Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics

Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics

Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

This page intentionally left blank

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Gary Banham

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics

First published in Great Britain 2000 by

MACMILLAN PRESS LTD

Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and London Companies and representatives throughout the world A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.

First published in the United States of America 2000 by ST. MARTIN’S PRESS, INC., Scholarly and Reference Division, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 ISBN 0–312–22748–5 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Banham, Gary, 1965– Kant and the ends of aesthetics / Gary Banham. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–312–22748–5 1. Kant, Immanuel, 1724–1804—Aesthetics. 2. Aesthetics, Modern—18th century. 3. Aesthetics, Modern—19th century. I. Title. B2799.A4B28 1999 193—dc21 99–36060 CIP © Gary Banham 2000 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. 10 09

9 08

8 07

7 06

6 05

5 04

4 03

3 02

2 01

1 00

Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ISBN 0–333–73222–7

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"# $"% &'((')*%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

This page intentionally left blank

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

!"#$%#$&

!"#$%#$&

)#$*"+,-$'"# .

.

/0% /0*%%12"3+ )#&%*$'"# "4 $0% 5%&$0%$''# $0% !*'$'-=3 >?&$%;

.@

@

/*=#&-%#+%#$=3 );=:'#=$'"#< >-0%;=$'&; =#+ 9,+:;%#$

A6

A

/0% B(C"&'$'"# "4 8,*% 9,+:;%#$& "4 /=&

%$DE

F

/0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';%

HI

6

/0% 7%+,-$'"# "4 8,*% 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$&< 2'#% 5*$ =#+ $0% 5#$'#";? "4 $0% !*'$'J,% "4 /=&

%$KD

D

/0% /%3%"3":? "4 !*'$'J,%

.@A

H

/0% B(C"&'$'"# "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$&

.AI

I

/0% 5#$'#";? "4 L%43%-$'M% 9,+:;%#$ L%1$*%=$%+

.FD

K

!0%;'&;< BC':%#%&'& =#+ !";;,#'$?

.D6

B&-0=$"3":? =#+ $0% B#+& "4 !,3$,*%

.IE

.E

4"2/3

.KI

5/(/,2 6'7('")#*89:

@EF

;%0/<

@EI

M''

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'(

+,-%".(/0)/1/%23

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

This page intentionally left blank

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

5-N#"O3%+:%;%#$&

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

'(

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

5-N#"O3%+:%;%#$&

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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

)#$*"+,-$'"#

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`<@ =#+ '$ '& V=#$]& '#$%#$'"# $0=$ $0'& J,%&$'"# O'33 G% &" +%-'&'M%3? =#&O%*%+ $0=$ O% O'33 4'#+ '# '$ \$0% '%G/%2"#: "4 =33 ",* C"&&%&&'"#& $0*",:0 8?#/ *%=&"#] _5((`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` =#+ +'=3%-$'-=33? _$0% '33,&"*? &$=$,& "4 -%*$='# -3=';& =G",$ ;"*=3'$? =*% %(C"&%+`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a,$ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 '& ,#'J,% '# V=#$]& I?G#/ =& 0% $,*#& $0% J,%&$'"# =G",$ \%#+&] G=-N ,C"# '$&%34 '# $0'& O"*N =#+ =&N&< O0=$ =*% $0% 3';'$& $" =&N'#: =G",$ 3';'$&< O0=$ '& $0% C,*C"&% "4 =&N'#: =G",$ C,*C"&%&X a%-=,&% $0'& '& $0% G=&'- J,%&$'"# *='&%+ '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 $0'& O"*N *%M%=3& $0% -"#+'$'"#& =#+ *=$'"#=3% "4 $0% O0"3% !*'$'-=3 %#+%=M",* '# = C=*$'-,3=*3? 3,-'+ ;=##%*R T"O%M%*< '$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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`R )$ O",3+ *%J,'*% = +'44%*%#$ N'#+ "4 +'&-,&&'"# $" =++*%&& O0%$0%* $0'& 3=$$%* +'&$'#-$'"# '& $%#=G3% "* O0%$0%* $0% +"-$*'#=3 O"*N& "C%*=$% =--"*+'#: $" +'44%*%#$ C*'#-'C3%& 4*"; $0"&% +'&-,&&%+ 0%*%R U0=$ ) O'33 &%$ ",$ #"O< 0"O%M%*< =*% $0% N'#+& "4 $0'#N'#: '# $%*;& "4 %#+& $0=$ V=#$ *%-":#'&%& =#+ $0% N'#+& $0=$ 0% +"%& #"$ &C%-'4'-=33? =++*%&& O0'-0 O'33 C*"M'+% ,& O'$0 &";% J,%&$'"#& =G",$ $0% C=*$'-,3=* -3"&,*% "4 $0% !*'$'-=3 &?&$%; $0=$ 0% &=#-$'"#&R

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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

;%2#"0?,2'"% A

3';'$& =#+ C,*C"&%& "4 -"#-%C$&R b#% N'#+ "4 $0'#N'#: '# $%*;& "4 %#+& '& $0%*%4"*% -"#-%C$,=3 $0'#N'#:< "$0%*O'&% -=33%+ N#"O3%+:%R T%*% V=#$ +%3';'$& O0=$ O% -=# -"0%*%#$3? -3='; $" N#"O 4*"; O0=$ O% -=##"$ =#+ *%M%=3& $0%*%G? $0% C,*C"&% "4 N#"O3%+:%Z $" G*'#: $0'#N'#: '#$" *%3=$'"# O'$0 &%#&'G'3'$?R )# "$0%* O"*+&< $" :'M% =# "7J/,2 $" $0",:0$ O0'-0 O",3+ "$0%*O'&% *%M"3M% '# -'*-3%& ,C"# '$&%34R V#"O3%+:% '& $0,& N#"O3%+:% "@ &";%$0'#:Y =#+ $0'& &";%$0'#: '& O0=$ O% %#-",#$%* '# %(C%*'%#-%R /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% $0,& *%-=33& ;%$=C0?&'-& $" '$& '#'$'=3 $=&N "4 *%M%=3'#: O0=$ $0% O"*3+ '& 3'N%R /0'& $=&N '& O0=$ $0'#N'#: 4"*:%$& O0%# '$ =$$%;C$& $" %#,#-'=$% * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3%& =& +%$%*;'#=$'M% "4 =33 $0'#:& O'$0",$ &%$$'#: $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 "GS%-$& "4 %(C%*'%#-% "* $0% O=?& '# O0'-0 $0% * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3% +%+,-%& = 4"*; O'$0",$ = -"#$%#$ _O0'-0 3=$$%* -=# "#3? G% :'M%# $0*",:0 &%#&'G'3'$?`R /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% $0%*%4"*% :'M%& ,& $0% *%=&"#& O0? O% 0=M% $" $0'#N =G",$ $0% %#+& "4 =#? '#J,'*? G? 4"*-'#: ,& $" -"#&'+%* $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C "4 $0% %#J,'*? $" +%$%*;'#=$% &%#&'G3% 4"*;& "4 3'4%R T%#-%< O0'3&$ &C%-,3=$'M% *%=&"# -=# G% $0",:0$ "4 '# $%*;& "4 3';'$& =#+ C,*C"&%&< O0=$ O% +%*'M% 4*"; '$ '& "#3? $0% G=*% -"#+'$'"#& "4 O"*3+0""+ =& &,-0R

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`R U0'3&$ $0'& $*%=$;%#$ "4 %$0'-& &%M%*%3? 3';'$& $0%'* &-"C%< '$ =3&" *%3=$%& $0'& *%&$*'-$'"# $" $0% C,*C"&% "4 $0% -3=';& "4 %$0'-&R /0% *%=&"# %$0'-=3 &$=$%;%#$& =*% ;=+% '& $" -";;%#+ =#+ -"#+%;# -%*$='# =-$'"#& O0'-0 *=$'"#=3 G%'#:& C%*4"*; '# "*+%* $" %#&,*% $0=$ &,-0 G%'#:& G%0=M% '# O=?& O0'-0 =*% G%&$ &,'$%+ $" $0%'* "O# #=$,*% =& *=$'"#=3 G%'#:&R /0% C,*C"&% "4 %$0'-& '& $" %#&,*% $0=$ O% G%&$ *%=3'&% ",* "O# C"&&'G'3'$?R T%#-%< $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 %$0'-& 0=& = #%-%&&=*? -"##%-$'"# $" $0% N'#+& "4 G%'#:& $0=$ O% =*%R B$0'-=3 C0'3"&"C0? '& #"$ +'&-"##%-$%+ 4*"; $0% %#J,'*? '#$" ",* #=$,*% =#+ O0=$ $0'& #=$,*%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

F C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

C%*;'$& ,& $" G% =G3% $" -3=';< G,$ '&< $" $0% -"#$*=*?< =# '#$%:*=3 C=*$ "4 $0'& %#+%=M",*R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& $0%*% '& =# '#%M'$=G3% $%3%"3":'-=3 &%#&% $" %$0'-&< #"$O'$0&$=#+'#: '$& 4"*;=3 =#+ +%"#$"3":'-=3 &$=$,&R /0'& '& O0? $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"% C*%&%#$& $0% #"$'"# $0=$ O% ;,&$ 0=M% ';;"*$=3 &",3& '4 O% =*% $" *%=3'&% ",* "O# C,*C"&%& =& -*%=$,*%& "4 4*%%+"; =& = #%-%&&=*? C*=-$'-=3 C"&$,3=$%R )$ '& =3&" O0? $0% \7'=3%-$'- "4 8*=-$'-=3 L%=&"#] -3"&%& O'$0 = &%-$'"# %#$'$3%+ \b# $0% U'&% 5+=C$=$'"# "4 P=#]& !":#'$'M% 2=-,3$'%& $" T'& 8*=-$'-=3 c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` "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#< O0'-0 '& 4,*$0%* %3=G"*=$%+ =#+ '$& -"#+'$'"#& +'&-,&&%+ '# *%3=$'"# $" $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% '# $0% \!*'$'-=3 B3,-'+=$'"# "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 8*=-$'-=3 L%=&"#]R ) O'33 *%$,*# $" $0'& C=*$ "4 $0% &%-"#+ -*'$'J,% '# !0=C$%* .R

6+7.$.5& 7%&C'$% [?"$=*+]& *%4%*%#-% $" = \4",*$0 -*'$'J,%] "4 C"3'$'-=3 *%=&"#< V=#$ #%M%* +'+ O*'$% = O"*N O'$0 $0'& $'$3%R T% +'+< 0"O%M%*< O*'$% = #,;G%* "4 O"*N& O'$0 C"3'$'-=3 $0%;%& O0'-0 =$$%;C$ $" &%$ ",$ -%*$='# -*'$%*'= 4"* = !*'$'-=3 =CC*"=-0 $" C"3'$'-=3 J,%&$'"#&R U0'3&$ $0'& =&C%-$ "4 0'& O"*N '& #"O =-0'%M'#: &";% *%-":#'$'"# '$ 0=& G%%# = 3"#: $';% '# -";'#:RA Q#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 V=#$]& C"3'$'-=3 O*'$'#:& O% -=# '#-3,+%Z ;0/*3 @"# * M%'G/#3*( N'32"#: @#"1 * ="31"8"('2*% E"'%2 "@ L'/. _.HIF`< +% +%3./# 2" 29/ O?/32'"%P Q9*2 ;3 D%(')92/%1/%2R _.HIF`< S% 29/ ="11"% 5*:'%)P B9'3 &*: 6/ B#?/ '% B9/"#:T 6?2 '2 $"/3 %"2 +88(: '% E#*,2',/ _.HKA`< E/#8/2?*( E/*,/ _.HK6`< B9/ ="%@(',2 "@ B9/ !*,?(2'/3 _.HKI`< F/(')'"% .'29'% 29/ U'1'23 "@ F/*3"% +("%/ _.HKA`< =#+ = +"-$*'#=3 &$=$%;%#$ '# $0% 4'*&$ 0=34 "4 B9/ &/2*89:3',3 "@ &"#*(3< $0% F/,932(/9#/< "* $",2#'%/ "@ F')92RF T"O%M%*< $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 =3&" -"#$='#& ;=$%*'=3 "# &$=$% =#+ -'M'3 &"-'%$? _dIA` =#+ *%43%-$'"#& "# /'29/# $0% 2*%#-0 "# $0% 5;%*'-=# L%M"1 3,$'"# _dD6`R6 V=#$ #%M%* 4'#=33? &?&$%;=$'&%+ $0% O%=3$0 "4 ;=$%*'=3 "# $0'& =*%=< =3$0",:0 $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0%*% '& = +"-$*'#=3 O*'$'#: "# $0% =*%= +"%&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

;%2#"0?,2'"% 6

&,::%&$ $0% -"#&'+%*=G3% ';C"*$=#-% 0% =$$=-0%+ $" $0% '#M%&$':=$'"# "4 C"3'$'-=3 *%=&"#R /0% %&&=? "# B#3':0$%#;%#$< O0'3&$ %($*%;%3? &0"*$< +"%& =$$%;C$ = -*'$'-=3 $*%=$;%#$ "4 '$& &,GS%-$ G? +'&$'#:,'&0'#: O0%# *%=&"# -=# *':0$4,33? -3='; '$& 4,#-$'"# '& $" %#3':0$%# _O0%# ,&%+ C,G3'-3?` 4*"; O0%# '$ &0",3+ #"$ _C*'M=$% ,&% "4 *%=&"#< '# &%*M'-% "4 "44'-'=3 $=&N&`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`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a,$< O0'3&$ $0'& '& G*"=+3? $*,%< $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 +"%& -";C3'-=$% ;=$1 $%*&R )# d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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

;%2#"0?,2'"% H

/0% $%*; \=%&$0%$'-&] O'33 G% +'&-,&&%+ =$ &";% 3%#:$0 '# !0=C$%* . =#+ *%3=$%+ $" $0% $0*%% -*'$'J,%&R ) O'33 &,::%&$ $0=$ $0% $%*; #%%+& $" G% ,#+%*&$""+ =& *%4%**'#: $" ;"*% $0=# S,&$ $0% J,%&$'"# "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R T"O%M%*< =$ $0'& C"'#$ ) O'33 *%&$*'-$ ;?&%34 $" $0'& #"O $*=+'$'"#=3 ,&% "4 $0% $%*;R V=#$]& 4'*&$ +'&-,&&'"# "4 $=&$% $""N C3=-% '# 0'& C*%1 -*'$'-=3 O*'$'#: S73/#G*2'"%3 "% 29/ !//('%) "@ 29/ 6/*?2'@?( *%0 29/ 5?7('1/ _.HDF`H< O0'-0 '& 0'& "#3? O*'$'#: "# $0% =*%= ,#$'3 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 _.HKE`R /0% %=*3'%* O*'$'#: C*%&%#$%+ = ;"+'4'%+ 4"*; "4 &%#&=$'"#=3'&;< &';'3=* '# ;=#? *%&C%-$& $" $0% %&&=? O0'-0 B+;,#+ a,*N% C,G3'&0%+ 4'M% ?%=*& %=*3'%*R b#-% 0% 0=+ =G=#+"#%+ &%#&=$'"#=3'&;< V=#$ O=& 3%4$ O'$0",$ =# =CC*"=-0 $" $0'& =*%= 4"* &";% ?%=*&R U0%# 0% 4'#=33? *%$,*#%+ $" '$< 0=M'#: %#,#-'=$%+ $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0%"*%$'-=3 =#+ C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#< 0% O=& 3%4$ O'$0 = J,=#+=*? -"#-%*#'#: $0% $?C% "4 -3='; '#M"3M%+ '# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%R /" *%&"3M% $0'& J,%&$'"# *%J,'*%+ *='&'#: $0% C*"G3%; "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$R /0'& '& O0? $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 '& C=*$ "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2< C=*$ $0=$ '&< "4 =# %#+%=M",* $0=$ '& O'+%* $0=# +%$%*;'#'#: S,&$ $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C"&&'G'3'$? "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R 9,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =*% '# = M%*? ';C"*$=#$ &%#&% -3%=*3? -"##%-$%+ $" &%#&'G'3'$?R /0'& N'#+ "4 S,+:;%#$ '& "#% O0'-0 '& C*"+,-%+ G? $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 &%#&% %(C%*'%#-% ?%$ &%%;& $" $*=#&-%#+ $0% ;";%#$=*'1 #%&& "4 &%#&%R /0%&% "++ 4=-$& =G",$ S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% *%M%=3 $0%; $" G% -"##%-$%+ %'$0%* $" $0% '#M"3M%;%#$ "4 $0% &,GS%-$ '# = 0=*;"#'",& %(C%*'%#-% _G%=,$?` "* "#% O0'-0 '& -"##%-$%+ $" = M'"3%#$ &%#&,",&#%&& O0'-0< 0"O%M%*< &$'33 =33"O& &";% *%C"&% _&,G3';'$?`R /0% -"#+'$'"#& 4"* +%$%*;'#'#: $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0%&% S,+:;%#$& =#+ $0% %3';'#=$'"# "4 %($*=#%",& ;=$%*'=3 4*"; $0%; =*% $0% C,*C"&% "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/3H 29/2', A?0)1/%2R U0'3&$ $0'& O",3+ 3';'$ $0% *=#:% "4 &,-0 S,+:;%#$& '$ O",3+ =3&" $*? $" *%M%=3 $0% C,*C"&% "4 ",* ;=N'#: $0%;< = C,*C"&% O0'-0 O'33 0"O%M%* #"$ G% +%$%*;'#%+ "#3? O'$0'# $0% *=#:% "4 S,+:1 ;%#$& "4 $=&$%< G,$ O'33 =3&" G% -"##%-$%+ $" $0% '#$%33%-$,=3 -"#+'$'"#& "4 ;"*=3 -3=';& _dd.H< 6K =#+ IA`R /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 4,34'3& $0% 4=;'3'=* +",G3% -"#+'$'"#& "4 = -*'$'-=3 $*%=$;%#$Z 3';'$'#: $0% =*%= -"#&'+%*%+ =#+ *%M%=3'#: $0% C,*C"&%& "4 &$=$%;%#$& ;=+% '# '$R /0'& 3%=+& $" &";% M%*? &C%-'4'+'44'-,3$'%& '# $0% =*%= "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% '# $0=$ $0%&% S,+:;%#$& O'33 G% &0"O# $" G% \C,*C"&'M% O'$0",$ = C,*C"&%]< =#+ ?%$ $0*",:0 $0%'* -"##%-$'"# O'$0 $0% '#$%33%-$,=3 -3=';& "4 ;"*=3'$? =*% &='+< =4$%* =33< $"

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8*&$-*$.5&

I C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

=-J,'*% = C,*C"&% '# -%*$='# &%#&%&R T"O%M%*< O0=$ O% -=# -3='; 4*"; =# '#'$'=3 :3=#-% =$ $0% =*%= '& $0=$ V=#$]& -*'$'-=3 $*%=$;%#$ "4 =%&$0%$'-& 0=&< '# =$$%;C$'#: $" G*'#: $":%$0%* $0% $O" &%#&%& "4 $0% %#+& "4 =%&$0%$'-&< $0% &=;% &$*,-$,*% =& 0'& "$0%* -*'$'-=3 '#J,'*'%&R

V=#$ '& -"#&$=#$3? -"#-%*#%+ O'$0 $%3%"3":?R T"O%M%*< 0% ;=N%& $0'& -"#-%*# %(C3'-'$ '# "#3? $O" O"*N&Z \b# $0% Q&% "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 8*'#-'1 C3%& '# 80'3"&"C0?] _.HII` =#+ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 _.HKE`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`< +%%"?%,/1/%2 "@ 29/ 4/*# ="%,(?3'"% "@ * B#/*2: @"# D2/#%*( E/*,/ '% E9'("3"89: _.HKD`<

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'*7*+7+0(

B9/ !'%*( D%0 "@ +(( B9'%)3 _.HKF`Y ;0/* "@ * M%'G/#3*( N'32"#: @#"1 * ="31"8"('2*% E"'%2 "@ L'/. _.HIF`< F/(')'"% .'29'% 29/ U'1'23 "@ F/*3"% +("%/ _.HKA` =#+ B9/ ="%@(',2 "@ B9/ !*,?(2'/3 _.HKI`RK 53$0",:0 V=#$ #%M%* O*"$% = -*'$'J,% &C%-'4'-=33? +%M"$%+ $" %3,-'+=$'#: %&-0=$"3":?< $0=$ '& $0% -";G'#%+ %44%-$ "4 $0%&% %&&=?&R $#/*13 "@ * 58'#'2H5//#< O0'3&$ = C*%1-*'$'-=3 O"*N< +"%& &%$ ",$ $0% C*"G3%;& O'$0 -%*$='# N'#+& "4 =C"-=3?C$'- -3=';&< O0'-0 '$ &%$& ",$ $" +'&;'&&R )$ 0=& = C*';=*'3? #%:=$'M% '#$%#$< =& 0=M% $0% 3=$% %&&=?& "4 .HKD +'*%-$%+ =$ 9"0=## e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`R

8 9+#:!"#$."# '-+;0-$ +, 3#4< /0%*% '& = #%%+ $" +'&-,&& "#% "$0%* N'#+ "4 $0'#N'#: "4 %#+& O0'-0< '$ -",3+ G% -3=';%+< '& $0% "#3? 4"*; "4 &,-0 $0'#N'#: #"$ +'&-,&&%+ G? V=#$Z -0%;'&;R /0'& '& C*%&%#$%+ =& = C*'#-'C3% G? T%:%3 '# G"$0 $0% \e*%=$%* [":'-]< $0% 5,'/%,/ "@ U")',< =#+ '# $0% \&;=33%* [":'-]< $0% D%,:,("8*/0'* U")',R.E )# G"$0 O"*N& $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 -0%;'&; '& C*%1 &%#$%+ $"O=*+& $0% -3"&% =#+ '& '#$*"+,-%+ =& =# '#$%*;%+'=*? C*'#-'C3% G%$O%%# ;%-0=#'&; =#+ $%3%"3":?R U0'3&$ ;%-0=#'&; '& $0'#N'#: '# $%*;& "4 %44'-'%#$ -=,&%&< =#+ $0%*%4"*% O'$0",$ =#? -"#-%C$ "4 C,*C"&% _\4,#-$'"#] G%'#: &,44'-'%#$`< =#+ $%3%"3":? $0'#N'#: '# $%*;& "4 C,*1 C"&%&< -0%;'&; -"#&$'$,$%& $0% $*=#&'$'"#=3 C*'#-'C3% G%$O%%# $0%&% $O" "CC"&'$%&< = C*'#-'C3% #"$ -"#&'+%*%+ "* %#,#-'=$%+ G? V=#$ '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2R /0% *%=&"# 4"* $0'& '& '#+'-=$%+ -3%=*3? %#",:0 G? T%:%3< O0" $%33& ,& $0=$ -0%;'&; '& ,&,=33? &';C3?

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

;%2#"0?,2'"% K

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b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e*%=$%* [":'-] T%:%3 $%33& ,& $0=$ -0%;'&; '& $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 &%(,=3'$? '# $0% #=$,*=3 O"*3+ =#+ "4 3=#:,=:% '# $0% &C'*'$,=3 O"*3+R b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a,$ $0% $0",:0$ "4 -0%;'&; C"&%& = -0=33%#:% $" V=#$ 4*"; ",$&'+% 0'& "O# 4*=;%O"*N %M%# $0",:0 O% -=# +%+,-% = 3';'$%+ 4"*; "4 $0'& C*'#-'C3% O'$0'# 0'& O"*NR T"O%M%*< :'M%# $0=$ -0%;'&; '& =

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.E C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

;%2#"0?,2'"% ..

$0",:0$ "4 -"1+%$%*;'#=$'"#< O% O",3+ %(C%-$ '$ $" ;=#'4%&$ '$&%34 =$ ;=#? 3%M%3& "4 !*'$'-=3 %(C"&'$'"#R

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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=*$-.#/.#0 >1.$.5"7 6-.7+&+)-(

.

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` "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#] "4 $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%< =#+ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,%R

'-* '1"#&5*#4*#$"7 8*&$-*$.5 /0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- '& $0% 4'*&$ C=*$ "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7"-$*'#% "4 B3%;%#$& _$0% &%-"#+ C=*$ G%'#: /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 [":'-< O0'-0 '& 4,*$0%* &,G+'M'+%+ '#$" = /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5#=3?$'- =#+ = /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 7'=3%-$'-`R /0% +'M'&'"# "4 $0% %3%;%#$& '& &$=$%+ '# $0% )#$*"1 +,-$'"# $" %;%*:% 4*"; $0% \$O" &$%;& "4 0,;=# N#"O3%+:%< #=;%3?< 3/%3'7'('2: =#+ ?%0/#32*%0'%)] _5.6fa@K`R /0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'+%=3& O'$0 &%#&'G'3'$?< 3%=M'#: ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $" G% +%$%*;'#%+ ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 [":'-R /0% S,&$'4'-=$'"# 4"* $*%=$'#: &%#&'G'3'$? ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 =%&$0%$''& #"$ C,*%3? %$?;"3":'-=3 ^ $0% $%*; \=%&$0%$'-] +%*'M'#: 4*"; $0% e*%%N *'329/3'3R /0% "C%#'#: C=*=:*=C0 "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- $%33& ,& $0=$ $0%*% '& =# \';;%+'=$% *%3=$'"#] "4 N#"O3%+:% $" "GS%-$&< O0'-0 '& $%*;%+ '%2?'2'"% _+%3,9*??%)`R 2,*$0%*;"*%< \=33 $0",:0$ =& = ;%=#&] '& +'*%-$%+ $"O=*+& '#$,'$'"#R a,$ $0% ';;%+'=$% *%3=$'"# $" N#"O3%+:% $0=$ '& #=;%+ 0%*% -=# "#3? "--,* '4 \$0% "GS%-$ '& :'M%# $" ,&]R /0% "GS%-$ .@

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% /0*%%14"3+ )#&%*$'"# "4 $0% 5%&$0%$'- '# $0% !*'$'-=3 >?&$%;

'& "#3? :'M%# $" ,&< 0"O%M%*< '4 $0% \;'#+] _K/1?W2`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`< =#+ &" ;,&$ =33"O "4 G%'#: -"#&'+%*%+ =C=*$ 4*"; =33 &%#&=$'"#R _5@EfaAF` /0%*% '&< $0%*%4"*%< =# ';;%+'=$% =O=*%#%&& "4 &%#&=$'"#< O0'-0 '& '$&%34 3":'-=33? +'&$'#-$ 4*"; &%#&=$'"# O0'3&$ &$'33 G%'#: = &%#&'G3% *%3=1 $'"# $" $0% "GS%-$R /0'& '& O0=$ O% ;,&$ -=33 * 8#'"#' &%#&'G'3'$?R )# $0% )#$*"+,-$'"# V=#$ +%4'#%+ $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 $" ;%=#Z \=33 N#"O3%+:% O0'-0 '& "--,C'%+ #"$ &" ;,-0 O'$0 "GS%-$& =& O'$0 $0% ;"+% "4 ",* N#"O3%+:% "4 "GS%-$& '# &" 4=* =& $0'& ;"+% "4 N#"O3%+:% '& $" G% C"&&'G3% * 8#'"#'] _5..^.@fa@6`R e'M%# $0'& &%#&% "4 $0% $%*;< 0'& %($%#&'"# "4 '$& -"#$%#$ '# $0% '#$*"+,-$"*? C=*$& "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- '& ,#&,*C*'&'#:R T% &$=$%& 0%*% $0=$ =33 \*%C*%&%#$=$'"#&] '# O0'-0 \$0%*% '& #"$0'#: $0=$ G%3"#:& $" &%#&=$'"#] =*% \8?#/ _'# $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &%#&%`] _5@EfaAF`R /0'& ;%=#& $0=$ *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& O0'-0 =*% #"$ "4 $0% "GS%-$ "4 &%#&% G,$ =*% #%-%&&=*? 4"* $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0%*% G%'#: =#? =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 &%#&% =*% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 *%C*%&%#$=$'"#&R 5& O% 0=M% %&$=G3'&0%+ $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 = 4"*;=3 =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 &%#&=$'"#< O0'-0 -=##"$ '$&%34 G% &%#&=$'"#=3< '$ 4"33"O& $0=$ $0%*% '& =# ';;%+'=$% *%3=$'"# $" $0% "GS%-$& "4 ';;%+'=$% -":#'$'"# O0'-0 '& #"$ &%#&'G3% G,$ -"#&$'$,$%& $0% 4"*; "4 &%#&'G'3'$?R )# &0"*$< $0%*% ;,&$ G% C,*% * 8#'"#' '#$,'$'"#&R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', .A

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faAD`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` =*% -=33%+ ;%$=C0?&'-=3 =#+ $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 %(C"&'$'"#&R /0% &%-$'"# "# &C=-% '& C*%&%#$%+ 4'*&$ =#+ O% =*% 0%*% $"3+ O0=$ $0%&% %(C"&'$'"#& =*%R T% &,::%&$& =$ aAI $0=$ =# %(C"&'$'"# '& = -3%=* $0",:0 #"$ %(0=,&$'M% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 O0=$ G%3"#:& $" = -"#-%C$R /0'& +%&-*'C$'"# '& &";%O0=$ "++ '# $0% -"#$%($ G%-=,&% O0=$ '& G%'#: \%(C",#+%+] '& #"$ = -"#-%C$ G,$ =# '#$,'$'"#R )# $0% U")',< -";C'3%+ G? 9=g&-0%< &%-$'"# .E6 +'&$'#1 :,'&0%& G%$O%%# %(C"&'$'"# =#+ +%&-*'C$'"# =#+ O% =*% $"3+ $0=$Z /0% /<8"3'2'"% "4 = -"#-%C$ -"#&'&$& '# $0% -"##%-$'#: _&,--%&&'M%` C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 '$& -0=*=-$%*'&$'-& &" 4=* =& $0%&% 0=M% G%%# 4",#+ G? =#=3?&'&R@ 5& =# =#=3?&'& '& "4$%# '#-";C3%$%< 0% =++&< =# %(C"&'$'"# ;,&$ &%*M% =& =# %(0'G'$'"# "4 = -"#-%C$R /0'& '& &$'33 -"#4,&'#: G%-=,&% O% =*% +%=3'#: O'$0 '#$,'$'"#& =#+ #"$ -"#-%C$&R a,$ '$ '& -3%=* $0=$ %(C"&'$'"# '& = ;%$0"+ O0'-0 -=# =CC3? $" G"$0 = -"#-%C$ _"4 $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 3":'-` =#+ =# '#$,'$'"# _"4 $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =%&$0%$'-`R 5# %(C"&'$'"# C*"M'+%& -3=*'4'-=$'"# "4 O0=$ G%3"#:& $" $0% $%*; '# J,%&$'"# =#+ +"%& $0'& '# = ;=##%* O0'-0 +*=O& "# $0% *%&,3$& "4 =#? C*%M'",& =#=3?$'-=3 +'M'&'"#R U'$0 *%:=*+ $" &C=-% =#+ $';%< $0% =#=3?$'-=3 +'M'&'"#& =3*%=+? C*%&%#$%+ 0=M% G%%# C%*4"*;%+ '# $0% ;=##%* "4 *%&$*'-$'"#R >" O% =*% %(C",#+'#: $0% $%*; =--"*+'#: $" O0=$ ;,&$ =CC3? $" =# * 8#'"#' *%C*%&%#$=$'"#R b*< $0'& '& O0=$ '& "--,**'#: '# $0% ;%$=C0?&'-=3 %(1 C"&'$'"# _aAI`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.F C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

5 $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 %(C"&'$'"#< "# $0% "$0%* 0=#+< :'M%& ,& =# %(C3=#=1 $'"# "4 = $%*; \=& = C*'#-'C3% 4*"; O0'-0 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 "$0%* * 8#'"#' &?#$0%$'- N#"O3%+:% -=# G% ,#+%*&$""+] _aFE`R /0,&< $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 %(C"&'$'"# C*"M'+%& =# %(0'G'$'"# "4 = $%*; =--"*+'#: $" $0% -"#+'$'"#& $0=$ '$ ;=N%& C"&&'G3%< *=$0%* $0=# $0% -"#+'$'"#& '$ ;,&$ &=$'&4?R /0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0%&% $O" 4"*;& "4 %(C"&'$'"# O=& ;=+% '# $0% &%-"#+ %+'$'"# "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% =#+ '$ %#=G3%& = +'M'&'"# $" G% ;=+% G%$O%%# =*:,;%#$& O0'-0 +'*%-$3? &%$ ",$ $" C*"M% $0=$ &C=-% =#+ $';% =*% '#+%%+ $0% &,GS%-$& "4 = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =%&$0%$'- _$0=$ '&< =*% -":#'&=G3% =& C*'#-'C3%& "4 * 8#'"#' &%#&'G'3'$?`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` =#+ $0%*%4"*% '$ -"#+'$'"#& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 %(C%*'%#-%R /0'& '& *%=33? $0% =#=3?$'- -"#&%J,%#-% "4 $0% 4'*&$ =*:,;%#$ G%'#: C,$ '#$" C"&'$'M% $%*;&R U0=$ $0% 4'*&$ $O" =*:,;%#$& O%*% -"#-%*#%+ O'$0 $0%*%4"*% O=& +%;"#&$*=$'#: $0=$ &C=-% '& * 8#'"#'R a%-=,&% 0% 0=+ #"$ ?%$ %&$=G3'&0%+ $0=$ '$ O=& =# '#$,'$'"#< 0% *%4%**%+ $" '$ '# G"$0 =*:,;%#$& =& = -"#-%C$R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', .6

/0% $0'*+ =*:,;%#$ _&%-"#+ %+'$'"# "*+%*'#:` '& $0% 4'*&$ $" :'M% *%=&"#& 4"* $0'#N'#: $0=$ &C=-% '& =# '#$,'$'"#R /0% -=&% 4"* $0'& '& $O"14"3+R 2'*&$< V=#$ &$=$%& $0=$ &C=-% '& &'#:,3=* =#+ #"$ C3,*=3R >%-"#+< =#?$0'#: O0'-0 O% -",3+ +%&-*'G% =& = C=*$ "4 &C=-% -=# "#3? G% $0",:0$ "4 =& -"#$='#%+ O'$0'# $0% "#% &C=-% _=#+ #"$ =& C*%-%+'#: '$ =#+ C*"+,-'#: $0% -"#-%C$ "4 '$`R /0% -"#$%#$ "4 $0'& =*:,;%#$ '& $0=$ &C=-% '& #"$ =# =G&$*=-$'"# G%-=,&% '$ +"%& #"$ %;%*:% 4*"; = &%*'%& "4 &%#&=$'"#& O0'-0 O% G,'3+ '#$" = ,#'$? "4 =CC*%0%#&'"#< G,$ '& *=$0%* $0% -"#+'$'"# 4"* =#? &,-0 &%#&=$'"#=3 -"#&$*,-$'"#R /0'& =*:,;%#$ 3%=+& $" $0% -"#-3,&'"# $0=$ &C=-% '& #"$ =# %;C'*'-=3 '#$,'$'"# G,$ =# * 8#'"#' "#%< =#+ $0,& =++& $" $0% -,;,3=$'M% O%':0$ "4 $0% C*%M'",& $O" =*:,;%#$&R /0% 4",*$0 =*:,;%#$ _4'4$0 '# $0% 4'*&$ %+'$'"#` '& C%*0=C& $0% "++%&$ '# 4"*;,3=$'"#R )# $0% 4'*&$ %+'$'"# 0% =*:,%&Z )4 $0%*% O%*% #" 3';'$3%&&#%&& '# $0% C*":*%&&'"# "4 '#$,'$'"#< #" -"#-%C$ "4 *%3=$'"#& -",3+ ?'%3+ = C*'#-'C3% "4 $0%'* '#4'#'$,+%R _5@6` /0'& 4"33"O& "# 4*"; $0% C*%M'",& =*:,;%#$]& +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% '#$,'$'"# "4 &C=-% =#+ $0% \:%#%*=3 -"#-%C$] "4 '$ $0=$ '& +%*'M%+ 4*"; $0% '#$,'$'"#R )# $0% \:%#%*=3 -"#-%C$] _G? O0'-0 V=#$ &%%;& $" ;%=# :%";%$*?`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`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.D C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

C*';=*? "GS%-$& "4 = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =%&$0%$'-R a,$ O0=$ $0% /*=#&-%#1 +%#$=3 B(C"&'$'"# O",3+ &%%N $" =++ $" $0'& '& $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"# $0=$ -%*$='# '$%;& "4 N#"O3%+:% =*% "#3? %(C3'-=G3% G? $0'&R V=#$ &%%N& $" +%;"#&$*=$% $0=$ :%";%$*? '& "#3? C"&&'G3% G%-=,&% &C=-% '& =# * 8#'"#' '#$,'$'"#R /0% =*:,;%#$ +%C%#+&< 0"O%M%*< "# 0'& =&&%*$'"# $0=$ :%"1 ;%$*? 4"*;& = G"+? "4 &?#$0%$'- * 8#'"#' N#"O3%+:%R e%";%$*? '& &?#1 $0%$'- G%-=,&% '$& &$=$%;%#$& _O'$0 $0% C"&&'G3% %(-%C$'"# "4 '$& C*';=*? =('";&` =*% #"$ $*,% G? +%4'#'$'"#< G,$ =*% +'&-"M%*%+R 5*% '$& $*,$0& * 8#'"#'X )# $0% &%#&% "4 #%-%&&=*'3? #"#1&%#&=$'"#=3 $0%? -3%=*3? =*%< =& "GS%-$& "4 :%";%$*? =*% #"$ %#-",#$%*%+ '# %(C%*'%#-%R 5*% $0%? #%-%&1 &=*'3? $*,% O'$0",$ &';C3? G%'#: $0% C*"+,-$ "4 +%4'#'$'"#=3 ;"M%&X h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aFK`R a,$ $0'& '& #"$ = *%=3 %J,'M=3%#$ $" :%";%$*? =& ;"$'"# ;,&$ '#M"3M% &C=-% =& O%33 =& $';%< =& V=#$ 3=$%* &$=$%& _5F.fa6I`R /';% '& #"$< $0%*%1 4"*%< :'M%# = /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 B(C"&'$'"#R 7%&C'$% $0'& +%4%-$ '# $0% /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-]& $*%=$;%#$ "4 $';%< $';% '& :'M%# =# =+M=#$=:% "M%* &C=-% '# $0=$ '$ '& $0% -"#+'$'"# "4 G"$0 '##%* =#+ ",$%* *%C*%&%#$=$'"#&R /0'& '& &$=$%+ '# $0% \!"#-3,&'"#&] _dD`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`< =*% #"#% $0% 3%&& #"$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', .H

.I C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0% $*,% -"**%3=$% "4 &%#&'G'3'$?< $0% $0'#: '# '$&%34 '& #"$ N#"O#< =#+ -=##"$ G% N#"O#< $0*",:0 $0%&% *%C*%&%#$=$'"#&Y =#+ '# %(C%*'%#-% #" J,%&$'"# '& %M%* =&N%+ '# *%:=*+ $" '$R _aF6` 5#"$0%* O=? "4 C,$$'#: $0'& =*:,;%#$ '& $0=$ %M%*?$0'#: O0'-0 G%3"#:& $" $0% -"#$%#$ "4 C,*% '#$,'$'"# _=#+ $0,& $" $0% 4"*; "4 %;C'*'-=3 '#$,'$'"#`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`< =#+ &" '& =44%-$%+ G? '$&%34 R R R _aDH^I`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a,$ $0'& -=# "#3? G% C"&&'G3% '4 O% 0=M% = ;%=#& "4 "*:=#'&'#: =#+ "*+%*'#: $0=$ %(C%*'%#-%R U0=$ $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&1 $0%$'- *%M%=3& '& O0=$ $0'& ;%=#&Z $0% * 8#'"#' '#$,'$'"#& "4 &C=-% =#+ $';%R /0% ';;%+'=$% *%3=$'"# $" N#"O3%+:% $0=$ '& 4"*;%+ '# C,*% '#$,'$'"# '& *%M%=3%+ $" G% = 4"*;=3 ,#'M%*&=3 =CC*%0%#&'"# O0'-0 \:'M%&] ,& $0% -"#+'$'"# 4"* &%#&'G3% %(C%*'%#-%R >%#&'G3% N#"O3%+:% ;%%$& 0%*% G"$0 O'$0 '$& -"#+'$'"# "4 C"&&'G'3'$? =#+ '$& +%$%*;'#=$% C*'#-'C3%&R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

C*%+'-=G3% "4 $0'#:& =C=*$ 4*"; -"#+'$'"#& "4 '#$,'$'"#R /0'& '& $0% M'%O $0=$ &C=-% =#+ $';%< O0'3&$ %;C'*'-=33? *%=3< =*% 2#*%3,/%0/%2*((: '0/*(R 5#"$0%* O=? "4 &$=$'#: $0'& -"#-3,&'"# '& $0=$< '4 $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 =#? C"&&'G3% %(C%*'%#-% O% -",3+ 0=M% =*% *%;"M%+< $0%# $0%*% O",3+ G% #" :*",#+& 4"* =&&,;'#: $0=$ &C=$'=3 "* $%;C"*=3 -"#+'$'"#& "4 *%C*%&%#$=1 $'"# O",3+ G% =M='3=G3%R 5& V=#$ O*'$%&Z

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', .K

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`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`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` '& +'M'+%+ O'$0'# $0% =#=3?$'- '#$" =# =#=3?$'- "4 C*'#-'C3%& =#+ -"#-%C$&< $0%# '$ *%C%=$& $0% '#$%*#=3 +'M'&'"# "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- $0=$ $0% 4'*&$ -*'$'J,% 0=+R /0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-]& G=&'& 4"* &%C=*=$'"# 4*"; /*=#&-%#+%#1 $=3 [":'- 0=& =3*%=+? G%%# $*%=$%+R /0% 5%&$0%$'- "4 $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'-* ?1.@*& +, 6;1* 61"5$.5"7 =*"&+#

'& 0%*% &$=$%+ $" $*%=$ #"$ "4 '#$,'$'"# G,$ "4 4%%3'#:< =#+ $0'& '& &$=$%+ $" G% $0% G=&'& 4"* '$& ,#'$=*? $*%=$;%#$ _=& "CC"&%+ $" $0% G'C=*$'$% +'M'&'"# "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-`R )4 $0% &%-"#+ \=%&$0%$'-] '& -"#-%*#%+ O'$0 \4%%3'#:]< 0"O%M%*< $0%# '$ '& -3"&%* $" $0% e*%%N *'329/3'3 $0=# O=& $0% $*%=$;%#$ "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R U0=$ O",3+ S,&$'4? -=331 '#: '$ =# \=%&$0%$'-] O",3+ G% $0=$ '$ $*%=$& "4 &%#&'G'3'$?< =& [%O'& U0'$% a%-N C,$& '$< "4 \4%%3'#: =& = ;"+% "4 &%#&%]R6 U% 0=M% = G=&'&< $0%*%4"*%< 4"* $*%=$'#: $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% \+*'M%&] =& =# =%&$0%$'-R 5 *%=&"# 4"* C3=-'#: $0% \=%&$0%$'-] =4$%* $0% =#=3?$'-=3 +'M'&'"# "4 $0% 3":'- 0=& G%%# &,G&$=#$'M%3? -";C3%$%+ _G,$ #"$ 4"* '#-3,+'#: $0'& \=%&1 $0%$'-] O'$0'# $0% C*"M'#-% "4 $0% =#=3?$'-` '& :'M%# '# $0% \)#$*"+,-$'"#] $" $0% O"*NZ R R R '# $0% C*%&%#$ O"*N O% G%:'# O'$0 C*'#-'C3%& =#+ C*"-%%+ $" -"#-%C$&< =#+ "#3? $0%#< '4 C"&&'G3%< :" "# $" $0% &%#&%&< O0'3% '# $0% &$,+? "4 &C%-,3=$'M% *%=&"# O% 0=+ $" &$=*$ O'$0 $0% &%#&%& =#+ %#+ O'$0 C*'#-'C3%&RRR$0% *%=&"# 4"* $0'& 3'%& '# $0% 4=-$ $0=$ 0%*% O% 0=M% $" +%=3 O'$0 = O'33 =#+ $" -"#&'+%* *%=&"# #"$ '# *%3=$'"# $" "GS%-$& G,$ $" $0'& O'33 =#+ '$& -=,&=3'$?R _5NR 6Z.D` U% =*% #"$ 0%*% =$$%;C$'#: $" +'&-,&& $0% -":#'$'"# "4 "GS%-$& O0%$0%* ';;%+'=$%3? _=& '# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-` "* "$0%*O'&% _/*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5#=3?$'-`R L=$0%*< O% 0=M% $" -"#&'+%* O0=$ -=# G% +%$%*1 ;'#%+ =G",$ $0% #=$,*% "4 $0% O'33 =#+ O0=$ -=,&=$'M% C*"C%*$'%& -=# G% =$$*'G,$%+ $" '$R a%-=,&% O% =*% =3*%=+? -":#'&'#: $0% O'33< O% -=##"$ G%:'# _=& '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%` O'$0 $0% +=$= "4 C,*% &%#&'G'3'$?R /0% J,%&$'"# 0%*% '&Z O0=$ C*'#-'C3%& =#+ -"#-%C$& +" O% #%%+ $" %&$=G3'&0 =& #%-%&&=*? 4"* $0% O'33 $" 0=M% = C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#X U% 0=M% $" +%$%*;'#% $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# =44%-$'#: $0% &%#&,",&3? %(C%*'%#-'#: &,GS%-$R /0,& $0% \=%&$0%$'-] "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# '& M'$=3 G%-=,&% "#3? $0*",:0 = -"**%-$ +%;"#&$*=$'"# 0%*% -=# O% &0"O #"$ "#3? O0=$ $0% C*'#-'C3%& "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# O",3+ G% _$0% %=*3'%* O"*N "4 $0% 5#=3?$'-` G,$ =3&" $0% G=&'& 4"* G%3'%M'#: $0=$ $0% &,GS%-$ '& &%#1 &,",&3? &,&-%C$'G3% $" $0%;R a,$< '4 O% G%:=# O'$0 $0% 5%&$0%$'- =& = +%$%*;'#=$'M% -"#+'$'"# "4 $0% =#=3?$'-=3 3":'- _=& '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%` O% O",3+ G% -";;'$$%+ $" $0% M'%O $0=$ ;"*=3'$? =*'&%& 4*"; $0% *%3=$'"#& "4 &%#&% =#+ $0'& O",3+ %#+=#:%* $0% ,#'M%*&=3 =CC3'-=G'3'$? "4 ;"*=3 C*'#-'C3%&R /0,& $0% \=%&$0%$'-] '& #"$ = -"#$'#:%#$ C=*$ "4 $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%< G,$ #%'$0%* -=# '$ G% '$& -"#+'$'"#R )$ 0=& *=$0%* $" G% O0=$ '& -"#+'1 $'"#%+ G? '$ _$0,& '$ 4'33& $0% &=;% C3=-% =& %;C'*'-=3 '#$,'$'"# '# $0% 2'*&$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@E C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

!*'$'J,%`R /0% C,*% 4"*;& "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# 0=M% =3*%=+? G%%# +%$%*1 ;'#%+Y #"O '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" =CC3? $0%; $" $0% &%#&,",& &,GS%-$ $0*",:0 $0% ,#-"M%*'#: "4 = -=$%:"*? "4 %$0'-& _$0% -=$%:"*'-=3 ';C%*=1 $'M%`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` /0% 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'- -"#-%*#%+ $0=$ O'$0 O0'-0 =33 N#"O3%+:% \=& = ;%=#&] O=& +'*%-$%+ $"O=*+&R /0% &%-"#+ G%:'#& G? $%33'#: ,& $0=$ $0% O'33 $" "C%*=$% ;"*=33? 0=& $" 0=M% = +'*%-$ +%$%*;'#=$'"# G? $0% 3=OR /0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'-]& $=&N '&< $0%*%4"*%< $" +%;"#&$*=$% 0"O $0'& +'*%-$ +%$%*;'#=$'"# '& C"&&'G3%R a,$ $0% &%#&,",& &,GS%-$ 0=& \+*'M%&]< $0=$ '&Z \&,GS%-$'M% +%$%*;'#'#: :*",#+&] "4 $0% O'33 O0'-0 +" #"$ G? $0%'* #=$,*% -"#4"*; $" \$0% "GS%-$'M% 3=O]R V=#$ '#&'&$& $0=$ C,*'$? "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# -=# "#3? G% +%+,-%+ '4 O% -=# &0"O $0% ;"*=3 3=O $" "C%*=$% .'29"?2 29/ %//0 @"# 3?88(/1/%23 ,C"# $0% O'33R /0% =%&$0%$'- 0=& $" +%;"#&$*=$%< $0%*%4"*%< \'# O0=$ O=? $0% ;"*=3 3=O G%-";%& $0% +*'M%] _5NR 6ZH@`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`R _5NR 6ZK`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', @.

@@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

T%*% O% 0=M% $0% 4'*&$ =#+ C%*0=C& $0% "#3? -=&% O0%*%'# O% -=# +%$%*;'#% 4*"; * 8#'"#' -"#-%C$& $0% *%3=$'"# "4 = -":#'$'"# _0%*% = -":#'$'"# "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#` $" $0% 4%%3'#: "4 C3%=&,*% =#+ +'&C3%=&,*%R _5NR 6ZHA` /0% 4'*&$ %44%-$ "4 $0% 3=O '& #%:=$'M%R )$ &$*'N%& +"O# ",* &%#&,",& +%&'*%& '#=&;,-0 =& $0%? 4='3 $" ;%%$ '$& +%;=#+&R )$ %;%*:%& $0%*%G? =& &";%$0'#: #"#1%;C'*'-=3 +,% $" '$& '#+%C%#+%#-% "4 &%#&=$'"# _S,&$ =& $0% * 8#'"#' '#$,'$'"#& "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- $*=#&-%#+%+ &%#&=$'"# '# "*+%* $" :'M% '$ 4"*;`R U0=$ $0% 3=O C*%&%#$& '&< $0%*%4"*%< =# '#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#:< =# * 8#'"#' 4%%3'#:R /0'& 4%%3'#:< #%:=$'M%3? %(C%*'%#-%+ =& 0,;'3'=$'"#< '& C"&'$'M%3? C*%&%#$%+ =& *%&C%-$R V=#$ O*'$%&Z L%&C%-$ 4"* $0% ;"*=3 3=O R R R '& = 4%%3'#: C*"+,-%+ G? =# '#$%33%-$,=3 -=,&%< =#+ $0'& 4%%3'#: '& $0% "#3? "#% O0'-0 O% -=# N#"O -";C3%$%3? * 8#'"#' =#+ $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 O0'-0 O% -=# +'&-%*#R _5NR 6ZHA` /0% ;?&$%*? "4 $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- '& 0"O $" %(C3'-=$% $0'& &%%;'#:3? -"#$*=+'-$"*? $%*; \;"*=3 4%%3'#:]R )# %3,-'+=$'#: '$ 4,*$0%* V=#$ +'&$'#1 :,'&0%& G%$O%%# $0% #%:=$'M% =#+ C"&'$'M% %44%-$& "4 $0% ;"*=3 3=O "# 4%%3'#:R /0% #%:=$'M% %(C%*'%#-% '& 0,;'3'=$'"#R a,$ $0% :*",#+ "4 $0'& 0,;'3'=$'"# '& = 4%%3'#: "4 C"&'$'M% -0=*=-$%*Z *%&C%-$R /0'& C"&'$'M% :*",#+ _O0'-0 '$&%34< '# G%'#: +%$%*;'#'#:< O",3+ 4"*; = &,GS%-$ -=C1 =G3% "4 ;"*=3 =-$'"#` '& #"$< V=#$ $%33& ,&< = 4%%3'#: 4"* $0% 3=O< G,$ *=$0%* $0% \+'&3"+:;%#$] "4 *%&'&$=#-% $" '$R /0'& '& &$'33 "G&-,*% =#+ '$& "G&-,*'$? -3%=*3? *%&'+%& '# $0% -%#$*=3 +'44'-,3$? "4 %(C3'-=$'#: 0"O $0%*% -",3+ G% =# '#$%33%-$,=3 %44%-$ "# &%#&'G3% ;=$%*'=3R 2%%3'#:< =--"*+'#: $" V=#$< \'& &%#&,",&] =#+ $0% ;"*=3 +*'M%& ;,&$ G% 4*%% 4*"; &%#&,",& -"#+'$'"#R >" '$ '& #"$ $0% 4%%3'#:& $0=$ ;"M% ,& $" =+"C$ $0% ;"*=3 3=OR /0% -"#+'$'"# 4"* ,& 4%%3'#: *%&C%-$ 4"* $0% 3=O '& &%#&,",& =& 4%%3'#: %;%*:%& 4*"; &%#&%R a,$ $0% \-=,&%] "4 $0'& 4%%3'#: '& '#$%33%-$,=3R >" '$ '& #"$ $0=$ 4%%3'#:& 0=M% -0=#:%+ '# $0%'* #=$,*% ^ $0%? &$'33 =*% &%#&,",& ^ G,$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>"< $0% C*"G3%; "4 $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- -=# G% ;"*% 4,33? &$=$%+ =& 0"O $" %#&,*% $0=$ '# 3'4% $0% &%#&,",& &,GS%-$ O'33 $=N% C3%=&,*% '# =-$'#: =--"*+'#: $" $0% ;"*=3 3=OR /0% C*"G3%; O% 4=-% '& $0=$ O% +%&'*% "$0%* $0'#:& $0=# $0% 3=OR a%-=,&% "4 $0'& $0% 3=O ;,&$ =-$ $" $0O=*$ ",* &%#&,",& \'#-3'#=$'"#&] _B#'/7@/0/#` =#+ $0,& G% C*"+,-$'M% "4 C='#R 5& V=#$ C,$& '$Z

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', @A

R R R *%&C%-$ 4"* $0% 3=O '& #"$ $0% +*'M% $" ;"*=3'$?Y '$ '& ;"*=3'$? '$&%34< *%:=*+%+ &,GS%-$'M%3? =& = +*'M%< '#=&;,-0 =& C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#< G? *%S%-$'#: =33 $0% *'M=3 -3=';& "4 &%3413"M%< :'M%& =,$0"*'$? =#+ =G&"3,$% &"M%*%':#$? $" $0% 3=OR _5NR 6ZHD` U0=$ '#+,-%& $0'& *%&C%-$X b#3? $0% %(=;C3% "4 =#"$0%* C%*&"#R /" =#"$0%* C%*&"# _0"O%M%* 3"O $0%'* C"&'$'"#` \1: 1'%0 7".3] O0%$0%* ) O'&0 '$ "* #"$ O0%# 0% '33,&$*=$%& '# 0'& C%*&"# $0% 4=-$ "4 $0% ;"*=3 3=OR T% C*"M%& G? 0'& %(=;C3% $0=$ $0% 3=O '& $0%*% ^ '$ -=# G% "G%?%+ =#+ C,$ '#$" C*=-$'-%R /0'& %44%-$ '& $0,& +'*%-$3? 0,;'3'=$'#: =#+ ,#C3%=&,*=G3%< =#+ '#+'*%-$3? $0% C*"C%#&'$? $"O=*+& *%&C%-$ 4"* $0% 3=O =& %(%;C3'4'%+ G? $0% C%*&"# O0" 3'M%& =--"*+'#: $" '$R /0% '#0'G'$'"# "4 &%#&,",& -"#+,-$ _O0'-0 '& $0% ;='# "G&$=-3% $" ;"*=3 =-$'"#`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`R /0'& '& =#"$0%* C"'#$ =$ O0'-0 $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- +'&C3=?& = &';'3=*'$? O'$0 $0% 4'*&$R 5& $0% /*=#&-%#1 +%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- C*"M'+%+ ,& O'$0 $0% C,*% 4"*; "4 &%#&,",& '#$,'$'"# &" $0% \+*'M%& "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#] =*% *%M%=3%+ $" G% \$0% *%C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 = 3=O &';C3? =& $" '$& 4"*; =#+ #"$ "# =--",#$ "4 =#? "GS%-$ "4 $0% 3=O] _5NR 6ZIE`R /0% 4%%3'#: "4 *%&C%-$ O0%# $,*#%+ '#$" $0% ;"$'M% 4"* 4,$,*% =-$'"# C*"M'+%& ,& O'$0 = -"#&-'",&#%&& "4 +,$?R 7,$? $" G% ;"*=33? -";;%#+=G3% '& $0% ;"$'M% -=,&% "4 $0% =-$'"# _O% =-$ @#"1 +,$?` *=$0%* $0=# ;%*%3? $0% ",$O=*+3? -"**%-$ 4"*; "4 G%0=M'",* _=-$1 '#: *,,"#0'%) $" +,$?`R T=M'#: %&$=G3'&0%+ O0=$ $0% &%#&% "4 ;"*=3'$? '&< V=#$ #"O $,*#& $" %&$=G3'&0'#: $0% &",*-% "4 '$ '# ",* C%*&"#R T% &$=$%& $0=$ '$ '& $0% 4=-$ "4 C%*&"#0""+ '$&%34Z

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

$0%*% '& = 4%%3'#: O0"&% %;%*:%#-% '# $0% &%#&,",& &,GS%-$ '& C*"+,-%+ G? $0% '#$%*M%#$'"# "4 =# '#$%33%-$,=3 "GS%-$Z $0% 3=OR /0% 3=O &$*'C& ,& "4 4=3&% -3=';& $" %&$%%;R )# +"'#: &"< \'$ 3%&&%#& $0% "G&$=-3% $" C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#] =#+ C*";"$%& $0% &,C%*'"*'$? "4 $0% ;"*=3 %(=;C3% $" $0% &%#&,",&3? +%$%*;'#%+ =-$'"#R >"Z

)$ '& #"$0'#: %3&% $0=# 8/#3"%*('2:< 'R%R< $0% 4*%%+"; =#+ '#+%C%#+%#-% 4*"; $0% ;%-0=#'&; "4 #=$,*% *%:=*+%+ =& = -=C=-'$? "4 = G%'#: &,GS%-$ $" &C%-'=3 3=O& _C,*% C*=-$'-=3 3=O& :'M%# G? '$& "O# *%=&"#`< &" $0=$ $0% C%*&"# G%3"#:'#: $" $0% O"*3+ "4 &%#&% '& &,GS%-$ $" 0'& "O# C%*&"#=3'$? &" 4=* =& 0% G%3"#:& $" $0% '#$%33':'G3% O"*3+R 2"* '$ '& #"$ $" G% O"#+%*%+ =$ $0=$ ;=#< =& G%3"#:'#: $" $O" O"*3+&< ;,&$ *%:=*+ 0'& "O# G%'#: '# *%3=$'"# $" 0'& &%-"#+ =#+ 0':0%* M"-=$'"# O'$0 *%M%*%#-%< =#+ $0% 3=O& "4 $0'& M"-=$'"# O'$0 $0% +%%C%&$ *%&C%-$R _5NR 6ZIH` U0=$ O% -"#$='# O'$0'# ,& '& $0% =G'3'$? $" -":#'&% ",*&%3M%& '#$%33':'G3?R /0'& M%*? 4=-$ ^ $0=$ O% -=# #"$% $0=$ O% =*% #"$ C,*%3? &%#&,",& G,$ =3&" '#$%33':'G3% ^ '& $0% G=&'& 4"* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: ",*&%3M%& _=#+ $0"&% "4 $0% &=;% N'#+ =& ",*&%3M%&` ;"*=33?R 2"* $0% #"#1&%#&,",& &%34 '& $0% ;"*=3 &%34R /0'& ;"*=3 &%34 '&< =& #"#1&%#&,",&< *='&%+ =G"M% $0% -"#+'$'"# "4 C=&&'M% *%-%C$'M'$? O0'-0 O% 0=M% +'&-3"&%+ 4"* ,& '# $0% %(C"&'$'"#& "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R /0% *%M%3=$'"# "4 $0'& &%34 '& $0% ;%$=C0?1 &'-=3 %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'-R U% -=# #"O M'%O ",*&%3M%& =-$'M%3?R )$ $%33& ,& $0% &,C*%;% *,3% :"M%*#'#: ",* =-$'"# O'$0 *%:=*+ $" "$0%* C%*&"#&Z \$0% C%*&"# #%M%* G% ,&%+ =& = ;%=#& %(-%C$ O0%# 0% '& =$ $0% &=;% $';% $*%=$%+ =& =# %#+] _5NR 6ZIH`R /0'& -";C3%$%& $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"# "4 $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'-< G,$ '$ -=# "#3? G% 4,33? '#$%:*=$%+ '#$" $0% !*'$'-=3 &?&$%;< =#+ $0% *%3=$'"#& G%$O%%# $0% $O" =%&$0%$'-& G% ;=+% -3%=*< '4 O% =&&%&& &";% *%;=*N& '# $0% &,--%%+'#: &%-$'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"%< $0% \!*'$'-=3 B3,-'+=$'"# "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 8,*% 8*=-$'-=3 L%=&"#]R /0% S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 $0'& &,--%%+'#: &%-$'"# '& :'M%# ';;%+'=$%3? '# $0% "C%#'#: C=*=:*=C0R V=#$ $%33& ,& $0=$ = -*'$'-=3 %3,-'+=$'"# "4 = \&-'%#-% "* "#% "4 '$& C"*$'"#& $0=$ '& = &?&$%; G? '$&%34] '& \$0% '#M%&$':=1 $'"# =#+ S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 $0% 4=-$ $0=$ '$ ;,&$ 0=M% C*%-'&%3? $0% &?&$%;=1 $'- 4"*; O0'-0 '$ +"%& 0=M% =#+ #" "$0%*] _5NR 6ZKE`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@F C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', @6

/0% -"#-%C$ "4 -=,&=3'$? =& #=$,*=3 #%-%&&'$?< ,#3'N% $0% -"#-%C$ "4 -=,&=3'$? =& 4*%%+";< -"#-%*#& "#3? $0% %('&$%#-% "4 $0'#:& =& 4=* =& '$ '& +%$%*;'#=G3% '# $';%< =#+ -"#&%J,%#$3? =& =CC%=*=#-%& '# -"#$*=&$ $" $0%'* -=,&=3'$? =& $0'#:& '# $0%;&%3M%&R _5NR 6ZKF` )4 $0% -=,&=3 +%$%*;'#=$'"#& "4 =CC%=*=#-%& O%*% '#+%%+ "#% O'$0 $0% -=,&=3 +%$%*;'#=$'"#& "4 $0'#:& '# $0%;&%3M%&< $0%# 4*%%+"; O",3+ 0=M% $" 4=33 =& = #"$'"#R B=-0 %M%#$ O",3+ G% +%$%*;'#%+ G? $0"&% $0=$ 0=+ C*%-%+%+ '$ =#+ O",3+ $0%*%G? #"$ G% $0% -0"'-% "4 = &,GS%-$R /0'& O",3+ #%-%&&=*'3? *%#+%* %;C$? =#? =&-*'C$'"#& "4 C*='&% "* G3=;%< =#? %&$';=$'"#& "4 ;%*'$ "* +'&:*=-%R a,$ '4 O% 4"33"O $0% =*:,;%#$ "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-< $0%# O% O'33 &%% $0=$ $0% $%;C"*=3 ;"M%1 ;%#$& "4 -=,&=3'$? _O0'-0 V=#$ 0%*% -=33& $0% \;%-0=#'&; "4 #=$,*%]` G%3"#: $" $0% 4"*;& "4 4"*;=3 '#$,'$'"#< =#+ $0,& =*% =CC%=*=#-%& "4 4"*;=3 &%#&'G'3'$?R a,$ $0%? =*% #"$ $0% =-$'"# "4 $0'#:& '# $0%;&%3M%&R U'$0'# ,&< O% 0=M% $0% -"#&-'",&#%&& "4 = &%34 O0" M'%O& 0'& -"#+'$'"# 3?7 38/,'/ */2/#%*/ _"*< =& V=#$ C,$& '$< \3" @*# *3 '2 0"/3 %"2 32*%0 ?%0/# 2/18"#*( ,"%0'2'"%3]Z 5NR 6ZKH` =#+ $0,& O'$#%&&%& $" $0% &%34 O0'-0 '& #"$ = -*%=$,*% "4 =CC%=*=#-%& G,$ '& = &%341'#1'$&%34R /0'& &%341'#1'$&%34 :'M%& :*",#+& 4"* *%:*%$ =$ C=&$ =-$'"#< &" =&&,*'#: ,& $0=$ $0'#:& -",3+ 0=M% G%%# "$0%*O'&%R /0,& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% C,*% '#$,'$'"# "4 $';% '& :'M%# '# $0% S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 = $*,% &?#$0%$'- * 8#'"#' 4"*; "4 N#"O3%+:% ;=+% C"&&'G3% G? '$ =3"#%Z $0% N#"O3%+:% "4 ;"*=31 '$?R /0% 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'- $0,& C*"M'+%& $0% :*",#+& 4"* $0% &%-"#+R b*< =& V=#$ C,$& '$Z R R R ) -=##"$ -"#-%'M% 0"O $0"&% O0" C%*&'&$ '# &%%'#: &C=-% =#+ $';% =& =$$*'G,$%& G%3"#:'#: $" $0% %('&$%#-% "4 $0'#:& '# $0%;&%3M%& -=# =M"'+ 4=$=3'&; "4 =-$'"#&R _5NR 6Z.E.` /0% ,#'$? "4 $0% 4'*&$ =#+ &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'-& '& $0,& *%M%=3%+R /0% ;='# C"'#$ 0%*% '& $0=$ $0% 4'*&$ $O" =%&$0%$'-& C3=? M'$=3 *"3%& '# $0% *%&C%-$'M% -*'$'J,%& '# O0'-0 $0%? 4%=$,*% =#+ $0% 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'- C*"M'+%& $0% :*",#+& "4 $0% &%-"#+ _$0%*%G? %#&,*'#: $0=$ $0% S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 ;"*1 =3'$? '& ;=+% C"&&'G3%`R ) O'33 #"O $,*# $" %3=G"*=$'#: #"$ $0% ;='# *%&,3$& "* 4"*; "4 $0% $0'*+ =%&$0%$'- _O0'-0 O'33 G% +%=3$ O'$0 =$ &";% 3%#:$0 '# $0% -0=C$%*& $" -";%`< G,$ *=$0%* $0% *%=&"#& O0? V=#$ 0=+ $" O*'$% '$ =#+ $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

T% =++*%&&%& $0'& J,%&$'"# G? O=? "4 $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"#& "4 $0% /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R T% *%;'#+& ,&Z

@D C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

-"##%-$'"#& :'M%# G%$O%%# $0%&% *%=&"#& =#+ $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"#& "4 $0% 4'*&$ $O" =%&$0%$'-&R

)# = #"$% $" $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-< V=#$ $",-0%& "# $0% C%-,3'=* e%*;=# ,&% "4 $0% O"*+ \=%&$0%$'-] $" &':#'4? \O0=$ "$0%*& -=33 $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$%] [email protected]`R /0'& ,&% "4 $0% $%*; '& +%-3=*%+ $" G%3"#: $" $0% %#+%=M",* "4 a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`RD U0%*%=& $0% &%-"#+ %+'$'"# "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% G*'%43? ;%#$'"#& $0% #"$'"# $0=$ $0% ,&% "4 $0% $%*; \=%&$0%$'-] '# = -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% -",3+ G% =33"O%+ '4 '$ O=& *%=3'&%+ $0=$ '$ O=& G%'#: &0=*%+ O'$0 &C%-,3=$'M% C0'3"&"C0?< 0% #"#% $0% 3%&& &,::%&$& $0=$ = -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% -",3+ "#3? G% \C&?-0"3":'-=3] _aAD`R T=M'#: %($%#+%+ $0% $%*; '# $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%< 0"O%M%* _%M%# '4 0% &$=$%& $0% $%*; '& $0%*% G%'#: ,&%+ G? \=#=3":?]`< '$ '& 0=*+ $" O'$00"3+ *%-":#'$'"# "4 $0% -3=';& "4 = -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% $" '$R a,$ $0'& '# '$&%34 +"%& #"$ %(C3='# 0"O V=#$ -=;% $" M'%O $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% =& 0=M'#: =#? $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 _=#+ #"$ ;%*%3? C&?-0"3":'-=3` &':#'4'-=#-%R /" =++*%&& $0'& '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" $,*# '#'$'=33? $" $0% $O" '#$*"+,-$'"#& V=#$ O*"$% $" $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2< O0'-0 =*% $0% G=&'& 4"* -";'#: $" M'%O $0'& ;=$$%* '# =# =$ 3%=&$ C*%3';'#=*? O=?R V=#$ O*"$% $O" )#$*"+,-$'"#& $" $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2< $0% 4'*&$ '# .HIK^KE _,#C,G3'&0%+ ,#$'3 .K.F`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'-* =*"&+#& A-( .$ A"& 9*5*&&"1( $+ A1.$* !"# $%&'&()# *+ ,#-'"#'&. /)012#3'

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` #"* "4 *%=&"# _&,-0 =& $0% -=$%:"*'-=3 ';C%*=$'M% "4 $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%`< G,$ "4 S,+:;%#$R )# V=#$]& O"*+&Z \S,+:;%#$ C*%&,CC"&%& = &?&$%; "4 #=$,*% %M%# '# $%*;& "4 %;C'*'-=3 3=O&< =#+ '$ +"%& &" * 8#'"#' =#+ 0%#-% G? ;%=#& "4 = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C*'#-'C3%] _5NR @EZ@.@`R V=#$ #%($ '#4"*;& ,& _=#+ $0'& =--"*+& %#$'*%3? O'$0 $0% =--",#$ "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5#=3?$'-` $0=$ S,+:;%#$ '& $0% -=C=-'$? $" &,G&,;% = C=*$'-,3=* ,#+%* *,3%& =#+ $0=$ $0'& '& O0=$ "--,*& '# $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &-0%;=$'&; "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% _O0'-0 O% O'33 %(=;'#% '# !0=C$%* @ G%3"O`R 9,+:1 ;%#$ '& 0%*% *%M%=3%+ $" G% $O"14"3+Z '$ '& %'$0%* +%$%*;'#=$'M% "* *%1 43%-$'M%R U0%# '$ '& +%$%*;'#=$'M% '$ 0=& = *,3% :'M%# $" '$ '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 O0'-0 '$ +%$%*;'#%& $0% C=*$'-,3=* _'# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% $0'& '& = *,3% C*"M'+%+ G? $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< '# $0% >%-"#+ G? *%=&"#`R a,$ O0%# '$ '& *%43%-$'M% '$ +"%& #"$ 0=M% = *,3% :'M%# '# "*+%* $" &,G&,;% $0% C=*$'-,3=* =#+ $0,& 0=& $" 4'#+ $0'& *,3% '$&%34R )# $0,& 4'#+'#: = *,3%< \*%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ $*'%& $" G*'#: :'M%# =CC%=*1 =#-%& ,#+%* %;C'*'-=3 -"#-%C$& $" +%$%*;'#=$% #=$,*=3 $0'#:&< '$ +%=3& O'$0 $0%; 2/,9%',*((: *=$0%* $0=# &-0%;=$'-=33?] _5NR @[email protected]`R /0'& +'&1 $'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% $%-0#'-=3 =#+ &-0%;=$'- C*"-%+,*% "4 S,+:;%#$ '& *%&$=$%+ O0%# V=#$ O*'$%& $0=$ *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ \+"%& #"$ +%=3 O'$0 $0%; i$0% =CC%=*=#-%&j ;%-0=#'-=33?]< $0=$ '&< $0*",:0 $0% :,'+=#-% "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ $0% &%#&%& $*%=$'#: =CC%=*=#-%& =& =# '#&$*,;%#$ _"* ;%=#& $"O=*+& '#$,'$'"# =& '# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-`R L=$0%*< '$ +%=3& O'$0 =CC%=*=#-%& \*#2'32',*((:< '# $%*;& "4 = C*'#-'C3% $0=$ '& ,#'M%*&=3 G,$ =3&" '#+%$%*;'#=$%] _5NR @[email protected]`R /0'& C*'#-'C3% '& \= C,*1 C"&'M% =**=#:%;%#$ "4 #=$,*% '# = &?&$%;] _5NR @[email protected]`R )# =$$%;C$'#: $" S,&$'4? $0% ,&% "4 $0'& C*'#-'C3% "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& O0=$ V=#$ O'33 0=M% $" +" '& G*'#: ",$ 0"O $0% -"#-%C$ "4 =*$ _"* \2/,9%/]` =*'&%& =#+ O0=$ $0% -"##%-$'"# '& G%$O%%# =*$ =#+ $0% -":#'$'"# "4

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', @H

#=$,*% =& C"&&%&&'#: 3=O& _%(0'G'$'#: = #"#1-"#$'#:%#$ -0=*=-$%* +%&C'$% 0=M'#: "#3? %;C'*'-=3 -"#$%#$`R b#-% O% &%% $0% #%$O"*N "4 C*"G3%;& $0=$ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 '& '#$%#+%+ $" +%=3 O'$0 '$ G%-";%& -3%=*%* O0? '$ G*'#:& $":%$0%* $0% J,%&$'"# "4 = -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% O'$0 = -*'$'J,% "4 $%3%"3":?R /0% -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# $0%; '& $0% -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# = \3":'-=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&& '# $0% 4"*; "4 #=$,*%] _$%3%"3":?` =#+ =# =%&$0%$'C,*C"&'M%#%&& '# $0% 4"*; "4 #=$,*%R /0'& +'M'&'"# G%$O%%# 3":'-=3 =#+ =%&$0%$'- C,*C"&'M%#%&& $0,& *%C%=$& $0% +'M'&'"# "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% '#$" = /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- =#+ = /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 [":'-R 2,*$0%*1 ;"*%< =& '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%< $0% +'M'&'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 =33"-=$%& $0% C*'"* C=*$ "4 $0% %(C"&'$'"# $" $0% =%&$0%$'- *=$0%* $0=# $0% 3":'-R a%4"*% $,*#'#: G=-N $" $0% ';C"*$=#$ J,%&$'"# "4 O0? $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 =*$ =#+ $=&$% '& +%$%*;'#%+ G? V=#$ =& =# =%&$0%$'-< '$ '& 4'*&$ #%-%&&=*? $" %(C3"*% 4,*$0%* $0% +'M'&'"# G%$O%%# $0%&% $O" 4"*;& "4 C,*C"&'M%1 #%&& =#+ $0%'* +'&$'#-$ =--",#$& "4 $0% 4"*; "4 %;C'*'-=3 -":#'$'"#R )# dc)) "4 $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# V=#$ $%33& ,& $0=$ $0% 3":'-=3 C*'#-'C3% "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& \+"%& #"$ +%$%*;'#% =#?$0'#: *%:=*+'#: $0% 4"*;& "4 #=$,*=3 C*"+,-$&] =& '$ '& "#3? \= &,GS%-$'M% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% +'M'&'"# =#+ &C%-'4'-=$'"# "4 #=$,*%] _5NR @[email protected]`R /0'& '& =#"$0%* O=? "4 &C%-'4?1 '#: $0=$ O0=$ O% =*% 0%*% +'&-3"&'#: '& = *%43%-$'M% =#+ #"$ +%$%*;'#=$'M% _"* -"#&$'$,$'M%` =-$ "4 S,+:;%#$R /0% -"#&%J,%#-% "4 $0'& '& #"O +*=O#Z \'$ '& =-$,=33? $0% 8"./# "@ J?0)1/%2 $0=$ '& $%-0#'-=3] _5NR @EZ@@E`R 9,+:;%#$< '# *%43%-$'"#< 1*-/3 * (*.R /0% J,%&$ 4"* 0"O S,+:1 ;%#$ +"%& $0'& *%J,'*%& =# =%&$0%$'- =#+ 3":'-=3 %(=;'#=$'"# "4 '$& C"O%*R 5$ $0'& C"'#$ O% ;,&$ $,*# $" $0% *%=&"# :'M%# '# $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# 4"* $0% ,&% "4 $0% $%*; \=%&$0%$'-] '# *%3=$'"# $" $=&$% =#+ =*$R >%-$'"# c))) "4 $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# '& %#$'$3%+ \b# $0% 5%&$0%$'- "4 $0% 8"O%* "4 9,+:'#:]R T%*% V=#$ *%0%=*&%& $0% 4=-$ _=& ;%#$'"#%+ '# $0% /*=#&-%#1 +%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-` $0=$ '$ '& "#3? '# *%3=$'"# $" \$0% 4"*; "4 &%#&'G'3'$?] $0=$ $0% $%*; \=%&$0%$'-] 0=& =# ,#=;G':,",& &%#&% _=#+ O% &=O $0=$ $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- 0=+ $" +*=O ,C"# $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"#& "4 $0% 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'- '# "*+%* $" O"*N`R a,$< 0% 0%*% -"#-%+%& $0=$ $0% $%*; =%&1 $0%$'-< \'R%R< &%#&'G3%]< 0=& G%-";% ,&%+ $" *%4%* $" $0% -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 =# "GS%-$ =#+ = 4%%3'#: "4 C3%=&,*% =#+ +'&C3%=&,*%R W"O '$ '& $*,% $0=$ _'# 3'#% O'$0 $0'& ;%=#'#: "4 $0% $%*; =%&$0%$'-` O% =*% '# $0% 0=G'$ "4 -=33'#: $0'& 4%%3'#: $"" = &%#&% _= ;"+'4'-=$'"# "4 ",* &$=$%`< &'#-% O% 0=M% #" "$0%* $%*; 4"* '$R _5NR @EZ@@@`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@I C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

a,$ $0'& 4%%3'#: '& #"$ = &%#&% '# $0% ;%=#'#: "4 = +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 $0% "GS%-$ G? -":#'$'"#R 5#+ $0'& '& $0% *%=&"# O0? V=#$ *%4,&%& $" =--%C$ $0=$ $0%*% -",3+ G% = &-'%#-% _Q'33/%3,9*@2` "4 4%%3'#:< =#+ $0,& +"%& #"$ G%3'%M% $0=$ $0%*% '& =# =%&$0%$'- "4 4%%3'#: '# $0% &%#&% $0=$ $0%*% '& =# =%&$0%$'- "4 -":#'$'"#R a,$ '4 O% =*% $" &C%=N "4 =# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$< $0%# $0'& -=##"$ G% $=N%# $" *%4%* $" '#$,'$'"# &'#-% =#? +%$%*;'#=$'M% S,+:;%#$ ;,&$ G% = 3":'-=3 ;"M%;%#$ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: _O0'-0 '& O0? $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 S,+:;%#$ "4 $0% 4'*&$ -*'$'J,% '& '#-3,+%+ ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5#=3?$'-`R 5$ $0'& C"'#$ O% #%%+ $" *%4%* =:='# $" $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 S,+:;%#$ =#+ *%1%(=;'#% $0%'* ;"+% "4 "C%*=$'"#R 5& V=#$ C,$& '$< \'# $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$ O% -"#&'+%* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ ';=:'#=$'"# =& $0%? *%3=$% $" %=-0 "$0%*] _5NR @EZ@@A` =#+ $0'& -=# G% +"#% '# $O" O=?&R U0%# O% -"#&'+%* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ ';=:'#=$'"# =& G%3"#:'#: $" $0% -":#'$'"# "4 =# "GS%-$< $0%# O% 0=M% $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &-0%;=$'&;R a,$ O0%# O% -"#&'+%* $0%; \'#&"4=* =& "#% "* $0% "$0%* "4 $0%&% C"O%*& 4,*$0%*& "* 0'#+%*& $0% "$0%* '# "#% =#+ $0% &=;% C*%&%#$=$'"# =#+ $0%*%G? =44%-$& "#%]& 1/%2*( 32*2/]< $0%# O% 0=M% = &,GS%-$'M% *%3=$'"# $0=$ \,*% 7/ 3/%3/0] _5NR @EZ@@A`R /0% &%#&=$'"# _D18@'%0?%)` $0=$ *%&,3$& '& %M'+%#$3? #"$ -"##%-$%+ $" $0% '#$,'$'"#=3 4"*; "4 -":#'$'"#R /0,& '$ '& #"$ = C=*$ "4 * 8#'"#' &%#&'G'3'$? '#=&;,-0 =& O% *%&$*'-$ $0'& $" $0% -":#'$'"# "4 =# "GS%-$ _O0'-0 O% +" O0%# '&"3=$'#: &%#&'G'3'$? 4*"; ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '# "*+%* $" +'&-"M%* O0=$ \$0",:0$ =& = ;%=#&] '& +'*%-$%+ $"`R a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` =#+ $0,& 0"3+& $0% ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '# = &$=$% "4 *%3=$'"# $0=$ 0=*;"#'",&3? -*%=$%& = &%#&=$'"# O0'-0 O% -=33 = 4%%3'#: "4 C3%=&,*%R /0% *%43%-$'M% =%&$0%$'S,+:;%#$ '& $0,& C*"+,-%+ $0*",:0 =# =-$'M'$? "4 -""*+'#=$'"# G%$O%%# -":#'$'M% C"O%*&R /0%*% '& =3&" =#"$0%* 4"*; "4 =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$< 0"O%M%*Z $0% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ "4 &%#&%R /0'& S,+:;%#$ "--,*& O0%#1 %M%* \$0% C*%+'-=$% "4 $0% S,+:;%#$ ,*%%"2 7/ = -"#-%C$ "4 $0% "GS%-$ =$ =33] _5NR @EZ@@F`< O0'-0 "--,*& '# &$=$%;%#$& =G",$ $0% =:*%%=G3%#%&& "4 &%#&=$'"#R /0'& &%-"#+ 4"*; "4 =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ '& $0% %(C*%&&'"# "4 =

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', @K

+'*%-$ *%4%*%#-% "4 = C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 &%#&% $" 4%%3'#: O0'-0 +"%& #"$ '#M"3M% -":#'$'"# =$ =33R /0'& &%-"#+ 4"*; "4 =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ '& $0,& &';C3%* =#+ ;"*% +'*%-$< O0'3&$ G%'#: ;%*%3? %;C'*'-=3 '# -"#$%#$R /0% G=&'& +%$%*;'#'#: =# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ "4 =#? &"*$ '& $0,& #%M%* = -"#-%C$ _"4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:` G,$ =3O=?& = &%#&=$'"# _"4 -""*+'#=$% ,#'$? "4 -":#'$'M% C"O%*& "* "4 =:*%%=G3%#%&& C*"+,-%+ G? = +'*%-$ 4%%3'#: O0'-0 +"%& #"$ '#M"3M% =#? -":#'$'"#`R /0'& &%#&=$'"# -=# "#3?< 0"O%M%*< G% = &%#&=$'"# "4 C3%=&,*% "* +'&C3%=&,*% =& \=33 "$0%* &%#&=$'"# -=# G% ,&%+ 4"* -":#'$'"#] _5NR @EZ@@F`R /0,& =%&$0%$'- S,+:1 ;%#$& =*% =33 S,+:;%#$& "4 C3%=&,*% "* +'&C3%=&,*%R /0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ '& #"O -3=*'4'%+ 4,*$0%* G? V=#$R T% O*'$%&Z 5# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ "4 &%#&% -"#$='#& ;=$%*'=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&&Y =# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ "4 *%43%-$'"#< 4"*;=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&&R _5NR @EZ@@F` )# $0% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ "4 &%#&% $0%*% '& #" *%4%*%#-% $" -":#'$'"# =#+ 4"* $0'& *%=&"# $0'& S,+:;%#$ '& #"$ G=&%+ "# $0% C*'#-'C3%& "4 S,+:;%#$ G,$ '& = ;=$%*'=3 *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# %;C'*'-=3 -"#$%#$&R a? -"#$*=&$ = *%43%-$'M% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ '& C*"+,-%+ G? = $0",:0$ "4 &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& 3%=+'#: $" = &%#&=$'"# "4 C3%=&,*% =#+ '& $0,& -"##%-$%+ $" $0% C*'#-'C3%& "4 S,+:;%#$ '$&%34R a%-=,&% $0'& 3=$$%* 4"*; "4 =%&$0%$'S,+:;%#$ '& -"##%-$%+ $" $0% C*'#-'C3%& "4 S,+:;%#$ '$ -3=';& ,#'M%*&=3 =&&%#$ '# '$& =&&%&&;%#$& "4 C3%=&,*% %M%# $0",:0< =& = 4%%3'#:< C3%=&,*% -=# "#3? %M%* G% =%&$0%$'-R /0% G=&'& "4 $0'& ,#'M%*&=3 -3='; _O0'-0 #%M%* =$$=-0%& $" =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$& "4 &%#&%` '& $0=$ $0% *%43%-$'M% =%&$0%$'S,+:;%#$ '& +%$%*;'#%+ #"$ G? $0% 4%%3'#: "4 C3%=&,*% '$&%34< G,$ G? = #?(/ "4 $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$R /0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0'& "C%*=$'"# '& O0=$ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 ;,&$ ,#-"M%*R >" $0% O0"3% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 '& = -*'$'J,% "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$< $0% 4'*&$ 0=34 "4 $0% O"*N -"#&$'$,$'#: $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$< $0% &%-"#+ 0=34 '$& 3":'- _$%3%"3":?`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

G*'#: ",$ '& O0=$ $0'& &%-"#+ )#$*"+,-$'"# =++& $" _"* $=N%& 4*";` $0% =--",#$ :'M%# '# $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"#R /0% &%-"#+ )#$*"+,-$'"# '& J,'-N $" ;=N% -3%=* $0=$ O0=$ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 '& -"#-%*#%+ O'$0 '& C,*% S,+:;%#$ _&$=$%+ '# dA` =#+ &C%33& ",$ $0% 4=-$ _;"*% 3=G"*'",&3? +%;"#&$*=$%+ '# $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"#` $0=$ '# =&&%&&'#: =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ '$ '& 4"*;=3 _"* *%43%-$'M%` S,+:;%#$ $0=$ O'33 G% +'&-,&&%+R V=#$ '& =3&" J,'-N%* 0%*% $" ;=N% -3%=* O0=$ $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '# :%#%*=3 _'#-3,+'#: G"$0 '$& =%&$0%$'- =#+ '$& 3":'-` '&Z $0% \(*. "@ 29/ 38/,'@',*2'"% "@ %*2?#/ '# $%*;& "4 '$& %;C'*'-=3 3=O&] _5NR 6Z.ID`R /0'& 3=O *%J,'*%& $0=$ #=$,*% G% -":#'k=G3% &?&$%;=$'-=33? _=#+ $0,& C,*C"&'M%3?`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`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` '& '$& 3":'-=3 M=3'+'$?R _5NR 6Z.II^K` /0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 =# "GS%-$ '# *%4%*%#-% $" $0% &,GS%-$ '& =# =%&$0%$'-R /0% =%&$0%$'- '& $0,& +%$%*;'#%+ #"#1-":#'$'M%3?R /0'& 0=*;"#'&%& -";1 C3%$%3? O'$0 $0% =--",#$ "4 =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ :'M%# '# $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"1 +,-$'"#< O'$0 $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- _O0'-0 +'+ #"$ '#M"3M% "GS%-$'M% -":#'$'"#` =#+ %M%# O'$0 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- _O0'-0 *%3'%& "# $0% "GS%-$ 0=M'#: =3*%=+? G%%# :'M%# $" '$ =#+ +"%& #"$ '$&%34 C*"+,-% $0% "GS%-$`R >" V=#$ 0%*% :'M%& ,& = :%#%*=3 -0=*=-$%*'&$'- "4 =#? N'#+ "4 =%&$0%$'-R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', A.

