χµ |N 2 − (p, s)N 2 − (p, s)|χ ¯ν |Ω M3/2− = −λ3/2− λ3/2− γ5 uµ (p, s)¯ uν (p, s)γ5 E3/2− M3/2− (γ · p − M3/2− ) 1 = −λ3/2− λ3/2− gµν − γµ γν E3/2− 2M3/2− 3 2pµ pν pµ γν − pν γµ − − , 2 3M3/2 3M3/2− − 3
3
1
1
Ω|χµ |N 2 + (p, s)N 2 + (p, s)|χ ¯ν |Ω M1/2+ γ · p + M1/2+ =− (α1/2+ pµ + β1/2+ γµ )γ5 γ5 (α1/2+ pν + β 1/2+ γν ) , E1/2+ 2M1/2+ ¯ν |Ω Ω|χµ |N 2 − (p, s)N 2 − (p, s)|χ M1/2− γ · p + M1/2− = (α − pµ + β1/2− γµ ) (α1/2− pν + β 1/2− γν ) . E−/2+ 1/2 2M1/2− 1
1
To reduce computational expense, we consider the specific case when µ = ν = 3 and in order to extract masses we require p = (0, 0, 0). In this case we have the simple expressions
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD 3
3
3 2−
3 2−
Ω|χ3 |N 2 + (p, s)N 2 + (p, s)|χ ¯3 |Ω = λ3/2+ λ3/2+
Ω|χ3 |N
(p, s)N
2 3
2 (p, s)|χ ¯3 |Ω = λ3/2− λ3/2− 3
γ0 M3/2+ + M3/2+ 2M3/2+ γ0 M3/2− − M3/2− 2M3/2−
91
,
(56) , (57)
γ0 M1/2+ + M1/2+ γ5 γ3 2M1/2+ γ0 M1/2+ + M1/2+ = +β1/2+ β 1/2+ , (58) 2M1/2+ γ0 M1/2− + M1/2− 1 1 ¯3 |Ω = β1/2− β 1/2− γ3 γ3 Ω|χ3 |N 2 − (p, s)N 2 − (p, s)|χ 2M1/2− γ0 M1/2− − M1/2− = +β1/2− β 1/2− . (59) 2M1/2− 1
1
Ω|χ3 |N 2 + (p, s)N 2 + (p, s)|χ ¯3 |Ω = −β1/2+ β 1/2+ γ3 γ5
Therefore, in an analogous procedure to that used in Sect. 5.1, where a fixed boundary condition is used in the time direction, positive and negative parity states are obtained by taking the trace of the spin-projected correlation function, Gs33 , in (47) with the operator Γ = Γ± ,
± s (60) Gs± 33 = tr Γ G33 , where in this case (cf. (15)) Γ± =
1 (1 ± γ4 ) . 2
(61)
The positive parity states propagate in the (1,1) and (2,2) elements of the Dirac γ-matrix, while negative parity states propagate in the (3,3) and (4,4) elements for both spin- 21 and spin- 32 projected states. A similar treatment can be carried out for the ∆ interpolating fields but is left as an exercise for the interested reader. 5.4 Octahedral Group Irreducible Representations The procedure outlined above largely follows the continuum construction of interpolating operators used in, say, QCD sum-rule calculations. An alternative approach is to construct operators that lie in the irreducible representations (IRs) of the cubic group Oh of the lattice directly [48, 49]. To illustrate the latter method, we consider the construction of the I = 1/2, I3 = 1/2 nucleon interpolating operator, following the discussion of [49]. The starting point is the formation of a set of elemental baryon operators that are gauge invariant, and have the correct isospin, or flavour, properties. In the case of point-like quark fields, these are given by
92
D.B. Leinweber et al.
Φαβγ = abc (uaα dbγ ucβ − daα ubγ ucβ ) ,
(62)
where the coordinate of the quark fields are suppressed, and α, β, γ are spinor indices. Examination of (62) reveals the constraints Φαβγ +Φγβα = 0 and Φαβγ + Φβγα + Φγαβ = 0 so that there are only 20 independent operators. The central result needed to find operators transforming irreducibly under the IRs of Table 2 is the projection formula BiΛλF(x) =
dΛ (Λ)∗ Dλλ (R)UR BiF(x)UR† , gOh
(63)
R∈Oh
where Λ refers to an Oh IR, λ is the IR row, gOh is the number of elements (Λ) in Oh , dΛ is the dimension of the Λ IR, Dmn (R) is a Λ representation matrix corresponding to group element R, and UR is the quantum operator which implements the symmetry operations; the temporal argument is suppressed. Application of the formula requires explicit representation matrices for each group element. These are applied to the 20 linearly independent operators above, from which 20 linearly independent operators that transform irreducibly under Oh are identified. The procedure is Dirac-basis dependent, and linearly independent operators are shown in Table 3, using the DeGrand-Rossi representation of the Dirac γ-matrices [49]. There are three embeddings of G1 and a single embedding of H for both even parity (g) and odd parity (u); the two helicities of spin 1/2 correspond to the two rows of the two-dimensional representation G1g(1u) while the four helicities of spin 3/2 correspond to the four rows of the four-dimensional representation H. The three embeddings of G1 correspond to some linear combinations of the operators of (16)–(17) and the spin-1/2 projection of (38); the embedding of H corresponds to the spin-3/2 projection. Whilst the results in Table 3 may be less intuitive than their counterparts derived earlier, the procedure can easily extended to more complicated operators, including those with excited glue, or to pentaquark operators. Furthermore, we have seen explicitly that there are three independent spin-1/2 operators.
6 Survey of Results Now that we have provided a detailed description of the procedure for the calculation of excited baryons on the lattice, we will now present an overview of recent lattice calculations of the excited baryon spectrum. The emphasis of most calculations has been the demonstration that the excited nucleon spectrum is indeed accessible to lattice calculations, and most of the calculations share several features. Namely, they are in the quenched approximation to QCD, are obtained on lattice volumes of 2−3 fm, employ pseudoscalar masses of around 500 MeV, and make fairly limited investigations of the systematic uncertainties on the calculations.
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
93
Table 3. Combinations of the operators Φαβγ in (63) which transform irreducibly under Oh for the DeGrand-Rossi representation of the Dirac γ-matrices, employed by LHPC and MILC Collaborations (see [49]) Irrep
Row
Operators
G1g G1g
1 2
Φ112 + Φ334 −Φ221 − Φ443
G1g G1g
1 2
Φ123 − Φ213 + Φ314 Φ124 − Φ214 + Φ324
G1g G1g
1 2
2Φ114 + 2Φ332 − Φ123 − Φ213 + 2Φ134 − Φ314 −2Φ223 − 2Φ441 + Φ124 − Φ214 − 2Φ234 + Φ324
G1u G1u
1 2
Φ112 − Φ334 −Φ221 + Φ443
G1u G1u
1 2
Φ123 − Φ213 − Φ314 Φ124 − Φ214 − Φ324
G1u G1u
1 2
Hg Hg Hg Hg
1 2 3 4
Hu Hu Hu Hu
1 2 3 4
2Φ114 − 2Φ332 − Φ123 − Φ213 − 2Φ134 + Φ314 −2Φ223 + 2Φ441 + Φ124 + Φ214 + 2Φ234 − Φ324 √ 3(Φ113 + Φ331 ) Φ114 + Φ332 + Φ123 + Φ213 − 2Φ134 + Φ314 Φ √223 − Φ441 + Φ124 + Φ214 − 2Φ234 + Φ324 3(Φ224 + Φ442 ) √ 3(Φ113 − Φ331 ) Φ114 − Φ332 + Φ123 + Φ213 + 2Φ134 − Φ314 Φ √223 − Φ441 + Φ124 + Φ214 + 2Φ234 − Φ324 3(Φ224 − Φ442 )
The most comprehensive study of the excited nucleon spectrum has been obtained using FLIC fermions, detailed in [34, 35], and we will describe these calculations at length in these lectures. For some of the lowest-lying resonances, such as the Roper resonance and the odd-parity partner of the nucleon, there have been studies of the systematic uncertainties in the calculations, in particular arising from the finite lattice spacing, and the need to perform a chiral extrapolation [13]. For completeness, we will first briefly describe the gauge and fermion actions used in the FLIC fermion analysis. Additional details of the simulations can be found in [33, 34, 35]. 6.1 Lattice Actions for FLIC Calculation For the gauge fields, a mean-field improved plaquette plus rectangle action is used. The simulations are performed on a 163 × 32 lattice at β = 4.60, which corresponds to a lattice spacing of a = 0.122(2) fm set by a string tension analysis
94
D.B. Leinweber et al.
