To Julian and to the Memory of Julien Favre
Contents Family Tree
viii
Introduction
ix
1 Feral Man
1
2 Kaspar Ha...
93 downloads
3843 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
To Julian and to the Memory of Julien Favre
Contents Family Tree
viii
Introduction
ix
1 Feral Man
1
2 Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
22
3 Homoeopathic Experiments
36
4 The Search For Identity
51
5 Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes Against the Soul’
66
6 Philip Henry, Lord Stanhope
81
7 Kaspar Hauser in Ansbach
98
8 The Death of Kaspar Hauser
112
9 Kaspar Hauser and the Grand Duchy of Baden
133
10 Who Was Kaspar Hauser?
156
11 Literary Representations of Kaspar Hauser
175
12 Conclusion
189
Notes
195
Bibliography
214
Index
226
vii
Luise
Karoline
Josephine Son 29.9.1812– 16.10.1812 (This is the son whom some claim was Kaspar Hauser †1833)
Amalie
2
Marie
Wilhelmine Karl 1786–1818 1811 Grand Duke = Stephanie Beauharnais 1789–1860
Leopold
2
Alexander
Marie
Ludwig I
Friedrich
Friederike
1
1
Luise
Karl Ludwig 1755 –1801 = Amalie von ssen-Darmstadt 1754–1832
1 Wilhelm
2
2 Maximilian
Carl Friedrich 1728–1811 1803 Duke 1806 Grand Duke = I) Caroline Luise von Hessen-Darmstadt 1723–83 = 2) Luise Geyer v. Geyersberg (Countess Hochberg) 1768–1820
Baden. Zähringen Family Tree
viii
Introduction
Kaspar Hauser was a foundling of about 16 years of age who appeared in Nuremberg in 1828. He was the object of considerable public curiosity and speculation and aroused the compassion of the city fathers. He claimed to have been confined in a dark cellar for years on end and to have been fed on a diet of bread and water. He arrived in the city barely able to speak and walked with great difficulty. Here was a blank screen on which could be projected the fantasies of those with whom he came into close contact. Here was another of those wild children who people ancient mythology and who had appeared infrequently in Europe since the fourteenth century and had excited philosophers and medical men to speculate on the nature of man. How was a human being to be defined? How is speech acquired? Is man by nature good or evil? Are there any innate ideas? Do children have rights? Is civilization harmful or beneficial? By 1828 some of these questions had lost their urgency, but faced with a youth who appeared to have grown up apart from human society there were many who wished to test their pedagogical and medical theories on such a promising subject. Much of the speculation about Kaspar Hauser was conditioned by the reaction of earlier intellectuals to previous cases of feral man. Nuremberg’s intellectual elite was fully conversant with the writing of the likes of Montaigne, Rousseau and Voltaire and were eager to make their contribution to a debate to which so many distinguished writers had contributed. In our own day such cases are still of great interest, although the emphasis is now no longer on speculation about the nature of man but rather on the psychological effects of child abuse and the question of language acquisition. Few ask whether children have an innate conception of God, but the question still is raised whether children have an innate generative grammar. These questions are addressed in the first chapter which gives the intellectual setting to Kaspar Hauser’s reception in Nuremberg on Whit Monday 1828. ix
x
Kaspar Hauser
The case of Kaspar Hauser was of particular interest to specialists in a number of different disciplines and thus provides us with fascinating insights into the climate of the times. This was the heyday of homoeopathy and Mesmerism, and ‘animal magnetism’ still had its devotees. Kaspar Hauser was put in the hands of a man who was fascinated by such forms of alternative medicine and he was placed in the care of homoeopathic doctors who conducted a series of experiments on their unfortunate patient. Kaspar Hauser appeared to be remarkably sensitive to homoeopathic medicines and was considered to have exceptional animal magnetism, particularly in his early days in Nuremberg. The doctors’ reports thus provide interesting insights into these unorthodox but popular medical practices. Kaspar Hauser claimed to have been kept in solitary confinement in a small, dark cellar for as long as he could remember. Under existing Bavarian law his gaolers were not necessarily liable for prosecution because it had to be shown that there were significant long-term harmful effects on the victim before a case could be made for abuse. Just as there had to be a corpse before anyone could be charged with murder so there had to be clear indication of abuse before charges could be laid. Kaspar Hauser appeared to be in good health, was not insane and insisted that he had been well treated, and thus no indictable crime had been committed. Under the Bavarian criminal code his gaolers could be charged with illegal confinement under articles 192 to 195 and with abandonment under article 174 but not for the lasting psychological damage they had inflicted on their victim. Anselm von Feuerbach, one of Germany’s foremost jurists and the principal author of Bavaria’s progressive criminal code, was fascinated by the case and took a kindly interest in Kaspar Hauser’s welfare. In his remarkable pamphlet Kaspar Hauser: An Example of a Crime Against the Soul he argued that a dastardly crime had been committed against his soul, a crime that was far more serious in his view than either illegal confinement or abandonment. The debates between lawyers over child abuse and mental cruelty are indicative of current legal opinion on important issues that were only just beginning to be addressed. When Kaspar Hauser arrived in Nuremberg he was barely able to talk and could only write the alphabet and his name. His education was first entrusted to a schoolmaster on sick leave who espoused progressive views on education that were tinged with the ideas of Jean-Jacques Rousseau. When it was felt that he was no longer safe in Nuremberg he was moved to near-by Ansbach where he was entrusted to a pedagogue with a radically different approach. He believed in strict discipline and
Introduction
xi
learning by rote. These two opposing views on education illustrate how a change was taking place in Germany from the flexible and humanistic to the rigid and authoritarian. Inevitably questions were soon asked about Kaspar Hauser’s origins. He had become an overnight celebrity in Nuremberg. A steady stream of visitors came to his cell. Sensation seekers mixed with those who wished him well. Later, on his walks around the town he was surrounded by the curious. He was a local conversation piece, but soon his fame spread far and wide until he was christened ‘Europe’s Child’. But who was this strange youth? Whence did he come? Who were his cruel gaolers? Most people were familiar with the fund of stories of foundlings, mysterious prisoners, and the intriguing drama of the ‘Man in the Iron Mask’. Then as now there was a widespread belief in conspiracy theories. Combined with the popular radicalism of south-western Germany it was hardly surprising that it was widely believed that Kaspar Hauser was of noble or even royal birth. Why else should such pains have been taken to hide him for so many years? How else could it be explained that he was in remarkably good health and had clearly lived in hygienic surroundings? Was it not reasonable to presume that only the rich and powerful could have managed to cover their traces so successfully that the police, in spite of handsome rewards offered for any relevant information, were unable to uncover a single clue that might have helped them solve the mystery. Radicals and republicans seized upon the Kaspar Hauser affair to discredit the petty principalities and what the great Prussian statesman Baron vom Stein described as the ‘sultanates’ of the German Confederation. Only such petty tyrants and their corrupt and ambitious satraps were capable of such cruelty. Only they had the dynastic or financial motives to remove an heir who stood in the way of a throne or a fortune. They alone had the power, the money and the organizational resources needed to cover all traces of their crime. The proponents of this conspiracy theory were quick to seize on the grand duchy of Baden as the scene of the crime. Both male heirs had died in early infancy. The daughters were all perfectly healthy. Since the line of succession went through the male line, and since offspring of the Grand Duke’s morganatic marriage to an ambitious schemer thus inherited the throne, there was a clear motive to remove the two legitimate male heirs. That Kaspar Hauser was the legitimate Grand Duke of Baden was explained by claiming that he had been exchanged when only a few days old with a baby that was mortally ill and who died a few hours later. He was then kept in captivity for about 16 years. He was
xii
Kaspar Hauser
now old enough to be able to pass as yet another of the homeless children that roamed the highways and byways of Germany. It was obvious that he had no notion of his exalted station and thus posed no danger to his kidnappers. The suggestion that Kaspar Hauser might be the legitimate Grand Duke of Baden was of particular interest to the Bavarian authorities because of a complex claim to some previously Bavarian territory which should revert to them if the direct succession to the grand duchy of Baden were broken. Since Nuremberg was in Bavaria the police were bound to investigate the Kaspar Hauser affair, but the case was given an added importance because of the long-standing territorial wrangles with the neighbouring state. It is for this reason that the king of Bavaria took a particular interest in the case and offered a handsome reward for its solution. It required a quite considerable leap of faith to believe that Kaspar Hauser was the first-born son of the grand duke of Baden and from the very beginning the theory was fiercely attacked by those who argued that he was simply an impostor who was leading a comfortable life at the expense of the taxpayers of Nuremberg. Many resented his fame, found his character unattractive, commented bitterly on his arrogance, his mendacity and his absurd pretensions to gentility. It was grotesque to people of a conservative bent that this somewhat ridiculous figure should be the darling of assorted radicals, devotees of alternative medicine and practitioners of experimental pedagogy. The ‘anti-Hauserianers’ saw the whole fuss as further evidence of the absurdity of radical pretensions and as an underhand attack on the established order. Then as now investigative journalists had their political agendas, the sensationalist press concocted fabulous tales to increase circulation, and the public eagerly consumed the latest startling revelation. Kaspar Hauser became a media celebrity. It was thus hardly surprising that Kaspar Hauser excited the interest of an eccentric British peer, Lord Stanhope, who had been educated in Germany, had a wide network of influential friends and acquaintances in Germany and whose Germanophile excesses caused no little comment at home. He first met Kaspar Hauser in Nuremberg in May 1831. He appeared to be entranced by the boy and believed that he must indeed be of high birth. He announced that he wanted to make him his ward, showered him with all manner of extravagant gifts and much to the relief of the authorities undertook to pay his expenses. Stanhope’s abortive efforts to solve the mystery of Kaspar’s birth left him angry and frustrated. He soon tired of Kaspar’s affection, and what had appeared
Introduction
xiii
to him initially as innocent and charming he found tiresome and irritating. His passionate affection soon turned into a positive dislike and he changed sides to become a leader of the anti-Hauserianers. Stanhope’s motives for becoming involved in the affair are mysterious. Various suggestions have been put forward. Was he merely intrigued by the case, seeing in Kaspar Hauser an entertaining curiosity and a mystery to solve? Was he acting as a political agent for some of the German courts and possibly for the British government? Did he hope to find further fame and fortune by restoring Kaspar Hauser to his rights? Was this merely a transitory homosexual infatuation? Added to the mystery of Kaspar’s past and the question of whether he had been the victim of a monstrous crime was the question of the attempt made on his life and his eventual murder. In October 1829 he received a severe gash on the forehead and claimed that he had been attacked by a mysterious man in black. Since no one had seen a stranger who matched this description some suggested that the wound had been self-inflicted. In December 1833 he died as the result of a knife wound which punctured his heart, liver and stomach. Once again the experts differed as to whether this was murder or a suicide. The circumstances of Kaspar Hauser’s death provided further material for both his supporters and his detractors. His supporters saw this as clear indication that he must indeed be the legitimate grand duke of Baden, for why should such an elaborate plot be hatched to dispatch a nonentity? His detractors argued that this was yet another attentionseeking device to win back Stanhope’s affection. From the ranks of the proponents of the crown prince theory came some staggering theories about the identity of his murderers. Strands of circumstantial evidence were woven together with imaginative abandon to show that the grand ducal house of Baden, the Zähringer, was deeply implicated in the murder. These suspicions were confirmed when most of the relevant papers in the possession of the family were destroyed and researchers were denied access to what remained. The themes of a lost childhood, an imprisoned prince, a mysterious stranger, the outsider and the simple fool provided ample material for artists and a remarkable body of literature was inspired by the tale of Kaspar Hauser. The protagonist in this remarkable story remains to this day a shadowy figure. He was a simple-minded youth who provoked both genuine affection and intense dislike. To some he appeared to be pure and innocent, to others mean-spirited, ludicrously vain and incapable of telling the truth. That he should excite such widely different emotions was due
xiv
Kaspar Hauser
to the fact that he was the screen upon which so many different people projected their fantasies and beliefs. Here was living proof that man was inherently good – or the exact opposite. Kaspar Hauser showed that an innocent child was spoilt by a corrupting society, or was evidence that bad character was inherent and not learned. He was a crown prince robbed of his rights or a contemptible swindler. Was he the victim of a vicious crime, or did he inadvertently kill himself in an attempt to draw attention to his distress? Did he provide evidence for the power of homoeopathic remedies, or was he simply an epileptic given to convulsions? These and many other questions plagued contemporaries and the answers they provided give us many clues to the mentality of his times. In a sense therefore Kaspar Hauser only really existed in the minds of those who projected their fantasies upon him. Of unknown origin, rumoured to be of noble birth, a simple soul who reflected mankind in a state of nature, here was a figure whom imaginative souls could easily mythologize. Much of the fascination of the Kaspar Hauser story was that it so easily fitted into a long tradition of foundling stories. He seemed to many to be in the line of succession to Moses, Joseph, Oedipus, Romulus and Remus, Gilgamesh, Siegfried and Parsifal. Some, such as Rudolf Steiner, were so carried away by such far-fetched analogies that they came to believe that Kaspar Hauser had some divine mission. Freudians were later eager to quote the master’s essay of 1909 ‘The Neurotic’s Family Novel’ to argue that the fascination of the case was due to the typical childhood fantasy that one is merely the adopted child of one’s parents and that one’s true parents are of exalted station. Adults suppress these fantasies which are then awakened when confronted with figures such as this mysterious foundling. Contemporaries were fed with a rich diet of Gothic tales in which cellars and oubliettes, seemingly motiveless murders, anonymous letters, and vicious stepmothers played prominent roles. Germans eagerly consumed the novels of Ann Radcliffe and Horace Walpole and their German epigones, along with rich doses of trivial literature, and were thus well prepared to embroider the Kaspar Hauser story with all manner of exotic and horrific speculation. Kaspar Hauser emerged from the obscurity of his mysterious past in the heyday of Metternichian reaction between the fall of Napoleon and the revolutions of 1848. The intellectual life of Germany was stifled by censorship, exile and emigration. The police rooted out revolutionaries and informants kept a close watch on subversives. The story of Kaspar Hauser, with the suggestion that he might be the heir to the grand duchy of Baden provided an ideal opportunity to attack the princes and
Introduction
xv
to give vent to a widespread dissatisfaction with the existing order. Once the story became politicized it mattered little whether it was true or false. This was not lost on the authorities and their efforts to silence those who used the affair for political ends merely served to convince the opposition that they had a great deal to hide. The ground was thus well prepared for Kaspar Hauser’s arrival in Nuremberg. The story of a child held prisoner for years on end and who was possibly of noble birth fascinated those who had been nourished on myth and the Gothic romance. In the stifling atmosphere of the Germany of the Karlsbad decrees the opposition seized this opportunity to attack the established order and the repercussions were considerable. Others had a more limited agenda in welcoming the opportunity to study a wild child and test their theories whether medical or educational. His story also served to open an important debate on the appropriate legal response to child abuse. That the story is of lasting interest can be seen in the stream of literary works that it has inspired. However enlightened we may feel ourselves to be today the mythical still has a strong hold upon us. We are still fascinated by violence, corruption and intrigue in high places. Addiction to conspiracy theories is as powerful as ever and the pushers, whether among the media or the politicians, are busy at work. Alternative medicine, experimental pedagogy and an obsession with the esoteric all have their place in the New Age. For those who are above all this there is the greatest attraction of the story of Kaspar Hauser. It is a rattling good yarn.
1 Feral Man
The myth of feral man is as old as myth itself. Cronus the Titan, having castrated his father Uranus and seized power over the gods, married his sister Rhea. Mother Earth and the dying Uranus prophesied that Cronus would be dethroned by one of his sons. He therefore swallowed the children which Rhea bore him every year – Hestia, Demeter, Hera, Hades and Poseidon. Rhea was determined to save a son and thus gave birth to Zeus in the middle of the night on remote Mount Lycaeum in Arcadia. She gave the newborn child to Mother Earth who entrusted it to the care of the goat nymph Amaltheia whose milk he drank alongside his foster-brother Pan. When Zeus became Lord of the Universe he paid homage to Amaltheia by setting her image among the stars as Capricorn. Tyro, having been ravished by Poseidon who disguised himself as the river-god with whom she was infatuated, bore twins. Frightened of the reaction of her wicked stepmother Sidero she left the twins on a mountainside. They were discovered by a horse-herd who took them home with him. One twin – Pelias – was raised by a brood mare, the other – Neleus – by a fierce bitch. Tyro later married her uncle who then adopted the twins. Feral man is as old as recorded history. He appears in the pages of Herodotus. Rome, we are told, was founded by the twins Romulus and Remus who were suckled by a she-wolf and, in a poetic symmetry, the last Roman surviving the pillaging Goths is said to have been saved by a kindly animal who offered him a nourishing teat. There were many reports during the Middle Ages of abandoned children who spent years in isolation, or who were nourished by wild beasts, but it was not until the eighteenth century that scientists and philosophers, particularly in France, who were fascinated by the question of the nature of man began to examine seriously the case histories of 1
2
Kaspar Hauser
those who had been denied a normal childhood in human society. The philosopher Condillac and the naturalist Buffon were both fascinated by enfants sauvages which they imagined could tell us something of the true nature of mankind. Condillac was particularly intrigued by the bear-child of Lithuania, discovered in 1694, whose story provided evidence for his conceptual model of man as a statue endowed with senses by which he hoped to illuminate the origins of his sensorial nature. Christian Wolff also used the same example in his immensely tedious but influential efforts to explain the relationship between concepts and language.1 In an earlier work the great legal theorist Baron Samuel von Pufendorf had argued that a child would have to fall to earth from the heavens for a true understanding of the fundamental nature of man. 2 Pufendorf’s disciple Heinrich Conrad Koenig argued that the feral men such as Peter of Hamlin and Anna Gennärt were concrete examples of the Fictio Pufendorfiana.3 It is thus hardly surprising that August Rauber in his work on feral man of 1885 should remark that had not such children existed they would have had to have been invented. 4 Rousseau in his ‘Essay on the Origin of Inequality’ of 1754 describes five such cases. The earliest was that of the wolf-child of Hessen, a boy of about 7 who was discovered in 1344. The bear-child of Lithuania was found in 1661 at the age of about 12, and the second Lithuanian bear-child of 1694 was about 10 years old. Two further wild children were found in the Pyrenees in 1719 and the famous Peter, the wild boy of Hanover, who provided entertainment for the court in London, was discovered in 1724. Rousseau reported that all these wild children walked on all fours and showed no signs of the ability to reason. Believing that the ‘noble savage’ was an intelligent biped he insisted that feral men owed their unfortunate characteristics to the imitation of the animals among which they had been obliged to live. Persian myths tell of children fed by bears. Japanese sagas accord this Samaritan role to monkeys. The abandoned child, surviving in the wild, often tended by a wild animal, has been an enduring literary device. In our own day the stories of Mowgli and Tarzan still have their fascination. This was but one phase in the long debate which dates back to Aristotle about whether the upright stance was an essential criterion of humanity. There is no valid reason to suppose that man was intended to walk on all fours. The head and the spine are designed for an upright stance. Mankind is not adorned with a tail. A woman’s breasts are inappropriately placed for a four-legged creature. The legs are wrongly designed and are far too long for anything other than an upright stance. Although some observers claimed that all feral men walked on
Feral Man
3
all fours, the wild boy of Aveyron walked upright and did not have any callouses on his knees. But none of this answers the questions as to whether orang-outangs are human because they walk upright, or feral men beasts because they walk on all fours. Columbus’ Caribs were not accepted as human beings until they were decreed so in a papal bull of 1537. Linné made a clear distinction between homo sapiens and homo ferus. Four years after Rousseau’s prize essay the great Swedish botanist, Carl Linné, published the tenth edition of his Systema naturae, in which he introduced seven further examples of feral man. Three more were added in the thirteenth edition of 1788. Johann Christian Daniel von Schreber’s ‘Mammals Drawn From Nature With Descriptions’ of 1775 and Michael Wagner’s ‘Contributions to a Philosophical Anthropology and Related Sciences’ mentioned some further cases. 5 Herder, who insisted that the ability to speak was an essential human characteristic, for without language there could be no thought, cited Schreber’s examples of feral man in his ‘Ideas on the Philosophy of Human History’. Claude Lévi-Strauss echoed Herder when he wrote, ‘he who speaks of man speaks of language; he who speaks of language speaks of society’. 6 By the time Kaspar Hauser appeared in Nuremberg in 1828 there were 16 recorded cases of feral men in Europe, by far the most famous and best recorded being that of Victor, the wild boy of Aveyron.7 The earliest case is that of the wild boy of Hessen of 1344. The great Dutch anatomist Nicolas Tulp, whom Rembrandt used as a model for his Anatomy Lesson, was delighted to be able to examine the Irish sheepchild ( juvenis ovinus hibernus) who was captured in 1672 and brought over to Holland. The calf-child of Bamberg (juvenis bovinus bambergensis), described by Linné, could fight large dogs with his bare teeth and it is reported that his intelligence showed some signs of improvement since he entered human society in 1680. The second bear-child of Lithuania, discovered in 1694, was able to learn to walk upright and to speak. The girl from Kranenburg in Holland ( puella transislana), who was given the name Anna Maria Gennärt, was about 19 years old when she was captured in 1717. She was never able to speak, but learnt to spin wool, a trade which she practised until her death. It was said that a business man from Amsterdam had got a woman pregnant whereupon he had sent her away. The child died in early infancy. On his deathbed the businessman ask to see his child. Hoping that he would leave her some money his spurned mistress stole a 16-month-old baby and went to see her repentant lover. Having inherited some money the woman left the child in the woods where she lived for many years until she was captured by the local peasants. At that time she was about 18 years old. 8
4
Kaspar Hauser
Peter, the wild boy of Hanover, is the subject of more detailed reports and is mentioned by both Rousseau and Linné. He had been abandoned by his father, but managed to find his way back home after one year in the wilds. He was savagely beaten by his stepmother who chased him away for good. Having managed to avoid numerous attempts to capture him he was finally seized at the age of about 13 in 1724. At first he was placed in the charge of the poorhouse in Hamlin. Then he lodged with a burgher in the vain hope that he would learn a useful trade. The religious leader Count Nicolaus Ludwig von Zinzendorf und Pottendorf asked whether he could have the boy so that he could make some experiments with him. He was told that the king had placed him in the care of a philosopher who wished to do some research in innate ideas. 9 He was thus taken to the court of George I in London. For some time he was in the care of Queen Anne’s physician, the renowned wit Dr John Arbuthnot, whose friend Jonathan Swift wrote a satirical piece on the wonderful Wild Man that was nursed in the woods of Germany by a wild beast, hunted and taken in toyls; how he behaveth himself like a dumb creature, and is a Christian like one of us, being called Peter; how he was brought to court all in green, to the great astonishment of the quality and gentry. 10 Swift wrote: I am told, that the new sect of herb-eaters intend to follow him into the fields, or to beg him for a clerk in their kitchen; and that there are many of them now thinking of turning their children into woods to graze with cattle, in hopes to raise a healthy and moral race, refined from the corruptions of this luxurious world. Peter lived in society for 18 years, but was never able to speak. He showed some appreciation of music and gradually got used to wearing normal clothes. The Scottish anthropologist Lord Monboddo was fascinated by this case and wondered whether Peter had any sense of ‘the great Author’ of the wonders of nature that so obviously fascinated him. He was told that he had no consciousness of the existence of God. 11 Peter provided clear evidence for Monboddo that the ‘state of nature is not an imaginary state . . . but a real state, upon which we may safely found our philosophy of man’. Other observers were less enthusiastic and said that Peter, far from being an example of man in a state of nature, was simply an idiot.12
Feral Man
5
The wild girl of Sogny in the Champagne was captured in 1731 when she was about 10 years old. 13 She lived on a diet of small birds, frogs and fish and particularly relished rabbit’s blood. She claimed to have lived with another human whom she had killed by accident. She was looked after by nuns in Châlons-sur-Marne who taught her to speak. She was taken to live with a religious order in Paris where she was visited by the Duke of Orleans. Her ambition was to become a nun, but ill-health prevented her from taking the veil. In 1756 Dr Milsintown found a wild child of about 12 on the Scottish island of Barra and undertook the awesome task of making him into a human being and a Christian. The good doctor had little success with either endeavour. The sickly child who had a cleft palate, upon which Milsintown performed a singularly clumsy and painful operation, soon died. Shortly before his death he was baptized and given the name Edward.14 Jean of Liège, who was estimated to be 21 years old when he was captured, was a strict vegetarian. It was assumed that he had spent about 16 years in the wild and, like Peter, he was never able to speak. In 1767 two further wild children were discovered in Hungary. Tomko managed to learn Slovak and to understand some German. His health was poor and he appeared to have no sexual drive. The Bear-Child, discovered in the same year, was kept in a hospital in Karpfen. The most famous of all the wild children, and the one about whom the most has been written, is Victor, the wild boy of Aveyron. 15 He was first spotted in 1797 playing stark naked in a wood in the Tarn. He was captured, but escaped after 15 months. He was caught once again by some hunters in the summer of 1798 and was placed in the care of a widow. Again he escaped and spent part of the winter in the woods. On 19 nivôse of the year VIII (9 January 1800) he was spotted in the garden of a dyer by the name of Vidal who lived at Saint-Sernin-sur-Rance in Aveyron. The following day he was brought to an asylum in SaintAffrique and on 4 February he was taken to Rodez. Here the naturalist Abbé Bonnaterre made a preliminary examination of the boy. 16 Bonnaterre had worked in Paris on the Encylopédie méthodique, was pursued by the Committee of Public Safety, and forced into hiding. On the creation of the central schools he was appointed professor in Rodez in 1796. Bonnaterre was particularly interested in the phenomenon of wild children and had studied the scanty literature on the subject. Like most contemporary philosophers he believed that society was ontogenetic and that ‘the greatest source of ideas among men is their human interactions’.17 He made a meticulous preliminary study of the child. News
6
Kaspar Hauser