U0'3&$ $0% &%-"#+ =#+ 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'-& =*% #"$ $0% -":#'$'M% +%$%*;'#1 =$'"# "4 "GS%-$&< $0% 4'*&$ +"%& C*"M'+% = G=&'& 4"* &,-0 -":#'$'"# =#+ $0% &%-"#+ $0% G=&'& 4"* $0% -":#'$'M% +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 ;"*=3'$?R a"$0 -=# $0%*%4"*% G%-";% %3%;%#$& "4 -":#'$'"#R a,$ $0%*% '& =# =%&$0%$'- _&,G1 S%-$'M%` 4%=$,*% "4 $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 =# "GS%-$ O0'-0 -=# #%M%* G%-";% =# %3%;%#$ "4 '$& -":#'$'"# =#+ $0'& '& \$0% 8(/*3?#/ "* 0'38(/*3?#/ -"#1 #%-$%+ O'$0 $0=$ C*%&%#$=$'"#] _5NR 6Z.IK`R 2,*$0%*;"*%< $0% C%*-%C$'"# "4 =# "GS%-$ =& C"&&%&&%+ "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& '& =3&" = &,GS%-$'M% 4%=$,*% "4 C*%&%#$=$'"# =& C,*C"&'M%#%&& -=##"$ G% C%*-%'M%+ '# $0% "GS%-$ G,$ "#3? '# $0% &%#&=$'"# "4 C%*-%C$'"#R 5& V=#$ C,$& '$Z 5 S,+:;%#$ "4 $0'& &"*$ '& =# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ =G",$ $0% "GS%-$]& C,*C"&'M%#%&&Y '$ '& #"$ G=&%+ "# =#? -"#-%C$ O% 0=M% "4 $0% "GS%-$< #"* +"%& '$ C*"M'+% &,-0 = -"#-%C$R _5NR 6Z.KE` U0%# $0'& S,+:;%#$ '& ;=+% O% 0=M% S,+:%+ $0% 4"*; "4 $0% "GS%-$ $0*",:0 *%43%-$'"# $" G% $0% G=&'& "4 = C3%=&,*%R /0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 S,+:1 '#: G? *%4%*%#-% $" $0'& &,GS%-$'M% &$=#+=*+ "4 C3%=&,*% '& O0=$ O% $%*; \$=&$%]R U0%# $=&$% C*"M'+%& ,& O'$0 &,-0 =# =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 =# "GS%-$ O% -=33 $0=$ "GS%-$ G%=,$'4,3R T"O%M%*< 0% #%($ &,CC3%;%#$& $0'& =--",#$ O'$0 $0% ;%#$'"# _=3&" +'&-,&&%+ '# $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"#` "4 &,G3';'$?R /0% &,GS%-$'M% *%-%C$'M1 '$? "4 = C3%=&,*% +%*'M%+ 4*"; = *%43%-$'"# "# 4"*; ;=? G% *%3=$%+ #"$ $" $0% -"#-%C$ "4 #=$,*% _= &$=#+=*+ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O0'-0 '& =$ O"*N '# S,+:;%#$& "4 G%=,$?`< G,$ *=$0%* $" $0% -"#-%C$ "4 4*%%+"; _$0% &$=#+=*+ "4 *%=&"#`R /0%*%4"*%Z R R R #"$ =33 =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$& =*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%< O0'-0 =& &,-0 *%4%* $" $0% G%=,$'4,3Y G,$ &";% "4 $0%; =*'&% 4*"; =# '#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#: =#+ =& &,-0 *%4%* $" $0% 3?7('1/< &" $0=$ $0'& !*'$'J,% "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$ ;,&$ G% +'M'+%+ '#$" $O" ;='# C=*$& -"**%&C"#+1 '#: $" $0%&%R _5NR 6Z.K@` >" $0% #%O =--",#$ "4 =%&$0%$'- $0=$ '& =##",#-%+ '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 '& #"$ "#3? =# =--",#$ "4 $=&$%R /=&$% '& $0%*%G? *%M%=3%+ $" G% $0% -=C=-'$? $" S,+:% $0*",:0 $0% *%4%*%#-% $" $0% C"O%* "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ '$& -"#-%C$'"# "4 #=$,*=3 *,3%&R /0'& #"$'"# "4 $=&$% _O0'-0 '& C,*%` '& '#$';=$%3? 3'#N%+ $" $0% =-$'M'$? "4 $0% /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- O0'-0 -"#+'$'"#%+ $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% $*=#&-%#1 +%#$=3 3":'- ,#+%*3?'#: $0% -"#-%C$ "4 #=$,*%R )#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#:< "# $0% "$0%* 0=#+< *%4%*& ,& G=-N $" $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'-< O0'-0 +'&-,&&%+

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

A@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

$0% \&,G3';%] 4%%3'#: "4 *%&C%-$ 4"* $0% %(0'G'$'"# "4 =# %(%;C3=* "4 ;"*=3'$?R /0% $O" ;='# C=*$& "4 $0% $0'*+ =%&$0%$'- *%4%* G=-N $0%# $" $0% 4'*&$ $O" =%&$0%$'-&R /0% &%-"#+ )#$*"+,-$'"# O0'-0< G? -";C=*'&"# O'$0 $0% 4'*&$< '& J,'-N%* $" +%;"#&$*=$% O0=$ = C,*% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ '&< :'M%& = 4,33%* =--",#$ "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ =#+ = #%O3? '#-3,&'M% +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 $0% $%*; \=%&$0%$'-]R a%-=,&% "4 $0% 4"*%&0"*$%#'#: "4 $0% :%#%*=3 +'&-,&1 &'"# =G",$ $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# $0% $0*%% -*'$'J,%& '# $0% &%-"#+ )#$*"+,-$'"# $0%*% '& =3&" =##",#-%+ ;"*% -3%=*3? $0% 3';'$=$'"#& "4 = -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% _O0'-0 ;,&$ G% = -*'$'J,% "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 G%=,$? =3"#%` =#+ = &0=*C +%;=*-=$'"# "4 $0'& 4*"; = -*'$'J,% "4 '#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#: _$0'& O=& =3&" :'M%# '# $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# G,$ 0%*% '$ ;"*% %=&'3? -";;=#+& ",* =$$%#$'"#`R /0% +'44%*%#-%& G%$O%%# $0% $O" )#$*"+,-1 $'"#& =*% #"$ O'$0",$ ';C"*$=#-% G,$ $0%? ?'%3+ $0% S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 $0% %($%#&'"# "4 $0% $%*; \=%&$0%$'-] '# = G*"=+3? &';'3=* ;=##%*R T=M'#: :'M%# $0'& S,&$'4'-=$'"# O% 0=M% #"O 4,34'33%+ $0% $=&N "4 &0"O'#: $0% *%=&"# O0? '$ O=& #%-%&&=*? $" O*'$% $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2R U% -=# #"O $,*# $" %(=;'#'#: $0% *%=&"#& $0'& +'&-,&&'"# 0=& :'M%# ,& $" G%3'%M% $0=$ $0% -*'$'-=3 &?&$%; *%&$& ,C"# $0% C"&$,3=$'"# "4 =# "M%*1 =33 =%&$0%$'-R

'-* B(#5-).# +, >1.$.5"7 6-.7+&+)-(C " D*#*1"7 8*&$-*$.5 U0=$ ",* +'&-,&&'"# 0=& $0,& 4=* +%;"#&$*=$%+ '& $0=$ $0% $0*%% =%&1 $0%$'-& =33 -"#&$'$,$% = M%*? ';C"*$=#$ C=*$ "4 $0% -*'$'J,%& $" O0'-0 $0%? =*% =$$=-0%+R U0'3&$ $0'& '& O%33 N#"O# '# $0% -=&% "4 $0% $0'*+ =%&$0%$'_O0'-0 -";C*'&%& 0=34 "4 $0% $0'*+ -*'$'J,% =#+ $0% *%=+'#: "4 O0'-0 0=& C*"M'+%+ $0% '+%#$'4'-=$'"# "4 \=%&$0%$'-] O'$0 \$=&$%] ^ =# '+%#$'4'-=$'"# %"2 S,&$'4'%+ '# $0% $%*;& "4 $0'& M%*? -*'$'J,%` =#+ C=*$'=33? =-N#"O31 %+:%+ '# $0% -=&% "4 $0% 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'-< [%O'& U0'$% a%-N '& *=*% '# :'M'#: =#? =$$%#$'"# =$ =33 $" $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- =#+ %M%# 0% ;'#';'&%& $0% -"##%-$'"#& G%$O%%# $0'& =#+ $0% 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'- _$0",:0 0% %;C0=&'&%& $0% -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% &%-"#+ =#+ $0% $0'*+ =%&$0%$'-&`R 7%&C'$% $0'& 3=-N "4 =$$%#$'"#< '$ '& $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- O0'-0 ;"&$ 4"*-%4,33? +%;"#&$*=$%& $0% '#$%*-"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# =33 $0*%% =%&$0%$'-&R /0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- '& &$=$%+ G? V=#$ $" G% +%C%#+%#$ "# $0% 4'*&$R b#3? $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"# '# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- $0=$ &C=-% =#+ $';% =*% C,*% '#$,'$'"#& %#=G3%& ,& $" ,#+%*&$=#+ $0=$ ;"*=3'$? -=# *%4%* $" $0% =$%;C"*=3 #",;%#=3 &%34 O0'-0 S,&$'4'%& ,& '# ;=N'#: ;"*=3 &$=$%;%#$&R /0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- '& G"$0 $0% C*"M'#: :*",#+ "4 $0% O0"3% &%-"#+ -*'$'J,% +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 ;"*=3'$?< =#+ =3&" $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B9#//H@"(0 ;%3/#2'"% "@ 29/ +/329/2', AA

$*=#&-%#+%#$=3 %(C"&'$'"# "4 $';% O0'-0 O=& 3=-N'#: 4*"; $0% /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R 2,*$0%*;"*%< $0% =--",#$ "4 *%&C%-$ :'M%# '# $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- C"'#$& 4"*O=*+ $" $0% =--",#$ "4 '#$%33%-$,=3 4*%%+"; $0=$ O'33 G% :'M%# '# $0% $0'*+ =%&$0%$'-R /0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- '& $0,& $0% 0'#:% G%$O%%# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- =#+ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2R /0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- '& $0% G=&'& "4 $0% 4"*;=3 +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 $0% C*'#-'C3%& "4 &%#&'G3% N#"O3%+:% =#+ '$& -"#+'$'"#& "4 C"&&'G'3'$?R e'M%# $0'& +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 '$< $0% &%-"#+ =%&$0%$'- -=# G% $*%=$%+ '% 2"2" =& =# %($%#&'"# "4 $0% 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'- _O0'-0 '& O0=$ '& ;%=#$ G? +%&-*'G1 '#: $0% &%-"#+ =& = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 %(C"&'$'"# "4 $';%`R /0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% "C%*=$%& =--"*+'#: $" = -"#-%C$ "4 #=$,*% =#+ '& $0,& C"&&'G3% G%-=,&% $0% 4'*&$ -*'$'J,%]& +%;"#&$*=$'"# "4 $0% *,3%& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: *%&$& ,C"# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R /0% $0'*+ =%&$0%$'- *%&$& "# $0% 4'*&$ O'$0 '$& =--",#$ "4 $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% =#+ "# $0% &%-"#+ O'$0 '$& -*'$'J,% "4 '#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#:R 533 $0*%% =%&$0%$'-& =*% $0%*%4"*% ;,$,=33? +%C%#+%#$R a,$ $0% &':#'4'-=#-% "4 $0'& +%C%#+&< '# $0% 4'*&$ '#&$=#-%< "# &0"O'#: $0% ';C"*$=#-% "4 $0% /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- 4"* $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R U0'3&$ ) 0=M% G%:,# $0=$ $=&N 0%*%< '$ O'33 #"O G% #%-%&&=*? $" $,*# $" $0% $=&N "4 ';=:'#=$'"# '# $0% 4'*&$ -*'$'J,% =#+ $" -"##%-$ $0'& $" $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R b# $0% G=&'& "4 O0=$ 0=& G%%# +%;"#&$*=$%+ $0,& 4=*< 0"O%M%*< O% -=# &%% $0=$ $0% $%*; \=%&$0%$'-] 0=& = -"#&'&$%#-? "4 ,&% G%$O%%# $0% $0*%% -*'$'J,%& =#+ '# %=-0 "4 $0%; $0% \=%&$0%$'-] C3=?& =# ';C"*$=#$ *"3%R U% -=# =3&" &%% $0=$ O% #"O 0=M% *%=&"#& $" G%3'%M% $0=$ $0% $0*%% =%&$0%$'-& =*% '#$%*3"-N%+ =#+ $0=$ $0'& C*"M'+%& $0% G=&'& 4"* C"&$,3=$'#: $0=$ $0%*% '& = :%#%*=3 =%&$0%$'-R ) O'33 #"O $,*# $" 4,*$0%* %3=G"*=$'#: $0% -"##%-1 $'"# G%$O%%# $0% 4'*&$ =%&$0%$'- =#+ $0% $0'*+R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

@

b#% "4 $0% :*%=$%&$ -"#$*"M%*&'%& '# V=#$ &-0"3=*&0'C -"#-%*#& $0% *%=+1 '#: "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7%+,-$'"#R. V=#$ 0';&%34 O=& O%33 =O=*% "4 $0% +'44'-,3$? "4 $0% +'&-,&&'"# ,#+%*$=N%# '# $0'& &%-$'"# "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R )# $0% 8*%4=-% $" $0% 4'*&$ %+'$'"# 0% +%&-*'G%+ $0% \%#J,'*'%&] ,#+%*$=N%# $0%*% =& ;"&$ ';C"*$=#$ 4"* \%(C3"*'#: $0% 4=-,3$? O% %#$'$3% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< =#+ 4"* +%$%*;'#'#: $0% *,3%& =#+ 3';'$& "4 '$& %;C3"?1 ;%#$] _5(M'` =#+ =& 0=M'#: -"&$ 0'; \$0% :*%=$%&$ 3=G",*]R /0% %#J,'*? '& &$=$%+ $0%*% $" 0=M% $O" &'+%&R b#% *%4%*& $" \$0% "GS%-$& "4 C,*% ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#:] =#+ '& '#$%#+%+ $" \%(C",#+ =#+ *%#+%* '#$%33':'G3% $0% "GS%-1 $'M% M=3'+'$? "4 '$& * 8#'"#' -"#-%C$&]< O0'-0 '& \%&&%#$'=3] 4"* V=#$]& C,*C"&%& _5(M'`R /0% "$0%* &'+% &%%N& $" '#M%&$':=$% $0% C,*% ,#+%*&$=#+1 '#: '$&%34< \'$& C"&&'G'3'$? =#+ $0% -":#'$'M% 4=-,3$'%& ,C"# O0'-0 '$ *%&$&]< =#+ '& $0%*%4"*% -"#-%*#%+ O'$0 $0% &,GS%-$'M% =&C%-$& "4 $0% 4=-,3$?R /0'& 3=$$%* &'+% "4 $0% '#M%&$':=$'"# '& \"4 :*%=$ ';C"*$=#-% 4"* ;? -0'%4 C,*C"&%]< G,$ \'$ +"%& #"$ 4"*; =# %&&%#$'=3 C=*$ "4 '$] _5(M'^(M''`R T% '& -"#-%*#%+ $" &$*%&& $0=$ %M%# '4 $0% &,GS%-$'M% &'+% "4 $0% +%+,-$'"# +"%& #"$ -"#M'#-%< $0'& +"%& #"$ $",-0 0'& "GS%-$'M% +%;"#&$*=$'"#R )# $0% 8*%4=-% $" $0% &%-"#+ %+'$'"# "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% V=#$ =+;'$& $0=$ $0% +%+,-$'"# =& "*':'#=33? -=&$ O=& \"G&-,*%] =#+ $0,& S,&$'4'%& 0=M'#: *%-=&$ $0'& &%-$'"# _a(((M'''`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/*=#&-%#+%#$=3 );=:'#=$'"#< >-0%;=$'&; =#+ 9,+:;%#$

=&C%-$& -=# G% +%$%*;'#%+ =& $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +%+,-$'"# "4 $0% "GS%-$& "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +%+,-$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '$&%34R U0=$ ) O=#$ $" G*'#: '#$" *%3'%4 0%*% '& $0=$ $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +%+,-$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '$&%34 '& -%#$*=3 $" $0% $=&N "4 &%$$'#: ",$ $0% e%#%*=3 5%&$0%$'- ,#+%*3?'#: $0% O0"3% !*'$'-=3 &?&$%;R )# =++'$'"# $" +%;"#&$*=$'#: 0"O $0% 517%+,-$'"# 4,*$0%*& $0'& =--",#$ "4 $0% !*'$'-=3 &?&$%;< ) O'33 =3&" +'&-,&& $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# $0% 51 7%+,-$'"# =#+ $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 8,*% 8*=-$'-=3 L%=&"#R ) O'33 =3&" &0"O $0% -"##%-$'"#& G%$O%%# $0% 7%+,-$'"# =#+ $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-< $0% -"##%-$'"# "4 G"$0 $" $0% >-0%;=$'&;< =#+ 0"O $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% 5%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ *%-=&$& $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C& G%$O%%# ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ S,+:;%#$R

'-* ?.,,*1*#$ E*#&*& +, FG2"0.#"$.+#% a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a,$ '4 $0'& ;=#'4"3+ '& $" G% N#"O#< $0% &C"#$=#%'$? "4 ",* $0",:0$ *%J,'*%& $0=$ '$ G% :"#% $0*",:0 '# = -%*$='# O=?< $=N%# ,C< =#+ -"##%-$%+R /0'& =-$ ) #=;% 3:%29/3'3R _5HHfa.E@` >?#$0%&'& '&< '# :%#%*=3< $0% =-$ "4 C,$$'#: +'44%*%#$ *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& $":%$0%* =#+ \:*=&C'#:] i7/)#/'@/%j $0%; '# = ;=#'4"3+ '# = ,#'$=*? -";G'#=$'"# $0=$ O% #=;% \N#"O3%+:%]R 5 C,*% &?#$0%&'& *%3=$%& $" =# * 8#'"#' ;=#'4"3+R >" = C,*% &?#$0%&'& C*"+,-%& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 * 8#'"#' N#"O3%+:%< =# %;C'*'-=3 &?#$0%&'& * 8"32/#'"#' N#"O3%+:%R )# M'%O "4 $0% C*';=*? *"3% "4 &?#$0%&'& =# =#=3?&'& "4 '$& "C%*=$'"#& ;,&$ 4"*; C=*$ "4 = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 3":'-R /0%*% =*% $O" ';;%+'=$%3? &,*C*'&'#: 4=-$& $" #"$% =G",$ &?#$0%&'&R /0% 4'*&$ '& '$& -"##%-$'"# O'$0 ';=:'#=$'"#R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AD C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

AH

>?#$0%&'& '# :%#%*=3< =& O% &0=33 0%*%=4$%* &%%< '& $0% ;%*% *%&,3$ "4 $0% C"O%* "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< = G3'#+ G,$ '#+'&C%#&=G3% 4,#-$'"# "4 $0% &",3< O'$0",$ O0'-0 O% &0",3+ 0=M% #" N#"O3%+:% O0=$&"%M%*< G,$ "4 O0'-0 O% =*% &-=*-%3? %M%* -"#&-'",&R /" G*'#: $0'& &?#$0%&'& 2" ,"%H ,/823 '& = 4,#-$'"# O0'-0 G%3"#:& $" $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< =#+ '$ '& $0*",:0 $0'& 4,#-$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $0=$ O% 4'*&$ "G$='# N#"O3%+:% C*"C%*3? &" -=33%+R _5HIfa.EA`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a.6.`R >"< &?#1 $0%&'& '& #"$ ;%*%3? $0% \4'*&$ "*':'#] "4 N#"O3%+:% G,$ '& =3&" 29/ ,"%0'2'"% @"# *%: -%".(/0)/ =#+ $0% G=&'& "4 $0% =-$ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:]& -"#1 -%C$,=3'&=$'"# "4 '#$,'$'"#R )# "$0%* O"*+&< '# &" 4=* =& ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =-$& $*=#&-%#+%#$=33?< '$ ;,&$ G% = C*"+,-$ "4 $0% "*':'#=3 * 8#'"#' =-$'"# "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#R /0'& '& &$=$%+ -3%=*3? %#",:0 '# $0% 517%+,-$'"#Z R R R $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% #%-%&&=*? ,#'$? "4 C,*% _C*"+,-$'M%` &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< C*'"* $" =CC%*-%C$'"#< '& $0% :*",#+ "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =33 N#"O3%+:%< %&C%-'=33? "4 %(C%*'%#-%R _5..I`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`R /0% *%C*"+,-$'M% &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# V=#$ $0,& -=33& \$0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 4=-,3$? "4 ';=:'#=$'"#] _5.E@`R )# $0% a17%+,-$'"#< 0"O%M%*< V=#$ +'&$'#:,'&0%& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# 4*"; *%C*"+,-$'M% ';=:'#=$'"#Y $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% 3=$$%* '& #"O &='+ $" G% \%#$'*%3? &,GS%-$ $" %;C'*'-=3 3=O&] _a.6@` '#&$%=+ "4 C*"+,-$'M% "4 $0%;R U0'3&$ $0%*% '& = -3%=* C*"G3%; O'$0 $0%&% $O" +'44%*%#$ =--",#$& "4 *%C*"+,-$'M% &?#$0%&'& O0=$ $0% -"#4,&'"# '#+'-=$%& '& = +%&'*% "# V=#$]&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

C=*$ $" +'&$'#:,'&0 G%$O%%# $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =#+ %;C'*'-=3 &?#$0%&%& "4 ';=:'#=$'"#R /0% J,%&$'"# 0%*% '& $0=$ '4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# '& #"$ = &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"#< $0%# O0=$ $*=#&-%#+%#1 $=3 G=&'& %('&$& 4"* $0'& %;C'*'-=3 &?#$0%&'&X ) &,::%&$ $0=$ $0*%% +'&$'#-$ =-$& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# #%%+ $" G% +'&$'#:,'&0%+Z _.` $0% "*':'#=3 &?#$0%&'& O0'-0 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: G*'#:& $" -"#-%C$& ^ $0'& '& =3&" +%&-*'G%+ =& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"# O0'-0 G*'#:& = *,3% $" $0% "GS%-$& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"#Y _@` = ;%+'=$'#: *"3% G%$O%%# &%#&'G'3'$? =#+ ,#+%*&$=#+'#:Y =#+ _A`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a17%+,-$'"# =#+ $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,%R

'-* 8:?*4;5$.+#H G2"0.#"$.+# "#4 $-* '1"#&5*#4*#$"7 8*&$-*$.5 /0% C,*C"&% "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7%+,-$'"# '& &$=$%+ $" G% $0% +'&1 -"M%*? "4 \$0% * 8#'"#' -"#+'$'"#& ,C"# O0'-0 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 %(C%*'1 %#-% *%&$&] _5K6^D`R /0% -=$%:"*'%& =*% &='+ $" C*"M'+% ,& O'$0 \$0% C,*% $0",:0$ '#M"3M%+ '# %M%*? %(C%*'%#-%] _5KD` =#+ O0=$ $0% +%+,-$'"# O'33 &%$ ",$ $" &0"O '& $0=$ '$ '& G? $0%'* ;%=#& =3"#% $0=$ =# "GS%-$ -=# G% $0",:0$R /0% J,%&$'"# '& 0"O *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& =*% G*",:0$ $":%$0%* '# $0=$ *%3=$'"# $" "GS%-$& O% -=33 N#"O3%+:% &" $0=$ O% -=# -3='; $" ,#+%*&$=#+ O0=$ \%(C%*'%#-%] -"#&'&$& '#R 5& &%#&% -"#$='#& = ;=#'4"3+ '# '$& '#$,'$'"#< ) =&-*'G% $" '$ = &?#"C&'&R a,$ $" &,-0 &?#"C&'& = &?#$0%&'& ;,&$ =3O=?& -"**%&C"#+Y *%-%C$'M'$? -=# ;=N% N#"O3%+:% C"&&'G3% "#3? O0%# -";G'#%+ O'$0 &C"#$=#%'$?R _5KH` /0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 *%-%C$'M'$? =*% O0=$ O% 0=M% %3=G"*=$%+ '# $0% /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R )$ '& G=&%+ "# $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 * 8#'"#' '#$,'$'"#R >C"#$=#%'$?< G? -"#$*=&$< '& \$0% :*",#+ "4 = $0*%%4"3+ &?#$0%&'&] O0'-0 0=& $" G% 4",#+ '# =33 N#"O3%+:%R /0% $0*%%4"3+ &?#$0%&'& -"#$='#& =& '$& -"#&$'$,$'M% ;";%#$& &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# '# '#$,'$'"#< &?#1 $0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"# '# ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ &?#$0%&'& "4 *%-":#'$'"# '# =

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AI C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

AK

-"#-%C$R 5& V=#$ =++&Z \/0%&% C"'#$ $" $0*%% &,GS%-$'M% &",*-%& "4 N#"O31 %+:% O0'-0 ;=N% C"&&'G3% $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '$&%34 R R R] _5KH^I`R T% C*"-%%+& $" &%$ ",$ C=&&=:%& '#$%#+%+ $" \C*%C=*% *=$0%* $0=# '#&$*,-$] _5KI` O0'-0 :'M% C*%3';'#=*? =--",#$& "4 %=-0 C=*$ "4 $0% $0*%%4"3+ &?#$0%&'&R /0% 4'*&$ =&C%-$ "4 $0% $0*%%4"3+ &?#$0%&'&< $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#1 &'"# '# '#$,'$'"#< '& C*%4=-%+ '# '$& %(C"&'$'"# G? =# ';C"*$=#$ C*%3';'#1 =*? *%;=*N $%33'#: ,& $0=$ =33 *%C*%&%#$=$'"#&< =& ;"+'4'-=$'"#& "4 K/1?W2< G%3"#: $" '##%* &%#&%R \533 ",* N#"O3%+:% '& $0,& 4'#=33? &,GS%-$ $" $';%< $0% 4"*;=3 -"#+'$'"# "4 '##%* &%#&%] _5KI^K`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`R /0% C%*4"*;=#-% "4 $0'& 0"3+'#: $":%$0%* '# $0% *,#1 #'#: $0*",:0 "4 $0% ,#'$? "4 $0% '#$,'$'"# '& O0=$ V=#$ #=;%& $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"#R U'$0",$ $0'& &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# O% &0",3+ #%M%* 0=M% $0% * 8#'"#' *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& "4 &C=-% =#+ $';%R \/0%? -=# G% C*"+,-%+ "#3? $0*",:0 $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ O0'-0 &%#&'G'3'$? C*%&%#$& '# '$& "*':'#=3 *%-%C$'M'$?] _5KK^.EE`R )4 $0'& '& &"< $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- 0=& = -"#+'$'"#< #"$ *%M%=3%+ '# '$& %(C"&'1 $'"#< O0'-0 '& $0'& "*':'#=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 *%-%C$'M'$?R e'M%# $0=$ $0% +=$= "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- =*% -3%=*3? $0% "#3? G=&'& 4"* %3=G"*=$'"# "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 [":'- "4 O0'-0 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7%+,-$'"# '& = C=*$< O% O",3+ 0=M% :*",#+& 4"* &,*C*'&% =$ $0'& #%O&R a,$ O0=$ '& *%M%=3%+ 0%*% '&< '# 4=-$< -"#:*,%#$ O'$0 $0% 3":'-=3 C*'"*'$? "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R U0=$ O=& +%;"#&$*=$%+ '# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#1 $=3 5%&$0%$'- '& $0=$ $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# =CC%=*=#-%& =#+ $0'#:& '# $0%;&%3M%& =CC3'%& $" $0% ;"&$ G=&'- -"#$%#$ "4 %;C'*'-=3 '#$,'$'"#Z $0% 4"*;& "4 C,*% '#$,'$'"#R e'M%# $0'& +%;"#&$*=$'"# '$ 4"33"O& $0=$ O0=$ $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 [":'- ;,&$ +%;"#&$*=$% '& 0"O '$ '& C"&&'G3% 4"* $0%&% * 8#'"#' '#$,'$'"#& $" G% -":#'&%+ =$ =33 G? ,&R 5#+< '$ '& $0'& O0'-0 O% +'&-"M%* '# $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# '# '#$,'$'"#< C=*$'-,3=*3? O0%# O% ,#+%*&$=#+ '$ =& ;%*%3? "#% ;";%#$ "4 = $0*%%14"3+ &?#$0%&'&R /0% "*':'#=3 *%-%C$'M'$? "4 &%#&'G'3'$? '& O0=$ O% +'&-"M%* '# $0% &?#1 $0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"#R a,$ =& O% 0=M% =3*%=+? +'&-,&&%+< ,#3%&& $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# O=& -"##%-$%+ $" $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-1 $'"# '# ';=:'#=$'"#< $0%# $0% "GS%-$& "4 '#$,'$'"# O",3+ 3=-N &$=G'3'$? =#+

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

O",3+ #"$ G% ,#+%*&$=#+=G3% O0%# *%1-":#'&%+ =& $0% \&=;%]R /0%*%4"*%Z \/0% &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# '& R R R '#&%C=*=G3? G",#+ ,C O'$0 $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"#] _5.E@`R 2,*$0%*;"*%< $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# '& #%-%&&=*? \=& -"#+'$'"#'#: $0% M%*? C"&&'G'1 3'$? "4 =33 %(C%*'%#-%] _5.E.`R /0% $0'*+ =&C%-$ "4 $0% $0*%%14"3+ &?#$0%&'& '& #%-%&&=*? G%-=,&% = -"#-%C$ '& #%%+%+ $" &%*M% =& = *,3% "4 *%-":#'$'"# "4 $0% "GS%-$ '# '#$,'$'"#R \/0'& "*':'#=3 =#+ $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 -"#+'$'"# '& #" "$0%* $0=# 2#*%3,/%0/%2*( *88/#,/82'"%] _5.ED^H`R /0'& 0=& $" G% +'&$'#:,'&0%+ 4*"; %;C'*'-=3 =CC%*-%C$'"#< O0'-0 3=$$%* '& =3&" $%*;%+ \'##%* &%#&%] _$0% -"#&$=#$ *,3% O0'-0 :"M%*#& *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& '# $0% 4"*; "4 $';%`R /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =CC%*-%C$'"#< $0% *,3% O0'-0 :"M%*#& $0% %;C'*'-=3 #%-%&&'$? "4 $';%1-"#&-'",&#%&&< '& = \C,*% "*':'#=3 ,#-0=#:%=G3% -"#1 &-'",&#%&&] "4 $0% #%-%&&=*? ,#'$? "4 -"#&-'",&#%&& O0'-0 O% ;,&$ ,#+%*&$=#+ $" G% $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 $0% &=;% -"#&-'",&#%&& =CC*%0%#+'#: "GS%-$&R )# "$0%* O"*+&< =CC%=*=#-%& '# %(C%*'%#-% ;,&$ &$=#+ ,#+%* $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0% #%-%&&=*? ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"#< S,&$ =& '# ;%*% '#$,'$'"# $0%? ;,&$ G% &,GS%-$ $" $0% 4"*;=3 -"#+'$'"#& "4 &C=-% =#+ "4 $';%R _5..E`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`R U% 0=M% &%%# $0=$ $0% $0*%% &",*-%& "4 N#"O3%+:% =*% '#$%**%3=$%+ =#+ $0=$ '$ '& $0%'* -";G'#=$'"# O0'-0 C*"+,-%& $0=$ *%3=$'"# $" $0% ;=#'4"3+ $0=$ %#=G3%& ,& $" -3='; \N#"O3%+:%] "4 \%(C%*'%#-%]R a,$ '4 O% O",3+ ,#+%*&$=#+ 0"O $0% $0*%% ;";%#$& -"#M%*:%< O% ;,&$ G%:'# O'$0 C,*% =CC%*-%C$'"# _5..D`R \/0% &?#$0%$'- C*"C"&'$'"#< $0=$ =33 $0% M=*'%$? "4 /18'#',*( ,"%H 3,'"?3%/33 ;,&$ G% -";G'#%+ '# "#% &'#:3% &%341-"#&-'",&#%&&< '& $0% *73"(?2/(: 4'*&$ =#+ &?#$0%$'- C*'#-'C3% "4 ",* $0",:0$ '# :%#%*=3] _5..H`R T=M'#: &$=$%+ $0'& #%-%&&'$? "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# G%'#: $=N%# =& $0% 4'*&$ C*'#-'C3%< 0% $0%# -"##%-$& $0% -%#$*=3'$? "4 $0'& C*'#-'C3% O'$0 $0% =-$'M'$? "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#Z

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

FE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

F.

/0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# $0,& *%3=$%& $" $0% C,*% &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< =& =# * 8#'"#' -"#+'$'"# "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =33 -";G'#=$'"# "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ '# "#% N#"O3%+:%R a,$ "#3? $0% 8#"0?,2'G/ &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# -=# $=N% C3=-% * 8#'"#'Y $0% *%C*"+,-$'M% *%&$& ,C"# %;C'*'-=3 -"#+'$'"#&R /0,& $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% #%-%&&=*? ,#'$? "4 C,*% _C*"+,-$'M%` &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< C*'"* $" =CC%*-%C$'"#< '& $0% :*",#+ "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =33 N#"O31 %+:%< %&C%-'=33? "4 %(C%*'%#-%R _5..I` /0%*% =*% &";% "GM'",& C*"G3%;& O'$0 $0'& &$=$%;%#$R 2'*&$< V=#$ &,+1 +%#3? *%&$*'-$& $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"# G? ';=:'#=$'"# $" =# %;C'*'-=3 :*",#+ 0=M'#: S,&$ +%$%*;'#%+ '$ =& = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =-$ _5.E@`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` /0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '& *%3=$%+ "#3? $" $0% * 8#'"#' -";G'#=$'"# "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ _O0'-0 '& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"#` =#+ '& G"$0 -"#+'$'"# =#+ -"#+'$'"#%+ '# *%3=$'"# $" $0'& * 8#'"#' -";G'#=$'"#R /0% C,*% 4"*; "4 N#"O3%+:% '& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# _$0% &?#$0%&'& '& ,#'4'%+ G? $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# O0'-0 '&< 0"O%M%*< :'M%# -"#$%#$ "#3? G? $0% ';=:'#=$'"#]& $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 *%C*"+,-$'"# "4 $0% ;"+%& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 '#$,'$'"#`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

F@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

a? -"#$*=&$ $" $0% %;C'*'-=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"# O% 0=M% $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =& %(C*%&&%+ '# = ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# $0*",:0 $';%R a? -"#$*=&$ O'$0 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# =& -"#+'1 $'"# =#+ -"#+'$'"#%+ "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# O% 0=M% $0% C*"+,-$& "4 $0% C,*% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O0'-0 =*% $0% -=$%:"*'%& _5..K`R /0'& -"#-3,+%& $0% C*":*%&&'M% %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% +%+,-$'"# 4*"; * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3%&R V=#$ #"O :'M%& = *%:*%&&'M% %(C"&'$'"# G%:'##'#: 4*"; $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 %(C%*'%#-%R 5CC%=*=#-% '& $0% C*';=*? +=$= 0%*% O0'-0 -"**%&C"#+& $" $0% C*';=*? +=$= "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*1 -%C$'"#R U0%# O% -";G'#% =CC%=*=#-% O'$0 -"#&-'",&#%&& O% 0=M% C%*-%C$'"#R a,$ &'#-% %=-0 =CC%=*=#-% -"#$='#& = ;=#'4"3+< =#+ &'#-% $0% ;=#'4"3+ 0=& O'$0'# '$ &%C=*=$% C%*-%C$'"#& O0'-0 %('&$ '# +'&$'#-1 $'"# 4*"; %=-0 "$0%*< $0%*% ;,&$ "4 #%-%&&'$? G% O'$0'# ,& =# =-$'M% C"O%* 4"* $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+R \/" $0'& 4=-,3$? ) :'M% $0% $'$3%< ';=:'#=$'"#] _5.@E`R )4 $0% C,*% C*"+,-$'M% &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# '& $0% -";G'#=$'"# "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ '#$" = C,*% 4"*;< $0%# '$& =-$'"# '& $0% &=;% =& $0=$ %=*3'%* +%&-*'G%+ =& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"1 +,-$'"# '# ';=:'#=$'"# _5.E@`R );=:'#=$'"# \0=& $" G*'#: $0% ;=#'4"3+ "4 '#$,'$'"# '#$" $0% 4"*; "4 =# ';=:%] _5.@.` G,$ $" +" &" '$ ;,&$ 4'*&$ 0=M% =CC*%0%#+%+ $0%; _O0'-0 -"#4'*;& $0=$ $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%1 0%#&'"# '# '#$,'$'"# '& =3*%=+? = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =-$ "4 ';=:'#=$'"#`R 2"* ';=:'#=$'"# $" G% =G3% $" G*'#: $":%$0%* '#$" = -";G'#=$'"# $0% +'M%*&% %3%;%#$& "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ '$ ;,&$ 0=M% = :*",#+ $" *%:=*+ =CC%=*=#-%& =& &,GS%-$ $" ,#'M%*&=3 *,3%&R \/0'& "GS%-$'M% :*",#+ "4 =33 =&&"-'=$'"# "4 =CC%=*=#-%& ) %#$'$3% $0%'* *@@'%'2:R )$ '& #"O0%*% $" G% 4",#+ &=M% '# $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# R R R] _5.@@`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`@

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ ?%'2: "@ *88/#,/82'"% '% #/(*2'"% 2" 29/ 3:%29/3'3 "@ '1*)'%*2'"% '& $0% ?%0/#32*%0'%)Y =#+ $0'& &=;% ,#'$?< O'$0 *%4%*%#-% $" $0% 2#*%3,/%0/%H 2*( 3:%29/3'3 "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#< $0% 8?#/ ?%0/#32*%0'%)R _5..K`

FA

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`R )$ '& #"O $0=$ V=#$ $%33& ,& $0=$ O0=$ $0% ';=:'#=$'"# +"%& $0=$ '& $*,3? '#+'&C%#1 &=G3% '& $" G*'#: '#$" *%3=$'"# $0% ;=#'4"3+ "4 '#$,'$'"# =#+ $0% ,#'$? "4 C,*% =CC%*-%C$'"#R )$ $0,& ;%+'=$%& G%$O%%# &%#&'G'3'$? =#+ $0% $*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R /0,& O% 0=M% +'&-"M%*%+ '# $0% 517%+,-$'"# $0% $0*%% 4,#-$'"#& "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# O0'-0 ) &$=$%+ '$ O",3+ G% &0"O# $" 0=M% G%4"*% O% ,#+%*$""N $0'& -3"&% %(=;'#=$'"# "4 $0% 7%+,-$'"#R /0% ';=:'#=$'"# 0=& $0*%% 4,#+=;%#$=33? +'&$'#-$ *"3%&Z _.` '$ C*"M'+%& $0% "*':'#=3 =-$ "4 *%-%C$'M'$?< $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# =#+ -";G'#%& $0'& '# = $*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"# O'$0 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 "GS%-$& 4=331 '#: ,#+%* *,3%& '# = &?#$0%&'& "4 *%-":#'$'"# '# = -"#-%C$Y _@` '$ C%*4"*;& =# %;C'*'-=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"# O0'-0 $=N%& '$& -"#$%#$ 4*"; $0% C,*% 4"*; "4 $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 *%C*"+,-$'"#Y =#+ _A`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g $R e%;,

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

FF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

T=M'#: :'M%# =# '#$%*C*%$=$'"# "4 &";% "4 $0% 4,#+=;%#$=3 ;"M%& "4 $0% 517%+,-$'"# '$ '& O"*$0 C=,&'#: $" '#+'-=$% O0=$ 0=& #"$ G%%# =$$%;C$%+ '# $0'& %(C"&'$'"#R ) 0=M% #"$ =$$%;C$%+ $" &0"O 0"O $0'& +%+,-$'"# =#&O%*& '$& 4,#+=;%#$=3 C,*C"&% "4 +%;"#1 &$*=$'#: $0=$ "#3? $0% -=$%:"*'%& C*"M'+% ,& O'$0 $0% C,*% $0",:0$ '#M"3M%+ '# %M%*? %(C%*'%#-%R W"* O'33 ) +" $0'& O'$0 $0% a17%+,-$'"#R P? -"#-%*# '& O'$0 $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% *"3% "4 ';=:'#=$'"# '# $0% $O" +'44%*%#$ +%+,-$'"#& =#+ ) O'33 =$$%;C$ $" G*'#: '#$" *%3'%4 0"O $0% =--",#$ "4 ';=:'#=$'"# '& *%3=$%+ $" $0% =--",#$ "4 S,+:;%#$ '# "*+%* $" S,&$'4? ;? C*'#-'C=3 -"#$%#$'"# $0=$ $0% O0"3% !*'$'-=3 C0'3"&"C0? *%J,'*%& =& '$& G=&'- -"#+'$'"# = e%#%*=3 5%&$0%$'- O0'-0 '& %3=G"*=$%+ '# $0% ,#'4?'#: '#$%#$'"# "4 $0% O0"3% C*"S%-$R a%4"*% $,*#'#: $" $0% a17%+,-$'"# $" =&&%&& O0%$0%* $0% -%#$*=3 *"3% "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '& $0%*% =G=#+"#%+< "* ;%*%3? *%4"*;,3=$%+< ) O'33 4'*&$ 3""N =$ $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 8,*% 8*=-$'-=3 L%=&"#R ) O'33 =#=3?&% 0%*%< =& '# ;? 4'*&$ -0=C$%*< "#3? $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% -"##%-$'"#& G%$O%%# ;"*=3'$? =#+ &%#&'G'3'$?R U0%*%=& '# $0% C*%M'",& +'&-,&&'"# ) O=& '#$%*%&$%+ '# +%;"#&$*=$'#: $0=$ C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# -"#$='#& =# =%&$0%$'- "4 '$& "O# _=#+ $0% O=? $0'& '& +%$%*;'#%+` O0=$ ) O'33 #"O +'&-,&& '& $0% =--",#$ "4 $0% &-0%;= "4 4*%%+"; '# "*+%* $" *%0%=*&% $0% *%=&"#& O0? V=#$ :'M%& #" &,G&$=#$'M% *"3% $" ';=:'#=$'"# '# 0'& %$0'-&R /0'& O'33 G% -"##%-$%+ $" $0% *%=+'#: "4 $0% &-0%;=$'&; "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% $0=$ ) O'33 ,#+%*$=N% 3=$%* '# $0'& -0=C$%*R )# $0% &%-"#+ -0=C$%* "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 8,*% 8*=-$'-=3 L%=&"# %#$'$3%+ \/0% !"#-%C$ "4 5# bGS%-$ "4 8,*% 8*=-$'-=3 L%=&"#]< V=#$ &%$& ",$ $0% -=$%:"*'%& "4 4*%%+"; =#+< 0=M'#: +"#% &"< &-0%;=$'&%& $0%&% -=$%:"*'%& '# $0% &%-$'"# %#$'$3%+ \b4 $0% /?C'- "4 $0% 8,*% 8*=-$'-=3 2=-,3$? "4 9,+:;%#$]R /0% 4=-,3$? "4 C*=-$'-=3 S,+:;%#$ =CC3'%& O0=$ '& =&&%*$%+ '# $0% ,#'M%*&=3 *,3% $" $0% -"#-*%$% :'M%# =-$'"#R U0=$ '$ *%J,'*%& '& *%-",*&% $" = 3=O O0'-0 +%C%#+& #"$ "# #=$,*% G,$ "# 4*%%+";R /0% *%=&"# '& $0=$ $0% "GS%-$& "4 C*=-$'-=3 S,+:;%#$ =*% &,C%*1 &%#&,",& =#+ $0%*%4"*% \#"$0'#: -"**%&C"#+'#:] $" $0%; \-=# G% 4",#+ '# &%#&'G3% '#$,'$'"#] _5NR 6ZDI`R /0'& *%J,'*%& ,&< 0"O%M%*< $" M'%O =-$'"#& '# = +",G3% =&C%-$Z =& C0?&'-=3< =#+ $0,& G%3"#:'#: $" $0% O"*3+ "4 #=$,*%Y =#+ =3&" =& '#$%33':'G3%< =#+ G%3"#:'#: $" $0% O"*3+ "4 4*%%+";R /0% +'&$'#-$'"# 0=& &";% ';C"*$=#$ -"#&%J,%#-%& 4"* $0% 4"*; "4 = &-0%;= "4 4*%%+"; =#+ 0"O '$ &$=#+& '# *%3=$'"# $" ';=:'#=$'"#Z

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'-* 8#"7($.5 +, 6;1* 61"5$.5"7 =*"&+#

F6

/0% C0?&'-=3 -=,&=3'$? "* $0% -"#+'$'"# ,#+%* O0'-0 '$ "--,*& G%3"#:& =;"#: $0% -"#-%C$& "4 #=$,*%< O0"&% &-0%;= '& &N%$-0%+ G? $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ';=:'#=$'"#R T%*%< 0"O%M%*< O% =*% -"#-%*#%+ #"$ O'$0 $0% &-0%;= "4 = -=&% "--,**'#: =--"*+'#: $" 3=O& G,$ O'$0 $0% &-0%;= _'4 $0'& O"*+ '& &,'$=G3% 0%*%` "4 = 3=O '$&%34< G%-=,&% $0% +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 $0% O'33 $0*",:0 3=O =3"#% =#+ O'$0",$ =#? "$0%* +%$%*;'#'#: :*",#+ _=#+ #"$ $0% =-$'"# O'$0 *%4%*%#-% $" '$& -"#1 &%J,%#-%&` -"##%-$& $0% -"#-%C$ "4 -=,&=3'$? $" -"#+'$'"#& =3$":%$0%* +'44%*%#$ 4*"; $0"&% O0'-0 -"#&$'$,$% -"##%-$'"# '# #=$,*%R _5NR 6ZDI^K` /0% -"#+'$'"# ,#+%* O0'-0 =# =-$'"#]& +%&-*'C$'"# 4=33& ,#+%* $0% -"#1 -%C$& "4 #=$,*% '& C*"M'+%+ G? $0% &-0%;= %(%-,$%+ G? $0% $*=#&-%#+%#1 $=3 ';=:'#=$'"#R U% O'33 +'&-,&& $0'& 4,*$0%* G%3"OR T"O%M%*< O0=$ '& -3%=* =$ $0'& C"'#$ '& $0=$ &,-0 = &-0%;= *%J,'*%& ,& $" -"**%3=$% = -=&% O'$0 $0% 3=O '$ 4=33& ,#+%*R a,$ O'$0 $0% &-0%;= "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# O% #%%+ #"$ = -"**%3=$'"# "4 -=&% O'$0 3=O< G,$ *=$0%*< = +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% 3=O '$&%34< =& $0'& 3=O &$=#+& ,#+%* +'44%*%#$ -"#+'1 $'"#& $" $0% 3=O& "4 #=$,*%< :'M%# $0=$ '$ '& = 3=O "4 4*%%+";R )# -"#+'$'"#& "4 #=$,*% = &-0%;= '& \= ,#'M%*&=3 C*"-%+,*% "4 ';=:'#=$'"#] _5NR 6ZDK`R a,$ G%-=,&% ';=:'#=$'"# *%J,'*%& *%4%*%#-% $" -"#+'$'"#& "4 &%#&'G'3'$?< =--%C$'#: $0=$ 3=O& "4 4*%%+"; =*% #"$ -"#+'$'"#& "4 &%#&'1 G'3'$?< = &-0%;= "4 4*%%+"; -=##"$ G% G=&%+ "# =# =-$'"# "4 $0% $*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 ';=:'#=$'"#R /0%*%4"*%Z R R R $0% ;"*=3 3=O 0=& #" "$0%* -":#'$'M% 4=-,3$? $" ;%+'=$% '$& =CC3'-=$'"# $" "GS%-$& "4 #=$,*% $0=# $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: _#"$ $0% ';=:'#=$'"#`Y =#+ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: -=# &,CC3? $" =# )+%= "4 *%=&"# #"$ = &-0%;= "4 &%#&'G'3'$? G,$ = 3=OR /0'& 3=O< =& "#% O0'-0 -=# G% %(0'G'$%+ '% ,"%,#/2" '# "GS%-$& "4 $0% &%#&%&< '& = #=$,*=3 3=O< G,$ "#3? '# '$& 4"*;R /0'& 3=O -=# &%*M% $0% C,*C"&% "4 $0% 4=-,3$? "4 S,+:;%#$< =#+ '$ ;=?< $0%*%4"*%< G% -=33%+ $0% 2:8/ "4 $0% ;"*=3 3=OR _5NR 6ZDK` /0% -"#$%#$ "4 $0% 3=O '& #"$ #=$,*=3 G,$ ;"*=3< G,$ '$& 4"*; _:'M%# $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 &";% ;%+'=$"* G%$O%%# '$& )+%= =#+ $0% 4"*;& "4 &%#&'G'3'$?` '& #=$,*=3 +,% $" $0% 4=-$ $0=$< O0=$ 0%*% =-$& =& = ;%+'=$"* G%$O%%# '$& -"#-%C$ =#+ '$& "GS%-$ '& #"$ ';=:'#=$'"# _=& $0'& O",3+ 3%=+ $" = ;%*%3? C=$0"3":'-=3 +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 ;"*=3'$? =#+ 0%#-% $" $0% +%&$*,-$'"# "4 $0% C,*'$? "4 ;"*=3 -"#-%C$&`< G,$ *=$0%* $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R /0% *,3% "4 $0% 4=-,3$? "4 S,+:;%#$ ,#+%* 3=O& "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# '& $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

-=$%:"*'-=3 ';C%*=$'M% _=#+ = 4"*; "4 &$=$%;%#$ "4 '$ '& :'M%# =$ 5NR 6ZDK`R U% -=# ,&% $0% $?C% "4 = 3=O "4 #=$,*% 4"* $0% '#$%33':'G3% O"*3+ &" 3"#: =& O% +" #"$ '33'-'$3? =&&,;% $0=$ $0'& :'M%& ,& =#? '#$,'$'"#=3 &%#&% =G",$ $0'& O"*3+ _O0'-0 -",3+ "#3? G% $0",:0$ C"&&'G3% G? =&&,;1 '#: $0=$ $0% &-0%;= "4 4*%%+"; +%C%#+%+ ,C"# ';=:'#=$'"# *=$0%* $0=# ,#+%*&$=#+'#:`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

'-* I:?*4;5$.+# /0% a17%+,-$'"# G%:'#& O'$0 = +'44%*%#$ J,%&$'"# 4*"; $0% 517%+,-1 $'"#R U0%*%=& $0% 3=$$%* &%$& ",$ $" &0"O $0=$ -=$%:"*'%& =*% $0% "#3? G=&'& G? O0'-0 =# "GS%-$ -=# G% $0",:0$< $0% 4"*;%* G%:'#& ';;%+'=$%3? O'$0 $0% J,%&$'"# "4 0"O '$ '& C"&&'G3% 4"* ,& $" G% :'M%# = ;=#'4"3+ "4 *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& '# = -";G'#=$'"#R >'#-% $0'& -=##"$ G% =# =-$ "4 &?#"C1 &'& "4 &%#&%< G,$ ;,&$ *%J,'*% = &?#$0%&'&< O% =*% ';;%+'=$%3? &%$ $0% $=&N "4 &%=*-0'#: 4"* $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% &?#$0%&'& $0=$ C*"+,-%& -";G'#=1 $'"#R e'M%# $0=$ -";G'#=$'"# "4 = ;=#'4"3+ *%J,'*%& _=--"*+'#: $" $0% 51 7%+,-$'"#` = &?#$0%&'& "4 *%-":#'$'"# '# = -"#-%C$< $0%# '$ O",3+ 4"33"O $0=$ $0% a17%+,-$'"# G%:'#& 4*"; $0% $0'*+ ;";%#$ "4 $0% $0*%%4"3+ &?#$0%&'&R /0'& '& &$=$%+ G? V=#$ O0" $%33& ,&< ,#&,*C*'&'#:3?< $0=$ =33 -";G'#=$'"# \'& =# =-$ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:] _a.AE`< $0",:0 &";%O0=$ &,*C*'&'#:3?< =++& $0=$ $0'& '& $*,% O0%$0%* "* #"$ O% =*% -"#&-'",& "4 $0% -";G'#=$'"#R /" $0'& =-$ i"4 -";G'#=$'"# G? $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:j $0% :%#%*=3 $'$3% \&?#$0%&'&] ;=? G% =&&':#%+< =& '#+'-=$'#: $0=$ O% -=##"$ *%C*%&%#$ $" ",*&%3M%& =#?$0'#: =& -";G'#%+ '# $0% "GS%-$ O0'-0 O% 0=M% #"$ ",*&%3M%& C*%M'",&3? -";G'#%+< =#+ $0=$ "4 =33 *%C*%&%#$=$'"#&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

FD C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

FH

>?#$0%&'& '& &$=$%+ %M%# '# $0% &%-"#+ %+'$'"# "4 $0% O"*N $" G% $0% =-$ "4 ';=:'#=$'"# _a.EA`< &" '$ '& "++ $0=$ V=#$ O*'$%& 0%*% $0=$ '$ '& =# =-$ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:RA /0% *%C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 -";G'#=$'"# '# = ;=#'4"3+ '& O0=$ -=##"$ G% :'M%# $0*",:0 "GS%-$&R U0=$ '& '$ =G",$ '$ $0=$ *%#+%*& '$ ,#'J,% '# G%'#: ,#=G3% $" G% :'M%# $0*",:0 "GS%-$&< =#+ 0"O +"%& $0'& *%3=$% $" V=#$]& &,++%# +%&-*'C$'"# "4 &?#$0%&'& =& =# =-$ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:X /0% 4'*&$ C=*$ "4 $0'& J,%&$'"# '& %=&'%* $" =++*%&&R /0% -"#-%C$ "4 = -";G'#=$'"# '& -";C"&%+ "4 = #,;G%* "4 C=*$&Z $0% ;=#'4"3+< $0% &?#1 $0%&'& "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ =#+ $0% ,#'$? "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+R !";G'#=$'"# '& *%C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% 3:%29/2', ,#'$? "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+R /0% *%C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0'& ,#'$? -=##"$< $0%*%4"*%< =*'&% ",$ "4 $0% -";G'#=$'"#R b# $0% -"#$*=*?< '$ '& O0=$< G? =++'#: '$&%34 $" $0% *%C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+< 4'*&$ ;=N%& C"&&'G3% $0% -"#-%C$ "4 $0% -";G'#=$'"#R _a.AE^.` U0=$ '& $0% G=&'& "4 $0'& ,#'$? =*'&'#: '# ",* -";G'#=$'"# O0'-0 ;=N%& C"&&'G3% $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 -";G'#=$'"#X V=#$ :'M%& ,& =& =#&O%*Z $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"#R /0'& '& O0=$ $0% "*':'#=3 -";G'1 #=$'"# *%&$& "#< $0% &';C3% #%-%&&'$? "4 =33 *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& $" *%3=$% $" "#% \) $0'#N]R \/0% C*'#-'C3% "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# '& $0% 0':0%&$ C*'#-'C3% '# $0% O0"3% &C0%*% "4 0,;=# N#"O3%+:%] _a.A6`R U0'3&$ $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% #%-%&&=*? ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# '& =# =#=3?$'- C*"C"&'$'"#< '$ \*%M%=3& $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 = &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ :'M%# '# '#$,'$'"#] _a.A6`R 5& V=#$ C,$& '$Z /0'& =;",#$& $" &=?'#:< $0=$ ) =; -"#&-'",& $" ;?&%34 * 8#'"#' "4 = #%-%&&=*? &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& ^ $" G% %#$'$3%+ $0% "*':'#=3 &?#$0%$'- ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# ^ ,#+%* O0'-0 =33 *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& $0=$ =*% :'M%# $" ;% ;,&$ &$=#+< G,$ ,#+%* O0'-0 $0%? 0=M% =3&" 4'*&$ $" G% G*",:0$ G? ;%=#& "4 = &?#$0%&'&R _a.A6` >"< $0% *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& $0=$ ) =; C*%&%#$%+ O'$0 0=M% $" G% -"#-%'M%+ =& 4"*;'#: = ,#'4'%+ 4'%3+ "4 C%*-%C$'"# $" G% C3=-%+ ,#+%* =# =-$ "4 &?#$0%&'&R a,$ $0%? 0=M% =3&" $" G% C3=-%+ ,#+%* $0'& =-$ "4 &?#$0%&'& ^ $0% \"*':'#=3] ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# ^ G? ;%=#& "4 = &?#$0%&'&R /0'& O"*+'#: &,::%&$&< =& O=& %(C3'-'$3? &$=$%+ '# $0% 4'*&$ %+'$'"# _5..I`<

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

,"17'%*2'"% '& $0% "#3? "#% O0'-0 -=##"$ G% :'M%# $0*",:0 "GS%-$&R _a.AEY ;? '#$%*C"3=$'"#`

$0=$ $0%*% '& = &?#$0%&'& C*'"* $" $0=$ "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# _=3$0",:0 5..H =3&" &$=$%& $0=$ $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# '& $0% \*73"(?2/(:X 4'*&$ &?#$0%$'- C*'#-'C3% "4 ",* $0",:0$`R )4 $0%*% '& = &?#$0%&'& C*'"* $" $0=$ "4 $0% "*':'#=3 &?#$0%$',#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"#< $0%# '$ O",3+ &$'33 G% 4=3&% _+%&C'$% $0% &$=$%;%#$ =$ a.AE` $" &,::%&$ $0=$ =33 &?#$0%&'& '& =# =-$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: ,#3%&& $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =-$& $0*",:0 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#R 7%&C'$% $0% 4=-$ $0=$ V=#$ 0=& 3%4$ "C%# 0%*% $0% O=? $" &0"O'#: $0=$ $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%$'- ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# +%C%#+& "# =# =-$ "4 "*':'#=3 *%-%C$'M'$?< O0'-0 ;=N%& '$ C"&&'G3%< 0% :"%& "# $" &,::%&$ $0=$ '$ '& $0% \4'*&$ C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% 0,;=# ,#+%*&$=#+'#:] _a.AK`R /0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0'& +"%& 3%=M% = C*"G3%; '& -"#-%+%+ G? V=#$ O0%# 0% *%;=*N& $0=$ \$0% ;=#'4"3+ $" G% '#$,'$%+ ;,&$ G% :'M%# C*'"* $" $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< =#+ '#+%C%#+%#$3? "4 '$]< $" O0'-0 0% =++&Z \T"O $0'& $=N%& C3=-%< *%;='#& 0%*% ,#+%$%*;'#%+] _a.F6`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a.6.` G,$Z R R R $0% 4':,*=$'M% &?#$0%&'&< '4 '$ G% +'*%-$%+ ;%*%3? $" $0% "*':'#=3 &?#$0%$'- ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"#< $0=$ '&< $" $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? O0'-0 '& $0",:0$ '# $0% -=$%:"*'%&< ;,&$< '# "*+%* $" G% +'&$'#:,'&0%+ 4*"; $0% ;%*%3? '#$%33%-$,=3 -";G'#=$'"#< G% -=33%+ $0% 2#*%3,/%0/%H 2*( 3:%29/3'3 "@ '1*)'%*2'"%R ;1*)'%*2'"% '& $0% 4=-,3$? "4 *%C*%&%#$'#: '# '#$,'$'"# =# "GS%-$ $0=$ '& %"2 '23/(@ 8#/3/%2R _a.6.` /0% &%-"#+ &?#$0%&'& '& &$'33 = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& G,$ '$ '& #"O +%$%*;'#%+ =& = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"#R )4 $0% 4'*&$ &?#$0%&'& -=**'%+ ",$ G? $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: -=# G% -";C=*%+ O'$0 $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

FI C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

FK

517%+,-$'"#]& &?#$0%&'& "4 *%-":#'$'"# '# = -"#-%C$< $0%# $0'& &?#$0%&'&< -=**'%+ ",$ G? $0% ';=:'#=$'"#< -=# G% -";C=*%+ $" $0% 517%+,-$'"#]& &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"# '# ';=:'#=$'"#R );=:'#=$'"#< O0'-0 -=# -=**? ",$ $0% %#+,*=#-% "4 =# '#$,'$'"#]& *=#:% G? -"#$'#,",&3? 0"3+'#: $":%$0%* $0% '#$,'$'"#]& C=&$ ;";%#$&< ;,&$ -=**? ",$ =# =-$ "4 $*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 *%C*"+,-$'"# _=& &$=$%+ =$ 5.E@`R );=:'#=$'"# '& $0% G=&'& "4 =33 &C"#$=#%",& &?#$0%&'&R /0'& &C"#$=#1 %",& &?#$0%&'& ;,&$ C%*4"*; $0% =-$ "4 C*"+,-'#: $0% ,#'$? "4 '#$,'$'"# 4"*< =#+ $0,& -"#&$'$,$'#:< $0% \"*':'#=3] $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*1 -%C$'"#R /0'& O=& &$=$%+ '# $0% 517%+,-$'"# _5..I`R a,$ 0%*% V=#$ &$=$%&Z /0'& &?#$0%&'& i"4 ';=:'#=$'"#j '& =# =-$'"# iQ'#-?%)j "4 $0% ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: "# $0% &%#&'G'3'$?Y =#+ '& '$& 4'*&$ =CC3'-=$'"# ^ =#+ $0%*%G? $0% :*",#+ "4 =33 '$& "$0%* =CC3'-=$'"#& ^ $" $0% "GS%-$& "4 ",* C"&&'G3% '#$,'$'"#R 5& 4':,*=$'M%< '$ '& +'&$'#:,'&0%+ 4*"; $0% '#$%33%-$,=3 &?#$0%&'&< O0'-0 '& -=**'%+ ",$ G? $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =3"#%< O'$0",$ $0% ='+ "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#R )# &" 4=* =& ';=:'#=$'"# '& &C"#$=#%'$?< ) &";%$';%& =3&" %#$'$3% '$ $0% 8#"0?,2'G/ ';=:'#=$'"# R R R _a.6@Y ;? '#$%*C"3=$'"#`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`R /0% =CC3'-=$'"# "4 $0% -=$%:"*'%& "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $" &%#&'G'3'$? O",3+ +%C%#+< $0%*%4"*%< "# $0% 4':,*=$'M% &?#$0%&'& O0"&% C"&&'G'3'$? '& G=&%+ "# $0% "C%*=$'"# "4 ';=1 :'#=$'"#R /0'& ;%=#& $0=$ $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:]& %44%-$& ,C"# #=$,*% '& $0=$ O% 0=M% = 4=-,3$? "4 ';=:'#=$'"# =& "#% "4 $0% 4,#-$'"#& \"4 $0% &",3] _5HIfa.EA`R a,$ V=#$ =++&Z /0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: R R R '# *%&C%-$ "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ O0'-0 ;=? G% :'M%# $" '$ '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 $0% 4"*;& "4 &%#&'G3% '#$,'$'"#< '& =G3% $" +%$%*;'#% &%#&'G'3'$? '#O=*+3?R /0,& $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< ,#+%* $0% $'$3% "4 = 2#*%3,/%0/%2*( 3:%29/3'3 "@ '1*)'%*2'"%< C%*4"*;& $0'& =-$ ,C"# $0% 8*33'G/ &,GS%-$< O0"&% @*,?(2: '$ '& R R R _a.6A`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

T%*% $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# '& C*%&%#$%+ =& &';C3? =#"$0%* #=;% 4"* $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:l /0'& &,*C*'&'#: $,*# =;",#$& $" &=?'#: $0=$ G"$0 '#$%33%-$,=3 =#+ 4':,*=$'M% &?#$0%&'& =*% =-$'"#& "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< =#+ $0=$ O",3+ 4'$ 0'& %=*3'%* &$=$%;%#$ $0=$ =33 &?#$0%&'& '& =# =-$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: _a.AE`R W%M%*$0%3%&&< '$ '& 4=* 4*"; =+%J,=$% '# $%*;& "4 %(C3='#'#: 0"O $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =& = \4=-,3$? "4 N#"O3%+:%] _a.AH` -=# *%3=$% $" &%#&'G'3'$? =& "*':'#=3 *%-%C$'M'$?R )#$0% -=&% "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# O% #"$%+ $0=$ '$ O=& =G3% $" "C%*=$% O'$0",$ *%4%*%#-% $" ';=:'#=$'"# G%-=,&% O0=$ #%%+%+ &-0%;=$'&'#: O=& #"$ &%#&'G'3'$? G,$ = -=$%:"*? "4 4*%%+";R )4 O% =*% 4=-%+ O'$0 = -=$%:"*? "4 #=$,*%< $0%# =# =-$'"# "4 &C"#$=#%'$? O'33 G% *%J,'*%+ $" ;=N% C"&&'G3% $0% =-$'"# "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: "# &%#&'G'3'$? O0'-0 =-$'"# V=#$ 0=& S,&$ +%&-*'G%+ =& \4':,*=$'M% &?#$0%&'&] "* $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"#R 5$ a.6F 0% +%&-*'G%& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =-$ "4 ';=:'#=$'"# =& \&?#$0%$'- '#43,%#-% "4 $0% ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: ,C"# '##%* &%#&%]< "* =& $0% +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 = $%;C"*=3 &%J,%#-% "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ $0*",:0 $0% =-$'"# "4 0"3+'#: &";%$0'#: C*%&%#$ %M%# O0%# '$ '& #"$ &"R U0=$ $0'& *%=33? =;",#$& $" '& $0=$ '# $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# O% 0=M% -";G'#%+Z _=` $0% -=$%:"*? "4 $0% C,*% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:Y _G` $0% +=$= "4 '#$,'$'"#]& \43"O]Y =#+ _-` $0% *%1-"33%-$'"# "4 %=-0 %3%;%#$ "4 $0% 43"O =& 4"*;'#: C=*$ "4 $0% &=;% &%J,%#-%R /0% "#3? G=&'& G? O0'-0 _=` =#+ _G` -=# G% &?#$0%1 &'&%+ '& $0*",:0 _-`R e'M%# $0=$ $0'& '& &"< $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0% *,3% &,CC3'%+ G? $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '& -3%=*3? = C*"+,-$ "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# +"%& #"$ '# '$&%34 %#$'$3% ,& $" C*%&%#$ $0% &?#$0%&'& =& =# =-$ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< =& $0% C*"-%&& "4 *%1-"33%-$'"# "4 %=-0 C=&$ %3%;%#$ "4 $0% '#$,'$'"# -=# "#3? G% -=**'%+ ",$ G? $0% ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ '$ '& $0'& O0'-0 *%#+%*& $0% &?#$0%&'& C"&&'G3% =$ =33R _U% -=# =3&" ,#+%*1 &$=#+ $0'& =& =# =-$ "4 ;%+'=$'"# G%$O%%# $0% *,3% =#+ $0% +=$= "4 &%#&'G'3'$?R` /0% a17%+,-$'"# 0=& ?%$ 4,*$0%* C%-,3'=*'$'%&R /0% "*':'#=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# O0'-0 $0% 517%+,-$'"# ,#+%*&$""+ =& = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =-$ _5KK^.EE` '& #"O *%+%&-*'G%+ =& ;%*%3? %;C'*'-=3 _a.DE`< O0'3&$ $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"#< =G",$ O0'-0 $0%*% 0=+ G%%# &";% -"#4,&'"# '# $0% 517%+,-$'"#< '& #"O =3&" +%&-*'G%+ =& ;%*%3? %;C'*'-=3 _a.6@`R /0% %3';'#=$'"# "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# '& C=*$ "4 V=#$]& "M%*=33 %3';'#=$'"# "4 $0% J,%&$'"# "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< O0'3&$ $0% %3';'#=$'"# "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 *%C*"+,-$'"# $0",:0 &%%;'#:3? &%*'",&< '& '# 4=-$ "4 3'$$3% =--",#$ =& '$& G=&'- =-$ '& #"O 3"-=$%+ =& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 C*"+,-$'M% ';=:'#=$'"#R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

6E C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

6.

