Inside the Latin@ Experience
This page intentionally left blank
Inside the Latin@ Experience A Latin@ Studies Reade...
46 downloads
1606 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Inside the Latin@ Experience
This page intentionally left blank
Inside the Latin@ Experience A Latin@ Studies Reader Edited by Norma E. Cantú and María E. Fránquiz
inside the latin@ experience Copyright © Norma E. Cantú and María E. Fránquiz, 2010. All rights reserved. First published in 2010 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN® in the United States – a division of St. Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Where this book is distributed in the UK, Europe and the rest of the world, this is by Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN: 978–0–230–62178–7 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available from the Library of Congress. A catalogue record of the book is available from the British Library. Design by MPS Limited, A Macmillan Company First edition: May 2010 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
A toda nuestra gente with love
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
List of Figures
ix
List of Tables
x
Acknowledgments
xiii
Introduction María E. Fránquiz
xv
Part I Historical Roots and Contemporary Realities 1
2
3 4
Changing the National Ethos or Just Being American? Latin@ Political Participation Sylvia Manzano and Arturo Vega State-Federal Relations Concerning Latin@ Civil Rights in the United States Norma V. Cantú Latin@s in the U.S. Military Jorge Mariscal The “Swirl” Migration of Mexican-Origin Students: A Cross-Border Analysis Using the Mexican and U.S. Censuses Stella M. Flores and Germán Treviño
3
23 37
51
Part II Popular and Traditional Cultural Expressions 5
6
7
Making, Buying, Selling, and Using the Umbrella: Recognizing the Nuances of Latin@ Popular Culture Patricia Marina Trujillo Traveling on the Biliteracy Highway: Educators Paving a Road toward Conocimiento María E. Fránquiz Traditional Cultural Expressions: An Analysis of the Secular and Religious Folkways of Latin@s in the United States Norma E. Cantú
75
93
111
viii
8
CONTENTS
Language and Identity of Immigrant Central American Pentecostal Youth in Southern California Lucila D. Ek
129
Part III Performance Arts and Literature 9
Staging the Self, Staging Empowerment: An Overview of Latina Theater and Performance Rita E. Urquijo-Ruiz 10 Literary Currency: Coined Contributions of Latin@ Literature in the United States Gabriella Gutiérrez y Muhs 11 Politics of Aesthetics: Mariachi Music in the United States Russell C. Rodríguez 12 From Boricua Dancers to Salsa Soldiers: The Cultural Politics of Globalized Salsa Dancing in Chicago Frances R. Aparicio
151
173 193
211
Epilogue: A Final Look at the Latin@ Experience: Past, Present, and Future Norma E. Cantú
227
Bibliography
235
List of Contributors
253
Index
259
List of Figures
1.1
Difference in volunteerism by race/ethnicity, GSS 1996, overall volunteer mean: 1.293
12
Mexican states with the highest percentage of households with a member migrating to the United States, 1995–2000
55
Mexican states with the highest percentage of children aged six to fifteen migrating to the United States, 1995 and 2000
56
4.3
School-age migrants by the size of locality of origin
57
4.4
Migration of school-age children to the United States, by month
58
Total Mexican-born migrant population in the United States, 2000
59
States with the highest number of Mexican-born residents not in the United States in 1995
60
States with the highest percentage of Mexican-born children under eighteen years of age, 2000
61
States with the highest percentage of noncitizen Mexican-born children under eighteen years of age, 2000
62
4.9
School-age “swirl” migrants’ return to Mexico, by year
66
4.10
Return of school-age children to Mexico, by month
67
7.1
Circles of experience and of influence
4.1 4.2
4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8
117
List of Tables
1.1
Frequency distribution of volunteerism, 1996 GSS
10
1.2
Volunteerism, ethnicity, and SES-GSS 1996
12
1.3
Predicting civic participation: Ethnicity and SES, GSS 1996
12
Latino political participation: Volunteering and political activities
13
New Mexican-origin migration states, 2000
63
4.1b Traditional Mexican-origin migration states, 2000
64
1.4 4.1a
4.2 5.1
Point of origin and destiny of migrant populations by size of locality
67
List of subject fields from the Encyclopedia of Latino Popular Culture’s “Entries by Subject”
82
Yo soy la sangre del indio soy latino soy mestizo, somos de todos colores y de todos los oficios y si contamos los siglos aunque le duela al vecino somos más americanos (“Somos más Americanos,” Los Tigres del norte)
This page intentionally left blank
Acknowledgments
Primeramente, gracias to all who supported us in this endeavor: a Roberto Con Davis who first approached me with the idea of such a collection of essays; that project was not to be, but we found a home for it at Palgrave. To my coeditor, mi querida amiga, María Fránquiz, and all the contributors whose presence and work enrich my life and my scholarship, mil gracias! Thank you to the University of Texas at San Antonio whose support provided the superb research assistance of, first, Cordelia Barrera, and, in the final stages, of Magda García and Christina Gutiérrez, and to my niece Vanessa Cantú for her help one particularly busy week. To the contributors for not giving up on the project and to the various readers along the way—they are too many to list, but they know who they are—we thank you for the insight and recommendations. To the copyeditors and staff at Palgrave, especially to Julia and Samantha, mil gracias. Finally, al universo, as always, gracias! Norma E. Cantú
Este libro me llena de felicidad—it is truly a labor of love precisely because it represents the sweetness and beauty of insiders’ perspectives, not all of whom are authors in this book. En primer lugar I extend my thanks to Tony and Dora Fabelo, who made it possible for Norma and I to discuss the book en mi querido Puerto Rico. For three summers we met in the house where Tony was raised in Santurce to discuss revisions of chapters and the reorganization of ideas. With us in these summer writing retreats were Cinthia Salinas and Elvia Niebla, who nurtured our spirits as we kneaded and twisted and shaped the pandulce creations of the other twelve chefs that helped us bake this wonderful feast of insider conocimiento. Mil gracias Tony, Dora, Cinthia, and Elvia for your generosity, patience, and encouragement as this project expanded to life. María E. Fránquiz
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction
María E. Fránquiz
Inside the Latin@ Experience: A Latin@ Studies Reader1 was compiled while contrasting events were impacting the lives of Latin@s in the United States and beyond. First was the fact that a 1,952-mile fence was being built along the U.S.-Mexico border in an effort to constrain or eliminate undocumented immigration through Mexico into the United States. This fence impacts the millions of adults and children living in the shadows of the fourteen-foot-high steel wall and the conscience of all Americans—in the United States and elsewhere in the Americas—including but not limited to educators, lawyers, political and social scientists, military professionals, artists, and researchers. As editors of this project, Norma and I invite you to come up with more humane ideas toward a dignified and nonviolent solution to social challenges such as the mobility of humans, precisely because the contemporary social and political reality of Latin@s in the United States owes much to the transnational movements of people back and forth between the United States and Latin America, Central America, and the Caribbean. In stark contrast to the concerns of border protection and undocumented immigration during the first decade of the twenty-first century are other noteworthy national events that reflect positive views about what persons of color can and do contribute to mainstream life in the United States, the Americas, and the world. In January 2009, Barack Hussein Obama was sworn in as the first African-American president of the United States. The month before taking office he nominated Hilda L. Solis to serve as the Secretary of Labor. Given the recognition that she had earned in promoting the rights of workers and justice for the environment during her tenure as a House representative for the 32nd Congressional District in California, Solis was confirmed in February 2009 as the first Latina
xvi
INTRODUCTION
secretary of labor in U.S. history. Then, in July 2009 President Obama nominated Judge Sonia Sotomayor to replace Justice David Souter in the highest court of the land, the Supreme Court. Her broad legal experience as a New York assistant district attorney, an international corporate litigator, trial judge in the U.S. District Court, and appellate judge in the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, proved that she was supremely qualified. Thus, she was the first among Latin@s to be nominated to and confirmed in this capacity—a historic landmark. To have Hilda Solis, a MexicanAmerican from a working class background—both her mother and father were blue-collar union members—as the Secretary of Labor and to have Judge Sonia Sotomayor, a Puerto Rican who grew up in a public housing project in the South Bronx, with appointments at the highest levels of U.S. government marks achievements with remarkable potential for the recognition of other valuable resources within Latin@ communities. From an interdisciplinary perspective, Inside the Latin@ Experience: A Latin@ Studies Reader specifically explores the varied and unique Latinidades, or Latin@ cultural identities, that reside in the United States. Each author in the anthology is an insider of the Latin@ community, and together the authors deploy various theoretical tools to present the condition of Latin@s living in the United States. Its appeal lies in the inclusion of essays that cross several disciplines, and it thus postulates a view of Latin@s in the United States that is different from the merely social science or literary or popular culture arenas. The underlying vision for Inside the Latin@ Experience was grounded in the fact that the U.S. Latin@ population is the fastest growing group and that it will soon become the largest ethnic minority in the country; therefore, a collection of essays that seeks to render the lived reality of this population seemed critical for a better understanding by both insiders and outsiders of Latin@ communities. Inside the Latin@ Experience is organized into three parts with each part containing four chapters. The first part presents the historical roots and contemporary realities of Latin@ communities. This part identifies salient historical trends that have impacted the relations of Latin@s with each other and with other groups in the United States. The second part focuses on popular and traditional cultural expressions as found in schools, churches, and the wider Latin@ communities. One challenge of this section is the monolithic idea of a pan-Latin@ identity that sells in the marketplace but is typically not helpful in the identity formation of insiders represented by the term Latin@ (for example, Salvadorian, Puerto Rican, Mexican-American, Panamanian, Argentinean, etcetera). The final chapters provide perspectives on the performance arts and literary productions of Latin@s, including theater, music, and dance.
INTRODUCTION
xvii
As a brief introduction to the contributions made in each of the three sections the following paragraphs offer an outline of a wide panoramic view of the Latin@ condition as presented by the authors in this reader. The authors who come from various disciplines and theoretical perspectives use specific methodologies, including empirical, ethnographic, linguistic, literary, and textual analyses, along with cultural studies and other appropriate approaches. This diversity is seen in the contributions from various disciplines and the distinct perspective each contributes to the research and study of the Latin@ community. In the following sections a summary of the content of each part and the essence of each chapter is captured in an effort to provide you, our reader, with a guide, of the book’s contents. Historical Roots and Contemporary Realities In the first part, Historical Roots and Contemporary Realities, the authors present demographic data, including transnational migration patterns, as well as the history of how Latin@s promoted their own civil rights in the United States. Important economic avenues for immigrant and working class Latin@s, such as their participation in military service and their political attitudes and perceptions, are examined. Large databases such as the Pew Hispanic Center / Kaiser Family Foundation 2002 National Survey of Latinos and the U.S. Decennial Census of 2000 are used to evaluate residence patterns, attitudes toward immigration, and views on the role of government, among others. These chapters use the disciplinary tools of political science, law, and sociology to present compelling information needed for considering directions for a new decade and era. Chapter 1 of Part I by Sylvia Manzano and Arturo Vega discusses the influences of U.S. Latin@ civic participation. Manzano and Vega employ the 1996 General Social Survey (GSS) and the Pew Hispanic Center / Kaiser Family Foundation 2004 National Survey of Latinos to examine the relationship between socioeconomic variables and civic participation across ethnic groups. They consider the influence of Latin@ participation, specifically volunteerism and political activity. They demonstrate that Latin@s vary along dimensions of political and economic incorporation, but this fact is no indication of “American-ness”; rather the distribution of resources within a highly diverse ethnic community explains participatory patterns. As a civil rights lawyer, Norma E. Cantú continues the discussion begun in Chapter 1 regarding Latin@ political participation in local and national affairs. In her chapter, “State-Federal Relations Concerning Latino Civil Rights in the United States,” she provides a historical overview of ways Latin@s in the United States promoted their civil rights. Remarkably,
xviii
INTRODUCTION
Latin@s did not bring federal court cases to the U. S. Supreme Court until the second half of the twentieth century. The author includes a report of the resistance by states to federal intrusion into states’ rights as well as an enlightened overview of the pervasive tension between the federal and state governments. The author’s own position as a lawyer and an educator is woven into her analysis of the effects of the No Child Left Behind legislation in the field of education. The interaction of federal and state laws in the United States is highly relevant to members of “minority groups” who are caught between inconsistent governmental practices and interpretations of civil rights laws. An important component of any nation is the participation of its citizenry in the protection and maintenance of its national borders and worldviews. In Chapter 3, Jorge Mariscal presents his research in his chapter, “Latin@s in the U.S. Military.” He examines how Latin@ military service, sustained by a constant flow of new immigrants and relatively limited career opportunities for the native-born working class of color, has historically been the primary vehicle for assimilation, access to the full rights of citizenship, and the construction of “American” identities premised on traditional patriotism. He argues that Latin@s and other working class bodies—like the inexpensive Latin@ labor that continues to be used for building the national economy—have provided the raw material for U.S. military conflicts for over a century and a half. Noteworthy in this chapter is the fact that among all ethnic groups in the United States, Latin@s have won forty-one Congressional Medals of Honor, more than any other group, and to date thousands of new immigrants continue to believe that the “American Dream” can only be achieved through military service. Part I concludes with a binational focus on cross-border flows of immigrants. Stella M. Flores and German Treviño indicate that surges in Latin American migration to the United States since the 1990s have led to an impressive increase in immigration research. In their study they specifically analyzed migration patterns between Mexico and the United States using the 2000 National Census questionnaire for each country: the XII General Census of Household and Population 2000 of Mexico and the U.S. Decennial Census. They evaluate migration patterns to, from, and in some cases back to the original residence area before migration of Mexican-origin individuals. Their study is particularly original in that it offers a cross-national analysis of migration patterns between these two countries for adults and school-age children. Additionally, they employ Geographic Information System (GIS) mapping to visually explore migration patterns of the states most likely to send, receive, and reincorporate Mexican-origin migrant populations in Mexico and the United States.
INTRODUCTION
xix
Popular and Traditional Cultural Expressions in School, Church, and Community The second part of the reader, “Popular and Traditional Cultural Expressions in School, Church, and Community,” looks at various forms of Latin@ culture, including the traditional arts as well as the fine and popular arts, and the ways these are enacted in school, church, and community. Highlighting the stellar contributions of educators, scholars in cultural studies, and sociolinguists, this section also foregrounds how traditional artists have been a mainstay and a resource for many popular arts. While one chapter uses a highway metaphor to explain the influence of Latin@ children’s literature on knowledge production among young Spanish speakers, another chapter highlights the heterogeneity of Latin@ communities in terms of socialization into language, culture, and religion. The first chapter in this section of the reader is titled “Making, Buying, Selling, and Using the Umbrella: Recognizing the Nuances of Latin@ Popular Culture.” The author Patricia Trujillo argues that multiple negotiations can be made when encountering and interpreting cultural symbols in the mass market and media. In considering Latin@ popular art and culture, she asks the following questions: Who is creating it? What images and symbols are being employed? How are they interpreted? By whom are they interpreted and for whom? She considers these questions important for a society that is becoming increasingly Latin@ and for a hegemonic popular culture that is increasingly influenced by these Latin@ communities. This growing phenomenon mandates that Latin@ art and culture be taken seriously as an economic and political influence that is able to inform and change what it means to be “American.” Accordingly, this essay provides a prefatory understanding of the various nuances of Latin@ popular and pop culture and serves as an introduction to a vast discourse. The essay also works to map out discursive signposts in the field but in no way claims to identify them all. Rather, in considering the ever changing nature of popular culture, this essay can be considered an entrance into a complicated, multifaceted, and dynamic field of study. Chapter 6, “Traveling on the Biliteracy Highway: Educators Paving a Road toward Conocimiento,” presents an argument for understanding the factors that support or constrain the development of Latin@ students’ biliteracy skills in U.S. classrooms. Data is presented on the ways in which teachers have created spaces for bilingual students to learn language, expand disciplinary knowledge, and experience powerful writing in their heritage or second language. Specifically, these teachers utilized two bilingual children’s books—Friends from the Other Side/Amigos del otro lado (Anzaldúa, 1993) and Prietita and the Ghost Woman/Prietita y
xx
INTRODUCTION
la llorona (Anzaldúa, 1995)—to show how conocimiento (reflective consciousness) about the topic of immigration can be achieved in elementary bilingual classrooms. Fránquiz argues that examining Latin@ children’s development of biliteracy and conocimiento in U.S. schools is significant because these skills augment intellectual possibilities, provide access to a broader range of social and cultural resources, and encourage teachers and children to place value on funds of knowledge from Latin@ homes and communities. She points out that the issue of immigration continues to be as critical today as when Gloria Anzaldúa wrote about her child characters Prietita and Joaquin in 1993 and 1995. Norma E. Cantú in Chapter 7, “Traditional Cultural Expressions: An Analysis of the Secular and Religious Folkways of Latin@s in the United States,” writes about the contested area of the U.S.-Mexico border where a number of cultural expressions still exist that reflect the mestizaje of cultures that coexist in this geopolitical space. This chapter explores how religious and secular cultural expressions, such as the coming-of-age ritual of the quinceañera and the veneration of religious icons and holy sites, have functioned as forms of contestation and resistance to the onslaught of U.S. hegemonic culture. The rituals are also hybrid expressions of cultural threads that show Christian and indigenous influences. Drawing from the particular site of the border, the author launches an analysis of the cultural expressions of the various groups and argues that groups that celebrate with parades and processions as well as with in-family or in-group rituals survive because the very act of celebrating assures survival. Another site for cultural expression is the church. In Chapter 8, Lucila Ek uses theories of language and identity to examine the language uses, attitudes, and experiences of Central American Pentecostal youth in California. These youth are linguistically and culturally doubly subordinated, first by the mainstream European-American culture and the English language and second by the Mexican-American population that comprises the largest Latin@ group in California. Findings of her study include the centrality of the voseo2 in the construction and maintenance of a Central American linguistic and cultural identity, the Mexicanization or Chicanoization of Central Americans in Southern California, and the erasure of national identity in the church context. The author draws from a multiyear ethnography conducted in Southern California to highlight the heterogeneity of Latin@ communities in terms of language, culture, and religion. Performance Arts and Literature The chapters in Part III, Performance Arts and Literature, provide descriptive overviews of Latin@ contributions to theater, literature, the mariachi
INTRODUCTION
xxi
musical form, and salsa dance. The role of the performance arts in Latin@ identity constructions and the predominant themes particular to different Latin@ ethnicities (for example, Puerto Rican, Cuban-American, Mexicano, etcetera) during the twentieth century and the first decade of the twenty-first century are closely examined with lenses from literary and/or cultural studies. Interestingly, the four authors whose work comprises this section are scholars who work more or less across the four directions of the United States—Urquijo-Ruiz from the South (Texas), Gutierrez y Muhs from the North (Washington), Rodriguez from the West (California), and Aparicio from the East (Illinois). Given that indigenous education is grounded in respect for the laws represented in the four directions as the building blocks of creation, it is fitting to conclude the chapters in this reader with four perspectives on Latin@ creative performance. In “Staging the Self, Staging Empowerment: An Overview of Latina Theater and Performance,” Rita E. Urquijo-Ruiz begins with a brief overview starting in the twentieth century and offers an example of an early type of performance. She then proceeds to focus primarily on the works created since 1980, briefly analyzing three Latina plays. The author focuses on the issues of self-representation and empowerment and at the same time attempts to contest the stereotypical and racist depictions that were historically created. Latina dramatic artists have chosen to voice their own concerns regarding issues of identity formation as subjects who constantly inhabit a liminal cultural space where multiple aspects of their cultures (mainstream and marginal) overlap. Furthermore, their contestation also addresses issues of gender and sexual discrimination from within their own ethnic groups, especially starting in the late 1970s when the first wave of Latina feminism produced empowering literary works that were later transformed and transferred to the stage. The chapter shows how Latina playwrights, in confronting the issues mentioned, insist on making their voices heard and on letting their “wild tongues” tell their own stories. With an emphasis on literature, Gabriella Gutiérrez y Muhs provides a chapter that gives a glimpse of the predominant themes particular to each Latin@ ethnicity explored by more prolific writers in recent U.S. Latin@ literature. Organizing her chapter thematically and ethnically, the author examines the works of poets, novelists, and creative nonfiction writers that have all had a significant impact on U.S. Latin@ literature. The key themes in her analysis of literature continue to be identity, gender, inequality, racism, the importance and centrality of the Latino family, and the inscription of physical Latin@ representations of subjectivity, spirituality, and agency, as well as language. She cites exile as a theme that recurs continuously in Cuban-American literature. In Puerto Rican literature the themes of independence, territory, and nationalism, as well as invasions in all
xxii
INTRODUCTION
metaphorical senses are central and well recognized. For non-U.S.-born Latin@s, issues of the reformulation of identity and in particular the fluctuations of social class are essential, adding many dialectical shifting side ladders to the bridge of immigration. For Chican@s in contemporary literature, spirituality, migration, sexuality, social consciousness, and death themes are the most prevalent. For both Chican@s and Puerto Ricans, the geographic attack on bilingualism is central. In the penultimate chapter, “The Politics of Aesthetics” by Russell C. Rodríguez, a brief description of the mariachi musical ensemble of Mexico and two case studies exhibiting the diffusion of meaning and representation around the mariachi musical form are presented. Through ethnographic research the author describes the developments and transformations this musical form has endured due to its presence in new public spaces and the participation of new practitioners who diverge from the Mexicano working-class masculinity that signifies the “traditional” mariachi musician. As a result of these shifts the central argument is that mariachi music has become a terrain of new understandings of aesthetics in which new repertoire, practice, and authority emerge, which are in turn affirmed, appropriated, and challenged. The concept of the “politics of aesthetics” is proposed to examine the intersection of race, gender, class, and culture, as integrated in an understanding of practice, performance, and aesthetics to clarify the dynamic of the developing mariachi space. The final chapter moves from mariachi music to salsa music and dance. In “From Boricua Dancers to Salsa Soldiers: The Cultural Politics of Salsa Dancing in Chicago,” Frances Aparicio argues that despite the dominant discourses that the dancing industry and some scholars have used for promoting salsa dancing as a vehicle for intercultural understanding and racial harmony, social and popular dancing in the global city produces complex moments of intercultural conflicts and gender power dynamics that reveal the ongoing, colonialist anxieties over racial minorities in the United States. Through participant observation, the author explores the processes through which the globalization of salsa dancing has had a negative impact on the relationship that Puerto Rican women have had with salsa music and dancing as central forms of identity reaffirmation. Aparicio posits that the sense of displacement reflects the gradual ways in which the shift of dancers from Boricua individuals to what one woman she interviewed referred to as “salsa soldiers” has displaced previous Puerto Rican dancers from dancing venues and clubs in Chicago. The twelve chapters that comprise Inside the Latin@ Experience: A Latin@ Studies Reader are followed by an epilogue where Norma E. Cantú presents ideas for future directions and possibilities for Latin@s in the United States. Taking into account the interconnectedness of trade,
INTRODUCTION
xxiii
natural resources, health and scientific knowledge, technological advances, and diverse expressions of cultural traditions, the authors of this project propose ways for (re)considering the stronger integration of Latin@ insider perspectives in all the pathways that will provide a safe and caring world for the generations to come. Notes 1. Latin@ is the term used by Latcrit (Latino critical race) theorists in the United States to identify persons of Spanish-speaking descent who designate themselves as being of Mexican-American, Chicano, Puerto Rican, Cuban, or other Hispanic origin (Franciso Valdés, “Under Construction—LatCrit Consciousness, Community, and Theory,” California Law Review 85 (1997): 1087–1142). We use the term Latin@ in this reader to acknowledge this wide intragroup diversity. 2. In Spanish grammar, voseo is the use of the second person singular pronoun vos instead of tú.
This page intentionally left blank
Part I
Historical Roots and Contemporary Realities
This page intentionally left blank
1
Changing the National Ethos or Just Being American? Latin@ Political Participation Sylvia Manzano and Arturo Vega
Introduction re U.S. Latin@ political participants really changing the national ethos or simply behaving in typical American fashion? In Who Are We: The Challenges to America’s National Identity, Samuel Huntington argues that U.S. Latin@s threaten the ethos of the nation due to an inability to assimilate or due to their resistance against assimilation into American life.1 However, there is substantial evidence to the contrary, indicating that Latin@ immigrants do indeed adopt many of the core cultural dimensions of American life.2 Civic participation and political engagement constitute one visible and measurable norm in American society. The decline in overall American civic engagement over the past half century is well documented.3 Yet during this same period, there is evidence that Latin@ participation in electoral politics has increased.4 This paper examines the political and civic assimilation of U.S. Latin@s using the Pew Hispanic Center’s 2004 National Survey of Latinos: Politics and Civic Participation. If Huntington is right, we should find uniform levels of nonparticipation across a broad spectrum of Latin@s. We challenge Huntington’s assertions and expect to find significant variation in political participation among Latino subgroups. Demographic and socioeconomic variables, particularly national origin, language, nativity, generational cohort, education, and income level should explain the variation in Latin@ political participation.
A
4
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
Latin@ Civic Participation: Same Variables, Some Similar and Some Different Results Several strands of literature typify examinations of political behavior—the traditional socioeconomic status models (education and income); individual, community, and institutional characteristics (race/ethnicity; election types and designs; partisan versus nonpartisan, local, state-wide versus national among election types); and assimilation and acculturation (nativity, language, socialization). Cutting to the chase—the weakness of this literature is its application to the diversity of U.S. Latin@s and nonelectoral political activity within this population. The most enduring consistencies in the political behavior literature are the linear relationships between socioeconomic and political participation. Higher levels of education and income are associated with the likeliness to vote and participate. But how does this model perform when applied to the civic engagement of U.S. Latin@s? For example, it is well recognized that U.S. Latin@s are not normally distributed among the typically used socioeconomic status measures. Broad sectors of the Latin@ population are below the mean income and education levels and statistically different from their white counterparts. And, while there is no shortage of literature describing the depressed rates of political engagement among Latin@s, there is an emerging literature that finds Latin@s low on the socioeconomic status (SES) scale actively engaged in politics and community.5 To develop more sophisticated explanations for Latin@ political behavior, researchers have tested models that incorporate more demographic and contextual variables to predict participation in various activities.6 Here, a number of individual, community, and institutional factors are typically examined as explanations for why Latin@s are less apt than whites to participate in both electoral and nonelectoral politics.7 Political and social trust, for example, are also often cited relative to both acculturation and civic engagement. Unfortunately, the relationship between political and social trust and acculturation and engagement are not always clear. What comes first? Trust, then acculturation and engagement or the other way around? Several surveys, for example, have found that U.S. Latin@s differ from their ethnic and racial counterparts relative to levels of political trust. The 1980s Latino National Political Survey (LNPS), for example, found that Latin@s overall expressed slightly more political trust in the government officials to do what is right than non-Latin@ whites did. At the time of the survey, 40 percent of Mexican-origin survey respondents indicated that they trusted government officials—“just about always” (7.5 percent) or “most of the time” (32.7 percent). In contrast, 35 percent of the Anglo respondents expressed a similar level of trust—1.4 percent
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
5
“just about always” and 33.7 percent “most of the time”. Notably, among the two other Latino groups surveyed, Cuban-Americans expressed the highest levels of political trust (48.6 percent) while Puerto Ricans were similar to respondents of Mexican origin.8 Since the LNPS, however, Latin@s are becoming less politically trustful. When asked about their level of political trust in the Pew 2002 survey, for example, a majority (51.5 percent) of the Latin@ respondents indicated that they never or only sometimes trusted the government in Washington to do what is right.9 In examining these data, Vega reports that “less than a third (29.5 percent) trusted the government most of the time and less than one in seven (14.1 percent) trusted the government always.”10 Moreover, Chávez and Fraga found that Latin@s have the lowest levels of social or generalized trust compared to African-Americans and whites.11 In the category “people can be trusted,” Latin@s rated the lowest (23 percent agreement); concerning “you can’t be too careful,” a measure of distrust, Latin@s rank the highest (68 percent agreement). And, what are its effects? One study, for example, concludes that acculturation corrodes political trust—“The more acculturated and thus assimilated Latinos become, accordingly, the more ‘American’ they become in their cynicism.”12 If this is the case, then “assimilated” Latin@s may exhibit “normal” (low) levels of civic participation, which, of course, says nothing about the independent effects of low levels of social trust. Michelson hints at important characteristics within the U.S. Latin@ population that influence participation. Others have found similar results, suggesting that it may be valid to say that there are differences in behavior. Segura and colleagues, for example, also found that being naturalized rather than native-born is associated with lower levels of political and social engagement.13 In a separate study Garcia and Arce also found that differences in organizational involvement for Latin@ joiners and nonjoiners rested on socioeconomic status and longer exposure to U.S. society.14 They added that the political integration of Latin@s was both uneven and diverse. On another level, still, using measures of commitment to community involvement and problem solving, Segura and colleagues found that support for the view “that individuals should help the community” was high among four Latino communities surveyed (97), suggesting an important contextual norm that could be associated with nonelectoral civic participation and engagement.15 Similarly research on the effects of the political efficacy of racial/ethnic members relative to their white counterparts in civic engagement is mixed. Emig, Hesse, and Fisher, in their study of Mobile, Alabama, for example, found that African-Americans exhibited more trust, efficaciousness, and involvement in the community than whites.16 Bobo and Gilliam suggest that in communities with greater and sustained political empowerment
6
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
(or incorporation), African-Americans have shown higher levels of political trust, efficacy, and participation than their counterparts in communities with less political empowerment.17 Shingles proposes that black consciousness (the awareness of a shared and historically oppressed status as a racial group) was linked to increased political efficacy and participation relative to whites and also to high levels of mistrust of government.18 Finally, Portney and Berry found that “black neighborhoods of all economic stripes demonstrate relatively high levels of political participation in neighborhood associations.”19 The Pew 2004 Latino National Survey also indicates that U.S. Latin@s exhibit mixed levels of efficacy. When asked to agree or disagree with the statement, “political leaders do not care much what people like me think,” 54 percent of the respondents either strongly agreed or agreed. In contrast, when asked to agree or disagree with the statement, “In the United States, citizens can have an influence at all levels of government, from top to bottom, by voting and engaging in other political activities,” 77.5 percent either strongly agreed or agreed. When applied to U.S. Latin@s, foreignborn Latin@s exhibit a stronger sense of political efficacy and trust government less.20 Given its typical use (high efficacy impacts civic engagement) and its mixed results when applied comparatively to racial/ethnic groups and, certainly, the mixed levels of efficacy for Latin@s, we wonder how political efficacy impacts civic participation for Latin@s relative to traditional socioeconomic and individual characteristic (subgroup identity, sex, education, etc.) models. A third strand of the literature on political participation includes separate considerations of assimilation and acculturation. Gordon defined cultural assimilation as acculturation.21 Here, new immigrants “absorb” the cultural behavior patterns (norms, values, and lifestyles) of the “host” country.22 The other side of acculturation is primary assimilation or “the subjectively felt or psychological identification with the majority.”23 Fuchs adds that according to the ideal behind the “acculturative power of American society,” differences between ethnic and racial groups and identities are gradually eliminated.24 Michelson, citing Parks, also adds that the speed of assimilation depends on the immigrant’s race, religion, and language; “the closer a group is to English-speaking Protestants, the more quickly assimilation can happen.”25 Interestingly, the literature on assimilation, acculturation, and political integration has traditionally taken a one-dimensional perspective. Racial and ethnic minorities “become” or “adopt” the norms and attitudes of the larger group. Few analyses, however, consider the reciprocal effects of racial and ethnic minorities and emerging immigrant communities’ cultures and practices within larger communities. These reciprocal effects
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
7
indeed seem to be driving the extended conversations over the direction of the ethos of the nation, for example. Measures of nativity and English language proficiency can be indicators of acculturation. Both factors mitigate socialization into American society. These two variables significantly influence socioeconomic outcomes and other variables associated with participation.26 Educational and economic opportunities, for example, are inextricably linked to language ability and nativity. Additionally, it is not the number of years in school that increases the propensity to vote, but rather the socialization that takes place within educational institutions that increases political participation. Many immigrants are not schooled in the United States. Frequently, those who do enroll in American public schools are tracked into academic programs that are distinct from the average student population. Similarly, the number of years of experience with American social and political norms, not age per se, has a positive influence on voting.27 Immigrant and U.S.-born Latin@s may have different information, interpretations, and experiences with American politics and its associated concepts, including ideological frameworks, parties, candidates, norms, rules, and processes. Nativity and language place additional direct and indirect participation costs on a significant proportion of the Latin@ population. Before they can even cast a ballot, immigrants must absorb the information costs of a new political environment in addition to the high costs associated with becoming a naturalized U.S. citizen. These obstacles are exacerbated for those with poor English skills. For Latin@s language ability is a clear line of demarcation with respect to acculturation, political participation, and social mobility.28 In short, language ability sets the social and formal parameters of interaction among Latino groups and across racial groups as well. As noted earlier, most foreign-born Latin@s’ primary language is Spanish, and they cluster on the low end of the socioeconomic spectrum. As one might expect, this group is also less likely to register or vote. In some instances though, low resources become a catalyst for political engagement aimed at redressing these circumstances.29 For example, in recent years foreign-born Latin@ voters in California have turned out to vote in larger numbers than expected. Ramakrishnan’s recent study of immigrant voter behavior by generational cohort confirms that age, education, income, marital status, and residential stability are all positively associated with Latin@ immigrant political participation.30 In terms of nonelectoral participation, it may be the case that Latin@s are better poised to participate in these activities due to institutional barriers coupled with low socioeconomic resources. Yet studies have found that Latin@ civic engagement lags behind that of other racial groups.31 However, DeSipio finds that nativity makes no difference in predicting civic engagement, which is quite low across the population.32
8
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
In terms of partisanship most Latin@ voters identify as Democrats. Voters of Cuban origin and the small proportion of voters who are of affluent Mexican and Puerto Rican origin tend to be more partial to Republicans.33 These trends are rather consistent. In early 1990, for example, the LNPS found that more than two-thirds of Mexican and Puerto Rican respondents identified as or leaned toward the Democrats and more than two-thirds of Cuban respondents identified or leaned toward Republicans. Anglo respondents were perhaps more evenly divided, with half identifying with the Democrats and 40 percent with Republicans.34 By 2002, U.S. Latin@s, in terms of partisan affiliation, identified principally as Independents (37.7 percent) and Democrats (35.2 percent). While one in nine (11.1 percent) did not provide an answer to the question, less than one in six (15.9 percent) Latin@ respondents identified as Republicans. Latinas were slightly more Democratic (37 versus 33.4 percent) and slightly less Republican than their male counterparts (14.5 versus 17.3 percent), while Latinos tended to identify more as Independents than Latinas (39.9 versus 35.5 percent). The differences by sex, however, were weakly associated.35 Montoya and colleagues found evidence that the factors influencing Latina and Latino voting are not the same.36 For Latinas, the most consistent predictors of turnout are an interest in politics, church attendance, and organizational and school involvement. Finally, we hasten to add that media explanations of the 2004 presidential election gave acculturation/assimilation explanations of Latin@ voting behavior. Russell (2005), for example, points to differences between secondand third-generation Latin@ voters.37 Campo-Flores and Fineman of Newsweek added nativity or country of origin to generational impacts.38 Clearly, rates of Latin@ political participation and partisan affiliation vary by identity, political trust, citizenship status, sex, generational cohort, and, seemingly, by context. Taken alone, one can begin to understand how comments like Huntington’s can be made. The literature, for example, correctly illustrates distinctions between immigrant and native-born Latin@s in voting behavior, attitudes, and preferences. What the literature lacks is a comprehensive application of traditional “explanatory” variables and models relative to the unique characteristics (nativity, heritage, citizenship/registration, generational cohort, and English proficiency) of U.S. Latin@s. Moreover, there is far less research on the relationship between nativity and nonelectoral political activity within the Latin@ population. There is some utility in examining more recent trends given the growth in immigrant population and national-origin diversity in the past fifteen years. Even though Latin@ voter turnout has increased in several elections, it is still the case that millions of adult Latin@s remain ineligible to participate in electoral politics. For this reason, we turn our attention to political and civic activities.
