This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
in the coordinates *i= 3a. Set p (P, Q) = <j>(r (P, Q)); this is positive for Py^Q and is of class C. The function F(P,Q)=« (P,Q)-^=^i (P, i&tm~m i = 0, and so f Gi{P,Z)-/{P )*1 -'Af U «/2, (S, 0, r N with degree +0 is homotopic to a branched cover iff (1) ^ ( N H w ^ A f ) ; and 2) \dj>j^ or tp^m^M^K^N) *h = ug. It is known that the (2,0)-part of the quadratic differential / is weakly conformal. A nonconstant weakly conformal harmonic map — 0; around the image of each of these points there are normal coordinates in which
) for any map d>:M^N,and tp°\p is harmonic iff (p is harmonic. In particular, the energy (2.4) and the notion of harmonicity are conformal invariants of (M,g). More generally, the composition :{M*g)->{N,h) inducing 0, minimising E amongst all maps representing 6. s (S, h). Any such map is conformal, or equivalently + holomorphic (i.e., holomorphic or anti-holomorphic) with respect to the associated complex structures on Af and N. Thus in order to find all such harmonic maps, we can represent both copies of the sphere minus one point as complex planes. Then a harmonic map can be represented by the rational functions (a , b e C) t ; and because in such a homotopy class lifts to a map ,'s to e . If p + 2, a similar construction permits us to represent the class associated to a morphism mapping exactly onec,. t o e This is illustrated in the case p = 3 in Fig. 5: A curve from one boundary of the cylinder with handles to the other represents that c , and the handles are placed symmetrically around the cylinder (which requirement imposes the restriction on p). ; fR with mean curvature H and Gauss map y, given by Kenmotsu [23]; we are indebted to Banchoff for calling our attention to that work. Indeed, if we let y also denote the map M'->IR defined as y composed with stereographic projection, where M' = A f - y ( 0 , 0 , +1), then 3 e[0,jr], the image of the rectangle covers once the hemisphere. From the identifications indicated in Fig. 8, we check that ) implies therefore that is an isomorphism. (2.4) For our application of the implicit function theorem, we consider the tension field r defined in (2.3) as a map 9 0 and J ( f t ) ^ 0 ior s < i}. As above, S is closed; and we observe that the method of Schoen-Yau applies to this deformation to show that S is open : Indeed, use the complex structure of M to decompose J dtp, | = | d' tp, | -f- | d" tp, | . Take tn^S; then the continuous dependence theorem ensures that \d' 0 on Af for all t near t„. The proof of theorem 3.1 of [26] now applies, to show that / ( f t [ H ° ) > 0; we conclude that a neighbourhood of f„ is contained in S. w ) has singularities. In particular, such a harmonic map homotopic to a diffeomorphism is uot a diffeomorphism (although it might still be a homeomorphtsm). Indeed, any such 3 to N which are homotopic to a branched covering hut are not branched coverings is established in [18]. a+1 N of minimum energy (weakly) conformal? That is true if Af is the real projective plane. 11. Problem. Let M be a closed Riemann surface, N a simply-connected Riemannian manifold, and <j>: M -* N a map of minimum energy. Is ) where t V, UQC , VcC* can be written: 2 denotes the Hermitian inner product on the fibres of that bundle, these structures being obtained by pulling back the standard Hermitian structure on T P " . Note that the condition (2.1) for x = 8 = 1 is that of weak conformality. Furthermore, a i holomorphic map is trivially isotropic and for n — 1 a smooth map is ± holomorphic if and only if it is isotropic. The identities (2.1) are a complex version of those considered by Calabi [Ca] for maps into real projective m-space (or S"). Then we have e/a G , ( C ) . I n fact / , g: M-* P" may be any holomorphic and antiholomorpnic map which satisfy (3.1) for oi-\- B^n—t. For t>l, g is not determined uniquely by these conditions (c.f. [D-Z3J). n+1 -'{L*tg) L -)) in the sense that, if D denotes the connection on this bundle induced from the connection on g>~ (L* xL ), D" y> = 0. Now as in [Wo4] by a result of J . L . Koszul [Ko] we can interpret this bundle as a holomorphic bundle over M with S operator given by F)" . Then rp is genuinely a holomorphic section of a holomorphic bundle and hence, near any zero x , has the form z 'F(x) where ^ 0 and z is a complex coordinate centred on x . f(x) is decomposable for all x # x and hence also for x = x so we may set P" as a real-analytic mapping. We may define the «-th augmented D'-associated curve of { ? ( C " ) (a = 0 , 1 , s ) , by including 0(x) in the multia ",: M -> maps. = ff! thus ± holomorphic maps I f ^-P" are included in the classification theorem. ){n A- 1) + n ( l — p)J. I n particular, for « = oo, all such maps N is harmonic if and only if, on each chart U t is harmonic since, as a map into G (C )xG (C~ '), its components are ± holomorphic, and by Lemma 3.9, it is horizontal with respect to n. Hence by Lemma 3.5, $ is harmonic. +,
• • ,x )
a
in U.
If we write similarly
then
(9) {
letting V i denote covariant differentiation on M relative x . The Dirichlet integral of * £ A"{M, W) is 2ZJ(d>) —
A»(M,W)
=H"{M,W)
© [dA^(M,W)
1
+
&A'» (M,W)~\
I
P
where H (M, W), the space of harmonic p-forms with values in W, is orthogonal to the other two summands. 5. The curvature of the connection can be expressed in U by an m X W matrix of 2-forms ® = ( ® ) where ® = dd + 0 A^ I f V denotes the covariant differential of M, then we define the covariant differential V on 4>eA*(M,W) by u
u
u
u
U
u
a f t
Letting i i / denote Ri"I, the diagonal m X m matrix each of whose diagonal terms is the Eicci tensor field Ri" (we follow the sign convensions in Eisenhart in defining By—-jBPyi)., we have for any q> £ A (M, W) the following expression for the components of the Laplacean of
where ( denotes the transposition of matrices. 1
I f tb^^ A (M,W), define the function Z7 we have (usual Laplacean A of functions)
*##f)
on M ; then in
14 122
J A M E S E E L L S , JR. AND J . H . SAMPSON. u
where a denotes the Riemannian structure of W in V. For each
W)
define the function m)= a® ) -m('P u m*.
(id
,
u
i
h
a
v
The matrix (of functions) of Q is
We consider this as an nm X rim matrix in the subscripts (ah), (0i); as such, it is symmetric: QaB — Qfx* The integral over M of &(d>-di/2) is always zero, by Green's theorem. Thus if
(12)
ih
f (*)»1-
f
( V ^ ^ r f ^ V ^ ' t ^ J M ^ O .
( B ) Given any / £ 9* (M, M'), let /"'ff (M') - » M be the induced vector bundle; it is clearly Riemannian-connected. Let us interpret the preceding development for that bundle. l
First of all, the elements of A°(M,f- 3(M')) are canontcally identified with the vector fields along f (i.e., with the elements of the space 91(f), in the notation of § 2 A ) . Secondly, for any PtM the differential f * ( P ) : M(P)—>M'(f(P)) is a linear map, to be considered as an element of M'(f(P))®MW(P); otherwise said, the assignment P^>f*(P) determines a specific 1-form / * £ A (M,f- -3 (W)). Thirdly, we have 1
,
J M
LEMMA. For any /£ Sf(Sl,M') tolA*(M,f-^3(M')). Thus if* Proof.
we have Sf* = 0; i.e., f„ is orthogonal dUf*.
Take a coordinate chart U on M, and write
(13)
SyW^T'viPffdxK u
Then {U )* — fffc>, (
^
D
)
whence 7
" w
(l
A
m
+ v w * *
a
m
which is zero, because both coefficients are symmetric in t, j . r
Similarly, the variation gf £ A°(M, f'^3 (M )) tation +
&f*h
u
s^V.Vi/HrVfW)
has coordinate represen4 m
15 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OP R I E M A N N I A N MANIFOLDS.
123
PROPOSITION. For any f € St (M, M') its differential f#is a closed 1-form. Its tension field r(f) = — 8/*, the divergence of its differential. The map f is harmonic if and only if its differential is a harmonic 1-form. Definition. For any map f S Si (M, M') its fundamental form f3(f) is the covariant differential V / * of its differential. Thus fi(f) is the f- 3(M')vatued 2-covariant tensor field on 31 whose coordinate representation is 1
m -
B
Sij-'+^fi% -f
^-
The tension field r(f) is just the trace of fi(f); i.e., &(f\—g*§n^ ( l ^ T ^ m ) . I t follows from § 2D that if f is a Riemannian immersion, then 0(f) is the second fundamental form of M in 31'. Analogously, let us say that a map / € 9i(M,M') is totally geodesic if 0(f) —0 on M; we will see as a consequence of Corollary 5A below that totally geodesic maps map geodesies into geodesies. u
(C) Let us consider the function Q(f*); from the expression (® 0 )i* = g R'aBi$fk"fi we compute (11), taking into account the skew symmetry ® ®ea to obtain the a
Rk
u
S
u
oB
LEMMA. (14) Its
For any smooth map f: M-*M' we have Q(U)
W
W
W
1
'
1
matrix (for arbitrary forms d>£ A (M,f- 3(M')))
(15)
-
W
*
is
7
Q «
PW* ftW'—
aB
If f is harmonic, then (16)
*e(f) = \J3(f)\* + Q(f*)-
We will refer to the matrix (15) as the Ricci transformation on the tensor product bundle f~*3 (M') ® 3 (M). Observe that if / is a real-valued function on M, then that Ricci transformation is just that given by the Ricci tensor of M. [l]
Remark. The above computations can of course be made without passing through the medium of vector-bundle-valued differential forms. One starts by applying the Ricci identities (Eisenhart [8, p. 30]) to the direct evaluation of &e(f), and then reads off the appropriate terms. The next result follows the well known pattern of Bochner; in [2] Bochner has also applied the method in a special case for maps. THEOREM.
If f: M->M' is a harmonic map, then
16 124
J A M E S B E L L S , J R . AND J . H . SAMPSOV.
r
«(/*)*!
m
J M
and equality holds when and only when f is totally geodesic. Furthermore, *f Q{f*)=® 3fj then f is totally geodesic and has constant energy density e(f). o
Proof.
n
This follows at once from Stokes' Theorem f
Ae(f)*l = 0,
applied to (16); for if Ae(f) £ £ 9 , then A e ( f ) = 0 everywhere, whence e{f) is a constant function. Following the conventions of Eisenhart [8], we say that the Ricci curvature of M is non-negative if at every point P £ M the matrix (—R (P) ) is positive semi-definite. tf
COROLLARY. Suppose that the Ricci curvature of M is non-negative and that the Riemannian curvature of M' is non~positive. Then a map f: M—*M' is harmonic if and only if it is totally geodesic. Furthermore, 1) if there is at least one point of M at which its Ricci curvature is positive, then every harmonic map f: M—*M' is constant; 2) if the Riemannian curvature of M' is everywhere negative, then every harmonic map f:M-*M' is either constant or maps M onto a closed geodesic of M'. Proof.
The theorem shows that
If hypothesis 1) is satisfied at ? £ M, then / * { P ) = 0 , whence the constant ( / ) = 0 ; i- v / is a constant map. If hypothesis 2) is satisfied at P = f(P)£M' and we take normal coordinates centered at P, then the f*(P)-image of the tangent space M(P) has dimension £ 1 . If it has dimension 0 at any f(P), then again e(f) — 0; otherwise, the image f (P)M(P) has constant dimension 1. Because f is totally geodesic, the conclusion follows. e
e
r
tl
Example. If f: M—*M' is a harmonic immersion, then e ( / ) = n / 2 , and | j3{f)\ -\- Q(f#) = 0. This relation also follows from Gauss's equations (Eisenhart [8, p. 162]) 2
17 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OP RIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS. 11
by multiplying by g^g
and summing.
135
We obtain n-ni ir=I
il
where fi = g h \i is the w-th the immersion (see ( 7 ) ) ; each Riemannian curvature of M' R — R gy of M is negative immersion of M in M'. a
a
j
iS
component of the mean normal curvature of p.„ — 0 if / is harmonic. FOT instance, if the is non-positive and if the scalar curvature at some point, then there is no harmonic
4. Examples. 1
(A) The case dim M = 1. Let us take for M the unit cirele S , coordin a t e d by the central angle 6. For any f£(S\M') we have 2 *1.
The tension field is t ( / )
+
W -"*
dt
df'
which (when the parameter of f is proportional to arc length) is often called the curvature (or acceleration) of f.
We have
1
(B) The case dim M = 2. We established here certain relations showing the close connection of our problem with the Plateau problem, in its potential theoretic formulation (Morrey [ 1 9 ] and Bochner [ 3 ] } ; incidentally, we see that in our energy theory the cases dim M £j 2 are favored. Recall that a map h: M->M' is conformat if there is a smooth function 6: M^»R such that h*g' = exrj(2e)g. Thus the differential h% preserves orthogonality and dilatates uniformly. Clearly such a map is a smooth immersion, and has energy density e(h) =
7iexp(20)/S.
18 126
J A M E S EET.T.S, J B . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
PHOPOBITION. If dimM = w = 2 and h: M-*M is a conformal difeomorphism, then for all f€3t(M,M') we have E(foh) = E(f). Moreover, h is harmonic. a
tl
a
3
Proof. First of all, (/ ° k), = f «hf, whence 3e(f °h) = g hfhfif f g' . The conformaltity condition foT h implies g'thfhj" = exp(%0)gM, and substituting gives f
3e
(f
f
o h) - ex (Z$)g^Wf/g' V
II
aB
- 3 exp(20) e(/).
aB
Secondly, we have -
[det(j Vty)/det( ,,)]»*l F t
f f
— esp(n#)*l, so that if 7i = 3 we have h*(e{f)*l)
= e(f"°ft)*l.
Finally, in suitable local coordinates on M we have iy = i v and
direct computation shows that T
V(f)
+V*,—y*»y
(ft)* = (2 — n)<7% .
(l^i^n).
PROPOSITION, dimilf— 2, then for any f€Si(M,M') we have ^E(f). Equality holds when and only when f is conformal.
Proof. The first statement follows immediately from the inequalities (2). Suppose f is conformal; then for fi = 2 we obtain y(f)-
f
exp(2t?}[ „^?
ConverBelyj if V(f) —E{f)
2 5 l 2
]S(2^=
(
e{f)*l =
E(f).
we conclude that at every point of M 1
tJ
2[det(/V)y] = ? (/*?')«[det(^)]l. In isothermal coordinates on M we have LW)n-(f*g'UY
{ ( r Y ^ n
whence (f*g')u— tf*9')*2 — 0 = ( / * / ) » • exp(2fl) -
Defining 6:M-*R
by
[det(/*/) /d t(^)]i, y
e
we obtain exp(2fi)jy = (f*g')nCOEOLLABY. f minimizes E. 0
If a map f„: M—>M' minimizes V and is conformal, then
19 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF RIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS.
127
For any f£ Si (M, M') we have E(f )=V(f )^V(f)^E(f). 0
0
Remark, I f M is a Riemann surface, then its complex structure defines a conformal equivalence class of Riemann structures. The energy of any map /: M—*M' therefore depends only on the complex structure of M. (C) Harmonic fibre maps. For any map f £ Si{M, W) and P€ M we have the vector space Mp(P) = ( u £ M(P): / ( P ) j t = 0}; the vectors in Mv(P) are called vertical. Let J V H ( P ) denote its orthogonal complement in M(P). Suppose that for all P e M the differential f*(P) maps M (P) isometrically onto M'(f(P)). Then / is a locaUy trivial surjective fibre map (see Hermann [13]) ; in particular, / determines an almost product structure on M (i. e., the structural group 0„ of 3 (M) admits a reduction to the product group O X On-m). We will call a map / : M^>M' a Riemannian fibration. +
H
m
Remark. There are smooth titrations / : M—*M? having no Lie structural group; e. g., there are non-trivial compact smooth fibrations over the 3-sphere S" (which cannot have a Lie structural group G, since ir ((?) = 0 ) . I t is a consequence of a theorem of Hermann [13] that the manifolds M, M' admit no Riemann structures compatible with f as above, for which the fibres are totally geodesic. 2
L E M M A . If f: M-*M' is a Riemannian fibration, then for any P e l f there are coordinate charts U and V centered at P and f(P) respectively, in terms of which fi (P) = &V" (1 = i = , 1 = = fft). Furthermore, the first m coordinates in U can be considered as normal coordinates in V, and the last n —m coordinates are local coordinates for the fibres. a
n
a
Proof. Let ( e ) i s „ be an orthonormal base for M(P) such that the first m vectors span MH(P), and the last n — m vectors span My(P). Then f#(P)ei = e\ (lt=i = m) form an orthonorrnal base for M'(f(P)), and we can construct the associated normal coordinates in some neighborhood V. According to Hermann [13] the unique horizontal lift to P of any geodesic of M' starting at f(P) is a geodesic of M; one determined by / lifts to one determined by e . We now use the local product structure to define a coordinate chart V in which the fibres have the desired property. Note that (unless the fibres are totally geodesic) we cannot generally require that the coordinates in U be normal. 1
5
(
(
PROPOSITION.
Let f: M->M'
be a Riemannian fibration. Then e{f)
20 128
J A M E S E E L L S , J B . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
= n/2. If for any P€M we let F denote the fibre through P and i : the inclusion map, then r(f)(Q) U(Q)r(i )(Q) for all QtF . P
P
P
Fp-*M
P
In particular, f is harmonic if and only if all fibres are minimal submanifolds. Proof. In § 2D we have seen that the tension field of any Riemannian immersion is perpendicular to the submanifold. Thus for every Q£ F we have r(i ) (Q) e M (Q). I f we use a split coordinate system as in the previous lemma, we see that m UT(i )(P)t=-2h->Hir) [P)*=i P
P
U
k
P
The proposition foUows by direct calculation. Examples. All covering maps are harmonic; in particular, the identity map is harmonic, which amounts to saying that Cartan's vitesse is a harmonic 1-form. If 3 (M)^*M is the bundle of orthonormal r-frames of M, then it is known (Liehnerowiez [15]) that with its natural Riemannian structure on 3 (M) the fibres are minimal, whence that fibre map is harmonic. Vector bundle maps are harmonic. Every homogeneous Riemannian fibration is harmonic, for the fibres are always totally geodesic, and therefore minimal. r
T
1
(D) Maps into flat manifolds. Let us take for M' the unit circle S ; we will construct harmonic representatives in every homotopy class of maps M—>S . First of all, it is well known that the set [M, S ] of these homotopy classes forms an abelian group canonically isomorphic to the first integral cohomology group 2f*(jflfJ. Secondly, every such cohomology class is canonically represented by a harmonic 1-form on M. l
1
Suppose M is connected, and fix a point P e M. Given any such harmonic 1-form to on M and any smooth path y from P to a point P e M, we define the number B
P
0
tm -1* A different choice y of yp may give a different number f(P), but P
Ki>)-/(P)=
f
«
is an integer since the periods of a are integral; consequently, oi determines a well defined map f : it-*. S by letting f (P) be the residue class modulo 1 of f(P). 1
a
a
21 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF R I E M A N N LAN MANIFOLDS.
129
Now since f is harmonic, every P e M has a neighborhood U in which df = m; thus A/ = Sdf 4- dSf = Sm = 0 in f7. I t is easy to see that n—^f establishes an isomorphism [M,S ]=H (M). a
a
1
1
To define harmonic representatives of the homotopy classes of maps M—> T , the flat m-torus, we merely take m-fold products of harmonic maps M—*S*. using § 5 C below; the existence of these harmonic representatives was first proved by F . B. Fuller [10]. More generally, any compact flat manifold M' is covered by T , by a theorem of Bieberbach, and any homotopy class of maps M—>M' which can be lifted to maps M—>T has harmonic representatives obtained by composition with the projection T —>M'. m
m
m
m
I f M and M' are both flat, then the only harmonic maps M-*M' are those which are locally linear, as can be seen from the maximum principle. ( E ) Maps of Euclidean spheres. Let S"(r) denote the Euclidean nsphere of radius r; write S" = S" (1). Then the homotopy classes of maps of S" into itself are classified by their degrees. We consider now the problem of constructing explicitly harmonic maps of a given degree fc; it is a simple matter to modify the following remarks to include the case of maps yS"(r)->S"(r'). 1
1
n
If (x ,- • •.a;"* ) are Euclidean coordinates and JJ: S (r) —>$"(/) is a map given by (jrfaV " " . E " * ) = ( z V / j y - - , i t f ^ V / r ) , then 1
6
{
y
i
=
)
n
/
{ry.
W
We will henceforth refer points of S" to coordinates (#,<£), where 6 denotes colatitude ( O ^ 0 S = T T ) , and tj> a point on the equator r?" of S*. Furthermore, corresponding to the integer Tc let * : S"' (r) —* fl* *^!*) be the (n — 3)fold suspension of the map ^ ( r ) —»S (r ) defined by
1
1
(17)
*W =
{
f
c
Z
+
3
1
/
W
~
3
>
(
/
A
>
i
-
n
We are interested in maps f: S»-*8 ol the form (9,^) - » ( © , # ) , where © is a function of 0 alone, and * is defined for r = j = 1. From ( 1 7 ) we see that on ^ ( s m f l ) we have 2e(f) = (fc + n — 3 ) s i n ® / s i n 0 , whence /
2
(18)
9
s
I
22 130
JAMES E E L L S , J R . AND J . EC. SAMPSON.
