High Lean Country Land, People and Memory in New England
Edited by Alan Atkinson, J.S. Ryan, Iain Davidson and Andrew Piper
High Lean Country PAGES.indd i
7/12/06 5:07:06 PM
First published in 2006 Copyright © Heritage Futures Research Centre 2006 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. The Australian Copyright Act 1968 (the Act) allows a maximum of one chapter or 10 per cent of this book, whichever is the greater, to be photocopied by any educational institution for its educational purposes provided that the educational institution (or body that administers it) has given a remuneration notice to Copyright Agency Limited (CAL) under the Act. Allen & Unwin 83 Alexander Street Crows Nest NSW 2065 Australia Phone: (61 2) 8425 0100 Fax: (61 2) 9906 2218 Email:
[email protected] Web: www.allenandunwin.com National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry: High lean country: land, people and memory in New England. Includes index. ISBN 9781741750867. ISBN 1 74175 086 5. 1. New England (N.S.W.) - History. I. Atkinson, Alan. 994.444 Designed by Tabitha King Set in 10.5/12 pt Adobe Garamond Pro by Midland Typesetters, Australia Printed in Australia by Ligare Book Printer, Sydney 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
High Lean Country PAGES.indd ii
7/12/06 5:07:10 PM
C O N T E NTS List of Maps and Diagrams List of Contributors Acknowledgements ‘South of My Days’
iv v xi Judith Wright
Note on Aboriginal Language Names Prelude: Uplands Always Attract 1. What is New England?
xv J.S. Ryan Alan Atkinson
PA RT 1: P H Y S I C A L E N V I RO N M E N T
2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
The Rocks Beneath Sunshine, Snow, Wind and Rain Wildlife The Vegetated Landscape Land and Livelihood
Robert Haworth Jack Hobbs and Alan Atkinson Peter Jarman and Karl Vernes Peter Clarke Nick Reid and Lewis Kahn
PA RT 2: F I R S T P E O P L E S
7. 8. 9. 10. 11.
Seeing Red: Musings on Rock Art Aboriginal Archaeology The Frontier Aboriginal People and Pastoralism Aborigines and Citizens
14. Homesteads 15. Schools 16. Religious Life 17. Twentieth-century Immigrants 18. Travelling and Communicating 19. Enterprise and Ingenuity 20. Politics
High Lean Country PAGES.indd iii
1 10 21
23 35 44 57 69 79
June Ross Wendy Beck David Andrew Roberts Rodney Harrison Matthew Jordan
PA RT 3: N E WC O M E R S
12. Passing Through 13. Colonial Settlement
xiii
81 88 98 111 122 135
Martin Auster Alan Atkinson and John Atchison Jillian Oppenheimer Bruce Mitchell and Jean Newall Jennifer Clark Janis Wilton Alan Atkinson and John Atchison G.R. Henning Frank Bongiorno
137 148 160 171 184 196 209 221 233
7/12/06 5:07:11 PM
High Lean Country iv
21. War and Its Memories 22. The Archaeology of the New Peoples 23. Collecting and Presenting the Past
Ian M. Johnstone 245 Pamela Watson 253 Nicole McLennan, Bill Oates, 263 Andrew Piper and Alan Atkinson 277
PART 4: REPRESENTATIONS 24. 25. 26. 27. 28.
Imagining New England A University Becoming Stories and Prose Music Theatre
29. Film 30. Visual Arts Epilogue: ‘a high lean country/ full of old stories’
Julian Croft Don Aitkin J.S. Ryan Richard Peter Maddox Judith Lamb and Christopher Ross-Smith Neil Rattigan Meg Vivers Iain Davidson
279 291 296 308 319 333 344 355
Endnotes Index
363 409
Maps and Diagrams New England’s location Aboriginal language groups of New England Mean altitudes of the major levels of the New England Tablelands (1911) Cross-sections of continental passive margin structures The climate and weather of Australia (1913) Bora grounds and ceremonial stone arrangements Sites of frontier violence in the 1830s and 40s Plan of Kunderang homestead Nineteenth-century mining settlements Some New England homesteads New England locations referred to in The Shiralee Journeys and stops by Conrad Martens and Tom Roberts
xiv xiv 31 33 39 89 99 120 151 161 302 346
High Lean Country PAGES.indd iv
7/12/06 5:07:11 PM
L I ST O F C O N TRIBUTORS Don Aitkin, AO, has been Professor of Politics at Macquarie University and of Political Science at the Australian National University (ANU), chair of the Australian Research Council and Vice-Chancellor of the University of Canberra. He is author of The Colonel: A Political Biography of Sir Michael Bruxner, The Country Party in New South Wales, The Second Chair, Stability and Change in Australian Politics, and joint author of Australian Political Institutions. John Atchison has taught Australian history at the Armidale College of Advanced Education and at the University of New England (UNE). He has chaired the Committee for Geographical Names in Australia (Intergovernmental Committee on Surveying and Mapping) and was an elected member of the Board of the International Council of Onomastic Sciences. Alan Atkinson has a research fellowship in history at UNE. His books include Camden: Farm and Village Life in Early New South Wales, The Common Task: A History of PLC Armidale (with Catherine Pound) and The Europeans in Australia, volumes one and two. His writing has won several national awards. He is currently a member of the Australian Research Council. Martin Auster teaches cyberspatial geography, architectural history, and urban planning law and administration, among other things, at UNE. He has an interest in cultural landscapes and is the author of A Poem on the Drummond Memorial Column in Drummond Park, Armidale: Being an Allegorical History of the University of New England, from Its Beginnings to its Present Time of Difficulty. Wendy Beck teaches archaeology at UNE. She has edited Plants in Australian Archaeology (with Anne Clarke and Lesley Head) and Gendered Archaeology: The Second Australian Women in Archaeology Conference (with Jane Balme) and was one of the authors of Yarrawarra Places Making Stories. In 1989 and 1990 she was President of the Australian Archaeological Association. Frank Bongiorno teaches history, including Australian local history, at UNE. He is author of The People’s Party: Victorian Labor and the Radical Tradition, 1875–1914 and has contributed chapters on New England’s political history to several publications connected with the Sesquicentenary of Responsible Government in New South Wales (2006). During 2003–05 he was chair of the Literature and History Committee, NSW Ministry for the Arts.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd v
7/12/06 5:07:12 PM
High Lean Country vi
Jennifer Clark teaches Australian and American history at UNE. She is a former Harkness Fellow at the University of Pennsylvania. She has published in the areas of war and society, nationalism, Anglo-American literature, church history and memorial culture. Peter Clarke teaches plant ecology at UNE. He has been a plant collector at the University of Sydney, a vegetation mapper at the Royal Botanic Gardens, Sydney and a soil conservationist studying coastal vegetation. He began his post-graduate studies in mangroves whilst working for CSIRO and his most recent research has focused on fire ecology. Julian Croft is Emeritus Professor of English at UNE. He has published one novel, four volumes of poetry (including Breakfasts in Shanghai, 1985, awarded the British Airways Commonwealth Poetry Prize for the Asia Pacific region), a study of the Australian novelist Joseph Furphy (The Life and Opinions of Tom Collins, awarded the McCrae Russell Prize), and numerous academic articles in the fields of Australian, Anglo-Welsh, and African literatures. Iain Davidson teaches archaeology at UNE, focusing on empirical and theoretical issues, particularly in the symbolic construction of landscape and in the history of communications and transport. He has been president of the Australian Archaeological Association (1991–92) and in 2003 he was a Fellow at the Collegium Budapest, Hungary. Rodney Harrison is a research fellow in archaeology at the University of Western Australia, and an adjunct fellow in the Centre for Cross-Cultural Research at the ANU. With Christine Williamson, he edited After Captain Cook, a series of essays on the historical archaeology of Aboriginal Australia, and in 2004 published Shared Landscapes: Archaeologies of Attachment and the Pastoral Industry in New South Wales. Robert Haworth is a geomorphologist and environmental historian at UNE, with a special interest in the effects of land use changes in Australia on settlement patterns, the landscape and society, including the folkways and folklore of Australia. He has published widely in academic journals, most recently on issues of sea-level change and erosion. G.R. Henning is a widely published economic historian and a member of the School of Economics at UNE. He has long been an active member of the Armidale and District Historical Society, and is working on an account of the New England industries, to appear as a School of Economics working paper. During 2005–10 he is president of International Commission for Maritime History (part of the Comité International des Sciences Historiques, or CISH).
High Lean Country PAGES.indd vi
7/12/06 5:07:12 PM
List of Contributors Jack Hobbs has been a geographer at UNE for 33 years, with a particular interest in climatology and natural hazards. He was editor, with J.A. Lindesay and H.A. Bridgman, of Climates of the Southern Continents: Present, Past, and Future. He is currently Assistant Master of Earle Page College at UNE.
vii
Peter Jarman is Emeritus Professor of Ecosystem Management at UNE. His major interest has been the behavioural ecology of large mammalian herbivores—antelopes in Africa and kangaroos in Australia—and interactions between wildlife and humans, especially through land-use practices. His books include Kangaroos: Two Centuries of Ecosystem Management and Land Use in a Changing Climate (edited with Kath Johnson). Ian M. Johnstone, born in Armidale, practised as a solicitor in that city for 40 years. He has published over 60 papers and letters on legal topics including environmental law, primary production, conveyancing and no-fault compensation. He has researched the lives of those from Armidale, and from The Armidale School, who fell in both World Wars, and was President of Armidale and District Historical Society during 1999–2004. Matthew Jordan has published on the history of the White Australia policy and he is also the author of A Spirit of True Learning: The Jubilee History of the University of New England, which was written to mark the 50th anniversary of UNE, in 2004. He now works in the Office of National Assessments, in Canberra. Lewis Kahn is a senior research scientist at UNE, specialising in agricultural ecosystems and with a focus on nutrition, health and production of grazing livestock and pasture ecology. He also works with the consultancy Agricultural Information and Monitoring Services (AIMS) on the better management of grazing lands and livestock in northern New South Wales and South Australia. Judith Lamb, OAM, has been associated with Armidale theatre for over 40 years, as an actor and director, and has also been a local journalist and bookshop proprietor. With support from UNE, she has recently written Never Whistle in the Dressing Room, a history of Armidale’s long love affair with the theatre. Nicole McLennan has been a lecturer at the Australian Catholic University and a research editor for the Australian Dictionary of Biography, and she was a curator at the National Museum of Australia, in Canberra. She is currently University Curator at UNE’s Heritage Centre, and co-ordinator for the New England and North West Chapter of Museums Australia. Richard Peter Maddox has degrees in music from the universities of London, Sydney and California, and he has taught at UNE. He now concentrates on composing, conducting and accompanying, working with many local musicians
High Lean Country PAGES.indd vii
7/12/06 5:07:13 PM
High Lean Country viii
in the Armidale area. His compositions are published by Warner-Chappell (Los Angeles) and The Keys Press (Perth). Bruce Mitchell taught in the History Department at UNE for 24 years, specialising in Australian history. He has been active in local history societies and the National Trust and has written numerous books and articles about the history of education and of families and houses in New England. Jean Newall is the archivist for St Peter’s Cathedral, Armidale, as well as the New England Girl’s School, whose archive centre is named in her honour. A former teacher and librarian, she has co-authored two books on the history of the New England Girl’s School and contributed articles to many journals. Bill Oates is the university archivist at UNE. He has worked at all levels of government record keeping for Commonwealth, State and Local Government organisations. He is in the vanguard of record keepers seeking to preserve valuable records for future generations as well as deliver our documented heritage to this generation via the internet. Jillian Oppenheimer, OAM, was a grazier for over 30 years. She has also been a member of the Council and Board of the National Trust of Australia (NSW), and for eleven years its vice-president. She was a Councillor of UNE, 2002–06. She has published numerous articles and books about people and places in New England as well as organising local history workshops and related activities. Andrew Piper has worked in the cultural heritage industry since 1981 as an archaeologist, curator and site manager in Africa, Australia, Micronesia and New Zealand. For five years he was the senior heritage professional at the Port Arthur Historic Site, Tasmania. He has since been co-ordinator of the Heritage Futures Research Centre and now teaches history at UNE. Neil Rattigan teaches film studies at UNE. His publications include Images of Australia: 100 Films of the New Australian Cinema, This is England: British Film and the People’s War, 1939–1945, and a study of the 1991 Australian film Strictly Ballroom. His continuing research interests are Australian cinema, post-war British cinema, the films of Woody Allen, and film and fairy/folk tales. Nick Reid teaches at UNE, specialising in sustainable agriculture and catchment management, agroforestry, protected area management and ecology. He is particularly interested in the integration of resources at local and regional levels and in biodiversity in production landscapes. His current research includes collaborative projects with the cotton and wool industries and the New South Wales National Parks and Wildlife Service.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd viii
7/12/06 5:07:14 PM
List of Contributors David Andrew Roberts teaches Australian history at UNE. He wrote his PhD thesis on the colonial frontier at Wellington Valley and has since written on numerous topics including convict history, race relations, Aboriginal religious change and Aboriginal rock paintings. He is co-author of Ancient Ochre: The Aboriginal Rock Paintings of Mount Borradaile (2003).
ix
June Ross trained as a designer in Sydney before going on to teach art at primary and secondary school level and then at the New England Regional Art Museum, where she developed the education and public programs. Having completed a PhD on the archaeological analysis of rock art in the central Australian Desert, she now teaches in archaeology at UNE. Christopher Ross-Smith has worked as an actor, director and lecturer in the UK, the USA and Africa. He was deputy director of the National Institute of Dramatic Art, Sydney, before establishing the Drama Department at UNE, where he was primarily responsible for its initial direction as well as developing the external major in Theatre Studies. As a member of the New South Wales Drama Syllabus Committee he helped to implement the first two-unit drama syllabus offered at HSC level. J.S. Ryan of UNE has long written and edited northern cultural materials and novelists and poets with strong New England and North Coast connections. He has published linguistic, biographical and other material with the Armidale and District Historical Society and in folklore journals worldwide. He is editor of Australian Folklore: A Yearly Journal of Folklore Studies and editorial board member of Greenwood’s Encyclopedia of World Folklore. Karl Vernes lectures in wildlife ecology, conservation and management at UNE. His research interests include mammal ecology and conservation, ecological relationships between mammals and fungi, and management of native and introduced wildlife. He has postgraduate degrees from James Cook University and held the McCain Postdoctoral Fellowship in the Biology Department at Mount Allison University, New Brunswick. Meg Vivers is a long-time resident of New England and is enrolled in a PhD at UNE, with a thesis on women’s writing in colonial Australia. She is author of Mick and the Manager, a book about her father and an Aboriginal stockman who worked with him. She writes poetry and is a successful artist, many of her paintings reflecting her love of the New England landscape. Pamela Watson is Adjunct Senior Lecturer in Archaeology at UNE and directs historical archaeology projects in the region. Her background is partly in the archaeology of Late Antiquity the Middle East, and she has spent many years in Jordan, where she was co-director of the Pella Project (amongst others)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd ix
7/12/06 5:07:14 PM
High Lean Country x
and assistant director of the British Institute at Amman for Archaeology and History. Janis Wilton, OAM, teaches Australian History at UNE, specialising in oral and immigration history. She is coordinator of the state-funded Golden Threads Project on the Chinese in regional New South Wales, which has resulted in a website and a travelling exhibition. She has been President of the International Oral History Association and is a Trustee of the Historic Houses Trust of New South Wales.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd x
7/12/06 5:07:15 PM
AC K N OW L E DG EMENTS This book is born of the collaborative expertise of members of the Heritage Futures Research Centre at the University of New England. In a similar spirit, many others have helped in the work in one way or another, and we are very grateful for their contributions. Robin Riley and John Farrell supplied useful historical information, and Robin went to considerable trouble unearthing photographs from early Tenterfield. Michael Sharkey similarly located photographs for Chapter 24. Ann-Katrin Eckermann, Diane Roberts, Vera Lovelock and Elva Taylor laid the foundation for Chapter 11. The staff of the Dixson Library at UNE have, as usual, been unremittingly helpful throughout the project. The University Archivist, Bill Oates, Philip Ward and other members of staff at UNE’s Heritage Centre have also taken very considerable trouble, especially with the supply of pictures. David Elkins, UNE’s photographer, and Michael Watson very kindly took and copied photographs for us. We are grateful also to Michael Roach and Cate MacGregor for drawing the maps, Cate the first two and Michael the remainder. We owe a great deal, as usual, to Trish Wright-Langsford and Gina Butler in the School of Classics, History and Religion. Gina has been endlessly patient in dealing with the illustrations. For permission to reproduce lines of verse, we are grateful to Jack Bedson and to Carmen Blomfield (both in Chapter 12; Bedson for his own verse and Mrs Blomfield for that of her late husband, Geoff Blomfield), and to Geoff Page (for his own verse, in Chapter 21). The lines from Judith Wright—‘South of My Days’ (opening the book), ‘Bora Ring’ (in Chapter 8), ‘Wildflower Plain’ (in Chapter 12), and ‘Bullocky’ (in Chapter 18), all from A Human Pattern: Selected Poems (ETT Imprint, Sydney, 1996)—are reproduced with the permission of ETT Imprint, and with thanks also to Meredith McKinney. Most of the illustrations have been supplied either by the authors themselves or from the Heritage Centre. Four pictures, in Chapters 1 (John Wetherspoon), 6 (farm at Moree), 16 (Rev. A. Cameron) and 19 (butter factory), are taken from The Land of ‘The Beardies’, published by the Glen Innes Municipal Council in 1922. One, in the Prelude (Judith Wright, in about 1950), is from The Concise Encyclopædia of Modern World Literature (ed. G. Grigson, 1963); and one in Chapter 3 (Wallamumbi Falls) is from The Picturesque Atlas of Australia (ed. A. Garran, 1888). For the remaining pictures, we acknowledge the following: among the colour plates, the Nymboida River sketch comes with permission to publish from the State Records of New South Wales; ‘Bailed Up’, by Tom Roberts, with permission to publish from the Art Gallery of New South Wales; ‘Time and Two Waterfalls’ by Stuart Boggs, from the artist, with permission to publish;
High Lean Country PAGES.indd xi
7/12/06 5:07:15 PM
High Lean Country xii
Anna Henderson’s pots, from Anna and David Henderson, with permission to publish; Jenny Evelyn’s digital art, from the artist, with permission to publish; and Anne Andrews’ two photographs from herself, with permission to publish. In Chapter 3, the image of snow in Armidale is from a picture held by Bruce Cady, and we thank him for permission to use it. In Chapter 10, the picture of branding at Kunderang is taken from the Fitzgerald-McDonell family albums held by the New South Wales Department of Environment and Conservation, in Armidale (thanks to Chris Lehmann for enquiries with regard to permission). In Chapters 27 and 28, the two images of performances in Tenterfield come, with permission, from originals held by the Tenterfield and District Historical Society. In Chapter 29, the image from The Picture Show Man is used with the permission of Limelight Productions and that from The Chant of Jimmy Blacksmith (supplied by the National Film and Sound Archive) with the permission of Fred Schepisi. In Chapter 30, the image of Conrad Martens’ drawing of Salisbury Court was supplied, with permission to publish, by the State Library of New South Wales, and with the agreement of Sir Owen and Lady Croft, of Salisbury Court. The image of Gerhard Koertner’s drawing was supplied by the artist and reproduced with his permission. We are also grateful to Lauren Finger and others at Allen & Unwin for their efficiency. John Ryan compiled the index.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd xii
7/12/06 5:07:16 PM
South of My Days Judith Wright (1940) South of my days’ circle, part of my blood’s country, rises that tableland, high delicate outline of bony slopes wincing under the winter, low trees, blue-leaved and olive, outcropping granite— clean, lean, hungry country. The creek’s leaf-silenced, willow-choked, the slope a tangle of medlar and crabapple branching over and under, blotched with a green lichen; and the old cottage lurches in for shelter. O cold the black-frost night. The walls draw in to the warmth and the old roof cracks its joints; the slung kettle hisses a leak on the fire. Hardly to be believed that summer will turn up again some day in a wave of rambler roses, thrust its hot face in here to tell another yarn— a story old Dan can spin into a blanket against the winter. Seventy years of stories he clutches round his bones, Seventy years are hived in him like old honey. Droving that year, Charleville to the Hunter, nineteen-one it was, and the drought beginning; sixty head left at the McIntyre, the mud round them hardened like iron; and the yellow boy died in the sulky ahead with the gear, but the horse went on, stopped at Sandy Camp and waited in the evening. It was the flies we seen first, swarming like bees. Came to the Hunter, three hundred head of a thousand— cruel to keep them alive—and the river was dust. Or mustering up in the Bogongs in the autumn when the blizzards came early. Brought them down; we brought them down, what aren’t there yet. Or driving for Cobb’s on the run up from Tamworth—Thunderbolt at the top of Hungry Hill, and I give him a wink. I wouldn’t wait long, Fred, not if I was you; the troopers are just behind, coming for that job at the Hillgrove. He went like a luny, him on his big black horse. Oh, they slide and they vanish as he shuffles the years like a pack of conjuror’s cards. True or not, it’s all the same; and the frost on the roof cracks like a whip, and the back-log break into ash. Wake, old man. This is winter, and the yarns are over. No-one is listening. South of my days’ circle I know it dark against the stars, the high lean country full of old stories that still go walking in my sleep.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd xiii
7/12/06 5:07:16 PM
❈ New England, showing its position within New South Wales and Australia.
❈ The Aboriginal language groups of New England.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd xiv
7/12/06 5:07:17 PM
Note on Aboriginal Language Names We have used the versions of language names prepared by the University of New England’s Discipline of Linguistics with local Aboriginal groups, working through the Oorala Centre, UNE; the Armidale Aboriginal Cultural Centre and Keeping Place (which holds the 2002 copyright of the supporting map); Armidale Dumaresq Council; and the GamilaraayYuwaalaraay Languages Network. There are other conventional versions, ‘Kamilaroi’ being an especially common alternative to ‘Gamilaraay’.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd xv
7/12/06 5:07:18 PM
High Lean Country PAGES.indd xvi
7/12/06 5:07:18 PM
P R E LU D E ❈
Up l a n d s A l w ay s Attract J. S . Ry a n
There is a part of England, an inland northern region set high above sea level, namely West Yorkshire, in which landscape still famously overshadows humanity, and where there remains a direct reliance on the land for food and employment and an awareness in its inhabitants of its isolation, outstanding scenery, diverse wildlife and cherished culture. In Australia, New England is a similarly elevated place, renowned for its brilliantly clear light—something noted by many regional writers (see Chapter 26 of this book)—and for its numerous sharp contrasts with the sun-drenched, holiday-focused beaches and densely populated cities of the coast. To New England, as to West Yorkshire, many visitors now come for solace, to enjoy a wide variety of leisure pursuits in the invigorating atmosphere, and to savour the distinctive and haunting settings of the innumerable stories—‘great flapping ribbons of shaped spacetime’— that enfold our identity.1 In Australia, as in the United States and the United Kingdom, the shocking upheavals of the first half of the twentieth century created among ordinary people the need to bond more deeply with the past in their places of residence. Both within universities and throughout western society for the last 60 years or so there has been an almost irresistible urge, both for those still living near their birthplaces and for newcomers, to engage with the local experience by grounding themselves more personally in their own landscape and its cultural heritage. Without a narrated past in and for our own place, we cannot face the dubious present or overwhelming future. Similarly, from such a vantage point the spaces of the world beyond can be explored with much more confidence.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 1
7/12/06 5:07:18 PM
High Lean Country 2
In New England, resident and visitor alike have been bemused by a potent sense of the past, a concern for the use and abuse of the earth’s resources, and a cultural ambience—an insistent pattern—categorised by a love of history and hierarchy, of order and beauty, and implying obedience, it almost seems, to some divine law. For there is here a certain orderly impress on the chaos of Australia’s history, a sense of sacredness and permanence, of community cohesiveness and of collective and inherited identity. To walk into a coaching inn built in 1856, surviving from pioneering days and still offering hospitality in the northern village of Deepwater, is to catch some of this feeling. What is now the New England Highway once had need of many such livery stables. To visit the western town of Inverell is to be reminded that the Celtic tongue was familiar on the lips of those who invented the name of that place—existing as it does nowhere else on any map in the world. In short, ‘Inverell’ was forged by those on the spot to mean ‘the confluence of waters where swans are to be found’. We believe in our landscape and have not forgotten its symbols. We are concerned to preserve the significant and the beautiful, and to affirm the relationship between cultural and economic regeneration.