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
9
Latin@ Civic and Political Participation The first set of analyses is conducted to establish a benchmark in terms of the relationship between socioeconomic variables and civic participation across ethnic groups. We expect to find patterns consistent with the social science literature where increased income, education, and age have a positive impact on civic participation, specifically volunteerism in several activities. Controlling these socioeconomic variables, it is expected that Latin@ ethnic subgroup identities will not have a distinctive impact on participation in one direction or the other. The second set of analyses considers the influence of Latin@ demographics, political trust, efficacy, and socioeconomic variables on Latin@ participation, specifically volunteerism and political activity. Because immigrant status and language ability are strongly associated with socioeconomic status, we expect that generational cohort, years in the United States, English language ability, income, and education will have an effect on both types of participation. Data and Methods The 1996 General Social Survey (GSS) and the Pew Hispanic / Kaiser Family Foundation 2004 National Survey of Latinos: Politics and Civic Engagement are utilized to test the hypotheses.39 The 1996 GSS serves as a point of context and benchmark because it includes a racially diverse national sample of respondents. The data from the GSS allows for some rudimentary crossgroup comparisons and a test of the traditional socioeconomic status variables on civic participation. The Pew survey includes only Latin@s, permitting specific modeling of civic engagement for the group. Details related to all variables and coding are included in the Appendix. Baseline volunteerism The first test considers the influence of socioeconomic variables on overall participation and civic engagement. To measure civic participation in the first model, we use a series of volunteerism and civic engagement questions. The dependent variable is developed by adding a series of fourteen questions on the topic. The 1996 GSS asked respondents to examine a card with different areas in which people do volunteer work, then asked the respondents if they had “done some volunteer work in the past twelve months” in any of the areas listed.40 The list included the following volunteer activity areas: (1) health, (2) education, (3) religious, (4) human
10
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
Table 1.1
Frequency distribution of volunteerism, 1996 GSS
No. of activities 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
No. of participants
% of Total
606 306 168 104 53 37 24 14 4 4 3 2
45.7 23.1 12.7 7.8 4 2.8 1.8 1.1 0.3 0.3 0.2 0.2
Cronbach Alpha = 0.69.
services, (5) environment, (6) public or social benefit, (7) recreation, (8) arts, (9) work-related organizations, (10) political, (11) youth development, (12) private and community foundations, (13) international, and (14) informal, individual volunteer work. The scale measuring participation in these activities ranges from a minimum 0 to a maximum value of 11 as no respondents exceeded participation beyond the eleven activities illustrated in Table 1.1. The cronbach alpha coefficient of 0.69 indicates the solid validity of the constructed variable. The first test considers the impact of traditional socioeconomic variables on volunteerism. The independent variables in the first regression are sex, marital status, education, income, age, number of children in a household, and ethnicity. The focus of this model is to evaluate whether Latin@ political behavior emulates other American racial groups. Thus ethnicity was recoded as a dichotomous variable indicating Latin@ origin or non-Latin@ origin. The difference in means test (ANOVA) and ordinary least squared multiple regression are utilized. Latin@ political activity and volunteerism The Pew dataset is used to test the impact of socioeconomic variables and Latin@-specific demographic variables on participation. Two dependent variables are constructed to measure two aspects of civic participation: political engagement and volunteerism. The first dependent variable measures Latin@ political participation; it is an additive index of five politically oriented activities. They are: 1) contact an elected official, 2) contribute money to a candidate, 3) work for a candidate, 4) participate in a meeting
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
11
or demonstration, and 5) attend a political party function. The values on this variable range from 0 to 5, and a Cronbach alpha test produces a coefficient of 0.66, confirming these variables cluster together well. The second dependent variable measuring Latin@ volunteerism is also an additive scale. Included are four variables that measure different types of volunteer work. They are: 1) church or religious groups, 2) schools, 3) neighborhood, business, or community, and 4) ethnic group. The values for the volunteerism variable range from 0 to 4 and chronbach alpha coefficient of 0.60. The independent variables in the Latin@ participation models include measures for specific ethnic group demographics as well as socioeconomic indicators. The independent variables are: English proficiency, citizen and voter registration status, generational cohort, religion, sex, education, income, age, employment, years in the United States, political trust, political efficacy, marital status, heritage, and partisanship (see the Appendix for the list of variables). Again, the difference in means test (ANOVA) and least squares multiple regression are utilized. First, the findings from the baseline volunteerism model using the GSS 1996 data are reported, then the results from the Latin@ participationspecific models. Findings If political participation remains an issue of opportunity costs, there should be a positive association between participation and traditional socioeconomic measures. Increased income and education, for example, should have a positive impact on volunteerism. Americans averaged slightly over 1.3 volunteer activities, with 46 percent of respondents reporting no involvement in any of the listed activities. About one in four (23 percent) participate in one activity. On the whole, Americans are not involved in volunteer work; 69 percent participated in only one activity or none at all in 1996. However, are Latin@s different in their civic participation? Figure 1.1 graphically represents a difference in means test of the volunteerism scale created from the 1996 General Social Survey. Latin@s do volunteer for a slightly higher average number of activities (average 1.5 for Latinos, Table 1.2); however, the statistical difference across groups is insignificant. Thus Latin@s are no different in their overall depressed levels of volunteerism compared to Anglo, African-American, and Other groups. These findings suggest that in this arena of civic participation, Latin@s exhibit “typical American” levels of volunteerism. Table 1.3 reports the regression results with the GSS 1996 volunteerism scale against Latin@ as an independent variable and traditional
12
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
Figure 1.1 Difference in volunteerism by race/ethnicity, GSS 1996, overall volunteer mean: 1.293 Table 1.2
Volunteerism, ethnicity, and SES-GSS 1996
Group
No.
Mean activities (SD)
White African American Other Latino Native American Asian American
989 178 20 71 42 25
1.29 (1.74) 1.24 (1.82) 1.4 (1.39) 1.51 (2.06) 1.21 (1.91) 1.24 (1.94)
Table 1.3
Predicting civic participation: Ethnicity and SES, GSS 1996 B
Latino Sex Married Education Age Income Children
0.2 0.226 0.113 0.144 0.073 –0.008 0.053
Standardized B 0.025 0.062 0.031 0.229 0.098 –0.07 0.051
SE
t
0.231 0.104 0.112 0.019 0.024 0.003 0.035
0.866 2.161* 1.008 7.454** 3.099** –2.226* 1.526
R2 = 0.086 N = 1150. ** p = 0.01, * p = 0.05.
socioeconomic status variables. While the overall model performs poorly (multiple R2 = 0.09), the statistical significance and direction of the independent variables is illustrative. Here, the dichotomized Latin@ variable remains statistically insignificant, while educational attainment and income have the most influential and statistically significant effects. Sex and age
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
13
are also significant and in the expected direction, while marital status and the number of children in a household is insignificant. The results here show that Latin@ ethnicity itself does not depress volunteerism. To dissect and update Latin@ political participation, we turn to the 2004 Pew National Survey of Latinos. Table 1.4 reports the findings on four regression models. There are two tests for each of the two dependent variables: volunteerism and political activities. Models 1 and 3 include independent and control variables. Models 2 and 4 include identical independent variables with the addition of the other dependent variable of interest but as an independent variable. While moderately correlated (0.42), the dependent variables—volunteerism and political activities—contribute significantly to the previous models (1 and 3). It seems that Latin@s who are politically active are also active volunteers and vice versa. Models 1 and 2 demonstrate the effects of our measures of interest in explaining volunteerism among Latin@s. In Model 1, English ability, education, sex, Mexican heritage, trust, and employment status are all statistically significant. An outcome of interest is that citizenship/voter registration status and generational cohort, while in the predicted directions, are not significantly associated with Latin@ volunteerism. When the political activities Table 1.4
Latino political participation: Volunteering and political activities
Sex Education Income Citizen/Registered Age Employed Years in the United States Trust Efficacy Children Married Democrat English fluency Gen cohort Religion Mexican heritage Political acts Volunteerism (Constant) R2 (adjusted) **p = 0.01, *p = 0.05.
Model 1 volunteer
Model 2 volunteer
Model 3 political acts
Model 4 political acts
0.13** 0.16** 0.03 0.03 0.06 0.07* –0.04 0.13** 0.01 0.06 0.02 –0.05 0.20** 0.02 –0.06 0.14**
0.13** 0.13** –0.01 0.00 0.05 0.07* –0.06 0.12** –0.01 0.07* 0.01 –0.07* 0.17** –0.02 –0.07* 0.10** 0.33**
0.01 0.08* 0.10** 0.06 0.01 0.02 0.05 0.03 0.06 –0.05 0.03 0.05 0.14** 0.01 0.03 0.11**
–0.03 0.04 0.10** 0.06 –0.01 –0.02 0.08 –0.01 0.06 –0.05 0.01 0.07* 0.05 0.01 0.06* 0.05
0.19 0.23
–0.46* 0.09
0.34** –0.27 0.21
0.14
14
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
variable is added as an independent variable (Model 2), it overshadows the statistically significant variables of English ability, education, sex, Mexican heritage, trust, and employment status. In addition, with this respecification, the presence of children in the household, Democratic partisanship, and Catholic religious affiliation are also statistically significant, with Democrats and Catholic Latin@s having negative influences. Regression models 3 and 4 produce coefficients for the political activities dependent variable. Model 3, without volunteerism as an independent variable, performs poorly (R2 = 0.09). Here, English ability had the largest effect (0.14), followed by income, Mexican heritage, and education. With all else being equal, as English proficiency, income, and education increase, and we move from non-Mexican-heritage to Mexican-heritage Latin@s, participation in political activities increases. When volunteerism is added as an independent variable in Model 4, the equation performs substantially better (R2 = 0.21). Here volunteerism had the strongest effects (0.34). Income remains statistically significant but English proficiency, Mexican heritage, and education are not. Partisanship and religious identity are also significant predictors. Education, sex, citizenship/registration status, political trust and age, years in the United States, number of children, and generational cohort were not statistically significant. The effect of generational cohort, political trust, efficacy, years in the United States, and citizenship/registration status are of particular interest, given previous statements concerning assimilation and civic participation. For Latin@s, the rate of volunteerism and political activism are linked and are important correlates of civic participation and, ultimately, of social incorporation. Discussion/Conclusion Our findings point to somewhat different dynamics at work for Latin@ volunteerism and political activities. On the one hand, these findings are somewhat consistent with previous work that finds language, education, and income as important variables in predicting Latin@ electoral participation. English proficiency and education, for example, had consistent and positive influences in three of the four models of volunteerism and political activities. Income was only influential in the political activities models—an important albeit subtle point that differs from the traditional models of civic participation. In combination, these variables are indicators of social, economic, and political incorporation for Latin@s, whether U.S. or foreign-born. On the other hand, Latin@s of Mexican heritage were also significantly different from other Latin@s with respect to our civic engagement measures. The consistent and positive performance of this variable in three of the four models points to an important difference in Latin@ civic engagement
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
15
between Mexican-heritage and non-Mexican-heritage Latinos. Broad strokes of the painter’s brush (à la Huntington) fail to capture this important difference. Still, our measures of generational cohort, years in the United States, age, citizenship/registration status, efficacy, and marital status—other measures of incorporation—had no impact on civic engagement for Latin@s. Interestingly, for Latin@s, level of political trust is a positive influence on volunteerism but insignificant to nonelectoral political participation. Being a Democrat and a Catholic also inhibit the level of volunteerism, but are positive attributes for the level of political activities when the level of volunteerism is included. The fact that Latin@s vary along these dimensions of political and economic incorporation (education, language, income, generational cohort, citizenship/registration status, years in the United States, etc.) is not indicative of their “American-ness” or even their lack of “American-ness,” but rather of the distribution of resources within a highly diverse ethnic community. It is also reasonable to acknowledge the formal and social rules that preceded these participatory patterns. Segregated public institutions, voter disenfranchisement, and racially exclusive civic arrangements were developed expressly to isolate and exclude specific minority groups from American society. Current trends show that white Americans are less civically engaged than previous generations. This pattern may be exaggerated among minority groups not only due to a history of exclusion, but also because in the calculus of participation, the costs are higher for many Latin@s. Simple institutional norms can create significant barriers for those with less linguistic and socioeconomic resources. Given our findings, we await the addition of cross-sectional and comparative racial/ethnic data to further examine whether U.S. Latin@s are unique relative to other Americans in their levels of civic engagement. Appendix Dependent variables 1996 GSS: Volunteering (Qs. 640A–646E): In which, if any, of the areas listed on this card have you done some volunteer work in the past twelve months? Item numbers 1–14 coded 0 = no, 1 = yes 1. health 2. education 3. religious organization
4. human services 5. environment 6. public/society benefit
16
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
7. 8. 9. 10.
recreation arts, culture, humanities work-related political organizations or campaigns
11. 12. 13. 14.
youth development private and community foundations international/foreign informal, alone
Pew Survey: Political activity People express their opinions about politics and current events in a number of ways. In the United States, in the past year, have you: Item numbers 1–5, coded 0 = no, 1 = yes 1. Contact: Contacted any elected official? 2. Contribute: Contributed money to a candidate running for public office? 3. Worked: Worked as a volunteer or for pay for a political candidate? 4. Meeting: Attended a public meeting or demonstration in the community where you live? 5. Partisan Meeting: Attended a political party meeting or function? Pew Survey: Volunteerism Next I would like to talk with you about volunteering, spending time helping without being paid for it. In the past year have you volunteered your time to: Item numbers 6–9 coded 0 = no, 1 = yes. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Church: Any church or religious group? School: Any school or tutoring program? Community: Any neighborhood, business, or community group? Ethnic: Any organization representing your own particular nationality or ethnic or racial group? Independent variables
Education range (treated as interval) 1 None, or grade 1–8 2 High school incomplete (grades 9–11) 3 High school grad 4 General Equivalency Diploma (GED) 5 Business, technical, or vocational school after high school 6 Some college, no four-year degree 7 College graduate 8 Postgraduate training / professional schooling after college
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
17
Age: Actual values Income: Range (treated as interval) 1 Less than $5,000 2 $5,000 but less than $10,000 3 $10,000 but less than $15,000 4 $15,000 but less than $20,000 5 $20,000 but less than $25,000 6 $25,000 but less than $30,000 11 $30,000 but less than $35,000 12 $35,000 but less than $40,000 13 $40,000 but less than $45,000 14 $45,000 but less than $50,000 19 $30,000 but less than $50,000 21 $50,000 but less than $60,000 22 $60,000 but less than $75,000 23 $75,000 but less than $100,000 24 $100,000 but less than $150,000 25 $150,000 but less than $200,000 26 $200,000 or more 29 $500,000 or more Years in the United States: Actual values Children: Number of children Employment Sex Citizen and voter registration
Children English fluency Generational cohort
Religion Married Mexican heritage
0 unemployed 1 employed 0 = Male 1 = Female 0 = not a citizen 1 = citizen, not registered to vote 2 = citizen, registered to vote 0 = no children 1 = children 0 = not English dominant 1 = English dominant 0 = foreign born 1 = first generation 2 = second generation 0 = not Catholic 1 = Catholic 0 = not married 1 = married 0=Non-Mexican Heritage 1=Mexican Heritage (Continued)
18
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
Trust—How much do you trust the government in Washington to do what is right? Party Efficacy—Political leaders do not care much what people like me think.
0 = little 1 = most 0 = Not Democrat 1 = Democrat 0 = disagree 1 = agree
Dependent variable distribution for Latino models Political activity No. of activities
Frequency
% of Total
0 1 2 3 4 5
1613 365 160 83 43 14
70.8 16.0 7.0 3.7 1.9 0.6
No. of activities
Frequency
% of Total
0 1 2 3 4
1088 557 357 207 65
47.8 24.5 15.7 9.1 2.8
Volunteer
Notes 1. See also Huntington, “The Hispanic Challenge,” Foreign Policy (March/April 2004): 30–45. 2. Gary M. Segura, “Who Are We? The Challenges to America’s National Identity,” Perspectives on Politics 3 (September 2005): 640–42; and Rodolfo O. de la Garza et al., “Will the Real Americans Please Stand Up? Anglo and Mexican American Support of Core American Political Values,” American Journal of Political Science 40 (May 1996): 335–51. 3. Robert Putnam, Bowling Alone (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2000); X. De Souza Briggs, “Bridging Networks, Social Capital, And Racial Segregation In America” (working paper, John F. Kennedy School Of Government, Faculty Research Working Paper Series, Harvard University, 2003); and S. Knack and
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
4.
5.
6.
7.
8. 9.
19
P. Keefer, “Does Social Capital Have An Economic Payoff? A Cross-Country Investigation,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 112 (November 1997): 1251–88. David Leal et al., “The Latino Vote in the 2004 Election,” PS: Political Science & Politics 38 (January 2005): 41–49; and Matt A. Barreto and others, “The Mobilizing Effect of Majority-Minority Districts on Latino Turnout,” American Political Science Review 98 (February 2004): 65–75. Current Population Survey data (2004), for example, estimates that approximately one-third (34 percent) of voting-age Latin@ citizens were registered to vote in November 2004, compared to 68 percent for whites and 64 percent for African-Americans. Further CPS data reports that of the adult age population, 28 percent of U.S. Latin@s reported voting in the 2004 election compared to 60 percent of whites and 56 percent of African-Americans. “Reported Voting and Registration of the Total Voting-Age Population, by Sex, Race and Hispanic Origin, for States: November 2004,” U.S. Census Bureau Current Population Survey, Internet release date: May 25, 2005, Table 4a; Adrian Pantoja et al., “Citizens by Choice Voters by Necessity: Patterns in Political Mobilization by Naturalized Latinos,” Political Research Quarterly 54 (December 2001): 729–50; and John Arvizu and F. Chris Garcia, “Latino Voting Participation: Explaining and Differentiating Latino Voting Turnout,” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences 18 (May 1996): 104–28. Adrian Pantoja and others, “Citizens by Choice Voters by Necessity,” 729–50; and Rodolfo O. de la Garza, “Latino Politics,” Annual Review of Political Science, 7 (2004): 91–123. Rodney Hero, Latinos in the Political System: Two-Tiered Pluralism (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1992); Rodolfo O. de la Garza, Martha Menchaca, and Louis DeSipio, eds., Barrio Ballots: Latino Politics in the 1990 Elections (Boulder: Westview Press, 1994); Sidney Verba et al., Voice and Equality—Civic Voluntarism in American Politics (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1995); Louis DeSipio, Counting on the Latino Vote: Latinos as a New Electorate (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 1996); John Arvizu and F. Chris Garcia, “Latino Voting Participation,” 104–28; Daran Shaw and others, “Examining Latino Turnout in 1996: A Three-State, Validated Survey Approach,” American Journal of Political Science 44 (April 2000): 332–40; Adrian Pantoja et al., “Citizens by Choice Voters by Necessity,” 729–50; and Carol A. Cassel, “Hispanic Turnout: Estimates from Validated Voting Data,” Political Research Quarterly 55 (June 2002): 391–408. Rodolfo O. de la Garza and others, Latino Voices—Mexican, Puerto Rican and Cuban Experiences On American Politics (Boulder: Westview, 1992). The Pew Hispanic Center / Kaiser Family Foundation 2002 National Survey of Latinos was conducted by telephone April 4–June 11, 2002, with a nationally representative sample of 4,213 adults, including 2,929 Latinos. Survey data were weighted by the Center for the national sample (weight) and separately for Latino respondents (weight). A third weighting process was created by the author to reflect nativity and gender segments within the Latin@ subpopulations relative to newly released U.S. Census data (WGT3). The Pew Hispanic
20
10. 11.
12.
13. 14.
15. 16.
17.
18. 19.
20.
21.
22.
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
Center and the Kaiser Family Foundation bear no responsibility for the interpretations offered, or conclusions made based on analysis of the Pew Hispanic Center / Kaiser Family Foundation 2002 National Survey of Latinos. Arturo Vega, “‘Americanizing?’ Attitudes and Perceptions of US Latinos,” Harvard Journal Of Hispanic Policy 18 (January 2006): 45. Maria Chávez and Luis. R. Fraga, “Social Trust, Civic Engagement and Social Mobility” (paper, The Annual Meeting of the Western Political Science Association, Denver, Colorado, March 26–29, 2003). Melissa R. Michelson, “The Corrosive Effect Of Acculturation: How Mexican Americans Lose Political Trust,” Social Science Quarterly 84 (December 2003): 918–33. Gary Segura and others, “Hispanics, Social Capital, And Civic Engagement,” National Civic Review 90 (March 2001): 88–96. J. A. Garcia and C. H. Arce, “Political Orientations And Behaviors Of Chicanos: Trying To Make Sense Out Of Attitudes And Participation,” in Latinos and The Political System (Notre Dame, Indiana: University Of Notre Dame Press, 1988), 125–52. Segura, 97. A. G. Emig, M. B. Hesse, and S.H. Fisher, “Black-White Differences in Political Efficacy, Trust, And Sociopolitical Participation—A Critique Of The Empowerment Hypothesis,” Urban Affairs Review 32 (1996): 265–76. R. Browning, D. R. Marshall, and D. H. Tabb, Protest Is Not Enough: The Struggle Of Blacks And Hispanics For Equality In Urban Politics (Berkeley: University Of California Press, 1984). Richard D. Shingles, “Black Consciousness and Political Participation: The Missing Link,” American Political Science Review 75 (March 1981): 76–91. K. E. Portney and J. M. Berry, “Mobilizing Minority Communities—Social Capital In Urban Neighborhoods,” The American Behavioral Scientist 40 (1997): 639. Using the Pew 2004 National Latino Survey, contingency analysis reveals statistically significant differences but weak associations among foreign-born and second- and third-generation Latinos relative to political efficacy (official care about me) and trust, with foreign-born more efficacious but less trusting. Crosstabs are not included. Milton M. Gordon, “Assimilation in America: Theory and Reality,” Majority and Minority—The Dynamics of Racial and Ethnic Relations (Boston: Allyn and Bacon, Inc., 1975), 248. Also see Michael Lemay, The Perennial Struggle—Race, Ethnicity And Minority Group Politics In The United States (Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall, 2000); Reid Luhman and Stuart Gilman, Race and Ethnic Relations—The Social And Political Experiences Of Minority Groups (Florence: Wadsworth Publishing, 1980); and Richard Alba and Victor Nee, “Rethinking Assimilation Theory For A New Era Of Immigration,” International Migration Review 31 (1997): 826–74.
CHANGING THE NATIONAL ETHOS OR JUST BEING AMERICAN?
21
23. Michael LeMay, The Perennial Struggle—Race, Ethnicity and Minority Group Politics in the United States (New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 2004). 24. Lawrence H. Fuchs, “Cultural Pluralism and The Future Of American Unity: The Impact Of Illegal Aliens,” International Migration Review 18 (Autumn 1984): 800–813. 25. Melissa R. Michelson, “The Corrosive Effect Of Acculturation: How Mexican Americans Lose Political Trust,” Social Science Quarterly 84 (2003): 918–33. 26. Wendy Tam Cho, “Naturalization, Socialization, Participation: Immigrants and (Non-) Voting,” Journal of Politics 61 (November 1999): 1140–55. 27. Wendy Tam Cho, “Naturalization, Socialization, Participation,” 2. 28. Louis DeSipio, Counting on the Latino Vote: Latinos as a New Electorate (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 1996); Lisa García Bedolla, “The Identity Paradox: Latino Language, Politics and Selective Dissociation,” Latino Studies 1 (July 2003): 264–83; and S. Karthick Ramakrishnan, Democracy in Immigrant America: Changing Demographics and Political Participation (Palo Alto: Stanford University Press, 2005). 29. Richard D. Shingles, “Black Consciousness and Political Participation: The Missing Link,” American Political Science Review 75 (March 1981): 76–91; and L. Bob and F. D. Gilliam, Jr., “Race, Sociopolitical Participation, and Black Empowerment,” American Political Science Review 84 (June 1990): 377–93. 30. S. Karthick Ramakrishnan, Democracy in Immigrant America: Changing Demographics and Political Participation (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2005). 31. Sidney Verba et al., Voice and Equality—Civic Voluntarism in American Politics (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1995); and William A. Diaz, “Latino Participation in America: Associational and Political Roles,” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences 18 (1996): 154–74. 32. Louis DeSipio, Counting on the Latino Vote: Latinos as a New Electorate (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 1996). 33. Rodolfo O. de la Garza, “Latino Politics,” Annual Review of Political Science 7 (2004): 91–123. 34. Rodolfo O. de la Garza et al., Latino Voices—Mexican, Puerto Rican and Cuban Experiences on American Politics (Boulder, CO: Westview, 1992), 122, 127. 35. Arturo Vega, “ ‘Americanizing?’ Attitudes and Perceptions of US Latinos,” Harvard Journal of Hispanic Policy 18 (2006): 39–57; Susan Welch and Lee Sigelman, “A Gender-Gap Among Hispanics? A Comparison with Black and Anglos,” Western Political Science Quarterly 45 (March 1992): 181–91; and Lisa J. Montoya, Carol Hardy-Fanta, and Sonia Garcia, “Latina Politics: Gender, Participation, and Leadership,” PS: Political Science and Politics 33 (September 2000): 555–61. 36. Lisa J. Montoya, Carol Hardy-Fanta, and Sonia Garcia, “Latina Politics: Gender, Participation, and Leadership,” 555–61. 37. Jan J. Russell, “Grand Opportunity Party—The Republicans and George W. Bush Won a Record Share of Hispanic Vote in November—And That Ought to Scare the Democrats to Death,” Texas Monthly (March 2005),
22
SYLVIA MANZANO AND ARTURO VEGA
http://www.texasmonthly.com/preview/2005-03-01/russell (accessed in June 2005). 38. Adrian Campo-Flores and Howard Fineman, “A Latino Power Surge,” Newsweek (2005), http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/7937184/site/newsweek (accessed in June 2005). 39. The Pew telephone survey was conducted from April 21 through June 9, 2004, among a nationally representative sample of 2,288 Latin@ adults, eighteen years of age or older. These data were weighted by the Pew Hispanic Center to represent the actual distribution of adults throughout the United States and was included in the data set. The margin of sampling error +/–2.83. 40. James A. Davis and Tom W. Smith, General Social Surveys, 1972–2002 Cumulative Codebook (Chicago: National Opinion Research Center, 2002), 614–17.