√ incorporating the lattice Coulomb potential [59] with σ = 440 MeV. For the quark fields, a Fat-Link Irrelevant Clover (FLIC) [33] action is implemented. A detailed description of the FLIC fermion action can be found in the contribution by Zanotti et al. in this series. A fixed boundary condition in the time direction is used for the fermions by setting Ut (x, Nt ) = 0 ∀ x in the hopping terms of the fermion action, with periodic boundary conditions imposed in the spatial directions. Gauge-invariant Gaussian smearing [51] in the spatial dimensions is applied at the source to increase the overlap of the interpolating operators with the ground states. Five masses are used in the calculations [33] and the strange quark mass is taken to be the second heaviest quark mass in each case. The analysis is based on a sample of 400 configurations, and the error analysis is performed by a thirdorder, single-elimination jackknife, with the χ2 per degree of freedom (NDF ) obtained via covariance matrix fits. 6.2 Spin- 12 Baryons −
In Fig. 1 we show the nucleon and N ∗ ( 12 ) masses as a function of the pseudoscalar meson mass squared, m2π . The filled squares indicate the results for the FLIC action, and the stars for the Wilson action [34] (the Wilson points are obtained from a sample of 50 configurations). We note here that the spatial size of the lattice is L = 1.95 fm and that from the values of mπ given in Table 1 of [34] we have mπ L ≥ 5.52.
2090 -
N* (1/2 )
M (GeV)
2
1650
-
1.6 1535
-
FLIC NP Imp Clover (ani) Fixed Point CI Wilson DWF Wilson NP Imp Clover
1.2
N 939 +
0.8 0
0.2
0.4 2
0.6
0.8
1
mπ (GeV2 ) −
Fig. 1. Masses of the nucleon (N ) and the lowest J P = 12 excitation (“N ∗ ”). The FLIC and Wilson results are from [34], the DWF [28], Fixed Point [32], Chirally Improved (CI) Wilson [32], NP improved clover [31] and NP improved anisotropic clover − [26] results are shown for comparison. The empirical nucleon and low lying N ∗ ( 12 ) masses are indicated by the asterisks along the ordinate
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
95
For comparison, we also show results from earlier simulations with domain wall fermions (DWF) [28] (filled triangles), a nonperturbatively (NP) improved clover action on anisotropic lattices at three different lattice spacings [26] (open diamonds), an NP improved clover action at β = 6.2 [31] (open squares, open circles and filled diamonds), and results using Fixed Point (FP) (crosses) and Chirally Improved (CI) (open inverted triangles) [32] fermion actions. The scatter of the different NP improved results is due to different source smearing and volume effects: the open squares are obtained by using fuzzed sources and local sinks, the open circles use Jacobi smearing at both the source and sink, while the filled diamonds, which extend to smaller quark masses, are obtained from a larger lattice (323 × 64) using Jacobi smearing. The empirical masses of the − nucleon and the three lowest 12 excitations are indicated by the asterisks along the ordinate. In an unquenched calculation, the results may shift by the order of 10% compared with a quenched calculation [12]. There is excellent agreement between the different improved actions for the nucleon mass, in particular between the FLIC [34], DWF [28], NP improved clover [26, 31], FP and CI [32] results. On the other hand, the Wilson results lie systematically low in comparison to these due to the large O(a) errors in this − action [33]. A similar pattern is repeated for the N ∗ ( 12 ) masses. Namely, the FLIC, DWF, NP improved clover, FP and CI masses are in good agreement with each other, while the Wilson results again lie systematically lower. A mass splitting of around 400 MeV is clearly visible between the N and N ∗ for all actions, including the Wilson action, despite its poor chiral properties. Furthermore, the − trend of the N ∗ ( 12 ) data with decreasing mπ is consistent with the approach to the mass of the lowest-lying physical negative parity N ∗ states. In the case of the NP-improved clover fermion action, with O(a2 ) discretisation errors, the calculation has been performed at three values of the lattice spacing, enabling a continuum extrapolation to be performed [31]. This is shown in Fig. 2, although it should be noted that a simple linear chiral extrapolation was performed in this calculation. There is a suggestion of a somewhat larger lattice spacing dependence for the higher excited resonance, emphasising the need to perform a careful analysis of systematic uncertainties in future calcu+ lations. Figure 3 shows the mass of the J P = 12 states (the excited state is denoted by “N (1/2+ )”). As is long known, the positive parity χ2 interpolating field does not have good overlap with the nucleon ground state [22] and a correlation matrix analysis confirms this result [34], as discussed below. It has + been speculated that χ2 may have overlap with the lowest 12 excited state, the N ∗ (1440) Roper resonance [28]. In addition to the FLIC and Wilson results from the present analysis, we also show in Fig. 3 the DWF results [28], and those from an earlier analysis with Wilson fermions together with the operator product ex+ pansion (OPE) [22]. The physical values of the lowest three 12 excitations of the nucleon are indicated by the asterisks. The most striking feature of the data is the relatively large excitation en+ ergy of the N ( 12 ), some 1 GeV above the nucleon. There is little evidence, therefore, that this state is the N ∗ (1440) Roper resonance. While it is possible
96
D.B. Leinweber et al.
5
4
mN r0
N(1535) 3
N(939)
2
Jacobi Fuzzed
1
0
0
0.01
0.02
(a/r0
0.03
0.04
)2
Fig. 2. The masses of the lowest-lying positive- and negative-parity baryons in units of r0−1 versus a2 in units of r02 , where r0 is Sommer’s scale [60]. The lines are linear fits in a2 /r02 to the positive- and negative-parity baryon masses; different plotting symbols correspond to different types of smearing. Also shown are the physical values 2.8
M (GeV)
2.4
+ N ’(1/2 )
2100 +
2 1710 +
1.6 1440 +
FLIC Wilson WilsonOPE DWF
N
1.2 939+
0.8
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
2 m 2 (GeV ) π Fig. 3. Masses of the nucleon, and the lowest J P = 12 excitation (“N ”). The FLIC results [34] are compared with the DWF [28] and Wilson-OPE [22] analyses, as well as + with the Wilson results from [34]. The empirical nucleon and low lying N ∗ ( 12 ) masses are indicated by asterisks, with physical masses given in MeV +
that the Roper resonance may have a strong nonlinear dependence on the quark mass at m2π ∼ 0.2 GeV2 , arising from, for example, pion loop corrections, it is unlikely that this behaviour would be so dramatically different from that of the
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
97
N ∗ (1535) so as to reverse the level ordering obtained from the lattice. A more likely explanation is that the χ2 interpolating field does not have good overlap with either the nucleon or the N ∗ (1440), but rather (a combination of) excited 1+ state(s). 2 Recall that in a constituent quark model in a harmonic oscillator basis, the mass of the lowest mass state with the Roper quantum numbers is higher than the lowest P -wave excitation. It seems that neither the lattice data (at large quark masses and with our interpolating fields) nor the constituent quark model have good overlap with the Roper resonance. Better overlap with the Roper is likely to require more exotic interpolating fields. As mentioned in Sect. 2, Lee et al. [36] have performed a calculation using overlap fermions with pion masses down to ∼180 MeV. Using new constrained curve fitting techniques, they extract excited states from a single correlation function calculated with the standard nucleon interpolating field in (16). The results from this calculation exhibit a dramatic drop in the mass of the first + excited 12 state of the nucleon at light pion masses, reversing the level ordering + − of the first 12 and 12 excited states. It is important, however, that this result be shown to be independent of the constrained curve fitting techniques adopted for this analysis. A correlation matrix analysis involving several operators would shed considerable light on this issue. Recently there has also been speculation that the Roper resonance suffers from large finite volume errors [29]. To study this issue, the authors of [29] calculate the nucleon and its first positive and negative parity excitations on three different lattice volumes (La = 1.5, 2.2 and 3.0 fm). Using Maximum Entropy Methods, they find that on large volume lattices (> ∼ 3.0 fm) the mass 1+ of the 2 excited nucleon state is reduced. A similar analysis remains to be − performed for the first 12 nucleon state obtained from the same fermion action. + At present Wilson fermion scaling violations allow the 12 excited nucleon state − to sit lower than the first 12 nucleon state obtained from the improved DWF action. It is essential to compare the masses of these states using the same fermion actions to remove systematic errors such as these. Similarly, a correlation matrix analysis involving several operators remains desirable. The BGR Collaboration has performed a calculation of the excited nucleon spectrum on two lattice volumes (La 1.8 and 2.4 fm) using Fixed Point and Chirally Improved Wilson fermions [32]. Using three different operators to cre+ − ate the nucleon states, the lowest two states in both the 12 and 12 channels are extracted using a 3 × 3 correlation matrix. The eigenvectors and eigenvalues determined from the correlation matrix analysis should correspond to the solutions of (4). It is unclear, however, whether the constraints which have been employed in [32] are physical, and in particular whether the eigenvectors correspond to the optimal projections onto physical states defined by the eigenvectors − u of (4). With this caveat, a splitting between the two 12 states is identified and + − the excited 12 state is observed to sit above the 12 states, in agreement with
98
D.B. Leinweber et al.
