10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palg...
28 downloads
1924 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Imagining the Black Female Body
Scarring the Black Body: Race and Representation in African American Literature James Baldwin’s Go Tell It on the Mountain: Historical and Critical Essays America and the Black Body
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Also by Carol E. Henderson
Reconciling Image in Print and Visual Culture Edited by Carol E. Henderson
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Imagining the Black Female Body
imagining the black female body Copyright © Carol E. Henderson, 2010.
First published in 2010 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN® in the United States—a division of St. Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010 Where this book is distributed in the UK, Europe and the rest of the world, this is by Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN: 978-0-230-10705-2 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Imagining the Black female body : reconciling image in print and visual culture / edited by Carol E. Henderson. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-230-10705-2 (alk. paper) 1. African American women in popular culture. 2. African American women—Social conditions. 3. Self-perception in women—United States. 4. Women—United States—Identity. I. Henderson, Carol E., 1964– E185.86.I49 2010 305.48’896073–dc22
2010017572
Design by Scribe Inc. First edition: December 2010 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
All rights reserved.
For my nieces, Lelycia, Tatyana, and Kiara.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
May you always imagine yourselves as beautiful as you are.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
This page intentionally left blank
List of Figures
ix
Acknowledgments Introduction: Public Property: On Black Women, Bodies, and First Lady Michelle Obama Carol E. Henderson
xi 1
∞
1
2
3
Racing Sex—Sexing Race: The Invention of the Black Feminine Body Kaila Adia Story Disembodiments: Ellen Gallagher’s Watery Metamorphoses Ana Nunes Stigmata: Embodying the Scars of Slavery Venetria K. Patton
23
45 59
∞∞
4
5
6
“Pull Up to the Bumper”: Fashion and Queerness in Grace Jones’s One Man Show Maria J. Guzman Images That Sell: The Black Female Body Imag(in)ed in 1960s and 1970s Magazine Ads Michelle L. Filling Four Women, For Women: Black Women—All Grown Up Debra A. Powell-Wright
79
95 109
∞∞∞
7
The Lower Stratum of History: The Grotesque Comic Stereotypes of Suzan-Lori Parks and Kara Walker Julie Burrell
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
123
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Contents
viii Contents
9
Navel-Erasing: Androgyny and Self-Making in Toni Morrison’s Song of Solomon and Jamaica Kincaid’s The Autobiography of My Mother Stacie Selmon McCormick “If Rigor Is Our Dream”: The Re-Membering of Violence by Black Women Writers of the Harlem Renaissance Zetta Elliott
145
163
Afterword: “You . . . You Remind Me of . . .”: A Black Feminist’s Rejection of the White Imagination Maria del Guadalupe Davidson
191
Contributors
207
Index
211
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
8
4.1
Grace Jones dressed in a “power suit” (1981).
83
4.2
Grace Jones performing “Trust in Me” at Meltdown Festival.
87
7.1
Kara Walker, The End of Uncle Tom and the Grand Allegorical Tableau of Eva in Heaven, 1995.
130
7.2
Kara Walker, Slavery! Slavery! Presenting a GRAND and LIFELIKE Panoramic Journey into Picturesque Southern Slavery or “Life at ‘Ol’ Virginny’s Hole’ (sketches from Plantation Life).” See the Peculiar Institution as never before!
138
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Figures
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
This page intentionally left blank
A project of this magnitude has roots in many places. I would be remiss if I didn’t thank those women whose ancestral wisdom has been my grounding, my saving grace: to my grandmothers Mrs. Mable Marbley and Mrs. Bertha Henderson who, during their lifetimes, prayed for me when I didn’t know who a “me” was—I love you. May this academic exercise reflect the wealth of your vision for me and honor your legacy. To my mom, Barbara Marbley Henderson, my sister, LaTonya Johnson, and my nieces, Lelycia, Tatyana, and Kiara—thanks for being my grounding, my inspiration, and my biggest fans! Your faith and love is where I draw my energy from. To my colleagues in the struggle, women whose intellectual prowess has engaged this scholar on so many levels in the fields of feminist and womanist studies, of African American and Africana studies, of film, literary, and popular culture—to Trudier Harris, Mary Helen Washington, Patricia Hill Collins, bell hooks, Hortense Spillers, Karla Holloway, Farah Jasmine Griffin, Toni Morrison, Sonia Sanchez, Charlotte PierceBaker, Kimberle Crenshaw, Deborah Willis, Carla Williams, Paule Marshall, Gloria Naylor, Rita Dove, Ann Petry, T. Sharpley-Whiting, Maggie Anderson, and others too numerous to name here—thank you for moving me and countless others to embody the spirit of sankofa as we look to the past for guidance in order to imagine a world where all women can be who they really are regardless of race, status, creed, or color. To my colleagues in the English department and in Women’s Studies at the University of Delaware—your belief in my academic pursuits is greatly appreciated. To my mentor and friend, Emory Elliott, whose absence in this world leaves a huge hole in the hearts of many—may this project honor your magnanimous spirit of goodwill toward humanity and its ability to be and do better. To my colleagues in Black American Studies and to my kindred spirits in the Center for Black Culture—thanks for being my home away from home, and a place for intellectual renewal and redirection. Grateful acknowledgment is given to Drs. Alvina Quintana and Ed Guerrero, who graciously shared the artistic vision of their lovely angel,
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Acknowledgments
Nanù Paloma Guerrero, with this editor. Her artwork graces the cover of this book, letting me know that the spirit lives on past the flesh. To the wonderful staff in the Office of Communication and Marketing at the University of Delaware, particularly Cheryl Cunningham, and seniorphotographer Kathy Atkinson and her assistant Amber Alexander, for making Nanù’s artwork come alive through digital image. Thank you for your sensitivity to the matter. To the departments of English and Black American Studies, specifically Matt Kinservik and James Jones, and to Deans Ann Ardis and George Watson in the College of Arts and Sciences—thank you, thank you, thank you for providing key financial support at a crucial moment in this project. To the wonderful photographers and art establishments who allowed us to use their images in this volume: to Richard of UrbanImage Media Limited in London, England; to photographers Jennifer Beeston, Gene Pittman, Dave Sweeney, and Sikkema Jenkins & Company; and especially artist Kara Walker—your collegiality is a breath of fresh air! And a special thank you is extended to the staff at Palgrave Macmillan, particularly editor Brigitte Shull who shared my vision and shepherded this book to print. Thank you for providing a welcome space for the sister voices contained herein. I would like to thank, as well, her administrative assistant, Lee Norton, who handled my technical concerns with humility and grace. My appreciation is also given to the outside reviewers who, with a keen eye, mapped an amendable plan for all concerned with this project. Thank you for respecting the unique voices of the essayists presented here. To the contributors of this volume, thank you for taking this journey with me, for digging deep into the recesses of your minds and spirits to find that common voice that speaks to the humanity in all of us. This collection is a testament to our collective chorus—unique and multifaceted voices on one accord—and what a song we sing! To the undergraduate and graduate students who took my black women’s writers courses at the University of Delaware—thank you for inspirited conversations! Your passion for black women—your interest in their lives and their well-being—gives me a hope that the future of women’s studies rests in good hands. For the men in my life, Leroy and Kels, I love you. Thank you for providing a wonderful space for me to spread my intellectual wings. Your love is my safe haven. For my brother Bobby, I miss you terribly. For my cohorts in SOS (Saving Our Sisters—Saving Ourselves!) at Beautiful Gate Outreach Center, and my sistahgirls in Bethel’s Women Bible Study in Wilmington, Delaware—I love and cherish you for your sincerity, encouragement, hugs, and spiritual strength—and for reminding me of my divine purpose.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
xii Acknowledgments
And finally to the sistahs I meet every day, and especially to those sistahs I stood in welfare lines with back in the day in South Central, Los Angeles—imagining a better day for ourselves and our children—to those of us struggling with ghosts that seem stronger and bigger than us, and to those sistahs still in the captive cycle of poverty, disillusionment, despair, and frustration—we hope one day the load will get lighter, the road a little brighter, and we pray for you a better day.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Acknowledgments xiii
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
This page intentionally left blank
Public Property On Black Women, Bodies, and First Lady Michelle Obama Carol E. Henderson
Identity often comes down to the meanings that are attached to bodies when they are rendered as objects of vision . . . Vision and the visual are western tools of social ordering. —Charmaine A. Nelson, The Color of Stone: Sculpting the Black Female Subject in Nineteenth-Century America
B
y now, the image has been firmly lodged in the cultural lexicon of international politics and in the minds of countless individuals here in the United States and abroad. The illustration is startling: Michelle Obama is depicted being tortured and branded by the Ku Klux Klan in a disturbing artistic rendition posted on the “progressive” liberal blog site The Daily Kos. For fear of giving too much room for the devil to play, I will not reproduce the visual image here, but I will provide the props for you to stage an image of this picture in your own mind’s eye: Michelle Obama is shown tied to a tree by her hands in a scarlet dress unzipped (or torn) to the tailbone, just below the small of her back. Her face is tilted toward the viewer in fear as she feels the heat from a branding iron that will soon be applied to her scarless back. The red dress she is wearing is form fitting, and the Klansmen appear in the same frame in typical attire—white hoods and robes—only their lustful eyes and hands are visible. The top of the poster reads “Fear Mongering
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Introduction
and Race Baiting.” The next line, “Our New Hi Tech Southern Strategy” appears in bold yellow and red lettering, as if emerging from a smoldering flame. The phrase “To Burn the Middle Class” appears above a burning cross. The poster states that this advertisement is “sponsored by the David Duke Fan Club.” The name of the artist of this photoplay, One Citizen, also appears in the bottom left-hand corner of the poster. Although the colors of yellow and red dominate the lettering of the poster, the narrative of black and white relations (Michelle Obama’s exposed black skin and the Klan’s nameless and faceless white robed members) sends a chilling message of just how far we have not progressed in our social interactions. The fact that Michelle Obama was imagined in this way is not surprising. When then junior Senator Barack Obama announced his candidacy for the presidential race in February 2007, attention swiftly turned to the woman who could become America’s next First Lady. And that, in and of itself, was an oxymoron. As op-ed columnist Maureen Dowd speculates, some Republicans, Democrats, and other unseemly constituents in our free America were so unnerved by the thought of a black woman becoming First Lady that they dedicated themselves to “painting Michelle as a female version of Jeremiah Wright, an angry black woman, the disgruntled, lecturing ‘Mrs. Grievance,’ depicted on the cover of the National Review” (Dowd). These characteristic nods to the controlling images1 of a hate-filled b——h or an emasculating Sapphire—images meant to fuel America’s paranoia and pathological obsession with bodies that are not in their “proper place”—foreshadows the now infamous July 2008 cover of The New Yorker that paints Obama as a flag-burning Muslim and his wife as a gun-toting, Afrowearing militant. Although alleged to be satirical in nature, this cover had the same effect as the One Citizen portrait—both reframed the image of Michelle Obama as either hypervulnerable or hyperaggressive. Such opposing yet similar views of America’s current First Lady place her squarely in a hundreds old cultural legacy that has the images of black women grotesquely caricatured in America’s Grammar Book.2 Unable to touch her actual body, individuals resort to a racial and gendered politics that mutilates and disfigures her public persona. These tactics, reminiscent of the politics of old, reveal the ways in which the black female body has been inscribed with an array of social meanings that amplify “the racially xenophobic tendencies that are redistributed and recycled in mass-mediated cultural practices” (Jackson 9). These “tendencies” permit commentators, television analysts, news
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
2 Carol E. Henderson
journalists, and others to write provocative and troubling assessments of Michelle Obama’s hair, her butt, her arms, her legs, her hips, and her intellectual acuities.3 As cultural historian Arica Coleman reiterates, America’s anxiety with Michelle Obama is located not only in the fact that she is “undeniably, and to some, unforgivably black” (Coleman), but also in the fact that, as a black woman, her blackness places her outside the “acceptable” conceptualizations of womanhood that have historically made black women the monstrous Other, and white women the worthier emblems of virtue and beauty. As one racist commentator scowls, “Absolutely pathetic . . . to make any comparison between this near-illiterate, anti-White Negress and a realfirst-lady, Jackie Kennedy, shows how classless, illiterate, and frighteningly delusional her supporters are” (Holland). The visceral nature of these portrayals in print and visual media speaks for itself. Detached from her myriad of accomplishments as a successful attorney and businesswoman, wife, and mother, Michelle Obama is reduced to flesh—a recoded conglomerate of signs and symbols that re-present to the American public an embodied figure in language it is familiar with. Carla Peterson has stated elsewhere that the black woman’s body in the nineteenth century “coheres around notions of the self-effacing body” (20). That is, the black woman’s body is always public, always exposed. In contrast, her white female counterparts of the nineteenth century, those women deemed worthy to define notions of femininity, purity, and morality—were hidden away, their bodies situated in the privacy of the domestic sphere. This tension between white cultural constructions of the black female body as overexposed, abject, and grotesque, and black female public speakers like Mary Ann Shadd Cary and Sojourner Truth, whose public speeches made them vulnerable to the distorted gazes of a sanctimonious listening audience, leads Peterson to conclude, “The black female body might well have functioned as what Elaine Scarry has called the ‘body in pain,’ whereby the powerless become voiceless bodies subject to pain and dominated by the bodiless voices of those in power” (21). One can certainly extend Peterson’s theoretical reach to the twenty-first century as depictions of black women along this historical path—from Harriet Jacobs to Oprah Winfrey—signal a stubborn unwillingness on the public’s part to move beyond the extreme binaries of Madonna/whore or Sapphire/mammy when framing the black female body. Analogously, notions of nationhood and womanhood coalesce around the tall and assured personage of Michelle Obama as she assumes an iconic role in our national (and
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 3
indeed) global communities as the First Lady. Her very presence challenges the brutal and racist stereotypes of our nation’s history that say black women can serve but not be the First Lady. Michelle Obama is certainly not the first (nor will she be the last) black woman placed on the dissecting table of America’s salacious and troubling racial experience. Examples abound in our national and international archives of the sinister ways in which the black female body is probed and catalogued, watched and desired, named and misnamed. One cannot help but recall, at this moment, the troubling legacy of South African Sarah Baartman, whose unmoving image, the “Hottentot Venus,” set the stage for Western constructions of the black female body. Her life reminds us of the egregious license taken with her body during her life and upon her death, and how the scientific “inquiries” of French naturalist Georges Cuvier—who preserved Baartman’s skeleton, and placed her brain and her genitalia in a jar and then presented them to the Musée de l’Homme for public display in Paris, France, as evidence that African women were the missing link between animals and humans—provided the material for sociopolitical scripts of race, gender, and sexuality. These cultural strongholds continue to place black women like Michelle Obama in linguistic and social fetters to the extent that the sexual and gendered implications of such interplays between public and private ways of “knowing” the intimate areas of black women’s femininity unveils the social industry built on the erotic and spiritual vulnerabilities of these same black female subjects. bell hooks calls it “consumer cannibalism” (“Eating the Other” 31). Sharon Patricia Holland puts it another way in Raising the Dead: “Consistently hovering between ‘sapphire’ and ‘mammy,’ black women are a danger both to themselves and their communities. Mammies if we don’t speak and Sapphires when we do, black women occupy a category of being like no other self in literature or in reality. We are so malleable, so brilliantly represented as a constant within our stubborn inconsistency that we can be manipulated while remaining simultaneously resistant to all attempts at regulation” (41). Holland goes on to say, given the quagmire of theorizing and reading black women and their “texts” (and here I would include the black female body as text), how does one formulate a useful theoretical subjectivity that “dances our way out of our constriction” (42)? Holland’s creative and ingenious riffing of Funk group Parliament’s4 1978 signature song “One Nation under a Groove” provides a wonderful segue into the creative and theoretical intent of our current study. Imagining the Black Female Body is a collection of essays committed to
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
4 Carol E. Henderson
exploring the revolutionary and subtle ways black women and their allies have sought to speak their unique embodied experiences in print and visual culture. When invoking the term “body,” in conjunction with its other descriptives, black and female, we understand the inextricable link between idea and subject formation and the historic conditions that shape our perceptions of flesh and bone. It is, however, the variety of venerable codings that move the body from flesh to its figurative manifestation as metaphor within certain cultural and artistic settings that offers the most illuminating glimpse into the persistent and likewise flexible free-associative signs of black women’s personal (internal) and communal (external) experiences. As metaphor, the black woman’s body brings into focus a gathering of social realities that evaluates how meticulously interwoven the political is to the social, the literal is to the figurative, so much so that, as Hortense Spillers states elsewhere, “distinctions between them are virtually useless” (68). Our contributors have sought creative ways out of this quagmire, as the borderland space between the literal and figurative provides fertile ground for tilling alternative perspectives of the black female body, both in terms of her relationship to herself and her community, and in terms of her representations in her own mind’s eye and in society at large. In interrogating the nexus that had most early feminist studies minimize or completely ignore the unique experiences of black women by focusing primarily on white female bodies or the dominant stereotypical images black women struggle against (in some cases, impotently), our contributors bear witness to the recovery efforts of artists and critics who excavate this historical terrain with the primary intent of discovering how those misdeeds done to the black female body get reshaped in the literary and cultural imaginary. Analogously, the devaluation of the black female body in slavery serves as a reflective mirror into the social, legal, and economic binds that refigured the black female subject as flesh and established a symbolic order of rhetorical and literal gesturing that ruptured spirit from flesh, mind from body. The current state of race relations, particularly as it relates to black womanhood, suggests that the images that emerge from these racially charged discussions link the contemporary dynamics of black sexual politics with that of the historical legacy of black women’s treatment in this country. Thus, we privilege these links between history, culture, and creativity. Moreover, the black female body becomes a holistic being in this volume, both in intent and in deed as artist and theorist suture together a vision of this body—mind, flesh, and spirit—that will make speculative
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 5
and creative movements “out of this constriction,” and restore the primary vision of black women—their courage, dignity, communal responsibility, and pride. This volume, then, emphasizes the importance of self-representation and the critical recovery of voices relegated to the margins. As bell hooks makes poignantly clear, the act of “talking back” for the disempowered—the marginalized—precipitates one’s movement from object to subject. It is a necessary requirement for claiming a self (Talking Back 9). It is in this move, then, that black women become the subjects of their own inquiry and the objects of their own studies, changing and challenging the words, criticism, and theories used to evaluate their work and their personhood. Our collection is specific in its reach. It does not attempt to recover the ground that has been so aptly tilled by other outstanding volumes on this subject.5 Rather, what we hope to do is explore the contours of these conversations, the continuities and discontinuities of black women’s subjectivity and agency in a world that places the physical self in direct contact with images and their vices. In assuaging how the word is made flesh, how images take on a life of their own, we do the necessary work of reconstituting metalevels of meaning and being in black women’s embodied experiences. Black women’s expressivity then becomes a multilayered enterprise. It is liberating and similarly confining, healing and likewise painful, for such engagements in the simultaneity of multiple and shifting and self-contradictory representations necessitate unique and sometimes troubling conversations. These discussions are by no means, however, the decisive antidote to the black woman’s condition. If anything, these inquiries reveal the contradictory impulses of using a body that is marked and likewise coded. As Hortense Spillers reminds us, in the retrieval of mutilated black female bodies, the critic and artist must, in a very real sense, reenact the very moment he or she is envisioning (69). In other words, we all share in the disfiguring and refiguring of the black female body with our pens because, as Sharon Patricia Holland points out, “What we have come to know experientially as the ‘truth’—about ourselves and others—is embedded in the dangerous crevices of the father’s tongue, the national language” (47). That said, our attempts at reconstituting alternative meanings for the embodied experiences of black women spring from the philosophical understanding of revisiting, in some cases, the original site of violation in order to redirect attention to the literal and physical ways this body is rebuilt in our cultural imaginary. The ritualistic manner in which authors reconcile their views on the
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
6 Carol E. Henderson
images they create in their narratives demarcates the theoretical arena in which the critic may “enter in” to forge a language—a code, a sign, a vision—that is not only salve for the wounded black female body but also a mechanism that reestablishes the integrity of the black female self in our literary and public spaces. Thus the representations of black women in art, literature, and culture perform a delicate and challenging dance of redemption—a redemption necessary to flesh out the precarious dynamics of being black and female at the turn of this century. This collection is divided into three units, or clusters. Each cluster considers not only the overall intent of this project—imagining the black female body—but also fulfills the theoretical and conceptual purpose inherent in its own unit, dispelling the myth that there is only one way to read the body or black women’s identity. The boundaries between each unit are not set in stone—they are porous. This fluidity establishes an eclectic yet purposeful methodological function of stimulating conversations across disciplines. In this practice, chapters address issues of identity and representation in literary, cultural, and historical mediums as they suggest provocative and innovative ways to redirect existing discourse on the black female body. In the first section, “Making,” Ana Nunes, Venetria K. Patton, and Kaila Adia Story return the focus of this project to the nineteenth century as they reevaluate racist medical practices and historical and cultural institutions that helped to frame black women’s embodied experiences here and abroad. These authors embark on a Morrisonian journey to “raise the dead,” as Sharon Patricia Holland suggests, as they undertake the necessary steps to retrieve imaginary and real black female bodies from a national border filled with the body parts of our foremothers. As Holland makes clear, “the dead” are not just those subjects who exist beyond or within the alternative universes of the living and the dying; “the dead” are transgressive bodies that are empowered to speak to the cultural and national phenomenon of figurative silencing and/or social and historical erasures that pepper our national and international archives. The writers, critics, and artists here realize that in “raising the dead,” their subjects have agency in the physical bodies created—an agency that allows them to tell their stories “of . . . deathin-life” (Holland 4). In “Stigmata: Embodying the Scars of Slavery,” Patton turns her critical eye toward the retelling of slavery, suggesting, as Deborah McDowell does, that while the majority of contemporary novels written about
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 7
it emphasize what was done to the bodies of slave women, what these novels also show is how black women processed what was done to them in ways that “talk back” to a history that has silenced their pain. According to Barbara Omolade, the gender-specific commodification of African women during slavery caused the industry and its white master to use every part of her. She was a fragmented being—a thing: “her head and her heart were separated from her back and her hands and divided from her womb and her vagina” (7). Patton charts how writers like Phyllis Alesia Perry reinhabit this disfigured being as a way of exploring and rewriting the meaning of the African American female body. In particular, Patton focuses on Perry’s protagonist, Lizzie, whose body bears the stigmatic markings of slavery upon reading her great-greatgrandmother Ayo’s diary. Using multilayered flashbacks and a cyclical sense of time within the body of the narrative itself, Perry re-members, that is pieces together, the story of chattel bondage along matrilineal lines because, as “maker and marker of boundaries,” the mother’s body is “reproducer of the group as a social body” (Doyle 27) and comes to signify, in many instances, “a bodily and collective past” (Doyle 6). This multilayering of bodies—in both written and physical forms (Perry’s book and her protagonist in the book)—points up the uncanny ways the black female body is language itself, a portal into a complicated social history where “black female bodies serve as the principal point of passage between humanity and nonhumanity as well as the articulation of that passage.”6 Perry utilizes these complex signs of flesh, body, and gender to form a remembrance of slavery grounded not only in the identity formation of a people but also in the collective body of womanness as the scars encircling Lizzie’s wrists and ankles and crisscrossing her back some one hundred years later make visible what is not visible—the genealogical begetting of the psychological wounds of slavery. Moreover, in making her characters three-dimensional, Patton concludes, as does Perry, that the scarred black body serves “as an active metaphor for the reinvention of African American subjectivity within certain cultural moments” (Henderson 7). Despite the pain associated with remembering the horrific experiences of slavery, remembering allows one to piece one’s self together— mind, body, and spirit—along the sutures of communal, familial, and cultural ties that keep the past ever present as a reminder of the unyielding and indomitable spirit of a people determined to survive. In “Disembodiments: Ellen Gallagher’s Watery Metamorphoses,” Nunes investigates the hybrid and mutable models of the black self that
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
8 Carol E. Henderson