I n case n = 1 the existence and properties of harmonic maps of degree k is elementary. We now consider the case n = 3. We have gn = l, <7i2 = 0 = 3 i, g = sin 0. The tension field of any map f is given by its components a
2
2Z
(Jf)"],
=Ae-sin cos«[^(g) + Z
T W
0
, „
;
r
0* d® ,
1
a* 0®-]
For the special maps under consideration we find that for a harmonic map f r ( * ) = A* — d^/d
1
d
(
•
d a
®\
>! sinOcos®
the only solution of T ( @ ) = 0 regular at the poles is =k
(19)
® — 3arctan [c(t&n8/%) '] with c > 0.
Then = ± ksin®/sin#, from which we can = 4TT I k | ; note that it is independent of c. Finally, for the degree of a map shows that degree f = ± & . k = 0 and all c > 0 the map is constant; for k — ± 1 the identity and the antipodal map, respectively.
conclude that E(f) the integral formula We observe that for and c = 1 the map is
Remark. Although the above construction does exhibit a harmonic map in every homotopy class, it does not begin to exhaust their topological interest. For instance, with the uniform topology on $t(S ,S ), the component 9t ,(S ,8 ) of those maps of degree 0 has infinite cyclic homology: 2
1
2
s
<
H ^ S l ^ , * ) ) — S
2
) )
=
W 3
(S^)=Z,
generated by the Hopf map. A harmonic representative of that generator should have positive Morse index. Consider now the case n 3 3. We do not know how to construct harmonic maps of degree 3. Incidentally, the suspensions of the above maps (and their "compressed" suspensions below) are generally not harmonic. We propose now to show that the functional E: 91 (S , S") - » R does not have an absolute minimum on the component 9l (S"' 8") for k^O and « > 3; that this phenonmenon could be illustrated explicitly and simply by maps of spheres was suggested to us by C. B. Morrey. : : >
x
k
!
Let &(»><#)!•— ( » 4 * ) , « ) be the map of S»-*S*
defined using (19)
23 HAEMONIC MAPPINGS OP BIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS,
131
with exponent fc ^ 0. Thus for small c > 0 the map /„ compresses most of S" into a small cell centered at the pole, and that compression takes place along longitudes. The energy integral (18) now takes the form
2
Jo
V, amff
/
For » £ 3 w e have
The following lemma shows that 3 i m £ ( f ) = 0 ; i.e., for n S 3 there are c
maps in Sl (8",8 ) map f £ 9t (8 ,S ) has degree 0. n
k
n
n
k
LEMMA. J
of arhitrarily small energy. But for fe^O there is no with zero energy, for such an f is constant, and therefore
2
Bm ® (6)d6^> e
0 as e - » 0.
Proof. For any < > 0 let a = —1/2. There is a number K such that 0 ^ (tan 0/2) g-BTfor all 0 ^ 0 £ p. I t follows that 0 , ( 0 ) ^ 2 arctan(eff), whence there is a number c > 0 for which 0 s i n 0 ( 0 ) < t/2p if 0 < e :£ c . Thus 2
r
c
*/p
5, (A)
«/o
f
-*
p
The composition of maps.
The following computation is elementary.
L E M M A . If / : M—*M' and f: M'-*M" their fundamental forms satisfy (20)
( f » /)
- ^ f V +
are any smooth maps, then
f ^fm ;
COBOLLABY. TAe composition of totally geodesic maps is totally geodesic. The inverse of a totally geodesic diffeomorphism is totally geodesic. COHOLLABY.
(21)
r(fof)^ (f)^ T
+
fifrfffif
If f is harmonic and f totally geodesic, then f of is harmonic. I n general, however, we do not expect the composition of harmonic maps to be harmonic, as the following example shows:
24
133
JAMES E E L L S , JR- AND J . H . SAMPSON. 2
Example. Let T be the flat 3-torus parametrized by the angles (6, <j>) with 0 g 0, ,, < 2sr. Let f':T ^> S be defined by 2
3
f(6,4>) — {cosfl, s i n 0 , c o s ^ , s i n ^ ) / V 2
;
2
considered as a point in fi*. Then / ' defines a Riemannian imbedding of T in S , which is a minimal hut not a totally geodesic imbedding. To see that f is harmonic we show that T ( / ' ) is perpendicular to S ( / ' ( P ) ) in R*, and then appeal to Proposition 5 B below. Namely, because T is flat we have 3
3
2
W
=
W
+
£
—
1
f
*
l
=
a
4
=
)
3
whence r(f)(P) is directed along the radius of S at f(P). On the other hand, T is not totally geodesic in 8 , for the map / : S -*T defined by /(6) = (0,0) is a geodesic of T ; it does not lie in any 2-plane through 0 in R*, and is therefore not a geodesic of 3 . I n particular, / : S —>T and f: T —*S are both harmonic maps, and their composition f'°f is not. 2
3
l
2
2
s
2
l
2
3
(B) PROPOSITION. / / f: M'-*M" is a Riemannian immersion, then for any map f: M-*M' we have E(f) =E(f°f). The tension field r(f) is the projection on M' of the tension field -r(f°f). Proof.
The first statement follows from the equation o
«(f /)-t
is
This generalizes the classical fact that a curve in M' is a geodesic if and only if its curvature vector in M" is always perpendicular to M'. ( C ) PROPOSITION. Let f:M'->M" be a Riemannian reducible fibration with totally geodesic fibres. Then for any map f: M—*M' we have Hf°n=r*(Hf))This is immediate, because we can in the present situation take split normal coordinates in Lemma 4 C .
25 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF RIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS.
133
COROLLAEY. If M = M" and f: M-*M' is a section, then f ° / = l is harmonic, and therefore T ( / ) is always vertical. Example. If we view a smooth r-form u> on M' as a section of the bundle 3 (M') of r-covectors of M', then the condition that ui be harmonic in the sense of de Rham-Hodge is generally different from the condition T(W) = 0 , rising (say) the Riemannian structure on S (M') of Sasaki [ 2 5 ] . However, these two concepts do coincide if M' is flat. lrl
[r]
Example. A map / : M M' X M" into a Riemannian product has a canonical decomposition f(P) = ( f (P), f (P)) for all PeM. Then / is harmonic if and only if both components /', f are harmonic. For instance, seee Proposition 2B. (D) Let us suppose that M' is a Riemannian submanifold of M" and that the imbedding is proper; i. e„ such that the inverse image of any compact subset of M" is compact in M'. Since M' is complete, there is a positive smooth function p : M' —> R such that for any P' £ M' the set {P"el£":
J
r {P\p")
gp(P')}
is geodesically convex in M"; if M' is compact, then of course we can suppose that p is a positive constant. For each P' £ M' let D - denote the closed ball of dimension q — m (q = dim M") consisting of all geodesic segments of length ^p(P') emanating from P' and perpendicular to M'(P'). The following result is well known and elementary. P
r
L E M M A . Let iV = U {Dp-: f € M ); then N is a neighborhood of M' in M", and the obvious map w: N —* M' defines a smooth fibre bundle over M' whose structure group is 0 . and whose fibres are closed balls. Q m
Taking into account Proposition 5 C we have the PROPOSITION. Let f: M'—*M" be a proper Riemannian imbedding and tr: N—>M' a normal tubular neighborhood. Then for any map f:M—*N the composition •wof is harmonic if and only if r(f) is vertical.
Chapter I I . Deformations of Maps. 6.
Deformations by the heat equation.
(A) This chapter is devoted to the fundamental problem of deforming a given map into a harmonic map; i.e., into a smooth map f:M-*M' satisfying the nonlinear elliptic equation
26 134
J A M E S E E L L S , J R . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
(1)
T(/)-0.
We begin by discussing general methods of attack. The interpretation given in § 2A of the tension field T ( / ) as the contravariant representative of the differential of E at / suggests that we try to invent gradient lines of E in a suitable function space of maps from M to if', and then to prove that these trajectories lead to critical points of E. We propose the following method for realizing such an attempt, which we now outline briefly. We do not pursue this method in the present paper, although the qualitative results are essentially those of the following sections. r
Let 9l {M,M') denote the function space of all maps from M to M' whose partial derivatives (relative to fixed coordinate coverings) of orders ^ T are square integrable. An inequality of Sobolev insures that if 2r > dim M then the maps in $l (M,M') are continuous, and its topology is larger than the uniform topology. It can be shown that the space 3l (M, M') admits an infinite dimensional Riemannian manifold structure modeled on a separable Hilbert space, and that E: 9t (M,M')-»R is a differentiable function. I f r is its gradient field on 9t {M,M'); i.e., V«E(f) < T (/)>»> for aU vectors v in the tangent space at /, then the ordinary differential equation r
r
r
f
T
t
has a local solution which is unique; furthermore, E(f ) is a decreasing function of t. Under suitable curvature restrictions the solutions are globally defined. I f each trajectory / is relatively compact, then it haB a limit point a harmonic map. Thus these trajectories define a canonical homotopy of the initial map onto a harmonic map; moreover, such trajectories enjoy the 1parameter group property. We observe that the critical points of E are just the zeros of all r (for any T > dim M / 2 ) . t
(
r
a
Now the function space 9i {M,M') is not a manifold, although with every map / we have the Hilbert space 9t°{f) of vector fields along / defined i n § 2 A . In particular, ° ( / ) — r ( / ) is in # " ( / ) . I n analogy with the above outline we are led to consider the nonlinear parabolic equation T
(2)
If—**/*}
((o<(
The study of this equation is our primary object in the foUowing sections. We will find that the properties of the trajectories of (2) include most of those mentioned as belonging to the trajectories of t* (2r > dimM). (There is one basic difference: The solutions of (2) are generally defined only for
HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF RIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS.
135
r
non-negative time, whereas the trajectories of r are always defined for an open time interval around i = 0.) Remark. I n the calculus of variations a standard method (Morrey [ 1 9 ] ) of establishing the existence of a minimum of E for a given class of maps is to take the space M (M,M') and to introduce on it a weak topology relative to which 1 ) E is lower semi-continuous, and 2) there are sufficiently many compact sets. That approach works well for dim i f = 1 or 2; however, the example given in § 4 E shows that it will not work in general for n S 3. 1
(B) PROPOSITION. If ( i , P ) - » f , ( P ) is a map of (t ,t,)XM^M' which is C on the product manifold and C on M for each t, and if that map satisfies (2), then it is C. 0
1
!
We will refer to such an f as a solution of (2). t
This follows from Friedman [ 9 , Th. 4 and 5 ] provided the second derivatives fy of the f are Holder-continuous. But we can represent the local functions f by Green's formula, using the fundamental solution of the heat equation Au— du/dt = 0 as in § § 9 - 1 0 below. The required Holdercontinuity is then established by standard techniques from the properties of the potentials involved (Pogorzelski [24], Dressel [7], Gevrey [ 1 1 , No. 8 ] ) . 0
(C) Let ft: M^>M' satisfy (2) ; the subscript ( refers to the deformation parameter (we will always indicate explicitly differentiation with respect to t). Then from (4) of § 2 B we have
dt
J"
^ '' dt ^ !
M
SM I
dt
*1.
If D/dt denotes covariant differentiation along paths in M', then for each P € M the curvature veetor of the path i - » f ( P ) is given by D{df /dt)/dt. (
t
PROPOSITION. If ft- M-*M' satisfies (2), then the energy E(f ) is a strictly decreasing function; i.e., dE{f )/dt < 0 except for those values of t for which r(fi) = 0 . Furthermore, its second derivative expresses the average angle between the tension field and the curvature vectors of the deformation paths: t
t
LEMMA. If we let
Let f :M^W t
be an arbitrary deformation for
(£((„,ti).
28
136
J A M E S E E L L S , J R . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
then 1
dt
JM
9
^ftr'Vfl*/
2
P V « /
7
2
This follows from a direct calculation of d e{f )/St and an application of Green's divergence theorem. Because the first integral of the right member is always non-negative, we have on appeal to the above proposition the t
THEOREM.
If / , : M—*W satisfies the heat equation ( 2 ) , then
9
JM
2
dt
^dx* \dt/'
dx> V a * /
O) iff
Hi
2
2
In particular, if M' has non-positive sectional curvature, then d E{f,)/dt 3 0. If t is a value for which equality holds, then r{f,) is a covariant constant; i. e., dx* \
(2)
dt
J
:0 for all P£ M and ( l g i g n ) ,
COROLLARY. / / M' has non-positive sectional curvature and if f, satisfies for all i S i „ , then
at (D) We have seen in § 5 that in supposing M' contained in a larger manifold M" we do not alter the energy of a map / : M -> W. That suggests that we still have control of the energy and the tension of deformations of / which take place in a normal tubular neighborhood N of M' in M". If f: M'—*M" denotes the imbedding, then the induced tangent vector bundle is f- 3 (If) — 3 ( J f ) © *ft (M", W), where the second summand is the normal bundle of M' in M". Then 'ft. —» M' is Riemannian-conneeted in the sense of § 3 A . There ia a canonical vector field : N-^-'U covering the projection map ir: N-*M' defined by assigning to each Q" 6 N the unique vector (Q")eM"(v(Q")) such that exp, (p(Q")) =Q". Suppose now that ft'. M-±N is a smooth deformation ( i ^ i < f i ) . Then p ° / is a vector field on the map *•">/,, and using the harmonic integral l
P
P
tQn
0
t
29 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OP R I E M A N N I A N MANIFOLDS.
137
theory of § 3 applied to the vector bundle 9l —> M', we can define its Laplacean HP°U)-
Let
where D/dt is the covariant derivative in N along the path i r ° / . (
We now establish the following stability property of deformations. T H E O R E M . Let N be a normal tubular neighborhood of M' in M", and suppose that f : M^*N is a smooth deformation ( ( ^ ( < i ) . / / L{p°f ) is always horizontal in ff~ (M") and if /,„: M-*M', then f : M—>M' for all t ^ t < i, t
0
l
t
(
a
t
Proof.
lC
We apply Green's theorem to u, v € A"(M, {v°ft)~ fl)
•
J
*l= — I
The hypotheses imply that >°f L(p<> f,)y = 0 for all t, so that t!
o=
f
< °/,,A( °f )>*i— P
P
(
(
&*h^fc*fj$m..
Therefore * 4 f
f< °ftMp°f )>*i
P
— I.e.,
I
r
t
\d(p °f*)\**i
go.
z
| p o / ( i * l is a non-negative, non-increasing function of t, and it
is zero for t = t„. We conclude that p ° ft = 0 for all t g t < t precisely that every f maps M into M'. 0
lf
which states
t
7.
Global equations.
(A) We now occupy ourselves with the problem of replacing equations (1) and (2), which in terms of local coordinates on M and M' are local systems of equations, by some much more tractable global systems. Remark. Assume for the moment that we have an isometric imbedding w: M'-*Ri for some q, which we can always do by a theorem of Nash [21], Then as in Proposition 5B we find that equation (2) is satisfied for a deformation /(: M —> M' when and only when the composition W = w o f, satisfies the t
condition that the vectors LW, = A V T — a r e perpendicular to M'; see (
30 138
JAMES E E L L S , J H . AND J . H . SAMPSON. q
Lemma 7B below. When expressed in terms of tbe coordinates of R , that condition gives rise to a global parabolic system of equations of tbe type (2). On the other hand, the assumption of an isometric imbedding apparently affords no real simplification in our theory, and we will not make it. We proceed with an elementary imbedding convenient for our purposes. Suppose that M' is smoothly and properly imbedded in some Euclidean space Ri by a map w: M'^*R". LEMMA. Given such an imbedding of M' in K«, it is always possible to construct a smooth Riemannian metric g" = (g"a*)i£a,i£q on a tubular neighborhood N of M' so that N is Riemannian fibred. Proof. Let N be any tubular neighborhood of M' constructed using the Euclidean structure of R"; let IT: N—>M' be the projection map. It suffices to construct an appropriate smooth inner product in each space R (P') for all P' £ M', for we can translate that tangent space to any point Q'€ N along the straight line segment (necessarily contained in N) from P' = ir(Q') to Q'. We take g' in M'(P') and the induced Euclidean metric in the (Euclidean) orthogonal complement of M'(P') in K ( P ' ) , and take their sum in R « ( P ) . q
9
y
x
m
I n terms of local coordinates (y , • • • ,y ) on M' that metric can be described as follows: Write w(P') =• (w (P'),- • - ,vfl(P')); then l
c dw° Qw^
2k dy° ay
s
is the metric on M' induced from the Euclidean metric. Let i" be the unique solution of Z« dy
a
dy
B
3
~
V '
a
dw
fl
We have the duality relation -^^( " = Sa , and the metric tensor is 0
Then so that g" does induce g' on M'. For any vector veR"(P') %v"-— = 0 ( l ^ a S m ) we have ^,v't ^ 0 also, so that a-i oy a=i dw a
a
b
satisfying
31
HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF RIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS.
139
Tims g" has the desired properties. (B) L E M M A . Let /,: M—*M' be any smooth deformation, and let W,: M-*N be the composition w°f = W . Then T ( / J ) =3/,/0f if and only if r(W )—dW /dt is perpendicular to M'(f (P)) for all P£M. t
t
t
t
t
Proof. The argument is essentially that of Proposition 5 B ; we choose local coordinates on M' and obtain ^ M / . ) * - f ) = ^ < w , ) ' - ^ f
I n terms of the coordinates of Ri the differential of the projection map IT: N—* M' has components *«?OK fdw . Its covariant differential in terms of the metric g" is a
=
^ The map : N-*R«
aSfc ~
r
"
a
o
A
/
(
1
=*
&
c
' =
9
)
•
defined {as in § 6 D ) by p(Q') =Q' — v(Q') assigns to
P
each Q' £ iV a vector perpendicular to M ' ( T T ( C ) ) , and pa" + o " = l r
V>
D
Pas'" + ™a& + r"o6" = 9. For its restriction to M' we obtain
where w ° = dvf/dy". For each a, the right member defines a vector perpendicular to M'; because the w " span the tangent space to M' in which they lie, we obtain the a
a
L E M M A . For any vectors u,v£M'(Q') ire p^Wv" is perpendicular to M'(Q'). LEMMA.
the vector whose components
For any map W,: M^*N with image in M' let £ be the vector
with components e^LWS—Tr^WtfW.W, where L = \ — 9/3f is the heat operator on M. Proof.
As in Proposition 5 B we have L{p{w )y^p/L(w y+^^w^w ^ t
t
l}
Then £ is tangent to M'.
32 140
JAMES B E L L S , J B . AND J . BT. SAMPSON.
(5)
But p(Wf) =0, whence the left member vanishes. the right member is a normal vector, we have
Since the second term in
It follows that
for l^d^g.
Thus J has normal component 0.
PROPOSITION. A map f: M-*M' position W = w°f satisfies
satisfies (1) if and only if the comi
(1)
AW°=* °w >w Y' ab
t
i
in terms of local coordinates on M. A deformation f : M~*M' W, — w°fi satisfies
(t < t < (,) satisfies (2) if and only if
t
a
1
(2)
LiW^^^'WtfWtjY
( i < t < (,). 0
Proo/. It suffices to establish tbe equivalence of (2) and (2). that we take any deformation f and compute
For
t
by the second perpendicular Conversely, if our equation must be 0.
(L(W y—
* <,°W 'W fg
t
a
ti
t
ci
y
>
lemma. I f IT, satisfies (2), then T { W ) ( P ) — dW,(P)/dt is to M'(f (P)), whence by the first lemma f satisfies (2). / , satisfies (2) and we define £ as in the third lemma, t h e n shows that £ ( P ) is perpendicular to ^ ' ( / i ( P ) ) , whence it (
t
t
(C) The following result is an application of Theorem 6D. I n order to have a proof avoiding the use of vector-bundle-valued harmonic forms, we can staTt with (5) and substitute (2) to obtain I (P (W,))
•
mt ( ~ ~ c
+ p T" <) C
AB
WteWtW,
a
using the projection relation p ir„ — it^p^. It follows that " - L( (W,))' so that a
P
P
= 0,
33 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OP R I E M A N N I A N MANIFOLDS.
141
2 -A< <wO)° = ^ 2 ( , { F , ) < r . P
P
Applying Green's identity (as in Theorem 6D) we find that i4f2(p(W )°) *l=-
f
2
(
az
jM
o
2
JM
and the conclusion follows: THEOREM. (
0
£ i < ti.
Let W : M->N
be a smooth deformation satisfying (3) for
t
If W 8.
to
maps M into M', then so does every TF { i = t < f
0
ti).
Derivative bounds for the elliptic case.
(A) Under suitable curvature and metric restrictions on M' we shall establish derivative estimates important for the solution of (1) and (3), or equivalently, of (1) and (3). Our starting point is the following result, essentially established in §3C.
LEMMA.