[34] (see next section). The results on two volumes do not exhibit any volume dependence. In the next section we present results from a 2 × 2 correlation matrix analysis using FLIC fermions on a single lattice volume. 6.3 Resolving the Resonances −
The mass splitting between the two lightest N ∗ ( 12 ) states (N ∗ (1535) & N ∗ (1650)) can be studied by considering the odd parity content of the χ1 and χ2 interpolating fields in (16) and (17). Recall that the “diquarks” in χ1 and χ2 couple differently to spin, so that even though the correlation functions built up from the χ1 and χ2 fields will be made up of a mixture of many excited states, they will have dominant overlap with different states [22, 24]. By using the correlation-matrix techniques described in [34] (see also Appendix), two separate mass states are extracted from the χ1 and χ2 interpolating fields. The results from the correlation matrix analysis are shown by the filled symbols in Fig. 4, and are compared to the standard “naive” fits performed directly on the diagonal correlation functions, χ1 χ1 and χ2 χ2 , indicated by the open symbols. − The results indicate that indeed the N ∗ ( 12 ) largely corresponding to the − χ2 field (labeled “N2∗ ”) lies above the N ∗ ( 12 ) which can also be isolated via Euclidean time evolution with the χ1 field (“N1∗ ”) alone. The masses of the corresponding positive parity states, associated with the χ1 and χ2 fields (labeled “N1 ” and “N2 ”, respectively) are shown for comparison. For reference, we also 2.8
M (GeV)
2.4 2100 + 2090
2
1710 + 1650
1.6
1535 1440 +
1.2 939 +
0.8
0
0.2
0.4
N1
N2
N1∗
N2∗
0.6
0.8
1
2 m 2 (GeV ) π +
−
Fig. 4. Masses of the J P = 12 and 12 nucleon states, for the FLIC action [34]. The positive (negative) parity states are labeled N1 (N1∗ ) and N2 (N2∗ ). The results from the projection of the correlation matrix are shown by the filled symbols, whereas the results from the standard fits to the χ1 χ1 and χ2 χ2 correlation functions are shown by ± the open symbols (offset to the right for clarity). Empirical masses of the low lying 12 states are indicated by the asterisks
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
99
±
list the experimentally measured values of the low-lying 12 states. It is interesting to note that the mass splitting between the positive parity N1 and negative ∗ ∗ states (roughly 400–500 MeV) is similar to that between the N1,2 parity N1,2 and the positive parity N2 state, reminiscent of a constituent quark–harmonic oscillator picture. Turning to the strange sector, in Fig. 5 we show the masses of the positive and negative parity Σ baryons calculated from the FLIC action [34] compared with the physical masses of the known positive and negative parity states. The pattern of mass splittings is similar to that found in Fig. 4 for the nucleon. + Namely, the 12 state associated with the χ1 field appears consistent with the + empirical Σ(1193) ground state, while the 12 state associated with the χ2 field + lies significantly above the observed first (Roper-like) 12 excitation, Σ ∗ (1660). There is also evidence for a mass splitting between the two negative parity states, similar to that in the nonstrange sector. The spectrum of the strangeness 2.8
M (GeV)
2.4 2
2000 1880 +
1.6
1770 + 1750 1660 + 1620
1.2
1193+
Σ1
Σ2
Σ∗
Σ ∗2
1
0.8
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
2 m 2 (GeV ) π Fig. 5. As in Fig. 4 but for the Σ baryons
–2 positive and negative parity Ξ hyperons is displayed in Fig. 6. Once again, the pattern of calculated masses repeats that found for the Σ and N masses in Figs. 4 and 5, and for the respective coupling coefficients [34]. The empirical masses of the physical Ξ ∗ baryons are denoted by asterisks. However, for all but the ground state Ξ(1318), the J P values are not known. Finally, we consider the Λ hyperons. In Figs. 7 and 8 we compare results obtained from the Λ8 and Λc interpolating fields, respectively, using the two different techniques for extracting masses. A direct comparison between the positive and negative parity masses for the Λ8 (open symbols) and Λc (filled symbols) states extracted from the correlation matrix analysis, is shown in Fig. 9. A similar pattern of mass splittings to that for the N ∗ spectrum of Fig. 8 is observed. In particular, the negative parity Λ∗1 state (diamonds) lies ∼400 MeV above the
100
D.B. Leinweber et al. 2.8 2.4
M (GeV)
2250 ? 2120 ?
2
1950 ?
1690 ? 1620 ?
1.6
1318 +
1.2 0.8
0
0.2
0.4
Ξ1
Ξ2
Ξ 1∗
Ξ ∗2
0.6
0.8
1
2 m 2 (GeV ) π Fig. 6. As in Fig. 4 but for the Ξ baryons. The J P values of the excited states marked with “?” are undetermined 2.8
M (GeV)
2.4 2 1810+ 1800 1670 1600 +
1.6
1405
1.2 0.8
1116+
0
8
Λ2
8∗
Λ82∗
Λ1 Λ1 0.2
0.4
0.6
8
0.8
1
2 m 2 (GeV ) π Fig. 7. As in Fig. 4 but for the Λ states obtained using the Λ8 interpolating field
positive parity Λ1 ground state (circles), for both the Λ8 and Λc fields. There is also clear evidence of a mass splitting between the Λ∗1 (diamonds) and Λ∗2 (squares). Using the naive fitting scheme (open symbols in Figs. 7 and 8) misses the mass splitting between Λ∗1 and Λ∗2 for the “common” interpolating field. Only after performing the correlation matrix analysis is it possible to resolve two separate mass states, as seen by the filled symbols in Fig. 8. As for the other baryons, there is little evidence that the Λ2 (triangles) has any significant overlap with the first positive parity excited state, Λ∗ (1600) (cf. the Roper resonance, N ∗ (1440), in Fig. 4).
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
101
2.8
M (GeV)
2.4 2 1810+ 1800 1670 1600 +
1.6
1405
1.2 0.8
0
Λ2
c∗
Λ2∗
Λ1 0.2
0.4
c
c
Λ1
1116+
0.6
c
0.8
1
2 m 2 (GeV ) π Fig. 8. As in Fig. 4 but for the Λ states obtained using the Λc interpolating field 2.8
M (GeV)
2.4 2 1810+ 1800 1670 1600 +
1.6
1405
1.2 0.8
1116+
0
Λc 0.2
Λ8 0.4
Λ1
Λ2
Λ∗1
Λ∗2
0.6
0.8
1
2 m 2 (GeV ) π Fig. 9. Masses of the positive and negative parity Λ states, for the octet Λ8 (open symbols) and “common” Λc (filled symbols) interpolating fields with the FLIC action [34]. The positive (negative) parity states labeled Λ1 (Λ∗1 ) and Λ2 (Λ∗2 ) are the two Λ states obtained from the correlation matrix analysis of the χΛ 1 and χ2 interpolating 1± fields. Empirical masses of the low lying 2 states are indicated by the asterisks
While it seems plausible that nonanalyticities in a chiral extrapolation [11] of N1 and N1∗ results could eventually lead to agreement with experiment, the situation for the Λ∗ (1405) is not as compelling. Whereas a 150 MeV pion-induced self energy is required for the N1 , N1∗ and Λ1 , 400 MeV is required to approach the empirical mass of the Λ∗ (1405). This may not be surprising for the octet fields, as the Λ∗ (1405), being an SU (3) flavour singlet, may not couple strongly to an SU (3) octet interpolating field. Indeed, there is some evidence of this in Fig. 9. This large discrepancy of 400 MeV suggests that relevant physics giving rise to a
102
D.B. Leinweber et al.