appear in the Coral Cities series of African American artist Ellen Gallagher. Nunes argues that Gallagher sees the body as a vehicle “to explore the imprints of black history in the African American consciousness.” This is particularly accurate for figurations of the Middle Passage that appear in the artworks of Gallagher and Howardena Pindell, who use the figurative body as a narrative thread to establish a link between the disembodied ancestors who appear as broken figures in their work, and the contemporary self who must piece these figures together in the cultural imaginary. As such, Gallagher’s Coral Cities series reimagines the black Atlantic as Drexciya, a mythological aquatic world inhabited by the descendants of pregnant slaves who were either thrown over or plunged to their deaths during the Middle Passage. In many of these works, the mother is represented as a disembodied female head “no longer confined to the ship’s hold . . . no longer whole or together, [but] rather dispersed in the genealogical map of the Americas—fragmented and mutilated.” The unborn children of these captives emerge as halfhuman, half-fish beings who have adapted to the new water environment in utero. Nunes suggests that, for Gallagher, the aquatic is the ideal setting for transforming African and African American history— thus the use of human and aquatic forms to exemplify the postmodern markers of hybridity, mutability, and fragmentation—requisite elements for metamorphosis and change. In “Racing Sex—Sexing Race: The Invention of the Black Feminine Body,” Story traces the perception of black women’s bodies and their behavior through two centuries of Western and European thought. Finding her inspiration in the wounded and puzzled faces of her black female students who felt that contemporary depictions of them in commercial hip-hop music videos “gave them a bad name,” Story confirms that the African and/or black female body was converted ideologically into the construction she terms “the black feminine body.” “If we think of the body as a corporeal (physical) text that can be read by ‘dominant’ and ‘subordinate’ bodies through a sociopolitical and differential gaze,” writes Story, “then we can begin to understand how for centuries (European) Western society has valued certain bodies and suppressed others.” Story’s ideological investigation of these values is extensive in her chapter. She traces the presumed corporeal differences of peoples back to the early 1400s, weaving together an important historiographic tapestry of exclusion based on the flesh. This global framing in the Americas, the Caribbean, Europe, and Africa had an impact on the linguistic systems of many nations as people became known not
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 9
for their humanity but for their differences, and more importantly, this framing helped to shape the commercial trafficking of human flesh, and as Story reiterates, over time the African female body (her sexual organs in particular) “began to represent the animal side of humanity, and sometimes their sexual organs were directly linked to that of apes.” Such vile and disturbing assessments of African people means our very language, and the imagination that produced it, must be reinvented in ways that not only acknowledge these historical projections placed on the black body, but reinscribes the performances of this feminine being within alternative coded systems. As Charmaine Nelson makes clear, symbol making, be it visual, psychological, or ontological, “indicates the body’s or subject’s process of materialization.” Narratives then become “indexes of the legitimization and moral interpretation” of these subjects, a process used by artists and audiences alike to help facilitate the process of viewership (xiii). In section two, “UnMaking,” Maria J. Guzman, Michelle L. Filling, and Debra A. Powell-Wright consider the nuanced and revolutionary practices of artists Grace Jones, Nina Simone, and Talib Kweli as each harnesses the symbolic power of the lyrical and the visual to reconstitute the black female form. Disassembling such categories as “male,” “female,” and “transgender,” Guzman, in particular, unmasks the normative methodological apparatuses that fuse performance with subjectivity in art and theater. Guzman’s critique of Grace Jones’s gender-bending, haute couture antics in her chapter “‘Pull Up to the Bumper’: Fashion and Queerness in Grace Jones’s One Man Show” suggests the theatricality of style and fashion present an occasion for the black female body to be “bent”—superimposed—visually and conceptually with contradictory male and female signs. She argues that androgyny was a popular metaphor for bodily transformation in the 1980s. Jones’s employment of this practice made her a music and queer icon in popular culture, and afforded her the chance to accumulate new versions of identity through music and video technology. Although known to be heterosexual, Jones used the fashion and music industries to reshape her identity through visual imagery, indulging in what Guzman calls “the more visually baroque version of pansexuality.” This tactic was very effective for Jones because within certain American fashion circles, her ethnic features were considered too strong for American magazines. Within the global community, however, Jones enjoyed immense popularity as international companies used her to sell everything from hair spray to axle grease. Based on these divergent views of her body, Jones’s adoption of the body
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
10 Carol E. Henderson
of androgyny integrates its own desires within gendered law because, as Guzman states, this body fails to regulate its behavior “in order to reproduce the heterosexual model.” This subversive behavior flirts with the spectacular, and Jones risks having her differences exploited as she is exotified within the common marketplace of the flesh. But it is Jones’s willingness to “blur the line between sexual identities known through popular culture” that gives her the rhetorical power to comment on the complex and troubling history of race in the Western culture—particularly as it relates to the primitivism of the black female body. As Guzman concludes, “The locus of primitivism was the black female body, which became the harbinger for a savage sexuality that exceeded the limits of representation.” Jones’s performances in One Man Show stretch these limits as she becomes object and subject in her own show. But it is exactly this twining, coupled with her provocative interplay of history and narrative, that allows Jones’s work to “attain its own rhetoric of power.” In “Images That Sell: The Black Female Body Imag(in)ed in 1960s and 1970s Magazine Ads,” Filling extends the lenses of progressive black sexual politics to include an examination of the standards of beauty that govern the various ways black women’s bodies were imagined in magazine advertisements in the popular culture of the 1960s and 1970s. According to Filling, the iconography of black beauty became intertwined with the social and political aesthetics of the Black Power movement as the Afro, silk blouse, and leather jacket reentered mainstream America as symbols of black liberation. Black women’s bodies, situated in the beauty ads of that time, became reflectors of this cultural interplay among politics, marketing, and consumer culture. Features such as hair and skin came to signify assimilation to white standards of beauty, or they could represent a departure from such conformity, presenting an opportunity to communicate “competing values about Blackness and beauty culture to both African American and white communities.” And, as Filling points out, while consumerism and capitalism appear to be the principal driving force behind beauty culture, “beauty culture has powerful implications for social, political, and cultural history,” and the appropriation of the black female body in these ads signaled these shifting power relations. In “Four Women, For Women: Black Women—All Grown Up,” Powell-Wright reenters the creative space of music as she tackles the physicality and cultural history of four archetypal African American women—Aunt Sarah, Siffronia, Sweet Thing, and Peaches—as
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 11
presented in the lyrical works of Nina Simone and Talib Kweli. Crossing the generational divide of the Black Arts Movement and hip-hop, Powell-Wright shows how Simone’s 1966 album Four Women created a black women’s aesthetic that not only represented the gender and sexual politics of the 1960s but also gave working-class black women— whose bodies disappeared in the libidinous wave of socialism and capitalism—a voice. Simone’s use of these images is not a mere mimicking of racist ideology, but rather a gesture to present a new understanding of black women’s sexual politics that reclaims sexuality for the greater social good. Thirty-four years later, Talib Kweli pays tribute to Simone’s revolutionary tactics with the final cut on his 2000 CD Train of Thought, titled “For Women.” Inspired by his chance meeting with 107-year-old “Aunt Sarah,” a woman he assists up the stairs after getting off the no. 2 train in Brooklyn, New York, Kweli channels Aunt Sarah’s ancestral voice to reflect on how the four black women in Simone’s day have evolved circa 2000. Kweli provides contemporary narratives for his portraits, portraits that demonstrate why Peaches is angry, for example, and why, despite her circumstances, she still has hope. Like Simone, Kweli celebrates the blackness of his women, the textures of their skin, their hair, and their lips—all signifiers that make them undesirable to some in the larger public forum. In providing Simone’s women with contemporary surrogates, Kweli echoes Simone’s song of love for black women as their spiritual expressivity gets “fleshed out” in lyrical form. Powell-Wright’s assessment of Simone’s and Kweli’s affirmation of black womanhood leads us to the last section of this collection, “ReMaking.” In it, Julie Burrell, Stacie Selmon McCormick, and Zetta Elliott engage in critical examinations of authors and artists whose work rematerializes the black female form through a dismantling of biological markers and their symbolic meanings. Blackness becomes transgressive in and of itself in this space—a frontier for each scholar to explore racial parody, disciplinary exclusion, and competing discourses of accuracy and authenticity when it comes to vision and representation. If identity comes down to meanings attached to objects of vision, and this vision has been central to keeping bodies and peoples in a particular social order, as Charmaine Nelson suggests in the epigraph to this chapter (xii), then the question becomes, can you use the Master’s Tools to dismantle his house?7 Burrell gets to the heart of this question in her chapter “The Lower Stratum of History: The Grotesque Comic Stereotypes of SuzanLori Parks and Kara Walker.” Burrell confronts the painful history of
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
12 Carol E. Henderson
grotesque and comic stereotypes that continue to haunt the artistic imaginary of black female artists, and speculates on Parks’s and Walker’s use of these images in their work. According to Burrell, Parks’s and Walker’s use of the grotesque and the abject reveal the critics’ ethical imperative: can such images work toward an antiracist agenda? The answer is complex in Burrell’s opinion. Parks and Walker risk critical and cultural condemnation in revisiting the very body they wish to reframe and restore on America’s public stage. Their excessive overtures at displaying this fantastic and phantasmagoric black female form, its overly sexualized and abused personage, its performance of lewd acts that include excretion and fellatio, suggests a painful acknowledgment of those heinous deeds done to this female body. Such examinations reconsider the complexities of performative agency, an agency compromised by the spectatorial politics of reobjectification when these deeds are married to the cultural narrative of the carnivalesque. It is the lower stratum “that both defecates and gives birth, reproduces and degenerates . . . that the topsy-turvy world of carnival turns all that is ‘high’ to ‘low,’” according to Burrell. Parks and Walker refuse to simply transform negative images into positive ones, for to do so reinscribes the racist vulgar with an other power. Rather, what Parks and Walker do is to force their audience to “dwell in the negative, in the lower stratum as it were, and emerge, not newly empowered, but scathed.” The penetrated black female body then becomes, in this instance, a mediated space, a body-text, that not only calls forth the humanity of black people but also exposes the pleasure gained by “spectatorship’s place in racist representation.” This intersubjectivity is an integral part of racialized meaning making. “To be human is to be sullied,” writes Burrell. And the art of Parks and Walker reminds us that “to deal with history humanely is to allow it to reach us with its polluting touch.” If the abject and the grotesque offer opportunities to confront the cultural trauma of racism and sexism at the heart of Parks’s and Walker’s ethical engagement of the representations of black people, then McCormick shows how Morrison and Kincaid translate into their works a transgressive black female body that is “fluid, ambiguous, unstable” in her chapter “Navel-Erasing: Androgyny and Self-Making in Toni Morrison’s Song of Solomon and Jamaica Kincaid’s The Autobiography of My Mother.” Using the critical work of Trinh Minh-Ha, who, as McCormick writes, encourages women writers to “write the body and write through the body in order to reappropriate femininity in a way that removes it from the traditional ideas of womanhood initiated and
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 13
sustained in large part by men,” McCormick charts the use of the navel in the fictions of Morrison and Kincaid, calling it a symbolic representative of self-expression and androgyny. For each, androgyny becomes a passageway to freedom and movement, a way of understanding the self and its relationship to the world. Navel-Erasing “is an act of forgetting without annihilating,” using the framework of one’s history to envision a different future uncircumscribed by the past. This act is literally embodied in Morrison’s character, Pilate Dead, and in Kincaid’s central character, Xuela. Pilate is self-birthed and self-created, as she has no physical navel because her mother dies at the moment of her birth. The agency gained from this self-act leads McCormick to conclude that Morrison’s authorial decision to make Pilate navelless with a degree of physical strength “is illustrative of her navigating between various states of being.” Kincaid’s central character, Xuela, negotiates the boundaries between life and death as well, as she is also born at the moment of her mother’s death. And like Pilate, Xuela becomes an orphan because her father “delivers” her to a laundry woman to rear. Xuela spends her life being passed around, her body even being used as an instrument of pleasure by Monsieur LaBatte. In order to reclaim her body from these forms of abuse, Xuela aborts the child that results from these “liaisons” in an act of defiance because, as McCormick argues, “laying claim to her body and her right to determine when she will bear children . . . signals that [Xuela] will not participate in . . . the reproduction of patriarchy.” Similarly, Xuela shifts into the category of “man” as she cuts off her hair and wears the clothes of a dead man to secure a job as a laborer. Kincaid’s creative gesture, like Morrison’s, allows their characters’ bodies to evolve over the course of the narratives. This declaration of self-rule, for the authors and their characters, means the unencumbered female body functions as an emblem of “revolutionary potential,” according to McCormick, and such revolutionary offerings present “new ways of thinking about black women’s bodies and what it means to write those bodies.” In “‘If Rigor Is Our Dream’: The Re-Membering of Violence by Black Women Writers of the Harlem Renaissance,” Zetta Elliott answers the call of critic Hortense Spillers, who issues a mandate calling for the “retrieval of mutilated female bodies” that lie disembodied across the manifold landscape of African American and American memory. Elliott grounds her exploration in the missing line from Countee Cullen’s poem “Heritage,” wherein he asks the question, “One three centuries removed / . . . . . . . . . . . . / What is Africa to me?” It is in this
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
14 Carol E. Henderson
reconfigured space—the elliptical void—that Elliott reconstitutes black women’s experiences and memories of historical pain, violence, and terror as the missing “middle” passage in Cullen’s text becomes their figurative “middle passage.” In short, Elliott frames the black female body as the material link for the immaterial presence of this absence. And, although pathologized as sexually deviant and abject, this female body registers real violence and terror as the traumas of black women (in the form of rape and lynching) are considered lesser historical subjects. Elliott demonstrates how Harlem Renaissance writers Marita Bonner, Georgia Douglas Johnson, and Jessie Redmon Fauset recapture this absence, making it a prominent objective in their works as they show how the spectacle of marking and branding transfers from one generation to another using the black female body as its substitute. Elliott uses Bonner’s “On Being Young—a Woman—and Colored” and other short stories to point up the social restraints of middle-class black women whose “inner space” is violated because “they watch their early desires and impulses die, smothered beneath the falsely calm demeanor required of all women by a racist and sexist bourgeois society.” Bonner goes on to say “that something is wrong with a world that stifles and chokes; that cuts off and stunts; hedging in, pressing down on eyes, ears and throat. Somehow all is wrong.” Utilizing Georgia Douglas Johnson’s play Blue Blood, Elliott focuses on the rape of black women—its physical, spiritual, and psychic damage. With Jessie Redmon Fauset’s novel Plum Bun, Elliott charts in acute detail the pain and trauma of “passing,” and the war that occurs in the body and psyche of black women who are physically “white” and spiritually “black” through blood. In the end, Elliott concludes that the writing and righting of the violence done to the black woman’s body during Reconstruction and beyond “enables the black female subject to operate as a conscious agent, one who is aware of her past and the wounds that are no longer visible upon her skin, but that are inflicted endlessly by a system of oppression that reveals itself only in subtle, symbolic substitutions.” Such a revelation replaces the absence in Cullen’s poem with figurative bodies who speak the meaning of Africa into a revised public discourse that both calls forth and empowers. Elliott’s efforts to designate space in the margins to speak the body whole lead us to our final chapter in this volume. In the afterword, Maria del Guadalupe Davidson takes the reader on a provocative and personal sojourn of the intellectual, spiritual, and physical costs of inhabiting the public female body. In “‘You . . . You Remind Me of . . .’:
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 15
A Black Feminist’s Rejection of the White Imagination,” Davidson recounts her intimate encounters with people who mistake her for comedian Whoopi Goldberg. Though Davidson is a professor, mother, and scholar, these qualities disappear in the known and more acceptable qualifier “black female comedian” because, like Cornel West’s contentious encounters with New York and New Jersey police,8 Davidson is rendered invisible—and hypervisible—because people refuse to see her. Her body is fixed, rendered knowable and public. So public in fact that, as Davidson recalls, “a crazed ‘frat’ boy grabbed and shook me, while screaming ‘Whoopi, Whoopi, Whoopi!’” After the assault ended, her attacker pushed her aside and walked off laughing with his friends. Strangers’ willingness to offensively touch her helps us to understand the underlying causes behind the failure to see black women as individuals. “Inasmuch as the black female body is supposedly a mysterious unapproachable entity,” writes Davidson, “controlling images serve to make that body comprehensible and controllable.” The result of such images (Davidson believes comedian Whoopi Goldberg embodies all four stereotypes of black womanhood) is the erasure of their very own being. Davidson’s solution for this sort of erasure is to use such incidents as teaching moments as we continue to use multiple mediums of expression—literature, film, art, and music—to give voice to “the plurality of the black female experience.” In this way, we can speak truth to power and provide a shared energy that allows black women to love themselves in all the colors and textures of the human rainbow we were created in. This collection goes a long way to demonstrate how the indomitable spirit of women of African ancestry becomes a catalyst for communal change. The contributors here—allies in revealing and dismantling the intricate network of forces that seek to devalue the black woman’s body and refashion her spirit into fragmented half-truths—acknowledge the delicate challenges black women face in their everyday lives. As Michelle Obama’s lived experiences have taught us, our bodies can become a text to be read—fondled—within other people’s distorted imagination. But this same body can be spiritually embraced—treasured—within the same social discussion. Anyone reading the volume of personal letters written to First Lady Michelle Obama realizes that millions of black women, in anticipation of her arrival at this unprecedented moment in history, walk into the White House with her through the blood of our ancestors. As one contributor writes on the back cover to the collection of letters Go Tell Michelle, “We are one woman, blessed to be born Black in America . . . I rejoice for every little girl, every teenager, young 10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
16 Carol E. Henderson
adult and yes, even every senior, who, like me, can look at you and see herself ” (Nevergold Seals and Brooks-Bertram). In exploring the various imaginings of the black female body in print and visual culture, it is hoped that the contradictory impulses of using a body that is marked and likewise coded, will give way to an alternative symphony of voices that honor the legacies of black women—both real and imagined. Notes 1. Here I am reminded of Patricia Hill Collins’s use of the term in Black Feminist Thought. Collins defines a “controlling image” as a central tool in “the political economy of domination fostering Black women’s oppression” (67). These images make certain “isms” appear “natural” (i.e., racism, sexism, classism), and they shore up the interlocking systems of race, class, and gender oppression. 2. This is a nod to Hortense Spillers’s provocative and landmark article, “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe: An American Grammar Book.” 3. Time would not permit me to evaluate the numerous articles available on these topics. One need only put “Michelle Obama and black female body” in a Google search and evaluate the commentary. While some critics have argued that Michelle Obama is a public figure and thus entitled to “evaluation,” no one can recall in recent years commentators focusing on the posteriors of other First Ladies. Disturbing as well is the global fascination with the hairstyles of the first children (both young ladies). 4. See the epigraph to Chapter 2, “Bakulu Discourse,” in Holland’s Raising the Dead to fully appreciate the ways she utilizes the lyrics to Funkadelic’s 1978 signature song, “One Nation Under a Groove.” 5. Our volume owes much of its creative energy to the stellar contributions of other outstanding studies on the black female body that came before us. Each of these volumes, in its unique way, has continued the long and vibrant tradition of showing the precarious position the black woman’s body occupies in African American and American culture and the creative ways black women have attempted to wrest control away from those systems that seek to distort their personage. Our study extends these conversations, demonstrating that the past is never too far away when assessing the material and spiritual importance of the black female body. This list includes, but is not limited to, such works as Michael Bennett’s and Vanessa D. Dickerson’s Recovering the Black Female Body: Self-Representations by African American Women (2001); Deborah Willis’s and Carla Williams’s The Black Female Body: A Photographic History (2002); Kimberly Wallace-Sanders’s Skin Deep, Spirit Strong: The Black Female Body in American Culture (2002); and E. Frances White’s Dark Continent of Our Bodies: Black Feminism and the Politics of Respectability (2001). Dorothy Roberts’s 1998 study on black women’s struggles to own their own reproductive rights in her provocative book Killing the Black Body frames an important juncture in the critical resurgence of black women
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 17
body studies. Other contemporary works that speak either directly or primarily on the sexual politics of the black female’s body include Ayana Byrd and Akiba Solomon’s Naked: Black Women Bare All about their Skin, Hair, Hips, Lips, and Other Parts (2005); Janell Hobson’s Venus in the Dark: Blackness and Beauty in Popular Culture (2005); Charmaine A. Nelson’s The Color of Stone: Sculpting the Black Female Subject in Nineteenth-Century America (2007); and T. Denean Sharpley-Whiting’s Pimps Up, Ho’s Down: Hip Hop’s Hold on Young Black Women (2007). I have chosen not to list the voluminous literary articles that could fit in this category for fear of creating a multipage endnote. But articles like bell hooks’s “Eating the Other” and Hortense Spillers’s “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe” are two that must have space here. 6. Holland aptly summarizes Hortense Spillers’s assessment of the black female body in “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe: An American Grammar Book.” This quote is from Holland’s book Raising the Dead, p. 43. 7. This is a creative nod to Audre Lorde’s provocative and enduring essay “The Master’s Tools Will Never Dismantle the Master’s House” in her collection of essays, Sister Outsider (1984). 8. Cornel West’s troubling encounters with Princeton police in New Jersey is readily accounted for in his book Race Matters. West recalls he was stopped three times in ten days for driving too slowly on a residential street in Princeton. In another instance that found him driving from New York to teach at Williams College, he was stopped on fake cocaine trafficking charges because of the car he was driving. When he informed the police officer that he was a college professor of religion, the police officer replied, “Yeh, and I’m the Flying Nun. Let’s go nigger!” (xv). This police officer’s denial of West’s status—fixing him in the status of “nigger”—aligns itself nicely with Davidson’s experiences.
Works Cited Bennett, Michael, and Vanessa Dickerson, eds. Recovering the Black Female Body. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers UP, 2001. Print. Byrd, Ayana, and Akiba Solomon, eds. Naked: Black Women Bare All about Their Skin, Hair, Hips, Lips, and Other Parts. New York: Penguin, 2005. Print. Coleman, Arica. “Thoughts on a Black First Lady in Waiting.” History News Network, George Mason University. 25 Aug. 2008. <www.hnn.us/articles/53429. html>. Web. Collins, Patricia Hill. Black Feminist Thought. New York: Routledge, 1990. Print. Dowd, Maureen. “Mincing Up Michele.” New York Times. 11 Jun. 2008. Print. Doyle, Laura. Bordering on the Body: The Racial Matrix of Modern Fiction and Culture. New York: Oxford UP, 1994. Print. Henderson, Carol E. Scarring the Black Body: Race and Representation in African American Literature. Columbia: U of Missouri P, 2002. Print. Hobson, Janell. Venus in the Dark: Blackness and Beauty in Popular Culture. New York: Routledge, 2005. Print.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
18 Carol E. Henderson
Holland, Francis. “Michelle Obama’s Bermuda Shorts Arouse White Supremacists.” 19 Aug. 2009. Now Public: Crowd Powered Media. Web. Holland, Sharon Patricia. Raising the Dead. Durham, NC: Duke UP, 2000. Print. hooks, bell. “Eating the Other.” Black Looks: Race and Representation. Boston: South End Press, 1992. Print. ———. Talking Back. Boston: South End Press, 1989. Print. Jackson, Ronald L., II. Scripting the Black Masculine. Albany: SUNY P, 2006. Print. Lorde, Audre. “The Master’s Tools Will Never Dismantle the Master’s House.” Sister Outsider: Essays and Speeches. Trumansburg, NY: Crossing, 1984. Print. Nelson, Charmaine A. The Color of Stone: Sculpting the Black Female Subject in Nineteenth-Century America. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 2007. Print. Nevergold Seals, Barbara A., and Peggy Brooks-Bertram. Go, Tell Michelle: African American Women Write to the New First Lady. Albany: SUNY P, 2009. Print. Omolade, Barbara. The Rising Song of African American Women. New York: Routledge, 1994. Print. One Citizen. The Daily KOS. 31 May 2008. Coffee Stained News Weblog. Web. Peterson, Carla L. Doers of the Word. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers UP, 1995. Print. Roberts, Dorothy. Killing the Black Body. New York: Pantheon, 1997. Print. Sharpley-Whiting, T. Denean. Pimps Up, Ho’s Down: Hip Hop’s Hold on Young Black Women. New York: New York UP, 2007. Print. Spillers, Hortense J. “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe: An American Grammar Book.” Diacritics 17.2 (Summer 1987): 64–81. Print. Wallace-Sanders, Kimberly, ed. Skin Deep, Spirit Strong: The Black Female Body in American Culture. Ann Arbor: U of Michigan P, 2002. Print. West, Cornel. Race Matters. New York: Vintage, 1994. Print. White, E. Francis. Dark Continent of Our Bodies. Philadelphia: Temple UP, 2001. Print. Willis, Deborah, and Carla Williams, eds. The Black Female Body: A Photographic History. Philadelphia: Temple UP, 2002. Print.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Public Property 19
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
This page intentionally left blank
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
∞
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
This page intentionally left blank
Racing Sex—Sexing Race The Invention of the Black Feminine Body Kaila Adia Story
When invoking the term “body” we tend to think first of its materiality— its composition as flesh and bone, its outline and contours, its outgrowth of nail and hair. But the body as we well know is never simply matter, for it is never divorced from perception and interpretation. As matter, the body is there to be seen and felt, and in the process it is subject to examination and speculation.
—Carla Peterson, Recovering the Black Female Body: Self Representations by African American Women
W
ithin Western borders, the human body has always been viewed and analyzed as a social body that physically and ideologically locates itself within society. The value of the individual human body has been so important to the Western social, cultural, and political agendas that its perceived corporeal value (based on race, national origins, and gender) inevitably translated into its perceived ideological value. “The ways people knew their places in the world had to do with their bodies and the histories of those bodies, and when they violated the prescriptions for those places, their bodies were punished, often spectacularly. One’s place in the body politic was as natural as the places of the organs in one’s body, and political disorder [was] as unnatural as the shifting and displacement of those organs” (Scheman 186).