Any solution f, of (3) has energy density e(f ) t
satisfying
d t
(6)
11
-g'aBh-UfR , where fi{ft) is the fundamental form of ft and where R' py$ and R > are the components of the Riemannian curvature tensor on ffl* and of the contravariant Ricci tensor on M, respectively. ( B ) For the elliptic systems (1), (1) we invoke Green's formula for the operator A on M. Let r(P, Q) denote the geodesic distance between points P, Q of M. Since M is compact (without boundary), there is a constant a>0 such that r*(P,Q) is of class C™ for r*{P,Q) < 3a. Let
a
2
2
P
(
=
o
g
p
(
3
)
is a parametrix for the operator A, wheTe 1/n is (n—-3) times the surface of the unit (n — l)-sphere. (7)
«(P)= f JM
Green's formula is [u{Q)-A F(P,Q)-P(P,Q)-Au{Q)'\*l , Q
0
34 143
J A M E S E E L L 8 , J E . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
this holding for any function u(P) of class C on M (see Giraud [13], Bidalde Eham [ l ] ) . Consider now a solution of (1), and suppose that the Riemannian curvature of M' is non-positive. Prom (6), in which it is merely necessary to suppress the term de(f )/dt, there follows at once t
Ae(/)
—Re(/),
where R is a constant (independent of the solution in question). Since F(P, Q)^0 (a and
f JM
l*oF(P,Q)+R-F(P,Qne(f)(Q)*U-
By using the osculating Euclidean metric at a point of M one can show that | A F(P, Q) I const. X p(P> Q)'"* - Hence for some constant A, 2
Q
f JM
e(f)(P)^A
F(P,Q)e(f)(Q)*l . Q
Iterating this k— 1 times we obtain f JM
e(f)(P)^A*
F (P,Q)e(f)(Q)*l . k
Q
where the F are denned inductively by F = F and k
±
Fu(P,Q)
=
f F _ (P,Z)-F(Z,Q)*l JM k
l
(t>l).
z
If k > ft/2, then F is bounded (see Giraud [12]), and we have tbe foUowing k
THEOBEM. If M' has non-positive Riemannian curvature, then there is a constant 0 such that e(f) < C-E(f) for any harmonic mapping f: M—>M'. (C) Green's function G{P,Q) for A can be written in the form G{P,Q) =F(P,Q) -\-F'(P,Q), where F' is of class C" for P^Q and has a singularity of order lower than that of F for P^Q (Giraud [12], Bidalde Rham [1 ] ) . G [P, Q) is symmetric and of class C" f or P Q and satisfies A G(P,Q) =& G(P,Q) = V-\ where V is the volume of M. Green's formula (7), with G in place of F, is P
(8)
Q
f
«(P) = F - ' J
u(Q)*l-f
M
G(P,Q)-Au(Q)*l . 0
•/ M
Now let tj be a compact coordinate neighborhood on M, V its interior, and let P e U have coordinates (a; ,• • • ,x"). Write 1
3S HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF RIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS. i
G (P,Q)=dG(P,Q)/dx ;
G (P,> =
i
143
r-G{P,Q)/dxW
U
Using normal coordinates on M one can show that there is a constant 0 such that | \ (9)
G^Q^^C-r(P,Q)-'^
|Gw(P,C)|^C-r(P,g)-» — Gi(Q,Z)\^C-r(P,Q) [r(P,Z)-''* a
I Gi(P,^)
1 a
1 a
+
r(Q,Z)-"' - ]
for P, Q G U, a being an arbitrary but fixed number with 0 < a < 1. If it is a solution of Au = f on M for some function /, then from (8) we have (for P£U) f
MP)
G (P,Z)
f(Z)*l .
i
z
JM Hence IMP)— for P,Qe.U.
f JM
MQ)\^
\G (P,Z)—G (Q,Z)\-\f{Z)\*U i
i
Using the last inequality of (9) we obtain
M wheTe
C = C-sup f JM
+,
Q
1
a
[r(P,?)-" - -f-r(g 2)-"* - ]*l . j
z
Suppose now that / is Holder-continuous with exponent a and Holder modulus M (f). I.e., Jl/ {f) = s u p I f(P) —f(Q)\-r(P,Q)- . It is a classical result a
a
a
M of potential theory that the function f G {P,Z)-[f(P )-f{Z)]*l JM l
0
(P,P 6t7)
z
0
has a derivative with respect to x> at the point P , given by 0
f JM
G (P ,Z)-[f(P )~f(Z}]*l , u
0
0
z
and by (9), this integral is majorized by 0-M (f)-
| JM
a
r(P ,Z)-"^*U. 0
On the other hand, the function
K
= 0.
is a constant, since
We conclude that
36 144
JAMES E E L I . S , J E . AND J . H . SAMPSON. i
(11)
\9*u/0t dxf\^C-M (f)
in U.
a
(This is an interior estimate of the type given by Hopf and Schauder (Hopf [ 1 4 ] , Schauder [26], Miranda [18]), but differs from them in that the magnitude of u is not involved.) (D) We apply these results to a harmonic mapping f:M—* the right member of ( 1 ) by F":
M'.
Denote
At this point we impose some boundedness conditions on the embedding of M' in R«, conditions which are automatically fulfilled if M' is compact. Namely we assume that , , | | ^ O, |W/aw" 1 g 0 on Jlf', ' Aids^^ds'^AzdsS, a
0
(
2
where C , At, A denote positive constants and where ds denotes the line element induced on M' by the usual metric in R'. Again let U be the interior of a compact coordinate neighborhood on M , and let P, Q be points of 13. From (12) and an elementary calculation involving the SchwaTZ inequality for quadratic forms and the equality e{f)P = g" W?W Y 0
2
0
,
ab
)
l
\F°(P)—F°(Q)\-r(P,Q)-> ( 1 3 )
a
^ B • [5 + # sup | Wf(P)—W (Q)\
-r(P,Q)
t
where B is a constant and e = e(f) —sup{e(f) ( P ) : P e M).
From (1) and
(10),
[ Wf(P) — Wf(Q) \-r(P,Q)-
a
^ C'sup I F" I, M
and plainly | F* | const. X e, in virtue of (12). of M there follows the estimate (14)
From the compactness
M (P=)gB'(e4-^) t t
for the Holder-modulus of F", B' denoting a constant. we have the
Referring to (11),
T H E O R E M . Suppose that M' satisfies the embedding conditions (12). Let U(x\ • • • ,x ) be the interior of a compact coordinate neighborhood on M. Then there is a constant C such that n
t
\d W/dx*d^\^C(Hf)
+ « ( / ) * ) in U,
(IgaSj),
37 HARMONIC MAPPINGS
OF R I E M A N N I A N
for any harmonic mapping f: M—*M'
Z
MANIFOLDS.
145
where e(f) = sup{e (/) (P) : P e ¥ } .
Remark. We point out that second derivative estimates can be obtained from linear theory in another way. Namely, if we write our equation (1) in the form c
c
e
&W + A >W,>' = 0, where A / J =
i
—ir Wfg i,
b
ab
then we have a linear system with bounded coefficients (in compact coordinate neighborhoods), by Theorem 8B. A Holder-modulus for the W* will then give us a Holder-modulus for the coefficients of the linear system, and we can apply Theorem 1 of Douglis and Nirenberg [6] to deduce second derivative estimates and analogous estimates on all higher derivatives as well. The second derivative estimates we obtain here are somewhat sharper, in certain respects; i. e., they do not involve a priori estimates on the magnitudes of the solutions W. 0
9.
Bounds for the parabolic case.
(A) We now embark upon some analogous computations for the operator £ = A — d/dt. The function !
(15)
2
X ( P , a ( ) = {2V^)-^-'" exp(- (P,g)/40 P
is a parametrix for the operator L (p* as in the preceding paragraph). Put jV,(P, Q, i) =L K(P, P
Q, t) = (\ -dfdt)K{P,
Q, t)
P
and N (P,Q,*)= t
f
f'dr
N^P^J
— T)-N{Z,Q, )*U T
(k>l).
It is well known that there exists a fundamental solution H for the heat operator L on any compact Riemannian manifold M, which can be expressed in the form (16)
H(P,Q,t)=K{P,Q,t)+
f- drf
K(P,Z,t
—
T)-N(Z,Q,T)*lz,
where N(P,Q,t)=i.N*{P,Q,t). (See Milgram-Rosenbloom [ 1 7 ] , Pogorzelski [34]). The function H(P, Q, t) is symmetric in P, Q and is positive. I t is of class C" except for P = t = 0;
10
38 146
J A M E S E E L L S , J H . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
and it satisfies L H(P,
Q, t) = L S{P,Q,t)
P
=0.
Q
Its spectral decomposition
is B(P,Q,t)
= F ^ + £esp(— m
Kt)
where the A„ are the non-zero eigenvalues of A, the
f'dr
u(P,t)
Ji*
(17)
+
f
f JM
— T) LU(Q,T)*1
H(P,Q,t
JM H(P,Q,t
0
— U) u(Q,t0)*lQ
(U
z
this holding for any function u(P, t) on M which IB of clasB C in P and C in ( for t ^ t 0
< tt.
( B ) Suppose now that we have a solution / : M—*M' of (2) defined in 0 < f < i j , and let M' have non-positive Riemannian curvature. According to Lemma 8A we have then Le(f,) 3 — Re(f ), R being a positive constant (independent of the solution in question). Since H > 0, there follows from (17) (
t
(18)
f'dr
e(f,)(P)^R
f
•ft*
+
H(P,Q,t—r)e{f )(Q)*lQ T
JM
6 (f )(P) a
t
where (19)
f
*>(/*)(P)=
ff(P,Q,i-M«(/«.)(e)*lo
"'AT
and 0 < in < ( < i , . Iterating (18) &— 1 times we obtain
(20) f dr
+ e (f,)(P)+iRa
f
ff,(P,g,t
—T)< (/ )(Q)*le, e
T
where the Et are defined by H = E and t
H (P,Q,t) k
Cd, f
= J
a
J
BMP^S—*)£(Z,&4*li
(fc>l).
M
From the integral representation it can be shown (see Pogorzelski [24]) that E(P,Q,t)
<j const. X £ - " r ( F Q ) )
n+2a
(O^(gl).
1
39 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OP RIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS.
147
where a is an arbitrary but fixed positive number less than 1. Therefore H is bounded for k > « / 2 ( 0 £ < £ 1,ft > 1 ) . Consider now our solution / for ( > 1. (
s
rutting (— 1 for f in (30) 0
we have e ( / , ) ( P ) g const.
('>1T t _ I
(SI)
J
f i'(fr)
K>)*1
m
+ S « p t f o ( / r ) ( P ) - [ l + 2 i ? ' C
f
H„(P,g,r)*l ]. 0
For tbe case at band, e is given from (19) by 0
«.(/.) (J*) Since H(P,Q,
f
//{P.V.ii
^/^KO-io.
1) is bounded, we have 6,(ft) (P) g const.
Recalling that j
« ( f ) (<2)*1 M
0
«•(/») ( £ ) is a decreasing function, we obtain finally from
(?1) e(f,) (P) ^ const, f
C<3)*J
(«>!)•
Auy smaller value can be put in for t —• 1 on the right, for example zero if e(f,)(P) is continuous at 1 = 0. Making that assumption, we now obtain an estimate for the range Q ' £ g i 2 | i . I n (20) we now put t„ — 0, getting (821
e(f,) ( P ) £ const. [ f'.ir o
f *S
-U
where now wo have
JM and where <•„(/,) = sup{<\,(/,) (P) : P € -V} : we define e(f ) similarly. But this function is precisely the solution of £<\, = 0 that reduces at i = 0 to *(/o) {.$)• From general principles it follows that ( ' , ( / i ) ( P ) ^ c ( / i ) for / ^ 0 , and so (?'?) gives at once t
e(f,) ( P ) g const. c(f ) 0
(Ogfgl).
We have then the TUKORKM. Let f,:M-*H' le a family of mappings for 0 5£ f < fi satisfying ("-') for 0 < < < / j and ••>urh that the energy density e(f,)(P) is
40 148
J A M E S E H L L 8 , J E . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
continuous at I
0. Suppose that M' has non-positive Riemannian curvature.
Then e(f )(P)^0-f t
J
and
M
e(f )(Q)*l
j o r t ^ K h
a
a(ii)(P)^o-8up{6(/ )() • QeM}
for
0
o^;sl,
0 denoting a constant which does not depend on the particular solution ft of (5). Remark. Under certain circumstances much sharper estimates can be obtained. With the hypotheses of the preceding theorem, assume further that the Ricci tensor of M is positive definite at every point. From (6) it is clear that de(fi)/dt^-—Ae(ft) at any maximum point of e(/i) on M, A denoting a positive constant. I t follows easily that e(/,) (P) ^ const, e . A t
1
n
(C) Now let (a; ,' • *,x ) be the coordinates of P in the interior U of a compact coordinate neighborhood 0 on M. And suppose that our solution of (2) and the first-order space derivatives are continuous at fl — 0. Then from (2), (17) we have W '(P) =
W°(P,t)
t
- - C ' d r f H(P,Q,t- )-F>(Q,T)*U Jo JM
(23)
T
=
+
W '(P,t) t
V°(P,t)+W ><(P,t), 0
where m
m
®
f
-
E(p,Q,t)w(Q,Q)*u,
JM the F"{P, t) being the functions on the right of (2). The first integral V"(P, t) has Holder continuous first-order space derivatives (Pogorzelski [23], Theorem 5 ) : | V '(P t) t
1
— V «{P', t') | ^ const, sup \ F°\ - \r{P, P')° -f-1 f _ < * | « » ] t
(
a being an arbitrary positive number less than 1, the points P and P' both in U. I f we continue with the assumption (12), we shall have | F" | ^ const. X «• The integral W °(P, t) can be differentiated under tbe integral sign (for t > 0) and the derivatives tend exponentially to zero, as is quickly seen from the spectral formula for H. Hence, if the hypotheses of Theorem 9U hold, it follows that the functions W (P, t) have first-order space derivatives which 0
C
41 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF R I E M A N N I A N MANIFOLDS.
149
are Holder-continuous in P, t, uniformly so for t 5; « > 0:
a
gconst. [e(/ ) 4-sup I W ( ( ? , 0 ) | ] • [r(P,P') M
+ | i — i ' WSJ,
0
(The constant depends upon t because of the behavior of W "(P,t) small t.) 0
for
Referring to (13) we see that (
M
\F'(P,t)-F'(Q,t)\-r(P Q)-
)
>
g const. B ( / ) [1 + «(/„)* + fi«P I W°(Q,0) |] 0
forig*>0. Now from (17) it is clear that (
dr f
H(P, Q, t — T)$(T)*1
q
is a
Jo JM function of t alone for arbitrary ip. Hence for the second derivatives F ( P , i ) = d*V (P,t)/dx fc' we can write c
e
l
( i i
f 'dTf H(P,Q,t-T)[F°(P r)--F<(Q,T)-\*l .
F,,(jV)=a^7
a
M
ni
9
From (Pogorzelski [24], Tb. 3) this is V °{P t)= u
t
('dr
f JM
./ f-e
Jo
Jo
ff . (P,g,i- )[P"(P , )-P"(g r)]*l i i
T
0 T
f
where we assume f ^ 2 * > 0 . The integral I is improper but uniformly convergent. Now | H^P, Q, t) | < const. X frfy{P,Q)- -™ (arbitrary 8, 0 < £ < 1 ) . Using (24) and putting P = P„ in I (we assume ( P ^ e P ) , we obtain an absolutely convergent integral if a, 8 are chosen properly, and there results x
n
B
t
\U\<
e
o^t. e(/„) [1 + sup | W°(Q,0) | - f e(/„)*] if C ^ 2*, Af
since then T in J , will be £ f . For I we have | H-i,j{P, Q,t) \ < const, erW for some positive y and for f ^ e > 0. Hence z
• i-e t-t -7('-T) oV
X
E
c
< const, sup | F | < const. e{f ), 0
using Theorem 9B.
42 150
JAMES E E L L S , J R . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
T H E O R E M . Suppose that M' satisfies the imbedding conditions (13). Let ft satisfy the conditions of Theorem 9B, and let (x ,- • • ,x ) be the coordinates of a point P in the interior of a compact coordinate neighborhood U on M. Given t > 0, there is a constant C, independent of the solution f of (2), such that 1
n
t
c
d*W (P,t) dx^x' for i^t,
0)\:Q£M}
< C e(f ) [ 1 + gtf )» + BupfJ W'(Q, 0
0
where e(f ) — sup{e(f ) (P) : P € M}. 0
0
Semarh.
Since I H{P,Q,t)*lQ is a constant, the functions W"(Q,0) JM appearing in the foregoing estimates can be altered by arbitrary additive constants without affecting the validity of the estimates. For example, one could replace W"(Q, 0) by the function minus its average value, say W , with the result that the term sup | W (Q,0)\ in Theorem 9C would be replaced by sup| TP"(Q,0) — W«\. c
a
10.
Successive approximations.
(A) Let W(P,t) and W'(P,t) be two solutions of (2) in 0^t
0
W ( P , ( ) — W">(P,t)
f ' dr f H (P, Q, t - r) CNft r) - tf* (Q, r) ] *1 , 0
Jo
•*M
c
where F" F' are the respective right members of (2). }
Z(t)
= s u p | W°(P,t)—
Set
W'°(P,t)\
M,c e
+ [sup(W —W '°) (Wf— t
{
W'iBtni.
M,B c
c
U(t) =e(f )
+e(r.)
From the constitution of F and F' it is easily verified (by an argument similar to that foT (13)), account taken of (12), that \F»—F"°\
+ *(/,)» + a
Hf>)y
For 0 £ ( g l we can write E(P,Q,t)
43
HARMONIC MAPPINGS OP R I E M A N N I A N MANIFOLDS.
151
where in the latter the constant depends upon the particular choice of local coordinates x . of course. Now let A denote an upper bound for the quantity U(t) in some fixed time interval 0 g t f = i . From the integral expression above there follows easily, for \ < a < 1, i
2
X(t)
< const. X A J ' {t —
and we conclude that X(t)
r)-"X{T)d
T!
vanishes for small t.
Hence the
T H E O R E M . Let f, and ft be two solutions of (3), both continuous along with their first-order space derivatives at ( = 0. If fo = fo, then the two solutions coincide for all (relevant) t > 0. COROLLARY.
Any solution of ( 2 ) enjoys the semi-group property along
the trajectory of each point P £ M.
That is, if we write ft[P) = T, (f ) , then
T (U)=T (f )=Tt(T (f )). UT
t
T
T
0
( B ) For tbe solution of ( 2 ) we now turn to the system of non-linear integro-differential equations ( 2 3 ) associated with ( 2 ) . 1
Let / : M - » M' be a mapping of class C , given by global mapping functions T P = ( W V •
W).
For v ^ O define W'=
W°-(P,f)= f Jit
(25)
{W--\- • • ,W'^)
by
H(P,Q,t)W°(Q)*l
Q
and C
W" (P, t) (26)
=
— C dr f HiPtQ^—^-F'-^iQ^^U Jo JM
+
W^iP^),
where b
F-"{P,t)
ii
=ir °(W)-W r-«W - g , ab
t
)
the functions TTab" as in ( 2 ) . Set y = sup [ 2 WV^TF/'V']*v
From ( 2 6 ) Wf<(P,t) (27)
f'
Jo
dT
C n (P,Q,i JM t
—
r)-F*-^(Q,r)*lQ+W^(P,t),
44 152
J A M E S B E L L S , J E . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
where the subscript i denotes differentiation with respect to a system of local coordinates x* at P. We recall the estimate I
a
Q,t)\<
At~ r{P, Q)-"-^<*
( 0 ^ i ^ l ; i < « < l ) ,
A denoting a constant which depends in general on the local coordinate system. Now let B denote an upper bound for the quantities | w b | in some compact neighborhood V of the image f(M) in the tubular neighborhood N C R«. I f W- €. U' for 0 g t% t, then from (27) we conclude that 0
a
1
where C is a constant which does not depend upon the given mapping f. Put y — sup y r
O^i^t,
n
Then y < Kt-oy^ v
a
1 0
If K^- g^
1
S £ and Ke - ^
+ y*,
K = BG/(1 — *).
% £, then
From a transparent induction it follows that, for sufficiently small positive *, we shall have W(P,
a
() 6 V and y„ ^ ^K^~ for 0 g * g t, y = 0,1,2, • •
In particular, the defining equation (26) makes sense for all v, provided Now put e
X „ ( i ) — sup I W- (P, f)
W - ^ ^ P , f) I 1
fl
• f [sup(W^= —W^" '") (Wy- — W y - ^ f l * ' ] ! . From the definition above, j^.e—j'F-i.n._,
W o f t 0
( r p » - i ) ( 1 F ^ » 1 P ^ I > — Wf-i*Wf-%.b)
gti
+ [».»"(W) — ^ " ( T F ' - ^ l W ^ W j - V ' . We can suppose that the constant B occurring above is also an upper bound for the quantities | d-n „ /dw | in the neighborhood IT. The preceding formula c
a
d
45
HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF BIEMANNLAN MANIFOLDS.