of the discovery excited the scientific world and Victor was taken to Paris to be examined by the most illustrious psychologist of the time, Philippe Pinel, the head of the Bicêtre. Pinel, who is often regarded as the father of psychiatry since he was the first person to write a textbook on the subject, introduced a number of reforms in the asylum, put a stop to the more brutal practices of the time, and insisted on a more humane treatment of the mentally ill. He classified mental illness in four categories: mania, melancholia, dementia and idiocy. In his classic text on mental illness he classified idiots as ‘destitute of speech and confined to the utterance of some inarticulate sounds. Their looks are without animation, their senses stupefied, and their movements heavy and mechanical.’18 Pinel decided that Victor was an idiot because he showed characteristics identical to those of his idiot patients in the Bicêtre. Many philosophers have argued that speech is essential for humanity. Julien Offray de La Mettrie as a thorough-going materialist, once reviled as an atheist and now regarded as one of the founding fathers of modern psychology, rejected Descartes’ notion of innate ideas. He insisted that ideas could not exist without speech, and since wild children had no speech they could not have any ideas, innate or otherwise. Thus a wild child could not of his own discover God, since Descartes’ belief that all humans had an innate notion of God was a fallacy. For la Mettrie ‘tous nos idées viennent des sens’, an idea which he acknowledged as a ‘belle conjecture’ which came from Arnobius the Elder who, in the fourth century, had argued that if a child were raised in total isolation on a simple diet he would emerge after 20 or more years ‘as baffled and mindless as an animal, a piece of wood or a stone’. 19 This was an idea which particularly appealed to Feuerbach when he first met Kaspar Hauser. Jean-Marc-Gaspard Itard, the resident physician in the Institution for the Deaf and Dumb in the rue Saint-Jacques, violently disagreed with his distinguished colleague at the Bicêtre. Itard was profoundly influenced by the philosophy of Locke and Condillac and believed that a human being was a social construct. He argued that Victor’s idiocy, which he could hardly deny, was due not to any inherent genetic failure, but simply to the fact that he had been excluded from human society at a vital stage in his development. His idiocy was thus due not to nature, but to the lack of nurture. In his first report of 1801 Itard said that the wild boy no longer wet his bed, could dress himself, and had learnt some elements of table manners; his sentiments and affections showed signs of growth, but he still had little intellectual curiosity. He painfully learnt to say all
Feral Man
7
the vowels, except the ‘u’, and three consonants. Thus he could say the word lait, but that was the extent of his verbal ability. In the six intervening years before the next report Victor made some further progress. He showed signs of emotional development, his senses were more acute and he was able to perform simple tasks. Although he remained virtually mute he was able to read and write a number of words and thus indicate his wishes and concerns. Victor was evicted from the Institute in 1811, was given a small state pension, and lived with a caretaker, Madame Guérin, in the Impasse des Feuillantines. He died in 1828, aged about 40, the year that Kaspar Hauser arrived in Nuremberg. He was almost forgotten and was no longer the talk of Paris as when he had dined with Madame Récamier, whom he delighted by stripping off his clothes and climbing a tree in the best enfant sauvage manner. He met the Marquis de Sade, and it was widely rumoured that he was none other than Louis XVII. Itard died in 1837. He had a distinguished career, acknowledged by the medal of the Legion of Honour and his election to the Academy of Medicine, but he never bothered to visit Victor after he left the Institute. Itard’s eulogist, Dr Bosquet, remained convinced that Victor was a cretin and that Itard’s failure to make significant progress with him was due to this simple fact. 20 Jean-Etienne-Dominique Esquirol, whose father had worked with Itard many years before, was convinced that Victor was an idiot who had been abandoned by his parents.21 Pinel agreed. Itard thought the exact opposite: Victor was an idiot because he had been abandoned in the woods. Other experts who shared Pinel’s opinion felt that although Itard was a psychiatrist and educator of genius his efforts were largely wasted on the wild boy of Aveyron. Itard suffered greatly from such criticism and continued to insist that there was nothing congenitally wrong with Victor and that his idiocy was due to his years of isolation. He argued that Victor had made enormous progress under his supervision and that this poor savage should not be compared with children who had enjoyed a normal upbringing in ‘the most civilised country in Europe’. The most spectacular modern case of feral children was that of Amala and Kamala who were discovered near Midnapur, some 120 miles west of Calcutta, in October 1920, by the Reverend J. A. L. Singh. 22 The two girls, aged about 18 months and 8 years had been nurtured by a shewolf. They were taken by Singh to an orphanage in the vain hope that they might be saved for ‘humanity and Christianity’. The younger child died a year later, the older lived for a further eight years. Singh’s diary of the case was published in the United States in 1942 in a book
8
Kaspar Hauser
co-authored by R. M. Zingg, Professor of Psychology at the university of Denver and an expert on feral children.23 Even though Singh’s account had been authenticated by Arnold Gesell, a professor of paediatrics at Yale, it was not long before its veracity was under fierce attack. The English-born American anthropologist Ashley Montagu, the most outspoken opponent of the view that cultural phenomena are genetically determined, announced that however attractive such stories of children reared by wolves might be they could not be accepted by any serious scientist.24 An American sociologist who cooperated with Gandhi’s one-time secretary Nirmal K. Bose cast further doubt on Singh’s account of the case. They were unable to find Godamuri, the village near which he had claimed to have found the children. Nor could they find anyone who could corroborate his tale. They concluded that Singh had made up the story as a publicity stunt, possibly in the hope of making some money. 25 Singh found a supporter in the little-known British novelist Charles Maclean who travelled to India in 1977. He claimed that Godamuri had been renamed Ghorabanda and that the older villagers in the region vividly remembered the capture of the wolf children. Too much credence should not be given to this account, for there are countless stories of feral children in India, dating from 1858 when William Henry Sleeman reported the appearance of such children in Husanpur, Sultanpur, Chupra, Lucknow and Banikpur. 26 Rudyard Kipling’s father collected stories of feral children and doubtless inspired his son to write the story of Mowgli in The Jungle Book and The Second Jungle Book.27 A number of cases of feral children in India was reported in the twentieth century, the last being Ramu who was found near New Delhi in 1954. Many of the things about feral man that fascinated eighteenth- and nineteenth-century intellectuals are no longer of pressing interest. We are hardly concerned about the precise nature of our distinct species of homo sapiens, the broader questions having been answered by Darwin. Our attention is directed to the even more sensitive questions of the differences between the races and between males and females. Similarly the issue of innate ideas is hardly central to the philosophical debate, although Noam Chomsky’s postulate of an innate grammar has done something to revive the question. Figures such as Kaspar Hauser continue to fascinate hermeneutists and linguists. A speechless foundling in possession of an authorless letter is a challenge to both disciplines. Friedrich Daniel Ernst Schleiermacher clearly enunciated the hermeneutic programme when he said that it was his aim ‘to understand speech as well and even better than the speaker’.28 From this starting point it is
Feral Man
9
argued that the truth about Kaspar Hauser is to be found in the text and not in what lies behind it, since speech does not have the ability to represent. From the moment of his arrival in Nuremberg Kaspar Hauser became the point at which various discourses crossed.29 From this point of view there is little more to him than a discursive meeting place. For most people he remains a mystery, a symbol of a world that cannot be understood. To the hermeneutist, however, he is an allegory for the relationship between speech and the world. Kaspar Hauser shows that language does not depict the world and his linguistic efforts are seen as an exemplification of a romantic longing for a state in which there is no distinction between being and meaning. It is a melancholy longing for it can never be achieved.30 Psychoanalysts are also intrigued by the story of Kaspar Hauser. Freud’s famous study of paranoia published in 1911 was based on Daniel Paul Schreber’s Memoirs of a Neuropath, in which he used the phrase ‘soul murder’, a notion which he had picked up from Feuerbach’s book on Kaspar Hauser. ‘Soul murder’, which Feuerbach defined as ‘the criminal invasion of man’s most sacred and unique property – the freedom and destiny of his soul’, became part of Freud’s vocabulary and was used by Jung, Abraham and Ferenczi.31 Schreber was a distinguished jurist, the presiding judge in a division of the appeal court in Saxony, who suffered from dreadful paranoid delusions and wrote a harrowing account of the torments they caused. 32 In 1909 Freud published an essay in which he pointed out that it was a typical childhood fantasy to believe that one was a bastard or a changeling, and that one was not the child of one’s official parents. Naturally one assumes oneself to be of more distinguished birth than one is in fact, usually imagining oneself to be the offspring of a landowning aristocrat.33 In the first (non-sexual phase) of this questioning of parental authority the child fantasizes that he is a foundling. In the second (sexual) phase only the role of the father is placed in question, and the child believes himself to be a bastard child of some distinguished person. In the inflated language of psychoanalysis this rests on an infantile conflict between a narcissistic inflation of the ego and a grossly exaggerated father image. Such fantasies feed on the fact that pater semper incertus est whereas the mother is certissima.34 Freudians thus believe that this widespread fantasy lies at the root of the fascination of the story of Kaspar Hauser as a child whose origins were wrapped in mystery. It is also used to explain Kaspar Hauser’s often arrogant behaviour and his brief but intense relationship with Lord Stanhope.
10
Kaspar Hauser
Alexander Mitscherlich even goes so far as to suggest that a Kaspar Hauser complex, rather than an Oedipus complex, should be seen as the fundamental causes of neuroses in today’s world which he described as a ‘fatherless society’.35 Children grow up denied the affection and comfort provided by their parents and fellow man. They are alone, virtually without a culture, developing within an asocial environment. The individual is merely a creature driven by the compulsions of the moment. From birth he suffers from impoverished relations with his cultural environment. The modern masses are thus open to seduction, anger, disloyalty and fear. The Oedipus complex, according to Freud, works itself out in normal relations between individuals, does not necessarily hinder a person’s healthy development, and is an essential component of our civilization. The Kaspar Hauser complex, based on a lack of love and affection, is a far more serious matter, for it cannot be overcome. A more contemporary case provides evidence for Mitscherlich’s theory. In 1970 a girl came to the attention of the Los Angeles County welfare office. She came with her aged grandmother and her virtually blind mother who was searching for the services for the blind, having left her brutal husband. The worker on duty was shocked by the little girl’s appearance. She was barely able to walk, and seemed to want to correct her bent-over stance by holding her hands out in front of her as if grasping an imaginary railing for support. The eligibility worker assumed that the child was autistic and estimated that she was about six years old. Her supervisor did not agree with this diagnosis, but could not fail to notice that something was seriously amiss. It was soon revealed that the child was a teenager, although she only weighed 49 pounds and was a mere 44 inches tall. She understood a few simple words, but was only able to say ‘stop it’ and ‘no more’ plus a couple of other negatives. She was incontinent, could not focus her eyes beyond 12 feet, was unable to chew food, had difficulty in swallowing, and had no perception of heat and cold. Further investigation revealed that she had been imprisoned from the age of two in a room measuring 10 by 14 feet, and had been tied down naked to a potty seat for hours at a time. She was beaten if she made the slightest noise. Like Kaspar Hauser, whose fate was similar, she was much liked by those who took care of her. She was sweetly innocent and responded to the care and affection that was lavished on her. The hospital workers named her ‘Genie’.36 This sensational story was reported in the local press, but was somewhat overshadowed by the Charles Manson trial, the bombing of Hanoi,
Feral Man
11
and the controversial policies of Governor Ronald Reagan. The parents’ arrest and the father’s suicide were reported on national news and Genie became something of a celebrity. Her arrival at Los Angeles’ exclusive Children’s Hospital happened at a time when linguistics and the question of language acquisition was the subject of intense academic debate. Noam Chomsky’s ideas about an inborn generative grammar were at the height of fashion. B. F. Skinner’s theory that ‘verbal behaviour’ was entirely learned had many supporters, and Eric H. Lenneberg’s theory of brain growth, which postulated that it was virtually impossible to acquire a first language after the age of 12 or 13, were hotly debated. The debate over the acquisition of language is long-standing and fraught with difficulties. Is it a purely biological function like sight or hearing as Epicurus argued, or is it a gift of God as Leibnitz insisted – although he made an exception for Chinese, a language which God in his infinite goodness could not possibly have imagined, and which was thus clearly the invention of some ingenious Asiatics. Herodotus tells us that in the late seventh century BC the Egyptian King Psamtik I of Egypt, a ruler with burning imperial ambitions, sought to discover the universal language which would hold his kingdom together. He ordered two infants to be taken from their mothers to be raised in an isolated shepherd’s hut. The shepherd was told not to speak to the children and to note their first words. Two years later one of them uttered a sound that resembled the word bekos, the word for bread in the Phrygian language. Whereupon the king announced that Phrygian was the original language on which all others were based.37 King Psamtik has been accused of a pitiful lack of methodological rigour and historians, although prepared to accept that the flute and the Dionysian orgy may well have originated in Phrygia, are dubious that the language, of which precious few traces remain, was the first that crossed human lips. Father Salimbene of Parma tells us that Frederick II of Hohenstaufen conducted a similar experiment to discover mankind’s original language. He was a truly remarkable ruler who had absorbed the cultures of Europe and the Orient, a patron of the arts and sciences, the author of a treatise De arte venandi cum avibus (The Art of Hunting with Birds) which was the definitive work on ornithology for several centuries. His tolerance towards Moslems was such that many Christians feared that he might convert to Islam. Others thought he was an atheist who believed in nothing at all. But he was brutally harsh in the pursuit of heretics and discriminated against the Jews, forcing them to wear special clothing. He was a man of immense culture and learning, but was also a suspicious and mean-spirited despot. The stupor mundi ordered
12
Kaspar Hauser
a number of children to be brought up in silent isolation. Alas, these harsh experiments brought no results. The good priest reports that these efforts were in vain. All the children died.38 In 1807 G. F. A. Wendeborn complained that it was a ‘misunderstanding of humaneness’ not to conduct experiments on a dozen children of both sexes who would be raised in complete isolation so as to unlock the secrets of human nature. 39 For many linguists Chomsky’s Syntactic Structures, published in 1957, provided the answer to these perplexing problems that had troubled inquisitive minds for so many centuries. By concentrating on syntax rather than vocabulary, Chomsky sought to show that all languages are essentially identical. This similarity is based on an innate structure of which language is an expression. The fact that by the age of four a child can produce and understand a large number of sentences which are new to them is indication that they can rearrange familiar words in new ways according to rules of which they are not aware. Thus the structure and design of language is in the genes. A particular language is the result of the interaction between this ‘universal grammar’ and the specific linguistic data to which the individual is exposed. Chomsky claimed that prelinguistic children on a desert island would most likely invent their own language and that this language would obey the same syntactical rules. He thus came to much the same conclusion as Montaigne who claimed in 1580 that a child brought up in solitude would develop some kind of language. Subsequent thinkers worried about what kind of language that would be. Would it be the language of the soul, or the language of the intellect? Did thought generate language and language society, or could it be the other way round? The environmentalists, recovering after Chomsky’s shattering review of Skinner’s Verbal Behaviour in the review Language in 1959, argued that there was no evidence for a language gene, that learning a language was a long and difficult process, and that the innatist argument was little more than a metaphor. As a prominent psycholinguist, George Miller remarked: ‘The trouble with language acquisition is that the nativists have proved that it’s a mystery and the environmentalists have proved that it’s impossible.’ It was the old debate between Condillac and Descartes. Victor appeared on the scene when Condillac’s ideas were in vogue, Genie when Chomsky’s transformational grammar was all the rage. Genie was fascinating both to linguists and to psychologists interested in the effects of sensory and social deprivation. But there were serious problems. The whole case was compromised by what one consultant, Jay Shurley, described as the ‘glitz factor’. Genie was a celebrity and there was fierce competition among the 20 psychologists and
Feral Man
13
neurologists concerned with the case as they sought the maximum of publicity and professional glory. There was also the problem that the team needed funding from the National Institute for Mental Health (NIMH) and thus the scientific value of the case was to some more important than the interests of the patient. Seven months after Genie arrived at Children’s Hospital she contracted rubella and was boarded with her teacher, Jean Butler, with whom she was particularly close. She was a single woman with private means, fiercely protective of her pupil, determined to keep the inquisitive scientists at bay. She applied to the Department of Public Social Services (DPSS) to adopt the child. When they argued that Genie needed a stepfather, Jean Butler asked her lover, a psychologist at the University of Southern California, to act in this capacity. He consented. Under Butler’s care Genie improved greatly. Her bed-wetting was less frequent, she masturbated less often, her speech improved somewhat, and she appeared to be a happier and more contented child. Nevertheless the DPSS turned down the application for adoption and Genie was returned to the Rehabilitation Centre. Genie was now placed in the care of David and Marilyn Rigler. David Rigler was the head of the Genie research project funded by NIMH, his wife Marilyn was a graduate student in human development. They lived with their three adolescent children, a golden retriever puppy and a cat in a comfortable home in an exclusive area of Los Angeles. They were handsomely rewarded by grant money for their efforts. After a promising start Genie’s language ability hardly improved, even though in other respects she was progressing remarkably well, and there was no evidence that she was mentally defective. The vast amount of data collected by researchers all over the country had produced precious little of value. NIMH was reluctant to renew the grant and the Riglers were under constant attack from Jean Butler who blamed Genie’s lack of progress and even regression on their failure as guardians. She had now married her lover, lived in great style, and collected some six thousand pages of documents to bolster her case against the Riglers. In spite of all her efforts her attempt to become Genie’s foster parent failed and Genie was returned to the Rehabilitation Centre. She then lived with the Riglers for four years in their home in an exclusive district of Los Angeles. She was then returned to her mother, who was unable to cope, and Genie passed from one foster home to another. Jay Shurley, Professor of Psychology at the University of Oklahoma and a specialist on cases of extreme isolation, who worked with Genie, made some prescient comments on the case which are directly relevant
14
Kaspar Hauser
to Kaspar Hauser. He pointed out that she was suddenly removed from an unfriendly but consistent environment to one that was overpowering. She went from a famine to a feast, and was unable to adjust to a frantic new world. Furthermore she was used by the scientists who found her case fascinating but had little concern for her real needs. She was exploited in both her worlds just as Victor and Kaspar had been before her. After some severe initial problems of adjustment Genie continued to make progress to the point that at a meeting of the American Psychological Association in Honolulu in September 1972 Victoria Fromkin, a distinguished linguist and member of the Genie team, reported to her colleagues that Genie’s linguistic ability disproved Eric Lenneberg’s then fashionable theory that language acquisition was virtually impossible after the age of five. Lenneberg and Chomsky had both been invited to join the Genie team, but had refused on the grounds that she was too emotionally disturbed for there to be any valuable scientific results in the field of language acquisition – a view which Professor Fromkin rejected out of hand. It soon became apparent that Professor Fromkin had been too optimistic in her assessment as Genie’s linguistic abilities improved only minimally. Genie’s inability to master syntax seemed to support Lenneberg’s theories, but were a problem for the Chomskians. If part of language was innate why was it that it was precisely this part which Genie lacked? Experiments on the receptivity of her left and right brain suggested an answer. Genie’s brain processed language in the right hemisphere rather than the left. Susan Curtiss suggested that Genie’s left hemisphere had not been stimulated in early childhood so that she perceived language as an environmental sound and thus appropriately processed it across the aisle. 40 Research on deaf children suggests that this is indeed the case. If they are not exposed to sign language at an early age they do not process language in the left hemisphere. The facts of Genie’s tragic life are fully known, but most wild children became the subject of much speculation. Why had they been left alone to fend for themselves? Who were their parents? Were they insane, or were they merely lacking in education? None of the wild children was the object of more speculation than Kaspar Hauser. In large part this was because he, like Genie, was not a truly wild child. Unlike any of the others he learnt to speak, to read and to write. Although retarded in his development, he would have been able to hold down a modest job. He shared with all the wild children an air of mystery – indeed the words ‘mystery’ and ‘puzzle’ are the characteristic words in many of the hundreds of pamphlets, articles and books written during his lifetime
Feral Man
15
and subsequent to his death. The mystery surrounding him could lead some imaginative spirits to believe that he was symbolic of certain aspects of human existence, or even that he had some divine mission. Those of a less mystical cast of mind were convinced that he was of noble, or even royal blood, and eagerly espoused the notion that he was the heir to the Grand Duchy of Baden – a belief that greatly appealed to the radical critics of the corruption of the petty German states. Many would have none of this and proclaimed him to be a swindler enjoying a comfortable life at the taxpayers’ expense and wallowing in the admiring curiosity of the highly born, the rich and the fashionable. Satirical journals frequently stooped to dubious levels in poking fun at the case. Der Komet recommended a number of books on the subject. Among them were: Caspar Hauser, The Unnatural Fruit Of Intercourse Between A Negress And A Baboon, Explained, Described And Edited With The Permission Of The Father By The Originator Of This Popular Prank – Sir Jocko The Long-Nosed Ape and A Medical-Fantastical-Political-DiplomaticCannibalistic-Bestial Experiment – Caspar Hauser Shown In The Magic Lantern of Public Opinion to Be An Impostor . . . By An Anonymous Author Who Is Well-known.41 The Kaspar Hauser of these pamphlets was certainly no ‘noble savage’, a child of nature whose innocence illuminated the falsity and depravity of contemporary civilization. By the time he appeared in Nuremberg the romantic cult of the savage, the child and the peasant was no longer fashionable. 42 Yet although actual savages, children and peasants were hardly objects of uncritical wonderment, as abstractions they provided rewarding objects for philosophical and ethnological investigation. This philosophical and ethnological approach was then applied to contemporary society as a critique of existing conditions, particularly of power relationships. It was a process that began with the French philosophes, was taken up by German philosophers such as Herder, and then pursued by Claude Lévi-Strauss in his attempt to find a universally valid methodology for the examination of cultures, and by Michel Foucault as an ‘ethnology’ of contemporary society. 43 The myth of the ‘noble savage’ dates back to Christopher Columbus whose enthusiasm for the virtues of the Arawaks knew no bounds. 44 But Columbus also provided in his description of the Caribs the archetype of the evil savage. This distinction between the noble and the evil savage is nowhere more striking than in the works of Bartolomé de las Casas and Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo y Valdés. 45 Oviedo went to San Domingo in 1514 as inspector of mines and wrote his history of the Indies on his return to Spain. He described the natives as cannibals,
16
Kaspar Hauser
sodomites, idolaters and pitiless beasts with insatiable sexual appetites. They could only be saved by the firm hand of Christian conquerors. Las Casas’ History of the Indies was a direct attack on Oviedo with whom he had clashed over the question of Indian rights. Whereas Oviedo insisted that such beasts could have no rights Las Casas argued that the Spanish behaved like ravenous beasts of prey who fed upon the Indians. He saw the Indians as a meek, patient, peaceful and virtuous people who were ruthlessly exploited by the conquistadors. Both the noble and the evil savage are projective fictions. The nobility of Las Casas’ savages is contrasted with the brutality of the Spanish. The idealized savage is representative of a condemnation of the barbarity of the civilized world. But he is also the ideal subject. He is submissive, but at the same time retains his sensuality and unrepressed sexuality. He is emotionally free, but knows his place in society. Las Casas was the first person to represent another culture as a means of criticizing European civilization. His Indians were to him what the Nambikwara were to be for Lévi-Strauss – their virtues and skills exposed the vices and vanity of European civilization. By the same token Oviedo’s evil savage justifies colonial repression and exploitation, but there is a hint of envy of his aggressiveness and unrestrained libido. Amerigo Vespucci was clearly titillated by the libidinal generosity of the Indians and somewhat coyly reported that their women treated the penises of their lovers with a balm which swelled the organ so as better to satisfy them. He was horrified at the tales of their cannibalism and claimed to have seen salted human hams hanging in their huts, but he felt that theirs was a prelapsarian society in which mankind lived in harmony with nature, naked, propertyless, uninhibited and with no gods to fear.46 To live ‘sans roi, sans loi, sans foi’ was for some commentators a vision of horror, for others pure utopia. The Franciscan monk Bernardino de Sahagún studied the Nahautl language, wrote a history of the conquest of Mexico from the native point of view, and is often considered to be the first ethnologist.47 He first wrote his history in Nahautl so that the Indians could speak for themselves. Later he translated the book into his native Spanish. His viewpoint was far removed from that of the cultural relativist, for his concern was to understand the Indians’ culture in order better to cure it of its ills and introduce these misguided people to the mysteries of the Christian faith. Sahagún respected The Other, was non-judgmental in his descriptions of Aztec religious practices, insisted that like any other culture the Nahautl had its strengths and its weaknesses, but was never in any doubt that Christianity was the only true religion and that
Feral Man
17
European culture was superior to that of the Indians. However harsh his judgment of the Spaniards’ behaviour in the New World he insisted on the fundamental superiority of Spanish culture. Spain might be a society given to indiscriminate slaughter, but it was still a bearer of Christian truths. Sahagún had a profound respect for the otherness of the Nahautl, but found it difficult to square with his belief in the universal equality of mankind. The savage endowed with considerable nobility confronted the murderous conqueror from a Christian culture. This clash of civilizations could only be overcome by the triumph of the Cross. Sahagún, like Las Casas, had made a bold step away from ethnocentrism, delivered a blistering attack on the shortcomings of his own society, but remained convinced that Christianity and European civilization offered the only true hope for universal salvation. It was Montaigne who first made the noble savage into a philosophical concept. Las Casas and Sahagún condemned the Spaniards for their barbarous behaviour towards a people which had many virtues; Montaigne claimed that the barbarity of the civilized world resulted from its separation from nature. Civilization was itself barbarous: the Spaniards were thus no special case. The Indian, living close to nature sets an example of utopian communal living. Such was his enthusiasm for the three Brazilian Indians with whom he conversed, and for the reports of various travellers, that he threw his scepticism overboard and announced that the New World had realized the utopian dreams of ancient philosophers. The Golden Age was no philosophical pipe dream, but a tangible reality. Montaigne’s Indians, like those of LéviStrauss, lived in a way which European philosophers could only imagine.48 Like any present-day cultural relativist he bemoaned the devastation of such societies by greedy, power-hungry Europeans who destroy such perfection all for the ‘traffic of pearls and pepper’. The iron age destroyed the golden age.49 Montaigne’s Indians lived in a classless society where there was no division between rich and poor. Without agriculture or industry there were no disparities of wealth. Without a written language there could be no Mandarin class. Without hierarchical kinship structures there was no familial ranking. Without trade or inheritance and lacking even the ability to count there were no classes. In this egalitarian society there was no place for lies, miserliness, envy, spite, or hatred. The country was so naturally abundant that there was no need for work and the people were seldom if ever sick. It was a society free of restraints and restrictions and thus their sexual life was uninhibited – in marked contrast to guilt-ridden Christian Europe with its taboos and restrictions.