❈ Judith Wright (1915–2000), one of Australia’s finest poets, was born and grew up at Wallamumbi, on the western edge of the escarpment, and although she spent most of her life elsewhere in Australia, much of her writing is about New England. Her sense of place and of people-in-place has helped to inspire this book. (photo: Moss Studio)
E M E RG I N G D I F F E R E N C E
Early in the settlement years, New England was the name of a sprawling northern pastoral district, and is now usually regarded as an extensive but undefined area in the north of New South Wales. From the beginning it seemed to many that the region deserved its own government. The Reverend Dr John Dunmore Lang (1799–1878) was one of those who argued for the creation of a number of small provinces in north-eastern Australia, each free of centralised bureaucracy and committed to a type of local free enterprise consistent with the social wellbeing of each provincial community. In the last third of the nineteenth century
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 2
7/12/06 5:07:18 PM
Prelude such arguments caused the drafters of the Federal Constitution to insert provisions for additional states and for their admission to the Commonwealth-to-be. And indeed, partly because of New England’s strongly articulated perception of its ‘difference’ and destiny, Armidale was—if briefly and with numerous other candidates—a proposed ‘Capital Site’ for the whole nation after Federation.2 However, the possibility of a separate New England remained a relatively quiescent issue until 1915 when Dr Earle Page, of Grafton—whose family had been admirers of J.D. Lang for three generations—boldly launched the New State Movement, an early campaign for separation from the rest of New South Wales. Page later became Member for Cowper in the Australian Parliament, and his increasing authority helped to push the movement forward. In 1934, a royal commission headed by H.S. Nicholas distinguished one obviously ‘cohesive NSW area’ in the districts between (and including) Newcastle and the Hunter valley and the Queensland border, an area already described as ‘the (proposed state of ) New England’.3 This recommendation helped to crystallise popular perception, and to draw out certain of New England’s more distinctive characteristics. Several of these attitudes are discussed in various parts of this book. They include a deep-seated distrust of an all-devouring Sydney. This last notion has overlapped with a persisting faith in development through decentralisation and through truly responsible local government, together with new ports on the North Coast, and so on. Note too, a long-running tendency in this region to nourish extreme right-wing groups, such as the New Guard and the League of Rights. New England has long demonstrated a Scottish desire for the generous provision of education for all, especially higher education. On the social and personal front, there was long the tendency to award quasi-aristocratic status to various early squatting families—among them the Ogilvies, the Whites, the Dangars, the Crofts, the Munros, the destiny-conscious Wyndhams and their minor branch, the Wrights, and so on. Among regional writers, there has persisted a somewhat blinkered obsession with the lives of these pioneering pastoralists. But New England’s sense of hierarchy and place also involved a commitment to the quality of the environment manifest in the drive for the New England National Park and for the University of New England’s School of Natural Resources, both orchestrated by leading graziers. Since the 1970s there have been similar campaigns for the creation of walking trails across unspoiled areas and giving onto magnificent mountain vistas. In July 1921, Earle Page described the core concerns of the separation movement in the first issue of the monthly New State Magazine. They were: the ‘developmental needs of the great wide spaces’ of Australia; ‘the decay of the countryside’; the conquest of drought; adequate public transport; the cultural development of new centres, to give ‘fresh stimulation to education and the cultivation of the arts and sciences’; and a conviction that ‘the country will find again its own power of expression and renew the old attraction it exerted before modern inventions irresistibly drew all into the city’.4 By this time the movement had 177 ‘leagues’ throughout the north of New South Wales, and
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 3
3
7/12/06 5:07:19 PM
High Lean Country 4
❈ The New State Movement was always seen as a part of nation-building. Here, Earle Page stands in silhouette— strangely pointing backwards—on the cover of a booklet (published 1947) by Ulrich Ellis, the movement’s leading writer.
twelve larger ‘district councils’ busily organising in the same area. Subsequent issues of the Magazine (it did not survive beyond the year) elaborated on the need to revise the Australian Constitution; to follow at the local level the already planned devolution of the British Empire into a Commonwealth of Nations—a community of equals—so to reinforce local government; and to keep the faith with the many thousands of men otherwise pointlessly lost in World War One, by the local provision of education for all. On this last theme a prominent ex-serviceman, Victor Bacon, of Coffs Harbour, remarked in the Magazine that the area of the proposed new state had only three post-primary schools, whereas New Zealand, which was of comparable size, had 119 high schools and four university colleges. Bacon wanted a technical school for every town with a population of 3000 or 4000 people, ‘scores’ of agricultural colleges, and some ‘four or five University Colleges affiliated with each other, and linked by an interlocked railway system, one radiating from a centrally situated capital city’.5 Such visions were to long imbue many local campaigners, and they seemed almost to be realised in the longdelayed and frustrating ‘hung’ Referendum of 1967 (see Chapter 21). Thus
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 4
7/12/06 5:07:20 PM
Prelude from 1921, if not earlier, we can also date a powerful ‘New England’ passion for the generous provision of education to all, and a significant willingness from secular and church leaders of various denominations to support all local tertiary education, meaningful decentralisation and a vigorous country life and enriched lifestyle for all—notably by keeping families together and employed—and, as an ultimate goal, life-long cultural fulfilment here in New England. Between the wars—and again from 1946 to 1970—there were many conferences and conventions throughout the region pressing for separation. A milestone gathering in Armidale in 1948 confirmed the boundaries laid down by the Nicholas Royal Commission, and also supported a plan for an autonomous university. The two leaders of the New England University College (NEUC) Council—and soon (1954) of the autonomous university—were the national leader of the Country Party, Earle Page himself, and the chairman of the New State Movement, P.A. Wright, a prominent grazier from east of Armidale. Some saw the separation movement as the hobby of eccentric jingoists, but at its core were many dedicated local regionalists who were also shaping the University College, notably the Scottish-descended David Drummond (a founder of both the Teachers’ College and NEUC, and at this point a federal MP), Dr James Belshaw (Deputy Warden of NEUC), the Kempsey-born geologist Dr Alan Voisey and the dynamic and compassionate Warden of NEUC, Dr (afterwards Sir) Robert Madgwick. Madgwick had been a brilliantly successful director of the wartime Army Education Service. He never formally entered politics, but remained totally committed to these visionary decentralising plans for education, while pioneering massive outreach schemes for adult education.6 In short, regional feeling gained a sharper edge from the ideals of enlightenment. Important as well was Christian compassion, galvanised by the difficulties of the 1930s depression.
5
OUR NEW ENGLAND REGION AND ITS COMMUNITY
Discrete regions have always moulded the Australian settler, migrant and refugee experience and, whether we are drawn to them or flee from them, the places we live in and visit etch themselves on European-Australian memory—as they have long done for the Indigenous peoples. We still use perceptions of ‘region’ today to provide definition to our lives, despite a certain reluctance to study such zones in a focused and thoughtful way. Yet, as individuals growing older, we, like the nation, are more concerned to understand the environment, history and enforcing culture of our more immediate lives—in short, to savour a sense of place, of the patterning of lives as lived here, of time working to mould our particular physical circumstances, well aware that it is this small-scale process that makes up our Australian character. In this book the contributors aim to explore, record and interpret our regional heritage and shared identity, thereby reducing persistent misunderstandings about this somewhat aloof, even elusive, zone. Thus these essays offer a series of perceptions, a synthesis of experience and character, which should
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 5
7/12/06 5:07:23 PM
High Lean Country 6
serve to mediate reflectively between the sciences, the social sciences and the humanities as they apply to New England. High Lean Country constitutes the first coming together in print of members of the Heritage Futures Research Centre at the University of New England. This research group, an inter-School and, to some extent, inter-Faculty colloquium of the interested, is committed to exploring in lively fashion the geomorphology, landscape, inherited natural environment, native and later peoples, history, economy, cultural endeavours and experiences, and the more representative and artistic interpretations, both written and pictorial, of the region. Some of us have earlier worked with various organisations in Tenterfield, in the north of New England, to assist that community in scrutinising both its historical and contemporary landscapes in order to produce a reflective self-study as to its identity. The resulting report presented Tenterfield and its district as they might be seen today by residents, and as they might appear to visitors and tourists or, for that matter, to students at whatever level.7 At the time, it was hoped that that pilot project from our communityfocused university would lead to larger ones aimed at investigating, recording and publishing research materials about the region as a whole, thereby enlarging and clarifying its sense of its several inheritances, its identity and its culture.8 The present volume is the result—similar to the Tenterfield survey, but probing more deeply into the various regional and discipline-based perceptions that New England can embrace.
❈ This book is another step forward in the detailed observation of New England. Here, John Fauna Campbell, resident surveyor at Walcha and a skilled botanist (right), is seen in 1897 with two experts from Sydney, J.H. Maiden, the government botanist, and William Forsyth, overseer of Centennial Park. (photo: unknown)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 6
7/12/06 5:07:23 PM
Prelude This book, then, is a team product of the Heritage Futures Research Centre, one concerned to inform the reader about the manifold heritage aspects of our region, its people and its traditions. In their totality, these lively contributions endorse two central and general notions. The first is that heritage is best understood when disciplines and their manifestations and data are collected, then sorted and focused in an appropriate and categorised fashion. The second is concerned with understanding the purpose of any heritage—once we have conceptualised or created it—with its better explication, sharing and presentation and, over time, its configuration and reconfiguration (see, for example, Chapters 2 and 23). We are all historical subjects, moving through time and space, and we should have the opportunity to understand the rooms and passages through which we travel. While Australian federal law may determine the fate of larger heritage items, and State law the treatment of significant structures, much more wideranging types of the region’s heritage have been identified throughout the various chapters of this book, particularly the stories and personal histories of its people. The larger themes woven through our tapestry include many once integral to the New State Movement. Implicit in our writing is a sense of the common need for personal space, clean air and green and uplifting vistas—an urge to ‘decentralise’. The reformist ideas of the New England tradition are far too often misunderstood or ignored by the centre, including as they do a deep-seated distrust of today’s ‘maximisation’ and its creeping authoritarian mentality, a conviction of the need to de-standardise Australian lifestyles and, at the same time, a readiness for high technology in agriculture, marketing and the ingenious delivery of education and ideas—all of which depend on an innovative spirit within (see, for example, Chapter 19). This Prelude is concerned to establish in readers a sense of the unexpected contrasts in New England experience, and of its nuanced differences from the larger national experience, even as our book also promulgates many distinctive perspectives as to the region’s history, dilemmas and development, its art and lifestyle. New England retains from its spacious past a lively emphasis on anecdote, story and biography—be it presented in settler history, regional radio, public lectures, migrant tales, or by performance poets—and likewise a strong musical tradition, manifest not only among the Koori people, but from Tamworth, with its country music, to Armidale, with its Bach festivals, and beyond. New England politics, too, have long been distinctive—typically provocative and disconcertingly personal. The English scholar William Hoskins once wrote that ‘the English landscape itself, to those who know how to read it aright, is the richest historical record we possess’.9 We cannot make a similar sweeping claim for the way we have interpreted our physical and cultural landscapes, but we hope that the accumulation of scholarly perspectives will give the reader many powerful ways of understanding both the various enduring and changing faces of New England and the nuances of thought and action lying behind the past and present patterns of our regional experience.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 7
7
7/12/06 5:07:24 PM
High Lean Country 8
New England’s character has never been isolationist. Rather it is outreaching, heterogeneous, open to possibility and sensitive to local idiosyncrasies. It involves a belief in flexible governance and an ability to adjust to new challenges, both by entering into voluntary agreements and by creating intellectual and cooperative links between localities and institutions. The core policies of the New State Movement soon found an echo in the world-pioneering outreach of the University of New England’s departments of Adult Education (founded 1948) and (from 1954) of External Studies. Regionalism in New England, as it exists today, has grown by profiting from the challenges offered by a scattered population, a freedom from the scars and legacies of heavy industry, and an articulate and even passionate opposition to the apparently inevitable impact of suburban segregation on the natural environment and the best aspects of humanity. From very different perspectives, Judith Wright and Anglican Bishop of Armidale between 1929 and 1964, John Stoward Moyes (see Chapter 1), powerfully expressed this point of view. Through its focal point—its university—and because of its general cast of mind, New England has sought with success to minimise social disparities and also to broaden community involvement in economic growth. Quite apart from education in a formal sense, its political, religious and artistic leaders have been evangelists of political equality, civic tolerance and cultural enrichment and expression. DEFIANCE?
It is worth the long drive up the New England highway, just to have such a feast of talk and society. Les Murray, ‘North of My Days’ 10 Our book reports on the scholarship of our physical and cultural environments, on many historical matters and social-educational concepts, and on extensive data from current and developing research work in many fields. Perhaps, too, it may be seen as a powerful record of our various deepening insights into the meaning of the region from particular disciplinary points of view. Few of the writers of this book were born here, and several come from other countries, yet all have been enthused by their local experiences, by practising their disciplines here, and re-invigorating their scholarly and personal philosophies in this setting. High Lean Country is no mere compilation of data. Its merit—or at least its greater purpose—lies in a fresh identification of patterns, changes and interrelations, thereby presenting many useful epistemological and cultural concepts. Many will already be familiar to some readers, while others may well seem provocative, or debatable. We believe them all to be fascinating. In November 1990, at the National Conference of the Australian Folklore Association, at a seminar on identity held in the shadow of Mt Duval, near Armidale, the speakers concluded that the single quality of difference that best
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 8
7/12/06 5:07:25 PM
Prelude marked the mental climate of New England was ‘defiance’, and in particular defiance of media-formed and simplistic and centralising (Australian) conformities.11 Indeed, there are parallels between New England and certain provinces in medieval Europe—only slowly settled and often culturally distinct—and, more recently, parallels between New England and the provinces of New Zealand, similarly settled by Europeans in the mid-nineteenth century and similarly defiant of pressures from the centre. In New England, homesteads, schools, cathedrals and university have all proved potent phenomena for enriching the realms of values, activities, roles and beliefs, both socially and symbolically, and for the promulgation of a moral authority the more successfully empowering for its being quietly exercised. Our tradition of cultural provision, persisting now for a century and more, is alive and defiantly shaping social actions and human relationships, ‘its overall meaning greater than the sum of its possible expressions’, as one of our most penetrating cultural historians has so proudly told the world.12 Finally, by their concentration on the quality of the private sphere rather than the public, the citizens of New England have had as their concern personal morality rather than centralist policy. So they have created a space where the individual may indeed dissent, survive and, in the words of Armidale Dumaresq Council’s challenging slogan, ‘thrive’. Pride and defiance, smallness of scale and the acknowledgement of individuality, social compassion and the wondrous clarity of atmosphere and thought—these, surely, abide as New England’s fascination, and as an inheritance that, like Chaucer’s modest scholar, it would gladly share.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 9
9
7/12/06 5:07:25 PM
CHAPTER 1 ❈
W h a t is Ne w En g lan d? Al an At ki n s o n
O’er all the wide Australian land I’ve wandered far and near, Through dusky scrubs and dreary plains The haunts of pallid fear; O’er valleys green and mountains high Where wild marsupials roam— Yet thou are dearer far to me My own New England home. So wrote John Wetherspoon, of Glencoe, near Glen Innes, in 1871, summing up in stumbling rhyme a real love of country. What was it he liked so much about New England? Most of his poem was a list of less interesting spots, from ancient Greece (over-rated, by comparison) to ‘the red Barcoo’ and the deserts of the Darling. But he did mention some local pleasures—or, as he called them, ‘scenes which please my beating heart’. They included the mountains, ‘[m]ajestic in their height’, the shaded valleys and New England’s still famous waterfalls.1 Wetherspoon was not a brilliant poet. All the same, he was one of the first in this part of Australia to try to capture its landscape in verse. There were three places in the world he felt passionate about. One was Scotland, his native country, though he had left it as a child and he could barely remember it. The second was Australia, not yet federated. The third was New England. Only in the case of New England did he wrestle at length with his feelings and ideas, trying to put down on paper what it was like to live in a place so new and
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 10
7/12/06 5:07:26 PM
What is New England? challenging. Some of his other poems give rousing accounts of the Scottish past and the Australian future, but his most interesting efforts were about the things he could see, touch and hear in his own region. He too seems to have asked himself, ‘What is New England?’—or, at least, ‘What does New England mean to me?’. He wrote of the balancing rock at Stonehenge, a great boulder of granite with a smoothly rounded top and a pointed base, that ‘it seems to rest on nothing but the circumambient air’. In a poem called ‘Night Musings’, he described a cold, wet night spent on horseback, holding cattle at Byron Plains. First he mentioned his impatience with the restless livestock (‘shivering hand upon the rein’), passing then to a few lines about his old cabbage-tree hat (‘patter, patter, one, two, three, / The rain falls on my cabbage tree’). Finally his mind drifted to his absent ‘angel’, ‘my darling Kate’, and thoughts of her seem to have kept his mind busy most of the night. At length it was morning.2 The feelings in this poem seem very personal and very local. Wetherspoon was a Tableland patriot. For him, New England was a palpable piece of Australia just as Scotland was a palpable piece of the British Isles. Whether we are good poets or bad, could we now write about New England as Wetherspoon did? Are we its citizens as he was?
11
❈ John Wetherspoon of Glencoe, Glen Innes (1843–1928), farmer, politician, poet. (photo: unknown)
SELLING POINT OR SOULFOOD?
Today, what does ‘New England’ mean? The 2005 telephone directory lists nearly a hundred enterprises using the name, from ‘New England Embroidery’ to ‘New England Tractors’. Half of them are in or around Armidale, but others are scattered through Uralla, Glen Innes, Tenterfield, Inverell and Moree, and as far south as Tamworth, Quirindi and Gunnedah. Obviously, the name has a living significance. It offers a sense of place reaching beyond any one town or district, which to the enterprising mind also means reaching an extended
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 11
7/12/06 5:07:26 PM
High Lean Country 12
market. On the other hand, it has geographical limits. In the north, there is the Queensland border. On the western slopes the pleasant reaches of the Gwydir River throw up some feeble terminological competition. So we find ‘Gwydir Glass’, ‘Gwydir Olives’ and ‘Gwydir Air’. There is no ‘New England’ beyond Moree. To the east, across the escarpment, the name is no use at all. There, the coastal rivers, the beaches and the ocean provide a sense of place for which the name is totally irrelevant. But within certain boundaries, ‘New England’ reigns supreme. It has a real existence in local imagination. What kind of existence, though? Is it more than a useful brand-name? In his day, Wetherspoon certainly thought it was. Ten years after Wetherspoon wrote the lines I quote at the beginning of this chapter, a Sydney Morning Herald journalist, Charles Lyne, visited this part of the colony and he had no doubts either. Lyne came in wintertime, and perhaps the crispness of the air gave a sharp edge to his feeling that, in venturing up the Moonbis, he was entering on something different. The weather had been gloomy enough on the plains. ‘Further on,’ he said, ‘in the New England country, there are times when the wind whistles loudly around the corners of the houses, and rumbles about the chimneys, when the snow, falling first like feathers borne upon the breeze, descends thickly and fast.’3 For John Wetherspoon, the Tableland was a place of stillness and affection. For him, it was home. For Charles Lyne it was a country to be explored. Lyne wanted to understand New England by hearing stories about it, as he moved about. The coach he travelled in was overcrowded but cold all the same, and it got colder as they neared Armidale and other passengers alighted—‘until one’s rug becomes very much like a sheet of cold iron, and one’s toes seem to have slipped away altogether’. But a stimulated mind made up for a freezing body, and Lyne discovered ‘several places of considerable interest’ along the way. New England already had a history. Lyne remarked on the Moonbi Range and on Bendemeer, on the site of ‘the late Constable Bowen’s exploits’ (undetailed), and on Uralla and the Rocky River goldfields. Each place, he said, ‘has attached to it either a history or some attractive incidents which the coachman can tell with great effect in lessening the discomforts of the journey’.4 However, Lyne was being paid by the Herald to hear stories of a different kind. He was travelling around all the settled parts of New South Wales to gather information about local industries, with the intention of making a report to the paper. If we read his final account carefully, we can see how men and women of his generation thought about the towns and regions ruled from Sydney. Their perspective was different from ours. In particular, it was formed, a good deal more than ours can be, by problems of distance and terrain. It was easy in those days to notice, and hard to forget, how long it took to travel any distance from Sydney, and obstacles in the way of getting to the Tableland were painfully obvious. Your toes froze, for instance, in a horse-drawn coach, while in hard and gasping stages you doubled your height above sea-level. In his account of the colony, Lyne mentions several discrete regions—almost provinces—isolated by such rigours, or by mere distance, but, in his eyes at least,
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 12
7/12/06 5:07:27 PM
What is New England? this part of New South Wales had a variety and a picturesqueness not to be found elsewhere. He was interested in it just as he was interested in the far west, the vast plains around Cobar, Wilcannia and Bourke. Both seemed to be set apart from New South Wales proper. The Hunter valley, though less remote, was another such province, and Lyne reported on its well-established farms, vineyards and tobacco plantations, its horse-breeding and coal-mining. Maitland, he said, ‘ranks perhaps next to Sydney in size, in population, in the amount of business done by its inhabitants, and in commercial soundness’.5 (In fact, Newcastle’s population had already overtaken that of Maitland.) In Lyne’s day, indeed, the Hunter valley had an economic importance within the colony that is now easy to forget. The rough country between Sydney and the Hunter, including Broken Bay, meant that there was no good road. A railway was not built until 1889, and the two places were linked mainly be sea. For the traveller from Sydney, New England was another stage beyond the Hunter, one reached only after a steam-ship journey, plus a relatively easy drive or ride up one or other of the coastal valleys, and then a harder climb across the mountains. In terms of wealth, New England was nothing to write home about. The 1881 census, parts of which Lyne added at the back of his book, proved the greater prosperity of the south, where the main towns (Forbes, Hay, Deniliquin, Wagga Wagga and Albury) were hurrying ahead at a surprising pace. Lyne admitted that New England had yet to be ‘very populous and very flourishing’. As for Armidale, he said, it showed ‘very little outside bustle’. For Lyne, however, this only proved the solid foundations of the local economy. ‘[I]n a quiet, earnest, effective way the people . . . push along, some of them making plenty of money, all or most of them getting a comfortable livelihood, and the city and district, as far as can be seen, gradually going ahead.’ He had a soft spot for Glen Innes—for the sound of ice cracking on its winter mornings, as horses and vehicles passed through puddles—mingled, as he said, with the songs of magpies looking for their breakfast. Such morning noises were ‘altogether new to a stranger in the district, and very interesting’.6 They might well have been ‘altogether new’ to him. London-born, Charles Lyne, like John Wetherspoon, had come to Australia as a child, and he probably had no clear recollection of frost-bound fields in the mother country.7 There were, of course, several other parts of New South Wales where the winters might be just as cold. But perhaps there was nowhere else that seemed so clearly to constitute a world of its own, a land to be reached (at least from Sydney) through such difficult passes. It was this sense of a dominion resting, like the balancing rock at Stonehenge, on ‘circumambient air’—of a detached high country held up and over-shadowed by mountains—that, at least in the colonial period, defined New England. In later days another Tableland poet, Judith Wright, wrote in similar terms. ‘I know it dark against the stars, the high lean country / Full of old stories that still go walking in my sleep.’8 Of course, the stories heard by Lyne en route to Armidale were even older by the time Judith Wright was familiar with them.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 13
13
7/12/06 5:07:28 PM
High Lean Country 14
But by then, too, the image of New England as a region was less concrete and obvious. Only someone who thought hard about the land, as Judith Wright did, might have taken the trouble to pin-point the characteristics of its terrain. She was, of course, drawing on other, more prosaic ways of thinking about landscape, on the vivid skills of men and women on the land, who learn to read the bush in all its tiny details—the variations of soil and pasture, the patterns of native vegetation—because their livelihood depends on it. Nevertheless, the question ‘What is New England?’ has to be answered, first of all, by saying that the name probably had more powerful meanings in the past than it has today. GIVING THE NAME LIFE
In May 1836, the Sydney Herald (later the Sydney Morning Herald ) reported that ‘Rumours have reached Sydney, of a party of armed bushrangers having visited a place called New England’. This is the name’s earliest recorded usage. In fact, this bushranging adventure took place at Henry Dumaresq’s newly established station of Saumarez, only a few miles from where, in the early winter of 1839, a police headquarters was to be established and named Armidale.9 And, as David Roberts says (see Chapter 9), the bushrangers in this case had their headquarters not far away at Gostwyck. It may well be that it was this fragment of landscape, no more than 50 or 100 kilometres across—roughly between today’s Armidale and Walcha—to which the name ‘New England’ was first attached. It soon became an official title. The birth of Armidale in 1839 coincided with the government’s creation of a much larger New England. The colonial frontier was now divided into so-called ‘pastoral districts’, each managed by a Commissioner of Crown Lands with his own body of police. The district of New England measured about 200 kilometres from east to west, from the edge of the escarpment to an imaginary line where the Tableland met the plains (including what is now Inverell and Bundarra). In the south it reached to the headwaters of the Hastings River. In the north, as the notice in the Government Gazette remarked, ‘the boundary is indefinite’, but in practical terms only for a very short time did it ever extend beyond what was later the Queensland border.10 In colonial Australia the names of most large areas were chosen either by governors or government surveyors. ‘New England’ seems to have begun as the choice of squatters, but these were well-connected squatters, which may explain why it was readily taken up by government. It was to be the name’s destiny, for ever after, to hover between local fancy and the priorities of officialdom, without being strongly embedded in either. Apart from its landscape and climate, have New England’s inhabitants ever really believed in it as a place with some kind of single life and purpose? The generation of John Wetherspoon and Charles Lyne thought in terms of a distinctive climate and landscape. This is all very well, but it may be harder to give this geographical space a political dimension. When Robin Walker, of the History Department at the University of New England, wrote his history of the region during the colonial period, Old New England (1966), he was struck with the way its towns had jostled and
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 14
7/12/06 5:07:28 PM
What is New England? sniped at each other. He could find no sense of common purpose—no belief that New Englanders should stick together. ‘In view of this intense parochialism,’ he said, ‘it may be asked whether New England was [at that time] more than a geographical expression.’11 Walker did notice, all the same, the strong separatist feeling that characterised the Tableland during the 1840s and 50s. But, as with the original name, this seems to have emanated mainly from the squatters. Those gentlemen certainly thought they were a special type within the colony at large. As one of them put it, with a little exaggeration, New England was ‘by far the most Aristocratic Part of New South Wales, almost all the young settlers are either Oxford or Cambridge’.12 They typically ran sheep—cattle were more common to the west—and their flocks were large. And, of course, the management of sheep was a more civilised business than the management of cattle, where profit depended not on docile shepherds but on the wild skill of men on horseback. New England squatters called themselves a ‘second race’. Not only was their air cleaner, but the social atmosphere of the Tableland was also more elevated than that of the city, a place still pungent with convict and ex-convict life. This region, so some asserted,
15
has been mainly discovered and settled by the enterprise and capital of those who, with very few exceptions, are not connected by the possession of land or otherwise with New South Wales . . . and have only landed at Sydney from necessity. They therefore asked, for the first time but not for the last, for a government of their own, for separation from ‘the old penal colony of New South Wales’.13 The same sense of superiority had been behind the foundation in 1836 of South Australia, a colony proudly convict-free, and it survived there for generations. The same argument worked for the Port Phillip district of New South Wales, which (for that and other more substantial reasons) became the separate colony of Victoria in 1851. But New Englanders had no such luck. Their logic was laughed at in Sydney. There was too much to drink in the bush, said one city paper, and it was hard to take seriously the talk of ‘gentlemen squatters [who were] “happy and glorious” every day of the week’.14 But the ideal lived on, oblivious to mockery, far beyond convict days. The selfcongratulatory sense of Tableland virtue took a long time to die. Today, it has its best tangible memorial in the glorious window of coloured glass, five metres high, that lights the stairwell at the sometime homestead of Booloominbah, near Armidale (now part of the University of New England). The window’s nine panels, pale brown patched over with burning scarlet, soft green and deep blue, commemorate the life of the steadfast ‘Christian soldier’, Charles Gordon, and his death at the hands of the less enlightened at Khartoum in 1885. It was installed by Booloominbah’s owner, F.R. White, in about 1901, in the final adornment of his new house. It is typical of New England that such a brilliant work should be set up as a moral beacon in such a far-away, rustic setting.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 15
7/12/06 5:07:28 PM
High Lean Country 16
These were days when a good deal of lyrical feeling was invested in the Australian bush. In stark contrast to F.R. White at Booloominbah, at Newstead, near Inverell, the Andersons had a small, unpretentious homestead, and yet the master, Duncan Anderson, was a wealthy man, a classical scholar and a skilled musician. He was also a close friend of the celebrated painter, Tom Roberts, and thirteen of Roberts’ pictures, including ‘The Golden Fleece’, ‘Bailed Up’ and ‘In a Corner on the Macintyre’, date from visits to Newstead during the 1890s (see Chapter 29). The paintings, with their dry, bright tones, commemorate down-to-earth rural life and labour. They also remind us of the friendship of two highly cultivated men, both of whom believed that the bush landscape was the best place in which to find humanity’s fundamental virtues.15
❈ Armidale, a place of dreaming spires and keen aspirations, with the Catholic Cathedral of St Mary and St Joseph on the right and the Anglican St Peter’s on the left. (photo: D. Elkins)
The same exclusive idealism—but exclusive to the Tableland rather than to the bush in general—explains why, from the 1870s, the name ‘New England’ was used by local private boarding schools, places designed to turn out ladies and gentlemen. Armidale had its New England Grammar School, and there was another with the same title later on at Glen Innes. Also at Armidale we find a New England Ladies College, a New England Proprietary School for boys and a New England Girls School—together with a widespread belief that the Tableland was unrivalled in the way it educated children (see Chapter 18). Of course, in each case, as with ‘New England Embroidery’ and ‘New England Tractors’, the name was also designed to capture a scattered clientele. Boarding schools needed to appeal beyond their town limits. They had to draw children from afar. But then, as I recall, in the classrooms and dormitories of my own school in Armidale where a boy came from was part of who he was. These schools thus helped to strengthen the possibility of a real and tangible New England, among a chosen few. They focused the collective sense of a regional elite. School speech days, when parents gathered from all quarters, were a celebration of the Tableland as a place of special promise. The name ‘New England’, then, spelt moral ambition. The same appears again in the New England New State Movement, from its birth in about 1920
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 16
7/12/06 5:07:29 PM
What is New England? to its dwindling away in the 1960s (see Chapter 20). Again, ‘New England’ embodied a sense of difference—especially difference from Sydney. The city was no longer a place of convicts. But since the 1890s there had grown up throughout rural Australia yet another form of moral pride, to which recent historians have given the name ‘countrymindedness’. Tom Roberts was among its precursors. In several places, this feeling was nourished by the hierarchy of the Anglican Church—here the diocese of Armidale included the Tableland and the southern and western plains. Countrymindedness, like Anglicanism of a certain type, included a faith in well-settled communities, with their roots deep in the local soil and shaped by their own old hierarchies, producing the basic foodstuffs of the people.16 All the better if such communities seemed to form, as in New England, a world apart. For instance, John Stoward Moyes, Bishop of Armidale from 1929 to 1964, was a prominent social critic, even in national terms, during the post-war period. An admirer of the nineteenth-century Christian Socialist F.D. Maurice, Moyes thought that ‘city life is an artificial life’. In his opinion, there was more room for kindness in the bush, and for a proper valuation of labour and property. He watched with interest socialist and communist governments overseas, as they moved (or seemed to him to move) away from the state ownership of land towards ‘ownership by the people, with peasant proprietorship and co-operative organisation’. Moyes wanted capitalist nations to embrace the same compromise. ‘The country has never had fair play,’ he said, ‘—it has merely been the lemon to be squeezed to provide the city’s food and drink.’17 Australia needed decentralisation. Only when a true value was placed on community life (and Australia’s only real communities were in the bush) would Australians create among themselves genuine humanity and common justice. The New State Movement failed. In the official Referendum of April 1967, two-thirds of voters on the Tableland supported separation, but at that time the area proposed included the north coast, Newcastle and the Hunter valley, and opposition in those places was enough to defeat the idea over-all. Even on the Tableland, support soon wavered. In the general election for the state parliament immediately afterwards, New State candidates took less than a fifth of the vote.18 No doubt the lack of sustained enthusiasm was due, partly, to the kind of small-town parochialism noticed by Robin Walker. But perhaps it was also due to limited sympathy with the ethical ideals and the economic ambitions of the large graziers who, with a number of professional men, were behind the movement. Generation by generation, this class had struggled to make New England a single, self-governing, self-conscious place, but with uneven success. All the same, it has to be said that there exists today an independent ‘Kingdom of New England’. It boasts a large and complicated website, a sovereign head of state (King James), and a colourful history, including a six-year war of independence from the Australian government, the climax of which was the Battle of Walcha—fought in gorge country. Six Black Hawk helicopters went down. This New England is one of the ‘Webring of Imaginary Countries’ that can be discovered by enterprising voyagers on the internet. They include the
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 17
17
7/12/06 5:07:30 PM
High Lean Country 18
❈ Poster for the New State Movement, with its defiant, even aggressive lion rampant, devised, apparently, by Ulrich Ellis, and still associated with New England. Badges could be bought with the lion in gold.