153
then gives us | p > - J W * | < C'BZ (y P
P
+
+
C a constant independent of the given mapping /. Hence, | F^ — F'- -"1 < G'BXill/K*-* 1
2
+ 1/4SV- "]
From (36), (27) and the estimates cited for H(P,Q,t) obtain f Z„(r)
X^{t)
=C"Z (t). v
and ff (P,Q,tO we (
a
((-T)- dr
(0g^ ), t
Thus if
X„(i) ^ s u p Z ^ r )
(O^rgi),
then
and so the series
0
converges for all sufficiently small (. This shows that our successive approximations W* and their first-order space derivatives converge uniformly on M (for small t). Hence, the F"- also converge. Set W" = lim W' and F" = lim¥"•" ( c — » » ) . Thus W'(P,t) has continuous first-order space derivatives Wi' (for sufficiently small t, of course), and W / —> WV (?—»a>), so that C
C
,e
J*>(P,^^(rfjTf^y). From (26) there follows at once (28)
W(P,t)
f'dr
f
3(P,Q,t
Jo
— T)-F°(Q,T)*l
Q
+
W°-°[P,t).
JM We conclude that the functions W have Holder-continuous first order space derivatives—uniformly Holder-continuous for any small elosed (-interval not containing zero. Therefore the functions F " ( P , t) are Holder-continuous with respect to the space variable, and so tbe functions W° of (28) satisfy equation (2) for all positive t in the interval in which the successive approximations converge (see Pogorzelski [24]). The ff" are moreover visibly cone
46 154
JAMES EEIXB, JE. AND J . EI. SAMPBON.
tinuous with their first order space derivatives at (— 0, and W"(P, 0) = W(P). From Theorem 7C we recall that the point W(P,t) — (W ,- • • ,W*) must lie on the manifold M' for all t in the interval of convergence. 1
THEOREM. Let M" be a compact subset of M'. Then, for any continuously differentiate mapping f:M^M' such that f(M) lies in M", there is a positive constant i , depending only on M" and the energy density e(f) such that (2) has a solution f, for O g ( g d which is continuous at ( = 0, along with its first order space derivatives, and which coincides with f at t = d. It only remains for us to inquire into the length of the (-interval for which the successive approximations converge. First of all, the upper bound B for | ir ," | and j (hatf/dm* | figuring in the foregoing proof can be taken once for all to be valid in some neighborhood U" of M". Therefore the constant K can be fixed, and a as well, of course. The < must satisfy Kf ~ y £ J , and to see what this entails we must look briefly into y„. Consider then a solution u of the heat equation on M, as a map u: M—*R. We suppose that u and its first order space derivatives are continuous at ( = 0. The argument of Theorem 9B holds in this situation. If we put p^g uiu, , then p(P, t) ^ Csupfp (Q, 0) : Q € M], where C is a constant depending only on M. Applying this to the functions W , we conclude that there is a constant C\ such that y„ < C\ • e(f). Thus < depends only on M" and the magnitude of e(f), and the same is true of the quantity C" involved in the estimates of the X . The assertion of the theorem then follows at once from those estimates. In § 2B we described the harmonic character of C maps in terms of their tension fields. For C maps we have the ai
l
a
a
il
j
0,c
v
1
1
COEOLLAEY. Let f: M—*M' be a continuously differentiate mapping for which the energy is a minimum with respect to small variations. Then f is harmonic. For let ft be the corresponding solution of (3) guaranteed by the preceding theorem. The energy E (/,) is continuous at ( = 0 and by assumption it must be non-decreasing for small (. But E{f,) is always non-increasing, so that dW/dt^O for small t. Thus (2) reduces to (1). (C) THEOEEM. Suppose that M' has non-positive Riemannian curvature, and that it satisfies the embedding restrictions (12). Then for any continuously differenliuble mapping f: M—*M' there is a unique solution f,
47 harmonic
mappings of
riemannian manifolds.
155
of (2), defined for all t^Q, which is continuous along with its first order space derivatives at t — 0 and which coincides with f at t = 0. Such a solution exists for small t, by Theorem 10B, and it is unique, by Theorem 10A. Let t, be the largest number such that a solution of the required sort exists for 0 f§ t < t„ and supposes that t± is finite. From Theorem 9B it is clear that the right members of (28) cannot become unbounded for O g i < ( i and consequently the images fi{M) (0^(<(,) all lie in a compact subset of M'; we recall that M' is always assumed to be complete. On the other hand, Theorem 9B shows that the energy density e(f,) remains bounded, and therefore by Theorems 10A and 10B there is a fixed positive number such that any f, can be continued as a solution of (2) into the interval ((,14-<,). This contradicts the definition of (D) If W is not compact, then solutions of (2) may very well become unbounded as t —*oo, as in the Example. Let M' be tbe manifold obtained by revolving the graph of a positive strictly decreasing smooth function v = v(u) around the u-axis; let <> / denote the revolution angle. For a map / : S —» M' of a circle S parametrized by the central angle 0 our heat equation is 1
H 3t dt
=
v'v" 1 + (v')
2 +
M-
2
+
/3uV \d&)
1
vv' 1+{»')*
(HY W
v 86 di) '
If / satisfies initial conditions du/d8 = 0,
I u
du e" 4- 1 St ~ e 4-1 * Ju
Thus e" 4- u — 2 logic" 4- 1) = ( 4 - const.; in particular, u—>oo as t—>w. We note in passing that there are no non-trivial closed geodesies on W, so that there are no harmonic representatives in any non-trivial homotopy classes of maps S —» AT. The following result shows that solutions must remain bounded if M' satisfies certain conditions at infinity. 1
48 156
J A M E S E E L L S , J E . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
THEOREM. Let M' be as in the preceding theorem and suppose further that j w | •TTab'tw) —» 0 uniformly as \ w j —>oo, where \ w | = sup \w°\. Then 0 every solution of (2) is bounded. Set W(t) = sup| W"(P,t)\,
W(t) = inf I W°(P, t)\,
c
U(t) =
2
f 2 (W ) *l.
In virtue of Theorem 9B, the difference W(t) — W(i) is bounded. Hence if our solution is unbounded as (-»<», then that is true of all three of the quantities above. Supposing that to be the case, let us denote by A& the set of all ( for which U(t) > fc. The Aj are then all non-empty and each As must contain at least one t = t at which dU/dt^.0. Now from (2) we have k
2 W°AW — 2 o
o
-n at
c
1
2 W Tr ° WfWjY ab
Hence by Green's Theorem idU/dt=—
f (gradW) *l — 2 f WV^W^W.VM. •J M aJ M 2
For large values of f* we have a plain contradiction, since the right-hand side must be negative. 11.
Harmonic mappings.
(A) We can now apply some of the results established above to prove the existence of harmonic mappings, even though we do not know whether the solutions of the parabolic system (2) converge in general as t—»oo. THEOEEM. Let M' have non-positive Riemannian curvature and let f :M—*M' be a bounded solution of (2), 0 < i < o > . Then there is a sequence d, U, t , • • • of t-values such that the mappings f, converge uniformly, along with their first order space derivatives, to a harmonic mapping f. t
a
k
From Theorems 9B and 9C it is clear that the mappings / , and their first order space derivatives form equicontinuous families. Hence there exists a sequence t„ t - • • such that the mappings f — f, converge uniformly, with their first order space derivatives, to a continuously differentiable mapping f. From (2) and (8) we can represent the f by the formula S!
k
k
k
49 HARMONIC MAPPINGS OF RIEMANNIAN MANIFOLDS.
157
c
where as usual F stands for the right member of ( 2 ) . Now fix c and temporarily put
X
dW-
The dW{P, t )/dt are bounded as &-»oo, by Theorems 9B and 9C, and so the u and their first derivatives are bounded. Hence the u form an equicontinuous family, and we can suppose that the sequence t t ,- • • is chosen so that the u converge uniformly, say to u. Now let (?„ denote the i>-th iterate of the Green's function G. We have k
k
k
l7
2
k
f G,(P,e)«(G)*l=lim f J M
G»{P,Q)u (Q)*\ k
h J M It J M
0,1
If v 4 - l > f i / S , then G is bounded. But the dW'(P, t )/dt the mean to zero as h—*oo, by Corollary 6C. Thus W 1
converge in
k
r
G»(P,Q)u(Q)*l
= 0,
J M
and so u = 0 because of the positive-definite character of G. Therefore, passing to the limit in the equation above, we get for the limit mapping f the formula
where
T P « ( P ) = 7 - » j" W'(Q*i— f G(P,Q) JM JM e
F (Q)—\imF»( Q, k L
h)
F<(Q)*1 , 0
=- '(W)WfWW. rM
C
From this it follows (as in § 1 0 B ) that W (P) has Holder-continuous first derivatives, and therefore f" is Holder-continuous. Consequently the W(P) satisfy (1). COROLLARY. Let M ' have non-positive Riemannian curvature and let f: M M ' he a continuously differentiate mapping. Let f, be the solution of (2) which reduces to f at ( = 0. / / / , is bounded as t—>oo, then f is homotopic to a harmonic mapping f for which E(f') ^E(f). In particular, if M ' is compact or satisfies the conditions of Theorem 10D, then every continuous mapping M—>M' is homotopic to a harmonic mapping.
50 158
JAMES EELLS, JR. AND J . H. SAMPSON. COROLLARY. If M' is compact and has non-positive Riemannian curvature,
then every homotopy class of mappings M—* M' contains a harmonic mapping whose energy is an absolute minimum. For in any homotopy class we can choose a minimizing sequence of harmonic mappings f ft, etc., by the preceding corollary. From Theorems 8B and 8D it follows that we can select a subsequence (same notation) which converges uniformly along with first derivatives to a continuously differentiable mapping /. Then E(f) = lim.E(ft), and f is harmonic by Corollary 10B. u
(B) THEOREM. Let M have non-negative Ricci curvature and let M' have non-positive Riemannian curvature. Suppose that M' is compact or that it satisfies the conditions of Theorem 10D. Then any continuous map f: M^*M' is homotopic to a totally geodesic map. Furthermore, 1) if there is at least one point of M at which its Ricci curvature is positive, then every continuous map from M to M' is null-homotopic; 2) if the Riemannian curvature of M' is everywhere negative, then every continuous map from M to M' is either null-homotopic or is homotopic to a map of M onto a closed geodesic of M'. This is a combination of Theorem 3C and Corollary l l A . COROLLARY. Let M be a compact smooth manifold admitting a Riemann structure g with non-positive Riemannian curvature. Then M does not admit any Riemannian structure g with non-negative Ricci curvature unless that curvature vanishes everywhere. 1
Proof. It suffices (by passing to the two leaved orientable cover if necessary) to consider the case that M is orientable. I f there were such a metric g, then the identity man (M, g) —> (M, g') would be homotopic to a totally geodesic map. That map has degree one, and therefore M cannot have any point of positive Ricci curvatuie relative to g. Remark. A special case of Theorem 11B (Part 1) can be obtained without the use of harmonic theory. Namely, assume 1) that M has positive Ricci curvature everywhere; then by a theorem of S. Myers [30], the fundamental group ^ ( j y . w i ) is finite;
51
HARMONIC
MAPPINGS
OF RIEMANNIAN
MANIFOLDS.
159
2 ) that M' is anr complete Riemannian manifold with non-positive Riemannian curvature. Then the homotopy groups m!) = 0 for t ^ l , and •w,(M',m'} has no elements of finite order. It is well known that the homotopy classes of maps of any arcwise connected space 11 into are in natural 1-1 correspondence with the conjugacy classes of homomorphisms 7r,{Jf, m) —>ir,(il', m'). But clearly in the situation at hand every such homomorphism is trivial, whence every continuous map M —* Zl' is null homotopic. COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY, T H E JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY, T H E INSTITUTE FOR ADVANCED STTDY.
REFERENCES.
[I] [2]
P. Bidal and G. de Rham, ' ' L e a formes differentielles harmonique," Commentarii Mathematici Helvetia, vol. 19 (1946-71, pp. 1-49. S. Bochner, ''Harmonic surfaces in Riemannian metric," Transactions of the
[3]
American Mathematical Society, vol. 47 (1940 J , pp. 146-154, , "Analytic mappings of compact Riemann spaces onto Euclidean space,"
[4]
Duke Mathematical Journal, vol. 3 11937), 339-354. , " C u r v a t u r e and Betti numbers in real and complex vector hundles," Ren-
diconti del Seminario Mateniatico di Torino, vol. 15 (1955-0), pp. 225-2-53. 15] C . Chevalley, Lie Groups I. Princeton, 1946. [6] A . Douglis and L . Xirenberg. "Interior estimates for elliptic systems of partial differential equations," Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, vol. 8 (1955), pp. 503-538. [71 P. Dressel, " T h e fundamental solution of the parabolic equation I , " Duke matical Journal, vol. 7 (1940 ) , pp. 186-203. [8] L . P . Eisenhart, Riemannian Geometry. Princeton, 1926.
Mathe-
[9] A. Friedman, " I n t e r i o r estimates for parabolic systems of partial differential equations," Journal of Mathematics and Mechanics, vol, 7 (1958), pp. 393-418. [10] F . B . F u l l e r , "Harmonic mappings," Proceedings of the Xational Academy of Sciences, U.S.A., vol. 40 (19541, pp. 987-991. [11] M. Gevrey, " S u r les equations aux derivees partielles du type parabolique," Journal de Mathematiques et Appliquees, b. 6, vol. 9 (1913), pp. 305-475, G. Giraud, " S u r le probleme de Dirichlet generalise," Annates de I'Ecole Normale Huperieure, vol. 46 (1929), pp. 131-245. [13] R . Hermann, "A sufficient condition that a map of Riemannian manifolds be a [12]
fibre bundle," Proceedings (1960), pp. 236-242.
of the American
Mathematical
Society,
vol. 11
52 160
JAMES EELLS,
J R . AND J . H . SAMPSON.
[14] E . Hopf, " TJber lien funktionalen, insbeaondere den analytischen Character der Losungen elliptiacher Different! algleichungen zweiter Ordnung," Mathematische Zeitschrift, vol. 34 (1931), pp. 194-233. [15] A . Liehnerowicz, " Quelquea theoremes de geometrie differentielle globale," Commentarii Mathematici Belvetid, vol. 22 (1949), pp. 271-301. [16] C . Maxwell, A Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism, Oxford, 1892. [17] A . Milgram and P. Rosenbloom, "Harmonic forma and heat conduction I , " Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, U.S.A., vol. 37 (1951), pp. 180-184. [18] G. Miranda, Equazioni alle Derivate Paraiali di Tipo Ellittiao, Berlin, 1955. [19] C . B . Morrey, " T h e prohlem of Plateau on a Riemannian manifold," Annals of Mathematics, vol. 49 (1948), pp. 807-851. [20] S. Myera, " Riemannian manifolds with positive mean curvature," Duke matical Journal, vol. 8 (1941), pp, 401-404.
Mathe-
[21] J . Nash, " T h e imbedding problem for Riemannian manifolds," Annals of Mathematics, vol. 63 (1956), pp. 20-64. [22] I . Petrovsky, " O n the analytic nature of solutions of systems of differential equations," M atematiieskiy Sbornik, vol. 47 (1939), pp. 3-70. [23] W. Pogorzelaki, " Propriatea des integrates da l'equation parabolique normale," Annates Polonici Mathematici, vol. 4 (1957), pp. 61-92. [24]
, " E t u d e de la solution fondamentale de l i q u a t i o n parabolique," Ricerche di Matematica, vol. 5 (1956), pp, 25-56. [25] S. Sasaki, " O n the differential geometry of tangent bundles of Riemannian manifolds," Tohoku Mathematical Journal, vol. 10 (1958), pp. 338-354. [26] J . Schauder, " Numerische Abschitzungen in elliptischen linearen Differentialgleichungen," Studia Mathematica, vol. 5 (1934), pp. 34-42. [27] D . Spencer, Mimeographed notes, Princeton University.
A n n . Inst. Fourier, Grenoble 14, 1 (1964), 61-70.
ENERQIE ET DEFORMATIONS EN QEOMETRIE DIFFERENTIELLE (') par James E E L L S , Jr. et J . H . SAMPSON (Columbia University et Strasbourg.)
1. Introduction.
De meme qu'une fonction reelle definie sur une variete entraine une decomposition (cf. theorie de Morse) de son domaine (sous certaines hypotheses, bien entendu), une fonctionelle definie sur un espace d'appiications peut donner lieu a une decomposition agreable de celui-ci moyennant certains systemes differentiels associes a la fonctionnelle. Les methodes principales sont la theorie des varietes differentiables de dimension infinie et la theorie des semi-groupes dans les espaces hilbertiens. Ici nous voulons donner une breve description de ces methodes telles qu'elles se presentent dans 1'etude de certains problemes geometriques du calcul des variations sur les varietes riemanniennes. Pour notre formulation nous avons profile de plusieurs conversations avec MM. S. Smale et A. H. Taub. 2. Un probleme general.
Dans ce paragraphe nous voulons esquisser une formulation du calcul des variations adaptee a une classe tres etendue de problemes qui font intervenir des derives d'ordre superieur d'inconnues dont le domaine est une variete difTerentiable (') Ce travail a fite finance partiellement par la National Science Foundation (U.S.A.) et l ' U . S . A r m y Research Office (Durham).
54 62
JAMES E E L L S ,
J R . E T J . H . SAMPSON
donnee. Parmi les problemes que nous envisageons certains sont obtenus par un procede d'iteration, done forcement des problemes d'ordre superieur. Le langage des espaces fibres est le plus naturel pour notre formulation. Soit X une variete riemannienne compacte. Pour ecarter des complications nous la supposerons orientee, sans bord, et de classe C". Soit ^ : V —>• X un fibre difTerentiable sur X ayant comme fibre une variete difTerentiable, et notons J (%) —*• \ lefibredesft-jetsde sections de \ (on ecrira \ tantot pour V, tantot pour 1'espace fibre tout entier). Par densite wariationnelle d'ordre k sur £ nous entendons une fonction difTerentiable / : J*(ij) -> R. Une section suffisamment difTerentiable f du fibre S; determine d'une facon evidente une section f' de J*^); et en appliquant a celle-ci la densite f on obtient une Tonction reelle f(f') sur la variete X. L'integrale de cette fonction, etendue sur X moyennant sa structure riemannienne, sera notee Iy(tp). Done L peut etre considere comme fonctionelle sur une classe donnee V de sections suffisamment differentiables de !;. Le choix de T joue un role important. Avec un choix convenable et sous des hypotheses raisonnables sur la densite / (convexite, par exemple), la fonctionnelle L determinera par ses varietes-niveau une decomposition de son domaine V, decomposition cependant beaucoup plus delicate dans le cas des espaces fonctionnels que dans le cas des varietes ordinaires. II n'est guere besoin d'insister sur sa relation etroite avec la theorie de M. Marston Morse. Les fonctionnelles L que 3'on vient de deerire ont une grande importance pour plusieurs problemes de l'analyse globale et de la geometrie differentielle. Nous en verrons quelques exemples plus loin. Precisons maintenant les espaces fonctionnels que nous voulons considerer. Pour chaque entier ft(0 ^ k < oo) notons C*(!j) 1'espace des sections de classe C* du fibre !;, et notons H(!;) 1'espace des sections de !j dont les derivees d'ordre <J r (par rapport a un systeme de cartes sur X) sont de carre sommable. On munit ces espaces des topologies evidentes. Si r > n/2 + ft, n designant la dimension de X, chaque element de H(c;) est une section de classe C , et on demontre que l'application canonique H (^) C (Z) est continue (lemme de Sobolev; voir [10, Lemme 3.2] ou bien [5]). k
r
r
r
k
55 ENERG1E
E T DEFORMATIONS EN GEOMETRIE D I F F E R E N T I E L L E
63
On sait le resultat suivant depuis quelque temps; voir [3] pour les idees essentielles : k
T H E O R E M E . —• Pour 0 ^ ft < GO Vespace C (c]) variete" differentiable, localement un espace de Banach, sion infinie en general. Pour n/2 < r -< GO Vespace une variete differentiable et les espaces de fecteurs admettent une structure hilbertienne.
est une de dimenH {^) est tangents r
r
Comme choix de T, les espaces H (£) semblent presenter certains avantages sur les C*(ij). En particulier, nous utilisons I'existence sur H (^) d'une structure riemannienne alin de construire le champ v d'Euler-Lagrange pour la fonctionnelle L, ce qui nous met a meme d'etudier les lignes de plus rapide decroissance de L. Or notre probleme general est bien l'etude de ces trajectoires de Vj, c'est-a-dire des applications r
s
$ : R X H'($) - * H'(S)
satisfaisant a l'equation
0
y£$).
