M i c h a e l J. C r o w e
A HISTORY OF
VEC O R ANALYSIS
T h e Evolution of t h e I d e a of a Vectorial System
A
...
655 downloads
5718 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
M i c h a e l J. C r o w e
A HISTORY OF
VEC O R ANALYSIS
T h e Evolution of t h e I d e a of a Vectorial System
A
HISTORY
OF
VECTOR ANALYSIS T h e E v o l u t i o n of the Idea of a V e c t o r i a l System
M I C H A E L J. CROWE University
of Notre
Dame
D o v e r Publications, I n c . New York
To
Copyright ©
MARY
ELLEN
1967 b y U n i v e r s i t y o f N o t r e D a m e Press
N e w m a t e r i a l C o p y r i g h t © 1985 by M i c h a e l J. C r o w e A l l rights reserved u n d e r Pan A m e r i c a n a n d International C o p y r i g h t Conventions. Published Lesmill Road,
in
Canada by
General
Publishing Company,
Ltd.,
30
D o n Mills, Toronto, Ontario.
Published in the United Kingdom by Constable and Company, Ltd., 10 Orange Street, This
London W C 2 H 7EG.
D o v e r edition, first published in
1985,
is an unabridged and
corrected republication of the work first published by the University of N o t r e D a m e Press i n 1967. A n e w Preface has b e e n a d d e d t o this e d i t i o n . M a n u f a c t u r e d i n t h e U n i t e d States o f A m e r i c a D o v e r Publications, Inc., 31 East 2 n d Street, Mineola, N.Y.
L i b r a r y of Congress Cataloging in Publication D a t a C r o w e , M i c h a e l J. A h i s t o r y of v e c t o r analysis. Originally published: Notre D a m e : University of N o t r e D a m e Press,
1967. W i t h c o r r e c t i o n s a n d n e w pref.
Includes bibliographies and index. 1.
Vector analysis—History.
QA433.C76 ISBN
1985
0-486-64955-5
515'.63
I.
Title. 85-13081
11501
Preface
Shortly before becoming President of Harvard in ematician the
Thomas
best k n o w n
Newton have dynasties
Hill
made
vectorial
done
the
system
following of his
1862, the math-
statement concerning
day:
"The
discoveries
of
m o r e for E n g l a n d a n d for the race than w h o l e
of British
monarchs;
and we
d o u b t not that in the great
mathematical birth of 1853, the Quaternions of H a m i l t o n , there is as much
real
promise
of benefit to
mankind as
in any event of Vic-
toria's r e i g n . " L o r d K e l v i n , w r i t i n g w h e n V i c t o r i a was v e r y o l d a n d the
modern
vector
"Quaternions been
done;
system
came
and,
from
very
new,
Hamilton
though
took
a very
different view.
really
good work had
after his
beautifully
ingenious, have been an
m i x e d evil to those w h o have t o u c h e d t h e m in any w a y .
.
un-
. vectors
. . . have n e v e r b e e n of the slightest use to any creature." T h o u g h Kelvin's barbs quaternion
in this attack of the 1890's w e r e d i r e c t e d against the
system,
methods since the
he
had
been
waging
w a r against all
vectorial
1860's.
If a scientist of the present day w e r e forced to take sides in this dispute
on the value of vectorial
methods, he might view Hill
as
overly enthusiastic, but he w o u l d not side w i t h Kelvin. T h e v i e w of vectorial m e t h o d s c h a m p i o n e d by this great physicist has b e e n refuted by the thousands
of uses
that have b e e n f o u n d for vectorial
m e t h o d s . N e a r l y all b r a n c h e s o f classical p h y s i c s a n d m a n y areas o f m o d e r n physics are n o w p r e s e n t e d i n the language o f vectors, a n d the benefits d e r i v e d t h e r e b y are m a n y . V e c t o r analysis has l i k e w i s e proved omy,
a valuable
Despite little
aid
for
many problems
in engineering, astron-
and geometry. the
studied.
importance Not a single
of vector book
analysis,
and
its
not more
history has than
been
a handful of
s c h o l a r l y p a p e r s h a v e u p t o n o w b e e n w r i t t e n o n its h i s t o r y . C o n s e quently m a n y historical errors m a y be f o u n d in the relevant literaiii
Preface
ture. T h e present study was not w r i t t e n in the expectation that all or even
most historical
swered;
questions a b o u t vector analysis w o u l d b e an-
rather it was
written
in the h o p e of presenting an essen-
t i a l l y c o r r e c t o u t l i n e o f t h e h i s t o r y o f t h i s i m p o r t a n t area. I n u n d e r t a k i n g this study I have f r e q u e n t l y b e e n h i n d e r e d by the scarcity of scholarly
studies
numbers,
linear algebra, tensors, theoretical
of the
history
teenth-century mechanics.
This
of such
r e l a t e d areas
as
complex
electricity, and nine-
is of course the c o m m o n plight of
historians of science, a n d I have b e e n consoled by the hope that the present
study
m a y s h e d l i g h t o n t h e h i s t o r y o f o t h e r areas
o f sci-
ence, such as those m e n t i o n e d above. In
this
pects
study I
h a v e c o n c e n t r a t e d o n t h e m o r e f u n d a m e n t a l as-
of vectorial
treated in detail:
analysis;
the
history of the
following topics
is
vector a d d i t i o n a n d subtraction, the forms of vec-
tor multiplication,
vector division
(in
those
systems
where
i t oc-
curs), a n d t h e s p e c i f i c a t i o n o f v e c t o r types. Less a t t e n t i o n has b e e n given to the history of vector differentiation and integration, and the operator V a n d the associated transformation theorems, since these were
for the
work.
No
most part developed originally in a Cartesian frame-
detailed
presentation
of the
complicated
history of the
l i n e a r vector f u n c t i o n has b e e n a t t e m p t e d . T h o u g h the above statement indicates the materials included, it does not sufficiently specify the approach taken in this study. For a n u m b e r o f r e a s o n s I h a v e c h o s e n t o f o c u s (as t h e s u b t i t l e i n d i c a t e s ) on t h e h i s t o r y of t h e i d e a of a v e c t o r i a l system. It s h o u l d not be forgotten that the m o d e r n
system
many
vectorial
created
these
systems e m b o d i e d an
systems
of vector analysis is but one of the in
the
course
of history.
Each of
idea or conception of the form that a
vectorial system can have and should have. A n d it is the history of these ideas that I have tried to describe. To do this I have discussed each
of the
tempted to led
to
these
vectorial
systems
created
before
1 9 0 0 a n d at-
creation,
development,
and acceptance
or rejection of
systems.
The the
the
major
d e t e r m i n e w h a t ideas (mathematical a n d motivational)
history of vectorial analysis m a y in one sense be v i e w e d as
history of systems of abbreviation, since any p r o b l e m that can
b e s o l v e d b y vectorial m e t h o d s can also b e s o l v e d ( t h o u g h usually less
conveniently) by the
vectorial
analysis
older Cartesian methods. T h e history of
may equally w e l l be v i e w e d as the history of a
w a y of looking at physical a n d geometrical entities. Consideration of these
two
aspects
chosen to focus
of the
history
will
help explain w h y I
have
on the evolution of the idea of a vectorial system,
rather than on the history of the major theorems in vectorial analy-
iv
Preface
sis, m a n y o f w h i c h w e r e i n a n y case d i s c o v e r e d b e f o r e a n d o u t s i d e of the vectorial traditions. Concerning
the
references.
The
reader
will
find
that a simple
and
not u n c o m m o n system o f reference has b e e n e m p l o y e d i n t h e text. T h e notes for each chapter are located at the e n d of that chapter; w i t h i n each chapter ordinary note numbers w i l l be f o u n d as w e l l as r e f e r e n c e s t o t h e s e n o t e s o f t h e f o r m (3,11,1; 2 7 ) . T h e l a t t e r a r e r e a d as follows: the first n u m b e r always refers to a note at the e n d of the chapter;
the
numbers to the right of the semicolon always refer to
the page n u m b e r s in the publication indicated in that note. In some c a s e s (as a b o v e ) o n e o r t w o o t h e r n u m b e r s a r e i n c l u d e d t o t h e l e f t of the semicolon; these numbers ( w h e n they occur) refer to the volume
number and
part n u m b e r of the
the reference above is read:
publication
indicated.
Thus
see v o l u m e I I , part I, of i t e m 3 in t h e
notes; consult page 27. T h r o u g h this m e t h o d it has b e e n p o s s i b l e to provide the reader w i t h
many references
that otherwise
could be
i n c l u d e d only t h r o u g h a substantial increase in the size of the book. Concerning sources
quotations
for this
and
translations.
study were books
Since
many
and journals
of
the
of limited circula-
tion I have used quotations rather liberally. All quotations from documents written in foreign languages (French, German, Italian, Russian,
and
cases
Danish)
where
have
previously
been
translated
published
into
English.
translations
In
were
the
few
available,
I
have used these after c h e c k i n g t h e m against the original a n d n o t i n g deviations. T h e sole e x c e p t i o n to this statement occurs in t h e case of Wessel's D a n i s h ; here I have c h e c k e d Nordgaard's E n g l i s h translation
against
translations Concerning
the
French
translation
of Zeuthen.
The
remaining
(the majority) are my o w n . bibliography.
No
formal
bibliographical
been i n c l u d e d in this book. T h e reader w i l l
find
section
has
h o w e v e r that the
sections of notes at the e n d of each chapter w i l l serve rather w e l l as a bibliography raphy
is
for that
greatly
chapter.
Moreover the
d i m i n i s h e d by the
existence
n e e d for a bibliogof a book
that
lists
nearly all relevant p r i m a r y d o c u m e n t s p u b l i s h e d to about 1912; this is
Alexander
Systems
of
Macfarlane's
Mathematics
(Dublin,
Bibliography 1904).
of
Quaternions
Supplements
to
and
Allied
this
un-
c o m m o n l y accurate bibliography w e r e p u b l i s h e d up to 1913 in the Bulletin
of
Quaternions The
the
International
and
Allied
author
wishes
Society Systems
to
express
for of
his
Promoting
the
Study
of
Mathematics.
gratitude
to those
who
have
aided h i m in preparing this study. P u b l i s h e d and u n p u b l i s h e d materials have b e e n o b t a i n e d f r o m libraries too n u m e r o u s to m e n t i o n , a n d this through the kindness of the librarians of the universities of v
Preface
Notre D a m e , Wisconsin, C a m b r i d g e , a n d Yale. Assistance at important
points
has
come
from
Professor Stephen J.
Rogers
of Notre
D a m e University and from Professor D e r e k J. Price of Yale University. Sincere thanks are e x t e n d e d to Professors C. H. B l a n c h a r d a n d William
D.
sor James
Stahlman of the W.
U n i v e r s i t y of W i s c o n s i n a n d to Profes-
B o n d o f P e n n s y l v a n i a State U n i v e r s i t y . T h e s e three
scholars (a physicist, an historian of science, a n d a mathematician) gave generously of their time (in reading the entire manuscript) and of t h e i r w i s d o m (in s a v i n g t h e m a n u s c r i p t f r o m a n u m b e r of errors). To
Professor E r w i n N.
most
sincere
thanks
Hiebert, of the University of Wisconsin, my
for
his
numerous,
detailed,
and
perceptive
c o m m e n t s on the entire manuscript. Portions of the research for this book
w e r e carried out w i t h f i n a n c i a l assistance p r o v i d e d b y funds
administered by C o m m i t t e e on Grants for the Arts and Humanities of the
University of Notre
Notre
Dame,
Dame. Michael J. Crowe
March,
vi
1967
Indiana
Acknowledgments
Grateful lishers
acknowledgment is hereby made to the following pub-
and
libraries
published B.
G.
for permission
to
quote
from
books
and un-
materials:
Teubner Verlag,
Friedrich
Engel,
Hermann
Grassmanns
kalische
Stuttgart,
Grassmanns
for
Leben,
permission
contained
Gesammelte
in
to
quote
Vol.
mathematische
from
Ill
und
of physi-
Werke.
Cambridge
University
published material
in
Library
for permission to quote from
un-
the correspondence of James Clerk M a x w e l l
and Peter Guthrie Tait. C a m b r i d g e U n i v e r s i t y Press for p e r m i s s i o n to quote f r o m Cargill Gilston
Knott,
Life
and
Scientific
Work
of
Peter
Guthrie
Tait.
Ernst B e n n L i m i t e d , L o n d o n , for permission to quote f r o m O l i v e r Heaviside,
Electromagnetic
Macmillan Oliver
&
Co.,
Theory,
Ltd.,
Heaviside,
Vols.
London,
Electrical
I
for
and
III.
permission
to
quote
from
Papers.
T h o m a s N e l s o n a n d Sons, Ltd., L o n d o n , for p e r m i s s i o n to quote from and
Sir
Edmund
Electricity,
Vol.
Yale
Whittaker,
A
History
of
the
Theories
o f Aether
I.
University Library for permission to quote from the u n p u b -
lished material
in the correspondence of Josiah W i l l a r d Gibbs.
Yale U n i v e r s i t y Press for p e r m i s s i o n to q u o t e f r o m L y n d e P h e l p s Wheeler,
Josiah
Willard
Gibbs:
The
History
of
a
Great
Mind.
vii
List
Graph I
Graphs
and
Tables
Q u a t e r n i o n P u b l i c a t i o n s f r o m 1841 to 1900
Graph I I Graph
of
III
Q u a t e r n i o n Books from 1841 to 1900 Annual
N u m b e r of Titles
of Mathematical
Articles and Books, 1868-1909 Graph I V
Grassmannian
Analysis
Publications
113 from
1841 to 1900 Graph V Graph V I Graph VII Graph
VIII
113
G r a s s m a n n i a n A n a l y s i s B o o k s f r o m 1841 to 1900 Q u a t e r n i o n P u b l i c a t i o n s by C o u n t r y
Analysis
Publications
115 by
Country Graph I X Chronology
viii
114 114
Q u a t e r n i o n B o o k s by C o u n t r y Grassmannian
111 112
G r a s s m a n n i a n Analysis Books by C o u n t r y
115 116 256
Contents
Chapter
One
THE
EARLIEST
TRADITIONS
I. I n t r o d u c t i o n II.
1
The Concept of the
Parallelogram
of Velocities
and
Forces
2
III.
L e i b n i z ' C o n c e p t of a G e o m e t r y of Situation
IV.
The
Concept of the
Geometrical
3
Representation
of
Complex Numbers V.
Chapter
5
Summary and Conclusion
11
Notes
13
Two
SIR
WILLIAM
ROWAN
HAMILTON
AND
QUATERNIONS I.
Introduction: Hamiltonian Historiography
17
Hamilton's Life and Fame
19
III.
Hamilton and Complex Numbers
23
IV.
Hamilton's Discovery of Quaternions
27
Quaternions until H a m i l t o n ' s D e a t h (1865)
33
II.
V. VI.
Chapter
Summary and Conclusion
41
Notes
43
Three
OTHER
EARLY
ESPECIALLY
VECTORIAL
GRASSMANN'S
SYSTEMS, THEORY OF
EXTENSION I. Introduction II.
III. IV.
47
August Ferdinand Mobius and His
Barycentric
Calculus
48
Giusto Bellavitis and His Calculus of Equipollences
52
Hermann
Grassmann
and His
Calculus
Introduction
of Extension: 54
V.
G r a s s m a n n ' s Theorie der Ebbe und Flut
60
VI.
G r a s s m a n n ' s Ausdehnungslehre o f 1 8 4 4
63 ix
Contents
VII. VIII.
IX.
T h e Period from 1844 to 1862 Grassmann's
77
Ausdehnungslehre
of
1862
and
the
Gradual, Limited Acceptance of His Work
89
Matthew O'Brien
96
Notes
Chapter
102
Four
TRADITIONS THE
I. II.
IN
MIDDLE
VECTORIAL PERIOD OF
ANALYSIS ITS
FROM
HISTORY
Introduction
109
Interest in Vectorial Analysis
in Various
Countries
from 1841 to 1900 III.
110
Peter Guthrie Tait:
Advocate
and
Developer of
Quaternions IV.
V. VI.
Chapter
Benjamin
117
Peirce:
Advocate
of Quaternions
in
America
125
James Clerk Maxwell: Critic of Quaternions
127
William Kingdon Clifford: Transition Figure
139
Notes
144
Five
GIBBS
AND
HEAVISIDE
DEVELOPMENT
OF
AND
THE
THE
MODERN
SYSTEM OF VECTOR ANALYSIS I.
Introduction
150
II. Josiah W i l l a r d Gibbs III.
Gibbs' Early W o r k in Vector Analysis
152
IV.
G i b b s ' Elements o f Vector Analysis
155
Gibbs' Other W o r k Pertaining to Vector Analysis
158
V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. X.
Chapter I. II. III.
x
150
Oliver Heaviside
162
Heaviside's Electrical Papers
163
H e a v i s i d e ' s Electromagnetic Theory
169
T h e Reception Given to Heaviside's Writings
174
Conclusion
177
Notes
178
Six
A
STRUGGLE
FOR
EXISTENCE
Introduction
IN
THE
1890'S 182
T h e "Struggle for Existence"
183
Conclusions
215
Notes
221
Contents
Chapter
Seven
THE
EMERGENCE
OF
THE
OF VECTOR ANALYSIS: I. II.
III.
SYSTEM
Introduction Twelve
Major Publications
225 in Vector Analysis
from
1894 to 1910
226
Summary and Conclusion
239
Notes
243
Chapter Eight Notes
Index
MODERN
1894-1910
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
247 255
260
xi
Preface
to
the
Dover
Edition
It is v e r y gratifying that interest in the materials presented in this v o l u m e i s s u f f i c i e n t t o j u s t i f y a s e c o n d e d i t i o n . T h i s has p e r m i t t e d t h e c o r r e c t i o n o f a n u m b e r of small errors and, more importantly, provides an opportunity to b r i n g t o r e a d e r s ' a t t e n t i o n s o m e o f t h e r e l e v a n t s t u d i e s o f s p e c i f i c areas w h i c h h a v e a p p e a r e d s i n c e t h e b o o k ' s first p u b l i c a t i o n i n 1967. Recent researches have shed light particularly on the history of algebra d u r i n g the nineteenth century. T h e most broadly conceived of such works is
Lubos
Novy's
Origins
o f Modern
Algebra.l
British
developments
in
algebra have received most attention, i m p o r t a n t studies having b e e n p u b lished by Harvey W.
Becher,
J.
M.
Dubbey,
Philip C.
Enros,
Elaine
K o p p e l m a n , L u i s M . Laita, a n d Joan L . Richards.2 Interest i n Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n ' s a c h i e v e m e n t s i n a l g e b r a has b e e n especially intense. R e s e a r c h i n t h i s a r e a has b e e n a i d e d b y t h e a p p e a r a n c e i n 1967 u n d e r t h e editorship of H. Hamilton's
Halberstam and R.
Mathematical Papers,
tions in algebra.3 T h o m a s L.
E.
Ingram of the third volume of
that volume
being devoted
H a n k i n s has e n r i c h e d
to his publica-
H a m i l t o n i a n schol-
arship by various publications, most notably his e n g a g i n g b i o g r a p h y of the great Irish m a t h e m a t i c i a n a n d scientist.4 T h e scholar most actively engaged in assessing H a m i l t o n ' s place in t h e history of B r i t i s h algebra is H e l e n a M. Pycior,
w h o s e d o c t o r a l d i s s e r t a t i o n i n t h i s a r e a has b e e n f o l l o w e d b y a
number
of studies
of the
contemporaries.5 Jerold algebraic/analytic
researches
W a e r d e n has p r o v i d e d quaternions.7
algebraic
David
ideas
of Hamilton
and
M a t h e w s has p u b l i s h e d a p a p e r o n during
the
a n e w analysis
1830's,6 w h i l e
of Hamilton's
B l o o r has b r o a d l y c o n s i d e r e d
B.
his
British
Hamilton's L.
van
der
1843 d i s c o v e r y o f
Hamilton's algebraic
a p p r o a c h in r e l a t i o n to t h e social, political, a n d p h i l o s o p h i c a l context o f his times,8 whereas T. the genesis and
L.
H a n k i n s a n d John H e n d r y have focused studies on
importance of Hamilton's conception of algebra as the
"Science of Pure Time."9 Arnold R.
N a i m a n i n his d o c t o r a l dissertation
surveyed the role of quaternions
the overall development of mathe-
matics.10 xii
in
Preface to the D o v e r Edition
The fascination
I felt for
Hamilton while
researching this b o o k was
rivaled, if not surpassed, as I l e a r n e d m o r e of his r e m a r k a b l e c o n t e m p o r a r y Hermann Grassmann.
M a n y issues I e n c o u n t e r e d i n s t u d y i n g his m a t h e -
matical creations have b e e n treated in d e p t h by A l b e r t C. doctoral dissertation
is
Lewis whose
a c a r e f u l a n a l y s i s o f G r a s s m a n n ' s Ausdehnungslehre
o f 1844 a n d its sources. D r . L e w i s has n o w p u b l i s h e d s o m e o f his r e s u l t s i n papers on the influence of Grassmann's father and of Schleiermacher on his mathematical system.11 M o r e o v e r , Jean D i e u d o n n e a n d D e s m o n d Fearnl e y - S a n d e r h a v e e a c h p u b l i s h e d essays o n G r a s s m a n n ' s p l a c e i n t h e h i s t o r y of linear algebra.12 R e c e n t r e s e a r c h e s h a v e also d e v e l o p e d n e w p e r s p e c t i v e s o n f i g u r e s less c e n t r a l t h a n H a m i l t o n a n d G r a s s m a n n i n t h i s h i s t o r y . H e l e n a M . P y c i o r has presented ciative
a fresh
Algebra,13
analysis
and
of B e n j a m i n
Hubert
Kennedy
Peirce's has
p i o n e e r i n g Linear Asso-
investigated
James
Mills
Peirce's place in t h e " c u l t of q u a t e r n i o n s " that arose in late n i n e t e e t h century America.14 G.
C . S m i t h i n a r e c e n t p a p e r has u r g e d t h a t M a t t h e w
O ' B r i e n deserves significantly m o r e credit as a pioneer of the
modern
v e c t o r i a l s y s t e m t h a n has t r a d i t i o n a l l y b e e n a c c o r d e d h i m , 1 5 a n d t h e late B. R.
Gossick has
provided
n e w insights on
the contrasting views
of
vectorial methods espoused by O l i v e r Heaviside and L o r d Kelvin.16 T h e first systematic study of the history of Stokes' T h e o r e m a n d of the associated theorems n a m e d after Gauss and G r e e n is d u e to V i c t o r J.
Katz.17 T h e
i n v o l v e m e n t o f R u s s i a n m a t h e m a t i c i a n s w i t h v e c t o r i a l m e t h o d s has b e e n treated b y W . D o b r o v o l s k i j , 1 8 a n d studies o f t h e history o f v e c t o r analysis i n general have b e e n u n d e r t a k e n by A d a l b e r t A p o l i n a n d James W. Joiner, b o t h of w h o m seem to have w r i t t e n w i t h o u t k n o w l e d g e of my book.19 F o r t h e sake o f c o m p l e t e n e s s , m e n t i o n s h o u l d b e m a d e o f t h r e e p u b l i c a tions w h i c h a p p e a r e d before m y book, b u t w h i c h escaped m y b i b l i o g r a p h i c searches. T w o o f these, b o t h f r o m t h e 1930 s , t r e a t t h e h i s t o r y o f c o m p l e x n u m b e r s ; the earlier was w r i t t e n by J. B u d o n whereas the second is E r n e s t Nagel's " I m p o s s i b l e N u m b e r s . " 2 0 T h e latter omission is especially regrettab l e b e c a u s e t h a t essay p r o v i d e s a h i s t o r i o g r a p h i c p e r s p e c t i v e w h i c h w o u l d h a v e e n r i c h e d m y p r e s e n t a t i o n . T h i s i s e v e n m o r e t r u e o f t h e t h i r d essay, that p u b l i s h e d in 1 9 6 3 - 6 4 by the late I m r e Lakatos.21 A l t h o u g h c o n t a i n i n g essentially n o t h i n g r e l e v a n t to the h i s t o r y of vector analysis, Lakatos' n o w f a m o u s essay i s r i c h i n p h i l o s o p h i c a n d h i s t o r i o g r a p h i c i n s i g h t s w h i c h , w e r e I to rewrite this book, w o u l d certainly be included. Some hints as to the d i r e c t i o n I w o u l d t a k e a r e p r o v i d e d i n a h i s t o r i o g r a p h i c essay I p u b l i s h e d i n 1975.22 Persons w h o m a y acquire f r o m this book an interest in f u r t h e r readings in the history of mathematics
may wish
to consult
the
excellent
general
histories of mathematics w r i t t e n by Carl B. Boyer and M o r r i s Kline,23 or for articles on i n d i v i d u a l mathematicians, o f Scientific
Biography,24
Bibliographic
t h e m a n y v o l u m e s o f t h e Dictionary
searches
which
required
days
in xiii
Preface to the D o v e r Edition
t h e e a r l y 1960's c a n n o w b e a c c o m p l i s h e d b y s p e n d i n g a f e w h o u r s w i t h t h e late
Kenneth
Mathematics
O.
Mays
and
with
Bibliography
the
ISIS
and
Research
Manual
of the
History
of
Bibliography.25
Cumulative
In c o n c l u d i n g this u p d a t e d preface, I extend w a r m e s t thanks to the two persons
w h o have
made
this
new edition
possible:
John
W.
Grafton,
Assistant to t h e P r e s i d e n t of D o v e r Publications, a n d James R. L a n g f o r d , D i r e c t o r o f t h e U n i v e r s i t y o f N o t r e D a m e Press. T h e e n c o u r a g e m e n t o f t h e f o r m e r a n d t h e cooperation of the latter are chiefly responsible for this book b e i n g once again available to readers. M i c h a e l J. C r o w e University of Notre
Dame
January, 1985
Notes 1
LuboS
2
Harvey
Novy,
Mathematica, Historia
W.
Origins
7 (1980),
Mathematica,
(1812-1813): (1983),
"Woodhouse,
3 8 9 - 4 0 0 ; J. 4
(1977),
Elaine
Archive for
M.
by Jaroslav T a u e r
Dubbey,
Renewal
Koppelman,
History
trans, Babbage,
295-302;
Precursor of t h e
24-47;
Algebra,"
o f Modern Algebra,
Becher,
Peacock,
and
"Babbage,
Philip
C.
1973).
A l g e b r a , " Historia
Peacock a n d M o d e r n A l g e b r a , "
Enros,
of C a m b r i d g e
(Leyden,
Modern
"The
Analytical
M a t h e m a t i c s , " Historia
Society
Mathematica,
10
" T h e C a l c u l u s o f O p e r a t i o n s a n d t h e Rise o f Abstract
o f Exact
Sciences,
8
(1971),
155-242;
Luis
M.
Laita,
"The
Influence of Boole's Search for a Universal M e t h o d in Analysis on the Creation of His Logic," Annals
o f Science,
Controversy
34
(1977),
between
163-176;
William
Luis
Hamilton
M.
Laita,
and
"Influences
Augustus
De
on
Boole's
Logic:
The
M o r g a n , " Annals o f Science,
36
(1979), 4 5 - 6 5 ; L u i s M . L a i t a , " B o o l e a n A l g e b r a a n d Its E x t r a - l o g i c a l Sources: T h e T e s t i m o n y of M a r y
Everest
Boole,"
History and Philosophy o f Logic,
" T h e A r t and the Science of British Algebra: Truth," 3
H.
Hamilton, 4
Historia
Mathematica,
Halberstam vol.
Ill:
Thomas
L.
7
and
Algebra
(1980),
R.
E.
Hankins,
Sir
William
(1980),
3 7 - 6 0 ; Joan
L.
Richards,
343-365.
Ingram,
(Cambridge,
1
A Study in the Perception of Mathematical
The
Mathematical
England, Rowan
Papers
of
Sir
William
Rowan
1967).
Hamilton
(Baltimore,
1980).
For
a
shorter
b i o g r a p h y w h i c h discusses H a m i l t o n ' s m a t h e m a t i c s o n a m o r e e l e m e n t a r y l e v e l , see: Sean O'Donnell, 5
William
Helena
Algebra ( A
M.
Rowan
Hamilton:
Pycior,
1976 C o r n e l l
The
Portrait
Role
of Sir
of a
Prodigy
William
Hamilton
University doctoral dissertation);
(Dublin,
1983).
in
the
Development
H.
M.
Pycior,
and the
B r i t i s h O r i g i n s o f S y m b o l i c a l A l g e b r a , " Historia Mathematica, 8 ( 1 9 8 1 ) ,
Pycior,
"Early
Criticisms
(1982), 3 9 2 - 4 1 2 ; H . Isis, 6
74 ( 1 9 8 3 ) ,
7
L.
available
in
Approach
to
Algebra,"
23-45;
Historia
H.
M.
Mathematica,
9
211-226. "William Rowan
Archive for
B.
Symbolical
Modern
M . Pycior, " A u g u s t u s D e Morgan's Algebraic W o r k : T h e T h r e e Stages,"
Jerold Mathews,
Analysis, "
of t h e
of British
" G e o r g e Peacock
van
History der
English
of Exact
Waerden,
as
H a m i l t o n ' s P a p e r o f 1837 o n t h e A r i t h m e t i z a t i o n o f
Sciences,
19
Hamiltons
"Hamilton's
(1978),
Entdeckungder
Discovery
177-200. Quaternionen(Gottingen,
of Q u a t e r n i o n s , "
1974).
Mathematics
Now
Magazine,
49
(1976), 2 2 7 - 2 3 4 . 8
David
Nineteenth
Bloor,
Century
"Hamilton
Mathematics,
and
ed.
by
Peacock
on
Herbert
the
Essence of A l g e b r a "
Mehrtens,
Henk
Bos
in
and
Social History o f Ivo
Schneider
( B o s t o n , 1981), p p . 2 0 2 - 2 3 2 . 9
Thomas L. Hankins, "Algebra as Pure Time: William Rowan Hamilton and the Founda-
tions
xiv
of
Algebra"
in
Motion
and
Time,
Space
and
Matter:
Interrelations
in
the
History
of
Preface to the D o v e r Edition
Philosophy and Science,
ed.
by P.
J.
Machamer and
R.
G.
Turnbull (Columbus,
1976),
pp.
327-359. 10
Arnold
R.
Naiman,
The
Role
of Quaternions
in
the
History
of
Grassmanns
of Mathematics
(A
1974
New
York University doctoral dissertation). 11
Albert
C.
Lewis,
An
Historical
Analysis
1975 U n i v e r s i t y o f T e x a s a t A u s t i n d o c t o r a l dissertation); A . Ausdehnungslehre A.
and
Schleiermacher's
Dialektik ,"
Annals
Ausdehnungslehre
of 1844
(A
C . L e w i s , " H . G r a s s m a n n ' s 1844
of Science,
34
(1977),
103-162;
C. Lewis, "Justus Grassmann's School Programs as Mathematical Antecedents of H e r m a n n
Grassmann's in
the
Early
1844
Ausdehnungslehre"
Nineteenth
Century,
ed.
in
by
Epistemological
Hans
Niels
and
Jahnke
Social and
Problems
Michael
of the
Otte
Sciences
(Dordrecht,
1981), p p . 2 5 5 - 2 6 7 . 12
Jean
1-14;
Dieudonne,
Desmond
gebra,"
American
"Hermann Monthly, 13
"The
Mathematical
Grassmann
89
(1982),
Helena
Tragedy
Fearnley-Sander, Monthly,
and
of G r a s s m a n n , ' '
"Hermann 86
the
Linear and
Grassmann
(1979),
809-817;
Prehistory
of
Multilinear Algebra,
and
the Creation
see
also
Universal
D.
8
(1979),
of Linear Al-
Fearnley-Sander,
Algebra,"
American
Mathematical
161-166.
M.
Pycior,
"Benjamin
Peirce's
Linear
Associative
Algebra,"
I sis,
70
(1979),
537-551. 14
Hubert
Kennedy,
"James
Mills
Peirce and
t h e C u l t o f Q u a t e r n i o n s , " Historia
Mathemat-
ica, 6 ( 1 9 7 9 ) , 4 2 3 - 4 2 9 . 15
G.
C.
Smith,
Mathematica, 16
B.
9
R.
"Matthew
(1982),
O'Brien's
Anticipation
of Vectorial
Mathematics,"
Historia
172-190.
Gossick,
"Heaviside
and
Kelvin:
A
Study
in
C o n t r a s t s , " Annals
o f Science,
33
(1976), 2 7 5 - 2 8 7 . 17
Victor
J.
Katz,
"The
History
of Stokes'
Theorem,"
Mathematics
Magazine,
52
(1979),
146-156. 18
W . D o b r o v o l s k i j , " D e v e l o p p e m e n t d e l a t h e o r i e des v e c t e u r s e t des q u a t e r n i o n s dans les
travaux des
mathematiciens
russes
du X I X e
siecle,"
Revue d'histoire des sciences,
21
(1968),
345-349. 19
Adalbert
ralis,
12
Apolin,
(1970),
"Die
357-365;
geschichtliche James
Entwicklung der Vektorrechnung,"
W a l t e r Joiner,
A
History of Vector Analysis (A
Historia Natu-
1971
doctoral
dissertation at G e o r g e Peabody C o l l e g e for Teachers). 20
J.
Budon,
quelques (1933), Ideas, the
175-200; 3
(1935),
Philosophy 21
" S u r la r e p r e s e n t a t i o n g e o m e t r i q u e s des n o m b r e s imaginaires (Analyse de
memoires
Imre
parus
de
220-232; 427-474;
and
History
Lakatos,
1795
Ernest reprinted
of Science
"Proofs
a
1820),"
Nagel, in
(New
and
Bulletin
des sciences
"Impossible
Ernest York,
Nagel,
1979),
Refutations,"
mathematiques,
Numbers,"
ser. the
2,
57
History
of
Teleology Revisited and Other Essays
in
pp.
Studies i n
166-194.
British Journal for
the
Philosophy
of Science,
14
( 1 9 6 3 - 1 9 6 4 ) , 1 - 2 5 ; 1 2 0 - 1 3 9 ; 2 2 1 - 2 4 5 ; 2 9 6 - 3 4 2 . T h e s e e s s a y s h a v e n o w b e e n r e p u b l i s h e d as: Imre
Lakatos,
Proof and
Refutations:
The
Logic
of
Mathematical
Discovery,
ed.
by
John
W o r r a l l a n d E l i e Z a h a r ( C a m b r i d g e , E n g l a n d , 1976). 22
M.
Historia 23
ical 24
J. Crowe, " T e n ' L a w s ' C o n c e r n i n g Patterns ofChange in the History of Mathematics," Mathematica,
Carl
B.
2
Boyer,
Thought from
(1975), A
Ancient
161-166.
History o f Mathematics ( N e w Y o r k , to
Modern
Dictionary o f Scientific Biography,
14
Times
(New
vols.,
ed.
1968) a n d
York, by
Morris
Kline,
Mathemat-
1972).
Charles
Coulston
Gillispie
( N e w York,
Science
Formed from
1970-1980). 25
ISIS
ISIS
Cumulative
Critical
1 9 7 1 - 1 9 8 2 ) ; ISIS 1980);
and
Bibliography.
Bibliographies
1-90:
Cumulative
Kenneth
O.
A
Bibliography
1913-1965,
Bibliography May,
5
of
vols.,
1966-1975, Bibliography
vol. and
the
ed.
History by
I,
Research
of
Magda
ed.
by
Manual
Whitrow
John of the
Neu History
(London, (London, of Mathematics
( T o r o n t o , 1973). XV
CHAPTER
The
I.
Earliest
ONE
Traditions
Introduction The
early
history
of
vectorial
analysis
is
most
viewed within the context of two broad traditions
appropriately
in the history of
science. O n e of these traditions relates to mathematics, the other to physical
science.
T h e first tradition, that w i t h i n the history of mathematics, extends from the time of the Egyptians and Babylonians to the present and consists
in
the
progressive
Throughout time to include
the
broadening of the
concept of number.
c o n c e p t of n u m b e r has b e e n e x p a n d e d so as
not only positive
integers, but negative
numbers,
frac-
tions, and algebraic and transcendental irrationals. E v e n t u a l l y complex
and
higher complex
numbers
(including
vectors)
were intro-
duced. T h e activities of some of the figures in the history of vector analysis m a y be v i e w e d as b e l o n g i n g to this tradition. The also
second tradition, that w i t h i n the history of physical science,
extends
back
mathematical
to
ancient
entities
and
times
a n d consists
operations
that
in the
represent
search for aspects
of
physical reality. This tradition p l a y e d a part in the creation of G r e e k geometry, and the inherited problems.
from
natural philosophers of the seventeenth century
the
Greeks
However
in the
the
geometrical
course
of the
approach
seventeenth
to
physical
century the
physical entities to be represented passed t h r o u g h a transformation. This
transformation
consisted
in
the
shift
in
emphasis
from
such
scalar q u a n t i t i e s as p o s i t i o n a n d w e i g h t to s u c h v e c t o r i a l q u a n t i t i e s as velocity, force, m o m e n t u m , and acceleration. T h e transition was neither abrupt nor was it confined to the seventeenth century. Later developments to
transform
with
in
the
electricity, space
magnetism,
of mathematical
and
optics
physics
into
acted
further
a space filled
vectors.
These two broad traditions converged at a n u m b e r of periods history;
one
such
period
was
in the
in
nineteenth century, and this
1
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
convergence
is
marked
by
the
creation
and
d e v e l o p m e n t of vec-
torial methods. T h e first major three-dimensional vectorial systems were
created in
portant ideas
1840,s.
the
Before
were put forth w h i c h
this
time, however, three im-
l e d t o t h e m a j o r v e c t o r i a l sys-
tems. T h e s e t h r e e ideas are the subject of the present chapter; t h e y are the c o n c e p t of a p a r a l l e l o g r a m of forces, L e i b n i z ' c o n c e p t of a geometry of situation, and the concept of the geometrical representation
of imaginary
II.
The and
Concept
numbers.
of
the
Parallelogram
of
Velocities
Forces
O n e of the most f u n d a m e n t a l m a t h e m a t i c a l ideas in vector analysis
is
the
idea of the addition of vectors.
T h e sum of t w o vectors
w h i c h have a c o m m o n point of origin is defined as the vector originating at the same point and extending to the opposite corner of the parallelogram d e f i n e d by the t w o original vectors. Certain physical entities,
such
as
velocities
a n d forces,
m a y be c o m p o u n d e d
in
a
similar w a y , a n d f r o m this c o r r e s p o n d e n c e stems m u c h of the usefulness
of vector analysis.
T h e idea of a parallelogram of velocities may be found in various ancient forces
authors,8 *
Greek was
not
uncommon
and in
the the
concept
of a
parallelogram
of
sixteenth and seventeenth cen-
turies.9 By the early n i n e t e e n t h century parallelograms of physical entities
frequently
appeared
in
treatises,
and
this
usage
indirectly
led to vector analysis, for this idea p r o v i d e d a striking example of how
vectorial
entities
could
be
used
for physical
applications.
It
s h o u l d not be inferred, h o w e v e r , that all of those w h o used the concept of a parallelogram of physical entities were aware of the idea of a vector or of vector addition.
T h e essential
idea in the parallelo-
gram of physical entities is the construction of a diagram in terms of w h i c h the operations involved in determining the resultant become evident.
The
i d e a o f adding t h e l i n e s n e e d n o t b e i n t r o d u c e d o r w a s
i t (to m y k n o w l e d g e ) e v e r i n t r o d u c e d b e f o r e t h e c r e a t i o n o f vectors. T h u s this
i d e a a l o n e c o u l d n o t a n d a l m o s t c e r t a i n l y d i d n o t directly
s t i m u l a t e a n y o n e to t h e c r e a t i o n of a vectorial system. Its i n f l u e n c e was
indirect b u t i m p o r t a n t , f o r i t w a s t h e f i r s t a n d m o s t o b v i o u s c a s e
in w h i c h vectorial methods could be brought to the aid of physical science. ° T h e system used for n u m b e r i n g notes is described in the preface.
2
The
III.
Leibniz'
Concept
of
a
Geometry
of
Earliest
Traditions
Situation
Gottfried W i l h e l m Leibniz (1646-1716) made many contributions to
mathematics;
among
geometry of situation.
the
In
less
this
well
regard
known
is
Leibniz
his
concept
discussed
of a
the possi-
bility of creating a system w h i c h w o u l d serve as a direct m e t h o d of space
analysis.
Although
the
details
of this
idea were
never fully
w o r k e d out by L e i b n i z , he a d v a n c e d far e n o u g h to be r a n k e d as a conceptual
forerunner of the
essay, w h i c h w a s
history of vectorial Leibniz' main 8,
first
vectorial
first p u b l i s h e d in
analysts.
M o r e o v e r his
1833, p l a y e d a part in the later
analysis.
ideas w e r e contained in a letter dated S e p t e m b e r Huygens.1
1679, a n d w r i t t e n to Christian
In this
letter L e i b n i z
wrote: I am still not satisfied w i t h algebra, because it does not give the shortest methods or the most beautiful constructions in geometry. This is w h y I believe that,
so far as
geometry is
concerned, we
need still
another
analysis w h i c h is distinctly geometrical or linear a n d w h i c h w i l l express situation
[situs]
directly
as
algebra
expresses
magnitude
directly.
And
I
believe that I have f o u n d the w a y a n d that we can represent figures a n d even
machines
and
movements
by
characters,
as
algebra represents
n u m b e r s or m a g n i t u d e s . I am s e n d i n g y o u an essay w h i c h seems to me t o b e i m p o r t a n t . (1; 3 8 2 ) I n his essay, w h i c h was c o n t a i n e d i n the letter, L e i b n i z d e s c r i b e d his
system further: I
have discovered certain e l e m e n t s of a n e w characteristic w h i c h is
entirely different f r o m algebra a n d w h i c h w i l l have great advantages i n r e p r e s e n t i n g t o t h e m i n d , e x a c t l y a n d i n a w a y f a i t h f u l t o its n a t u r e , e v e n w i t h o u t f i g u r e s , e v e r y t h i n g w h i c h d e p e n d s o n sense p e r c e p t i o n . A l g e b r a is the characteristic for u n d e t e r m i n e d n u m b e r s or m a g n i t u d e s o n l y , b u t it does not express situation, angles, a n d m o t i o n directly. H e n c e it is often difficult to analyze the properties of a figure by calculation, and still more difficult to find very convenient geometrical demonstrations and constructions,
even
w h e n the algebraic calculation
is completed.
But
this n e w characteristic, w h i c h follows the visual figures, cannot fail to give the solution, the construction, and the geometric demonstration all at the
same time,
and
in
a natural
w a y and in
one
analysis,
t h a t is,
through determined procedure.
B u t its c h i e f v a l u e l i e s i n t h e r e a s o n i n g w h i c h c a n b e d o n e a n d t h e c o n clusions could
which
not
be
c a n b e d r a w n b y o p e r a t i o n s w i t h its c h a r a c t e r s , w h i c h expressed
in
figures,
and
still
less
in
models,
without
m u l t i p l y i n g these too greatly o r w i t h o u t c o n f u s i n g t h e m w i t h too m a n y points and lines in the course of the m a n y futile attempts one is forced to
make.
This
method,
by contrast, w i l l g u i d e us
surely and without
3
A
History
effort.
of V e c t o r Analysis
I b e l i e v e that by this m e t h o d one c o u l d treat mechanics almost
l i k e g e o m e t r y , a n d o n e c o u l d e v e n test the qualities of materials, because this o r d i n a r i l y d e p e n d s o n c e r t a i n f i g u r e s i n t h e i r s e n s i b l e parts. F i n a l l y , I have no h o p e that we can get v e r y far in physics u n t i l we have f o u n d s o m e s u c h m e t h o d o f a b r i d g m e n t t o l i g h t e n its b u r d e n o f i m a g i n a t i o n . (1; 3 8 4 - 3 8 5 )
His
system
as actually sketched by h i m shows that he by no means
discovered a primitive vector analysis, though the above quotations show
that
he
was
searching
for
s o m e t h i n g a k i n to vector analysis.
L e i b n i z ' s y s t e m c e n t e r e d o n t h e i d e a o f t h e c o n g r u e n c e o f sets o f points.
He used A, B, . . . to represent fixed points and X, Y , . . . to
represent u n k n o w n relation
points.
congruence;
The
thus
he
s y m b o l b was used to express the wrote
A B C b DEF
to
express
that
a
set of t h r e e p o i n t s A, B, C, e a c h of w h i c h w a s a fixed distance f r o m t h e o t h e r t w o p o i n t s , c o u l d b e m a d e t o c o i n c i d e w i t h a n o t h e r set o f similarly fixed points D, E, F. He then discussed locus relations and stated that the locus of points congruent to a
fixed
space
g i v e n t h a t AB
infinite
in
all
directions."
(1;
387)
If it is
point " w i l l be a b
AY,
the p o i n t values of Y w i l l be points on a sphere w i t h center at A and radius
of
whose
points
length
A B C b A B Y
(X)
AB.
The
are
equidistant
determines
relation
AX b BX
from
a circle.
locus
that the
of all
Y's
r e l a t i o n AY
will V
BY
be V
a
determines
and
B,
and
a
the
plane
relation
L e i b n i z then discussed the locus
of points Y satisfying the relation AY "the
A
b BY
straight
CY V
DY
line."
b
CY and c o n c l u d e d that (1;
389)
determines
applied his analysis to four simple problems.
After
showing
a point, Leibniz
O n e of these may be
discussed as typical. T h e p r o b l e m is to show that the intersection of two planes plane,
is a straight line.
and
the
combining before,
relation
these
we
determines
AY
have
T h e relation AY b BY determines one b CY
AY
determines
b BY b CY,
a
second
which,
as
plane.
it was
By
shown
a straight line.10
Proceeding from this s u m m a r y of Leibniz' best-known exposition system,11
of his sis.
First,
w e m a y d i s c u s s its r e l a t i o n t o m o d e r n v e c t o r a n a l y -
Leibniz
deserves
much
credit for suggesting that a n e w
algebra, w h e r e i n geometrical entities are symbolically represented and he
the
symbols
operated u p o n directly, was
desirable.
However,
failed to discover a system in w h i c h geometrical entities could
be a d d e d , subtracted, a n d m u l t i p l i e d . L i k e w i s e he failed to see that A B a n d B A (for e x a m p l e ) can b e v i e w e d a s distinct entities a n d that —AB
could have a significant meaning.
representing runner the
4
of
a
fixed
Mobius
concept
point
and
of a vector.
by
a
T h o u g h his idea of directly
symbol
Grassmann,
he
makes
certainly
him did
a partial forenot
introduce
D e s p i t e the fact that angle considerations
The
Earliest Traditions
d i d not enter into his system, he still m u s t be v i e w e d as h a v i n g constructed a system w h i c h a l l o w e d for the use of co-ordinai^s. L e i b n i z saw that a n e w algebra of the applications failed
to
in
mathematics
develop
Leibniz'
system
practical taken
form
and
sought
in
methods
by
w o u l d have
the physical for these
Couturat,
though
numerous
sciences, but he
tasks.
stated
The in
view
of
relation
to
Grassmann's system, is also a p p l i c a b l e in r e l a t i o n to m o d e r n vector analysis; Couturat wrote:
" I n summary, the calculus of Grassmann
seems to bring fully into reality the geometrical characteristic conceived by Leibniz, and shows that Leibniz' idea was not simply a dream. But there is such a disproportion b e t w e e n Leibniz' conception
of a
system
and
the
very
defective
p r o d u c e d that Grassmann felt a sharp
essay
which
he
actually
distinction should be made
between the ideal conceived and the sketch actually written." Shortly after Jablonowski
1833,
12
w h e n L e i b n i z ' essay was first p u b l i s h e d , the
Gesellschaft expressed their interest in
and enthusi-
asm for the essay by offering a prize for the f u r t h e r d e v e l o p m e n t of Leibniz'
system.
One
mathematician entered the competition and
w o n the prize, e v e n t h o u g h he had created his system before hearing of L e i b n i z ' ideas; this mathematician was Grassmann a n d this incident w i l l be more fully discussed in the third chapter.
IV.
The of
Concept
Complex
Though ence
to
the
term
systems
dimensional
of
the
Geometrical
Representation
Numbers vector
of
space,
analysis
is
mathematics it
should
now
that
not
be
used
may
primarily
be
applied
forgotten
that
in
refer-
in
the
three-
complex
n u m b e r s y s t e m m a y l e g i t i m a t e l y be c o n s i d e r e d as a v e c t o r i a l system.
The
metrical useful
as
two-dimensional representation the
of
vectorial complex
three-dimensional
primary subject of this history. cuss
briefly
system
based
numbers
vectorial
is
on
the
certainly
systems
which
geo-
not are
as the
Nevertheless it is i m p o r t a n t to dis-
the early history of the
geometrical representation
of
complex numbers, not only because the complex n u m b e r system is (broadly
speaking)
a vectorial
system
b u t also
because
Hamilton
discovered quaternions in the course of a search for a t h r e e - d i m e n sional analogue to the complex n u m b e r system. A t least six m e n are c o m m o n l y c r e d i t e d w i t h t h e d i s c o v e r y o f t h e geometrical
representation
of complex
numbers;
t h e y are Wessel,
Gauss, Argand, Buee, M o u r e y , a n d Warren.13 Since the systems crea t e d b y these six m e n are v e r y s i m i l a r a n d are o f l i m i t e d r e l e v a n c e to
the
present
study, they need not all be discussed in
detail.