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
1
In Western societies, the natural places that measure and regulate our bodies within the body politic then have all been dependent on the body’s corporeal and translated ideological value. In this sense our perception of our own bodies and other bodies becomes our reality. Elizabeth Grosz explains how Western societies have inscribed individual human bodies by their construction of corporeal worth, which is inevitably based on its soul or psyche worth: Our body forms are considered expressions of an interior, not inscriptions on a flat surface. By constructing a soul or psyche for itself, the “civilized body” forms libidinal flows, sensations, experiences, and intensities into needs, wants . . . The body becomes a text, a system of signs to be deciphered, read, and read into. Social law is incarnated, “corporealized,” correlatively; bodies are textualized, read by others as expressive of a subject’s psychic interior. A storehouse of inscriptions and messages between external and internal boundaries . . . generates or constructs the body’s movements into “behavior,” which then interpersonally and socially identifiable meanings and functions within a social system.” (198)
Since the body is seen as a corporeal (physical) text in our society, then the body is “always in view and on view. As such, it invites a gaze, a gaze of difference, a gaze of differentiation—the most historically constant being the gendered gaze” (Oyewumi 2). Typically, gender discourses surrounding the body and race discourses surrounding the body have historically been treated as separate and distinct dialectics (Schiebinger 116). However, in this chapter, they are being treated as one and the same. I contend that gender discourses and race discourses surrounding the body have historically influenced each other and created a complex interplay that has had its hand in the shaping and invention of the black feminine body. Although the body has been and is seen as a text that is gazed upon by its viewers, early Western philosophical discourses contended that some human bodies were read and other bodies were attached to minds that allowed them to be the readers. Again, the social location of a reading body was determined by its translated ideological value (based on race, national origins, and gender) that was seen through a physical lens. “Early in Western discourse, a binary opposition between body and mind emerged. The much-vaunted Cartesian dualism was an affirmation of a tradition in which the body was seen as a trap from which any rational person had to escape. Ironically, even as the body remained at the center of both sociopolitical categories and
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
24 Kaila Adia Story
discourse, many thinkers denied its existence for certain categories of people, most notably themselves” (Oyewumi 3). Since Cartesian dualism left certain bodies attached to minds and certain bodies attached to matter or flesh, “women, primitives, Jews, Africans, the poor, and all those who qualified for the label of different in varying historical epochs have been considered to be the embodied, dominated therefore by instinct and affect, reason being beyond them” (Oyewumi 3). Thus, if we think of the body as a physical text that can be read by “dominant” and “subordinate” bodies, through a sociopolitical and differential gaze, then we can begin to understand how for centuries Western society has valued certain bodies and suppressed others. “Differences and hierarchy, then, are enshrined on bodies; and bodies enshrine differences and hierarchy. Hence, dualisms like nature/culture, public/private, and visible/invisible are variations on the theme of male/female bodies hierarchically ordered, differentially placed in relation to power, and spatially distanced one from the other” (Oyewumi 7). These presumed corporeal differences and inevitable social hierarchies were especially at work during the early eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. I am not arguing that these sociopolitical ideologies that Europe set forth started to manifest in their sciences only in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries; I am arguing, however, that these differential notions of the self became a very important discursive staple in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. These investigative constructions of embodiment, gender, race, and sexuality began to formulate out of Europe’s initial contact with Africa. “[Europe] found the natives of Africa very different from themselves. Negroes looked different; their religion was un-Christian; their manner of living was anything but [European]; they seemed to be particularly libidinous sort of people. All these clusters of perceptions were related to each other, though they may be spread apart for inspection, and they were related also to circumstances of contact in Africa, to previously accumulated traditions concerning that strange and distant continent, and to certain special qualities of [European] society on the eve of its expansion into the New World” (Jordan 4). Since the early 1400s, when Portugal began to trade directly with West African societies, Europe’s presence in Africa has remained a constant. Increasing expansionism during the late sixteenth century with the opening of sugar, tobacco, coffee, cotton, and rice plantations in the Americas and the Caribbean, has been fortified in history as a collective
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 25
defining moment. The need for expansion was not in the name of science; rather it was facilitated by more pressing issues in Europe in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. Intolerable socioeconomic conditions, famine, disease, war, and rebellion characterized Europe, and expansion offered “an avenue of escape, a kind of geographical solution to existing social chaos” as well as the promise of facilitating economic recovery in Europe (Jordan 4). The African body proved to be a viable labor source for Europe due to its acculturation to tropical climates and farming. Europe began exploiting Africa inasmuch as it relied on it for its own survival. Between 1500 and 1870, an estimated 12 to 20 million Africans were enslaved and forcibly shipped across the Atlantic Ocean to the Americas and the Caribbean (Davidson 1995). Enslavement, which was characterized by the visual, ideological, and physical alteration of African bodies and European bodies, gave Europe a catalyst to begin focusing their interest in trade almost exclusively on the body—physically and ideologically. First established out of desire for economic gain, enslavement simultaneously turned into an ideological investment for Europe. It was during this expansion and exploration of the body, physically and ideologically, that the initial seedlings of race were constructed (Davidson 1995). Europe’s initial contact with and immediate perceptions about Africa were loaded with intense ideological meaning. To Europeans African people represented a strong juxtaposition to themselves. The English particularly “found in the idea of blackness a way of expressing some of their most ingrained values; no other color except white conveyed so much emotional impact” (Jordan 7). Thus, even before Europe’s contact with Africa, there was already a sociopolitical ideology surrounding blackness not as race within itself but as a mere consequence or opposite of whiteness. As described by the Oxford English Dictionary, the meaning of “black” before the sixteenth century included, “Deeply stained with dirt; soiled, dirty, foul . . . Having dark or deadly purposes, malignant; pertaining to or involving death, deadly; baneful, disastrous, sinister . . . Foul, iniquitous, atrocious, horrible, wicked . . . indicating disgrace, censure, liability to punishment, etc.” Black was an emotionally partisan color, the handmaid and symbol of baseness and evil, a sign of danger and repulsion. Embedded in the concept of blackness was its direct opposite—whiteness . . . White and black connoted purity and filthiness, virginity and sin, virtue and baseness, beauty and ugliness, beneficence and evil, God and the devil. (7)
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
26 Kaila Adia Story
Since Europe’s idea of blackness as a color was already outlined in their religion and culture as inherently evil, by the time Europeans came face to face with peoples who were colored black, their perceptions of Africans began to become filtered through their lenses of polarization. African’s black bodies immediately signified their inherent evilness, libidinousness, and disgrace to Europeans. “Over time, black people themselves were compared to apes, and their childishness, savageness, bestiality, sexuality, and lack of intellectual capacity [was] stressed,” and became a fundamental congruency of European cultural expectation (Stepan 42). During the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries this congruency continued to garner more support within and throughout Europe as the enslavement of Africans progressed, and Europe needed to provide a justification for its inhumane treatment of enslaved Africans. In a culture where bodies were endowed with messages and ideological meaning, black bodies were subjected to the ultimate scrutiny based on racial prescriptions of humanity. Female bodies came to be regarded with similar if not the same type of measurement. “The eighteenth century was the great age of classification. The voyages of discovery had flooded Europe with new and strange specimens of plants, animals, and humans. Natural historians attempting to lay the grid of reason over the unwieldy stuff of nature sought new and simple principles that would hold universally” (Schiebinger 117). European science, in search of its physical origination, attempted to move beyond its religious belief in physical creation through a Christian God, and began to study in detail the anthropoid ape, “thinking that something in their physiology might pinpoint that elusive boundary between humans and simians” (Schiebinger 88). Although voyagers brought back with them a female and male ape of each species, the female ape was always studied as consequence or deviation of the male ape, and overwhelmingly the studies focused on the sex organs and sexuality of the female ape. “When naturalists’ attention turned to females, only sexual traits were considered. This was characteristic of European scientific studies of females— human or animal. Since Aristotle, the female had been studied only insofar as she deviated from the male . . . this way of thinking, where the male constituted the universal subject and the female a sexual subset, pervaded natural history in the eighteenth century. Females across the kingdoms of nature were viewed as primarily sexual beings . . . thus it is not surprising that studies of female anatomy designed to reveal the exact boundary between humans and apes interrogated aspects
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 27
of their sexuality” (Schiebinger 88–89). Consequently, to European naturalists women’s sexual organs began to represent the animal side of humanity, and sometimes their sexual organs were directly linked to those of apes. “Debates about human uniqueness in the female came to focus on key sexual characters: menstruation, the clitoris, the breasts, and the hymen—that celebrated ‘veil of modesty.’ Menstruation had long puzzled male naturalists . . . Women alone had ‘moles’ in their wombs regulating the flow. Contact with menstrual blood was said to turn new wine sour, destroy crops, kill bees, and drive dogs mad” (Schiebinger 89–90). The “scientific” discourse surrounding menstruation led early naturalists to conclude that “apes and monkeys did not menstruate,” and as a consequence of this, women who had large quantities of menstrual flow became ranked “along a single chain of being” (Schiebinger 90–91). European naturalists also hypothesized that women’s menses should coincide with their respective environments, and that women who lived in colder climates would have a reduced menstrual flow as opposed to women who lived in hotter climates. “[Naturalists] made two assumptions: that a copious flow is uniquely human and that females menstruate more heavily in warm climates than in cold . . . When investigating the menses of African women and apes [they] found, however, that despite the warmth of their homelands, ‘Negresses’ menstruated very little, apes and baboons even less, monkeys still less, and some types of monkeys not at all . . . Thus, [they] concluded that European women, distinguished by copious menses, were more human than African women or female apes. For [them], one’s rank in this bloody business determined one’s moral worth” (Schiebinger 91). Even though the Enlightenment period was well under way during the eighteenth century, and philosophers and scientists concluded that faith in rationality and scientific discovery was to be the bedrock of society, the “natural” principles that they attempted to universally project onto human bodies reduced humanity to mere “scientific” measure and this yardstick designated certain bodies, typically male and European, with moral worth. African bodies and European female bodies were compared to apes and other mammals to determine their moral worth and degree of humanity. “Experiment” and “discovery” by European naturalists and anatomists deemed European women’s bodies dangerous and suspicious due to the fact that they had anatomy unlike males; African bodies were hypersexual and ultimately nonhuman because of their polarization to whiteness. African bodies’ social,
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
28 Kaila Adia Story
scientific, and cultural location was that of animals whose bodies had been “stripped clean of history and culture as it was of clothes” and physically represented the earliest stages of evolution (Schiebinger 116). During the fifteenth, sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth centuries, Europe cycled through a myriad of ideological evolutions, religious queries, and scientific revelations. Throughout all of these significant historical moments, the dangerous and vile bodies of European women and Africans continued to be constructed as either subsets of humanity or animal-like creatures whose linkages in the human chain of being were given and natural truths. By the nineteenth century, the African or black female body came into focus as entertainment and scientific discovery. “In Europe in the nineteenth century, the body of the black female symbolized three themes—colonialism, scientific evolution, and sexuality. Virtually always when she is depicted she is either a sexualized mythology or a neutered anomaly, defined by her sexuality or lack of it” (Willis and Williams 2). Her (the African or black female) examination within science reduced her to an animal or a creature that through training could be controlled, and her image through popular media and exposition “was understood to represent that which could be dominated and that which could be possessed, especially sexually” (Willis and Williams 3). The scrutiny of human bodies was part of the scientific community’s response to the expansive, optimistic, and egalitarian energy of the Enlightenment period. Transcendently, “Middle-and-lower class men, women, Jews, Africans, and West Indians living in Europe [believed that they too would] share the privileges heretofore reserved for elite European men” (Schiebinger 144). Through the human sciences, however, elite European men would be able to secure their natural sociopolitical and cultural rights, by arguing that African and women’s bodies were nothing but deviations of themselves. Scientific racism and sexism both “regarded women and non-European men as deviations from the European male norm. Both developed new methods to measure and discuss difference, both sought natural foundations to justify social inequalities between the sexes and the races” (Schiebinger 144). Accordingly, scientific theories of race began to dance and overlap with theories of gender, continually influencing each other, sometimes merging, and always determining that women and Africans were among the lowest strata of human (Schiebinger 147).
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 29
30 Kaila Adia Story
In nineteenth-century Europe and eventually America, monogenism and polygenism were the two preevolutionary justifications for racial ranking; the first view, monogenism, “upheld the scriptural unity of all peoples in the single creation of Adam and Eve” and contended that “human races are a product of degeneration from Eden’s perfection. Races have declined to different degrees, whites least and blacks most” (Gould 39). The second view, polygenism, “abandoned scripture as allegorical and held that human races were separate biological species, the descendants of different Adams” (Gould 42). Although both views of the human hierarchy and “great chain of being” were different, both contended that “blacks [and women] need not participate in the equality of man” (Gould 47). It is at this point of departure that science and culture begin to become intertwined. Scientific race and gender discourses began to influence the cultural and political milieu of Europe, and the race and gendered politics of Europe began to color the scientific lenses of anatomists, scientists, and paleontologists. Monogenism was at one point the more popular of the two theories of evolution due to its location within Christian doctrine and its “common sense” approach to science; the fact that all humans could breed with each other and produce offspring seemed to “guarantee their union as a single species” (Gould 39). Georges Buffon, one of the great naturalists of eighteenth-century France and a strong abolitionist, believed that “inferior races” such as Africans could be improved and regenerated if placed in the proper environments. To Buffon, this meant in the company of Europeans. “The most temperate climate lies between the 40th and 50th degree of latitude, and it produces the most handsome and beautiful men. It is from this climate that the ideas of the genuine color of mankind, and of the various degrees of beauty ought to be derived” (Gould 39). Other proponents of monogenism or degeneration theories argued that polygenism was a theory that only sought to promote the enslavement and exploitation of Africans or other members of the “lower races” and was a theory that merely used scientific support to garner these political and social relations. Etienne Serres, a French anatomist and proponent of degeneration theory, believed polygenism was a “barbaric theory” and that the American scientific community should be ashamed that they promoted such a theory in the name of science. However, in his own way, Serres
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Sociocultural Racial Ranking: A Brief Discussion of Monogenism and Polygenism
found a way to “scientifically prove” African inferiority. Studying African and European anatomy to determine corporeal hierarchy admittedly proved difficult to Serres in the realms of criteria and data, and thus Serres settled on the theory of recapitulation. Serres contended that Africans were perpetual White children and upheld the idea that “higher creatures repeat the adult stages of lower animals during their own growth” (Gould 39). Serres argued that African and Asian adults were to be seen by science and society as European children, due to the distance between their navels and penises—Europeans had a great or large distance between their navels and their penises, Asians had a shorter distance than Europeans, and the distance between Africans’ navels and penises was the shortest. This, to Serres, marked Africans as the lowest form of man. David Hume, a polygenist, also argued that Africans were somewhat of a different species and were inherently inferior. Although Hume’s belief argued that Africans were a separate species of man, Hume, like his cohort, also believed that time spent around Europeans would elevate Africans’ status of humanity, but still not to the degree of Europeans. I am apt to suspect the negroes and in general all the other species of men (for there are four or five different kinds) to be naturally inferior to the whites. There never was a civilized nation of any other complexion than white, nor even any individual eminent either in action or speculation. No ingenious manufacturers amongst them, no arts, no sciences . . . Such a uniform and constant difference could not happen in so many countries and ages, if nature had not made an original distinction between these breeds of men. Not to mention our colonies, there are negroe slaves dispersed all over Europe, of which none ever discovered and symptoms of ingenuity, tho’ low people without education will start up amongst us and distinguish themselves in every profession. In Jamaica indeed they talk of one negroe as a man of parts and learning; but ‘tis likely he is admired for very slender accomplishments like a parrot who speaks a few words plainly. (Gould 42)
It is clear from Hume’s commentary that science and culture had an integral relationship. “Scientific data” became translated as sociopolitical and sociocultural fact. At the same time that the European scientific community was presenting its facts of human arrangement to the public, Europeans were witnessing and participating in a society where African people were politically and culturally abject, occupying the lowest political and social positions. The taxonomy of race and racial logic was not only used to prove the biological inferiority of Africans
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 31
but also the ideological insignificance of Africans. African bodies became marked as objects for exploration and study under the auspices of European economic advancement, and although physical enslavement in Europe had been abolished since the seventeenth century, that did not stop Europe from exploring and exploiting African land and peoples through the respective lenses of monogenism and polygenism. While monogenism was largely popular in European science, polygenism, in the early to mid-nineteenth century, found its home in the budding profession of American science. The “American school” of anthropology, borrowing from the Emersonian philosophy of breaking with Europe intellectually, “became a group of professionals with indigenous ideas and an internal dynamic that did not require constant fueling from Europe” (Gould 42). Polygenism “acted as an important agent in this transformation; for it was one of the first theories of largely American origin that won the attention and respect of European scientists” (Gould 42). Polygenism, the belief that human races were actually different species culturally, fit within the social relations of American society as monogenism fit within European society. As Europeans believed that Africans were degenerated humans that could regenerate in their presence and become civilized by their relationship with them, Americans believed Africans were a different species that could only be controlled in order for civilization to continue. Louis Agassiz, a Swiss naturalist and pupil of Georges Cuvier, immigrated to America in the 1840s and “immediately elevated the status of American natural history,” eventually becoming the leading spokesperson for polygenism after interacting with American blacks in Philadelphia (Gould 43). Even though Agassiz was a devout creationist, which would naturally make him a proponent of monogenism, Agassiz evolved to polygenism for two main reasons. First, his biological studies of animals concluded that every species had its own environmental nexus and did not migrate far from the center of its origination. Second, an avid taxonomist, Agassiz also determined that different species were characterized by minute distinctions and did not concentrate his energies on the similarities of species. If a species he was studying had the slightest variation it was deemed an entirely different organism. “Agassiz may have been predisposed to polygeny by biological belief . . . [and] confronted both by the sight of American blacks and the urgings of his polygenist colleagues,” but these things still did not totally convert the devout creationist (Gould 44). After interacting with black servants at a Philadelphia hotel in 1846, Agassiz became repulsed and
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
32 Kaila Adia Story
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 33
It was in Philadelphia that I first found myself in prolonged contact with negroes; all the domestics in my hotel were men of color. I can scarcely express to you the painful impression that I received, especially since the feeling that they inspired in me is contrary to all our ideas about the confraternity of the human type [genre] and the unique origin of our species. But truth before all. Nevertheless, I experienced pity at the sight of this degraded and degenerate race, and their lot inspired compassion in me in thinking that they are really men. Nonetheless, it is impossible for me to repress the feeling that they are not of the same blood as us. In seeing their black faces with their thick lips and grimacing teeth, the wool on their head, their bent knees, their elongated hands, their large curved nails, and especially the livid color of the palm of their hands, I could not take my eyes off their face in order to tell them to stay far away. And when they advanced that hideous hand towards my plate in order to serve me, I wished I were able to depart in order to eat a piece of bread elsewhere, rather than dine with such service. What unhappiness for the white race—to have tied their existence so closely with that of negroes in certain countries! God preserve us from such contact! (Gould 44)
Agassiz’s plea with God in this candid letter to his mother falls directly in line with the thought processes of his American polygenist colleagues and with the society to which he was now becoming acculturated. In the Christian Examiner in 1850, Agassiz published his foremost declaration on the human races. Being a tortured scientist in that he struggled internally to reconcile his scientific training with his Christianity, Agassiz argued that he was not a “demagogue” nor was he a “defender of slavery” in terms of his polygenist beliefs. Agassiz wrote, It is has been charged upon the views here advanced that they to tend support slavery . . . Is that a fair objection to a philosophical investigation? Here we have to do only with the question of the origin of men; let the politicians, let those who feel themselves called upon to regulate human society, see what they can do with the results . . . We disclaim, however, all connection with any question involving political matters. It is simply with reference to the possibility of appreciating the differences existing between different men, and of eventually determining whether they have originated all over the world, and under what circumstances, that we have here tried to trace some facts respecting the human races. (Gould 45)
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
frightened by the possibility of African people being regarded as equal to white men.
To satisfy Americans and his own Christian sentiment and belief, Agassiz continued to state that the creation story of Adam and Eve that is found within the Bible “refers only to the origin of Caucasians,” and that “Negroes and Caucasians are as distinct in the mummified remains of Egypt as they are today.” As a result of these invariant and geographical differences between Africans and Europeans (Americans) Agassiz concluded that this in fact meant Africans were a different species (Gould 46). To conclude his statement, however, Agassiz contended that although he was an “objective scientist,” who had no personal or ideological investment in his findings, he still gave a moral plea to the public that Africans were inherently inferior based on his invented racialized “personality characteristics.” The indomitable, courageous, proud Indian—in how very different a light he stands by the side of the submissive, obsequious, imitative negro, or by the side of the tricky, cunning, and cowardly Mongolian! Are not these facts indications that the different races do not rank upon one level in nature . . . It seems to us to be mock-philanthropy and mock-philosophy to assume that all races have the same abilities, enjoy the same powers, and show the same natural dispositions, and that in consequence of this equality they are entitled to the same position in human society. History speaks here for itself . . . This compact continent of Africa exhibits a population which has been in constant intercourse with the white race, which has enjoyed the benefit of the example of the Egyptian civilization, of the Phoenician civilization, of the Roman civilization, of the Arab civilization . . . and nevertheless there has never been a regulated society of black men developed on that continent. Does not this indicate in this race a peculiar apathy, a peculiar indifference to the advantages afforded by civilized society? (Gould 46)
And yet Agassiz was not finished with his declaration. He completed his statement by suggesting different social policies that needed to be put into place as remedy, if you will, to solve the great problem of whites living among Africans, whom they saw as a different species. Agassiz contended that education was to be the corrective for the African. “What would be the best education to be imparted to the different races in consequence of their primitive difference . . . We entertain not the slightest doubt that human affairs with reference to the colored races would be far more judiciously conducted if, in our intercourse with them, we were guided by a full consciousness of the real difference existing between us and them, and a desire to foster those dispositions that are eminently marked in them, rather than by treating them on terms of equality” (Gould 47).
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
34 Kaila Adia Story
Thus, to Agassiz, Africans needed to be educated insofar as that allowed them to remain a different and separate species. There was no need for Africans to be given sympathy for their lot as slaves or subhumans because it was biologically ordered this way. The only way, in Agassiz’s eyes, to rid whites of the guilt they “forced upon themselves” was to remain “conscious” of the fact that science as well as history had “proven” the inferiority of Africans. Whether divinely degenerated or biologically inferior, monogenists and polygenists sought to scientifically prove the inferior nature of Africans during the early to mid-nineteenth century. Inasmuch as the proponents of monogenism and polygenism were invested in “scientifically” uncovering the mysteries of mankind, they also had personal and ideological investments in rendering Africans’ bodies as inferior. What remains clear about both camps is that Africans’ physical and ideological inferiority was necessary to the very structure of European and American societies. However, the problem European and American scientists faced in the years to come was their attempt to find “actual hard data” to prove their theories. This led nineteenth-century scientists to propose a series of analogies between racial and sexual differences that was newly generated through the measuring of human skulls. Race and Gender Analogies and the Search for Hard Data
Just as monogenism and polygenism were once widely accepted theories within the European and American “scientific” community, American scientists in the nineteenth century began to search for new ways to still utilize the theory of Polygenism, while using hard or raw data to support it. European and American scientific notions of human difference and similarity “were widely accepted, partly because of their fundamental congruence with cultural expectations” (Stepan 42). It is important to remember that, culturally speaking, Europe as well as America had held on to the notions of African inferiority since the Middle Ages and, through the sciences of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, felt they had scientifically proven this inferiority. The new emergence of racial and sexual analogy fell right in line with the ways in which Europeans as well as Americans regarded Africans. “The scientists’ contribution was to elevate hitherto unconsciously held analogies, to expand their range through new observations and comparisons, and to give them precision through specialized vocabularies and new technologies. Another result was that the analogies became ‘naturalized’ in the
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 35
language of science, and their metaphorical nature disguised” (Stepan 42). The finagled measurements of the human skull called craniometry provided scientists with the hard data they needed to link Africans with apes and other mammals and inevitably concluded that they were a different species or subhuman. “It was the measurements of the skull, brain weights, and brain convolutions that gave apparent precision to the analogies between anthropoid apes, lower races, women, criminal types, lower classes and the child” (Stepan 43). Samuel George Morton, a distinguished scientist and physician, had amassed six hundred skulls, which he began collecting in the 1820s to study his hypothesis “that a ranking of races could be established objectively by physical characteristics of the brain, particularly by its size” (Gould 51). Morton set out to rank races by the average sizes of their brains. He filled the cranial cavity with sifted white mustard seed, poured the seed back into a graduated cylinder and read the skull’s volume in cubic inches. Later on, he became dissatisfied with mustard seed because he could not obtain consistent results. The seeds did not pack well, for they were too light and still varied too much in size, despite sieving. Remeasurements of single skulls might differ by more than 5 percent, or 4 cubic inches in skulls with an average capacity near 80 cubic inches. Consequently, he switched to oneeighth-inch-diameter lead shot “of the size called BB” and achieved consistent results that never varied by more than a single cubic inch for the same skull” (Gould 53).