II sera surtout question de leur convergence vers des points critiques de L lorsque le parametre t tend vers l'infini. Mais il convient de noter que meme I'existence et Punicite des trajectoires voulues presentent de grandes difficultes en general. La construction du champ Vj peut se faire aussi pour des valeurs de r inferieures a n/2, bien que H (£) ne soit probablement pas une variete alors. Par exemple, pour r — 0 et J; un fibre riemannien, le champ v est une application de H°(^) dans H°(TJj), ou T!; est lefibredes vecteurs tangents a f; et cette application est caracterisee par la formule r
f
(iM,
«> = ( I / U » =
oh fj> e H°(!j), oil u est un element de differentielle formelle de L.
v.h
H°(T^),
et oii (lf)
r
est la
3. Quelques excmplcs de deformations.
A. D E N S I T E S QUADRATIQUES. — Si \ i V -> X est un fibre fibre vectorielle, il en est de meme de 1'espace J ($), des ft-jets, et H {^) est un espace vectoriel admettant une struck
a
r
56
64
JAMES E E L L S ,
J R . E T J . H . SAMPSON
ture hilbertierme. Dans ce cas on peut considerer les densit£s variationnelles f: J*(i;) R qui sont quadratiques dans chaque fibre. Le champ Vj d'Euler-Lagrange associe a une telle densite definit a chaque point 0 e H{S;) un operateur lineaire, discontinu en general. r
]
1. — Prenons pour 5 le fibre T'* (X) formes differentielles exterieures sur X, et posons Exemple
f() = ij2\\d \>
X les
+ W j ,
9
oil d* est la codifferentielle pour la structure riemannienne donnee sur X. Alors I/: H (^) -> R n'est autre que l'integrale de Dirichlet pour les formes differentielles. Munissant H ^) du produit scalaire de H°(£), on obtient vfy) = A
1
etudiee par Milgram-Rosenbloom [7] fournit un semi-groupe a un parametre de deformations (R>0) X IT(5)-> H'tf), a partir d'une forme 9 donnee. Mais si H ($) est muni du produit scalaire deduit de l'integrale de Dirichlet, le champ vt est, a chaque point de H (^), un operateur borne"; et l'equation p
r
ot
a
;
definit un groupe a un parametre de deformations d'une forme f donnee. Cette theorie fut utilisee par Morrey-Eells [10] dans leur demonstration du theoreme de Hodge. Exemple 2. — Chaque operateur lineaire D : C°(5) C°°(rj) d'ordre k defini pour desfibresriemanniens S; et r) sur X determine une densite variationelle f-a d'ordre k,
57 ENERGIE
E T DEFORMATIONS E N GEOMETRIE
DIFFERENTIELLE
65
et le champ d'Euler-Lagrange est v (f) = D*D
r
T
T
TY
et
T'
1
On pose alors f = ° T'f o i oT
Exemple 1. — Prenons pour o* la fonction \/a , oil a„ est la n-ieme fonction symetrique elementaire. Les points critiques de la fonctionnelle L qui en resulte sont les soi-disant « sous-varietes minimales », bien que celles-ci ne soient ni varietes ni minimales en general. Desormais nous nous bornerons au cas
S
o u
oil g (resp. k) est la metrique sur X (resp. sur Y). L'integrale de faif) considere comme fonction sur X sera notee simplement E(
5
58 66
JAMES
EELLS,
J R . E T J . H . SAMPSON
cisement les zeros de l'operateur non lineaire elliptique du deuxieme ordre K^ =
A^ +
n (Y)gg;V
(1
E
oil les a? (resp. les 9") sont des coordonnees locales sur X (resp. sur Y ) , ou A est l'operateur de Laplace-Beltrami sur X , et ou les rja(Y) sont les symboles de Christoftel de Y , m etant la dimension de Y . Pour H ( X , Y ) muni de la structure metrique de H°, les 1
solutions de l'operateur non lineaire de la ckaleur (i)
sont les analogues des lignes de plus rapide decroissance.
Nous avons utilise la solution fondamentale de l'equation de la chaleur sur X pour demontrer [12] que l'equation (1) a une solution unique pour un certain intervalle de temps se reduisant a une application donnee de classe C pour t = 0. Certaines majorations des derivees d'une solution eventuelle de (1), obtenues par une methode geometrique due a Bochner dans un autre contexte, nous permirent d'etablir le 1
THEOREME. — Soient X et Y des varietes riemanniennes fermees, et supposons que la courbure riemannienne de Y soit non positive. Alors il existe dans chaque classe d'homotopie d'applications $ : X - > Y une representante harmonique qui est un point de minimum absolu pour I'energie E . Exemple 2. — Dans le cas d'une variete X de dimension 1 (l'intervalle ferme ou le cercle), on sait que I'energie E : H ^ X , Y)
-> R
est une fonction differentiable qui determine une bonne decomposition de 1'espace H ^ X , Y ) , dont on obtient les estimations de Morse des nombres de Betti de 1'espace des lacets de Y . On en trouve un expose elegant dans Palais [11]. Le theoreme enonce ci-dessus peut etre etabli dans le cadre de la theorie de la fonction differentiable E sur la variete
59 ENERGIE
E T DEFORMATIONS
EN GEOMETRIE
DIFFERENTIELLE
67
r
H (X, Y), pour r > ra/2 (n etant toujours la dimension de X). Mais il convient de signaler qu'a defaut de la condition requise sur la courbure de Y, la fonction E peut ne pas donner une bonne theorie de Morse. Par exemple, si nous prenons
la sphere euclidienne (n 3), alors E n'a aucun point de valeur minimum sur les composantes de H (S , S ) des applications de degre ^= 0. En effet, on peut trouver une famille a un parametre T , : S„ «-* S„ d'applications C°° et de degre un telle que lim E(*F ) = 0 (t -*• oo). Mais bien entendu il n'existe pas d'application de degre un dont I'energie s'annule. r
n
n
t
C. E N E R G I E S D'ORDRE SUPERIEUR. — S. Smale et R. Palais ont etudie le principle de Dirichlet dans 1'espace euclidien a n dimensions; S. Smale a pu demontrer I'existence d'un extremum pour une classe de fonctionnelles quadratiques du /r"°" ordre, avec k > n/2. Ce resultat souligne l'importance d'une etude de ce que nous appelerons e^nergie du /c" * ordre E . Done si T*X = T(T* X) est 1'espace fibre here de vecteurs tangents, chaque application 9 : X Y de classe C* induit saft""differentielle T"f : T*X->T"Y, et Ton peut s'en servir, comme nous l'avons fait dans le cas k = 1, pour definir une energie E^'f^). Le laplacien itere apparait comme partie principale du champ d'Euler-Lagrange associe a E \ II y a lieu de croire que des methodes analogues a celles qui nous servirent dans la demonstration du theoreme cite au n° 3 B permettront une generalisation de ce theoreme pour les E " , sans hypothese sur la courbure de Y si k est suffisamment grand. Et l'on peut esperer trouver une theorie de Morse pour E<*>: H*(X, Y) ^ R (A > n/2). m
w
-1
( t
0
D. Q U E L Q U E S REMARQUES. — La notion de o"-energie peut etre appliquee a d'autres situations. Par exemple, si p(g) = (R^g)) est le tenseur de Ricci de la metrique g sur X, alors <Ji(p[g)) = g^Rij = R, la courbure scalaire. Son integrale est la courbure totale de X, consideree comme fonction de g; notons-la T(g). Hilbert a montre [4] que ses extrema satisfont a l'equation R f — ^ R / 2 = 0.
60
68
JAMES
EELLS,
J R . E T J . H . SAMPSON
Voir aussi Taub [3]1, ou est decrite une methode par laquelle on peut normaliser la fonctionnelle T(g) afin d'obtenir pour ses extrema les metriques dites d'Einstein : — g"R/n = 0. Nous ne connaissons pas de conditions raisonnables sur X qui garantissent I'existence d'un extremum de T. Pourtant la nature des estimations figurant dans la demonstration du theoreme du n° 3 suggere I'existence d'une deformation de g dans une metrique d'Einstein sur X si g est a courbure riemannienne strictement positive. (Cf. Berger [1]). Pour la validite de cette assertion il est clair que certaines restrictions topologiques sont necessaires. Par exemple, S X S* et (S X S ) # (S X S ) (somme connexe) n'admettent pas de metrique d'Einstein. Remarquons, pour terminer, que la conjecture de Poincare dit que T (normalise convenablement) a un extremum si X est simplement connexe et de dimension 3. Pour d'autres problemes relatifs a Ia deformation de metriques, voir Calabi [2] et Yamabe [14]. 1
1
3
1
3
BIBLIOGRAPHIC [1] M. B E R G E R , Les spheres parmi les varietes d'Einstein, C.R. 254 (1962), 1564-1566, [2] E . C A L A B I , The space of Kahler metrics, Proc. Inter. Congress. Math., 1954. [3] J . E E L L S , On the geometry of function spaces, Symp. Inter, de Top., At . (1958), 303-308, [4] D. H I L B E R T , Die Grundlagen der Physik (Erste Mitteilung), Nachr. Ges. WLss. Gott., (1915), 395-407. [5] J . L . L I O N S , Equations differentielles operationne'les et problemes aux Hmites, Springer, 1961. [6] P . L A X and J . A . M I L G R A M . Parabolic equations and semigroup, Annals s
of Math. Studies, 33.
[7] A. M I L G R A M and P . C . R O S E N B L O O M , Heat conduction on Riemannian manifolds I, Proc. N.A.S., 37 (1951). [8] C . B. M O R R E Y , The problem of Plateau on a Riemannian manifold, Anncds of Math. 49 (1948), 801-851. [9] C . B. M O R R E Y , Multiple integral problems in the calculus of variations and related topics, Ann. Scuola Nor. Sup. Pisa, (1960), 1-61. [10] C . B. M O R R E Y et J . E E L L S , A variational method in the theory of harmonic integrals I, AnnaU of Math; 63 (1956), 91-128. [11] R. S. P A L A I S , Lectures on Morse theory; Mimeo. Notes. Brandeis Univ., 1963.
61
ENERGIE [12] [13]
[14]
E T DEFORMATIONS
E N GEOMETHIE
DIFF ERENTIELL E
69
et J . H. S A M P S O N , Harmonic mappings of Riemannian manifolds, Am. Journ. of Math, (a paraitre). A. H. T A U D , Conversation laws and variational principles in general relativity, Notes of a lecture at the Summer Syntp. in Diff. Geometry, Santa Barbara, (1962). H. Y A M A B E , On a deformation of Riemannian structures on compact manifolds, Osaka Math. J., 12 (1960), 21-37. J. EELLS
62
lie printed
from
Proceedings of the United Stalea Japan Seminar in Differentia! Ceomelry Kyoto, Japan, 1965
Variational Theory in Fibre Bundles J a m e s E E L L S , J r . a n d J o s e p h H . SAMPSON
11
T h i s i s a b r i e f d e s c r i p t i o n of c e r t a i n m e t h o d s — s o m e
old a n d
s o m e n e w — o f e s t a b l i s h i n g e x i s t e n c e i n t h e c a l c u l u s of v a r i a t i o n s , c o n f i n e d ( f o r t h e p r e s e n t p u r p o s e s ) to a s e t t i n g w h i c h s e e m s propriate
for
R i e m a n n i a n geometry.
r e s u l t s h a v e a p p e a r e d in
[4, 5, 6 ] ;
Some
our
ap-
of o u r m e t h o d s
viewpoint
overlaps
and to
a
c e r t a i n e x t e n t w i t h t h a t ( d e v e l o p e d e s s e n t i a l l y s i m u l t a n e o u s l y ) of P a l a i s a n d S m a l e [17, 18, 23],
1.
Abstract variational theory. (A)
C l a s s i c a l l y , t h e p r i m a r y m e t h o d i n t h e c a l c u l u s of v a r i a -
t i o n s is b a s e d o n t h e t h e o r e m of W e i e r s t r a s s t h a t i f F:
V-*R
is a
l o w e r s e m i - c o n t i n u o u s f u n c t i o n o n a c o m p a c t s p a c e V, t h e n t h e r e i s a p o i n t of V a t
which F
assumes
its
minimum
value.
This
w a s t h e b a s i s of t h e m e t h o d u s e d for e x a m p l e i n H i l b e r t ' s p r o o f of the
existence
of
geodesic
segments,
in
the
potential
theoretic
s o l u t i o n of t h e P l a t e a u p r o b l e m ( e v e n i n i t s e x t e n s i o n b y M o r r e y [12] to R i e m a n n i a n m a n i f o l d s ) , a n d i n t h e a b s t r a c t a r e a t h e o r y of F e d e r e r - F l e m i n g [7) a n d of R e i f e n b e r g [19]. A s a n illustration in the differentiable context, let V be a real Hilbert space
a n d F: V-*R
for s i m p l i c i t y of derivative
of
F
statement). a t xe
a differentiable If
l
d F{x;u,v)
f u n c t i o n (of c l a s s denotes
V i n t h e d i r e c t i o n s u, v,
the
z
C
second
then we have
the
PROPOSITION. / / d*F(x] v, v)^0 for all x,veV, then F is lower semi-continuous in the weak topology of V. Furthermore, the subsets of V which are weakly compact are precisely those which are bounded and weakly closed. T h i s s i m p l e r e s u l t is a n a b s t r a c t i o n of t h e b a s i c w o r k of T o n e l l i 1)
Research partially supported by N.S.F. Contract G P 4217 and G P 1825. 22
63
VARIATIONAL THEORY IN F I B R E BUNDLES
23
and Morrey (see [13]) on convexity properties of a variational density to insure existence in the calcuJus of variations. EXAMPLE. The norm is weakly lower semi-continuous in a Hilbert space V, and any closed convex subset K of V is weakly closed. Thus there is a point of K at minimum distance from the origin in V. This is the essence of Weyl's method of orthogonal projection. (B) That method was greatly broadened by M. Morse [15] using homology theory. The sets F (—oo,b)=Fi for b eR (which are closed when and only when F is lower semi-continuous) define a filtration of the space V, and analysis of the homology groups H(Fi, F ) for a^Lb relative to some fixed coefficient field leads to an abstract definition of critical points of type k^O. In this general form we have a method of obtaining extremals in the calculus of variations, used to a certain extent by Morse-Tompkins [16] and M. Schiffman [21] in their work on the Plateau problem. It is essential that we take into account critical points of type k > 0; for there are standard variational problems admitting extremals which are critical points of higher type, but not admitting any extremal which is a minimum: See (4, Section 4E of Chapter % _1
a
Indeed, from this general topological viewpoint the abstract calculus of variations becomes a theory of the decomposition of a space V by means of a real function, using the order of the real numbers. In particular, we would like to join each point x£ V to a critical point of F by a path (sort of a gradient line) lying in V. There are various types of decomposition that one might consider: 1) filtration of the space V itself by F; 2) filtration of the homology of V by the H{Ft, Ft); 3) decomposition of a suitable cellular space having the homotopy type of V; 4) handlebody decomposition of V (homeomorphically, or diffeomorphicaily, when that makes sense). We will call decompositions of types 2), 3), 4) Morse-Smale decompositions. (C) Our aim now is to present another method, less general, but well adapted to variational problems of differential geometry. In broad terms, we formulate certain variational problems in the context of infinite dimensional differentiable manifolds, and then use ideas of non-linear functional analysis and infinite dimensional
64 24
J. EELLS,
Jr. A N D J . H . SAMPSON
Riemannian geometry to produce solutions of the given problem. The effect will be to construct a decomposition of the appropriate function space by lines of steepest descent; for further motivation in a linear setting we refer to [6]. 2.
General form of the problem.
(A) Let X b e a compact oriented Riemannian M-manifold. We will suppose throughout that X has no boundary, which will have the effect of restricting our variational problems to closed problems; that will simplify our exposition. On the other hand, the modification of our formulation and methods to include boundary value problems, while presenting interesting analytic and geometric features, does not offer severe difficulties. Let r: V^X be a smooth ( = differentiable of class C°°) fibre bundle over X, whose fibre model is a manifold, again without boundary. We let / ( r ) : J*(V)-*X denote the bundle of r-jets of sections of r. A variational density of y of order r is a smooth function / : f'(V)-* R. If C"(V) denotes the space of smooth sections of the bundle J and j':C (V)-*C (J (V)) the r " jet prolongation, then we define the function F:C"(V)^>R through the diagram T
a
a,
C(V)
r
R
f
I'' , C<"U'(V))—>-C°"(XxR) Here the right hand arrow denotes the integration over X of a real valued function with respect to the volume «-form *1 of X: r
F(>P)= [fU 9>l
•
Our first problem is the following: Given a component of C"(V), find in it an extremal of F\ for the nonce, let " extremal" be taken in a homological sense. We arrive at once at a fundamental technical idea of variational theory: Although we have a specific problem formulated in a differentiable setting and we require differentiable solutions, it is most convenient to complete the problem by suitably enlarging the function space C"( V) and extending the
VARIATIONAL THEORY
IN FIBRE BUNDLES
25
function F to the enlarged space. In general there can be many essentially different completions of a problem. We will confine ourselves here to what we will call Riemannian problems: We will use essentially the Riemannian structure of X to construct spaces of sections of r which are often Hilbert space manifolds; our variational problems will satisfy a form of Legendre condition, so that their Euler-Lagrange equations will be of elliptic type. (B) Let us suppose for the moment that r is a Riemannian vector bundle f: W-*X; that means that £ is a smooth vector bundle over X having a linear connection P' and an inner product on each fibre, expressed as a 2-covariant tensor field g$, related by pe.g*=0. For any real number 1 < I J ? < C O let LAW) be the completion of the vector space C°°(W) in the norm Mvif>=Q
,
P
l?U)l '*iJ' .
For any integer r g 0 let LA W) be the Banach space of all sections such that all iterated covariant differentials Fty are of class LAO ^ t £ r). In particular, for p = 2 we have the inner product
giving a Hilbert space structure to LAW). The following results [24] are fundamental, where the inclusion is taken to mean that the natural map is a continuous injection; SOBOLEV THEOREMS 1. LA. W)^ LAW) and
\lq >
for 0^ s
— n/p,
. 2.
LA W ) c CK W) for r > n/p+k .
In the present paper we will need this second result only for k = 0. p = 2. The following application is known [3,5]: THEOREM. Let r: V-*J£ be a closed fibre subbundle of £, and LA V) = {
25
J. E E L L S , Jr. AND J. H. SAMPSON
then LAV) is a closed smooth submanifold of the Hilbert space LAW). In particular, LAV) has a smooth Riemannian structure. There are three main points in the demonstration: 1) Use of the inverse function theorem in Banach spaces; 2) use of the first Sobolev theorem to show that the composition of an LA W)-tunction and a smooth function is an Lr'fTTJ-f unction; 3) use of the second Soboiev theorem to insure that the topology in LAW) is larger than the uniform topology. (C) DEFINITION. A variational density / o f order r is (quadratically) Coextensive if the function F admits an extension of class C to a function LAV)-*B. For the case r = ? good conditions to insure that / b e Coextensive have been given by Smale [23]. In the present work we will not worry further about C*-extensivity of a variational density, for in most of our applications F; Lr\V)—*R arises as the restriction of a continuous quadratic form on the Hilbert space LAW), and is therefore automatically C°°-extensive. k
( D ) Given such a variational density / we consider the gradient field t of F on the Riemannian manifold LAV). Its trajectories (fpt)
are the solutions of
= — ?(
or^
relative to the initial Con-
dition p, = ip
a
when
/ = 0.
As in the finite dimensional case one proves the PROPOSITION. If r > M/2, / is Coextensive and / SO, then these trajectories are uniquely defined for all teR. A limit point of (fi) as t—*oa is a differentiable critical point p« of F, and hence represents an extremum in the generalized sense that it belongs tO Lr\V). We are thus in position to formulate the basic Condition (CT): Every trajectory of F has a critical point in its closure. This condition is not always satisfied. It is insured, however, if the sets F* are all compact, or if each trajectory (¥>()iao is relatively compact.
VARIATIONAL THEORY IN FIBRE
BUNDLES
27
If Condition (CT) is satisfied, then we are in position to provide generalized solutions to the problem posed in Section 2A: Starting with any p e L r ( V ) there is a critical point ip^eLr"(V) which, using the Riemannian geometry of L (V) and Sobolev's second theorem for r > M/2, is shown to be arcwise connected to fa- Now critical points tpSLr\V) can sometimes be shown to belong to C™(V), in which case our solution is satisfactory; however, that question of higher differentiability of critical points is a most difficult and only partially developed aspect of the field (see Morrey [13] for a discussion of recent results). We will content ourselves by remarking that in our examples in Section 3 below, all critical points p « e L r ( F ) are actually in C~{V). !
0
2
R
!
(E) Our first problem is only the first step in a much richer theory, of the sort outlined in Section IB, Palais and Smale have taken this stronger viewpoint by requiring Condition (C). Given any sequence (pjJtju in L \V) such that F{
in
Lr\V).
Condition (C) implies Condition (CT) and can be viewed as motivated by it; for if {
t
(
REMARK. Smale [23] has used Condition (C) in case r is a vector bundle to establish the existence of L -solutions of a certain non-linear Dirichlet problem. We cite also the recent work of F . Browder [1], applying (C) in the context of Lusternik-Schnirelmann 2
r
28
J . E E L L S , J r . AND J . H . SAMPSON
category. (F) To us the most unsatisfactory aspect of our theory is the requirement that r > «/2. Presumably, for 0 g r ^ M/2 the function space L \V) is not a manifold in general. That seems to mean, roughly speaking, that it is easier to solve variational problems whose integrals involve high derivatives in a prominent role than it is to solve low order problems. (This was recognized also by Palais [17, §16] and Smale [23, Condition (3)].) T
3.