In
5
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
w h a t follows, the system p u b l i s h e d by Wessel, w h i c h was the earliest a n d a m o n g t h e m o s t i m p r e s s i v e , w i l l b e a n a l y z e d i n s o m e d e p t h ; t h e ideas o f t h e o t h e r f i v e m e n w i l l b e t r e a t e d less f u l l y t h o u g h w i t h special will
be
attention
to
certain
shown
that
some
three-dimensional
aspects of their d e v e l o p m e n t . T h u s it of
vectorial
these
mathematicians
systems
and
that
one
searched
of them
for
influ-
enced Hamilton in an important manner. Although
Hero
of Alexandria
and
Diophantus
in ancient times
h a d encountered the question of the m e a n i n g of the square root of a negative
number,
and although
Cardan
had in his
1 5 4 5 Ars Magna
used complex numbers in computation, nevertheless complex numbers were not accepted by most mathematicians as legitimate mathematical
entities
until
well
into
hardly surprising since numbers
the
nineteenth
such as
century.
This is
V ^ T seem to be neither
less t h a n , greater t h a n , n o r e q u a l to zero. In
modern
mathematics
complex
numbers
are
usually justified
either by representing t h e m in terms of couplets of real numbers or by representing them geometrically. T h e origin of the first method w i l l be discussed in the next chapter. T h e first attempt (which was unsuccessful)
to
represent
complex
numbers
geometrically
was
m a d e in the seventeenth century by John Wallis.14 W h e r e Wallis failed, a Norwegian Caspar Wessel geometrical
(1745-1818)
representation
surveyor succeeded;
in
1799
published the first explanation of the of complex
numbers.15
His
ideas w e r e
p r e s e n t e d before the Royal A c a d e m y o f D e n m a r k i n 1797 a n d publ i s h e d t w o years later in the m e m o i r s of that society.2 Unfortunately, however, Wessel's ematicians until
publication went unnoticed by European math-
1897, w h e n it was r e p u b l i s h e d in a F r e n c h transla-
tion.3 In the first paragraph of his m e m o i r W e s s e l stated: attempt
deals
with
the
question,
"This present
h o w may we represent direction
a n a l y t i c a l l y ; t h a t is, h o w s h a l l w e e x p r e s s r i g h t l i n e s s o t h a t i n a single the
equation length
i n v o l v i n g one u n k n o w n line and others k n o w n , both and
the
direction
of the
unknown
line
may
be
ex-
p r e s s e d . " (2; 55) A s t h i s q u o t a t i o n suggests a n d later passages confirm, Wessel's chief interest was the creation of geometrical methods; his representation of c o m p l e x n u m b e r s was subservient to this aim.
Nonetheless
the
latter p l a y e d a f u n d a m e n t a l role as is indi-
cated by the following statement: treatise]
was
my
" T h e o c c a s i o n for its b e i n g [his
seeking a method whereby I could avoid the im-
possible operations. . .
(2; 57)
After stating that previously only oppositely directed lines could be r e p r e s e n t e d analytically, W e s s e l suggested that it s h o u l d be pos-
6
The
sible to a
find
definition
added
Traditions
methods to represent inclined lines. Wessel then gave of the
if we
Earliest
addition
of straight
lines:
" T w o
unite t h e m in such a w a y that the
right
lines
are
second line begins
w h e r e t h e first o n e e n d s , a n d t h e n pass a r i g h t l i n e f r o m t h e first to t h e last p o i n t o f t h e u n i t e d lines. T h i s l i n e i s t h e s u m o f t h e u n i t e d lines."
(2;
58)
In
the
subsequent
discussion
of addition
Wessel
stated that the same definition can be used in a d d i n g m o r e than t w o (not necessarily coplanar) lines a n d that the order of addition is immaterial.
(2;
59)
Hence Wessel
had
introduced three-dimensional
vector addition and realized the importance of the commutative law for
addition.
Though
Wessel
had
up
to
called the positive unit (our 1
this of x
point •
only
discussed
what
he
1 + yV—I) a n d h a d n o t y e t i n d i -
cated h o w lines in general were to be represented in terms of complex numbers, nevertheless he proceeded to introduce the multiplication of lines.
The
product of two lines
(coplanar with each other
and w i t h the positive unit) was to have a length equal to the product of the lengths of the t w o factors. T h e p r o d u c t l i n e was to be coplanar w i t h t h e t w o factor l i n e s a n d w a s t o h a v e its i n c l i n a t i o n o r d i r e c t i o n angle (defined by reference to the inclination of the positive unit as 0°) e q u a l Wessel
to the
then
L e t 4-1
sum
of the
inclinations
of the
factor lines.
(2; 60)
added:
designate the positive rectilinear unit and +e a certain other
unit perpendicular to the positive unit and having the same origin; then t h e d i r e c t i o n a n g l e o f + 1 w i l l b e e q u a l t o 0°, t h a t o f - 1 t o 180°, t h a t o f + e t o 90°, a n d that o f - e t o - 9 0 ° o r 270°. B y t h e r u l e that t h e d i r e c t i o n a n g l e of the p r o d u c t shall e q u a l the s u m of the angles of the factors, we have: (+1)(+1) = + 1 ;
( + 1 ) ( — 1 ) = —1; ( - 1 ) ( - 1 ) = + 1 ; ( + l ) ( + e ) = +
(-l)(+e) = - e ; ( - l ) ( - € ) = +6;
(+e)(+e) = - 1 ;
e ;
(+e)(-e) = + 1 ;
(+l)(-6) = -
€ ;
(-e)(-e) = - 1 .
F r o m this it is seen that e is equal to V ^ I ; a n d the divergence of the product is d e t e r m i n e d such that not any of the c o m m o n rules of operation are c o n t r a v e n e d . (2; 60) Wessel
stated that any straight line in a plane m a y be represented
analytically showed
how
by
the
expressions
such
expressions
a +
eb
and
are to be
r(cos
v + €
multiplied,
v)
and
divided,
sin
and
raised to powers.
After giving t w o examples of the application of his
methods, Wessel
developed an elementary three-dimensional vec-
tor analysis.
(3; 2 3 - 2 8 )
Wessel began by constructing three mutually perpendicular lines w h i c h passed t h r o u g h the center of a sphere of radius r. W e s s e l specified three
that three radii
of the sphere w h i c h were collinear with the
m u t u a l l y p e r p e n d i c u l a r axes
s h o u l d be
designated by r,
171%
and er and that any point in space c o u l d be designated by a vector of
7
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
t h e f o r m x + r)y + ez.
(3;
23-24)
By a n a l o g y w i t h o r d i n a r y c o m p l e x
n u m b e r s W e s s e l d e f i n e d 1717 a n d e e a s e q u a l t o — 1 . T h e m u l t i p l i c a tion
of vectors corresponded to the rotation and extension of one
v e c t o r by a n o t h e r . T h u s (x
f 171/ + ez)
,,
( c o s u + € s i n u) r e p r e s e n t e d
t h e r o t a t i o n o f t h e v e c t o r x + iqy + e z t h r o u g h t h e a n g l e u a r o u n d t h e 17 or y axis. W e s s e l stated that t h e c o m p o n e n t of t h e v e c t o r that lies on
the
axis
product
of
of t h e
rotation above
is
should 17y +
remain x
cos
unchanged,
u — z
sin
and
thus
u + ex s i n
the
u + ez
cos u . ( 3 ; 2 5 - 2 6 ) T h e s y m b o l , , w a s u s e d t o i n d i c a t e m u l t i p l i c a t i o n . A r o t a t i o n of v d e g r e e s a r o u n d t h e € or z axis w a s e x p r e s s e d in t h e f o l l o w i n g w a y : (x + 1 7 y + ez)
,, ( c o s v + 1 7 s i n v) = ez + x c o s v — y s i n v
+ rjx s i n v + 7)y c o s v . ( 3 ; 2 6 ) R o t a t i o n s a r o u n d t h e 1 7 a x i s c o u l d b e compounded with
rotations
a r o u n d t h e € axis a n d v i c e versa, b u t
r o t a t i o n s a r o u n d t h e axis of t h e p o s i t i v e u n i t (the x axis) w e r e n e v e r discussed by Wessel. T h e reason for this is that serious mathematical
difficulties
were
involved
in
determining how
such
rotations
s h o u l d b e r e p r e s e n t e d , f o r e x a m p l e , t h e p r o d u c t s 17c a n d erj w o u l d h a v e h a d to be defined. W e s s e l p r e s u m a b l y e n c o u n t e r e d these difficulties b u t c o u l d not solve them.16 But even w i t h this limitation on his m e t h o d s Wessel was able to use t h e m to derive a n u m b e r of important results in spherical trigonometry. Wessel's
t h r e e - d i m e n s i o n a l v e c t o r i a l s y s t e m e x h i b i t e d a n a d hoc
character that makes
it appear seriously deficient w h e n compared
to m o d e r n systems; nevertheless, if it is v i e w e d as a creation of the late
eighteenth century, it can only be v i e w e d w i t h awe. Wessel's
treatment of ordinary complex numbers is equally impressive, and it was unfortunate for Wessel a n d for mathematics that his m e m o i r lay b u r i e d for nearly a century. In the early history of complex numbers a striking p h e n o m e n o n occurred:
on three separate occasions t w o m e n i n d e p e n d e n t l y and
simultaneously
discovered
the geometrical representation of com-
plex numbers. In 1806 A r g a n d a n d Buee both p u b l i s h e d independent
treatments
of imaginary
numbers,
and the
same
coincidence
o c c u r r e d i n 1828 w i t h M o u r e y a n d W a r r e n . W h a t i s e v e n m o r e surprising
is
that
Gauss
probably
discovered the
geometrical repre-
sentation of complex numbers at the same time as Wessel. Gauss' tion
first
published
treatment
of the geometrical representa-
of complex numbers appeared in
1831;
17
herein Gauss com-
m e n t e d that h e h a d h a d this i d e a for m a n y years a n d that traces o f i t could Lowell
easily be f o u n d in his Coolidge
investigated
1799 this
"Demonstratio Nova." point
and
showed
18
that
Julian Gauss'
c l a i m was a m p l y s u p p o r t e d b y the fact that s o m e m e t h o d s u s e d i n the
8
1799
paper
seem
"blind
and meaningless"
unless the author
The
Earliest Traditions
already possessed this idea.19 It was t h r o u g h Gauss'
1831 publica-
tion that most mathematicians came into contact w i t h the geometrical
representation of complex numbers, although
of Gauss'
paper
only
in
1852
However Hamilton heard in
(4;
312)
and
Hamilton
Grassmann
1845 that Gauss
heard 1844.20
in
had been
searching
for a "triple algebra" corresponding to the d o u b l e algebra of complex numbers. tion
(4; 3 1 1 - 3 1 2 ) F e l i x K l e i n a r g u e d i n a n 1 8 9 8 p u b l i c a -
that Gauss
Knott
had in
vigorously
accept
the
fact d i s c o v e r e d this.21
denied
geometrical
quaternions,
Ironically
representation
Gauss
but Tait and
himself did
of c o m p l e x
numbers
not
as
a
sufficient justification for them.22 In conclusion it m a y be n o t e d that Gauss' p u b l i c a t i o n w a s t h e shortest, t h e m o s t precise, t h e last, a n d the most influential
o f t h e six i n d e p e n d e n t p r e s e n t a t i o n s .
T h e next p u b l i c a t i o n to be c o n s i d e r e d was the longest, the least precise, the earliest (except for Wessel's), a n d the least influential. On J u n e 20, 1805, a l o n g essay e n t i t l e d " M e m o i r e sur les q u a n t i t e s imaginaires"
was
read before
the
Royal
Society
of London.
The
author was A b b e B u e e a n d his paper was p u b l i s h e d ( w i t h o u t translation)
in
the
1806
Transactions
of
the
Society.23
Royal
treatment of complex numbers was not of high quality; fact
has
expressed
surprise
that
it
was
Buee's
Coolidge in
published.24
The
well-
founded consensus a m o n g those w h o have studied Buee's paper is that
some
ingenuity
mixed
with
much
obscurity
is
to
be
found
there, as w e l l as a near approach to the concept of the m u l t i p l i c a t i o n of directed lines.
H a m i l t o n asserted that B u e e attempted to extend
his m e t h o d s t o space (5; [57]), b u t i f B u e e d i d d o t h i s , h e d i d i t i n a very
unorthodox
manner.
A far s u p e r i o r w o r k also a p p e a r e d in Argand's tites
small
book,
imaginaires
Essai
dans
sur
les
une
1806; this was Jean Robert maniere
constructions
de
representer
les
geometriques.6
quan-
Herein
Argand gave the m o d e r n geometrical representation of the addition and multiplication of complex numbers, and s h o w e d h o w this representation
could
trigonometry,
be
applied to deduce a n u m b e r of theorems
elementary
geometry, and algebra.
in
At this t i m e Ar-
gand d i d not attempt to e x p a n d his m e t h o d s for application to threed i m e n s i o n a l space. F o r seven years A r g a n d shared the fate of W e s sel;
however
unexpected In
in
1813 J.-F.
Gergonne's
1813
attention
was
called to his
book in
a very
way. Frangais published a short m e m o i r in v o l u m e IV of
Annates
de
mathematiques
(6;
63-74),
in
which
Fran-
gais p r e s e n t e d t h e g e o m e t r i c a l r e p r e s e n t a t i o n o f c o m p l e x n u m b e r s . At the conclusion of his paper Frangais stated that the f u n d a m e n t a l ideas in his paper w e r e not his o w n ; he h a d f o u n d t h e m in a letter
9
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
w r i t t e n by L e g e n d r e to his (Frangais') brother w h o had died. In this letter L e g e n d r e discussed the ideas of an u n n a m e d mathematician. Frangais
a d d e d that he h o p e d that this mathematician w o u l d make
himself k n o w n and publish his The
unnamed
ideas,
for
Legendre's
Frangais'
paper,
Gergonne
in
results.
mathematician friend
Argand
which
he
had
(6;
in
was Jean
already
p u b l i s h e d his
Robert Argand.
immediately
identified
74)
fact
sent
a
Hearing of
communication
to
himself as the mathematician of
L e g e n d r e ' s l e t t e r , c a l l e d a t t e n t i o n t o h i s b o o k , s u m m a r i z e d its c o n tents, a n d
finally
presented an (unsuccessful) attempt to extend his
system to three-dimensions. lications,
(6; 7 6 - 9 6 ) B e f o r e s e e i n g A r g a n d ' s p u b -
Frangais h a d w r i t t e n a letter to G e r g o n n e containing his
admittedly unsatisfactory attempts to extend the geometrical representation of c o m p l e x n u m b e r s to space.
(6;
96-101) A n d soon after
Argand's publication, Servois published a paper criticizing Argand's attempt and (6;
o u t l i n i n g his o w n ideas on a m e t h o d of space analysis.
101-109)
to
an
Hamilton
anticipation
triplets.
.
. ."
o f the
(5;
[57])
f o l l o w i n g passage
attributed
quaternions,
or
to at
In m a k i n g this
from
Servois least
to
"the an
nearest
approach
anticipation
statement Hamilton
of
had the
Servois' paper in mind.
Analogy w o u l d seem to
indicate that the tri-nominal should be of the
f o r m p cos a + q cos (3 + r cos y, a,
a n d y b e i n g t h e a n g l e s m a d e by a
r i g h t l i n e w i t h t h r e e r e c t a n g u l a r axes, a n d t h a t we s h o u l d h a v e (p cos a + q c o s (3 + r c o s y)(p' c o s a + q' c o s (3 + r' c o s y) = c o s 2 a + c o s 2 /3 + c o s 2 y — 1 . T h e v a l u e s o f p , q , r , p ' , q', r ' s a t i s f y i n g t h i s c o n d i t i o n w o u l d b e absurd;
but
A+
would
B V ^ I ? (7;
they
be
imaginaries,
reducible
to
the
general
form
114-115)
C o n c e r n i n g this
passage
Hamilton
wrote:
T h e s i x N O N - R E A L S w h i c h S e r v o i s t h u s w i t h r e m a r k a b l e s a g a c i t y foresaw,
without
b e i n g a b l e t o determine t h e m ,
the ther; u n k n o w n symbols +i, at
least,
these
latter
him, and furnish
may n o w be
identified with
+ / c , — i , — j , —/c, o f t h e q u a t e r n i o n t h e o r y :
symbols
fulfil
p r e c i s e l y t h e condition p r o p o s e d b y
a n answer t o h i s " s i n g u l a r q u e s t i o n . " I t m a y b e p r o p e r
t o state that m y o w n t h e o r y h a d b e e n c o n s t r u c t e d a n d p u b l i s h e d for a l o n g t i m e , b e f o r e t h e l a t e l y c i t e d passage h a p p e n e d t o m e e t m y eye. (5; [57]) The
series
of articles
in
Gergonne's
letter written by A r g a n d in w h i c h by
Lacroix
(6;
111)
Annales
was
concluded
calling attention to
Buee's
(1806)
this
very
point were
nions
10
is
in
1843.25
strong evidence unknown to The
ideas
that all
Hamilton of the
a
publication.
A r g a n d w r o t e t h a t h e h a d h a d n o k n o w l e d g e o f B u e e ' s w o r k . (6; There
by
he responded to a notice sent in
the
men
123)
discussed up to
w h e n he discovered quater-
next man
to be
discussed were
The
k n o w n to H a m i l t o n as early as thinking,
as
published cal
he
in
repeatedly
1828
Representation
a of
Earliest Traditions
1829 a n d m o r e o v e r i n f l u e n c e d his
acknowledged.
short
book
the
Square
(4;
entitled A Roots
190)
Treatise of
John Warren on
the
Negative
GeometriQuantities.
Warren's
presentation of the geometrical representation of complex
numbers
e x h i b i t e d great care a n d u n d e r s t a n d i n g ; he, u n l i k e B u e e
a n d A r g a n d , was a w a r e o f t h e i m p o r t a n c e o f t h e c o m m u t a t i v e , associative, and distributive laws, t h o u g h he d i d not use these terms.26 W a r r e n discovered his ideas in c o m p l e t e i n d e p e n d e n c e of the other mathematicians
who
wrote
on
the
geometrical
representation
of
complex numbers, b u t he, unlike the majority of t h e m , d i d not discuss t h e e x t e n s i o n o f h i s s y s t e m t o space.27 T h e final independent discoverer of the
geometrical representa-
tion of complex n u m b e r s was the F r e n c h m a n C. V. M o u r e y , w h o in 1828
published
quantites
an
negatives
excellent et
des
the conclusion of his book bra surpassing
treatise
entitled
quantites
La
pretendues
vrai
Theorie
imaginaires.28
des At
M o u r e y stated that there exists an alge-
not o n l y o r d i n a r y algebra b u t also the t w o - d i m e n -
sional algebra created by him.
This
algebra, he stated, extends to
three-dimensions.29 Presumably M o u r e y searched for such an algebra; if he f o u n d it, he d i d not p u b l i s h his discovery.
V.
Summary
and
Conclusion
T h u s w e can say that a t least f i v e m e n , w o r k i n g i n d e p e n d e n t l y o f each other, had by 1831 discovered and p u b l i s h e d the geometrical representation
of
complex
numbers.
These
men
were
Wessel,
Gauss, A r g a n d , W a r r e n , a n d M o u r e y . A t least t w o others, W a l l i s a n d Buee, had c o m e close to the same idea. Wessel, Gauss, Argand, a n d M o u r e y , a s w e l l a s S e r v o i s a n d F r a n g a i s , a n d p e r h a p s B u e e , h a d attempted to
find
higher c o m p l e x n u m b e r s for the analysis of space,
and all had failed. A number of conclusions cussed.
The
first is
m a y be d r a w n f r o m w h a t has b e e n dis-
that the
idea of a graphical representation of
complex numbers was certainly " i n the air" at that time. H o w e v e r , the acceptance of this idea was very slow, and little attention was p a i d to these ideas u n t i l Gauss p u b l i s h e d his p a p e r of 1831.
The
fact that the i d e a was n e g l e c t e d u n t i l Gauss e n t e r e d t h e f i e l d s h o u l d not, I think, be taken as surprising. peatedly
shown
that
radically
new
H i s t o r i a n s of science h a v e reideas
presented only on their
o w n merits are usually neglected. T h e m e n b e f o r e Gauss w e r e all little k n o w n ;
i n d e e d t h e y are n o w k n o w n o n l y because o f t h e i r o n e
great discovery. B u t w h e n Gauss wrote, he w r o t e w i t h the authority
11
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
of one w h o had already acquired fame through impressive work in traditional fields and through his w i d e l y k n o w n prediction of the position of the lost p l a n e t o i d Ceres.
It m a y be n o t e d n o w a n d dis-
cussed later that the pattern exhibited in this instance w i l l recur in the later history of vectorial analysis. S e c o n d , i t has b e e n n o t e d that m o s t o f those w h o w o r k e d o n the geometrical
representation
struct analogous
methods
of c o m p l e x n u m b e r s a t t e m p t e d to confor t h r e e - d i m e n s i o n a l space. T h a t m a n y
e m b a r k e d on this quest illustrates w h a t is probably mathematically o b v i o u s : the search for a system of space analysis was a natural concomitant to the numbers. fore
idea of the
geometrical representation of complex
Up to this point only those w h o m a d e their attempts be-
1831 h a v e b e e n discussed; m a n y others also p u z z l e d over this
p r o b l e m after 1831. A m o n g t h e m was H a m i l t o n , w h o , w o r k i n g precisely in this tradition, discovered quaternions.
12
Notes 1
Gottfried W i l h e l m
Christian Leroy E. first
Leibniz, "Studies
Huygens"
in
Loemker, vol.
published
mathematische
in
und
"Christi.
Leibniz,
I
1833;
Papers
(Chicago, 1956), 3 8 1 - 3 9 6 . the
physikalische
Huygenii
in a G e o m e t r y of Situation w i t h a Letter to
Philosophical
citation
Werke,
as
vol.
aliorumque
given
I,
seculi
pt.
based
Schriften, e d . (which
C.
is
sophic, e d .
I.
translation
Gerhardt, vol.
superior)
as
on II
the
given
are
above)
and
Hermann (Leipzig,
in
and
from
Loemker and
Uylenbroek's
have
text as
trans.
Grassmann, 1894),
Gesammelte
415-416,
celebrium
is
exercitationes
H a g a e c o m i t u m 1833. fasc. I I , p . 6 . " as
1850),
given
in
Leibniz,
Mathematische
17-27, a n d on U y l e n b r o e k ' s text
Leibniz,
Hauptschriften
zur
Griindung
been checked with
the
der
Philo-
1924). Q u o -
Gerhardt's text
g i v e n i n G r a s s m a n n , Werke, v o l .
I, pt.
(cited
I, 417-420.
All quotations have been taken from Martin A. Norgaard's English translation of
the first sixteen sections of Wessel's book; A
in
virorum
text
(Berlin,
ed.
E r n s t Cassirer, trans. A. B u c h e n a u , 2nd. ed., 2 vols. ( L e i p z i g ,
tations
2
his
Letters,
I
XVIII.
mathematicae et philosophiae. Ed. Uylenbroek. Loemker
and
L e i b n i z ' essay a n d letter w e r e
Source
55-66.
Book
I
in
Mathematics,
have also
vol.
used the
I,
ed.
French
see W e s s e l , " O n C o m p l e x N u m b e r s " i n
David
Eugene
Smith
translation of Wessel's
(New
book
York,
1959),
w h i c h is cited in
n o t e (1) a b o v e . T h e t i t l e f o r W e s s e l ' s o r i g i n a l p u b l i c a t i o n i s " O m D i r e c t i o n e n s a n a l v tiske
Betegning,"
Danske
Videnskabernes
by S. Lie
and
it
appeared
Selskabs
Skrifter.
in
vol.
V
Wessel's
(1799)
essay
o f Nye
was
Samling
a f det
rediscovered
Kongelige
in
1895
D. Christensen and C. Juel; it was republished without translation by Sophus in
the
1896
Archiv for
Mathematik
og
Naturvidenskab.
In
this
connection
see
Viggo Brun, "Caspar Wessel et l'introduction geometrique des nombres c o m p l e x e s " in
Revue 3
d'histoire
Caspar
des
Wessel,
sciences, Essai
12
sur
(1959), la
V a l e n t i n e r a n d T . N . T h i e l e , trans. 4
Robert
Perceval
Graves,
20-21.
representation
analytique
de
la
direction,
ed.
H. G. Z e u t h e n and others (Copenhagen,
Life
of
Sir
William
Rowan
Hamilton,
vol.
Ill
H.
1897).
(Dublin,
1889). 5
Sir
William
Rowan
Hamilton,
Lectures
on
Quaternions
(Dublin,
1853).
All
refer-
ences are to H a m i l t o n ' s Preface, w h e r e A r a b i c n u m e r a l s set in p a r e n t h e s e s are u s e d to indicate page numbers. 6
Jean
naires
Robert
dans
contains papers
les
Essai
sur
geometriques,
a reprint of the
on
papers
Argand,
constructions
first
une
2nd
edition
maniere
ed.,
(Paris,
ed.
de J.
representer Hoiiel
les
quantites
imagi-
1874).
This
(Paris,
1806) a l o n g w i t h
selections from the
complex numbers by Frangais, Argand, Gergonne, Lacroix, and Servois,
which
were
originally
published
in
Gergonne's
Annales
des
Mathematiques,
4 ( 1 8 1 3 - 1 8 1 4 ) a n d 5 ( 1 8 1 4 - 1 8 1 5 ) . S e e t h e w o r k c i t e d i n n o t e (7) b e l o w f o r a n E n g l i s h translation series in 7
Hoiiel's
edition.
Jean
Robert
trans. A. S. 8
of Argand's
book;
Hardy
included
less
material
than
Hoiiel
from
the
o f p a p e r s i n G e r g o n n e ' s Annales b u t s u p p l i e d v a l u a b l e c o m m e n t a r y n o t f o u n d
Argand,
Imaginary
Quantities:
Their
Geometrical
Representation,
H a r d y ( N e w Y o r k , 1881).
T h e t h r e e G r e e k a u t h o r s w h o u s e d t h i s c o n c e p t are (1) t h e a u t h o r o f t h e s o - c a l l e d
"pseudo-Aristotelian
Mechanica,"
(2)
Archimedes,
and
(3)
Hero
of Alexandria.
For
13
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis the
first
Ages
(Madison,
and
the
nique
Analytique
"On
Spirals"
third
1959),
in
see
4-5,
Marshall
41.
Lagrange,
in
The
On
CEuvres,
Works
Clagett,
The
Archimedes vol.
XI
o f Archimedes,
Science
o f Mechanics
see J o s e p h
(Paris,
trans.
Louis
1888),
Thomas
12,
in
and
Heath
the
Middle
L a g r a n g e , MecaArchimedes,
(New
York,
n.d.),
165. 9
T h e history of this concept is discussed by n u m e r o u s authors; the f o l l o w i n g are
among
the
Maddox J.
most
(New
McCormack
1962);
(4)
tischen 10
(La
A.
For
this
Salle,
Rene
(2)
111.,
Dugas,
Ernst
Mach,
1960);
(3)
"Grundlegung
vol.
example
. .
(1)
1955);
Voss,
Wissenschaften,
plane . has
important:
York,
IV, see
pt.
(1;
I
A
The
History
o f Mechanics,
Science
Max Jammer,
der
Concepts o f Force
Mechanik"
(Leipzig,
390) but note
trans.
o f Mechanics, t r a n s .
in
1901-1908),
J.
R.
Thomas
( N e w York,
Encyklopadie
der
mathema-
43-46.
that L o e m k e r wrote
"AB
b BY for one
w h e r e a s t h e U y l e n b r o e k t e x t ( s e e G r a s s m a n n , Werke, v o l . I , p t . I , 4 2 0 )
(correctly) " A Y « B Y . "
11
There
is
a
fuller
but
similar
vol. V, ed. C. I. Gerhardt (Halle,
exposition
in
Leibniz,
Mathematische
Schriften,
1858), 141-171. M a n y m i n o r statements of L e i b n i z
(for e x a m p l e , statements in letters) are referred to a n d discussed by L o u i s Couturat, La
Logique
de
Leibniz
(Paris,
ideas, particularly as discussed by A. nection
with
Grassmann
E.
Heath,
Leibniz's
in
1901),
they relate
his
which
"The
Geometrical
Characteristic"
Geometrische
Analyse
in
in
12
Louis
Couturat,
There
have b e e n a n u m b e r of studies
that have a i d e d me ruff
Beman,
American
"A
Cajori,
for
"Historical of
1912),
1924);
in
the
Leibniz
(3)
(4)
on
the
in Julian
Analysis
vol.
discussion
27
I,
of
Leibniz'
L e i b n i z ' s y s t e m was also
of Grassmann
Monist,
(Paris,
History of
(1917),
pt.
1901),
I,
a n d Its Con-
36-56,
and
by
321-399.
538.
on the early history of complex numbers
of
Mathematics"
Science,
Graphic
American
46
Monthly,
Coolidge,
Hankel,
der
The
Proceedings
33-50;
(2)
of Imaginaries 19
Geometry
Theorie
in
(1897),
Representation
Mathematical
Lowell
Hermann
full
a m o n g t h e m o s t i m p o r t a n t are (1) W o o s t e r W o o d -
the
Advancement
Note
Wessel"
167-171;
ford,
de
in this study;
Chapter
Association
Time
Logique
a
system.
The
Werke,
13
La
includes
to Grassmann's
o f the
Florian
Before
the
(September-October,
o f the
complexen
Complex
Domain
Zahlensysteme
(Ox-
(Leipzig,
1 8 6 7 ) ; (5) P . S . J o n e s , " C o m p l e x N u m b e r s : A n E x a m p l e o f R e c u r r i n g T h e m e s i n t h e Development
of
263, 340-345; of
Certain
vancement narii
Branches
o f Science
nella
and 36
Mathematics"
of
(1834),
Mathematics
317-345;
Quantities"
Analysis" 185-352;
geometria"
(1898),
Complex
in
Teacher,
47
(1954),
106-114,
257-
(6) G e o r g e P e a c o c k , " R e p o r t o n t h e R e c e n t P r o g r e s s a n d P r e s e n t State in
(7)
in
Battaglini's
(8)
G.
in
Mathematical
of
the
British
Romorino,
Giornale
Windred,
Unfortunately a recent excellent
Report
Angelo
di
Association
"Gli
matematica,
for
the
Elementi
35
(1897),
Ad-
imagi-
242-258;
" H i s t o r y of the T h e o r y of Imaginary and
Gazette,
14
study came
(1929),
533-541.
to my attention too late to take full
a d v a n t a g e o f it. T h i s i s F . D . K r a m a r ' s " V e k t o r n o e i s c h i s l e n i e k o n t s a X V I I I i n a c h a l a XIX
vv"
14
The
matics, e d . 15
be
(in
Russian)
important David
in
passage
Eugene
lstoriko-Matematicheskie
from
Smith,
Wallis
vol.
I
may
Issledovaniia,
be
found
( N e w York,
in
15 A
(1963), Source
Book
225-290. in
Mathe-
1959), 4 6 - 5 4 .
T h e w o r d s " t o p u b l i s h " qualify this statement sufficiently that no m e n t i o n n e e d
made
in
the
text
of Leonard Euler, Charles Walmesley, and Dominique Truel.
T h e basis for attributing the geometrical representation to the first t w o of these m e n is
that it seems f r o m reading their writings on relevant subjects that they probably
had
this
representation.
The
sole
basis
for
mentioning
C a u c h y that T r u e l had this representation as early as Florian Cajori, fore
14
Wessel"
"Historical in
American
Notes on the Mathematical
Truel
is
a
statement
by
1786. F o r f u l l e r discussion see
G r a p h i c Representation of Imaginaries be-
Monthly,
19
(1912),
167-171.
T h e Earliest Traditions 16
Some
of these
difficulties
H a m i l t o n ' s efforts to 17
ische
gelehrte
Friedrich l
will
be
discussed
more
fully
in
Chapter
II, where
a t h r e e - d i m e n s i o n a l vectorial system are treated.
Gauss' untitled publication, w h i c h was a discussion of his " T h e o r i a r e s i d u o r u m
biquadraticum,
Commentatio
Anzeigen
of A p r i l
G a u s s , Werke,
»Ibid.,
19
find
secunda," 23,
vol.
II
1831.
was I
originally
have
(Gottingen,
used
1863),
published
the
text
in
as
the
given
Gotting-
in
Carl
169-178.
175.
Julian
Lowell
Coolidge,
The
Geometry
o f the
Complex
Domain
(Oxford,
1924),
28-29. 20
Hermann
Werke, v o l . 21
Felix
matische
Klein,
o f Edinburgh,
this in
Abbe
Royal
of
24
Coolidge,
25
This
is
VIII
96
Geometry
X,
sur
les
(1806), of
the
implied
Philosophical that
2
see
is
especially
(5;
in
on
the
Gilston
Proceedings
which
Mathe-
Recently
i n Proceedings
Knott,
o f the
Klein
in
Claim
"Pro-
Royal
Society
his
claim,
based
357-362. "Uber
Gauss
(Gottingen,
quantites
Arbeiten
zur
Function-
1922-1933), 55-57.
imaginaires"
the
Domain,
fact
in
Transactions
of
the
24.
that
3rd
in
an
Ser.,
had influenced him;
in
" O n
23-88.
Magazine,
implied
physikalische
Gauss' W e r k e n "
Cargill
criticism"
Complex by
von Tait,
17-23;
1900),
pt.
und
Discovery) of Quaternions"
Schlesinger,
representation of complex
same conclusion Quaternions;
the
(Leipzig,
Ludwig
discussed the authors geometrical
For
"Memoire
in
the
(1900),
document
London,
Quaternions"
Guthrie
24-34.
see
strongly
(not
23
G a u s s , Werke, v o l .
Buee,
Society
Invention
Herausgabe
Peter
a
vol.
point
der
mathematische
397-398.
of Q u a t e r n i o n s :
(1900),
G a u s s , Werke, On
the
Stand
128-133;
o f Edinburgh,
View
23
entheorie" 23
to
Gesammelte
1896), 8 - 9 ,
den
(1898),
Society
Klein's
Grassmann,
(Leipzig,
"Uber
51
Royal
fessor
2 2
II
for Gauss
the
see
pt.
Annalen,
Made of
Giinther
I,
1844
25
paper
(1844),
[31]—[57])
richly historical
as
"On
Hamilton
o f t h e six m e n w h o d i s c o v e r e d t h e
numbers, only Warren was
Hamilton's
(Hamilton,
489-495)
well
as
the
mentioned.
The
p r e f a c e t o h i s Lectures o n work
listed
in
note
(4)
above, w h e r e i n m a n y letters f r o m H a m i l t o n t o D e M o r g a n w e r e p u b l i s h e d i n w h i c h Hamilton
discussed these men.
p a p e r (4; 3 1 2 ) , (2) paper Rowan
(5;
[57]),
Hamilton,
and
vol.
H a m i l t o n e x p l i c i t l y d e n i e d h a v i n g s e e n (1) G a u s s '
M o u r e y ' s b o o k (4; 4 8 9 ) , (3) A r g a n d ' s b o o k (4; 4 3 5 ) , (4) S e r v o i s '
II
(5)
Frangais'
[Dublin,
papers
1885],
(Robert
606).
Perceval
From
the
Graves,
fact
that
Life o f Sir William
Hamilton
had not
read Servois' and Frangais' papers or Argand's book, it seems reasonable to conclude that he had Annales
not read any of the
before
1844.
Hamilton
relevant papers did
not
in
explicitly
volumes IV and V of Gergonne's
deny knowledge
of Wessel,
since
h e never, e v e n after 1843, h e a r d o f W e s s e l , a n d h e d i d not e x p l i c i t l y d e n y k n o w l e d g e of Buee's hand,
paper,
Hamilton
since
he
had already d e n i e d that
attended
the
vancement of Science, and on
the
Recent
(.B.A.A.S.
Report,
Argand's 26
See
Roots
Progress
and
John
o f Negative
the
in
Present
which
papers
Warren, Quantities
it had any merit.
meeting of the
A
from
Treatise
State
Peacock
of
on
the
1828),
Certain
briefly
Gergonne's
(Cambridge,
addition, page 9 for c o m m u t a t i v e
Branches
extent
on
"associative,"
probably
the
the
recognition
first
the
other
discussed
of
(ibid.y
"Report
Analysis" page
228)
Annales.
Geometrical page
Representation
3
for
of
the
commutative
law for multiplication, page
was aware of the associative l a w for m u l t i p l i c a t i o n , a n d page law. T h e importance of this
names
On
British Association for the Ad-
at this m e e t i n g George Peacock presented his and
185-352),
book
1833
Square law
of
18 for a hint that he
13 for the distributive
is that the discovery of quaternions d e p e n d e d to some of the
importance
"commutative,"
historical
and
statement
of these
laws.
"distributive"
was
made
by
in
On a
origin
of the
mathematical
sense
Hermann
the
Hankel,
Theorie
der
15
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis complexen
Zahlensysteme
"These have
names
(Leipzig,
have
been
1867),
adopted
footnote
on
universally in
page
3,
not hesitated to transplant t h e m to G e r m a n soil;
was
it
seems
first
i n t r o d u c e d by Sir. W.
R.
he
said,
1840 and hence I
'distributive' and 'commuta-
tive' w e r e introduced by Servois ( G E R G O N N E ' S Ann. vol. V. tive'
where
E n g l a n d since
1814, p . 93); 'associa-
H a m i l t o n . " T h i s statement is re-
peated by both D a v i d E u g e n e S m i t h and Florian Cajori. T h e earliest recognition of the
necessity of proving the commutative
VII, Proposition the term
"associative" is
Connected with lished
in
the
"However, in
l a w for m u l t i p l i c a t i o n is in
Euclid, Book
16. T h e first p u b l i c a t i o n , t o m y k n o w l e d g e , i n w h i c h H a m i l t o n u s e d in the paper " O n a N e w Species of Imaginary Quantities,
a T h e o r y o f Q u a t e r n i o n , " c o m m u n i c a t e d N o v e m b e r 13, 1843, p u b Proceedings
of
the
Royal
Irish
Academy,
2
(1844)
424-434.
He
wrote:
virtue of the same definitions, it w i l l be f o u n d that another important
property of the o l d m u l t i p l i c a t i o n is preserved, or e x t e n d e d to the n e w , namely, that which 27
may
be
called
the
associative
character of t h e
operation.
.
.
."
Ibid., 4 2 9 - 4 3 0 .
At least no extension is suggested in his b o o k or in the t w o s u b s e q u e n t papers
w h i c h he p u b l i s h e d on this subject. Philosophical entitled
Transactions
of
"Considerations
sentation of the Square Geometrical Square
the
H i s t w o later papers w e r e b o t h p u b l i s h e d in the
Royal
of the Roots
Society
Objections
of
London,
119
(1829);
they
were
Raised Against the Geometrical Repre-
of Negative Quantities," pages 2 4 1 - 2 5 4 , and " O n the
Representation of the Power of Quantities Whose Indicies Involve the
Roots
of
251-254) Warren
Negative
Quantities,"
stated that he
pages
had written
339-359.
In
the
first
paper
(ibid.,
his book before he heard of Buee's or
M o u r e y ' s p u b l i c a t i o n ; A r g a n d was not m e n t i o n e d , p r e s u m a b l y because W a r r e n still had not heard of Argand's 28
C.
dues
V.
Mourey,
imaginaires
reprint Buee; have
of his
(Paris, 1828
book.
La 1828).
work.
vrai
Theorie
The
second
Nowhere
des
in
quantites
edition the
work
negatives
et
book
since
quantites
preten-
1861) was used; this was a
does
Mourey mention Argand or
i n fact n o m a t h e m a t i c i a n s are ever m e n t i o n e d i n the book. k n o w n Warren's
des
(Paris,
it was p u b l i s h e d after his o w n .
Mourey could not M o u r e y [ibid., I X )
m a d e the interesting c o m m e n t that his b o o k was an a b r i d g e m e n t of a longer treatise he had written but had not published. 29
16
Ibid.,
95.
CHAPTER
Sir
William
Rowan and
I.
Introduction: The
task
of the
Hamiltonian historian
w o r k of Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n estimates
of his
extreme
dinger
of Hamilton:
While
these
Hamilton Quaternions
Historiography
who
wishes
to
treat any
aspect of the
H a m i l t o n is c o m p l i c a t e d by the fact that
significance for the history of science have varied
between two wrote
TWO
positions.
discoveries
Thus,
(Quaternions,
for example,
etc.)
would
Erwin
suffice
to
Schro-
secure
H a m i l t o n in the annals of both mathematics a n d physics a h i g h l y hono u r a b l e place, s u c h p i o u s m e m o r i a l s can i n his case e a s i l y b e d i s p e n s e d with. For H a m i l t o n is virtually not dead, he h i m s e l f is alive, so to speak, not his m e m o r y . I daresay n o t a d a y passes — a n d s e l d o m an h o u r — w i t h out somebody,
somewhere
writing or printing
on
Hamilton's
this
globe,
name.
pronouncing or reading
or
T h a t is due to his f u n d a m e n t a l
d i s c o v e r i e s i n g e n e r a l d y n a m i c s . T h e H a m i l t o n i a n p r i n c i p l e has b e c o m e the cornerstone of m o d e r n physics, t h e t h i n g w i t h w h i c h a p h y s i c i s t exp e c t s every p h y s i c a l p h e n o m e n o n t o b e i n c o n f o r m i t y . . . . T h e modern development of physics is continually enhancing Hamilton's name. H i s famous analogy b e t w e e n mechanics a n d optics v i r t u a l l y anticipated wave-mechanics,
which
did
not
have to add m u c h to his
ideas, o n l y h a d to take t h e m seriously —a little m o r e seriously t h a n he was
able to take t h e m , w i t h the experimental k n o w l e d g e of a century
ago.
The
central conception of all
modern theory in physics
is
"the
Hamiltonian." If you wish to apply modern theory to any particular probl e m , y o u m u s t start w i t h p u t t i n g t h e p r o b l e m " i n H a m i l t o n i a n f o r m . " T h u s H a m i l t o n i s o n e o f t h e greatest m e n o f s c i e n c e t h e w o r l d has p r o duced.6 In
*
1945 J.
into eclipse.7 above
all
variations.
L.
Synge lamented that Hamilton's fame was passing
Synge cited m a n y aspects of this eclipse b u t stressed
the neglect of Hamilton's contribution to the calculus of He wrote:
" H a m i l t o n was, in fact, a great c o n t r i b u t o r —
probably the greatest single contributor of all t i m e —to the calculus of variations."
(7;
15)
17
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
In
1940 E. T. Whittaker p u b l i s h e d a paper entitled " T h e H a m i l -
tonian ton's
Revival,"
8
reputation
century: verse
in
which
was
he maintained:
touched
about
the
since w h e n , t h e r e has b e e n a steady m o v e m e n t in t h e re-
direction:
one
after
another,
the
i n n o v a t i o n s has b e e n a p p r e c i a t e d . . . ton in
" T h e nadir of Hamil-
beginning of the present
1954:
significance 9
."
of his
" A f t e r Isaac N e w t o n , t h e greatest m a t h e m a t i c i a n of the
E n g l i s h - s p e a k i n g p e o p l e s is W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n . . . ." In
1937
titled
great
W h i t t a k e r w r o t e of H a m i l -
E.
T.
Bell
in
his
widely
the
chapter on
Hamilton
presented
Hamilton's
life
as
"An
read
Men
Irish
a tragedy,
o f Mathematics
Tragedy."
10 11
Herein
enBell
in a sense a m a g n i f i c e n t
failure. This
disparity o f v i e w s c o n c e r n i n g H a m i l t o n , w h i c h i n fact dates
back to the nineteenth century, is central to Hamiltonian historiography. T h e m a i n source of this disparity of v i e w s relates to H a m i l ton's
work
on
quaternions.
represented
the
voted
more
than
twenty
quaternions
held
by
Hamilton
mathematics
of the
years
nearly
of his
all
believed
future
and
life
to
that
them.
mathematicians
quaternions
consequently The
of the
de-
view
of
present is
h o w e v e r quite different; the consensus n o w is that the quaternion system
is b u t one of m a n y comparable mathematical systems, and
though value
it for
is
i n t e r e s t i n g as a rather special
application.
system, it offers
little
T h e historian of today must take the above
e v a l u a t i o n of q u a t e r n i o n s as m o s t p r o b a b l y v a l i d , t h o u g h t h e r e remain
sources
of doubt.
Statements qualifying or contradicting this
evaluation — m a d e by such important scientists as E. T. Whittaker,12 George D. Birkhoff,13 and P. A. M. Dirac
14
caution
large
in the
historian,
as
do
the
two
— instill some degree of volumes by Otto F.
Fischer,15 in w h i c h the author attempted to rewrite m u c h of m o d e r n physics
in terms of Hamilton's quaternions.
E. T. Bell's v i e w of H a m i l t o n as a tragic failure certainly s t e m m e d from
the
modern victim
fact that he
felt that
mathematics. of
a
Bell
monomaniacal
deepest tragedy was
quaternions
was
are of little interest to
convinced that
delusion;
he
Hamilton was the
stated
"that
Hamilton's
neither alcohol nor marriage but his obstinate
belief that quaternions h e l d the key to the mathematics of the physical
universe."
much taker
16
of what E. however
The
passed
contributions to
problem
of quaternions
T. Whittaker wrote over
the
mathematical
also stands b e h i n d
concerning Hamilton; Whit-
problem
by
stressing
Hamilton's
physics and by arguing that quater-
nions " m a y even yet prove to be the most natural expression of the n e w physics."
17
T h e present study m u s t stand in the shadow of this dispute con-
18
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n
and Quaternions
cerning Hamilton's greatness; nevertheless it is h o p e d that substantial
progress
toward
following analysis, not possible
to
a
solution
which
argue
may
be
achieved
in
terms
of the
w i l l be d e v e l o p e d m o r e f u l l y later.
that the
quaternion
system
is
the
It is
vectorial
system of the present day; the so-called Gibbs-Heaviside system is the
only system that merits
this distinction.
N o r is it legitimate to
a r g u e (as W h i t t a k e r h a s d o n e ) t h a t t h e q u a t e r n i o n s y s t e m w i l l b e t h e system of a future day.
B o t h of these alternatives are unacceptable;
nonetheless
argued
it
can
be
(though
previously been done) that Hamilton's historically
determinable
path to the
hence to the m o d e r n system.
in
my opinion
this
has
not
quaternion system led by an Gibbs-Heaviside
system
and
In what follows it w i l l be s h o w n that
this was in fact t h e case, a n d thus it w i l l b e c o m e clear that H a m i l ton deserves i m m e n s e credit for his w o r k in quaternions, since this work
led
reasons
to
the
now
w h y this
is
widely
so
used
system
little k n o w n
will
of vector analysis.
also be
discussed.
The
If this
analysis is f o u n d acceptable, it s h o u l d clear up the major p r o b l e m in Hamiltonian
historiography.
II.
s
Hamilton Though
in
Life
and
Fame
general a detailed discussion of a scientist's life n e e d
not be i n c l u d e d in a study such in
regard to
the
fame
Hamilton
attained
and
by
Hamilton
fluenced subsequent events. Hamilton's the
title
The the
during
Some
his
lifetime
indication
of the
strongly
in-
importance of
fame in this history may be attained by a comparison of
pages
title
as this, it is of necessity otherwise
quaternions. T h e reason for this is that
of Hamilton's
page
of
and
Grassmann's
Grassmann's Ausdehnungslehre
first of
major
1844
works.
contained
following: Hermann
Grassmann
Lehrer an der Friedrich-Wilhelms-Schule zu Stettin By
contrast,
the
title
page
of
Hamilton's
Lectures
on
Quaternions
contained: SIR W I L L I A M R O W A N H A M I L T O N , L L . D . , M . R . I . A., F E L L O W OF THE AMERICAN
SOCIETY O F ARTS A N D SCIENCES; O F T H E
SOCIETY
FOR
OF
ARTS
SCOTLAND;
NOMICAL SOCIETY OF LONDON; ERN
SOCIETY
SPONDING
OF
ANTIQUARIES
MEMBER
OF
T H E
HONORARY OR CORRESPONDING OR
ROYAL ACADEMIES
TURIN; LIN;
OF
OF THE THE
OF
ST.
OF
T H E
AND OF T H E AT
ROYAL
ASTRO-
ROYAL NORTH-
COPENHAGEN;
INSTITUTE
OF
CORREFRANCE;
M E M B E R OF T H E IMPERIAL
PETERSBURGH,
BERLIN, AND
ROYAL SOCIETIES OF EDINBURGH A N D DUBCAMBRIDGE
PHILOSOPHICAL
SOCIETY;
T H E
19
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
N E W YORK HISTORICAL SOCIETY; T H E SCIENCES CIETIES
AT
IN
LAUSANNE;
BRITISH
A N D
AND
OF
FOREIGN
PROFESSOR OF ASTRONOMY IN T H E AND
ROYAL
William
ASTRONOMER
Rowan
Hamilton
OF
was
was
o r p h a n e d at age
SCIENTIFIC
COUNTRIES;
SO-
ANDREWS'
UNIVERSITY OF DUBLIN;
IRELAND.
born of undistinguished ancestry
on the midnight between August 3 and 4, He
SOCIETY OF NATURAL
OTHER
fourteen,
1805, in D u b l i n , Ireland.
b u t h a d ceased to live w i t h his
parents f r o m the age of three, at w h i c h t i m e he h a d b e e n sent to live with
his
Trim,
uncle,
Ireland.