light Λ∗ (1405) may be absent from simulations in the quenched approximation. The behaviour of the Λ∗1,2 states may be modified at small values of the quark mass through nonlinear effects associated with Goldstone boson loops including ¯ channels. While some of this the strong coupling of the Λ∗ (1405) to Σπ and KN coupling will survive in the quenched approximation, generally the couplings are modified and suppressed [12, 61]. It is also interesting to note that the Λ∗1 and Λ∗2 masses display a similar behaviour to that seen for the Ξ1∗ and Ξ2∗ states, which are dominated by the heavier strange quark. Alternatively, the study of more exotic interpolating fields may indicate the the Λ∗ (1405) does not couple strongly to χ1 or χ2 . Investigations at lighter quark masses involving quenched chiral perturbation theory will assist in resolving these issues. 6.4 Spin- 32 Baryons The interpolating field defined in (40) has overlap with spin- 12 and spin- 32 states of both parities. After performing appropriate spin projections on the correlation ± ± functions, the masses of the N 32 and N 12 states are extracted and displayed in ± Fig. 10 as a function of m2π . Earlier results for the N 12 states using the standard 1 spin- 2 interpolating field [33, 34] from (16) are also shown with open symbols in Fig. 10 for reference. It is encouraging to note the agreement between the ± spin-projected 12 states obtained from the spin- 32 interpolating field in (40) and ± the earlier 12 results from the same gauge field configurations. We also observe
−
+
Fig. 10. Masses of the spin projected N 32 (filled triangles), N 32 (filled inverted + − triangles), N 12 (filled circles), and N 12 (filled squares) isospin- 12 states [35]. For + comparison, previous results from the direct calculation of the N 12 (open circles) and − N 12 (open squares) from Fig. 1 are also shown. The empirical values of the masses of + − − + the N 12 (939), N 12 (1535), N 32 (1520) and N 32 (1720) are indicated (in MeV) on the left-hand-side at the physical pion mass
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD −
103 −
that the N 32 state has approximately the same mass as the spin-projected N 12 state which is consistent with the experimentally observed masses. The results − + for the N 32 state in Fig. 10 indicate a clear mass splitting between the N 32 and − N 32 states obtained from the spin- 23 interpolating field, with a mass difference around 300 MeV. This is slightly larger than the experimentally observed mass difference of 200 MeV. + − Turning now to the isospin- 32 sector, results for the ∆ 32 and ∆ 32 masses + are shown in Fig. 11 as a function of m2π . The trend of the ∆ 32 data points with decreasing m± is clearly towards the ∆(1232), although some nonlinearity with − m2π is expected near the chiral limit [11, 12]. The mass of the ∆ 32 lies some 500 MeV above that of its parity partner, although with somewhat larger errors.
Fig. 11. Masses of the spin-projected ∆ 32
±
and ∆ 12
3/2+
±
isospin- 32 3− ∆ 2 (1700),
resonances [35]. −
(1232), ∆ 12 (1620) and The empirical values of the masses of the ∆ + ∆ 12 (1910) are shown (in MeV) on the left-hand-side at the physical pion mass ±
After performing a spin projection to extract the ∆ 12 states a discernible, but noisy, signal is detected. This indicates that the interpolating field in (43) has only a small overlap with spin- 12 states. However, with 400 configurations we are able to extract a mass for the spin- 21 states at early times, shown in Fig. 11. ± Here we see the larger error bars associated with the ∆ 12 states. The lowest − excitation of the ground state, namely the ∆ 12 , has a mass ∼350–400 MeV + − + above the ∆ 32 , with the ∆ 32 possibly appearing heavier. The ∆ 12 state is found to lie ∼100–200 MeV above these, although the signal becomes weak at smaller quark masses. This level ordering is consistent with that observed in the empirical mass spectrum, which is also shown in the figure. − − The N 12 and ∆ 12 states will decay to N π in S-wave even in the quenched approximation [62]. For all quark masses considered here, with the possible
104
D.B. Leinweber et al.
exception of the lightest quark, this decay channel is closed for the nucleon. While there may be some spectral strength in the decay mode, we are unable to separate it from the resonant spectral strength. + + − − The N 32 and ∆ 12 states will decay to N π in P -wave, while N 32 and ∆ 32 states will decay to N π in D-wave. Since the decay products of each of these states must then have equal and opposite momentum and energy given by 2 2π 2 2 , E =M + aL these states are stable in the present calculations.
7 Conclusions The increasing effort given to the study of the excited baryon and meson spectrum by the lattice community reflects the appreciation that the determination of the spectrum provides vital clues to the dynamics of QCD, and the mechanisms of confinement. The N ∗ spectrum in particular has several features, such − as the anomalously light N ∗ (1440) Roper resonance and the J P = 12 Λ(1405), that defy a straightforward interpretation within the quark model, and whose understanding can help to resolve the competing pictures of hadron structure. The impetus to study the N ∗ resonances has also strengthened following the observation of the S = +1, Θ+ pentaquark state, whose properties remain essentially unknown, but whose various interpretations offer vastly different pictures of baryon structure. In these lectures, we have described the techniques required to compute the N ∗ spectrum in lattice QCD, and given an overview of the current status of lattice calculations. The lightest states of both parities for spin 1/2 and spin 3/2 have been successfully resolved in the quenched approximation to QCD in both the nucleon (isospin- 12 ) and ∆ (isospin- 32 ) sectors, and in general the level ordering, albeit at relatively large pseudoscalar masses, mπ ≥ 500 MeV, is in accord with that observed experimentally. At these large pseudoscalar masses the spectrum largely follows quark-model expectations. It is important to appreciate that most current spectroscopy calculations have employed essentially “S-wave” quark propagators. The measurement of a wider basis of interpolating operators will be an important element of future studies, and the technology to construct such operators with lattice symmetry properties has now been developed. An important by-product of such studies will be insight into the quark and gluon structure of such hadrons. The realisation that hadronic physics at physical values of the pion mass is very different from that at mπ ≥ 300 MeV, and the consequent need to correctly account for the chiral properties of the theory, have been some of the most important developments in lattice QCD of recent years. FLIC fermions and the development of fermions having an exact analogue of chiral symmetry provide the means to attain such pion masses. There are suggestions that such radically
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
105
different behaviour at light quark masses has been seen in the excited nucleon sector. With the development of exact dynamical fat-link fermion algorithms [63, 64, 65], FLIC fermions provide tremendous promise for accessing the lightquark mass regime of full QCD. The continuation to physical values of the light quark masses poses extra challenges to the calculation of the resonance spectrum. The excited states are no longer stable under the strong interaction at sufficiently light quark masses. Even in the quenched approximation, this instability is manifest through nonunitary behaviour in the correlators and through additional non-analytic terms in the chiral expansion of nucleon masses [13]. The means to study the full spectrum, including the scattering lengths of multi-particle states, is in principle known, relying on examining the finite-volume shift in the two-particle spectrum. However, the method is computationally very demanding, requiring the measurement of many operators. With the realisation of large-scale computing facilities expected over the next several years, we can expect many of these endevours to come to fruition. An exciting era for baryon spectroscopy on the lattice lays ahead.
Acknowledgements This work was supported in part by the Australian Research Council and by DOE contract DE-AC05-84ER40150 under which the Southeastern Universities Research Association (SURA) operates the Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility. Generous grants of supercomputer time from the Australian Partnership for Advanced Computing (APAC) and the Australian National Computing Facility for Lattice Gauge Theory are gratefully acknowledged.
A Appendix − Correlation Matrix Analysis In this section we outline the correlation matrix formalism for calculations of masses, coupling strengths and optimal interpolating fields. After demonstrating that the correlation functions are real, we proceed to show how a matrix of such correlation functions may be used to isolate states corresponding to different masses, and also to give information about the coupling of the operators to each of these states (see also [34]). A.1 The U + U ∗ Method A lattice QCD correlation function for the operator χi χj , where χi is the i-th interpolating field for a particular baryon (e.g. χp+ 2 in Sect. 5.2), can be written as
106
D.B. Leinweber et al.
+ , Gij ≡ Ω|T (χi χj )|Ω ¯ −S[U,ψ,ψ] ¯ χi χj DU DψDψe , = ¯ −S[U,ψ,ψ] ¯ DU DψDψe
(64)
where spinor indices and spatial coordinates are suppressed for ease of notation. ¯ ψ] = SG [U ] + The fermion and gauge actions can be separated such that S[U, ψ, ¯ ¯ ψM [U ]ψ. Integration over the Grassmann variables ψ and ψ then gives DU e−SG [U ] det(M [U ])Hij [U ] Gij = , (65) DU e−SG [U ] det(M [U ]) where the term Hij stands for the sum of all full contractions of χi χj . The pure gauge action SG and the fermion matrix M satisfy SG [U ] = SG [U ∗ ] ,
(66)
[U ∗ ]C −1 = M ∗ [U ] , CM
(67)
and
≡ Cγ5 . respectively, where C Using the result of (67), one has det (M [U ∗ ]) = det (M ∗ [U ]) ,
(68)
and since det(M [U ]) is real, this leads to det (M [U ∗ ]) = det (M [U ]) .