Morton eventually published his findings in Crania Americana in 1839 and Crania Aegyptiaca in 1844. Each table of skulls represented a “major contribution of American polygeny to debates about racial ranking. They outlived the theory of separate creations and were reprinted repeatedly during the nineteenth century as irrefutable, ‘hard’ data on the mental worth of human races” (Gould 53). Stephen Jay Gould, in Chapter 2 of his book the Mismeasure of Men, replicates Morton’s tables to refute Morton’s “hard” data about the races in terms of his skull measurements. Morton in fact finagled his “objective” and “hard” data to suit his own racist beliefs about the racial ranking of mankind. Morton’s findings “needless to say . . . matched every good Yankee’s prejudice—whites on top, Indians in the middle, and blacks on bottom; and among whites, Teutons and AngloSaxons on top, Jews in the middle, and Hindus on the bottom” (Gould 53–54). Although Gould concludes that Morton’s “hard” data was in
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
36 Kaila Adia Story
fact biased, due to his accumulation of small-bodied (therefore smallbrained) African and Indian peoples and his overrepresentation of large-bodied (therefore large-brained) European and Caucasian peoples, I argue that Morton’s “hard” data was in fact only created to support his prior assumption of African inferiority. Gould goes through Morton’s research to find that “Morton’s summaries are a patchwork of fudging and finagling in the clear interest of controlling a priori convictions” (54). However, Gould still argues that he has no “evidence of conscious fraud” on the part of Morton because he feels that if Morton were in fact a “conscious fudger, he would not have published his data so openly” (54). I differ with Gould’s conclusion. While I’m not arguing that Morton was “consciously” skewing the data, I am arguing that his method of accumulating “hard data” to “scientifically” prove the inferiority of Africans was no different than the hypothesizing and observational data that preceded his own. European as well as American scientists not only were “scientifically” invested in the conviction of African inferiority but also created an ideological outlay with this assumption, due to their capitalist and social interests. It is at this point of departure that science and culture merged and began informing one another, so we become unclear as to where science begins and culture ends. The European and American sociopolitical structure of society rested on the scientific positioning of Africans and women in order to rank them socially, and the social positioning of Africans and women in society gave many scientists their hypotheses about how the races of man were to be ranked. The effects of “scientific” reasoning had a major impact on European and American visual culture. These differential scientific prescriptions of human rank and behavior were all translated visually through cultural, genealogical, and sociopolitical lenses to reinscribe the black female body as the antithesis of the white female body. Enslavement and Asymmetries of Race, Gender, and Sexuality
In her book Olympia’s Maid: Reclaiming Black Female Subjectivity, Lorraine O’Grady discusses the ways in which the black female body and the white female body have served as asymmetries of one another. “The female body in the West is not a unitary sign. Rather, like a coin, it has an obverse and a reverse: on the one side, it is White; on the other, not-White or, prototypically, Black. The two bodies cannot be separated, nor can one body be understood in isolation from the other in
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 37
the West’s metaphoric construction of ‘woman.’ White is what woman is; not-White (and the stereotypes not-White gathers in) is what she had better not be” (152). Colonial expansion, enslavement, and “science” all contributed to the ways in which the black female body came to be regarded within visual and actual European culture (Gilman 100; Sharpley-Whiting 22; Stoler 14; Willis and Williams 1–2). While the scientific community concluded Africans were inferior biologically, the institutions of enslavement and colonization advanced the conclusion that Africans were inferior ideologically as well physically. During enslavement, the black body was turned into a corporeal possession that mattered, as it was physically productive for plantation work. Enslavement as an institution visually and aesthetically altered the African body, leaving its corporeal value open to interpretation and perception. Since African bodies were being viewed through a racist and sexist “scientific” lens, the worth of the African body hinged on the ideological convictions of Europeans. In her work Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limitations of Sex, Judith Butler retraces the origins of materiality and argues “the classical configuration of matter as a site of generation or origination becomes especially significant when the account of what an object is and means requires recourse to its originating principle” (31). More specifically, she argues that matter (flesh or corporeality), when not associated with reproduction, is generally linked to origination and causality. In her discussion of matter she locates the substances of which any physical object consists or is composed, and these substances themselves assume a history and a form. In the second component of her argument, Butler begins to discuss the production of intelligibility—how individuals’ own subjectivity often reads a body’s worth. She contends that the materiality or matter of the body in and of itself is not an absolute certainty but is rooted in a matrix of origination and composure that is inevitability colored by European rationality and power and leads one to intelligibility—a subjective reading of matter. Therefore “to know the significance of something is to know how and why it matters, where ‘to matter’ means at once ‘to materialize’ and ‘to mean’” (32). Consequently, if the body then is clearly matter, how that body comes to materialize, mean, or matter is contingent on its origination, its transformation, and its potentiality; the body’s intelligibility therefore is not a given but is produced. Butler goes on to discuss how the discourse surrounding these bodies that “don’t matter” happens at the site of performativity,
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
38 Kaila Adia Story
which is colored by modalities of power. “For discourse to materialize a set of effects, ‘discourse’ itself must be understood as complex and convergent chains in which ‘effects’ are vectors of power. In this sense, what is constituted in discourse is not fixed in or by discourse, but becomes the condition and occasion for further action. This does not mean that any action is possible on the basis of a discursive effect. On the contrary, certain reiterative chains of discursive production are barely legible as reiterations, for the effects they have materialized are those without which no bearing in discourse can be taken” (32). Performativity, Butler argues, is not “willful” or “arbitrary” but has been confined to the domains of intelligibility, which are bound with the effects of a “historicity of discourse” and “historicity” of norms, which have constituted the power of discourse. Therefore, the normalization of the body depends largely on reiteration and exclusion. Butler’s argument delineates the ways in which European enslavers physically and ideologically removed African bodies from their respective social contexts during enslavement. I contend that as a result of doing this, European enslavers reinvented the materiality of African bodies as commodities (which inevitably excluded them from normalcy). As Europeans placed themselves in a position of authority over African bodies, they simultaneously placed themselves in a position to reproduce the intelligibility of African bodies. As a result, Europeans began to recreate and rewrite the origins, transformation, and potentiality of African bodies through the institutions of enslavement, colonization, and science. Since African bodies existed during enslavement and colonization as commodified possessions and were regarded within the realm of science as either apes or subhuman creations that happened to be bodies, the materiality of their bodies became less significant and in fact disposable, therefore scripting African bodies as having no origins, no transformative abilities, and no potential, inevitably making them not matter. “In the name of science, colonized peoples were compared to Western types. Major institutions were founded to finance and support such work: the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland in 1843; the Société d’Anthropologie de Paris in 1859; and the National Geographic Society, founded in the United States in 1888. Studies of skin color, facial structure, and particularly genitalia contributed to the classification of human types. Regarded as less developed than White, Black became associated with moral deficiency, sexual deviance, and intellectual inferiority” (Willis and Williams 1–2). As a consequence of this process, African bodies became the mere corporeal
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 39
manifestations of the European imagination. The social and ideological assignment of black bodies as deviant, impulsive, hypersexual, imitative, and criminal by European science, culture, and society transformed African bodies into Europe’s commodified possessions. Europe having “scientifically,” ideologically, physically, and culturally obscured the social and political relations of their African commodities, the value attributed to these possessions was based solely upon their presented appearance. This appearance was then measured against bodies that Europe deemed normal or typical (which were inevitably their own). The European “scientific” conclusion that designated African bodies as inferior, as I have said before, inevitably translated into the visual culture of the West. The nude or seminude bodies of black women in nineteenth-century paintings and photographs suggested the hypersexuality of African (black) women and the hidden sexuality of European women who, although objectified through these visual images, were still allowed to remain modest and fully human. Consequently, this juxtaposition of semiclothed European women with nude black women in the art world and the already “scientific” conclusion that designated African (black) female and male bodies inferior in the larger society converted the speculation and fantasies of black sexuality as deviant or abnormal sexuality into concrete fact. Thus, at any point in time when the black female body and African female body caught the European gaze, it becomes not only important that they were written about and studied in a particular way in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries in Europe, but the black female body also came to represent a different type of physiological difference to Europe and ultimately to the West. The “scientific,” and differential conclusions that Europe reached in terms of the black female body, over determined the anatomy and persona of the black female body to such a degree that in fact invented an ideological construction that was as much real as it was imagined. African or black women soon turned into public spectacle and “scientific discovery” and came not only to embody this invention but also, in fact, their bodies came to serve as the “master texts” or example of it. This (European) Western projection of “hypersexuality,” “immodesty,” and “inhumanity” onto the black or African female body served two essential needs for Europe. The first is that this invention allowed and continues to allow (European) Western man to serve as the pinnacle of humanity and further helps to maintain his sexual, racial, and moral superiority. Second, it established an ideological perception of the black female body that made these
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
40 Kaila Adia Story
scripts inherent to what blackness and femaleness meant and mean. Black female bodies on any kind of display—then on stages, now on television—gave Europe and now the West a corporeal example for the “scientific conclusions” that it had reached concerning the black female body. The imagery surrounding black female bodies then (as is the case now) was and is both erotic and propagandistic. Our representation and the discourse surrounding our “fleshy” figure have now informed our own collective perception of what it physically means to be black and female. Although different ideologies have informed our collective consciousness throughout time and space, the invented black feminine body is still regarded in the same way, and although the purposes for the invention have changed and continue to be nuanced to fit its particular moments, the invention, necessary for European and now Western corporeal affirmation, remains one of the only representations of black feminine embodiment that we see. This becomes problematic not only for the women who inhabit these black and female bodies but also for our entire nation. In the aftermath of Don Imus’s “nappy-headed hoes” comment about the Rutgers women’s basketball team, the black feminine body has once again resurfaced for both blacks and whites as the living embodiment of the black female body. Imus, knowing nothing personally about the black women who played for the Rutgers basketball team, inferred because of their visible blackness and femaleness that they were in fact “whores” as well as “nappy headed.” Imus, like many of his European predecessors, inferred that the black and female basketball players’ bodies represented in their mere physiology the projected image and invention of the “black feminine body.” From the fifteenth to the twenty-first century, the dangerous and vile bodies of black women have continued to be constructed as the subsets of humanity or revealed their bodies’ uninhibited and ball-busting whorish nature. In every century it has been imperative that the constructed “black feminine body” continue to resurface and reappear in film, television, and videos, to ensure that Western man’s “superior” position within the Western body politic is solidified. The current analysis of the black female body and its invented image—the black feminine body—is in no way conclusive. It rather offers an alternative lens through which to possibly understand why the black female body has been and is seen as the black feminine body. If this chapter has accomplished anything, I hope it serves as testimony to the fact that despite popular belief, the
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 41
42 Kaila Adia Story
Notes 1. I use the term “Black Feminine body” to refer to specific black female body (gendered and sexual) performances that embody (European) Western projections of the “hypersexuality,” “immodesty,” and “inhumanity” regarded as inherent to blackness and femaleness. 2. Winthrop Jordan in White Over Black: American Attitudes Toward the Negro, 1550–1812 argues that “English voyagers did not touch the shores of West Africa until after 1550, a century after . . . [the] Portuguese thrust southward for a water passage to the Orient.” Although Jordan states English, I say Europe here because it was not just English men and women who had these thoughts of African people. Travel logs from the Portuguese and the French state these types of sentiments concerning African people. 3. Although Butler does not specifically discuss race, she discusses the queering of the body with her exclusion theory. I utilize this point in her argument to insert race for queering.
Works Cited Butler, Judith. Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limitations of “Sex.” New York: Routledge, 1993. Print. Davidson, Basil. The Search for Africa: History, Culture, Politics. New York: Three Rivers, 1995. Print. Gilman, Sander. Sexuality: An Illustrated History. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1989. Print. Gould, Stephen Jay. The Mismeasure of Man. New York: W. W. Norton, 1996. Print. Grosz, Elizabeth. “Bodies and Knowledges: Feminism and the Crisis of Reason.” Feminist Epistemologies. Ed. Linda Alcoff and Elizabeth Potter. New York: Routledge, 1994. 190–200. Print. Jordan, Winthrop. White Over Black: American Attitudes Toward the Negro, 1550– 1812. Chapel Hill, NC: U of North Carolina P, 1968. Print. O’Grady, Lorraine. “Olympia’s Maid: Reclaiming Black Female Subjectivity.” New Feminist Criticism. Ed. Joanna Freuh et al. New York: HarperCollins, 2004. 150–52. Print. Oyewumi, Oyeronke. The Invention of Women: Making Sense of Western Gender Discourses. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 1997. Print.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
script and the subsequent invented black feminine body did not start with us. However, it is up us to take on the challenge of discovering and inventing new ways for the black female body to become regarded and seen. Indeed this is a great challenge, but hopefully, our ancestral legacy of survival and maintenance will aid us in this quest.
Peterson, Carla. “Foreword: Eccentric Bodies.” Recovering the Black Female Body: Self Representations by African American Women. Ed. Michael Bennett et al. Piscataway, NJ: Rutgers UP, 2000. viiii–xi. Print. Scheman, Naomi. Engenderings: Constructions of Knowledge, Authority, and Privilege. New York: Routledge, 1993. 185–87. Print. Schiebinger, Londa. Nature’s Body: Gender in the Making of Modern Science. Boston: Beacon, 1993. Print. Sharpley-Whiting, T. Denean. Black Venus: Sexualized Savages, Primal Fears, and Primitive Narratives in French. Durham, NC: Duke UP, 1999. Print. Stepan, Nancy Leys. “Race and Gender: The Role of Analogy in Science.” Anatomy of Racism. Ed. David Theo Goldberg. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 1990. Print. Stoler, Ann. “Carnal Knowledge and Imperial Power: Gender, Race, and Morality in Colonial Asia.” The Gender/Sexuality Reader. Ed. Roger N. Lancaster et al. New York: Routledge, 1997. 13–36. Print. Willis, Deborah, and Carla Williams. The Black Female Body: A Photographic History. Philadelphia: Temple UP, 2002. Print.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Racing Sex—Sexing Race 43
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
This page intentionally left blank
Disembodiments Ellen Gallagher’s Watery Metamorphoses Ana Nunes
F
igurations of the Middle Passage have presented the body as an archive of a history that attempts to deal with the want of a continuum of cultural memory. Artists’ reliance on a history that has to be constructed and imagined is reflected on a marked black body. In her painting Autobiography: Water/Ancestors/Middle Passage/Family/ Ghosts (1988), Howardena Pindell positions herself at the center of her autobiographical account. Her face emerges clear from the water, but her body is submerged in a blue sea of a personal history that is made more from scraps than from a continuous narrative thread. Sinking her own body in deep water, the central figure in the canvas establishes a link between her contemporary self and that of the forebears. The ancestors appear as broken figures—disembodied hands, limbs, the occasional partial or blurred head—but the figure that dominates the image is the eye. The eye is cut from the face, but nonetheless imposes a significant gaze on the viewer. Pindell’s work reveals several layers of African American history, from slavery to a more recent past, evident in the inclusion of extracts from edicts governing the institution and the rights of slave owners, a printout of the “Separate but Equal” credo of the Jim Crow era, and other scraps of text that are an integral part of the tableau created by the artist. However, it is the white diagram of a slave ship that stands out in Pindell’s genealogical and historical scrapbook. The depiction of a ship that refuses to be sunk in the blue that covers the canvas,
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
2
imposing its whiteness as an entry to another time and space, represents the original ghost of African American experience. Although the figure of the ship reflects nineteenth-century illustrations of this type of vessel, the conventional representation of the stacked black bodies is absent here. The ancestral bodies are no longer confined to the ship’s hold, but they are no longer whole or together either. Rather, they are dispersed in the genealogical map of the Americas—fragmented and mutilated. Although the slave ship constitutes a central element of Pindell’s composition, she challenges its role as the primary link to Africa, the ancestral home. A series of strips was sewn to the canvas, alluding to, as Sharon F. Patton observes, “the narrow-strip weavings of West of Africa, to women’s handiwork, and, with the impasto of paint, creat[ing] a corrugated surface that suggests physical and psychological wounds and healing” (242). The healing, notwithstanding, remains compromised by the mark left on the surface on the canvas/psyche/ skin, the eternal scar of history. In her Coral Cities series, African American artist Ellen Gallagher enters into dialogue with Pindell’s work. Both artists see the body as a vehicle to explore the imprints of black history in the African American consciousness. Gallagher, however, challenges Pindell’s autobiographical scrapbook. Her approach to the African American historical record is to explore the ways in which history can be recreated, if not factually, imaginatively. Gallagher draws attention to the influence that stereotypical representations of race and gender exercise on American culture. Referring to a lasting caricature of black people, the artist observes, “Black face minstrel . . . is the literal reading of the African body into American public culture. Disembodied eyes and lips float, hostage in the electric face of the minstrel stage, distorting the African body into American black face” (Heartney 254). Gallagher attempts to represent the multiple processes of objectification that have reigned over private and collective consciousness. In this way, she also challenges traditional boundaries established between visual arts and the politics of race and gender. The idea of art for art’s sake is challenged by the examination of critical historical, social, and economic contexts. Her work incites the viewer to rethink the cultural tendency to read the black body, particularly the black female body, as a cultural text. Moreover, the artist calls for an African American self-generated subjectivity in which the self is able to reconceptualize her or his own body outside imposed hegemonic discourses. Central to this project is the deconstruction of the artificial boundary established between
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
46 Ana Nunes
private and public spheres. Thus, Gallagher’s artistic project is consistent with feminist criticism that emphasizes the influence of the public arena over the private, interior self and the imperative to deconstruct the body as a cultural signifier. The black female body has been, as Hortense J. Spillers puts it, “a meeting ground of investments and privations in the national treasury rhetoric wealth. My country needs me, and if I were not here, I would have to be invented” (454). In order to challenge the black face with bulging eyes, enlarged lips, flattened nose, the black female self has to appropriate its own body—often a marker of imposed signification—and construct its own meanings, questioning both culturally acquired internal and external gazes. In Coral Cities, Gallagher reimagines the black Atlantic as a mythological aquatic world inhabited by the descendants of pregnant slaves who either plunged or were thrown into the ocean during the Middle Passage. The slaves’ unborn children adapted to the water in utero and developed into half-human, half-fish beings. For Gallagher, the aquatic realm provides the ideal setting in which to reveal and transform African American history. In her work, human and aquatic forms merge to suggest an identity characterized by hybridity, mutability, and fragmentation. These postmodern markers are apparent in the representation of disembodied female heads. In this respect, and others that will become apparent throughout this exploration, Gallagher’s work challenges the idea of originality, which was at the center of the modernist movement and engages in a creative practice that appropriates material from other media, giving it new form and meaning. In this instance, the artist uses the Drexciya project of the eponymous Detroit techno band led by James Stinson and Gerald Donald (see Tate 18). At the centre of Drexciya is an aquatic community of female slaves who either jumped or were thrown overboard during the inferno of the Middle Passage. Critical to both Drexciya and Gallagher’s version, Coral Cities is the idea of resistance present in the figuration of marooned communities. However, those who escaped their masters, either by force or by their own resolve, are not placed in the mountaintops of the West Indies, or in recondite parts of Brazil where they would lead a life of isolation or be threatened by the danger of capture. Nonetheless, Coral Cities does not represent an ideal of freedom, but rather freedom within captivity. The watery deep transports the slaves and their descendants to a civilization beneath the black Atlantic, but this is not a return to the ancestral home. It is a return to the watery deep made impossible by the physical mutations that the slaves undergo in order to survive in
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Disembodiments 47
the new aquatic environment. In this context, Gallagher’s work suggests that both in the watery deep and in the New World, the displacement imposed by the Middle Passage required more than survival; it demanded metamorphosis and evolution. This notion of a compromised freedom is reflected in Gallagher’s representation of the Maroons as disembodied heads. In fact, on the rare occasion when the body is represented, as in the central piece of the exhibition presented in the Hugh Lane Dublin City Gallery in 2007, it is disfigured and dismembered. In this piece, Bird in Hand (oil, mixed media, gold leaf on canvas, 2006), the Melvillian Ahab is transformed into a black mariner with preoccupations of his own. His wooden leg has gained roots, embedding this figure in the seabed—the graveyard of those lost in the Middle Passage. The use of rooting imagery here is significant in a number of ways. With its connotations of rummaging, inquiry, turning things over in search of something—the bodies of the missing, a partially lost past, layers of culture diluted in sea water—the image of the sailor functions as the artist’s alter ego en route to a foraging expedition. The findings appear not only scattered on the surface of Bird in Hand but also on the canvas of the other works in the exhibition. Thus, as Karen Alexander puts it, Peg-Leg’s “magnetic presence sucks in the whole of black history . . . , sailing the seas of history to retrieve the discarded cargo of black souls” (77). Gallagher’s visual strategy is based on minute pictographs (which in Bird in Hand form the subject’s Afro) built on shallow relief, which on closer examination reveal eyes, mouths, noses, hairstyles that the artist has distorted in order to portray the imprint of racial discourses on the black female body. Peg-Leg’s laced cuff that adorns his only arm alludes to a time when slave ships triangulated the Atlantic, but a closer look at the locks that compose his colossal Afro reveal Gallagher’s attempt to cross temporal and spatial boundaries. Each lock of hair reveals its own small vignette. Several of these vignettes represent a hand holding a magnifying lens, revealing the microscopic specks of dirt on another hand, reminding the viewer of Gallagher’s preoccupation with what lies beneath the surface. Her work demands a closer look at the world and an attention to detail, and above all it elicits a different view of the familiar. In this way, Peg-Leg’s Afro evokes both those lost to the Middle Passage and those who, in the twentieth century, lost their identities to the imperative to conform their bodies to standardized notions of white beauty. By filling Peg-Leg’s strands of hair with images from
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
48 Ana Nunes
advertisements found in black magazines of the 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s, Gallagher recontextualizes these images. On one hand, she takes these depictions of black female models advertising products such as “Miracle Whip” and “Greaseless,” which promise straighter hair or lighter skin, and sets them against words and phrases such as “success,” “human,” “buy it,” “Love Charm,” and “You!” The obvious link between image and text is the obliteration of the female self in a culture that singles out certain black women’s physical attributes as undesirable but somewhat redeemable by consumer goods. Nonetheless, Gallagher’s artistic project is more ambitious than this. Even as she presents a parody of the kinds of interiorized racist gaze on the female black body, as Hal Foster et al observe, “she breaks down its constituent parts, its loaded details nearly to the point of their destruction” (642). The adverb “nearly” calls attention to the dangerous waters navigated by Gallagher. The use of stereotypical images of African Americans runs the risk of perpetuating the racist discourses that the artist attempts to dismantle. However, portraying stereotypes as a primary mark of racism, Gallagher does not merely present a collage of the images she collects from midcentury black publications such as Ebony, Black Digest, and Our World. Working with Plasticine, cut paper on paper, gesso, gold leaf, and ink, among other techniques, she reworks the caricature of the black face, flattening the nose, widening the lips, distorting the eyes almost to a point beyond recognition. Imposing her low relief on formulaic depictions of black people, she restages the racial identity of the American un/conscious. This strategy, which the critic Kobena Mercer calls “the stereotypical grotesque” (Foster, Krauss, Bois, and Buchloh 641)1 allows the artist to confront stereotypical representations of race and gender (changing its attributes and contexts), while turning the gaze of racism on the viewer.2 It is interesting to note that, like Pindell’s Autobiography: Water/Ancestors/Middle Passage/Family/Ghosts and Gallagher’s Coral Cities, the eye remains a powerful witness of racist structures and the preferred metonymy for both external and internalized gazes. By turning the gaze of racial prejudice on the other, African American artists expose “the damaging internalization of assumptions of immutable inferiority originating in an outside gaze,” just as Morrison explains in her 1993 afterword to The Bluest Eye (168). However, Gallagher’s use of stereotypical representations of the black body is distinct from other contemporary black female artists. Carrie Mae Weems, for example, challenges the objectification of the black body as an image of otherness by constructing intimate portraits of the