R R R '$ '& ';=:'#=$'"# $0=$ -"##%-$& $0% ;=#'4"3+ "4 &%#&'G3% '#$,'$'"#Y =#+ ';=:'#=$'"# '& +%C%#+%#$ 4"* $0% ,#'$? "4 '$& '#$%33%-$,=3 &?#1 $0%&'& ,C"# $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< =#+ 4"* $0% ;=#'4"3+#%&& "4 '$& =CC*%1 0%#&'"# ,C"# &%#&'G'3'$?R _a.DF` );=:'#=$'"# +%C%#+& 4"* '$& =-$'"# "# G"$0 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ &%#&'G'31 '$?< G,$ $0% ,#'$? "4 $0%&% $O" '#$" "#% 4':,*=$'M% &?#$0%&'& '& +%C%#+%#$ "# $0% ';=:'#=$'"#]& &?#$0%$'- =-$'"#R );=:'#=$'"# 0=& $0,& *%$='#%+ $0% ';C"*$=#$ 4,#-$'"# "4 ;%+'=$'"# =#+< +%&C'$% V=#$]& =$$%;C$& $" C*%&%#$ '$ =& ;%*%3? =# =*; "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< '$ 0=& $" G% ,#+%*&$""+ =& 0=M'#: = C"O%* "4 '$& "O#Z $0% G=&'- $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =-$'"# "4 *%1-"33%-$'"# O'$0",$ O0'-0 $0% =-$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O",3+ G% ;%*%3? M='#< G%-=,&% '$ O",3+ 3=-N =CC3'-=$'"# $" =-$& "4 &%#&'G'3'$? _a.6@`R

>+2)"1.&+# +, $-* 8: "#4 I:?*4;5$.+#& )# $0% 517%+,-$'"# O% 4",#+ $0=$ $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ';=:'#=$'"# 0=+ $0*%% G=&'- 4,#-$'"#&Z *%C*"+,-$'"# "4 '#$,'$'"#&< "*':'#=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 *%-%C$'M'$? =#+ ;%+'=$'"# G%$O%%# &%#&'G'3'$? =#+ ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R B=-0 3%M%3 "4 &?#$0%&'& O=& $0,& *%M%=3%+ $" G% +%C%#+%#$ ,C"# '$R /0'& %#=G3%+ ;% $" =&&%*$ $0=$ $0% +%&-*'C$'"# "4 $0% =-$'"# "4 $0% $*=#&-%#1 +%#$=3 ';=:'#=$'"# G*",:0$ $0% 7%+,-$'"# '#$" ,#'$? O'$0 $0% /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-R )# $0% a17%+,-$'"# O% 4'#+ $0=$ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '& C*%&%#$%+ =& $0% "*':'# "4 =33 &?#$0%&'& %M%# $0",:0 $0% %=*3'%* *%;=*N $0=$ &?#$0%&'& '& =3O=?& =# =-$'"# "4 ';=:'#=$'"# O=& 3%4$ ,#-0=#:%+ _5HIfa.EA`R /0% =-$& "4 &?#$0%&'& =*% C*%&%#$%+ '# = +'44%*%#$ "*+%* 4*"; $0% 517%+,-$'"# O'$0 $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 *%-":#'$'"# '# = -"#-%C$ O0'-0 '& *%M%=3%+ $" G% +%C%#+%#$ "# =# "*':'#=3 &?#$0%$'- ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# C*%&%#$%+ 4'*&$R U0'3&$ $0'& &?#$0%$'- ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"# '& C*%&%#$%+ =& $0% 0':0%&$ 4"*; "4 N#"O3%+:%< V=#$ -"#4%&&%& $" '$& +%C%#+%#-% "# =# %=*3'%* &?#$0%&'& O0'-0 '& #"$ +'&-,&&%+R T% $0%*%4"*% 3%=M%& ",$ "4 $0% a17%+,-$'"# $0% "*':'#=3 =-$ -=**'%+ ",$ G? $0% ';=:'#=$'"#R /0'& *%;"M%& "#% 3=?%* "4 $0% =-$'"# "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#< 4"* $0% C,*C"&% "4 *%;"M'#: 4*"; $0% 7%+,-$'"# '$& \&,GS%-$'M%] &'+% "4 %(C3'-=$'#: $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0% %('&$%#-% "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R /0% %;C'*'-=3 =-$ "4

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

U0=$ '& -3%=* '& $0=$ $0% =-$'"# "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ $0=$ "4 ';=:'#1 =$'"# '& =# =-$'"# "4 &C"#$=#%'$? *=$0%* $0=# "4 *%-%C$'M'$? _a.D@`R /0% O"*N'#: "4 &C"#$=#%'$? '& :'M%# = 4'#=3 +%&-*'C$'"#Z

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a.D@`< O0'-0 &';C3? 0=& +'44%*%#$ %(C*%&&'"#&R a"$0 +%+,-$'"#& O0%# *%=+ O'$0 -=*% C*%&%#$ $0% ';=:'#1 =$'"#]& =-$'M'$? =& %&&%#$'=3 4"* $0%*% $" G% =#? N#"O3%+:% "4 %(C%*'%#-% =#+ G"$0 _5 %(C3'-'$3?< =#+ a ';C3'-'$3?` 0=M% $" +%&-*'G% '$ =& =# '#+%C%#+%#$ 4=-,3$?R /0% a17%+,-$'"#]& =--",#$ &%%;& $" 3%=M% = 3%&& "GM'",& -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% 5%&$0%$'- =#+ $0% 7%+,-$'"#R !"**%&C"#+'#: $" $0% * 8#'"#' '#$,'$'"#& C*%&%#$%+ '# $0% 5%&$0%$'- O% =*% :'M%# #"O $0% $*=#&-%#+%#1 $=3 ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"#R a,$ $0% 3'#N=:% G%$O%%# $0% $O" _"#3? 4,33? *%M%=3%+ '# $0% &-0%;=$'&;` '& $0% 4':,*=$'M% &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"#R )$ '& &$'33 $0% -=&%< $0%*%4"*%< $0=$ $0% ';=:'#=$'"# C3=?& $0% C'M"$=3 *"3% "4 -"##%-$'#: $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7%+,-$'"# =#+ $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&1 $0%$'-R

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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

6@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

6A

G% *%C*%&%#$%+ =& = 4=-,3$? "4 S,+:;%#$ _5DKfaKF`R U% &0=33 4,*$0%* +'&-,&& G%3"O $0% *%=&"#& O0? $0% &-0%;=$'&; "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% '& +%&-*'G%+ =& C=*$ "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +"-$*'#% "4 S,+:;%#$R 5& O% 0=M% =3*%=+? +'&-,&&%+< S,+:;%#$ 0=& $O" :%#%*=3 =&C%-$&Z &,G&,;C$'"# "4 = C=*$'-,3=* ,#+%* = ,#'M%*&=3 *,3% =#+ +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# C=*$'-,3=*& $" +%$%*;'#% $0%'* *,3% "4 "C%*=$'"#R a"$0 "4 $0%&% =&C%-$& "4 S,+:;%#$ =*% C=*$ "4 +%$%*;'#=$'"#< $0,& "4 +%$%*;'#=$% S,+:;%#$R L%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ G? -"#$*=&$ 0=& $" "C%*=$% $" C*"+,-% = G*'+:% G%$O%%# $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 +%$%*;'#=$% S,+:;%#$ C*"+,-%+ G? $0% 4'*&$ $O" -*'$'J,%&R /0'& *%#+%*& $0% +%&-*'C$'"# "4 '$& "C%*=$'"# C=*$'-,3=*3? '#$*'1 -=$% =& $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ 0=& G"$0 $" +%;"#&$*=$% $0% :*",#+& "4 C*'#-'C3% "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ =#+ +%;"#&$*=$% $0% O=? '# O0'-0 $0'& S,+:;%#$ -=# =-$ =& = G*'+:% G%$O%%# $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 +%$%*;'#=$% S,+:;%#$ +%+,-%+ '# $0% %=*3'%* O"*N&R b#3? '4 G"$0 $0%&% "C%*=$'"#& =*% C%*4"*;%+ O'33 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 0=M% 4,34'33%+ '$& $=&NR U0=$ ) O=#$ $" ",$3'#% 0%*% =*% &";% "4 $0% G=&'- %3%;%#$& "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '# "*+%* $" +*=O ",$ = 4,*$0%* -"##%-1 $'"# G%$O%%# $0% ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ $0% ,#+%*3?'#: #%-%&&'$? "4 = e%#%*=3 5%&$0%$'- O0'-0 -";G'#%& $0% *%&,3$& "4 $0% $0*%% -*'$'J,%& '#$" = O0"3%R >%$$'#: $0'& =*:,;%#$ ",$ =$ $0'& S,#-$,*% %#=G3%& = 4,*$0%* +%;"#&$*=1 $'"# "4 $0'& C"'#$< G,$ 0=& $0% +'&=+M=#$=:% "4 -";C%33'#: ;% $" C*%+%$%*;'#% &";% "4 $0% *%&,3$& "4 $0% =#=3?$'- "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ O'$0",$ 0=M'#: 4'*&$ -=*%4,33? +%$%*;'#%+ 0"O $0% O0"3% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 4,#-$'"#&R /0'& +'&=+M=#$=:% '&< 0"O%M%*< -";C%#&=$%+ 4"* G? $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0'& +%;"#&$*=$'"# O'33 0=*;"#'&% O'$0 $0=$ '# !0=C$%* . =G"M%< G*'#:'#: =G",$ = -3%=* =#+ -"0%*%#$ *%=&"# 4"* =+"C$'#: ;? C"&$,3=$% -"#-%*#'#: $0% #%-%&&'$? =#+ '#+,G'$=G'3'$? "4 $0% !*'$'-=3 &?&$%; G%'#: ,#+%*&$""+ =& $0% %3=G"*=$'"# "4 = e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`R _5NR 6Z@FE`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

/0% *%-"M%*? "4 $0% #"$'"# $0=$ $0%*% '& = C*"+,-$'M% =&C%-$ "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#< O0'-0 O=& =3;"&$ G,*'%+ '# $0% a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a,$< O0%*%=& $0% &"3,$'"# '# $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%]& =--",#$ "4 = 3=O "4 4*%%+"; O=& $" "44%* = &-0%;=$'&; O0'-0 +'+ #"$ *%3? ,C"# $0% ';=:'#=$'"#< '# $0% -=&% "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% '$ '& C*%-'&%3? $0% *,3% "4 ';=:'#=$'"# O0'-0 '& #"$ +%$%*;'#%+ G? =#? *%4%*%#-% $" +%$%*;'#=$% -"#-%C$& O0'-0 '& *%J,'*%+R )$ '& $0% #"#1-"#-%C$,=3 #=$,*% "4 $=&$% O0'-0 =33"O& '$ $" G% +%&-*'G%+ =& =# "*':'#=33? 4*%% =-$ "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#R b#% "4 $0% ';C"*$=#$ $=&N& "4 $0% =#=3?$'- "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ O'33 G% $" +%;"#&$*=$% 0"O O% -=# -"#-%'M% "4 = 4*%% 3=O "4 ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ $" +%&-*'G% $0% "C%*=$'"# "4 $0'& 3=OR a,$ '$ '& "#3? O'$0 *%4%*%#-% $" $0% '#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#: "4 &,G3';'$? $0=$ O% $*,3? +'&-"M%* = 3=O '# $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ =& '# $0% $*,3? &C"#$=#%",& =-$'"# "4 $=&$% O% 4'#+ $0% ';=:'#=$'"# :"M%*#%+ G? '$&%34 '# $0% ;=##%* "4 C3=? _5NR 6Z@DI`R /0%*%4"*%< O0'3&$ $0% =--",#$ "4 $=&$% 0=& $0% +'44'1 -,3$ $=&N "4 ",$3'#'#: = 3=O4,3#%&& O'$0",$ = 3=O _$0% ';=:'#=$'"# '# '$& 4*%%+";`< $0% =--",#$ "4 '#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#: C*%&%#$& \$0% ';=:'#=$'"# G? '$& "O# =-$'"#] +%C*'M'#: '$&%34 "4 '$& 4*%%+"; _5NR 6Z@DK`R T%*% O% +'&-"M%* $O" +'44%*%#$ N'#+& "4 C*"+,-$'M% ';=:'#=$'"#Z $0=$ O0'-0 "C%*=$%& 3=O4,33?< G,$ O'$0",$ = 3=O _=#+ $0%*%4"*% 4*%%3?`< =#+ $0=$ O0'-0 "C%*=$%& $" +%C*'M% '$&%34 "4 '$& 4*%% *=#:%< G,$ O'$0",$ *%4%**'#: $" = +%$%*;'#=$% 4"*; "4 -":#'$'"# =& :"M%*#"* "4 '$& =-$'"#R )# "*+%* $" +%$%*;'#% $0% $O" *,3%& G? O0'-0 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# "C%*=$%& '# $0% \$*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =%&$0%$'- "4 S,+:;%#$] _5NR 6Z@DK` O0=$ O% #%%+ $" &%$ ",$ =*% $0% -"#+'$'"#& 4"* = +'44%*%#$ =&&%&&;%#$ "4 $0% *%3=$'"#1 &0'C G%$O%%# K/1?W2 =#+ * 8#'"#' '#$,'$'"#& 4*"; $0=$ C*"M'+%+ '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R >"< $0% =--",#$ "4 $O" N'#+& "4 3=O& $0=$ $0% ';=:'#1 =$'"# :'M%& $" '$&%34 _"#% $" =-$ 4*%%3?< $0% "$0%* $" G% +%C*'M%+ "4 4*%%+";` +%C%#+& "# $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 = +'44%*%#$ $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =%&$0%$'- 4*"; $0=$ :'M%# '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R /0% -*'$'J,% "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ +"%& #"$ S,&$ :'M% $0% *,3%& 4"* =#

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

6F C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

66

=%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$Y '$ =3&" &%$& ",$ 0"O $0%&% *,3%& C*"+,-% $0%'* "GS%-$< O0'-0 '& O0=$ '& ;%=#$ G? &=?'#: $0=$ 0%*% $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '& -"#&'+%*%+ C,*%3? C*"+,-$'M%3?R /0'& &%-"#+ $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =%&$0%$''& =# %($*%;%3? ';C"*$=#$ %3%;%#$ "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 O0'-0 O'33 =33"O $0% 4"*;=$'"# "4 = 3":'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ $" :'M% *,3%& $" $0% 4"*; "4 ;=#'4"3+ C*"+,-%+ G? $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '# '$& C,*%3? C*"+,-$'M% C"O%*R

'-* E5-*2"$.&2 "#4 $-* G2"0.#"$.+# ) 0=M% =3*%=+? *%4%**%+ $" $0% &$*=#:% N'#+ "4 &-0%;=$'&; C*%&%#$%+ '# $0% /?C'- "4 8*=-$'-=3 9,+:;%#$< = &-0%;=$'&; O0"&% "++'$? *%&'+%& '# '$& G%'#: ;%*%3? $0% &-0%;= "4 $0% 4"*; "4 3=OR /0'& %#=G3%+ V=#$ $" +%&-*'G% =# "C%*=$'"# $0%*% O0'-0 0=+ #" *%4%*%#-% $" $0% ';=:'#=$'"# =$ =33R )# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% $0% &$"*? '& J,'$% +'44%*%#$R 5& ) 0=M% =3*%=+? ;%#$'"#%+< $0% &-0%;=$'&; "4 $0% C,*% -"#-%C$& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '& C*%&%#$%+ '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% =& C=*$ "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +"-$*'#% "4 S,+:;%#$R /0% &-0%;=$'&; '& '#$%#+%+ $" $*%=$ "4 \$0% &%#&'G3% -"#+'1 $'"# ,#+%* O0'-0 =3"#% C,*% -"#-%C$& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: -=# G% %;C3"?%+] _5.ADfa.H6`R 2"* C,*% -"#-%C$& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $" G% =CC3'%+ $" %(C%*'%#-% = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +"-$*'#% "4 S,+:;%#$ '& *%J,'*%+< = +"-$*'#% O0'-0 O'33 +%$%*;'#% $0% -"#+'$'"#& ,#+%* O0'-0 &,-0 =# =CC3'-=$'"# '& C"&&'G3%R 2"* $0% -=$%:"*? $" G% =CC3'%+ $" =CC%=*=#-%& O% #%%+ &";%$0'#: O0'-0 O'33 ;%+'=$% G%$O%%# $0%; G? G%'#: '# "#% *%&C%-$ '#$%33%-$,=3 =#+ '# =#"$0%* *%&C%-$ &%#&'G3%R \>,-0 = *%C*%&%#$=$'"# '& $0% 2#*%3,/%H 0/%2*( 3,9/1*] _5.AIfa.HH`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fa.HI` /0'& O'33 "--,* $0*",:0 +%;"#&$*=$'#: $0% *%&$*'-$'"# "4 $0% %;C3"?1 ;%#$ "4 -"#-%C$& "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $" $0% 4"*;=3 -"#+'$'"#& "4 &%#&'G'3'$? =#+ O'33 $0,& -";C3%$% $0% G*'+:% G%$O%%# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#1 $=3 7%+,-$'"# =#+ $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- C*"M'+%+ G? %'$0%* $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

$*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# _517%+,-$'"#` "* \4':,*=$'M% &?#$0%&'&] _a17%+,-$'"#`R /0% &-0%;= O'33 +%;"#&$*=$% $0% M'$=3 '#$%*1 -"##%-$'"#< $0%*%4"*%< G%$O%%# $0% &?#$0%&%& "4 &%#&'G'3'$? =#+ '#$%33%-$1 ,=3'$?R V=#$ C*"-%%+& $" &C%-'4? $0% #=$,*% "4 $0'& G*'+:'#: "C%*=$'"#R T% $%33& ,& $0=$ $0% &-0%;= '& '# '$&%34 \=3O=?& = C*"+,-$ "4 ';=:'#=$'"#] _5.FEf a.HK`R e'M%# $0=$ $0% &?#$0%&'& "4 ';=:'#=$'"# C*"M'+%& "#3? = ,#'$? "4 +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 &%#&'G'3'$? =#+ #"$ = &C%-'=3 '#$,'$'"# "4 '$& "O#< $0% &-0%;= #%%+& $" G% +'&$'#:,'&0%+ 4*"; $0% ';=:%R 5# ';=:% "4 = #,;1 G%*< 4"* %(=;C3%< -=# G% C*%&%#$%+ &';C3? =& = &%*'%& "4 C"'#$&< O0%*%=& '4 O% $0'#N $0% '+%= "4 #,;G%* '# :%#%*=3 \$0'& $0",:0$ '& *=$0%* $0% *%C*%&%#$=$'"# O0%*%G? = ;,3$'C3'-'$? R R R ;=? G% *%C*%&%#$%+ '# =# ';=:% '# -"#4"*;'$? O'$0 = -%*$='# -"#-%C$] _5.FEfa.HK`R /0'& C*"-%1 +,*%< O0%*%G? O0=$ ';=:'#=$'"# C*"M'+%& '& = ,#'M%*&=3 C*"-%+,*% 4"* -"#-%C$,=3'$? +%*'M%+ 4*"; $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 4':,*=$'M% =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 C=*$'-,3=*&< '& \$0% &-0%;= "4 $0'& -"#-%C$] _5.FEfa.IE`R 5#"$0%* O=? "4 +%&-*'G'#: $0% &-0%;= O0'-0 '& ;"*% %-"#";'-=3 '& $0=$ '$ '& \= *,3% "4 &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#< '# *%&C%-$ $" C,*% 4':,*%& '# &C=-%] _5.F.fa.IE`R 2"* %(=;C3%Z /0% -"#-%C$ \+":] &':#'4'%& = *,3% =--"*+'#: $" O0'-0 ;? ';=:'#=$'"# -=# +%3'#%=$% $0% 4':,*% "4 = 4",*14""$%+ =#';=3 '# = :%#%*=3 ;=##%*< O'$0",$ 3';'$=$'"# $" =#? &'#:3% +%$%*;'#=$% 4':,*% &,-0 =& %(C%*'1 %#-%< "* =#? C"&&'G3% ';=:% $0=$ ) -=# *%C*%&%#$ '% ,"%,#/2"< =-$,=33? C*%&%#$&R _5.F.fa.IE`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f a.EA``R U0'3&$ $0% ';=:% '& = C*"+,-$ "4 $0% %;C'*'-=3 *%C*"+,-$'"# "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< $0% &-0%;= '& \= C*"+,-$ =#+< =& '$ O%*%< = ;"#":*=;< "4 C,*% * 8#'"#' ';=:'#=$'"#< $0*",:0 O0'-0< =#+ '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 O0'-0< ';=:%& $0%;&%3M%& 4'*&$ G%-";% C"&&'G3%] [email protected].`R /0% &-0%;= '& $0,& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 -"#+'$'"# "4 ';=:%&R a,$ = &-0%;=

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

6D C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

6H

)$ '& &';C3? $0% C,*% &?#$0%&'&< +%$%*;'#%+ G? = *,3% "4 $0=$ ,#'$?< '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 -"#-%C$&< $" O0'-0 $0% -=$%:"*? :'M%& %(C*%&&'"#R )$ '& = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C*"+,-$ "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< = C*"+,-$ O0'-0 -"#1 -%*#& $0% +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 '##%* &%#&% '# :%#%*=3 =--"*+'#: $" -"#1 +'$'"#& "4 '$& 4"*; _$';%`< '# *%&C%-$ "4 =33 *%C*%&%#$=$'"#&< &" 4=* =& $0%&% *%C*%&%#$=$'"#& =*% $" G% -"##%-$%+ * 8#'"#' '# "#% -"#-%C$ '# -"#4"*;'$? O'$0 $0% ,#'$? "4 =CC%*-%C$'"#R [email protected].` 5$ $0'& C"'#$ V=#$ &C%-'4'%& $0% &-0%;= "4 $0% C,*% -"#-%C$& "4 ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: _",$%* &%#&%< '##%* &%#&%< ;=:#'$,+%< *%=3'$?< &,G&$=#-%< -";;,#'$?< C"&&'G'3'$?< ;"+=3'$?< =-$,=3'$? =#+ #%-%&&'$?` [email protected]@^ 5.F6fa.IF`R 5#=3?&'#: $0% &-0%;= "4 %=-0 "4 $0% -=$%:"*'%& *%=3'&%& $0%; '# $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 $*,$0< $0,& +%$%*;'#'#: $0% G=&'& "4 %;C'*'-=3 $*,$0R a,$< =& =3*%=+? &$=$%+< $0% &-0%;= +"%& #"$ ;%*%3? *%=3'&% $0% -"#-%C$& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< G,$ =3&" *%&$*'-$& $0%'* 4'%3+ "4 "C%*=$'"# $" $0% :*",#+& "4 C"&&'G3% %(C%*'%#-%R [=$% '# $0% O"*N V=#$ =3&" &%$& ",$ =# %M%# G*"=+%* *"3% 4"* &-0%;=$'&; O0%# 0% O*'$%& $0=$ '$ C*"M'+%& \= -"#&$'$,%#$ ;=#'4"3+ =#+ =# "*+%* "4 '$& C=*$&< G"$0 "4 O0'-0 ;,&$ G% +%$%*;'#%+ * 8#'"#' 4*"; $0% C*'#-'C3% +%4'#%+ G? '$& %#+] _5IAAfaID.`R /0'& :'M%& ,& =# ",$3'#% "* 1"%")#*1H 1*2* "4 $0% %#$'*% &?&$%; "4 C,*% *%=&"#R /0'& &%-"#+ &%#&% "4 &-0%;=$'&; '#+'-=$%& $0=$ &-0%;=$'&; '& #"$ ;%*%3? = ;%+'=$'#: 4,#-$'"# G%$O%%# ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ &%#&'G'3'$? _O0'-0 O",3+ &';C3? -"#4'*; $0% *%&$*'-1 $'"# "4 ';=:'#=$'"#]& $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 4,#-$'"# =& :'M%# '# $0% a17%+,-1 $'"#`R )$ =3&" +%&-*'G%& = :%#%*=3 *%&$*'-$'"# =#+ *%=3'&=$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: G? &%#&'G'3'$? O0'-0 '& =-$'M=$%+ #"$ G? $0% &-0%;= 0=M'#: = 4,#-$'"# "4 ;%+'=$'"#< G,$ *=$0%* '$&%34 G%'#: $0% =-$'M'$? "4 ;%+'=$'"#R6 U% -=# '# &,; +'&$'#:,'&0 G%$O%%# $0*%% 4"*;& "4 &-0%;=$'&;Z %;C'*'-=3< $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =#+ 4'#=3 %#+ "4 *%=&"#R /0'& -"#4"*;& $" $0% $0*%%14"3+ *"3% "4 ';=:'#=$'"# O0"&% '#&$*,;%#$ $0% &-0%;=$'&; '& =#+ 0%3C& $" -"#4'*; $0=$ $0% &?&$%; "4 C,*% *%=&"# '& =# %3=G"*=$'"# "4 = e%#%*=3 5%&$0%$'-R

G2"0.#"$.+#H E5-*2"$.&2 "#4 $-* 8*&$-*$.5 +, =*,7*5$.@* J;402*#$ U% 0=M% ,#-"M%*%+ '# $0% -",*&% "4 $0'& -0=C$%* 4,*$0%* %M'+%#-% 4"* ;? -0=*=-$%*'&=$'"# "4 !*'$'-=3 C0'3"&"C0?R U0=$ O% -=# &%% '& $0=$ '# $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

"4 = C,*% -"#-%C$ '& G? +%4'#'$'"# #%M%* -=C=G3% "4 G%'#: C*%&%#$%+ '# =# ';=:% =$ =33R L=$0%*Z

517%+,-$'"# %=-0 3%M%3 "4 &?#$0%&'& *%J,'*%+ =# =-$'"# "4 $0% ';=:'#1 =$'"#R U0'3&$ $0% a17%+,-$'"# *%&$*'-$& $0% *"3% "4 ';=:'#=$'"# '$ ';C3'-1 '$3? -"#4'*;& $0% =--",#$ "4 $0% 51 7%+,-$'"# '# = #,;G%* "4 C3=-%&R /0% >-0%;=$'&; "4 $0% 8,*% !"#-%C$& "4 Q#+%*&$=#+'#: '# =++'$'"# $" $0% \4':,*=$'M% &?#$0%&'&] "4 $0% a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a1 7%+,-$'"#` "* =& -"#&$'$,$'M% "4 %=-0 3%M%3 "4 &?#$0%&'& _517%+,-$'"#`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faKF`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a,$ '$ =3O=?& 4"*;& C=*$ "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +"-$*'#% "4 $0% 4=-,3$? "4 S,+:;%#$< O0=$%M%* $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

6I C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

6K

&C%-'4'- -*'$'J,% '& %#:=:%+ '# +%3';'$'#:R >-0%;=$'&; C*"M'+%& = #"$'"# "4 $0% 4'#=3 %#+ "4 $0% &?&$%; "4 C,*% *%=&"# O0'-0 0"O%M%* *%J,'*%& $0% "C%*=$'"# "4 = *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# $0% $0*%% +'&$'#-$ +"-$*'#%& "4 $*=#&-%#1 +%#$=3 S,+:;%#$ $" G% %3,-'+=$%+R /0% !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0? +%C%#+& "# =#+ =$$%;C$& $" %3,-'+=$% = e%#%*=3 5%&$0%$'- $0=$ %;%*:%& $0*",:0 $0% =--",#$& "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< &-0%;=$'&; =#+ S,+:;%#$R /" %3=G"*=$% $0% =--",#$ "4 !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0? "44%*%+ 0%*% '$ '& #"O #%-%&&=*? $" =&&%&& $0% "C%*=$'"# "4 '$& =*-0'$%-$"#'-R /0'& ) O'33 +" G? $,*#'#: $" $0% &$*,-$,*% "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 O0"&% =*-0'$%-$"#'- ) #"O '#$%#+ $" S,&$'4? =:='#&$ *%-%#$ -*'$'-'&;R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;1*)'%*2'"%T 5,9/1*2'31T A?0)1/%2

A

/0% C%#,3$';=$% -0=C$%* "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% '& %#$'$3%+ \/0% 5*-0'$%-$"#'- "4 8,*% L%=&"#]R V=#$ 0%*% +%&-*'G%& =# =*-0'$%-$"#'- =& \$0% =*$ "4 -"#&$*,-$'#: &?&$%;&] =#+ =& = &?&$%; '& O0=$ ;=N%& N#"O31 %+:% &-'%#$'4'-< =# =*-0'$%-$"#'- '& \$0% +"-$*'#% "4 $0% &-'%#$'4'- '# ",* N#"O3%+:%] _5IA@faIDE`R 5 &?&$%; '& \$0% ,#'$? "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ ;"+%& "4 N#"O3%+:% ,#+%* "#% '+%=] =#+ =& =# '+%= '& = *=$'"#=3 -"#-%C$ "4 = O0"3%< $0% #"$'"# "4 &?&$%; '& "#% O'$0 $0% '+%= "4 *%=&"# '# '$& ;"&$ %($%#&'M% +%C3"?;%#$R \/0% &-'%#$'4'- -"#-%C$ "4 *%=&"# -"#$='#&< $0%*%1 4"*%< $0% %#+ =#+ $0% 4"*; "4 $0=$ O0"3% O0'-0 '& -"#:*,%#$ O'$0 $0'& *%J,'*%;%#$] _5IA@faIDE`R 2"* $0% '+%= $" G% *%=3'&%+ '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" *%&"*$ $" = &-0%;= +%M'&%+ '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 $0% '+%= "4 *%=&"# O0'-0 '& '+%#$'-=3 O'$0 C0'3"&"C0? '# :%#%*=3R 5& V=#$ C,$& '$Z R R R C0'3"&"C0? '& $0% &-'%#-% "4 $0% *%3=$'"# "4 =33 N#"O3%+:% $" $0% %&&%#$'=3 %#+& "4 0,;=# *%=&"# _2/(/"(")'* #*2'"%'3 9?1*%*/` =#+ $0% C0'3"&"C0%* '& R R R 0';&%34 $0% 3=O:'M%* "4 0,;=# *%=&"#R _5IAKfaIDH` /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%]& '#$%*#=3 "*:=#'&=$'"# 4"33"O& $0'& #"$'"# "4 =# =*-0'$%-$"#'- '# '$& +'M'&'"# "4 %3%;%#$& _=%&$0%$'- =#+ 3":'- O0'-0 3=$$%* '& &,G+'M'+%+ '#$" =#=3?$'- =#+ +'=3%-$'- O'$0 &,;;=*? "4 $0% O0"3% '# ;%$0"+"3":?`R )$ ;,&$ =3&" "4 #%-%&&'$? 4"*; O'$0 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"% =# %#+ "4 *%=3'&'#: $0% M"-=$'"# "4 ;=# O0'-0 $O" O"*N& =3"#%< 0"O%M%*< +" #"$ &,--%%+ '# +%;"#&$*=$'#: $0% '#$%*-"#1 #%-$'"# "4 &C%-,3=$'"# =#+ C*=-$'-=3 "*'%#$=$'"# G%-=,&% $0%? =*% 3=-N1 '#: = ;%+'=$'#: $0'*+ $%*; "4 S,+:;%#$ O0'-0 '$ '& $0% $=&N "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 $" C*"M'+%R 2"* $0% 3=$$%* $" &,--%%+ '# G*'#:'#: =G",$ $0% ,#'$? "4 $0% &?&$%; '# = +%;"#&$*=$'"# "4 $0% M"-=$'"# "4 DE

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% B(C"&'$'"# "4 8,*% 9,+:;%#$& "4 /=&

%$ ;=#< '$ O'33 G% #%-%&&=*? 4"* $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% $" +%;"#&$*=$% '# '$& 4"*; =& O%33 =& '$& -"#$%#$ =# '#$%*#=3 #%-%&&'$? O'$0",$ O0'-0 '$ O'33 =CC%=* = \;%*% =::*%:=$%]R )$ 0=& G%%# &,::%&$%+ 0"O%M%*< G? O*'$%*& "4 J,'$% +'44%*'#: $?C%< $0=$ $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% _=#+ C=*$'-,3=*3? $0% 4'*&$ 0=34< $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2` +"%& #"$ -"#$='# $0'& '#$%*#=3 #%-%&&'$? "4 4"*;R /0% -0=*:% $0=$ $0% O0"3% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 3=-N& =# '#$%*#=3 -"0%*%#-% '& &";%1 $0'#: $0=$ O'33 G% =++*%&&%+ =4$%* -"#&'+%*'#: $0% $O" 0=3M%& &%C=*=$%3?R ) O'33 4'*&$ *%M'%O $0% *%=&"#& O0'-0 0=M% G%%# :'M%# 4"* &-%C$'-'&; =G",$ $0% =*-0'$%-$"#'- "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 =#+ &,::%&$ $0% O=? '# O0'-0 $0% 4"*; "4 $0% O"*N -=# G% &0"O# $" 0=M% '#$%*#=3 #%-%&&'$?R b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a%=,$'4,3] =#+ =# \5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';%]R /0% \5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3] '& '# $,*# &%$ ",$ ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 4",* +'&$'#-$ ;";%#$& -"**%&C"#+'#: $" $0% 0%=+'#:& "4 J,=3'$?< J,=#$'$?< *%3=$'"# =#+ ;"+=3'$?R /0% \5#=3?$'"4 $0% >,G3';%] G? -"#$*=&$ '& +'M'+%+ '#$" $O" C=*$&Z \b# $0% P=$0%;=$1 '-=33? >,G3';%] =#+ \b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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ D.

&";%$0'#: &$*=#:% :'M%# $0=$ $0'& +'=3%-$'- &%%;& $" *%C*'&% $0% $*%=$1 ;%#$ "4 $0% +%+,-$'"# =#+ $" -";C3%$% '$R V=#$ $%33& ,& '# = 4""$#"$% =$ $0% G%:'##'#: "4 $0% \5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3] $0=$ $0% &%C=*=$% ;";%#$& O0'-0 =*% %(C",#+%+ =& G%'#: $0% C=*$& "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =*% C3=-%+ ,#+%* \$0% 3":'-=3 4,#-$'"#& "4 S,+:'#:] =& \%M%# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% 0=& *%4%*%#-% $" $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:] _5NR 6Z@EA`R BM%# '4 O% =--%C$ $0'& C*"-%+,*% =& S,&$'4'=G3%< *%$,*#'#: $" $0% $=G3% "4 S,+:;%#$& '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% *%M%=3& $0=$ $0% 4",* ;";%#$& O0'-0 V=#$ ,&%& $" %(C",#+ S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =*% $0%;1 &%3M%& 4,*$0%* +'M'&'G3%R m,=#$'$? '& +'M'+%+ '#$" ,#'M%*&=3< C=*$'-,3=* =#+ &'#:,3=*Y J,=3'$? '#$" =44'*;=$'M%< #%:=$'M% =#+ '#4'#'$%Y *%3=$'"# '#$" -=$%:"*'-=3< 0?C"$0%$'-=3 =#+ +'&S,#-$'M%Y =#+ ;"+=3'$? '#$" C*"1 G3%;=$'-< =&&%*$"*'- =#+ =C"+%'-$'-R U% O",3+ %(C%-$ $0% %(C"&'$'"#< $0%*%4"*%< '4 '$ '& $" $=N% '$& 4"*; 4*"; $0% $=G3% "4 S,+:;%#$&< $" +%;"#1 &$*=$% '# %=-0 -=&% 0"O $0% 4",* 0%=+'#:& =*% 0%*%G? +%$%*;'#%+R 7"#=3+ !*=O4"*+ &,::%&$& $0=$ $0'& '& 4=* 4*"; G%'#: $0% -=&% =&< 4"* %(=;C3%< '# $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 m,=3'$?< V=#$ +"%& #"$ ;%#$'"# $0% 4=-$ $0=$ = &$=$%;%#$ =G",$ G%=,$? '& =# =44'*;=$'M% S,+:;%#$ _$0",:0 0% +"%& &C%-'4? $0=$ = &$=$%;%#$ =G",$ &,G3';'$? '& = #%:=$'M% S,+:;%#$` =#+Z /0% -"**%&C"#+%#-% '# $0% P";%#$ "4 L%3=$'"# '& %J,=33? ';C*%-'&%R /0% *%3=$'"# -"#&'+%*%+ '& $0=$ "4 C,*C"&%&R )# $%*;& "4 $0% "*':'#=3 $=G3% i'# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%j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iY?/#32jX /0% C*'"*'$? '& #"$ C*%&-*'G%+ G? $0% $=G3%< G? $0% "*+%* "4 S,+:;%#$< G? $0% 3":'- C*"C%* $" $0% 4*=;%R W"$0'#: '# $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ DA

9%=#12*=#-n"'& [?"$=*+ &%$& ",$ $0% G=&'& 4"* =# =#=3":'-=3 *%=+'#: "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 O'$0 $0% -3"&%&$ =$$%#$'"# $" $0% J,%&1 $'"# -"#-%*#'#: $0% =*-0'$%-$"#'-R T% =+;'$& $0=$ $0% ,&% "4 $0% 0%=+1 '#:& 4*"; $0% $=G3% "4 S,+:;%#$& '& C%-,3'=* :'M%# $0=$ $0% $%*;& \=+;'$ *%&$*'-$'M% -3=,&%& $0=$ ;,&$ $,*# $0%; '#$" &";%$0'#: 3'N% \\3":'-=3 ;"#&$%*&]] ]RA a,$ 0% &,::%&$& $0=$ $0'& =CC%=*=#-% "4 \3":'-=3 ;"#&$*"&1 '$?] '& #%-%&&=*? 4"* $0% %(C"&'$'"# $" G% =# =--",#$ "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$R T% -"##%-$& $0'& $" $0% *%=&"# O0? $0%*% '& #" -"#-3,+'#: +'&-,&&'"# "4 ;%$0"+"3":? '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)H 1/%2R )# dFK \b# $0% 8"O%*& "4 $0% P'#+ O0'-0 !"#&$'$,$% e%#',&] V=#$ $%33& ,&Z U0%#%M%* O% -"#M%? ",* $0",:0$&< $0%*% =*% $O" O=?& _1"0'` "4 =**=#:'#: $0%;< =#+ "#% "4 $0%&% '& -=33%+ ;=##%* _1"0?3 */329/2'H ,?3`< $0% "$0%* 1/29"0 _1"0?3 (")',?3`Y $0% +'44%*%#-% G%$O%%# $0%&% $O" '& $0=$ $0% 4'*&$ 0=& #" &$=#+=*+ "$0%* $0=# $0% @//('%) $0=$ $0%*% '& ,#'$? '# $0% %(0'G'$'"# i"4 $0% $0",:0$&j< O0%*%=& $0% &%-"#+ 4"33"O& '# i=33 "4j $0'& +%$%*;'#=$% 8#'%,'8(/3 R R R _5NR 6ZA.I^.K` /0'& &,::%&$& $0=$ $0% ;"+% "4 %(C"&'$'"# 0%*% '& "#% "4 ,&'#: $0% ;%$0"+ "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =4$%* $0% ;=##%* "4 4%%3'#:R /0'& &,::%&$'"# '& :'M%# 4,*$0%* &,CC"*$ '4 O% $,*# $" $0% 5CC%#+'( $" $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R T%*% V=#$ &%$& ",$ \/0% 5;C0'G"3? "4 !"#-%C$& "4 L%43%-$'"#] =#+ *%;'#+& ,& $0=$Z L%43%-$'"# _#/@(/<'"` +"%& #"$ -"#-%*# '$&%34 O'$0 "GS%-$& $0%;&%3M%& O'$0 = M'%O $" +%*'M'#: -"#-%C$& 4*"; $0%; +'*%-$3?< G,$ '& $0=$ &$=$% "4 ;'#+ '# O0'-0 O% 4'*&$ &%$ ",*&%3M%& $" +'&-"M%* $0% &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"#& ,#+%* O0'-0 i=3"#%j O% =*% =G3% $" =**'M% =$ -"#-%C$&R [email protected]` 533 S,+:;%#$& _%M%# +%$%*;'#=$% "#%&` *%J,'*% *%43%-$'"# =& $0'& C3=-%& $0%; ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#:& "4 $0% =CC*"C*'=$% -":#'$'M% 4=-,3$?R /0% G=&'& "4 *%43%-$'"# '& = 2#*%3,/%0/%2*( 2"8', O0'-0 -"#$='#& 4",* 0%=+'#:& "4 '$& "O#Z '+%#$'$?f+'44%*%#-%< =:*%%;%#$f"CC"&'$'"#< '##%*f",$%* =#+ ;=$$%*f4"*;R )# S,+:;%#$& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $0'& &,GS%-$'M% G=&'& "4

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

_3":'-=3` =#=3?$'- =& &,-0 -=# =--",#$ 4"* $0% C*'"*'$?R W"O '4 = *%M%*1 &=3 "4 $0% 3":'-=3 "*+%* $=N%& C3=-% 0%*% 4"* *%=&"#& O0'-0 =*% #"$ 3":'-=3< O0? &0",3+ '$ #"$ -"#$'#,%X U0=$ '& $0% *,3% "* -*'$'-=3 3';'$ 0%*%X@

DF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0% +'&$"*$'"# "* $0% ;"#&$*"&'$? $0=$ =44%-$& $0% -=$%:"*'%& G? ;%=#& "4 O0'-0 $0% =#=3?&'& "4 $=&$% C*"-%%+&< *%&,3$& 4*"; $0% 4=-$ $0=$ 0%*% $0% ;"M%;%#$ "4 *%43%-$'M% =#=;#%&'& O"*N& 4*"; $0% "GS%-$'M% $" $0% &,GS%-$'M%R _[?"$=*+< "8V ,'2V< CR .H`

'-* K+2*#$ +, L;"7.$( b# $0'& G=&'& [?"$=*+ *%&C"#+& $" 7%**'+=]& J,%&$'"# =& $" $0% *%=&"# O0? $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$? C*%-%+%& $0=$ "4 m,=#$'$? '# $0% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%Z )$ '& #" =--'+%#$ $0=$ J,=3'$? $=N%& $0% C3=-% "4 J,=#$'$? =$ $0% 0%=+ "4 $0% -=$%:"*'-=3 =#=3?&'& "4 $=&$%Z $0% \?%&] =#+ $0% \#"] "4 4%%3'#: =*% #"$ = &';C3% 3":'-=3 C*"C%*$? "4 S,+:;%#$ -"#$='#%+ G? $0% 4%%3'#:Y $0%? +%$%*;'#% O0%$0%* "* #"$ 29/#/ '3 G%=,$?R _[?"$=*+< "8V ,'2V< CR F6` Q#3%&& $0% 4%%3'#: "4 C3%=&,*% '& C*%&%#$ $0%*% '& #" C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$Y $0%*%4"*% %&$=G3'&0'#: $0=$ '$ '& C*%&%#$ =#+ 0"O $" +%$%*;'#% $0=$ '$ '& $0'& 4%%3'#: '# C=*$'-,3=* $0=$ '& C*%&%#$ ;,&$ G% $0% 4'*&$ $=&N "4 =# =#=3?&'& "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R a,$ $" +%$%*;'#% $0=$ $0% 4%%3'#: '& C*%&%#$ +%C%#+&< &" V=#$ $%33& ,&< "# "#% $0'#: =3"#%Z \O0%$0%* ;? ;%*% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% $0'#: '& =--";C=#'%+ G? = 3'N'#:] _5NR 6Z@E6` O'$0",$ *%4%*%#-% $" &%#&=$'"# "* -"#-%C$R W%-%&&=*'3?< &,-0 = S,+:;%#$ 0=& $" G% +'&$'#-$ 4*"; "#% =G",$ &%#&=$'"# =& $0% &%3%-$'"# '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 &%#&=$'"# '& +%$%*;'#%+ G? #%%+ =#+ $0,& #"$ G? = C,*% 3'N'#:R BJ,=33? #%-%&&=*'3?< &'#-% O0=$ O% =*% -"#-%*#%+ O'$0 '& = C,*% 3'N'#:< '$ -=# G% G=&%+ "# #" -"#-%C$ =& = -"#-%C$ -";C%3& ,& $" S,+:% %'$0%* =--"*+'#: $" $0% +%$%*;'#=$'M% *,3%& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: "* $0% #%-%&&'$'%& "4 ,#'M%*&=3 =CC3'-=$'"# :'M%# '# ;"*=3&R a"$0 &%#&=$'"# =#+ -"#-%C$&< $0%*%4"*%< *%&$ "# #%%+& =#+ =*% +%$%*;'#%+ G? $0%;R 5 C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% ;=#'4%&$& '$& C,*'$? '# *%4%**'#: ,& $" #" "$0%* G=&'& $0=# = 3'N'#: O0'-0 S,&$'4'%& '$&%34 =#+ :'M%& '$&%34 '$& "O# *,3%R /0'& '& C*%-'&%3? O0=$ '& ;%=#$ '# +%&-*'G'#: '$ =& &,GS%-$'M%R /0'& =--",#$ "4 $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$? '# $0% \5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'1 4,3] C*"+,-%& = C,*% =44'*;=$'"# _O0'-0 '& O0=$ '& ;%=#$ 0%*% G? = 4%%3'#:

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

+%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 -"#-%C$& C*%-%+%& $0% "C%*=$'"# "4 $0% -=$%:"*'%& O0%*%=&Z

"4 C3%=&,*%`< G,$ '$ '& $0% *%M%3=$'"# "4 O0=$ ;=N%& $0'& =44'*;=$'"# C,*% O0'-0 '& $0% *%&,3$ "4 $0% %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$? =#+ '& O0=$ ;=N%& $0'& %(C"&'$'"# +'&$'#-$ 4*"; = 3":'-=3 "#% O0%*% $0% 4=-$ "4 =44'*;=$'"# O",3+ #%%+ $" G% %&$=G3'&0%+ =#+ %(C3='#%+ _=#+ O",3+ G% =3O=?& -"#+'$'"#=3`R /0'& =--",#$ "4 $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$? -=# G% :'M%# = :%#%*=3 %($%#&'"# $" =33 $0% P";%#$& "4 $0% \5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3] 4"*< =& [?"$=*+ C,$& '$Z R R R $0% C,*% -"#-%C$& "#3? =CC3? $" 4%%3'#: "# $0% -"#+'$'"#< = *%43%-1 $'M% -"#+'$'"#< =& '$ O%*%< $0=$ $0%? G%#+ $" 4%%3'#:]& *%&'&$=#-% =#+ $0=$ $0%? +'&$"*$ $0% &$*=':0$ &?#$0%&%& =,$0"*'k%+ '# $0%'* *%=3; '# "*+%* $" *%;='# 4='$04,3 $" 4%%3'#:R /0,& '$ O'33 G% &0"O# 4",* $';%& $0=$ $=&$% "#3? 3%$& '$&%34 G% ,#+%*&$""+ G? $0% -=$%:"*'%& "# $0% -"#+'$'"# $0=$ '$ %&-=C% $0% -=$%:"*?]& 3":'-R _[?"$=*+< "8V ,'2V< CR FD` /0% =44'*;=$'"# O0'-0 '& C*"+,-%+ G? $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$? *%3=$%& $0% 3":'-=3 ;";%#$ "4 J,=3'$? $" $0% $"C'-=3 0%=+'#: "4 =:*%%;%#$f"CC"&'1 $'"#R !"#&'+%*%+ "#3? #/*('2*3 %"?1/%"%< *%=3'$? -"#$='#& #" "CC"&'$'"#& =#+ '#+%%+ $0% #"$'"# "4 = C,*% =44'*;=$'"# O'$0",$ *%&$*'-$'M% -"#+'1 $'"# 0=& $0'& 4"*;R 5& &,-0 $0% 3":'-=3 ;";%#$ '& *%+,-%+ $" '$& $"C'-=3 C*%-"#+'$'"#< = C,*% %(C%*'%#-% "4 $0% *%=3 O0'-0 *%J,'*%& =# =,$"1 =44%-$'"# O'$0",$ *%&%*M%R

'-* K+2*#$ +, L;"#$.$( /0% &%-"#+ ;";%#$ "4 m,=#$'$? C*%&%#$& O0=$ !*=O4"*+ *':0$3? +%&-*'G%+ =& \=# */329/2', >?*%2'2: "4 ,#'M%*&=3'$?] O0'-0 0% 4",#+ &,&C'1 -'",& G%-=,&% 0% -",3+ &%% #" -3%=* O=? "4 &%C=*=$'#: $0'& 4*"; $0% 3":'-=3 J,=#$'$? "4 ,#'M%*&=3'$? _!*=O4"*+< "8V ,'2V< CCR .D^.H`R V=#$ +"%& '#+%%+ =+;'$ $0=$ O% $=3N "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 \=& '4 G%=,$? O%*% = -0=*=-$%*'&$'- "4 $0% "GS%-$ =#+ $0% S,+:;%#$ O%*% 3":'-=3] _5NR 6Z@..` C*%-'&%3? G%-=,&% $0% 4*%% 3'N'#: O% =-0'%M% '# S,+:'#: &";%$0'#: G%=,1 $'4,3 &%%;& &" -3%=* $0=$ O% =*% =&$"#'&0%+ $" 4'#+ =#?"#% '# O0"; $0% &=;% 4%%3'#: '& #"$ =O=N%#%+R a,$ :'M%# $0=$ $0% ,#'M%*&=3'$? "4 = S,+:1 ;%#$ "4 $=&$% +"%& #"$ *%&$ "# -"#-%C$& '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" '#+'-=$% $0% G=&'& 4"* = &C%-'4'- =%&$0%$'- J,=#$'$? "4 ,#'M%*&=3'$?R )# &";% *%&C%-$& $0'& =&C%-$ "4 $0% %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% \5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3] '& *%C*'&%+ $0*",:0",$ $0% O"*N =#+ 4"*;& "#% "4 $0% ;=S"* *%J,'*%;%#$& "4 = &,--%&&4,3 -=**?'#: $0*",:0 "4 $0% %#$%*C*'&% "4 -"#&$*,-$'#: = -*'$'J,% "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ D6

U0'3&$ $0% %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$? *%J,'*%+ ,& $" %3,-'1 +=$% = C,*% =44'*;=$'"# O'$0",$ 3":'-=3 *%&$*'-$'"#< $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=#$'$? *%J,'*%& #"$ ;%*%3? = &$=$%;%#$ "4 = ,#'M%*&=3'$? O0'-0 '& #"$ -"#-%C$,=3 G,$ =3&" = 4%%3'#: O0'-0 $=N%& = 4"*; $0=$ G%=*& -";C=*1 '&"# O'$0 = 3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$R 2"* $0'& $" ;=N% &%#&% =$ =33 O% #%%+ $" *%;%;G%* $0=$ = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& #"$ = &$=$%;%#$ "4 4'#+'#: &";%1 $0'#: _-"#$'#:%#$3?`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a%-=,&% '$ +"%& #"$ *%&$ "# 3":'-=3 :*",#+& _$0",:0 =#=3":",& '# 4"*;` '$ -=##"$ G% S,&$'4'%+ -"#-%C$,=33? =#+ '& #"$ "GS%-$'M% '# &$=$,& G,$ C,*%3? &,GS%-$'M% _=#+ $0'& C,*'$? "4 &,GS%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '& O0=$ O% =*% '# = C"&'$'"# $" 0=M% &";% &%#&% "4 G%-=,&% "4 0=M'#: C*%M'",&3? %(C",#+%+ $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$?`R /0% C%-,3'=*'$? "4 $0'& ,#'M%*&=3 S,+:;%#$ '& ;=+% %(C3'-'$ G? $0% O=? V=#$ +'&$'#:,'&0%& '$ 4*"; 3":'-=3 ,#'M%*&=3'$?Z R R R 4"* =3$0",:0 '$ +"%& #"$ -"##%-$ $0% C*%+'-=$% "4 G%=,$? O'$0 $0% -"#-%C$ "4 $0% "7J/,2< -"#&'+%*%+ '# '$& %#$'*% 3":'-=3 &C0%*%< ?%$ '$ %($%#+& $0=$ C*%+'-=$% "M%* $0% %#$'*% &C0%*% "@ J?0)'%) 8/#3"%3R _5NR [email protected]` V=#$ +"%& #"$ ;%*%3? $%33 ,& $0=$ $0% m,=#$'$? "4 =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ "4 *%43%-$'"# '& ,#'M%*&=3< 0% =3&" &$=$%& $0=$ '$ '& &'#:,3=*R )$ ;,&$ G% &'#:,3=* =& '$ '& #"$ -"#-%C$,=3 =#+ O% -=##"$ &';C3? G% =*:,%+ '#$" $0% M'%O $0=$ &";%$0'#: '& G%=,$'4,3R \U% O=#$ $" &,G;'$ $0% "GS%-$ $" ",* "O# %?%&< S,&$ =& '4 ",* 3'N'#: "4 '$ +%C%#+%+ "# $0=$ &%#&=$'"#] _5NR [email protected]`R /0,& O0=$ O% 0=M% $" C"&$,3=$% '# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& $0% %('&$%#-% "4 O0=$ V=#$ -=33& = \?%'G/#3*( G"',/]< O0'-0 '& '# 4=-$ \;%*%3? =# '+%=]< ?%$ "#% O0"&% 8"33'7'('2: 0=& $" G% &,CC"&%+ $" =--",#$ 4"* $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# = *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% =#+ = &%#&=$'"#=3 &$=$%;%#$ "4 $=&$% _O0'-0 3=$$%* -=**'%& O'$0 '$ #" ,#'M%*&=3 -3=';`R T"O $0'& C"&&'G'3'$? -=# G% %#$%*$='#%+ =$ =33 '& O0=$ $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=#$'$? 0=& $" *%M%=3R >%-$'"# K "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

DD C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ DH

/0% &"3,$'"# "4 $0'& C*"G3%; '& $0% N%? $" $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% =#+ 0%#-% +%&%*M%& 4,33 =$$%#$'"#R _5NR [email protected]` /0% &,::%&$'"# $0=$ $0% 4%%3'#: "4 C3%=&,*% C*%-%+%& $0% S,+:'#: "4 $0% "GS%-$ '# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% ;':0$ G% $0",:0$ =C$ :'M%# $0=$ O% 0=M% #%%+%+ $" %(C",#+ $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$? C*'"* $" $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=#$'$?R T"O%M%*< '4 $0% C3%=&,*% C*%-%+%+ $0% S,+:;%#$< $0%# $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% "GS%-$ O",3+ G% $0% 4'*&$ $0'#: G*",:0$ '#$" $0% S,+:;%#$ =& $0=$ "# O0'-0 '$ O",3+ #%-%&&=*'3? +%C%#+R a,$< :'M%# $0=$ = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& C,*%3? &,GS%-$'M% =#+ 0%#-% #"$ +%C%#+%#$ ,C"# $0% %('&$%#-% "4 $0% "GS%-$ G*",:0$ G%4"*% '$< O% ;,&$ &$=$% $0=$ 4"* $0% S,+:;%#$ $" G% +%C%#+%#$ "# $0% C3%=&,*% O",3+ G% $=#$=;",#$ $" *%+,-'#: $0% *%43%-$'M% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% $" = ;%*%3? &%#&=1 $'"#=3 S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%R T%#-% '$ ;,&$ G% $0% ,#'M%*&=3 -";;,#'-=G'3'$? "4 $0% ;%#$=3 &$=$%< '# $0% :'M%# C*%&%#$=$'"#< O0'-0 ,#+%*3'%& $0% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% =& '$& &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"#< =#+ $0% C3%=&,*% '# $0% "GS%-$ ;,&$ G% '$& -"#&%J,%#-%R _5NR [email protected]`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

%(C3'-=$%& $0'& ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: \)#M%&$':=$'"# "4 $0% m,%&$'"# U0%$0%* '# = 9,+:;%#$ "4 /=&$% $0% 2%%3'#: "4 83%=&,*% 8*%-%+%& $0% 9,+:'#: "4 $0% bGS%-$ "* $0% 9,+:'#: 8*%-%+%& $0% 83%=&,*%]R 5$ $0% G%:'##'#: "4 $0'& &%-$'"# V=#$ O*'$%&Z

%M%*?"#%]& C*%&%#$=$'"#=3 C"O%* '& -";C%33%+ $" 0=*;"#'k%R )4< $0%#< O% =*% $" $0'#N $0=$ $0% S,+:;%#$ =G",$ $0'& ,#'M%*&=3 -";;,#'-1 =G'3'$? "4 $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# 0=& = ;%*%3? &,GS%-$'M% +%$%*;'#'#: G=&'&< 'R%R< "#% $0=$ +"%& #"$ '#M"3M% = -"#-%C$ "4 $0% "GS%-$< $0%# $0'& G=&'& -=# G% #"$0'#: "$0%* $0=# $0% ;%#$=3 &$=$% $0=$ O% 4'#+ '# $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# $0% C*%&%#$=$'"#=3 C"O%*& i';=:'#=$'"# =#+ ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#:j '#&"4=* =& $0%? *%4%* = :'M%# C*%&%#$=$'"# $" ,")%'2'"% '% )/%/#*(R _5NR [email protected]`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email protected]` /0'& \4*%% C3=?] G%$O%%# ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ ,#+%*&$=#+'#: ;,&$ G% ,#'1 M%*&=33? -";;,#'-=G3% G%-=,&% $0% =&C%-$& O0'-0 ;=N% -":#'$'"# C"&1 &'G3% =$ =33 =*% '#M"3M%+ 0%*% O'$0",$ 3%=+'#: $" $0% -":#'$'M% +'&-"M%*? $0=$ &";%$0'#: %('&$&R /0'& \&,GS%-$'M% *%3=$'"#] "4 -":#'$'M% C"O%*& \;,&$ 0"3+ S,&$ =& ;,-0 4"* %M%*?"#%< =#+ 0%#-% G% S,&$ =& ,#'M%*&=33? -";;,#'-=G3%] =& =#? =&C%-$ "4 -":#'$'"# =& \-":#'$'"# =3O=?& *%&$& "# $0=$ *%3=$'"# =& '$& &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"#] _5NR [email protected]`R 5& [?"$=*+ &,::%&$%+< $0%*%4"*%< O% *%$,*# "#-% =:='# $" $0% C"&&'G'1 3'$? "4 $0% "C%*=$'"# "4 $0% P";%#$ "4 m,=#$'$?< O0'-0 '& 0%*% $0% $"C'-=3 \0%=+'#:] "4 '+%#$'$?R /0% &$=$% O0'-0 '& %#$'$3%+ = \4*%% C3=?] '& #"$ -"#-%*#%+ "* -"##%-$%+ O'$0 =#?$0'#: +'44%*%#$ 4*"; '$&%34 =#+ '$ '& '$& C,*% &%341'+%#$'$? _"* =,$"1=44%-$'"#` $0=$ ;=N%& C"&&'G3% = C,*% =44'*;1 =$'"#R /0'& C,*% &%341'+%#$'$? '# = C,*% =44'*;=$'"# '& "4 #%-%&&'$? $0% C"&&'G'3'$? =& &,-0 "4 =#? C,*% &,GS%-$'M'$? =#+ ;,&$ G% $0% ,#'J,% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 -";;,#'-=$'"# G%$O%%# &,GS%-$'M'$'%& =& '$ +%C%#+& '# #" O=? "# $0% #%%+& $0=$ =*'&% 4*"; $0% %('&$%#-% "4 "GS%-$& =#+ ?%$ =,$0"*'&%& ,& $" &C%=N "4 =# %(C%*'%#-% O0'-0 '# '$& M%*? &'#:,3=*'$?

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

DI C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ DK

=44'*;& %=-0 $';% = -";;,#'-=$'"# O0'-0 '& #"$ +%C%#+%#$ "# $0% -"#-%C$,=3 4"*;& "4 C,*% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R

/0% 4'*&$ $O" P";%#$& "4 $0% 9,+:;%#$ "4 /=&$% =*% %(C"&'$'"#& "4 $0% -"#+'$'"#& ,#+%* O0'-0 '$ '& C"&&'G3% $" &C%=N "4 $0%*% G%'#: S,+:;%#$& O0'-0 =*% =%&$0%$'- G,$ =3&" *%43%-$'M%R /0% #%($ $O" P";%#$& 4,*$0%* -3=*'4? $0'& =3$0",:0 $0% %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% /0'*+ P";%#$ _"4 L%3=$'"#` 0=& $O" +'&$'#-$'M% C%-,3'=*'$'%&R 2'*&$< O0'3&$ $0% 2'*&$ P";%#$ '& -3%=*3? =# =44'*;=$'M% "#% =#+ $0% &%-"#+ =# %J,=33? %M'+%#$ ,#'M%*&=3 J,=#1 $,; _-";C3'-=$%+< 0"O%M%*< '# G%'#: =3&" &'#:,3=*`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fa.ED`R !";1 ;,#'$? '#M"3M%& '#$%**%3=$'"# =#+ $0'& '& &%$ ",$ C*=-$'-=33? '# $0% >%-1 "#+ !*'$'J,%]& /=G3% "4 !=$%:"*'%& "4 2*%%+";R b#-% O% &%% $0=$ $0% '#$%**%3=$'"# G%$O%%# &,GS%-$& '# $=&$% '& :*",#+%+ "# = C,*% =,$"1=44%-1 $'"# "C%*=$'#: O'$0'# %=-0 &,GS%-$< $0%# $0% #"$'"# "4 = *%3=$'"# O0'-0 '& ;"+%33%+ "# ;"*=3'$? G,$ +'&$'#-$ 4*"; '$ O'33 #%-%&&=*'3? *%J,'*% = $*%=$;%#$ "4 C,*C"&%R /0% '#-3,&'"# "4 $0'& #"$'"# ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 L%3=$'"# '& = #"M%3$?< G,$ *%4%*%#-% $" $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% ;=N%& -3%=* $0=$ '$ '& #"$ %#$'*%3? ,#C*%-%+%#$%+R V=#$ G%:'#& $0% /0'*+ P";%#$ G? %(C",#+'#: \C,*C"&'M%#%&& '# :%#%*=3] _d.E`R B(C3'-=$'#: = C,*C"&% $*=#&-%#+%#$=33?< 0% &$=$%& $0=$ = C,*C"&% '& \$0% "GS%-$ "4 = -"#-%C$ '#&"4=* =& O% *%:=*+ $0'& -"#-%C$ =& $0% "GS%-$]& -=,&%] =#+ '# *%3=$'"# $" $0% '#M%&$':=$'"#& "4 $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% O% +%$%*;'#%+ $0'& =& \$0% O'33] O0'-0 ;=N%& ;"*=3 =-$'"# C"&&'G3% =#+ :'M%& ,& '$& -"#+'$'"#& "4 '#$%33':'G'3'$?R /0'& +",G3% *"3% "4 = C,*C"&% ^ G"$0 =& "*':'#=$"* "4 = C*"-%&& =#+ =& C*'#-'C3% "4 %(C3=#=$'"# "4 $0=$ C*"-%&& ^ '& O0=$ :'M%& ,& $0% #"$'"# "4 = 4'#=3 -=,&%R a,$Z

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'-* K+2*#$ +, =*7"$.+#

R R R O% +" -=33 "GS%-$&< &$=$%& "4 ;'#+< "* =-$& C,*C"&'M% %M%# '4 $0%'* C"&&'G'3'$? +"%& #"$ #%-%&&=*'3? C*%&,CC"&% $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 = C,*C"&%Y O% +" $0'& ;%*%3? G%-=,&% O% -=# %(C3='# $0%; =#+ :*=&C $0%; "#3? '4 O% =&&,;% $0=$ $0%? =*% G=&%+ "# = -=,&=3'$? i$0=$ "C%*=$%&j =--"*+'#: $" C,*C"&%&< 'R%R< "# = O'33 $0=$ O",3+ 0=M% =**=#:%+ $0%; '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 = -%*$='# *,3%R T%#-% $0%*% -=# G% C,*C"&'M%#%&& O'$0",$ = C,*C"&%< '#&"4=* =& O% +" #"$ =3O=?& #%%+ $" 0=M% '#&':0$ '#$" '$ G? *%=&"# _=& $" 0"O '$ '& C"&&'G3%`R _5NR 6Z@@E` 5:='#< O% =*% *%4%**%+ 0%*% $" $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"#& "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"%< O0'-0 '& O0%*% O% O%*% &0"O# $0=$ $0% -=,&=3'$? "4 4*%%+"; O=& = #%-%&&=*? #"$'"# $" &,CC"&% 4"* ;"*=3'$?]& C"&&'G'3'$'%& $" G% -";C*%0%#&'G3%R P"*=3'$? *%&$& "# $0% &,CC"&'$'"# "4 = C,*C"&'M%#%&& '# :%#%*=3 O'$0",$ G%'#: =G3% $" +%;"#&$*=$% = C,*C"&% =& G%'#: %('&$%#$ _O0'-0 '# "$0%* -=&%& -",3+ G% +"#% &C%-,3=$'M%3? G,$ #"$ '# $0'& -=&% =& $0'& O",3+ $*=#&-%#+ =#? C"&&'G3% %(C%*'%#-%`R /0% /0'*+ P";%#$ #%%+&< $0%*%4"*%< $" G% +'&$'#:,'&0%+ 4*"; $0% +%$%*;'#=$'M% S,+:;%#$& "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# O0'-0 '& O0=$ '$ '& ;"&$ 3'N%R U0=$ '& '#M"3M%+ 0%*% '& =# %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% 4"*; "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& =G&$*=-$%+ 4*"; =#? -"#$%#$ G%'#: =&&':#%+ =& C,*C"&'M%R 5 ;"*=3 C,*C"&% *%J,'*%& =# '#M"31 M%;%#$ '# $0% S,+:;%#$ G%'#: ;=+% =G",$ $0% *':0$#%&& "* O*"#:#%&& "4 C=*$'-,3=* "*'%#$=$'"#& O0'-0 '#M"3M%;%#$ '& = #%-%&&=*? -";C"#%#$ "4 =#? 4"*; "4 %$0'-=3 $0'#N'#:R a,$ 4"* &,-0 '#M"3M%;%#$ $" G% '#M"N%+ '# $0% -"#$%($ "4 =# =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'"# O",3+ G% $" 4='3 $" *%3=$% $" $0% 4=-$ $0=$ &,-0 =# =%&$0%$'- '& +%C%#+%#$ 4"* '$& C"&&'G'3'$? "# $0% C,*% *%3=$'"#& G%$O%%# $0% %3%;%#$& "4 -":#'$'"#R 5& &,-0< '$ '& $0% C,*C"&'M% 4"*; "4 -":#'$'"# O0'-0 '& '#M"N%+ O'$0",$ $0%*% G%'#: =#?$0'#: -":1 #'&%+R BM%# &"Z R R R '$ +"%& 0=M% = -=,&=3'$? '# '$< #=;%3?< $" -//8 i,& '#j $0% &$=$% "4 i0=M'#:j $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# '$&%34< =#+ i$" N%%Cj $0% -":#'$'M% C"O%*& %#:=:%+ i'# $0%'* "--,C=$'"#j O'$0",$ =#? 4,*$0%* =';R U% ('%)/# '# ",* -"#$%;C3=$'"# "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3< G%-=,&% $0'& -"#$%;C3=$'"# *%'#1 4"*-%& =#+ *%C*"+,-%& '$&%34R _5NR 6Z@@@` /0% -"#$%;C3=$'"# O% %#:=:% '# O0%# -"#4*"#$%+ O'$0 $0% G%=,$'4,3 '& "#% O0'-0 %(0'G'$& = -=,&=3'$? '# C*"+,-'#: $0% %44%-$ "4 &,CC*%&&'#: ",* ';C=$'%#$ &,G;'&&'"# $" #%%+& =#+ 0=3$'#: ,& G%4"*% $0% O"#+%* "4 $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0%*% '& &,-0 = C"&&'G'3'$? =& $0% =44'*;=$'M% C,*'$? "4 C,*% &,GS%-$'M'$?R /0% C,*'$? "4 $0% C,*C"&'M%#%&& '#M"3M%+ '# =# =%&$0%$'-

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

HE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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` '& %'$0%* 39*8/ "* 8(*:Y '4 $0% 3=$$%*< '$ '& %'$0%* C3=? "4 &0=C%& _'# &C=-%< #=;%3?< ;';%$'- =*$ =#+ +=#-%`< "* ;%*% C3=? "4 &%#&=$'"#& _'# $';%`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` U0=$ ;=N%& $0% =$$%#$'"# $" $0% ;=$$%* "4 $0% "GS%-$ C"&&'G3% '& $0=$ $0% ;=$$%* '& C,*C"&'M%3? $*=#&4"*;%+ '#$" = 4"*;=3 %3%;%#$ "4 =%&$0%$'S,+:;%#$R )# G%'#: &" $*=#&4"*;%+ '$ G%-";%& &,'$=G3% =& C=*$ "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "GS%-$< G,$ '$& %#$*? '#$" $0% =%&$0%$'- %3%;%#$ "4 S,+:;%#$ '& =3O=?& =# =-$ "4 '#+,3:%#-% =& &,-0 C=*$& "4 $0% -"#$%;C3=$'"# =3O=?& $0*%=$%# $" +'&$*=-$ 4*"; $0% C,*'$? "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- &$=$%R /0%*% ;=? G% "--=&'"#& "# O0'-0 &,-0 +'&$*=-$'"# '& =# '#$%#$'"#=3 %3%;%#$ "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- &$=$%< G,$ &,-0 = &$=$% '& #"$ = C,*% =%&$0%$'- &$=$%R V=#$ =33"O& 4"*< =#+ '# $0% /0'*+ P";%#$ %(C",#+&< = #"#1C,*% =%&$0%$'- &$=$% O'$0",$< 0"O%M%*< &,G&,;'#: $0'& ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: \=:*%%=G3% &%#&=1 $'"#]R Q#+%* $0% #"$'"# "4 \C,*C"&'M%] O% -=# ,#+%*&$=#+ $0=$ = C,*% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ '& C,*C"&'M% O'$0",$ = C,*C"&% G,$ $0=$ = #"#1 C,*% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ '& C,*C"&'M% O'$0 = C,*C"&%R /0% 3=$$%*< =& = #"#1C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%< +%*'M%& '$& C,*C"&% 4*"; ;"*=3 S,+:;%#$R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ H.

V=#$ 4'*&$ C*%&%#$& $0'& +'&$'#-$'"# '# d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`R /0'& -"#$*=&$& ;=*N%+3? O'$0 "$0%* 4"*;& "4 #=$,*=3 G%=,$?Z R R R $0% G%=,$? "4 = 0,;=# G%'#: _=#+< =& N'#+& &,G"*+'#=$% $" = 0,;=# G%'#:< $0% G%=,$? "4 = ;=# "* O";=# "* -0'3+`< "* $0% G%=,$? "4 = 0"*&% "* "4 = G,'3+'#: _&,-0 =& = -0,*-0< C=3=-%< =*;",*?< "* &,;;%*10",&%` +"%& C*%&,CC"&% $0% -"#-%C$ "4 $0% C,*C"&% $0=$ +%$%*;'#%& O0=$ $0% $0'#: '& i;%=#$j $" G%< =#+ 0%#-% = -"#-%C$ "4 '$& C%*4%-$'"#< =#+ &" '$ '& ;%*%3? =+0%*%#$ G%=,$?R _5NR 6Z@AE` W"#% "4 $0% =G"M% ;%#$'"#%+ #=$,*=3 G%=,$'%& -=# G% 3""N%+ "# 8?#/(: G%-=,&% = *%4%*%#-% $" $0% C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 $0'& %3%;%#$ "4 #=$,*% '& '#%M'$=G3? '#M"3M%+ O0'-0 3%=+& ,& $" S,+:% '$ =& \:""+] "4 '$& N'#+R /0'& \:""+#%&&] '& +%$%*;'#%+ '# *%4%*%#-% $" %($%*'"* C,*C"&%& *=$0%* $0=# &';C3% -"#$%;C3=$'"#R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& O% -=# &,*;'&% $0=$ &";% $0'#:& -=# #%M%*< G%-=,&% "4 $0%'* #=$,*%< G% '#M"3M%+ '# = C,*% =%&$0%$'S,+:;%#$R b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a,$ O0'3&$ $0'& '& &$*'-$3? $0% -=&% $0% &%-"#+ +'&C,$=#$ -=# C"'#$ $" $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $=&$% "4$%# '& C*%&%#$%+ =& -"#$='#'#: $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 :%#%*=3 =:*%%;%#$ "# :*",#+& "$0%* $0=# $0% \?%'G/#3*( G"',/] '#M"N%+ G? V=#$ =#+ $0=$ $0%&% "$0%* :*",#+& =*% $0% $%#+%#-? $" %;C'*'-=3 =:*%%;%#$ =G",$ $0% G%&$ %(=;C3%& _;"&$ C%*4%-$ N'#+&` "4 G%=,$'4,3 "GS%-$R /" $0'& -3='; V=#$ *%&C"#+& G? &%$$'#: ",$ $0% #"$'"# "4

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

H@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ HA

R R R '4 =# '+%=3 '& $" G% 3"-=$%+ '# =#? N'#+ "4 G=&%& 4"* S,+:'#:< $0%# $0%*% ;,&$ G% &";% ,#+%*3?'#: '+%= "4 *%=&"#< :"M%*#%+ G? +%$%*;'#1 =$% -"#-%C$&< $0=$ +%$%*;'#%& * 8#'"#' $0% C,*C"&% "# O0'-0 $0% "GS%-$]& '##%* C"&&'G'3'$? *%&$&R 5# '+%=3 "4 G%=,$'4,3 43"O%*&< "4 G%=,1 $'4,3 4,*#'&0'#:&< "* "4 = G%=,$'4,3 M'%O '& ,#$0'#N=G3%R _5NR 6Z@AA` a,$ ;=#? +%$%*;'#=$% C,*C"&%& +" #"$ ?'%3+ =# '+%=3 %'$0%*R 5 G%=,$'4,3 :=*+%# -=# G% C*"+,-%+ 4"* ;=#? N'#+& "4 *%=&"#< =& -=# = G%=,$'4,3 ;=#&'"#R a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` =#+ *=$'"#=3 _$0,& +%$%*;'#=G3% G? C,*C"&%& "4 4*%%+";`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=# )+%=3 "4 G%=,$?R T% &$=$%& $0=$ '$ '& \=# '+%=3 "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#] G%-=,&% '$ +"%& #"$ 0=M% = -"#-%C$,=3 G=&'& _=#+ '# $0=$ *%&C%-$ =--"*+& O'$0 O0=$ O% 0=M% ,#+%*&$""+ =G",$ C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%` =#+ =3&"< \'4 O% =*% $" &%%N =# '+%=3 "4 G%=,$? $0%# $0% G%=,$? ;,&$ G% @'
HF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

R R R $0%&% ;"*=3 '+%=& ;,&$ G% -"##%-$%+< '# $0% '+%= "4 $0% 0':0%&$ C,*C"&'M%#%&&< O'$0 %M%*?$0'#: $0=$ ",* *%=&"# 3'#N& O'$0 $0% ;"*=33? :""+Z :""+#%&& "4 &",3< "* C,*'$?< "* 4"*$'$,+%< "* &%*%#'$?< %$-RY =#+ '# "*+%* 4"* $0'& -"##%-$'"# $" G% ;=+% M'&'G3%< =& '$ O%*%< '# G"+'3? %(C*%&&'"# _=& =# %44%-$ "4 O0=$ '& '#O=*+`< C,*% '+%=& "4 *%=&"# ;,&$ G% ,#'$%+ O'$0 = M%*? &$*"#: ';=:'#=$'"# '# &";%"#% O0" &%%N& &" ;,-0 =& $" S,+:%< 3%$ =3"#% %(0'G'$ '$R _5NR 6Z@A6` /0'& #"#1C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% *%J,'*%& $0% 4"*;=$'"# "4 $0% C%*&"# O0" -",3+ S,+:% '$ G? *%4%*%#-% $" )+%=&R a,$ $0'& C*"-%&& "4 4"*;=$'"# O'33 *%J,'*% G"$0 = $*='#'#: '# *%=&"# =#+ = -*%=$'M% %#:=:%;%#$ O'$0 ';=:'#=$'"#R /0'& '& $0% C*"M'#-% "4 -,3$,*% =#+ V=#$ +'&-,&&%& $0% '+%= "4 -,3$,*% _'#-3,+'#: $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 '$& C*":*%&&'M% *%=3'&=$'"#` ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 $%3%"3":? _dIA "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2`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a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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

C3%=&,*% O0'-0 '& '#%3';'#=G3% 4*"; $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% 4"*;R a,$ O0=$ 3'4$& $0% &$=#+=*+ '+%=3 =G"M% $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 C,*% -"#$'#:%#-? '#M"3M%+ '# *%4%*%#-%& $" $0% :%#%*=3 =:*%%;%#$ =G",$ $0% &$=#+=*+ '+%= '& $0% =++'$'"# "4 = ;"*=3 -=&$ $" $0% 4':,*% O0'-0 *%M%=3& = 4':,*% $0=$ -=# &%*M% =& = &':# "4 =&C'*=$'"#R BM%# &" $0% %(0'G'$'"# "4 &,-0 =# '+%=3 0=& ';;%#&% +'44'-,3$'%&Z

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ H6

/0% P"+=3'$? "4 = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& &C%-'4'%+ -3%=*3? =#+ ,#%J,'M"1 -=33? G? V=#$Z = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& $0% "GS%-$ "4 = #%-%&&=*? 3'N'#:R a,$ '$ '& =# "++ &"*$ "4 #%-%&&'$? &'#-% '$ '& #%'$0%* $0%"*%$'-=33? #"* C*=-$'-1 =33? "GS%-$'M%R )$ '&< *=$0%*< &$=$%& V=#$< \/
10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'-* K+2*#$ +, K+4"7.$(

HD C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

$*=#&-%#+%#$=3 $"C'- 3%4$Z $0% 4",*$0 0%=+'#: "4 \;=$$%* =#+ 4"*;] "4 O0'-0 V=#$ O*'$%&Z

P=$$%* '& %(C3'-=$%+ =& $0% +%$%*;'#=G3% '# :%#%*=3 O0'3&$ 4"*; '& $0% +%$%*;'#=$'"#R )# -"#-%C$& "4 C,*% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $0% %3%;%#$& "4 $0% ;=$$%* =*% $0% C*';=*? C"'#$ "4 $0% %(C"&'$'"#< O0'3&$ '# $0% %(C"&'$'"# "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% '$ '& #%-%&&=*'3? $0% -=&% _:'M%# $0=$ O% =*% #"$ 0%*% +%=3'#: O'$0 O0=$ '& +%$%*;'#%+ &'#-% #" "GS%-$ '& '# J,%&$'"#` $0=$ O% ;,&$ G% -"#-%*#%+ "#3? O'$0 $0% +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 $0% ;'#+ "* '$& 4"*;=3 -0=*=-$%*'&$'-&R /0'& 4"*; ;,&$ '# 4=-$ G% C,*% =& '$ G%=*& #" *%3=$'"# $" $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 =#?$0'#: "$0%* $0=# C,*% &,GS%-$'M'$?]& -=C=-'$? $" =,$"1=44%-$R /0,& $0% P"+=3'$? "4 $=&$% '& *%&"3M=G3% '#$" $0% 0%=+'#: "4 C,*% 4"*;=3'$? O0'-0 '& $0% $"C'-=3 C"&&'G'3'$? "4 = #%-%&&'$? O0'-0 '& #"$ "GS%-$'M%R

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a%=,$'4,3R )# 0'& \e%#%*=3 !";;%#$] "# $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:1 ;%#$ V=#$ *%&$=$%& $0%&% C"&'$'"#& G? ;=N'#: -3%=* O0=$ O% 0=M% 3%=*#%+ =G",$ $=&$%R /=&$% '& =# =G'3'$? \$" S,+:% =# "GS%-$ '# *%4%*%#-% $" $0% @#// (*.@?(%/33 "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#] "*< \'# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% $0% ';=:'#=$'"# ;,&$ G% -"#&'+%*%+ '# '$& 4*%%+";] _5NR 6Z@FE`R /" ,#+%*&$=#+ $0% ';=:'#=$'"# =& "C%*=$'#: 4*%%3? *%J,'*%&< 0"O%M%*< $0=$ O% #" 3"#:%* -"#-%'M% "4 '$ =& 0=M'#: $0% &=;% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 *,3%& =& 3='+ ",$ '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% =#+ V=#$ =-N#"O3%+:%& $0'& O0%# 0% &$=$%& $0=$ O% #%%+ $" -"#&'+%* $0% ';=:'#=$'"# #"O =& \C*"+,-$'M% =#+ &C"#$=#%",&] O0'-0 *%J,'*%& $0% ';=:'#=$'"# $" "C%*1 =$% $0*",:0 \= 3=O4,3#%&& O'$0",$ = 3=O] _5NR 6Z@F.`R /0'& O'33 *%J,'*% 4,*$0%* =--",#$'#: "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#]& *%3=$'"#&0'C $" ,#+%*&$=#+'#:

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0%&% $O" -"#-%C$& ,#+%*3'% =33 "$0%* *%43%-$'"#< &" '#&%C=*=G3? =*% $0%? G",#+ ,C O'$0 =33 %;C3"?;%#$ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R _5@DDfaA@@`

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ E?#/ A?0)1/%23 "@ B*32/ HH

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=& '$ '& $0% 3=$$%* $0=$ :'M%& $0% 3=O G,$ O'$0",$ -"**%&C"#+'#: $" = +%$%*;'#=$% *,3%R /0% %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% 0=& G%%# +%;"#&$*=$%+ $" G% =$$=-0%+ $" $0% ,#'$? "4 $0% !*'$'-=3 &?&$%; $0*",:0 =# =*-0'$%-$"#'- 1/29"0 "@ 1*%%/# =#+ $" +%;"#&$*=$% $0% +%C%#+%#-% "4 $0% $=G3% "4 S,+:;%#$& ,C"# $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 $"C'-R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

F

U0? +"%& V=#$ 4%%3 $0% #%%+ $" =,:;%#$ $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3 O'$0 =# 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';%X /0'& J,%&$'"# #%-%&&=*'3? =*'&%& $0% ;";%#$ O% #"$% $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 :'M'#: = S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 $0% =*-0'$%-1 $"#'- "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3R /0% '#-3,&'"# "4 =# 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% -"#&'+%*=G3? -";C3'-=$%& $0% J,%&$'"# "4 $0% =*-0'$%-$"#'- "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2R /" +'&-,&& $0% &,G3';% %#$='3& =+;'$1 $'#: $0=$ $=&$% '& #"$ -"$%*;'#",& O'$0 =%&$0%$'-&R 2,*$0%*< O% 0=M% $" =--",#$ 4"* $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$ '& '$&%34 #"$ ;%*%3? '#$%*#=33? +'M'+%+< G,$ $0=$ "#3? "#% "4 '$& ;";%#$& _$0% 5#=3?1 $'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3` -=**'%& $0*",:0 $" '#-3,&'"# =#+ +'&-,&&'"# '# $0% 7'=3%-$'- "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$R )# $0% &%-"#+ )#$*"+,-$'"# $" $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2< V=#$ ;%#$'"#& $0% &,G3';% "#3? 43%%$'#:3?< $0",:0< '#$%*%&$'#:3?< $0'& '& =$ $0% -"#-3,1 &'"# "4 $0% &%-$'"# +'&-,&&'#: $0% =%&$0%$'- C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% C,*C"1 &'M%#%&& "4 #=$,*% _&%-$'"# c))`< S,&$ C*'"* $" $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% 3":'-=3 C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 #=$,*% _&%-$'"# c)))`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` HI

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';%

U0%# '$ -";%& $" &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& O% -=# #"$% $0=$ '# $0% -=&% "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 $0% 4"*; "4 =# "GS%-$ '& C%*-%'M%+ =& C,*C"&'M% %M%# O'$0",$ = -"#-%C$ "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& =#+ $0,& O% =$$*'G,$% $0% &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& \$" $0% $0'#: =#+ $" #=$,*% '$&%34]R /0% C,*'$? "4 $0% 4"*; C"'#$& ,& G%?"#+ -"#-%C$&< =#+ '# &" +"'#: '#M"3M%& ,& '# = *%3=$'"# $" '#$,'$'"# +'*%-$3?< G,$ #"$ '# $0% 4"*; "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'"4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R U'$0 $0% %(=;C3% "4 *%3=$'M% &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%1 #%&& O% +" #"$ *%4%* $" =#? C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 $0% 4"*; "4 $0% "GS%-$< G,$ ;%*%3? $" $0% C"&&'G3% ,&% O0'-0 $0% &,GS%-$ -=# ;=N% "4 $0% "GS%-$ G? ;%=#& "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$R /0% +'44%*%#-% G%$O%%# $0%&% $O" 4"*;& "4 =%&$0%$'- *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '& $0=$ $0% S,+:;%#$ =G",$ &,G3';'$? \O",3+ #"$ *%J,'*% ,& $" C*%&,CC"&% = &C%-'=3 $%-0#'- "4 #=$,*%] _5NR @EZ@6.` =#+ \$,*#& $0% $0%"*? "4 $0% &,G3';% '#$" = ;%*% =CC%#+'( $" ",* =%&$0%$'- S,+:'#: "4 $0% C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6Z@FD`R /0'& &,::%&$& $0=$ $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% '& '#-3,+%+ O'$0'# $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$ ;%*%3? 4"* $0% &=N% "4 '#+'-=$'#: = 4%O ;'#"* =++'$'"#& $" $0% =--",#$ "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 #=$,*% =#+ $0=$ $0% =--",#$ "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 '& =*-0'1 $%-$"#'-=33? ;,-0 ;"*% &':#'4'-=#$R 7%&C'$% $0'&< ;,-0 *%-%#$ +'&-,&1 &'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 0=& 4"-,&%+ "# $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% =$ $0% %(C%#&% "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a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`< $0% C"O%* "4 ';=:'#=$'"# -"#&'+%*%+ =& 0=*;"#1 '&'#: O'$0 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: "* *%=&"# =#+< 3'N% $0% S,+:;%#$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ HK

-"#-%*#'#: $0% G%=,$'4,3< $0% S,+:;%#$ -"#-%*#'#: $0% &,G3';% '& = &'#:,3=* S,+:;%#$R T=M'#: G*",:0$ ",$ $0%&% ';C"*$=#$ -"##%-$'"#&< O0'-0 ;=N% %M'+1 %#$ &";% -"#$'#,'$?< V=#$ G%:'#& $0% $=&N "4 +'&$'#:,'&0'#: $0% '#$*'#&'&,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& ;=#'4%&$%+ '# $0% G%=,$'4,3 4*"; $0% *%3=$'M% &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& ;=#'4%&$%+ '# $0% &,G3';% 4%%3'#: _$0",:0 '$ &0",3+ G% =++%+ $0=$ $0% 4"*;,3=$'"# "4 =# )+%=3 "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 4"*;& 0%*% = G*'+:% =& '$ '& =3&" = *%3=$'M% &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&&`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`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a%=,$'4,3`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`R a,$ '4 =# "GS%-$ 3%=+& ,& $" =

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

IE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

4%%3'#: "4 $0% &,G3';%< $0%# '$ -=# =CC%=* '# '$& 4"*; #"$ C,*C"&'M% G,$ *=$0%* $0% *%M%*&%< \-"#$*=1C,*C"&'M%] =#+ $0,& \'#-";;%#&,*=$%] O'$0 ",* C"O%* "4 %(0'G'$'"#R V=#$ &$=$%& $0=$ &,G3';'$? -=##"$ G% &='+ $" G% = C*"C%*$? "4 =#? "GS%-$ "4 #=$,*% =& \0"O -=# O% -=33 &";%$0'#: G? = $%*; "4 =CC*"M=3 '4 O% =CC*%0%#+ '$ =& '# '$&%34 -"#$*=C,*C"&'M%]X _5NR 6Z@F6`R 5# =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 +"%& #"$ $%33 ,& =#?$0'#: =G",$ $0% "GS%-$ +%$%*;'#=1 $'M%3? =& $0'& =CC*%0%#&'"# +"%& #"$ G%3"#: $" $0% "*+%* "4 -":#'$'"#< G,$ '$ #"#% $0% 3%&& %(C=#+& ",* -"#-%C$ "4 #=$,*% =#+ 3%=+& ,& $" =CC*%-'=$% $0=$ #=$,*% '& #"$ ;%*%3? = ;%-0=#'&; G,$ =3&" =*$< =#+ '# 3%=+'#: ,& $" $0'& C%*-%C$'"# 4"*-%& ,& $" J,%&$'"# $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: #=$,*% $0'& O=?R a,$ O'$0 $0% &,G3';% $0%*% '& \=# ,$$%* 3=-N "4 =#?$0'#: 3%=+'#: $" C=*$'-,3=* "GS%-$'M% C*'#-'C3%&]< O0'-0 '& O0? $0% &,G3';% '& #"$ =& ';C"*$=#$ =& $0% G%=,$'4,3 '# *%3=$'"# $" -":#'$'"# "4 #=$,*%R T"O%M%*< V=#$ #%($ ;%#$'"#& $0=$ O0'3&$ $0% 4%%3'#: "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 3%=+& $0% ;'#+ $" = *%&$4,3 -"#$%;C3=$'"#< $0% 4%%3'#: "4 $0% &,G3';% C*"+,-%& = ;%#$=3 =:'$=$'"#R /0'& =:'$=$'"# ;':0$ G% $0",:0$ _C=*$'-,1 3=*3? :'M%# '$& &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&&` $" $%33 ,& ;"*% =G",$ $0% #=$,*% "4 0,;=#'$? =#+ '$& M"-=$'"# $0=# O% O",3+ G% =G3% $" =&-%*$='# '4 *%43%-$'M% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$& O%*% =33 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R /0% =:'$=$'"# C*"+,-%+ G? $0% &,G3';% *%3=$%& $0% ';=:'#=$'"#]& C*%1 &%#$=$'"#& $" %'$0%* $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: "* *%=&"#< =3$0",:0 =3O=?& _:'M%# $0=$ $0% 4%%3'#: "4 $0% &,G3';% '& = 4%%3'#: =G",$ '+%=&` $0*",:0 = 0'#/,2 *%3=$'"# $" $0% C"O%* "4 *%=&"#R /0% '#$%*#=3 +'M'&'"# "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% '& G=&%+ "# O"*N'#: $0*",:0 $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% $O" $?C%& "4 &,G3';% 4%%3'#:Z $0=$ O0'-0< '# '$& +'*%-$ -"#-%*# O'$0 J,=#$'$?< ,$'3'&%& '+%=& "4 *%=&"# $" *%4"*;,3=$% = $*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 =%&$0%$'- "4 = #%O $?C% _;=$0%;=$'-=33? &,G3';%` =#+ $0=$ O0'-0< $0*",:0 = +'*%-$ *%3=$'"# "4 ';=:'#=$'"# $" *%=&"# =3"#%< C*"1 +,-%& = +?#=;'-=3 =:'$=$'"#R a%4"*% +'&-,&&'#: $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 &,G3';% 4%%3'#: '$ '& O"*$0 C=,&'#: $" %(=;'#% =#+ %(C3='# 4,*$0%* $0% =*-0'$%-$"#'- G=&'& "4 $0'& +'M'&'"# "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';%R V=#$ %(C3'-'$3? &$=$%& $0=$ $0% 4",* ;";%#$& "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3 =*% *%C*'&%+ 0%*% =#+ $0=$ $0% -"#-3,1 &'"#& "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% =& -"#-%*#'#: *%43%-$'M% =%&$0%$'S,+:;%#$& =*% =$ "#% O'$0 $0% -"#-3,&'"#& "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'1 4,3R a,$ $0'& 4,*$0%* +'M'&'"# '# $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% :*",C& $":%$0%* '# %=-0 -=&% $O" "4 $0%&% ;";%#$&Z ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 ;=$0%;=$'-=33? &,G3';% O% %#-",#$%* $0% -=$%:"*'%& "4 J,=#$'$? =#+ J,=3'$? =#+ ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 $0% +?#=;'-=33? &,G3';% $0% -=$%1 :"*'%& "4 *%3=$'"# =#+ ;"+=3'$?R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ I.

