Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis Series Editor John J. Benedetto University of Maryland Editorial Advisory Board Akram Aldroubi Vanderbilt University
Douglas Cochran Arizona State University
Ingrid Daubechies Princeton University
Hans G. Feichtinger University of Vienna
Christopher Heil Georgia Institute of Technology James McClellan Georgia Institute of Technology Michael Unser Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Lausanne M. Victor Wickerhauser Washington University
Murat Kunt Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Lausanne Wim Sweldens Lucent Technologies, Bell Laboratories Martin Vetterli Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Lausanne
Ovidiu Calin Der-Chen Chang Kenro Furutani Chisato Iwasaki
Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators Methods and Techniques
Ovidiu Calin Department of Mathematics Eastern Michigan University Ypsilanti, MI 48197, USA
[email protected]
Kenro Furutani Department of Mathematics Science University of Tokyo 2641 Yamazaki, Noda Chiba 278-8510, Japan
[email protected]
Der-Chen Chang Department of Mathematics and Statistics Georgetown University Washington, DC 20057, USA
[email protected]
Chisato Iwasaki Department of Mathematical Science University of Hyogo 2167 Shosha Himeji 671-2201, Japan
[email protected]
ISBN 978-0-8176-4994-4 e-ISBN 978-0-8176-4995-1 DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 Springer New York Dordrecht Heidelberg London Library of Congress Control Number: 2010937587 Mathematics Subject Classication (2010): 22E25, 35B40, 35Q80, 35S05, 35R03, 35P10, 35K08, 35K30, 35K65, 35K05, 35F21, 35H10, 35J08, 49L99, 53B20, 53C15, 58J65, 53C17 c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011 All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, 233 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use in this publication of trade names, trademarks, service marks, and similar terms, even if they are not identified as such, is not to be taken as an expression of opinion as to whether or not they are subject to proprietary rights. Printed on acid-free paper www.birkhauser-science.com
ANHA Series Preface
The Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis (ANHA) book series aims to provide the engineering, mathematical, and scientific communities with significant developments in harmonic analysis, ranging from abstract harmonic analysis to basic applications. The title of the series reflects the importance of applications and numerical implementation, but richness and relevance of applications and implementation depend fundamentally on the structure and depth of theoretical underpinnings. Thus, from our point of view, the interleaving of theory and applications and their creative symbiotic evolution is axiomatic. Harmonic analysis is a wellspring of ideas and applicability that has flourished, developed, and deepened over time within many disciplines and by means of creative cross-fertilization with diverse areas. The intricate and fundamental relationship between harmonic analysis and fields such as signal processing, partial differential equations (PDEs), and image processing is reflected in our state-of-theart ANHA series. Our vision of modern harmonic analysis includes mathematical areas such as wavelet theory, Banach algebras, classical Fourier analysis, time-frequency analysis, and fractal geometry, as well as the diverse topics that impinge on them. For example, wavelet theory can be considered an appropriate tool to deal with some basic problems in digital signal processing, speech and image processing, geophysics, pattern recognition, biomedical engineering, and turbulence. These areas implement the latest technology from sampling methods on surfaces to fast algorithms and computer vision methods. The underlying mathematics of wavelet theory depends not only on classical Fourier analysis, but also on ideas from abstract harmonic analysis, including von Neumann algebras and the affine group. This leads to a study of the Heisenberg group and its relationship to Gabor systems, and of the metaplectic group for a meaningful interaction of signal decomposition methods. The unifying influence of wavelet theory in the aforementioned topics illustrates the justification for providing a means for centralizing and disseminating information from the broader, but still focused, area of harmonic analysis. This will be a key role of ANHA. We intend to publish with the scope and interaction that such a host of issues demands. Along with our commitment to publish mathematically significant works at the frontiers of harmonic analysis, we have a comparably strong commitment to publish v
vi
ANHA Series Preface
major advances in the following applicable topics in which harmonic analysis plays a substantial role: Antenna theory Prediction theory Biomedical signal processing Radar applications Digital signal processing Sampling theory Fast algorithms Spectral estimation Gabor theory and applications Speech processing Image processing Time-frequency and Numerical partial differential equations time-scale analysis Wavelet theory The above point of view for the ANHA book series is inspired by the history of Fourier analysis itself, whose tentacles reach into so many fields. In the last two centuries Fourier analysis has had a major impact on the development of mathematics, on the understanding of many engineering and scientific phenomena, and on the solution of some of the most important problems in mathematics and the sciences. Historically, Fourier series were developed in the analysis of some of the classical PDEs of mathematical physics; these series were used to solve such equations. In order to understand Fourier series and the kinds of solutions they could represent, some of the most basic notions of analysis were defined, e.g., the concept of “function.” Since the coefficients of Fourier series are integrals, it is no surprise that Riemann integrals were conceived to deal with uniqueness properties of trigonometric series. Cantor’s set theory was also developed because of such uniqueness questions. A basic problem in Fourier analysis is to show how complicated phenomena, such as sound waves, can be described in terms of elementary harmonics. There are two aspects of this problem: first, to find, or even define properly, the harmonics or spectrum of a given phenomenon, e.g., the spectroscopy problem in optics; second, to determine which phenomena can be constructed from given classes of harmonics, as done, for example, by the mechanical synthesizers in tidal analysis. Fourier analysis is also the natural setting for many other problems in engineering, mathematics, and the sciences. For example, Wiener’s Tauberian theorem in Fourier analysis not only characterizes the behavior of the prime numbers, but also provides the proper notion of spectrum for phenomena such as white light; this latter process leads to the Fourier analysis associated with correlation functions in filtering and prediction problems, and these problems, in turn, deal naturally with Hardy spaces in the theory of complex variables. Nowadays, some of the theory of PDEs has given way to the study of Fourier integral operators. Problems in antenna theory are studied in terms of unimodular trigonometric polynomials. Applications of Fourier analysis abound in signal processing, whether with the fast Fourier transform (FFT), or filter design, or the adaptive modeling inherent in time-frequency-scale methods such as wavelet theory. The coherent states of mathematical physics are translated and modulated Fourier
ANHA Series Preface
vii
transforms, and these are used, in conjunction with the uncertainty principle, for dealing with signal reconstruction in communications theory. We are back to the raison d’ˆetre of the ANHA series! University of Maryland College Park
John J. Benedetto Series Editor
Preface
The Fourier transform is known as one of the most powerful and useful methods for finding fundamental solutions of operators with constant coefficients. However, in the general case this method has its own limitations. This book presents several other methods that can be used concurrently with the Fourier transform method to obtain heat kernels for elliptic and sub-elliptic operators. The text contains a large number of examples which facilitate understanding. An Overview for the Reader. The theory of parabolic operators describes the distribution of heat on a given manifold as well as evolution phenomena and diffusion processes. The solution of an initial value problem for a parabolic partial differential equation depends on its heat kernel, which is the fundamental solution of the associated parabolic operator. Hence the importance of finding explicit formulas for these kernels. This monograph presents several theories for finding explicit formulas for heat kernels for both elliptic and sub-elliptic operators. These methods are treated in distinct chapters. We shall find heat kernels for classical operators by several different methods. Some methods come from stochastic processes, others come from quantum physics, and others are purely mathematical. Depending on the symmetry, geometry and ellipticity, some methods are more suited for certain operators rather than others. This book is a perfect reference material for graduate students, researchers in pure and applied mathematics as well as theoretical physicists interested in understanding different ways of approaching evolution operators. Scientific Outline. Heat kernels arise naturally from probabilistic properties of stochastic processes. The transition density of a stochastic process provides the heat kernel for the associated generator operator, which is a second-order PDE operator. For instance, the generator of a Brownian motion in a plane is the operator 1 2 .@ C @2y /. On the other side, since the x- and y-components of the Brownian 2 x motion are independent, the joint transition density, given that the motion starts at .x0 ; y0 / at t D 0, is the product of two transition densities: .xx0 /2 .xx0 /2 1 1 1 1 Œ.xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 e 2t e 2t p e 2t p D ; 2 t 2 t 2 t
which is the heat kernel for the aforementioned generator operator. ix
x
Preface
One of the large classes of operators studied in this book is the sum-of-squares operators. These operators might be either elliptic or sub-elliptic. The methods for finding the heat kernel depend on the commutativity condition of the operators. If the operators commute, then the heat kernel is the product of the heat kernels of the operators. If the operators do not commute, then the Trotter formula applies and the heat kernel is computed using the path integral method. This method was borrowed from quantum physics, and it was used to compute propagators for the Schr¨odinger equation. This technique of path integrals was initiated by Feynman in the early 1940s. Another class of operators investigated by this book is the sum between a second partial differential operator and a smooth potential. The case of linear and quadratic potentials can be solved explicitly by the path integral method, by van Vleck’s formula, or by geometric methods that encounter classical action and volume function. Finally, they can also be solved by means of pseudo-differential operators. For instance, the aforementioned operator 12 .@2x C @2y / has a heat kernel of the type K.x0 ; y0 ; x; yI t/ D V .t/e Scl .x0 ;y0 ;x;yIt / ; where V .t/ D
1 2 t
(0.0.1)
describes the density of geodesics emerging from .x0 ; y0 /, and
Scl .x0 ; y0 ; x; yI t/ D
1 1 Œ.x x0 /2 C .y y0 /2 D dist2 .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/ 2t 2t
is the classical action on the Euclidean plane from .x0 ; y0 / to .x; y/ at time t. The key idea here is that the heat propagates mainly along the geodesics of the associated (sub-)Riemannian space. Then the heat density at a certain point in the space, which is the heat kernel of a certain operator, depends on the action along the geodesic and the density of geodesics at that point, given that all geodesics start at a given initial point. The density of geodesics is described by the volume function, which in certain special cases is given by a van Vleck determinant. This idea can be applied in general for elliptic operators to obtain locally closedform expressions for the heat kernels for certain operators. However, there are some limitations to the applicability of the method, and it depends on the nature of the potential function. The operators involving a power potential of degree greater than 2 do not in general have a closed-form solution. Geometrically speaking, this reduces to infinitely many geodesics between two points whose energies cannot be obtained in a closed-form solution in terms of the boundary points. None of the methods presented in this book can be applied to obtain exact solutions for these types of operators. For instance, the well-known problem of nonsolvability of the quartic oscillator problem is one of them. In the case of sub-elliptic operators, formula (0.0.1) no longer holds, due to the degeneracy of the operator, and another formula will take its place. This new formula will require a fiber integration along the characteristic variety (which for elliptic operators degenerate to a point). We note that pseudo-differential techniques and the path integration method do not, in general, provide easy ways of obtaining heat kernels for sub-elliptic operators.
Preface
xi
The novelty of this work is the diversity of methods aimed at computing heat kernels for elliptic and sub-elliptic operators. It is interesting that apparently distinct branches of mathematics, such as stochastic processes, differential geometry, special functions, quantum mechanics and PDEs, have all a common concept – the heat kernel. This concept unifies the aforementioned domains of mathematics, and hence deserves us dedicating our study to it. It is worth noting the relation of the material of this book with other previous books on the subject. One of the long-standing textbooks in the field is the well-known book of David Widder [111], which appeared in the mid-1970s. This treats the heat equation mainly in dimension 1, discussing boundary value problems, Green’s functions, integral transforms, theta-functions, the Huygens property, series expansions, heat polynomials, and other miscellaneous topics. Unlike the classical tract of the aforementioned reference, the present monograph covers the heat equation in several other contexts, such as geometric, stochastic, and quantic. However, the present work does not intend to replace Widder’s book, but to complement it with newer facts regarding the geometric and analytic contexts. This book contains most of the heat kernels computable by means of elementary functions. Future developments in this field can consider the possibility of closed-form expressions of heat kernels involving elliptic functions and hyperelliptic functions. These types of special functions have already appeared in the explicit computation of geodesics on certain sub-Riemannian manifolds, and we treated them in the monograph [27]. Similar types of functions also appeared in considering the heat kernel of operators with polynomial potential of degree greater than 2, one of the most famous being the “quartic oscillator” example. In general, the heat kernels of sub-elliptic operators associated with some sub-Riemannian manifolds of step larger than 2 may lead to the need for special functions. However, our present restrictive knowledge of the subject of hyperelliptic function theory indicates today’s limit of explicit computability of these types of heat kernels. The material was prepared as follows: Chaps. 1–8 were prepared by Ovidiu Calin; Chaps. 9–11 were written by Kenro Furutani, Chaps. 12–14 are attributed to Der-Chen Chang, while Chap. 15 was worked out by Chisato Iwasaki. Two of the authors (Calin and Chang) reside in the United States, while the others (Furutani and Iwasaki) live in Japan. Acknowledgments We wish to express our gratitude to Prof. Peter Greiner, who introduced us to the subject of this book. The monograph was written in 2009–2010 while the first author was on a sabbatical leave from Eastern Michigan University, and he was also partially supported by NSF Grant no. 0631541 and a fund from Tokyo University of Science during his stay there in the summer of 2009. The second author was partially supported by Hong Kong RGC Grant no. 600607, the Norwegian Research Council Research Grant no. 180275/D15 and a competitive research grant at Georgetown University. The third author was partially supported by the JSPS-grant and Grantsin-Aid for Scientific Research (C) no. 20540218, and the fourth author was partially supported by the Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research (C) no. 21540194. Finally, we would like to express our thanks to the Birkh¨auser and ANHA editors, especially to J. J. Benedetto, in making this project possible.
Tokyo, 2009
xii
Preface The chapters’ diagram
Contents
Part I Traditional Methods for Computing Heat Kernels 1
Introduction .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 1.1 Physical Significance of the Heat Equation.. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 1.2 The Fundamental Solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 1.3 The Heat Equation in Its Setting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 1.4 Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 1.5 Theta-Functions .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 1.6 Some Useful Integrals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
2
A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1 Lagrangian Mechanics .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.1 The First Variation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.2 The Second Variation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.3 Geometrical Interpretation .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.4 The Case of Riemannian Geometry . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.5 Examples of Lagrangian Dynamics . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Hamiltonian Mechanics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 The Hamilton–Jacobi Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
13 13 14 15 16 18 20 23 24
3
The Geometric Method . . . . . . P . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 Heat Kernel for L D 12 ni;j D1 aij @xi @xj . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Interpretation of the Volume Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P 3.3 The Operator L D 12 niD1 bi @2xi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 The Generalized Transport Equation.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Solving the Generalized Transport Equation . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6 The Operator L D 12 y m .@2x C @2y /, m 2 N . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.7 Heat Kernels on Curved Spaces .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.8 Heat Kernel at the Cut-Locus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.9 Heat Kernel at the Conjugate Locus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.10 Heat Kernel on the Half-Line . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.11 Heat Kernel on S 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.12 Heat Kernel on the Segment Œ0; T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
27 27 30 31 33 38 40 45 46 47 47 48 49 xiii
xiv
Contents
3.13 3.14 3.15 3.16 3.17 3.18
Heat Kernel on the Cylinder .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Operators with Potentials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Linear Potential . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Quadratic Potential.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P The Operator 12 @2xi ˙ 12 a2 jxj2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Operator L D 12 @2x C x2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
50 52 54 58 60 64
4
Commuting Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Commuting Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.1 The Operator L D 12 .@2x C @2y / . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.2 The Operator L D 12 .@2x C y@2y / . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.3 The Operator L D 12 .x@2x C y@2y /. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.4 Sum of Squares of Linear Potentials . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.5 The Operator L D 12 .x 2 C y 2 /.@2x C @2y / . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
71 71 71 72 72 72 73
5
The Fourier Transform Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1 The Algorithm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Heat Kernel for the Grushin Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Heat Kernel for @2x C x@x @y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 The Formula of Beals, Gaveau and Greiner . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 Kolmogorov Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6 The Operator 12 @2x C x@2y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P 5.7 The Generalized Grushin Operator 12 niD1 @2xi C 2jxj2 @2t . . . . . . . . . . 5.8 The Heisenberg Laplacian .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
75 75 76 77 78 80 85 85 87
6
The Eigenfunction Expansion Method .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 89 6.1 General Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 89 6.2 Mehler’s Formula and Applications.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91 6.3 Hille–Hardy’s Formula and Applications .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 6.4 Poisson’s Summation Formula and Applications . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98 6.4.1 Heat Kernel on S 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 6.4.2 Heat Kernel on the Segment Œ0; T . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .100 6.5 Legendre’s Polynomials and Applications .. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .102 6.6 Legendre Functions and Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .104
7
The Path Integral Approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .105 7.1 Introducing Path Integrals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .105 7.2 Paths Integrals via Trotter’s Formula . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .107 7.3 Formal Algorithm for Obtaining Heat Kernels .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .112 7.4 The Operator 12 @2x . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .118 7.5 The Operator 12 .@2x C @x / . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .123 7.6 Heat Kernel for L D 12 .@2x @x / . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .125 7.7 Heat Kernel for L D 12 x 2 @2x C x@x . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .126 7.8 The Hermite Operator 12 .@2x a2 x 2 / . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .126
Contents
xv
7.9
Evaluating Path Integrals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .132 7.9.1 Van Vleck’s Formula .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .132 7.9.2 Applications of van Vleck’s Formula . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .133 7.9.3 The Feynman–Kac Formula . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .138 Non-Commutativity of Sums of Squares . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .140 Path Integrals and Sub-Elliptic Operators . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .143
7.10 7.11 8
The Stochastic Analysis Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .145 8.1 Elements of Stochastic Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .145 8.2 Ito Diffusion .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .152 8.3 The Generator of an Ito Diffusion.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .154 8.4 Kolmogorov’s Backward Equation and Heat Kernel .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .156 8.5 Algorithm for Finding the Heat Kernel . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .157 8.6 Finding the Transition Density . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .159 8.7 Kolmogorov’s Forward Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .166 8.8 The Operator 12 @2x x@x . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .167 8.9 Generalized Brownian Motion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .168 8.10 Linear Noise. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .170 8.11 Geometric Brownian Motion .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .171 8.12 Mean Reverting Ornstein–Uhlenbeck Process . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .174 8.13 Bessel Operator and Bessel Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .176 8.14 Brownian Motion on a Circle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .181 8.15 An Example of a Heat Kernel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .183 8.16 A Two-Dimensional Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .185 8.17 Kolmogorov’s Operator.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .188 8.18 The Operator 12 x12 @2x2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .189 8.19 Grushin’s Operator .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .191 8.20 Squared Bessel Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .192 8.21 CIR Processes .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .193 8.22 Limitations of the Method .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .193 8.23 Operators with Potential and the Feynman–Kac Formula . . . . . . . . . .195
Part II Heat Kernel on Nilpotent Lie Groups and Nilmanifolds 9
Laplacians and Sub-Laplacians .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .201 9.1 Sub-Riemannian Structure and Heat Kernels .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .201 9.1.1 Sub-Riemannian Structure .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .201 9.1.2 Heat Kernel of the Sub-Laplacian and Laplacian .. . . . . . . . .203 9.1.3 The Volume Form . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .206 9.2 Laplacian and Sub-Laplacian on Nilpotent Lie Groups .. . . . . . . . . . . .207 9.2.1 Nilpotent Lie Groups.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .207 9.2.2 The Heisenberg Group .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .209 9.2.3 Higher-Dimensional Heisenberg Groups .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .211 9.2.4 Quaternionic Heisenberg Group .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .213 9.2.5 Heisenberg-Type Lie Algebra . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .216
xvi
Contents
9.2.6 9.2.7
Free Two-Step Nilpotent Lie Algebra .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .219 The Engel Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .220
10 Heat Kernels for Laplacians and Step-2 Sub-Laplacians . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .225 10.1 Spectral Decomposition and Heat Kernel.. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .225 10.2 Complex Hamilton–Jacobi Theory.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .229 10.2.1 Path Integrals and Integral Expression of a Heat Kernel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .230 10.2.2 A Solution of a Hamilton–Jacobi Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .232 10.2.3 The Generalized Transport Equation .. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .237 10.2.4 Heat Kernel for the Sub-Laplacian . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .244 10.2.5 Heat Kernel for Laplacian I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .251 10.2.6 Heat Kernel for Laplacian II . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .252 10.2.7 Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .255 10.3 Grushin-Type Operators and the Heat Kernel . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .263 10.3.1 Grushin-Type Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .263 10.3.2 Heisenberg Group Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .265 10.3.3 Heat Kernel of the Grushin Operator .. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .267 11 Heat Kernel for the Sub-Laplacian on the Sphere S 3 . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .273 11.1 Sub-Riemannian Structure and Sub-Laplacian on the Sphere S 3 . .273 11.1.1 S 3 in the Quaternion Number Field . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .273 11.1.2 Heat Kernel of the Sub-Laplacian on S3 . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .277 11.1.3 Spherical Grushin Operator and the Heat Kernel .. . . . . . . . .282 Part III Laguerre Calculus and the Fourier Method 12 Finding Heat Kernels Using the Laguerre Calculus . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .289 12.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .289 12.2 Laguerre Calculus. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .291 12.2.1 Twisted Convolution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .292 12.2.2 P.V. Convolution Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .293 12.2.3 Laguerre Functions .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .294 12.2.4 Laguerre Calculus on H1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .295 12.2.5 Laguerre Calculus on Hn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .296 12.2.6 Left Invariant Differential Operators . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .297 12.3 The Heisenberg Sub-Laplacian.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .300 12.4 Powers of the Sub-Laplacian .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .303 12.5 Heat Kernel for the Operator Lm ˛ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .306 12.6 Fundamental Solution of the Paneitz Operator . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .309 12.6.1 Laguerre Tensor of the Paneitz Operator ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .311 12.6.2 Fundamental Solution: The Case n 2 . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .313 12.6.3 Fundamental Solution: The Case n D 1 . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .316 12.7 Heat Kernel of the Paneitz Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .318 12.8 Projection and Relative Fundamental Solution .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .321
Contents
xvii
12.9 The Kernel ‰m .z; t/ for m > n .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .326 12.10 The Isotropic Heisenberg Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .328 12.11 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .330 13 Constructing Heat Kernels for Degenerate Elliptic Operators .. . . . . . . . .333 13.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .333 13.2 Finding Heat Kernels for Operators Lj , j D 1; : : : ; 5 .. . . . . . . . . . . . .335 13.3 Some Explicit Calculations .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .340 13.3.1 Laplace Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .341 13.3.2 Kolmogorov Operator .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .342 13.3.3 The Operator L3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .344 13.3.4 The Operator L4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .346 13.3.5 The Operator L5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .347 14 Heat Kernel for the Kohn Laplacian on the Heisenberg Group .. . . . . . . .349 14.1 The Kohn Laplacian on the Heisenberg Group .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .349 14.2 Full Fourier Transform on the Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .351 14.3 Solving the Transformed Heat Equation Using Hermite Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .353 14.4 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .358 Part IV
Pseudo-Differential Operators
15 The Pseudo-Differential Operator Technique . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .361 15.1 Basic Results of Pseudo-Differential Operators .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .361 15.1.1 Definition of Pseudo-Differential Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . .362 15.1.2 Calculus with Pseudo-Differential Operators .. . . . . . . . . . . . .363 15.1.3 Proof of Lemma 15.1.3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .366 15.2 Fundamental Solution by Symbolic Calculus: The Nondegenerate Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .372 15.3 Basic Results for Pseudo-Differential Operators of Weyl Symbols 376 15.3.1 Calculus with Pseudo-Differential Operators .. . . . . . . . . . . . .376 15.4 Fundamental Solution by Symbolic Calculus: The Degenerate Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .382 15.4.1 Construction of the Symbol.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .382 P 15.4.2 The Symbol pm D 12 `j D1 qj2 . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .396 15.4.3 The Special Case of Quadratic Symbols . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .397 15.4.4 A Key Theorem for Eigenfunction Expansion .. . . . . . . . . . . .400 15.5 The Hermite Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .400 15.5.1 Exact Form of the Symbol of the Fundamental Solution .. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .401 15.5.2 Eigenfunction Expansion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .403 15.6 The Grushin Operator.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .407 15.7 Exact Form of the Symbol of the Fundamental Solution for the Sub-Laplacian .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .408
xviii
Contents
15.8 15.9
The Sub-Laplacian on Step-2 Nilpotent Lie Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .410 The Kolmogorov Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .415
Appendix . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .417 Conclusions . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .419 List of Frequently Used Notations and Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .423 References .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .425 Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .431
Part I
Traditional Methods for Computing Heat Kernels
Chapter 1
Introduction
1.1 Physical Significance of the Heat Equation Consider the problem of finding the temperature of a gas contained in a volume V , which is supposed to be a bounded, open and connected set in R3 . Denote by u.x; t/ the gas temperature at the point x 2 V at time t. Let be a subdomain of V with smooth boundary @. Let be the unit normal to @; see Fig. 1.1a. In order to write the equation of temperature evolution, we shall consider the law of conservation of thermal energy on the domain , under the assumption that there is no external absorption or application of heat: The rate of change of the energy with respect to time in is equal to the net flow of energy across the boundary @. The total thermal energy (heat) in at time t is Z U.t/ D
u.x; t/ dx;
(1.1.1)
and the net flow of energy across the boundary is given by the Fourier law Z Q.t/ D @
@u.x; t/ d; @
where d is the area element on @. The normal derivative @u.x; t/ D hrx u.x; t/; .x/i; @
x 2 @;
is the flux density normal to the boundary @. If x 2 @, the only gas particles in a small neighborhood U of x that hit @ are those which have a normal direction to @. The other particles in U that do not have a perpendicular direction to @ do not have a contribution toward the term Q.t/, since they are colliding with other particles in U and are bouncing back: see Fig. 1.1b.
O. Calin et al., Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis, DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 1, c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
3
4
1 Introduction
a
b
Fig. 1.1 .a/ The domain and its normal . .b/ The particles which do not have normal direction do not contribute to the heat exchanged through @
Applying Gauss’s formula, the heat changed through the boundary becomes Z
Z Q.t/ D
divrx u.x; t/ dx D
x u.x; t/ dx:
(1.1.2)
The aforementioned conservation of energy can be written as @ U.t/ D Q.t/I @t using (1.1.1) and (1.1.2), it becomes Z
@ u.x; t/ dx D @t
Z
x u.x; t/ dx:
Since is an arbitrary domain of V , it follows that @ u.x; t/ D x u.x; t/; @t
x 2 V; t 0;
which is called the heat equation for the Laplacian x on R3 . A similar approach can beapplied in the case when .V; gij / is a Riemannian manifold and ; .x1 ; : : :; xn / is a local chart on V . In this case the measure dx is p replaced by the volume element d vg D det.gij /dx1 ^ ^dxn and the divergence and the gradient are given by X @ 1 det.gij /X j ; div X D det.gij / @xi n
i D1
rx u D
X i;j
g ij
@u @ : @xj @xi
1.2 The Fundamental Solution
5
The Laplacian in this case becomes the elliptic operator LD
X
g ij
i;j
where ijk D
1 2
X `
g k`
@gi ` @xj
C
X @2 @ ijk ; @xi @xj @xk k
@gj ` @xi
@gij @x`
are the Christoffel symbols.
1.2 The Fundamental Solution Consider the following heat problem: Given two distinct points x0 ; x on a Riemannian manifold .V; g/, assume that a unit volume of heat is applied at the point x0 at time t D 0. What is the heat distribution at any time t > 0? Equivalently, what is volume of heat K.x0 ; xI t/ that transmits from x0 to x after time t? K.x0 ; xI t/ is defined on V V .0; 1/ and is called the fundamental solution of the heat operator, or the heat kernel, if it satisfies the equations @ K.x0 ; xI t/ D LK.x0 ; xI t/; @t lim K.x0 ; xI t/ D ıx0 :
x 2 V; t 0;
t &0
Since in the compact case (with no boundary) no heat is lost, the total amount of heat is preserved: Z Z K.x0 ; xI t/ dx D ıx0 .x/dx D 1: This is the reason why K.x0 ; xI t/ can be considered as a probability density function for any t > 0 for a certain random process discussed in Chap. 2. For instance, in the one-dimensional case, at t D 0 the density is the Dirac distribution ıx0 centered at x0 , while at t > 0, the distribution is Gaussian; see Fig. 1.2a, b.
a y
b y
± x0 t =0 x0
x
t>0 x0
Fig. 1.2 .a/ The Dirac distribution ıx0 . .b/ The one-dimensional Gaussian
p1 e 2 t
.xx0 /2 2t
x-
6
1 Introduction
The main use of the heat kernel is to find the temperature evolution in V , provided the initial distribution of temperature is given. For any continuous, bounded function , Cauchy’s problem @ u.x; t/ D Lu.x; t/; @t u.x; 0/ D .x/;
x 2 V; t 0;
Z
has the solution u.x; t/ D
V
K.x; yI t/.y/ d vg :
Since K.x; yI t/.y/ represents the volume of heat transmitted from y to x after time t, given the initial temperature .x/, the kernel K.x; yI t/ is sometimes also called a propagator.
1.3 The Heat Equation in Its Setting The heat equation is a particular case of a more general linear second-order partial differential equation of the type A@2x C B@x @t C C @2t C D@x C E@t C F D 0; where the coefficients A; B; C; D; E; F are functions on x and t only. The following classification is familiar from undergraduate courses on differential equations: Condition B 2 < 4AC B 2 > 4AC B 2 D 4AC
Type Elliptic Hyperbolic Parabolic
Example @2x u C @2t u D 0 @2x u @2t u D 0 @2x u @t u D 0
Name Laplace Wave Heat
The type is suggested by the corresponding conic curve defined by the principal symbol. The Laplace equation describes static equations such as minimal surfaces, gravitational potentials, electric potentials, etc., having the Riemannian geometry as its underlined geometry. The wave operators describe the propagation of mechanical, radio and electro-magnetic waves, and radiation. It is associated with a geometry of Lorentz type. The heat equation describes diffusion phenomena in classical physics, Schr¨odinger-type equations in quantum mechanics, and the Black–Scholes equation in finance. The reader can find an elementary treatment of these equations, for instance, in Folland [44].
1.5 Theta-Functions
7
1.4 Methodology The first part of this book provides several methods for computing heat kernels for both elliptic and sub-elliptic operators using the following methods:
Stochastic analysis of diffusion processes The Path integral method The Geometric method involving the action along the geodesics The Fourier transform method The eigenfunction expansion method
The stochastic analysis method associates with each Ito diffusion a generator operator. The heat kernel of this operator is given by a transition density for the associated Ito diffusion. Several methods for computing transition densities are provided. The path integral method stems from the computation of propagators in quantum mechanics and has the following approaches:
By direct computation By using Trotter’s formula By using van Vleck’s formula By using Feynman–Kac’s formula
The eigenfunction expansion is a method which can be applied as long as we are able to compute the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the operator. However, closed-form solutions can be provided only if one of the following bilinear generating formulas is used:
Mehler’s formula Hille–Hardy’s formula Poisson’s summation formula Any other bilinear generating function
The geometric method expresses the heat kernel in terms of the action and volume element. It is a method which can be applied successfully as long as we are able to find the explicit formula for the action and solve the transport equation. It can be applied for both elliptic and sub-elliptic operators.
1.5 Theta-Functions A theta-function is a special function that describes the evolution of temperature on a segment domain subject to certain boundary conditions. We shall use them in the sequel when several heat kernels will be expressed in terms of theta-functions.
8
1 Introduction
Consider the heat equation @ @2 2 D0 @t @x
(1.5.3)
on Œ0; , with constant diffusivity . There are two important boundary-type conditions which lead to several types of theta-functions. Dirichlet boundary condition. The heat is maintained at zero temperature at the endpoints at all times t: .0; t/ D .; t/ D 0: The separation-of-variables method provides the solution of (1.5.3) in the form 1 .x; t/ D 2
X
2 t
.1/n e .2nC1/
sin.2n C 1/x;
n0
also called the first theta-function. We note the temperature will decrease to zero in the long run, so limt !1 1 .x; t/ D 0. Neumann boundary condition. There is no heat exchange at the endpoints x D 0; . In this case we say the endpoints are insulated and the following condition holds at the boundary: @ @ .0; t/ D .; t/ D 0: @x @x In this case the solution of (1.5.3) is 4 .x; t/ D 1 C 2
X
.1/n e 4n
2 t
cos 2nx;
n1
called the fourth theta-function. Since the heat cannot escape the domain, in the long run the solution tends to a constant equilibrium solution. A translation of 1 and 4 with =2 in the direction of x yields two other thetafunctions: X 2 2 .x; t/ D 1 .x C =2; t/ D 2 e 4.nC1=2/ t cos.2n C 1/x; n0
3 .x; t/ D 4 .x C =2; t/ D 1 C 2
X
e 4n
2 t
cos 2nx:
n1
The theta-functions 1 and 2 are periodic with period 2, and the functions 3 and 4 are periodic with period .
1.5 Theta-Functions
9
A few variations of the definition of theta-functions can be found in the literature. If we let q D e 4t , then the aforementioned formulas become 1 .x; q/ D 2
X
2
.1/n q .nC1=2/ sin.2n C 1/x;
n0
2 .x; q/ D 2
X
2
q .nC1=2/ cos.2n C 1/x;
n0
3 .x; q/ D 1 C 2
X
2
q n cos 2nx;
n1
4 .x; q/ D 1 C 2
X
2
.1/n q n cos 2nx:
n1
The graphs of the theta-functions with q D 0:7 and x 2 Œ0; 12 can be seen in Fig. 1.3. In the aforementioned formulas the variable q can also be considered complex with jqj < 1. In this case, if we let q D e i , with 2 C, and I m. / > 0, we consider the notation X 2 3 .xj / D 1 C 2 e i n cos 2nx; n1
a
b
3
3
2
2
1
1 2
4
6
8
10
12
−1
−1
−2
−2
−3
−3
c
d
3.0
3.0
2.5
2.5
2.0
2.0
1.5
1.5
1.0
1.0
0.5
0.5 2
4
6
8
10
12
2
4
6
8
2
4
6
8
10
10
12
12
Fig. 1.3 The theta-functions plotted for q D 0:7: .a/ 1 .x; 0:7/, .b/ 2 .x; 0:7/, .c/ 3 .x; 0:7/ and .d/ 4 .x; 0:7/
10
1 Introduction
which is sometimes useful to be written as X 2 3 .xji / D 1 C 2 e n cos 2nx:
(1.5.4)
n1
Using Euler’s formula and the fact that sine is an odd function, we have the equivalent definition 1 X
3 .xj / D
2
q n e 2nxi D
nD1
1 X
2
e i n e 2nxi :
nD1
Similar considerations can be carried out for the other theta-functions. More properties of the theta-functions can be found in Chap. 1 of [86].
1.6 Some Useful Integrals When computing heat kernels, one often gets into integrals which can be reduced to one given by the following result. Proposition 1.6.1. We have Z
r
b2 e 4a ; a r Z 2 2 e 4a ; e ay Ci y dy D a e
ay 2 Cby
dy D
8a 2 R ; b 2 R; 8a 2 R ; 2 R:
Proof. Completing the square and using the Gaussian integral yields Z e
ay 2 Cby
dy D e
b2 4a
Z
p
e
p 2 ayb=.2 a/
(1.6.5)
dy D e
b2 4a
1 p a
Z e
R
v2
(1.6.6) 2
e v d v D r dv D
p
b2 e 4a : a
The second integral is obtained by formally replacing b by i . Next we shall present a complete proof of this result. Completing the square yields Z
e ay
2 Ci y
Z p p 2 p 2 2 ayi =.2 a/ ui =.2 a/ 4a 1 e e dy D e dyD e p du a Z 2 1 2 e z dz; (1.6.7) D p e 4a p a Im zD=.2 a/ 2
4a
Z
where I m z denotes the imaginary part of the complex number z. The integral can be brought down to an integral on the real line as follows. Since the function p 2 e z is holomorphic, its integral on the contour f.R; 0/; .R; 0/; .R; =.2 a//;
1.6 Some Useful Integrals
11
Fig. 1.4 The rectangular contour f.R; 0/;p a//; .R; 0/; .R; =.2 p .R; =.2 a//g
p 2 .R; =.2 a//g vanishes; see Fig. 1.4. Since the limit of the integral of e z on the vertical edges of the aforementioned rectangle vanishes as R ! 1, it follows that Z Z p 2 z2 e dz D e x dx D : p Im zD=.2 a/
R
Substituting in (1.6.7) yields the desired result.
Chapter 2
A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations
The Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms will be useful in the following chapters when the heat kernel will be computed using the path integral and geometric variational methods. In the following we shall present a brief overview of the variational theory needed in the sequel.
2.1 Lagrangian Mechanics In classical mechanics a moving particle is completely described at any instance of time t by its position x.t/ and its velocity x.t/. P The position x belongs to the coordinate space, which is, in general, a Riemannian manifold with the metric defined by the kinetic energy. The space of the positions and velocities .x; x/ P is called the phase space, and it is identified with the tangent bundle TM of the coordinate space M . The pair .x; x/ P is called the state of the particle. A real-valued function defined on the tangent bundle L W TM ! R is called Lagrangian. In classical mechanics the usual Lagrangian is given by the difference between the kinetic energy and the potential energy of the particle: L.x; x/ P D K.x/ P U.x/; P where K.x/ P D 12 niD1 xP i2 and U.x/ is usually a polynomial function of x. The trajectory of a particle x.t/ in the coordinate space is a curve parameterized by the time parameter t. The Lagrangian L.x; x; P t/ describes the dynamics of the particle, in the sense that the particle moves on a trajectory x.t/ such that the following action integral Z
S.x0 ; x; / D
L.x.t/; x.t/; P t/ dt
(2.1.1)
0
is locally minimized under small variations of the path x.t/. We shall investigate this problem in the next few sections.
O. Calin et al., Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis, DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 2, c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
13
14
2 A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations
2.1.1 The First Variation For our study it would be sufficient to investigate the case of Lagrangians that do not depend explicitly on time t. Let x.t/ be a smooth curve joining x0 D x.0/ and x D x./. The action along x.t/ is given by
S D S x.t/ D
Z
L x.s/; x.s/ P ds:
0
The main problem of Lagrangian formalism is formulated below: Given the fixed endpoints x0 and x, find the path x.t/ for which the functional x.t/ ! S x.t/ (a) Has a “critical point” (b) Has a minimum Customarily, this problem is approached by considering a fixed path x.t/ and a variation x .t/ D x.t/ C .t/ with fixed endpoints x .0/ D x.0/ D x0 ;
x ./ D x./ D x0 :
The vector field .t/ defined on Œ0; is an arbitrary variation vector field with homogeneous boundary conditions .0/ D ./ D 0:
(2.1.2)
Expanding S about the path x.t/ in powers of yields Z @L @L S x .t/ D S x.t/ C ; P C ; dt @xP @x 0 2 2 2 Z 2 @ L @ L @ L ; P C ; P P C 2 ; dt C O. 3 / C 2Š 0 @xP 2 @x@x P @x 2 2 2 ı S C O. 3 /; D S C ıS C 2Š The path x.t/ is a “critical point” for the action functional S x.t/ if and only if ıS D 0. Integrating by parts and using the boundary conditions (2.1.2) yields Z 0 D ıS D 0
Z @L @L d @L @L ; P C ; dt D C ; dt: @xP @x dt @xP @x 0
2.1 Lagrangian Mechanics
15
Since the vector field is arbitrary, we obtain the variational equations, which are the famous Euler–Lagrange equations @L d @L D ; dt @xP @x
(2.1.3)
where xP D .xP 1 ; : : : ; xP n / and x D .x1 ; : : : ; xn / denote the velocity and position of the particle, respectively. A solution of (2.1.3) is called a classical path and will play a central role in the rest of the book.
2.1.2 The Second Variation Assume x.t/ is a solution of the Euler–Lagrange equations; i.e., it is a classical path. If the second variation is positive definite along x.t/, i.e., P .t/i > 0; hı 2 S .t/;
8t 2 .0; /;
(2.1.4)
for any variation vector field .t/ with .0/ D ./ D 0, then the path x.t/ minimizes the action functional between x0 and x./. In order to have relation (2.1.4) satisfied, it suffices to prove that minfhı 2 S .t/; P .t/i; 8t 2 .0; /g > 0:
Let be a variation vector field for which the previous minimum is reached. Then will satisfy the Euler–Lagrange equations for the associated Lagrangian L.; / P D hı 2 S .t/; P .t/i; which are given by d dt
2
2 d @ L @2 L @2 L @2 L @ L P C 2 C P D 0; @xP 2 dt @x@xP @x @x@x P @x@xP
(2.1.5)
which is called the Jacobi equation. A solution .t/ of (2.1.5) is called a Jacobi vector field. If there is a value t1 2 .0; / such that a Jacobi vector field .t1 / D 0, then inequality (2.1.4) fails at t D t1 . A well-known result of variational calculus states that as long as the Jacobi vector field doesn’t vanish, the classical path is still minimizing the action. The classical path ceases to be a minimizer as soon as the Jacobi vector field vanishes the first time. The vanishing points of a Jacobi vector field are called conjugate points. This is equivalent to saying that the classical path is minimizing between two consecutive conjugate points and is no longer minimizing after that.