Empire of Gruver, in North America, the Kingdom of Kaupelan, to Australia’s north, and many more. The Kingdom of New England is an imagined state, a utopia built on the realities and values of the present. Its people are virtuous in twenty-first-century ways. They believe, so we are told, ‘in a sense of community that should encompass all those around us’. They are also scrupulous environmentalists—‘one of the “greenest” nations on earth’.19 Here is New England idealism wonderfully up-dated. For many years the New State idea seemed almost to rank with the glassy idealism of General Gordon and with the green perfections of this cyberspace kingdom. Every age has its own moral attitudes, and looking backwards we can easily mix up foolishness, vanity and genuine high principle. It is interesting too, to trace connections between countrymindedness at the regional level and the national level, particularly since for many years the federal leadership of the Country/National Party drew largely on New England (see Chapter 20). As
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 18
7/12/06 5:07:30 PM
What is New England? John Ryan says in the ‘Prelude’ to this book, Armidale (or nearby Gostwyck, to be precise) was once briefly thought of as the national capital. What a neat interweaving of attitudes and aspirations that would have been! Some of the energy behind New England separatism survives today in the University of New England, founded by a few leading New Staters (and Bishop Moyes) as a moral and intellectual engineroom for their yet-to-be-realised ideal. The university began life in 1938 as a college of the University of Sydney and became an autonomous university in 1954 (see Chapter 24). As Matthew Jordan says in his history of UNE, for many years its teaching staff laboured to make education a means of social justice. In some ways, they still do. (General Gordon thought along similar lines, spending part of his life teaching boys from poor families living along the River Thames.) Organised Christianity also had a powerful impact during the early years of what was called ‘the holiest campus’ in Australia. Most significant, however, was the fact that, as with the boarding schools, students were gathered largely from the Tableland and nearby places. UNE seems to have been especially attractive to country girls, who probably thought—or whose parents thought—that its residential colleges were free of the moral danger that accompanied student life in Sydney.20 In some countries, universities have inspired regional and national awareness. Future leaders living and working together as young men and women have manufactured a collective identity for themselves and their country. In the nineteenth century England’s governing class was shaped at Oxford and Cambridge, and after World War Two many political careers in new nationstates had similar beginnings, in Delhi, Jakarta and so on. In Canberra, the Australian National University was intended to be a breeding ground for federal administrators.21 New England New Staters probably hoped for the same kind of thing on a smaller scale in Armidale—the creation of a well-informed provincial leadership. In fact, UNE’s early undergraduates usually set their sights on wider horizons. Drawn mainly from the region, perhaps they were more like the Welsh students who for centuries followed each other to Jesus College, Oxford, but who found there a much larger intellectual landscape than Wales could offer.22 Academic staff at UNE focused some of their research efforts on the region round about and, as this book shows, they still do. But if the university was designed to perpetuate the patriotic spirit of John Wetherspoon, it failed. For most of those first students, it was a stepping-stone away from their own parochial origins towards the civilisation of the Western world. Despite the desire of these young inhabitants to spread their wings, it is easy to love particular corners of New England—the Tableland and its escarpment, slopes and plains—and to feel that the landscape and sky have a character all their own. The appeal of the ‘high lean country’, the ‘majestic mountains’ and the extraordinary waterfalls and gorges has inspired some of the chapters of this book. It is easy too to represent the history of New England as something like a single story. In short, the name does mean something. But as many of these chapters also show, it is hard to settle on just what that meaning is. Our various authors work within whatever geographical boundaries
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 19
19
7/12/06 5:07:31 PM
High Lean Country 20
seem logical for their subject. In other ways too, the meaning of ‘New England’ is suspended today between the concrete and the abstract. It is solid enough to be useful for administrative purposes (as with ‘New England Institute of TAFE’ and ‘Hunter New England Area Health’) and for advertising. The name is now stamped on bales of wool sent to market from the Tableland, and it is available for car numberplates.23 But at the same time, in day-to-day talk, in the opening years of the twenty-first century, it is too indefinite, at one and the same time too expansive and too slight to mean anything solid. New England is an idea, slippery, evanescent and rich. As these chapters will show, it is only by connecting the past to the present—through a careful sense of heritage—that that idea gives itself continuing power.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 20
7/12/06 5:07:32 PM
Part 1: Physical Environment
❈
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 21
7/12/06 5:07:32 PM
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 22
7/12/06 5:07:32 PM
CHAPTER 2 ❈
T h e Ro c ks Ben eath Rob e r t Ha w o r t h
The winter of the year 1818 in what is now northern New South Wales was extremely cold, frosty and wet.1 That winter a party of explorers led by John Oxley struggled with their horses and dogs through bogs and across flooded rivers to be the first official expedition from the Sydney-based colony to reach the New England Tableland.2 They had entered what seemed to be a strange, almost inverted landscape. That the lowlands adjacent to the Liverpool Plains were boggy after heavy rain Oxley could understand, but he was puzzled that even as he left the plains and entered the highlands all the way up he encountered numerous ‘wet hollows’. As he approached the Great Escarpment from the west the only indication of high altitude was the hard August frost. Also, instead of displaying the serrations of a mountain range, as experience had led them to expect, the land remained one of gentle rolling relief. Oxley and his party came from west to east, up the gentle gradient of the inland slopes, rather than tackling the highlands from their steep coastal margin. As a result, the transect cut by their path inadvertently revealed the structure of the south-eastern highlands of Australia. They found no ‘Great Dividing Range’, as had been imagined by those who viewed the highlands from the coast or from ships at sea and who saw there a landform apparently similar to the ‘tented’ range of high, Alpine-style peaks to be found in Europe and North America. Instead, they discovered an ‘upside-down land’ of plateaux cut by deep gorges, ‘natural phenomena’ as Oxley remarked, ‘which, from their defiance of all rule, perplex us . . . greatly’.3
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 23
7/12/06 5:07:32 PM
High Lean Country 24
So powerful was the cultural expectation that Australia should have a defining range on the lines of the Rocky Mountains that for 150 years maps and atlases have perpetuated the cartographic myth of a ‘Great Dividing Range’. In fact, the continental drainage divide is usually so flat that it accommodates lakes, lagoons, and even airstrips and race-courses. The watershed is marked along most of its course by the modern New England Highway, built by engineers who presumably sought the easiest gradient, hardly an indication of a near-impassable barrier of peaks that the term ‘Dividing Range’ implies. From the beginning, British settlers had been bemused by the contradictory style of nature in the Antipodes, and Oxley and his men were about to make a discovery that would show that Australian landscapes could be as perverse as any black swan or hopping marsupial. Reaching the edge of the Tableland, a greatly surprised Oxley recorded: fine open forest land ended abruptly on . . . precipices . . . and deep and apparently impassable glens . . . the country eastward of these glens appeared very lofty, and much broken . . . the country between us and the coast was of an equal elevation and appeared broken and divided by ravines and steep precipices.4 Oxley’s ordeal began when he left the Tableland and struggled through a maze of gorges. As he neared the coast, he realised that the many high ‘peaks’ were remnants of a once continuous plateau, now dissected by the gorges. Some, such as the Carrai Tableland, are flat; further erosion reduces them to rugged ridges.5 After a final effort, Oxley exclaimed, ‘Bilboa’s ecstasy at the first sight of the South Sea could not have been greater than ours, when on gaining the summit of a mountain, we beheld Old Ocean at our feet’.6 There is a hint of the ‘wild surmise’ of John Keats (see his poem, ‘On first looking into Chapman’s Homer’ ) in the descriptions in Oxley’s journal, as he looked back from the coast and realised that the apparent mountain range was not what it had seemed. But it took another 150 years of surmising before the problem of its peculiar formation could be resolved. S K E TC H O F N E W E N G L A N D
Modern geomorphic descriptions of the landscape confronting Oxley, like his original description, stress the contrast between the bland relief of the plateau and the abruptness of its edge. Modern accounts also set it in the time scale needed to account for its formation. The New England Tableland consists of ancient rocks planed down to a low-relief surface and then uplifted in association with the opening of the Tasman Sea from about 80 million years ago. Granitic intrusions were eventually stripped of their cover to form stark outcrops such as the Moonbi Range in the south, Mount Duval near Armidale and Bald Rock near Tenterfield. After uplift between 50 and 30 million years ago, the
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 24
7/12/06 5:07:33 PM
The Rocks Beneath ancient surface was blanketed with outpourings of flood lava from multiple local vents. Between twenty and fourteen million years ago, parts were also covered with lava from some of the great shield volcanoes surrounding New England, particularly from the Ebor/Dorrigo volcano in the east. This preserved part of the ancient surface (including gold-bearing fossil river beds) has been systematically exhumed over the last twenty million years by the erosion of the basalt cover. This down-cutting erosion has also formed the present east-flowing river system, which rolls sluggishly over the Tableland until it meets the gorges cutting back from the escarpment. The New England Tableland is the second highest surface in Australia (after the Southern Alps). Because of its height it has been subjected to recurring extremes of cold as well as drought over the last two million years. Until 15 000 years ago, the higher parts of the Tableland formed a largely treeless, cold and windy steppe, with an estimated 40 snow days a year.7 Large sand dunes built up in areas such as the Llangothlin Lakes near Guyra. Evidence obtained from lake sediments indicates that the climate began to improve 13 000 years ago, with permanent water in the many ponds and lagoons that dotted the uplands before European settlement.8 The mid-nineteenth century onwards has seen significant landscape changes, caused by stock trampling and consequent erosion. Many local streams have been transformed from stable ‘chain of ponds’ systems to more deeply incised channels with sharply variable flow patterns.9 The dominant relief feature in the region is the abrupt eastern edge of the old, flat, eroded Tableland surface. This local escarpment (roughly equivalent to the so-called ‘falls’ country) is part of the continent-long Great Escarpment, the dominant relief feature of Australia that extends from North Queensland to Gippsland in Victoria as a chain of tablelands and plateaux, their eastern edges sharply truncated by an advancing erosion front. The confounding feature of the New England escarpment is the extremely deep, entrenched gorge system that cuts cross-wise through the Tableland to the eastern sea. This pattern is repeated along the entire hinterland of the east coast of Australia, but nowhere are the gorges so pronounced as in New England.
25
TA B L E L A N D S , C O N T I N E N TA L M A RG I N S , A N D G R E AT ESCARPMENTS
The mapping of the New England Tableland in the years following Oxley’s expedition allowed the first recognition of landforms and landscapes that were seen later to be the pattern for the full length of the eastern highlands. The west–east route taken by Oxley across the southern edge of the Tableland revealed not a range of mountain peaks (as one would expect in a ‘Great Dividing Range’), but a high, smooth land surface that terminated in a line of steep and rugged cliffs up to almost 1600 metres in altitude above the Pacific Ocean. This line of cliffs is part of the 3000 kilometre-long north–south bulwark of the Great Escarpment.10
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 25
7/12/06 5:07:33 PM
High Lean Country 26
❈ Darkies’ Point, from Point Lookout, on New England’s eastern escarpment, said to be the site of a massacre of Aborigines. These heights reach almost 1600 metres, making the eastern side of the upwarped Tableland over 600 metres higher than the area around Armidale in the west (see diagrams later on). (photo: I. Davidson)
The gorges and cliffs that blocked Oxley’s way were analogous to the steep canyon sequence of the Blue Mountains that held back inland expansion of the Sydney settlement for almost 30 years. But the same landscape pattern of deep ‘glens’ and terminal escarpments in New England was reproduced from rocks completely different from the near-horizontal sandstones of the Sydney Basin. The ‘inverted relief ’ of plateau and ravine was imposed on the very different rocks of the New England Fold Belt. What could produce similar landscapes with dissimilar geology? It was, obviously, something on a continental rather than a local scale. By way of answer, the first hint of global tectonics was presented to the discerning mind. The ‘deep and impassable glens’, while driving the explorers at times to despair, do not seem to have quenched either their romantic sensibility or their scientific inquisitiveness. Oxley remarked on the ‘grand natural spectacle’ of the gorges blocking his progress, and he wondered ‘how dreadful must the convulsion have been that formed these glens’.11 He somehow managed to record the major physical features of what later Earth scientists would call a ‘passive continental margin’ produced by the break-up of Gondwana (the landmass comprising South America, Africa, India and Australia) 80 million years earlier. The subdued relief of the top of the New England Tableland, as traversed by Oxley, was the Australian equivalent of the South African Highveld.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 26
7/12/06 5:07:34 PM
The Rocks Beneath Oxley was entering New England at the very moment when worldwide European exploration had concluded its first great task of mapping the world’s coastlines and the extent of the World Ocean.12 New England exploration represented one of the first forays involving an understanding of continental interiors. Oxley’s expedition followed on the Lewis and Clark penetration and survey of inland North America, and was nearly contemporary with the first quests for the source of the Nile, where African explorers encountered features of highveld and rift valley structure of a tectonic mould similar to the formation of eastern Australia. Trained in the methods of the scientific enlightenment, officers of the British Empire such as Oxley were in fact engaged in mapping the major surviving fragments of Gondwana. These explorers and surveyors were beginning the process that would lead to the great advance in Earth science represented by plate tectonic theory. The puzzle of the New England landscape was to play a key role in deciphering such mysteries as drifting continents and globally disjunct flora and fauna distributions. It thus led to one of the greatest intellectual advances in the understanding of Earth dynamics. The process of interpreting inland landscapes such as New England went handin-hand with improved and accessible mapping. The false geomorphic aim of some Australian explorers, the location of an inland sea, compelled them to think in continental terms when interpreting the landscape. If the rivers they discovered ended up in many cases running nowhere, it nevertheless brought to early attention the strangeness of the drainage systems originating in the Tableland.
27
G E O L O G Y A N D A RT I N T E R P R E T T H E TA B L E L A N D
In 1852, the colony’s leading geologist, the Church of England clergyman William Branwhite Clarke, began his official survey of the headwaters of rivers rising in the ‘Great Divide’ north of the Hunter River, that is, in our region of New England. The first feature that impressed him was the non-existence of a ‘dividing range’ and the flatness of the country that separated the inland from the coastal rivers. He also noted the extensive alluvial gold-bearing deposits, often containing the bones of extinct megafauna. But these remnants of ancient rivers were located in the most unlikely places—in many cases on the tops of present-day hills beneath ancient lava flows. As he looked at these ‘deep leads’ on his tour of the New England diggings, Clarke reasoned: No one can believe that our present conditions of climate consort with such deposits as those which fill up receptacles 100 feet deep with detritus of shales, sandstones, quartz rock, bones of extinct animals, trappean alluvium and . . . gold.13 He leapt to a startling conclusion. What were now hilltops must once have been valleys, and if these valleys contained great quantities of rounded cobbles they must have been worn down by great and rapid streams that could only have come from a higher and wetter land to the east. But there was now a
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 27
7/12/06 5:07:35 PM
High Lean Country 28
mighty absence of land to the east—first the gap of the gorges and the Great Escarpment, and beyond that only the Pacific Ocean running to South America. A thought came to Clarke that was to revolutionise Earth science in the next century—could the continents themselves move, not only vertically by uplift, but laterally, across the earth’s surface? If not, where were the lost lands to the east? How did the New England landscape fit, if at all, into the picture of the new science of geology as it was being developed in old England? This new science was the work of men who had never set eyes on either Australia or any of the other remnants of Gondwana, and Clarke lost no time declaring an independent view: Geologists at home [England] have in the past considered that we can, in Australia, know nothing aright but what we glean from them. But . . . to those who are interested in the advancement of Australia . . . Australia itself is likely to throw considerable light on questions . . . imperfectly understood at home.14 Clarke was following in the mental footsteps of Darwin who, less than two decades before, had deduced from his Southern Hemisphere voyage that the island and coral reef environments of the Pacific were the result of great earth movements of subsidence and uplift. But even Darwin’s mind had stopped short of imagining the long ages needed for persistent water erosion to wear down the results of continental uplift.15 The idea that the world’s landscapes could be carved by the humble agency of running water had only just been introduced to the scientific community.16 Clarke, looking at the New England lakes and lagoons nestling where no lakes should be, on the crest of the ‘Great Divide’, and noticing the void to the east, foreshadowed the next 150 years of thinking in Earth science: The conviction in my mind is . . . that the continent, then occupying a nobler portion of the Pacific, has oscillated vertically and therefore, has been shattered and broken up; that we now inhabit but a portion, and that a ridge only of the ancient Australia; that vast areas to the eastward have sunk, of which we have traces in our present sea border . . . and that there was once . . . a breadth of surface . . . to allow the formation of reservoirs or, when higher, melting snows. As Ollier and Pain would put it 150 years later, ‘the (passive) continental margin is basically a former land surface—the palaeoplain—which has been warped, producing the basal unconformity offshore where it is down-warped, and the marginal swell where it is upwarped’, a consequence of the earth mechanics of break-up of the former Gondwana supercontinent.17 Clarke, following in Oxley’s tracks, but with a more extensive geological knowledge and an imagination stimulated by several more critical decades of nineteenth-century science and art, could make the intellectual leap that allowed for a fluid and mobile
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 28
7/12/06 5:07:35 PM
The Rocks Beneath earth. The ‘rock of ages’, such an important metaphor for stability in Clarke’s Church of England, was beginning to look anything but solid. Clarke was one of the last in the tradition of the great eighteenth-century scientist-clergymen, and indeed was only one degree of separation from Darwin’s own circle. Clarke’s best friend in his parish of North Sydney was the sometime landscape painter of Darwin’s Beagle expedition, Conrad Martens. During their long bush walks the two discussed and developed the method of looking beneath the superficial landscape to understand structure and dynamics, such as had long been done in life drawing of the human figure.18 Martens, even more than the Tasmanian-based John Glover, was the greatest early exponent of the English landscape-painting school in Australia. His painting, ‘Belltrees’, now held in the New England Regional Art Museum, depicts the view north from the Hunter valley to the southern margin of New England, with the dominating image of the Great Escarpment looming out of the distance. Like Clarke, Martens had also apparently managed to grasp the essential physiographic reality—even today not understood by most Australians—that the Great Escarpment was a more significant barrier and boundary than any ‘Great Dividing Range’. When Clarke brought this approach to interpreting the puzzling anomalies of New England’s plateaux and gorges, he was bound to see far more and far further, with all the interpretive visionary power that the marriage of Enlightenment science and the Romantic imagination could offer. Following on Clarke’s investigation of the New England Tableland, in 1882 Thomas Edgeworth David, the founder of the Department of Geology and Physical Geography at Sydney University, visited the Uralla goldfields to work on the puzzle of deep leads in relation to local gold deposits and granite outcrops.19 The alluvial gold did not seem to come from quartz reefs, as was usual, or if it did it was from some faraway source that no longer seemed to exist. Edgeworth David was able to use information gleaned from prospecting the Tableland for over 30 years, representing the collective knowledge of many thousands of diggers. This allowed him to make a very detailed reconstruction of previous geological eras, and particularly past drainage systems, thus providing the key to the record of uplift and downwarp. During the nineteenth century, and increasingly in the twentieth century, the years of work of explorers and surveyors had allowed for the production and sale of easily accessible topographic maps.20 Once again, New England was at the forefront: following on the region-wide mapping by the early explorers of the Tableland—John Oxley, Allan Cunningham and Henry Dangar—government surveyors such as J.J. Galloway began the process of detailed local mapping.21 It has been said of Galloway’s extraordinary surveying and mapping work in the New England region that ‘almost single-handed [he] reduced a great cartographic blank to an ordered and planned region in as few as six years [1848–54]’.22 Access to cheap, easy-to-understand maps gave ordinary people a better knowledge of the land and more control of their environment. Maps became an important adjunct to political and social democracy.23 By the 1970s large-scale topographic maps were available for most of Australia, creating an
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 29
29
7/12/06 5:07:36 PM
High Lean Country 30
educated audience ready for the radical shift in Earth science ideas of the second half of the century. C A RTO G R A P H Y F O R A C O N T I N E N T
To ordinary literacy and numeracy could be added a third skill necessary to conceive of the world as a product of global process, ‘topographic comprehension’, or cartographic literacy. Once people were used to taking the bird’s eye view provided by a topographic map, a view for which several centuries of landscape perspective painting had prepared them, it was possible for them to follow elaborate arguments about the origin and development of the Earth’s surface, and to accept that a world of such complicated physiography could have only evolved over exceptionally long ages. The topographic map, indeed, represents the ultimate ‘marriage’ of science and art, and is very often a thing of great beauty as well as a mundane land management tool. The increasing cartographic awareness of the early nineteenth century was primed for the popularising work of the Commonwealth Meteorologist, geographer and sometime Antarctic explorer, Thomas Griffith Taylor. In 1911 Griffith Taylor brought out a work that was both popular and scientific and that demonstrated enormous insight on matters of geology and landscape. Entitled ‘Physiography of Eastern Australia’, it was essentially a plea for systematic topographic mapping of the entire country. Relying on the contemporary rise in popularity of outdoor sports such as bushwalking and recreational fishing, Taylor was able to appeal to a large audience with what became best-selling books on geomorphology.24 There was one driving mystery for Griffith Taylor—what had fractured the landscape of eastern Australia, turning the land upside down and reversing the coastal rivers? Gentle rolling plains were at the top of the range and tortuous gorges below, while coastal rivers displayed bizarre courses, often beginning near the present coast and flowing inland until suddenly switching back again to find the sea. The most contorted of coastal rivers was the Clarence, with many of its major tributaries appearing to be oriented to reach the inland Condamine River and the Murray-Darling system, only to switch back in a series of ‘boathook bends’ against the trend of headwater flow to return to the eastern sea. Taylor, like Clarke, was convinced that this river system had risen to the east of the present coastline, in land no longer there, a lost continent he dubbed ‘Pacifica’. He concluded that river-flow had been disrupted in all the coastal streams by a reversal of drainage as water-flow from the Tableland sought a new base level on a new eastern coastline. As geophysical detail accumulated, there were various attempts at a great synthesis. The New England Tableland figured in the writings of most researchers as a key by which they might interpret the whole eastern highlands of Australia. From 1903, E.C. Andrews published a series of papers and geological reports emphasising the unity of the highlands, arguing that the similar physiography throughout suggested the action of continent-wide, possibly
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 30
7/12/06 5:07:36 PM
The Rocks Beneath 31 Tenterfield
C la c re n
Location
eR
1200m
.