/0% ,&% "4 $0% $%*;& \;=$0%;=$'-=3] =#+ \+?#=;'-=3] '& #"$ %(C3='#%+ G? V=#$ =#+ 0% +"%& #"$ :'M% = S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 '$R /0%*% '& "#% :'M%#< 0"O%M%*< '# $0% $%($ "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%R )# $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% $=G3% "4 -=$%:"*'%& V=#$ C3=-%& $0% :*",C& 0%=+%+ \"4 J,=#$'$?] =#+ \"4 J,=3'$?] ,#+%* $0% $'$3% "4 \;=$0%;=$'-=3] =#+ $0"&% G%3"#:'#: $" $0% 0%=+'#:& \"4 *%3=$'"#] =#+ \"4 ;"+=3'$?] ,#+%* $0% $'$3% \+?#=;'-=3] _a..E`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fa.KK^@EE`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

8 =*,7*5$.@* '1"#&5*#4*#$"7 8*&$-*$.5 +, E;M7.2.$( )# $0% &%-"#+ %+'$'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% V=#$ =++%+ = #"$% $" 0'& =--",#$ "4 $0% =('";& "4 '#$,'$'"#R T% O*'$%&Z 533 -";G'#=$'"# _,"%J?%,2'"` '& %'$0%* -";C"&'$'"# _,"18"3'2'"` "* -"##%-$'"# _%/
10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

I@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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a@E.^@`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`R )$ '& $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 $0'& *%4%*%#-% $" = -"#&$*,-$'"# $0=$ ;=N%& $0% %($%#&'M% ;=:#'$,+%& ;%*% =::*%:=$%&R a? -"#$*=&$< $0% '#$%#&'M% ;=:#'$,+%& -"#-%*# C0%#";%#= "4 '#$,'$'"# G? *%4%*%#-% $" J,=3'$? "4 &%#&=$'"# =#+ =*% G*",:0$ =G",$ G? = -"=3'$'"# G%$O%%# $0% &%#&=$'"# =#+ '$& +%$%*;'#=$'"# G? = *%43%-1 $'"# "# '$& +%:*%% O0'-0 +"%& #"$ *%J,'*% \= &,--%&&'M% &?#$0%&'& C*"-%%+'#: 4*"; C=*$& $" $0% O0"3% *%C*%&%#$=$'"#] _5.DHfa@EK`< O0'-0 '$ O",3+ '4 '$ O%*% =# %($%#&'M% ;=:#'$,+%R )# $0% -=&% "4 =# '#$%#&'M% ;=:#'$,+% =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 &%#&=$'"# \"--,C'%& "#3? =# '#&$=#$] =#+ +"%& #"$ $=N% '#$" =--",#$ $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 =::*%:=$'"# "4 $0% %3%;%#$& G? -";G'#=$'"#R /0% '#$%#&'M% ;=:#'$,+% -"#-%*#& "#3? J,=3'$? =#+ 0=& #" %3%;%#$ "4 =++'$'"# _G,$ *%4%*& "#3? $" -"#+'1 $'"#& "4 '#$,'$'"# O0'-0 '& O0=$ '& ;%=#$ G? +%&-*'G'#: '$ =& = ;=$0%1 ;=$'-=3 &?#$0%&'&`R /0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% ;=$0%;=$'-=33? &,G3';% ;,&$< $0%*%4"*%< C*%&%#$ &?#$0%&%& "4 =::*%:=$'"# =#+ -"=3'$'"#R a%4"*% &%$$'#: ",$ $0%&% +'&$'#-$ ;=$0%;=$'-=3 &?#$0%&%& "4 $0% &,G3';% V=#$ 4'*&$ %(C3'-=$%& $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ IA

$%*; \&,G3';%]R /0'& '& +"#% '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 ;=$0%;=$'-=3 &?#$0%&'& O0%# 0% $%33& ,& $0=$ O% -=33 &,G3';% $0=$ O0'-0 '& =G&"3,$%3? _3,9(/,929'%` 3=*:%R /" +%&-*'G% &";%$0'#: $0'& O=? '& $" &$=$% $0=$ '$ '& 3=*:% G%?"#+ =33 -";C=*'&"#R a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k% iK#"WZ/j "4 $0% C%"C3% O% N#"O< "4 =#';=3& "4 = -%*$='# N'#+< "4 $*%%&< 0",&%&< ;",#$='#&< =#+ &" "#R b#% $0=$ '& :'M%# * 8#'"#' O",3+ G% -"#4'#%+< G%-=,&% "4 $0% +%4'-'%#-'%& "4 $0% S,+:'#: &,GS%-$< $" &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"#& "4 =# %(0'G'$'"# '% ,"%,#/2"Y =# %(=;C3% 4*"; $0% C*=-$'-=3 &C0%*% '& $0% ;=:#'$,+% i"* +%:*%%j "4 = -%*$='# M'*$,%< "* "4 $0% -'M'3 3'G%*$? =#+ S,&$'-% '# = -",#$*?Y 4*"; $0% $0%"*%$'-=3 &C0%*%< $0% ;=:#'$,+% i"* +%:*%%j "4 $0% -"**%-$#%&& "* '#-"**%-$#%&& "4 &";% "G&%*M=$'"# "* ;%=&,*%;%#$ $0=$ 0=& G%%# ;=+%< =#+ &" "#R _5NR 6Z@FK` )# G"$0 '#&$=#-%&< O% 0=M% = &,GS%-$'M% &$=#+=*+ O0'-0 '& #"$ G=&%+ "# +%$%*;'#=$% *,3%&R U0%# O% &,GS%-$'M%3? &=? $0=$ &";%$0'#: '& 3=*:% \O% -=# =3O=?& -"##%-$ O'$0 $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# = N'#+ "4 *%&C%-$< =& O% -"#1 #%-$ = N'#+ "4 -"#$%;C$ O'$0 O0=$ O% &';C3? -=33 &;=33] _5NR 6Z@FK`R 5#?$0'#: -=# G% +%$%*;'#%+ G? ,& =& 3=*:% "* &;=33 _5('";& "4 )#$,'1 $'"#`R a,$ $" -=33 &";%$0'#: =G&"3,$%3? 3=*:% ;%=#& \O% +" #"$ C%*;'$ = &$=#+=*+ =+%J,=$% $" '$ $" G% &",:0$ ",$&'+% '$< G,$ "#3? O'$0'# '$] _5NR 6Z@6E`R b*< '$ '& = ;=:#'$,+% \%J,=3 "#3? $" '$&%34]R /0'& ;%=#& $0=$ $0% &,G3';% '& #"$ =M='3=G3% '# #=$,*% =$ =33 =& #" &,-0 ;=:#'$,+% -=# G% 4",#+ $0%*% =#+ '$ ;,&$ G% &",:0$ "#3? '# ",* '+%=&R >" O0%# O% _;=$0%;=$'-=33?` +%&-*'G% &";%$0'#: =& &,G3';%Z R R R ",* ';=:'#=$'"# &$*'M%& $" C*":*%&& $"O=*+& '#4'#'$?< O0'3% ",* *%=&"# +%;=#+& =G&"3,$% $"$=3'$? =& = *%=3 '+%=< =#+ &" i$0% ';=:'#1 =$'"#<j ",* C"O%* "4 %&$';=$'#: $0% ;=:#'$,+% "4 '+%=& '# $0% O"*3+ "4 &%#&%< '& '#=+%J,=$% $" $0=$ '+%=R h%$ $0'& '#=+%J,=-? '$&%34 '& $0% =*",&=3 '# ,& "4 $0% 4%%3'#: $0=$ O% 0=M% O'$0'# ,& = &,C%*&%#&'G3% C"O%*Y =#+ O0=$ '& =G&"3,$%3? 3=*:% '& #"$ =# "GS%-$ "4 &%#&%< G,$ '& $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

IF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ I6

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` '& = C,*%3? =%&$0%$'- ;%=&,*%;%#$R a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`] _5NR 6Z@6.`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

,&% $0=$ S,+:;%#$ #=$,*=33? ;=N%& "4 -%*$='# "GS%-$& &" =& $" i=*",&%j $0'& _4%%3'#:`< =#+ '# -"#$*=&$ O'$0 $0=$ ,&% =#? "$0%* '& &;=33R _5NR 6Z@6E`

C%*4"*; $O" =-$&Z $0% =-$ "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# =#+ $0% =-$ "4 -";C*%0%#1 &'"#R /0% $%*; -";C*%0%#&'"# _[?3*11/%@*33?%)`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`R /0'& 3%=+& $" $0% &,G3';% 4%%3'#: G%'#: %(C%*'%#-%+ =& $0% &%-"#+ &?#$0%&'& G%-";%& ';C"&&'G3% '# $0% &%#&% "4 4,34'33'#: $0% *%J,'*%;%#$ $0=$ $0% O0"3% G% C*%&%#$%+ '# '#$,'$'"#R /0% "GS%-$ G%4"*% ,& *%4,&%& $0% ,#'$=*? +%;=#+ "4 $0% ;'#+ G? ",$&$*'CC'#: $0% -=C=-'$'%& "4 C*%&%#$=1 $'"# "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#R /0% C%-,3'=*'$? '& $0=$ =& $0% ;'#+ %(C%*'%#-%& '$& '#-=C=-'$? $" ;%%$ '$& "O# +%;=#+ _= +%;=#+ O0'-0 %;%*:%& 4*"; $0% G=&'- -"#+'$'"# "4 ;%=&,*%;%#$< '#$,'$'"#` '$ *%=-$& O'$0 +%3':0$R a,$ O0'3&$ $0'& :'M%& ,& $0% G=&'- #"$'"# "4 $0% &,G3';% _O'$0",$ =& ?%$ %(C3'-=$'#: $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 ",* +%3':0$` '$ '& 4,*$0%* *%J,'&'$% $" +%$%*1 ;'#% O0%# O% -=# &$=$% $0=$ O% 0=M% = C,*% =%&$0%$'- *%43%-$'M% S,+:1 ;%#$ "4 &,G3';'$? O0'-0 '& #"$ ;'(%+ %'$0%* O'$0 &%#&=$'"#=3 "* '#$%33%-$,=3 '#$%*%&$&R /0'& V=#$ &%$& ",$ #%:=$'M%3? G? %3';'#=$'#: *%4%*%#-% $" =#?$0'#: O0'-0 '#M"3M%& = $%3%"3":'-=3 _=#+ 0%#-% -":#'$'M%` S,+:;%#$ O0'-0 ;%=#& *,3'#: ",$ =& '#=+;'&&'G3% 4"* $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C,*C"&%& $0% #"$'"# $0=$ $0%*% '& =#?$0'#: &,G3';% '# =*$ _=& $0% 3=$$%* *%&$& "# $0% -"#-%C$& "4 0,;=# C,*C"&'M%#%&&` =#+ =3&" =#? *%4%*%#-% $" #=$,*=3 $0'#:& O0'-0 0=M% +%$%*;'#=$% C,*C"&% _S,&$ =& O'$0 $0% C,*% -"#-%C$ "4 $=&$% O% 0=+ $" *,3% ",$ =& C"&&'G3% "GS%-$& "4 &$=$%;%#$& =G",$ $0% G%=,$'4,3 =#';=3& O'$0 = ,&%`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ID C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ IH

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m,=#$'$? "4 >,G3';'$? '& %(C",#+%+ =& *%J,'*'#: *%4%*%#-% $" =# '+%= "4 *%=&"# _$"$=3'$?` O0'-0 :"M%*#& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 ;%=&,*%;%#$ G? '$& *%4%*%#-% $" = G=&'- ;%=&,*%R /0% P";%#$ "4 m,=3'$? "4 >,G3';'$? '#M"3M%& ,& '# = 4%%3'#: $0=$ '$ '& G%?"#+ ",* C"O%* $" =$$='# $" =# '+%= \29*2 '3 * (*. @"# ?3X O0'-0 '#=G'3'$? C*"+,-%& '# ,& = &%#$';%#$ "4 *%&C%-$R )# $0% %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% 4'*&$ P";%#$ "4 >,G3';'$? O% *%;='#%+ -"#&$=#$3? '# *%4%*%#-% $" -"#+'$'"#& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ $0% ;"M% G%?"#+ $0%; O=& +%;"#&$*=$%+ =& ';;=#%#$ O'$0'# $0%;R a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`R U% 0=M% =3*%=+? %#-",#$%*%+ $0% #"$'"# "4 ",* M"-=$'"# '# $0% '+%=3 "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3R a,$ O0%*%=& $0% '+%=3 "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 O=& *%&$4,3 '# '$& &%#&'G3% %;G"+';%#$ "4 ",* M"-=$'"#< O'$0 $0% &,G3';% O% +'&-"M%* = -"#$%;C3=$'"# O0'-0 +"%& #"$ *%&$ $0% ;'#+ G,$ *=$0%* &%#+& '$ '#$" = &$=$% "4 =:'$=$'"#R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

)4 $0% 0,;=# ;'#+ '& #"#%$0%3%&& $" 7/ *7(/ /G/% 2" 29'%- $0% :'M%# '#4'#'$% O'$0",$ -"#$*=+'-$'"#< '$ ;,&$ 0=M% O'$0'# '$&%34 = C"O%* $0=$ '& &,C%*&%#&'G3%< O0"&% '+%= "4 = #",;%#"# -=##"$ G% '#$,'$%+ G,$ -=# ?%$ G% *%:=*+%+ =& $0% &,G&$*=$% ,#+%*3?'#: O0=$ '& ;%*% =CC%=*1 =#-%< #=;%3?< ",* '#$,'$'"# "4 $0% O"*3+R _5NR 6Z@6F^6`

/0'& =:'$=$'"# _=G"M% =33 =$ '$& '#-%C$'"#` -=# G% -";C=*%+ O'$0 = M'G*=$'"#< 'R%R< O'$0 = *=C'+ =3$%*#=$'"# "4 *%C,3&'"# 4*";< =#+ =$$*=-1 $'"# $"< "#% =#+ $0% &=;% "GS%-$R )4 = i$0'#:j '& %(-%&&'M% 4"* $0% ';=:'#=$'"# _=#+ $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '& +*'M%# $" i&,-0 %(-%&&j =& '$ =CC*%0%#+& i$0% $0'#:j '# '#$,'$'"#`< $0%# i$0% $0'#:j '&< =& '$ O%*%< =# =G?&& '# O0'-0 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '& =4*='+ $" 3"&% '$&%34R h%$< =$ $0% &=;% $';%< 4"* *%=&"#]& '+%= "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% i$0'& &=;% $0'#:j '& #"$ %(-%&&'M% G,$ -"#4"*;& $" *%=&"#]& 3=O $" :'M% *'&% $" &,-0 &$*'M'#: G? $0% ';=:'#=$'"#R T%#-% i$0% $0'#:j '& #"O =$$*=-$'M% $" $0% &=;% +%:*%% $" O0'-0 i4"*;%*3?j '$ O=& *%C,3&'M% $" ;%*% &%#&'G'3'$?R _5NR 6Z@6I`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`R )# = J,=3'$=$'M% &?#$0%&'& "4 ;=$0%;=$'-=3 &,G3';'$? O% +" \M'"3%#-% $" $0% '##%* &%#&%] =#+ %&-=C% $0% -"#+'$'"# &%$ ",$ '# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#1 $=3 5%&$0%$'-< $0% -"#+'$'"# $0=$ =33 '#$,'$'"#& "4 =CC%=*=#-% 0=M% $" $=N% C3=-% '# $';% _O0'-0 '& $0% &%-*%$ "4 =#? '#$%#&'M% J,=#$'$?`R /0'& '& O0? V=#$ +%&-*'G%& $0% &,G3';% =& = C*%&%#$=$'"# O0'-0 '& &,GS%-$'M%3? -"#1 $*=1C,*C"&'M% =& '$ %&-=C%& $0% -";G'#=$'"# O0'-0 :,'+%& =33 "$0%* &?#$0%&'& "4 $0% ;'#+R BM%# &"Z \$0'& &=;% M'"3%#-% $0=$ $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '#43'-$& "# $0% &,GS%-$ '& &$'33 S,+:%+ C,*C"&'M% @"# 29/ .9"(/ G",*2'"% "4 $0% ;'#+] _5NR 6Z@6K`R T"O -=# $0'& G%X 5#&O%*'#: $0'& J,%&$'"# O'33 %#=G3% ,& $" ,#+%*1 &$=#+ 0"O $0%*% -=# G% C3%=&,*% '# $0% &,G3';% 4%%3'#:R )$ '& =# ';;%+'1 =$% &%#&=$'"# "4 +'&C3%=&,*% =& '$ *%M%=3& $" $0% ;'#+ =# '#-=C=-'$?R h%$ $0'& '#-=C=-'$? *%M%=3& $" $0% ;'#+ $0% M"-=$'"# O0'-0 '$ 0=&R /0'& '& +,% $" $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0% 4='3,*% "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# $" C*%&%#$ $0% -"#+'$'"#&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

II C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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` $0% C,*C"&% "4 #=$,*%R )# = +?#=;'-=33? &,G3';% S,+:;%#$ O% -"#&'+%* $0% ;':0$ "4 #=$,*% =& 3%&&%* '# 4"*-% $0=# $0% ;':0$ "4 $0% ;'#+R 5& V=#$ O*'$%&Z

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ IK

2"* =3$0",:0 O% 4",#+ ",* "O# 3';'$=$'"# O0%# O% -"#&'+%*%+ $0% ';;%#&'$? "4 #=$,*% =#+ $0% '#=+%J,=-? "4 ",* =G'3'$? $" =+"C$ = &$=#+=*+ C*"C"*$'"#=$% $" %&$';=$'#: =%&$0%$'-=33? $0% ;=:#'$,+% "4 #=$,*%]& 0"1*'%< ?%$ O% =3&" 4",#+< '# ",* C"O%* "4 *%=&"#< = +'44%*%#$ =#+ #"#&%#&'G3% &$=#+=*+ $0=$ 0=& $0'& '#4'#'$? '$&%34 ,#+%* '$ =& = ,#'$Y =#+ &'#-% '# -"#$*=&$ $" $0'& &$=#+=*+ %M%*?$0'#: '# #=$,*% '& &;=33< O% 4",#+ '# ",* ;'#+ = &,C%*'"*'$? "M%* #=$,*% '$&%34 '# '$& ';;%#&'$?R _5NR 6Z@D.` U0%# O% -"#&'+%* #=$,*% =& = C"O%* _'# $0% -=&% "4 "M%*0=#:'#: *"-N& "* &$"*;& =$ &%=`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a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a%=,$'4,3 =-0'%M%+ +'*%-$3? $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% =-0'%M%& "#3? '#+'*%-$3?R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

KE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

)# $0% 2",*$0 P";%#$ "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3 O% O%*% $*%=$%+ $" =# %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0% #"$'"# "4 = #%-%&&'$? =$$=-0'#: $" $0% S,+:;%#$& =G",$ $0% G%=,$'4,3R a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` 5 S,+:;%#$ =G",$ $0% &,G3';% *%J,'*%& -,3$,*%R 5& $0% 4%%3'#: "4 $0% &,G3';% '& =# '#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#: '$ *%J,'*%& "4 ,& $0=$ O% *%3=$% $" ",*&%3M%& =& G%'#:& O0" =*% ;"*% $0=# +=$= "4 &%#&% =#+ O0" =*% '# 4=-$ $0*",:0 $0% C"O%* "4 '+%=& -=C=G3% "4 -";C3%$%3? $*=#&-%#+'#: &%#&%R /0% +?#=;'-=3 &?#$0%&%& "4 &,G3';'$? $0,& -"#-%*# $0% *%3=$'"# "4 &,G3';'$? $" $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& =#+ $0% ;"+=3'$? "4 #%-%&1 &'$? O0'-0 -"##%-$& $0% &,G3';% $" $0% ;"*=3 3=OR a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a,$ 4"* $0% &,G3';% =$$'$,+% $"O=*+& ;"*=3'$? $" 4,*$0%* ",* =CC*%0%#1 &'"# "4 $0% 3=$$%* '$ ;,&$< +%&C'$% $0% =:'$=$'"# -"##%-$%+ O'$0 '$&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ K.

K@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

T%#-% $0% &,G3';% ;,&$ =3O=?& 0=M% *%4%*%#-% $" ",* .*: "@ 29'%-'%)< 'R%R< $" ;=(';& +'*%-$%+ $" C*"M'+'#: $0% '#$%33%-$,=3 i&'+% '# ,&j =#+ ",* *=$'"#=3 '+%=& O'$0 &,C*%;=-? "M%* &%#&'G'3'$?R _5NR 6Z@HF` )# &,-0 =# '#&$=#-% $0% &,G3';% 4%%3'#: *%M%=3& '$&%34 '# '$& ;"&$ %($*%;% =#+ $*,% 3':0$ =& '$ =G=#+"#& -"#+'$'"#& "4 &%#&% %#$'*%3? _&";%$0'#: = S,+:;%#$ =G",$ $0% G%=,$'4,3 -=##"$ +"`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` )# $0'& =G=#+"#;%#$ "4 $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 &%#&'G'3'$?< 0"O%M%*< $0% &,G3';% 4%%3'#: =3&" $*=#&-%#+& $0% -"#+'$'"# "4 O0=$ '& =3O=?& =$ '&&,% 4"* $=&$% =#+ '# &" +"'#: *%M%=3& 0"O $0%*% -=# G% =# =%&$0%$'- "*'%#$=1 $'"# $" $0% O"*3+ O0'-0 +"%& #"$ *%&$ ,C"# *%C*%&%#$=$'"#&R /0'& *%;"M=3 "4 -"#+'$'"#& "4 &%#&'G'3'$? 4*"; $0% &,G3';% =O=N%#& $0% ;'#+ $" = -"#&-'",&#%&& "4 '$& "O# 4*%%+"; _C,*% =,$"#";? =& %;%*:1 '#: 4*"; C,*% &,GS%-$'M'$?`R /0,& '$ -";%& =& #" &,*C*'&% $" 4'#+ $0=$< =--"*+'#: $" V=#$< &';C3'-'$? '& \#=$,*%]& &$?3% '# $0% &,G3';%] =& $0'& '& =3&" $0% &$?3% "4 ;"*=3'$? O0'-0 '& \= &%-"#+ _#=;%3?< = &,C%*&%#&'G3%` #=$,*%< "4 O0'-0 O% N#"O "#3? $0% 3=O&] _5NR 6Z@H6` O'$0",$ G%'#: =G3% $" -";C*%0%#+ ",* "O# &,C%*1 &%#&'G3% =G'3'$? $" 4"*;,3=$% $0%&% 3=O&R U0=$ $0% *%;=*N& =++%+ $" $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% '# $0'& \e%#%*=3 !";;%#$] $%#+ $" *%'#4"*-% '& $0% -3"&%#%&& "4 $0% &,G3';% 4%%3'#: $" $0% ;"*=3 4%%3'#: O0%# O% ;':0$ 0=M% %(C%-$%+ ;"*% -=*% $" +%;=*-=$% $0%&% $O" 4%%3'#:& 4*";

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=CC%=*=#-% '# $0% ;'#+< \3%=M% ,& O'$0 = ;%#$=3 =$$,#%;%#$] $0=$ '#+'*%-$3? '#43,%#-%& ",* &%#&% "4 4"*$'$,+% =#+ *%&"3,$'"# =#+ +'*%-$ ,& $"O=*+& $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% '4 '$ '& = $*,3? &,G3';% *%3=$'"# $" ;"*=3'$? _=#+ #"$ ;%*%3? =# \%#$0,&'=&;] $0=$ '# '$& 0%=$ C=&&%& '$&%34 "44 =& &,G3';% G,$ '& ;%*%3? :"M%*#%+ G? =44%-$& =#+ 0%#-% '& =3'%# $" *%43%-1 $'"#`R

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a%=,$'4,3 $0*",:0 *%M%3=$'"# "4 O0=$ 3'%& G%0'#+ $0% -"#-%C$& "4 C,*% ,#+%*&$=#+1 '#: _O0'-0 3=$$%* ;=N% %(C%*'%#-% C"&&'G3% =$ =33`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`R /0%&% 4=-$& =G",$ $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% $0*%=$%# $" ,#+%*-,$ '$& -"#$*'G,$'"# $" $0% +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 =#+ *%3%:=$% '$ $" =# =CC%#+'( "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"%R a,$ $O" ;=$$%*& #%%+ $" G% &$*%&&%+ 0%*%Z 4'*&$< $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 &,G3';% 4%%3'#: '& 3":'-=33? +%C%#+%#$ "# $0% %('&$%#-% "4 )+%=& "4 *%=&"# =#+< &%-"#+< $0% +%:*%%& "4 &,G3';% 4%%3'#: #%%+ $" G% +'&$'#:,'&0%+R /0% 4'*&$ C"'#$ '&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ KA

O0=$ *%M%=3& $0% G=&'& "4 = -"#$'#,",& ;"M% $"O=*+& = C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 = ;"*=3'$? "4 *%43%-$'"# G%-=,&% =& =# %3%;%#$ "4 '#$%33%-$,=3 4%%3'#: '$ +"%& &';C3? +*=O ,C"# $0% -"#-%C$ "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# =& '$ '& "#3? C"&&'G3% G%-=,&% "4 $0'& -"#-%C$R a,$< S,&$ =& $0%*% '& = +=#:%* "4 C*"+,1 -'#: = ;"*=3'$? "4 *%43%-$'"#< &" =3&" $0% ;"*=3 3=O -=# G% C*%&%#$%+ =& =# "GS%-$ "4 ",* *%M%*%#-% '# C,*%3? =%&$0%$'- $%*;&R /0% &%-"#+ C"'#$ '& O0=$ #%%+& $" G% &$*%&&%+ $" ,#+%*&$=#+ $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# &,G3';% 4%%3'#: =#+ $0% ;"*=3 3=OR 9,&$ =& &,G3';% 4%%3'#: -=# G% C*"+,-%+ G? =#? C*%&%#$=$'"# O0'-0 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '& '#-=C=G3% "4 3';'$'#:< &" =3&" $0% ';C*%&&'"# "4 =#? C"O%* O0'-0 O% =*% -=C=G3% "4 &,C%*&%+'#: 3%=+& ,& $" = *%43%-$'"# ,C"# $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$% "4 ",* ;'#+&R )$ '& $0% "*'%#$=$'"# $"O=*+& $0'& &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$% =& *%M%=3'#: $0% #"G'3'$? "4 ",* ;'#+ O0'-0 '& $0% G=&'& "4 =#? &,G3';% 4%%3'#:< G,$ O0'3&$ $0'& '#M"3M%& ,& =3O=?& '# *%3=$'#: $" =# =G&"3,$% $0%*% =*% +'44%*%#$ N'#+& "4 =G&"3,$% _=G&"3,$% ;=:#'$,+%< =G&"1 3,$% ;':0$< =G&"3,$% &%341*%&C%-$` O0'-0 =&-%#+ '# $0% ;"M%;%#$ $"O=*+& = *%=3'k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a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dIA "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

KF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

a%-=,&% "4 $0% '#$';=$% -"##%-$'"# "4 &,G3';% S,+:;%#$& O'$0 -,31 $,*=3 4"*;=$'"# $0%*% '& =# ';;%+'=$% $%#+%#-? $" &,::%&$ $0=$ $0% +'44%*%#-% G%$O%%# &,G3';% S,+:;%#$& =#+ =%&$0%$'- *%43%-$'M% S,+:1 ;%#$& =G",$ $0% G%=,$'4,3 '& $0=$ "#3? $0% 3=$$%* =*% C,*%3? =%&$0%$'_O'$0 $0% %(-%C$'"# "4 S,+:;%#$& =G",$ $0% '+%=3 "4 G%=,$?`R a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`< O0%*%=& $0% G%=,$'4,3 3%=M%& ,& O'$0 = 4%%3'#: "4 C3=? =#+ C,*% C3%=&,*% ,#=+,3$%*=$%+ O'$0 C='#R /0'& +'&$'#-$'"# C"'#$& $" $0% 4=-$ $0=$ 4"* =# =%&$0%$'- $" G% 3=O4,3 '$ ;,&$ G% 3';'$%+ G? &";%$0'#: 4"* O0'-0 ';=:'#=$'"# -=##"$ &,CC3? $0% -"#+'$'"#&R /0%*% '&< $0%*%4"*%< G"$0 =# =%&$0%$'- =#+ = 3":'-=3 :*",#+ $" $0% ;"*=3 3=O _O0'-0 O=& $0% C"'#$ "4 $0% B#'/7@/0/#`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a%=,$'4,3 O0%*% $0% 2",*$0 P";%#$ ;%*%3? C*";'&%+ ,& =# =--",#$ "4 $0% ,#'M%*&=3'$? "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% G,$ +'+ #"$ C*"M'+% '$R 2"* $0'& =--",#$ O% ;,&$ $,*# #"O $" $0% 7%+,-$'"# "4 8,*% 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ K6

/0% 7%+,-$'"# "4 8,*% 5%&$0%$'9,+:;%#$&< 2'#% 5*$ =#+ $0% 5#$'#";? "4 $0% !*'$'J,% "4 /=&

%$/0% 4'*&$ C*"G3%; $0=$ &$*'N%& "#% =G",$ $0% 7%+,-$'"# "4 8,*% 5%&$0%$'9,+:;%#$& '& +%$%*;'#'#: O0%*% '$ '& -";C3%$%+R )#+%%+< &";% *%-%#$ -";;%#$=$"*& 0=M% %M%# G%%# -"#4,&%+ =G",$ O0%*% '$ G%:'#&R 2"* O0'3&$ $0% 7%+,-$'"# '& #"$ ;%#$'"#%+ ,#$'3 dAE< 8=,3 e,?%* &,::%&$& $0=$ $0% 7%+,-$'"# '& 4'*&$ &$=$%+ '# $0% 2",*$0 P";%#$ "4 $0% 5#=3?$'"4 $0% a%=,$'4,3R. /0% G=&'& 4"* $0'& '& e,?%*]& M'%O $0=$ $0% C,*C"&% "4 $0% 7%+,-$'"# '& $" C*%&%#$ $0% -3=';& "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% $" ,#'M%*&=3'$?R a,$ O0'3&$ $0% 2",*$0 P";%#$ "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,1 $'4,3 +"%& &,::%&$ $0=$ ,#'M%*&=3'$? '& = -0=*=-$%*'&$'- "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% $0'& &,::%&$'"# '& C=*$ "4 $0% %(C"&'$'"# "4 &,-0 S,+:;%#$& =#+ +"%& #"$ '$&%34 -"#&$'$,$% = S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 $0% -3='; $0,& '#M"3M%+ '# &,-0 S,+:;%#$& _O0'-0 '& $0% C,*C"&% "4 = +%+,-$'"#`R m,'$% +'&$'#-$ 4*"; e,?%*]& &,::%&$'"# $0=$ $0% 7%+,-$'"# G%:'#& G%4"*% dAE "$0%* O*'$%*& C*%&%#$ '$ =& -"#$'#,'#: '#$" $0% 7'=3%-$'- "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:1 ;%#$R@ /0'& 3=$$%* &,::%&$'"# 0=& $0% =++%+ +'44'-,3$? $0=$ '$ 3%=+& #"$ "#3? $" $0% M'%O $0=$ $0%*% =*% =$ 3%=&$ $O" =&C%-$& $" $0% 7%+,-$'"# _'4 #"$ $O" 7%+,-$'"#&`< G,$ =3&" $0=$ '$ ;':0$ G% $0",:0$ $" &,::%&$ = +%C%#+%#-% "4 $0% C,*% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ ,C"# $0% ;"*=3 S,+:;%#$ _+%C%#+'#: "# 0"O d6K '& $" G% *%=+`< O0'-0 O",3+ "M%*$,*# $0% *%&,3$& "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3R /0% 4,*$0%* C*"G3%; O'$0 $0'& 3=$$%* $?C% "4 *%=+'#: '& $0=$ '$ 3%=M%& ,#%(C3='#%+ O0? $0%*% '& = 0'=$,& G%$O%%# $0% &%%;'#: -3"&% "4 $0% 4'*&$ C=*$ "4 $0% 7%+,-$'"# '# dAK =#+ $0% "C%#'#: "4 $0% 7'=3%-$'- '# d66 _O0'-0 0'=$,& '& 4'33%+ O'$0 $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 4'#% =*$ =#+ :%#',&`R U0'3&$ $0'& *%=+'#: +"%& =$ 3%=&$ =M"'+ $0% -"#4,&'"# "4 +%+,-$'"# =#+ %(C"&'1 $'"# -";;'$$%+ G? e,?%*< '$ +"%& "M%**'+% %&&%#$'=3 =*-0'$%-$"#'- +'M'1 &'"#& =#+ 3%=+& "#% $" e,?%*]& -"#-3,&'"#Z KD

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

6

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: KH

/0'& *=$0%* +*=&$'- -"#-3,&'"# -=# "#3? G% =M"'+%+ '4 O% &%$ ",$ =#%O $" +%;"#&$*=$% O0=$ '& :"'#: "# '# $0% 7%+,-$'"#< O0=$ $0% -"##%-$'"# '& G%$O%%# $0% 7%+,-$'"# =#+ $0% =--",#$ "4 4'#% =*$< =#+ 0"O $0% 7%+,-1 $'"# -"#$='#%+ '# $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$ *%3=$%& $" $0% 5#$'#";? "4 $0% !*'$'J,% "4 /=&$% 4",#+ '# $0% 7'=3%-$'- "4 5%&$0%$'9,+:;%#$R

'-* ?*4;5$.+# +, 6;1* 8*&$-*$.5 J;402*#$& T=M'#: +'&-=*+%+ e,?%*]& -3='; $0=$ $0% 7%+,-$'"# G%:'#& '# $0% 5#=1 3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3 O% -=# =+"C$ $0% &$*=':0$4"*O=*+ =&&,;C$'"# $0=$ '$ "C%#& =$ $0% C3=-% V=#$ 4'*&$ &%$& ",$ = #%%+ 4"* '$< #=;%3? '# dAER /0% 4'*&$ &%#$%#-% "4 $0'& &%-$'"# *%;'#+& ,& "4 $0% C,*C"&% "4 = +%+,-$'"#< $" &,CC3? = \3%:'$';=$'"#] "4 = -3='; "4 = S,+:;%#$ $" G% G=&%+ "# =# * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3%R W"O< '# $0% -=&% "4 &,G3';% S,+:;%#$& $0%'* -3='; $" =# * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3% O=& *%M%=3%+ '# $0% ;%*% %(C"&'$'"# "4 $0%;< =& $0%&% S,+:;%#$& +%;"#&$*=$% = C,*C"&'M% "*'%#$=$'"# "4 $0% ;'#+R a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`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`R 5& V=#$ C,$& '$ =$ $0% -3"&% "4 dA.Z

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!=*%3%&&#%&& -=# G% $0% "#3? %(C3=#=$'"# "4 $0% 3"-=$'"# "4 $0% +%+,-$'"# '# $0% =*-0'$%-$"#'- "4 $0% $0'*+ =#'2'>?/RA

KI C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

)$ '& M'$=3 $" *%;%;G%* $0% J,=3'4'-=$'"# 0%*% '#$*"+,-%+ O0'-0 *%1 %;C0=&'&%& $0% C"'#$ ;=+% '# dK "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a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`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`R )# %=-0 '#&$=#-% = -3=&&'-=3 ;"+%3 -=# "#3? G% =+"C$%+ '4 $0% &,GS%-$ -=# 4'#+ O'$0'# 0';&%34 $0% :*",#+& 4"* '$& &$=$,& O0'-0 :*",#+& O'33 3%=+ $" $0% +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 0'& $=&$%R /0%*% '& #" O=? "4 C*"M'#: $" &";%"#% $0=$ = :'M%# M'%O "* C"%; _"* 43"O%*` '& G%=,$'4,3< %'$0%* G? *%4%*%#-% $" %;C'*'-=3 "* * 8#'"#' C*""4&R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

)4 O% *%&"3M% $0%&% 3":'-=3 C%-,3'=*'$'%&< O0'-0 +'&$'#:,'&0 = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% 4*"; =33 -":#'$'M% S,+:;%#$&< O% &0=33 0=M% +"#% =33 $0=$ '& #%%+%+ '# "*+%* $" +%+,-% $0'& &$*=#:% =G'3'$? O% 0=M%< 8#"G'0/0 29*2 *2 29/ "?23/2 ./ *732#*,2 @#"1 *(( ,"%2/%2 "@ 29/ J?0)1/%2T 'V/VT @#"1 29/ @//('%) "@ 8(/*3?#/T *%0 1/#/(: ,"18*#/ 29/ */329/2', @"#1 .'29 29/ @"#1 "@ "7J/,2'G/ J?0)1/%23 *3 8#/3,#'7/0 7: (")',V _5NR 6Z@I.< ;? %;C0=&'&`

9,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =*% $0,& &,GS%-$'M% '# -0=*=-$%*< G,$ +" C"&&%&& $0% C%-,3'=*'$? "4 %($%#+'#: $0%'* -3=';< '#=&;,-0 =& $0%? =*% *%43%-$'M% *=$0%* $0=# &%#&=$'"#=3< $" =33 &,GS%-$& +%&C'$% C"&&%&&'#: #" -";C%33'#: +%;"#&$*=$'M% ;%=#& "4 4"*-'#: "$0%*& $" =+"C$ $0%;R /0% -*'$'-=3 *%M"1 3,$'"# '# =%&$0%$'-& -"#&'&$& '# -%=&'#: $" 3""N 4"* $0% :*",#+& "4 $0'& ,#'M%*&=3 =#+ #%-%&&=*? -3='; '# $0% "7J/,23 "4 $=&$% _$0% C=*$'-,3=* -"#1 $%#$ "4 $0% S,+:;%#$& -"#-%*#%+` =#+ '# $,*#'#: '#&$%=+ $" =# =#=3?&'& "4 \",* -":#'$'M% C"O%*&]Z T%#-% $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% '& '$&%34 "#3? &,GS%-$'M% =& *%:=*+& $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# G? O0'-0 =# "GS%-$ '& :'M%# ,&Z '$ '& $0% =*$< "* &-'%#-%< "4 4'#+'#: *,3%& 4"* $0% *%-'C*"-=3 *%3=$'"# $0=$ ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ ';=:'#=$'"# 0=M% '# $0% :'M%# C*%&%#$=$'"# _O'$0",$ *%4%*%#-% $" C*'"* &%#&=$'"# "* -"#-%C$`< =#+ 0%#-% 4"* $0%'* =--"*+=#-% "* +'&1 -"*+=#-% =#+ "4 +%$%*;'#'#: $0%; =& *%:=*+& $0%'* -"#+'$'"#&R /0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% '& =# *#2 '4 '$ &0"O& $0'& "#3? $0*",:0 %(=;C3%&Y '$ '& = 3,'/%,/ '4 '$ +%*'M%& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 &,-0 S,+:'#: 4*"; $0% #=$,*% "4 $0%&% C"O%*& =& -":#'$'M% C"O%*& =& &,-0R _5NR 6Z@ID` 5#"$0%* O=? "4 +%&-*'G'#: $0% &-'%#-% "4 $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% '& =& = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 =& "CC"&%+ $" ;%*%3? C&?-0"3":'-=3 $*%=$;%#$ "4 $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R /*%=$;%#$ "4 S,+:1 ;%#$& "4 $=&$% -=# $0%*%4"*% $=N% "#% "4 $0*%% 4"*;&Z '$ -=# =$$%;C$ =# "GS%-$'M% +%+,-$'"# "4 &,-0 S,+:;%#$& O0'-0 O'33 =&&';'3=$% $0%; $" -":#'$'M% S,+:;%#$& _*=$'"#=3'&;`Y '$ -=# =$$%;C$ = C&?-0"3":'-=3 "* C0?&'"3":'-=3 +%*'M=$'"# "4 $0%; O0'-0 O'33 =&&';'3=$% $0%; $" &%#&=1 $'"#=3 S,+:;%#$& _%;C'*'-'&;`Y "* '$ -=# &%$ ",$ =#+ S,&$'4? $0% -"#+'1 $'"#& "4 $0%; $*=#&-%#+%#$=33? O0'-0 O'33 *%&C%-$ $0% &C%-'4'-'$? "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'"#R b#3? $0'& 3=&$ 4"*; "4 C*%&%#$=$'"# O'33 %#&,*% $0=$ $0% C,*'$? "4 =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$& '& *%&C%-$%+R /0% *=$'"#=3'&$ $*%=$;%#$ 4='3& $" %(C3='# O0? C%"C3% -=##"$ G% -";1 C%33%+ G? *%=&"#& $" =+"C$ = C=*$'-,3=* S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%< $0% %;C'*'-'&$ $*%=$;%#$ 4='3& $" %(C3='# $0% -3='; "4 #"#1&%#&=$'"#=3 =%&$0%$'- S,+:1 ;%#$&< C*%4%**'#: $" +%#? $0=$ $0%*% =*% =#? &,-0 S,+:;%#$&R \/0% &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"#& "4 =33 S,+:;%#$& '& ",* M%*? =G'3'$? $" S,+:%< 'R%R< $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$] _5NR 6Z@IH`R )# = +%$%*;'#=$'M% S,+:;%#$ $0%*% '& S"'#%+ $":%$0%* $0% '#$,'$'M% -";G'#=$'"# "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ '# = C,*% 4"*; _&C=-% =#+ $';%` O'$0 = -";G'#=$'"# '# = -"#-%C$R >'#-% = S,+:1 ;%#$ "4 $=&$% -"#$='#& #" -"#-%C$ "4 =# "GS%-$< \'$ -=# -"#&'&$ "#3? '# $0% &,G&,;C$'"# "4 $0% M%*? ';=:'#=$'"# ,#+%* $0% -"#+'$'"# iO0'-0 ;,&$ G% ;%$j 4"* $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $" C*"-%%+ '# :%#%*=3 4*"; '#$,'$'"#

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: KK

$" -"#-%C$&] _5NR 6Z@IH`R /0'& -"#+'$'"# '& &-0%;=$'&;R T"O%M%*< $0% 4*%%+"; "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& $0=$ '$ &-0%;=$'&%& O'$0",$ = -"#-%C$ &" $0=$ = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% +"%& '#+%%+ *%&$ "# = &%#&=$'"# "4 = N'#+ G,$ #"$ "4 =# "GS%-$< *=$0%* \",* &%#&=$'"# "4 G"$0 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# '# '$& @#//0"1 =#+ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O'$0 '$& (*.@?(%/33< =& $0%? *%-'C*"-=33? J,'-N%# %=-0 "$0%*] _5NR 6Z@IH`R /0,&< $0%*% '& = C*'#-'C3% "4 &,G&,;C$'"# '# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% G,$ #"$ "4 '#$,'$'"#& ,#+%* -"#-%C$& _=& '& :'M%# '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%` G,$ *=$0%* "4 \$0% 8"./# "4 '#$,'$'"#& "* %(0'G'$'"#& _$0% ';=:'#=$'"#` ,#+%* $0% 8"./# "4 -"#-%C$& _$0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:`] _5NR 6Z@IH`< O0'-0 '& C*";C$%+ G? =# =:*%%;%#$ G%$O%%# $0% 4*%% ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ $0% 3=O4,3 ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R a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a,$ $0% S,+:;%#$ =&&%*$%+ +"%& -3='; = #%-%&&=*'3? ,#'M%*&=3 &$=$,&R /0,& $0% $?C% "4 S,+:;%#$ '# 3":'-=3 4"*; O% =*% +%=3'#: O'$0 '& = &?#$0%$'- * 8#'"#' S,+:;%#$R U0=$ '& '$< $0%#< $0=$ O% -=# =&&%*$ =& #%-%&&=*? =#+ $0,& ,#'M%*&=33? G'#+'#: '# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%X !3%=*3?< '$ -=##"$ G% $0=$ =#?"#% &0",3+ 4%%3 $0% C3%=&,*% ) 4%%3 0=M'#: ;=+% $0% S,+:;%#$ _$0'& '& *,3%+ ",$ G? dK< =#+ V=#$ =:='# %;C0=&'&%& $0'& '# dAH`R T%#-%< '4 '$ '& #"$ $0% C3%=&,*% O0'-0 ) =; =&&%*$'#: $0=$ "$0%*& &0",3+ #%-%&&=*'3? 4%%3< '$ ;,&$ '#&$%=+ G% $0% \,#'M%*&=3 M=3'+'$? "4 $0'& C3%=&,*%]R /0=$ '&< O% C*%&%#$ = ,#'M%*&=3 *,3%Z O0%# = C3%=&,*% '& -"##%-$%+ '# $0% K/1?W2 O'$0 $0% ;%*% S,+:;%#$ "4 =# "GS%-$ '$ &0",3+ G% &$=$%+ G? =#?"#% $0=$ $0%? 4'#+ $0% "GS%-$ G%=,$'4,3R /0% +%+,-$'"# '& #%($ &';C3? *%&$=$%+ G? V=#$ '# dAI 4"33"O'#: 4*"; $0'& G=&'- &N%$-0 +%*'M%+ 4*"; ddA6^HR )4 = C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% -"#1 -%*#& "#3? $0% 4"*; "4 $0% "GS%-$ $0%# ",* 3'N'#: 4"* $0'& 4"*; '& #"$0'#: ;"*% $0=# ",* =O=*%#%&& "4 $0% \4"*;]& &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& 4"* S,+:;%#$] O0'-0 O% 4'#+ -"##%-$%+ #%-%&&=*'3? O'$0 $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% "GS%-$R /0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0'& '& *%3=$%+ $" $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 =#? S,+:;%#$ =$ =33R 5G&$*=-$'#: %#$'*%3? 4*"; $0% -"#$%#$ "4 =#? S,+:;%#$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.EE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

O% -=# &=? $0=$ = S,+:;%#$ ;,&$ G% +'*%-$%+ $"O=*+& = &,G&,;C$'"# "4 ';=:'#=$'"# ,#+%* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O0'-0< '4 O% C*%&%#$ $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 S,+:;%#$ '# :%#%*=3< '& $0% G=&'- C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =#?"#%]& -=C=-'$? "4 -":#'$'"#R \)$ 4"33"O& $0=$ O% ;,&$ G% %#$'$3%+ $" =&&,;% * 8#'"#' $0=$ = C*%&%#$=$'"#]& 0=*;"#? O'$0 $0%&% -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$ '& M=3'+ 4"* %M%*?"#%] _5NR 6Z@KE`R /0% G=&'- C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% +%+,-$'"# $0,& :'M%# '& &';C3%< M'kR< \$0=$ O% =*% S,&$'4'%+ '# C*%&,CC"&'#: '# =33 C%"C3% $0% &=;% &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$ $0=$ O% 4'#+ '# ",*&%3M%&] _5NR 6Z@KE`R /0,& $0% 7%+,-$'"# "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% '# 4=-$ -";C3%$%& $0% =--",#$ "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 4=-,3$? "4 S,+:;%#$ '# :%#%*=3 ;%*%3? =++'#: = #%O 4"*; "4 &-0%;=$'&; '# =++'$'"# $" $0"&% :'M%# '# $0% 2'*&$ =#+ >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%&R ['N% $0% \$?C'-] "4 $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +%+,-$'"# "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% "44%*& $0% 4"*; "4 = 3=O '# :%#%*=3 =#+< =& '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%< $0'& 4"*; "4 = 3=O _$0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:`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`< '# ",* $0",:0$< "4 %M%*?"#% %3&%]& O=? "4 C*%&%#$'#:]< &" $0=$ O% =*% $0%*%G? 3'G%*=$%+ 4*"; $=N'#: C*'M=$% -"#+'$'"#& "4 S,+:;%#$ 4"* "GS%-$'M% "#%&R /0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0'& =*%Z R R R O% -";C=*% ",* S,+:;%#$ #"$ &" ;,-0 O'$0 $0% =-$,=3 =& *=$0%* O'$0 $0% ;%*%3? C"&&'G3% S,+:;%#$& "4 "$0%*&< =#+ i$0,&j C,$ ",*1 &%3M%& '# $0% C"&'$'"# "4 %M%*?"#% %3&%< ;%*%3? G? =G&$*=-$'#: 4*"; $0% 3';'$=$'"#& $0=$ i;=?j 0=CC%# $" =$$=-0 $" ",* "O# S,+:'#:Y =#+ $0'& '# $,*# O% =--";C3'&0 G? 3%=M'#: ",$ =& ;,-0 =& C"&&'G3% O0=$%M%* '& ;=$$%*< 'R%R< &%#&=$'"#< '# $0% C*%&%#$=$'"#=3 &$=$%< =#+ G? C=?'#: =$$%#$'"# &"3%3? $" $0% 4"*;=3 4%=$,*%& "4 ",* C*%&%#$=$'"# "* "4 ",* C*%&%#$=$'"#=3 &$=$%R _5NR 6Z@KF`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: .E.

/0% #"$'"# "4 &,-0 = 3/%3?3 ,"11?%'3 '& O0=$ '& *%4%**%+ $" '# =&&%*$'#: $0% ,#'M%*&=3 M=3'+'$? =#+ #%-%&&'$? "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R /0'& '& O0? O0%# ;=N'#: &,-0 S,+:;%#$& O% +" '# 4=-$ 3%:'$';=$%3? %(C%-$ ,#'M%*&=3 =&&%#$R a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

N.#* 81$ "#4 D*#.;&C $-* >+#57;&.+# +, $-* 8#"7($.5 +, 8*&$-*$.5 J;402*#$ /0% 7%+,-$'"# "4 8,*% 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$& $0,& -3"&%& +%-'&'M%3? O'$0 dFE< 0=M'#: %&&%#$'=33? G%%# :'M%# '# dAIR e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h%$ '$ *%;='#& = -";;"#C3=-% $" &$=$% $0=$ V=#$ O=& M%*? ;,-0 3%&& '#$%*%&$%+ '# =*$ $0=# '# #=$,*=3 G%=,$?R6 ) O'33 0%*% &,::%&$ $0=$ $0% 4=-$ $0'& +'&-,&&'"# -"#-3,+%& $0% O0"3% 5#=3?$'- "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$ +%;"#&$*=$%& '$& &':#'4'-=#-%< = &':#'4'-=#-% O0'-0 O'33 G%-";% -3%=*%* O0%# O% $,*# $" =&&%&&'#: $0% -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# '$ =#+ $0% 5#$'#";? "4 $0% !*'$'J,% "4 /=&$%R a%4"*% G%:'##'#: $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 4'#% =*$ V=#$ C*"M'+%& ,& O'$0 $O" 3'#N'#: &%-$'"#& G%$O%%# $0% -3"&,*% "4 $0% 7%+,-$'"# "4 C,*% S,+:1 ;%#$& "4 $=&$% =#+ $0% &%$$'#: ",$ "4 =# =%&$0%$'- =--",#$ "4 $0% C*"+,-1 $'"# "4 4'#% =*$R /0%&% 3'#N'#: &%-$'"#& G"$0 -"#-%*# $"C'-& O0'-0 =*% #"$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.E@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: .EA

)4 O% -",3+ =&&,;% $0=$ $0% ;%*% ,#'M%*&=3 -";;,#'-=G'3'$? =& &,-0 "4 ",* 4%%3'#: ;,&$ =3*%=+? -=**? O'$0 '$ =# '#$%*%&$ 4"* ,& _&";%$0'#: O% =*%< 0"O%M%*< #"$ S,&$'4'%+ '# '#4%**'#: 4*"; $0% -0=*=-$%* "4 = ;%*%3? *%43%-$'M% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$`< $0%# O% -",3+ %(C3='# 0"O '$ '& $0=$ O% *%J,'*% 4*"; %M%*?"#% =& = +,$?< =& '$ O%*%< $0% 4%%3'#: i-"#$='#%+j '# = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%R _5NR 6Z@KD` /0% ;%*% ,#'M%*&=3 -";;,#'-=G'3'$? =& &,-0 O0'-0 ,#+%*3'%& $0% C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% +"%& #"$ -=**? O'$0 '$ =# '#$%*%&$ G%-=,&% $" G% = C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '$ ;,&$ G% O'$0",$ '#$%*%&$ "4 =#? N'#+ _'#-3,+1 '#: '#$%33%-$,=3`R a,$ &'#-% $0'& 4%%3'#: '& = &':# $" ,& "4 =# =:*%%;%#$ '# -":#'$'M% C"O%* '$ ;':0$ G% $0",:0$ $0=$ $0%*% =*% *%=&"#& G%?"#+ $0% C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '$&%34 4"* %(C%-$'#: 4*"; "$0%*& $0% %(0'G'$'"# "4 $0% -=C=-'$? 4"* &,-0 = 4%%3'#:R 5$ $0'& C"'#$< $0%*%4"*%< =& %=*3'%* O'$0 $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% )+%=3 "4 a%=,$? =#+ '# $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';%< O% 3%=M% G%0'#+ $0% =--",#$ "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =#+ G%:'# = +'&-,&&'"# O0'-0 '& #" 3"#:%* $0=$ "4 4"*;=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&& =3"#% G,$ O0'-0 #"O -"#$='#& = *%4%*%#-% "4 &";% &"*$ $" ;=$%*'=3 C,*C"&%&R V=#$ "C%#& dF. O'$0 = :%#%*=3 S,&$'1 4'-=$'"# "4 $0'& C*"-%+,*%Z /0=$ = S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% G? O0'-0 O% +%-3=*% &";%$0'#: $" G% G%=,$'4,3 ;,&$ #"$ 0=M% =# '#$%*%&$ *3 '23 0/2/#1'%'%) 7*3'3 0=& G%%# %&$=G3'&0%+ &,44'-'%#$3? =G"M%R a,$ '$ +"%& #"$ 4"33"O 4*"; $0'& $0=$< =4$%* $0% S,+:;%#$ 0=& G%%# ;=+% =& = C,*% =%&$0%$'- "#%< =# '#$%*%&$ -=##"$ G% -"##%-$%+ O'$0 '$R _5NR 6Z@KD`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

O'$0'# $0% *=#:% "4 = +'&-,&&'"# "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R /0%? -"#1 -%*# $O" &"*$& "4 \'#$%*%&$] '# $0% G%=,$'4,3< %;C'*'-=3 =#+ '#$%33%-$,=3R U% =*% C*%C=*%+ 4"* $0'& +'&-,&&'"# "4 &";%$0'#: $0=$ O=& %(C3'-'$3? &$=$%+ #"$ $" G% C=*$ "4 $0% =--",#$ "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =& %=*3? =& d@ "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% a%=,$'4,3 G? $0% *%;=*N& =$ $0% -3"&% "4 dFEZ

b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`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` "4 ;=#R /0% *%=&"#& O0? O% =*% -"#-%*#%+ O'$0 $0% J,%&$'"# =& $" O0%$0%* $0%*% '& = G=&'& 4"* $0% ,#'M%*&=3 *%J,'*%;%#$ -"#$='#%+ O'$0'# S,+:1 ;%#$& "4 $=&$% '& $0=$ $0'& 4"*; "4 S,+:;%#$ +"%& '# 4=-$ ='+ ,& '# -";;,#'-=$'#: O'$0 %=-0 "$0%*R )# *%3=$'"# $" ",* 3'4% '# -";;"# O% %(C%-$ =& = ;=$$%* "4 -",*&% $0=$ "$0%*& O'33 =$$%;C$ $" -";;,#'-=$% O'$0 ,&< %M%# '# *%3=$'"# $" $0% &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0%'* %('&$%#-%< $0=$ '&< $0%'* ;%*% 4%%31 '#:&R /0'& '& %&C%-'=33? $0% -=&% O'$0 *%:=*+ $" 4%%3'#:& "4 C3%=&,*%< O0'-0 C*"M'+% ,& O'$0 = &$=#+=*+ "4 -'M'3'k=$'"# $0=$ '& +'&$'#-$ '# C*'#-'C3% 4*"; ;%*% =G'3'$? $" -"#M%*&% 3":'-=33?< = &$=#+=*+ "4 *%1 4'#%;%#$Z 2"* O% S,+:% &";%"#% *%4'#%+ '4 0% 0=& $0% '#-3'#=$'"# =#+ $0% &N'33 $" -";;,#'-=$% 0'& C3%=&,*% $" "$0%*&< =#+ '4 0% '& #"$ &=$'&4'%+ O'$0 =# "GS%-$ ,#3%&& 0% -=# 4%%3 0'& 3'N'#: 4"* '$ '# -";;,#'$? O'$0 "$0%*&R _5NR 6Z@KH` /0'& :*"O& %(C"#%#$'=33? O'$0 +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$'%& "4 -'M'31 '&=$'"# =& O% C*":*%&&'M%3? +'&-"M%* $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $*=#&-%#+'#: ;%*% %#S"?;%#$ '# -0=*;& =#+ #"$'-% G%=,$'4,3 4"*;& &,-0 =& -3"$0%& $0=$ '#M"3M% #" %#S"?;%#$ "4 &%#&=$'"#R /0'& '#+'*%-$ *%3=$'"# $" $0% 4%%3'#: "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 $0=$ O% -=# #"$% '# &"-'%$? '& #"$ %#",:0 '# '$&%34 $" *%3=$% $0% C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% $" $0% +%;=#+& "4 +,$? ;%#$'"#%+ =$ $0% -"#-3,&'"# "4 dFER 2"* +%&C'$% $0% *%4'#%;%#$ &,-0 =# '#$%*%&$ *%M%=3& '$ -=# %=&'3? 4,&% O'$0 $0% "$0%* C=&&'"#& $0=$ =#';=$% &"-'%$?

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.EF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

=#+ $0,& -=#< &$=$%& V=#$< C*"M'+% =$ G%&$ \"#3? = M%*? =;G':,",& $*=#&'1 $'"# 4*"; $0% =:*%%=G3% $" $0% :""+] _5NR 6Z@KI`R 2,*$0%*;"*%< +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 %;C'*'-=3 '#$%*%&$ '# $0% G%=,$'4,3 -=# %M%# 0=M% G=+ -"#&%J,%#-%& O0%# M'%O%+ 4*"; $0% &$=#+C"'#$ "4 $0% ;"*=3 3=O =& $0"&% O0" 0=M% = :*%=$ C*"C%#&'$? $" +'&C3=?'#: &,-0 %;C'*'-=3 '#$%*%&$ "4$%# =*% \M='#< "G&$'#=$% =#+ :'M%# $" *,'#",& C=&1 &'"#&] _5NR 6Z@KI`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a,$ '$ &0",3+ G% *%-=33%+ $0=$ $0'& '& +"#% G%-=,&% $0% /18'#',*( '%2/#/32 '# $0%&% $?C%& "4 G%=,$? '& 0%*% G%'#: -"#&'+%*%+R 2"* =# '#$%*%&$ $" G% =$$=-0%+ $" = 4%%3'#: "4 C3%=&,*% '# $0% G%=,$? "4 #=$,*% '$ O'33 G% #%-%&&=*? $0=$ $0% "#% O0" "G&%*M%& $0% G%=,$? C,*%3? &0",3+ G% 3%+ $" $0% 4%%3'#: $0=$ 0% \O",3+ #"$ O=#$ #=$,*% $" G% %#$'*%3? O'$0",$ $0%; %M%# '4 $0%? C*"M'+%+ 0'; #" C*"&C%-$ "4 G%#%4'$] _5NR 6Z@KK`R /0'& '#M"3M%& =# '#$%*%&$ O0'-0 '& #" 3"#:%* ;%*%3? %;C'*'1 -=3 =#+ +'*%-$%+ $" &"-'%$?]& O'&0%& =#+ -"#-%'$&< G,$ '& C,*%3? '# =--"*+ O'$0 = 4%%3'#: "4 *':0$#%&& =G",$ $0% %('&$%#-% "4 $0% "GS%-$ =#+ 0%#-% '& = ;"*=3 4%%3'#:R /0'& '#$%*%&$< ,#3'N% $0% %;C'*'-=3 '#$%*%&$ '# $0% G%=,1 $'4,3< '& +'*%-$ =#+ G=&%+ "# = C,*'$? "4 4%%3'#: O0'-0 '& C*%-'&%3? $0% &=;% =& $0=$ :'M%# '# $0% ;"*=3 3=OR a,$ O'$0 =*$ O% #%M%* -=# %(C%-$ &,-0 = +'*%-$ '#$%*%&$ '# G%=,$? $" =*'&%R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& 4=-$ $0%*% '&< =& V=#$ &$=$%&< = \&,C%*'"*'$? "4 #=$,*=3 G%=,$? "M%* $0=$ "4 =*$] _5NR 6Z@KK`Z !"#&'+%*< '# =++'$'"#< 0"O O% =+;'*% #=$,*%< O0'-0 '# '$& G%=,$'4,3 C*"+,-$& +'&C3=?& '$&%34 =& =*$< i'R%R< =& =-$'#:j #"$ ;%*%3? G? -0=#-% G,$< =& '$ O%*%< '#$%#$'"#=33?< '# $%*;& "4 = 3=O4,3 =**=#:%;%#$ =#+ =& = C,*C"&'M%#%&& O'$0",$ = C,*C"&%Y =#+ &'#-% O% +" #"$ 4'#+ $0'& C,*C"&% =#?O0%*% ",$&'+% ,&< O% #=$,*=33? 3""N 4"* '$ '# ",*&%3M%&< #=;%3?< '# O0=$ -"#&$'$,$%& $0% ,3$';=$% G=&'& "4 ",* %('&$%#-%Z ",* ;"*=3 M"-=$'"#R _5NR 6ZAE.` /0% $*,% M"-=$'"# "4 0,;=#'$? '& #"$ &"-'%$? _O0'-0 "44%*& ;%*%3? %;C'*'-=3 '#$%*%&$&`< G,$ ;"*=3'$? _O0'-0 :'M%& ,& ",* $*,% '#$%33%-$,=3 '#$%*%&$&`R )$ '& $"O=*+& $0'& O0'-0 O% =*% +'*%-$%+ G? $0% '#$%*%&$ O0'-0

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: .E6

.ED C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0% -0=*;& '# G%=,$'4,3 #=$,*%< O0'-0 O% &" "4$%# 4'#+ 4,&%+< =& '$ O%*% O'$0 G%=,$'4,3 4"*;< G%3"#: %'$0%* $" $0% ;"+'4'-=$'"#& "4 3':0$ _'# -"3",*'#:` "* "4 &",#+ _'# $"#%&`R 2"* $0%&% =*% $0% "#3? &%#&=$'"#& $0=$ =33"O #"$ ;%*%3? 4"* = 4%%3'#: "4 &%#&%< G,$ =3&" 4"* *%43%-$'"# "# $0% 4"*; "4 $0%&% ;"+'4'-=$'"#& "4 $0% &%#&%&< &" $0=$ $0%? -"#$='#< =& '$ O%*%< = 3=#:,=:% '# O0'-0 #=$,*% &C%=N& $" ,& =#+ O0'-0 &%%;& $" 0=M% = 0':0%* ;%=#'#:R _5NR 6ZAE@`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a,$< O0'3&$ $0'& #"$'"# "4 *%43%-$'M% +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 -%*$='# &%#&=1 $'"#& '& #"$ 0%*% :'M%# =# %(C3=#=$'"#< '$ O'33 G% &,G&%J,%#$3? '# $0% -",*&% "4 V=#$]& =--",#$ "4 4'#% =*$R /0% 3%#:$0? C*%3';'#=*? O% 0=M% +%M"$%+ $" $0% -"##%-$'#: dd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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=--*,%& $" #=$,*=3 G%=,$? O0'-0 '& O0? = +'*%-$ '#$%*%&$ '# '$ '&< V=#$ &=?&< =3O=?& $0% ;=*N "4 = :""+ &",3 _=#+ %M%# = \G%=,$'4,3 &",3]`R V=#$ #"O =++& &";%$0'#: O0'-0 O% ;':0$ *%:=*+ =& &,*C*'&'#: :'M%# 0'& %=*3'%* &$=$%;%#$& =G",$ &%#&=$'"#Z

>%-$'"# FA %3=G"*=$%& = &%*'%& "4 +'&$'#-$'"#& G%$O%%# =*$ =#+ #=$,*%< =*$ =#+ &-'%#-%< =#+ =*$ =#+ -*=4$R 5*$ '& +'&$'#-$ '# :%#%*=3 $%*;& 4*"; #=$,*% '# G%'#: $0% +%3'G%*=$% -*%=$'"# "4 &";%$0'#: $0=$ G=&%& '$& =-$& "# *%=&"#R 5*$ '& $0,& = C*"+,-$ "4 4*%%+";< #=$,*% "4 *,3%1:"M%*#%+ +%$%*;'#=$'"#R Q#3'N% &-'%#-%< =*$ '& #"$ = $0%"*%$'-=3 =G'3'$?< $0=$ '&< '$ -=##"$ G% C*"+,-%+ &';C3? G? *%4%**'#: $" :%#%*=3 =#+ ,#'M%*&=33? 3%=*#1 =G3% C*"-%+,*%&R 2,*$0%*;"*%< =*$ '& +'&$'#-$ 4*"; -*=4$ '# $0=$ = -*=4$ '& ,#+%*$=N%# =& = 3=G",* =#+ #"$ = C3%=&,*%R /0% C*"+,-$ "4 $0%&% +'&$'#-$'"#& '& $0% #"$'"# "4 @'%/ =*$R )4 =*$ '& #"$ = C*"+,-$'"# =--"*+'#: $" $0%"*%$'-=3 C*'#-'C3%&< $0%# '$ 4"33"O& "4 #%-%&1 &'$? $0=$ $0%*% -=# G% #" &-'%#-% "4 $0% G%=,$'4,3 =3$0",:0 $0%*% -=# G% = -*'$'J,% "4 '$& C"&&'G'3'$? "4 C*"+,-$'"# G? *%=&"#=G3% 0=#+&R >';'3=*3?< $0%*% -=# G% #" 4'#% &-'%#-% =& $0'& O",3+ *%&$ "# $0% =&&,;C$'"# $0=$ $=&$% '$&%34 -=# C*"+,-% +%$%*;'#=$% *,3%&< O0'-0 '& =# =G&,*+'$?R 2'#% =*$ '& '# '$& -"#-%C$ =# =*$ $0=$ =';& $" C*"+,-% =%&$0%$'- &%#&=$'"#&R /0'& '& +'&$'#-$ 4*"; =# =:*%%=G3% =*$< O0'-0 0=& $0% C,*C"&% "4 =*",&'#: %#S"?1 ;%#$ ,#+%* O0'-0 -"#-%C$ O% -=# 3'&$ -""N%*?< -"#M%*&=$'"#=3 &N'33< :=;%& "4 ;=#? $?C%& =#+ %M%*?$0'#: $0=$ C*";"$%& 3'M%3? =#+ -"#M'M'=3 -"#M%*&%R >,-0 =:*%%=G3% =*$& =*%< $0%*%4"*%< "#% '# C*'#-'C3% O'$0 $0% %;C'*'-=3 '#$%*%&$ '# $0% G%=,$'4,3R )4 '# =++'$'"# $" &,-0 =*$& O% 0=M% = -"#-%C$ "4 4'#% =*$ O0'-0 $*=#&-%#+& &,-0 %;C'*'-=3 '#$%*%&$< $0%# O% 0=M% &";%$0'#: O0'-0 '# C*'#-'C3% '& +'&$'#-$ '# $?C% 4*"; $0% =*$ O0'-0 V=#$ C3=-%+ G%3"O #=$,*=3 G%=,$? '# $%*;& "4 %;C'*'-=3 '#$%*%&$R 5& V=#$ &,;;=*'&%&Z \=%&$0%$'- =*$ $0=$ '& =3&" 4'#% =*$ '& "#% O0"&% &$=#+=*+ '& $0% *%43%-$'M% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$< *=$0%* $0=# &%#&=$'"# C*"C%*] _5NR 6ZAED`R )4 O% =*% *%3=$'#: $" 4'#% =*$ =%&$0%$'-=33?< 0"O%M%*< O% =*% =O=*% $0=$ $0% C,*% 4"*; O0'-0 O% =*% =CC*%-'=$'#: '& #"$ = C*"+,-$ "4 #=$,*% %M%# $0",:0 -"#&'+%*%+ =& = C,*C"&'M% 4"*; '$ ;,&$ C*%&%#$ '$&%34 $" ,& =& 4*%%3? =& = #=$,*=3 G%=,$?R )# 4=-$ #=$,*% =#+ =*$ 0=M% = *%-'C*"-=3 *%3=$'"#Z \W=$,*%< O% &=?< '& G%=,$'4,3 i3,9"W%j '4 '$ =3&" 3""N& 3'N% =*$Y =#+ =*$ -=# G% -=33%+ 4'#% i3,9"W%j =*$ "#3? '4 O% =*% -"#1 &-'",& $0=$ '$ '& =*$ O0'3% ?%$ '$ 3""N& $" ,& 3'N% #=$,*%] _5NR 6ZAED`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: .EH

e%#',& '& $0=$ %#+"O;%#$ O0'-0 \:'M%& $0% *,3%] $" =*$R b$0%*O'&% C,$Z \K/%'?3 '& $0% '##=$% ;%#$=3 C*%+'&C"&'$'"# _'%)/%'?1` 29#"?)9 .9',9 #=$,*% :'M%& $0% *,3% $" =*$] _5NR 6ZAEH`R /0'& +%4'#'$'"# '& &";%O0=$ "G&-,*% _0"O =#+ O0? '& $0% \C*%+'&C"&'$'"#] '##=$%X`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` O% -=# &%% $0=$ =#? O"*N "4 C*"+,-$'"# "4 C,*C"&'M% =-$'"# *%J,'*%& *%4%*%#-% $" &";% #?(/3 "4 C*"+,-$'"#R /0'& ;,&$ $0%*%4"*% G% *%J,'*%+ "4 4'#% =*$ =& O%33 =#+ '$ O'33 G% #%-%&&=*? $" +%;"#&$*=$% 0"O '$ '& C"&&'G3% $" 0=M% = C*"+,-$'"# =--"*+'#: $" *,3%& O0'-0 #%M%*$0%3%&& =33"O& $0% ;'#+ $" *%;='# '# 4*%% C3=? O0%# -"#$%;C3=$'#: '$ _=& '& #%-%&&=*? '# =# =%&$0%$'- &$=$%`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a%-=,&% "4 $0'& &";%$0'#: "$0%* $0=# $0% %;C'*'-=3 -"#+'$'"#& "4 C*"+,-$'"# ;,&$ G% $=N%# $" G% $0% :*",#+& "4 '$& *,3%R /0'& =33"O& ,& $" *%$,*# $" $0% "G&-,*% +%4'#'$'"# "4 :%#',& =3*%=+? :'M%# O'$0 #%O -";1 C*%0%#&'"#Z \'$ ;,&$ G% #=$,*% '# $0% &,GS%-$ _=#+ $0*",:0 $0% =$$,#%1 ;%#$ "4 0'& C"O%*&` $0=$ :'M%& $0% *,3% $" =*$] _5NR 6ZAEH`R 9,&$ =& $0% =G'3'$? $" ;=N% C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% O=& &0"O# $" *%&$ ,C"# $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 -":#'$'"# '# :%#%*=3< &" $0% =G'3'$? $" 8#"0?,/ O"*N& O0'-0 =*% =';%+ =$ C*"+,-'#: &,-0 S,+:;%#$& ;,&$ =3&" +*=O ,C"# $0% ;"&$ G=&'- -":#'$'M% C"O%*& O0'-0 =*% :'M%# $" ,&R /0'& '& #"O &%$ ",$ ;"*% &?&$%;=$'-=33?R e%#',&< $0% C"O%* "4 C*"+,1 -'#: &";%$0'#: $0*",:0 $0% =$$,#%;%#$ "4 $0% -":#'$'M% C"O%*& "4 $0% &,GS%-$< +"%& #"$ *%&$ ,C"# =#? +%$%*;'#=$% *,3%&R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& 4=-$ '$ '& #"$ &";%$0'#:< ,#3'N% $0% &-'%#$'4'- =G'3'$?< O0'-0 -=# G% 3%=*#%+ G?

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.EI C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

4"33"O'#: &";% &%$ *,3%& %M%# $0",:0 '$ +"%& *%&$ "# *,3%&R a%-=,&% $0% C*"+,-$'"#& "4 :%#',& +" #"$ *%&$ ,C"# +%$%*;'#=$% *,3%& %=-0 O"*N %;%*:%& 4*"; = &C"#$=#%",& =#+ ,#C*%+'-$=G3% -";G'#=$'"# "4 -":#'1 $'M% C"O%*& O0"&% C"&&'G'3'$? '& #"$ :'M%# '# =+M=#-%R T"O%M%*< &'#-% '$ '& =3O=?& C"&&'G3% $" C*"+,-% &";%$0'#: O0'-0 0=& #" =%&$0%$'- M=3,% G? &';C3? =G=#+"#'#: =#? *%4%*%#-% $" *,3%&< $0%*% '& = &$=#+=*+ 4"* S,+:1 ;%#$ "4 O"*N& O0'-0 O",3+ =&C'*% $" G% O"*N& "4 :%#',& $0",:0 '$ '& "4 #%-%&&'$? =# '#+%$%*;'#=$% &$=#+=*+R /0'& '& $0=$ O"*N& "4 :%#',& #%%+ $" G% \%(%;C3=*?]< $0=$ $0%? -=# =-$ =& = G=&'& _&$=#+=*+ "* *,3%` G? O0'-0 $" S,+:% "$0%* O"*N&R 533 "4 $0'& '& &$'33 %($*%;%3? "G&-,*% =$ $0'& &$=:%< +%&C'$% $0% -3=*'$? O0'-0 #"O =$$=-0%& $" $0% #"$'"# $0=$ '# :%#',& #=$,*% :'M%& $0% *,3% $" =*$R U0=$ N'#+ "4 *,3% '& '#M"3M%+ '# :%#',&X e'M%# $0=$ '$ -=##"$ G% &%$ ",$ '# +%$%*;'#=$% -"#-%C$& '$ ;,&$ G% \=G&$*=-$%+ 4*"; O0=$ $0% =*$'&$ 0=& +"#%] _5NR 6ZAEK`R a,$ 0"O '& $0'& C"&&'G3%X T%*% V=#$ 4=M",*& &";%1 $0'#: "4 = ;'(%+ *%&C"#&% O0'-0 0%3C& $" +%M%3"C $0% -"#-%C$ "4 4'#% =*$R /" G% = C*"+,-$ "4 =*$ &";%$0'#: ;,&$ G% = C*"+,-$'"# "4 = 4*%% =-$'"#R a,$ 4"* =#?$0'#: $" G% &,-0 *%J,'*%& =$ 3%=&$ &";% *,3%& $0=$ -=# G% :'M%# '# =+M=#-%R /0,& $0% %;C'*'-=3 C*"+,-$'"# "4 4'#% =*$ +"%& *%&$ ,C"# &";% *,3%&< O0=$ V=#$ $%*;& \=-=+%;'- -"**%-$#%&&]R \2"* &";%1 $0'#: ;,&$ G% $0",:0$< =& C,*C"&%< &'#-% "$0%*O'&% $0% C*"+,-$ -=##"$ G% =&-*'G%+ $" =#? =*$ =$ =33< G,$ O",3+ G% = ;%*% C*"+,-$ "4 -0=#-%] _5NR 6ZA.E`R T"O +"%& $0'& *%3=$% $" $0% 4*%% O"*N "4 :%#',&X e%#',& -=# "#3? C*"M'+% *'-0 1*2/#'*( 4"* C*"+,-$& "4 4'#% =*$Y C*"-%&1 &'#: $0'& ;=$%*'=3 =#+ :'M'#: '$ @"#1 *%J,'*%& = $=3%#$ $0=$ '& =-=+%;'-1 =33? $*='#%+< &" $0=$ '$ ;=? G% ,&%+ '# = O=? $0=$ -=# &$=#+ $0% $%&$ "4 $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$R _5NR 6ZA.E`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: .EK

..E C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

R R R '4 $0% "GS%-$ '& :'M%# =& = C*"+,-$ "4 =*$< =#+ =& &,-0 '& $" G% +%-3=*%+ G%=,$'4,3< $0%# O% ;,&$ 4'*&$ G=&% '$ "# = -"#-%C$ "4 O0=$ $0% $0'#: '& i;%=#$j $" G%< &'#-% =*$ =3O=?& C*%&,CC"&%& = C,*C"&% '# $0% -=,&% _=#+ '$& -=,&=3'$?`R 5#+ &'#-% $0% 0=*;"#? "4 = $0'#:]& ;=#'4"3+ O'$0 =# '#$*'#&'- +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 $0% $0'#:< 'R%R< O'$0 '$& C,*C"&%< '& $0% $0'#:]& C%*4%-$'"#< '$ 4"33"O& $0=$ O0%# O% S,+:% =*$'&$'- G%=,$? O% &0=33 0=M% $" =&&%&& $0% $0'#:]& C%*4%-$'"# =& O%33< O0%*%=& C%*4%-$'"# '& #"$ =$ =33 =$ '&&,% O0%# O% S,+:% #=$,*=3 G%=,$? _$" G% $0=$`R _5NR 6ZA..` /0% C,*'$? "4 $0'& -"#$*=&$ '& #"$ -";C3%$% =& O% -=# *%-=33 4*"; $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% )+%=3 "4 a%=,$? '# O0'-0 O% +" $=N% '#$" =--",#$ =# "GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& _C=*$'-,3=*3? '# S,+:'#: $0% 0,;=# 4"*;`R )$ O=& =3&" $0% -=&% '# &,-0 S,+:;%#$&< 0"O%M%*< $0=$ O% O%*% #" 3"#:%* ;=N'#: C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% G,$ *%&$'#: ",* S,+:;%#$ ,C"# = $%3%1 "3":'-=3 #"$'"# "4 O0=$ $0% C,*C"&% '# $0% 4"*; O=& $=N%# $" G%R /0,&< '4 O% &$=$% $0=$ = C%*&"# '& G%=,$'4,3< '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" '#+'-=$% O0%$0%* $0% C%*&"# ,#+%* -"#&'+%*=$'"# '& ;=3% "* 4%;=3%< =& O% *%4%* '# ;=N'#: &,-0 = S,+:;%#$ $" $0% C,*C"&%& '# $0% G,'3+ "4 $0=$ $?C% "4 0,;=# 4"*; =#+ *%&$ ",* =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ ,C"# = $%3%"3":'-=3 -"#&'+%*=$'"#< $0%*%G? C*"+,-'#: O0=$ V=#$ +%&-*'G%& =& \= 3":'-=33? -"#+'$'"#%+ =%&$0%$'S,+:;%#$] O0'-0 '#M"3M%& = -"#-%C$ =& O%33 =& = 4"*;R T"O%M%*< O0'3&$ %=*3'%* '# +'&-,&&'#: $0% %;C'*'-=3 '#$%*%&$ '# $0% G%=,$'4,3 O% -",3+ +'&-"M%* = :*",#+ 4"* =&&%*$'#: = &,C%*'"*'$? "4 #=$1 ,*=3 "M%* =*$'&$'- G%=,$? _O0%*% $0% 3=$$%* O=& $=N%# '# $0% ;"&$ :%#%*=3 &%#&% =#+ #"$ &C%-'4'-=33? '# *%3=$'"# $" @'%/ =*$` O% =*% #"O '#4"*;%+ "4 = &%#&% '# O0'-0 =*$'&$'- G%=,$? '& &,C%*'"* $" #=$,*=3 G%=,$? _O0%*% O% *#/ #"O $=N'#: $0% 4"*;%* $" &C%-'4'-=33? *%4%* $" 4'#% =*$`Z 2'#% =*$ &0"O& '$& &,C%*'"*'$? C*%-'&%3? '# $0'&< $0=$ '$ +%&-*'G%& $0'#:& G%=,$'4,33? $0=$ '# #=$,*% O% O",3+ +'&3'N% "* 4'#+ ,:3?R _5NR 6ZA.@` 2'#% =*$ -=# =33"O = G%=,$'4,3 C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 &";%$0'#: $0=$ O% O",3+ 4'#+ $%**'G3% '4 O% O%*% -"#4*"#$%+ O'$0 '$ '# #=$,*%< '#-3,+'#: &,-0

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

G%=,$?R /0% C*"+,-$'"# "4 4'#% =*$ '& =4$%* =33 =$ 3%=&$ C=*$3? = C*"+,-$'"# =--"*+'#: $" *,3%& &0=*%+ G? "$0%* "GS%-$& "4 +%$%*;'#=$% =-$'"#R /0,&< =3$0",:0 '# S,+:'#: = #=$,*=3 G%=,$? ) #%%+ 0=M% #" *%4%*%#-% =$ =33 $" O0=$ '$ '& $0=$ ) =; S,+:'#: G%=,$'4,3 =& ;=$%*'=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&& #%%+ C3=? 0%*% #" C=*$< $0'& -=##"$ G% $0% -=&% '# S,+:'#: 4'#% =*$R

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: ...

