House Selling FOR
DUMmIES 3RD
‰
EDITION
by Eric Tyson and Ray Brown Authors of Home Buying For Dummies
Praise for ...
108 downloads
1765 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
House Selling FOR
DUMmIES 3RD
‰
EDITION
by Eric Tyson and Ray Brown Authors of Home Buying For Dummies
Praise for House Selling For Dummies “You won’t find a better ‘how-to-sell-your-home’ book than this one. The authors have included practical knowledge you won’t find anywhere else. . . . On my scale of one to 10, it rates a solid 10.” — Robert J. Bruss, syndicated real estate columnist “Brown and Tyson . . . are back with a timely tome: House Selling For Dummies. . . . Packed with the proven punch of the Brown-Tyson combination . . . the book is destined to become a home seller’s best friend.” — Broderick Perkins, San Jose Mercury News “The authors cover every aspect of the home-selling process — from deciding whether you are financially able to sell, to assembling a real estate team and marketing your property, to selling it quickly for top dollar.” — Don DeBat, Crain News Service “[Tyson and Brown] tackle the complex subject of selling a house with humor and practicality . . . the authors explain strategies that could generate or save readers thousands, perhaps even tens of thousands of dollars on the sale of their house.” — Inman News Features “The best thing about this book [House Selling For Dummies] is that it doesn’t recommend anything. Instead, it helps you in a far greater way. It helps you think through the relocation decision.” — Dr. David Demko, AgeVenture News “House Selling For Dummies by Eric Tyson and Ray Brown is fun . . . and also filled with practical advice.” — Allen Norwood, Charlotte Observer “Do’s and Don’ts for Do-It-Yourself Home Sellers: Start by educating yourself. I recommend the book House Selling For Dummies by Eric Tyson and Ray Brown, which offers excellent advice on the entire process.” — Rick Wilking, Reuters News Service “Home Buying For Dummies and House Selling For Dummies, both by Eric Tyson and Ray Brown, go into surprising depth on their topics without straying from their mission of explaining the processes simply. Perhaps the best thing is what the authors call their holistic approach. . . .” — Maryann Haggerty, Washington Post
Praise for Eric Tyson and Ray Brown’s best-selling Home Buying For Dummies “This fun read for home buyers includes the essentials, laced with humor and practical advice. The new material on Internet resources updates this classic how-to-buy-a-home book. Of the many books on this topic, this is by far the best. . . .” — Robert J. Bruss, syndicated real estate columnist “. . . takes you step by step through the process . . . humorous insights that keep the pages turning. This is a reference you’ll turn to time after time.” — Judy Stark, St. Petersburg Times “. . . Home Buying For Dummies immediately earned a prominent spot on my reference bookshelf . . . takes a holistic approach to home buying.” — Broderick Perkins, San Jose Mercury News “. . . Home Buying For Dummies provides a much-needed emotional stabilizer.” — Judy Rose, Knight-Ridder News Service “The humorous Home Buying For Dummies by Ray Brown and Eric Tyson is a favorite . . . because the editorial is so good. They check their facts very well. They set out to make you understand this subject and make it fun reading and informative.” — Michelle Wong, Minneapolis Star Tribune “The book [Home Buying For Dummies] is a primer on all the things to do and not to do when - buying a home.” — Brian Banmiller, FOX-TV “. . . can help you buy a castle for the price of house. The authors present a balanced approach to buying a house.” — Times-Picayune, New Orleans, LA “A survival guide to buying . . . fun to read and very clearly written. . . . Whether taking over a foreclosure, determining not how much you can borrow but how much you can actually afford to spend, how to find a good broker, landing a lender . . . Tyson and Brown definitely help ease the trauma of the transaction. . . .” — Paula Lee Aldridge, Homes and Real Estate Magazine
Here’s what critics have said about Eric Tyson and his previous national best-selling personal finance guides: “Personal Finance For Dummies is the perfect book for people who feel guilty about inadequately managing their money but are intimidated by all of the publications out there. It’s a painless way to learn how to take control. My college-aged daughters even enjoyed reading it!” — Karen Tofte, producer, National Public Radio’s Sound Money “Among my favorite financial guides are . . . Eric Tyson’s Personal Finance For Dummies.” — Jonathan Clements, The Wall Street Journal “Smart advice for dummies . . . skip the tomes . . . and buy Personal Finance For Dummies, which rewards your candor with advice and comfort.” — Temma Ehrenfeld, Newsweek “Eric Tyson is doing something important — namely, helping people at all income levels to take control of their financial futures. This book is a natural outgrowth of Tyson’s vision that he has nurtured for years. Like Henry Ford, he wants to make something that was previously accessible only to the wealthy accessible to middle-income Americans.” — James C. Collins, coauthor of the national bestseller Built to Last; Lecturer in Business, Stanford Graduate School of Business “You don’t have to be a novice to like Mutual Funds For Dummies. Despite the book’s chatty, informal style, author Eric Tyson clearly has a mastery of his subject. He knows mutual funds, and he knows how to explain them in simple English.” — Steven T. Goldberg, Kiplinger’s Personal Finance Magazine “Personal Finance For Dummies offers a valuable guide for common misconceptions and major pitfalls. It’s a no-nonsense, straightforward, easyto-read personal finance book. . . . With this book, you can easily learn enough about finances to start thinking for yourself.” — Charles R. Schwab, Chairman and CEO, The Charles Schwab Corporation
“It can be overwhelming to keep up with the latest developments, which is why you might turn to the book Mutual Funds For Dummies by Eric Tyson. A light touch and the use of plenty of graphics help the pages fly by. This book is a primer for those who flinch when contemplating the 7,000 funds you can now buy.” — Brian Banmiller, FOX-TV “Best new personal finance book.” — Michael Pellecchia, syndicated columnist “Eric Tyson . . . seems the perfect writer for a ...For Dummies book. He doesn’t tell you what to do or consider doing without explaining the why’s and how’s — and the booby traps to avoid — in plain English. . . . It will lead you through the thickets of your own finances as painlessly as I can imagine.” — Clarence Peterson, Chicago Tribune “Personal Finance For Dummies is, by far, the best book I have read on financial planning. It is a simplified volume of information that provides tremendous insight and guidance into the world of investing and other money issues.” — Althea Thompson, producer, PBS’s Nightly Business Report “This book provides easy-to-understand personal financial information and advice for those without great wealth or knowledge in this area. Practitioners like Eric Tyson, who care about the well-being of middleincome people, are rare in today’s society.” — Joel Hyatt, founder, Hyatt Legal Services, one of the nation’s largest general-practice personal legal service firms “Personal Finance For Dummies is a sane and useful guide that will be of benefit to anyone seeking a careful and prudent method of managing their financial world.” — John Robbins, founder of EarthSave, author of May All Be Fed
“Worth getting. Scores of all-purpose money-management books reach bookstores every year, but only once every couple of years does a standout personal finance primer come along. Personal Finance For Dummies, by financial counselor and columnist Eric Tyson, provides detailed, action-oriented advice on everyday financial questions. . . . Tyson’s style is readable and unintimidating.” — Kristin Davis, Kiplinger’s Personal Finance Magazine “For those named in the title, such as myself, Personal Finance For Dummies is a godsend. It’s bright, funny, and it can save you money, too.” — Jerome Crowe, reporter, Los Angeles Times “Eric Tyson has brought his financial experience, investment knowledge, and down-to-earth writing style to create an outstanding book on mutual funds for all investors — and an essential book for new investors . . . in short, a classic. . . .” — Jack Bogle, former CEO, The Vanguard Group “This is a great book. It’s understandable. Other financial books are too technical and this one really is different.” — Shad Johnson, producer, “Business Radio Network” “An invaluable, easy-to-read financial help book that should be in every family’s library.” — Stan Schaffer, reporter, The Morning Call, Allentown, PA
More Bestselling For Dummies Titles by Eric Tyson Investing For Dummies ® A Wall Street Journal bestseller, this book walks you through how to build wealth in stocks, real estate, and small business as well as other investments. Personal Finance For Dummies ® Discover the best ways to establish and achieve your financial goals, reduce your spending and taxes, and make wise personal financial decisions. Wall Street Journal bestseller with more than 1 million copies sold in all editions and winner of the Benjamin Franklin best business book award. Taxes For Dummies ® The complete, best-selling reference for completing your tax return and making tax-wise financial decisions year-round. Tyson coauthors this book with tax experts David Silverman and Margaret Munro. Home Buying For Dummies ® America’s #1 real estate book includes coverage of online resources in addition to sound financial advice from Eric Tyson and frontline real estate insights from industry veteran Ray Brown. Also available from America’s best-selling real estate team of Tyson and Brown — House Selling For Dummies and Mortgages For Dummies®. Real Estate Investing For Dummies ® Real estate is a proven wealth-building investment, but many people don’t know how to go about making and managing rental property investments. Real estate and property management expert Robert Griswold and Eric Tyson cover the gamut of property investment options, strategies, and techniques. Small Business For Dummies ® Take control of your future and make the leap from employee to entrepreneur with this enterprising guide. From drafting a business plan to managing costs, you’ll profit from expert advice and real-world examples that cover every aspect of building your own business. Tyson coauthors this book with fellow entrepreneur Jim Schell.
House Selling FOR
DUMmIES 3RD
‰
EDITION
House Selling FOR
DUMmIES 3RD
‰
EDITION
by Eric Tyson and Ray Brown Authors of Home Buying For Dummies
House Selling For Dummies®, 3rd Edition Published by Wiley Publishing, Inc. 111 River St. Hoboken, NJ 07030-5774 www.wiley.com
Copyright © 2008 by Eric Tyson and Ray Brown Published by Wiley Publishing, Inc., Indianapolis, Indiana Published simultaneously in Canada No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Sections 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400, fax 978-646-8600. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Legal Department, Wiley Publishing, Inc., 10475 Crosspoint Blvd., Indianapolis, IN 46256, 317-572-3447, fax 317-572-4355, or online at http://www. wiley.com/go/permissions.
Trademarks: Wiley, the Wiley Publishing logo, For Dummies, the Dummies Man logo, A Reference for the Rest of Us!, The Dummies Way, Dummies Daily, The Fun and Easy Way, Dummies.com and related trade dress are trademarks or registered trademarks of John Wiley & Sons, Inc. and/or its affiliates in the United States and other countries, and may not be used without written permission. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Wiley Publishing, Inc., is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. LIMIT OF LIABILITY/DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTY: THE PUBLISHER AND THE AUTHOR MAKE NO REPRESENTATIONS OR WARRANTIES WITH RESPECT TO THE ACCURACY OR COMPLETENESS OF THE CONTENTS OF THIS WORK AND SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIM ALL WARRANTIES, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION WARRANTIES OF FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. NO WARRANTY MAY BE CREATED OR EXTENDED BY SALES OR PROMOTIONAL MATERIALS. THE ADVICE AND STRATEGIES CONTAINED HEREIN MAY NOT BE SUITABLE FOR EVERY SITUATION. THIS WORK IS SOLD WITH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT THE PUBLISHER IS NOT ENGAGED IN RENDERING LEGAL, ACCOUNTING, OR OTHER PROFESSIONAL SERVICES. IF PROFESSIONAL ASSISTANCE IS REQUIRED, THE SERVICES OF A COMPETENT PROFESSIONAL PERSON SHOULD BE SOUGHT. NEITHER THE PUBLISHER NOR THE AUTHOR SHALL BE LIABLE FOR DAMAGES ARISING HEREFROM. THE FACT THAT AN ORGANIZATION OR WEBSITE IS REFERRED TO IN THIS WORK AS A CITATION AND/OR A POTENTIAL SOURCE OF FURTHER INFORMATION DOES NOT MEAN THAT THE AUTHOR OR THE PUBLISHER ENDORSES THE INFORMATION THE ORGANIZATION OR WEBSITE MAY PROVIDE OR RECOMMENDATIONS IT MAY MAKE. FURTHER, READERS SHOULD BE AWARE THAT INTERNET WEBSITES LISTED IN THIS WORK MAY HAVE CHANGED OR DISAPPEARED BETWEEN WHEN THIS WORK WAS WRITTEN AND WHEN IT IS READ. For general information on our other products and services, please contact our Customer Care Department within the U.S. at 800-762-2974, outside the U.S. at 317-572-3993, or fax 317-572-4002. For technical support, please visit www.wiley.com/techsupport. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Library of Congress Control Number: 2007939645 ISBN: 978-0-470-17046-5 Manufactured in the United States of America 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
About the Author Eric Tyson, MBA, is a former financial counselor, lecturer and coauthor of the national best-seller, Home Buying For Dummies, as well as the author of four other best-selling books in the For Dummies series: Personal Finance, Investing, Mutual Funds, and Taxes (coauthor). Eric has counseled thousands of clients on a variety of personal finance, investment, and real estate quandaries and questions. In addition to maintaining a financial counseling practice, he’s a former lecturer of the San Francisco Bay Area’s most highly attended financial management course at the University of California, Berkeley. Eric is also a syndicated columnist and was an award-winning journalist for the San Francisco Examiner. His work has been featured and praised in hundreds of national and local publications, including Newsweek, Kiplinger’s, The Wall Street Journal, Money, The Los Angeles Times, and the Chicago Tribune, and on NBC’s Today Show, PBS’s Nightly Business Report, CNN, The Oprah Winfrey Show, ABC, CNBC, Bloomberg Business Radio, CBS National Radio, and National Public Radio. A former management consultant to Fortune 500 financial service firms, Eric is dedicated to teaching people to manage their personal finances better. Over the past two decades, he has successfully invested in securities as well as in real estate, started and managed several businesses. He earned his MBA at the Stanford Graduate School of Business and his bachelor’s degree in economics at Yale. Ray Brown, coauthor of the national best-seller Home Buying For Dummies, is a veteran of the real estate profession with over three decades of hands-on experience. A former manager for Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage Company, McGuire Real Estate, Pacific Union GMAC Real Estate, and founder of his own real estate firm — the Raymond Brown Company — Ray is currently a writer, consultant, and public speaker on residential real estate topics. Ray knows that most people are pretty darn smart. When they have problems, it’s usually because they don’t know the right questions to ask to get the information they need to make good decisions themselves. He always wanted to write real estate books that focused readers on what they needed to know to make sound home-buying and house-selling decisions. On his way to becoming a real estate guru, Ray worked as the real estate analyst for KGO-TV (ABC’s affiliate in San Francisco) and as a syndicated real estate columnist for The San Francisco Examiner. He also hosted a weekly radio program — The Ray Brown on Real Estate, for KNBR — for 16 years. In addition to his work for ABC, Ray has appeared as a real estate expert on CNN, NBC, and CBS and in The Wall Street Journal and TIME.
Ray’s most significant achievements, however, are still Jeff and Jared, his two incomparable sons, and over 42 years of nearly always wedded bliss to the always wonderful Annie B. He’s delighted to welcome Jeff’s wife, Genevieve, and his grandson, Aidan Joseph Brown, to the family.
Dedication This book is hereby and irrevocably dedicated to my family and friends, as well as to my counseling clients and customers, who ultimately have taught me everything I know about how to explain financial terms and strategies so that everyone may benefit. — Eric Tyson This book is lovingly dedicated to Annie B., who makes my heart sing. — Ray Brown
Authors’ Acknowledgments Many, many people at Wiley Publishing, Inc. helped to make this book possible and (we hope in your opinion) good. These folks include Chad Sievers, Project Editor; Carrie Burchfield, Copy Editor; and all the fine folks in Production! Thanks also to everyone else at Wiley who contributed to getting this book done and done right. Extraordinary acclamation, copious praise, and profound gratitude is due our brilliant technical reviewers for this and prior editions who toiled long hours to ensure that we didn’t write something that wasn’t quite right. These good folks include two extraordinary real estate professionals: Kip Oxman, McGuire Real Estate and Lynnea Key, Lynnea Key Realty; one extraordinary mortgage consultant: David Wales, Palo Alto Funding Group, Inc.; as well as Patti Wallace with ECHO Housing and Dennis Ito, Bob Taylor, and all the good folks at KPMG Peat Marwick. Thank you one and all! We also owe an enormous debt of gratitude to Paul Bragstad, Pacific Union GMAC Real Estate, for his incredible Internet insights; Joy Alafia for helping us obtain the California Association of Realtors’ exclusive listing contract and the property disclosure statement used in Chapter 8, the counter offer used in Chapter 14, and the real estate purchase contract included in Appendix A; Warren Camp, Warren Camp Inspection Services, for providing the exemplary premarketing inspection report included in Appendix B; Patty Oxman, Frank Howard Allen Realtors’ super star, for her staging tips; Victoria Naidorf, VP and Brokerage Counsel for Coldwell Banker in Northern California, who developed the ten troublemakers in Chapter 12; Brian Felix, Old Republic Title Company, who provided his usual scholarly advice about title insurance and escrows; Roland Jadryev, listing-statement writer extraordinary; Barbara Pacak, who unlocked the mysteries of lockboxes; Liz Johnson, who had answers to all our questions; and last, but far from least, Esty Lawrie and Dolly Toms, for their greatly appreciated wisdom and support.
Publisher’s Acknowledgments We’re proud of this book; please send us your comments through our Dummies online registration form located at www.dummies.com/register/. Some of the people who helped bring this book to market include the following: Acquisitions, Editorial, and Media Development Project Editor: Chad R. Sievers (Previous Edition: Suzanne Snyder) Acquisitions Editor: Mike Baker Copy Editor: Carrie Burchfield (Previous Edition: Neil Johnson) Editorial Program Coordinator: Erin Calligan Mooney
Composition Services Project Coordinator: Kristie Rees Layout and Graphics: Reuben W. Davis, Alissa D. Ellet, Melissa K. Jester, Shane Johnson, Barbara Moore, Christine Williams Anniversary Logo Design: Richard Pacifico Proofreaders: John Greenough, Jessica Kramer, Nancy Reinhardt Indexer: Potomac Indexing, LLC
Technical Editor: Kip Oxman Editorial Manager: Michelle Hacker Editorial Assistants: Joe Niesen, Leeann Harney Cover Photos: © Seth Joel/Getty Images Cartoons: Rich Tennant
(www.the5thwave.com)
Publishing and Editorial for Consumer Dummies Diane Graves Steele, Vice President and Publisher, Consumer Dummies Joyce Pepple, Acquisitions Director, Consumer Dummies Kristin A. Cocks, Product Development Director, Consumer Dummies Michael Spring, Vice President and Publisher, Travel Kelly Regan, Editorial Director, Travel Publishing for Technology Dummies Andy Cummings, Vice President and Publisher, Dummies Technology/General User Composition Services Gerry Fahey, Vice President of Production Services Debbie Stailey, Director of Composition Services
Contents at a Glance Introduction .................................................................1 Part I: The Selling Decision ...........................................7 Chapter 1: Deciding to Sell ................................................................................................9 Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances ............................................................23 Chapter 3: Exploring the Economics of Selling.............................................................43 Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues.......................................................................55
Part II: Tactical Considerations....................................73 Chapter 5: Timing is Everything .....................................................................................75 Chapter 6: For Sale By Owner .........................................................................................87 Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team ..................................................................................97 Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions .........................................................123
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell..................151 Chapter 9: Preparing Your House for Sale...................................................................153 Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value .............................................................163 Chapter 11: Price It Right and Buyers Will Come .......................................................181
Part IV: The Brass Tacks of Getting Your House Sold ...197 Chapter 12: Marketing Your House ..............................................................................199 Chapter 13: Harnessing Your Computer for House Selling .......................................213 Chapter 14: Negotiating Strategies for Sellers ............................................................221 Chapter 15: It Ain’t Over ‘til the Check Clears............................................................251 Chapter 16: Income Tax Filings after the Sale.............................................................263
Part V: The Part of Tens ............................................271 Chapter 17: Ten Things to Do After You Sell...............................................................273 Chapter 18: Ten Tips for Selling Rental Real Estate ...................................................279 Chapter 19: Ten Questions Home Buyers May Ask and How to Answer ’Em .........287
Part VI: Appendixes ..................................................293 Appendix A: Sample Real Estate Purchase Contract .................................................295 Appendix B: Example of a Good Inspection Report...................................................305 Appendix C: Glossary ....................................................................................................321
Table of Contents Introduction ..................................................................1 The Eric Tyson/Ray Brown Difference ..........................................................1 Conventions Used in This Book .....................................................................2 Foolish Assumptions .......................................................................................2 How This Book Is Organized...........................................................................3 Part I: The Selling Decision ...................................................................3 Part II: Tactical Considerations ............................................................4 Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell...........................................4 Part IV: The Brass Tacks of Getting Your House Sold........................5 Part V: The Part of Tens.........................................................................5 Part VI: Appendixes................................................................................5 Icons Used in This Book..................................................................................6 Where to Go from Here....................................................................................6
Part I: The Selling Decision ............................................7 Chapter 1: Deciding to Sell . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9 Figuring Out if You Really Need to Sell ........................................................10 Good reasons to stay ...........................................................................12 Reasons to consider selling ................................................................16 Knowing the Health of Your Housing Market .............................................18 Selling in a depressed housing market ..............................................19 Selling during a strong market............................................................20
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .23 Trading Up ......................................................................................................23 Examining your housing budget.........................................................24 Figuring your expected expenses after trading up ..........................26 Determining the financial impact on your future goals...................30 Exploring the other costs of trading up ............................................30 Making Retirement Housing Decisions........................................................31 Trading down ........................................................................................31 Researching reverse mortgages .........................................................36 Tax Facts Sellers and Landlords Ought to Know .......................................41
Chapter 3: Exploring the Economics of Selling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .43 Estimating Proceeds of Sale..........................................................................43 Estimated sale price.............................................................................44 Closing costs .........................................................................................45 Mortgage payoff....................................................................................46
xviii
House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition Moving expenses ..................................................................................48 Putting it all together ...........................................................................49 Assessing the Financial Feasibility of a Move ............................................50 Researching living costs and employment opportunities ..............50 Avoiding relocation traps ....................................................................52
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .55 Financing Decisions When Trading Up........................................................55 Choosing your mortgage .....................................................................56 Financing improvements .....................................................................57 The Trials and Tribulations of Seller Financing .........................................59 Asking yourself why you’d ever want to be a lender.......................59 Deciding if seller financing is for you.................................................61 Finding creditworthy buyers ..............................................................62 Deciding what to charge......................................................................69 Protecting yourself legally...................................................................71
Part II: Tactical Considerations ....................................73 Chapter 5: Timing is Everything . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .75 Timing the Sale of Your House .....................................................................75 First peak season: Spring flowers and For Sale signs bloom ..........77 First valley: Summer doldrums...........................................................77 Second peak season: Autumn leaves and houses of every color...78 Death Valley: Real estate activity hibernates until spring ..............80 The Seller’s Quandary: Timing the Purchase of Your Home ....................80 Consolidating Your Sale and Purchase........................................................81 Determine your house’s current value ..............................................81 Check your buying power ...................................................................82 Familiarize yourself with the market .................................................82 Take action ............................................................................................83
Chapter 6: For Sale By Owner . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .87 Eyeing the Potential FSBO Advantages .......................................................87 You want to save money on commissions ........................................87 You may already have a ready, willing, and able buyer...................88 You may know the house and neighborhood well ...........................88 You may be more motivated than an agent ......................................90 You like challenges ...............................................................................90 You want to be in control ....................................................................90 Your house may sell itself ...................................................................91 Focusing on Potential FSBO Disadvantages ...............................................91 You may not know how to price property ........................................91 You may not know how to prepare your house for sale..................91 You may not know how to market your property ............................92 You may not know how to separate real buyers from fakes...........92 You may not have enough experience as a negotiator....................92
Table of Contents You may get yourself into legal trouble.............................................93 You may not know how to close the sale ..........................................93 Increasing Your Chances of Success............................................................93 Educate yourself...................................................................................94 Ensure that other team members are especially strong .................94 Cooperate with agents.........................................................................94 Financially qualify prospective buyers..............................................95
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .97 Teaming Up — a Winning Concept ..............................................................97 Landing the Perfect Listing Agent................................................................99 Understanding agent relationships..................................................100 Recognizing the best listing agents..................................................100 Choosing your listing agent ..............................................................102 Achieving top performance from the winner .................................109 Bringing in the Broker .................................................................................110 Handling House Inspectors.........................................................................111 Arranging premarketing property inspections...............................111 Exploring the advantages of inspecting before marketing ...........111 Investigating inspectors ....................................................................114 The Officiating Escrow Officer ...................................................................117 Finding Financial and Tax Advisors ...........................................................117 Locating a Good Lawyer..............................................................................118 Choosing among lawyers ..................................................................119 Working well with your lawyer .........................................................121
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .123 Understanding Listing Contracts ...............................................................123 Considering the Types of Listings..............................................................125 Exclusive listings ................................................................................125 Open listings .......................................................................................133 Examining Broker Compensation...............................................................134 Commissions.......................................................................................134 Net listings...........................................................................................139 Discount brokers ................................................................................140 Preparing Seller Disclosure Statements ....................................................142 What information should you disclose?..........................................142 An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure .........................147
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell ..................151 Chapter 9: Preparing Your House for Sale . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .153 Handling Presale Preparation.....................................................................154 Creating curb appeal..........................................................................154 Exteriors attract, but interiors sell ..................................................156 Staging..................................................................................................158 Think Again: Avoiding Major Improvements ............................................161
xix
xx
House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .163 Defining Cost, Price, and Value...................................................................164 Value is elusive....................................................................................164 Cost is history.....................................................................................165 Price is the here and now..................................................................166 Determining Fair Market Value (FMV) .......................................................166 Need-based pricing isn’t FMV ...........................................................167 Median prices aren’t FMV .................................................................167 Using a Comparable Market Analysis........................................................169 Playing with the numbers .................................................................173 Interpreting CMA adjustments and flaws........................................174 Considering appraisals versus CMAs ..............................................176 Bidding Wars.................................................................................................177 How buyers and sellers get to FMV .................................................177 Why “buying a listing” ruins property pricing................................178
Chapter 11: Price It Right and Buyers Will Come . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .181 Getting a Grasp on Pricing Methods..........................................................181 Four-phase pricing: Prevalent but ineffective.................................182 Pleasure-pleasure-panic pricing: Fast, top-dollar sales .................183 Quantum pricing: An effective technique .......................................184 Identifying Incentives and Gimmicks.........................................................188 Deal-making incentives ......................................................................188 Deceptive gimmicks ...........................................................................189 Overpricing Your House..............................................................................190 Can’t sell versus won’t sell................................................................190 Three factors all buyers consider ....................................................191 Danger signs of overpricing ..............................................................192 The foolproof way to correct overpricing.......................................192 Placing the blame where it belongs .................................................194
Part IV: The Brass Tacks of Getting Your House Sold ....197 Chapter 12: Marketing Your House . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .199 Advertising That Works...............................................................................199 For Sale sign ........................................................................................200 Classified ads ......................................................................................201 Multiple listing service (MLS)...........................................................204 Listing statement................................................................................204 Computers...........................................................................................206 Word of mouth ....................................................................................207 Arranging Open Houses ..............................................................................207 Brokers’ opens ....................................................................................207 Weekend open houses .......................................................................208 Showing Your Property ...............................................................................209 Preshowing preparations ..................................................................209 The final showing ...............................................................................210
Table of Contents Chapter 13: Harnessing Your Computer for House Selling . . . . . . . .213 Knowing the Internet’s Limitations: The Net Alone Can’t Sell Your House...............................................................................214 Ensure good Web promo of your house ..........................................214 Knowing the truth about for-sale-by-owner (FSBO) sites .............215 Realize the limits of valuing your house online..............................216 Relying on Software and the Web to Determine Whether to Sell...........218
Chapter 14: Negotiating Strategies for Sellers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .221 Mastering Your Feelings ..............................................................................222 Putting emotions in their place ........................................................223 Gaining detachment through an agent ............................................224 Following Some Basic Rules........................................................................224 Surviving the Bargaining Process ..............................................................225 Receiving an offer to purchase .........................................................225 Dealing with contingencies — necessary uncertainty ..................227 Making a counter offer.......................................................................228 Negotiating from a Position of Strength ....................................................233 Handling multiple offers ....................................................................233 Delaying presentation of offers ........................................................234 Setting guidelines for an orderly presentation process ................235 Selecting the best offer ......................................................................236 Negotiating from a Position of Weakness..................................................238 Rejecting lowball offers .....................................................................239 Considering other offers usually made in weak markets ..............241 Negotiating credits in escrow ...........................................................244 Distinguishing Real Buyers from Fakes .....................................................247 Are the buyers creditworthy?...........................................................248 Are the buyers realistic?....................................................................248 Are the buyers motivated?................................................................249 Do the buyers have a time frame?....................................................249 Are the buyers cooperative?.............................................................249
Chapter 15: It Ain’t Over ‘til the Check Clears . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .251 Entering the Neutral Territory of an Escrow ............................................251 Understanding the role of the escrow officer .................................252 Maximizing your escrow....................................................................254 Avoiding the curse of December escrows.......................................256 Letting Go of Your House ............................................................................257 Moving daze ........................................................................................258 The final verification of condition....................................................260 Surviving Seller’s Remorse or (Gasp) the Double Whammy ..................260 Confronting your fears.......................................................................261 Facing the ultimate test .....................................................................262
xxi
xxii
House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition Chapter 16: Income Tax Filings after the Sale . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .263 Profits from a House Sale ............................................................................263 Defining profits ...................................................................................263 Excluding house sale profits from tax .............................................264 Tax Filings Required after the Sale.............................................................265 Schedule D: Capital Gains and Losses .............................................265 State income taxes on housing profits ............................................269
Part V: The Part of Tens .............................................271 Chapter 17: Ten Things to Do After You Sell . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .273 Keep Copies of the Closing and Settlement Papers.................................273 Keep Proof of Improvements and Prior Purchases .................................274 Stash Your Cash in a Good Money Market Fund ......................................274 Double-check the Tax Rules for Excluding Tax on Profits ......................275 Cast a Broad Net When You Consider Your Next Home..........................275 Remember That Renting Can Be a Fine Strategy .....................................276 Reevaluate Your Personal Finances When Things Change.....................276 Don’t Simply Rehire Your Listing Agent When You Repurchase............277 Think through Your Next Down Payment .................................................277 Remember to Send Change of Address Notices.......................................278
Chapter 18: Ten Tips for Selling Rental Real Estate . . . . . . . . . . . . . .279 Don’t Inadvertently Convert Your House into Income Property ...........279 Exercise Extra Care When You Sell Rental Property................................280 Know How to Defer Your Investment Property Profits ...........................281 Understand Your Local Market to Time Your Sale...................................282 Understand Opportunities for Adding Value............................................283 Maximize Your Property’s Income .............................................................283 Minimize Your Property’s Expenses ..........................................................284 Utilize Agents with Investment Property Experience..............................285 Visit Comparables and Review the Valuation Analysis ...........................285 Work with Rental-Property-Experienced Tax and Legal Advisors .........286
Chapter 19: Ten Questions Home Buyers May Ask and How to Answer ’Em . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .287 What Do You Like Best and Least about Living Here?.............................287 Why Are You Selling This Lovely House?..................................................288 How Much Did You Pay for This House?...................................................289 How Did You Establish the Asking Price? .................................................289 Have You Received Inspection Reports?...................................................290 May I See Your Written Defect Disclosure Statement? ............................290 Are There Any Neighborhood Changes that May Affect the Home’s Desirability?...............................................................291
Table of Contents How Many Times in the Last Year Have You Called the Police and Why?.....................................................................291 What Problems Have You Had with the House?.......................................292 What Are the Local Public Schools Like?..................................................292
Part VI: Appendixes...................................................293 Appendix A: Sample Real Estate Purchase Contract . . . . . . . . . . . . .295 Appendix B: Example of a Good Inspection Report . . . . . . . . . . . . . .305 Appendix C: Glossary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .321
xxiii
xxiv
House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition
Introduction
W
elcome to House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition, the completely updated companion to Home Buying For Dummies (also in its 3rd Edition), the #1 bestselling real estate book (that we also happened to write). If you’re like most people, your biggest investment is your house. Sell your house wisely and you not only save yourself loads of time, but you also pocket thousands — if not tens of thousands — of dollars more than you would otherwise. Making a big mistake in the sale of your house, on the other hand, can easily cost you additional weeks — perhaps even months — of work and headache, as well as half a year’s worth (or more) of your takehome income. One of Ray’s treasures is a well-worn fortune cookie message that says, “A wise person knows everything. A shrewd person knows everyone.” We apply that same principle to house sales. Real estate is a team sport. In this book, we show you how to put together a winning team, and we alert you to key points to consider throughout your sale. Follow our advice and your house is as good as sold before the For Sale sign even goes up. We don’t care about whether you decide to sell your house or how much of the transaction you attempt to handle yourself. It’s not that we’re insensitive; we simply don’t have a vested interest in the sale of your house. What we do care very deeply about is that you make the best possible decisions for your situation. If those decisions mean staying in your current home instead of selling, or if they mean selling through a good local real estate agent, that’s terrific. We wrote this book to help you avoid making mistakes in your selling decisions and to ensure that you sell your house in the best way possible.
The Eric Tyson/Ray Brown Difference We’ve received great accolades from the prior editions of this book and for Home Buying For Dummies. House Selling For Dummies fills a void for house sellers: It’s a user-friendly book totally oriented to your needs as a seller. If you’ve visited your local library or bought books on selling your home, you may be familiar with the shortcomings of most house-selling books. In writing this book, we attempt to avoid those shortcomings. Thus, we expect that you’ll find that our book is
2
House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition Holistic: No one sells a house just for the sake of selling it. Selling a house creates tax and financial ramifications, particularly if you’re selling to buy a more expensive home, relocating to a different part of the country, or retiring. Most other house-selling books, however, don’t help you consider these bigger-picture issues of personal finance before you sell. In Part I, we come right out and tell you that some people who are thinking about selling their current homes shouldn’t. Educational: Most house-selling books are written by real estate agents or their firms. Such books are long on singing the praises of real estate agents but short on specific advice, helpful tips, and caution signs. That’s why many of those other books are less than 200 pages long. The authors aren’t interested in sharing the innermost secrets of selling real estate; they’re more interested in promoting their own business by convincing you to use a real estate agent. We wrote this book first and foremost to educate you. (Of course, if we end up making a few bucks for ourselves in the process, we won’t complain.) Jargon-free: One of the hallmarks of books written more to confuse the reader than to convey information is the use of all sorts of insider terms that make things sound more mysterious and complicated than they really are. In this book, we try to keep everything in plain English. We even include a glossary, just in case you do encounter a term that appears to be Greek or Latin to you!
Conventions Used in This Book When writing this book, we included some general conventions that all For Dummies books use. We use the following: Italic: We italicize any words you may not be familiar with and provide a definition. Boldface type: We bold all keywords in bulleted lists and the actual steps in numbered lists. Monofont: All Web sites and e-mail addresses appear in monofont.
Foolish Assumptions We’re not trying to scare you — quite the contrary. We just want to make it clear that, even though selling your house isn’t brain surgery, you can easily make mistakes, especially if you’re overconfident or do a poor job selecting people to work with in the transaction. When we wrote this book, we made a few assumptions about you.
Introduction You’re humble: You realize that you aren’t a house-selling expert. You’re smart: Even though you’re not an expert, you realize the value of getting as much information as you can. This trait bodes well for your upcoming experience in selling real estate. Although you’re likely to hire some professionals to help you sell your house, you still need to educate yourself about all aspects of the transaction. Why? You’re the one who ultimately must make the decision about whether or not, and when, to sell your house. No real estate agent, loan broker, or anyone else who has a vested interest in the sale can objectively advise you about whether you should sell your house or when is the best time for you to sell. You’re the one (if you do decide to sell) who must interview and hire competent and affordable people who can help you with the sale. You need to know what all the people you hire do, why they do it, what to expect from them, and what they expect from you. Oscar Wilde said, “Experience is the name everyone gives to their mistakes.” We want to add a corollary to this observation: “Learning from other people’s mistakes is infinitely better than learning from your own.” House Selling For Dummies saves you money, time, and heartache — but only if you read it!
How This Book Is Organized Perhaps you’re sure that you want to sell your house. On the other hand, maybe you (like many people each year who contemplate a sale) aren’t sure whether you can or should sell. If you do decide to sell your house, you must face the hard work of picking the best time to sell, preparing your house for sale, choosing the best people to help you sell, and closing the deal. And, even after the deal is done, you’re sure to have questions and unresolved issues. House Selling For Dummies covers everything you need to know.
Part I: The Selling Decision Even if you think that you can or must sell, consider the big picture before you take action. This book starts with the premise that many important factors — financial and personal — should fall into place before you decide to sell your house. For example, how do you know if you can really afford to sell your house and buy another home if you haven’t yet considered your overall financial situation and goals? Without taking stock of important financial and personal issues, you’re simply guessing, or hoping, that selling is financially feasible and the right thing to do.
3
4
House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition One element of the decision to sell hinges on the financial ramifications of selling. Amazingly, most people crunch few, if any, numbers before they decide to sell their home. Or they leave the financial analysis to a salesperson with a vested interest in the house-selling transaction. We explain that you don’t need a PhD in quantum physics or even an interest in mathematics to make some simple, yet powerful, financial assessments before you sell. We also help you understand the pros and cons of lending money to the buyer of your humble abode.
Part II: Tactical Considerations In this part, we assume that you’ve already made the decision to sell your house. Now you’re ready to tackle important selling decisions, such as when to put your house on the market. Because most house sellers buy another home to replace the one they’re leaving behind, we walk you through the logistical considerations of whether you should sell your current house before buying the next one or purchase your next home before cutting the cord to your current house. This part also covers all the issues relating to how you’re going to get your house sold. Are you going to try selling it yourself, or are you going to hire a real estate agent? We also explain the other players that you may want or need to include on your house-selling team, and we tell you how to choose the best people in their respective fields. Finally, if you’ve chosen to sell your house through a real estate agent, we walk you through the all-important listing contract that you complete with the agent and his or her firm, and explain the best ways to negotiate the commission for the sale of your house.
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Before you actually put your house on the market, read all our best tips for preparing your property to look appealing to prospective buyers (and real estate agents that many of them work with). Next comes the critical decision of determining the asking price for your house. Just as Goldilocks was looking for a bowl of porridge that was the right temperature, you don’t want to over-price or under-price your home; you want to price it just right. In this part, we show you how.
Part IV: The Brass Tacks of Getting Your House Sold After you price your house and put it on the market, the actual marketing of the property begins. In this part, we review different marketing methods and
Introduction then explain how to choose those strategies that are best for your property. If you follow our advice up to this point in the book, you can bet that an offer or two will come rolling in before you know it. Although you’ve probably never aspired to be Secretary of State, you (and your agent, if you’re working with one) do need to know how to keep your composure and use proven negotiating tactics to get what you want and make the buyers of your house feel good about the deal they’re getting. We also guide you through the final steps of your sale, including the escrow process and the money transfer. And, last but not least, we walk you through the unavoidable tax hoops you need to jump through when you sell your house.
Part V: The Part of Tens This part provides counsel and advice on shorter topics that seem to stand alone well. Here, we explain ten important things to remember to do after your house sale is complete, our top ten tips for successfully selling rental real estate, and how to handle ten difficult questions you may be asked about selling your house. If you have a short attention span, or if you like the feeling you get from completing chapters, this part’s for you!
Part VI: Appendixes Appendixes are typically a tad dull and probably aren’t the first thing you want to read in a book. On the other hand, the appendixes in this book include examples of important documents that can help enhance your house-selling knowledge. In this part, we provide an example of a premarketing inspection report and a real estate purchase contract and receipt for deposit. Finally, we include a handy glossary to define real estate terms that often sound like Pig Latin, unless you happen to sell real estate for a living (in which case, they probably sound very sensible).
Icons Used in This Book Just as you use tasty seasonings in your favorite recipes, we’ve sprinkled helpful icons throughout this book to draw attention to key points or to denote stuff that you can skip over. This icon flags key strategies that can improve your real estate deal and, in some cases, save you mounds of moola. Think of these icons as pointing out little words of wisdom that we would whisper in your ear if we were close enough to do so.
5
6
House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition Numerous booby-traps await novices as well as experienced house sellers. This explosive symbol marks those mines and tells you how to sidestep them. Occasionally, we suggest that you do more research or homework. Don’t worry; we tell you exactly how to go about your investigation. Unfortunately, as is the case in all realms of the business world, some people and companies are more interested in short-term profits than in meeting your needs and addressing your concerns. This icon highlights places in a houseselling transaction where sharks may be swimming and points to advice on avoiding such scoundrels. To ensure that you don’t forget important points, this icon serves as your little reminder, like a string tied around your finger.
This icon marks stuff that you don’t really have to know, but that may come in handy at cocktail parties thrown by people in the real estate business.
This icon points out the best resources and techniques for selling your property faster, more profitably, and with less hassle.
Where to Go from Here You don’t need to read this book cover to cover. But if you’re a beginner or you want to fully immerse yourself in the world of house selling, go for it! However, you may have a specific question or two today and want some other information tomorrow. No problem there, either. House Selling For Dummies, 3rd Edition, is lighter on its feet and easier to use than other house selling reference books. Use the Table of Contents or the Index to speed your way toward what you need to know and get on with your life.
Part I
The Selling Decision
W
In this part . . .
e help you tackle the big-picture issues that you must face before selling your house. To begin with, we ask you to consider whether you should even sell your house in the first place. Do you need to sell or do you just want to sell? Wanting to sell isn’t a bad thing, but selling and moving can wreak havoc with your pocketbook if you don’t first study the financial ramifications. We walk you through your options and assist you with making the selling decision. And before you sell your house, you need to figure out how much you’ll net from the transaction. Unless you’re quite affluent, you’re going to need to know how much money to put toward your next place, your retirement nest egg, or whatever else you envision doing with the proceeds. We tell you how to come up with an accurate estimate, not a “guesstimate.” We also encourage you to think through another important issue before you put up your For Sale sign: Are you interested, willing, and able to provide financing to a prospective buyer of your house?
Chapter 1
Deciding to Sell In This Chapter Making the choice: To sell or not to sell Selling in weak and strong housing markets
S
elling your house and moving can be an enjoyable (not to mention profitable) experience. Unfortunately, for most people, it isn’t. Selling a house not only introduces financial turmoil into most people’s lives but also causes them stress. One goal of this book is to help you make the right decision about whether to sell your house. If you do decide to sell, we want to make sure that you get as many dollars and as few upset stomachs from the sale as possible. The reasons people want to sell their houses are almost as varied as the houses themselves. Here are some of the common, not-so common, and downright bizarre reasons: Additional debt burden because of layoff, medical expenses, disability, or overspending Bad vibes or bad luck associated with house Better job opportunities elsewhere Diminished space requirements now that children are grown House located in a flood, earthquake, or other disaster zone Increased space requirements for expanding family Lack of garage Neighborhood conditions incompatible with socioeconomic status Noisy neighborhood Noisy/messy/obnoxious family or business moved next door Recent death of spouse Recent marriage or divorce
10
Part I: The Selling Decision Serious house defects (such as radon or termites) that owners don’t want to fix Unfriendly neighbors Unsafe neighborhood Unsatisfactory neighborhood shopping Unsatisfactory school district Unsuitable climate As you can see from this partial list, most of the reasons why people have a desire to sell their houses are based on wants, not needs. In the United States, we sometimes take for granted how economically fortunate we are. You don’t need to move because your neighborhood is too noisy or because your house seems too small. You don’t need to move because the weather in your area isn’t nice enough. You don’t need to live on quieter, tree-lined streets. All these features are things people want, not things they need. And people who think that they can afford to pay for such things usually get more of what they want. Sometimes, however, people spend money moving and, ironically, still don’t get what they want. The weather in the new locale may not be terrific, the neighbors may not be friendly and quiet, and the schools may not turn children into stellar students. You may move to get away from particular problems and then find yourself facing a new set of different problems. We’re certainly not going to tell you how and where to spend your money — that’s your choice. However, we definitely want you to make the most of your money. Unless you’re one of the few who has far more money than you can ever possibly spend, we suggest that you prioritize the demands on your money to accomplish your most important financial goals. Nothing’s wrong with spending money to trade in one house for another, but before you set those wheels in motion, think about the impact of that kind of spending on other aspects of your life. The more that you spend on housing, the less you’ll have for your other goals, such as saving for retirement, taking annual vacations, and spending less time working and more time with your family and friends.