James
Hamilton,
Hamilton's
uncle,
an a
Anglican
man
clergyman
of education
serving
and
intelli-
gence, d i r e c t e d his n e p h e w ' s p r e u n i v e r s i t y education. T h e success of the uncle as tutor and the brilliance of Hamilton as student were manifested in thirteen, teen
many ways,
Hamilton
"was
languages. . . ."
brew,
Syriac,
French,
Italian,
however
only
18
of w h i c h
in
These
Persian,
the
best k n o w n
is that at age
different degrees acquainted w i t h thirlanguages
Arabic,
were
Sanskrit,
Greek,
Latin,
Hindoostanee,
He-
Malay,
Spanish, and German. T h e study of languages was one
of
Hamilton's
interests,
for
he
also
read
in
geography, religion, mathematics, astronomy, and the best of English
and
foreign
Mecanique but
not
was
in
forces. In
Celeste
literature.
and
significant Laplace's (2,1;
1823
At
detected for this
age
an
sixteen
error
study that the
demonstration
he
began
therein.
It
is
Laplace's interesting
error found by Hamilton
of the law of the parallelogram of
661-662)
Hamilton
entered Trinity College of D u b l i n University.
He h a d placed first in the entrance exam a n d h a d decided that his calling was to science. incredible.
In
knowledge
of Greek,
knowledge optime
was
"became vitations, .
His record at the University bordered on the
second
rare.
celebrity
in
Upon in
the
embarrassing
him.
.
year
the
This
wish
year
Hamilton
was
third
physics.
an
optime
for
another
optime
for his
his
T h e w i n n i n g of even a single
winning
the
intellectual their
awarded year
second
circle
optime,
Hamilton
of Dublin;
number,
poured
and in
in-
upon
. " (2,1; 2 0 9 ) H a m i l t o n r e s o l v e d t o a t t e m p t t o w i n i n h i s f i n a l University was
mer of Ireland. creative
honors
he
his
from
Gold
for
Medals
not fulfilled, was
offered
fessor of A s t r o n o m y at the
in
year
and
of mathematical very
a
his
for the
in
both
classics
during the
and in
science.
s u m m e r after his third
honor of becoming Andrews'
Pro-
University of D u b l i n and Royal Astrono-
H i s s t u d e n t days w e r e also d i s t i n g u i s h e d b y success
endeavors. some
of
He
them.
wrote
numerous
Researches
in
poems science
and
received
begun
in
his
seventeenth year on certain questions in mathematical optics led to
20
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n
his
now famous
1824
and
"Theory
published
of Systems
with
Other important papers
of Rays,"
which
further developments
in
the
same
line
and Quaternions
was
read
four years
in
later.19
of development came in
1830,
1831, a n d 1837. H i s a i m in these papers ( w h i c h e x t e n d to over
three
hundred
science his
in
pages)
terms
mathematical
methods
for
was
of his
methods
use
in
to
reduce
optics
"Characteristic in
optics
dynamics.
to
a
Function."
led
The
Hamilton
mathematical
The
success
of
to extend these
distinguished
historian
of
m e c h a n i c s R e n e D u g a s has s u m m a r i z e d the nature a n d i m p o r t a n c e of Hamilton's
work in
I n short, jealous
optics
and
dynamics:
of the formal perfection w h i c h Lagrange had been
able to give to dynamics, and w h i c h optics lacked, H a m i l t o n undertook the rationalisation of geometrical optics.
He
d i d this by d e v e l o p i n g a
formal theory w h i c h was free of all metaphysics a n d w h i c h , moreover, s u c c e e d e d in a c c o u n t i n g for a l l t h e e x p e r i m e n t a l facts. . . . Then,
returning to
dynamics,
Hamilton presented the
l a w o f varying
action i n a f o r m v e r y l i k e t h a t w h i c h h e h a d d i s c o v e r e d i n o p t i c s . T h u s h e r e d u c e d t h e g e n e r a l p r o b l e m o f d y n a m i c s (for c o n s e r v a t i v e systems) to the solution of t w o simultaneous equations in partial derivatives, or to the determination of a single function satisfying these t w o equations.
Hamilton's
g u i d i n g idea is continuous f r o m his optical w o r k to his
w o r k in d y n a m i c s — i n this fact lies his greatness a n d his p o w e r .
Here
was a synthesis that L o u i s de Broglie was to rediscover a n d t u r n to his o w n account; a synthesis that was, it appears, to be Schrodinger's direct inspiration.20 These
works
certainly
contributed
to
was probably thinking of them w h e n in
Hamilton's
fame;
Jacobi
1842 he referred to H a m i l -
t o n a s " l e L a g r a n g e d e v o t r e p a y s . " (2,111; 5 0 9 ) O f t e n h o w e v e r s u c h highly
mathematical
otherwise
for
basis
new
two
refraction. colleague In
this
At
phenomena
of Hamilton,
he
was and
wrote
siderable
vigorous
and
"perhaps made.
.
the .
most
popular fame.
predicted
on
It was
a theoretical
Humphrey
men
Whewell's
and
Airy
remarkable
friend
in
prediction
predicted (2,1;
635)
a very con-
England and on the
praise
referred
both
time
and
prediction.
predicted.
"excited at the
scientific
636)
finding
had not been
discovery
Lloyd,
to verify Hamilton's
successful,
which
immediate,
he
in optics, internal and external conical
among
(2,1;
21
request,
attempted
third
sensation
not produce
1832
completely a
that this
Continent. . . ."
do
in
Hamilton's
phenomena Graves
papers
Hamilton;
for
to
Hamilton
the
that
was
discovery
has
ever
as
been
. " (2,1; 6 3 7 ) D e M o r g a n w r i t i n g i n 1 8 6 6 s t a t e d : " O p t i c i a n s
had no more i m a g i n e d the possibility of such a thing, than astronomers
had
imagined
the
planet
Neptune,
which
Leverrier
and
21
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
A d a m s calculated into existence. t o g e t h e r as,
perhaps,
predictions." No
2 2
the
Pliicker of Bonn
experiment
These two things deserve to rank
t w o most remarkable of verified scientific
i n p h y s i c s has
wrote:
made
such a strong impression on my
m i n d as that of conical refraction. A single ray of light e n t e r i n g a crystal and leaving as a l u m i n o u s cone: this is something unheard of and without
analogy.
wave
Mr.
H a m i l t o n p r e d i c t e d it, starting f r o m the f o r m of the
w h i c h h a d b e e n d e d u c e d b y a l o n g calculation f r o m a n abstract
theory. I confess I w o u l d have h a d little hope of seeing an experimental confirmation theory
of such
which
an
extraordinary
Fresnel's
genius
had
result,
recently
predicted by the created.
But
mere
since
Mr.
L l o y d h a d d e m o n s t r a t e d that the e x p e r i m e n t a l results w e r e i n c o m p l e t e accordance w i t h the predictions of M r . H a m i l t o n , all prejudice against a t h e o r y s o m a r v e l o u s l y l o f t y has b e e n f o r c e d t o d i s a p p e a r . (2,1; 6 3 7 ) T h e fame that came to
Hamilton because
of this
discovery was in-
creased by the fact that it w a s m a d e , l i k e nearly all the discoveries d i s c u s s e d t h u s far, b e f o r e Also was
his
literary
close figures
friendship such as
ridge.
Numerous
worth,
and
had up
H a m i l t o n h a d r e a c h e d his t h i r t i e t h year.
illustrative of, a n d c o n t r i b u t o r y to, H a m i l t o n ' s p o p u l a r fame with
William
Wordsworth
and
other
Maria Edgeworth and Samuel Taylor Cole-
letters
passed
between
Hamilton
and
Words-
each visited the other on m a n y occasions. W o r d s w o r t h
said that H a m i l t o n was one of t w o m e n to w h o m he could look (the
other was Coleridge). To this H a m i l t o n replied:
" I f I am to
look d o w n on you, it is only as L o r d Rosse looks d o w n in his teles c o p e to see t h e stars of h e a v e n r e f l e c t e d . " By
1835
Hamilton's
fame
was
(2,111; 2 3 7 )
established.
In
that year he
was
knighted and received a medal from the Royal Society; in addition he
finished
ton's In
a paper on algebraic couples, w h i c h is the first of Hamil-
publications to be of direct importance for the present study.
1837
h e l d this covery
he
was
elected president of the Royal
position
(1843)
until
1843 to
ment
of quaternions. of
resignation
of quaternions.
from
Honors
his
The
received
Sciences along
Irish Academy and
1845, soon after his dis-
last t w e n t y - t w o years
of his life,
1865, w e r e for the most part devoted to the develop-
all
sorts
continued
these deserves final mention. In ton
in
notice
that the
to
be
bestowed
on
him.
One
of
1865, the year of his death, H a m i l -
newly
founded
National
Academy of
of t h e U n i t e d States h a d e l e c t e d h i m a F o r e i g n Associate,
with
Hamilton's
fourteen
other men.
The
name at the head of the
members
had voted to
place
list of F o r e i g n Associates, pre-
s u m a b l y signifying that in their o p i n i o n he was the greatest living scientist.
In
this
j u d g m e n t does
22
they were
attest to the
probably overly enthusiastic, but their fact,
which
is
very significant for this
Sir W i l l i a m
study,
that
great.
Hamilton's
fame
Rowan
among
Hamilton
his
and Quaternions
contemporaries
had b e e n completed, b u t he was still nearly u n k n o w n . in
was
very
At this same time the majority of Grassmann's scientific w o r k
his
1862
Ausdehnungslehre
now "Professor am
III.
Hamilton
It was
had
Gymnasium
and
Complex
changed zu
only
His subtitle
slightly;
it
was
Stettin."
Numbers
stated previously that H a m i l t o n ' s
was in the tradition of the work done on
discovery of quaternions complex numbers, and in
this regard the history of the geometrical representation of c o m p l e x numbers
and associated ideas
was
given.
But there
was
a second
line of d e v e l o p m e n t in studies on c o m p l e x n u m b e r s that also l e d to quaternions. This line of development was established by H a m i l t o n himself in his titled:
l o n g a n d i m p o r t a n t essay p u b l i s h e d in
1837 and en-
"Theory of Conjugate Functions, or Algebraic Couples; with
a Preliminary Pure Time."
and Elementary Essay on Algebra as the This
paper is
important
in
itself;
Science of
indeed one mathe-
matician referred to it as a greater c o n t r i b u t i o n to algebra than his of quaternions.23
discovery sections:
Hamilton's
paper is divided into three
the first section, w h i c h consists of " G e n e r a l Introductory
Remarks,"
was
written
last;
the
second
section,
an
essay
" O n
Algebra as the Science of Pure T i m e " was w r i t t e n in 1835; a n d the third or
section,
Algebraic
(2,11;
containing Couples,"
his
was
"Theory for
the
of
most
Conjugate part
Functions,
written
in
1833.
144) N e g l e c t of t h e historical s e q u e n c e of t h e c o m p o s i t i o n has
led to
a n u m b e r of historical
Hamilton
began
the
misconceptions.
paper by
writing:
T h e study of Algebra may be p u r s u e d in three very different schools, the Practical, the Philological, or the Theoretical, according as A l g e b r a itself is a c c o u n t e d an I n s t r u m e n t , or a L a n g u a g e , or a C o n t e m p l a t i o n ; according
as
ease
thought,
(the
of operation, agere,
or
the f a r i ,
s y m m e t r y of expression, or
the
sapere,)
is
or clearness
eminently
prized
of
and
sought for. T h e Practical p e r s o n seeks a R u l e w h i c h he m a y a p p l y , t h e P h i l o l o g i c a l person seeks a F o r m u l a w h i c h he m a y w r i t e , the T h e o r e t i c a l p e r s o n seeks a T h e o r e m o n w h i c h h e m a y m e d i t a t e . (3; 2 9 3 ) He then proceeded to
state that t h e a i m o f this p a p e r w a s theoreti-
cal. The
thing
aimed
at,
is
to
improve
the
Science,
not
the
Art
nor
the
L a n g u a g e o f A l g e b r a . T h e i m p e r f e c t i o n s s o u g h t t o b e r e m o v e d , are confusions of t h o u g h t , a n d obscurities or errors of reasoning; riot difficulties of application of an instrument nor failures of symmetry in expression.... F o r i t has n o t f a r e d w i t h t h e p r i n c i p l e s o f A l g e b r a a s w i t h t h e p r i n ciples
of Geometry.
No
candid
and
intelligent
person can
doubt the
23
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis truth
of the
chief properties
o f Parallel
Lines,
as
set f o r t h
by E U C L I D
i n his E l e m e n t s , t w o t h o u s a n d years ago; t h o u g h h e m a y w e l l desire t o see t h e m t r e a t e d i n a c l e a r e r a n d b e t t e r m e t h o d . T h e d o c t r i n e i n v o l v e s no
obscurity
nor
confusion
of
thought,
and
leaves
in
the
mind
no
reasonable g r o u n d for d o u b t , a l t h o u g h i n g e n u i t y m a y usefully be exercised in improving the plan of the argument. But it requires no peculiar scepticism to doubt, or even to disbelieve, the doctrine of Negatives and I m a g i n a r i e s , w h e n s e t f o r t h (as i t h a s c o m m o n l y b e e n ) w i t h p r i n c i p l e s like
these:
that
the
numbers plied t h e
that
a
remainder denoting one
greater is
magnitude
less
than
magnitudes
by the
other,
may
be
nothing;
each
less
subtracted from that
two
than
a
negative
nothing,
less,
and
numbers, o r
may be
multi-
a n d t h a t t h e p r o d u c t w i l l b e a positive n u m -
ber, or a n u m b e r d e n o t i n g a m a g n i t u d e greater than nothing; and that a l t h o u g h t h e square o f a n u m b e r , o r t h e p r o d u c t o b t a i n e d b y m u l t i p l y i n g that be
number
by
itself,
is
therefore
always positive,
whether the
number
p o s i t i v e o r n e g a t i v e , y e t t h a t n u m b e r s , c a l l e d imaginary, c a n b e f o u n d
or conceived or d e t e r m i n e d , a n d operated on by all the rules of positive and
negative
they
have
selves
numbers,
negative
squares,
as
i f t h e y w e r e s u b j e c t t o t h o s e r u l e s , although
and
must
therefore
be
s u p p o s e d to
be t h e m -
neither positive or negative, nor yet n u l l numbers, so that the
m a g n i t u d e s w h i c h t h e y are s u p p o s e d t o d e n o t e can n e i t h e r b e greater t h a n n o t h i n g , n o r less t h a n n o t h i n g , n o r e v e n e q u a l t o n o t h i n g . I t m u s t b e h a r d t o f o u n d a S C I E N C E o n s u c h g r o u n d s a s t h e s e . . . . (3; 294)
Hamilton
then
asked
w h e t h e r e x i s t i n g A l g e b r a , i n t h e state t o w h i c h i t has b e e n a l r e a d y u n f o l d e d b y t h e m a s t e r s o f its r u l e s a n d o f its l a n g u a g e , offers i n d e e d n o rudiment which Algebra:
a
may encourage
Science
a hope
properly so called;
of developing a S C I E N C E of strict, pure, a n d i n d e p e n d e n t ;
d e d u c e d b y v a l i d r e a s o n i n g s f r o m its o w n i n t u i t i v e p r i n c i p l e s ; a n d t h u s n o t less a n o b j e c t o f p r i o r i c o n t e m p l a t i o n t h a n G e o m e t r y , n o r less d i s t i n c t , i n its o w n e s s e n c e , f r o m t h e R u l e s w h i c h i t m a y t e a c h o r use, a n d f r o m t h e S i g n s b y w h i c h i t m a y express its m e a n i n g . (3; 2 9 5 ) Hamilton
concluded
ment"
295) a n d elaborated on this idea by writing:
(3;
The folded is
argument into
an
possible,
for
"that
the
chiefly
Intuition
conclusion
independent
rests
the
Pure on
that
the
or
that
Science,
the
of T I M E
existence
notion a
is
such
o f time
Science
of certain
a rudi-
may
be
of Pure
priori
unTime
intuitions,
c o n n e c t e d w i t h that n o t i o n of t i m e , a n d fitted to b e c o m e the sources of a pure Science; and on the actual deduction of such a Science from those p r i n c i p l e s , w h i c h t h e a u t h o r c o n c e i v e s t h a t h e has b e g u n . (3; 2 9 6 - 2 9 7 ) In velop
the
second
the
real
section
of this
number system
concept of time.
paper
on
the
Hamilton attempted to basis
of the
intuition
de-
of the
In this w a y he b e l i e v e d he c o u l d justify the use of
negative n u m b e r s as c o r r e s p o n d i n g to steps in time. It
is
derived
24
generally from
Kant.
believed Such
that
Hamilton's
stress
on
m a y n o t b e t h e case, for Kant's
time
was
name is
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n
never
mentioned
these
ideas
he
did
Pure
in
mention
Reason
the
paper.
Preface
Kant
(4;
In
to
and
"encouraged
v i e w . . . ." after
in
the
Hamilton's
his
Lectures
wrote
[him]
that
to
[2]) As early as
mentioning geometry:
nected made
became
with by
other."
Hamilton
reading
K a n t four
in
years
Hamilton wrote:
later
exposition
Quaternions
reading
(4;
Kant's
and
of
[2]-[3]) Critique
publish
of this
1827 H a m i l t o n wrote, i m m e d i a t e l y
"The
intimately
each
on
entertain
sciences
adopt here a v i e w of Algebra w h i c h propose)
Hamilton and Quaternions
I
of Space
have
intertwined
(2,1;
229)
letters
it
From
seems
after m a k i n g t h e
and Time
(to
elsewhere v e n t u r e d to and
indissolubly
con-
a n u m b e r of statements
quite
clear that
he
statement.24
above
began
In
1835
"and my o w n convictions, mathematical and meta-
physical, have b e e n so long and so strongly converging to this point (confirmed I
cannot
no
doubt
easily
of late by the
yield
to
the
stare at my strange t h e o r y . "
study of Kant's
authority (2,11;
142)
of those It thus
Pure Reason),
other
friends
seems
that who
that at most
K a n t served as a catalyst for the d e v e l o p m e n t of his ideas a n d as a confirmation
of them.
In the third part of the Conjugate
of his essay is part
is
essay H a m i l t o n p r e s e n t e d his " T h e o r y o f
Functions, or Algebraic Couples." W h i l e the second part generally considered of minor importance, the third
universally
admitted
to
be
of great importance,
for herein
H a m i l t o n d e v e l o p e d c o m p l e x n u m b e r s in terms of ordered pairs of real numbers in almost exactly the same w a y as it is done in m o d e r n mathematics.25 T h e stress
in this section was not on time, although
the interpretation of the couples in terms of time was given. Hamilton
at no point in the paper mentioned Warren or the geometrical
interpretation of complex n u m b e r s ; f r o m this it seems probable that H a m i l t o n believed (like Gauss) that the geometrical representation was
an aid to
intuition,
b u t not a satisfactory justification for com-
plex numbers. Essentially w h a t H a m i l t o n d i d in this section was to set u p o r d e r e d pairs o f r e a l n u m b e r s (a, b ) a n d d e f i n e o p e r a t i o n s o n them.
T h e s e operations w e r e all
numbers.
He
equivalent to In the and
then
complex
THEORY
denotes
showed
an
OF
done
that the
numbers SINGLE
in terms of the rules for real
couples thus considered were
o f t h e f o r m a - h bi.
N U M B E R S , the
IMPOSSIBLE
He
symbol
EXTRACTION,
or a
wrote:
V ^ T is
merely
absurd,
IMAGI-
N A R Y N U M B E R ; but i n the T H E O R Y O F C O U P L E S , the same symbol V - l REAL
is
significant, COUPLE,
square-root
o f the
and
denotes
namely
couple
(—1,
(as 0).
a we In
POSSIBLE have the
just
EXTRACTION, now
latter theory,
seen)
the
or
a
principal
therefore, though
not in the former, this sign V — l may properly be e m p l o y e d ; a n d we m a y write,
if
a, + a2V-l
we
choose,
for
any
couple
(au
a2)
whatever,
(a,,
a2)
=
(3; 4 1 7 - 4 1 8 )
25
A
History
Hamilton
of V e c t o r Analysis
concluded
the
essay b y
writing:
t h e p r e s e n t Theory o f Couples i s p u b l i s h e d . . .
to s h o w .
.
.
that expres-
sions w h i c h seem a c c o r d i n g to c o m m o n v i e w s to be m e r e l y symbolical, and quite
incapable
of being interpreted,
m a y pass
into the w o r l d of
thoughts, and acquire reality and significance, if Algebra be v i e w e d as not
a
mere
Art or
Language,
but as
the
Science
of Pure T i m e .
The
author hopes to p u b l i s h hereafter m a n y other applications of this v i e w ; especially to Equations and Integrals, and to a T h e o r y of Triplets and Sets
of Moments,
Steps, a n d N u m b e r s , w h i c h includes this T h e o r y of
C o u p l e s . (3; 4 2 2 ) The
" T h e o r y of Triplets" that he sought was of course the extension
of the
complex
It is and
number system
clear from
importance
this
to three
paper that
of the
dimensions.
Hamilton
associative,
understood the
commutative,
nature
and distributive
laws.26 T h e majority of mathematicians appreciated the significance of these
laws
had been
only
after
number
developed which
Hamilton's
"Theory"
systems
(especially
quaternions)
did not obey them.
was
poorly received.
Most mathematicians
d i d n o t agree w i t h H a m i l t o n ' s stress o n t i m e , a n d a f e w felt t h e n e e d for
the
d e v e l o p m e n t of c o m p l e x
geometrical
one.
That
Gauss
numbers
and
justification of complex numbers
Bolyai
on
a basis
other than
rejected the
a
geometrical
is almost certainly d u e to the fact
that they both had previously discovered non-Euclidean geometry. W h e n n o n - E u c l i d e a n g e o m e t r y b e c a m e k n o w n (after 1860), mathematicians
then
numbers
became
interested
in
the
in terms of ordered pairs of real
Hamilton's
"Essay"
was
quaternions
numbers.
an
important event in the history of the
for
a
discovery
of
Hamilton
on
direction,
in addition to the
the
development of complex
number
of
quest for higher complex quest in terms
reasons. numbers
First, from
it
set
another
of a m e t h o d of analysis
for t h r e e - d i m e n s i o n a l space. Second, t h r o u g h his m e t h o d of couples at
least
Hamilton
himself became
convinced of the
legitimacy
of
c o m p l e x n u m b e r s , a n d m o r e i m p o r t a n t l y he also o b t a i n e d a m e t h o d that c o u l d be e x t e n d e d in such a w a y as to assure the legitimacy of higher
complex
numbers,
formed
for example by triplets or quad-
r u p l e t s (as i n t h e c a s e o f q u a t e r n i o n s ) . T o p u t i t a n o t h e r w a y , b y t h i s method cantly
H a m i l t o n was prepared, perhaps to discover, m o r e signifi-
to
accept
as
legitimate,
"four-dimensional"
complex
num-
b e r s (as q u a t e r n i o n s ) , e v e n i f n o g e o m e t r i c a l j u s t i f i c a t i o n w e r e t o b e available. from
Support for the above analysis is f o u n d in a letter of 1841
Hamilton to
As
to T r i p l e t s ,
De I
Morgan:
m u s t a c k n o w l e d g e , that t h o u g h I fancied m y s e l f at
one time to be in possession of something w o r t h publishing about them,
26
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n
Hamilton
and Quaternions
I never could resolve the p r o b l e m w h i c h you have justly signalised as t h e m o s t i m p o r t a n t i n t h i s b r a n c h o f ( f u t u r e ) A l g e b r a : t o assign t w o s y m b o l s O a n d &), s u c h t h a t t h e o n e s y m b o l i c a l e q u a t i o n a + M l + co) = a , +
+ c,&>
shall give the three equations b = bu c = c,
a = au
B u t , i f m y v i e w o f A l g e b r a b e j u s t , i t must b e p o s s i b l e , i n some w a y o r o t h e r , t o i n t r o d u c e n o t o n l y t r i p l e t s b u t polyplets, s o a s i n s o m e s e n s e t o satisfy the s y m b o l i c a l e q u a t i o n a= (a,, a2, . .
.
an);
a being here one symbol, as indicative of one (complex) thought; and f l j , a2, . . . a n d e n o t i n g n r e a l n u m b e r s , p o s i t i v e o r n e g a t i v e ; t h a t i s , i n o t h e r w o r d s , n dates, in t h e c h r o n o l o g i c a l sense of t h e w o r d , o n l y excluding
outward
marks
and
measures,
and
the
notion
of cause
and
e f f e c t . (2,11; 3 4 3 ) Moreover,
after
1843
point of v i e w for his he made this perusal
Hamilton
discovery one
of my
old
stressed
the
importance
discovery of quaternions.
essay,
day w h e n
I
He
of
this
said in fact that
" b e i n g t h e n fresh f r o m a re-
renewed
my
attempts
to
combine
my
g e n e r a l n o t i o n o f sets o f n u m b e r s , c o n s i d e r e d a s s u g g e s t e d b y sets of moments
of time,
with
geometrical
considerations
of points and
lines in t r i d i m e n s i o n a l space. . . . " 2 7
IV. At
Hamilton
s
end
of his
the
Discovery "Essay"
seeking a triplet system. find triplets
as
of
early as
of 1837
not alone
that John system
Hamilton from
at
which
T.
for
in his
1830.
(4;
and
least was
Graves 1836,
similar
(4;
[36]-[37])
De
Morgan,
had
"as
In in
tried
to or
been
1841 which
one
form
in
a
higher
he
was
Morgan
had
received asked
Hamilton
o w n statement
than
correspondence sent
of that year
That
complex
earlier
Graves
Hamilton
Hamilton De
conjecture
property.
perhaps
at w h i c h time to
stated that
shown by Hamilton's
early, had
[39]) T h e
distributive
quest is
Graves space
Hamilton
He h a d , in fact, m a d e d e f i n i t e a t t e m p t s to
entailed abandonment of the was
Quaternions
letter
Hamilton
2 8
on the subject
Hamilton
constructed a
number
myself."
from
a system in
1835.
Augustus
about his
trip-
lets. W i t h this letter w a s a c o p y o f D e M o r g a n ' s 1 8 4 1 p a p e r " O n t h e Foundation
of Algebra,"
2 9
brief discussion of triplets. When lets, t h e
by
1843
Hamilton
framework
within
in (4;
which
De
Morgan
had
included
a
[41]—[42])
began
another intense
which
the
search
search
for trip-
had to be conducted
27
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
was clear to him. T h e following m a y be taken as an outline of the properties that he consciously h o p e d the n e w n u m b e r s w o u l d have. 1. T h e associative property for addition and multiplication. T h u s if
N,
N\
and
(N
+
N')
+
2. T h e N + 3.
N'
N" N"
are
three
and
commutative
=
N'
The
+
N
and
distributive
4. T h e
such
N(N'N")
=
property NN'
=
numbers,
then
N + ( N ' + N") =
and
multiplication.
(NN')N". for
addition
N(N'
+
N'N.
property.
N")
=
NN'
+
NN".
p r o p e r t y that division is u n a m b i g u o u s . T h u s if N a n d N'
are any g i v e n c o m p l e x n u m b e r s , it is always possible to a n d only one n u m b e r X N
and
N')
such
that
(in
general,
NX =
a n u m b e r of t h e
find
one
same f o r m as
N'.
5. T h e property that the n e w n u m b e r s obey the law of the moduli. T h u s if any three triplets c o m b i n e so that {ax
bxi +
+
cj)(a2 +
b2i +
c2j) =
a3 +
b3i +
b22
c 22) =
(a32 +
fo32
c3j,
then (a,2 6. T h e
+
b2
+
c2){a2
+
+
+
c32):
property that the n e w numbers w o u l d have a significant
i n t e r p r e t a t i o n i n t e r m s o f t h r e e d i m e n s i o n a l space. It is well
k n o w n that ordinary c o m p l e x n u m b e r s have all these
properties, w i t h the exception that their geometrical interpretation is for t w o - d i m e n s i o n a l space. In one sense, then, the above is simply
a
detailed
which
statement that
would be
Hamilton
sought for n e w
numbers
directly analogous to ordinary complex numbers.
Of the above properties o n l y the c o m m u t a t i v e property for multiplication h a d to be a b a n d o n e d for quaternions. W i t h limits as restrict i v e a s these H a m i l t o n c o u l d o n l y b e satisfied w i t h quaternions, for, as C. S. Peirce p r o v e d in 1881, " o r d i n a r y real algebra, o r d i n a r y algeb r a w i t h i m a g i n a r i e s , a n d real q u a t e r n i o n s are t h e o n l y associative algebras in w h i c h division by finites always yields an unambiguous quotient." erties
are
30
It is s i g n i f i c a n t to ask at this p o i n t w h i c h of t h e s e p r o p -
retained
for the
scalar (dot)
a n d v e c t o r (cross)
m u l t i p l i c a t i o n s in m o d e r n vector analysis.
product
For the dot product the
associative l a w for multiplication is not relevant, and both the law of the m o d u l i and the unambiguity of division must be abandoned.31 For the must be
cross
product the
associative
and commutative properties
abandoned.32 Moreover division is not unambiguous, and
the l a w of the m o d u l i fails as well.33 F r o m the above comparison of the properties of quaternions and vectors it is e v i d e n t that at least in some ways quaternions not o n l y are s i m p l e r t h a n m o d e r n vectors b u t also entail f e w e r innovations.
28
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n
In the
period
immediately
after
their
Hamilton
discovery
and Quaternions
quaternions
were
criticized because of the abandonment of the commutative property for m u l t i p l i c a t i o n .
It is an interesting historical speculation in this
regard as to what w o u l d have commutative
and
associative
sion was in general
been
said of a system in w h i c h the
properties
failed,
ent types of multiplication were defined. context of the above attempts to
and
in w h i c h divi-
impossible, and in w h i c h m o r e o v e r t w o differIn any case it was
properties that H a m i l t o n in
in the
1843 r e n e w e d his
triplets.34
find
O n O c t o b e r 16,
1843, H a m i l t o n discovered quaternions.
the best description
Perhaps
of the circumstances surrounding this event is
contained in a letter H a m i l t o n wrote in 1865 to his son A r c h i b a l d H. Hamilton: I f I m a y b e a l l o w e d t o s p e a k o f myself i n c o n n e x i o n w i t h t h e s u b j e c t , I m i g h t d o s o i n a w a y w h i c h w o u l d b r i n g you i n , b y r e f e r r i n g t o a n antequaternionic t i m e ,
when
the
of a V e c t o r ,
conception
you
were as
a
m e r e child, b u t h a d c a u g h t f r o m m e
r e p r e s e n t e d b y a Triplet:
and indeed I
happen to be able to p u t the finger of m e m o r y u p o n the year a n d m o n t h — October, 1843 — w h e n h a v i n g r e c e n t l y r e t u r n e d f r o m visits to C o r k a n d Parsonstown, connected w i t h a M e e t i n g of the British Association, the desire to discover the
laws
of the
multiplication referred to regained
w i t h me a certain strength a n d earnestness, w h i c h h a d for years b e e n dormant, b u t was t h e n on the p o i n t of b e i n g gratified, a n d was occasionally talked of w i t h you. E v e r y m o r n i n g in the early part of the abovecited month, on my c o m i n g d o w n to breakfast, your (then) little brother W i l l i a m E d w i n , a n d y o u r s e l f , u s e d t o a s k m e , " W e l l , P a p a , c a n y o u multiply t r i p l e t s " ? W h e r e t o I of the head:
was always o b l i g e d to r e p l y , w i t h a sad shake
" N o , I c a n o n l y add a n d s u b t r a c t t h e m . "
B u t on the 16th day of the same m o n t h — w h i c h h a p p e n e d to be a M o n day, and a C o u n c i l day of the Royal Irish A c a d e m y — I was w a l k i n g in to attend and preside, a n d your m o t h e r was w a l k i n g w i t h me, along the Royal Canal, to w h i c h she h a d perhaps d r i v e n ; a n d a l t h o u g h she t a l k e d with
me
now
and then,
my m i n d , w h i c h that
I
and a
felt
at
spark
l o n g years
to
gave
once
the
flashed come
yet
a n under-current o f t h o u g h t w a s
going on in
a t l a s t a result, w h e r e o f i t i s n o t t o o m u c h t o s a y importance. forth,
the
An
herald
electric (as
circuit
seemed
to
close;
I foresaw, immediately) o f m a n y
o f d e f i n i t e l y d i r e c t e d t h o u g h t a n d w o r k , b y myself i f
s p a r e d , a n d a t a l l e v e n t s o n t h e p a r t o f others, i f I s h o u l d e v e n b e a l l o w e d to live long enough distinctly to communicate the discovery. Nor could I resist t h e i m p u l s e — u n p h i l o s o p h i c a l as it m a y h a v e b e e n —to cut w i t h a knife on a stone of B r o u g h a m B r i d g e , as we passed it, the f u n d a m e n t a l formula w i t h the symbols, i, j, k; namely i2 = j2 = which
contains
t i o n , has
the
k1 =
ijk = —1,
Solution o f t h e Problem, b u t o f c o u r s e , a s
an
inscrip-
long since m o u l d e r e d away. A more durable notice remains,
however, on the
Council
Books of the A c a d e m y for that day (October
16th, 1843), w h i c h records t h e fact, that I t h e n a s k e d for a n d o b t a i n e d
29
A
History
leave
of V e c t o r Analysis
to
Session:
read
a
Paper
on
Quaternions,
at t h e
First
General
Meeting o f t h e
w h i c h reading took place accordingly, on M o n d a y the 13th of
t h e N o v e m b e r f o l l o w i n g . (2,11; 4 3 4 - 4 3 5 ) Thus
in
a
very
nounced
the
numbers
of t h e
dramatic
discovery form
of
manner
Hamilton
quaternions.
w + ix + jy +
kz,
discovered
These
are
and
an-
hypercomplex
w h e r e w, x, y, a n d z a r e r e a l
n u m b e r s , a n d i, j, a n d /c are u n i t vectors, d i r e c t e d a l o n g the x, y, a n d z axes
respectively. ij = ji
=
The
i, j, a n d /c units obey the f o l l o w i n g laws:
k
jk
- k
kj ii
It is
to be
general
= j j
noted that for t w o
equal
q'q.
=
T h e loss
i
ki
- i
ik
= =
kk
=
= j =
- j
—1
quaternions
q
and
of commutativity in
q',
qq'
does
not in
quaternions, while
it is v e r y i m p o r t a n t h i s t o r i c a l l y , is also significant m a t h e m a t i c a l l y , because this complicates calculations in w h i c h quaternions are used. A l l the other properties discussed above are satisfied by quaternions. T h u s it may be v e r i f i e d that q u a t e r n i o n m u l t i p l i c a t i o n is associative a n d q u a t e r n i o n division
is
unambiguous.
special m e n t i o n ,
These
are
two
important properties
which
bear
since t h e y are not preserved in the algebra of m o d e r n
vectors. There have been a n u m b e r of discussions published on the mathematical present
details
of Hamilton's
purposes
within the Almost
all
that
procedure
need
be
after his
is
his
discovery;
for the
that
Hamilton
worked
discussed above.35
context that has b e e n immediately
in
said
discovery
H a m i l t o n stated that he
"felt that it m i g h t be w o r t h my w h i l e to expend [on quaternions] the labour of at least ten 436)
Hamilton
working
(or it m i g h t be
actually
almost
spent
exclusively on
fifteen)
the
last
y e a r s t o c o m e . " (2,11;
twenty-two
quaternions.
The
years letters
of
his
life
of the first
f e w days after the discovery s h o w that H a m i l t o n felt that his system had
importance
nometry.
for
heat
electricity,36
theory,
sense
I
nions,
from
hope
spherical
trigo-
that
I
am
sions
of their principles, to
me
actually
g r o w i n g modest a b o u t t h e
quater-
m y s e e i n g s o m a n y p e e p s a n d vistas into f u t u r e expan-
pears
to
be
as
I
still
important
must for
century as the discovery of fluxions teenth."
and
(2,11; 4 4 2 ) I n 1 8 5 1 h e w r o t e : " I n g e n e r a l , a l t h o u g h i n o n e
(2,11;
assert that this d i s c o v e r y apthe
middle
of the nineteenth
was for the close of the seven-
445)
In o n e sense at least H a m i l t o n ' s discovery was e p o c h m a k i n g , for quaternions
were
the
number system which His
30
first
well-known
did not obey the
consistent
and
significant
laws of ordinary arithmetic.
" c u r i o u s , a l m o s t w i l d " (as h e c a l l e d i t [2,11; 4 4 1 ] ) d i s c o v e r y m a y
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n
Hamilton
and Quaternions
be c o m p a r e d to the discovery of n o n - E u c l i d e a n geometry. B o t h discoveries broke bonds
set b y c e n t u r i e s o f m a t h e m a t i c a l t h o u g h t . I m -
mediately
other
after
by Augustus
1843
De
Morgan
new
(who
number
systems
were
(1846).38
T . G r a v e s ( 1 8 4 4 ) (2,11; 4 5 4 - 4 5 5 ) , a n d C h a r l e s G r a v e s This
section
publications 13,
1843,
Irish
will
on
be
concluded
by
a
quaternions through the
Hamilton
Academy,
of
read a paper on which
at
discovered
p u b l i s h e d f i v e n e w systems),37 J o h n
least
discussion
of Hamilton's
year
On
1847.
quaternions
part
was
November
before the Royal
published
in
1844.39
Either this paper or the very similar paper in the July, 1844, issue of the
Philosophical
nions.
(5,25;
Magazine
was
Quaternions,"
delivered
the
In
these
July,
1846,
papers
not analogous (the
w
first
November
Academy and published in in
his
publication
on
quater-
10-13) A m o n g the m o s t i m p o r t a n t papers are his " O n
issue
Hamilton
to
11,
1844,
of the
Philosophical
dealt w i t h
the
the
Royal
Irish
Magazine.
does
(5,29;
26-31)
fact that q u a t e r n i o n s are
ordinary complex numbers
o f w + i x + j y + kz)
to
1847,40 a n d t h e s i m i l a r p a p e r p u b l i s h e d
in that the
scalar part
n o t i n d i c a t e d i s t a n c e on an axis
un-
less, as he h a d s u g g e s t e d earlier, q u a t e r n i o n s be c o n s i d e r e d as f o u r dimensional. A n d on
Thus
account
Hamilton
of the
(writing
facility w i t h
in
the
which
third person)
this
so
stated:
c a l l e d imaginary e x -
p r e s s i o n , o r s q u a r e r o o t o f a n e g a t i v e q u a n t i t y , i s c o n s t r u c t e d b y a right line
having direction
in
space,
and
h a v i n g x,
y,
z f o r its t h r e e r e c t a n g u l a r
c o m p o n e n t s , o r p r o j e c t i o n s o n t h r e e r e c t a n g u l a r axes, h e has b e e n i n d u c e d to call the t r i n o m i a l expression itself, as w e l l as the line w h i c h it
represents,
a
VECTOR.
A
quaternion
g e n e r a l l y o f a real p a r t a n d a vector.
may
The
thus
fixing
be
said
to
consist
a s p e c i a l a t t e n t i o n on
this last part, or e l e m e n t , of a q u a t e r n i o n , by g i v i n g it a s p e c i a l n a m e , a n d d e n o t i n g it in m a n y calculations by a single a n d special sign, appears
to
the
dealing with
author to the
have
subject:
been
although
an
improvement in
the general
his
method
of
notion of treating the
constituents of the imaginary part as coordinates had occurred to h i m in his first researches. Regarded from a geometrical point of v i e w , this algebraically imagin a r y p a r t of a q u a t e r n i o n has t h u s so n a t u r a l a n d s i m p l e a s i g n i f i c a t i o n or representation in space, that the difficulty is transferred to the algebraic a l l y r e a l p a r t ; a n d w e are t e m p t e d t o ask w h a t t h i s last c a n d e n o t e i n g e o m e t r y , o r w h a t i n s p a c e m i g h t h a v e s u g g e s t e d it.41 The
origin
following
of the
word
quotation
in
vector ( a n d t h e w o r d scalar) the
similar
paper
in
is
the
clear from the Philosophical
Maga-
zine. The
a l g e b r a i c a l l y real p a r t m a y r e c e i v e . . . a l l v a l u e s c o n t a i n e d o n t h e
o n e scale o f p r o g r e s s i o n o f n u m b e r f r o m n e g a t i v e t o p o s i t i v e i n f i n i t y ; w e shall
call
it t h e r e f o r e
the
scalar part,
or
simply the
scalar o f t h e q u a t e r -
n i o n , a n d s h a l l f o r m its s y m b o l b y p r e f i x i n g , t o t h e s y m b o l o f t h e q u a t e r -
31
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
n i o n , t h e c h a r a c t e r i s t i c S e a l . , o r s i m p l y S., w h e r e n o c o n f u s i o n s e e m s l i k e l y t o arise f r o m u s i n g this last a b b r e v i a t i o n . O n t h e o t h e r h a n d , t h e algebraically
imaginary
part,
being
geometrically
constructed
by
a
straight l i n e or radius vector, w h i c h has, in general, for each d e t e r m i n e d q u a t e r n i o n , a d e t e r m i n e d l e n g t h a n d d e t e r m i n e d d i r e c t i o n in space, m a y be
c a l l e d t h e vector part, o r s i m p l y t h e vector o f t h e q u a t e r n i o n ;
and may
be denoted by prefixing the characteristic Vect., or V. We may therefore say
that
a
quaternion
is
in
general
parts, a n d m a y w r i t e Q = S e a l . SQ + V Q . F r o m the
(5,29;
above
quotations
introduced
cise
mathematical
The than
the
this.
scalar
sense,
analysis.
quotations
In
of its
own
scalar
and
vector
Q = S . Q + V . Q or s i m p l y Q =
it m a y be inferred that it was H a m i l t o n
term
a
sense
Hamilton
also
the
the
term
vector i n
similar
term
its
pre-
radius
vector
before.
however
they
had
and
although
used for m a n y years
above
sum
26-27)
who
had been
the
Q + Vect.
have
mark
the
introduced
a
far
greater
beginning
his
significance
of modern
symbols
S
and
vector
V because
"separation of the real a n d i m a g i n a r y parts of a q u a t e r n i o n is an operation of such frequent occurrence, and may be regarded as so fund a m e n t a l in this theory. . . of his
quaternions xi + yy'
yj + +
(5,29; 26) H a m i l t o n illustrated the use
symbols as applied to the product of the multiplication of two a a n d a',
zk a n d
zz');
V.
in
which
the
a' = x'i + y ' j + z'k, aa'
=
i(yz'
-
z y ' )
scalar parts w e r e 0.
Hamilton wrote: + j(zx'
-
x z ' )
+
Letting a =
" S . aa' = — (xx' +
k(xy'
-
yx').
.
.
(5,29; 30) It is o b v i o u s that these are e q u i v a l e n t to the m o d e r n vector
(cross)
product.42 bols,
product
using them
n o w be used. S.aa'
=
0
negative
of the
modern
scalar (dot)
in
cases
where
the
dot and
cross p r o d u c t w o u l d
Hamilton then proceeded to prove such equations as
when
Another 1847.43
and to the
H a m i l t o n and Tait m a d e very frequent use of these sym-
pair
In these
a
and
of
a'
very
papers
...<],
defined
known
operation
with
are
parallel.
important Hamilton
relation
of partial
to
papers
appeared
introduced the
these
three
differentiation,
in
1846
and
n e w operation
symbols
performed
ijk,
and to
the
w i t h respect to
t h r e e i n d e p e n d e n t b u t r e a l v a r i a b l e s xyz, a s f o l l o w s : id
this
new
expressed
characterestic by
the
will following
have
jd L— the
kd 1 negative
of
its
symbolic
square
formula:
of w h i c h it is clear that t h e a p p l i c a t i o n s to a n a l y t i c a l p h y s i c s m u s t be ext e n s i v e in a h i g h d e g r e e . (5,31; 291)
32
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n a n d Q u a t e r n i o n s
T h e final paper of special importance is that delivered N o v e m b e r 13,
1843, b u t p u b l i s h e d o n l y in f u l l (and certainly w i t h additions) 1848.44 T h i s v e r y l o n g p a p e r w a s m a i n l y d e v o t e d t o d e v e l o p i n g
in
quaternions as
in
analogy to his
number couples,
1837 treatment of complex n u m b e r s
and to relating his
quaternions to the opera-
tions, principles, and elements of traditional mathematics. In s u m m a r y , by the e n d of 1847 H a m i l t o n h a d p u b l i s h e d at least thirty-four papers i n f i v e different journals. M a n y o f these w e r e expository;
some
geometry,
used
quaternions
mechanics,
and
for the
astronomy.
On
solution a
of problems
number
in
of occasions
n e w results w e r e obtained by means of quaternions, b u t n o n e seem to have b e e n of a striking nature.
V.
Quaternions
Until
Hamilton
s
Death
(1865)
T h e aim of this section is to consider H a m i l t o n ' s w o r k on quaternions from
1847 to
1865 and, m o r e i m p o r t a n t to us, to discuss the
reception of quaternions f r o m the t i m e of their d i s c o v e r y u n t i l 1865. In considering the reception of quaternions it must not be forgotten that, u n l i k e m a n y n e w discoveries, the discovery o f q u a t e r n i o n s was made by a m a n having considerable fame before the discovery was
made.
Lagrange 1842
It was in de
votre
1842 that Jacobi referred to H a m i l t o n as " l e pays,"
and
the
Athenaeum,
in
discussing
the
meeting of the British Association, m e n t i o n e d that "peculiar
interest was excited by the presence of the three great astronomers, Bessel, Herschel, a n d H a m i l t o n , w h o w e r e seen seated together on the
platform."45
Hamilton's
fame
acted
as
a
powerful
force
in
spreading knowledge of quaternions and in forestalling criticism of them.
Mathematicians w h o d i d not use quaternions w e r e nonethe-
less c a u t i o u s a b o u t a t t a c k i n g t h e m . The
question
within
of the
reception
of quaternions
should
be
seen
the perspective provided by the history of the reception of
s i m i l a r s y s t e m s . T h e r a p i d i t y w i t h w h i c h n e w s y s t e m s o f i d e a s (as o p p o s e d to n e w e x p e r i m e n t a l or technical results) are r e c e i v e d is often
exaggerated.
Non-Euclidean
geometry,
Boolean
algebra,
Maxwell's theory, and even the calculus were only gradually appreciated
and
numbers,
assimilated
into
scientific
thought.
the Grassmannian system, and the
Moreover complex
Gibbs-Heaviside
(or
modern) system of vector analysis w e r e all s l o w l y received. W h e n H a m i l t o n and the y o u n g Tait express their surprise that the quaternion
system
was
only
slowly being appreciated, their statements
are to be t a k e n w i t h caution, for t h e y express a l a m e n t that is n e a r l y universal a m o n g the p r o p o n e n t s of n e w systems of ideas.
33
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
It is also i m p o r t a n t to realize that to a certain extent the groundwork
had
gand,
been
laid for quaternions
representation of complex numbers Gauss, more
before
1843.
The
work
of Ar-
M o u r e y , Warren, Gauss, and others had made the geometrical
Peacock,
De
Morgan,
an accepted idea.
and others
sophisticated v i e w of algebra.
Mobius,
and
Grassmann,
The work of
had helped to produce a
Finally, the work of Bellavitis,
a n d t h e fact that Wessel, Gauss, A r g a n d ,
Servois, Frangais, M o u r e y , John T. Graves, De Morgan, and Hamilton h a d all, a n d for the most part i n d e p e n d e n t l y , searched for triplets, indicates that there was a felt n e e d for such a system as quaternions. Quaternions,
with
their abandonment of commutativity,
were
in
any case s o m e w h a t r e v o l u t i o n a r y i n conception. T h u s , e v e n J o h n T . Graves, such
a
perhaps new
Hamilton's
the
idea,
mathematician
wrote
in
the
best
prepared
following
letter announcing the
manner
for in
accepting
response
to
discovery:
T h e r e is still s o m e t h i n g in the system w h i c h gravels me. I have not yet a n y clear v i e w s a s t o t h e e x t e n t t o w h i c h w e are a t l i b e r t y a r b i t r a r i l y t o create imaginaries, and e n d o w t h e m w i t h supernatural properties. You are c e r t a i n l y j u s t i f i e d by t h e event. Y o u have got an i n s t r u m e n t that facilitates t h e w o r k i n g o f t r i g o n o m e t r i c a l t h e o r e m s a n d suggests n e w ones, a n d i t s e e m s h a r d t o ask m o r e ; b u t I a m g l a d t h a t y o u h a v e g l i m p s e s o n p h y s i c a l a n a l o g i e s . (2,11; 4 4 3 ) It seems that De abandonment were
troubled,
lights?
Morgan and
MacCullagh were troubled by the
of commutativity, what
Probably
the
must initial
and
have
if such
been
reaction
the
was
great
mathematicians
reaction
opposition,
time into curiosity and a greater openness of mind.
among
lesser
passing w i t h
By 1847 quater-
nions h a d to some degree b e c o m e k n o w n , a n d at the British Association
meeting
value.