(69)
Thus, U and U ∗ are configurations of equal weight in the measure DU det(M [U ]) exp (−SG [U ]), in which case Gij can be written as * ) DU e−SG [U ] det(M [U ]) {Hij [U ] + Hij [U ∗ ]} 1 Gij = . (70) 2 DU e−SG [U ] det(M [U ]) Let us define
G± ij ≡ tr[Γ± Gij ] ,
(71)
where “tr” denotes the spinor trace and Γ± is the parity-projection operator
∗ [U ] , then G± defined in (15). If tr [Γ Hij [U ∗ ]] = tr Γ Hij ij is real. This can be shown by first noting that Hij will be products of Dirac γ-matrices, fermion propagators, and link-field operators. In a γ-matrix representation which is −1 = γ ∗ . Fermion prop µC Hermitian, such as the Sakurai representation, Cγ µ −1 [U ∗ ]C −1 =M ∗ [U ], then agators have the form M , and recalling that since CM −1 [U ∗ ]C −1 =(M −1 [U ])∗ . For products of link-field operators O[U ] we have CM contained in Hij , the condition O[U ∗ ] = O∗ [U ] is equivalent to the requirement that the coefficients of all link-products are real. As long as this requirement
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
107
C −1 inside the trace to is enforced, we can then simply proceed by inserting C ± show that the (spinor-traced) correlation functions Gij are real. If one chooses −1 = −γ ∗ and Cγ −1 = γ ∗ . Therefore, 0C kC the Dirac representation, then Cγ 0 k in the Dirac representation of the γ-matrices, if Hij contains an even number ± of spatial γ-matrices with real coefficients, G± ij is purely real; otherwise Gij is purely imaginary. In summary, the interpolating fields considered here are constructed using only real coefficients and have no spatial γ-matrices. Therefore, the correlation functions G± ij are real. This symmetry is explicitly implemented by including both U and U ∗ in the ensemble averaging used to construct the lattice correlation functions, providing an improved unbiased estimator which is strictly real. This is easily implemented at the correlation function level by observing M −1 ({Uµ∗ }) = [Cγ5 M −1 ({Uµ }) (Cγ5 )−1 ]∗ for quark propagators. A.2 Recovering Masses, Couplings and Optimal Interpolators Let us again consider the momentum-space two-point function for t > 0, Gij (t, p) = e−ip·x Ω|χi (t, x)χj (0, 0)|Ω .
(72)
x
At the hadronic level, Gij (t, p) =
e−ip·x
p ,s
x
Ω|χi (t, x)|B, p , s
B
× B, p , s|χj (0, 0)|Ω , where the |B, p , s are a complete set of states with momentum p and spin s |B, p , sB, p , s| = I . (73) p
s
B
We can make use of translational invariance to write 1 0 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ Gij (t, p) = Ω eHt e−iP·x χi (0)eiP·x e−Ht B, p , s e−ip·x p
x
s
B
, + × B, p , s χj (0) Ω + , = e−EB t Ω|χi (0)|B, p, sB, p, s|χj (0)|Ω . s
(74)
B
It is convenient in the following discussion to label the states which have the χ interpolating field quantum numbers and which survive the parity projection as |Bα for α = 1, 2, . . . , N . In general the number of states, N , in this tower of excited states may be infinite, but we will only ever need to consider a finite
108
D.B. Leinweber et al.
set of the lowest such states here. After selecting zero momentum, p = 0, the parity-projected trace of this object is then G± ij (t) = tr[Γ± Gij (t, 0)] =
N
α
e−mα t λα i λj ,
(75)
α=1 α
where λα i and λj are coefficients denoting the couplings of the interpolating fields χi and χj , respectively, to the state |Bα . If we use identical source and sink interpolating fields then it follows from the definition of the coupling strength that α ± ± ∗ ∗ ± λj = (λα j ) and from (75) we see that Gij (t) = [Gji (t)] , i.e., G is a Hermitian matrix. If, in addition, we use only real coefficients in the link products, then G± is a real symmetric matrix. For the correlation matrices that we construct, we have real link coefficients but smeared sources and point sinks. Consequently, G is a real but non-symmetric matrix. Since G± is a real matrix for the infinite number of possible choices of interpolating fields with real coefficients, then we α can take λα i and λj to be real coefficients without loss of generality. Suppose now that we have M creation and annihilation operators, where M < N . We can then form an M × M approximation to the full N × N matrix G. At this point there are two options for extracting masses. The first is the standard method for calculation of effective masses at large t described in Sect. 5.1. The second option is to extract the masses through a correlation-matrix procedure [44]. Let us begin by considering the ideal case where we have N interpolating fields with the same quantum numbers, but which give rise to N linearly independent states when acting on the vacuum. In this case we can construct N ideal interpolating source and sink fields which perfectly isolate the N individual baryon states |Bα , α
φ =
N
uα i χi ,
(76)
vi∗α χi ,
(77)
i=1
φα =
N i=1
such that α
Bβ | φ |Ω = δαβ z α u(α, p, s) , Ω| φα |Bβ = δαβ z α u(α, p, s) , α
(78) (79)
where z α and z α are the coupling strengths of φα and φ to the state |Bα . The ∗α coefficients uα i and vi in (77) may differ when the source and sink have different smearing prescriptions, again indicated by the differentiation between z α and z α . For notational convenience for the remainder of this discussion repeated indices i, j, k are to be understood as being summed over. At p = 0, it follows that,
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
) α G± ij (t) uj =
109
*
tr Γ± Ω| χi χj |Ω uα j x
α −mα t = λα . i z e
(80)
The only t-dependence in this expression comes from the exponential term, which leads to the recurrence relationship α mα ± Gik (t + 1) uα G± k , ij (t) uj = e
(81)
which can be rewritten as ± α mα α uk . [G± (t + 1)]−1 ki Gij (t) uj = e
(82)
This is recognised as an eigenvalue equation for the matrix [G± (t + 1)]−1 G± (t) with eigenvalues emα and eigenvectors uα . Hence the natural logarithms of the eigenvalues of [G± (t + 1)]−1 G± (t) are the masses of the N baryons in the tower of excited states corresponding to the selected parity and the quantum numbers of the χ fields. The eigenvectors are the coefficients of the χ fields providing the ideal linear combination for that state. Note that since here we use only real coefficients in our link products, then [G± (t + 1)]−1 G± (t) is a real matrix and so uα and v α will be real eigenvectors. It also then follows that z α and z α will be real. These coefficients are examined in detail in the following section. One can also construct the equivalent left-eigenvalue equation to recover the v vectors, providing the optimal linear combination of annihilation interpolators, mα ∗α ± vi Gij (t + 1) . vk∗α G± kj (t) = e
(83)
Recalling (80), one finds: α α α −mα t , G± ij (t) uj = z λi e
vi∗α
G± ij (t)
=
± α vk∗α G± kj (t)Gil (t) ul =
α z α λj e−mα t , α −2mα t z α z α λα i λj e
(84) (85) .
(86)
The definitions of (79) imply α α α −mα t , vi∗α G± ij (t) uj = z z e
(87)
indicating the eigenvectors may be used to construct a correlation function in which a single state mass mα is isolated and which can be analysed using the methods of Sect. 2. We refer to this as the projected correlation function in the following. Combining (86) and (87) leads us to the result vk∗α Gkj (t)Gil (t) uα α −mα t l = λα . i λj e vk∗α Gkl (t)uα l
(88)
By extracting all N 2 such ratios, we can exactly recover all of the real couplings α λα i and λj of χi and χj respectively to the state |Bα . Note that throughout
110
D.B. Leinweber et al.
this section no assumptions have been made about the symmetry properties of G± ij . This is essential due to our use of smeared sources and point sinks. In practice we will only have a relatively small number, M < N , of interpolating fields in any given analysis. These M interpolators should be chosen to have good overlap with the lowest M excited states in the tower and we should attempt to study the ratios in (88) at early to intermediate Euclidean times, where the contribution of the (N − M ) higher mass states will be suppressed but where there is still sufficient signal to allow the lowest M states to be seen. This procedure will lead to an estimate for the masses of each of the lowest M states in the tower of excited states. Of these M predicted masses, the highest will in general have the largest systematic error while the lower masses will be most reliably determined. Repeating the analysis with varying M and different combinations of interpolating fields will give an objective measure of the reliability of the extraction of these masses. In our case of a modest 2 × 2 correlation matrix (M = 2) we take a cautious approach to the selection of the eigenvalue analysis time. As already explained, we perform the eigenvalue analysis at an early to moderate Euclidean time where statistical noise is suppressed and yet contributions from at least the lowest two mass states is still present. One must exercise caution in performing the analysis at too early a time, as more than the desired M = 2 states may be contributing to the 2 × 2 matrix of correlation functions. We begin by projecting a particular parity, and then investigate the effective mass plots of the elements of the correlation matrix. Using the covariance-matrix based χ2 /NDF , we identify the time slice at which all correlation functions of the correlation matrix are dominated by a single state. In practice, this time slice is determined by the correlator providing the lowest-lying effective mass plot. The eigenvalue analysis is performed at one time slice earlier, thus ensuring the presence of multiple states in the elements of the correlation function matrix, minimising statistical uncertainties, and hopefully providing a clear signal for the analysis. In this approach minimal new information has been added, providing the best opportunity that the 2 × 2 correlation matrix is indeed dominated by 2 states. The left and right eigenvectors are determined and used to project correlation functions containing a single state from the correlation matrix as indicated in (87). These correlation functions are then subjected to the same covariance-matrix based χ2 /NDF analysis to identify new acceptable fit windows for determining the masses of the resonances.