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Disembodiments 49
black family, often drawn from her personal experiences and familial history. Bringing her camera into the domestic space, Weems contests two influential approaches to the black body as cultural archive. One is the photo-documentary tradition that has produced a vast catalogue of the African American as the Other. The second is the official sociological study, such as the notorious 1965 Moynihan Report on the black family, which has objectified the African American family unit and turned it into a kind of scientific paradigm with roots in Darwinist ideas of social evolution. In projects such as the series Family Pictures and Kitchen Table, Weems aims at drawing a complex identity for the black self by representing African American subjectivity in intimate settings guarded from the hegemonic gaze. If Weems’s portraits aim at representing a black body using markers of individuality of the self and complexity of experience, Lorna Simpson makes use of what Beryl J. Wright terms the “generic figure” (401). Simpson’s photographs usually reveal a partial female body. The head may have been cut from the image, or more characteristically the body is represented from the back. “Concealment or effacement of body elements, particularly of the face,” as Wright observes, “is an act of resistance that denies the presumption of unrestricted access to the exterior body and to the interior life within” (406). In this way, the viewer’s desire or subconscious inclination to master the figure’s interiority is frustrated. Simpson’s early projects, such as The Water Bearer (1986), present the “generic figure” that will become archetypal in her work. A black woman in what appears to be a white cotton shift aims to represent any black woman who finds herself at the crossroads of racism, sexism, and economic disadvantage. Through the use of these devices, Simpson, as Wright suggests, “enables the studio model to achieve her iconic role as ‘Every-black-woman’ and avoids any unintended conflation between the individual and the generic figure” (406). Simpson’s generic figure attempts to dilute the body as cultural archive. Guarded Conditions (1989), a series of Polaroid photographs, features a woman seen from behind in attire that veils both her age and her social class. Below the prints runs a sequence of text that alternates throughout the series: “SKIN ATTACKS/SEX ATTACKS.” Not only does the juxtaposition of the image and text set sexual and racialized versions of the female black body against its biological and even medical dimensions, but this pairing also strives to complicate black corporeality and deconstruct one-dimensional representations of the African American self.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
50 Ana Nunes
While Simpson presents the body as a complex physical reality that is better conveyed in a partial or veiled manner, Gallagher chooses to omit it from her work. Her focus is on a face distorted by the “stereotypical grotesque” or presenting a rather innovative version of the “generic figure.” “Denial of access,” as Wright argues, “is the effective means to control all forms of dominant gaze” (406). The absence of the body closes it to imposed interpretations. However, in order for the head to function as more than a metonymic fragment, Gallagher’s work, which clearly plays with the notion of “denial of access,” requires a novel representational code. Gallagher’s artistic vision is rooted in the idea of finding a visual strategy that can translate the absences of African American history into tangible presences, revising realistic reconstructions of the past in search of “new representations . . . in order to impart a stronger sense of the unpresentable,” as Jean-François Lyotard puts it (81). In Coral Cities, Gallagher creates a fantasy out of the historical reality of the Middle Passage. The artist combs the seabed in search of those who threw themselves or were thrown out of slave ships. In the series Watery Ecstatic 2003, 2005, and 2006, the slaves are found in the watery deep as part of marvellous sea creatures. In one painting from Watery Ecstatic 2005 (unnumbered series) a jellyfish, painted in vivid greens and dazzling pinks, carries in its trailing tentacles the faces of the lost and found. Their hair has become almost pure white, perhaps marking the passage of time, and their faces are somewhat expressionless, indicating that the freedom of the deep sea does not represent a return to either homeland or family. The motif of the jellyfish, or sometimes only its floating tentacles, is repeated in this series of watercolors (which also make use of pencil, ink, oil, varnish, cut paper, and other techniques), but there is variation in the repetition. In one of the 2003 works, sea urchins with their hard spines drift dangerously close to the heads of the marooned, reminding the viewer of the sharp edges of a painful history. In another, a white fish reveals its menacing teeth. The white fish directly carved on paper contrasts with the green tentacles of the jellyfish, reminiscent of the ghostly “men without skin” who haunt Morrison’s Beloved (210). In all these works, the most vivid aspect of the minute faces that punctuate the floating green ribbons of the aquatic creatures is the eyes. The eyes, which make a noticeable attempt to catch the eyes of the other faces, reveal a desire for connection, communication, and community.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Disembodiments 51
The need to reestablish a sense of community when all that was familiar has vanished is also evoked in the Watery Ecstatic works of 2004 and 2005 in which the artist carves her imaginings directly onto layers of white watercolor paper. Here Gallagher plays with the scrimshaw crafting used by whalers to pass the time. The mariners tended to carve figurations of their trade, women, or home (Lipman, Warren, and Bishop 112). Gallagher’s work evokes the last motif. The circular form in which she arranges the series of female heads suggests a sense of community and the desire to establish links to the ancestral home. This connection between these marooned communities and Africa is made by transforming hair, a natural aspect of the physiological body, into a cultural signifier. The hair of the jellyfish series is depicted as organic matter at the mercy of the currents and the passage of time, while in works such as Dirty O’s (2006) and Bird in Hand, to state just two examples, hair is represented as a cultural object. In these the clipped images from black magazines display advertisements for wigs for women that mimic the characteristics of white hair with its attributes of desirability and attractiveness. Both wig and wig wearers, as mentioned before, are transformed by Gallagher’s use of the stereotypical grotesque, and the oppressive standards of white female beauty are revealed. Gallagher is well aware that hair, as Mercer puts it, “is never a straightforward biological fact, because it is almost always groomed, prepared, cut, concealed and generally worked upon by human hands. Such practices socialize hair, making it the medium of significant statements about self and society and the codes of value that bind them, or do not” (420). In Gallagher’s hands, hair is portrayed as a malleable medium invested with symbolic value. It can unveil racist ideology, exhume the history of the Middle Passage, or reveal African cultural practices. It is worth noting that in Gallagher’s work these figurations of hair are not clearly divided in ideological or semiotic fields, but they are part of parallel and sometimes competing meanings, as in the case of Peg-Leg’s Afro, which encloses the miniature pictographs of the wig advertisements. In this way, Gallagher deconstructs the Afro as “natural” black hair and places it in its cultural and political contexts as a reaction vehicle against hegemonic ideologies. The artist’s project is one that juxtaposes seemingly disparate realities, spaces, and time spans in order to reveal the complexity of African American history and identity. Thus, the Afro also functions as link between now and the past, bondage and ideologies of consumption, and as a “reconstitutive link to Africa . . . helping
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
52 Ana Nunes
to redefine a diaspora people not as Negro but as Afro-American,” as Mercer argues (423). Diaspora is a key element of Gallagher’s work. Her own familial history encompasses Atlantic islands. Her father’s family comes from the Cape Verde archipelago, where her grandfather was a whaler before he left for Providence, Rhode Island, and her mother has roots in Ireland. The navigation of the Atlantic, as the forced voyage of the Middle Passage, or the more contemporary strained journey of migration functions as central leitmotif in the artist’s oeuvre. This Atlantic diaspora is perhaps more clearly articulated in her scrimshaw works. Seen from a distance, these seem to be maps of islands lost in the oceanic vastness and, as such, they suggest the imperative of creating a cartography of the Middle Passage and its diaspora. In this manner, the artist shows her understanding of the role of art as memorial and monument to the dead and object of remembrance to the living. Upon closer inspection, Gallagher’s white maps reveal a loose circle of disembodied female heads, displaying intricate hairstyles evoking African hair culture. Here hair functions as the signpost to Africa. It is interesting to note that in these works, the generic figure of the jellyfish paintings is absent. There is an individualization of the female figure represented by the diverse hairstyles. This points to the ethnic variety seen aboard the slave ships and the decimation of a continent that then, as now, was culturally diverse. The distinctiveness of the place of ancestry is frequently lost in a substantive that describes a whole continent, stressing the memories vanished in the transatlantic crossing. Nonetheless, it is worth noting that in Western culture and even in African American visual and literary production, Africa, a vast and culturally and linguistically varied region, is often represented as uniform and somewhat standardized. The concept of hegemony is, thus, a fluid one. Gallagher, however, via her meticulous carving, confers to each figure her own sense of individuality. Albeit with all other references lost in the seabed, a rhetoric of nationality or ethnicity cannot be reconstructed. But it can, as Gallagher demonstrates, be signaled. A critical aspect of Gallagher’s insistence on the diasporic as a means of representing a historical chart of the New World from the Middle Passage to the present day is the representation of the marked or mutilated black body. Morrison is possibly the one contemporary author who has given primacy to the female body as marked territory that challenges her characters’ own sense of identity. From Pauline’s deformed foot; Eva’s missing leg; Sula’s birthmark; Baby Sugg’s limp;
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Disembodiments 53
Sethe’s scarred back described by Paul D in a moment of (com)passion as “the decorative work of an ironsmith too passionate for display” (Morrison, Beloved 17) and instants later as “a revolting clump of scars” (Morrison, Beloved 21); Sethe’s mother’s branded body, whose mouth is permanently twisted from being punished with a bit; Beloved’s “smile under her chin” (Morrison, Beloved 275); Golden Gray’s lost arm; and Dorca’s marked face, the body defies the characters’ sense of self while remaining elusive as a means of explaining that same self. As McDowell persuasively argues, “In Beloved, as throughout Morrison’s corpus, the dispersed pieces of the body can only partly represent the ‘self ’ and are not reducible to the ‘self.’ In other words, body and self do not coincide; the body does not constitute the sum total of the self ” (308). When Beloved emerges from the water, it seems that her body is all that is left from her crossing. Nonetheless, despite her unlined skin, her body is broken: “It is difficult keeping her head on her neck, her legs attached to her hips when she is by herself. Among the things she could remember was when she first knew that she could wake up any day and find herself in pieces. When her tooth came out—an odd fragment, last in a row—she thought it was starting” (133). Morrison dramatizes the loss of home and family, the disruption of all mores to the point that all that is left from the transatlantic passage is the body. However, this is a body that has been kidnapped, shackled, beaten, abused, subjected to hunger, cold, and lying in its own filth—this is an occupied body. In Beloved, the colonized body is a site of both physical and psychological oppression: “Anybody white could take your whole self for anything that came to mind. Not just work, kill, or maim you . . . Dirty you so bad you forgot who you were and couldn’t think it up” (251). For Morrison, the body is a “stubbornly local phenomenon,” as Terry Eagleton puts it (70). Thus, it constitutes a plastic surface where history has left definite imprints. However, manifested in this writer’s work is also how the local and historical can be universal and timeless, and how the marked body can link past and future in search of “new representations . . . in order to impart a stronger sense of the unpresentable,” to return to Lyotard. In Gallagher’s work the notion of the occupied body manifested in Morrison’s novel gives way to a sense of absence. The strategy of disembodiment seemingly frees the self from its scarred corporeality. However, the head, the house of personal and racial memory, remains. The eyes also remain, bearing witness to the physical assaults on the body. Gallagher shares with Morrison the interest in the dialectic between
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
54 Ana Nunes
past and present and in a diasporic body that can encompass several places and time spans. These are artistic projects that require a new aesthetic. Such art, as Homi Bhabha puts it, “demands an encounter with ‘newness’ that is not part of the continuum of the past and present . . . Such art does not merely recall the past, refiguring its contingent ‘inbetween’ space, that innovates and interrupts the performance of the present. The ‘past-present’ becomes part of the necessity, not the nostalgia, of living” (7). Inherent in Bhabha’s “past-present” is the creation of the future diaspora, which is influenced by the collective memory, but not confined by it; moved by history, but not defeated by it. “This kind of work,” as Nicholas Mirzoeff states, “cannot be done by standard histories or realistic representations” (209). This is precisely the diasporic reality that Gallagher seeks to construct: a reality that it not limited by the boundaries of factual histories or the frontiers of realistic representations. The revision of hegemonic histories, as Ella Shohat and Robert Stam argue, requires the creation of alternative aesthetics: “These aesthetics bypass the formal conventions of dramatic realism . . . featuring other historical rhythms, other narrative structures, other views of the body, sexuality, spirituality, and collective life” (41). This is a polycentric figurative and narrative model aimed at disrupting authoritarian forms of discourse. In Coral Cities, Gallagher attempts to recover the undocumented and fundamentally “unpresentable” past of the diaspora. There is no record of those who died en route aboard slave ships. “They never survived in the lore; there are no songs or dances or tales of these people,” as Morrison explains (Darling 247). Thus, Gallagher’s creation of a fantastic aquatic world corresponds with a desire to visually represent a historical reality for which there is no register. This “desire for narrative freedom from realism, and from univocal narrative stance,” as Wendy Faris states, also “implicitly correspond[s] textually in a new way to a critique of totalitarian discourses of all kinds” (180). In this way, inherent in Gallagher’s project is not only the adoption of the fantastic as an effective means of portraying African American history but also the pursuit of a figurative model that would allow her to present a critique of dominant ideologies. Her creation of a fantastic world inhabited by half-human, half-fish creatures can, thus, be equated to the use of magical realism in the literary text. Magical realism, as Theo L. D’haen argues, enables writers to displace hegemonic ideologies by “first appropriating the techniques of the ‘centr-al’ line and then . . . create an alternative world correcting so-called existing
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Disembodiments 55
reality, and thus to right the wrongs this ‘reality’ depends upon. Magical realism thus reveals itself as a ruse to invade and take over dominant discourse(s)” (195). Hence, magical realism facilitates the displacement of the hegemonic control over discourse and recovers the silenced voices of those who remained outside history and who were, therefore, obliterated from realistic modes of representation. In this way, Gallagher, like magical-realist writers, offers the viewer a counternarrative that aims at critiquing, revising, and transforming the world as perceived in stereotypical views of identity and history. Hers is not a chronological or linear history, as implied in the circular form of her figurations and the juxtaposing of elements from different times and places, but rather a history that aims at disrupting the linearity of narratives rooted in practices of institutional abuse, thus unsettling forms of univocal discourse. For this artist, the diasporic present is embedded in the past and several time spans can be condensed, juxtaposed, contrasted in the same canvas. There is, then, a sense that history is spatial rather than temporal. This evokes the techniques used in Romare Bearden’s collages where African American history is represented, as Patton states, in “an overall shallow pictorial space . . . There is a similar jazz-rhythm created for the eye in the juxtaposition of different-sized figures in one spatial plane” (189). In this graphic space where the lost bodies of the Middle Passage are set side by side with the bodies lost to demands of hegemonic discourses of the twentieth century, Gallagher paints a canvas of synthesis in which seemingly contradictory forces such as past and present, personal and collective can be contained, evoking Houston Baker’s view of the blues as “a robust matrix, where endless antinomies are mediated and understanding and explanation finds conditions of possibility” (7). Her work confronts the viewer with these paradoxical elements. As Ralph Ellison states in relation to another artist, Gallagher’s canvases reflect the “leaps in consciousness, distortions, paradoxes, reversals, telescoping of time and surreal blending of styles, values, hopes and dreams which characterize much of the Negro history” (Patton 189). In this manner, Gallagher’s notion of diaspora is characterized by heterogeneity and hybridity. Her watery metamorphoses of the black body point toward diasporic identities that are, as Stuart Hall observes, “constantly producing and reproducing themselves anew, through transformation and difference” (235).
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
56 Ana Nunes
Disembodiments 57
1. The “stereotypical grotesque” was used by black artists such as Faith Ringgold and David Hammons in the 1970s. 2. The “stereotypical grotesque” has also been used to dismantle preconceived notions of sexuality tied to ideas of race and gender. Karen Walker’s caricatures of sexual scenes between slaves and their masters is a good example of how this type of grotesque can be used to challenge different aspects of the politics of identity.
Works Cited Alexander, Karen. “A Challenge to History: Ellen Gallagher’s Coral Cities.” Coral Cities: Ellen Gallagher. Liverpool: Tate Liverpool, 2007. 71–78. Print. Baker, Houston, Jr. Blues, Ideology, and Afro-American Literature: A Vernacular Theory. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1987. Print. Bhabha, Homi. The Location of Culture. London: Routledge, 1994. Print. Darling, Marsha. “In the Realm of Responsibility: A Conversation with Toni Morrison.” Conversations with Toni Morrison. Ed. Danielle Taylor-Guthrie. Jackson: UP of Mississippi, 1994. 244–46. Print. D’haen, Theo L. “Magical Realism and Postmodernism: Decentering Privileged Centers.” Magical Realism: Theory, History, Community. Ed. Lois Parkinson Zamora and Wendy B. Faris. Durham, NC: Duke UP, 1995. 191–208. Print. Eagleton, Terry. The Illusions of Post-Modernism. Oxford: Blackwell, 1996. Print. Faris, Wendy B. “Sheherazade’s Children: Magical Realism and Postmodern Fiction.” Magical Realism: Theory, History, Community. Ed. Lois Parkinson Zamora and Wendy B. Faris. Durham, NC: Duke UP, 1995, 163–190. Print. Foster, Hal, Rosalind Krauss, Yve-Alain Bois, and Benjamin H. D. Buchloh. Art Since 1900: Modernism, Antimodernism, Postmodernism. London: Thames & Hudson, 2004. Print. Hall, Stuart. “Cultural Identity and the Diaspora”, 1990. Web. . Heartney, Eleanor. “Mapping the Unmentionable.” After the Revolution: Women Who Transformed Contemporary Art. Ed. Eleanor Heartney, Helaine Posner, Nancy Princenthal, and Sue Scott. London: Prestel, 2007, 252–73. Print. Lipman, Jean, Elizabeth V. Warren, and Robert Charles Bishop. Young America: A Folk Art History. Manchester, VT: Hudson Hills Press/Museum of American Folk Art, 1986. Print. Lyotard, Jean-François. The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 1984. Print. Mercer, Kobena. “Black Hair/Style Politics.” The Subcultures Reader. Ed. Ken Gelder and Sarah Thornton. New York: Routledge, 1997. 420–35. Print.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Notes
McDowell, Deborah E. “Recovery Missions: Imaging the Body Ideals.” Recovering the Black Female Body: Self-Representations by African American Women. Ed. Michael Bennett and Vanessa D. Dickerson. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers UP, 2001. 296–317. Print. Mirzoeff, Nicholas. “The Multiple Viewpoint: Diaspora and Visual Culture.” The Visual Culture Reader. Ed. Nicholas Mirzoeff. New York: Routledge, 2002. 204– 214. Print. Morrison, Toni. Beloved. London: Picador, 1988. Print. ———. The Bluest Eye, 1970. London: Virago, 1994. Print. Patton, Sharon F. African-American Art. New York: Oxford UP, 1998. Print. Shohat, Ella, and Robert Stam. “Narrativizing Visual Culture: Towards a Polycentric Aesthetics.” The Visual Culture Reader. Ed. Nicholas Mirzoeff. New York: Routledge, 2002. 525–32. Print. Spillers, Hortense J. “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe: An American Grammar Book.” Within the Circle: An Anthology of African American Literary Criticism from the Harlem Renaissance to the Present. Ed. Angelyn Mitchell. London: Duke UP, 1994. 454–81. Print. Tate, Greg. “Are You Free or Are You a Mystery?” Coral Cities: Ellen Gallagher. Liverpool: Tate Liverpool, 2007. 17–29. Print. Wright, Beryl J. “Black Body: Recording the Body.” Callaloo 19.2 (1996): 397–413.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
58 Ana Nunes
Stigmata Embodying the Scars of Slavery Venetria K. Patton
D
eborah McDowell has observed that while black men wrote most of the slave narratives, black women have written the majority of contemporary novels about slavery—novels that emphasize “not what was done to slave women, but what they did with what was done to them” (146). I would argue that black women writers’ investment in contemporary novels of slavery is rooted in the history of partus sequitur ventrem—the child follows the condition of the mother. Thus the mother’s body determined the slave status of her offspring. Through this doctrine, the mother’s body serves as a border to police the purity of the nation’s boundary (Patton 124). In Bordering on the Body: The Racial Matrix of Modern Fiction and Culture, Laura Doyle notes, “In the race-bounded economy the mother is a maker and marker of boundaries, a generator of liminality . . .” (27). This position of “maker and marker of boundaries” places slave women in a rather precarious position. According to Doyle, “Because of the mother’s alignment with the body and her function as reproducer of the group as a social body, the mother comes to signify, often ambivalently, a bodily and collective past” (6). It is this collective past that I find embodied in the scars prevalent in contemporary novels of slavery, whether it is Ursa’s damaged womb in Gayl Jones’s Corregidora (1975), Dana’s severed arm in Octavia Butler’s Kindred (1979), or Lizzie’s scarred body in Phyllis Alesia
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
3
Perry’s Stigmata (1999). Whether through stories passed down by the Corregidora women, Dana’s supernatural time travel, or Lizzie’s inexplicable shackle scars, these protagonists must cope with a matrilineal history shrouded in the pain of slavery. However, for the purpose of this chapter, I will limit my discussion to Perry’s Stigmata and Lizzie’s relationships with her grandmother, Grace, and great-great-grandmother, Ayo. Although the intercession of Grace and Ayo may initially seem unsettling and unwelcome since it leads to 14 years of confinement in mental institutions, the story that unfolds is actually one of healing as Lizzie connects to a matrilineal story of slavery and its legacy. In fact, Lizzie’s scars illustrate the ongoing process of healing slavery’s wounds. I will argue that Perry uses Lizzie’s scars or stigmata as a way of exploring and rewriting the meaning of the African American body. In Scarring the Black Body: Race and Representation in African American Literature, Carol Henderson argues that the scarred black body serves “as an active metaphor for the reinvention of African American subjectivity within certain cultural moments” (7). I assert that authors of contemporary novels of slavery do not return to the site of slavery in order to emphasize its devastating effects, but instead use their writing as a means to heal the wounds of slavery. Thus Lizzie’s scarred body serves as a rewriting of the legacy of slavery. The condition of slavery is often seen as one that eradicated ties to African homelands and traditions and left a broken or damaged person; however, we see in Stigmata an insistence on remembering not just the harm inflicted by slavery, but a determination to cling to the scraps of African heritage as well. We see characters who may be physically damaged but who refuse to be mentally broken. Slavery then becomes a legacy of survival, not defeat. Stigmata opens in Atlanta in 1994 with Lizzie having been in her latest mental institution for the past two years. She finds it funny that the doctor thinks he’s cured her madness, while she knows there is no cure for her condition. After 14 years “and some well-acted moments of sanity,” she is headed home to Tuskegee (Perry 6). It is clear from the outset that Lizzie is playing the role of the cured patient. However, what becomes increasingly clear is that her diagnosis of insanity may have been a misreading of slavery’s scars. The story unfolds in a nonlinear format of multilayered flashbacks, present tense, and excerpts from her great-great-grandmother’s journal. A sense of circularity is introduced by the first entry from Ayo’s diary, dated December 26, 1898, in which Ayo explains to Lizzie’s great-grandmother, Joy, why she wants her to record her history. Ayo’s
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
60 Venetria K. Patton
insistence on documenting her story is her first attempt to rewrite the legacy of slavery. With enslavement, Ayo was expected to forget her African past, but the first thing Ayo does with her journal is to deny her slave name and claim her African name: “‘Bessie ain’t my name . . . My name Ayo’” (Perry 7). Bessie, we assume, is the name Ayo was given by her owners, but this is her story, not theirs. After stating that her true name is Ayo, she notes the importance of remembering who one is and what one means to the world: “‘I come from a long line of forever people. We are forever. Here at the bottom of heaven we live in the circle. We back and gone and back again’” (Perry 7). African religion authority John S. Mbiti notes in Introduction to African Religion that Africans view the universe as eternal: “In many places, circles are used as symbols of the continuity of the universe. They are the symbols of eternity, of unendingness, of continuity” (Mbiti 37).1 The circle is also an apt illustration of the African concept of time, which is synchronic or cyclical in nature rather than diachronic or linear. This cyclical sense of time is also apparent in African religious beliefs “that human life does not terminate at the death of the individual, but continues beyond death” (Mbiti 75). Ayo uses this continuity to tell a story that can’t be sufficiently told by entries in a diary. As the novel progresses, we find that Ayo must use her very body to tell her story—it is as if she makes her very scars speak. But even this is not enough to fully tell her story, so her granddaughter and great-great-granddaughter must pick up the thread and help their foremother tell this unspeakable tale. Thus Lizzie finds herself inhabiting the lives of her foremothers, Ayo and Grace, in an attempt to rewrite the legacy of slavery. At the age of 14, Lizzie inherited her grandmother’s quilt and her great-great-grandmother’s papers. Grace left instructions to give her trunk not to one of her daughters, but to a granddaughter who had not even been born. Lizzie’s father says, “I think your Grandma Grace must have had some kind of premonition about you” (Perry 23). This ability to know the future seems to be an inherited trait, as Ayo also predicted the birth of Joy’s long-awaited first child. Not only does she predict Grace’s birth, but she also foretells her ability to see into the future. In the March 22, 1899, diary entry, Ayo says of the yet unborn Grace, “She cant get here cause Im in the way she say. But when Im gone she come to take my place. She gon know things the one that’s comin” (Perry 34). Ayo dies the following year, the same year Grace is born, which suggests that Grace does indeed come to take Ayo’s place and with it she inherits Ayo’s slavery experience. Literary critic Lisa Long notes, “It is significant