M a c inty r e
R. Glen Innes
960m
Boy
dR
.
Inverell
Ben Lomond Llangothlin Ls.
Guyra
B o orol ong C k Ebor
Gw
1300m
yd
Armidale
ir
R
.
960m M
ac
le
ay
R.
1300m
Kilometres 0
100
❈ Mean altitudes of the major levels of the New England Tablelands—from a map by Griffith Taylor in a Commonwealth Bureau of Meteorology Bulletin, 1911.
global, forces.25 Frank Craft, a student of Griffith Taylor, demonstrated the part played by differential erosion in the development of landforms, using as examples the New England gorges.26 After the formation of the Geology and Physical Geography departments at the future University of New England, researchers such as Alan Voisey and Robin Warner built on this body of work by mapping large-scale denudation zones, or ‘erosion surfaces’.27 The unique outreach of the university’s external studies system also brought knowledge of Earth science to a wider audience than ever before. These later New England researchers concentrated on the detailed pursuit of elusive ‘erosion surfaces’ that they thought might be a key to the past, but the amount of detail often obscured the central puzzle. For the first and earliest contemplators of the region, such as Oxley, Clarke or Griffith Taylor, a flash of inspiration working on basic geological knowledge was enough. The clear outline of their topographic vision was unclouded by as yet undiscovered detail.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 31
7/12/06 5:07:36 PM
High Lean Country 32
Only in the last decades of the twentieth century was such clarity again within reach—now because a good global template was finally available. C O N T I N E N TA L R I F T I N G , R I V E R R E V E R S A L A N D T H E O P E N I N G O F T H E TA S M A N S E A
Earth scientists with extensive experience of the Southern Hemisphere were among the most adamant supporters of what for long were regarded as heretical theories of continental drift. Not until it was recast as plate tectonics in the early 1960s were the mainstream scientists of the Northern Hemisphere prepared to accept this vast paradigm change in understanding the Earth. The New Zealand-born and South African-based geologist Lester King synthesised the immense amount of geological detail gathered by earlier workers to make an unanswerable case in support of drifting continents,28 and an outspoken Tasmanian geologist, Warren Carey, spread the news in a series of barnstorming lectures to British and American universities throughout the 1950s and 60s. King particularly emphasised the similarity between the escarpments of southeast South Africa and Australia, and the parallel development of highvelds and high tablelands. The geological record from New England encapsulated the whole history of Southern Hemisphere earth movement and drift. Arriving at the University of New England in the early 1980s, Cliff Ollier was able to look at the landscape of the whole of the eastern highlands in light of the new theory. Ollier was the first to identify and map the Great Escarpment for its full length, but particularly where it is at its most spectacular, on the eastern edge of the New England Tableland. He placed it in the time frame of the fracturing of Gondwana. Eighty million years ago, one fracture of this megacontinent had opened the Tasman Sea, separating Australia from New Zealand. There had been a great landmass east of the Australian mainland, most of which had sunk beneath the ocean to form the Lord Howe Rise as well as parts of New Zealand. The inland plain had been uplifted to become the Tableland. We now know that major rivers between the divide and the coast were reversed by the uplift, setting in action an erosion front marked by the escarpment, which slowly moved to the west. The Great Escarpment is present only on the eastern side of the Tableland, so the escarpment’s development must be related to events that occurred on the eastern side, not the western. The emergence of the new continental margin, combined with uplift, produced short, steep rivers flowing to the new coastline and forming deep, amphitheatre-shaped valleys, or gorges. It then coalesced to form the inlandadvancing escarpment. However, the bizarre pattern of the coastal streams suggests something more gradual than a simple single event.29 Much of the early flow direction of the eastern rivers is still preserved. That is, they flow inland from the coast until they suddenly turn on their tracks and run in the opposite direction, to the Pacific Ocean. This reversal of flow, particularly evident in the drainage pattern of the coastal streams that flow off the Tableland, strongly suggests not only continuous erosion but continuous,
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 32
7/12/06 5:07:43 PM
The Rocks Beneath 33
Great Escarpment Sedimentary wedge
mountain
coast
belt
palae oplain
sea Breakup unconformity
Zone of Zone of normal drainage reversed drainage
sea
deposition
pala
eoplain
maximum uplift hinge zone Breakup unconformity
Great Divide outlying plateau mountain belt
Great Escarpment palaeoplain
coastal plain
maximum uplift coastal facet Breakup unconformity deposition
Gondawana 2500m
lan ds u
rface Coast Cretaceous and younger sediments
2000m
❈ Diagrammatic cross-sections and plan drawings of continental passive margin structures, using New England as a template—from a work by Cliff Ollier and Colin Pain (see note 5). The key to the top cross-section is the ‘mountains’ (in fact, isolated fragments of the former Tableland) carved out by the advance of the Great Escarpment erosion front, and the transfer of the sediment from erosion to the continental shelf. The second figure from the top shows the effects in diagrammatic plan, with warping to partially offset the sediment movement. Third from the top is a representational plan. The ability to understand these maps and diagrams is derived from a particular way of looking developed by western representational art. All these types of figures can now, of course, be presented electronically, with endless permutations. The bottom cross-section shows an idealised, uneroded Gondwanic fragment, immediately after break-up and rifting.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 33
7/12/06 5:07:43 PM
High Lean Country 34
or at least continuously intermittent, uplift of the Tableland. Ollier developed a model of differential uplift and subsidence that best fitted the apparent surface phenomena. This postulated the existence of a hinge of landform flexion along a former Great Divide with downwarp to the coast.30 The most dynamic marker of landform change is the carving out of the great gorges31(Oxley’s ‘impassible glens’), but this is only the most obvious of a set of processes whose ultimate trigger has to do with the fluid motion of the Earth’s lithosphere under pressure from orbital motion and spin. To comprehend such a vast and dizzying evolution of Earth and sky was the work of centuries, one only set in motion by the first explorers from Europe, who tried to understand where they were in relation to terrestrial and celestial markers. Some of the first penetrations of the interiors of the colonial world were the ventures onto the New England Tableland, and the explorers immediately saw that the unknown landforms needed to be fitted into a bigger picture. They and their followers developed new forms of mapping and positioning and, ultimately, a cartographic way of thinking that allowed new, comprehensive and secular ways of looking at the Earth. This understanding could only come from men of the Enlightenment, those able not only to train their minds in scientific precision but also to expand their imagination under the influence of the art forms of the Romantic movement. Seeing new continental landscapes through the lens of this ‘Higher Intuition’, the very first explorers and surveyors could sense that what they could not explain or understand might nonetheless be the key to a more universal explanation of the mysteries of the Earth. For a while the wealth of new detail obscured the grander vision, but by the latter parts of the twentieth century enough data had been amassed to fit it to one of the great intellectual advances, global plate tectonic theory. The New England Tableland’s perverse landscape pattern and the various attempts, spanning two centuries, to explain it played a significant part in formulating this theory. N E W E N G L A N D A N D A C O N T I N E N TA L T E M P L AT E
The discovery and description of New England’s physical features by a series of explorers, followed by surveyors, geologists and geographers, as well as diarists, poets and landscape artists, represented the first attempt to depict and understand relatively the inland structure of any continent. Australia was a useful template, being small, isolated and structurally simple. Between Oxley in the 1810s and Ollier in the 1980s, the puzzle of a fractured ‘upside-down’ landscape was solved. Meanwhile, the particular case of the New England Tableland found a worldwide application to similar landscapes on the trailing edges of their continents.32 The Tableland provided a template against which theories of Earth development were tested over a century and a half of speculation— speculation all the clearer because it was perceived through the casement that science and perspective art had opened onto the lost worlds of Australia’s continental past.33
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 34
7/12/06 5:07:44 PM
CHAPTER 3 ❈
Su n s h in e , Sn ow, Win d an d Rain Jack Hob b s and Al a n At k i n s o n
It was customary once to think that New England’s weather was like the weather ‘at Home’, that is, in England, Scotland and Ireland. This idea might have been comforting for settlers, but it did not encourage the interest of weather specialists during the colonial period, especially since the meteorological novelties of other parts of Australia were more obvious and intriguing. Also, the Government Meteorologist in Sydney during the late nineteenth century was mainly concerned with Australia as a whole, and New England was not a criticial piece in his jigsaw. This officer, Henry Chamberlain Russell, set up weather stations or in other words observation points from which he heard about local conditions by daily telegraph throughout the colony, but he was slow to extend his net to New England. In 1877, when he began to publish weather maps in the Sydney Morning Herald—the first such publications anywhere in the world—the only weather stations on the Tableland were at Tenterfield and Armidale. There were others nearby, however, at Grafton, Inverell, Narrabri and Tamworth.1 Local settlers were more observant. For instance, Albert Norton, who lived near Walcha in the 1850s, remarked on the possible effect of climate on Tableland forests. ‘The district of New England,’ he said, ‘is subject to sudden and severe changes of temperature.’ Also, he went on, although the region had copious rain, ‘it is also subject of long periods of comparatively dry weather’. Norton thought that trees on the Tableland must feel the impact of such dramatic shifts in the weather. For instance, ‘if they have been first weakened by want of rain, then further tried by too great a quantity, [and] their protecting foliage thinned
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 35
7/12/06 5:07:45 PM
High Lean Country 36
by the trials to which they have been exposed’ then, he said, the impact of a hard winter might surely be enough to kill them.2 More recently, long years of experience have suggested that widely ranging, unpredictable temperatures may be even more damaging to vegetation than heavy snow is in Europe. Animals, including livestock, are affected in their turn, especially where trees have been cleared for grazing or crops. It is said that God tempers the wind to the shorn lamb, but without tree cover the high country winds can be cruel.3 When H.C. Russell finally turned his attention to the New England region, it was because he too had noticed such destructive power. In 1891 he reported to the Royal Society of New South Wales on a tornado that had lately made its way southward across the western slopes, past Yetman and Bingara. According to Russell’s Bingara informant, ‘as far as one could see, there was nothing left but bare tree stumps and fallen trees’. The forward movement of the storm was about 50 miles an hour, and Russell estimated that the ‘gyratory motion’ must have been more than 120 miles an hour. Next year he reported on a hail storm around Narrabri, with stones measuring at least six inches around: trees two feet in diameter were torn up by the roots, limbs twelve inches through were snapped off short, a brick factory completely ruined, roofs, sign-boards, and everything that the wind could move went flying.4 And yet, the current reputation of the Tableland proper was just the opposite. It was supposed to be like a resort, ‘high on the sanitary scale’, and
❈ Snow in Central Park, Armidale, in 1917, with St Paul’s Presbyterian church in the background. (photo: unknown)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 36
7/12/06 5:07:45 PM
Sunshine, Snow, Wind and Rain bracing and healthy, especially for growing children.5 This partly explains the number of boarding schools established in Armidale from this period (see Chapter 17). The smallest, lowest and flattest of the continents, Australia is a land of extremes. It is the driest continent apart from Antarctica. Droughts, floods, heatwaves, storms and bushfires are part of the way of life for many of its inhabitants. The climate and weather of New England reflect these characteristics. Also, there are marked climatic variations across the region, from the Tableland and eastern ranges to the slopes and plains in the west.
37
PA S T C L I M AT E S 6
Climate is ever-changing on all timescales, from geological epochs to decades. Assessment of past change is hampered by lack of evidence and problems of interpretation but, as with all other parts of Australia, the climate of New England has clearly changed over long periods of time. The last two million years have been punctuated by glacial periods and characterised by extreme climatic instability. Generally, temperatures have been colder than today. The Tableland climate during the last glacial maximum, about 18 000 years ago, may have been as much as 8°C colder, with rainfall about half of the present average. Thereafter, 10 000–15 000 years ago, the melting of continental ice and the retreat of glaciers created wetter and warmer climates. In New England, there are some indications of an abrupt change to wetter conditions at around the 10 000-year mark, especially in the east. The period since that time has been dominated by the Holocene Climatic Optimum (HCO), a phenomenon that apparently occurred a little late in New England, around four or five thousand years ago, with rainfall possibly 50 per cent more than at present. There is currently considerable interest in the HCO as the most suitable recent epoch to indicate the possible nature of future warmer earth conditions. From that point to the time of European settlement, weather conditions seem to have been much more stable than in earlier epochs, becoming cooler and drier, especially within the last 2000 years. Reliable and continuous rainfall records in Australia date only from about the 1880s (the H.C. Russell period), but there is evidence of wetter conditions over eastern Australia from the 1850s to the early twentieth century, with drier conditions dominant until the late 1940s. This pattern was certainly evident in New England, although once again there have been significant variations within each period. The 1888 drought, for instance, was extremely severe and, coupled with a bitterly cold winter, caused high sheep losses, complicating what were already angry negotiations between squatters and shearers. The very driest years on the Tableland seem to have been 1861 and 1874, when the gauge at the Armidale Post Office collected an annual rainfall of 436 and 420 millimetres respectively. In 1902, a disastrous year for the continent as a whole with the worst drought on record at that time, the Armidale measure went no lower than 468. The wettest year, on the other hand, was apparently 1863, with a
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 37
7/12/06 5:07:46 PM
High Lean Country 38
measurement of 1507 millimetres, twice what we now know to be the average and more than three times the minimum (420 millimetres in 1874).7 Good temperature data are even more limited. Eastern Australia seems to have warmed slightly after about 1940, with an increase in mean temperatures of up to 0.17°C per decade. Maximum temperatures have risen less than minima. But these trends are very small. They are not yet reflected, for instance, in fewer frosts. New England has recently experienced some of the most severe frosts on record, a thick white shell on the landscape, and at all times of the year there have been some unusually low day-time temperatures. The severity of frosts has not been helped, once again, by broadscale clearing of the landscape—and a hard spring frost can be fatal to lambs and hoggets.8 On the other hand, very high temperatures may also be a little more common and during the last few years there has been some hint of a return to drier conditions, with a possible shift towards more winter-type rainfall, even in summer. P R E S E N T C L I M AT E S : C AU S E S A N D PAT T E R N S 9
Because of the combined size and shape of the Australian continent there is considerable modification of air moving inland. The long coastline and few mountain barriers mean that large areas of the continent are subject to oceanic influence, but this is much reduced in the western parts of New England, thanks to distance and the barrier of the eastern escarpment. Oceans to the south of the continent lie in the way of unmodified polar air from Antarctica, and plenty of moisture is picked up in transit. Australia as a whole experiences high variability from year to year, and various factors combine to produce only moderate variations from one season to another. Because of their altitude, the higher parts of New England experience greater seasonal differentiation than much of the rest of Australia. It was H.C. Russell who discovered the importance of high-pressure systems, or anticyclones, for Australian weather. Moving east across the continent, these systems are the main controls on seasonal patterns of atmospheric circulation and rainfall. They cross the east coast at an average latitude of about 38°S in late summer and at about 28°S in late winter. Places north of the highs receive mainly easterly or south-easterly winds, and south winds come predominantly from the west. This means that in winter New England receives mainly cool to cold westerly or south-westerly winds. In summer it is usually under the influence of an easterly to south-easterly airflow, with cold fronts passing well to the south—on average, about 40 anticyclones cross New England every year. They are most frequent in winter, and they often bring frosts. High-pressure ridges are common along the New South Wales coast, especially during summer. Combined with a trough of low pressure, they can lead to heavy precipitation, strong winds and sudden changes in wind direction and temperature. For New England, this can mean the crackling light and vast noise of dramatic thunderstorms. Wind patterns shift all the time. The complicating effect of the meeting of land and sea breezes from the coast sometimes reaches the eastern parts of the
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 38
7/12/06 5:07:46 PM
Sunshine, Snow, Wind and Rain Tableland. Also, topography can shape airflow, especially over the Tableland, with cold air drainage from higher to lower ground being especially obvious in particular spots. In summer, air from the sea is cooler than the land over which it passes, and heating by the land surface can cause high instability and violent storms. Conversely, in winter easterly airflows tend to be warmer than the land surface. Stabilised by chilling from below, they lessen the chance of rain. It was obvious to the first colonial meteorologists that New England lay on the border between two great climatic regions, north and south. The north is monsoonal. From the south, frontal systems come from as far away as the Southern Ocean, and sudden cooling by more than 10°C is not unusual. Again, the interaction of such systems with the higher parts of the Tableland and with warm and humid air from the sea can mean severe thunderstorms along the ranges. If very cold but moist air follows, it can bring on snow. A strong, lengthy southerly flow, carrying air from near-ice-bound latitudes, can mean especially heavy snow falls in the higher parts. For early settlers, snow was a considerable nuisance. Albert Norton spoke of a particularly heavy and damaging fall near Walcha in early September 1857. Even a fortnight later, he said, ‘it was difficult
39
❈ A map from a school textbook, The Climate and Weather of Australia, issued by the Commonwealth Bureau of Meteorology in 1913, and showing Port Macquarie and the Tableland on the border between ‘Summer Monsoon’ and ‘Uniform Rains’. This text was presumably used in New England’s first high schools (see Chapter 15).
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 39
7/12/06 5:07:47 PM
High Lean Country 40
in places to get through the heaps of branches that lay thick upon the roads, and . . . large patches of snow were still lying in the shady places’.10 In summer, on the other hand, tropical cyclones can move southward along the Queensland coast, bringing with them prolonged heavy rain, locally called ‘monsoonal rains’. However, this now seems to be less common than it was even twenty to 25 years ago, when it happened at least once every summer. In late winter and early spring, east coast lows, in various forms, can be a cause of major flooding for eastern New South Wales, including New England. These multiple interactions have complex results. Day-to-day weather is rarely uniform, with striking contrasts between the higher parts of the Tableland and the slopes and plains to the south and west. The longer-term patterns of climate are just as variable—the region is neither uniformly cold nor hot, wet nor dry, when compared with other parts of the continent. Hence the common remark, now used as a draw-card for tourists, that Armidale is the city of four seasons, all of them coming sometimes in a single day. T E M P E R AT U R E
In New England, July is the coldest month, when much of the Tableland can be among the coldest parts of the continent. On the nightly television weather charts, the Tableland’s higher parts regularly show the lowest temperatures in New South Wales, with the precise location varying from time to time. Forty years ago Walcha was consistently reporting the lowest, then Armidale, then Tenterfield and, most recently, Glen Innes. With no other explanation available, it is tempting to suggest that towns have been vying for the publicity that goes with being at the bottom of the temperature league table. Walcha, on the other hand, took the opposite approach, asking to be removed from official registration. In all seasons, solar radiation, and therefore temperature, tends to be progressively higher across New England from south-east to north-west. But the main reason for the differences between the Tableland and its southern and western margins is altitude (usually pushing the mercury down by at least 5°C per 1000 metres). Distance from the ocean tends to increase the heat in summer and the cold in winter. Similarly, night-time cloud helps the temperature stay up and day-time cloud can bring it down. Strong winds generally produce a cooling effect, but they also reduce the chance of frost. Air from the south tends to be cold, while that from the north is warmer. Cold air drainage into valleys takes with it more and heavier frosts. High landforms can create shade, producing narrowly localised patterns of strong winds and calms, all of which can influence temperature. In all seasons there is a broad increase in temperatures as we move from Walcha, through Armidale and Guyra to Glen Innes, Inverell and Tenterfield. The warmest areas are well to the west, beyond Moree, and to the south around Tamworth and on the Liverpool Plains. Throughout the whole area of the Tableland and its slopes and plains, the frequency of frosts varies considerably,
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 40
7/12/06 5:07:48 PM
Sunshine, Snow, Wind and Rain 41
❈ The effect of good rain on the Wallamumbi Falls—a drawing first published in 1886. Note the small human figures in the middle foreground. (artist: unknown)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 41
7/12/06 5:07:48 PM
High Lean Country 42
the heaviest and most frequent being in the higher parts, where they can occur in any month of the year. Overnight temperatures of –10°C have been recorded regularly over most of the Tableland, while temperatures over 35°C are very rare, as are heatwaves. On the other hand, all the country to the west has at some time experienced temperatures over 45°C, and heatwaves of twenty days or more. P R E C I P I TAT I O N
In terms of rainfall, once again New England lies between the summer maximum areas of northern Australia and the winter maximum areas familiar in the south. Rain can come at any time of the year. In summer, most rain in the east is due to moist easterly winds, the influence of which lessens rapidly inland. Thunderstorms are common in summer, and can bring copious rain. Between May and September (especially in May and June), good rain can be the result of major north-west cloud bands or other cloud masses from the tropics meeting cold fronts from the south-west. But such good rainfall seems to have been increasingly rare in recent years. We still have the cloud bands and the frontal systems, but not at the same time, which means fewer precipitating interactions. Annual rainfall decreases rapidly inland. Mean figures range from nearly 900 millimetres on the higher parts of the Tableland to about 500 in the far north-west. Much of Australia suffers from extreme variability of rainfall, but most of this region has relatively low variability from year to year. Variability usually increases from east to west. On the other hand, as Albert Norton noticed in the 1850s, any particular area might suffer devastating floods in one year or season, and severe drought straight afterwards—or the other way around. Norton’s experience was around Walcha, but in fact such juxtapositions of flood and drought are more common to the west. Thunderstorms sometimes bring flash-flooding, and occasionally, as H.C. Russell remarked, giant hail—in modern measurements, up to 100 millimetres in diameter. The great hailstorm of September 1996 did $10 million of damage in and around Armidale.11 Small hail (less than ten millimetres in diameter) is more common in late winter and spring, while large or giant hail is more likely in late spring and summer, especially over the Tableland. Thunderstorm climatology shows a clear peak of storms in December, but widespread hail tends to peak a month earlier. Most parts of the Tableland experience one to three days per year with hail, the highest frequencies appearing to be between Copeton Dam and Inverell, and around Armidale and Uralla. Tornadoes are also a feature of New England, though a rare one. H.C. Russell thought that as settlement pushed into the remoter parts of the country tornadoes might be found to be as devastating as the American variety. In fact, they have rarely caused much damage, except to trees, sheds and small buildings. With a denser population there might be more risk to life and limb.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 42
7/12/06 5:07:49 PM
Sunshine, Snow, Wind and Rain T H E F U T U R E 12
43
We cannot know how future climate will be affected by such factors as increasing greenhouse gas concentrations and changes in the working of the atmosphere. There are no scenarios specific to New England, but predictions for Australia as a whole suggest what might happen in our region. Water vapour and as many as 40 trace gases may contribute to enhanced global warming, the most significant being carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, CFC-11 and CFC-12. Some models predict temperature increases of anything up to 5°C by the middle of this century. There is still no certainty as to the exact causes of this warming and as to how large any increases might be, but there will certainly be regional differences. In New England warming could be up to 2°C. Likely differences from place to place are hard to specify in the models, but it is most likely that the greatest rises will be further inland. There may be more summer rainfall, perhaps by as much as 20 per cent by 2030, with decreases in winter by as much as 10 per cent. At the same time rainfall intensity is predicted to increase, although the number of rain days may fall, with longer and more frequent dry spells. In the longer term, atmospheric circulation zones may shift south, and severe weather may be both worse and more common. Global warming could lead to changes in rainfall, run-off, cloudiness, frost and thunderstorm frequency, increased erosion and drought, changes in soil moisture and salinity, shifts in bioclimatic zones and species extinction. It might also result in the introduction of new species, reduced yields for some crops because of fewer frosts and the increased incidence of some diseases, human and animal. The picture is complicated by recent research, which suggests that increasing concentrations of solid pollutants in the atmosphere may create a dimming effect by reducing incoming solar radiation. That would help to mask any local impact of global warming. There are still many gaps in our knowledge as to how the global climate system works, and how processes on a global scale affect the regional and local level. But whatever the precise truth about the greenhouse effect, it is not too early to be preparing for its dangerous possibilities, and to be addressing related questions about energy consumption, population growth and material circumstances, many of them crucial to the way we live on the Tableland.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 43
7/12/06 5:07:50 PM
CHAPTER 4 ❈
Wil d l i fe Pet e r Jar man and K a r l Ve r n e s
When New England was first settled by the Whites, they found the standing nets of the Blacks in many parts of the bush for the purpose of entrapping the wild animals—The tribes of Blacks met by appointment at these places at certain times driving from different directions their game before them, and this from a circle of many miles into these nets . . . Since the Whites have occupied the Pundarra & Byron plains Countries, the wild animals of every description have left the plains & frequented places occupied by civilized man, and have betaken to the mountains & unfrequented parts.1 The schoolmaster and chronicler William Gardner thus described the impact of the first twenty years of pastoralism. The Aborigines’ hunting infrastructure was destroyed, and the wildlife on which they depended drastically reduced in the developed areas, remaining abundant only in ‘the mountains and unfrequented parts’. This chapter takes up the theme of the diversity, distribution and human attitudes to New England’s vertebrate fauna—its native and introduced mammals, birds, reptiles, frogs and fishes—with a particular focus on mammals. To begin with, vertebrate species occurred on the Tableland in numbers above the average for Australian bioregions. From the mid-nineteenth century pastoral and agricultural settlement had an accidental but dramatic impact on species numbers and variety, mainly through habitat alteration, suppression of native predators and introduction of exotic predators and competitors. The
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 44
7/12/06 5:07:50 PM
Wildlife period around World War One was especially important. The eastern forest and gorge country then offered sanctuary to several species that could no longer survive on the Tableland proper. On the other hand, we can also date serious efforts to understand and preserve native wildlife, as typical of the region and Australia, from this time. Armidale, for instance, was one of the very first rural towns to see the formation of a branch of the New South Wales Naturalists’ Club (by 1906).2 Geographical patterns of wildlife distribution are among the many, often inconsistent factors that fix the heartland and boundaries of the Tableland. There are also historical patterns, in which we see temporary increases of populations and of species within a larger, long-term pattern of decline.