References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
V. Burkert et al., Few Body Syst. Suppl. 11 (1999) 1. 71 http://www.lepp.cornell.edu/public/CLEO/spoke/CLEOc/. 71 http://www.gsi.de/zukunftsprojekt/experimente/hesr-panda/. 71 http://www.jlab.org/Hall-D/. 71 S. Capstick and W. Roberts, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 45 (2000) S241. 71, 72 N. Isgur and G. Karl, Phys. Lett. B 72 (1977) 109; Phys. Rev. D 19 (1979) 2653. 71
Baryon Spectroscopy in Lattice QCD
111
7. Z.-P. Li, V. Burkert and Z.-J. Li, Phys. Rev. D 46 (1992) 70; C. E. Carlson and N. C. Mukhopadhyay, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 3745. 71 8. P. A. M. Guichon, Phys. Lett. B 164 (1985) 361. 72 9. O. Krehl, C. Hanhart, S. Krewald and J. Speth, Phys. Rev. C 62 (2000) 025207. 72 10. R. H. Dalitz and J. G. McGinley, in Low and Intermediate Energy Kaon-Nucleon Physics, ed. E. Ferarri and G. Violini (Reidel, Boston, 1980), p. 381; R. H. Dalitz, T.C. Wong and G. Rajasekaran, Phys. Rev. 153 (1967) 1617; E. A. Veit, B. K. Jennings, R. C. Barrett and A. W. Thomas, Phys. Lett. B 137 (1984) 415; E. A. Veit, B. K. Jennings, A. W. Thomas and R. C. Barrett, Phys. Rev. D 31 (1985) 1033; P. B. Siegel and W. Weise, Phys. Rev. C 38 (1988) 2221; N. Kaiser, P. B. Siegel and W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A594 (1995) 325; E. Oset, A. Ramos and C. Bennhold, Phys. Lett. B 527 (2002) 99 [Erratum-ibid. B 530 (2002) 260]. 72 11. D. B. Leinweber, A. W. Thomas, K. Tsushima and S. V. Wright, Phys. Rev. D 61 (2000) 074502. 72, 101, 103 12. R. D. Young, D. B. Leinweber, A. W. Thomas and S. V. Wright, Phys. Rev. D 66 (2002) 094507. 72, 95, 102, 103 13. D. Morel, B. Crouch, D. B. Leinweber and A. W. Thomas, “Physical baryon resonance spectroscopy from lattice QCD,” arXiv:nucl-th/0309044. 72, 93, 105 14. A. De R´ ujula, H. Georgi and S.L. Glashow, Phys. Rev. D 12 (1975) 147. 72 15. L. Y. Glozman and D. O. Riska, Phys. Rep. 268 (1996) 263; L. Y. Glozman, Phys. Lett. B 494 (2000) 58. 72 16. D.B. Leinweber, Annals Phys. 198 (1990) 203. 72 17. S. Capstick and N. Isgur, Phys. Rev. D 34 (1986) 2809. 72 18. C. L. Schat, J. L. Goity and N. N. Scoccola, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 (2002) 102002; C. E. Carlson, C. D. Carone, J. L. Goity and R. F. Lebed, Phys. Rev. D 59 (1999) 114008; J. L. Goity, Phys. Lett. B 414 (1997) 140; D. Pirjol and C. Schat, Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003) 096009. 72 19. See Penta-Quark 2003 Workshop, Jefferson Lab, Virginia (November 2003), http://www.jlab.org/intralab/calendar/archive03/pentaquark/. 73 20. D. B. Leinweber, A.W. Thomas, K. Tsushima and S.V. Wright, Phys. Rev. D 64 (2001) 094502. 73 21. C. R. Allton et al. [UKQCD Collaboration], Phys. Rev. D 47 (1993) 5128. 74 22. D. B. Leinweber, Phys. Rev. D 51 (1995) 6383. 74, 75, 84, 95, 96, 98 23. M. W. Hecht and T. A. DeGrand, Phys. Lett. B 275 (1992) 435; T. A. DeGrand and M. W. Hecht, Phys. Rev. D 46 (1992) 3937. 74 24. F. X. Lee and D. B. Leinweber, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 73 (1999) 258. 74, 87, 98 25. F. X. Lee, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 94 (2001) 251. 74 26. N. Nakajima, H. Matsufuru, Y. Nemoto and H. Suganuma, “SU (3) lattice QCD study for octet and decuplet baryon spectra,” arXiv:hep-lat/0204014; Y. Nemoto, N. Nakajima, H. Matsufuru and H. Suganuma, Nucl. Phys. A 721 (2003) 879. 74, 94, 95 27. S. Sasaki, T. Blum and S. Ohta, Phys. Rev. D 65 (2002) 074503. S. Sasaki, “Lattice study of nucleon properties with domain wall fermions,” arXiv:hep-lat/0110052. 74 28. D. Kaplan, Phys. Lett. B 288 (1992) 342. 74, 94, 95, 96 29. S. Sasaki, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 151 (2003) 143; K. Sasaki, S. Sasaki, T. Hatsuda and M. Asakawa, “Excited nucleon spectrum from lattice QCD with maximum entropy method,” arXiv:hep-lat/0309177. 74, 97 30. B. Sheikholeslami and R. Wohlert, Nucl. Phys. B 259 (1985) 572. 74 31. D. G. Richards, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 94 (2001) 269; M. G¨ ockeler et al. [QCDSF Collaboration], Phys. Lett. B 532 (2002) 63; D. G. Richards et al., [Lattice Hadron Physics Collaboration], Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 109 (2002) 89. 74, 94, 95
112
D.B. Leinweber et al.
32. D. Brommel, P. Crompton, C. Gattringer, L. Y. Glozman, C. B. Lang, S. Schaefer and A. Schafer [BGR Collaboration], “Excited nucleons with chirally improved fermions,” arXiv:hep-ph/0307073; C. Gattringer et al., Nucl. Phys. B 677 (2004) 3. 74, 85, 94, 95, 97 33. J. M. Zanotti et al. [CSSM Lattice Collaboration], Phys. Rev. D 65 (2002) 074507; Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 109 (2002) 101. 74, 93, 94, 95, 102 34. W. Melnitchouk, S. Bilson-Thompson, F. D. R. Bonnet, F. X. Lee, D. B. Leinweber, A. G. Williams, J. M. Zanotti and J. B. Zhang, Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003) 114506. 74, 85, 93, 94, 95, 96, 98, 99 35. J. M. Zanotti et al. [CSSM Lattice Collaboration], Phys. Rev. D 68 (2003) 054506. 74, 87, 89, 93, 102, 103 36. F. X. Lee et al., Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 119 (2003) 296. 75, 97 37. S. J. Dong, T. Draper, I. Horvath, F. X. Lee, K. F. Liu, N. Mathur and J. B. Zhang, “Roper resonance and S11 (1535) from lattice QCD,” arXiv:hep-ph/0306199. 75 38. F. Csikor, Z. Fodor, S. D. Katz and T. G. Kovacs, JHEP 0311 (2003) 070. 75 39. S. Sasaki, “Lattice study of exotic S = +1 baryon,” arXiv:hep-lat/0310014. 75 40. T. W. Chiu and T. H. Hsieh, “Pentaquark baryons in quenched lattice QCD with exact chiral symmetry,” arXiv:hep-ph/0403020. 75 41. B. Lasscock et al. [CSSM Lattice Collaboration], in preparation. 75 42. C. Michael, Nucl. Phys. B 259 (1985) 58. 77 43. M. L¨ uscher and U. Wolff, Nucl. Phys. B 339 (1990) 222. 77 44. C. McNeile and C. Michael, Phys. Rev. D 63 (2000) 114503. 77, 108 45. C. J. Morningstar and M. J. Peardon, Phys. Rev. D 60 (1999) 034509; Phys. Rev. D 56 (1997) 4043. 77 46. For an introduction to finite groups, see Symmetry in Physics, Vol. I, J. P. Elliott and P. G. Dawber, Oxford University Press (1979). 79 47. R. C. Johnson, Phys. Lett. 114B (1982) 147. 80 48. R. Edwards et al. [Lattice Hadron Physics Collaboration], “Baryonic operators for lattice simulations,” arXiv:hep-lat/0309079. 80, 91 49. R. G. Edwards et al. [Lattice Hadron Physics Collaboration], in preparation. 80, 91, 92, 93 50. S. Basak et al. [Lattice Hadron Physics Collaboration], “Mass spectrum of N ∗ and source optimization,” arXiv:hep-lat/0309091. 80 51. S. Gusken, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 17 (1990) 361. 81, 94 52. A. Frommer, V. Hannemann, B. Nockel, T. Lippert and K. Schilling, Int. J. Mod. Phys. C 5 (1994) 1073. 81 53. D. B. Leinweber, R. W. Woloshyn and T. Draper, Phys. Rev. D 43 (1991) 1659. 83, 85 54. K. Bowler et al., Nucl. Phys. B 240 (1984) 213. 84 55. D. B. Leinweber, T. Draper and R. W. Woloshyn, Phys. Rev. D 46 (1992) 3067. 87, 88 56. F. X. Lee, D. B. Leinweber, L. Zhou, J. M. Zanotti and S. Choe, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 106 (2002) 248. 87 57. Y. Chung, H. G. Dosch, M. Kremer and D. Schall, Nucl. Phys. B 197 (1982) 55. 87, 88 58. M. Benmerrouche, R. M. Davidson and N. C. Mukhopadhyay, Phys. Rev. C 39 (1989) 2339. 88 59. R. G. Edwards, U. M. Heller and T. R. Klassen, Nucl. Phys. B517 (1998) 377. 94 60. R. Sommer, Nucl. Phys. B 411 (1994) 839. 96 61. J. N. Labrenz and S. R. Sharpe, Phys. Rev. D 54 (1996) 4595. 102 62. D. B. Leinweber, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 109 (2002) 45. 103 63. W. Kamleh, D. B. Leinweber and A. G. Williams, “Hybrid Monte Carlo with fat link fermion actions,” arXiv:hep-lat/0403019. 105 64. W. Kamleh, D. B. Leinweber and A. G. Williams, “Dynamical fat link fermions,” arXiv:hep-lat/0402036. 105 65. W. Kamleh, D. B. Leinweber and A. G. Williams, “Dynamical FLIC fermions,” arXiv:hep-lat/0309154. 105
Hadron Structure and QCD: Effective Field Theory for Lattice Simulations D.B. Leinweber1 , A.W. Thomas1 , and R.D. Young1 Special Research Centre for the Subatomic Structure of Matter, and Department of Physics, University of Adelaide, Adelaide SA 5005, Australia
Abstract. Chiral extrapolations will be essential for many years if one is to connect modern lattice QCD calculations with experiment. Given the enormous efforts made to ensure that the lattice QCD simulations are a rigorous implementation of nonperturbative QCD, it is essential that the chiral extrapolation procedure should also be consistent with all known constraints of QCD. We review the enormous progress made on this problem over the past three or four years.