R R R '# $0=$ &$*=#:% &%#&=$'"#< O0'-0 *%&$& "# #"$0'#: G,$ ';=:'#1 =$'"#< $0% "GS%-$ '& C*%&%#$%+ =& '4 '$ '#&'&$%+< =& '$ O%*%< "# ",* %#S"?'#: '$ %M%# $0",:0 $0=$ '& S,&$ O0=$ O% =*% 4"*-%4,33? *%&'&$'#:Y =#+ 0%#-% $0% =*$'&$'- C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% "GS%-$ '& #" 3"#:%* +'&$'#1 :,'&0%+ '# ",* &%#&=$'"# 4*"; $0% #=$,*% "4 $0'& "GS%-$ '$&%34< &" $0=$ '$ -=##"$ C"&&'G3? G% -"#&'+%*%+ G%=,$'4,3R _5NR 6ZA.@` U'$0 $0'& "#% &':#'4'-=#$ %(-%C$'"#< 4'#% =*$ &,*C=&&%& #=$,*% $0*",:0 '$& C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =3$%*'#: $0% %(C%*'%#-% "4 $0=$ O0'-0 '& C*%&%#$%+ &" $0=$ O% =*% =G3% $" 4'#+ C3%=&,*% O0%*% "$0%*O'&% O% -",3+ "#3? +'&-"M%* C='#R T"O%M%*< $0% C*"+,-$'"# "4 4'#% =*$]& +,=3 -"#+'$'"# *%J,'*%& ;"*% $0=# = G%=,$'4,3 4"*; "4 C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% "GS%-$R /0'& '& $0% %;C'*'-=3 -"#+'$'"# "4 C*"+,-$'"# O0'-0 4"33"O& *,3%& =#+ O0'-0 $0% =*$'&$ +%M%31 "C& $0*",:0 +%M%3"C'#: 0'& "O# C"O%* "4 $=&$%R a,$ $0'& +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 $0% =*$'&$]& $=&$% ;%*%3? :'M%& 0'; *,3%& "4 S,+:;%#$ O0'-0 -=# G% :'M%# = -%*$='# +%$%*;'#=$% 4"*; G? *%4%*%#-% $" ;"+%3& "4 =:*%%+ G%=,$?R a,$< $0% =-$,=3 C*"+,-$'"# "4 = #%O O"*N "4 =*$ O0'-0 '$&%34 C*"M'+%& *,3%& 4"* "$0%* O"*N&< *%J,'*%& :%#',&R 5$ $0'& C"'#$< $0%*%4"*%< '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" &%$ ",$ O0=$ '& '#M"3M%+ '# $0% #"$'"# "4 :%#',&R /0'& V=#$ +"%& '# dFKR )# +"'#: &" 0% *%4%*& $" = $%*; ';C"*$=#$ 4"* &,G3';% S,+:;%#$&Z K/'32R 9,+:;%#$& "4 &,G3';'$? =*% #"$ S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% G,$ *=$0%* "4 )/'32/3)/@?W9( _'#$%33%-$,=3 "* &C'*'$,=3 4%%3'#:`R )# $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% 0"O%M%* V=#$< &";%1 O0=$ &,*C*'&'#:3?< +"%& #"$ &%$ ",$ $0% #"$'"# "4 K/'32R /0'& '& +"#% 0%*%Z >C'*'$ iK/'32j '# =# =%&$0%$'- &%#&% '& $0% =#';=$'#: C*'#-'C3% '# $0% )/1?W2R a,$ O0=$ $0'& C*'#-'C3% ,&%& $" =#';=$% i"* J,'-N%#j $0% &",3< $0% ;=$%*'=3 '$ %;C3"?& 4"* $0'&< '& O0=$ ';C=*$& $" $0% ;%#$=3 C"O%*& = C,*C"&'M% ;";%#$,;< 'R%R< ';C=*$& $" $0%; = C3=? O0'-0 '& &,-0 $0=$ '$ &,&$='#& '$&%34 "# '$& "O# =#+ %M%# &$*%#:$0%#& $0% C"O%*& 4"* &,-0 C3=?R _5NR 6ZA.A` K/'32 $0,& ';C=*$& = C,*C"&'M% ;";%#$,; =#+ =#';=$'"# $" $0% &,G1 S%-$]& -":#'$'M% C"O%*& &,-0 $0=$ $0% 4*%% C3=? "4 $0%; '& &$*%#:$0%#%+ =#+ &,&$='#%+R /0'& C*'#-'C3% _K/'32` '&< &=?& V=#$< $0% =G'3'$? $" \%(0'G'$ */329/2', '0/*3] _5NR 6ZA.F` O0'-0 '+%=& =*% C*%&%#$=$'"#& "4 $0% ';=:'#1 =$'"# $" O0'-0 #" -"#-%C$ -=# %M%* G% =+%J,=$%R /0,& $0% =%&$0%$'- '+%=

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

+*%=+4,3 -=3=;'$'%& =& O=* =#+ +'&%=&%R /0%*% '& "#3? "#% N'#+ "4 ,:3'#%&& $0=$ -=##"$ G% =3$%*%+ G? $0'& C"O%* "4 =*$'&$'- $*=#&4':,*=$'"# =#+ $0'& '& $0% ,:3'#%&& O0'-0 =*",&%& +'&:,&$ "4 O0'-0 V=#$ O*'$%&Z

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`R )# = O"*+< =# =%&$0%$'- '+%= '& = C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# O0'-0 '& -"#S"'#%+ O'$0 = :'M%# -"#-%C$ =#+ '& -"##%-$%+< O0%# O% ,&% ';=:'#=$'"# '# '$& 4*%%+";< O'$0 &,-0 = ;,3$'C3'-'$? "4 C=*$'=3 C*%&%#$=$'"#& $0=$ #" %(C*%&&'"# $0=$ &$=#+& 4"* = +%$%*;'#=$% -"#1 -%C$ -=# G% 4",#+ 4"* '$R _5NR 6ZA.D` );=:'#=$'"# G%:'#& O'$0 = *%3=$'"# $" = -"#-%C$ =#+ %(C=#+& $0% &%#1 &'G3% *=#:% "4 $0=$ -"#-%C$ $" &,-0 = +%:*%% $0=$ '$ '& ';C"&&'G3% $" +%$%*;'#% %M%*?$0'#: $0=$ '& '#M"3M%+ '# $0% &%#&'G3% *%C*%&%#$=$'"# =& $0% -"#-%C$]& C*%&%#$=$'"# -"#$='#& #"O ;"*% $0=# =#? C=*$'-,3=* =--",#$ $0=$ -",3+ G% :'M%# "4 '$R >" :%#',& '& = -";G'#=$'"# "4 ';=:'#1 =$'"# _$0% C"O%* "4 &%#&'G3% C*%&%#$=$'"#` O'$0 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: _$0% C"O%* "4 *,3%&` &,-0 $0=$ $0% ';=:'#=$'"#]& 4*%%+"; "M%*-";%& =#? +%$%*;'#=$% %(C*%&&'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:]& *,3%& O0'3&$ -"#&'&$%#$3? =#+ 4*%%3? +%M%3"C'#: '$& "O# *,3%&R );=:'#=$'"# $0,& $,*#& -"#-%C$& '#$" '+%=& O'$0",$ *%4%*%#-% $" *%=&"# =& $0%&% '+%=& +" #"$ G%-";% *=$'"#=3 '# 4"*; G,$ *=$0%* &%#&'G3% O0'3&$ 0=M'#: $0% -";C3%$% &-"C% $0=$ O",3+ =$$=-0 $" =#? '+%= "4 *%=&"#R e%#',& $0,& -"#&'&$& '# = +",G3% =G'3'$?Z 4'*&$< '$ '#M%#$& '+%=& $" =$$=-0 $" -"#-%C$& =#+ $*=#&4':,*%& $0% 3=$$%* =#+< &%-"#+< %(C*%&&%& $0%; '# = O=? $0=$ %#=G3%& $0% -";;,#1 '-=$'"# "4 $0% \;%#$=3 =$$,#%;%#$] $0% '+%=& C*"+,-%R /0% C"O%* "4 %(C*%&&'#: =%&$0%$'- '+%=& '& :%#',&R e%#',& #%%+& $" -";G'#% O'$0 $=&$% 4"* 4'#% =*$ $" G% C*"+,-%+R e%#',& '& = C"O%* "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< $=&$% "4 S,+:;%#$R e%#',&]& C*%&%#-% '& O0=$ O% +%&-*'G% =& '#&C'*%+ _)/'32#/',9` =#+ '$ '& $0'& O0'-0 :'M%& $0% O"*N 3'4%R /0% C*%&%#-% "4 $=&$%< 0"O%M%*< ;=N%& $0% O"*N "4 4'#% =*$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

..@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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a%=,$? '& \$0% /<8#/33'"% "4 =%&$0%$'- '+%=&]< O0'-0 '# 4'#% =*$ 0=& $" *%4%* ,& $" = -"#-%C$ "4 = C=*$'-,3=* &"*$ _O0'-0 -"#+'1 $'"# '& #"$ *%J,'*%+ '# #=$,*=3 G%=,$?`R /0%*% =*% '# :%#%*=3 "#3? $0*%% $?C%& "4 4'#% =*$ O0'-0 *%3=$% $" $0% $0*%% $?C%& "4 %(C*%&&'"#Z %(C*%&&'"# G? O"*+< %(C*%&&'"# G? :%&$,*% =#+ %(C*%&&'"# G? $"#%R /0% $0*%% $?C%& "4 4'#% =*$ =*% $0,&Z =*$& "4 &C%%-0< M'&,=3 =*$ =#+ =*$ "4 $0% C3=? "4 &%#&=$'"#&R 5*$& "4 &C%%-0 =*% ;%*%3? C"%$*? =#+ *0%$"*'-< M'&,=3 =*$& ^ &-,3C$,*% =#+ C='#$'#: _,#+%* O0'-0 V=#$ C3=-%& :=*+%#'#: =#+ %M%# $0% =*$ "4 +*%&&'#: $=&$%4,33?< =& O%33 =& "'3 C='#$'#:`< =#+ =*-0'$%-$,*%R Q#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 C3=?& "4 &%#&=$'"# 0% '#-3,+%& ;,&'- =#+ -"3",*R b#3? $0% 3=&$ "4 $0%&% :'M%& V=#$ *%=3 +'44'-,3$?R U% 0=M% =3*%=+? #"$%+ 0'& =&&%*$'"# $0=$ $0% O0'$% "4 $0% 3'3? 3%=+& ,& $" $0",:0$& "4 '##"-%#-% &" $0=$ $0% &%#&=$'"# C*"+,-%& =,$";=$'-=33? = 4"*; "4 *%43%-$'"#R /0'& C,kk3'#: =&&%*$'"# '& *%$,*#%+ $" =#+ =;C3'4'%+ O0%# 0% O*'$%& $0=$ \O% -=##"$ &=? O'$0 -%*$='#$? O0%$0%* = -"3",* "* = $"#% _&",#+` '& ;%*%3? =# =:*%%=G3% &%#&=$'"# "* O0%$0%* '$ '& "4 '$&%34 =3*%=+? = G%=,$'4,3 C3=? "4 i-";C"#%#$j &%#&=$'"#&] _5NR 6ZA@F`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a,$ O0=$ '& %&&%#$'=3 '# =33 4'#% =*$ '& $0% 4"*; $0=$ '& C,*C"&'M% 4"* ",* "G&%*M=$'"# =#+ S,+:'#:< *=$0%* $0=# $0% ;=$$%* "4 &%#&=$'"#] _5NR

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: ..A

6ZA@D`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a,$ '# 4=-$ $0% *%M%*&% '& $0% -=&%R 8"%$*? '& &='+ $" G% $0% 0':0%&$ =;"#:&$ $0% =*$& %M%# $0",:0 '$ "O%& '$& "*':'# \=3;"&$ %#$'*%3? $" :%#',&]R 8"%$*? \&%$& $0% ';=:'#=$'"# 4*%%] =#+ 3%$& ,& 4%%3 ",* =G'3'$? $" -"#$%;C3=$% #=$,*% "# +'44%*%#$ :*",#+& $0=# =*% :'M%# '# $0% =-$& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ 0%#-% \3%$& $0% ;'#+ 4%%3 '$& =G'3'$? $" ,&% #=$,*% "# G%0=34 "4 =#+< =& '$ O%*%< =& = &-0%;= "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3%] _5NR 6ZA@D`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a,$ $0% %44%-$ "4 0'& +'&-,&&'"# "4 4'#% =*$ '& $" G*'#: '#$" $0% =--",#$ "4 $=&$% =# '#$%*%&$ O0'-0 '& #"$ ;%*%3? %;C'*'-=3 O0'3&$ G%'#:< =& =# '#$%*%&$< G%?"#+ $0% *%=3; "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R 2'#% =*$ '& ';C"*$=#$ '# +%;"#&$*=$'#: $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% 8#"0?,2'"% "4 $0% &$=$% "4 C3%=&,*% '# $0% %(C*%&&'"# "4 G%=,$?R /0'& C*"+,-$'"# '& #"O ,#+%*&$""+ =& 0=M'#: = -"#+'$'"# '#

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

..F C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

$0% *%3=$'"# "4 $=&$% =#+ :%#',&< ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ S,+:;%#$R /0% =--",#$ "4 4'#% =*$ O0'-0 -3"&%& $0% 5#=3?$'- :'M%& ,& = #"$'"# $0=$ O% +'+ #"$ +%*'M% 4*"; %'$0%* $0% 7%+,-$'"# "* =#? "$0%* C=*$ "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$Z $0% #"$'"# "4 =%&$0%$'- '+%=& _O0'-0 O%*%< 0"O%M%*< =#$'-'C=$%+ G? $0% =##",#-%;%#$ "4 =# )+%=3 "4 a%=,$?`R W"O '$ '& $';% $" &%$ ",$ $0% 5#$'#";? "4 $0% !*'$'J,% "4 /=&$% G*'#:'#: ",$ =& O% +" &" $0% -"##%-$'"#& G%$O%%# $0'& =#+ $0% =--",#$ "4 4'#% =*$ O0'3&$ +'&$'#:,'&0'#: '$ 4*"; O0=$ O=& +%;"#&$*=$%+ '# $0% 7%+,-$'"# "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R

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`R >'#-% $0'& '& C*%-'&%3? O0=$ O% $0",:0$ 0=+ G%%# S,&$'4'%+ '# $0% 7%+,-$'"# '$ O",3+ &%%; $0=$ V=#$ '3 #"O C*"-%%+'#: =& '4 $0% 7%+,-1 $'"# O=& '#-";C3%$% =#+ #%%+%+ &,CC3%;%#$=$'"#R )# d6D V=#$ C*%&%#$& $0% =#$'#";? =& =*'&'#: 4*"; $0% -"#43'-$ G%$O%%# $O" "CC"&%+ -";;"#C3=-%& =G",$ $=&$%R 2'*&$< $0% &$=$%;%#$ /G/#:"%/ 9*3 9'3 ".% 2*32/ _O0'-0 '& \,&%+ G? %M%*?"#% O0" 3=-N& $=&$% G,$ $*'%& $" %&-=C% -%#&,*%]`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` =#+ J,=**%33'#: _O0'-0 '& = 4"*; "4 =*:,;%#$ O0'-0 -=##"$ G% &%$$3%+ +%-'&'M%3? G,$ '& O"*$0 %#$%*$='#'#: $" = -%*$='# +%:*%%`R /0,& "#% -=# C"'#$ $" = ;'+1$%*; G%$O%%# $0%&% $O" -";;"#C3=-%& O0'-0 G*'#:&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: ..6

..D C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

_.` B9/3'3Z 5 S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& #"$ G=&%+ "# -"#-%C$&Y 4"* "$0%*1 O'&% "#% -",3+ +'&C,$% =G",$ '$ _+%-'+% G? ;%=#& "4 C*""4&`R _@` +%2'29/3'3Z 5 S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& G=&%+ "# -"#-%C$&Y 4"* "$0%*1 O'&%< *%:=*+3%&& "4 $0% M=*'=$'"# =;"#: i&,-0 S,+:;%#$&j< "#% -",3+ #"$ %M%# &" ;,-0 =& J,=**%3 =G",$ $0%; _3=? -3='; $" "$0%* C%"C3%]& #%-%&&=*? =&&%#$ $" "#%]& S,+:;%#$`R _5NR 6ZAAI^K` 5$ $0'& C"'#$< G%4"*% 3""N'#: =$ 0"O V=#$ C*%&%#$& $0% *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0'& =#$'#";?< '$ '& O"*$0 C"'#$'#: ",$ $0=$ $0% =#$'#";? -"#-%*#& &";%1 $0'#: +'44%*%#$ 4*"; $0=$ O0'-0 O=& S,&$'4'%+ G? $0% 7%+,-$'"#R /0% 7%+,-$'"# &0"O%+ $0=$ O% O%*% *':0$ $" -3='; ,#'M%*&=3 #%-%&&'$? 4"* C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% G%-=,&% &,-0 S,+:;%#$& *%&$ 4"* $0%'* &,GS%-$'M% C"&&'G'3'$? "# $0% &=;% :*",#+& =& -":#'$'"# '# :%#%*=3R /0% =#$'#";?< 0"O%M%*< C"'#$& $" = C*"G3%; =G",$ O0%$0%* "* #"$ &,-0 S,+:;%#$& =*% G=&%+ "# -"#-%C$&R /0,&< O0'3&$ $0% 7%+,-$'"# "44%*& = &,GS%-$'M% :*",#+ 4"* $0% ,#'M%*&=3 -3='; #%-%&&=*'3? '#M"3M%+ '# C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%< $0% 5#$'#";? -"#-%*#& $0% J,%&$'"# "4 O0=$ ;=N%& C"&&'G3% = J,=**%3 =G",$ &,-0 S,+:;%#$&R /0'& '& O0? $0% 5#$'#";? '& -"**%-$3? C%*-%'M%+ =& 0=M'#: = -"##%-$'"# $" $0% 7%+,-$'"#< G,$ '$ '& =3&" =# '#+'-=$'"# $0=$ O0=$ $0% *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0% 5#$'#";? ;,&$ -"#&'&$ '# '& #"$ O0=$ $0% 7%+,-$'"# S,&$'4'%+R )# :'M'#: $0% &"3,$'"# $" $0'& 5#$'#";? V=#$ ;%#$'"#& $0=$ $0% $O" M=*?'#: C*'#-'C3%& "4 $0%&'& =#+ =#$'$0%&'& =*% O=?& "4 %(C*%&&'#: $0% $O" C%-,3'=*'$'%& "4 C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% $0=$ O%*% +%&-*'G%+ '# $0% 7%+,-$'"#R /0'& '& -"**%-$< =& '# dA@ O% O%*% '#4"*;%+ $0=$ "#% C%-,1 3'=*'$? "4 = C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% O=& $0=$ '$ ;=+% = -3='; $" ,#'M%*&=3 =&&%#$ S,&$ =& '4 '$ O%*% =# "GS%-$'M% S,+:;%#$< O0'3&$ '# dAA O% O%*% *%;'#+%+ $0=$ &,-0 = S,+:;%#$ -",3+ #"$ G% +%$%*;'#%+ G? G=&%& "4 C*""4R /0% 7%+,-$'"# $0%# &0"O%+ $0=$ $0% *%-"#-'3'=$'"# "4 $0%&% $O" C%-,3'=*'$'%& -",3+ G% :'M%# '# = 3/%3?3 ,"11?%'3R a,$ $0'& '& ;%*%3? = &,GS%-$'M% :*",#+ 4"* $0% ,#'M%*&=3'$? "4 &,-0 S,+:;%#$&< O0'-0 +"%& #"$ '# '$&%34 *%#+%* -";C*%0%#&'G3% $0% #=$,*% =#+ %('&$%#-% "4 +'&-,&1 &'"# "4 &,-0 S,+:;%#$&R )$ '& $0% *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0% 5#$'#";? O0'-0 O'33 C%*4"*; $0'& $=&NR /0% *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0% 5#$'#";? $0,& #%%+& $" C*%&%#$ $0% :*",#+& "4 C"&&'G'3'$? "4 J,=**%33'#: =G",$ &,-0 S,+:;%#$& =#+ +%$%*;'#% O0%$0%*

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

",$ $0% -"#$*=+'-$'"# G%$O%%# $0%;Z "%/ ,*% >?*##/( *7"?2 2*32/R )4 O% -=# J,=**%3 =G",$ $=&$%< 0"O%M%*< $0%# '$ ;,&$ G% C"&&'G3% 4"* $0%*% $" G% :*",#+& '# -";;"# G%$O%%# ,& =#+ $0'& 4=-$ G*'#:& ",$ $0% =#$'#";?Z

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: ..H

5 S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% ;,&$ *%4%* $" &";% -"#-%C$ "* "$0%*< 4"* "$0%*1 O'&% '$ -",3+ #"$ C"&&'G3? 3=? -3='; $" #%-%&&=*? M=3'+'$? 4"* %M%*?"#%R _5NR 6ZAAK` 2"* $0%*% $" G% = J,=**%3 $0%*% ;,&$ G% &";% *%4%*%#-% $" -"#-%C$& =G",$ O0'-0 O% =*% J,=**%33'#:R a,$ =& = J,=**%3 '& = J,=**%3< =#+ #"$ = +'&C,$%< $0% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& -3%=*3? #"$ C*"M=G3% G? -"#-%C$&R >" C,*% S,+:1 ;%#$& "4 $=&$% *%4%* $" -"#-%C$& O0'-0 =*% #"$ +%$%*;'#=$% "* +%$%*;'#1 =G3%R /0'& O",3+ &%%; +'44'-,3$ $" =--%C$ _3%$ =3"#% %(C3='#` #"$ 3%=&$ G%-=,&% C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% -"#-%*# &%#&'G'3'$? =#+ =*% *%4%**%+ $" =# %44%-$ "4 C3%=&,*%R )$ '& $0'& 4=-$ =G",$ $0%; O0'-0 3%=+& $" $0% -";;"#C3=-% $0=$ %M%*?"#% 0=& 0'& "O# $=&$%R a,$< &'#-% O% 0=M% C*"M%+ =3*%=+? $0=$ $0%*% '& = -3%=* :*",#+ 4"* &%C=*=$'#: C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% 4*"; &$=$%;%#$& =G",$ $0% =:*%%=G3%< O% -=# &%% $0=$ $0% C3%=&,*% '# J,%&$'"# '& "#% O0'-0 ) -=# *%=&"#=G3? =#$'-'C=$% $" 0=M% = -"**%3=$% '# "$0%*& :'M%# $0%'* &0=*%+ -":#'$'M% %J,'C;%#$ _$0% C"'#$ "4 $0% 7%+,-$'"#`R )# J,=**%33'#: =G",$ S,+:1 ;%#$& "4 $=&$% O% ;,&$ G% *%4%**'#: $" = -"#-%C$ O0'-0 =& &,-0 :'M%& = G=&'& 4"* $0% J,=**%3]& %('&$%#-% =#+ $0,& S,&$'4'%& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% J,=**%3R )$ -=##"$ G% = +%$%*;'#=$% -"#-%C$ =#+ &" ;,&$ G% &";%$0'#: O0'-0 O0'3&$ '$&%34 #"$ C*"M=G3% -=# :'M% :*",#+& 4"* $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0'#:& O% N#"O $" %('&$R /0%*% '& = &';'3=* C*"G3%; 0%*% =& O=& %#-",#1 $%*%+ O'$0 *%:=*+ $" ;"*=3 S,+:;%#$& O0'-0 O% =*% =O=*% "4 =& -"#1 &$=#$3? #%-%&&=*? 4"* ,& ?%$ O0"&% C"&&'G'3'$? -=##"$ G% :'M%# C,*%3? G? -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R )# $0% -=&% "4 ;"*=3 S,+:;%#$& O% O%*% 3%+ $" C"&$,3=$% $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 *%=&"# =#+ '$& C"&&'G'3'$? O=& 4,*$0%* G=&%+ ,C"# -"#+'$'"#& O0'-0 ;=+% '$& ,&% -3%=*R /0% ,3$';=$% G=&'& "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 *%=&"# '& 0"O%M%* \= C,*% -"#-%C$ "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3%] O0'-0 ,#+%*3'%& G"$0 ",*&%3M%& =& &,GS%-$& =#+ $0% "GS%-$ =& =# "GS%-$ "4 =CC%=*=#-%R R R R =33 -"#$*=+'-$'"# +'&=CC%=*& '4 ) &=? $0'&Z 5 S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$% '& G=&%+ "# = -"#-%C$ _$0% -"#-%C$ "4 = :%#%*=3 G=&'& "4 #=$,*%]& &,G1 S%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& 4"* ",* C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$`< G,$ $0'& -"#-%C$ +"%& #"$ =33"O ,& $" -":#'k% =#+ C*"M% =#?$0'#: -"#-%*#'#: $0% "GS%-$ G%-=,&% '$ '& '#$*'#&'-=33? '#+%$%*;'#=G3% =#+ '#=+%J,=$% 4"* -":#'$'"#Y =#+ ?%$ $0'& &=;% -"#-%C$ +"%& ;=N% $0% S,+:;%#$ "4

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

$0%&% :*",#+& C%*;'$ ,& $" '#4%* $0=$ S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =*% '# 4=-$ G=&%+ ,C"# -"#-%C$&R V=#$ &%%;& $" +%-'+% $0% ;=$$%* &";%O0=$ J,'-N3? O0%# 0% &$=$%& '# d6HZ

..I C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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iO0%*%j =33 ",* * 8#'"#' C"O%*& =*% *%-"#-'3%+< &'#-% $0=$ '& $0% "#3? =3$%*#=$'M% 3%4$ $" ,& 4"* G*'#:'#: *%=&"# '#$" 0=*;"#? O'$0 '$&%34] _5NR 6ZAF.`R /0% *%&"3,$'"# C"'#$& ,&< '# +*=O'#: "# = *%&",*-% G%?"#+ $0% &%#&'1 G3%< $" $0% :%#%*=3 C"O%* "4 *%=&"# O0'-0 '& *%&C"#&'G3% 4"* $0% C*"+,-1 $'"# "4 *=$'"#=3 '+%=&R a,$ $0'& C"O%* "4 *%=&"# '& -";C3%;%#$%+< =& O% N#"O 4*"; $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 4'#% =*$< G? = C"O%* "4 ';=:'#=$'"# $" C*"+,-% =%&$0%$'- '+%=& _$0% 4=-,3$? "4 :%#',&`R \2"* O% ;,&$ S,+:% $0% G%=,$'4,3 #"$ =--"*+'#: $" -"#-%C$&< G,$ =--"*+'#: $" $0% C,*C"&'M% =$$,#%;%#$ "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"# $0=$ G*'#:& '$ '#$" 0=*;"#? O'$0 $0% C"O%* "4 -"#-%C$& =& &,-0] _5NR 6ZAFF`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` "4 =33 0'& C"O%*&Y =#+ 0%#-% $0% ;%#$'"#%+ &$=#+=*+ -=# G% &,CC3'%+ "#3? G? i;%=#& "4j $0=$ G? *%4%*%#-% $" O0'-0 O% =*% $" ;=N% =33 ",* -":#'$'M% C"O%*& 0=*;"#'k%< i+"'#:j O0'-0 '& $0% ,3$'1 ;=$% C,*C"&% :'M%# ,& G? $0% '#$%33':'G3% i%3%;%#$j "4 ",* #=$,*%R )$ '& '# $0'& O=? =3"#%< $""< $0=$ $0'& C,*C"&'M%#%&&< 4"* O0'-0 O% -=##"$ C*%&-*'G% =# "GS%-$'M% C*'#-'C3%< -=# G% G=&%+ * 8#'"#' "# = C*'#-'C3% $0=$ '& &,GS%-$'M% =#+ ?%$ ,#'M%*&=33? M=3'+R _5NR 6ZAFF`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

$=&$% M=3'+ 4"* %M%*?"#%< G%-=,&% _$0",:0 %=-0 C%*&"#]& S,+:;%#$ '& &'#:,3=* =#+ +'*%-$3? =--";C=#'%& 0'& '#$,'$'"#` $0% G=&'& $0=$ +%$%*1 ;'#%& $0% S,+:;%#$ 3'%&< C%*0=C&< '# $0% -"#-%C$ "4 O0=$ ;=? G% -"#&'+%*%+ $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$% "4 0,;=#'$?R _5NR 6ZAFE`

)# 4'#% =*$ O% -=# *%3=$% $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$% $" = C"&&'G'3'$? "4 C*"+,-$'"# '# $0% 4"*; "4 $0% =*$'&$]& -*%=$'"#R /0,& 4'#% =*$ 0%3C& ,& $" ;=N% = ;"*% -"#-*%$% &%#&% "4 $0% *%4%*%#-% $" $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% G? '33,&$*=$'#: 0"O = 4*%% -"#4"*;'$? $" *,3% -=# G% *%4%**%+ $"R /0% &$=#+1 =*+ G? O0'-0 4'#% =*$ '& S,+:%+ '& $0% ,3$';=$% C,*C"&% "4 ",* "O# #=$,*%< '$& *%4%*%#-% G%?"#+ $0% &%#&'G3%< $" = -"#+'$'"# O0'-0 O% -=# "#3? *=$'"#=33? =&&%*$ '# $0% '#$,'$'M% 4':,*% "4 e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` /0% 4'*&$ '+%= "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% '# :%#%*=3 %;%*:%& 4*"; $0% =#$'1 #";'%& "4 $0%"*%$'-=3 *%=&"#< $0% '+%= "4 $0% &=;% &,C%*&%#&'G3% =& $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% C,*C"&%& "4 4*%%+"; %;%*:%& 4*"; $0% =#$'#";'%& "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# =#+ #"O O% =*% :'M%# $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 #=$,*%]& C,*C"1 &'M%#%&& 4"* ",* -":#'$'M% C"O%*&R /0'& 3=&$ '+%= 0=& G%%# +%&-*'G%+ '# $0% 7%+,-$'"# '# $%*;& "4 $0% C*'#-'C3%& "4 -":#'$'"# '# :%#%*=3 _*%4%**=3 "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- $" :%#%*=3 -"#+'$'"#& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#:` =#+ =3&" '# *%3=$'"# $" $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =# ,#*%&"3M=G3% J,=**%3 O0'-0 &$'33 0=& *=$'"#=3 &%#&% _C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 =%&$0%$'- '+%=& O0'-0 O% -=# C%*-%'M% ;"&$ -3%=*3? '# 4'#% =*$`R 9,&$ =& O% ;,&$ =&&,;% $0=$ "GS%-$& "4 &%#&% =& =CC%=*=#-%& =*% '0/*( '4 O% =*% $" %(C3='# 0"O O% -=# +%$%*;'#% $0%'* 4"*;& * 8#'"#'< &" O% ;,&$ C*%&,CC"&% =# '0/*('32', '#$%*C*%$=$'"# "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& '# S,+1 :'#: $0% G%=,$'4,3 '# #=$,*% =#+ '# =*$ '4 $0% -*'$'J,% i"4 $=&$%j '& $" %(C3='# 0"O $0%*% -=# G% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% $0=$ -=# -3='; * 8#'"#' M=3'+'$? 4"* %M%*?"#% _?%$ O'$0",$ G=&'#: "# -"#-%C$& $0% C,*C"&'M%1 #%&& C*%&%#$%+ '# $0% "GS%-$`R _5NR 6ZA6.` V=#$ 0%*% -"##%-$& $0% *%&,3$ "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 O'$0 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% =#+ +%;"#&$*=$%& $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: ..K

,#'$? "4 0'& C*"-%+,*%R /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 $0,& -"#4"*;& '# :%#%*=3 $" $0% C*'#-'C3%& :'M%# '# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- =#+ $0% B#'/7@/0/# _=3$0",:0 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >,G3';% 3'N% $0% B#'/7@/0/# \M'"3=$%&] $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 '##%* &%#&%`R a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`R )# &?;G"3'- 0?C"$?C"&'& $0%*% '& = -"#-%C$ O0'-0 "#3? *%=&"# -=# $0'#N =#+ $" O0'-0 #" &%#&'G3% '#$,'$'"# -=# G% =+%J,=$%< =#+ $0'& -"#-%C$ '& &,CC3'%+ O'$0 =# '#$,'$'"# $0=$ S,+:;%#$ $*%=$& '# = O=? ;%*%3? =#=3":",& $" $0% C*"-%+,*% 4"33"O%+ '# &-0%;=$'k'#:Y 'R%R< $0% $*%=$;%#$ =:*%%& O'$0 $0'& C*"-%+,*% ;%*%3? '# $0% *,3% 4"33"O%+ *=$0%* $0=# '# $%*;& "4 $0% '#$,'$'"# '$&%34< =#+ 0%#-% ;%*%3? '# $%*;& "4 $0% 4"*; "4 $0% *%43%-$'"# *=$0%* $0=# '$& -"#$%#$R _5NR 6ZA6.` 5 &?;G"3'- %(0'G'$'"# 4,#-$'"#& G? S,+:;%#$ =CC3?'#: = -"#-%C$ $" = &%#&'G3% '#$,'$'"# _3'N% '# -":#'$'"# G,$ 0%*% "#3? 4"* $0% C,*C"&% "4 C3%=&,*%` O0'-0 '& $0%# -"##%-$%+ G? \$0% ;%*% *,3%] G? O0'-0 '$ *%43%-$& "# $0% 4'*&$ '#$,'$'"# O'$0 = &%-"#+ "#% \"4 O0'-0 $0% 4"*;%* "GS%-$ '& "#3? $0% &?;G"3] _5NR 6ZA6@`R /0'& '&< 4"* %(=;C3%< $0% O=? '# O0'-0 =33 =--",#$& "4 e"+ =*% 4"*;%+ _O0'-0 G*'#:& $0% #"$'"# "4 e"+ '# M%*? -3"&% -"#$=-$ O'$0 $0% ,&% "4 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 ",* S,+:;%#$`RH /0'& '& = &,GS%-$ $" O0'-0 O% O'33 #%-%&&=*'3? 0=M% $" *%$,*# '# +'&-,&&'#: $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C& G%$O%%# =%&$0%$'-&< $%3%"3":? =#+ %&-0=$"3":? G%3"OR /0% -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ =#+ *%3':'"# '& ;=+% G? V=#$ $0*",:0 ;"*=3'$?R \/0% ;"*=33? :""+ '& $0% '%2/((')'7(/ $0=$ $=&$% 0=& '# M'%O] _5NR 6ZA6A`< 'R%R $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G1 &$*=$%& O0'-0 O% 0=M% &%%# $" %('&$ '# $0*%% &%C=*=$% G,$ '#$%**%3=$%+ 4"*;& =*% ,#'$%+ '# $0% :%#%*=3 -"#-%C$'"# "4 $0% e""+< O0'-0 O% C*%&%#$ $" ",*&%3M%& ,#+%* $0% '#$,'$'M% 4"*; "4 e"+ _G,$ "#3? G? =#=3":? =#+ #"$ +%$%*;'#=$'M%3? =--"*+'#: $" -"#-%C$& O0'-0 3=$$%* O",3+ :'M% ,& $0% :*",#+ "4 &,C%*&$'$'"#`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.@E C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

T%*% O% 3%:'&3=$% %#$'*%3? 4"* ",*&%3M%& O'$0",$ $0% +%$%*;'#=$% 4"*-% "4 "GS%-$& 0=M'#: =#? C"O%*< S,&$ =& "--,*& '# $0% *=$'"#=3 C*"+,-$'"# "4 $0% ;"*=3 3=OR /0'& &%341;"M%;%#$ "4 $0% S,+:% '# = C,*% =,$"1=44%-$'"# *%3=$%& $0% &,GS%-$ $" = C"&&'G'3'$? O0'-0 ,#+%*3'%& =33 C0'3"&"C0'-=3 $0%"+'-?< M'kR< $0=$ $0% O"*3+ ;':0$ '# '$& 4"*; &,'$ $0% &,GS%-$]& C3%=1 &,*%R /0'& C"&&'G'3'$? *%4%*& $0% &,GS%-$ $" = C"&&'G3% -";;"# :*",#+ G%$O%%# 0'& "O# C"O%* =#+ $0=$ "*:=#'&=$'"# "4 = O0"3% ,#+%* 3=O& $0=$ O% -=33 #=$,*% O0'-0 '& O0=$ O% *%4%* $" '# $0% #"$'"# "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$%R /0'& C"&&'G3% -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# 3=O& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ $0% =,$"#";",& C"O%* "4 *%=&"# $0=$ '& :'M%# '# $0% C*%&%#$=$'"#& "4 $=&$% &,::%&$& :*",#+& 4"* = ,#'$? "4 4*%%+"; =#+ #=$,*% G? ;%=#& $0=$ O% +" #"$ ,#+%*&$=#+ '# "#% =G&"3,$% &,GS%-$1 "GS%-$R 2,*$0%* :*",#+& 4"* $0'& C"&$,3=$% =O='$ $0% +%M%3"C;%#$ '# $0% &%-"#+ 0=34 "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% "4 $0% =--",#$ "4 $%3%"3":?R /0,& 4=* O% 0=M% =--,;,3=$%+ *%=&"#& 4"* $0'#N'#: = -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% G%=,$'4,3 =#+ $0% :""+ O0'-0 '& C,*%3? &?;G"3'- =#+ #"$ = :*",#+ "4 &-0%;=$'&=$'"#R a"$0 $0% G%=,$'4,3 =#+ $0% :""+ =*% 3'N%+ +'*%-$3? '# $0%'* C,*% &$=$% _$0",:0 "#% '#M"3M%& #%-%&&=*? &%#&'G3% -"#+'$'"#& O0'3&$ $0% "$0%* &"=*& G%?"#+ $0%;`R a"$0 =*% 3'N%+ O'$0",$ G%'#: +%$%*;'#%+ G? =# '#$%*%&$ _%M%# $0",:0 $0% :""+ C*"+,-%& =# '#$%*%&$ +'*%-$3? =#+ $0% G%=,$'4,3 -=# C*"+,-% G"$0 +'*%-$ =#+ '#+'*%-$ '#$%*%&$&`R a"$0 =*% 4*%% =#+ =,$"#";",& C*%&%#$=$'"#& "4 $0% ;'#+ _$0% G%=,$'4,3 "4 $0% ';=:'#=$'"#]& "O# 3=O< $0% :""+ "4 $0% O'33]& 0=*;"#? O'$0 '$&%34`R a"$0 0=M% #%-%&&=*? ,#'M%*&=3 -3=';& _$0",:0 "#3? $0% :""+ 0=& +%$%*;'#=$% -"#&$'$,$'M% C*'#-'C3%& ,#+%*3?'#: $0%&% -3=';&`R /0% &?;G"3'- -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% G%=,$'4,3 =#+ $0% :""+ _&" $0=$ $0% 4"*;%* C"'#$& ,& $"O=*+& $0% 3=$$%*`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ $/0?,2'"%T !'%/ +#2 *%0 29/ +%2'%"1: .@.

.@@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0*",:0 $=&$% O% -=# 4*%%3? ;"M% $"O=*+& $0% ;"*=3 3=O O0'3&$ ;='#1 $='#'#: = *%3=$'"# $" $0% &%#&'G3% :'M%#& "4 ",* #=$,*%R /0'& 4=-$ =G",$ $=&$% ;=N%& '$& C*%&%#-% =--"*+'#: $" * 8#'"#' -"#+'$'"#& &%*%#+'C'$",&l )$ &0",3+ 4'#=33? G% *%;=*N%+ $0=$ $0% %(0'G'$'"# "4 $0% -"#-%C$ "4 =%&$0%$'- '+%=& +'+ #"$ %;%*:% 4"*$,'$",&3? '# $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 4'#% =*$ G,$ "4 #%-%&&'$? +,% $" ",* #%%+ $" %(C3='# $0% :*",#+& 4"* =CC*%-'=$'#: &,-0 O"*N "4 0,;=# =-$'M'$? C,*%3? =%&$0%$'-=33?R b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` *%J,'*%& $0% =-$'"# "4 \-,3$,*%]< O0'-0 -"#-%C$ '& *%4%**%+ $" "#3? '# C=&&'#: G? V=#$ '# dDE "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 =#+ O0'-0< O0%# +%M%3"C%+ =& = -"#+'$'"# "4 $0% -,3$'M=$'"# "4 $=&$%< O'33 $'% $0% #"$'"# "4 $=&$% %M%# ;"*% -3"&%3? $" $0=$ "4 ;"*=3'$? =3$0",:0 #"O ,#+%* -"#+'$'"#& "4 %($%*#=3 +%$%*;'#=$'"# O0"&% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 0=*;"#1 'k=$'"# O'$0 '##%* 4*%%+"; *%J,'*%& = -";C*%0%#&'"# "4 $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# %$0'-=3 =#+ C0?&'-=3 $%3%"3":?R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

4*%%+";< "4 +%$%*;'#=$'"# $0=$ '& C,*C"&'M% 4"* $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< =#+ '$ $%=-0%& ,& $" 3'N% %M%# "GS%-$& "4 &%#&% 4*%%3?< %M%# =C=*$ 4*"; &%#&'G3% -0=*;R _5NR 6ZA6F`

D

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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% /%3%"3":? "4 !*'$'J,%

.@F C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

4=* =& $0=$ ,#'$? &%*M%& =& = *,3% 4"* $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R

L%=&"# 0=& $0% ='; "4 C*%&%#$'#: $0% "*:=#'&=$'"# "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: ,#+%* = *,3%R /0'& *,3%< O0'-0 C%*;'$& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#1 +'#:]& "C%*=$'"#&< '&< V=#$ &$=$%&< \= (")',*( C*'#-'C3%] _5DFIfaDHD`R /0% 3=O "4 *%=&"# O0'-0 *%J,'*%& ,& $" C"&$,3=$% $0% &?&$%;=$'- ,#'$? "4 C*'#-'C3%& ,#+%* = *,3% O0'-0 +"%& #"$ +%*'M% 4*"; $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '& O0=$ %#=G3%& ,& $" 0=M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =$ =33R \)# "*+%*< $0%*%4"*%< $" &%-,*% =# %;C'*'-=3 -*'$%*'"# O% 0=M% #" "C$'"# &=M% $" C*%&,CC"&% $0% &?&$%;=$'- ,#'$? "4 #=$,*% =& "GS%-$'M%3? M=3'+ =#+ #%-%&&=*?] _5D6.f aDHK`R /0% #"$'"# "4 = &?&$%;=$'- ,#'$? "4 #=$,*% '& = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C*'#-'C3% O0'-0 O% -=# '+%#$'4? O'$0 *%=&"# '$&%34R 2*"; '$ O% +%*'M% :%#%*=3 *,3%& "4 C*"-%+,*% "* 3":'-=3 ;%$0"+&R /0%&% '#-3,+% 4,#+=;%#1 $=3 4"*;,3=$'"#& &,-0 =& b--=;]& L=k"* _5D6@faDIE` =#+ $0% M%*? C"&1 &'G'3'$? "4 =#? 3":'-=3 :%#%*= =& =CC3'-=G3% =$ =33 $" #=$,*% _5D6FfaDI@`R /0'& 4,#+=;%#$=3 $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C*'#-'C3% "4 C*'#-'C3%& _*%=&"# '$&%34` '& $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& =& '& '#+'-=$%+ G? V=#$]& *%4%*%#-% $" $0% #"$'"# "4 = G"+? \"4 N#"O3%+:% =#+ =# "*:=#'k%+] O0"3% _$%3%"3":? G%'#: $0% =$$%;C$ $" -";C*%0%#+ $0% M%*? C"&&'G'3'$? "4 "*:=#'k=$'"# =& ;,$,=3 '#$%*=-$'"# "4 O0"3%& =#+ C=*$&`R )$ +'*%-$& ,& '# =33 '#M%&$':=1 $'"# =#+ 4"*;,3=$'"# "4 3=O& =#+ %(-%%+& =#? %;C'*'-=3 &C%-'4'-=$'"# "4 *,3%& '# $0% '#$%*%&$ "4 C%*;'$$'#: &,-0 $" G% 4"*;,3=$%+ '# O'+%* =#+ O'+%* :%#%*=3'$? _5D6HfaDI6`R 5-$& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =*% =3O=?& +'M'&'M%< %M%* &%%N'#: $" 4'#+ 4,*$0%* +'44%*%#-%& G%$O%%# &C%-'%& $0,& C%*;'$$'#: %M%# :*%=$%* $?C%& "4 :%#%*= $" G% 4"*;,3=$%+Z L%=&"# $0,& C*%C=*%& $0% 4'%3+ 4"* $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:Z _.` $0*",:0 = C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% 9"1")/%/'2: "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ ,#+%* 0':0%* :%#%*=Y _@` $0*",:0 = C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% G*#'/2: "4 $0% 0";":%1 #%",& ,#+%* 3"O%* &C%-'%&Y =#+ _A` '# "*+%* $" -";C3%$% $0% &?&$%;=1 $'- ,#'$?< = 4,*$0%* 3=O< $0=$ "4 $0% *@@'%'2: "4 =33 -"#-%C$& ^ = 3=O O0'-0 C*%&-*'G%& $0=$ O% C*"-%%+ 4*"; %=-0 &C%-'%& $" %M%*? "$0%* G? :*=+,=3 '#-*%=&% "4 $0% +'M%*&'$?R _5D6H^IfaDI6^D` 2*"; $0%&% :%#%*=3 C*'#-'C3%& O% -=# -";C*%0%#+ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:]& :%#%*=3 "C%*=$'"# =& 3%:'&3=$'"#R /0% 3=O "4 0";":%#%'$? '& $0% 0':0%&$ "4 =33 3=O&< O0'-0 C%*;'$& $0% 4"*;,3=$'"# "4 =33 "$0%*& O0"&% M=*'%$? '# %(%-,$'"# '& C*%&%#$%+ '# $0% 3=O "4 &C%-'4'-=$'"#R /0%*% '& $0,& #" M"'+ '# $0% O0"3% &C0%*% "4 =33 C"&&'G3% -"#-%C$& \=#+ #"$0'#: -=# G% ;%$ O'$0] $0=$ +"%& #"$ -"#4"*; $" $0%&% *,3%& O0'-0 :'M%& ,& = C*%&,CC"&'1

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

_5DF6faDHA`

$'"# "4 = \,#'M%*&=3 0"*'k"#] _5D6KfaDIH`R /0%&% :%#%*=3 C*'#-'C3%& -=#< :'M%# $0%'* :%#%*=3 #=$,*%< "#3? G% 4"33"O%+ \=&?;C$"$'-=33?] =#+ =*% "4 \"GS%-$'M% G,$ '#+%$%*;'#=$% M=3'+'$?] G,$ +" &%*M% =& *,3%& 4"* C"&&'G3% %(C%*'%#-% _5DDAfaDK.`R e'M%# $0=$ $0%? =*% '+%=&< 0"O%M%*< #"$ -"#1 -%C$&< $0%? =*% #"$ &,&-%C$'G3% $" = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +%+,-$'"#< O0'-0 -=# "#3? G% C*"M'+%+ 4"* -"#-%C$& _G? 3'#N'#: $0% 3=$$%* $" '#$,'$'"#& O0'-0 *%J,'*%& ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $" -"##%-$ $" ';=:'#=$'"#`R L%=&"# 0=& ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: =& '$& "GS%-$ S,&$ =& ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $=N%& $0% +=$= "4 C,*% &%#&'G'3'$? =& '$& "GS%-$R a,$ O0'3&$ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: -=# $=N% $0% +=$= "4 C,*% &%#&'G'3'$? =& &';C3? :'M%# =#+ "C%*=$% "# $0%; O'$0 $0% 0%3C "4 $0% ;%+'=$'#: 4,#-$'"# "4 ';=:'#=$'"#< $0%*% '& #" &,-0 C"&&'G'3'$? 4"* *%=&"#R L%=&"# 0=& $" -"#&$'$,$% $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 '$& "GS%-$&R >'#-% *%=&"# -=##"$ *%3? "# ';=:'#=$'"# $" C*"M'+% '$ O'$0 =# '#$,'1 $'"# 4"* $0% O0"3% "C%*=$'"# "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: _O0'-0 3=$$%* %(-%%+& =#? &,-0 &%#&'G3% +%$%*;'#=$'"#` *%=&"#]& ,3$';=$% C"&&'G'3'$? '& G=&%+ "# \$0% 1*<'1?1 '# $0% +'M'&'"# =#+ ,#'4'-=$'"# "4 $0% N#"O3%+:% "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: ,#+%* "#% C*'#-'C3%] _5DD6faDKA`R /0'& C*"M'+%& = :%#1 %*=3 *,3% "* C*'#-'C3% "4 0";":%#%'$?< O0'-0 '& -";G'#%+ O'$0 $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 &C%-'4'-=$'"# '# = :%#%*=3 C*"-%+,*% "4 =44'#'$?R >,-0 *,3%& =#+ C*'#-'C3%& -=##"$ -"#&$'$,$% -"#-%C$& '# C=*$'-,3=* '#&$=#-%& =& $0% *,3%& $0%;&%3M%& 0=M% #" *%4%*%#-% $" '#$,'$'"# G%'#: +%*'M%+ C,*%3? 4*"; *%=&"# =3"#%R 5& $0% C*'#-'C3%& O% $0,& +%*'M% =*% #"$ $0%*%4"*% G=&%+ "# "GS%-$'M% :*",#+&< $0%? ;,&$ G% G=&%+ "# = C,*% &,GS%-$'M'$? "4 *%=&"# =#+ =& &,-0 +" #"$ &$*'-$3? +%&%*M% $0% $'$3% "4 C*'#-'C3%&R V=#$ &,::%&$& '#&$%=+ $0=$ O% +%&-*'G% $0%; =& \;=(';&]R /0% -"#43'-$& O0'-0 =*'&% '# $0% +'&C,$%& =#=3?&%+ '# $0% 5#$'#";'%& _"4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%` =*'&% 4*"; $=N'#: =& "GS%-$'M% C*'#-'C3%& O0=$ =*% '# 4=-$ ;=(';&R a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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B/(/"("): "@ =#'2'>?/ .@6

$0'#: '# :%#%*=3 =& -=,&'#: $0% "GS%-$ "4 %(C%*'%#-%R \U% +%-3=*%< 4"* '#&$=#-%< $0=$ $0% $0'#:& "4 $0% O"*3+ ;,&$ G% M'%O%+ *3 '@ $0%? *%-%'M%+ $0%'* %('&$%#-% 4*"; = 0':0%&$ '#$%33':%#-%] _5DH.faDKK`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` 0=& = &'#:3%< 0':0%&$ =#+ =331&,44'-'%#$ :*",#+ G%?"#+ '$&%34< #=;%3?< = &%341&,G&'&$%#$< "*'1 :'#=3< -*%=$'M% *%=&"#] _5DH@faHEE`R a,$ '$ '& ';C"*$=#$ O'$0 %=-0 "4 $0%&% '+%=& _;"&$ ';C"*$=#$3? O'$0 $0% -"&;"3":'-=3 "#%` $" *%;%;G%* $0=$ $0%? 0=M% "#3? $0% *%=3'$? "4Z \$0% &-0%;= "4 $0% *%:,3=$'M% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% &?&$%;=$'- ,#'$? "4 =33 N#"O3%+:% "4 #=$,*%] _5DHFfaHE@`R /0% 0':0%&$ ,#'$? O0'-0 -=# G% *%=-0%+ G? $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 '+%=& '& $0% $0%"3":'-=3 '+%= "4 e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faH.H^5DKAf aH@.``R U0'3&$ $0'& +=#:%* '& C*%-'&%3? O0=$ 0=& $" G% :,=*+%+ =:='#&$ '# $0% ;"&$ 4,#+=;%#$=3 &%#&% "4 /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7'=3%-$'-< $0% #"$'"# "4 -";C3%$% C,*C"&'M% ,#'$? '& \'#&%C=*=G3? G",#+ ,C O'$0 $0% M%*? #=$,*% "4 ",* *%=&"#] _5DK6faH@A`R /0'& 4,#+=;%#$=3 '+%= ,#+%*3'%& %M%*? C"&1 $,3=$'"# "4 = ,#'4'%+ &%#&% '# 3=O& O0'-0 &%#&%< 0"O%M%*< '& =G&"3,$%3? #%-%&&=*? $" G% C*%&,CC"&%+< =& O'$0",$ '$ O% O",3+ #"$ N#"O ",* O=? =G",$ '# #=$,*%R U0'3&$ $0% '+%= "4 e"+ '&< $0%*%4"*%< 4,#+=;%#$=33?

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.@D C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

O'$0",$ ;%=#& "4 "GS%-$'M% C*""4 '$ '& $0% '+%= O0'-0 C*"M'+%& ,& O'$0 $0% M%*? &%#&% =#+ C*"-%+,*% "4 O0=$ "GS%-$'M% C*""4 '& _#=;%3? &?&1 $%;=$'- =#+ #%-%&&=*? -"##%-$'"# G? ;%=#& "4 3=O`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e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faH@I`R

'-* 6;1)+&.@* I"&.& +, 3$-.5& U0'3&$ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% -"#-3,+%& O'$0 = *%:,3=$'M% S,&$'4'-=1 $'"# "4 $0% '+%= "4 =# '#$%33':%#$ G%'#: O0'-0 ,#'$%& '# '$&%34 $0% C,*1 C"&%& "4 $0% O"*3+< O% =*% $"3+ $0=$ \'$ ;,&$ G% = ;=$$%* "4 -";C3%$% '#+'44%*%#-% $" ,&] O0%# O% #"$% $0% ,#'$? "4 3=O& '# $0% O"*3+ \O0%$0%* O% &=? $0=$ e"+ '# 0'& O'&+"; 0=& O'33%+ '$ $" G% &" "* $0=$ #=$,*% 0=& O'&%3? =**=#:%+ '$ $0,&] _5DKKfaH@H`R /0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 '+%=& 0=M% = ;%*%3? *%:,3=$'M% ,&% '# &C%-,3=$'M% *%=&"# =#+< =& &,-0< =*% ;%*%3? 0%,*'&$'- '# $?C%R 2"* $0'& *%=&"# O% =*% '#4"*;%+ '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% $0=$ C,*% *%=&"#< C*"C%*3? ,#+%*&$""+< \-"#$='#& #"$0'#: G,$ *%:,3=$'M% C*'#-'C3%&] _5HE.faH@K`R /0% &-"C% "4 C,*% *%=&"# '& #"$< 0"O%M%*< %#$'*%3? +%4'#%+ G? $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R /0%*% O% =*% $"3+< 4"* %(=;C3%< $0=$< +,% $" $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# 4"*;& "4 '#$,'$'"# =#+ *=$'"#=3 '+%=& '# :%#%*=3< $0% '+%= "4 4*%%+"; '& -"#-%'M=G3% =& '# C*'#-'C3% #"$ -"#43'-$'#: O'$0 $0% *,3% "4 #=$,*=3 #%-%&&'$? '# $0% C0%#";%#=3 O"*3+R a,$ "#3? $0% ;%*% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0'& '+%= "4 4*%%+"; '& :'M%# '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%R )$ '& $0% $=&N "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"% $" C*"M'+% = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +%+,-1 $'"# "4 $0% '+%= "4 4*%%+"; =#+< =3"#: O'$0 $0'& '+%=< $" %($%#+ $0% -3=';& $0=$ -=# G% ;=+% =G",$ $0% $0%"3":'-=3 '+%= "4 e"+R /0'& '&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B/(/"("): "@ =#'2'>?/ .@H

$0% \%#':;= "4 $0% -*'$'-=3 C0'3"&"C0?]< 'R%R $0=$ \O% ;,&$ *%#",#-% $0% "GS%-$'M% *%=3'$? "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% ,&% "4 $0% -=$%:"*'%& '# &C%-,3=$'"# =#+ ?%$ -=# =$$*'G,$% $0'& *%=3'$? $" $0%; '# *%&C%-$ $" $0% "GS%-$& "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#] _5NR6Z6`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` ^ '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" '#+'-=$% $0% %(C=#&% "4 *%=&"#& "C%*=$'"#& =& =3&" '#-3,+'#: $0% *%=3; "4 =-$'"#R /0'& 3%=+& $" = C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% O'33 =& \$0% 4=-,3$? "4 C,*C"&%&] _5NR 6Z6I`R /0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% '&< $0%*%4"*%< = S,&$'4'-=$'"# "4 $0% C,*% O'33< $0=$ '&< "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 C,*C"&'M% =-$'"# O0'-0 '& O0=$ '& ;%=#$ G? ;"*=3'$?R T"O '& '$ C"&&'G3% 4"* ,& $" 0=M% C,*% C*=-$'-=3 C,*C"&%&X /0'& J,%&$'"# '& O0=$ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"% '& O*'$$%# $" =#&O%*R /0% C"&&'G'1 3'$? "4 =# '+%= "4 4*%%+"; '& =+;'$$%+ '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%V a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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.@I C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ B/(/"("): "@ =#'2'>?/ .@K

/0% +'44%*%#-%< $0%*%4"*%< G%$O%%# $0% 3=O& "4 = &?&$%; "4 #=$,*% $" O0'-0 $0% O'33 '& &,GS%-$ =#+ "4 = &?&$%; "4 #=$,*% O0'-0 '& &,GS%-$ $" = O'33 _=& 4=* =& $0% *%3=$'"# "4 $0% O'33 $" '$& 4*%% =-$'"#& '& -"#-%*#%+` *%&$& "# $0'&Z '# $0% 4"*;%*< $0% "GS%-$& ;,&$ G% $0% -=,&%& "4 $0% -"#-%C$'"#& O0'-0 +%$%*;'#% $0% O'33< =#+ '# $0% 3=$$%*< $0% O'33 '& $0% -=,&% "4 $0% "GS%-$&R !"#&%J,%#$3?< '# $0% 3=$$%* $0% -=,&=3'$? "4 $0% "GS%-$& 0=& '$& +%$%*;'#'#: :*",#+ &"3%3? '# $0% C,*% 4=-,3$? "4 *%=&"#< O0'-0 $0%*%4"*% ;=? G% -=33%+ C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#R _5NR 6ZFF` /0'& ;=N%& -3%=* '# O0=$ $0% '+%= "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"# -"#&'&$&R 2*%%+"; '& +%C%#+%#$ "# $0% -"#-%C$ "4 = -=,&=3'$? +'44%*%#$ 4*"; $0=$ O0'-0 :"M%*#& $0% C0%#";%#=3 O"*3+]& ;=$%*'=3R a,$ $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% -",3+ "#3? -";C*%0%#+ $0'& &%-"#+ $?C% "4 -=,&=3'$? #%:=1 $'M%3?R /0% ;"*=3 3=O :'M%& = C"&'$'M% +%4'#'$'"# $" $0'& #%O $?C% "4 -=,&=3'$?< \$0=$ "4 = *%=&"# O0'-0 +%$%*;'#%& $0% O'33 +'*%-$3? $0*",:0 $0% -"#+'$'"# "4 = ,#'M%*&=3 3=O4,3 4"*; "4 $0% ;=(';& "4 $0% O'33] _5NR 6ZFI`R L%=&"# $0%*%G? 0=& =# ';;=#%#$ ,&%R )$ G%-";%&< '# $0% 4'%3+ "4 %(C%*'%#-% \=# %44'-'%#$ -=,&% $0*",:0 )+%=&] _5NR 6ZFI`R W=$,*=33?< O% -=##"$ +%&-*'G% '# = $0%"*%$'-=3 ;=##%* 0"O $0'& "--,*&R a,$< :'M%# $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 #%-%&&'$? "4 =--",#$'#: 4"* $0% 4=-$ $0=$ O% ;=N% ;"*=3 S,+:;%#$&< $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0%&% S,+:;%#$& '& &,44'-'%#$3? %(C3='#%+ G? $0% C*%-%+'#: +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% G=&'- C"&&'G'3'$? "4 C,*% C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#R /0% -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# &,-0 *%=&"# =#+ =-$'"# '& O0=$ $0% \$?C'-] =#+ $0% B#'/7@/0/# &%$ ",$ _+'&-,&&%+ =G"M% '# !0=C$%*& . =#+ @`R U0'3&$ $0'& &,G&$=#$'=33? +%&-*'G%& $0% =:%#+= "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% $0% -%#$*=3 C*"G3%; "4 $0% 7'=3%-$'- $=N%& ,& "M%* $0% :*",#+< :'M%# '# $0% \5CC%#+'(] $" $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7'=3%-$'"4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%< 4*"; =#"$0%* =#:3%R U0%*%=& '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% O% O%*% 3%+ $" S,&$'4? $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 $0%"3":'-=3 '+%= G? *%4%*%#-% $" $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 $0'#N'#: 3=O& =& ,#'$%+ '# C*'#-'C3% '# $0% -"#-%C$ O0'-0 O",3+ =,$0"*'k% ,& $" &C%=N "4 = O"*3+ _O0'-0 '& O0=$ e"+ ;%=#&`< '# $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% $0% C*"G3%; '& =# %-"#";'-=3 "#% -"##%-$%+ $" $0% &%#&% "4 =# '#$%33':'G3% O"*3+ '# $0% "#3? *%&C%-$ '# O0'-0 O% -=# =$$*'G,$% "GS%-$'M% J,=3'$'%& $" '$< $0=$ '&< ;"*=33?R /0% "GS%-$'M% &$=$%;%#$ "4 4*%% -=,&=3'$? '#M"3M%& ,& '# -";C*%0%#+'#: =& *':0$ $0=$ O0'-0 -=# G% %(C*%&&%+ ,#'M%*&=33? G,$ $0=$ O0'-0 '& :""+ '# '$&%34 _-=33%+ G? V=#$ $0% 3?11?1 7"%?1` '&< "4 #%-%&&'$?< $0=$ O0'-0

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% G=&'- +'44%*%#-% G%$O%%# $0% C,*%3? '#$%33':'G3% O"*3+ =#+ $0% ;=$%*'=3 O"*3+ '& +%&-*'G%+ O'$0 C*%-'&% %-"#";? G? V=#$Z

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`< &" $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% '#$%33':'G3% O"*3+ =& =# "GS%-$'M%3? ;"*=3 O"*3+ *%J,'*%& =#"$0%* '+%= $" G% =++%+ $" '$& -"#-%C$Z $0% '+%= "4 e"+R \/0%*%4"*%< '$ '& ;"*=33? #%-%&&=*? $" =&&,;% $0% %('&$%#-% "4 e"+] _5NR 6Z.@6`R /0'& #%-%&&'$? "4 $0% '+%= "4 e"+ $" ;=N% ;%=#'#:4,3 $0% '+%= "4 = C,*%3? '#$%33':'G3% =#+ "GS%-$'M%3? ;"*=3 O"*3+ '& #"$ '$&%34 "GS%-$'M%R /0%*% -=##"$ G% * 0?2: $" G%3'%M% '# e"+< =& :*",#+& 4"* G%3'%4 -=# "#3? G% :'M%# $0%"*%$'-=33?R a,$ $0%*% '& = 3":'-=3 #%-%&&'$? $" =+;'$ $0=$ $0% '#$%33':'G3% O"*3+ '& = O"*3+ O0"&% -"#-%C$ '& '#-"#&'&$%#$ O'$0",$ &,-0 = G%3'%4 G%'#: =++%+ $" '$& #"$'"#R )# *%4%*%#-% $" $0% -";C*%0%#&'G'3'$? "4 =# "GS%-$ _$0% 0':0%&$ :""+` C3=-%+ G%4"*% ,& G? $0% ;"*=3 3=O< =#+ $0,& =& = C*=-$'-=3 #%%+ $0'& G%3'%4 '& @*'29T C,*% #*2'"%*( @*'29< \G%-=,&% C,*% *%=&"# =3"#% _G? '$& $0%"*%$'-=3 =& O%33 =& C*=-$'-=3 %;C3"?;%#$` '& $0% &",*-% 4*"; O0'-0 '$ &C*'#:&] _5NR 6Z.@D`R /0'& *=$'"#=3 4='$0 '# $0% "GS%-$ O0'-0 ;%%$& $0% C*=-$'-=3 #%%+ O% 4%%3 4"* $0% 3?11?1 7"%?1 '& = 4='$0 O0'-0 -";%& 4*"; $0% '#$%*#=3 #%-%&1 &'$'%& "4 $0% +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 C,*% *%=&"#R /0% 0=CC'#%&& "* O%331G%'#: O0'-0 -=# G% C*%&%#$%+ =& C*"C"*$'"#=$% $" :""+ =-$'"#& C%*4"*;%+ '& \=$$='#=G3% "#3? '# %$%*#'$?] _5NR 6Z.@I`R b#3? = 0"3?< G%#%4'-%#$ =#+ ";#'C"$%#$ O'33 -=# %#&,*% $0=$ $0% -"#+'$'"# "4 $0% 3?11?1 7"%?1 -=# G% ;%$R /0'& %#&,*%& $0=$ $0% '+%= "4 e"+ ,#'$%& $0% 3=O& "4 $0% '#$%33':'G3% O"*3+ =& '$ +'+ $0% 3=O& "4 $0% ;=$%*'=3 O"*3+R /0'& '& G%-=,&% e"+ '& $0% "#3? G%'#: O0" '& 0"3? _%#$'*%3? :"M%*#%+ G? ;"*=3 3=O& O'$0",$ &%#1 &'G3% -"#&'+%*=$'"#`< $0% "#3? G%'#: O0" '& G3%&&%+ _%#$'*%3? =$ C%=-% '# 0=*;"#? G%$O%%# :""+#%&& =#+ 0=CC'#%&&`< =#+ $0% "#3? G%'#: O0" '& O'&% _O0"&% N#"O3%+:% '& %#$'*%3? -"#-%#$*=$%+ "# :""+#%&&`R a? $0% =**=#:%;%#$ "4 $0%&% T% '& $0,& $0% 0"3? 3=O1:'M%* _=#+ -*%=$"*`< $0% G%#%4'-%#$ *,3%* _=#+ &,&$='#%*` =#+ $0% S,&$ S,+:%R \/0%&% $0*%% =$$*'G,$%& -"#$='# %M%*?$0'#: O0%*%G? e"+ '& $0% "GS%-$ "4 *%3':'"#< =#+ '# -"#4"*;'$? $" $0%; $0% ;%$=C0?&'-=3 C%*4%-$'"#& "4 $0%;&%3M%& =*'&% '# *%=&"#] _5NR 6Z.A.`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.AE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

a,$ =3$0",:0 $0% ;"*=3 O"*3+ $=N%& $0% -%#$*=3 C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% 0=*;"#? "4 '$& 3=O& '# = &'#:3% ,#'4?'#: '+%= O0'-0 %#=G3%& ,& $" &C%=N "4 = O"*3+ 4*"; $0% '+%= "4 e"+< '$ '& *=$'"#=3 G%'#:& '# :%#%*=3 O0" =*% %#+& '# $0%;&%3M%&R BM%*? *=$'"#=3 G%'#:< =& = &,GS%-$ "4 $0% ;"*=3 3=O< '& =# %#+ '# '$&%34R /0%? =*% #%M%* $" G% ,&%+ =& = ;%=#& $" &";%$0'#: O'$0",$ =$ $0% &=;% $';% G%'#: -";C*%0%#+%+ =& =# %#+R /0,& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 G%'#: :"M%*#%+ =#+ =-$'#: '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 = C,*%3? '#$%33':'G3% 3=O '& '$&%34 = C,*% ;'*=-3% "4 *%=&"#R

'-* =*"&+#& .$ A"& 9*5*&&"1( $+ A1.$* !"# $%&'&()# *+ !#4#*4*1&.54 /)012#3' )# &" 4=* =& G"$0 $0% 2'*&$ =#+ >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%& '#-3,+% M%*? +%-'&'M% +'&-,&&'"#& "4 C,*C"&'M% ,#'$? -,3;'#=$'#: '# $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 = 4'#=3 %#+ 4"* $0% O0"3%< '$ ;':0$ &%%; &";%O0=$ &,*C*'&'#: $0=$ V=#$ 4%3$ = #%%+ $" O*'$% = O0"3% -*'$'J,% O0'-0 '& 4"-,&%+ C,*%3? "# $%3%"3":?R a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a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b# *%$,*#'#: $" $0% 2'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# =4$%* *%=+'#: $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 &";% =&C%-$& "4 '$ O0'-0 ;':0$ "$0%*O'&% =CC%=* C,kk3'#: =*% -=C=G3% "4 -3%=* '#$%*C*%$=$'"#R 5& ) ;%#$'"#%+ '# !0=C$%* .< &%-$'"# ) "4 $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# '#M"N%& $0% $%*; \$%-0#'-=3] S,+:1 ;%#$R >,-0 S,+:;%#$& -"#-%*# \$0% *#2 "4 G*'#:'#: =G",$ &";%$0'#: $0=$ O% O=#$ $" %('&$] _5NR @EZ@EE` G,$ $0% $%*; $%-0#'-=3 S,+:;%#$ _"* \$%-0#'-]` '& =3&" -=C=G3% "4 ;"*% %($%#+%+ ,&%Z \) &0=33 0%#-%4"*$0 ,&% $0% $%*; $%-0#'- '# "$0%* -=&%& $""< #=;%3?< O0%*% O% ;%*%3? J?0)/

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B/(/"("): "@ =#'2'>?/ .A.

i-%*$='#j "GS%-$& "4 #=$,*% *3 '@ $0%? O%*% ;=+% C"&&'G3% $0*",:0 =*$] _5NR @EZ@EE`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`R )# "$0%* O"*+&< $0% *,3% O",3+ G% "#% "4 = C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 #=$,*% \4"* $0% &=N% "4 ",* =G'3'$? $" -":#'k% #=$,*%] =#+ = -"#-%C$ "4 $0'& &"*$ '& \$0% -"#-%C$ "4 %(C%*'%#-% *3 * 3:32/1 '% 2/#13 "@ /18'#',*( (*.3X _5NR @EZ@EA`R /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% "#3? S,&$'4'%& $0% -"#-%C$ "4 %(C%*'%#-% =& = &?&$%; "4 $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 3=O& O'$0",$ +%;"#&$*=$'#: $0=$ %;C'*'-=3 3=O& =*%< '% 29/'# 8*#2',?(*#'2:< #%-%&&=*?R /0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 3=O& +%+,-%+ '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% -",3+< '# C*'#-'C3%< =CC3? $" = :*%=$ M=*'%$? "4 +'&$'#-$ O"*3+& =#+ 0=M% #" &C%-'=3 =CC3'-=$'"# $" $0% C0%#";%#=3 O"*3+ O% 0=CC%# $" +'&-"M%* ",*&%3M%& '#R a,$ ,#3%&& %;C'*'-=3 3=O& -=# G% +%;"#&$*=$%+ $" G% '# 4=-$ 3=O13'N% '# -0=*=-$%*< 'R%R $" 0=M% = #%-%&1 &=*? &$*,-$,*%< $0%# O% O'33 G% 4=-%+ #"$ O'$0 = ,#'$? "4 %(C%*'%#-% G,$ O'$0 = &%$ "4 $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 3=O& O0'-0 +" #"$ +%$%*;'#% 0"O $0% C=*$'-,3=* 3=O& ;,&$ O"*N $" -*%=$% =#+ ;='#$='# = 0=*;"#? '# ",* O"*3+R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& S,+:;%#$ =+"C$& =& =# =&&,;C$'"# \= 4"*;=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 #=$,*%] O0'-0 3%=+& '$ $" C*"+,-% '$& "O# -"#-%C$Z \$0% -"#-%C$ "4 #=$,*% =& *#2] _5NR @EZ@EF`R /0'& C*'#-'C3% +"%& #"$ -"#$='# =#? -":#'$'"# "4 "GS%-$& "* C*"M'+% ,& O'$0 = #%O "GS%-$'M% 3=O G,$ '& = 0%,*'&$'- C*'#-'C3% 4"* S,+:;%#$& "4 #=$,*%R /0'& -"#&'+%*=$'"# -3%=*3? *%$,*#& ,& $" $0% +'&-,&&'"#& =3*%=+? $*%=$%+ '# C=*$ '# $0% 5CC%#+'( $" $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7'=3%-$'- "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R >" $0% C*"-%+,*% "4 $%-0#'-=33? *=$0%* $0=# &-0%;=$'-=33? S,+:'#: =CC%=*=#-%& +%=3& O'$0 $0%; \'# $%*;& "4 = C*"-%+,*% $0=$ '& ,#'M%*&=3 G,$ =3&" '#+%$%*;'#=$%] _5NR @[email protected]`R U% =+"C$ $0% C*%&,CC"1 &'$'"# $0=$ #=$,*% 0=& = C,*C"&'M% =**=#:%;%#$ 4"* $0% G%#%4'$ "4 ",* S,+:;%#$ =#+ $0,&Z \S,+:;%#$ '$&%34 ;=N%& * 8#'"#' $0% 2/,9%', "@ %*2?#/ i=j C*'#-'C3% 4"* '$& *%43%-$'"#] _5NR @[email protected]`R 5 &,GS%-$'M% 3=O '& $0,&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.A@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

*%43%-$%+ "# '# "*+%* $" 0=*;"#'&% '$ O'$0 #=$,*=3 3=O& '# :%#%*=3R /0'& '& $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C*"-%+,*% '#M"3M%+ '# =33 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ =#+ &$=$'#: '$ &" -3%=*3? ;=N%& $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 ;,-0 ;"*% C%*&C'-,",&R a,$< O0%# O% =++ $" $0'& 4"*;=3 3":'-=3 -"#&'+%*=$'"# "4 $0% -"#-%C$ "4 = C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 #=$,*%< O% 0=M% $" C=&& "M%* $" $%3%1 "3":'-=3 -"#&'+%*=$'"#& _O0'-0 =*% '# 4=-$ #%-%&&=*'3? '#M"3M%+ '# =33 #"#1C,*% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$&`R T"O%M%*< '# "*+%* $" +'&$'#:,'&0 G%$O%%# $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ =#+ '$& 3":'-< '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" -"#$*=&$ $O" +'44%*%#$ O=?& '# O0'-0 $0'& S,+:;%#$ *%3=$%& $" $0% =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 $0% ;=#'4"3+ _';=:'#=$'"#` =#+ $0% -";C*%0%#&'"# "4 '$ =& = &?#$0%$'- ,#'$? _,#+%*1 &$=#+'#:`R U'$0 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ O% #"$% = ;%*% ;,$,=3 0=*;"#? "4 ';=:'#=$'"# =#+ ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '# = &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 *%43%-$'M% C3%=&,*%R a,$ O'$0 $0% 3":'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ O% -=# O'$#%&& = -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# %;C'*'-=3 3=O& =#+ -"#-%C$& G*",:0$ '#$" *%3=$'"# O'$0 *%=&"#]& +%;=#+ 4"* = &?&$%; $" :'M% ,& $0% #"$'"# "4 = \#=$,*=3 C,*C"&%] '# =++'$'"# $" $0% =%&$0%$'=CC*%-'=$'"# "4 = \#=$,*=3 4"*;]R /0'& #"$'"# "4 = \#=$,*=3 C,*C"&%] '& 4'*&$ C*%&%#$%+ '# d)o "4 $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# _\b# /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:'#:]`R 5$ $0% G%:'##'#: "4 $0'& &%-$'"# V=#$ *%&$=$%& $0% -"#$*=&$ G%$O%%# $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 "C%*=$'"# "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$Z a? = @"#1*( $%-0#'- "4 #=$,*% ) ;%=#$ $0% C,*C"&'M%#%&& $0=$ #=$,*% 0=& '# '#$,'$'"#Y G? #/*( $%-0#'- ) ;%=# $0% C,*C"&'M%#%&& '$ 0=& '# $%*;& "4 -"#-%C$&R R R R /0% *%=3 $%-0#'- "4 #=$,*% i'#M"3M%&j $0% -"#1 -%C$ "4 $0'#:& =& #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%&< 'R%R< =& $0'#:& O0"&% '##%* C"&&'1 G'3'$? C*%&,CC"&%& = C,*C"&% =#+ 0%#-% = -"#-%C$ $0=$ '& $0% ,#+%*3?'#: -"#+'$'"# "4 $0% -=,&=3'$? i*%&C"#&'G3%j 4"* $0%'* C*"+,-1 $'"#R _5NR @EZ@A@` /0% *%=3 $%-0#'- $0=$ '& '#M"3M%+ '# $0% 3":'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '& -"##%-$%+ $" $0% M%*? C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0'#:& "4 #=$,*%R /0'& %3%;%#$ "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '& #"$< $0%*%4"*%< = C*"+,-$ "4 $0% -";C3%$% =,$"#1 ";? "4 S,+:;%#$]& "O# C"O%* =& O=& $0% -=&% O'$0 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'"#< G,$ =3O=?& $=N%& '$& ;=$%*'=3 4*"; %3&%O0%*%< 'R%R 4*"; $0% C0%#";%#=3 O"*3+ =& *%M%=3%+ G? $0% C"O%* "4 -"#-%C$& '# :%#%*=3R /0'& C"O%* '& O0=$ O% $%*; $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R a,$ *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$< '# '$& 3":'-=3 "C%*=$'"#< +"%& #"$ ;%*%3? +%C%#+ "# $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< '$ =3&" *%3=$%& $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $" =# )+%= "4 *%=&"#< O0'-0 '& O0=$ $0% #"$'"# "4 C,*C"&% '&R L%=&"# '# '$& "O# C,*% "C%*=$'"#< 0"O%M%*< -=# "#3? %(C",#+ C,*C"&% =& '#$%#$'"#R 2"* = C,*C"&% $" "--,* =& &,-0 '# #=$,*%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B/(/"("): "@ =#'2'>?/ .AA

=#+ 4"* '$& C"&&'G3% -=,&=3'$? $" 0=M% = &%#&% "$0%* $0=# $0% C,*%3? &,C%*&%#&'G3% "#% "4 ;"*=3'$?< O% *%J,'*% $0% &C%-'4'- -"#-%C$ "4 *%43%-1 $'M% S,+:;%#$]& "O# 3":'-=3 "C%*=$'"# O0'-0 '& $0=$ "4 \@'%*( ,*?3/3 '# #=$,*%] _5NR @EZ@AF`R 5& $0'& -"#-%C$ "4 = N'#+ "4 -=,&=$'"# $0=$ '& =&&,;%+ O'$0'# #=$,*% '$&%34 -=##"$ G% :'M%# +%$%*;'#=$'M%3? _=& $0'& O",3+ "M%*$,*# $0% O0"3% "4 $0% *%&,3$& "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%`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`R /0% *%=&"# 4"* $0'& =&&%*$'"# '& $0=$ &,-0 *,3%& \-"#-%*# #"$0'#: G,$ $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0'#:& =--"*+1 '#: $" -"#-%C$& "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6Z.H@`R /%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$& =*% -"#1 -%*#%+ %#$'*%3? O'$0 "GS%-$& "4 #=$,*% =#+ =*% $0,& C=*$ "4 $0%"*%$'-=3 C0'3"&"C0?< =3G%'$ = &C%-'=3 C=*$ '# #"$ G%'#: +%$%*;'#=$'M%R >%-$'"# @ "4 $0% &%-"#+ )#$*"+,-$'"# *%;'#+& ,& "#-% =:='# "4 $0% :,34 G%$O%%# $0% -"#-%C$ "4 #=$,*% =#+ $0=$ "4 4*%%+";< =#+ '# +"'#: &" =&&%*$& $0=$ \'$ ;,&$ G% C"&&'G3% $" $0'#N "4 #=$,*% =& G%'#: &,-0 $0=$ $0% 3=O4,3#%&& '# '$& 4"*; O'33 0=*;"#'k% O'$0 =$ 3%=&$ $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 i=-0'%M'#:j $0% C,*C"&%& $0=$ O% =*% $" =-0'%M% '# #=$,*% =--"*+'#: $" 3=O& "4 4*%%+";] _5NR 6Z.HD`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.AF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ B/(/"("): "@ =#'2'>?/ .A6