16
2 A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations
2.1.3 Geometrical Interpretation Next we shall deal with the geometrical significance of the Jacobi vector fields. Consider the classical path starting at x0 and all the neighboring, classical paths x.p; t/ starting at the same point and parameterized by their initial momenta p; this is x.p; 0/ D x0 ; see Fig. 2.1. For the time being we neglect the fixed endpoint condition at t D . The separation between two classical paths is given by x.p C ; t/ D x.p; t/ C J.p; t/ C O. 2 /; with J.p; t/ D Jij .p; t/, where Jij .p; t/ D
@xi .p; t/ ; @pj
i; j D 1; : : : ; n:
(2.1.6)
Since x.p; t/ are classical paths, the Euler–Lagrange equations are satisfied: @L d @L
D ; dt @xP r @xr
r D 1; : : : ; n:
Using the chain rule @L @xi @L @xP j @L D C @pk @xi @pk @xP j @pk @L @L P D Ji k C Jjk @xi @xP j and differentiating in the Euler–Lagrange equations yields 2 2 @L @2 L @ L @ L P d @2 L d JPi k D 0: Ji k C Ji k C dt @xP r @xP i dt @xP r @xi @xr @xi @xP r @xi @xr @xP i (2.1.7)
Fig. 2.1 The Jacobi vector field along a classical path between two conjugate points
2.1 Lagrangian Mechanics
17
A standard result of ODEs shows that the second-order-system (2.1.7) together with the following 2n2 initial conditions @xi .p; 0/ D 0; @pk @xP i .p; 0/ D ıi k ; JPik .p; 0/ D @pk Jik .p; 0/ D
has a unique solution Jij .p; t/ 6D 0, for t 2 .0; /, with > 0 small enough. Let p D x.0/ P be fixed. For any vector v D .v1 ; : : : ; vn / 6D 0, we can define the vector field .t/ D J.t/v along the classical path x.t/, by i .t/ D Ji k .t/vk . If there is a T > 0 such that .T / D 0, then det Ji k .T / D 0. The point x.T / is conjugate with x0 D x.0/, in the sense of the definition given in the previous section. This fact will be shown next. Multiplying (2.1.7) by vk and summing over k yields the equation 2 2 @ L i d @2 L d @2 L @2 L @ L i C P D 0; P C dt @xP r @xP i dt @xP r @xi @xr @xi @xP r @xi @xr @xP i which is exactly the Jacobi equation (2.1.5). The vector field .t/ becomes a Jacobi vector field. Since Ji k is nondegenerate for t 2 .0; T /, the set of Jacobi vectors forms an n-dimensional space at every point along the path x.t/. The first point where one Jacobi vector (and hence all of them) vanishes is a conjugate point with x0 . The classical path x.t/ minimizes the action as long as it does not pass through a conjugate point. In the following we shall write the matrix J , which satisfies (2.1.7), in terms of the action S . Let x0 and x be two fixed endpoints and let x.t/ be a classical path such that x.0/ D x0 and x./ D x. The momentum along x.t/ at time t is denoted by p.x0 ; xI t/. Let e x .t/ be the reverted curve defined by e x .t/ D x. t/ D x.tQ/. The curves e x .t/ and x.t/ have the same endpoints, x0 D e x ./ D x.0/ and x D e x .0/ D x./. The following relation between the momenta along the curves x.t/ and e x .t/ holds: p.x0 ; xI t/ D p.x; x0 I t/ D p.x; x0 I tQ/: Using the well-known relation
@S @x
D p along x.t/ at instances t and yields
@S.x0 ; x.t/I t/ D p.x0 ; x.t/I t/; @x.t/
@S.x0 ; xI / D p.x0 ; xI /: @x
A similar argument for the curve e x .t/ yields @S.x; x0 I tQ/ D p.x; x0 I tQ/ D p.x0 ; xI t/: @x0
18
2 A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations
Differentiating with respect to x yields @S @p.x0 ; xI t/ 1 D D : @x@x0 @x J.p; x/ This means that
@S @x i @x0k
(2.1.8)
and Ji k are inverse matrices. Since at conjugate points
det Ji k D 0, it follows that at conjugate points D D det
@S
D ˙1: @x@x0
One of the main properties of D is that it satisfies a continuity equation of the following type (see [54]): @D X @ C .xP k D/ D 0; @t @xk
(2.1.9)
k
which means that D can be interpreted as a density of paths. This fact will be useful in the future chapters that deal with path integration, van Vleck’s formula and the geometric method of computing heat kernels.
2.1.4 The Case of Riemannian Geometry P Consider the Lagrangian L.x; x/ P D 12 ni;j D1 gij .x/xP i xP j , with gij a positive definite and non-degenerate matrix at each point x 2 Rn . This Lagrangian can also be considered on the tangent bundle of an n-dimensional Riemannian manifold .M; g/. However, since we are studying local properties, we can make the simplifying assumption M D Rn . In this case the Euler–Lagrange equations become the familiar equations of geodesics xR k .t/ C
X
ijk .x.t//xP i .t/xP j .t/ D 0;
k D 1; : : : ; n:
i;j
The classical paths are called geodesics and satisfy the following local result. Theorem 2.1.1. Given a point x0 on a Riemannian manifold .M; g/, there is a neighborhood V of x0 such that for any x 2 V, there is a unique geodesic joining the points x0 and x. The aforementioned result does not necessarily hold globally for any Riemannian manifold. However, it holds on compact manifolds, and in general on metrically complete manifolds, as the Hopf–Rinov theorem states; see [79].
2.1 Lagrangian Mechanics
19
Moreover, any geodesic is locally minimizing the action functional. The distance on the Riemannian manifold .M; g/ is defined by d.A; B/ D inff`.x/ j x geodesic; x.0/ D A; x./ D Bg; where the length of x.t/ is Z `.x/ D 0
sX
gij .x.t//xP i .t/xP j .t/ dt:
i;j
The classical action in this case is given by the formula S.x0 ; xI t/ D
d 2 .x0 ; x/ : 2t
Along a geodesic we have rS D x.t/, P where r is the gradient in the metric g: g.U; rS/ D dS.U /; for any tangent vector field U ; see [24]. The Jacobi equation (2.1.5) on Riemannian manifolds takes the form .t/ R D R .t/x.t/ P x.t/; P
(2.1.10)
where R is the Riemannian curvature tensor induced by the Levi–Civita connection D: R.U; V /W D DŒU;V W ŒDU ; DV W: If the manifold has constant curvature K, then R.U; V /W D K g.W; U /V g.W; V /U : In this case, under the additional hypotheses that x.t/ is unit speed and the Jacobi vector field is normal to the geodesic x.t/, the Jacobi equation (2.1.10) can be written in the suggestive form .t/ R D K.t/;
(2.1.11)
with the initial condition .0/ D 0. Solving, we distinguish the following cases: (1) Euclidean case: K D 0, .t/ D ct, c constant. See Fig. 2.2a. (2) Elliptic case: K D k 2 > 0, .t/ D c sin.kt/. See Fig. 2.2b. (3) Hyperbolic case: K D k 2 < 0, .t/ D c sinh.kt/. See Fig. 2.2c. In cases (1) and (3) there are no conjugate points, while in case (2) there are infinitely many conjugate points to x.0/ that occur at tn D n=k, n D 1; 2; : : : :
20
2 A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations
a
b
c
Fig. 2.2 .a/ Euclidean case: K D 0; .b/ elliptic case: K > 0; .c/ hyperbolic case: K < 0
This behavior, for instance, occurs on a sphere. In general, all manifolds in situation (2) are compact. Just for the record, we include here a generalization of this case. Recall the notation for the diameter of a manifold as diam.M / D supfd.p; q/I p; q 2 M g. Theorem 2.1.2 (Myers). Let .M; g/ be a complete, connected n-dimensional Riemannian manifold. If there is a positive number k > 0 such that Ric .n 1/k 2 g;
(2.1.12)
where Ric denotes the Ricci tensor of M , then the following relations hold: (i) diam.M / =k (ii) M is compact As a special case of the previous theorem, we have Corollary 2.1.3. If .M; g/ is a complete, connected n-dimensional Riemannian manifold with constant curvature K satisfying K k 2 > 0, then (i) diam.M / =k (ii) M is compact References for Riemannian geometry and its variational methods are the books [24, 79, 94].
2.1.5 Examples of Lagrangian Dynamics In the following examples we shall assume that the initial and final positions of the particle x0 D x.0/ and x D x./ are given and we shall determine its trajectory between these endpoints.
2.1 Lagrangian Mechanics
21
Example 2.1.4 (The natural Lagrangian). Let U.x/ be a smooth potential, and consider the Lagrangian L D 12 xP 2 U.x/. The Euler–Lagrange equation is @U : (2.1.13) x.t/ R D @x Given the boundary conditions x.0/ D x0 , x./ D x, (2.1.13) might not always have a unique solution, regardless of how close the boundary points x0 and x are: see [24]. If the potential is linear or quadratic, the aforementioned boundary value equation has a unique solution, and in this case the action is well defined. The Jacobi equation for the previous Lagrangian takes the form ˇ @2 U.x/ ˇˇ .t/ R D ˇ @x 2 ˇ
.t/:
(2.1.14)
x.t /
We note that if U.x/ is linear or quadratic in x, then the previous equation becomes similar to (2.1.11). Example 2.1.5 (The free particle). If the Lagrangian is L.x; P x/ D 12 jxj P 2 D P 2 1 P j , then the variational equation (2.1.13) is x.t/ R D 0, and the trajectories are j x 2 the straight lines t x.t/ D x0 C x x0 : (2.1.15) The Jacobi equation (2.1.14) is .t/ R D 0. Using the initial conditions .0/ D 0, .0/ P D 1 yields the Jacobi vector field .t/ D t. The classical action is obtained by integrating the Lagrangian along the classical path: Z
S.x0 ; xI / D 0
.x x0 /2 1 x x0 2 dt D : 2 2
We recuperate formula (2.1.8) by taking the mixed derivative of the action @2 S 1 1 D D 6D 0: @x@x0 ./ Hence there are no conjugate points to x0 in this case. Next we shall check the continuity equation (2.1.9). We have D D 1t , xP k .t/ D
x k x0k , t
X @D @ 1 X @ @xk .vk D/ D C C @t @t t @xk n
kD1
n
kD1
and then
x k x0k t2
!
1 1 D 2 C 2 D 0: t t Example 2.1.6 (Particle in constant gravitational field). The Lagrangian describing the dynamics of a free-falling particle under the action of a constant gravitational
22
2 A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations
force is given by L.x; P x/ D 12 xP 2 kx, k > 0. The trajectory x.t/ satisfies Galileo’s equation xR D k with the solution k t k x.t/ D t 2 C .x x0 / C t C x0 : 2 2 Since the Jacobi equation is .t/ R D 0 with the Jacobi vector field .t/ D t 6D 0, for t > 0, there are no conjugate points along the trajectory. We leave the computation of the classical action as an instructive exercise to the reader. Example 2.1.7 (The linear oscillator). If L.x; P x/ D 12 xP 2 the Euler–Lagrange equation is x.t/ R D kx, with the solution
k 2 x , 2
k > 0, then
p p
sinh. kt/ x.t/ D x x0 cosh. k/ C x0 cosh. kt/: p sinh. k/
p
This represents the trajectory of a particle under an elastic force F .x/ D kx. The Jacobi equation (2.1.14) can be R D k.t/, and the Jacobi vector field pwritten as .t/ is given by .t/ D p1 sinh. kt/ 6D 0, for t > 0. Then there are no conjugate k points to x0 along the classical path x.t/. A tedious computation shows that the classical action in this case is p p
2 k p .x C x02 / cosh. k / 2xx0 : S.x0 ; xI / D 2 sinh. k / Differentiating yields p @2 S 1 k D ; p D @x@x0 .t/ sinh. k / which is (2.1.8). Example 2.1.8 (The simple pendulum). The dynamics of a unit mass pendulum bob with unit length pendulum string under the action of the gravitational force is modeled by the Lagrangian L.x; P x/ D 12 xP 2 k.1 cos x/, k > 0. Its variational equation is given by the second-order differential equation x.t/ R D k sin x that cannot be solved using elementary functions. A solution using elliptic functions can be found in [24], p. 38. In the case of small oscillations the dynamics is approximated by the linearized pendulum equation x.t/ R D kx, with the solution p p p
sin. k t/ x.t/ D x x0 cos. k / C x0 cos. k t/: p sin. k/ The Jacobi equation (2.1.14) becomes .t/ R D k.t/:
2.2 Hamiltonian Mechanics
23
p Under the standard initial conditions, the Jacobi vector field is .t/ D p1 sin. k t/. k p Hence the conjugate points to x0 will occur along x.t/ at instances tn D n= k, n D 1; 2; : : : . The classical action is p p p
2 k … fn= kg: p .x C x02 / cos. k / 2xx0 ; S.x0 ; xI / D 2 sin. k / Example 2.1.9 (Particle in a constant electric field). The Lagrangian of a particle in a one-dimensional electric potential U.x/ D k=x, x > 0, is L.x; P x/ D 12 xP 2 2 k=x, k > 0. The trajectories satisfy the equation xR D k=x , which cannot be integrated using elementary functions. The same occurs for the Jacobi equation R D
2k : x3
2.2 Hamiltonian Mechanics An alternate way of describing the dynamics of a particle is using the Hamiltonian function. A real-valued function defined on the cotangent bundle of the coordinate space T M is called a Hamiltonian function. There is an intimate relationship between the Lagrangian and the Hamiltonian associated with a moving particle. The Hamiltonian associated with a Lagrangian is obtained using Legendre’s transform H.x; p/ D p xP L.x; x; P t/; where xP is a function of the momentum p obtained by solving the equation pD
@L : @xP
(2.2.16)
For instance, if the Lagrangian L.x; x/ P D 12 xP 2 x m , then the Hamiltonian is H.x; p/ D
1 2 p C xm: 2
The procedure works vice versa, i.e., for a given Hamiltonian, the associated Lagrangian can be obtained by L.x; x; P t/ D p xP H.x; p/; with the momentum p given by (2.2.16). The dynamics of the particle is described in the cotangent space by the Hamiltonian system of equations xP D @p H; pP D @x H: A solution x.t/; p.t/ of the aforementioned system is called a bicharacteristic.
24
2 A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations
If the Hamiltonian H does not depend explicitly on the time variable t, the system is said to be conservative, because in this case the Hamiltonian evaluated along the above solutions is constant. This can be verified by using the chain rule. If x.t/; p.t/ is a bicharacteristic curve, then d P @p H D 0: H x.t/; p.t/ D x.t/ P @x H C p.t/ dt The value of the Hamiltonian evaluated along the bicharacteristic is called the total energy of the particle. This is a first integral of motion. If .x.t/; p.t// is a bicharacteristic curve, then the component x.t/ is a solution of the Euler–Lagrange equation. Conversely, if x.t/ is a solution of the Euler–Lagrange equations, then x.t/; @L .t/ is a bicharacteristic curve, called the lift of x.t/. @xP
2.3 The Hamilton–Jacobi Equation The classical action associated with the Lagrangian L.x; x; P t/ is obtained by integrating the Lagrangian along the solution of the Euler–Lagrange equation Z L x.t/; x.t/; P t dt: (2.3.17) Scl .x0 ; xI / D 0
This assumes that there is only one solution x.t/ satisfying the boundary conditions x.0/ D x0 and x./ D x. The classical action is a solution of the following Hamilton–Jacobi equation: @ Scl C H.x; @x Scl / D 0: @
(2.3.18)
Since the above equation is nonlinear, there might be more than one solution. In the case of a conservative system, if E D E.x0 ; x; / D H denotes the energy along the solution, the equation becomes @ Scl D E; @ with the solution Scl .x0 ; x; / D E.x0 ; x; / C c.x0 ; x/;
(2.3.19)
where c.x0 ; x/ D Scl .x0 ; x; 0/ is the initial condition. The action plays a very important role in the geometric methods of finding the heat kernel. To conclude our brief discussion, there are three ways of computing the action. 1. Starting from the Lagrangian. After solving the Euler–Lagrange equations, we integrate the Lagrangian along solutions using formula (2.3.17). This is a robust method and works as long as we are able to solve the Euler–Lagrange system of equations explicitly.
2.3 The Hamilton–Jacobi Equation
25
2. Solving the Hamilton–Jacobi equation. Substitute p D @x S in the expression of the Hamiltonian H and solve (2.3.18). Because it is nonlinear, there are no standard methods to solve the aforementioned equation. Depending on the problem, one may try different strategies. For instance, we can try to look for particular solutions of the type S.x; t/ D a.t/Cb.x/. Substituted in (2.3.18), the functions a.t/ and b.x/ satisfy the separable equation a0 .t/ C H.x; @x b/ D 0; so there is a constant C such that a0 .t/ D C H) a.t/ D C t C a.0/; H.x; @x b/ D C:
(2.3.20)
If the Hamiltonian H does not depend explicitly on the variable x, (2.3.20) can sometimes be reduced to an eikonal equation. For instance, if H D 12 jpj2 , then the function b.x/ satisfies j@x bj2 D C =2;
C > 0:
This equation has infinitely many solutions of the type r b.x/ D
v u n u2 X 2 .xi xi0 /2 ; jx x0 j D t C C
x0 2 Rn :
i D1
3. The conservative Hamiltonian case. If the Hamiltonian does not depend explicitly on the time parameter t, the action function is given by (2.3.19), where the energy should be expressed in terms of the endpoints x.0/ and x./. Next we shall work out an example. The aforementioned methods will be used to find the action function for the free particle case; see Example 2.1.5. Differentiating in (2.1.15) yields 1 xP D x./ x.0/ : The Lagrangian along the solution is L.x; x/ P D
1 2 jx./ x.0/j2 ; xP D 2 2 2
and using (2.3.17) we obtain the action Z
S.x0 ; xI / D 0
jx x0 j2 jx./ x.0/j2 jx./ x.0/j2 D : dt D 2 2 2 2
26
2 A Brief Introduction to the Calculus of Variations
If we try to solve the Hamilton–Jacobi equation, using @x S D p D (2.3.18) becomes
@L @xP
D x, P
@ @ 1 1 jx x0 j2 2 D0” ” S C jx.t/j P S D @ 2 @ 2 2 @ @ jx x0 j2 : SD @ @ 2 Integrating yields the aforementioned relation for the action. The reader can find more advanced topics on the calculus of variations in [6, 24, 52].
Chapter 3
The Geometric Method
This chapter deals with a construction of heat kernels from the geometric point of view. Each operator will be associated with a geometry. Investigating the geodesic flow in this geometry, one can describe the heat kernels for a large family of operators. The idea behind this method is that the heat flow propagates along the geodesics of the associated geometry. The “density” of the heat flow is described by a volume function that satisfies a transport equation which is an analog of the continuity equation from fluid dynamics. This corresponds to the density of paths given by the van Vleck determinant in the path integral approach. This method works for elliptic operators with or without potentials or linear terms. The method can be modified to work even in the case of sub-elliptic operators, as the reader will become familiar with in Chaps. 9 and 10. This method was initially applied for the Heisenberg Laplacian; see, for instance [28].
3.1 Heat Kernel for L D
1 2
Pn
i;j D1
aij @xi @xj
P Consider the elliptic differential operator L D 12 ni;j D1 aij @xi @xj . Since the matrix aij is symmetric, nondegenerate and positive definite at each point, then .Rn ; aij / becomes a Riemannian space, where .aij /1 D .aij /. The study of the geometry of this space provides a method for finding the heat kernel of the operator L. The heat kernel models the physical phenomenon of heat propagation from a point x0 to another point x within time t. The main idea is that the heat flows along the geodesics of the space .Rn ; aij / from the initial point x0 to the final point x. For the sake of simplicity, we shall assume in Theorems 3.1.1 and 3.4.3 that the Riemannian space .Rn ; aij / has the property that any two points can be joined by a unique geodesic, i.e., the space is geodesically complete, and there are no conjugate or cut points along the geodesics. This condition is always satisfied locally on a Riemannian manifold, so the aforementioned theorems provide a local expression for the heat kernels. However, in some cases, for instance in the case of spaces with negative or zero curvature, this property is globally satisfied, and hence the expression for the heat kernels is globally defined.
O. Calin et al., Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis, DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 3, c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
27
28
3 The Geometric Method
The case when the cut locus of x0 is not empty, i.e., there is more than one geodesic joining the points x0 and x, the analysis is more complicated and shall be treated separately. The geometric method described in this chapter is based on finding geodesics. Obtaining the geodesics. The geodesics of the Riemannian space .Rn ; aij / can be obtained in two ways. Consider the following Hamiltonian function obtained by taking the principal symbol of the operator L: H.x; p/ D
n 1 X aij pi pj : 2
(3.1.1)
i;j D1
One way to define the geodesics is by considering the x-component of the bicharacteristic curve that solves the Hamiltonian system xP D Hp ; pP D Hx with the boundary conditions x.0/ D x0 ;
x.t/ D x:
The solution will be a geodesic joining the points x0 and x. For a large class of ODE systems, the solution of the previous boundary value problem is unique. The alternate approach for finding the geodesics is by solving the Euler– Lagrange system for the Lagrangian associated with the Hamiltonian (3.1.1). Assuming that we were able to find the geodesic x.s/ in one way or another, we can measure its length by the formula v Z tuX u n t `.x/ D aij .x.t//x i .t/x j .t/ dtI 0
i;j D1
Denote by d.x0 ; x/ the Riemannian distance between the points x0 and x measured in the metric aij . This is the length of the shortest geodesic x.s/ which joins x0 D x.0/ with x D x.t/. This length is independent of the parameter t, in the sense that it is invariant when the geodesic changes its parameterization. One may show that the associated action is S.x0 ; xI t/ D
d 2 .x0 ; x/ I 2t
see, for instance, [24]. The aforementioned action satisfies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation @t S C H.rS / D 0I (3.1.2)
3.1 Heat Kernel for L D
1 2
Pn
i;j D1 aij @xi @xj
29
where H is the Hamiltonian (3.1.1). There is an alternate way of finding the action by integrating the Lagrangian along the geodesic Z
t
S.x0 ; xI t/ D 0
1 L x.s/; x.s/ P ds; 2
where x W Œ0; t ! Rn is the geodesic which satisfies x.0/ D x0 and x.t/ D x. There is an intimate relationship between the geometric method and the path integration technique. In Chap. 7 the previous action is called the classical action and is denoted by Scl . It will be shown that the heat kernel can be represented as a path integral by Z K.x0 ; xI t/ D
Px0 ;xIt
e S.;t / d m./ D e Scl .x0 ;xIt /
Z
e S. P0;0It
;t /
d m. /:
R We shall see that in several cases the path integral P0;0It e S. ;t / d m. / is a function of t only. In this case the heat kernel takes the friendly form K.x0 ; xI t/ D V .t/e Scl .x0 ;xIt / ;
t > 0;
(3.1.3)
so we may say that the geometric method is a particular case of the path integral method. More precisely, we have the following result. P Theorem 3.1.1. Consider the operator L D 12 ni;j D1 aij @xi @xj and assume that L.Scl / is a function of t only. If there is only one geodesic joining the points x0 and x within time t, then the heat kernel of L is given by (3.1.3), where V .t/ satisfies the following transport equation: V 0 .t/ C V .t/L.Scl / D 0;
(3.1.4)
with the initial condition Z
V .0/ D lim
t &0
1 e Scl .x;x0 I0/ dx
:
(3.1.5)
Proof. Let S D Scl .x0 ; xI t/ denote the classical action. Since @xi @xj e S D @xi e S @xj S D e S .@xi S @xj S @xi @xj S /; then L.e S / D
n 1 X aij @xi @xj e S D e S .H.rS / L.S // : 2 i;j D1
(3.1.6)
30
3 The Geometric Method
On the other hand, @t e S V .t/ D @t e S V .t/ C e S @t V .t/ D e S .@t V .t/ V .t/@t S / :
(3.1.7)
Subtracting (3.1.6) and (3.1.7) yields .@t L/ e S V .t/ D @t e S V .t/ L e S V .t/ D e S @t V C V .t/ L.S / V .t/ .@t S C H.rS // ƒ‚ … „ D0
S
De D 0;
.@t V C V .t/ L.S //
where we used the Hamilton–Jacobi equation (3.1.2) and the transport equation (3.1.4). The solution V .t/ of the transport equation is unique up to a multiplicative constant. Relation (3.1.5) is fixing this constant. The reason behind relation (3.1.5) is the normalization condition for the heat kernel Z K.x; x0 I t/ dx D 1: Remark 3.1.2. Since the differential operator L is quadratic, the term L.S / does not depend on x in the cases when the action S depends on x linearly or quadratically. Formula (3.1.3) resembles van Vleck’s formula with van Vleck’s determinant V .t/. The function V .t/ shows how the geodesics spread away from the point x0 as t increases. For this reason we shall refer to V as the volume function.
3.2 Interpretation of the Volume Function One of the well-known conservation equations in fluid dynamics is the continuity equation @ C div. vk / D 0; @t where v D .v1 ; : : : ; vn / denotes the velocity of the fluid and is the fluid density. If the fluid follows the direction of the geodesic flow of a Riemannian manifold, then the velocity of the flow is related to the action by v D rScl :
3.3 The Operator L D
1 2
Pn
2 iD1 bi @xi
31
Assuming the fluid is homogeneous, i.e., it has the same density .t/ at each point, the aforementioned equation becomes 0 .t/ C .t/divrScl D 0: Substituting V .t/ D
p
.t/, we get V 0 .t/ C V .t/LScl D 0;
where L D 12 . This is exactly the transport equation (3.1.4) in the case of the Laplace–Beltrami operator. Hence the square of the volume function describes the “density” of the geodesic flow, i.e., the way the geodesics spread away from a given geodesic. We also note the relation with the Jacobi vector field emphasized in Chap. 2. In the following we shall deal with explicit computations in a few particular cases.
3.3 The Operator L D Consider the operator L D Hamiltonian function
1 2
1 2
Pn
i D1
Pn
i D1
bi @x2 i
bi @2xi , with bi > 0 constants. Associate the 1X bi pi2 : 2 n
H.p/ D
i D1
Solving the associated Hamiltonian system xP i .s/ D bi pi ; pPi .s/ D 0; x.0/ D x0 ;
x.t/ D x;
yields xi .s/ D bi pi s C x0 D
xi xi0 s C xi0 ; t
i D 1; : : : ; n;
where x.t/ D x D .x1 ; : : : ; xn /, x.0/ D x 0 D .x10 ; : : : ; xn0 /, and the pi are constants. The associated Lagrangian is 1X 1 2 xP ; 2 bi i n
L.x; x/ P D
i D1
32
3 The Geometric Method
and the action becomes Z
t
S.x0 ; xI t/ D 0
Z t
n 1X 1 L x.s/; x.s/ P ds D 2 bi
0
i D1
xi xi0 t
2 ds
n X .xi xi0 /2 : D 2bi t i D1
Since n 1X bj @2xj LS D 2
n X .xi xi0 /2 2bi t
j D1
!
n ; 2t
D
i D1
the transport equation becomes V 0 .t/ C
n V .t/ D 0: 2t
Integrating yields
V .t/ D ct n=2 : P By Theorem 3.1.1, the heat kernel of 12 niD1 bi @2xi is K.x0 ; xI t/ D ct
n=2
Pn
e
2
i D1
.xi xi0 / 2bi t
:
The constant c is determined from the relation Z K.x0 ; xI t/ dx D 1;
(3.3.8)
Rn
by using the well-known formula Z
1
e 2
Pn
i;j D1
Mij ui uj
Rn
In our case ui D xi xi0 and Mij D grating in (3.3.8) yields Z 1D Rn
D ct
K.x0 ; xI t/ dx D ct
n=2
d u1 d un D
1 ı , bi t ij
n=2
.2/n=2 : .det M /1=2
with det M D t n .
Z e
1 2
Pn
i D1
n Y .2/n=2 n=2 D c.2/ bi 1=2 t
Qn1 n
i D1 bi
i D1
1 i D1 bi / .
2
.xi xi0 /
Rn
Qn
bi t
!1=2 :
dx1 dxn
Inte-
3.4 The Generalized Transport Equation
33
Hence n Y
c D .2/n=2
!1=2 bi
:
i D1
We have arrived at the following result. Theorem 3.3.1. Let bi > 0. Then the heat kernel of L D K.x; x0 I t/ D .2 t/
n=2
n Y
!1=2 bi
e
1 2
Pn
2 i D1 bi @xi
is given by
2
Pn
.xi xi0 /
i D1
2bi t
;
t > 0:
i D1
When bi D 1, we obtain the familiar formula for the heat kernel of the Laplacian. Corollary 3.3.2. The heat kernel for L D K.x; x0 I t/ D .2 t/
1 2
n=2
e
Pn
2 i D1 @xi
Pn
i D1
is given by 2
.xi xi0 / 2t
;
t > 0:
3.4 The Generalized Transport Equation In Theorem 3.1.1 we had assumed that L.Scl / depends on t only. In this case the transport equation (3.1.4) can easily be solved by integration. However, there are some cases when L.Scl / depends on both variables t and x. In these cases the transport equation is replaced by the generalized transport equation. This equation describes how the heat density evolves along the geodesics. We shall start with an example. One of the operators for which L.Scl / depends on both x and t is L D 12 x@2x . The following discussion applies to the domain fxI x > 0g, where the operator is elliptic. The associated Hamiltonian function is H.x; p/ D
1 2 xp : 2
The Hamiltonian system is xP D Hp D xp; 1 pP D Hx D p 2 ; 2 with boundary conditions x.0/ D x0 , x.t/ D x. First we solve for p. Integrating in the equation
pP 1 D 2 p 2
(3.4.9)
34
3 The Geometric Method
yields pD
1 ; s0 C 12 s
with s0 2 R. Substituting in the first Hamiltonian equation, we get 1 xP H) ln x.s/ D D x s0 C 12 s and hence
1 2 ds D ln s0 C s C C; 2 s0 C 12 s
Z
1 2 x.s/ D e C s0 C s : 2
It is worth noting that x.s/ > 0 for s > 0 and hence only points on the positive semiaxis can be joined by a geodesic, i.e., no heat propagates in the negative semi-axis, a fact which agrees with the domain fxI x > 0g considered before. Given the endpoints x0 ; x > 0, we shall determine the unique constants C and s0 such that x0 D x.0/ and x D x.t/. This will show that the geodesic between x0 and x within time t is unique. Setting s D 0 and s D t, we arrive at the system x0 D e C s02 ; 1 2 C s0 C t : xDe 2 The elimination method provides s0 D
t p ; 2. x=x0 1/
eC D
p 4 .x C x0 xx0 /: 2 t
(3.4.10)
The Lagrangian associated with the Hamiltonian (3.4.9) is obtained by applying the Legendre transform L.x; x/ P D p xP H D D
1 xP 2 xP xP x 2 x 2 x
1 xP 2 : 2 x
Integrating along the geodesic and using (3.4.10), we obtain the classical action Z Scl .x0 ; xI t/ D 0
D
t
1 xP 2 .s/ ds D 2 x.s/
Z
t 0
p 2 .x C x0 xx0 /: t
2 1 e C s0 C 12 s 1 ds D e C t 2 2 e C s0 C 1 s 2 2
3.4 The Generalized Transport Equation
35
A straightforward computation shows L.Scl / D
1 2 1 x0 1=2 : x@x Scl D 2 4t x
Since the function V also depends on x, the hypothesis of Theorem 3.1.1 is not satisfied, and therefore the transport equation (3.1.4) does not hold. In the following we shall find the equation satisfied by the volume function V .t; x/. This will be called the generalized transport equation. Assume the heat kernel has the form K D V .t; x/e Scl . Since @x K D e Scl .@x V V @x Scl /; @2x K D e Scl @2x V 2@x Scl @x V C V .@x Scl /2 V @2x Scl ; @t K D e Scl .@t V @t Scl V / ; we obtain 1 LK D @t K x@2x K (2 De
! !) 1 1 2 2 2 @t V V @t Scl C x.Sx / x @x V 2@x Scl @x V V @x Scl 2 2 „ ƒ‚ …
Scl
D e Scl
D0
1 2 2 @t V x @x V 2@x Scl @x V V @x Scl ; 2
where we used that Scl satisfies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation 1 @t Scl C x.Sx /2 D 0: 2 Since LK D 0 for any t > 0, it follows that V .t; x/ satisfies the following generalized transport equation: 1 @t V x @2x V 2@x Scl @x V V @2x Scl D 0: 2
(3.4.11)
An explicit computation of the coefficients of @x V and V in the above equation yields r 1 2 1 1 x0 p V D 0: (3.4.12) @t V x@x V C .2x xx0 /@x V C 2 t 4t x This equation does not have a straightforward solution. The function V should be looked for as a product between an exponential term and a modified Bessel function, as in (8.20.79), where the operator is associated with a squared Bessel process.
36
3 The Geometric Method
However, an easy explicit solution can be obtained if x0 D 0. In this particular case it is not hard to check that a solution is cx V .t; x/ D 2 ; t with c constant. In this case the classical action is Scl .0; xI t/ D 2t x. By Theorem 3.1.1, the heat kernel for 12 x@2x from the origin is K.0; xI t/ D V .t; x/e Scl D
cx 2 x e t : t2
The constant c is determined from the condition Z K.0; xI t/ dx D 1: x>0
Since integration by parts shows that Z 1 c cx 2 x e t dx D ; 2 t 4 0 it follows that c D 4. If x0 D 0, then s0 D 0, and e c D 4x=t 2 , and the geodesics joining x0 D 0 and x at time t is x.s/ D xs 2 =t 2 . Proposition 3.4.1. The heat kernel for 12 x@2x from the origin is given by K.0; xI t/ D
4x 2 x e t ; t2
t > 0; x > 0:
Proof. We have shown that 12 x@2x K D 0 for t > 0. We still need to check that lim K.0; xI t/ D ı0 in the distribution sense. For any test function , we have t &0
Z
1
lim K.0; xI t/./ D lim
t &0
K.0; xI t/.x/ dx
t &0 0
Z
1
D lim
t &0 0
Z
1
D lim
t &0 0
Z
D .0/ „0
4x 2 x 2x t e .x/ dx make u D t2 t Z 1 tu t tu 4 tu u u ue du e d u D lim 2 t 2 2 2 t &0 0 2
1
ue u d u D .0/ D ı0 ./: ƒ‚ … D1
If x0 > 0, x > 0, then the heat travels in infinitely many ways between x0 and x since it is reflected at the wall x D 0; the kernel will be given by a series in this case.
3.4 The Generalized Transport Equation
37
Remark 3.4.2. The change of variable x D r 2 transforms the operator 12 x@2x into an operator that looks just like a two-dimensional Bessel operator with a changed sign 1 2 1 2 1 @ @r : x@ D 2 x 8 r r The above calculations also hold in the general case. This is given by the following result. P Theorem 3.4.3. Consider the operator L D 12 ni;j D1 aij @xi @xj with .aij / a symmetric, non-degenerate matrix. Assume L.Scl / depends on both variables x and t. If there is a unique geodesic joining the points x0 and x within time t, then the heat kernel of L is given by K.x0 ; xI t/ D V .t; x/e Scl .x0 ;xIt / ; where V .t/ satisfies the following generalized transport equation: X aij @xi S @xj V LV C V LS D 0; @t V C
(3.4.13)
(3.4.14)
i;j
Z
with lim
t &0
V .t; x/e Scl .x;x0 It / dx D 1:
(3.4.15)
Proof. To simplify notations, we shall denote the classical action by S D Scl .x0 ; xI t/. Differentiating in (3.4.13) yields @xj @xi K D e S V @xi S @xj S C @xi @xj V V @xi @xj S .@xi S @xj V C @xi V @xj S / ; LK D e S fVH.rS / C LV V LS a.rS; rV /g ; @t K D e S f@t V V @t S g; where 1X aij @xi S @xj S; 2 X a.rS; rV / D aij @xi S @xj V: H.rS / D
Since S satisfies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation @t S C H.rS / D 0; and V satisfies the generalized transport equation (3.4.14), we get .@t L/K D e S f@t V C a.rS; rV / LV C V LS g D 0:
Remark 3.4.4. If V does not depend on x, the generalized transport equation (3.4.14) becomes the usual transport equation (3.1.4).
38
3 The Geometric Method
The first two terms of the generalized transport equation (3.4.11) can be written as a derivative along the classical path x.t/: X @V d @V @V xP k D V t; x.t/ D C C a.rV; x/ P dt @t @xk @t @V C a.rV; rS /: D @t Hence we obtain another form of the generalized transport equation, d V t; x.t/ C V LS D LV: dt
3.5 Solving the Generalized Transport Equation The generalized transport equation (3.4.14) is in general hard to solve explicitly. Its solution V .t; x/ might be represented as an integral formula rather than being an elementary function. The following computation holds in the case of an elliptic operator and uses a series expansion for t small. A parametrix expansion can also be found in [84]. We shall consider V .k/ .t; x0 ; x/ D .2 t/n=2
0 .x0 ; x/
C
1 .x0 ; x/t
CC
k .x0 ; x/t
k
;
which approximates the volume function locally for t small, as a correction to the Euclidean volume element. Then K .k/ .x0 ; xI t/ D Vk .t; x0 ; x/e Scl .x0 ;xIt / is an approximation of the heat kernel K.x0 ; xI t/ D K .k/ .x0 ; xI t/ C O.t k /; We need to solve for
m
t 0:
recursively for small t. A computation shows
n @t V .k/ D .2 t/n=2 2t
0C
n 1 2
1
n C t 2 2
2
n Ct k1 k k : 2 (3.5.16)
Since the classical action on a Riemannian manifold is related to the Riemannian distance by d 2 .x0 ; x/ ; Scl .x0 ; xI t/ D 2t then rScl D
1 rd 2 .x0 ; x/. 2t
Hence
a.rScl ; rV .k/ / D .2 t/n=2
k 1 X 2 a rd .x0 ; x/; r 2t j D0
j
t j:
(3.5.17)
3.5 Solving the Generalized Transport Equation
We also have LV
.k/
n=2
D .2 t/
39
k X
L
j .x0 ; x/ t
j
(3.5.18)
j D0
and V .k/ LScl D .2 t/n=2
k X 1 2 L d .x0 ; x/ 2t
j .x0 ; x/t
j
:
(3.5.19)
j D0
Using (3.5.16)–(3.5.19) and equating the coefficients of t j with 0 in the generalized transport equation for V .k/ , @t V .k/ C a rS; rV .k/ LV .k/ C V .k/ LS D O.t k /; yields the following system in the unknown functions 2 Ld n 2 Ld n C 2 2 Ld n C 4
Ld 2 n C 2k
0;
1; : : : :
0
C a.rd 2 ; r
0/
D 0;
1
C a.rd 2 ; r
1/
D 2L
0;
2
C a.rd 2 ; r
2/
D 2L
1;
:: :
k
D
C a.rd 2 ; r
k/
(3.5.20)
:: :
D 2L
k1 ;
together with the initial conditions j .x0 ; x0 / D 0, j D 1; : : : ; k. In general, solving the above system is as hard as solving the generalized transport equation. The system can be solved only in simple cases, as we shall see in the next example. Example 3.5.1. Let L D 12 @2x . Then d 2 .x0 ; x/ D .x x0 /2 , L d 2 .x0 ; x/ D 1, and rd 2 .x0 ; x/ D 2.x x0 /. The first equation of the above system becomes 2.x x0 / with the solution
0
1
C 2.x x0 /
with the solution 1 1 .x0 /
D 0;
(3.5.21)
D c0 , a constant. Then the second equation becomes 2
because
0 0
D
0 1
D 0;
c1 D 0; x x0
D 0. Inductively we obtain all
j
D 0, j 1.