2
State-Federal Relations Concerning Latin@ Civil Rights in the United States Norma V. Cantú
Early Court Appearances by Latin@s atin@s did not bring federal court cases to the U.S. Supreme Court until the second half of the twentieth century. The earliest case promoting the civil rights of Latin@s urged the Supreme Court to overturn the practice of excluding Latin@s from serving on juries in criminal cases.1 The case concerned a Latino defendant in a criminal case who was tried in a county in which no Latin@ had ever been permitted to serve on a jury in several decades. The highest state court in Texas held that the attorneys for Pete Hernandez had failed to assert a viable legal challenge to the jury process as whites had overwhelmingly been selected to serve on juries because “Mexicans are white people.”2 The U.S. Supreme Court reversed the decision. Basing the decision on the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, the Hernandez ruling resulted in three prominent and related holdings by the highest federal court:
L
●
●
Latin@s were an identifiable class to be distinguished from Anglos (whites, Caucasians) and from African-American persons (then called Negroes); Latin@s were entitled to the highest level of review, or strict scrutiny, offered by the court in evaluating whether the State’s public actions violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution; and
24
NORMA V. CANTÚ ●
The Court recognized U.S. society’s proclivity to identify new groups upon which to heap discrimination, and the Court acknowledged its duty to protect new groups who suffered from unconstitutional conduct.3
The Hernandez decision, decided immediately before the landmark school decision in Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas,4 signaled that the NAACP legal strategy would win equal opportunities that would also benefit non-African-American students. The Hernandez case offered an excellent illustration of the conflict between how the federal and state governments identified, counted, and classified Latin@s. The States selected varying definitions of race and eligibility for state services that met local interests. On the other extreme, the federal government sometimes ignored existing classifications of race and ethnicity. For example, the term “Hispanic” was not in common use until the U.S. Census created it in the 1980s to combine data about MexicanAmericans, Chican@s, Mexican@s, Puerto Ricans, Cubans, Central and South Americans, and “other Spanish.” The ambiguity of the labels and terms no doubt caused a serious undercount of Latin@s in the United States. Nor did Census respondents fully adopt the term “Hispanic.” Thus, the problem of the Census undercount continues to this day. States relying on full and accurate Census counts were affected by the new definitions of ethnicity.5 Tension between Federal and State Governments in Employment Cases In the 1960s, Congress passed the federal civil rights laws to create a mandate to end discrimination and to bring the formerly excluded into the mainstream of American life. For Latin@s, the barriers of discrimination appeared in the form of bias on the basis of ethnicity, national origin, immigration status, culture, language, accent, and ethnic appearance. Although forty years have passed since these laws were enacted, national progress has sometimes been tragically slow, and on rare occasions dramatically brilliant. Empowered by the civil rights laws, the federal government established the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) to investigate claims of employment discrimination in both the public and private sectors. The new agency was given the responsibility to review individual and class action complaints and to ascertain whether the federal government needed to bring lawsuits or to intervene in existing lawsuits to require compliance with Title VII, a piece of civil rights legislation that prohibited discrimination on the basis of ethnicity or national origin.6 The U.S. Congress augmented the impact of the Title VII laws with those aimed
STATE-FEDERAL RELATIONS CONCERNING LATIN@ CIVIL RIGHTS
25
specifically at the plight of women workers, including the Equal Pay Act7 and the Pregnancy Discrimination Act.8 The EEOC has the authority to sue private employers as well as state governments, and to order broad remedial relief, including monetary damages, for workers who have suffered discrimination, as well as to seek that judges issue injunctions, such as to rehire dismissed minority workers, or to promote them, to award back pay and fringe benefits, or to place employers under orders to cease acts of discrimination. Title VII also authorizes the courts to award attorneys’ fees.9 Employers who disagreed with the EEOC obtained rulings by the Supreme Court that curbed the recovery of compensatory damages. In response, Congress passed several amendments that clarified the circumstances—such as instances of intentional discrimination—under which these damage awards were warranted.10 Not surprisingly, litigants seeking to enforce the newly passed Title VII laws in the courts experienced delays as the courts pondered which party had the burden of proving whether the discrimination had occurred. In 1973, the Supreme Court placed the initial burden of establishing a prima facie case of racial or national-origin discrimination on the injured party.11 The plaintiff carries that burden by showing proof (i) that he/she belongs to a racial or ethnic minority; (ii) that he/she applied and was qualified for the job or employment opportunity for which the employer was seeking applicants; (iii) that, despite his/her qualifications, the minority applicant was rejected; and (iv) that after the rejection, the position remained open with the employer continuing to seek applicants.12 According to the information on EEOC’s Web page, the number of national-origin charges filed with the federal government showed a steady increase in the past ten years.13 The data does not report the percentage of these charges brought by Latin@s. However, the EEOC has noticed an increase in the number of charges brought to complain of English-only workplace rules ever since the federal agency began tracking such charges separately.14 The EEOC permits English-only rules or initiatives only when such rules are justified by business necessity or are required by reasons of safety. The EEOC’s interpretation of the illegality of English-only rules stands in contrast to state initiatives that have been presented and approved in several states. In the employment area, a substantial amount of litigation ensued regarding conflicts in interpretation between the federal and state governments regarding who had the power to receive and investigate charges of employment discrimination, and whether the deadlines for filing such employment complaints had been met. The U.S. Supreme Court has frequently encountered difficulties with state classifications dealing with aliens, including efforts to restrict
26
NORMA V. CANTÚ
employment opportunities based on alienage. See, for example, Ambach v. Norwich15 and Yick Wo v. Hopkins.16 In Cabell v. Chavez-Salido, a case involving a California statute requiring all “peace officers” to be U.S. citizens, the U.S. Supreme Court continued to draw a distinction between States that reserved certain economic benefits exclusively for citizens for economic reasons from those States that excluded noncitizens to further the sovereign functions of the local government. The Court recognized a State’s interest in limiting participation in government to people who fit the State’s definition of community. Sugarman v. Dougall17 upheld California’s statute. Four of the Supreme Court’s Justices dissented, urging the court to reconsider, and concluding in the dissent that the inclusion of deputy probation officers in the category of persons who must be citizens stemmed “solely from state parochialism and hostility towards foreigners who have come to this country lawfully.” One last Supreme Court case regarding employment concerns the relationship between the hiring of minority teachers and the pattern of minority student enrollments in the public schools. The case Hazelwood School District v. U.S.18 rejected the efforts by the U.S. government to insist that the school district in St. Louis County, Missouri, would have to make greater efforts to obtain qualified “Negro”19 faculty members. The Supreme Court noted that the district had hired its first “Negro” teacher in 1969 and had steadily increased its hiring patterns until 5.7 percent of the teachers in the district were “Negro.” The Court of Appeals ruled for the U.S. government, noting that 15 percent of teachers in the relevant labor market were “Negro,” and that only 3.4 percent of the new teachers hired were “Negro.” The U.S. Supreme Court overturned the Court of Appeals, criticizing the school district for its lack of precision in ascertaining the relevant figures from which the district might hire its teachers. It allowed the district to use as a defense the competitive recruitment policies of neighboring districts and to consider whether “Negro” teachers preferred to teach in neighboring districts where the percentages of “Negro” teachers were higher. The high court sent the case back to the trial court for more evidence. The decision drew a stinging dissent from Justice Stevens, who questioned whether such “absolute precision” was “too much to expect.”20 Justice Stevens’s words were prophetic, with few court cases successfully closing the gap between the increasing percentages of minority students and the decreasing percentages of minority teachers.21 Sovereign Immunity of the State Governments The resistance by States to federal intrusion into States’ rights has deep historical roots. The Tenth Amendment reserved to the States all powers not
STATE-FEDERAL RELATIONS CONCERNING LATIN@ CIVIL RIGHTS
27
delegated to the U.S. government by the Constitution. This role of States as sovereigns entitled to immunity from lawsuits is a closely guarded right. The Bill of Rights, consisting of the first ten amendments to the U.S. Constitution, was not successfully advanced in the post-Reconstruction era, either because African-Americans were not apprised of their rights or because state actors were unwilling to extend these rights to minorities. The U.S. Supreme Court spoke to the great need to pass the 1871 Civil Rights Act, as follows, in Monroe v. Pape:22 It is abundantly clear that one reason the legislation was passed was to afford a federal right in federal courts because, by reason of prejudice, passion, neglect, intolerance or otherwise, state laws might not be enforced and the claims of citizens to the enjoyment of rights, privileges, and immunities guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment might be denied by the state agencies.
Section 1983, enacted in 1871, altered the relationship between federal and state governments by enabling victims of unconstitutional state action to bring suit against the “person” doing wrong. This law removed a substantial barrier to suits against state actors who had interfered with the civil rights of citizens to sue or be sued, to hold property, and to enter into contracts, among other rights. Preemption of Federal Government in Immigration-Related Matters In matters where the U.S. Congress has spoken plainly and comprehensively, federal courts have ruled that the action by Congress has “preempted” the issue so that state and local governments may not act inconsistently with the will of Congress. Areas of preemption include, for example, maritime law and immigration law. The Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) expanded employment protection to persons who were residing legally in the United States.23 The Department of Justice interpreted those rules to prohibit only intentional acts of discrimination.24 The IRCA does not prohibit the hiring or giving of a preference to a U.S. citizen over another qualified individual who is an alien.25 Tension between Federal and State Governments in Education Cases Latin@s brought both state and federal claims regarding education, employment, and other denial of their rights, urging theories of prejudice,
28
NORMA V. CANTÚ
differential treatment, and discrimination by differential outcomes. The earliest cases in education served as test cases for the trailblazing litigator, the honorable Thurgood Marshall, who filed briefs against the segregation of children in Mendez v. Westminster,26 several years before arguing in Brown v. School Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas. Relying on the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, Latin@ plaintiffs in Mendez (who were Puerto Rican and Mexican-American) challenged patterns of segregation of Latin@ children in schools near Anaheim, California. The legal strategies in the Mendez v. Westminster case departed dramatically from the theories of the Brown case. In Mendez, the Latin@ parents asserted that the district official sought to keep children with darker complexions from attending the same schools as children with lighter skin color. This case was not about the concept of segregation by race. The Mendez parents asserted their children were white, a claim the school district did not dispute. According to the students’ attorneys, the children did not deserve to be treated differently from other white children. Also, in contrast to the State law in Kansas that supported the segregation of African-Americans, the State law in California did not support the use of segregation of white children from other white children. Thus, the Latin@ legal arguments were unique, but the outcomes were the same: the courts rejected the segregation. The federal Civil Rights Acts, passed in 1964 and 1965, prompted several key changes in the relationship between Latin@s and the court system. First, the passage of the bills encouraged the filing of individual court actions on behalf of Latin@ clients by private attorneys across the country. Secondly, the activities of the NAACP to enforce the new federal laws inspired legal visionaries such as Pete Tijerina and Mario Obledo to establish the national nonprofit Mexican-American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF) in 1967, with a generous grant from the Ford Foundation.27 Thirdly, newly elected Latin@ state legislators began to file state bills to overturn discriminatory state laws and to pass state civil rights legislation. In Keyes v. School District No. 1 (Denver), the high court acknowledged that states and local school districts outside the southern states had engaged in the illegal acts of segregating schoolchildren by race.28 By ruling that Latin@s in the Denver, Colorado, schools had been illegally segregated, the U.S. Supreme Court expanded the reach of the Brown case to states outside the traditional South. In Rodriguez v. San Antonio School District, lawyers for Latin@ students, attempting to cover low-income students with the same Equal Protection rights already available to racial minorities, argued that State officials should not be permitted to discriminate on the basis of poverty. The U.S.
STATE-FEDERAL RELATIONS CONCERNING LATIN@ CIVIL RIGHTS
29
Supreme Court ruled that poverty was not a suspect class;29 therefore, low-income students in predominantly Latin@ school districts could not successfully challenge vast disparities in funding for public schools.30 The federal court declined to treat education as a fundamental right that merited special protection under the U.S. Constitution, noting that education was not mentioned in the original Constitution. In rejecting the students’ federal claims, the Court suggested that the students should bring cases in the State court. Thereafter, students who challenged school finance disparities appeared in state courts until more than half of the states were embroiled in legal battles over school funding gaps. In a split 5–4 ruling, the Supreme Court granted a federal legal victory to undocumented children in 1982 by overturning a Texas law that allowed local districts to charge out-of-state tuition to public school students whose parents were not legal U.S. residents. The ruling in Plyler v. Doe chastised the State for asserting an economic interest in keeping students out of school, believing the plaintiffs’ experts who testified that the costs of keeping the students uneducated would be much greater than the small savings realized from denying the students an education.31 Congress passed the Equal Educational Opportunity Act of 1974, 20 U.S.C., section 1703(f) to ensure that state and local districts would take appropriate action to remove barriers against the education of nonEnglish-proficient students.32 That same year, the U.S. Supreme Court delivered an opinion regarding Title VI33 of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 in Lau v. Nichols.34 In ruling that the equal treatment of unequal children violated Title VI, the Court did not reach the Equal Protection Clause argument advanced in the case. The holding in the Lau case resonated in the case Guardians Association35 in 1983, in which the Supreme Court wrote that Title VI forbids the use of federal funds “not only in programs that intentionally discriminate on racial grounds but also in those endeavours that have a disparate impact on racial minorities.” The Supreme Court has held that “Title VI itself directly reached only instances of intentional discrimination . . . [but that] actions having an unjustifiable disparate impact on minorities could be addressed through agency regulations designed to implement the purposes of Title VI” in Alexander v. Choate.36 More recently, in Alexander v. Sandoval, though,37 the Court determined that private plaintiffs could urge only intentional discrimination cases under Title VI. In this case, Latin@s challenged the operation of Alabama’s driver’s license process as discriminating against Latin@s because the testing was conducted solely in English, having a disparate impact on ethnic minorities. The Court explained its view that only the federal government could challenge disparate impact claims under
30
NORMA V. CANTÚ
Title VI as it believed that Congress never intended private individuals to bring these claims. The Court rejected the view of the U.S. Attorney General that the private right to bring a disparate impact claim could be implied by the statute, even though such private suits had been filed for over two decades. This ruling serves as a caution to policymakers and law enforcers alike that the federal courts may attempt to avoid giving full force and effect to the laws if the laws are not expressly written or are not supported by ample record and evidence to bolster the directives of Congress. With the federal government as the sole entity that may bring disparate impact claims, the opportunities for legal issues concerning Latin@s to be heard are greatly diminished. The Department of Justice brings hundreds of cases to enforcement per year out of tens of thousands of administrative complaints that are filed with federal agencies annually. While it has been hailed as a new civil rights law, the No Child Left Behind Act of 200138 did not expressly create any rights that could be filed in court. Parents who attempted to sue for better instruction by using the new federal education law were quickly and quietly dismissed from court. School districts and state governments are now attempting in court to determine whether the law adds or detracts from the hard work of educating children. In 1994 I addressed the Hacemos 5th Annual Conference in Lubbock, Texas, and urged the Latin@ community in attendance to reject “what some have called the conspiracy of low expectations.” Later, in the same speech, I applauded the Goals 2000 education bill for “sweeping away the tyranny of low expectations.” How could I have known that the phrase would change into “bigotry of soft expectations” and become the rallying cry for the passage of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001. The Goals 2000 law, signed by President Clinton on March 31, 1994, already contained much of the substance of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, but the emphasis on the annual testing of students, the sanctions and accountability of transfers of students, and the loss of school funds based on low test scores has done little to end the “tyranny of low expectations.” On June 28, 2007, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a highly divided legal opinion in which five of the justices agreed in the result that two public school districts had illegally considered race in student assignments. The cases issued jointly were Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle and Meredith v. Jefferson County Board of Education.39 Each of these two cases is helpful for understanding the level of complexity that arises when both the federal government and the state governments step in to review the actions of local governments. The Seattle case concerned a voluntary school desegregation plan that included a “tiebreaker” that considered the race of the student applicants
STATE-FEDERAL RELATIONS CONCERNING LATIN@ CIVIL RIGHTS
31
for popular, overenrolled schools. The parents in the Seattle case alleged that Seattle’s use of race among other factors for determining student assignments violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment,40 Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964,41 and the State of Washington civil rights law.42 In following the State claims in the Seattle case in which the parents challenged the school district’s use of race as a tiebreaker in situations where equally situated students had asked for the same placement in the same school, the Court considered the facts and concluded that the Washington State Civil Rights Act barred only preferential treatment programs “where race or gender is used by government to select a less qualified applicant over a more qualified applicant.”43 The federal district court considered the same evidence as applied to the Fourteenth Amendment and Title VI. First, the district court asked whether the district had a compelling interest in using race at all. Secondly, the court inquired whether the use of race was appropriate and sufficiently narrowly tailored to avoid discrimination against third parties. The first inquiry required a deep understanding of the district’s motives in agreeing to consider race in the selection of students for oversubscribed schools. The district explained to the court that the population from which the district drew its students was 70 percent white, and that the public schools were only 40 percent white. Further, most of the minority students lived south of downtown, and the more popular schools were located north of downtown. The district had never been ordered by a court to desegregate its school, but had historically implemented voluntary measures to integrate. These measures included voluntary majority-to-minority programs in which students volunteered to attend schools in which their race was underrepresented in the student body. The district had also attempted to adopt a desegregation plan, but it was blocked by a State law that had been adopted due to the Washington voters’ initiative against desegregation. Later, the initiative was found to be unconstitutional. In the interim, the Seattle School Board had adopted a different student assignment plan, one that gave parents three top choices of schools in which to enrol their students. All parents were guaranteed that the students would be enrolled in one of the three schools, but that no parent would be guaranteed the top choice. The legal challenge in Seattle by a parent who did not receive their top choice of schools serves to remind Americans that our history of basing decisions on race is shameful and embarrassing. The justifications for any governmental decision that uses race should be bolstered by clear evidence and abundant documentation to support the claimed need. Yet, Justice Kennedy’s separate decision in the Seattle case correctly noted that
32
NORMA V. CANTÚ
in our zeal to insist on proof of the need to consider race, we should not foreswear the use of race in situations where it is justified. By stating that four of the Justices were too “dismissive of government’s legitimate interest in ensuring that all people have equal opportunity regardless of their race,” Justice Kennedy brought some common sense back into the debate between the federal and state lawmakers. We have not arrived at the point where all matters of race no longer matter. Local and state policymakers will continue to need a variety of raceconscious measures to address the problems of race, both long-standing and newly created. It will take hard work for the Seattle schools to walk that tightrope and to deliver to Justice Kennedy the careful, thoughtful policies that the U.S. Constitution demands. It would be consistent with the optimism of the Seattle School Board for them to continue to make that attempt, though. They are most aware that this country strives to rid itself of its history of creating new groups that can suffer discrimination, while continuing to hold back groups that have borne that burden for too long. Conclusion The legal system in the United States attempts to harmonize inconsistent federal and state laws by expecting the courts to try in good faith to give force and effect to both laws. To the extent that the federal law does not reach the substance of a state law, the Tenth Amendment reserves the sovereign power of the State to settle the legal question. To the extent that the federal law substantially reaches the question, the federal law trumps the State’s authority. This hybridized form of civil rights legislation and enforcement can be easily justified and defended if certain assumptions were to prove true: 1. The goal of protecting the civil rights of Latin@s is too important to leave to either the federal and state laws alone; 2. The duplication in laws is necessary to respect federalism and states’ rights; 3. The federal and state laws amplify the message of the importance of respect for Latin@s’ human rights; and 4. The federal and state laws serve as checks and balances to ensure a safety net for Latin@s and others. In all of the areas discussed above, the combined strength of federal and state civil rights laws and enforcement have been insufficient to protect fully the human rights of Latin@s. For example, despite the enormous activity in both federal and state legal arenas, the economic disparities for
STATE-FEDERAL RELATIONS CONCERNING LATIN@ CIVIL RIGHTS
33
the Latin@ workforce are problematic. The unadjusted earnings data for Latin@s reflect earnings that are 65 percent of the earnings of white men and 79 percent of the earnings of white women.44 Roughly one-third to one-half of the disparities could be traced to differences in fluency in the English language.45 Nonetheless, the most visible successes in raising compliance with civil rights laws have occurred when federal and state agencies cooperate, rather than engage in conflict. In one example, one of the school superintendents in Georgia determined he would avoid a confrontational posture with the U.S. government, and approached the federally funded Desegregation Assistance Center for help in ending the use of IQ tests as screening devices for entry in gifted and talented programs in his district. With the help of the Center and the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights, the superintendent was able to identify valid entry criteria that did not have the effect of screening out minority students. He later succeeded in encouraging the entire state to drop its overreliance on IQ tests. Before his state-wide efforts, whites were five times as likely to be recognized as gifted than were African-Americans. The superintendent won a national award for his courage in defying the tradition of maintaining all-Anglo gifted and talented classes.46 The last thirty-five years have been most fruitful and exciting for understanding the relationship between federal and state laws as they define Latin@ civil rights. Unlike some countries in which the human rights of its minority citizens are fixed in legislative enactments that the courts may not interpret, the U.S. legal system has some small, crucial bits of flexibility. One may speculate that a stronger, centralized federal government might have wrested more control from the States, and might have passed more civil rights laws, but I do not agree that the model of a more powerful central government would have caused more economic and social gains for Latin@s than the combined efforts of States and the federal government. The relationships between the federal laws and state laws have given me more reason to have optimism than would a scenario in which the federal government acted alone. The two forms of government working to bring about the most balanced result have caused frustration at times, but the gains have been nonviolent, and in many instances, directly related to the hard work of law enforcers. The words of Dr. Martin Luther King should inspire our efforts toward finding the right level of collaboration between federal and state governments. In his own words, Dr. King preached: Through our scientific genius we have made of this world a neighborhood. Now . . . we must make of it a brotherhood. We must all learn to live together
34
NORMA V. CANTÚ
as brothers, or we will all perish together as fools. We must come to see that no individual can live alone; no nation can live alone. We must all live together. We must all be concerned about each other.”47
Notes 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
6.
7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
Hernandez v. State of Texas, 347 U.S. 475 (1954). Hernandez v. State of Texas, 160 Tex. Crim. App. 72 (1952). Hernandez v. State of Texas, 347 U.S. 475 (1954). 347 U.S. 483 (1954). In 1997, the Office of Management and Budget, the federal bureau charged with setting out definitions of racial and ethnic categories for the U.S. Census, decided that respondents to the Census could identify themselves as belonging to more than one racial group, and thereby created “multiracial” categories. See 62 Fed. Reg. 58781 (October 30, 1997). Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 as amended in 1991, 42 U.S.C. Section 20003-2000h. I served as co-counsel in employment discrimination cases from 1980 to 1992, during which time the national female-male earnings ratio for Latinas (Hispanic females) advanced from 49 percent to 61 percent. Equal Pay Act of 1963, 29 U.S.C. Section 206(d) (1). Pregnancy Discrimination Act, 42 U.S.C. Section 2000(k). 42 U.S.C. Section 2000-5(k). Civil Rights Act of 1991 (adding a new Section 1981a, which allows for damage claims for intentional discrimination by private defendants). McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. Green, 411 U.S. 792 (1973). Ibid. See www.EEOC.gov, last visited August 6, 2007. The number of complaints against employers who misused English—only policies grew from 77 charges in the fiscal year 1996 to 365 charges in the fiscal year 2000. See www.EEOC.gov/press/9-19-00.html (retrieved on January 6, 2010). Cases regarding restrictions based on alienage have “not formed an unwavering line over the years.” Ambach, 82. 118 U.S. 356 (1886). 413 U.S. 634, 642 (1973). 433 U.S. 299 (1977). The original language as it was argued and decided in 1977 is used in this chapter. For this reason “Negro” is used to refer to African-Americans. Ibid. I spoke about the lack of racially and ethnically diverse teachers to several nonprofit groups. At a meeting with the Quality Education for Minorities Network, I reported that one-third of the nation’s children belonged to a minority group, but only 12 percent of U.S. teachers were from minority backgrounds. See Remarks by author, Washington, D.C. (1996).
STATE-FEDERAL RELATIONS CONCERNING LATIN@ CIVIL RIGHTS
35
22. 365 U.S.167, 180 (1961). 23. Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986, 8 U.S.C.A. Section 1324b (a), creating a separate set of rules from the EEOC’s Title VII laws prohibiting national-origin discrimination. 24. 28 C.F.R. Section 44.200(a). 25. 8 U.S.C. Section 1324b (a) (4). 26. Mendez v. Westminster School District. 27. Rudolfo De la Garza, ed., The Mexican American Experience: A Legal Voice for the Chicano Community (Austin: University of Texas Press, 1985), 281–83; citing MALDEF annual reports. 28. Keyes v. School District No. 1 (Denver), 413 U.S. 189 (1973). 29. In American jurisprudence a classification of suspect meets a series of criteria suggesting the classified group is probably the subject of discrimination. 30. Rodriguez v. San Antonio Independent School District, 411 U.S. 1 (1973). 31. Plyler v. Doe, 457 U.S. 202 (1982). 32. 20 U.S.C. Section 1703(f). 33. The regulations passed by the agency then known as Health, Education and Welfare, 45 C.F.R. Section 80.3(b)(1), required in subsection (iv) that recipients of federal funding may not “restrict an individual in any way in the employment of any advantage or privilege enjoyed by others receiving any service, financial aid, or other benefit of the program.” When the HEW agency split to produce the U.S. Department of Education, the Title VI regulation was continued by the agency, and published at 34 C.F.R. Part 100. The Office for Civil Rights of the U.S. Department of Education enforces Title VI as it applies to recipients who offer educational programs and who receive federal funding. 42 U.S.C. Sections 2000d et seq. 34. 414 U.S. 563 (1974). Students of Chinese ancestry who did not speak English received their instruction in English. The Court did not interfere in the school’s options, which might include, among other options, to either choose to teach English to students of Chinese ancestry or to give instructions in their mother tongue. Instead, the Supreme Court held: “ . . . there is no equality of treatment merely by providing students with the same facilities, textbooks, teachers, and curriculum; for students who do not understand English are effectively foreclosed from any meaningful education.” 35. Guardians Assn. v. Civil Service Commission, 463 U.S. 582 (1983). 36. 439 U.S. 287, 295 (1985) (discussing Guardians) 37. Alexander v. Sandoval, 427 U.S.1 (2001). 38. 20 U.S.C. Section 6301 (2001). 39. 551 U.S. 701 (2007) Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1, Nos. 05-908 and 05-915. 40. “No State shall . . . deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” U.S. Constitution, Amendment 14, Section 1. 41. “No person in the United States shall, on the ground of race . . . be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.” 78 Stat. 252, 42 U.S.C. Section 2000d.
36
NORMA V. CANTÚ
42. “The state shall not discriminate against, or grant preferential treatment, to any individual or group on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in the operation of public employment, public education, or public contracting.” Wash. Rev. Code Section 49.60.400(1) (2006). 43. Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School Dist., No. 1, 149 Wash. 2d 660, 689–690, 663, 72 P.3d 151, 1666, 153 (2003)(en banc)(PICS V). 44. Arthur Smith, Employment Discrimination Law: Cases and Materials, 5th ed. (New York: Lexis Nexis Matthew Bender, 2000), 43 (citing Carlson and Swartz, “The Earnings of Women and Ethnic Minorities, 1959–79,” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 41 (1988): 530–46, Tables 3, 4). 45. Ibid. 46. Remarks by me at the 2nd Annual Civil Rights Summit, Kansas City, MO (1995). 47. Commencement address at Lincoln University in Pennsylvania (1961).
3
Latin@s in the U.S. Military Jorge Mariscal
rom the time the first tejanos, nuevomexicanos, and californios joined the ranks of the U.S. military out of cultural displacement and economic despair in the second half of the nineteenth century, Latin@s have been an essential part of the U.S. armed forces. When Puerto Ricans became eligible for the draft during World War I, another source of recruits was established that would produce 1,250 fallen boricuas and four Puerto Rican Congressional Medal of Honor winners in U.S. wars throughout the twentieth century. During the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq, a guatemalteco, a mexicano, and a colombiano, all noncitizens, were among the first to lose their life. Sustained by a constant flow of new immigrants and relatively limited career opportunities for the native-born working class of color, Latin@ military service has been a primary vehicle for assimilation, access to full rights of citizenship, and the construction of “American” identities premised on traditional patriotism. Not unlike the ways in which inexpensive Latin@ labor fueled (and continues to fuel) the growth of the national economy, Latin@ and other working-class bodies have provided the raw material for U.S. military conflicts for over a century and a half. Among all ethnic groups in the United States, Latin@s have won forty-one Congressional Medals of Honor, more than any other group.