Figuring Out if You Really Need to Sell Although spending your entire life in the first home you buy is an unlikely prospect, some people do end up living in the same home for 10, 20, even 30 or more years. Ray (humble coauthor of this book), for example, lived in his home nearly 30 years. Ray’s no fool; staying put must have its advantages.
Chapter 1: Deciding to Sell If, like most prospective house sellers, you have a choice between staying put and selling, not selling has clear advantages. Selling your house and then buying another one takes a great deal of legwork and research time on your part. Whether you sell your house yourself or hire an agent, you’re going to be heavily involved in getting your house ready for sale and keeping it pristine while it’s on the market. In addition to time, selling your house and buying another one can cost serious money. Between real estate commissions, loan fees, title insurance, transfer tax, and myriad other costs of selling your house and then buying another one, you can easily spend 15 percent or more of the value of the property that you’re selling (see bar on the left in Figure 1-1). Fifteen percent sounds like a lot, doesn’t it? Well, consider this: Unless you own your house free and clear of any mortgage debt, your transaction costs are going to gobble up an even larger percentage of the money you’ve invested in your home.
100%
$240,000 house
$60,000 equity
90% 80% 70% $36,000 60% 50% 40% 30% 20%
$36,000
10% Figure 1-1: Trading homes can cost you big bucks.
0%
$36,000 in transaction costs as a percentage of the house's value
$36,000 in transaction costs as a percentage of the homeowner's equity
11
12
Part I: The Selling Decision Check out this scenario: You’re thinking about selling your $240,000 house. If selling your house and buying another one costs you 15 percent of the first house’s value, then you’re taking $36,000 out of your sale proceeds. However, if you happen to owe $180,000 on your mortgage, your equity in the home — the difference between the amount the house is worth ($240,000) and the amount you owe ($180,000) — is $60,000. Therefore, the $36,000 in transaction costs devours a huge 60 percent of your equity (see bar on the right in Figure 1-1). Ouch! Before spending that much of your hard-earned money, make sure that you give careful thought and consideration to why you want to sell, the financial consequences of selling, and the alternatives to selling. In Chapters 2 and 3, we walk you through the personal financial issues that you need to weigh when contemplating the sale of your current house. But before we get to the numbers, consider the qualitative issues.
Good reasons to stay Whereas some people have clear and compelling reasons for selling their homes, others do so for the wrong reasons. You don’t want to make the financially painful mistake of selling if you don’t have to or can’t afford to. The following sections offer reasons why you may be better off staying right where you are.
You’re already having trouble living within your means If you’re having difficulty making ends meet, and you use high-interest consumer credit, such as credit cards or auto loans, to maintain your desired standard of living, you shouldn’t spend more money on housing. Even if you’re planning to trade your current house for one of comparable value, you may not be able to afford all the transaction costs of selling and buying. Even if you aren’t a consumer-debt user and you’re saving a comfortable portion (10 percent or more) of your current earnings, don’t assume that you can afford to trade up to a more expensive home. In addition to a higher mortgage payment, you may also face increased property taxes, insurance rates, and home maintenance costs. A mortgage lender may be willing to finance a loan that enables you to trade up to a more expensive home, but qualifying for a loan doesn’t mean that you can afford that home. Mortgage lenders use simplistic formulas, based primarily on your income, to determine the amount they’re willing to lend you. Mortgage lenders don’t know (or care) how far behind you are in saving for your retirement or how many children you must help with college costs or how much assistance you want or need to give to elderly parents.
Chapter 1: Deciding to Sell Mortgage lenders are concerned about protecting their interests in the event that you default on your mortgage. As long as you meet a few minimal financial requirements (you make a sufficient down payment, and your housing expenses are less than a certain percentage of your income), the mortgage lenders can sell your loan with the backing of a government mortgage agency, effectively wiping their hands clean of you and your problems. If you’re thinking about trading in your current house for another one, especially for a more expensive one, you absolutely, positively must consider the financial repercussions of changed housing expenses in addition to the costs of buying and selling. We cover these important issues in Chapters 2 and 3.
The problems are more in your perceptions Everybody, at some point, leaps to conclusions based on faulty assumptions or incomplete research in virtually all aspects their lives. Peter, for example, was a single parent living with his son in a nice neighborhood in an urban environment. When his son started junior high school, Peter grew increasingly concerned with the possibility that his son would become involved with drugs, which seemed to be so prevalent in their city. Despite working in the city, Peter decided to move to an easygoing, suburban community about 45 minutes outside the city. Shortly after the move, Peter’s son got mixed up with drugs anyway — perhaps, in part, because the long daily commute meant that Peter was around even less. In addition to ignoring lifestyle issues (such as the length of his commute), Peter made a common human mistake — he assumed that things were a particular way without getting the facts. The reality was that the suburban community to which Peter moved had as many problems with teenagers on drugs as the good neighborhoods in his former city. Crime and safety make up another common realm where people have misconceptions. Some communities often make the evening news with graphic stories and film footage of crimes. Statistically, however, most crimes committed in a given city or town occur in fairly small geographic areas. Local police departments tabulate neighborhood crime rates. If you’re concerned about crime and safety, don’t guess; get the facts by calling your local police department and asking them how to obtain the data. Schools are another hot-button issue. In some areas, people make blanket statements condemning all public schools. They also insist that if you live in such-and-such town or city, you must send your children to private school if you want them to get a good education. The reality, as education experts (and good old-fashioned common sense) suggest, is that you can find good and bad public schools and good and bad private schools. You also need to evaluate if you’re spending too many hours working and commuting just so you can make expensive school payments. If that’s the case, you may not be able to spend adequate time with your children. The best possible teacher for your children is you.
13
14
Part I: The Selling Decision Selling won’t solve the problem(s) Avoiding problems is another human tendency. That’s what Fred and Ethel tried to do. Much to their chagrin, Fred and Ethel discovered that their home had two not-so-visible but, unfortunately, costly-to-fix problems. The new roof they needed was going to cost big bucks, because local ordinances required the removal of several layers of existing roofing material when a new roof was installed. Fred and Ethel also had recently found out that their house contained asbestos, a known carcinogen. Rather than research and deal with these problems, Fred and Ethel decided that the easiest solution was to sell their house and buy another one in a nearby town where they thought they’d be happy. They then attempted to sell their home without disclosing these known defects — a major legal no-no, as we point out in Chapter 8 — but were tripped up by smart buyers who found out about the problems from inspectors they hired to check out the property. Actually, the prospective buyers did Fred and Ethel two big favors: By uncovering the problems early, the buyers saved Fred and Ethel from a costly lawsuit that could easily have resulted if the flaws were discovered after the house was sold. By ultimately deciding to hold onto their home, which they otherwise were content with, Fred and Ethel saved themselves thousands of dollars in selling and buying transaction costs. Those savings more than paid for the cost of a new roof. And Fred and Ethel discovered that, because the asbestos was in good condition and properly contained, it was best left alone.
You can fix some or all the problems When they realized that they couldn’t run from their home’s problems, Fred and Ethel, discussed in the preceding section, discovered how to get those problems fixed. You can address quite a number of possible shortcomings in your home less expensively than buying a new home. If you think that home improvement projects are going to be too expensive, do some rough calculations to determine the cost of selling your current house and then buying another. Remember, you can easily spend 15 percent of the house’s value on all the transaction costs of selling and then buying again. Instead of trading houses, why not spend those transaction dollars on improving the home you currently own? Do you hate the carpeting and paint job? Get new carpets and repaint. If your home is a tad too small, consider adding on a room or two. Just be careful not to turn your home into a castle if all the surrounding houses are shacks. Overimproving your property can be an expensive mistake. By overimproving, we mean that after the improvements to your house, you’ll own the most expensive house on the block, and you’ll have difficulty recouping the cost of the improvements in the form of a higher house sale price.
Chapter 1: Deciding to Sell Some people are seduced by the seeming better attributes of other houses on the market. If your house is small, larger ones seem more appealing. If you don’t like your carpeting, houses that have hardwood floors may attract you. However, as is true of long-term friends or spouses, you know your current home’s defects all too well because you’ve probably lived with them for years. Unless you’re incredibly observant, you surely didn’t know half your home’s faults and shortcomings before you moved in. The same is true of new homes you may be lusting after. Some problems and defects are more easily fixed and more worth fixing than others. When you’re deciding whether to fix problems or move away from them, consider these important issues: What’s the payback? Some home remodeling projects may actually pay for or come close to paying for themselves. We’re not suggesting that you can have the work done for free. However, certain remodeling projects do increase your home’s value by enough to make up for most or even all the cost of the improvement(s). Generally speaking, projects that increase the cosmetic appeal or usability of living space tend to be more financially worthwhile than projects that don’t. For example, consider painting and recarpeting a home versus fixing its foundation. The former projects are visible and, if done well, enhance a home’s value; the latter project doesn’t add to the visible appeal of the home or usability of living space. If, however, you must do foundation repairs or the house will collapse, spend your money on the foundation. If you decide to stay put and renovate or improve your current home, you’re going to need to find a way to pay for all that work. In Chapter 4, we discuss the way to figure out the amount you can afford to spend improving and how to actually finance your improvements. If you head down the renovation path, don’t forget that contracting work often ends up costing more than you (and your contractor) originally expected. How intrusive will the work be? As you surely know, money isn’t everything. Six months into a home remodeling project that moves you out of your bedroom, spreads sawdust all over your kitchen table, and has you wanting to flee the country, the “payback” on the project doesn’t seem so important anymore. In addition to costing more than most parties expect, contracting work almost always takes longer than everyone expects. Ask yourself and others who’ve endured similar projects: How much will this project disrupt my life? Your contract with the contractor should include financial penalties for not finishing on time. Some problems or shortcomings of your current house simply can’t be fixed. If you’re tired of shoveling snow in the winter and dripping sweat in the summer, you’re not going to be able to change your local weather. If crime is indeed a big problem, you yourself aren’t going to be able to cut area crime anytime soon. Moving may be the best solution.
15
16
Part I: The Selling Decision
Reasons to consider selling If you’re in a situation where you really need to sell, as opposed to wanting to sell, by all means put your house on the market. And if you want to sell, and can afford to do so, you should go for it, as well. The following sections offer some solid reasons for selling.
You can afford to trade homes Your desire to sell your current house and buy another one may be driven by a force as frivolous as sheer boredom. But if you can afford to sell and buy again, and you know what you’re getting into, why not? Now, defining afford is important. By afford, we mean that you’ve identified your personal and financial goals and you’ve calculated that the cost of trading houses won’t compromise those goals. Everyone has unique goals, but if you’re like most people, you probably don’t want to spend the rest of your life working full-time. To retire or semi-retire, you’re going to need to save quite a bit of money during your working years. If you haven’t yet crunched any numbers to see where you stand in terms of retirement saving, postpone major real estate decisions until you explore your financial future. In Chapter 2, we walk you through the important retirement planning considerations in selling your house, and in Chapter 3, we show you how to calculate the economics of selling and moving.
You need to move for your job Some people find that at particular points in their lives they need to move to take advantage of a career opportunity. For example, if you want to be involved with technology companies, certain regions of the country offer far greater opportunities than others. When you lack employment, paying bills is difficult, especially the costs involved in home ownership. If you’ve lost your job or your employer demands that you relocate to keep your job, you may feel a real need to move, especially in a sluggish economy. Moving for a better job (or simply for a job) is a fine thing to do. However, some people fool themselves into believing that a higher-paying job or a move to an area with lower housing costs will put them on an easier financial street. As we discuss in Chapter 3, you must consider all the costs of living in a new area versus your current area before deciding that moving to a new community is financially wise. And, although we don’t pretend to be career counselors, we want you to consider that you may be overlooking opportunities right in your own backyard. Just because your employer offers you a better job to get you to relocate doesn’t mean that you can’t bargain for a promotion and stay put
Chapter 1: Deciding to Sell
Patience — not money — solves some problems Some problems may solve themselves if you’re patient and willing to wait things out. For example, Eric (humble coauthor of this book) once lived a block away from a busy California freeway. Although adequate fencing and safety barriers separated the speeding cars on the highway from the neighborhood, the noise was a bit of a nuisance, especially during peak commute hours.
The longer Eric, who was raised in a quiet nonurban environment, lived in the home, the more the noise bugged him. Within several years of having bought the home, however, the problem was solved. Expansion of the freeway forced the state to add sound walls, which greatly dampened the noise and enhanced home values in the area.
geographically. Likewise, during an economic slowdown, if your employer says you must relocate or face downsizing, explore other employment options in your area, especially if you want to stay put.
You’re having (or will have) financial trouble Sometimes, people fall on difficult financial times because of an unexpected event. Check out these two scenarios: After Ryan graduated from college, he landed a good marketing job and seemed financially secure. So he bought a home. After a few years in the home, Ryan discovered that he had a chronic medical problem. Ultimately, Ryan decided to go into a lower-stress job and work part time. As a result, his income significantly decreased while his medical expenses increased. He no longer could afford his home. It made sense for Ryan to sell his house and move into lower-cost housing that better addressed his reduced mobility. When Teri and her husband bought a home, they were both holding down high-paying jobs. Unfortunately, two years later, Teri discovered that her husband had an affair. After much marital counseling and many attempts to get their marriage on a better track, Teri and her husband divorced. Because neither of them alone could afford the costs of the house, Teri and her husband needed to sell. In addition to unexpected events, some people simply live beyond their means and can’t keep their heads above the financial water of large mortgage payments and associated housing costs. Sometimes, people get bogged down with additional consumer debt because they stretched themselves too much when buying their home.
17
18
Part I: The Selling Decision Selling your house and moving to a lower-cost housing option may be just what the financial doctor ordered. On the other hand, if you can bring your spending under control and pay off those consumer debts, maybe you can afford to remain in your present home. Be sure that you’re being honest with yourself and realistic about your ability to accomplish your goals given your continuing housing expenses (see Chapter 2 for more information).
You’re retiring If you decide to call it quits on the full-time working life, you may find yourself with more house than you need, or you may wish to move to a less costly area. Instead of trading up, you may consider trading down. You can free up some of the cash you’ve tied up in your current house and use that money to help finance your retirement by moving to a less expensive home. If you’re otherwise happy with where you’re currently living, don’t think that you must trade down to a less expensive home simply to tap the equity in your current property. As we discuss in Chapter 2, you can tap your home’s equity through other methods, such as taking out a reverse mortgage.
Your house is associated with bad feelings As with other financial decisions, choosing to sell or buy a home isn’t only about money. Human emotions and memories can be just as powerful and just as real factors to consider. If your spouse or child has passed away, you divorced, or your house was burglarized, the property may be a constant source of bad feelings. Although selling your house and moving won’t make your troubles go away, being in a new home in a different area or neighborhood may help you get on with your life and not dwell excessively on your recent unpleasant experiences. Just be sure to temper your emotions with a realistic look at your financial situation.
Knowing the Health of Your Housing Market Your personal financial situation clearly is an important factor in deciding whether and when to sell your house, but the state of your local housing market may also influence your decision. Check out the following sections for the lowdown on the housing market and how it affects your sale.
Chapter 1: Deciding to Sell
Selling in a depressed housing market No one likes to lose money. If you scraped and saved for years for the down payment to buy a home, finding out that your house is worth less than the amount you paid for it can be quite a blow. Between the decline in the market value of your home and the selling costs, you may possibly even lose your entire invested down payment. And you thought the stock market was risky! In the worst cases we’ve seen, some homeowners find themselves upside down, which simply means that the mortgage on the house exceeds the amount for which the house can be sold. In other words, upside-down homeowners literally have to pay money to sell their houses because they’ve lost more than their original down payment. Ouch! When deciding whether to sell in a depressed market, consider the factors discussed in the following sections.
If you still have adequate equity Although your local real estate market may have recently declined, if you’ve owned your house long enough or made a large enough down payment, you still may be able to net a good deal of cash by selling. If you can make enough money to enable yourself to buy another home, we say don’t sweat the fact that your local real estate market may currently be depressed. As long as the sale fits in with your overall financial situation, sell your house and get on with your life! All real estate markets go through up cycles and down cycles. Over the long term, however, housing prices tend to increase. So, if you sell a house or two during a down market, odds are you’ll also sell a house or two during better market conditions. And if you’re staying in the same area or moving to another depressed housing market, you’re simply trading one reduced-price house for another. If you’re moving to a more expensive market or a market currently doing better than the one you’re leaving, be sure that spending more on housing doesn’t compromise your long-term personal and financial goals (see Chapter 2).
If you lack enough money to buy your next home Sometimes, homeowners find themselves in a situation where, if they sell, they won’t have enough money to buy their next home. If you find yourself in such a circumstance, first clarify whether you want or need to sell:
19
20
Part I: The Selling Decision If you want to sell but don’t need to and can avoid selling for a while, we say wait it out. Otherwise, if you sell and then don’t have adequate money to buy your next home, you may find yourself in the unfortunate position of being a renter when the local real estate market turns the corner and starts improving again. So you’ll have sold low and later be forced to buy high. You’ll need to have an even greater down payment to get back into the market, or you’ll be forced to buy a more modest house. If you need to sell, you have a tougher road ahead of you. You must hope that the real estate market where you buy won’t rocket ahead while you’re trying to accumulate a larger down payment. However, you may also want to look into methods for buying a home with a smaller down payment. For example, a benevolent family member may help you out, the person selling you your new home may lend you some money, or you may decide to take out one of the low-down-payment loans that some mortgage lenders offer. If prices do rise at a fast rate, you can either set your sights on a different market or lower your expectations for the kind of home you’re going to buy. If you must move or relocate and don’t want to sell in a depressed market, you can rent out your home until the market turns around. Be sure that you understand the tax consequences of this arrangement, which we cover in detail in Chapter 2. Before becoming a landlord, consider your ability to deal with the hassles that come with the territory. You must also educate yourself on local rent-control ordinances and compare your property’s monthly expenses with the rental income that you’ll collect. (We explain how to calculate the difference between a property’s income and expenses in the sidebar, “Figuring the cash flow on rental property.”) If you’re going to lose money each month, the constant cash drain may handicap your future ability to save, in addition to increasing your total losses on the property.
Selling during a strong market What could be better than selling your house during a time of rising or alreadyelevated home prices? If you can afford the transaction costs of selling your current house and buying another home, and if the costs of the new home fit within your budget and financial goals, go for it. Just be careful of two things: Don’t get greedy and grossly overprice your house. You may end up getting less from the sale than you expected, and the sale is likely to take much longer than if you’d priced the property fairly. If you price your house too high, when you finally drop the price to the right range, you may face lower offers because your house has the stigma of being old on the market. In Chapter 11, we detail how to price your house for a quick sale that gets you top dollar.
Chapter 1: Deciding to Sell If you’re staying in your current strong market or moving to another strong market, be careful about timing the sale of your current house and the purchase of your next one. For example, you probably don’t want to sell and then spend months bidding unsuccessfully on other homes. You may get stuck renting for a while and need to make an additional move; such costs can eat up the cash from your recent sale and interfere with your ability to afford your next home. In Chapter 5, we explain how to time the sale of your house and the subsequent purchase of your new home.
Figuring the cash flow on rental property Cash flow is the difference between the amount of money that a property brings in and the amount you have to pay out for expenses. Some homeowners-turned-rental-property-owners can’t cover all the costs associated with rental property. In the worst cases, such property owners end up in personal bankruptcy from the drain of negative cash flow (that is, expenses exceed income). In other cases, the negative cash flow hampers property owners’ ability to accomplish important financial goals such as saving for retirement or helping with their children’s college expenses. Before you consider becoming a landlord, make some projections about what you expect your property’s monthly income and expenses to be. Income On the income side, determine the amount of rent you’re able to charge: Take a look at what comparable properties currently are renting for in your local market. Check out the classified ads in your local paper(s). Speak with some leasing agents at real estate rental companies. Be sure to allow for some portion (around 5 percent per year) of the time for your property to be vacant — finding good tenants takes time.
Expenses On the expense side, you have your monthly mortgage payment (of which we’re sure that you’re already painfully aware). And, of course, you have property taxes. Because you probably pay them only once or twice yearly, divide the annual amount by 12 to arrive at your monthly property tax bill. You may end up paying some or all your renter’s utility bills, such as garbage, water, or gas. Estimate from your own usage what the monthly tab will be. Expect most utility bills to increase a bit because tenants will probably waste more when you’re picking up the bill. Be sure to ask your insurance company about how your property insurance premium changes if you convert the property into a rental. As is true with your property taxes, divide the annual total by 12 to get a monthly amount. Don’t forget repairs and maintenance. Expect to spend about 1 percent of the property’s value per year on maintenance, repairs, and cleaning. Again, divide by 12 to get a monthly figure. Finding good tenants takes time and promotion. If you choose to list through them, rental brokers normally take one month’s rent as their cut. If you advertise, estimate at least $100 to $200 in advertising expenses, not to mention the cost of your time in showing the property to prospective tenants. You must also plan on running credit checks on prospective tenants. (continued)
21
22
Part I: The Selling Decision (continued)
Estimated cash flow Now, total all the monthly expenses and subtract that number from your estimated monthly income after allowing for some vacancy time. Voilà! You’ve just calculated your property’s cash flow. If you have a negative cash flow, you may actually be close to breaking even when you factor in a rental property tax write-off known as depreciation. You break down the purchase of your property between the building, which is depreciable, and land, which isn’t depreciable. You can make this allocation based on the assessed value for the land and the building or
on a real estate appraisal. Residential property is depreciated over 271⁄2 years at a rate of 3.64 percent of the building value per year. For example, if you buy a residential rental property for $250,000, and $175,000 of that amount is allocated to the building, that allocation means that you can take $6,370 per year as a depreciation tax deduction ($175,000 × .0364). After you’ve crunched all these numbers, if you find that you’re still interested in renting your property, be sure to read Chapter 2, especially the section dealing with the tax consequences of converting your home into a rental property.
Chapter 2
Selling and Your Personal Finances In This Chapter Considering the economics of trading up Grappling with trading down, renting, or taking a reverse mortgage in retirement Understanding tax issues when selling
B
uying a home can seriously shake up your personal finances. But selling your house and then buying another one generally leads to even bigger financial shock waves. If you’re considering the sale of your house, you may think, “No big deal. After all, the sale will pay off my mortgage debt and bring a big chunk of money my way. What do I have to stress over?” In fact, the financial consequences of selling your house can be serious, especially if you’re trading up to a more expensive home. You must be well prepared and alert as you sail through the often-treacherous waters of house selling. Consider this chapter your first mate, helping you make all the best moves you can.
Trading Up Many people who still are in their prime working years and who want to sell their houses and buy others in the same general geographic areas are planning to trade up, which usually means moving into a “better” — and, therefore, more expensive — home. The desire to trade up is only natural; people usually want their next car, their next job, and their next set of living room or bedroom furniture to be better than the last. After all, you work hard for a living; you deserve “better.” A nicer neighborhood, better schools, more rooms, bigger rooms, more luxurious bathrooms, a more spacious kitchen, better shopping nearby, a bigger yard, better parking and storage space — the list of things that can be better in your life is limitless. Your budget, on the other hand, is not.
24
Part I: The Selling Decision Although you may want all these extra features and amenities in the next home that you buy, those extra goodies are going to cost more money — in some cases, much more. So, unless you’ve recently won the lottery or earned a huge windfall from stock options or the like, you’re going to have to prioritize your desires. You can’t have it all — only what fits with your budget and longerterm financial and personal plans.
Examining your housing budget Before you set out to trade in your current house for a “better” one, you need to take a good look at your overall budget and determine how much more, if any, of your monthly spending can go toward housing costs. If you haven’t examined your monthly budget in a while, now is the time to do so — before you set the wheels in motion to trade up. Get out your checkbook register, credit card statements, paycheck stub, most recent year’s tax return, and anything else that documents where you’ve been spending your money during the past six to 12 months. You may also need to do some tracking or estimating of cash purchases that don’t leave a paper trail. Table 2-1 can help you to organize your spending by category.
Table 2-1 Figure Your Spending, Now and After a Home Purchase Item Income Taxes Social Security Federal State and local Housing expenses Mortgage Property taxes Gas/electric/oil Water/garbage Phone Cable TV Furniture/appliances Maintenance/repairs Food and eating Supermarket Restaurants and takeout
Current Monthly Average Spending in Your Current Home ($)
Expected Monthly Average Spending in Your Next Home ($)
_____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________
_____________ _____________
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances
Item Transportation Gasoline Maintenance and repairs State registration fees Tolls and parking Bus or subway fares Appearance Clothing Shoes Jewelry/watches Dry cleaning Haircuts Makeup Other Debt repayments Credit cards and charge cards Auto loans Student loans Other Fun stuff Entertainment (movies, concerts, and so on) Vacation and travel Gifts Hobbies Pets Health club or gym Other Advisors Accountant Attorney Financial advisor Healthcare Physicians and hospitals Drugs Dental and vision Therapy
Current Monthly Average Spending in Your Current Home ($)
Expected Monthly Average Spending in Your Next Home ($)
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ (continued)
25
26
Part I: The Selling Decision Table 2-1 (continued) Item Insurance Homeowners Auto Health Life Disability Educational expenses Courses and tuition Books Supplies Kids Day care Toys Other Charitable donations Other _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________
Current Monthly Average Spending in Your Current Home ($)
Expected Monthly Average Spending in Your Next Home ($)
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
_____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____________
Total spending Amount saved (subtract “Total spending” line from “Income”)
Figuring your expected expenses after trading up Knowing how you spend your money now on housing and other items is only half the picture. You also need to know how much you’ll spend after buying your next home. In Table 2-1, we shaded the Housing expenses category in the “Current” and “Expected” columns for a reason. These expenses probably are going to change the most when you sell your current house and buy a new home. To help you fill in the holes in the expected costs column, check out these areas:
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances Mortgage payment: Unless you’ve been squirreling away extra savings while living in your current house, the total amount you’re borrowing through your mortgage (and, therefore, your monthly mortgage payment) will probably increase if you trade up. By using our handy-dandy mortgage payment calculator in Table 2-2, you can calculate the approximate monthly mortgage payment you’ll face in your new home. To calculate your monthly loan payment, multiply the relevant number from Table 2-2 by the total amount that you’re borrowing, expressed in (that is to say, divided by) thousands of dollars. So, for example, if you intend to borrow $150,000 at 8 percent interest on a 30-year mortgage, you multiply 150 by 7.34 (from Table 2-2) to come up with a monthly payment of $1,101. Property taxes: In most communities, the annual property taxes that you pay on your next home purchase initially are set at a percentage of the property value. To find out the property tax rate in the area where you plan to purchase your new home, simply call the local tax collector, assessor, or other taxing authority (you can locate those phone numbers in the government section of your local phone directory). Don’t base your property tax estimate on the amount that the seller of the home you’re interested in buying is currently paying or on the amount you’re paying on your present house. When you trade up, the taxes on the home may be reassessed upward. Utilities: If you’re trading up, some of your utility bills — such as cable TV — may stay the same, but others may change. Until you have in mind a specific home to buy, you can’t request hard numbers on utility usage. In the interim, make some educated estimates. For example, if you’re planning on moving into a larger home in your area with, say, 30 percent more square footage, you can estimate that your heating and electric bills will increase by about 30 percent. However, if you’re moving from an old, energy-inefficient home into a newer and more efficient one, the new home may not cost you more in utilities even if it’s a bit larger. Furniture: If you buy a larger home, you’ll have more space to fill, so you’re probably going to spend more money on furnishings. Make a reasonable estimate of how much you expect to spend on new furnishings. If and when you actually trade up, remember the amount that you budgeted for new furnishings; some trade-up buyers get carried away with redecorating and decimate their budgets after they move into their new properties. Maintenance: If you’re buying a more expensive home, you’re probably also going to spend more on maintenance, even if the home isn’t a fixerupper. A good way to estimate your annual maintenance costs is to multiply the purchase price of the home by 1 percent (use 1.25 percent of the purchase price for older and more run-down properties).
27
28
Part I: The Selling Decision Federal and state income taxes: If you buy a more expensive home and have larger mortgage payments and property taxes, your income tax bill will probably go down. Why? Mortgage interest and property taxes are deductible expenses on Schedule A of your federal income tax Form 1040 and on most state returns. See the sidebar “Estimating how your taxes may change if you trade up,” later in this chapter. Homeowners insurance: If you buy a more expensive home, your homeowners insurance premiums may increase. In the absence of a specific quote for a property you’re interested in buying, you can estimate that your homeowners insurance costs will increase in proportion to the increased size (square footage) of your home. Because land isn’t insured, ignore the extra land that may come with your next home.
Table 2-2
Mortgage Payment Calculator
Interest Rate (%)
15 Years
30 Years
5
7.91
5.37
51⁄8
7.98
5.45
1
5 ⁄4
8.04
5.53
53⁄8
8.11
5.60
1
5 ⁄2
8.18
5.68
55⁄8
8.24
5.76
3
5 ⁄4
8.31
5.84
57⁄8
8.38
5.92
6
8.44
6.00
61⁄8
8.51
6.08
1
6 ⁄4
8.58
6.16
63⁄8
8.65
6.24
1
6 ⁄2
8.72
6.33
65⁄8
8.78
6.41
3
6 ⁄4
8.85
6.49
67⁄8
8.92
6.57
7
8.99
6.66
71⁄8
9.06
6.74
Term of Mortgage
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances
Interest Rate (%)
Term of Mortgage 15 Years
30 Years
71⁄4
9.13
6.83
3
7 ⁄8
9.20
6.91
71⁄2
9.28
7.00
5
7 ⁄8
9.35
7.08
73⁄4
9.42
7.17
7 ⁄8
9.49
7.26
8
9.56
7.34
1
8 ⁄8
9.63
7.43
81⁄4
9.71
7.52
3
8 ⁄8
9.78
7.61
81⁄2
9.85
7.69
8 ⁄8
9.93
7.78
83⁄4
10.00
7.87
8 ⁄8
10.07
7.96
9
10.15
8.05
1
9 ⁄8
10.22
8.14
91⁄4
10.30
8.23
3
9 ⁄8
10.37
8.32
91⁄2
10.45
8.41
5
9 ⁄8
10.52
8.50
93⁄4
10.60
8.60
9 ⁄8
10.67
8.69
10
10.75
8.78
10 ⁄8
10.83
8.87
101⁄4
10.90
8.97
10 ⁄8
10.98
9.06
101⁄2
11.06
9.15
7
5
7
7
1
3
29
30
Part I: The Selling Decision Some lucky folks can squeeze higher housing costs into their budgets without having to cut spending in other expense categories or fall short of their savings goals. If your budget has that much padding, terrific! But most people need to cut some fat from their budgets to afford spending more on housing. If you hope to someday retire or be able to help pay for a portion of your children’s college costs, you have to be realistic about how much you need to save and how much you can afford to spend on housing and other expenses.
Determining the financial impact on your future goals Before you trade up to a more expensive home, in addition to analyzing how the move affects your current financial picture, you also need to examine how it’s going to affect your future financial goals. One such goal that many people share is to enjoy a comfortable retirement. If you completed Table 2-1 earlier in this chapter, you can see that the additional monthly housing expenses from a trade up put the squeeze on — and can possibly even eliminate — your ability to save money. And, as we explain in the nearby sidebar, “Estimating how your taxes may change if you trade up,” if you end up contributing less to your tax-deductible retirement savings plans, your income taxes will increase. Before you even consider trading up to a more expensive home, do yourself a big favor and make some savings calculations for your retirement and other important financial goals. If you completed the budgeting exercise in Table 2-1 (earlier in this chapter), you have a good idea about how much you’re currently saving from your monthly income and how much you may save if you trade up. Of course, you may discover that you aren’t even saving enough money right now, before trading up, to meet your long-term goals. In this case, trading up to a more expensive home is highly inadvisable.
Exploring the other costs of trading up If you trade up to a more expensive home, your ongoing, monthly housing expenses are sure to increase. But that isn’t all the additional costs that you’ll encounter. Finding a new home to buy and selling your current one requires that you expend dozens, perhaps even hundreds, of hours of your precious free time. And if you hire real estate agents and others to help you with all the transactions, you’re going to spend a good deal of money for their services.
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances And then there’s moving — a stressful, time-consuming ordeal to get all your belongings (and family members!) to your new abode. Unless you have scads of free time and enjoy hauling heavy boxes and furniture, you’re likely to end up spending thousands of dollars paying a moving company to help you. Before you go in search of your next great home, you need to understand all the one-time fees involved in trading up and moving. Otherwise, you may run out of money and be forced to use high-interest consumer credit, or worse. In Chapter 3, we walk you through all the important considerations and calculations so that you don’t have any financial surprises upsetting your proposed move.
Making Retirement Housing Decisions If you’re an older homeowner, your home equity — the difference between the market value of your home and the outstanding mortgage(s) on it — can be one of your largest (if not your largest) assets. Many folks nearing retirement and retirees who own their homes find that their home equity is surprisingly large. Why? First, if all goes well, the value of your property increases over the years. Second, all those years of monthly mortgage payments add up; by the time you’re ready to retire, your mortgage balance should be low or even zero. Your house’s equity can help supplement the cost of your retirement . . . with or without selling. Of course, the obvious option is selling your house and buying or renting something less expensive. The less-obvious option is taking out a reverse mortgage that provides you with income based on your home’s equity without selling your home. In this section, we cover these important options along with important tax and personal issues that you need to weigh before deciding what to do with your home when you retire.
Trading down Perhaps, when you’re in your living room, you hear more noise than you used to notice. Or one day, you just can’t muster the desire to skim the leaves out of the pool that no one swims in anymore. And ever since your daughter went off to college, maybe you get a hollow feeling when you walk past her empty bedroom. You suddenly realize that, now that the kids have moved out of the house, you have more space than you really need or want. Even if you don’t have kids, you may find that, now that you’re no longer working, you don’t need to live within driving distance of the city where you spent your entire life working. You suddenly have the freedom to step out of the rat race and move to a place where life moves a bit more slowly (and costs a bit less).
31
32
Part I: The Selling Decision If you’re like most near or actual retirees, these feelings may also accompany the realization that you don’t have as much money to live on during your retirement as you want. You may be “house rich and cash poor,” or, to put it another way, you have “more house than you need and less cash than you want.” Don’t despair! You’re actually in an enviable position if you have a house with a good deal of equity in it. Now may be the time for you to trade down — sell your current house and either buy a less expensive home or become a renter. For some seniors, trading down is a wise move that can simultaneously meet financial and emotional needs.
Estimating how your taxes may change if you trade up Here’s a shortcut method for figuring the change in your income taxes caused by a higher mortgage payment and property taxes. Multiply the expected increase in your monthly property taxes and mortgage payment by your current federal income tax bracket which you can find at www.irs.gov or the most recent IRS Form 1040 instruction booklet you received. In case you care — and it’s okay if you don’t — why this shortcut yields a pretty darn good estimate for calculating the change in your income taxes, here’s an explanation: The calculation appears to overestimate your income tax savings because it assumes that your entire mortgage is tax-deductible, when in fact only mortgage interest, not the portion of your mortgage payment going to principal repayment, is tax deductible. However, in the early years of your mortgage, the interest portion of the mortgage payment represents more than 90 percent of the total payment. The state income tax savings that the residents of most states enjoy for deductibility of mortgage interest and property taxes is ignored.
If the higher housing expenses that come with trading up put a noose around your ability to save money, your income taxes may increase. If you’re saving money in a tax-deductible retirement savings account, such as an employer-based 401(k) or 403(b) account or selfemployed Keogh or SEP-IRA, your contributions are generally tax-deductible from your taxable income. If higher housing expenses reduce your funding of these tax-sheltered accounts, your federal and state income taxes increase. How much? Multiply your combined federal and state income tax bracket by the amount of the reduction in your retirement account contributions. (Note: You probably won’t be able to estimate the reduction in your monthly retirement savings until you complete Table 2-1.) Two methods may give you a better estimate of the way your income taxes may change with a house purchase. Try plugging in the estimated tax-deductible housing expenses into your most recent federal and state tax returns and see how your tax bill changes. Or you can consult with a tax advisor.
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances
Don’t ignore emotional considerations During your working years, selling your house to move to a “better” one or to relocate to another area for a job can be an invigorating experience that you may even look forward to with pleasure. Sure, moving is a pain in the posterior, but you find some joy in the newness of things.
Ignoring personal considerations is what Henry did. Consider his story:
Retirees may look forward to change as well. But if you’ve lived in a home or a particular area for many years, moving someplace else may be emotionally difficult. Leaving behind happy memories is hard, and some people equate retirement with dying. Retiring is a major life change. Take your time in assessing your options and don’t be rushed into making decisions you’re not ready to make. Be sure that you understand the financial ramifications of a move. At the same time, don’t make the mistake of basing your retirement-housing decision entirely on a calculator, while ignoring your personal needs and emotions.
Henry was quite concerned about the cost of living in the area to which he and his wife, Lucy, would eventually retire. He did a lot of analysis and coerced his wife into moving to a rural area in a part of the country that they’d never visited before. To make a long story short, Lucy ended up disliking the area they moved to. Few cultural activities were available in their new location, and they didn’t find many people they were interested in getting to know. To add insult to injury, the area ended up not being as cheap to live in as they originally thought it would be. (In Chapter 3, we help you assess the real, total cost of living in a different area.) Henry was stubborn about wanting to stay, and he and Lucy fought a lot and eventually divorced.
(Huge) tax perk for house sellers As we discuss in detail in Chapter 16, house sellers can shield a big portion of their house sales profits from taxation. Single taxpayers can avoid capital gains taxation on up to $250,000 and couples filing jointly up $500,000 of profit. As long as you lived in the house as your primary residence for at least two of the previous five years, this tax exclusion is available to you without age restriction, and you can take the exclusion as many times as you want (but no more than once every two years). This law (passed in 1997) is more expansive than the old exclusion rules, which required you to be at least 55 years old. (The old rules allowed you to take an exclusion only once per lifetime, and even then allowed an exclusion of up to only $125,000 in house sales profit from capital gains taxation.)
33
34
Part I: The Selling Decision Presuming that you’re willing to sell your primary residence, the new house sales tax law makes it easier to convert your home equity directly into liquid investments you can live off during retirement. Of course, such a strategy requires you to either trade down or become a renter. Trading to an equal cost or more expensive home won’t free up more of your money (if you’re thinking about simply borrowing more, please see the sidebar, “What about taking out a new mortgage or home equity loan?” later in this chapter).
Renting versus trading down Usually, trading down is financially savvier than becoming a renter. If you’re able to pay for your new home in cash, your housing costs during retirement will be next to nil. The price range that you should consider depends on a couple of factors: How much other money do you have for retirement? If you’re really pinched for money to live on during retirement, you may be willing to buy a considerably less expensive home to free up more money for living expenses. Until you run some retirement projections to see where you stand, however, you won’t know how much or how little you need to carve off your home’s equity. And, as we cover in the next section, you can use a reverse mortgage to tap into your property’s equity while you still live there. What do you want to buy? If your retirement dream is to live on New York’s Upper West Side or near the water in Hawaii, you may not be able to trade down much. However, if living in Manhattan is more your idea of a retirement nightmare than a dream, and you want to scale down and move out to the countryside, you can probably spend much less on your next home. Some people sell their houses and simply rent in retirement. By selling, you free up all the money invested in your house and make it available to live on or do with as you desire. And when you rent, you have more flexibility to move in the future. If you’re considering the sale of your house and becoming a renter in retirement, be aware of these potential drawbacks: Exposure to rental inflation: As a renter, unless you live in a unit protected by local rental-control ordinances, your monthly rental payment is fully exposed to inflation. Today, $1,000 per month in rent may not sound like a mountain of cash, but consider that, with annual increases of only 4 percent annual increases, in 20 years, your rent will mushroom to nearly $2,200 per month. With 6 percent annual rental increases — which can happen if the United States returns to a 1970s-style period of high inflation — that $1,000 monthly rent balloons to more than $3,200. Ouch!
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances
Getting advice (if you need it) Sometimes, you just become overwhelmed with countless financial questions in your life — including whether to sell your home — and you may need someone to help guide and advise you. Hiring an objective, competent, and affordable advisor may be your ticket to better decision-making. If your experience is like that of many who have come before you, finding a good advisor will be a challenge. Most financial planners work in a way that creates conflicts of interest — either because they sell financial products that pay them a commission or because they manage money for ongoing fees. So, for example, if you consider taking some of your savings and investing more in a home by trading up, most planners will rain on your idea. The reason: The home purchase depletes capital that you can invest through them and that provides them with more income. On the other hand, if you’re on the verge of retiring, these same planners may just love your idea of trading down to a less costly home, if doing so frees up cash for you to invest with them. Even if you’re successful in finding a local financial advisor who has nothing to sell you but his or her time and good advice, you must be on guard for another potential problem — inexperience in dealing with the housing issues and decisions you’re confronting. Most financial
advisors spend the bulk of their time making investment recommendations and analyzing retirement plans, not helping people like you decide whether to sell their homes. No matter how overwhelmed you feel by your housing quandaries, no matter how desperately you want outside help, don’t abandon the process of educating yourself. No one knows your overall financial and personal situation better than you do. You’ve obviously demonstrated an interest in educating yourself by reading this book. Keep reading this book and consider others on financial topics of interest to you: Personal Finance For Dummies (Wiley), by one of us — Eric Tyson — can help you to review your overall financial situation. Besides giving you a better grasp of your personal finances, that book walks you through the process of finding and interviewing financial advisors you may consider hiring. If you do end up hiring someone to help analyze your situation, the more educated you are, the more you can evaluate that person’s competence and make efficient use of your advisor’s time and, hence, your money. Always clarify what expertise you’re seeking — be it tax, legal, retirement planning, investment advice, or whatever. And remember that a good advisor’s job is to lay out the facts, discuss the options, and recommend what’s in your best interests.
Obeying your landlord: As a homeowner, you get to call the shots. You can change the interior and exterior of your home as you please. As a renter, you’re largely at the mercy and whims of your landlord. If you’re used to owning your own home and not having to answer to a landlord, adjusting to the realities of tenant life can be difficult. So, if you do sell and return to the ranks of renters, spend as much time inspecting and interviewing your prospective landlord as you do examining the rental unit. Remember that your landlord can sell the building, possibly forcing you to move again — with added expenses.