Examples of the general theory.
(A) EXAMPLE 1. Suppose £: V-*X and n: W-*X are vector bundles over X and A an r** order linear elliptic operator from the sections of £ to sections of v. Then the variational density /(p) = l/2|.4 'l , relative to some inner product in q, is quadratically C=°-extensive, and defines a continuous quadratic form F: LAV)-* K( £ 0). Condition (CT) is satisfied, and in fact (as a consequence of the linearity of the problem) the trajectories converge to points of the kernel of A, a finite dimensional subspace of C™(V)
r
As an application, we cite the following well known result; Given iireC™(W), there is a
(B) We obtain a large variety of variational problems by taking the situation of Example 1 and restricting / to a closed subbundle r of f having compact fibres (this last condition is not essential; it suffices to have fibres having some metric boundedness conditions). For expositional reasons we will discuss only the following special case.
69
V A R I A T I O N A L T H E O R Y IN F I B R E B U N D L E S
29
EXAMPLE 2. Take for $ the trivial bundle XxR" and for r the product manifold X x F c X x J ? ' ; we will view the sections of r as maps from X to Y. We set A — (d+d*) and define the r energy E (
th
1
T
&(¥<) = 1/2 j \(d+d*)' \**\ V
. s
Its restriction to the closed submanifold Lr (Xx Y) is smooth (when r > n/2). Its extremals are called the polyharmonic maps of degree r {or r-harmonic maps) from X to Y. They are known to be smooth. THEOREM. / / Y is compact and r > n/2, then every map from X to Y is homotopic to an r-harmonic map. If r = \ or if Riem (Y)^.0, then the same conclusion holds. This was proved a few years ago [4, 5, 6]; a problem similar to the first assertion but involving boundary values was solved by Palais [17], and his approach can be applied to produce that assertion without essential difficulty. Furthermore, it is not difficult to generalize both assertions to non-trival bundles r. EXAMPLE. If n = l, the 1-harmonic maps are just the closed geodesies of Y. For this case our proof in [4] does not use any restriction on the sectional curvature of Y. A treatment of closed geodesies—in particular their Morse theory—as critical points of Ei has been given by J. McAlpin [10]; the starting point is verification of Condition (C), modifying the presentation of Palais [17]. It follows immediately (as McAlpin has shown) that there is a nontrivial closed geodesic on Y, thus producing a simple proof of the theorem of Fet. This approach has subsequently been taken up by Klingenberg [9], whose paper claims many important new results. If Y is not compact, then Condition (C) is never satisfied; however, if YIs complete and satisfies certain natural conditions at infinity, then Condition (CT) is satisfied. For r > 1 the r-harmonic maps are the poly geodesies, which on Y play the role of polynomials, just as geodesies play the role of straight lines.
70
30
J . E E L L S , Jr. AND J. H . SAMPSON
EXAMPLE. I f n = 2 and r=l, the energy function E\ is called the Dirkhlet-Douglas integral. The 1-harmonic maps are called minimal surfaces of Y (although of course they are neither minimal nor surfaces, in general). We feel that this case is very special in our theory. For instance, E, is a conformal invariant of X; as another instance, LftXx Y)czLAX x F ) for all 1
(C) Still another example of a variational problem obtained by restriction of a quadratic form has been given by Yamabe [25]: EXAMPLE 3. Take r as the trivial bundle XxR F: Li\XxR)->R by the quadratic form ( « S 3 ) Fiv) =
and define
4(w - 1 ) \d
where R:X->R is the scalar curvature of the Riemannian metric of X. Now for every number l^q<2n/(.n — 2) we have LiHXx R)
71
VARIATIONAL THEORY IN FIBRE BUNDLES
31
range the
4.
Variation theory and cobordism:
A problem.
(A) Thus far in our presentation we have emphasized homotopy aspects of our problem: Proving the existence of extrema in a given component of a function space of sections. That is a somewhat narrow view, and not at all in the proper spirit of many classical variational problems. (For instance, the Plateau problem starts with an immersed 1-manifold B in a given Riemannian manifold Y, and then asks for a minimal surface in Y spanning B. There are no additional restrictions on the surface, such as requiring that it should have a prescribed topological character.) It seems to us that the following problem—here loosely formulated for maps of closed manifolds, but capable of generalization—is of importance. (B) DEFINITION. Suppose the Riemannian manifold Y fixed, together with a positive integer n. Let us consider pairs {
th
PROBLEM. Fix r £ l . Under what conditions is there an extremal pair in a given cobordism class ? 1
For instance, let us take « = 1; then in the picture {
•See note on p. 33a,
72 32
J. E E L L S , Jr. AND J. H. SAMPSON l
and {
A cobordism of (
V
Bibliography [1] Browder, F.: Infinite dimensional manifotds and nonlinear elliptic eigenvalue problems, Mimeo. notes, Univ. of Chicago. 12 ] Dieudonne, J.: Foundations of Modern Analysis, Academic Press, 1960. [ 3 J Eells, J.: On the geometry of function spaces, Sym. Inter, de Top. Alg., 1958, 303-308.
[ 4 ] Eells, J. and J. H. Sampson: Harmonic mappings of Riemannian manifolds, Amer. J. Math., 86 (1964), 109-160. [5] : Energie et deformations en geometrie differentielle, Annales de lTnstitut Fourier, 14 (1964), 61-70.
[6]
: Analyse fonctionnelle non lineaire et geometrie differentielle, Sem. Ehresmann.
73
VARIATIONAL THEORY IN F I B R E BUNDLES
[7]
F e d e r e r , H . and W . F l e m i n g :
33
Normal and integral currents, A n n . of
M a t h . , 7 2 (1960), 458-520. [8]
Gaffney:
T h e heat equation method of Milgram and Rosenbloom for
open Riemannian manifolds, A n n . of Math., 6 0 (1954), 458-466. [9]
Klingenberg, W . :
[10]
McAlpin, J . : bia
(11]
U n i v . , T h e s i s , 1965.
M i l g r a m , A . and P . Rosenbloom: I,
[12]
Closed geodesies, Mimeo. Notes, 1 X 5 .
Infinite dimensional manifolds and Morse theory, ColumHarmonic forms and heat conduction
P . N . A . S . , 3 7 (1951), 180-184.
Morrey, C . :
T h e problem of Plateau on a Riemannian manifold, A n n .
of Math., 4 9 (1948), 801-851. [13j
•
;
Multiple integrals
in the calculus of
variations,
Colloq.
L e c t u r e s A . M . S . 1964. [14]
and J . E e l l s :
A variational method in the theory of harmonic
integrals I , A n n . of M a t h . , 6 3 (1956), 91-128. [15]
Morse, M . :
Functional topology
Gauthier-Villars, [16]
and T o m p k i n s : critical type,
117]
Palais, R . :
and
abstract
variational
theory,
minimal surfaces of
general
Paris, 1939. Existence of
A n n . of M a t h . , 4 0 (1939). Morse theory on Hilbert manifolds,
Topology, 2
(1963),
299-340. [18]
—
and S. Smale:
A generalized Morse theory,
Bull.
A.M.S.
165-172. [19]
Reifenberg, E . : Solution of surfaces.
the Plateau problem for m-dimensional
A c t a M a t h . , 1 0 4 (1960), 1-92.
[20]
Rothe, E . H . :
[21]
Schiffman, M . :
Gradient mappings.
[22]
Shibata, K . :
B u l l . A . M . S . , 5 9 (1953), 5-19.
T h e Plateau problem for non-relative minima, A n n ,
of Math., 4 0 (1939), 834-854. On the existence of a harmonic mapping, Osaka Math.
J . , 1 5 (1963), 173-211. [23]
Smale, S . : problem,
[24]
Morse theory and a non-linear generalization of the Dirichlet A n n . of Math., S O (1964), 382-396.
Sobolev, S . :
Applications of functional analysis, T r a n s l . Math Mono-
graphs, 7 (1964). [25]
Yamabe, H . :
On a deformation of Riemannian structures on compact
manifolds, Osaka, Math. J . , 1 2 (I960), 21-37.
Cornell U n i v e r s i t y Johns Hopkins University
74 33a
*Note to p. 31
Yamabe's assertion is correct, although his proof is not. A coherent exposition of the subject, describing carefully the contributions of many mathematicians, is given by Lee.J.M. and Parker, T. H.: The Yamabe problem, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc, 17 (1987), 37-91.
75
ToptAosj
Vol.
IS. pp. ZBMH. Pefgmwii
Pi™.
1974.
RESTRICTIONS
Printed In GreiL Brilun
O N HARMONIC MAPS
O F SURFACES
I . EELLS and J . C . WOOD (Received lOSeptember 1975) Dedicated 10 Professors S.-S. Chern and H Wtiilney. i l . STATEMENT OF THE MAIN RESULTS
LET X and V be closed orientable smoolh surfaces, and
w„+(2o ic)wM w
=0,
(1)
being the Euler-Lagrange equation associated to the energy functional
The purpose of this notet is to prove the THEOREM. If ip:X-*Y is a harmonic map relative to Riemannian metrics g and h, and if e(X) + \d\ e(Y)\>0, then ipis ± holomorphic relative to the complex structures determined by g and h. l
Here e(X) = 2-2p and e( Y) = 2 -2q denote Euler characteristics; and d„ is the degree of
h) of degree p, whatever the metrics (compatible with the complex
structures).
By way of contrast, A. M. Macbeath has shown us that meromorphic functions of degree p do exist on all other Riemann surfaces X of genus p 3=2. tA special (and Ihe moat important) case of (hat result was anounced a[ [he Summer Course in Complex Analysis, Trieste 1975{ 14]. I' is a pleasure Irj record our rhanks loM. J. Field. L. Lemaire, and A. M. Macbeath for their comments during the preparation of this note.
76
264
I. EELLS AND J. C. WOOD
Application. We give an analytical proof of trie following topological theorem of H . Kneser[7]: If q»2, then for any continuous map ip?.X-*Y, we have \d \e(Y)s: e(X). Namely, we introduce an arbitrary metric g on X, and a metric k of negative curvature on Y. and appeal to the existence theorem[3] to obtain a harmonic map a>: (X,g)-*(Y, ft) which is homotopic to thus d. = aV Now if \a\\e( Y) < e ( X ) , then e(X) + |d.e( Y)\ > 0, so that
|
[ W f f f - ' n l l s p - l . T h u s | d , ( q - l ) | = |p*H'(n)| = | H V - n | ' S p - l ] . Remark Lemaire notes that with our present theorems[81—we can respond to the question:
knowledge—especially
his
existence
Giuen closed orientable surfaces X, Y and a homotopy class of maps ip:X-*Y, can we find metrics g, h on X, Y relative to which there is a harmonic map if homotopic to ^i? The answer is yes in all cases except whenp = 1, q = O.and = 1. In that case the answer is DO. SI. PROOF OF THE THEOREM Given a smooth map y : X -* Y, its differential dip: T(X) -»T( Y) extends to a complex linear map d'
T{X)® C;
IX]. Corresponding to the decompositions T'(X) = V"{X)®
we have
3uoip: T'^X^T'^Y),
3e.,
H
T°'(X)
see [6, Ch.
V(X)-*T°-'(Y).
These can be interpreted as sections of the complex line bundles ncfXlOcff-T^r)
and
TUX)®
respectively. We note that 3i.o^=0iffp is anti-holomorphic, c V , f = 0 i f f ip is holomorphic. The following result is standard; PROPOSITION 1. If the sections i'l.w- and 3 ip have only finitely many zeros, then 0lI
Index 0,. a>) = -e(X)
+
o
d,elY)\
Index lo .,
(2)
a
Here Index(i) = the sum of the zeros of the section s (having only finitely many zeros) of the complex line bundle f over X, counted at each point x according to the local degree of s at x. Then Index(s) = c(f), the (first) Chem class of f; see [11, Part III]. For the first assertion of the Proposition, we take H . o ( X > ® c » > " T " { Y ) for f Now [A, Chapter I ] l
c«.®f ) = c«,)+c« ), 5
)
c(f*) = - c ( f ) ,
|
e(p- ^)=d.e(f).
Since we have canonical isomorphisms T t . ( X ) = T * ( X ) and T ' ^ O O ^ T
a
s
complex line
Index (a,. >) = c{TUX)® -'T(Y)) = clTU(X)+c{
cV
r
PROPOSOION 2. If q>:X->Y is harmonic, then the (Ifir-pan of the tensor field ip*h is a holomorphic quadratic differential on X; we denote it by i).. Furthermore, n . = 0 iff ip is ± holomorphic.
77 RESTRICTIONS ON HARMONIC MAPS OF SURFACES
265
Here
T,, = A ( z ) d z ' = c r V ( z ) ) | r f f -
0)
The partial differentials Sijof and 3*.i
(4)
Y is harmonic but not ± holomorphic, then neither 3,.nip nor Bo.iip has a
zero of infinite order. m
For otherwise the holomorphic function a(z) = o{\z\ )
as z-*0
for all m »0; but that would
imply that a = 0 , so that by Proposition 2, ip would be ± holomorphic. LEMMA. If ip: X - » Y is harmonic but not ± holomorphic, then in isothermal charts 3x$
3wiBz = Az
+o(\z\") for some m 3 0 and complex number A ^ 0 ;
Bwl3z = Bz" +o{\z\") for somen 1*0 and BkO-
(5)
h
Proof. Taylor's expansion to m' order for the first gives 3wldz-Q (z,z) m
where Q
+ R(z,g),
(6) m
m
is a homogeneous polynomial of degree m ==0, and R is 0(1^| ) as z - * 0 .
The preceding Corollary shows that Q „ # 0 for some m. Substituting (6) in ( 1 ) gives
31 Now 3Q l3z m
a
3z
is either a homogeneous polynomial of degree m - 1 or is identically 0. Each of the 1
other terms is o(|z|"'~ ). It follows that BQaldz = 0. Therefore Q„ is a holomorphic homogeneous polynomial of degree m, and consequently has the form Az"
The case of Bo.iip is handled
similarly. Remark. A local expansion theorem for harmonic maps, their differentials, and Jacobians was given by Wood [12, T h 1.4.8; 13], based on work of Hart man-Win tner and Heinz. Our needs here are more modest, and the above direct argument suffices. PROPOSITION 3, If ip:X-*Y
is harmonic and not ± holomorphic, then the zeros of 3,. ip and a
de.tip are isolated and of strictly positive index. Proof. Taking an isothermal chart centered at a zero x of Si&p, we obtain from (5) Bw/dz = Az" +o(|z|"') with m >0; thus d,.r,ip has a zero of index m at x. Similarly for the zeros of do. 1 (p. Proof of the theorem. Assume that
one of the right members of (2) is negative,
contradicting Proposition 3. REFERENCES 1. H. BEHNKE and F. SOMMEB: Theorie der ano/jiiicfitn Funkiionen finer kompiexen Vaiandtrikhen. Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1955). 2. S. S. CHFRN and S. I. GOLDBERG: On the volume-decreasing properly of a class of real harmonic mappings. Am. 3. Morn. 97 (1975), 133-147.
3. J. EELLS and J. H. SAMPSON: Harmonic mappings of Riemannian manifolds. Am. J. Math. 86 (1964), 109-160. 4. F. HIRZEBRUCH: Topological Methods in Algebraic Geometry. Third EdiLion. Springer (1966), 5. M. GBPSTGNIIADEB and H. E. RAUCH: On extremal quasi-conformal mappings—1, Proc. natn. Acad. Sci- 40
(1954).
808-812.
and K. NOMIZU: Foundations of differential geometry—II. lnterscience (1969). 7 H. KneSEit: Die klcinste Bedeckungzah] imnwrhalb einer (Classe von Flachenabbitdungen. Moth. Ann 103 (1930). 347-358. 8. L . LEUATRE: Applications harmonique! de surfaces. C.S., Paris. 280 (1975), Ser. A. 897-899. 9. J . MtLttOR: On the existence of a connection with curvature zero, Comm. Math Httv. 32 (1958). 215—223¬ 10. R. T. SMITH: Harmonic mappings of spheres. Thesis, Warwick duly 1972), 6. S KOBAYASW
2fiS
I. EELLS AND I. C WOOD
11. N. SmwtOD: Topology oj Fibre Bundles. Princeton (]9J1). 12. J . C. WOOD: Harmonic mappings between surfaces. Thesis, Warwick (June 1974). 13. J. C. WOOD: Singularities of harmonic mappings, lo appear. 14. J, C. WOOD: Harmonic maps and complex analysis, Proc. Summer Course in Complex Analysis. Trieste (1975). 15. H-H Wu: The equidistribution theory of holomorphic curves. Ann. Math. Stud (1970). University of Warwick. Brighton Polytechnic.
79
The Surfaces of Delaunay James Eells
1. Background
2. Ron I elk's of a Conic
In 1841 the astronomer/mathematician C Delaunay isolated a certain class of surfaces in Euclidean space, representations of which he described explicitly Ml in an appendix lo that paper M. Strum characterized Delaunay's surfaces vanationally; indeed, as the solutions to an iso peri metric problem in the calculus of variations. That in turn revealed how those surfaces make their appearance in gas dynamics; soap bubbles and stems of plants provide simple examples. See Chapter V of the marvellous book |81 by D'Arcy Thompson for an essay on the occurrence and properties of such surfaces in nature.
The first step is to derive the equations describing the trace of a focus F of a nondegenerate conic f as ^ rolls along a straight line in a plane (Perhaps these derivations were better known a century agol) We examine various cases separately f IS A PARABOLA:
More than 130 years later E. Calabi pointed out to me thai the solutions to a certain pendulum problem of R. T, Smith \7] could be interpreted via the Gauss maps of Delaunay's surfaces [2}. And Eells and Lemaire 141 found that the Gauss map of one of those surfaces produces a solution lo an existence problem in algebraic/differential topology. The purpose of this article is lo retrace those steps in an expository manner—as a revised version of [2)
James Eells
MATHEMATICAL INTtl.LICENCtfl VOL 1. NO I *> I9R7 Spiin^Tr-V-rl^ UVK/ York 5 3
80 Here A is the vertex of f The line PK is tangent to ( at the point K. The following properties are elementary: (1) Correspondingly marked angles are equal; (2) FP is orthogonal lo PK. Thus we obtain FA = FP cos Z AFP = FP cos C PFK. Now we change our viewpoint and Ihink of the tangent line PK as the axis—the i-axis—along which the parabola t rolls. We denote the ordinate of F by y; and observe that cos I . PFK =
m
as
where a denotes the angle made by the tangent with the x-axis. Thus setting c = FA, we obtain the differentia] equation
V
ds
Thai equation describes the shape of a flexible inextensible free-hanging cable—thereby explaining its name. In that context we can obtain the equation of the catenary as the Euler-Lagrange equation of the potential energy integral 1
2
V +• y' dx.
subject to variations holding fixed the length integral PI £Vl +
dx = L.
Indeed, from general principles we are asked to find A real number a and an extremal of the integral
l(y)
- Q,
c - y
(2.1)
- e cosh xle.
~
describes the rate of change of abscissa of F with respect to arc length s; i.e., •m_
V = 2 (<*" +
=
j'W
1
+
v"
+
"yVl + y'
:
dx
lis Euler-Lagrange equation has first integral y -
/(I + ay)- . /
r;
, for (J
i
R.
The equation of the catenary is derived from this, choosing suitable normalizations. The curvature of ( is measured by the amount of turning of its tangent That is expressed by the Gauss map of f into the unit circle, given by x —• where dx c COS o. = — = - , ds y
V l + y"
-
Its solution is the catenary
A*
54 THE MATHEMATICAL IATGITGENCEB VOL. *. NO. 1.11?
81 The Gauss map of the roulette of the parabola is injective onto an open semicircle
The locus (of either focus) will be called the unduiary:
f !S AN ELLIPSE:
Its Gauss map is given by x —* a . where y
1
- —
f/V
y + (-> COS a - + " It maps i onto a closed arc of the unit circle. There are two limiting cases, which are perhaps best handled separately: When b -• a the unduiary degenerates to a straight line, the locus of the centre of a circle rolling on a line. And where b —• 0 the unduiary becomes a semicircle centred on the .r-axis.
1 O F'
j
t IS AN HYPERBOLA:
Here F and F are Ihe foci of t j the 0 is its centre. The line PKP' is tangent to i at K. Letting n and IF denote the lengths of the semi-axes of f , we obtain the following properties: (1) TM + F K = 2a > 0; (2) the pedal equation PF • FT 6]);
y\\i' O
;
= b (see [°. Ch.VHI
/
(3) the normal to the locus of F passes through K P^-
Again using PK as i-axis. S= - sin i. FKP = cos L FTP - ^~
In analogy with the Case of the ellipse, we have 4=-su\i-
(1) FK - P K = 2o > 0;
F'KP- = cos L FTP' = ~-.
2
(2) Pf - P T = b . Thus we obtain the following differential equation for the locus of F, given as a firsi integral of an EulerLagrange equation:
From these we derive •
i
to
z
u ± lay
2
y y' = b , so Ihat
f
- 2«y| +
By analyzing all cases and taking a & b. we obtain 1
2
2
b = 0.