F
Historical Background Narratives about “Hispanic-Americans,” deploying a broad definition of “Hispanic” that includes Spaniards and other Spanish-speaking groups, trace a line of Latin@s in uniform from the American Revolutionary War
38
JORGE MARISCAL
through the Civil War (in both the Union and Confederate armies) and into the present. From this perspective, a “proud tradition” of military service includes Civil War admiral David Farragut (1801–70), the son of a Spaniard, who led Union forces in the 1862 battle of New Orleans and Hispanic members of Teddy Roosevelt’s Rough Riders in the war against Spain in 1898. Less expansive stories about the role of Spanish-speaking minorities in times of war begin with World War I in which Latinos from diverse national backgrounds served in segregated units in Europe. The cultural power of these narratives cannot be underestimated insofar as they perpetuate the idea of military service as a necessary pathway to full acceptance by the dominant society in the United States. On the one hand, they reproduce the tropes of courage and service that indeed are values deserving of recognition and inclusion in the national memory. On the other hand, the emphasis on “heroes” and “honor” obfuscates the oftentimes questionable motives for which numerous U.S. wars have been waged from the interventions of 1898 to the Korean and Vietnam conflicts to the invasion of Iraq in 2003. There is no doubt that the Latino and Latina individuals who fought in all of these wars and their families made tremendous sacrifices, but too often the historical and political realities that informed those wars had less to do with the defense of the nation and more to do with the very ideologies—colonialism, racism, and Manifest Destiny—that had led to oppression in Latin@ barrios domestically and Latin American countries abroad. The one war about which there is little debate, however, is World War II, and indeed it was the participation of Latinos and Latinas in that war that altered significantly their role, both overseas and on the home front. Even before the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, National Guard units from New Mexico made up almost exclusively of hispanos were stationed in the Philippines. These men would later participate in the Battle of Bataan, many of them suffering in the Bataan Death March and, for extended periods, as prisoners of war. In every other campaign in Europe and the Pacific, Latin@s were present. Members of the famed 65th Army Infantry Regiment, the “Borinqueneers,” which is made up almost exclusively of Puerto Ricans, won numerous medals both in World War II and the Korean War. Less well-known is the participation of the Mexican military in the war in the Pacific, especially the 201st Mexican Fighter Squadron that provided air support for U.S. forces during the battle for the Philippines. Many Latina women served as members of the Women’s Army Corps (WAC) and other military branches as nurses for the Army and Navy Nurse Corps, or the Red Cross, or in the defense industries, giving rise to the popular image of “Rosita the Riveter.” As the scholar Naomi Quiñonez has
LATIN@S IN THE U.S. MILITARY
39
written: “The wartime labor shortages created a window of opportunity for ethnic populations who had been historically restricted from any kind of economic mobility.”1 Latin@s as a Racialized Group Upon their return to the United States, many Latin@ veterans encountered the same discrimination they had left behind. The irony of the so-called Zoot Suit riots of 1943, in which servicemen assaulted young Mexican-Americans in Los Angeles and other urban centers, was not lost on Mexican-American communities whose sons were fighting in the war. It would not be the last time that Latin@s, as a racialized minority, experienced the paradox of fighting abroad for democracy while being denied equal rights at home. The decisive case of Felix Longoria, a soldier killed in the Philippines and denied access to facilities at the cemetery in Three Rivers, Texas, until Senator Lyndon B. Johnson and Dr. Hector P. García intervened on the family’s behalf, gave visibility to the plight of the Latino veteran who had completed his patriotic duty only to be denied the most fundamental rights. Longoria was buried at Arlington National Cemetery in Washington, DC. Advocacy groups such as the American GI Forum were born of these demands by Latin@ veterans for equal rights as citizens of the United States. Latin@ soldiers were present again in the Korean War and the U.S. war in Southeast Asia. The decade-long conflict in Vietnam coincided with the emergence of the Chicano movement, a mass mobilization with diverse political agendas ranging from reform to revolutionary change. During the same period, the Puerto Rican Young Lords adopted anti-imperialist and internationalist political programs. Even as thousands of young Latinos served in the U.S. military, their sisters and brothers at home protested against the war as part of the radical transformation of Latino and Latina identities. The National Chicano Moratorium Committee founded by the Los Angeles Brown Berets, the draft resister Rosalío Muñoz, and others staged massive antiwar demonstrations that culminated in the rally of August 29, 1970. The killing of three people by law enforcement officers at that rally revived the bitter paradox of Latin@s dying in the streets at home while many of the community’s young men fought for “democracy” in Vietnam. For a brief moment in the late 1960s, one sector of the Latin@ community had questioned the traditional relationship between Latin@ youth and the armed forces. If basic civil rights were denied to them at home, asked militant Chican@s and Puerto Ricans, why should they fight in a
40
JORGE MARISCAL
war against Third World peoples abroad? “La batalla está aquí” became the slogan adopted by this briefly radicalized sector of the Latin@ population. In the years following the war in Southeast Asia and the end of obligatory military service in 1973, social conditions in Latin@ communities once again conspired to elevate the armed forces as one of the primary career paths for working-class youth. The conservative retrenchment of the Reagan era was followed by a concerted campaign by the Pentagon during the Clinton administration to target Latin@ youth with Spanishlanguage advertising and ethnic-based outreach. Given the fact that Latin@s represented the fastest growing military age population and faced limited economic and educational opportunities, multimillion dollar recruiting campaigns for the “volunteer Army” were intensified. The promise of job training, high school equivalency (GED) diplomas, money for college, and a sense of direction in life led many Latin@s to enlist despite the fact that U.S. foreign policy produced a steady string of armed conflicts in Panama, the Gulf War, Somalia, Kosovo, Afghanistan, and Iraq. Since at least the U.S. war in Vietnam and the tremendous pressures created by the military draft, Latin@ communities have sensed that their young people were fighting and dying in disproportionate numbers. While it is true that in the early years of that war Chican@s and Puerto Ricans served in numbers higher than their percentages of the total U.S. population, it is also true that the disparity subsided toward the end of the war. Today it is difficult to know with any certainty how many Latin@s served in Southeast Asia, but given traditional military practices of testing and job placement we can say that the number of Latin@s in combat units was consistently high. Recruitment of Latin@s for Military Service A tradition of military service often informs family histories across multiple generations. Portraits of young men and women in uniform grace living rooms in countless Latin@ homes, and the rhetoric of “duty to country” and patriotism is a powerful influence. For young men, to break the continuity of service is an inexcusable act in many families, given the association of manhood with military experience and ancient cultural traditions based on warrior identities. Recruiters have become adept at exploiting such traditions, and Louis Caldera, the secretary of the U.S. Army under President Bill Clinton, once remarked that Latinos are “predisposed to military service.” For young women from traditional patriarchal homes, the military is often seen as a road to empowerment and agency. For all young people, the desire “to make a difference” is a strong motivation that often leads to military service.
LATIN@S IN THE U.S. MILITARY
41
Since at least the 1990s, the Pentagon has employed Hispanic ad agencies to tailor its recruiting message to Latin@ communities. Large Hispanic advocacy groups such as the National Council for La Raza (NCLR) and the League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) have assisted the military in fashioning recruitment campaigns that exploit certain perceived ethnic stereotypes. In 1997 LULAC, through its National Educational Service Centers, established a partnership with the U.S. Army Recruiting Command to expose Latin@ youth to military careers. A 1999 study completed for the Department of Defense on how best to target Hispanics for recruitment enjoyed the participation of many prominent Latin@s who reemphasized cultural traditions that might make the recruitment message more effective. At the Marine Corps website, for example, the potential recruit is told: “At the core of every Marine is the warrior spirit, a person imbued with the special kind of personal character that has defined greatness and success for centuries. And in this organization, you will be regarded as family.” The powerful trope of “family” functions here as an essential part of the sales pitch, and the invocation of the “warrior spirit” reproduces the narrowest forms of traditional Latin American masculinity. Within this complex ideological field there is no doubt that such messages resonate with Latin@ youth. The Marine Corps slogan “Born to fight and die” is not very different from the Mexican “Grito, ‘Mi raza sabe morir dondequiera’” (“Yell, ‘My people know how to die anywhere’”). In working class barrios, role models are often associated with returning veterans or local law enforcement. Combined with limited educational and career opportunities, this means that many young Latin@s will be channeled toward careers as police officers, border patrol agents, prison guards, and in the military. A 2009 study by the Research and Development Corporation (RAND) lamented the fact that elevated high school dropout rates for Hispanics, low scores on the Armed Forces Qualification Test, and a high percentage of overweight Latin@ youth inhibit the ability of recruiters to increase the number of Latin@s in uniform. Weight and educational attainment standards will most likely be lowered given that the Obama administration remains committed to increasing the overall size of both the army and the Marine Corps. According to the Army Times, the study’s conclusions “suggest that it would be worthwhile to direct more recruiting resources to black and Hispanic markets.”2 Local community leaders in Latin@ urban centers across the country often push youth toward a military career as an alternative to gang and drug culture. Ironically, many Hispanic charter schools created in the 1990s, including so-called Raza schools that espouse chicanismo and its
42
JORGE MARISCAL
critique of assimilation, welcome the presence of Junior ROTC units and military recruiters. It is not surprising, therefore, that large numbers of Latin@ high school students have had more exposure to military recruiters than to college recruiters. The heightened militarization of educational spaces inhabited by Latin@ youth has led to surveys such as the one conducted in December 2007 by the Department of Defense in which 12.6 percent of eighteen to twenty-four-year-old Latin@ respondents stated they were probably or definitely going to join the military, compared with 10.1 percent of black respondents and 6.6 percent of white respondents.3 For decades, the State educational and media apparatus has manipulated the inherent contradiction for Latin@ parents—between their desire to assimilate and the need to see their children safe and out of harm’s way. Although parents might fear the dangers inherent in military service, the pressure to display acritical forms of patriotism is often overwhelming and the need to “fit into” one’s surroundings drives many to accept the military as a viable option for their children. This is especially the case for first-generation immigrants. Immigrants and Military Service After an unusually large number of legal immigrants (most of them from Latin America) were admitted into the United States during the decade of the 1990s, the potential for increasing the ranks of the military with immigrants and their children was not lost on the Pentagon. The phenomenon of “green card soldiers” slowly emerged as a major issue, especially after the declaration of the so-called Global War on Terror, and in 2002 President George W. Bush reduced the length of time that permanent residents in the military had to wait before applying for citizenship. Another pool of potential recruits was to be found among the many undocumented youth who had lived most of their life and even completed high school in the United States. Although many of them lacked resident status, they attracted the attention of the Pentagon in part because of rising demands on military force levels caused by the long occupation of Iraq that began in 2003. Legislation such as the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act (DREAM Act), designed to “legalize” undocumented youth so that they could attend college, suddenly included military service options. In his testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee on July 10, 2006, Under Secretary of Defense David Chu made the connection between immigration status and military service: “According to an April 2006 study from the National Immigration Law Center, there are an
LATIN@S IN THE U.S. MILITARY
43
estimated 50,000 to 65,000 undocumented alien young adults who entered the US at an early age and graduate from high school each year, many of whom are bright, energetic and potentially interested in military service . . . Provisions of S. 2611, such as the DREAM Act, would provide these young people the opportunity of serving the United States in uniform.”4 Ironically, undocumented family members of those in the military gained little from their relative’s service. Among the most troubling cases was that of Army Private Armando Soriano, aged twenty, who died in Iraq in 2004. In the summer of 2007, when Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids swept across the country, his Mexican-born father Enrique was arrested in Houston and threatened with deportation. In a similar case, the undocumented Dominican wife of Army Specialist Alex Jimenez, who went missing in action in Iraq in 2007, was about to be deported until pressure from media reports forced the government to grant her a green card. Structured Glass Ceilings for Latin@s in the U.S. Military The predicament for many Latin@ families is that structural glass ceilings continue to make economic mobility difficult. At the beginning of the twenty-first century, ethnic Mexicans in the United States fell below every other Latin@ group on almost every social and economic indicator, according to the 2002 “Interim Report of the President’s Advisory Commission on Educational Excellence for Hispanic Americans.” Firstgeneration Mexican immigrants, who made up 54 percent of all legal Latin American immigrants in 2003, had significantly reduced life chances compared to their U.S.-born Mexican-American counterparts. High school dropout rates of around 30 percent for U.S.-born Mexican-Americans were bad enough, but the rate doubled to 61 percent for first-generation immigrant children. This was not because recent arrivals did not value education, as conservative ideologues often claim, but because the public school system simply was not equipped to deal with linguistic and cultural difference. College attendance rates for Latin@s also lagged behind those for other groups. Conditions for Puerto Ricans in the United States were equally dire and in Puerto Rico itself, a source of thousands of draftees and recruits for the U.S. military over the decades, they were especially difficult. In 2005 the poverty rate on the island was over 40 percent. Although Latin@s have a high rate of participation in the labor force, in 2007 over 21 percent of all Latin@s were living in poverty (compared to 8.2 percent for whites). The Economic Policy Institute noted that according to a variety of measurements the United States was in “the longest continuous stretch of job decline since 1944–46” during the eight years of the
44
JORGE MARISCAL
Bush administration. What was clear from the data was that many Latin@s were working extremely hard but were trapped in minimum-wage jobs. Many held multiple jobs at low wages. In 2002, 61 percent of all workers in agricultural production were Latin@s; the vast majority of them were of Mexican descent. While nearly 11 percent of non-Hispanic whites earned more than $75,000 a year, only 2 percent of all Latin@s earned as much. The so-called economic recovery that took place in early 2004 in the midst of the housing bubble was limited to the financial sectors and did little to ameliorate conditions for working-class families whose children became the recruits for what was in essence a “working poor military draft.” The bursting of the housing bubble led to the deep recession that began in 2008 and to an increasingly contracted job market (the February 2009 Hispanic unemployment rate soared to 10.9 percent compared to 6.3 percent the previous February). These and other factors will continue to drive many working-class Latin@s into the military for economic reasons. Once situated within the structure of the armed forces, Latin@s become part of what is essentially a secondary class system. In 2007, Latin@s made up only 4.7 percent of the commissioned officer corps. Over 75 percent of the officer corps (in all branches of the service) was white. According to official Pentagon records, the majority of Latin@s are bunched together in the private and corporal ranks (or lowest ranks) and therefore are among the most likely to receive hazardous duty assignments. According to the Office of Army Demographics in 2003, Latin@s made up only 11 percent of the enlisted force but represented high concentrations in the combat arms and combat support occupations. (Although women do not serve in the “infantry,” they can be found on gun crews and in other forms of hazardous duty.) It was a disturbing but not surprising fact, then, that in the early weeks of the U.S. invasion of Iraq, Latin@s made up almost 20 percent of those killed in action. These statistics are less the result of a conscious conspiracy (a claim made by some Latin@ activists since at least the U.S. war in Vietnam) than they are the product of inferior educational opportunities in civilian society and the resultant placement of Latin@ recruits in low-tech military occupations. Like class divisions in the U.S. economy, disparities in rank and occupation in the military are structured along racialized lines. According to a 1997 Pentagon survey of over 40,000 active duty members, 38 percent of Latin@s interviewed felt that the military did not pay sufficient attention to issues of racial harassment and discrimination.5 Although military academies continue to employ affirmative action policies in an effort to diversify the officer corps, race, class, gender, language proficiency, and sexual preference continue to be sites of unequal treatment for many Latin@s in the enlisted ranks. In 2006, for example, military investigators
LATIN@S IN THE U.S. MILITARY
45
in Kuwait forced members of the New Mexico National Guard to disrobe for a “tattoo search,” because it had been reported that some guardsmen had “gang tattoos.” The majority of troops subjected to the body search were Mexican-American, and charges of racial targeting were soon levelled by the unit’s commanding general Kenny Montoya who wrote to the army’s chief of staff: “Let me know how I can help our Army to end their discriminatory practices, both now and in the future.”6 Junior Reserve Officers’ Training Corps (JROTC) The combination of reduced life chances for a majority of Latin@s, demographic changes that make Latin@s the largest “minority market” of military age youth, and lingering ideologies of masculinity will continue to push Latin@ youth into the armed forces. Facilitating the process is the increasing influence of militarism in the public school system, a process that gained momentum in the 1990s. In the wake of the Los Angeles riots of 1992, the then general Colin Powell argued that as a preventive measure of social engineering the number of JROTC units should be dramatically increased. Within a five-year period the number of JROTC units had more than doubled from 1,600 in 1992 to 3,500 in 1997. At any high school with a large Latin@ population one finds JROTC units, Army-sponsored computer games, and an overabundance of recruiters, often more numerous than career counselors. Although the Pentagon periodically claims that JROTC is not being used for recruiting purposes, studies by promilitary think tanks state: “Junior ROTC is a strategic initiative that allows us to present the idea of the military lifestyle to high school students. By mission JROTC attempts to create better citizens, but also emphasizes military values, and presents the idea of the military lifestyle.”7 According to Department of Defense statistics, about 40 percent of high school students who have spent more than two years in JROTC enlist in the military.8 During the Clinton administration, Secretary of the Army Louis Caldera increased the army’s Spanish-language yearly budget from $5 million to $10 million. Elaborate websites in Spanish such as elNavy. com and hip-hop campaigns such as the Hispanic H-2 Tour—whose goal according to its creator Latino Sports Marketing of San Diego, California, is to “build confidence, trust, and preference of the Army within the Hispanic community”—aimed the recruiter’s message at Latin@ youth. The Marine Corps, the service branch of choice for young Latino men and women, waged especially effective campaigns. By 2006, the Marine JROTC program (MCJROTC) had established over 250 units in high schools across the country, and the “Young Marines” initiative offered “character
46
JORGE MARISCAL
building” for boys and girls between the ages of eight and eighteen. On some school grounds, air rifle ranges were installed for JROTC weapons training. In 2007, the Army launched its “Leaders Among Us” (LAU) program to specifically target Latin@ youth. With events taking place at select universities in key Hispanic recruiting markets (Los Angeles, San Antonio, and Miami), the program pitched military service through video games, music, and motivational speakers. At one LAU event at California State University, Fullerton, student groups protested the targeting of Latin@s and attempted to stop the activities. In 2002, a program called the Broad Superintendents Academy began offering a ten-month management program to train former military officers as top-ranking administrators in public school systems, especially in urban areas. Half of the Academy’s 2007 graduating class was made up of former senior military officers. Many of these school officials would become de facto recruiters in inner-city school systems. Women and Military Service As the role of women in the military expanded during the 1990s, more Latina women joined the ranks of not only the active duty services, but also, of JROTC units in high schools across the country. For working-class women and women of color, the military was viewed as a site that offered them a feeling of “empowerment” that was lacking in their private lives and domestic situations. The reality of military life, however, was that a large majority of all women on active duty and in the service academies such as West Point experienced some form of sexual harassment ranging from inappropriate remarks to rape. According to a 1995 Department of Defense survey of active duty women, 78 percent experienced “military sexual trauma.”9 In 2008 it was reported that the number of reported cases of sexual assault had increased by 9 percent over the previous year. Given that thousands of other cases go unreported, the Democrat Congresswoman Jane Harman (California) told the Washington Post: “Military women are more likely to be raped by a fellow soldier than killed by enemy fire in Iraq.”10 In the first six years of the U.S. occupation of Iraq, 104 women serving in the U.S. military lost their lives. Approximately seventeen of those women were Latinas, which means that the death rate of Latina women was higher than that of Latinos in the military (approximately 13 percent in 2009). Among the first women soldiers lost was the Mexican citizen Ana Laura Esparza Gutiérrez. A green card soldier who had come to the United States with her family from Monterrey, Mexico, when she was seven, Esparza joined the army in 2002 so she could receive money to attend the
LATIN@S IN THE U.S. MILITARY
47
University of Houston. Her dream was to become a psychologist and buy her parents a bigger home. According to her father, the military officers sent to notify the family of their daughter’s death did not speak Spanish. Ana Laura’s parents do not speak English. An improvised explosive device had destroyed her vehicle on October 1. She was twenty-one years old. In 2007 Army Captain Maria Ortiz, who was born in New Jersey but raised in Puerto Rico, died during a mortar attack in Baghdad. The forty-year-old Ortiz was the first nurse to die in combat since the U.S. war in Vietnam. By the first decade of the twenty-first century, a small number of Latinas held high profile positions throughout the military. In 2006, for example, the Marine Corps officer Angela (Angie) Salinas became the first Latina to achieve the rank of brigadier general. A native of Alice, Texas, Salinas enlisted in 1974 and soon after was selected for a special officer–training program. Many of the best-known successes are “Horatio Alger” stories like those of Salinas and Lieutenant General Ricardo Sánchez who commanded coalition forces during the first year of the U.S. occupation of Iraq. Contradictions and Moral Dilemmas Rick Sánchez, as he was known while he was growing up, spent his childhood two miles from the Mexican border in Rio Grande City in Starr County, Texas, one of the poorest counties in the nation. The son of a singleparent family, his uneducated mother once made him spend the day picking cotton as she had done so that he would learn the value of hard work. In a 2003 interview with Hispanic magazine, Sánchez asserted: “When I became a soldier the ethics and the value system of the military profession fit almost perfectly with my own heritage. It made it very easy for me to adapt to the military value system.”11 Several months later, revelations about Sánchez’s role in the abuse and torture of prisoners at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq raised serious doubts about Sánchez’s understanding of the values of his “heritage.” More importantly, they forced a rethinking of the costs of military culture in which morally questionable orders from superiors must be followed at any cost. Although he had been scheduled for promotion, Sánchez’s name continued to surface during the investigation of misconduct by U.S. troops in Iraq. He quietly retired from the Army in 2006. One of the more interesting developments early in the U.S. occupation of Iraq was the appearance of Latin@ war resisters and conscientious objectors within the U.S. military. Soldiers such as Camilo Mejía, Agustín Aguayo, and Aiden Delgado (of Nicaraguan, Mexican, and Cuban ancestry respectively) served in Iraq but subsequently spoke out against the war. Because he refused to redeploy to Iraq, Mejía spent nine months in prison and later wrote: “On those occasions when I destroyed human life in failing
48
JORGE MARISCAL
to refuse my orders, I also failed myself, my soldiers, the Iraqi people, and humanity. I should have resisted my orders, and I should have fought for the dignity and preservation of life.”12 In the civilian sector, the movement against militarism generated a robust counterrecruitment campaign across the country in which Latin@ activists challenged the presence of military recruiters in public schools. Such actions were particularly strong in Puerto Rico where the battle over Vieques and the status of the island and its population gave rise to organizations such as the Universitarios por la Desmilitarización, the Coalición Ciudadana contra el Militarismo, and Madres contra la Guerra. In San Diego, California, young Latin@s joined with African-American high school students to form the “Education Not Arms” coalition to demand the removal of firing ranges from their schools and the involuntary placement of Latin@ students in JROTC courses. As the militarization of U.S. culture progressed in ways invisible to the general public, the Pentagon and Department of State under President George W. Bush pursued a program of outsourcing many traditional military occupations in theaters of war. In Iraq especially, the role of private contractors increased notably during the long occupation. By 2006, private companies such as Blackwater, Triple Canopy, and Halliburton employed over 150,000 combat and support personnel, many of whom were recruited in Mexico and Latin America. In the summer of 2005, with thousands of Mexican-Americans (as well as hundreds of non-U.S. citizen Mexican nationals) fighting and dying in Iraq, the so-called Minutemen hunted Mexican workers along the border and harassed them in locations as diverse as southern California and eastern Tennessee. Hiding behind the issue of illegal immigration and tacitly supported by politicians like Arnold Schwarzenegger, the California governor, the Minutemen join the long line of racist vigilantes who pockmark U.S. history. As the veteran Charley Trujillo, the author of the first oral history collection of Chicano Vietnam veterans, puts it in his documentary Soldados: Chicanos in Viet Nam: “They call us Americans when they need us for a war. The rest of the time we’re just Mexicans.”13 Such racist residue has the potential to taint the historical record because of the propensity of mainstream academics and filmmakers to either consciously or unconsciously erase the contributions of Latino servicemen and women from official accounts of U.S. wars. The most egregious example of this embedded bias was the Ken Burns film The War, the original version of which contained not a single Latin@ despite the fact that almost half a million Latin@s served in World War II.14 The fact that the Public Broadcasting System sponsored and promoted the Burns film with public monies made the omission even more offensive and throughout 2007 Latin@ groups battled with the network. Burns finally agreed to add footage of two Latino veterans.
LATIN@S IN THE U.S. MILITARY
49
Conclusion Despite the continuing paradox faced by U.S. Latin@s who serve only to be treated upon their return as “foreigners,” thousands of new immigrants continue to believe that the “American Dream” can only be achieved through military service. The Pentagon and recruiters will exploit ideological traps like “gratitude to my new country” and “machismo” to draw Latin@ youth into the ranks of U.S. forces as the wars of the twenty-first century loom in the distance. The narrative of Latin@ military service is inescapably structured along a series of parallel and often contradictory tracks—on the one hand, the desire to recognize the valor and sacrifice of our elders who have served and on the other hand, the recognition that so many of our youth have been drawn to military service because of a lack of educational and economic opportunity; on the one hand, the pride born of a deeply felt patriotism that transcends past and current injustices and on the other hand, the knowledge that America’s wars have too often had little to do with national defense and a great deal to do with the kind of imperial hubris that informed the earliest U.S. contacts with Spanishspeaking peoples. Notes 1. Naomi Quiñonez, “Rosita the Riveter,” in Mexican Americans and World War II, ed. Rivas Rodriguez (Austin: University of Texas Press, 2005), 249. 2. Army Times, “N.M. Guard Unit Alleges Racial Profiling,” Associated Press, April 24, 2007. 3. Defense Human Resources Activity 2008; and Beth Asch, Christopher Buck, Meridith Kleykamp, Jacob Alex Klerman, and David Loughran, Military Enlistment of Hispanic Youth: Obstacles and Opportunities (Santa Monica, CA: RAND National Defense Research Institute, 2009), xv. 4. Prepared Statement of The Honorable S. C. Chu, July 10, 2006, http://armedservices.senate.gov/statemnt/2006/July/Chu%2007-10-06.pdf, accessed on July 17, 2009. 5. Armed Forces Equal Opportunity Survey (Arlington: Defense Manpower Data Center, 1997). 6. Army Times, “N.M. Guard Unit Alleges Racial Profiling,” Associated Press, April 24, 2007. 7. “Junior Reserve Officers’ Training Corps: Contributing to America’s Communities,” Washington, DC: Center for Strategic and International Studies, 1997. 8. Linda D. Kozaryn, Help Wanted: DoD Seeks JROTC Instructors, Department of Defense, American Forces Information Service, 2001, http://www.defense. gov/news/newsarticle.aspx?id=44939, accessed on January 6, 2010.
50
JORGE MARISCAL
9. Amy Street and Jane Stafford, Military Sexual Trauma: Issues in Caring for Veterans, in Iraq War Clinician Guide (U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs: National Center for PTSD, 2004), 66–69. 10. Anne Gearan, “Military Rape Reports Rise, Prosecution Still Low,” Washington Post, March 17, 2009. 11. Mark Holston, “Soldier of Fortune,” Hispanic Magazine (2003): 10–12. 12. Camilo Mejía, Road from Ar Ramadi: The Private Rebellion of Staff Sergeant Mejía (New York: New Press, 2007), 299. 13. The documentary film Soldados directed by Charely Trujillo and Sonya Rhee was aired on PBS in 2003 and followed the publication of Trujillo’s Soldados: Chicanos in Vietnam (San Jose, CA: Chusma House Publications, 1991). 14. The War, directed and produced by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick, written by Geoffrey C. Ward (Boston: Florentine Films and WETA-TV, 2007), film.
4
The “Swirl” Migration of Mexican-Origin Students: A Cross-Border Analysis Using the Mexican and U.S. Censuses Stella M. Flores and Germán Treviño
Introduction surge in Latin American migration to the United States since the 1990s has led to an impressive increase in immigration research, using both original data and data collected by national governmental agencies.1 Data from the U.S. Census Bureau have been especially critical in understanding patterns of migration to the United States over time.2 Other datasets, such as those used by Feliciano,3 expand the field of migration and educational attainment research by presenting premigration characteristics of individuals by country of origin, thus illustrating differences in the social and human capital of migrant families arriving in the United States. These studies and others have made important contributions to the study of migration and educational attainment for the United States. The study of Mexico, however, continues to dominate this area of research due to the large number of both documented and undocumented migrants from that country, its proximity to the United States, and the growing literature on participation in the labor force as a primary reason for migration. A phenomenon more recently documented, although not new in occurrence, is the return of migrants to their country of origin. Migration
A
52
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
to the United States, followed by a return to the country of origin, and subsequent reentry to the United States is another pattern that is even more difficult to capture than a single-direction migration path from one country to another. We label these phenomena “swirl” migration and attempt to document this pattern through existing government databases in the United States and Mexico. Such efforts to capture a “swirling” pattern of migration are expectedly complicated, however, and require multiple datasets from the countries involved. That is, representative information both from the country of origin of migrating individuals and from the country entered is the most desirable form of data to use for constructing these multidirectional migration patterns. Our aim is to understand multidirectional migration patterns between Mexico and the United States and the effects this movement might have on the educational status of school-age children who are participants in these migration pathways. We employ the national census questionnaires from both countries: Mexico’s Sampling Measure of the XII General Census of Household and Population 2000 and the 2000 U.S. Decennial Census. Using a common and specific window of time (1995–2000) that documents the place of residence of census respondents in Mexico and the United States, we evaluate the migration (to and from the United States and in some cases back to the original area of residence) patterns by state, in both countries, of Mexican-origin individuals. Our study is particularly original in that it offers a cross-national analysis of migration patterns involving these two countries for adults and school-age children. We also employ Geographic Information Systems (GIS) mapping to visually explore the migration patterns of the states in both countries that are most likely to send, receive, and reincorporate Mexican-origin migrants. The mapping provides a visual overview of these “swirling” patterns over time and creates a snapshot of human movement that helps to identify the new areas of activity and need that are shaping the social environments of the areas in question. Such changes have strong implications for the education systems and labor forces in these areas of the United States and Mexico.
Research Questions The purpose of this study is to illuminate multidirectional migration patterns or “swirl migration” between Mexico and the United States between 1995 and 2000, with a particular examination of the educational conditions and factors encountered by school-aged migrant children.