In the following we shall discuss a few more examples.
40
3 The Geometric Method
3.6 The Operator L D 12 y m .@x2 C @y2 /, m 2 N We shall discuss the cases m D 0; 1 and 2. Case m D 0. In this case the operator is the usual two-dimensional Laplacian L D 1 2 .@ C @2y / with the heat kernel 2 x K.x0 ; xI t/ D
.xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 1 2t : e .2 t/
Case m D 1. The operator becomes L D 12 y.@2x C @2y /. We shall consider it in the domain f.x; y/I y > 0g where the operator is elliptic. The Hamiltonian function in this case is 1 (3.6.22) H D y.p12 C p22 /; 2 and the associated Lagrangian is given by LD
1 2 .xP C yP 2 /: 2y
We are interested in the geodesics and the action from .x0 ; y0 / to .x; y/ within time t. From the Hamiltonian system we have xP D Hp1 D yp1 ; yP ; y pP1 D Hx D 0 H) p1 D k constant; 1 1 pP2 D Hy D p12 C p22 : 2 2 yP D Hp2 D yp2 H) p2 D
Since the Hamiltonian function H does not depend explicitly on the parameter s, it is preserved along the solutions; i.e., there is a constant C > 0, which depends on the boundary points .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/ and t, such that H.x; y; p1 ; p2 / D
1 2 C : 2
Using the expression of the Hamiltonian (3.6.22) yields the following equation in y: yP 2 k2 C 2 D C 2: y Solving for yP yields yP 2 D C 2 y k 2 y 2 :
(3.6.23)
3.6 The Operator L D 12 y m .@2x C @2y /, m 2 N
41
Completing the above to a square, we obtain ( ) 4 2 2 1 C C y yP 2 D k 2 : 4k 4 2 k2 With the substitution u D y ( uP D k 2
2
1 C2 , 2 k2
the previous equation becomes
C2 u2 2k 2
2 )
r H) uP D ˙k
C2 u2 : 2k 2
Separating and integrating yields Z
u.s/
Z
du
s
k” 0 u2 2 2k 2k u.s/ D arcsin u.0/ ˙ ks ” arcsin C2 C2 C2 u.s/ D sin. ˙ ks/; 2k 2 u0
where
q
D˙
C2 2k 2 2
2k 2 D arcsin u.0/ : C2
Going back to the variable y, we obtain y.s/ D
1 C2 .1 C sin. ˙ ks// : 2 k2
Integrating in the first Hamiltonian equation xP D ky yields Z s x.s/ D x0 C k y 0 cos. ˙ ks/ k C2 : s D x0 C 2 k2 ˙k
(3.6.24)
(3.6.25)
Sign convention. If we choose the “plus” sign in front of k, it means that y.s/ is increasing, and hence y > y0 . If we choose the “negative” sign in front of k, it means that y.s/ is decreasing, and hence y < y0 . Relations (3.6.25) and (3.6.24) provide the equations of the geodesics. In the following we shall eliminate their trigonometric part. Rewrite the equations as k C2 1 C2 sD cos. ˙ ks/; 2 2 k ˙2 k 2 1 C2 1 C2 D sin. ˙ ks/: y.s/ 2 k2 2 k2
x.s/ x0
42
3 The Geometric Method
Summing the squares yields the following implicit equation: 2 2 k C2 1 C2 1 C4 x.s/ x0 s C y.s/ D : 2 k2 2 k2 4 k4
(3.6.26)
Making s D 0 yields 2 1 C4 1 C2 D ” y 2 k2 4 k4 C2 y0 y0 2 D 0: k Since y0 6D 0, it follows that
C2 D y0 : k2
(3.6.27)
Then (3.6.26) can be rewritten as 2 2 k 1 1 x.s/ x0 y0 s C y.s/ y0 D y02 ” 2 2 4 2 k x.s/ x0 y0 s C y.s/ y.s/ y0 D 0: 2
(3.6.28)
From (3.6.28) it follows that on the half-plane f.x; y/I y > 0g the solution y.s/ is a decreasing function of s. If by contradiction we assume that y.s/ is increasing, then 0 < y0 < y.s/ and hence y.y y0 / > 0 and (3.6.28) cannot hold. Hence the sign in front of k in formulas (3.6.24)–(3.6.25) must be negative. A particular family of geodesics is obtained when both terms of (3.6.28) vanish: k y0 s 2 x x0 s; D x0 C t y.s/ D y0 : x.s/ D x0 C
In this case the geodesics are lines and the action is S .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y0 /I t D
Z Z
t 0 t
D 0
1 P 2 / ds .x.s/ P 2 C y.s/ 2y.s/ 1 .x x0 /2 1 x x0 2 ds D : 2y0 t 2y0 t
3.6 The Operator L D 12 y m .@2x C @2y /, m 2 N
Since LS D
43
1 .x x0 /2 1 1 D ; y.@2x C @2y / 2 2y0 t 2t
the transport equation is 1 V .t/ D 0; 2t c with the solution V .t/ D t 1=2 , c a constant. Then the heat kernel between .x0 ; y0 / and .x; y0 / is given by Theorem 3.1.1: V 0 .t/ C
c 1 .xx0 /2 K .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y0 /I t D 1=2 e 2y0 t ; t Finding the constant c. Z 1D D
K dx D c t 1=2
c
Z
t 1=2
e
1 2y
0
.xx0 /2 t
t > 0:
dx
.2y0 t/1=2 D c.2y0 /1=2 H) c D
1 : .2y0 /1=2
Hence K .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y0 /I t D
2 1 .xx0 / 1 2y t 0 e ; .2y0 t/1=2
t > 0:
The general case. From the Hamiltonian equation xP D ky and y > 0, it follows that if k > 0, then x.s/ is increasing and hence x0 < x. And if k < 0, then x.s/ is decreasing and then x0 < x. Making s D t in (3.6.28), we obtain 2 k x x0 y0 t C y y y0 D 0; 2 and then solving for k, we get
kD
8 p 2 ˆ < y0 t x x0 C y.y0 y/ ;
if x > x0 I
p x x0 y.y0 y/ ;
if x < x0 :
ˆ :
2 y0 t
We note that y0 y always, since y.s/ is decreasing. Finding the action between .x0 ; y0 / and .x; y/ within time t. Since the Lagrangian along the geodesics is 1 2 1 2 2 .xP C yP 2 / D .y p1 C y 2 p22 / 2y 2y 1 1 D y.p12 C p22 / D H D C 2 ; 2 2
LD
44
3 The Geometric Method
integrating yields the action S .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/I t D
Z
t
1 2 1 C2 2 1 k t D y0 tk 2 C tD 2 2 2k 2 0 8 p 2 < y2 t x x0 C y.y0 y/ ; if x > x0 I 0 D : 2 x x py.y y/2 ; if x < x : 0 0 0 y0 t LD
Since LS D 12 y.@2x C @2y /S depends on t, x and y, the heat kernel is given in this case by Theorem 3.4.3: 8 2 p ˆ 2 xx0 C y.y0 y/ ; if x > x0 I < V .t; x; y/e y0 t K .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/I y D 2 p ˆ : 2 xx0 y.y0 y/ V .t; x; y/e y0 t ; if x < x0 ; where V .t; x; y/ satisfies the generalized transport equation (3.4.14). Case m D 2. The operator becomes L D 12 y 2 .@2x C @2y /, which is the Laplace– Beltrami operator on the upperhalf-plane U D f.x; y/I y > 0g, with the metric ds2 D y12 .dx2 C dy 2 /. The Hamiltonian function is H D
1 2 2 y .p1 C p22 /; 2
(3.6.29)
with the associated Lagrangian Any two points of U can be joined by a unique geodesic, which is either a vertical radius or a half-circle perpendicular on the line fy D 0g. Hence, by Theorem 3.4.3, the heat kernel can be represented as a product Scl .x0 ;y0 /;.x;y/It : (3.6.30) K .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/I t D V .t; x; y/e Let dh denote the hyperbolic distance on the upperhalf-plane. If the points A.x0 ; y0 / and B.x; y/ belong to the same vertical line, then the distance between them is ˇ AM ˇ ˇ y ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ 0ˇ ˇ ˇ dh .A; B/ D ˇ ln ˇ D ˇ ln ˇ D ˇ ln y ln y0 ˇI BM y see Fig. 3.1a. Otherwise, ˇ BN=BM ˇ ˇ A0 M NB 0 ˇ ˇ .K x C r/.x K C r/ ˇ 0 ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ dh .A; B/ D ˇ ln ˇ D ˇ ln ˇ; ˇ D ˇ ln AN=AM AA0 BB 0 y0 y where r 2 D y02 C .K x0 /2 ; KD
1 .x x0 /2 C y 2 y02 I 2 x x0
3.7 Heat Kernels on Curved Spaces
a
45
b A(xo,yo ) B(x,y)
N(-r,0)
A(xo,0)
O(K,0)
B (x,0)
M(r,0)
Fig. 3.1 The hyperbolic distance dh .A; B/. (a) The case when A and B are on a vertical direction; (b) A and B are on a non-vertical direction
see Fig. 3.1b. Since dh is the associated Riemannian distance on the upper space U, we have dh2 .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/ Scl .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/I t D : 2t Since LScl does not depend on t only, the transport equation is messy and the heat kernel in this case is hard to find in the product form (3.6.30). However, McKean [89] found the integral representation p Z 1 s2 2 se 2t t =2 e p ds; (3.6.31) .2 t/3=2 cosh s cosh where D dh .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/ . It is interesting for further investigations to clarify the relationship between the integral representation (3.6.31) and the product formula (3.6.30). As we shall see in the next section, this relation is obvious in the case of a three-dimensional hyperbolic space. K .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/I t D
3.7 Heat Kernels on Curved Spaces Let g be the Laplace–Beltrami operator on a Riemannian space .M; gij / of dimension n. Let R D g ij Rij be the Ricci scalar curvature of the space, which will be assumed constant. Let d.x0 ; x/ denote the Riemannian distance between the points x0 and x. The heat kernel for the elliptic operator g is given by K.x0 ; x; t/ D where
d 2 .x0 ;x/ 1 g.x/1=4 D 1=2 g.x0 /1=4 e Rt e 4t ; n=2 .4 t/
2 @ Scl D D det @x0 @x
is the van Vleck determinant; see Schulman [102], Chap. 24.
(3.7.32)
46
3 The Geometric Method
Applying the aforementioned formula for the classical spaces with constant curvatures 0; 1; 1, we arrive at the following classical results. The three-dimensional hyperbolic space. The Laplace–Beltrami operator on the three-dimensional hyperbolic space, i.e., the domain f.x1 ; x2 ; x3 /jx3 > 0g endowed with the metric ds2 D .dx21 C dx22 C dx23 /=.x3 /2 , is given by D x32 .@2x1 C @2x2 C @2x3 / x3 @x3 : The heat kernel of is obtained from formula (3.7.32) by letting scalar curvature R D 1 and hyperbolic distance d.x0 ; x/ D , KD
2 1 e t e 4t : 3=2 .4 t/ sinh
This relation was obtained by a direct method in [39], p. 396. The three-dimensional unit sphere S 3 . The Laplace–Beltrami operator on S 3 in spherical coordinates is given by D
1 @2 @ C C cot @ 2 @ sin2
@2 @2 @2 C 2 cos 2 2 @ @ @@
:
In this case R D 1 and the heat kernel becomes K.x0 ; xI t/ D
t 2 1 e e 4t ; 3=2 .4 t/ sin
(3.7.33)
where D dS 3 .x0 ; x/. This was obtained for S U.2/ by Schulman [101], who also conjectured that this formula works in general for Lie groups. The three-dimensional Euclidean space. In the case of the Laplace operator D
@2 @2 @2 C C ; @x12 @x22 @x32
making the curvature R D 0 in (3.7.32) yields the familiar formula for the Euclidean heat kernel jxx0 j2 1 4t K.x0 ; xI t/ D e : .4 t/3=2
3.8 Heat Kernel at the Cut-Locus The point x belongs to the cut-locus of x0 if there is more than one geodesic between the points x0 and x in time t, and this number is finite. In this case the heat propagates from x0 to x in more than one way, each geodesic having its own contribution
3.10 Heat Kernel on the Half-Line
47
toward the heat kernel. If there are k geodesics between x0 and x, parameterized by Œ0; t, with the corresponding volume element Vk and classical action Sk , then the formula for the heat kernel is the sum of all contributions: K.x0 ; xI t/ D
k X
Vk .t; x0 ; x/e Sk :
(3.8.34)
j D1
The above sum has only one term in the case of elliptic operators. In the case of sub-elliptic operators the sum may become an infinite series, as in the case of the Grushin operator.
3.9 Heat Kernel at the Conjugate Locus If the points x0 and x are conjugate, there is a smooth variation with geodesics of the same length with fixed endpoints x0 and x. Consider the space x0 ;xIt D fc W Œ0; t ! M I c.0/ D x0 ; c.t/ D x; c geodesicg: Each element of the above space contributes to the propagation of heat between x0 and x. In this case the sum (3.8.34) becomes an integral over x0 ;xIt : Z
e S./ d ./;
K.x0 ; xI t/ D x0 ;xIt
where d ./ is the volume measure obtained by a limit process from Vk . This recovers a refined concept of path integral. In the particular case of homogeneous spaces, the volume element depends only on the Riemannian distance between x0 and x and does not depend in an explicit way on the end points. This can be seen in the cases of the Euclidean space and the three-dimensional hyperbolic space.
3.10 Heat Kernel on the Half-Line We interested in finding the heat kernel of the Laplacian
1 d2 2 dx2
on the domain Œ0; 1/,
D 0. This means that no heat can leak subject to the boundary condition across the point x D 0. Let x0 ; x > 0. The heat can travel from the point x0 to the point x in time t in two different ways: @ u.t; 0/ @x
On the shortest path between the points, of length d1 D jx x0 j, given by x.s/ D x0 C
.x x0 /s ; t
s 2 Œ0; t:
48
3 The Geometric Method
On a piecewise path that hits the origin at time and then is reflected toward x: .1 s /x0 ; 0 s ; x.s/ D x.s /=.t /; s t: of length d2 D x0 C x. The heat kernel is the amount of heat received by x at time t, which is the sum of the aforementioned amounts of heat: K.x0 ; xI t/ D p D p
d2 1
1
e 2t C p
2 t 1
e
2 t
.xx0 /2 2t
d2 2
1 2 t
e 2t
Cp
1 2 t
e
.xCx0 /2 2t
:
The following result will be needed in the next two applications. p Lemma 3.10.1. For any 2 R, T > 0, i D 1, we have X
1
2
e 2t .2nT C/ C
n1
X
1
2
2
e 2t .2nT / D 2e 2t
n1
X
e
2n2 T 2 t
cos
n1
2nT i : t
Proof. Expanding the binomial in the exponent and using Euler’s formula, we have X
1
2
e 2t .2nT C/ C
n1
D
X
X n1
e
2 2t
X
e
2 2 4n2tT
2 2t
X
e
2 2 2n t T
C
X
1
e
2nT t
cos
n1
Ce
2 T 2 C 2 4nT /
e 2t .4n
n1
n1
D 2e
2
1 2t .4n2 T 2 C 2 C4nT /
n1
De
1
e 2t .2nT /
2nT t
2
D 2e 2t
X
e
2n2 T 2 t
cosh
n1
2nT t
2nT i : t
3.11 Heat Kernel on S 1 Let X0 and X be two points on the unit circle S 1 with angular arguments s0 and s. The heat kernel K.X0 ; X I t/ depends on all geodesics that join the points X0 and X . The square of the lengths of both clockwise and counterclockwise geodesics joining X0 and X are `20 D .ss0 /2 ;
2 `2n D 2nC.ss0 / ;
2 `2n D 2n.ss0 / ;
n 2 N:
3.12 Heat Kernel on the Segment Œ0; T
49
Since the unitpcircle is locally Euclidean and one-dimensional, the volume element is V .t/ D 1= 2 t, and the heat kernel has the following expression: K.X0 ; X I t/ D 0 1
@e Dp 2 t
X
`2 k
V .t/e 2t D p
n2Z .ss /2 2t0
C
X
e
1 2t
1 X
1 2 t
1
e 2t
2
2nC.ss0 /
nD1
2nC.ss0 /
2
C
n1
X
e
1 2t
2n.ss0 /
2
1 A:
n1
Applying Lemma 3.10.1 with T D and D s s0 , we obtain 0 1 K.X0 ; X I t/ D p e 2 t
.ss /2 2t0
@1 C 2
X
e
2 2 2 t n
n1
1 2n .s s0 /i A : cos t
Choosing z D .s s0 /i=t and D 2=t in the definition of the theta-function 3 .zji / D 1 C 2
X
e n
2
cos.2nz/
n1
[see (1.5.4)], we arrive at the following formula for the heat kernel on S 1 : K.X0 ; X I t/ D p
1 2 t
e
.ss0 /2 2t
3
.s s0 /i ˇˇ 2 i : ˇ t t
(3.11.35)
Since there is no generating formula for 3 , this shows that even in the simplest compact case, the heat kernel does not have a neat formula. For an approach using eigenfunctions expansion and the Poisson summation formula, see Sect. 6.4.
3.12 Heat Kernel on the Segment Œ0; T The heat kernel of concern here is the one corresponding to the Neumann boundary @ @ conditions @x u.t; 0/ D @x u.t; T / D 0. This corresponds to the case when x D 0 and x D T are perfectly insulated reflecting walls. The distances traveled by heat from x0 to x in a direct way or using reflections in the walls are x x0 ;
x C x0 ;
2nT C x x0 ;
2nT x C x0 ;
2nT C x C x0 ;
2nT x x0 ; : : : ;
50
3 The Geometric Method
with n D 1; 2; : : : . These are the distances from x0 to the images of x seen in two parallel plane mirrors situated at coordinates 0 and T . Each of these distances has a contribution to the heat kernel as follows: X `2 n V .t/e 2t K.x0 ; xI t/ D n0
D p
2
1 2 t
4e
.xx0 /2 2t
C
X
C e
.xCx0 /2 2t
1
2
e 2t .2nT Cxx0 / C
n1
C
X
X
1
e 2t .2nT xCx0 /
2
n1
e
1 2t
.2nT CxCx0
n1
/2
C
X
3 e
1 2t
.2nT xx0
/2
5:
n1
Lemma 3.10.1 enables us to write the previous expression as 3 2 X 2n2 T 2 .xx0 /2 1 2nT K.x0 ; xI t/ D p e 2t 41 C 2 e t cos .x x0 /i 5 t 2 t n1 3 2 X 2n2 T 2 .xCx0 /2 2nT 1 e 2t 41 C 2 e t cos .x C x0 /i 5 ; Cp t 2 t n1 which, after using the definition of the 3 -function, can be expressed as ˇ 2T 2 i .xx0 /2 1 T ˇ e 2t 3 K.x0 ; xI t/ D p (3.12.36) .x x0 /i ˇ t t 2 t ˇ 2T 2 i .xCx0 /2 T 1 ˇ : (3.12.37) .x C x0 /i ˇ Cp e 2t 3 t t 2 t
3.13 Heat Kernel on the Cylinder The cylinder is two-dimensional and locally Euclidean, so the volume element is V .t/ D 21 t . Let .x0 ; y0 / and .x; y/ be two points on the cylinder. The geodesic joining the points is a spiral which makes a constant angle with the vertical. If the geodesic winds n times, the vertical distance is the sum of n equal increments plus a remainder amount (see Fig. 3.2): y y0 D 2n tan C .x x0 / tan : This shows that the angle D n must be quantized by the relation tan n D
y y0 ; 2n C .x x0 /
n 2 Z:
3.13 Heat Kernel on the Cylinder
51
Fig. 3.2 The geodesic between the points .x0 ; y0 / and .x; y/ on the cylinder R S1 tan
(x0 , y0)
x0
x0 mod
By convention, we consider the integer n positive if the winding is counterclockwise and negative otherwise. The length of the geodesic is the sum of n C 1 oblique segments: 2 n x x0 `n D C : cos n cos n Expressing cosine in terms of tangent function and using the aforementioned formula yields q p 2 `n D D 1 C tan2 n .2n C x x0 / D 2n C .x x0 / C .y y0 /2 : Then the heat kernel is given by the contribution of all geodesics from .x0 ; y0 / and .x; y/: K .x0 ; y0 /; .x; y/I t 1 X 2t1 .2nCxx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 1 X `2n e 2t D e D 2 t n2Z 2 t n2Z 1 .xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 X 2t1 4n2 2 C4n.xx0 / 2t e D e 2 t n2Z 2n.x x0 /i 1 .xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 X 2n2 2 2t t e cos e D 2 t t n2Z 2n.x x0 /i i .xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 X 2n2 2 2t t e sin e C 2 t t n2Z 1 0 2 C.yy /2 X 2 2 .xx / 2n.x x0 /i A 1 2n 0 0 @1 C 2 2t e t cos e D 2 t t n1 1 .xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 2t e 3 D 2 t
.x x0 /i ˇˇ 2 i : ˇ t t
52
3 The Geometric Method
It is worth noting that the previous heat kernel is the direct product of the heat kernels on R and S 1 . This formula could have been written directly since the cylinder is the product of these two manifolds.
3.14 Operators with Potentials This is an extension of the method described in the previous sections to operators that have a potential. We start the presentation with the heat kernel of the operator 1 d2 C U.x/, where U.x/ is a function of the variable x, called the potential. Since 2 dx the heat kernel will depend on the classical action between any two given points, in order to obtain closed-form formulas, we need to consider only those potentials U.x/ for which the classical action can be computed explicitly. This will occur in several cases, for instance, in the case of linear and quadratic potentials. In these cases there is a unique solution joining any two given points x0 and x within time t. The classical action cannot be obtained explicitly for potentials of the type U.x/ D a2 x m , with m 3. d 2 Consider the operator L D 12 dx C U.x/ with smooth potential U.x/. We associate the Hamiltonian function H.p; x/ D
1 2 p C U.x/: 2
(3.14.38)
Hamilton’s equations are xP D Hp D p; pP D Hx D U 0 .x/; and hence xR D pP D U 0 .x/: For any two given points x0 and x, the classical path joining them is obtained by solving the equation 8 0 ˆ ˆ <xR D U .x/; (3.14.39) x.0/ D x0 ; ˆ ˆ :x.t/ D x: We shall assume the potential U.x/ is such that the previous system has a unique solution. Since the Hamiltonian (3.14.38) does not depend explicitly on the variable t, it will be preserved along the solutions of (3.14.39): H D
xP 2 C U.x/ D E; 2
(3.14.40)
where E D E.x0 ; x; t/ is the constant of energy. Hence x.s/ verifies the integral equation Z x.s/ dw D ˙s; p 2E 2U.w/ x0
3.14 Operators with Potentials
53
where the positive (negative) sign is taken on the right-hand side if x > x0 .x < x0 /. The energy E D E.x0 ; x; t/ satisfies the equation Z x dw p D ˙t; 2E 2U.w/ x0 with the same sign convention. The action S is verifying the Hamilton–Jacobi equation @t S D E.x0 ; x; t/. Since along the solutions we have p D @x S , using xP D p, we get xP D @x S , and hence (3.14.40) becomes .@x S /2 D 2E 2U.x/:
(3.14.41)
We shall look for a fundamental solution of the type K D V .t; x/e S , where S D Scl is the classical action. A computation provides 0 V CE ; @t K D K V @x V C @x S ; @x K D K V 2 @ @x V xV 2 @x S C .@x S /2 @2x S : @2x K D K V V Let P D @t 12 @2x U.x/. Using the above formulas, we obtain PK D K DK
1 @t V 1 @2x V @x V @x S 1 CE C .@x S /2 C @2x S U.x/ V 2 V V 2 2 ! 1 2 @t V 2 @x V C @x V @x S 1 C @2x S ; V 2
where we used (3.14.41). Hence PK D 0 if and only if V satisfies the generalized transport equation 1 1 @t V @2x V C @x S @x V C @2x S V D 0: 2 2
(3.14.42)
Using that xP D @x S , we have d P x V D @t V C @x S @x V; V .t; x/ D @t V C x@ dt and hence (3.14.42) becomes d 1 1 V .t; x/ D @2x V .t; x/ @2x S V .t; x/: dt 2 2
(3.14.43)
54
3 The Geometric Method
If @2x S depends on t only, then it makes sense to look for a function V D V .t/ satisfying the simplified transport equation 1 @t V C @2x S V D 0: 2
(3.14.44)
The volume function V .t; x/ should satisfy the initial condition Z lim V .t; x/e Scl dx D 1: t &0
(3.14.45)
We conclude the above calculations with the following method for finding explicit formulas for heat kernels: 1. Assume the boundary value problem (3.14.39) satisfies the uniqueness condition; let x.s/ be its solution. 2. Let S D Scl .x0 ; xI t/ be the classical action along solution x.s/ between x0 and x in time t. 3. Consider the solution V .t; x/ of the transport equation (3.14.42) satisfying (3.14.45). 4. Then K.x0 ; xI t/ D V .t; x/e S is the heat kernel for the operator 12 @2x C U.x/. Unfortunately, there are potential functions U.x/ for which the boundary value problem (3.14.39) has a unique solution. This happens, for instance, in the case when U.x/ D x 4 ; see Calin and Chang [24]. Even if the solution is unique and the action function is found, the transport equation might be difficult to solve. It is worth noting that the potential function U.x/ does not appear explicitly in the expression of the generalized transport equation. It is even more interesting to observe that (3.14.42) is a particular form of the multidimensional generalized transport equation (3.4.11) with .aij / D 1 (one-dimensional matrix). In the following se shall consider the case of linear and quadratic potentials, for which all the computations can be done explicitly.
3.15 The Linear Potential Let U.x/ D ax, with a a real constant. The operator is L D associated Hamiltonian function is H.p; x/ D
1 2 p ax: 2
The Hamiltonian system becomes xP D Hp D p; pP D Hx D a:
1 d2 2 dx
ax and its
3.15 The Linear Potential
55
The associated Lagrangian function is L.x; x/ P D 12 xP 2 C ax. The Euler–Lagrange equation xR D a with the boundary conditions x.0/ D x0 , x.t/ D x has the unique solution 1 x.s/ D as 2 C bs C x0 ; (3.15.46) 2 with x x0 at : (3.15.47) bD t 2 The Lagrangian along the solution (7.9.43) is 1 P 2 C ax.s/ L x.s/; x.s/ P D x.s/ 2 1 1 2 D .as C b/2 C a as C bs C x0 2 2 1 D a2 s 2 C 2abs C ax0 C b 2 : 2 The classical action is obtained by integrating the Lagrangian along the solution: Z
t
S.x0 ; xI t/ D
L x.s/; x.s/ P ds
0
1 1 D a2 t 3 C abt 2 C ax0 t C b 2 t: 3 2 Substituting b from (7.10.67) yields 1 2 3 1 x x0 at 2 at 2 x x0 S.x0 ; xI t/ D a t C at C ax0 t C t 3 t 2 2 t 2 .x x0 /2 1 2 3 1 D (3.15.48) C a.x C x0 /t a t : 2t 2 24 There is an alternate method for finding the action using the Hamilton–Jacobi equation. For this we need first to find the energy along the solution as a function of the boundary points. In our case (3.14.40) becomes 1 x.s/ P 2 ax.s/ D E: 2 Using (7.9.43) yields ED
1 2 1 .as C b/2 a as C bs C x0 ; 2 2
8s 2 Œ0; t:
56
3 The Geometric Method
Taking the particular value s D 0 yields 1 2 b ax0 2 1 x x0 at 2 D ax0 2 t 2
ED
D
.x x0 /2 1 a2 t 2 a.x C x : / C 0 2t 2 2 8
It is not hard to check that the Hamilton–Jacobi equation @t S D E 1 a2 t 2 .x x0 /2 C / a.x C x ; D 0 2t 2 2 8 with the initial condition Sjt D0 D 0, has the solution S.x0 ; xI t/ D
1 .x x0 /2 1 C a.x C x0 /t a2 t 3 : 2t 2 24
(3.15.49)
In the following we shall find the volume function V . Since 12 @2x S D V D V .t/ and the transport equation is V 0 .t/ C
1 V .t/ D 0; 2t
with the solution V .t/ D
c t 1=2
:
The constant c can be found using (3.14.45): Z Z 1 D lim K.x0 ; xI t/ dx D lim V .t/ e S.x0 ;xIt / dx t &0
D lim
c
D lim
c
e
t &0 t 1=2
t &0
D lim
t
t &0
Z
.xx0 /2 1 2 3 1 2t 2 a.xCx0 /t C 24 a t
1
1
2t3
1
1
2t3
e 2 ax0 t C 24 a 1=2 c
t &0 t 1=2
e 2 ax0 t C 24 a
Z
e
.xx0 /2 2t
1
dx
1 2 a.xx0 /t
.2 t/1=2 e 8 a
dx
2t 3
D c.2/1=2 ; and hence c D .2/1=2 and the volume function is V .t/ D 1=.2 t/1=2 .
1 , 2t
then
3.15 The Linear Potential
57
We have arrived at the following result: Theorem 3.15.1. Let a 2 R. The heat kernel of the operator L D given by K.x; x0 ; t/ D p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
1 2 3 1 2 a.xCx0 /t C 24 a t
1 d2 2 dx
ax is
; t > 0:
Remark 3.15.2. In the case when a D 0 we recover the well-known heat kernel of 1 2 @ , 2 x
which is
p1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
.
Without muchPeffort, the previous result can be generalized to the n-dimensional P operator L D 12 niD1 @2xi niD1 ai xi . In this case the Hamiltonian function is H.p; x/ D
1X 2 X pi ai xi ; 2 n
n
i D1
i D1
and the Hamiltonian equations are xP j D pj ; pPj D aj ;
j D 1; : : : ; n:
The solution joining the points x0 and x is x j .s/ D
1 j aj s 2 C bj s C x0 ; 2
(3.15.50)
with bj D
x j x0j aj t ; t 2
j D 1; : : : ; n:
(3.15.51)
The Lagrangian L.x; x/ P D
1X 2 X 1 jxP i j2 C ha; xi D xP i C ai xi 2 2 n
n
i D1
i D1
evaluated along the previous solution is 1 L x.s/; x.s/ P D jaj2 s 2 C 2ha; bis C ha; x0 i C jbj2 : 2 Integrating the Lagrangian along the solution yields the following classical action: S.x0 ; xI t/ D
1 jx x0 j2 1 C ha; x C x0 it jaj2 t 3 : 2t 2 24
(3.15.52)
58
3 The Geometric Method
Similar calculations show that the generalized transport equation in this case is ! n n 1X 2 1 X 2 @t V @xi V C hrS; rV i C @xi S V D 0: 2 2 i D1 i D1 P n does not depend on x, it makes sense to look for a Since 12 niD1 @2xi S D 2t volume function of the form V D V .t/, in which case the previous equation takes the simplified form n V 0 .t/ C V .t/ D 0: 2t The solution is V .t/ D ct n=2 . Using a similar method as before, we find c D .2/n=2 . We conclude with the following result: P Theorem 3.15.3. Let a 2 Rn . The heat kernel of the operator L D 12 niD1 @2xi Pn i D1 ai xi is given by K.x; x0 ; t/ D
jxx0 j2 1 1 2 3 1 2t 2 ha; xCx0 it C 24 jaj t ; t > 0: e .2 t/n=2
3.16 The Quadratic Potential 2
d We consider the operator L D 12 . dx a2 x 2 /, with a constant, called the Hermite operator. The associated Hamiltonian is given by H.p; x/ D 12 p 2 12 a2 x 2 and the Hamiltonian system of equations is
xP D Hp D p; pP D Hx D a2 x: The geodesic between x0 and x within time t satisfies xR D a2 x; x.0/ D x0 ; x.t/ D x:
(3.16.53)
x x0 cosh.at/ sinh.as/ C x0 cosh.as/: sinh.at/
(3.16.54)
The solution is x.s/ D
The Lagrangian associated with the previous Hamiltonian is L.x; x/ P D p xP H D
1 2 1 2 2 xP C a x : 2 2
(3.16.55)
3.16 The Quadratic Potential
59
Integrating the solution (7.9.51) along the Lagrangian (7.9.52) and performing the same computations as in Sect. 7.8 yields S.x0 ; x; t/ D
2 a .x C x02 / cosh.at/ 2xx0 : 2 sinh.at/
(3.16.56)
There is an alternate way of finding the action using the Hamilton–Jacobi equation. The conservation of energy law for (7.9.50) is 1 2 1 xP .s/ a2 x 2 .s/ D E; 2 2 where E is the energy constant. This can also be written as p dx dx D 2E C a2 x 2 H) p D ds: ds 2E C a2 x 2 Integrating between s D 0 and s D t, with x.0/ D x0 and x.t/ D x, and solving for the energy yields a2 x 2 C x02 2xx0 cosh.at/ a2 .x x0 cosh.at//2 2 2 2E D a x0 D : sinh.at/2 sinh.at/2 The Hamilton–Jacobi equation becomes @t S D H.rS / D E a2 x 2 C x02 2xx0 cosh.at/ D 2 sinh.at/2
@ a 2 axx0 2 D : .x C x0 / coth.at/ @t 2 sinh.at/ Hence
a 2xx0 2 2 .x C x0 / coth.at/ S.x0 ; x; t/ D 2 sinh.at/ D
2
1 a x C x02 cosh.at/ 2xx0 : 2 sinh.at/
(3.16.57)
Since @2x S D a coth.at/ is a function of t only, the transport equation becomes 1 V 0 .t/ C a coth.at/V .t/ D 0: 2
60
3 The Geometric Method
Integrating, we obtain the solution c V .t/ D p ; sinh.at/ where c is a constant which will be determined later. Using K D V .t/e S , we get the fundamental solution K.x0 ; x; t/ D p
c sinh.at/
a
1
e 2 sinh.at / Œ.x
2 Cx 2 / cosh.at /2xx 0 0
:
In order to determine the constant c we write s 1 at 2 2 c at e 2t sinh.at / Œ.x Cx0 / cosh.at /2xx0 : K.x0 ; x; t/ D p at sinh.at/ Since at= sinh.at/ ! 1, for a ! 0, we can write 1 c 2 K.x0 ; x; t/ p e 2t .xx0 / : at
By comparison with the fundamental p solution for the usual heat operator p 1 2 .xx / 0 , we obtain c D a=2. To conclude, we have the following 1= 2 t e 2t result. 2
d Theorem 3.16.1. Let a be a constant. The heat kernel for the operator 12 . dx 2 2 a x / is s 1 at 2 2 1 at e 2t sinh.at / Œ.x Cx0 / cosh.at /2xx0 ; t > 0: K.x0 ; x; t/ D p 2 t sinh.at/
Using the substitutions a D i ˛ and cosh.i ˛t/ D cos.˛t/ and sinh.2i ˛t/ D i sin.2˛t/, we get 2
d Corollary 3.16.2. Let ˛ be a constant. The heat kernel for the operator 12 . dx C 2 2 ˛ x / is s 1 2˛t 2 2˛t 2 1 K.x0 ; x; t/ D p e 2t sin.2˛t / Œ.x Cx0 / cos.2˛t /2xx0 ; t > 0: 2 t sin.2˛t/
3.17 The Operator
1 2
P
@x2 i ˙ 12 a2 jxj2
Consider the operator 1 1 1 1 n a2 jxj2 D .@2x1 C C @2xn / a2 .x12 C C xn2 /; a 0: 2 2 2 2
3.17 The Operator
1 2
P
@2xi ˙ 12 a2 jxj2
61
The associated Hamiltonian is H D
1 2 1 .1 C C n2 / a2 .x12 C C xn2 /; 2 2
with the Hamiltonian system ( xP j D Hj D j ; Pj D Hxj D a2 xj ; j D 1; : : : ; n: The geodesic x.s/ starting at x0 D .x10 ; : : : ; xn0 / and having the final point x D .x1 ; : : : ; xn / satisfies the equations 8 2 ˆ ˆ <xR j D a xj ; xj .0/ D xj0 ; ˆ ˆ :x .t/ D x ; j D 1; : : : ; n: j
j
As in the one-dimensional case, we have the law of conservation of energy xP j2 .s/ a2 xj2 .s/ D 2Ej ; j D 1; : : : ; n; where Ej is the energy constant for the j th component. The total energy, which is the Hamiltonian, is given by H D
n X 1
1 xP j2 a2 xj2 2 2
j D1
D E1 C C En D E(constant):
Since the energy for the one-dimensional case is Ej D
a2 Œxj2 C .xj0 /2 2xj xj0 cosh.at/ 2 sinh2 .at/
;
we get the total energy H DED
n X j D1
where jxj2 D
Pn
j D1
Ej D
a2 Œjxj2 C jx0 j2 2hx; x0 i cosh.at/ ; 2 sinh2 .at/
xj2 and hx; x0 i D
Pn
0 j D1 xj xj .