/0'& '& $0% ,3$';=$% &%#&% "4 $0% O0"3% /0'*+ !*'$'J,%< $" C*"M'+% $0'& ,#'$? "4 $0% $O" &,C%*&%#&'G3%&R /0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C*'#-'C3% "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& O0'-0 '& $0% $*=#&-%#1 +%#$=3 C*'#-'C3% "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '& O0=$ O'33 G*'#: =G",$ $0'& ,#'$? G%$O%%# $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3%&R /0'& C*'#-'C3% C*%&-*'G%& 4"* S,+:;%#$ = 3=O 4"* *%43%-$'"# "# #=$,*%Z /0'& 3=O -",3+ G% -=33%+ $0% (*. "@ 29/ 38/,'@',*2'"% "@ %*2?#/ '# $%*;& "4 '$& %;C'*'-=3 3=O&R )$ '& = 3=O $0=$ S,+:;%#$ +"%& #"$ -":#'k% * 8#'"#' '# #=$,*%< G,$ $0=$< '# +'M'+'#: #=$,*%]& ,#'M%*&=3 3=O&< '$ =&&,;%& * 8#'"#' O0%# '$ &%%N& $" &,G"*+'#=$% $" $0%; = +'M%*&'$? "4 C=*$'-,3=* 3=O&< &" $0=$ $0% +'M'&'"# O'33 0=M% =# "*+%* $0=$ ",* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: -=# -":#'k%R _5NR 6Z.ID` b#3? G? =CC3?'#: $0'& C*'#-'C3% $" #=$,*% -=# O% '#M%&$':=$% '$ =$ =33R a,$ $0'& C*'#-'C3% '& C,*%3? 4"*;=3 =#+ G%3"#:& $" $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ *=$0%* $0=# '$& 3":'- _5NR 6Z.KA`R b# $0% "$0%* 0=#+< O0%# *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '& ,&%+ $%3%"3":'-=33?< '$ '#+'-=$%& \$0% -"#+'$'"#& ,#+%* O0'-0 &";%$0'#: _%R:R =# "*:=#'k%+ G"+?` '& $" G% S,+:%+ '# $%*;& "4 = C*'#-'C3% "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6Z.KF`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k% #=$,*% "#3? =& =CC%=*=#-%< =#+ 0%#-% =$ $0% &=;% $';% C"'#$& $" = &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$% "4 #=$,*%Y G,$ '$ 3%=M%& $0'& &,G&$*=$% O0"33? ?%0/2/#1'%/0R 9,+:;%#$< $0*",:0 '$& * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3% "4 S,+:'#: #=$,*% '# $%*;& "4 C"&&'G3% C=*$'-,3=* 3=O& "4 #=$,*%< C*"M'+%& #=$,*%]& &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$% _O'$0'# =& O%33 =& ",$&'+% ,&` O'$0 0/2/#1'%*7'('2: 7: 29/ '%2/((/,2?*( 8"./#R a,$ *%=&"#< $0*",:0 '$& * 8#'"#' C*=-$'-=3 3=O< :'M%& $0'& &=;% &,G&$*=$% 0/2/#1'%*H 2'"%R _5NR 6Z.KD`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

4*"; ",* O=? "4 $0'#N'#: '# $%*;& "4 C*'#-'C3%& "4 #=$,*% $" ",* O=? "4 $0'#N'#: '# $%*;& "4 C*'#-'C3%& "4 4*%%+";R _5NR 6Z.HD`

9,+:;%#$ :'M%& = &%#&% $" $0% =CC3'-=$'"# $" #=$,*% "4 *%=&"#]& C*';% C*'#-'C3% "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& G? &%$$'#: ,C $0% #"$'"# "4 4'#=3 -=,&%& =& "C%*=$'M% O'$0'# $0% *%=3; "4 #=$,*%R U% O'33 4'#+ ;"*=3 J,=3'$'%& '# #=$,*% =#+ #=$,*=3 J,=3'$'%& '# ;"*=3'$? =#+ -";C*%0%#+ $0% G=&'- ,#'$? "4 $0% $O" *%=3;& '# $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 &,C%*&%#&'G3% C"&&'G'3'$'%& O0'-0 ,#+%*3'% =33 S,+:'#:R /0%*% '& = -"+= $" $0%&% $O" )#$*"+,-$'"#& $" $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 '# dD. "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2< O0'-0 &%-$'"# C*%-%+%& $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$R V=#$ =:='# &$*%&&%& 0%*% $0=$ $0% '#$*"+,-$'"# "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$ '#$" ",* '#M%&$':=$'"# "4 #=$,*% '& C*"G3%;=$'- =#+ '& G=&%+ "# =#=3":? O'$0 $0% -=,&=3'$? "4 4*%%+"; O'$0",$ C*%&,;'#: $" /<8(*'% \#=$,*% '# $%*;& "4 $0=$ -=,&=3'$?] _5NR 6ZADE`R T"O%M%*< '4 O% +'+ #"$ '#$*"+,-% &,-0 = 4"*; "4 S,+:;%#$ '#$" ",* '#M%&$':=$'"# "4 #=$,*% O% O",3+ 0=M% $" =CC*"=-0 #=$,*% =& = ;%*% ;%-0=#'&;< $0=$ '&< =& '4 '$ +'+ #"$ -"#$='# C,*C"&%&R /0'& '& $0% %**"* O0'-0 '& C*";"$%+ G? %;C'*'-'&;< O0%*%=& $0% *%M%*&% %**"* "4 -";C*%1 0%#+'#: #=$,*% =& =# %#$'*%3? '#$%#$'"#=3 C*"+,-$'"# '& C*";"$%+ G? *=$'"#=3'&;R a%$O%%# $0%&% $O" &0"=3& $0% 7'=3%-$'- "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:1 ;%#$ O'33 0=M% $" #=M':=$%R b#3? '4 O% -";C*%0%#+ $0% C"&&'G'3'$? =#+ #%-%&&'$? "4 $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 "C%*=$'"#& "4 S,+:;%#$ =*% O% %#:=:'#: '# !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0?R

'-* D*#*1"7 8*&$-*$.5 .& " D*#*1"7 '*7*+7+0( 533 "4 V=#$]& -*'$'-=3 O"*N& '#-3,+% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $%3%"3":?< =& ) 0=M% S,&$ +%;"#&$*=$%+R /0'& 4=-$ '& *=*%3? #"$%+ =#+ $0% &%-"#+ 0=34 "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% '& *=*%3? *%=+ =& = -"#&%J,%#-%R /0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# $0% =%&$0%$'-& "4 $0% $0*%% -*'$'J,%& =#+ $0%'* *%&C%-$'M% +%3'#%=$'"#& "4 $%3%"3":? &0",3+ G% 4'*;3? &$=$%+ '# C*'#-'C3% '# "*+%* $" ;=N% -3%=* ;? -"#$%#$'"# $0=$ $0% !*'$'-=3 &?&$%; *%&$& "# =#+ %(C",#+& = e%#%*=3 5%&$0%$'- O0'-0 '& =3&" = e%#%*=3 /%3%"3":?R /0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%]& /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- :'M%& $0% G=&'- * 8#'"#' G=&'& "4 '#$,'$'"# O0'-0 '& $O"14"3+ =#+ #%-%&&=*? 4"* -";C*%0%#&'"# "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 4"*;,3=$'#: = *%3=$'"# $" #=$,*%R a,$ S,&$ =& $0% /*=#&1 -%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- C*"M'+%& $0% :%#%*=3 -"#+'$'"#& "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 = /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5#=3?$'-< $0% 5CC%#+'( $" $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7'=3%-1 $'- &%$& ",$ $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 &?&$%;=$'- -";C*%0%#&'"# "4 $0% *,3%& C*"M'+%+ '# $0% 5#=3?$'- =& +%C%#+%#$ ,C"# = &-0%;=$'&; "4 *%=&"#R /0% G=&'& 4"* $0'& -3='; '& $0=$ $0% 5%&$0%$'- *%M%=3& $0=$ $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 '#$,'$'"# +%C%#+ "# = #"$'"# "4 = O0"3% G%'#: #%-%&&=*'3? -";1 C*%0%#+%+ O0%#%M%* =#?$0'#: '& C*%&%#$%+ $" '#$,'$'"# =$ =33R U%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.AD C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

-=##"$ -"#-%'M% "4 &";%$0'#: "--,C?'#: = C3=-% '# &C=-% ,#3%&& O% -"#-%+% $0=$ &C=-% '& "#% =#+ '#+'M'&'G3% _=#+ &';'3=*3? O'$0 $';%`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e"+ '# $0% 7'=3%-$''& '#$*"+,-%+ $" C*%&%#$ = &-0%;= "4 0=CC'#%&& O0'-0 O'33 S,&$'4? = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 %-"#";? "4 0=CC'#%&& =#+ :""+#%&& '# $0% C,*C"&'M% 4':,*% "4 $0% 3?11?1 7"%?1R 5& $0'& 4':,*% '& $0% &,;;'$ "4 $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%< $0'& O"*N< 3'N% $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%< '#$%#+& $" +%;"#&$*=$% = #%-%&&=*? ,#'$? "4 =%&$0%$'-& =#+ $%3%"3":?R /0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% '& $0% &,;;'$ "4 V=#$]& O0"3% !*'$'-=3 %#+%=M",* =#+ '& C*%&%#$%+ G? 0'; =& &,-0 _5NR 6Z.HE`R )$ '& #"$ 4"*$,'$",& $0=$ $0'& O"*N &0",3+ $0%*%4"*% G% +'M'+%+ '#$" $O" 0=3M%& O0'-0 =*% ,#'4'%+ '# C*'#-'C3% ,#+%* $0% 0%=+'#: "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&&R /0% $O" )#$*"+,-$'"#& $" $0% O"*N =:*%% $0=$ O0=$ '& C*%&%#$%+ '# '$ '& = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C*'#-'C3% "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& O0'-0 '& :'M%# '# $O" 4"*;&< 4'*&$ 4"*;=33? _'# $0% =%&$0%$'-` =#+ $0%# ;=$%*'=33? _'# $0% $%3%"13":'-`R )$ O'33 G% ;? $=&N '# $0% #%($ -0=C$%*& $" =&&%&& $0% -0=33%#:%& O0'-0 0=M% G%%# C"&%+ $" $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% O"*N &,--%%+'#: '# C*%&%#$'#: = G=&'- ,#'$? "4 3":'=#+ =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ B/(/"("): "@ =#'2'>?/ .AH

H

/0% ;='# C"'#$ "4 $0% 5#=3?$'- "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$ '& $" %(C",#+ $0% #"$'"# "4 = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%R /0'& "--,*& '#'$'=33? '# dD@ G? -"#$*=&$1 '#: 4"*;=3 O'$0 ;=$%*'=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&&< =#+ -"#$'#,%& '# d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

N+12"7 "#4 =*7"$.@* 6;1)+&*&C A-"$ '*7*+7+0( .& 9+$ /0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 4"*;=3 C,*C"&%& '# dD@ '& =# ';C"*$=#$ G*'+:% G%$O%%# =%&$0%$'- =#+ ;=$%*'=3 C,*C"&%&R U0=$ +'&$'#:,'&0%& = 4"*;=3 C,*C"&% '& $0=$ '$ '& \"GS%-$'M% =#+ '#$%33%-$,=3] _5NR 6ZAD@`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`< 0%*% O% 4"-,& "# '$ =& C*"+,-$'M% "4 = C,*C"&'M%#%&& O0'-0 '& #"$ G=&%+ "# C3%=&,*% _=& '& =%&$0%$'- C,*C"&'M%#%&&` #"* "# = -"#-%C$ "4 #=$,*% _=& '& $%3%"3":?`R .AI

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% B(C"&'$'"# "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$&

U0'3&$ $0'& 4"*; "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& '& '# 4=-$ $0% C*"+,-$ "4 = -"#&$*,-$'"# _O0'-0 =*:,;%#$ %-0"%& $0=$ "4 $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'-`< $0'& -"#&$*,-$'"# '& "#% O0'-0 +*=O& ",$ $0% #=$,*% "4 $0% 4':,*% '$&%34R a%-=,&% = 4"*; "4 C*%&%#$=$'"# ^ O0'-0 '& O0=$ = 4':,*% '& ^ *%C*%&%#$& = +'M'&'"# "4 &C=-% '$ +"%& #"$ #%%+ $" +%&-*'G% =# %('&$%#$ &0=C% =#+ $0,& +"%& #"$ #%%+ $" G% -"#-%C$,=3'&%+R /0'& '& $0% *%=&"# O0?< =& V=#$ ;%#$'"#&< $0% 4':,*%& "4 ;=$0%;=$'-& =#+ :%";%$*? =*% "4$%# =&&';'3=$%+ $" $0% C,*% S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =#+ +%&-*'G%+ =& G%=,$'4,3R a,$< O0%*%=& '# =# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$< C3%=&,*% =*'&%& $0*",:0 = ;%*% 4*%% C3=? "4 ",* -":#'$'M% C"O%*&< ;=$0%;=$'-& =& $0% C*"+,-$ "4 =# '#$%33%-$,=3 S,+:;%#$ \*%M%=3& +'&$'#-$3? =# "GS%-1 $'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&&< 'R%R = &,'$=G'3'$? 4"* =33 &"*$& "4 C,*C"&%& _"4 '#4'#'$% +'M%*&'$?`] _5NR 6ZADD`R /0,&< '# =CC*"(';=$'#: $" =# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%< O0=$ &,-0 =# '#$%33%-$,=3 S,+:;%#$ '& -3"&%&$ $" '& =# )+%=3 "4 G%=,$? #"$ = C,*% S,+:;%#$ "4 $=&$%< O0'-0 '& O0? V=#$ &$=$%& $0=$ '$ O",3+ G% G%$$%* $" &C%=N "4 \$0% 4':,*%]& #/(*2'G/ 8/#@/,2'"%X _5NR 6ZADD`R 2"*;=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&& +"%& #"$ '#M"3M% = -"#-%C$ "4 =# "GS%-$ G,$< ,#3'N% = C,*% =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$< '$ +"%& *%4%* ,& $" C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 $0% -"#&$*,-$'"# '# '$& %(0'G'$'"#R ['N% =# )+%=3 "4 G%=,$? '$ &,::%&$& = $0",:0$ "4 C%*4%-$'"#R /0'& &,::%&$& G? %3';'#=$'"# $0=$ $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$ ;,&$ G% = N'#+ "4 S,+:;%#$ =G",$ ;=$%*'=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&&< $0=$ '&< "4 $0% -"#-%C$ "4 $0% "GS%-$R 5$ $0% "C%#'#: "4 dDA V=#$ G%:'#& $" ;=N% -3%=*%* $0% #=$,*% "4 &,-0 = C,*C"&'M%#%&&Z b#3? '# "#% -=&% +"%& %(C%*'%#-% 3%=+ ",* C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$ $" $0% -"#-%C$ "4 = C,*C"&'M%#%&& $0=$ '& G"$0 "GS%-$'M% =#+ ;=$%*'=3 i"* *%=3j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` "* G%#%4'$ _4"* =#? "$0%* -*%=$,*%` =#+ $0'& &%-"#+ C,*C"&'M%#%&& '& ;%*%3? *%3=$'M%< O0%*%=& $0% 4'*&$ '& =# '#$*'#&'- C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 $0% #=$,*=3 G%'#:R _5NR 6ZADD^H`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%23 .AK

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`R /0% ,&%1 4,3#%&& "4 &";%$0'#: $" &";%$0'#: %3&% '& "#3? *%=33? = C,*C"&% '4 O% 0=M% :*",#+& 4"* =&&,;'#: $0=$ $0%*% '& &";%$0'#: #%-%&&=*? '# $0% 3=$$%*R a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dDD =#+ O'33 G% *%$,*#%+ $" '# $0% 7'=3%-$'-]& =--",#$ "4 = +'44%*%#-% G%$O%%# C,*C"&%& "4 #=$,*% =#+ #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%&R U0=$ O% 0=M% %&$=G3'&0%+< 0"O%M%*< '& $0=$ $0% &$,+? "4 $%3%"3":? ;,&$ '#M"3M% -"#&'+%*=$'"# "4 ;=$%*'=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&& =#+ O'$0'# $0'& -"#&'+%*=$'"# =$ &";% &$=:% = +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# '#$*'#&'- =#+ *%3=$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& ;,&$ G% '#-"*C"*=$%+R

'-* 9"$;1* +, 9"$;1"7 6;1)+&*& V=#$]& *%=3 +'&-,&&'"# G%:'#& '# dDFR T% $%33& ,& $0=$ $" -"#&'+%* &";%1 $0'#: = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% '& $" &=? $0=$ $0% -=,&=3'$? $0=$ :=M% *'&% $" '$ ;,&$ G% &",:0$< #"$ '# $0% ;%-0=#'&; "4 #=$,*%< \G,$ '# = -=,&% O0"&% =G'3'$? $" =-$ '& +%$%*;'#%+ G? -"#-%C$&] _5NR 6ZADK`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`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.FE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0% =CC%=*=#-% "4 &,-0 = C0%#";%#"# =& = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% -*%=$%& ,#'J,% C*"G3%;&R Q#3%&& O% -=# ,$'3'&% $0% C*"-%+,*%& "4 $0% ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#:< $0% 4"*; "4 O0=$ '& =CC*%0%#+%+ O'33 #"$ G% -":#'k%+ ,#+%* 3=O =#+ '4 $0'& "--,*& '$& %('&$%#-% =& = #=$,*=3 4"*; O'33 '#M"3M% = -"#$*=+'-$'"# =&Z \*%=&"#< %M%# '4 '$ $*'%& $" :='# '#&':0$ "#3? '#$" $0% -"#+'$'"#& =$$=-0%+ $" $0% C*"+,-$'"# "4 = #=$,*=3 C*"+,-$< ;,&$ =3O=?& -":#'k% #"$ "#3? $0% C*"+,-$]& 4"*; G,$ $0% 4"*;]& #%-%&&'$? =& O%33] _5NR 6ZAHE`R U'$0",$ = 3=O C*"M'+%+ G? $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: *%=&"# -=##"$ *33?1/ =#? #%-%&&'$?R /0%*%4"*%< $0% 8#"0?,2'"% "4 $0% $0'#: ;,&$ G% $=N%# $" 0=M% "--,**%+ +'*%-$3? $0*",:0 *%=&"# _'# $0% O=? $0=$ O% $0'#N "4 = O'33`R /0'& O",3+ *%J,'*% $0=$ O% $0'#N "4 $0% =-$'"# "4 #=$,*% =& G%'#: '#M"3M%+ O'$0 $0% '+%= "4 = C,*C"&%R /0'& :'M%& V=#$ = C*"M'&'"#=3 #"$'"# "4 &,-0 = C,*C"&%< M'kR< $0=$ '$ %('&$& =& \7"29 ,*?3/ *%0 /@@/,2 "@ '23/(@X _5NR 6ZAHE`< =3$0",:0 $0% $0'#: O",3+ 0=M% $" G% $0",:0$ "4 '# $O" +'&$'#-$ O=?& 4"* $0'& $" G% C"&&'G3%R V=#$ $*'%& $" ;=N% $0'& ;"*% -";C*%0%#&'G3% $0*",:0 $0% %(=;C3% "4 = $*%% O0'-0 :%#%*=$%& =#"$0%* $*%% &" $0=$Z O'$0 *%:=*+ $" '$& 38/,'/3 $0% $*%% C*"+,-%& '$&%34Z O'$0'# '$& &C%-'%&< '$ '& G"$0 -=,&% =#+ %44%-$< G"$0 :%#%*=$'#: '$&%34 =#+ G%'#: :%#%*=$%+ G? '$&%34 -%=&%3%&&3?< $0,& C*%&%*M'#: '$&%34 =& = &C%-'%&R _5NR 6ZAH.` a,$ $0'& '& "#3? C=*$ "4 $0% %(=;C3%R 5 $*%% +"%& #"$ ;%*%3? :%#%*=$% "$0%* $*%%& \'$ =3&" C*"+,-%& '$&%34 =& =# '%0'G'0?*(X _5NR 6ZAH.`R )# "$0%* $%*;&< '$ )#".3< O0'-0 =-$ V=#$ -"#&'+%*& =& %J,'M=3%#$ $" :%#%*=$'"# =&Z $0% ;=$$%* $0=$ $0% $*%% =&&';'3=$%& '& 4'*&$ C*"-%&&%+ G? '$ ,#$'3 $0% ;=$$%* 0=& $0% J,=3'$? C%-,3'=* $" $0% &C%-'%&< = J,=3'$? $0=$ $0% #=$,*=3 ;%-0=#'&; ",$&'+% $0% C3=#$ -=##"$ &,CC3?< =#+ $0% $*%% -"#$'#,%& $" +%M%3"C '$&%34 G? ;%=#& "4 = ;=$%*'=3 $0=$ '# '$& -";C"1 &'$'"# '& $0% $*%%]& "O# C*"+,-$R _5NR 6ZAH.` 5#+< 4'#=33?< $0% $*%% *%C='*& '$&%34 $0*",:0 "#% C=*$ "4 '$ -";'#: $" *%C3=-% "* 4,34'3 $0% *%J,'*%;%#$& "4 =#"$0%* +=;=:%+ C=*$R \T%#-% %M%# '# "#% =#+ $0% &=;% $*%% O% ;=? *%:=*+ %=-0 G*=#-0 "* 3%=4 =& ;%*%3? &%$ '#$" "* )#*@2/0 "%2" '$< =#+ 0%#-% =& =# '#+%C%#+%#$ $*%% $0=$ "#3? =$$=-0%& '$&%34 $" =#"$0%* "#% =#+ #",*'&0%& '$&%34 C=*=&'$'-=33?] _5NR 6ZAH.Y ;? %;C0=&'&`R /0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0% $*%% &%341"*:=#'&%& $0% C*"+,-$'"# "4 '$&%34 =& &C%-'%&< $0=$ '$ :*"O& $0*",:0 $0% ,&% "4 '$& "O# *%&",*-%& =#+ $0=$ '$ *%C='*& '$&%34 $0*",:0 ;,$,=3 '#$%*-0=#:% "4 C=*$&< C*"+,-%& $0% -";C"&'

%$10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%23 .F.

C'-$,*% "4 $0% $*%% =& G%'#: =$ "#-% -=,&% =#+ %44%-$ "4 '$&%34 _$0",:0 $0% +'44%*%#$ &%#&%& 0%*% '#M"3M%+ -=# G% =#=3?$'-=33? &%C=*=$%+ &" ;,-0 $0=$ O% ;':0$ %M%# *%:=*+ %=-0 C=*$ =& +'&$'#-$ 4*"; ^ =#+ '#+,G'$=G3? C=*=&'$'- "# ^ $0% O0"3%`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k%+ G? = ;,$,=3 '#$%**%3=$'"# G%$O%%# -=,&% =#+ %44%-$R /0'& 0=CC%#& J,'$% #=$,*=33? '# $%-0#'-=3 C*%&%#$=$'"#Z \2"* %(=;C3%< =3$0",:0 = 0",&% '& $0% -=,&% "4 $0% ;"#%? *%-%'M%+ 4"* *%#$< ?%$< -"#M%*&%3?< $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# iO% 4"*;%+j "4 $0'& C"&&'G3% '#-";% =3&" -=,&%+ $0% 0",&% $" G% -"#&$*,-$%+] _5NR 6ZAH@`R /0'& ;,$,=3 '#$%**%3=$'"# G%$O%%# +%&-%#+'#: =#+ =&-%#+'#: -=,&%& '& O0=$ '& -=33%+ = 4'#=3 -=,&%R a,$ O% O'33 &$'33 #%%+ $" +'&$'#:,'&0 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 = 4'#=3 -=,&% =--"*+'#: $" $0% $%-0#'-=3 C"&&'G'3'$'%& "4 ",* O'33 _=*$`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`R /0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# ;=$$%* =#+ 4"*; O0'-0 '& '#M"3M%+ '# $0% O"*N "4 =*$ C"'#$& $" $0% 4=-$ $0=$ 0%*% O% +" #"$ 0=M% = &%341 "*':'#=$"*R /0% &%-"#+ %3%;%#$ O0'-0 ;,&$ G% '#M"3M%+ $" G% =G3% $" $=3N "4 = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% ;,&$ $0%*%4"*% G*'#: '# $0'& %3%;%#$ "4 &%341"*':'#=$'"# _=& O% O'$#%&&%+ '# $0% -=&% "4 $0% $*%%`R 5 #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% ;,&$ 0=M% \O'$0'# '$&%34 =#+ '$& '##%* C"&&'G'3'$?< *%4%*%#-% $" C,*C"&%&] &" $0=$ \$0% C=*$& "4 $0% $0'#: -";G'#% '#$" $0% ,#'$? "4 = O0"3% G%-=,&% $0%? =*% *%-'C*"-=33? -=,&% =#+ %44%-$ "4 $0%'* 4"*;] _5NR 6ZAHA`R /0,& $0% G=&'& "4 $0% ;=$$%* "4 $0% $0'#: '& '$& '#$%*1-"##%-$'"# "4 C=*$&R /" C,$ $0'& =#"$0%* O=?< '# = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%Z \O0=$ '& #%%+%+ '& $0=$ =33 '$& C=*$&< $0*",:0 $0%'* "O# -=,&=3'$?< C*"+,-% "#% =#"$0%* =& *%:=*+& G"$0 $0%'* 4"*; =#+ -";G'#=$'"#] &" $0=$ \$0% -"##%-$'"# "4 /@@','/%2 ,*?3/3 -",3+ =$ $0% &=;% $';% G% S,+:%+ $" G% = ,*?3*2'"% 29#"?)9 @'%*( ,*?3/3X _5NR 6ZAHA`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.F@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B=-0 C=*$ "4 = #=$,*=3 $0'#: +"%& #"$ S,&$ -";% $" %('&$ G%-=,&% $0% "$0%* C=*$& 4"*-% '$ $" =& = *%&,3$ "4 $0%'* =-$'"# G,$ '& =3&" =# "*:=# "4 $0% "$0%* C=*$& O0'-0 $0%&% C=*$& -=# ,$'3'&%R /0,& #"$ "#3? '& %=-0 C=*$ 3'N% = C=*=&'$% '# 4%%+'#: "# $0% *%&$ G,$ '$ '& =3&" $*%=$%+ G? $0% *%&$ =& = C,*% '#&$*,;%#$R 2,*$0%*< G? &=?'#: $0=$ $0% "*:=# \8#"0?,/3 $0% "$0%* C=*$&] V=#$ ;=N%& '$ -3%=* $0=$ = #=$,*=3 G%'#: '& #"$ ;%*%3? "*:=#'&%+ _O0'-0 4=-$ -=# G% &='+ =G",$ = O"*N "4 =*$` G,$ '& =3&" 3/(@1"*:=#'&%+R /0'& '& O0? $0% &"1-=33%+ =*:,;%#$ 4*"; +%&':# -=##"$ C*"+,-% = -"#M'-$'"# "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 -"##%-$'"#R 5 O=$-0 _=& '# 8=3%?]& '#4=;",& =*:,;%#$` ;=? O%33 %(0'G'$ +%&':# G,$ '$ '& #"$ &%341"*:=#'k%+ =#+ +"%& #"$ $0%*%4"*% &%341*%C='* =& = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% +"%&R /0'& '& O0? '$ '& = ;%*% ;=-0'#% _"* O"*N "4 =*$`R /" ;=N% -3%=*%* &$'33 $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% $O" $?C%& "4 4'#=3 -=,&%& 0%*% %(0'G'$%+ ^ $0% ;=-0'#'O0'-0 +%C%#+& "# *=$'"#=3 '#$%*M%#$'"# 4*"; O'$0",$ =#+ $0% "*:=#'O0'-0 &%341 "*:=#'&%& ^ V=#$ O*'$%&Z R R R = ;=-0'#% 0=& "#3? 1"2'G/ 4"*-%R a,$ =# "*:=#'&%+ G%'#: 0=& O'$0'# '$ @"#1*2'G/ 4"*-%< =#+ = 4"*;=$'M% 4"*-% $0=$ $0'& G%'#: ';C=*$& $" $0% N'#+& "4 ;=$$%* $0=$ 3=-N '$ _$0%*%G? "*:=#'&'#: $0%;`R /0'& 4"*-% '& $0%*%4"*% = 4"*;=$'M% 4"*-% $0=$ C*"C=:=$%& '$&%34 ^ = 4"*-% $0=$ = ;%*% =G'3'$? i"4 "#% $0'#:j $" ;"M% i=#"$0%*j _'R%R< ;%-0=#'&;` -=##"$ %(C3='#R _5NR 6ZAHF` /0% -3=&&'-=3 +%&':# =*:,;%#$ O0'-0 =$$%;C$& $" -"#M'#-% "# $0% G=&'& "4 -";C=*'&"# G%$O%%# $0% O"*3+ =#+ $0% O"*N "4 =*$ '&< $0%*%4"*%< #"$ G=&%+ "# $%3%"3":'-=3 C*'#-'C3%& =#+ '& 4=3&%3? -=33%+ = $%3%"3":'-=3 =*:,1 ;%#$R /0'& '& ';C"*$=#$ G%-=,&% ,#3%&& O% =*% -3%=* =G",$ $0'& +'&$'#-1 $'"# G%$O%%# +%&':# =#+ #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% O% O'33 *%S%-$ $%3%"3":? O'$0",$ 0=M'#: :'M%# '$ $*'=3R /%3%"3":? *%4%*& ,& $" $0% C0%#";%#= "4 4"*;=$'M% 4"*-% _G'*$0 =#+ :*"O$0`R )# =$$%;C$'#: $" ;=N% 4"*;=$'M% 4"*-% =# =#=3":,% "4 =*$ O% #%-%&&=*'3? $0'#N "4 = -*=4$&;=# O0" '& &%C=*=$% 4*"; #=$,*%R a,$ $0% C"'#$ "4 = $%3%"3":'-=3 M'%O "4 #=$,*% '& $" '#&'&$ $0=$ #=$,*% \"*:=#'&%& '$&%34] O0'-0 "--,*& G? *%4%*%#-% $" = N'#+ "4 -=,&=3'$? O0'-0 0=& #" =#=3":,%R )# =# "*:=#'&%+ G%'#: O0'-0 -"#1 $='#& O'$0'# '$&%34 C=*$& O0'-0 =*% =33 ;%=#& =#+ *%-'C*"-=33? =3&" C,*1 C"&%& \#"$0'#: '& :*=$,'$",&< C,*C"&%3%&&< "* $" G% =$$*'G,$%+ $" = G3'#+ #=$,*=3 ;%-0=#'&;] _5NR 6ZAHD`R /0% ,#'$? "4 = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% '& $0,& G=&%+ "# =# '+%= O0'-0 3%=+& ,& $" &%% $0=$ %=-0 C=*$ '& =# "*:=# 4"* $0% O0"3%R /0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0'#:& &%*M% "$0%* $0'#:& =3&" +"%& #"$ "4 '$&%34 %#$'$3% ,& $" =&&,;% $0=$ '$ '& *':0$ $" $0'#N "4 $0%; =& &" +%&':#%+R /" ;=N% $0% 3=$$%* =&&%*$'"# O% O",3+

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%23 .FA

#%%+ ;"*% $0=# $0% -"#-%C$ "4 = C"&&'G3% C,*C"&%Z \O% O",3+ 0=M% $" -":#'&% $0% 4'#=3 C,*C"&% _3,"8?3` "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6ZAHI`R a,$ $0'& \4=* &,*C=&&%& =33 ",* $%3%"3":'-=3 -":#'$'"# "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6ZAHI`R b#-% O% G%:'# $" $0'#N $%3%"3":'-=33? $" $0% -"#&'+%*=$'"# $0=$ $0'#:& =*% ?3/@?( 4"* "$0%* $0'#:& =#+ $0,& $0% %(=;C3% $0=$ #=$,*% "44%*& ,& '# '$& "*:=#'C*"+,-$& \S,&$'4'%& ,&< '#+%%+ -=33& ,C"# ,&< $" %(C%-$ #"$0'#: 4*"; '$ =#+ '$& 3=O& %(-%C$ O0=$ '& C,*C"&'M% '# i*%3=$'"# $"j $0% O0"3%] _5NR 6ZAHK`R a=&'#: ",*&%3M%& "# $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 &,44'-'%#$ *%=&"# O% -=# %(C%-$ $0=$ &'#-% #"$0'#: '& :*=$,'$",& '$ O'33 G% ,&%4,3 4"* &";%$0'#:< =#+ &'#-% %=-0 #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% '& &%341:%#%*=$'M% $0*",:0 '$& $*%=$;%#$ "4 '$&%34 =& = &%$ "4 :*=4$& $0'& %#$='3& $0=$ %=-0 $0'#: '& =M='3=G3% =& = :*=4$ "4 &";% &"*$ 4"* "$0%* $0'#:&R /0,& O% =*% 3%+ $" = +"-$*'#% "4 ,#'M%*&=3 C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 #=$,*% -"#&'+%*%+ $%-0#'-=33?R )# $0'& O=?< \O% %(C=#+ #=$,*=3 &-'%#-% i4*2?#-?%0/j '# $%*;& "4 = +'44%*%#$ C*'#-'C3%< $0=$ "4 4'#=3 -=,&%&< ?%$ O'$0",$ +%$*=-$'#: 4*"; $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 ;%-0=#'&; '# $0% -=,&=3'$? "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6ZAHK`R BM'+1 %#$3?< O% -=##"$ $0%*%G? 0"3+ $0=$ #=$,*% =-$& =& =# '#$%#$'"#=3 O0"3%< G,$ O% =*% &$'33 %#=G3%+ $" = O'+%* &?&$%;=$'- '#&':0$ '#$" $0% $"$=3'$? "4 #=$,*% $0=# &';C3? =*'&%& 4*"; = ;%-0=#'-=3 #"$'"# "4 %44'1 -'%#$ -=,&=$'"#R b#-% O% :*=&C $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% ,#'M%*&=3 :*=4$ O% O'33 &%% $0% +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 #=$,*=3 4"*;& $0*",:0 C,*C"&'M% '#$%*=-$'"# =& = #%-%&&=*? =&C%-$ "4 =# "M%*=33 M'%OR \2"* $0% '+%= "4 #=$,*% =& = &?&$%; "4 #=$,*% =3*%=+? 3%=+& ,&< =& -"#-%*#& '$& G=&'&< G%?"#+ $0% O"*3+ "4 &%#&%< &" $0=$ $0% ,#'$? "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% C*'#-'C3% ;,&$ G% -"#&'+%*%+ M=3'+ #"$ ;%*%3? 4"* -%*$='# &C%-'%& "4 #=$,*=3 G%'#:&< G,$ S,&$ =& ;,-0 4"* $0% O0"3% "4 #=$,*% =& = &?&$%;] _5NR 6ZAI.`R U'$0'# $0% *%=3; "4 &-'%#-%< 0"O%M%*< O% 0=M% #" *':0$ $" -3='; $0% ,&% "4 C*'#-'C3%& "4 +'M'#% =-$'"#Z \L=$0%*< O% ;,&$ -=*%4,33? =#+ ;"+1 %&$3? *%&$*'-$ ",*&%3M%& $" $0% %(C*%&&'"# $0=$ &=?& #" ;"*% $0=# O% N#"O ^ G'YR< C,*C"&% "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6ZAI@`R W=$,*=3 &-'%#-% &0",3+ #"$ =#+ ;,&$ #"$ 3%=C "M%* $0% G",#+=*'%& "4 C"&&'G3% N#"O3%+:% =#+ =G&"*G = C*'#-'C3% $" O0'-0 #" %(C%*'%#-% O0=$%M%* -=# G% =+%J,=$% =#+ O0'-0 O% 0=M% #" %#$'$3%;%#$ $" =$ =33 &-'%#$'4'-=33?R a,$ '# $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 "*:=#'&%+ G%'#:& $0% \$%3%"3":'-=3 .*: "@ J?0)'%)X '& ,#=M"'+=G3%< %M%# 4"* #=$,*=3 &-'%#-%R /0% ,&% "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 C*'#-'C3%& O0'3&$ #"$ -"#&$'$,$'M% "4 = &-'%#$'4'- "GS%-$< '3 = #%-%&&=*? =&C%-$ "4 #=$,*=3 &-'%#$'4'- C*"-%+,*%R /0'& +%3'-=$% "C%*=$'"# -=# G% ;='#$='#%+ '4 O% \=G&$*=-$ %#$'*%3? 4*"; $0% J,%&$'"# =& $" O0%$0%* #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%& =*% C,*C"&%& '%2/%2'"%*((: "* ?%'%2/%2'"%*((:X _5NR 6ZAI@` O0'-0 J,%&$'"#& =*% 3%4$ ",$ "4 &-'%#-% =3$"1 :%$0%*R 5 &-'%#$'&$ &0",3+ &%$$3% 4"* *%:=*+'#: #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%& =& "GS%-$&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.FF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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` =#+ $0%&% C,*C"&%& 0=M% G%%# C*%&%#$%+ =& -"#$='#'#: ;=$%*'=3 "*:=#'&=$'"# '# =++'$'"# $" 4"*;=3 "*:=#'&=$'"# /0% #"$'"# "4 &%341"*:=#'&=$'"# $0=$ %;%*:%& '& C%*0=C& "++%* $0=# "#% ;':0$ %(C%-$ =& '$ *%M%=3& $0% "*:=#1 '&%+ G%'#: =& -";C"&%+ "4 C=*$& O0'-0 %=-0 C*"+,-% =#+ *%C='* %=-0 "$0%* &" $0=$ $0% G"+? '& = -";C"&'$% "4 "*:=#& _&%C=*=$% G"+'%& O0'-0 %=-0 =*% C=*=&'$'-=33? :*=4$%+ ,C"# %=-0 "$0%*`R /0'& %#$='3& = #"$'"# "4 )/%/#*( )#*@2'%)R )$ '& '#$%*%&$'#: $0=$ $0% "#3? C0%#";%#"# $0=$ V=#$ -=# 3'&$ =& *%;"$%3? -";C=*=G3% $" =# "*:=#'&; '& = C"3'$'-=3 G"+?R. 5& O'$0 $0% %(=;C3% "4 C"3'$'-=3 =&&"-'=$'"# _O0'-0 O% O'33 +'&-,&& 4,*$0%* '# !0=C$%* .E G%3"O`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` =#+ = M'$=3 G,$ '#-"0%*%#$ '#$%*-"##%-$'"# _$0% -"#$'#,",& '#M=&'"# "4 $0% G"+? G? &%#&=$'"# '# %;C'*'-'&;`R /0'& &0",3+ :'M% ,& = C*%3';'#=*? #"$'"# "4 $0% C"3'$'-& "4 $0% !*'$'-=3 C0'3"1 &"C0? =#+ '$& C"$%#$'=3 C*"G3%;&R /0%&% C*"G3%;& O'33 G% 4"33"O%+ $0*",:0 #"O =& '#$%:*=33? -"##%-$%+ $" $0% =G&$*,&% +'44'-,3$'%& "4 $0% 7'=3%-$'- "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$< "#% "4 $0% ;"&$ ';C"*$=#$ =#+ ?%$ 3%=&$ M'&'$%+ C=*$& "4 $0% O0"3% !*'$'-=3 -"*C,&R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ D<8"3'2'"% "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%23 .F6

I

)# $0'& -0=C$%* ) O'33 +%&-*'G% $0% -"#$*"M%*&? $0=$ %('&$& -"#-%*#'#: $0% '#$%*C*%$=$'"# "4 $0% =#$'#";? "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ =#+ =*:,% 4"* = ,#'$=*? *%=+'#: "4 $0% 7'=3%-$'- "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$R ) O'33 -"##%-$ ;? *%=+'#: $" =# =--",#$ "4 $0% =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2R )# +"'#: &"< ) O'33 C*%&%#$ = +%$='3%+ *%&C"#&% $" U%*#%* 83,0=*]& '#$%*C*%$=$'"# "4 $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# $0% 5#$'#";'%& "4 /=&$% =#+ /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$R

8#&P*1.#0 $-* L;*&$.+#C A-"$ .& "# 8#$.#+2( +, J;402*#$< V=#$ "C%#& $0% 7'=3%-$'- O'$0 =# %(C3=#=$'"# "4 O0=$ =# =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$ '&R /" %(C3='# $0% #=$,*% "4 &,-0 =# =#$'#";? V=#$ *%;'#+& ,& "#-% =:='# $0=$ O0%# S,+:;%#$ '& +%$%*;'#=$'M% \'$ 0=& #" C*'#-'C3%& "4 '$& "O# $0=$ 4"*; $0% G=&'& 4"* ,"%,/823 "@ "7J/,23X _5NR 6ZAI6`R a%-=,&% "4 $0'&< '# = +%$%*;'#=$'M% S,+:;%#$< S,+:;%#$ '& #"$ =#+ -=##"$ G% %(C"&%+ $" =# =#$'#";? "4 '$& "O#R )# $0% -=&% "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ 0"O%M%*Z R R R S,+:;%#$ R R R 0=& $" &,G&,;% ,#+%* = 3=O $0=$ '& #"$ ?%$ :'M%#< =#+ 0%#-% ;,&$ &,G&,;% ,#+%* = 3=O $0=$ '& '# 4=-$ "#3? = C*'#-'C3% "4 *%43%-$'"# "# i-%*$='#j "GS%-$& 4"* O0'-0 O% 0=M% #" "GS%-$'M% 3=O =$ =33< #" -"#-%C$ "4 $0% "GS%-$ =+%J,=$% =& = C*'#-'C3% 4"* $0% -=&%& $0=$ "--,*R a,$ &'#-% '$ '& #"$ C%*;'&&'G3% $" ,&% $0% -":#'$'M% C"O%*& O'$0",$ C*'#-'C3%&< *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ O'33 '# $0"&% -=&%& 0=M% $" &%*M% '$&%34 =& = C*'#-'C3%R _5NR 6ZAI6` /0'& &%341:*",#+'#: '& %(C*%&&%+ '# $%*;& "4 ;=(';&R \W"O G%$O%%# $0%&% #%-%&&=*? ;=(';& "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ = -"#43'-$ ;=? =*'&%< .FD

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% 5#$'#";? "4 L%43%-$'M% 9,+:;%#$ L%1$*%=$%+

=#+ 0%#-% =# =#$'#";?Y =#+ $0'& =#$'#";? 4"*;& $0% G=&'& 4"* = +'=3%-1 $'-] _5NR 6ZAID`R 5--"*+'#: $" B9/ K#"?%0."#- "@ 29/ &/2*89:3',3 "@ &"#*(3 = ;=('; '& ,#'M%*&=3 '# 4"*;< C3,*=3 '# ;=$$%* =#+ $"$=3 '# +%$%*;'#=$'"# _5NR FZFAD`R /0% *%43%-$'M% =-$ "4 S,+:;%#$ :'M%& $0% O"*3+ -"0%*%#-% $0*",:0 $0% -"##%-$'"# "4 ;=(';& "4 C=*$'-,3=* =CC3'-=$'"# $" ,#'M%*&=3 3=O& C*%&%#$%+ * 8#'"#'R >"< *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ 0=& $" *%3=$% $0% ,#'M%*&=3 *,3% "4 +%$%*;'#=$'"# $" $0% C=*$'-,3=* &'$,=$'"# "4 = :'M%# %('&$'#: #=$,*%R /0'& ;%=#& $O" N'#+& "4 ;=('; _4"*;=3 =#+ ,#'M%*&=3< ;=$%*'=3 =#+ C3,*=3` 0=M% $" G% *%3=$%+ '# "*+%* $" *%3%=&% = $0'*+ N'#+ _$"$=3 =#+ +%$%*;'#=$%`R a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` _5NR 6ZAIH` /0'& '& =# =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$ O0'-0 *%&$& "# $0% -"#43'-$ "4 *%:1 ,3=$'M% C*'#-'C3%&R )$ '& J,'$% +'&$'#-$ 4*"; =# =#$'#";? "4 *%=&"#R /0% 3=$$%* O",3+ $=N% $0% ;=(';& $" G% +%$%*;'#=$'M% * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3%&R a,$Z \O% -=##"$ 0=M% = +%$%*;'#=$'M% * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3% 4"* $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0'#:& '# $%*;& "4 ;%*%3? %;C'*'-=3 3=O& "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6ZAIH` =& +%$%*;'#=$'M% *,3%& +" #"$ -"#-%*# &,-0 3=O&R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& 4=-$ $0% =#$'#";? $0=$ =*'&%& 0%*% '& C,*%3? "#% "4 *%:,3=$'M% ;=(';&R /0% 4'*&$ ;=('; "4 S,+:;%#$ '& #"O *%1C*%&%#$%+ G? V=#$ =& ;%=#'#: $0% 4"33"O'#:Z R R R ) "?)92 =3O=?& $" #/@(/,2 "# $0%&% %M%#$& =#+ 4"*;& '% 2/#13 "@ 29/ 8#'%,'8(/ "4 $0% ;%*% ;%-0=#'&; "4 #=$,*%< =#+ 0%#-% ",:0$ $" '#M%&$':=$% $0'& C*'#-'C3% =& 4=* =& ) -=#< G%-=,&% ,#3%&& O% C*%&,CC"&% '$ '# ",* '#M%&$':=$'"# i"4 #=$,*%j O% -=# 0=M% #" -":#'$'"# "4 #=$,*% =$ =33 '# $0% C*"C%* &%#&% "4 $0% $%*;R _5NR 6ZAIH` /0%*% '& &";%$0'#: ';C%*=$'M% =G",$ *%43%-$'#: '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 ;%-0=#'&;R /0'& '& $0% ';C%*=$'M% "4 -":#'$'"# '$&%34 O0'-0 +%;=#+& $0=$ -"##%-$'"#& G%$O%%# C0%#";%#= =*% 3=O13'N%< $0=$ '&<

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .FH

.FI C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

R R R 9?1*% #/*3"%< '4 '$ "G%?& $0% 4'*&$ ;=('; =#+ =-$& =--"*+'#:3?< O'33 #%M%* G% =G3% $" +'&-"M%* $0% &3':0$%&$ G=&'& 4"* O0=$ '& &C%-'4'- '# = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%< $0",:0 '$ ;=? =-J,'*% "$0%* -":#'$'"#& "4 #=$,*=3 3=O&R _5NR 6ZAII` 2,*$0%*;"*%< O0%$0%* "* #"$ $0% \'##%* G=&'& "4 #=$,*% '$&%34] =33"O& = ,#'4'-=$'"# "4 $0% $O" ;=(';& '# "#% C*'#-'C3% '& &";%$0'#: O% -=##"$ N#"OR /0'& &,::%&$& $0=$ $0% $O" ;=(';& "4 *%43%-$'"# "# %;C'*'-=3 3=O& #%%+ '# &";% O=? $" G% ,#'$%+ G,$ $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 &,-0 ,#'4'-=$'"# _O0'-0 O",3+ :,=*=#$%% $0% 3=O13'N% -0=*=-$%* "4 $0=$ O0'-0 %&-=C%& ;%-0=#'&;` '& #"$ '$&%34 -3%=*3? :'M%# $" ,& '# =#? C*'#-'C3%R /0% *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0% =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$ O",3+ &%%; $" *%J,'*% &";% &,-0 C*'#-'C3%R ) O'33 #"O *%M'%O $0% =3$%*#=$'M% =--",#$& "4 $0% =#$'#";? "4 S,+:1 ;%#$ $0=$ 0=M% G%%# C*%&%#$%+ $" +=$% -"#-3,+'#: O'$0 = *%=+'#: "4 $0% *%&$ "4 $0% 7'=3%-$'- '# "*+%* $" +%;"#&$*=$% V=#$]& &"3,$'"#R /0'& &"3,1 $'"# O'33 *%J,'*% *%$*=-'#: $0% =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% =#+ $0,& O'33 G*'#: $" $0% 4"*% $0% ,#'$? "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2R

'-* >+#,7.5$.#0 855+;#$& +, '-* 8#$.#+2( +, J;402*#$ /0%*% =*% =$ C*%&%#$ $0*%% +'&$'#-$ =--",#$& "4 O0=$ $0% =#$'#";? -"#1 &'&$& '# =#+ 0"O '$ '& *%&"3M%+R /0% 4'*&$ '& C*%&%#$%+ '# =# =*$'-3% G? e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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

#%-%&&=*? '# 4"*;R Q#3%&& $0% -"##%-$'"#& =*% #%-%&&=*? O% O'33 "#3? C"&&%&& = ;%*% =::*%:=$% "4 %(C%*'%#-% *=$0%* $0=# = 4"*; "4 #=$,*%R /0% &%-"#+ ;=('; 0"O%M%* &$=$%& $0=$Z

$0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2R /0,&< 0=M'#: C*%&%#$%+ V=#$ =& '#-=C=G3% "4 *%&"3M'#: $0% =#$'#";?< >-0*=+%* &%$& ",$ =3$%*#=$'M% ;%$01 "+& "4 *%&"3M'#: '$< '#-3,+'#: $0% =&&,;C$'"# $0=$ $%3%"3":? '& = -"#&$'1 $,$'M% C*'#-'C3%R T% -"#-3,+%&< 0"O%M%*< $0=$ $%3%"3":? '& =# '+%= "4 *%=&"# =#+ &,::%&$& $0% =;G'M=3%#$ &$=$,& "4 '$ '& -"##%-$%+ $" $0% =;G'M=3%#$ &$=$,& "4 *%=&"# _=& "C%*=$'#: G"$0 O'$0'# =#+ G%?"#+ %(C%*'%#-%`R 5& 0% C,$& '$< '4 *%=&"# '& '#%M'$=G3? '#M"3M%+ '# = +'=3%-$'-Z R R R =& V=#$ -"#&'+%*%+ '$ $" G%< $0%# $0% =;G'M=3%#$ &$=$,& =&&':#%+ $" *%=&"#< =& =3&"< $" *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$< '& #"$ "#3? ,#+%*&$=#+=G3% G,$ #%-%&&=*?R _>-0*=+%*< "8V ,'2V< CR @@I`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l /0'& -"#4,&%+ =#+ -"#4,&'#: &%$ "4 *%&C"#&%& '& -3%=*3? '#&,44'-'%#$ =& =# =--",#$ "4 $0% =#$'#";?R 9"0# P-2=*3=#+]& G""N "# V=#$'=# $%3%"3":? "44%*& J,'$% = +'44%*%#$ '#$%*C*%$=$'"# "4 $0% =#$'#";? $" >-0*=+%*R@ ['N% >-0*=+%*< 0% '& -";1 ;'$$%+ $" $0% M'%O $0=$ $0%*% '& '# 4=-$ #" &,-0 $0'#: =& =# =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$ _S,&$ =#$'#";'%& "4 *%=&"#` =#+< =3&" 3'N% >-0*=+%*< =*:,%& $0=$ $0%*% '& #" C*"G3%; '4 G"$0 C*'#-'C3%& =*% $=N%# $" G% *%:,3=$'M%R T"O1 %M%*< 0% &,--%&&4,33? =M"'+& $0% +%%C %#$=#:3%;%#$& >-0*=+%* :%$& '#$" =G",$ $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% =#+ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2< G? &$=$'#: $0=$ '$ '& #"$ $0% -=&% _=& >-0*=+%* =&&,;%&` $0=$ $0% $0%&'& '& =&&%*$'#: $0% -=$%:"*? "4 -=,&=3'$? _=& :'M%# '# $0% >%-"#+ 5#=3":?` $" G% ;%*%3? *%:,3=$'M% G,$ *=$0%* $0=$Z R R R $0% ;%-0=#'-=3 &?&$%; '& *%:,3=$'M% =& = ;%$0"+"3":'-=3 C*'#-'C3%< =#+ $0=$ O0%# "--=&'"# =*'&%& O% ;=? ,&% $%3%"3":'-=3 -"#-%C$& O'$01 ",$ -"#$*=+'-$'"#R _P-2=*3=#+< "8V ,'2V< CR .@E` /0%*% '& &";% &,CC"*$ 4"* $0'& =*:,;%#$ '# V=#$]& $%($R 5$ $0% %#+ "4 dH. "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 V=#$ O*'$%&Z R R R =33 &%;G3=#-% "4 =# =#$'#";? G%$O%%# $0% ;=(';& "4 &$*'-$3? C0?&'-=3 _;%-0=#'-=3` =#+ $%3%"3":'-=3 _$%-0#'-=3` %(C3=#=$'"# *%&$&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .FK

.6E C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0'& O",3+ &,::%&$ $0=$ $0% =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$ '&< =& P-2=*3=#+ &%%;& $" $0'#N< ;%*%3? =# %**"* "4 &,G&$'$,$'#: = -"#&$'$,$'M% C*'#-'C3% 4"* = *%:,3=$'M% "#% _= 4"*; "4 $0% 4=33=-? "4 &,G*%C$'"#`R V=#$]& &$=$%;%#$ -";%& =$ $0% %#+ "4 = &%-$'"# %#$'$3%+ \8*%3';'#=*? $" $0% >"3,$'"# "4 $0% 5G"M% 5#$'#";?]R a,$ :'M%# $0=$ $0'& &$=$%;%#$ '& &='+ $" G% \C*%3';'#=*?] $" $0% &"3,$'"#< '$ -=##"$ '$&%34 -"#&$'$,$% $0% &"3,$'"# $" $0% =#$'#";?R W"* +"%& P-2=*3=#+ -3='; $0=$ '$ +"%&R T% &,::%&$& $0=$ $0% =#$'#";? '& '# 4=-$ *%&"3M%+ G? &0"O'#: $0=$ $0% $O" ;=(';& =*% #"$ '#-";C=$'G3% $0*",:0 =# =CC%=3 $" $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% _P-2=*3=#+< "8V ,'2V< CR .@.`R /0% =CC%=3 $" $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% '& -"#$='#%+ '# V=#$]& *%&$=$%;%#$ "4 $0% =#$'$0%&'& =& '#M"3M'#: =CC%=3 $" $0% 0,;=# ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R )$ '&< C%*0=C&< "#3? G%-=,&% "4 ",* -":#'$'M% 4=-,3$'%& $0=$ O% =*% -"#&$*='#%+ $" M'%O =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 = C,*C"&% =& '#M"3M'#: *%4%*%#-% $" '#$%#$'"#&R a,$ C%*0=C& = +'44%*%#$ 4"*; "4 '#$%33':%#-% O",3+ M'%O $0'#:& "$0%*1 O'&%R P-2=*3=#+ O*'$%&Z )$ '& $0'& #"$'"# "4 = +'44%*%#$ ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O0'-0 V=#$ ,&%& '# 0'& *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0% =#$'#";? G%$O%%# $0% ;%-0=#'-=3 =#+ $%3%"3":'-=3 C*'#-'C3%&R _P-2=*3=#+< "8V ,'2V< CR .@H` /0% +'M'&'"# '# ",* 4=-,3$'%& $0=$ 3%=+& ,& $" -"##%-$ = C,*C"&% O'$0 =# '#$%#$'"# '& $0=$ G%$O%%# ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ '#$,'$'"#R /0% C"&&'G3% G%'#: $" O0"; V=#$ *%4%*& '& "#% O0'-0 0=& #" +'M'&'"# G%$O%%# ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: =#+ '#$,'$'"#R V=#$ +%&-*'G%& $0'& C"&&'G3% G%'#: =& "#% =#'1 ;=$%+ G? \=# '%2?'2'G/ ,#+%*&$=#+'#:] O0'-0 O",3+ C*"-%%+ 4*"; \$0% 3:%29/2',*((:H?%'G/#3*( _$0% '#$,'$'"# "4 $0% O0"3% =& = O0"3%` $" $0% C=*$'-,3=*< 'R%R< 4*"; $0% O0"3% $" $0% C=*$&] _5NR 6ZFEH`R /0'& '& J,'$% ,#3'N% ",* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O0'-0 0=& $" C*"-%%+ \4*"; $0% *%*(:2',H *((: ?%'G/#3*( $" $0% C=*$'-,3=* _'R%R< 4*"; -"#-%C$& $" $0% %;C'*'-=3 '#$,'$'"# $0=$ '& :'M%#`] _5NR 6ZFEH`R b,* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '& '#-=C=G3% "4 +%$%*;'#'#: $0% C=*$'-,3=*< %(-%C$ $0*",:0 $0% C*"-%+,*% "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ O0'3&$ =# '#$,'$'M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< '# '$& -":#'$'"# "4 $0% "GS%-$&< "C%*=$%& $0*",:0 = +%$%*;'#=$% '#$,'$'"# "4 $0% C=*$'-,3=* _=#+ 0%#-% %3';'#=$%& $0% C%*-%C$'"# "4 -"#$'#:%#-?`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

"# ",* -"#4,&'#: = C*'#-'C3% "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ O'$0 "#% "4 +%$%*;'#=$'M% S,+:;%#$< =#+ "# ",* -"#4,&'#: $0% *?2"%"1: "4 *%1 43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ _O0'-0 0"3+& ;%*%3? &,GS%-$'M%3? 4"* ",* ,&% "4 *%=&"# *%:=*+'#: $0% C=*$'-,3=* %;C'*'-=3 3=O&` O'$0 $0% 9/2/#"%"1: "4 +%$%*;'#=$'M% S,+:;%#$< O0'-0 ;,&$ -"#4"*; $" $0% 3=O& _,#'1 M%*&=3 "* C=*$'-,3=*` $0=$ =*% :'M%# G? ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R _5NR 6ZAIK`

P-2=*3=#+]& =--",#$ $0,& +*=O& ;,-0 ;"*% &"3'+3? "# V=#$]& $%($ $0=# >-0*=+%*]& =#+ *%-%'M%& -"#&'+%*=G3% &,CC"*$ 4*"; $0'&R a,$ $0%*% =*% *%=3 C*"G3%;& O'$0 P-2=*3=#+]& &"3,$'"#R T% G%:'#& G? $*=#&4"*;'#: $0% =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$ '#$" "#% "4 *%=&"# =#+ '# +"'#: &" +%#'%& $0% #"$'"# $0=$ $0%*% '& =#? +'&$'#-$'M% +'=3%-$'-=3 C*"G3%; "4 S,+:;%#$R /0'& '& = C%-,3'=* C*"-%+,*% G%-=,&%< +%&C'$% $0% =&&%*$'"#& "4 V=#$ =$ $0% %#+ "4 dH.< 0% $""N C='#& '# d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` $0=$ $0%*% '& "#3? = -"#$*=+'-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% $O" ;=(';& '4 $0%? =*% G"$0 $=N%# $" G% -"#&$'$,$'M%R 2,*$0%*< V=#$]& *%;=*N =$ 5NR 6ZAIK _=3&" J,"$%+ =G"M%`< $0=$ \=33 &%;1 G3=#-%] "4 =# =#$'#";? +'&=CC%=*& '4 O% *%;%;G%* $0=$ O% =*% "#3? +%=3'#: O'$0 ;=(';&< &%%;& $" -"#4'*; $0% -"**%-$#%&& "4 +'&*%:=*+'#: V=#$]& -3%=* =&&%*$'"# '# d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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .6.

.6@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

U0%# O% S,+:% =# "GS%-$ _=# "*:=#'&;` =& = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%< O% =*% S,+:'#: '$ '# $%*;& "4 G"$0 ;%-0=#'&; =#+ 4'#=3 -=,&%&Z '# $%*;& "4 ;%-0=#'&; '#&"4=* =& $0% "GS%-$ '& = C*"+,-$ "4 #=$,*%< '# $%*;& "4 4'#=3 -=,&%& '#&"4=* =& '$ '& = C,*C"&%R W"O ;%-0=#'&; '#M"3M%& $0% #%-%&&'$? ';C3'-'$ '# $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 -=,&=3'$? O0'-0 '& G=&%+ "# $0% -=$%:"*'%&Y "# $0% "$0%* 0=#+< O% -=##"$ $0'#N "4 =# "GS%-$ =& = C,*C"&% O'$0",$ $0'#N'#: "4 '$ =& -"#$'#:%#$< M'kR< -"#$'#:%#$ '# $%*;& "4 $0% ,#'M%*&=3 #=$,*=3 3=O& _5NR AKI`R T%#-% '$ &%%;& $0=$ O% =*% S,+:'#: =& G"$0 #%-%&&=*? =#+ -"#$'#:%#$ \"#% =#+ $0% &=;% C*"+,-$] _5NR F.A`< '#+%%+< %M%# $0% &=;% -=,&=3 ,"%%/,2'"%3 O'$0'# $0=$ C*"+,-$ _5NR AHA< =#+ -4R AH@^HA`R T%#-% O% =*% ,"%2#*0',2'%) ",*&%3M%& _5NR AKD` ?%(/33 ./ ,*% #/,"%,'(/ 29/ 2." 8#'%,'8(/3 _5NR F.F`R _83,0=*< "8V ,'2V< CR (-` /0'& &$=$%;%#$ "4 $0% #=$,*% "4 $0% =#$'#";? *%3=$%& $0% =#$'#";? "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$& $" $0% J,%&$'"# "4 0"O O% -=# &C%=N "4 #=$,*=3 3=O&R /0=$ $0'& '& '#+%%+ $0% -%#$*=3 C*"G3%; "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% '& ,#+%#'=G3% :'M%# $0=$ V=#$ J,'$% %(C3'-'$3? &$=$%& $0'& $" G% $0% -=&%R 2"* %(=;C3%< '# $0% &%-"#+ )#$*"+,-$'"#< V=#$ O*'$%& $0=$ $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 4"*;,3=$'#: C*'#-'C3%& &,-0 =& b--=;]& L=k"* 3%=+& $" $0% #%%+ 4"* = $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 +%+,-$'"# "4 $0% -":#'$'"# "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& '# #=$,*%< =#+Z \S,+:;%#$ ;,&$ =&&,;%< =& =# * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3% 4"* '$& "O# ,&%< $0=$ O0=$ $" 0,;=# '#&':0$ '& -"#$'#:%#$ '# $0% C=*$'-,3=* _%;C'*'-=3` #=$1 ,*=3 3=O& +"%& #%M%*$0%3%&& -"#$='# = 3=O1:"M%*#%+ ,#'$?< ,#4=$0";=G3% G,$ &$'33 -"#-%'M=G3% G? ,&< '# $0% -";G'#=$'"# "4 O0=$ '& +'M%*&% '# $0%; $" i4"*;j =# %(C%*'%#-% $0=$ '& '#$*'#&'-=33? i*% 3',9j C"&&'G3%] _5NR 6Z.IA^ F`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=*% ;%*%3? &0=*C O=?& "4 &$=$'#: $0=$ $0% N'#+ "4 =#$'#";? O% =*% 0%*% 4=-%+ O'$0 '& "#% O0'-0 '#M"3M%& _=& =&&%*$%+ '# dDK` M%*? &C%-'=3 _*%43%-1 $'M%` C*'#-'C3%&R /0'& O",3+ C*%&%*M% $0% &%#&% $0=$ $0%*% *%=33? '& =# =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$ O0'-0 -"#-%*#& $%3%"3":? #"$ ;%*%3? = &,G*%C1 $'"#< O0'-0 $,*#& *%:,3=$'M% '#$" -"#&$'$,$'M% C*'#-'C3%&R U0=$< $0%#< 4"* 83,0=*< '& $0% #=$,*% "4 $0'& =#$'#";?X T% O*'$%&Z

=*% _=& +'&-,&&%+ '# dD6`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`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`R )$ ;,&$ G% C"&&'G3%< $0=$ '&< $" ,#+%*&$=#+ $0% -"#43'-$ '#$" O0'-0 $0% ;=(';& 4=33 =& *%&,3$'#: 4*"; = 4='3,*% $" -";C*%0%#+ $0% =-$,=3 #=$,*% $" O0'-0 $0%? =CC3?R /0'& 4='3,*% ;,&$< 0"O%M%*< 0=M% &";% G=&'& '# $0% -":#'$'M% *%3=$'"# O% #%-%&&=*'3? 0=M% $" #=$,*% _'$ ;,&$ G% = \#=$,*=3 +'=3%-$'-]`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`R _83,0=*< "8V ,'2V< CR (-'` 83,0=* 0%*% ;=N%& 0'& C"'#$ 0"O%M%* #"$ G? *%4%**'#: $" &";% &%-$'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 O0%*% $0'& *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .6A

=#$'#";? '& C*%&%#$%+< G,$ '#&$%=+ -'$'#: $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)H 1/%2R 2,*$0%*< $0% *%4%*%#-% 0% :'M%& '& $" d6H< $0% &%-$'"# -"#-%*#%+ O'$0 $0% &"3,$'"# $" $0% =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$%R U0? +"%& 83,0=* *%4%* $" $0% *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0% =#$'#";? "4 S,+:;%#$& "4 $=&$% O0%# C*%&%#$'#: O0=$ 0% $=N%& $" G% $0% *%&"3,$'"# "4 $0% =#$'#";? "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$X a%-=,&% 0% $0'#N& $0=$ $0% $O" =#$'#";'%& \=*% ;%*%3? $O" ;=#'4%&$=$'"#& "4 $0% &=;% =#$'#";?] _83,0=*< "8V ,'2V< CR (-'M`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dHH` "4 =# \'#$,'$'M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:]R V=#$ -"#$*=&$& $0'& $?C% "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O'$0 ",* "O# '# $0% 4"33"O'#: ;=##%*Z /0% C"'#$ '& $0'&Z b,* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: 0=& $0% C%-,3'=*'$? $0=$ O0%# '$ -":#'k%&< %R:R< $0% -=,&% "4 = C*"+,-$< '$ ;,&$ C*"-%%+ 4*"; $0% *%*(:2',*((: ?%'G/#3*( $" $0% C=*$'-,3=* _'R%R< 4*"; -"#-%C$& $" $0% %;C'*'-=3 '#$,'$'"# $0=$ '& :'M%#`Y -"#&%J,%#$3?< '# $0'& C*"-%&& ",* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: +%$%*;'#%& #"$0'#: *%:=*+'#: $0% +'M%*&'$? "4 $0% C=*$'-,3=*R )#&$%=+ _,#+%* $0% &,CC"&'$'"# $0=$ $0% "GS%-$ '& = #=$,*=3 C*"+,-$` ",* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: ;,&$ O='$ ,#$'3 $0% &,G&,;C$'"# "4 $0% %;C'*'-=3 '#$,'$'"# ,#+%* $0% -"#-%C$ C*"M'+%& $0'& +%$%*;'#=$'"# 4"* $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$R a,$ O% -=# =3&" -"#-%'M% "4 =# ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: $0=$< ,#3'N% ",*&< '& #"$ +'&-,*&'M% G,$ '#$,'$'M%< =#+ 0%#-% C*"-%%+& 4*"; $0% 3:%29/2',*((: ?%'G/#3*( _$0% '#$,'$'"# "4 $0% O0"3% =& = O0"3%` $" $0% C=*$'-,3=*< 'R%R< 4*"; $0% O0"3% $" $0% C=*$&R T%#-% &,-0 =# ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =& O%33 =& '$& C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% O0"3% 0=& #" ,"%2'%)/%,: '# $0% -";G'#=$'"# "4 $0% C=*$& '# "*+%* $" ;=N% = +%$%*1 ;'#=$% 4"*; "4 $0% O0"3% C"&&'G3%R _5NR 6ZFEH` a%-=,&% O% C*"-%%+ 4*"; C=*$ $" O0"3% O% =*% -"#&$*='#%+ $" M'%O $0% #"$'"# "4 3=O =& ;%-0=#'-=3R U% -"#-%'M% = +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# =-$,1 =3'$? =#+ C"&&'G'3'$? =#+ M'%O $0% G%-";'#: =-$,=3 "4 &";%$0'#: ;%*%3? C"&&'G3% $" G% $0% %44%-$ "4 $0% '#$%**%3=$'"# G%$O%%# C=*$& C*"+,-'#: = O0"3%R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& O% -=# "#3? -"#-%'M% "4 4'#=3 -=,&%& =& -"#$'#:%#$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.6F C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .66

5& =# '#$,'$'M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O",3+ %/,/33'2*2/ %M%# $0% C=*$'-,3=*< $0% ;%*% '+%= "4 &,-0 =# ,#+%*&$=#+'#: C%*;'$& ,& $" 29'%- "4 $0% \-"#$'#:%#-?] "4 $0% C=*$'-,3=* =& G%'#: "#3? = 3//1'%) -"#$'#:%#-?< = \-"#$'#:%#-? 4"*] ",* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: O'$0 '$& C%-,3'=*'$?< G,$ =& '# 4=-$ G%'#: = %/,/33'2:R 5 ;%*%3? &%%;'#: -"#$'#:%#-? $0=$ '& '# 4=-$ = #%-%&&'$? +"%& #"$ -"#43'-$ O'$0 $0% #%-%&&'$? ';C3'-'$ '# 1/,9*%'31R _83,0=*< "8V ,'2V< CR (-'''` U0=$ '& $0% -"##%-$'"# 83,0=* C"&'$& G%$O%%# $0'& &"3,$'"# "4 $0% =#$'1 #";? "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$ =#+ $0% &"3,$'"# "4 $0% =#$'#";? "4 $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$%X U% 0=M% #"$%+ '# !0=C$%* 6 =G"M% $0=$ $0% &"3,$'"# "4 $0% =#$'#";? "4 $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% =3&" '#M"3M%+ *%4%*%#-% $" $0% #"$'"# "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% '# $0% 4"*; "4 &?;G"3'- 0?C"$?C"&'&R T"O +"%& $0'& -"##%-$ $" $0% '#$,'$'M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $0=$ O% -=# C"&'$ =& = +'44%*%#$ '#$%33':%#-% O0'-0 -",3+ -":#'&% $0% #%-%&&'$? O0'-0 '& ';C3'-'$ '# $0% &%%;'#: -"#$'#:%#-? "4 $0% C=*$'-,3=* O% =CC*%0%#+X )# %(C3='#'#: $0% =#$'#";? "4 $0% -*'$'J,% "4 $=&$% 83,0=* O*'$%&Z W=$,*%]& &,GS%-$'M% C,*C"&'M%#%&& '& $0% '#+%$%*;'#=$% @"#1 R R R $0=$ #=$,*% 0=& '# $0% C=*$'-,3=*Y =#+ $0% '#+%$%*;'#=$% ,"%,/82 "4 $0'& C,*C"&'M%#%&& '& $0% '#+%$%*;'#=$% -"#-%C$ "4 $0=$ 4"*; "4 $0% C=*$'1 -,3=*R a,$ $0'& -"#-%C$ '& ,"%2#*0',2"#: _G%-=,&% "4 $0% =#$'#";?` ,#3%&& O% $0'#N "4 $0'& C,*C"&'M% 4"*; =& %/,/33'2*2/0 _= C*'"*'` G? =# '#$%33%-$,=3 '#$,'$'"#R _83,0=*< "8V ,'2V< CR (-M` /0%*%4"*%< =--"*+'#: $" 83,0=*Z a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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

%44%-$& O0'-0 =*% #"$ %(C3='#=G3% G? 3=O13'N% -"##%-$'"#R a,$ 4"* =# '#$,'$'M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $0'#:& O",3+ G% J,'$% +'44%*%#$R 5& 83,0=* %(C3='#&Z

.6D C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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`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kR< = -"#43'-$ G%$O%%# $0% #%-%&&'$? '# #=$,*% =#+ ",* 4*%%+"; _O0'-0 =:='# ';C3'%& -"#1 $'#:%#-? '# $%*;& "4 #=$,*=3 3=O&` $" =44%-$ #=$,*% '# =3$%*#=$'M% O=?&R h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` -=,&=3'$?< =3$0",:0 = &,C%*1 &%#&'G3% -=,&=3'$? $0=$ -=# #%M%*$0%3%&& =44%-$ #=$,*% =& =CC%=*=#-% '# =3$%*#=$'M% O=?&R )4 $0% #%-%&&'$? '# #=$,*% '& &$*'-$ %#",:0 4"* $0% =#$'#";? "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$ $" =*'&% =$ =33< =#+ '4 ",* 4*%%+"; O'$0 '$& -"#$'#:%#-? -=# G% *%-"#-'3%+< =& S,&$ +%&-*'G%+< O'$0 $0=$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

C,*C"&'M%#%&&< $0% \$O"] 4"*;& $" O0'-0 $0% $O" -"#-%C$& *%4%* \=*%] &$*'-$3? '+%#$'-=3R _83,0=*< "8V ,'2VR< CR (-M`

&$*'-$ #%-%&&'$? +%&C'$% 0=M'#: $" ;=#'4%&$ '$&%34 '# $0=$ #=$,*% =& =CC%=*=#-% O'$0 '$& #%-%&&'$?< O0? &0",3+ $0% =#$'#";? "4 $%3%"31 ":'-=3 S,+:;%#$ *%J,'*% = &"3,$'"# $0=$ '& &" +'44%*%#$X U0? -",3+ O% #"$ &"3M% '$< G? $0'#N'#:< #"$ = &,C%*&%#&'G3% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $0=$ '& '#$,'$'M% =#+ 0%#-% *%;"M%& $0% -"#$'#:%#-? '# $0% C=*$'-,3=*< G,$ = &,C%*&%#&'G3% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $0=$ +%$%*;'#%& $0'#:& "#3? C*=-$'-=33? =#+ 0%#-% 3%=M%& $0% -"#$'#:%#-? '#$=-$X _83,0=*< "8V ,'2V< CCR -'M^-M`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dHE< '# dH. V=#$ O*'$%&Z \U% =*% J,'$% ,#=G3% $" C*"M% $0=$ "*:=#'k%+ #=$,*=3 C*"+,-$& -=##"$ G% C*"+,-%+ $0*",:0 $0% ;%*% ;%-0=#'&; "4 #=$,*%] _5NR 6ZAII`R U% -=##"$ C*"M% $0'& G%-=,&% \O% 0=M% #" '#&':0$ '#$" $0% 4'*&$ '##%* G=&'& i*%&C"#&'G3%j 4"* $0% %#+3%&& +'M%*&'$? "4 $0% C=*$'-,3=* #=$,*=3 3=O&] O0'-0 4=-$ 4"33"O& 4*"; ",* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: "4 $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# =CC%=*=#-% =#+ $0'#:& '# $0%;&%3M%& =& :'M%# '# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R V=#$ O*'$%&Z

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .6H

.6I C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0'& &%-$'"# _%#$'$3%+ \8*%3';'#=*? $" $0% >"3,$'"# "4 $0% 5G"M% 5#$'1 #";?]` $0,& &%$& ",$ $0% *%=&"# O0? $0% =#$'#";? 0=& $0% 4"*; $0=$ '$ +"%&R U% =*% #"$ 4=-%+ O'$0 *%&"3M'#: C*"G3%;& "4 -"#&$'$,$'M% *,3%& =& $0%*% '& #" O=? O% -=# C*"M% $0=$ ;%-0=#'-=3 C*'#-'C3%& +" #"$< G? *%4%*%#-% $" $0'#:& O% N#"O #"$0'#: "4< '#-3,+% O'$0'# $0%'* C*"M'#-% $0% #"$'"# "4 "*:=#'&=$'"#R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& 4=-$ $0% =#$'#";? '& =# =#$'#";? "4 *%43%-$'M% ;=(';& #"$ "4 -"#&$'$,$'M% C*'#-'C3%&R )4 $0% =#$'#";? -"#-%*#& *%43%-$'M% ;=(';& $0%# 83,0=* '& &,*%3? *':0$ $" -";C*%0%#+ $0% -3"&'#: O"*+& "4 dH. _=G",$ \=33 &%;G3=#-% "4 =# =#$'#";?] *%&$'#: ,C"# = &,G*%C$'"#` =& '#+'-=$'#: $0=$ $0% N'#+ "4 =#$'#";? O% =*% 0%*% +%=3'#: O'$0 '& #"$ "#% O0'-0 '#M"3M%& &$*'-$ -"#$*=+'-$'"# G,$ "#% O0'-0 -"#-%*#& $0% C*"G3%; "4 $0% '#$%*#=3 ,#'$? "4 *%43%-$'M% C*"-%+,*%& "4 S,+:;%#$R a,$ O0'3&$ $0'& &%-$'"# 0"/3 S,&$'4? 83,0=*]& '#$%*C*%$=$'"# "4 $0% -3"&'#: *%;=*N& '$ +"%& %"2 S,&$'4? 0'& =--",#$ "4 $0% =#$'#";? =& '#M"3M'#: '# '$& *%&"3,$'"# #" *%4%*%#-% $" $0% =CC%=*=#-%f#",;%#= +'&$'#-$'"#R )$ '& C*%-'&%3? G%-=,&% "4 $0'& +'&$'#-$'"# G%'#: -%#$*=33? G"*#% '# ;'#+ $0=$ V=#$ '& &" N%%# $" &$*%&& $0=$ 0%*% O% =*% 4=-%+ "#3? O'$0 = C*"G3%; =G",$ $0% -"0%*%#-% "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$R /0% -"#4,&'"#& O0'-0 =*'&% 4*"; ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $0% C*"G3%; "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$ $" G% = C*"G3%; "4 -"#&$'$,$'M% C*'#-'C3%& "--,C'%& V=#$]& =$$%#$'"# '# ddH@^A =#+ 0% &%$& =:='#&$ =33 &,-0 +%=3'#: '# \"7J/,2'G/ *33/#2'"%3X $0% -*'$'-=3 C*"-%+,*% "4 +%;"#&$*=$1 '#: $0% M=3'+'$? "4 $0% ;=('; "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&&R /0% #"$'"# "4 $0'& ;=('; "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& +"%& #"$ =*'&% 4*"; "G&%*1 M'#: #=$,*% =& #=$,*% +"%& #"$ '# '$&%34 C*%&%#$ ,& O'$0 C,*C"&'M% 4"*;&R L=$0%*< O% =++ $0'& -"#-%C$ "4 C,*C"&% '# ",* $0",:0$ \=& = :,'+% 4"* S,+:;%#$ '# *%43%-$'#: "# $0%&% C*"+,-$&] _5NR 6ZAKK`R a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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

5CC3'%+ $" *%43%-$'"#< $0'& C*'#-'C3% '& = ;%*% ;=('; "4 S,+:;%#$Y =#+ $0% -"#-%C$ "4 $0=$ -=,&=3'$? '& = ;%*% '+%=R U% ;=N% #" -3='; $0=$ $0'& '+%= 0=& *%=3'$?< G,$ "#3? ,&% '$ =& = :,'+% 4"* *%43%-$'"#R _5NR 6ZAIK`

O%*% '#$,'$'M% i*=$0%* $0=# +'&-,*&'M%< 'R%R< -"#-%C$,=3j '$ O",3+ 0=M% #" "GS%-$& %(-%C$ =-$,=3 i"#%&j] _5NR 6Z FE@`R /0% *%=&"# V=#$ &=?& $0'& '& $0=$ -"#-%C$& O'$0",$ '#$,'$'"#& =*% ;%*%3? C"&&'G3% O0'3&$ '#$,'$'"#& O'$0",$ -"#-%C$& +%4? $0% =G'3'$? $" -":#'&% _$0% 4"*;%* =*% :'M%# '# )+%=& "4 *%=&"#< $0% 3=$$%* '# =%&$0%$'- )+%=&`R a,$ O0'3&$ 4"* ,& $0%*% '& $0,& = +'44%*%#-% G%$O%%# C"&&'G'3'$? =#+ =-$,=3'$? '$ +"%& #"$ 4"33"O $0=$ $0'& +'&$'#-$'"# '& C=*$ "4 $0% #=$,*% "4 $0'#:& '# $0%;&%3M%&R 2,*$0%*< =& O% 0=M% +'&-"M%*%+ '# !0=C$%* D =G"M%< *%=&"# '# -"#&'+%*'#: #=$,*% =& = O0"3% 0=& $" =&&,;% $0% '+%= $0=$ \$0% "*':'#=3 G=&'& "4 #=$,*% 0=& ,#-"#+'$'"#%+ #%-%&&'$?] _5NR 6ZFEA`R L%=&"# =3&" 0=& $" -"#&'+%* O0%# '$ =CC*"=-0%& #=$,*% C*=-$'-=33?< $0=$ '23 ".% -=,&=3'$? '& ,#-"#+'$'"#%+R a,$Z \$0% i-"#-%C$ "4j 4*%%+"; &%*M%& =& = ,#'M%*&=3 #/)?(*2'G/ C*'#-'C3% G%-=,&% "4 $0% _'# C=*$ &%#&'G3%` -0=*=-$%* "4 ",* #=$,*% =#+ =G'3'$?R R R R /0=$ C*'#-'C3% +"%& #"$ "GS%-$'M%3? +%$%*;'#% $0% -0=*=-$%* "4 4*%%+"; =& = 4"*; "4 -=,&=3'$?Y *=$0%*< =#+ O'$0 #" 3%&& M=3'+'$? $0=# '4 '$ +'+ +" $0=$< '$ ;=N%& $0% *,3% i$0=$ O% ",:0$j $" =-$ =--"*+'#: $" $0=$ '+%= = -";;=#+ 4"* %M%*?"#%] _5NR 6ZFEF`R /0'& &,;;=$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: "4 $0% '+%= "4 4*%%+"; =& = ,#'M%*&=3 *%:,3=$'M% C*'#-'C3% '& ':#"*%+ G? 83,0=* O0%# 0% C*%&%#$& 0'& #"$'"# "4 \=# =#$'#";? "4 =#$'#";'%&]R a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fa6DH^I`6 /0% 4=-$ $0=$ V=#$ '& *%4%**'#: '# $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 4*%%+"; $" = $?C'- "4 -=,&=3'$? '& O0=$ %#=G3%& $0% =--",#$ "4 #",;%#=3 4*%%+"; $" 0=M% &%#&% =3"#:&'+% =# =--",#$ "4 ;%-0=#'-=3 #%-%&&'$?R /0% ';C%*=$'M% #=$,*% "4 ;"*=3'$? $0,& =*'&%& 4*"; $0% &=;% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# C"&&'1 G'3'$? =#+ =-$,=3'$? $0=$ -*%=$%& 4"* ,& = C*"G3%; '# 0"O $" -":#'&% C,*C"&%&R /0%*% '& $0% &=;% G=&'- C*"G3%; ,#+%*3?'#: +'&-,&&'"# "4 $%3%"3":? =& +'&-,&&'"# "4 ;"*=3'$?R 9,&$ =& O% 4'#+ '$ '#+'&C%#&=G3% $"

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .6K

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`R /0'& 3%=+& V=#$ $" O*'$% $0=$ $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 $%3%"3":?Z R R R '& = C*'#-'C3% i$0=$ 0%3C& ,&j ;%*%3? $" =CC3? ,#+%*&$=#+'#: :%#1 %*=33? $" C"&&'G3% "GS%-$& "4 %(C%*'%#-%< #=;%3?< '# $0"&% -=&%& O0%*% O% -=##"$ S,+:% +%$%*;'#=$'M%3? G,$ -=# S,+:% ;%*%3? *%43%-$'M%3?R /0%*%4"*%< %M%# $0",:0 '# $0"&% -=&%& $0% "GS%-$ -=# G% :'M%# '# %(C%*'%#-%< ?%$ O% -=##"$ %M%# 0/2/#1'%*2'G/(: J?0)/ '$ '# -"#4"*;'$? O'$0 $0% '+%= _3%$ =3"#% +" &" O'$0 -";C3%$% =+%J,=-?` G,$ -=# "#3? *%43%-$ "# '$R _5NR 6ZFE6` /0% +'&$'#-$ C*"G3%; O'$0 $%3%"3":? '& $0=$ '$ =CC3'%& $" "GS%-$'M% ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: "4 #=$,*% _#"$ ;%*%3? &,GS%-$'M% +%3':0$ =& O'$0 $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$`R a,$ O0'3&$ '$ +"%& $0'&< =#+ $0%*%G? =CC3'%& $0% *,3%& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: $" #=$,*%< '$ +"%& &" '# &'$,=$'"#& O0%*% +%$%*1 ;'#=$% S,+:;%#$ O",3+ 3%=+ $" '#&"3,G3% -"#$*=+'-$'"#R a,$ $0'& %#$='3& $0=$ \O% ;,&$ 0%*% G% C*%&,CC"&'#: $0% '+%= "4 &";% C"&&'G3% ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: +'44%*%#$ 4*"; $0% 0,;=# "#%] _5NR 6ZFE6`R /0% C*"-%+,*% "4 ",* ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '& =#=3?$'-=33? ,#'M%*&=3 '# ;"M'#: 4*"; C=*$ $" O0"3% =#+ O% +%C%#+ ,C"# = *%-%C$'M% _C=&&'M%` C"O%* "4 '#$,'$'"# O0'-0 '& "*:=#'k%+ G? $0%&% -"#-%C$& "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R a,$ O% -=# -"#-%'M% "4 =# '#$,'$'"# O0'-0 O",3+ #"$ G% *%-%C$'M% G,$ C,*%3? &C"#1 $=#%",& =#+ =-$'M% =#+ $0,& O",3+ G% \= -":#'$'M% C"O%* +'44%*%#$ 4*";< =#+ O0"33? '#+%C%#+%#$ "4< &%#&'G'3'$?] =#+ O0'-0 O",3+ G% \=# ,#+%*1 &$=#+'#: '# $0% ;"&$ :%#%*=3 &%#&% "4 $0% $%*;] _5NR 6ZFED`R /0'& '& $0% #"$'"# O0'-0 83,0=* +%&-*'G%& =& *%&"3M'#: $0% =#$'#";? "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$< $0% #"$'"# "4 =# '#$,'$'M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R /0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 -"#-%'M'#: $0'& +'44%*%#$ $?C% "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '&< 0"O1 %M%*< G=&%+ ,C"# $0% 4=-$ $0=$ O% -=# -"#-%'M% "4 $0% O"*3+ =& C0%#"1 ;%#=3 =#+ $0,& *%:=*+ '$ =& *%&$'#: ,C"# = &,G&$*=$% O0'-0 '& '$& G=&'&R a,$ $0'& #"$'"# "4 =# '#$,'$'M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: +"%& #"$ '# '$&%34 *%&"3M% $0% =#$'#";? =& 83,0=* &,::%&$& G,$ *=$0%* 3%=+& ,& $" G% =G3% $" C"&% '$& $%*;& -"#&'&$%#$3?R V=#$ -"#-3,+%& dHH '# $0% 4"33"O'#: ;=##%*Z

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.DE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

R R R O0%# O% +%=3 O'$0 = $0'#: $0=$ O% ;,&$ S,+:% $" G% = #=$,*=3 C,*C"&% _'R%R< O0%# O% +%=3 O'$0 =# "*:=#'k%+ G%'#:`< $0",:0 O% -=# $*? "# '$ =33 $0% 3=O& "4 ;%-0=#'-=3 C*"+,-$'"# $0=$ O% N#"O "* ;=? ?%$ +'&-"M%*< =#+ $0",:0 O% ;=? '#+%%+ 0"C% $" ;=N% :""+ C*":*%&& O'$0 &,-0 ;%-0=#'-=3 3=O&< ?%$ O% -=# #%M%* i=--",#$j 4"* $0% C"&&'1 G'3'$? "4 &,-0 = C*"+,-$ O'$0",$ =CC%=3'#: $" = G=&'& 4"* '$& C*"+,-$'"# $0=$ '& O0"33? +'&$'#-$ 4*"; $0% ;%-0=#'-=3 "#%< #=;%3?< = -=,&=3'$? $0*",:0 C,*C"&%&R R R R '$ &%%;& $0=$ i./%%j S,+:;%#$ '& J,'$% ,#=G3% $" &$,+?< %M%# '4 '$ *%&$*'-$& '$&%34 $" %(C%*'%#-% =& = :,'+%< i0"Oj &,-0 "GS%-$& =*% C"&&'G3%< O'$0",$ i,&'#:j $0% $%3%"3":'-=3 -"##%-$'"# "4 -=,&%& =#+ %44%-$&R ih%$j '$ =3&" &%%;& $0=$ 4"* %($%*#=3 "GS%-$& =& =CC%=*=#-%& O% -=##"$ C"&&'G3? 4'#+ =# =+%J,=$% G=&'& $0=$ *%4%*& $" C,*C"&%& G,$ '$ &%%;& '#&$%=+ $0=$< %M%# $0",:0 $0'& G=&'& =3&" 3'%& '# #=$,*%< O% ;,&$ &$'33 &%=*-0 4"* '$ "#3? '# #=$,*%]& &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G1 &$*=$%< %M%# $0",:0 =33 C"&&'G3% '#&':0$ '#$" $0=$ &,G&$*=$% '& -,$ "44 4*"; ,& R R R _5NR 6ZFEK^.E` /0'& C%#,3$';=$% &%-$'"# "4 $0% 7'=3%-$'- ;=N%& -3%=* $0% $*,% #=$,*% "4 $0% =#$'#";?R P%-0=#'-=3 3=O& -=##"$ %(C3='# $0% =CC%=*=#-% "4 $0'#:& G%4"*% ,& O0'-0 O% 1?32 S,+:% $" G% #=$,*=3 C,*C"&%&R a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dHI _%#$'$3%+ \T"O $0% 8*'#-'C3% "4 $0% Q#'M%*&=3 P%-0=#'&; "4 P=$$%* =#+ $0% /%3%"3":'-=3 8*'#-'C3% !=# a% L%-"#-'3%+ '# $0% /%-0#'- "4 W=$,*%]`R V=#$ "C%#& $0'& &%-$'"# G? &$=$'#: ?%$ =:='# $0% G=&'& "4 $0% =#$'#";?R 2'*&$< *%=&"# 0=& #" O'&0 $" =G=#+"# $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 ;%-0=#'&; G%-=,&% O'$0",$ '$ $0%*% '& #" C*'#-'C3% "4 %(C3=#=$'"# "4 #=$,*=3 C*"+,-$'"#R 5# =--",#$ O0'-0 G=&%+ %M%*?$0'#: "# =# "*':'#=3 =*-0'$%-$ O",3+ #"$ C*"+,-% C*'#-'C3%& "4 -":#'$'"#R a,$< &%-"#+< *%=&"# $=N%& =& = #%-%&&=*? ;=('; $0=$ O% =+"C$ $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 C,*C"&%&R \a,$ &'#-% $0% J,%&$'"# "4 0"O $0%&% C*"+,-$& i"*:=#'&%+ G%'#:&j =*% C"&&'G3% ;,&$ G% *='&%+ '# $0% %#+<

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .D.