18
Kaspar Hauser
Montaigne felt that their supposedly complete sexual freedom meant that there could be no jealousy, possessiveness or shame. Europeans like Montaigne saw in American Indians a picture of their former selves, and bemoaned the loss of their freedom and spontaneity. Montaigne was a conservative sceptic who withdrew from public life in the Bordeaux parlement at the age of 38 and retired to his country estate where he wrote his Essays. His motto, que sais-je? is indicative of his scepticism and his open-minded and undogmatic mind. He returned to public life, serving as mayor of Bordeaux while the murderous religious war still raged. He was a leading figure of the parti des politiques which called for religious toleration, but as a conservative he opposed the Reformation, for it had called the old order into question and set off a chain of events which had led to the current disaster. His scepticism and his conservatism were in accord. Truth and falsehood were for him subjective judgments the outcome of which was likely to be disastrous. Thus it was best to stay with the familiar than risk the new. In contrast his scepticism made him an outspoken critic of existing society. Thus although he roundly condemned the cannibalism of his beloved Indians, he argued that European practices such as torture, sadistic executions and the burning of witches were far worse. He believed that by painting a grim picture of the barbarities of the cannibals attention was deliberately diverted away from the cruelty and viciousness of European society. In spite of his conservatism he also knew that custom and tradition could be forms of tyranny. His projective fiction of the noble savage enabled him to live among the Tupinamba when he sat in the tower of his ancestral home and pondered the iniquities and injustices of his own times, a perfumed handkerchief to cool his brow. Here he distanced himself from the real world in melancholy isolation and found thereby the freedom for which he yearned. As a cultural pessimist he despaired of the written word, of which he was a past master, as only serving to stir up strife. Rome, he declared, was at it best when it was the least learned. Among contemporary societies the Turks were the highest in his estimation. They glorified the sword and despised the pen.50 The noble savage lived on in the imagination of philosophers and provided a convenient literary device with which to exorcize the abuses of contemporary society. Campanella’s Città del Sol, Thomas More’s Utopia and Francis Bacon’s Nova Atlantis formed the foundation of a literary genre that was to become increasingly popular. Montaigne’s noble savage, whom Columbus would have counted among the evil savages, can be found in the description of the voyage made by the Domincan
Feral Man
19
Father Du Tetre to the West Indies in 1640, and in the writings of his fellow Dominican Labat who published a book on the Caribs in 1722. Du Tetre was to have a profound influence on Rousseau who did more than any other philosopher to popularize the notion of the noble savage.51 Captain Cook, Johann Georg Forster and Louis Antoine de Bougainville brought back glowing reports of the Tahitians, conveniently overlooking the complexity of their social structure and the higher level of their civilization, and extolled the virtues of this primitive Pacific paradise. Their fictional ethnology provided a means of criticizing existing society and for the projection of dreams of personal freedom. Baron Louis-Armand de Lahontan felt that the Hurons were the truly noble savages who lived according to their three commandments of brotherly love, virtue and tranquillity. 52 Lahontan had served with the French army in Canada – his first visit to New France was in 1683 – and convinced himself that the Hurons, unlike the French, lived in harmony with nature. He argued that only a bloody revolution, carried out by means of a military coup, and the abolition of private property could save France from greed, materialism, violence and selfishness. Voltaire agreed with Lohantan that the civilized were the true barbarians, and his highly idealized noble savage – a Frenchman who had been brought up among the Hurons – commented on the evils of contemporary society from the peace and quiet of the prison library in the Bastille where he had been incarcerated thanks to the machinations of his putative father-in-law and a wicked Jesuit. 53 Voltaire’s Huron, unlike Lohantan’s, is no revolutionary. Like Montaigne in his tower, his meditations in the Bastille lead him to the conclusion that he should make his peace with the world around him, maintain an ironic and melancholy distance from it, and pursue a career. Voltaire’s hero is thus not a true noble savage. In his ignorance he merely lacks the trappings of a civilization which, for all its shortcomings and evils, is susceptible to perfection. Diderot confessed that he believed the state of nature to be a fiction but that only in Tahiti were people truly happy. In Europe only the Calabrians led a tolerable existence for they lived in a state of anarchy. His fictional character argued that anarchy caused less harm than civilized behaviour, for European civilization was based on domination and sexual repression. Calabrians sought to destroy the power structure and Tahitians lived in a free and open society with complete sexual freedom. 54 Rousseau also saw the savage as a freedom fighter against the tyranny of Western civilization. His Caribs, like Montaigne’s Tupinamba,
20
Kaspar Hauser
Diderot’s Tahitians, or Lévi-Strauss’s Nambikwara, heroically resisted attempts by colonialists to impose their way of life upon them, a way of life which they too condemned. He adopted the point of view of the Carib in order to write an ethnology of European society. He believed that despotism was inevitable and that it would in turn be overthrown. Despotism was based on power, and when that power dwindled it would finally collapse. The result would be a new state of nature with all against all. For Hobbes the state of nature was overcome by the formation of society. For Rousseau it was the consequence of social development. The Second Discourse makes it clear that he did not hanker after a long lost primitive state of nature when mankind was merely a ‘stupid and limited animal’, but looked forward to a state in which reason, an equitable distribution of property, morality and civil rights were guaranteed. Rousseau, like Montaigne before him, saw himself as a noble savage. It was not for nothing that he frequently quoted Horace: ‘I am a barbarian because they do not understand me’. 55 Along with the noble and ignoble savage there were the myths of the Wild Folk who roamed the woods and forests of Europe. To some they were dwellers of an Arcadia, delighting in the beauties of nature, leftovers from a golden age of which Gonzalo speaks in The Tempest: All things in common nature should produce Without sweat or endeavour: treason, felony, Sword, pike, knife, gun, or need of any engine, Would I not have; but nature should bring forth, Of its own kind, all foison, all abundance, To feed my innocent people. (2.i.166–71) Others feared the Wild Folk as dangerous heathens who would viciously attack unsuspecting travellers. The noble savage was not merely a convenient myth whereby contemporary society could be called into question, it was also a fictional device whereby fundamental questions about human nature could be asked. Is there such a thing as ‘human nature’? Is each individual a product of circumstances, a historical artifact? Behaviourists deny that mental ability is genetically determined. Marxists see society as ontogenetic. Psychoanalysts assert that even instinctual behaviour is the result of individual experience. Those who assert the importance of genetic factors are vulnerable to ferocious attack for asserting a point of
Feral Man
21
view which provides ammunition for racists, reactionaries and the enemies of the poor and underprivileged. Is the new-born child a tabula rasa, or does it possess certain innate ideas? At the time that Kaspar Hauser appeared in Nuremberg people were still worried about the question of whether mankind is by nature good or evil. Nowadays it is generally felt that unacceptable behaviour is the product of an undesirable society or of faulty parenting, and those who think otherwise belong to an endangered minority. Concepts such as original sin seem to most people to be quaintly scholastic. Although Kaspar Hauser emerged into a largely secular world morality was still a serious issue. Was the foundling a sweet innocent, a holy fool, a Parsifal? Or was he by nature mendacious, spiteful and fraudulent? Were his shortcomings the result of a faulty socialization since his release from his prison cell, or were they due to an essentially evil character? Which was at fault – the individual or society? Kaspar Hauser was not only the object of fierce debates, onto whom such notions were projected, he was also the pawn in a political game of republicans against legitimists, of radicals against conservatives. If that were not enough his case aroused the interest of all manner of faddists, charlatans, fortune hunters and sensation seekers. A simple-minded foundling thus became the point of intersection of so many strains of thought so that his own curious personality became hidden under layers of fictional projections. Each had their own Kaspar Hauser – prince, fraud, sweet innocent, pathological liar, tragic object of abuse, victim or culprit.
2 Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
The city in which the drama of Kaspar Hauser unfolded had a rich and proud history. In 1471 the astronomer Johannes Müller (Regiomontanus) flattered the city fathers by proclaiming the city to be the centre of Europe.1 As a sign of its wealth and sense of civic responsibility Nuremberg was one of the first cities in Europe to boast a public library which was opened in the early sixteenth century. Henry IV of France’s brilliant financial councillor Maximilien de Béthune, Duc de Sully, while in retirement after the assassination of his royal master dreamt up a fantastic scheme for the peace of Europe. Fifteen regions were to be created with six regional councils. Nuremberg was to be the seat of the German body.2 By 1828 such schemes would have seemed even more preposterous and the city had yet to adjust fully to its new and inferior position within the German Confederation. On 15 September 1806 at ten in the morning the French plenipotentiary Friron handed over the imperial city of Nuremberg to the Bavarian commissioner Count Thürnheim in an impressive ceremony. Cannons roared, church bells rang, French soldiers and the Nuremberg militia paraded through the streets as the decision of the Act of Confederation of the Rhine was formally acknowledged. The patricians of the city were appalled. The wife of the prominent businessman Paul Wolfgang Merkel burst into tears and told her bemused children that they were now the slaves of princes. 3 The vast majority of the citizenry were more stoic and accepted the inevitable and waited upon events. The Patricians felt it prudent to give the Bavarian commissioner a lavish banquet. They were hard hit by the high-handed way in which the Bavarian government took over both the city’s assets and its debts, and they lost many of their privileges when Nuremberg ceased to be an imperial city. Most of the 22 patrician families were 22
Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
23
later included in the ranks of the Bavarian aristocracy and given the title of Baron. Although the city’s governing body, the Patriarchy, was abolished and replaced by a directorate of police, little changed in the administration of the city. The civic offices were renamed royal Bavarian departments, and Christian Wurm from Ansbach was appointed director of the police. Although authoritarian and vain, he was a hard working and effective administrator. In 1808 the administration of Bavaria was reformed and the kingdom was divided into a number of districts. Nuremberg became the capital of the Pegnitz District. The districts were reorganized two years later and Nuremberg was now placed in the Rezat district whose capital was Ansbach. This was partly the result of the riots in Nuremberg in 1809 when the people had welcomed the Austrian army, forced Wurm to flee, and mishandled Count Thürnheim. This outburst of popular anger was prompted by Thürnheim’s remark that the Austrians were ‘a motley rabble of cobblers, tailors and linen-weavers’ which Nuremberg’s proud artisans found highly offensive. 4 The police director Wurm was the most powerful man in the city. The Municipal Council (Munizipalrat) had only 5 members and they were elected by a mere 10 electors who were appointed by the police director. The council could only meet at the police director’s bidding. In 1818 the city was given a degree of self-government under a city commissioner. A few thousand voted for the 36 members of the Municipal Committee (Gemeindekollegium) of solid bourgeois property owners and professionals. These worthies elected a mayor and his deputy (who was responsible for charitable organizations), 4 regular councillors (Magistratsräte), an officer of works (Baurat) and 12 honorary councillors. In 1821 Jakob Friedrich Binder was appointed mayor. It was an enormously popular choice, and he remained in office until 1854. There were about 80 people in the city’s employ, most of them clerks and policemen and 20 teachers. There was a garrison of some 3000 men who stood guard at the city gates and controlled the visitors. A great deal was done for the poor and needy, providing food and clothing, medical assistance and education. Binder’s deputy mayor, Johannes Scharrer, instituted a special scheme whereby the working poor could put by a modest amount to help them out in times of unemployment. It was a remarkably successful idea which was soon copied throughout Bavaria. In the socially disruptive years of the pre-March Nuremberg had to deal with the pressing problems of post-war poverty and the dislocations caused by the onset of the industrial revolution. The call
24
Kaspar Hauser
on the city’s resources for poor relief were excessive. 5 In 1839 a special tax had to be instituted to help pay off the debt and provide the funds for future investment in hospitals and schools. In this context it is understandable that the exceptionally generous treatment afforded to Kaspar Hauser gave rise to widespread adverse comment. Patrician and bourgeois Nuremberg had a rich cultural and social life. Family music and amateur dramatics were popular home entertainment, and clubs such as Harmony (Harmonie) and Museum (Museum) were popular meeting places. In the spirit of German romanticism there was a lively interest in local history and Johann Ferdinand Roth’s Nuremberg Pocketbook (Nürnberger Taschenbuch) of 1812/13 and New Pocketbook (Neues Taschenbuch) of 1819/22 are among the finest book productions of the age. It was not until 1833 that a theatre was built by public subscription. The price of admission was very high, so only the wealthier could enjoy the productions of modern drama. Nuremberg was a traditional city and at the time it was handed over to Bavaria its economy, severely hit by Napoleon’s continental blockade and the disruptions of war, had not yet adjusted to the needs of a new industrial age. There were 2500 businesses – in other words one enterprise for every 10 inhabitants. The majority were tailors, shoemakers, smiths and wood turners. Few had more than one employee. Eight tobacco firms employed 76 workers in 1811, 2 furniture manufactories had 84 employees in the same year. In all there were only 30 firms which employed more than 10 workers, but many of the small workshops were linked together in putting out arrangements under a single entrepreneur. There were a number of high-quality mirror manufactories along the river Pegnitz, the water power being used for polishing the glass and pounding the foil backing. These highly prized products were exported to North and South America. The most important trades were brewing and tobacco. The Bavarian government loosened the control of the guilds, and the trade and industries law (Gewerbeordnung) of 1825 made it far easier to form a new company, but it took some time before Nuremberg saw any sizable modern factories. The textile manufacturer Johann Philip Lobenhofer followed the example of his Rhineland colleagues and opened a factory with 56 machines and 96 employees in 1827, but the machines were still water-driven. By 1834 when the German customs union (Zollverein) was formed only four enterprises had more than 50 employees. Nuremberg prided itself for being a traditional city of independent artisans largely unaffected by the problems of industrialization. Romantic writers such as Ludwig Tieck praised Nuremberg as
Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
25
a model of old-fashioned German civic virtue, and the city was widely seen as the perfect German city. Few thought it unreasonable that Jews were still not allowed to reside in the city, and that only wealthy Jews were granted permission to do business within the city walls. The Zollverein and the opening of a polytechnic in 1833, along with the opening of the first German railway from Nuremberg to Fürth two years later mark the beginning of a new and dynamic era of economic expansion. The population of Nuremberg in 1806 was 25,176 according to the census. By mid-century the population had doubled. During that period Nuremberg was transformed from a city of merchants and artisans to an industrial centre. This traditional, proud and conservative city was the setting for a remarkable drama which was to excite the interest of Germany and Europe. No one could have imagined that a story which had such a humdrum beginning would end so dramatically. On Whit Monday 26 May 1828, some time between four and five o’clock in the afternoon, Georg Leonhard Weickmann, a 53-year-old cobbler, set out for a stroll through the streets of his native Nuremberg. The town was almost empty as the Nurembergers profited from the good weather to relax in the countryside. As he was about to leave his house on the corner of the Unschlittplatz and the Mittlere Kreuzgasse he met his guild-brother Jakob Beck and stayed in the doorway for a chat. His attention was drawn to a strange young man, who appeared to be about 16 years old, waddling downhill in a most peculiar manner from the Bärleinhuter shouting ‘hey lad’ (‘He Bue!’), an expression used by master craftsmen to hail an apprentice. At first sight he appeared to be drunk. He walked with his heels and soles touching the ground at the same time, the feet turned inwards. He stretched out his arms in order to keep his balance. As he came closer to the two cobblers he said, ‘Neue Torstraße!’ – the name of a street in Nuremberg.6 He was wearing a grey jacket which had been crudely shortened. The grey riding breeches did not match, and had probably belonged to a servant or a forester. He wore a waistcoat with red spots and a black silk scarf around his neck. His boots had high heels with metal cleats and studs. His hat was of a type worn in the town, it was of poor quality and there was a heavily scratched picture of Munich in the lining. His hair was very fine and curly, cut in the style of a farm boy. His clear bluish eyes and blank expression gave him an impression of animal stupidity. Weickmann naturally assumed that the stranger was looking for the Neutorstraße. Since he intended to go in that direction Jakob Beck suggested that he could show him the way. Beck, who was going in the
26
Kaspar Hauser
opposite direction, took his leave. It was a decision he was later to regret when this pathetic newcomer became an international celebrity. Weickmann set off with the awkward stranger over the Max bridge in the direction of the Neutorstraße. They walked together in silence. Shortly after they had crossed the bridge the young man stopped and took a large sealed letter from his jacket pocket and handed it to Weickmann without saying a word. The letter was addressed to ‘The Major of the 4th Battalion’. Since Weickmann had no idea who this person might be, he suggested that they should go to police station at the New Gate. The stranger muttered: ‘Station! Station! New Gate just built eh?’ The cobbler tried to explain that the New Gate was in fact old, and that it had simply kept the name from the time it was built. The young man did not appear to understand this curious logic. Weickmann then asked him where he came from and was told ‘Regensburg’. Asked whether he had been to Nuremberg before he replied: ‘No. First time.’ When Weickmann asked what was new in Regensburg and what he knew of ‘war and peace’, the boy parroted the word ‘war! war!’ It did not take Weickmann long to realize that he had no idea what the word ‘war’ meant, nor did he understand anything that he was saying. By this time the two had reached the police station at the New Gate. The desk clerk asked if the stranger had his journeyman’s identity papers, and Weickmann replied that he did not. The cobbler then took the young man to another guard room where he respectfully removed his hat in front of a corporal and two other men. He showed his letter to the corporal, whereupon the desk clerk showed him the way to a door and told him to enter. Weickmann understood this to mean that the police would look after the stranger and therefore went on his way. There is no record of what happened in the next few hours and it was not until seven o’clock that evening that the stranger arrived at the house of Major von Wessenig. The Major’s batman, Johann Matthias Merk, who was working in the stables, answered the bell and was somewhat non-plussed by the sight of a strange youth, all alone, who thrust a letter into his hand and said, ‘I wanna be a sixth cavalryman like wot my father were’, and, ‘I were showed here to the house.’ Merk, whose master was out, asked the young man where he came from and to whom the letter was addressed. To this and a number of similar questions the only reply was ‘I dunno’. He took pity on the visitor who cut a very pathetic figure and who indicated that his feet hurt badly. He led him to the stable where the stranger immediately threw himself down onto a pile of straw. Merk offered him beer and meat but this he energetically refused, but he eagerly accepted bread and water. 7
Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
27
The Major returned home at eight in the company of a police official called von Scheurl and Lieutenant von Huenpoët with whom he had been to a fête in Erlangen. They were met by the Major’s eight-year-old daughter who announced that there was a wild man in the stables who would not go away. The Major and von Scheurl went into the stables and found the young man asleep on a pile of straw. They had a hard time waking him and were somewhat startled at his reaction. The youth rushed towards the Major, who commanded the 4th squadron of the 6th light cavalry regiment and was in uniform, showing a childish delight in the uniform and exclaiming, ‘I wonna be in the sixth like my father.’ He answered both men’s questions with ‘I dunno’. The Major noticed that he was utterly exhausted and could hardly walk, and thought that his behaviour was infantile. 8 Merk showed the Major the letter which the stranger had given him. He read it hastily and then asked von Scheurl to take the young man to the police station. The anonymous letter, riddled with spelling mistakes and grammatical errors, but written in a clear hand, said that the writer had been given the child on 7 October 1812, and that since he was a poor day labourer with ten children of his own, he had been unable to pay much attention to him. Nevertheless he had brought him up as a Christian and had taught him to write. When he had asked the boy what he wanted to be he replied that he wanted to be in the cavalry like his father. He had told him that when he became a soldier he would come and visit him. He ended the letter by pointing out that there was no point in the Major trying to find out where he came from as the youth had no idea. A second note, in a very uncertain hand, said that the child had been baptized and that his name was Kaspar. His father, who was now dead, had been in the Light Cavalry (Chevaulegerregiment – in this letter corrupted as ‘Schwolische’) and had asked that when the boy was 17 he should be sent to join the 6th Light Cavalry. The writer, purporting to be his mother, said that the child was born on 30 April 1812 and that she had no money and could not look after him. The letter answered none of the questions which people were likely to ask of him and was deliberately confusing. The writer claimed that he had given the foundling a Christian education and then adds that he had not let him out of the house since 1812 – hardly an example of Christian charity. He claimed to have been a poverty-stricken daylabourer, and yet he goes on at great length about the excellent care he had given Kaspar. He insisted no less than four times that he had given him an excellent education, and yet Kaspar Hauser had clearly had
28
Kaspar Hauser
none. The letter was thus pure nonsense, designed to mislead and misinform. That it was reproduced and widely distributed (the original getting lost in the process) could only lead to further confusion. In addition to the letter and the short note, the lad had in his possession a prayer book entitled A Spiritual Forget-me-not (Geistliches Vergißmeinnicht), a small rosary made of horn with a metal cross, two short pamphlets with prayers, a collection of old and worn prayers and sacred pictures, a folded piece of paper containing a small quantity of gold dust, and some blue and white rags. Just as the rosary and religious pamphlets were in marked contrast to his total lack of religious feeling so the single key he carried with him could be interpreted as a mockery, as could the pamphlet entitled ‘The Art of Making up for Lost Time and Unhappy Years’. 9 Scheurl got a servant from the inn Zum schwarzen Kreuz to drive him to the police. The police offered him food, all of which he refused except for bread and water, which he wolfed down eagerly. He answered all questions with his habitual ‘I dunno’. Johann Adam Röder was the officer of the day responsible for questioning the newcomer. He assumed that he was a vagrant since he had no papers. According to a statement made six years later by Jean Jacques Lemarié, a police constable who was on duty at the time, the boy made no reply to any of the questions asked of him, even when he was threatened with a beating if he did not say where he came from. When it was realized that there was little point in continuing this questioning the boy was handed over to a gaoler, Andreas Hiltel, at about 10.30 p.m., with the instruction that he should not be locked up with the beggars and vagrants but with ‘decent prisoners’ who might be able to find out something about this peculiar youth.10 Hiltel put him in a cell with a Swabian butcher’s boy who had been locked away for 48 hours for drunkenness. He lay down on his pallet, remained silent and occasionally sobbed. The next morning he was given black bread and water. When Hiltel asked his name he replied ‘Kaspar Hauser’. Hiltel later noticed that the two shirts he wore one over the other were marked with a letter ‘H’, as was his handkerchief. Encouraged by this reply he asked him where he came from, only to be treated to yet another ‘I dunno’. He then tried another tack, but without much success. In answer to the question ‘from whom do you come’ came the reply: ‘From ’im where I always were and from who I were led inner the big village.’ All further questions were answered with the habitual ‘I dunno’. A clerk of the court (Aktuar), Hüftlein, in the company of a medical officer, Dr Paul Siegmund Karl Preu, tried to get a statement from the boy, but he was unable to speak coherently.
Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
29
Much to the amazement of the police officers he was able to write his name clearly and legibly, but he was unable to write anything else. He was thus able to write his name before he could speak a coherent sentence. He took pure pleasure in writing, without knowing what it was he wrote. In his mind there was no relationship between the signifier and the signified. There is a curious symmetry in Kaspar Hauser’s arrival in Nuremberg with a meaningless letter of introduction and his dying moments when he tried to write on the bedcover with his index finger. The written word served as a denial that there was a subject behind each sentence, a consciousness behind each utterance, just as Kaspar Hauser’s reluctance to use the reflexive pronoun was a denial of the subject. His first statement ‘I wanna be a sixth cavalryman like wot my father were’ is not that of a self-activating subject but the overdetermined object of others’ intentions. The symbolic father determines that the son shall be his double. Kaspar Hauser’s personality is thus merely a derivative of an absent and unknown figure. He was given beef and noodles for lunch but refused to eat them. The butcher’s boy ate both portions with gusto. He told his gaoler that he thought his cell-mate was an idiot and that he had been unable to get any sense out of him. Hiltel, a patient and considerate man, was less damning in his judgment, although he came to similar conclusions. He noticed that the youth referred to all humans, regardless of sex or age, as ‘lads’. Similarly he called all animals ‘horse’. He had no idea of the difference between night and day, or the sun and the moon. He was obviously unfamiliar with fire and on his second day under Hiltel’s care he grabbed the flame in a lantern. Apart from ‘I dunno’ all he could say was ‘wanna go ’ome where I were’ and ‘I wanna be a cavalryman, a sixer like my father were’. At the same time he was able to write a few single letters in addition to signing his name. Hiltel let Kaspar play with his two children, aged 11 and 3, and this gave him obvious pleasure. In 1834 Hiltel made a further statement in court about his charge. It is clear that he soon grew fond of the boy and would have kept him under his care had it not been for the fact that he had eight children of his own to look after. Kaspar learnt quickly, was obliging, and appeared direct and honest. Hiltel remarked that Kaspar was extremely sensitive to the light. He ate two pounds of bread daily and was regularly given fresh water. He sat cross-legged, never stretched his legs out, and appeared uncomfortable in a chair. The great jurist Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach, who played such an important role in Kaspar’s life, insisted to the contrary that he sat with his legs stretched out in front of him, and that since he had always sat in this manner his legs had become deformed. 11
30
Kaspar Hauser
Kaspar was filthy when he arrived, objected to being washed, and shrank at any physical contact. He was so fearful that he was even frightened of Hiltel’s 2-year-old son, whom he thought was about to beat him up. In contrast when police officers brandied their sabres at him, stabbing and slashing, he showed no sign of any emotion and looked at them with blank amazement. He was fascinated by a lighted candle, but howled when he innocently touched the flame. He told Hiltel that he had been confined in a cellar. Through an opening in the wall he could see a pile of wood and the tip of a tree. His gaoler had brought him to Nuremberg, had given him a change of clothes and had abandoned him at the city gate. After three of four days Kaspar was moved into a room in Hiltel’s quarters on orders from the Mayor of Nuremberg, Jakob Friedrich Binder. This small room was such that it was possible to observe the boy without him noticing, and Hiltel was instructed to keep a close watch on his charge. He came to the conclusion that Kaspar Hauser was no idiot but that he had been denied any education or training. At first he had played with toys like a small child, but he quickly became interested in more mature pursuits. Hiltel’s 3-year-old daughter Margareta showed him how to thread beads and his 11-year-old son Julius taught him vocabulary and encouraged him to write. He showed great interest in drawings and etchings which were given to him and he pasted them on the walls of his little room. The curious and sundry well-wishers brought him toys so that the room was soon crammed full of hundreds of lead soldiers, wooden dogs and horses, and other toys for which Nuremberg was famous. He was also given clothing in which he took a certain coquettish pride, but he showed no interest in the money he was given. He did not play with his toys, merely packed them away in the evening and set them up again the next morning. Two days after Kaspar’s arrival in Nuremberg the court asked Dr Preu, a prominent Nuremberg physician, to examine him to decide whether he was insane.12 This was a reasonable assumption since a number of idiots, who also were unable to say whence they came, had arrived in Nuremberg in recent years. The doctor examined Kaspar Hauser for a number of days and concluded that far from being stupid he was the innocent victim of a monstrous crime. He had been denied normal human company, decent food and a rudimentary education. It was thus understandable that he behaved like the ‘wild man of the woods’. Dr Preu remarked that Kaspar’s body movements were awkward, his walk unsteady, his voice monotonous. He could only repeat his limited
Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
31
repertoire of phrases and frequently wept. The doctor concluded that he could not possibly be a fraud, nor the instrument of a fraud. He was genuine – but was he mad? This could only be decided by careful observation. Hiltel was therefore instructed to let him move about as freely as possible and to keep a close watch on him. After a few days Dr Preu confirmed his diagnosis that Kaspar was a human animal who had been denied a normal upbringing. He later admitted to having made two false assumptions during this first examination. He had assumed that he could read a few words from the devotional pamphlets he had brought with him, but in fact he had learnt a passage by heart. He had further believed that when Kaspar Hauser had said that he had fed a horse he meant a real horse and not a wooden toy. A policeman, Joseph Blaimer, was given the task of taking Kaspar for walks around Nuremberg in the hope that he might recognize some part of the city through which he had passed on his arrival. This was to no avail. Blaimer soon grew tired of the endless repetition of his few phrases and noted that he called all animals a horse, all humans Bue. He was terrified of black animals, but liked white ones. Kaspar’s feet were exceptionally sensitive and he was unable to walk for more than a quarter of an hour without getting exhausted. In spite of his irritation, Blaimer felt sorry for Kaspar, had great sympathy for his plight and was convinced that he was not play-acting. 13 A few days after examining Kaspar, Dr Preu went for a five-week cure in Karlsbad, leaving the observation of the stranger in the hands of his colleague Dr Osterhausen. He felt that the wealth of new impressions was too much for someone who was said to have been locked away in a cellar for years. This was compounded by his obvious desire to learn. He was amazed how quickly Kaspar was able to remember the names of the various flowers which he showed him. Kaspar became increasingly nervous and irritable. His face twitched, his hands shook, his eyes were bloodshot and hurt whenever he concentrated on a particular object or tried to read. His hearing was so sensitive that a loud conversation caused him considerable pain, and he could no longer listen to music, even though he had previously enjoyed it so much. He had a poor appetite, complained of stomach pains and suffered from constipation. Osterhausen did not recommend the use of any drugs since Kaspar intensely disliked anything other than bread and water, and reacted violently to any other form of nourishment. Kaspar’s rapidly deteriorating condition became a matter of concern. There was a constant stream of visitors anxious to catch a glimpse of this strange youth. Feuerbach described him as living the life of ‘the
32
Kaspar Hauser
kangaroo and the tame hyena in Herr van Aken’s famous menagerie’. 14 Dr Osterhausen was therefore delighted when he was handed over on 18 July to the care of a kindly but eccentric grammar school teacher who was on sick leave, Georg Friedrich Daumer, who lived with his mother and sister, and it was felt that these three compassionate people would give Kaspar the affection, the family life, and the education he so sadly lacked. Daumer had been introduced to Kaspar Hauser on 27 June by Baron Gottlieb von Tucher who was appointed the foundling’s legal guardian. Kaspar was moved into Daumer’s house on 18 July 1828. His preceptor was one of the leading figures in Nuremberg’s cultural life. Nuremberg was not a great intellectual or literary centre like Berlin, Königsberg, Heidelberg, Jena or Weimar and its intellectual life was distinctly provincial. Among the intellectual elite the dividing line was between rationalists and anti-rationalists and Daumer was considered to be the leading figure among the rationalists. He was born in Nuremberg on 5 March 1800. He was the third of six children of a furrier whose prosperous business had been bankrupted by the disruption to the German economy caused by Napoleon’s continental blockade. The family survived, although in abject poverty, thanks to the efforts of Georg Friedrich’s remarkable mother, to whom he was greatly attached. His father, Peter, was so shattered by his bankruptcy that he lost his reason. He spent most of his time chewing his nails to the bone and muttering: ‘When are we going to go home?’ This unhappy man died in 1826.15 Daumer was not only poor, he was also a sickly child, and remained throughout his life a self-pitying valetudinarian. He was a brilliant though dreadfully earnest pupil at the Aegidius grammar school and, as was typical for gifted children from a poor background, was destined for a career in the church. He had been G. W. F. Hegel’s pupil, for the great idealist philosopher was headmaster of this Nuremberg grammar school, having lost his professorship at Jena when the French closed the university. Hegel treated his pupils to a potted version of his immensely taxing Phenomenology of Mind, which was published in 1807. He continually contrasted his rational approach to the romantic and intuitional philosophy of Schelling which was then very much in vogue. At the age of 17 Daumer went to Erlangen to study Protestant theology. Erlangen was a centre of pietism and set store by excessive ascetic practices. Daumer fasted in the hope of having a divine vision, but abandoned the attempt after nine days without the desired result. A fellow student was even more avid in the pursuit of spiritual enlightenment that he castrated himself in an excess of religious zeal.
Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
33
Disillusioned with the grim rigour of Erlangen, and having lost his theological vocation, Daumer contemplated suicide but opted for classical studies at Leipzig university, a centre of rationalist philosophy. He soon found this approach equally unsatisfactory and condemned it as superficial. Having abandoned theology he studied languages and literature with a passionate enthusiasm, taking his degree in Munich in 1823. He returned to Nuremberg in 1823 to teach at the Melanchthon Grammar School. In 1826 Daumer fell foul of his headmaster, Karl Ludwig Roth, an appalling tyrant who managed actually to scare one of his pupils to death. In a speech written on the occasion of the school’s third centenary Daumer suggested that the Lutheran church should undergo a permanent reformation. Roth felt that this was a scandalous attempt to make Luther’s teaching of merely relative significance and cancelled the speech. Daumer thereupon had it published and was now in open conflict with Roth. Two years later he retired: his poor eyesight gave him the right to a pension at the age of 28. It took five years before the question of his pension was settled, and he was thus obliged to supplement his modest income by giving private lessons. He was therefore given the responsibility for educating Kaspar Hauser in the year that he was obliged to leave his teaching post. He continued to write pamphlets on philosophical topics and on his experiences with the famous foundling, and wrote a great deal of verse. He dabbled in homoeopathy and animal magnetism, which were popular fads of the day. Most of his writings are the derivative and superficial efforts of a dilettante, but Brahms saw fit to set 54 of his poems to music. In characteristic terms Karl Marx denounced Daumer in the Neue Rheinische Zeitung as a pathetic Nuremberg petit bourgeois, as a coward who was so scared by the historical tragedy of the 1848 revolution that he had taken refuge in a ridiculous idyllic agrarian vision, in order to hide his ‘female resignation’. 16 He was a prolific and erratic writer, a poet of modest talent and an indefatigable searcher for what he took to be religious truth. From 1827 to 1835 – roughly the time that Kaspar Hauser was in Nuremberg and Ansbach – he struggled with the absurdly ambitious project of writing a ‘speculative history of God, the spirit and the world’. He was forced to abandon this mammoth task having published four volumes on the subject. 17 His outspoken attacks on Christianity resulted in some of his works being seized by the police, but he had no sympathy for the atheism of Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach’s son Ludwig Feuerbach, by whom he was befriended during the Kaspar Hauser period. Karl Marx poured scorn on Daumer’s extremely far-fetched theory that Christianity
34
Kaspar Hauser
was based on cannibalism, and that the Eucharist was an anthropophagous ceremony. 18 His ‘Hafis’ poems, which were mostly his own invention, or extremely loose translations from the Persian, enjoyed considerable popularity, not least for their steamy eroticism, which was all the more surprising since they sprang from the pen of a solitary and self-absorbed old maid. The leader of the anti-rationalists in Nuremberg was Kaspar Hauser’s legal guardian, Christoph Karl Gottlieb von Tucher, who came from a prominent patrician family which had made its money as brewers. The Tucher brewery still exists, but is no longer in the possession of the family. Tucher had also studied under Hegel and became his brother-in-law when the philosopher married his elder sister, Marie von Tucher, in 1811. He had visited Kaspar Hauser in an official capacity soon after his arrival in Nuremberg. 19 He thought him to be an utterly innocent child who did not know the difference between good and evil. His mind was a tabula rasa for he had, as Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach argued, lived a life analogous to that of an oyster in its shell with no idea of the outside world and no sensation but that of eating. He was highly receptive, so that it was easy to imagine that he was exceptionally gifted, but became increasingly nervous and mindless. This Tucher attributed either to the inappropriate treatment he had received in the first few weeks since his arrival in Nuremberg, or to the dramatic change in his circumstances. Tucher was overwhelmed by Kaspar Hauser’s ‘natural and unaffected purity and unselfconsciousness, which gave an exceptional insight into what mankind looked like before the Fall’. 20 Although the anti-rationalists called their opponents the ‘false prophets’ the distinctions between the two sides were not so very great. Daumer did not deny the role of personal feelings and subjectivity in theology, but felt that the idealism of those who called themselves ‘The Awakened’ went too far. Their philosophical differences had no influence on their attitudes towards Kaspar Hauser. Indeed the two were good friends, and Tucher had no second thoughts about entrusting Kaspar Hauser to Daumer’s care.21 Daumer was a bachelor and lived with his mother and unmarried sister. Between them they gave their ward his first taste of family life. Kaspar lived with the Daumers from 18 July, and on 11 September Daumer reported to the mayor’s office that his pupil had only just recovered from a bout of severe nervous tension which had made it impossible to continue with his lessons. While he had been in the tower Daumer, since he was unemployed, was able to visit him daily and managed to teach him the rudiments of reading, writing and
Kaspar Hauser Appears in Nuremberg
35
arithmetic. Since there was a constant stream of visitors it was almost impossible for Kaspar to concentrate on his work for more than half an hour at a time. After about three weeks it was no longer possible to teach him because his nervous condition had become so acute. By the time Daumer took over the responsibility of looking after him, Kaspar could hardly stand up. His acute constipation improved somewhat but he still suffered from severe digestive problems, and was in such a nervous state that he could not bear to hear a single note on a piano, could not write, found the colour white insufferable, and his hands shook violently. He complained that his eyes hurt and he had frequent severe headaches. Two days after arriving in Daumer’s house Kaspar Hauser fell seriously ill and was unable to continue with his studies. Daumer encouraged him to do some handicrafts, to work in the garden and to play some simple games. The attempt to make him do some exercises was a failure, but he showed a considerable aptitude for riding in which he was instructed by an equerry, Wilhelm von Rumpler. Some sought to explain his remarkable equestrian abilities by suggesting that he must come from a nation of horsemen. Other less charitable folk claimed that he had escaped from a circus and was living it up at the expense of Nuremberg’s hard-pressed taxpayers.22 Kaspar’s physical condition improved rapidly so that he grew two inches within a month and was now able to walk for miles, when previously even a short stroll left him completely exhausted. His senses were exceptionally acute. He could detect the smallest drop of meat stock in his watery soup. He could distinguish the smell of different berries from a distance of 100 paces. He could see clearly in the dark and could read better at dusk without a lamp than during the day when the sunlight dazzled him. Daumer reported that in August his charge was for the first time able to distinguish between a serious statement and a joke. Kaspar remained in Dr Osterhausen’s care until Dr Preu took over the case on his return from Karlsbad. He was less concerned about Kaspar’s extremely nervous condition than was his colleague and attributed his gradual improvement to a change of diet whereby he reluctantly ate a certain amount of meat and animal products, and to the beneficial effects of his homoeopathic remedies.
3 Homoeopathic Experiments
Dr Paul Siegmund Karl Preu was an avid homoeopath and jumped at the opportunity to test the theories of Christian Friedrich Samuel Hahnemann, the founder of this science and the author of the Organon of the Rational Art of Healing, who was then living in retirement in Koethen having been forbidden to practise since 1821. Hahnemann’s fundamental principle, which he published in 1810, was summed up in the Latin tag similia similibus curantur (like can be cured by like). Cures could be effected by minute dilutions of substances which produced a similar effect as the disease to be cured. It was thus a method analogous to vaccination – a practice that was still not universally accepted by the medical profession. Indeed at the time that Hahnemann published his Organon the principles of a scientific medical practice had yet to be agreed upon. It was not until mid-century that Hahnemann’s teaching found a substantial following, and thus Dr Preu was one of his earliest disciples. He saw his experiments on Kaspar Hauser as a triumphant vindication of Hahnemann’s ideas. 1 The theory of Animal Magnetism, to which Daumer and Preu both subscribed with equal fervour, was much in vogue and was enthusiastically espoused by German natural philosophers and dabblers in the occult. The leading figures in the occult movement in the late eighteenth century were Swedenborg, Lavater, Basedow, Hamann, Hemsterhuis, Jung-Stilling, Cagliostro and the Count de Saint Germain who provided critical material for Goethe’s Faust. Mesmer’s theories of magnetism were a European-wide fad. By the time Kaspar Hauser arrived in Nuremberg animal magnetism and somnambulism were widely regarded as absurd. Daumer, however, took Justinus Kerner’s revelations about the ‘medium of Prevorst’ very seriously, and felt that they could be effectively combined with Hahnemann’s homoeopathy. He was in contact with 36
Homoeopathic Experiments
37
such prominent contemporary practitioners of alternative medicine as Baron von Reichenbach, the advocate of positive pneumonology, Baron Ludwig von Güldenstubbe and Maximilian Petry. That Daumer should have been fascinated by occult phenomena is hardly surprising. After all Bacon, Descartes, Newton and Leibnitz were all influenced by the Rosicrucians, and some of Daumer’s contemporaries, including such philosophical heavyweight rivals as Hegel and Schopenhauer, supported such endeavours. In our own day a fascination with the paranormal is not restricted to credulous devotees of astrology and tarot cards, but is shared by scientists of – admittedly highly controversial – repute. Daumer, although a minor figure, was part of a tradition that went from the Romantics to Ludwig Klages’ philosophy of life to Freud and Jung. Daumer’s occult studies and his theory of the essential principle of a transcendental subject endowed with what he was pleased to call the ‘eidolo-magic power of the soul’, mostly published in the 1860s, long after Kaspar Hauser’s death, enjoyed a certain popularity. Although his was hardly a household name, he is mentioned in a novella by Theodor Storm, who assumed he needed no introduction to his well-educated readers.2 Apart from Kaspar Hauser the only object of Daumer’s homoeopathic and magnetic experiments was Mathilde Binder, the illegitimate daughter of the mayor of Nuremberg. Daumer encouraged her in her literary endeavours and she published a number of works of dubious quality under the pseudonym Amara George. ‘Amara’ reflected her bitterness at being rejected as an outsider by Nuremberg’s society, and ‘George’ was an expression of gratitude for the help given her by Daumer. 3 His experiments were not a great success. He was convinced that all he had managed to achieve was to transfer Mathilde’s lung disease to himself by the aid of magnetism. Friedrich Anton Mesmer, who claimed to have discovered this lifeforce, had a sensational career in Paris from 1778 until 1785 when two commissions, one of which included Benjamin Franklin, Jean Sylvan Bailly and Antoine Lavoisier, pronounced against him and he was eventually obliged to leave town.4 In 1793, when he returned to his native Vienna, Mesmer was arrested and spent some time in jail as a suspected Jacobin. In Paris mesmerism had been all the rage in fashionable society and was supported by those who hoped to discredit the establishment. Mesmer founded a club, the Order of Harmony, and similar clubs were formed in a number of French towns, many of which later became centres of Jacobinism. Alternative medicine, then as now, was both a self-indulgent fad and a cause taken up by those who felt that all
38
Kaspar Hauser
was not right, not only with the medical profession but also with society at large. Mesmer’s ideas were based on a combination of Newton’s notion of the ‘ether’ which permeated space and matter with more recent discoveries in electricity and magnetism. He wished to establish a gravitas animalis analogous to Newton’s theory of gravity. He claimed that certain parts of the nervous system are affected by a phenomenon similar to light (materia luminosa) which can have an effect throughout the body. The Scottish doctor John Brown (1735–88) had suggested that there was a mysterious power which existed between bodies and that ‘asthenic’ diseases were caused by an abnormal excitability of the organs and could be cured with debilitating medicines. ‘Brunonians’ likewise insisted that ‘asthenic’ diseases were to be treated with stimulants. Their major contribution to contemporary medicine was that they condemned the practice of bloodletting. In Germany mesmerism, or animal magnetism, was more esoteric and conservative. Schelling’s On the World Spirit: A Hypothesis of Higher Physics on the Understanding of the Common Organism published in 1798 was the fundamental text and inspired much high-falutin’ claptrap. 5 Schelling, the high priest of the German romantics, rejected mechanical explanations of nature and argued that the natural world could only be understood in terms of a vital process, a process which had a purpose and whose main characteristic was polarity. The dialectical tensions whereby the unconscious determines the conscious and vice versa could only be overcome by artistic genius. The artist’s conscious activity reveals the unconscious and thus removes a polarity which otherwise could only end in infinity. 6 The objective world ranges from matter to light, from electricity to chemistry and physics to the organism as the highest, most ‘potent’ and most ‘spiritual’ aspect of nature. The subjective world extends from morality to knowledge and art, the last being the highest form of subjectivity. The universe as the perfect organism is also a perfect work of art. It is thus a manifestation of the absolute which Schelling was to call God. In the mystic harmony of the universe, spirit and nature, mind and body, are united. Schelling’s disciples took a holistic approach to medicine based on an intuitive understanding of the ‘life force’ and its polarities. The rational and the systematic were rejected as necessary keys to an understanding of the natural world. This could lead to some astonishing conclusions. There was a polarity between the liver and the spleen, also between iron and mercury, therefore mercury should be used to cure diseases of the
Homoeopathic Experiments
39
spleen. Inanimate nature was potential life, the earliest stage of the spirit. Hence the fascination with electricity, magnetism and smells. It was an approach which prompted Hegel, in one of his more comprehensible utterances, to remark that heat was ‘the auto-restoration of material in its formlessness, its liquidity, the triumph of its abstract homogeneity over specific certainties’. 7 Schelling’s heady mixture of science and speculation, situated on the border between imaginative literature and natural science, was a typical product of Germany in the Biedermeier years of the first half of the nineteenth century. 8 It created the intellectual atmosphere in which the Kaspar Hauser affair would be discussed. Contemporaries were fascinated by the mythological aspects of the ‘Child of Europe’ and could place him within a distinct literary tradition of foundlings and wild children. Calderón’s Life as a Dream of 1634/5 where the heir to the throne is imprisoned in a tower and from which Feuerbach quoted in the introduction to his pamphlet on Kaspar Hauser, the affair of the Man in the Iron Mask, and Jean Paul’s The Invisible Lodge of 1793, in which the hero spends the first eight years of his life in an underground cave instructed by a member of the Moravian Brotherhood, did much to prepare the way for the reception of the Kaspar Hauser story. The gaps in the story of his life could be filled in with fictional material or speculation based on past cases. ‘Kaspar Hauser’ as a social construct was thus a curious blend of fact and fiction, of systematic inquiry and poetic imagination, of science and sentiment. He was not in the strict sense of the term a ‘wild child’, and most of those who wrote about him, from Anselm von Feuerbach to hack poets and provincial journalists, emphasized his innocence and goodness that was in sharp contrast to the behaviour of most wild children. He was a unique child whose fate poetically illuminated the nature of childhood. His childishness rather than his wildness was thus of primary interest, although both were fascinating because they were seen as states of emptiness, resulting in a total lack of understanding of the world, and an inability to distinguish between the self and the other. Further confusion was caused by the political dimension of the case when it was rumoured and widely believed that he was the legitimate heir to the grand duchy of Baden. Small wonder then that he remains as much a mystery today as he did when he arrived in Nuremberg in 1828. The natural philosophers with their emphasis on the irrational were the exact opposite of modern scientists who, in Max Weber’s words, seek the ‘de-mystification of the world’. Schelling had two devoted disciples in the two leading authorities on animal magnetism in
40
Kaspar Hauser
Germany: Karl Alexander Ferdinand Kluge and Gotthilf Heinrich Schubert. Kluge was particularly interested in somnambulism and dreams. He distinguished between three forms of sleep: normal sleep, somnambulistic sleep and magnetic sleep. Schubert was even more extreme, examining what he was pleased to call ‘panpsychism’: the inter-relationship of spirit and nature, mind and body.9 Schelling’s own experiments with animal magnetism were hardly encouraging. He tried to heal Caroline Schlegel’s daughter with magnetism but without success. The unfortunate girl, who was also his stepdaughter, died. The humorist Jean Paul surprisingly had a far greater success and claimed to have cured his wife’s toothache using this new technique. Friedrich Schiller consulted a mesmerist, and one of Germany’s leading doctors, Christoph Wilhelm Hufeland, president of the medical college in Berlin and author of Makrobiotik, a treatise on the prolongation of life, was the most prominent convert to the new science. As in France, the German medical establishment moved to ban this rival therapy. In 1812 a commission was established to examine animal magnetism and recommend that it be outlawed. The Prussian king’s personal physician, Johann Ferdinand Koreff, who had persuaded the chancellor Hardenberg and the minister of education Wilhelm von Humboldt of the virtues of magnetism, was able to frustrate the establishment. It was agreed that full reports should be made of the therapeutic use of magnetism in an attempt to stop the more outrageous forms of quackery and charlatanism. It was also decreed that only qualified doctors could practise animal magnetism, but this proved impossible to enforce. Mesmer insisted that only a few people with special qualities were able to establish a magnetic rapport with a patient. This power could be transferred to other living objects, such as trees, or to water. Tubs filled with mesmerized water and pieces of iron were widely used, their therapeutic value highly rated. There thus attached a charisma to the mesmerists which could easily provoke the charge of charlatanism.10 Kluge, following the lead of the Marquis de Puségur and his Societé harmonique des amis réunis, sought to combine the physical approach to magnetism as practised by Mesmer and the psychic approach of the Chevalier Barbarin, who had a large following in Ostende and Lyon. Barbarin’s notion of a purely psychic power with no material basis was particularly attractive to Schelling and the natural philosophers. He claimed that somnambulists could distinguish colours and read unknown handwriting blindfolded, hence the experiments made with Kaspar Hauser’s night vision, the acuteness of which was attributed not
Homoeopathic Experiments
41