35
36
Part I: The Selling Decision
Researching reverse mortgages If you’re happy and content with your home but want more money to live on in retirement, a reverse mortgage may be for you. If you’re house rich but cash poor, a reverse mortgage enables you to tap into the equity in your home while you still live in it. However, if you’re like most older homeowners, you’ve worked so hard for many years to eliminate a mortgage and get your darn home “paid for” that the thought of reversing that process and rebuilding the debt owed on your home is troubling. Reverse mortgages are newer loan vehicles that few people understand. And most of today’s reverse mortgage borrowers are low-income, single seniors who’ve run out of other money for living expenses. Thus, it isn’t too surprising that people who don’t fully understand reverse mortgages often have preconceived, mostly negative notions about how they work. Your first reaction may be to say, “I don’t want to be forced out of my home; I could end up owing more than the house is worth.” Rid yourself of those notions. You won’t be forced out of your home and you (or your heirs) won’t end up owing more than your house is worth. Federal law requires that reverse mortgages be non-recourse loans, which simply means that the home’s value is the only asset that can be tapped to pay the reverse mortgage debt balance. In the rare case when a home’s value does drop below the amount owed on the reverse mortgage, the lender must absorb the loss.
Installment sale Some house sellers don’t take their proceeds in one big lump sum. Instead, they set up an installment sale — a plan that spreads out proceeds payments over future years. In addition to delaying your required income tax payments until you receive the future house-sale money (and enabling you to earn interest on that money in the meantime), an installment sale also can lower your income taxes. For example, you may save tax dollars if — because you’re on the verge of retiring — you’re expecting to be in a lower tax bracket in future tax years.
If you’re considering an installment sale, be sure to pick up a good tax advice guidebook and/or consult a competent tax advisor who has experience with such transactions. Because you’re delaying receipt of some of the sale proceeds, you’re risking that the buyer may not pay you everything you’re owed. In addition, the correct planning and reporting of an installment sale for tax purposes can be complicated, especially if the installment sale arrangement is unfamiliar to you.
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances
Protecting your home’s equity from nursing home expenses Ironically, selling your house and renting in retirement has another “benefit.” State governments are getting more aggressive about going after the home equity of people who enter nursing homes, deplete their assets, and then qualify for Medicaid (the state assistance program). In the past, in some states, protecting home equity from nursing home expenditures was possible. This legal protection no longer is available. Congressional legislation passed in the mid1990s mandated that state governments go after the home equity of Medicaid recipients. Although some states have been more aggressive than others about going after Medicaid recipient’s home equity, home equity increasingly is treated as an asset available for nursing home costs, just like stocks, bonds, and mutual funds.
If you want your assets to go to your heirs rather than to your nursing home, start giving your assets to your heirs well in advance (at least five years) of your latter years of retirement when you’re most likely to have more major health problems. Current Medicaid rules include what is called 60-month lookback, which means that, to determine whether you qualify for Medicaid coverage, Medicaid looks at assets that you held for the five years prior to your application for coverage. All assets that you disposed of during that period need to be used to pay for your nursing home expenses before Medicaid kicks in. And, if you’re thinking about not disclosing the assets that you gave away, remember that it’s a criminal offense to lie.
Some reverse mortgages are good, many are mediocre, and some are just plain bad. The best reverse mortgages merit your consideration. A good reverse mortgage enables you to cost-effectively tap your home’s equity and enhance your retirement income. So, if you have bills to pay, want to buy some new carpeting, need to paint your home, or simply feel like eating out and traveling more, a good reverse mortgage can be your salvation.
Reverse mortgage basics So what exactly is a reverse mortgage, and how does it work? Well, as the name suggests, a reverse mortgage reverses the traditional mortgage process. Think back to when you bought your first home. Unless you had generous and affluent relatives, you probably had to scrape together the money for the down payment and seeming never-ending closing costs. And then you were likely saddled with what seemed like a mountain of mortgage debt. Every month, thereafter, you dutifully mailed to the mortgage lender a check for the monthly mortgage payment. In the early years of your mortgage, a major portion of those monthly mortgage payments went to pay interest on
37
38
Part I: The Selling Decision your outstanding loan balance, but a small amount of each of payment went toward lowering the principal, or in other words, reducing the loan balance. (As the years roll by, the loan balance should pay down at a faster and faster rate until, eventually, your mortgage is paid off.) A reverse mortgage reverses that process. When you take out a reverse mortgage, the mortgage lender typically sends you a monthly check. Imagine that! You can spend the check any way your heart desires. And, because the check represents a loan, the payment to you isn’t taxable. As the reverse mortgage lender gives you more payments, you accumulate an outstanding loan balance. You typically don’t have to pay back your reverse mortgage loan until the home is sold (and then the loan and the accrued interest is paid back from the sale proceeds) or, with some reverse mortgage programs, when you move out of the property.
Reverse mortgage payment options The whole point of taking out a reverse mortgage on your home is to receive money that is drawn from the equity you have in your home. How much can you tap? That amount depends mostly on how much your home is worth, how old you are, and the interest and other fees that a given lender charges. The more your home is worth, the older you are, and the lower the interest rate and other fees a lender charges, the more you should realize from a reverse mortgage. You can decide how you want to receive your reverse mortgage money: Monthly: Most people need monthly income to live on. Thus, a commonly selected reverse mortgage payment option is monthly. However, not all monthly payment options are created equal. Some reverse mortgage programs commit to a particular monthly payment for a preset number of years, and other programs make payments as long as you continue living in your home or for life. Not surprisingly, if you select a reverse mortgage program that pays you for the rest of your life, you’re going to receive less monthly, probably a good deal less, than from a program that pays you for a fixed number of years. Line of credit: Rather than receiving a monthly check, you can simply create a line of credit from which you draw money by writing a check, whenever you need income. Because interest doesn’t start accumulating on a loan until you actually borrow money, the advantage of a credit line is that you pay for only what you need and use. If you have fluctuating and irregular needs for additional money, a line of credit may be for you. Because you have to take the initiative to draw on a line of credit, some thrifty seniors have a hard time tapping and spending the money. The size of the line of credit is either set at the time you close on your reverse mortgage loan or may increase over time.
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances
What about taking out a new mortgage or home equity loan? You may be wondering, “Why do I want to get involved with this complicated reverse mortgage business when I could just take out a home equity loan or a new mortgage on my home?” The problem with traditional “nonreverse” mortgage loan options is that you have to begin paying them back soon after taking them out. The following example illustrates the problem: Suppose that you’re the proud owner of a home worth $225,000, and you have no mortgage on the home. You want to stay in the home and have no desire to sell it and move. You speak with some lenders and discover that they’re willing to lend you $100,000 through a 15-year mortgage at 8 percent. Getting $100,000 in your hands right now sounds appealing. However — and this is a big however — you need to begin making payments of $956 per month on your traditional mortgage loan.
Now, if you invested the $100,000 that you borrowed in some high-quality bonds, you’d discover that you may get only about a 7 percent return, which bring in only $583 of monthly income, not nearly enough to cover your monthly mortgage payments. If you invest in stocks and earn the market average return of 10 percent per year, which is by no means guaranteed, that return translates into only $833 per month — still less than the monthly payment required by the mortgage. Now, if you’re thinking that you can simply live on the $100,000 principal to supplement the money from the investment returns, don’t forget that you’re going to have to keep making payments, and the longer you live in the house, the more likely you are to run out of money and begin missing loan payments. If that happens, unlike with a reverse mortgage, the lending institution may foreclose on your loan, and you can lose your property.
Lump sum: The least beneficial type of reverse mortgage is the lump sum option. When you close on this type of reverse mortgage, you receive a check for the entire amount that you were approved to borrow. Lump sum payouts usually only make sense if you have an immediate need for a substantial amount of cash for some purpose, such as wanting to gift money to family or to make a major purchase. Mix and match: Perhaps you need a large chunk of money soon for some purchases you’ve been putting off, but you also want the security of a regular monthly income. You can usually put together combinations of the preceding three programs. Some reverse mortgage lenders even allow you to alter the payment structure as time goes on. Not all reverse mortgage lenders offer all the combinations, so shop around even more if you’re interested in mixing and matching your payment options.
39
40
Part I: The Selling Decision The costs of reverse mortgages Reverse mortgage lenders, of course, aren’t charities; they make money on reverse mortgages by charging an interest rate on the amount borrowed and by collecting other fees. Although many of the costs of a reverse mortgage are similar to those charged on a traditional mortgage loan, some are unique. On a reverse mortgage, you typically see these types of fees: Interest: As with a traditional mortgage, the interest rate on a reverse mortgage can either be fixed or adjustable. Fixed-rate loans offer peace of mind because you know upfront what your loan’s interest rate will be. However, you typically end up paying more interest over the life of the loan for the security of a stable interest rate. With adjustable-rate reverse mortgages, the overall level of market interest rates determines your loan’s future interest rate. If you get an adjustable-rate mortgage and rates significantly increase, your outstanding loan balance increases faster, thus leaving less equity for the day when your home is finally sold. Odds are better, though, that an adjustablerate loan will save you on interest costs over the long run, because interest rates rarely skyrocket and remain elevated. Because you’re taking on additional risks with an adjustable loan, you’ll probably owe less total interest on your reverse mortgage with more equity remaining for you and your heirs after your house is sold. Fixed-rate reverse mortgages make the most sense for seniors who anticipate using their loans over a number of years — preferably seven or more. Fixed-rate loans also help you sleep better at night if you’re the type who frets over fluctuating interest rates. Upfront fees: Most reverse mortgage lenders charge you fees for processing your application, fees for pulling a copy of your credit report, and other fees for originating your loan. Closing costs: Your reverse mortgage lender will want to appraise your home to determine its worth. This appraisal helps determine how much you can borrow on your home. The more your home is worth, the more money a reverse mortgage lender lets you tap from your home’s equity. Other common closing costs include title insurance, local recording fees, and inspections. Insurance costs: When a reverse mortgage lender commits to giving you a reverse mortgage, the institution is taking a risk. If you live much longer than the lender expects, and your home’s future value falls far short of the expected worth, the reverse mortgage lender can actually lose money if the amount of your outstanding loan balance exceeds the value of your home. To reduce the risk, mortgage lenders buy insurance. And guess what? You get to pay for the insurance, either as a yearly fee (sometimes called a risk pooling fee) or as a percentage of your home’s value when you take out your reverse mortgage.
Chapter 2: Selling and Your Personal Finances A portion of your home’s value or future appreciation: Some reverse mortgages include an additional cost. On some loans, this cost is based on a portion of the appreciation in your home’s value from when your reverse mortgage began. On other loans, this added cost is a portion of the value of your home when your reverse mortgage is ultimately paid off from the sale of your home. Understanding and shopping for reverse mortgages takes time and patience. Don’t rush the process. A number of nonprofit counseling agencies, supported through government funding, stand ready to assist you with sorting through the reverse mortgage options in your area. Start with the AARP (202-434-6044; www.aarp.org/revmort). At the state level, check with the Department of Aging; at the local level, check with the Area Agency on Aging (call the Eldercare Locator Service at 800-677-1116 for the agency nearest you). We also encourage you to pick up a copy of the latest edition of Mortgages For Dummies (which we also co-wrote) for its wealth of useful material about all types of mortgages including reverse mortgages.
Tax Facts Sellers and Landlords Ought to Know You can exclude from taxation a large amount of profits on the sale of a house: up to $250,000 for single taxpayers and $500,000 for couples filing jointly. Conditions are relatively lax: The seller must have used the property as his or her principal residence for at least two of the previous five years. The exclusion is allowed as many times as a taxpayer sells a principal residence but no more than once every two years. If you’re considering renting your home, even for just a short time, after you move out of it and before you sell it, tread carefully! After you’ve converted your house into rental property, you can’t avoid taxation on the profits from that property simply by purchasing another primary residence. See Chapter 18 for more details. We don’t mean to frighten you out of turning your house into a rental property. You don’t lose all your tax breaks; you get different ones. If you decide to turn a property into a rental, and then later sell it, you can roll over your capital gain into another “like kind” investment real estate property. Currently, the IRS broadly defines what a “like kind” property is. They allow you, for example, to exchange undeveloped land for a multi-unit rental building. Just remember that the IRS draws a sharp line between a primary residence and a rental property, and they won’t let you roll profits over that line.
41
42
Part I: The Selling Decision The rules for rolling over a gain from one rental property to another (called a 1031 or Starker exchange) are strict. To begin with, you’re allowed little time to complete the rollover — only six months — and you must also identify a replacement property within 45 days of the sale of the first property. You aren’t allowed to handle the proceeds: They must pass through an escrow account. Because of the complexity of the transaction, please do yourself a favor and find an attorney and/or tax advisor who can guide you through the process and ensure that you do it right. Before you consider converting your home into a rental property, in addition to understanding the tax issues that we just discussed, also weigh the following: How do you feel about being a landlord? Managing a rental property takes time, patience, and knowledge of local rent-control laws. Some tenants are a pain, and premises occasionally need repairs. You can hire a property manager, but this service costs money, and finding a good one can be a challenge. What about wear and tear? If you’ve gone to great lengths to make your house immaculate, realize that renters aren’t going to treat your home with the same loving care that you gave it. Although you can protect your interests somewhat by securing from your tenants a large security deposit (at least one month’s rent), you can’t expect them to pay for the inevitable and gradual wear and tear. For documentation purposes, you may also videotape the interior of the rental, including the condition of floors, walls, and so on. Beware, though; you may find that, at the end of the lease, your tenants disagree with you over what you think is unreasonable wear and tear. What’s the cash flow? Tally up all the monthly property expenses that you anticipate and compare that amount with the expected rental income. If you’ve recently bought your property or have little equity in it, you may be unable turn a profit. The worst-case scenario is that the additional monthly cash drain cramps your budget and causes you to accumulate consumer debt or underfund your tax-deductible retirement accounts. See Chapter 18 for more information about selling rental property.
Chapter 3
Exploring the Economics of Selling In This Chapter Estimating how much cash you can clear from selling your house Understanding the realities and costs of relocating
A
s Forrest Gump would’ve said if he’d been a real estate agent, “House selling is like a box of chocolates . . . you never know what you’re gonna get.” You never know how much your house is really worth until you reach an agreement with a prospective buyer. And even after you decide to accept an offer, you never know what surprise costs may crop up before your deal actually closes. We don’t mean to introduce uncertainty here. Although it’s an inexact science, there’s no reason you can’t reasonably estimate your expected proceeds of sale. This chapter can show you how. If money isn’t a constraint for you and you can comfortably make the move that you’re proposing, feel free to skip this chapter. Spend the free time reflecting on how fortunate you are!
Estimating Proceeds of Sale You may need to get a certain amount of money from the sale of your house, or at least know before you can close on a deal how much you’ll receive. Take the time to understand the particular probable proceeds of sale under the following scenarios:
44
Part I: The Selling Decision You’re strapped for cash because you want to buy a more expensive home. You need to know before you sell if you’ll have enough money to complete your next purchase. If you don’t know this amount, the worstcase scenario is that the sale of your current house doesn’t leave you enough money to buy your next one. Although you probably won’t end up homeless, you may end up renting for a while and having to make an extra move, or having to scrounge around at the last minute for money. You’re trading down because you need more money for retirement. Perhaps you want to receive a certain amount of money from your house sale to afford a particular retirement standard of living. If you’re not realistic about how much cash you’ll net from the sale, you may end up wasting a great deal of time and money on a house sale that yields less cash than you need or expect. You’re relocating, in part, because of finances. If you have a choice about taking a job in some other part of the country, you may be tempted to relocate if you think that you’ll be more comfortable financially. However, if you’re simply assuming or guessing that you’ll be better off in the new area, you may be wrong. You need to gather and review some facts before you move. Note: Throughout this discussion of estimating house sale proceeds, we assume that you don’t have an employer who’s willing to pay for some of your house selling and moving costs. If you’re relocating because of a new job, by all means negotiate to have your new employer pay for some or even all the expenses related to your house sale. You’ll have that much more money to plow into your next home.
Estimated sale price Clearly, the price at which you can sell your house is the biggest factor in determining how much money you’ll be able to put into your pocket from selling your house. The estimated sale price, unfortunately, is also the hardest number to pin down. You shouldn’t allow your needs to dictate the price at which you list your house for sale (see Chapter 10). Prospective buyers of your house don’t care about your needs, wants, or desires — such as, “I need $250,000 from the sale of my house to retire.” Your house’s asking price should be based on the house’s worth — which sometimes may not be to your liking. Your house’s worth is best determined by examining the recent sale prices of comparable houses. A good real estate agent can put together a comparable market analysis for you. If you’re selling your house yourself, we explain in Chapter 10 how to prepare a comparable market analysis yourself.
Chapter 3: Exploring the Economics of Selling Estimated house sale price
$ ____________________________
– Closing costs
– $ ____________________________
– Mortgage payoff
– $ ____________________________
– Moving costs
– $ ____________________________
= Estimated proceeds from house sale
= $ ____________________________
Closing costs Selling a house costs a good deal of money. Generally, expect to pay about 7 to 10 percent of the house’s sale price in various closing costs for which you, as the seller, may be responsible. A closing cost is an expense that you incur in the sale of your house and that reduces the total money you receive from the sale. The typical closing costs include Real estate agent commissions: If you’re selling your house through real estate agents, they typically take a commission of 5 to 6 percent of the selling price. As we discuss in Chapter 6, you may choose to work with agents. If you do work with agents, the commission percentage you pay is negotiable and may be somewhat lower on higher-priced properties. Repairs: Unless you’ve taken really good care of your house over the years, or you’re selling in a strong local real estate market, you can also expect to shell out some money for corrective work. For example, in some communities, you may need a pest-control and dry-rot clearance to sell your property. Inspections of your property may uncover buildingcode violations, such as faulty electrical wiring or plumbing problems, that you must repair. You need to consider having your house inspected before listing it for sale (see Chapter 7 for more info). Transfer tax: Taxes, taxes, taxes — the three sure things in life. Some cities and towns whack you with a transfer tax when you sell your house. Such taxes typically are based on the sale price of the property. Check with your friendly local real estate agent or your local tax collector’s office to get an idea about your community’s transfer tax rates. Prorated property taxes: Depending on the date you close on the sale of your house, you may owe money to bring your property tax payments up-to-date. In most towns and cities, unless you’re delinquent with your payments, you probably won’t owe more than six months of property taxes. In fact, because many communities require that you pay your property taxes in advance of the period that the payments cover, you may find that you’re owed a refund of taxes from the buyer of your property.
45
46
Part I: The Selling Decision Because you can’t predict the date your house will sell, estimating the amount that you may owe in property taxes at closing is a tad difficult. You do know, however, whether you have to pay your taxes well in advance. If your local community has such a pay-in-advance payment system or you wait until the last minute to pay your taxes or make delinquent payments, you may want to budget three months or so of property taxes as a closing cost. Possible credits: If you’ve paid ahead on your property taxes, you may be getting a “refund” from the buyer of your house. You may also get a refund from your homeowners insurance company for the unused portion of your homeowners policy. And, finally, if you put less than 20 percent down when you originally purchased the house, your lender may have required that you pay a portion of your property taxes and homeowners insurance in advance each month and then held these payments in an impound account. (An impound account refers to money held in a trust account established by the lender which is used to pay property taxes and insurance premiums on your behalf when they’re due). The lender refunds the unused funds from your impound account money when the sale is complete. Do the necessary research for the above expenses if you want to more closely estimate expenditures on closing costs. Otherwise, for a safe, ballpark estimate, assume that 10 percent of the expected sale price of your house will go toward paying closing costs. Estimated house sale price
$ ____________________________
– Closing costs
– $ ____________________________
– Mortgage payoff
– $ ____________________________
– Moving costs
– $ ____________________________
= Estimated proceeds from house sale
= $ ____________________________
Mortgage payoff For most people, the need to payoff an outstanding mortgage (or two) greatly depletes the expected proceeds from a house sale. Figuring out your mortgage payoff balance usually is a snap. Simply whip out the most recent monthly statement you’ve received from your mortgage lender to find out the amount you still owe as of the date of the statement. You may need to make a couple of adjustments to this amount to make it more accurate.
Chapter 3: Exploring the Economics of Selling First, on most mortgages, your outstanding balance should decline each month as you make additional payments. Because you can’t sell your house immediately, your balance should decline between now and the date that you actually close on the sale. If your loan has negative amortization (the monthly payment falls short of paying the monthly interest that’s accruing), your loan balance may be growing rather than shrinking. Subtract from your outstanding balance the sum of the principal payments you’ll be making between now and the proposed sale date. For example, if your most recent monthly mortgage statement shows that $200 of your payment went toward principal reduction, and you expect to hold onto the house for at least six more months, you can subtract $1,200 from your current outstanding balance. Add to your balance any penalties that your mortgage lender may charge you for prepaying. Of course, if you bought Home Buying For Dummies (Wiley) when you bought your home, you avoided mortgages with a prepayment penalty. If you have any doubts at all about whether your mortgage has a prepayment penalty, find out. You can either check your loan agreement (issued to you at the time you originally closed on your mortgage) or ask your mortgage lender (check your statement for a phone number). Write down the information you’re given, the name of the person you spoke with, and the date. You may also ask that person to send you something in writing to confirm the information you were provided by phone. You can try negotiating with the lender to reduce or remove the prepayment penalty. A good bank may offer to cut you a deal if they realize that you may do more of your future banking with them if they keep you happy. Your lender may also waive or greatly reduce a mortgage prepayment penalty if the buyers of your house use your lender to finance their purchase. If it’s a large prepayment penalty, you can ask that the buyers obtain their mortgage from your lender, presuming the lender has competitive loan terms. Most mortgage lenders assess a nominal fee for sending you a payoff statement detailing, to the penny, the cost of paying off your loan balance on a specific day, as well as for other paperwork fees. These fees usually don’t amount to more than $100 or so, but if you want to know exactly how much to expect, simply call your lender. If the fee seems excessive or you’re willing to haggle, ask the lender to reduce these fees; some will comply with your request.
47
48
Part I: The Selling Decision Estimated house sale price
$ ____________________________
– Closing costs
– $ ____________________________
– Mortgage payoff
– $ ____________________________
– Moving costs
– $ ____________________________
= Estimated proceeds from house sale
= $ ____________________________
Moving expenses Over the years, you’ve probably accumulated more stuff than you realize. Whether you’ve piled knickknacks in your closets, filled your attic with boxes of gadgets, lined your garage with old bikes, or decorated every room with the finest furnishings, you’re going to have to pack up all your stuff and have someone haul it away. Most people don’t have the equipment, experience, and muscle power to move all their stuff themselves. If you’re like most folks on the move, you call a moving service. As with any other service business, prices and quality of service vary. The farther you move and the more weight you’re moving, the more the costs escalate. Move the contents of a typical one-bedroom house about one-third of the way across the United States, and you can easily spend several thousands of dollars. Move the same items all the way across the country, and the cost may double. Moving the contents of a spacious four-bedroom house halfway across the country can run you about $15,000 to $20,000. Be sure to research moving costs, especially if you’re selling a big house filled with furniture and other personal possessions or if you’re moving a great distance. Get bids from several reputable movers and check references. Price and quality of service vary greatly. Estimated house sale price
$ ____________________________
– Closing costs
– $ ____________________________
– Mortgage payoff
– $ ____________________________
– Moving costs
– $ ____________________________
= Estimated proceeds from house sale
= $ ____________________________
Chapter 3: Exploring the Economics of Selling
Putting it all together After you understand the important elements of determining your proceeds from the expected sale of your house, you can work through the numbers to figure how much moola you hope to have coming your way. Estimated house sale price
$ ____________________________
– Closing costs
– $ ____________________________
– Mortgage payoff
– $ ____________________________
– Moving costs
– $ ____________________________
= Estimated proceeds from house sale
= $ ____________________________
Now that you know what proceeds you can expect from your house sale, what can and should you do with this information? As we discuss earlier in the chapter, this estimate is necessary if you’re at all cash constrained in buying your next home or if you’re selling to finance some important financial goal, such as retirement. (Be sure to review Chapter 2 to see if you can really afford to trade up and to make sure that you understand the important financial and tax issues involved in selling your home, particularly in retirement.)
Tax deductions for moving costs If you’re moving to a new job location, you can deduct from your taxable income many of the incurred moving costs that aren’t paid for by your employer. These deductions include the cost of moving your household goods and personal effects and the cost of transporting yourself and your family from your old homestead to your new one. However, you can’t deduct the costs of house-hunting trips, transaction fees for selling and buying the old and new residences, temporary living expenses, or the cost of meals during relocation travel. To qualify for the IRS moving tax deduction (which is claimed on IRS Form 3903), you must pass two tests. First, the distance between your former house and your new job must be at least 50 miles greater than the distance between your
former house and your old job. For example, suppose that you currently work 20 miles from your house. You get transferred to a new office that is 71 miles from your house. Because the difference between the two distances is greater than or equal to 50 miles, you pass the first test. You must also pass the second test. During the 12-month period following your relocation, you must work at your new job on a full-time basis for at least 39 weeks. If you get fired after 38 weeks, you can’t take any deductions. These rules are even stricter for the selfemployed. Refer to a good tax book (we’re partial to Taxes For Dummies by Eric Tyson, Peggy Munro, and David Silverman) to get more information on these deduction details.
49
50
Part I: The Selling Decision
Assessing the Financial Feasibility of a Move In the event that you’re staying in the same neighborhood or community, estimating the cost of living in another home should be fairly easy. See Chapter 2 to help you organize and analyze potential changes in your budget. If, on the other hand, you’re relocating to a new area, don’t make the common mistake of neglecting to consider possible changes in your overall expenses. Many people simply assume that their finances “will work out” while others fall prey to wishful thinking: “Because housing costs are lower in the area we’re moving to, I’m sure we’ll be financially better off.” We wish life was that simple, but unfortunately it isn’t.
Researching living costs and employment opportunities Before you commit to listing your house for sale and actually selling it, understand what your cost of living will be in the new area (check out Chapter 2). Your property taxes, utilities, food, commuting costs, and many other important items in your personal budget will change when you move into a new home in a different area. If you don’t consider the cost of living in the new location, you may end up facing unpleasant surprises. That’s what happened to Joanne and Andy: Weary of working long hours to afford the seemingly high cost of living in Northern California, the couple viewed Andy’s Midwest job offer as their ticket to financial freedom. Although the pay was about what Andy was receiving in his present job, Joanne and Andy figured they’d be on easy street, given how much cheaper home prices were in the town where they expected to live. So Andy happily accepted his new job offer, and he and Joanne quit their current jobs. They sold their house and decided to rent for a while after they moved so that they could better assess exactly where they wanted to live. After moving, Joanne and Andy spent the next several months in their new Midwest community looking for a home. Although they’d thought that housing was far less costly in their new area, they discovered that replicating what they had in Northern California — a community with parks, cultural amenities, and a good school system — cost more than they expected.
Chapter 3: Exploring the Economics of Selling And then they discovered that some of the other things that they spend money on each month were even more costly in their new area. For example, Joanne and Andy found that their first winter’s heating bill eclipsed the total annual utility bill that they paid out West! Food was more expensive, as were property taxes. And Joanne had great difficulty replicating her previous job because her profession was less in demand in the new area. When all was said and done, Joanne and Andy’s new home in the Midwest put them in the same financial boat as they were in out in California. Now, if Joanne and Andy had moved for nonfinancial reasons, then the fact that they didn’t end up being better off financially may not have mattered. But, except for the seemingly high cost of living, Joanne and Andy had liked their location in Northern California. As they found, however, high home prices are only a piece of the local financial puzzle. You must also consider the other items in your budget and figure out how your income and expenses may change if you move. Five years after their move, Joanne and Andy moved back to the San Francisco Bay Area. They made some adjustments to their spending so that they could accomplish their goals and live in the community of their choice.
Using a bridge loan to take equity out of a current house before a sale Some people put themselves in a housing pickle that causes them to incur additional houseselling costs. The pickle results from buying a new home before their current one is sold. Most people can’t afford to own two homes at the same time; they need to get the cash out of their current home to buy a new one. Not surprisingly, the friendly lenders invented a way for people to get around this little inconvenience. It’s called a bridge loan, and if you qualify, this loan enables you to borrow against the equity in your current property, giving you the cash to buy your new home before your current house sells. Bridge loans are a bad idea for a number of reasons. First, if you get stuck holding both houses
for many months, you face a continuing cash drain from making two mortgage payments, two property tax payments, and two insurance payments, as well as maintaining two houses. Second, the interest rate and fees on a bridge loan are quite high compared with a conventional mortgage. Finally, if housing prices head south, you may end up in deep financial trouble if you’re unable to sell your current house for enough money to pay the outstanding loans against it. As we advise in Chapter 5, you should sell your current house before buying a new one.
51
52
Part I: The Selling Decision Numerous resources are available for estimating the cost of living in a particular area: The American Chamber of Commerce Research Association (ACCRA) publishes a quarterly cost-of-living index (online at ACCRA’s Cost of Living Index Web site www.coli.org or by calling ACCRA at 703-522-4980). They charge $7.95 for a two-city comparison. The U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics calculates the cost of living for major metropolitan areas, and you can access this free information online at www.bls.gov/cpi/home.htm. Homefair.com offers a free salary calculator that easily enables you to compare salaries between two different towns or cities. Visit the Web address www.homefair.com and click “The Salary Calculator” link on the home page. Cost-of-living indexes and surveys should be used only as a starting point and as general guidelines. They shouldn’t replace a thorough budgetary breakdown that addresses the specifics of your situation. Sure, the indexes may tell you that Louisville generally is cheaper than Boston, but they ignore the fact that, for example, you never needed a car in Boston, because you could walk to work and take the subway almost everywhere else. Your job in Louisville may require you to buy a car, auto insurance, and fuel for commuting, in addition to more airplane trips to visit your family in the Northeast.
Avoiding relocation traps As Joanne and Andy found in the preceding section, you shouldn’t act first (move and buy a new home) and ask questions later (see the section “Researching living costs and employment opportunities” earlier in this chapter). Don’t base such a critical decision on assumptions and wishful thinking. Here are the common pitfalls that ensnare those making relocation decisions so you can avoid falling into them yourself: Equating lower housing costs with a lower cost of living: This was one of the big mistakes Joanne and Andy made. The cost of housing probably accounts for no more than a third of your spending. So if you don’t consider the other goods and services you spend money on, you neglect the lion’s share of your budget. Research all the major costs of living in an area before you commit to relocating to the area.
Chapter 3: Exploring the Economics of Selling Not doing an apples-to-apples comparison of housing costs: Again, Joanne and Andy made this mistake. To a certain extent, you get what you pay for. Housing costs are lower in communities with fewer amenities, inferior schools, poor commuting access, and so on. So if you’re looking at relocating to an area with much lower housing costs, you need to be skeptical instead of thinking that you’ve found the deal of the century. Ask yourself, “What does that area lack that my current area offers?” Ignoring the overall opportunities in the local job market: Your next job is just that — your next job. You’re probably not going to stay in this job for decades on end. So, when you’re contemplating moving to a new area, think bigger than just this “next” job. Unless you enjoy the cost and hassle of relocating frequently, consider your chances for finding your next couple of jobs in a given area. Although it’s impossible for some people to know what they’re going to want to do several years down the road, considering the job market for more than your current job can save you from relocating more than you need to or leaving behind an area you otherwise like. If you’re married, you also need to consider your spouse’s job prospects in your new community. In the case of Joanne and Andy, they learned the hard way about the pitfalls of focusing on only one person’s job. Taking the place where you live for granted: All too often you appreciate what you liked about a place only after you move away. Maybe, for example, you’re tired of the urban congestion and dream of the relaxed pace of a more rural community. After you make the move, however, you really start missing going to the theater and eating out at cosmopolitan restaurants. Pretty soon, you find yourself spending a great deal of money to escape the “boondocks,” traveling back into the city to see musicals and eat Indian food.
53
54
Part I: The Selling Decision
Chapter 4
Confronting Financing Issues In This Chapter Analyzing mortgage options when you trade up Understanding the ins and outs of lending money to buyers
“F
inancing issues?” you’re wondering to yourself. “What does that have to do with selling my house? I’ll worry about financing my next home when the time comes.” It would be nice if sellers could ignore financing issues . . . one less thing to worry about. Unfortunately, sellers aren’t off the hook on that one. You definitely should pay attention to financing issues when trading up. If you sell your house to buy another and take on too much debt and a risky mortgage, you can end up strapped for cash or, worse, losing your new home and the equity in it. The more that you borrow, the more money you can save through the wise shopping and selection of the best mortgage for your situation. You may decide to improve your current home and will face the challenge of paying for those expenditures. Or perhaps the prospective buyers of your current house want you to lend them money to make their purchase a reality. If you agree, you have to think about financing issues but from the other side of the fence — that of the lender. Lend money to a non-creditworthy buyer who can’t afford to make mortgage payments and you may have to play Mr. or Ms. Banker with the unpleasant duty of foreclosing your old property. This chapter helps you to deal with these important borrowing considerations.
Financing Decisions When Trading Up You need to examine your overall financial situation before you commit to trading up to a more costly property. Make that assessment now if you haven’t already done so (see Chapters 1 and 2 for more info). This section highlights a few important decisions you need to make.
56
Part I: The Selling Decision
Choosing your mortgage Because this book is about selling a house rather than buying one, we won’t cover in detail how to choose a mortgage when you’re buying a home. However, if you’re thinking about trading up, you’ll ultimately buy as well as sell, so we highlight the important considerations in selecting a mortgage. Keep these issues in mind as you begin thinking about selling your house, particularly if you’re stretching your finances for the trade up. Because you already own a home, this section may just be a refresher course. But the following are some brief definitions for the major types of mortgage options: Fixed-rate loan: As the name implies, this loan is one with a permanent interest rate that never changes. You take out the loan at a certain interest rate, and that rate is locked in for the life of the loan, which, in most cases, is a term of 15 or 30 years. Obviously, with an interest rate that is constant, your monthly mortgage payment is also constant. Adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM): The interest rate of an ARM varies over time, typically adjusting every 6 to 12 months, but sometimes as frequently as every month. These adjustments reflect the fluctuations in the interest rates of the overall economy. The monthly mortgage payment usually changes as often as the loan’s interest rate does. Hybrid loans: Mortgage lenders weren’t content to leave you with only two options, so they did some grafting and came up with another one, sometimes called intermediate ARMs. A hybrid loan starts out like a fixed-rate loan and then, after a certain number of years — three, five, seven, or even ten years — converts into an ARM, usually adjusting every 6 to 12 months thereafter. A newer twist on this type of mortgage, which we generally don’t recommend, is interest-only loans that have lowered payments in their early years because you’re only paying interest. When you begin paying back principal, the mortgage payment jumps significantly. When choosing among the three mortgage options, ask yourself two questions: How able and willing are you to take on financial risk? Getting an ARM is a bit of a gamble. Although its initial interest rate usually is lower than that of a fixed-rate loan, if market interest rates go up, so does your monthly mortgage payment. If your cash flow doesn’t have much breathing room, you may get into trouble. Before you take out an ARM, check out its periodic adjustment cap (the amount that the loan’s interest rate can change at each adjustment) and life of loan adjustment cap (the highest interest rate allowed on the loan) so that you know how fast your
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues monthly payments can increase and how high the allowable interest rate and your payment can go. If the ARM’s maximum monthly payment would break your budget, don’t get the loan. How long do you plan to keep the mortgage? If you don’t intend to stick around in your new home for longer than five to seven years, then a hybrid loan makes more sense. Because the initial interest rates are lower than the rates on fixed loans, a hybrid loan definitely saves you money on interest charges in the early years of your mortgage. If, however, you intend to keep your mortgage more than seven years, you may be better off with a fixed loan. If, after analyzing your financial situation as we discuss in Chapter 2, you see that you’re stretching yourself financially, but you nevertheless want to trade up, be extra careful in going with an ARM. Although a fixed-rate loan starts off at a higher interest rate than an adjustable-rate loan, at least you know that your payment on a fixed-rate loan can’t increase. If an ARM’s potentially higher future payments would destroy your budget, stick with a fixed-rate loan.
Financing improvements After reading our discussion in the earlier chapters of this book, you may decide to stay in your current home because you can improve it and make it more to your liking. Instead of having to go through all the time, trouble, and expense of selling your home and buying another, you can “trade up” by upgrading your current property. Although improving your current home may enable you to get the home you want at less total cost than selling and buying another, you still need to make sure that you can afford the costs of the improvements. The more you spend on housing, the less you have for other important future expenditures, such as retirement, college educations for your little gremlins, and vacations. Just be careful not to overimprove your home. For example, suppose that you want to add a second story and put in a pool. If those additions give you the most expensive house on the block, you may have a problem recouping the renovation costs when you attempt to sell your house. If that situation is okay with you or you can rationalize by saying, “Heck, it’ll cost me big bucks to sell this house and buy another,” then improve to your heart’s content. You have several options for financing the work to be done on your home. If you can afford it, the simplest route is to pay cash for the improvements. Unless you have some investment in mind that you think can provide a high enough rate of return to justify borrowing to finance the project, you’re better off using your available cash.
57
58
Part I: The Selling Decision Here’s why. Suppose that you have the choice of using available cash or borrowing money at 7 percent interest to finance your home improvements. If you borrow to pay for the project and keep your cash to invest, you’re going to lose out financially if you don’t earn at least 7 percent, before state and federal income taxes, on your investments. (Note that, although your mortgage interest may be tax-deductible, your investment profits are generally taxable.) For example, if you invest your cash in a boring old bank savings account that pays just 3 percent interest, you’d have been better off using your cash to pay for your home improvements instead of borrowing. Unless you invest in growth investments, such as stocks or rental real estate, you’re unlikely to earn an average of more than 7 percent annually over the long-term. “Safer” investments, such as Treasury bonds or certificates of deposit (CDs), simply won’t provide returns that high. What if you don’t have tens of thousands of dollars burning a hole in your wallet, crying out for you to spend them on remodeling your kitchen? If you have equity in your home — that is, the market value of your home exceeds the mortgage balance you owe on it — you may be able to borrow against that equity. Generally, you can most cost effectively borrow on your home’s equity up to the point where the total mortgage(s) outstanding on the property is equal to or less than 80 percent of the market value of your home. For example, suppose that your home is currently worth $250,000 (as determined by a lender’s appraisal), and you have an outstanding mortgage of $150,000. As long as your financial situation enables you to qualify, you can borrow up to a total of $200,000 (that is, 80 percent of $250,000) — $50,000 more than you currently owe — under reasonably favorable terms. If you borrow more than 80 percent of the current market value of your home, you generally must pay a higher interest rate and more upfront loan fees. You may also get stuck paying private mortgage insurance, which protects the lender financially in the event you default. You can tap the equity in your home in two ways. You can pay off your current mortgage and get a new first mortgage for enough additional money to cover the remodeling job, or you can take out a separate home-equity loan. The best option for you depends mainly on how good the deal is on your current mortgage compared to the current level of mortgage interest rates. For example, suppose that your existing fixed-rate mortgage was taken out at an interest rate of 6 percent and fixed-rate mortgages currently are going for 7 percent. You probably don’t want to give up your existing loan because the interest rate is lower than current loan rates. Under this scenario, taking out a home-equity loan (second mortgage) probably makes more sense. (Note: Because home-equity loans are riskier from a lender’s perspective — they make
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues the lender a secondary creditor to the first mortgage lender — the interest rate on a home-equity loan generally is a little higher than the rate on a comparable first mortgage.) Now reverse the scenario. Suppose that you took your fixed-rate mortgage out years ago at a higher interest rate, say 8 percent. Now, you can obtain a loan at a lower rate, 7 percent. In this case, you may as well go ahead and refinance to benefit from the current, lower interest rates. One final consideration in choosing between a home-equity loan and a refinanced mortgage: If you don’t need to borrow much money to pay for the improvements and you think that you can pay the money back within a few years, you may want to go with a home-equity loan. The reason: Refinancing a large first mortgage is probably going to run you much more in upfront fees than taking out a smaller home-equity loan.
The Trials and Tribulations of Seller Financing In an episode of the popular television series Seinfeld, Newman, a mailman and a buffoon, appeals a speeding ticket in court. Newman’s defense: He was rushing to the aid of his friend, Kramer, who was on the verge of killing himself because he had failed to achieve his lifelong dream of becoming a banker. In that episode, Newman loses the case not only because he’s a terrible liar, but also because Kramer’s failed career aspirations seemed, well, so preposterous! Have you ever dreamed of being a banker? Unless you’re in the business, probably not. As a child, your career aspirations were probably more along the lines of being an astronaut, athlete, doctor, or police officer. However, when selling your house, you may need to know a bit about lending and financing. This section has you covered.
Asking yourself why you’d ever want to be a lender So, why all this talk about bankers and why in the world would you want to be one? You may want to take on the role to lend money to the buyer of your house, that’s why. And what would possibly motivate you to do such a thing? Usually one of the following:
59
60
Part I: The Selling Decision Desperation: Some houses are difficult to sell because of major warts and some won’t sell because they’re overpriced. A high interest rate on your money: We can see those dollar signs in your eyes. You can earn a higher rate of interest lending money to the buyer of your house than you can investing through bank accounts and most bonds. If your local real estate market is slow or you’re having difficulty selling your property, you may sweeten the appeal of your house by offering to be the mortgage lender. Prospective buyers of your property may realize that they can save thousands of dollars in loan application fees and points (upfront interest). After all, you’re not a big bank with costly branches to operate and countless personnel to pay. By offering seller financing, you broaden the pool of potential buyers for your house. Traditional mortgage lenders are subject to many rules and regulations that force them to deny quite a number of mortgage applications. But, as we discuss in upcoming sections, making loans to borrowers rejected by banks can be risky business. So you absolutely, positively must thoroughly review a prospective borrower’s creditworthiness before you agree to lend him money as a condition of selling him your house. We explain how to make this evaluation later in this chapter in “Finding creditworthy buyers.” In addition to helping sell a house, some sellers are motivated to play banker and lend money to the buyer of their property because the mortgage usually carries an attractive interest rate, at least when compared to the typical returns on conservative investments, such as bank savings accounts (currently 3 percent) or CDs and Treasury bonds (currently around 5 percent). If you have money to invest but investing in stocks terrifies you, lending money to the buyer of your house may interest you. You may be able to earn 8+ percent in interest by lending your money to a borrower. Agreeing to offer a mortgage to the buyer of your house can clearly be advantageous; the loan may help sell your house faster and at a higher price and, at the same time, provide a better return on your investment dollars. However, nothing that sounds this good ever comes without some real risks. If you lend your money to someone who falls on difficult financial times or simply chooses to stop making mortgage payments, you can lose money, perhaps even a great deal of money. And you may have to take legal action and foreclose if the buyer defaults on the loan. And if all that isn’t bad enough, you’ll again be the owner of a house that you thought you’d sold, with all the associated expenses of home ownership, including higher loan payments for the buyer’s new first mortgage and, most likely, a higher property tax bill. Foreclosed homes also tend to deteriorate under the care of the prior owners so you can also expect fix-up costs.
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues
The dangers of relying on faith and hope Ron was interested in selling his house, and Mark, an old college buddy, happened to be renting nearby and was looking to buy. Ron and Mark thought it was a real estate match made in heaven. “I can sell without paying those exorbitant real estate agent commissions,” said Ron. “I can buy a house now without having a large down payment,” said Mark. Mark, in fact, had only 5 percent of the purchase price for his down payment. Ron had another friend, an attorney, draw up a loan agreement that didn’t require any down payment. Ron didn’t want his good friend, Mark, to deplete what little cash he had, so Ron agreed to a no-money-down loan. Within in a few short weeks, Mark moved into his new home and Ron moved out of the area. Mark mailed his monthly mortgage checks to Ron and all seemed well. Two years after the purchase, the proverbial horse manure hit the fan. Mark, who was already up to his eyeballs in consumer debt
(credit cards and an auto loan), lost his job. Mark was already a couple of months behind in his mortgage payments, and he obviously didn’t start catching up after he lost his job. Ron, being a good friend, was extremely understanding, but his patience evaporated when Mark stopped calling him and filed for bankruptcy. To make a long, ugly story short, in addition to losing what appeared to be a good friend, Ron also lost a good deal of money. Home prices had dropped about 20 percent since Mark bought the house, which Ron foreclosed and became the proud owner of once again. What are the lessons of this story? Never make a loan without thoroughly and completely reviewing the financial situation of the borrower. Neither assume, nor guess, nor act on faith, nor hope. Be careful in doing business with friends. If the deal goes sour, you can lose more than money.