45
MAMMALS
Monotrem e s, t h e e gg-la yi n g m a mmal s In 1818 the explorer John Oxley wrote of seeing in the Peel River ‘numbers of the ornithorrynchus [sic] or water mole’. Europeans considered the Platypus a remarkable oddity of nature, and this is its first reported sighting in or near New England. Later in the colonial period, many platypuses were to be trapped or shot for their fine skins. In 1978 residents of the Manilla district, just west of the Tableland, showed John Wheeler, of the University of New England, four rugs, each probably 50 years old and containing at least 25 skins.3 Indeed, in the 1910s and 20s the Platypus was hunted to such an extent that its very survival seemed threatened. As a result, zoos and museums, both in Australia and the United States, tried urgently to secure Platypus specimens. There were also private conservation initiatives, as a result of a widespread and growing interest in Australian wildlife. The Wildlife Preservation Society was founded in Sydney in 1909 and its early members included P.A. Wright of Wallamumbi and his teenage daughter Judith, the later poet. It was about this time that Wright also began his campaign for a New England National Park on the eastern escarpment, which came to fruition in the 1930s.4 Touring parts of the Tableland in 1919–21, Charles Hoy, of the National Museum in Washington, visited the wealthy grazier Charles Baldwin at Durham Court, near Manilla, and found that he had ‘taken to breeding up native mammals which are approaching extinction’. Baldwin’s private zoo seems to have included platypuses— the Taronga Zoological Park Trust, in Sydney, had asked him for live specimens in 1916.5 Visiting the headwaters of the Namoi and Manilla rivers, Hoy reported that the ‘Platypus although scarce is not by any means nearing extinction’.6 Today, although still widespread, platypuses are absent from some headwaters and small creeks on the Tableland, especially above waterfalls.7 They cannot survive in intermittent streams. The Short-beaked Echidna is also common throughout New England, although its numbers have similarly diminished where agriculture is intense.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 45
7/12/06 5:07:50 PM
High Lean Country 46
In the cold Tableland winters Echidnas get under cover and go into torpor, awaking to brief activity every few weeks.8 Mars u pia ls, t h e po uc h e d m a m m a l s The Platypus might have seemed to settlers the most remarkable of Australian vertebrates, but the marsupials have always been the most familiar. Of the small, insectivorous marsupial species, only the Yellow-footed Antechinus (found in drier woodland and forest) and the Common Dunnart (found in open grassy woodland) still live across the whole Tableland, although both are scarce. Others occupy the edges. The Dusky and the Brown Antechinus occupy wetter forests and heathlands in the east, and there may be Common Planigale in the far north-east. The plains-dwelling Stripe-faced and Fat-tailed Dunnarts may reach the Tableland’s western edge. Brush-tailed Phascogales are tree-dwellers, raiding birds’ and bees’ nests for eggs, chicks, honey and grubs, and hunting in trees for large insects and small vertebrates. In the colonial period, they raided settlers’ bee-hives and killed poultry by biting their heads and, or so the settlers believed, drinking their blood. They are vulnerable to forest clearing and fragmentation, and today probably survive only along the escarpment.9 Settlers called quolls ‘native cats’. The Spotted-tailed Quoll (the ‘tiger cat’) was persecuted for raiding poultry, but it can still be found in the region. The smaller Eastern Quoll, now extinct throughout New South Wales, may never have occurred on the Tableland, although it was supposedly seen west of Glen Innes in the 1860s–80s.10 Quolls were once common enough for riders with dogs to put up two or three a day, but during the first years of the twentieth century they succumbed to foxes and competition from rabbits. Charles Hoy noted in 1921 that Aboriginal people spoke of quolls, together with bandicoots, Rufous Rat-kangaroos and Brush-tailed Phascogales, as ‘plentiful up to a few years ago’. In the 1920s they were further reduced by rabbit poison.11 They also now survive most abundantly around the eastern gorges and forested country, and they still raid chook pens. Bandicoots hide in a nest in the daytime, but settlers were quick to notice the conical pits dug during their foraging at night. The Long-nosed Bandicoot was once found throughout the Tableland, and the Northern Brown Bandicoot in the north. Both ranged east to the coast, but they quickly disappeared after the introduction of foxes.12 Both species have now gone from most of the pastoral country but, like so many others under threat, they have found a refuge on the Tableland’s eastern fringe. Settlers found the Koala everywhere in New England, but numbers have been greatly reduced by land clearing and epidemic disease. In 1887–89 and 1900–03, throughout the whole of New South Wales, outbreaks were reported of ‘ophthalmia and periostitis of the skull’, which match symptoms of the chlamydial infections that still afflict Tableland Koalas and cause female sterility.13 Now that trees are more widely scattered, Koalas are sometimes forced to cross
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 46
7/12/06 5:07:51 PM
Wildlife open ground, which exposes them to dogs and cars. They survive across the Tableland, but are no longer ubiquitous. None have been seen near Glen Innes since 1920, but they still appear occasionally in or near other towns, including Armidale and Walcha.14 The Common Wombat is often seen between the Liverpool Ranges and the Nundle–Nowendoc area (including Riamukka State Forest), just beyond the Tableland’s southern edge. But it is inexplicably scarce on the Tableland itself.15 There have been occasional sightings in the south and a few small and dwindling populations exist north-east of Glen Innes, around Butterleaf State Forest, and in the north around Bald Rock National Park. In some places, farmers have destroyed wombats to protect fences and pasture, and to prevent stock and vehicles from falling into their burrows. Possums are much more numerous. All species have been affected by forest fragmentation and clearing, but none is extinct. Collecting possums and gliders for the British Natural History Museum in the 1920s, the polar explorer Sir Hubert Wilkins said of the Ebor district: ‘Trappers have exterminated most, if not all, of the valuable fur-bearing animals, such as the grey and black opossum, the wallaby, and the kangaroo’.16 Hoy found much the same, perhaps because New England maintained open seasons to allow trapping of possums and gliders for several years after the species were protected in the rest of the state.17 And yet, the Common Brushtail Possum (pictured on page 350) and the Sugar Glider are now widespread once more, and the Common Ringtail Possum is well distributed in the east. It may be that the Greater Glider was always restricted to tall eucalypt forests in the east, and the Yellow-bellied Glider and the Mountain Brushtail Possum to the high-rainfall northern and eastern edges of the Tableland. The Squirrel Glider and Feathertail Glider are both found only sparsely, again mainly in the east. Large numbers of macropods have been killed by both Aborigines and Europeans, for various reasons. They have always been valued for their flesh and skins, and kangaroos and wallabies, in particular, have been hunted for sport. Between the first pastoral settlement and the 1870s, despite initial reports of their displacement by stock, large kangaroos multiplied quickly, probably because of improved pasture and reduced hunting by Aborigines and dingoes.18 In 1878 over 400 residents of New England petitioned the Legislative Assembly for ‘special legislation’ to suppress the ‘alarming increase and ravages of the marsupials’ (meaning kangaroos).19 Soon afterwards, Pastures Protection Boards began to offer bounties on pests affecting the pastoral industry. Eastern Grey Kangaroos and Common Wallaroos were among the first species bountied in New England, as they were considered to be direct competitors with sheep. The impact on kangaroo populations was immediate. In the Tamworth district, 260 780 kangaroo scalps were paid for in 1884, but only 12 337 in 1892. On the Tableland the bountying of large kangaroos had largely ceased by the late 1890s. It had done its job, but also hunting for skins now paid as much as scalp bounties. On the other hand, from the mid-1890s the Tamworth Board sometimes paid bounties on more than 100 000 wallaby scalps a year.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 47
47
7/12/06 5:07:52 PM
High Lean Country 48
❈ The release of endangered Rufous Bettongs, by Peter Jarman and Lorraine Smith, into a predator-proof enclosure at Yarandoo, near New England National Park, in January 2003—a turning point for this species, once ubiquitous on the Tableland. (photo: D. Elkins)
Not surprisingly, in 1921 Hoy remarked that the Eastern Grey Kangaroo was ‘getting rather scarce’ in the Ebor District. The Swamp Wallaby and Red-necked Wallaby, he said, were both ‘very scarce’.20 Meanwhile tens of thousands of rat-kangaroo scalps were submitted every year until about 1910, when rabbit poison and foxes became even more lethal. Around Manilla in 1908, rat-kangaroos were still so abundant that netting was used to keep them from crops, but only five years later they were scarce.21 Bountied rat-kangaroos included the Brush-tailed, Tasmanian and Rufous Bettongs. Only the last survives in New England, and only in the north and east where foxes are few. In the Tamworth district the ‘pademelon’, or Bridled Nailtail Wallaby (also called ‘Flash Jack’), was bountied between 1897 and 1913, and it too largely disappeared during the last three years.22 In 1924, Baldwin’s collection at Durham Court apparently contained the last specimens in New South Wales. Brush-tailed Rock-wallabies were hunted for their pelts and were also bountied in some districts. Once widespread across the Tableland, wherever boulder piles or caves gave them refuge, today the cliffs and gorges on the eastern rim are their last stronghold in New South Wales.23
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 48
7/12/06 5:07:52 PM
Wildlife Native rode n t s a n d b a t s
49
Few species of native rodents or bats ever had their range centred on New England. The Water Rat is the only native rodent still widespread, and its numbers may well have declined over the last 50 years, especially in the headwaters of the Namoi, Manilla and Apsley rivers, and more widely in degraded and now intermittent streams. Dependent on permanent water, it leaves distinctive middens of mussel shells on rocks or logs in the water or on the bank.24 Until the 1960s it was trapped for its dense and lustrous fur. The Bush Rat survives in some forest remnants, and the Fawn-footed Melomys and the Swamp Rat venture onto the eastern, forested edges. Other species of rat are now extinct, either on the Tableland or altogether. The Pale Field-rat, and possibly the Darling Downs Hopping-mouse, once inhabited the north. The Plains Rat was found on the western slopes, but no longer occurs closer than South Australia. Gould’s Mouse, also extinct, once ran on the Liverpool Plains. The White-footed Tree-rat, which lived throughout the Tableland in the nineteenth century, is also now wholly extinct. Remains of the Eastern Chestnut Mouse and New Holland Mouse, together with those of the White-footed Tree-rat, have been identified in superficial but pre-European cave deposits at Dripping Rock, on the western edge.25 As for bats, small numbers of Grey-headed and Little Red Flying-foxes occasionally venture onto the Tableland from the north-east coast and hinterland in search of blossoming trees, usually eucalypts, but they almost never breed here. In some years Little Red Flying-foxes even reach the western plains. These are fruit bat or ‘megabat’ (megachiropteran) species. At least 24 insecteating or ‘microbat’ (microchiropteran) species have also been recorded on the Tableland, mostly in forest country in the east and north-east.26 The Greater Broad-nosed Bat, Eastern Freetail Bat and Eastern False Pipistrelle all shelter in the daytime in tree hollows, while the Lesser Long-eared and Gould’s Longeared Bats hide under loose bark. The Eastern Horseshoe, Common Bentwing and Little Cave Bats roost in abandoned mine shafts and in houses. When Copeton Dam was created in the 1970s a colony of Large-eared Pied Bats was flooded out of Copeton Mine.27 Some bats gather in towns, colonising the colonisers. The Lesser Long-eared Bat, for instance, forages for insects around houses and roosts in roofs, and is one bat species that may have benefited from European settlement. Introdu c e d m a m m a ls The Dingo, introduced to Australia from south-east Asia 3500 years ago, was once ubiquitous on the Tableland. Pastoralists trapped, poisoned and shot dingoes until they were largely eradicated by the 1860s or 70s. There have been occasional sightings in cleared parts into the twentieth century and some live still along the forested eastern edge, at times attacking stock. An old system of dog-fences runs along much of the rim of the eastern escarpment, mostly in disrepair but maintained or restored in places. Fencing to exclude dogs was
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 49
7/12/06 5:07:53 PM
High Lean Country 50
❈ Dingo and wild dog carcases displayed on a ‘dog tree’ near Oxley Wild Rivers National Park. Game-keepers like to show that they are playing their part in controlling ‘pests’. (photo: P. Jarman)
largely abandoned in the 1960s as Wild Dog Destruction Boards promoted widespread poisoning with 1080 (sodium fluoroacetate). Poison baits are still spread each year in forests and parks to ‘control’ wild dogs, many of which are no longer pure-blood dingoes.28 Rabbits, hares and foxes were all brought originally from England to Tasmania and/or Victoria, for traditional coursing and hunting. The European Rabbit was established on the mainland in 1859 and it reached New England in the 1890s. Tamworth Pastures Protection Board had already offered a bounty on rabbits, hoping to stop the species’ advance, but the Armidale board saw no need for organised effort until 1909, and by then rabbits were out of control. Fencing, poisoning, trapping and, more recently, introduced diseases (myxomatosis and rabbit haemorrhagic disease), together with the poison 1080, have been part of the New England battle against rabbits for the past century. Rabbits are the major food source for foxes, Wedge-tail and Little Eagles, and Whistling Kites. The Brown Hare reached Armidale, Tamworth and Glen Innes by 1892 or 1893, and Tenterfield by 1900. Scalp returns show that hare numbers erupted and then declined quite rapidly, usually as rabbit numbers built up. Hares were hunted for sport, landholders boasting of the numbers (often hundreds) shot on their property in a day. They are now ubiquitous in pastoral areas, but much more rare in remnant native vegetation.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 50
7/12/06 5:07:54 PM
Wildlife The Red Fox, imported in the 1860s and 70s, reached southern New England in about 1900 and within a few years its numbers had risen exponentially.29 Recognised as lamb-killers, foxes had bounties on them before they arrived. They are still a major threat to many native species, but they avoid areas where there are dingoes. In the 1970s and 80s foxes on the Tableland were hunted (both casually and professionally) for their excellent winter pelts, but that trade collapsed when rabies in Europe made fox fur unpopular. Use of 1080 to control foxes on sheep-breeding properties then dramatically increased.30 Some introduced animals were not originally meant to run completely wild. Feral cats became widespread soon after settlement and now occur throughout the Tableland. They too may be responsible for the eradication of some native species. In the early years of settlement, before cheap and effective fencing was available, sheep, cattle and horses were only lightly controlled by shepherds and stockmen. As a result, these animals also escaped and formed feral populations. Horses often ran free, being mustered only when needed. Graziers would capture them and break them either for stock work or for sale as re-mounts for the British, Indian and Australian armies. Feral populations remain on leasehold and Crown land in the east of the region. Herds at Guy Fawkes ‘represent a mixture of different breeds, with a continual introduction of outside blood’.31 Fallow Deer have run wild since the late nineteenth century, mainly between Glen Innes and the Queensland border, but since the 1960s they have spread
51
❈ Wild horses in Guy Fawkes River National Park in 2005, being censused by helicopter. (photo: K. Vernes)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 51
7/12/06 5:07:54 PM
High Lean Country 52
further south. Feral goats are common in the eastern gorges, and scattered feral pigs have multiplied in forests and around wetlands and watercourses. By the late nineteenth century, the introduced House Mouse was a problem on the Tableland and it is now the region’s most widespread rodent species. After drought-breaking rains it can erupt in huge numbers, especially in cropping districts, and has done so in northern New South Wales (including western New England) half a dozen times since 1903. The Black Rat was first noticed in the Manilla district as late as 1920–21. After ‘two good wheat years’, numbers were so high that rats were eating rats.32 There have been no more plagues on this scale, but Black Rats are now common in Tableland towns. They can also survive without human resources, and they may even perform some of the ecological functions of native Bush and Swamp Rats, such as dispersing spores of below-ground fungi. BIRDS
Between 1978 and 1982 a total of 296 bird species were recorded in New England for the Royal Australasian Ornithologists Union Atlas.33 Two-fifths either occurred throughout the Tableland or showed no geographic pattern. The remainder were mostly characteristic of the western slopes and plains, or the wet forests along the eastern edge. Despite being on a high plateau, the Tableland’s lagoons are visited, at least occasionally, by most of Australia’s waterbirds, including such rarities (for New South Wales) as the Freckled Duck, Magpie Goose and Brolga. Many visiting birds are on their way between inland wetlands and the coast, but the lagoons no longer provide good breeding habitat for most species—apart from the Black Swan, Eurasian Coot, Purple Swamphen and Dusky Moorhen. Several wetlands are conserved, Llangothlin Lagoon as a game reserve for breeding and shooting ducks, and nearby Little Llangothlin, Billy Bung and Mother-ofDucks as nature reserves. Dangar’s Lagoon, near Uralla, although a Travelling Stock Reserve, is also managed for the preservation of waterbirds. However, the draining of the Tableland’s once-extensive temporary wetlands, both intentional and accidental and, as William Gardner shows, well under way in the 1850s,34 has left limited habitat for Latham’s Snipe, which each summer migrates to Australia from Japan. Woodland birds have declined in numbers since European settlement.35 Emus have largely disappeared from the Tableland. The Bush Thick-knee (the ‘curlew’ of the settlers) was once widespread and common but, as one observer near Walcha said in 1922, ‘since the coming of the fox they have become very rare’.36 Their haunting call was last reported at Inverell in 1958.37 The Squatter Pigeon once ranged further south than at present—to Inverell, Ashford and Bingara, for instance.38 The Paradise Parrot occurred in the north but may now be extinct throughout its range. The Whistling Kite was common near Walcha in 1919–20 and in Glen Innes in the 1920s, but it disappeared in the 1960s.39 There is no single cause for these declines. Ground-nesting birds, such as the Bush
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 52
7/12/06 5:07:55 PM
Wildlife Thick-knee and the Squatter Pigeon, are very vulnerable to foxes. The Paradise Parrot was probably affected by changed fire regimes, which reduced its food supply (grass seeds), and by intense hunting for the trade in aviary birds. On the other hand, a few native birds of more open, grassy habitat have increased in numbers since settlement. The Crested Pigeon is now common, and the Galah was absent at first settlement and not recorded at Glen Innes until after 1945.40 The once-migratory Pied Currawong now lives here year-round, and breeds in areas where exotic berry-bearing shrubs (such as hawthorn) provide a continuous food source. It also takes the eggs and nestlings of smaller birds, adding to a general decline among songbirds. The Little Eagle was recorded as new to Bundarra in 1920, and even in 1922 it had not reached Walcha.41 Its increase may be linked to its modern diet of rabbits.42 Introduced bird species are few. However, House Sparrows, Common Starlings and feral Pigeons occupy every town and some farms, the Common Mynah and the Spotted Turtledove have spread from the south-east as far as Tamworth, and a few Blackbirds live in Armidale and Uralla. Goldfinches are patchy on the croplands and pastures. The small populations of parrots and cockatoos from outside the region that are established in some towns—for instance, Little Corellas in Armidale—are probably descended from escaped cage-birds.
53
REPTILES
New England is home to between 22 and 30 species of snake, and between 62 and 76 species of lizard.43 No exotic reptiles are established on the Tableland. The cold climate favours skinks and venomous (elapid) snakes, several of which bear live young rather than laying eggs. The spine of the Tableland appears to divide the snake and lizard fauna into eastern and western elements. No species particularly characterise the central Tableland.44 Turtle species are few. The Eastern Snake-necked Turtle occurs across the Tableland in all kinds of waterbodies, including farm dams, and the Murray River Turtle probably lives on the western edge.45 Bell’s Turtle is restricted to headwaters of the Namoi and Gwydir rivers. Its isolated populations may well turn out to be several distinct species or sub-species. Foxes dig up and eat the eggs of all turtle species, and both foxes and cats prey on lizards and snakes. Such predation may threaten the survival of some reptile species. F RO G S
Frog species in New England, all of them indigenous, apparently total 48.46 A dozen are confined to the high-rainfall eastern edge of the region (and usually down onto the coastal plain), and another set extends up the western slopes onto the west of the Tableland.47 Three sphagnum frog species (genus Philoria) have ranges along the eastern rim, each being found in high-altitude rainforest with persistently wet sphagnum or ferns.48 In the headwaters of rivers above
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 53
7/12/06 5:07:56 PM
High Lean Country 54
the escarpment these frogs show interesting patterns of distribution, with each species inhabiting a distinct range. The Yellow-spotted Tree frog and the Peppered Frog, both once unique to the region, have become very rare or even extinct within the past 30 years. The numbers of some other species, including the Green and Golden Bell Frog and the Booroolong Frog, have declined and several with restricted distribution and specialised habitat requirements are listed as threatened in the region. These include the sphagnum frogs,49 the Pouched Frog that inhabits Antarctic Beech forest and the barred frogs (genus Mixophyes) found in rainforest streams. Perhaps the greatest global threat to amphibians in recent times is the pathogenic chytrid fungus that affects frog populations. In some cases it has caused extinction. In Australia, frogs that have suffered the greatest declines have typically been stream-dwelling species in upland areas where conditions seem to encourage fungal infection and transmission. Most New England species are relatively safe, because they live in non-stream habitats such as dams, ponds and lakes (tree frogs, genus Litoria); soaks and marshes (sphagnum frogs and brood frogs, genus Pseudophryne); or else in places intermittently free of standing or flowing water (the Burrowing Frog, Spade-foot Toad and toadlets of the genus Uperoleia). Some, for example the marsh frogs of the genus Limnodynastes and froglets of the genus Crinia, manage in a variety of habitats. Overall then, much of the Tableland has a secure and diverse frog fauna. The eastern rim is another matter. There, where some species are already threatened and where the greatest diversity occurs, the danger of chytridiomycosis is likely to be high.50 In addition, this is where cool-adapted, high-altitude frogs will be confronted by the reality of global warming. FISHES
All native fishes in New England have (or had) their major distributions in rivers either flowing inland into the Murray-Darling system or flowing coastwards in the Richmond, Clarence and Macleay.51 Most reach only the edge of the Tableland. No native fish species is unique to New England, although a few are now better represented here than in their former downstream ranges.52 Such species include the River Blackfish, which has suffered from degradation and siltation of its habitat, and the Climbing Galaxias and the Mountain Galaxias, both of which are sensitive to introduced trout and are now mainly confined to trout-free headwater streams. The Eastern Cod declined from the 1920s as a result of intensive agriculture and commercial exploitation. It now breeds in only a few sites in the Guy Fawkes, Nymboida, Boyd and Mann rivers.53 The Southern Purple-spotted Gudgeon, once widespread in the whole MurrayDarling system, now occurs only in a few sites near Inverell and Tenterfield, and in the Gwydir at Bingara. Its massive range reduction correlates, in space and time, with the invasion of the Mosquito Fish.54 The Tableland has had few commercially important native fishes, although the Eastern Cod was once heavily exploited and the Long-finned Eel is still
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 54
7/12/06 5:07:56 PM
Wildlife harvested in the Guyra-Ebor area. Large numbers of exotic cool-water fishes have been bred and released here for sport-fishing, most notably the Brown and Rainbow Trouts. There are many self-sustaining wild populations of both species, and one of Brook Char.55 The Redfin Perch, also introduced for sport, is similarly widespread. Trout, Mosquito Fish (which were introduced in a vain attempt to control mosquito larvae) and Goldfish (released from aquaria) are blamed for the reduction of several native fish species. However, trout fishing is a major sport in New England and commercially important. The trout hatchery near Ebor (begun in 1925 near Guyra, by Les Dutton, and moved to its present site in 1949) is the last example in New South Wales of government-sanctioned breeding, and of the release of non-native vertebrates to the wild. It is therefore the last gasp of the nineteenth-century acclimatisation movement which also brought to Australia foxes, rabbits and hares.