only to his lengthy imprisonment in a dark room but also to his remarkable ‘magnetic’ powers. It was said that a magnetized person would sneeze when another took snuff, just as Kaspar Hauser was to appear drunk when a champagne bottle was opened in the same room. Such ideas were bound to appeal to romantic writers, particularly the importance accorded to dreams. E. T. A. Hoffmann was a friend of the magnetizer Johann Ferdinand Koreff and was fascinated by the subject. Two other friends, the Bamberg doctors Friedrich Marcus, a mesmerist with a national reputation, and Friedrich Speyer, gave him expert advice on the subject. He remained sceptical, feeling that most of these remarkable effects were due to hypnotism and autosuggestion, but found magnetism an ideal topic for his Gothic novellas.11 Hoffmann was particularly intrigued by the power that magnetizers had over their patients. Alban in ‘The Magnetiser’ says to a patient: ‘I am your god who can see into your inmost soul, and everything that you have or would like to hide there is clearly and vividly revealed to me.’ Hoffmann described Napoleon as a ‘political magnetizer’, a man who fully understood the dynamics of power, and of whose analogue Alban said: All existence is struggle and comes from struggle. The powerful achieves victory in an ever increasing climax, and the enslaved vassals increase his power . . . The struggle for such a power is the struggle for the godlike, and as the feeling of power increases so does a degree of bliss and in the same proportion. The claim to see into a person’s inmost secrets and to stimulate healing properties in the autonomic nervous system places the animal magnetizers within a therapeutic tradition which extends from clairvoyance, somnambulism and hypnotism to psychoanalysis and psychotherapy. Samuel Hahnemann’s homoeopathy was based on principles similar to those of the animal magnetists. Hahnemann was born in 1755, the son of a porcelain painter in the Meissen works.12 He studied medicine in Leipzig, Vienna and Erlangen and received his medical degree in 1779. For the next 15 years he travelled around Germany, unable to establish a viable practice, frequently reduced to abject poverty, but nonetheless establishing a reputation as a scholar and practitioner of note. He earned his living in part by translating medical books from the English. Among these was William Cullen’s Materia Medica which he translated in 1790. In this work Cullen describes the effect of cinchona (the Peruvian bark from which quinine is extracted) on intermittent fever which he ascribed to the
42
Kaspar Hauser
‘strengthening power it exerts on the stomach’. Hahnemann found this a most unsatisfactory speculation and decided to experiment with the drug on himself. For several days he took a drachma twice daily. 13 He experienced cold in his hands and feet, became extremely tired and had tachychardia; his pulse became fast; his head ached; his cheeks became flushed; he was thirsty and overcome with a feeling of anxiety. In other words he experienced the various symptoms of intermittent fever in sequence, but without the high fever. From this he concluded that the effect of the drug was to suppress the intermittent fever by causing a short fever of its own. This experiment with cinchona gave Hahnemann the clue to his homoeopathic theory. To cure a disease the physician needed to prescribe a drug which caused a similar artificial disease. Such was the origin of the basic principle of this new therapy: similia similibus curantur. He argued that illness was caused by a clouding over of the life force which could be restored to its full vitality by the administration of dilutions of medicine with an effect analogous to that of the apparent disease. The degree of dilution varied with each specific patient. Drugs were tried out on perfectly healthy subjects to see what effects, however trivial, they had. They were then used to treat diseases which had similar symptoms. Edward Jenner’s successful experiments with vaccination in 1798 confirmed him in his belief that like cured like. Hahnemann published his findings in the Organon of Rational Medicine in 1810 in which he argued that drugs should be administered in infinitesimal doses. The book was also an outspoken attack on the medical establishment and Hahnemann saw himself as a latter-day Luther fighting against a corrupt orthodoxy. He opposed the current belief in the stimulation of vomiting and haemorrhaging and argued that this was merely encouraging the patient’s disordered ‘natural force’ and thus worsening his condition. Hahnemann insisted that attempting to cure a disease with a drug which had a contrary effect (contraria contraiis curantur), a practice which he called ‘allopathy’, in fact harmed the patient. In subsequent editions of the Organon the dosages became increasingly diluted. The juice of a medicinal plant was mixed with an equal amount of alcohol. Two drops of this mixture were then diluted in 98 drops of alcohol. The vial was shaken twice to ‘exalt its energy’. Two drops of this mixture was then mixed with 99 drops of alcohol. This process was repeated for a total of 30 times to reach what he called the ‘decillionth development of power’. It needed a quite extraordinary faith to believe that such dilutions of a drug could have any effect, since at the fourth dilution the ration of
Homoeopathic Experiments
43
drug to solution was one to one hundred million. Allopaths ignored Hahnemann’s dire warnings of the effects of his medicines and took great delight in swallowing large quantities of the final dilution to prove that it had no effect. In 1828 Hahnemann gave the allopaths further occasion for ridicule. In his Chronic Diseases he claimed that with the exception of syphilis and a particular type of venereal wart, all maladies were caused by the itch and should be treated by antipsoric medicines. It is for this reason that Kaspar Hauser was diagnosed at times as suffering from ‘internal itch’. Hahnemann’s ideas were so extreme and so implausible that homoeopathy would almost certainly have disappeared were it not for the fact that many of his followers took their own individual approach and selected those aspects of his teaching which they found useful. He complained bitterly of such ‘mongrel homoeopaths’ and was angry that his views on psora were not always endorsed by the fraternity. The other reason for the continued interest in homoeopathy was that the approach at least did considerably less harm than did massive purgings and bleedings, and homoeopaths could show that the recovery rates for their patients stricken by the cholera epidemics of 1832 and 1848/9 were superior to those of the allopaths. Homoeopathy gradually faded away as advances in conventional medicine brought spectacular results, but has recently enjoyed a revival with the modish New Age fascination with alternative medicine. In June 1988 the highly regarded scientific magazine Nature published a sensational article by a team of scientists from Israel, Italy and Canada under the leadership of Jacques Benveniste from the Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM) at the Université Paris-Sud in which it was claimed that water can be imprinted with the memory of past solutes so that an antibody could retain its biological effectiveness even when diluted by factors as great as 10120 – a dilution so extreme that one of Nature’s correspondents argued that even if the entire universe were converted into water it would not be sufficient to dilute the contents of a 1 cm3 vial to such an extent.14 The publication of such an amazing hypothesis was met with widespread incredulity in the scientific community and suspicions were further aroused when it was pointed out that the salaries of two of Dr Benveniste’s associates were paid for under a contract with Boiron et Cie., a supplier of homoeopathic medicines. Since in France 15 per cent of all medicines are homoeopathic, much was at stake. Nature had agreed to publish the paper on the condition that it could investigate Dr Benveniste’s laboratory. The three-man team was made
44
Kaspar Hauser
up of the magazine’s editor John Maddox, whose background is in theoretical physics, Walter W. Stewart, a specialist in detecting errors and inconsistencies in scientific papers with a particular interest in scientific misconduct, and James Randi, a professional magician who played an important role in exposing Uri Geller, and who had once worked as a laboratory assistant to Banting and Best in Toronto. Many French scientists saw the composition of the investigating team to be an example of Albion at its most perfidious, and there were loud protests from the homoeopathic industry, particularly from Boiron et Cie., but there was no serious challenge to their conclusions that there was no substantial basis for Dr Benveniste’s extravagant claims, that the experiments had been poorly conducted, and that the ‘climate of the laboratory (was) inimical to an objective evaluation of the exceptional data’. It was suggested that Dr Benveniste’s assistant, Dr Davenas, had manipulated the data to produce results pleasing to her superior. 15 Dr Beneveniste was given no further funding to continue his research in this area. This latest attempt to find scientific justification for a metaphysical conceit was a dismal failure, although some still believe that once again the establishment had silenced a courageous scientist whose ‘obviously positive results’ were silenced in a ‘crusade’ that used ‘fact twisting, errors omissions, misquotations and mistruths’ to suppress a revolutionary scientific discovery. 16 Homoeopathy was part of an attack prompted by the vitalist philosophy of Schelling and his epigones on empiricism, determinism and mechanics, and the belief that the human body was a suitable object of investigation for the natural sciences. The ‘natural philosophers’ took Newton to task for his empiricism and insisted that nature could only be understood by intuition and contemplation. Physicians, like Baron Ernst von Feuchtersleben in Vienna and Johann Nepomuk Ringseis in Munich, denounced ‘materialist’ medicine and called for an approach that combined prayer, the laying on of hands and meditation along with slightly more modern therapeutic practices. Proponents of empirical scientific investigation had a singularly hard struggle against these priestly doctors and poetic contemplators of the marvels of nature. Germany’s greatest contemporary scientist, Justus Liebig, bitterly protested against such mumbo-jumbo as ‘the plague of our century’. He continued: A person who kills another in a fit of madness is put in prison. Nowadays natural philosophy allows our doctors to be educated and to be taught their particular brand of madness, which allows them
Homoeopathic Experiments
45
in good conscience and according to established principles to kill thousands. 17 The violent reaction against the natural philosophers by such as Liebig accounts in part for the triumph of the exact sciences in Germany, although it is only fair to point out, as has Thomas Kuhn, that the approach of the natural philosophers also brought significant progress in such modern disciplines as electromagnetism, embryology, morphology and the theory of evolution. 18 Georg Friedrich Daumer shared Dr Preu’s enthusiasm for Hahnemann’s theories and encouraged him to conduct a number of homoeopathic experiments on the hapless foundling. Daumer had long suffered from various complaints, but a number of doctors had been unable to improve his condition using allopathic medicine. For the last year he had been taking homoeopathic remedies under Dr Preu’s supervision and had studied the science diligently. Preu suggested that homoeopathic medicine would benefit Kaspar Hauser greatly. Dr Preu decided that since Kaspar Hauser had been confined for many years in the dark he was a ‘night person’ who was dominated by the ‘telluric principle’, the ‘solar sphere’ of the human personality having been suppressed. The fundamental cause of Kaspar Hauser’s problems was that he had been too rapidly forced to adjust to daytime life. The transition from the ‘telluric’ to the ‘solar’ had been too abrupt. Kaspar Hauser made remarkable progress under Daumer’s supervision while still in his room in the tower under Hiltel’s supervision. Within three weeks he had learnt the elements of reading and writing, counting, adding and subtracting, and could play a few tunes on the piano. Daumer noticed, however, that this also proved to be a great strain for him. Sweat would break out on his brow and he suffered from severe headaches. The nervous tic in his face grew worse and after these initial three weeks he was utterly exhausted. Given his extremely delicate constitution, it was decided to allow him time to relax. His studies stopped; he worked in the garden, cut out paper, and was given lukewarm baths, which he much enjoyed; and riding instruction proved a great success. After he had been in Nuremberg for about six weeks he grew an astonishing two inches within four weeks. But he still remained highly sensitive and nervous and his senses were remarkably acute. He could count the number of elderberries on a branch from a distance of 100 metres and could distinguish shades of colour at dusk. His power of sight was greater in the half-light than during the day.
46
Kaspar Hauser
In August 1828 Daumer began his homoeopathic experiments on Kaspar Hauser and was assisted by Dr Osterhausen who had begun to study homoeopathy and was eager to try out various substances on such an apparently susceptible patient. Daumer placed a homoeopathic tincture in a glass which emitted a slight smell. This caused Kaspar Hauser to have severe convulsions. He developed a headache, his eyes hurt and he had a sensation which began in the eyes, ran down each cheek, both sides of the neck and joined together in his stomach. He asked to go out in the fresh air whereupon he began shivering and vomited twice. Preu remarked that had Daumer or Dr Osterhausen known anything about homoeopathy they would have administered nux vomica which, in its highest dilution, ‘would have worked wonders’. It took a long time to accustom Kaspar Hauser to eating meat. At first even a drop of broth in a watery soup caused his stomach to turn. By October 1828 he was able to digest single strands of meat. By the end of the year he could eat a small piece and then soon was able to eat meat normally. To Daumer’s delight Kaspar Hauser not only showed exceptional sensitivity to homoeopathic medicines and remarkable powers of animal magnetism but also had fascinating symbolic dreams. He could tell when Daumer stood behind him at a distance of 125 paces and pointed his hand in his direction. He could distinguish different metals that were hidden under a piece of paper. Thunderstorms caused him to shiver and shake, particularly on the left side of his body. He automatically closed his eyes and felt pressure on the chest. Lightning made his eyes hurt and caused his nose to bleed. He could tell by the temperature of his hands and feet how long a storm would last. These reactions to thunderstorms became less violent as time went by. He felt extremely uncomfortable under a full moon. He felt pressure on the chest, shivered and trembled – even in warm weather or in a well-heated room. Further evidence of his powers of animal magnetism was provided by the fact that he alone could play with Professor Daumer’s cat. Whereas this ferocious animal would not tolerate any other human being, it happily ate from his hand. When he began to eat meat regularly the cat was as aggressive towards him as it was to the rest of the household. Daumer attributed Kaspar Hauser’s extraordinary powers of perception and sensitivity to the fact that he had been kept prisoner for many years. He did not attribute them to any mystical or supernatural powers.19 He thought that the eventual loss of his extraordinary ‘magnetic and
Homoeopathic Experiments
47
somnambulistic’ powers was due to the introduction of meat into his diet. This ‘dietary materialism’, which argued that a ‘transubstantiation’ of food took place, was a widely held belief in the nineteenth century, but was in marked contrast to Daumer’s anti-materialist philosophy. Anselm von Feuerbach’s son, the philosopher Ludwig Feuerbach, for example, believed that the revolution of 1848 had failed because the people had been rendered lazy and supine by an excess of potatoes in their diet. Their revolutionary fervour could only be aroused by eating more legumes. 20 Daumer’s dietary theories were less radical. He had serious reservations about ‘cadaverous foods’ and argued that ‘people who eat a lot of meat always become brutal and less receptive to higher things. This is not the way to reach the peaks of humanity and become fully cultured as all men should strive to be.’21 In December 1828 someone who had been suffering from scabies for several years breathed in Kaspar Hauser’s face. Blisters which itched and burnt, and which were full of a yellowish liquid, appeared on the side of his face which had been breathed upon. Another person suffering from an internal disease laughed in his face causing similar blisters. Quite by chance Kaspar Hauser got some sulphur on his hands and thus on his face. The itching lessened immediately and within three-quarters of an hour the blisters had disappeared, but he fell ill for several days. Sulphur diluted one million times was held under his nose. He claimed that it smelled like alum. His face began to burn where the blisters had been. Within ten minutes a blister appeared which immediately burst. A dilution of silica smelled to him first of spirits, then of sugar, and lastly had a smell he could not describe. He went very pale, broke out in a sweat and was sick. Ipecacuanha caused him to cough, gave him pains in the chest and shortness of breath. After a sleepless night he was violently sick, whereupon he was given a minute dilution of nux vomica. This made his tongue go white and skin peeled from it. He had a painfully sore throat and another sleepless night. He was ill for several days until Daumer held a piece of blotting paper with a drop of wine on it about one pace away from his head. This seemed to cause a noticeable improvement. After a few days the old symptoms reappeared. The next experiment was with an extreme dilution of sepia. After a quarter of an hour he had difficulties in speaking and soon had a fever. After five days he seemed to be perfectly well, but about three weeks later he banged his hip on a window sill and complained of pains in his back and neck and felt extremely hot. The stopper of a bottle in which a pellet which was soaked in an extreme dilution of arnica was kept was given to him to smell at arm’s length. He had such a violent
48
Kaspar Hauser
reaction to this treatment that a bottle with a dilution of camphor was opened at some distance. This brought him some relief. The treatment was repeated and he began to get better after six days. On 18 August 1829, after seven months of homoeopathic experiments and almost continual indisposition, he was given the stopper of another bottle containing a minute amount of a dilution of lime to smell. This was designed to cause him to lose weight as he had a horror of fat people and he had grown somewhat corpulent. It caused him to cough and his breath smelled foul. Two days later he was delighted to discover that his clothes were noticeably looser. He lost his appetite and his hair began to fall out. Camphor was again used to relieve these symptoms. On 4 October he was given stoppers to smell on which there was either a drop of water or a drop of spirits. He was told that they were medicines but he could smell nothing. In the evening the stopper of a bottle containing a dilution of spirits was held at a considerable distance from his nose. It had an alarming effect on the patient which camphor, wine or coffee were unable to relieve. As a ‘half somnambulist’ he had a premonition that an attempt would be made on his life. When this actually happened on 17 October 1829 he was in a state of semi-consciousness for two days, was unable to open his eyes and had such violent paroxysms that several men were needed to hold him down. Dr Preu treated him first with a dilution of aconite. He had further convulsions and cried out: ‘It stinks, it stinks, why do you give me such ghastly stuff?!’ He quietened down after ten minutes and Preu got him to test various metals. His ability to distinguish between them was as acute as it had been when these experiments had first been carried out. One of Kaspar Hauser’s attendants was a strong and healthy man who was well disposed towards him. On 19 October he placed his hands on Kaspar Hauser’s arm. Even though Kaspar Hauser was wearing a woollen jacket he immediately felt better. When he repeated this action Kaspar Hauser fell asleep. On the following evening the result was that Kaspar Hauser was able to pass water without difficulty and then fall asleep. He had had considerable difficulties in urinating. Kaspar Hauser could only tolerate the attendant’s hands on his forearm. If they were placed anywhere else they caused considerable discomfort and headaches. Dr Preu listed other examples of Kaspar Hauser’s powers of animal magnetism. At times Kaspar was unable to tolerate the presence of Professor Daumer, and one visitor actually made him vomit. He was at first attracted to and then repelled by a cat. He was strongly attracted to
Homoeopathic Experiments
49
his image in a mirror. When Dr Preu felt his pulse Kaspar Hauser felt pain throughout his entire body. He was unable to have a bowel movement for five days after the attack. Daumer then asked Kaspar Hauser’s favourite attendant to pass his hand over a cup of water and then hold it under Kaspar Hauser’s nose. Fifteen minutes later he was able to have a satisfactory bowel movement. As late as 19 November smelling ‘magnetized’ water acted as a powerful laxative. Kaspar Hauser’s condition worsened in the middle of November 1829. He felt weak, his eyes hurt, his urine was dark red and he had no sexual drive. Daumer then administered a minute dilution of lycopodium on Dr Preu’s advice. When Kaspar smelled the stopper of a bottle which contained the liquid he felt dizzy, his eyes stung and watered. This condition was relieved somewhat by camphor. In the afternoon he smelled some cinnamon by chance and this stopped the stinging sensation in the eyes but caused his nose to run. He had a painful sensation in the penis and on the following day he had his first erection. By 15 December he no longer experienced a burning itch in his penis before having an erection. He described the sensation of having an erection as pleasant, but he appeared not to have any sexual desire and felt that an erection was pointless and unnecessary.22 When Kaspar Hauser left Daumer’s care he was no longer treated with homoeopathic medicines, except when he felt ill. The treatment with lycopodium thus stopped and he ceased to have any sexual sensation. Further homoeopathic experiments showed that rhus was effective in relieving toothache. Nux vomica was used when he felt generally unwell, particularly after having had a vivid dream reminding him of his childhood. On 9 August 1830 the medicine was administered by placing a cloth over his mouth and nose and putting his finger in a bottle containing a few drops of the liquid. He had a burning sensation in his finger and then it went numb. It felt cold, his eyes began to run, but the headache disappeared. A less dramatic effect was achieved by asking him to touch the stopper on a closed bottle containing a minute amount of the medicine. When Kaspar Hauser hurt his arm exercising on the parallel bars the surgeon would not allow Dr Preu to use a homoeopathic remedy and placed a poultice on the injured spot made of vinegar, ammonia and ammonium chloride (salmiac). The smell gave Kaspar an acute headache and caused him to vomit. He felt so wretched that he imagined that he was about to die. The following day Dr Preu removed the poultice, washed the arm to remove the smell and made Kaspar Hauser hold his
50
Kaspar Hauser
nose and mouth closed and place his right index finger over a glass containing a dilution of arnica. This caused violent spasms and he cried out in agony. After a quarter of an hour the pain disappeared and the arm only hurt when he moved it. In the summer of 1831, when Kaspar Hauser was feeling extremely run down, Professor Daumer decided to experiment with an extreme dilution of silica, in the hope that the unpleasant side effects would be minimal. The dilution was placed in an open window in a closed flask. Kaspar Hauser approached the flask with his finger pointing towards it. He reported a sensation in his arm before he even touched the flask. His body began to feel warm and after about an hour he had diarrhoea. On the second day he had four nose bleeds and his feet began to sweat – a sure sign to Dr Preu that the treatment was working. After a few days he had completely recovered and enjoyed excellent health for some time. Dr Preu gave Kaspar Hauser a dilution of opium to smell in order to test whether he had been drugged while in his cell. The dilution had a remarkable effect on him. He quickly became very drowsy and slept soundly on a sofa for an hour and a half. When he awoke he had a terrible thirst, exactly as he had had when he was confined in his cell. Dr Preu attributed his extreme irritability to the long-term effects of having been given so much opium. Dr Preu ended his report on homoeopathic experiments with Kaspar Hauser by saying that on one occasion he had opened his case containing a number of homoeopathic medicines in extreme dilutions in his presence. Kaspar Hauser froze and only when Dr Preu called his name several times did he come back to his senses. After a few minutes his nose started to bleed. The doctor repeated this action to test whether the medicines had caused this reaction, or whether it was due to other causes. The effects were identical. It is hardly surprising that Kaspar Hauser developed an intense dislike for doctors, having been subjected to such treatment. He was used as a guinea pig by cranks and amateurs who gained nothing from their experiments. He was so frightened of these experiments that it was impossible to tell whether the often violent reactions were caused by the homoeopathic medicines or by sheer terror. When he was ill the medicines he was given made him feel worse, and it seemed to him that the medical profession devoted its efforts towards torturing their unfortunate subjects and making the healthy sick. 23
4 The Search for Identity
On 4 and 7 June and 7 July 1828 the Mayor of Nuremberg, Jakob Friedrich Binder, in his capacity as head of the city’s police force, crossexamined Kaspar Hauser. No records survive of these interviews, but on 14 July the Mayor published an account of the Kaspar Hauser case, an affair which by now was widely discussed throughout Bavaria and beyond, which states what he had learnt from the foundling. Binder offered rich rewards for anyone who could shed any light on this mysterious affair. 1 The Mayor gave a detailed account of what had happened since Kaspar’s arrival in Nuremberg and pointed out the large number of ‘doctors, teachers, educators, psychologists, police officers, lawyers, the most acute observers from all classes, and the countless number of people who have taken a personal interest in his previously tragic fate’ all came to the conclusion that he was of sound mind and that his retarded behaviour was due solely to the circumstances of his youth. The Mayor said that Kaspar had been kept in a cellar with an earthen floor and a wooden roof. He had worn a loose shirt and leather breeches that opened at the back and which were held up by braces. His feet were bare. There were two small rectangular windows against which wood was piled so that sunlight never entered the cell. He had two wooden horses which were painted white, the larger one was not more than from 12 to 15 inches high. He also had a small white wooden dog. There was a container with a lid which served as a commode. He slept on a sack filled with straw. Since he could hardly walk he played with his wooden animals on the floor. There was a small door, bolted on the outside. The cellar was heated by a small, white, bee-hive shaped stove which was stoked from outside. When he woke up in the morning he found that bread and water had been placed in front of his bed, and 51
52
Kaspar Hauser
that the commode had been emptied. He claimed that his hair and nails were cut and his shirt changed while he was asleep. One day a man appeared and announced that he was the person who brought him bread and water and had given him the horses. He said that he now had to learn to read and write and that he would then bring him to his father who was a cavalryman. His gaoler warned him that there was a heaven above in which lived a god who would get angry and punish him if he tried to escape. One night the gaoler came and told him they were to leave, dressed him, and they set off up a high mountain. The stranger had to teach him how to walk which he found very difficult, especially as he was barefoot. On the third day the stranger gave him a change of clothes and a pair of boots. During their journey he tried to teach Kaspar to say the rosary, but although he could remember the Lord’s Prayer he could not remember the other prayer. They slept in the open, in spite of the cold and the rain, and lived off bread and water. When they reached Nuremberg the stranger gave Kaspar a letter and told him to go into the city and show it to ‘a lad’. Kaspar was reluctant to set off on his own, but the stranger promised that he would follow him. He found his way to the city gate, walked on until he attracted the attention of the good cobbler Weickmann. The Mayor waxed eloquent in his description of Kaspar’s sufferings, his acute sensitivity to sounds, light and smells, his inability to eat anything other than bread or drink anything other than water, his extreme nervousness and a walk that was no better than a two-year-old’s. He praised his open and honest expression, his innocence (particularly in sexual matters), his gentleness, kindness to animals, warm-heartedness, eagerness to learn, love of order and cleanliness, and the purity of his spirit. He argued that Kaspar Hauser was a thoroughly admirable young man who had been denied a normal childhood by criminals who had taken him away from his home and from a family which he assumed was of the best. Kaspar had thus been robbed of a family and fortune, the privileges of his station and the innocent delights of childhood; and he had been denied a proper education and upbringing. He was thus the innocent victim of a monstrous crime. Binder insisted that the authorities should do everything in their power to uncover this crime and promised that the city of Nuremberg would protect and nurture him as providence ordained. The citizens of Nuremberg responded generously and Kaspar was swamped with toys, clothes and books from his many well-wishers. Appended to this notice was a reproduction of the two letters Kaspar had given to the Major, a description of the boy and of the clothes he
The Search for Identity
53
was wearing when he arrived. It was noted that he spoke the Bavarian dialect of the area around Regensburg, Straubing and Landshut. His possessions were also listed. This highly unusual police notice was widely published and caused a lively reaction. Kaspar Hauser was soon known as ‘Europe’s Child’: his fate was the concern of an entire continent, not simply the city of Nuremberg.2 Kaspar had been in the tower under the protection of Hiltel for seven weeks when he was visited on 11 July by Paul Johann Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach, president of the court of appeal in Ansbach. With Friedrich Karl von Savigny he was the most brilliant and original legal mind of his generation. Born in Jena in 1775 he fled from his father’s house in Frankfurt in 1792, unable to bear the tension between his father and his father’s mistress. He sought refuge with his relatives in Jena. He studied with the Kantian Professor Reinhold in Jena and was strongly influenced by Kant and Reinhold’s criticisms of natural law. While still a student he published On the Only Possible Proofs Against the Existence and Validity of Natural Law. His reputation was secured with the Critique of Natural Law (1796) and Anti-Hobbes (1798). He argued that there was no such thing as natural law, that laws are created by men, and further that there was a clear distinction between laws and morals. He insisted that judges had to apply the law with absolute objectivity and should discount all subjective factors. It was a curious point of view for a man who held radical political views and was highly strung and emotional, frequently given to violent outbursts of moral indignation. He married in 1798 and was therefore obliged to earn a living as a university lecturer. He was offered professorships at Jena, Greifswald, Erlangen, Landshut and Kiel in 1801 and opted for Kiel. Later that year he published a Handbook of Laws Concerning Life and Limb (Lehrbuch des gemeinen peinlichen Rechts) in which he appealed for a more humane approach to justice and which made him one of the most prominent proponents of the rigorist school of jurisprudence. Although a Protestant he went in 1803 to the Catholic university of Landshut, attracted by the tolerant reforming regime of King Maximilian Joseph during whose enlightened reign Bavaria was among the most progressive of German states. He joined the department of justice in Munich in 1805, having fallen foul of some of his colleagues in Landshut, and was the moving spirit behind the Bavarian penal code of 1813 which abolished torture, and which was regarded as a model of progressive legislation. Feuerbach did not share this view. He felt that it had been amended and changed beyond recognition, and convinced himself that his work had been to no avail.