Deciding if seller financing is for you Most house sellers aren’t in a position, financially or otherwise, to provide financing to the buyer of their home. So, before you waste too much of your time reviewing and reading the rest of this chapter, make sure that you’re in a position to seriously consider providing financing. To consider making a loan against the house that you’re selling, you should be able to answer yes to all the following questions: Will you be able to purchase the next home you desire without the cash you’re lending to the buyer of your current house? This issue keeps most sellers out of the financing business. If you need all the cash that you have as a down payment to qualify for the mortgage on your next home, seller financing is out of the question. And, if you can lend
61
62
Part I: The Selling Decision some of your money to the buyer of your house, don’t make the loan if you then need to borrow more yourself for your next home purchase. Even if you can charge the buyer of your current house a percent or two more in interest on the money you lend than you’ll pay for the money you’re borrowing to buy your next home, such an arrangement generally isn’t worth the hassle and financial pitfalls. Do you desire income-oriented investments? Understand that mortgages are a type of bond. When you invest in a bond, your return comes from interest if you hold the bond to maturity. Unlike investing in stocks, real estate, or a small business, you have no potential for making money from appreciation when investing in bonds held to maturity. So if you’re looking for growth as well as income, seller financing isn’t for you. Are you in a low enough tax bracket to benefit from the taxable interest income on the mortgage loan? If you’re in the federal 28 percent or higher tax bracket, consider investing in tax-free bonds, such as municipal bonds, and not mortgages, the interest on which is fully taxable. The reason: The interest income from municipal bonds is free of federal taxation and sometimes state income taxation. By contrast, the interest income from a mortgage is taxable as ordinary income at the federal and state levels. Are you willing to do the necessary and time-consuming homework to determine the creditworthiness of a borrower? As we discuss in the next section, unless you secure a large down payment (25 percent or more of the value of the property) from the buyer of your house, you need to be darn sure that the borrower can pay you back. So if you’re looking for a simple, non-time-consuming investment, look elsewhere. Try mutual funds. Can you weather a default? Even if you do all the homework we suggest in this chapter before agreeing to lend money, the buyer/borrower still can default on you just as he can on a banker. Bad and unforeseen events can happen to borrowers. Accept this reality. Ask yourself if you can financially tolerate going without the borrower’s payments for many months during the costly and time-consuming process of foreclosure.
Finding creditworthy buyers After you determine that you have spare cash to invest or lend, and you’re looking for taxable interest income, the hard work comes: putting on your detective hat and assessing the merits of lending your money to a prospective buyer who’s more than likely a complete stranger.
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues
Doing second mortgages A prospective buyer of your house may ask you to provide 10 percent of the financing in the form of a second mortgage while a traditional mortgage lender provides an 80 percent first mortgage and the buyer makes a down payment of 10 percent of the purchase price of your house. A second mortgage means that if the borrower defaults, you’re second in line behind the first mortgage lender who has first rights to the value of the property after foreclosure. You’re entitled to the amount left over. Consider such a loan if, and only if, you do all the homework we suggest in this chapter to check out the creditworthiness of a borrower, and if you can accept the risk that you can lose your entire investment (the loan) if property prices
fall and the borrower defaults. Be sure that you also meet the criteria we laid out earlier in this chapter in the section entitled, “Deciding if seller financing is for you.” As an alternative to making a risky second mortgage loan yourself, some lenders make loans when the borrower makes less than a 20-percent down payment. Such low-down-payment loans keep you, the house seller, out of the financing business and enable you to sell your house to a prospective buyer with a 10-percent or less down payment. Tell your cash-short prospective home buyers to ask mortgage lenders and brokers about low-down-payment loans.
So how do you, someone who isn’t a mortgage lender by profession, become a savvy credit analyst? Perhaps you’ve heard the expression, “Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.” Well, do what bankers do when deciding whether to lend someone money. The first thing that a lender does in her evaluation of the creditworthiness of a prospective borrower is to bury him in paperwork. As a lender, you absolutely, positively must gather financial facts from the borrower. You can’t accurately assess the risk of lending money to a buyer, even one whom you’ve known personally for a number of years, without going through the information-gathering exercise in this section. Only agree to make a loan to the buyer of the property when he’s able to make at least a 20 percent down payment. Bankers normally require a down payment of that size for good reason: If the borrower defaults and the banker is forced to hold a foreclosure sale, the down payment provides a cushion against the expenses of sale and possible losses in property value if real estate prices have declined since the loan was made. If the buyer falls on hard times at the same time real estate prices go into the tank, you may find yourself in the unfortunate position of repossessing a house that’s worth less than the amount the borrower owes on it. So, what documents should you request and what information should you look for? We’re glad you asked; we tackle that topic in the following sections.
63
64
Part I: The Selling Decision The loan application The best way we know to get data from a prospective borrower is to have him complete the Uniform Residential Loan Application (see Figure 4-1), also known as Form 1003, which mortgage lenders almost always use. You can obtain one of these forms through mortgage lenders or mortgage brokers. (If, because no profit is in it for them, they’re unwilling to send you a form for your personal use, you can pose as a prospective borrower and have them mail you their standard application package. You can also find the forms online for free at www.efanniemae.com/sf/formsdocs/forms/1003.jsp. Be sure to review the sample real estate purchase contract (for California) in Appendix A. Pay particular attention to Paragraph 2, which covers financing terms and conditions. Even if you don’t live in California, the provisions and precautions in this excellent contract are useful. After you receive the completed application from the borrower, be sure that it’s completely filled out. Ask for explanations for unanswered questions. The following list explains how to evaluate the information in various parts of the form: Type of mortgage and terms of loan: Asking the borrower to fill in these sections isn’t vital; the legal loan document that you both sign later contains information on the terms of the loan — the loan amount, interest rate, length of the loan, and the loan type (fixed-rate or adjustable-rate). Later in this chapter, we walk you through the steps for setting the terms of your loan and having a loan agreement prepared. Property information and purpose of loan: You can also skip most of this section of the application. The address of the property and its legal description (the block and lot number that come from the title report) are specified in the loan agreement. Although you know that the borrower is obviously buying, you may not know whether he’s going to use the property as a primary or secondary residence or as an investment property. If the buyer intends to rent the property for investment purposes, your loan is riskier, and you should charge a higher interest rate than you’d charge an “owner-occupied” buyer (see “Deciding what to charge” later in this chapter). Verify the source of the buyer’s down payment and closing costs to ensure that this money isn’t yet another loan that may handicap the buyer’s ability to repay the money that you’re lending him. The down payment and closing costs should come from the buyer’s personal savings. Ask to see the last several months of the buyer’s bank and investment account statements to verify that the funds have been in the accounts during that time and didn’t arrive there recently as a loan, for example, from a relative.
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues
Figure 4-1: The first page of the Uniform Residential Loan Application.
Borrower information: In this section, the borrower tells you about himself/herself, or themselves, with regard to educational background and housing history. More schooling typically translates into greater job stability for a borrower.
65
66
Part I: The Selling Decision If the borrower hasn’t lived in his most recent housing situation for at least two years, be sure that he also lists two prior residences. If the borrower was renting in his recent housing situation(s), request a letter from the buyer’s landlord to verify that rent was paid on time. Alternatively, ask for both sides of canceled checks or checking account statements covering the most recent 12-month period evidencing timely rental payments. If the person moved frequently in recent years, check with more than the most recent landlord. Borrowers who’ve had trouble paying rent on time may well have trouble making regular mortgage payments. Ask for explanations of any red flags you find. Employment information: Even more important than a borrower’s recent housing record is the employment record. Here, you’re again looking for stability as well as an adequate income to make housing payments. If the borrower hasn’t been in the most recent position for at least two years, ask the person to list prior employment to cover the past two years. (Note: The borrower actually lists the monthly income from the current job in the next section of the application.) Monthly income and housing expense projections: In this important section, the borrower details monthly employment income as well as income from bank, brokerage, and mutual fund investments. In addition to income from bank accounts, stocks, bonds, or mutual funds, a borrower may have income from real estate rental properties. For most people, obviously, employment provides the lion’s share of their income. The buyer’s expected monthly housing expenses (which include the mortgage payment, property taxes, and insurance) should be compared against (divided by) the borrower’s gross (before-tax) monthly income. Most mortgage lenders require that a homebuyer’s monthly expenses do not exceed about 33 percent of the homebuyer’s monthly income; we think that’s a good ratio for you to work with as well. However, like a good banker, you don’t want to be rigid. If someone’s proposed monthly housing expenses come in at 34 percent or 35 percent of her monthly income and the borrower has a good job, large down payment, solid references, and so on, then you may decide to go ahead and make the loan, especially if the deal gets your house sold. Assets and liabilities: The borrower should also tell you about her personal assets and liabilities. The mortgage application form divides the buyer’s assets between those that are liquid and therefore available for a down payment or closing costs (for example, savings and money market account balances outside retirement accounts), and those that aren’t so liquid (retirement account investments or real estate).
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues In the liabilities section, the borrower should detail any and all outstanding loans or debts. Be wary of lending to someone who carries a great deal of high-interest consumer debt (such as credit cards or auto loans). If the borrower has the cash available to pay off consumer debts before closing, have her pay those balances. Details of transaction: The purpose of this section is for you and the borrower to make sure that the borrower has enough money to close the purchase. The first part of this section tallies the cost of the house, including closing costs. Subtract the expected loan amount from this total. The result is how much money the borrower needs to come up with to close the purchase. Declarations: In this section, the borrower should disclose any past financial or legal problems: foreclosures, bankruptcies, and so on. If the borrower answers any of these questions in the affirmative, ask for a detailed written explanation.
Documentation, documentation, documentation If you borrow from a lender, the staff asks that you provide a raft of financial documents. If you’re the lender, you need to ask for the pile of papers, too. You may rightfully wonder why you need more paperwork after the buyer completes a detailed loan application. Unfortunately, some people lie. Even though you may think that you have the most financially stable, honest, and creditworthy buyers nibbling on your “house for sale” fishing line, don’t start reeling them in yet. You need to get the additional paperwork to prove and substantiate the borrower’s financial status. Pay stubs, tax returns, and bank and investment-account statements document the borrower’s income and assets. Just because someone tells you on an application form that he’s earning $5,000 per month doesn’t prove that he really is. When verifying the information supplied on the mortgage application, ask the prospective borrower for the following documents: Federal income tax returns and W-2s for the past two years Original pay stubs for the past month or two (if the borrower is selfemployed, request a year-to-date income statement and balance sheet) Award letter and copy of the most recent check if the borrower receives pension, Social Security, or disability income Past three months of account statements for money to be used for down payment, as well as copies of all other investment accounts (including retirement accounts)
67
68
Part I: The Selling Decision Most recent statement for all outstanding loans Divorce or separation papers if the borrower pays or receives alimony or child support You also should obtain, at the borrower’s expense, a copy of his or her credit report(s) to check credit history and to ensure that you’re aware of all outstanding debts. Check your local yellow pages under “Credit Reporting Agencies” for such providers. The larger consumer credit reporting agencies include Experian, Trans Union, and Equifax. Even when you request and receive all this documentation, some buyers still can falsify information, which is committing perjury and fraud. For example, some people, particularly those who are self-employed, may make up phony income tax returns with inflated incomes.
Borrower problems As you may know from your own personal experience, some people don’t have perfect financial and credit histories. In some cases, a prospective borrower may have enough problems for you to reject the application. In other situations, however, the problems may be minor, and can be overcome by taking some simple steps and precautions. Here are common problems likely to crop up with prospective borrowers, and our best advice on how to deal with each situation: Income appears too low to support monthly housing costs: The best way to protect your interests if you’re considering lending to someone who’s stretching (in terms of monthly income) to afford your house is to ask for a larger down payment. As we discuss in the next section, you can charge a higher rate of interest for lending to someone who’s a greater credit risk. Another strategy is having the borrower get a cosigner, such as a parent. Past credit problems: Just because someone has nicks on her credit report doesn’t mean that you should immediately reject the loan application. Credit reporting agencies and creditors who report information to the agencies sometimes make mistakes. Someone who has a small number of infrequent late payments shouldn’t be as big a concern as someone who has reneged on a loan. Ask the borrower for a detailed explanation of any problems you see on the report and use your common sense to determine whether that person is simply human or irresponsible with credit. In the latter case, you may suggest that the borrower enlist a cosigner.
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues Outstanding consumer debt: If the borrower has the cash available to pay off the debt, have him or her do so as a condition of making the loan. If the borrower lacks the cash to pay off consumer debt and lacks a 20-percent down payment, you’re probably better off not making the loan, unless the buyer’s income provides a great deal of breathing room. If you’re on the fence, consider having the borrower get a cosigner.
Deciding what to charge After determining that a buyer is creditworthy, you can get down to the brass tacks of setting the terms — interest rate and fees — on the mortgage. As with collecting the financial data on a borrower, you don’t need to reinvent the wheel. Because agreeing to terms and administering an adjustable-rate loan are complicated, you’re far more likely to make a fixed-rate mortgage. Call several local lenders to find out the rates they’re charging for the size and type loan that you’re contemplating (for example, 15- or 30-year fixed-rate mortgage, first or second mortgage, owner-occupied or rental property). Be sure to ask about all the fees — application, appraisal, credit report, points, and so on. Although you may not charge all these same fees, you nevertheless need to understand what the competition is charging. Some states have usury laws that forbid unregulated lenders (that is, private individuals like you) to charge loan origination fees, prepayment penalties, and so on. These laws also put a ceiling on mortgage interest rates that unregulated lenders can charge. You should consult a local, competent real estate lawyer about local usury laws. All else being equal, you should charge a higher interest rate for jumbo loans (loans in excess of $417,000 for a single-family dwelling as of 2007 ), longerterm loans, loans with less than 20 percent as a down payment, rental property loans, and second mortgages. If the borrower is in good financial health and can easily qualify to borrow from a traditional lender, offer better terms than the commercial competition. You may decide to charge the same interest rate but not upfront fees. Most buyers are short on cash, so a reduction in closing costs usually is well received. Besides, unless the buyer sells or refinances within a few years, a mortgage’s ongoing interest rate is the greatest determinant of how much you make anyway. Charge a premium to borrowers to whom you’re willing to lend but who are unable to get a good loan — or any loan — from traditional lenders. Remember, you need to be compensated for the extra risk you’re taking. You may add as
69
70
Part I: The Selling Decision
Getting permission to request tax and financial documents and to verify employment As an extra precaution in verifying the authenticity of a borrower’s income tax return, have the borrower complete and sign IRS Form 4506 (Request for Copy of Tax Return). This measure enables you to request and obtain, directly from the IRS, a copy of the actual tax return(s) the borrower filed with the IRS. To verify bank and other investment account balances, as well as current employment, mortgage lenders usually have borrowers sign a simple one-page permission form authorizing them to contact organizations that can confirm the borrower’s financial information. Copies of statements can be falsified and so can pay stubs. And, even if a prospective borrower
produces a recent pay stub, that doesn’t mean that he’s still employed. If you want to maximize your chances of making a successful and profitable loan, get authorization to verify account balances and employment. On the other hand, if the borrower is making a substantial down payment (20 percent or more) and you otherwise feel confident in his ability to repay the loan that you’re extending, you may simply rely on copies the borrower provides for you. The figure shows a sample form that you can use to obtain the borrower’s permission for you to request account balances and verify employment.
much as 1 percent or 2 percent to the ongoing interest rate on the loan and charge fees comparable to a lender. Be absolutely sure about the reasons why the borrower got turned down for a loan from a traditional lender and make certain that you’re comfortable with taking on a risk that an experienced mortgage lender wouldn’t.
Chapter 4: Confronting Financing Issues
Protecting yourself legally Unless you’ve made mortgage loans before, you may not have a clue as to how to go about drawing up a loan agreement, so hire a real estate attorney to draw one up for you. Expect the cost to be several hundred dollars — that amount is money well spent. See Chapter 7 for how to find a good real estate attorney. One final piece of advice: If you sell the house and make an owner-occupied loan to the buyer, you may afterward want to ask for proof that the borrower is living in the property rather than renting it out. You can ask for utility and other household bills to see if the bills are in the buyer’s name. Or you may just stop by and knock on the front door of your old house to see who’s living there.
71
72
Part I: The Selling Decision
Part II
Tactical Considerations
I
In this part . . .
f you’ve decided to part company with your humble abode, this part is where you tackle some challenging questions: Should you sell your current house before or after you buy your next home? When during the year is the best time to sell your house? Should you sell your house yourself or use a real estate agent? How do you go about assembling an all-star team of professionals to help you sell your house? Last, but not least, we explain the all-important listing contract you negotiate and sign if you hire a real estate broker.
Chapter 5
Timing Is Everything In This Chapter Knowing how to time the sale of your house Figuring out when to purchase your new home Closing both transactions simultaneously
T
homas Edison, one of our country’s foremost inventors, was often called a genius. He modestly said that genius was 1 percent inspiration and 99 percent perspiration. He should know. It took him years of hard work to invent the phonograph. And Edison tested more than 4,000 different filaments before discovering the one he ultimately used in the first practical electric light bulb. Insight helps, but there’s no substitute for hard work and planning. You don’t have to be a genius to get top dollar for your house when you sell it. Nor do you have to be lucky, although a little luck here and there never hurts. To paraphrase Edison, lucky sales are 1 percent good fortune and 99 percent planning and perspiration.
If you follow the right steps before you put your house on the market, good fortune may come your way throughout the transaction. You can control the selling process instead of reacting to it on a crisis-by-crisis basis. You can create your own luck. This chapter shows you how to make time your best pal.
Timing the Sale of Your House Time is your most precious gift. When it’s gone, you can never get it back. Some people spend their time wisely; others foolishly fritter it away. Depending on how well or how poorly you use it, time can either be an ally or a terrible enemy during the sale.
Part II: Tactical Considerations In most communities, choosing the date that you put your house on the market is an important decision. Certain periods of each year are predictably advantageous for sellers. Others are just as predictably less than stellar. Real estate marketing activity isn’t flat throughout the year. No matter where you live in the United States, the real estate marketing calendar generally has two distinct peaks and valleys created by ebbs and flows of activity in your local real estate market (see Figure 5-1). The sales peaks are higher and longer in good years, and the valleys are deeper and longer in bad years, but the marketing calendar’s relentless rhythm never changes. These seasonal cycles are heartless. They don’t care about birth, death, divorce, job loss, or any other life changes that force you to sell. You can’t alter the rise and fall of market cycles any more than you can stop the tides. You can, however, use the predictability of these cycles to your advantage. This section helps you identify when the best times are to put your house on the market and which are the worst.
March 1st
Memorial Day
The week before Thanksgiving
Labor Day High
1st peak
Marketing Activity
Summer doldrums Death Valley
Figure 5-1: A real estate marketing calendar usually has predictable peaks and valleys in housing sales activity.
2nd peak
Low
76
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
Chapter 5: Timing Is Everything
First peak season: Spring flowers and For Sale signs bloom Calendar years begin January 1, but real estate years don’t. Depending where you live, the longer and stronger of two annual peak seasons begins somewhere between late January and early March. If you live in a temperate area, such as Florida or California, the market kicks into gear a little sooner. If you’re still digging out from under ten feet of snow on March 1, your market may take a little longer to heat up. Weather aside, most folks don’t bound out of bed on New Year’s Day to buy a house. They need several weeks to adjust to the daily grind after that happy whirl of holiday parties and vacations. The buy-now, pay-later monster also rears its ugly head; people need time to recover from the trauma of paying all their holiday bills. As a result, many January buyers are extremely price conscious. February through May normally is the most active selling time for residential real estate. Families with children want to get their purchase or sale out of the way by late spring so moving (which typically occurs 30 to 60 days after the ink dries on the contract of sale) won’t disrupt the kids’ schooling for the next academic year. Other people buy or sell early in the year for tax purposes or to avoid interference with their summer vacations. The annual outpouring of new listings pulls buyers out of the woodwork. Sellers are drawn into the market by all the buying activity. The first peak season is usually the best time to put your house on the market. High sale prices result from spirited buyer competition. Because more buyers are in the market now than at any other time of the year, your best chance of getting a fast, top-dollar sale is during the first season. If you intend to buy another home after yours is sold, this time period offers the best selection of homes to purchase.
First valley: Summer doldrums Memorial Day usually marks the beginning of the first valley. Sales activity usually slows during June, July, and August. People who bought or sold in the spring move in the summer. Buyers, sellers, and agents often take summer vacations, which reduces market activity. Many folks spend their weekends having fun in the sun instead of looking at houses. Who wants to be cooped up inside on a sumptuous summer day?
77
78
Part II: Tactical Considerations Houses ordinarily take somewhat longer to sell in the summer because of a lower level of buyer activity. Unless you have to sell now (or if property values are declining), wait until the fall to put your house on the market. You’re likely to get a higher price after people return from vacation. If you’re selling your house to buy another one, keep in mind that summer is your first opportunity to go bargain shopping. Summer is a good time to find motivated sellers who bought a new home and must sell their old one fast before the ownership expenses of two properties put them in the poorhouse. Less property is available to choose from in the summer than in the spring, but plenty is still on the market.
Second peak season: Autumn leaves and houses of every color Labor Day usually starts the second peak season. This peak normally rolls through September, October, and into November. Don’t let the beautiful autumn leaves fool you, however. Just as fall brings a chill to the air, an icy edge of desperation develops in the second season for some sellers. People who sell during late autumn tend to be strongly motivated. Some bought new homes in the spring before selling their old ones. Now they’re slashing their asking prices — finally getting realistic after wasting months marketing overpriced turkeys. Others are calendar-year taxpayers who sold houses earlier in the year and want to buy their new home before December 31. Why? So they can pay taxdeductible expenses (such as the loan origination fee, mortgage interest, and property taxes) prior to the end of the year to reduce the impact of federal and state income tax. Either way, these folks are under pressure to sell. If you’re a bit of a gambler, the second peak season may be the most rewarding time to sell. Given that you correctly apply the pricing techniques we describe in Chapters 10 and 11, your house should sell quickly and profitably. Unless prices are rapidly increasing in your area, wait until activity slows in mid-November and then buy your next home at a discount price. You get the best of both worlds — “sell high and buy low.” Deciding to sell during the second peak season can be a risky gambit. If you inadvertently overprice your house, it won’t sell. If you need to sell, carefully monitor buyer response to your property. Be prepared to drop your asking price as soon as you identify the danger signs (noted in Chapter 11). Don’t wait until Thanksgiving to reduce your price. You may end up attempting to sell your house during the dreaded dead season (see the next section).
Chapter 5: Timing Is Everything Another problem with waiting until the second valley in the real estate marketing calendar to sell your house and buy your next home is that you’ll probably have a very small selection of houses to choose from. What good is a fantastically low price on a house you hate?
“Never try to catch a falling safe” “Never try to catch a falling safe” is a common expression that describes the crushing financial burden of folks who compound their losses because they refuse to accept the reality of falling house prices in a declining market. One of those safes smashed into Carlos and Jody, who bought a new home before selling their old one. Their tale began one Sunday about six months after prices peaked in one of San Francisco’s real estate booms. A Victorian house they’d always admired had just come on the market. They decided to attend the open house and have a peek. The Victorian had high ceilings, great architectural details, and a gourmet kitchen. The master bedroom contained a working fireplace, and the extra bedroom would make a perfect home office. It was love at first peek. “Can you believe our luck, Carlos? It’s a steal at $895,000. They’re practically giving it away. If we don’t buy it today, someone else will.” “I like it, too, Jody. But how can we buy it? Our money is tied up in our house.” “Don’t worry. Our house will sell fast. It’s worth enough for us to afford this one. We’ll get a long close of escrow so we have plenty of time to sell our house. What can go wrong?” Fortified by those comforting thoughts, they made a fullasking-price offer, which the sellers accepted. Jody and Carlos then spent three weeks selecting an agent and spiffing up their house before putting it on the market. They asked $799,500, a
price wishfully based on what they needed to net from the sale to buy their dream home. Carlos and Jody were underwhelmed with offers. After five frustrating weeks with not even a nibble, they cut their asking price to $749,500 and pulled money out of their old house with a home equity loan to increase the deposit on their dream home. That “long” escrow was quickly nearing an end. Jody and Carlos had a few showings after the price cut, but no offers. They finally got another home equity loan to close escrow. To their dismay, they’d inadvertently joined the elite ranks of people who own two homes. Their agent advised them to cut their asking price to $699,500 to prove that they were serious about selling. At that price, they wouldn’t clear enough from the sale to pay off the mortgage and home equity loans, but they had no alternative. They now had two mortgage payments, two insurance payments, two property tax payments, and two utility bills each month. They unhappily lowered the asking price and covered the shortfall by selling some bonds that they’d been saving for their kids’ college expenses. (That swooshing sound you hear is a falling safe.) Knowing that the longer they kept the house, the more bonds they’d ultimately have to sell to make ends meet, Jody and Carlos sold their house for $675,000 six weeks after their final price reduction. This financial debacle wouldn’t have happened if Jody and Carlos had used the techniques described in this chapter.
79
80
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Death Valley: Real estate activity hibernates until spring The second peak season usually drops dead a week or two before Thanksgiving. With the exception of a few, mostly desperate, sellers and bargain-hunting or relocating buyers who stay in the market until the bitter end of December, residential real estate sales activity ordinarily slows significantly by midNovember. Folks stop buying property and start buying gifts. Would-be sellers take their houses off the market while their kids are out of school and their guests are visiting for the holidays. Ski slopes and sunny beaches beckon. This real estate Death Valley is generally the worst time of year to sell a house. Even the brilliant pricing techniques in this book may not be able to save you from getting your financial bones picked clean by bargain-hunting vultures if you’re forced to sell at this time of the year. The weather is miserable, and very few buyers are in the market. Time will show you no mercy if you wait until this point to get realistic about pricing your house to sell. Don’t put your house on the market during Death Valley days unless you have absolutely no other alternative.
The Seller’s Quandary: Timing the Purchase of Your Home So which comes first, selling your house before buying a new one, or buying first and then selling? Neither course of action is risk free. The adverse consequences of buying a new home before selling your present house, however, can be far more dire. At worst, buying your dream house before selling your present house may put you in the poorhouse. If you read the sad tale of Carlos and Jody in the “Never try to catch a falling safe” sidebar, you may think that selling first is the only correct answer. Believe it or not, you can make a compelling case for either course of action: Selling before you buy eliminates financial risk. When you sell first, you know precisely how much money you have from your sale to put toward your next home. No sleepless nights worrying about how you’ll come up with the cash you need for a down payment on your new home or how much longer you’ll have to make mortgage, property tax, and insurance payments on two houses. Your fiscal future is clear.
Chapter 5: Timing Is Everything Selling first, however, introduces uncertainties and problems. If you sell first, you may be forced out of your old house before you have somewhere else to go. Where will you live? Where will your kids go to school? Where will you store your grand piano and your bowling-ball collection if you’re forced to rent an apartment while looking for another home? Do you really want to move twice? What if you can’t find a home you like as much as the one you just sold? Putting your life on hold indefinitely while searching for a new home is emotionally draining and insomnia-producing. Given a choice between either selling your present house first or buying your next home first, we strongly recommend that you sell your present house before purchasing a new home. Even in good real estate markets, sales frequently drag on much longer than you expect. Selling in a weak market usually compounds the problem. Homeowners tend to overestimate their house’s resale value and underestimate the length of the selling process — a fiscally deadly one-two punch.
Consolidating Your Sale and Purchase Suppose you don’t want to sell your house first and then buy a new one. Nor do you wish to buy a new home before selling the old one. What then? You can use a third option to sell your old house and buy your dream home without terror, chaos, pain, or privation. Your best alternative is to consolidate the sale and purchase into a seamless whole. The following sections describe how.
Determine your house’s current value The ultimate success or failure of your transaction depends on accurately determining your house’s present fair market value. Don’t kid yourself. This isn’t a place for wishful thinking. Overpricing is bad in any real estate market — in a weak market, overpricing is a sure prescription for disaster. You must be realistic when pricing your house, or the sale of your present property and the purchase of your new home may flounder. In a nutshell, you can either pay to have your house appraised or get a written opinion of its fair market value (called a comparable market analysis) from several real estate agents who fervently want to represent you during your sale. Chapter 10 covers everything you need to know about establishing your house’s value.
81
82
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Check your buying power Buying power is a function of the amount of cash you put down on your new home and the size of the mortgage you get. Both numbers are easy to figure out. Here’s how: Calculate your cash position by subtracting the probable expenses of sale from your house’s estimated resale value. Chapter 3 goes into probable expenses of sale, such as mortgage payoffs, corrective work credits, real estate agent’s commissions, and property tax prorations. We also cover relocation traps, such as higher housing costs associated with buying a more expensive home than the one you own now. You see how to figure your proceeds of sale before putting your house on the market. Have a lender evaluate your creditworthiness. Find out the size of the mortgage you can get based on current interest rates, your income, and the probable down payment you can make on a new home if your present house sells at its estimated resale value. If you’re nearly ready to sell your current house and buy another, now is a perfect time to get prequalified or, better yet, preapproved for a loan. Read Chapter 14 to see why preapproval can give you a negotiating advantage. Lenders can’t tell you how much money you can afford to borrow — just how much money they’re willing to loan you based on their assessment of your ability to repay the mortgage. Lenders don’t know or care about your other financial goals and objectives, such as providing for your retirement or socking away money to help your kids through college. We, however, care a great deal about your financial well-being. That’s why we devote Chapter 2 to helping you determine how the next home you buy fits into your overall financial picture.
Familiarize yourself with the market Harry S. Truman, our country’s 33rd president, was a renowned skeptic. He was fond of saying, “I’m from Missouri. You’ll have to show me.” Folks from the “show me” state don’t value silver-tongued talkers. They live by the doctrine that seeing is believing. When buying or selling houses, everyone needs to adopt Missouri’s principle. Reading Chapter 10 to explore the theory of pricing property is all fine and good. However, merely reading about valuing houses can’t turn you into an educated buyer or seller. To properly educate yourself about property values, you must tour comparable houses. No amount of book smarts beats good old shoe leather and eyeballing.
Chapter 5: Timing Is Everything You have to wear two different hats during your property tours: Seller’s hat: A good comparable market analysis (CMA) prepared by a real estate agent to determine your house’s current value contains two lists. One documents houses comparable to yours in condition, size, age, and location (called comps) that have sold within the past six months. The other shows comps that are currently on the market. You probably won’t be able to get into properties that have already sold, but you should make a point of touring each comp currently on the market to verify your house’s resale value. If you’re working with an agent, have him or her tag along when you tour property. As you walk through a house, ask the agent to point out similarities and differences between it and recently sold properties that you haven’t seen. This “show and tell” greatly speeds up your discovery process. After visiting a few comps, you start to see which houses are priced to sell and which houses are overpriced turkeys. Buyer’s hat: The house that you intend to sell and the home you want to buy may be different — different neighborhoods, styles, sizes, ages, conditions, and prices. Your new home may not even be in the same city or state. You won’t, however, have to reinvent the wheel as a buyer because most principles of valuing property apply whether you’re a buyer or a seller. Smart buyers also use CMAs. Seeing is still believing, and nothing beats touring property currently on the market so you know what’s available when the time is right. We also wrote a book to help buyers find their way through the purchasing maze. It’s called — surprise, surprise — Home Buying For Dummies (Wiley).
Take action Now you’re ready to start the action phase — selling your old house and buying a new one. Timing is critical. If you structure your transactions properly from inception, you’ll be in firm control of the process instead of the process controlling you.
Putting your house on the market First things first. Let the world know that your house is for sale. You must, however, continue looking at any new comps that come on the market after yours as well as other new homes being offered for sale. The market constantly changes. New property becomes available. Houses currently on the market sell. A good real estate agent can keep you posted regarding important changes that may affect your situation.
83
84
Part II: Tactical Considerations Push your hands deeply into your pockets whenever you tour prospective dream homes. Untimely dreams have a way of turning into nightmares. As long as your hands are safely out of harm’s way, you can’t sign any purchase offers. Don’t make an offer to purchase your next home yet, for the following reasons: Your asking price may be too high. Even though you try your best to price your property to sell, you may inadvertently overprice it. You know that you’ve overpriced your property if purchase offers fail to appear. Because the amount you can afford to spend for your next home probably depends on the amount you net from the sale of your current house, knowing how much money you’ll have available may be critical. If your budget provides little wiggle room and you’re forced to reduce your asking price, you can simply make a commensurate adjustment in the amount you eventually pay for your new home. You aren’t a real buyer until you have a solid contract on the house you’re selling. Read Chapter 14 to understand why this statement is true. For now, trust us; any offer you make on a new home that depends on first selling your present house (if your house isn’t in contract yet) won’t be taken seriously. Real sellers refuse to tie up their property indefinitely while you attempt to sell your house.
Structuring your terms of sale Chapter 14 gets into information you must know when offers for your house begin pouring in from potential buyers. For now, concentrate on one extremely important aspect of the deal you make — structuring your terms of sale to provide enough time to purchase your new home. You shouldn’t need a ton of time because you’re already familiar with prospective new homes currently on the market, and you’re probably either preapproved or, at least, prequalified for a mortgage. Here’s how you can give yourself the time that you need to make a wellplanned and executed purchase: Schedule close of escrow on your old house to occur 30 days after the buyers remove all their conditions of purchase and increase their deposit. Buyers may take three or four weeks to remove the two most common conditions of nearly all house purchases — mortgage approval and property inspections. Getting loan approval usually takes somewhat longer than completing the various property inspections. Thirty days is your magic number, because lenders normally won’t hold their loan commitment more than 30 days after they approve a mortgage. Some lenders may be willing to hold mortgage commitments more than 30 days. One quick call to the buyers’ loan officer is necessary to determine the lender’s policy on this issue. If, for example, the buyers’ lender guarantees a loan commitment 45 days after the loan is approved, schedule your close of escrow accordingly. The more time you give yourself to close your other transaction, the better.
Chapter 5: Timing Is Everything You can get even more time by putting a “rent-back” clause in your counter offer to the buyers’ purchase offer. This clause lets you rent your house back from the buyers after escrow closes. It can buy you an extra month or two (or more) if the buyers agree to a rent-back. Sellers usually pay rent equal to their buyers’ actual cost for principle, interest, taxes, and insurance. For example, if the buyers pay $1,500 a month for mortgage payments plus their prorated property tax and insurance payments, that amount is your rent. Although the rent may be more than you currently pay to live in your house, the amount is probably less than it would cost you to move into a motel for a month or two and much more convenient. As we note in Chapter 14, sellers are wise to prepare a formal lease agreement that covers the rent-back. No standard rent-back clause exists. Check with your real estate agent or a lawyer to determine how rent-backs are best handled where you live.
Timing the offer to buy your new home You may be tempted to rush out and make an offer on your dream home while the ink still is drying on the contract you just signed to sell your present house. Don’t. Give yourself time to shake out deal-killing glitches in your sale before you make any offers on a new home. Don’t present an offer to buy your next home until the contract on your present house resembles the Rock of Gibraltar. If you want the sellers of your new home to treat your offer with respect, delay making an offer until your buyers remove all their conditions of purchase and increase their deposit on the house you’re selling. Until you know the buyers’ mortgage is approved, and you resolve questions related to handling corrective work discovered during the property inspections, your contract is as solid as a bowl of pudding. You may think that we’re overly cautious when we urge you to wait until the contract for the sale of your house is rock solid before making an offer to buy your new home. We’ve seen seemingly solid deals blown apart out of the blue. The real estate gods can be cruel and fickle. Make the offer to purchase your new home subject to the sale of your present house. This step protects you from being forced to buy a second home. Your offer should specify that if the escrow for the sale of your house doesn’t close within the time specified in your contract of sale, you have the right to cancel the contract to purchase the new property. If for some utterly unforeseen reason the sale of your house falls apart, at least you can get out of the contract to buy the new home. Combining a 30-day close of escrow with a two-month rent-back clause gives you a three-month comfort zone in which to close the purchase of your new home. Ideally, you can simultaneously close the sale of your present house and the purchase of your new home. If you can’t, however, then sell before you buy. You’ll sleep better.
85
86
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Chapter 6
For Sale By Owner In This Chapter Selling without using a real estate agent — the pros and cons Hiring advisors to help with your sale
A
pproximately 20 percent of the houses sold in the United States each year are sales made directly by property owners without using a real estate agent. Selling your house yourself, without having an agent represent you, is commonly referred to as a For Sale By Owner or FSBO (“fizz-bo”). We know some people who’ve successfully sold their houses by themselves and others who’ve made a major mess of their transactions. Whether you opt to sell your house without an agent or conclude that hiring an agent is a better way to go, our paramount concern is simple: that your sale is as profitable and painless as possible. To that end, this chapter contains an objective look at the pros and cons of FSBOs.
Eyeing the Potential FSBO Advantages After conversations with people who’ve actually gone through a FSBO, we’ve concluded that each seller’s personal situation and motivation for selling is unique. The following sections describe the most common reasons why sellers choose to sell without using an agent.
You want to save money on commissions People who’ve gone through a FSBO often do so to avoid having to pay real estate agent commissions. As we discuss in Chapter 1, the lion’s share of the expenses related to selling your house are typically real estate agent commissions, which can gobble a large portion of your house’s equity (that is, the difference between the market value of your house and outstanding mortgages). In most areas of the country, a 5 to 6 percent real estate brokerage commission is common. Thus, on a $250,000 house, the commission typically sets you back $12,500 to $15,000.
88
Part II: Tactical Considerations
You may already have a ready, willing, and able buyer If you spread the word that you’re planning to sell your house, you may turn up someone who’s financially able to buy and willing to pay you the amount that you feel your house is worth. Good for you. Why pay a full commission if you’ve already found a buyer? As we note in Chapter 8, you’re in a good position to either negotiate a reduced commission with a real estate broker or hire an attorney to help you complete your transaction. Whether you’re contemplating selling your house with an agent or doing a FSBO, tell as many prospective buyers as possible that you’re interested in selling. Although most people don’t find a buyer for their house simply by getting the word out through their own network of friends and contacts, you won’t know whether you’ll be one of the fortunate few who successfully sell their houses this way unless you try. Before you start getting the word out, take these tips to heart: Follow our advice in Chapter 1 to make sure that selling your house is the correct course of action for you. Read Chapter 10 to discover how to determine the fair market value of your property. Follow the tips in Chapter 9 to ensure that your house looks its absolute best. Hire a good real estate lawyer to review your house sale contract and other documents.
You may know the house and neighborhood well You may know more about the strengths of your house and neighborhood than local real estate agents, especially if you’ve lived in an area for many years. You may be able to speak from personal experience about how childfriendly the neighborhood is and how terrific the local schools are. You can praise the virtues of nearby shopping, transportation, and entertainment. You can gush about your wonderful neighbors. And you can point with pride to all the improvements you’ve made to your house over the years.
Chapter 6: For Sale By Owner Be careful in praising your house and neighborhood. As Chapter 12 explains, even the most interested prospective buyer can get turned off if you’re overbearing or sound like a used car salesman. And, as we discuss in Chapter 8, what you say about your property may cause you legal problems down the road. If you’re going to sell without a real estate agent, be sure to have a good real estate lawyer on your team to assist you with mandatory property transfer disclosures and to provide advice about what you should avoid saying about your house.
How much can you really save by doing a FSBO? Maybe a friend, neighbor, relative, or business associate is interested in buying your house. If you know a ready, willing, and financially qualified buyer who wants to work with you directly, you may save the full standard real estate brokerage commission for your area, less a nominal fee paid to a real estate attorney.
Last, but not least, most buyers expect to share the commission savings you’re enjoying by not using an agent. They may expect to split the savings with you. If you’re a strong negotiator and the prospective buyers aren’t, you may be able to keep most of the savings for yourself.
In the best-case scenario, given that you make all the right moves and are an astute negotiator, you may save yourself a good deal of money. You’re more likely, however, not to save the typical 5 percent to 6 percent real estate brokerage commission. Here’s why:
Unless you can find a buyer without having to advertise your house for sale, or you sell your house to a buyer who isn’t working with an agent, you can realistically expect to save about 1 percent to 2 percent of the sale price in a typical FSBO. Ultimately, of course, the amount you do or don’t save depends on how much the buyers pay for your house. If you end up selling for a lower price than a good real estate agent could’ve fetched for you, the lower sale price may wipe out any commission savings.
Unless you already have a buyer in hand or you find one quickly, you have to spend money advertising and marketing your house, as we describe in Chapter 12. Advertising costs money; the longer your house is for sale, the more you spend. You may have to pay a real estate commission if a cooperating real estate agent brings you a buyer. Most homebuyers work with agents, and these agents must be paid for bringing you a bona fide buyer. This expense alone can cut your expected commission savings in half.
Also, don’t forget the value of your time — especially if you’re self-employed or in a profession where your income suffers if you work less. Handling buyer and agent phone calls, showing the property, holding open houses, meeting property inspectors and appraisers, and handling escrow details take time.
89
90
Part II: Tactical Considerations
You may be more motivated than an agent Your house and the money you have tied up in it are important to you. Some real estate agents, despite having dollar signs in their eyes in anticipation of the commissions they’ll earn if they sell your house, may be less than eager to invest sufficient time in promoting and showing your property. If you decide to use an agent to help you with your sale, as we discuss in Chapter 7, exercise great care in choosing the right agent. Avoid overextended agents who juggle too many listings and clients to give your house sale the attention it deserves.
You like challenges Some people don’t select the easier path. For example, instead of working for a corporation, you may be the type who starts your own business. Many small business owners say that the desire for a potentially higher income wasn’t the primary reason they started their own business. Some small business owners pursue this career path as a means of self-expression, to make a contribution to a particular field, or for the pleasure of working with and satisfying customers. For the same reasons, some people try to sell their houses by themselves. Although most FSBO sellers are eager to save commission dollars, a few do it for the challenge or because they want to apply skills they possess to selling their own house.
You want to be in control Some folks just don’t like giving up control. If you’re the type of person who wants to be in charge, you may be unwilling to relinquish control to an agent. If you sell your house yourself, you can decide when and where to place ads for your house and exactly what features to emphasize. You may want to say when it is and isn’t okay to have strangers (interested buyers and their agents) strolling through your house. Perhaps you want to ensure that your cat or the family dog isn’t let out of the house by an agent who fails to notice your special showing instructions. Whatever the reason, for better or worse, you’re the boss with a FSBO.
Chapter 6: For Sale By Owner
Your house may sell itself If the local real estate market is strong, and good houses get multiple offers as soon as the For Sale sign goes up, you may feel that selling your wonderful house will be a snap. All things considered, FSBOs usually are more successful in a sellers’ market than a buyers’ market.
Focusing on Potential FSBO Disadvantages Although selling a house isn’t rocket science or heart surgery, it nevertheless requires some important skills as we discuss throughout this book. Even the smartest of FSBO sellers can get into trouble. This section points out a few cons to going the FSBO route.