.D@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

b# $0% "$0%* 0=#+< O% -=# 0=M% #" -"#-%C$ "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% %(-%C$ $0% '#+%$%*;'#=$% -"#-%C$ "4 = G=&'& $0=$ ;=N%& '$ C"&&'G3% 4"* ,& $" S,+:% #=$,*% '# $%*;& "4 %;C'*'-=3 3=O&Y G,$ O% -=##"$ +%$%*;'#% $0'& =#? 4,*$0%* G? =#? C*%+'-=$%R )$ 4"33"O& 4*"; $0'& $0=$ O% -=##"$ *%-"#-'3% $0% $O" C*'#-'C3%& "# = G=&'& $0=$ O",3+ =33"O /<8(*%*2'"% _%(C3'-=$'"#`< "# $0% C=*$ "4 0/2/#1'%*2'G/ S,+:;%#$< "4 0"O = C*"+,-$ '& C"&&'G3% '# $%*;& "4 :'M%# 3=O&< G,$ "#3? "# = G=&'& $0=$ =33"O& /<*1'%*2'"% iD#"W#2/#?%)j _%(C"&'$'"#` "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$?< "# $0% C=*$ "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$R 2"* $" %(C3='# i&";%$0'#:j ;%=#& $" +%*'M% i'$j 4*"; = C*'#-'C3%< =#+ 0%#-% O% ;,&$ G% =G3% $" -":#'k% =#+ &$=$% $0'& C*'#-'C3% +'&$'#-$3?R _5NR 6ZF.@` /0% C*'#-'C3% $0=$ ,#'$%& $0% $O" ;=(';& '& #"$ "4 = $?C% $0=$ -=# G% +%$%*;'#=$%3? +%&-*'G%+R )$ '& =# '#+%$%*;'#=$% -"#-%C$R /0'& -"#-%C$ $*=#&-%#+& $0% *%=3; "4 =CC%=*=#-%& =#+ '& $0,& #"$ -":#'k=G3%R \U% -=# "#3? S,+:% $0%; =& G=&%+< '# $%*;& "4 $0% -"##%-$'"# "4 4'#=3 -=,&%&< "# = &,C*%;% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< &" $0=$ #"$0'#: '& $=N%# =O=? 4*"; $0% $%3%"1 3":'-=3 N'#+ "4 %(C3=#=$'"#] _5NR 6ZF.F`R /0% &,C*%;% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '& $0% 4':,*=$'M% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$% =& '#$,'$'M% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R /0'& 4':,*=$'M% C*%1 &%#$=$'"# =33"O& ,& $" &,CC"&% $0=$ G%$O%%# $0% $O" ;=(';& $0%*% '& = \,#'M%*&=3 0=*;"#?] %M%# $0",:0 O% -=##"$ '# =#? O=? -":#'&% $0% G=&'& "4 $0'& 0=*;"#?R b#3? $0,& -=# O% *%&"3M% $0% =#$'#";? O0'-0 *%&"3,$'"# +%C%#+& "# $0% &,G"*+'#=$'"# "4 N#"O3%+:% $" 4='$0 _=& =&&%*$%+ =& =# ';C"*$=#$ *%&,3$ "4 -*'$'J,% =$ a(((`R /0% G=&'& "4 $0'& O=& %(C3='#%+ '# $0% 8*%4=-% $" $0% &%-"#+ %+'$'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%< O0%*% V=#$ +%&-*'G%+ $0% =#=3?&'& "4 $0% _-*'$'-=3` ;%$=C0?&'-'=# =& &%C=*=$'"# "4 C,*% * 8#'"#' N#"O3%+:% '#$" '$& $O" 0%$%*":%#%",& %3%;%#$& =#+ $0% &,G&%J,%#$ %&$=G3'&0;%#$ '# +'=3%-$'- "4 0=*;"#? \O'$0 $0% #%-%&&=*? '+%= "4 $0% ?%,"%0'2'"%/0 +%;=#+%+ G? *%=&"#] _a(('`R )# -"#-3,+'#: $0% \7'=3%-$'- "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$] '# $0'& 4=&0'"# $0%*%4"*% V=#$ +%;"#&$*=$%& = ,#'$? "4 C*"-%+,*% 4*"; $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% $" $0% /0'*+R U0'3&$ 83,0=*]& =--",#$ "4 $0% =#$'#";? '& -3%=*3? -"**%-$ '# ;=#? +%$='3& 0% '& 3%+ $" = ;'&&$=$%;%#$ "4 $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'$ '& S,&$ =& #%-%&&=*? 4"* *%=&"# $" $0'#N = &C%-'=3 N'#+ "4 -=,&=3'$? $0=$ -=##"$ G% 4",#+ '# #=$,*%< =& '$ '& #%-%&&=*? 4"* $0% ;%-0=#'&; "4 #=$,*=3 -=,&%& $" 0=M% '$& "O# -=,&=3'$?] _5NR 6ZF..Y ;? '#$%*C"3=$'"#`R >"Z '@ ./ *#/ 2" #/%0/# 29/ ?3/ "@ 7"29 29/3/ 8#'%,'8(/3 ,"%3'32/%2 .'29 /*,9 "29/# ./ %//0 * @?#29/# 8#'%,'8(/ .9',9 ('/3 7/:"%0 7"29R T"O%M%*Z

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e""+R /0% =#$'#";? "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$< G? -"#$*=&$< 3%=+& ,& $" $0% G=&'& "4 $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% &,G&$*=$% =& "*':'#=3 ,#'$? "4 $0% $O" ;=(';& '# = &,C*%;% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R a,$ $0%*% '& #" \=#$'#";? "4 =#$'#";'%&] G%$O%%# $0% =#$'#";? "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:1 ;%#$ =#+ $0% $0'*+ =#$'#";? "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%R a"$0 =#$'#";'%& =*% *%&"3M%+ G? *%4%*%#-% $" $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# =CC%=*=#-%& =#+ $0'#:& '# $0%;&%3M%& O0'-0 +'&$'#-$'"# =33"O& ,& $" -"#-%'M% "4 = $?C'- "4 -=,&=3'$? '# $0% -=&% "4 4*%%+"; =#+ = $?C'- "4 ,#+%*&$=#+'#: '# $0% -=&% "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$R )# d)) "4 $0% &%-"#+ )#$*"+,-$'"# V=#$ O*"$% $0=$Z \$0%*% ;,&$ G% = G=&'& ?%'2'%) $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% $0=$ ,#+%*3'%& #=$,*% =#+ $0% &,C%*1 &%#&'G3% $0=$ $0% -"#-%C$ "4 4*%%+"; -"#$='#& C*=-$'-=33?< %M%# $0",:0 $0% -"#-%C$ "4 $0'& G=&'& +"%& #"$ *%=-0 -":#'$'"# "4 '$ %'$0%* $0%"*%$'-1 =33? "* C*=-$'-=33?] _5NR 6Z.HD`R /0'& G=&'& '& $0% 3=O $0=$ *%43%-$'M% S,+:1 ;%#$ :'M%& $" '$&%34 O0'-0 '& $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 *%J,'*%;%#$ "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&&R /0'& '& 4'*&$ +'&-,&&%+ G? *%4%*%#-% $" = C3%=&,*% O0'-0 '& #%'$0%* G=&%+ "# $0% &%#&%& #"* = C*"+,-$ "4 =&&"-'=1 $'"# "4 )+%=& "4 *%=&"#< $0% C3%=&,*% O0'-0 G%3"#:& $" $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$R a,$ $0% 4"*; "4 $0'& C3%=&,*% =3&" %#=G3%& ,& $" 4"*; =%&$0%$'- '+%=& O0'-0 -*"&& $0% +'M'+% G%$O%%# *%=&"# _$0% C"O%* "4 '+%=&` =#+ $0% &%#&'G'3'$? _O0'-0 '& :"M%*#%+ '# 3=O G? $0% ,#+%*&$=#+1 '#:`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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B9/ +%2'%"1: "@ F/@(/,2'G/ A?0)1/%2 F/H2#/*2/0 .DA

.DF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

"4 ;=#< G? =#=3":? O'$0 =# ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< ) -=##"$ G? =#=3":? '#4%* $0=$ '$ 0=& $0%&% i&=;%j C*"C%*$'%&Z 4"* '# $0'& -=&% $0% C*'#-'C3% $0=$ =,$0"*'k%& &,-0 =# '#4%*%#-% '& S,&$ O0=$ '& 3=-N'#:< 'R%R< O% +" #"$ 0=M% 8*#'2*3 #*2'"%'3 i&=;%#%&& "4 :*",#+&j 4"* '#-3,+'#: $0% &,C*%;% G%'#: '# "#% =#+ $0% &=;% :%#%*=3 N'#+ =& ;=# _=& *%:=*+& $0%'* *%&C%-$'M% -=,&=3'$'%&`R _5NR 6ZFDF`

K

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

R*0*7%& 855+;#$ +, >-*2.&2 V=#$]& =--",#$ "4 #=$,*=3 &-'%#-% +%C%#+& "# = -"#M'-$'"# $0=$ %44%-$'M% -=,&=$'"# '& $0% "#3? 4"*; "4 -=,&=$'"# $0=$ -=# G% +'&-%*#%+ =& 3=O13'N% '# &$*,-$,*% =#+ ?%$ $0=$ $0'& &$*,-$,*% +%C%#+& "# &";%$0'#: $0=$ -=##"$ G% S,&$'4'%+ G? #=$,*=3 &-'%#-% '$&%34 G,$ ;,&$ :,'+% '$& C*"+,-1 $'"#Z #=;%3?< 4'#=3 -=,&=$'"#< $%3%"3":'-=3 $0'#N'#:R /0% 5#$'#";? $0=$ =*'&%& G%$O%%# ;%-0=#'&; =#+ $%3%"3":? '& O0=$ $0% 7'=3%-$'- "4 /%3%1 "3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$ *%&"3M%+R a,$< O0'3&$ V=#$]& =--",#$ 3%=+& $" = -"#1 M'-$'"# $0=$ $0%*% =*% "#3? $O" &$=#+C"'#$& O'$0 *%:=*+ $" #=$,*=3 -=,&=3'$?< T%:%3 &,::%&$& = -";C3'-=$'"# O0%# 0% '#$*"+,-%& $0% -"#1 -%C$ "4 -0%;'&;R /0'& $0'*+ C*'#-'C3% '&< &$=$%& T%:%3< ,&,=33? =&&';'3=$%+ $" ;%-0=#'&;R a,$ 4"* T%:%3 $0'& =&&';'3=$'"# '& 4,#+=;%#$=33? C*"G3%;=$'-R T%:%3 $=N%& ;%-0=#'&; $" '#M"3M% ;"*% $0=# S,&$ $0% C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 #"#1*%-,*&'M% .D6

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!0%;'&;< BC':%#%&'& =#+ !";;,#'$?

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` "* $0% "#% O0'-0 0=& $0% *%3=$'"# $" $0% "$0%* '& C,*%3? %($%*#=3 $0%*%$" _"#% ;%-0=#'&; =#+ "#% #"#1;%-0=#'-=3 C*'#-'C3%`R /0'& =++'$'"#=3 +%$%*;'#=$'"# "4 ;%-0=#'&; '& O0=$ =33"O& T%:%3 $" &,::%&$ = $0'*+ C*'#-'C3% =3"#:&'+% ;%-0=#'&; =#+ $%3%"3":?R 2"*< '4 ;%-0=#'&; '& 3'4%3%&& =#+ $%3%"3":? +%&-*'G%& $0% C*'#-'C3%& O0'-0 ;,&$ =CC3? $" "*:=#'&;&< $0%*% '& = &$=$% G%$O%%# $0% 3'4%3%&& =#+ $0% 3'4%14'33%+ O0'-0 '& '#$%*=-$'"# G%$O%%# $O" "GS%-$& $0*",:0 = $0'*+Z $0'& $0'*+ &$=$% '& $0=$ "4 G%'#: = -0%;'-=3 %3%;%#$R /0'& %3%;%#$ '& $0% ;%+',; $0*",:0 O0'-0 $0% "GS%-$& -":#'k%+ 4'#+ -";;"# -"##%-$'"#Z '$ '& $0%'* G=&'& "4 '#$%*=-$'"#R U=$%* '& $0% ,3$';=$% &,-0 %3%;%#$ O0'-0 G"$0 C*"M'+%& #,$*'$'"# =#+ =3&" G"+'3? &,G&$=#-% _;=&& G%'#: *%+,-'G3% $0%*%$"`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`R /0% %44%-$ "4 $0% -0%;'-=3 %3%;%#$ "# $0% ,#'$& O0'-0 ;%%$ O'$0'# '$ '& "#% "4 G*'#:'#: $":%$0%*R /0% +'44%*%#-%& G%$O%%# $0% $O" -";C"#%#$& =*% O%=N%#%+ $0*",:0 $0% %#$*? '#$" $0% -";;"# ;%+',; O0'-0 C*"M'+%& = G=&'& "4 '#$%*=-$'"#R /0'& %#&,*%& $0=$ $0% &%C=*=$% C=*$& =-0'%M% = ,#'$? O'$0'# $0% %3%;%#$ O0'-0 "M%*-";%& =#+ +'&C3=-%& $0%'* *%3=$'M% "CC"&'$'"# $" %=-0 "$0%* =& '#+'M'+,=3&R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.DD C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0% ;%-0=#'-=3 M'%O "4 $0% C*"-%&&%& '& "#% "4 *%+,-$'"# "4 %=-0 %3%;%#$ $" = ;%*% =++'$'"# $" "$0%* -";C"#%#$&R /0% ;%-0=#'-=3 =--",#$ "4 %3%;%#$& +"%& #"$< $0%*%4"*%< %(C3='# $0% C*'#-'C3%& "4 $0% "GS%-$& -"#&'+%*%+ =& '$ #%:3%-$& $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% "GS%-$& '& #"$ C,*%3? %($%*#=3 $" $0%;< G,$ '& *=$0%* +%C%#+%#$ '# '$& '#$%*#=3'$? "# %3%;%#$& O0'-0 C*"M'+% '$ O'$0 '$& ;%=#& "4 &,*M'M=3 =#+ '$& "O# C"&&'G'3'$?R b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`R /0% *%C*"+,-$'"# O0'-0 '& $0% %44%-$ "4 $0% -"#S"'#'#: '# $0% ;%+',; 0=& = $O"4"3+ %44%-$Z $0% #%O %3%;%#$ -"#$='#& =& C*"+,-$ C=*$& 4*"; G"$0 '$& C*":%#'$"*& O0'-0 '# $,*# 4'#+ $0%'* &%341&,G&'&$%#-% O%=N%#%+ G? $0% %44"*$ =$ C*"C=:=$'#: $0%'* N'#+R /0,&< '# $0% G*"=+%&$ &%#&%< +%=$0 '& -"#$='#%+ O'$0'# $0% ;%+',; O0'-0 =33"O& 3'4%R a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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=9/1'31T D8')/%/3'3 *%0 ="11?%'2: .DH

.DI C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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

>-*2.&2 "& " 61+M7*2 ,+1 !"#$ /0% %3,-'+=$'"# "4 $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 -0%;'&; '& ,#3'N%3? '# '$&%34 $" -"#M'#-% =#?"#% $0=$ $0'& C*'#-'C3% "44%*& = C*'M'3%:%+ =--%&& $" -";1 C*%0%#+'#: $0% #=$,*% "4 $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# T%:%3 =#+ V=#$R /0% -*'$'-'&; "4 V=#$]& C*=-$'-=3 C0'3"&"C0? G? T%:%3 _C=*$'-,3=*3? '# B9/ E9'("3"89: "@ F')92` '& G? 4=* $0% ;"&$ '#&'&$%+ "# =&C%-$ "4 $0% *%3=$'"#1 &0'C G%$O%%# $0%; =#+ '$ '& '#+%%+ =# ';C"*$=#$ =*%=RA a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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

R R R $0% 3'4% "4 >C'*'$ '& #"$ $0% 3'4% $0=$ &0*'#N& 4*"; +%=$0 =#+ N%%C& '$&%34 ,#$",-0%+ G? +%M=&$=$'"#< G,$ *=$0%* $0% 3'4% $0=$ %#+,*%& '$ =#+ ;='#$='#& '$&%34 '# '$R )$ O'#& '$& $*,$0 "#3? O0%#< '# ,$$%* +'&1 ;%;G%*;%#$< '$ 4'#+& '$&%34R@

;%#=3 %(C%*'%#-% '#$" *%=3;& O0%*% $0%*% -=# G% #" %(C%*'%#$'=3 -3=';& _5F@DfaF6F^5F@KfaF6H`R /0% %44%-$ "4 $0'& 2'*&$ 5#$'#";? &0",3+ $0%*%4"*% G% $" *%M%=3 _=& '& $0% C"'#$ "4 =33 -*'$'J,%`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faIHE` /0'& -'$=$'"# '& 4"33"O%+ G? $0% &$=$%;%#$ $0=$ $0,& 4=* ;%$=C0?&'-& 0=& #"$ G%%# =G3% $" 4*%% '$&%34 4*"; 4"*%':# %3%;%#$& =#+ $0=$ $0'& 0=& ';C%+%+ $0% C*":*%&& "4 '$& '#J,'*?R /0% C*'#-'C3%& $0% ;%$=C0?&'-'=# &0",3+ 0=M% G%%# +'&-%*#'#: *%J,'*% = -3%=* =#+ &0=*C ,#+%*&$=#+'#: "4 $0% +'44%*%#$'=$'"# "4 * 8#'"#' 4*"; * 8"32/#'"#' %3%;%#$& =#+ $0% -";C*%1 0%#&'"# "4 $0% $?C%& "4 * 8#'"#' C*'#-'C3%& $0=$ %('&$ _+'&$'#:,'&0'#: $0%*%O'$0 &?#$0%$'- 4*"; =#=3?$'- * 8#'"#']&` O=& $0% -%#$*=3 $=&N "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%R /0'& O"*N '& +%C%#+%#$ '# '$& $,*# "# = /*=#&-%#1 +%#$=3 7"-$*'#% "4 B3%;%#$& O0'-0 C*"M'+%& ,& O'$0 $0% ;%=#& G? O0'-0 *%=&"# 4"*;,3=$%& '$& "O# -";C*%0%#&'"# "4 '$&%34 =#+< S,&$ =& ';C"*$1 =#$3?< *%M%=3& $0% #=$,*% "4 *%=&"#]& &%341+%-%C$'"# $" *%3? ,C"# '$& ;'($,*% "4 $0%&% %3%;%#$&< = ;'($,*% +%%;%+ G? V=#$ '#%M'$=G3%R /0% !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0? $0,& *%&$& ,C"# =# =*-0'$%-$"#'- $0=$ -=# G% +%&-*'G%+ =& =# %3%;%#$"3":? "4 $0",:0$R a,$ O0'3&$ $0'& '& &" '# :%#%*=3 $%*;&< 0"O +"%& V=#$ =++*%&& $0% -0=*:% $0=$ 0'& C0'3"&"C0? #%:3%-$& $" ,#-"M%* $0% %3%;%#$& O0'-0 ;=N%& C"&&'G3% $0% $0",:0$ "4 &C%-'%& $" -";C*%0%#+ $0% '#$%*1*%3=$'"# "4 "*:=#'&;&X /0% =#&O%* $" $0'& J,%&1 $'"# *%M%=3& = C*"4",#+ =#+ &-=*-%3? %(C3"*%+ -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# V=#$ =#+ T%:%3 =#+ '& 4",#+ '# $0% %3=G"*=$'"# "4 $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 %C':%#%&'&R

3).0*#*&.& "#4 >-*2.&2C N.1&$ >+2)"1.&+# /"O=*+& $0% -3"&% "4 $0% a17%+,-$'"# "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% V=#$ O*'$%&Z /0%*% =*% "#3? $O" O=?& '# O0'-0 O% -=# =--",#$ 4"* = %/,/33*#: =:*%%;%#$ "4 %(C%*'%#-% O'$0 $0% -"#-%C$& "4 '$& "GS%-$&Z %'$0%*

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=9/1'31T D8')/%/3'3 *%0 ="11?%'2: .DK

%(C%*'%#-% ;=N%& $0%&% -"#-%C$& C"&&'G3% "* $0%&% -"#-%C$& ;=N% %(C%*'%#-% C"&&'G3%R /0% 4"*;%* &,CC"&'$'"# +"%& #"$ 0"3+ '# *%&C%-$ "4 $0% -=$%:"*'%& _#"* "4 C,*% &%#&'G3% '#$,'$'"#`Y 4"* &'#-% $0%? =*% * 8#'"#' -"#-%C$&< =#+ $0%*%4"*% '#+%C%#+%#$ "4 %(C%*'%#-%< $0% =&-*'C1 $'"# $" $0%; "4 =# %;C'*'-=3 "*':'# O",3+ G% = &"*$ "4 )/%/#*2'" */>?'G",*R /0%*% *%;='#&< $0%*%4"*%< "#3? $0% &%-"#+ &,CC"&'$'"# ^ = &?&$%;< =& '$ O%*%< "4 $0% /8')/%/3'3 "4 C,*% *%=&"# ^ #=;%3?< $0=$ $0% -=$%:"*'%& -"#$='#< "# $0% &'+% "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< $0% :*",#+& "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =33 %(C%*'%#-% '# :%#%*=3R _a.DH` /" G%:'# =&&%&&'#: V=#$]& C"&&'G3% *%&C"#&% $" $0% $0'*+ C*'#-'C3% T%:%3 C3=-%& =3"#:&'+% ;%-0=#'&; =#+ $%3%"3":? '$ '& #%-%&&=*? $" *%3=$% $0'& =--",#$ "4 =# /8')/%/3'3 "4 C,*% *%=&"# =3"#:&'+% &";% *%;=*N& =$ $0% "C%#'#: "4 $0% P%$0"+"3":? "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$R )# = 4""$#"$% $" dIE V=#$ +%&-*'G%& )/%/#*2'" */>?'G",* =& \$0% C*"+,-$'"# "4 =# "*:=#1 'k%+ G%'#: G? $0% ;%-0=#'-& "4 -*,+%< ,#"*:=#'k%+ ;=$$%*] _5NR 6ZF@E`R /0'& O=& 3=$%* +%&-*'G%+ =& $0% $0%"*? "4 &C"#$=#%",& :%#%*=$'"#R V=#$ O",3+ G% ,#=G3% $" =--%C$ &,-0 = $0%"*? :'M%# $0% #%-%&&'$? 4"* 0'; "4 $%3%"3":'-=3 C*'#-'C3%&R /0% "$0%* $0%"*? ;%#$'"#%+ '# dIE O=& )/%/#*2'" ?%'G",* ;%=#'#: $0=$ \=#?$0'#: "*:=#'- O",3+ G% C*"+,-%+ "#3? 4*"; &";%$0'#: %3&% $0=$ '& =3&" "*:=#'-] _5NR 6ZF@E`R /0'& '& O0? '# dI. "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 V=#$ $,*#& $" =&&%&&'#: $0% J,%&$'"# "4 $0% $%3%"3":'-=3 C*"+,-$'"# "4 "*:=#'&%+ G%'#:& '# :%#%*=3 ,C"# = ?%'G",* "C$'"# =#+ +'&-,&&%& $0%*% $0% =3$%*#=$'M% $?C%& "4 $0'& 0?C"$0%&'&Z "--=&'"#=3'&; =#+ C*%1%&$=G3'&0%+ 0=*;"#?R V=#$ ';;%+'=$%3? *%S%-$& "--=&'"#=3'&; =& '$ *%J,'*%& ,& $" 3%=M% =&'+% =33 $0",:0$ "4 #=$,*=3 -=,&=$'"# =#+ 3=C&%& '#$" $0% &,C%*&%#&'G3% 4"* %(C3=1 #=$'"#< =& 0% C,$& '$< \"4 %M%*? -"C,3=$'"#] _5NR 6ZF@@`R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& 0% ",$3'#%& 4"* ;"*% &%*'",& -"#&'+%*=$'"# $0% $0%"*? "4 C*%1%&$=G3'&0%+ 0=*;"#?R a,$ $0%*% =*% $O" M%*? +'&$'#-$ $?C%& "4 $0'& $0%"*? +%C%#+'#: ,C"# $0% O=? O% M'%O $0% =-$ "4 4"*;=$'"# "4 =# "*:=#'&; G? =#"$0%* "*:=#'&;R /0% C*":%#'$"* -=# %'$0%* 8#"+,-% $0% C*"+,-$ _G*'#:'#: 4"*$0 $0% 4"*; "4 $0% $0'#:` "* ;%*%3? /+,-% '$ _+*=O ",$ &";%$0'#: $0=$ 0=& = 4"*; =3*%=+? C*%+%$%*;'#%+ 4"* '$`R /0% $0%"*? "4 C*%1%&$=G3'&0%+ 0=*;"#? $0=$ *%:=*+& $0% "*:=#'&; =& = C*"+,-$ '& -=33%+ = &?&$%; "4 /8')/%/3'3 =& "CC"&%+ $" $0% $0%"*? "4 \%M"3,$'"#] $0=$ ,#+%*3=?& $0% #"$'"# "4 $0% %+,-$R _T%*% $0% $%*; \%M"3,$'"#] ;%=#& $0=$ $0%*% '& #" -*%=$'M% %3%;%#$ '# $0% +%M%3"C;%#$ O0'-0 ;%*%3? 4"33"O& = C=$$%*# &%$ 4"* '$ '# =+M=#-%R` /0% %C':%#%$'=--",#$ '& $0%# 4,*$0%* +%&-*'G%+ =& = &?&$%; "4 :%#%*'- C*%4"*;=$'"# \&'#-% $0% C*"+,-$'M% C"O%* "4 $0% :%#%*=$'#: G%'#:&< =#+ $0%*%4"*% $0%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.HE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

4"*; "4 $0% &C%-'%&< O=& &$'33 C*%4"*;%+ G'#2?*('2/# '# $0% '#$*'#&'- C,*C"1 &'M% C*%+'&C"&'$'"#& ';C=*$%+ $" $0% &$"-N] _5NR 6ZF@A`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` )4 $0% C*%4"*;=$'"# '& =$$=-0%+ $" $0% '#+'M'+,=3 "*:=#'&; $0%# =33 -"##%-$'"# '&< '# T%:%3]& &%#&% "4 $0% $%*;< ;%-0=#'-=3R /0=$ '&< '$ '& = C,*% '#$%*=-$'"# O'$0",$ '#$%*#=3 -"##%-$'"#R a,$ '# $0=$ -=&% 0"O -",3+ 0?G*'+& =*'&%X /0%*%4"*%< $0% %M"3,$'"#'&$ O=& +*'M%# $" =+;'$ $0=$ '# &";% -=&%& $0%*% ;,&$ G% =# =-$ C%*4"*;%+ G? $0% C=*%#$ "4 $0% #%O1G"*# =#+ $0'& =-$ _"4 &C%*;=$'- C"O%*`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` C,&0< '& &';C3? %(C3='#=G3%R /0% "*':'#=3 G=&'& "4 $0'& /8')/%/3'3 '& =3&" %#$'$3%+ G? V=#$ _4"33"O'#: 0%*% $0% 3%=+ "4 a3,;%#G=-0` = 4"*;=$'M% ';C,3&% _6'(0?%)32#'/7`R a,$ '# $0% =-$,=3 =CC%=*=#-% "4 #=$,*=3 "*:=#'&;& $0%*% '& 4"* V=#$ "#3? "#% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# $0%; '# O0'-0 O% 4'#+ $0% -0%;'-=3 %3%;%#$ ;=#'1 4%&$%+Z /0%*% '& "#3? "#% i-=&% O0%*%j %($*'#&'- C,*C"&'M%#%&& '& -"##%-$%+ O'$0 $0% '#$*'#&'- C,*C"&'M%#%&& "4 "*:=#'k=$'"#R /0'& i-=&%j '& $0% "*:=#'&=$'"# "4 $0% $O" &%(%& =& *%3=$%+ $" %=-0 "$0%* $" C*"C=:=

%$10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=9/1'31T D8')/%/3'3 *%0 ="11?%'2: .H.

$0%'* &C%-'%&R T%*%< =3$0",:0 O% ;,&$ #"$ =&N O0=$ '& $0% %#+ 4"* O0'-0 $0% G%'#: 0=+ $" %('&$ i=&j &" "*:=#'&%+< i$0=$ G%'#:j &$'33 &%*M%& =& = ;%=#& %($*'#&'-=33? *%3=$%+ $" = C,*C"&%R 2"* 0%*%< S,&$ =& '# $0% -=&% "4 =# '#+'M'+,=3< O% -=# =3O=?& :" "# $" =&NZ U0? +'+ &,-0 = C='* 0=M% $" %('&$X /0% =#&O%* '&Z /0'& C='* '& O0=$ 4'*&$ =;",#$& $" =# "#)*%'3'%) O0"3%< %M%# '4 #"$ $" =# "*:=#'k%+ O0"3% '# = &'#:3% G"+?R _5NR 6ZF@6`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

'-* 'P+ '()*& +, 3).0*#*&.& /0% -'$=$'"# 4*"; $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%]& a17%+,-$'"# :'M%# =G"M% '#+'-=$%+ $0=$ 4"* V=#$ $0% C*"-%&& "4 C,*% *%=&"# '$&%34 '& "#% "4 )/%/#*2'" ?%'G",*R /0'& -"##%-$& $" $0% :%#%*=3 +%;"#&$*=$'"# :'M%# '# !0=C$%* H =G"M% $0=$ $0% !*'$'-=3 >?&$%; '& =& = O0"3% = &?&$%; "4 %#+& "* = e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faIDA`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.H@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0% 4'*&$ =CC%=*=#-% "4 *%=&"#< 3'N% $0% 3"O3'%&$ 4"*;& "4 3'4%< '& =& = ;%*% =&&%;G3=:% "4 *=O ;=$%*'=3 O'$0 &-=#$ "* #" "*+%*R a,$ S,&$ =& $0'& =CC%=*=#-% '& +%-%C$'M% 4"* $0% #=$,*% "4 *%=&"# &" O",3+ '$ G% 4=3&% $" ,#+%*&$=#+ 3"O3? "*:=#'&;& '# $0'& 4=&0'"#R /0% &?&$%; "4 C,*% *%=&"# $=N%& '$& &,&$%#=#-% 4*"; $0'#N%*& =#+ +%M%3"C& $0*",:0 -"##%-$'"# O'$0 $0% ,3$';=$% %#+& "4 *%=&"#R /0%&% ,3$';=$% %#+& =*% $0% %3%;%#$ "4 $0",:0$ O0'-0 ;,&$ &,&$='# =#+ +%&$*"? :'M%# &?&$%;& '# $0% +%M%31 "C;%#$ "4 $0% C,*C"&%& "4 *%=&"# '$&%34R 5#$0"#? e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dI@ =#+ '#+'-=$% C*"M'&'"#=33? $0% #=$,*% "4 $0% =#&O%* $" '$ $0=$ O% -=# %(C%-$R >%-$'"# I@ +'&-,&&%& $0% %($*'#&'- C,*C"&'M%#%&& ;=#'4%&$%+ '# #=$,*% =#+ '& $0% &",*-% "4 $0% -'$=$'"# %=*3'%* :'M%# =G",$ $0% &%(,=31*%C*"+,-1 $'M% *%3=$'"# O0'-0 ) '#$%*C*%$%+ =& = $*,3? -0%;'-=3 %3%;%#$ "4 V=#$]& =--",#$R B($*'#&'- C,*C"&'M%#%&& '& +%4'#%+ 0%*% =& \= C,*C"&'M%#%&& O0%*% "#% $0'#: "4 #=$,*% &%*M%& =#"$0%* =& = ;%=#& $" = C,*C"&%] _5NR 6ZF@6`R /0% G=&'- %3%;%#$& "4 =33 -*%=$,*%& _O0'-0 =*% $0% -0%;'-=3 :*",#+ "4 $0%;` =*% 3'&$%+ ,#+%* $0'& 0%=+'#:Z O=$%*< ='* =#+ %=*$0R /0%&% %3%;%#$& =*% $0%;&%3M%& -=C=G3% "4 G%'#: S,+:%+ $%3%"3":'-=33? '#=&;,-0 =& $0%? C*"M'+% $0% :*",#+ 4"* "*:=#'&;&R a,$ %M%# O0%# O%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=9/1'31T D8')/%/3'3 *%0 ="11?%'2: .HA

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` /*=#&-%#+'#: $0'& C%*&C%-$'M% *%J,'*%&< =& =3*%=+? #"$%+< C*'#-'C3%& "4 = &,C%*&%#&'G3% $?C%R

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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.HF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

$" T%:%3]& :%#%*=3 C"&$,3=$% "4 >C'*'$ O0'-0 '& $0% 3'4% "4 ;'#+ =& +%=$0 "4 ;'#+ '# 0'&$"*?R a? -"#$*=&$< /8')/%/3'3 '& +%$%*;'#%+ '# $O" +'&$'#-$ O=?&Z =& $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"# $0=$ *%=&"# =*'&%& "#3? 4*"; '$&%34 =#+ -=# 0=M% #" "*':'# '# =#?$0'#: %3&% =#+ =& $0% =*:,;%#$ $0=$ "*:=#'- %('&$%#-% -=##"$ =*'&% 4*"; #"#1"*:=#'- %('&$%#-%R a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a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b#-% O% #"$% $0=$ $0'& '& $0% -=&%< $0%# O% -=# G%:'# $" 4"33"O $0'& 0'#$ 4,*$0%* =#+ *%"C%# $0% J,%&$'"# "4 V=#$]& *%3=$'"#&0'C $" e%*;=# )+%=3'&;R /0'& *%3=$'"#&0'C #%%+& $" G% $0",:0$ '# *%3=$'"# $" $0% $O'# J,%&$'"#& "4 $0% ,#'$? "4 C*'#-'C3%& G%$O%%# *%=&"# =#+ 3'4% =#+ $0% $0",:0$ "4 -";;,#'$? '# :%#%*=3R /0% G=&'& "4 $0% ,#'$? G%$O%%# *%=&"# =#+ 3'4% '# V=#$ '& -3%=*3? $0=$

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=9/1'31T D8')/%/3'3 *%0 ="11?%'2: .H6

G"$0 +%C%#+ "# $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 C,*C"&'M%#%&& =#+ $0=$ C,*C"&'M%#%&& -=##"$ G% %(C3='#%+ G? *%4%*%#-% $" =#? "$0%* C*'#-'C3% $0=# '$&%34R a,$ T%:%3]& &=3,$=*? '#&'&$%#-% "# $0% C*'#-'C3% "4 -0%;'&; +"%& G*'#: ",$ $0=$ #%'$0%* *%=&"# #"* 3'4% -=# G% -";C*%0%#+%+ %(-%C$ $0*",:0 $0% C"&$,3=$'"# "4 ;%+',;& "4 -"##%-$'"#R /0'& 4=-$ *%J,'*%& *%4%*%#-% $" &,G&$=#$'=3 +'&-,&&'"#& "4 -";;,#'$?R )# -3"&'#: $0'& -0=C$%* ) O'33 *%M'&'$ $0% =--",#$& "4 -";;,#'$? C*"M'+%+ G? V=#$ C*'"* $" O*'$'#: $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2R

!"#$ +# >+22;#.$( )# $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,%]& $=G3% "4 -=$%:"*'%& V=#$ C*%&%#$& -";;,#'$? =& $0% $0'*+ -=$%:"*? "4 *%3=$'"#R /0% $0'*+ -=$%:"*? '# %=-0 &%*'%& '& &='+ $" \=3O=?& =*'&% 4*"; $0% -";G'#=$'"# "4 $0% &%-"#+ -=$%:"*? O'$0 $0% 4'*&$] _a..E` =#+ -";;,#'$? '& $0%*%4"*% \$0% -=,&=3'$? "4 &,G&$=#-%& *%-'C*"1 -=33? +%$%*;'#'#: %=-0 "$0%*] _a...`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faKK` T"O%M%*< 0=M'#: &%$ ",$ $0% +%*'M=$'"# "4 $0% -=$%:"*'%& 4*"; $0% $=G3% "4 S,+:;%#$< V=#$ -"#4%&&%& $0=$ $0% +%*'M=$'"# "4 -";;,#'$? 4*"; +'&S,#-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '& \#"$ =& %M'+%#$ =& '# $0% -=&% "4 $0% "$0%*&] _a..@`R /0% +%;"#&$*=$'"# $0=$ $0'& +%*'M=$'"# '& -"**%-$ C*"-%%+& 4*";

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.HD C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

*%&$=$'#: $0=$ = +'&S,#-$'M% S,+:;%#$ '#M"3M%& $0% -";C*%0%#&'"# $0=$ $0% C=*$& -":#'&%+ =*% \$0",:0$ =& -"1"*+'#=$%+ O'$0< #"$ &,G"*+'#=$%+ $"< %=-0 "$0%*< =#+ &" =& +%$%*;'#'#: %=-0 "$0%*< #"$ '# "#% +'*%-$'"# "#3?< =& '# = &%*'%&< G,$ *%-'C*"-=33?< =& '# =# =::*%:=$%] _a..@`R /0'& *%-'C*"-=3 +%$%*;'#=$'"# '& C*%-'&%3? $0% ;%=#'#: "4 -";;,#'$?R V=#$ +%*'M%& 4*"; -";;,#'$? = &-0%;= O0'-0 '& \$0% -"%('&$%#-%< =--"*+'#: $" = ,#'M%*&=3 *,3%< "4 $0% +%$%*;'#=$'"#& "4 $0% "#% &,G&$=#-% O'$0 $0"&% "4 $0% "$0%*] _5.FFfa.IA^F`R /0%*% '& =3&" = C*'#-'C3% O0'-0 -";%& O'$0 $0'& &-0%;= =#+ O0'-0 '& %(C*%&&%+ '# $0% /0'*+ 5#=3":? "4 B(C%*'%#-% =& $0% C"'#$ $0=$ &,G&$=#-%& \&" 4=* =& $0%? -"%('&$< &$=#+ '# $0"*",:0:"'#: -";;,#'$?< $0=$ '&< '# ;,$,=3 '#$%*=-$'"#] _5@..` "* \=*% '# $0"*",:0:"'#: *%-'C*"-'$?] _a@6D`R /0'& 4=-$ -=##"$ G% +%*'M%+ C,*%3? 4*"; $0% %;C'*'-=3 &?#$0%&'& "4 =CC*%0%#&'"# _"* *%C*"+,-$'"#` '# ';=1 :'#=$'"# G,$ *%J,'*%& \= C,*% -"#-%C$] _a@6H`R /0,& $0% -";'#: $":%$0%* "4 &,G&$=#-%& '# -";;,#'$? +%C%#+& "# =# * 8#'"#' -"#-%C$ "4 '#$%*=-1 $'"# O0'-0 C*"M'+%& \$0% -"#+'$'"# "4 $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% $0'#:& $0%;&%3M%& =& "GS%-$& "4 %(C%*'%#-%] _a@6I`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` =& $0'& '& $0% 4%%3'#: "4 *%&C%-$ 4"* =#"$0%* =#+ $0% %#$%*'#: $0%*%O'$0 '#$" -";;,#'$? O'$0 0'; "# ,#'M%*&=3 *=$'"#=3 :*",#+&R /0'& 4=-$ "4 *%=&"# ^ $0% 4%%3'#: "4 *%&C%-$ =& = &,C%*&%#&'G3? C*"+,-%+ &$=:% "4 =44%-$'"# ^ '& O0=$ %#=G3%& = M'&'"# "4 ;"*=3 -";;,#'$?R /0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% $0,& C*"M'+%& $0% -"#+'$'"#& 4"* $0'#N'#: "4 ;"*=3 -";;,#'$?< G,$ '$ +"%& #"$ %(C3'-=$% $0% #"$'"# "4 ;"*=3 -";1 ;,#'$?< #"* +"%& '$ *%3=$% $0'& C"&&'G'3'$? $" $0% J,%&$'"# "4 %;C'*'-=3

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=9/1'31T D8')/%/3'3 *%0 ="11?%'2: .HH

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a%=,$? O0'-0 3=$$%* C*"M'+%& ,& O'$0 = -=#"# 4"* $0% =CC*%-'=$'"# "4 =*$R e'M%# $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 :%#',& O% -=# #"$% $0=$ V=#$]& =--",#$ :'M%& &%#&% $" $0% #"$'"# "4 = -=#"# =$ $0% &=;% $';% =& -":#'k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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.HI C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

O"*N =#+ $0*%=$%#& $" *%+,-% '$ $" = ;%*% -"#4"*;'$? O'$0 = C*%1:'M%# &$=#+=*+ =#+ $0,& $" =-$ =& +%$%*;'#=$'M%R /=N'#: $0% &$=#+=*+& "4 $=&$% =& +%$%*;'#=$'M% '& = *=$'"#=3'&$ %**"* "4 =CC*%-'=$'"#R /0% +",G3% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% &$=#+=*+& "4 $=&$% =& G"$0 %#=G3'#: =#+ $0*%=$%#'#: "4 =*$]& C*"+,-$'"# '#+'-=$%& $0=$ $0%&% &$=#+=*+& =-$ =& = N'#+ "4 -0%;'-=3 %3%;%#$R T"O%M%*< $0% #=$,*% "4 $0'& %3%;%#$ =#+ $0% 4"*;=$'"# "4 $0%&% &$=#+=*+& '# =-$,=3'$? =*% #"$ 4,33? %(C3='#%+ '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2R /" -";C*%0%#+ $0%; '& $" $0'#N =G",$ $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# $0% $%3%"3":'-=3 C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =*$ =#+ $0% =%&$0%$'- C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =CC*%-'=$'"# "4 G%=,$?R /0% ,#'4'-=$'"# "4 $0%&% C"&&'G'3'$'%& '# :%#%*=3 $%*;& =#+ $0% -"#+'$'"#& 4"* $0%'* &,--%&& =#+ 4='3,*% '# :'M%# '#&$=#-%& *%;='#& $" G% $0",:0$R )# -"#-3,&'"# ) O'&0 $" C"&% $O" J,%&$'"#& =G",$ -";;,#'$?R 2'*&$< +"%& V=#$]& C*=-$'-=3 $0",:0$ "4 -";;,#'$? *%-%'M% =# =*$'-,3=$'"# C*'"* $" 0'& +"-$*'#=3 O"*N "4 = $?C% O0'-0 %#=G3%& ,& $" *%3=$% $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% $" '$X >%-"#+< O0=$ +"%& $0% $0",:0$ "4 -";;,#'$? 0=M% $" +" O'$0 $0% J,%&$'"# "4 %&-0=$"3":?X /0'& &%-"#+ J,%&$'"# O'33 G% $=N%# $" G% N%? $" $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 =--",#$'#: 4"* V=#$]& O0"3% !*'$'-=3 %#+%=M",* =#+ O'33 %#=G3% $0% C*%-'&% C"&'#: "4 J,%&$'"#& =G",$ $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C "4 !*'$'-=3 C0'3"&"C0? $" +"-$*'#=3 C0'3"&"C0?R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=9/1'31T D8')/%/3'3 *%0 ="11?%'2: .HK

.E

/0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# $0% $O" C=*$& "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% -=# #"O G% *%C"&%+R /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2]& -,3;'#=$'"# '# $0% &?;G"3'0?C"$?C"&'& "4 ;"*=3'$? *='&%+ = &':#'4'-=#$ -"##%-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% =%&$0%$'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ =#+ $0% $?C'- "4 C*=-$'-=3 *%=&"#R /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 -=# #"O G% &%%# $" 0=M% *%"C%#%+ $0% J,%&$'"# "4 *%=&"#]& &%341:%#%*=$'"# '# *%3=$'"# $" $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 -":#'$'"# "4 #=$,*%R a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dIA "4 $0% O"*NZ \b# /0% Q3$';=$% 8,*C"&% /0=$ W=$,*% T=& =& = /%3%"3":'-=3 >?&$%;]R U% 0%*% .IE

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

B&-0=$"3":? =#+ $0% B#+& "4 !,3$,*%

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b# $0% 4'*&$ =3$%*#=$'M% $0% C,*C"&% "4 #=$,*% O",3+ G% ;=#]& 9*88'%/33< "# $0% &%-"#+ 0'& ,?(2?#/] _5NR 6ZFAE`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` C*"+,-%+ G? -"#43'-$& "4 =CC%$'$%&R \T%#-% %M%# '4 #=$,*% ",$&'+% ,& O%*% ,$$%*3? G%#%4'-%#$< '$& C,*C"&% O",3+ #"$ G% =-0'%M%+ '# = &?&$%; "4 #=$,*% "# %=*$0 '4 $0=$ C,*C"&% =';%+ =$ $0% 0=CC'#%&& "4 ",* &C%-'%&< G%-=,&% #=$,*% O'$0'# ,& '& #"$ *%-%C$'M% $" '$] _5NR 6ZFAE`R T=CC'#%&&< -"#&'+%*%+ =& = C*"+,-$ "4 #=$,*% '$&%34< 0%#-% =& = &%$ "4 &%#&=$'"#=3 -";C"#%#$&< '& '#-=C=G3% "4 C*"M'+'#: ,& O'$0 =# ,3$';=$% ='; 4"* $0% %('&$%#-% "4 #=$,*%R U% =*%< =& -*%=$,*%&< =& =3*%=+? ;%#1 $'"#%+< =& ;,-0 ;%=#& $" $0% #=$,*=3 0=CC'#%&& "4 "$0%* -*%=$,*%& =& $0%? =*% ;%=#& $" $0% &=$'&4=-$'"# "4 ",* =CC%$'$%&R )4 $0%*% '& = G=&'& '# $0% C"&&%&&'"# "4 *%=&"# C*"M'+'#: 0,;=#'$? O'$0 = $'$3% "M%* $0% *%&$ "4 #=$,*%< $0%# $0'& G=&'& '& &,GS%-$ $" = -"#+'$'"#Z \0% i;=#j ;,&$ 0=M% $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: =#+ $0% O'33 $" :'M% G"$0 #=$,*% =#+ 0';&%34 *%4%*%#-% $" = C,*C"&% $0=$ -=# G% '#+%C%#+%#$ "4 #=$,*%< &%341&,44'-'%#$< =#+ = 4'#=3 C,*C"&%] _5NR 6ZFA.`R /0'& %#$='3& $0=$ #=$,*% +"%& #"$ -"#$='# =# ,3$'1 ;=$% ='; =& = &';C3% ';;=#%#$ $%#+%#-?< G,$ *=$0%* C*"+,-%& '# $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 *%=&"# =# %#+ O0'-0 C"'#$& G%?"#+ '$&%34R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .I.

/0% ;=$$%* "4 0,;=# C,*C"&%& '& 0=CC'#%&&< G,$ $0% 4"*; "4 0,;=# C,*C"&%& -"#&'&$& '# $0% -=C=-'$? $" &%$ C,*C"&%& =$ =33R \8*"+,-'#: '# = *=$'"#=3 G%'#: =# =C$'$,+% 4"* C,*C"&%& :%#%*=33? _0%#-% i'# = O=? $0=$ 3%=M%&j $0=$ G%'#: 4*%%` '& ,?(2?#/] _5NR 6ZFA.`R !,3$,*% '&< $0%*%4"*%< $0% ,3$';=$% %#+ "4 $0% &C%-'%& =#+ "4 #=$,*% =& = O0"3%R !,3$,*% '& $0% ,3$';=$% ,#'$? "4 4*%%+"; =#+ 3=OR /0%*% =*% $O" $?C%& "4 -,3$,*% =#+ $0% *%3=$'"#1 &0'C G%$O%%# $0%; '& O"*$0 %(=;'#'#: =$ -"#&'+%*=G3% 3%#:$0Z /0% -,3$,*% "4 3-'(( '& '#+%%+ $0% 4"*%;"&$ &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"# 4"* =# =C$'$,+% $" C*";"$% i7/@"W#0/#%j C,*C"&%& :%#%*=33?Y G,$ '$ '& #"$ =+%1 J,=$% $" =&&'&$ i7/@"W#0/#%j $0% .'(( '# $0% +%$%*;'#=$'"# =#+ &%3%-$'"# "4 '$& C,*C"&%&< O0'3% ?%$ $0% O'33]& +%$%*;'#=$'"# =#+ &%3%-$'"# "4 '$& C,*C"&%& '& &,*%3? =# %&&%#$'=3 C=*$ "4 ",* %#$'*% =C$'$,+% 4"* C,*1 C"&%&i< =#+ '& $0% "$0%* -"#+'$'"#< G%&'+%& &N'33< "4 $0'& =C$'$,+%jR /0'& "$0%* -"#+'$'"# -",3+ G% -=33%+ $0% -,3$,*% "4 +'&-'C3'#% i[?,92 _$'3Y'8('%`jR )$ '& #%:=$'M% =#+ -"#&'&$& '# $0% 3'G%*=$'"# "4 $0% O'33 4*"; $0% +%&C"$'&; "4 +%&'*%&< = +%&C"$'&; $0=$ *'M%$& ,& $" -%*$='# #=$,*=3 $0'#:& =#+ *%#+%*& ,& ,#=G3% $" +" ",* "O# &%3%-$'#:Y O% =33"O ",*&%3M%& $" G% 4%$$%*%+ G? $0% ';C,3&%& $0=$ #=$,*% :=M% ,& "#3? =& :,'+%& &" $0=$ O% O",3+ #"$ #%:3%-$ "* %M%# '#S,*% ",* =#';=3 -0=*=-$%*'&$'-&< O0%*%=& '# 4=-$ O% =*% 4*%% %#",:0 $" $':0$%# "* $" &3=-N%#< $" 3%#:$0%# "* $" &0"*$%# $0%;< =& $0% C,*C"&%& "4 *%=&"# *%J,'*%R _5NR 6ZFA.^@` /0'& +'&$'#-$'"# '# dIA '& C=*=33%3%+ G? V=#$]& +%&-*'C$'"# "4 $0% *%3=$'"#1 &0'C G%$O%%# :%#',& =#+ $=&$% '# d6EZ /=&$%< 3'N% $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$ '# :%#%*=3< -"#&'&$& '# +'&-'C3'#'#: _"* $*='#'#:` :%#',&R )$ &%M%*%3? -3'C& '$& O'#:&< =#+ ;=N%& '$ -'M'3'k%+< "* C"3'&0%+Y G,$ =$ $0% &=;% $';% '$ :'M%& '$ :,'+=#-% =& $" 0"O 4=* =#+ "M%* O0=$ '$ ;=? &C*%=+ O0'3% &$'33 *%;='#'#: C,*C"&'M% R R R R /0%*%1 4"*%< '4 $0%*% '& = -"#43'-$ G%$O%%# $0%&% $O" C*"C%*$'%& '# = C*"+,-$< =#+ &";%$0'#: 0=& $" G% &=-*'4'-%+< $0%# '$ &0",3+ G% *=$0%* "# $0% &'+% "4 :%#',&Y =#+ S,+:;%#$< O0'-0 '# ;=$$%*& i5*,9/%j "4 4'#% =*$ G=&%& '$& C*"#",#-%;%#$& "# C*'#-'C3%& "4 '$& "O#< O'33 &""#%* C%*;'$ $0% ';=:'#=$'"#]& 4*%%+"; =#+ O%=3$0 $" G% ';C='*%+ $0=# $0=$ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: G% ';C='*%+R _5NR 6ZA.K^@E` /0'& C*%4%*%#-% 4"* +'&-'C3'#% "M%* &N'33< $=&$% "M%* :%#',&< 43"O& 3":'-=33? 4*"; $0% +'&-3"&,*% $0=$ &%#&=$'"# -=##"$ '# '$&%34 G% $0% ,3$';=$% %#+ "4 #=$,*%R )4 $0% ,3$';=$% %#+ "4 #=$,*% '& $0% -=C=-'$? $" 4"*; %#+& =&

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.I@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

&,-0< $0%# $0% %#+ "4 -,3$,*% ;,&$ *%&'+% '# $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 4"*;'#: %#+& $0*",:0 3';'$=$'"# G? = -*'$'J,% "4 %#+&R B9'3 '3 29/ ?(2'1*2/ 8"('2',3 "@ ,#'2'>?/R )$ %#$='3& $0=$ $0% C*"C"*$'"#=$% 0=*;"#? "4 4*%%+"; =#+ 3=O '# $0% C*"+,-$'"# "4 -,3$,*% ;,&$ G% %#&,*%+ $0*",:0 $0% 3=O "4 C,*C"&'M% C*"+,-$'"#R /0'& *%J,'*%& =-=+%;'- '#&$*,-$'"# "4 :%#',& G? *%4%*%#-% $" -=#"#& "4 $=&$% =#+ $0% &,G"*+'#=$'"# "4 $0% -=C=-'$? "4 &N'33 $" $0% "M%*=33 +%;=#+& "4 +'&-'C3'#%R 7'&-'C3'#% =& = 4"*;=3 =#+ #%:=$'M% -"#1 +'$'"# '& $0% &,CC*%&&'"# =#+ *%+'*%-$'"# "4 &%#&=$'"#=3 +=$= G? *%=&"#R /0'& -*%=$%& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 = *=$'"#=3 *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# C%*&"#& '# = -,3$,*% =#+ '& $0% 4"*;=3 -"#+'$'"# 4"* =#? C"&&'G'3'$? "4 = -,3$,*% "4 &N'33R )4 &N'33 +%C%#+& "# +'&-'C3'#% $0%# O% ;,&$ =&N 0"O +'&-'C3'#% 4"*;& $0% -"#+'$'"#& "4 &N'33R V=#$ '& -3%=*Z $0*",:0 '#%J,=3'$?Z /0% ;=S"*'$? $=N% -=*%< ;%-0=#'-=33? =& '$ O%*% =#+ O'$0",$ C=*$'-,1 3=*3? #%%+'#: =*$ 4"* $0'&< "4 $0% #%-%&&'$'%& "4 3'4% 4"* "$0%*&< O0" $0,& 0=M% $0% %=&% =#+ 3%'&,*% $" O"*N '# &-'%#-% =#+ =*$< $0% 3%&& #%-%&&=*? '#:*%+'%#$& '# -,3$,*%R /0%&% "$0%*& N%%C $0% ;=S"*'$? '# = &$=$% "4 "CC*%&&'"#< 0=*+ 3=G",*< =#+ 3'$$3% %#S"?;%#$< %M%# $0",:0 &";% "4 $0% -,3$,*% "4 $0% 0':0%* -3=&& +"%& :*=+,=33? &C*%=+ $" $0% 3"O%* =3&"R a,$ "# G"$0 &'+%& $*",G3% '#-*%=&%& O'$0 %J,=3 M':",* =& -,3$,*% C*":*%&&%&R _/0% 0%':0$ "4 $0'& C*":*%&&< O0%# C%"C3%]& C*"C%#&'$? $" i&$*'M% 4"*j O0=$ '& +'&C%#&=G3% G%:'#& $" '#$%*4%*% O'$0 O0=$ '& '#+'&1 C%#&=G3%< '& -=33%+ 3,(,*?R` _5NR 6ZFA@` 5#"$0%* O=? "4 C*%&%#$'#: $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# +'&-'C3'#% =#+ &N'33 '& '# -3=&& $%*;&Z $0% ;=S"*'$? 0=M% = -,3$,*% "4 +'&-'C3'#%< $0% 4%O< = -,3$,*% "4 &N'33 _"*< =$ 3%=&$< $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 "#%`R /0%*% '& :*%=$ -"#43'-$ G%$O%%# $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 -,3$,*%< #"$ 3%=&$ G%-=,&% "4 $0% M'$=3 #%-%&&'$? $0=$ $0% -,3$,*% "4 &N'33 +"%& #"$ G%-";% $0% +";'#=#$ #"$% "4 $0% -,3$,*% =& $0'& O",3+ C*"+,-% +%-=+%#-%R /0% #=$,*% "4 $0'& +%-=+%#-% _-=33%+ G? V=#$ \3,(,*?]` '& $0% ,&,*C=$'"# "4 $0% 3=O1:'M'#: C"O%* "4 +'&-'C3'#% G? &N'33< $0% "M%*3"*+'#: "4 $=&$% G? :%#',&R /0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 $0% &$*,::3% G%$O%%# -,3$,*%& $0=$ 4"*;& $0% 3'4% "4 &"-'%$? '& $0% 4"*;=3 *%=3'&=$'"# "4 #=$,*%]& ,3$';=$% ='; O0'-0 V=#$ +%-3=*%& $" G%Z \$0=$ -"#&$'$,$'"# "4 0,;=# *%3=$'"#& O0%*% $0% ';C='*1 ;%#$ $" 4*%%+"; O0'-0 *%&,3$& 4*"; $0% ;,$,=33? -"#43'-$'#: 4*%%+"; i"4 $0% '#+'M'+,=3&j '& -",#$%*%+ G? 3=O4,3 =,$0"*'$? O'$0'# = O0"3% -=33%+ ,'G'( 3",'/2:X _5NR 6ZFA@`R /0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0% $O" 4"*;& "4 -,3$,*% '& ;'**"*%+ '# $0% +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# -"#$%;C3=$'"# =#+ $0% 4"*;=$'"# "4 $0% :""+ O'33R V=#$ &,G"*+'#=$%& -"#$%;C3=$'"# _"* -":#'$'"#` $" $0% :""+ O'33 &$=$'#: $0=$ $0% O"*3+ +"%& #"$ =-J,'*% M=3,%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .IA

.IF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

8%"C3% O'33 &=?Z )4 $0'& C%*&"# +"%& #"$ C"&&%&& = :""+ O'33< O0=$ C"'#$ '& $0%*% '# 0'& 0=M'#: =33 $0'& $=3%#$< =&&,;'#: %M%# $0=$ 0% =CC3'%& '$ M%*? ;,-0 '# =-$'"# =#+ $0%*%G? %(%*$& = ,&%4,3 '#43,%#-% "# 0'& -";;,#'$?< &" $0=$ 0% '& M%*? M=3,=G3% '# *%3=$'"# G"$0 $" 0'& "O# &$=$% "4 0=CC'#%&& =#+ $" $0% G%#%4'$ "4 "$0%*&X )4 O% -"#&'+%* O0=$ $0'& C%*&"# '& 3'N% '#O=*+3?< $0%# 0% '& =# "GS%-$ "4 -"#$%;C$ R R R _5NR 6ZFFA` /0'& C"'#$& ,& $" $0% ,3$';=$% G=&'& "4 $0% *%-":#'$'"# $0=$ 0,;=#'$? '& $0% %#+ "4 -*%=$'"#Z $0% -=C=-'$? "4 0,;=#& $" =-$ 4*%%3?< $0=$ '&< '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 $0% ;"*=3 3=OR /0% ;"*=3 3=O '& &,C%*&%#&'G3% =#+< =& &,-0< \'$ '& $0% "#3? C"&&'G3% i$0'#:j '# $0% "*+%* "4 C,*C"&%& $0=$ '& =G&"3,$%3? ,#-"#+'$'"#%+ =& -"#-%*#& #=$,*%] _5NR 6ZFAD`R /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"% +%M%3"C%+ =#+ %&$=G3'&0%+ $0% C"&&'G'1 3'$? "4 4*%%+";R U% *%M'&'$ #"O $0% $0",:0$ "4 $0% :""+ O'33< -0=*=-$%*1 'k%+ G? V=#$ =& \$0% C,*%&$ ;"*=3 =$$'$,+%] O0'-0 %(0'G'$&Z R R R )#*2'2?0/T "7/0'/%,/< =#+ 9?1'('*2'"% _&,G;'&&'"# $" +%&%*M%+ C,#1 '&0;%#$` R R R '# &,-0 -=&%& $0% ;'#+ 0=& =# '#-3'#=$'"# $" %(C=#+ '$& ;"*=3 =$$'$,+%< =#+ M"3,#$=*'3? $0'#N& =# "GS%-$ $0=$ '& #"$ '# $0% O"*3+< &" $0=$ '$ ;=? C"&&'G3? +" '$& +,$? $" $0=$ iG%'#:j =& O%33R _5NR 6ZFFD` /" ,#+%*&$=#+ $0% G=&'& "4 $0% =CC%=3 $" $0'& ;"*=3 =$$'$,+% O% #%%+ $" *%$,*# $" $0% J,%&$'"# "4 0"O 3=O =,$0"*'&%& =#+ C*"+,-%& 4*%%+";R /0'& '& C*%&%#$%+ '# $0% P%$0"+"3":? "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$Z /0% ;"*=3 3=O '& *%=&"#]& 4"*;=3 -"#+'$'"# 4"* $0% ,&% "4 ",* 4*%%+"; =#+ 0%#-% "G3':=$%& ,& =33 G? '$&%34< '#+%C%#+%#$3? "4 =#? C,*C"&% O0=$%M%* =& ;=$%*'=3 -"#+'$'"#R a,$ '$ =3&" +%$%*;'#%& 4"* ,&< =#+ * 8#'"#'< = 4'#=3 C,*C"&%< =#+ ;=N%& '$ "G3':=$"*? 4"* ,& $" &$*'M% $"O=*+ i=-0'%M'#:j '$Y =#+ $0=$ C,*C"&% '& 29/ 9')9/32 )""0 '% 29/ ."#(0 $0=$ O% -=# =-0'%M% $0*",:0 4*%%+";R /0% &,GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"# ,#+%* O0'-0 ;=# _=#+< =& 4=* =& O% -=# -"#-%'M%< =#? i"$0%*j *=$'"#=3 i=#+j 4'#'$% G%'#: =& O%33` -=# &%$ 0';1 &%34 = 4'#=3 C,*C"&% ,#+%* $0% =G"M% 3=O< '& 0=CC'#%&&R T%#-% $0% 0':0%&$ C0?&'-=3 :""+ O% -=# i=-0'%M%j '# $0% O"*3+ '& 9*88'%/33< =#+ $0'& '& O0=$ O% =*% $" 4,*$0%* =& $0% 4'#=3 C,*C"&% =& 4=* =& O%

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

;%*%3? G? G%'#: -":#'k%+R !":#'$'"# =3"#% -=##"$ -"#$*'G,$% $" $0% 4"*;=$'"# =#+ +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 +'&-'C3'#%R 5& V=#$ C,$& '$Z

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .I6

/0'& =--",#$ "4 $0% ;"*=3 3=O]& *%3=$'"# $" 0=CC'#%&& -"**%-$& $0% +'&C3=-%;%#$ "4 0=CC'#%&& =& = C"&&'G3% ,3$';=$% %#+ 4"* #=$,*%R T=CC'1 #%&& '# C*"C"*$'"# $" $0% +'&C"&'$'"# $" G% O"*$0? "4 0=CC'#%&& _0%#-%< $" =-$ '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 $0% ;"*=3 3=O`Z $0=$ O",3+ G% $0% 0':0%&$ :""+ _$0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 O0'-0 '& C*=-$'-=33? ;=#+=$%+ =#+ 0%#-% C*"M'+%& $0% :*",#+& "4 = C*=-$'-=3 4='$0 '# $0% %('&$%#-% "4 e"+`R P"*=3'$? -=##"$ G% &%C=*=$%+ 4"* ,&< =& &%#&,",& -*%=$,*%&< 4*"; 0=CC'#%&&R a,$ O% 0=M% = $%#+%#-? $" C*%&%#$ 0=CC'#%&& '# *%3=$'"# $" $0'& &%#&,",& #=$,*% =& = ;=(';=3 C0?&'-=3 -"#+'$'"# '#&$%=+ "4 = C*"C"*$'"# G%$O%%# $0% C0?&'1 -=3 =#+ $0% #",;%#=3R a%-=,&% "4 $0'& $%#+%#-? $0% &,G"*+'#=$'"# "4 &N'33 G? +'&-'C3'#% 4"33"O& 4*"; $0% #%%+ $" =&&%*$ -,3$,*%]& %$0'-=3 _*=$0%* $0=# &%#&=$'"#=3`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a"$0 $0%&% 4"*;& "4 &-0%;=$'&;< 0"O%M%*< O%*% O=?& "4 C3=-'#: $0% =-$'M'$? "4 $0% $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 ';=:'#=$'"# '# *%3=$'"# $" $0=$ "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:R /0% 4'#=3 %#+ &-0%;=< G? -"#$*=&$< +%$%*1 ;'#%& $0% O0"3% &?&$%; "4 *%=&"# '# =--"*+=#-% O'$0 =# '+%= "4 "*:=#1 'k=$'"#R )# $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% O% O%*% $*%=$%+ $" = C,*% &-0%;= "4 $0% 3=O '$&%34 O0'-0 *%J,'*%+ #" *%4%*%#-% $" $0% ';=:'#=$'"#R /0% &-0%;= "4 $0% 3":'- "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$< 3'N% $0% 4'*&$ 4"*; "4 \*%&$*'-$'"# =#+ *%=3'k=$'"#] &-0%;=< ;%*%3? ;%+'=$%& G%$O%%# C*%1-"#&$'$,$%+ %3%;%#$&R U% =*% 4=-%+< $0%*%4"*%< G? = C,*% &,G;'&&'"# "4 $0% &%#&'G3% G%4"*% $0% '#$%33':'G3% O0'-0 =-$ "4 &,G;'&&'"# +'&$"*$& $0% M'$=3 &%#&% "4 $0% -"#1 &$'$,$'"# "4 $0% 3=$$%* G? $0% 4"*;%*RF

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

-=#< i$0",:0j &,GS%-$ $" $0% "GS%-$'M% -"#+'$'"# $0=$ ;=# G% '# 0=*;"#? O'$0 $0% 3=O "4 1"#*('2:< i&'#-%j ",* O"*$0'#%&& $" G% 0=CC? -"#&'&$& '# $0=$ 0=*;"#?R _5NR 6ZF6E`

.ID C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

);;%+'=$%3? =4$%* +'&-,&&'#: $0% #%%+ 4"* -'M'3 &"-'%$? '# dIA V=#$ :"%& "# $" &$=$% $0=$ &";%$0'#: 4,*$0%* '& *%J,'*%+Z \= ,"31"8"('2*% O0"3%< = &?&$%; "4 =33 &$=$%& $0=$ =*% '# +=#:%* "4 =44%-$'#: "#% =#"$0%* +%$*';%#1 $=33?] =& \O'$0",$ &,-0 = O0"3% $0%*% O'33 '#%M'$=G3? G% .*#X _5NR 6ZFA@^ A`R >';'3=*3?< $"O=*+& $0% -3"&% "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% V=#$ S,&$'4'%& $0% #%%+ 4"* -*'$'J,% =& O'$0",$ '$Z \*%=&"# '&< =& '$ O%*%< '# $0% &$=$% "4 #=$,*%< =#+ -=# %&$=G3'&0 =#+ &%-,*% '$& =&&%*$'"#& =#+ -3=';& "#3? $0*",:0 .*#X _5H6.faHHK`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e%"*:% 5*;&$*"#: V%33?< $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0%&% J,%&$'"#& '# dIA O=& =#$'-'C=$%+ G? V=#$ '# ;0/* @"# * M%'G/#3*( N'32"#: @#"1 * ="31"8"('2*% E"'%2 "@ L'/.RD /0% ;='# $%($ "4 ;0/* @"# * M%'G/#3*( N'32"#: -"#&'&$& "4 #'#% C*"C"&'1 $'"#& '#$%#+%+< =--"*+'#: $" V=#$< $" \+'&-"M%* = 8?#8"3/ '% %*2?#/] 4"* G%'#:& O0" +" #"$ &%%; $" 0=M% = C3=# "4 $0%'* "O# _$0=$ '&< 0,;=#'$?`RH /0'& O",3+ :'M% ,& = :,'+'#: C3=# 4"* = 0'&$"*?R e'M%# $0'& $%3%"3":'-=3 "C%#'#: '$ '& #" &,*C*'&% $0=$ $0%&% C*"C"&'$'"#& =*% $%3%"3":'-=3R /0% 4'*&$ C*"C"&'$'"# ;%*%3? *%&$=$%& =#+ %(C=#+& $0% 4,#+=;%#$=3 $0",:0$ "4 $0% 6'(0?%)32#'/7R /0% &%-"#+ C*"C"&'$'"# C"'#$& =:='# $" $0% -%#$*=3 4=-$ "4 $0% C"&&%&&'"# G? ;=# "4 *%=&"#< G,$ 0%*% =++& $0% ';C"*$=#$ C"'#$ _%M'+%#$3? -"#$='#%+ '# $0% M%*? #"$'"# "4 = -,3$,*% "4 +'&-'C3'#%`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dIA "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 =& '$ &$=$%& $0=$Z \B9/ 1/*%3

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>+22;#.$( "#4 R.&$+1(

%*2?#/ /18(":3 2" 7#'%) *7"?2 29/ 0/G/("81/%2 "@ '%%*2/ ,*8*,'2'/3 '3 29*2 "@ *%2*)"%'31 .'29'% 3",'/2:T '% 3" @*# *3 29'3 *%2*)"%'31 7/,"1/3 '% 29/ ("%) #?% 29/ ,*?3/ "@ * (*.H)"G/#%/0 3",'*( "#0/#X _L%'&&< CR FF`R /0% -"#43'-$ $0*",:0 O0'-0 C%"C3% 3'M% C*"+,-%& $0% C"&&'G'3'$? "4 3=O =& = &"3,$'"# =#+ $0'& :'M%& ,& O0=$ $0% 4'4$0 C*"C"&'$'"# -=33& \29/ )#/*2/32 8#"7(/1 @"# 29/ 9?1*% 38/,'/3X< #=;%3?< \*22*'%'%) * ,'G'( 3",'/2: .9',9 ,*% *01'%'32/# J?32',/ ?%'G/#3*((:] _L%'&&< CR F6`R /0% C*"G3%; '& #"O &$=$%+ O'$0 &";% %-"#";? G? V=#$Z /0'& C,*C"&% -=# G% 4,34'33%+ "#3? '# = &"-'%$? O0'-0 0=& #"$ "#3? $0% :*%=$%&$ 4*%%+";< =#+ $0%*%4"*% = -"#$'#,=3 =#$=:"#'&; =;"#: '$& ;%;G%*&< G,$ =3&" $0% ;"&$ C*%-'&% &C%-'4'-=$'"# =#+ C*%&%*M=$'"# "4 $0% 3';'$& "4 $0'& 4*%%+"; '# "*+%* $0=$ '$ -=# -"1%('&$ O'$0 $0% 4*%%1 +"; "4 "$0%*&R _L%'&&< CR F6` /0'& '& $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# $=&$% =#+ :%#',& *%&$=$%+ '# =# %(C3'-'$3? C"3'$'-=3 N%?R U% #"$%+ $0=$ '# d6E V=#$ &$=$%+ $0=$ '# = -=&% "4 -"#43'-$ :%#',& &0",3+ ?'%3+ =& $=&$% C*"M'+%+ $0% C"O%* "4 S,+:;%#$ =#+ +'&1 -'C3'#%< = *%&"3,$'"# O0'-0 ;'**"*& $0% &,G"*+'#=$'"# "4 &N'33 $" +'&-'C1 3'#% '# :%#%*=3 $%*;& '# dIAR /0% &'($0 C*"C"&'$'"# *%&$=$%& $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0% C*"G3%; "4 -"#&$'$,$'#: = -'M'3 &"-'%$? '& $0% 3=&$ $" G% &"3M%+ G? $0% 0,;=# *=-% =#+ '$& ;"&$ +'44'-,3$ C*"G3%; O0'-0 C*"C"&'$'"# &%M%# &$=$%& -=##"$ G% &"3M%+ ,#3%&& $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# &$=$%& '& *%:,1 3=$%+R /0'& *%J,'*%& = -"&;"C"3'$=# &?&$%; "4 :%#%*=3 C"3'$'-=3 &%-,*'$? O0'-0 V=#$ +%&-*'G%& '# $0% %':0$0 C*"C"&'$'"# =& = \,9'('*32',X %(C%-$=1 $'"#R /0% #'#$0 C*"C"&'$'"# ;%*%3? &$=$%& $0% #%%+ 4"* O*'$'#: = C0'3"1 &"C0'-=3 0'&$"*? O0'-0 O",3+ C*%&%#$ = -";C*%0%#&'"# "4 ",* =44='*& =4$%* $0'& C3=# "4 #=$,*%R ;0/* @"# * M%'G/#3*( N'32"#: @#"1 * ="31"8"('2*% E"'%2 "@ L'/. O=& C,G3'&0%+ &%M%# ?%=*& C*'"* $" $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% =#+ =#$'-'C=$%& $0% C*"G3%; O0'-0 O% +'&-"M%*%+ '# dIAR a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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .IH

.II C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0% &,::%&$'"# $0=$ $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,%]& ,3$';=$% C*"G3%; '& -,3$,*% '& &,CC"*$%+ G? $0% +'&-,&&'"# "4 4'#% =*$ '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)H 1/%2 =#+ =3&" G? $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0% 4'*&$ 0=34 "4 $0% O"*N -"#-3,+%& O'$0 = +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% O=? '# O0'-0 $0% G%=,$'4,3 '& = &?;G"3 "4 $0% :""+R /0% -"##%-$'"#& G%$O%%# $0%&% $0",:0$& =#+ $0% $0",:0$ "4 = -,3$,*% "4 +'&-'C3'#% O=& &$=$%+ O'$0 =+;'*=G3% -"#-'&%#%&& =$ $0% -"#-3,&'"# "4 d6KZ /=&$% %#=G3%& ,& $" ;=N% $0% $*=#&'$'"# 4*"; &%#&'G3% -0=*; $" = 0=G'$,=3 ;"*=3 '#$%*%&$ O'$0",$ ;=N'#: $"" M'"3%#$ = 3%=CY 4"* $=&$% C*%&%#$& $0% ';=:'#=$'"# =& =+;'$$'#:< %M%# '# '$& 4*%%+";< "4 +%$%*1 ;'#=$'"# $0=$ '& C,*C"&'M% 4"* $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:< =#+ '$ $%=-0%& ,& $" 3'N% %M%# "GS%-$& "4 &%#&% 4*%%3?< %M%# =C=*$ 4*"; &%#&'G3% -0=*;R _5NR 6ZA6F` 2,*$0%*< $0% M%*? 3=&$ &%#$%#-% "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 &$=$%& $0=$Z \$0% C*"C=%+,%$'- $0=$ O'33 $*,3? %&$=G3'&0 ",* $=&$% -"#&'&$& '# +%M%3"C'#: ",* ;"*=3 '+%=& =#+ '# -,3$'M=$'#: iC?(2?#j ;"*=3 4%%3'#:Y 4"* "#3? O0%# &%#&'G'3'$? '& ;=+% $" 0=*;"#'k% O'$0 $0'& 4%%3'#: -=# :%#,'#% $=&$% $=N% "# = +%4'#'$%< ,#-0=#:%=G3% 4"*;] _5NR 6ZA6D`R /0% #%-%&&'$? "4 $=&$% *%3=$'#: $" ;"*=3 C*'#-'C3%& %M%# 4"*;& $0% M%*? #"$'"# "4 =# )+%=3 "4 a%=,$? O0'-0 '& *%C*%&%#$%+ '# $0% 0,;=# 4"*;R U0%# O% -"##%-$ $0%&% =*:,;%#$& $" $0% 4,#+=;%#$=3 +%;"#&$*=$'"# "4 d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a,$ $0'& '& ;"*% $0=# V=#$ -=# :*=#$ =& = !*'$'-=3 $0'#N%*R !*'$'J,% '& $0% &'#:,3=* 4"*; "4 = -,3$,*% "4 +'&-'C3'#% O'$0'# C0'3"&"C0? _"* =& V=#$ C,$& '$< = \-,3$,*% "4 *%=&"#]`R 5& &,-0 '$ "C%*=$%& $" +'&&,=+% $0% ;'#+ 4*"; G"3+ =#+ "M%*3?