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Stigmata 61
that in Stigmata the ‘possession’ skips generations from grandmother to granddaughter, so that the woman who suffers the Middle Passage and slavery never visits that experience on her own daughter. Still, the further from slavery one moves, the more pain those granddaughters must bear” (473). Lizzie must attend to both Ayo’s and Grace’s experiences, but Grace only had to contend with Ayo’s. “This cycle does not bode well for Lizzie’s future granddaughter, who, we presume, will endure the weight of Lizzie’s fourteen-year institutionalization” (Perry 473). Thus Ayo, Grace, and Lizzie form a matrilineal line of descent in which every other generation is bestowed with the gift of second sight that allows them to inhabit the lives of their foremothers. However, the ability to crisscross space and time to inhabit the past and present is generally not seen as a gift but as a form of madness. In fact, it is the fear of being put in an asylum that leads Grace to abandon her husband and children. Ayo’s memories invade Grace, and she believes she has lost her mind because she knows things she should not know and feels excruciating pain for no apparent reason. Grace realizes that if she stays, her husband will be forced to commit her, and her mother and sisters will not be able to help her. While Grace ran away to avoid an insane asylum, Lizzie is institutionalized for 14 years before faking her recovery. Upon her release, though, she picks up where Grace left off. Just as Grace was compelled to record her Grandmother Ayo’s life story through a quilt, Lizzie must tell Grace’s story through a new quilt. This passing on of her foremother’s story will not end with Lizzie, as she realizes the quilt’s fabric has to last long enough for the next storyteller. Lizzie has joined a long line of women who refuse to let the painful history of slavery be forgotten. Thus the rewriting of her enslavement begins with Ayo’s diary and continues with the story quilts of her descendants, Grace and Lizzie. The granddaughter and greatgranddaughter are driven to quilting in order to make sense of their visions and scars. Thus the marks Lizzie bears on her arms and legs are not only symbolic of the manacles worn by Ayo but also serve as a testament to the refusal to forget. Just as Ayo before her chose to remember, Lizzie’s very body demands that the horrors of slavery never be forgotten. When Father Tom asks Lizzie how she got the scars around her wrists, she responds, “‘A legacy. Two lifetimes ago. I was a slave then’” (Perry 212). Earlier in their conversation, she explained, “‘My trouble is, Father, that I’m an old soul in a young body’” (Perry 211). She has tried to explain her visions to many doctors only to have them dismissed as fantasies
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
62 Venetria K. Patton
brought on by the reading of her great-great-grandmother’s diary. Yet she has no way of explaining how she knows things about the past that she could not possibly know without having been there herself. However, her Aunt Eva considers Lizzie lucky because she has been here before. Eva sees her sister Grace in Lizzie and knows about her visions of Ayo, but for Eva reincarnation is a given, as she believes “all of us have been around once or twice” (Perry 117). Ayo seems to share this sentiment as she recounts a memory of her mother: “This is the hand of my mother, she says. And of my grandmother. Petals of the flower. Your life is many lives” (Perry 176). The multiplicity of Lizzie’s life is reflected in the scars on her wrists, ankles, and back, as these scars speak of the horrors endured not by Lizzie but by her foremother. Yet, her doctors have told her that reincarnation is not real, and so Lizzie has pretended that she cut her own wrists and ankles. But for Lizzie reincarnation is real, and her scars are stigmata, a physical trauma to remind her of a past not to be forgotten. Initially, Lizzie does not have a word to describe the connection she experiences with her ancestor, Ayo. In a moment of frustrated sarcasm, she displays her scarred back to her psychiatrist, Dr. Brun, and tells her, “‘What you’re looking at was rather commonplace back then. Scars like these. That’s the thing, Doctor, I’m just a typical nineteenth-century nigger with an extraordinary gift. The gift of memory’” (Perry 204). However, it is not until a discussion with a Catholic priest that Lizzie learns about stigmata and realizes that there is a precedent for what she is experiencing. Father Tom tells Lizzie about a monk wounded in the manner of Christ’s crucifixion: “‘It’s called stigmata, child. That’s what you have’” (Perry 213). Although Perry does not name the monk, this appears to be a reference to Saint Francis of Assisi. St. Bonaventure, one of St. Francis’s early biographers, read his stigmata “as an indicator of an inner condition” (Kiely 32). I believe this is how Perry intends for her readers to read the scars on Lizzie’s body—they are representative of her inner turmoil. Robert Kiely observes, “For Christians, the wounds of the crucified Christ are the paradigm of transformative stigmata, marks of punishment and pain reread as signs of healing and salvation” (21). It is this type of rereading that Lizzie is able to do once she has a word for what is happening to her body. Rather than merely thinking of herself as crazy, Lizzie can learn from her body. Father Tom suggests, “‘Maybe you’re marked so you won’t forget this time, so you will remember and move on’” (Perry 213). Father Tom’s remarks are a bit ambiguous in that he could mean Lizzie won’t forget this period of
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Stigmata 63
Ayo’s enslavement or that this time Ayo will not forget. It is almost as if Ayo has had three chances to contend with these memories: first as Ayo, then as Grace, and now as Lizzie. However, recognizing the importance of remembering seems to be what leads Lizzie from apparent mental illness to healing and wholeness. It is almost as if the repression of memory or its denial is the cause of Lizzie’s anguish, but once she is willing to remember she is in a position to heal. However, this movement from illness to healing is not easy. Lizzie spends 14 years in mental institutions contending with a trauma she and her doctors cannot comprehend. Psychotherapist Laura S. Brown notes that a key aspect to the definition of a traumatic event according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSMIII-R) is that “‘The person has experienced an event that is outside the range of human experience’” (qtd. in Brown 100). Clearly what Lizzie is experiencing as she flashes back in time to the lives of her foremothers is beyond the pale of human experience, as was the initial experience of slavery by Ayo, which triggers these episodes for her descendants, Grace and Lizzie. “The trauma is a repeated suffering of the event, but it is also a continual leaving of its site” (Caruth 10). Part of the trauma for both Lizzie and Grace is that they are yanked back and forth between their worlds and the world(s) of their ancestor(s). Grace and Lizzie have no control over when they will be snatched from their lives into the past, and Lizzie may be thrown into either Grace’s or Ayo’s experiences. Thus these moments are disconcerting to say the least. Nor does inhabiting these moments of their ancestor’s life mean that Lizzie and Grace fully understand their foremother. They are just as perplexed by Ayo’s predicament as Ayo must have been. Psychiatrist Dori Laub and psychologist Nanette Auerhahn have argued that “since neither culture nor experience provide structures for formulating acts of massive aggression, survivors cannot articulate trauma, even to themselves. . . . Close to the experience, survivors are captive observers who can only repeat it. They cannot make sense of it; they cannot know it cognitively” (288). Thus even though Grace and Lizzie relive Ayo’s experiences, they cannot protect Ayo; they can merely share her pain and confusion but at a distance. These visions or memories are confused in their minds, thus reflecting Cathy Caruth’s observation, “The traumatized, we might say, carry an impossible history within them, or they become themselves the symptom of a history that they cannot entirely possess” (5). Grace and Lizzie also display the symptoms of
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
64 Venetria K. Patton
Ayo, who endured the horrors of the Middle Passage, but they cannot fully grasp what is happening to them. Ayo’s painful history begins this matrilineal legacy of cultural trauma. Interestingly, Laub and Auerhahn note a connection between trauma and familial dysfunction, “as trauma disrupts the link between self and empathic other, a link first established by the expectation of mutual responsiveness in the mother-child bond and ‘objectified’ in the maternal introject” (287). For Laub and Auerhahn, trauma is the “absence of a mothering function” (287) to prevent trauma, which is akin to what is experienced by Ayo and her descendants. Ayo’s mother could not prevent her abduction, and Ayo and Grace cannot shield their granddaughter(s) from Ayo’s painful memories. According to Henderson, if one is to understand “the generational ‘begetting’ of cultural wounds, one must return to the figure of the black mother” (14). This brings one back to Doyle’s point of the precarious position of the black mother as “maker and marker of boundaries” (27). This role places her in the unenviable position of being “the instrument and embodiment of their oppression” (Doyle 33). Ayo must not only contend with her transition from Ayo to Bessie, but she must also accept the legacy she has bequeathed to her descendants. Grace has a similar dilemma as she contends with her guilt for abandoning her daughter Sarah when she feared her husband would be forced to commit her to an insane asylum due to the visions she was experiencing. Grace is grappling with abandoning her daughter and seeking a means of making amends while explaining her actions. However, Grace’s sorrows begin with Ayo’s initial traumatic transformation from Ayo to Bessie. Just as Grace cannot escape her guilt for abandoning Sarah, neither can Ayo absolve her guilt for wandering away from her mother and being caught by slave catchers. The separation of families was a common feature of slavery, which operated as though enslaved Africans were commodities rather than sensate beings. Mothers and children were separated with impunity, as African women were deemed to be “natally dead” and thus not emotionally connected to their offspring. In Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and the Literary Imagination, Toni Morrison observes that there is an assumption “that slave women are not mothers; they are ‘natally dead,’ with no obligations to their offspring or their own parents” (21). In fact, Orlando Patterson describes the situation of slavery as “natal alienation” because the slave is “alienated from all ‘rights’ or claims of birth, he ceased to belong in his own right to any legitimate social order” (5). However, Patterson is also
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Stigmata 65
quick to note, “When we say that the slave was natally alienated and ceased to belong independently to any formally recognized community, this does not mean that he or she did not experience or share informal social relations. . . . The important point, however, is that these relationships were never recognized as legitimate or binding” (6). This lack of recognition of her relationship with her mother is part of Ayo’s trauma, and thus part of the rewriting of slavery’s legacy for Ayo is an attempt to reconnect with her mother via her memories. Joy writes in the diary, “She once told me that Ayo got los when she crossed the water. Bessie kinda took over. She had to think like her not like Ayo from Afraca” (Perry 50). When telling Joy about her capture, Ayo explains the pain that her wanderlust created because it led to her enslavement. However, when Ayo recounts this pain, it is not her pain alone, but also her mother’s pain that she remembers. Not only has Ayo lost her mother and homeland, but her mother has lost a daughter as well. This was the moment that engendered psychic trauma for generations of women, but in order to move beyond Ayo’s pain Lizzie must figure out how to face her foremother’s painful past. Henderson believes that “for African Americans to reconstitute their humanity, they must return to the site of that violence—their own captive bodies” (Henderson 38). The stigmata that Lizzie experiences seems to be a means of drawing her back to her body and her foremothers’ bodies. Her very body is demanding that she remember her cultural past. Lizzie begins by seeing visions, but they quickly become more intense and physically painful. Lizzie’s response is similar to her grandmother Grace’s—she resists the memories and tries to avoid them. Lizzie believes she has “to get out of the past or perish” (Perry 120). However, on the evening her parents believe she has attempted suicide, Lizzie has no choice but to confront what is happening to her. She has been experiencing Ayo’s terrifying Middle Passage ordeal only to discover that “All the aches and mysterious stabs of pain now have their corresponding wounds. Raggedy, ugly, familiar skin openings and welted patterns” (Perry 146). Ana Nunes observes that in “African American literature, the disfigurement of the body constitutes a central vehicle of both personal and collective history. Lizzie’s stigmata works as a physical manifestation of Morrison’s concept of rememory, the never-ending resurfacing of a traumatic and partially lost history” (230). However, this physical manifestation of trauma is not limited to African American contexts. Caruth asserts that trauma “is always the story of a wound that cries out” (Duboin 288). Laurie Vickroy shares this assessment as
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
66 Venetria K. Patton
she notes, “Survivors’ painful connection to past trauma is also displayed and replayed through the body, even branded into their flesh” (32). Vickroy goes on to observe that “trauma writers make the suffering body the small, focused universe of the tormented and a vehicle for rendering unimaginable experience tangible to readers” (33). Although Perry is not one of the writers included in Vickroy’s study, it is clear that she would fit within this category of trauma writers. According to Vickroy, “serious trauma writers attempt to guide readers through a re-created process of traumatic memory in order that this experience be understood more widely” (8). This is exactly what Lisa Long argues Perry does by using physical pain as a means to authenticate her historical renderings: “The protagonists believe that history really happened because it hurts them. Without the bodily transubstantiation of distant suffering, there is no apprehension of the past” (461). Thus for Perry, the wound and associated pain are essential aspects of her story. After all, Lizzie can pass off her visions as dreams, but there is no denying the bloody wounds that cover her body. Yet Lizzie’s parents are horrified when they see their wounded and bloodied daughter and can only read the scene as one of self-mutilation. However, one must remember “the dual functionality of scars as simultaneously signs of wounding and signs of healing” (Henderson 7). Lizzie’s parents see her bloody bedroom as symbolic of her downward spiral to insanity, but this is actually a step toward healing. One can read this scene as a transitional moment for Lizzie. The wounds are not simply marks of pain, but also symbols of “connection between the ancestors and Lizzie, the past and present” (Nunes 230). Dennis Slattery asserts, “The wounded body is sacred in some deep level of its existence; it is a body specialized and formed by experience; in its new way of being present to the world, the wounded body gains something not possessed before” (7). Slattery elaborates on this point by noting “that a richer experience of being open to the world occurs through wounding” (13). He believes “our wounds have the capacity to advance our consciousness to new levels of awareness” (16). Lizzie seems to move toward this new level of awareness through her two years of silence. According to Vickroy, “Silence has multivalent meanings when considering trauma and narrating specific elements and processes of that experience. . . . Silence can represent a traumatic gap, a withholding of words because of terror, guilt, or coercion; it characterizes traumatic memory as wordless, visual, and reenactive rather than cognitive/verbal when facing the unspeakable” (187). Lizzie tries to explain her silence
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Stigmata 67
by saying, “if they knew, if they heard and smelled and saw all, they’d understand how speech, for me, has become inadequate” (Perry 157). Bessel Van der Kolk and Onno Van der Hart note that trauma “cannot be easily translated into the symbolic language necessary for linguistic retrieval” because this “speechless terror” is experienced on a “somatosensory or iconic level: as somatic sensations, behavioral reenactments, nightmares and flashbacks” (442–43). At this point, Lizzie cannot form the words to make her experience understandable to others because she is not yet in a position to fully process what is happening to her. “During the two years of silence, I dream memories of Africa every night and wake to mornings of fiery pain. My scars burn at the edges” (Perry 157). Since Lizzie has never been to Africa, these must be Ayo’s memories. Ayo is determined to cling to whatever pieces of her heritage she can hold on to despite the horrors of slavery. Yes, she remembers the pain inflicted, but she refuses to allow this to eradicate her memory of home. The burning sensation Lizzie experiences also seems to be an indication that something is going on below the surface of the scars, just as something is going on beneath the facade of her silence. According to Stefanie Sievers, “despite the overall negative connotations of this long period of external stasis and lack of genuine communication, the novel also suggests that a necessary development is happening within Lizzie during that time” (135). For example, it is during this time that she meets Mrs. Corday, another patient who confirms for Lizzie and the reader that Lizzie is not imagining what is happening to her because Mrs. Corday actually sees Lizzie as Grace. On another occasion Mrs. Corday sees Lizzie as a young Ayo. At this point, Lizzie would like to speak, but instead she begins to bleed from her wounds. Mrs. Corday stares in awe and fusses over Lizzie while asking her to teach her how to do that. These two episodes with Mrs. Corday precede the healing of Lizzie’s wounds, which suggests that she needed some indication that what she was experiencing was real before she could move forward in the healing process. Lizzie notes that the scars have healed, but they leave ugly marks. Dr. Cremrick puzzles over the fact that the scars look a few years old despite the fact that she was bleeding just last week. This odd timetable for the healing of her wounds suggests that the healing process was more than a physical endeavor. A few months after her wounds have healed, Lizzie begins speaking again. Lizzie’s decision to speak suggests that she is moving forward in her recovery, while her conversation with her cousin Ruth calls into question the original determination of attempted suicide. During their
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
68 Venetria K. Patton
conversation, Ruth observes, “‘Sanity . . . is a mutual agreement between folks trying to control their world . . . The definitions of sanity change every day’” (Perry 192). This acknowledgment by Ruth leads Lizzie to explain that she did not try to commit suicide. Although Ruth does not say she believes Lizzie, her response implies her belief: “‘I’m sorry they hurt you . . . I don’t know why they have to do that’” (Perry 193). Ruth may not understand the reason, but Lizzie has come to understand the importance of remembering. She tells Ruth it is to keep her from forgetting again. Lizzie realizes that she cannot run away from the past. Henderson argues, “writing becomes an antidote to pain, a way to reinterpret the language of the body and heal the wounds of the psyche” (58). Ayo chose writing in the form of the diary she narrated to her daughter Joy. She tells her daughter, “I am Ayo. I remember. This is for those whose bones lay sleepin in the heart of mother ocean for those who tomorrows I never knew who groaned and died in that dark damp aside a me. You rite this daughter for me and for them” (Perry 7). Interestingly, Perry records a similar statement from Ayo, but with a significant difference in the opening lines, “I am Ayo. Joy. I choose to remember” (Perry 17). In the first account Ayo is described as merely remembering, but in the second account she reports her decision to remember. Thus memory is linked to will. Despite the pain associated with her memories, Ayo consciously decides to remember, and she induces her ancestors to keep her memories alive. Remembering is important not only for her but also for those who did not live to tell their stories. She and her ancestors must serve as witnesses to what was done to them. “Moreover, as a storyteller, she has gained vision. She can now testify and become an agent who takes possession of her own past through words that denounce the evils she has survived” (Duboin 291). This is why it is so important for Ayo to begin by claiming her rightful name; this is not Bessie’s story, for that would be someone else’s view of her life. “Ayo tells her haunting story more than three decades after her emancipation. Speaking out is a way for her to exorcize her demons and feel free at last” (Duboin 291). Ayo is speaking for herself and for those who did not make it, and she insists on speaking in her own words. Vickroy believes that “for healing to take place, survivors must find ways to tell their stories and to receive some social acknowledgement if not acceptance” (19). Ayo began seeking this acknowledgment through her diary, but as a dialogic text it is not a fully satisfying approach to telling her story. Duboin notes that the diary “interweaves the mother’s
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Stigmata 69
effort to articulate her pain . . . with the daughter’s difficulty in writing it down, her unwillingness to listen to a story she cannot fully comprehend” (290). Joy tells her mother that she’s tried talking about stuff that isn’t real because she “is unprepared to face the reality of hard facts, and the unconceivable yet real atrocities of slavery” (Duboin 290). Perhaps it is this resistance that leads Ayo to reach out across generations to her descendants in order to have her story really heard and accepted. This is also how the practice of skipping generations begins. It is as if speaking directly to one’s daughter is too painful because the bond is too close, but with the distance of a granddaughter one is better able to communicate. Thus Ayo turns to Grace after encountering Joy’s resistance, and Grace turns to Lizzie rather than burdening her daughter Sarah. However, Grace, like her mother Joy, initially resists Ayo’s story by trying to run away from the scenes in her head. “Erecting barriers against knowing is often the first response to such trauma” (Laub and Auerhahn 290). Grace flees Alabama for Detroit, thinking that she can leave Ayo behind. She has no visions or voices while on the train, but shortly after settling into the Detroit rooming house her ankles begin to bleed. Grace becomes hysterical once she realizes that Ayo is still with her and not back in Alabama. Laub and Auerhahn describe the traumatic experience as “being caught between the compulsion to complete the process of knowing and the inability or fear of doing so” (288). Grace’s initial reaction is fear and avoidance, but she eventually comes to accept the importance of remembering and documenting Ayo’s experience. Rather than a diary, she chooses to use a quilt as her vehicle to record her grandmother’s story of being stolen from Africa and forced into slavery. Before leaving her family, Grace begins a story quilt based on the visions from Ayo’s life. According to Duboin, Perry uses the appliqué quilt “as an overarching metaphor for the legacy of the past, the permanence of rich traditions, and the construction of self within a matrilineage. The quilts crafted or inherited by her female characters are to be seen as narratives that relate individual and collective experiences. They are the gendered expression of a shared cultural memory, the re-writing of American and African American history” (293). As an artifact of shared cultural memory, the quilt has a communal nature, which seems to differentiate it from the dialogic text of the diary. Ayo does not have to prove her experiences to Grace, as she did with Joy, because Grace shares her experiences by inhabiting key moments of Ayo’s life. However, for Grace, “quilting serves the same
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
70 Venetria K. Patton
purposes as writing. . . . Sewing allows Grace to complete the healing process . . . It is an outlet . . . to memorialize the dead, as well as a historical testimony to be passed on” (Duboin 294). Thus Grace uses the quilt as a means to gain some understanding of her visions, but also as a means of telling Ayo’s story. Duboin observes, “Quilting is a family tradition that has roots in African history and culture; it ties up the past with the present, the old with the new. It also facilitates female bonding and bridging across generations and continents” (294). However, it is important to note that Grace’s and Lizzie’s quilts are hybrid artifacts, representing their African American identities. According to Houston Baker and Charlotte Pierce-Baker, “The transmutation of quilting, a European, feminine tradition, into a black women’s folk art, represents an innovative fusion of African cloth manufacture, piecing, and appliqué with awesome New World experiences—and expediencies” (156). This fusion of European and African traditions is particularly apparent in the appliquéd narrative quilts created by Grace and Lizzie. Their technique “in the making of the quilt is similar to that used in the tapestries of West Africa, while the narrative structure roots it in an American tradition, evoking the geographical and cultural journey of black people from the African continent to the New World” (Nunes 237). Thus the appliqué style creates a link to their African heritage, much like Ayo’s insistence on using her African name. The story that they are telling is necessarily rooted in their African heritage. Although she feels better with the completion of the quilt and sends it home to her sister Mary Nell, Grace writes strict instructions not to show the quilt to her daughter Sarah in hopes that she will “not curse her with these things that are happening to me. I thought getting all that down on the quilt in front of me out of me would get rid of it somehow” (Perry 15). Through the quilt, Grace has also sought to rewrite Ayo’s legacy of slavery, but just as the diary was not sufficient to tell the tale, neither is the quilt. Neither words nor images can fully capture Ayo’s story. This seems to be the motivation for Ayo to pass down “that knowin . . . a gift from me her family that’s lost” (Perry 34). Ayo wants to share her story with her descendants but must turn to extraordinary methods to tell a story beyond the realm of the human imagination. The difficult nature of Ayo’s story is implied by the recipients’ response. Both Grace and Lizzie initially resist the images they see and try to escape Ayo’s memories. In fact, Grace eventually dies from
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Stigmata 71