Computing the classical action. The action between x0 and x within time t satisfies the equation @t@ S D E or @ a2 Œjxj2 C jx0 j2 2hx; x0 i cosh.at/ S D @t 2 sinh2 .at/
ahx; x0 i @ a 2 2 .jxj C jx0 j / coth.at/ D @t 2 sinh.at/
62
3 The Geometric Method
and hence Scl .x0 ; xI t/ D
a 1 .jxj2 C jx0 j2 / cosh.at/ 2hx; x0 i : 2 sinh.at/
(3.17.58)
We are looking for a kernel of the form K.x0 ; x; t/ D V .t/e kScl .x0 ;x;t / ;
k 2 R:
(3.17.59)
Since the Lagrangian is at most quadratically in x and x, P the function V .t/ is given by the van Vleck formula (see also Chap. 7) s 1 @2 Scl V .t/ D det : 2 @x @x0 Since in this case a @2 Scl D In ; @x @x0 sinh.at/ we obtain
V .t/ D
a 2 sinh.at/
n=2 :
Hence the heat kernel is K.x0 ; x; t/ D
a 2 sinh.at/
n=2
a
1
e 2 sinh.at /
.jxj2 Cjx0 j2 / cosh.at /2hx;x0 i
for t > 0. In a similar way, one can find the heat kernel for the operator 12 n C 12 a2 jxj2 . Formally, this reduces to changing sinh into sin and cosh into cos in the previous expression. An alternate method. Another method for finding the heat kernel of 1X 2 @xi 2ajxj2 2 n
LD
i D1
is described next by following reference [11]. Using the rotational symmetry of the operator L, it makes sense to state the following. Anzatz: The heat kernel of L starting at the origin is of the form 1
2
K.x; aI t/ D a .t/e 2 ˛a .t /jxj ;
t > 0:
3.17 The Operator
1 2
P
@2xi ˙ 12 a2 jxj2
63
Substituting in equation .@t L/K D 0 yields 0 2 1 2 .t/ n 0 2 ˛ .t/ C ˛ .t/ a jxj K D 0: ˛.t/ C .t/ 2 2 We shall look for functions and ˛ such that ˛ 0 .t/ D a2 ˛ 2 .t/; n 0 .t/ D ˛.t/: .t/ 2 Using the substitution ˛ D ˇ 0 =ˇ yields the equation ˇ 00 D a2 ˇ, with the solution ˇ.t/ D A cosh.at/ C B sinh.at/: Using limt &0C K.x; aI t/ D ıx yields 1 D lim ˛.t/ D t &0C
ˇ 0 .0/ 2aB D ; ˇ.0/ A
so A D 0. Hence ˛.t/ D a coth.at/. Integrating in
0 .t / .t /
D n2 a coth.at/ yields .t/ D
cn : sinh.at/n=2
The constant cn may be obtained from the condition Z
lim
t &0C
1 cn 2 e 2 ˛a .t /jxj dx D 1 ” sinh.at/n=2 cn 2 n=2 lim D1” ˛.t/ t &0C sinh.at/n=2 n=2 2 lim D cn1 ” t &0C a cosh.at/ a n=2 : cn D 2
Hence we obtain the heat kernel of L: 1
2
K.x; aI t/ D a .t/e 2 ˛a .t /jxj n=2 a 1 2 D e 2 a coth.at /jxj ; 2 sinh.at/
t > 0:
64
3 The Geometric Method
3.18 The Operator L D 12 @x2 C
x2
The operator is defined on the domain fx > 0g. This is an example where the transport equation reduces to a modified Bessel equation. This operator has been considered from the geometric point of view in reference [26]. First we find the classical action. The associated Hamiltonian is H D 12 p 2 C x 2 , a real constant. The geodesic joining the points x0 and x within time t satisfies the Euler–Lagrange equation associated with the Lagrangian L D 12 xP 2 x 2 : 2 ; x3 x.0/ D x0 ; x.t/ D x: xR D
Since the regions fx < 0g and fx > 0g are separated, in order to have connectivity, we have to assume that either x0 ; x > 0 or x0 ; x < 0. We can show that the energy is a first integral of motion, so that 1 2 xP .s/ C 2 D E; 2 x .s/
s 2 Œ0; t:
Under the assumption x0 ; x > 0, the previous relation becomes x.s/x.s/ P D
p
2Ex 2 .s/ 2 :
Let u.s/ D x 2 .s/, u0 D x02 , ut D x 2 . Then u.s/ verifies the ODE p uP D 2 2Eu 2 ; u.0/ D u0 ;
u.t/ D ut :
Integrating yields Z
ut
du p D 2t ” 2Eu 2 u0 p p 2Eut 2 2Eu0 2 D 2Et: Eliminating the square roots, we obtain 2 .u0 C ut / 2Et 2 D 4.u0 ut 2 t 2 /;
(3.18.60)
3.18 The Operator L D 12 @2x C
x2
65
assuming the following condition: <
x02 x 2 : 2t 2
Solving for E in (3.18.60) yields q x2 C x2 ED 0 2 2t
x02 x 2 2 t 2 t2
:
(3.18.61)
The classical action Scl satisfies the following Hamilton–Jacobi equation: @t Scl D E; with E given by (3.18.61). We can write Scl D S0 C S1 , where x02 C x 2 x2 C x2 H) S0 D 0 ; 2 2t 2t q x02 x 2 2 t 2 @t S1 D : t2
@t S0 D
We shall solve (3.18.63) as a homogeneous equation. Let D S1 . x0t x /. Then p 1 2 2 d S2 . / D : d
2 With the substitution D
p1 2
(3.18.62)
(3.18.63) t , x0 x
and S2 . / D
sin , integrating yields
Z p p Z 1 2 2 d D 2 cot2 d S2 . / D
2 p Z p D 2 1 cot0 d D 2 . C cot / ) ( p 2 p p 1 2
D 2 sin1 . 2 / C p 2
and hence S1 .x0 ; x; / D
q 2 x02 x 2 t 2 2t
p p t 2 sin1 2 : x0 x
(3.18.64)
66
3 The Geometric Method
From (3.18.64) and (3.18.62), we obtain the classical action
Scl .x0 ; x; t/ D
x02
Cx 2t 2
q 2 x02 x 2 t 2 2t
p p t 1 2 : (3.18.65) 2 sin x0 x
By the general theory, or by a direct computation, the classical action Scl satisfies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation 1 @t Scl C .@x Scl /2 C 2 D 0: 2 x
(3.18.66)
The transport equation. We shall assume the heat kernel for L of the type K.x0 ; x; t/ D V .x; t/e S.x0 ;x;t / : Then a computation shows @t K D e S .@t V V @t S / ; @2x K D e S @2x V 2@x V @x S C V .@x S /2 V .@2x S / ; and hence 1 .@t L/K D @t @2x 2 K 2 x ( " # 1 Œby .3:18:66/ D e S V @t S C .@x S /2 C 2 2 ƒ‚ x… „ D0
) 1 2 1 2 C@t V @x V C @x V @x S C V .@x S / : 2 2 We shall ask V to satisfy the following transport equation: 1 1 @t V @2x V C @x V @x S C V .@2x S / D 0: 2 2
(3.18.67)
Equation (3.18.67) might be hard to solve since the action S and its derivatives are complicated. In the following we shall consider a shortcut for these computations. We note that the action is the sum S D S0 C S1 , where the term S1 is a function of x0t x . Then e S D W
x x x02 Cx2 0 e 2t : t
3.18 The Operator L D 12 @2x C
x2
67
Then it makes sense now to look for a heat kernel of the type K.x0 ; x; t/ D V .x; t/e S0 D V .x; t/e where V .x; t/ D
1 p Z. x0t x / t
x 2 Cx 2 0 2t
;
satisfies the extended transport equation
1 1 1 @t V @2x V C @x V @x S0 C V .@2x S0 / V @t S0 C .@x S0 /2 C 2 D 0: 2 2 2 x (3.18.68) In the following we shall solve (3.18.68). Let D
x0 x . t
Then we have
1
V D t 2 Z. /; 1 3 0 2 Z. / C Z . / ; @t V D t 2 3
@x V D t 2 Z 0 . / x0 ; 3
@2x V D t 2 Z 00 . /
x02 : t
Since @t S D
x02 C x 2 ; 2t 2
@x S D
x ; t
@2x S D
1 ; t
(3.18.68) becomes, after cancelations,
x 2 1 1 x0 2 1 1 0 t 2 Z. / 2 D 0: t 2 Z 00 . / 2 t x 2 t 1
Multiplying by 2x 2 t 2 yields
2 Z 00 . / C Z. /Œ2 2 D 0: 1
Let U. / D 2 Z. /. A computation shows 1 3 3 1
2 Z. / 2 Z 0 . / C 2 Z 00 . /; 4 1 1 1
U 0 . / D 2 Z. / C 2 Z 0 . /; 2
2 U 00 . / D
(3.18.69)
68
3 The Geometric Method
and using (3.18.69), we have 1 2 00
U . / C U . / D
Z . / C Z. / 4 1 2 1 2 Z. / 2 C Z. / D
4 1 D U. / 2 2 C : 4 2
00
0
1 2
Hence U. / satisfies the modified Bessel equation
2 U 00 C U 0 C . 2 2 /U D 0; with D
1 2
p
1 8 . The general solution can be written as a linear combination U. / D ˛I . / C ˇJ . /;
˛; ˇ 2 R;
where I . / and J are the modified Bessel functions of the first and second types. Hence the general solution of (3.18.69) is given by Z. / D
p p p
U. / D ˛ I . / C ˇ J . /;
where r I . /
1 e ; 2
r J . /
1 as ! 1I 2 e
(3.18.70)
see, for instance, [41]. Consequently, the solution of the extended transport equation (3.18.68) will be given by V .x0 ; x; t/ D t
1=2
p xx xx xx0 0 0 Z. / D ˛I
C ˇJ
; t t t
(3.18.71)
with ˛; ˇ 2 R. Theorem 3.18.1. The heat kernel for the operator L D 12 @2x C x 2 , with 0 < < 1=8 and x > 0, is K.x0 ; xI t/ D
p x0 x x0 x x02 Cx2 2t e I
; t t
t > 0;
where I is the nonsingular modified Bessel function of order D
1 2
p
1 8 .
3.18 The Operator L D 12 @2x C
x2
69
Proof. We have shown already in the previous section that .@t L/K.x0 ; x; t/ D 0;
t > 0;
with K.x0 ; x; t/ D V .x0 ; x; t/e
x 2 Cx 2 0 2t
;
and V given by (3.18.71). We need to choose the constants ˛ and ˇ such that lim K.x0 ; x; t/ D ıx0
t &0
in the distributions sense. Let K D K1 C K2 with p
xx0 xx0 x2 Cx02 2t ; e I
t t p xx0 xx0 x2 Cx02 2t : e J
K2 .x0 ; x; t/ D ˇ t t K1 .x0 ; x; t/ D ˛
Then
p lim K1 .x0 ; x; t/ D lim ˛
t &0
t &0
D ˛ lim
!1
xx0 xx0 xx0 .xx0 /2 2t e t e I
t t
p
.xx0 /2 1
I . /e lim p e 2t t &0 t
.xx0 /2 1 1 lim p e 2t D ˛p 2 t &0 t D ˛ıx0 ;
where we have used the first relation of (3.18.70). Hence we shall choose ˛ D 1. A similar computation, using the second relation of (3.18.70) yields p xx0 xx0 xx0 .xx0 /2 2t e t e J
lim K2 .x0 ; x; t/ D lim ˇ t &0 t &0 t t D ˇ lim
!1
p
.xx0 /2 1
J . /e lim p e 2t t &0 t
.xx0 /2 p 1 D ˇ lim e 2 lim p e 2t !1 t &0 2 t D 0:
Hence lim K.x0 ; x; t/ D lim K1 .x0 ; x; t/ C lim K2 .x0 ; x; t/ D ˛ıx0 ;
t &0
t &0
t &0
70
3 The Geometric Method
so we need to choose ˛ D 1. In order to find ˇ, we shall consider the limit ! 0, in which case we recover the Gaussian kernel .xx0 /2 1 p D lim K.x0 ; x; t/ e 2t &0 2 t .xx0 /2 .xx0 /2 1 p 1 p D p I1=2 . /e e 2t C ˇ p J1=2 . /e e 2t t t .xx0 /2 .xx0 /2 p 1 1 D p e 2t C ˇ p J1=2 . /e e 2t ; t 2 t
since we take D 1=2 in I . / D p
1 2
e
1 . 2 1 / 2 4
C O.1= 2 /;
and hence we need to choose ˇ D 0 in relation (3.18.71).
Chapter 4
Commuting Operators
4.1 Commuting Operators If X and Y are two vector fields, or in general, two operators which commute, i.e., X Y D YX , then it is obvious that their squares also commute. If L D 12 .X 2 C Y 2 / with ŒX 2 ; Y 2 D 0, then the problem of finding the heat kernel for L is reduced to the same problem for the operators X 2 and Y 2 , with e t .X
2 CY 2 /
2
2
D e tX e t Y :
The aforementioned formula is reminiscent from stochastic calculus, where if the operators 12 X 2 and 12 Y 2 are generators for certain independent Ito diffusion processes, then their joint density function is a product of their individual density functions. A similar formula holds in the general case of n commuting vector fields. The nontrivial problem occurs when X 2 and Y 2 do not commute, in which case the heat kernel can be obtained either by using Trotter’s formula and path integrals (see Chap. 7), or by using the geometric method (see Chap. 3). We shall provide a few examples below that can be reduced to a commuting sum of squares of two vector fields.
4.1.1 The Operator L D 12 .@x2 C @y2 / This is an elementary example of reducing the two-dimensional Laplacian problem to a one-dimensional Laplacian problem. Since the operators @2x and @2y commute, we can write .xx0 /2 .yy0 /2 1 1 1 2 1 2 e t L D e 2 t @x e 2 t @y D p p e 2t e 2t 2 t 2 t
D
1 .xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 2t e : 2 t
O. Calin et al., Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis, DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 4, c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
71
72
4 Commuting Operators
4.1.2 The Operator L D 12 .@x2 C y@y2 / Let .x; y/ 2 R.0; 1/. Since the operators @2x and y@2y commute, using Proposition 3.4.1, the heat kernel for L between .x0 ; 0/ and .x; y/ within time t is t t 2 t 2 2 2 K .x0 ; 0/; .x; y/I t D e t L D e 2 .@x Cy@y / D e 2 @x e 2 y@y .xx0 /2 4y 1 2 2t e e t y 2 1=2 t .2 t/ r 2 y 2t1 4y.xx0 /2 D2 e ; t 3=2
D
t > 0:
4.1.3 The Operator L D 12 .x@x2 C y@y2 / The operator is defined on the domain .x; y/ 2 .0; 1/ .0; 1/. Since the operators x@2x and y@2y commute, using Proposition 3.4.1 we have t 2 t 2 K .0; 0/; .x; y/I t D e t L D e 2 x@x e 2 y@y D
4x 2 x 4y 2 y 4xy 2 e t e t D 4 e t .xCy/ ; t2 t2 t
t > 0:
The graph of this heat kernel for t D 0:25 and x > 0, y > 0 is given by Fig. 4.1a.
4.1.4 Sum of Squares of Linear Potentials The following example will be useful in the sequel. It is obtained by applying the Fourier transform to the Heisenberg operator. Consider the noncommutative
Fig. 4.1 Heat kernel profiles for different operators. (a) 12 .x@2x C y@2y /; (b) 12 2 C 12 ! C 12 jxj2 ; (c) 12 .x 2 C y 2 /.@2x C @2y /
4.1 Commuting Operators
73
operators L1 D @x1 C ax2 and L2 D @x2 ax1 , with a 2 R constant. Construct the operator 1 2 .L C L22 / 2 1 a a2 1 D .@2x1 C @2x2 / C .x2 @x1 x1 @x2 / C .x12 C x22 / 2 2 2 2 a 1 a D 2 C ! C jxj2 ; 2 2 2
LD
a
where ! stands for the angular momentum. We note that e t 2 ! ı.0;0/ D ı.0;0/ . Since the operators ! and 12 C a2 jxj2 commute, the heat kernel for L is 1 a a2 2 t 2 2 K.x; yI t/ D e 2 .L1 CL2 / ı.0;0/ D e t 2 2 C 2 !C 2 jxj ı.0;0/ 2 1 a2 2 t 1 2 C a2 jxj2 t a 2 De e 2 ! ı.0;0/ D e t . 2 2 C 2 jxj / ı.0;0/ t
D e 2 .2 Ca D
2 jxj2 /
ı.0;0/
1 2at 2 2 1 2at e 2t sin.2at / Œ.jxj Cjyj / cos.2at /2hx; yi ; 2 t sin.2at/
t > 0:
The shape of the heat kernel for the values a D 1 and t D 0:05 is given in Fig. 4.1b.
4.1.5 The Operator L D 12 .x 2 C y 2 /.@x2 C @y2 / Assume .x; y/; .x0 ; y0 / 6D .0; 0/. Using the representation in polar coordinates x D r cos , y D r sin , the operator can be written as a sum of two operators in variables r and : .x 2 C y 2 /.@2x C @2y / D .r 2 @2r C r@r / C @2 : Using formulas which will be proved in Sect. 6.3, we have t
K.x0 ; y0 ; x; yI t/ D e 2 .x
2 Cy 2 /.@2 C@2 / x y
t
2 2
t
2
D e 2 .r @r Cr@r / e 2 @ r r 1 r 2 Cr 2 . 0 /2 1 0 0 D e 2t I0 p e 2t 2t t 2 t r r 1 2 2 2 0 e 2t r0 Cr C. 0 / ; D 1=2 .2t/3=2 I0 t
t; r; r0 > 0;
74
4 Commuting Operators
where I0 is the Bessel function of the first kind of order zero. The profile of the heat kernel with r0 D 1, 0 D 0 and t D 0:2 is depicted in Fig. 4.1c.In the view of the geometric method (see Chap. 3), the term 1=2 .2t/3=2 I0 r0t r represents the volume element, while d 2 .r0 ; 0 /; .r; / D r02 C r 2 C . 0 /2 is the square of the associated Riemannian distance.
Chapter 5
The Fourier Transform Method
The Fourier transform has been known as one of the most powerful and useful methods of finding fundamental solutions for operators with constant coefficients. Sometimes the application of a partial Fourier transform might be more useful than the full Fourier transform. In this chapter, by the application of the partial Fourier transform, we shall reduce the problem of finding the heat kernel of a complicated operator to a simpler problem involving an operator with fewer variables. After solving the problem for this simple operator, the inverse Fourier transform provides the heat kernel for the initial operator represented under an integral form. In general, this integral cannot be computed explicitly, but in certain particular cases it actually can be worked out. We shall also apply this method to some degenerate operators.
5.1 The Algorithm If L is a partial differential operator in variables .x; y/ 2 Rn R, then the heat kernel K.x0 ; y0 ; x; yI t/ D v.x; yI t/ satisfies @t v D Lxy v; lim v.x; yI t/ D ıx0 .x/ ˝ ıy0 .y/;
t &0
where ıa is the Dirac distribution centered at a. Let u.x; I t/ D Fy .v/.x; I t/, where Fy denotes the partial Fourier transform with respect to y: Z .Fy v/.x; I t/ D
e iy v.x; yI t/ dy: R
Then u satisfies the equation @t u D Px u; u.x; I 0/ D ıx0 .x/ ˝ I ;
O. Calin et al., Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis, DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 5, c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
75
76
5 The Fourier Transform Method
where Px is obtained from Lxy by replacing @2y by i . In order to recover v, we need to apply the inverse Fourier transform on u: v.x; yI t/ D .F1 u/.x; I t/: The following formulas will be useful in the sequel: 1 F .Lu/; where uL .x/ D u.x/; 2 1=2 2 2 e x =.4a/ ; a > 0; F .e a /.x/ D a F 1 .u/ D
F .ı/ D I;
F .I/ D 2ı:
5.2 Heat Kernel for the Grushin Operator The two-dimensional, two-step Grushin operator is defined as the sum of squares G D
1 2 1 .X C Y 2 / D .@2x C x 2 @2y /; 2 2
where X D @x and Y D x@y . The heat kernel satisfies @t v D G v;
t > 0;
lim v.x; yI t/ D ıx0 .x/ ˝ ıy0 .y/:
t &0
Let u D Fy .v/ be the partial Fourier transform of v with respect to y. Then u satisfies @t u D
1 2 .@ u x 2 2 u/; 2 x
t > 0;
u.x; I 0/ D ıx0 .x/ ˝ I : The solution is t
2
u.x; I t/ D e 2 .@x x
22 /
.ıx0 .x/ ˝ I /:
(5.2.1)
By Theorem 3.16.1, the kernel of the Hermite operator 12 @2x 12 2 x 2 is s K.x0 ; xI t/ D p
1 2 t
t 1 t e 2t sinh.t / sinh.t/
.x 2 Cx02 / cosh. t /2xx0
;
t > 0:
5.3 Heat Kernel for @2x C x@x @y
77
Applying an inverse Fourier transform with respect to in (5.2.1) yields 1 v.x; yI t/ D 2
Z
e iy u.x; I t/ d s ( Z ) t 1 2 Cx 2 / cosh. t /2xx 1 1 t 2t .x iy 0 0 sinh.t / e d e D p 2 2 t sinh.t/ Z r
.let D t /
=t 2 2 1 e iy=t 2 sinh .x Cx0 / cosh./2xx0 d .2 t/2 sinh Z r 1 1 2 2 p D e fiy 2 .x Cx0 / coth sinh xx0 g=t d: 3=2 sinh .2/ t
D
If we let 1 xx0 ; f .x0 ; x; yI / D iy C .x 2 C x02 / coth C 2 sinh r ; V ./ D sinh
(5.2.2) (5.2.3)
we obtain the following form: v.x; yI t/ D
Z
1
.2/
p 3=2
t
e f .x0 ;x;yI/=t V ./ d;
t > 0;
where f is called the modified complex action (see also [16]), and V ./ is the volume element. Formula (5.2.2) cannot be reduced to just an elementary function, since the Grushin operator does not have a heat kernel of the function type. This result is true for most sub-elliptic operators given as a sum of squares.
5.3 Heat Kernel for @x2 C x@x @y The heat kernel of the operator L D @2x C x@x @y satisfies @t v D @2x v C x@x @y v;
t > 0;
lim v.x; yI t/ D ıx0 .x/ ˝ ıy0 .y/:
t &0
Let u D Fy .v/ be the partial Fourier transform of v with respect to y. Then u satisfies @t u D @2x i x@x u; u.x; I 0/ D ıx0 .x/ ˝ I :
t > 0;
78
5 The Fourier Transform Method
The solution is 2
u.x; I t/ D e t .@x i x@x / .ıxx0 ˝ I /:
(5.3.4)
By Theorem 10.29 of [24], the fundamental solution of @t @2x C i x@x is s K.x0 ; xI t/ D p
1 4t
t 1 t e 4t sin.t / sin.t/
.x 2 Cx02 / cos. t /2xx0
;
t > 0:
Applying the inverse Fourier transform, we obtain 1 2
Z
e iy u.x; I t/ d s ( Z ) t 1 2 Cx 2 / cos. t /2xx 1 1 t 4t .x iy 0 0 sin.t / d p e e D 2 4 t sin.t/
v.x; yI t/ D
Z r
1 1 i y e t 4t sin 4.t/3=2 Z 1 D V ./e f =t d; 4.t/3=2
D
2xx .x 2 Cx02 / cot sin 0
.let D t /
d
(5.3.5)
with r V ./ D
; sin
f .x0 ; x; yI / D iy C
1 2 2xx0 .x C x02 / cot : 4 sin
It is remarkable that heat kernel formulas (5.2.2) and (5.3.5) are similar; just the modified complex actions and the volume elements are different. This leads to the question of whether this is a universal formula for sub-elliptic-type operators.
5.4 The Formula of Beals, Gaveau and Greiner In this section we shall consider a sub-elliptic operator with one degenerate direction of the type n 1 X LD aij @xi @xj C .x/@y : 2 i;j D1
In general, heat kernels in this case can be represented as an integral, which usually does not integrate to yield a function-type kernel. The degenerate direction can be
5.4 The Formula of Beals, Gaveau and Greiner
79
eliminated by applying a partial Fourier transform in the y-variable. Let v be the fundamental solution for the sub-elliptic operator L: Lv D 0;
t > 0;
lim v.x; yI t/ D ıx ˝ ıy :
t &0
Let u.x; I t/ D Fy v.x; yI t/ be the partial Fourier transform of v with respect to y. Then u satisfies Pu D 0; t > 0; lim u.x; I t/ D ıx ˝ I ;
t &0
where PD
n 1 X aij @xi @xj i .x/ 2 i;j D1
is an elliptic operator with potential U.x/ D i .x/. If we treat as a real parameter, then u becomes the heat kernel for the operator P P. Now we P shall assume that the potential is at most quadratic, i.e., .x/ D bij xi xj C cj xj C k, so the geodesic joining any two points is unique. The geometric method or the path integral method yields in this case a fundamental solution of the type u.x; ; t/ D V .t; /e Scl; where Scl is the classical action associated with the operator P. This is obtained by integrating the Lagrangian LD
n 1 X aij pi pj C i .x/ 2 i;j D1
along the geodesics. The parameter can be considered as a Lagrange multiplier that depends on the endpoints of the geodesic. Taking the inverse Fourier transform yields the heat kernel for the sub-elliptic operator L: v.x; y; t/ D F1 u.x; I t/ D
1 2
Z
e iy V .t; /e Scl .x0 ;x;t I/ d : (5.4.6)
We shall assume that in the formula of Scl the variables t and come as a product, so we can write D t. Let g.x0 ; x; / D tScl .x0 ; x; tI /:
80
5 The Fourier Transform Method
Under this hypothesis, the variables t and will also come as a product in the formula of V . This follows from the van Vleck formula s 1 @2 Scl V D det : 2 @x @x0 Consider the function W ./ D V .t; /. Then formula (5.4.6) becomes Z 1 W ./e iy.=t / e Scl .x0 ;x;/ d.=t/ 2 Z 1 W ./e Œiyg.x0 ;x;/=t d./ D 2 t Z 1 W ./e f .x0 ;x;/=t d./; D 2 t
v.x; yI t/ D
(5.4.7)
where f .x0 ; x; / D iy C g.x0 ; x; / is called the modified complex action function. The interested reader can find more details about finding the complex action function by methods of complex Hamiltonian mechanics in Chap. 5 of [28]. Formula (5.4.7) was first shown in the case of the Heisenberg operator in the work of Beals, Gaveau and Greiner [16, 48].
5.5 Kolmogorov Operators This section deals with the case of a degenerate operator for which the integral formula (5.4.7) actually does integrate exactly, providing a closed-form formula for the heat kernel. The operator LD
1 2 @ x@y 2 x
(5.5.8)
was first studied by Kolmogorov [80], who constructed its heat kernel as a transition probability of a diffusion process. We note that the operator is degenerate in the y-direction and is not a sum of squares of vector fields. This section is based on the results obtained in Calin and Chang [27]. Let K be the heat kernel for L, and denote by u D Fy K the partial Fourier transform with respect to the y-variable. Then 1 2 @ u i xu; 2 x u.x; yI t/ D ıx0 .x/ ˝ I : @t u D
5.5 Kolmogorov Operators
81
Denote a D i , and consider it a parameter. Then u is the heat kernel for the operator PD
1 2 @ ax: 2 x
Applying Theorem 3.15.1 yields u.x0 ; xI t/ D p D p
1 2 t 1 2 t
e e
.xx0 /2 2t
1 2 3 1 2 a.xCx0 /t C 24 a t
.xx0 /2 2t
1 2 3 1 2 i .xCx0 /t 24 t
:
The heat kernel of L can be obtained by taking the inverse Fourier transform: Z
K.x0 ; y0 ; x; yI t/ D
1 2
D
1 2
D
.xx0 /2 1 p e 2t 2 2 t
e i.yy0 / u.x; I t/ d Z p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 1 2 3 24 t Ci Œ.yy0 / 1 2t 2 .xCx0 /t
Z
1
e 24
d
2 t 3 Ci Œ.yy / 1 .xCx /t 0 0 2
d :
(5.5.9) Let
1 A D A.x0 ; x; y0 ; y; t/ D .y y0 / .x C x0 /t: 2 If we complete the square, the exponent becomes
h i 1 1 t3 n 24 o 1 2 3 .i /2 Ci 3 A t Ci .y y0 / .xCx0 /t D 2 t 3 Ci A D 24 2 24 24 t 12 2 12A 2 o t 3 n i C 3 A D 24 t t3 12 2 6A2 t3 i C 3 A 3 : D 24 t t
The integral can be written as an integral along a line: Z e
1 2 t 3 Ci A 24
d D e
2
6A3 t
Z
3
e
t .i 12 A/2 24 3 t
d D e
2
6A3
Z
t3 2
e 24 z d z;
t
I m zDb
(5.5.10)
82
5 The Fourier Transform Method 3 2
where b D 12 A. Let R > 0. Using that f .z/ D e t z =24 is holomorphic, the t3 integral along the rectangular contour .R; 0/; .R; b/; .R; b/; .R; 0/ vanishes, so Z e I m zDb
t3 2 24 z
(Z
R
3
d z D lim
e
R!1
t 24 y2
Z
R
Z
t3
2
e 24 .RCi/ i d
0
)
0
C
b
dy C
3
e
t 24 .RCi/2
Z
i d D
3
e
t 24 y2
b
p 2 6 dy D 3=2 ; t (5.5.11)
since
ˇ t3 ˇ t3 2 2 ˇ 24 .RCi/2 ˇ ˇe ˇ D e 24 .R / ! 0;
for R ! 1:
We also note that the computation could be short-cut by the use of Proposition 1.6.1. Using (5.5.10) and (5.5.11), (5.5.9) yields p 2 .xx0 /2 1 6A3 2 6 2t t K.x0 ; y0 ; x; yI t/ D p e t 3=2 2 2 t p 2 2 0 / 6 yy 1 .xCx /t 3 .xx 0 2 0 2t 3 t D e : t2 Theorem 5.5.1. The heat kernel of the sub-elliptic operator 12 @2x x@y is given by p
K.x0 ; y0 ; x; yI t/ D
2 0/ 6 3 .xx 2t t3 e t2
yy0 1 2 .xCx0 /t
2 ;
t > 0:
One may consider Kolmogorov operators of the type 12 @2x x m @y . The previous method provides heat kernels only for the values m D 0; 1; 2. In the following we shall treat the case m D 0. We need the following result. Lemma 5.5.2. The heat kernel for the operator 12 @2x a, with a 2 C, is .xx0 /2 1 e 2t at : u.x0 ; x; y0 ; yI t/ D p 2 t
Proof. The associated Hamiltonian and Lagrangian are H D 12 p a and L D 1 2 xP C a. The Euler–Lagrange equation is xR D 0, with the boundary conditions 2 x.0/ D x0 , x.t/ D x. The classical action is Scl D
.x x0 /2 C at: 2t
5.5 Kolmogorov Operators
83
The fundamental solution has the form s u.x0 ; x; y0 ; yI t/ D
1 @2 Scl Scl det e 2 @x @x0
D p
1
e
2 t
.xx0 /2 2t
at
:
Let K be the heat kernel for the sub-elliptic operator 12 @2x @y . Then u D Fy K is the heat kernel for the operator 12 @2x i . Applying Lemma 5.5.2 with a D i yields Z
KD
1 2
D
1 2
D
.xx0 /2 1 1 p e 2t 3=2 .2/ t
e i.yy0 / u.x0 ; x; I t/ d Z e i.yy0 / p
1 2 t
e Z
.xx0 /2 i t 2t
d
e i .yy0 t / d
.xx0 /2 1 D p e 2t ˝ ıy0 Ct .y/; 2 t
where we have used the formula for the Dirac distribution Z
1.x/ D 2ı0 .x/: e i x d D b
To conclude, we have the following result: Proposition 5.5.3. The heat kernel for the operator 12 @2x @y is K.x0 ; x; y0 ; yI t/ D p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
˝ ıy0 Ct .y/:
We shall next find the heat kernel for the operator 12 @2x C ix 2 @y . After applying a partial Fourier transform with respect to y, we obtain the Hermite operator 1 2 @ x 2 with the heat kernel 2 x 1 u.x0 ; x; t/ D p 2
r
1 2 a 2 a e 2 sinh.at / Œ.x Cx0 / cosh.at /2xx0 ; sinh.at/
t > 0;
84
5 The Fourier Transform Method
with a2 D 2; see Theorem 3.16.1. The inverse Fourier transform yields the heat kernel for the operator 12 @2x C ix 2 @y : 1 KD 2
Z e i.yy0 / u.x0 ; x; I t/ d
r Z 2 a 2 2 a 1 1 i.yy0 / a2 1 2 sinh.at / Œ.x Cx0 / cosh.at /2xx0 D e a da 2 .2/3=2 sinh.at/ Z a2 1 a 2 2 1 a 3=2 ae i.yy0 / 2 2 sinh.at / Œ.x Cx0 / cosh.at /2xx0 da: D 5=2 2
We note that in this case the heat kernel has an integral representation that cannot be reduced to a function. In the rest of the section we shall study the sub-elliptic operator LD
1 2 .@ C @2x2 / C .x1 x2 /@y ; 2 x1
(5.5.12)
which can be regarded as a two-dimensional Kolmogorov operator. If K denotes the heat kernel for L, then u D Fy K is the heat kernel for the operator PD
1 2 .@ C @2x2 / C i .x1 x2 /: 2 x1
(5.5.13)
u can be obtained by letting a1 D a2 D i in Theorem 3.15.3: u.x0 ; x; I t/ D D
1 jxx0 j2 1 ha;xCx0 it C 1 jaj2 t 3 2t 2 24 e 2 t 1 jxx0 j2 i h;xCx0 it 2 t 3 2t 2 12 ; e 2 t
with D .1; 1/ 2 R2 . Let A D .y y0 / 12 h; x C x0 it. The heat kernel of (5.5.12) is obtained by taking the inverse Fourier transform: KD
Fy1 u
1 D 2 D
Z e i.yy0 / u.x0 ; x; I t/ d
jxx0 j2 1 2t e .2/2 t
Z
e
2t 3 12
The second formula of Proposition 1.6.1 yields Z
2 3
e
12t Ci A
De
2
3A3 t
p 2 3 ; t 3=2
Ci A
d :
(5.5.14)
5.7 The Generalized Grushin Operator
1 2
Pn
2 2 2 iD1 @xi C 2jxj @t
85
and substituting in (5.5.14), we arrive at the following result: Theorem 5.5.4. The heat kernel of the operator (5.5.12) is p
K.x0 ; y0 ; x; yI t/ D
jxx0 j2 2 3 33 Œ.yy0 / 1 2t 2 h;xCx0 it t e 3=2 5=2 2 t
with t > 0 and vector D .1; 1/.
5.6 The Operator 12 @x2 C x@y2 The operator L D 12 @2x C x@2y resembles the Kolmogorov operator, but it has a higher derivative in y. Its heat kernel can be obtained in a similar way, but it is not of a function type. Applying the Fourier transform with respect to y, we arrive at the operator P D
1 2 @ x 2 ; 2 x
which according to Theorem 3.15.1 has the heat kernel given by u.x0 ; x; tI / D p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
1 4 3 2 1 2 .xCx0 /t C 24 t
:
The heat kernel for the sub-elliptic operator L is obtained by applying the inverse Fourier transform: 1 2
Z
e i.yy0 / u.x0 ; x; tI / d Z .xx0 /2 1 1 1 3 4 2 2t e i.yy0 / 2 .xCx0 /t C 24 t d ; D e 3=2 1=2 .2/ t
K.x0 ; x; y0 ; y; t/ D
which is an integral that cannot be worked out by elementary functions since the exponent is of the fourth degree.
5.7 The Generalized Grushin Operator
1 2
Pn
i D1
@x2 i C 2jxj2 @t2
Consider the sub-elliptic operator 1 Ln D 2
n X kD1
! Xi2
CY
2
1X 2 @xi C 2jxj2 @2t ; 2 n
D
i D1
(5.7.15)
86
5 The Fourier Transform Method
where Xk D @xk , Y D 2jxj@t are vector fields on RnC1 . It is worth noting that L1 D 12 @2x C 2x 2 @2t is the two-dimensional Grushin operator treated in Sect. 5.2. In the following we shall find the heat kernel for Ln . Applying the Fourier transform in t, we obtain the operator 1X 2 @xi 2 2 jxj2 : 2 n
P D
i D1
Making a D 2 in Sect. 3.17, we obtain the following heat kernel for P : u.x0 ; x; tI / D
sinh.2t/
n=2
e sinh.2t / Œ.jxj
2 Cjx
2 0 j / cosh.2 t /2hx;x0 i
;
t > 0:
The inverse Fourier transform in t provides the heat kernel for the operator Ln : KD
1 2
1 D 2
Z e i.yy0 / u.x0 ; x; tI / d Z
sinh.2t/
n=2
e i.yy0 / sinh.2t / Œ.jxj
2 Cjx j2 / cosh.2 t /2hx;x i 0 0
d :
Changing the variable D t yields Z
n=2 2 2 2 2 1 e fi.yy0 /.jxj Cjx0 j / coth.2/C sinh.2 / hx;x0 ig=t d 2 t sinh.2/ t n=2 Z 2 2 2 2 1 D e fi.yy0 /.jxj Cjx0 j / coth.2/C sinh.2 / hx;x0 ig=t d : 1C n sinh.2/ 2 .2 t/
KD
1 2
We have arrived at the following result: Theorem 5.7.1. The heat kernel for the sub-elliptic operator 1X 2 @xi C 2jxj2 @2t 2 n
Ln D
i D1
is given by K.x0 ; x; t/ D
Z
1 1C n 2
.2 t/
V ./e f .x0 ;x;t;/=t d ;
(5.7.16)
with V ./ D
2 sinh.2/
n=2 ;
f .x0 ; x; t; / D i.y y0 / C .jxj2 C jx0 j2 / coth.2/
2 hx; x0 i: sinh.2/
5.8 The Heisenberg Laplacian
87
Formula (5.7.16) agrees with the formula obtained by Beals, Gaveau and Greiner for sub-elliptic operators [16], where f and V stand for the complex modified action and volume element, respectively.
5.8 The Heisenberg Laplacian Consider on R2nC1 the following 2n vector fields: Xj D @xj C 2xnCj @t ;
XnCj D @xnCj 2xj @t ;
j D 1; : : : ; n;
called the Heisenberg vector fields. The commutation relations are ŒXnCj ; Xj D 4@t ;
ŒXj ; Xk D 0 for jk j j 6D n:
The vector fields Xk together with @t are left invariant with respect to the following group law on R2nC1 : 0 .x; t/ ı .x 0 ; t 0 / D @x C x 0 ; t C t 0 C 2
n X
1 0 .xnCj xj0 xj xnCj /A :
j D1
This group is denoted by Hn and is called the Heisenberg group. The sub-elliptic operator H
2n 1X 2 D Xk 2 kD1
is called the Heisenberg Laplacian. In this section we shall determine the heat kernel for H . A computation yields H
2n 2n n X 1X 2 1X 2 2 2 D Xk D @xk C 2jxj @t C 2 xnCj @xj xj @xnCj @t 2 2 kD1
j D1
kD1
D Ln C 2 @t ; where Ln is the Grushin operator (5.7.15) and
D
n X j D1
xnCj @xj xj @xnCj
88
5 The Fourier Transform Method
is the angular momentum operator. A computation shows that ŒLn ; D 0. Using the property of the semigroup generated by the sum of two operators which commute, we have e t H D e t Ln C2t @t D e t Ln e 2t @t : Since e 2t @t D I at x D 0, it follows that e 2t @t ıx D Iıx D ıx . Then the heat kernel of H at x0 D 0 is K.0; x; t/ D e t H ı.x/ D e t Ln e 2t @t ı.x/ D e t Ln ı.x/ D u.0; x; t/; where u is the heat kernel of the operator Ln at x0 D 0, which is obtained from Theorem 5.7.1. Making x0 D y0 D 0 and replacing n by 2n in formula (5.7.16), we obtain Theorem 5.8.1. The heat kernel for the Heisenberg Laplacian H starting from the origin is given by K.0; x; t/ D
1 .2 t/nC1
Z
V ./e f .x;t;/=t d ;
with the volume element and complex modified action given by V ./ D
2 n ; sinh.2/
f .x; t; / D i.y/ C jxj2 coth.2/:
(5.8.17)
Chapter 6
The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
Finding the heat kernel of an elliptic operator on a compact manifold using the eigenvalues method is a well-known method in mathematical physics and quantum mechanics. Roughly speaking, the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of an operator determine its heat kernel. The formula is an infinite series that involves products of eigenfunctions; see Theorem 6.1.1. It is interesting that in several cases this series can be written as an elementary function by using the associated bilinear generating function. We shall present applications of the bilinear generating formulas of Mehler, Hille–Hardy, and Poisson. The main disadvantage of this method is that in general the bilinear generating formula is missing, in which case the series that represents the heat kernel cannot be represented as a function. This fact is not surprising, since many heat kernels are not of the function type. Since this method involves a great deal of work with special functions, we shall refer the reader to the useful book of Erd´elyi [41].
6.1 General Results Consider the self-adjoint differential operator L defined on the interval I and let fi be its eigenfunctions Lfi D i fi ;
i D 0; 1; : : : ;
with i 2 R eigenvalues. We shall R assume that ffi gi 0 is a complete orthogonal system of L2 .I / D ff W I ! C I I jf j2 < 1g, i.e., Z I
fn .x/fm .x/ dx D ınm ;
and for any 2 L2 .I / with Z I
.x/fn .x/ dx D 0;
8n D 0; 1; : : :
H) D 0:
O. Calin et al., Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis, DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 6, c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
89
90
6 The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
Then for any 2 L2 .I /, we can write .x/ D
X
hfi ; ifi .x/;
i 0
Z where hfi ; i D
I
fi .x/.x/ dx.
The next result provides a formal expression for the heat kernel. Proposition 6.1.1. Let ffi gi be an orthogonal complete system of L2 .I / of real eigenfunctions of operator L. Then the heat kernel of L is given by K.x0 ; x; t/ D
X
e i t fi .x0 /fi .x/:
(6.1.1)
i 0
Proof. We shall check the definition properties of the heat kernel .@t L/K.x0 ; x; t/ D
X i e i t fi .x0 /fi .x/ e i t fi .x0 /Lfi .x/ i 0
X i e i t fi .x0 /fi .x/ e i t fi .x0 /i fi .x/ D i 0
D 0: We also need to check the following limit in the distribution sense: lim K.x0 ; x; t/ D ıx0 :
t &0
For any smooth function with compact support, we have Z lim
t &0 I
K.x0 ; x; t/.x/ dx D lim
X
t &0
D
X Z X
Z
I
I
i 0
i 0
D
e
i t
fi .x/.x/ dx fi .x0 /
fi .x/.x/ dx fi .x0 /
hfi ; ifi .x0 / D .x0 / D ıx0 ./:
i 0
Hence the heat kernel is given by formula (6.1.1).