Hamilton
of that year a debate described the
debate
took
place
concerning their
in a letter to R.
P.
Graves:
B e i n g ready, h o w e v e r , at the c o m m e n c e m e n t of the M e e t i n g , I was told that I n e e d not straiten m y s e l f as to t i m e , the pressure of other Papers h a v i n g not yet b e e n felt; a n d Dr. Peacock said afterwards to me that I had g i v e n " a c a p i t a l e x p o s i t i o n " : w h i l e f r o m m a n y o t h e r q u a r t e r s i t has b e e n t o l d m e t h a t h e has e x p r e s s e d h i m s e l f e v e r y w h e r e a s f a v o u r a b l e t o m y w h o l e system.
M r . Jarrett b r o u g h t f o r w a r d again his C a m b r i d g e objec-
tions, and d w e l t particularly on the possibility of making'mistakes in the u s e o f m y n e w c a l c u l u s . I n r e p l y t o w h i c h I d i s c l a i m e d t h e p o w e r o f sett i n g any l i m i t to the faculty of m a k i n g blunders; but said that the practic a l q u e s t i o n o n t h a t p o i n t w a s , w h e t h e r w i t h a r e a s o n a b l e d e g r e e o f attention a reasonable
security against error c o u l d be attained; w h i c h I
t h o u g h t that my experience
of the
w o r k i n g of the quaternions enabled
me to answer in the affirmative. T h e Rev. Richard Greswell, an Oxford m a n for w h o m I have a great respect, b u t w h o is not particularly scien-
34
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n
Hamilton
and Quaternions
tific, m a d e some critical remarks in a not u n f r i e n d l y spirit; b u t o b l i g e d me to disclaim a triplet w h i c h he attributed to me, of Positive, Negative, and Imaginary:
a n d t o state that w i t h m e t h e d i s t i n c t i o n b e t w e e n Posi-
tive a n d N e g a t i v e was exactly t h e same a s that b e t w e e n F u t u r e a n d Past, o r b e t w e e n Past a n d F u t u r e . A f t e r s o m e g e n t l e s k i r m i s h e s o f this sort, rose H e r s c h e l ; w h o said that his a d m i r a t i o n o f t h e q u a t e r n i o n s h a d increased w i t h every r e s u m p t i o n of his study of t h e m : a n d that a l t h o u g h it m i g h t be d i f f i c u l t at first to master t h e e x t r e m e l y abstract c o n c e p t i o n s , and the n e w algorithm w h i c h they involve, yet he was w e l l c o n v i n c e d that it was w o r t h the trouble. T h e y appeared to h i m a bag, into w h i c h one n e e d o n l y insert his h a n d to d r a w forth treasures; he m i g h t call t h e m a cornucopia of scientific abundance: and in a w o r d , his earnest advice to mathematicians w o u l d be, to " s t u d y the q u a t e r n i o n s . " Sir J o h n H e r s c h e l had r e m a i n e d at O x f o r d on purpose to make this statement; a n d i m m e d i ately afterwards he started off for C o l l i n g w o o d . M r . Airy, seeing that the subject c o u l d not be c u s h i o n e d , rose t h e n to speak of his o w n acquaintance w i t h it, w h i c h he a v o w e d to be n o n e at all; b u t gave us to u n d e r stand that what he d i d not k n o w c o u l d not be w o r t h k n o w i n g . He w a r n e d all persons, if t h e y s h o u l d use the m e t h o d , to do so w i t h the extremest caution; professing to regard me as b e l i e v i n g it to be a right one, solely o n t h e g r o u n d o f t h e a g r e e m e n t o f its r e s u l t s , s o far a s t h e y h a v e b e e n y e t obtained, w i t h those of the older method. W h a t was obscure was to h i m as if it w e r e erroneous, what was paradoxical was to h i m as if it w e r e f a l s e ; a n d h e t h o u g h t that s y s t e m u s e l e s s a s a n a l g e b r a i c a l g e o m e t r y , o f w h i c h the expressions were so extremely difficult of geometrical interp r e t a t i o n . (2,11; 5 8 5 - 5 8 7 ) Concerning this statement It also
quotation it should be m e n t i o n e d that Herschel's
appeared
seems
in
the
Athenaeum
in
an
even
only partly valid, though forcefully delivered. seem
to
stronger
form.45
that Jarrett's, Greswell's, a n d Airy's objections w e r e
have
changed
around
this
time,
for
MacCullagh's views in
late
1847,
on the
night before he c o m m i t t e d suicide, he told a friend that in his opini o n H e r s c h e l h a d not g o n e too far in his statement at the B r i t i s h Association meeting. In
1846
Academy
(2,11;
Hamilton presumably
searches, a n d in
595-596)
resigned to
obtain
the
presidency
more
time
for
of the his
Royal
Irish
quaternion
re-
1848 both the Royal Irish A c a d e m y and the Royal
Society of E d i n b u r g h a w a r d e d h i m medals for his discovery. It was also in
1848 that H a m i l t o n gave a series of four lectures on quater-
nions at D u b l i n
University.
sketch"
of them.
George
Salmon
cian, besides
and
quaternions
time
who
heard the
Arthur Cayley,
who
was
1845, g i v e n "a short 1848
lectures
were
the first mathemati-
Hamilton, to publish a paper on quaternions (Cayley's
paper appeared in in
He had earlier, in
A m o n g those
and
1845).46 G e o r g e
S a l m o n also b e c a m e interested
a d v a n c e d far e n o u g h i n t h e i r s t u d y that a t o n e
H a m i l t o n thought that Salmon m i g h t b e c o m e his successor in
quaternion
studies.
(2,111;
90)
Salmon
however w e n t on
to
attain
35
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
fame in other branches of mathematics, and Peter Guthrie Tait (who will
be
discussed
quaternion
Hamilton's and
detail
lectures
published
described the 1852:
in
as
of
his
1848
Lectures
became
Hamilton's
successor in
were
on
eventually
Quaternions
in
greatly
1853.
expanded
Salmon
aptly
n e e d for such a w o r k w h e n he wrote to H a m i l t o n in
"Your book will
general.
later)
researches.
probably m a k e the use of your m e t h o d more
At present it is a b o w of Ulysses, w h i c h no one can bend
but the owner." Hamilton's
(2,111;
Lectures
346)
on
Quaternions
consisted
of a
series
of
seven
lectures, extending to 737 pages w i t h an additional 64-page preface and a 72-page table of contents. the
history
nions
could
be
interpreted
founded on the numbers.
In the preface Hamilton discussed
of quaternions and showed in in
terms
great detail h o w quater-
of his
concept
concept of time and in terms
These
sections
were
of algebra
of quadruples
as
of real
neither easy nor probably interest-
ing reading for most readers.
Early in the w o r k H a m i l t o n wrote that
he
would
style
not
a
use
happy
a
"metaphysical
choice,
and
the
of e x p r e s s i o n . "
work
(4;
4)
This
was
was further e n c u m b e r e d by his
practice of introducing a multitude of n e w terms.
Early in the work
h e set u p a n elaborate t e r m i n o l o g y b y u s i n g such w o r d s a n d c o m b i nations
as
vector,
vehend,
vection,
vectum,
revector,
revehend,
revection, r e v e c t u m , provector, . . . transvector, . . . factor, . . . profactor, . . . versor, . . . a n d quadrantal semi-inversor. pages
the
mathematical
first seventy-four pages. dition,
v e r s o r , w h i c h is of c o u r s e a
Authors of later quaternion books expressed in three
subtraction,
ideas
that
Hamilton
had
presented in his
H a m i l t o n dealt at s o m e l e n g t h w i t h the ad-
multiplication,
and division of quaternions.
He
showed h o w quaternions were to be applied to spherical geometry and ".
trigonometry
L O G A R I T H M S , T I O N S , .
and
showed
. . C O - O R D I N A T E S ,
.
,"
4 7
It was read. any . . .
SERIES,
He
relations
L I N E A R
D I F F E R E N T I A L S ,
plications
the
of
D E T E R M I N A N T S ,
A N D
A N D
quaternions
to
T R I G O N O M E T R Y ,
Q U A D R A T I C
C O N T I N U E D
E Q U A -
F R A C T I O N S .
c o n c l u d e d w i t h s o m e geometrical a n d astronomical apand the
without
introduction question
of the biquaternion.
a very
long
and a very difficult book to
Herschel in 1853 wrote to H a m i l t o n that the book w o u l d "take man
a
twelvemonth
, " 4 8 a n d in
Your
to
read,
and
near
a
lifetime
to
digest
1859 Herschel wrote:
deduction f r o m Quaternions of Fresnel's W a v e is one of those
things w h i c h I have just knowledge enough to admire without enough to understand.
But
it
set
me
again
on
reading
you
Lectures
on
Quater-
nions, a n d I g o t t h r o u g h t h e t h r e e f i r s t c h a p t e r s o f i t w i t h a m u c h c l e a r e r
36
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n
Hamilton
and Quaternions
p e r c e p t i o n of m e a n i n g than w h e n I attacked it some three or four years back, b u t I was again o b l i g e d to give it up in despair. N o w I pray y o u to listen to this
cry of distress.
I
f e e l certain t h a t i f y o u p l e a s e d y o u could
put the w h o l e matter in as clear a light as w o u l d make the Calculus itself a c c e s s i b l e a s a n i n s t r u m e n t t o r e a d e r s e v e n o f less " p e n e t r a t i n g p o w e r " than
myself,
who,
having
once
mastered
the
algorithm
a n d t h e conven-
tions s o a s t o w o r k w i t h i t , w o u l d t h e n b e b e t t e r p r e p a r e d t o g o a l o n g w i t h y o u i n y o u r m e t a p h y s i c a l e x p l a n a t i o n s . (2,111; It may be was
recalled that Herschel
a man
of great ability.
three chapters cians
121)
had been a Senior Wrangler and
If he could read no more than the first
(129 pages), h o w far w o u l d t h e less a b l e m a t h e m a t i -
advance?
H a m i l t o n faced some difficulty in getting such a large, n e w w o r k published. Thus in
1853 he wrote to a friend ( M o r t i m e r O'Sullivan):
Y o u w i l l I h o p e b e a r w i t h m e i f I s a y , t h a t i t r e q u i r e d a c e r t a i n capital of scientific reputation, amassed in f o r m e r years, to m a k e it other than d a n g e r o u s l y i m p r u d e n t to hazard the p u b l i c a t i o n of a w o r k w h i c h has, a l t h o u g h at b o t t o m q u i t e c o n s e r v a t i v e , a h i g h l y r e v o l u t i o n a r y air. It w a s a part of t h e o r d e a l t h r o u g h w h i c h I h a d to pass, an e p i s o d e in t h e b a t t l e of life, to k n o w that e v e n c a n d i d a n d f r i e n d l y p e o p l e secretly, or, as it m i g h t happen, openly, censured or r i d i c u l e d me, for w h a t appeared to t h e m m y m o n s t r o u s i n n o v a t i o n s . (2,11; 6 8 3 ) The
longest
Review
for
writing: judge,
1857, "It
is
that
in
review
of the
written
probably by Thomas
confidently the
coming
work
appeared
predicted, centuries
by
in
the
Hill.49
those
Hamilton's
North
Hill
best
American
began
by
qualified
Quaternions
to
will
stand out as the great discovery of our nineteenth century. Yet h o w s i l e n t l y has t h e b o o k t a k e n its p l a c e u p o n t h e s h e l v e s o f t h e m a t h e matician's
library. Perhaps not fifty m e n on this side of the Atlantic
h a v e s e e n it, c e r t a i n l y n o t f i v e h a v e r e a d i t . " 5 0 H e t h e n p r o c e e d e d to compare
Hamilton
and Newton
in
to
Archimedes,
Galileo,
Descartes,
Leibniz,
regard to the p r o b l e m of w h o can j u d g e their ideas.
O t h e r sections p r a i s e t h e b o o k a n d its a u t h o r i n s u c h s t r o n g w o r d s as " T h e discoveries of N e w t o n have done m o r e for E n g l a n d a n d for the
race,
archs;
t h a n has
and
we
been
doubt
done by whole
not
that
in
the
dynasties
great
of British
mathematical
mon-
birth
of
1853, the Q u a t e r n i o n s of H a m i l t o n , there is as m u c h real p r o m i s e of benefit to m a n k i n d as in any event of Victoria's reign." tioning Pythagoras, twenty-three found,
like
Hill
hundred that
with
the
eternal
such
statements
of
stated:
years
longer, the name
Pythagoras,
made
somewhat
had not read the work:
"In
After men-
of Hamilton
immortal
truth first revealed through was
5 1
" A n d if the w o r l d should stand for
weakened
by
him."
when
its 5 2
will be
connection
The
force
of
Hill admitted he
looking over Hamilton's eight hundred
37
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
pages
on
Quaternions
them.
.
,"
sketch
.
of the
Hill's one
5 3
in
(for w e
review
of
concluded
with
an extremely brief
of quaternions.
Hamilton's
favorable
Lectures
reviews
mathematics
w o u l d feel
w i l l not p r e t e n d t o say w e h a v e read
was
mathematics
review
of most
ested
The
who
ever
read
on
Quaternions
published;
and
is
any
accepted
certainly
person
Hill's
inter-
statements
inclined, if not obliged, to read Hamilton's book.
review Hill
In the
s h o w e d m o r e ability for rhetoric than for the analysis of
mathematical
ideas;
he
reviewed
Hamilton,
not
his
book,
and
thereby failed to h e e d his o w n advice, for he had argued that f e w if any in
could judge
this
are
case
reviewed
At
various
from
the
significance
book. T h e fate o f H a m i l t o n
times
after
these
were
1843
who
whose
Hamilton
received
letters
or visits
had acquired an interest in quaternions.
Thomas
first-rate mathematician Carmichael,
their books
favorably but uncritically.
mathematicians
A m o n g
of the
is the not u n c o m m o n fate of m e n of fame;
Penyngton
but
interest
lost in
Kirkman,
interest
in
quaternions
who
became
quaternions; was
cut
short
a
Robert by
his
death at age 31, b u t w h o h a d by that t i m e p u b l i s h e d five papers on quaternions;
and J.
w h o wrote to no
"less
P.
Nichol, Professor of Astronomy at Glasgow,
H a m i l t o n that the discovery of quaternions seemed of
value
than
the
momentous
step
shown
us
by
Descartes.
. . ." (2,11; 6 3 5 ) In cal
1860
Nichol
Sciences,
for
published
which
a
Hamilton
work
called
wrote
an
Cyclopaedia
exposition
o f the of
Physi-
quater-
nions.54 T h e interesting aspect of this is that N i c h o l a p p e n d e d to the article a short note w h i c h stated that since these sections were written, t h e n e w b r a n c h o f m a t h e m a t i c s t o w h i c h t h e y r e l a t e a p p e a r s t o h a v e attracted an increasing degree of attention, in our o w n and in foreign countries. of a
The
Lectures
favourable
(Dublin,
article
1853) have for e x a m p l e , f o r m e d the subject
in
the
North American
Review
for July,
1857:
and,
i n d e e d , the Q u a t e r n i o n s h a d b e e n m e n t i o n e d as a m o n g the sources of hope for the future progress of analytical mechanics, in the conclusion to a
very
beautiful
Boston,
volume
(A
System
o f Analytic
Mechanics,
&c.,
page
476.
1855) on that science; by Professor B e n j a m i n Peirce of H a r v a r d
University,
U.S., as f o l l o w s :
. . and much
must soon b e c o m e anti-
quated and obsolete as the science advances, and especially w h e n we shall
have
Hamilton's Benjamin the time tail
the
full
benefit
of the
remarkable
machinery
of
Quaternions."55
Peirce,
who
was
the leading American mathematician of
(and the teacher of T h o m a s Hill), w i l l be discussed in de-
later. At this p o i n t it n e e d o n l y be stated that in
published
38
received
hjs
System
o f Analytical
Mechanics
without
1872 P e i r c e realtering
the
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n a n d Q u a t e r n i o n s
statement
above56
quoted
and
without
introducing
quaternions.
Such statements as those discussed above h e l p e d to lay the foundation for the spread of the quaternion system, b u t in a very indirect way. To advocate the use of a system is not of course equivalent to using the system, a n d the latter is the m o r e important. In the late 1850's a n d 1860's the f e e l i n g g r a d u a l l y arose that q u a t e r n i o n s w e r e o f t e n p r a i s e d b u t s e l d o m used. I n t h e last t h i r d o f t h e c e n t u r y t h e i r use became more frequent, partly as a result of H a m i l t o n ' s second book on quaternions
and partly because elementary presentations
of quaternions b e c a m e available t h r o u g h the efforts of other mathematicians. 1880)
De Volson W o o d in an elementary exposition (written in
perhaps
w e n t t o o f a r i n h i s d e s c r i p t i o n o f H a m i l t o n ' s Lectures
w h e n h e w r o t e o f it: " b u t t h e style i s s o p e c u l i a r , b e i n g diffuse a n d hesitating as
if he
labored t o m a k e h i s r e a d e r s u n d e r s t a n d , a n d t h e
arrangement b e i n g such as to separate parts of essential principles, that, p r o b a b l y , c o m p a r a t i v e l y f e w o f its r e a d e r s , w i t h o u t o t h e r aids, have
m a s t e r e d its
57
principles."
Charles
Graves,
Hamilton's
col-
league at D u b l i n , w r o t e in his eloge for H a m i l t o n : "Students of his lectures
on
claimed
from
Quaternions them
too
have
sometimes
much
attention
c o m p l a i n e d that h e has
to the metaphysics of the
subject, a n d has s t o p p e d t h e m i n t h e i r career o f b u i l d i n g u p , i n order that they m i g h t contemplate afresh the plan of the structure." Some information
is
available concerning the early reception of
quaternions in other countries. that
France
had
been
very
Although
slow
in
in
1861
accepting
Hamilton wrote
quaternions
129), i t w a s t h e
Frenchman Alexandre Allegret who
lished
book
the
first
58
on
H e r m a n n H a n k e l stated in
quaternions
not
written
in
(2,111;
1862 p u b Hamilton.59
by
1867 that H a m i l t o n wrote in a very un-
conventional w a y for continental readers a n d that the only source of information for t h e m at that t i m e was Allegret's w o r k , w h i c h H a n k e l called an "indeed insufficient presentation." lavitis
became
published have
interested
papers
spread to
in
relating to
Russia,
quaternions quaternions.61
for Tait wrote to
60
In Italy Giusto Bel-
and
in
1858
and
1862
Finally, interest must
Hamilton in
1862:
"Pro-
fessor B o l z a n i is h e r e a n d we h a v e h a d l o n g discussions on t h e subject [ q u a t e r n i o n s ] . He is i m m e n s e l y i n t e r e s t e d in it, a n d has g i v e n a c o u r s e o f l e c t u r e s o n i t i n Russia, o f w h i c h h e has p r o m i s e d t o s e n d c o p i e s w h e n p r i n t e d . " (2,111; quaternions
among
the
149) T h u s t h e r e w a s s o m e i n t e r e s t i n
non-English
speaking countries,
although
n a t u r a l l y i t w a s less t h a n t h a t i n B r i t i a n a n d i n A m e r i c a . By
1856
nions,
which
Hamilton
had
begun
work
was p u b l i s h e d in a nearly
year after his
death.62
on
his
finished
Elements form in
H a m i l t o n was aware that his
o f Quater1866, the
e a r l i e r Lectures
39
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
had not provided a successful presentation of quaternions. In John
Herschel
encounaged
Hamilton
to
make
troductory work with examples and problems approach
to a f r i e n d ( A .
a
one,
for
be
and
cited,
hope
almost
or m e m o i r s "Book
finished state) is
as
sale,
(2,111;
1859
an
in-
121), a n d this
"I
like
w a n t to
was
was
an
and
elementary
Hamilton
Hamilton
could
a Book o f Reference —
other
writers,
is
that
intention
the
Elements
t h e otoix<eta of E u c l i d , in f u t u r e treatises
fulfilled,
one
finish
it cannot n o w be— but my
regards
n o t altogether sad;
composed only
Hart):
for
o n t h e Q u a t e r n i o n s . " (2,111;
o f Reference"
This
S.
unluckily
myself,
may
Elements
seems to have b e e n H a m i l t o n ' s intention. B u t in 1862 he
wrote short
the
for
139) T h e w i s h to m a k e it a
the
Elements
one-half times
as
(even long
in
as
its
un-
t h e Lectures.63
a n u m b e r of mathematicians could have work
have
(and m a n y later did), b u t probably
written
such
a
work
as
the
Elements.
p a i d m u c h attention to the foundations for the quater-
n i o n system. T h i s was valuable in that later workers in quaternions could the
in
their researches
Elements
for
the
mental property. the
"Science
plex
turn
detailed
Hamilton
to,
the
In
proof
of
any
funda-
of Pure T i m e , " or his ideas on the foundation of comi n t e r m s o f o r d e r e d sets o f n u m -
a letter (1861) to De M o r g a n , H a m i l t o n described m a n y of
important
As
t h e i r p u b l i c a t i o n s refer to,
rigorous
d i d n o t stress his c o n c e p t o f a l g e b r a a s
and higher complex numbers
bers.
or in
and
a book,
Lectures,
I
characteristics
am
with
&c.
the
Elements:
far b e t t e r satisfied w i t h t h e n e w v o l u m e t h a n w i t h t h e
which,
satisfied
of
however,
is
them,
point
in
not saying m u c h , for I am v e r y m u c h disof
composition
and
arrangement—the
I t m u s t , I o w n , r e q u i r e a s o m e w h a t r e s o l u t e p a t i e n c e t o r e a d t h e Lectures
through;
but
I
trust
that,
although
parts
may
conveniently
be
o m i t t e d a t f i r s t r e a d i n g , t h e n e w w o r k i s s o a r r a n g e d , a n d subdivided, a s to be q u i t e e a s i l y a c c e s s i b l e to a n y s t u d e n t w h o has a c o m p e t e n t (not a profound) knowledge of former mathematics, and wishes to understand the
subject.
No
new
notation, f o r i n s t a n c e , i s
i n t r o d u c e d — a n d after all,
I do n o t e m p l o y m a n y such — w i t h o u t a series of e x a m p l e s f o l l o w i n g , in n u m b e r e d s u b - a r t i c l e s , t o r e n d e r its m e a n i n g a n d its u s e f a m i l i a r . A n d generally I have
h o p e that t h e progress is
w e l l graduated t h r o u g h o u t ;
a v o i d e d w h a t m a y b e c a l l e d talk,
with
while I
some care; a n d have o n l y
one m e t a p h y s i c a l r e m a r k , i n f o u r a n d a h a l f l i n e s o f a n o t e ! (2,111; 5 6 8 ) The
work
is
certainly
clearer
than
the
Lectures,
although
be-
labored explanations
occur frequently in both books. A primary aim
of the
do
Elements
ordinary velop the
was
to
for
quaternions
what
others
had
done
for
n u m b e r s a n d to some extent for c o m p l e x n u m b e r s —to de-
them
in terms
of all the major aspects
of mathematics.
Thus
logarithms of quaternions were discussed, quaternions raised to
quaternion powers, the solution of equations in quaternions, and so
40
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n a n d Q u a t e r n i o n s
on.
That
were
the
majority
geometrical
of the
applications
rather than
physical
of quaternion
methods
was a natural result of the
f a c t t h a t H a m i l t o n (as h e h i m s e l f a d m i t t e d [2,111; 1 5 0 ] ) h a d l o s t c o n tact
with
some
many
ways
developments
unfortunate,
in
for
physics.
interest
in
This
partiality
quaternions
was
and
in
vector
analysis was to be stronger a m o n g physicists than mathematicians. It
is
over
noteworthy
later
treated and
by
that
vector
quaternions
included
planned to
many
parts
o f t h e Elements
analysts.
Thus
for
with
zero
a large
section
(hence
differentiation. of the
work
be
taken
the first section
scalar c o m p o n e n t s
a treatment of vector
devote
could
example
vectors)
Hamilton had
to his o p e r a t o r <];
however by the t i m e of his death this section h a d not b e e n written. The
development
of
this
mainly
left
science,
was
note:
. . Professor
other
applications
cluding
some
operator, for
Tait,
Tait.
who
has
of Quaternions,
on
so
important
Hamilton already
physical
in
published
mathematical
Electro-Dynamics,
for
noted
appears
and to
a
foot-
tracts
on
physical,
in-
the
writer
emi-
nently fitted to carry on, happily and usefully, this n e w branch of m a t h e m a t i c a l science: a n d l i k e l y t o b e c o m e i n it, i f t h e e x p r e s s i o n may
be
Five
hundred
202), nions
allowed,
and
one
copies
in
the
appeared.
of the
chief successors
o f t h e Elements next
Tait had
year
were
Tait's
begun
this
to
inventor."64
in
1866
printed
Elementary
book
its
by
Treatise
1859,
on
(2,111; Quater-
but at Hamil-
ton's r e q u e s t h e h a d w i t h h e l d its p u b l i c a t i o n u n t i l after t h e p u b l i cation
VI.
of H a m i l t o n ' s
Summary
and
Elements.
(2,111;
133)
Conclusion
T h e status o f q u a t e r n i o n analysis a t t h e t i m e o f H a m i l t o n ' s d e a t h in
1865 m a y n o w b e s u m m a r i z e d . B y the e n d o f 1865 one h u n d r e d
and fifty papers had b e e n published on quaternions; one h u n d r e d and nine
(or 7 3 p e r c e n t )
were by
Hamilton.
T h e r e m a i n i n g forty-
one were by fifteen other authors, four of w h o m w e r e not British. T w o books had been published; the first, written by Hamilton, was l o n g a n d difficult t o read; t h e second, w r i t t e n b y A l l e g r e t , w a s less than one-tenth as long and written in French. T w o other books had been
written;
thorough, cians; value
the as
of
these
other
(Tait's
(Hamilton's
as
Treatise)
a reference was
short,
Elements) work
was
long,
for mathemati-
readable,
and
of great
a text for those w h o w i s h e d to b e c o m e acquainted w i t h
quaternion other.
one
a n d of great value
methods.
Quaternions
mathematics,
Together the two works complemented each were
not
in
1865
an
established
branch
of
b u t by 1865 a f o u n d a t i o n for this h a d certainly b e e n
laid.
41
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
Hamilton his
Elements
Charles
died on of
September 2,
Quaternions
Graves
wrote
in
until an
a
1865.
He continued to work on
few
days
eloge
that
before
Hamilton's
his
death.
"diligence
of
late was e v e n excessive — i n t e r f e r i n g w i t h his sleep, his meals, his exercise, his social enjoyments. It was, I believe, fatally injurious to his health." the
brilliant
life to on
65
T h e r e is certainly something tragic in the thought of Hamilton
devoting
q u a t e r n i o n s , w h i c h are
Hamilton's
place
in
the
the
last
twenty-two
years
of his
now o f l i t t l e i n t e r e s t . B u t j u d g m e n t s history
of
sophisticated basis than that quaternions
science
require
a
more
n o w seem to be of little
i m p o r t a n c e . T h e j u d g m e n t m u s t b e m a d e o n t w o bases. T h e f i r s t i s whether
or
not
Hamilton
acted
with
insight in
light of what was
k n o w n and could be k n o w n in mathematical and physical science at that t i m e . E n o u g h has b e e n said on this that the reader m a y j u d g e for h i m s e l f . T h e s e c o n d p o i n t i s w h e t h e r i t has h i s t o r i c a l l y t u r n e d out that Hamilton's ideas led in any w a y to fruitful developments. E n o u g h w i l l be said on this that the reader m a y j u d g e for himself.
42
Notes 1
A
Collection
Eugene 2
Robert
an
Addendum
Sir
William
Couples; Pure 4
in
Memory
Mathematica
Perceval
a in
Hamilton,
Transactions Rowan
Sir
William
No.
The
Rowan
II).
Life
Hamilton,
(New
of Sir
York,
William
ed.
David
1945).
Rowan
Hamilton,
3
vols,
1882-1891).
Preliminary
William
of
Studies,
Graves,
(Dublin, Rowan
with
Time"
Sir
Papers
(Scripta
Rev.
and 3
of
Smith
"Theory
of Conjugate
Functions,
and Elementary Essay on Algebra as of
the
Royal
Hamilton,
Irish
Lectures
Academy, on
17
(1837),
Quaternions
or
Algebraic
the
Science of
293-422.
(Dublin,
1853).
Three
types of p a g e r e f e r e n c e are used: (10) m e a n s t h e t e n t h p a g e of the preface, x m e a n s the t e n t h page of the table of contents, a n d 10 m e a n s the t e n t h page of the text. 5
Sir W i l l i a m
naries
in
489-495; 461; 31 34
Rowan
Algebra"
Hamilton,
in
"On
Philosophical
26 (1845), 2 2 0 - 2 2 4 ;
29
Quaternions, or on a N e w System of Imagi-
Magazine,
3rd.
Ser.,
(1846), 2 6 - 3 1 ,
(1847), 2 1 4 - 2 1 9 , 2 7 8 - 2 9 3 , 5 1 1 - 5 1 9 ; 32
(1849),
294-297,
340-343,
425-439;
35
25
(1844),
10-13,
241-246,
1 1 3 - 1 2 2 , 3 2 6 - 3 2 8 ; 30 (1847), 4 5 8 (1848), 3 6 7 - 3 7 4 ; 33
(1849),
133-137,
(1848), 5 8 - 6 0 ;
200-204;
36
(1850),
305-306. 6
Erwin
Schrodinger as q u o t e d in " T h e H a m i l t o n Postage Stamp:
ment by the Irish
An Announce-
M i n i s t e r o f Posts a n d T e l e g r a p h s . " (1; 82)
7
J . L . S y n g e , " T h e L i f e a n d E a r l y W o r k o f Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n . " (1;
8
E.
T.
Whittaker,
"The
Hamiltonian
Revival,"
Mathematical
Gazette,
24
17)
(1940),
153-158. 9
Ibid.,
10
154.
E.
T.
Whittaker,
"William
Rowan
Hamilton"
in
Lives
in
Science
(New
York,
1957), 61. 11
E.
12
See for e x a m p l e Whittaker's
13
George D. Birkhoff, "Letter from George D. Birkhoff" included in the papers in
the emy, 14
T.
15
o f Mathematics
Centenary
(1944-1945),
P.
A.
Otto
M. of
Dirac, the
F.
Bell,
alcohol;
York,
Celebration"
"Application Irish
Fischer,
with Men
(New
1937).
"Hamiltonian Revival."
in
Proceedings
of
the
Royal
Irish
Acad-
72-75.
Royal
(Stockholm,
Philosophy 16
Men
"Quaternion 50
Proceedings
cade
Bell,
of Quaternions
Academy, Universal
1951)
Technical
Physical 404.
Five
Lorentz Transformations"
and
it
that
Quaternions,
Structural
(Stockholm, has
Models
A in
writings of Hamilton's contemporaries.
CavalNatural
1957).
Hamilton
overindulged
there is to my k n o w l e d g e no u n a m b i g u o u s , direct e v i d e n c e for this
difficult to interpret; thus
in
261-270.
Hamilton's
Mathematical
Quaternions Tradition
to
(1944-1945),
Mechanics
and
o f Mathematics,
50
in
in the
T h e statements that s e e m relevant are v e r y
Hamilton's chief biographer, R.
P. Graves, both was and
wrote like a Victorian clergyman. It is clear that H a m i l t o n ' s marriage was not h a p p y or was his h o m e life w e l l o r d e r e d , b u t it is far f r o m clear that these factors seriously h i n d e r e d his 17
Whittaker,
18
[Rev.
creativity. "Hamiltonian
Robert
Perceval
Revival," Graves],
158.
"Sir William
Rowan
Hamilton"
in
Dublin
Uni-
43
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis versity
Magazine,
(2,11;
344).
19
19
William
(1842),
Rowan
94.
For
proof that
Hamilton,
Graves
Transactions
of
the
J.
R.
wrote
Royal
the
Irish
above
paper,
Academy,
15
see
(1828),
69-174. 20
Rene
land, 2 1
Dugas,
A
History
o f Mechanics,
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n ,
Systems 22
trans.
Maddox
(Neuchatel,
Switzer-
1955), 400-401.
of
Rays"
Augustus
(1866),
in
De
" T h i r d S u p p l e m e n t to an Essay on the Theory of
Transactions
Morgan,
of
"Sir
the
W.
Royal
R.
Irish
Academy,
Hamilton"
17
in
(1837),
Gentleman's
1-144.
Magazine,
220
133. T o v e r i f y that this u n s i g n e d o b i t u a r y n o t i c e w a s w r i t t e n b y D e M o r g a n ,
s e e (2,111; 2 1 6 - 2 1 7 ) . 23
C. C.
24
(2,1;
Critique 25
MacDuffee, "Algebras 478).
o f Pure
For
further
Reason
see
D e b t t o H a m i l t o n . " (1; 25)
information
(2,1;
545,
concerning
582,
585)
and
Hamilton's
(2,11;
87-88,
reading 96-97,
of Kant's 342).
It should be m e n t i o n e d that at nearly the same time Johann Bolyai developed a
similar representation of c o m p l e x n u m b e r s . B o l y a i w r o t e d o w n his ideas in 1837 b u t did not publish them.
H a m i l t o n p r e s e n t e d his ideas i n 1833 a n d p u b l i s h e d t h e m i n
1837. Paul Stackel refers to Bolyai's d e v e l o p m e n t as inferior to Hamilton's. See Paul Stackel,
Wolfgang
und
(Leipzig
and
Berlin,
130-133,
for
Stackel's
Bolyai, 26
pages
Johann
1913).
223-233,
Bolyai,
See
commentary; for
the
Geometrische
Part
I,
Leben
and
document
Part
Untersuchungen,
und Schriften II,
Stucke
der
aus
Beiden
den
2
pts.
Bolyai,
Schriften
der
pages Beiden
itself.
See, for e x a m p l e , e q u a t i o n s 65, 75, 112, 191, 195, a n d 196 in the s e c o n d section
o f t h e w o r k c i t e d i n n o t e (3) a b o v e , a n d e q u a t i o n s 6 , 5 6 , 5 7 , a n d 5 8 i n t h e t h i r d section. 27
to
(2,11; 5 7 4 ) .
the
major
discovery part
them by
It seems
doubtful that Hamilton's m e t h o d of "polytets" led directly
of quaternions.
in
his
acceptance
indicating the
However
it
of quaternions
is
probable
and
that this
moreover
method played a
s u p p o r t e d his
search
for
possibility and legitimacy of higher complex numbers. That
this is an important point is indicated from the history of ordinary complex numbers, where 28
the
(4;
difficult
[35]).
Hamilton's 29
30
De
Morgan,
Philosophical
This
is
"Linear
was
not
discovery
but
acceptance.
biographer.
Augustus
Cambridge
task
J o h n T. Graves was a mathematician a n d the brother of R. P. Graves,
" O n
the
7,
pt.
Society,
proved
in
Associative
Charles
Foundation
Saunders
Algebra"
in
of A l g e b r a "
in
Transactions
o f the
2. Peirce's
American Journal
addenda
to
o f Mathematics,
Benjamin 4
(1881),
Peirce's 97-229.
T h e above q u o t a t i o n f r o m C. S. Peirce is f r o m page 229. 31
T h u s (i + j)
will be it
is
•
( 2 i -I- 2 j ) = 4 , b u t s o a l s o d o e s ( i + j ) • ( 4 i ) . T h e t e r m " d o t p r o d u c t "
used t h r o u g h o u t w i t h o u t qualification; t h o u g h this is legitimate historically,
questionable
generally
not
mathematically.
The
term
"product"
in
current mathematics
is
used w h e n the entity resulting from the combination (by multiplica-
tion) of t w o factors
is
not a m e m b e r of the
s a m e class as t h e factors, that is, w h e n
closure is not preserved. T h e dot product is n o w classified as a bilinear functional. 32
(i
To s e e t h a t t h e a s s o c i a t i v e p r o p e r t y f a i l s , c o n s i d e r i X (i X j) = i X k = —j, w h e r e a s
x i) x j = 0. To s e e t h a t t h e c o m m u t a t i v e p r o p e r t y f a i l s , c o n s i d e r i X j = k ^ j X i =
-k. 33
T h u s , to s h o w t h a t d i v i s i o n is
34
It is historically interesting, b u t probably not historically significant, that in 1841
Hamilton Royal
Irish
for the
44
delivered Academy,
first
2
time)
a
paper
(1844), that " t h e
"On
n o t u n a m b i g u o u s , c o n s i d e r i X (i + j) = i X j = k.
the
166-168.
In
Composition this
paper
resultant force coincides
of F o r c e s " Hamilton
in
Proceedings o f the
p r o v e d (he claimed
i n direction w i t h t h e d i a g o n a l o f
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n a n d Q u a t e r n i o n s
the rectangle
constructed with
lines
r e p r e s e n t i n g x a n d y a s s i d e s . " {Ibid.,
168.)
He
said that the previous (Laplace) proof of the parallogram of forces t h e o r e m h a d dealt only with the magnitude 35
of the resultant force.
The main primary documents
of his
discovery written
ceedings next
of
day
Magazine, his
the
Royal
Irish
(October
3rd
on
25
the
1843)
to
The
C. C. MacDuffee, "Algebra's in
36
in
Proceedings
(2,11; 4 3 9 - 4 4 0 ) .
quaternion may
v
polarized,
v
Morgan's
bridge
-I-
OF
(2)
printed
(only)
Hamilton's
9th
mainly
discussions
ed.,
Sequence
Royal
Irish
kz,
"xyz
vol.
of Ideas
Academy,
may
of s o m e
unpolarized.
38
paper
Philosophical See
(4;
Proceedings
50
.
.
.
such
The
as
preface are
to (1)
160-164;
Discovery
he
(3)
of Quater-
93-98.
wrote in regard to the
direction
of
the
(2) P e t e r G u t h r i e T a i t , (1890),
and
electricity,
Calculus
of
Philosophical
point
(1944-1945),
determine
agent
the
historical
the
Thus
letter
in
of this
XX in
His
x,
intensity; y,
z
Quaternions
while
are
may
t;
electrically turn
out
P O L A R I T I E S . " (2,11; 4 3 9 - 4 4 0 )
[38]).
of
was
8,
Royal
the
in
pt.
Charles
the
with
written
Society,
1844
and
published
in
Transactions
o f the
Cam-
3.
Graves'
Irish
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n
nected 2
(3)
89-92.
S e e t h e a b s t r a c t o f D e M o r g a n ' s " M e m o i r o n T r i p l e A l g e b r a " i n (2,111; 2 5 1 - 2 5 3 ) .
De
3 9
Graves
historical
Britannica,
"The
quantity
to be a C A L C U L U S 3 7
T.
D e b t t o H a m i l t o n " (1; 2 5 - 3 5 ) ;
the
4- jy
the
electrically
John
T h e s e are vague g l i m m e r i n g s .
+ jx
determine
of
d i s c o v e r y . T h i s i s p r i n t e d ( o n l y ) i n Pro-
(1944-1945),
main
Encyclopaedia
E d m u n d Taylor Whittaker, nions"
of the
50
(1844), 490-495.
Quaternions.
"Quaternions"
d e a l i n g w i t h t h i s p o i n t a r e (1) t h e s h o r t s u m m a r y
day
Academy,
17,
Ser.,
Lectures
on
"On
Academy,
Algebraic Triplets"
3
(1847),
51-54,
was
57-64,
published 80-84,
in
the
105-108.
Hamilton, " O n a N e w Species of Imaginary Quantities Con-
Theory
of
Quaternions"
in
Proceedings
o f the
Royal
Irish
Academy,
(1844), 4 2 4 - 4 3 4 . 40
Sir
Irish 41
Sir
Irish 42
4 3
3
then
44
a
"On
Quaternions"
in
Proceedings
o f the
Royal
"On
Quaternions"
in
Proceedings
o f the
Royal
1-16.
Hamilton, 3.
-
a n d a ' = ( x ' i -I- y ' j -I- z ' k ) a r e t w o v e c t o r s
a' = xx' -1- yy' +
zz'
and
a X
a' = i(yz'
in t h e m o d -
— zy') -I- j(zx'
— xz') +
yx').
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n Proceedings
in
Rowan (1847),
i f a = ( x i + y j + zk)
sense, -
Hamilton,
(1845-1847),
William
Thus
k(xy'
Rowan
3
Academy,
ern
in
William
Academy,
of
the
Hamilton,
Royal
Irish
" O n Q u a t e r n i o n s " ( c o m m u n i c a t e d July 20,
Academy,
3
(1847),
273-292,
and
(5,31;
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n , "Researches respecting Quaternions. Transactions
of
the
Royal
Irish
for July
7,
45
In
46
In a later part of this
t h e Athenaeum,
Academy, 1847,
21
as
(1848),
quoted
in
1846)
278-293).
First Series"
199-296. (2,11;
587).
w o r k a detailed statistical study is g i v e n on the n u m b e r of
papers published, per five-year period, on quaternions. 47
This
is extracted from the summary of the seventh lecture as given in the con-
tents (4; xxxvi). 48
(2,11; 6 8 3 ) .
4 9
U n s i g n e d article, " R e v i e w of Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n ' s
ternions" ing the matics
in
North
American
authorship to and
Ginsburg
state
Review,
Hill
Mathematicians
Jekuthiel 1934)
De M o r g a n m a d e a very similar statement.
is
(New in
that T h o m a s
A Hill
85
(1857),
Ibid.,
223.
51
Ibid.,
228.
My
Lectures on Qua-
evidence
for
attribut-
t h a t t h i s i s d o n e i n R o b e r t E d o u a r d M o r i t z , O n MatheYork, History
1958), of
279.
Mathematics
(1818-1891)
was an early advocate of quaternions). 50
223-237.
(2,11; 6 8 3 ) .
was
in
David America
Eugene before
Smith
1900
a student of Benjamin
and
(Chicago,
Peirce
(who
H i l l b e c a m e p r e s i d e n t of H a r v a r d in 1862.
45
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis 52
Ibid.,
226.
53
Ibid.,
229.
54
Sir
Physical
William Sciences,
Rowan
2nd
ed.
55
Ibid.,
726.
56
See
Benjamin
Hamilton, (London
Peirce,
"Quaternions"
and
A
Glasgow,
System
of
in
Nichol,
1860),
Analytical
Cyclopaedia
of
the
706-726.
Mechanics
(New
York,
1872),
in
The
Mathematical
Papers
L.
Synge
476-477. 57
De
58
Charles
of
Sir
Volson
William
England,
Wood,
Graves, Hamilton,
"Quaternions" "Eloge"
vol.
Alexandre
Allegret,
60
Hermann
Hankel,
B1
Giusto
Scienze,
(1862), 62
e
W.
(1880),
33.
Hamilton
Conway
ed
Arti
Fisica
Essai
sur
Theorie
le der
calcul
delle
(1858), della
des
and
quaternions
complexen
" D e l Calcolo dei
metodo
William
Though
my
rough
in
Rowan
the 64
Sir
terms
estimate
figure includes in
J.
(Paris,
Zahlensysteme
(Cambridge,
334-342,
and
Italiana
in
Atti
same
delle
del
7
+
72
pp.
1867),
196.
H a m i l t o n e delle sue Reale
author
Scienze
1862),
(Leipzig,
quaternioni di W. R.
equipollenze"
Societd
Hamilton,
the
of pages
the
453,740
words
Istituto
and
title,
(Modena),
2nd
Veneto
di
Memorie
di
Ser.,
1
Elements
o f Quaternions
(London,
1866),
59
+
long
preface
B5
two
in
books are comparable,
as the
compared Lectures,
to
t h e Elements c o n t a i n s
3 0 4 , 0 0 0 f o r t h e Lectures. T h i s
for w h i c h
there
is
vol.
II,
no
counterpart
Elements. William
Rowan
Hamilton,
Charles Jasper Joly (London,
46
7
pp.
63
by
A.
Analyst,
William
126-186.
Sir
762
Bellavitis, col
Lettere
Matematica
ed.
in
Sir
1931), xiii. T h e e l o g e w a s g i v e n b e f o r e t h e R o y a l I r i s h A c a d e m y i n 1865.
5H
relazioni
I,
on
C. G r a v e s , " E l o g e , " xv.
Elements
1901), 350.
o f Quaternions,
2nd
ed.,
ed.
CHAPTER
Other Systems,
I.
THREE
Early
Vectorial
Especially
Grassmann's
Theory
of Extension
Introduction Hamilton and those w h o w o r k e d w i t h ordinary complex numbers
were not the
only mathematicians
for vectorial systems. tries
were
developing systems
character.
These
Bellavitis,
Hermann
of the time
w h o were searching
I n d e e d , a t least six o t h e r m e n f r o m f o u r c o u n -
men
were
that were August
Giinther
more
o r less v e c t o r i a l i n
Ferdinand
Grassmann,
Mobius,
Adhemar
Barre
Giusto (better
k n o w n as Comte de Saint-Venant), Augustin Cauchy, and Reverend Matthew
O'Brien.
By
far t h e
most
important
of these m e n for the
present study is Grassmann, w h o s e first publication of his system, his
Ausdehnungslehre,
came
in
published his first paper on It should be
1844,
remarked that the
history of vector analysis
is
the
year
in
which
Hamilton
quaternions. significance of these m e n in the
different from that of H a m i l t o n ,
for it
w a s o n l y t h e i d e a s o f H a m i l t o n (as w i l l b e s h o w n ) t h a t h a d a m a j o r influence on the development of the m o d e r n system of vector analysis. T h e f a c t t h a t t h e s e m e n h a d l i t t l e o r n o d i r e c t i n f l u e n c e o n s u b sequent
developments
question,
"Why
vector
should
raises these
the
men
important
be
included
methodological in
the
history
of
analysis?"
To this question at least t w o replies m a y be given. First, the ideas o f these m e n are m a n d attention.
of such
great originality a n d m e r i t that they de-
It could in
fact b e
a r g u e d that Grassmann's crea-
tion surpasses that of H a m i l t o n in p r o f u n d i t y a n d perfection. W h i l e this
reason
reason
for
seems
guished from
their even
inclusion more
is
certainly
decisive.
important,
Chronology
may
a
second
be
distin-
history in that whereas the former presents events in
47
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
isolation,
the
latter aims
at
delineating the "trends of the times"
a n d the causes for events. C o i n c i d e n c e is certainly not the explanat i o n for t h e fact t h a t m o r e t h a n t e n m e n i n six c o u n t r i e s , w o r k i n g i n the period from the
1790's to the 1850's, sought to create vectorial
systems. T h o u g h f e w of these m e n k n e w of the ideas of any of the others, nonetheless some factors in the mathematics a n d physics of this
p e r i o d m u s t have m o t i v a t e d their search. T h u s the discussion
of these m e n w i l l be aimed at describing the form of the trend of w h i c h t h e y w e r e part a n d at s e e k i n g out the causes that l e d to their investigations
a n d results.
II.
Ferdinand
August Though he
decisely nand
Mobius
and
His
Barycentric
Calculus
neither constructed an original vectorial
influenced
Mobius
anyone
holds an
who
did,
system nor
nevertheless August Ferdi-
important position
in the history of vector
analysis for a n u m b e r of reasons. T h e c h i e f of these is that M o b i u s constructed
a
mathematical
system
(his
barycentric
calculus)
w h i c h is in m a n y ways similar to vectorial systems. In his system of space
analysis,
were
dealt
Mobius'
geometrical
with
entities
directly
and
positioned points, w i t h
(as
(points he
which
rather
hoped)
than
vectors)
advantageously.
numerical magnitudes
are
usually associated, are a d d e d in such a w a y that b o t h position a n d m a g n i t u d e are method
his
more his was
included in the addition.
system
has
Thus both in aim and in
k i n s h i p w i t h vectorial systems.10 Further-
system as later i n d e p e n d e n t l y discovered by Grassmann
put f o w a r d by Grassmann as an integral part of a system that
included
vectors.
Mobius
also
carried
on
an
important
corre-
s p o n d e n c e w i t h G r a s s m a n n ( w h i c h w i l l b e discussed later), a n d i n his later years M o b i u s d i d some w o r k directly in the vectorial tradition
(although
lifetime).
only
Thus
the
n u m b e r of points
a
small part of this was p u b l i s h e d d u r i n g his
work
of Mobius
admits
to
discussion from a
of view.
August F e r d i n a n d M o b i u s (1790-1868) was born in Schulpforta, e d u c a t e d at L e i p z i g , G o t t i n g e n , a n d Halle, a n d began his teaching career in
1815 at L e i p z i g University, b e c o m i n g ordinary professor
of mechanics and astronomy in death.
He
chanics, The
made
most
Behandlung
48
1844, a position he h e l d until his
contributions
to
mathematics,
me-
and astronomy.11 significant
barycentrische
Bildung
important
Calcul, der neuer
work ein
Mobius
neues
Geometrie Classen
by
dargestellt von
Aufgaben
for this
Hiilfsmittel und
study zur
insbesondere und
die
is
h i s Der
analytischen auf
die
Entwickelung
Other Early Vectorial
mehrerer
Eigenschaften
in
Herein
1827.
points.