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
53
In exploring the hypothesis of “swirl migration” activity during this period, we were guided by the following questions: 1. What were the migration patterns of children under the age of eighteen between the United States and Mexico from 1995 to 2000? 2. Where in the United States did the flow of Mexican-born migrants go starting in 1995? What were the patterns of return and reincorporation into Mexico, if any? 3. Are there differences in the demographics of the U.S. states receiving and returning the highest percentage of Mexican-born migrants from 1995 to 2000? We provide a brief theoretical framework to address these questions, followed by a description of our methods for matching and corroborating data from both national censuses. We then provide results on migration patterns in the states that send, receive, and reincorporate migrant families and their school-age children. Finally, we present a summary of our major findings and the implications of those findings, and call for further research in the area of transnational, database-driven comparisons of migration activities in relation to educational outcomes. Theoretical Motivation We evaluated “swirl migration” activity at the turn of the twenty-first century, using a framework of migration-specific social and human capital theories expounded by Massey and Espinosa,4 who find that the fundamental forces behind Mexican migration to the United States are the formation of social capital and human capital, and the opportunity for market diversification in the form of economic development activities that result from migration to new locations. Social capital in a migration context is accumulated with each act of migration, thereby creating the conditions that facilitate and sustain additional migration activity,5 especially among individuals who are related to migrants. Human capital, which is represented in the knowledge, skills, and labor market experience gained as a result of migration, also leads to additional migration. Within this framework, once a person migrates, the odds of their migrating again will be even higher. Finally, in regard to market diversification as a motive for migration, we build on the work of Wortham, Hamann, and Murillo,6 who describe the states most recently receiving large numbers of Mexican migrants—located primarily in the U.S. South and the Northeast—as the “new Latino diaspora.” We utilize theories on this diaspora and the new Latino demographics to identify
54
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
locations where Mexican-origin individuals entered the United States in the late 1990s. In sum, we apply these migration data and the Mexico-specific framework to the multidirectional migration movement of Mexican-born migrants and their school-age children between the United States and Mexico during the specified time period. Methods This study utilizes the 2000 censuses of Mexico and the United States. The Mexican Census incorporates survey data from both the basic and expanded questionnaires at the individual and state levels of analyses. The U.S. Census data used are from Summary File 4, which has disaggregated data on the country of origin for Hispanic groups in the United States; this allows us to focus specifically on the Mexican-origin population. This level of detail regarding the country of origin is needed to accurately compare Mexican-origin residents in the United States to Mexican citizens surveyed by the Mexican Census. Nonetheless, some data limitations remain. While the Mexican Census provides data at the individual level of analysis for all ages in the survey, individual-level data for school-age students from the U.S. Census, using similar sampling and timeframes, were not readily available. Individual-level data are available for respondents aged sixteen and older, using the U.S. Current Population Survey. However, this older age range is not the only or primary focus of our analysis. To answer our research questions, we employ U.S. Census data on school-age students (aged five to eighteen) by using the state as the primary level of analysis. We analyze the data by country and by the states within each country. These include fifty U.S. states and thirty-one Mexican states, including the federal district. We provide a trend analysis of various factors over time, using both the Mexican and U.S. censuses. Finally, we use GIS mapping techniques, as described earlier, to visually evaluate migration activity for individuals by age and citizenship status for both the United States and Mexico. Results Mexico: The traditional and new migrant-sending states We introduce GIS mapping to illustrate migration patterns most effectively, as it helps to identify the particular regions in Mexico and the United States that are sending and absorbing migration, broken down on the basis of individual states. For example, the Mexican census data allow us to examine, by household, the Mexican states that sent the highest
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
55
percentage of migrating adults and children to the United States between 1995 and 2000, as well as the Mexican states that reincorporated these migrant families into Mexico’s public and economic institutions. Mexican census data show that the states with the largest percentage of households that had at least one member migrating to the United States between 1995 and 2000 are Zacatecas, Michoacán, and Guanajuato.7 In these states, between 10 percent and 12 percent of households had a member who migrated to the United States between 1995 and 2000; this is considerably above the Mexican national average of 4.14 percent. Other states experiencing high rates of migration to the United States can be seen in Figure 4.1. Since migration between Mexico and the United States is often primarily motivated by economic factors, most of the existing research in the Mexican context focuses on adult migration. There is less research on school-age children who migrate to the United States, either to reunite with their families already there or to stay with their migrating parents. According to these data, the number of children that migrated to the United States during this time period is considerable. Of the total migrating population, 24 percent (approximately 354,996 migrants) were children of primary-, middle-, and high-school age, and thus eligible for mandatory education in the United States. Twenty-two percent of them (about 84,000) were between the ages of six and fifteen.
Figure 4.1 Mexican states with the highest percentage of households with a member migrating to the United States, 1995–2000 Source: Censo General de Población y Vivienda, México (2000).
56
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
Figure 4.2 Mexican states with the highest percentage of children aged six to fifteen migrating to the United States, 1995 and 2000 Source: Censo General de Población y Vivienda, México (2000).
Figure 4.2 shows the states from which the majority of school-age children migrated to the United States. These states include Michoacán (11.96 percent), Jalisco (10.86 percent), Oaxaca (7.68 percent), Guanajuato (7.42 percent), and Puebla (7.26 percent). Together these states account for 45 percent of school-age child migration. States with lower percentages, although still significant numbers, are Guerrero, Nuevo León, Chihuahua, and San Luis Potosi. It was also important to consider not only the states where the migrants were coming from, but also the demographic characteristics, such as size, of their specific communities. Mexican migration to the United States has been a rural phenomenon, with about 80 percent of migrating children coming from small cities in rural areas. An important percentage of these children come from the rural areas of Oaxaca (10.2 percent) and Puebla (8.7 percent). These are states with high concentrations of indigenous people who were not considered traditional migrants in the past. Figure 4.3 details the migration of children by the size of the sending locality between 1995 and 2000. The rural origins of most migrant children might be a relevant indication of their educational profile. Previous research documents that children attending rural and indigenous schools are clearly at an academic disadvantage in Mexico.8 These trends suggest that migrating
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
57
Figure 4.3 School-age migrants by the size of locality of origin Source: Censo General de Poblacion y Vivienda, Mexico (2000).
children already have a lower than average academic performance and are in need of more educational help even before they arrive at their U.S. destinations. The data also indicate that the geographic origin of school-age child migration is not static, and has been getting more complex since the mid1990s. Over the last five years, we have seen a considerable percentage of migrants coming from medium and large cities. For example, about 11 percent of school-age children migrate from cities with 100,000 inhabitants or more; 18.3 percent of children migrating from the largest cities come from the state of Nuevo León and from Mexico City, areas with greater than average educational resources. These trends suggest that the educational background of children migrating to the United States in the twenty-first century might be changing. The timing of when Mexican families migrate to the United States, as well as of their reincorporation back into Mexico, is also a critical factor to consider in examining the effects of migration on each country’s school systems. An important issue identified in this research is that the migration of school-age children often does not coincide with the U.S. school-year calendar. Various U.S. school districts thus have to incorporate immigrant children at different times during the academic year. As seen in Figure 4.4, 27 percent of the Mexican children migrated in the first three months of the year. There is a spike in the number of migrants that arrived in the United States in March (10.4 percent) and in August (9.2 percent). The remainder of the respondents migrated in almost equal numbers
58
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
Figure 4.4 Migration of school-age children to the United States, by month
during the remaining months of the year. One hypothesis is that the peak of migration in March and August could be associated with the spring and the summer school breaks in Mexico, although the difference from the other months is not particularly large. Any policy aimed at incorporating Mexican migrant children into U.S. schools—as noted by López, Romo, and Salinas and Fránquiz—should take the seasonality of immigration into account.9 The United States: Traditional and new migrant-receiving states With these migration patterns in mind, we now examine Mexican migration to the United States from 1990 to 2000, more specifically from 1995. Using data from the 2000 U.S. Census, we investigate where in the United States these Mexican-born migrants were residing at the time the Census was taken. The data show, for example, which U.S. states are receiving this immigrant group both in raw numbers and as an increasing share of the population. For example, it is not surprising to see continued migration to states with traditionally high rates, such as California, Texas, Florida, and Illinois. However, states in the South that have less such history appear to be experiencing an unprecedented increase in their share of Mexican migrants. Of interest are the U.S. states that continue to experience migration activity and are experiencing the starkest transitions in their educational, political, and economic infrastructure as a result of changes in their share of migration activity.
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
59
The greatest change in the migration patterns of the Mexican-born population in the United States post-1995, and to a certain extent since 1990, is in the increased number of these migrants in the southeastern and northeastern regions of the United States. The movement of Spanish-speaking migrants into the Northeast is not a new phenomenon; for some time this region has had a Spanish-speaking immigrant population that includes Puerto Ricans, Dominicans, and some South American groups.10 New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, for example, are other states familiar with Spanish-speaking populations in the educational and political realms. However, these states have never before experienced a large influx of Mexican migrants, a group with cultural and historical characteristics that are distinct from those of their Latin American and Caribbean counterparts.11 The states that have experienced the most notable “shock” or change in the incorporation of a Mexican-born population are in the Southeast. Historically, this area has served a primarily black and white population, and its educational, political, and economic infrastructure is still adjusting to this rupture in the traditional racial dichotomy.12 For example, while issues of racial segregation in southern schools remain contentious fifty years after Brown v. Board of Education (1954), the landmark Supreme Court decision that outlawed this type of segregation in schools as an acceptable practice, schools in the South are now also dealing with a new minority population that is both racially and linguistically different from the predominantly
Figure 4.5 Total Mexican-born migrant population in the United States, 2000
60
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
English-speaking student body in these areas. The data presented below on Mexican-born migrant students in the United States, and specifically in these traditionally non-Mexican areas, illuminate the gravity of the adjustments these states must make to accommodate new migration. Moreover, it quantitatively confirms once again that there truly is a new Latino diaspora—a phenomenon documented by recent research.13 U.S. census data from 2000 indicate that the states with the largest Mexican-born populations are California (CA), Texas (TX), Arizona (AZ), and Illinois (IL), states that historically have had the largest number of immigrant and U.S.-born individuals of Mexican origin (Figure 4.5). However, by 2000, states that traditionally have not had a Mexican-born population joined those with the largest. These newcomers included Washington and Oregon, which have served a seasonal migrant population, southeastern states such as Florida, Georgia, and North Carolina, and New York in the Northeast. The data in Figure 4.6 show that in absolute numbers, almost all of the states with the highest number of foreign-born residents before 1995 are also the states with the most recent Mexican migrants to the United States after 1995 (California, Texas, Illinois, and Arizona). However, states in the Southeast and the Midwest show increasing numbers of Mexican-born residents who were not present before 1995.
Figure 4.6 States with the highest number of Mexican-born residents not in the United States in 1995
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
61
After 1995, the areas experiencing significant increases in the schoolage Mexican-born migrant population expanded beyond the Southwest. Figure 4.7 shows this dramatic shift in the states that had the highest percentage of the Mexican-born school-age population as a percentage of the total Mexican-origin population in the state by 2000. In this category, several southeastern states and two in the Northeast—North Carolina, Tennessee, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Arkansas, Kentucky, New Jersey, and Connecticut—shared the distinction of having the highest percentage of Mexican-born children under the age of eighteen in 2000. Other states in the Northeast (New York and Pennsylvania) and several midwestern states also showed a relatively higher percentage of Mexican-origin migrants than in 1995. The citizenship status of school-age children is another key factor in understanding the educational trajectories of these students in U.S. schools. A number of Mexican-born individuals live in households where family members have varied citizenship status. The educational options of migrating students who stay in the United States and those who return to Mexico may be predicted in part by the citizenship status they are able or not able to attain while in the United States. To link data on school-age Mexican children who came to the United States after 1995 to data from the 2000 U.S. Census, we examine states where noncitizen Mexican-origin
Figure 4.7 States with the highest percentage of Mexican-born children under eighteen years of age, 2000
62
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
Figure 4.8 States with the highest percentage of noncitizen Mexican-born children under eighteen years of age, 2000
children who were under the age of eighteen in 2000 represent the highest percentage of the state’s Mexican-origin population. Looking more closely at Mexican-born school-age children who are not citizens, we see an even more extensive territory of educational transition for families and students with higher odds of having uncertain citizenship status.14 Figure 4.8 shows that states in the Southeast have the greatest percentage (20–34 percent of all Mexican-origin individuals in those states) of the Mexican-born school-age population that are noncitizens. Additionally, a large number of states throughout the United States have a Mexican-origin population with approximately 14 percent to 20 percent of them being foreign-born noncitizens. Opportunities in higher education for students in this population who do graduate high school are limited; of the states newly receiving this high percentage of noncitizen school-age children, only New York and Utah have legislation that allows undocumented high-school graduates to attend college at in-state resident tuition rates.15 Comparison of selected characteristics of U.S. migration states While the change in migration activity throughout the United States is considerably more dramatic in some states than others, the demographic
Table 4.1a
New Mexican-origin migration states, 2000
State
North Carolina Georgia New Jersey New York Delaware South Carolina Tennessee Connecticut Arkansas Alabama
Pct foreign-born
77.59 75.76 73.35 71.04 70.16 65.97 63.53 60.47 59.72 58.81
Total Pct Non-U.S. Pct year of foreign-born residence in entry 1990 to 1995 March 2000 by m-o 185,890 205,083 74,434 177,755 8,497 33,635 47,995 14,074 36,032 24,795
Source: Authors’ calculations; 2000 U.S. Census.
35.47 33.15 25.49 19.35 25.92 33.14 30.43 24.41 21.74 24.00
80.41 77.47 73.16 66.48 72.86 81.12 76.84 70.24 67.25 74.87
Pct male
63.41 63.42 58.62 57.47 56.95 64.86 62.75 58.92 57.91 59.24
Pct foreign-born under 18 35.34 33.83 29.15 25.76 30.94 28.35 24.93 22.69 25.49 22.83
Total Pct school age foreign-born (5–17 yrs) under 18 27,181 29,589 9,519 21,432 1,416 4,358 6,038 1,640 5,874 3,428
19.13 19.88 20.12 21.30 23.37 18.55 19.54 19.86 24.14 22.66
Pct m-o male ages 5–17 enrolled in school
Pct m-o female ages 5–17 enrolled in school
73.77 76.38 69.20 69.55 73.68 79.84 75.46 62.73 78.03 75.69
77.60 79.76 73.20 70.23 77.65 72.80 73.63 64.92 79.89 76.01
64
State
California Texas Illinois Arizona Colorado Florida New Mexico Nevada
Traditional Mexican-origin migration states, 2000 Pct Total Pct Non-US Pct year of entry foreign-born foreign-born residence 1990 to March in 1995 2000 by m-o 47.53 37.59 57.75 41.96 40.86 57.23 31.14 56.54
4,087,992 1,947,068 666,726 454,614 187,502 204,940 106,279 164,445
Source: Authors’ calculations; 2000 U.S. Census.
6.91 7.92 11.86 10.62 14.06 17.32 5.42 13.34
39.38 46.64 49.28 54.18 65.59 61.47 39.95 53.45
Pct male
51.68 51.21 53.70 51.81 54.51 58.64 51.17 54.39
Pct Foreign-born Pct school-age under 18 total (5–17 yrs) foreign-born under 18 14.43 12.84 18.23 16.84 18.20 21.02 11.64 20.04
471,346 238,553 77,768 70,057 30,181 26,522 14,286 22,436
26.81 25.20 24.95 26.55 24.64 23.64 25.98 25.70
Pct male ages 5–17 enrolled in school
Pct female ages 5–17 enrolled in school
74.57 73.76 74.29 75.94 76.35 75.56 74.66 80.24
71.68 77.55 73.05 75.61 75.87 75.16 71.81 79.28
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
Table 4.1b
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
65
portrait of the Mexican-origin population (both U.S.-born and foreignborn) also differs significantly in the following categories: percentage with foreign-born status, entry into the United States after 1995, gender, and percentage of school-age children as a share of the Mexican-origin population by state. Table 4.1 shows that many of the “new” migration states (Table 4.1a) have a share of Mexican-born individuals as a percentage of their Mexican-origin population that is greater by 20 percentage points or more than in the traditional migration states of California and Texas (Table 4.1b). In addition, the number of individuals of Mexican origin in the new migration states who were not in the United States in 1995 is much higher than for their counterparts in the traditional migration states; this is true to an even greater extent for those who have entered the United States since 1990. These new migration states also have a much higher percentage of male migrants and a lower percentage of children of school age than the traditional migration states. This pattern is characteristic of areas experiencing recent migration, where men are usually the first in their household to migrate, bringing partners and children to join them later in the migration process.16 Among children of Mexican origin aged five to seventeen who were enrolled in U.S. schools, the data do not seem to show stark differences by gender. “Swirl migration”: Return and reincorporation to and from Mexico Approximately one million Mexican households (around one percent) experience the phenomenon we identify as “swirl migration.” For this analysis, we define a “swirl migrant” as a person who migrated to the United States between 1995 and 2000 and returned to live in Mexico within the same window of time, a period explicitly documented in the 2000 Mexican Census survey. Migration, therefore, is not a one-way phenomenon. “Swirl migration” complicates the educational experience of migrant children and poses distinct challenges to both the Mexican and the U.S. education systems. Our data indicate that 10 percent of school-age children who migrated to the United States between 1995 and 2000—about 39,000 students—returned to Mexico within the same window of time. This means that the children in this group faced not only the challenge of incorporating into new schools in the United States, but also of reincorporating back into the schools of their homeland. In some cases, as will be presented later in this analysis, they also had to adjust to a new area of Mexico before migrating to the United States. The size of the “swirl migration” has recently been increasing. Figure 4.9 shows that approximately 86 percent of the children who returned to
66
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
Figure 4.9 School-age “swirl” migrants’ return to Mexico, by year
Mexico from the United States did so in 1998 and 1999. This increasing trend of children returning to Mexico signals the growing importance of Mexican children’s ability to readapt to schools in their homeland after having migrated to the United States. Where in Mexico these children return to after migrating to the United States is also worth noting. The Mexican states that receive the largest percentage of returning school-age migrants are Jalisco (14.8 percent), Nuevo León (11.4 percent), Michoacán (10.7 percent), Chihuahua (8.4 percent), Zacatecas (5.9 percent), Distrito Federal (5.23 percent), and the State of Mexico (5 percent). A significant finding of this research is that the states reincorporating migrants differ from those sending them. Some states receive a larger share of returning migrants than they originally send. Chihuahua, for example, accounts for only 3 percent of Mexican migration to the United States but receives more than 6 percent of all returning migrants. One possible explanation is that Chihuahua is a border state and might serve as a buffer or transition area for future migration. Nevertheless, this trend indicates that schools in Chihuahua receive and integrate children from other parts of Mexico. Another interesting case is Nuevo León, which is now a primary reincorporation state although it is not a major sending state. These findings call for future research on the effects of this reincorporation of migrants into local governments and school systems in Mexico. Another interesting finding is that although migration is still predominantly a rural phenomenon, a larger percentage of “swirl migrants” return
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
Table 4.2
67
Point of origin and destiny of migrant populations by size of locality
Size of Locality Fewer than 2,500 inhabitants 2,5000 to 14,999 inhabitants 15,000 to 19,999 inhabitants 20,000 to 49,999 inhabitants 50,000 to 99,999 inhabitants 100,000 to 499,999 inhabitants 500,000 inhabitants and more
Percentage of Migrants
Percentage of Returning Migrants
61.3 19.7 1.3 4.1 2.5 5.1 6.0
50.9 18.4 1.3 4.8 3.5 8.9 12.1
Source: Censo General de Poblacion y Vivienda, Mexico (2000).
Figure 4.10 Return of school-age children to Mexico, by month
to cities than leave them. Table 4.2 shows a side-by-side comparison of the sizes of the localities that migrants to the United States leave and return to after migration. The data show that although the majority of children return to rural areas, about a quarter of the “swirl migrants” return to cities of 100,000 inhabitants or more. This phenomenon indicates that the profile of migrants who return from the United States might differ from the profile of all migrants as a group. One hypothesis is that these migrants might be more educated or in a better economic condition to make the transition back to urban areas in Mexico. Another important issue to consider is the timing of return. There is a clear pattern of school-age children returning to Mexico. Figure 4.10 shows that approximately 50 percent of these children return to Mexico in
68
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
the last three months of the year. As one would expect, the return of this age group coincides with the return of adult migrants, again indicating that the nature of “swirl migration” is unrelated to the education cycle. This pattern of return means that from an organizational perspective, schools in Mexico have to reincorporate Mexican students returning from the United States after the educational cycle has already started. From the students’ perspective, they again have to catch up with their peers, this time back in their home country, but not always in the original school system that they attended prior to migration. Conclusion, Implications, and Future Research A summary of the findings from both the Mexican and U.S. national censuses includes the following: ●
●
●
●
●
Mexican school-age child migration to the United States is a growing phenomenon with important educational implications. Approximately 24 percent of migrants are children between four and eighteen years old, and thus eligible for compulsory education in the United States. Migrating children come mainly from rural areas in the states of Michoacán, Jalisco, Oaxaca, Guanajuato, and Puebla, where schools have been documented to have lower than average academic performance. However, an increasing number of migrants are coming from medium and large urban areas. Almost one in five children in this group comes from the states of Nuevo León and México. The number of children identified as “swirl migrants” increased considerably from 1997 to 2000. These transnational students account for approximately 10 percent of all school-age migrant children from Mexico. The number and age of migrants differ in the states that send, receive, and reincorporate them. In addition, states reincorporating migrants differ from states sending migrants. However, current data do not allow the identification of the reasons why children from certain states in Mexico participate in “swirl migration” more than those in others. The timing of migration to the new country and return to the home country is worth considering in any policy aimed at helping migrant children to perform well in school. Movement across the border does not seem appropriately coordinated with the academic year calendars of either the United States or Mexico. These timing issues
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
●
●
69
indicate a severe adjustment not only for the students but also for the national systems that educate them. On the U.S. side, significant implications related to citizenship and educational opportunities must be considered for this particular group of school-age children. States with the highest number of noncitizen children as a percentage of their Mexican-origin migrant population are also states with the least experience in educational programs designed to support these students and their families. Finally, although this is primarily a story of the education of schoolage migrant children, the families that accompany these children in the migration process are an integral part of their educational outcomes. The labor markets in which adults participate are as essential to their children’s educational opportunities as the schools that educate them.
The data show that each side of the U.S.-Mexico border is faced with enormous educational implications for children and their families who engage in the migration process. The “swirl migration” pattern captured by the national censuses of Mexico and the United States illuminates the great need for continued quantitative and qualitative research to investigate these patterns and their effects on the school systems that host migrant children, and the labor markets in which their parents and families participate. Moreover, for families that do stay in the United States, their educational opportunities beyond the K-12 system are limited by their citizenship status. New in-state resident tuition laws that promote greater access to college for undocumented immigrants in Texas, California, and eight other states offer additional educational opportunities to this population. However, the states with the most dramatic surge in noncitizen school-age children do not have such legislation. Finally, the data indicate that children migrating to the United States with their parents are perhaps the most vulnerable and most in need of educational opportunities. The complexities captured by these cross-national databases highlight the need for additional research in the area of transnational comparison of educational and labor outcomes of migrant families and their children. Notes 1. Frank Bean and B.L. Lowell, “Unauthorized Migration,” The New Americans: A Guide to Immigration Since 1965, ed. Mary Waters, Reed Ueda, and Helen Marrow (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007), 70–82; Douglas S. Massey and K. Espinosa, “What’s Driving Mexico-U.S. Migration?
70
2.
3. 4. 5. 6.
7. 8.
9.
10. 11.
STELLA M. FLORES AND GERMÁN TREVIÑO
A Theoretical, Empirical and Policy Analysis,” American Journal of Sociology, 102 (1997): 939–99; Jeffrey S. Passel, Estimates of the Size and Characteristics of the Undocumented Population (Washington, DC: Pew Hispanic Center, 2005), available online at http://pewhispanic.org/reports/report/php?ReportID=44 (retrieved on September 1, 2005); Jeffrey S. Passel, J. Van Hook, and Frank D. Bean, Estimates of Legal and Unauthorized Foreign-Born Population for the United States and Selected States, Based on Census 2000 (Report to the Census Bureau) (Washington, DC: Urban Institute, 2004); Alejandro Portes and Rubén Rumbaut, Immigrant America: A Portrait (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1996); and Marcelo Suárez-Orozco and Mariela M. Páez, eds., Latinos Remaking America (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2002). George J. Borjas and Lawrence F. Katz, “The Evolution of the Mexican-Born Workforce in the United States,” in Mexican Immigration to the United States, ed. George J. Borjas (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2007), 13–55; and David Card and Ethan G. Lewis, “The Diffusion of Mexican Immigrants During the 1990s: Explanations and Impacts,” in Mexican Immigration to the United States, ed. George J. Borjas (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2007), 193–227. Cynthia Feliciano, Unequal Origins: Immigrant Selection and the Education of the Second Generation (New York: LFB Scholarly Publishing, 2006). Douglas Massey and K. Espinosa, “What’s Driving Mexico-US Migration? A Theoretical, Empirical and Policy Analysis,” 939–99. Ibid. Stanton Wortham, Edmund T. Hamann, and Enrique G. Murillo Jr., eds., Education in the New Latino Diaspora: Policy and the Politics of Identity (Westport: Ablex, 2001). Douglas Massey and K. Espinosa, “What’s Driving Mexico-US Migration? A Theoretical, Empirical and Policy Analysis,” 939–99. Germán Treviño and Ernesto Treviño, Factores socioculturales asociados al rendimiento de los alumnos al término de la educación primaria: Un estudio de las desigualdades educativas en México (México: Instituto Nacional de Evaluación, 2004). Gerardo Lopez, Jay D. Scribner, and Kanya Mahitivanichcha, “Redefining Parental Involvement: Lessons from High-Performing Migrant-Impacted Schools,” American Educational Research Journal 38 (2001): 253–88; Harriett D. Romo, “The Newest ‘Outsiders’: Educating Mexican Migrant and Immigrant Youth,” in Children of La Frontera: Binational Efforts to Serve Mexican Migrant and Immigrant Students, ed. Judith L. Flores (Charleston: ERIC Clearinghouse on Rural Education and Small Schools, 1996); and Cinthia Salinas and María Fránquiz, eds., Scholars in the Field: The Challenges of Migrant Education (Washington, DC: AEL, 2004). Alejandro Portes and Rubén Rumbaut, Immigrant America: A Portrait (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1996). Regina Cortina and Mónica Gendreau, eds., Immigrants and Schooling: Mexicans in New York (New York: Center for Migration Studies, 2003).
THE “SWIRL” MIGRATION OF MEXICAN-ORIGIN STUDENTS
71
12. Stanton Wortham, Edmund Hamann, and Enrique Murillo Jr., eds., Education in the New Latino Diaspora. 13. Rakesh Kochhar, Roberto Suro, and Sonya Tafoya, The New Latino South: The Context and Consequences of Rapid Population Growth (Washington, DC: Pew Hispanic Center, 2005), available at http://pewhispanic.org/files/reports/ 50.1.pdf (retrieved on September 15, 2007); and Wortham, Hamann, and Murillo Jr., eds., Education in the New Latino Diaspora. 14. The U.S. Census captures citizenship status only up to the level of “noncitizen.” This category includes both legal resident and undocumented immigrants. 15. Michael Olivas, “IIRIRA, The DREAM Act, and Undocumented College Student Residency,” Journal of College and University Law 30 (2004): 435. 16. Douglas Massey and K. Espinosa, “What’s Driving Mexico-US Migration? A Theoretical, Empirical and Policy Analysis,” 939–99.