Remark 6.1.2. If the eigenfunctions fn are complex, the heat kernel of L is given by X e i t fi .x0 /fi .x/: K.x0 ; x; t/ D i 0
6.2 Mehler’s Formula and Applications
91
6.2 Mehler’s Formula and Applications In this section we show how a bilinear generating function involving Hermite polynomials, called Mehler’s formula, is reducing the series (6.1.1) to a function in the case of the Hermite operator. We shall start first with some prerequisites regarding Hermite polynomials. The Hermite polynomial Hn .x/ of order n is defined by 2 2 Hn .x/ D .1/n e x .d=dx/n e x D 2n x n C : : : : Using repetitive integration by parts, we obtain Z
8Z m m x 2 ˆ dx D 0; if n < m, ˆ < Hn .x/.1/ .d=dx/ e R
2
R
Hn .x/Hm .x/e x dx D
ˆ ˆ :
Z
R
p 2 .Hn /.n/ .x/e x D 2n nŠ ;
if n D m.
This can be written as Z
2
R
Hn .x/Hm .x/e x dx D 2n nŠ 1=2 ınm ;
where ınm denotes the Kronecker delta function. The graphs of a few Hermite polynomials are sketched in Fig. 6.1. Hence fn .x/ D
e x
2 =2
2n=2
p
Hn .x/
nŠ 1=4
n D 0; 1; : : : ;
;
(6.2.2)
forms an orthogonal system in L2 .R/. One may show that it is also a complete system.
a
b
c
60
100
40 20 -2
-1
-2 1
-20
500
50
2
-1
1 -50 -100
2
-2
-1
1 -500
Fig. 6.1 The graphs of a few Hermite polynomials Hn .x/: .a/ n D 4; .b/ n D 5; .c/ n D 6
2
92
6 The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
Lemma 6.2.1 (Generating function formula). We have X
Hn .x/
n0
yn 2 D e 2xyy : nŠ 2
Proof. Taylor’s formula for F .y/ D e .xy/ yields F .y/ D
X F .n/ .0/ nŠ
n0
.1/n y n D e x
2
X
Hn .x/
n0
yn ; nŠ
and hence X
Hn .x/
n0
yn 2 2 2 2 D e x F .y/ D e x .xy/ D e 2xyy : nŠ
The following result deals with the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the Hermite operator @2x x 2 . Proposition 6.2.2. The functions given by (6.2.2) satisfy .@2x x 2 /fn .x/ D .2n C 1/fn .x/; 2
Proof. Let F .y/ D e 2xyy D 2y
P n0
Hn .x/ n y nŠ
and
n D 0; 1; : : : :
(6.2.3)
D 12 x 2 C 2xy y 2 . Then
X 1 2 1 2 @ yn Hn .x/e 2 x 2n : e D 2ye 2 x F 0 .y/ D @y nŠ n0
(6.2.4)
And applying (6.2.4), we have .@2x x 2 C 1/e
De De
2 x
C
xx
x2 C 1
.x C 2y/2 x 2 D 2ye .2x 2y/
D 2y
X @ 1 2 yn e D Hn .x/e 2 x .2n/ : @y nŠ n0
(6.2.5)
On the other hand, we have .@2x x 2 C 1/e
i h 1 2 D @2x x 2 C 1 e 2 x F .y/ D
i y n X h 1 2 : @2x x 2 C 1 Hn .x/e 2 x nŠ n0
(6.2.6)
6.2 Mehler’s Formula and Applications
93
Comparing the coefficients of the power series (6.2.5) and (6.2.6) yields 2 1 2 1 2 @x x 2 Hn .x/e 2 x D .2n C 1/Hn .x/e 2 x ;
which is proportional to (6.2.3). Lemma 6.2.3 (Mehler’s formula). If Hn is the nth Hermite polynomial, then e .x
2 Cy 2 /
2 2 2 1 X zn e .x Cy 2xyz/=.1z / H .x/H .y/ D p : n n 2n nŠ 1 z2 nD0
For the proof, the interested reader can look in Erd´elyi [41], Vol. 2, p. 194. As an application of Mehler’s formula, we shall find a closed-form expression for the heat kernel K.x0 ; x; t/ of the operator @2x x 2 . The heat kernel as an eigenfunction expansion is given by Proposition 6.1.1. Using Proposition 6.2.2, the heat kernel is X K.x0 ; x; t/ D e n t fn .x0 /fn .x/ n0
D
X
1 1 1 2 2 e .2nC1/t e 2 .x0 Cx / p n Hn .x0 /Hn .x/ 2 nŠ n0
X .e 2t /n e t 1 2 2 D p e 2 .x0 Cx / Hn .x0 /Hn .x/: 2n nŠ n0
(6.2.7)
Making z D e 2t and applying Mehler’s formula, (6.2.7) becomes 2
2 2
.x Cx /z 2x0 xz 1 e t 1 2 2 0 1z2 e 2 .x0 Cx / e K.x0 ; x; t/ D p p 1 z2 2 1 e t Œ 1 .x 2 Cx 2 / 1Cz2 2x0 x z 2 : 1z 1z D p p e 2 0 1 z2
Since p
r
e t 1
z2
D
e 2t D 1 e 4t
r e 2t
1 1 D p ; 2t e 2 sinh.2t/
1 C e 4t e 2t C e 2t 1 C z2 D D D coth.2t/; 1 z2 1 e 4t e 2t e 2t z e 2t 1 ; D D 1 z2 1 e 4t 2 sinh.2t/
(6.2.8)
94
6 The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
formula (6.2.7) becomes the heat kernel of @2x x 2 : 1 1 1 2 2 e Œ 2 .x0 Cx / coth.2t /x0 x= sinh.2t / ; K.x0 ; x; t/ D p p 2 sinh.2t/
t > 0: (6.2.9)
6.3 Hille–Hardy’s Formula and Applications In this section we show how a bilinear generating function involving Laguerre polynomials, called Hille–Hardy’s formula, is reducing the series (6.1.1) to a function 2 in the case of the operator L D x@2x C @x 14 .b 2 x C ax /. Then we shall provide a couple of applications regarding the Bessel operator and an operator with gravitational potential in two dimensions. We shall first present some prerequisites regarding Laguerre polynomials. The Laguerre polynomial Lan of degree n and parameter a can be defined either by the Rodrigues formula Lan D
e x x a d n x nCa 1 x D .x/n C : : : ; n e nŠ dx nŠ
or equivalently, by the generating function formula X
Lan .x/y n D
n0
1 e xy=.y1/ : .1 y/aC1
(6.3.10)
It is worth noting that for the same degree n the graph does not depend essentially on the value of the parameter a; see Fig. 6.2. Applying integration by parts several times yields 8 Z 1 if n 6D m, < 0; Lan .x/Lam .x/e x x a dx D .a C n C 1/ : 0 ; if n D m. nŠ
a
b 40
600
100
20
400 200
50
10 2 -10
800
150
30
-2
c
4
6
8
10
12
5 -50
10
15
-200
5
10
15
20
25
-400 -600
Fig. 6.2 The graphs of the Laguerre polynomial La5 .x/ for a few distinct values of the parameter a: .a/ a D 0; .b/ a D 3; .c/ a D 9
6.3 Hille–Hardy’s Formula and Applications
95
Hence s fn .x/ D
nŠ e x=2 x a=2 Lan .x/; .a C n C 1/
n D 0; 1; : : : ;
(6.3.11)
forms an orthogonal system for L2 .0; 1/. One may show that the system is also complete. Proposition 6.3.1. The functions (6.3.11) are eigenfunctions for the operator L D x@2x C @x
1 a2 xC ; 4 x
with the corresponding eigenvalue n D n C
aC1 2
(6.3.12)
.
Proof. It comes from the generating formula (6.3.10) and the fact that y D Lan .x/ verifies the Laguerre equation xy 00 C .˛ C a x/y 0 C ny D 0: The following bilinear generating formula can be found in Erd´elyi [41], Vol. 2, p. 189. Proposition 6.3.2 (Hille–Hardy’s formula). If Lan denotes the Laguerre polynomial, and Ia is the modified Bessel function of first type of order a, then for jzj < 1 we have 1 X
.xCy/z nŠ 1 zn .xyz/a=2 Lan .x/Lan .y/ D e .1z/ Ia .n C a C 1/ .1 z/ nD0
p 2 xyz : 1z
In the following let z D e t and use that p
1 z D ; 1z 2 sinh.t=2/
1C
2z 1 C e t D coth.t=2/: D 1z 1 e t
By Proposition 6.1.1, the heat kernel for the operator (6.3.12) on .0; 1/ is given by K.x0 ; x; t/ D
X
e n t fn .x0 /fn .x/
n0
D
X
n0
a
t
e nt e 2 t e 2
p X 1 D e 2 .x0 Cx/ z
nŠ La .x0 /Lan .x/x0a=2 e x0 =2 x a=2 e x=2 .a C n C 1/ n
nŠ zn .x0 xz/a=2 Lan .x0 /Lan .x/ .a C n C 1/ n0
96
6 The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
p p z .x0 Cx/ z z 1 .x0 Cx/ 2 1z De Ia 2 x0 x e 1z 1z (by Hille–Hardy’s formula) 2z p 1 1 1 2 .x0 Cx/.1C 1z / Ia x0 x D e 2 sinh.t=2/ sinh.t=2/ p x0 x 1 1 .x0 Cx/ coth.t =2/ 2 Ia : e D 2 sinh.t=2/ sinh.t=2/ p
Hence the heat kernel of the operator LD
x@2x
1 a2 C @x xC 4 x
is given by the formula 1 1 K.x0 ; x; t/ D e 2 .x0 Cx/ coth.t =2/ Ia 2 sinh.t=2/
p x0 x ; sinh.t=2/
t > 0:
Next we shall present a slight generalization of the previous result. If we define L1 D L, then we shall find the kernel of the operator Lb D
x@2x
1 a2 2 b xC : C @x 4 x
Q 1 . Then If we take xQ D bx as a new variable, a computation shows that Lb D b L .e
t Lb
Z Q1 Q t bL f /.x0 / D e f .xQ 0 / D K.bx0 ; bx; bt/f .x0 /bdx0 ;
and hence the heat kernel of e t Lb is bK.bx0 ; bx; tb/; that is, b=2 b e 2 .x0 Cx/ coth.bt =2/ Ia Kb .x0 ; x; t/ D sinh.bt=2/
p b x0 x : sinh.bt=2/
(6.3.13)
Therefore, the heat kernel of the operator Lb is given by formula (6.3.13). We shall present next two applications. 2
a , then its heat kernel is Heat kernel for the Bessel operator. If L0 D x@2x C @x 4x obtained by making b ! 0 in the above relation: p 2 x0 x 1 1 K0 .x0 ; x; t/ D e t .x0 Cx/Ia ; (6.3.14) t t
where we used lim
b!0
bt=2 D 1: sinh.bt=2/
6.3 Hille–Hardy’s Formula and Applications
97
The change of variable x D r 2 in L0 yields a Bessel operator with potential a2 =r 2 : a2 a2 1 2 1 2 x@x C @x @ C @r 2 : D 4x 4 r r r Let D t=2. Since the following relation holds among the heat kernels e
a2 t x@2 x C@x 4x
De
t 4
2
1 2 a @2 r C r @r 2 r
De
2
1 2 a2 @2 r C r @r 2 r
;
2
then the heat kernel of 12 .@2r C 1r @2r ar 2 / is obtained from the heat kernel of x@2x C 2
a @x 4x by making the substitutions x0 D r02 , x D r 2 and D t=2 in formula (6.3.14). 2 Hence the heat kernel of 12 @2r C 1r @r ar 2 is
G.r0 ; r; / D
1 1 .r 2 Cr 2 / r0 r Ia : e 2 0 2
(6.3.15)
Operator with gravitational potential. In the following we shall present an application of formula (6.3.15) to a two-dimensional operator with gravitational potential; see [26]. We shall look for the heat kernel of the operator LD
2 1 2 ; @x1 C @2x2 2 2 x1 C x22
with 2 R:
(6.3.16)
In polar coordinates this becomes LD
2 1 2 1 1 @r C @r C 2 @2 2 : 2 r r r
If K is the heat kernel of the above operator, then applying a partial Fourier transform with respect to , we obtain that KO D F K is the heat kernel of the operator PD
1 1 2 1 a2 22 1 2 1 @r C @r 2 2 2 D @r C @r 2 ; 2 r r 2r 2 r r
with a2 D 22 C 2 . The heat kernel e t P can be obtained from the formula (6.3.14): O 0 ; r; I / D 1 e 21 .r02 Cr 2 / Ia r0 r : K.r 2
98
6 The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
Applying the inverse Fourier transform yields the heat kernel of the operator (6.3.16): Z r r 1 1 1 2 2 0 e i . 0 / e 2 .r0 Cr / I.22 C 2 /1=2 d K.r0 ; 0 ; r; ; / D 2 2 Z r r 1 1 .r 2 Cr 2 / 0 D e i. 0 / I.22 C 2 /1=2 d : e 2 0 4 Remark 6.3.3. In the case D 0 the above formula becomes Z r r 1 1 .r 2 Cr 2 / 0 2 0 d : e K.r0 ; 0 ; r; ; / D e i. 0 / I 4
(6.3.17)
On the other hand, the heat kernel for (6.3.16) with D 0 is given by 1 jxx0 j2 1 r02 Cr 2 2rr0 cos. 0 / 2 2 e e D : 2 t 2 t Comparing with (6.3.17) and making D 1 2
Z
r0 r
and u D 0 yields
e iu I . / d D e cos u :
6.4 Poisson’s Summation Formula and Applications Under some convergence and regularity conditions on the function f , we have the following summation formula, called Poisson’s summation formula (see [86]): 1 X nD1
f .x C 2n/ D
Z 1 1 X ikx 1 iky e e f .y/ dy: 2 1 kD1
As a consequence, we have the next result regarding the theta-function, which was introduced in Sect. 1.5. The result deals with the case of the 3 -function, but similar transformation formulas work for the other theta-functions. Proposition 6.4.1 (Jacobi’s transformation for 3 ). If t 0 D 1=t, we have 3 .zjt 0 / D .it/1=2 e itz
2 =
3 tzjt ;
(6.4.18)
where the third Jacobi theta-function is defined by 3 .zjt/ D
1 X nD1
e itn
2 C2nzi
:
(6.4.19)
6.4 Poisson’s Summation Formula and Applications
99
Proof. We note that we can write 3 .zjt/ D e
1 X
z2 =.i t /
it
2
e 4 .uC2n/ ;
nD1 2 =4
with u D 2z=t. Applying Poisson summation formula with f .u/ D e i t u
yields
Z 1 1 z2 = i t X iku 1 i ty 2 iky e e 4 dy e 3 .zjt/ D 2 1 D
1 z2 = i t e 2
D .i t/
kD1 1 X
e iku 2.i t/1=2 e i k
2 =t
kD1
1=2 z2 = i t
e
3 .z=t j 1=t/:
Replacing z by tz yields (6.4.18).
The interested reader can find details about the theta-functions in reference [86]. Next we shall present a few applications.
6.4.1 Heat Kernel on S 1 In this section we shall compute the heat kernel for the Laplacian on the unit circle S 1 using Jacobi’s transformation. If is the arc length on the unit circle, the d2 1 eigenfunctions of 12 d 2 on the circle S satisfy 1 d2 uk D k uk ; 2 d 2 where k D k 2 =2 and uk ./ D ck e ik . The constant ck can be obtained from the orthogonality condition Z 2 1 uk ./uk ./ d D 2ck2 H) ck D p : 1D 2 0 The functions uk ./ 2
D
p1 e ik 2
1
form a complete orthogonal system on
L .S ; d/. Therefore, the heat kernel for K.0 ; I / D D
X
e k
2 =2
1 d2 2 d 2
on the circle S 1 is given by 1 X k 2 =2 i k. 0 / e e 2 1 0 ˇˇ i ; 3 D ˇ 2 2 2
uk ./uk .0 / D
1 X k2 =2Ci k. 0 / e 2
100
6 The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
by the definition of the 3 given in (6.4.19). Denoting zD
0 ; 2
t0 D
i D 1=t; 2
t D 2 i=;
Jacobi’s transformation formula provides K.0 ; I / D
1 0 3 2 2
ˇ i 1 ˇ D 3 .zjt 0 / ˇ 2 2
1 2 .it/1=2 e itz = 3 .tzjt/ 2 ˇ 2 i i .0 /2 1 ˇ e 2 3 : . 0 / ˇ D p 2 D
(6.4.20)
This formula agrees with the geometric formula of the heat kernel for S 1 obtained in Sect. 3.11.
6.4.2 Heat Kernel on the Segment Œ0; T We shall determine the heat kernels on the segment Œ0; T with the Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions, respectively. Dirichlet boundary condition. In this case the temperature u.x; t/ is kept equal to zero at the endpoints x D 0; T all the time. A complete orthonormal system for the d2 Laplacian 12 dx 2 on Œ0; T is given by r uk .x/ D
kx 2 sin ; T T 2
2
with the corresponding eigenvalues k D k2T2 , k D 0; 1; : : : . For any two points x0 ; x 2 Œ0; T , the heat kernel can be expressed as K.x0 ; xI / D
X
e k uk .x0 /uk .x/
k0
D
2 X k2 22 kx0 kx e 2T sin sin T T T k1
D
1 X k2 22 h k.x C x0 / i k.x x0 / : (6.4.21) cos e 2T cos T T T k1
6.4 Poisson’s Summation Formula and Applications
101
Substituting z D .x ˙ x0 /=.2T / and t D =.2T 2 /, the previous series can be written in terms of theta-functions: " # X k2 2 k.x ˙ x0 / 1 2 e 2T cos 3 z j i t 1 D T 2 k1 " ! # .x ˙ x0 / ˇˇ i 1 3 1 ; D ˇ 2 2T 2T 2 and hence (6.4.21) becomes K.x0 ; xI / D
1 .x x0 / 3 2T 2T
ˇ i 1 .x C x0 / ˇ 3 ˇ 2 2T 2T 2T
ˇ i ˇ : (6.4.22) ˇ 2T 2
Even if (6.4.22) is a perfectly valid formula, we shall still transform it according to Poisson’s summation formula, obtaining the familiar term e i 0 / it. Taking z D .x˙x and t 0 D 2T 2 in formula (6.4.18) yields 2T 3
.x ˙ x0 / 2T
.x˙x0 /2 2
in front of
ˇ i 2T .x˙x0 /2 .x ˙ x0 /T i ˇˇ 2T 2 i ˇ 0 2 e 3 ; D 3 .zjt / D p ˇ ˇ 2T 2 2
and hence the heat kernel becomes " .xx0 /2 1 .x x0 /T i ˇˇ 2T 2 i 2 e 3 K.x0 ; xI / D p ˇ 2 # .xCx0 /2 .x C x0 /T i ˇˇ 2T 2 i 2 e 3 : ˇ Neumann boundary condition. In this case there is no leak of heat at the endpoints @ u.x; t/ D 0 for x D 0; T , and all of Œ0; T . This condition can be written as @x 2
d t 0. Then a complete orthonormal system for 12 dx 2 on Œ0; T with respect to the aforementioned boundary conditions is r kx 2 cos ; uk .x/ D T T 2
2
with the corresponding eigenvalues k D k2T2 , k D 0; 1; : : : . A computation similar to the one before provides the heat kernel: K.x0 ; xI / D
X
e k uk .x0 /uk .x/
k0
D
2 X k2 22 kx kx0 2 C cos e 2T cos T T T T k1
102
6 The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
20
1 X k2 2 / 1 4@ k.x C x 0 A 1C D e 2T 2 cos T T k1
0 C @1 C
X
e
2 2 k 2 2T
k1
D
1 3 T
.x C x0 / 2T
13 k.x x0 / A5 cos T
ˇ i 1 .x x0 / ˇ C ˇ 3 2T 2 T 2T
ˇ i ˇ : (6.4.23) ˇ 2T 2
Applying Poisson’s summation formula yields
K.x0 ; xI / D p
1 2
" e
.xCx0 /2 2
Ce
3
.xx0 /2 2
.x C x0 /T i
3
ˇ 2T 2 i ˇ ˇ
# .x x0 /T i ˇˇ 2T 2 i ; ˇ
which agrees with the geometric formula (3.12.37).
6.5 Legendre’s Polynomials and Applications Consider the operator @2 C cot @ :
(6.5.24)
If we make the change of variable cos D x, the operator becomes .1 x 2 /@2x 2x@x ;
x 2 .1; 1/:
(6.5.25)
The nth-degree Legendre polynomial Pn is defined by the Rodrigues formula Pn .x/ D
1 dn 2 .x 1/n : 2n nŠ dxn
Pn can also be defined by the following generating function: X n0
Pn .x/y n D
1 : .1 2xy C y 2 /1=2
6.5 Legendre’s Polynomials and Applications
a
b
1.0
103
c
1.0
0.6
0.8
0.5
0.4
0.6
0.2
0.4 -1.0
-0.5
0.5
0.2
1.0
-0.5
-1.0
-0.5
-0.2
-1.0 0.5
-0.5
1.0
0.5
1.0
-0.4 -0.6
-0.4
-1.0
-0.2
Fig. 6.3 The graphs of a few Legendre polynomials Pn .x/: .a/ n D 5; .b/ n D 10; .c/ n D 23
The graphs of three polynomials are contained in Fig. 6.3. One may show that Pn satisfies the equation .1 x 2 /@2x Pn .x/ 2x@x Pn .x/ D n.n C 1/Pn .x/; and hence Pn .x/ is an eigenfunction of the operator (6.5.25) with the corresponding eigenvalue n D n.n C 1/. Since Z
1 1
Pn .x/Pm .x/ dx D 0; Z
1 1
ŒPn .x/2 dx D
n 6D m;
1 ; n C 1=2
it follows that r fn .x/ D
1 n C Pn .x/; 2
n D 0; 1; 2 : : : ;
forms an orthogonal system on L2 .1; 1/. The system is also complete. By Proposition 6.1.1, the heat kernel for (6.5.25) on .1; 1/ is K.x; y; t/ D
X
.n C 1=2/e n.nC1/t Pn .x/Pn .y/;
n0
and hence the heat kernel for (6.5.24) is K.; ; t/ D
X
.n C 1=2/e n.nC1/t Pn .cos /Pn .cos /:
n0
In this case a bilinear generating function is missing, so the operator (6.5.24) does not have a function-type heat kernel.
104
6 The Eigenfunction Expansion Method
6.6 Legendre Functions and Applications In the following we shall deal with the heat kernel for the Laplacian on the sphere S 2 D fx 2 R3 I jxj D 1g. In spherical coordinates 2 .0; /, 2 Œ0; 2/, the Laplacian is given by S 2 D
1 @ @ 1 @2 : sin C sin @ @ .sin /2 @2 2
The eigenfunctions are given by the spherical harmonics Ymk .; / D cmk Pmjkj .cos /e i k ; where m D 0; 1; 2; : : : and k 2 f0; ˙ 1; : : : ; ˙ mg. Pmk denotes the Legendre function. Since S 2 Ymk D m.m C 1/Ymk ; the eigenvalue corresponding to Ymk is km D m2 m; see, for instance, [63], p. 74. The heat kernel is given by K.0 ; 0 I ; I t/ D D D
X X
k
e m t Ymk .; /Ymk .0 ; 0 / 2 e m.mC1/t Pmk .cos /e i k Pmk .cos 0 /e i k 0 cmk
X
e
m.mC1/t
m0
m X
2 cmk Pmk .cos /Pmk .cos 0 /e i k. 0 / :
kDm
A neater formula can be obtained if the kernel is represented in terms of the angle between x0 and x given by D cos1 .hx0 ; xi/. Even if the inverse cosine function is multi-valued, since the heat kernel is an even, 2-periodic function of , we may use any value of with cos D hx0 ; xi; see references [30, 106]. The heat kernel on S 2 can be written as Z 1 1 1 K.x0 ; xI t/ D p e t =4 p p 2 t 2 t cos cos
1 X 1 2 .1/n . 2 n/e 2t .2 n/ d : nD1
It is worth noting that in the case of the three-dimensional sphere there is a simple formula given by (3.7.33). To conclude this chapter, we note that the eigenfunction expansion technique is a robust method, which works as long as we are able to find an orthonormal set of functions and their eigenvalues. The heat kernel can be expressed in this case as an infinite series. There are only a few known cases when this series has a bilinear generating function, in which case the heat kernel has an elegant expression.
Chapter 7
The Path Integral Approach
7.1 Introducing Path Integrals In 1948 Feynman [42] provided an informal expression for the propagators of the famous Schr¨odinger equation, involving an integration over all the continuous paths with respect to a nonexistent infinite-dimensional Lebesgue measure. In fact, this is not really an integral, since there is no measure to give the integral. Since then, a large number of papers have tried to explain the precise mathematical meaning of the Feynman integral. In this chapter we do not attempt this direction. We are concerned only with the immediate applications of the concept of a Feynman integral to obtaining heat kernels for differential operators. In classical mechanics the particles follow trajectories provided by the Euler– Lagrange equations or Hamiltonian system. Given the initial conditions, standard theorems of ODE theory state the existence and uniqueness of the solution of the above systems of equations. This can be stated by saying that classical particles travel along deterministic trajectories. Unlike the aforementioned case, in quantum mechanics particles travel on nondeterministic trajectories. This was inferred from the double-slit experiment and was theoretically stated by the Heisenberg principle of uncertainty. Nondeterministic trajectories are better described by the notion of transition probability. Let P .c j a/ denote the probability that the particle is in state c given that it starts at state a. An application of the conditional probability rule yields that the previous probability depends on all the intermediate states b: P .c j a/ D
X
P .c j b/P .b j a/I
b
see Fig. 7.1b. In quantum mechanics the conditional probability P .c j a/ is replaced by the probability amplitude function 'ca , in which case the aforementioned rule becomes X 'cb 'ba : 'ca D b
O. Calin et al., Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis, DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 7, c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
105
106
7 The Path Integral Approach
a
b
b
P(c lb)
P(b la) b`
c
c
b’’
Fig. 7.1 .a/ Quantum particles do not travel on deterministic paths. .b/ Nondeterministic trajectories
b b c b Fig. 7.2 Intermediate states and probability amplitude functions
Assume the particle starts at a at time zero and ends at b at time t. Consider the following n intermediate states between a and c: a D b0 ; b1 ; : : : ; bn ; bnC1 D c; such that the particle is in state bk at time tk , k D 0; : : : ; n; see Fig. 7.2. The probability amplitude function between a and c can be written as 'ca D
X
'cbn 'bn bn1 : : : 'b2 b1 'b1 a :
b1 ;:::;bn
When the number of the intermediate states n ! 1, the linear function ab1 b2 bn c tends to a continuous path x.s/ with x.0/ D a and x.t/ D c. The “transition probability” from a to c at time t is obtained by summing over all the continuous paths between a and c parameterized by Œ0; t: 'a;cIt D
X
'x.s/ :
x.s/
A breakthrough idea came from Dirac, who indicated that 'x.s/ D e iS=„ for t small, where S satisfies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation and „ denotes the Planck
7.2 Paths Integrals via Trotter’s Formula
107
constant. The idea was continued by Feynman, who provided a heuristical expression for the propagator of Schr¨odinger’s operator in the form X e iS=„ ; K.a; cI t/ D C x.s/
with C D .2 i „t/n=2 , for n large. This was expressed later as the path integral written in the form Z K.a; cI t/ D e iS.;t /=„ dm./; (7.1.1) P.a;cIt /
where P.a; cI t/ D f W Œ0; t ! R I .0/ D x0 ; .t/ D xg denotes the space of the continuous paths from x0 to x within time t. The “propagator” K.x0 ; xI t/ given by (7.1.1) satisfies Schr¨odinger’s equation n
i„
„2 @ K C x K D U.x/K; @t 2
(7.1.2)
where S.; t/ is the solution of the Hamilton–Jacobi equation @S C H.; @ S / D 0; @t with the Hamiltonian H.x; p/ D
1 2 jpj C U.x/: 2
Feynman’s formula for the propagator of the Schr¨odinger equation can be adapted for the heat kernels by replacing t by i t and U.x/ by V .x/ in (7.1.2). If for the sake of simplicity we choose m D „ D 1, then Schr¨odinger’s equation becomes the following heat equation: 1 @K D x K C V .x/K: @t 2 In this chapter we shall deal with finding heat kernels for second-order differential operators using path integrals. Since any heat kernel can be expressed formally as a path integral, the problem of finding the heat kernel is to compute the path integral explicitly. As we shall see throughout the chapter, even if the computation is sometimes tedious, this can be done for several examples of operators.
7.2 Paths Integrals via Trotter’s Formula This section deals with the application of Trotter’s formula to a formal construction of path integrals as an infinite limit of improper integrals. Consider the heat equation @ D L; @t
(7.2.3)
108
7 The Path Integral Approach
where L D C V .x/, with V a smooth function called the potential, and with the Laplacian D 12 @2x1 C C @2xn . If the initial condition is jt D0 D 0 , then the solution of (7.2.3) is given by .x; t/ D K.t/0 .x/;
t > 0;
where K.t/ D e t L D e t .CV .x//
(7.2.4)
is called the evolution operator or the propagator of the operator L. If 0 D ı0 is the Dirac distribution centered at x D 0, then the heat kernel is given by K.t/ı0 . We need to find an integral representation for the evolution operator K.t/ defined by (7.2.4). Before going on, we shall recall a few concepts regarding integral kernels. Let K be an integral operator on L2 .Rm /. Then its integral kernel, denoted by b K, is defined by Z b y/f .y/ dy; K.f /.x/ D K.x; Rm
b W Rm Rm ! R. with K m=2 jxyj2 ct .x; y/ D 1 e 2t and Example 7.2.1. The Gaussian kernel on Rm is K 2 t hence 1 m=2 Z jxyj2 .e t f /.x/ D e 2t f .y/ dy: (7.2.5) 2 t Rm The following result deals with the integral kernels of the product of two or more operators. Proposition 7.2.2. (1) Let K1 and K2 be two integral operators with the integral c1 and K c2 . Then the integral kernel of the product K D K1 K2 is kernels K b y/ D K.x;
Z Rm
c1 .x; u/K c2 .u; y/ du: K
(2) In the case of r operators K1 ; K2 ; : : : ; Kr , the integral kernel of the product operator K D K1 K2 Kr is Z Z c2 .u1 ; u2 / Kr1 .ur2 ; ur1 / c1 .x; u1 /K b y/ D K K.x; Rm
Rm
1
cr .ur1 ; y/ dur1 du1 : K
7.2 Paths Integrals via Trotter’s Formula
109
Let A and B be two self-adjoint operators on a Hilbert space H. There are two cases: 1. The operators commute. In this case ŒA; B D ABBA D 0 and e ACB D e A e B . Using Proposition 7.2.2, part (1), the integral kernel of e t .ACB/ is given by Z Rm
b
tA ec .x; u/e tB .u; y/ du:
Example 7.2.3. Let A D 12 @2x and B D 12 @2y . Let Z .yv/2 1 e 2t f .x; v/ dv: p .x; y/ D e tB f .x; y/ D 2 t Using that AB D BA, we have t 2 2 e 2 .@x C@y / f .x; y/ D e t .ACB/ f .x; y/ D e tA e tB f .x; y/ Z tA .xu/2 1 e 2t .u; y/ du D e .x; y/ D p 2 t Z Z .xu/2 .yv/2 1 1 D p e 2t f .u; v/ dv du p e 2t 2 t 2 t ZZ 2 2 .xu/ C.yv/ 1 2t D f .u; v/ dudv: e 2 t If we let f .u; v/ D ıx0 .u/ ˝ ıy0 .v/, we get the heat kernel t
2
2
e 2 .@x C@y / .ıx0 ˝ ıy0 / D
1 .xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 2t : e 2
This is just the product of the heat kernels of A and B. 2. The operators do not commute. If ŒA; B 6D 0, then e ACB 6D e A e B . In this case the following Trotter product formula is needed. Theorem 7.2.4. Let A and B be self-adjoint operators on a separable Hilbert space H such that they are bounded from below and ACB is essentially self-adjoint. Then e ACB D lim
n!1
t n t e n Ae n B ;
with the convergence in the strong operator topology.1
1
limn!1 An D A in the strong operator topology if kAn f Af kH ! 0, for any f 2 H.
110
7 The Path Integral Approach
In our case the Hilbert space H is the space of test functions. We also denote A D t; B D tV .x/ Kn D e
t n
e
[we mean multiplication by tV .x/],
t n V .x/
:
Using the Trotter product formula, (7.2.4) becomes K.t/ D e ACB D lim Kn ı ı Kn D lim Knn : n!1
n!1
(7.2.6)
In order to compute the integral kernel of the product operator Knn , we first need to find the integral kernel for Kn . Substituting t D t=n in (7.2.5) yields t
.e n f /.x/ D
n m=2 Z njxyj2 e 2t f .y/ dy; 2 t
(7.2.7)
t
and substituting e n V .x/ f for f , we get the integral representation for Kn : t
t
.Kn f /.x/ D .e n e n V .x/ f /.x/ D or cn .x; y/ D K
n m=2 Z njxyj2 t e 2t e n V .y/ f .y/ dy; 2 t
n m=2 njxyj2 t e 2t e n V .y/ : 2 t
Using Proposition 7.2.2, part .2/, we obtain the integral kernel of the product operator Knn : cn .x; y/ D K n
Z
Z
b n .x; u1 /K b n .u1 ; u2 / : : : K b n .un1 ; y/ dun1 : : : du1 K
Z n nm=2 Z Pn1 n Pn1 2 t e 2t j D0 juj C1 uj j e n j D0 V .uj C1 / du D 2 t Z P n nm=2 Z n1 n t 2 e j D0 2t juj C1 uj j C n V .uj C1 / du D 2 t Z n nm=2 Z e Sn du; D 2 t where u0 D x, un D y, du D dun1 du1 and Sn D
n1 X j D0
n t juj C1 uj j2 V .uj C1 / : 2t n
(7.2.8)
7.2 Paths Integrals via Trotter’s Formula
111
Using the Trotter formula (7.2.6), the integral kernel of K.t/ is
bD K.t/
cn D lim lim K n
n!1
Z
n!1
Z
e Sn
n nm=2 du: 2 t
(7.2.9)
We shall make sense of the above integral as a Feynman path integral. The space of continuous, finite-energy paths from x to y in Rm within time t is defined by Z t P 2 < 1; .0/ D x; .t/ D y : jj Px;yIt D W Œ0; t ! Rn I 0
Let the points u0 .Dx/; u1 ; : : : ; un1 ; un .Dy/ 2 Rm be fixed. Consider the piecewise linear function n 2 Px;yIt such that n .0/ D x, n . kt / D uk , n .t/ D y, n for all k D 0; : : : ; n. Then (7.2.8) becomes Sn D
n1 X j D0
D
n1 X j D0
ˇ ! ˇ2 t .j C 1/t jt ˇˇ .j C 1/t n ˇˇ V n n n 2t ˇ n n ˇ n n ˇ ˇ2 ˇ ˇ .j C1/t ! n njt ˇ n t .j C 1/t 1 ˇn V n : 2 t=n n n
This is a Riemannian sum for the integral action Z t 1 P S.; t/ D j.s/j2 V .s/ ds; 2 0 which is associated with the Lagrangian 2 P D 1 j.s/j P L.; / V .s/ : 2 Since the associated Hamiltonian is H.p; q/ D
1 2 jpj C V .q/; 2
we note that S.; t/ satisfies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation @S 1 C jr S j2 C V .x/ D 0: @t 2 The measure element becomes d m.n / D
t n nm=2 n nm=2 .n 1/t dn : du D dn 2 t 2 t n n
112
7 The Path Integral Approach
When taking the limit, we assume n ! , Sn ! S , and d m.n / ! d m./, where 2 Px;yIt , S is the classical action, and d m is the Wiener measure defined on the space Px;yIt . A rigorous proof of the existence of the Wiener measure is beyond the goal of this exposition. With this preparation we can formally treat the limit of (7.2.9) as an integral: cn D lim lim K n
n!1
n!1
Z
Z
e
Sn
Z n nm=2 du D e S.;t / d m./: 2 t Px;yIt
This is called a Feynman path integral and is a formal expression that physicists use in their computations of propagators. We shall use it in this chapter to compute heat kernels. With this introduction, the integral kernel of K.t/ can be written as a Feynman path integral: Z
b
K.t/ D Px;yIt
e S.;t / d m./:
(7.2.10)
Anzatz: The above limit does not depend on the sequence of piecewise functions n chosen. Under this assumption, the path integral (7.2.10) makes sense. The concept of “Feynman integral” stems from Feynman’s 1948 paper [42], which contains a formula for the evolution of quantum systems. Making this idea rigorous has proven difficult. In this book we are using this concept just informally.
7.3 Formal Algorithm for Obtaining Heat Kernels The following result states that the heat kernel can be represented as a path integral. This means that the heat kernel from point x to point y at time t depends on all continuous curves between x and y parameterized by Œ0; t. Each curve is counted with a certain weight which is given as a solution of a transport equation. We shall just check the results informally, but the reader can elaborate a proof using the Trotter formula, in a similar way as we did in the case of the operator 12 C V .x/. Theorem 7.3.1. Let .aij / be a symmetric, nondegenerate, positive definite m m matrix. The heat kernel for the operator LD
m 1 X aij .x/@xi @xj C V .x/ 2 i;j D1
can be obtained by the following algorithm: 1. Associate the Hamiltonian as the principal symbol of the operator L: m 1 X H.p; x/ D aij .x/pi pj C V .x/: 2 i;j D1
7.3 Formal Algorithm for Obtaining Heat Kernels
113
2. Using the Legendre transform, associate the Lagrangian L.x; x/ P D
m 1 X ij a .x/xi xj V .x/; 2 i;j D1
where .aij / D .aij /1 . 3. Solve the Euler–Lagrange equation @L d @L D : ds @xP @x 4. Find the classical action S.x; t/ by integrating the Lagrangian along the solution of the Euler–Langrange equation: Z
t
S.x; t/ D
L x.s/; x.s/ P ds:
0
5. The action S.x; t/ also verifies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation @S C H.rx S; x/ D 0: @t 6. Then the integral kernel of the operator e t L is given by the path integral b yI t/ D K.x;
Z Px;yIt
e S.;t / d m./;
where the measure d m./ is determined as in step 8, and S.; t/ is the classical action S evaluated along the continuous curve 2 Px;yIt . 7. Consider the solution vn .t/ of the “transport equation” v0n .t/
m 1 X C aij .x/@xi @xj Sn vn .t/ D 0; 2n
n 1;
i;j D1
satisfying the boundary condition lim
t &0
2 t m=2 n
vn .t/ D 1;
where the Sn are the partial Riemannian sums of the integral action S.; t/. 8. The Wiener measure in the previous path integral is formally defined by dm./ D lim dm.n /; n!1
114
7 The Path Integral Approach
where d m.n / D vn .t/n dn
t .n 1/t dn : n n
Proof. We proceed by an informal computation, i.e., we shall assume, when necessary, that the conditions of the dominated convergence theorem always hold, so we can use the commutativity between the limit symbol and the integral. Using Sn D Sn .x; t/, we have L.e Sn / D
m 1 X aij @xi @xj e Sn C V .x/e Sn 2 i;j D1
8 9 m m = X 1 Sn < X D e aij .@xi Sn / .@xj Sn / aij @xi @xj Sn C V .x/e Sn : ; 2 i;j D1
i;j D1
8 9 m < = X 1 D e Sn H.rSn / aij @xi @xj Sn : : ; 2
(7.3.11)
i;j D1
Using (7.3.11) yields @t L e Sn vnn .t/ D @t e Sn vnn .t/ Le Sn vnn .t/ 8 9 m < = 0 X v 1 D e Sn vnn @t Sn n n e Sn vnn H.rSn / aij @xi @xj Sn : ; vn 2 i;j D1
( D
e Sn vnn
n .@t Sn C H.rSn // vn
m vn X C aij @xi @xj Sn 2n i;j D1 „ ƒ‚ …
!)
v0n
D0 by 7:
D e Sn vnn @t Sn C H.rSn / :
(7.3.12)
Assume there is a constant M > 0 such that je Sn vnn j < M for all n 1. Applying the operator @t L to the path integral b yI t/ D K.x;
Z e Px;yIt
S.;t /
Z d m./ D lim
n!1
Z
e Sn vnn .t/ dun1 du1
7.3 Formal Algorithm for Obtaining Heat Kernels
115
and using (7.3.12) yields b yI t/ D lim .@t L/K.x;
Z
Z
n!1
.@t L/ e Sn vnn .t/ dun1 du1
Z
Z
D lim
n!1
e Sn vnn @t Sn C H.rSn / dun1 du1
D 0; because lim
n!1
@t Sn C H.rSn / D @t S C H.rS / D 0;
by the Hamilton–Jacobi equation. The next theorem deals with second-order operators with a linear part.