(2.3)
The loci of the two foci fit together to form the curve which we shall call the nodary:
V = 0.
V t 2 « y ^ + b = 0.
§j
ai)
The solutions to that differential equation can be given explicitly in terms of elliptic functions; see [J], [5, pp. 416-416].
82 lis Gauss map x -* a, is governed by !
y "& cos a, = ~ Thus f - y'fy = ± e , where b is another real paramlay eter. Consequently, The Gauss map has no extreme points, and direct verification shows that it is surjective. A roulette of a conic is a catenary, unduiary. nodary, ' Vl + jr 5 a straight line parallel to the i-axis, or a semicircle centred on the i-axis. But 2
1 _ dx V l + y' ~ ds 2
3. Surfaces of Revolution with Constant Mean Curvature
so the extrema] equation for our variational problem coincides with that of the roulette of the ellipse or hyperbola ((2.2) and (2.3)).
Rotating each of the roulettes about its axis of rolling produces five types of surfaces in Euclidean 3-space GAUSS MAPS: In an analogy with the case of oriented R . called the surfaces of Delaunay: the catenoids, iwducurves in the plane (§2), we associate to any oriented loids, nodoids, the tight circular cylinders, and the spheres. surface M immetsed in R its Gauss map y : M -» S (the unit 2-sphere centred at the origin in R ), defined by assigning to each point x E M the positive unit VARIATIONAL CHARACTERIZATION: We formu- vector orthogonal to the oriented tangent plane to M late the following isoperimetric principle, for the un- at x. Its differential dy[x) can be interpreted as a symduloid and nodoid (only minor technical changes metric bilinear form on the tangent space TJA. Its eibeing required for the other cases). genvalues k,,X are well determined up to order. The Consider graphs in R of non-negative functions symmetric functions K = k K and H = (\i + are called the curvature of M and the wean curvature of yM*rj,*il— R(^O) the mmersltm at x, respectively. For instance, with fixed volume of revolution (1) the cylinder has K = 0 and constant mean curvature H * 0; 1/(3,) = « (''y'dx: (2) the sphere of radius R has constant curvature K •B = IfR and constant mean curvature H = 1/R; (3) the catenoid has variable curvature K and mean and extremize their lateral area curvature H = 0; (4,5) the unduloid and nodoid have variable curvaAii/) = 2K f 'y ds ture K and constant mean curvature H # 0. 3
3
3
2
J
x
t
2
s
2
2
holding the endpoints fixed. By general principles of constraint (under the heading of Lagrange's method of multipliers for isoperimetric problems [5}), we are led to the Euler-Lagrange equation associated with the integral
F(y) =
»jV
d l+
3
,2
+ 2oyVl + y )dx.
Here o is a convenient real parameter- Its integrand f does not involve x explicitly, so we obtain a first integral from 5*
THE MATHEMATICAL
3
DELAUNAY'S THEOREM: The complete immersed surfaces of revolution in R with constant mean curvature are precisely those obtained by rotating about their axes the roulettes of the conies.
ds)
>o = n ['V
These five surfaces were recognized by Plateau, using soap film experiments. Say that a surface of constant mean curvature in R is complete it it is not part of a larger such surface. From Sturm's variational characterization, we obtain
rtmlXsaKm VOL.
I. NO.
I. iw
Thus Delaunay's surfaces are those surfaces of revolution M in R which are maintained in equilibrium by the pressure of a field of force which acts everywhere orthogonally to M. 3
83 4. Harmonic Gauss Maps
Again, that has an explicit solution in terms of elliptic functions. Furthermore, the associated map y : R* - » S An easy yet vitally important theorem of Ruh-Vilms is doubly periodic, factoring through the torus T <* R IZ [6] states that: to produce a map y : T—- 5. as desired. Incidentally, the integrand of E is A surface M immersed in R* has cuiistanl mean curvature if and only ifils Causs map -y:M->S satisfies the equation ®dyp = a' + y s i n V = \dyfy, Calabi made the beautiful observation that Smith's where A denotes the Laplacian of M with conformal maps y : T —> S are the Gauss maps of certain surfaces of structure induced from that of R', and vertical bars the Delaunay [2j. Euclidean norm at each point. Indeed, (4.1) is the condition for harmonicity of the map y |3j—and is the Euler- A HARMONIC REPRESENTATIVE IN A HOMOLagrange equation associated to the energy (or action) TOPY CLASS: If we represent the torus T in the form integral T = R/nZ x Rj2nZ and use polar coordinates (r,0) on the unit sphere S, then a map from the cylinder to S of the form Uii - U\\dy¥. r •= »(r), » = y M :
1
£ is a conformal invariant of M. SMITH'S MECHANICS: Motivated by certain mechanical analogies, R. T. Smith |7J found solutions to equation (4.1) as maps -y : R —- S, as follows: Think of points of R parametrized by angles (d>,B), and use spherical coordinates on the sphere 5: !
!
e
r
subject to the conditions u>(0) = 0, 4>(n) = n is harmonic if and only iffl>satisfies the pendulum equation (4.3) with A = 1. There are such solutions. Indeed [4], the GAUSS map of the nodoid induces a harmonic map of a Klein bottle y : K -* S. Furf'imnore, that map is not deformable to a cunslitrrl map. Hopf's classification theorem insures that the maps K —* S are partitioned by homotopy into just two classes. Thus the harmonic map y represents the nontrivial class.
2
References ] C- Delaunay, Snr
la surface de revolution dont la courbure moyenne est constants, f. Math, pures et appl. Ser. 1 (6)
If we restrict our attention lo maps y of the special form ,B
(*,fl| = fe sin n(c|>), cos o(o»), then the equation of harmonicity becomes the pendulum equation o" =
j
sin
7. It. T. Smith, Harmonic mappings of spheres. University of
2a.
(4.3)
We assume that a(0) = ir/2, so that the solution oscillates symmetrically about Ttt2. Now a first integral of (4.3) is given by lc - A cos
(1841), 309-320. With a note appended by M. Sturm. 2. J; Eells. On the surfaces of Delaunay and their GAUSS maps. Proc. IV Int. Colloq. Diff. Geo. Santiago de Composltla [1978), 97-116. 3. J. Eells and L. Lemaire. A report on Itarmoiuc maps. Bull. London Math. Soc. 10 (1978), 1-68, 4. J, Eells and L. Lemaire, On the construction of harmonic and holomorphic maps between surfaces. Math. Ann. 252 (1980), 27- 52. 5. A. R. Forsyth, Calculus of variations. Cambridge (1927). 6. E. A. Ruh and ]. Vilms, The tension field of the Gauss map. Trans. Amer. Math Soc. 149 (1970), 569- 573.
2
Warwick Thesis (1972). 0. D'A. W. Thompson, Growth and form. Cambridge (1917). 9. C. Zwikker, TIic advanced geometry of plane curves and their applications. Dover (1963). Mathematics Institute University of Warwick Coventry CV4 7AL England THE MATHEMATICAL
LNIELllCENCEH VOL
9.
NO- ].
IW
57
2
84
B a
manuscripts math. 28, 101 - 108 (1979)
*
2i^£«fi?«i!
mathematica ©ti»Sprjn :cf-Vtrlaiil >''9 1
t
MINIMAL GRAPHS James
Eells
D e d i c a t e d t o Hans Lewy and C h a r l e s B . M o r r e y , J r .
E l e m e n t a r y p r o p e r t i e s of harmonic maps between Riemannian m a n i f o l d s a r e i n t e r p r e t e d v i a t h e i r g r a p h s , viewed as n o n p a r a m e t r i c m i n i m a l s u b m a n i f o l d s (Proposition 1). Then examples a r e g i v e n of n o n p a r a m e t r i c submanifolds of compact R i e m a n n i a n m a n i f o l d s which cannot be deformed - through n o n p a r a m e t r i c submanifolds - to n o n p a r a m e t r i c m i n i m a l s u b m a n i f o l d s ( P r o p o s i t i o n s 2 and 4 ) .
L e t <J>:M and d e f i n e
N be a smooth map between
$:M -+ M * N by $ ( x )
a smooth embedding
= (x,rj>(x)).
of M onto a c l o s e d
M >= N, which we c a l l
the graph
of_ the map ttj •
( N , h ) when we w i s h to
Riemannian c o n s i d e r a t i o n s .
Then $
submanifold
Riemannian m e t r i c s g , h on M,N, we w r i t e form $ : ( M , g ) *
manifolds, is of Given
the map i n
the
emphasise
The graph r
of 4
is
W endowed w i t h the R i e m a n n i a n m e t r i c induced from
that
of
an
(M g N,g x h ) .
e x t r e m a l of
Then
the volume
i s minimal ( i . e . , functional
101
is
EELLS
V(*)
f
=
m
x
1
|A »*( i|dx ...dx
m
M f A [A * Cx)| M p>0 P
=
h e r e m •= dim H , and /^<J> ( x )
is
A
of (1) is
2
f t
J
the d i f f e r e n t i a l
cj> ( x ) )
if
the p -
t h
and o n l y
4: (M,$ (g x h)) -»- (M * N,g x h ) an e x t r e m a l of
E(»)
the energy
=
k\
f f l
dxl...dx
;
exterior if
power
the map
harmonic; i . e . ,
functional
| $ ( x ) | ^ e T ^ ^ g x h ) d x ^ . - d x 'm ' ( x j | - / d e t T (,g x hj d x ' . . . a : 2
A
m
A
' •!
See
[3,
If $ = I x
p.119].
I : M •* M d e n o t e s the so
i d e n t i t y map,
( I x
then thus
we have *
PROPOSITION 1. projections, if
(g
x
h)
-
g + c#> h .
L e t t i n g I T ' , T T " denote the
the map $ i n
the c o m p o s i t i o n s
$'
(1)
indicated
harmonic i f
and o n l y
and 3>" a r e both h a r m o n i c :
102
86 EELLS
(M,g + * h)
(M,g)«f-
(M *
This follows
EXAMPLE 1.
N
,g
x h)
MN,h).
from the c o n s i d e r a t i o n s
[9,6].
m
R , w i t h induced E u c l i d e a n
( N , h ) be
the form $ ( x )
n
R .
= (x,ffi(x))
Then a map $:U -+ R is
nonparametric immersion. k($)
p.133].
L e t (M,g) be an open s u b s e t U of
the E u c l i d e a n space metric; let
in [3,
m + n
of
traditionally called a
Set
= g + ij>*h = $*(g
x h);
thus f o r 1 £ i , j < m we have
where
-
1
B^/Sx .
The t e n s i o n f i e l d s
E u l e r - L a g r a n g e o p e r a t o r s of
the a s s o c i a t e d
f u n c t i o n a l , whose v a n i s h i n g i s h a r m o n i c i t y ; see
l e f t members of the m Z - V ( / d e t lcC
the
energy
the c o n d i t i o n
[ l , 3 ] ) T(4>'), !"($") a r e
by the (2')
(i.e.,
for
represented
systems
1 J
(*))
=
0 ( 1 < j <_ m ) ;
L
(2")
m t i,j=l
(/det ax
1J
k ( » k (
1
=
0.
3
These a r e c l e a r l y e q u i v a l e n t system:
103
to the m i n i m a l s u r f a c e
87
EELLS
m Z -21-1 rJX
(3')
(/det
k(*) k
1 J
($)
=
0 (1 < j
<. m ) ;
1
m E
(3")
=
EXAMPLE 2 .
0.
L e t (M,g) be a r b i t r a r y ,
and take N = R .
Then T ( * ' ) = 0 a u t o m a t i c a l l y i f T<4") = 0; and the c o n d i t i o n T ( $ " ) = 0 means t h a t harmonic f u n c t i o n . our
notation
(M,k($)) + R i s
a
(As we have a l r e a d y e m p h a s i s e d ,
indicates
t h a t $ i s harmonic w i t h
respect
to t h e R i e m a n n i a n m e t r i c k(<J>) on M; i n p a r t i c u l a r , may
depend on
. m Z
In local
it
charts
J
k <•)*..-
=
0,
and
T a k i n g (M,g) to be R , then T(3>) = 0 m . Z ( * . / / l + |d$| ) = 0. i = l 3x
if
2
(4) The
i f and o n l y
equation
form.
(4)
is
quasilinear e l l i p t i c ,
I t i s not uniformly e l l i p t i c ,
the maximum to minimum e i g e n v a l u e s of
the c o e f f i c i e n t s
be
bounded.
of
S.jjJ,
is
104
of
in
divergence
f o r the r a t i o of the m a t r i x ( a 2
1 + |dr)| ,
)
w h i c h may not
EELLS
EXAMPLE 3 .
5
L e t (M,g) and ( N , h ) be K a h i e r
and tf>:M •* N a holomorphic map. n Kahier metric for follows
that *
the complex
manifolds,
Then g + $ h i s a s t r u c t u r e of M.
the i d e n t i t y map
= I
: (M,g + 4> h) *
(M,g) and
*" - <> f : (M,g + 4 h) -
(N,h)
a r e b o t h h a r m o n i c , b e i n g holomorphic maps of manifolds
It
[3, p . 1 1 8 ] .
Kahier
Consequently,
* : (M,g +0 h) * (M x N,g x h) i s h a r m o n i c ; i . e . , any holomorphic map cj>:M -*- N between 11
Kahier manifolds
Let
has m i n i m a l graph T .
(M,g) be the 2 - s p h e r e
S or the r e a l
p l a n e P , w i t h any Riemannian m e t r i c g.
Then f o r
conformal map $iM •* ( N , h ) the m e t r i c g +
to g.
*" = i s harmonic i f case,
is
(M,g)
and
(M,g +
and o n l y i f
(N,h)
(|>:(M,g) •* ( N , h ) i s ;
cf i s w e a k l y c o n f o r m a l , Proposition
and
in
that
is^ a_ m i n i m a l g r a p h .
1 g i v e s an i n t e r p r e t a t i o n of m i n i m a l
graphs i n terms of harmonic maps; g e n e r a l l y ,
in
c o n t e x t the n o t i o n
of h a r m o n i c i t y depends on a
Riemannian m e t r i c
(on the domain) w h i c h i n v o l v e s
map i t s e l f .
any
The i d e n t i t y map
(M,g +
i s harmonic [ 3 , p . 1 2 6 ] ;
projective
An e x c e p t i o n
a r i s e s i n the c a s e
105
of
that
the
89 6
EELLS
surfaces:
We c a n i n t e r p r e t a r e s u l t
follows:
For
graph
in
keeping
any m e t r i c s g , h
(P * S , g * h )
the same n o t a t i o n
PROPOSITION 2.
is_ h o r i z o n t a l .
[2]
Furthermore,
we have
of
of
the
unique
such maps, t h e n rJ> cannot o
to £i map w i t h m i n i m a l graph
A generalisation
as
o_n P , S e v e r v m i n i m a l
I f $ ;P •* S r e p r e s e n t s
n o n t r i v i a l homotopy c l a s s be deformed
in [2,7]
i n P x S.
a theorem of Lawson [5^
gives
PROPOSITION 3 .
E v e r y m i n i m a l graph of p x S
3
is
horizontal.
Here S
d e n o t e s the E u c l i d e a n n - s p h e r e .
contrast, mal
it
graphs
By way of
i s w e l l known t h a t t h e r e a r e many m i n i -
in P x s
n
f o r n >_ 4, which a r e not
horizontal.
We can i n t e r p r e t the Proposition
2,
theorem i n
[4]
as we d i d
t a k i n g i n t o a c c o u n t Example 3:
106
in
90
EELLS
Let
( T , g ) be the
PROPOSITION 4.
2-torus,
7
w i t h any R i e m a n n i a n m e t r i c
The graph r
o f a harmonic map
4>: ( T , g ) •+ ( S , h ) of_ s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e submanifold
g.
degree i s _a K a h i e r
(hence m i n i m a l ) of T x S .
No map
degree 1 _is_ homotopic to a. map
w i t h m i n i m a l graph i n T * S.
Finally, be adapted
let
to the
us note t h a t
can
c a s e of harmonic s e c t i o n s $ o f
Riemannian f i b r e b u n d l e s map
these constructions
TT:W •* M, g e n e r a l i s i n g
the
(1).
REFERENCES [l]
E E L L S , J . and L . LEMAIRE, A r e p o r t on harmonic maps. B u l l . London Math. S o c . 10, 1-68 (1978)
[2|
E E L L S , J . and L . LEMAIRE, On the c o n s t r u c t i o n of harmonic and holomorphic maps between s u r f a c e s . (To appear )
[3]
E E L L S , J . and J . H . SAMPSON, Harmonic mappings of Riemannian m a n i f o l d s . Am. J . Math. 86, 109-160 (1964)
[4]
E E L L S , J . and J . C . WOOD, R e s t r i c t i o n s on harmonic maps of s u r f a c e s . Topology 15, 263-266 (1976)
107
91 EELLS
[5]
LAWSON, H . B . , Complete m i n i m a l Ann. Math. 9 2 , 335-374 (1970)
[6]
LAWSON, H. B . and R . OSSERMAN, N o n - e x i s t e n c e , n o n - u n i q u e n e s s and i r r e g u l a r i t y of s o l u t i o n s to the m i n i m a l s u r f a c e s y s t e m . A c t a Math. 139, 1-17 ( 1 9 7 7 )
[7]
LEMAIRE, L . , On the e x i s t e n c e of harmonic U n i v e r s i t y of Warwick T h e s i s (1977)
[8]
OSSERMAN, R . , M i n i m a l v a r i e t i e s . Math. S o c . 7 5 , 1092-1120 (1969)
[9]
OSSERMAN, R . , A s u r v e y of minimal s u r f a c e s . Van N o s t r a n d Math. S t u d i e s 25 (1969)
[10]
surfaces in
Bull.
3
S .
maps.
Amer.
OSSERMAN, R . , Some p r o p e r t i e s of s o l u t i o n s to the minimal s u r f a c e system for a r b i t r a r y codimension. P r o c . Symp. Pure Math. Amer. Math. Soc. 15, 283-291 (1970)
James E e l l s Mathematics I n s t i t u t e U n i v e r s i t y of Warwick Coventry, England
(Received January 2o,
108
1979)
92
Mathematische AlUISiCII
Math. Ann. 252, 27-52 (1980)
© by Spnnger-Vcilag 1980
On the Construction of Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces* 1
J. Eells and L. Lemaire
2
1 Department of Mathematics, University of Warwick, Coventry C V 4 7AL, U K 2 Department de Mathematiqtte, Universite Libre de Bruxelles, Boulevard du Triomphe, B-1050 Bruxelles, Belgique
Introduction (A) Let M and N be compact surfaces without boundary; and a homotopy class of maps of M into N. We shail denote by & the integer which is the common value of the twisted degree of any map <^eJff; and the index of the subgroup (b^n^M)) of TT.IJV). The following result is an immediate consequence of recent work of Edmonds [14]; see Theorem 1.3 below: x
Theorem 1. Suppose that M and N are orientable, and that Jff is a homotopy class with d 4=0. For any complex structure on N there is a complex structure on M relative to which JV contains a holomorphic representative if and only if \d .\>j , or 4>^:%^Mj-tn^N) is injective. x
x
x
(B) Ifg and /tare Riemannian metrics on Mand N, thenamap<^:M-*N [which we will often write tp:(M,g)-*(N,h) for emphasis] is harmonic if the divergence of its differential vanishes everywhere; see Sect. 2 for details. We let S,T,P,K denote the sphere, torus, projective plane, Klein bottle, respectively. In the present paper we will establish Theorem 2. The surfaces M and N admit Riemannian metrics relative to which 3nf contains a harmonic representative, except 1) when Af= T, N = S, and \dj = \; 2) when M — T,N — P, and y? is the class obtained from that in I) by composition with the covering map n:S~*P; 3) when M = P, N = S, and jj? is the nontrivial class; 4) when M — P,N = P, and j>f is the class obtained from that in 3) by composition with n; 5) perhaps when N — P and for certain classes of nonorientable maps M->P with mod 2 degree = 0. (That case does not arise. See [28, §5.8J.) * The main results in this paper were presented at the Mathematische Arbeitstagung (Universitat Bonn) in June 1978
0025-5831/80/0252/0027/S05.20
93 J. Eells and L . Lemaire
We know of no case where 5| provides a new exception. Of course, Theorem 2 bears on the fundamental Problem [15]. Given Riemannian metrics g, h on M, N, when does harmonic map
contain a
It is known [see Corollary (2.7) below] that the answer is always, provided + S orP; this implies the corresponding statement in Theorem 2. Of course, it also follows as an application of the main existence theorem in [15]. There will be several other circumstances in which we can provide a solution to the problem; for instance, if M and N are spheres or projective planes; see Sect. 3 below. The cases 1) and 2) were established in [17]. Cases 3) and 4) were found by the authors - and first appeared in [27]; see Sect. 3 below. The case N = S was treated in [29] for M orientable; and is Theorem 4.2 for M non orientable. (C) Our presentation is organised as follows: In Sect. 1 we recall the homotopy classification of maps between surfaces, and formulate Edmonds' theorem characterising those homotopy classes which contain branched immersions. Section 2 summarises the properties required of harmonic maps of surfaces. In Sect. 3 we obtain a complete description of harmonic maps between spheres and projective planes, with arbitrary Riemannian metrics. Section 4 is devoted to the existence part of Theorem 2, when IV=S; and Sect. 5 to that when N = P. In Sect. 6 we give examples of harmonic maps M-*S which arise as Gauss maps of immersions of M in R with constant mean curvature, especially in relationship to the examples of Lawson. Section 7 develops some related constructions for such immersions in IR ; we aiso adapt a geometric interpretation (due to Calabi) as Gauss maps of an analytical construction (due to Smith) of harmonic maps 4
3
T->S. K These examples have served as primary motivation and inspiration to us, in our efforts to understand Theorem 2. Finally, in Sect. 8 we discuss briefly several related constructions of harmonic maps of surfaces into certain higher dimensional homogeneous spaces. I . Homotopy Classification of Maps Between Surfaces Any compact connected surface A/{ + S) without boundary is differentiably the connected sum ( # ) of projective planes and tori; accordingly, its fundamental group 7E,(M) is presented by generators {a^ g ; „ (b ,c ) ^ ^ subject to the single relation {J7 a?} (njlbjcpj cJ '))= 1. If M is orientable, it is a sum of p tori, where p = genus(M); thus there are no u/s in the presentation of 7t,(M). If M is nonorientable, it admits different representations; for instance, T#P=P#P#P; we choose to realise M as a sum ofk projective planes, k is called the genus of M, and %(M) is generated by ( a ^ , < subject to the relation TIaf=l. For any two compact connected smooth surfaces M, N without boundary, consider the space ^(M,N) of maps M-*N; these can be of any class C" for Ogn g
l
(
ifii
J
J
l
j
m
94 Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
29
goo, unless otherwise specified. The components of ^{M,N) are the homotopy classes, the set of which we denote by [Af, JV]. The following enumeration [in (A)] and classification [in (B)] results on homotopy classes are well known: (A) Enumeration of \_M,N~} Case N + S or P [21]. Two homomorphisms 0, 0':7t (M)--7r (JV) are said to be conjugate (8^6') if there is an element ben,(N) such that 6'{a) = b~ 6(a)b for all aen^M). Any continuous map M-*N induces a conjugacy class of homomorphisms from rc (M) to n^N). When N + S or P, these conjugacy classes are canonically identified with the components of '4{M, N): 1
1
l
1
mm
(1.1)
*
HoMnJMU^N))/^)).