This page intentionally left blank
Part II
Popular and Traditional Cultural Expressions
This page intentionally left blank
5
Making, Buying, Selling, and Using the Umbrella: Recognizing the Nuances of Latin@ Popular Culture Patricia Marina Trujillo
ecently, I discovered a T-shirt at the corporate-owned department store Target. The shirt was in the women’s clothing department, salmon-colored and clearly cut for a woman’s body. It had a central image of bright red chile (pepper) proclaiming, “I’m HOT!” I was immediately drawn to the T-shirt and simultaneously repelled. In a store that rarely has culturally relevant or culturally specific items, I knew as a Latina that this T-shirt was made with me in mind. The “hot chile” image made my own thoughts collide. On the one hand, the bright, curvy, and plump chile on the shirt at once evoked within me issues of the mass commodification of my culture and the objectification of Latinas (after all, it is the chile, an object, that is hot and supposed to represent “the” Latina on the shirt— como se dice, or how would one say, “reification?”), and emphasized the common stereotypes of Latinas as fiery, hot-tempered, and overly/overtly Sexualized. On the other hand, as a Latina who is manita (an identity linked geographically to northern New Mexico), the chile is a central image that I identify with culturally. My yearly seasons are planned around the chile harvest, and most cultural events include chile preparation in one way or another (tying ristras, making tamales, packing green chile away for the year in Ziploc bags, and so on). Even though I clearly saw the T-shirt as stereotypical, I was also able to appreciate it with tongue-in-cheek humor. Chiles are hot! They literally spice up the food I eat and as a metaphor they
R
76
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
can be read as culturally symbolic of the passion and orgullo, the pride I feel as a manita. Chiles culturally connect me to my family, our land, and our traditions. I can disconnect culturally from the stereotypical connotations of “hot” and embrace “hot” and “spicy” in nonstereotypical ways that might only be obvious to others who share my cultural heritage. Chiles are symbolic as the central heat (read: a cultural energy) in our lives. Here I was in the store, staring at this shirt. I considered how this shirt was being marketed. There were shirts of similar style all around it. One with a central image of a slice of cherry pie proclaimed, “Sweetie Pie.” Another with a picture of a chick (that is, a baby chicken) in a frying pan said, “Hot chick.” Yet, the “I’m HOT!” chile was the only one I considered buying. It was supposed that I would want to buy it because on multiple levels I connect with this image, and this image is connected with me, positively and negatively. It was supposed that non-Latinas would want to buy chile because it is a conduit to the stereotypical traits that are seen as positive for Latinas. For non-Latinas, putting on the T-shirt is a way to assert that they too are “hot” and “spicy” in a dominant culture with exploitative mores of what constitutes an attractive woman. In the context of the non-Latina wearing the shirt, issues of reification take on an additional layer of objectification. A Latina sporting this shirt (in a nonsubversive way) stereotypes her own identity by proclaiming via the printed message: “I am like a chile. I am hot.” A non-Latina sporting this shirt further problematizes this reification by implicitly proclaiming: “I am like a chile that is hot like a Latina. Therefore, I am hot.” The more I saw that T-shirt, the more I wanted it and the more I felt like a Tía Taco (sell-out) for colluding with the corporate structure that would stereotype me. I picked it up. I put it down. The woes of graduate student shopping in a Latin@ cultural marketplace! This encounter with a Latina “pop” image while shopping is an example of the multiple negotiations that can be made when encountering and interpreting cultural symbols in the mass market and media. In considering Latin@ popular art and culture, we must ask the following questions: Who is creating it? What images and symbols are being employed? How are they interpreted? By whom? For whom? In an increasingly Latin@ United States, hegemonic popular culture will be increasingly influenced by Latin@s art and culture, in this sense, must be taken seriously as an economic and political influence able to inform and change what it means to be “American.” This chapter seeks to provide a prefatory understanding of the various nuances of Latin@ popular and pop culture. Popular culture can be generally defined as some aspect of culture that is accepted and consumed by significant numbers of people, as in the case of Latin@ popular culture. While popular culture can be understood as a cultural
RECOGNIZING THE NUANCES OF LATIN@ POPULAR CULTURE
77
representation created and supported by the populace that is being represented, “pop culture” can be said to be a reified representation that is often used for mass marketing or hegemonic maintenance of conventional stereotypes. Working as an introduction to a vast discourse, the chapter works to map out discursive signposts in the field but in no way claims to identify them all. Rather, in considering the ever-changing nature of Latin@ popular culture, this chapter can be considered an entrance into a complicated, multifaceted, and dynamic field of study. My use of the term “umbrella” in the title and throughout this chapter is a way to keep readers connected to and questioning the concept of a pan-Latino identity. The term “Latin@” is considered an umbrella, or unifying term, to speak about a large group (hundreds of millions) of diverse people from over twenty countries and territories where Romance languages are spoken. Spanish and Portuguese are predominant, but French is also considered in this definition. In addition, indigenous and Creole languages, as well as other world languages, are spoken in Latin America. One of the challenges of writing a broad description of Latin@ popular culture is that Latin@ identity is not indicative of a singular culture with a singular worldview or even similar traditions and customs. Rather, while considering Latin@ popular culture, we must question our terminology from within and without the United States’ mainstream academy. Because of my own position as a Latina and a scholar from the United States, the primary focus of this chapter will be Latin@ popular culture in the United States from the perspective of Latin@s as U.S. ethnic minorities who have been marginalized and underrepresented. However, I want to stress that this is one of many vantage points from which to enter the discussion. As you can imagine, an introductory essay to Latin@ popular culture written by an El Salvadoran writer might be configured much differently. Bear in mind that even though the term “Latin@” is useful for discursive discussions, many people would choose to identify nationally, for example, as Mexicano or Brazileña; or locally as I did earlier in this chapter as manita or Nuevomexicana, and even politically as Chican@ or Boricua, for example. In this chapter I will contextualize the study of Latin@ popular culture and engage in a Latin@-centered study of Latina popular culture, then I will speak to Latin@ community participation in the production of popular culture, and finally I will speak to perspectives that complicate understandings of Latin@ popular culture. Contextualizing Latin@ Popular Arts and Culture For Latina@s who may share a dedication to issues of racialization, class, gender, sexuality, and language, popular culture is an avenue that
78
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
necessarily explores power relationships embedded in such forms of popular expression as theater, film, music, sports, and dance. However, expressions of popular culture can vary from empowering and oppositional, such as the Teatro Campesino (Chican@ street theater of the 1960s and 1970s) and public murals, to blatant appropriations of cultural stereotypes, such as Speedy Gonzalez (a Looney Toons character) and Chiquita Banana.1 As discussed earlier, a distinction in vocabulary is usually made between these two types of cultural production. An understanding of popular culture should include familiarization with the terms high culture, low culture, folk culture, and mass culture. These terms are central to most discussions of popular culture in what is a long, much contested, and continuing sphere of academic inquiry. Historically, high culture is the term used to identify “activities that appeal to an educated and sophisticated audience” that often signals recognition of Western European works of literature, classical music, theater, opera, and artwork housed in museums and privately owned galleries and collections.2 Since education and pecuniary access is necessary for this definition, high culture, thus, is established on an accepted notion of classism and intellectual prejudice that elevates art and artists from particular backgrounds, allowing audience access to a few, and production access to even fewer people. This conceptualization of high culture has been historically accepted as the determinative norm of “highly developed aesthetics.” In contrast, low culture has been defined as activities that tend to appeal to a more general audience whose tastes are considered less refined and sophisticated. Examples of low culture could include sporting events, reality television, and rock and roll concerts. These definitions are based on a hierarchal view of culture, one that generally orders culture according to those who control economic and political power and those who do not. High and low culture can be problematized through the example of Plácido Domingo’s singing of rancheras, or popular Mexican folk songs. Domingo is an international tenor, most celebrated for his singing with José Carreras and Luciano Pavarotti as The Three Tenors. His experience and expertise in the realm of opera place him squarely in the high culture category. However, Domingo has been criticized for his participation in recordings made of popular ranchera songs, such as Feria de las Flores, because of their low-culture origins. On the one hand, Domingo was criticized for recording songs that have low-culture origins, and on the other hand, for taking popular culture productions to the realm of high culture. The designations of high/low culture are constructed along a problematic binary that associates art and aesthetics from a Eurocentric perspective as superior and more refined than non-European art and aesthetics. Thus, cultural productions emerging from Latin@-centered positions are often
RECOGNIZING THE NUANCES OF LATIN@ POPULAR CULTURE
79
rendered as “low” art, or are placed in the realm of folk culture. Folk cultures are the practices of small groups within a larger society; generally, the cultural productions are not widespread throughout the entire cultural group but are limited to traditional geographical locales. Like high/low culture designations, folk culture is a term that can be called problematic, since “folk” is usually a term applied to communities because of their “otherness” in relation to hegemonic culture.3 Mass culture was articulated by the Frankfurt School theorists Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer as culture industries invested in producing cultures that keep the majority of a population accepting specific cultural mores. Culture industries can include television, print media, advertising for mass media, as well as new media such as the Web sites, blogging sites, and social networking interfaces, such as Facebook, MySpace, and the like. Mass culture, in this figuring, is invested in keeping consumers buying products and accepting ideas that make capitalist systems like the United States endure and prosper.4 Likewise, the theorists Louis Althusser and Antonio Gramsci considered popular culture as a form of dominant ideology through which the dominant group controls subordinate groups by making them complicit with hegemony in multiple ways—for example, the Puerto Rican actor Jennifer Lopez’s choice to portray the stereotypical housekeeper in Maid in Manhattan. Many critics of Lopez’s choices in movie roles problematize her success as an actress as dependent on collusion with the stereotyping forces of the hegemonic structure of Hollywood. However, Althusser and Gramsci’s view of mass or popular culture has been criticized by theorists who are not willing to concede that audience members from subordinated groups are only passive, vulnerable, and exploitable.5 John Fiske and Stuart Hall emerged from the Cultural Studies school of thought that defines popular culture as the expression of the interests, the experiences, and the values of common people.6 This definition is inclusive, acknowledging historically silenced or ignored groups as producers of popular culture. As Hall posits, “Popular culture is one of the sites where this struggle for and against a culture of the powerful is engaged: it is also the take to be won or lost in that struggle. It is the arena of consent and resistance.”7 In this paradigm, cultural representation is produced from the bottom up rather than in accordance with the hierarchical model of from the top down. This fundamentally different approach to popular culture not only allows for subordinated people to represent themselves, it also allows for subordinated people to analyze, criticize, and undermine hegemonic cultural constructions. Néstor García-Canclini, the Argentinean/Mexican anthropologist, believes that popular culture also serves the function of “‘re-elaborating’ social structures and inventing new ones.”8 An example of this “bottom up” approach to popular culture can
80
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
be considered in forms of popular Latin dance. Dances such as merengue and salsa emerged from Latin@ communities and have influenced, changed, and been incorporated into the dominant conceptualizations of dance throughout the world. Blurring the theoretical lines of popular culture, Latin@ popular art and culture emerges as a field that can simultaneously be problematic and problematizing. That is to say that there is a whole spectrum of ideological thought that can be identified through popular culture and art. One can see the influence of Latin@ popular culture in many aspects of U. S. culture, in the names of major cities (Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Albuquerque), and in the popularity of Latin@ dance styles and rodeo culture. Popular culture can be problematic when complicit with hegemony to monitor and maintain aesthetic production for the benefit of the dominant society through cultural commodification and capital; take, for example, the recent emergence of the literary sub-genre of “Chica Lit.” Though Chica Lit seeks to forge a space for Latina-centered narratives in the mass-market paperback book trade, many of the texts such as The Dirty Girls Social Club and the forthcoming sequel, Dirty Girls on Top, both by Alisa Rodriguez-Valdes, maintain and exploit problematic stereotypes of Latinas.9 Read as popular culture, the texts reify Latina identity to sell a product.10 However, at the same time, Latin@ popular culture is an empowered articulation by subordinated groups seeking to express collective discontent about prejudicial institutions in the United States. Thus, Latin@ popular culture and identity cannot be separated from issues of class, labor, and political economy—language, nationality, and citizenship. Latin@ popular culture and art represent a politics of self-representation that addresses the need to confront the countenance of the United States and Latin America. It affirms a multilingual and multicultural heritage that necessarily seeks to represent complexities and contradictions that accompany the simultaneous worldviews that accompany mestizaje (mixed race heritage) and La Raza (a synoptic term for Latin@s). Popular culture is simultaneously progressive and problematic. Through the technologies of popular culture, traditional practices are maintained but new practices are constantly emerging to provide avenues for interrogating and reconceptualizing culture. Popular culture concurrently articulates the need to interpret the cultural images and symbols for contemporary usage, while it privileges the need for preserving traditions for posterity, and at times, nostalgia. Often the multiple significances of popular culture emerge on various levels of recognition, as I will interrogate below in discussing the 2007 boxing match between Oscar de la Hoya and Floyd Mayweather.
RECOGNIZING THE NUANCES OF LATIN@ POPULAR CULTURE
81
Making the Umbrella: Community Participation and the Production of Latin@ Popular Culture Of central importance to Latin@ popular culture is the understanding that it is a study of la raza’s (the people’s) creative capacity in all aspects of cultural production: traditional, economic, political, artistic, spiritual, and intellectual. Latin@ popular culture studies problematize previous scholarly models that looked toward Latin@ cultural production as strange, quaint, exotic, or outside of the dominant conceptualization of normativity. Rather, many recent publications and scholarly works have begun to address Latin@ popular culture through “contemporary analytic and interpretive frames [that] challenge prior perceptions and current conceptualizations” of Latin@ culture as an artifact.11 This reframes Latin@ cultural production as epistemological and ontological in and of itself rather than as a production that can be compared to those of the dominant society. In this sense, scholarly work by Latin@s about Latin@ cultural production can be read from multiple perspectives as simultaneously a theoretical and a cultural production. Recent publications of such scholarship includes: Latino/a Popular Culture (2002), edited by Michelle Habell-Pallán and Mary Romero; Velvet Barrios: Popular Culture and Chicana/o Sexualities (2003), edited by Alicia Gaspar de Alba; and Loca Motion: The Travels of Chicana and Latina Popular Culture (2005) by Michelle Habell-Pallán. In the 2004 publication Encyclopedia of Latino Popular Culture, the editors, Cordelia Chávez Candelaria, Arturo J. Aldama, Peter J. Garcia, and Alma Alvarez-Smith, worked to create a reference text that commits textual space to specific entries about creators and creations of Latin@ popular culture. In the introduction, the editors acknowledge the contributions of interdisciplinary scholarship in fields such as women’s studies, African American studies, Chican@ studies, cultural and ethnic studies, and ethnomusicology as the foundation for the framework of the encyclopedia. They assert that interdisciplinary fields since the 1960s have produced a vast reservoir of research, documentary evidence, theoretical approaches, and sources of knowledge that have begun to repair the damaging consequences of neglect, and, even worse, the inaccuracies and distortions of traditional European gazes.12 Drawing from the ethnographic, theoretical, and ideological insights of scholars from interdisciplinary fields was central to the framework of the text because a consequence of the rethinking and concomitant reconceptualizing arising from such vigorous research investigations was the recognition that popular culture—people’s living expressive practices and creative forms—encompasses a wide and heterodox range of mutually influencing and interanimating forms and styles. As a result, the attitudes
82
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
toward popular culture began to shift among scholars and other researchers. Once considered less than and inferior to the evolved and highly stylized patterns of what was once called and understood as elitist “high” culture, popular culture came to be valued for the shaping multiplicity that it, in fact, is—the dynamic, everyday practices and expressive forms that include food, clothing, language, music, dance, religion, literature (print, spoken, digital, and other forms), theater and ritual performance, geographical influences, and art in all its media and performative styles.13 It is from this perspective that Candelaria, Aldama, and others designed the taxonomy for The Encyclopedia of Latino Popular Culture. The twovolume reference thus becomes a valuable tool for those interested in reading on specific contributions and contributors to Latin@ popular culture.14 In efforts to further clarify the types of endeavors that constitute the field of Latin@ popular culture, the table below identifies the subject fields provided by the editors. I have included the table above to make clear the myriad entryways to studying and understanding popular and pop culture in the Latin@ United States. The encyclopedia’s taxonomy is important to consider as it broadly categorizes fields for consideration in Latin@ popular culture. As evidenced through the extensive list, the field spirals out into many realms of influence. Entries in the encyclopedia include actors such as Jessica Alba, the popular Mexican American star of television and film; Table 5.1 List of subject fields from the Encyclopedia of Latino Popular Culture’s “Entries by Subject” Actors and Performers Art Artists Associations and Community-Based Organizations Business and Commerce Crafts and Technology Cultural Centers Dance Ethnicity Fashion and Clothing Film Folklore Food and Cooking Gangs Gender Geography and Place History Holidays and Fiestas
Health Practices Immigration Language Law and Policy Leaders and Legends Literature Museums, Libraries, and Archives Music Musicians and Singers Periodicals and Newspapers Playwrights Politics Publishers Religion Sports Television and Media Theater and Drama Holistic Theory
RECOGNIZING THE NUANCES OF LATIN@ POPULAR CULTURE
83
Andy Garcia, the Cuban American actor and director; Benjamin Bratt, the Peruvian American action star; and Rita Hayworth, the Mexican American actress of classic American film. Along with entries about people involved in various popular culture industries, the encyclopedia also defines the products of traditional, historic, and contemporary Latin@ creativity. The entries range from papel picado (decorative paper garlands) used as decorations at celebrations to celebrations such as Día de los Muertos, Cinco de Mayo, and Quinceañeras. The encyclopedia works to provide as broad a spectrum of popular culture as possible in hopes that “in providing solid, documented information about Latin@ popular culture and heritage, the Encyclopedia of Latino Popular Culture will deepen the substance of conversations throughout the world on culture, (trans)nationalism, and representation, to contribute to a genuine narrative of community.”15 With regard to “making the umbrella,” the above discussion makes clear that Latin@s involved in any of the multiple forms of production are actively making meaning. In the introduction to Latino/a Popular Culture, edited by Michelle Habell-Pallán and Mary Romero, the editors articulate the tensions between the kinds of meaning made inside and outside of the Latin@ communities. They argue, “As emergent signifiers, ‘Latina’ and ‘Latino’ have no fixed definition; historical and social locations create shifting fields of meaning. The power to define these terms is political and economic and plays out symbolically in the imaginative products of the popular culture machine.”16 Thus, the readers or the audience of such imaginative products are left to negotiate the tensions of the meaning(s) that is (are) being made. In a recent boxing match on May 5, 2007, between Oscar de la Hoya and Floyd Mayweather, the producers of the boxing match, de la Hoya’s own company, Golden Boy Promotions, carefully marketed the sporting event as a cultural event17 hosted on Cinco de Mayo.18 Was de la Hoya paying reverence to his own Mexican American heritage by promoting the fight on Cinco de Mayo? Or did the major moneymaking machine that corporate America has made out of Cinco de Mayo influence the marketing choices? On the night of the fight, many nods toward recognizing the significance of the date were made. From Pepe Aguilar, the popular ranchera musician singing the Mexican national anthem and the Puerto Rican musician and singer Marc Anthony performing “The Star Spangled Banner” to Mayweather approaching the ring in a Mexican sombrero, wearing trunks reminiscent of the green, white, and red of the Mexican flag, the cultural underpinnings of the fight were apparent. Very soon after the fight, the economic significance of marketing to a Latin@ audience brought by the careful marketing was also made clear. The revenue for the fight’s HBO Pay-Per-View release generated a record high of $120 million.
84
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
De la Hoya’s purse from the event, regardless of his loss to Mayweather, has been recorded at over $50 million. In what ways can this event be read? Viewing this boxing match as a major event in Latin@ popular culture, Romero and Habell-Pallán inform the reading of this event “as social and artistic phenomena through which major cultural and political debates, conflicts, and social expressions of identity, gender, sexuality, community, and nation are staged and performed.”19 It becomes meaningful that media coverage leading up to the event kept the boxers in a contentious dialogue, not only about the fight, but also about their “tough” backgrounds growing up in their respective Mexican American and African American communities and the ways in which their communities shaped their masculinities. In a Time magazine article “Will the De La Hoya-Mayweather Fight Save Boxing?” Floyd Mayweather is described as a child whose father “taught him how to punch in his stroller,” and it is noted that as an infant Mayweather was used by his father as a human shield in a gun altercation with another family member. De la Hoya is figured as a “softer” man, “bred tough in East L.A. but now a clean-cut corporate sweetheart whose broad, boyish smile has made millions swoon into his corner.”20 In this configuration, the two men are not only prizefighters, they become symbolic of the stereotypical violent roles cast onto Mexican American spaces and African American men in the United States. In the media’s figuring of the fight, de la Hoya, unlike Mayweather, is presented as being domesticated by corporate America. Since the 2000 census, much has been reported in the media about Latin@s “taking over” as the largest U.S. ethnic minority group, whereas this group was historically African American. The ring, in this sense, becomes one of the battlegrounds where this political debate posing a brown man against a black man can play out visually, reinforcing the absence of the dominant white society’s responsibility for the lack of resources they are symbolically fighting over. It also keeps men of color in the realm of violence even though that violence is mitigated through the auspices of a sporting event. That Cinco de Mayo was chosen as the date adds layers of meaning to the fight in that de la Hoya became a symbolic figure of cultural pride to the many Latin@ viewers (particularly Mexicans, Mexican Americans, and Chican@s). To further complicate this reading, even with the split-decision loss of the fight, de la Hoya was actually the economic winner earning $30 million more than Mayweather through his production of the fight, and was projected to be the highest-paid athlete in the United States for 2007.21 This example is laden with opportunities for Latin@ popular culture interpretations. For Romero and Habell-Pallán, “issues of popular culture and the construction of Latina and Latino identity cannot be separated from issues of class, labor, and political economy—language, nationality,
RECOGNIZING THE NUANCES OF LATIN@ POPULAR CULTURE
85
and citizenship.”22 It is clear that a reading of this event is always already invested in language, nationality, and citizenship, from considering the decision to host the event on Cinco de Mayo to the bicultural inclusion of the Mexican national anthem sung in Spanish and the United States’ national anthem sung by a Latino, as well as the simultaneous Pay-Per-View showing on HBO in English and HBO Latino in Spanish. For de la Hoya, this production springs from a long boxing history of Mexican Los Angeles.23 In the first half of the twentieth century, Los Angeles boxing contributed to a sense of belonging among people of Mexican descent in the way flags, anthems, religious icons, geographical boundaries, commonality of language, political structures, and the ideas of a shared culture did.24 Decades later, de la Hoya’s influence as a boxer and promoter poses notions of mere inclusion in a mainstream sport against those of being a leader in producing the sport. Early in his career, de la Hoya “appealed to many corporate sponsors because he was telegenic, family-oriented, and wholesome. His promoters portrayed him as ‘all-American,’ the antithesis of the stereotypical, threatening Mexican masculinity so often represented by the media.”25 Also, as he became more successful, the media often reported on how his community had read him as emasculated for his wholesome persona (i.e., not “macho”) and deracialized him for allegedly colluding with the mores of Anglo American corporate thought when he moved out of East Los Angeles to the more affluent Montebello. However, de la Hoya consistently presented himself as a proud, bicultural man of color through his choice of boxing trunks with the Mexican flag on one side and the U.S. flag on the other, which he consistently wore in his early career. In this sense, the bicultural spectacular of the Cinco de Mayo fight can be read as a reassertion of his racialized masculinity through a negotiation of his role as fighter/performer and as promoter/producer. We must juxtapose de la Hoya with the hypermasculinized Mayweather who could be read as taking the “macho” Mexican pose as he entered the ring. Mayweather’s choice to wear a sombrero and trunks in the colors of the Mexican flag can be understood as purposefully ambiguous. Were they meant to provoke de la Hoya and the Latin@ fans by invoking stereotypical images of media Mexicans? Could they have been an earnest attempt to celebrate Cinco de Mayo? Or could his choice of uniform be read as an attempt to express Anzaldúa’s concept of mestizaje, “or cultural syncretism, in which survival has meant negotiating identities in the borderlands of racial, sexual, and national power?”26 In this sense, we can read de la Hoya and Mayweather as negotiating a ring of historic exploitation in the boxing world and in society in general. Rather than “brown man versus black man,” the visual rhetoric of Mayweather’s entrance suggests
86
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
to the reader that we are to read him as “the stereotypical, threatening Mexican” with whom de la Hoya is referenced in counterdistinction. However, in setting up this problematic binary—“macho” man against soft man—Mayweather immediately begins to dismantle it when he removes the sombrero. Left only with his Mexican flag trunks, reminiscent of de la Hoya’s own bicultural trunks, the removal of the stereotypical sombrero signifies a change in Mayweather’s masculinity. This plays with how we are to read race in this boxing match. Mayweather’s “black”-ness is not erased, rather it is refigured, opening avenues for us to read Mayweather’s identity through a lens of mestizaje, as a man negotiating the borderlands of race, gender, and sexuality. Thus, we can read the two boxers’ performances not as contentious but as collaborative. Historically, there have been complex and meaningful relationships between African Americans and Mexicans in the United States.27 As symbolic of men of color historically pitted against one another to fight for resources—representation, housing, education, health care, etc.—de la Hoya and Mayweather’s fight can remain in this realm of investigation. However, I offer a different reconfiguring—the fight as a collaborative act. In this figuring, the ring becomes a place where both of these men, figured in stereotypes in the mainstream media, can be economically victorious. On the surface they are fighting each other, but they are also renegotiating (i.e., fighting) a system that has historically disenfranchised them as men of color. There are obvious ways to further complicate this reading: How are de la Hoya and Mayweather replicating problematic race, gender, and sex hierarchies? How can this discussion take into account gender and sexuality to include a discussion of how women are or are not involved in the boxing world, specifically, but in sports, generally? And so on. However, with regard to exemplifying the complex nature of reading Latin@ popular culture, the de la Hoya / Mayweather fight provides a rich model for reading the multiple layers of Latin@ cultural production and also for understanding the ways in which Latin@ cultural production is consistently invested in cross-cultural alliances as well.
Using the Umbrella: Complicating Latin@ Cultural Production in a Corporate Age From boxing to hip-hop music to corporate commercials, understanding Latin@ popular culture also means understanding how people are selling, buying, and using the “umbrella” of Latin@ culture. Latin@ cultural expressions are created within and outside Latin@ communities. Oftentimes, particularly in corporate constructions of identity, Latin@
RECOGNIZING THE NUANCES OF LATIN@ POPULAR CULTURE
87
pop images are often invoked to create a sense of inclusion without being rooted in the historical or sociopolitical context in which they were created. An example of this is the 1990s Taco Bell advertising campaign that parodied cultural revolutionary Ernesto “Che” Guevara as a taco-selling Chihuahua. In “Appropriation and Popular Culture,” Arturo J. Aldama and Cordelia Chávez Candelaria explain that implicit in the understanding of appropriation in popular culture studies is the first definition of the word in its strictest sense, which means “to take possession of, without consent and unlawfully.”28 Significantly, the Latin root of “appropriation,” proprius and proprietas, is the same stem form as that of the word “property.” This linguistic context underscores the significance of appropriation in popular culture studies, for a large number of scholars believe that much of American popular culture, possibly even a majority of it, is adapted and appropriated from the creative property and cultural practices of marginalized peoples. Like the concept of colonialism wherein a more powerful country takes over a smaller, more vulnerable country and exploits that nation’s resources, appropriation, in essence, is about dominance and exploitation for profit.29 Contemporarily, it is common to see corporate appropriations of identity as Latin@ populations and economic buying power grow in the United States. In a 2007 Starbucks campaign, the corporate coffee giant advertised its Latin American coffee blends under the slogan “Soy Starbucks. I am Starbucks.” The bilingual advertisements featured Latin@s at all stages of coffee production (as growers of coffee and makers of traditional flavorings like dulce de leche) and as consumers of the coffee. In addition to the print campaign, Starbucks has also started serving food items such as empanadas to create an ambience of inclusivity. Again, these types of appropriations beg scholars of Latin@ popular culture to begin asking questions: Is Starbucks taking advantage of traditional Latin@ foods and methods of food production for profit? How does the corporatization of culture limit the ways in which Latin@ communities can market their own products for profit? Can their selling of Latin@ products mainstream Latin@ culture in positive ways while simultaneously exploiting traditional cultures? How does our reading change when considering how the slogan “Soy Starbucks” is evocative of the slogan “Soy Zapatista”? The Zapatista movement was started by indigenous people in the southern Mexican state of Chiapas to assert their rights to autonomy of culture with full rights to their ancestral lands. The phrase “Soy Zapatista” was popularized by Subcomandante Marcos, the spokesperson for the EZLN, in the early 1990s as an effort to encourage their global audience, reached in large part through the Internet, to identify as Zapatistas to understand how the oppression of indigenous people in Chiapas is connected to the
88
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
oppression of people everywhere. The Zapatistas actively fight neoliberalism and the corporate models (like Starbucks) that benefit from policies like NAFTA that exploit indigenous and poor people. In their efforts toward remaining autonomous, many Chiapanecan communities have started organic farming cooperatives to sell coffee at a fair price to growers. This grassroots movement has put pressure on major buyers, such as Starbucks, to serve only fair-trade coffee. In this context it seems unlikely that the company could claim ignorance of the similarities in slogans. Aldama and Candelaria address this tension by arguing that in a globalized society one could argue that all culture is up for grabs and that when food, music, and clothing corporations launch international campaigns to appropriate ethnic cultures it is a form of corporate acknowledgment. Until it actually means economic success for impoverished communities, however, and until artisans of the community are credited and paid for their labor, the homogenization and selling of ethnic-inspired products will continue to fail to meet the needs of grassroots people and cultures.30 This passage speaks to how appropriation disallows Latin@ communities from participating in many large corporate markets, but it is important to note that Latin@s find a way to participate in other ways. Studying popular culture allows scholars not only to read the mass media models of identity but also to read how communities interpret and refigure those mass media models. In my hometown of Española, New Mexico—a predominantly Chicana/o and American Indian community— a local entrepreneur opened a local coffee shop named Carlbucks.31 The hand-painted signage advertising the shop mimics the corporate logo with the exception of the wording and variations on the central image of a woman drinking coffee in the Starbucks version. In the Carlbucks version, the central image is of an elk’s skull with antlers framing a zia sign (a pueblo Indian four-directions symbol and the central image of the New Mexico flag); stylized lines around the central image mimic the form of the woman from the original Starbucks logo. The zia symbol and the elk’s skull are images of local significance. In particular, the elk’s skull speaks to the large population of hunters in northern New Mexico who commonly travel on Highway 285, the road on which Carlbucks is located. Upon first glance, the viewer is caught off guard by the Carlbucks sign, but it takes no more than a few seconds to realize that the sign is riffing on and simultaneously depending on the recognition of the Starbucks sign to lend credibility to the business or to provide a stark alternative to the corporate coffee business. In her text Chicano Art: Inside and Outside the Master’s House, Alicia Gaspar de Alba cites Tomás Ybarra-Frausto as coining the term rasquachismo, “a uniquely working-class aesthetic of Mexican origin—resourceful, excessive, ironic, and, in its transformation
RECOGNIZING THE NUANCES OF LATIN@ POPULAR CULTURE
89
of utilitarian articles into sacred or aesthetic objects, highly metaphoric.”32 Though Carlbucks cannot necessarily be read as sacred or aesthetic, the term rasquache certainly applies as it transforms a common symbol of mass culture into a resourceful and ironic metaphor for an alternative to corporate consumption. Though Gaspar de Alba is looking specifically at Chicano art, she articulates a paradigm of rasquachismo that is useful for considering the ways in which Latin@s have creative agency over Latin@ popular culture, specifically, but also mass culture, generally. Her model is based on Celeste Olalquiaga’s study of kitsch and religious paraphernalia.33 Gaspar de Alba formulates the three degrees of rasquachismo as such: Like kitsch, rasquachismo comes in at least three flavors noted by Olalquiaga: first-degree rasquachismo, or icons, objects, and practices that are rooted in the oral and popular traditions of Chicano/a culture; second-degree rasquachismo, which is appropriated from its original context by mainstream commercial enterprises such as stores that sell “ethnic” paraphernalia by taking, for example, iconography from Mexican and Chicano culture (such as Popocatépetl/Ixtaccihuatl imagery taken from calendarios, the José Guadalupe Posada calaveras, and reproductions of Frida Kahlo’s work) and appliquéing these images to clothing, mouse pads, coffee mugs, throw rugs, etc., all bearing the business’s own labels; and third-degree rasquachismo that informs the work of Chicano and Chicana artists—writers, musicians, filmmakers, and other producers of culture.34
Carlbucks is articulating third-degree rasquachismo in that it recycles a commodified symbol of coffee consumption that originally exploited the traditional Latin@ food practice of selling coffee. In this figuring, Gaspar de Alba’s model of rasquachismo works to empower Latin@s producing popular culture to gaze back at dominant culture and to question problematic models of appropriation. It provides a model for appropriating the mass images that appropriate Latin@ culture, and highlights the ways in which Latinas/os challenge, produce, and incorporate structures to, in some cases, replicate problematic power structures, and in other cases to revise the power structures more equitably.
Did I Buy the Umbrella?: Trajectories for Further Considering Latin@ Popular Culture It is important to note that as the field of Latin@ popular culture grows, there is a reassertion of la raza constantly defining and redefining itself. As members of our specific communities and as consumers in the capitalist marketplaces found in the United States, Latin@s constantly employ
90
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
differential consciousness models of identity when negotiating popular and pop culture to decide how and in which ways to interact with the multiple processes involved as producers, creators, writers, audience members, and/or consumers. We all negotiate these roles on multiple sites. In Methodology of the Oppressed Chela Sandoval asserts that the differential consciousness model allows identity negotiations from the liminal space between the either/or binaries where subjectivity designated for third-world people of color in the West emerges.35 With regard to Latin@ popular culture, Sandoval’s differential consciousness model allows shifting between and amongst the simultaneous identities that inform and maintain cultural production. From this position, “the practitioners of the differential mode of social movement develop and mobilize identity as political tactic in order to renegotiate power.”36 From this perspective, Latin@s as producers and reproducers of culture are involved in a social movement invested in the politics of representation as power. We are producers and consumers of Latin@ popular culture empowered to maneuver identity formations. As the Latin@ population in the United States booms, more and more companies, universities, and institutions are also being forced to consider their collective identities to include Latin@ perspectives in their practices. This leads us back to the beginning; in the introduction of this chapter you will remember that I was considering buying the “I’m Hot” chile T-shirt at Target. Did I succumb to the culturally produced moment of impulse shopping? Or did I just say no to the product as another gross stereotype of Latinas? I said no. I realized that the T-shirt made me laugh precisely because it failed to represent me. Even though I am rather fond of chiles, on this shirt they were oversimplified symbols of my identity. If I were to buy a T-shirt with chiles on it, the image would have to encompass the more complex nature of chile production, including the land, the water, the sun, and the hands of the people who cultivate it. In much the same way, as a field of exchange, Latin@ popular culture, with all of its dynamics, contradictions, and complexities, offers an exciting opportunity for scholars to interrogate the worlds in which Latin@s live, thrive, change, and create. Notes 1. Michelle Habell-Pallán and Mary Romero, eds., Latino/a Popular Culture (New York: New York University Press, 2002), 2. 2. Charles M. Tatum, Chicano Popular Culture: Que Hable el Pueblo (Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 2001), 3.