Theorem 7.3.2. Let .aij / be a symmetric, nondegenerate, positive definite m m matrix. The heat kernel for the operator LD
m X 1 X aij .x/@xi @xj C Vj .x/@xj 2 i;j D1
j
can be obtained following this algorithm: 1. Associate the following Hamiltonian:2 H.p; x/ D
m X 1 X aij .x/pi pj Vj .x/pj : 2 i;j D1
j
2. Using the Legendre transform, associate the Lagrangian L.x; x/ P D
m 1 X ij a .x/ xi Vi .x/ xj Vj .x/ ; 2 i;j D1
where .aij / D .aij /1 . 3. Solve the Euler–Lagrange equation @L d @L D : ds @xP @x
2
Note the minus sign in front of the second term.
116
7 The Path Integral Approach
4. Find the classical action S.x; t/ by integrating the Lagrangian along the solution of the Euler–Lagrange equation: Z
t
S.x; t/ D
L x.s/; x.s/ P ds:
0
5. The action S.x; t/ also verifies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation @S C H.rx S; x/ D 0: @t 6. Then the integral kernel of the operator e t L is given by the path integral b yI t/ D K.x;
Z Px;yIt
e S.;t / d m./;
where the measure d m./ is determined as in step 8, and S.; t/ is the classical action S evaluated along the continuous curve 2 Px;yIt : 7. Consider the solution vn .t/ of the “transport equation” 1 0 m X 1 @ aij .x/@xi @xj Sn A vn .t/ D 0; v0n .t/ C 2n
n 1;
i;j D1
satisfying the boundary condition lim
t &0
2 t n
m=2 vn .t/ D 1;
where the Sn are the partial Riemannian sums of the integral action S.; t/. 8. The Wiener measure in the above path integral is formally defined by dm./ D lim dm.n /; n!1
where d m.n / D vn .t/ dn n
t n
dn
.n 1/t n
:
Proof. We shall proceed formally, providing a verification by a direct computation without worrying about the details. First we check the form of the Lagrangian given in step 2: Consider the vectors x D .x1 ; : : : ; xn / and V D .V1 ; : : : ; Vn /. The Hamiltonian can also be written as H D
1 hap; pi hV; pi: 2
7.3 Formal Algorithm for Obtaining Heat Kernels
117
One of the Hamiltonian equations yields xP D Hp D ap V H) p D a1 .xP C V /: The Legendre transform yields 1 L D p xP H D hp; ap V i hap; pi C hV; pi 2 1 1 D hap; pi D haa1 .xP C V /; a1 .xP C V /i 2 2 1 X ij 1 a .x/ xP i C Vi .x/ xP j C Vj .x/ : D h.xP C V /; a1 .xP C V /i D 2 2 i;j
By computation, we have m X 1 X L e Sn D aij .x/@xi @xj e Sn C Vj .x/@xj e Sn 2 i;j D1 j 8 9 m < = X X 1 D e Sn aij @xi Sn @xj Sn aij @xi @xj Sn : ; 2 i;j D1
e Sn
X
Vj .x/@xj Sn
j
D e Sn
8 <1 X :2
i;j
i;j
9 = X aij @xi Sn @xj Sn Vj .x/@xj Sn ; j
X 1 e Sn aij @xi @xj Sn 2 i;j 8 9 m < = X 1 D e Sn H.rSn / aij @xi @xj Sn : : ; 2
(7.3.13)
i;j
Using (7.3.13) yields @t L e Sn vnn .t/
8 9 < = 0 X v 1 aij @xi @xj Sn D e Sn vnn .t/ @t Sn n n e Sn vnn .t/ H.rSn / : ; vn 2 i;j
118
7 The Path Integral Approach
( D
e Sn vnn .t/
D
e Sn vnn .t/
n vn X v0n C aij @xi @xj Sn @t Sn C H.rSn / vn .t/ 2n i;j „ ƒ‚ …
!)
D0
@t Sn C H.rSn / :
The rest of the proof is the same as the last part of the proof of Theorem 7.3.1.
When det.aij .x// D 0, the matrix aij cannot be inverted, and we might have difficulty in assigning a Lagrangian. In this case we may skip from step 1 to step 5: Since the main point is finding the action, we may always do this skip as long as we are able to solve the Hamilton–Jacobi equation. We shall consider next several examples of operators for which we are able to compute the heat kernels using the previous theorems. We start the presentation with the easiest case. For more worked-out examples, the reader can consult, for instance [102]. We end this section by reminding the reader of two important integrals that will play a major role in computing path integrals in the sequel. Let M D .m/ij be a k k symmetric nonsingular matrix and .1 ; : : : ; k / 2 Rk be a given vector. Then Z Rk
Z
1
Rk
e 2
Pk
1
e 2
i;j D1
Pk
i;j D1
mij yi yj C
mij yi yj
Pk
i D1 i yi
D .2/k=2 .det M /1=2 ;
(7.3.14) 1
D .2/k=2 .det M /1=2 e 2
Pk
i;j D1 i .M
1 /
ij j
:
(7.3.15)
7.4 The Operator 12 @x2 We are interested in finding the heat kernel of the operator L D 12 @2x by using path integrals. The Hamiltonian is given by the principal symbol H.p; x/ D 12 p 2 and the associated Lagrangian is given by L.x; x/ P D 12 xP 2 . The Euler–Lagrange equation is xR D 0. The classical solution satisfying the boundary conditions x.0/ D x0 and x.t/ D x is xcl .s/ D
x x0 s C x0 : t
The classical action from x0 to x within time t is Z Scl .x; x0 ; t/ D 0
t
1 xP cl .s/2 ds D 2
Z
t 0
2 2 x x0 x.t/ x.0/ : ds D 2t 2 2t
7.4 The Operator 12 @2x
119
The heat kernel of the operator @t 12 @2x is given by the path integral Z K.x0 ; xI t / D
Px0 ;xIt
e S.;t / d m./:
In order to evaluate the above path integral, we shall change the integration variable 2 P0;0It as follows. For any 2 Px0 ;xIt , we consider the continuous curve defined by .s/ D xcl .s/ C
.s/:
(7.4.16)
Since .0/ D xcl .0/ D x0 and .t/ D xcl .t/ D x, it follows that .0/ D .t/ D 0. The reason for the change of variables (7.4.16) is to simplify a later computation from the more complicated integral (7.3.15) to the simpler one (7.3.14). This technique might not always work, in which case we need to use (7.3.15) directly. The value of the action integral along the curve is denoted by S.; t/ D S j .0/ D x0 ; .t/ D x : The action along can be written in terms of the action along
Z t 2 1P 2 1 xP cl .s/C P .s/ ds .s/ ds D 0 2 0 2 Z t Z t Z t 1 1P 2 xP cl .s/2 ds C .s/ ds D xP cl .s/ P .s/ ds C 0 2 0 0 2 Z x x0 t P .s/ ds C S j .0/ D 0; .t/ D 0 : D Scl .x; x0 ; t/ C t 0
S.; t/ D S j.0/Dx0 ; .t/ D x D
Z
. One obtains
t
The second term in the sum vanishes because Z t P .s/ ds D .t/
.0/ D 0:
0
Therefore, the action integral along is S.; t/ D
x x0 2t
2 CS
j .0/ D 0; .t/ D 0 ;
and substituting in our initial path integral yields Z e Px0 ;xIt
S.;t /
d m./ D e
.xx0 /2 2t
Z P0;0It
e S.
;t /
d m. /:
(7.4.17)
This way, the path integral over Px0 ;xIt was replaced by a path integral over the space of continuous loops P0;0It . We shall next compute the right-hand side of (7.4.17).
120
7 The Path Integral Approach
Let uj D .jt=n/, for j D 0; : : : ; n. Then the Riemannian sum Sn of the action integral along is Sn D
n1 X j D0
D
n1 X .uj C1 uj /2 1 uj C1 uj 2 t D 2 t=n n 2t=n j D0
1 ˚ .u1 u0 /2 C .u2 u1 /2 C C .un un1 /2 : (7.4.18) 2t=n
Since u0 D un D 0, we get Sn D D
1 f2u21 2u0 u1 C 2u22 2u1 u2 C C 2u2n1 g 2t=n n1 1 X bij ui uj ; 2t=n
(7.4.19)
i;j D1
where
0
2 1 B 1 2 B B B 0 1 .bij / D B :: B :: B : : B @ 0 0 0 0
0 1 2 :: :
:: :
0 0 0 :: :
0 0
2 1
0 0 0 :: :
1
C C C C C C C C 1 A 2
(7.4.20)
is an .n 1/ .n 1/ matrix. In order to construct the measure d m. /, we need to construct the volume elements vn given by part 8 of Theorem 7.3.1. First we need to construct the transport equation. Since x D un D .t/, differentiating in formula (7.4.18) by un yields @2x Sn D
2 n D : 2t=n t
Hence the transport equation given by part 8 of Theorem 7.3.1 is v0n .t/ C Integrating yields
1 vn .t/ D 0: 2t
cn vn .t/ D p : t
The constant cn is determined from the boundary condition 1 D lim
t &0
2 t 1=2 n
2 t 1=2 c n p : t &0 n t
vn .t/ D lim
7.4 The Operator 12 @2x
It follows that cn D
121
q
n . 2
The volume element becomes r vn .t/ D
n ; 2 t
and the measure element is r dm. / D lim vn .t/ du1 dun1 D lim n
n!1
n!1
n 2 t
n du1 dun1 :
Now we are ready to evaluate the path integral on the right side of (7.4.17). Using (7.4.19), we have Z e S. ;t / d m. / P0;0It
r
n n du1 dun1 n!1 2 t n Z r Z 1 Pn1 n e 2t =n i;j D0 bij ui uj du1 dun1 D lim n!1 2 t n Z r n 1 Pn1 D lim e 2 i;j D0 mij ui uj du1 dun1 n!1 2 t Rn1 n s r n .2/n1 D lim n!1 2 t det.mij / n=2 n 1 1 p : (7.4.21) D lim p n!1 t det.m 2 ij / Z
D lim
Z
e
Sn
where we let mij D bij =.t=n/. Using a property of determinants, det.mij / D
n n1 t
det.bij /:
(7.4.22)
We shall now compute det.bij /. Consider the following .n1/.n1/ determinant:
Bn1
ˇ ˇ 2 ˇ ˇ 1 ˇ ˇ ˇ 0 D ˇˇ : ˇ :: ˇ ˇ 0 ˇ ˇ 0
1 0 2 1 1 2 :: :: : : 0 0 0 0
:: :
0 0 0 :: :
2 1
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ; ˇ ˇ ˇ 1 ˇˇ 2 ˇ 0 0 0 :: :
122
7 The Path Integral Approach
Expanding after the last row yields the following linear recursion equation: Bn1 D 2Bn2 Bn3 : The associated characteristic equation r 2 D 2r 1 D 0 has the double root r1 D r2 D 1. Then the general term of the sequence Bn can be written as Bn D r1n .C1 C nC2 / D C1 C nC2 ;
(7.4.23)
where C1 and C2 are two real constants which will be determined from the initial conditions. Since ˇ ˇ ˇ 2 1 ˇ ˇ D 3; B1 D j2j D 2; B2 D ˇˇ 1 2 ˇ the constants C1 , C2 satisfy the linear system C1 C C2 D 2; C1 C 2C2 D 3; with solution C1 D C2 D 1. Substituting in (7.4.23) yields Bn D n C 1. Hence det.bij / D Bn1 D n; and then (7.4.22) yields
n n1 det.mij / D n : t Substituting in (7.4.21), we obtain Z
e S.
P0;0It
;t /
1 n n=2 d m. / D lim p n!1 2 t D p
1 2 t
n1=2
1 n1 2 n t
:
(7.4.24)
Substituting in (7.4.17) yields the well-known heat kernel for 12 @2x : Z K.x0 ; xI t/ D
Px0 ;xIt
e S.;t / d m./ D p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
;
t > 0: (7.4.25)
7.5 The Operator 12 .@2x C @x /
123
7.5 The Operator 12 .@x2 C @x / Consider the operator L D 12 .@2x C@x /. Since the operator has a linear term, we shall use the method given by Theorem 7.3.2. The associated Hamiltonian is obtained by replacing @x by the momentum p and changing the sign3 in front of p: H.x; p/ D
1 2 .p p/: 2
The Hamiltonian system 1 1 H) p D C x; P 2 2 pP D Hx D 0 H) p constant; xP D Hp D p
with the boundary conditions x.0/ D x0 ; has the solution x.s/ D
x.t/ D x;
x x0 s C x0 : t
(7.5.26)
The Legendre transform provides the Lagrangian L.x; x/ P D p xP H D D
2 1 1 1 1 1 C xP xP C xP C C xP 2 2 2 2 2
xP 2 xP 1 C C : 2 2 8
The Euler–Lagrange equation is xR D 0 and its solution is given by (7.5.26). The classical action is Z t Z t 1 1 1 L xcl .s/; xP cl .s/ ds D Scl .x0 ; xI t/ D ds x.s/ P 2 C x.s/ P C 2 2 8 0 0 Z t x x0 1 .x x0 /2 C ds C D 2t 2 2t 8 0 D
3
1 .x x0 /2 t C .x x0 / C : 2t 2 8
This is the Hamiltonian of the conjugate operator.
(7.5.27)
124
7 The Path Integral Approach
Let be a curve satisfying .0/ D x0 and .t/ D x. We make a “change of variables,” introducing the curve , .s/ D xcl .s/ C
.s/:
We note that .0/ D .t/ D 0. Next we shall express the action along in terms of the action along : Z t P L .s/; .s/ ds S.; t/ D S. j .0/ D x0 ; .t/ D x/ D 0 Z t 1 1 P2 1P ds .s/ C .s/ C D 2 2 8 0 Z t Z t 1 1 1 2 D xP cl .s/ P .s/ ds ds C xP cl .s/ C xP cl .s/ C 2 2 8 0 0 Z t 1P 1 1 1 P2 .s/ C ds .s/ C C 2 2 8 8 0 Z t x x0 P .s/ ds C S j .0/ D 0; .t/ D 0 t : D Scl .x0 ; xI t/ C t 8 0 Rt Since 0 P .s/ ds D .t/ .0/ D 0, using relation (7.5.27), the above equation becomes S.; t/ D
.x x0 /2 1 C .x x0 / C S j .0/ D 0; .t/ D 0 : 2t 2
(7.5.28)
By Theorem 7.3.2, the heat kernel is Z K.x0 ; xI t / D
Px0 ;xIt
e S.;t / d m./ D e
.xx0 /2 2t
12 .xx0 /
Z P0;0It
e S.
;t /
d m. /: (7.5.29)
We still need to compute the path integral on the right side. We note that this is taken over the space of loops starting at the origin. Consider the intermediate points uj D .jt=n/, j D 0; : : : ; n, with u0 D .0/ D 0, un D .t/ D 0. The Riemannian sum of the action is given by Sn D
n1 X
j D0
D
1 uj C1 uj 1 1 .uj C1 uj /2 t C C 2 2 .t=n/ n 2 t=n 8
t n
n1 X
n1 1 .uj C1 uj /2 t 1X .uj C1 uj / C C 2 t=n 2 8 j D0 j D0 ƒ‚ … „ D0
D
1 2t=n
n1 X i;j D0
t bij ui uj C ; 8
(7.5.30)
7.6 Heat Kernel for L D 12 .@2x @x /
125
with .bij / given by (7.4.20). The same computation as before shows that the volume element is n 1=2 vn .t/ D 2 t and the measure is
n n=2 du1 dun1 : (7.5.31) 2 t Using (7.5.30) and (7.5.31), the path integral on the right side of (7.5.29) can be evaluated as in the following: Z e S. ;t / d m. / d m. / D
P0;0It
Z
Z
n n=2 du1 dun1 n!1 2 t Z n n=2 Z 1 Pn1 t e 2t =n i;j D0 bij ui uj du1 dun1 D e 8 lim n!1 2 t t 1 D e 8 ; .2 t/1=2 D lim
e Sn
by a previous calculation; see (7.4.24). Substituting in (7.5.29), we obtain the heat kernel for 12 .@2x C @x /: K.x0 ; xI t/ D p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
t 1 2 .xx0 / 8
;
t > 0:
(7.5.32)
7.6 Heat Kernel for L D 12 .@x2 @x / The Hamiltonian in this case is H.p; x/ D 12 .p 2 C p/. A similar computation as in the previous section shows that the associated Lagrangian is given by L.x; x/ P D
1 xP 2 xP C ; 2 2 8
with the classical action Scl .x0 ; xI t/ D
.x x0 /2 1 t .x x0 / C : 2t 2 8
The same computation as in the previous example yields the heat kernel for 1 2 .@ @x /: 2 x K.x0 ; xI t/ D p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
t C1 2 .xx0 / 8
;
t > 0;
(7.6.33)
126
7 The Path Integral Approach
7.7 Heat Kernel for L D 12 x 2 @x2 C x@x The operator is elliptic away from the origin. We shall find the heat kernel for x0 ; x > 0. We can obtain a similar formula for x0 ; x < 0. Note that there is no heat transfer between the regions x0 > 0 and x < 0. An efficient way to solve this problem is to reduce the operator to the previous operator. Changing the variable x D e u , and using x
@ @ D ; @x @u
x2
@2 @ @2 D 2 ; 2 @x @u @u
we obtain 1
et . 2 x
2 @2 Cx@ / x x
t
2
D e 2 .@u C@u / .uu0 /2 1 t 1 e 2t 2 .uu0 / 8 D p 2 t D p D p
1 2 t 1
e r
2 t
.ln xln x0 /2 2t
t 1 2 .ln xln x0 / 8
x0 1 .ln xln x0 /2 t ; 8 e 2t x
t >0
where we used formula (7.5.32).
7.8 The Hermite Operator 12 .@x2 a2 x 2 / Consider the operator L D 12 .@2x a2 x 2 /, with a constant. The associated Hamiltonian is H.p; x/ D 12 p 2 12 a2 x 2 and the Hamiltonian equations are xP D Hp D p; pP D Hx D a2 x: Then the classical path between x0 and x within time t satisfies xR D a2 x; x.0/ D x0 ; x.t/ D x: The solution is
x.s/ D A sinh.as/ C B cosh.as/:
From the boundary conditions, we get B D x0 ;
AD
x x0 cosh.at/ : sinh.at/
(7.8.34)
7.8 The Hermite Operator 12 .@2x a2 x 2 /
127
Therefore, the classical path is xcl .s/ D
x x0 cosh.at/ sinh.as/ C x0 cosh.as/: sinh.at/
The associated Lagrangian is
L.x; x/ P D p xP H D xP 2
1 2 1 2 2 xP a x 2 2
D
(7.8.35)
1 2 1 2 2 xP C a x ; 2 2
with the Euler–Lagrange equation (7.9.50). The classical action from x0 to x within time t is Z t 1 2 .s/ ds: xP cl .s/2 C a2 xcl Scl .x; x0 ; t/ D 0 2 We shall compute the above integrand first. In order to simplify the calculations, we let D sinh.at/; D cosh.at/: Using (7.8.35) yields xcl .s/ D
x x0 sinh.as/ C x0 cosh.as/;
!2 1 2 1 2 x x0 xP .s/ D a cosh.as/ C x0 sinh.as/ 2 cl 2 D
1 2 .x x0 /2 x x0 cosh2 .as/ C 2 a cosh.as/x0 sinh.as/ 2 2 ! C x02 sinh2 .as/ ;
1 2 2 .x x0 /2 1 x x0 a xcl .s/ D a2 cosh.as/x0 sinh.as/ sinh2 .as/ C 2 2 2 2 ! C x02 cosh2 .as/ : Using 1 C cosh.2as/ ; 2 adding the above relations yields cosh2 .as/ D
sinh2 .as/ D
1 C cosh.2as/ ; 2
.x x0 / 1 a2 .x x0 /2 1 2 2 .s/ D cosh.2as/ C 2x0 xP cl .s/ C a2 xcl sinh.2as/ 2 2 2 2 ! C x02 cosh.2as/ :
128
7 The Path Integral Approach
Integrating between 0 and t, we obtain the classical action Scl .x; x0 ; t/ D
a2 1 .x x0 /2 .x x0 / sinh.2at/ C 2x0 Œcosh.2at/ 1 2 2a 2 ! C x02 sinh.2at/
a2 1 .x x0 /2 .x x0 / 2 2 C 2x0 2 C x02 2 D 2 2a 2 ! a 2 2 2 2 D .x x0 / C 2x0 .x x0 / C x0 2 ! a 2 2 2 2 2 2 x 2xx0 C x0 C 2xx0 x0 D 2 ! a 2 2 2 2 2 2 x C x0 . / C 2xx0 . / D 2 ! a 2 2 x C x0 2xx0 ; D 2 where we used 2 2 D 1 Hence a Scl .x0 ; x; t/ D .x 2 C x02 / cosh.at/ 2xx0 : 2 sinh.at/
!
(7.8.36)
Let x W Œ0; t ! R be a path satisfying x.0/ D x0 and x.t/ D x. Consider the deviation v.s/ from the classical path x.s/ D xcl .s/ C v.s/; where v.0/ D v.0/ D 0. The action along x.s/ becomes Z t a2 1 2 S x j x.0/ D x0 ; x.t/ D x D xP .s/ C x.s/2 ds 2 0 2 Z t 2 2 a 1 2 D xcl .s/ C v.s/ xP cl .s/ C vP .s/ C ds 2 0 2 Z t Z t 1 1 2 a2 a2 2 2 2 D xP cl .s/ C xcl .s/ ds C vP .s/ C v.s/ ds 2 2 0 2 0 2 Z t xP cl .s/Pv.s/ C a2 xcl .s/v.s/ ds C 0 D Scl .x0 ; x; t/ C S v j v.0/ D 0; v.t/ D 0 Z t C xP cl .s/Pv.s/ C a2 xcl .s/v.s/ ds: 0
7.8 The Hermite Operator 12 .@2x a2 x 2 /
129
We shall show that the last integral vanishes: Z
t
xP cl .s/Pv.s/ C a2 xcl .s/v.s/ ds
0
Z
t
D 0
d .xP cl .s/v.s// ds ds
Z
t
xR cl .s/ a2 xcl .s/ v.s/ ds
0
D xP cl .t/v.t/ xP cl .0/v.0/ D 0; where we used v.0/ D v.t/ D 0 and the Euler–Lagrange equations (7.9.50). Hence S x.s/ D S x j x.0/ D x0 ; x.t/ D x D Scl .x0 ; x; t/CS v j v.0/ D 0; v.t/ D 0 D Scl .x0 ; x; t/ C S v.s/ : Using (7.8.36), Theorem 7.3.1 yields the heat kernel Z K.x0 ; xI t/ D
De
Px0 ;xIt
e S.x.s// d m.x/ D e Scl .x0 ;x;t /
a 2 2 2 sinh.at / .x Cx0 / cosh.at /2xx0
Z P0;0It
Z P0;0It
e S.v.s// d m.v/
e S.v.s// d m.v/: (7.8.37)
In order to compute the path integral on the right side of (7.8.37), we need to consider the intermediate points uj D v.jt=n/, j D 0; : : : ; n, with u0 D v.0/ D 0 and un D v.t/ D 0. The Riemannian sum associated with the action Z t SD 0
1 2 1 2 2 xP C a x 2 2
ds
is Sn D
n1 X j D0
D
X1 1 .uj C1 uj /2 t t C a2 u2j 2 .t=n/2 n 2 n n1
j D0
n1 n1 a2 t X 2 1 X bij ui uj C uj 2t=n 2 n i;j D0
D
n1 1 X aij .t/ ui uj ; 2t=n i;j D0
j D0
(7.8.38)
130
7 The Path Integral Approach
where aij .t/ D bij C 0
at 2 n
ıij
1 2 1 0 0 0 B 1 2 1 0 0 C B C B C 0 C at 2 B 0 1 2 0 B DB : :: :: C :: :: :: C C n ıij : B :: : : C : : B C @ 0 0 0 2 1 A 0 0 0 1 2 2 0 1 0 0 2 C at n B 2 B B 1 2 C at 1 0 n B 2 B B 0 0 1 2 C at B n DB :: :: :: :: :: B : B : : : : B 2 B 0 0 0 2 C at B n @ 0 0 0 1 is an .n 1/ .n 1/ matrix. Let fn .t/ D over the last row yields the recursion
t n
0
1
C C C C C C 0 C C :: C C : C C 1 C 2 A 2 C at n 0
det.aij .t//. Expanding the determinant
h at 2 i fn D 2 C fn1 fn2 : n This can be written as a difference equation: fn 2fn1 C fn2 D a2 fn1 : .t=n/2 Assume the pointwise limit f .t/ D limn!1 fn .t/ exists. Then the above difference equation becomes the ordinary differential equation f 00 .t/ D a2 f .t/; with solution f .t/ D A sinh.at/ C B cosh.at/;
A; B 2 R:
We shall determine the value of the constants A and B from the initial conditions.
7.8 The Hermite Operator 12 .@2x a2 x 2 /
131
Note that det.aij /.0/ D n, so fn .0/ D lim fn .t/ D lim t &0
t &0
t lim det.aij .t// D 0: n t &0
Hence, f .0/ D limn!1 fn .0/ D 0. It follows that B D 0 and f .t/ D A sinh.at/: Differentiating at t D 0, fn0 .0/ D lim
n t 0
t &0
n
nt d o o det aij .t/ det aij .t/ C lim t &0 n dt
D 1; since the second limit is zero. Therefore, f 0 .0/ D 1 and hence A D 1=a. It follows that 1 f .t/ D lim fn .t/ D sinh.at/: (7.8.39) n!1 a A similar computation as in a previous example shows that the volume elements are r n vn .t/ D ; 2 t and hence the Wiener measure becomes d m.v/ D
n n=2 du1 dun1 : 2 t
Next we evaluate the path integral on the right side of (7.8.37): Z P0;0It
e S.v.s// d m.v/ Z
Z
n n=2 du1 dun1 n!1 2 t Z n n=2 Z 1 Pn1 e 2t =n i;j D0 aij ui uj du1 dun1 D lim n!1 2 t n n=2 Z Pn1 1 D lim e 2 i;j D0 mij ui uj du1 dun1 ; n!1 2 t Rn1 D lim
e Sn
132
7 The Path Integral Approach
where mij D Z P0;0It
aij . t=n
s n n=2 .2/n1 e S.v.s// d m.v/ D lim n!1 2 t det.mij / n=2 t 1 1 r D lim p n!1 2 n det aij .t/ .t =n/n1
1 1 1 1 D lim p q D lim p p n!1 n!1 t 2 2 fn .t/ det aij .t/ n r a 1 D p ; sinh.at/ 2 by (7.8.39). Substituting in (7.8.37), we obtain the following heat kernel for the Hermite operator: K.x0 ; xI t/ D p
1 2 t
s
a at e 2 sinh.at / sinh.at/
.x 2 Cx02 / cosh.at /2xx0
; t > 0: (7.8.40)
7.9 Evaluating Path Integrals We have seen in the previous sections that the heat kernel can be expressed formally as a path integral. However, computing path integrals from the definition, even in the simplest cases, is a tedious job and reminds us of computing Riemann integrals starting from the Riemann sum. Since this is not always efficient, we shall next present a couple of methods that overpass the computation of the path integral.
7.9.1 Van Vleck’s Formula Given two points x; y in space and a time t > 0, the propagator from x to y within time t is given by the path integral Z K.x0 ; xI t/ D
Px;yIt
e S.;t / d m./:
(7.9.41)
This means that K depends on all continuous paths joining x and y parameterized by Œ0; t. Among all the possible paths between the aforementioned points, the classical path plays a distinguished role; see Fig. 7.3. This is the path on which a
7.9 Evaluating Path Integrals
133
Fig. 7.3 Classical and quantum paths between x and y
classical particle would travel on and is given by the solution of the Euler–Lagrange system of equations. It is a remarkable fact that for a classical Lagrangian, i.e., a Lagrangian which is at most quadratic in xP i and xi , the path integral (7.9.41) depends only on the classical action. This is the famous van Vleck formula which expresses the path integral in the following closed-form formula(see [109]): s
Z e Px;yIt
S.;t /
d m./ D
1 @2 Scl .x; y/ det e Scl .x;y;t / ; 2 @x @y
where
Z
t
Scl .x; y; t/ D
(7.9.42)
L x.s/; x.s/ P ds
0
is the classical action obtained by integrating the Lagrangian along the solution x.s/ of the Euler–Lagrange equation. The factor s V .t/ D
1 @2 Scl .x; y/ det 2 @x @y
is called the van Vleck determinant, and it plays the role of volume element in the geometric method described in Chap. 3. The aforementioned formula can be applied successfully in the cases of second-order elliptic operators with constant, linear and quadratic potential.
7.9.2 Applications of van Vleck’s Formula In the following we shall present some applications. In all of the next examples the heat kernel will be calculated using the formula K.x; yI t/ D V .t/e Scl .x;yIt / ; where V is the van Vleck determinant.
134
7 The Path Integral Approach
.a/ One-dimensional case. We have seen in Sect. 7.4 that the classical action associated with the operator L D 12 @2x is Scl .x0 ; x; t/ D
.x x0 /2 : 2t
2
@ Scl D 1t , formula (7.9.42) yields the following familiar formula of Since @x 0 @x the heat kernel:
K.x0 ; x; t/ D p
1
1
2 t
2
e 2t .xx0 / ;
t > 0:
.b/ One-dimensional case with linear part. The associated action with the operator L D 12 .@2x C @x / as provided by Sect. 7.5 is Scl .x0 ; x; t/ D Since
.x x0 /2 t 1 C .x x0 / C : 2t 2 8 1 @2 Scl D ; @x0 @x t
van Vleck’s formula (7.9.42) yields the following heat kernel: K.x0 ; x; t/ D p
1
1
2 t
2 1 .xx / t 0 2 8
e 2t .xx0 /
;
t > 0:
.c/ The case of linear potential. In the following we shall find the heat kernel of the operator L D 12 @2x ax, with a 2 R. The Hamiltonian function associated with the operator L is given by H.p; x/ D
1 2 p ax: 2
The Hamiltonian system becomes xP D Hp D p; pP D Hx D a: The associated Lagrangian function is L.x; x/ P D 12 xP 2 C ax. The Euler– Lagrange equation xR D a with the boundary conditions x.0/ D x0 , x.t/ D x has the unique solution x.s/ D
1 2 as C bs C x0 ; 2
(7.9.43)
7.9 Evaluating Path Integrals
135
with
x x0 at : t 2 The Lagrangian along the solution (7.9.43) is bD
(7.9.44)
1 L x.s/; x.s/ P D x.s/ P 2 C ax.s/ 2 1 2 1 2 as C bs C x0 D .as C b/ C a 2 2 1 D a2 s 2 C 2abs C ax0 C b 2 : 2 The classical action is obtained by integrating the Lagrangian along the solution: Z t S.x0 ; xI t/ D L x.s/; x.s/ P ds 0
1 1 D a2 t 3 C abt 2 C ax0 t C b 2 t: 3 2 Substituting b from (7.10.67) yields the classical action x x at 1 2 3 1 x x0 at 2 0 C ax0 t C t a t C at 2 3 t 2 2 t 2 2 .x x0 / 1 1 D (7.9.45) C a.x C x0 /t a2 t 3 : 2t 2 24
Scl .x0 ; xI t/ D
The heat kernel is now given by van Vleck’s formula: v u u K.x0 ; x; t/ D tdet D p
1 2 t
1 @2 Scl 2 @x @x0 e
.xx0 /2 2t
! e Scl .x0 ;x;t /
1 2 3 1 2 a.xCx0 /t C 24 a t
; t > 0:
.d / The n-dimensional linear potential. Consider the n-dimensional operator LD
X 1X 2 @xi ai xi ; 2 n
n
i D1
i D1
with ai 2 R. In this case the Hamiltonian function is H.p; x/ D
1X 2 X pi ai xi ; 2 n
n
i D1
i D1
(7.9.46)
136
7 The Path Integral Approach
and the Hamiltonian equations are xP j D pj ; pPj D aj ;
j D 1; : : : ; n:
The solution joining the points x0 and x is x j .s/ D
1 j aj s 2 C bj s C x0 ; 2
(7.9.47)
with j
bj D
x j x0 aj t ; t 2
j D 1; : : : ; n:
(7.9.48)
The Lagrangian L.x; x/ P D
1 1X 2 X xP i C ai xi jxP i j2 C ha; xi D 2 2 n
n
i D1
i D1
evaluated along the above solution is 1 L x.s/; x.s/ P D jaj2 s 2 C 2ha; bis C ha; x0 i C jbj2 : 2 Integrating the Lagrangian along the solution yields the following classical action: S.x0 ; xI t/ D
jx x0 j2 1 1 C ha; x C x0 it jaj2 t 3 : 2t 2 24
(7.9.49)
The van Vleck determinant is v ! u 2 u tdet 1 @ Scl .x0 ; x/ D .2 t/n=2 ; 2 @x0 @x so we conclude that the heat kernel of the operator (7.9.46) is K.x; x0 ; t/ D
jxx j2 1 1 2 3 2t0 1 2 ha; xCx0 it C 24 jaj t ; t > 0: e n=2 .2 t/
.e/ We shall next find the heat kernel for the Hermite operator 1 LD 2
! d 2 2 2 a x ; dx
7.9 Evaluating Path Integrals
137
with a 2 R. The associated Hamiltonian is given by H.p; x/ D
1 2 1 2 2 p a x 2 2
and the Hamiltonian system of equations is xP D Hp D p; pP D Hx D a2 x: The classical path between x0 and x at time t satisfies xR D a2 x;
(7.9.50)
x.0/ D x0 ; x.t/ D x; with the solution x.s/ D
x x0 cosh.at/ sinh.as/ C x0 cosh.as/: sinh.at/
(7.9.51)
The Lagrangian associated with the above Hamiltonian is given by the Legendre transform 1 1 L.x; x/ P D p xP H D xP 2 C a2 x 2 : (7.9.52) 2 2 Integrating the solution (7.9.51) along the Lagrangian (7.9.52) yields the classical action a .x 2 C x02 / cosh.at/ 2xx0 : (7.9.53) Scl .x0 ; x; t/ D 2 sinh.at/ The van Vleck determinant is v u u V .t/ D tdet
1 @2 Scl 2 @x @x0 s 1 at : D p sinh.at/ 2 t
!
Applying formula (7.9.42) yields the following heat kernel: K.x0 ; x; t/ D p where t > 0.
1 2 t
s
1 2 at 2 at e 2t sinh.at / Œ.x Cx0 / cosh.at /2xx0 ; sinh.at/
138
7 The Path Integral Approach
In spite of the fact that van Vleck’s formula is a fast way of obtaining functiontype heat kernels, it is not useful in the case when the potential is more than quadratic or when the operator is sub-elliptic, since in these cases the operators might not have function-type heat kernels.
7.9.3 The Feynman–Kac Formula This famous formula was first used by Kac in order to compute heat kernels for P 2 Laplace operators with potential; see [75]. Let m D 12 m @ i D1 xi be the Laplace operator on Rm and V be a smooth potential function. Let C0t denote the space of Rn -valued functions .s/ continuous on Œ0; t such that .0/ D 0. Then the following formula holds (see [73, 74]): .e
t .m V /
Z f /.x/ D
C0t
e
Rt 0
V .s/Cx ds
f .t/ C x d m.x/;
(7.9.54)
where m is the Wiener measure, which is the product of m one-dimensional Wiener measures. The right-hand side is a Wiener integral, which is computed as a path integral. Even if in the general case the integral cannot be computed explicitly, we shall work out just a few simple examples of heat kernels for which the Feynman– Kac formula can be successfully applied. 1. The operator 21 @x 2 . In this case V D 0 and m D 1 and hence formula (7.9.54) becomes Z t 2 .e 2 @x f /.x/ D f .t/ C x d m./ C0t
n n=2 Z Pn .uj 1 uj /2 e j D1 2.t =n/ f .un / dun du1 n!1 2 t Rn ( ) n n=2 Z Z P .uj 1 uj /2 n j D1 2.t =n/ D lim e dun1 du1 n!1 2 t R Rn1
D lim
f .un / dun n n=2 Z 2 t n1 .un u0 /2 2 D lim n1=2 e 2t f .un / dun n!1 2 t n R Z .vx/2 1 D e 2t f .v/ dv; (7.9.55) .2 t/1=2 R where we used that x D u0 . Making f .v/ D ıx0 .v/ yields the familiar formula of the heat kernel Z 2 .xx0 /2 1 1 t 2 .vx/ 2t 2t K.x0 ; xI t/ D .e 2 @x ıx0 /.x/ D e ı dv D e : x 0 .2 t/1=2 R .2 t/1=2
7.9 Evaluating Path Integrals
139
Equation (7.9.55) can be written in the equivalent form Z C0t
f .t/Cx d m./ D E x f .Wt Cx/ ;
where E x is the expectation operator and Wt is a Brownian motion starting at zero. This result holds in general for the right-hand side of (7.9.54): Z C0t
e
Rt
0
V .Xs / ds
h Rt i x 0 V .s/Cx ds f .t/ C x d m.x/ D E e f Xt ;
where E x is the expectation operator given that Xt is a Brownian motion starting at x. This shows that Feynman–Kac’s formula can be represented either as a path integral or as an expectation operator; see also formula (8.23.89). 2
2. The Hermite operator in m dimensions. In the case V .u/ D a2 juj2 , formula (7.9.54) becomes Z R a2 a2 t 2 2 e 2 0 j.s/Cxj ds f .t/ C x d m./ .e t .m 2 jxj / f /.x/ D C0t
D lim
n!1
2 t nm Z n
Rnm
e
Pn
j D1
juj 1 uj j2 2 C nt a2 2.t =n/
juj j2
f .un / du; 2 t nm Z e SnC1 f .un / du1 dun ; D lim n!1 n Rnm where SnC1 has the meaning given in formula (7.8.38). The rest of the path integral computation follows Sect. 7.8, with uj 2 Rm and x D u0 . The result will be the n-dimensional analog of formula (7.8.40): Z a2 2 e t .m 2 jxj / f .x/ D K.v; xI t/f .v/ dv; with K.x0 ; xI t/ D
1 .2 t/n=2 t > 0:
at n=2 a e 2 sinh.at / sinh.at/
.jxj2 Cjx0 j2 / cosh.at /2hx;x0 i
;
(7.9.56)
An application of the above formula for computing the heat kernel for the Heisenberg operator can be found in [112].