cancer without fully coming to terms with her visions or her decision to abandon her family. Therefore Lizzie’s drive to tell Grace’s story through the quilt is not only to document the pain of slavery across generations, but it is also an attempt by Grace to reach out through Lizzie to the daughter she abandoned. For Lizzie’s mother Sarah, all that matters about Grace is that “She left. She died” (Perry 70). But it is clear that Sarah has never gotten over returning from her grandmother’s house only to find her mother gone. Lizzie gradually unfolds Grace’s story to Sarah through the quilt, but Sarah initially refuses to accept that Lizzie is her mother, great-grandmother, and daughter in one body.2 As much as Sarah tries to deny what Lizzie tries to explain about her reincarnation, she also cannot deny that Lizzie knows things only her mother could know. Sarah’s acceptance of the truth comes only after Lizzie adds the last piece to the quilt—a blue scrap from the dress Ayo wore on the day she was kidnapped and enslaved. Nunes refers to this blue scrap as a “fragment of cultural memory,” which “functions in the narrative as a link to Africa, but it also symbolizes the passing on of the historical testimony along the generational line” (236). With this last piece, Ayo’s descendants have come full circle—Grace’s story is complete only when the symbol of Ayo’s capture and enslavement has been added to the quilt. As she adds the piece, Lizzie explains, “‘That’s what this quilt is about. The past. And putting the past aside when we’re through’” (Perry 228). The pain of the past can be healed only after it’s confronted. According to Long’s reading of Stigmata, Perry challenges “readers to conceive of remembering as a palpable, physical experience” (460). Thus it is not enough for Lizzie to merely remember her foremother’s experience, she must relive it and bear the scars. Her body can then “attest to the reality of slavery” (Long 460). Long asserts in her discussion of Stigmata and Butler’s Kindred that “the suffering that ordinarily cannot be conveyed is invoked in these novels as metonymic proof of a knowable past” (461). Sarah has escaped this traumatic embodiment of slavery’s pain since the matrilineal line of reincarnation skips every other generation. Grace thinks her daughter will be safe because she cannot relive these painful memories, but Long argues, “Sarah is perhaps the most damaged character in Stigmata, stifled by her inability or unwillingness to see the history her daughter embodies for her” (473). Thus in order for Sarah to be healed, her mother, Grace, must return in the figure of Lizzie to reconnect her with her familial history of slavery. Only after Sarah confronts the past can she come to terms with it.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
72 Venetria K. Patton
Sarah is finally able to come to terms with the past and her mother’s abandonment through the assistance of her ancestors—Grace and Ayo—as embodied in Lizzie, thus suggesting, “one’s access to the past is determined by the intensity of one’s connection to ancestors” (Long 462). Sarah accesses the past only with the return of her mother from the dead. Toward the end of the novel Grace, through Lizzie, observes, “The circle is complete and my daughter sits across from me with the gap finally closed” (Perry 230). Although Sarah used to pray for God to send her mother back to her, Grace could return only through her granddaughter, Lizzie. This reunion of mother and daughter is followed by an excerpt from Ayo’s journal in which Joy records Ayo’s death and the passing down of the scrap of blue cloth from the dress she wore when she was captured in Africa: “Take care of that little girl she say and she smiled and say I meant to put this in but I never did and she gave me a piece of blue cloth she had balled up in her hand” (Perry 230). The scene is more than a parallel scene of mother–daughter affection; it is a fitting example of the way in which Lizzie has managed to merge the lives of Ayo and Grace with her own. Sievers observes,“Following her release in 1994, Lizzie then consciously integrates Ayo’s and Grace’s lives into her own. . . . This intersection of identities is supported structurally by having all chapters in this narrative strand conclude with entries from Ayo’s diary. To have Ayo’s words accompany the time period in Lizzie’s life when she is supposedly cured is an indication that she is, in fact, able to integrate the life stories of her foremothers into her own without being overwhelmed by them” (136). This point is supported by Van der Kolk and Van der Hart’s assertion that “In the case of complete recovery, the person does not suffer anymore from the reappearance of traumatic memories in the form of flashbacks, behavioral re-enactments, etc. Instead the story can be told, the person can look back at what happened; he has given it a place in his life history . . . and thereby in the whole of his personality” (447–48). Thus despite Lizzie’s claim that there is no cure for her condition, she has successfully merged her life with that of her foremother, and like the scars on her body she is proof of the intersection of the past and present (Perry 204). The scars serve as both a reminder of the past and a legacy connecting Ayo’s descendants across generations. This matrilineal legacy of Ayo’s descendants is just one thread of a larger cultural trauma. In Cultural Trauma: Slavery and the Formation of African American Identity, Ron Eyerman explores slavery as a cultural
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Stigmata 73
trauma, which he defines as “a collective memory, a form of remembrance that grounded the identity-formation of a people” (1). A distinguishing component of cultural trauma is that one need not directly experience an event that induces trauma. “It is through time-delayed and negotiated recollection that cultural trauma is experienced, a process which places representation in a key role” (Eyerman 12). Thus while Ayo may have experienced trauma, her descendants experienced cultural trauma. It is the impact of cultural trauma that Perry seeks to depict through her focus on the scars encircling Lizzie’s wrists and ankles and crisscrossing her back. These literal scars allow readers to imagine the psychological scars as well. It is no coincidence that writers such as Perry, Butler, and Jones have opted to wound their protagonists in some way in order to symbolize the wounds of slavery, but also to begin the healing process. We are now over one hundred years past the abolition of slavery in the United States, and thus many believe that slavery is a thing of the past that no longer carries tangible hurts. Perhaps this is why some writers are drawn to physical wounds as a means to make the pain of slavery visible. Once the pain is made tangible, maybe the healing can begin. Lizzie will always carry her scars, Dana’s arm will not grow back, and Ursa’s womb cannot be repaired. These permanent scars or wounds are indicative of the lingering impact of slavery even on women who were never slaves themselves. Their bodies tell their stories; however, these are not stories of defeat, but ones of survival. We as readers are called to be witnesses. In the words of Father Tom, we will remember and move on. The point is not to wallow in the past, but to use the past as a stepping stone for growth and development, so that the errors of the past will not be repeated. Like Ayo, we must choose to remember. Notes 1. Although I may make reference to African beliefs, I realize that Africa is a vast continent with many differences. However, like scholars such as Mbiti, I do believe it is possible to look at shared customs and points of view, particularly in reference to particular regions of Africa. 2. I can’t help but note allusions to the Trinity in that Lizzie represents three persons in one body. Perry seems to have revised the notion of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit to that of great-great grandmother, grandmother, and granddaughter. Ayo, like the Father, also sends her other two persons to reach others, such as Sarah.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
74 Venetria K. Patton
Stigmata 75
Baker, Houston A., and Charlotte Pierce-Baker. “Patches: Quilts and Community in Alice Walker’s ‘Everyday Use.’” “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker. Ed. Barbara Christian. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers UP, 1994. 149–65. Print. Bonaventure. The Soul’s Journey into God; The Tree of Life; The Life of Saint Francis. Trans. Ewert Cousins. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist, 1978. Print. Brown, Laura S. “Not Outside the Range: One Feminist Perspective on Psychic Trauma.” Trauma: Explorations in Memory. Ed. Cathy Caruth. Baltimore: John Hopkins UP, 1995. 100–112. Print. Butler, Octavia. Kindred. Boston: Beacon, 1979. Print. Caruth, Cathy. Introduction to Trauma: Explorations in Memory. Ed. Cathy Caruth. Baltimore: John Hopkins UP, 1995. 3–12. Print. Doyle, Laura. Bordering on the Body: The Racial Matrix of Modern Fiction and Culture. New York: Oxford UP, 1994. Print. Duboin, Corinne. “Trauma Narrative, Memorialization, and Mourning in Phyllis Alesia Perry’s Stigmata.” Southern Literary Journal 40.2 (2008): 284–304. Project Muse. Web. 1 Sept. 2009. Henderson, Carol E. Scarring the Black Body: Race and Representation in African American Literature. Columbia: U of Missouri P, 2002. Print. Jones, Gayl. Corregidora. Boston: Beacon, 1975. Print. Kiely, Robert. “Further Considerations of the Holy Stigmata of St. Francis: Where Was Brother Leo?” Religion and the Arts 3.1 (1999): 20–40. Print. Laub, Dori, and Nanette C. Auerhahn. “Knowing and Not Knowing Massive Psychic Trauma: Forms of Traumatic Memory.” International Journal of Psychoanalysis 74.2 (1993): 287–302. Print. Long, Lisa. “A Relative Pain: The Rape of History in Octavia Butler’s Kindred and Phyllis Alesia Perry’s Stigmata.” College English 64.4 (2002): 459–83. JSTOR. Web. 1 Sept. 2009. McDowell, Deborah E. “Negotiating between Tenses: Witnessing Slavery after Freedom—Dessa Rose.” Slavery and the Literary Imagination. Ed. Deborah E. McDowell and Arnold Rampersad. Baltimore: John Hopkins UP, 1989. 144–63. Print. Mbiti, John S. Introduction to African Religion. 2nd ed. Oxford: Heinemann, 1991. Print. Morrison, Toni. Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and the Literary Imagination. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 1990. Print. Nunes, Ana. “From the Fantastic to Magic Realism: The Spectral Presence in Phyllis Perry’s Stigmata.” Revisiting Slave Narratives II/Les Avatars Contemporains des récits d’esclaves II. Ed. Judith Misrahi-Barak. Montpellier, France: Université Paul-Valéry, 2007. 223–48. Print. Patterson, Orlando. Slavery and Social Death: A Comparative Study. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 1982. Print. Patton, Venetria. Women in Chains: The Legacy of Slavery in Black Women’s Fiction. Albany: SUNY P, 2000. Print. Perry, Phyllis Alesia. Stigmata. New York: Anchor Books, 1998. Print.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Works Cited
Sievers, Stefanie. “Embodied Memories—Sharable Stories? The Legacies of Slavery as a Problem of Representation in Phyllis Alesia Perry’s Stigmata.” Monuments of the Black Atlantic: Slavery and Memory. Ed. Joanne M. Braxton and Maria Diedrich. Münster, Germany: LIT, 2004. 131–39. Print. Slattery, Dennis Patrick. The Wounded Body: Remembering the Markings of Flesh. Albany: SUNY P, 2000. Print. Van der Kolk, Bessel, and Onno Van der Hart. “The Intrusive Past: The Flexibility of Memory and the Engraving of Trauma.” American Imago 48.4 (1991): 425–54. ProQuest. Web. 6 Sept. 2009. Vickroy, Laurie. Trauma and Survival in Contemporary Fiction. Charlottesville: U of Virginia P, 2002. Print.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
76 Venetria K. Patton
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
∞∞
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
This page intentionally left blank
“Pull Up to the Bumper” Fashion and Queerness in Grace Jones’s One Man Show Maria J. Guzman
G
race Jones’s One Man Show (1982), a music-video version of performances she did in London and New York City, continues to be an unusual relic of the 1980s music scene. Its star, Grace Jones, is a music and queer icon in popular culture. She is an artist who personifies a spectrum of personalities to audiences, but she has never been a man, contrary to rumors that suggest otherwise. In spite of her completely singular approach to the reigning interest in androgyny, she has become an iconic figure of the 1980s and is even experiencing a newfound popularity among music fans today. Two summers ago, I happened to be in London, England, and read about her surprise appearance at the Meltdown Festival, which was curated by Jarvis Cocker that year. The following year, one of the most influential contemporary British duos, Massive Attack, curated the event, and arranged it to be a tribute to Jones’s entire musical career. It is clear to me that she has continued to appeal to music lovers and artists alike. Just a few months ago, I enjoyed her cameos in an exhibit based on Andy Warhol’s art and his love affair with music of all genres, Warhol Live, at the de Young Museum in San Francisco. International companies have used her image to advertise everything from hair spray to axle grease, which is an estimation of her many-sided persona (Norment 90). Most recently, bloggers and fashion critics have used her as the measure of credibility for the experimental
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
4
stylings of Rhianna, Lady Gaga, and other young performers. Truly, there is something about her. Born Grace Mendoza in 1952, she grew up in Spanish Town, Jamaica, and later relocated to Syracuse, New York. Carolyn Anderson has suggested that Jones developed her signature style partly as a reaction against her strict religious upbringing and her exposure to more permissive American cultural styles. Anderson links the crafting of Jones’s bold persona to an early period in Jones’s life, shortly after her move to the United States at the age of 12 (493). It has been noted in interviews that Jones had few friends in high school, and was raised in a household that required she wear only dresses or skirts in public. In response, she chose to accommodate such wishes by wearing extravagant, handmade Givenchy designs to school (Norment 92). One of Jones’s early interviews in Ebony magazine cited her Pentecostal upbringing as a priority throughout her life. This detail about Jones’s upbringing is only briefly mentioned in discussions about her performances yet explains much about her bicultural rendition of style and self-expression. I firmly believe that this is what makes her such an outstanding example of a black woman in the music industry during such an eclectic and experimental time in American culture as the 1980s. More often than not, cultural awareness beyond our own immediate experiences (or immediate memories) seems to be a quality that many individuals must actively cultivate, and for many people who experience bicultural lifestyles it can be quite gratifying to see experimentation reflected in popular culture. It is a glamorous, and at times poetic, affirmation that there are other women and men out there who also see culture with a more performative sensibility. This is what I find most appealing about Grace Jones—her seamless presentation of the multitude of roles that are available to individuals in contemporary society. Inasmuch as her presence is fascinating and entertaining to some, it is also a symbol of identification and self-assessment. In this context, her references to French culture as displayed throughout One Man Show may stem from her relationship to Jean-Paul Goude as well as her earlier experiences as a popular model whose career was especially well received in France. In short, both desirable and undesirable roles are created by individuals, who in turn create the vague national identities that we all recognize as acceptable representations. These identities exist in an abbreviated, distant manner, not unlike our favorite characters from a television show.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
80 Maria J. Guzman
In addition, Jones’s early fashion play raises an important question: how can individuals who have been viewed as outsiders interact with popular culture? It is worth noting at this point that Grace Jones attended Syracuse University briefly before leaving to pursue a modeling career, which was primarily based in Paris because her features were criticized as being “too strong for American magazines” (Internet Movie Database [IMDB]). I often wonder how she understood her own appeal to various audiences, which then gave her the understanding to manage it in order to become the cult sensation that she is today. Public reception plays a large role in transnational identity; therefore, Jones’s early impression upon American audiences typifies Western attitudes about beauty. In fact, after several years in France, Jones returned and became a fixture in the more liberal community of the disco scene. She frequented Studio 54 and was eventually touted as “The Queen of Gay Discos” (IMDB). She began recording music in 1976 and released her first album, Portfolio (1977), with famed disco producer Tom Moulton. Her following albums, Fame (1978) and Muse (1979), were produced by Moulton as well. In 1980, she worked with reggae– dub pioneers Sly & Robbie on the single “Warm Leatherette.” The song was a cover of an electro-punk single by The Normal, and broadened her appeal to new wave and punk fans alike. In addition, this period marked Jones’s transformation from disco diva to new wave androgyne (IMDB). By 1981, Jones had released a body of work that could be formatted into a full-length feature, One Man Show. The video includes performances of “Warm Leatherette,” “Walking in the Rain,” “Feel Up,” “La Vie en Rose,” “Demolition Man,” “Pull Up to the Bumper,” “Private Life,” “My Jamaican Guy,” “Living My Life,” and “Libertango/I’ve Seen That Face Before.” It was directed by her creative and romantic partner, Jean-Paul Goude; the New York City footage was shot by Michael Shamberg. The video was produced by Eddie Babbage and released in 1982, and was nominated for a Grammy the following year (And We Danced, “Grace Jones”). My analysis will begin with a discussion of the perceived logic and significance of fashion and current theoretical interpretations of identity (namely, corporeal style as explained by Judith Butler). I am concerned with the issue of how the black female body relates to these views as well as how popular discourse has accumulated new versions of identity through music and video technologies. My conclusion is that Grace Jones personified the complexities of black female sexuality through a technologically enhanced worldview, exploring multiple
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
“Pull Up to the Bumper” 81
82 Maria J. Guzman
Fashion and Queer Performance
Queer identities have been ascribed negative associations throughout the modern era, and non-heterosexual lifestyles or practices of any kind have been defined as dysfunctional and threatening to the general population. This ideation has in turn marked the queer body as potentially diseased or out of control. The most disturbing rationalization to date has been the hysteria-inducing blame placed upon male homosexual activity for the AIDS (acquired immune deficiency syndrome) epidemic, which gained national attention in the 1980s. Although Jones was known to be heterosexual, she has garnered much attention based on her appearance as queer or androgynous. During the early 1980s, androgyny was a popular metaphor for bodily transformations, and was adopted by artists like Duran Duran, The Eurythmics, and Grace Jones as an apparatus that reflected various nontraditional versions of sexuality, such as asexuality (Annie Lennox), or the more baroque version of pansexuality, which characterized “hair bands,” new wavers, and glam rockers during the early ’80s (Boy George). While Jones’s contemporaries were also experimenting with cross-dressing and androgyny, most performers of non-Western descent were not. Grace Jones’s adoption of this style provided an alternative model for visualizing the black female body. Her experimental and outrageous style developed at a time when the entertainment and fashion industries produced a uniformly white vision of style and beauty and, theoretically, this placed Jones at a disadvantage. Fashion depends on theatricality and style, which shape desire in order to sell a “look.” It is the consumer-friendly realization that identity can be shaped and reshaped, in part through visual imagery. I would like to point out a distinction between Grace Jones and other performers who may have toyed with the concept of androgyny during Jones’s ascent to celebrity status. Many of them, most notably Madonna, changed offstage and then appeared in their new costumes and personas. Jones was shown ripping off her costume during the initial moments of One Man Show. Donning a gorilla suit, a reference to
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
roles that undid popular beliefs about race, nationalism, and sexuality. Her work awakens viewers to the possibility that there are many ways to understand and articulate our tumultuous history of imagining the black female body, while also challenging the accuracy of the historical origins of such images.
one of the more historically abusive illustrations of racist ideology, she beats a drum and proceeds to rip off her costume mask. She emerges from her gorilla suit and appears in a wholly different type of suit—the thoroughly ’80s “power suit,” which was one of the first uniforms to have a unisex appeal (see Figure 4.1). Queer theorists such as Judith Butler and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick have suggested that identity is a composite of behaviors and appearances, not natural at all. Butler’s discussion concerning the performativity of drag is especially pertinent to the construction of gender and the modes of expression in fashion shows, which Jones has clearly taken cues from. Butler cited the visual and conceptual contradiction that
Figure 4.1 Grace Jones dressed in a “power suit” (1981). Photograph courtesy of UrbanImage.tv/ Adrian Boot/(http://www.UrbanImage.tv).
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
“Pull Up to the Bumper” 83
occurs when female and male signs are superimposed, and described gender as a “corporeal style” (365). The word itself, modeling, suggests a manipulation of behavior and appearance. By manipulating visual codes and symbols for “different” cultural identities, she formed a parallel between the imaginary drama of contagiousness that marked queer identities with its more positive and marketable twin, fashionability (Sedgwick 73–74). Grace Jones was in fact, the new hot trend. In “Pull Up to the Bumper” for example, Jones gives us a performance that exhibits the dismissal of gendered authenticity altogether by challenging the very concept of Grace Jones as a real being in the modernist sense of the word. During “Pull Up to the Bumper,” Jones is shown dancing toward the microphone, and is later framed from the neck up while she looks out to the audience. A male break-dancer emulates her in the background, and the camera alternates between an apparently real Grace and her double. She invites the audience to “take your big machine, somewhere in this town” and reminds listeners to “follow all the written rules” in order to “fit into the space.”1 While Jones sings, the male twin dances throughout the performance on a separate podium, eventually kicking off his heels in a gesture that disavows a sense of formal entertainment or gender. This recalls Judith Butler’s assertion that an absence occurs as a result of a failure to recognize prescribed opposites (genders) occupying the same body. Jones also plays on and subsequently discards both male and female traits in an empowered manner that has been long denied to women of color in the hip-hop or rock genres for the most part. This prevents the audience from having their perception of the black female body completely reinforced or affirmed, and it is in part due to the inability to absolutely identify gender as it is popularly defined (Butler 361). In addition, the body of the androgyne fails to integrate its own desires within gendered law, which regulates behavior in order to follow the heterosexual model. One of the funnier moments in One Man Show occurs during “Demolition Man.” Toward the end of the song, the screen is filled with an army of Grace Jones lookalikes, each dressed in her signature power suit. The procession is both oddly charismatic and detached. In a truly inspired nod to both the sexual and industrial revolutions, Jones becomes the antithesis of natural reproduction (giving birth), and it never looked so good! Presenting a series of the same body, symbolized by Jones’s recognizable uniform and makeup, “Pull Up to the Bumper” and “Feel Up” are two performances that also deal
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
84 Maria J. Guzman
with visually reorganizing both genders through what Judith Butler has postulated as the production of corporeal style (361). During “Feel Up,” the audience sees three musicians, all men dressed alike in form-fitting suits, playing bass, drums, and bongo drums. Jones also plays percussion in this performance, yet she is not shown as a member of the band—she is shown as the sole performer with a spotlight on her. At the end of the song, the band is once again shown, having increased to five members playing. Then the screen widens to include two more musicians, totaling seven Grace Jones figures. In terms of masculinity, there are two clear features in this section of the video: the musicians are all male, and Jones is always shown apart from them. Therefore, her own possible masculinity is always on the verge of being reinforced visually yet never is. Keeping Jones separate from her sartorial twins maintains a degree of difference, however vague it may be. She remains in this position throughout “Warm Leatherette,” during which she plays the cymbals. By the end of “Warm Leatherette,” Jones has beaten the cymbals until they fall off the podium she stood on. By asserting her dominance through her instruments of choice, power was thus symbolized by the ability to produce sound and subsequently destroy it. Later, during “Feel Up,” Jones’s power seems to be shared with her musicians by clothing them to resemble a “band” of Grace Jones figures. This visual relationship fails to assure viewers of Jones’s position as a masculine or feminine individual. As a result, she remains androgynous. The only readable elements of Jones’s body are interchangeable, like floating features that join her to supporting musicians or dancers. To an extent, the signs for both genders were deemed arbitrary yet incredibly necessary in order for things to “make sense.” This is relevant to Pacteau’s definition of the androgyne as a subversive figure: “From the instant my biological sex is determined, my identity is defined in difference—I am either a boy or a girl. I . . . take up my position in society on one side of the sexual divide . . . reaffirm the difference . . . the androgynous ‘position’ represents a denial, or a transgression, of the rigid gender divide, and as such implies a threat to our given identity and to the system of social roles which define us” (63). Through fashion play and first-person narrative, art and its masculinized mythology are revealed as performances that require many encores in order to remain relevant (Pacteau 71).2 Narratives are akin to fashion’s repertoire of poses. Jones’s performances embarked on an imaginary tour of such fascinations—they are spectacular presentations of various sexual and cultural “poses.” By combining both forms
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
“Pull Up to the Bumper” 85
86 Maria J. Guzman
Primitivism, Minimalism, and the Black Female Body Jean-Paul saw my work and became a fan and I saw his work and became a fan. Together we developed the Grace Jones look. —Grace Jones, “The World of Grace Jones”
The boundary crossing in Grace Jones’s One Man Show is simultaneously physical and imaginary. Grace Jones’s seemingly contradictory persona appears to exist in several different categories. She is often described as “androgynous,” “dykey,” “scary,” “savage,” and “primitive.” Normally, the category of the androgyne is not associated with the category of the primitive, a contradiction in terms that makes Jones’s performances interesting. Primitivism is characterized by the belief that the black body is oversexed and potentially violent. As mentioned in the previous section, queer identities have been marked as threatening to nonqueer people, and this fear is usually expressed as an ever-present possibility of contagion. Primitivism also has the taint of contagion, whether it was a “fever” for the cultural artifacts and dances or the more threatening event of miscegenation. While engaging the contemporary aesthetics of Minimalism, Jones plays on the trope of the display of the primitive female body in order to undermine the construct of the black woman as inherently sexualized and primitive. Jones has been described by Barry Walters, a music critic for The Advocate, as an “attitude-intensive, gender-twisting, gay-rific persona that mixed high style with subversive substance” (61). The high style referred to by Walters is arguably that of Minimalism, which was also identified by Miriam Kershaw, albeit briefly, in her essay on Jones’s work in the early 1980s (19–25). Kershaw cited it as a feature in Jones’s performances at the Roseland dance club in 1978 (20). The minimalist aesthetic has framed Jones’s body of work and costuming from the early 1980s to the present. The minimalist aesthetic was created during the 1960s, largely in response to Abstract Expressionism, by a group of New York–based artists that included Donald Judd, Robert Morris, and Frank Stella. Distinguished by monumental and abstracted shapes, minimalist
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
of narrative, iconic and personal, Jones’s work attains its own rhetoric of power and essentially blurs the line between male and female, sex and violence, reality and fantasy.
paintings and sculptures were claimed by their creators as forms that were ultimately spatial objects, subject to perceptual and temporal changes. Spectatorship is essential to the experience of minimalist art, yet there remains a fine line between confrontation and distance in its rhetoric. This is partly due to the insistence that authentic minimalist art eschew any form of narrative. In June 2007, Jones performed in London’s annual Meltdown Festival (see Figure 4.2), curated by Jarvis Cocker, wearing an outfit that resembled the minimalist outfits she wore in One Man Show. Her headdress recalled a minimalist accessory that would have easily fit in among the costumes in One Man Show, especially the headdress worn during “Feel Up.”
Figure 4.2 Grace Jones performing “Trust in Me” at Meltdown Festival. Photograph courtesy of Jennifer Beeston (http://www.intermezzo.com).