You may not know how to price property Grossly overpriced property isn’t going to sell. Buyers and agents who know property values will, in fact, avoid it like the plague. In the end, you may not get as much for your house as you could have by pricing it realistically to begin with. If you under price your house, you may sell it below its market value — shortchanging yourself thousands of dollars — perhaps even tens of thousands. Say goodbye to the commission you “saved.” Chapter 10 deals with using a comparable market analysis (CMA) to determine your house’s fair market value. Chapter 11 is filled with tips about how to fine-tune your asking price.
You may not know how to prepare your house for sale Your familiarity with your house can be a liability if it blinds you to your house’s flaws. You may like your house’s clutter and quirks, but their dubious charms may turn off prospective buyers. One important benefit that a good agent brings to the table is a fresh pair of eyes and a desire to whip your house into get-it-sold shape. Chapter 9 spells out, in detail, what you should — and shouldn’t — do to your property prior to putting your house on the market.
91
92
Part II: Tactical Considerations
You may not know how to market your property Did you know that a humble, low-tech For Sale sign and a classified ad are two of the most potent forms of advertising available to people who sell their houses without using an agent? Do you know how to use the Internet to market your house? Unless you have a background in real estate or marketing, you probably have some research to do. And, by undertaking a FSBO, you miss out on two powerful promotional tools only available to agents: the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and brokers’ tours of newly listed properties. If you’re undertaking a FSBO, be sure to read Chapter 12, which details the best advertising and marketing techniques to get the word out about your house. Chapter 8 delves into how, if you’re selling without an agent, you can gain access to the MLS and brokers’ open house tours on a fee basis from discount brokers. Scrutinize Chapter 13 to see what role computers can play in selling your house.
You may not know how to separate real buyers from fakes Serious buyers make good offers. Bogus buyers waste your time and money. In the worst of all possible scenarios, you may unintentionally allow someone with criminal intentions into your house. Chapter 14 points out the three qualities that all good offers have in common. You can also find a section in Chapter 14 to help you distinguish real buyers from time-wasting fake ones.
You may not have enough experience as a negotiator If you know that you’re a weak negotiator, you have to be especially careful about selling your house without an agent. Not knowing smart negotiating tactics can cost you big bucks. Even if you are a good negotiator, your financial and emotional involvement in the sale may cause you to lose your cool when bargaining with a buyer, or you may undermine the deal by appearing greedy. Chapter 14 is brimming with techniques and tips for negotiating your price and terms of sale. Secure the services of a good real estate lawyer who, in addition to keeping you out of legal hot water, can also act as your negotiating agent.
Chapter 6: For Sale By Owner
You may get yourself into legal trouble Selling your house yourself to save on real estate brokerage commissions is a hollow victory if the buyers sue you after close of escrow. Perhaps you didn’t give them the mandatory federal, state, and local property disclosures about problems such as lead-based paints or work you did on the property without a building permit. House selling is a team sport. Chapter 7 describes players you may need on your team, one of whom is a real estate lawyer who can help you put together a proper disclosure statement and sales contract if you’re selling your house yourself. Also, be sure to read the section about property disclosures in Chapter 8. Trying to save money by avoiding legal fees is a false economy. If you’re not using an agent, you need to have a lawyer review the sales contract before you sign it. If that’s not possible, at least put a clause in the contract to say your acceptance is subject to review and approval of the contract by an attorney of your choice within five business days after you sign it. Don’t discriminate! Disqualifying prospective buyers on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin is illegal. Discrimination can get you into a heap of legal trouble and can cost you big bucks. If in doubt, check with the Equal Housing Opportunity agency in your area.
You may not know how to close the sale You won’t save on commissions if your deal falls apart in escrow. As a FSBO seller, you have to make arrangements that a good listing agent normally handles. Do you, for example, know how to open an escrow, get a preliminary title report, order property inspections, handle contingency removals, and order a payoff demand for your mortgage? Chapter 15 guides you through the blocking and tackling necessary to complete your house sale after you have a signed purchase contract in hand.
Increasing Your Chances of Success Selling a house without an agent is doable, but it’s considerably more challenging than it looks. If, after weighing the pros and cons of doing a FSBO, you decide to attempt to sell your house yourself, be sure to read our final words of wisdom.
93
94
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Educate yourself The things you don’t know generally are what get you into trouble. This book is crammed with tips and advice to help you sell your house for top dollar and steer clear of problems, whether you do a FSBO or use an agent. Unread, this book won’t do you a darn bit of good — unless you’re looking for a yellow paperweight. We strongly urge you to read this entire book if you’re going to sell your house yourself. Then again, if you decide to hire an agent, you may still want to read this entire book! Why? Because you can manage the transaction better and feel much more comfortable if you’re knowledgeable about what’s going on. Even if you’re certain about selling your house sans agent, interview several good agents (using the criteria we outline in Chapter 7). Interviewing agents may reaffirm that you can handle the sale yourself, or the interviewing process may convince you that you’re better off hiring the best agent you contacted. You’ll probably pick up some helpful advice and information you can implement if you do decide to sell yourself. And, if your FSBO isn’t successful, you can always hire the best candidate after you’ve given FSBOing a shot. Either way, interviewing agents is well worth your time.
Ensure that other team members are especially strong Without a real estate broker or agent on your team, making sure that your other players are the best they can be is all the more critical. Be especially careful to hire an excellent real estate lawyer. Chapter 7 details criteria you can use to select the members of your team.
Cooperate with agents Because the vast majority of buyers work with agents, be sure to mention in your classified ads and listing statement that you “will cooperate with agents.” This statement tells local agents that you’re willing to pay them a commission if they procure the buyer who ultimately purchases your house.
Chapter 6: For Sale By Owner
Financially qualify prospective buyers When someone makes an offer on your house, don’t take your property off the market until you’re sure that the buyer is going to be able to swing the deal financially. Few buyers are wealthy enough to pay all cash for your house. Most folks need to qualify for a mortgage. Ideally, the buyers are preapproved for a loan with a conventional lender. As opposed to merely being prequalified — a quick financial once-over — preapproval means that they’ve gone through a rigorous financial examination. If, however, the buyers are just starting to shop for a mortgage, inquire about their occupations, incomes, and the source of their down payment for the purchase. When the buyers apply for a mortgage, get their permission to contact the lender to find out the likelihood of loan approval. (Even though you probably aren’t going to be financing their purchase of your house, check out Chapter 4 to see what smart lenders look for on a mortgage application.) Watch out for buyers who make their offer to purchase your house subject to the sale of their own house first. As we note in Chapter 14, this tactic, if handled improperly, can tie up your property and scare away other prospective buyers who are ready, willing, and able to buy immediately.
95
96
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Chapter 7
Your Real Estate Team In This Chapter Forming a winning team Picking a superior listing agent Choosing your broker Dealing with house inspectors and inspections Finding an escrow officer Securing financial advisors and lawyers
A
dentist Ray knows once compared what he’d just gone through during a protracted house sale to having root-canal work done on every tooth in his head . . . without Novocain. Don’t take the dentist literally; he’s a master of understatement. Unless you’re a masochist, you never willingly seek out intense pain. Yet we’ve seen smart people blunder into painful situations while selling their houses. The key word is blunder. What usually gets people into trouble is something that they (or the professionals they hire to handle the transaction) should’ve known, but didn’t. No need to worry, though. This chapter takes a closer look at who you need on your real estate team and how to select them.
Teaming Up — a Winning Concept Knowing everything about everything is impossible. What is possible, however (and much more important, to boot), is putting good people on your team — people who know the things you need to know to solve the problems that invariably arise during your sale. You don’t have to become an expert in property values, mortgages, tax and real estate law, title insurance, escrow, pest-control work, and construction techniques to play the house-selling game well. Instead, you can hire people who’ve already mastered the skills that you lack.
98
Part II: Tactical Considerations House selling is a team sport. Your job is to lead and coach the team, not play every position. After you assemble a winning team, your players should give you solid advice so you can make brilliant decisions. If cost were no object, you’d hire every competent expert you could get your hands on. However, because you probably don’t have an unlimited budget, you need to determine which experts are absolutely necessary and which tasks you can handle yourself. In this section, we explain which experts generally are worth hiring and which ones you can pass on. Ultimately, of course, you’re the one who must determine how competent or challenged you feel with the various aspects of the house-selling process. Here’s an overview of the possible players on your team: Your favorite person: You are the most important player on your team. Sooner or later, another player is bound to drop the ball or fail to satisfy your needs. You have every right to politely, yet forcefully, insist that this person make things right. Remember that you hire the players on your team; they work for you. Bad players may see things the other way around — they want to believe that they’re in charge. They may attempt to manipulate you into acting in their best interests rather than yours. Don’t tolerate this behavior. You’re the boss — you can fire and hire. Real estate agent: Because the house that you’re getting ready to sell is probably one of your largest investments, you want to protect your interests by having someone on your team who knows property values. Your agent’s primary mission is to accurately tell you what your house is worth and then negotiate on your behalf to sell it for top dollar. Real estate broker: All states issue two different real estate licenses: one for salespeople (agents) and one for brokers. Real estate brokers must satisfy more stringent educational and experience standards than agents do. If your real estate agent isn’t an independent broker or the broker for a real estate office, a broker must supervise the agent. The broker is responsible for everything that your agent does or fails to do within the course and scope of the duties of real estate sales professionals. In a crisis, your transaction’s success may depend on backup support from your agent’s broker. Property inspectors: Your house’s physical condition greatly affects its value. Smart buyers will insist on having your house thoroughly inspected from roof to foundation as a condition of the purchase. Don’t passively wait for buyers to give you a copy of their report. Get your house thoroughly inspected before putting it on the market so that you know what to expect during any subsequent corrective-work negotiations with the buyer. Escrow officer: Mutual distrust is the underlying rule of many real estate deals. You and the buyer need a neutral third party, an escrow officer, to handle funds and paperwork related to the transaction without playing favorites. The escrow officer is the referee in the game of house selling.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team Financial and tax advisors: Before selling your house, make sure that you understand how the sale (and the purchase of another home, if applicable) fits into your overall financial situation. In Part I of this book, we explain how financial and tax advisors can help you evaluate these considerations. Lawyer: Whether you need a lawyer on your team depends on three things: the complexity of your contract, the location of your house, and your personal comfort level. As we discuss in Chapter 6, if you decide to sell your house without an agent, you definitely need a lawyer who specializes in real estate law on your team. The purchase agreement you sign to sell your house is a legally binding contract. If you have any questions about your contract’s legality, put a real estate lawyer on your team. Each player brings a different skill into the game. Assemble members of a great team, and they guide you through any situation that may arise during your transaction. Keep in mind that good players serve as advisors — not decision makers. Decision making is your job. After all, it’s your money on the line.
Landing the Perfect Listing Agent The real estate agent that you hire to sell your house, known as the listing agent, must be able to accurately answer your most important question: “What’s it worth?” Houses sell for fair market value, which is whatever buyers are willing to offer and sellers are willing to accept. Fair market value isn’t a specific number; it’s a price range. For example, suppose that an agent says that your property is worth $300,000, more or less. If your agent is a better negotiator than the buyer’s agent, and the buyer desperately wants your house, you may sell it for $315,000. On the other hand, if you have to sell your house immediately, and the buyer has a better agent than you do, you may only get $285,000. Sale prices often are directly related to a listing agent’s knowledge of the price that comparable houses sell for and negotiating skills. Of course, other factors (such as the buyer’s and seller’s motivation, needs, and market knowledge) also are important. A good agent can be the foundation of your real estate team. An agent helps you price your property, orchestrates the marketing and showing activities, negotiates with buyers on your behalf, supervises property inspections, and coordinates the closing. A good agent’s negotiating skills and knowledge of property values can add 5 percent to 10 percent to your house’s sale price.
99
100
Part II: Tactical Considerations Bad agents may pressure you to accept a low offer to make a quick sale. The real estate world is full of many well-intentioned-but-inept agents. In this section, we show you how to avoid the bad agents and how to sift through the hordes of mediocre agents to narrow the field down to good agents who are worthy of their commissions.
Understanding agent relationships Sellers and buyers can have two types of relationships with real estate agents: Single agency: In this form of representation, an agent represents only one of the two parties (the seller or the buyer) in the transaction. In single agency, an agent may play one of two roles: • Seller’s agent: In this type of single agency, an agent works solely for the seller. • Buyer’s agent: In this type of single agency, the agent works only for the buyer. A buyer’s agent isn’t an agent of the seller even if the buyer’s agent gets a portion of the commission paid by the seller. Dual agency: In this form of representation, the same agent represents the seller and the buyer. Dual agency is the most confusing and least understood form of agency. See the nearby sidebar, “Dual agency problems” for more info. Ideally, you want a single agency relationship. However, given the everexpanding market presence of large regional and nationwide brokerage firms, it’s increasingly likely that you’ll find yourself in a dual agency situation where the same estate brokerage firm represents both you and the buyer. Should that happen, we strongly recommend that you and the buyer at least work with different individual agents within the firm. If humanly possible, avoid having the same agent represent you and the buyer.
Recognizing the best listing agents Good agents come in a variety of races, colors, creeds, and ages and may be male or female. All the best listing agents, however, have certain important qualities in common. They do the following: Educate you: Your agent knows the selling process and carefully explains each step so that you understand exactly what’s happening at all times. Agents should be patient, not pushy. A good agent never uses your inexperience to manipulate you. Enable you to make good decisions: Your agent always explains what your options are so you can make wise decisions regarding your best course of action.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team
Dual agency problems Most people think that dual agency means that one person represents the buyer and the seller. Although such arrangements are possible, that type of dual agency is highly inadvisable. Logically, one agent can’t represent your best interests as a seller (getting the highest possible price) and the buyer’s best interests (getting the lowest possible price) at the same time. A more common kind of dual agency involves two different agents who work for the same real estate broker. For example, you list your house for sale with Sarah, an Acme Realty agent, who agrees to be your exclusive agent. Unknown to you and Sarah, Betty Buyer met Bob, who’s also an Acme Realty agent. Betty liked Bob’s style and asked him to represent her exclusively as a buyer’s agent. Bob enthusiastically accepted. So far, so good. You have Sarah, your exclusive agent. Betty has Bob, her exclusive agent. Everything is fine, until Bob shows Betty your house. Betty loves it and instructs Bob to write up an offer on it immediately. At the moment Betty decides to make an offer on your house, the agency relationships that you and Betty have with your respective agents change. Like it or not, Sarah suddenly represents you and Betty. Similarly, Bob becomes your agent as well as Betty’s agent.
Why? Even though two different agents are involved in the transaction, both agents work for the same real estate broker — Acme Realty. As soon as Bob starts to work on Betty’s offer, Acme Realty represents the seller and the buyer of the same property. That’s dual agency. You probably won’t have to worry about dual agency if your agent works in a small office that has only a few agents. The odds that one of the other agents in your agent’s office will have a buyer for your house are quite small. However, if the agent that you select works for a large brokerage operation with multiple offices and thousands of agents (such as Coldwell Banker, Century 21, and the like), your odds of having to deal with dual agency increase. Most states permit dual agency relationships as long as the agency status is disclosed to the sellers and the buyers in advance, and both parties agree to it. Undisclosed dual agency, which occurs if the buyer and seller haven’t been advised about or consented to dual agency, can be used as grounds for having a purchase agreement revoked and usually permits the injured parties to seek recovery against (that is, sue) the real estate agents.
Advise you if they think that you should add other experts (property inspectors, lawyers, and so on) to your team: Experts don’t threaten a good agent. The agent’s ego should always be secondary to the primary mission of serving you well. Voluntarily limit themselves geographically and by property type: Good agents know that trying to be all things to all people invariably results in mediocre service. Even though real estate laws are the same throughout your state, different areas within the state generally have radically different market conditions, local zoning ordinances, and building code restrictions.
101
102
Part II: Tactical Considerations Agents go out of their area of geographical or property expertise for one of two reasons: because they’re greedy or because they’re too darn inept to know better. Whatever the reason, avoid such agents like the plague. Are full-time professionals: To reduce the financial impact of changing jobs, many people begin their real estate careers as part-timers, working as agents after normal business hours and on weekends. Such an arrangement is fine for the agents but not for you. One of the first questions to ask any agent who you’re considering working with is “Are you a full-time agent?” Just as you wouldn’t risk letting a part-time lawyer defend you, don’t let a part-time agent represent you. Have contacts: Folks prefer doing business with people they know, respect, and trust. You can make use of your agent’s working relationships with local lenders, property inspectors, lawyers, title officers, insurance agents, government officials, and other real estate agents. Have time for you: Success is a two-edged sword. An agent who’s already working with several other sellers and buyers probably doesn’t have enough surplus time to serve you properly. Occasional scheduling conflicts are unavoidable. If, however, you often find your needs being neglected because your agent’s time is overcommitted, get a new agent. Are technologically savvy: Good agents know how to use technology to get the job done. They (or their staff) know how to use the Internet to make property searches, can put listing information about your house on a variety of Web sites, and routinely utilize digital cameras and desktop publishing software as marketing tools. They understand the importance of staying in close touch with you and their other important contacts via cell phone, e-mail, or some other yet-to-be invented hightech tool that works immediately if not sooner. Some agents think technology has replaced human interaction. They’re wrong. A geek who spends all his time in the office hiding behind a computer is the wrong agent for you. A good real estate agent harnesses technology to make more efficient use of her time, maximize your property’s exposure, and stay in closer touch with clients and others involved in real estate transactions. Personal relationships still are critically important.
Choosing your listing agent When you’re ready to get down to the nitty-gritty specifics of selecting your own agent, we recommend that you interview at least three agents before selecting the lucky winner. (Chapter 6 deals with the pros and cons of selling your house without using an agent.) To help you find three good agents to interview, tap into the following referral sources:
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team Friends, business associates, and members of professional, social, and religious organizations to which you belong: In short, anyone you know who recently sold a house or is in the process of selling a house in your neighborhood is a source of agent referrals. Don’t just ask for names; find out why they liked the agent. Your employer: The company you work for may have a relocation service that you can consult. Professionals in related fields: Financial, tax, and legal advisors can be good sources of agent referrals. Sunday open houses: Visit houses currently on the market in your neighborhood to check out the competition and to see how well the agents hosting the open houses handle the process. Here’s your chance to “audition” agents without their knowledge. Listen to the agent answer questions from prospective buyers. Observe the way people respond to the agent. Seeing is believing. Chapter 9 covers preparing property to optimize its favorable impression on prospective buyers. When you tour an open house, note whether the house makes a good impression on you. If not, drop the agent from further consideration as your listing agent. In the next few sections, we outline the process of choosing your listing agent.
Step 1: Showing off your house After you identify at least three prospective agents, start the selection process by inviting these agents to tour your house — individually, of course — so each can prepare a comparable market analysis (CMA) for your property. The CMA establishes your house’s value by comparing it to other houses in your neighborhood that are approximately the same size, age, and condition as your house. Chapter 10 goes into detail about how to use sale prices and asking prices of comparable houses (comps) to determine the probable value of your house. During that first meeting, tell each agent that you intend to interview several agents before selecting the one to work with to sell your house (the listing agent). Schedule second meetings with each agent a few days later to review their CMAs, their marketing plans for your property (a topic we cover in Chapter 12), and their activity lists (see the nearby sidebar, “The proof is in the activity list”). Before the second meeting with your prospective listing agents, you have to do a little homework (pun intended) yourself. Be sure to read Chapters 10 and 12 before the second meeting so you know the difference between good and bad CMAs and marketing plans. Read Chapter 8, as well, to find out about the different types of listing agreements and ideal length of the listing period. Chapter 8 also explains real estate commissions, a subject that should be of great interest to you because sellers usually pay the commission.
103
104
Part II: Tactical Considerations Step 2: Conducting agent interviews Begin each interview by analyzing the agent’s CMA, marketing proposal, and activity list. After you review the written material, get answers to the following questions: Are you a full-time agent? You should’ve asked this question before inviting the agent to be interviewed. If you didn’t, do so now. Don’t work with part-time agents. Whom do you represent? This question gets back to the fundamental concept of agency. Be sure that you know whom your agent represents at all times. What can you tell me about your office? Office size is a matter of personal preference. Some folks feel that they need the depth and scope of services a large office provides. Others think that they’ll get more personal attention in a small office. No matter whether you prefer large or small offices, check on staff support, market specialization, and reputation. Determine whether the agent’s broker is knowledgeable, is available to you if necessary, and is a good problem solver. In a crunch, the success of your transaction may depend on the quality of backup support that you and the agent receive.
The proof is in the activity list The activity list is exactly that — a list of every property the agent either listed or sold during the preceding 12 months. This list is a powerful analytical tool. Here’s what the activity list should include and how you can use it during the interview: Property addresses: Addresses help you zero in on the agent’s geographical focus. See how many properties the agent listed and sold in your neighborhood. Eliminate agents who are focused outside your area or who have no geographical focus. Property types (house, condo, duplex, and the like): This information indicates whether the agent works on property similar to yours. If, for example, an agent specializes in condos, and you want to sell a house, you may have a problem. Sale prices: Does the agent handle property in your price range? An agent who
deals in much more or much less expensive property than yours may not be the right agent for you. If, for example, your house is worth about $300,000, and the most expensive property the agent sold in the past year was $150,000, you likely have a mismatch. Such agents probably don’t know how to value and market higher-priced property like yours. Days on market (DOM): Ask agents you interview to specify how long property they listed was on the market before it sold. Compare that to the average DOM for your neighborhood according to statistics developed by a reliable independent source such as the local Multiple Listing Service (MLS). Eliminate agents whose listings habitually take far longer to sell than the average DOM in your area.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team
Dates of sale: Sales should be fairly evenly distributed throughout the year. If they aren’t, find out why. A lack of recent sales activity may be caused by illness or marital problems that could reduce the agent’s effectiveness. Be understanding of resolved problems. Remember, however, that your house and money are on the line when considering agents who are in the midst of ongoing problems that may affect their ability to do a good job for you. Who the agent represented — sellers or buyers: Seasoned agents work about half the time with sellers and the other half with buyers. Avoid agents who focus primarily on buyers; such agents tend to lack the qualities you need as a seller. When discussing transactions in which the agent represented sellers, see which offices represented the buyers. Eliminate agents who either personally sell all their own listings or who sell listings only through other agents in their office. You want an agent who cooperates with other good agents throughout the brokerage community to sell your house as quickly as possible and for top dollar.
Total dollar value of property sold during the preceding 12 months: Comparing the three agents’ grand total property sales is a quick way to measure individual activity and success. However, you don’t necessarily want a “top producer” representing you. These agents may not have the time or patience to provide the level of personal service and education you may need. Names and current phone numbers of sellers/buyers: Later, you can spot-check these references. Although a few people may request that their names or phone numbers be kept confidential, be suspicious of any agent who claims that all his or her clients made this request. Such a claim is most likely a pathetic attempt to get out of giving you references. Actions speak louder than words. Activity lists transform cheap chatter into firm facts. Good agents willingly give you their lists and encourage you to check references. Eliminate from consideration any agent who won’t provide an activity list.
Don’t select an agent based solely on the size of the agent’s office. Office size, or lack thereof, doesn’t affect how quickly property sells. Some excellent agents operate as sole practitioners; other excellent agents prefer the synergism and support services of a huge office. Although larger offices tend to have more listings, no one office ever has a monopoly on the good listings. Quality of service is more important than quantity of agents or listings. How long have you been an agent? You want an agent who keeps learning and growing. After five years in real estate, a good agent has five years’ experience, whereas a mediocre agent has one year’s experience five times. Time in the saddle is one factor to consider when selecting an agent, but, by itself, it’s no guarantee of competence. Even with a timetested agent, you still have to review activity lists and ask all the other questions (see the sidebar, “The proof is in the activity list” for more info).
105
106
Part II: Tactical Considerations Do you have a salesperson’s license or a broker’s license? An agent must satisfy rigorous educational and field sales experience requirements to get a broker’s license. Many fine agents have a salesperson’s license throughout their entire career. Although a broker’s license isn’t a guarantee of excellence, good agents often get a broker’s license to improve their professional skills and to give themselves an advantage in agent-selection situations. Do you hold any professional designations? Have you recently taken any real estate classes? What do you read to keep current in your field? Taking continuing education courses and reading to stay informed about changes in real estate brokerage is a good characteristic in an agent. So is obtaining professional designations, such as the GRI (Graduate Realtor Institute) and CRS (Certified Residential Specialist) designations through the National Association of Realtors’ study programs. Credentials in and of themselves are no guarantee of competence or ethics, but they usually indicate that the agent has a desire for selfimprovement. What do you think of the other two agents (name them) that I’m interviewing? To encourage frankness, assure the agents that you won’t repeat their comments. Good agents never build themselves up by tearing down other agents. If all three agents are good ones, you won’t hear derogatory comments about any of them. If, however, one of the agents (or the agent’s firm) has a bad reputation in the community, the other two agents’ silence will speak volumes. Remember: Good or bad, the reputations of your agent and the agent’s office rub off on you. How many other sellers and buyers do you currently represent? If, for example, the agent holds four listings open every weekend and is working with six buyers, where will you fit in? Don’t contort your life to fit the agent’s schedule. The agent who’s right for you has time to accommodate your schedule. Do you work in partnership with another agent or use assistants? Sometimes an agent teams up with another agent to handle sellers and buyers jointly. In such cases, you must interview both agents. Other agents delegate time-consuming detail work to their assistants so that they can focus on critical points in the transaction. If an agent relies on such assistants, be sure that you understand exactly how and when during the buying process the agent plans to work directly with you. You don’t want to hire an agent only to find that you end up working most of the time with an assistant whom you can’t stand. Is there anything I haven’t asked about you or your firm that you think I should know? Perhaps the agent is planning to change firms or is leaving next week for an extended vacation. Maybe the agent’s broker is going out of business. Always ask this “make sure I find out everything that I need to know to make a good decision” question.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team Step 3: Checking the all-important agent references By checking up on agent references, you can gain experience the easy way — by learning from other people’s mistakes. Be sure to get activity lists with names and phone numbers of every seller and buyer the agent represented during the past 12 months. With a complete activity list, you can pick and choose whomever you want to call, instead of permitting the agent to limit you to a highly selective list of references who are primed to tell anyone who calls that this agent is God’s gift to real estate. What’s to prevent agents from culling their worst transactions from the activity list? Nothing. However, the more deals they delete, the less activity they have to show you — and the worse they look when you compare the agents’ overall sales activity. Any agent who refuses to give you an activity list is trying to hide either a lack of sales or unhappy clients. Dump the agent. Suppose that each agent gives you a list containing 50 transactions. Assuming one seller or buyer for each transaction, 50 clients per agent times 3 agents interviewed equals 150 phone calls. No way. Your doctor would have to surgically remove the phone from your ear by the time you finished checking references. Good news. You don’t have to call every client to check references — that is, unless you want to. You can get a pretty darn accurate picture of the agents you’re considering by making just six calls per agent. Here’s how: 1. Because you’re a seller, ignore buyer references. That restriction probably cuts the list in half. 2. Next, look for people who sold property comparable to yours in price, location, and property type. Because their property is like yours, their experiences also are likely to be similar to yours. 3. Of these sellers, call two who sold a house about 12 months ago, two who sold approximately 6 months ago, and two whose sales just closed. By spreading references evenly over the past year, you can see whether the agent’s service has been consistently good. After you identify which sellers to call, ask the following questions while you have them on the phone:
107
108
Part II: Tactical Considerations Is the agent trustworthy and honest? Did the agent follow through on promises? Your agent can’t be even slightly untrustworthy, dishonest, or unreliable. Consider a “no” answer to either of these questions to be the kiss of death. Did the agent have enough time to properly serve you? Was the agent available to fit your schedule? An occasional scheduling conflict is okay. Frequent conflicts are absolutely, flat-out unacceptable. Did the agent clearly and satisfactorily explain in sufficient detail everything that happened during the selling process? What one person thinks is ample detail may not be nearly enough for another. For example, some folks are content just to know what time it is. Others aren’t happy until they know exactly how to make a clock. You know which type you are; question agent references accordingly. Did the agent set realistic contract deadlines and then meet or beat them? “Time is of the essence” is a condition of every real estate contract. Contract deadlines for obtaining financing, completing property inspections, and so forth are extremely important and must be met, or your sale will fall apart. A good agent makes sure that you and the buyer meet all contract deadlines. Do the words self-starter, committed, and motivated describe the agent? No one likes pushy people. But if you need to sell quickly, the last thing you want is a lethargic agent. You shouldn’t have to jab your agent periodically with an electric prod to make sure that he’s still breathing. Find out how energetically your prospective agent is prepared to work for you. Did the agent get a good sale price for your house? See whether the agent’s clients still think that they did well on their sale. Would you use the agent again? This question is the ultimate test of customer satisfaction. If someone answers “No,” find out why. The negative answer may be the result of a personality conflict between client and agent that won’t bother you. On the other hand, the negative answer may reveal a horrendous agent flaw that you haven’t yet uncovered. Is there anything I haven’t asked you about the agent or the agent’s office that you think I should know? You never know what you may find out when you ask this open-ended question.
Step 4: Picking the best of the lot By analyzing all three agents’ CMAs, marketing plans, and activity lists; interviewing the agents; and talking to their clients, you can gather facts that you need to make an intelligent decision. Here are three final considerations to help you select the paragon of virtue that you need on your real estate team:
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team Will you be proud having the agent represent you? People who deal with your agent will form opinions of you based on their impressions of your agent. You can’t afford to have anyone on your team who isn’t a competent professional. Do you communicate well with the agent? Good agents make sure that you completely understand everything they say. If you can’t understand your agent, don’t blame yourself; the agent is probably a poor communicator. Do you enjoy the agent’s personality? Don’t kid yourself. House selling is stressful. You share extremely intense situations with your agent. Working with an agent you like may transform the selling process from a horrible experience into an exciting adventure — or, at least, a tolerable transaction.
Achieving top performance from the winner After working so hard to find a great agent, the last thing you want to do is inadvertently ruin the relationship. Good seller-agent relationships aren’t accidental. On the contrary, these relationships are based on pillars of mutual loyalty and trust that develop over time. You obviously don’t want to tell your innermost secrets to an agent who’s going to blab them to a buyer or the buyer’s agent. To that end, some sellers view their agent as an adversary. These sellers think that the less their agent knows about them, the better. Such sellers believe that, if their agent finds out what their bottom line is and why they want to sell, the agent will manipulate them into selling their house for less than it’s worth just to make a quick commission. Good agents don’t betray your trust. They know that if they take care of you, their commission will take care of itself. If you can’t trust your agent, don’t play cat-and-mouse games; get a new agent. Smart agents know that you have the power to make or break their careers. If they please you, you’ll be a geyser of glowing referrals for them. If your agent upsets you, you’ll be like a festering thorn in her paw. Use the immense power of potential referrals to control your relationship with the agent. If your agent does a lousy job, don’t get mad — get even. Tell the world every gory detail of your rotten experience. Nothing ruins an agent’s career faster than dissatisfied clients.
109
110
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Bringing in the Broker When you select an agent, your agent’s broker is part of the package. If your purchase rolls merrily along, you may never meet the broker. But if a truly nasty problem rears its ugly head, guess who you can turn to for a quick fix? Brokers are the invisible grease in problematic transactions. All states issue two markedly different types of real estate licenses: one for salespeople (agents) and one for brokers. Agents who have broker’s licenses must satisfy much more stringent educational and experience standards than agents with only a salesperson’s license. Your agent may have either type of license. Broker’s licensees have the option either to operate independently or to work for another broker. An agent who has a salesperson’s license, on the other hand, must work under a broker’s direct supervision, ensuring that you have access to the broker’s higher lever of expertise if you need it. The broker’s image, good or bad, will be obvious from comments that you hear while checking agent references. You want the buyer, lender, and all other people involved in your transaction working with you because of your broker’s reputation, not in spite of it. You shouldn’t have to overcome guilt by association. If an agent’s references disparage the agent’s broker, dump the agent. Good brokers develop and maintain relationships with the people with whom their offices deal — other brokers, lenders, title officers, city officials, and the like. This reservoir of good will is yours to use if the going gets rough. Brokers with strong business relationships can work near-miracles for you in a crisis. House sales sometimes become highly emotional. If your life savings are on the line, you may lash out at other players. Someone must handle the resulting quarrels and misunderstandings. That someone is the broker. Because the broker participates directly or indirectly in every deal the office handles, your broker’s practical experience is directly related to the number of agents in the office. A broker who manages a 25-agent office, for example, gets 25 years of real estate experience per calendar year. Any broker who can survive five years of handling all the office’s gut-wrenching messes becomes a superb problem solver out of sheer necessity. Call your broker into the game if your agent is stymied by a tough problem or if you’re having problems with the agent. Everything an agent does or fails to do is ultimately the broker’s responsibility. After all, the broker’s job is to help make your problems go away.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team
Handling House Inspectors Houses in good physical condition sell for top dollar. Fixer-uppers sell at greatly reduced prices because whoever buys them must spend money on repairs to get them back into pristine condition. Even if you’ve lived in your house for the past 20 years, it may have hidden problems you know nothing about. You probably can’t see, for example, whether your house’s electrical system is shot or whether dry rot is turning the woodwork into sawdust or whether the roof is one rainstorm away from springing a Niagara of leaks. Invisible defects can be deal breakers because they cost major money to repair. The more you know about your house’s hidden problems, the better you can effectively deal with those problems. For that reason, we recommend that you have your property thoroughly inspected before putting it on the market.
Arranging premarketing property inspections Count on it. Prudent purchasers will have your property thoroughly inspected before they buy it. Expect inspectors to poke into everything — your house’s roof, chimney, gutters, plumbing, electrical wiring, heating and cooling systems, insulation, smoke detectors, all the permanent appliances and fixtures in your kitchen and bathrooms, and the foundation. They’ll also check for health, safety, and environmental hazards. If you live in a temperate climate, you can bet that they’ll have a structural pest control inspector look for damage from wood-destroying insects (carpenter ants, termites, and powderpost beetles) as well as dry rot and fungus infections. Whew! Flowers, fragrances, and all that other staging stuff aside, smart buyers know that a house’s physical condition greatly affects its value. No matter how beautifully your property is staged, buyers won’t pay top dollar for a house that needs extensive and expensive repairs.
Exploring the advantages of inspecting before marketing The best defense is a good offense. Beat buyers to the punch — get your inspections before they get theirs. Discover everything wrong with your house before putting it on the market. Defusing a crisis begins by discovering that a problem exists.
111
112
Part II: Tactical Considerations Some real estate agents argue against getting a house inspected before putting it on the market. As we explain in Chapter 8, many states now require that sellers disclose any known property defects to prospective buyers. These agents point out that you can’t tell buyers about problems if you don’t know that the problems exist. Handing buyers a long list of repair problems as they enter your house will turn many of them off. They recommend getting buyers emotionally committed to the property first, before their own inspectors drop the bomb. That line of reasoning is based on an ostrich-like logic: What you don’t know can’t get you in trouble — for a while, anyway. Agents may use a second argument to convince sellers not to get their own property inspections: Buyers generally won’t believe anything in reports paid for by sellers. According to these agents, buyers suspect that you’ll hire a goeasy inspector to falsely report that your house is as solid as the Rock of Gibraltar. Why spend several hundred dollars on an inspection report that buyers won’t believe? Again, you can find a nugget of truth in this argument. Only a suicidal chicken would ask the fox about how things are in the hen house. More than one unscrupulous seller has paid an equally unscrupulous inspector to write a false inspection report.
What you don’t know CAN get you in trouble One of San Francisco’s more infamous real estate horror stories involves a man trying to sell his house. He didn’t get his property inspected before putting it on the market because he was absolutely certain his house was in perfect condition. He should know. He had never experienced one single problem with it during nearly 25 years of ownership. The house showed beautifully and was priced to sell. He got a full asking price offer just two days after the house went up for sale — so far, so wonderful. About a week later, the seller was stunned to receive a copy of the buyer’s property inspection report stating that his house had a crumbling foundation and needed a new roof. According to three contractor estimates the buyers had obtained, repairs would cost about $45,000 for the indicated corrective work. The seller was convinced that the buyer’s inspector was an incompetent boob. He insisted
on getting a second inspection by an inspector of his choice to debunk the buyer’s report. The seller’s inspector confirmed everything in the buyer’s report and, worse yet for the seller, found additional damage that the first inspector had missed. The seller’s contractor estimated repairs would total nearly $60,000. Armed with the second report, the seller offered the buyers a $45,000 credit per their request. Too late. For some strange reason, the buyers now wanted a $60,000 corrective-work credit. The seller offered to split the difference between the two estimates, the buyers held out for $60,000, and the deal fell apart. The property sold nearly three months later, shortly after the seller reduced his asking price by $60,000 to compensate for the necessary repairs. By that time, the seller had learned a bitter truth: Killing the messenger doesn’t get rid of a corrective work problem.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team On the other hand, consider these four reasons to have your property thoroughly inspected before putting it on the market: Damage control: Suppose that your house needs a new roof. The problem is there whether you know about it or not. Why wait passively for an ultimatum to fix the roof at a cost established by the buyer’s inspection or kiss the deal goodbye? If you discover the problem before marketing the house, you can either disclose it to prospective buyers with a repair estimate or, although — as noted in Chapter 9 — we don’t recommend this, you can do the work before putting your house up for sale. Your negotiating position is much stronger if you know about problems in advance — and accurately know the cost to correct them. You can’t lose what you never had. Some buyers won’t want to tour your house if they know that it needs a great deal of repair work. Those buyers don’t want a fixer-upper. Even if you paid for all the repairs, they still wouldn’t buy your house. Forget them. Concentrate on buyers who are willing to do corrective work after the close of escrow if your price and terms are fair. Financial planning: Chapter 3 explains that it’s very important to have a realistic estimate of your present house’s net proceeds of sale before committing to buy a new home. Asking prices aren’t sale prices. If your house needs major repairs, you’ll pay for them one way or another — either by doing the repairs yourself, by reducing your asking price to reflect the cost of repairs, or by giving buyers a credit in escrow to do the work. Latent defects — flaws hidden out of sight behind walls or concealed in inaccessible areas, such as under your house or up in the attic where you can’t see them — are time bombs. Defects you can’t see and don’t know about (such as faulty wiring, a cracked heat-exchanger in your furnace, asbestos insulation, lead in your water pipes, and so on) are potential deal killers. A good premarketing inspection can reveal all these problems. Fine tuning: Professional property inspectors can help you spot minor defects, such as dirty filters in the heating system; ventilation problems in the basement, garage, or crawl space; blocked gutters; loose doorknobs; stuck windows; a missing chimney hood or spark arrester, and so on. Eliminating small maintenance problems like these gives prospective buyers who tour the property a favorable — and correct — impression that your house is extremely well-maintained. Peace of mind: The inspector alerts you to health and safety precautions you should take. Installing smoke detectors, grounding electrical outlets, clearing a clogged sewer line, and keeping flammable products away from furnaces, heaters, and fireplaces, for example, make your house safer for the next owner and safer for you as long as you continue living in it.
113
114
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Investigating inspectors Quite a few so-called house inspectors have neither the background nor the special training required to do premarketing house inspections. Compounding your problem of finding a qualified inspector, few states certify, license, or regulate house inspectors. And, as we all know from personal experience with government regulation, states that do regulate house inspectors don’t always do a good job. Anyone with a clipboard, a pickup truck, and a decent houseside manner can instantly anoint himself or herself a house inspector nearly anywhere in the country. Avoid contractors who graciously offer to inspect your house and then do repairs that they discover during their inspection. If, like us, you’re mechanically challenged, unscrupulous contractors can use your ignorance to fatten their wallets by billing you for phony corrective work they create themselves. The best way around this conflict of interest is to hire someone who only performs property inspections — a professional property inspector, not a contractor wearing two hats. Doing property inspections requires special expertise that not all contractors, engineers, and architects have. Good professional property inspectors earn their living solely from inspection fees and don’t do corrective work. This restriction removes any temptation to find unnecessary corrective work during inspections.
Finding property inspectors Locating house inspectors is usually quite easy. One good source of property inspectors is the Yellow Pages of your local phone book under “Building Inspection Services” or “Home Inspection Services.” You can also ask friends and business associates who’ve either bought or sold a house recently for the names of their property inspectors. If you’re working with an agent, ask the agent to recommend several highly regarded inspectors. Using a well-known inspector with an excellent reputation increases your report’s credibility. In the interest of full disclosure, allow prospective buyers to review your inspection report prior to making an offer if they want. However, encourage buyers to get their own inspections. Even the best inspector occasionally misses defects. If the buyers rely solely on your report and find repair problems after the sale is complete, you don’t want them claiming that you intentionally gave them a faulty inspection report to mislead them about your house’s condition. The American Society of Home Inspectors (ASHI) is a professional association of independent property inspectors. ASHI membership doesn’t guarantee that the inspector is competent, but hiring a member of this organization increases the likelihood that you’ll be working with a qualified professional. You can’t buy your way into the ASHI by paying a fee. All ASHI-certified
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team members must have performed at least 250 property inspections and must pass two written proficiency exams as a prerequisite of membership. ASHI members must also adhere to the ASHI standards of practice, continuing education requirements, and code of ethics. To find members in your area, call ASHI at (800) 743-ASHI (2744) or visit its Web site at www.ashi.com.