Mobius
and by
1821
der
Kegelschnitte,
Mobius came
he
gave
upon
had
a
the
decided
published
full
exposition
first n o t i o n s to
publish
Systems
at
Leipzig
of his
calculus
of his system in
them
in
of
1818,
form.12
book
In
1823 he p u b l i s h e d his first discussion of his n e w m e t h o d as a short Appendix
to
Sternwarte
his
An idea of the following trische
nature
auf
der
Koniglichen
Mobius
In
pointed
the
out
foreword
that
the
center of gravity, or centroid (Schwerpunkt), since (2;
Archimedes'
iii)
Universitats-
of Mobius' system may be gained from the
exposition.14
brief
Calcul
Beobachtungen
Leipzig.13
zu
time
for
the
discovery
to
his
Der
barycen-
physical
concept
had been
useful ever
of
geometric
of
truths.
He w e n t on to state:
T h e p r e s e n t researches also p r o c e e d f r o m t h e same e l e m e n t a r y a n d purely geometrical concept of the center of gravity. W h a t first stimulated these researches
was
consideration of the fruitfulness of the law, that
e a c h s y s t e m o f w e i g h t e d p o i n t s has o n l y o n e c e n t e r o f g r a v i t y , a n d t h a t thus, in whatever sequence one brings the points into connection, the result is that one a n d the same point must always be found. T h e simple technique,
by means
of w h i c h I
was
able to prove more geometrical
laws, stimulated me to find a suitable algorithm for still greater simplif i c a t i o n o f s u c h i n v e s t i g a t i o n s . (2; iv) E a r l y in his first c h a p t e r M o b i u s stated that in his s y s t e m a l i n e segment
from
a
point
A
to
whereas a line from B then
a
point
B
would
be
designated
indicated h o w collinear segments were to be added.
Mobius
extended
by A B ,
t o A w o u l d b e d e s i g n a t e d b y BA, o r — A B . H e
this
sign
principle
to
and
(2;
3-5)
constructed addition
laws for figures d e t e r m i n e d by m o r e than t w o points, for e x a m p l e , to
triangles
(ABC)
and
pyramids
(ABCD).
(2;
20-23)
It
is
surprising
that M o b i u s n o w h e r e in this w o r k presented addition laws for noncollinear segments a n d also that he p r o c e e d e d f r o m such equations as
BDE
+
BEC
+
BCD
=
0
to
ABDE
+
ABEC
+
ABCD
=
0
(2;
24)
without v i e w i n g this as a multiplication by A, as Grassmann was to do
later. T h e central theorem
in his
book was the following:
G i v e n a n y n u m b e r (v) o f p o i n t s A , B , C , . . . N w i t h c o e f f i c i e n t s a , b , c, . . . n w h e r e t h e s u m of t h e coefficients does not e q u a l zero, t h e r e can always be f o u n d one (and only one) point S —the centroid — w h i c h point has t h e p r o p e r t y that i f o n e d r a w s p a r a l l e l l i n e s ( p o i n t i n g i n a n y d i r e c tion) through the given points and the point S, and if these lines inters e c t s o m e p l a n e i n t h e p o i n t s A ' , B ' , C \ . . . A T , S', t h e n o n e a l w a y s h a s : a.AA' + b.BB' + c.CC' +
.
.
. + n.NN' = (a + b + c +
.
.
. + n)SS\
a n d c o n s e q u e n t l y , if t h e p l a n e goes t h r o u g h S itself, t h e n a.AA'
+
b.BB'
+
c.CC'
+
...
+
n.NN'
=
0.
(2;
9-10)
49
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
He A,
later
stated
B, . . . ,
that
and
fo.B + c . C + .
.
in
place
hence
the
of
AA',
above
.+ n . N = ( a + fo + c + .
BB', . . . h e
expression .
would
becomes
write a. A
. + n)S. T h u s M o b i u s dealt
w i t h w e i g h t e d points or points w i t h numerical coefficients (positive or negative) w h i c h w e r e a d d e d as p o i n t masses are a d d e d in comp u t i n g t h e center of gravity of a b o d y . On such a basis M o b i u s proceeded
to
his
discovery
of h o m o g e n e o u s
n e w t r e a t m e n t of m a n y parts Mobius' ceived, Gauss
highly
with
and to a
and
well-presented
Jacobi,
Dirichlet,
work
was
Steiner,
well
Pliicker,
reand
t a k i n g s o m e i n t e r e s t i n it.16 H o w e v e r h i s m e t h o d s n e v e r
all
attained
original
Cauchy,
15
coordinates
of geometry.
widespread
use,
and
no
second edition
of the
w o r k ap-
peared (except for the republication of the w o r k in 1885 in the first volume
of his
collected works).
Mobius
did however continue to
p u b l i s h papers on this subject t h r o u g h o u t his life. In
1843
ing
Mobius
noncollinear
Himmels.17
In
ducing
this
a
Reinhardt but
23,
vectors
letter
concept
implied
Reinhardt
June
p u b l i s h e d t h e m e t h o d for a d d i n g a n d subtract-
also
1835,
in
Baltzer
in
his
that
that
letter to
cussion mann
of this
Die
Elemente
had
lectures
showed
Mobius
he
Mobius
stated
in
the
the
this
method
was
Mechanik
he
winter
discovered
that
der
that
was
des
intro-
of 1841-1842.
method
himself,
presented
in a
M o b i u s f r o m Bellavitis ( w h o w i l l be dis-
cussed in the next section). 1840's
his
to
came
( 1 , I V ; 7 1 7 - 7 1 8 ) I t w a s also i n t h e early into
contact
relationship will
with
best be
Grassmann;
the
dis-
p o s t p o n e d to the Grass-
sections.
The
final
w o r k by M o b i u s that demands attention is his " U e b e r
geometrische
Addition
und
Multiplication,"
written
in
1862
and
revised in 1865, b u t p u b l i s h e d only in 1887 in the fourth v o l u m e of his collected works. (1,IV; 659-697) This w o r k was mainly derived from
Grassmann's
work as
work,
published in
with
changes
in
notation.
Though
the
1887 c o u l d have had some influence on the
history of vector analysis, such influence is unlikely. Nevertheless his treatment is of interest, since it represents M o b i u s ' final judgm e n t as to w h a t form of vector analysis is most useful. After
the
presented tors AB
usual
his
discussion
"geometrische
of the
addition
Multiplication,"
a n d CD was represented by AB
of vectors, which
Mobius
for t w o vec-
• C D . T h i s product was to
be n u m e r i c a l l y equal to the area of the parallelogram, or twice the area of the triangle, d e t e r m i n e d by these t w o vectors. T h e product of the
multiplication
was
the
parallelogram
or triangle
itself and
was considered to be an entity that could assume any position in space p r o v i d e d that it always r e m a i n e d parallel to the plane of AB
50
Other Early Vectorial
and
CD.
The
usual
sign
conventions
were
used.
(1,IV;
Systems
663-665)
This definition is similar but not identical to the modern definition o f t h e v e c t o r (cross) p r o d u c t , s i n c e i n M o b i u s ' g e o m e t r i c a l m u l t i p l i cation the
product is
a plane
figure,
not another vector. T h e t w o
products are of course e q u a l n u m e r i c a l l y . It
may
be
noted
mutually parallel and
similarly
that
any vector uniquely
planes
any
(the planes
plane
figure
determines
a
set of
perpendicular to that vector)
determines
a vector
(or
a
set
of
mutually parallel vectors) perpendicular to that plane figure. T h u s the
two
products
are
similar but
not identical
(the
two
products
w i l l b e c o m p a r e d i n m o r e detail later). M o b i u s was w e l l a w a r e o f these t w o points of v i e w ; indeed, in treating the a d d i t i o n of plane figures he
s h o w e d that this addition c o u l d be represented by the
addition of vectors
perpendicular to those figures if the lengths of
t h e vectors are e q u a l t o t h e areas o f t h e p l a n e f i g u r e s . ( 1 , I V ; 6 7 1 673) M o b i u s t h e n p r o c e e d e d to the geometrical p r o d u c t of a vector and a parallelogram, and concluded that the
figure
produced was
the parallelepiped d e t e r m i n e d by the vector a n d t w o adjacent sides of the parallelogram. (1,IV; 673 ff) This was f o l l o w e d by his definition of the projective product of t w o vectors, w h i c h was s y m b o l i z e d by AB
•
CD a n d is e q u i v a l e n t to m o d e r n scalar (dot) p r o d u c t . (1,IV;
678 ff) T h e next section treated the relation b e t w e e n the geometric and projective products of vectors in a plane. H e r e i n M o b i u s began by considering four coplanar vectors, u, v, a, a', w h o s e positions w e r e only
limited by
perpendicular.
the He
restriction
then
gave
that u
the
and v
equation
w e r e to be mutually
au
•
a'v 4 - a v
•
a'u = 0 ,
w h i c h equation he attempted to prove. It is clear that the left-hand m e m b e r of this
equation
represents
a number,
but it
seems
that
M o b i u s n e v e r d e f i n e d t h e p r o d u c t o f t w o areas; h e n c e t h e i n t e r p r e tation
of the
right-hand
m e m b e r of the
equation
is
by
no means
clear. (1,IV; 6 8 2 - 6 8 3 ) In fact, M o b i u s at a n u m b e r of points in this m a n u s c r i p t f a i l e d e i t h e r to d e v e l o p a suitable s y m b o l i s m or to see that
a
given
expression
veloping the projective
ambiguous.18
was
He
concluded
by
de-
multiplication of solid figures. (1,IV; 6 8 5 -
697) T h o u g h Grassmann was never mentioned, it is clear that M o b i u s ' treatment was
m a i n l y d e r i v e d f r o m G r a s s m a n n ' s efforts.
Hamilton
i s l i k e w i s e n o t m e n t i o n e d , a l t h o u g h M o b i u s h a d k n o w n o f his system
since
casionally analysis.
at
least
dealt
1859.19
with
It
is
matters
noteworthy that M o b i u s relevant
to
his
system
o n l y ocof
point
In general his treatment is almost completely lacking in
comments that allow one to j u d g e h o w M o b i u s h i m s e l f v i e w e d his
51
A
History
o w n
of V e c t o r Analysis
work;
system
eventually the two sions
came
were
Giusto the time
example,
to
Bellavitis,
in
is
viewed clear
it
appreciate when
of the modern
and
an
the
some
which
as
the
that
a
Mobius
significance
of
limited to three-dimen-
dot a n d cross
His
presenting
however
understand and
Calculus
of
products.
Equipollences
Italian mathematician born in
of his death in
but in
he
It
products,
Bellavitis
senator
interests
for
Hamilton's.
precursors
Giusto
a
to
Grassmann
III.
and
whether,
superior
1803, was at
1880 a professor at the University of Padua
Kingdom cases
of Italy.20
He
was
a
man
of broad
of narrow view, whose fame in general
and relevance for the present study derives from the creation of his calculus of equipollences. W h a t this is m a y be understood from the f o l l o w i n g section of a paper (1835) w h i c h contained his earliest full explanation 4.
l.°
of this
method.
A straight l i n e (retta) expressed as usual by t w o letters is u n d e r stood as taken f r o m the first letter to the second, so that AB a n d BA s h o u l d not be regarded as the same entity, b u t as t w o equal q u a n t i t i e s h a v i n g o p p o s i t e signs.
2.° T w o
straight lines
are
c a l l e d equipollent i f t h e y a r e e q u a l , p a r a l l e l
a n d d i r e c t e d i n the same sense. 3.° I f t w o
or more
straight lines
are
related in such a w a y that the
second extremity of each line coincides w i t h the first extremity of the
following, then the
line w h i c h together w i t h these forms a
polygon (regular or irregular), and w h i c h is drawn from the first extremity
of
the
last
line,
is
called
their
equipollent-sum
(com-
posta-equipollente). T h i s is r e p r e s e n t e d by the signs 4- interposed b e t w e e n the lines to be combined, and w i t h the sign
indicating
the equipollence. Thus we have AB AB
+
BC
+ BC +
±
CD
AC, ±
AD,
etc.
Such e q u i p o l l e n c e s c o n t i n u e to h o l d w h e n one substitutes for the lines
in
t h e m , o t h e r lines w h i c h are r e s p e c t i v e l y e q u i p o l l e n t t o
t h e m , h o w e v e r t h e y m a y b e s i t u a t e d i n space. F r o m this i t can b e understood
how
any
summed,
that
in
and
number
whatever
and order
any
kind
these
of
lines
lines are
may
taken,
be the
s a m e e q u i p o l l e n t - s u m w i l l be o b t a i n e d . . . . 5.° I n e q u i p o l l e n c e s , j u s t a s i n e q u a t i o n s , a l i n e m a y b e t r a n s f e r r e d f r o m o n e side to t h e other, p r o v i d e d that t h e sign is changed. . . . 6.° T h e e q u i p o l l e n c e AB
n. C D , w h e r e n stands for a positive n u m -
b e r , i n d i c a t e s t h a t AB is b o t h p a r a l l e l to a n d has t h e s a m e d i r e c t i o n a s CD, a n d t h a t t h e i r l e n g t h s h a v e t h e r e l a t i o n e x p r e s s e d b y the
equation
AB
=
n.CD.
5. L e t us restrict ourselves n o w to lines situated in the same plane. T h e inclination
52
of the
l i n e AB
i s t h e a n g l e HAB, w h i c h t h i s
line forms with
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
the horizontal AH d r a w n from left to right, w i t h the qualification that positive angles are m e a s u r e d f r o m t h e r i g h t u p w a r d s , a n d f r o m 0° to 360° 2.° T h e a n g l e o r i n c l i n a t i o n o f C D o n A B i s e q u a l t o t h e i n c l i n a t i o n o f CD
minus
3.° T h e
that
o f AB.
equipollence C D ^ F A b
GH
r e q u i r e s n o t o n l y t h a t t h e l e n g t h s A B , CD, e t c . , s h o u l d b e s u c h a s to satisfy the e q u a t i o n into w h i c h t h e e q u i p o l l e n c e is c h a n g e d by c o n v e r t i n g the e q u i p o l l e n c e sign i n t o a n e q u a l sign, b u t also that i n c . AB = i n c .
CD + i n c .
EF — i n c .
GH . . . .
T h e l i n e e q u i p o l l e n t to 1 is c o n s i d e r e d as h o r i z o n t a l , t h a t is, as h a v i n g no i n c l i n a t i o n . . . . 6.
Fundamental
Theorem.
In
equipollences,
terms
are
transposed,
sub-
stituted, a d d e d , subtracted, m u l t i p l i e d , d i v i d e d , etc., i n short, all t h e algebraic o p e r a t i o n s are p e r f o r m e d w h i c h w o u l d b e l e g i t i m a t e i f o n e were
dealing
with
equations,
and
the
resulting
equipollences
are
a l w a y s exact. A s w a s s a i d i n 5.°, n o n - l i n e a r e q u i p o l l e n c e s c a n o n l y b e referred to figures in a single plane.21
T h e first point to be m a d e concerning this passage is that Bellavitis
herein
described
equivalent
in
represented.
geometrical
behavior Numerous
to
It
that
are
numbers
mathematicians,
equivalence.22
recognized this
entities
complex
should
as
in
all
ways
geometrically
including
however be
Bellavitis,
stressed that
Bellavitis d i d not v i e w his system as based on the c o m p l e x n u m b e r system; inary
indeed,
numbers
essentially
throughout his entire life he was o p p o s e d to imag-
as
algebraic entities.23 T h u s he v i e w e d his
geometrical
entities,
rather
than
as
lines as
geometrical
repre-
sentations. O n e major significance of Bellavitis is that in his papers a n d book on
equipollences
applications
he
gave n u m e r o u s , a n d i n m a n y cases i n g e n i o u s ,
of his m e t h o d to mathematical and physical problems,
so that in a l i m i t e d sense he was a rival of Grassmann a n d H a m i l ton.
Bellavitis' chief follower was
Charles
Ange
Laisant, w h o
dur-
i n g the last q u a r t e r o f t h e n i n e t e e n t h c e n t u r y d e v o t e d m u c h e n e r g y to
making the
system
known
in
France.
It
that Bellavitis, as the founder of a vectorial ferent viewed
at
least
as
tendency
to
in
another
spirit
from
other
representative
construct
vectorial
systems of the
systems.
is
of the
early It
also
of significance
system w h i c h was dif-
is
times,
may
be
nineteenth-century interesting
in
this
regard to note that Bellavitis m a d e a long, unsuccessful attempt to extend his system to three-dimensional
space.
(3;
158-159)
53
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
Bellavitis came to his system in connection w i t h attempts to give a g e o m e t r i c a l justification for c o m p l e x n u m b e r s . T h u s he stated: " I t was
while
considering
a
geometrical
representation of imaginary
n u m b e r s p r o p o s e d b y B u e e that t h e r e c a m e t o m e (in 1832) the f i r s t idea of the
m e t h o d of equipollences, b u t t h e n I thought that geo-
m e t r i c a l truths c o u l d not rest on the t h e o r y of i m a g i n a r y n u m b e r s , w h i c h entities I h a d for some years o p p o s e d as u n w o r t h y of belonging to
a science
based on
alone."24
reason
Bellavitis
h a d in fact
p u b l i s h e d articles attacking the views of various mathematicians on i m a g i n a r i e s . (3; 159, 163) H i s f i r s t p u b l i c a t i o n (1832) r e l a t i n g t o his m e t h o d , b u t not containing it in a fully d e v e l o p e d form, contained a m e t h o d of deriving properties of points in a plane from the properties of points in a straight line (for e x a m p l e , he d e d u c e d the Pythagorean t h e o r e m by means of this method).25 In this paper he d i d not use
the
orally A
term
"equipollence," but he seems to have used it in an
presented
communication
second publication
which
appeared
of 1832 in
1833,27
at the
Ateneo Veneto.26
a n d a t h i r d in
1835, in
B e l l a v i t i s u s e d t h e t e r m " e q u i p o l l e n c e " a n d gave a f u l l ex-
position of his system.28 T h e l o n g quotation g i v e n at the b e g i n n i n g of this section was taken from that paper.
IV.
Hermann
Grassmann
and
His
Calculus
of
Extension:
Introduction H e r m a n n G r a s s m a n n was a b r i l l i a n t m a t h e m a t i c i a n , w h o s e creations in vectorial analysis can only be c o m p a r e d to those of Hamilton. It w i l l be s h o w n that his system c o u l d have led to m o d e r n vector analysis, b u t it d i d not.
T h e reasons for a n d the nature of this
failure w i l l be traced. Grassmann presented his system in a n u m b e r of different forms; i n fact h e w r o t e four w o r k s i n w h i c h his system was presented, a n d these
four
differ
substantially
among themselves,
two of Grassmann's most important followers
and
moreover,
(Schlegel and Hyde)
chose a fifth f o r m for their presentation of his system. T h e part of his system that is e n c o u n t e r e d in some mathematics books of today is a small a n d by no m e a n s characteristic part. Because of these c i r c u m stances fully.
a
n u m b e r of Grassmann's
works w i l l be discussed rather
M a n y details concerning Grassmann's life and the reception
accorded his writings have b e e n i n c l u d e d in the hope that they may m a k e clear b o t h h o w a n d w h y his system failed to m a k e as significant an impression on the times as it m i g h t have. What
G r a s s m a n n created was above all a mathematical
not just a n e w mathematical idea or theorem.
54
system,
H i s creative act can-
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
not be compared w i t h such mathematical discoveries as the Pythagorean
theorem
or
Newton's
version
of the
calculus.
Rather it is
best thought of as comparable to such creations as n o n - E u c l i d e a n geometry or Boolean algebra.
Thus
it was natural that Grassmann
chose to introduce his system, not by means of a paper, b u t rather by means of a long and complicated book. Grassmann's system is so b r o a d a n d so general that there are serious difficulties in t r y i n g to s u m m a r i z e it; n e v e r t h e l e s s a s u m m a r y is necessary for t h e p r e s e n t purposes. T h e m a i n stress h o w e v e r w i l l b e p l a c e d o n t h e d i s c u s s i o n of such
ideas
as
Grassmann's
form
of the
scalar (dot)
and vector
(cross) p r o d u c t s , w h i c h h a v e c o u n t e r p a r t s i n m o d e r n v e c t o r a n a l y sis. Hermann
GiAnther
Grassmann
(1809-1877)
was
born and lived
the m a j o r i t y of his life in Stettin (or Szczecin), a t o w n in P o m e r a n i a on the O d e r River a short distance inland from the Baltic.
He was
the third of the t w e l v e c h i l d r e n b o r n to Justus Giinther Grassmann (1779-1852), who, though trained mainly in theology, taught mathematics
and
physical
science
at
the
Gymnasium.29
Stettin
Grass-
m a n n , u n l i k e H a m i l t o n , w a s n o p r o d i g y ; i n fact, q u i t e t h e opposite. Grassmann's
father,
it
is
said,
often
remarked
that he
h a p p y if H e r m a n n b e c a m e a g a r d e n e r or a craftsman. In ing
w o u l d be
(5; 9)
1827 Grassmann e n t e r e d the U n i v e r s i t y of Berlin, w h e r e durhis
six
semesters
he
mainly
studied philology
and theology,
being especially influenced by the Church historian Neander and Schliermacher;
he
attended
no
mathematical
lectures, though he
d i d read some m a t h e m a t i c a l textbooks w r i t t e n b y his father.30 After leaving Berlin, Grassmann returned to Stettin and pursued studies in
mathematics,
physics, natural history, theology, and philology,
preparing himself for the
state e x a m i n a t i o n s r e q u i r e d for teachers
of these subjects. In 1834 he accepted a position at a B e r l i n technical school, a position just vacated to take Grassmann
stayed
w h i c h the great geometer Jacob Steiner h a d
a position at the U n i v e r s i t y of Berlin.
in
(5; 45)
B e r l i n for slightly m o r e than a year, d u r i n g
w h i c h time he seems to have had little contact w i t h Steiner. At the b e g i n n i n g of 1836 he returned to Stettin a n d spent the r e m a i n d e r of his life t e a c h i n g t h e r e i n v a r i o u s schools, i n all cases b e l o w t h e u n i versity
level
despite
his
constant
attempts
to
attain
a university
post. In
order to
improve
his
standing
as
a
teacher
of science
and
mathematics, Grassmann in 1839 w r o t e the B e r l i n scientific examination committee that he w o u l d like to write a w o r k to prove his competence. entitled
Thus
Theorie
der
Grassmann began work on Ebbe
und
Flut31
He
a study of the tides
completed
his
study
in
55
A
History
1840,
of V e c t o r
and
ceived
it
the on
Analysis
chief reader of the
April
26,
1840.
essay,
Carl
L u d w i g
Conrad,
re-
T h e essay was of considerable length
(over t w o h u n d r e d pages as printed in Grassmann's works) and was not carefully read by C o n r a d , for he h a d r e t u r n e d it by M a y 1, 1840, the
day
of Grassmann's examination.
T h u s it is not surprising that
C o n r a d failed to see the i m p o r t a n c e of the work.32 Yet Grassmann's Theorie
der
Ebbe
presentation
Information from
a
letter
cerning
a
und
Flut
is
important,
of a system of spatial concerning written
paper
by
the
origin
Grassmann
published
by
for
analysis
the
it
of this in
contained
work
1847 to
latter
t h e first
based on vectors.
in
may
be
gained
Saint-Venant con-
1845,
in
which
Saint-
V e n a n t c o m m u n i c a t e d results identical to results discovered earlier b y G r a s s m a n n (this p a p e r w i l l b e t r e a t e d later). mann
In this letter Grass-
wrote:
As I was reading the extract f r o m your paper on the geometric sum and difference, the
which
marvelous
was
p u b l i s h e d in the
similarity
between
your
Comptes rendus, results
and
I
was struck by
those
discoveries
w h i c h I m a d e e v e n as e a r l y as 1 8 3 2 . . . . I c o n c e i v e d t h e first i d e a o f t h e g e o m e t r i c s u m a n d d i f f e r e n c e o f t w o o r m o r e lines a n d also o f t h e g e o m e t r i c p r o d u c t o f t w o o r t h r e e lines i n that y e a r (1832). T h i s i d e a i s i n a l l w a y s i d e n t i c a l t o t h a t p r e s e n t e d i n t h e extract f r o m y o u r paper. B u t since I was for a l o n g t i m e o c c u p i e d w i t h entirely different pursuits, I c o u l d not d e v e l o p this idea. It was o n l y in 1839 that I was lead back to that idea a n d p u r s u e d this geometrical analysis up to the p o i n t w h e r e it ought to be applicable to all mechanics. It was possible for me to a p p l y this
m e t h o d of analysis to the theory of tides,
a n d in this I was astounded by the simplicity of the calculations resulting f r o m t h i s m e t h o d . (5; 4 2 - 4 3 ) Thus
in
ideas theory. 1832
1832
which
Grassmann were
attained
developed
Grassmann explained in
and
dehnungslehre
indicated of
the
1844.33
source
in
the the
first work
ideas
for
his
(1839-1840)
system, on
tidal
greater detail w h a t he had f o u n d in thereof in the
Grassmann
foreword to
h i s Aus-
wrote:
T h e first i m p u l s e c a m e f r o m t h e c o n s i d e r a t i o n o f negatives i n g e o m e try;
I
was a c c u s t o m e d to v i e w i n g t h e distances AB a n d BA as o p p o s i t e
m a g n i t u d e s . A r i s i n g f r o m this i d e a was t h e c o n c l u s i o n that if A, B, C are p o i n t s o f a s t r a i g h t l i n e , t h e n i n a l l cases A B + B C = A C , t h i s b e i n g t r u e whether AB
and BC
are d i r e c t e d i n t h e same d i r e c t i o n o r i n o p p o s i t e
d i r e c t i o n s ( w h e r e C lies b e t w e e n A a n d B). I n t h e latter case A B a n d B C were not v i e w e d as merely lengths, but simultaneously their directions were considered since they were oppositely directed. Thus d a w n e d the distinction b e t w e e n the s u m of lengths a n d the s u m of distances w h i c h w e r e fixed in direction. F r o m this resulted the r e q u i r e m e n t for establishi n g this latter c o n c e p t o f s u m , n o t s i m p l y for t h e case w h e r e t h e distances w e r e d i r e c t e d i n t h e same o r o p p o s i t e d i r e c t i o n s , b u t also for any other case. T h i s c o u l d b e d o n e i n t h e m o s t s i m p l e m a n n e r , since t h e l a w that
56
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
AB + BC = AC r e m a i n s v a l i d w h e n A, B, C do n o t l i e in a s t r a i g h t l i n e . T h i s t h e n was t h e first step t o a n analysis w h i c h s u b s e q u e n t l y l e d t o the n e w branch of mathematics, w h i c h is presented here. I d i d not h o w ever t h e n realize h o w fruitful and h o w rich was the field that I h a d o p e n e d up; rather that result s e e m e d scarcely w o r t h y of note u n t i l it was c o m b i n e d w i t h a related idea. W h i l e I was p u r s u i n g the concept of geometrical product, as this idea h a d b e e n e s t a b l i s h e d b y m y f a t h e r ( i n h i s Raumlehre, p t . I , 1 7 4 a n d h i s Trigonometrie, p . 1 0 ) , I c o n c l u d e d t h a t n o t o n l y r e c t a n g l e s , b u t a l s o parallelograms, m a y be v i e w e d as products of t w o adjacent sides, prov i d e d that the sides are v i e w e d not m e r e l y as lengths, b u t rather as directed magnitudes. W h e n I j o i n e d this concept of geometrical product w i t h the previously established idea of geometrical s u m the most striki n g harmony resulted. T h u s w h e n I m u l t i p l i e d the s u m of t w o vectors by a third coplanar vector, the result coincided (and must always coincide) w i t h the result obtained by m u l t i p l y i n g separately each of the t w o original vectors by the t h i r d vector a n d a d d i n g together ( w i t h d u e attention to positive and negative values) the t w o products. [ T h u s A ( B + C) = AB + AC.] F r o m t h i s h a r m o n y I c a m e t o see t h a t a w h o l e n e w area o f a n a l y s i s w a s o p e n i n g u p w h i c h c o u l d lead t o i m p o r t a n t results. T h i s idea r e m a i n e d dormant for some t i m e since the demands of my occupation l e d me to o t h e r tasks; also I was i n i t i a l l y p e r p l e x e d by t h e strange r e s u l t t h a t though the other laws of ordinary multiplication (including the relation of multiplication to addition) were preserved in this n e w type of multiplication, yet o n e c o u l d o n l y exchange factors i f o n e s i m u l t a n e o u s l y c h a n g e d t h e s i g n (i.e. c h a n g e d + to — a n d — to +)• A w o r k on tidal theory, w h i c h I u n d e r t o o k at a later t i m e , l e d me to L a g r a n g e ' s Mecanique analytique a n d t h e r e b y I r e t u r n e d t o t h o s e i d e a s o f analysis. A l l t h e d e v e l o p m e n t s i n that w o r k w e r e t r a n s f o r m e d t h r o u g h the principles of the n e w analysis in such a s i m p l e w a y that the calculations often came out m o r e than ten times shorter than in Lagrange's work. T h i s encouraged me to a p p l y the n e w analysis to the difficult theory of the tides; there were numerous n e w concepts to d e v e l o p and to clothe in the n e w analysis; the concept of rotation l e d to geometrical exponential m a g n i t u d e s , to t h e analysis of angles a n d of t r i g o n o m e t r i c f u n c t i o n s , etc. I was d e l i g h t e d h o w t h o r o u g h the analysis thus f o r m e d a n d e x t e n d e d , not o n l y the o f t e n v e r y c o m p l e x a n d u n s y m m e t r i c f o r m u l a e w h i c h are fundamental in tidal theory, come out as the most simple and symmetric f o r m u l a e , b u t also t h e t e c h n i q u e o f d e v e l o p m e n t parallels t h e concept.
T h u s I feel e n t i t l e d to hope that I have f o u n d in this n e w analysis the only natural m e t h o d according to w h i c h mathematics should be applied t o nature, a n d a c c o r d i n g t o w h i c h g e o m e t r y m a y also b e t r e a t e d , w h e n ever it leads to general a n d to f r u i t f u l results. T h u s I d e c i d e d to m a k e the presentation, e x t e n s i o n a n d a p p l i c a t i o n of this analysis a task of my life. W h e n I c a m e to d e v o t e a l l my free t i m e to this task, m a n y of t h e gaps, left in the m o r e casual earlier d e v e l o p m e n t , w e r e f i l l e d up. T h u s the f o l l o w i n g ideas ( w h i c h are p r e s e n t e d i n this b o o k ) r e s u l t e d : t h e s u m o f several points is their centroid; the product of t w o points is the vector connect-
57
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
i n g t h e m ; t h e p r o d u c t o f t h r e e points i s t h e surface area d e t e r m i n e d b y t h e m ; the p r o d u c t of four points is the spatial m a g n i t u d e (a p y r a m i d ) determined by them. The
c o n c e p t i o n o f c e n t r o i d a s s u m l e d m e t o e x a m i n e M o b i u s ' Bary-
centrische
Calcul, a w o r k
of w h i c h
until then
I k n e w only the title; and I
was not a little pleased to find here the same concept of the summation of points to w h i c h I had been led in the course of the development. This was the which
first, a n d as I s u b s e q u e n t l y l e a r n e d , t h e o n l y p o i n t of contact
my new
system of analysis
had w i t h the one that was
already
k n o w n . Since h o w e v e r the concept of a product of points does not occur in that w o r k a n d since w i t h this concept, w h e n it is c o m b i n e d w i t h that of the s u m of points, the d e v e l o p m e n t of the n e w analysis begins, I f o u n d that I
c o u l d not expect a n y a d v a n c e m e n t of my ideas f r o m that source.
(4,1,1; 7 - 1 0 ) From
this
quotation
w e l e a r n first o f all that G r a s s m a n n ' s discus-
sion of the addition of lines is only partly within the "parallelogram of forces" tradition. sum
of two
with the
Thus
directed
what Grassmann
lines
and
was
discussing was the
o n l y that, whereas those w h o dealt
parallelogram of forces w e r e not conceptually adding lines
b u t w e r e taking the geometrically d e t e r m i n e d diagonal as the representation of the resultant of t w o forces. with ing
sums lines
of complex numbers but
representing
Grassmann's stated
that
complex
view he
was
numbers
ferred h i m to It
is
gested the
was
obvious of
unaware
In
Similarly those w h o dealt
not directly conceptually add-
as
a
line.
any
of the
case
Thus
to
some
Grassmann
geometrical
extent
explicitly
representation
G a u s s i n a l e t t e r o f D e c e m b e r 14,
of
1844, re-
p a p e r o f 1831.34
that
Mobius'
Grassmann's
c o n c e p t that the line AB
negative of the
sum
new.
until
Gauss'
some
a
were
Barycentrische
ideas;
thus
Calcul for
could
example
have
sug-
Mobius
had
(the line f r o m A to B) w a s e q u a l to the
line BA (from B to A).
M o b i u s h a d moreover come to
v i e w (before G r a s s m a n n ) not o n l y lines b u t also triangles a n d tetrahedra as positive or negative. mann
It is thus very interesting that Grass-
stated that he had k n o w n of Mobius' w o r k only by name until
he h a d laid the foundation for his to
note
that
Grassmann
concept for his Mobius
wrote
points),
he
things
failed to
In the above
II,
p. Justus
footnote
58
the 194"
not
system.
It is above all important
anticipated by Mobius in the key
system, that of geometrical multiplication. Although such
a s A B = —BA
conceive
quotation
multiplication that the referred
was
of this
(where A
as
Giinther in the
B
represent
Grassmann stated concerning geometrical
idea came from his
father and in a footnote
reader to t w o of his father's books, and
and
a multiplication of points.
"Trigonometric,
p.
Grassmann
first of these
10."
made
books:
"Raumlehre Theil
35
the
following
statements
in
a
O t h e r E a r l y Vectorial Systems
The tion
rectangle
of it,
as
it
itself
is
appears
the in
true
§53,
geometrical is
really
product,
and
geometrical
the
construc-
multiplication.
If t h e
c o n c e p t o f m u l t i p l i c a t i o n i s t a k e n i n its p u r e s t a n d m o s t g e n e r a l sense, then one comes to v i e w a construction as something constructed f r o m elements already c o n s t r u c t e d a n d i n fact c o n s t r u c t e d i n the same w a y . Thus multiplication is only a construction of a higher power. In geometry the point is the original " p r o d u c i n g " element; from it through construction the l i n e emerges; if we take as the basis of a n e w construction the finite line constructed from the point, a n d if we treat it in the same manner as
we formerly treated the point, then the rectangle emerges.
Just as the l i n e c a m e f r o m the p o i n t , so t h e rectangle conies f r o m the line. T h e s i t u a t i o n i s t h e same i n a r i t h m e t i c . I n this case t h e u n i t i s t h e original
"producing''
element. T h e unit must simply be v i e w e d as given.
F r o m this, t h r o u g h c o u n t i n g (arithmetic construction), n u m b e r appears. If this n u m b e r is t a k e n as t h e basis of a n e w c o u n t i n g (setting it in p l a c e of the
unit),
then
arises
the arithmetic
connection to
multiplication,
w h i c h is n o t h i n g else b u t a n u m b e r of a higher order, a n u m b e r of w h i c h the u n i t is also a n u m b e r . T h u s it c o u l d perhaps be said that t h e rectangle is a (finite) line in w h i c h , in place of the " p r o d u c i n g " points, a f i n i t e l i n e has gested: this
A
product
b e e n substituted. T h u s the f o l l o w i n g laws m a y be sug-
rectangle behaves
is in
the the
geometrical same
way
product as
of its
the
base
arithmetic
and
height
product.
and
(4,1,11;
507) In in
the
second
book
(the
Trigonometrie)
the
elder
Grassmann
wrote
a footnote: I f t h e c o n c e p t o f p r o d u c t i s t a k e n i n its m o s t p u r e a n d g e n e r a l sense, then it is v i e w e d as the result of a synthesis in w h i c h an e l e m e n t (prod u c e d f r o m a n e a r l i e r s y n t h e s i s ) i s set i n t h e p l a c e o f t h e o r i g i n a l e l e m e n t a n d treated i n the same w a y . T h e p r o d u c t m u s t arise l i k e w i s e f r o m w h a t r e s u l t e d f r o m the first synthesis, just as this arose f r o m the o r i g i n a l elements. In arithmetic the unit is the element, counting is the synthesis, a n d t h e r e s u l t i s n u m b e r . I f t h i s n u m b e r , a s t h e r e s u l t o f t h e f i r s t s y n thesis, i s set i n t h e p l a c e o f t h e u n i t , a n d t r e a t e d i n t h e s a m e w a y (i.e., counted), then the arithmetic product appears, a n d this m a y be v i e w e d as a n u m b e r of a h i g h e r o r d e r t h a n a n u m b e r of w h i c h u n i t y is a l r e a d y a number. In geometry the point is the element, the synthesis is the motion of the point in some direction, and the result, the path of the point, is t h e line. I f this l i n e , p r o d u c e d b y t h e first synthesis, i s set i n t h e p l a c e o f t h e p o i n t a n d t r e a t e d i n t h e s a m e w a y (i.e., m o v e d i n s o m e o t h e r d i r e c tion), t h e n a surface is p r o d u c e d f r o m the path of the line. T h i s is a true geometrical p r o d u c t of t w o linear factors a n d appears in the first place as a rectangle, insofar as t h e first d i r e c t i o n shares n o t h i n g w i t h t h e second. If t h e surface is set in p l a c e of t h e p o i n t , t h e n a g e o m e t r i c a l s o l i d is p r o d u c e d as t h e p r o d u c t of three factors. T h i s is as far as o n e can go in g e o m e t r y s i n c e space has o n l y t h r e e d i m e n s i o n s ; n o s u c h l i m i t a t i o n a p p e a r s in
arithmetic.
F o r f u r t h e r i n f o r m a t i o n , s e e m y Raumlehre, p t .
II
(Berlin,
1 8 2 4 ) . (4,1,11; 5 0 7 - 5 0 8 ) These quotations justify attributing to Justus Giinther Grassmann the honor for b e i n g the first to p u b l i s h the idea of a p u r e l y geometri-
59
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
cal product. blown
He of course failed to extend the concept into a full-
system;
this
his son d i d , a n d this was clearly a far greater
achievement. It is noteworthy that the first of these statements was p u b l i s h e d b e f o r e 1832, that is, b e f o r e H e r m a n n G r a s s m a n n r e a c h e d the
first
more
insights
leading to his
sophisticated
system, whereas the
statement appeared
after
1832.
second and
This
fact m a y
h o w e v e r be of small importance, for the quotations m a y do no more than suggest w h a t m i g h t have b e e n c o m m u n i c a t e d b e t w e e n a father a n d a son w h o was l i v i n g i n his father's h o u s e i n 1832. N o i n f o r m a tion seems to be available concerning the interesting question as to the source of J. G. Grassmann's concept of a geometrical product. It w o u l d for e x a m p l e b e v e r y e x c i t i n g t o f i n d a l i n k b e t w e e n his statem e n t s a n d t h e g e o m e t r i c a l r e p r e s e n t a t i o n o f c o m p l e x n u m b e r s tradition or the "parallelogram of forces" tradition. As
Grassmann's
important to keep published interest
until
than
lehre o f 1 8 4 4 .
Theorie the
1911;
the
der
Ebbe
und
Flut
following points hence
first
it
is
at
publication
is
considered,
in mind. a
lower level
of his
it
is
First, it was not
system,
of historical
h i s Ausdehnungs-
S e c o n d , it is of great interest as a source of i n f o r m a -
tion concerning h o w Grassmann came to the m u c h fuller system, w h i c h w a s p u b l i s h e d i n 1844. T h i r d , the presentation o f his system was
somewhat biased,
as
he r e p e a t e d l y stated, by the fact that it
was t i e d t o t h e specific p h y s i c a l p r o b l e m o f t i d a l theory. I n this regard it w o u l d be interesting to be able to determine h o w m u c h of Grassmann's full system was developed w i t h physical applications in
mind.
At least this
much
seems
clear:
his
original ideas were
engendered, like those of Hamilton, in the course of a mathematical quest, but, unlike Hamilton, Grassmann seems to have forged many o f h i s m a t h e m a t i c a l tools w i t h p h y s i c a l a p p l i c a t i o n s (to t i d a l t h e o r y ) in
mind.
V.
Grassmann s The
Theorie
der
Ebbe
und
Flut
s t u d y b e g a n w i t h a n i n t r o d u c t i o n i n w h i c h G r a s s m a n n sur-
veyed the
h i s t o r y o f t i d a l t h e o r y a n d i n d i c a t e d p a r t i c u l a r l y his re-
lationship
to
celeste.
Laplace's
new mathematical felt
treatment
of the
subject
in
La
Mecanique
In the first chapter Grassmann stated that he had developed methods
which
forced however to comment:
he w o u l d use in the work.
He
"Since the scope of the present
w o r k does not a l l o w me to present all the principles of the methods of
geometrical
laws
analysis
(though
they
which could
I
have be
employed,
developed
l a t e d l a w s o f a l g e b r a i c a n a l y s i s . " (4,111,1;
60
I
will
independently)
borrow
from
the
the re-
18) T h i s suggests t h a t b y
Other Early Vectorial
1840
he
had
presented
developed
in
1844.
Grassmann
then
pressed
by
that
equality
the
the
a
substantial
considered
equation sign
^
with
the
=
part
law
Const."
the
of the
of
dot above
system
inertia,
(4,111,1; it
Systems
as
which
18),
fully
he
a n d he
signified
ex-
noted
geometrical
e q u a l i t y , t h a t is, t h a t t h e v e l o c i t y r e m a i n e d c o n s t a n t i n b o t h m a g n i tude
and
direction.
velocities, by
the
(P, S
imparted
P 4- Q
Proceeding to
arrived
combined
()) =
he
at
force
by
the
is
the
the
parallelogram
statement:
the
"The
geometrical
individual forces,
or
of forces a n d
velocity
sum
of
expressed
(S)
imparted
the
as
a
velocities formula,
w h e r e 4- is t h e s i g n of g e o m e t r i c a l s u m m a t i o n . " (4,111,1;
19) A f t e r i n d i c a t i n g t h a t m o r e f o r c e s (or v e l o c i t i e s ) c o u l d b e a d d e d in
the
same
way,
Grassmann
turned
a d d i t i o n a n d s u b t r a c t i o n . " (4,111,1; tive
and
vectors
associative (Strecken)
laws
and
to
h o l d for the
argued
"the
laws
of geometrical
19) H e p r o v e d t h a t t h e c o m m u t a -
that
addition
since
all
and
subtraction
laws
for
addition
of in
ordinary algebra can be d e r i v e d f r o m these t w o laws, all those laws could n o w be assumed for vectorial addition.
(4,111,1; 2 0 ) I t s h o u l d
be noted here a n d kept in m i n d for later discussions t h a t G r a s s m a n n was among the first to realize the full well the
as
their correlates
development of the
with
the
sequently analysis, tions
differential
statement: also
of
insofar except
as
sketched the
"All
they
method
of
are
are
and
in
algebraic
then
differentiation
likewise
fact
subtraction."
for taking
Grassmann
began
calculus of vectors, concluding
laws
integration
addition
significance of these laws as
for multiplication.
valid
obtained
from
(4,111,1;
partial
21)
in
con-
geometrical
no
other
After
derivatives
and
opera-
this
he
for vectors a n d
"d2 restated
the
law
of inertia as
p — 0"
( w h i c h is
equivalent, in
2
dp modern
notation,
to
= 0),
sents three o r d i n a r y equations. Grassmann and
gave
gravity. two
for
applied example
F r o m this
his the
and
he
(4,111,1;
methods
to
vectorial
pointed out that this
repre-
21-22) the
physics
formulation
of the of the
problem center
of
he returned to define the geometrical product of
vectors. By
the
geometrical
product
o f two
vectors,
we
mean
the
surface
con-
t e n t o f t h e p a r a l l e l o g r a m d e t e r m i n e d b y t h e s e v e c t o r s ; w e h o w e v e r fix the position o f the p l a n e i n w h i c h the p a r a l l e l o g r a m lies. W e refer t o t w o surface areas a s g e o m e t r i c a l l y e q u a l o n l y w h e n t h e y are e q u a l i n c o n t e n t and
lie
in
we m e a n the
parallel
planes.
By
the
geometrical
product
of
three
vectors
s o l i d ( a p a r a l l e l e p i p e d ) f o r m e d f r o m t h e m . A s t h e sign o f
61
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
geometrical
multiplication
while
indicate
we
we
choose
either
the
point
or
the
sign
x,
ordinary algebraic multiplication by writing the two
q u a n t i t i e s n e x t t o e a c h o t h e r o r b y u s i n g t h e s i g n x . (4,111,1; 3 0 ) As
was
natural,
he
s h o w e d that the
product of three vectors w h i c h
lie in the same or in parallel planes is zero. He p r o v e d b o t h forms of the
distributive
by
anticommutativity.
law
and
showed
(4,111,1;
that 30)
commutativity was
Also
the
replaced
expression
for
the
geometrical product was given as the product of the lengths of lines multiplied to
the
by
the
sign),
raume)
was
of the
finally
angle
the
between them (with attention
addition
of directed
areas
(Flachen-
defined.
Grassmann's vector
sine
and
(cross)
geometrical
product is
product.
will
It
be
quite
similar to the modern
advantageous
to
specify
the
similarities a n d differences for these t w o products, since the Grassm a n n product w i l l occur again and since this difference in products constitutes mann's
one
of the
system
identical
and
most significant differences b e t w e e n the
numerically
conventions.
modern
and
system.
likewise
The
two
correspond
in
Grass-
products regard
T h e most significant difference is that in the
are
to
sign
modern
m u l t i p l i c a t i o n t h e p r o d u c t is of t h e s a m e k i n d as the factors (all are vectors),
whereas
in
the
Grassmann
multiplication the
product is
not of t h e same nature as the factors. T h u s in the G r a s s m a n n m u l t i plication of t w o vectors the product is not another vector, but rather a
d i r e c t e d area.
It is t r u e that this area (or t h e
set of g e o m e t r i c a l l y
e q u a l areas) d e t e r m i n e s a v e c t or (or set of vectors) p e r p e n d i c u l a r to that area, a n d that t h e v e c t o r (or vectors) so d e f i n e d is p r e c i s e l y that vector tion.
which
plane
(or
which
the
lard
is
the
Conversely, set
and
has
E d w i n
for other uses, as After
reaping
In
in
there
is
it
was
concepts;
rather
the
true
the
establishment
62
of parallel
which
is
vectors)
precisely
that
defines
a
plane
in
purely
W i l s o n maintained that the vector for physical
applications, whereas
I
harvest
a
be
made
mechanical
came of of
concept
determined
not
foundation
geometrical
g e o m e t r y a n d in m u l t i p l e algebra.36 possible
by
this
new
without
these
stated:
scarcely
that a
of the
can
and in
Bidwell
projective
some
concepts
Nevertheless these
set
G r a s s m a n n f o r m of the p r o d u c t has a superiority
Grassmann
fact,
geometrical
(or
planes)
greater advantages
they h e l d that the
technique,
vector
of parallel
d i r e c t e d area o f t h e G r a s s m a n n p r o d u c t lies. Josiah W i l -
Gibbs
product
product in the modern form of the multiplica-
the
to
these their
context.
in in
purely
concepts (4,111,1;
general
(which 33)
a
which
on
development
which and
considerations
them natural
mechanics a
a I
simple led
geometrical cannot
must
be
way.
me
to
basis,
so
now given
discuss) only
Other Early Vectorial
Soon
after
this
Grassmann
defined
what
he
called
Systems
the
linear
product. By the one
linear product o f t w o
vector
multiplied
by
vectors the
we
mean
the
perpendicular
algebraic product of
projection
of the
second
o n t o it. We s e l e c t t h e s i g n ^ as t h e s i g n of l i n e a r m u l t i p l i c a t i o n , so t h a t by d e f i n i t i o n = cos
b — a b cos (ab). F r o m t h i s d e f i n i t i o n a n d s i n c e c o s ( a b )
(ba), we
s e e t h a t a ->b = b ^
a.
(4,111,1;
40, 212)
He then p r o v e d that the distributive law holds for this product, a n d explained that the where
a,
b,
c
l i n e a r p r o d u c t of (a 4- b 4- c)
a n d au bu cx
are t w o
sets
w i t h (ax 4 - b x 4 - cx)
of m u t u a l l y p e r p e n d i c u l a r
v e c t o r s a n d a i s p a r a l l e l t o a u b t o b u c t o c u i s e q u a l t o aax ccx.
(4,111,1;
40)
Finally
he
stated
that
since
the
+
distributive laws w e r e preserved in this multiplication, all algebraic
multiplication
this product is
to
applicable.
identical to the m o d e r n
Throughout the methods
were
remainder of his
tidal
theory
with
It
fob,
commutative
should
be
+
and
laws
clear
of
that
scalar product.
work Grassmann applied these
some
success.
In
later
portions
he
i n t r o d u c e d o t h e r n e w , b u t less r e l e v a n t , m a t h e m a t i c a l m e t h o d s , including the linear vector function.
(4,111,1;
7 9 ff.)
In summary, Grassmann presented in this w o r k a strikingly large part
of
major
vector kinds
elements
analysis.
of
Vector
vectorial
of the
addition
products,
and
vector
linear vector function
subtraction,
differentiation,
were
all
presented
the
two
and
the
in
forms
either equivalent or nearly equivalent to their m o d e r n counterparts. Grassmann's
work
vector analysis;
was
more
than
that was d a w n i n g at that time. algebra
may
the
first
important
system
of
it was also the first major w o r k in the n e w algebra
be
compared
T h e revolutionary nature of this n e w
with
that
of non-Euclidean
geometry.