140
7 The Path Integral Approach
7.10 Non-Commutativity of Sums of Squares Let X and Y be two vector fields on Rm . We denote by X n D X X … the „ ƒ‚ n times
n-fold iterated composition of X . It is easy to note that if the vector fields X and Y commute, then the operators X n and Y n also commute; i.e., ŒX; Y D 0 H) ŒX n ; Y n D 0;
8n 1:
Since the case of concern is the sum of squares of vector fields, we shall limit ourselves to the case n D 2. Next we introduce a special class of noncommutative vector fields. Definition 7.10.1. Two vector fields X and Y satisfy condition N at the point p if ŒX 2 ; Y 2 p 6D 0. If the above condition holds at each point, the distribution D spanned by the vector fields X and Y is called an N-distribution, and the vector fields X and Y are called N-fields. Example 7.10.1. The vector fields X D @x and Y D @y C x@z satisfy condition N everywhere on R3.x;y;z/ . We have ŒX; Y D @z 6D 0; X 2 D @2z ; Y 2 D @2y C 2x@y @z C x 2 @2z ŒX 2 ; Y 2 D 4@x @y @z C 2@2z C 4x@x @2z 6D 0: The computation is left to the reader. In the following we shall provide a sufficient condition for a distribution to be of class N. First we need a few definitions. Definition 7.10.2. A distribution D D spanfX; Y g is called nilpotent if there is an integer k 1 such that all the Lie brackets of X and Y iterated k times vanish. The smallest integer k with this property is called the nilpotence class of D. For instance, the vector fields of Example 7.10.1 span a nilpotent distribution with nilpotence class k D 2: ŒX; ŒX; Y D 0;
ŒY; ŒX; Y D 0;
but ŒX; Y 6D 0:
The nilpotence class of a distribution is not the same thing as the step of the distribution. The nilpotence class describes the functional nature of the distribution (i.e., of polynomial, exponential type), while the step describes the non-holonomy of the distribution (i.e., the degree of non-integrability). More precisely, the step at the point p is the number of brackets plus 1 needed to span Rn at p. The nilpotence class
7.10 Non-Commutativity of Sums of Squares
141
and the step are the same thing only in the case when the distribution is generated by left invariant vector fields on nilpotent Lie groups (for instance, on the Heisenberg group). Example 7.10.2. For example, the distribution spanned by the vector fields X D @x C e y @z and Y D @y on R3 is bracket generating with step 2 everywhere, but it is not nilpotent. On the other side, the distribution spanned by the vector fields X D @x and Y D @y C zx@z is nilpotent with the nilpotence class 2. However, this distribution is not bracket generating on the plane fz D 0g; i.e., it does not have a finite step there. The following result can be found in [23]: Theorem 7.10.3. Any distribution D D spanfX; Y g with nilpotence class 2, is an N-distribution. Proof. Since the nilpotence class is 2, we have ŒX; ŒX; Y D 0;
ŒY; ŒY; X D 0;
ŒX; Y 6D 0:
(7.10.57)
The first two relations of (7.10.57) become X 2 Y C YX 2 D 2X YX; Y 2 X C X Y 2 D 2YX Y:
(7.10.58) (7.10.59)
Multiplying on the right of (7.10.58) by Y and of (7.10.59) by X yields X 2 Y 2 C YX 2 Y D 2.X Y /2 ; Y 2 X 2 C X Y 2 X D 2.YX /2 ; and subtracting, we have ŒX 2 ; Y 2 D X 2 Y 2 Y 2 X 2 D 2.X Y /2 YX 2 Y 2.YX /2 X Y 2 X D 2f.X Y /2 .YX /2 g C .X Y 2 X YX 2 Y /:
(7.10.60)
Multiplying on the left of (7.10.58) by Y and of (7.10.59) by X yields YX 2 Y C Y 2 X 2 D 2.YX /2; X Y 2 X C X 2 Y 2 D 2.X Y /2 ; and subtracting, we get ŒX 2 ; Y 2 D X 2 Y 2 Y 2 X 2 D 2.X Y /2 X Y 2 X 2.YX /2 YX 2 Y D 2f.X Y /2 .YX /2 g C .YX 2 Y X Y 2 X /:
(7.10.61)
142
7 The Path Integral Approach
Comparing (7.10.60) and (7.10.61) yields X Y 2 X YX 2 Y D YX 2 Y X Y 2 X ” X Y 2 X D YX 2 Y;
(7.10.62)
and hence relations (7.10.60) and (7.10.61) become ŒX 2 ; Y 2 D 2f.X Y /2 .YX /2 g:
(7.10.63)
If we let A D X Y and B D YX , using (7.10.62), the operators A and B commute, AB D .X Y /.YX / D X Y 2 X D YX 2 Y D .YX /.X Y / D BA; so A2 B 2 D .A B/.A C B/. Then (7.10.63) becomes ŒX 2 ; Y 2 D 2.X Y YX /.X Y C YX /:
(7.10.64)
We need to show that X and Y are N-fields; i.e., if ŒX; Y 6D 0, then ŒX 2 ; Y 2 6D 0. By contradiction, assume ŒX 2 ; Y 2 D 0. Then by (7.10.64), we have either: X Y YX D 0, i.e., ŒX; Y D 0, which is a contradiction. or: X Y C YX D 0, i.e., X Y D YX:
(7.10.65)
The remainder of the proof deals with showing that (7.10.65) cannot hold. By contradiction, we assume that (7.10.65) holds. Then ŒX; Y D X Y YX D 2X Y D 2YX: Therefore, we have ŒX; ŒX; Y D 0 H) ŒX; X Y D 0 H) X 2 Y D X YX; ŒY; ŒY; X D 0 H) ŒY; YX D 0 H) Y 2 X D YX Y:
(7.10.66) (7.10.67)
Using (7.10.66) and (7.10.67), we have X ŒX; Y D X.X Y YX / D X 2 Y X YX D 0; Y ŒX; Y D Y .X Y YX / D YX Y Y 2 X D 0: Combining the last two relations, we obtain ŒX; Y 2 D ŒX; Y ŒX; Y D .X Y YX /ŒX; Y D X.Y ŒX; Y / Y .X; ŒX; Y / D 0: Hence ŒX; Y D 0, which is a contradiction. It turns out that (7.10.65) cannot hold. It follows that X and Y are N-fields.
7.11 Path Integrals and Sub-Elliptic Operators
143
Next we present an example of a distribution with the nilpotence class 2. Example 7.10.3 (Heisenberg-type distributions). Consider the vector fields X; Y; T on R3 . If ŒX; Y D T; ŒX; T D 0; ŒY; T D 0; we say that D D spanfX; Y g is a Heisenberg-type distribution. Since ŒŒX; Y ; X D ŒT; X D 0;
ŒŒX; Y ; Y D ŒT; Y D 0;
it follows that D is a nilpotent distribution with the nilpotence class 2. One of the classical examples of vector fields with the above properties is X D @x C 2y@z ;
Y D @y 2x@z ;
T D 4@z :
It is left as an exercise for the reader to show that X 2 and Y 2 do not commute.
7.11 Path Integrals and Sub-Elliptic Operators In the following we shall assume that X1 and X2 are N-vector fields on R3 ; i.e., ŒX1 ; X2 6D 0 and ŒX12 ; X22 6D 0. We also assume that the distribution D D spanfX1 ; X2 g is step 2; i.e., fX1 ; X2 ; ŒX1 ; X2 g span R3 at each point. In this section we shall describe the heat kernel of the sub-elliptic operator X D 1 .X12 C X22 /. We are led to the study of the heat semigroup e t X , with t > 0. Since 2 the operators X12 and X22 do not commute, we need to invoke the Trotter formula. Hence we have t 2 t 2 n 1 2 1 2 K.t/ D e t X D e 2 tX1 C 2 tX2 D lim e 2n X1 e 2n X2 D lim Knn ; (7.11.68) n!1
n!1
where t
2
t
2
Kn D e 2n X1 e 2n X2 D Kn1 Kn2 ; t t 2 2 c1 , K c2 be the integral kernels of the cn , K with Kn1 D e 2n X1 , Kn2 D e 2n X2 . Let K n n 1 2 operators Kn , Kn , Kn , respectively. By Proposition 7.2.2, part .1/, we have
cn .x; y/ D K
Z R3
c2 .u; y/ du: c1 .x; u/K K n n
(7.11.69)
c1 and K c2 . Since the computacn , it suffices to know K Hence in order to compute K n n tions of the above integral kernels are virtually identical, it suffices to do it only for the first one.
144
7 The Path Integral Approach
c1 is the integral kernel for the operator @ K t n X12 D
3 X
ai aj @xi @xj C
i;j D1
t X 2. 2n 1
3 X
If X1 D
P3
i D1 ai @xi ,
ai .@xi aj / @xj
i;j D1
is a second-order operator with a linear term. Using Theorem 7.3.1 with L D yields a path integral form for the kernel c1 .x; yI t/ D K n
then
Z Px;yIt
e S.;t / d m./;
t X2 2n 1
(7.11.70)
where S satisfies the Hamilton–Jacobi equation (2.3.17). c2 yields K c1 and K cn by formula (7.11.69). Applying (7.11.68) yields Knowing K n n the integral kernel for @t X :
b
K.t/.x; y/
Z Z cn D lim cn .u1 ; u2 / K cn .un1 ; y/ dun1 du1 cn .x; u1 /K D lim K K n!1 n n!1 Z c2 .v ; u /K c1 .u ; v /K c2 .v ; u / K c1 .u ; v / c1 .x; v /K D lim K 1 n n 1 1 n 1 2 n 2 2 n n1 n n!1 R6n
c2 .v ; y/ dudv; K n n c with dudv D dun1 dvn1 du1 dv1 , and Knj given by (7.11.70). Even if the above computation is always theoretically possible, the computation complexity might make the integral almost impossible to evaluate, even in the case of relative simple vector fields such as X1 D @x1 and X2 D x1 @x2 . The conclusion is that the method of path integrals is not well suited to this type of operator.
Chapter 8
The Stochastic Analysis Method
This chapter deals with probabilistic methods of obtaining the heat kernel. The main idea of this subject is that the heat kernel can be represented as a transition density of an associated stochastic process, as pointed out by Kolmogorov [80] in the early 1930s. The probabilistic methods were also useful in obtaining the heat kernel of the Heisenberg Laplacian, as shown by Hulanicki [68] and Gaveau [49] in the late 1970s.
8.1 Elements of Stochastic Processes A stochastic process describes a random phenomenon that changes in time. For instance, the velocity of a small particle in a liquid, the price of a stock and the interest rates for bonds are random phenomena depending on time. A stochastic process is a family of random variables Xt depending smoothly on a parameter t 2 T . In our case, the parameter set T is usually the half-line Œ0; 1/. For each t, the random variable Xt is defined on a sample space , where we have a Borel field F of subsets of , called events, and a probability measure P on F . We shall assume the reader is already familiar with the basic notions of the probability space .; F ; P / the and random variables defined on it. For each state of the world ! 2 , the function t ! Xt .!/ is called a realization or sample path of the stochastic process. In Fig. 8.1 we have represented a few realizations of a process Xt . Stochastic processes are also called random processes or random functions. For convenience, a stochastic process will be denoted by Xt or X.t/. The process can be real-valued or vectorial. In the latter case Xt D .X1 .t/; : : : ; Xn .t// 2 Rn , for t 2 T . The joint distribution function of a real-valued stochastic process Xt is defined by F .x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xn I t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tn / D P Xt1 x1 ; Xt2 x2 ; : : : ; Xtn xn ;
O. Calin et al., Heat Kernels for Elliptic and Sub-elliptic Operators, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis, DOI 10.1007/978-0-8176-4995-1 8, c Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
145
146
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method xt
Fig. 8.1 Three realizations of the process Xt
xt xt
x
xt
t
for t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tn 2 T and n 1 integer. The previous function satisfies the following two conditions: (1) Symmetry: For any permutation .i1 ; i2 ; : : : ; in / of .1; 2; : : : ; n/ we have F .xi1 ; xi2 ; : : : ; xin I ti1 ; ti2 ; : : : ; tin / D F .x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xn I t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tn /: (2) Compatibility: For any k < n, we have F .x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xk ; 1; : : : ; 1I t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tk ; tkC1 ; : : : ; tn / D F .x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xk I t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tk /: In 1931 Kolmogorov proved that given any system of distribution functions F satisfying the previous conditions (1) and (2), there are a probability space .; F ; P / and a stochastic process Xt .!/ such that F .x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xn I t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tn / gives the joint distribution of the random variables Xt1 .!/; Xt2 .!/; : : : ; Xtn .!/: For a proof of Kolmogorov’s extension theorem, the reader can consult reference [85]. Using Kolmogorov’s result, one may define a stochastic process given the distribution function. We shall consider an important example below. The Gaussian process. This is a process Xt such that for any t1 ; : : : ; tn 2 T , the random variables Xt 1 ; X t 2 ; : : : ; X t n
8.1 Elements of Stochastic Processes
147
have an n-variate Gaussian distribution1 with E.Xtj / D m.tj /; Cov.Xtj ; Xtk / D E ŒXtj m.tj / ŒXtk m.tk / D .tj ; tk / D jk : Let D .jk / denote the covariance matrix, which is assumed nonsingular. The joint distribution function in this case is F .x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xn I t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tn / Z D
Z
x1
xn
1
1
8 n < 1 X jG.u/j1=2 exp Gij .u/ ui m.ti / : 2 .2/n=2 i;j D1 9 = du du1 ; uj m.tj / ; n
where .Gij / D G D 1 . Sometimes the following equivalent characterization of Gaussian processes is useful in practice. Proposition 8.1.1. The process Xt is Gaussian if and only if the linear combination Pn a X i D1 i ti is normally distributed for all n 1, all coefficients ai 2 R, and all times ti 2 T . The stationary process. A stochastic process Xt is called stationary in the strict sense if F .x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xn I t1 C ; t2 C ; : : : ; tn C / D F .x1 ; x2 ; : : : ; xn I t1 ; t2 ; : : : ; tn /; for any t1 ; : : : ; tn ; 2 T . For these kinds of processes, P .X./ x/ D F .x; / D F .x; 0/ D F .x/; and the mean and the variance are constants: E.Xt / D m;
1
Var.Xt / D 2 :
This means that Xt1 ; Xt2 ; : : : ; Xtn have a joint normal distribution.
(8.1.1)
148
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
Furthermore, the covariance function depends only on the difference jt sj: Z Z .s; t/ D xy dF.x; yI s; t/ D xy dF.x; yI 0; t s/ (8.1.2) R2
D .0; t s/:
R2
A process for which relations (8.1.1)–(8.1.2) hold is said to be stationary in the wide sense. Example. Let Xt D A1 cos t C A2 sin t, with A1 , A2 uncorrelated random variables, having mean 0 and variance 2 . Standard properties of random variables show that E.Xt / D E.A1 / cos t C E.A2 / sin t D 0; Var.Xt / D 2 cos2 t C 2 sin2 t D 2 ; .s; t/ D E.Xs Xt / D 2 .cos s cos t C sin s sin t/ D 2 cos.t s/: Hence Xt is a stationary process in the wide sense. The stationary Gaussian process. Another important process is the Gaussian process with constant mean m.t/ D m and covariance function .tj ; tk / D .tj tk /. This process is stationary in the wide sense. Since a Gaussian distribution is completely determined by its mean and variance, it follows that the process is also stationary in the strict sense. Independent increments process. This is a stochastic process Xt such that for any t1 < t2 < : : : < tn , the random variables Xt2 Xt1 ; Xt3 Xt2 ; : : : ; Xtn Xtn1 are mutually independent. The process is said to be stationary if the increment Xtj Xtj 1 has a distribution depending on the difference tj tj 1 . If the process Xt has independent increments and is stationary such that Xt Xs has a Gaussian distribution with mean E.Xt Xs / D 0 and variance
Var.Xt Xs / D 2 jt sj;
then Xt is called a Wiener–Einstein process. Brownian motion. A stochastic process Wt is called a Brownian motion if it satisfies the following properties: (1) The process starts at zero: W0 D 0 (2) For s < t, the random variable Wt Ws is normally distributed with mean 0 and variance t s
8.1 Elements of Stochastic Processes
149
(3) Wt has independent increments (4) The sample paths t ! Wt .!/ are continuous A Brownian motion is a stationary Gaussian process with independent increments. Its distribution function is given by Z
x
F .x; t/ D
p 1
and
P ˛ Wt Ws ˇ D p
1
2 =.2t /
2 t
e u
Z
1 2.t s/
ˇ
du;
e x
2 =2.t s/
dx;
˛
for 0 s < t and ˛ < ˇ. Since the process starts at zero, we note that Wt is normally distributed with mean 0 and variance t, see Fig. 8.2. An important fact is that the covariance Cov.Wt ; Ws / D minft; sg. This can be shown by using conditions (2) and (3). Assuming s < t, we have Cov.Wt ; Ws / D E.Ws Wt / D E .Ws W0 /.Wt Ws / C Ws2 D E.Ws W0 /E.Wt Ws / C E.Ws2 / D 0 C Var.Ws / D s D minft; sg:
The infinitesimal notation. If 0 D t0 < t1 < < tn , then the increment Wtj Wtj 1 is a random variable normally distributed with zero mean and variance tj tj 1 , and can be denoted by . W /tj . In the case when the difference dt D tj tj 1 is infinitesimal, the random variable . W /tj will be denoted by dW t . The random variable dW t has zero mean and variance p dt. It is a well-known result of stochastic analysis that dW t has the magnitude of dt; more precisely, the random variable dW 2t is completely predictable and we have dW 2t D dt in the mean sense. 5
200 -5
Fig. 8.2 A realization of a Brownian motion
-10
400
600
800
1000
150
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
Markov processes. Brownian motion belongs to a larger class of “memoryless” processes, called Markov processes. A stochastic process Xt is said to be a Markov process if P .Xt j Xt1 ; Xt2 ; : : : ; Xtk / D P .Xt j Xtk /; for any ascending sequence t1 < t2 < < tk < t. This means that the probability that the particle has position Xt at time t, given that its position is Xti at time ti , for i D 1; : : : ; k, depends only on the last position Xtk of the particle. If Xt is a real-valued process, consider the function F .x0 ; t0 I x; t/ D P .Xt x j Xt0 D x0 /; called the transition distribution function of the process Xt . This function can be interpreted as the probability that the particle will be in a state included in .1; x, given that the particle starts at the point x0 at time t0 . Using the properties of the probability, we can check that F .x0 ; t0 I x; t/ 0;
F .x0 ; t0 I 1; t/ D 0;
F .x0 ; t0 I 1; t/ D 1:
Furthermore, the transition distribution function satisfies the Chapman–Kolmogorov equation Z F .x0 ; t0 I x; t/ D
1 1
F .y; sI x; t/ dy F .x0 ; t0 I y; s/;
t0 < s < t:
(8.1.3)
The derivative of the transition distribution function f .x0 ; t0 I x; t/ D
@ F .x0 ; t0 I x; t/ @x
(8.1.4)
is called the transition density function of Xt . It satisfies the Chapman–Kolmogorov equation Z f .x0 ; t0 I x; t/ D
1
1
f .y; sI x; t/ f .x0 ; t0 I y; s/ dy;
t0 < s < t:
(8.1.5)
The transition density function will play an important role in finding the heat kernel of certain second-order partial differential operators which generate stochastic processes. In the case t0 D 0, we shall denote pt .x0 ; x/ D f .x0 ; 0I x; t/. This makes sense in the case when the transition distribution function F .x0 ; t0 I x; t/ depends on the difference t t0 . These kinds of processes are called homogeneous. In this case F .x0 I x; t/ D P .Xt x j X0 D x0 /; and pt .x0 ; x/ D f .x0 I x; t/ D
@ @x F .x0 I x; t/.
8.1 Elements of Stochastic Processes
151
Stochastic differential equations. In the case of ordinary differential equations we deal with equations of the form dX t dY t D aX t C b ; dt dt
t 0;
which can also be written in the differential form dX t D aX t dt C b dY t ; where Yt is a given function. In the case of stochastic differential equations the continuous process t ! Xt is not differentiable, so one may not write dX t =dt. The stochastic processes of concern in this chapter have the form dX t D a.t; Xt /dt C b.t; Xt / dW t :
(8.1.6)
This can be interpreted as the infinitesimal notation for the finite difference equation Xt Ch Xt D a.t; Xt /h C b.t; Xt / .Wt Ch Wt /;
h & 0:
Another way of looking at (8.1.6) is by using integrals: Z
Z
t 0
dX s D
Z
t 0
a.s; Xs / ds C
0
t
b.s; Xs / dW s ;
where the last term on the right-hand side is an Ito integral. More details about stochastic differential equations and stochastic integrals can be found in references [95] and [83]. Ito’s formula. A process of the type (8.1.6) is called an Ito process. Consider the process Ft D F .t; Xt / derived2 from Xt , with F twice differentiable in both arguments. Ito’s formula provides the expression of dFt , which looks like a usual Taylor series up to the second derivative in Xt : dFt D
2 @F @F 1 @2 F dX t C dt C dX t : 2 @Xt @t 2 @Xt
Using the stochastic relations .dW t /2 D dt;
dt dW t D dW t dt D .dt/2 D 0;
If Xt is the stock price at time t , a financial instrument with the price Ft D F .t; Xt / derived from Xt is called a financial derivative.
2
152
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
the aforementioned formula becomes the Ito formula
@F @F @F 1 @2 F 2 a.t; Xt / C b.t; Xt / dt C b.t; Xt / dW t : dF t D C 2 @Xt @t 2 @Xt @Xt (8.1.7) For instance, if Ft D F .t; Wt / D Wt2 is the square of the one-dimensional Brownian motion, then 1 dF t D 2Wt dW t C Œ2.dW t /2 D 2Wt dW t C dt: 2 There is also a multidimensional version of Ito’s formula. In this case W1 .t/; : : : ; Wm .t/ denote m independent Brownian motions and consider n Ito processes dX j .t/ D aj .t; Xt / dt C bj1 .t; Xt / dW 1 .t/ C C bj m .t; Xt / dW m .t/; j D 1; : : : ; n: (8.1.8) We have the following result. Lemma 8.1.2 (Ito). Let F .t; x/ D F1 .t; x/; : : : ; Fp.t; x/ be a C 2 map from Œ0; 1/ Rn into Rp , where Xt D X1 .t/; : : : ; Xn .t/ is given by (8.1.8). Then the process Yt D F .t; Xt / is also an Ito process satisfying d Yt D
X @F @F 1 X @2 F .t; X / dXk .t/ C .t; X / dXi .t/ dX j .t/; .t; X / dt C @xk @t 2 @xi @xj k
i;j
with the conventions dW i .t/ dW j .t/ D ıij dt, dW i .t/ dt D dt dW i .t/ D 0.
8.2 Ito Diffusion This section deals with a particular type of Ito process that is related to our study of heat kernels. Definition 8.2.1. A time-homogeneous Ito diffusion is an n-dimensional stochastic process t 0; X0 D x; (8.2.9) dX t D b.Xt /dt C .Xt / dW.t/; where W .t/ D W1 .t/; : : : Wm .t/ is an m-dimensional Brownian motion and b W Rn ! Rn and W Rn ! Rnm are measurable functions.
8.2 Ito Diffusion
153
In general, the stochastic differential equation (8.2.9) does not have a unique solution. For instance, the one-dimensional equation dX t D 3Xt1=3 dt C 3Xt2=3 dW t ;
X0 D 0;
(8.2.10)
has infinitely many solutions. If for any a > 0 we define 'a .x/ D
.x a/3 ; x a; 0; x < a; 2=3
then a straightforward computation provides the derivatives 'a0 .x/ D 3'a .x/ and 'a00 .x/ D 6'a1=3 .x/. Denoting Fa .t/ D 'a Wt , an application of Ito’s formula yields 1 dFt D 'a0 .Wt /dW t C 'a00 .Wt /dt; 2 D 3Fa .t/2=3 dW t C 3Fa .t/1=3 dt: Moreover, Fa .0/ D 'a .W0 / D 'a .0/ D 0. Hence the aforementioned equation has a solution Fa .t/ D 'a .Wt / for each a > 0. Sometimes the solution of (8.2.9) might explode in finite time. An application of Ito’s formula shows that Xt D 1=.1 Wt / is a solution for the following stochastic differential equation: dX t D Xt3 dt C Xt2 dW t ;
t 0; X0 D 1;
(8.2.11)
which blows up when the Brownian motion Wt reaches 1. As in the theory of ordinary differential equations, in order to ensure the existence and uniqueness of the solution of the stochastic differential equation (8.2.9), we need to require an additional Lipschitz condition on the functions b.x/ and .x/. Let jj2 D
X
ij2
denote the norm of the matrix function . The following result can be found, for instance, in reference [95], Theorem 5.2.1. Theorem 8.2.2. If there is a constant K > 0 such that jb.x/ b.y/j C j.x/ .y/j Kjx yj;
8x; y 2 Rn ;
(8.2.12)
then there is a unique stochastic process .Xt /t 0 satisfying the stochastic differential equation (8.2.9).
154
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
Equation (8.2.10) does not satisfy condition (8.2.12). To show this, let’s assume there is a positive constant K such that jx 1=3 y 1=3 j C jx 2=3 y 2=3 j Kjx yj
(8.2.13)
for all x; y 2 R. Let u D x 1=3 and v D y 1=3 . Then (8.2.13) becomes ju vj C ju2 v2 j Kju3 v3 j;
8u; v 2 R:
Assuming u 6D v and dividing by ju vj, the preceding equation becomes 1 C ju C vj < Kju2 C uv C v2 j: This implies 1 < Kju2 C uv C v2 j or 1 < ju2 C uv C v2 j; K
u; v 2 R; u 6D v:
(8.2.14)
If > 0 and we let juj < , jvj < , then the right term is bounded by ju2 C uv C v2 j juj2 C juj jvj C jvj2 < 3 2 : p This contradicts the inequality of (8.2.14) if we choose < 1= 3K. Hence the inequality (8.2.14) does not hold for x and y small enough, with x 6D y. The Lipschitz condition (8.2.12) does not hold for the stochastic equation (8.2.10), and hence the uniqueness result given by Theorem 8.2.2 does not hold.
8.3 The Generator of an Ito Diffusion Let .Xt /t 0 be a stochastic process with X0 D x0 . In this section we shall deal with the operator associated with Xt . The generator of the stochastic process Xt is the second-order partial differential operator A defined by Af .x/ D lim
t &0
EŒf .Xt / f .x/ ; t
for any smooth function (at least of class C 2 ) with compact support f W Rn ! R. Here E stands for the expectation operator taken at t D 0; i.e., Z EŒf .Xt / D
Rn
f .y/pt .x; y/ dy;
where pt .x; y/ is the transition density of Xt .
8.3 The Generator of an Ito Diffusion
155
In the following we shall find the generator associated with the Ito diffusion (8.2.9). The main tool used in deriving the formula for A is Ito’s formula in several variables. If we let Ft D f .Xt /, then using Ito’s formula, we have dFt D
X @f 1 X @2 f j .Xt / dX it C .Xt / dX it dX t ; @xi 2 @xi @xj i
(8.3.15)
i;j
where Xt D .Xt1 ; : : : ; Xtn / satisfies the Ito diffusion (8.2.9) on components; i.e., dX it D bi .Xt /dt C Œ.Xt / dW.t/i X D bi .Xt /dt C i k dW k .t/:
(8.3.16)
k
Using the stochastic relations dt2 D dt dW k .t/ D 0 and dW k .t/ dW r .t/ D ıkr dt, a computation provides X X i k dW k .t/ bj dt C jk dW k .t/ dX it dX jt D bi dt C D
X
k
i k dW k .t/
X
k
jr dW r .t/
r
k
D
X
i k jr dW k .t/dW r .t/ D
X
k;r
i k jk dt
k
D . T /ij dt: Therefore, dX it dX jt D . T /ij dt: Substituting (8.3.16) and (8.3.17) into (8.3.15) yields " dFt D
# X @f 1 X @2 f T .Xt /. /ij C bi .Xt / .Xt / dt 2 @xi @xj @xi i;j
i
X @f .Xt /i k .Xt / dW k .t/: C @xi i;k
integrating, we obtain # Z t" X 2 X @f 1 @ f T . /ij C bi Ft D F0 C .Xs / ds 2 @xi @xj @xi 0 i;j i XZ t X @f C i k .Xs / dW k .s/: @x i 0 k
i
(8.3.17)
156
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
Since F0 D f .X0 / D f .x/ and E.f .x// D f .x/, applying the ,expectation operator in the previous relation, we obtain 2 E.Ft / D f .x/ C E 4
Z
t 0
3 1 2 X @f X 1 @ f @ A .Xs / ds 5 : . T /ij C bi 2 @xi @xj @xi 0
i;j
i
Using the commutation between the operator E and the integral
Rt 0
(8.3.18) yields
1X E.Ft / f .x/ @2 f .x/ X @f .x/ D . T /ij C bk : t 2 @xi @xj @xk t &0 lim
i;j
k
We conclude the previous computations with the following result. Theorem 8.3.1. The generator of the Ito diffusion (8.2.9) is given by AD
X @2 @ 1X . T /ij C bk : 2 @xi @xj @xk i;j
(8.3.19)
k
Substituting (8.3.19) in (8.3.18), we obtain Dynkin’s formula: Z EŒf .Xt / D f .x/ C E
0
t
Af .Xs / ds ;
(8.3.20)
for any f 2 C02 .Rn /.
8.4 Kolmogorov’s Backward Equation and Heat Kernel For any function f 2 C02 .Rn /, let v.t; x/ D EŒf .Xt /, given that X0 D x. As usual, E denotes the expectation at time t D 0. Then v.0; x/ D f .x/, and differentiating in Dynkin’s formula (8.3.20), Z v.t; x/ D f .x/ C 0
t
EŒAf .Xs / ds;
yields @v D EŒAf .Xt / D AEŒf .Xt / D Av.t; x/: @t We have arrived at the following result.
8.5 Algorithm for Finding the Heat Kernel
157
Theorem 8.4.1 (Kolmogorov’s backward equation). For any f 2 C02 .Rn /, the function v.t; x/ D EŒf .Xt / satisfies the following Cauchy problem: @v D Av; @t v.0; x/ D f .x/;
t > 0;
where A denotes the generator of the Ito diffusion (8.2.9). Using the expression of the expectation operator, the previous solution can also be written in the familiar form Z f .y/ pt .x; y/ dy; v.t; x/ D Rn
which implies that the transition density pt .x; y/ of the process Xt is the heat kernel for the operator A. This observation is fundamental and will lead to a method of computing heat kernels for second-order partial differential operators. The formalization of this fact will be done as in the following. Let f .x/ D ıx be the Dirac distribution centered at x 2 Rn ; i.e., Z ıx .'/ D ıx .y/'.y/ dy D '.x/: Rn
Then for any x0 2 Rn , Z v.t; x0 / D
Rn
ıx .y/ pt .x0 ; y/ dy D pt .x0 ; x/
satisfies @v D Av; @t lim v.t; x/ D ıx I
t > 0;
t &0
i.e., pt .x0 ; x/ is the heat kernel of the operator A. Equivalently, pt .x0 ; x/ is the transition density function between the points x0 D X0 and x D Xt for the diffusion process (8.2.9).
8.5 Algorithm for Finding the Heat Kernel We shall conclude the last few sections with the following algorithm for finding heat kernels for second-order differential operators:
158
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
1. Consider a second-order operator of the form AD
n n X @ 1 X ij @2 g .x/ C bk ; 2 @xi @xj @xk i;j D1
kD1
with det gij .x/ eventually zero at some points. 2. Decompose the matrix g.x/ 2 Rnn as g.x/ D .x/ T .x/, where .x/ 2 Rnm . 3. Construct the homogeneous Ito diffusion process dXt D b.Xt /dt C .Xt / dW.t/;
t 0; X0 D x0 ;
where W .t/ D W1 .t/; : : : ; Wm .t/ are m independent Brownian motions. 4. Solve the stochastic differential equation for Xt and find the transition density pt .x0 ; x/ with Xt D x, X0 D x0 . 5. The heat kernel (propagator) of the operator A is given by the transition density K.x0 ; xI t/ D pt .x0 ; x/. All the previous steps are almost obvious, with the exception of steps 2 and 4. When solving for Xt , we need also to check the uniqueness of solution by Theorem 8.2.2. The delicate part is to figure out the transition density associated with the process Xt , especially in cases when Xt has a complicated expression. Several methods of finding the transition density will be presented in the next section. We finalize this section with a simple application of the aforementioned algorithm for the operator 12 @2x . In this case n D m D 1 and b D 0, g D 1. Then D 1 and the associated Ito diffusion is dX t D dW t ;
X0 D x0 :
The solution is given by Xt D x0 C Wt , t 0. Since the Brownian motion Wt is normally distributed with mean 0 and variance t, it follows that Xt is normally distributed with mean x0 and variance t, so the transition density for Xt is pt .x0 ; x/ D p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
;
t > 0:
Hence the heat kernel for 12 @2x is given by K.x0 ; xI t/ D p
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
;
t > 0:
8.6 Finding the Transition Density
159
8.6 Finding the Transition Density We concluded in the previous section that the problem of finding the heat kernel is now reduced to the problem of finding the transition density of an Ito diffusion process. Next we shall present a few techniques of obtaining the transition density that will be useful in the sequel when computing heat kernels. 1. The case of a well-known distribution. In this case Xt is one of the familiar stochastic processes for which the density is well known. We shall next consider a few examples. 2
1 If Xt D Wt is a Brownian motion, then pt .0; x/ D p2 e x =.2t / ; see t Fig. 8.3.a/. If Xt D x0 C Wt , i.e., a Brownian motion starting at x0 , then the transition 2 density is pt .x0 ; x/ D p 1 e .xx0 / =.2t / . 2 t
If Xt D e Yt , with Yt normally distributed with mean and variance 2 , then Xt is lognormally distributed, with .ln x/2 1 e 2 2 ; pD p x 2
x > 0:
For instance, in the particular case when Xt D e Wt Cc , with c 2 R given by c D ln x0 , the transition density is .ln xln x0 /2 1 2t ; e pt .x0 ; x/ D p x 2 t
x > 0I
(8.6.21)
see Fig. 8.3b. 2. Reduction to a well-known distribution. Here we shall distinguish between the cases of one and more variables.
b
a
0.4
1.2 1.0
0.3
0.8 0.2
0.6 0.4
0.1
0.2 −1.0
−0.5
0.5
1.0
2
4
6
8
Fig. 8.3 .a/ The standard normal distribution; .b/ the lognormal distribution with D 1, D 0:5
160
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
The case of one variable. Let Xt D h.Wt C c/, with h an increasing, smooth function with the inverse h1 D g. The process starts at x0 D h.c/, so c D g.x0 /. If FXt and FWt denote the distribution functions of Xt and Wt , respectively, then we have FXt .x/ D P .Xt x/ D P .h.Wt C c/ x/ D P .Wt g.x/ c/ D FWt .g.x/ g.x0 //: Differentiating, we obtain the transition probability of Xt : d FX .x/ D FW0 t .g.x/ g.x0 // g 0 .x/ dx t .g.x/g.x0 //2 1 2t D p e g 0 .x/: 2 t
pt .x0 ; x/ D
We note that we recover formula (8.6.21) in the case h.x/ D ln x. The case of several variables. We shall next deal with the case of two variables. The general case of n variables can be treated in a similar way. Consider a continuous differentiable transformation of the region .x1 ; x2 / 2 R into the region .y1 ; y2 / 2 S given by y1 D g.x1 ; x2 /; y2 D h.x1 ; x2 /; with the nonzero Jacobian
@yi @.y1 ; y2 / D det 6D 0; @.x1 ; x2 / @xj i;j
8.x1 ; x2 / 2 R:
By the inverse function theorem, we can write x1 D G.y1 ; y2 /; x2 D H.y1 ; y2 /;
8.y1 ; y2 / 2 S:
Consider the two-dimensional stochastic process Xt D .Xt1 ; Xt2 / such that the vector .x1 ; x2 / is a possible value of Xt . Consider another stochastic process Yt D .Yt1 ; Yt2 / defined by Yt1 D g.Xt1 ; Xt2 /; Yt2 D h.Xt1 ; Xt2 /: Let pX .x/ and pY .y/ be the probability density functions of Xt and Yt , respectively. Since we have P .Xt 2 R/ D P .Yt 2 S/;
8.6 Finding the Transition Density
161
and the left side is given by ZZ P .Xt 2 R/ D
ZZ R
@xi pX .G.y/; H.y// det @y j S
pX .x/ dx D
while the right side is
dy;
ZZ P .Yt 2 S/ D
S
pY .y/ dy;
equating yields
ZZ S
pX .G.y/; H.y// det
@xi @yj
ZZ dy D S
pY .y/ dy:
Since this relation holds for any set S, it follows that pY .y/ D pX .G.y/; H.y// det
@xi @yj
:
Inverting, we get a formula that provides the density function of Xt in terms of the density function of Yt :
@yi : (8.6.22) pX .x/ D pY .g.x/; h.x// det @xj A similar relation holds for the n-dimensional case. If the process Xt can be transformed into the process Yt , and the joint density function for .Yt1 ; Yt2 / is known, then formula (8.6.22) provides a formula for the joint density function of .Xt1 ; Xt2 /. In the particular case when Yt1 and Yt2 are independent processes, then pY .y/ D pY 1 .y1 / pY 2 .y2 / and the aforementioned formula becomes
@yi : (8.6.23) pX .x/ D pY 1 .g.x//pY 2 .h.x// det @xj 3. Reduction to a Wiener integral. Sometimes we deal with stochastic differential equations of the form dX t D f .t/dW t ;
X0 D x0 ;
where Wt is a one-dimensional Brownian motion. The solution can be written in terms of a Wiener integral, Z t X t D x0 C f .s/ dW s : (8.6.24) 0
The following result can be found in [83], p. 11.
162
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
Rb Theorem 8.6.1. Let f 2 L2 Œa; b. Then the Wiener integral a f .s/ dW s is a Rb Gaussian random variable with mean 0 and variance kf k2 D a f .s/2 ds. The idea of the proof is to show that the result holds for the step functions first. Then approximating any function f 2 L2 Œa; b by step functions, and using that the limit of a Gaussian random variable is Gaussian, one obtains the desired result. The proof details can be found in [83]. Using Theorem 8.6.1, R t the process Xt given by (8.6.24) is Gaussian, with mean x0 and variance 2 D 0 f .s/2 ds. Then the transition density of Xt is Z t
1=2 .xx0 /2 1 2 R t f 2 .s/ ds 2 0 pt .x0 ; x/ D 2 f .s/ ds e ;
t > 0:
(8.6.25)
0
4. The case of an integrated Brownian motion. The solution of the stochastic differential equation dXt D Wt dt;
X0 D x0
is given by
Z Xt D x0 C
t 0;
t 0
Ws ds
(8.6.26)
and is called an integrated Brownian motion. A realization of an integrated Brownian motion starting at x0 D 0 is given in Fig. 8.4. We shall find next the transition density of Xt .
y
0:8
0:5 Xt =
t 0
Ws ds
0:2 0:3
0:6 .