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

R.&$+1(H >;7$;1* "#4 3&5-"$+7+0(

&C%-,3=$'M% 4"*;& "4 C*%&%#$=$'"# '# "*+%* $" 4"*-% '$& "C%*=$'"# G=-N "# $0% :*",#+& "4 C*=-$'-=3 "*'%#$=$'"#R /0% C"'#$ "4 $0'& '# $0% *%=3;& "4 *%3':'",& $0'#N'#: '& ;=+% -3%=* G? V=#$]& +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $0%"3":? _= *=$'"#=3 %#+%=M",* $" 4"*; $0% -"#-%C$ "4 e"+` =#+ $0%"&"C0? _O0'-0 C'-$,*%&J,%3? $=N%& 43':0$ =;"#:&$ -3",+& "4 ,#*%=&"#`R /0% "#3? -"#-%C$ $0=$ V=#$ =33"O& $" C*"M'+% = :*",#+'#: 4"* $0% 0"C%& "4 *%3':'"# '& 4*%%+";< =& '$ \'& $0% "#3? -"#-%C$ "4 $0% &,C%*1 &%#&'G3% O0'-0 _G? ;%=#& "4 $0% -=,&=3'$? $0=$ O% $0'#N '# '$` C*"M%& '# #=$,*% $0=$ '$ 0=& "GS%-$'M% *%=3'$?< G? $0% %44%-$& '$ -=# C*"+,-% '# '$] _5NR 6ZFHF`R >,::%&$'"#& "4 = +'44%*%#$ =--",#$ %;%*:% 0"O%M%* $"O=*+& $0% -"#-3,&'"# "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% O0%*% V=#$ C"'#$& ",$ = &';'3=*'$? G%$O%%# =+;'*=$'"# "4 G%=,$? '# #=$,*% =#+ *%3':'",& 4%%3'#:Z /0% =+;'*=$'"# 4"* i$0%j G%=,$? i"4 #=$,*%j< =& O%33 =& $0% %;"$'"# =*",&%+ G? $0% &" +'M%*&% C,*C"&%& "4 #=$,*%< $0=$ = ;%+'$=$'M% ;'#+ '& =G3% $" 4%%3 %M%# G%4"*% '$ 0=& = -3%=* -"#-%C$'"# "4 =# '#$%33':%#$ =,$0"* "4 $0% O"*3+< 0=M% &";%$0'#: =G",$ $0%; O0'-0 '& &';'3=* $" = #/(')'"?3 4%%3'#:R T%#-%< O0%# $0%? '#&C'*% '# ,& $0=$ =+;'*=$'"# O0'-0 '& -"##%-$%+ O'$0 4=* ;"*% '#$%*%&$ $0=# ;%*% $0%"*%$'-=3 -"#$%;C3=$'"# -=# =*",&%< $0%? '#'$'=33? &%%; $" =44%-$ $0% ;"*=3 4%%3'#: _"4 :*=$'$,+% =#+ M%#%*=$'"# $"O=*+ $0% -=,&% O% +" #"$ N#"O`< G%-=,&% O% i$0%#j S,+:% i#=$,*%j '# = O=? =#=3":",& $" $0% ;"*=3 O=?< =#+ $0%*%4"*% $0%? &%%; $" =44%-$ $0% ;'#+ G? =*",&'#: ;"*=3 '+%=&R _5NR 6ZFI@` /0%*% '& =# =#=3":? G%$O%%# $0% =CC*%0%#&'"# "4 #=$,*% =& G%=,$'4,3 "* C,*C"&'M% =#+ = ;"*=3 4*=;% "4 ;'#+R /0'& =#=3":? -";%& 4*"; 29/ @//('%)3 O0'-0 =*% C*%&%#$%+ $" $0% ;'#+ G"$0 O0%# '$ '& -"#&'+%*'#: '+%=& =#+ O0%# '$ C%*-%'M%& #=$,*% =4$%* = C=$$%*# "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$Z =+;'*=$'"#< :*=$'$,+% =#+ M%#%*=$'"#R /0%&% %;"$'"#& C"'#$ $" = 3'#N=:% O0'-0 '& &';'3=* $" $0=$ &,::%&$%+ '# d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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .IK

*%3=$'"# $" $0% O"*3+ _=#+ $0%*%4"*%< "4 C0'3"&"C0?` '$ '& = &':#=3 4,*$0%* '#+'-=$'"# "4 $0% ,3$';=$% =%&$0%$'- G=&'& "4 !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0?R 5& = -"##%-$'"# G? =#=3":? '$ G*'#:& ",$ $0=$ $0% &-0%;=$'&; O0'-0 '# 4=-$ '& $0% 4,#+=;%#$=3 &-0%;=$'&; "4 *%43%-$'"# '& #"$ $0% &-0%;= "4 0=CC'1 #%&& C*%&%#$%+ G? !=?:'33 _';C"*$=#$ =& $0=$ '&`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e'M%# $0=$ $0% ,#'$? "4 !*'$'-=3 $0",:0$ =& C*"C"&%+ "# $0'& *%=+'#: *%&'+%& '# =# ,3$';=$% =%&$0%$'- O0'-0 O% -=# ,#+%*&$=#+ $0*",:0 $0% C*"-%+,*%& "4 *%43%-$'M% S,+:;%#$ $0%# '$ O",3+ &%%; $0=$ $0% *%3=$'"# $" C"3'$'-& O0'-0 ;,&$ %;%*:% 4*"; -*'$'J,% ;,&$ G% G=&%+ "# $0% %($%#&'"# $" $0% 0,;=# *=-% =& = O0"3% "4 = N'#:+"; "4 %#+& O0'-0 '& G=&%+ "# = :*",#+ "4 &?;C=$0?R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.KE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

/0'& O",3+ 4"*; $0% G=&'& 4"* V=#$'=# %&-0=$"3":?R )# B9/ !'%*( D%0 "@ +(( B9'%)3 _.HKF` V=#$ C*%&%#$& = *%43%-$'"# "# $0'& =*%=R 5& %&-0=$"3":? '& $0% =$$%;C$ $" $0'#N $0% 4'#=3 &%#&% "4 $0'#:& =& &,-0 '$ '& #"$ &,*C*'&1 '#: $0=$ $0% O"*N "C%#& O'$0 = +'&-,&&'"# "4 $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# +%=$0< $';%< =#+ %$%*#'$?R /0% J,%&$'"# "4 0"O $" $0'#N $0% %#+ "4 $0'#:& '& C*%&%#$%+ G? V=#$ 0%*% =& #%-%&&=*'3? G%'#: = C*=-$'-=3 J,%&$'"# _-"#1 #%-$%+ $" = 4'#=3 J?0)1/%2` *=$0%* $0=# = $0%"*%$'-=3 "#%R T% ';;%+'=$%3? +'&-%*#& =# =#$'#";? "4 %&-0=$"3":'-=3 S,+:;%#$ '# *%3=$'"# $" $0% C"&'$'"#& "4 Q#'$=*'=#'&; =#+ 7,=3'&;R /0% 4'*&$ C"&'$'"# \=O=*+& &=3M=1 $'"# $" =33 ;%#] O0'3&$ $0% &%-"#+ \=O=*+& &=3M=$'"# $" &";% &%3%-$ "#%&< G,$ $" =33 $0% *%&$ %$%*#=3 +=;#=$'"#] _5NR IZA@I^K`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`R /0'& J,%&$'"# 3'#N& $0'& %&&=? M%*? -3"&%3? $" $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 4"* V=#$]& *%&C"#&% '& $0=$ $0% O"*3+]& M=3,% '& -";;%#&,*=$% O'$0 $0% ,3$';=$% C,*C"&% "4 '$& %('&$%#-%< O0'-0 C,*C"&% ;,&$ G% ;%=#$ $" G% =-0'%M%+ =& '4 '$ O=& #"$ $0%# $0% O"*3+ O",3+ G% \3'N% = +*=;= $0=$ '& $"$=33? O'$0",$ '&&,% =#+ 0=& #" *=$'"#=3 +%&':#] _5NR IZAA.`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` #=$,*=33? C*%-%+%& $0% +%M%3"C;%#$ "4 ;"*=3'$?Y =#+ $0'& &'$,=$'"# '& C*%-'&%3? $0% ;"&$ G,*+%#&";% =#+ 0=k=*+",& 4"* ;"*=3'$?< =& O%33 =& 4"* C0?&'-=3 O%=3< G%-=,&% #%%+& '#-*%=&% ;,-0 ;"*% M':"*",&3? $0=# $0% ;%=#& $" &=$'&4? $0%;R _5NR IZAA@`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .K.

/0'& C=&&=:% *%&$=$%& $0% C"3'$'-=3 C*"G3%; =& %;%*:'#: 4*"; = $%;C"*=3 +'&S,#-$,*% G%$O%%# $0% -,3$,*% "4 +'&-'C3'#% =#+ $0% -,3$,*% "4 &N'33R /0% %(C%*'%#-% "4 $0% ;=S"*'$? "4 $0% &C%-'%& '&< =& &$=$%+ '# d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dIA "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,%R a"$0 =--",#$& C*%&%#$ $0% &=;% C'-$,*% "4 $0% -"#$*=&$ G%$O%%# = 3,(,*'",& 3'4% =#+ "#% -"#1 &,;%+ G? = ;%-0=#'&; "4 #%%+R /0% -"#43'-$ G%$O%%# $0% $O" C*"+,-%& = $0",:0$ "4 $0% #%%+ 4"* = ;'33%##',; $" *%+*=O $0% -"#+'$'"#& ,#+%* O0'-0 O% 3'M%R /0'& 3%=+& V=#$ $" +%;=*-=$% =#+ &%C=*=$% $0*%% J,'$% +'44%*%#$ $?C%& "4 %&-0=$"3":'-=3 $0'#N'#:Z _.` R R R $0% %*2?#*( %#+ "4 =33 $0'#:& -"#4"*;'#: $" $0% "*+%* "4 ;"*=3 %#+& "4 +'M'#% O'&+"; O0'-0 O% -=#< $0%*%4"*%< -%*$='#3? -";C*%1 0%#+ _'# = C*=-$'-=3 &%#&%`Y _@` '# '$& 1:32', _&,C%*#=$,*=3` %#+ '# $0% "*+%* "4 %44'-'%#$ -=,&%& "4 O0'-0 O% -";C*%0%#+ #"$0'#:Y _A` '# $0% ?%%*2?#*( _C%*M%*$%+` %#+ "4 =33 $0'#:& 4"* O0'-0 O% ",*&%3M%& =*% *%&C"#&'G3% '# $0=$ O% 1'3?%0/#32*%0 $0% ,3$';=$% C,*C"&%R _5NR IZAAA` W=$,*=3 %&-0=$"3":? '& J,=3'4'%+ '# = 4""$#"$% 0%*% $" *%4%* $" $0'#:& O0'-0 C*"-%%+ =--"*+'#: $" 3=O& "4 = -%*$='# "*+%*< O0=$%M%* "*+%* $0=$ ;=? G% =#+ O0'-0 $0%*%4"*% '#-3,+%& ;"*=3 "*+%* G,$ #"$ &,C%*#=$,*=3 "*+%*R U0'3&$ $0'& &%%;& -3%=* %#",:0< '$ '& -";C3'-=$%+ G? $0% 4=-$ $0=$ $0% =G"M% J,"$% -0=*=-$%*'k%& = ;?&$'-=3 %&-0=$"3":? =& C*"-%%+'#: 4*"; = &%$ "4 %44'-'%#$ -=,&%& O0'-0 O",3+ *%#+%* '$& -=,&=3'$? =& ;%-0=#'-=3R /" =++ $" $0% -"#4,&'"# =*",#+ $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# $0% 4'*&$ =#+ &%-"#+ $?C% "4 %&-0=$"3":?< V=#$ $%33& ,& $0=$ = &,C%*#=$,*=3 %#+ '& C=*$ "4 =# "*+%* "4 O0'-0 O% -=# -";C*%0%#+ #"$0'#:< +%&C'$% 0'& C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 '$ =& '#M"3M'#: = *%4%*%#-% $" %44'-'%#$ -=,&%&R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.K@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

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`R T% =3&" -'$%& $0% '#&'C'+'$? "4 ';=:'#=$'"# O0'-0 '& %M'+%#-%+ '# C=&&1 =:%& =G",$ $0% 3'4% "4 $0% G3%&&%+ =#+ $0% *%C%$'$'"# "4 $0% &=;% -"#&$=#$ &,44%*'#:& =;"#:&$ $0% +=;#%+ _L%MR .KZ.^DY @EZ.6`R /0'& %(C3'-1 =$'"# "4 $0% '#-"#&'&$%#-'%& =#+ C*=-$'-=3 $0",:0$3%&&#%&& "4 &,C%*1 #=$,*=3 %&-0=$"3":? '& 4"33"O%+ G? = ;%+'$=$'"# "# !0*'&$'=#'$? O0'-0 %#=G3%& V=#$ $" %(C3='# O0=$ 0% ,#+%*&$=#+& G? ,##=$,*=3 %&-0=$"3":?R a%-=,&% !0*'&$'=#'$? +%C%#+& "# = C*'#-'C3% "4 3"M% V=#$ -"#&'+%*& $0% *%3=$'"# "4 $0'& C*'#-'C3% $" *%&C%-$< $0% 4,#+=;%#$=3 4%%3'#: $0=$ C*"1 -%%+& 4*"; $0% ;"*=3 3=OR T% ;='#$='#& $0=$ *%&C%-$ '& C*';=*? =& 3"M% -=##"$ %('&$ O'$0",$ '$ _S,&$ =& +'&-'C3'#% '& *%J,'*%+ 4"* $0% %(%*-'&% "4 &N'33`R a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`R _5NR IZAAH^I`

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .KA

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`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a"$0 =$$'$,+%& &0=*% $0% :*",#+ "4 G=&'#: $0%;&%3M%& ,C"# = ;=(';=3 M'%O "4 $0% '#-3'#=$'"#&R /0% #%-%&&'$? "4 3'G%*=3 C*'#-'C3%& -";%& 4*"; $0% #%%+ $" $%;C%* $0% =CC%=3 $" &%#&,",&#%&&R /0% ;%$0"+ "4 '&"3=$'"# =33"O& V=#$ $" C*%&%#$ $0% G=&'- :*",#+'#: -"#+'$'"#& "4 &%#&,",&#%&& '# $0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 5%&$0%$'- _;"+'4'%+ *%43%-$'M%3? '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

.KF C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

>';'3=*3?< 0% '&"3=$%& =#+ $*%=$& $0% =,$"#";",& C"&&'G'3'$? =#+ #%-%&1 &'$? "4 *%=&"# '# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"%R a,$ $0% G*'+:% *%J,'*%+ G%$O%%# *%=&"# =#+ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: G*'#:& ,& G=-N $" $0% #%%+ 4"* ",$3'#'#: $0% e%#%*=3 5%&$0%$'- O0'-0 $0% O0"3% &?&$%; *%3'%& ,C"# =#+ $0'& %#=G3%& ,& $" &%% $0% #%%+ 4"* =# =CC%=3 $" $0% %;"$'"#& '# "*+%* $" ;=N% $0% ;"*=3 3=O]& C"&&'G'3'$? *%=3 '# =-$'"#R /0'& =CC%=3 -=#< 0"O1 %M%*< "#3? G% :*=#$%+ = 4"*;=3 =$$%#$'"# '# V=#$]& =+;'&&'"# "4 $0% *"3% "4 3"M% '# ;"$'M=$'#: :""+ =-$'"#R /0'& =+;'&&'"# :*",#+& 0'& 3'G%*=3 C*%&%#$=$'"# "4 !0*'&$'=#'$? G,$ =3&" %#&,*%& 0'& -,*$='3;%#$ "4 $0% -3=';& "4 $0=$ "* =#? "$0%* *%3':'"# G? *%4%*%#-% $" $0% C,*% &",*-%& "4 $0% 3=O =3O=?& #%%+'#: $" G% C=*=;",#$R /0% 3=-N "4 %('&$%#-% "4 -'M'3 &"-'%$? =& &,-0 '& :*",#+%+ '# $0% 3=-N "4 3=O G%$O%%# &$=$%& =#+ $0% -"#43'-$ O'$0'# %=-0 &$=$% C*"+,-%+ G? $0% "M%*O%%#'#: C*%&%#-% "4 = -,3$,*% "4 &N'33R /0%&% $O'# -"#+'$'"#& C*%&%#$ = C*"G3%; 4"* $*=#&-%#+%#$=3 C0'3"&"C0? O0'-0 '& -";C%33%+ '# *%&C"#&% $" -"#&$*,-$ = C*=-$'-=3 %&-0=$"3":?R /0% $,*# $" %&-0=$"3":? '# V=#$ '& &";%O0=$ C%*4,#-$"*? '# B9/ !'%*( D%0 "@ +(( B9'%)3 0"O%M%* =& $0'& O"*N '& &$'33 O*'$$%# O'$0'# $0% 3';'$& "4 -*'$'-=3 $0'#N'#:R U0=$ $0% $%*;'#=$'"# "4 $0'& O"*N *%M%=3& '& $0=$ 4"* =# %&-0=$"3":? $" %;%*:% O0'-0 -=# *%3=$% $" $0% C"3'$'-=3 +'44'-,3$'%& -*'$'J,% 4=-%& '# C*";"$'#: '$& 3'G%*=3 C"&'$'"# O'33 *%J,'*% = M%#$,*% G%?"#+ $0% 3';'$& "4 -*'$'-=3 C0'3"&"C0? =#+ $0% ;"M% $"O=*+& C*=-$'-=3 +"-$*'#%R )# -"#-3,&'"# '$ O'33 G% #%-%&&=*? $" &%$ ",$ O0=$ $0% !*'$'-=3 &?&$%; =-0'%M%& =#+ O0=$ '$& -3"&,*% 4"*-%& ,C"# $0% =:%#+= 4"* V=#$R

>1.$.5"7 6-.7+&+)-( "#4 $-* 9**4 ,+1 61"5$.5"7 ?+5$1.#* /0% *%M%3=$'"# $0=$ ",* &%#&,",& -";C*%0%#&'"# *%J,'*%& = :*",#+'#: '# $0% %;"$'"#=3 C*';=-? "4 ",* *%&C"#&%& $" $0% O"*3+ '& $0% #%:=$'M% %44%-$ "4 *%&$*='#$ ,C"# *%=&"#&] * 8#'"#' -3=';&R a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a,$ $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#: G*'#:& $" ",* =$$%#$'"# $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 = C"O%* "4

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .K6

.KD C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

BM%# '# = 4,33? -'M'3'k%+ &"-'%$? $0%*% *%;='#& $0'& &,C%*'"* *%&C%-$ 4"* $0% O=**'"* R R R R T%#-%< #" ;=$$%* 0"O ;,-0 C%"C3% ;=? +'&C,$%< O0%# $0%? -";C=*% $0% &$=$%&;=# O'$0 $0% :%#%*=3< =& $" O0'-0 "#% +%&%*M%& $0% &,C%*'"* *%&C%-$< =# =%&$0%$'- S,+:;%#$ +%-'+%& '# 4=M",* "4 $0% :%#%*=3R _5NR 6Z@D@^A`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` =#+ B9/ &/2*89:3',3 "@ &"#*(3R /0% 3=$$%* O"*N< 3'N% $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,%< '& +'M'+%+ '#$" $O" 0=3M%&< -"**%&C"#+'#: $" = 7"-$*'#% "4 L':0$ =#+ = 7"-$*'#% "4 c'*$,%R )$ 0=& ?%$ $" G% &,GS%-$%+ $" +%$='3%+ %(=;'#=$'"#R /0% .HKE& O=& #"$ "#3? +%M"$%+ $" $0% O*'$'#: "4 B9/ &/2*89:3',3 "@ &"#*(3< 0"O%M%*Y '$ O=& =3&" $0% C%*'"+ '# O0'-0 V=#$ O*"$% F/(')'"% .'29'% 29/ U'1'23 "@ F/*3"% +("%/ _.HKA` =#+< '# *%&C"#&% $" $0% 4,*"*% C*"+,-%+ G? $0'& O"*NT B9/ ="%@(',2 "@ !*,?(2'/3 _.HKI`R /0% 3';'$%+

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

+'M'&'"# O0'-0 G*'#:& ",$ $0% '#0%*%#$3? -*%=$'M% #=$,*% "4 "CC"&'$'"# =#+ -"#43'-$R /0'& C"'#$& $" $0% *%J,'*%;%#$ 4"* &$*,::3% =#+ +'&,#'$? _0,;=#'$?]& \,#&"-'=3 &"-'=G'3'$?]`R /0'& -=# G% &%%# =& $0% &,G3';% #=$,*% "4 O=* -";;%;"*=$%+ G? V=#$Z

C*=-$'-=3 %&-0=$"3":? &%$ ",$ '# B9/ !'%*( D%0 "@ +(( B9'%)3 '& -"#&'+%*=G3? %(C=#+%+ '# F/(')'"% .'29'% 29/ U'1'23 "@ F/*3"% +("%/ =#+ = 4,*$0%* -*'$'-=3 +%;=*-=$'"# "4 G",#+=*'%& G%$O%%# ;"+%& "4 N#"O3%+:% O0'-0 &%$& &$*'-$ 3';'$& "# $0% C"3'$'-=3 :*",#+& "4 *%3':'",& -3=';& '& 4",#+ '# B9/ ="%@(',2 "@ !*,?(2'/3R 533 $0%&% O"*N& =*% O*'$$%# =:='#&$ $0% G=-N+*"C "4 $0% 2*%#-0 L%M"3,$'"#< O0'-0 V=#$ *%&C"#+& $" '# J,'$% +'44%*%#$ O=?& '# B9/ ="%@(',2 "@ !*,?(2'/3 =#+ $0% $",2#'%/ "@ F')92R /0% '**,C$'"# "4 $0% *%M"3,$'"# "# $0% &-%#% "4 B,*"C%=# C"3'$'-& C*"+,-%& =# '#$%#&'4'-=$'"# "4 $0% -*'&'& O0'-0 ;=*N%+ $0% -3"&,*% "4 V=#$]& -*'$'-=3 O"*N& =& 0% -";C*%0%#+& $0% '**,C$'M% #=$,*% "4 $0'& %M%#$ =& 4"*-'#: = *%-"#&'+%*=$'"# "4 $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# $0% #%%+ 4"* = 3=O1:"M%*#%+ &$=$% =#+ $0% #%-%&&'$? "4 &%$$'#: ",$ = C*=-$'-=3 %&-0=$"3":?R /0% +"-$*'#=3 O"*N "# C*=-$'-=3 C0'3"&"C0? =#+ $0% 3%#:$0? C'%-%& "# *%3':'"# O0%# *%=+ '# -"#S,#-$'"# &,::%&$ $0=$ $0% J,%&$'"#& *='&%+ '# $0'& -0=C$%* =#+ =$ $0% -"#-3,&'"# "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% 4"*-%+ #%O =$$%;C$& G? V=#$ $" $0'#N $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# *%3':'"# =#+ &"-'%$?< %&-0=$"3":? =#+ %$0'-=3 3'4%R )# $0% C*%M'",& -0=C$%* O% &,::%&$%+ $0=$ V=#$ 0=+ = :""+ &%*'%& "4 *%&C"#&%& $" $0% -0=33%#:% T%:%3 C"&%& $" 0'; =*",#+ $0% #"$'"# "4 -0%;'&;R a,$ O0=$ O% -=# #"O &%% '& $0=$ V=#$]& -*'$'-=3 O"*N& +" #"$ &,--%%+ '# C*%&%#$'#: = &$=G3% -0%;'-=3 %3%;%#$ '# O0'-0 %M%*?$0'#: G"$0 ;"M%& =#+ +%M%3"C&< G,$ $0=$ $0% #"$'"# "4 -,3$,*% '&< *=$0%*< '#0%*%#$3? ,#&$=G3% =#+ +'M'+%+ G%$O%%# = 4,$,*%1 C*"S%-$%+ *%3':'",& 0"C% =#+ =# %;C0=&'& "# 3=O $0=$ $%#+& $" C*";"$% $0% =--%C$=#-% "4 =#? *,3% *=$0%* $0=# =-J,'%&-% '# =#=*-0?R /0'& ,3$';=$% +'M'&'"# '# V=#$ G%$O%%# 4*%%+"; =#+ "*+%*< 0"C% =#+ 3=O< '#+'-=$%& $0=$ $0% T%:%3'=# $0",:0$ "4 >C'*'$ -=##"$ G% ;%$ O'$0 "# $0% :*",#+& "4 -*'$'J,% =& $0'& 3=$$%*]& C*%1%;'#%#$ $0",:0$ "4 3';'$ '& '#&,44'-'%#$ $" -";C*%0%#+ $0% 4,#+=;%#$=3 C*"G3%; "4 $0% *%3=$'"#1 &0'C G%$O%%# $0% %&-0=$"3":'-=3 +%;=#+ =#+ =-$,=3'$?R /0'& '& $0% *%%4 "# O0'-0 -*'$'J,% 4",#+%*& =#+ '# +"'#: &" '$ *%M%=3& $0% #%%+ 4"* C*=-$'-=3 +"-$*'#%R /0'& '& $" $0'#N $0% *%3=$'"#&0'C G%$O%%# *%3':'"#< C"3'$'-& =#+ %$0'-&R /0%&% =*% $0% ,3$';=$% %#+& "4 *%=&"# =#+ $0% *%3=1 $'"#&0'C G%$O%%# $0%; %;%*:%& 4*"; +%3';'$'#: $0% %#+& "4 =%&$0%$'-& =& -"#&$'$,$'#: $0% 3';'$ "4 -*'$'J,%R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D3,9*2"("): *%0 29/ D%03 "@ =?(2?#/ .KH

W"$%&

.R 5;"#:&$ $0% ;=#? ';C"*$=#$ -"#$%;C"*=*? O"*N& "# V=#$< &%% '# C=*$'-,3=*< 9%=#12*=#-n"'& [?"$=*+ _.KK.` U/33"%3 "% B9/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ _.KKF $*=#&R B3'k=G%$0 L"$$%#G%*:< >$=#4"*+ Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z >$=#4"*+< !5`Y 9=-J,%& 7%*1 *'+= _.KHI` B9/ B#?29 '% E*'%2'%) _.KIH $*=#&R e%"44 a%##'#:$"# =#+ )=# P-[%"+< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`Y T"O=*+ !=?:'33 _.KIK` B9/ +#2 "@ A?0)1/%2 _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`Y L,+"34 5R P=NN*%%3 _.KKE` ;1*)'%*2'"% *%0 ;%2/#8#/2*2'"% '% C*%2P B9/ N/#1/%/?2',*( ;18"#2 "@ B9/ =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:"`Y >,&=# P%3+ >0%33 _.KKD` B9/ D17"0'1/%2 "@ F/*3"%P C*%2 "% 58'#'2T K/%/#*2'"%T *%0 ="11?%'2: _Q#'M%*1 &'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:"`R b# $0% G*"=+ =*%= "4 =%&$0%$'-&< &%% 80'3'CC% [=-",%1[=G=*$0% _.KK.` &?3',* !',2* _!')?#/3 "@ Q*)%/#` _.KKF $*=#&R 2%3'-'= P-!=**%#< >$=#4"*+ Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&< >$=#4"*+< !5`Y /0'%**? 7% 7,M% _.KKD` C*%2 *@2/# $?,9*18 _P)/ 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%< P5R =#+ ["#+"#`Y 9=-J,%& 7%**'+= _.KKE` &/1"'#3 "@ 29/ 6('%0P B9/ 5/(@HE"#2#*'2 *%0 S29/# F?'%3 _.KKA $*=#&R 8=&1 -=3%15##% a*=,3$ =#+ P'-0=%3 W==&< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:"`Y /0%"+"* 5+"*#" _.KHE` +/329/2', B9/"#: _.KIF $*=#&R !R [%#0=*+$< L",$3%+:% =#+ V%:=# 8=,3Z ["#+"#`Y /%**? B=:3%$"# _.KKE` B9/ ;0/"("): "@ 29/ +/329/2', _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`Y 5#+*%O a"O'% _.KKH` !#"1 F"1*%2','31 2" =#'2',*( B9/"#:P B9/ E9'("3"89: "@ K/#1*% U'2/#*#: B9/"#: _L",$3%+:%Z ["#+"# =#+ W%O h"*N`Y 9=? a%*#&$%'# _.KK@` B9/ !*2/ "@ +#2P +/329/2', +('/%*2'"% !#"1 C*%2 2" +0"#%" _8"3'$? 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%`R @R T%*%< =#+ $0*",:0",$< *%4%*%#-%& $" $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% 4"33"O &$=#+=*+ #"$=$'"# 4"* 4'*&$ =#+ &%-"#+ %+'$'"#& =#+ =*% G=&%+ "# W"*;=# V%;C >;'$0]& $*=#&3=1 $'"#R L%4%*%#-%& $" $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% =*% ;=+% $" U%*#%* 83,0=*]& $*=#&3=$'"#R L%4%*%#-%& $" $0% "$0%* O"*N& "4 V=#$< ,#3%&& "$0%*O'&% &$=$%+< =*% G? +-*0*1'/ C=:'#=$'"#R AR U"*N& "# V=#$]& C"3'$'-& =*% #"O =CC%=*'#:R >%%Z L"#=3+ a%'#%* =#+ U'33'=; 9=;%& a""$0 _%+&R` _.KKA` C*%2 ] E"('2',*( E9'("3"89:P B9/ ="%2/18"#*#: U/)*,: _h=3% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z W%O T=M%# p ["#+"#`Y T=##=0 5*%#+$ _.KI@` U/,2?#/3 "% C*%2X3 E"('2',*( E9'("3"89: _%+R L"#=3+ a%'#%*< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:"`Y T=#& >=#%* _.KHA` C*%2X3 E"('2',*( B9"?)92P ;23 S#')'%3 *%0 $/G/("8H 1/%2 _$*=#&R BR aR 5&0$"#Z !0'-=:" Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !0'-=:"`Y U'33'=; 9=;%& a""$0 _.KID` ;%2/#8#/2'%) B9/ Q"#(0P C*%2X3 E9'("3"89: "@ N'32"#: *%0 E"('2',3 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 /"*"#$" 8*%&&Z /"*"#$"`Y >,&=# P%3+ >0%33 _.KIE` B9/ F')923 "@ F/*3"%P + 52?0: "@ C*%2X3 E9'("3"89: *%0 E"('2',3 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 /"*"#$" 8*%&&Z /"*"#$"`Y T"O=*+ U'33'=;& _.KIA` C*%2X3 E"('2',*( E9'("3"89: _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`Y 9%=#12*=#-n"'& [?"$=*+ _.KIA` B9/ $'@@/#/%0P E9#*3/3 '% $'38?2/ _.KII $*=#&R e%"*:%& c=# 7%# 5GG%%3%< P=#-0%&$%* Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z P=#-0%&$%*`R FR T=#& L%'&& _%+R` _.KK.` C*%2P E"('2',*( Q#'2'%)3 _!=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&` '#-3,+%& $0% %&&=?& "# 0'&$"*?< B#3':0$%#;%#$< $0%"*? =#+ C*=-$'-% =#+ C%*C%$1 ,=3 C%=-%Y V=#$ _.HKA` F/(')'"% .'29'% 29/ U'1'23 "@ F/*3"% +("%/ _.KAF $*=#&R /0%"+"*% PR e*%%#% =#+ T"?$ TR T,+&"#< bC%# !",*$ 8,G3'&0'#: !";C=#?Z .KI

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

G#$1+4;5$.+#

6R !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`Y ="%@(',2 "@ !*,?(2'/3 _.HKD` _.KHK $*=#&R P=*? 9R e*%:"*< 5*=G'& a""N&Z W%O h"*N`Y B9/ &/2*89:3',3 "@ &"#*(3 _.HKH` _.KKD $*=#&R P=*? e*%:"*< !=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%`R 6R >%% 4""$#"$% "4 dD6 "4 B9/ =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2R U%*#%* 83,0=* "# CR @6F "4 0'& $*=#&3=$'"# "4 $0% O"*N '#$%*C*%$& $0'& =& = *%4%*%#-% $" $0% 5;%*'-=# L%M"3,1 $'"#R U%*#%* >R 83,0=* _.KIH` C*%2P =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 _T=-N%$$ 8,G3'&0'#: !";C=#?Z )#+'=#"C"3'& =#+ !=;G*'+:%`R T"O%M%*< T"O=*+ !=?:'33 _.KK6` + C*%2 $',2'"%*#: _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`< %#$*? "# \C"3'$'-=3 O*'$'#:&]< $=N%& $0'& =& = *%4%*%#-% $" $0% 2*%#-0 L%M"3,$'"#R DR 9=;%& >-0;'$$ _%+R` _.KKD` Q9*2 '3 D%(')92/%1/%2R D')92//%29H=/%2?#: +%3./#3 *%0 B./%2'/29H=/%2?#: O?/32'"%3 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !=3'4"*#'= 8*%&&Z a%*N%3%?< ["& 5#:%3%& =#+ ["#+"#` *%C*'#$& = #,;G%* "4 %&&=?& "# V=#$]& -"#$*'G,$'"# $" $0% -"#$*"M%*&? "M%* B#3':0$%#;%#$< '#-3,+'#: $0"&% "4 T=G%*;=& =#+ 2",1 -=,3$R T% &'$,=$%& $0'& %&&=? 0'&$"*'-=33? G? *%C*'#$'#: 0%*% = #,;G%* "4 "$0%* %&&=?& "# $0% $"C'- O0'-0 =*% -"#$%;C"*=#%",& $" $0=$ "4 V=#$R HR V=#$ _.HDF` S73/#G*2'"%3 "% B9/ !//('%) "@ B9/ 6/*?2'@?( *%0 B9/ 5?7('1/ _.KHA $*=#&R 9"0# /R e"3+$0O='$%< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !=3'4"*#'= 8*%&&Z a%*N%3%?`R IR V=#$ _.HDD` $#/*13 "@ * 58'#'2H5//# D(?,'0*2/0 7: $#/*13 "@ &/2*89:3',3< '#-3,+%+ '# 7R U=$4"*+ =#+ LR P=NN*%%3 _%+&R =#+ $*=#&R` _.KK@` B9/"#/2',*( E9'("3"89: ^_``a^__b _!=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%`R KR 8%$%* 2%#M%& _%+R` _.KKA` F*'3'%) 29/ B"%/ "@ E9'("3"89: _9"0#& T"CN'#& Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z a=3$';"*% =#+ ["#+"#` '#-3,+%& =33 $0% %&&=?& +'*%-$%+ =:='#&$ >-03"&&%*R 2%#M%&] M"3,;% =3&" '#-3,+%& = *=*% *%43%-$'"# "# V=#$'=# %&-0=$"3":?< 9=-J,%& 7%**'+= _.KI.` \b# 5 W%O3? 5*'&%# 5C"-=3?C$'- /"#% )# 80'3"&"C0?] _.KKA $*=#&R 9"0# [%=M%? 9*R`R 5 $*=#&3=$'"# "4 \/0% B#+ "4 533 /0'#:&] G? L"G%*$ BR 5#-0"* '& '#-3,+%+ '# [%O'& U0'$% a%-N _%+R` _.KIE` C*%2P S% N'32"#: _['G*=*? "4 ['G%*=3 5*$&< a"GG&1P%**'33 B+,-=$'"#=3 8,G3'&01 '#:Z )#+'=#=C"3'&`R .ER /0% \e*%=$%* [":'-] '& C,G3'&0%+ =& N/)/(X3 5,'/%,/ "@ U")', _.KDK $*=#&R 5R cR P'33%*Z e%"*:% 533%# p Q#O'#Z ["#+"# p T,;=#'$'%& 8*%&&Z W%O h"*N`R /0% \&;=33%* [":'-] '& =M='3=G3% '# U'33'=; U=33=-%]& .KH6 $*=#&3=$'"# N/)/(X3 U")', _!3=*%#+"# 8*%&&Z b(4"*+`R

>-")$*1 T .R /0% $%*; K/1?W2 '& +'&-,&&%+ '# T"O=*+ !=?:'33 _.KK6` + C*%2 $',2'"%*#: _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`< CCR @.E^.@R !=?:'33 M'M'+3? +%;"#&$*=$%& $0% -";C3%('$? "4 $0% $%*;R /0% -"#M%#$'"#=3 *%#+'$'"# "4 '$ =& \;'#+] &0",3+ #"$ G% $=N%# =& '#+'-=$'#: $0=$ '$ *%4%*& $" = \$0'#N'#: &,G&$=#-%] G,$ '#&$%=+< \= -"*C"*%=3 =O=*%#%&& "4 &%#&=$'"# =#+ &%341=44%-$'"#]R @R V=#$< U")', _.KHF $*=#&R LR >R T=*$;=# =#+ UR >-0O=*k< 7"M%* 8,G3'-=$'"#&< W%O h"*N` CR .FAR AR )# $0% 4'*&$ %+'$'"# =# =*:,;%#$ '& +%&-*'G%+ =& = \;%$=C0?&'-=3 %(C"&'$'"#] O0%# '$ &0",3+ 0=M% G%%# $%*;%+ = \$*=#&-%#+%#$=3 %(C"&'$'"#]R FR ) =; ,&'#: [%O'& U0'$% a%-N]& .K6D $*=#&3=$'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"% _['G*=*? "4 ['G%*=3 5*$&Z P=-;'33=#< W%O h"*N =#+ b(4"*+` =#+ $0% &$=#+=*+ *%4%*%#-% 0%*% =#+ O'$0 $0% B9'#0 =#'2'>?/ '& $" $0% +-*0/1'/ C=:'#=1 $'"#< 0%*% 5NR 6ZKER

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

4"2/3 .KK

@EE C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

>-")$*1 U .R >%%< 4"* %(=;C3%< P=*$'# T%'+%::%* _.K@K` C*%2 *%0 29/ E#"7(/1 "@ &/2*89:3',3 _$*=#&R G? 9=;%& >R !0,*-0'33< .KD@Z )#+'=#= Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z a3"";'#:$"#` 4"* = M%*? 4"*-%4,3 *%=+'#: "4 $0% 517%+,-$'"#Y W"*;=# V%;C >;'$0 _.K.I` + ="11/%2*#: 2" C*%2X3 =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% _P=-;'33=#Z ["#+"#< @#+ %+'$'"#< .K@A` C*%&%#$& $0% "CC"&'$% C"&'$'"# "4 =*:,'#: $0=$ "#3? $0% a17%+,-$'"# C*"M'+%& = $*,3? !*'$'-=3 =--",#$R 2"* -"#$%;C"*=*? -";;%#$=*? "# $0% -"#1 $*"M%*&? &%% >=*=0 e'GG"#& _.KKF` C*%2X3 B9/"#: "@ ;1*)'%*2'"% _!3=*%#+"# 8*%&&Z b(4"*+` =#+ U=?#% U=(;=# _.KK.` C*%2X3 &"0/( "@ B9/ &'%0P + 4/. ;%2/#8#/2*2'"% "@ B#*%3,/%0/%2*( ;0/*('31 _b(4"*+ Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z b(4"*+`R @R ) 0=M% '#$%#$'"#=33? *%;"M%+ V%;C >;'$0]& '#$%*C"3=$'"# =$ $0'& C"'#$ O0'-0 &%%;& $" ;% =# =$$%;C$ $" O%=N%# $0% &%#&% "4 $0'& C=&&=:%R AR )# 0'& "O# -"C? "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% V=#$ =3$%*%+ $0'& &%#$%#-% &" $0=$ ';=:'#=$'"# '& #" 3"#:%* &C"N%# "4 =& = \4,#-$'"# "4 $0% &",3] G,$ *=$0%* = \4,#-$'"# "4 $0% ,#+%*&$=#+'#:]R /0'& -'$%+ '# T%'+%::%* _"8V ,'2R< CR .DI` =#+ =3&" '# L,+"34 5R P=NN*%%3 _.KKE` ;1*)'%*2'"% *%0 ;%2/#8#/2*2'"% ;% C*%2P B9/ N/#1/%/?2',*( ;18"#2 "@ B9/ =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`< CR @KR P=NN*%%3 &,::%&$& "# $0% G=&'& "4 $0'& %M'+%#-% $0=$ $0% *%=CC%=*=#-% "4 $0% ,#=;%#+%+ &%#$%#-% '# $0% &%-"#+ %+'$'"# "4 $0% 2'*&$ !*'$'J,% O=& \=# "M%*&':0$ "# V=#$]& C=*$]R ) O'33 &,::%&$ "$0%*O'&%R FR /0'& C*"G3%; '& ;=+% ;,-0 "4 G? e%"*:% >-0*=+%*R !4R >-0*=+%* _.K6A^F` \/0% >$=$,& "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$ '# $0% !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0?] C*%2H52?0'/% F6 =#+ &%% ;? %=*3'%* *%&C"#&% $" 0'& =--",#$ '# e=*? a=#0=; _.KKD` \V=#$]& =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 =#+ $0% 8,*C"&'M% Q#'$? "4 !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0?] _&*%H ,9/32/# E*8/#3 '% E9'("3"89: *%0 E9/%"1/%"("):< W"R AZ PPQ< 7%C$ "4 8"3'$'-& =#+ 80'3"&"C0?< U"*N'#: 8=C%*& >%*'%&`R 6R 2"* = 4,33 =--",#$ "4 $0'& +'&$'#-$'"# G%$O%%# $O" N'#+& "4 &-0%;=$'&; &%% T"O=*+ !=?:'33 _.KII` \8"&$1P"+%*#'&; =#+ 9,+:;%#$] D,"%"1: *%0 5",'/2:< c"3R .H< W"R .R

>-")$*1 V .R 7"#=3+ UR !*=O4"*+ _.KHF` C*%2X3 +/329/2', B9/"#: _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 U'&-"#&'# 8*%&&Z P=+'&"#`< CR .HR @R 9=-J,%& 7%**'+= _.KHI` B9/ B#?29 '% E*'%2'%) _.KIH $*=#&R e%"44 a%##'#:$"# =#+ )=# P-[%"+< !0'-=:" Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !0'-=:"`< CR HFR AR 9R12R [?"$=*+ _.KK.` U/33"%3 "% B9/ +%*(:2', "@ B9/ 5?7('1/ _$*=#&R B3'k=G%$0 L"$$%#G%*:< .KKFZ >$=#4"*+ Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z >$=#4"*+< !5`< CR .HR

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

6R [%O'& U0'$% a%-N _.KDE` + ="11/%2*#: "% C*%2X3 !*'$'J,% "4 8*=-$'-=3 L%=&"# _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:"`< CR @.@R DR );;=#,%3 V=#$ _.HDF` S73/#G*2'"%3 "% B9/ !//('%) "@ B9/ 6/*?2'@?( *%0 B9/ 5?7('1/ _$*=#&R 9"0# /R e"3+$0O='$%< .KHAZ Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'1 -=:"`R /0% e%*;=# $'$3% '& 6/"7*,92?%)/% 7/# 0*3 K/@9( 0*3 5,9"W%/% ?%0 D#9*7/H %/% =#+ '$ '& '#-3,+%+ '# M"3,;% @ "4 $0% +-*0/1'/ %+'$'"#R

4"2/3 @E.

.R 5C=*$ 4*"; $0% =4"*%;%#$'"#%+ O"*N "4 [?"$=*+ _O0" 0=& =3&" O*'$$%# %3&%1 O0%*% "# $0% $"C'- "4 &,G3';% S,+:;%#$&`< -4R L,+"34 5R P=NN*%%3 _.KKE` ;1*)'%*2'"% *%0 ;%2/#8#/2*2'"% ;% C*%2P B9/ N/#1/%/?2',*( ;18"#2 "@ B9/ =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`< 7"#=3+ UR !*=O4"*+ _.KI6` \/0% 83=-% "4 $0% >,G3';% '# V=#$]& 5%&$0%$'- /0%"*?]< '# LR V%##'#:$"# _%+R` _.KI6` B9/ E9'("3"89: "@ ;11*%?/( C*%2 _!=$0"3'Q#'M%*&'$? "4 5;%*'-= 8*%&&Z U=&0'#:$"#` =#+ 9=-J,%& 7%**'+=< "8V ,'2V< CCR ..K^FHR @R ) =; 0%*% 3%=#'#: "# U%*#%* 83,0=*]& =--",#$ '# 0'& \/*=#&3=$"*]& )#$*"+,-$'"#] $" B9/ =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2R 2"* = 4,33%* *%&C"#&% $" 83,0=*< &%% !0=C$%* I G%3"OR

>-")$*1 X .R 8=,3 e,?%* _.KKH` C*%2 *%0 29/ =(*'13 "@ B*32/ _!=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&`< CR @FIR /0'& O"*N O=& 4'*&$ C,G3'&0%+ '# .KHK =#+ $0'& *%1'&&,% -"#$='#& = C*%4=-% O'$0 &";% &':#'4'-=#$ %;%#+=$'"#& "4 e,?%*]& "*':'#=3 C"&'$'"# $0",:0 #"$ "# $0'& J,%&$'"#R @R 2"* M%*? +'44%*%#$ *%=&"#& $0'& &,::%&$'"# '& ;=+% '# G"$0 "4 $0% 4"33"O'#:Z 5#$0"#? !R e%#"M= _.KH@` \V=#$]& /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7%+,-$'"# "4 5%&$0%$'-=3 9,+:;%#$&] A"?#%*( "@ +/329/2',3 *%0 +#2 =#'2','31 M"3,;% ooo W"R FY !3=,+% P=-;'33=# _.KI6` \V=#$]& 7%+,-$'"# "4 8,*% 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$&]< C*%2H52?H 0'/%< W"R HDR AR e,?%*< "8V ,'2V< CR @AFR !4R =3&" $0% 4"33"O'#: *%;=*N G? BM= >-0=C%*Z /0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 '& #"$ -"#&C'-,",& 4"* -3=*'$? "4 =*:,;%#$ "* %M%# 4"* '#$%33':'G3% &$=$%;%#$& "4 '#$%#$'"#R W" 0%3C '& $" G% :3%=#%+ 4*"; $0% 4=;",& V=#$'=# =*-0'$%-$"#'-< O0'-0 '# $0% -=&% "4 $0'& !*'$'J,% &%%;& $" 0=M% :"$ ",$ "4 0=#+ %#$'*%3?R

FR

6R

DR HR

BM= >-0=C%* _.KHA` \V=#$ b# 5%&$0%$'- 5CC*='&=3&]< C*%2H52?0'/%< W"R DF< CR FA@R b#% "4 $0% *=*% %(-%C$'"#& 0%*% '& 2"**%&$ U'33'=;& _.K6F^6` \80'3"&"C0'-=3 5#$0*"C"3":? =#+ $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2]< C*%2H52?0'/%< c"3R @< W"R FR /0'& M'%O 0=&< 0"O%M%*< G%%# M':"*",&3? -"#$%&$%+ G? >=3'; V%;=3 _.KIE` \/0% );C"*$=#-% "4 5*$'&$'- a%=,$?]< C*%2H 52?0'/%< W"R H. =#+ '# >=3'; V%;=3 _.KID` C*%2 *%0 !'%/ +#2P +% D33*: "% C*%2 *%0 B9/ E9'("3"89: "@ !'%/ +#2 *%0 =?(2?#/ _!3=*%#+"# 8*%&&Z b(4"*+`R !4R C=*$'-,3=*3? LR VR B33'"$$ _.KDI` \/0% Q#'$? "4 V=#$]& =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2]< 6#'2'39 A"?#%*( "@ +/329/2',3R !4R V=#$]& =--",#$ "4 $0% \&-0%;=$'&; "4 =#=3":?] '# F/(')'"% .'29'% 29/ U'1'23 "@ F/*3"% +("%/T 5N c)Z DF^6< 4""$#"$%R 2"* $0% +*=O'#: "4 =# %($*%;%3? $':0$ *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# *%3':'"# =#+ $0% =%&$0%$'- C"O%* '# 3=$%* C0'3"&"C0? &%% C=*$'-,3=*3? 2*'%+*'-0 W'%$k&-0% _.IH@` B9/ 6'#29 "@ B#*)/0: _.KDH $*=#&R U=3$%* V=,4;=##Z c'#$=:% a""N&Z W%O h"*N`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>-")$*1 W

@E@ C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

.R !4R U%*#%* 83,0=*]& G'G3'":*=C0? =$ $0% %#+ "4 0'& $*=#&3=$'"# "4 $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,% O0'-0 "44%*& = *%3=$'M%3? -";C3%$% &,;;=*? "4 *%-%#$ O"*N C,G3'&0%+ "# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 =#+ '#+'-=$%& $0% C=,-'$? "4 ;=$%*'=3 "# $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2R )$ '& &$'33 $0% -=&% $0=$ 9"0# P-2=*3=#+ _.KHE` C*%2X3 ="%,/82 "@ B/(/"("): _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 B+'#G,*:0 8*%&&Z B+'#G,*:0 =#+ !0'-=:"` '& %($*%;%3? ,#,&,=3 '# 4"-,&'#: %(-3,&'M%3? "# $%3%"3":?R BM%# P-2=*3=#+]& O"*N 4='3& $" +'&-,&& ;"*=3 $%3%"3":?< 0"O%M%*< O0'-0 '& $0% C*"M'#-% "4 /0";=& 5,($%* _.KI@` C*%2X3 &"#*( B/(/"("): _P%*-%* Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z P=-"#`R @R 5& e%"*:% >-0*=+%* O*'$%&Z \/%3%"3":? $0,& C*"M'+%& $0% G=&'- C*'#-'C3% :"M%*#1 '#: $0% '#'$'=3 *%-%C$'"# "4 $0% \\%;C'*'-=3 ;=#'4"3+]]R e%"*:% >-0*=+%* _.K6A^ F` \/0% >$=$,& "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$ )# /0% !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0?] C*%2H 52?0'/%< c"3R F6< CR @.KR

>-")$*1 Z .R 5NR 6ZAHA< W"$% AIR T%:%3 %($%#+& $0'& -";C=*'&"# '# B9/ E9'("3"89: "@ F')92V

>-")$*1 [ .R e%"*:% >-0*=+%* _.K6A^F` \/0% >$=$,& "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$& '# $0% !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0?]< C*%2H52?0'/%< c"3R F6R @R 9"0# 7R P-2=*3=#+ _.KHE` C*%2X3 ="%,/82 "@ B/(/"("): _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 B+'#G,*:0 8*%&&Z B+'#G,*:0 =#+ !0'-=:"`R AR )# =++'$'"# $" P-2=*3=#+ =#+ >-0*=+%*< &%% L"G%*$ BR a,$$& _.KIF` C*%2 *%0 B9/ $"?7(/ K"G/#%1/%2 &/29"0"("): _7R L%'+%3Z 7"*+*%-0$`R FR U%*#%* 83,0=* _.KIH` \/*=#&3=$"*]& )#$*"+,-$'"#] $" 0'& $*=#&3=$'"#R CR 3((('(R 6R /0% O0"3% -"#$%($ "4 $0'& *%;=*N 4,*$0%* &,CC"*$& $0% -%#$*=3 C"'#$ "4 $0% *%:,3=$'M% #=$,*% "4 $0% '+%= "4 4*%%+";R 2"* $0% -"**%&C"#+'#: +"-$*'#% '# $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,% $0=$ $0% G=&'& "4 $0% *%:,3=$'M% ,&% "4 $0% '+%= "4 4*%%+"; '& $0% +%;"#&$*=$'"# "4 $0% C0%#";%#=3 -0=*=-$%* "4 &C=-% =#+ $';% &%% 5NR 6Z KF^.EAR

>-")$*1 \ .R eRUR2R T%:%3 _.I.@^.D` B9/ 5,'/%,/ "@ U")', _$*=#&R 5RcR P'33%*< .KDKZ e%"*:% 533%# p Q#O'#Z ["#+"# =#+ T,;=#'$'%& 8*%&&Z W%O h"*N`< CR H@HR @R eRUR2R T%:%3 _.IEH` B9/ E9/%"1/%"("): "@ &'%0 _$*=#&R 5RcR P'33%*< .KH6Z b(4"*+ Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z b(4"*+`< C=*=R AHR AR 2"* =# '#$%*%&$'#: *%-%#$ =--",#$ "4 $0'& =&C%-$ "4 $0% V=#$fT%:%3 *%3=$'"# -4R L'-0=*+ a%=*+&O"*$0 _.KKD` $/##'0* *%0 29/ E"('2',*( _L",$3%+:%Z ["#+"# =#+ W%O h"*N`< !0=C$%* @R FR 5#$0"#? e%#"M= _.KHF` \V=#$]& BC':%#%&'& "4 8,*% L%=&"#]< C*%2H52?0'/%< c"3R D6< CR @HER

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>-")$*1 Y

4"2/3 @EA 6R /0% (",?3 ,(*33',?3 4"* $0'& =--",#$ '& T=##=0 5*%#+$ _.KHE` U/,2?#/3 "% C*%2X3 E"('2',*( E9'("3"89: _C"&$0,;",&3? C,G3'&0%+ .KI@< %+R L"#=3+ a%'#%*< T=*1 M%&$%* 8*%&&Z a*':0$"# =#+ Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&`R

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` B9/ +#2 "@ A?0)1/%2 _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`< CR AI6R AR >%% !0=C$%* . "4 /0% /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7"-$*'#% "4 P%$0"+< \/0% 7'&-'C3'#% "4 8,*% L%=&"#] _5HEIfaHAD^5HKFfaI@@` 4"* = 3%#:$0? =--",#$ "4 $0% *%3=$'"# G%$O%%# +'&-'C3'#% =#+ *%=&"#R >%% =3&" 5IAAfaID. 4"* $0% 4'#=3 %#+ &-0%;=R FR T"O=*+ !=?:'33 _.KII`< \8"&$1P"+%*#'&; =#+ 9,+:%;%#$]< D,"%"1: *%0 5",'/2:< c"3R .H< W"R .< CR .H =#+ 8*33'1R 6R !=?:'33 _.KIK`< CR @KIR DR e%"*:% 5*;&$*"#: V%33? _.KDK` ;0/*('31T E"('2',3 *%0 N'32"#:P 5"?#,/3 "@ N/)/('*% B9"?)92 _!=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%`R HR T%*% =#+ $0*",:0",$ -'$=$'"#& =*% 4*"; L%'&&< CR F@R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>-")$*1 T]

>%3%-$ a'G3'":*=C0?

/0% 5-=+%;? B+'$'"# O0'-0 O=& G%:,# '# .KE@ G? $0% 8*,&&'=# 5-=+%;? "4 >-'%#-%&< -"#$'#,%+ 3=$%* G? $0% e%*;=# 5-=+%;? "4 >-'%#-%& '# a%*3'# =#+ $0% g $$'#:%# '& #"O $0% *%-":#'&%+ &$=#+=*+ %+'$'"#R /0% 5-=+%;? "4 >-'%#-%& '# e" /0'*+ !*'$'J,% '& c"3R 6 "4 $0'&< =& '& $0% >%-"#+ !*'$'J,%R c"3R @E -"#$='#& $0% 2'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# $" $0% /0'*+ !*'$'J,%R

3#07.&- '1"#&7"$.+#& +, !"#$ W"*;=# V%;C >;'$0]& .K@K $*=#&3=$'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"% _P=-;'33=#` '& *%4%**%+ $" $0*",:0",$R [%O'& U0'$% a%-N]& .K6D $*=#&3=$'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"% _/0% ['G*=*? "4 ['G%*=3 5*$&` '& =3&" = -"#&$=#$R L"G%*$ >R T=*$;=# =#+ U"34:=#: >-0O=*k]& .KHF $*=#&3=$'"# "4 9=g&-0%]& #"$%& "4 V=#$]& 3%-$,*%& "# 3":'- O=& ,&%+ $0*",:0",$ _7"M%* 8,G3'-=$'"#&Z W%O h"*N`R T=#& L%'&& _%+R` C*%2P E"('2',*( Q#'2'%)3 _$*=#&R TR aR W'&G%$` _.KHE O'$0 &%-"#+ %#3=*:%+ %+'$'"# .KK.`R [%O'& U0'$% a%-N _%+R` C*%2P S% N'32"#: _.K6H< $*=#&R [%O'& U0'$% a%-N< L"G%*$ BR 5#-0"* =#+ B;'3 [R 2=-N%#0%';< ['G*=*? "4 ['G%*=3 5*$&`R 9=;%& UR B33'#:$"# _.KKA $*=#&R` K#"?%0'%) @"# 29/ &/2*89:3', "@ &"#*(3 _T=-N%$$ 8,G3'&0'#: !"Z )#+'=#=`R P=*? e*%:"* _.KKF %+R =#+ $*=#&R` B9/ &/2*89:3',3 "@ &"#*(3 _!=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*1 &'$? 8*%&&`R F/(')'"% .'29'% 29/ U'1'23 "@ F/*3"% +("%/ _.KAF $*=#&R /R PR e*%%#% =#+ TR TR T,+&"#< bC%# !",*$ 8,G3'&0'#: !";C=#?Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`R ="%@(',2 "@ !*,?(2'/3 _.KHK $*=#&R P=*? e*%:"*< 5*=G'& a""N&Z W%O h"*N`R 8=,3 !=*,& _.KE@` E#"(/)"1/%* _bC%# !",*$ 8,G3'&0'#: !";C=#?Z [= >=33%`R 8%$%* 2%#M%& _%+R` _.KKA` F*'3'%) 29/ B"%/ "@ E9'("3"89: _9"0#& T"CN'#& Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z a=3$';"*% =#+ ["#+"#`R

'1"#&7"$.+#& +, $-* '-.14 >1.$.O;* 9R TR a%*#=*+ _.IK@`< *%M'&%+ @#+ %+'$'"# .K.F _P=-;'33=#`R /0'& %+'$'"# 0=& G%%# *%C*'#$%+ =#+ &$'33 -'*-,3=$%&< G,$ '& M%*? 3""&% =#+ ";'$& $0% 2'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"#R 9=;%& !*%%+ P%*%+'$0 $*=#&3=$%+ $0% $O" 0=3M%& &%C=*=$%3?< $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ +/329/2', A?0)1/%2 =CC%=*'#: '# .K.. O'$0 &%M%# '#$*"+,-$"*? %&&=?& _!3=*%#+"# 8*%&&`R P%*%+'$0]& $*=#&3=$'"# "4 $0% =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 =CC%=*%+ '# .K@I O'$0 =# '#$*"+,-$'"# _!3=*%#+"# 8*%&&`R /0% $O" O%*% -";G'#%+ '#$" "#% =#'2'>?/ "@ A?0)1/%2 '# .K6@ O'$0",$ $0% '#$*"1 +,-$'"#& =#+ #"$%&R Q#$'3 *%-%#$3? $0'& O=& $0% &$=#+=*+ $*=#&3=$'"#< G,$ +%&C'$% ;,-0 :*%=$%* =--,*=-? $0=# a%*#=*+< $0% O"*N &$'33 3=-N%+ $0% 4'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"# =#+ -"#$='#& #" G'G3'":*=C0? "4 O"*N& "# V=#$R @EF

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

34.$.+#& +, !"#$ .# D*12"#

5/(/,2 6'7('")#*89: @E6 U%*#%* 83,0=* _.KIH` _T=-N%$$ 8,G3'&0'#: !";C=#?Z )#+'=#=C"3'& =#+ !=;1 G*'+:%` '& $0% 3=$%&$ $*=#&3=$'"# O0'-0 '#-3,+%& $0% 2'*&$ )#$*"+,-$'"#< =# ';C"*$=#$ /*=#&3=$"*]& )#$*"+,-$'"#< a'G3'":*=C0? =#+ :3"&&=*? "4 e%*;=# C3,& =# '#+%(R

5,'/%,/ "@ U")', _.I.@`< _.KH6 $*=#&R 5RcR P'33%*< e%"*:% 533%# p Q#O'#Z ["#+"# p T,;=#'$'%& 8*%&&Z W%O h"*N`R N/)/(X3 U")', _.IAE`< _\B#-?-3"C=%+'= [":'-]` _.KH6 $*=#&R U'33'=; U=33=-% !3=*1 %#+"# 8*%&&Z b(4"*+`R D(/1/%23 "@ 29/ E9'("3"89: "@ F')92 _.I@.`< _.KK. $*=#&R TR aR W'&G%$ =#+ %+R G? 533%# U""+< !=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%`R

E*5+#4"1( E+;15*& 5+"*#"< /0%"+"* _.KHE` +/329/2', B9/"#: _.KIF $*=#&R G? !R [%#0=*+$< L",$3%+:% p V%:=# 8=,3Z ["#+"#`R 5*%#+$< T=##=0 _.KI@` U/,2?#/3 "% C*%2X3 E"('2',*( E9'("3"89: _%+R L"#=3+ a%'#%*< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&`R 5,($%*< /0";=& _.KI@` C*%2X3 &"#*( B/(/"("): _P%*-%* Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z P=-"#`R a=#0=;< e=*? _.KKD` \V=#$]& =#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 =#+ $0% 8,*C"&'M% Q#'$? "4 !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0?] _P=#-0%&$%* 8=C%*& '# 80'3"&"C0? =#+ 80%#"1 ;%#"3":? W"R AZ P=#-0%&$%* P%$*"C"3'$=# Q#'M%*&'$?< 7%C$R "4 8"3'$'-& =#+ 80'3"&"C0?< U"*N'#: 8=C%*& >%*'%&`R a%=*+&O"*$0< L'-0=*+ _.KKD` $/##'0* *%0 29/ E"('2',*( _L",$3%+:%Z ["#+"# =#+ W%O h"*N`R a%-N< [%O'& U0'$% _.KDE` + ="11/%2*#: "% C*%2X3 =#'2'>?/ "@ E#*,2',*( F/*3"% _/0% Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`R a%'#%*< L"#=3+ =#+ a""$0< U'33'=; 9=;%& _%+&R` _.KKA` C*%2 ] E"('2',*( E9'("3"89: _h=3% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z W%O T=M%# =#+ ["#+"#`R a%*#&$%'#< 9=? _.KK@` B9/ !*2/ "@ +#2P +/329/2', +('/%*2'"% !#"1 C*%2 2" +0"#%" _8"3'$? 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%`R a""$0< U'33'=; 9=;%& _.KID` ;%2/#8#/2'%) 29/ Q"#(0P C*%2X3 E9'("3"89: "@ N'32"#: *%0 E"('2',3 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 /"*"#$" 8*%&&Z /"*"#$" =#+ ["#+"#`R a"O'%< 5#+*%O _.KKH` !#"1 F"1*%2','31 2" =#'2',*( B9/"#:P B9/ E9'("3"89: "@ K/#H 1*% U'2/#*#: B9/"#: _L",$3%+:%Z ["#+"# =#+ W%O h"*N`R a,$$&< L"G%*$ BR _.KIF` C*%2 *%0 29/ $"?7(/ K"G/#%1/%2 &/29"0"("): _7R L%'+%3 8,G3'&0'#: !";C=#?Z 7"*+*%-0$< a"&$"# =#+ [=#-=&$%*`R !=*#"'&< a%*#=*+ _.KHA` B9/ ="9/#/%,/ "@ C*%2X3 $",2#'%/ "@ !#//0"1 _.KIH $*=#&R G? 7=M'+ a""$0< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`R !=&&'*%*< B*#&$ _.K.I` C*%2X3 U'@/ *%0 B9"?)92 _.KI. $*=#&R 9=;%& T=+%#< h=3% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z W%O T=M%# =#+ ["#+"#`R !=?:'33< T"O=*+ _.KII` \8"&$1P"+%*#'&; =#+ 9,+:;%#$]< D,"%"1: *%0 5",'/2: c"3R .H< W"R.R !=?:'33< T"O=*+ _.KIK` B9/ +#2 "@ A?0)1/%2 _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`R !=?:'33< T"O=*+ _.KK6` + C*%2 $',2'"%*#: _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'1"#&7"$.+#& +, R*0*7

!*=O4"*+< 7"#=3+ UR _.KHF` C*%2X3 +/329/2', B9/"#: _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 U'&-"#&'# 8*%&&`R !*=O4"*+< 7"#=3+ UR _.KI6` \/0% 83=-% "4 $0% >,G3';% '# V=#$]& 5%&$0%$'- /0%1 "*?]< '# L'-0=*+ V%##'#:$"# _%+R` _.KI6` B9/ E9'("3"89: "@ ;11*%?/( C*%2 _!=$0"3'- Q#'M%*&'$? "4 5;%*'-= 8*%&&`R 7%3%,k%< e'33%& _.KDAc C*%2X3 =#'2',*( E9'("3"89:P B9/ $",2#'%/ "@ 29/ !*,?(2'/3 _.KIF $*=#&R G? T,:0 /";3'#&"# =#+ a=*G=*= T=GG%*S=;< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 P'##%&"$= 8*%&&Z P'##%=C"3'&`R 7%**'+=< 9=-J,%& _.KHI` B9/ B#?29 '% E*'%2'%) _.KIH $*=#&R e%"44 a%##'#:$"# =#+ )=# P-[%"+< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`R 7%**'+=< 9=-J,%& _.KKE` &/1"'#3 "@ 29/ 6('%0P B9/ 5/(@HE"#2#*'2 *%0 S29/# F?'%3 _.KKA $*=#&R 8=&-=3%15##% a*=,3$ =#+ P'-0=%3 W==&< Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`R 7,M%< /0'%**? +% _.KKD` C*%2 *@2/# $?,9*18 _P)/ 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:% P=&&R< =#+ ["#+"#`R B=:3%$"#< /%**? _.KKE` B9/ ;0/"("): "@ 29/ +/329/2', _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`R B33'"$$< LR VR _.KDI` \/0% Q#'$? "4 V=#$]& \\!*'$'J,% "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$]] ]< 6#'2'39 A"?#%*( "@ +/329/2',3< IR e%#"M=< 5#$0"#? !R _.KHE` \V=#$]& !";C3%( 8*"G3%; "4 L%43%-$'M% 9,+:;%#$] F/G'/. "@ &/2*89:3',3< c"3R o))< W"R AR e%#"M=< 5#$0"#? !R _.KH@` \V=#$]& /*=#&-%#+%#$=3 7%+,-$'"# "4 5%&$0%$'-=3 9,+:;%#$&]< A"?#%*( "@ +/329/2',3 *%0 +#2 =#'2','31< c"3R ooo< W"R FR e%#"M=< 5#$0"#? !R _.KHF` \V=#$]& BC':%#%&'& "4 8,*% L%=&"#]< C*%2H52?0'/%< D6R e'GG"#&< >=*=0 _.KKF` C*%2X3 B9/"#: "@ 29/ ;1*)'%*2'"% _!3=*%#+"# 8*%&&Z b(4"*+`R e,?%*< 8=,3 _.KKH` C*%2 *%0 29/ =(*'13 "@ B*32/ _!=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%`R T%'+%::%*< P=*$'# _.K@K` C*%2 *%0 29/ E#"7(/1 "@ &/2*89:3',3 _.KD@ $*=#&R 9=;%& >R !0,*-0'33< )#+'=#= Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z a3"";'#:$"#`R V%33?< e%"*:% 5*;&$*"#: _.KDK` ;0/*('31T E"('2',3 *%0 N'32"#:P 5"?#,/3 "@ N/)/('*% B9"?)92 _!=;G*'+:% Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !=;G*'+:%`R V%;=3< >=3'; _.KIE` \/0% );C"*$=#-% "4 5*$'&$'- a%=,$?]< C*%2H 52?0'/% W"R H.R V%;=3< >=3'; _.KID` C*%2 *%0 !'%/ +#2P +% D33*: "% C*%2 *%0 29/ E9'("3"89: "@ !'%/ +#2 *%0 =?(2?#/ _!3=*%#+"# 8*%&&Z b(4"*+`R [=-",%1[=G=*$0%< 80'3'CC% _.KK.` &?3',* !',2* d!')?#/3 "@ Q*)%/#c _.KKF $*=#&R 2%3'-'= P-!=**%#< >$=#4"*+ Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&`R [?"$=*+< 9%=#12*=#-n"'& _.KIA` B9/ $'@@/#/%0P E9#*3/3 '% $'38?2/ _.KII $*=#&R e%"*:%& c=# 7%# 5GG%%3%< P=#-0%&$%* Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z P=#-0%&$%*`R [?"$=*+< 9%=#12*=#-n"'& _.KK.` U/33"%3 "% 29/ +%*(:2', "@ 29/ 5?7('1/ _.KKF $*=#&R B3'k=G%$0 L"$$%#G%*:< >$=#4"*+ Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&`R P=-;'33=#< !3=,+% _.KI6` \V=#$]& 7%+,-$'"# "4 8,*% 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$&]< C*%2H 52?0'/%< HDR P=NN*%%3< L,+"34 5R _.KKE` ;1*)'%*2'"% *%0 ;%2/#8#/2*2'"% '% C*%2P B9/ N/#1/%/?H 2',*( ;18"#2 "@ 29/ !*'$'J,% "4 9,+:;%#$ _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`R P-4=*3=#+< 9"0# 7R _.KHE` C*%2X3 ="%,/82 "@ B/(/"("): _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 B+'#G,*:0 8*%&&Z B+'#G,*:0 =#+ !0'-=:"`R W'%$k&-0%< 2*'%+*'-0 _.IH@` B9/ 6'#29 "@ B#*)/0: _.KDH $*=#&R U=3$%* V=,4;=##< c'N'#: 8*%&&Z W%O h"*N`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@ED C*%2 *%0 29/ D%03 "@ +/329/2',3

8=$"#< TR 9R _.KAD` C*%2X3 &/2*89:3',3 "@ D<8/#'/%,/ _e%"*:% 533%# p Q#O'#Z ["#+"#`R L"J,%< 53'-'= 9,=**%*" _.KI6` \>%341b*:=#'k=$'"#Z V=#$]& !"#-%C$ "4 /%3%"3":? =#+ P"+%*# !0%;'&$*?]< F/G'/. "@ &/2*89:3',3< AKR >=#%*< T=#& _.KHA` C*%2X3 E"('2',*( B9"?)92P '23 S#')'% *%0 $/G/("81/%2 _$*=#&R BR aR 5&0$"#< !0'-=:" Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`R >-0=C%*< BM= _.KHA` \V=#$ "# 5%&$0%$'- 5CC*='&=3&]< C*%2H52?0'/%< W"R DFR >-0;'$$< 9=;%& _%+R` _.KKD` Q9*2 '3 D%(')92/%1/%2R D')92//%29H=/%2?#: O?/32'"%3 *%0 B./%2'/29H=/%2?#: +%3./#3 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !=3'4"*#'= 8*%&&Z a%*N%3%?< ["& 5#:%3%& =#+ ["#+"#`R >-0*=+%*< e%"*:% _.K6A^6F` \/0% >$=$,& "4 /%3%"3":'-=3 9,+:;%#$& )# /0% !*'$'-=3 80'3"&"C0?]< C*%2H52?0'/% F6R >0%33< >,&=# P%3+ _.KIE` B9/ F')923 "@ F/*3"%P + 52?0: "@ C*%2X3 E9'("3"89: *%0 E"('2',3 _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 /"*"#$" 8*%&&Z /"*"#$"`R >0%33< >,&=# P%3+ _.KKD` B9/ D17"0'1/%2 "@ F/*3"%P C*%2 "% 58'#'2T K/%/#*2'"%T *%0 ="11?%'2: _Q#'M%*&'$? "4 !0'-=:" 8*%&&Z !0'-=:" =#+ ["#+"#`R >;'$0< W"*;=# V%;C _.K.I` + ="11/%2*#: 2" C*%2X3 X=#'2'>?/ "@ E?#/ F/*3"%X _P=-;'33=#< ["#+"#`R U=(;=#< U=?#% _.KK.` C*%2X3 &"0/( "@ 29/ &'%0P + 4/. ;%2/#8#/2*2'"% "@ B#*%3H ,/%0/%2*( ;0/*('31 _b(4"*+ Q#'M%*&'$? 8*%&&Z b(4"*+`R U'33'=;&< 2"**%&$ _.K6F^66` \80'3"&"C0'-=3 5#$0*"C"3":? =#+ $0% !*'$'J,% "4 5%&$0%$'- 9,+:;%#$] C*%2H52?0'/%< c"3R @< W"R FR U'33'=;&< T"O=*+ _.KIA` C*%2X3 E"('2',*( E9'("3"89: _a3=-NO%33Z b(4"*+`R

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

5/(/,2 6'7('")#*89: @EH

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

a%=,$?fa%=,$'4,3 .< H< @D< AE< A@^A< HA< DF^6< H@^A< HK^I.< ID< KE< KA< KI< .EF^H< ..E^..< ..A< ..I< .@.< .AK< .IK^KE )+%=3 "4< HA< IE< ..E< .AK< .HI< .II a%-N< [%O'& U0'$% @E< AA< .KK^@EE 6'(0?%)32#'/7 .H.^F< .I.< .ID 6'#29 "@ B#*)/0: @E. !=$%:"*'%& AD< AI< F@< FD< FI^6E< 66< 6H^I< D@< DF^6< .@I< .HD !=,&%f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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

)#+%(

;%0/< @EK

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fP'#+ .A< .I< @K< AD< AK< FA< 6F< DA< I6^D< II^K< K@< K6< .EE< ...< .6I< .KK e%#',& DA< .EI^K< ...^.6< .HI< .I@^A< .IH

e%#"M=< 5#$0"#? .HA< @E.^@ e"+ ..K^@E< .@D^A.< .AH< .IK e*=4$fe*=4$'#: .F.< .FF^6 K#"?%0."#- @"# * &/2*89:3',3 "@ &"#*(3 F< .FH e,?%*< 8=,3 KD^H< @E. T=CC'#%&& .AE< .I.^@< .IF^D< .KE< .K@ T%:%3< e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a%=,$?< )+%=3 "4 );=:'#=$'"# @K^AE< AF< AD^6K< DI< HD< HK^I.< IF^I< KF^6< KH< .EE^E.< ...^.@< ..I< .@6< .AA< .HH< .I.^@< .I6< .II< .KE< @EE )#-%#$'M% 3// B#'/7@/0/# )#$,'$'"# .@^@E< @F^6< @H< @K< AA< AD^K< F.< FA^F< FK^6.< I@^D< II^K< KK^.EE< .@E< .@F< .@H< .AD< .AI< .6E< .6F^D< .6I^DE< .HE 9,+:;%#$ .E< @H< @K< A.^@< AD< FF< 6@< 66< 6H^I< DE< DA< DD< I@< IF< KI< .E.< .EK< ..A< .A@^F< .AD< .FD< .6.< .DE^.< .HD^H< .I@< .ID^H< .K. =%&$0%$'- @K^AA< DF< DI< H.< K6< KK< ..E< .AK< .KD

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=#'2'>?/ "@ B/(/"(")',*( A?0)1/%2 .^A< 6^D< I^K< ..< HF< KF< .A.^H< .FI^K< .6A< .6D< .DF< .HE< .HD< .IE< @EE !,3$,*% D< HF< K.< KF< ..F< .@@< .IE^D< .II< .K6

@.E ;%0/<

V%33?< e%"*:% 5*;&$*"#: .ID< @EA V#"O3%+:% @< F< .@^.A< .I< @6< AD^F.< 6E< 6@< DE< .@F< .D.< .DK< .H@^A [=O& @.^A< @I< A.< FF^D< 6F^6< HA< HD^H< IH< K@^F< .E.< .@.^@< .@H^A6< .FE^.< .F6< .FH^I< .6@^6< .6H< .D.< .I@^A< .I6^D< .KE< .KA^F< .KH [%:'&3=$'"# FD< .@.< .6D ['4% @.< ..@< .DD< .DI< .HA^F [';'$ A< .D< .KH [":'- K^.E< .A^.F< .K^@.< @I< AE< A@< AD< AK< FA< 66< DE^.< D6< KI< .@F< .A.< .AA< .D6< .I6 [?"$=*+< 9%=#12*=#-n"'& .< 6< DA^6< DI< HF^6< KA< .KI< @EE P=:#'$,+% .6< IF^6< IH< KF P=NN*%%3< L,+"34 5R .KI< @E. P=#'4"3+ .A< AD< AI^K< F.^A< FD^H< FK^6E< 66< 6H< DE< I@^A< ..E< .@F< .AA< .AH< .HA< .KA P%-0=#'-=3fP%-0=#'&; K^.E< @F^6< @H< I.< .FE^.< .FA^F< .FD< .FI^66< .D.< .D6^H< .HE^.< .HF^6< .ID< .K@ P%$=C0?&'-& ..< .F< .6< .AF &/2*89:3',3 "@ &"#*(3 F< .HI< .KD< .KK P%$0"+fP%$0"+"3":? @< .F< .K< DE^.< DA< HH< IE< .IF< @EA P-2=*3=#+< 9"0# .FK^6.< .6D< @E@^A P'#+ 3// K/1?W2 P"+=3'$? D.^@< HE< H6^D< I.< IK

W=$,*% F< @H^I< A.^@< AF< FF^D< 6E< I.< IH< IK^KE< .E6^H< ...^.A< ..I^.K< .@F< .@D< .@K< .A@< .AF^D< .FF< .FD^I< .6@< .66^D< .6I< .D.< .HF< .I.^@< .ID< .II W'%$k&-0%< 2*'%+*'-0 @E. b*:=#'-fb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m,=3'$? D.^@< DF^H< I.^A m,=#$'$? D.^@< DF^H< H6< I.^@< IH L%=&"# @< .K^@F< @H< @K< A@< FF^D< 6E< 6I< HF< HK< I.< I6< II< KE< ..@< ..H^.I< .@.< .@A^6< .@H^I< .A.< .AF^H< .FE^.< .FK< .6.< .6K^D.<

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

9,+:;%#$ _="%20V` +%$%*;'#=$'M% @H^A.< 6@^A< IF< K.< .A@< .FD< .6E< .DE^. 4=-,3$? "4 FF^6< 6@^A< .E. *%43%-$'M% H< @H^I< AE^.< AA< 6@^6< D.< DA< HK< I.< KF< .ED< .A.^A< .A6< .AH< .FD< .FK^6E< .DE^.< .DA< .I6< .IK &?#$0%$'- * 8#'"#' .EE "4 $=&$% H< @D< A@< D@< DF< DD^H< DK< H.< H6^D< I.< K.< KH^.EH< ..F< .AK $%3%"3":'-=3 I< IE< ID< .AA^F< .AI^F6< .6.

;%0/< @..

>-0%;=f>-0%;=$'&; @H< @K< AD< AI< FF^D< 6E< 6@^DE< .EE^.< ..F< .@E< .A@< .AD< .DD< .H@< .HH< .I6< .II< .KE< @E. >-0*=+%*< e%"*:% .FI^K< .6.< .6D< @EE< @E@ 5,'/%,/ "@ U")', K< .D6< .KK< @E@ >%#&'G'3'$? A^F< .@^.I< @E< @6< @I^K< AI< FA^6< FK^6@< 66< 6H^I< K@< ..@< ..H< .@A< .@6< .DE< .DA< .IK 5/%3?3 ="11?%'3 H6< .E.^F< ..D< .HI >C=-% .F^.D< .I< @6< AA< AD^H< .AH< .AK< @E@ >C'*'$ ...< .DH^I< .H6< .KH >,G3';% H< @D< A@^A< HI^K6< .E.< .K6 +?#=;'-=3 D.< I.< IK ;=$0%;=$'-=3 D.< I.< IF< IH =#+ ;"*=3'$? K.^@ >,G*%C$'"# .6E< .6@ >,C%*&%#&'G3% >,G&$*=$% IH< KF^6< ..I< .@E^.< .A6 >?;G"3 .@E^.< .A@< .66< .IE >?#$0%&'& ..< AD^F@< FD^6.< 66< 6H< I@< I6^H< K.< K6< .HD

>?&$%; @F< @H< A.< DE< .@A< .@D< .@K< .FE< .H@< .I6< .KE /=&$% .^@< D^H< @D< @I< A.< AA^F< 6A^F< 6H< D.^@< DF< DH< DK< H.^@< HD< HI< ...^.I< .@E^.< .HI^K< .I@^A< .IH^I +'=3%-$'- "4 ..6^@@ %(C"&'$'"# "4 DE^HH /%-0#'-=3f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

10.1057/9780230287600 - Kant and the Ends of Aesthetics, Gary Banham

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L%=&"# _="%20V` .DA< .H@^A< .H6< .I.< .I6^D< .II< .KE< .K6 L%43%-$'M% 9,+:;%#$ 3// 9,+:;%#$ L%:,3=$'M% 8*'#-'C3%& .@D^H< .FI< .6E^@< @E@ F/(')'"% .'29'% 29/ U'1'23 "@ F/*3"% +("%/ 6< K< .KD^I< @E.