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
“Pull Up to the Bumper” 87
Grace Jones’s conflation of Minimalism and Primitivism created an unexpected bridge between the primitive body and the minimalist object that was deemed a “physical fact” (Stokstad, Oppenheimer, and Addiss 1106). In addition, the “black” aesthetic that has been represented by Primitivism was delegitimized through implied minimalist narratives that conveyed a clean, white heterosexual male prowess. For example, white masculinity or androgyny can be symbolically transferred onto Jones’s body through the appropriation of the super-slick and streamlined power suit. However, she also dressed as an ape at the beginning of “Warm Leatherette.” Jones’s performances in One Man Show also critiqued another dimension of cultural history—the (relatively) obscured visual history of race in Western culture as it was understood in the late twentieth century. In order to fully appreciate the longevity of this concept, it is important to note that Primitivism was used as an umbrella term that could categorize many cultures into one entity. Primitivism was originally attributed to anything that was not Greek or Italian Renaissance art, Roman and Byzantine art, Egyptian art, Aztec art, and, by the early twentieth century, Oceanic and African art (Rubin 9). As a result of colonialist propaganda and folklore, Primitivism took on a new meaning—that of the savage, uncivilized race that served as a foil to AngloEuropean society. The locus of Primitivism was the black female body, which became the harbinger for a savage sexuality that exceeded the limits of representation. As a consequence of changing values and cultural attitudes, the black female body has undergone various symbolic transformations in Western culture. The art that was produced in response to Primitivism has formed a largely fractured vision of other cultures, based on a general nonwhite identity that is characterized by an alternately coveted and overwhelming sexuality, an inferior intellect and spirituality, and a tendency to violence. Throughout art history, Primitivism has been represented by abstract and pseudonaive subject matter. Although inspired by nonWestern cultures, the main proponents of this style were French male artists, such as Paul Gauguin and Jean Dubuffet, and their inspiration was premised on the display of Other bodies. Grace Jones played up this notion in her performances. During the blitzkrieg montage that Jean-Paul Goude inserted before the live footage in One Man Show, an image appears and resonates with intensity, reaching back into the past while symbolizing modern fashion. It is a photograph of Jones modeling a sheer black dress to a white audience
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
88 Maria J. Guzman
in a large room filled with seats that are positioned exclusively for watching her. There is no music, just the oddly canned admiration of her audience—“oohs” and “ahs” provide a soundtrack for the dramatic scenario. The final image is the cover photograph for her album Island Life. Jones is shown in a severe yet fluid pose and is an effect of Goude’s use of photographic collage in order to achieve a more dramatic appeal. These scenarios are equal parts colonialist exhibition and modern spectacle. The commodification of the black female body has a long history in European and American history, and has been correlated to specific sexualities and lifestyles. The associations left behind in the wake of Primitivism have altered how we view the black female body, which has been repeatedly displayed in the nude or in various states of undress. In a wholly self-conscious contrast to this history of display, Jones and Goude evoked spectators’ reactions using a highly orchestrated approach; it began immediately with the opening montage of still photographs in One Man Show. During this brief glimpse into Jones’s history, the audience is made aware of the isolating effect that is a result of displaying other cultures. Ultimately, the audience will see that the final images portray what we can all imagine to be wholly terrifying or completely gratifying—being the center of attention and on full display. In order to fully understand this duality, it is important to keep in mind the history of the black female body as an object on display. Jones was referencing two historical figures: the Hottentot Venus and the Black Venus, or Saartjie Baartman and Josephine Baker. Miriam Kershaw cited the French fantasy of the Black Venus as an influence for the imagery in One Man Show, in which Jean-Paul Goude contemporized the French fascination with the black female body (19).3 According to Goude, “Initially, she was flattered by all of my attention . . . and she’s no dope—Grace is an opportunist and she knew my vision was good for her career. Initially, she let herself be taken over, but then she suspected that I had only fallen in love with her image. Of course . . . that’s the story of my life” (Hodgkinson). Obviously Jones did not wish to replicate the hypercritical tendency to examine the “curious” nature of the black female body. Instead, she reframed herself as a high style, minimalist figure distinguished by bold references to the Western collective unconscious. By choosing a style that was believed to be neutral and nonrepresentational (Minimalism), Jones could insert any subject matter without having to challenge its visual integrity.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
“Pull Up to the Bumper” 89
Minimalism is an appropriate example, especially when considered along with Miriam Kershaw’s brief yet revealing description of the aesthetics in One Man Show. Kershaw’s reading positioned Jones’s art “in relation to popular culture and modernist conceptions of Primitivism and Minimalism reinterpreted by modernist’s black female Other,” in which “Jones’s grooming and clothing serve a second function. Modernism appropriated the striking geometry of African art. Coming full circle, the African cultural heritage emphasized in Jones’s nearly sculptural appearance is linked to a Minimalist contemporary urban aesthetic” (21). Anna Chave argued that minimalist art was not immune to symbolism, and that minimalist artists’ insistence on the absence of narrative in their work was ultimately false. In fact, Minimalism, like Primitivism, was a disguised reenactment or “pose” modeled after the familiar modernist rhetoric that had perfected the process of fetishizing over a century ago (Kershaw 19). There are aspects of the definition of Primitivism that remain problematic as well. For instance, while it was commendable to embody the primitive and its untouched naïveté, industrialized Western culture evoked the primitive as a sign on which to map what it had socially and psychologically repressed: desire and sexual abandon (Primitivism). In addition, it corresponds to the queer aspects of Jones’s persona as well. Kershaw’s description of Jones as “nearly sculptural” bears a resemblance to Michael Fried’s account of minimalist artist Robert Smith’s objects, each of which became “a kind of statue” as a consequence of their “objecthood” (156). The fear of boundary crossing that Michael Fried mapped out in his extensive discussion of Minimalism’s failure as a modern art movement is articulated in his essay, “Art and Objecthood” (148–75). According to Fried, boundary crossing from one medium to another was theatrical and the cause of “objecthood,” the death of art, no longer autonomous as a truly modern work. Therefore, Jones’s work reaches “objecthood” for its theatrical, multimedia presentation (Fried 153). Perceived as “confrontational” by Fried, literalist (i.e., minimalist) art objects can inspire the same disorienting presence as a person can. Fried used interpersonal metaphors throughout his essay, and suggested that “being distanced by such objects is not . . . unlike being distanced, or crowded, by the silent presence of another person; the experience of coming upon literalist objects unexpectedly—for example, in somewhat darkened rooms—can be strongly, if momentarily, disquieting in just this way” (155).
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
90 Maria J. Guzman
Equally charged with a dominating presence, Grace Jones’s appearance does not comply with the oppressive imagery of passive bodies marked as “primitive,” particularly during “Demolition Man.” Her ability to embrace the more menacing characteristics that mark certain bodies is what makes her powerful to audiences that may also be acutely aware of their perceived difference. In response to such awareness, Jones brags that she’s the “sort of thing they ban” and that she compels her audience to pay attention, like “a moth to a flame.”4 In reference to the objectification of the black female body, Evelyn Hammonds described historical portrayals of black female identity and sexuality as “often described in metaphors of speechlessness, space, or vision, as a ‘void’ or empty space that is simultaneously ever visible (exposed) and invisible and where black women’s bodies are always already colonized” (142). In terms of visual relationships to the audience, minimalist (and most avant-garde) art prescribed the quality of silence and ineffectuality to its “Other,” the object. Minimalism is the quietest of all modern art movements, and Jones’s dramatic show activates its fetishized surface into a site of performance. Minimalist art too has been critiqued for its unilateral preference for highlighting a heterosexual, male white narrative. This is one of the driving forces in Jones’s striking presence: in the midst of various objects and uniforms that reinforce brute masculinity, she is undeniably at its center. Besides the fact that Minimalism is yet another art movement that has been documented as a uniformly male phenomenon, it has also displayed a distinctly industrialized rhetoric (Chave 264). The promise of agency through objectification is an issue that Anna C. Chave took up in her account of Minimalism, which examines the phallocentric themes that are inscribed in the spectatorship of minimalist art. Chave perceived the discourse of Minimalism as based on displays of power that were fully adopted by prominent artists such as Richard Serra, Carl Andre, and Donald Judd. Her premise was most persuasively argued in her analysis of Dan Flavin’s The Diagonal of May 25, 1963 (to Robert Rosenblum), in which she cited the form as “explicitly phallic” and the minimalist equivalent to a “hot rod” (267). By appropriating minimalist style, Jones created a modern platform for black female artists. The association of power was an accepted part of the minimalist experience, and her image provided viewers with a democratizing illustration of art’s legacy in American culture. Grace Jones used her ability to mold her image as a response to modernist
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
“Pull Up to the Bumper” 91
attitudes about black culture, sexuality, and music. Instead of idealizing art’s capacity for truth, she celebrated the possibility of objecthood as an alternative to stagnant representations of black women in art and popular culture. While multimedia aesthetics may have left critics such as Fried unimpressed, Jones exemplifies the benefits of using elaborate contexts for otherwise overlooked topics in art theory. The songs included in One Man Show are minimalist in spirit, connecting themes in cultural history that have been presented as mutually exclusive. In order to better grasp what we see as an audience, we should be destabilized and brought out of our cultural comfort zones. Notes 1. Lyrics translated by the author. 2. I found the explanation for the possibilities of the visual semiosis that occurs on the body of the perceived androgyne to be relevant to the concept of the male artist as supremely divine and capable of creating and originating styles—as having the ability to reproduce in his own right. Both artistic style and the androgyne exist in an imaginary space and are defined in real space through metaphor (the former through spiritual or biological–natural terms and the latter through Lacanian interpretation by Pacteau). Pacteau explained, “At an unconscious level, where the androgyne belongs, conciliation of the positive and the negative is possible . . . androgyny, as a fetishistic resolution of castration anxiety—providing the woman with the penis she lacks—could also evoke the possibility of the pregnant man.” 3. Kershaw’s essay begins with the conflation of the postcolonial and the postmodern, which are viewed as “interdependent.” This term implies that each exists only because of the other term, which is posed as an opposite. Although she is correct in her assertion that Jones’s performance can contribute to such a discursive approach to art-historical narratives containing Western and nonWestern subjects, I found that Kershaw’s analysis returned to a binarism during certain sections of her essay. For example, she cited Goude as a person whose aesthetic was discernible amid Jones’s performance, which maintains a possessiveness and origin for the two styles that she cited as conceptually tied to each other, mutually creating each other in the process of identification. 4. Lyrics translated by the author.
Works Cited Anderson, Carolyn. “En Route to Transnational Postmodernism: Grace Jones, Josephine Baker and the African Diaspora.” Social Science Information Sur Les Sciences Sociales 32.3 (Sept. 1993): 491–512. Print.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
92 Maria J. Guzman
Butler, Judith. “From Interiority to Gender Performatives.” Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. New York: Routledge, 1990. Print. Fried, Michael. Art and Objecthood: Essays and Reviews. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1998. Print. Hammonds, Evelyn. “Black (W)holes and the Geometry of Black Female Sexuality.” Feminism Meets Queer Theory. Ed. Elizabeth Weeds and Naomi Schor. Boston: Brown UP, 1997, 136–56. Print. Hodgkinson, Will. “Snapshot: Grace Jones.” Guardian Unlimited Online. 24 July 2007. Web. Internet Movie Database. “Biography for Grace Jones.” 3 June 2007. Web. Jarvis Cocker Enters the Forest of No Return: Meltdown Part 2. Intermezzo. 24 July 2007. Web. Kershaw, Miriam. “Postcolonialism and Androgyny: The Performance Art of Grace Jones.” Performance Art: (Some) Theory and (Selected) Practice at the End of This Century 56.4 (Winter 1997): 19–25. Print. Norment, Lynn. “The Outrageous Grace Jones.” Ebony July 1979, 84–94. Print. One Man Show. Directed by Jean-Paul Goude. VHS. Sequences by Michael Shamberg. Performed by Grace Jones. Los Angeles: Island Visual Arts, 1982. Pacteau, Francette. “The Impossible Referent: Representations of the Androgyne.” Formations of Fantasy. Ed. Victor Burgin, James Donald, and Cora Kaplan. London: Methuen, 1986. 62–84. Print. Primitivism. Guggenheim Museum. 19 July 2007. Web. Rubin, William Stanley. “Museum of Modern Art, Detroit Institute of Arts, and Dallas Museum of Art.” “Primitivism” in 20th Century Art: Affinity of the Tribal and the Modern. New York: Museum of Modern Art, 1984. Web. Sedgwick, Eve Kosofsky. “Epistemology of the Closet.” Epistemology of the Closet. Berkeley: U of California P, 1990. 67-90. Print. Stokstad, Marilyn, Margaret A. Oppenheimer, and Stephen Addiss. Art History: From Prehistory to the Twenty-First Century. New York: Harry N. Abrams, 2000. 1105–1106. Print. Walters, Barry. “Pull Up to Her Bumper.” The Advocate 761 (1998): 61. Print. The World of Grace Jones. 17 July 2007. Web.
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
“Pull Up to the Bumper” 93
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
This page intentionally left blank
Images That Sell The Black Female Body Imag(in)ed in 1960s and 1970s Magazine Ads Michelle L. Filling
A
s the forty-fourth president of the United States was sworn into office in January 2009, not all eyes were on Barack Obama. The media anxiously awaited Michelle Obama’s appearance in her inaugural outfit and ballgown. Much of the media and the nation’s attention has focused on Michelle’s attire and how she has been “imaged” in photographs in her early days in the White House in very traditional mother roles in the kitchen, and waiting for Sasha and Malia to arrive home from school. While some might criticize this media attention as overshadowing Michelle’s education and potential for leadership within the White House, or discount it as a shameless plug for brands like J. Crew, the image of Michelle Obama contributes to a long history of images of black women who have shaped beauty culture. While the fashion and beauty industries seem to be solely about consumerism, beauty culture has powerful implications for social, political, and cultural history.1 As Michelle Obama appears on the covers of People, Vogue, Life, Time, and Ebony, I question what this media attention means. What does it mean for us to be standing in the grocery checkout lane gazing at First Lady Obama’s toned arms in a shift dress or long legs in shorts as she steps off Air Force One? While this might seem like a replication of the overeroticized and colonizing voyeurism that Saartjie
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
5
Baartman endured in the 1800s, there is a distinct difference—Michelle Obama’s agency. African American women’s bodies have historically been excluded from white beauty culture or viewed as abnormal, like Baartman; yet Michelle Obama builds on the work of African American women from the 1960s and 1970s to insert her image in mainstream media. To a great extent, she has the power to present her body in a certain way; for example, she has agreed to pose for the covers of magazines (as opposed to just paparazzi shots of her body). The highly glamorous photograph of Michelle Obama on the cover of Vogue magazine seems to be a conscious effort to showcase a black woman’s body as powerful, feminine, and beautiful. Almost a year into President Obama’s term Michelle Obama seemingly had not established any political or social agenda, and yet she has done just that through her power to have her body viewed by the world. She confidently gazes at the camera and projects an image of a beautiful black body that is not ruled or colonized by anyone. She uses the media not only to preserve the historic moment of the first black president but also to further the evolving definition of beauty in America through the imaging of her body. Michelle Obama contributes her iconic image of the black body to the collection of icons that control notions of beauty in America. President Obama’s inauguration day is a product of decades of fighting for justice within America, more specifically driven by the 1960s and 1970s when America seemed like a war zone. Volatile events like the riots in Watts, deaths in campus demonstrations, and assassinations of leaders increased the representation of blackness in the media and dramatically affected race relations in America. The changes that occurred during the 1960s and 1970s did not happen just through the clenched fists of Tommie Smith and John Carlos at the Olympic games in Mexico City, or the protests of the women’s liberation movement, or the rallying calls of Martin Luther King Jr., but in all aspects of culture, including the realm of beauty. Beauty culture, driven by consumerism and capitalism, might not seem a likely place for transformation; however, mainstream white beauty culture experienced a change also as the imaginings of blackness shifted the cultural scene during the 1960s and 1970s, which ultimately affected the way society views a black woman’s body in today’s beauty culture. Although attempts at transforming beauty culture happened throughout the twentieth century, during 1965 to 1975—a time when our country was in great turmoil and unrest—blackness was inserted in mainstream white beauty culture more forcefully than ever.2 The
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
96 Michelle L. Filling
cultural events of this time period catalyze a fluctuation in power that penetrates every aspect of culture—including beauty. As the radical political events and social movements of 1965 to 1975 forced black beauty into the media, mainstream beauty culture absorbed the influences of black culture while still retaining its dominant ideological bias. Mainstream beauty culture’s imaginings of blackness are most evident in magazine images in which bodies can be contrived and transformed to signify different markers of race, class, and gender. Magazine advertising demonstrates how marketers’ appropriation of black bodies within both mainstream and black magazines contributed to America’s collective imagining of the black female body. By comparing the ads for beauty products in the 1965 and 1975 issues of Ebony and Good Housekeeping,3 I delineate how notions of blackness became present within mainstream beauty culture by identifying what I term duplication and inverse articulation, that is, the ways in which the marketers use images of black women in relation to their white counterparts. Duplication—when two ads are identical except for the model—reveals the construction of beauty and black women’s ability to occupy the same space as white models, as the sets for the photo shoots remained unchanged. While duplication marks progress in that it presents images of blackness that were previously absent from magazines, the sign systems within these advertisements complicate what the ads signify in terms of black beauty. By looking at signs such as hair and skin within these ads, we can see how black women’s bodies signified either assimilation to white standards of beauty or departure from such conformity. In order to evaluate progress in racial representations with magazines, we must also examine moments of inverse articulation, which describes when advertisers used black models in traditionally white magazines, thus articulating or expressing black beauty to market to a largely white audience. Of course, within both duplication and inverse articulation, sign systems of the models’ bodies can signify either black or white aesthetics of beauty, which could suggest how these ads further the emergence of black beauty. When John Johnson created Ebony in 1945, he created it in the likeness of Life magazine, thus creating a black duplication of a white magazine. Johnson attempted to mirror its competitor and archetype, Life, in terms of format but not content. Ben Burns, editor of Ebony, describes how he imitated the white magazine: “I had copies of Life constantly in front of me to emulate, and I did so religiously” (85).4 Sections of the magazines clearly mirrored each other, such as “Speaking of People” in
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Images That Sell 97
Ebony and “Speaking of Pictures” in Life. However, Ebony did not just copy Life, it articulated what it meant to be black in America. While Johnson used similar organizational structures as in Life, he revealed a difference in experience for black Americans through the content of the images and articles. Johnson imitated Life to show a level of equality, and also aimed to highlight black Americans’ ability to succeed in spite of oppression and racism. With the advent of the first black magazine with a large-scale circulation, white advertisers saw the black middle class as prime consumers to target via print ads in Ebony. At first, instead of doing market research on how to reach this specific audience, advertisers used the same ads but with a black model substituted for the original white model, thus creating duplication. Eventually, companies created ads exclusively for Ebony that did not appear in mainstream white magazines like Good Housekeeping because they realized the economic benefit of marketing directly to the black community. While it might seem easy to mark these new ads designed exclusively for the black community as an indication of progress because they seem to recognize the contemporary needs and desires of the black community, we must not herald these new ads as more authentic or more progressive than the duplicate ads. In fact, the duplicate ads use the same kind of substitution that Ebony, as a whole, used. The duplicate ads convey an idealized version of separate but equal as they showcase how both races can inhabit the same spaces and fulfill the same roles. In this sense, duplicate ads reveal how constructs of beauty are just that—constructed. Through the lens of duplication and inverse articulation, we can see how Ebony, a magazine that Johnson created in the likeness of a white magazine, attempted to progress the advancement of representations of blackness within beauty culture through its acceptance of both duplicate and original ads and its inclusion of articles that highlighted the contributions of black women to America’s evolving beauty culture. Based on more than 330 advertisements for beauty products appearing in the 1965 and 1975 issues of Ebony and Good Housekeeping, I find that cultural assumptions about black women’s bodies are embedded in the advertisements. In Ebony, the advertisements attempt to define black beauty, yet their attempt at codification becomes challenged by a readership whose keen awareness of the political and social movements of the time causes them to call for alteration, critique, and transformation of the signs and signifiers at work in the ads. A semiotic analysis of the advertisements in Ebony and Good Housekeeping develops my argument that (a) beauty culture exists within the matrix of multiple texts
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
98 Michelle L. Filling
that intersect and influence each other, (b) these texts both reflect and reshape beauty culture, and (c) the imag(in)ing of black women’s bodies contributes to the evolving ethos of how America defines beauty. When Ebony first began running ads, the companies only used their stock ads, which featured white models, because they never had an advertising forum like Ebony with a predominantly black readership. Eventually this began to shift in the 1950s and 1960s as black women set forth the call for advertising that reflected their beauty—their hair, skin, and smiles. Duplicate advertising, which saved companies money by utilizing the same ad but with the substitution of models of different races, ultimately influenced beauty culture in a way that marketers who were just trying to maximize their money never anticipated. Duplication shows how black women can exist in the same constructed space as white women. While these ads show how beauty is constructed, the images within the duplication contain complex sign systems that signify more than just equality between the black and white models. This marketing technique appears in the January 1965 issues of Good Housekeeping and Ebony where Clairol advertises “Loving Care” Hair Color Lotion in two ads with identical layouts. For hair product advertisements such as these, we must consider how they evoke a sign system of hair. Ads display the signifier, hair, in a multitude of textures, lengths, and styles. If a model styles her hair in an Afro, a straightened bob, or organized plaits, these markers signify differently and range from embracing an unprocessed style synonymous with the Black Power movement, to assimilating a white standard of hair styling, to creating a style that evokes an African aesthetic. Based on this signification, hair becomes part of a complex sign system that, when depicted in advertisements, communicates competing values about blackness and beauty culture to both African American and white communities. In the Good Housekeeping ad, a white woman with her head turned slightly to the left and with a pleasant, almost innocently coy smile looks at the camera while the reflection of her profile appears in a mirror behind her. In large white print, the ad says, “Hate that gray? Wash it away! Now! Color only the gray without changing your natural hair color!” The woman wears jewelry and makeup that allows her to appear to be middle to upper class. She looks as though she is ready for a night on the town, and yet her stereotyped image, complete with a strand of pearls, resembles a June Cleaver-esque housewife. The duplicate ad in Ebony contains exactly the same layout except the model is black and the text of the large print is black.5 The graphic designers most
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Images That Sell 99
likely switched the font color because the background for the Ebony ad needed to be lighter to contrast the model’s dark skin. The ads reveal an intertextual sign system of hair, as the black model’s hair resembles the style worn by the white model. The black hair has been processed so that it is smooth and straight and then restyled into soft, large waves. The black model’s hair signifies the aesthetic created in the duplicate ad in Good Housekeeping, which creates a sign of hair associated with a middle- to upper-class housewife. The other notable duplication within the two ads is that at the bottom there is a small picture of a man with the caption: “Makes your husband feel younger, too . . . just to look at you!” While it would have been easy for Clairol just to delete the image and caption from the ad appearing in Ebony because of its placement in the bottom left margin of the ad, they instead photographed a black male model for the duplicate ad. Clairol’s attention to these small details and creation of a duplicate ad shows its commitment to achieving a marketing campaign that directly appeals to the black community. Hair appears as a sign even in these smaller photographs of the husbands. The black husband has his hair neatly trimmed close to his scalp, thus signifying a departure from the popular Afro and its connections to the Black Power movement. The hair of the male and female models in the duplicate ad creates a sign of conservative, middle-class blackness that mirrors the hair styling and class established in the Good Housekeeping ad. Although duplicate advertising symbolized a positive move away from using exclusively white models, the use of duplicate advertising mirrors its contemporary cultural, social, and political movements in terms of racial inequality. Using the same ad layout with a different model seems to create a separate-but-equal climate in the world of advertising. Over a decade after Brown v. Board of Education and Bolling v. Sharpe (1954), it would seem that American culture should have been moving beyond a separate-but-equal mentality. Of course, consumer culture differs greatly from legal realms in that economics drives it, not justice. The establishment of Ebony itself recognizes that equal racial representation does not exist in generalist magazines like Life and Good Housekeeping. While companies generally did not put black models in mainstream white magazine ads in the 1960s, by creating duplicate advertising, companies recognized the value of black models for the African American market of consumers who read magazines like Ebony and later, Essence, and simultaneously ignored any differences between black and white consumers.6 Duplicate ads demonstrate how these
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
100 Michelle L. Filling
companies could not essentialize differences in the black community and expected darkened images of whiteness to effectively target black consumers through a reinscription of class biases with a “color-blind” application of beauty. Eventually, in a move that advanced the place of blackness within beauty culture, Clairol designed advertisements specifically for Ebony. Perhaps this change indicates that duplicate ads were not working because they were still classed in a way that did not reach all audiences. Regardless, this shift away from duplicate advertising meant that companies were investing money in the black modeling industry and placing value in the contributions of black women to America’s changing beauty culture. In March 1965, Clairol placed a large ad in Ebony whose duplicate never appeared in Good Housekeeping, thus suggesting they were specifically targeting the readers of Ebony. In the ad, five smiling black women, perfectly coifed and wearing pearls, crisp white collars, and soft sweaters, exude a conservative style. The models’ preppy style represents a rejection of the counterculture fashions popular in the 1960s. Although the women in the ad appear too young to actually have gray hair, the advertisement targets middle-aged women who experience an early onset of gray hair. The ad features a four-page pullout insert with a “shade-selector chart” for women to take with them to their hairdresser. The chart features the faces of many black models showcasing the various shades of hair dye. Although Clairol intends for the product to be used to cover gray, they market it to women who want to be “right in fashion, soft and ladylike” by showing how people admire the models “for their radiant smiles, their up-to-the-minute prettiness.” The wording of the ad focuses on high style and the “fun of fashion.” Although most African American women would not be aware of the duplicate advertising unless they also read mainstream white magazines like Good Housekeeping, Clairol’s ad uniquely designed for Ebony showcases the strength of the economic base in the black community that Clairol would create a marketing campaign designed exclusively for black women. Reading the hair as a sign system within this ad, the hair signifies conformity to conservative white beauty standards, as many of the shades are blonde, similar to the Loving Care ad that appeared in January 1965. While this March 1965 ad is not a duplicate, the hair signifies the same compliance with white standards.7 Each model’s hair replicates the style of the hair worn by the girl next to her, but with a different color shade. The hair is straightened and styled into a voluminous
10.1057/9780230115477 - Imagining the Black Female Body, Edited by Carol E. Henderson
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromsoe - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-08
Images That Sell 101
and precisely arranged bob. In order to achieve the almost wiglike perfection of the models’ hair, most black women would need to undergo several processes to straighten and color the hair. In fact, one shade of Clairol dye, “Pale Baby Blonde,” requires prelightening for the average black woman. The small print at the bottom of the ad reveals that three of the five models applied their Clairol color to “prelightened hair.” The ad asks the reader, “If you want to . . . why not?” The ellipsis of this statement leaves the end of the statement ambiguous. The ad could be asking if the reader wants to dye her hair or if she