Paradoxically Grassmann's d e v e l o p m e n t of his system as applied to three
dimensions
Ausdehnungslehre one
sense
This
was
early
in
led a
him
form
constituted a
a
magnificent
thirties
who
had
to
present
applicable discovery
of
achievement never
his
to
system
in
n-dimensions, non-Euclidean
for
attended
a
a
his
in
geometry.37
mathematician
university
1844
which
in
his
mathematical
lecture.
VI.
Grassmann's
Between textbooks
Ausdehnungslehre
1840 and
and
1844
Grassmann
a long mathematical
his n e w method. A r o u n d Easter, full
energies
to
the
1844 published
paper which
some
language
did not pertain to
1842, G r a s s m a n n b e g a n to t u r n his
composition
and by the fall of 1843 he had
of
of his
finished
Ausdehnungslehre
(5;
91-92),
w r i t i n g it. (5; 9 5 ) T h a t G r a s s -
63
A
H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
mann
r e q u i r e d such a short t i m e for the compositon of the book is
doubly striking since he wrote it w h i l e involved in numerous other activities
and
since,
presentation
was
according
reworked
to
in
a
remark
many
s e l e c t e d t h e f o r m a c t u a l l y e m p l o y e d . (4,1,1; ing the
best form
fact that
of presentation
sometime
discovered coveries.
new
He
after
1839,
in the
his
was
foreword,
forms
the
before
he
16) D i f f i c u l t y i n c h o o s -
caused in
large
part by the
and probably in
1842,38 G r a s s m a n n
and
of
implications
wrote
in
different
extensions
his
earlier
dis-
foreword:
W h e n I thus proceeded to w o r k out, coherently and from the beginnings, the results that I h a d found, b e i n g careful to appeal to no principle p r o v e n in any b r a n c h of mathematics, it resulted that the analysis w h i c h I d i s c o v e r e d d i d not t o u c h , as it h a d s e e m e d before, on t h e area of g e o m e t r y . R a t h e r I soon r e a l i z e d that I h a d c o m e u p o n a r e g i o n of a n e w science of w h i c h geometry itself is only a special application. It h a d for a l o n g t i m e b e e n e v i d e n t to me that geometry can in no w a y be v i e w e d , like arithmetic or combination theory, as a branch of mathematics; instead g e o m e t r y relates to s o m e t h i n g already g i v e n in nature, n a m e l y , space. I also h a d r e a l i z e d that t h e r e m u s t be a b r a n c h of mathematics
w h i c h yields
in a p u r e l y abstract w a y laws
similar to those in
g e o m e t r y , w h i c h appears b o u n d t o space. B y means o f t h e n e w analysis it
appeared
possible to f o r m such a p u r e l y abstract branch of mathe-
matics; i n d e e d this n e w analysis, d e v e l o p e d w i t h o u t the assumption of any principles
e s t a b l i s h e d o u t s i d e o f its
own
domain and proceeding
p u r e l y by abstraction, was itself this science. T h e essential advantages w h i c h w e r e attained t h r o u g h this conception w e r e 1) in relation to the f o r m — n o w all p r i n c i p l e s w h i c h express v i e w s of space
are e n t i r e l y o m i t t e d , a n d c o n s e q u e n t l y t h e b e g i n n i n g s of the
science w e r e as direct as those of arithmetic — a n d 2) in relation to content—the limitation to three dimensions is omitted. O n l y herein do the laws come to light in their full clarity and generality and reveal themselves
in
their essential
mutual
relationships,
and
m a n y regularities,
w h i c h for three dimensions present themselves either not at all or only obscurely,
now
present
themselves
with
this
generalization
in
full
c l a r i t y . (4,1,1; 1 0 - 1 1 ) Thus Die
in
1844
lineale
dargestellt
und
Mathematik,
wie
Magnetismus tioned
Grassmann's
book
Ausdehnungslehre,
und
before,
durch
neuer
Anwendungen
auch die
appeared
ein
auf
die
had
auf
die
Statik,
Krystallonomie
Grassmann
under Zweig ubrigen
Mechanik,
erlautert.
no
array
the
As of titles
full
der
Zweige
der
Lehre
vom
die it to
title:
Mathematik
was put
menafter his
name, as h a d H a m i l t o n w h e n n i n e years later in 1853 he p u b l i s h e d the
first
the
title
Schule
full treatment of his page zu
appeared
Stettin."
only
Some
system.
Under Grassmann's name on
"Lehrer an
idea
of the
der
Friedrich-Wilhelms-
n u m b e r of copies
of Grass-
m a n n ' s b o o k t h a t w e r e p r i n t e d , a s w e l l a s s o m e i d e a o f its r e c e p t i o n ,
64
Other Early Vectorial
may be
obtained from
written
to
dehnungslehre: print
for
the
Grassmann "Your
some
following
in
1876
book
time.
600 copies w e r e in
Die
Since
by
quotation the
Ausdehnungslehre
your work
taken
publisher
hardly
from a letter
of his
has
Systems
first
been
sold
at
out
all,
Ausof
roughly
1864 used as waste paper and the remainder, a
few o d d copies, have n o w been sold w i t h the exception of one copy which remains
in our library."
3 9
As Grassmann's book is discussed, it is important to keep in m i n d that
not
only
sidered.
its
To put
richness
but
also
its
readableness
must
be
con-
it briefly, the analysis of the w o r k w i l l lead to the
conclusion that the w o r k is a classic, that it is v e r y difficult to read, and
that
it
contains
a
large
portion
of
modern
vector
analysis,
w h i c h was h o w e v e r d e e p l y e m b e d d e d w i t h i n a far b r o a d e r system, and embedded in
such
a w a y that it c o u l d be extracted only w i t h
difficulty. Grassmann i n c l u d e d at the beginning of his w o r k a philosophical introduction
which
is
for it is
of the
major barriers b e y o n d w h i c h m a n y mathemati-
one
cians of his
time
both
interesting and historically significant,
d i d n o t pass.
Grassmann began this
introduction by stating:
T h e primary d i v i s i o n in all the sciences is into the real a n d the formal. T h e former represent in thought; the existent as existing i n d e p e n d e n t l y of thought, existent.
and their truth
The formal
consists
sciences
in their correspondence with the
on the other hand have as their object
w h a t has b e e n p r o d u c e d b y t h o u g h t a l o n e , a n d t h e i r t r u t h consists i n t h e correspondence b e t w e e n the t h o u g h t processes themselves.40 Concerning
proof
in
"Proof in the formal
the
formal
sciences thus
sphere of t h o u g h t itself;
sciences
does
Grassmann
stated:
not proceed outside of the
rather it remains purely in the combination
o f d i f f e r e n t acts o f t h o u g h t . T h u s i t i s that t h e f o r m a l s c i e n c e s n e e d not begin
with axioms;
instead definitions form their foundation."
(4,1,1; 2 2 ) T h e s p e c i a l r e l e v a n c e o f t h i s v i e w b e c o m e s c l e a r w i t h t h e following
two
statements:
P u r e m a t h e m a t i c s i s t h u s t h e s c i e n c e o f t h e p a r t i c u l a r e x i s t e n t w h i c h has come
to be
through
thought.
The
particular existent,
viewed in
this
sense, we n a m e a t h o u g h t - f o r m or s i m p l y a f o r m . T h u s p u r e m a t h e m a t i c s i s t h e t h e o r y o f f o r m s . (4,1,1; 2 3 ) Before we proceed to the division of the theory of forms, we have to s e p a r a t e o u t o n e b r a n c h w h i c h has h i t h e r t o i n c o r r e c t l y b e e n i n c l u d e d i n it.
This
branch
is
geometry.
e v i d e n t that g e o m e t r y as
From
the
concepts
set o u t a b o v e ,
it is
w e l l as m e c h a n i c s refers to a real existent;
for g e o m e t r y this is space. T h i s is clear since t h e c o n c e p t of space can in no w a y be produced by thought, b u t rather comes forth as something g i v e n . (4,1,1; 2 3 )
65
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
W h a t Grassmann b e l i e v e d he h a d discovered was thus a system, a purely
formal
system,
which
geometry a n d i n d e e d of all was
a
sort
necessarily
was
algebra41
of universal
above
mathematics in
and
as
independent
of
k n o w n at that time.
which
the
elements
had
It no
real content but could take on geometrically significant
content w h e n
such
deed marvelously
was
desirable.
general
His
" T h e o r y of F o r m s " was in-
a n d abstract.
Grassmann c o n t i n u e d in the introduction to lay the philosophical foundation his
theory
for his
system.
of forms
could
He
specified four concepts with which
develop
all
of mathematics;
these
were
t h e d i s c r e t e a n d t h e c o n t i n u o u s , t h e e q u a l a n d t h e d i f f e r e n t . (4,1,1; 24-25)
According to
of each
different—comes which
Grassmann,
from
the
combination of the
last
o f t h e s e pairs o f o p p o s i t e s — t h a t is, t h e c o n t i n u o u s a n d t h e forth
includes the
dimensions points)
of
vary
the line).
his
"Ausdehnungslehre,"
notion of difference
space)
and
continuously
and
in
which
hence
that
doctrine
(for e x a m p l e , the different
the
elements
produce
different
(for
example,
entities
(as
(4,1,1; 2 6 - 2 7 ) T h u s G r a s s m a n n s t a t e d :
Space theory [die R a u m l e h r e ] m a y again serve as an example. H e r e in t w o d i f f e r e n t d i r e c t i o n s f r o m a n e l e m e n t all t h e e l e m e n t s o f a p l a n e are p r o d u c e d w h e n the p r o d u c i n g e l e m e n t progresses i n any w a y according to two
directions.
T h e totality of points
(elements) producible in this
w a y i s c o m p r i s e d i n o n e e l e m e n t [ t h e p l a n e ] . T h e p l a n e i s t h u s t h e system of the second order; in it there is an infinite collection of directions d e p e n d e n t on those t w o original directions. If a third independent direct i o n i s a d d e d , t h e n b y m e a n s o f t h i s d i r e c t i o n i n f i n i t e s p a c e (as t h e s y s tem of the third order) is produced. Up to n o w one could not go beyond three directions; however in the pure theory of extension the number of d i r e c t i o n s c a n i n c r e a s e t o i n f i n i t y . (4,1,1; 2 9 )
The above mann
gives
attempted
concluded with tion
for the
s o m e idea of the p h i l o s o p h i c a l basis that Grass-
to
construct for his
a discussion
work;
it
aware that a reader's Whatever may
be
system.
T h e introduction was
concerning the best form of presenta-
n e e d only be noted that Grassmann was w e l l entry into his the
absolute
s y s t e m w o u l d not i)e easy.
value of Grassmann's philosophi-
cal u n d e r p i n n i n g of his system, it is important to keep in m i n d that it
seems
new
to
have
a l l o w e d G r a s s m a n n h i m s e l f to feel at ease w i t h
mathematical
ideas,
tions
and n-dimensional
with
Hamilton's
time.
Finally,
general the
66
for example, n o n c o m m u t a t i v e multiplicaspaces.
speculations Grassmann's
on
In this regard it m a y be c o m p a r e d algebra
penchant
d i d certainly lead to m a n y ideas
next section
of his
book.
as
for
the
the
science abstract
of and
pure the
of value, a fact e v i d e n t in
Other Early Vectorial
This
section
Forms."
He
was
began
entitled
with the
"Survey
of
the
General
Systems
Theory
of
statement:
By the general t h e o r y of forms I m e a n that series of truths w h i c h relate to all branches of mathematics in the same w a y , a n d thus p r e s u m e o n l y the general concepts of e q u a l i t y a n d difference, c o n n e c t i o n a n d separation.
The
general
theory
of forms
should
thus
precede
all
special
branches of mathematics. Since h o w e v e r that general b r a n c h does not as such exist yet, a n d since we cannot o m i t it w i t h o u t e n t a n g l i n g ourselves in useless r a m b l i n g s , we have no c h o i c e b u t to d e v e l o p this subject insof a r a s w e n e e d i t f o r o u r s c i e n c e . (4,1,1; 3 3 ) This
statement
tions
of the
introduced what was
book
for
the
reader
one
of the
o f t h e m o s t d i f f i c u l t sectime;
in
this
case
it
was
mainly the richness of content and the newness of the concepts that made
this very important section difficult.
c e e d e d to construct the basis
H e r e i n Grassmann pro-
of his theory of forms by postulating
certain initially contentless f o r m s (or m a g n i t u d e s ) a n d j o i n i n g these forms
by
certain
connections
(Verkniipfungen).
Thus
given
two
f o r m s a a n d b, G r a s s m a n n first i n t r o d u c e d a c o n n e c t i o n s y m b o l i z e d by
^
to
yield
connection could be
a
was
new
form
of such
a ^
(a ^ b) He
Grassmann
that the
specified
that
this
following two equations
set u p : a
s h o w e d that
forms
b.
a nature
were
^
b =
b
^
a
^ c = a
=
if equations
connected,
were
then
one
set u p i n w h i c h a n y n u m b e r o f could
members and omit the parentheses.
in
all cases
rearrange the
Grassmann called such a con-
n e c t i o n a s y n t h e t i c c o n n e c t i o n (4,1,1; 3 4 - 3 6 ) a n d f r o m i t p r o c e e d e d to his analytical connections.
For Grassmann an analytical connec-
tion connects t w o forms in such a w a y that w h e n the resultant form is
synthetically connected with one of the original forms, the other
original f o r m results. cal
connection
thetically
and
connected
Grassmann then
Thus when a
and to
b
b
as
^ is taken as the sign for analytithe
gives
a,
two or,
forms, in
then
short,
(a
(a ^
s h o w e d that the following equations
^ b)
b)
^
synb = a.
are true:
Grassmann further specified this f o r m of analytic connection by the assumption unique b
that
the
result
or u n e q u i v o c a l ;
remains
constant
of
thus,
and
the
an
analytic
for example, other
connection if a
changes,
was
to
be
^ b = c, t h e n if a or the
result
(c)
must
67
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
change.
Finally
he
s h o w e d that these
results
to connections of any n u m b e r of forms. These
statements
must
have
reader
of the
times.
At the
mann
stated
what
should
appeared
very
end
have
could be
extended
(4,1,1; 3 6 - 3 8 ) very
of this
strange
to
the
d e v e l o p m e n t Grass-
considerably
enlightened
the
matter: w h e n these connections obeyed the above laws, they could be called addition and subtraction. Grassmann then s h o w e d that t w o n e w forms, the indifferent and the
analytic
lytically
form,
could
connected
to
be
produced.
itself—for
When
example,
a
any form
was
ana-
w a —then the indif-
ferent f o r m resulted (indifferent in the sense that a c o u l d have any value).
He represented this
n e w f o r m b y (/) a n d s t a t e d t h a t w h e n
t h i s f o r m i s c o n n e c t e d t o b > p r o d u c i n g () ^ (wfe),
called
the
analytic form,
emerges.
b), t h e n t h e n e w f o r m
Finally Grassmann
ad-
m i t t e d t h a t t h e i n d i f f e r e n t f o r m c o u l d b e c a l l e d " N u l l " (i.e., zero) and
the
analytic
form
could
be
called
the
negative
form.
(4,1,1;
38-40) Grassmann went on to
develop two further connections, one of
w h i c h was
synthetic and the other analytic.
tions
of such
were
a sort that w h e n
a form
Both of these connecwas
applied through
such a connection to two forms connected in either of the previous manners, a transformation w o u l d take place w i t h o u t a change in the result.
His
new
k i n d of synthetic connection he
symbolized by «
and postulated the following: a
connection,
(4,1,1;
41-43)
Grassmann Note
operation that is in his
Such
stated,
could
be
called
multiplication.
that this implies that Grassmann w i l l call any
distributive a multiplication, and w h a t he sought
work was, broadly speaking,
distributive operations, w h i c h
n e e d not be either c o m m u t a t i v e or associative. Grassmann then introduced the second k i n d of analytical connection
(i.e., d i v i s i o n ) . T h i s w a s l i m i t e d b y t h e l a w e x p r e s s e d i n t h e
equation
_
.
?
a • +• b
a _ b
He pointed out that unlike the former type of analytic connection, three
forms
determined
connected (thus,
for
by
division
example,
are
if t
=
c
not in and
all cases
a = 0,
then
uniquely b
is
not
b
uniquely determined). To the
(4,1,1; 4 3 - 4 4 )
above s u m m a r y it n e e d only be a d d e d that according to
Grassmann similar forms (forms of the same order, thus t w o points, t w o vectors, a n d so forth) w h e n connected by either of the first t w o kinds
68
of
connection
give
in
general
forms
of
the
same
order,
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
whereas in multiplication forms of the same or different orders may be c o m b i n e d and in general produce forms of a higher order. T h u s the p r o d u c t of t w o vectors (forms of the first order) is a d i r e c t e d area (a form of the second order). The
section just
discussed
combined
with
the
introduction
to
present a nearly impassable barrier for most mathematicians of the time. Ideas s u c h as these w e r e so n e w , so abstract, a n d at first sight so useless that it is not difficult to u n d e r s t a n d w h y M o b i u s r e g a r d e d the work as simply unreadable, Baltzer f o u n d it m a d e h i m
dizzy,
and H a m i l t o n was led to write to De M o r g a n that to be able to read Grassmann passages they
he
would
have
to
learn
smoke.42
to
However
these
are not o n l y characterized by o b s c u r i t y a n d abstractness;
also
reveal
powerful mind. commutative,
(to
a modern
mathematician)
the
brilliance
of a
Grassmann had c o m e to understand the associative,
and
distributive
laws
more
fully
than
any
earlier
mathematician, a n d this understanding is reflected in the construction of his
system.
Grassmann
allowed
his
initially
many
values —numbers,
forth;
moreover he eventually
plicative
connections.
points,
All
43
these
contentless
vectors,
forms
oriented
to
areas,
assume and
so
developed sixteen kinds of multiforms
and connections
were
un-
d e r s t o o d i n t e r m s o f t h e l a w s set o u t b y G r a s s m a n n i n this section, a n d thus this
section was
one of the most important.
Having laid
the foundation, we m a y turn to the m a i n contents of the book.44 T h e first chapter of part one of Grassmann's book centered on the production
of his
various
systems.
N e w systems
were created by
taking an element from another system and allowing it to undergo a n e w variation; thus for e x a m p l e a point (the element) is m o v e d in a single direction (the variation) to produce a straight line (a system of the first order).
If this
line n o w varies by m o v i n g in some (recti-
linear) direction, a plane (a system of the second order) is produced. According to Grassmann the same process can be e x t e n d e d to f o r m systems o f a n y o r d e r ( h e n c e his " a n y " d i m e n s i o n a l spaces). I n this chapter a n d w i t h i n this f r a m e w o r k Grassmann i n t r o d u c e d vectors, proved that they obey his previously d e v e l o p e d addition a n d subtraction
laws,
and
explained
vectorial
addition.
He
furthermore
proved various
algebraic properties for his systems. T y p i c a l of his
statements
the
order the
can m
pression
is be
following:
expressed
given
independent
is
unique."45
as
the manners
"Every
vector
sum
m
of
of change
of a
mth
system
of the
vectors,
which
belong
to
of the
system.
This
ex-
T h e first chapter was concluded, as w e r e all others, w i t h a section on application of the theoretical ideas presented.
For this chapter
69
A
History
the
applications
ideas
were
mainly
two:
Grassmann
showed
how
his
c o u l d be u s e d to lay a secure foundation for geometry a n d he
gave a
of V e c t o r Analysis
the
body
vectorial
as
well
method
as
the
of representing
laws
of force
the
center of gravity of
a n d velocity for the center of
gravity. The tion
second
chapter
of Vectors."
lent to
what had been
work, and hence Grassmann only
of this
in
it is
called the
entitled
"Outer Multiplica-
product is
essentially equiva-
geometrical
product in
linear product
(renamed
the first published
uct,
we shall
Besides
definition
give it in full.
of his
1840
Since this
o f t h e m o d e r n scalar (dot) p r o d -
After G r a s s m a n n h a d c o n c l u d e d a dis-
outer product,
this
his
inner product)
offhand manner in the foreword to the book.
was
cussion
outer
s i m i l a r t o t h e m o d e r n v e c t o r (cross) p r o d u c t .
m e n t i o n e d his
an
part was
Grassmann's
he
wrote:
concept there is another that l i k e w i s e relates distances
to fixed directions. N a m e l y , w h e n I took the perpendicular projection of the one distance onto the other, the arithmetic product of this projection and the distance (onto w h i c h the projection was made) represented the product of those distances,
provided
that
the
multiplicative
relation
to
addition
was
valid. But this product was of an entirely different k i n d than the first, in that the factors c o u l d be e x c h a n g e d w i t h o u t c h a n g i n g the sign a n d the product of t w o
m u t u a l l y perpendicular vectors
first
product
the
latter
outer
has
non-zero
and
values
was zero.
I
called the
the
second
the
inner product,
only
when
the
directions
since
approach
the one
a n o t h e r , that is, w h e n t h e distances lie p a r t l y i n e a c h other.46 Grassmann's lehre
of
1844
outer
in
a
product
manner
was
both
presented
different
than the presentation in his study of the tides. a
simple
way
by
in
from
and
his
Ausdehnungs-
more
general
Grassmann began in
stating:
We shall b e g i n w i t h geometry in order to secure an analogy according to w h i c h the abstract science m u s t proceed, a n d thus obtain a clear idea to
escort us a l o n g the u n k n o w n a n d arduous path of abstract d e v e l o p -
ment. We go f r o m the vector to a spatial form of higher order w h e n we allow the
entire
another vector
vector,
which
is
that
is
each
point of the
heterogeneous
to the
vector, to
first,
describe
so that all points
c o n s t r u c t a n e q u a l v e c t o r . T h e s u r f a c e area p r o d u c e d i n t h i s w a y has t h e form of a parallelogram.
T w o such
surface areas
w h i c h belong to the
same p l a n e are d e s i g n a t e d as e q u a l if the d i r e c t i o n of t h e m o v e d vector lies i n b o t h cases o n t h e s a m e s i d e (for e x a m p l e , o n t h e left side) o f t h e v e c t o r p r o d u c e d t h r o u g h t h e m o t i o n . W h e n i n t h e t w o cases t h e c o r r e sponding
vectors
lie
on
opposite
sides,
then
the
surface
areas
are
designated unequal. Thus we have a simple and general law: If in then the
70
the the
individual
plane total
a
vector
surface
surface
area
elements
moves
successively
along
thereby
(provided
that
given
manner)
produced are
set
in
the
any
series
of vectors,
the
signs
of
is
equal
to
that
area
sum
which
of those
would
vectors.
he
produced
(4,1,1;
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
if
along
the
vector
had
moved
the
77-78)
Statements as concrete as the above were not typical of the work nor always
desirable
geometrical have
hindered
went
beyond
the
we
the
the
above
parallel
if
consider
the
nature
understanding
usual
(cd,
ef
of
later
three-dimensional
statement,
lines
Grassmann and
ab)
lines:
i n g along ac u n t i l
for
developments
were
cut
To
which
illustrate
three by
if
it could
coplanar
three
pairs
of
d
move
L e t t i n g ab r e p r e s e n t
parallel to itself, he p i c t u r e d ab m o v -
i t r e a c h e d l i n e cd.
T h u s t h e a r e a acdb w a s
swept
It w i l l be seen by simple geometry that this area is equal to the
sum
of
areas cd.
work,
geometry.
e c a n d d f e a a n d f b , c a a n d db.
a vector constrained to
out.
the
considered
which
c
parallel
of
intuition had b e e n a l l o w e d to enter too early,
the
areas
of the
swept out w h e n
Moreover the
parallelograms
ab
aefb
and
ecdf
that
is,
the
m o v e s a l o n g ae to ef a n d t h e n a l o n g ec to
r e s u l t i n g areas
w i l l be
the
same,
he
stated,
if ab
m o v e s along ae u n t i l it coincides w i t h ef or if it m o v e s a l o n g ac a n d t h e n ce as l o n g as the reversal in d i r e c t i o n ac is c o m p e n s a t e d for by taking
the
area
Grassmann
resulting
then
noted
from
that
ab's
since
motion for
along
example
ce
the
as
negative.
motion
of
ab
along ac gave the same area as w h e n ab m o v e d a l o n g ae a n d t h e n ec,
this
was
on the basis From 1844
the
was
an
operation
above in
that
should
be
viewed
as multiplication
of his theory of forms.47
all
one ways
might
easily infer that his outer product of
equivalent
to
his
geometrical
product
of
1 8 4 0 . T h i s i s t r u e o n l y i n p a r t , s i n c e (as i t w i l l b e s h o w n p r e s e n t l y ) his
geometrical
general
product
of 1840 was
outer p r o d u c t of 1844.
Thus
only one
species
lar t o t h e m o d e r n v e c t o r (cross) p r o d u c t , w a s i n t h e bedded many
within
of
dehnungslehre
the of
a
far
broader
elements 1844
and
of is
system.
vector an
of the
more
his geometrical product, simi-
This
analysis important
1844 w o r k em-
situation
is
developed reason
w h y
typical in
the it
of Aus-
would
71
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
have b e e n difficult to extract the m o d e r n system of vector analysis f r o m his system.
At the e n d of his introductory section Grassmann
stated:
. . we can n o w return to our science in order to pursue it
according
to
a
purely
abstract
manner
and
independently
of all
s p a t i a l c o n s i d e r a t i o n s . " (4,1,1; 8 0 ) At this point it w i l l be helpful to consider in m o d e r n terms what G r a s s m a n n m e a n t by his outer product. It was a p r o d u c t of base elements
e2,
eu
e3, . . . ,
en
which
obey
the
following
laws:
letting
x, y, z take on a n y v a l u e s of n,
^xi^y
€z
^x^y
I t s h o u l d b e n o t e d that t h e last e q u a t i o n n e e d not h a v e b e e n g i v e n since
the
outer product
must be
distributive,
for this property is
contained for Grassmann in the definition of " p r o d u c t . " T h e product of N such order.
elements
was
considered to be an entity of the N t h
H e r e again Grassmann's outer product differs f r o m the m o d -
e r n cross p r o d u c t , since t h e r e s u l t o f t h e cross m u l t i p l i c a t i o n o f t w o vectors
is
another vector (in
Grassmann's
terms,
an
entity of the
first order), whereas the outer product of t w o vectors is an entity of the
second
especially
order.
This
important
difference
in
that
between
Grassmann's
the
outer
two
products
product
is
allowed
h i m t o g e n e r a t e all sorts o f n e w entities w h i c h h e d u l y c o n s i d e r e d . Grassmann vectors.
proceeded
to
discuss the
product of any number of
G r a s s m a n n s t a t e d t h a t a p r o d u c t s u c h a s a.b.c . . . w a s t o
m e a n t h a t t h e v e c t o r a f i r s t m o v e s a l o n g b (as b e f o r e ) , t h e n t h e r e sultant o r i e n t e d area w o u l d m o v e along c, a n d so on t h r o u g h orders higher than the third. distributive
and
that
Grassmann entities
proved that such relations were
thus
arising could be
added
under
c e r t a i n c o n d i t i o n s . A s e a c h n e w e n t i t y arose, h e c h e c k e d its p r o p e r ties in relation to his general theory of forms. S o m e of Grassmann's applications of his outer p r o d u c t m e r i t discussion. uct
I m m e d i a t e l y after his
Grassmann
showed
full presentation of the outer prod-
how
Varignon's
principle
could
be
represented in terms of the outer product in a very simple manner, and he in general product.48 solving Then
he
n
discussed the representation of m o m e n t s by this
H e also s h o w e d h o w the outer p r o d u c t c o u l d b e used i n first-degree considered
equations what
he
outer division ordinary numbers t e m f o r t h e f i r s t t i m e . (4,1,1;
72
in
called
n
unknowns.
(4,1,1;
outer division,
99-102)
and through
( " Z a h l e n g r o s s e " ) e n t e r e d h i s sys-
118-137)
Other Early Vectorial
In
the
last c h a p t e r of t h e
called "Abschattung," was
primarily
original equation
when
with
could be an
part he
dealt w i t h
a process
or, loosely speaking, projection.
concerned
equation
first
the
conditions
definitely
equation
among
extensive
he
Herein he
under
inferred from
Systems
which
the
the
resulting
magnitudes
was
m u l t i p l i e d by an extensive magnitude. T h e results obtained in this chapter
were
applied
to
spatial
projections
and
the
solution
of
equations. T h e majority of the ideas considered up to this point w e r e given by Grassmann in the five chapters of the first section (Abschnitt) of his
book,
a
section
entitled
"Extensive
Magnitude"
("Die
Aus-
dehnungsgrosse"). T h e second of the t w o sections of the book was entitled
"Elementary
Magnitude"
("Die
Elementargrosse").
This
section began w i t h a lengthy discussion of elementary magnitudes, a term by w h i c h Grassmann referred mainly to points. of Grassmann's was
point analysis
a prominent
part of his
is
relevant both
Discussion
directly, in that it
system, and indirectly, in that it had
n u m e r o u s relationships to his system of vector analysis. H i s system of point analysis, h a v i n g b e e n discovered i n d e p e n d e n t l y of M o b i u s , was presented differently and developed more fully. Grassmann
began
this
section
by
considering the addition and
subtraction of elementary magnitudes, although he seems never to have
stated
precisely
except by implication.
what
he
meant by
elementary
magnitudes
E a r l y in the discussion he stated: " I n order
to b r i n g this result into sharper focus, we w i l l apply it to geometry a n d t h u s t a k e t h e e l e m e n t s as p o i n t . . . ." (4,1,1;
158) G r a s s m a n n
proceeded to write such equations as the following, in w h i c h Greek letters
represent elementary
represent
magnitudes,
and the
i s,
UPA,] + .
.
. + in[pan] = k f o M + .
.
. + kn[pf3n]
Grassmann
mained true
when
then
established
both
the
traction,
any other element a was
commutative that
these
and
members
of such
associative
operations
gave
. are the
laws
unique
substituted for p. an
equation
He
satisfied
for addition a n d subresults,
and that the
satisfied for the m u l t i p l i c a t i o n of the e l e m e n t
p a i r s s u c h a s [a/3] w i t h n u m b e r s . s h o w e d that
.
159)
w e n t f r o m this t o s h o w that t h e e q u a t i o n re-
that the
distributive law was
mann
a n d ris
(4,1,1;
T h i s i s e s s e n t i a l l y a v e c t o r e q u a t i o n ( i n w h i c h pau pa2 . vectors).
/c's
numbers:
in
On t h e basis of t h e s e facts Grass-
the e q u a t i o n g i v e n above, the p's
could be
d e l e t e d to y i e l d an e q u a t i o n s u c h as aa + fo/3 . . . w h e r e a, b, . . . r e p r e s e n t n u m b e r s ; a , f3, . . . e l e m e n t s o r p o i n t s ; a n d a a w a s c o n s i d e r e d a w e i g h t e d p o i n t . (4,1,1;
160-163)
73
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
Grassmann, analysis
in
previously He then be
unlike
close
established
of the
Grassmann
by
a
weights to
developed vectorial laws
his
ideas
in
system and
proving
point whose
laws
weight was
individual points.
(4,1,1;
point
in
for
fact
points.
equal
to the
164) T h i s
led
consider a point of 0 weight, w h i c h he s h o w e d was a v e c t o r . (4,1,1;
164-166) T h e final topic in the
part of this chapter concerned the result obtained w h e n
a p o i n t or a m u l t i p l e p o i n t w a s a d d e d to a vector. The
of
used
sum of a n u m b e r of weighted points could
single of the
best interpreted as theoretical
to
vectorial
s h o w e d that the
represented
sum
Mobius,
relation
a p p l i e d parts
of the
chapter dealt with
(4,1,1;
166-167)
such topics
as
geo-
metrical m e t h o d s for constructing s u m points and physical applications
of his
made
reference
point
analysis.
to
In
this
part of the
chapter Grassmann
Mobius:
W e are h e r e a t t h e first a n d o n l y p o i n t a t w h i c h our science touches o n ideas already k n o w n . addition of simple primarily only as the
same
N a m e l y in the barycentric calculus of M o b i u s an
and multiple
points
is
presented.
M5bius used it
an abbreviated m e t h o d of expression but developed
techniques
of calculations
which
we
presented (in
greater
g e n e r a l i t y ) i n t h e first paragraphs o f this chapter. W h a t i s e n t i r e l y l a c k i n g in M o b i u s presentation is the conception of s u m as a magnitude in the case w h e r e t h e w e i g h t s t o g e t h e r total zero. W h a t h i n d e r e d the sagacious author o f that w o r k i n v i e w i n g this s u m as a vector of constant l e n g t h a n d d i r e c t i o n is certainly the strangeness of c o m p o u n d i n g length a n d direction into one concept. If that s u m h a d b e e n d e t e r m i n e d to be a vector, then the concept of the addition and s u b t r a c t i o n o f v e c t o r s f o r g e o m e t r y (as w e h a v e p r e s e n t e d i t i n S e c t i o n I, C h a p t e r I) w o u l d have arisen, a n d thus our w o r k w o u l d have had a s e c o n d p o i n t o f contact w i t h M o b i u s ' w o r k ; also the b a r y c e n t r i c calculus w o u l d h a v e o b t a i n e d a m u c h f r e e r a n d m o r e g e n e r a l d e v e l o p m e n t . (4,1,1; 172) In
the
mann chapter P — a, [a/3]
second
chapter of the
introduced he that
had is,
the
outer
s t a t e d t h a t [a/3] as
second
should be
a vector from
s h o u l d be v i e w e d ,
section
multiplication
a
t o /3.
of
of his
book
points^
In
interpreted as
(4,1,1;
165-166)
Grass-
the first equal
to
However
n o t s i m p l y a s t h e v e c t o r a/3, b u t a s a v e c t o r
l i m i t e d t o p o s i t i o n s i n t h e l i n e t h r o u g h a a n d /3, t h a t i s , ( t o u s e t h e modern (the
term)
line
from
as a
a
line-bound
point
to
the
vector. same
(4,1,1;
point
is
179)* S i n c e no
line)
[pp] = 0
and
since
[ p a ] — — [ a p ] ( b e c a u s e [ p a ] = a — p = — ( p — a) = — [ a p ] ) , [ a / 3 ] s h o u l d be v i e w e d as an outer multiplication. It is mann's
(4,1,1;
175)
not necessary for present purposes to f o l l o w in detail Grasshighly
abstract
and
complicated development of the outer
product for points. Rather it n e e d only be noted that here as before Grassmann continually
74
made
use
of vectors and vector relations in
Other Early Vectorial
developing
the
outer
product.
Finally
this
section
may
Systems
be
sum-
marized through the use of Grassmann's o w n s u m m a r y as presented in
his
der
paper
of
1845
entitled
"Kurze
Uebersicht
iiber das
Wesen
4 9
Ausdehnungslehre."
I f A , B , C , D , are points, t h e n w e m e a n b y (1) A . B , t h e l i n e , w h i c h has A a n d B
as e x t r e m i t i e s , r e g a r d e d as a
definite part of the infinite right line d e t e r m i n e d by A and B; (2) A . B . C , t h e
triangle,
whose
vertices
are A, B, C, r e g a r d e d as a
definite part of the infinite plane d e t e r m i n e d by A, B, C; ( 3 ) A.B.C.D,
the
tetra[h]edron,
whose
vertices
are
A,
B,
C,
D,
re-
g a r d e d as a d e f i n i t e part of i n f i n i t e space. That
is,
we
put A . B = A1.B1,
when
both
products
represent equal
p'ts, w i t h like signs, of the same r i g h t l i n e ; f u r t h e r A . B . C ^ A ^ B ^ C ^
w h e n b o t h triangles are e q u a l parts, w i t h l i k e signs, o f t h e same p l a n e ; and finally A.B.C.D
=
Ax.Bi.C1.D1,
w h e n b o t h t e t r a [ h ] e d r o n s h a v e e q u a l v o l u m e s , w i t h l i k e signs.50 The
applied
section
ordinate
systems,
plane
terms
in
of
this
chapter
treated
such
topics
as
co-
transformations of co-ordinates, the equation of a
of points,
and
cluding the representation
n u m e r o u s applications to statics, in-
o f static
moments and equilibrium con-
ditions. The than
materials
discussed
two-thirds
to
dealt w i t h what Grassmann the
regressive
characterized
product. by
factors is zero;
this
of Grassmann's
the
point constituted
book.
called
The
"Das
that
the
more
last c h a p t e r
eingewandte Produkt," or
He pointed out that the
property
slightly
next to the
product
outer product was of two
dependent
since this property was not essential to the ideas of
a product,
a
restriction.
(4,1,1;
new
product could 206)
Thus
be
defined which was
Grassmann
free
of this
introduced his regressive
product, or, m o r e accurately, he extended the concept of product in such a w a y that the
regressive
and outer products could be treated
as t w o forms of one product. As E n g e l pointed out in his notes, this complicated the presentation. An
idea of Grassmann's
the following.
(4,1,1; 4 0 8 )
regressive
product may be
gained from
It is natural to ask if a n y m e a n i n g m a y be a s s i g n e d to
the p r o d u c t of t w o factors,
some of w h o s e c o m p o n e n t s are m u t u a l l y
dependent
multiplication
as
Similarly
any
o f factors
may be
viewed
taking place w i t h i n a system of some order, for example, three-
or four-dimensional space. W h e n the s u m of the orders of the factors exceeds the order of the space u n d e r consideration, the factors m u s t
75
A
History
be
of V e c t o r Analysis
dependent.
gressive
It was
product.
this further;
for this case that G r a s s m a n n d e f i n e d t h e re-
T w o
quotations
from
Grassmann
will
explicate
the first quotation is from his " K u r z e Uebersicht" and
is m o r e general than the second, w h i c h is f r o m the latter part of the chapter under discussion and w h i c h gives a geometrical interpretation
of the
regressive
product.
Henceforth outer multiplication will be designated by simply writing the
factors
tween where is
together;
the A,
B,
C
as
a
treated
referred time.
to
regressive
factors.
the
(4,1,1;
are
understand
by
the
any
magnitudes,
the
product
co-efficient field
multiplication,
We
belonging
of lowest
to
order
in
A,
by
a point placed be-
regressive provided
which A,
product
ABC .A,
B,
that
and C
in the lie
AB.AC, which
ABC
product at
the
be same
310-311)
T h e product of t w o line magnitudes in the plane is the point of intersection of the t w o lines j o i n e d w i t h a part of that plane as factor; if for example
ab
a n d ac
magnitudes, three
line
then
(where
their
magnitudes
a, b, c r e p r e s e n t points) are t h e t w o l i n e
product in
the
is
abc.a.
plane
is
Furthermore equal
to the
the
product of
d o u b l e d surface
c o n t e n t (set t w i c e a s factor) o f t h e t r i a n g l e e n c l o s e d b y t h e lines, m u l t i plied by the
p r o d u c t o f the three quotients, w h i c h express h o w m a n y
t i m e s e a c h s i d e i s c o n t a i n e d i n its c o r r e s p o n d i n g l i n e m a g n i t u d e ; t h u s if a,
b,
c are
those three points,
a n d mab,
nac, pbc ( w h e n m ,
n,
p are
n u m e r i c a l m a g n i t u d e s ) are the three l i n e m a g n i t u d e s , t h e n their p r o d u c t is e q u a l to mnp.abc.abc T h e p r o d u c t of t w o plane magnitudes in space is part of the intersecting edge
m u l t i p l i e d b y a p a r t o f s p a c e , f o r e x a m p l e , abc.abd —
abed. ab.
Furthermore the product of three plane magnitudes is the intersection p o i n t of t h e t h r e e planes, m u l t i p l i e d by t w o parts of space, for example, abc.abd.acd= The
above
pose, does partly
abed.abed.
in
(4,1,1;
description,
which
243-244) is
sufficient
for
the
present pur-
scant justice to the complexities of this chapter.
mitigated
deleted
a.
by
the
the
fact
Ausdehnungslehre
that of
some 1862,
ideas and
in
this
many
This is
chapter were
of the
develop-
ments were approached from a different point of view. T h e chapter concluded
with
geometrical
applications.
T h e final chapter in the book was devoted mainly to applications of the
previous
ideas
to
geometry and to crystallography. T h e final
section of the chapter was
entitled "Remark on the O p e n Product."
This section is of special importance since Gibbs argued that it contained " t h e key to the theory of matrices .
.
and the linear vector
function.51 Before the reception accorded to Grassmann's w o r k is discussed, it will above
76
be
useful
detailed
to
state t h e m a j o r c o n c l u s i o n s e m e r g i n g f r o m the
discussion
of
his
first
Ausdehnungslehre.
First,
it
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
should be evident that it was a w o r k of great brilliance, a w o r k that along with
much
else
contained
a large
v o l v e d in m o d e r n vector analysis.
n u m b e r of the
ideas
in-
It s h o u l d also be clear that e v e n
if priority disputes are j u d g e d by date of p u b l i c a t i o n (thus e x c l u d i n g Grassmann's
Theorie
der
Ebbe
und
Flut),
Grassmann's
ideas
as
p u b l i s h e d i n 1844 w e r e far m o r e e x t e n s i v e a n d r i c h e r t h a n t h o s e o f H a m i l t o n at the same time. T h e r e is merit to Sarton's remark that Grassmann's Hamilton's
Ausdehnungslehre Lectures
on
of
1844
Quaternions
should
of
1853,
be not
compared with
with
Hamilton's
early researches.52 Grassmann's b o o k is a great classic in t he history of mathematics,
even
though one
of t h e mosc u n r e a d a b l e classics.
T h e w o r k was exceedingly abstract a n d very c o m p l i c a t e d and, perhaps most importantly, it departed from all the then current mathematical traditions. E v e n in the early sections of the book the reader encountered h i g h l y original ideas and at most tenuously
placed in a philosophic setting
attached to
the
mathematical
ideas
of the
time. In order for a m a t h e m a t i c i a n of that t i m e to
derive the
modern
system of vector analysis from Grassmann's book, he w o u l d have to (1) r e a d a n d u n d e r s t a n d t h e b o o k ( n o s m a l l t a s k ) , (2) d e l e t e m a j o r mathematical
portions
of the
book
(such
as
point
analysis),
(3)
l i m i t t h e p r e s e n t a t i o n t o t h r e e - d i m e n s i o n a l s p a c e , (4) r e d e f i n e s o m e o f t h e f u n d a m e n t a l i d e a s ( s u c h a s t h e o u t e r p r o d u c t ) , (5) c h a n g e t h e structure
and
from
philosophical
the
emphasis
of the ideas
work,
(6)
detach
contained in
it,
the
a n d (7)
presentation attach
to
it
ideas already in the literature of the times, b u t u n k n o w n to Grassmann, such as the development of the geometrical representation of complex n u m b e r s and the theorems of G r e e n a n d Gauss. No one at that t i m e or at a later t i m e a c c o m p l i s h e d these seven labors;
that
this was so is not surprising. It w i l l presently be s h o w n that m o r e than t w e n t y years
passed before
someone accomplished even the
f i r s t o f these, t h a t is, b e f o r e a n y o n e r e a d a n d u n d e r s t o o d a n d f u l l y appreciated
VII. In
The the
Grassmann's
Period from period
Grassmann's events,
work
which
1844
from
a n u m b e r of events
book.
to
the
1862
Ausdehnungslehre
of
1844
to
that
of 1862
took place w h i c h shed light on the relation of to
will
the be
mathematical discussed
narrative of Grassmann's activities
ideas of the times.
within
the
framework
These of
the
in this period, range in variety
from the discovery a n d publication by others of ideas contained in Grassmann's
system to the reading of Grassmann's book by Hamil-
77
A History
of V e c t o r Analysis
ton.
The
tion
accorded Grassmann's
primary concern
Friedrich this
Engel
reception Thus
of this section is discussion of the recepwork.
accurately described the magnitude and form of
in the following statement:
Grassmann
experienced
what
must
be
the
most
painful
ex-
p e r i e n c e for the author of a n e w w o r k : his book n o w h e r e r e c e i v e d attention; the p u b l i c was c o m p l e t e l y silent about it; there was no one w h o d i s c u s s e d i t o r e v e n p u b l i c l y f o u n d f a u l t w i t h it. T h e m a t h e m a t i c i a n s t o w h o m h e h a d sent t h e w o r k e x p r e s s e d t h e m s e l v e s a s not u n f r i e n d l y t o it, t o s o m e e x t e n t e v e n a s b e n e v o l e n t t o it, b u t n o o n e r e a l l y s t u d i e d it. (5; 97) Engel's given
statement
the
book
mathematician
is
well
illustrated by considering the reception
by the
man generally esteemed as the most gifted
of
period—Carl
the
Friedrich
Gauss.
apparently sent a copy of his book to Gauss, and the with
a
note
of thanks he
had
dated
worked
December
stated
that
on
before
and had published some
similar of his
14,
1844.
ideas
Grassmann
latter r e p l i e d
Therein
Gauss
nearly a half century
results
in
1831; Gauss was
probably referring to his w o r k on the geometrical representation of numbers.53
complex
Gauss
also
stated that he
was
very busy and
that he h a d c o n c l u d e d that to get at the kernel of the w o r k it w o u l d be
necessary
lichen) Gauss
to
familiarize
terminology never
used
himself with
in
the
book.
the peculiar (eigenthiim-
(4,1,11;
398)
This
it seems
did.
T h e reaction of Mobius to Grassmann's work should prove illuminating,
for of all
mathematicians
best position to judge visited asked
Mobius Mobius
at Leipzig, to
of the
period
Mobius
Grassmann's work. Thus in
write
and in
a review
was in the
1844 Grassmann
a l e t t e r o f O c t o b e r 10,
of his book.
He wrote:
1844, he
"Finally I
take the liberty of asking y o u to w r i t e a r e v i e w of the w o r k for some critical journal,
for
I
am
c o n v i n c e d that just as n o w no one stands
nearer the ideas expressed in the w o r k than you, no one will be in a better position than you to judge the work so fundamentally and to bring to may
light both
contain."
nearly I
(5;
the 99)
four months reply that I
kindred
spirit,
weaknesses
and whatever merits
Mobius' reply was
dated
the book
February 2,
1845,
later:
was but
sincerely pleased to have c o m e to m e e t in y o u a our
kinship
relates
only
to
mathematics,
not
to
p h i l o s o p h y . As I r e m e m b e r t e l l i n g y o u in person, I am a stranger to the area of p h i l o s o p h i c speculation.
The
philosophic element in
y o u r ex-
c e l l e n t w o r k , w h i c h lies at t h e basis of t h e m a t h e m a t i c a l e l e m e n t , I am not prepared to appreciate in the correct manner or even to understand properly.
78
Of this
I
have
become
sufficiently aware
in
the
course
of
Other Early Vectorial
numerous
attempts
to
study
your
work
Systems
without interruption;
in
each
case h o w e v e r I h a v e b e e n s t o p p e d b y t h e g r e a t p h i l o s o p h i c a l g e n e r a l i t y . (5; 100) However named
Mobius
wrote
Drobisch
would write that the
who
a r e v i e w (he
Engel
(5;
recorded
had a
contacted
philosopher
d i d not).
Mobius
a
mathematician
and
hoped
that
he
went on to recommend
Friedrich
100-101)
an
illuminating
Apelt
Jena, and M o b i u s . to
he
also
best procedure m i g h t be for Grassmann h i m s e l f to p u b l i s h
a r e v i e w (he did!).
Ernst
that
was
exchange
(1812-1859),
of
professor
letters of
between
philosophy
at
On September 3,1845, Apelt wrote the following
Mobius: Have only
you
from
read
Grassmann's
Grunert's
mathematics
lies
Archiv;
at
matical knowledge,
its its
it
strange
seems
foundation.
to The
intuitiveness
Ausdehnungslehre?
me that a false essential
I
know
it
p h i l o s o p h y of
character of mathe-
(Anschaulichkeit),
seems
to
have
b e e n e x p e l l e d f r o m the work. Such an abstract theory of extension as he seeks c o u l d o n l y b e d e v e l o p e d f r o m concepts. B u t t h e source o f m a t h e m a t i c a l k n o w l e d g e lies n o t i n c o n c e p t s b u t i n i n t u i t i o n . (5; Mobius
in a letter dated January 5,
You this
I
ask
me
whether
I
have
101)
1846, responded:
read
Grassmann's
Ausdehnungslehre.
To
answered that Grassmann h i m s e l f presented me w i t h a copy and
that I have on n u m e r o u s occasions a t t e m p t e d to study it b u t have never gone
b e y o n d the first sheets,
since,
as
you
mentioned,
intuitiveness
(Anschaulichkeit), the essential character of mathematical thought, is not to be found in the work. H o w e v e r I have been forcing myself through the w o r k by s k i m m i n g it on n u m e r o u s occasions in regard to extension or g e n e r a l i t y a s y o u w o u l d p r e f e r t o c a l l it. F r o m t h i s I h a v e c o m e t o f e e l that it can be influential in a g o o d w a y for mathematics, especially in regard to the
systematic presentation
o f its
elements. To this belongs
the a d d i t i o n a n d s u b t r a c t i o n o f lines w h e n these are c o n s i d e r e d not o n l y i n r e l a t i o n t o t h e i r l e n g t h b u t also t h e i r d i r e c t i o n . (5; Partly on
the
basis of the above letters a n d on the translation of
"Anschaulichkeit" major reason "the
for
as
the
contemporary
intuitiveness
Ernest
Nagel
To
Nagel's
views
suggested that a
poor reception of Grassmann's
scene
was
dominated by
i n d i s p e n s a b i l i t y of i n t u i t i o n for m a t h e m a t i c s .