54
Kaspar Hauser
He then wrote a number of important criminological studies of the psychology of crime. His boldly stated progressive and democratic views were increasingly suspect to the authorities. It was rumoured that he was a member of the secret society The Association of the Virtuous (Tugendbund). The political pamphlets he published in 1813/14, although moderate in tone, were too much for his superiors and he was transferred to Bamberg as a punishment. In 1817 he was appointed president of the court of appeals in Ansbach. He had five sons, all of whom were exceptionally gifted. His son Ludwig became a famous philosopher, the object of Karl Marx’s scorn in his Theses on Feuerbach. Ludwig and his two brothers were arrested for their political activities which did nothing to further their father’s career. One of these two – Karl who was a brilliant young mathematician – died as a result of the ill treatment he had received in jail. Feuerbach senior died in Frankfurt in 1833, his last published work being an impassioned pamphlet on Kaspar Hauser. His son Eduard, a lawyer in Erlangen, was to carry on his father’s investigation of the Kaspar Hauser affair, but was to die suddenly in 1844. Ludwig took up where his brother left off and published his father’s papers and continued with his investigation of the case of Kaspar Hauser.3 Nuremberg came under the court of appeal of the Rezat district in Ansbach of which Feuerbach was the president. From the moment he first met Kaspar Hauser in July 1828 he was totally fascinated by the case, believing it to be ‘the most remarkable of remarkable criminal cases, the like of which is only likely to occur once in thousands of years’. 4 At the time he was involved in the publication of his book Documentary Representations of Remarkable Crimes: A Contribution to Legal and Human Science.5 It was a particularly unhappy time in his life. He suffered from bouts of profound depression and in 1827 he found it virtually impossible to read, write or even speak. His father died in March and his son Karl, who had twice tried to commit suicide, suffered an acute nervous breakdown.6 When the Bavarian government approached him to draft a new civil law he turned down the offer, in part because of his poor health, but primarily because he felt that his previous efforts had brought no positive results, and he saw no reason to believe that he would not be equally disappointed by the fruits of this new and Herculean labour. He likened the work to that of an architect who saw his building changed beyond recognition by self-willed builders and craftsmen. 7 For a while he thought that he might indeed return to his ‘youthful love’, but a fresh bout of his ‘habitual autumnal sickness’ forced him to change his mind once again. 8
The Search for Identity
55
His first visit to Kaspar Hauser was in a private capacity. He was fascinated by the case and its human and legal implications. At first Feuerbach had no idea where Kaspar Hauser might have come from and doubted whether the mystery would ever be solved. He was enormously impressed by his thirst for knowledge and his extraordinary powers of memory. He was disgusted by the way that Kaspar Hauser had been treated when he first arrived in Nuremberg. He overlooked the fact that Andreas Hiltel was a thoroughly decent and sensitive man, and snobbishly objected that he had been looked after by a simple prison warder. He had more reason to protest that Kaspar had been exhibited to the people as if he were a wild animal, and had been taken around the city’s inns as an object of scurrilous curiosity. Feuerbach had objected to such treatment and saw to it that Kaspar Hauser was placed in Georg Friedrich Daumer’s care. Daumer was a friend of Feuerbach’s philosopher son, Ludwig, and a man for whom he had the highest respect, although he feared that the good schoolmaster was impractical, eccentric, too much under the influence of Hegel’s philosophy, and was likely to be seriously misled by Kaspar Hauser’s story.9 There was so much about Kaspar Hauser’s tale which Feuerbach found improbable, unlikely and untruthful, and he felt that the persistent rumour that Kaspar Hauser was of noble birth, which had been taken up in the magazine Hesperus, was a complete fantasy.10 Since Kaspar Hauser was virtually unable to speak and had no idea of the real world, his statements were of little value.11 Feuerbach’s health remained precarious and he showed every sign of a severe depression. In April 1829 he collapsed in court and remained in a state of semi-consciousness for four hours. Although it seemed that he had suffered a stroke, his doctors insisted that his indisposition had been caused by a nervous disorder. Having rested for a while at home he set off for Frankfurt to visit his sister and thence to Wiesbaden and Mainz where he took the Rhine steamer to Holland. Lack of funds and the fear of seasickness stopped him from continuing his journey on to England. He returned in excellent spirits to the ‘cultural backwater’ of Ansbach after an absence of seven weeks.12 In his report to King Ludwig I of Bavaria of 8 April 1830 he described the popular theory that Kaspar Hauser was the legitimate Grand Duke of Baden as belonging to ‘the many rumours, some ridiculous, some absolutely false, some absolutely impossible to examine legally’ that were circulating about Kaspar Hauser. They were nothing more than ‘romantic sagas’ that no court of law could take seriously.13
56
Kaspar Hauser
In spite of these reservations Feuerbach was fascinated and charmed by Kaspar.14 He was amazed at the speed with which he learnt and at his hunger for knowledge. He got quite carried away, claiming that Kaspar Hauser was living proof of the fallacy of the doctrine of original sin. He was full of innocent virtue, even though he had no concept of good and evil. He believed that all men were essentially good, even the man who had kept him prisoner for years. He had no notion of God, and Feuerbach noted with satisfaction that he had been spared the company of priests and had not been subjected to church dogmas. He felt that Kaspar Hauser provided clear evidence that man has no innate idea of God, but learns of him either by the teachings of others or through the contemplation of nature. 15 Feuerbach’s son Ludwig, the atheist philosopher and Daumer’s friend, was also delighted to note that Kaspar Hauser had no concept of God.16 Professor Daumer, a man whose quest for the transcendental frequently took on curious forms, tried to explain the concept of God to his young pupil. He argued that there were phenomena which one knew existed, but which one could not see nor hear. Kaspar Hauser was fascinated by the fact that ideas and thoughts were without material substance. Daumer then suggested that God was a being made up of thoughts and ideas whose relationship with the world was analogous to that between the human body and the mind. Kaspar Hauser could move his arms and legs by the power of thought, just as God could move the world. A human being could move both arms and both legs, just as God was omnipresent and omnipotent. Kaspar Hauser was perplexed when he was told that God would not necessarily answer his prayers and that he had to bow to his divine purpose. Why would God not want to make his eyes better so that he could work harder and learn more? Surely that would be good for him? If God were indeed all-powerful and all good why did he not make time go backwards so that he could recover his lost childhood?17 Although he knew nothing of religion and did not want to know anything about Christianity, he was profoundly moral. When told the story of Joseph and his brothers he was shocked by Joseph’s cruelty towards his brothers. The attempt on his life in October 1829 caused a major change in his attitude. Whereas he had previously felt pity for his captor since he felt that he must have been in a state of permanent anxiety that he might be discovered, he now believed his assailant to be the same as his jailer and wished him dead. Daumer might have regretted this loss of his blind faith in the goodness of mankind, but insisted that this attack had the beneficial effect of causing him
The Search for Identity
57
to recover some of the sensitivity to metals and his powers of animal magnetism that he had possessed before he had started to eat meat. His fear and loathing of men of the cloth was as intense as his dislike of doctors. He had been visited by four ministers when he was still in the care of the Nuremberg police and living in the tower under Hiltel’s supervision. They told him that God created the world out of nothing. When he asked how this was possible they started to squabble with one another and shouted at the top of their voices, making him so nervous that he asked them to leave. He felt most uncomfortable in church and found the crucifix an unbearable sight. He was horrified by the image of a man nailed to a cross who was so obviously suffering incredible pain. He hated the noise made by the congregation when they sang, and once said of a church service that when the congregation stopped screaming the minister began to yell.18 Feuerbach felt that much of what Kaspar had said about his imprisonment and his trip to Nuremberg was obviously untrue, but attributed this to the fact that he had to tell his story when he was barely able to speak, and he imagined that he was still terrified of his captor and mindful of his warnings not to say anything of his past. He hoped that some time in the future Kaspar would be able to give a full account of his life in the cellar. He was sharply critical of the mayor’s publication of his account of Kaspar Hauser’s arrival in Nuremberg, for this made him more than ever the object of general curiosity. He was paraded around the inns of the city, plied with wine which he could not tolerate, and was subjected to all manner of humiliations by an ignorant public to the point that his health became seriously affected. Feuerbach urged the chairman of the regional council (Regierungspresident), Arnold von Mieg, to go to Nuremberg and take appropriate action to save Kaspar. It was as a result of this initiative that Kaspar was placed in the care of Georg Friedrich Daumer. Feuerbach gave an account of his first visit to Kaspar Hauser on 11 July 1828 in his book published in 1832.19 He was fascinated by the story and, since there had been no official notice of the case, decided to visit the boy in a private capacity. Kaspar was still in the Vestner tower and the public were free to come and go as they pleased and to gaze at this latest curiosity. Feuerbach went to visit Kaspar in the company of a colonel, two ladies and two children and was delighted to find him alone. He was barefoot and clad in a pair of old trousers and a shirt. He had covered the walls with pictures which visitors had brought him and the floor
58
Kaspar Hauser
was full of lead soldiers, wooden horses and dogs, along with other locally produced toys. He had been given clothes by the Nurembergers which he placed beneath his pillow and which he proudly showed the visitors. Various coins were lying on the floor, but he had no idea of their value or purpose, and Feuerbach was unable to make him understand their relative values. Kaspar appeared to be pleased to meet the visitors. He showed great delight in the colonel’s splendid uniform and golden helmet, as well as the colourful clothes of the two women. He showed no interest in Feuerbach, who was wearing a black tailcoat. He was careful to avoid the sunlight shining through the window. When it shone on his face he grimaced and was clearly in some pain. His eyes were inflamed and he frequently shook on the left side of his body, particularly his arm and hand. This was very pronounced when he was unable to understand what he was being told. When the shaking became particularly violent it suddenly stopped and he became completely rigid. His speech was very limited and often incomprehensible. He used certain words to cover all manner of objects. He used the word ‘mountain’ to describe any projecting or round object and thus referred to a fat man as ‘the man with the big mountain’. His favourite colour was red and he intensely disliked black, green and yellow. He was indifferent to white. He liked the red apples in a picture of an apple tree, but said that it would be much prettier if the leaves were also painted red. He had no sense of space and perspective and at first was unable to distinguish between an object and a picture of that object. When Daumer showed him the magnificent crucifix by Veit Stoß on the outside of the Sebaldus church he was horrified and cried out that the poor man should be brought down from the cross. He could not be persuaded that it was a carving and that the man was not real. He could not understand that distant objects appeared to be smaller than they were in fact. This phenomenon had already been discussed by Diderot in his tract on the blind.20 Kaspar Hauser was convinced that everything in nature was man made. Daumer gave him some seeds to plant and he watched them germinate with fascination. This simple experiment convinced him that he had been mistaken, but his view of nature was still very confused. When he saw a man with one eye he asked why he did not make himself another one. After all he had already made one. He could not understand why the cat did not walk on its hind legs, and was shocked that it did not use its paws to eat – in the manner of a human. When he
The Search for Identity
59
saw some oxen lying in the street he asked why they did not go home to lie down. He was disgusted that a horse urinated in public. He found it difficult to understand that his ears were part of his body and not things that were attached to it and which could be removed. When a doctor held his head in both hands he begged him not to take his head off.21 Daumer felt that Kaspar Hauser was ‘the picture of the purest goodness’ which was ‘beyond all description’ when he first arrived in Nuremberg.22 He had an absolute horror of all forms of violence. He wept copiously when he saw a small child being punished. He did not even want to kill the fleas which caused him so much discomfort when he was in the tower. He could not bare to see caged animals and thought it needlessly cruel to kill animals for their meat. Kaspar Hauser spent his days trying to write, draw and to do the exercises which the schoolmaster Daumer set for him. He complained bitterly that the constant stream of visitors interrupted his work. He expressed his desire to return to his cellar and said that he had never suffered so many pains as he had since he had arrived in Nuremberg. He had to absorb too many new sensations and was subjected to continual questioning from visitors who tried all kinds of experiments on him. He said he was prepared to stay in Nuremberg until he had learnt as much as the mayor and Professor Daumer, then the mayor should take him home and he would show the ‘man with whom he always was’ how much he had learnt. When his visitors said that the man had done him a great deal of harm he protested, ‘Man not bad. Man do me no bad!’ It was only later, when he began to appreciate all that the world had to offer, and after the attempt on his life, that he showed any anger towards his gaoler. Wondering at the beauty of a starry night he burst into tears and said that ‘the man with who he always was’ should be locked away for a couple of days to show him how hard that is. He, after all, had never shown him any such things.23 Kaspar had a remarkable memory. He could recall all the names of the people who had given him pictures and toys. One group of visitors met Kaspar, who was on his way to visit the mayor, one hour after they had been together in the tower, and he could remember all their names and titles. Dr Osterhausen later told Feuerbach that he had shown Kaspar a bouquet of flowers and named each one of them. A week later he could remember all the names. However, as time went by his memory waned. Feuerbach assumed this was because it became overloaded. In spite of all these difficulties and setbacks within three months Kaspar Hauser was able to speak coherently and reasonably fluently. He could write letters, began to understand the difference between a joke
60
Kaspar Hauser
and a serious statement, and started to play chess. By September he began to write the story of his life, but kept the manuscript hidden under his bed. During the first few months in Nuremberg his memory was phenomenal. A number of officials was soon involved in the Kaspar Hauser affair. Prominent among them were Jakob Friedrich Binder, the Mayor of Nuremberg, Arnold von Mieg, President of the district council, Josef Ludwig Count von Armansperg from the Bavarian ministry of the interior, August Alexander von Roeder from the district court, Feuerbach and his subordinates von Gruner and Johann Karl Friedrich Schumann from the court of appeal and Baron von Zentner of the ministry of justice. The affair was soon to excite the interest of King Ludwig of Bavaria. What at first had been a simple local police matter was now the concern of high government officials and was even reported in the international press. On 15 July 1828, the day after Binder had published his account of the affair, Feuerbach wrote to the district council’s department of the interior complaining that this precipitate action had seriously compromised criminal proceedings for unlawful imprisonment and the abandonment of a helpless person. Von Mieg replied on behalf of the district council that they had tried to stop the publication and had seized a number of copies of the two local papers in which it had appeared. He agreed to send Feuerbach the relevant papers on the case, but argued that criminal proceedings should not begin until Kaspar Hauser had been put in the care of a qualified educator and was able to give a coherent account of events. Mieg also wrote on the same day to the king, via the minister of the interior, giving a brief account of the affair and complaining about Binder’s publication. Count Joseph Ludwig von Armansperg, the Minister of the Interior, replied to this letter agreeing that the Mayor of Nuremberg had acted too hastily and requested to see the relevant documents. On 21 July the district council sent the documents to the court of appeal. They were returned the following day with comments by von Gruner. He argued that there were not yet sufficient grounds for a criminal investigation, and that the mayor had jumped to an over-hasty conclusion. The fact that Kaspar appeared to be healthy and his face had a good colour made it unlikely that he had spent 14 years in a cellar and had lived on bread and water alone. The doctor who examined him should be required to give a detailed account of how he had reached his conclusions. All who had been in contact with Kaspar, particularly the mayor, should make detailed statements. It should be ascertained whether Kaspar was now capable of being cross-examined. The district
The Search for Identity
61
council agreed with these remarks and complained to the mayor’s office that the police work had been extremely sloppy, that Binder’s publication was riddled with contradictions and unsubstantiated charges, and had probably tipped off the guilty party or parties. It was also suggested that Kaspar Hauser might not be always telling the truth and that he could very well be concealing valuable information for fear of the consequences. 24 Armansperg reported to the king on 23 July that an unfortunate youth had turned up in Nuremberg who had been held prisoner for years and had been given nothing but bread and water. He pointed out that his inability to speak properly and his lack of understanding of the world around him was proof positive that he was absolutely genuine. He complained about Binder’s proclamation which he felt would make the police’s work more difficult, but hastened to add that the mayor of Nuremberg had acted out of the very best of motives. 25 The first reaction of the Nuremberg authorities had been to lock Kaspar Hauser away, subject him to cross-examinations by the police, and require Hiltel to observe him closely from a hidden place. It soon became apparent that this strategy of compulsory exclusion from society failed to provide any solution to the mystery of his origins, the solution of which the mayor had made a civic duty. Compulsory integration was the more promising route. Kaspar Hauser became the ‘son of Nuremberg’ and shortly even the ‘son of Europe’, the focal point of many dreams, hopes and fantasies. But he also remained for many the outsider, the unknown, the threatening, even the criminal, and thus should be excluded from normal, ‘decent’ society. In the few years which he spent in society Kaspar Hauser was constantly threatened by compulsory exclusion or compulsory inclusion. In either case he was the predicate of another subject. This was noted by Feuerbach who reported that he said ‘Kaspar very good’ rather than ‘I am very good’ and it was no good addressing him as ‘you’ (Du), since the word was applied to so many different people. He would only answer to his name. 26 Daumer also reported that Kaspar found it very hard to understand that the various parts of his body formed part of a whole. He did not know where he ceased to be and where the outside world began. Kaspar refused to distinguish between the self and the other. To use Jacques Lacan’s phrase, he refused to leave the world of being for the world of meaning. Daumer reported that it took a long time for him to understand the concept of self and to use the word ‘I’. Looking at his portrait he remarked ‘if the nose were not there Kaspar would not be in the picture’. 27
62
Kaspar Hauser
Just as he struggled against being defined as a speaking subject he also refused to become a sexually defined subject. He much preferred women’s clothes and announced that he would like to be a girl. Feuerbach remarked that when he first met Kaspar Hauser he took no notice of him as he was wearing drab clothing. He admired the colonel who accompanied him because of his magnificent uniform with its gold braid, but he was most taken by the women in their brightly coloured dresses. When asked whom he would like to marry he replied ‘my cat’. He referred to both sexes as ‘lads’ (Bua) and never showed any interest in sex. Ludwig Feuerbach, Anselm’s philosopher son, pointed out to him that girls often had to perform tasks which got their clothes dirty. This promptly put him off the idea that a sex change would be desirable.28 Two years later he planned to get a job, earn some money and get married, but his notion of a wife was that of a housekeeper or maid whom he would dismiss if she put too much salt in the soup, did not mend his shirts properly, or failed to brush his clothes to his satisfaction. 29 All those who concerned themselves with his education saw him as a tabula rasa. They argued over what they wished to project upon this blank surface. They could believe, like Feuerbach, that it was ‘a mirror of childish innocence’, or in a more exuberant moment that was to open him to the charge of blasphemy by one reviewer: ‘as spotless and clean, the reflection of the eternal in the soul of an angel’. Others insisted, like the Ansbach teacher Meyer, that he was essentially evil. They all agreed, however, that their projections were directed upon an empty mind. Baron von Tucher said of him that ‘with his direct and natural purity and unselfconsciousness he provided the perfect picture of the first man in paradise before the fall’.30 Johann Jakob Schnerr, the Nuremberg bookbinder and magistrate, echoed Feuerbach when he said that there was no trace in him of original sin.31 Daumer found Kaspar Hauser an ideal subject for his own experiments in homoeopathy, magnetism and the occult, and conducted a number of experiments on his charge. Kaspar was able to distinguish between different metals that were hidden under sheets of paper. To make sure that the results were not due to chance Daumer, Dr Osterhausen and a visitor from Munich by the name of Brunner, tested him without there being any metal under the paper. He insisted that there was some metal at one point. He continued to insist that he was correct, even when the paper was removed. To general amazement it was revealed that there was a nail under the oilcloth that covered table at exactly the point that he had indicated. 32
The Search for Identity
63
Kaspar Hauser claimed to feel electric impulses when anyone stretched a hand out in his direction. He would turn his back to Daumer who stood 125 paces away and could tell whenever he stretched out his hand in his direction. He got cold shudders whenever someone touched him. He could clearly distinguish between the effects of the north and south poles of a magnet when they were pointed at him. Kaspar Hauser used his right hand for these experiments because he complained that his left hand was too sensitive and the sensation was uncomfortable. Daumer noted that Friedericke Hauffe the ‘Clairvoyant of Prevorst’, a well-known neurasthenic and somnambulist of exceptional magnetic sensibility, used her left hand because that was the most receptive to magnetic impulses. 33 During the night of 30 to 31 August 1828 Kaspar had a remarkably detailed dream which fascinated Daumer. During a visit to the castle in Nuremberg on 14 September Kaspar was reminded of this dream. As they entered the castle he was particularly struck by a double door; he stopped and told Daumer that it reminded him of a door in a dream he had of a ‘big house’. He said that he had dreamt of similar steps, but that they were more beautiful. When they were in the picture gallery Kaspar suddenly stopped, was lost in thought and then exclaimed that he could remember a large courtyard with a fountain in the middle and rooms all around. He said that when one opened a door one could see into several adjoining rooms. One could walk through the rooms all around the courtyard. On the steps there was a statue of a knight with a sword in his hand. The sword had a lion’s head as a handle. Later he said that there were pillars around the courtyard decorated with carvings. Steps lead down from the courtyard to the entrance gates. He thought there were four or five gates, some of which were open, through which one had to pass before entering the building. At the bottom of the steps was a circular stone, as high as the banisters, on which was a statue of a bearded man wearing a ruff and holding a sword with the point resting on the ground. There were two stories in the courtyard. On the first floor one could walk all the way round and one could see the fountain from all the doors. Each room on the top floor had 12 chairs, 3 chests of drawers and two tables, 1 in the middle and the other against the wall. In the library there were no chests of drawers. The first room one entered was the largest, but the next was the prettiest. All the rooms had mirrors with golden frames. Four of the rooms had chandeliers. In the largest room there was an oval table. The chests of drawers had bow fronts in the old Frankish style and lion’s heads as handles on the drawers. There were 2 mirrors in the library as well as a large table. One room had
64
Kaspar Hauser
a large collection of silver in cabinets with glass doors. Kaspar dreamt that he was lying on a bed in the largest room. A woman entered wearing a yellow hat with bushy feathers. She was followed by a man in a black tailcoat, wearing a hat. He had a rapier and a cross hanging from a blue ribbon around his neck. The woman approached the bed, the man behind her. Kaspar twice asked her what she wanted, but got no reply. She held a piece of white linen in her hand. The two then left. Daumer asked Kaspar whether he could remember a coat of arms in his first dream. He had no idea what a coat of arms was, but with further questioning remembered seeing something on the wall above a door. He made a simple sketch of this object which was clearly a coat of arms. The sketch showed some sort of animal and three triangular shapes. Daumer then showed him a picture of a coat of arms and asked him if it was similar to the one in his dream. Kaspar made a number of modifications to this picture in a second sketch. Kaspar had a further dream during the night of 10 to 11 November 1828. He was visited by his mother who wept copiously and called him Gottfried – a name which he claimed never to have heard before. 34 Shortly afterwards he began work on an autobiographical fragment. His verbal ability improved rapidly and once he began seriously to learn to read he no longer played with his toys. He was fascinated to learn about plant growth. As soon as Kaspar came to stay with him Daumer tried to vary his diet which hitherto had consisted solely of bread and water. First he tried a watery soup thickened with flour. The first eight attempts were unsuccessful, but at the ninth attempt Kaspar seemed to enjoy it. He ate it virtually cold, otherwise it caused him ‘to walk’ – his left arm shook violently and the little finger of his left hand twitched. Daumer remarked that a warm bath had a similar effect. The thirteenth time he was given this soup he ate it warm without having spasms and without suffering any abdominal pains. He had similar problems adapting to drinking chocolate. He drank it 20 times before becoming accustomed to it, then it gave him strength and helped him overcome his chronic tiredness. On 15 August he was given a milk pudding which he ate without any ill effects. Millet gruel had the best effect of all and seemed to give him more strength than rice pudding or semolina. He found gruel too sweet. He ate potatoes, but without salt which he could not tolerate unless it was in cooked foods. Daumer was determined to accustom Hauser to eating meat. At first a few drops of meat stock on a piece of bread, taken after meals, caused the spasms in his left arm. After a fortnight these spasms ceased, and
The Search for Identity
65
after a month he was able to eat a dessert spoonful of soup. Soon he could eat three spoonfuls and the effects on his general health were remarkable. The mayor’s office and the court of appeal followed Kaspar’s progress with lively interest since they hoped that he would soon be able to give a coherent account of his past. At the beginning of October 1829 he finished the first part of his ‘autobiography’. The autobiography is an important part in Kaspar Hauser’s effort to become a coherent subject. He constantly revised it, tearing out whole pages, reinserting them, changing the emphasis or adding fresh information. The first version tells of his imprisonment, of eating and drinking, playing with his toys and the instruction which ‘the man’ gave him. It ends with him arriving in Nuremberg and walking through the streets. Later versions tell of his visit to the Major’s house, his examination by the police and his time in the tower. His memory was imperfect and, as Schmidt von Lübeck pointed out, at first he lacked the words to describe what had happened and when he had the words his memory was imperfect. 35 Desperate attempts were made to jog his memory by reciting foreign words, taking him to visit various castles, palaces and cellars, travels to Hungary and the analysis of his more vivid dreams. All of this was to no avail and the mystery of Kaspar Hauser was never solved. He had made great progress thanks to Daumer’s efforts and to the assistance of Emmerling, a teacher in a local girls’ school who instructed him in writing, mathematics and music, and Kirchner from the polytechnic who taught him to draw. Nevertheless progress on this work was painfully slow. Having completed the first part of his story he complained that his eyes were hurting and that he was unable to continue. A dramatic event then opened a new chapter in Kaspar Hauser’s life.