Selecting your inspector Choosing the right inspector takes a little effort. We recommend that you interview several property inspectors before hiring one. The following questions can help you select the best inspector: Are you a full-time, professional property inspector? The only satisfactory answer is yes. How many houses do you personally inspect annually? Although the number of inspections varies from area to area, active inspectors usually average from 100 to 300 inspections per year. Be sure that the inspector works primarily in the vicinity of your house and is familiar with local building regulations and codes as well as local problems (such as mud slides, earthquakes, floods, or tornadoes). Do you have any special certifications or licenses? Property inspectors generally have experience in some related field (such as construction, architecture, or engineering) or have worked as an electrician, plumber, or insurance-claim adjuster. This diversity brings extra depth to their inspections. Membership in ASHI or other trade associations indicates at least a minimal knowledge of house-inspection procedures. Ask about the size of the inspector’s company and how long the company has been in business. What’s the scope of your premarketing inspection? Be certain that the inspection covers all your house’s major structural and mechanical systems, inside and out, from foundation to roof. Anything less is unacceptable. Thoroughly inspecting a house or condo of average size usually takes three to four hours. You probably won’t be invited to join the buyers when their property inspector goes through your property. That’s why it’s critically important that you (and your agent, if possible) tag along when your inspector does the premarketing inspection. Reading the best report ever written is no substitute for seeing defects with your own eyes and hearing your inspector’s commentary on the significant findings. Use this opportunity to question the inspector about a defect’s ramifications and explore corrective work alternatives. After completing the inspection, you understand why some defects cost megabucks to fix, and others are no big deal. Will your report include a cost estimate for you to do necessary corrective work? Trick question. If the inspector says yes, don’t use the inspector. Good property inspectors only do inspections. They don’t do
115
116
Part II: Tactical Considerations repair work themselves or generate referral fees for themselves by sending work to their pals. A good inspector can, however, help you determine repair costs by giving you a list of reputable contractors, roofers, electricians, plumbers, and other tradespeople who can give you corrective work quotes. Generally, more than one way is possible to fix a defect. You must decide the best way to deal with a problem after you consult the appropriate repair people. What type of report will I receive? Verbal reports and boilerplate, checklist reports are usually worthless. You need a written, narrative-type report that provides a detailed description of your house’s mechanical and structural condition and clearly explains the implications of the findings in plain English. Get a sample report from each inspector you interview. The best way to find out if an inspector writes good reports is to read one and draw your own conclusion. We thoughtfully include a premarketing inspection report in Appendix B so you know exactly what a good report looks like. Do you have errors-and-omissions (E & O) insurance? To err, unfortunately, is all too human. Even the best inspector misses a defect or two every now an then, which is why good property inspectors carry E & O insurance. If your inspector accidentally makes a boo-boo that costs you big bucks, E & O insurance can help ease your pain. May I call your recent customers for references? Good inspectors happily give you names and phone numbers for all the satisfied customers you want. Bad inspectors, by definition, don’t have satisfied customers. Check at least three references per inspector. Ask references if, after the transaction was completed, major defects were discovered that the inspector missed. Also see if they’d hire the inspector again. How much will your inspection cost? A good inspection can cost anywhere from $350 to $800 depending on the property’s size, the inspection’s scope and degree of detail, and where the property is located — inspections cost least in the Midwest and South; they’re much more expensive in urban areas of New York and California. Beware of unrealistically low, “this week only” promotional fees offered by new inspectors just starting in the business. Don’t let inexperienced inspectors practice on you. See if the premarketing inspection includes an additional consultation at a later date to discuss the report’s findings with buyers who make an offer to purchase your house. Because time is money, the inspector probably adds an extra charge for this service. The fee is worth every penny, though, if the property inspector’s explanation helps you negotiate a lower corrective work credit.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team
The Officiating Escrow Officer Even the simplest house sale involves many details that must be resolved to everyone’s satisfaction before the sale can be completed. Without someone to bridge the gulf between mutual buyer and seller distrust that exists in most transactions, deals would grind to a halt. Bridging that gulf of distrust, real estate (like other team sports) engages the escrow officer, a referee who keeps the game civilized. Escrow officers aren’t on anyone’s team; they’re neutral. They act as a disinterested third party for buyers and sellers without showing favoritism to either party. After you and the buyer have a signed contract, all the documents, funds, and instructions related to your transaction usually are given to the escrow holder specified in your purchase agreement by the buyer’s agent. We cover this process, known as opening an escrow, in detail in Chapter 15. Buyers and sellers often select an escrow holder based on the recommendations of their real estate agents. Depending on the location of your property, local custom dictates whether your escrow is handled by a lawyer, bank, real estate broker, or the firm that issues the title insurance. Escrow fees range from a few hundred dollars to several thousand dollars and are based on your property’s sale price. Once again, local custom nearly always determines whether the buyer or seller pays for escrow, or whether escrow fees are split 50/50. However, as Chapter 15 explains, this item often is negotiable.
Finding Financial and Tax Advisors If you need the services of another advisor, such as a tax or financial advisor, find one who works by the hour and doesn’t have a vested interest — because they sell investments or manage money for an ongoing fee — in your houseselling decision. Few financial advisors work on this basis. Although tax advisors are more likely than financial advisors to work for an hourly fee, they tend to have a narrower-than-needed financial perspective. A competent tax advisor may be able to help you structure the sale to maximize your tax benefits. For most transactions, however, a tax advisor is unnecessary. If you want to hire a financial or tax advisor, interview several before you select one. Check with your agent, banker, lawyer, business associates, and friends for referrals. As is the case with selecting your agent, you should get client references from each tax advisor and call the references.
117
118
Part II: Tactical Considerations A good financial or tax advisor should possess the following qualities: Does the advisor work full time in this occupation? The realm of personal finances and taxes is too vast for you to trust a part-timer. You need the services of a full-time professional. Does the advisor speak your language? Good advisors can explain your options in simple terms. If you don’t understand exactly what the tax advisor is saying, ask for clarification. If you still don’t understand, get another tax advisor. Is the advisor objective? Hire someone who works solely by the hour and doesn’t have a vested interest in the advice that they give you. Never blindly follow the advice of experts because you’re in awe of their expertise. Experts can be just as wrong as ordinary mortals. What is the advisor’s fee schedule? Hourly fees vary widely. Don’t pick someone strictly on a cost-per-hour basis. An advisor who’s just beginning to practice, for example, may only charge half as much as one with 20 years of experience. If the rookie takes four hours to do what the old pro does in an hour, which advisor is more expensive in the long run? Furthermore, the quality of the seasoned veteran’s advice may be superior to the quality of the novice’s advice. Is the tax advisor a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) or Enrolled Agent (EA)? These professional designations indicate that the tax advisor has satisfied special education and experience requirements and has passed a rigorous licensing exam. A CPA does general accounting and prepares tax returns. An EA focuses specifically on taxation. Only CPAs, Enrolled Agents, and attorneys are authorized to represent you before the IRS in the event of an audit. Does the tax advisor have experience with real estate transactions? Tax practice, like law or medicine, is an extremely broad field. The tax advisors that big corporations use may be wonderful, but they aren’t necessarily best for you. You need a tax advisor whose clients have tax problems like yours. The best advisors in the world can’t do much to change the financial and tax consequences of a transaction after the deal is done. If you’re going to consult advisors, do so before you make significant financial decisions.
Locating a Good Lawyer Lawyers are like seat belts. You never know when you may need one. Your deal is rolling merrily along when out of nowhere — slam, bam, wham — you hit a legal pothole and end up in Sue City.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team The real estate purchase agreement you sign is a legally binding contract between you and the buyer. If you have any questions about the legality of your contract, get a lawyer on your team immediately. No one else on the team is qualified to give you legal advice. Suppose the buyer’s contract is presented to you at night or on a weekend when a lawyer isn’t readily available. Put a clause in the contract to stipulate that your acceptance is contingent upon review and approval of the contract by an attorney of your choice within five business days after you sign it. To determine whether you need a lawyer on your team, check out the following factors: If no agent is involved: For example, suppose that you’re selling your house by yourself. If neither you nor the buyer has an agent, get a lawyer to prepare the contract, and have the lawyer do the work that an agent would normally handle. As Chapter 6 explains, eliminating the real estate agent doesn’t eliminate the disclosures, inspections, contingency removals, and other details involved in the house-selling process. The location of your property: In states such as California, lawyers rarely work on deals that only involve filling in the blanks on a standard, preprinted purchase agreement that’s been previously reviewed and approved by members of the state bar association. In other states, however, lawyers routinely do everything from preparing purchase contracts to closing the escrow. Your agent, if you’re working with one, knows the role that lawyers play in your locale. The complexity of your transaction: You need a lawyer if you get into a complex financial or legal situation that can’t be covered by a standardized contract. For example, suppose that you hold title as a tenantin-common and are selling a partial interest in the property, or that you want to structure the transaction as an intricate installment sale. Whatever. Unless your agent also is a lawyer, the agent isn’t qualified to do creative legal writing. If consulting an attorney helps you sleep at night: You may have the world’s easiest deal. Still, if you feel more comfortable having a lawyer review the contract, your peace of mind certainly is worth the cost of an hour or two of legal time.
Choosing among lawyers If, for whatever reason, you decide that you need a lawyer, interview several before making your selection. Real estate law, like medicine, is highly specialized. A corporate attorney or the lawyer who handled your neighbor’s
119
120
Part II: Tactical Considerations divorce isn’t necessarily the best choice for your real estate team. Get a lawyer who specializes in residential real estate transactions. Good agents and brokers usually are excellent referral sources because they work with real estate lawyers all the time in their transactions. A lawyer working for you needs to have the following qualities in her favor: Is a full-time lawyer and licensed to practice law in your state: Of course. Is local talent: Real estate law, like real estate brokerage, not only varies from state to state, it also changes from area to area within the same state. Rent control laws, condominium conversion statutes, and zoning codes, for example, usually are formulated and adopted by city or county governing agencies. A good local lawyer knows these laws and has working relationships with people who administer them in your area. Has a realistic fee schedule: Lawyers’ fees vary widely. A good lawyer gives you an estimate of how much it costs to handle your situation. As with financial and tax advisors, the experience factor comes into play. Seasoned lawyers generally charge more than novice lawyers, but seasoned lawyers also may get more done in an hour than inexperienced lawyers can. A low fee is no bargain if the novice is learning on your nickel. And you may pay the consequences if the novice fails to handle your case properly. Has a good track record: If the lawyer you consult thinks that your case may go to trial, find out whether that lawyer has courtroom experience or intends to refer you to another lawyer. (Some lawyers don’t do trial work.) Always ask about the lawyer’s track record of wins versus losses. What good is a lawyer with a great deal of trial experience if that lawyer never wins a case? Is a deal maker or a deal breaker (whichever is appropriate): Some lawyers are great at putting deals together. Others specialize in blowing them out of the water. Each skill is important. Depending on whether you want the lawyer to get you out of a deal so you can accept a better offer or need legal assistance to keep your deal together, be sure that you have the right type of lawyer for your situation. If your lawyer’s only solution to every problem is a lawsuit, you may be in the clutches of a deal breaker who wants to run up big legal fees. Find another lawyer! Speaks your language: A good lawyer explains your options clearly and concisely without resorting to incomprehensible legalese. Then she gives you a risk assessment of your options to help you make a sound decision. For example, the lawyer may say that one course of action will take longer but will give you a 90 percent chance of success, whereas the faster option only gives you a 50/50 chance of prevailing.
Chapter 7: Your Real Estate Team
Working well with your lawyer Whoever said that an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure must’ve been thinking of lawyers. A two-hour preventative consultation with your lawyer is infinitely less expensive than a two-month trial. Good lawyers are excellent strategists. Given adequate lead time, they can structure nearly any deal to your advantage. Conversely, if you bring wonderful lawyers into the game after the deal is done, all they can do is damage control. The best defense is a good offense. Beware of the awe factor. People tend to hold lawyers in awe because their word is law. Disobey lawyers and you go to jail. Baloney. Don’t blindly follow your lawyer’s advice. If you don’t understand the advice or if you disagree with it, question it. You may be correct and the lawyer may be wrong. Lawyers are every bit as fallible as everyone else.
121
122
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Chapter 8
Listing Contracts and Commissions In This Chapter Knowing the A-to-Zs of listing contracts Checking out the different types of listing terms Exploring broker compensation Setting up your disclosure statements
T
he single most important contract that you sign throughout the entire process of selling your house is the one between you and the person who ultimately buys your property. Without that contract, you’d never be anything more than a property owner who wants to be a seller. What’s the second most important contract? If you guessed the listing contract that you sign with the agent you hire to help sell your house, you win an all-expenses-paid trip to the next paragraph. You’ve probably heard of listings, but most folks don’t really understand what listings are or how they operate. We’re not talking about a listing of names in a phone book. Nor does this listing have anything to do with transferring ownership of your property to buyers. This chapter spells out everything you need to know about listing contracts and tips on how you can negotiate commissions with agents.
Understanding Listing Contracts In the context of selling property, a listing contract is a personal service contract between you and a licensed real estate broker. This contract authorizes the broker to act as your agent by finding someone to buy your house. The listing contract contains two basic promises: The broker promises to do his or her best to find a buyer for your property, and you promise to pay the broker a commission.
124
Part II: Tactical Considerations Sounds simple, doesn’t it? Legally speaking (because listings are meant to be legally binding agreements), the definition of a listing contract is a bit more complex: An employment contract: A listing contract specifies the exact terms and conditions of your employment contract with a licensed real estate broker. It also authorizes the broker to represent you during the sale of your property. As Chapter 7 explains, if the real estate agent you select to work with doesn’t have a broker’s license or isn’t the broker of record for the office, a licensed broker must supervise the agent and be responsible for everything he does or fails to do. A compensation agreement: Although the listing broker’s pay is almost always a commission based on a specified percentage of the sale price, compensation doesn’t have to be a commission. Other possible options include paying your broker a set fee for selling the property or compensating the broker on an hourly fee basis. Regardless of how the broker is paid, compensation is a negotiable item decided by mutual agreement between you and the broker. Although the listing contract doesn’t obligate you to sell your house, it may obligate you to pay the broker a commission even if you don’t sell. The key is whether the broker gets you an “acceptable” offer. You may think that an acceptable offer is any offer a buyer makes to purchase your house that you’d be willing to sign. If an offer isn’t acceptable to you, you won’t sign it. But suppose that your broker brings you a valid, written offer made by a ready, willing, and able buyer who wants to purchase your house for the exact price and terms specified in your listing contract. You reject the offer solely because you don’t like the buyer’s red tennis shoes. In this example, you probably owe the broker a commission, even though you didn’t accept the offer. Technically speaking, whether you ultimately sell the house to the buyer who submitted the offer doesn’t matter if the buyer met your price and terms. “That’s not fair,” you say. “If I decide not to sell, why should I pay a commission?” The answer: Because you agreed to those terms when you signed the listing. The broker found a buyer who was ready to accept your terms, willing to enter into a contract of sale with you, and financially able to buy your property. The listing agreement doesn’t specify that you actually have to sell your property. If your broker fulfills his end of the contract by procuring an acceptable buyer, you must honor your promise and pay the broker. Buyers and agents almost always cooperate with sellers who are forced to cancel a transaction because of the sudden occurrence of some dire unforeseen situation beyond their control, such as job loss or a death in the family. They may get upset, though, if a seller suddenly decides not to go through with a deal for no good reason.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions Breaking any contract may have serious legal consequences. A listing contract is a legal contract. Don’t list your property on a lark just to test the water — the water could get boiling hot quickly.
Considering the Types of Listings Some brokers are so desperate for listings that they take oral listings. A broker may, for example, introduce himself to you at a party, tell you he has always admired your house, and ask if you’re interested in selling it. To brush him off, you say that you may sell “at the right price.” He responds that he’ll see what he can do for you. The next thing you know, you’re besieged day and night by eager buyers waving lowball offers in your face. Take one guess about who told these vultures your house was for sale. Oral listings are a no-no. Samuel Goldwyn, the famous movie producer, once said, “A verbal agreement isn’t worth the paper it’s written on.” Heed his advice. If you want an enforceable contract, get the contract in writing and always get a file copy of anything you sign (listing contract, purchase contract, and so on) as soon as you sign it. ’Nuf said. At first glance, you may think that you can choose from many different kinds of listings. Appearances are, as usual, deceiving. All your various listing options boil down to variations on two types of listings: exclusive listings and open listings. This section gives you the lowdown.
Exclusive listings An exclusive listing is exactly that — an exclusive authorization giving only one broker the right to find a buyer for your house. As simple as it sounds, an exclusive listing contract can take two different forms.
Exclusive agency listings The broker designated in an exclusive agency listing is the one and only agent authorized to sell your house during the term of the listing. If any other licensed real estate broker or agent finds a buyer, your broker gets paid. Even so, brokers think that this form of exclusive listing is just barely better than no listing at all. About now you may be wondering about the downside from the broker’s perspective? After all, you authorize the broker to be your sole agent. You’re not playing the field with 50 or 100 other brokers on a winner-take-all basis. So what’s the problem? You, dear house seller.
125
126
Part II: Tactical Considerations Because you aren’t a licensed real estate agent, the listing contract excludes you. Under the terms of an exclusive agency listing, owners specifically reserve the right to sell their own house directly and ace the broker out of a commission. Your broker — who should be your strongest ally — is your competitor. The adversarial relationship isn’t good for you or your broker. Exclusive agency listings discourage brokers from spending time or money marketing property because the arrangement offers no assurance of a reward for their efforts. Keeping listed property a secret isn’t the best way to sell it quickly for top dollar.
Exclusive right to sell listings An exclusive right to sell listing is also referred to as an exclusive authorization and right to sell or just a plain, old exclusive. The exclusive is the most widely used form of listing contract in the United States. It’s popular with sellers and brokers because it provides the following: Maximum incentive for brokers: Under this form of exclusive listing, the listing broker gets paid if anyone — even the owner — finds a ready, willing, and able buyer for the property during the life of the contract. Owner and broker are allies, not adversaries, with a mutually beneficial goal of getting the listed property sold as quickly as possible for as much money as possible. (See the nearby sidebar, “Listing exclusions: Avoiding a commission by selling to friends,” for information about listing exclusions, the one way you can sell your property without paying a commission.) Maximum effort for seller: An exclusive right to sell listing gives your listing broker a strong monetary incentive to focus his or her time, energy, and advertising dollars on one priority — a fast, top-dollar sale of your house. To that end, the listing broker should immediately cooperate with any and all other brokers who may have buyers for your property by offering to split the compensation 50/50 (or whatever split is customary in your area) with the broker who generates a ready, willing, and able buyer. You know that you’re dealing with a bad broker if she wants to keep your listing quiet for several weeks before advertising it and opening it up to cooperating brokers. Greedy brokers sit on listings to give themselves and the agents in their offices time to sell your house to buyers with whom they’re working. They want someone in their office to generate an offer for your property so the listing office can get the entire commission. Brokers call this tactic “getting both ends of a deal.” From your perspective, a more apt description would be “getting the shaft.” Chapter 11 reveals that the secret of getting a top-dollar price when you sell is to generate spirited buyer competition for your house by getting broad, immediate market exposure. Nothing is terribly wrong with giving your listing broker a day or two head start on other brokers, if you approve. A broker who wants to keep your listing in-house more than 48 hours, however, is unworthy of being your listing agent.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions
Listing exclusions: Avoiding a commission by selling to friends Suppose that you invited your best friends over to your house last year for Thanksgiving dinner. After a magnificent feast, you’re all sitting by the fireplace eating scrumptious slices of pumpkin pie. Basking contentedly in the fire’s rosy glow, your pal Martin says, “You know Faye (his wife) and I have always admired your home. If you ever decide you want to sell it, let us know. We would buy your place in a nanosecond.” You may have heard something like that from friends or business associates. When push comes to shove, however, nothing usually comes of these conversations. Talk is cheap. But what if Martin and Faye really meant it? If there’s even one chance in a thousand that they were serious, why pay a broker to find buyers until you give your pals a chance to put up or shut up? You can use a perfectly acceptable method to avoid paying a commission for people you identify as potential buyers of your house. This method is called a listing exclusion. You can amend your listing agreement so that if Faye and Martin — or anyone else you specifically exclude from the listing — actually purchases your house during the exclusion period, you won’t have to pay the broker a commission. Always put a time limit on listing exclusions. A couple of weeks usually is enough time for serious buyers to explore their financial options and get back to you with a decision. For example, tell your broker that you want a two-week exclusion for Martin and Faye. Don’t sign the listing unless
the broker agrees to the exclusion and further agrees not to market your house at all during those two weeks. If the broker agrees to these stipulations, sign the listing. By listing your house with a broker, your actions prove to Faye and Martin that you’re a serious seller. By putting a fuse on the listing exclusion, you establish a time frame within which they must act or be treated like any other buyers. Without a deadline, folks tend to stall by asking for more time to think it over. Don’t make the mistake of giving any buyers you exclude additional time. How long can you put your life on hold while they think it over? What’s to think over? Either they want to buy your house, or they don’t want to buy it. Real buyers will tie up your property with a contract of sale as fast as possible. During the two-week exclusion period, you don’t have to worry about paying a commission to the broker. If Martin and Faye make an offer you can’t refuse, you simply cancel the listing and sell the house to your friends. The broker won’t be upset because she didn’t waste any time or money marketing your house. If, however, the two weeks pass without an offer from your pals, your house goes on the market without the stigma of any exclusions. And you have the comfort of knowing that you explored the possibility of avoiding a commission by selling directly to your friends.
Exclusive right to sell listing contracts vary widely in length, wording, and complexity from one state to another and from city to city within any given state. Under these circumstances, the listing contract you ultimately sign probably won’t look exactly like the California Association of Realtors (C.A.R.) exclusive listing contract shown in Figures 8-1a, 8-1b, and 8-1c. The C.A.R. listing is, nonetheless, a fine example of a well-written, comprehensive listing agreement.
127
128
Part II: Tactical Considerations Regardless of the wording in your contract, here are a few fundamental facts to keep in mind about all exclusive listings: Listings are intended to be legal contracts. Real estate agents hate the word contract because it scares people and puts them on guard. They prefer to call contracts agreements because agreements sound less threatening. Whatever your listing is called, the intent is to create a legally binding contract between you and the listing broker. Read it carefully. Consult a real estate lawyer if you have questions or concerns about the listing’s fine points. Agents aren’t qualified to answer legal questions. An exclusive listing must have a definite termination date. Note that paragraph 1 of the form in Figure 8-1a provides a “Listing Period” commencing on a specific date and expiring at 11:59 p.m. on an equally specific date. Don’t sign any exclusive listing that starts when the contract is prepared and runs “until sold” or “until canceled in writing” or any other type of indefinite duration. A broker protection clause keeps everyone honest. Just as a few real estate agents are dishonest, some sellers and buyers also behave unethically. For example, a seller may tell an interested buyer that the listing contract with the broker is about to expire. Without a broker, the seller won’t have to pay a commission. The seller offers to pass on a portion of the savings to the buyer by lowering the asking price, if they sign the deal after the listing contract’s expiration date. Paragraph 4.A. (2) of the sample listing contract shown in Figure 8-1a is known as the broker protection clause. This clause prohibits (for a specified period of time) the homeowner from selling directly to a buyer. If a broker finds a suitable buyer for a property, the clause requires that the seller pay the broker’s commission according to the listing contract. Brokers generally ask for at least a 90-day buffer period. The time frame is, however, negotiable. In most cases, 30 to 60 days gives the broker sufficient protection. Regardless of the buffer period you agree to, be sure that the broker protection clause in your listing contract includes this statement: This section shall not apply if Seller enters into a valid listing agreement with another licensed real estate broker after the final termination of this agreement. This clause protects you from the possibility of paying two commissions if you relist your house with a second broker and a dispute develops after the first broker’s listing expires. Title verification is critically important. Paragraph 5 of the sample listing contract in Figure 8-1b asks who has title to the property, because anyone who signs a listing contract obligates himself to pay a commission, even if that person ultimately can only convey a partial interest in the property.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions
CALIFORNIA A S S O C I AT I O N OF REALTORS®
RESIDENTIAL LISTING AGREEMENT (Exclusive Authorization and Right to Sell) (C.A.R. Form RLA, Revised 4/07)
E PL M SA
a1. EXCLUSIVE RIGHT TO SELL: ________________________________________________________________________ (“Seller”) hereby employs and grants ___________________________________________________________________________ (“Broker”) beginning (date) ________________________ and ending at 11:59 P.M. on (date) _________________________ (“Listing Period”) the exclusive and irrevocable right to sell or exchange the real property in the City of _____________________________________, County of____________________________________________, Assessor’s Parcel No. _____________________________, California, described as:____________________________________________________________________________ (“Property”). 2. ITEMS EXCLUDED AND INCLUDED: Unless otherwise specified in a real estate purchase agreement, all fixtures and fittings that are attached to the Property are included, and personal property items are excluded, from the purchase price. ADDITIONAL ITEMS EXCLUDED: ___________________________________________________________________________. ADDITIONAL ITEMS INCLUDED: ___________________________________________________________________________. Seller intends that the above items be excluded or included in offering the Property for sale, but understands that: (i) the purchase agreement supersedes any intention expressed above and will ultimately determine which items are excluded and included in the sale; and (ii) Broker is not responsible for and does not guarantee that the above exclusions and/or inclusions will be in the purchase agreement. 3. LISTING PRICE AND TERMS: A. The listing price shall be: _________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________ Dollars ($ ____________________________). B. Additional Terms: ______________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________.
4. COMPENSATION TO BROKER: Notice: The amount or rate of real estate commissions is not fixed by law. They are set by each Broker individually and may be negotiable between Seller and Broker (real estate commissions include all compensation and fees to Broker). A.
OR
OR B.
C. D.
E. F.
Figure 8-1a: Your exclusive listing contract may look something like this.
Seller agrees to pay to Broker as compensation for services irrespective of agency relationship(s), either _________ percent of the listing price (or if a purchase agreement is entered into, of the purchase price), or $ ___________________________, AND ________________________________________________________________________________________, as follows: (1) If during the Listing Period, or any extension, Broker, Seller, cooperating broker, or any other person procures a buyer(s) who offers to purchase the Property on the above price and terms, or on any price and terms acceptable to Seller. (Broker is entitled to compensation whether any escrow resulting from such offer closes during or after the expiration of the Listing Period.) (2) If within ______ calendar days (a) after the end of the Listing Period or any extension; or (b) after any cancellation of this Agreement, unless otherwise agreed, Seller enters into a contract to sell, convey, lease or otherwise transfer the Property to anyone (“Prospective Buyer”) or that person’s related entity: (i) who physically entered and was shown the Property during the Listing Period or any extension by Broker or a cooperating broker; or (ii) for whom Broker or any cooperating broker submitted to Seller a signed, written offer to acquire, lease, exchange or obtain an option on the Property. Seller, however, shall have no obligation to Broker under paragraph 4A(2) unless, not later than 3 calendar days after the end of the Listing Period or any extension or cancellation, Broker has given Seller a written notice of the names of such Prospective Buyers. (3) If, without Broker’s prior written consent, the Property is withdrawn from sale, conveyed, leased, rented, otherwise transferred, or made unmarketable by a voluntary act of Seller during the Listing Period, or any extension. If completion of the sale is prevented by a party to the transaction other than Seller, then compensation due under paragraph 4A shall be payable only if and when Seller collects damages by suit, arbitration, settlement or otherwise, and then in an amount equal to the lesser of one-half of the damages recovered or the above compensation, after first deducting title and escrow expenses and the expenses of collection, if any. In addition, Seller agrees to pay Broker: _____________________________________________________________________. Seller has been advised of Broker’s policy regarding cooperation with, and the amount of compensation offered to, other brokers. (1) Broker is authorized to cooperate with and compensate brokers participating through the multiple listing service(s) (“MLS”) by offering MLS brokers either _________ percent of the purchase price, or $_____________________. (2) Broker is authorized to cooperate with and compensate brokers operating outside the MLS as per Broker’s policy. Seller hereby irrevocably assigns to Broker the above compensation from Seller’s funds and proceeds in escrow. Broker may submit this Agreement, as instructions to compensate Broker pursuant to paragraph 4A, to any escrow regarding the Property involving Seller and a buyer, Prospective Buyer or other transferee. (1) Seller represents that Seller has not previously entered into a listing agreement with another broker regarding the Property, unless specified as follows: ___________________________________________________________________________. (2) Seller warrants that Seller has no obligation to pay compensation to any other broker regarding the Property unless the Property is transferred to any of the following individuals or entities: ___________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________. (3) If the Property is sold to anyone listed above during the time Seller is obligated to compensate another broker: (i) Broker is not entitled to compensation under this Agreement; and (ii) Broker is not obligated to represent Seller in such transaction.
The copyright laws of the United States (Title 17 U.S. Code) forbid the unauthorized reproduction of this form, or any portion thereof, by photocopy machine or any other means, including facsimile or computerized formats. Copyright © 1991-2007, CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS®, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
RLA REVISED 4/07 (PAGE 1 OF 3) Print Date
Seller acknowledges receipt of a copy of this page. Seller’s Initials (__________)(__________) Reviewed by _______ Date _______
RESIDENTIAL LISTING AGREEMENT - EXCLUSIVE (RLA PAGE 1 OF 3)
Reprinted with permission, CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS ™. Endorsement not implied.
129
130
Part II: Tactical Considerations Property Address: ______________________________________________________________________ Date: ________________ 5.
6.
8.
9. 10.
11.
12.
Figure 8-1b: Sample exclusive listing contract, continued.
13. 14. 15.
16.
E PL M SA
7.
OWNERSHIP, TITLE AND AUTHORITY: Seller warrants that: (i) Seller is the owner of the Property; (ii) no other persons or entities have title to the Property; and (iii) Seller has the authority to both execute this Agreement and sell the Property. Exceptions to ownership, title and authority are as follows: ____________________________________________________________________. MULTIPLE LISTING SERVICE: All terms of the transaction, including financing, if applicable, will be provided to the selected MLS for publication, dissemination and use by persons and entities on terms approved by the MLS. Seller authorizes Broker to comply with all applicable MLS rules. MLS rules allow MLS data to be made available by the MLS to additional Internet sites unless Broker gives the MLS instructions to the contrary. MLS rules generally provide that residential real property and vacant lot listings be submitted to the MLS within 48 hours or some other period of time after all necessary signatures have been obtained on the listing agreement. However, Broker will not have to submit this listing to the MLS if, within that time, Broker submits to the MLS a form signed by Seller (C.A.R. Form SEL or the locally required form) instructing Broker to withhold the listing from the MLS. Information about this listing will be provided to the MLS of Broker’s selection unless a form instructing Broker to withhold the listing from the MLS is attached to this listing Agreement. SELLER REPRESENTATIONS: Seller represents that, unless otherwise specified in writing, Seller is unaware of: (i) any Notice of Default recorded against the Property; (ii) any delinquent amounts due under any loan secured by, or other obligation affecting, the Property; (iii) any bankruptcy, insolvency or similar proceeding affecting the Property; (iv) any litigation, arbitration, administrative action, government investigation or other pending or threatened action that affects or may affect the Property or Seller’s ability to transfer it; and (v) any current, pending or proposed special assessments affecting the Property. Seller shall promptly notify Broker in writing if Seller becomes aware of any of these items during the Listing Period or any extension thereof. BROKER’S AND SELLER’S DUTIES: Broker agrees to exercise reasonable effort and due diligence to achieve the purposes of this Agreement. Unless Seller gives Broker written instructions to the contrary, Broker is authorized to order reports and disclosures as appropriate or necessary and advertise and market the Property by any method and in any medium selected by Broker, including MLS and the Internet, and, to the extent permitted by these media, control the dissemination of the information submitted to any medium. Seller agrees to consider offers presented by Broker, and to act in good faith to accomplish the sale of the Property by, among other things, making the Property available for showing at reasonable times and referring to Broker all inquiries of any party interested in the Property. Seller is responsible for determining at what price to list and sell the Property. Seller further agrees to indemnify, defend and hold Broker harmless from all claims, disputes, litigation, judgments and attorney fees arising from any incorrect information supplied by Seller, or from any material facts that Seller knows but fails to disclose. DEPOSIT: Broker is authorized to accept and hold on Seller’s behalf any deposits to be applied toward the purchase price. AGENCY RELATIONSHIPS: A. Disclosure: If the Property includes residential property with one-to-four dwelling units, Seller shall receive a “Disclosure Regarding Agency Relationships” form prior to entering into this Agreement. B. Seller Representation: Broker shall represent Seller in any resulting transaction, except as specified in paragraph 4F. C. Possible Dual Agency With Buyer: Depending upon the circumstances, it may be necessary or appropriate for Broker to act as an agent for both Seller and buyer, exchange party, or one or more additional parties (“Buyer”). Broker shall, as soon as practicable, disclose to Seller any election to act as a dual agent representing both Seller and Buyer. If a Buyer is procured directly by Broker or an associate-licensee in Broker’s firm, Seller hereby consents to Broker acting as a dual agent for Seller and such Buyer. In the event of an exchange, Seller hereby consents to Broker collecting compensation from additional parties for services rendered, provided there is disclosure to all parties of such agency and compensation. Seller understands and agrees that: (i) Broker, without the prior written consent of Seller, will not disclose to Buyer that Seller is willing to sell the Property at a price less than the listing price; (ii) Broker, without the prior written consent of Buyer, will not disclose to Seller that Buyer is willing to pay a price greater than the offered price; and (iii) except for (i) and (ii) above, a dual agent is obligated to disclose known facts materially affecting the value or desirability of the Property to both parties. D. Other Sellers: Seller understands that Broker may have or obtain listings on other properties, and that potential buyers may consider, make offers on, or purchase through Broker, property the same as or similar to Seller’s Property. Seller consents to Broker’s representation of sellers and buyers of other properties before, during and after the end of this Agreement. E. Confirmation: If the Property includes residential property with one-to-four dwelling units, Broker shall confirm the agency relationship described above, or as modified, in writing, prior to or concurrent with Seller’s execution of a purchase agreement. SECURITY AND INSURANCE: Broker is not responsible for loss of or damage to personal or real property, or person, whether attributable to use of a keysafe/lockbox, a showing of the Property, or otherwise. Third parties, including, but not limited to, appraisers, inspectors, brokers and prospective buyers, may have access to, and take videos and photographs of, the interior of the Property. Seller agrees: (i) to take reasonable precautions to safeguard and protect valuables that might be accessible during showings of the Property; and (ii) to obtain insurance to protect against these risks. Broker does not maintain insurance to protect Seller. KEYSAFE/LOCKBOX: A keysafe/lockbox is designed to hold a key to the Property to permit access to the Property by Broker, cooperating brokers, MLS participants, their authorized licensees and representatives, authorized inspectors, and accompanied prospective buyers. Broker, cooperating brokers, MLS and Associations/Boards of REALTORS® are not insurers against injury, theft, loss, vandalism or damage attributed to the use of a keysafe/lockbox. Seller does (or if checked does not) authorize Broker to install a keysafe/lockbox. If Seller does not occupy the Property, Seller shall be responsible for obtaining occupant(s)’ written permission for use of a keysafe/lockbox. SIGN: Seller does (or if checked does not) authorize Broker to install a FOR SALE/SOLD sign on the Property. EQUAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITY: The Property is offered in compliance with federal, state and local anti-discrimination laws. ATTORNEY FEES: In any action, proceeding or arbitration between Seller and Broker regarding the obligation to pay compensation under this Agreement, the prevailing Seller or Broker shall be entitled to reasonable attorney fees and costs from the non-prevailing Seller or Broker, except as provided in paragraph 19A. ADDITIONAL TERMS: ____________________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________________________________ Seller acknowledges receipt of a copy of this page. Seller’s Initials (__________)(__________)
Copyright © 1991-2007, CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS®, INC.
RLA REVISED 4/07 (PAGE 2 OF 3)
Reviewed by _______ Date _______
RESIDENTIAL LISTING AGREEMENT - EXCLUSIVE (RLA PAGE 2 OF 3)
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions Property Address: ______________________________________________________________________ Date: ________________
E PL M SA
17. MANAGEMENT APPROVAL: If an associate-licensee in Broker’s office (salesperson or broker-associate) enters into this Agreement on Broker’s behalf, and Broker or Manager does not approve of its terms, Broker or Manager has the right to cancel this Agreement, in writing, within 5 Days After its execution. 18. SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS: This Agreement shall be binding upon Seller and Seller’s successors and assigns. 19. DISPUTE RESOLUTION: A. MEDIATION: Seller and Broker agree to mediate any dispute or claim arising between them out of this Agreement, or any resulting transaction, before resorting to arbitration or court action, subject to paragraph 19B(2) below. Paragraph 19B(2) below applies whether or not the arbitration provision is initialed. Mediation fees, if any, shall be divided equally among the parties involved. If, for any dispute or claim to which this paragraph applies, any party commences an action without first attempting to resolve the matter through mediation, or refuses to mediate after a request has been made, then that party shall not be entitled to recover attorney fees, even if they would otherwise be available to that party in any such action. THIS MEDIATION PROVISION APPLIES WHETHER OR NOT THE ARBITRATION PROVISION IS INITIALED. B. ARBITRATION OF DISPUTES: (1) Seller and Broker agree that any dispute or claim in law or equity arising between them regarding the obligation to pay compensation under this Agreement, which is not settled through mediation, shall be decided by neutral, binding arbitration, including and subject to paragraph 19B(2) below. The arbitrator shall be a retired judge or justice, or an attorney with at least 5 years of residential real estate law experience, unless the parties mutually agree to a different arbitrator, who shall render an award in accordance with substantive California law. The parties shall have the right to discovery in accordance with California Code of Civil Procedure §1283.05. In all other respects, the arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with Title 9 of Part III of the California Code of Civil Procedure. Judgment upon the award of the arbitrator(s) may be entered in any court having jurisdiction. Interpretation of this agreement to arbitrate shall be governed by the Federal Arbitration Act. (2) EXCLUSIONS FROM MEDIATION AND ARBITRATION: The following matters are excluded from mediation and arbitration: (i) a judicial or non-judicial foreclosure or other action or proceeding to enforce a deed of trust, mortgage, or installment land sale contract as defined in California Civil Code §2985; (ii) an unlawful detainer action; (iii) the filing or enforcement of a mechanic’s lien; and (iv) any matter that is within the jurisdiction of a probate, small claims, or bankruptcy court. The filing of a court action to enable the recording of a notice of pending action, for order of attachment, receivership, injunction, or other provisional remedies, shall not constitute a waiver of the mediation and arbitration provisions.
“NOTICE: BY INITIALING IN THE SPACE BELOW YOU ARE AGREEING TO HAVE ANY DISPUTE ARISING OUT OF THE MATTERS INCLUDED IN THE ‘ARBITRATION OF DISPUTES’ PROVISION DECIDED BY NEUTRAL ARBITRATION AS PROVIDED BY CALIFORNIA LAW AND YOU ARE GIVING UP ANY RIGHTS YOU MIGHT POSSESS TO HAVE THE DISPUTE LITIGATED IN A COURT OR JURY TRIAL. BY INITIALING IN THE SPACE BELOW YOU ARE GIVING UP YOUR JUDICIAL RIGHTS TO DISCOVERY AND APPEAL, UNLESS THOSE RIGHTS ARE SPECIFICALLY INCLUDED IN THE ‘ARBITRATION OF DISPUTES’ PROVISION. IF YOU REFUSE TO SUBMIT TO ARBITRATION AFTER AGREEING TO THIS PROVISION, YOU MAY BE COMPELLED TO ARBITRATE UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF THE CALIFORNIA CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE. YOUR AGREEMENT TO THIS ARBITRATION PROVISION IS VOLUNTARY.” “WE HAVE READ AND UNDERSTAND THE FOREGOING AND AGREE TO SUBMIT DISPUTES ARISING OUT OF THE MATTERS INCLUDED IN THE ‘ARBITRATION OF DISPUTES’ PROVISION TO NEUTRAL ARBITRATION.” Seller’s Initials ______/______ Broker’s Initials ______/______
20. ENTIRE AGREEMENT: All prior discussions, negotiations and agreements between the parties concerning the subject matter of this Agreement are superseded by this Agreement, which constitutes the entire contract and a complete and exclusive expression of their agreement, and may not be contradicted by evidence of any prior agreement or contemporaneous oral agreement. If any provision of this Agreement is held to be ineffective or invalid, the remaining provisions will nevertheless be given full force and effect. This Agreement and any supplement, addendum or modification, including any photocopy or facsimile, may be executed in counterparts. By signing below, Seller acknowledges that Seller has read, understands, received a copy of and agrees to the terms of this Agreement. Seller __________________________________________________________________________ Date ______________________ Address __________________________________________ City ________________________ State ________ Zip __________ Telephone ________________________ Fax ______________________________ E-mail ________________________________ Seller __________________________________________________________________________ Date ______________________ Address __________________________________________ City ________________________ State ________ Zip __________ Telephone ________________________ Fax ______________________________ E-mail ________________________________
Figure 8-1c: Sample exclusive listing contract, continued.
Real Estate Broker (Firm) __________________________________________________________ DRE Lic. # __________________ By (Agent) ________________________________________ DRE Lic. # __________________ Date ______________________ Address __________________________________________ City ________________________ State ________ Zip __________ Telephone ________________________ Fax ______________________________ E-mail ________________________________ THIS FORM HAS BEEN APPROVED BY THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® (C.A.R.). NO REPRESENTATION IS MADE AS TO THE LEGAL VALIDITY OR ADEQUACY OF ANY PROVISION IN ANY SPECIFIC TRANSACTION. A REAL ESTATE BROKER IS THE PERSON QUALIFIED TO ADVISE ON REAL ESTATE TRANSACTIONS. IF YOU DESIRE LEGAL OR TAX ADVICE, CONSULT AN APPROPRIATE PROFESSIONAL. This form is available for use by the entire real estate industry. It is not intended to identify the user as a REALTOR®. REALTOR® is a registered collective membership mark which may be used only by members of the NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® who subscribe to its Code of Ethics. Published and Distributed by: REAL ESTATE BUSINESS SERVICES, INC. a subsidiary of the California Association of REALTORS® 525 South Virgil Avenue, Los Angeles, California 90020
Reviewed by _______ Date _______
RLA REVISED 4/07 (PAGE 3 OF 3)
RESIDENTIAL LISTING AGREEMENT - EXCLUSIVE (RLA PAGE 3 OF 3)
131
132
Part II: Tactical Considerations Unless all the parties who hold title in a property join in the sale, a full interest in the property can’t be sold. To avoid future problems, the listing broker wants to be sure that all property owners sign the listing contract. Just as death is nature’s way of warning you to slow down, a co-owner’s refusal to sign a listing is real estate’s way of warning you about a potential deal killer. If your spouse (or a co-owner in a tenancy-in-common partnership) won’t sign the listing, that person probably will also refuse to sign a sale contract. Don’t sign a listing until you resolve the co-owner’s problem, and all owners are willing to sign it. A Multiple Listing Service (MLS) option offers benefits. Paragraph 6 of the form in Figure 8-1b gives sellers the option of having information about their listing put into the local MLS. Chapter 12 provides reasons why listing information about your property in the MLS is a good idea. In some areas, brokers use the MLS contract to sign up their listings. If that’s the case in your area, signing your contract automatically places your property in the MLS database. In all other respects, a multiple listing contract operates the same way as any other exclusive right to sell listing contract. Alternative dispute resolution options can save you time and money. Lawsuits are time consuming and darned expensive, to boot. Most real estate contracts — listing contracts and purchase contracts — now have provisions for alternative dispute resolution, a phrase that describes using either mediation or arbitration (see paragraph 19 of Figure 8-1c) to resolve contract disputes faster and generally in less expensive ways than litigation in a court of law. This provision makes sense. No one, including a good lawyer, wants you to needlessly waste time and money in court.
How long is long enough? We can offer no one correct answer to the question of how long your listing’s duration should be. Unless you have good reason to believe that extra time will be necessary to find a buyer for your house (because either the property is unusual or because the local real estate market is in the dumps), we strongly recommend a 90-day listing period. Why 90 days? Dr. Samuel Johnson, the famous 18th-century writer, once said, “When a man knows he is to be hanged in a fortnight, it concentrates his mind wonderfully.” Three months are, under normal circumstances, long enough
to give the listing broker a good chance to sell your house, yet short enough to keep the broker’s mind concentrated on the job at hand — finding a buyer for your property before the listing expires. If your house hasn’t sold after 90 days but you were pleased with the listing broker’s efforts on your behalf, you can simply renew the listing. But, on the other hand, if you were unhappy with the listing broker’s service, 90 days isn’t forever. After the listing expires, find yourself a different and, hopefully, a better broker.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions
Open listings An open listing is a nonexclusive authorization for brokers to find a buyer for your property. You can give as many brokers as you want an open listing on your house. It’s the real estate version of a winner-take-all horse race. You’re obligated to pay a commission to the first broker who fulfills either of the following conditions: Finds a buyer ready, willing, and able to enter into a contract that meets the exact terms of your listing Procures the buyer whose offer you ultimately accept If you find the buyer by yourself, you don’t have to pay any of the brokers. And you can cancel an open listing any time you want without penalty. If this arrangement sounds wonderful, think again. Smart sellers won’t give brokers an open listing and good brokers won’t accept them. Here’s why: Limited advertising and marketing of your property: In many places, depending on the local rules, brokers can’t put open listings into the MLS. This restriction is a big disadvantage. As we note in Chapter 12, the MLS is a highly effective tool that brokers use to internally advertise listings to other MLS members who may have buyers for their listings. Nor do brokers produce fancy brochures or put big classified ads in the newspaper to tell the world about an open listing. Why should they? Potential buyers may end up going to another broker or directly to the seller to write up an offer. The seller may also suddenly decide to cancel the listing. Brokers only advertise or market open listings as a last resort if they have nothing more promising to do. They disdainfully refer to open listings as pocket listings because brokers tuck them away “in their pocket” passively waiting for a buyer to come along. If you want a quick sale, an open listing isn’t the way to get one. No control: If you give 10 brokers an open listing on your house, you end up doing work that a listing agent normally handles. All the agents call you to coordinate showings of your property. You must prepare the house for showings. You also have to debrief agents after showings to find out whether you’re getting an offer and, if not, find out why not. You have no neck to wring if you come home after work and find that someone left the front door unlocked and let the cat out after a showing. If you like chaos, you’ll like an open listing.