55
C O N C LU S I O N
New England’s native vertebrate wildlife, while rich in species, now includes none confined to this region alone. The two distinctive species of frog are apparently gone, and the National Parks and Wildlife Service lists as threatened with extinction in the region 23 mammal, 24 bird, one reptile and seven frog species.
❈ The Brush-tailed Rock-wallaby, once common from Toowoomba to the Grampians, is now an endangered species, but persists in healthy numbers in the gorges and eastern escarpment of the New England bioregion. (photo: K. Vernes)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 55
7/12/06 5:07:57 PM
High Lean Country 56
The threat to mammal species—accounting for one fifth of the total (including 38 per cent of bat species)—is especially serious. On the other hand, populations of ground-dwelling mammals such as rock-wallabies, bettongs, potoroos and bandicoots survive wherever foxes are scarce. Exotic birds are not numerous and generally avoid native vegetation, leaving it to indigenous species. Also, the Tableland is free of the Cane Toad and exotic reptiles. Some native fishes have suffered from competition with trout, Mosquito Fish and Goldfish, but we have no other seriously detrimental exotic fishes, such as the European Carp. Change to New England’s vertebrate fauna following European settlement has come in phases. The first phase (1830–80) involved the establishment of sheep and cattle, the eradication of native predators such as the Dingo and an increase in the number of kangaroos and wallabies. The second phase (1880– 1920) saw the arrival of hares, rabbits and foxes, and with it the swift extirpation of ‘critical-weight-range’ native mammals and ground-nesting birds.56 In the third phase (1920–60), exotic mammals, birds and fishes established themselves in settled patterns, agriculture intensified, remaining tree and understorey cover was fragmented and removed on pastoral land, and many mammals and some birds disappeared from affected areas. The final phase (since 1960) has seen better control of rabbits, the systematic culling of kangaroos and the establishment of many conservation reserves around the edges of the Tableland. But native mammals, birds and reptiles continue to disappear from isolated remnants of native vegetation, and frog species likewise dwindle. The contrast between the impoverished wildlife community on the Tableland proper and the rich diversity still to be found within the forests on the eastern escarpment should remind us of the wildlife heritage we have almost lost. Some species will remain in the rural environment, and even in suburbs, for generations yet. Unhappily, however, the reserves that are meant to represent the ecosystems of the Tableland proper (rather than the eastern escarpment) are too few, too small and too disconnected to ensure that full communities of wildlife will live on into the distant future.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 56
7/12/06 5:07:58 PM
CHAPTER 5 ❈
T h e Ve g e t a t e d L an ds cap e Pet e r C la rk e
Plants, both natural and agricultural, are fundamental to all New England life. Directly or indirectly, native animals depend on them for food and habitat. Agriculture itself benefits directly from native vegetation because it provides renewable herbage for sheep and cattle production, and indirectly because it ensures healthy soils and water, and limits insect pests. This chapter summarises what we know about the striking diversity of native vegetation to be found on the New England Tableland. More than this, it seeks to show that the vegetation is dynamic. While the people of New England depend on its plant life, the future of the plant life depends on the people. The Tableland is more or less a single bioregion, as defined by the New South Wales National Parks and Wildlife Service. As such it extends a little to the north of the Queensland border and to the south of Walcha, eastward to the escarpment, and with Inverell just beyond its limits to the west. Very roughly, a bioregion is an ecosystem in itself, having distinctive natural features and environmental processes, and contributing to the geophysical pattern of Australia as a whole. Native vegetation is ever-present in the rural landscape of the Tableland bioregion, from roadsides to paddocks and from stock reserves to national parks. Even within towns and villages, native vegetation is common in cemeteries and parks. While much of the bioregion has highly modified vegetation, resulting from more than 150 years of agriculture, there are remnants and reserves that still reflect the pre-European nature of its plant life. This can be gleaned from the accounts of John Oxley, who described the vegetation around Walcha in 1818, and of Allan Cunningham, who made
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 57
7/12/06 5:07:58 PM
High Lean Country 58
the first known collections of New England plants, at Bald Rock Creek, in 1826–27. About 220 500 hectares (7.7 per cent) of the bioregion is managed as conservation reserves, mostly national parks and nature reserves. These areas tend to have nutrient-deficient soil (which is why they were not taken up for settlement) and vegetation types to match. However, rather than distinguishing sharply between ‘natural’ and ‘agricultural’ or ‘cleared’ areas, this chapter describes a continuum, ranging from conservation reserves to the more highly modified native pastures. F LO R A N OVA A N G L I C A
About 2000 native plant species are to be found on the Tableland. This flora began to be systematically described by the distinguished Government Botanist in Melbourne, Ferdinand von Mueller, who received specimens in the 1860s from Charles Stuart, a gardener at Clifton station, near Tenterfield, and from Alexander Crawford, of Moona Plains, near Walcha. Stuart’s work was recognised in the names, Pultanaea stuartiana, a rare pea, and Brachyscome stuartii, the more common Rock Daisy. Mueller also employed Herman Beckler as a collector, receiving from him many rainforest species from the head of the Bellinger and Macleay rivers. Some specimens were later sent to George Bentham at Kew Gardens, London, and Bentham published the first list of Australian flora in 1866. When the New South Wales Herbarium was established, collections from the region were contributed by Ernst Betche, James Boorman and Joseph Maiden and, in the 1920s, by the Presbyterian minister at Guyra, E. Norman McKie. More recently, the late John Williams made extensive collections of the flora, and both he and McKie had eucalypt species named after them (Eucalyptus mckieana, Eucalyptus williamsiana). The work of describing species continues today at the New England (Beadle) Herbarium at UNE, where the evolution and biogeography of the flora is being unravelled. By far the most numerous species are those that make up the ground cover— grasses and forbs (broad-leaved herbs), many of them widespread but several highly localised and/or rare. One of the most obvious in summer is the annual Paper Daisy (Xerochrysum bracteatum). Some widespread ground species emerge after disturbance and even then may be hard to notice. The yellow-flowered Fire Spurge (Monotaxis macrophylla), for instance, springs up in the months following bushfires. The New England Gentian (Gentiana wissmannii), on the other hand, with its long, bell-like flowers, green outside and sky-blue within, has been seen only a handful of times and always on wet ground near Cathedral Rocks, on the eastern escarpment. Approximately 250 native and 100 exotic forbs have been recorded in the bioregion, mostly in grassy or wetland vegetation, plus some 150 species of orchids and 100 species of sedges and rushes. More dominant in the landscape are the ubiquitous native grasses used for grazing. Some 250 grasses have been recorded, about 150 natives and 100 exotics. A dozen or so of the native grasses form the bulk of herbage used in animal production.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 58
7/12/06 5:07:58 PM
The Vegetated Landscape The less palatable woody plants form the shrub and tree layers of the forests and woodlands. Eucalypts dominate these formations with some 50 species being recorded, several of them unique to the region—for example, the New England Peppermint (Eucalyptus nova-anglica), with its narrow, grey-green leaves and oval buds. Several species have been identified only recently, including the Bolivia Stringybark (Eucalyptus boliviana), which is restricted to the Bolivia Range between Glen Innes and Tenterfield, and the Gorge Red Gum (Eucalyptus sp. nov.). A sometimes prominent feature of New England eucalypts are the twenty or so species of mistletoes which parasitise trees and shrubs. Acacia trees and shrubs are another species-rich component of the flora, with about 70 varieties recorded in habitats ranging from rainforest (Blackwood, or Acacia melanoxylon) to dry rocky outcrops (Beadle’s Wattle, or Acacia beadleana). Beadle’s Wattle, its yellow blossom scattered along hairy stems, commemorates Noel Beadle (1914–98), foundation Professor of Botany at the University of New England, whose work greatly advanced our knowledge of New England vegetation. The six volumes of Beadle’s book, Students’ Flora of North Eastern New South Wales, with pictures by Lois Beadle, were published between 1971 and 1987. The lack of shrubs along many roadsides and nearby paddocks belies the richness of the shrub flora found in the more remote and rugged parts of the region. Some 350 species in 40 families have been recorded and of these 40 are listed as endangered.1 Remarkably, many species have only recently been
59
❈ Acacia beadleana, a rare wattle restricted to rocky granite habitats at Gibraltar Range. (photo: J.J. Bruhl)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 59
7/12/06 5:07:59 PM
High Lean Country 60
described, such as the Torrington Boronia (Boronia inflexa ssp. torringtonensis), and a handful or more are currently being described by botanists at UNE. The richest spots for shrubs are the spectacular granite landscapes of Cathedral Rock National Park, Gibraltar Range National Park and Torrington State Conservation Area. Species restricted to one region are called ‘endemics’, or ‘narrow endemics’ if there are few or single localities. The Tableland contains an unusual number of endemic species, some in isolated habitats and others that have survived through glacial periods because of regional topography. They include the spectacular Silver Sword Lily (Neoastelia spectabilis) identified by John Williams in the 1970s. This rare lily-like plant, with its long green and silver leaves and white flowers, grows on rocky slopes near waterfalls and seepage lines in the Antarctic Beech forests of New England National Park. Its nearest relatives are the bog lilies of the Australian Alps, Tasmania, New Zealand and South America, their common forebear being one of the ancient species of Gondwana (for which, see Chapter 2). Rocky outcrops of the bioregion provide another setting for the evolution of species, where ancestral populations have become isolated and have diverged into highly localised types. The Heath Myrtle (Homoranthus spp.) includes a number of species restricted to areas of less than a few square kilometres each, such as the Bolivia Hill species (Homoranthus croftianaus) and the Torrington species (Homoranthus binghiensis). These are narrow endemics, each with less than a few thousand individual plants limited to a few square kilometres. Their survival depends on protection from feral goats and not too frequent fire. Introduced plants are prominent among the modern vegetation of the bioregion. Many are harmless, some are important for pasture production, but a few are invasive weeds detrimental to the economy and environment. No precise estimates are available on species numbers, but surveys of the grassy communities have recorded more than 150 introduced species.2 The most common are those typically found in any garden lawn or paddock, such as Cats Ear (Hypochaeris radicata), Dock (Rumex crispus) and Thistle (Cirsium vulgare), all of which thrive on regular disturbance and fertiliser, but otherwise dwindle. Of more concern are longer-lived invasive perennial grasses and shrubs that restrict pasture production and biodiversity. The most obvious have spread in the past decade along roadsides and stock reserves. These include African Lovegrass (Eragrostis curvula), Chilean Needlegrass (Nassella neesiana) and Coolati Grass (Hyparrhenia hirta), all of which displace native plants and pasture. Serrated Tussock (Nassella trichotoma) has also been reported recently on the Tableland. It is a ‘Weed of National Significance’ that is on the march throughout Australia and is a potent threat to grassland biodiversity. Woody introduced plants have been slower to invade bushland and roadside reserves but their prevalence has increased markedly in the last decade. Most of these woody weeds originate from gardens and hedgerow shrubs. They include Hawthorn (Crataegus monogyna), Plum (Prunus), Privet (Ligustrum vulgare)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 60
7/12/06 5:08:00 PM
The Vegetated Landscape and Blackberry (Rubus ulmifolius), and are spread by birds such as the Pied Currawong, which thrive in the more open rural landscapes.
61
PLANT SOCIETIES
Groups of plants that coexist in similar environments form characteristic types of vegetation. Far from having uniform vegetation, the bioregion has distinctive and diverse types, the major ones being rainforest, sclerophyll forest (swamp, wet and dry), grassy woodland, heathland, grassland and wetland. In the 1870s, William Christie distinguished shrub-dominated heaths, woodlands and forests, which grow on infertile siliceous soils, from the grasslands, grassy woodlands and wet sclerophyll forests that need the better soils derived from metasediments and basalts. Christie was struck with the way water collected in the granite country around his home. The broken-down rock, he said, retains a very large amount of moisture: so that if the wheels of a vehicle break through the outer crust, the argillaceous matter [sediment] from below spurts up and is soon worked into a bog, out of which it is almost impossible to be extracted. Such areas, where drainage is poor, feature wet heaths, sedgelands and wetlands, while rocky outcrops support species-rich scrub and dry heath.3 Rai nforest Closed canopied rainforests, listed as World Heritage, occur on high rainfall sheltered sites free from fire along the eastern edge of the Tableland. They are interspersed with the more open-canopied sclerophyll forests dominated by eucalypts. The boundary between these two types is thought to be shaped by fire, which at rare intervals opens the way for eucalypts to invade the rainforest and, conversely, by its long absence allows rainforest species to return, driving the eucalypts out. The coldest high altitude forests (cool temperate rainforest) are dominated by the ancient Antarctic Beech (Nothofagus moorei), a genus found as Tertiary fossils in Antarctica and still common in various parts of the Southern Hemisphere. These forests mainly consist of small-leaved trees and are structurally much simpler than other rainforests.4 At lower altitudes the rainforest becomes gradually warmer and Coachwood (Ceratopetalum apetalum) becomes more common, while even further down, beyond the bounds of the bioregion, more complex coastal subtropical rainforest takes over. Curiously, so-called ‘dry rainforest’ also exists in a patchwork along the dry, rocky slopes of the Macleay River gorges, next to the more fireprone gorge woodlands. These viney thickets are found in sites that have annual rainfall below that normally associated with rainforest (less than 900 millimetres each year). They survive apparently because of isolation from fire and an ability to reach down into deep water tables.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 61
7/12/06 5:08:00 PM
High Lean Country 62
❈ Cool temperate rainforest in the New England National Park, with the trunk of an Antarctic Beach (a remnant of Gondwana plant life) in the foreground. (photo: P. J. Clarke)
We t s c l e ro p h y l l f o re s t ‘Sclerophyll’ means hard-leaved. Wet sclerophyll forests are tall, with an understorey of tall shrubs, ferns and grasses. Variety depends on past management. Few stands of ‘old growth’ wet sclerophyll forest remain along the edge of the Tableland, but at Washpool National Park and in New England National Park, New England Blackbutt (Eucalyptus campanulata), Tallowood (Eucalyptus microcorys), Brush Box (Lophostemon confertus) and Blue Gum (Eucalyptus saligna) remain, standing more than 60 metres high in isolated valleys. The soil is shallow mudstone, common to the eastern edge of the Tableland. Even taller trees were once found on the deeper soils derived from basalt caps and softer shales. Here, the understorey species are often soft-leaved. On the wettest southfacing slopes they include Tree Ferns (Cyathea australis) and understorey shrubs associated with rainforests. On the more exposed northerly slopes these mesic (moisture-loving) species give way to a grassy understorey including grass trees and hard-leaved shrubs.5 Frequent fires and grazing have reduced the mesic shrub cover, and in fact many forests on the escarpment now have only a grassy understorey with a few scattered shrubs.6 Dr y s c l e ro p h y l l f o re s t The dry sclerophyll eucalypt forests are the most widespread forests on the Tableland. More than twenty communities have been described across the region.7 Sclerophyll forests standing on the most nutrient-deficient soils
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 62
7/12/06 5:08:01 PM
The Vegetated Landscape 63
❈ Dry sclerophyll forest in Gibraltar Range National Park, between Grafton and Glen Innes, after burning. (photo: P.J. Clarke)
have a diverse and heathy understorey, varying from east to west because of differences in rainfall. The heathy forests to the east, where there is more rain, feature Peppermint Eucalypts (Eucalyptus radiata, Eucalyptus olida) while the western fall features Stringybark (Eucalyptus williamsiana, Eucalyptus subtilior). And again, along the Tableland’s western edge we find Black Cypress Pine (Callitris endlicheri), with its wide-spreading branches and light green foliage, and Tumbledown Red Gum (Eucalyptus dealbata), with its grey-green leaves and bark streaked in white, grey and coppery-orange. Legumes, Heath and Banksia families dominate the shrub layer, their short, narrow or needlelike leaves reducing water loss and conserving nutrients in these relatively harsh environments. Gr a s s y f o re s t s , w o o d l a n d s a n d g r a s s l a n d s Wet sclerophyll forests, typical of fertile soils, gradually change into more open, park-like, grassy woodlands in the colder and drier parts of the Tableland. These forests and woodlands have suffered greatly from dieback, which seems to have a long history on the Tableland (see Chapter 6). Albert Norton, who lived near Walcha in the 1860s, set down his observations from that time on what he called ‘the natural decay of indigenous forests’.8 In valleys and basalt plains the forests and woodlands give way to natural grasslands, wherever cold air drainage and cracking soils make life hard for trees. Soil, altitude and rainfall all seem to matter here. The basalt parts of the central
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 63
7/12/06 5:08:02 PM
High Lean Country 64
❈ Grassy woodlands close to the Oxley Wild Rivers National Park, with dry rainforest on the right. The grassland on the upper right is typical of the Tableland at the top of the gorges. (photo: P.J. Clarke)
Tableland support woodlands of Mountain Gum (Eucalyptus dalrympleana ssp. hepantha) on upper slopes, and of Snow Gum (Eucalyptus pauciflora) further down, with Black Sallee (Eucalyptus stellulata) on the valley bottoms. On less fertile sedimentary (trap-rock) country Silvertop Stringybark (Eucalyptus laevopinea) covers the ridges, while New England Stringybark (Eucalyptus caliginosa) forms grassy forests on the hillsides. On the lower slopes we find woodlands of Yellow Box (Eucalyptus melliodora) and Red Gum (Eucalyptus blakelyi), with narrow belts of River Oak (Casuarina cunninghamii) dangling long branches and grey-green leaves along the creeks and rivers. The deep alluvial soils in the Tableland’s broad valleys once supported natural grasslands, but only vestiges remain. The ‘montane’ or high-country grasslands featured tussocks of Snow Grass (Poa) and Kangaroo Grass (Themeda), with a rich diversity of other herbaceous species in between.9 He a t h s — Ro c k y o u t c ro p s Where granite rocks stand out in large masses, as at the monolithic Bald Rock, east of Tenterfield, shrubs and mallee eucalypts form archipelagoes in a sea of forest. The species living here are only occasionally found in the surrounding dry sclerophyll woodland and some are narrowly endemic. Remarkably, each cluster of outcrops, from Tamworth in the south to Stanthorpe in the north, has a distinct species composition, 25 types in all, ranging from mallee heaths to hummock grasslands of Spinifex.10 A unique feature of these outcrops is the miniature plant life nestled in the rocky depressions. Each microcosm can contain
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 64
7/12/06 5:08:02 PM
The Vegetated Landscape native bulbs, such as Wurmbea, for drought avoidance, together with tiny succulents, such as Crassula, for drought tolerance, and carnivorous sundews, such as Drosera, whose insect diet makes up for the paucity of nutrients.