5 Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes against the Soul’
In the morning of 17 October 1829 Kaspar Hauser went to visit Dr Preu. He returned home at 11 o’clock and was greeted by Daumer’s 22-year-old sister Anna Katharina who was chatting with the neighbour’s daughter. Anna Katharina then went to clean the living room on the second floor. Her mother was busy in the kitchen. At 12 o’clock she went down to the courtyard to empty a bucket of water. On the first floor staircase she was shocked to see bloody footsteps coming from the direction of the lavatory which was under the stairs. She assumed that someone had had a nose bleed, but the neighbour’s daughter suggested that it might have come from a wounded cat. Anna Katharina did some preliminary cleaning and then went to complain to her mother about the mess. Both women wondered what had happened to Kaspar Hauser. Her mother, Elisabetha Daumer, went into his room and saw that his coat was hanging on the wall and his shirt, cravat and waistcoat were on the piano. Since he usually partially undressed before going to the lavatory she assumed that this was where he had been. They looked all over the house for him without success, and he was not to be found at the neighbour’s. Elisabetha saw bloodstains on the cellar steps and although she saw something white in the corner, she did not go into the cellar because there was too much water on the floor. When Anna Katharina brought a light she suggested that the neighbour’s maid, who had come to see what was going on in the Daumer household, should have a closer look. She went down into the cellar and called out that she had found Kaspar dead. The neighbour’s son, Friedrich Haubenstricker, arrived on the scene having heard the maid call out that Hauser was dead, and went down into the cellar with her to take a closer look. They carried him 66
Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes against the Soul’ 67
upstairs to his room. He asked him what had happened and Kaspar replied, ‘Man . . . hit!’ While Friedrich went off to get Dr Preu, Kaspar lay in bed muttering, ‘Black man hit me, rang, opened, black man like in the kitchen’, and, ‘Black man hit me, on the lavatory, wanted to go up and tell mother, couldn’t find the room, went down into the cellar and hid!’ Elizabetha Daumer said that the blood stains on the wall and the door of the lavatory indicated that Kaspar had been attacked there. She assumed that by ‘black man’ Kaspar meant the chimney sweep whom he found very frightening. She wiped the blood from his face and noticed a cut, about two inches long, on his forehead. At the court hearing into the incident both women said that there had been no visitors to the house that morning apart from the milk maid, the butcher’s boy, a baker’s girl and a maid who brought back the plates from a student for whom Elisabetha Daumer cooked every day. It was assumed that she might have left the door unlocked thus enabling the assailant to enter the house unnoticed. No one could remember seeing anyone who resembled the man described by Kaspar Hauser. He said he was of medium build, wearing a new suit of dark material, yellow leather gloves and polished boots. All the witnesses pointed out that Kaspar Hauser had frequent visitors who were curious to see such a famous person. Young Haubenstricker pointed out that many people bitterly resented the fact that Kaspar was living at the city’s expense and was even getting riding lessons. Dr Preu told the court that Kaspar’s wound came from an extremely sharp instrument, but that the blow had not been particularly hard since the skull had not been fractured. He had been unable to stitch the wound because Kaspar had made such an appalling fuss that it would have needed three people to hold him down. Preu and Dr Osterhausen both testified that the wound could not have been caused by a fall. Thus the widespread rumour that Kaspar had fallen over when drunk was malicious, the more so since he could not tolerate alcohol.1 On 19 October Feuerbach visited Kaspar who begged him to protect him from his assailant. Kaspar was convinced that the man would make another attempt on his life. He had had a premonition three days before the attack that he would be murdered. In his testimony before the court he claimed that his assailant had said, ‘You will die before you leave Nuremberg!’ Feuerbach believed that those who had been responsible for keeping him prisoner had become extremely nervous on hearing of Kaspar Hauser’s remarkable intellectual development since he had arrived in Nuremberg, and had read in the newspapers that he
68
Kaspar Hauser
was writing the story of his imprisonment. They therefore had a powerful reason for wanting to have him removed. Further witnesses substantiated Kaspar’s story. A washerwoman, Barbara Maria Rupprecht, who lived opposite the Daumers, noticed two strangers coming from the professor’s house at about the time of the attack, although she admitted that neither exactly fitted the description given by Kaspar Hauser. Another woman, Christiane Übelhör, claimed to have seen a man who met the suspect’s description washing his hands at about 11.30 a.m. in a water container used by the fire brigade. A servant in the guest house Saint Peter, Johann Groß, claimed to have seen a stranger fitting the description published by the mayor’s office between 3 and 4 o’clock in the afternoon of 17 October. He appeared to be trying to avoid some soldiers who were following behind him. Lieutenant Baptist Klein of the 5th Infantry Regiment was out hunting on Monday 19 October and saw two suspicious looking characters ‘from the lower orders’ who stopped talking as soon as he approached them. One resembled the suspect. Lieutenant Hickel of the local police was ordered to search for the man described by Klein and Groß, but his efforts were to no avail. A blacksmith’s apprentice, Johann Pfauntsch, saw a powerfully built man, about 20 years old, wearing a dark overcoat and a cap, coming from the common entrance to Daumer’s and Haubenstricker’s house at about 11.15 on 17 October. Pfauntsch claimed that the man then went to visit a widowed washerwoman, Maria Margaretha Geiersberger. She told the court that this was not the case, but admitted meeting someone of a similar description that afternoon. He claimed to be a craftsman’s servant and asked for money. She gave him a penny. Margaretha Stenglin testified that she had met a stranger on 21 October as she was going to work who asked her whether a young man who had been attacked had died. She asked whom he had in mind, since she could not think what he was talking about. He replied that his name was Kaspar Hauser. She replied that as far as she knew Kaspar Hauser was still alive. He asked whether one could enter the city without being stopped at the gate, and whether there was a police poster about the attempt on Kaspar’s life. She replied that one was not stopped at the gate and that there was a notice pinned up there, but that she was unable to read. By this time they had reached the city gates. The stranger read the notice, and Margaretha went on her way to work. When she looked back she saw the man leaving the city hurriedly. The maid who came everyday to the Daumers to collect a midday meal testified that she sometimes left the door unlocked since she was
Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes against the Soul’ 69
only briefly in the house. As far as she could remember she had locked the door behind her on 17 October and she had not seen any strangers. Professor Daumer’s health, particularly his eyesight, was deteriorating rapidly. After the attack it was felt wise to find somewhere safer for Kaspar to live. Daumer’s house was also too small to accommodate the two police officers appointed by the king of Bavaria to guard Kaspar Hauser. On 17 December 1829 Kaspar Hauser was made the legal ward of Baron Gottlieb von Tucher, an official of the court who had taken particular interest in him since he had arrived in Nuremberg. Von Tucher would have liked to look after him but his mother did not want to have the policemen in the house. The city was complaining about the cost of looking after Kaspar Hauser, and Johann Christian Biberbach, a local merchant and magistrate, agreed to pay for Kaspar’s upkeep out of his own pocket. As a result of these factors he was placed in Biberbach’s care. The two policemen detailed to keep watch on him lived in Biberbach’s house. Although Kaspar Hauser was no longer living in his house Daumer continued to take a lively interest in his well-being and visited him regularly, but now he had more time to devote to his literary and philosophical pursuits. In 1850 he published the first three volumes of his Religion for a New Age, an incredible synthetic natural religion based on assiduous researches on the wilder shores of natural religion and mythology. Karl Marx poured his vitriolic scorn on the work in the Neuen Rheinischen Zeitung and there were few followers of this new religion. Daumer’s publisher, Campe, decided not to publish any further volumes of this Brobdingnagian work. In 1854 Daumer left Nuremberg, which he described as a ‘hell full of Philistines’ and moved to Frankfurt. He soon came into close contact with the city’s influential Jewish community. He toyed with the idea of converting to Judaism, but first wanted to modify the teachings concerning the Messiah and to free the religion from what he called ‘Molochism’, on which he believed the Christian blood sacrifice to be based. Hardly surprisingly his Jewish acquaintances showed little enthusiasm for these ideas which he published in book form. He soon looked for fresh fields to conquer. He now moved to a village in the Taunus hills and began contemplation of yet another new religion. This lead him to a re-examination of the life and teachings of Jesus. In 1858, on the feast of the assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary, he was received into full communion in the Catholic Church in Mainz cathedral. He published a series of works on his new religion, but remained an eccentric whose works often had to
70
Kaspar Hauser
be submitted to clerical censors. His speculations on the relationship between the Virgin Mary and the god Pan caused some concern but, although the Catholic Church was passing through a sternly conservative and authoritarian phase, its new disciple was on the whole treated with a certain indulgence. Echoes of Daumer’s confused ideas can be found among the practitioners of Lebensphilosophie, in Nietzsche and Rudolf Steiner, but he remains an obscure and minor figure. Ludwig Klages, himself both philosopher and psychologist, described him as a psychopath, and felt that his conversion to Catholicism was the result of a ‘male menopause’. This judgment may well be a trifle harsh, but Daumer was certainly a monomaniac whom his fellow-Nurembergers regarded as an ‘intelligent idiot’ whose uncritical excursions into the occult appeal principally to anthroposophists who also rate him highly because of the way he treated Kaspar Hauser whom they see as a man with a mystic mission. Daumer was obliged to defend himself against the attacks of the ‘antiHauserians’. In 1857 the Danish psychologist Daniel Friedrich Eschricht published a booklet in which he insisted that Kaspar Hauser was a simple idiot who had been educated by some strange characters in Nuremberg to the point that he was able to become a successful swindler. 2 Daumer decided to answer these insinuations and took this opportunity also to reply to Lord Stanhope’s attacks which had been published in 1835. Baron Karl von Reichenbach, the industrialist and chemist who invented paraffin and creosote, was eager to collaborate with Daumer in a book on Kaspar Hauser. He dabbled in such fashionable subjects as natural philosophy, the paranormal and magnetism and developed his own bizarre theories of ‘odian magnetism’ (odische Magnetismus), an intermediate force between electricity, magnetism, heat and light which only very sensitive persons could perceive. He felt the existence of such a force was triumphantly confirmed in Kaspar Hauser’s extraordinary initial perceptual abilities. Daumer wanted nothing to do with the Baron, believing that he simply wanted to use Kaspar Hauser to justify an esoteric theory which was too bizarre even for him.3 Meanwhile von Tucher had serious reservations about allowing his ward to live with Biberbach. He was on the city council and was totally absorbed in his commercial activities. His wife (who was over 40) was a moody creature and was reputed to be a nymphomaniac, and it was feared that she was likely to make improper advances towards the extremely bashful young man. Tucher objected to the idea vigorously in a letter to Feuerbach, pointing out Frau Biberbach’s dubious morals. 4
Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes against the Soul’ 71
The city fathers of Nuremberg who had come under considerable public criticism for their bountiful treatment of Kaspar Hauser were anxious to save money, so it was agreed he could stay with the Biberbachs. As von Tucher had predicted, Kaspar Hauser was alarmed and disgusted by Frau Biberbach’s salacious advances, and from the very beginning of his stay on 30 January 1830 relations between the two were extremely tense. In the 18 months since Kaspar had arrived in Nuremberg the police investigation into his origins had reached a dead end and the case was virtually closed. With this mysterious attack it was reopened. The police officer Hüftlein, who had questioned Kaspar Hauser on his arrival in Nuremberg, was called upon to write an official report on the incident. He went to Daumer’s house but was unable to speak to Kaspar who was suffering from paroxysms. Daumer’s mother showed him the bloodstains which he carefully noted. He then listed all the measures taken, ruefully noting that none had brought any results.5 The king of Bavaria was informed on 24 October 1829 that a murder attempt had been made on Kaspar Hauser, and that no clues had been found. The letter pointed out that he was making remarkable progress in his studies particularly in music and drawing. King Ludwig responded to this letter on 4 November by ordering that Kaspar should be given police protection since it was highly probable that yet another attempt would be made on his life. It was assumed that the criminals who had kept him prisoner were now determined to ensure that their whereabouts were not discovered.6 Shortly afterwards the king offered the extremely generous reward of 500 florins for anyone who produced information which led to the apprehension of the guilty party, and repeated that Kaspar had to be properly guarded to avoid another attempt on his life. Feuerbach and the court of appeal stressed the importance of the case, published an account of the crime, and repeated the king’s offer of a reward. 7 The investigation was in the hands of Baron von Roeder who questioned a large number of witnesses and who travelled many miles in the bitter Bavarian winter in search of information. The results were very disappointing. No clues were unearthed to indicate a possible assailant, and a re-examination of the witnesses to Kaspar’s arrival in Nuremberg spread further confusion. Many of them contradicted their earlier statements, a fact which was exploited by Lord Stanhope when he questioned them again in 1834 and, by using leading questions, provided further ammunition for his case that Kaspar Hauser was a fraud. Kaspar was cross-examined about his childhood on 6, 7 and 9 November 1829. 8 He said that he could only remember being in his cell.
72
Kaspar Hauser
He described it as being 6 or 7 feet (Schuh) by 4 feet and 5 feet high. The floor was of beaten sand. Half of the floor was covered in straw which served as his bed. There was a receptacle with a lid and a removable earthenware pot inside, placed in a slight hollow in the ground, which served as a commode. There were two windows, 8 or 9 inches square. The walls were dark and probably made of sandstone. It was permanently dark, so that he was unable to distinguish between day and night and developed an unusual ability to see in the dark. He found daylight extremely bothersome when he was released from captivity. The temperature remained constant and caused him no problems. There was a small door which was fastened on the outside. He was given nothing but black rye bread and water. The bread, although often very hard, was at least plentiful, but he complained that he often did not get enough water. Sometimes the water tasted unpleasant and made him go to sleep. He wore short leather breeches, open at the back, woollen bracers and a shirt, and his legs were covered with a white woollen blanket. During his waking hours he played with his two wooden horses and his dog. Eight or nine days before he was taken to Nuremberg a stranger appeared three times, at about three-day intervals. The first time he had said nothing, but had tried to show Kaspar how to write the alphabet and his name. The second time he taught him the word for ‘horse’. He said, ‘Your father is in the big village. You will get a beautiful horse.’ Kaspar was also taught to say, ‘I wanna be a sixfer (sixth?) cavalryman like wot my father were.’ The third time the stranger came and told him that it was time to go. He carried him on his back with Kaspar’s hands tied together around his neck with a white cloth. It was still dark outside and Kaspar soon fell asleep. When he awoke he was lying on the ground. The man forced him to get up and tried to teach him to walk. This Kaspar found very painful and he complained bitterly of the pain. The man said that if he stopped walking he would not get a horse. He repeated the sentence ‘I wanna be a sixfer cavalryman like wot my father were’ over and over again so that he could remember it. He was told to look at the ground and to pay no heed to what was going on around him. They walked through the cold and the rain, but Kaspar was unable to say for how many days. He assumed that it was not very far, since he was barely able to walk. He could not remember having seen a river or a stream, nor a bridge or any form of water. They never went downhill. They walked all the time on footpaths and avoided the highway. One day the stranger gave Kaspar a change of clothes. He stood behind him while he changed so that he could not see him. He gave Kaspar a letter
Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes against the Soul’ 73
and told him he should take it ‘where it belonged’. Suddenly Kaspar found himself alone in the city. Then he met the shoemaker Weickmann. On further examination Kaspar said that he had never stood up in his cell and that he had only been visited on three occasions by the stranger. He had never seen anyone bring his food, empty the commode or change his clothes. Nor could he remember seeing anyone cut his hair or his nails, although he was regularly groomed. He was convinced that the man who had attacked him on 17 December 1829 was the same man who had brought him to Nuremberg 18 months before. Kaspar’s story was so fantastic that many people thought that he must be a fraud. Prominent among the earlier sceptics was Johann Friedrich Merker, a criminologist and journalist from Berlin, who had read about the case in the newspapers, but who had never met Kaspar. Another prominent sceptic was Georg Philipp Schmidt von Lübeck. Merker published an attack on Kaspar in 1830 and Schmidt von Lübeck followed suit in the following year.9 The court felt that the best way to deal with these rumours was to get detailed medical reports so that they had hard facts and did not have to rely solely on the subjective account given by Kaspar Hauser, made first when he could speak only a few words, and whose later testimony could very well have been influenced by those around him. Dr Preu’s report was presented on 3 December 1830. He described Kaspar as being 5 feet 4 inches tall (having been a mere 4 feet 9 inches when he first arrived) with blue eyes, light brown hair, a round flat face with a small nose, a delicate white skin and weak muscles. The scar from his attack was 1.75 inches long and there were a number of other scars caused by falls and by a pistol shot – the result of an accident in April. He had a vaccination mark on his right upper arm. His genitalia were fully developed and the pubic hair was abundant. He was uncircumcised. He had no idea about sex and when he was given powdered licopodium he awoke every morning with an erection. He found the sensation most unpleasant and complained about it to the schoolmaster Meyer, with whom he was now lodging. He was not consoled when told that this was a normal and healthy sign. His knee joints were somewhat deformed so that when sitting on the ground with his legs stretched out in front of him the back of the knees touched the ground. While sitting in this position he could move his arms about freely without bending his back. He was unable to stand on one leg, since this caused him considerable pain in the hips. His feet began to hurt badly when he walked for more than three-quarters of an hour. Dr Preu noted that his sense of smell was unusually acute. He
74
Kaspar Hauser
could see remarkably well in the dark and his hearing was so sensitive that loud noises, such as military music, caused him considerable pain. When thinking, or trying to remember something, the left side of his face and body began to twitch and he became oblivious to everything around him. The smell of diluted homoeopathic medicines from several paces caused him to break out in a sweat and to shiver, and caused numbness. He could not tolerate coffee, beer or wine and detested herbs and spices other than coriander, caraway, anise and fennel which had been mixed in the bread he had been given while in his cell. He was particularly fond of caraway. Dr Preu took all this as strong evidence that he had indeed spent a long time in a cell, been given an extremely primitive diet, had been denied normal stimuli to the senses, and had spent a long time sitting on the floor. Dr Preu insisted that Kaspar had a remarkable degree of ‘animal magnetism’ and that metals had a profound effect on his nervous system, even from a considerable distance. He was more affected by the terrestrial (tellurian) than the heavenly (sidereal). As soon as he began to eat meat he lost this sensitivity. Dr Osterhausen presented his report on 31 December 1830. It further substantiated Dr Preu’s description. He noted that Kaspar had been able to distinguish between various metals when they were covered by a piece of paper from a distance of two or three inches. Gold had the strongest effect on him and he found the sensation most unpleasant. When shaking hands he felt quite distinct sensations with different people. Most of the time he found this unpleasant. Once he started to eat meat these sensations ceased. He was able to wear a gold ring without noticing it and could shake hands without experiencing any discomfort. Dr Osterhausen assumed, on the basis of experiments conducted by a young officer, von Pirch, that Kaspar’s mother tongue was either Hungarian or Polish. If it had been German he felt that he would have been able to say more about his earliest childhood. The attempt on his life and the medical evidence caused Feuerbach to change his mind about Kaspar Hauser. Although he had been greatly attracted to the boy, he was initially sceptical about tales of his noble birth. He now became the most outspoken and enthusiastic partisan for the foundling’s cause. In his book on Kaspar Hauser, published in 1831, he hints that the foundling might be of noble birth. From the notes he made for the book it is clear that he thought that Kaspar Hauser was indeed the legitimate Grand Duke of Baden. 10 On 27 January 1832 he wrote to the queen dowager of Bavaria, Caroline, suggesting that Kaspar Hauser was the object of a crime against
Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes against the Soul’ 75
the crown.11 In February that year he wrote to the court preacher von Schmidt in Munich asking him to arrange an interview for Police Lieutenant Hickel with Queen Caroline so that he could give her a full account of his suspicions. 12 On 4 February he wrote a long letter to Lord Stanhope in which he answered some of the objections to the theory that Kaspar Hauser could be a prince of Baden. 13 Later that month he sent Queen Caroline his memoir on the Kaspar Hauser affair in which he insisted that circumstantial evidence pointed to him being the rightful Grand Duke. He was careful to point out that such circumstantial evidence, based on a number of reasonable assumptions, was not enough to convince a court of law, but pointed out that rumours (famam publicam) are used by lawyers as evidence of crimes, even though that evidence may well be circumstantial. He argued that Kaspar Hauser must have been a legitimate child since no one would go to such extraordinary lengths to hide an illegitimate birth. It could be safely assumed that those who were responsible for the crime had substantial means at their disposal. Three years of intensive search and the offer of a handsome reward had shed no light on the case. An attempt on Kaspar’s life had been made in broad daylight in the crowded city of Nuremberg without a single reliable witness coming forward. All this indicated that people of wealth and influence were behind the crime. It further seemed obvious that Kaspar Hauser was a person whose fate was of considerable importance, otherwise nobody would risk their lives by becoming involved in such a crime. It was not possible that either revenge or hatred were motives, but rather personal advantage. Kaspar Hauser had to be removed so that others should profit from his inheritance. The remarkable dreams which Kaspar Hauser had in Nuremberg were taken to be further indication that he must be of noble birth, since these dreams revived memories of his earliest youth. The castle or palace of which he dreamt was unlike anything he could have seen in Nuremberg, and Feuerbach insisted that the lions’ heads, or lions, in his dream were of particular significance. Kaspar Hauser’s cell was kept remarkably clean and he was kept well groomed. His food was very simple but adequate. He was provided with toys. His guardian could well have killed him with an overdose of opium had he so wished, and his simple food was dictated by the need not to cause any probing questions in the community. Kaspar Hauser always spoke kindly of ‘the man with whom he always was’. It could thus be safely assumed that the man was his saviour who hid him from those who wished him dead. Feuerbach thought that the fact that Kaspar Hauser had some
76
Kaspar Hauser
religious pamphlets with him indicated that his captor was probably a Catholic priest or monk. Feuerbach now assumed that since there was no noble family from which a child had been kidnapped Kaspar Hauser had been exchanged in infancy for another baby which had died shortly afterwards. There was also indication that Kaspar Hauser had lived for a while in relatively normal circumstances, possibly in Hungary, before he was imprisoned. The motive for this imprisonment was to hide him from those who were determined to kill him. Feuerbach concluded that only ‘the house of B’ came in question. The two sons of the Grand Duke of Baden had died in infancy whereas the three daughters were perfectly healthy. Their death enabled another’s sons to be in the line of succession since females were excluded. The note which Kaspar Hauser brought with him to Nuremberg said that he had been born on 30 April 1812 and was given to the unknown person on 7 October that year. The oldest prince of Baden was born in 1812 and died on 16 October. The second prince of Baden was also born on 30 April. The differences in the October dates were hardly significant. Thus what Feuerbach had previously dismissed as a wild fantasy he now accepted as a likely truth. 14 Feuerbach had elaborated his ideas about admissible evidence in his classic Handbook of Laws Concerning Life and Limb (Lehrbuch des gemeinen peinlichen Rechts), the eleventh edition of which he published in 1832. According to him a legal judgment was based firstly on ‘grounds for suspicion’ (Vermutung) which included police reports and clues, and secondly on ‘grounds for judicial certainty’, based on clear evidence. He defined certainty as a situation in which ‘all those reasons are given which are needed in order to assume that an event really happened’. He distinguished, however, between ‘judicial’ certainty and ‘moral’ certainty. Judicial certainty is based on existing laws of evidence, whereas moral certainty rests on reason. Feuerbach assumed that judicial certainty could not exist without moral certainty, largely because the rules of evidence were so stringent. The Bavarian criminal law of 1813, which was largely Feuerbach’s work, demanded that before a witness’s testimony could be admitted in court it had to be corroborated by a second equally credible witness. 15 Thus although Feuerbach was convinced that Kaspar Hauser was the Grand Duke of Baden as a lawyer he knew he could not prove it. Feuerbach felt that circumstantial evidence could well form the basis of ‘judicial certainty’. Other contemporary jurists argued that circumstantial evidence could establish likelihood but never certainty. Feuerbach insisted that each individual piece of circumstantial evidence had to fit
Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes against the Soul’ 77
logically together for it to be admissible, but this was certainly not the case with his argument that Kaspar Hauser was the Grand Duke of Baden. The only pieces of circumstantial evidence that Feuerbach had were that the Hochberg family had an interest in removing the Grand Duke of Baden’s sons so that they might succeed to the throne, that Kaspar Hauser had had a dream that might be interpreted as indicating that he was of noble birth, and that he had been kept prisoner for a number of years. There was no evidence that the Grand Duke’s son had been exchanged for a dying infant and thus no reason to suppose that Kaspar Hauser was indeed his son. Feuerbach’s argument did not even meet the criteria he himself had laid down for admissible evidence. Paragraph 192 of the Bavarian criminal code made forcible restraint a criminal offence. Paragraph 193 provided for up to eight years of penal servitude (Arbeitshaus) as punishment if the victim was kept prisoner for four years. If the period of imprisonment exceeded four years the offender was to be sent to jail (Zuchthaus). Paragraph 194 called for corporal punishment if the victims had been physically mishandled.16 Feuerbach argued that paragraph 194 only dealt with physical mistreatment whereas the Kaspar Hauser case was one of ‘the denial of all means of intellectual development and education, the unnatural preservation of a human soul in a state of animal stupidity’. 17 The problem was that the Bavarian criminal code made no provision for psychological mistreatment or, to use Feuerbach’s term, ‘crimes against the soul’. Article 182 only considered ‘raving, madness, idiocy and similar psychological disorders’ as grounds for prosecution when these disorders were the result of physical mistreatment, which was to be punished accordingly.18 Punishment was to be based on the principle of reciprocity (Talionsprinzip). The victims had been forcibly restrained: the culprit would therefore be imprisoned. The victim had suffered physical mistreatment: the culprit would also suffer corporal punishment. Paragraphs 174 to 177 of the Bavarian criminal code deal with the abandonment of children. In most criminal codes only the parents were held responsible for the abandonment of their children (exposito infantum), but the Bavarian code was progressive in this respect in that paragraph 174 spoke not only of children but also of all those who were in need of care and who were abandoned by those who were responsible for them. The problem here was that it was not at all clear what obligations and responsibilities Kaspar Hauser’s keeper had towards his charge and therefore in what sense he had violated paragraph 174. Nor had there been any serious risk to his life as foreseen in paragraphs 175 to 177. The danger had been to what Feuerbach described as his ‘mental life’.