133
134
Part II: Tactical Considerations Your broker is your competitor: Because you don’t have to pay any broker if you sell the house yourself, brokers see you as a competitor. This adversarial relationship encourages brokers to work for buyers, not you. Brokers know that if they take care of their buyers, they’ll get a commission sooner or later. No such loyalty exists in their relationship with you. An open listing is barely better than no listing at all. Unless you have an extremely compelling reason that you absolutely, positively must list your house with a bevy of brokers, you’ll be better served with an exclusive listing.
Examining Broker Compensation When most people hear the term broker compensation, they immediately think of a commission based on a percentage of the property’s sale price. Commissions are the most common method of broker compensation so that’s a logical place to start. However, commissions aren’t the only way to pay brokers. Keep reading this section for a rundown on commissions.
Commissions In the following list, we try to answer questions you’ve had about commissions but may have been too embarrassed to ask. Don’t worry. Questions are good. If you didn’t have any questions, we wouldn’t get to write a book! Check out the following important questions: Who pays the commission? Usually sellers pay the commission, although in rare cases, buyers pay their agents directly. After all, sellers get money when property sells. Buyers generally don’t have funds left for anything more expensive than a Big Mac after making a cash down payment to buy the house, plus paying loan charges, property inspections fees, homeowners insurance premiums, moving costs, and other miscellaneous expenses of purchase. Are commissions set by law? There’s no such thing as a legal minimum commission or a mandatory percentage. Commissions vary from one area to the next. The price and type of property being sold also affect the percentage. Commissions on houses, for example, usually range from 4 to 7 percent of the sale price, and commissions on vacant land can go as high as 10 percent.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions Are commissions negotiable? Absolutely! If a real estate broker or agent tells you otherwise, dump ’em. In fact, most listing contracts contain language similar to the following notice contained in paragraph 4 of the C.A.R. listing: “Notice: The amount or rate of real estate commissions is not fixed by law. They are set by each Broker individually and may be negotiable between Seller and Broker (real estate commissions include all compensation and fees to Broker).” Unbelievably, the vast majority of people who use the services of real estate agents erroneously believe that commissions aren’t negotiable. In an Opinion Research Corporation survey for AARP, only 26 percent of respondents correctly chose the answer that commissions can be negotiated.
Bartering over commissions Knowing that commissions are negotiable is fine. By itself, however, that information is worthless. This section deals with ways to translate your knowledge into a lower commission. Be sure to read Chapter 13 before beginning your negotiations. Good negotiators replace emotions with facts. People can get their feelings hurt. Facts don’t have any feelings to hurt. Don’t try to outargue agents; outfact them.
Mediation and arbitration Mediation generally is the fastest, least expensive way to resolve simple problems. You and the broker (if the dispute is over a listing contract) or you and the buyer (if the problem arises from a dispute related to the purchase contract) present your differences to a neutral third party called a mediator. The mediator can’t impose a settlement on either of the quarreling parties. Instead, the mediator attempts to help both parties work together to reach an agreement regarding a mutually satisfactory solution to their problem.
If mediation fails to resolve the dispute, or if your problem is too complex to handle by mediation, arbitration also is generally less costly and faster than going to court. During arbitration, the parties present their differences to a neutral arbitrator who listens to all the evidence and then makes a binding decision that resolves the dispute. The arbitrator’s decision is final and is as enforceable as a judgment handed down in court. If you’re ever a party in a mediation or arbitration, consult a good real estate lawyer.
135
136
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Commission splits Suppose that your house sells for $300,000. With a 6 percent commission, the sale generates an $18,000 commission. If your listing broker receives the entire $18,000, she’ll be one happy camper. Unfortunately for her, that isn’t what happens. Brokerage commissions almost always are split 50/50 at the close of escrow. In your transaction, for example, your listing broker gets half $9,000 in our example) of the commission. The other $9,000 goes to a cooperating agent from another firm who represents the buyer. Because your broker is a licensed independent broker, she doesn’t split her $9,000 with anyone. The buyer’s agent holds a salesperson’s license, however, so the selling-side commission is paid
to the agent’s broker, who then splits the $9,000 50/50 with the agent so each end up with $4,500. (Top-notch agents can receive 80 percent or more of the total commission.) If you want to be effective during commission negotiations, understanding internal commission splits among agents and brokers is important. Most agents don’t have the authority to cut a commission without getting their broker’s approval. By the same token, brokers can’t unilaterally agree to commission cuts that affect their agents. As a rule, brokers and agents have to agree to a commission reduction because a cut reduces both of their commissions.
Before entering into commission negotiations, you must know these important facts: What’s the going rate for commissions in your area? Straight 6 percent commissions on the sale price may be the norm in your neighborhood. A tiered commission schedule is possible, such as 6 percent on the first $100,000 of sale price, 5 percent on the next $50,000, and 4 percent on the balance. Or, to provide more incentive to agents, commissions may increase from 5 percent on the first $100,000 to 6 percent on the balance. Check local commission rates by questioning several real estate agents as well as friends and business associates who’ve sold property recently. Note: In some areas, high-end houses are listed at a reduced commission rate. If, for example, you’re the proud owner of a $500,000 house, the standard commission rate on property in that price range may be 5 percent rather than the 6 percent commission for less expensive houses. How’s the real estate market? Market competition is the number one reason commissions are or aren’t cut. In a buyers’ market when listings are a dime a dozen, agents have little incentive to cut commissions. They need buyers, not more listings. In a sellers’ market, however, when listings are extremely scarce and buyers are plentiful, agents are more willing to shave commissions.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions How badly does the broker or agent need listings? Brokerage firms love listings because they make phones ring for agents in the office. Buyers who read about your house in the broker’s classified ad call the office to get more details. If your house isn’t right for them, the agent who got the call can, at least, make a contact and may end up selling the caller another property. The listing agent uses your listing to develop more business by mailing prospecting letters about the listing to other property owners in your neighborhood and by holding open houses to generate buyers and listings. If a prospective listing broker’s weekly ad seems short of listings compared to other offices, you probably have a good chance of cutting a deal on the commission. Is your house in good condition and will it be priced to sell? The faster that your house sells, the less time, money, and effort a broker must spend advertising and marketing it. Houses in good condition usually sell faster than fixer-uppers. If your house is not only in great shape but also is priced realistically, some brokers share their savings with you by reducing the commission. However, commission cuts are hard to negotiate when you want a record-high sale price for your neighborhood, expect the broker to do a great deal of expensive advertising, and want your house held open every Saturday and Sunday until it sells. Are you a package deal? If you intend to sell your house and purchase a new home through the same broker, you’re twice as valuable to the broker because you represent two deals: a listing and a sale. Brokers may take that fact into account and offer you a “volume discount” by reducing the listing commission. As we discuss in Chapter 7, you need to select an agent who has the skills and experience required for your particular transaction. Unless you’re moving within the same geographical area, you’re buying a similar type of property, and your listing agent has the requisite skills to work as a buyer’s agent, you may need a different agent to represent you in the purchase of your new home.
Recognizing good versus bad commission cuts Handled properly, a good commission reduction saves money without adversely affecting the length of time the house is on the market or the sale price. Bad commission cuts are false economies, because they end up extending the selling process and reducing your ultimate sale price by cutting the incentive of cooperating brokers to show and sell your property. Assume that the prevailing commission rate in your area is 6 percent for houses like yours. During the agent selection interviews, you point out to the prospective listing agents that your house is in excellent condition. You tell each of them that you want to price your house realistically for a fast sale
137
138
Part II: Tactical Considerations because you want to buy a larger house in the immediate vicinity before your baby is born three months from now. By determining how the listing broker proposes to split the commission with selling brokers, you can know when a commission cut is good or bad. For example: Deep discount special: “I’ll list your house for 4 percent,” the first broker says, “but only if I sell it myself. I want the whole commission. I won’t cooperate with other agents.” A 4 percent commission sounds great. In fact, it’s awful. If your listing agent won’t work with other agents to find a buyer, your house’s market exposure is severely reduced. As a result, your house takes longer to sell and ultimately sells for less money. On top of all that, you’ll have months of extra payments on your mortgage, property taxes, and homeowners insurance. This “deal” costs you far more than you can save. Selling broker absorbs cut: The second broker offers you a 5 percent commission. He proposes to give cooperating agents 2 percent and keep 3 percent (half of a full 6 percent commission) for himself. Picking the pockets of agents who represent buyers is stupid. This split makes the greedy listing broker happy, but turns off cooperating agents. Why? Because, under this arrangement, your house is advertised in the Multiple Listing Service with a 2 percent commission, putting it at a competitive disadvantage to other houses advertised paying a 3 percent commission to cooperating agents. If agents can find another house as nice as yours in the same price range but offering a full 3 percent commission, guess which house they’ll try harder to sell? Even split: The third broker offers to list your house for a 5 percent commission, which she’ll split 50/50 if a cooperating agent obtains the buyer for your house. Both listing and selling agents get 2.5 percent, which isn’t too much off the going rate of 3 percent. That deal seems fair, you think. Fair, yes. Smart, no. A reduction in the cooperating agent’s commission from the norm for a property like yours acts as a disincentive for commission-motivated real estate agents to show and sell your house. Listing broker absorbs cut: The last broker suggests a 5.5 percent commission, but says that he’ll take 2.5 percent for the listing side and give cooperating agents 3 percent. Offering selling agents a full 3 percent commission ensures that you’ll have their enthusiastic cooperation. This commission split is the best way for you to go. Suppose that your house sells for $300,000. Each 1 percent of the sale price equals $3,000, which is significant money for you and the agents. If the listing agent volunteers to shave the listing-side commission by $1,500 (0.5 percent),
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions that’s swell. But don’t mess with the selling side. Taking another 0.5 percent out of the selling-side commission may cost you more than $1,500 in reduced activity by cooperating agents. The amount of commission that you pay ultimately is less important than the value you receive for the money you spend. Some top-notch agents won’t cut commissions. Compared to mediocre agents, the best agents pay their own commissions because they’re able to get more money for a house. Consider this premise when you’re trying to negotiate a lower commission with a prospective listing agent: If the agent can’t defend her money (the commission) by persuading you that she’s worth the commission she charges, how effectively will she defend your money from buyers who want to cut your asking price or get a bigger credit for corrective work? The agent who ultimately convinces you that she’s worth every penny of a full commission may be the best agent for your team — given that the agent satisfies all the other listing agent selection criteria in Chapter 7.
Net listings Unlike an open listing or an exclusive listing, a net listing isn’t a type of listing. Rather, a net listing is a way to pay brokers. Under the terms of a net listing, the seller and broker make this agreement: When property sells, the broker is paid all money received over and above a predetermined net amount that goes to the seller. Because the net listing is a payment method, it can be used with either open or exclusive listing contracts. For example, you tell the listing broker that you want to net $200,000 from the sale of your house after paying off the existing $70,000 mortgage and all other expenses of sale except, of course, the brokerage fee. According to the broker, your house is worth around $300,000, and expenses of sale in your area typically run about $10,000. If everything goes according to plan and your house actually sells for $300,000, the broker earns $20,000 — $300,000 less $70,000 to pay off the loan, $10,000 for expenses of sale, and $200,000 to you. As far as you’re concerned, you’re happy to pay a $20,000 brokerage fee if you can clear $200,000 for yourself.
139
140
Part II: Tactical Considerations Unfortunately, sales rarely go according to plan in the real world. For example, consider the following possibilities: The broker overestimated your house’s value. What if no one will pay more than $280,000 for your property? That’s fine with you. You can pay off the loan, pay the $10,000 for expenses of sale, and still walk away with $200,000. Because no money is left, however, all your broker gets is a pat on the back. Under the circumstances, a bad listing broker may discourage prospective buyers from offering $280,000 by falsely telling them that you absolutely won’t accept a penny less than $300,000. If a cooperating broker brings in a $280,000 offer, a bad listing agent may advise you not to accept the “lowball” offer and tell you to hold out for more money. Or worse yet, the broker may not even tell you about the offer in the first place. In either case, the broker is putting the commission (or lack thereof) ahead of your best interests as a seller. The broker underestimated your house’s value. What if your house sells for $320,000? As Chapter 10 explains, pricing property is an imprecise art. If the listing broker says that your house is “worth around $300,000,” a $20,000 variation in its value one way or the other is an acceptable margin of error. Even so, how will you feel paying the broker $40,000 (a whopping 12.5 percent commission!) because your house sold at the high end of its fair market value? Worse yet, what if the listing broker purposely understated your house’s value to get a bigger fee? That’s fraud. Net listings are illegal in some states because of their high level of risk for broker fraud or misrepresentation. Even if using a net listing is perfectly legal in your area, that still doesn’t make it a good way to compensate brokers. Don’t use a net listing.
Discount brokers So-called full-service real estate brokers, as their title indicates, handle many tasks and details related to your property’s sale and charge a full commission for their services. A good listing broker does the following: Determines your house’s fair market value Helps you prepare the property for marketing Handles all its advertising Holds Sunday open houses as well as open houses for cooperating brokers
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions Schedules private showings for buyers Negotiates with buyers or their agents to get you the best possible price and terms of sale Makes sure that all the contract details are handled properly right up to the close of escrow Your job is to serve as supervisor and decision maker. At the opposite end of the service spectrum is the For Sale By Owner (FSBO) option. As Chapter 6 discusses, FSBO sellers don’t have a listing broker. If you choose the FSBO option, you handle all the listing broker’s chores yourself and thus avoid paying the listing agent’s portion of a brokerage fee when your house sells. (As we note in Chapter 6, you may have to pay the buyer’s agent a brokerage fee to put your deal together.) Discount brokers occupy the middle range of the real estate brokerage service spectrum. If you use a discount broker, you pick and choose the tasks you want to do yourself to market your house. The more work you’re willing to handle yourself, the less you typically pay the broker. Your savings, although not as great as those offered by the FSBO option, may be better than simply cutting the commission on your house’s sale price from 6 to 5.5 percent. Discount brokers utilize different pricing programs: Flat fee: With some discount brokers, you pay a flat fee for services rendered. For example, services can include providing a For Sale sign to put in your front yard, putting a write-up about your house in sales brochures published by the firm and distributed in free newsstands located around town, and training you in fundamentals (such as how to write a classified ad, how to hold an open house, and how to negotiate). For an extra fee, discount brokers may put a house’s listing in the local MLS. (You’re obligated to pay an additional commission if an MLS cooperating broker procures the buyer.) Percentage commission: Instead of charging 5 or 6 percent, which traditional real estate firms charge, some discount brokers charge 3 or 4 percent. Hourly: If you prefer, some discount brokers also provide assistance on an hourly fee basis. For example, you want a firm to handle all your Sunday open houses, negotiate contract terms whenever you receive written offers, and help you fill out sale-related paperwork. The drawback to this approach is that if you don’t end up selling, you’re out all the fees you’ve already paid. Some full-service/full-commission brokers aren’t keen about working on discount broker listings. For one thing, their listings often offer lower fees for cooperating brokers. Even if the fee is equal to the prevailing local rate,
141
142
Part II: Tactical Considerations however, full-service agents know that they’ll probably have to do extra work because you don’t have a full-service broker handling your end of the deal. For these reasons, discount broker listings get less than enthusiastic showings by most full-service brokers. Using discount brokers makes the most sense if your local real estate market is strong, pricing your house is relatively simple, and you’re willing to handle some of the work. However, if your property will be difficult to sell (because of the amount of corrective work it needs or its unusual floor plan, for example), you may have to use a full-service broker to make a sale. Flat fees and hourly charges vary from one discount broker to the next. If you decide to use a discount broker, do some comparison shopping. Look for a discount broker who’ll give you a bundle of services that best meets your needs for the lowest flat fee or hourly charge. Larger discount real estate brokerage firms include Help-U-Sell: (800) 366-1177; www.helpusell.com ZipRealty.com: (800) 225-5947; www.ziprealty.com
Preparing Seller Disclosure Statements The days of caveat emptor — let the buyer beware — are gone forever. In fact, given the flood of federal, state, and local consumer protection laws enacted during the last couple of decades, this is the era of caveat vendor — let the seller beware. Prudent house sellers and agents must now follow two simple guidelines: Beware of belligerent buyers. All buyers become belligerent if not given full disclosure. As a seller, you may think that some of the disclosure requirements are overly protective of buyers. Because, however, you probably intend to purchase a new home to replace the one you’re selling, you can benefit from disclosures as a buyer. All things considered, it’s a fair trade.
What information should you disclose? Disclosure statements aren’t identical throughout the United States. Like other real estate contracts and forms, disclosure statements vary enormously in scope and intricacy because the disclosures themselves differ widely from state to state and from one area to another within any given state.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions The documents you give prospective buyers probably won’t look like the California Association of Realtors’ Real Estate Transfer Disclosure Statement, shown in Figure 8-2. The C.A.R. form, however, gives you an idea of the kind of disclosures you may have to make.
CALIFORNIA A S S O C I AT I O N OF REALTORS®
REAL ESTATE TRANSFER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT (CALIFORNIA CIVIL CODE §1102, ET SEQ.) (C.A.R. Form TDS, Revised 10/03)
THIS DISCLOSURE STATEMENT CONCERNS THE REAL PROPERTY SITUATED IN THE CITY OF _________________ _______________________________, COUNTY OF _______________________________, STATE OF CALIFORNIA, DESCRIBED AS _____________________________________________________________________________________.
LE MP SA
THIS STATEMENT IS A DISCLOSURE OF THE CONDITION OF THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PROPERTY IN COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 1102 OF THE CIVIL CODE AS OF (date) _______________________. IT IS NOT A WARRANTY OF ANY KIND BY THE SELLER(S) OR ANY AGENT(S) REPRESENTING ANY PRINCIPAL(S) IN THIS TRANSACTION, AND IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR ANY INSPECTIONS OR WARRANTIES THE PRINCIPAL(S) MAY WISH TO OBTAIN. I. COORDINATION WITH OTHER DISCLOSURE FORMS
This Real Estate Transfer Disclosure Statement is made pursuant to Section 1102 of the Civil Code. Other statutes require disclosures, depending upon the details of the particular real estate transaction (for example: special study zone and purchase-money liens on residential property). Substituted Disclosures: The following disclosures and other disclosures required by law, including the Natural Hazard Disclosure Report/Statement that may include airport annoyances, earthquake, fire, flood, or special assessment information, have or will be made in connection with this real estate transfer, and are intended to satisfy the disclosure obligations on this form, where the subject matter is the same: Inspection reports completed pursuant to the contract of sale or receipt for deposit. Additional inspection reports or disclosures: _____________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________
II. SELLER’S INFORMATION The Seller discloses the following information with the knowledge that even though this is not a warranty, prospective Buyers may rely on this information in deciding whether and on what terms to purchase the subject property. Seller hereby authorizes any agent(s) representing any principal(s) in this transaction to provide a copy of this statement to any person or entity in connection with any actual or anticipated sale of the property. THE FOLLOWING ARE REPRESENTATIONS MADE BY THE SELLER(S) AND ARE NOT THE REPRESENTATIONS OF THE AGENT(S), IF ANY. THIS INFORMATION IS A DISCLOSURE AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE PART OF ANY CONTRACT BETWEEN THE BUYER AND SELLER. Seller
is
is not occupying the property.
A. The subject property has the items checked below (read across): Oven Microwave Range Trash Compactor Garbage Disposal Dishwasher Rain Gutters Washer/Dryer Hookups Smoke Detector(s) Fire Alarm Burglar Alarms Satellite Dish Intercom TV Antenna Central Air Conditioning Evaporator Cooler(s) Central Heating Sprinklers Public Sewer System Wall/Window Air Conditioning Sump Pump Water Softener Septic Tank Built-in Barbecue Gazebo Patio/Decking Sauna Pool Spa Hot Tub Child Resistant Barrier* Locking Safety Cover* Locking Safety Cover* Automatic Garage Door Opener(s)* Number Remote Controls ____ Security Gate(s) Not Attached Carport Attached Garage: Solar Electric Pool/Spa Heater: Gas Water Heater Anchored, Braced, or Strapped* Water Heater: Gas Well Private Utility or Water Supply: City Other____________________ Bottled Gas Supply: Utility Window Screens Window Security Bars Quick Release Mechanism on Bedroom Windows*
Figure 8-2a: A disclosure statement looks something like this.
Exhaust Fan(s) in _________________ 220 Volt Wiring in ___________________________ Fireplace(s) in _____________________ Gas Starter _______________________ Roof(s): Type: ________________________ Age: _____________________ (approx.) Other: ___________________________________________________________________________________________________ Are there, to the best of your (Seller's) knowledge, any of the above that are not in operating condition? Yes No. If yes, then describe. (Attach additional sheets if necessary): ____________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ (*see footnote on page 2) The copyright laws of the United States (Title 17 U.S. Code) forbid the unauthorized reproduction of this form, or any portion thereof, by photocopy machine or any other means, including facsimile or computerized formats. Copyright © 1991-2003, CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS®, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TDS REVISED 10/03 (PAGE 1 OF 3) Print Date
Buyer’s Initials (__________)(__________) Seller’s Initials (__________)(__________) Reviewed by _______ Date _______
REAL ESTATE TRANSFER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT (TDS PAGE 1 OF 3)
Reprinted with permission, CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS ™. Endorsement not implied.
143
144
Part II: Tactical Considerations Property Address: _______________________________________________________________
Date: _________________
B.
LE MP SA
Are you (Seller) aware of any significant defects/malfunctions in any of the following? Yes No. If yes, check appropriate space(s) below. Insulation Slab(s) Interior Walls Ceilings Floors Exterior Walls Roof(s) Windows Doors Foundation Driveways Sidewalks Walls/Fences Electrical Systems Plumbing/Sewers/Septics Other Structural Components (Describe: __________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________) If any of the above is checked, explain. (Attach additional sheets if necessary.): ____________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ *This garage door opener or child resistant pool barrier may not be in compliance with the safety standards relating to automatic reversing devices as set forth in Chapter 12.5 (commencing with Section 19890) of Part 3 of Division 13 of, or with the pool safety standards of Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 115920) of Chapter 5 of Part 10 of Division 104 of, the Health and Safety Code. The water heater may not be anchored, braced, or strapped in accordance with Section 19211 of the Health and Safety Code. Window security bars may not have quick release mechanisms in compliance with the 1995 edition of the California Building Standards Code. C. Are you (Seller) aware of any of the following: 1. Substances, materials, or products which may be an environmental hazard such as, but not limited to, asbestos, formaldehyde, radon gas, lead-based paint, mold, fuel or chemical storage tanks, and contaminated soil or water No on the subject property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes 2. Features of the property shared in common with adjoining landowners, such as walls, fences, and driveways, whose use or responsibility for maintenance may have an effect on the subject property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes No No 3. Any encroachments, easements or similar matters that may affect your interest in the subject property . . . . . . . . . Yes No 4. Room additions, structural modifications, or other alterations or repairs made without necessary permits . . . . . . . . Yes 5. Room additions, structural modifications, or other alterations or repairs not in compliance with building codes . . . . Yes No No 6. Fill (compacted or otherwise) on the property or any portion thereof . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes 7. Any settling from any cause, or slippage, sliding, or other soil problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes No 8. Flooding, drainage or grading problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes No No 9. Major damage to the property or any of the structures from fire, earthquake, floods, or landslides . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes No 10. Any zoning violations, nonconforming uses, violations of "setback" requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes No 11. Neighborhood noise problems or other nuisances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes No 12. CC&R's or other deed restrictions or obligations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes 13. Homeowners’ Association which has any authority over the subject property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes No 14. Any "common area" (facilities such as pools, tennis courts, walkways, or other areas co-owned in undivided No interest with others) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes 15. Any notices of abatement or citations against the property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes No 16. Any lawsuits by or against the Seller threatening to or affecting this real property, including any lawsuits alleging a defect or deficiency in this real property or “common areas” (facilities such as pools, tennis courts, walkways, No or other areas co-owned in undivided interest with others) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes If the answer to any of these is yes, explain. (Attach additional sheets if necessary.): _________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Seller certifies that the information herein is true and correct to the best of the Seller's knowledge as of the date signed by the Seller. Seller______________________________________________________________________ Date ___________________________
Figure 8-2b: A disclosure statement continued.
Seller______________________________________________________________________ Date ___________________________ Buyer’s Initials (__________)(__________) Seller’s Initials (__________)(__________) Copyright © 1991-2003, CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS®, INC.
TDS REVISED 10/03 (PAGE 2 OF 3)
Reviewed by _______ Date _______
REAL ESTATE TRANSFER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT (TDS PAGE 2 OF 3)
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions Property Address: _______________________________________________________________
Date: _________________
III. AGENT'S INSPECTION DISCLOSURE (To be completed only if the Seller is represented by an agent in this transaction.) THE UNDERSIGNED, BASED ON THE ABOVE INQUIRY OF THE SELLER(S) AS TO THE CONDITION OF THE PROPERTY AND BASED ON A REASONABLY COMPETENT AND DILIGENT VISUAL INSPECTION OF THE ACCESSIBLE AREAS OF THE PROPERTY IN CONJUNCTION WITH THAT INQUIRY, STATES THE FOLLOWING: Agent notes no items for disclosure. Agent notes the following items: __________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
LE MP SA
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Agent (Broker Representing Seller) _______________________________ By _____________________________________ Date ______________ (Please Print)
(Associate Licensee or Broker Signature)
IV. AGENT'S INSPECTION DISCLOSURE (To be completed only if the agent who has obtained the offer is other than the agent above.)
THE UNDERSIGNED, BASED ON A REASONABLY COMPETENT AND DILIGENT VISUAL INSPECTION OF THE ACCESSIBLE AREAS OF THE PROPERTY, STATES THE FOLLOWING: Agent notes no items for disclosure.
Agent notes the following items: __________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Agent (Broker Obtaining the Offer) _______________________________ By _____________________________________ Date ______________ (Please Print)
(Associate Licensee or Broker Signature)
V. BUYER(S) AND SELLER(S) MAY WISH TO OBTAIN PROFESSIONAL ADVICE AND/OR INSPECTIONS OF THE PROPERTY AND TO PROVIDE FOR APPROPRIATE PROVISIONS IN A CONTRACT BETWEEN BUYER AND SELLER(S) WITH RESPECT TO ANY ADVICE/INSPECTIONS/DEFECTS. I/WE ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF A COPY OF THIS STATEMENT.
Seller ___________________________________ Date _______________ Buyer ___________________________________ Date ______________ Seller ___________________________________ Date _______________ Buyer ___________________________________ Date ______________ Agent (Broker Representing Seller) _______________________________ By _____________________________________ Date ______________ (Please Print)
(Associate Licensee or Broker Signature)
Agent (Broker Obtaining the Offer) _______________________________ By _____________________________________ Date ______________ (Please Print)
(Associate Licensee or Broker Signature)
SECTION 1102.3 OF THE CIVIL CODE PROVIDES A BUYER WITH THE RIGHT TO RESCIND A PURCHASE CONTRACT FOR AT LEAST THREE DAYS AFTER THE DELIVERY OF THIS DISCLOSURE IF DELIVERY OCCURS AFTER THE SIGNING OF AN OFFER TO PURCHASE. IF YOU WISH TO RESCIND THE CONTRACT, YOU MUST ACT WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED PERIOD. A REAL ESTATE BROKER IS QUALIFIED TO ADVISE ON REAL ESTATE. IF YOU DESIRE LEGAL ADVICE, CONSULT YOUR ATTORNEY.
Figure 8-2c: A disclosure statement continued.
THIS FORM HAS BEEN APPROVED BY THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® (C.A.R.). NO REPRESENTATION IS MADE AS TO THE LEGAL VALIDITY OR ADEQUACY OF ANY PROVISION IN ANY SPECIFIC TRANSACTION. A REAL ESTATE BROKER IS THE PERSON QUALIFIED TO ADVISE ON REAL ESTATE TRANSACTIONS. IF YOU DESIRE LEGAL OR TAX ADVICE, CONSULT AN APPROPRIATE PROFESSIONAL. This form is available for use by the entire real estate industry. It is not intended to identify the user as a REALTOR®. REALTOR® is a registered collective membership mark which may be used only by members of the NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® who subscribe to its Code of Ethics. Published and Distributed by: REAL ESTATE BUSINESS SERVICES, INC. a subsidiary of the California Association of REALTORS® 525 South Virgil Avenue, Los Angeles, California 90020
TDS REVISED 10/03 (PAGE 3 OF 3)
Reviewed by _______ Date _______
REAL ESTATE TRANSFER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT (TDS PAGE 3 OF 3)
145
146
Part II: Tactical Considerations Generally speaking, the law requires that you disclose to prospective buyers any information you have that materially affects your property’s value or desirability. A material fact is anything that reasonably affects either a buyer’s decision to purchase your house or the price he’d pay. This disclosure must cover facts that you, as an owner, are expected to know about your property and the neighborhood that couldn’t be known by (or wouldn’t be apparent to) the buyer. For example: Physical condition: Are your built-in appliances in good working order? Do you know about any hidden defects or malfunctions in your house’s major components (roof, foundation, electrical system, plumbing, sewer, insulation, windows, doors, walls, and so on)? Although you certainly ought to know whether your air conditioner works properly, no one expects you to be a professional property inspector. Disclosure laws are just one more reason why, as we note in Chapter 7, getting a premarketing inspection of your house is wise. You (and your agent, if you’re using one) should also encourage buyers to conduct their own investigations and obtain inspections from their own experts instead of relying solely on your inspections or the information you provide about the property’s physical condition. Health, safety, and environmental hazards: You must comply with federal, state, and local disclosure laws regarding property problems related to asbestos, formaldehyde, lead-based paints, underground fuel or chemical storage tanks, radon gas, contaminated soil or water, and other health hazards. Is your property in harm’s way from earthquakes, floods, hurricanes, or other natural disasters? Does your property comply with local energy or water conservation ordinances? Don’t worry about running all over town to stock up on the various booklets, pamphlets, and forms the law requires you to give to prospective buyers. Your listing agent or real estate lawyer (if you’re selling without an agent) should provide all necessary disclosure information prior to marketing your property. Legal condition: Are any lawsuits pending that affect your property? Did you make any modifications or alterations to your property without getting the necessary building permits? Do these modifications or alterations comply with state and local building codes? If you’re selling a condominium, you must give the buyer copies of the Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), the Homeowners Association bylaws, and the budget.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions If you have any legal problems related to the property, clear them up before marketing your property if possible. Nobody wants to buy a lawsuit. Legal problems are deal killers. Buyers generally don’t want to inherit legal problems, which tend to take a long time to resolve and are expensive, to boot. Subjective areas: Until now, you could provide objective answers to the various disclosure questions. Your roof either leaks or it doesn’t. You either have lead-based paint in your house or you don’t. Either you’re being sued or you aren’t. Now things get fuzzy. Is your neighborhood quiet? Can you find parking spaces easily near your house? Is car traffic excessive in the neighborhood? Would you call the morning commute horrendous? Are schools in the area overcrowded? Subjective questions can’t be answered with a simple yes or no. The environment that you think is extremely quiet, the buyer may consider a boiler factory. Parking a block from your house may be close in your opinion, but a long walk to your buyer. How much traffic is excessive? And so it goes. Answer all subjective questions to the best of your ability, and then encourage buyers to familiarize themselves with the area so they can draw their own subjective conclusions about these issues. Some state courts have ruled that certain unpleasant facts materially affect the desirability and value of property and insist that sellers disclose these facts. One such fact is a death on the property within several years of the sale — especially if the death was gruesome or violent. For example, the difference between an elderly man dying peacefully in his sleep and a homicide is obvious. Other examples of unpleasant material facts are high crime rates in the immediate area or the presence of known child molesters or rapists who’ve been released from prison and now live in the neighborhood. If you’re not sure whether you have to make this type of disclosure about your property, consult your listing agent or a real estate lawyer.
An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure Sometimes, lawsuits are unavoidable. Certain litigious lads and lasses will take you to court at the drop of a summons whether they have a case or not. Other than identifying them in advance as troublemakers and refusing to
147
148
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Disclose work done without permits This cautionary note is for do-it-yourselfers who’ve done carpentry, plumbing, and electrical work around the house without bothering to get a permit for the work or having it inspected by their friendly local building department. We, your friendly authors, are keenly aware that building permits can be expensive, are sometimes difficult to get, and may trigger property tax increases. We also know that, for these reasons, many folks do work without a permit.
Your written disclosure, for example, that you built that magnificent deck without a permit (and that the deck may not meet local building codes) serves to protect you if the buyer sues you about it after the deal closes. Remember: The key to avoiding lawsuits is complete, timely, written disclosure of all problems so your buyer can make an informed purchasing decision.
That’s all fine and good. But when you sell, ’fess up in writing about work performed without a building permit.
accept an offer from them, you can’t protect yourself from people who believe that a lawsuit is their only solution for real or imagined problems. If you have the misfortune of selling your house to one of these misguided souls, your best recourse is to get a good lawyer to defend you. The best defense is a good offense. Here are four suggestions you can enact to reduce the possibility of a legitimate lawsuit: If in doubt, disclose. If you have to ask whether to disclose something about your property or the neighborhood, you’ve answered your own question. Overdisclosure is better than running the risk of being sued for damages or having the sale rescinded because you failed to reveal a fact that materially affects your property’s desirability or value. Remember the golden rule. “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” may sound hokey, but it’s mighty fine real estate advice. Don’t guess. Not sure about the square footage of your house, the roof’s age, the life expectancy of your water heater, or any other material fact? It’s better by far to answer “unknown” than to guess. If prospective buyers are concerned about any of your “unknowns,” they can hire their own experts to render opinions. Put your disclosure in writing. Have the buyers affirm receipt of your disclosure statement by signing and dating it. Be sure to keep a copy for your file. Hire a professional to inspect your house prior to putting it on the market. After seeing the results, you have the option of fixing defects you want to repair and disclosing the others.
Chapter 8: Listing Contracts and Commissions Don’t fight the problem. Like it or not, disclosure statements are a fact of real estate life. They’re here to stay. Handled properly, mandatory disclosures speed up the sale of your house and ensure that, when your house sells, it stays sold.
149
150
Part II: Tactical Considerations
Part III
Getting Top Dollar When You Sell
B
In this part . . .
efore the For Sale sign goes up, you must prepare your property for sale. Fear not, we detail all the work you do and don’t need to do, including staging, to make your house look its best. We also explain how you (and your agent, if you’re using one) can analyze the sales of comparable houses in your neighborhood to determine your house’s fair market value. Finally, using time-tested and proven techniques, we show you how to hone in on the perfect asking price for your castle.
Chapter 9
Preparing Your House for Sale In This Chapter Getting your home ready to make a great first impression Steering clear of major home renovations
A
magical metamorphosis occurs the moment you decide to sell your property. The “home” you love so dearly turns into a “house.” This shift in vocabulary is an important part of letting go — the emotional detachment process all sellers experience sooner or later. Home is where your heart is. Houses, like TV sets, toasters, and tangerines, are commodities sold on the open market. You’re getting ready to sell a house. Most folks don’t really see their houses after they’ve lived in them for a while. Things that buyers may find objectionable, owners accept as charming quirks. The bathroom door, for example, that sticks whenever it rains. That weird noise the refrigerator makes every so often in the middle of the night. The dirty spot on the hall carpet near the front door where the family dog always takes his afternoon nap. Little stuff. Nor do homeowners tend to notice the insidious effects of gradual physical deterioration and equally gradual junk accumulation. Homeowners fail to see how badly the house needs a new paint job, how big that “little” stain from the leaky roof has grown, and how many clothes they’ve jammed into the once-spacious closets over the years. Not so little stuff. A “lived-in” look is fine — until you want to sell. You may not see this decline, but buyers who tour your property definitely will. To be a successful seller, you must have your house looking its best. This chapter highlights what you can do to your house, outside and inside, to make it stand out above the other houses on the market and what common mistakes to avoid so you can get the best offer.
154
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell
Handling Presale Preparation Getting your house ready to put on the market takes time. Exposing your property to the market before it looks its best gives buyers and agents who tour the house a bad initial impression. It’s nearly impossible to get them back for a second look after you correct the showing flaws. After you read this section, you’ll know why you probably need at least two weeks to prepare your property for marketing. If you make the right improvements when fixing up your property, you increase the odds of selling it quickly for top dollar. If, conversely, you make the wrong changes to your property, you waste the time and money you spent, prolong the sale, and possibly even reduce the ultimate sale price. Start the presale fix-up process by getting outside opinions of your house’s strengths and weaknesses. Don’t ask your best friends or the next-door neighbors. They may have the same blind spots you do. Worse yet, they may sugarcoat the truth in a misguided attempt to spare your feelings. Good real estate agents are an excellent source of advice about readying your house for sale. Because agents see your house with fresh eyes, they can spot flaws you no longer notice. Furthermore, agents look at your house the way buyers do. They know how to prepare houses so they’re appealing for marketing — a process sometimes referred to as staging. And, last but not least, because agents work on commission, good agents don’t want to waste your time or theirs trying to sell a house that isn’t up to snuff. The more you get for your house, the bigger their commission. This section focuses on how to prepare your house for sale, starting from the curb and working your way inside.
Creating curb appeal Most buyers make snap judgments about your house. Their first impressions, good or bad, generally are lasting impressions. Buyers begin forming their opinion of your house long before they go inside. Curb appeal, the external attractiveness of your property when viewed from the street, is critically important. If you want to see how your house looks to strangers, go across the street and take a good, hard look at it. No matter how magnificent your house is on the inside, many buyers will drive by your house without stopping if the property lacks curb appeal. Your house’s exterior appearance and landscaping either attract buyers or repulse them. You can enhance your house’s curb appeal through some tried-andtrue ways:
Chapter 9: Preparing Your House for Sale Painting: Painting your house’s exterior before you put it on the market can be expensive (unless you do it yourself), but it gives the biggest bang for your fix-up buck — if you use colors that conform with your neighborhood’s decorating norm. Now isn’t the time to make a fashion statement! White, light grays, or soft tans are safe choices for exterior walls. If your house doesn’t need a new paint job, at least touch up window frames, front shutters, gutters, and down spouts and have your house gently power washed by people who know what they’re doing. Also, be sure to give your mailbox and front door a fresh coat of paint. Greet prospective buyers by dressing up your freshly-painted entrance with a new welcome mat. In addition to spending big bucks on a paint job, house painting is a timeconsuming project. Because exterior painting is seasonal work, professional painters are busy folks after the snow melts and during the dry season. Don’t wait until a week before you want to put your house on the market to call several painters for bids to do the job. Schedule your painting contractor well in advance of the crunch or you may end up with two nasty choices: either painting the house yourself or putting it on the market with peeling, faded paint. Lawn: A freshly mowed, neatly trimmed lawn gives your house a wellmaintained appearance. Don’t leave toys, lawn equipment, or garden hoses scattered around the yard. You can make your grass look extra lush and green by fertilizing it in the appropriate season. However, if your pet, or your neighbor’s pet, tries to help out with the fertilizing, use your pooper-scooper daily to clean up. Sidewalks: Sweep your sidewalks daily. Keep your walks free of snow and ice in the winter. Nothing puts buyers in a foul mood faster than falling flat on their faces while trying to navigate your icy sidewalk. A badly cracked, crumbling sidewalk is a lawsuit waiting to happen if someone trips and injures himself due to the sidewalk’s poor state of repair. In addition, a poorly maintained sidewalk creates a terrible first impression of your property. Compounding the problem, buyers know that if you don’t fix the sidewalk, they’ll have to do it. Patching cracks or replacing damaged portions of a sidewalk prior to putting your house on the market is money well spent. Keep cost to a minimum by getting bids to do the corrective work from several reputable contractors. Shrubbery: Remove or replace any dead or dying trees, hedges, or shrubs, and prune anything that looks scraggly or overgrown. Cut back overgrown shrubs that block windows and keep light from entering your house.
155
156
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Flowers: Filling flowerbeds with seasonal flowers is an inexpensive way to add color and charm to property. Choose bright, fresh colors that draw buyers’ eyes to otherwise ignored areas of your yard. Don’t forget to keep flowerbeds watered and weeded throughout the marketing process until your sale closes. If you’re among the flower-growing impaired, allow us to recommend Perennials For Dummies by Marcia Tatroe and the National Gardening Association (Wiley). Repairs: Be sure that all gutters and downspouts are in place and clean. Replace missing roof shingles and broken or cracked windows. Repair cracks in your driveway and remove large oil stains. Replace or repair broken stairs, torn window screens, broken or missing fence slats, and defective doorknobs. Make sure that your front and back doors, garage doors, and all windows open easily. Check exterior lights to be certain that they’re working properly. Windows: Keep your windows spotless inside and out throughout the marketing period. When you’re not home, curious buyers attracted by the For Sale sign will peek through the windows to size up your house. Don’t let their first impression be windows covered with cobwebs and smeared with fingerprints. Don’t forget that interior window treatments can be seen from the outside. Worn or faded drapes or lopsided window shades need to be replaced or removed. Eliminate or hide clutter: Clear everything you don’t need out of the garage. Friends and family who live nearby can be a great source of temporary places to stash your excess stuff. If you can’t clean your garage out, at least keep the door closed to conceal the mess from prying eyes. Store recycling bins in an out-of-the-way spot in back of your house. Don’t have a fleet of cars, trucks, boats, and campers cluttering up your driveway or parked in front of your house. You’re selling a house, not a parking lot. If just reading this list makes you tired, you’re not alone. You probably lack the time and the desire to do all this prep work yourself. If you can afford it, make your life easier by hiring competent folks to help you with these chores. Your real estate agent, if you’re working with one, should be brought into the spiffing process as soon as possible. The agent should help prioritize the various projects and can probably refer you to people who specialize in this kind of work.
Exteriors attract, but interiors sell Curb appeal draws buyers into your house. Appealing interiors make the sale. But you don’t have to spend tens of thousands of dollars on your house prior to putting up the For Sale sign. On the contrary, the little things you do generally give the biggest increase in value. Concentrate on the three Cs.
Chapter 9: Preparing Your House for Sale Clean up Clean, scrub, and polish your house. Your stove, oven, refrigerator, microwave oven, and other appliances must be spotlessly clean inside and out. Scour walls, floors, bathtubs, showers, sinks, and faucets until they sparkle. Clean or repair tub and shower grout. Don’t forget to clean the ventilating hood in your kitchen as well as the dusty heating and air conditioning vents throughout your house. Buyers will notice strong smells as soon as they walk through your front door, so eliminate smoke, mildew, and pet odors. Cleaning drapes and carpets helps get rid of odors. So does cleaning your cat’s litter box daily. Remove ashes from the fireplace. If you’re a smoker, clean all ashtrays daily and take your smoking breaks in the great outdoors until you sell your house. Use air fresheners or citrus-scented potpourri to keep your house odor free. Open windows at least ten minutes every day to let in fresh air (unless you live near something emitting an undesirable odor). Whether you do the work or hire someone, make sure that your house is spotless and smell-less. Fix drippy faucets. If any of your sinks or bathtubs drain slowly, unclog them. Just as car buyers love to kick tires, some property buyers test houses by flushing toilets and running water in sinks and bathtubs to check drains. Buyers consider leaky faucets and clogged drains a sign of poor maintenance and, more often than not, they’re right!