65
We t l a n d s — Sw a m p h e a t h s a n d l a g o o n we t l a n d s Two distinctive wetland vegetation types occur on the Tableland. On the eastern granite country there are swamp heaths where organic matter, or peat, has accumulated in poorly drained, infertile spots. The peat contains pollen records of vegetation change that extend back thousands of years and which have yet to be fully explored. These are ‘acid’ swamps and often have a drainage line where Sphagnum moss has gathered as a result of constant seepage, with sedgeland ‘fens’ further out and heaths on the drier margins.11 Sphagnum peatlands are confined to a handful of localities along the escarpment. Many are severely degraded because of cattle grazing and in most cases the Sphagnum moss has now vanished.12 They are now listed as endangered communities. The fertile basaltic soils of the central Tableland include a scatter of lagoon wetlands, with floating and emergent water plants (hydrophytes) wherever the water is still. In summer these wetlands are a haven for water birds, including migratory waders (see Chapter 4), but severe winters freeze the surface and the rushes die back during drought. Remarkably, however, they regenerate rapidly in the aftermath of droughts, thanks to a seed bank that germinates when moisture and temperature are right.13 Distinctive zonal patterns emerge
❈ Little Llangothlin Lagoon, north of Guyra. Montane wetlands, locally known as lagoons, often fluctuate from moist pasture to lake-like conditions with abundant plant and bird life. (photo: C. Cooper)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 65
7/12/06 5:08:03 PM
High Lean Country 66
as these lagoons wet up, the deepest parts having floating-leaved species and submerged water plants, while the edges sometimes form wet lawns of grasses, forbs and sedges. D Y N A M I C S O F V E G E TAT I O N
Fire is an integral part of the ecology of New England. Whether lit by lightning or by hand, most of our vegetation burns when ignited. In the spring and summer of 2002 over 130 000 hectares of heath, dry sclerophyll forest and wet sclerophyll forest burned, but new life emerged from the ashes as seedlings and old plants re-established. Single fires are part of a long-term fire regime that shapes the pattern and process of vegetation types. The effect varies. Wet sclerophyll forests and grassy woodlands are dominated by species that resprout after burning, whereas the rocky outcrops and dry sclerophyll include many species that are killed by fire.14 Fire intensity and season can both be important. Moderately intense fires in spring are more effective than lighter ones in autumn.15 Fire frequency is perhaps even more significant. Fires that are too frequent reduce species richness in all vegetation types, but on the other hand many years without fire can lead to the senescence and dwindling of some species. Preliminary fire-regime ‘thresholds’ are being established for the major vegetation types on the Tableland and we now know that in most communities biodiversity depends on burning at intervals of five years or more. The mosaic of vegetation across New England has been termed a ‘variegated landscape’.16 This pattern is caused, not only by complex environments (geology, soils, topography and climate), but also by the imprint of agriculture and dieback. Eucalypt woodlands and forests have been removed or thinned to promote palatable native grasses and improved pasture (see Chapter 6). The resulting man-made grasslands and woodlands form a continuum of vegetation ranging from introduced pastures through to grassy woodlands that are predominantly native. Cultivation and the addition of fertilisers have caused major shifts in the composition and diversity of native vegetation. Long-term grazing of native pastures leads to reduced diversity because of the selective removal of ferns, forbs, shrubs and climbers.17 Kangaroo Grass (Themeda australis), Native Sorghum (Sorghum leiocladum) and Snow Grass (Poa sieberiana) initially gave way to Wallaby Grass (Austrodanthonia spp.) and Spear Grass (Austrostipa spp.). More recently, graziers have been concerned to find that, because of overgrazing or frequent burning, these are being replaced in turn by the less palatable Wiregrass (Aristida ramosa) and Redgrass (Bothriochloa macra).18 However, much herbaceous understorey can still be found in lightly grazed and unfertilised places, such as roadside verges, backblocks and stockroutes.19 The herbaceous layer is moderately resilient to some forms of grazing, but shrubs and trees eaten by stock cannot always replace themselves, even when the animals are moved away. The natural opportunities for tree and shrub recruitment are rare. It needs warm summer temperatures, above average
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 66
7/12/06 5:08:04 PM
The Vegetated Landscape rainfall, soil disturbance and sometimes fire.20 Seed, whether from canopies or from the soil, also needs the right conditions. The availability of naturally occurring seed is one of the major drivers of woody plant recruitment for the Tableland. Unfortunately, there are very low levels of such seed. Even under optimal conditions, regeneration of trees and shrubs is now very rare on New England’s grassy woodlands.21
67
C O N S E RVAT I O N
Much research remains to be done on the current state of vegetation on the Tableland. Of the major vegetation types defined at a statewide level we know that fifteen are found here, and the pre-European extent of these has been modelled to measure loss and conservation protection.22 Within these fifteen main types, many (perhaps more than 70) plant communities have been described, including the 25 granite outcrop communities mentioned above.23 We have a comprehensive survey and map of the Guyra 1:100 000 Map Sheet, and smaller scale maps, mostly 1: 25 000, have been produced for conservation reserves.24 But vegetation on other public and on private lands remains largely unmapped and no overall synthesis has been attempted. So it is difficult to assess conservation status at the plant community level. More broadly, however, the statistics are stark, with approximately 60 per cent of the landscape being cleared of woody vegetation. There are now no large (more than 1000 hectares) areas of grassy woodland left in the bioregion.25 There are no natural grassland reserves and only a few of the montane lakes are managed for biodiversity conservation. Most at risk perhaps are the Sphagnum peatlands, with only a handful of sites remaining intact and mostly unprotected from grazing, clearing and drainage. Whether trees, shrubs and the herbaceous layer can survive and replace themselves in the variegated New England landscape is now a critical question. Some forests, woodlands, heaths and wetlands remain close to their native state and can look after themselves, as long as they remain safe from frequent fires, grazing by feral animals and invasive plant species. But some remnants are small and isolated, with loss of connectivity preventing species from migrating from one to the other. Climate change may also threaten migration pathways. Vegetation which has been altered to make way for agriculture offers a more complicated challenge. But there is growing awareness of the importance of native vegetation and of the need to manage some of it for sustainable production, as well as for conservation. Conservation management will eventually go beyond the immediate issues of saving representative samples of vegetation types. The urge to clear is already abating and attention is being focused upon re-vegetation and management of remnants on farms, especially after the shock of dieback (see Chapter 6). A perennial concern is how best to manage remnants, especially as boundaries with intensive agriculture are often diffuse. There is no easy remedy, but fencing and the removal of feral animals, control of weeds and management of stock are starting points.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 67
7/12/06 5:08:05 PM
High Lean Country 68
Pasture management has long focused on maintaining and improving feed suitable for livestock. Some of this focus must now be shifted to the retention of all native plants on the Tableland, not just the ones palatable to stock. What we manage today is the result of a long evolutionary history. It is up to us to ensure that the vegetation of the New England Tableland also has a future.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 68
7/12/06 5:08:05 PM
CHAPTER 6 ❈
L a n d a n d L i velih o o d Ni ck Re i d and Le w i s K a h n
The biophysical environment of any region dictates the use of resources, but resource use in turn affects the biophysical environment. In this chapter we explore that process for New England. In broad terms, this is an account of pastoralism. Temperate pastures for livestock grazing, high rainfall and mild temperatures first attracted Europeans to New England in the 1830s and 40s, and pastoral land use dominates the region today. There have been significant changes all the same. By the late nineteenth century, increased population and changes in the tenure and administration of land meant that parts of the region had been more closely settled by smallholders, depending on crops. And again, the advent of aerial fertilisation and reliable machinery for sowing pasture in the mid-twentieth century meant that livestock production reached a much more intensified level than hitherto. Soils and topography combine to form a mosaic of primary production zones across the New England landscape. Other things being equal, upper slopes have shallower soils and a dry micro-climate because of exposure and the continual downhill movement of water and other matter. Lower slopes and valley floors receive more water, soil and nutrients, creating deeper, more fertile and more finely textured soils, which hold water better and are altogether more productive. Also, floodplains benefit from periodic accessions of silt, clay and organic matter, and sometimes have underlying aquifers within reach of tree roots. Poorer country, including most of the coarse granite and acid volcanic landscapes, are suitable for the growth of fine wool (from wethers) and timber. In basalt landscapes and valley floors, meat production (beef and fat lambs), forage
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 69
7/12/06 5:08:05 PM
High Lean Country 70
❈ Drenching sheep at Spring Hill, near Bingara, in about 1900. (photo: A. McLennan)
crops, hay and vegetables do well. These examples of land uses are typical of central New England. Varying temperature and rainfall mean that productive potential declines to the west and increases to the east. Grazing happens across all soil types but, apart from small areas of fodder, profitable crops (potatoes, for instance) depend on basalt-derived soils and alluvial soils in valley floors. G R A Z I N G A N D FA R M I N G
Today, the perennial grass base of New England pastures distinguishes the region from other parts of southern temperate Australia, where native perennial grasses have largely been replaced by introduced annual grasses. The native perennial grasses cope well with droughts, erosion, weeds and acid soils, but the varieties have changed under the impact of grazing. Tussock grasses such as Kangaroo Grass (Themeda australis), Barbed-wire Grass (Cymbopogon refractus) and Wild Sorghum (Sorghum leiocladum) have given way to more grazingtolerant species, such as Paddock Lovegrass (Eragrostis leptostachya), Parramatta Grass (Sporobolus creber), Wallaby Grass (Austrodanthonia spp.) and Redgrass (Bothriochloa macra). The usefulness of perennial grasses depends on management. The layout and size of paddocks, artificial fertilising and grazing patterns all make a considerable difference. But the use of superphosphate fertiliser, containing phosphorus, sulphur and calcium, has caused the most dramatic changes in New England. The sowing of exotic legumes and grasses in conjunction with superphosphate began in the 1930s, and aerial spreading was widespread by the 1960s.1 The benefits of rotating livestock from paddock to paddock according to plans that
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 70
7/12/06 5:08:06 PM
Land and Livelihood take account of the needs of both animals and plants have been proven only recently, with stocking rate increasing by 22 per cent, annual pasture production by 40 per cent and water-use efficiency by 45 per cent. Worm infections in Merino lambs at weaning are even more dramatically decreased.2 Improved pasture productivity and nutritional quality in turn allow for the more reliable breeding of both sheep and cattle. Various forms of agriculture, including pastoralism, now account for 69 per cent of the region. The great majority of enterprises are sheep and cattle, with beef cattle properties outnumbering sheep, except around Guyra and Uralla. In 2001, the region supported about 685 000 cattle and calves and 3 815 000 sheep and lambs, and produced 13 924 tonnes of wool, or 2 per cent of the national output. A recent survey of 356 woolgrowers in southern New England showed that half are essentially ‘range managers’ with larger properties (1380 hectares, on average), a high dependence on wool income (shearing an average of 4355 sheep each year) and a good deal of native pasture and bushland. A quarter are ‘meat producers’, depending on income from lamb and beef, with large (64 per cent of the farm) areas of sown pasture. A minority (9 per cent) are ‘high input wool producers’, managing mostly sown pastures (averaging 83 per cent of their land) and shearing large flocks (on average, 7300 head). The rest are the ‘lifestylers’ (17 per cent), who depend on off-farm income and whose properties (522 hectares on average) are largely native pasture and bush.3
71
❈ Deeargee woolshed, near Uralla, one of the largest sheds in Australia. Built by A.A. Dangar in about 1869, its unusual design, with glass ventilators set high in the roof, is proof of the kind of ingenuity often applied to life on the land. (photo: I. Davidson)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 71
7/12/06 5:08:07 PM
High Lean Country 72
Pasture production in New England depends very much on climate, and the region supports both cool-season and warm-season pasture species. Coolseason species, which peak during November, include all the legumes (Trifolium and Medicago spp.); introduced annual grasses such as Oats (Avena sativa) and Brome grasses (Bromus spp.); introduced sown grasses such as Perennial Ryegrass (Lolium perenne), Fescue (Festuca arundinacea) and Phalaris (Phalaris aquatica); native annual grasses such as Blown Grass (Lachnagrostis filiformis); and native perennial grasses such as Wallaby Grass (Austrodanthonia spp.), Wheat Grass (Elymus scaber) and Weeping Rice Grass (Microlaena stipoides). Warm-season pasture species, which peak in January, include introduced perennial grasses such as Paspalum (Paspalum dilatatum) and native perennial grasses such as Paddock Lovegrass, Parramatta Grass, Redgrass and Wild Sorghum. In fact, most pasture swards are a mix of cool- and warm-season, and of native and introduced species. The Tableland’s wetlands and swamps reduce the grazing area for sheep because they harbour parasitic liver-fluke (Fasciola hepatica). Liver-fluke infections weaken the animals and can result in death from loss of blood. Adult fluke live in the bile ducts of sheep and cattle and their eggs are passed in faeces. Under wet and warm conditions, the eggs hatch to release the first larvae, which invade lymnaeid snails (both native and introduced Lymnaea spp.), re-emerging as tadpole-like cercariae that encyst on vegetation and can infect grazing animals.4 Sheep usually avoid wetlands and swamps, but in dry weather and drought they are drawn to moisture, exposing themselves to infection. Dingoes are another problem. They have been exterminated from most of New England but, along with wild dogs, they still live in the rugged wilderness and forests along the eastern escarpment. In the early phases of settlement wire fences, typically two metres high and of large-gauge netting, were erected to keep them from attacking sheep. However, the fences have not always been maintained and some areas remain unfenced, so losses continue. Many landowners in the east therefore graze cattle. Where sheep are run, graziers, with the help of the National Parks and Wildlife Service and the Rural Lands Protection Boards, run baiting and trapping programs, and continue to erect new fencing. Patches of wheat, maize and vegetables were grown on New England properties from the earliest times for household use and for sale. Following the Robertson Land Acts (1861), which encouraged closer settlement, the area under crops increased but most free selectors found it hard to make a living from their allotments. Most of the region cannot sustain cultivation on a regular basis, the soils being relatively infertile, of poor structure and easily eroded because of the undulating landscape and the quantity of sodium in low-lying subsoils. The opening up of more reliable and productive farming districts to the west of the Tableland, and the advent of rail transport, bringing copious supplies of good South Australian grain, meant that in due course regular cropping ceased on most properties. The conversion of farmland to pasture has been helped by the resilience of some of the native and introduced pasture species, which
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 72
7/12/06 5:08:08 PM
Land and Livelihood readily spring up after cropping. Today, there are forage crops on small acreages and better soils, and sown pastures have been established on much of the more productive country. But in most New England shires the area cropped in 2001 was only 1–2 per cent of farm area.5 Grain production and cropping businesses are largely on the western slopes, and on the basalt soil around Glen Innes and Inverell.
73
H O RT I C U LT U R E , V I N E Y A R D S A N D T I M B E R
Temperate stone fruit ought to do well in the New England climate, but there have been problems. After World War One, soldier settlement began around Uralla and Armidale, with the settlers growing fruit for sale in Brisbane and Sydney. The project struggled from the outset because of poor planning and boron deficiencies in the soil.6 Also, after World War Two, horticultural districts were established closer to the state capitals (around Stanthorpe, for instance), and only a few of the Armidale-Uralla orchards now remain. Fruit and vegetable businesses have done better around Tenterfield, which is closer to the large markets in south-eastern Queensland, but otherwise the few enterprises across the region depend largely on local demand. Grape and wine production has emerged in a small way in recent years. Although there are frost and hail hazards, the Tableland climate is well suited to cool-climate white and red grape varieties. Just as grain crops on the Tableland failed to hold up against outside competition, so (rather later) has timber production. In the early twentieth century, there were many small sawmills scattered across the region, producing building material for nearby settlements. For instance, two mills were worked in the early 1900s on Newholme, a property near Armidale, harvesting the Stringybark on Mount Duval and selling the timber in town.7 But as transport services improved and terms of trade deteriorated, the number of mills dwindled. This decline was hastened in the 1990s as state forest was transferred to national parks, as easily won timber in publicly owned forests was exhausted and as competition increased from plantation-grown softwood and imported timber. Mills in Armidale, Glen Innes, Tenterfield and Guyra all closed during this time. There are still a number of smaller timber mills in New England, but only one large mill, Fennings, at Walcha. Most of the smaller mills produce fencing material, pallets and so on from trees on private land, whereas Fennings takes advantage of state forest to turn out large quantities of value-added, featuregrade timber products.8 About 32 per cent of the timber harvested in New England is trucked to mills on the north coast. In 2000, about 5 per cent of the region (170 000 hectares) was native forest managed by the state government for timber production, with a further 12 300 hectares of softwood timber plantations, mainly near Glen Innes and Walcha. However, a vast resource of largely unmanaged native forest exists on private land. The private timber resource is largely second-growth Stringybark, which has regenerated over the last century or more, after logging and
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 73
7/12/06 5:08:08 PM
High Lean Country 74
❈ The late nineteenth-century saw various irrigation schemes throughout Australia. The great Moree Bore (851 metres deep) was completed in 1895 and during 1900–10 supplied artesian water to this experimental farm, which grew various grain crops, plus oranges, lemons, apricots, quinces, figs, almonds and mulberries. There was a similar experimental farm at Glen Innes. (photo: unknown)
the ringbarking of old-growth forests. These forests are either unmanaged or ‘high-graded’. In other words, they are managed only by the occasional selective removal of the best trees, which over time lowers both the value of the remaining resource and the genetic stock. I M PA C T O N T H E N AT U R A L E N V I RO N M E N T
Water is essential to agriculture, horticulture and forestry, but it is hard to measure the precise impact of such activity on New England’s water resources. Detailed records of the original distribution of wetlands, water quality and aquatic life are rare. The initial impact of European settlement was obviously severe, because much of the wetlands sedimentation can be traced to that period, when large flocks of sheep were penned in small areas close to permanent water. For instance, within ten years of first settlement over a metre of sediment had been deposited in Little Llangothlin Lagoon, near Guyra.9 The need to improve pasture and reduce sheep parasites also led to the draining of swamps on valley floors, a major transformation of the environment.10 Today, the state of most New England streams is fair to poor.11 The low relief and substantial weathering of the Tableland environment promote meandering streams that are easily silted up. Vegetation in and along streams and rivers has been affected by clearing, dieback and overgrazing, while nutrient and sediment accessions to streams have probably increased (from erosion, animal excreta and
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 74
7/12/06 5:08:08 PM
Land and Livelihood fertiliser drift). In turn, shading from fringing vegetation and natural debris is likely to have declined and average water temperature increased. This would mean that the production and decomposition processes in Tableland streams now depend less on external litter inputs and invertebrate grazers, and more on algae and herbivorous invertebrates.12 This in turn means a fundamental shift in aquatic ecosystem structure and function and, ultimately, poorer water quality. Astute graziers realise that clean drinking water is important for livestock performance. Similarly, rotational grazing can be a means of controlling the damage done to streams and farm dams.13 Such changes may well lead to an overall improvement in the health of wetlands and streams. Erosion along gullies and streams is widespread. In the catchment area of the Gwydir River alone, there are 180 kilometres of moderate to severe streambank erosion. In the Uralla area there are 76 kilometres of gully erosion.14 Around Uralla and Tingha such erosion is mainly a result of the destructive way mines were worked in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.15 But elsewhere the main cause, once again, has been uncontrolled grazing, the trampling of soil and the stripping of vegetation by the water’s edge.16 Evidence of topsoil acidification resulting from tree clearing and livestock grazing has recently come to light. At Newholme, near Armidale, UNE student surveys since 1995 show a reduction of about half a pH (acidity) unit in the topsoil in going from wooded to open areas of native pasture.17 This means that the topsoil has become more acid with the loss of native trees, potentially lowering production from pasture species sensitive to acid soils. Other work has shown not only the beneficial effect of the canopies of certain eucalypt species (Eucalyptus viminalis, Eucalyptus melliodora) on topsoil pH in grazed pastures, but also the link between fertilised, commercially grazed pastures and increased topsoil acidity.18 Light tree cover may help in maintaining productive pasture soils. However, New England’s perennial pasture base and the mix of actively growing species throughout the year hinders the loss of nitrate from around pasture roots, with the result that the area suffers less from soil acidification than other parts of Australia.19 One heavily grazed and fertilised pasture on well-buffered, alluvial soils at Chiswick, between Armidale and Uralla, has been tested over 50 years for topsoil pH, with no sign of change.20 Less fertile, duplex soils on the same property have registered an increase in acidity over a 30-year time frame with the development of sown fertilised pastures. Over much of New England, ground-storey vegetation has suffered from clearing for sown pasture and cultivation, fertilising and selective grazing. Intensive management has reduced species numbers overall and changed species composition (see Chapter 5). Tree cover has not fared well either under European settlement. In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, trees were cleared from grazing country by ringbarking, with regular removal of sucker regrowth and ringbarking of saplings. John F. Campbell, a surveyor in the region between 1888 and 1903, recalled that most of the ‘pasture plants of the tableland . . . required direct sunshine for the true development of their fattening properties, hence the indifferent average carrying capacity of four acres to a sheep, as
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 75
75
7/12/06 5:08:09 PM
High Lean Country 76
estimated by the pastoralists prior to the destruction of the timber’.21 (Four acres to a sheep equals 0.6 DSE, to use the modern formula, or ‘dry sheep equivalent’ per hectare.) Ringbarking became widespread in the 1870s, as free selectors and squatters began to improve land to which they now had more secure title, thanks to the Robertson Land Acts. The Taylor family had settled at Terrible Vale, near Kentucky, in the 1840s. Today Jon Taylor tells how by the mid-1950s they had reduced tree cover to about 25 per cent of the original, largely through ringbarking and the control of regrowth.22 Pasture improvement has done even more damage to trees. Exotic pasture grasses and clovers were originally introduced in the nineteenth century. Squatters spread White Clover, Perennial Rye and Cocksfoot seed by letting it trickle from a small hole in bags tied to their saddles as they rode across their runs.23 However, the advent of aerial fertilising and extensive sown pasture development from the 1950s, together with the resulting growth in stock numbers, meant that tree populations fell out of balance with the new land-use regime. In years of high rainfall (particularly the 1950s and 1970s), defoliating insect numbers built up on the remaining eucalypts, particularly those of pasture scarab beetles, which have a soil larval phase.24 These beetles flourished because of increased nutrition for the larvae in and around pasture roots. Under natural conditions parasitic wasps (scoliids, tiphiids), parasitic flies and
❈ Dieback: eucalyptus trees dead before their time. (photo: P.J. Clarke)
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 76
7/12/06 5:08:10 PM
Land and Livelihood smaller insectivorous birds help control pests, but the nutrient content of trees standing in fertilised and sown pastures probably increased, and high stocking rates and continued clearing eliminated the forbs and shrubs that provided habitat and food for these creatures.25 The former Walcha settler, Albert Norton, reported the widespread death of eucalypts early in the 1850s, so that outbreaks of defoliating insects and widespread tree death are probably a natural phenomenon.26 However, under natural conditions, eucalypt seedlings grow up to replace dead canopy trees. Now seedlings and sucker regrowth are killed by browsing sheep (cattle do less damage to eucalypt regrowth). The result is ‘dieback’, the decline and death from the 1950s of millions of eucalypts in the more intensely developed pasture lands of the lower parts of central and southern New England. Dieback continues today, and is extending its reach as new pasture is developed. Grazing and associated light burning also affect forests along the eastern escarpment. Forest and woodland grazing leases in those areas were once managed by regular late winter and early spring burning (probably following Aboriginal example), to promote grass growth and reduce woody understorey and fuel. The usual fire return time was two to three years, but in some seasons and areas graziers burned twice a year.27 Frequent fires and cattle grazing may maintain open, grassy understoreys but they also prevent shrub development and forest regeneration, reduce diversity in ground cover, shrubs and small trees, and decrease litter cover.28 Fire and grazing have thus had more impact on the structure and composition of escarpment forests and the variety of animal life than logging. The conversion of many grazing leases to national parks over the past ten years, and the increased logging of remaining state forest to supply mill quotas, will have major, and perhaps opposite, impacts on the escarpment forests.