1 Introduction Central to the strong interaction within the Standard Model is the challenge of solving a strongly coupled field theory with spontaneous symmetry breaking. Making a precise determination of the masses and properties of free mesons and baryons directly from QCD itself is a tremendous challenge. It is equally important that we learn the sort of qualitative lessons needed to develop an intuitive understanding or picture of hadron structure. Important issues include the content of non-valence quarks and their spin distribution, as well as the changes they induce in the nonperturbative QCD vacuum in relation to energy density and topology. There exist hints that the structure of individual hadrons may play a fundamental role in properties of dense matter, including its saturation properties [1, 2]. Changes of hadron properties in-medium [3, 4] should serve as precursors of the quark-gluon physics which one expects to appear explicitly at higher densities. This is a central issue for both nuclear and particle physics and a sound understanding of free hadron structure is a vital piece of that puzzle. It will be quite a few years before full QCD simulations can be performed at physical light quark masses. With computation time scaling like ∼1/mq3.6 [5], quark masses are typically restricted to above 50 MeV for accurate calculations with improved quark and gluon actions. The exception to this is to use staggered fermions – which have shown some results at 25 MeV [6] – but this approach has a number of technical problems, including a larger effective lattice spacing for fermions and multiple pions (extra tastes). The latter, especially, threatens to complicate the chiral extrapolation problem which we explore next. Given the computational difficulty of making a calculation at low quark mass there are three options:
D.B. Leinweber, A.W. Thomas, and R.D. Young: Hadron Structure and QCD: Effective Field Theory for Lattice Simulations, Lect. Notes Phys. 663, 113–129 (2005) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2005 www.springerlink.com
114
D.B. Leinweber et al.
1. Make no comparison with any physical hadronic data: while not leading to any errors of interpretation, such an approach is quite unsatisfying. Hadronic physics is an extremely active area of study, both experimental and theoretical and it is important that all of that work receives the best theoretical guidance possible. As the only known rigorous, nonperturbative method of solving the strong interaction problem, lattice QCD should be a vital component of this equation. 2. Use an appropriate method to extrapolate the properties calculated at large light-quark mass to the physical value: this is the chiral extrapolation problem, which is complicated by spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking in QCD. As we shall explain, this problem has recently been solved by a careful reformulation of the effective field theory. 3. One can use the lattice simulations, which do represent the rigorous consequences of non-perturbative QCD, as guidance for models of hadron structure. This simply requires that one treat the light quark masses as variable parameters in any model and compare the resulting hadron properties directly with lattice results.
2 Effective Field Theory for QCD The power of effective field theory for strongly interacting systems has been apparent for more than 50 years, beginning with Foldy’s inclusion of the anomalous magnetic moment of the proton in a derivative expansion of the electromagnetic coupling of photons to baryons. Of course, the fact that nucleon form factors can be approximated by a dipole with mass parameter M 2 = 0.71 GeV2 means that the radius of convergence of the formal expansion is less than 0.84 GeV. In the last twenty years our understanding of the symmetries of QCD have led to a systematic expansion of hadron properties and scattering amplitudes about the limits mπ = 0 and q = 0, known as chiral perturbation theory. For the pseudoscalar mesons, which are rigorously massless in the limit where the u, d and s quark masses are zero (the chiral SU (3) limit), this approach has been especially successful. Although, even here, serious questions have been raised over whether the formal expansion is really convergent for masses as large as ms [7, 8, 9]. In the case of baryons the questions concerning convergence are even better developed. As our example we take the best studied case relevant to lattice QCD, namely the dependence of MN on light quark mass mq . Given the GellMann–Oakes–Renner (GOR) relation, m2π ∝ mq , we prefer to use m2π , rather than mq , as the measure of explicit chiral symmetry breaking in the expressions below1 . The formal chiral expansion for MN , in terms of mπ , about the SU (2) chiral limit in full QCD is: 1
We stress, however, that wherever the GOR relation fails, e.g. for m2π > 0.8 GeV2 or for mπ → 0 in QQCD (where there are logarithmic chiral corrections), one should revert to an expansion written explicitly in terms of mq .
Hadron Structure and QCD
115
MN = a0 + a2 m2π + a4 m4π + a6 m6π + · · · +σNπ (mπ ) + σ∆π (mπ ) ,
(1)
where σBπ is the self-energy arising from a Bπ loop (with B = N or ∆). These N and ∆ loops generate the leading and next-to-leading non-analytic (LNA and NLNA) behaviour, respectively. These loop integrals contain ultraviolet divergences which require some regularisation prescription. The standard approach is to use dimensional regularisation to evaluate the self-energy integrals. Under such a scheme the N N π contribution simply becomes σNπ (mπ ) → cLNA m3π and the analytic terms, a0 and a2 m2π , undergo an infinite renormalisation. The ∆ contribution produces a logarithm, so that the complete series expansion of the nucleon mass about mπ = 0 is: MN = c0 + c2 m2π + c4 m4π + cLNA m3π + cNLNA m4π log mπ + · · · ,
(2)
where the ai have been replaced by the renormalised (and finite) parameters ci . The coefficients of the low-order, non-analytic contributions are known [12, 13, 14]: 32 2 3 3 3 g . (3) cLNA = − g2 , cNLNA = 32 π fπ2 A 32 π fπ2 25 A 4 π ∆ Although strictly one should use values in the chiral limit, we take the experimental numbers with gA = 1.26, fπ = 0.093 GeV, the N − ∆ mass splitting, ∆ = 0.292 GeV and the mass scale associated with the logarithms will be taken to be 1 GeV. We stress that (2) was derived in the limit mπ /∆ 1. At just twice the physical pion mass this ratio approaches unity. Mathematically the region mπ ≈ ∆ is dominated by a square root branch cut which starts at mπ = ∆. Using dimensional regularisation this takes the form [15]: 2 mπ −3 32 2 1 3 2 g (2∆ − 3mπ ∆) log 32 π fπ2 25 A 2π µ2 ) * ∆ − ∆2 − m2π 3 − 2(∆2 − m2π ) 2 log ∆ + ∆2 − m2π
(4)
for mπ < ∆, while for mπ > ∆ the second logarithm becomes an arctangent. Clearly, to access the higher quark masses in the chiral expansion, currently of most relevance to lattice QCD, one requires a more sophisticated expression than that given by (2). 2.1 Naive Convergence Forgetting for a moment the issues surrounding the ∆π cut, we note that the formal expansion of the N → N π → N self-energy integral, σNπ , has been
116
D.B. Leinweber et al.
shown to have poor convergence properties. Using a sharp, ultra-violet cut-off, Wright showed [16] that the series expansion, truncated at O(m4π ), diverged for mπ > 0.4 GeV. This already indicated that the series expansion motivated by dimensional regularisation would have a slow rate of convergence. A similar conclusion had been reached somewhat earlier by Stuckey and Birse [10]. In considering the convergence of the truncated series, (2), it is helpful to return to the general form from which it was derived, namely (1). The dimensionally regulated approach requires that the pion mass should remain much lighter than every other mass scale involved in the problem. This requires that mπ /ΛχSB 1 (and mπ /∆ 1 if we use the simple logarithm in (2) rather than the full cut structure of (4)). An additional mass scale, which we address in detail below, is set by the physical extent of the source of the pion field [17]. This scale, which is of order −1 RSOU RCE , corresponds to the transition between the rapid, non-linear variation required by chiral symmetry and the smooth, constituent-quark like mass behaviour observed in lattice simulations at larger quark mass. An alternative to dimensional regularisation is to regulate (1) with a finite ultra-violet cut-off in momentum space. Figure 1 displays results for a dipole-vertex regulator.