78
Kaspar Hauser
Feuerbach had some difficulty in defining what he meant by a crime against the mental life of a victim. Kaspar Hauser had, after all, suffered no long-term disabilities. He was not cretinous, nor seriously disturbed, and had been able to make up much of the lost ground. Feuerbach was thus speaking of damage without a corpus delicti. He had to argue that Kaspar Hauser had been robbed of his childhood, and that was something that could not be given back to him. His real childhood began when he was already physically mature. It also meant that he had to be shown to be permanently retarded in his mental development, even though he was able to function adequately. The concept of ‘crimes against the soul’, or ‘mental crimes’, had first been adumbrated by Regnerius Engelhard in the eighteenth century. He was a pupil of one of the outstanding jurists of the day, Christian Wolff, and attempted to apply his teacher’s notions of natural law to criminal law. 19 Engelhardt included the spreading of ‘error’ and the publication of harmful books as crimes against the soul. Thus his concept of this misdemeanour was essentially religious. Carl August Tittmann, a Saxon contemporary of Feuerbach’s, argued in his De delictis in vires mentis humanae commissis of 1795 that crimes against the ‘mental powers’ (Geisteskräfte) were sui generis and had to be distinguished from physical injury or acts that were damaging to a victim’s health.20 Tittmann argued that mental powers should be protected by the law, in the same manner as such traditional notions as physical integrity and honour. An act which served to hinder the development of an individual’s intellectual abilities, or which harmed or impeded such abilities which were already fully developed, should be considered a crime. He expressly excluded Engelhard’s ‘crimes against the soul’ since he did not believe that a dubious book or a questionable doctrine could permanently damage the psyche. He argued that physical abuse, poison, the withholding of sensory perception, the separation of an individual from human contact, the refusal to teach a child to speak or the systematic ‘education in stupidity’ were as much crimes as the refusal to feed babies and small children. Tittmann argued that for there to be a ‘crime against the powers of the mind’ (Geisteskräfte) there had to be evidence either of idiocy (fatuitas) or of madness (delirium). The obvious problem was how to establish whether or not such severe disturbances were the result of a crime, but he argued that by including medical evidence it should be possible to establish the degree to which these disorders had been exacerbated by external causes. Since Tittmann regarded such crimes as a form of mental murder he argued that they should be punished with the death penalty.
Anselm Ritter von Feuerbach and ‘Crimes against the Soul’ 79
A number of commentators supported Tittmann, but others merely pointed out that since such a crime did not exist in German criminal codes laws concerning acts harmful to an individual’s health or poisoning would have to suffice. His critics pointed to the impossibility of establishing the degree to which a victim’s mental powers had been affected by the purported crime. It also had to be shown that there was no possibility of recovery, just as for a murder to have taken place the victim had to be shown to be truly dead.21 Salchow argued that if a mad person were no longer considered fully human, his human nature having been destroyed by the madness, then it was no more of a crime to kill a madman than to kill a horse or a dog. He still believed that ‘mental crime’ should be a capital offence, not because it amounted to murder, but because it was analogous to murder in that it robbed an individual of an inborn and irreplaceable gift.22 Feuerbach had hardly concerned himself with these problems before he was confronted with the case of Kaspar Hauser. In his Revision of the Fundamentals and Essential Ideas of the Positive Law of Life and Limb of 1800 he spoke of a right to the full use of one’s mental powers (Gemütskräfte) along with the right to health and physical freedom, but he made no attempt to define what he meant by this idea. 23 He also mentioned the concept in his textbook of 1832, but again only in passing, and in such a way as to suggest that he was in the camp of Tittmann’s critics. 24 Mental crimes were subsumed under bodily harm, and the emphasis was on the causes of any disturbance. This was very much in the spirit of the Prussian code of law in which madness, sickness or ‘unhappiness’ resulting from physical abuse or poisoning were regarded as serious crimes, in certain cases to be punished with death. Mental crimes were thus not seen as being in a separate category from bodily harm.25 The Saxon criminal code also contained similar provisions. The section on ‘crimes against health’, the ‘damaging of mental powers and hindering their development’, rendering permanently mad or hindering the intellectual development of a child states that the culprit could be punished with up to 20 years’ imprisonment.26 Once Feuerbach began to ponder the case of Kaspar Hauser he changed his views radically and found himself in broad agreement with Tittmann and Salchow. Whereas for Tittmann there had to be evidence of idiocy or madness, Feuerbach now felt that this was far too restrictive a definition. Kaspar Hauser, after all, was neither idiotic nor mad, but was obviously the victim of a crime that was far more serious than imprisonment. The crime that had been committed against him was
80
Kaspar Hauser
that he had been robbed of his childhood, and that was something which could never be returned to him. Daumer did not subscribe to Feuerbach’s fanciful theory. Although he thought that Kaspar Hauser was almost certainly of noble birth – the circumstances of his arrival in Nuremberg and the attempt on his life suggested that this was the case – unlike Feuerbach he was not particularly interested in the question of his birth. He saw Kaspar Hauser as a fascinating example of natural man, and it was of little concern to him whether the ‘Myth of Franconia’ was the son of a prince or a pauper. He was, however, greatly concerned that he himself might become the target of assassins hired by a princely house anxious to cover its bloodstained tracks. Feuerbach said that it was ‘fear of poison and the dagger’ that stopped his friend Daumer from publishing a manuscript he had written on the Kaspar Hauser affair.27 Were this the case Daumer soon overcame any such fears and published his first piece on the Kaspar Hauser affair in 1832. 28
6 Philip Henry, Lord Stanhope
Kaspar stayed with Biberbach from January to July 1830. By now he was an international celebrity, his story published in newspapers in London, Paris, New York and Philadelphia. Inevitably there was a flood of rumours and ingenious theories as to his parentage. In April 1830 Feuerbach, on behalf of the court of appeal in Ansbach, reported to the king of Bavaria that a Hungarian priest claimed that he knew where and by whom Kaspar had been kept prisoner in Bavaria. On 27 March a Prussian guards’ officer, Otto von Pirch, arrived in Nuremberg, talked to Kaspar Hauser and claimed that he had evidence that he had spent some time in Hungary.1 Lieutenant von Pirch, who was on his way back to Potsdam where he was stationed, having visited Hungary and Italy, was cross-examined by the court on 30 March 1830. He said that he had become interested in the case having read about it in the Hungarian press. He had visited Kaspar on 27 March and asked him whether he recognized the words for ‘one’, ‘two’ and ‘three’ in Hungarian. Kaspar thought hard for a while and replied that he had heard them before ‘as if in a dream’. He then asked him if he recognized the word for ‘hundred’. He answered that it was a large number. When von Pirch swore ‘basmana remtete!’ Kaspar shrank in horror and said that ‘the man’ had said that twice when they were on their way to Nuremberg and once when he hit him. He recognized the Polish word ‘matka’ as mother and his face lit up. He also recognized ‘ociec’ as father, but added that he had not heard the word very often. He claimed to have heard the Polish expression ‘Buzirscz moi Kochan, buzirscz moi chlopek‘ (Come, my dear, come, my boy!) from his nursemaid. He was very shocked at ‘Boi foi mat!’ and said it was a very bad word. Although Tucher felt that Kaspar was far too excited after this experiment he eventually allowed Pirch and Binder to conduct one further 81
82
Kaspar Hauser
test. They placed some corn on the cob on the table in front of him to see how he would react, since children in Hungary often played with corn. Kaspar said he could remember seeing corn in his earliest childhood and claimed that his nursemaid used to work with corn. Pirch asked Biberbach’s daughter Klara to bring two paving stones between which she placed a number of cobs and began to grind them. Kaspar exclaimed that that was the way they used to prepare corn while he was in his nursemaid’s arms. Von Pirch, who was a highly educated and charming man, made a considerable impression on the court and his testimony was corroborated by Johann Jakob Schnerr, a member of the town council and a book binder to whom Kaspar Hauser was briefly apprenticed and who had arranged the meeting with Kaspar Hauser. His legal guardian, Baron von Tucher, and Biberbach both verified Pirch’s statement. Kaspar took to him immediately and wept copiously when he took his leave. On 3 April Kaspar had another accident. He fell while climbing on a chair to reach some books on a shelf. As he fell he tried to grab the panelling but got hold of a pistol which was hanging loaded on the wall. The pistol went off and the ball scraped his head just above the right ear. He fell to the ground where he lay unconscious. The two policemen who had been designated to guard him were in the next room. Hearing the shot they hastened to his assistance. Kaspar was soon revived. The pistol was still hanging on the wall and the powder burns on the wall indicated that his account of this misfortune was absolutely accurate. By this time the Biberbachs were getting tired of Kaspar. They felt that since he had become the object of general attention, praise and flattery, particularly after he was attacked, he had become self-indulgent, ungrateful and a liar.2 Tucher became very disturbed at Kaspar’s worsening condition which he attributed to conditions in the Biberbach household. Biberbach was fully occupied with his business affairs and Kaspar’s education was being neglected. Klara Biberbach was hovering on the brink of insanity and was to end her life by hurling herself out of a window a few years later. Tucher was also fully aware of the tensions between the Biberbachs and their charge. On 15 July 1830 he decided to look after the boy himself in his house in the Burgstraße 5 for six or seven weeks. In fact Kaspar stayed for a year and a half. The city of Nuremberg provided 300 guilders for Kaspar Hauser, but this did not cover Tucher’s costs. Feuerbach, Tucher, Otto von Pirch and the jurist, colleague, friend and biographer of E. T. A. Hoffmann, Julius Eduard Hitzig, latched onto the idea of Kaspar Hauser as ‘Europe’s Child’ and planned a European subscription campaign to collect money
Philip Henry, Lord Stanhope
83
for the foundling.3 Nothing came of the idea, in part because Merker’s pamphlet attacking Kaspar Hauser was widely read and the adverse publicity made a successful subscription campaign unlikely. On 9 August 1830 Tucher continued the language experiments which von Pirch had begun. He invited Dr Moritz Gottlieb Saphir to meet Kaspar Hauser. Saphir was a Hungarian-born writer of humorous sketches who lived in Munich and who had read of Pirch’s experiments. He came in the company of the bookseller Eichhorn, and tried to see whether Kaspar could understand Hungarian. Kaspar realized that he was speaking the same language as von Pirch. He then claimed that Saphir had asked whether he would like to go for a walk, adding that he used to ask his wooden horse the same question when he was in his cellar. He recognized another sentence as ‘do you want to go to papa?’ Saphir recited a list of Hungarian place names. Kaspar was particularly excited about Poschamba (Pressburg), and said that his nursemaid had often referred to the place and used to say ‘papa has gone to Poschamba’. He became so upset and pained that the meeting had to be brought to a halt. Saphir returned the following day for breakfast. Kaspar seemed exhausted after the previous day’s excitement and had a headache. He claimed to recognize some words and tried to speak a few words himself. Most were incomprehensible except for ‘Motschär’ which Saphir said did not exist in Hungarian, not even as a place name. 4 In the spring of 1831 the city fathers of Nuremberg ordered an officer of the Gendarmes, Lieutenant Joseph Hickel, to make a careful search for a likely place where Kaspar Hauser might have been hidden. Since he had said that the journey on foot had taken about three days it was assumed that he had been kept within a 40-kilometre radius of the city. Hickel was unable to find any clues and ended his search on 28 May. The experiments in Hungarian were reported in the press and excited considerable interest. A Hungarian professor suggested that Kaspar should make a trip to Hungary. Two trips were eventually financed by a strange Englishman who was to play a critical role in the life of Kaspar Hauser, Lord Stanhope, who arrived in Nuremberg on the same day that Lieutenant Hickel ended his search. Philip Henry, Lord Stanhope, was born on 7 December 1781. His father Charles was a brilliant but emotionally unstable man. His greatest achievement was the invention of an iron printing press, and a light twoor four-wheeled open carriage was named after him. He was a close friend of William Pitt the younger whose sister, Lady Hester Pitt, he married in 1774. Their first child was Lady Hester Stanhope, the delightfully dotty
84
Kaspar Hauser
‘Queen of the Arabs’ who ended her days as an oriental despot, mystagogue and prophetess living on Mount Lebanon with two magnificent horses ready to ride with the Messiah to the Holy City. Charles’s wife died in 1780 at the age of 25 having borne him two further daughters. Shortly after her death Charles married her cousin Louisa Grenville. It was not a happy marriage. Louisa Stanhope was emotionally cold and stiff and brought out the worst in her husband. He became domineering, ill-tempered and brutal, and treated his children abominably. Louisa was seldom at home and devoted all her energies to London’s hectic social life. Her stepdaughter Lucy once remarked that if she met her in the street she doubted that she would recognize her. Louisa promptly bore Charles an heir nine months after their marriage. Philip had three younger brothers, Bank who died in the year of his birth, Charles Bank and James Hamilton. Charles’s godfather was Lord Chesterfield, the author of the egregious Letters to His Son, a work that caused no little amusement to those who knew that the son in question was in fact the product of a passionate liaison between his father’s fiancée, Petronella Melusine von Schulenburg, the illegitimate daughter of George I, and the captain of the ship in which she travelled from Holland to marry the 5th earl. Charles Stanhope became increasingly eccentric and difficult. His enthusiastic support for the French Revolution was treated with derision in the House of Lords and provided rich material for the caricaturists. Although a very rich man he imposed a harsh regime of austerity upon his household at Chevening in Kent. All luxury items were removed, his children were clad in the simplest of clothing, Lady Hester was required to tend the turkeys and the boys were apprenticed to the local blacksmith. The children’s tutor Jeremiah Joyce was chosen for his revolutionary enthusiasm rather than his pedagogic ability with the result that he was arrested for high treason in 1794 and spent 23 weeks in the Tower of London. His release was celebrated in Charles Stanhope’s progressive Masonic lodge at the Crown and Anchor. Joyce was succeeded by Dr Crawford, a foul-mouthed and violent Freemason who made Philip Henry’s life utterly miserable. Lady Hester managed to escape from the stifling atmosphere of Chevening and lived in her Prime Minister uncle’s exciting household. Philip Henry appealed to her for help. Pitt, Sir Francis Burdett, a fabulously wealthy radical politician who had married into the Coutts banking family and who had an enormous popular following, and Francis Jackson, a young member of the diplomatic service, appealed to the father to treat his son better. The effect of this well-intended intervention was
Philip Henry, Lord Stanhope
85
that Philip Henry was placed virtually under house arrest with the dreadful Dr Crawford watching his every move. Flight now seemed the only way out of what all agreed was an intolerable situation. Lady Hester and her co-conspirators, the Prime Minister, Burdett and Jackson, agreed that Philip Henry should be sent to university in Erlangen, a small, socially exclusive and exacting seat of learning, in an attempt to make up for a woefully inadequate education. Erlangen was chosen because Karl Alexander, Margrave of Ansbach-Bayreuth, who had abdicated and lived in London, was well known to Pitt, and the widowed magravine was prepared to receive Philip Henry at her modest court. Francis Jackson provided Philip Henry with a forged passport in the name of Mackwell, Burdett put up the money to finance the flight, and a Mr Rice was chosen to accompany the fugitive. The escape was made to Hamburg by way of Harwich. Philip Henry bought a coach in Hamburg and set forth to Celle and Hanover and on to Leipzig. After a fortnight of travelling around Germany the party arrived in Erlangen and Philip Henry lodged with Professor Breyer who was awaiting his arrival. Philip Henry Viscount Mahon was then matriculated at the university. Although he wrote fulsomely of his determination to study assiduously and spoke warmly of Professor Breyer, there is little indication that he did much work, and after eight months he suddenly moved from Breyer’s house to the more congenial quarters of the widow Gelly. It was a move that shocked Professor Breyer and occasioned much gossip. Philip Henry was soon heavily in debt and his prospects of a handsome inheritance dwindled as his father tottered on the brink of bankruptcy. Lady Hester had no difficulty in persuading Pitt and Jackson that her half-brother badly needed a career. But what could he do? Jackson was impressed by Philip Henry’s vivid reports of life in Germany and suggested that he could be usefully employed as a political agent. For the time-being Philip Henry was not informed of these plans for his future, and alarming reports of his irresponsible behaviour must have caused some doubts as to whether he would ever be of much service to his country. In 1802 Lady Hester met her brother in Baden-Baden, which gave him his first and abiding taste for the world of fashion and court intrigue. Later that year they met in Lyon and began a tour of Italy. Relations between the two were strained. Lady Hester found her brother to be an insufferable know-all and was contemptuous of his absurdly dandified clothing and his tiresome little poodle which was his constant companion. Philip Henry was appalled at his sister’s lack of interest in art galleries and architecture, and found her fascination with the daily
86
Kaspar Hauser
lives of ordinary Italians embarrassingly vulgar. Their ways soon parted. Lady Hester decided to winter in Italy, Philip Henry returned to England. In typical Stanhope fashion they soon became bitter enemies, Philip Henry referring to his sister as ‘my bitter and implacable enemy’. 5 Having been disowned by his father he pleaded with his uncle William Pitt for support. As Warden of the Cinque Ports, Pitt was able to provide him with the position of deputy warden of Dover Castle, an appointment which gave him an extremely modest income and a roof over his head. Shortly after his return to England Philip Henry married Catherine Lucy Smith, the fourth daughter of Robert Smith, 1st Baron Carrington. Lady Holland described her as ‘that odd, but lively, agreeable and good humoured wife of an odd but far from agreeable husband’. 6 Unable to provide adequately for his young bride he appealed to his father for help. He replied with effusive expressions of his love, affection and concern for his well-being, but insisted that as long he was so closely associated with his arch-enemy William Pitt there could be no reconciliation. Pitt installed Philip Henry in Walmer Castle and provided him with further sinecures, among them the Surveyorship of the Green Wax and the Keepership of the Records in the Birmingham Tower of Dublin Castle, which provided him with a comfortable income of £1000 per annum and no responsibilities. Lucy bore Philip Henry a son and heir in 1805 – Philip Henry who was to become a well-known historian – and two further children, George Joseph in 1806 and Catherine Lucy Wilhelmina in 1819. His youngest daughter became the Duchess of Cleveland and was the mother of the future prime minister and three times Derby winner Lord Roseberry. She also wrote a book defending her father’s role in the Kaspar Hauser affair. 7 George suffered from tuberculosis and was sent to Brazil in 1828 in the hope that his condition would improve. He died on the voyage and Stanhope was heartbroken. Since the birth of a grandchild did nothing to soften his father’s heart his son decided to sue in the Court of Chancery. The result of the action Mahon v. Stanhope was that relations between father and son were severed for good, and Philip Henry was now totally dependent on Pitt and on his father-in-law, Lord Carrington. In 1806 Mahon became Member of Parliament for Wendover. In 1807 he represented Hull until 1812 when he became MP for Midhurst. He was obliged to resign his seat in 1816 when he succeeded to the peerage. His political views were excentrically reactionary and he described himself as ‘an old Tory of Mr Pitt’s school’. He was a prophet of doom, warning of impending disasters and revolution on the contin-
Philip Henry, Lord Stanhope
87
ental model. He strongly opposed Catholic emancipation arguing that: ‘In a country where all the institutions were decidedly Protestant no further powers can with safety be granted to them.’ He predictably opposed Puseyism as a ‘popish doctrine’. His opposition to industrialization and his defence of the old agricultural order made him the hero of the West London Anti-Enclosure Society, and he became patron to a society devoted to the improvement of poultry stock. He was strongly disapproving of the Great Exhibition of 1851 and refused an honour due to him as vice-president of the Society of Arts which sponsored the exhibition. His quixotic parliamentary career, both in the Commons and the Lords, brought him few friends and many enemies. He condemned industry as the cause of unemployment, was an outspoken agricultural protectionist and a fervent opponent of the repeal of the corn laws. He condemned the new poor laws for making poverty a crime and was outspoken in his opposition to the opium trade in China. The Duke of Wellington described him as a ‘madman’ for his denunciation of the Opium War. The Home Office, mistaking his eccentricities for subversion, intercepted his mail and destroyed much of it. By 1844 he had wearied of public life and wrote to his son-in-law: ‘It is my wish and intention to retire as much as possible from public life in which all my exertions have been utterly useless, except indeed for the satisfaction of my own conscience.’ Throughout his life he was fascinated with herbal medicine and was president of the Medico-Botanical Society. He was elected to the Royal Society in 1807, but his contributions to science were no more impressive than his political crusades. His enthusiastic support for W. H. Phillip’s exotic flying machine, the aerodiphros, proved to be an expensive mistake. As a perpetual traveller he was able to offer many suggestions for the improvement of John Murray’s best-selling Handbooks for Travellers. On his trips to Germany he dabbled in homoeopathy and animal magnetism, although there is no evidence that he showed any interest in Daumer’s experiments on Kaspar Hauser using these arcane sciences. In 1847 he told Lord Wilton that he had lost his faith in homoeopathy remarking that he had ‘long since passed the age at which everyone is said to be either a fool or a physician’. He claimed that he had ‘received no benefit from the “infiniment petits” which were given to me by a German physician’, and added, ‘I should think better of homoeopathy if it were entirely empirical and did not proceed upon a theory which seems to me quite erroneous.’8 He remained throughout his life a great believer in herbal remedies, many of them prescribed
88
Kaspar Hauser
by one Dr Söst, and had a substantial collection of recipes. He also followed a strict if bizarre diet, consisting largely of thin soups, gruel and pu