77
THE FUTURE
The main drivers for resource use throughout New England will continue to change rapidly. In particular, the likelihood of global warming has several implications. Increased temperature will favour warm-season pasture species at the expense of cool-season species. Under the climate experienced for the last 100 years, the annual productive potential of warm-season species has been only 63 per cent of that of cool-season species. If warm-season species now crowd out the other, more productive species, overall pasture production may decline. This trend would be reinforced by the more variable rainfall patterns that are expected to come from global warming. Also, diets in developing countries are changing as income level improves. The use of cereals and roots is declining, whereas between 1965 and 1998 meat consumption increased by 150 per cent and milk and dairy products by 60 per cent. By 2030 the consumption of livestock products of all sorts could increase by a further 44 per cent.29 If the price of wool does not rise in line with the price for sheep and beef meat, more Australian graziers will turn to meat production. However, meat (or dual-purpose sheep) production demands better nutrition for greater rates of reproduction and growth, and that means
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 77
7/12/06 5:08:11 PM
High Lean Country 78
changes in farm management to ensure better pastures. More graziers may adopt best-management practices, including periods of rest from grazing, and thereby reduce selective grazing and loss of palatable species and worm infections, while helping pasture growth. The use of fertiliser and legume species will probably change in response to climate variations. Cool-season species will probably be encouraged even more, to make up for new disadvantages to their growth. Already, the timing of fertiliser application is typically in autumn and winter to favour such species at a time of year when rain is scarce. There is room in New England for more timber plantations. Not only are extensive parts of the region suited to Radiata Pine (Pinus radiata), but recent research on native hardwoods shows that the higher-rainfall, southern and eastern zones might be used for eucalypt plantations.30 Shining Gum (Eucalyptus nitens) is the standout species, but several other eucalypts almost match it in terms of form, early growth and resistance to frost, waterlogging and insect attack. If global trading in carbon becomes a reality and native production forests continue to be transferred to the nature conservation estate, large areas of New England could eventually be given over to timber and pulpwood plantations. The consequences would be profound, particularly in the western catchment area, since most of the water for the irrigation industries in northwestern New South Wales rises in New England. Timbered landscapes retain and transpire much more rainfall than pastured catchments, so the farming and grazing communities on the plains and the whole ecology of the northern Murray-Darling Basin would be considerably affected. It is useful to think of the benefits we derive from the environment as ‘ecosystem goods and services’.31 Many such benefits, including agricultural commodities, have well-defined markets, but others do not. They include attractive, biodiverse landscapes, clean water generated from farming catchments and carbon sinks that stabilise the global climate. Some of the most vexed natural resource management issues in Australia arise from the question as to how farmers can be encouraged to continue providing ecosystem goods and services for the rest of us when there is no way of rewarding them and when they would do better commercially from other forms of production. Some farmers are prepared to be land stewards at their own expense, conserving natural resources and undertaking works for the public good. But with the best will in the world, it is not economically possible for farmers to provide all the ecosystem services now demanded by society, such as on-farm nature conservation, protection for healthy rivers or sensitive management of recharge zones to prevent salt outbreaks lower in the catchment. Mechanisms are needed to make it commercially possible for them to do so. The catchment management authorities being established across Australia will be at the forefront of developing equitable ways of balancing the public and private interest in ecosystem service provision. However, so far governments and bureaucracies have proved to be relatively poor at dealing with such complex ecological issues. Success may ultimately depend on the way the challenge is met by wider networks of interest and expertise, particularly by the agricultural industries themselves.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 78
7/12/06 5:08:12 PM
Part 2: First Peoples
❈
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 79
7/12/06 5:08:12 PM
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 80
7/12/06 5:08:12 PM
CHAPTER 7 ❈
Se e in g Re d : Mu s ing s o n Ro ck Ar t Ju ne Ro s s
The plaintive gwarr gwaaar of two foraging crows is the only sound that greets our arrival at Mt Yarrowyck Nature Reserve, half an hour’s drive west of Armidale. The pair swoop and swerve between the stringybarks, keeping a sharp eye on the activities of all who enter the area. More alert than military sentinels, the crows watch over the Aboriginal sites found on the slopes of the mountain. Like us, most visitors to the Reserve are keen to see one of the few publicly accessible examples of Aboriginal rock art on the New England Tableland. Our interest aroused by tales of totemic birds and ceremonial grounds, we take the marked track to the art site, edging along the fringes of a sandy plain, cleared for agriculture decades ago.1 The path climbs into more densely vegetated slopes at the base of the mountain whose rocky summit rises to more than 1200 metres, dominating the Gwydir River valley below. A single discarded stone tool, a small grey-green silcrete flake, provides tantalising evidence of past Aboriginal use of the region and sharpens our anticipation. The track broadens and brings us to a grassy clearing bounded by a group of massive granite boulders, their grey shapes rolled together in nature’s chance arrangement, so that their irregular forms lie balanced haphazardly on the western slope of the mountain. The granular surface of the boulders, etched by the erosive action of wind and rain over millions of years, provides an unlikely artist’s canvas. Before us, on the rounded underbelly of a boulder, nestled in an alcove, is the rock art—a frieze of red ochre motifs, glowing like warning lights against the powder grey of the substrate.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 81
7/12/06 5:08:12 PM
High Lean Country 82
❈ The tors that conceal the Mt Yarrowyck rock art are a typical geological formation in the granite country of New England. (photo: J. Ross)
Like other such assemblages on the Tableland, the rock art comprises a series of repeated motifs painted using a pigment of red ochre, and applied in thick bold lines with brush or finger. Motifs have been painted over each other in what appears to us a random composition. A small range of motifs is repeated across the rock face, with bird-like tracks the most numerous. The tracks have been arranged in scattered clusters or in vertical trails as if the birds had strutted up the sheer rock face. Enigmatic groups of short parallel lines, several rough circles, a cluster of dots and two small human-like stick figures add variety to the assemblage. The abstract nature of the motifs, where the artist has included only those aspects of the subject deemed essential to allow identification of the appearance and character of the animal (or idea), means that we can only speculate on the original meaning of the rock art. The ideas conveyed in the motifs are condensed into a sort of minimalist visual shorthand. Art historians might judge the art before us in terms of ‘the artist’s skill’ or the ‘realism of the motifs’, and with the ‘aesthetic presuppositions’ of today’s values, but these approaches to rock art seem inappropriate given the small assemblage of monochrome motifs, which lack frame, perspective or complex composition, and where a natural bush setting replaces hallowed gallery space.2 The apparently haphazard arrangement of motifs on the rock face might challenge concepts of the value of art, and the over-painting of some motifs with others might be viewed as a disrespectful disregard of earlier works.3 Art
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 82
7/12/06 5:08:13 PM
Seeing Red: Musings on Rock Art historians might rail against the difficulty of categorising the art or placing it in chronological order to be neatly labelled as an ‘ism’. Nor would they find in some dusty archive a long lost manuscript or Rosetta Stone that might contain the key to deciphering the symbols. Ethnography (written records of Aboriginal life) does not provide us with meanings for the motifs before us. Though distant descendants of those who created the paintings live in the region today, the abrupt interruption to Aboriginal traditional life resulting from the impact of nineteenth-century European settlement means that this art cannot be studied as an integral part of today’s Aboriginal culture as can similar work in some other parts of Australia.4 However, the importance of Mt Yarrowyck is recognised by today’s Aboriginal custodians, who consider the art site to provide a ‘tangible symbol of past cultural practices’, and many are actively involved in the site’s management.5 The original meanings of the art might be lost, but clues about the site and its role can be drawn from knowledge retained by the artists’ descendants. Little of past Aboriginal cultural practices and nothing of the rock art of the region was recorded by early pastoralists or by that pioneering group of explorers, religious ministers and hardy adventurers who provided so much invaluable information on customs and beliefs in other regions of the country. Without the aid of detailed ethnography or written records, and with a more functional view than that of art historians, we archaeologists look at the art mainly in the hope of discovering something of the lives of the people who painted the motifs on the rocks so long ago. Rather than viewing the art simply as an object, like a painting in a frame, as an art historian might do, we see the creation of art as a practice that results in the production of a tangible visual image. The image conveys a message to a viewing audience, provided they share an understanding of the artistic conventions the artist uses to communicate meaning.6 We can thus investigate the decisions past artists made in relation to what, how, where and when to paint, in order to help us to understand why they produced the art. Studying rock art in this way means that the clues we need are found, not only in the art itself, but also in the surrounding landscape and any artefacts found nearby, as these may provide evidence about the social context in which the art was produced. Questions spring to mind as we gaze at the art. Why are the paintings on this particular rock face and not on other boulders? How old are they? Were the motifs painted as an integral part of ceremonial rites or were they produced as part of more mundane subsistence activities? Is this an isolated example of rock art or are there similar sites secreted in other rugged corners of the Tableland? Who were these people producing paintings so long ago? Potential answers to these questions lie tangled in the art, the topography and the archaeology, waiting to be teased out. Investigation reveals that little can be established from the physical qualities of the artwork. The source of the ochre (haematite) ground to produce the pigment for the paint remains a mystery, and we cannot determine if it was traded over long distances, as in other parts of Australia, or if it was quarried
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 83
83
7/12/06 5:08:14 PM
High Lean Country 84
❈ The birds’ feet and circle shapes painted in red ochre on the granite tor. (photo: I. Davidson)
from a local source yet to be discovered.7 Complex and expensive analysis of the organic content of the pigment, which might establish the binder used in the paint, has not been undertaken because the ochre at Mt Yarrowyck has sunk deep into the substrate, as ink sinks into chalk, leaving little pigment remaining on the rock face. As a result of this fusion, the motifs have survived far longer than any produced with today’s commercial paints might do, but there is no paint residue from which to take samples. In other rock art assemblages around Australia testing has identified animal fats, saliva or plant juices as pigment binders. The damp and acidic nature of the granite soils below the art panel at Mt Yarrowyck may also have played a part in denying us evidence. Any rough brushes of chewed stick or bark used to produce the paintings would have deteriorated rapidly, as would any organic material left on the sandy surface of the overhang, leaving no trace in the dirt below. However, we can discern two distinct ochre colours among the motifs— a strong clear red and a more subdued red-orange. The variation in pigment colour suggests to us that motifs could have been added to the panel on separate occasions, a conclusion supported by the difference in the weathering of the motifs, with the underlying motifs taking on a faded appearance, which contrasts with the brighter overlying paintings. So it seems likely that artists painted at Mt Yarrowyck on several different occasions and that this was an important art site for some considerable time. We discover further evidence in support of this conclusion when a close inspection of the art panel shows that some motifs have
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 84
7/12/06 5:08:14 PM
Seeing Red: Musings on Rock Art been over-painted using the underlying motif as a template. We infer from this evidence of re-marking that some motifs also retained their significance over the period of time that people were painting at Mt Yarrowyck. Repainting, remarking or rubbing of rock art motifs was a relatively common practice among Aboriginal people in other rock art regions, especially in central Australia and the Kimberley. These practices have been tied to ritual activities that activate or reinvigorate the power believed to be contained within the motifs.8 While we have no evidence of similar ritual practices on the Tableland, we can speculate that the paintings before us have been produced as part of ceremonial activities. Keen to establish when the art had been painted, we turn our minds to issues of time. Dating of rock art has long been problematic and, while science (today’s fix-all, if television murder mysteries are to be believed) has added to the repertoire of techniques we can use, most methods require a sample of pigment large enough to test, and this, as we have discovered, is not available at Mt Yarrowyck. Further, the motifs before us, because of their abstract nature, convey no clues about the period during which they were produced, as similar work does in other areas of Australia where subjects can be used as time markers: no extinct animal species such as thylacines to invoke a deep-time dimension; no long-lost boomerang style; no recently introduced spear head; no domesticated animals such as camels or sheep; no clothed European riding on a kangaroo-like horse. However, the friable nature of the rock surface on which the art is painted would have limited the time the painting remained visible, allowing us to place the art within a broad time scale. The rock surface is exposed to the elements and would have suffered from the extremes of the New England climate. Seasonal heat, wind, rain and frost expand and contract the substrate, continually eroding away small grains from the rock’s surface and causing a gradual weathering of the motifs over time—leaving us finally, some time in the future, with a blank rock face. Although the past rate of erosion is not measurable, we can safely assume that the paintings, which remain clearly visible, are unlikely to be extremely old. Trying some less direct methods, we wonder if the results of an excavation of the deposit under the art panel, made more than a quarter of a century ago, might provide us with information on the period when people used the art site in the past.9 We might then, very tentatively, suggest that this was also the period when the paintings were produced. In 1980 two small, shallow test pits were dug into the deposit under the art, but the only charcoal recovered proved unsuitable for carbon dating, probably because of decaying action caused by damp seeping into the overhang. Casting our net further afield for even more general dating methods, we try to recall whether any similar art sites in the region have been excavated. We find that two—one in the southern area of the Tableland and another on the north-west slopes—provide some relevant information on the timing of the production of rock art in the region. At Bendemeer, to the south of Mt Yarrowyck, sandy deposits covering the base of paintings within a rockshelter contain dateable charcoal showing that the paintings at that site might
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 85
85
7/12/06 5:08:15 PM
High Lean Country 86
have been produced as much as 700 years ago. We know then, that people in the region were using art as a means of communication by that time. More tenuous evidence comes from the results of excavations at Graman, north-west of Inverell, where small fragments of red and yellow pigment were recovered, but as ochre has many uses in traditional life in addition to the production of pigment for painting rock art, we cannot reach sound conclusions from the presence of ochre alone.10 However, drawing our dating evidence together, we agree that, based on the weathering of the art surface and our knowledge of other art sites, we may reasonably suggest that the art at Mt Yarrowyck is likely to have been produced in the last 500 years or so. Although the excavations at the art site have not provided us with useful information on the dating of the motifs, they do provide evidence of another kind: evidence that allows us to envisage the way in which the site may have been used in the past.11 Only a handful of stone artefacts was recovered during the sieving of the excavated deposits. The conclusions drawn at the time of the excavation, based on the paucity of stone tools, seem plausible, and it is clear that the art site was used infrequently and even then not as a general living area. In contrast to Mt Yarrowyck, sites where people participated in traditional habitation activities are characterised by numerous and varied discarded stone artefacts used in the procurement and preparation of food and in the making of tools and wooden implements. As quantity and variety of stone tools is not evident, it would appear that people coming to Mt Yarrowyck in the past probably made short and infrequent visits to the art site. The remaining clues lie in the topography. Features of the surrounding landscape suggest logistical reasons for the paintings being found at this specific location, rather than on similar boulders further down the mountainside. A permanent spring fills a tiny, almost hidden, cola-coloured pool just a short distance below the art site. The pool, although small, would have provided a convenient and reliable source of water for humans and animals visiting the vicinity. Our brief survey of the surrounding area indicates that, in all but the wettest times, people needing a drink would otherwise have faced a considerable walk to a distant creek line. Another practical consideration that inhabitants of New England have to consider, both today and in the past, is the variable nature of the climate: freezing winter frosts, cutting autumn winds and the heat of summer. The fortuitous spatial arrangement of abutting boulders on which the art is painted provides an enclosed area with passive solar heating elements that would be the envy of many an architect bent on designing a place to ensure a client’s comfort. The irregular U-shape formed by the boulders provides a secluded place where people in the past might have gathered together, sheltered from the wind and warmed by the afternoon sun. On the other hand, the shallow dimensions of the painted overhang suggest to us that the art site would have afforded little protection from the sudden sharp thunderstorms that characterise summer rains on the Tableland. We remind ourselves that, despite the film industry’s attempts to depict all hunter–gatherers as cave dwellers, Australian ethnography
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 86
7/12/06 5:08:16 PM
Seeing Red: Musings on Rock Art indicates that Aboriginal people were unlikely to use rockshelters as permanent residences, preferring to camp on open, sandy sites. Such overhangs were more likely to be used opportunistically as temporary shelters during periodic visits. On reflection, however, there are obviously a multitude of locations throughout the Tableland where a similar combination of physical attributes coexist. Additional factors must have led artists to select Mt Yarrowyck, in particular, as a painting site. Snatches of recorded Aboriginal knowledge provide grounds for speculation. Further to the east, high peaks such as Point Lookout and The Pinnacle have mythical stories associated with them.12 Other summits such as Round Mountain, where specific knowledge of related stories appears to have been lost, still retain significance for Aboriginal people today as ‘strong’ places.13 The absence of art sites at any of these other high altitude locations prevents us from drawing any necessary link between the mythological significance of art sites and mountain summits in general. Similarly, there does not appear to be a clear patterning in the distribution of Aboriginal art sites on the Tableland that might provide us with a key to understanding the role of the rock art in past regional societies. Rather, the patterns are varied. Rock art is found in closely related site clusters at Ottley, Graman, Yetman, Gravesend, Goonoowigal, Torrington, Moonbi and Bendemeer, while in contrast, single isolated sites are dotted in what appears to be a random manner at Copeton, Guyra, Aberfoyle, Warialda, Invergowrie and other widely separated locations. Neither is there a consistent pattern in the association of rock art sites and Bora grounds on the Tableland. A Bora ground or earth circle, believed to be used as part of initiation ceremonies, was located in the valley about a kilometre to the west of the Mt Yarrowyck art site, but it was destroyed in 1959.14 The proximity of the Bora ground to the art site suggests that at one time, at least, people were coming to the mountain to perform ceremonies, but we cannot be sure that the painting activities were undertaken at that time. While there are a number of other Bora grounds associated with rock art sites on the Tableland, the two site types occur independently of each other, so that we cannot tie the two together in a neat ceremonial bundle. In reviewing what we have discovered about the rock art on the panel before us, we find that we can speculate that ancestors of today’s Aboriginal custodians probably produced the paintings some time in the last 500 years, during infrequent visits to Mt Yarrowyck. The subjects they painted and the manner in which they produced them are typical of rock art assemblages spread across the Tableland. We can further surmise that the paintings were produced during unknown ceremonial activities, which may or may not have been associated with the lost Bora ground. We can appreciate the choice of location, which would have provided both sustenance and a comfortable and congenial environment for such activities. What we can never know with any certainty is the meaning of the motifs. But, just as we can while away hours deliberating over the mysteries of a piece of contemporary abstract art, so we can enjoy pondering the mysteries of the red motifs painted on the rocks so long ago.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 87
87
7/12/06 5:08:16 PM
CHAPTER 8 ❈
Ab o rigin a l A rch aeo lo g y Wend y Be c k
The song is gone; the dance is secret with the dancers in the earth, the ritual useless, and the tribal story lost in an alien tale. Judith Wright, ‘Bora Ring’ (1946)1 Observers of New England such as the poet Judith Wright have long been attuned to the traces of past Aboriginal inhabitants through their own experience of living in the land. As these lines from Wright’s verse attest, such men and women know how to read the landscape. Along with other experienced observers, New England archaeologists, through their own fieldwork and experience, have also learnt to heed and make meaning of subtle marks such as the Bora rings. The archaeological meaning of such traces is written mostly as archaeological accounts—as ‘alien tales’—in the sense that archaeologists do not try to replicate the hunter–gatherer meaning, or the landscape’s ‘tribal story’. However, the archaeological story of New England, as it has been pieced together since the 1960s, reveals the distinctive character of Aboriginal hunter– gatherer peoples’ past inhabitation of the landscape. In this chapter, I have chosen three common elements of the regional archaeological tales—ceremonies, cold climates and group movement—and I focus on their spatial aspects, rather than on their chronology or archaeological artefacts. My aim is to build up a picture of archaeologists’ evolving construction of the regional cultural landscape. This chapter is in three parts: first a
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 88
7/12/06 5:08:17 PM
Aboriginal Archaeology 89
QUEENSLAND 0
Tweed Heads
50 Kilometres
Byron Bay
yre
t cIn
ce Claren
Ma
er Riv
COASTAL r ve
Ri
NORTHERN
ir
yd
Gw
WESTERN River
TABLELANDS ZONE Black Mt.
Bora grounds Ebor
Recorded in field survey Reported in survey
SLOPES
Recorded in the literaure
Walcha
Kempsey
Quirindi Stone arrangements Recorded in field survey Reported in survey Recorded in the literaure
❈ Bora grounds and ceremonial stone arrangements in New England
brief description of the New England landscape, its archaeological sites and the kinds of societies that shaped them; then a sketch of the regional themes established by the work of archaeologists Isabel McBryde and Luke Godwin, together spanning the 40 years or so since archaeological studies began in New England; and, finally, a description of the issues I think are important for the future of New England archaeology. Most of the archaeological evidence so far discovered in New England is thought to be, in Aboriginal terms, relatively recent, that is, dating from within the last 9000 years or so. Most of the dated sites fall within the last 5000 years, despite the fact that eastern Australia was probably occupied much earlier in time. The lack of older sites is due both to a lack of suitable preservational environments and, perhaps, to the smaller human population in the Pleistocene (before 10 000 years ago). The oldest hunter–gatherer inhabitation of the region remains unknown at the present time, but it is likely that scattered remains of earlier settlements and social networks may yet be found. The present lack of dated sites precludes a detailed understanding of changes over time, leaving us with only speculative, but perceptive, models.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 89
7/12/06 5:08:17 PM
High Lean Country 90
Between 30 000 and 10 000 years ago, available data show that the whole of the south-eastern highlands of the continent, including the New England Tableland, was much colder than it is now. The Tableland would have consisted of cold steppe grassland, with some shrubs and eucalypt woodland in protected locations (see Chapter 5). It would have been a fairly harsh environment, with few food resources. By 10 000 years ago temperatures could have been warmer by an average of two or three degrees, which may have led to an increase in tree cover. After 5000 years, it is possible that the tree cover opened out and grasslands began to develop.2 The nature and rate of specific changes in the environment is another area for further research, which could clarify both the temperature levels and the seasonal movements of people in the past. A RC H A E O L O G I S T S ’ N E W E N G L A N D
Isabel McBryde’s Aboriginal Prehistory in New England: An Archaeological Survey of North-eastern New South Wales was published in 1974.3 From 1960, McBryde had systematically recorded hundreds of archaeological sites and excavated several. This book was the first (and is still the only) study of the archaeology of the region, and was mostly written while the author was at the University of New England. Indeed, it was the first systematic archaeological study of any region in Australia. New England therefore has not only a distinctive archaeological character, but also an important place in the history of Australian archaeology—as it does in the history of Australian geology (see Chapter 2).4 McBryde defined the study area as ‘north-eastern New South Wales, from the latitude of Tamworth and Kempsey, north to the Queensland border, and from the coast westwards to the Nandewar Ranges and the western slopes of the Northern Tableland’.5 In another publication she explained that: ‘In defining our geographical area we have interpreted New England broadly . . . but conform to the bounds envisaged by the late nineteenth and twentieth century New England New State movement’.6 (For this movement and its territory, see Chapter 20.) McBryde used the terms ‘north-eastern New South Wales and ‘New England’ interchangeably. McBryde clearly understood that there were three contrasting environmental zones in the region (coast, Tableland and western slopes), but she conceived of the region in a relatively abstract way, rather than consisting, for example, of specific Aboriginal territories. The zones existed in contrast with each other, and each was perceived as including several tribal territories (in recent pre-European times, Bundjalung, Gumbaynggir, Dunghutti, Aniwan, Yugambul and Gamilaraay).7 The New England archaeological region is large enough to encompass a range of possible social organisations and individual networks. For instance, general studies of hunter–gatherer movement patterns suggest that individual exploration ranges were likely to be no more than about 300 kilometres, and distances of this scale are feasible within the region.8 McBryde never put the specific boundaries of the three zones on paper, but a version which seems to accord with her geographic categories was mapped by James Belshaw and is
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 90
7/12/06 5:08:18 PM
Aboriginal Archaeology 91
❈ Stone artefact (small blade) in the landscape near Armidale. (photo: J. Appleton)
❈ Axe grinding grooves near Armidale—the result of many years of sharpening blades of very hard stone against softer sandstone. (photo: J. Appleton)
shown on page 89.9 Later archaeologists have used similar boundaries. Thus ‘New England’ was created as an archaeological region. The most recent geographic assessment of north-eastern New South Wales divides this area into three bioregions (North Coast, New England Tableland and Nandewar), which correspond fairly closely to McBryde’s three zones. This has had implications for how the archaeology of the zones has been perceived, because each zone has to be understood and explained in the context of the others.
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 91
7/12/06 5:08:18 PM
High Lean Country 92
A RC H A E O L O G I C A L S I G N AT U R E S I N N E W E N G L A N D
Archaeological signatures are the human landscape traces left behind by previous inhabitants. They can be so subtle that untrained observers do not notice them. In New England, the signatures are archaeological objects such as stone artefacts, earth circles, grinding grooves and painted rock surfaces, each with its own spatial context. All the inhabitants of New England in the pre-1788 past were hunter–gatherers and, based on what we know of other hunter–gatherers, we can assume that they lived in relatively small groups (less than 25 people), and were self-sufficient for food and other major resources within each social territory. Larger groups of up to several hundred individuals might come together for particular social occasions, such as group hunting or ceremonial activities. Movement was not random but socially determined within environmental limits. For example, access to water was a prerequisite for journeys of any length. Labour was probably divided according to age and sex, food was shared within the family, and kin relationships were paramount. The relationship between the landscape and hunter–gatherers is now seen by archaeologists as consisting of places where people lived and worked, of tracks and pathways along which people moved between these sites, and of areas infrequently or never visited. (In this respect, Aborigines were unlike settled farmers, who tend to have plots of land with continuous boundaries, determined by houses, gardens and towns.10) There are five basic types of archaeological traces or ‘sites’ occurring in New England. Domestic sites exhibit open stone artefact scatters, isolated stone artefacts, shell middens and rock shelters with occupation deposit. Ceremonial sites include natural mythological sites and exhibit carved trees, Bora and ceremonial grounds and stone arrangements. Art sites exhibit stone engravings and rock shelters with art. Industrial sites have scarred trees, waterholes or wells, and axe grinding grooves, fish traps and quarries. Burial sites include human bones. Multiple site-types can also occur at a single place. Not all sites are preserved or visible on the surface, and not all areas are equally surveyed or sampled. Surface sites are difficult to date and may also be the result of various periods of use. All the same, analyses of these places have produced a basic archaeological knowledge of the New England region. The movement of people within the region is reflected in the nature and distribution of sites—for example, in the distribution of raw materials (such as stone for artefacts) among the sites—and in the landscape. In places where movement among areas was rapid, camp sites will be mainly along access routes, taking little account of environment and showing little re-use and little variation in type. Stone artefacts will be quickly made and discarded, irrespective of the distance from the quarry source.11 Movement in and out of the region can also be assessed from the movement of raw materials. The recording and description of archaeological sites require time and energy, and the database builds up only incrementally. In 1960, the New England database consisted of two sites, but by the end of McBryde’s fieldwork it included
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 92
7/12/06 5:08:19 PM
Aboriginal Archaeology 250 and by 1989, after the formal registration of sites was firmly established, it had expanded to 1291.12 While more recent estimates for the whole region are not available, a recent summary of site numbers in a small (about 10 per cent) cross-section of the region recorded 753 sites.13 The number of sites in the region must now be more than 7000, with many others as yet unrecorded. We still do not have a sophisticated understanding of the distribution of sites in New England, partly because of a lack of systematic regional site survey coverage. Since the 1990s most archaeological fieldwork (survey and excavation) has been the work of consultant archaeologists assessing the environmental impact of proposed development, rather than of academic researchers. Such work has not generally been incorporated into archaeological academic research because of difficulties in accessing unpublished reports. However, a recent research project has attempted to compile all site data for Gumbaynggir territory, from published and unpublished sources, and geographic modelling is underway.14 The figures are difficult to interpret, but they certainly seem to disprove the earlier idea that there is little to be discovered on the central Tableland. The need for more fieldwork is clear. McBryde discovered what are still the oldest known archaeological sites in the region.15 Her excavations on the coast revealed that the oldest known site, at Seelands rockshelter on the Clarence River, was first occupied about 6500 years ago. The oldest archaeological dates obtained for the Tableland itself are from two rockshelters at Bendemeer, the older of which was occupied from about 4300 years ago, while excavations on the western slopes, from rockshelters near Graman, revealed the oldest of all, dating from 9000 years ago.16 These dates still represent the oldest dated archaeological layers for each of the three environmental zones. All fall within the Holocene, or the period since the last Ice Age, when Aboriginal populations are thought to have been highest. The majority of sites recorded on the landscape have not been dated, but are assumed to date to within the last 3000 years or so.
93
CEREMONIES
Places of ceremony and ritual are very evocative of spiritual power. Judith Wright’s poem ‘Bora Ring’ describes the kind of memories these places hold, at least from a European perspective, and the landscape traces they leave behind: Only the grass stands up to mark the dancing-ring: the apple gums posture and mime the past corroboree, murmur a broken chant. Ray Yarry, an Aboriginal elder, has described the invisibility of New England Bora rings, in information passed on to him by his elders: They used to just tell me like where they were but they wouldn’t take me near it. It was a secret they wouldn’t even show us or wouldn’t allow us to—we could’ve been walking over it and I wouldn’t even know, see. It’s
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 93
7/12/06 5:08:20 PM
High Lean Country 94
❈ Tree carved with ritual designs, near Bingara. (photo: J. Appleton)
only just where they had it cleared years ago—real bare, but you see a lot of grass grew over it, you can’t see ’em. It’s just sort of like on that ground there, they just made a ring there, just a flat ring.17 Bora rings can be difficult to see on the ground. But an archaeologist’s perspective on landscape features, such as Bora rings, involves interpreting these features so as to understand where, when and how they occur in the landscape and how they fit into a wider pattern. McBryde mapped and recorded 80 ceremonial sites (see map on page 89), including Bora rings and stone arrangements, describing them as a ‘common archaeological feature of the region’, and they have remained a constant theme of archaeological studies.18 For example, a 1989 study of the Site Register noted that a high proportion (30 per cent) of Tableland sites were ‘ceremonial’.19 Indeed, one suggestion in the 1980s was that occupation of the Tableland at over 1000 metres altitude reflected male ceremonial use only.20 Luke Godwin has analysed the placing of ceremonial sites (defined as art sites, Bora rings, stone arrangements and carved trees) on the Tableland and western slopes, and has found that they were unusually frequent, especially on the Tableland. Out of a total of 129, 49 were clustered, with three or more within five kilometres of each other, forming six clusters in all. Godwin suggests that this clustering could be related to the regular use of these places by relatively large groups of people, compared with ‘local’ sites used by individual clans.21 In summary, ceremonial Bora rings are a distinctive part of New England archaeology and research suggests that they occur both singly and clustered together with other site types (such as art sites and stone arrangements). All seem relatively recent. We can still see some of them, circles of earth raised up to half a metre around their edges, in sites such as Tucki Tucki and Minjungbal,
High Lean Country PAGES.indd 94
7/12/06 5:08:20 PM
Aboriginal Archaeology but many more have been destroyed by white settlement. Clusters of sites may also be an expression of territorial claims to land.22 This gives us a picture of a region unusually rich in the physical traces of ceremonies, which in turn provides another kind of understanding of the way the place now called New England was once inhabited. There are very few surviving hunter–gatherer ritual monuments any