Writing in
101)
may
be
added
the
work
was
Kantian views .
.
on
that the
."54
opinions
of A.
E.
Heath.
1917, H e a t h a r g u e d that a m a j o r reason for t h e p o o r re-
ception was the philosophical
nature of the book, a condition com-
p o u n d e d by a reaction against a philosophical f o r m of presentation that h a d set in a m o n g m a t h e m a t i c i a n s
as
a result of " t h e exaggera-
tions of the metaphysical unification of k n o w l e d g e in the schools of Schelling
and
Hegel."
5 5
In
any
case
Grassmann's
book
provoked
79
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
the
following
comment
from
Heinrich
Mobius had recommended the book: to enter into those thoughts; fore
my
eyes
Baltzer:
when
I
Richard
Baltzer,
to
whom
" i t is not n o w possible for me
I b e c o m e d i z z y a n d see s k y - b l u e be-
read them."
(5;
102)
Mobius wrote back to
"If, as you write me, you have not relished Grassmann's
Ausdehnungslehre,
I
reply
that
I
have
the
same
experience.
I
like-
w i s e h a v e m a n a g e d to get t h r o u g h no m o r e t h a n the first t w o sheets ( B o g e n ) o f h i s b o o k . " (5;
102)
Grassmann had sent a copy of the w o r k to Johann August Grunert, founder
and
Grunert
editor
encountered
of
the
serious
Archiv
der
difficulties
Mathematik
und
Physik.
in reading the work and
requested Grassmann to write a r e v i e w of his book for publication in
t h e Archiv a n d t o g i v e s o m e s i m p l e e x a m p l e s .
Grassmann did, and in der
appeared.56
Ausdehnungslehre"
book
was
neither
understanding stated,
completely
the
102-103) This
work.
It
Grassmann's
representative
was
s u m m a r y of his
nor
however, as
a
major
other publication
Elektrodynamik,"57 f o u n d through his fate
of
his
contained
of
an
n e w system
1845,
his
important
aid
to
Grassmann himself
the only r e v i e w of his book that was published.
Grassmann's
the
(5;
1845 his " K u r z e U b e r s i c h t u b e r das W e s e n
(4,1,11; 3 )
" N e u e Theorie der electrical
discovery
of mathematics. This paper shared
Ausdehnungslehre;
the
significance
of
Grassmann's
d i s c o v e r y was o n l y r e a l i z e d after C l a u s i u s in the 1870's p u b l i s h e d the same result, w i t h o u t of course k n o w i n g of Grassmann's earlier discovery.
(5;
104-105)
T h e o n l y recognition that Grassmann r e c e i v e d at this t i m e for his mathematical "Die
investigations
Geometrische
February 2,
1845,
to
Jablonowskischen for the creation system
for the
Grassmann prize
in
offered
notify
in
regard
Mobius
him
Gesellschaft
of an
to
a
had written
paper
entitled
Grassmann
on
1844 a n n o u n c e m e n t of the
der Wissenschaft
offering
a prize
of a s y s t e m s i m i l a r to (or for t h e e x t e n s i o n of) t h e
sketched
published
came
Analyse."
by
Leibniz
first
the
time
rather
for the
in in
his
letter
1833.
delightful
completion
(5;
to
Huygens
109)
position
Mobius'
of
1679,
letter put
of being aware
of a
of a task j u d g e d significant by a
scientific g r o u p , w h i c h task G r a s s m a n n h a d already a c c o m p l i s h e d . Grassmann gekniipft teristik. prize
und The to
die
sis;
80
came
to
von
Leibnitz
Jablonowskische
Grassmann's
appendix by
of
thus
write
his
Gesellschaft
work58
and
Die
Geometrische
erfundene in
published
geometrische 1846 it
in
Analyse Charak-
awarded 1847
with
the an
Mobius.59 T h e w o r k does not d e m a n d detailed analy-
it m a y be noted that Grassmann i n c l u d e d a thorough treatment his
inner
product
(the
modern
dot
product),
which
he
had
Other Early Vectorial
neglected
to
do
in
his
Ausdehnungslehre
of
1844.
Systems
Though
this
paper had major defects in presentation, it was more readable than his
Ausdehnungslehre;
neglect. In
(5;
its
fate
however
was
the
same:
colossal
111-118)
1847 Grassmann attempted to secure a university position. He
wrote to with
Eichhorn, the
his
letter
Prussian minister for culture, and i n c l u d e d
copies
of
his
principal
mathematical
Eichhorn asked the noted mathematician report on
the
Kummer's about
significance
Grassmann's
Kummer's
lack
was
of
less
than
others
a
month. as
was
In a n y case
great
mixed
clarity.
negative judgment
and
greatness
of Grassmann's
report scant praise
mathematical
works.
Probably
a
major
K u m m e r joined the who
achievement.
In
with repeated statements cause
that K u m m e r had the
mathematicians
of Grassmann's
writings.
Ernst Eduard K u m m e r t o
failed
Thus
to
of
works
ranks
for
of Gauss
appreciate
the
no professorship was
o f f e r e d , n o r i n fact w a s o n e e v e r o f f e r e d t o G r a s s m a n n . (5; 1 2 3 - 1 3 0 ) Three
mathematicians
take
notice
they
were
of
of this
Grassmann's
Adhemar
period
work
Barre,
were
forced,
because
Comte
de
of
as
it were, to
priority
questions;
Saint-Venant
(1797-1886),
Augustin C a u c h y (1789-1857), a n d Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n H a m i l t o n . Saint-Venant was elasticity, w h o in sommes
et
simplifier ideas
les la
differences
similar
his
or
7
identical
system
paper
engineer,
noted for his researches in
geometriques,
Mecanique."
Grassmannian began
a French
1845 p u b l i s h e d a p a p e r e n t i t l e d " M e m o i r e sur les
by
This to
and to
some
modern
stating:
n u m b e r w h a t e v e r of lines
paper
"I
a,
b,
et
sur
leur
contained
ideas
fundamental
vector analysis.
call
the
usage
to
the
Saint-Venant
geometrical
c, . . . g i v e n
pour
mathematical
sum
of
any
in m a g n i t u d e , direc-
tion, a n d sense a l i n e w h i c h is e q u a l a n d parallel to t h e last side of a polygon
of w h i c h
end,
in
each
its
I = a + b + c . the
.
.
"difference
ferentielle
geometriques."
call
other
."
the
sides are a, b, c, .
sense.
(7;
620)
If
(7;
areas
620)
This
product
or
and
and of the
geometrical
I
is
the
last
. . p l a c e d e n d to side,
then
I
write
S a i n t - V e n a n t t h e n p r o c e e d e d to d e f i n e
geometrique,"
geometrique";
sum of plane I
the
proper
vector the
was
subtraction;
"coefficients
followed
by a
the
"dif-
differentiels
definition
of the
"produit geometrique." (of
a
line
b
multiplied
by
a
line
a,
designated a b) the area obtained, b o t h in m a g n i t u d e a n d d i r e c t i o n , in forming a parallelogram from those t w o lines d r a w n from the same point. T h e positive face is that on w h i c h a is on the left a n d b is on the right. T h u s a a — 0 a n d b a = —a b. I
call
the
geometrical
product
of
an
area
multiplied
by
a
line
the
v o l u m e of t h e p a r a l l e l e p i p e d (or t h e o b l i q u e p r i s m ) h a v i n g t h e area for a base a n d the sides e q u a l a n d parallel to the g i v e n line. T h e v o l u m e is
81
A
History
of V e c t o r Analysis
c o n s i d e r e d n e g a t i v e w h e n t h e sides are o n t h e n e g a t i v e side o f t h e base. a b c w i l l d e s i g n a t e t h e p r o d u c t of t h e area b c m u l t i p l i e d by t h e l i n e a. (7; 6 2 1 ) Thus
Saint-Venant
had
discovered
vectorial
addition,
subtrac-
tion, differentiation, a n d also a m u l t i p l i c a t i o n similar to the m o d e r n cross
product, the major difference b e t w e e n t h e m b e i n g that Saint-
Venant's
product was,
spatially
oriented
equations brief
Grassmann's,
Saint-Venant
not another vector, but a
then
stated
that
geometric
can be added, subtracted, and multiplied and made very
mention
vectors.
like
area.
(7;
of
the
possibility
of
integration
and
division
for
621) T h e ideas m e n t i o n e d to this point w e r e treated in
t w o pages by Saint-Venant; thus his paper is best seen as a sketch of the fundamentals of a vector analysis. pages
of the
paper
suggested
how
The
final
his
ideas
paper
nor
three and one-half
could
be
applied to
mechanics. Though mann
neither
question
as
letter does gan
to
to
out
to
his
what
contain
work
response that
Saint-Venant's
his
letters
to
Grass-
(those p u b l i s h e d by Engel) allow us to answer the interesting motivated
Saint-Venant
to
his
information concerning when
his ideas.
In
a
letter
(quoted
initial
ideas
came
a letter of July earlier)
in
1832,
in
creation,
one
Saint-Venant be-
17,
which
1847, w r i t t e n in
Grassmann
stated
Saint-Venant commented:
"It
was thus around
1832 that I first came to the idea of extending the
use
signs
of algebraic
to
those
geometrical
operations
which
are
p e r f o r m e d on lines a n d areas in m e c h a n i c s , b u t I p u b l i s h e d n o t h i n g until
1 8 4 5 . " (5;
and motivation
122) A l t h o u g h the q u e s t i o n of t h e sources of ideas for Saint-Venant m a y not be a n s w e r e d definitively,
some indication as to the possible sources m a y be given. It is very improbable
that
Grassmann's
he
was
stimulated
by
the
work
of Mobius
or
of
father, since Saint-Venant had great difficulty in read-
ing German.60 Since the writings of Argand, Servois, Buee, Mourey, Warren,
and
numbers
on
the
geometrical
published
before
representation
to
which
presumably
Saint-Venant
had
but
direct
evidence
lacking,
Saint-Venant
is
1832
stimulated by one or more of these men.61
and
of complex
all
languages possible,
Gauss
were
that
were
written
access,
it
in is
was
Saint-Venant's influence
on later writers was at most v e r y small.62 Grassmann April a
18,
letter
had
heard
for
Saint-Venant
taneously
Grassmann
dehnungslehre
and
copy
82
of Saint-Venant's
paper by
1847,
and on
1847, G r a s s m a n n w r o t e to A u g u s t i n C a u c h y a n d enclosed
of the
book
whose
mailed
requested to
address
to
Cauchy
Saint-Venant.
he
Cauchy to (5;
did two
give
not know. copies
the
letter
120-121) T h e
of
Simulhis
and
Ausone
part of Grass-
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
mann's letter w h i c h contained statements concerning the history of his discoveries has already b e e n q u o t e d ; t h e r e m a i n d e r i n c l u d e d a statement
of priority and a discussion
developed inner
in
his
Ausdehnungslehre
of some
(in
materials
particular,
the
not fully linear
or
product).
On July
17,
received the
1847, Saint-Venant w r o t e to G r a s s m a n n that he h a d letter but
send h i m the book.
not the book;
(5;
he requested Grassmann to
122) G r a s s m a n n a s s u m e d that C a u c h y h a d
been delayed in giving the book to Saint-Venant, and on January 27,
1848, he w r o t e to Saint-Venant a n d sent h i m a c o p y of his " D i e
Geometrische Analyse," along w i t h another paper. Grassmann d i d not
send
the
his
copy
mann's
Ausdehnungslehre
sent
"Die
to
him
nor
did
Geometrische
Analyse"
t h e r w i t h G r a s s m a n n a t t h i s t i m e . (5; In
Cauchy
for Saint-Venant.
give
Saint-Venant
Saint-Venant read Grass-
but d i d not correspond fur122)
1853 another priority question was raised by a p u b l i c a t i o n of
that
year
in
entitled "clefs
the
"Sur
Comptes
les
rendus,
clefs
algebriques"
authored by A u g u s t i n
algebriques."
or
algebraic
63
keys
Cauchy,
Cauchy's was
paper
primarily
on
and his
directed
toward p r o v i d i n g m e t h o d s for dealing w i t h algebraic problems, in general, the
finding
of u n k n o w n s in equations. A v e r y s i m p l e ex-
a m p l e w i l l i l l u s t r a t e b o t h h i s m e t h o d a n d its r e l e v a n c e . G i v e n t h e equations
x + 3y = 11
algebraic
keys,
i
and
a n d j,
Ax + 2y = 14,
which
behave
we
so
introduce
two
that i • i = j • j = 0
may
and
i - j = —j - i. We t h e n m u l t i p l y e a c h e q u a t i o n by o n e k e y a n d o b t a i n xi + 3yi = 1 1 i
and 4xj + 2yj =
14j.
we
equation
f o r m Ax + By = K, w h e r e A = i + 4 j ,
obtain
an
B = 3i + 2 j , (Ax + laws
By)B as
and
=
i
K =
K(B).
a n d j,
of t h e
l l i + 14j.
If we n o w a d d these equations,
From
this
we
S i n c e A, B, a n d K o b e y t h e the
above
equation
obtain
the
same
equation
multiplication
b e c o m e s ABx = KB, w h i c h c a n
KB be transformed into x =
=
(lli +
T h u s we obtain
AB
1 4 ; ) ( 3 t + 2jy)
=
(» + 4 j ) ( 3 < + 2 j ) The
significance
equivalent to
of this
2ij + 1 2 j i
is
that
Cauchy's
- 2 0ij
=
nearly
=
-10»j keys
are
Grassmann's extensive magnitudes
latter's outer m u l t i p l i c a t i o n . Ausdehnungslehre
( 2 2 ij + 4 2 \ j i )
algebraically
in regard to the
M o r e o v e r Grassmann d e v e l o p e d in his
identical
algebraic
methods.65
Grassmann probably first learned of Cauchy's publications in the following way. ing
the
B a l t z e r o n J u n e 14, 1853, w r o t e t o M o b i u s c o n c e r n -
identity
those
of Grassmann.
Mobius then wrote to Grassmann on September 2,
of Cauchy's
methods
with
1853, to i n f o r m
83
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
h i m of Cauchy's publication and to suggest that Grassmann make a c l a i m for priority. Grassmann "De
(5;
(5;
172-175) At the same time Mobius informed
172)
of a
Interpretation 66
determinants/' Cauchy's this,
to
those
keys
could
made he
be
des
interpreted
mathematical
Saint-Venant
though
of 1853 by
Saint-Venant entitled
clefs
algebriques
et
des
T h e aim of Saint-Venant's paper was to show h o w
show the
Venant
paper
geometrique
no
had
presented
priority
mentioned
geometrically and,
in
relationship of Cauchy's
claim
in
for
Grassmann's
his
paper
himself linear
or
of
or
1845.
for
inner
doing
ideas
to
Saint-
Grassmann, product
in
a
footnote. On
February
19,
1854, G r a s s m a n n w r o t e to M o b i u s that illness
h a d d e l a y e d h i m in seeing Cauchy's papers, b u t that he h a d finally managed to travel from
Stettin to Berlin to read them. Grassmann
had decided to claim priority through a letter to the F r e n c h Academy and through a publication
i n C r e l l e ' s Journal.
(5;
176-182) His
letter to the French A c a d e m y was read on April 17,1854, and stimulated the A c a d e m y to form a committee to investigate the priority question.
The
C a u c h y (!);
committee
was
no decision was
composed
haps because of Cauchy's death in paper les
for
C r e l l e ' s Journal
differents
genres
Lame,
Binet,
and
M a y , 1857. (5; 198) G r a s s m a n n ' s
appeared
de
of
h a n d e d d o w n by the committee, per-
in
1855
under
multiplication."67
the
Herein
title
"Sur
Grassmann
claimed priority over Cauchy and Saint-Venant and published some new of
results,
in
particular the
definition
of sixteen
different kinds
multiplication. On
December
16,
1856,
S a i n t - V e n a n t ( p r o b a b l y a t C a u c h y ' s re-
quest) wrote to Grassmann that he had never received the copy of the
Ausdehnungslehre
and
had
been
p l a i n e d that this fact was the
unable
to
find
a
copy.
He
ex-
cause of his slighting Grassmann in
his paper of 1853, a n d he requested Grassmann to i n f o r m h i m as to how
a
copy
of
the
Ausdehnungslehre
might
be
obtained.
(5;
199-
200) G r a s s m a n n r e p l i e d in a letter of M a r c h 28, 1857, a letter that is
typical
of Grassmann's
patience
and
good
nature.
Grassmann
stated that his book was in the library of the French Institute, but w r o n g l y classified; copy
of
the
that he had b e l i e v e d Cauchy had passed on the
Ausdehnungslehre
to
Saint-Venant,
so
that
another
copy had not b e e n sent directly to h i m ; and that he was sending to Saint-Venant a copy of his book and of a paper and was translating parts of b o t h so that Saint-Venant c o u l d read t h e m m o r e easily. He also a s k e d S a i n t - V e n a n t t o pass o n t h e l e t t e r t o C a u c h y a n d t o t e l l C a u c h y of his
high respect for him.
from Saint-Venant.
84
(5; 2 0 0 - 2 0 1 )
There
is
no record of a reply
Other Early Vectorial
In
Grassmann's
Cauchy:
Ausdehnungslehre
of
1862
he
stated
in
Systems
regard
to
"I have no intention of accusing the famous mathematician
o f p l a g i a r i s m . . . . " (4,1,11; 9 - 1 0 ) V i c t o r S c h l e g e l h o w e v e r i n 1 8 7 8 explicitly
accused
publication believed Engel
that
he
that or
strongly
of plagiarism
went
too
Cauchy
did
not
criticized
(6;
38-39),
his judgment.68
reversed
Schlegel
argued
Ausdehnungslehre ever
Cauchy
of 1896
far
in
probably
remember
Cauchy
for
his
charge
either its
though
Friedrich
a
of plagiarism.
did
not
contents.
not
in
Engel
read
Engel
answering
the how-
Grassmann's
p r i o r i t y c l a i m . (5; 2 0 2 ) Another alternative may h o w e v e r be suggested. Cauchy was w e l l acquainted
with
Saint-Venant's
paper
of
1845
and
used
results
f r o m it in a p a p e r of 1849 e n t i t l e d " S u r les Q u a n t i t e s g e o m e t r i q u e s , et sur u n e m e t h o d e n o u v e l l e p o u r la resolution des equations algebriques
de degre
quelconque."
69
M o r e o v e r this
paper shows that
Cauchy had a good k n o w l e d g e of the w o r k of Argand, Servois, and Buee
on
complex
numbers;
and papers by C a u c h y of 1853 make M o b i u s ' works.70 T h u s
clear that C a u c h y k n e w of H a m i l t o n ' s
and
it
knowledgeable
can
be
suggested
works
done
charge
brought by
part
of the
"clefs
that Cauchy
independently
of
Grassmann
methods
was
published
algebriques."
was
Grassmann
by
and
that
appropriate Cauchy
in
only his
in
relevant
the in
priority
regard
papers
on
to his
It was perfectly possible for C a u c h y to d r a w
on the sources m e n t i o n e d above for h e l p in creating his methods. A residuum of originality of course w o u l d remain, and it is in regard to that r e s i d u u m that a priority dispute w o u l d be in order. Saint-Venant and Cauchy were not the only mathematicians w h o encountered Grassmann
firmly
lodged in a d o m a i n that they had
previousJy v i e w e d
as
Sir W i l l i a m R o w a n
Hamilton's surprise w h e n in some unrecorded
way
he
heard
of 1844. his
their o w n
of the
Stettin
discovery;
great m u s t have b e e n
schoolmaster
and
his
Ausdehnungslehre
P r o c u r i n g a c o p y of t h e b o o k , H a m i l t o n set to r e a d i n g it;
interesting c o m m e n t s are p r e s e r v e d in letters, in the m a r g i n s
of his copy of Grassmann's book, a n d in the historical preface to his Lectures it,
on
Quaternions.
The
latter
comments,
as
comprised (with the exception of Mobius'
fate
would
have
comments) the only
p u b l i s h e d d i s c u s s i o n o f G r a s s m a n n that a p p e a r e d b e f o r e t h e 1860's. It was
in late
historical a
letter
very
1852 that H a m i l t o n , w h o was t h e n p r e p a r i n g the
preface of October
original
to
his
26,
1852,
work. . . . which
Lectures,
read
Hamilton work,
the
wrote
if any,
the
Ausdehnungslehre. to
De
Morgan:
Germans,
In "a
if t h e y
t h i n k m e w o r t h n o t i c i n g , w i l l p e r h a p s set u p i n r i v a l s h i p w i t h m i n e , but which
I d i d not see till l o n g after m y o w n v i e w s w e r e f o r m e d
85
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
and
published."
book
(8;
424)
Hamilton continued to read Grassmann's
a n d on January 31,
I
1853, w r o t e the
following to
De
Morgan:
h a v e r e c e n t l y b e e n reading ( a n d i t i s c u r i o u s t h a t s o m e t i m e s , w h e n
o t h e r w i s e in m e n t a l activity, I seem to m y s e l f unable to read a page, or almost a sentence of G e r m a n ) m o r e t h a n a h u n d r e d pages of Grassmann's Ausdehnungslehre, only the
with
most
great
admiration
slight and
and
interest.
Previously
I
had
general knowledge of the book, and thought
t h a t i t w o u l d r e q u i r e m e t o l e a r n t o smoke i n o r d e r t o r e a d i t . I f I c o u l d h o p e to be put in rivalship w i t h D e s Cartes on the one hand, and w i t h Grassmann on the other, my scientific ambition w o u l d be fulfilled! But i t i s c u r i o u s t o see h o w n a r r o w l y , y e t h o w c o m p l e t e l y , G r a s s m a n f a i l e d to hit off the Quaternions. He p u b l i s h e d in 1844, a little later t h a n m y self, b u t w i t h t h e m o s t o b v i o u s a n d p e r f e c t i n d e p e n d e n c e . (8; 4 4 1 ) H a m i l t o n ' s c o m m e n t s as
given in a letter of February 2,
1853, are
I am n o t q u i t e so e n t h u s i a s t i c t o - d a y a b o u t G r a s s m a n n as I was w h e n I last w r o t e . B u t I h a v e r e a d t h r o u g h n e a r l y all of w h a t I c o u l d p r o c u r e of his
writings,
Mobius.
including
Grassmann
is
a a
subsequent great
and
commentary
(in
German)
most German genius;
space i s a t l e a s t a s n e w a n d c o m p r e h e n s i v e a s
by
his v i e w of
m i n e o f time; b u t h e h a s
not a n t i c i p a t e d , nor attained t h e c o n c e p t i o n of, the
quaternions, e v e n s o
nearly as I guessed he m i g h t have done, f r o m a notion hastily taken up, of w h a t
might
have
been
know
even
now),
quote
from
memory.
His
and
is
understand;
in
his
that
his
meaning
doctrine outer saying
of
( a n d w h a t i t was,
"eingewandte
products
(aiissere)
something
I
very d i m l y
multiplikation." I
think
that
for a person w h o
I
has
I do
not
l e a r n e d t o s m o k e . A n d e v e n h i s inner p r o d u c t s , p u b l i s h e d s u b s e q u e n t l y to
the
outer
ones
(in
1847),
I
"inner products"
of Grassmann
of a
and
quaternion,
notion
o f combining
his
them
can
swallow
have
much
"outer products"
h a d occurred to
pretty well. analogy to to
him,
my he
In
my
fact,
" v e c t o r parts." might
the
"scalar parts''
have
If the
been
led
to the quaternions; b u t those he seems to me to have altogether failed to perceive. have
a
Yet
I
better
t h i n k that chance
my o w n
of b e i n g
researches,
appreciated i n
or
these
speculations, w o u l d countries,
if readers
h a d first b e e n p u t t h r o u g h a sufficient course (or dose) of G r a s s m a n n . I m u s t say that I s h o u l d n o t fear t h e c o m p a r i s o n . Y o u tolerate e g o t i s m in correspondence . . . . De
Morgan
Christian
had
name
was
(8; 4 4 2 ) asked
Hamilton
the joke a n d e m b e l l i s h e d it in his if you
have
any curiosity
Nebuchadnezzarological shoulder is
at
Nebuchadnezzar.
to
know
reading
amused at the
one
point
if
Grassmann's
(8; 4 2 5 ) H a m i l t o n p i c k e d u p
letter of February 9,
1853:
anything of the result of my recent (my
daughter
looking
over
my
folly of philosophers), it w i l l be quite con-
s i s t e n t w i t h m y h u m o u r t o i n f o r m y o u . T o t h e p u b l i c I a m l i k e l y t o say b u t little a t p r e s e n t a b o u t G r a s s m a n n ; f o r I
find
adding
independently
lines,
whereas
I
except one
86
which
took
he
seems
to
have
that b e y o n d the rule for worked
out,
it from Warren, we have scarcely a result in c o m m o n ,
thing which
is
(in
my view)
important,
namely, the inter-
Other Early Vectorial
pretation He
of B
comes
to
preparations, knowing
— A,
where A and B
this,
in
and
his
page
d e n o t e points, a s t h e directed line AB.
139
of the
ostrich-stomach-needing
nothing
of
this
result,
Systems
as
in
Ausdehnungslehre, iron
any
after
previous
way
arrived
long
doses. at
by
I,
him,
S T A R T E D w i t h the same interpretation i n m y Lectures, i n 1848, h a v i n g printed
the
same
conception
some
years
earlier,
and
f a m i l i a r w i t h i t (see P u r e T i m e ) f o r a long t i m e b e f o r e . Hamilton's
published
his
on
Lectures
It
is
statement
Quaternions
proper
to
state
tion f o r i n c l i n e d l i n e s and
remarkable
Leipzig, from
here, by
which
invention
concerning
1853
is
that
(aiissere
work
1844),
the
of
as
a
having
been
(8; 4 4 4 )
Grassmann
given
in
follows:
species
o f non-commutative
multiplica-
M u l t i p l i k a t i o n ) occurs in a v e r y original
Prof.
H.
Grassmann
(Ausdehnungslehre,
I d i d not m e e t w i t h till after years h a d e l a p s e d
and
communication
of the
quaternions:
in
which
w o r k I have also n o t i c e d ( w h e n too late to a c k n o w l e d g e it e l s e w h e r e ) an
employment
(Strecke),
of
drawn
the
from
symbol
the
point
— a, a
to
to
the
denote
p o i n t ($.
the
Not
directed
line
withstanding
these, a n d perhaps some other coincidences of v i e w , Prof. Grassmann's system and m i n e appear to be perfectly distinct and i n d e p e n d e n t of each other, in their c o n c e p t i o n s , m e t h o d s , a n d results. At least, that the profound and philosophical author of the Ausdehnungslehre was not, at the time
o f its
publication,
in
possession
of the
theory
of the
quaternions,
w h i c h h a d in the p r e c e d i n g year (1843) b e e n a p p l i e d by me as a sort of organ
or
calculus for
spherical
trigonometry,
seems
clear
from
a
passage
o f his Preface ( V o r r e d e , p . xiv.), i n w h i c h h e states ( u n d e r date o f J u n e 28th,
1844),
imaginairies
that
from
he
the
had plane
not to
then
succeeded
space;
and
in
extending
generally
the
use
of
unsurmounted
difficulties had opposed themselves to his attempts to construct, on his principles, moglich,
a
theory
of
vermittelst
des
angles
in
space
Imaginaren
(hingegen
auch
die
nicht
mehr
Gesetze fur den
ist
es
Raum
abzuleiten. A u c h stellen sich iiberhaupt der Betrachtung der W i n k e l im Raume
Schwierigkeiten
entgegen,
zu
deren
allseitiger
Losung
mir
n o c h n i c h t h i n r e i c h e n d e m u s s e g e w o r d e n ist).71
Finally,
a remark
September
30,
mann's
1855
recent
researches,
worthy to and not." By
it
article
have
appears (8;
by
may
in
Hamilton
in
be
After
cited.
a letter to J. mentioning
T.
Graves of
that
Grass-
Crelle's journal had stimulated h i m in some
Hamilton
stated
that
Grassmann
"was
well
anticipated me in the discovery of the quaternions; to
me
a very
remarkable
circumstance
that he
did
70)
1860
one
mathematician one
made
1856,
French
mathematician of
the
of the
British
German-speaking
mathematician
(Saint-Venant)
Isles
(Hamilton), one
countries
(Mobius),
and
had come to appreciate
to some extent Grassmann's work. T w o other mathematicians, both of
Italy,
complete
Cremona and
this
Giusto
small
group.
These
two
men
were
Luigi
Bellavitis.
87
A
History
In
of V e c t o r Analysis
1860
mathematiques had
Luigi a
been
Cremona
note
proposed
a brief exposition
with
the
following cannot
the
in
solution
that journal.72
in
gave
"... I
published
concerning
As
of Grassmann's
Nouvelle
of t w o
part of this
Annales
de
problems
that
note Cremona
ideas, w h i c h was prefaced
statements:
refrain
from
mentioning
a
very
expeditious
and
very
c u r i o u s m e t h o d , o f w h i c h t h e first i d e a seems t o b e l o n g t o L e i b n i z , b u t w h i c h has b e e n t r u l y e s t a b l i s h e d by G r a s s m a n n . E x c e p t for M o b i u s . . . and
Bellavitis . . . I
do
not
know
of any
geometers
who
have
given
Grassmann's researches the attention w h i c h they deserve. I w i l l here r e p r o d u c e the p r i n c i p l e definitions a n d conventions of this ingenious At
a
later
theory time
Grassmann least o n e
which
Bellavitis and
by
one
Bellavitis,
a
names
even
contact
looks
letters that
back
independently arrive
on It
but
9,
their
ideas
1853,
schneider,
who
(5;
and
163n);
copies (4,1,1;
praise
ideas
Italian
and
Grassmann by
went
from
the
of
in at
during the
the
latter
with
on
to
study
the
Bellavitis
in
1860
and
mathematician
intended
the
decades
before
is
striking
first
Grassmann,
to
was
acquaint
imhis
1860,
of
all
a number of that
Mobius,
Saint-Venant, and Cauchy should
a t ideas that w e r e i n m a n y cases similar. T h e
brilliance
was
in nearly every instance
primarily
algebraic.
Though
had already obtained m u c h attention, Grassmann
remained nearly unknown. June
in
73
106-107)
emerge.
Hamilton,
Hamilton's
analysis."
words
paper
Bellavitis
Ausdehnungslehre (5;
with
motivation b e h i n d their investigations was geometric,
geometrical
stronger
geometrical
issue.
learned
the
generalizations
into
was
through
c o u n t r y m e n w i t h it. W h e n
used
came
took
Grassmann
pressed
author
books.74
occasion
Ausdehnungslehre, 1862
Cremona
Bellavitis the
the
335) and i n c l u d e d some of Grassmann's
of his
Giusto 1850's;
(5;
which
that
he
had as
I n d e e d M o b i u s m e n t i o n e d in a letter of
knew
read
of
Grassmann
of
the
first
18)
The
factors
only
one
Grassmann's
completely
himself mentioned,
Ausdehnungslehre that
mathematician,
book
were
caused
this
used
neglect
the
as have
Bret-
through
remaining
wastepaper. been
amply
discussed. Finally a summary will
fill
1844 to
of Grassmann's
1861
in this period
mathematics
From
G r a s s m a n n p u b l i s h e d seventeen scientific papers, in-
cluding important papers textbooks.
also
published
was
done
88
other activities
out the picture of Grassmann as a very active person.
materials
while
he
in physics, and a n u m b e r of language and He
edited
on the
taught
a
a
political paper for a t i m e a n d
evangelization
heavy
load
and
of China.75 All this raised
a
family,
for
Other Early Vectorial
Grassmann children This
had
married
p e r i o d of his
and
from
this
union
eleven
life
was
concluded w i t h the publication of his
Ausdehnungslehre.
VIII.
Grassmanns Limited
On
1849,
came.
second
Ausdehnungslehre
Acceptance
October 31,
high,
in
Systems
sent
of
His
of
1862
and
1861, Grassmann, n o d o u b t w i t h
to
Mobius
a
the
Gradual,
Work.
copy
of
the
hopes running
second
Ausdehnungslehre.
E i g h t years earlier in a letter to the same c o r r e s p o n d e n t G r a s s m a n n had stated his intention of preparing a n e w w o r k ; there is e v i d e n c e that by 1854 or 1855 he h a d b e g u n writing. of the book bore the date mann's
brother,
was
Die
bearbeitet.
and were
paid for by the
Ausdehnungslehre:
Under
the
Vollstanding
Grassmann's
a m G y m n a s i u m TAX S t e t t i n . " In
foreword
(5; 2 2 3 ) T h e 3 0 0 c o p i e s
1862, w e r e p r i n t e d in the shop of Grass-
name
author. und
appeared
(5;
223) Its title
in
strenger
the
title
Form
"Professor
76
Grassmann
discussed
the
poor
reception
ac-
corded his earlier w o r k and stated that the content of the n e w book was presented in
"the
strongest mathematical form that is actually
k n o w n to us; this is the E u c l i d e a n . the that
content of the of Gauss,
book and
Mobius,
.
Bellavitis,
For
I
. " (4,1,11; 4 ) H e e l a b o r a t e d o n relation
Saint-Venant,
final paragraph in the foreword was
pended
.
discussed the
of his
the
science
presented
The
the following:
remain completely confident that the labor w h i c h on
work to
and Cauchy.
here
and
which
has
I
have ex-
demanded a
significant part of my life as w e l l as the most strenuous application of m y p o w e r s , w i l l not b e lost. I t i s t r u e that I a m a w a r e that t h e f o r m w h i c h I have given the science is imperfect and must be imperfect. B u t I k n o w a n d f e e l o b l i g e d to state ( t h o u g h I r u n t h e risk of s e e m i n g arrogant) t h a t even
if this
work
s h o u l d again r e m a i n u n u s e d for another seventeen
years o r e v e n l o n g e r , w i t h o u t e n t e r i n g i n t o t h e actual d e v e l o p m e n t o f science, still that t i m e w i l l come w h e n it w i l l be brought forth f r o m the dust of oblivion
a n d w h e n ideas n o w d o r m a n t w i l l b r i n g forth fruit.
I
k n o w that if I also fail to gather a r o u n d me in a p o s i t i o n ( w h i c h I h a v e up to n o w desired in vain) a circle of scholars, w h o m I c o u l d fructify w i t h these ideas, a n d w h o m I c o u l d stimulate to d e v e l o p a n d e n r i c h further these ideas, nevertheless there w i l l c o m e a t i m e w h e n these ideas, perhaps i n a n e w f o r m , w i l l arise a n e w a n d w i l l enter into l i v i n g c o m m u n i cation w i t h contemporary developments. For truth is eternal and divine, and no phase in the d e v e l o p m e n t of truth, h o w e v e r small m a y be the r e g i o n e n c o m p a s s e d , c a n pass o n w i t h o u t l e a v i n g a t r a c e ; t r u t h r e m a i n s , even
though
the garment in w h i c h poor mortals
clothe
it may fall to
d u s t . (4,1,11; 1 0 )
89
A
History
As the
of V e c t o r Analysis
Grassmann Euclidean.
with
himself pointed out, The
a m i n i m u m
banished (which
consisted
of comment.
(which
was
book
not
was
form of presentation was of theorems
presented
Philosophical commentary had been
helpful),
helpful).
the
o f sets
as
were
Concerning
physical
this
form
of
applications presentation
w h i c h G r a s s m a n n h a d also u s e d in an e l e m e n t a r y textbook of 1861, Lehrbuch
der
Arithmetik,
Engel
commented:
W i t h o u t a d o u b t this was a disastrous mistake. W h a t was perfectly in place in the treatment of a subject so c o m m o n p l a c e for all mathematicians
as a r i t h m e t i c , at least for readers w h o p u r s u e m a t h e m a t i c s as a
science, to
was
which
the
the
most
unsuitable
reader was
form
for the
of presentation
first b e i n g
for
introduced.
a subject
Though
this
form of presentation led to an admirable codification of the n e w concepts a n d laws of his theory of extension, still it was not a presentation likely to
win
followers
wished
to
read
undertaken work
the
because
for his
his
ideas,
first
let
alone
Ausdehnungslehre.
convert those
Grassmann
who
had
had
actually
not only
i m m e n s e task i n v o l v e d i n the c o m p o s i t i o n o f the n e w
he
h o p e d t h a t n o w a t last h e w o u l d
find
readers.
It is
actually puzzling that he could so deceive himself and be so mistaken in his c h o i c e o f t h e m e a n s f o r a t t a i n i n g his a i m . (5; 2 3 1 ) The
second
first: it was most
Ausdehnungslehre
important of these
"Pfaffian
was
more
than
a
reworking
of the
o n e - t h i r d longer a n d c o n t a i n e d m a n y n e w results. T h e
Problem."
appreciated after
was
Grassmann's
According
1877,
to
solution of the
Engel
a neglect which
this
solution
so-called was
only
E n g e l ascribed to the fact
that f e w mathematicians w o u l d seek such a solution in Grassmann's book
and fewer w o u l d be able to disentangle it from the other ma-
terials
s u r r o u n d i n g it.
equal justice be The been
reception a
great
(5;
232-233) The
accorded
the
disappointment
Ausdehnungslehre
Grassmann,
one
must
for at first his
have efforts
he w r o t e in 1877, "this n e w w o r k m e t
e v e n l e s s a t t e n t i o n t h a n t h e f i r s t . " (4,1,1;
a p p e a r e d (5; only
second
to
seemed to have been in vain; with
latter c o m m e n t could w i t h
a p p l i e d in relation to vector analysis.
18) N o r e v i e w s o f i t
231), and it seems probable that Grassmann received f r o m those to w h o m he sent copies.77 T h e
note of thanks
f o l l o w i n g statements of E n g e l m a y serve as a c o n c l u s i o n to the discussion "Thus
of
the
the
maticians
early
second
a book
with
reception
of
Ausdehnungslehre seven
the
also
seals,
and
second
Ausdehnungslehre:
remained the
for
mathe-
abundance of entirely
n e w developments w h i c h it contained was like something buried in the
ground"
matters
and
which
pendently
"As
in
the
Grassmann
rediscovered
by
first
had
Ausdehnungslehre
published
others,
and
in
only
so it
in
were
much
the
second:
later later
indewas
it
r e a l i z e d t h a t G r a s s m a n n h a d d i s c o v e r e d t h e m e a r l i e r . " (5; 2 3 2 - 2 3 3 ) Thus
90
Grassmann's
works
were
almost
totally
neglected
during
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
the first fifty-five years of his life; the first real ray of h o p e a p p e a r e d in the second half of the second 1844
edition
Grassmann
in
1878)
in the foreword to the
of
his
Ausdehnungslehre
of
d e s c r i b e d the events that l e d up to the r e c o g n i t i o n that he re-
ceived in the
last years
Hermann
Hankel
Zahlensysteme of
1860's.
(published
my
was
(Leipzig,
decisive
the
(see
was
life. first
1867),
Ausdehnungslehre
more
of his
who,
stressed
pp.
16,
Clebsch's
in
the
112,
his
Theorie
der
fundamental 119-140,
recognition.
Shortly
complexen
significance
and
140).
Even
his
death
before
Clebsch, in his " z u m Gedachtniss an Julius Pliicker, G o t t i n g e n , 1 8 7 2 " (see t h e
notes
significance
set at t h e
b o t t o m of pages 8 a n d 28), e m p h a s i z e d the
o f m y Ausdehnungslehre
In fact in his
of
1844
second note Clebsch
in
stated:
words
of
strong
praise.
" I n a c e r t a i n sense t h e co-
ordinates of the straight line, as w e l l as a large part of the basis of the newer
algebra,
o f 1844.
The
are
already
more
contained
in
Grassmann's
exact statement of these
relations
Ausdehnungslehre
would however
l e a d too far a t p r e s e n t . " I n v i e w o f his l o v i n g a n d s o c o n s t a n t l y f r u i t f u l participation in the works of others, w h i c h trait distinguished this most eminent of the
more
recent mathematicians, it is certain that Clebsch
w o u l d later have f o u n d space to present these relations and, as was his way,
to
fructify
the
Ausdehnungslehre
with
new
and
far-reaching
ideas.
B u t , alas, h e w a s s n a t c h e d a w a y s o s u d d e n l y i n t h e m i d s t o f his p o w e r f u l efforts on b e h a l f of science. However three
years
earlier (in
1869) V i c t o r S c h l e g e l h a d b e g u n t o
execute the ideas suggested by Clebsch. In his " S y s t e m der R a u m l e h r e nach
den
Prinzipien
Einleitung Teubner," 1875,
in
der
dieselbe
of which
Schlegel
has
independently,
the
Grassmann'
dargestellt
schen
Ausdehnungslehre
Victor
Schlegel,
von
the first part appeared in presented with meaning
als bei
1872 a n d the second in
great clarity, and in large measure
of the
completely appropriate manner.
und
Leipzig
Ausdehnungslehre.
This
he
did
in
a
It is especially to be e m p h a s i z e d that
this b o o k b y S c h l e g e l i s t h e first w h i c h has v i e w e d t h e essential ideas o f the
Ausdehnungslehre
in
p r e s e n t a t i o n . (4,1,1; It was from
in
their
November
Hermann
inner
connections
and
has
given
them
a
18-19)
Hankel
Riemann and w h o was wrote
1866 that Grassmann received a long letter (1839-1873),
who
had
been
a
student
of
at that time privatdozent in mathematics at
Leipzig.
Hankel
numbers
in w h i c h he planned to include a treatment of Hamilton's
that
he
was
w r i t i n g a treatise
on
complex
q u a t e r n i o n m e t h o d s a n d also Grassmann's ideas, w h i c h h e strongly praised. A series of letters passed b e t w e e n and
in
18B7
appeared. mann's
the
Roughly
system,
10
former's
Theorie
percent of this
on which
Hankel
Hankel and Grassmann, der
book
complexen
was
Zahlensysteme
d e v o t e d to Grass-
b e s t o w e d m u c h praise.
book was influential, and if he had not died in
Hankel's
1873, he m i g h t have
done even more to make Grassmann's system known. Clebsch came to
know
Grassmann's
work
in
the
following
way:
Grassmann's
91
A
History
oldest
son,
1869 to
of V e c t o r Analysis
and
be
Justus,
began
brought
with
given
to
Stern
studies him
and
in
mathematics
copies
of the
Clebsch.
(5;
at Gottingen in
s e c o n d Ausdehnungslehre
311)
Stern
became
en-
thusiastic about Grassmann's book a n d passed on his enthusiasm to Felix
Klein,
1872.
(5;
his
who
312)
death in
Grassmann
of the
earliest of his
Because
that
influenced
mentioned,
proponents
life
his
was
Erlanger Program
of
unfortunately stilled by
students
his
system;
and
at
courses,
who
(1843-1905) was one
indeed
Schlegel
developing Grassmann's
isolation
mathematical
any
Victor Schlegel
of
expounding
of Grassmann's
elementary produce
it
enthusiasm
1872.
As
most
said
Clebsch's
would
Stettin
it
was
a n d his
unlikely
develop
his
spent
system.
teaching only that
system.
he
would
However a
n u m b e r of his followers came f r o m his "associates"; these i n c l u d e d his sons Justus a n d H e r m a n n , his brother Robert, a n d Schlegel h i m self,
w h o for t w o years ( 1 8 6 6 - 1 8 6 8 ) t a u g h t w i t h G r a s s m a n n i n Stet-
tin.
Schlegel
Sein
Leben
discussed
und
seine
Werke;
many
conversations
rarely
mentioned
this during
with his
period his
in
time
Grassmann, Ausdehungslehre.
his in
but
Stettin
decided with
to
explaining them. ect
from
der
In
Clebsch,
Raumlehre
dehnungslehre
und
published in Schlegel
study
Schlegel's
Grassmann's
Grassmann's methods 1871
and
works.
Grassmann: had
had
had
only
interest
had
1869 after leaving Schlegel
was
de-
and decided to publish a work
he received e n c o u r a g e m e n t in this proj-
in
1872 appeared the
nach
dem
als
Einleitung
1875.
he
Grassmann
h o w e v e r b e e n stimulated to the point that he in
lighted
Hermann
Stettin
Prinzipien in
den
Dieselbe;
first part of his
Grassmann the
second
System
schen
Aus-
part
was
(6; 6 1 - 6 2 )
attempted to explain Grassmann's
results through their
relations to e l e m e n t a r y g e o m e t r y (part I) a n d to the n e w e r m e t h o d s of h i g h e r g e o m e t r y a n d algebra (part II). E n g e l c o m m e n t e d on the content
and
significance
of Schlegel's
book
in
the
following way:
A c t u a l l y S c h l e g e l ' s w o r k also was n o t a success. T h e a u t h o r h a d definitely
gone
too
one-sidedly
for Grassmannian
methods
w i t h o u t prac-
t i c i n g the necessary criticism. H e t h o u g h t that the p e o p l e w h o a r g u e d for a progress of m o d e r n algebra as opposed to the theory of extension had d o n e it o n l y because t h e y k n e w the theory of extension m a i n l y by hearsay, w h e r e a s h e h a d c l a i m t o w h a t c o n c e r n s k n o w i n g . O n t h e o t h e r h a n d , the
superiority of modern
others
asserted was
algebra over the theory of extension which
no fiction a n d c o n s e q u e n t l y a large part of Grass-
mann's methods had b e c o m e dispensible. Schlegel was not the man to p u t the o l d G r a s s m a n n i a n w i n e in n e w vessels; he was not able to present the ideas c o n t a i n e d in the theory of extension from the point of v i e w o f t h e t h e o r y o f i n v a r i a n t s a n d t o b r i n g t o l i g h t w h a t w a s s t i l l n e w . (5; 324)
92
Other Early Vectorial
Engel
also
published lehre,
commented in
1878,
despite
(or
that
was
Schlegel's
more
perhaps
biography
influential
because
of)
the
went to extremes in praising Grassmann.
than
Systems
of Grassmann,
his
System
fact that the
derRaum-
biography
(5; 3 2 4 ) S c h l e g e l ' s p a r t l y
successful efforts to m a k e Grassmann's ideas k n o w n c o n t i n u e d until Schlegel's death in
1905, b y w h i c h t i m e h e h a d p u b l i s h e d over
twenty-five papers in the Grassmannian tradition. Three other m e n w h o developed an interest in Grassmann's work during the mid-1870's and published related works were H e r m a n n Noth
(1840-1882),
William
Kingdon
Clifford
(1845-1879),
and
W. Preyer (1841-1897); the latter w r o t e to Grassmann that d u r i n g a trip to
England
(made
in
1875
or
1876)
he
h a d discussed Grass-
mann's w o r k w i t h Sylvester, w h o was quite interested in it and had p l a n n e d a p u b l i c a t i o n i n r e g a r d t o it. (5; 3 3 0 ) As
more
ideas,
mathematicians
the
creased;
demand
for
became
copies
of
interested the
first
in
Grassmann's
Ausdehnungslehre
in-
none h o w e v e r were available, since the publisher had in
1864 used the r e m a i n i n g copies for wastepaper. A l t h o u g h the 300 copies
of
second
edition
the
second
Ausdehnungslehre
of the
had
f i r s t Ausdehnungslehre
not was
yet
been
sold,
published
in
a
1878
w i t h three appendices a n d a n e w f o r w a r d (left i n c o m p l e t e by Grassmann and completed by
Schlegel).
Grassmann's activities after 1862 w e r e m a n y a n d diversified. H e , like the y o u n g H a m i l t o n , had a strong interest in a n d great talent for languages. It was only Grassmann h o w e v e r w h o m a d e an important contribution
to
philology,
a contribution
which
in
fact rivals
m a t h e m a t i c a l w o r k . A s t u d y o f S a n s k r i t b e g u n i n 1 8 4 9 (5; minated Rig-Veda
in
the
(1784
pages).79
1870's
with
the
pages)78
and
his
These
achievements
publication translation
of Grassmann
of his of the did
not
his
155) cul-
Worterbuch Rig-Veda
zum
(1123
go unrecog-
nized, for in 1876 he was m a d e a m e m b e r of the A m e r i c a n O r i e n t a l Society and received an honorary doctorate from the University of T u b i n g e n . (5; 3 0 9 ) In the p e r i o d after
1862
Grassmann published textbooks on the
German and Latin languages and on mathematics, as well as numerous religious a n d m u s i c a l w r i t i n g s a n d a b o o k on G e r m a n botanical terminology. time.75
These
He
also
invented
activities,
the
combined
Grassmann w i t h his
Heliostat
at
this
increasing interest in
philology and increasing disappointment at the neglect of his mathematical creations, explain his d i m i n i s h e d mathematical productivity d u r i n g the late In the
1860's.