RECOGNIZING THE NUANCES OF LATIN@ POPULAR CULTURE
91
3. See John Laudun’s discussion on the use of the term “folk” in his article “Is “Folk” a Four-Letter Word?” in Louisiana Living Traditions. Available at http:// www.louisianafolklife.org/LT/Articles_Essays/folk_is_not.html (accessed on January 11, 2010). 4. T. W. Adorno and Max Horkheimer, Dialectic of Enlightenment, trans. Edmund Jephcott (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2002). 5. See Antonio Gramsci’s Selections from the Prison Notebooks, trans. and ed. Quintin Hoare and Geoffrey Nowell Smith (New York: International Publishers, 1971). Also see Louis Althusser’s Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays (New York: Monthly Review Press, 2001). 6. For more on mass culture, see John Fiske’s Reading the Popular (Boston: Unwin and Hyman, 1989) and Stuart Hall: Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies, ed. Stuart Hall, David Morley, et al. (New York: Routledge, 1996). 7. Stuart Hall, “Notes on Deconstructing ‘The Popular,’” in People’s History and Socialist Theory, ed. Raphael Samuel (Boston: Routledge, 1981), 39. 8. Nestor García-Canclini, Transforming Modernity: Popular Culture in Mexico, trans. L. Lozano (Austin: University of Texas Press, 1993), 10. 9. Alisa Valdes-Rodriguez, The Dirty Girls Social Club (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2003); and Valdes-Rodriguez, Dirty Girls on Top (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2008). For a longer discussion of Valdes-Rodriguez’s Dirty Girls texts, see “Subjective Agency, Global Nuevomexicana Identity, and the Politics of Consumption in the Dirty Girls Social Club, Dirty Girls on Top, and Mother Tongue,” in Patricia Trujillo’s dissertation, Gentefication: A Spatial Rhetorical Analysis of Differential Landscapes in Northern New Mexico Literature and Social Space (diss., University of Texas at San Antonio, 2008, print). 11. Cordelia Chávez Candelaria and Arturo Aldama, et al., eds., Encyclopedia of Latino Popular Culture, vol. A-L and M-Z (Westport: Greenwood Press, 2004), xxv. 12. Ibid., xxiii. 13. Ibid., xxiv–xxv. 14. One note that should be made for usage of the reference is that the editors of the encyclopedia did not clarify the differences between the terms “popular culture” and “pop culture” as described above; therefore, in the encyclopedia these terms are used interchangeably and without nuanced differences between meanings. 15. Cordelia Chávez Candelaria and Arturo Aldama, et al., eds., Encyclopedia of Latino Popular Culture, vol. A-L and M-Z (Westport: Greenwood Press, 2004), xxxi. 16. Michelle Habell-Pallán and Mary Romero, Latino/a Popular Culture (New York: New York University Press, 2002), 2. 17. See “A Real Knockout” by Larry Stewart and Lance Pugmire, Los Angeles Times, May 10, 2007; and “Will the De La Hoya-Mayweather Fight Save Boxing?” by Sean Gregory, Time Magazine Online, April 26, 2007. 18. Though not a federally recognized holiday in the United States or Mexico, the day commemorates an initial victory of Mexican forces led by General Ignacio
92
19. 20.
21. 22. 23.
24. 25. 26. 27.
28.
29. 30. 31.
32. 33. 34. 35. 36.
PATRICIA MARINA TRUJILLO
Zaragoza Seguín over French forces in the Battle of Puebla on May 5, 1862. The date is observed internationally as a celebration of Mexican heritage and pride. Michelle Habell-Pallán and Mary Romero, Latino/a Popular Culture (New York: New York University Press, 2002), 6. Sean Gregory, “Will De La Hoya-Mayweather Fight Save Boxing?” Time Magazine Online, April 26, 2007, http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1615178,00.html (accessed on January 12, 2010). Ibid. Michelle Habell-Pallán and Mary Romero, Latino/a Popular Culture (New York: New York University Press, 2002), 3. Gregory Rodriguez, “Boxing and Masculinity: The History and (Her)Story of Oscar de la Hoya,” in Latino/a Popular Culture, ed. Michelle Habell-Pallán and Mary Romero (New York: New York University Press, 2002), 253. Ibid., 253. Ibid., 254. Gloria Anzaldúa, Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza (San Francisco: Aunt Lute Press, 2002). A traveling exhibition on the issues of Afro-Mexicanidad and African identity in Mexico is currently being exhibited around the country at various cultural arts centers and museums. In addition, there is a companion exhibit entitled “Who Are We Now? Roots, Resistance & Recognition” that explores the complex relationships between African Americans and Mexicans in the United States. Both exhibitions were organized by the National Museum of Mexican Art, Chicago, Illinois. Arturo J. Aldama and Cordelia Chávez Candelaria, “Appropriation and Popular Culture,” in the Encyclopedia of Latino Popular Culture, vol. A-L., ed. Cordelia Chávez Candelaria, Arturo Aldama, and others (Westport: Greenwood, 2004), 30. Ibid., 30–34. Ibid., 33–34. As of July 2009, Carlbucks is no longer the name of the business mentioned in this chapter that was written at an earlier date. Despite the change in business name, I keep the example to show how the riffing of a mass culture production influenced the business owner at one time to incorporate the well-known image into the marketing of his business. Alicia Gaspar de Alba, Chicano Art: Inside/Outside the Master’s House (Austin: University of Texas Press, 1998), 12. Ibid., 12. Ibid., 13–14. Chela Sandoval, Methodology of the Oppressed (Minneapolis: University Press of Minnesota, 2000), 144. Ibid., 145.
6
Traveling on the Biliteracy Highway: Educators Paving a Road toward Conocimiento María E. Fránquiz
When you include the complexity of feeling two or more ways about a person/issue, when you empathize and try to see her circumstances from her position, you accommodate the other’s perspective, achieving un conocimiento that allows you to shift toward a less defensive, more inclusive identity. When you relate to others, not as parts, problems, or useful commodities, but from a connectionist view compassion triggers transformation. (Gloria Anzaldúa).
n her explanation of the seven stages of conocimiento (reflective consciousness), Gloria Evangelina Anzaldúa1 explains that this concept is embodied in the wisdom known in many cultures—that we walk in others’ shoes, that we love them as ourselves, that we empathize and sympathize with others from our own or a different group, and that we listen carefully to each others’ views. This is sound advice. So how can teachers develop this kind of consciousness work among young students in educational settings, particularly in classrooms with majority Latin@ students? To address this question I present portraits of teachers and students in U.S. classrooms who are interested in making schools and literacy instruction more responsive to bilingual, bicultural, and biliterate learners. Because I am primarily interested in working with teachers that actively promote opportunities for the positive social and academic development of young Latin@2 students who can be said to be traveling on the biliteracy highway,3 I pay attention not only to what teachers say (for example, in
I
94
MARÍA E. FRÁNQUIZ
interviews) but to what they actually do in educational settings with their students’ linguistic and cultural resources to foster conocimiento. This chapter, then, presents a case study of student engagement with and responses to children’s stories written by Anzaldúa, Amigos del otro lado (Friends from the Other Side), published in 1993, and Prietita y la llorona (Prietita and the Ghost Woman), published in 1995. These two stories were selected because they have been found to assist with the development and use of critical thinking skills or with “reading to learn.”4 Put another way, by critical thinking I am not referring to instances when teachers ask students only “known information questions”5 that invite them to recite the facts (characters, setting, plot, outcome) in stories. Rather, by critical thinking I refer to Anzaldúa’s theorization of conocimiento or the development of deep reflective consciousness that questions conventional knowledge while fostering a less defensive and more inclusive personal and collective identity. The two books Amigos del otro lado and Prietita y la llorona are appropriate for fostering conocimiento as they are typically chosen by elementary school districts’ Departments of Language Arts and Bilingual / English-as-a-Second-Language Education precisely because they provide many culturally relevant references that connect Latin@ students to story characters and authentic social contexts. However, documents of effective strategies used by teachers during the reading and response to bilingual parallel texts such as Anzaldúa’s Amigos del otro lado and Prietita y la llorona in the elementary grades are few. Additionally, educators rarely find appropriate literature for drawing out firsthand accounts of their students’ various stances toward complex social issues— specifically, undocumented immigration, curanderismo (folk knowledge about healing), biosystems along the U.S.-Mexico border, poverty in both rural and urban settings, and tension between U.S.-born Latin@s and recently arrived Latin@s, among other themes. My Position as Writer, Researcher, Theorist Although I am not of Mexican-American descent as are Anzaldúa and the majority of teachers and students whose lives I discuss in this chapter, I share the same social justice orientation. As a Puerto Rican professor of bilingual/biliteracy studies I locate myself in the camp of Diasporican scholars. The term Diasporican was popularized by the Nuyorican poet Mariposa and refers to the increasingly diverse and dynamically evolving nature of Puerto Rican identity within the United States.6 This identity aligns with theories of the sociocultural foundations of education and of critically caring feminist theorists.7 Caring theorists value an ethos of caring and are concerned when the curriculum and school are not actively
TRAVELING ON THE BILITERACY HIGHWAY
95
promoting a search for meaningful connections between teacher and students, between students and families, and among students themselves. These interpersonal connections are the ones that have profound consequences for the ways in which students’ identities develop and for the ways in which their academic resiliency is influenced.8 A premise underlying all my work is that when interpersonal relationships, curricula, and institutional structures do not place value on the native languages, histories, and cultures of students, literacy resources for learning are subtracted9 and academic resiliency suffers.10 As explained by Thompson,11 critical educators ought not to equate caring with emotionally laden practices of feeling pity for Latin@ students’ circumstances nor ought they to lower academic expectations. More poignantly noted, critical educators are not motivated by “ay bendito” or “pobrecito” (“poor little one”) forms of teacher caring.12 Instead I suggest that communities of color understand caring within their own sociocultural context and possess promising, rather than deficient, funds of knowledge.13 Unfortunately, these funds of knowledge are too often not academically validated in schools.14 Thus, in this chapter I pay particular attention to how the neglected and misunderstood hidden literacies15 among Latin@ students demonstrate potential for positive identity formation, development of conocimiento, and potential for academic success. The Transformative Potential of Bilingual Children’s Literature In 1982 Linda Smuckler asked Anzaldúa the question, “Can you talk about your voice in writing?” Gloria responded: I have many voices. But I think the voice I most treasure is this little voice I had when I was little, which I call Gloria Gaurita; she was my little childself. She was repressed and never got a chance to be a child. She had to be adult. I associate creativity and imagination with her. She’s tender, open and vulnerable. I think that’s my main voice. And then I have these other voices. You know, Gloria the lesbian, Gloria the feminist, Gloria the person interested in philosophy, psychology, psychic phenomena.16
With this child-self in mind I worked with a team of three doctoral students17 to learn about the child voices of Chicanit@s attending public elementary schools in Austin, Texas. As a research team we were interested in learning about how teachers used and children responded to two children’s books written by Anzaldúa—Amigos del otro lado (Friends from the Other Side) and Prietita y la llorona (Prietita and the Ghost Woman). We recorded classroom observations and discussed the types of connections
96
MARÍA E. FRÁNQUIZ
Latin@ children made with these two pieces of literature. We were particularly invested in learning about how the linguistic and cultural funds of knowledge from children’s homes and communities were used to better understand these texts. Our hope was to witness ways that critical thinking was promoted through this literature. This meant observing for questioning by teachers or students of “conventional knowledge’s current categories, classifications, and contents”18 as well as documenting opportunities provided and taken up for development of reflective consciousness— moving from desconocimiento (ignorance or willful unawareness) toward deep critical awareness. The theoretical assumption for the study of the movement toward awareness requires that the teacher become a bridge between the funds of knowledge from home and the valued language and literacy practices of school. In this way students’ travel toward conocimiento is facilitated when teachers choose to be a bridge rather than a wall and provide an invitation to travel on a biliteracy highway rather than demand travel on a parallel English-only thoroughfare. But how do teachers themselves acquire this conocimiento and what strategies do they use to promote conocimientos? Anzaldúa defines conocimiento as the Spanish word for knowledge and skills, and argues that the acquisition of conocimiento has to do with getting to know each other by really listening with the outer and the inner ears. I argue that the two children’s books authored by Anzaldúa can be used to promote conocimiento. At the same time it is how the teacher uses these books in her/his class that determines whether critical thinking takes place or not. To provide an appropriate context for the argument presented in this chapter, I provide a synopsis of the two books. Then, I will show how two teachers used these books to provide students opportunities to acquire conocimientos. In Amigos del otro lado, the protagonist is a girl from Texas, Prietita, who asks Joaquín, a boy from the Mexican side of the border, “Did you come from the other side? You know, from Mexico?” Since their arrival in Texas, the boy and his mother suffered the scorn of some of the MexicanAmericans, but Joaquín immediately discovers that Prietita meant no harm. In fact, they begin a solid friendship in spite of the economic hardships that Joaquín and his mother endure after crossing the Rio Grande River in search of a better life. In the story, Prietita’s cousin and other neighborhood kids taunt Joaquín. They call him mojado, a derogatory term for individuals who have crossed the river from Mexico to the United States. Prietita successfully warns the kids off. The feelings of children as well as adults are explored, and Prietita plans to take Joaquin to the curandera (natural healer) for treatment of the sores he hides under long sleeves. The climax of the story is when Prietita must figure out what can
TRAVELING ON THE BILITERACY HIGHWAY
97
be done to protect Joaquín and his mother from the Border Patrol. While the suspense builds there is also a good dose of Chican@ humor when Prietita’s neighbors tell the Chicano migra that there are some “illegals” living in “the gringo side of town” (n.p.).19 The book is not considered overtly didactic. Instead it paints for its readers a picture of humanitarian engagement.20 Additionally, the illustrations by Consuelo Méndez are rich with cultural references (Don Pedrito Jaramillo, Santo Niño de Atocha, mesquite trees, nopal, La Virgen de Guadalupe) that provide opportunities for exploring deeper levels of reading with young readers. In the second book that Anzaldúa wrote for children, Prietita is again the protagonist. The story takes place in a setting in South Texas near the infamous King Ranch, one of the world’s largest ranches with hundreds of thousands of acres considered by many as stolen from Mexico. This area is home to many native plants such as nopal and animals like the jaguarundi as well as trees such as mesquite and huisache. Ever since she can remember, Prietita has heard frightening stories about La Llorona—the legendary ghost woman who steals children at night. One day when Prietita goes in search of the missing herb that can help cure her mother’s illness, she becomes lost in the woods. Suddenly she hears a distant crying sound and sees flashes of white in the trees. She wonders if it could be La Llorona. In Prietita’s search for the healing ruda plant that will cure her mother, she discovers that La Llorona is not at all like what people had said she would be. Both stories offer powerful themes for teachers drawing out funds of knowledge regarding students’ lived experiences and those of their parents and community, and provide opportunities to critically think about sensitive social and political issues. However, teachers must become comfortable teaching topics where students must struggle with uncomfortable themes.21 In the two books that teachers used for this study, themes included the hardship of daily life on the border for poor children and their families, the beauty of the plants and animals in the landscape, intergenerational apprenticeship related to health and healing, and examining the dignity and generosity Mexican-American and Mexican immigrants ought to share among themselves but often do not. As Anzaldúa explains, to be a bridge “is an act of will, an act of love, an attempt toward compassion and reconciliation, and a promise to be present with the pain of others without losing themselves to it.”22 Others concur and provide further ways of imagining how to be a bridge: There can be bridges that join community knowledge and school validation of that knowledge. There can be bridges between parents and teachers, school and community. There can be bridges of understanding in learning communities. There can be bridges between practical, out-of-school,
98
MARÍA E. FRÁNQUIZ
experiential knowledge and academic, abstract knowledge. And of course, there are bridges between diverse peoples who come together to fulfill a common mission. There is also the bridge between childhood and adulthood.23
Two Stories and Two Classrooms During the academic year 2008–2009 pedagogical strategies such as Read Alouds, literature discussions, and writing activities in six bilingual classrooms from the third to the fifth grades were observed for five months. Oral discourse and written artifacts from more than 100 students were collected. Analyses of transcripts and artifacts from these classes provide firsthand accounts of students’ various stances on complex issues, such as undocumented immigration, curanderismo, and endangered wildlife, among others, within the stories. For this chapter, I focus on two of the six classrooms. Reading Amigos del otro lado in a newcomers’ class In the first classroom example, issues of documented and undocumented immigration examined through the lens of the characters in Amigos del otro lado provided a rich context for fifth-grade students to arrive at new conocimiento. All students in this fifth-grade class were newcomers to the United States (they had arrived in the United States in the previous two years) and were being provided a Spanish language arts literacy class to improve overall biliteracy development. They were pulled out of their regular homeroom class (English monolingual) for approximately ninety minutes a day to work with the bilingual teacher. The newcomers’ group was comprised of four fifth-grade girls and four fifth-grade boys whose families recently emigrated from Mexico, Ecuador, and Peru. The teacher whom I will call Nereida was an apprentice in the education profession and was raised in the border city of El Paso, Texas. In an autonarrative that she wrote for a writing class that I taught in Fall 2008, Nereida remembered some noninspiring experiences in her own education. I hated my reading classes because the tasks were ever so boring. The class consisted of reading passage after passage and answering questions. I think I would have much rather read a novel or anything that I could bring from home at least once in a while to distract the routine of reading short stories and answering questions. In high school, I recall reading To Kill a Mockingbird, The Scarlet Letter, Hamlet, The Bluest Eye, Frankenstein, Wuthering Heights. These books were great, but even now, I don’t get very
TRAVELING ON THE BILITERACY HIGHWAY
99
enthusiastic talking about them. I prefer books such as El Alquimista and Cien Años de Soledad.
For Nereida the superficial reading of classic literature and answering of superficial comprehension questions during her middle and high school years was not satisfying. She felt frustration in not being able to connect with content, having no choice in the type of material to read, and in being deprived of reading material in her heritage language. Overall, she did not feel she was “reading to learn.” For this reason Nereida stated further in her autonarrative, “Based on what I liked and disliked about my learning growing up, I will allow student choice in their writing and reading assignments. Keeping a balance between rigorous curriculum and language choice can make a difference in students and how fond they become of reading and writing.” True to her desire to provide a rigorous curriculum, cultural content, and language choice, during her student-teaching semester Nereida read Amigos del otro lado in Spanish to her newcomers in the fifth grade. They could follow the reading in English or Spanish as the story is written as a dual-language parallel text. During the reading the children noticed a dicho (proverb) written on the book’s illustration of the jacal (shack) where Joaquín lived with his mother, la espada rota no se rinde nunca (“The broken sword never surrenders”). Because the children were attracted to the dicho, for homework they were asked to collect dichos to share in class the following day. Among the ones collected from family and community members were: Perro que ladra no muerde (“A barking dog does not bite”), Más vale sola que mal acompañada (“It’s better to be alone than in bad company”), Más vale prevenir que lamentar (“It’s better to anticipate than to regret”), and Es mejor dar buena cara al mal tiempo (“It’s better to be positive during hard times”). Nereida compiled the collection of dichos into a class text representing the accumulation of funds of knowledge that had assisted her Latin@ students from different countries when they experienced geographical as well as spiritual dislocations as they traveled on the biliteracy highway. Interestingly, when the newcomer class was “brainstorming” the meanings of the concept of immigration, one young female said, “Hay personas que cruzan y hay personas que nada más pasan; que pasan nada más así” (“There are people who cross and there are people who only have to pass, who pass just like that”). This critical vocabulary distinction signals that this fifth-grade girl was aware of the different kinds of border-crossing experiences, both documented and undocumented. The use of the word solamente or “only have to” suggests that she knew about the deeper and more complicated challenges of what it meant to cross the border. Her
100
MARÍA E. FRÁNQUIZ
peers—one who had crossed the border via the river and one who had passed the border in an airplane—took up this distinction of cruzar/pasar. For example, one girl in the newcomers’ class stated, “Yo cruzé por el Rio Bravo. ¡Yo soy inmigrante!” (“I crossed through the Rio Grande. I am an immigrant!”). However, before she made this very risky declaration to class members, she pointed at another girl in the newcomers’ class who had papeles (legal documentation) and said, “No me juzgues” (“Don’t judge me”). The teacher reinforced the need for class members to learn about and honor the different border-crossing experiences that people in general, and, they in particular, had experienced. This new range of understanding about ways people immigrate to the United States provided conocimientos that students were not always comfortable reporting to or accepting from class members. However, in this class every student was motivated to produce an immigration narrative and to compose an accompanying drawing. These narratives and illustrations were compiled in a culminating anthology representing the various firsthand experiences of children and families who emigrated from Mexico, Ecuador, and Peru to the United States. In this way the teacher acted as a bridge in assisting students to shift toward a less defensive, more inclusive identity as to who is an immigrant. She used a culturally relevant book, class discussion, illustrations, and writings as forms of activism, because her goal was for students themselves to become bridges within their own spheres of influence. Reading Prietita y la llorona in a science class In the second classroom example, the students were also fifth graders and bilingual. However, they were not newcomers to the United States. They were enrolled in a bilingual science class where their personal growing understanding of and uses for yerbas en remedios caseros (herbal use in home remedies) were documented by the researchers. In the classroom, the enrollment consisted of Texas-born students of Mexican descent and more recent immigrants from Cuba, Honduras, and Mexico (more than two years in the United States but some prior schooling outside of the United States). The teacher whom I will call Liliana was born in South Texas in the Suntex Farms ranch right outside of Rio Grande City, Texas. She is a first-generation U.S. citizen born of migrant farm workers. Liliana was also enrolled in one of my courses during the summer of 2008 and wrote in her autonarrative: When I was introduced to researching in my science and social studies classes I came to the realization that I loved to write about facts. Reading
TRAVELING ON THE BILITERACY HIGHWAY
101
history books and writing reports about my learning became a favorite pastime of mine. This type of writing together with my poetry writing and letter writing really gave me an outlet to express the thoughts, feelings, emotions, and learning that I was experiencing at school and at home. Writing provided me with the consciousness of thinking about my thinking and putting it on paper. I guess in my literary life the one thing I always tried to find was my own voice. In the chaos of child poverty and migrant working, it became very important. It was an outlet away from the realities of life and a place to contemplate on what life should become for me in the future.
The search for her voice as a writer, both in disciplinary and social writing, provided Liliana with the tools necessary to deal with the mobility that was an ordinary part of her bilingual migrant family and Mexican-American community. She was acutely aware of the benefits of the funds of knowledge at home as can be seen in another passage of her autonarrative. Today, I am bilingual because of the fact my environment provided me with an enriched life filled with bilingualism and biculturalism that I wouldn’t have otherwise. If it had been up to my educational system they would have stripped me of it all. I find myself today as a teacher struggling with the fact that my students could experience this stripping away of their language and culture. The only thing I pray for is that I give them some tools to defend themselves and to protect themselves from it all.
Liliana’s writing illustrates deep conocimiento that in her own education maintenance of her Spanish-heritage language had typically been seen as a problem to be expunged by her and other Latin@ students. Instead, Liliana knew that her bilingualism should have been seen as a resource for her learning or acknowledged as her fundamental human right.24 The desire to equip her students with the bilingual and bicultural tools that had been passed to her by family and community was evident across the weeks that her lessons were documented using the Anzaldúa story Prietita y la llorona. When Liliana used the story, she wanted to use the text as a bridge to understanding concepts such as habitats, ecosystems, and animal and plant adaptations. As was customary she pretaught these science concepts in Spanish and later extended knowledge of the concepts in English. The bilingual story of Prietita y la llorona was ideal for preteaching as well as for eliciting students’ prior knowledge and experience. The teacher began by reading the story from the overhead projector. As she read she asked students to jot down the plant and animal life included in the illustrations or mentioned in the conversations among the characters in the story. Among the plants identified by the children were many hierbas (herbs). These
102
MARÍA E. FRÁNQUIZ
included yerba buena (mint), ruda (rue), sábila (aloe vera), pino (pine), and nopal (cactus). Among the animals identified by the children were luciérnagas (fireflies), jaguarundi (endangered feline animals of South Texas), venado (deer), and salamandra (salamander). The individual contributions were used to create a class list regarding the plants and animals that could be found around the ranches and rural cities in South Texas, a relatively short drive on the interstate from their school. To build a bridge between the funds of knowledge at home and the required science curriculum, Liliana asked her students to bring actual hierbas (herbs) from home. These were compared with each other. Next the students wrote an expository text explaining how their families used these herbs as remedios (remedies). Some brought nopal (cactus), ruda (rue), canela (cinnamon), oregano, manzanilla (chamomile), and arnica (species of sunflower family). They wrote about the ways mint was used to cure stomachaches or colic, how chamomile was used for sore throats or headaches, and that rue was used for headaches and earaches. The aloe vera was mentioned by many of the children because the sap could be used for rashes, pimples, wounds, and cuts; the juice could be used for gastritis; and the plant, like many others, was used in making healing teas. One student wrote, Le avisé a mi mamá que me dió fiebre y me hizo una canela y me quedé mirando cómo lo hacía. Primero pones una olla con agua a hervir. Luego pones la canela en la olla y la dejas por unos minutos. También me quedé mirando para saber cómo hacer para que cuando [me] sintiera mal me hiciera uno yo sola. [I let my mom know that I had a fever and she made cinnamon tea and I watched how she did it. First you put a large pot of water to boil. Then you put the cinnamon in the pot and leave it for a few minutes. I watched so that when I feel sick I can make the tea alone.]
With this student’s story there was an accompanying detailed illustration of the school, the route that led to her house, and the exterior and interior of her house with the herb, stove, pot, and her bed, all labeled. This illustration was a concrete example of how this student felt about the bridge her teacher was constructing between lived experience at home and the science curriculum at school. The class was better able to understand the science curriculum as a result of examining the role of herbs in family/community healing practices. For example, students were able to articulate that the rue plant grows by water and that Prietita found the healing herb on the riverbank. Students also agreed that the nopal adapts to grow in the desert and that the jaguarundi adapts to live in the underbrush.
TRAVELING ON THE BILITERACY HIGHWAY
103
The Path of Conocimiento through Sustained Literary Study What seems important in these two classrooms is that both teachers are responsible for teaching the required curriculum but without separating school instruction from the funds of linguistic and cultural knowledge children bring to the classroom from home and their community. The teachers, Nereida and Liliana, see their students’ lived experiences as an important resource for learning. They see the heritage language and cultural traditions as equally credible resources. For them, achieving conocimiento is about creating class assignments that capitalize on all the linguistic and cultural resources from home as much as it is about teachers and students taking risks in using these resources at school. The way Anzaldúa explained this type of bridge is summarized in the words that Jamie Lee Evans captured on audiotape when she interviewed her in 1993: “One of the drawbacks to being a bridge is being walked on, but one of the pluses is that it’s two-way—oncoming and outgoing traffic. It’s being in different worlds and getting the best from those worlds.”25 As discussed in this chapter, the children in these two classrooms lived in different cultural worlds at home and in school, but their teachers were willing to be a bridge across these worlds as they traveled together with their students along the biliteracy highway that comprises fifth grade and beyond. Nereida and Liliana’s pedagogy can be described as a humanizing pedagogy26 because it produces what Anzaldúa stated were “new conocimientos [that] have to shift the frame of reference, reframe the issue or situation being looked at, connect the disparate parts of information in new ways or from a perspective that’s new.”27 Implications for educators The findings reported in this chapter were from a collaborative study proposing the use of Anzaldúa’s bilingual children’s books in the language, arts, and science curriculum to provide Latin@ students with opportunities to develop critical thinking and biliteracy skills for the development of conocimiento related to the study of (im)migration and the ecosystem of the U.S.-Mexico borderlands. This study verifies the importance of providing children with reading materials that are culturally relevant, because such readings provide connections with their background knowledge and lived experiences. Such readings must be supplemented with discussion, including the investigation of the linguistic and cultural dimensions of the text that are typically incorporated in the dialogue and actions among characters and in the accompanying illustrations. Often the Read Aloud
104
MARÍA E. FRÁNQUIZ
by the teacher allows students the opportunity of becoming familiar with and appreciating the sounds and structure of written language, be it the heritage or the second language. When homework relates the topics of the story to the cultural experiences of home, children are better able to generate their own stories, or at least to contribute a page to a class text. Examining the Latin@ children’s development of biliteracy and conocimiento in school is significant, because these skills augment intellectual possibilities, provide access to a broader range of social and cultural resources, and encourage teachers and children to place value on household and community funds of knowledge as key sites for linguistic and cultural identity formation as well as content-area learning. Because Mexican immigrants in the United States are often targets of symbolic violence,28 Liliana and Nereida recognized that dominant ideologies are often internalized by such students and motivated them to create spaces in the language arts and science curriculum for close reading and responding to relevant stories—such as Amigos del otro lado and Prietita y la llorona—where child protagonists can actively resist, interrupt, and contradict the status quo. By utilizing a sustained literacy study approach (or the studying of one literacy theme over time), they provided opportunities for students to accrue information, without which children are less able to question, synthesize, and evaluate what they read. This pedagogical approach aligns with the worldview of Anzaldúa who stated, “When you relate to others, not as parts, problems, or useful commodities, but from a connectionist view, compassion triggers transformation.”29 Through sustained literacy study children are able to practice making connections with their self, others (like and unlike themselves), and the complex world of the twenty-first century. What Anzaldúa described as “conocimiento—consciousness work” seeks to connect the inner life of each child to the outer worlds of action and as she specified, “Writing is a form of activism, one of making bridges.”30 While it should not be news that the inner life and funds of knowledge that students bring into classroom literacy events can be effectively used as material resources for communicating, making meaning, and constructing one’s identity as a bilingual person, it must still be shouted by the travelers on the biliteracy highway for there are different roads that English-only advocates in the United States would construct. And, while there are other researchers who agree that Spanish/English bilinguals draw on all linguistic codes available to them in patterned and structured ways to communicate, to (re)claim membership and affiliation,31 and to support children’s bilingual development at home or in school,32 there are those who would question and deny those benefits, particularly to immigrants.
TRAVELING ON THE BILITERACY HIGHWAY
105
The issue of immigration continues to be as critical today as when Anzaldúa wrote about Prietita and Joaquin in 1993 and 1995. It may be that the economic recession in the United States makes the political debate more difficult today, but senior officials of the Barack Obama administration report of plans to begin addressing the U.S. immigration system comprehensively, including looking for ways that undocumented immigrants can become legal citizens.33 Such possibilities anger representatives of anti-immigration groups such as The Minutemen, Numbers USA, and FAIR (a recognized hate group). Who would ever imagine that supporting children’s bilingual, bicultural, and biliterate development would be such a contested issue in the twenty-first century? That adults would be “marinated in the vile and racist juices of an anti-illegal immigration movement that often seeks to dehumanize people it considers ‘illegal alien invaders’”?34 What we need to keep in mind is that there are teachers like Nereida and Liliana who do not judge their students by their immigration status but by their right to an additive education that honors both the part of the road left behind as well as the one on the horizon. After all, the Social Policy Report Brief, volume 22, Issue 3, of 2008 reminds us: Children in immigrant families are the fastest-growing population in the United States. This rapid growth is transforming the racial and ethnic composition of America, with the result that racial and ethnic minorities will become the majority US population. Baby boomers will depend heavily for economic support in retirement on young people who grew up in immigrant families. The current circumstances and future prospects of children in immigrant families are therefore important not only to the children themselves, but to all Americans.35
Notes 1. Gloria E. Anzaldúa, “now let us shift . . . the path of conocimiento . . . inner work, public acts,” in Gloria E. Anzaldúa and AnaLouise Keating, This Bridge We Call Home: Radical Visions for Transformation (New York: Routledge, 2002), 540–78. This essay describes the stages of conocimiento; however, Anzaldúa refers to this concept in many of her other works. 2. See the note in the introduction of this reader regarding the use of the term Latin@. It is intentionally used here even though the student populations described in this chapter are for the most part of Mexican heritage. Because Central, South American, and Caribbean students often feel invisible and struggle against being culturally and linguistically swamped by the local Mexican population, and because many students are ethnically mixed (for example, of Puerto Rican and Mexican heritage), I use the term Latin@ to acknowledge this wide intragroup diversity.