1.8
MN GeV
1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0
0.2
0.4 0.6 mΠ 2 GeV2
0.8
1
Fig. 1. Fits to lattice data with dipole regulator for the self-energy loop N → N π (neglecting the N → ∆π term for simplicity). The dashed lines show the expansion up to successive orders in mπ , from m2π up to m8π – these alternate about the solid curve as we go through even and odd terms
2.2 Renormalization and Effective Field Theory In this section we draw extensively from the pedagogic introduction to effective field theories given a few years ago by LePage [11]. In that case the problem considered was to develop an effective field theory for the solution of the Schr¨ odinger equation for an unknown potential. The key physical idea of the effective field
Hadron Structure and QCD
117
theory is to introduce an energy scale, λ, above which one does not attempt to understand the physics. For example, the energy region above that cut-off may involve new physics – e.g., in the very high energy limit, physics beyond the Standard Model. Because one does not pretend to control physics above the scale λ, one should not include momenta above λ in computing radiative corrections. Instead, one introduces renormalization constants which depend on (or “run with”) the choice of cut-off λ so that, to the order one works, physical results are independent of λ. As LePage points out, “it makes little sense to reduce a [i.e., increase λ ∼ 1/a] below the range” in which we understand the physics, because the “structure they see there is almost certainly wrong.” When it comes to specific problems with the development of an effective theory of NN scattering, this line of argument leads him to conclude that “the problem is with dimensional regularization – and not with effective field theory.” In particular, dimensional regularization involves integrating loop momenta in the effective field theory over momenta all the way to infinity – way beyond the scale where the effective theory has any physical significance. In the context of our present problem of chiral extrapolation, the essential lesson to draw from LePage’s investigation is that one should not take the cutoff to ∞, that is one should not use dimensional regularization. Nor should one attempt to determine the “true” cut-off of the theory. Rather, one should choose a cut-off scale somewhat below the place where the effective theory omits essential physics and use data to constrain the renormalization constants of the theory and hence eliminate the dependence on that cut-off as far as possible. The issue is then what mass scale determines the upper limit beyond which the effective field theory is applicable. This is commonly taken to be ΛχP T ∼ 4πfπ ∼ 1 GeV. Unfortunately this is incorrect for baryons. In the context of nuclear physics it has long been appreciated that nuclear sizes could never be derived from naive dispersion relation considerations of nearest t-channel poles – anomalous thresholds associated with the internal structure of nuclei dominate. Similarly, the size of a baryon is determined by nonperturbative QCD beyond the scope of chiral perturbation theory. The natural scale associated with the −1 size of a nucleon is the inverse of its radius or a mass scale RSOU RCE ∼ 0.2 to 0.5 GeV – far below ΛχP T . In the context of effective field theory it is inconsistent to keep loop contributions from momenta above this scale! As a result of these considerations, we are led to regulate the radiative corrections which give rise to the leading and next-to-leading non-analytic contributions to the mass of the nucleon using a finite range regulator with a mass −1 in the range RSOU RCE . As far as possible residual dependence on the specific choice of mass scale (and form of regulator function) will be eliminated by fitting the renormalization constants to nonperturbative QCD – in this case data obtained from lattice QCD simulations. The quantitative success of applying the method is to be judged by the extent to which physical results extracted from the analysis are indeed independent of the regulator (over a physically sensible range). We refer to this approach as finite range regularization, FRR.
118
D.B. Leinweber et al.
3 Chiral Expansion of the Nucleon Mass Having established the philosophical framework for our analysis we now investigate the effective rate of convergence of the chiral expansions obtained using different functional forms for the regulator. For comparison we also make comparisons with the results obtained using a dimensionally regulated approach. To analyse the merits of various regularisation schemes, at best, we would require exact knowledge of how the nucleon mass varies with quark mass. Having only one value for the experimental nucleon mass we cannot determine the parameters that govern the quark mass dependence of MN without taking some information from alternate sources. Through lattice QCD we have a reliable, non-perturbative method for studying the variation of MN with mπ . In principle, this allows one to fix the parameters of the chiral expansion using data obtained in simulations performed at varying quark mass. Lattice simulations of full QCD are restricted to the use of relatively heavy quarks and hence it is not clear, a priori, whether the effective field theory expansion is capable of linking to even the lightest simulated quark mass where mπ ∼ 500 MeV. We take as input both the physical nucleon mass and recent lattice QCD results of the CP-PACS Collaboration [18] and the JLQCD Collaboration [19]. This enables us to constrain an expression for MN as a function of the quark mass. The lattice results of [18] have been obtained using improved gluon and quark actions on fine, large volume lattices with high statistics. These simulations were performed using an Iwasaki gluon action [20] and the mean-field improved clover fermion action. In this work we concentrate on only those results with msea = mval and the two largest values of β (i.e., the finest lattice spacings a ∼ 0.09– 0.13 fm). We use just the largest volume results of [19], where simulations were performed with non-perturbatively improved Wilson quark action and plaquette gauge action. The lattice volumes and spacings are similar for the two data sets. We set the physical scale at each quark mass, using the UKQCD method [21]. That is, we use the Sommer scale r0 = 0.5 fm [22, 23]. This choice is ideal in the present context because the static quark potential is insensitive to chiral physics. This ensures that the results obtained represent accurate estimates of the continuum, infinite-volume theory at the simulated quark masses. The lattice data lies in the intermediate mass region, with m2π between 0.3 and 1.0 GeV2 . To remove the bias implicit in choosing any particular regularization scheme, we allow each scheme to serve as a constraint curve for the other methods. In this way we generate six (one for each regularisation) different constraint curves that describe the quark mass dependence of MN . The first case corresponds to the truncated power series obtained through the dimensionally regulated (DR) approach, (2). We work to analytic order m6π , which is necessary in order to remove incorrect short distance physics arising from the non-analytic contribution at order m4π log mπ . The second procedure (labeled “BP”) takes a similar form but the branch point obtained from the dimensionally regularised N → ∆π transition is retained in its full functional form. That is, the logarithm in (2) is
Hadron Structure and QCD
119
replaced by the full expression, (4), which ensures the correct non-analytic structure where the logarithm converts to an arctangent above the branch point. We refer to this form as the dimensionally-regulated branch-point (BP) approach. Finally, based on (1), we evaluate the loop integrals σNπ ≡ cLN A Iπ (mπ , Λ) and σ∆π ≡ cN LN A Iπ∆ (mπ , Λ), where: 2 ∞ k 4 u2 (k) Iπ = dk 2 (5) π 0 k + m2 and Iπ∆ = −
8∆ 3
0
∞
dk √
k 4 u2 (k) √ . k 2 + m2 (∆ + k 2 + m2 )
(6)
We use four different functional forms for the finite-ranged, ultra-violet vertex regulator, u(k) – namely the sharp-cutoff (SC), θ(Λ − k); monopole (MON), Λ2 /(Λ2 + k 2 ); dipole (DIP), Λ4 /(Λ2 + k 2 )2 ; and Gaussian (GAU), exp(−k 2 /Λ2 ). Closed expressions for these integrals in the first three cases are given in the Appendix of [24]. Provided one regulates the effective field theory below the point where new short distance physics becomes important, the essential results will not depend on the cut-off scale [11]. We use knowledge learned in [24] as a guide for the appropriate scales for each of the regulator forms. In particluar, we choose regulator masses of 0.4, 0.5, 0.8 and 0.6 GeV for the sharp, monopole, dipole and Gaussian regulators respectively. For all six regularisation prescriptions, both DR-based and FR