Clear out Get rid of clutter. Be ruthless. Removing clutter increases the perceived size of your house. Eliminating clutter and excess furniture makes rooms appear larger. Try this simple test: take shoes, sweater boxes, and so on off your closet floor and look again. Small rooms such as closets and bathrooms seem larger without a ton of stuff all over the floor. Where furniture is concerned, less is more. Go through your house room by room with your real estate agent or a friend who isn’t a packrat. Get their opinion on what to eliminate. Set a goal of getting rid of at least a quarter of the furniture in each room — half would probably be better. Big furniture such as large sofas or grand pianos make a room look smaller. A glass table, for example, seems smaller than a solid wood table of the same size. Think visually. If you want a better idea of what your room looks like, take pictures of each room. Remember the rule of three: No more than three items should be on your kitchen and bathroom counters, tabletops, and mantels. Keep dirty dishes out of the kitchen sink. Store, sell, or give away surplus or bulky furniture. Recycle those stacks of old magazines and newspapers you’ve been saving for no good reason. Don’t just move stuff into the attic or garage. On the contrary, dump all that junk from your attic, basement, and garage that you’ve accumulated over the years.
157
158
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Closet space sells houses. Create additional space in your closet by weeding out all those old clothes you never wear anymore. Clean and organize closets, bookcases, and drawers. Like it or not, serious buyers inspect your closets and open built-in drawers. Be sure that they’re neat and roomy. Closets look more organized if you replace wire hangers with matching wood or plastic hangers. Ironically, the clutter that reduces your house’s value is far from worthless. On the contrary, your junk is someone else’s treasure. Make a donation to your favorite charity and earn a tax deduction (be sure to ask for a donation receipt). Have a garage sale. Who knows? You may make enough from a garage sale to pay for your move.
Cosmetic improvements Make cosmetic improvements. Painting isn’t expensive if you do it yourself, but be careful when selecting interior colors. Lighter colors make rooms look larger. Avoid cherry red, canary yellow, cobalt blue, emerald green, and other bold colors with strong visual impact. You may love the effect, but you aren’t the buyer. Stick to conventional whites, soft pastels, warm tans, honey, taupe, and other neutral colors that won’t clash with most prospective buyers’ tastes. If, like most basements, yours is dark and gloomy, paint the walls and ceiling a light color and put the highest wattage light bulbs that you can safely use in your light fixtures to brighten up the space. Repair cracks in the floor. Just because we recommend using neutral colors doesn’t mean that you should turn your house into a bland, boring blob of mush. You have our permission to give it visual spice. Use fabric — area rugs, tablecloths, napkins, sofa cushions, window curtains or drapes, bedspreads and quilts, bath and hand towels, shower curtains, and so on — to create temporary color accents in rooms. Unlike other more permanent improvements, you can take these items with you for use in your next home. You can also use flower arrangements to add bright splashes of color to rooms.
Staging Staging a house goes way beyond your efforts to make it look nifty before having friends over for a dinner party. After all, your pals are there to eat your food and drink your wine — not buy your house. Just as stagehands set the stage for Broadway productions, you can stage your house to create a production designed to wow prospective purchasers. Good stagers know how to emphasize the best features of a house and minimize the worst.
Chapter 9: Preparing Your House for Sale Staging became even more important with the advent of Internet marketing, which we cover in Chapter 13. Today it’s no longer a simple matter of how your house looks to people who walk through it. Many buyers shop online prior to actually seeing a house, so be sure your house looks good online too. If you’ve ever visited a new home development and walked through the builder’s model home, you’ve seen staging. Builders usually do extremely elaborate staging jobs. They use professional decorators who take care of everything: placing furniture, choosing soothing colors for carpets and drapes, hanging artwork, having a bowl of fruit on the kitchen counter, putting flower arrangements in the living room, and leaving an open book on a table by the bed in the master bedroom. All cabinets, closets, and drawers are empty, of course, so buyers can easily see that the house appears to have plenty of room for their stuff. That unnaturally clean, utterly bare garage looks huge. The patio is furnished with nice lawn furniture and one of those tables with an umbrella in the center. Staging the property this way helps prospective buyers visualize themselves living in the home. The message a bright, cheerful, immaculately clean model home in perfect working condition sends to buyers is, “What are you waiting for? Go ahead. Buy me. You won’t regret it. Living here will be easy. You can relax and enjoy life.” Staging finishes the process you started with the three Cs (see the preceding section). You don’t have to spend wads of cash to stage your property. Small bucks spent staging can bring big rewards. If you’re looking to increase your house’s emotional appeal, check out the following areas of improvement: Kitchen: Aromas from fragrant goodies like freshly baked gingerbread or just-brewed coffee bring back wonderful memories of home. Conversely, many people find odors from pungent foods such as liver, fish, and cabbage a turnoff. Be careful about the foods you cook throughout the marketing process; you never know when prospective buyers may tour your house. Bathrooms: Always have fresh towels and potpourri in bathrooms. Buy new shower curtains; old ones may have water spots or mildew on them. Put new soap in the soap dishes. Take toothbrushes, toothpaste, combs, prescription bottles, and rubber duckies off the bathroom counter. Clear out the medicine cabinet, make sure the toilets are flushed and cleaned, and remove the tub mat and rug in front of the toilet.
159
160
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Collections: Everyone has collections — family photos on the wall, autographed baseballs, dolls, CDs and DVDs, sports and school trophies, model airplanes, whatever. Unfortunately, now isn’t the time to have prospective buyers thinking about your family living in the house. You want them to focus on their family living in it. Depersonalize your property. Put away your collections so people focus on the task at hand — buying your house. Most folks use magnets or tape to stick everything from vacation snapshots and finger-painting masterpieces to notes for the kids and “to do” lists on the surface of their refrigerator. That’s a mighty distracting collection. Clear everything off the top and sides of your refrigerator. Comfort: Keep your house warm in winter and cool in summer. A house that’s too hot or too cold isn’t inviting. Remember Goldilocks. Fireplace: Functioning fireplaces are utilitarian (another heat source) and romantic (candlelit dinners by the fire). If you have a fireplace, spotlight it. Polish your fireplace tools. Pile logs neatly in the fireplace. When your house is shown on cold fall or winter days, nothing says “Welcome” like the warmth, glow, crackle, and smell of a blazing fire in the fireplace. Flowers: Vases of colorful, fresh flowers spotted throughout the house make a wonderful impression on prospective buyers. You don’t have to spend a fortune on hothouse orchids. Bouquets of daisies, tulips, or other seasonal flowers from your local supermarket are fine. Furniture: Rearrange furniture to create a warm, inviting feeling. If you’re selling a vacant house, consider renting furniture to create a homey atmosphere. Light: Bright, well-lit houses seem more spacious and cheerful. Wash all your windows. Clean the window screens. During the day, open all your curtains and drapes (unless you overlook the city dump or your view is a brick wall). If the view is unattractive, get sheer window coverings that let light through but mask the view. Don’t force buyers and agents to grope around in the dark looking for light switches. When you show your house, brighten up rooms by turning on all your lamps, even during the day. Be sure hallways and stairways are brightly lit. Don’t forget to turn on closet lights, oven lights, and the lights over your stove and kitchen counter. Prospective buyers often drop in or drive by in the evening to see how your house looks at night. Interior lights that can be seen from the street make a house look cozy and inviting. From sunset until you go to bed, keep at least one light on in each room that faces the street. As you may know, some folks earn their living (either part-time or full-time) as home stagers. If you’re working with a real estate agent to sell your house and you’ve done a thorough job interviewing agents, as we explain in Chapter 7, your agent can probably recommend several stagers. In the event your agent is unable to suggest anyone, she should ask fellow agents in her office and her office manager for advice.
Chapter 9: Preparing Your House for Sale
Think Again: Avoiding Major Improvements You’re about ready to sell your home, and you realize (or perhaps already know because you had the premarketing inspection we recommend in Chapter 7) that your house needs a new roof, a new foundation, new copper plumbing, kitchen remodeling, or bathroom upgrades. What’s the best way to handle major expenses like these? At this stage in the marketing process, you shouldn’t bite off more than you can chew. If you only have a few weeks before you want to put your house on the market, you simply don’t have the time to manage a huge project. Rehabs, larger and small, have two things in common: No surprise number one: All rehabs take longer than you though they would. No surprise number two: All rehabs cost more than you thought they would. If you have to ask how much longer or how much more, you’ve never done a rehab. If your house is in need of a major improvement, heed the two following points: Don’t spend big bucks on major improvements. For example, don’t install a new roof just before putting your house on the market. As we note in Chapter 14, a wiser plan is to give buyers a credit in escrow to cover the repair cost. Prepare for negotiations regarding the credit by getting several competitive bids for the corrective work from reputable local contractors, and then base your credit on the lowest realistic bid. Why offer to give the buyer a credit in escrow? For one thing, you can avoid a huge out-of-pocket expense by handling the repairs this way. Furthermore, this arrangement allows the new owners to have the work done by their own contractor whenever they want after the sale is completed. Last, but not least by a long shot, if the buyers have problems with their new roof after the sale, the repair is their problem — not yours. You aren’t liable for their contractor’s work. Don’t do a major rehab of the kitchen or bathroom. You generally can’t increase your sale price enough to fully compensate you for all the work and money you put into these projects. Furthermore, you can’t guess the next owner’s preferences in toilets, tile, and tubs. Don’t even try. Odds are that you’ll make the wrong decisions on appliances, cabinets, colors, finishes, and other design choices. A much better plan is to reduce your asking price so it reflects that your house has an old kitchen or bathroom instead of squandering your time and money on a major remodeling job that people may dislike.
161
162
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell
Chapter 10
Determining Your House’s Value In This Chapter Knowing the difference between cost, price, and value Determining your house’s resale value Understanding a comparable market analysis Finding out how real estate agent bidding wars ruin the pricing process
S
tep into our handy-dandy time machine, please. Be careful. Don’t bump your head. These darn economy models have such low ceilings. We’re about to transport you back to the day you began looking for your current home — the house hunt that culminated in the purchase of the home you now own. Ah. There you are, hesitantly wandering from one Sunday open house to the next with the classified ads in your hand and a puzzled look on your face. When you first started your search, you didn’t have a clue about how much any of the houses you toured were worth. Do you remember how the asking prices were merely meaningless sequences of numbers to you? If, for example, you saw a house being offered at $274,950, you didn’t know whether it was a steal at that price or grossly overpriced. Your experience is common. Everyone goes through that phase during the initial stage of the home-buying process. Hold on while we make a short leap forward in time. What a difference a couple of months make. Now look at you, confidently zipping in and out of open houses. You figured out property values by personally eyeballing as many houses as you could. Then you kept checking the status of the properties to see whether they’d sold and, if they had, at what price. You discovered that sale prices, not asking prices, establish a house’s value. Your hard work paid off. You became a market-savvy, educated buyer.
164
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Okay, buckle up for your return to the present. How do you think that things will change when you become a seller? Surprise. Where property values are concerned, the rules of the game are identical for buyers and sellers. Being an educated seller is just as important as being an educated buyer. You get educated exactly the same way — by touring houses comparable to yours that are currently for sale in your neighborhood. Good news. You don’t have to spend every weekend between now and the sale of your house touring property. If you choose to use the services of a good real estate agent, he can accelerate your learning curve by screening which houses you visit. After seeing no more than a dozen houses comparable to yours in size, age, condition, and location, you’ll be an educated seller. (You can spend the time you save gussying up your house for sale!) After you’ve made these tours, you can start to set a value on your own house. This chapter helps you determine that price.
Defining Cost, Price, and Value Winston Churchill sagely observed that England and the United States were countries separated by a common language. Citizens of the two countries use the same words, but the words may have entirely different meanings in each country. For example, folks in Merry Old England buy bangers with pounds. “What an odd country,” Americans think, “they purchase hot dogs with weights?” You don’t have to go all the way to England for a verbal joust. A similar breakdown in communication occurs here in the good old USA whenever Americans use cost, price, and value interchangeably. This linguistic imprecision creates big problems during negotiations between homebuyers and house sellers. The fact is: Neither cost nor price is the same as value. After you understand the meanings of these words and how they differ, you can say exactly what you mean and replace emotion with objectivity during price negotiations. Outfacting buyers is always better than attempting to outargue them.
Value is elusive Value is your opinion of your house’s worth to you based on the way you use it now and plan to use it in the future. Note that, in the preceding sentence, the words “your” and “you” each appear twice. Because your opinion is subjective, the features you value may not be the universal standard for all of humanity.
Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value You may, for example, be of the strongly held opinion that the one and only acceptable house color is beet red. We, your humble authors, may feel just as resolutely that only sky blue houses are gorgeous and all other colors are major ugly. No harm done, as long as everyone realizes that a big difference exists between opinions and facts. Two factors greatly affect value: Internal factors: Your personal (internal) situation has a fascinating way of changing over time. Suppose that 30 years ago, when you bought your present house, you put great value on a four-bedroom home with a fencedin backyard. The house had to be located in a town with a terrific school system. Why? Because 30 years ago, you were the proud parent of two adorable little rug rats. Now your children are grown and have their own homes. They left you rattling around in your house like a tiny pea in a gigantic pod. Without kids, you don’t need the big house, huge yard, or terrific school system. The house didn’t change — what changed were the internal factors regarding your use for the house and, thus, its value to you. Divorce and retirement are other internal factors that compel folks to buy or sell houses. External factors: Circumstances outside your control that affect property values also change for better or worse. If, for example, commute time to the big city where you work is cut from 1 hour to 30 minutes when mass transit rail service is extended into your area, your house’s value increases. If, on the other hand, a toxic waste dump is discovered next to your house, the house’s value takes a hit. The law of supply and demand is another external factor that affects value. If more people want to buy houses than sell them, buyer competition drives up house prices. If, on the other hand, more people want to sell than buy, reduced demand results in lower property prices.
Cost is history Cost measures past expenditures — for example, the amount you originally paid for your house. But that was then, and this is now. The amount you paid long ago, or the amount you spent fixing up the house after you bought it, doesn’t mean diddlypoo as far as your house’s present or future value is concerned. For example, when home prices began skyrocketing in many areas of the country during the late 1980s, some buyers accused sellers of being greedy. “You paid $75,000 fifteen years ago. Now you’re asking $250,000,” they said. “That’s a huge profit.”
165
166
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell “So what?” sellers replied compassionately. “If you don’t want to pay our modest asking price, move out of the way so the nice buyers standing behind you can present their offers.” In a hot sellers’ market, people who base their offering prices on the original price paid for a property waste everyone’s time. The market changed radically in a few short years. By the early 1990s, prices had declined dramatically in many areas. Sellers would’ve been ecstatic to find buyers willing to pay them the amount they’d paid five years earlier when home prices peaked. In those areas, sellers who priced their houses based on the inflated purchase prices they’d paid years earlier learned a painful lesson: Your potential profit or loss as a seller doesn’t enter into the equation when determining your house’s present value.
Price is the here and now You put an asking price on your house. Buyers put an offering price in their contract. You and the buyers negotiate back and forth to establish your house’s purchase price. Today’s purchase price becomes tomorrow’s cost, and so it goes. Cost is the past, price is the present, and value (like beauty) is in the eyes of the beholder. Neither the price you paid for your house eons ago when you bought it, nor the amount you want to get for it today matters to buyers. Don’t waste valuable time on fantasy pricing.
Determining Fair Market Value (FMV) Every house sells at the right price. That price is defined as its fair market value (FMV) — the price a buyer will pay and a seller will accept for the house — given that neither buyer nor seller is under duress. Duress comes from life changes, such as divorce or sudden job transfer, which put either the buyers or sellers under pressure to perform quickly. If appraisers know that a sale was made under duress, they raise or lower the sale price accordingly to more accurately reflect the house’s true FMV. FMV is a zillion times more powerful than plain old value. As a seller, you have an opinion about the amount your house is worth. Buyers have a separate, not necessarily equal, and probably lower, opinion of your house’s value. Values are opinions, not facts. FMV, conversely, is fact. It becomes fact the moment you and the buyer agree on a mutually acceptable price. Just as it takes two to tango, it takes you and a buyer to make FMV. Facts are bankable.
Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value
Need-based pricing isn’t FMV Whenever the residential real estate market gets soft and squishy like a rotten tomato, many would-be sellers feel that FMV isn’t fair at all. “Why doesn’t our house sell?” they ask. “Why can’t we get our asking price? It’s not fair.” Don’t confuse “fair” with equitable or favorable. Despite its amiable name, FMV is brutally impartial and sometimes even cruel. Need is not an integral component of FMV. FMV doesn’t give a hoot about any of the following: How much money you need because you overpaid for your house when you bought it How much money you need to replace the money you spent fixing up your house after you bought it How much money you need to pay off your mortgage or home-equity loan How much money you need from the sale to buy your next home Here’s why need doesn’t determine FMV. Suppose that two identical houses located right next door to one another are listed for sale at the same time. One house was purchased by Marcia for $30,000 in 1970. You made a $60,000 cash down payment when you bought the other house for $300,000 two years ago. As luck would have it, property values declined a year after you bought your house. You clearly need more money from the sale than Marcia. After all, you paid ten times as much for your house. What’s more, Marcia paid off her loan five years ago. You, on the other hand, owe the bank big bucks on your mortgage. Because the houses are identical in size, age, condition, and location, they have the same FMV. Under the circumstances, the fact that they both sold for $285,000 isn’t surprising. Marcia got a nice nest egg for her retirement. You barely cleared enough from the deal to pay off your mortgage and other expenses of sale. Fair? Marcia thinks so. You don’t. FMV is utterly unbiased. It’s the amount your house is worth in the market today — not the amount you or the buyers would like it to be.
Median prices aren’t FMV Organizations such as the National Association of Realtors, the Chamber of Commerce, and private research firms gather data on house sales activity in a specific geographic region, such as a city, county, or state. They use this
167
168
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell information to prepare reports on housing topics, such as the average cost of houses in an area and the increase or decline in regional house sales on a yearly or monthly basis. One of the most widely quoted housing statistics is the median sale price, which is simply the midpoint in a range of all house sales in an area during a specified reporting period, such as a month or a year. Half the sales during the reporting period are above the median, and half fall below it. The median-priced house, in other words, is the one exactly in the middle of the prices of all the houses that sold during the specified reporting period. Figure 10-1 demonstrates what we mean.
$265,000
$251,000
$239,000
$227,000
$220,000
$207,000
$196,000 Figure 10-1: The median sale price is smack dab in the middle.
$187,000
$170,000
Median sale price
Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value For example, the median sale price of an existing single-family house in the United States was about $220,000 in 2007 — meaning that half the houses in the U.S. sold for more than $220,000 and the other half sold for less than $220,000. (In case you’re interested, the median sale price was just $118,000 in 1996 when the first edition of this wonderful book went to press.) Unfortunately, all you know about this hypothetical median-priced American house is its price. You don’t know how many bedrooms or baths the mythical median-priced house contains. Nor do you know how many square feet of interior living space the house offers, how old it is, whether it has a garage or a yard, or how well maintained it is. You don’t even know where in the U.S. this elusive median-priced house is located. As a homeowner, you can use median sale price statistics to measure general property value trends. For example, suppose that your local Chamber of Commerce says that the median sale price of a house in your area was $200,000 five years ago when you bought your house, and it’s $240,000 today. Based on that information, you can safely say that median sale prices have increased 20 percent over the past five years. Just because the median sale price of a house in your area went up 20 percent doesn’t mean that the house you paid $250,000 for five years ago is worth $300,000 today. Median sale price statistics aren’t any more accurate for determining your house’s value than median income statistics are for calculating your paycheck. You need much more precise information to establish the FMV of the house you’re about to sell.
Using a Comparable Market Analysis The best way to accurately determine your house’s FMV is by using a written comparable market analysis (CMA) to see how your house compares to other houses like yours that have either sold recently or currently are on the market. If you hire a real estate agent to sell your house and use the techniques we cover in Chapter 7 to select your agent, you get several CMAs during the selection process. You can use these CMAs to fine-tune your asking price. The “Recent Sales” section of the CMA helps establish the FMV of your house by comparing it to all other houses that Are located in the same neighborhood as your house Are of approximately the same age, size, and condition as your house Have sold in the past six months
169
170
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Houses meeting these criteria are called comps, which is short for comparables. Depending on the date you started looking at houses for sale in your neighborhood, you may not have visited all the sold comps. No problem. A good real estate agent can show you listing statements for the houses you haven’t seen, take you on a verbal tour of every house, and explain how each one compares with your house. Every residential real estate office develops its own CMA format. Regardless of the way your agent’s office presents its CMA information, Tables 10-1 and 10-2 illustrate the elements that all good CMAs contain. Suppose that you live at 220 Oak Street. These tables provide CMA information for your house (abbreviated as YH).
Table 10-1
Sample CMA — “Recent Sales” Section
Address
Date Sold
Sale Price
210 Oak
04/30
335 Elm
307 Ash
Bedrm/ Bath
Parking
Condition
Remarks
$290,000 3/3
2 car
Very good
Best comp! Approx. the same location, size, and condition as your house (YH) with a slightly smaller lot. 1,867 square feet. $155 per square foot.
02/14
$268,500 3/2
2 car
Fair
Busy street. Older baths. 1,805 square feet. $149 per square foot.
03/15
$285,000 3/3
2 car
Good
Slightly larger than YH, but nearly the same condition. Good comp. 1,850 square feet. $154 per square foot.
Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value
Address
Date Sold
Sale Price
555 Ash
01/12
75 Birch
04/20
Bedrm/ Bath
Parking
Condition
Remarks
$282,500 3/2.5
2 car
Excellent
Smaller than YH, but knockout renovation. 1,740 square feet. $162 per square foot.
$293,000 3/3
3 car
Very good
Larger than YH, but location isn’t as good. Superb landscaping. 1,910 square feet. $153 per square foot.
When you analyze the sales in Table 10-1, you find that houses comparable to your house are selling in the range of $149 to $162 per square foot. Putting the sale prices into a price-per-square-foot format makes property comparisons much easier. As Table 10-2 shows, any price that’s way above or below the norm really leaps out at you. The “Currently For Sale” section of the CMA compares your house to neighborhood comps that are currently on the market. These comps are included in the analysis to check price trends. If prices are falling, asking prices of houses on the market today will be lower than sale prices of comparable houses. If prices are rising, you’ll see higher asking prices today than sale prices for comps that sold three to six months ago.
Table 10-2 Address 220 Oak (Your House)
Sample CMA — “Currently For Sale” Section
Date on Market
Asking Price
Bedrm/ Bath Parking Condition Remarks
Not on market
To be 3/3 determined
2 car
Very good Quieter location than 123 Oak, good detailing, older kitchen. 1,880 square feet. (continued)
171
172
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Table 10-2 (continued) Address
Date on Market
Asking Price
Bedrm/ Bath Parking Condition Remarks
123 Oak
05/01
$299,500
3/2
2 car
Excellent
High-end rehabilitated and priced accordingly. 1,855 square feet. $161 per square foot.
360 Oak
02/10
$275,000
3/2
1 car
Fair
Kitchen & baths need work, no fireplace. 1,695 square feet. $162 per square foot.
140 Elm
04/01
$279,500
3/3
2 car
Good
Busy street, small rooms, small yard. 1,725 square feet. $162 per square foot.
505 Elm
1/15
$325,000
2/2
1 car
Fair
Delusions of grandeur. Grossly overpriced! 1,580 square feet. $206 per square foot.
104 Ash
04/17
$294,500
3/2.5
2 car
Very good Best comp! Good floor plan, large rooms. Surprised it hasn’t sold. 1,860 square feet. $158 per square foot.
Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value
Address
Date on Market
Asking Price
Bedrm/ Bath Parking Condition Remarks
222 Ash
02/01
$319,500
3/2
1 car
Fair
Must have used 505 Elm as comp. Will never sell at this price. 1,610 square feet. $198 per square foot.
47 Birch
03/15
$319,000
4/3.5
2 car
Good
Nice house, but overimproved for neighborhood. 2,005 square feet. $159 per square foot.
111 Birch
04/25
$289,500
3/3
2 car
Very good Gorgeous kitchen, no fireplace. 1,870 square feet. $155 per square foot.
Playing with the numbers Suppose today’s date is May 15th. You and your agent are sitting at the kitchen table looking at two sheets of paper. One page shows all the recent sales of comps in your neighborhood. The other lists houses comparable to yours that currently are on the market in your area. Each set of comps tells you something important.
“Sold” comps indicate probable FMV Your agent says that 210 Oak is an ideal “sold” comp because it’s two doors away from your house, is roughly the same size as your house, and is in about the same condition as your house. Furthermore, no major changes have occurred in your local real estate market since 210 Oak sold two weeks ago for $155 per square foot. The only other recent sale at a higher price per square foot was 555 Ash, but that comp isn’t as good because the house is in better condition than your house (no offense).
173
174
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Factually establishing your house’s probable sale price based on its square footage is easy after you know how. Multiply your house’s square footage by estimated FMV expressed in a price per square foot. In this case, because your house (220 Oak) has 1,880 square feet multiplied by $155 per square foot, it should sell for about $291,400. Simple.
“Currently For Sale” comps define asking price You’ve toured every one of the comparable properties listed in the “Currently For Sale” section of your agent’s CMA. Having seen 104 Ash with your own eyes, you agree that it’s more like your house than any other property now on the market in your area. Even so, it isn’t a perfect comp because 104 Ash is smaller than your house and has only two and a half baths versus three full baths in your house. You know enough about property values to realize that the house is priced to sell at $158 per square foot. Even though 123 Oak and 360 Oak are closer to your house than 104 Ash, neither house is as good a comp as the Ash Street property. The house at 123 Oak is totally renovated, has a wonderful kitchen, and should sell for a higher price per square foot than your house. Whether they can get $161 per square foot remains to be seen. The house at 360 Oak, on the other hand, is smaller than your house, doesn’t show well, and has one less bath and a smaller garage. No way will 360 Oak sell for $162 per square foot. All things considered, you decide to base your asking price on $158 per square foot. For one thing, that amount is the upper limit of comparable houses’ asking prices. The extra $3 per square foot over your house’s probable FMV gives you a little room to negotiate with buyers. Multiplying 1,880 square feet times $158 per square foot equals $297,040, which is an odd asking price. To make the asking price more exciting for prospective buyers, you round it down to an even $295,000. This example is rather straightforward. Pricing in the real world, however, is usually somewhat complicated. That’s why we devote Chapter 11 to more sophisticated pricing considerations. Give sale prices more weight than asking prices when determining your house’s asking price. Don’t guess about your house’s worth. Analyze the sale prices of comparable houses. Your CMA should note any price reductions made while the comps were on the market as well as the credits sellers gave buyers for corrective work repairs.
Interpreting CMA adjustments and flaws CMAs beat the heck out of median price statistics for establishing FMV, but keep in mind that CMAs aren’t perfect. We’ve seen buyers and sellers use exactly the same comps and arrive at stunningly different opinions of FMV. Here’s where discrepancies can creep into your CMA:
Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value Incomplete comps: Your CMA must be comprehensive. It should include all comp sales in the past six months and all comps currently on the market. Be sure that the comp sales data reflects price reductions during the marketing period and credits given for corrective work repairs. Getting an accurate picture of FMV may be difficult if parts of the puzzle are missing. Old comps: Like milk in your refrigerator, comps have expiration dates. Lenders rarely accept as comps houses that sold more than six months ago, because their sale prices don’t reflect current consumer confidence, business conditions, or mortgage rates. As a rule, the older the comp, the less likely that it represents today’s FMV. Why six months? Because six months generally is accepted as long enough to represent a good cross section of comparable sales, but short enough to have fairly consistent market conditions. This time period, however, isn’t carved in stone. If, for example, the biggest employer in your area had a massive layoff three months ago, six months is too long for a valid comparison. Conversely, if houses in your area rarely sell, you’ll probably have to use comparable sales that occurred more than six months ago. House condition: No two homes are the same after they’ve been lived in. Suppose that two identical tract homes are located next door to one another. One, owned by an older couple with no children or pets, is in pristine condition. The other, owned by a family with five small kids and three large dogs, resembles a federal disaster area. It’s Guesstimate City when trying to determine the cost to repair the wear-and-tear damage in the second house. A good CMA, however, makes adjustments for this type of difference between houses. Site differences within your neighborhood: Even though all the comps are in the same neighborhood, they aren’t located on precisely the same plot of ground. How much is being located next to the beautiful park worth to a buyer? How much will a buyer pay to be seven blocks closer to the bus stop during the rainy season? These value adjustments are subjective and, thus, imprecise. Out-of-neighborhood comps: Suppose that, in the past six months, no houses sold in your neighborhood. Going into other areas to find comps forces you and your agent to make value adjustments between two different neighborhoods’ amenities (schools, shopping, transportation, and so on). Comparing different neighborhoods is a lot more difficult than making value adjustments within your neighborhood. Noncomp house sales: What if five houses sold in your neighborhood in the past six months but not one was remotely comparable to yours in age, size, style, or condition? You and your agent must estimate value differences for three-bedroom versus four-bedroom houses, old versus new kitchens, small versus large yards, garages versus carports, and so on. If your house offers a panoramic view and none of the other houses have any view at all, how much does the view increase your house’s value? Guesstimates like these are highly subjective.
175
176
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell A valid comparison of your house to the other houses is impossible if you and your agent have only read about the comps in listing statements. Seeing is believing. Most listing statements (those one-page property descriptions we cover in Chapter 12) are exaggerated to greater or lesser degrees. You don’t know how overstated if you haven’t seen the house for yourself. You may discover that a “large” master bedroom is tiny. A “gourmet” kitchen’s only distinction may be an especially fancy hot plate. That “sweeping” view from the living room may be visible only if you’re as tall as Michael Jordan. Of course, you won’t know any of these things if you only read the houses’ puff sheets instead of visiting each house in person. Floor plans also greatly affect a house’s value. Two houses, for example, may be approximately the same size, age, and condition, yet vary wildly in value. One house’s floor plan flows beautifully from room to room; the rooms themselves are well proportioned with high ceilings. The other house doesn’t work well because its floor plan is choppy and the ceilings are low. You can’t tell which is which just by reading the two listing statements. Eyeballing — touring houses and noting important details inside and out — is the best way to decide which houses are true comps for your house and which differences you must adjust for in your comparable analysis. (When you read Chapter 13, you’ll see for yourself why online CMA providers such as Zillow may be wildly inaccurate.)
Considering appraisals versus CMAs If you’re the suspicious type, you may want to double-check your agent’s opinion of value before putting your house on the market. You can do so by paying several hundred dollars for a professional appraisal of your house. Getting an unbiased second opinion of value is always reassuring. Appraisers, unlike agents, have no reason to tell you what you want to hear to get a listing. Whether your house sells or not, an appraiser gets paid. On the other hand, if you think that a professional appraisal is vastly superior to your agent’s opinion of value, think again. A good agent’s CMA usually is as good as an appraisal for purposes of marketing your house. Conversely, if a professional appraisal is vastly superior because your agent is a lousy judge of property values, get a better agent. In any given area, appraisers don’t usually see as many houses as do agents who focus on that area. Appraisers aren’t lazy; they use their time in other ways. Formal appraisals are time consuming. An appraiser inspects a property from foundation to attic, measures its square footage, makes detailed notes regarding everything from the quality of construction to the amount of wear and tear, photographs the house inside and out, photographs comps for the house being appraised, writes up the appraisal, and so on. Agents can tour 15 to 20 houses in the same amount of time an appraiser requires to do one appraisal.
Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value As a result, appraisers frequently call agents to find out about houses the agents listed or sold that may be comps. Regardless of how good an agent’s description of the house, eyeballing property is better. Any appraisal’s accuracy suffers if the appraisal is based on comps the appraiser hasn’t seen. Agents also call each other about houses they haven’t seen, so don’t jump to the conclusion that appraisers are the only ones who do such things. Reading listing statements and picking other agents’ brains to find out about property is no substitute for first-hand eyeballing. If your agent hasn’t seen most of the comps used in your CMA, get an agent who knows your local market. Unless you’re pretty darn uncertain about your house’s worth or are considering selling your house yourself (a topic we cover in Chapter 6), don’t waste money on an appraisal.
Bidding Wars In a perfect world, buyers and sellers would only use facts to establish property values, and sales would be fast and easy. Unfortunately, the world is far from perfect. The following sections provide two reasons.
How buyers and sellers get to FMV Buyers and sellers zero in on a house’s FMV from utterly different directions (see Figure 10-2). Buyers bring their offering price up to FMV because they don’t want to overpay. Sellers, conversely, ratchet their asking price down to FMV because they don’t want to leave any of their profit on the table.
Sellers
Fair Market Value Figure 10-2: How buyers and sellers approach fair market value.
Buyers
177
178
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell Even though sellers and buyers approach FMV from opposite directions, note that they end up at exactly the same place. That result is no surprise. If you and the buyers rely on the same data — the asking prices and sale prices of comparable houses — to determine FMV, you’re bound to reach the same conclusion sooner or later.
Why “buying a listing” ruins property pricing One crucial aspect of selling a house is correctly establishing its initial asking price. If a seller prices a house near its FMV, the house usually sells quickly for top dollar. If, on the other hand, a seller grossly overprices a property, it tends to linger on the market month after month until the owner corrects the problem. Why would you be tempted to overprice your house? Because an unprincipled real estate agent takes advantage of your legitimate concern about underpricing your property, or, perhaps, the agent just wants to exploit your greed. A bidding war develops among the agents who’re competing to list your house for sale. The first victim of this bidding war is, unfortunately, the concept of FMV. Here’s what happens: “Thanks for giving me a chance to represent you during the sale of your handsome house,” says Tommy Truthful, an agent from Honest Realty. “As you can see from the CMA I prepared today, 142 houses sold in your neighborhood during the past six months. Two are considerably larger than yours, so they aren’t good comps. The 140 properties comparable to your house in size, age, location, and condition sold in a price range of $225,000 to $227,500. Based on this astonishing abundance of undeniable, irrefutable, incontestable, indisputable, incontrovertible, unquestionable facts, I recommend an initial asking price of not more than $229,500.” “Wait just a second,” cautions Sally Slick from Aim To Please Realty. “You may be leaving money on the table if your asking price is $229,500. Comps aren’t everything. Your chimney is made of better quality bricks than any of those other 140 houses’ chimneys. Even more importantly, not one of the 140 houses has an ostrich-sized birdbath in its front yard. These special features, in my humble opinion, are easily worth an additional $20,000. I recommend that you ask $249,500.” “Facts, schmacts,” oozes Otto Outrageous from Sky High Realty, who figures he won’t get your listing unless he outbids the other two agents. “I think that $249,500 isn’t even close to what you should ask. We’ll feature your house on our Internet page and include it in the glossy, full-color brochures we mail every week to our affiliate offices in Paris, London,
Chapter 10: Determining Your House’s Value Rome, and Nome. Massive exposure is the key to maximizing your sale price. I’m sure that if we look long enough and hard enough we can find a buyer in some secret nook of this vast planet who’ll pay $275,000 for your wonderful house.” This deceptive approach — when several agents give a seller increasingly outrageous opinions of a house’s value — is called buying a listing. Agents who use this ploy think that the best way to get listings is to tell sellers what they want to hear — that their house is unique and is worth way, way, waaaaaaaaaaay more than any comparable house. Greed conquers reason. This ruse may be a successful tactic for getting listings, but it’s a rotten way to sell them. Property owners who succumb to fantasy pricing are condemned to waste their time until they finally return to real-world economics. These misguided homeowners confuse the act of listing a house with the act of selling it. Unless their listing agent intends to buy the house, the owners and agent are playing an expensive game of let’s pretend. The price you and your listing agent agree on doesn’t really matter. Until you find a buyer who agrees with you, your house won’t sell. Resist the temptation to base your asking price on: The amount that you want your house to be worth The amount you need to receive from the sale to be able to buy your dream home Let the comps tell you the price your house is worth. Unlike unscrupulous agents, comps don’t lie.
179
180
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell
Chapter 11
Price It Right and Buyers Will Come In This Chapter Understanding house-pricing methods Using buyer enticements to help you sell and avoiding gimmicks Figuring out why your house is still on the market
I
f you really want to be a successful seller, think like a buyer. You probably didn’t buy the first house you looked at. Few folks do. On the contrary, most people spend months industriously inspecting many houses on the market. To avoid overpaying for the home they ultimately purchase, buyers are forced to become experts on property values.
It’s a free country. You can ask any price you want for your house. But your house won’t sell until you find a buyer who agrees that it’s worth the price you’re willing to accept. Smart sellers know that although only one person sets a price, two people — a seller and a buyer — make a sale. Adverse factors outside your control (such as a flood of houses on the market, high mortgage interest rates, or dismal consumer confidence) may negatively affect your sale price. Even so, you don’t have to passively let the real estate gods crush you. This chapter offers proven ideas that you can use to create demand for your house no matter how poor prevailing market conditions are.
Getting a Grasp on Pricing Methods Chapter 10 explains how to use the asking prices and sale prices of comps (houses comparable to your house) to factually determine your house’s value. This information puts you light years ahead of sellers who either don’t know about using comps or, worse yet, choose to ignore comps when pricing property.
182
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell You can pick a price for your house in a hundred different ways — visit an astrologer, poll your friends for their guesses about its worth, roll dice, pay for a professional appraisal, grab a number out of your hat, interview dozens of real estate agents until you find one with a suitably elevated opinion of your house’s value, and so on. In the final analysis, however, they’re all variations of the two pricing methods we discuss in the following sections.
Four-phase pricing: Prevalent but ineffective The consequences of pulling an unsubstantiated asking price out of the air are unacceptable for a smart seller. You may undervalue your house and risk leaving money on the table when you sell. Or, more likely, you may overprice your house, which results in an exhaustingly slow marketing process that ultimately lowers your sale price. Houses marketed by unrealistic sellers usually go through the following four distinct pricing phases prior to sale: Phase one: Sellers start by blithely disregarding any factual pricing method, such as checking comparable property sales. Why? Some sellers don’t know any better or get lousy advice from their real estate agents. Other sellers think that their house is infinitely superior to those tickytacky comps. They’re sure that their house’s inherent superiority will quickly attract a buyer with more money than good sense. Either way, this misguided method generally results in grotesque overpricing. Phase two: After several months of total market rejection, the sellers grudgingly make a tiny price reduction, which brings their asking price down from the grotesque level to merely absurdly overpriced. Fantasy moderated is, however, still abject fantasy. Phase three: More lonely months pass, and then two things happen. First, the sellers typically get a new agent — poetic justice for an agent who either didn’t know property values or who intentionally misled the sellers about pricing to get the listing. Second, the sellers reduce their asking price to one that “leaves room to negotiate.” Even though the revised price still is moderately higher than the house’s probable sale price based on sales of comparable property, at least the new asking price has some basis in market reality. Phase four: The sellers ultimately accept the validity of comps and reduce their asking price accordingly to a “let’s sell it” level. After the sellers establish a good correlation between asking price and fair market value (FMV), their house finally sells. Ironically, instead of getting more money with this method, four-phase pricing usually stigmatizes a property and reduces the eventual sale price to less than it would’ve been with more realistic pricing. Here’s why:
Chapter 11: Price It Right and Buyers Will Come The listing agent can’t justify an indefensible asking price. If the asking price has no factual basis, the agent can’t provide a good answer to buyers who ask, “Why hasn’t the house sold after all this time on the market? What’s wrong with it?” In degree of difficulty, this situation ranks right up there with, “Just what do you think you’re doing?” when your mom caught you with your hand deeply buried in the cookie jar. The property is slowly but surely buried by new listings that come on the market. After several months, most buyers and agents either forget that your house still is on the market or belittle the house by saying, “That old thing. It’ll never sell.” In desperation, sellers are forced to slash their asking price to the bone to attract buyers. Four-phase pricing creates a self-fulfilling prophecy. Folks who use this pricing method expect it will take a long time to sell their house. In a strong market, they’re correct because the market will ultimately rise to their price level. In a weak market, they’re disastrously correct as they chase the market ever lower.
Pleasure-pleasure-panic pricing: Fast, top-dollar sales If the four-phase pricing plan is a flop, what’s your alternative? We’re glad you asked. The smart way to sell your property is the pleasure-pleasure-panic pricing method. You can sell your house quickly and get the highest possible price by using this method. The secret of success is establishing a realistic asking price for your house when you first place it on the market. As we note in Chapter 10, the correct way to establish an asking price is to analyze houses comparable to yours in size, age, condition, and location — houses that currently are on the market and those that have sold within the past six months. Don’t be misled by asking prices; many sellers use fourphase pricing. Sale prices, not asking prices, determine FMV. Here’s how the pleasure-pleasure-panic pricing method works — Milt and Judy have spent the last three months looking at houses on the market in their price range. They’re educated buyers; they know how to distinguish between a well-priced house and an OPT (overpriced turkey). Judy and Milt nearly bought a great house a couple of months ago. It had all the features they wanted and was fairly priced, to boot. However, Milt didn’t realize how well priced it was because he’d just started the education process. While Milt was haggling over the price and terms of sale, the seller accepted a better offer. Judy still blames Milt for losing their dream house. They’re spending today the same way they’ve spent the previous 11 Sundays, touring what seems like an endless series of newly listed OPTs with their
183
184
Part III: Getting Top Dollar When You Sell agent. Then Judy and Milt trudge into your first open house and pleasurepleasure-panic kicks into gear. Pleasure Number 1: Judy and Milt love your property. It’s the best place they’ve seen in the past three months. They could live in your house happily ever after. Their eyes start to sparkle. Pleasure Number 2: Milt and Judy can’t believe their eyes when they look at the asking price on your listing statement. By now, they know property values every bit as well as their agent. Your house is definitely priced to sell. Their hands start to tremble. Panic: Judy and Milt see another couple entering your house. They’ve seen these folks at many other open houses during the past couple of months. That familiarity isn’t a coincidence. The other couple obviously wants to buy a house in the same neighborhood and price range. Judy and Milt stare at each other in horror. If they love your house and know that it’s well priced, so will the other couple. Their deodorants fail when they realize that if they don’t act quickly, the other couple will snap up the house. Milt tells their agent to write up a full-asking-price offer. Judy kicks Milt in the shin and instructs the agent to go $1,000 above your asking price just to be safe. Milt agrees. He doesn’t want to be a two-time loser. That scenario explains how pleasure-pleasure-panic pricing creates a seller’s market even in the midst of a buyer’s market. This approach puts intense pressure on buyers to perform quickly. Don’t be surprised if you get several purchase offers, including some that are equal to or more than full asking price, as soon as your house hits the market — if your house is priced right. After your property has been given broad, immediate market exposure, spirited competition forces buyers to pay top dollar for your house. This method works almost every time. (And, by the way, we cover exactly how to handle multiple purchase offers in Chapter 14.)
Quantum pricing: An effective technique Put yourself in the buyer’s shoes for a moment and imagine that you’re buying, not selling, your house. If you’re like most people, one of the first things you do is decide how much you want to spend. For example, you set your upper limit of affordability at $250,000. If you’re working with a real estate agent, you probably tell the age