0:9 . t
Fig. 8.4 A realization of an integrated Brownian motion Xt D
Rt 0
Ws ds
8.6 Finding the Transition Density
163
For any smooth function f, the integration by parts for a Riemann–Stieltjes integral yields Z
Z
b a
f .s/ dW s D f .b/Wb f .a/Wa Z D f .b/Wb f .a/Wa
b
Ws df .s/
a b a
Ws f 0 .s/ ds:
Making f .s/ D s, a D 0, b D t, and using that W0 D 0, the previous relation implies Z t Z t Ws ds D tWt s dW s : 0
0
Then (8.6.26) becomes Z Xt D .x0 C tWt /
t
s dW s ;
0
t > 0:
(8.6.27)
Then Xt is a difference of two Gaussian random variables (see Theorem 8.6.1), and hence it will be Gaussian. Its mean is equal to Z E.Xt / D E.x0 C tWt / E
t 0
f .s/ dW s
D x0 :
A direct computation (see [99], p. 370) shows that the variance is Z Var.Xt / D Var
t 0
Ws ds D
t3 : 3
Hence the transition probability of Xt is given by r pt .x0 ; x/ D
3.xx0 /2 3 2t 3 e ; 2 t 3
t > 0:
(8.6.28)
5. Using the transition distribution function. If Xt is a one-dimensional continuous stochastic process with X0 D x0 , we recall that the transition distribution function is defined by F .x0 I x; t/ D P .Xt x j X0 D x0 /; where P denotes the probability. Then the transition density is obtained by differentiating the distribution function pt .x0 ; x/ D
d F .x0 I x; t/: dx
164
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
A similar relation works in the case of several variables. For instance, consider a two-dimensional continuous process Xt D X1 .t/; X2 .t/ ; then define F .x10 ; x20 I x1 ; x2 I t/ D P .X1 .t/ x1 ; X2 .t/ x2 j X1 .0/ D x10 ; X2 .0/ D x20 /: Then the transition probability is obtained as the following mixed derivative: pt .x0 ; x/ D
@2 F .x10 ; x20 I x1 ; x2 I t/: @x1 @x2
6. Using the expectation operator. Assume again that Xt is a one-dimensional continuous stochastic process with X0 D x0 , and transition density pt .x0 ; x/. Then the expectation operator is given by Z (8.6.29) EŒf .Xt / D f .x/pt .x0 ; x/ dx; for any function f. This will lead to the following formula for computing the transition probability: pt .x0 ; x/ D EŒı.Xt x/; (8.6.30) where ı is the Dirac distribution and Xt is the associated stochastic process with X0 D x0 and Xt D x. The reason behind the aforementioned formula is the simple computation Z EŒı.Xt x/ D
ı.y x/pt .x0 ; y/ dy D pt .x0 ; x/I
see formula (8.6.29). We shall exemplify this in the case of the operator 12 @2x . The associated Ito diffusion satisfies dX t D dW t with the solution Xt D x0 C Wt . Consequently, Z pt .x0 ; x/ D EŒı.x0 C Wt x/ D
y2 1 e 2t dy ı.y .x x0 // p 2 t
.xx0 /2 1 e 2t : D p 2 t
However, for sub-elliptic operators, this easy computation does not work. Then we shall proceed as in the following. The trick is to use the expression of the Dirac distribution as the inverse Fourier transform of 1: Z 1 ı.y/ D e i y d : 2
8.6 Finding the Transition Density
165
Then we have Z
y2 1 e 2t dy ı.y x C x0 / p 2 t Ry Z Z y2 1 1 e i .yxCx0 / d e 2t dy D p 2 t Ry 2 R # Z "Z 2 1 1 i .yxCx0 / y2t e dy d D p 2 t 2 R R # "Z Z y2 1 1 D p e i .xx0 / e i y 2t dy d : 2 t 2 R R
pt .x0 ; x/ D
(8.6.31)
From relation (1.6.6), we have Z p y2 2 e i y 2t dy D 2 te t =2 : R
Substituting in (8.6.31) and using (1.6.6) yields pt .x0 ; x/ D
1 2
1 D 2
Z
t
2
e i .xx0 / e 2 d R
r
.xx0 /2 1 2 .xx0 /2 2t Dp e 2t : e t 2 t
(8.6.32)
The aforementioned computation can also be applied in the case of several variables. For instance, in the case of the operator 12 .@2x C @2y /, the associated stochastic process is .Xt ; Yt / D .x0 C Wt ; y0 C Wt / and the probability density can be computed as pt .x0 ; y0 I x; y/ D EŒı.Xt x/ı.Yt y/ D EŒı.x0 C Wt x/EŒı.y0 C Wt y/ Dp
1 2 t
e
.xx0 /2 2t
p
1 2 t
e
.yy0 /2 2t
D
1 1 Œ.xx0 /2 C.yy0 /2 : e 2t 2 t
The main ingredient of the computation was EŒX Y D EŒX EŒY for X and Y independent random variables. However, in general, Xt and Yt are not independent processes and the computation becomes more complicated. We shall deal with this case in Sect. 8.17. 7. Exponential martingale. Let Xt be a one-dimensional stochastic process satisRT fying EŒ 0 Xt2 dt < 1, with T 1. Define the process Zt D e
Rt
0
Xs dW s 1 2
Rt 0
Xs2 ds
:
166
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
A sufficient condition that Zt be a martingale is Novikov condition (see [95], p. 55): 1 RT 2 E e 2 0 Xs ds < 1: This property has a useful consequence. Since Z0 D 1, from the martingale condition EŒZt D Z0 D 1, so i h Rt R 1 t 2 E e 0 Xs dW s =e 2 0 Xs ds D 1;
8t > 0:
If the process Xt is independent of Wt , then i h Rt R 1 t 2 E e 0 Xs dW s D e 2 0 Xs ds :
(8.6.33)
In particular, if Xt D ˛ is a constant process, the aforementioned relation becomes 1 2 EŒe ˛Wt D e 2 ˛ t .
8.7 Kolmogorov’s Forward Equation The adjoint operator of the operator Af .x/ D
X i;j
aij .x/
X @2 f @f C bk .x/ @xi @xj @xk k
is given by A .x/ D
X i;j
X @ @2 .aij / .bk /; @xi @xj @xk k
and satisfies the property hAf; iL2 D hf; A iL2 , for any f; 2 C02 . Let pt .x; y/ be a smooth transition density of the process Xt which satisfies the stochastic differential equation (8.2.9). Denote by A the generator of the Ito diffusion Xt . (x0 and x have been replaced in this section by x and y, respectively.) Theorem 8.7.1 (Kolmogorov’s forward equation.). The transition density pt .x; y/ satisfies the equation3 d pt .x; y/ D Ay pt .x; y/; dt
3
This equation is also called the Fokker–Plank equation.
8x; y 2 Rn :
8.8 The Operator 12 @2x x@x
167
Proof. Substituting the expectation operator EŒf .Xt / D Dynkin’s formula (8.3.20) yields Z
Z Rn
f .y/pt .x; y/ dy D f .x/ C
t
R
f .y/pt .x; y/ dy into !
Z
0
Rn
Rn
Ay f .y/ ps .x; y/ dy ds:
Differentiating with respect to t and using the definition of the adjoint, we obtain Z
d f .y/ pt .x; y/ dy D dt Rn D
and hence
d p .x; y/ dt t
Z ZR
n
Rn
Ay f .y/ pt .x; y/ dy f .y/ Ay pt .x; y/ dy;
8f 2 C02 .Rn /;
D Ay pt .x; y/.
In the following sections we shall consider several examples of second-order partial differential operators associated with an Ito diffusion for which we shall calculate the heat kernels following the algorithm presented in Sect. 8.5.
8.8 The Operator 12 @x2 x@x In this section we shall study an operator associated with Langevin’s equation in one dimension, dX t D Xt dt C dW t ;
t 0;
(8.8.34)
with X0 D x0 . The aforementioned equation is a homogeneous Ito diffusion with coefficients .x/ D 1 and b.x/ D x. Using formula (8.3.19), we obtain the generator for Langevin’s equation: AD
1 @2 @ x : 2 @x 2 @x
Next we shall solve (8.8.34) by multiplying by the integrating factor e t : e t dX t C Xt e t dt D e t dW t ” d.e t Xt / D e t dW t : Integrating yields e t Xt D x0 C
Z
t
e s dW s ” Z t Xt D e t x0 C e t e s dW s : 0
0
(8.8.35)
168
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
Since Xt can be expressed in terms of Wiener integral, using Theorem 8.6.1 it follows that Xt is a Gaussian process, with mean E.Xt / D e t x0 and variance Var.Xt / D e 2t
Z
t
e 2s ds D
0
1 e 2t : 2
If we denote the Gaussian density with mean and variance t by Gt .; x/ D p
1 2 t
e
.x/2 2t
;
t > 0;
then Xt has density G.1e2t /=2 .e t x0 ; /. Following the algorithm of Sect. 8.5, the heat kernel of the operator (8.8.35) is given by K.x0 ; xI t/ D pt .x0 ; x/ D G.1e2t /=2 .e t x0 ; x/ .xx0 e t /2 1 e 1e2t D p .1 e 2t / 2
2
x Cx x x 1 0 Cx 2 C 0 D p e 1e2t 0 sinh t ; .1 e 2t /
t > 0:
8.9 Generalized Brownian Motion Consider the stochastic differential equation dX t D a dt C b dW t ;
X0 D x0 ;
(8.9.36)
with a; b 2 R constants, called the drift and diffusion coefficients. Sometimes this is also called Brownian motion with drift. Let X0 D x0 . Integrating in (8.9.36) yields Z Xt D x0 C at C b
t 0
dW s
D x0 C at C bWt ; which is Gaussian distributed with mean E.Xt / D x0 C at and variance Var.Xt / D b 2 t, so the transition density is Gb 2 t .x0 C at; x/ D
1 1 .xx0 at /2 e 2t b2 : p jbj 2 t
(8.9.37)
8.9 Generalized Brownian Motion
169
Using formula (8.3.19), the generator of the generalized Brownian motion (8.9.36) is given by AD
1 2 @2 @ Ca : b 2 2 @x @x
(8.9.38)
Using (8.9.37), it follows that the heat kernel of the operator (8.9.38) is given by 1 1 .xx0 at /2 e 2t b2 ; pt .x0 ; x/ D p b 2 t
t > 0;
(8.9.39)
where we assumed b > 0. We can easily extend this result to the case of n variables considering the operator LD
n n X 1 X 2 @2 @ bj 2 C aj : 2 @xj @xj j D1 j D1
(8.9.40)
The aforementioned operator is the generator of the n-dimensional generalized Brownian motion dX jt D aj dt C bj dW j .t/;
j D 1; : : : ; n:
(8.9.41)
Since W1 .t/; : : : ; Wn .t/ are independent Brownian motions, the processes Xt1 ; : : : ; Xtn are also independent, and hence the joint density function for .Xt1 ; : : : ; Xtn / is the product of the probability density functions associated with each Xtj : n Y ptj .x0j ; x j /; pt .x0 ; x/ D j D1
where ptj .x0j ; x j / D
1
j
2
2 .xj x0 aj t / 1 p e 2t bj ; jbj j 2 t
This is equivalent to the relation e Lt D e L1 t CCLn t D e L1 t e Ln t ; where Lj D
@ 1 2 @2 bj 2 C aj : 2 @xj @xj
t > 0:
170
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
Proposition 8.9.1. The heat kernel of the operator (8.9.40) is 1 Pn 1 2t j D1 K.x0 ; xI t/ D e jb1 bn j.2 t/n=2
xj xj aj t 2 0 bj
;
t > 0: (8.9.42)
Taking b1 D D bn , we obtain the following result. P P 2 Corollary 8.9.2. The heat kernel of 12 njD1 @ 2 C njD1 aj @x@ is @xj
j
kxx0 k2 kak2 1 e 2t 2 t Cha; xx0 i ; n=2 .2 t/
K.x0 ; xI t/ D
t > 0;
where x0 D .x01 ; : : : ; x0n /, x D .x1 ; : : : ; xn /, a D .a1 ; an / and k k, h ; i denote the length and the inner product of vectors in Rn . Taking a D 12 , we obtain the next result. Corollary 8.9.3. The heat kernel of
1 @2 2 @x 2
1 @ 2 @x
is
.xx0 /2 1 1 1 K.x0 ; xI t/ D p e 2t 2 .xx0 / 8 t ; 2 t
t > 0:
8.10 Linear Noise The following Ito diffusion dX t D Xt dW t ;
X0 D x0 > 0;
(8.10.43)
is modeling linear noise. According to formula (8.3.19), the generator associated with the previous equation is AD
1 2 @2 ; x 2 @x 2
x > 0:
(8.10.44)
Following the algorithm of Sect. 8.5, we next need to solve (8.10.43). In order to do this, we shall consider the process Ft D ln Xt . Applying Ito’s lemma, we obtain 1 1 1 dX t dX 2 Xt 2 Xt2 t 1 1 1 2 D dX t X dt Xt 2 Xt2 t 1 D dW t dt; 2
dFt D
8.11 Geometric Brownian Motion
171
where we used (8.10.43). Integrating yields Z Ft D F0 C
t 0
1 dW s 2
ln Xt D ln x0 C Wt
Z
t
ds ” 0
t ” 2
t
t
Xt D e ln x0 CWt 2 D x0 e Wt 2 : Since Yt D ln x0 C Wt t=2 is normally distributed with mean D ln x0 t=2 and variance 2 D t, then following item 1 of Sect. 8.6, the process Xt has a lognormal distribution with the transition density pt .x0 ; x/ D
p
1
x 2 2
e
.ln x/ 2 2
2
.ln xln x0 C t /2 1 2 2t e D p x 2 t
D
1 t 1 2 1 p e 2t .ln xln x0 / 2 .ln xln x0 / 8 x 2 t
D
1 t x0 1 2 1 e 2t .ln xln x0 / 2 .ln xCln x0 / 8 ; p x 2 t
t > 0;
(8.10.45)
with x; x0 > 0. To conclude, the operator (8.10.44) has the heat kernel given by (8.10.45).
8.11 Geometric Brownian Motion The following stochastic differential equation dX t D ˛Xt dt C ˇXt dW t ;
X0 D x0 > 0;
(8.11.46)
is called geometric Brownian motion and is famous for its applications in the stock market.4 Both the drift and diffusion coefficients are linear, b.x/ D ˛x, .x/ D ˇx, and using (8.3.19) the generator associated with (8.11.46) becomes A D A˛;ˇ D
4
1 2 2 @2 @ ˇ x C ˛x : 2 @x 2 @x
In mathematical finance Xt represents the stock price with return ˛ and volatility ˇ.
(8.11.47)
172
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
We shall first solve the stochastic equation (8.11.46). Let Ft D ln Xt , with F0 D ln x0 . An application of Ito’s lemma yields 1 1 1 dX t .dX t /2 Xt 2 Xt2 1 1 1 2 2 D .˛Xt dt C ˇXt dW t / ˇ Xt dt Xt 2 Xt2 1 D .˛ ˇ2 /dt C ˇ dW t : 2
dFt D
Integrate and get
Z t Z t 1 2 Ft D F0 C dW s ” ˛ ˇ ds C ˇ 2 0 0
1 ln Xt D ln x0 C ˛ ˇ 2 t C ˇWt ; 2 and hence the solution is 1
Xt D e ln x0 C.˛ 2 ˇ
2 /t CˇW
t
:
(8.11.48)
Let Ut D ln x0 C .˛ 12 ˇ2 /t C ˇWt . The process Ut is normally distributed with mean D ln x0 C .˛ 12 ˇ 2 /t and variance 2 D ˇt. Using the item 1 of Sect. 8.6, we obtain that Xt D e Ut is lognormally distributed with the transition density 2 1 1 .ln x/ 2 2 p e x 2 2 ˇ2 2 1 1 1 D p e 2ˇt Œln xln x0 .˛ 2 / ; x 2ˇt
pt .x0 ; x/ D
t > 0; (8.11.49)
with x; x0 > 0. To conclude, the heat kernel of the operator (8.11.47) is given by the relation (8.11.49). In the particular case when ˇ D 1 and ˛ D 12 , the Ito diffusion (8.11.48) becomes Xt D x0 e Wt ; see (Fig. 8.5). The generator operator A 1 ;1 D 2
1 2 @2 1 @ C x ; x 2 @x 2 2 @x
x > 0;
has the heat kernel K.x0 ; xI t/ D
1 1 1 2 p e 2t .ln xln x0 / ; x 2 t
t > 0:
8.11 Geometric Brownian Motion
173
y
0:8
X t = e Wt
0:5 0:2
0:3 t
Fig. 8.5 A realization of the geometric Brownian motion Xt D e Wt
This result can be generalized to n dimensions in a way similar to that presented at the end of Sect. 8.9. It follows that the operator n n 1 X 2 @2 1X @ xj 2 C xj ; 2 2 @xj @xj j D1 j D1
xj > 0;
has the heat kernel K.x0 ; xI t/ D
j 2 1 1 P 2t j .ln xj ln x0 / ; e x1 xn .2 t/n=2
t > 0:
Remark 8.11.1. The generator (8.11.47) is an Euler operator, which, after the change of variable y D ln x, becomes a second-order operator with constant coefficients AD D
@ 1 2 2 @2 C ˛x ˇ x 2 @x 2 @x @ 1 2 @2 C ˛ ˇ 2 =2 ˇ ; 2 2 @y @y
which is the generator of the Brownian motion with drift ˛ ˇ 2 =2 and diffusion coefficient ˇ given by d Yt D .˛ ˇ 2 =2/ dt C ˇ dW t :
174
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
8.12 Mean Reverting Ornstein–Uhlenbeck Process In this section we shall study the heat kernel associated with the generator of the stochastic differential equation dXt D .m Xt /dt C dW t ;
X0 D x0 ;
m; 2 R:
(8.12.50)
Equation (8.12.50) has been used to model stochastic interest rates in finance that exhibit mean reverting properties. Since the drift is b.x/ D m x, the associated generator is given by AD
1 2 @2 @ C .m x/ : 2 2 @x @x
(8.12.51)
We may assume > 0. The next step in the algorithm of Sect. 8.5 is to solve the aforementioned stochastic equation. We proceed by writing the relation (8.12.50) in the form dX t C Xt dt D m dt C dW t : Multiplying by e t , we obtain the exact equation: d.e t Xt / D me t dt C e t dW t : Integrating yields e t Xt D x0 C m
Z
t
e s ds C
Z
t
e s dW s ” Z t e s dW s ; Xt D e t x0 C m.1 e t / C e t 0
0
(8.12.52)
0
which is the mean reverting Ornstein–Uhlenbeck process.5 We can see from formula (8.12.52) that Xt is the sum of a deterministic function of t and a Wiener integral. Using Theorem 8.6.1, we obtain that Xt is Gaussian with mean E.Xt / D e t x0 C m.1 e t / and variance 2 2t
Var.Xt / D e
5
Z 0
t
e 2s ds D 2
1 e 2t : 2
The name mean reverting comes from the fact that in the long run the mean E.Xt / tends to m.
8.12 Mean Reverting Ornstein–Uhlenbeck Process
175
Using the notation for the Gaussian distribution, the probability density of Xt is pt .x0 ; x/ D G 2 .1e2t /=2 e t x0 C m.1 e t /; x D D
p p
1 .1 e 2t / 1 .1e 2t /
e
e
1 Œxe t x0 m.1e t /2 2 .1e 2t /
1 Œ.xx0 /C.x0 m/.1e t /2 2 .1e 2t /
; t > 0: (8.12.53)
It follows by the last step of the algorithm in Sect. 8.5 that the operator (8.12.51) has the heat kernel given by (8.12.53). It is interesting to note that when t ! 1, the heat kernel tends to p1 .x0 ; x/ D
1 .xx20 /2 ; p e
which resembles a normal distribution. This shows that the distribution of heat does not go to zero in the long range, but it tends to a steady-state distribution. Particular cases: If we let D m D 1, we obtain that the heat kernel of the operator 1 @2 @ C .1 x/ 2 @x 2 @x is given by K.x0 ; xI t/ D p
1 .1
e 2t /
e
1 1e 2t
Œ.xx0 /C.x0 1/.1e t /2
;
If we take m D 0, we obtain that the operator AD
1 2 @2 @ x ; 2 @x 2 @x
has the heat kernel given by K.x0 ; xI t/ D
p
1 .1 e 2t /
e
.xe t x0 /2 2 .1e 2t /
;
t > 0:
t > 0:
176
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
8.13 Bessel Operator and Bessel Process In this section we shall deal with the process satisfied by the Euclidean distance from the origin to a particle following a Brownian motion in Rn . More precisely, let W .t/ D .W1 .t/; : : : ; Wn .t// be a Brownian motion in Rn , n 2. Let R.t/ D dist.O; W .t// D
p W1 .t/2 C C Wn .t/2 :
The process R.t/ is not smooth at t D 0, but since W .t/ never hits the origin almost surely for n 2, we may still apply Ito’s formula and obtain n X Wj .t/ n1 dW j .t/ C dt; dR.t/ D R.t/ 2R.t/
(8.13.54)
j D1
called the n-dimensional Bessel process. In this case Wn W1 ; D ; ; R R
P
n1 ; b.R/ D 2R
T
D
Wi2 D 1: R2
Formula (8.3.19) provides the generator AD
n1 @ 1 @2 C ; 2 @ 2 2 @
> 0;
(8.13.55)
called the Bessel operator. The rest of this section deals with finding the transition density pt . 0 ; / of the Bessel process (8.13.54). The computation will be different for the cases 0 D 0 and 0 6D 0. In the case 0 D 0 we have the following result. The next computation can be found in reference [83], p. 133. Proposition 8.13.1. If 0 D 0, the transition density function of R.t/, t > 0, is given by 8 2 2 ˆ ˆ
n1 e 2t ; 0, < n=2 .2t/ .n=2/ pt .0; / D ˆ ˆ : 0;
< 0, with
n 2
D
8 n < . 2 1/Š :
. n2 1/. n2 2/ 32 12
for n even, p
; for n odd.
8.13 Bessel Operator and Bessel Process
177
Proof. Since the Brownian motions W1 .t/; : : : ; Wn .t/ are independent, their joint density function is fW1 Wn .t/ D fW1 .t/ fWn .t/ D
1 2 2 e .x1 CCxn /=.2t / ; n=2 .2 t/
t > 0:
In the next computation we shall use the following formula of integration which follows from the use of polar coordinates: Z Z f .x/ dx D .Sn1 / r n1 g.r/ dr; (8.13.56) 0
fjxjg n
where f .x/ D g.jxj/ is a function on R with spherical symmetry, and where .Sn1 / D
2 n=2 .n=2/
is the area of the .n 1/-dimensional sphere in Rn . Let 0. The distribution function of R.t/ is Z FR . / D P .R.t/ / D fW1 Wn .t/ dx1 dxn fR.t /g Z 1 2 2 D e .x1 CCxn /=.2t / dx1 dxn n=2 2 2 2 .2 t/ x1 CCxn ! Z Z 1 2 /=.2t / n1 .x12 CCxn D r e d dr n=2 0 S.0;1/ .2 t/ Z .Sn1 / n1 r 2 =.2t / D r e dr: .2 t/n=2 0 Differentiating yields d .Sn1 / n1 2 FR . / D
e 2t d .2 t/n=2 2 2
n1 e 2t ; D
> 0; t > 0: n=2 .2t/ .n=2/
pt .0; / D
In the two-dimensional case the aforementioned density becomes Wald’s distribution, (see Fig. 8.6a) ft .x/ D
1 x2 xe 2t ; t
x > 0; t > 0:
The case 0 > 0 is more complex and requires a few preliminary definitions.
178
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
a
b 10
1.5
8 1.0
6 4
0.5
2 0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
−4
−2
2
4
Fig. 8.6 .a/ Wald’s distribution; .b/ the Bessel function I0 .x/
The second-order differential equation z2
d2 dw .z2 C 2 /w D 0 Cz 2 dz dz
is called the modified Bessel equation. If D n is an integer, a fundamental system of solutions is given by the solutions In .z/ and Kn .z/. The modified Bessel function of the first kind has the expansion In .z/ D
X .z=2/2mCn I mŠ.m C n/Š m0
(8.13.57)
see reference [41], p. 9. The case D 0 serves our purposes, when the modified Bessel function of order zero of the first kind is given by I0 .z/ D
X .z=2/2m I .mŠ/2 m0
(8.13.58)
see Fig. 8.6b. Lemma 8.13.2. For any z 2 C we have Z
2 0
e z cos d D 2I0 .z/;
where I0 is the modified Bessel function of order zero of the first kind. Proof. Integrating in the Taylor expansion e z cos D
X zn cosn n0
nŠ
(8.13.59)
8.13 Bessel Operator and Bessel Process
179
yields Z
2
e z cos d D
0
X zn Z nŠ
n0
2
cosn d D
0
X z2m Z 2 .cos /2m d .2m/Š 0 m0
D4
X z2m Z =2 X z2m Z =2 .cos /2m dD4 .sin /2m d .2m/Š .2m/Š 0 0 m0 m0
D4
X z2m 1 3 5 .2m 1/ .2m/Š 2 4 .2m/ 2 m0
D 2
X z2m 1 X z2m .2m/Š D2 D2I0 .z/; .2m/Š Œ2 4 .2m/2 22m .mŠ/2
m0
m0
by virtue of (8.13.57). In the previous proof we also used the following relations, which are left as an exercise for the reader: Z
2
.cos /
2mC1
Z d D 0;
0
Z
.cos /
Z
=2
Z
=2
d D 4
.cos /2m d;
0
=2
f .sin / d;
0 =2
2m
0
f .cos / d D Z
2
0
.sin /2m d D
0
1 3 5 .2m 1/ : 2 4 .2m/ 2
Now we go back to the problem of finding the transition density pt . 0 ; /, with t; 0 ; > 0. The Brownian motion starts at the point x0 D .x10 ; : : : ; xn0 / at t D 0 and we let 0 D jx0 j. The conditional distribution function of R.t/ given R.0/ D 0 is given by FR.t /jR.0/ . j 0 / D P R.t/ jR.0/ D 0 Z D f 0 Z D D
fR.t /g
0 W1 Wn jW1 .0/Dx1 Wn .0/Dxn
2 2 g fx12 CCxn
1 .2 t/n=2
Z
.t/ dx1 dxn
Pn 1 1 e 2t j D1 n=2 .2 t/ 1
xj xj0
2
dx1 dxn
2
e 2t jxx0 j dx B.0;/
1 1 2 e 2t jx0 j D .2 t/n=2
Z
1
2
1
e 2t jxj e t hx;x0 i dx:
(8.13.60)
B.0;/
The integral over the ball B.0; / can be easily computed in the particular case n D 2. The general case is more complicated and we shall omit it. Using polar
180
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
coordinates, the area element changes as dx1 dx2 D r d d, where r D jxj. Since the inner product is invariant under orthogonal transformations, if M 2 O2 , det M D 1, and then Z
1
1
2
e 2t jxj e t hx;x0 i dx D B.0;/
Z
1
2
1
e 2t jM xj e t hM x;M x0 i dx:
(8.13.61)
B.0;/
Choosing the orthogonal matrix M such that M x0 D jx0 je1 D 0 e1 , by using polar coordinates and Fubini’s theorem, the integral (8.13.61) becomes Z
Z
2
e 0
2
r2t
e
1 t r0
cos
Z
r dr d D
re
0
2
r2t
"Z
e
0
Z
1 t r0 cos
d dr
0
D
#
2
0
r2
re 2t I0
r 0
t
r;
by Lemma 8.13.2. Substituting back in (8.13.60) with n D 2 yields the following conditional distribution function: FR.t /jR.0/ . j 0 / D
1 1 2 e 2t 0 2 t
Z 0
r2
re 2t I0
r 0
t
dr:
Differentiating with respect to yields the transition density function pt . 0 ; / D
d 1 1 2 2
0 : FR.t /jR.0/ . j 0 / D e 2t 0 e 2t I0 d 2 t t
We have obtained the following result. Proposition 8.13.3. The heat kernel of the Bessel operator AD
1 @2 1 @ C ; 2 2 @ 2 @
> 0;
(8.13.62)
is given by pt . 0 ; / D
1 .2 C2 /
0 I0 ; e 2t 0 2 t t
t > 0; > 0:
(8.13.63)
Since the heat kernel of a sum of commuting operators is the product of their kernels, we obtain the following consequence.
8.14 Brownian Motion on a Circle
181
Corollary 8.13.4. The heat kernel of the operator n 1 X @2 1X 1 @ C 2 2 xi @xi @xi2 i D1n i D1
is K.x0 ; xI t/ D
n xi xi0 x1 xn 1 .jx0 j2 Cjxj2 / Y 2t ; e I 0 .2 t/n t
xi ; xi0 ; t > 0:
i D1
8.14 Brownian Motion on a Circle Let x0 D .cos 0 ; sin 0 / 2 S 1 be a fixed point on the unit circle. If Wt is the one-dimensional Brownian motion, consider the following system of stochastic differential equations: 1 dX 1 .t/ D X1 .t/ dt X2 .t/ dW t ; 2 1 dX 2 .t/ D X2 .t/ dt C X1 .t/ dW t ; 2
(8.14.64) (8.14.65)
to Theorem 8.2.2, the aforementioned with the initial condition X0 D x0 . According system has a unique solution X.t/ D X1 .t/; X2 .t/ . If we let Xt D X1 .t/; X2 .t/ D cos.0 C Wt /; sin.0 C Wt / ;
(8.14.66)
a direct application of Ito’s formula yields 1 dX 1 .t/ D cos.0 C Wt / dt sin.0 C Wt / dW t ; 2 1 dX2 .t/ D sin.0 C Wt / dt C cos.0 C Wt / dW t ; 2 which shows that (8.14.66) is the desired solution for the system (8.14.64)– (8.14.65). The process (8.14.66) is called the Brownian motion on the circle S 1 starting at x0 . The stochastic differential equation can also be written as dX t D b.Xt / dt C .Xt / dW t ; with the drift and diffusion given by
x1 =2 ; b.x/ D x2 =2
x2 .x1 ; x2 / D : x1
182
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
Then T D
x1 x2 ; x12
x22 x1 x2
and hence the generator of the process Xt is AD
X @ 1X @2 . T /ij C bj .x/ 2 @xi @xj @xj i;j
j
D
i 1h 2 2 x2 @x1 C x12 @2x2 2x1 x2 @2x1 x2 x1 @x1 x2 @x2 2
D
1 .x1 @x2 x2 @x1 /2 : 2
In polar coordinates x1 D r cos , x2 D r sin , we have A D 12 @2 , which is the Laplace operator on S 1 . The heat kernel of A is given by the transition density of the process Xt D cos.0 C Wt /; sin.0 C Wt / : The distribution function given that the Brownian motion on the circle starts from 0 at t D 0 is F . j 0 / D P .0 C Wt C 2n < ; 8n 2 Z/ X X D P .Wt 2n C 0 / D FWt .2n C 0 /; n2Z
n2Z
and then the transition density is pt .0 ; / D
X 1 .2nC0 /2 d 2t e F .j0 / D p d 2 t n2Z
D p D p
1
X
2 t
n2Z
1 2 t
e
1
e 2t
.0 /2 2t
4n2 2 C.0 /2 C4n.0 /
X
e
2n2 2 t
D p
2 t
2n.0 / t
n2Z
0 1
e
e
.0 /2 2t
@1 C 2
X n1
e
2 2 2n t
1 2n. 0 / A cosh : t
This series can also be expressed as a theta-function, see (3.11.35).
8.15 An Example of a Heat Kernel
183
8.15 An Example of a Heat Kernel The following example follows [25]. Consider the stochastic differential equation dX t D
q
1C
Xt2
1 C Xt 2
dt C
q
1 C Xt2 dW t ;
X0 D x0 :
The drift and diffusion coefficients are given by b.x/ D p 1 C x 2 . The following estimations hold: p p j.x/ .y/j D j 1 C x 2 1 C y 2 j D p D p
p
(8.15.67)
1 C x 2 C 12 x, .x/ D
jx 2 y 2 j p 1 C x2 C 1 C y 2
jx C yj jx yj < 2jx yj; p 1 C x2 C 1 C y 2
since jx C yj jxj jyj p p p p Cp p 2 2 2 2 2 1Cx C 1Cy 1Cx C 1Cy 1 C x C 1 C y2 < p
jxj
Cp
jyj
< 1 C 1; 1 C x2 1 C x2 p p 1 jb.x/ b.y/j j 1 C x 2 1 C y 2 j C jx yj 2 5 1 < 2jx yj C jx yj D jx yj: 2 2 Hence jb.x/ b.y/j C j.x/ .y/j
9 jx yj; 2
8x; y 2 R;
and by Theorem 8.2.2 it follows that the stochastic equation (8.15.67) has a unique solution. Therefore, instead of solving the equation, it suffices to guess a solution. Let Ut D c Ct CWt , where c D sinh1 .x0 /. Then Xt D sinh.Ut /, with X0 D x0 , and by Ito’s formula we have 1 sinh Ut .d Ut /2 2 1 D cosh.Ut / .dt C dW t / C sinh.Ut / dt 2 1 D cosh.Ut / C sinh.Ut / dt C cosh.Ut / dW t 2
dX t D cosh.Ut / d Ut C
184
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
q
q 1 1 C sinh2 .Ut / C sinh.Ut / dt C 1 C sinh2 .Ut / dW t 2
q q 1 D 1 C Xt2 C Xt dt C 1 C Xt2 dW t : 2 D
Hence Xt D sinh.c C t C Wt /;
c D sinh1 .x0 /
(8.15.68)
is the solution of (8.15.67). The generator of the aforementioned process Xt is the operator p 1 d2 x d A D .1 C x 2 / 2 C 1 C x2 C : (8.15.69) 2 2 dx dx The conditional distribution function of Xt is FXjX0 .xjx0 / D P .Xt x j X0 D x0 / D P .sinh.Ut / x j U0 D sinh1 x0 / D P .c C t C Wt sinh1 x j x D sinh1 x0 / D P .Wt sinh1 x c t j c D sinh1 x0 / D P .Wt sinh1 x sinh1 x0 t/ Z sinh1 xsinh1 x0 t 1 u2 D e 2t du; p 2 t 1 so the transition density of Xt is pt .x0 ; x/ D
.sinh1 xsinh1 x0 t /2 d 1 2t ; e FXjX0 .xjx0 / D p dx 2 t
t > 0: (8.15.70)
We may further transform this formula by using
q p sinh1 x sinh1 x0 D ln x C 1 C x 2 ln x0 C 1 C x02 p x C 1 C x2 ; q D ln x0 C 1 C x02 p p x C 1 C x2 1 C x2 1 1 2 2 xC .sinh x sinh x0 t/ D ln 2t ln C t 2: q q 2 2 x0 C 1 C x0 x0 C 1 C x0
8.16 A Two-Dimensional Case Fig. 8.7 The transition density as a function of x, with x0 D 0 in the cases: t D 1, t D 0:5 and t D 0:25. For t small, the graph tends to the Dirac distribution centered at x0 D 0
185
0.25
1
0.5
Then the transition density (8.15.70) becomes p p 1 t 2 xC 1Cx 2 1 C x 2 2t ln x0 Cp1Cx2 2 0 e ; pt .x0 ; x/ D p q 2 t x0 C 1 C x 2 0
1
xC
t > 0: (8.15.71)
To conclude, the heat kernel of the operator (8.15.69) is given by (8.15.71). Its graph is given by Fig. 8.7.
8.16 A Two-Dimensional Case Let W1 .t/ and W2 .t/ be two independent Brownian motions and consider the random process Xt D .X1 .t/; X2 .t// given by X1 .t/ D W1 .t/ C W2 .t/ C x10 ; X2 .t/ D sinh W2 .t/ C c ; c D sinh1 .x20 /: The process starts at X0 D .x10 ; x20 / D x0 . The associated stochastic differential equation is dX 1 .t/ D dW 1 .t/ C dW 2 .t/; 1 dX 2 .t/ D cosh W2 .t/ C c dW 2 .t/ C X2 .t/ dt 2 p 1 D 1 C X2 .t/2 dW 2 .t/ C X2 .t/ dt: 2
186
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
In matrix form this becomes
1p 1 0 dX1 .t/ dW 1 .t/ D 1 dt C ; X .t/ dX2 .t/ dW 2 .t/ 0 1 C X2 .t/2 2 2 with the coefficients b.x/ D
0 ; 1 x 2 2
D
0
0
!
1q 1
1 C x22
;
T D @q
q 1
1 C x22
1 C x22 1 C x22
1 A:
Following relation (8.3.19), the generator of Xt is given by AD
X @ 1X @2 . T /ij C bj .x/ 2 @xi @xj @xj i;j
0
j
q
1
D
2 1 1 C x22 1@ A @ q C 2 @xi @xj 1 C x22 1 C x22
D
1 2
0 .@x1 ; @x2 / 1 x 2 2
q 2
@2 1 @2 2 @ 2 C 2 1 C x C .1 C x / C x2 @x2 : 2 2 2 2 @x1 @x2 2 @x1 @x2
In order to find the heat kernel of the operator A, we need to find the transition density of the process Xt D .X1 .t/;X2 .t//. This can be obtained from the transition density of the Brownian motion W1 .t/; W2 .t/ using formula (8.6.23) and the technique presented in Sect. 8.6, item 2. The transformation x1 D u1 C u2 C x10 ; x2 D sinh.u2 C c/;
c D sinh1 .x20 /;
has the inverse u1 D .x1 x10 / sinh1 .x2 / sinh1 .x20 / ;
(8.16.72)
u2 D sinh1 .x2 / sinh1 .x20 /;
(8.16.73)
with the Jacobian det
@.u1 ; u2 / 1 6D 0: D q @.x1 ; x2 / 1 C x22
8.16 A Two-Dimensional Case
187
The density function of Xt is @.u1 ; u2 / pt .x0 ; x/ D fX jX.0/Dx0 .xjx0 / D fW1 ;W2 u1 .x0 ; x/; u2 .x0 ; x/ det @.x1 ; x2 / @.u1 ; u2 / D fW1 u1 .x0 ; x/ fW2 u2 .x0 ; x/ det @.x1 ; x2 / 2 u2 u 1 1 1 1 2 e 2t p e 2t q D p 2 t 2 t 1 C x22 D
juj2 1 1 q e 2t ; 2 t 1 C x 2 2
with u given by (8.16.72)-(8.16.73). A computation provides juj2 D u21 C u22
D .x1 x10 /2 2.x1 x10 / sinh1 .x2 / sinh1 .x20 / 2 C2 sinh1 .x2 / sinh1 .x20 / q x2 C 1 C x22 2 D .x1 x10 /2 2.x1 x10 / ln C 2 sinh1 .x2 / sinh1 .x20 / q x20 C 1C.x20 /2
and hence
e
2 juj 2t
" D
0 q 1 # x1 x 2 t x2 C 1 C x22 1 0 2 1 1 1 0 q e 2t .x1 x1 / t sinh .x2 /sinh .x2 / : x20 C 1 C .x20 /2
We have arrived at the following result. Proposition 8.16.1. The heat kernel of the operator 1 AD 2
q 2
@2 1 @2 2 @ 2 C 2 1 C x2 C .1 C x2 / 2 C x2 @x2 2 @x1 @x2 2 @x1 @x2
is given by 0 q 1 # x1 x 2 t C 1 C x x 2 2 1 1 q pt .x0 ; x/ D q 2 t 1 C x 2 x 0 C 1 C .x 0 /2 2 2 2 2 1 0 2 1 1 1 0 e 2t .x1 x1 / t sinh .x2 /sinh .x2 / ; t > 0:
"
188
8 The Stochastic Analysis Method
8.17 Kolmogorov’s Operator One of the classical examples of heat kernels obtained by using the transition density of an associated stochastic process is the degenerate operator of Kolmogorov on R2 (see [80, 81]): 1 L D @2x1 x1 @x2 : (8.17.74) 2 Since
0 10 1 0 T ; bD D ; ; D x1 00 0 0 the operator L is the generator of the following two-dimensional Ito diffusion: dX t D b dt C dW
dW 1 .t/ 1 0 0 dt C ; D 0 0 X1 .t/ dW 2 .t/ where W1 .t/ and W2 .t/ are independent Brownian motions. If Xt D .X1 .t/; X2 .t//, then dX 1 .t/ D dW 1 .t/; dX 2 .t/ D X1 .t/ dt; with the solution X1 .t/ D x10 C W1 .t/; Z t Z t 0 X2 .t/ D x20 x1 C W1 .s/ ds D x20 x10 t W1 .s/ ds; 0
0
where X0 D .x10 ; x20 /. We shall use the expected value method presented in item 6 of Sect. 8.6. Denote W .t/ D W1 .t/: pt .x0 ; x/ D EŒı X1 .t/ x1 ı X2 .t/ x2 Z t D E ı.x1 x10 W .t//ı.x20 x2 x10 t W .s/ ds/ 0 Z Rt 1 0 i.x20 x2 x10 t 0 W .s/ ds/ d e D E ı.x1 x1 C W .t// 2 Z Rt 1 0 0 e i .x2 x2 x1 t / EŒı.x10 x1 C W .t//e i 0 W .s/ ds d: D 2 (8.17.75)
8.18 The Operator 12 x12 @2x2
189
Let v D v.x10 ; x1 ; tI / D EŒı.x10 x1 C W .t//e i
Rt 0
W .s/ ds
:
According to the Feynman–Kac formula (see Theorem 8.23.1) with the linear potential V .x/ D ax and a D i, the element v verifies the initial boundary problem @t v D
1 2
@2x1 ax1 v;
vjt D0 D ıx 0 .x/: 1
Theorem 3.15.1 yields vD p
1 2 t
e
.x1 x 0 /2 1 2t
1 2 3 0 1 2 a.x1 Cx1 /t C 24 a t
.x1 x 0 /2 i 1 t3 2 0 1 e 2t 2 .x1 Cx1 /t 24 : D p 2 t
Substituting back in (8.17.75) yields .x1 x 0 /2 1 1 1 pt .x0 ; x/ D e 2t p 2 2 t
Z
t3
e 24
2 CiŒx x 0 1 .x Cx 0 /t 2 1 2 2 1
d
r 0 /2 .x1 x1 1 24 243 Œx2 x20 12 .x1 Cx10 /t 2 1 2t e D e 4t p 2 2 t t3 p 0 2 1 / 6 Œx x 0 1 .x Cx 0 /t 2 3 .x1 x 2 1 2 2 1 2t t3 D e ; t > 0; t2
which is the heat kernel of the operator (8.17.74).
8.18 The Operator 12 x21 @x22 The operator A D 12 x12 @2x2 is the generator of the two-dimensional Ito diffusion dX 1 .t/ D 0; dX 2 .t/ D X1 .t/ dW t ;
t 0;
where Wt is a one-dimensional Brownian motion. Solving yields