106
MARÍA E. FRÁNQUIZ
3. Traveling on the biliteracy highway is a metaphor that refers to students learning to read and respond orally and in writing in both Spanish and English. In elementary schools with bilingual education programs, the biliteracy highway is often referred to as the bilingual track or the bilingual strand. For examples, see María E. Fránquiz, “Featured Essay Book Review: Literacy Reform for Latin@ Students,” Reading Research Quarterly 38, no. 3 (July/August/ September 2003): 418–30. 4. A differentiation between “learning to read” and “reading to learn” is made in elementary education. In the former process many skill-based strategies are used to help students learn to become independent readers by emphasizing phonics, phonological awareness, and systemic phonics instruction; in the latter process children use their acquired literacy skills for greater comprehension, to question, wonder, analyze, summarize, and synthesize information. For a discussion of how fourth-grade teachers foster “reading to learn” with its reduced reliance on processing every characteristic of the word and letter, see Richard L. Allington and Peter Johnston, Reading to Learn: Lessons from Exemplary Fourth Grade Classrooms (New York: The Guilford Press, 2002). 5. Known information questions refer to questions that ask for information that is already known to the questioner. Rather than seeking information, the teacher or parent merely requires children to rehearse or verbally display their knowledge. These types of questions are commonly used in middleclass homes and help socialize children into the preferred ways for displaying knowledge in classrooms. Children from nondominant cultural groups in the United States may not be socialized to such displays of knowledge. Also see Hugh Mehan, “What time is it Denise? Some Observations On The Organization and Consequences of Making Known Information Questions in Classroom Discourse,” Theory Into Practice 18, no. 4 (1979): 285–92; Shirley Bryce Heath, “The Learner As Cultural Worker,” in The Teachability of Language, ed. Mabel R. Rice and Richard L. Scheifelbusch (Baltimore: Brookes, 1989); and Ron Scollon and Suzanne Scollon, “Athabaskan-English Interethnic Communication,” in Narrative, Literacy, And Face In Interethnic Communication, ed. Ron Scollon and Suzanne B. K. Scollon (Norwood, NJ: Ablex, 1981), 259–90. 6. See Rene Antrop-González and Anthony De Jesús, “Toward a Theory of Critical Care in Urban Small School Reform: Examining Structures and Pedagogies of Caring in Two Latino Community-Based Schools,” International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education 19 (2006): 409–33; and Jorge Matos Valldejuli and Juan Flores, “New Rican Voices: Un Muestraria/o Sampler at the Millennium,” Journal of the Center for Puerto Rican Studies 12, no. 1 (2000): 49–96. 7. See Rosalie Rolón-Dow, “Critical Care: A Color(Full) Analysis of Care Narratives in the Schooling Experiences of Puerto Rican Girls,” American Education Research Journal 42, no. 1 (2005): 77–111; and Nel Noddings. The Challenge to Care in Schools: An Alternative Approach to Education (New York: Teachers College Press, 1992).
TRAVELING ON THE BILITERACY HIGHWAY
107
8. In a 2004 article published in the High School Journal, María del Carmen Salazar and I propose a theoretical model of respeto that is based on three principles that Chican@ high school students identified as instrumental for their academic resiliency: fostering confianza, providing buen ejemplos, and access to critical consejos. In another article written by Jason Irizarry and René Antrop-González in 2008, the authors discuss ways in which what teachers call culturally responsive teaching can be extended to combat the colonial pedagogies specifically impacting DiaspoRican student resiliency in schools; they propose “RicanStructing” the discourse of school success. 9. See Sonia Nieto, Language, Culture, and Teaching: Critical Perspectives for a New Century (Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2002); and Angela Valenzuela, Subtractive Schooling: U.S.-Mexican Youth and the Politics of Caring (New York: State University of New York Press, 1999). 10. Jason Irizarry and Rene Antrop-González, “RicanStructing the Discourse and Promoting School Success: Extending a Theory of Culturally Responsive Pedagogy for DiaspoRicans,” Hispanic Health Care International 6, no. 4 (2008): 172–84; and María del Carmen Salazar, “Echándole Ganas: The Elements that Support or Constrain the Academic Resiliency of Mexican Immigrant Students in a High School ESL Program” (Phd Diss., University of Colorado, Boulder, 2004). 11. Audrey Thompson, “Not the Color Purple: Black Feminist Lessons for Educational Caring,” Harvard Educational Review 68 (1998): 522–54. 12. See Lilia I. Bartolomé and María V. Balderrama, “The Need for Educators with Political and Ideological Clarity,” in The Best for Our Children: Critical Perspectives on Literacy for Latino Students, ed. Maria de la Luz Reyes and John J. Halcón (New York: Teachers College Press, 2001), 48–64; and María E. Berzíns and Alice E. López, “Starting Off Right: Planting the Seeds of Biliteracy,” in The Best for Our Children: Critical Perspectives on Literacy for Latino students, 81–95; and Eugene Garcia, Hispanic Education in the United States: Raíces y Alas (New York: Rowman & Littlefield, 2001). 13. Funds of knowledge are the accumulated and culturally developed bodies of knowledge and skills essential for household as well as individual functioning and well-being. These funds may include activities and knowledge related to household management (for example, knowledge of contemporary as well as folk medicine), agriculture and gardening (for example, soil and irrigation systems), mechanics (for example, repair), and religion (for example, moral knowledge of ethics), among others. For contextualized details, see Luis C. Moll, Cathy Amanti, Deborah Neff, and Norma González, “Funds of Knowledge for Teaching: Using a Qualitative Approach to Connect Homes and Classrooms,” Theory into Practice 31 (1992): 132–41; and Carlos G. Vélez-Ibañez and James B. Greenberg, “Formation and Transformation of Funds of Knowledge among U.S.-Mexican Households,” Anthropology & Education Quarterly 23, no. 4 (1992): 313–35. Later in 2002, Gonzáles and Moll argued that funds of knowledge are rooted in practice—in what individuals and households actually do and what they think about what they do. Often exchange of these vital funds of
108
14.
15. 16. 17.
18. 19. 20. 21.
22. 23. 24.
25.
MARÍA E. FRÁNQUIZ
knowledge involves the use of literacy in Spanish and English, and constitutes the necessary economic and labor resources for family survival. These funds are resources from home and community with great potential for learning at school and in other contexts. Carmen Martínez-Roldán and María E. Fránquiz, “Latin@ Youth Literacies: Hidden Funds of Knowledge,” in Handbook of Literacy Research, ed. Leila Christenbury, Randy Bomer, and Peter Smagorinsky (New York: Guilford Press, 2009), 323–42. Kerrie E Villalva, “Hidden Literacies and Inquiry Approaches of Bilingual High School Writers,” Written Communication 23 (2006): 91–129. Anzaldúa and Keating, 61. During the initial collection of data, Angie Zapata, Dolores Godinez, and Toni Avila—all doctoral students in the Department of Curriculum and Instruction at the University of Texas—recorded field notes, made video recordings of selected activities, and conducted interviews. I express my profound gratitude for their assistance in collection and discussion of the data presented in this chapter. Anzaldúa and Keating, 541. There were no page numbers as these children’s books do not have pagination. Manuel M. Martín-Rodríguez,“Chicano/a Children’s Literature: A Tranaztlantic Reader’s History,” Journal of American Studies of Turkey 23 (2006): 15–35. In a separate study in California I used Anzaldúa’s concept of nepantla to discuss the process of struggle to interrogate powerful ideas when a teacher in a bilingual fifth-grade classroom had students “read to learn” about hate and violence in historical contexts such as World War II. In this case one student from Israel was in-between an “American” and a Jewish identity, while others were comfortable in their identities as African-American or Mexican-American. For a more detailed description of how student thinking was transformed, see María E. Fránquiz, “Learning in the Transformational Space: Struggling with Powerful Ideas,” Journal of Classroom Interaction 34, no. 2 (1999): 30–44. Ibid., 4. González and Moll, 624. In his seminal 1984 article, Richard Ruiz differentiated three premises that are used by school administrators for language-planning programs in school. Language can be seen as a problem in learning, as a human right, or as a resource for learning. Escamilla adds that school assessments are aligned with the language-as-a-problem orientation. For more comprehensive details, see Richard Ruiz, “Orientations in Language Planning,” The Journal for the National Association of Bilingual Education 8, no. 2 (1984): 15–34; Kathy Escamilla, “Monolingual Assessment and Emerging Bilinguals: A Case Study in the U.S.,” in Imagining Multilingual Schools, ed. Ofelia García, Tove SkutnabbKangas, and María Torres-Guzman (Clevedon: Multilingual Matters, 2006), 184–99. Jamie Lee Evans, 206.
TRAVELING ON THE BILITERACY HIGHWAY
109
26. Lilia Bartolomé, “Beyond the Methods Fetish: Toward a Humanizing Pedagogy,” Harvard Educational Review 64 (1996): 173–94; María E. Fránquiz and María del Carmen Salazar, “The Transformative Potential of Humanizing Pedagogy: Addressing the Diverse Needs of Chicano/Mexicano Students,” The High School Journal 87, no. 4 (2004): 36–53; and Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed (New York: Seabury Press, 1970). 27. Lilia, 178. 28. See Sheila M. Shannon and Kathy Escamilla, “Mexican Immigrants in U.S. Schools: Targets of Symbolic Violence,” Educational Policy 13, no. 3 (1999): 347–70. 29. Anzaldúa and Keating, 569. 30. Ibid., 206. 31. See Gloria Anzaldúa, Borderlands / La Frontera: The New Mestiza (San Francisco: Spinsters / Aunt Lute, 1987); and Norma González, I Am My Language: Discourses of Women and Children in the Borderlands (Tucson: The University of Arizona Press, 2001). 32. See Bertha Pérez, ed., Sociocultural Contexts of Language and Literacy, 2nd ed., (Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum, 2004); and Ana Celia Zentella, Growing up Bilingual: Puerto Rican Children in New York (Oxford: Blackwell, 1997). 33. Julia Preston, “Obama to Push Immigration Bill as One Priority,” New York Times, April 8, 2009. 34. Ruben Navarrette, “Editorial: A Racist Stew,” San Antonio Express-News, January 12, 2009. 35. Social Policy Report Brief, volume 22, III, 2008, http://www.srcd.org/index. php?option=com_content&task=view&id=229&Itemid=381 (accessed on July 31, 2009).
This page intentionally left blank
7
Traditional Cultural Expressions: An Analysis of the Secular and Religious Folkways of Latin@s in the United States Norma E. Cantú
Introduction* hroughout the Americas, cultural expressions include the syncretic process of 500 years of cultural mestizaje that brings together European, chiefly Spanish, cultural expressions and the autochthonous practices of the Amerindian peoples of this continent. For the last thirty years, I have researched this cultural phenomenon by examining the traditional culture of Spain and of Texas as sites that reflect this blending of cultures. Contemporary Spanish culture includes elements from the three main cultural threads that have been celebrated and contested throughout its history. The three—Christian, Jewish, and Muslim—as can be easily discerned in a number of locations such as Toledo, where the city prides itself in its multicultural past, have not always coexisted in harmony, but through the sheer power of historical weight have shaped each other, however reluctantly, despite the resistance of the currently predominant Christian culture. Thus, it was an already hybrid culture that arrived in the Americas at the end of the fifteenth century and became further hybridized for the next 400 years.
T
112
NORMA E. CANTÚ
Undoubtedly, we can see the remnants of the disastrous clash that occurred over 500 years ago as we witness the folk Catholicism that evolved around the Christian rituals in their diasporic reality as well as the foodways of the Spanish and other European cuisines. For instance, the wedding ceremony in Mexico retains remnants of a rich cultural mestizaje from the Arabic, Christian, and Nahuatl nuptials. Many of the elements of the ceremony, such as the lazo or arras, are not practiced in Europe but thrive in the folk Catholic rituals in the Americas as practiced in much of South, Central, and North America, especially in Mexico and in the Southwest, or in what Américo Paredes referred to as Greater Mexico.1 Another example of the significant impact of that clash of cultures exists in the foodways of both the Americas and Europe. The tomato and chocolate are but two American foodstuffs that transformed the culinary production of Europe. Although there is growing interest in the Afro-Mexican and in the Jewish-Mexican cultural practices, both of which reveal added layers of cultural mestizaje, I am limiting the focus of this overview and analysis to religious Catholic and secular cultural expressions, such as the comingof-age ritual of the quinceañeras, the veneration of religious icons and holy sites, as well as folk saints and secular folk manifestations that have functioned in Latin@ communities as forms of contestation and resistance to the onslaught of hegemonic U.S. culture. If we examine the Latin@ experience in the United States, we find ourselves in enclaves of cultural production that mirror that production in a number of communities in the Americas. The various Latinidades that celebrate with parades and processions as well as with in-family or in-group rituals survive as cultural groups because the very act of celebrating assures survival. In my analysis, I focus on secular and religious celebrations and on how these traditional practices cement the otherwise seemingly disparate Latin@ community, the various Latinidades, through the creation of a pan-Latin@ culture and language. Theorizing around the ideas of border theory and third-space Chicana feminist theories of identity, I view the cultural production— both secular and liturgical—through the lens of a cultural studies theory partly grounded in Raymond Williams’s notions of cultural studies and in the work of Gloria Anzaldúa. Williams’s “structures of feeling” and Anzaldúa’s “mestiza consciousness” are useful for my argument that cultural expressions and practices cohere a group’s identity and assist in the project of self-construction that Latin@s are engaged in as they move to the United States and join the millions of Latin@s who have been here for generations. Central to my argument is that those who have been here since before there was a border set the stage for the rest of the diasporic contingent. I structure my essay around two main axes: the secular and the liturgical celebrations; further grounding my analysis in key elements of
TRADITIONAL CULTURAL EXPRESSIONS
113
language, material culture, and performative acts such as the quinceañeras, I set forth a theory for examining Latinidades and the cultural panorama. But first I explore the theories of Raymond Williams and Gloria Anzaldúa because they form a trellis, as it were, upon which I situate other concepts such as the concepts of sitio y lengua (site and language) that Chicana feminist historian Emma Pérez uses so ably in her analysis of the decolonization project that we are all involved with in the twenty-first century.2 What follows is a very brief synthesis of the aspects of the work by Williams and Anzaldúa that I use for this project. Cultural anthropologist Raymond Williams, in a chapter of his book Marxism and Literature, explores the relationships between groups’ identities actively lived and thought, and proposes that the process be seen as a structure whereby society shapes itself. He claims, “We are . . . defining these elements as a ‘structure’: as a set, with specific internal relations, at once interlocking and in tension,” and thus superimposes a structural frame onto the emotive or affective realm of society.3 He further proposes that “structures of feeling can be defined as social experiences in solution, as distinct from other social semantic formations which have been precipitated and are more evidently and more immediately available.”4 In such a view, then, cultural expression is relegated to the realm of symbolic action. Williams also proposes that it is structures of feeling that allow us to recognize fellow members of our group—to tell impostors. Exploring the linguistic and semantic nuances, he also traces how groups construct and define these structures. While Williams identifies claims that these structures exist to bind the group, Chicana philosopher Gloria Anzaldúa explores how the structures of cultural feelings can both bind and deter bonding with the group. In her feminist work Borderlands / La Frontera: The New Mestiza, Anzaldúa time and again refers to the cultural expressions that shaped her identity. As a lesbian, she identifies the “structures of feeling,” to use Williams’s phrase, that force her to resist the group culture of homophobia.5 At the same time, she claims that the music, corridos, and many other cultural expressions help form an allegiance to and loyalty to that cultural group.6 Anzaldúa posits that we must bridge our differences, and she proposes a path for achieving just that as the structures are dismantled and reconfigured through a consciousness that includes confronting “the shadow beast” and finding a path to conocimiento, to a new consciousness that will lead to wholeness.7 All the while she situates the process in the border spaces and places, the nepantla (the Aztec concept of the third space), the in-between space, the liminal space, a third space that allows for such movement. Chicana feminist third-space theorist Chela Sandoval takes Anzaldúa to yet another realm as she employs a differential
114
NORMA E. CANTÚ
consciousness to achieve the desired change in society.8 Useful for our analysis of the Latin@ traditional cultural expressions are Anzaldúa’s ideas, for while they are grounded in her South Texas lived reality, they transcend across borders and address issues found in the greater Latin@ cultural world.
Sitio (Site or Place) The very location, the place where Latin@s live in the United States as well as the places they come from affects the cultural production of the group. Briefly, at the national level, the largest group by far, the over thirty-five million Mexican Americans—the majority—reside in the Southwest in the territory that became part of the United States when Mexico lost more than half of its land mass in 1848 at the conclusion of the U.S.-Mexican War and in subsequent agreements such as the Gadsden Purchase. While the whole country has pockets of populations from other Latinidades, such as Central Americans and Puerto Ricans, the Northeast has long been recognized as a center for Puerto Ricans. Specific traditional celebrations, then, occur in these spaces and define the Latin@ experience there. Two brief examples: the Puerto Rican parade in New York City and the Guelaguetza as celebrated in Los Angeles. The former is a constructed social event that brings together the Puerto Rican community to celebrate nothing more than its very presence in New York City, and the latter reenacts a celebration from Oaxaca in California, and, while also celebrating the community’s presence there, hearkens back to its social and religious purposes in its home space. In like fashion, local communities celebrate fiestas, religious and not, all over the United States; the religious folk matachines dance celebrations in Bernalillo, New Mexico, or in Laredo, Texas, and the Día de Reyes celebrations in Austin, Texas, or Brooklyn, attest to the widespread presence of Latin@s and their continued celebration of identity-based cultural expressions. But the regional differences are also there in the language spoken by these groups.
Lengua (Language/Tongue) Gloria Anzaldúa in Borderlands / La Frontera (1987) cites the importance of loyalty to cultural roots for the survival of a community that is accosted and harshly attacked. She is specifically talking about language and identity as she says, “So if you really want to hurt me, talk badly about my language.”9 Indeed language is one of the main identifiers we Latinos who live in the United States share. Nevertheless, not all of us speak the language
TRADITIONAL CULTURAL EXPRESSIONS
115
of our ancestors, and those of us who do, speak a variety of Spanishes that are intelligible even as they are different and unique. In addition, the variant Spanish of a Columbian or Puerto Rican and a New Mexican, or the variants within Chicano groups that have been in the United States for generations—such as the variant forms of Spanish spoken by Tejanos and Tucsonenses—are all unique and distinct, yet intelligible. In terms of lexicon, the regional differences are due as much to the local material history as to the influences of recent immigrant groups settling there. I limit my example, as there are many, to the term used to refer to an infant or child. While there are 1500 Yoeme, or Yaqui, in Mexico and about 500 in Arizona, the linguistic impact on the Spanish of the region is vast. In Arizona the term for a child is buqui, variant spelling buki, one of many words in the local Spanish that comes from the Yoeme or Yaqui. (There is even a music group from Sonora, Los Bukis, that would translate as “the kids.”) In northern Mexico and South Texas a common term is huerco or huerca whose etymology is Spanish, but it is not used for child in other Spanish-speaking countries. In Spain the most common is peque or peke, a clipped form of pequeña/o. Only a few years ago, the preferred term was crío. But in the Americas, the terms “Chamaco/a” or esquincle are also used to refer to a child, and both derive from the Náhuatl and are in more general use, especially in Mexico and in Greater Mexico. In a column published in 2007, Ricardo Espinoza lists over fifteen terms used to refer to a child in various variants of Spanish from pibes in Argentina to chavales in Spain. Yet, this last one was a common term in the caló of my youth. Other terms such as rorroro/a or simply nene or “nena” find their way into local usage for practical purposes. The latter, for example, is often the nickname of the oldest child, or of the child who bears a parent’s name and is still in practice, while the term “junior” has fallen into disuse although it was very common up to about thirty years ago. Suffice it to say that the many Spanish variants that are spoken in the Americas all find their way to the United States, making marketing to this group a challenge not easily solved. The solution seems to be the creation of a pan-Spanish that is easily understood by all, so baby products will not use crío or pibe or chaval or huerco, or even nena; instead the preferred term when selling baby products is bebé, and thereby it is marketing that creates a standard Spanish term that then becomes the “official” or standard term. Although I must say that I have not heard anyone in Laredo use bebé, yet everyone switches to English and uses “baby,” or opts for niña or niño in Spanish.10 In the last fifty years, language laws have instituted dramatic changes such as the introduction of bilingual education where children accustomed to saying “cachete” instead of “mejilla” are now being taught the latter term as the “correct” one for “cheek.” This is but one of many words that will
116
NORMA E. CANTÚ
no doubt fade from the Spanish of South Texas. Yet, the “English only” movement threatens the language even more dramatically as the push for English may bring about even more serious changes in the Spanish spoken in the United States. However, I remain an optimist as I observe the various languages spoken by the many Latin@s in the United States. Language is never static, and it will no doubt continue to change as speakers adapt to their regional and rich historical reality. Additionally, the potential market is so large that targeting the population in their language, Spanish, will no doubt also impact its survival. Indeed sitio y lengua, location/region, and language are inextricably linked with the Latin@ experience in the United States. The cultural expressions of Latin@s found in the most remote areas of the country where one would not suspect that there would be much of a Latino presence, such as Boise, Idaho, or Scottsbluff, Nebraska, to the most populated, where Latin@s have a historical presence, such as New York City or Los Angeles, all adhere to what we can claim constitutes Latin@ cultural artifacts that signify Latinidad. Chief among these cultural artifacts are celebrations and feasts or fiestas that function in a particular fashion to strengthen group identity or to reassert individual and group presence. Celebrations and Fiestas—Secular and Religious If language is ever changing and demands that new speakers inherit old forms and create new ones, traditional cultural expressions also are ever changing and demand that its practitioners inherit the old variants and create new ones to serve their purpose and insure their survival. As I turn to the celebrations themselves, I would like to keep in mind a discussion of the theoretical tenets that I discussed earlier as they will frame my analysis. Any analysis of traditional cultural expressions regarding fiestas and celebrations implies a cross-Latinidades enterprise as we can see that the impact of transnational movements and the Internet have influenced cultural production beyond what Williams and Anzaldúa ever imagined. We must keep in mind the ways in which such social structures pervade groups and transform themselves in an effort to survive intact in processes similar to languages that evolve and change and yet remain structurally the same. Secular fiestas are those that are outside of any religious or liturgical calendar and can be classified either as folk or socially constructed. Further, they can be schematically placed along a continuum of concentric circles around the self and that individual’s involvement. Imagine that there are five concentric circles at the center of which is the self, and proceeding outward, the family, the neighborhood (or the barrio), the city, the state, the nation, the hemisphere, and even the world. Given this schema we can
TRADITIONAL CULTURAL EXPRESSIONS
117
Figure 7.1 Circles of experience and of influence
place both secular and religious celebrations within the parameters of each concentric circle (see Figure 7.1). For example, a birthday celebration focuses on an individual and is secular insofar as it is not necessarily a religious ritual or celebration, while a Catholic child’s first communion event would also be at the level of the individual but within a religious or liturgical realm. Yet, the Latin@ birthday or first communion celebration includes certain elements found in the larger hegemonic cultural group of the United States across Latinidades: a birthday cake, a birthday song (sometimes two in the case of Mexican American celebrations such as the ones I often attend in Texas where singing “Happy Birthday” is followed by Las Mañanitas), and often a piñata (a phenomenon that seems to be in the process of crossing over as I have seen them appear outside of Latin@ birthday celebrations). (As an aside, I would point to the fact that the impact of the “Happy Birthday” song sung in Spanish at birthday parties in Spain can be interpreted as a process of cultural migration.) So at each level of the concentric circles we find feasts and celebrations that can be either secular or liturgical. As purely secular events, constructed celebrations that commemorate or celebrate military or political events as well as national celebrations of a hero’s birthday, such as Presidents’ Day or Martin Luther King Day, perform a different function. Secular community celebrations can be Founders’ Day or other origin stories such as San Antonio’s Canary Islanders celebration, or the State
118
NORMA E. CANTÚ
of Texas celebration of Texas Independence. As a whole the Latin@ community celebrates, at the level of the hemisphere, Día de la Raza or as it is known in the United States, Columbus Day, on October 12, a celebration that indigenous people in the Americas are wont to eschew—often there are “counter-celebrations.” For instance, in Uruguay, the feast celebrating the end of European rule is called Día de la Resistencia Indígena. Beyond the level of the self, however, at the level of the nation state, we find a constructed celebration that ostensibly commemorates the Latinidades in the United States—the month-long celebration of Hispanic heritage. This constructed event began as a week-long celebration under President Lyndon B. Johnson in 1968 and was established in its current format under President Reagan twenty years later. I first learnt of this celebration when I moved to D.C. in 1993 and worked for a government agency. It was then that I discovered that there was a month set aside to celebrate the culture, history, and contributions of the Hispanic community in the United States. The celebration included the requisite parade, and various Latino groups in the D.C. area participated. However small the contingent, the parade had representation from Dominican, Peruvian, and, of course, a larger presence of Puerto Rican, Salvadoreño, and Mexican American participants. Fiestas Patrias celebrations for a number of countries fall within this month, and commemorate Independence Day on September 15 in Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, and Nicaragua and on September 16 in Mexico and on September 18 in Chile. A fiesta that celebrates the overthrow of a colonial empire implies an ethnocentric and often nationalist fervor, although not always so. Even now, fifteen years later, the celebration is not widely known, except in school and in government offices. Some communities and institutions such as Knoxville, Tennessee, or El Paso Community College, El Paso, Texas, observe Hispanic Heritage Month with a pan-Latino community celebration. Such constructed celebrations, usually sponsored by a governmental or institutional organism, by definition become in-group identity affirming events as do nationalist celebrations such as Fourth of July, Texas Independence Day, Memorial Day, or Veterans Day that celebrate the nation-state as a unit. Among the secular fiestas, we also find those that are designed to instill group identity. The celebration of George Washington’s Birthday in Laredo, Texas, is perhaps the oddest but clearest example of this.11 Additionally, some celebrations have traveled from one to country to the other; the Día del niño (Day of the Child) celebrated in Mexico on April 30 is now celebrated in the United States on the same day. The first such celebration was organized in 1997 when the poet Pat Mora and the librarian Oralia Garza de Cortés teamed up to establish the celebration. Of course, as I bring up El Día del Niño, I must mention Mother’s Day, which in most Latino communities
TRADITIONAL CULTURAL EXPRESSIONS
119
is celebrated on May 10, while the United States celebrates it on the second Sunday in May. Mother’s Day in Mexico and, consequently, in many celebrations in greater Mexico involves a day-long observance with children and adults honoring mothers with poetry, flowers, gifts, and other ceremonial behavior. Schools often have programs where children declaim poetry memorized for the special occasion and adults sport either a red or white flower, usually a carnation, in honor of their mother; the latter is for someone whose mother has passed on and the red honors a living mother. Other celebrations that fall within the secular realm are those that commemorate special dates such as New Year’s Eve. The many traditional practices around the latter include special meals, practices, and behaviors that exist in the United States, such as bacalado (cod) for the New Year’s Eve dinner that many combine with black-eyed peas, the practice of wearing certain garments—red underwear—for good luck, or of sweeping the house, or of eating twelve grapes at the stroke of midnight. But many secular feasts coincide with religious feast days as well. Many towns keep the tradition of celebrating the patron saint’s day even when they are away from their community, as is the case with the Los Angeles celebration of the Guelaguetza. In many other communities, the saint’s day celebrations date back to the Spanish conquest. Such is the case in Bernalillo, New Mexico, where it is San Lorenzo that has been celebrated from August 9 to August 11 for over 300 years, with matachines dancing and religious and secular events such as a mass and a social dance.12
Religious or Liturgical Celebrations The San Lorenzo celebration in Bernalillo falls during the religious feasts at the local level but outside of the liturgical calendrical feast dates for the Catholic Church. The fiestas patronales, or saints’ day festivals, are the most common form of religious celebrations at the level of the community; they are numerous throughout Europe and the Americas. Of course, the liturgical calendar feast days around the Catholic Church cycle are celebrated across the Latinidades since the majority of Latin@s are culturally Catholic, whether lapsed or not. I focus on the Catholic liturgical calendar, but obviously all religious groups hold special feasts or commemorate certain dates or events; thus, Latin@ Jewish and Buddhist practitioners would celebrate different feast days. I further limit my observations to the folk Catholic celebrations, first acknowledging the formal church celebrations. The cycle begins with the Christmas cycle that can be said to begin on December 12 in Mexico, with the celebration of la Virgen de Guadalupe.13 The liturgical cycle dictates the religious celebrations according to the Catholic Church’s feast days: from Christmas through Easter and to
120
NORMA E. CANTÚ
Corpus Christi, these global celebrations cross national and hemispheric borders and are not particular to Latin@s. However, the folk celebrations associated with each are distinct and unique for various Latinidades. For example, the observance of misa de gallo, or midnight mass on Christmas Eve, is part of the folk religious celebration for although attendance at mass is obligatory, since it is a feast day, there is no requirement that it be held at midnight. Indeed nowadays, many church services begin as early as 10 p.m. on Christmas Eve. On the other hand, some quite secular aspects of religious feast day celebrations are similar to the various elements of Easter celebrations in South Texas where the cascarónes, colorfully dyed and confetti-filled eggshells, are decorated and then broken on people’s heads on Easter Sunday. Among the fiestas patronales, that is, the feasts that are off the calendar of official feasts within the Catholic Church’s liturgical calendar, I would like to focus briefly on the vejigantes in Loiza, Puerto Rico, celebrating the Fiesta de Santiago Apóstol (Feast of St. James the Apostle) on July 25. The vejigantes, the clownishly clad masked characters of Ponce, differ somewhat from those found in Loíza. For one, in Ponce they form part of the Carnival festivities, a liturgical calendar celebration; additionally, the masking tradition differs somewhat from the vejigante masks in Loíza. In doing some very brief research on the fiesta, I observed several elements that lead me to situate the festival within the fiestas patronales and folk religious celebrations at a local level. The Fiestas de Santiago lasts ten days or so, with parades featuring traditional bomb