1870's h o w e v e r G r a s s m a n n p u b l i s h e d a n u m b e r of m a t h e -
matical papers w h i c h Engel described as of inferior quality. E n g e l
93
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
ascribed this to the fact that G r a s s m a n n h a d lost contact w i t h the current
mathematical literature a n d even to some extent w i t h his
o w n e a r l i e r ideas. (5; 3 1 5 - 3 1 7 ) I n h i s " D i e n e u e r e A l g e b r a u n d d i e A u s d e h n u n g s l e h r e " of 1874
80
Grassmann attempted somewhat un-
successfully to relate his ideas to n e w d e v e l o p m e n t s in algebra, particularly 1877
invariant
81
he
previously mann in
theory;
claimed
and
(justly)
mentioned
in
his
"Zur
electrodynamical
law
P r i n z i p i e n der A u s d e h n u n g s l e h r e " of 1872 that
time
of
still
published
by
Grass-
1876.82 " D i e M e c h a n i k n a c h d e n
1845 a n d by Clausius in
at
Elektrodynamik"
priority over Clausius in regard to the
83
contained some of the
results
of his
unpublished
theory.
O n e of the m o r e controversial papers was his " D e r Ort der
dissertation
on tidal
H a m i l t o n s c h e n Q u a t e r n i o n e n i n d e r A u s d e h n u n g s l e h r e " o f 1877,84 in
w h i c h Grassmann attempted to show that quaternions could be
derived from
the
p a p e r " S u r les
units
a n d multiplications discussed in his
differents
genres de multiplication";
1855
unfortunately
his p r e s e n t a t i o n was w e a k e n e d b y the fact that h e k n e w H a m i l t o n ' s ideas only f r o m second-hand sources such as Hankel. Grassmann's richly productive, b u t in ways tragic, life came to an e n d on S e p t e m b e r 26, and
for
Grassmann
schoolmaster were 1870's
1877. It is regrettable b o t h for mathematics
that
the
ideas
appreciated at
of this
brilliant,
but
isolated,
such
a late hour. A l t h o u g h the
brought h i m a measure of fame,
nevertheless by that t i m e
m a n y o f h i s i d e a s a n d m e t h o d s h a d b e e n (as E n g e l c o m m e n t e d [ 5 ; 315]) rediscovered by others and integrated into different formulations a n d systems. M u c h of m o d e r n vector analysis d i d h o w e v e r lie e m b e d d e d w i t h i n a n d as yet unextracted from his system. But the fates d e c r e e d h e r e as e l s e w h e r e :
Grassmann's ideas exerted little
or no influence on the later history of vector analysis. T h e irony is t h a t t h e y c o u l d h a v e ; t h e f a c t i s (as w i l l b e s h o w n ) t h a t t h e y d i d n o t . M u c h has b e e n said i n e x p l a n a t i o n o f the n e g l e c t o f Grassmann's works.
S o m e of the factors that c o n t r i b u t e d to this neglect b o r d e r on
the incredible.
E s p e c i a l l y s t r i k i n g is the fate of G r a s s m a n n ' s ideas
i n r e l a t i o n t o t h e s m a l l g r o u p w h o b e f o r e 1870 r e c o g n i z e d t h e i r significance. T w o (Hankel and Clebsch) w h o "discovered" Grassmann d i e d almost immediately thereafter; three (Mobius, Hamilton, and Bellavitis) and
had
Schlegel
strong
was
allegiances
a man
whose
elsewhere
(their o w n
systems);
enthusiasm exceeded his critical
facilities. Though
these
and
other factors
help to
explain
the
neglect of
Grassmann's w o r k , in a b r o a d sense this neglect needs little explanation, for their discoveries
were
revolutionary and the historical
pattern exhibited here is not uncommon.
94
Other Early Vectorial
Contemporary
analyses
of the
history
of
scientific
Systems
revolutions
have uncovered m a n y important patterns. C o n c e r n i n g discovery, it has
been
quently
shown
that there are
essentially
no
irrelevant,
direct paths
often
to
discovery;
philosophic,
ideas
may
freplay
a decisive role. T h u s it is p r o b a b l y not accidental that b o t h H a m i l ton a n d Grassmann w e r e supported (but not directed) in their discoveries
by
certain
philosophic
assumptions.
While
Hamilton
meditated on the metaphysics of time, Grassmann d e v e l o p e d ideas c o n c e r n i n g space. T h e truth a n d direct r e l e v a n c y of their speculations
in this regard are beside the
these
speculations
plored
domains.
supported
The
point; w h a t is relevant is that
them
discovery
in
acceptance, a n d philosophic notions new
idea frequently
and
Grassmann
bulked
large
hinder
realized
in
their
ventures
of a n e w idea does
its
the
their first books
unex-
that aid in the discovery of a
acceptance.
this;
into
n o t i n s u r e its
Eventually
philosophic
were
Hamilton
discussions
banished
from
that
their later
presentations. Historical analyses of the acceptance of revolutionary ideas s h o w that acceptance by
definition.
scriptive;
it
requires
But
the
explains
much
time;
this
seems
statement that time nothing.
The
real
is
to be
needed
question
is
so almost
is
only
de-
W h y is time
n e e d e d ? W h a t factors operate in t i m e to b r i n g about the acceptance of revolutionary factors
ideas?
that frequently
revolutionary
Listed play
below
are
three
significant roles
in
of the the
numerous
acceptance of
scientific ideas.
(1) A c c e p t a n c e i s p r o m o t e d w h e n t h e d i s c o v e r y i s t a k e n u p (or made)
by
tional
pursuits
someone
who
or w h e n
has
already
it is
attained great fame
associated w i t h
some
in tradi-
event or non-
scientific question of great importance. (2) A c c e p t a n c e made
which
are
is
promoted
more
easily
when
less
startling discoveries are
interpreted in
terms
of the
revolu-
tionary ideas than in terms of traditional doctrines. (3) A c c e p t a n c e i s p r o m o t e d w h e n a n e e d f o r t h e m e t h o d s w h i c h the
revolutionary
ideas
provide
e i t h e r arises
or is recognized for
the first time. Examples those Young,
action with
Lobachevski,
abundance. factors
of the
associated
In
the
of these
factors
Copernicus,
Darwin, present
and
case
in
Einstein we
such
Galileo,
shall
revolutions
Lavoisier,
as
Hutton,
could be supplied in examine
these
three
only in relation to the acceptance of the ideas of H a m i l t o n
and Grassmann.
Hardly a more striking example could be found to
illustrate the first factor: in 1844 H a m i l t o n h a d attained w i d e s p r e a d fame on the basis of important, b u t not r e v o l u t i o n a r y , discoveries,
95
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
a n d his ideas r e c e i v e d i m m e d i a t e t h o u g h l i m i t e d attention; Grassm a n n was u n k n o w n h o w e v e r a n d suffered the fate o f a m a n w h o s e first great
discovery
factor it is were did
is
revolutionary.
not accidental
rediscovered before not
certain
discover coastal
continent.
the
areas
b u t his
continent.
find
this
was
whole
readers
appreciated.
American
subsequent
over a
a continent,
second
the
and
to
the
parts of Grassmann's system
North
Grassmann
Concerning
that m a n y
continent;
generations
discovered
recognized
p e r i o d of t w e l v e years neither expected to
Columbus
he
a
d i d discover
find
nor wanted
C o n c e r n i n g the t h i r d factor it is important
t o r e a l i z e t h a t t h e n e e d for v e c t o r i a l m e t h o d s i n 1800 w a s less t h a n the n e e d in 1900 and that although vectorial methods aid investigations, t h e y are n e v e r i n d i s p e n s i b l e . W h a t can b e d o n e b y vectorial methods was
can
needed
also
be
during
done
by
which
traditional methods, and thus time
scientists
could
see
that
the
labor of
learning vectorial methods was amply compensated. We
may
now
Grassmann's Roughly
150
Grassmann's though
the
briefly
ideas
trace
during
papers
and
collected majority
the
the 9
reception
last
books
works)
of these
two
and
(excluding
appeared
development
decades
from
publications
of the
the
publication
1881
of
1900.85 A l -
to
appeared
of
century.
in
German
journals, a substantial n u m b e r of papers may be found in the American,
British,
French,
and
Italian journals
of the
period.86
Engel
c o m m e n t e d that there was a strong tendency a m o n g the authors of these papers to b e c o m e unrealistically enthusiastic and narrow conc e r n i n g t h e G r a s s m a n n m e t h o d s . (5; 3 4 3 ) F e l i x K l e i n , w h o w a s w e l l acquainted w i t h Grassmann's methods, expressed the same view.87 The works Gibbs
task was 8S
of
collecting
begun
in
the
and
publishing
1890's.
Grassmann's
complete
T h e stimulus for this came from
a n d f r o m Klein.89 In 1892 K l e i n contacted Frederick E n g e l
(1861-1941)
and
requested
that
he
prepare a biography of Grassmann.
edit (4,1,1;
Grassmann's
works
and
vi) T h e works began to
appear in 1894, w i t h the final section containing Engel's biography appearing in
1911.
Though
E n g e l was by no m e a n s an ardent fol-
l o w e r o f G r a s s m a n n ' s i d e a s , a s h e h i m s e l f s t a t e d , (4,1,1; v i ) h e d i d nevertheless
write
a detailed, critical, and sympathetic biography
of that great mathematician.
IX.
Matthew
Writing in
O'Brien 1892, the quaternionist C. G. Knott c l a i m e d " t h e anti-
quaternionic vector analysts of today [Gibbs, Heaviside, and Macfarlane] h a v e b a r e l y a d v a n c e d b e y o n d t h e stage r e a c h e d [ i n
96
1852]
Other Early Vectorial O'Brien. . . ."90
by
Knott's
statement
(which
he
Systems
frequently
re-
peated) is obviously of great importance if it is true. The
Reverend
1854
Professor
Matthew O'Brien of
Natural
(1814-1855) was from
Philosophy
and
Astronomy
1844 to
in
King's
College, L o n d o n . In 1830 he h a d b e e n admitted to T r i n i t y College, Dublin, whence he proceeded to Cambridge to graduate as T h i r d W r a n g l e r i n 1838.91 D u r i n g his short life O ' B r i e n p u b l i s h e d r o u g h l y twenty
papers
and
to vector analysis
a few
elementary
books.
T h e papers relevant
were published during the
last t e n years
of his
life.92 Judgment on the
significance of O'Brien's ideas is complicated,
in part because the presentation of his vectorial ideas g i v e n in his early
papers
differs
longest of his cal
Transactions
with
from
that
of his
was
that
published
papers
1852.9
for
passing
mention
It
is
this
going
to
later
paper
the
papers.
in
the
that
The
will
important
last
London
and
Philosophi-
be
discussed
papers
published
earlier. O ' B r i e n began by stating that his a i m was to p r o v i d e a n e w notation of
for an "the
operation
translation
considered surface
by
duced it
on
.
from
.
three the a
.
the
actual
directed
instances
parallel rigid
The
of constant occurrence
of a
magnitude." of such
motion body
of
by
a the
effect
produced
motion
of its
by point
in mathematics, that
(9;
161)
translations: right
line
.
translation the
.
of
. a
The
of
application."
a
(9;
then
generation
force
translation
of
O'Brien "The
effect acting
of pro-
upon
force
resulting
162)
From
a n analysis o f t h e s e cases h e c o n c l u d e d that t h e essential c o n c e p tion
in
of a
directed
each
case
magnitude
"is .
.
that
of
,"
and
.
effects m a y be r e p r e s e n t e d as magnitude
the
effect
he
produced
noted
that
by
the
each
translation of
these
a product of the translated directed
and the translation undergone.
(9;
162)
He stated that
t h e s e t r a n s l a t i o n s c o u l d be c l a s s i f i e d as " l a t e r a l " (cases 1 a n d 2) or " l o n g i t u d i n a l " (case 3 ) a n d t h a t his n e w n o t a t i o n w o u l d b e a i m e d a t representing these t w o types of translations.
(9;
162-163)
H e t h e n d e f i n e d directed m a g n i t u d e a n d the t w o types o f translation:
t h e t r a n s l a t i o n of v a l o n g u is l o n g i t u d i n a l w h e n a n g l e A is
A 0 ° a n d lateral w h e n a n g l e A i s 90°. (9; duced
the
"symbolical
that they w e r e
forms"
distributive
x.y
163-164) O ' B r i e n then intro-
and
functions
x X y
9;J
;
of x and y.
he
assumed only
H i s choice of the
97
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
s y m b o l s . a n d X was e x p l a i n e d as o n e s t e m m i n g f r o m the fact that they
were
O'Brien
obsolete
defined
together," tion,"
while
used for
"successive
symbols
"addition" he
for
of
multiplication.
directed
differentiated
between
directed magnitudes
addition,"
with
used for t w o
(9;
magnitudes
164-165)
as
"putting
"simultaneous
addi-
coincident origins, and
directed magnitudes,
one
of
w h i c h has its o r i g i n a t t h e e n d p o i n t o f t h e o t h e r . (9; 1 6 5 - 1 6 6 ) A f t e r a
discussion
of equality
and
of the
suitability
of directed magni-
tudes for the representation of physical entities, O ' B r i e n introduced three " d i r e c t e d units" a,
y w h i c h go out from the origin along
t h e x, y, z axes r e s p e c t i v e l y ; a n y d i r e c t e d m a g n i t u d e u w a s thus to be r e p r e s e n t e d in t h e f o r m
" w = x a + yfi + r y . "
(9;
166-167)
O ' B r i e n w e n t on to discuss the significance of such an expression a s da.
He n o t e d that for t w o d i r e c t e d m a g n i t u d e s a a n d a' separated
by an infinitesimal angle, " d a is the expression for an indefinitely small
line
a t right
angles
to
a."
(9;
168)
This
property bears
men-
tion, since it served as the starting p o i n t for his vectorial system as presented results
in
his
obtained
earlier papers published during the in
these
papers
were
very
1840's. T h e
similar to the results
obtained in the paper presently under discussion, but the approach was
quite different.
O'Brien
showed
that
both
lateral
and
longitudinal
effects
of
t r a n s l a t i o n s a r e d i s t r i b u t i v e a n d i d e n t i f i e d u.v a s t h e n o t a t i o n t o b e u s e d to represent the
lateral
effect of the translation of v along u,
a n d u X u t o represent the longitudinal effect of the translation of v along u.
(9;
169-170) He established the rules to be used for ordi-
nary numbers in regard to these t w o multiplications and w e n t from this
to
show
O'Brien
t h a t u.v = v.u
and
u X v = v X u.
(9;
170-172)
Thus
h a d e s t a b l i s h e d t h a t u.v a n d u X v w e r e b o t h d i s t r i b u t i v e
a n d that the latter was a c o m m u t a t i v e multiplication; he never h o w ever the
investigated paper,
tudes
or
planes).
to
directed This
associativity.
state
w h e t h e r u.v magnitudes
ambiguity
was
H e also failed, u p t o this p o i n t i n and u X v were numerical magni(for
only
example, partly
vectors
clarified
by
or
vectorial
his later ex-
planations. O ' B r i e n then i n t r o d u c e d his t e r m "directrix" explaining that in a lateral translation a plane was d e t e r m i n e d a n d that the directrix for a lateral translation was to be a l i n e of a certain l e n g t h p e r p e n d i c u lar to that p l a n e ; for
t h u s t h e d i r e c t r i x f o r a.fi w a s t o b e y ; f o r / 3 . y , a ;
a , —y; a n d s o on. I t t h e n b e c o m e s clear ( t h o u g h o n l y i n part
from O'Brien's direct statements) that the magnitude of the product of t w o d i r e c t e d m a g n i t u d e s l i n k e d by " . " is mn sin 6 w h e r e m a n d n are the lengths of the t w o m a g n i t u d e s a n d 0 is the angle b e t w e e n
98
Other Early Vectorial
the t w o directed magnitudes. symbol
"D,"
D(a.f3)
y.
=
meaning
(9;
O'Brien proceeded to introduce the
directrix of," a n d wrote, for example,
173-176)
Proceeding 0 X 0 = 1 ,
"the
Systems
to
longitudinal
y X y = 1";
a X
translations, a X y,
he
wrote,
0 X y, . . . are
as e q u a l to z e r o . H e n c e "u X v = mn c o s
"a: X a = 1,
naturally taken
w h e r e m a n d n are the
m a g n i t u d e s of u a n d v, a n d 0 is t h e a n g l e b e t w e e n t h e m . (9;
176)
O ' B r i e n then considered the results of the repetition of the operat i o n Da, f o r e x a m p l e , i n t h e e x p r e s s i o n ( D a . ) 2 a ' w h e r e a a n d a ' a r e any t w o unit directed magnitudes. In this regard he c o n c l u d e d that if a n d o n l y if a a n d a'
a r e m u t u a l l y p e r p e n d i c u l a r , t h e n (Da.)
—a',
has
and thus
The tem;
that
(Da.)
one
of the
of
a'
=
V^-I.
s e c o n d p a r t o f t h e p a p e r d e a l t w i t h a p p l i c a t i o n s o f t h e sys-
in his applications to physical optics O ' B r i e n i n t r o d u c e d the
symbol
O
"to
denote
the
operation
used this in the expressions f l u , above his
properties
2
exposition
system;
of O'Brien's
a
+ /3
fiXu,
+ y -J-^. . . . "
a n d CI.v.
thought
He
(9; 2 0 4 - 2 0 5 ) T h e
should give
some
ideas
of
the question that must be dealt w i t h is w h e t h e r Knott
was correct in his belief that O'Brien's system is essentially that of Gibbs
and
Heaviside,
and
hence
is
the
now
current
system.
If
Knott was correct, then O ' B r i e n deserves great credit a n d m u s t be called the father of m o d e r n vector analysis. O n e aspect of this question is w h e t h e r O ' B r i e n attained conceptions
o f t h e scalar (dot) p r o d u c t a n d t h e v e c t o r (cross) p r o d u c t .
He
must
be
his
given
credit for h a v i n g the
scalar p r o d u c t ,
although
justification of it is hardly traditional. Concerning the vector product
the
question
numerical
is
magnitude
far
from
with
simple.
the
His
modern
product
vector
u.v
agrees
product;
in
however
O ' B r i e n never clearly stated w h a t it represented. As we m e n t i o n e d previously, it seems that he v i e w e d it as a n u m e r i c a l quantity; at another point in the paper he seems h o w e v e r to,have v i e w e d it as a directed
and
oriented
parallelogram.
(9;
180)
It
is
clear that he
v i e w e d h i s p r o 4 u c t Du.v a s a d i r e c t e d l i n e s e g m e n t , e q u a l i n m a g nitude, direction, a n d sense to the m o d e r n product. But still
this
spond with failure to y
do
the
product in modern
his
s y s t e m does n o t i n all cases corre-
product.
understand associativity not
correspond
with
the
T h e reason for this
is O'Brien's
a n d the related fact that his a, modern
i, j,
k.
This
becomes
evident from statements made by O ' B r i e n in a footnote to his paper in w h i c h he c o m p a r e d his
system to that of H a m i l t o n .
Herein he
compared
H a m i l t o n ' s i , j , k w i t h h i s a , (3, y a n d n o t e d t h a t H a m i l -
ton's
k are
i, j,
both
units
of direction
and
have
the
property of
99
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
c o r r e s p o n d i n g to square roots of m i n u s one, whereas his a, n o t h a v e t h e l a t t e r p r o p e r t y . (9; property
in
some
cases,
y do
178) T h e m o d e r n i, j, k do h a v e this
specifically
for
example
in
i X (i X v)
w h e r e v has no i c o m p o n e n t . B u t O ' B r i e n r e a l i z e d t h a t he c o u l d express
this
contains
(Da.)2 v = Da. (Da. v)
as
where
a
is
a
unit
vector
and
v
no a c o m p o n e n t .
O'Brien's
failure
to
understand
associativity
was manifested in
t h i s f o o t n o t e w h e n h e s t a t e d t h a t H a m i l t o n ' s i 2 a l w a y s e q u a l s —1, (Da.)2 e q u a l s — 1
whereas his magnitude
perpendicular
o n l y w h e n it is a p p l i e d to a directed
to
a.
(9;
178)
W h a t is
striking
is
that
O ' B r i e n s h o u l d h a v e e x p e c t e d this, for the t w o forms are not comparable,
(i2) =
since
(ii),
(Da.)2 =
whereas
Da.(Da.
.
.
.).
T h e first
means i times i; the latter means a p p l y Da to the quantity attained after Da
has
failed to
been
see
applied
to
some other quantity.
Thus
O'Brien
that his system was not associative for this product;
indeed it seems
not to have b e e n a question for him.
He never in
the course of the paper wrote a triple product except in the form (Da.)2 v .
He h a d in fact no s y m b o l i s m for expressing the e q u i v a l e n t
of (i X j) X k ( w r i t t e n in m o d e r n terms); this c o u l d o n l y be w r i t t e n (Da.Dfi.)y,
which
would
have
been
meaningless
in
his
system.
T h u s one can at most attribute to O ' B r i e n a very near approach to t h e m o d e r n v e c t o r (cross) p r o d u c t . In and
summary,
O'Brien
should
be
viewed
a forerunner of Gibbs
Heaviside, but he d i d not anticipate them in the construction
of the m o d e r n system. His system was rather primitive as compared to theirs, w a s d e v e l o p e d on a d i f f e r e n t a n d less satisfactory f o u n d a tion, a n d d i f f e r e d f r o m theirs in at least o n e m a j o r point. H i s system failed to
include
not ended in
a treatment of associativity.
If O'Brien's life had
1855, this last defect m i g h t h a v e b e e n r e m e d i e d , b u t
in n e i t h e r his last p a p e r n o r in a n y of t h e earlier ones was it in fact remedied. O'Brien
seems to have had no followers; neither Heaviside nor
Gibbs
ever mentioned him,
to
work.
his
Hamilton
It
had
w o u l d be
even
after Knott h a d called attention
interesting to
of O'Brien's
ideas
and
know
what view,
likewise
to
if any,
know whether
O ' B r i e n created his system from Hamilton's system. T h e first question seems unanswerable since H a m i l t o n referred to O'Brien only once, a n d t h e n o n l y to i n c l u d e his n a m e in a list of mathematicians who
had
searches,
"at to
moments notice,
turned
and
in
s p e c u l a t i o n s of m i n e . . . ."
aside
some
from
instances
their
own
to
extend,
original results
reor
94
T h e answer to the second question seems almost certainly to be that O ' B r i e n created his system directly from Hamilton's. He never
100
Other Early Vectorial
Systems
stated t h i s , n o r d i d h e d e n y it. O ' B r i e n c e r t a i n l y k n e w o f H a m i l t o n ; indeed
Hamilton
probably taught O'Brien during the early
1830's
when O'Brien studied at Trinity College, Dublin. Moreover, as we indicated before, Hamilton's w o r k immediately attracted attention. H e h a d p u b l i s h e d f r o m 1844 t o 1846 e i g h t papers (or e i g h t sections of
one
paper95
paper)
in
the
Philosophical
Magazine
appeared in the same journal.
before
But this
O'Brien's
external
first
evidence
does no m o r e than a d d further support to w h a t is obvious f r o m the internal similarities b e t w e e n their systems. If we
put
priority
disputes
aside,
O'Brien
is
found to
make
a
fitting conclusion for this chapter, since he was i n d e e d on the road that lead to
Heaviside and Gibbs, a n d his w o r k further illustrates
the breadth a n d d e p t h of the search for n e w vectorial systems.
101
Notes 1
August
Ferdinand
2
August
Ferdinand
3
Anton
lichen
Favaro,
Mobius,
"Justus
Werkens"
Gesammelte
Mobius,
in
Der
Werke,
4
barycentrische
vols.
(Leipzig,
Calcul
(Leipzig,
Bellavitis, E i n e Skizze seines Schlomilch's
Zeitschrift fur
1885-1887). 1827).
Lebens u n d wissenschaft-
Mathematik
und
Physik,
26
(1881),
Gesammelte
mathe-
153-169. 4
Hermann
matische 5
und
Giinther physikalische
Friedrich
Grassmann,
Werke,
Engel,
3
vols,
Grassmanns
Leben
Hermann
in
6
Grassmanns
pts.
comprises
(Leipzig,
vol.
Ill,
1894-1911).
pt.
II
of the
work
cited
i n n o t e (4) a b o v e . 6
Victor
Schlegel,
Hermann
Grassmann:
Sein
Leben
und
Seine
Werke
(Leipzig,
1878). 7
Adhemar
Barre,
differences Comptes 8
rendus
Rev.
9
10
VAcademie
Saint-Venant, sur
des
Perceval
Matthew
leur
usage
Sciences,
21
Graves,
O'Brien,
Translation
Royal
de et
Life
"Memoire pour
(1845), of
Sir
sur
les
simplifier
sommes
la
et
les
mecanique"
in
620-625.
William
Rowan
Hamilton,
vol.
Ill
1889).
Rev.
the
de
Robert
(Dublin,
Comte
geometriques,
Society
1
a
of London,
Rudolf
rechnung,
of
142
Mehmke Band,
"On
Symbolic
Directed (1852),
in
his
Forms
in
Philosophical
Transactions
of
of the
161-206.
valuable
Punktrechung,
derived from the Conception
Magnitude"
1.
book
Vorlesungen
Teilband
(Leipzig
uber and
Punkt
und
Berlin,
Vektoren-
1913),
346,
argued that G i o v a n n i Ceva could be v i e w e d as a "Vorlaufer," a precursor of M o b i u s in regard to a system of analysis based on points. 11
For information on
Mobius'
life and scientific activity the following were used:
R i c h a r d B a l t z e r , " A u g u s t F e r d i n a n d M o b i u s " (1,1; v - x x ) a n d C u r t R e i n h a r d t , " U e b e r die
Enstehungszeit u n d den Z u s a m m e n h a n g der wichtigsten Schriften u n d Abhand-
lungen von 12
These
Mobius" facts
(1,IV;
were
published writings. See 13
Published at
14
A
much
Calculus
fuller of
(1892), 2 - 2 1 . Gibbs, York, (New
Reinhardt
through
his
study
For this
work
see (1,IV; 4 4 1 - 4 7 6 ) , b u t for the i m p o r t a n t
exposition
is
in
available
Proceedings
in of
R.
E.
the
Allardice,
Edinburgh
Algebra"
91-117;
1963),
in
Julian
148-150;
Papers
H e r m a n n Rothe,
Willard A
ff.
A section of M o b i u s ' book was translated by J.
A
Source
102
Barycentric Society,
10
Book
1959), 6 7 0 - 6 7 6 .
in
vol.
Boyer,
Mathematics,
vol.
of
II
(New
Geometrical
vol.
Methods
"Systeme geometrischer Analyse" in
1956),
B.
Gibbs,
History
1289-1293;
Carl
Wissenschaften,
of J.
Coolidge,
1931[?]),
in
mathematischen
Scientific Lowell
der
lished
"The
Mathematical
Encyklopadie
York,
un-
389-398).
Mobius"
"Multiple
242
of Mobius'
B r i e f expositions w i t h historical c o m m e n t s are g i v e n i n Josiah W i l l a r d
1961), York,
by
(1,IV; 707-710).
Leipzig.
a p p e n d i x see (1,1;
699-728).
established
Ill,
History
II,
pt.
1,2nd
o f Analytical
ed.
David
half,
Geometry P.
(Leipzig,
(New
York,
Kormes and pub-
Eugene
Smith
(New
O t h e r E a r l y Vectorial Systems
1 5
This
discovery was made
Bobillier, Analytical
K.
W.
Geometry
nearly simultaneously and independently by Etienne
Feuerbach, (New
and
York,
Julius
1956),
16
See R i c h a r d Baltzer's remarks
17
Published at Leipzig;
Pliicker.
See
Carl
B.
Boyer,
History
of
240-244.
i n (1,1; x i - x i i i ) .
later p u b l i s h e d in
(1,IV;
1-318).
For Mobius' treatment
of vectorial a d d i t i o n , see (1,IV; 41). 18
Thus,
A'B'C'
is
for
the
of this
example,
projection
equation
is
Mobius
of the
wrote
t r i a n g l e ABC
a triangle
(fixed as
A'B'C'
on
= ABC
some
parallel
-
cos
ABC
A'B'C'
where
plane. T h e right-hand m e m b e r
to
some
plane)
m u l t i p l i e d by the
cosine of the angle b e t w e e n the t w o planes, w h i c h must be a n u m b e r , whereas the left-hand
member
would
is clear that he was
in
general
not
be
parallel
s i m p l y stating that the
to the
projection
right-hand member.
It
of a triangle on some plane
gives an area w h i c h is equal to the original area m u l t i p l i e d by the cosine of the angle between the two 19
In
1859
Lectures
on
planes.
Mobius
H o w e v e r his
symbolism
d i d not express this.
published a paper entitled
" N e u e r B e w e i s des
aufgestellten
Princips
Quaternions
associativen
bei
der
(1,IV; 685)
in
Hamilton's
Zusammensetz-
u n g v o n B o g e n g r o s s t e r K r e i s e a u f d e r K u g e l f l a c h e . " (1,11; 5 5 - 7 0 ) 20
(3)
Biographical above
sciences 2 1
and
mathematiques,
Giusto
analitica
Bellavitis,
22
geometrique
Vavancement himself
des
Lettere, 23
ed
(3;
in the
"Saggio
di
(1835), (3;
Bellavitis"
(1880),
sciences.
Comptes
the
work cited in Darboux's
note
Bulletin
des
di
in
un
nuovo
Annali
delle
metodo Scienze
di
Geometria
del
Regno
Lom-
Laquiere, "Observations sur l'origine naturelle
des rendus,
equivalence
Equipollenze"
Arti,
(1876),
449
the in
343-348.
applicazioni
155) or M. Calcul
19
mainly from
246-247.
delle
155).
drawn "Giusto
equipollenze)"
du
recognized
Metodo
4
5
See for e x a m p l e
been
Laisant,
Ser.,
delle
Padova,
has
Ange
2nd
(Calcolo
bardo-Veneto.
et
information
Charles
Equipollences"
in
(1881),
evidence
see
in
77.
For
Giusto
Memorie
Association
Bellavitis,
del
Reale
Frangaise
that
"Sulle
Istituto
pour
Bellavitis
Origini
Venetoy
di
del
Scienze,
ff.
F o r his v i e w s in 1876 see Bellavitis, " O r i g i n i , " 4 7 6 - 4 7 7 . F o r his v i e w s
1830's see b e l o w . In r e g a r d to his n a r r o w n e s s of v i e w it is i n t e r e s t i n g to n o t e
that Bellavitis e x h i b i t e d the same t e n d e n c y in relation to n o n - E u c l i d e a n g e o m e t r y and,
according
24
Bellavitis,
25
Giusto
to
Favaro,
crusaded
against
its
acceptance.
On
this
see
(3;
159).
Scienze
del
Regno
" O r i g i n i , " 449.
Bellavitis,
Lombardo-Veneto.
Padova,
"Sulla 2
Geometria
(1832),
Derivata"
in
Annali
delle
250-253.
26
Bellavitis,
2 7
Giusto Bellavitis, "Sopra alcune applicasioni di un nuovo metodo di Geometria
Analitica"
" O r i g i n i , " 451.
in
II
Poligrafo.
Giornale
di
Scienze,
Lettere
ed
Arti.
Verona,
13
(1833),
53-61. I have not seen this paper, for the above journal does not s e e m to be available in this 28
country.
Giusto
analitica Veneto.
Bellavitis, (Calcolo
Padova,
5
"Saggio
delle
(1835),
di
applicasioni
equipollenze)"
244-259.
I
have
in
di
un
Annali
inferred
nuovo delle
from
metodo
Scienze some
del
di
Geometria
Regno
Lombardo-
not completely clear
comments m a d e by Bellavitis ( " O r i g i n i , " 451) that the 1833 paper contained neither the term "equipollence" nor the presentation 29
T h e r e are a n u m b e r of g o o d b i o g r a p h i c a l
of his fully d e v e l o p e d system. studies
of Grassmann. T h e definitive
w o r k i s c i t e d i n n o t e (5) a b o v e . A s h o r t e r , v a l u a b l e , b u t s o m e w h a t o v e r l y e n t h u s i a s t i c b o o k i s c i t e d i n n o t e (6) a b o v e . mann" A.
E.
in Heath,
Jahresbericht "Hermann
der
Also used was F r i e d r i c h E n g e l , " H e r m a n n Grass-
Deutschen
Grassmann"
Mathematiker-Vereinigung, i n Monist, 2 7 ( 1 9 1 7 ) ,
19 1-21; A.
(1910), E.
1-13;
Heath, " T h e
103
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis
Neglect "The
of the
Work
Geometrical
Characteristic"
in
Monist,
35 (1944), 3 2 6 - 3 3 0 ; sein
Leben
Annalen,
14
ception
R.
und
Grassmann"
27
(1917),
and
27
and
(1917),
Its
George
Mathematik
Victor Schlegel's
work,
und
"Die
22-35;
Connection Sarton,
A.
E.
with
Heath,
Leibniz's
"Grassmann"
Physik,
41
Arbeiten"
valuable
article,
Grassmann'sche (1896),
30
S e e (5; 3 - 7 ) a n d (6;
This was published posthumously in
32
Monist,
36-56;
31
note
in
Grassmann
mathematisch-physikalischen
1-45;
Grassmann's
Z e i t s c h r i f t fur
of
in
Isis,
Sturm, E. Schroder, and L. Sohncke, " H e r m a n n Grassmann:
seine
(1879), of
of H.
Analysis
1-21
in
Mathematische
m a i n l y on the
re-
Ausdehnungslehre"
in
and
41-59.
16-30). 1911
as vol. I l l , pt. I, of the w o r k c i t e d in
(4) a b o v e . C o n c e r n i n g t h e d e t a i l s o f t h i s p e r i o d i n G r a s s m a n n ' s l i f e see (5; 7 2 - 8 5 ) a n d for
C o n r a d ' s s t a t e m e n t s e e (4,111,1; 2 0 9 ) . 33
Though
in
this
foreword Grassmann d i d not give the date
1832, there is every
reason to believe that E n g e l was right in taking the statements from the foreword as referring to the 34
part of Gauss' 35
1832 period.
S e e (4,1,11; 8 - 9 ) f o r G r a s s m a n n ' s s t a t e m e n t a n d (4,1,11; 3 9 7 - 3 9 8 ) f o r t h e r e l e v a n t letter.
(4,1,1; 8). T h e s e b o o k s , t h o u g h i n t e n d e d f o r e l e m e n t a r y i n s t r u c t i o n , w e r e w r i t t e n
f r o m a r a t h e r p h i l o s o p h i c a l p o i n t o f v i e w . O n t h i s see (6; 48) a n d (5; 2 - 7 ) . T h e f u l l references Raumlehre, und
to
Grassmann's
Ebene
raumliche
spharischen
Raumlehrey
father's
Trigonometrie
(Berlin,
first
having
the
part
two
Grossenlehre
been
These
gress, British
Museum, nor Biblioteque
For Wilson's
discussion
seem
to
are
Justus
1824)
The
book
first
published
Combinationslehre.
38
books
1835).
books
(Berlin,
be
in
quite
is
1817
rare;
Giinther
and the
under
neither
Grassmann,
Lehrbuch
der
ebenen
second
part
of his
the
the
title
Geometrische
Library
of Con-
Nationale list copies in their catalogues.
of these t w o products a n d for Wilson's statements con-
c e r n i n g G i b b s ' v i e w s see E d w i n B i d w e l l W i l s o n , " O n Products i n A d d i t i v e F i e l d s " in
Verhandlungen
1904. 37
(Leipzig,
des
C o n c e r n i n g this
nichteuklidischen Engel's
III.
1905),
Internationalen
see Grassmann's
Geometrie
zur
Kongresses
statement of 1877:
im
Heidelberg,
" U b e r das V e r h a l t n i s s d e r
Ausdehnungslehre"
(4,1,1;
293-294),
and
for
n o t e t h e r e o n s e e (4,1,1; 4 1 3 ) .
38
This is the year suggested by Engel.
39
(5;
See (5; 92).
331). T h i s is based on Engel's restoration of one unclearly abbreviated w o r d
in the original 40
Mathematiker
202-215.
(4,1,1;
letter.
22). E r n e s t
of philosophical Formation
of
Geometry"
in
Nagel gave an interesting, but brief, discussion of the degree
sophistication Modern
Osiris,
7
manifested by
Conceptions (1939),
of
142-224.
Grassmann
Formal On
Logic
Grassmann
in this w o r k in his " T h e in
the
Development
see especially pages
of
168-
174. 41
This
is
not
an
inappropriate
cluded many of Grassmann's
indeed
Whitehead's
Universal
Algebra
in-
42
F o r t h e i r s t a t e m e n t s see (5;
43
In a paper published in
44
S o m e discussion of the writings in E n g l i s h that attempt to explain Grassmann's
system
may
Grassmann, Algebra," (2) in
term;
ideas.
be "A
Annals
104
at
this
Brief Account
trans.
Alexander
given
102, 207).
point. of the
There
2
"A
are
Essential
Wooster Woodruff Beman,
Ziwet,
o f Math,
102,
1855, w h i c h w i l l be discussed later.
i n Analyst, 8
Brief Account of H.
(1885-1886),
1-11
and
five
such
Features
(1)
Hermann
of Grassmann's
Extensive
(1881),
Grassmann's
25-34;
(3)
writings:
96-97
and
Geometrical
Edward Wyllys
114-124; Theories" Hyde,
The
O t h e r E a r l y Vectorial Systems
Directional Analysis
Calculus
(Boston,
(London,
1906);
Grassmann's
1890); (5)
(4)
Joseph
Edward V.
'Ausdehnungslehre'"
Wyllys
Collins, in
American
193-198, 2 6 1 - 2 6 6 , 2 9 7 - 3 0 1 , a n d 7 (1900), 3 1 - 3 5 , 258.
I
have
used
all
Hyde,
"An
Mathematical
163-166,
of these, but their usefulness
is
Grassmann
Elementary
s
Space
Exposition
Monthly,
6
of
(1899),
181-187, 207-214, 253-
definitely limited.
They did
h o w e v e r set t h e s t a n d a r d i n g i v i n g E n g l i s h e q u i v a l e n t s for G r a s s m a n n ' s n e w t e r m s , and I have thus used their terms. I t e m 1 is the o n l y m a t h e m a t i c a l w r i t i n g by Grassm a n n ever translated marize
his
scope;
in
Items
2,
into
Ausdehnungslehre fact
3,
only 32
4,
presentation
and 5
English. of
of the all
is
useful
but
188
stem
substantially
It
1844,
an
sections
from
different
in that in it he attempted to sum-
adequate
summary
o f t h e Ausdehnungslehre
t h e Ausdehnungslehre o f
from
that
of the
was were
1862,
which
earlier book.
beyond
its
summarized. embodied
Item 2
is
a
short,
general, a n d h e n c e l i m i t e d . Items 3 a n d 4 contain Grassmann's ideas in a s i m p l i f i e d f o r m , i.e., l i m i t e d t o t h r e e
d i m e n s i o n s a n d w i t h t h e stress
on
applications.
Item 5
stays f a i r l y c l o s e to t h e o r i g i n a l text of 1862, as 3 a n d 4 do n o t ; it h o w e v e r is m a r r e d by misprints a n d a f e w mathematical errors and, t h o u g h surpassing the above works, still
falls
Finally and
far
short
Alfred
Henry
of b e i n g
North
an
adequate
Whitehead's
George
Forder's
summary
Universal
Calculus
of
Algebra
of the
Ausdehnungslehre
(Cambridge,
Extension
(Cambridge,
of
1862.
England,
1898)
England,
1941)
should be mentioned, though both depart considerably from Grassmann's presentation and content, and hence were used sparingly. 45
(4,1,1;
analysis
62).
This
books
that
may be compared with the any
statement found in
current vector
v e c t o r m a y be e x p r e s s e d in t h e f o r m a\ + bj + ck w h e r e a,
b, c a r e u n i q u e . 46
(4,1,1;
veloped
11-12). in
appeared. 47
the
In
a footnote
second
Grassmann
volume
of
the
stated that this Ausdehnungslehre,
product w o u l d be de-
but
no
second
volume
He d i d h o w e v e r develop this product in other writings.
This was so because for Grassmann any distributive operation was by definition
a multiplication.
F o r G r a s s m a n n ' s p r e s e n t a t i o n o f t h e a b o v e s e c t i o n s e e (4,1,1;
77-
79). 48
C o n c e r n i n g t h i s s e e (4,1,1; 9 3 - 9 9 ,
49
This
was
published
in
114-118).
Grunert's
Archiv
der
Mathematik
und
Physik,
6
(1845),
3 3 7 - 3 5 0 , a n d r e p u b l i s h e d i n (4,1,1; 2 9 7 - 3 1 2 ) . I t w i l l b e d i s c u s s e d l a t e r . H e r e a s e l s e w h e r e in the s u m m a r y Grassmann focused on s u m m a r i z i n g the results m o r e than the methods. 5 0
tial 51
As translated by W. W. Features Josiah
Willard
York, 1961), 52
George
53
The
pointed
Sarton, is
Extensive The
Algebra"
Scientific
"Grassmann"
given
previously,
representation Gauss
Gibbs,
Papers
i n Analyst, o f j .
wrote,
in
Seite
der Ternaren
Carl
Freidrich
in
in
Isis, 3 5 (4,1,11;
in
numbers July,
through
1831,
Formen." This
Gauss,
(1944),
Werke,
vol.
a
was II
this
very
117.
vol.
II
(New
162-167.
It
may be
n o t e d that,
as
we
acquainted with the geometrical letter.
short
however
(1881), Gibbs,
327.
397-398).
Grassmann first became
of complex probably
part
8
Willard
167. F o r a f u l l e r d i s c u s s i o n see pages 9 4 - 1 1 3 ,
letter out
Beman and published as "A Brief Account of the Essen-
of Grassmann's
It m a y also be
essay
entitled
noted that
"Geometrische
only published posthumously
(Gottingen,
1863),
305-310;
therein
in
Gauss
d e v e l o p e d an expression r o u g h l y e q u i v a l e n t to t h e scalar product. 5 4
Ernest
Nagel, " T h e Formation
Development 55
A.
E.
of G e o m e t r y "
Heath,
"The
in
Neglect
of Modern Conceptions of Formal
Osiris,
7
(1939),
of the W o r k
Logic
in the
173-174.
of H.
G r a s s m a n n " i n Monist, 2 7 ( 1 9 1 7 ) ,
24.
105
A H i s t o r y of V e c t o r Analysis 56
Hermann
Giinther
dehnungslehre" 350. 5 7
in
Grassmann, Grunert's
"Kurze
Archiv
Ubersicht
der
Mathematik
iiber
und
das
Wesen
Physik,
6
der
Aus-
(1845),
337-
R e p u b l i s h e d i n (4,1,1; 2 9 7 - 3 1 2 ) . H e r m a n n Giinther Grassmann, " N e v e Theorie der Elektrodynamik" in Poggen-
dorff's
Annalen
der
Physik
und
Chemie,
64
(1845),
1-18.
Republished
in
(4,11,11;
147-160). 58
Strictly speaking it was not a competition, since Grassmann's work was the only
essay s u b m i t t e d ! O n t h i s see (5; 59
Hermann
von
Giinther
Leibnitz
see
erfundene
(4,1,1;
Lehre (1,1;
geometrische
321-398).
von
119).
Grassmann,
For
Mobius'
Punktgrossen
Die
Geometrische
charakteristik essay,
und
den
Analyse
(Leipzig,
which
davon
gekniipft
1847).
For
und
this
die work
was entitled " D i e Grassmannische
abhangenden
Grossenformen,"
see
613-633).
60
See for e x a m p l e Saint-Venant's e x p l i c i t s t a t e m e n t to this effect.
61
I n t h i s r e g a r d i t s h o u l d b e n o t e d t h a t (1) o n e o f G a u s s ' t w o p u b l i c a t i o n s o f 1 8 3 1
was
i n L a t i n (the o t h e r i n G e r m a n ) , a n d h e n c e S a i n t - V e n a n t m i g h t h a v e h a d access
to this w o r k ;
(5; 200).
(2) S a i n t - V e n a n t d e s i g n a t e d v e c t o r s b y a s t r a i g h t l i n e a b o v e t h e l e t t e r
s y m b o l i z i n g the vector (thus
a),
and Argand was the first and only one of the m e n
m e n t i o n e d w h o u s e d t h e s a m e s y m b o l ; a n d (3) S a i n t - V e n a n t k n e w o f W a r r e n ' s w o r k by
at
least
trique des
1853, w h e n he
des
clefs
Sciences,
62
36
mentioned it in
algebriques
(1853),
et
des
an article,
" D e
determinants"
in
l'interpretation geome-
Comptes
rendus
de
VAcademie
583.
A l t h o u g h Saint-Venant is rarely m e n t i o n e d by later authors, he d i d influence his
countryman
Henri
Resal,
whose
Traite
de
Cinematique
pure
(Paris,
1862)
included
a
presentation of elementary vector addition, subtraction, and differentiation as well as
one
vectorial
product.
Resal's
product
was
however not Saint-Venant's;
it was
instead the m o d e r n scalar (dot) p r o d u c t w h i c h h e p r e s u m a b l y created b y g o i n g f r o m S a i n t - V e n a n t ' s a b s i n 6 to a b cos 6. N e i t h e r G r a s s m a n n n o r H a m i l t o n is m e n t i o n e d , and
although
references
to
sufficient to show that the use
of vectorial
Mechanik x-xi
.
methods
Kinematik,
Saint-Venant latter was
in
trans,
are
mechanics
from
few
his source. by
Russian
(see
Joseph by
pages
18
a n d 64), t h e y are
Resal was f o l l o w e d in his l i m i t e d Somoff.
Alexander
See
Somoff,
Ziwet
Theoretische
(Leipzig,
1878),
and 46-51.
63
Augustin
des
Sciences,
Cauchy,
1st
Cauchy, 36
"Sur
(1853),
Ser.,
vol.
les
Clefs
70-75
XI
and
(Paris,
algebriques"
129-136.
1899),
439-445,
in
See and
Comptes
also vol.
rendus
CEuvres
XII
de
VAcademie
completes
d'Augustin
(Paris,
1900),
12-21.
C a u c h y also p u b l i s h e d " S u r les avantages q u e presente, dans
un grand nombre de
questions
36
or
in
1'emploi
CEuvres,
ferentielles rendus,
36
46-63; sur
les
64
et
a
des
Ser., les
(1853),
and clefs
1938),
1st
clefs vol.
variations
38-45
memoir
algebriques,
algebriques"
XII
and
(Paris,
title
57-68,
as
Comptes 21-30;
employees
published
its
in
1900),
as
or a
in
comme CEuvres,
separate
republished
in
rendus, and
clefs
1st
(1853),
"Memoire
algebriques"
Ser.,
vol.
XII
161-169,
sur in
(Paris,
les
dif-
Comptes 1900),
publication
under the
t i t l e Memoire
CEuvres,
Ser.,
XII
2nd
vol.
(Paris,
417-466.
Because of the simplicity of the above illustration, the usefulness of the m e t h o d
for the solution of a large n u m b e r of simultaneous equations is not readily apparent. Cauchy's keys
for
CEuvres,
method the
is
directly analogous
solution
1st Ser., v o l .
of n
XII
equations.
(Paris,
1900),
65
C o n c e r n i n g t h i s s e e (4,1,1; 9 9 - 1 0 2 ;
66
Comte
106
and For 13
involves Cauchy's
the
introduction
more
elaborate
of n distinct example
see
ff.
156-157).
de Saint-Venant, " D e l'interpretation g e o m e t r i q u e des clefs algebriques
O t h e r E a r l y Vectorial Systems
et
des
determinants"
in
Comptes
rendus
de
VAcademie
des
Sciences,
36
(1853),
582-585. 67
Hermann
in
Crelle's
Giinther Journal
Grassmann,
fiir
die
R e p u b l i s h e d i n (4,11,1; 6 8
Victor
Schlegel,
Geschichte schrift 69
fiir
der
VAcademie
und
1st S e r . , v o l .
XI
the
interpretation
developed in Cauchy,
no
in
differents
29
letzten
41 les
(1896),
genres
Mathematik,
de
44
multiplication"
(1855),
123-141.
1899),
Ein
Beitrag
zur
fiinfzig
Schlomilch's
Zeit-
152-160.
Jahren"
The
or
in
in
Comptes
CEuvres
rendus
d'Augustin
de
Cauchy,
method of solving equations given in
later m e t h o d ;
numbers
in
geometriques"
250-257,
w i t h his
complex
Ausdehnungslehre.
6.
Quantites
(1849),
connection of
den
Physik,
(Paris,
paper has
les
angewandte
Grassmann'sche
"Sur
Sciences,
this
70
"Die
Cauchy,
des
"Sur und
199-217).
Mathematik
Mathematik
Augustin
reine
according
the paper deals to
the
mainly with
geometrical
methods
1845 by Saint-Venant for g e o m e t r i c lines. "Sur
les
Clefs
443-445, for
Hamilton;
les
lineaires
moments
algebriques"
and des
Cauchy,
in
CEuvres,
1st
Ser.,
vol.
XI
(Paris,
1899),
" S u r la T h e o r i e des m o m e n t s lineaires et sur
divers ordres"
i n CEuvres,
1st S e r . , v o l . X I I ( P a r i s , 1 9 0 0 ) ,
6, for M o b i u s . 71
Sir
William
Rowan
Hamilton,
Lectures
on
Quaternions
(Dublin,
1853),
(62)
of
Grassmann
et
preface. 72
Luigi
Cremona,
propriete
de
la
"Solution
cubique
des
questions
gauche"
in
494
Nouvelle
et 499