Case N = S [8]. Then the assignment tp-'d^, ( = the degree or degree mod2 of
[M,S~\^H\M;1)=%
if hi is orientable, — 2l if Af is nonorientable. 2
CaserV = P [ 8 , 34]. Then 1
Hom(7r, (Af), n^PM ») = Hom(7r, (Af), E ) = H (Af; J, ). 2
2
Using that identification we say that a homomorphism 0 ;it {M)-*7i (P) is oriented if 0 = Wj(A/) (=the first Stiefel-Whitney class of Af); and nonorientable otherwise. Geometrically, 0 is oriented if the maps d> which induce it are oriented; i.e., if when X is an orientation-preserving (-reversing) loop of Af, then d>°k is an orientationpreserving (-reversing) loop of N. Equivalently, let S'p-^P denote the orientation sheaf of P; then 0 is oriented iff Q~ 3~ = 3~ . The classification of [Al, P] is thus partitioned into two subclasses depending on the orientability of the induced homomorphisms. Note that being given 0 is equivalent to being given a homotopy class M->P" for any n £ 3 ; and we are asked to classify those elements 0 of [Af, P"] which have image in [Af, P] under the inclusion map P-»P". l
l
1
f
M
a) 0 is oriented. Then 6 is represented by infinitely many homotopy classes: these are parametrised by the absolute value of the twisted degree d. It takes the values t/s0mod2 if Af is orientable; t/s genus (Af) mod 2 if M is nonorientable. b) 0 Is nonorientable. Then 0 is represented either by 1 or by 2 homotopy classes in [Af, P ] , as follows: If the degree mod2 d (ff)=l, then we have 1 class (equivalently, Sq 0 + 0, as Epstein has noted); rfj(0) = O, then we have 2 classes (equivalently, Sq' 0 = 0); these being parametrised by H (M,8-'3r ) = z. . 1
2
2
p
2
(B) Classification of\M,N'\. The only case not covered in (A) is that of b) with d 6 = 0. We must determine how to distinguish those two cases. 2
95 30
J . Eells and L . Lemaire
One method is as follows [4]: Given two maps ^ d> rel. x iff d E Image a , where a is a homomorphism 0
0
1
M i
2
a
0
i
0
M i
9
9
(in the notation of [4]) defined via the boundary operator in the homotopy exact sequence of the fibration ^(Af, P J - ^ A f ' ^ P ) defined by restriction. In the case under consideration, we know [34] that there are two classes so that image a = 2ZC? _ and the homotopy classes relative to x representing 8 are in bijective correspondence with coker a = Z . Olum's description [34, 33, 35] of the classes determining 8 is as follows: Subdivide Af into a simplicial complex with ordered vertices (x,|, with x as first vertex. For each i choose a path U from x to x and for any ordered 1-simplex x Xj define y^^K^M^a) by VfajX^V]'. Construct the simplicial map g :M-
9
0
fl
2
0
j
0
f
t
iOI
g
0
a
111
(x x )-»y (
y
if
0 !
(x,.X;HP< >
6(y{x x )) = e i
if
]
0
OiyiXfX^e,.
1
Here P " is a projective line in P representing e EiiA.P,y ); e is the neutral element of n {P,y^\. If (XfXjXj is an ordered 2-simplex and i
0
0
Y
111
,L
then define a to be a homeomorphism onto P —P . Otherwise, map Then g represents 8, and d (g ) — d {8). Finally, define the map
{x x x )-'P '.
9
e
2
e
i
j
y
2
p-.n^y^HHM^-'^,,)
by
/f(e-,) = obstmction to deforming g to g with x traversing P description of /J(e,): Assign - 1 to (XjXjX,) if B
e
0
l n
[Alternative
9(v(x,x ))- =%(x xJ); ;
ei
;
and 0 otherwise. I.e., /?(e,) = 0if an even number of — 1 are assigned; and /!(£,)= 1 if an odd number of —1 are assigned.] Then j3 is a crossed homomorphism pVw') = $w) + w<./?(*"), 2
l
where «denotes the action ofn,(P,y )on H (M ;8~ 3~ ); consequently, it partitions H^M-J-'Pp), the orbit of h being 0
C(fc) = { ^ ) + ^ ^ : w
e f r i
P
(P,y )}. 0
Thus C(0)={0,/J( )}, e(l)={l,P(e )+e ol}. ei
Case / ^ H O .
T
h
e
n
1
1
C(0)={0}, C(I)={1}. This is the case deg g = 0. 2
9
31
Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
Case /J(e,)=l. Then C(0)= (0,1} = C{1). This is the case deg g„ = l . 2
(C) Asurjective map d>:M->N between surfaces is a branched cover if it is finite-toone and open. A branched cover is an oriented map, in the sense that it preserves the I ' Stiefel-Whitney classes: >*w (/V)=w (M). s
J
9
1
1
The following is well known; if N is not S or P and d>\M->N is a branched cover, then its induced homomorphism tp^ :n: (M)-'n (N) is injective iff 0 is unramified; i.e., is a covering map. l
l
Indeed, the sufficiency is standard in the theory of covering spaces. For the necessity, let 9:N-*N be the unramified covering associated to the subgroup 4>^n,(M)) of jt,(rV> Then
is injective.
Here \d^\ is the absolute degree. As the notation suggests, jd^j is the absolute value of the usual degree when Af and N are orientable. It has been shown recently [6] that if Af and A/are orientable with genus (Af)^d •genus (AOfor some integer
x
+
1
1
2. Harmonic Maps of Surfaces Background references: see [15, 16]. If
m m = \ m f ^
where the vertical bars indicate the Hilbert-Schmidt norm of the linear map (the differential of
(2.2) Bm=Smm&-
)
97 32
J. Eells and L . Lemaire
A smooth map 4>e^{M, N) is harmonic if it is an extremal of E. Thus it satisfies the Euler-Lagrange equation (2-3)
T<0)=O,
where x(cp) = Trace Vdd, is the tension of <j>. Suppose that M and N are surfaces. Then we can introduce isothermal charts relative to the Riemannian metrics g and h. Calling z, z (resp. w, w) the complex variable and its conjugate in these charts, we can write g = Q (z)dzdz, h = G {w)dwdw. Then 2
(2.4)
£(0)=,|rj»[|wj * M
2
1
3
+ |vv | ]^i, 5
In particular, we note that i / M and N are orientable and tp :M-*. N is holomorphic or antiholomorphic relative to the complex structures determined by g and h, then
4>\ ) Z
C
Re(z") + (|z|'); 0
c l m ^ + oflzl*); oi\z\*) for
aS3;
see [19] for further details. If both M and N are surfaces, then a branched immersion is a branched covering. // cp is harmonic and its Jacobian J ^ S O on M, then
98
Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
(2.7) Corollary. If
K (N)=0 2
(i.e., JV* S or P) then every homotopy class Jt?e [Af, jV]
has a harmonic representative
cp:(M,g)-*(N,h).
3. Maps Between Spheres and Projective Planes When Af and N are spheres or projective planes, equipped with any given Riemannian metrics, we have a complete description of all harmonic maps.
(A) Maps from Sphere to Sphere
First we recall the description of the harmonic maps in question [28, 42]:
3
or
If these quotients are irreducible and a, #0, bj+0, then the degree of such a map is + maxfr, s). All degrees are thereby represented.
(B) Maps from Projective Plane to Sphere
There are two homotopy classes of maps from P to S, one of which contains the constant maps. (3.3) Proposition. Any harmonic map d>:(P,g)~-(S,h) is constant. In particular, the nontrivial homotopy class does not contain a harmonic representative.
Proof. Let tp be harmonic. Composition of
gives a
(S,p*g)
(P,0)-*> (S,h) 3
2
The degree of d> is 0, for its induced homomorphism tp*:H (S)->/f (S) factors through H (P)=Z . Since any harmonic map {S,p*g)-*(S,h) has the form (3.1) or (3.2), we conclude that
2
99 J. Eells and L. Lemaire (C) Maps from Sphere to Projective Plane Any map tp :S-»P lifts to a map 0: (S,p*h) (S,g)
(P,h)-
The twisted degree of
1
1
(S,p*g) 4 {S,p*h) (P,g)
$
(P,h).
Since rb is harmonic it is conformal, together with
wi-lzy^-Wz))- . If
&,=(-!)'5,
[We do not have to consider maps given by (3.2), for they project on the same class of 0's.] All classes are represented harmonically (for instance, by the maps w — z ); and we obtain an explicit description of every harmonic map. The second family, associated to the zero morphism $:n (P)-*n {P), contains two homotopy classes, including the trivial one. All maps in these classes lift to maps from P to .9, and any such harmonic map is constant [as shown in (3.3)]. In summary: 4
1
l
(3.5) Proposition. There are two families of homotopy classes of maps from (P,g) to (P, h). The first contains an infinite number of classes, all of which contain harmonic
100 Harmonic and Hoiomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
35
representatives. These are given by (3.1), subject to condition (3.4). The second contains two homotopy classes: The trivial class, in which every harmonic map is constant; and a class which contains no harmonic representative. 4. Maps of a Surface to a Sphere When M is not a sphere or a projective plane, we have only partial existence results; therefore we shall concentrate on the following question [28]: Given two compact surfaces Atf and N and a homotopy class 3^ of maps from M to N, does contain a map which can be rendered harmonic by a suitable choice of Riemannian metrics on M and N ? In other words, do there exist metrics on M and N such that #f contains a map harmonic with respect to these metrics? (A) Maps from an Orientable Surface to the Sphere For completeness, we first recall the known results concerning the harmonic maps from an orientable surface to the sphere; let p — genusM. The homotopy classes of maps M-»S are parametrised by the degree d of the maps, and it is shown in [17] that for \d\ ^p any harmonic map of degree d is + holomorphic. Such maps exist in the following cases: if \d\^p+l; if \d\ = p and M is nonhyperelliptic (i.e., the associated Riemann surface is not a holomorphic 2-sheeted branched covering of S); if \d\ = p is even. On the other hand, when \d\ = p is odd and M is hyperelliptic, there is no + holomorphic map of degree d from M to S; and hence no harmonic map in these classes. For the remaining degrees, it is known [26,28,29] that if Af is a surface of genus p and \d\ g p — 1, there exist metrics on M and S such that there is a harmonic non + holomorphic map from M to S of degree d. This map is not an absolute minimum of the energy in the class. These results provide the following answer to the rendering problem [28]: (4.1) Proposition. Let Mbea surface ofgenus p and d an integer. There exist metrics g and honM and S and a harmonic map d> :(M,g)^{S,h) of degree d in all cases except when p— \ and \d\ — 1. (B) Maps from a Nonorientable Surface to the Sphere In contrast to (3.3): (4.2) Theorem. Let Mbea nonorientable surface of genus k S: 2 and S a sphere. There exist metrics on M and S such that the (unique) nontrivial homotopy class of maps from MtoS contains a harmonic representative. As above, this map is not an absolute minimum of the energy in that class. Proof. The difTerentiable manifold M is a connected sum of k projective planes; we shall represent it as a connected sum M of hemispheres, quotiented by the identification of antipodal points on each boundary circle L,(t—1,k).
101 36
J . Eells and L. Lemaire
We equip Af with a metric inducing a smooth metric on Af such that Af appears as a surface in R symmetric with respect to k + 1 planes, one of them orthogonal to the k others; and these forming equal angles. We call („,/;,...,/,, the lines of intersection of these planes with Af and S (s = 0, ...,fe) the symmetry with respect to / (see Fig. 1, where / is in the plane of the paper). On S we choose the metric of a surface of revolution symmetric with respect to its equator (for example, the Euclidean metric). We call the equator /'„ and choose k meridians forming equal angles, put in correspondence with the l and called t' (see Fig. 1). We denote by S' the symmetry with respect to Finally, we associate to each boundary circle L , a point P, on S as indicated in Fig. 1. 3
s
s
0
3
s
s
We note that if k is even and k>2 it would be sufficient for the construction below to impose symmetry with respect to k/2+1 lines (see Fig. 2 for k = 4):
Fig. 1
Adapting the method of [28, Sect. 11], we shall use the direct method of the calculus of variations to find a harmonic map of degree one 0:Af-»S, equivariant with respect to the groups of symmetries, and mapping L , on P,. Then we shall check that 4> induces a C -harmonic map from Af to S. i) Following [32, Sect. 9.4], we say that a measurable map
2
J
102 Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
37
ii) Let us say that a map 0 :M-»S satisfying rpS = S' <j>(s = 0 k) is equivariant. Consider a minimising sequence {0 } for the energy functional E in the class of equivariant L^-maps sending L , to P,. (An Z?i-map has an L trace on L,.) First of all, we observe that we can replace {0 } by another minimising sequence {4>' } in the same class, where 0J has the additional property of mapping (almost everywhere) a region of M bounded by three lines of symmetry and a piece of L , in the corresponding region of S (see Fig. 3): s
s
f
1
r
r
ill
Fig. 3
For that it suffices to associate to each
r
r
2
2
r
v
2
r
2
£(0)£liminfE(0;) [32, Lemmas 9.4.16 and-9.4.15]. iv) In each region, 0 minimises E with respect to the Dirichlet problem induced by its trace on the boundary. By a fundamental theorem of Morrey ([31] or [32, Theorem 9.4.2]) 0 is C™ in the interior of the region. v) We observe that the method of [31, 32] enables us to prove that 0 is continuous on each line of symmetry, away from the intersections with the other lines or the Z.,'s. Indeed, for two sufficiently nearby points on such a line, the proof will involve only discs centred on the image of the line in an exponential chart; and the fact that 0 minimises E in such a disc amongst the equivariant maps is sufficient for us to proceed with the proof (see [28, Sect. 12] for details).
103 38
J. Eells and L. Lemaire
On each line L„ $ is continuous by construction, for it has constant image P,. By the boundary statement of [32, Theorem 9.4.2], 4> ' therefore continuous everywhere, except perhaps at the intersections of two lines of symmetry or one line of symmetry and one L , . vi) By identification of the antipodal points on the L,'s, $ induces a map d>:M-*S with the same continuity properties. In a small enough disc centred at a point on a line of symmetry, we know by construction that
t
r
0
,p (x,y)=-rp°(-x y). !
Conversely, a map d> satisfying these relations also satisfies d>"(0,y)—0; i.e., <j> is obtained from a map 0of a neighbourhood of a point of L , to S such that 0(Z,,) - P,. A minimum of E for the given Dirichlet problem is therefore a minimum of E in the class of equivariant maps for these new relations. vii) Using this, we now show that (except at the intersection points) <j> is weakly harmonic; i.e., d> satisfies x(4>) — 0 in a weak sense. If D is an open neighbourhood of a point such that D does not contain a point of intersection,
X + ^X
X-£r*X
=X,+X ; 2
P
thus SfX =X and S X =-X . Then V E(d>) = 0, because X , induces a variation in the class of equivariant maps and
l
2
2
Xi
= F_ E(0)--f £(0), K2
X)
hence V E{d>) = 0. viii) Except perhaps at the points of intersection of the symmetry lines, tb's weakly harmonic and continuous. Therefore it is C " [41]. By a theorem [37] on removable singularities,
s
104
Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
39
5. Maps of a Surface to a Projective Plane (A) Maps from an Orientable Surface M-*P Consider first the zero morphism din^Mj-m^P). It is oriented, and therefore is induced from an infinite number of homotopy classes. Any map 0 inducing 8 lifts to a map 0: S
V M
r
1 P
The degree of 0 is twice that of 0, and the nonnegative even numbers parametrise the possible homotopy classes. (The classes of maps 0 of degrees k and - k project to the same class with absolute value of the degree 2k.) All statements made about the maps from M to S in Sect. 4 A apply therefore to the maps from M to P (the notion of oriented holomorphy being replaced by that of conformality). Suppose now that 8 is a nonoriented morphism. It is induced by two homotopy classes, and Theorem (2.6) shows that one of them contains a harmonic map, which minimises E in the union of the two. Unfortunately, that general statement does not indicate which class is represented. Independently we have the (5.1) Proposition. One of the classes associated to 8 can be represented by a harmonic map whose image is a geodesic. Proof. The morphism 8 is characterised by specifying the images of the generators {b„c^ of it,(Af) in B (P) = Z = {* ,e }. i
2
0
I
We can define a morphism from jr (Af) to 2 by mapping the generators sent to e onto 0 and those sent to e onto 1. The relation nbfifc 'c " = 1 is preserved by that map, which therefore induces a homomorphism. Its composition with the morphism from 2 to 2 , defined by (0, l)-*(e , t ) is the given homomorphism 8. To the morphism 7t,(M)-*Z is associated a homotopy class of maps from M to S , which contains a harmonic representative. Its composition with a map from S' to a non con tract ible geodesic of P is harmonic and induces the homomorphism 8. We do not know whether this geodesic minimises E in the union of the two classes associated to 8. It is not excluded that the answer to that question would depend on the metric of M. Concerning the other homotopy class associated to 0, we have results only for certain morphisms. For instance, if 8 is defined by mapping every b to e and every c, toe,,a construction using symmetries as in Sect. 4B yields a harmonic map for certain metrics, as indicated on Fig. 4. (Here the genus is 3 and the boundary circle L, is identified with I*.) An equivariant map is built from the surface with boundary to S mapping the boundary circle L,(L*) onto P,(P*). It factors as a map 0 from M to P, inducing the given morphism. One verifies easily that the separation element of a suitably chosen map homotopic to 0 and a harmonic map inducing the same morphism and whose image is ageodesic.is the generator of n (P). (l.B) implies then that these two maps are not homotopic (free and based homotopy coincide in this case). t
0
1
l
;
e
3
0
1
t
2
0
105 40
J. Eells and L. Lemaire
Fig. 4
L',
This construction is valid for any genus M = p>0. When studying the rendering problem, we can compose the harmonic map
(
t
r
t
L
Fig. 5
Variants for these constructions allow us to treat other homomorphisms, but do not seem to lead to a complete solution to the rendering problem in all classes in [M,P]. (B) Maps from a Nonorientable Surface M->P: Oriented Homomorphisms Let M b e a nonorientable surface of genus k^2 and 8:n (M)->n lP) the oriented morphism. To 8 is associated an infinite number of homotopy classes of maps M-*P, parametrised by the absolute value of the twisted degree, which takes all even (resp., odd) values if k is even (resp., odd). l
1
(5.2) Proposition. For any homotopy class of maps from M to P determining the oriented morphism, there exist metrics on M and P such that the class contains a harmonic map. Except when the degree is 1 the metric on P can be prescribed.
41
Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
Proof. First of all, we treat the case of degrees > 1 and prove that for all k and d 2: 2 there is a d-sheeted branched covering of P by a surface of genus k. Since the projection map of any branched covering is oriented [14, Theorem 5:2], these maps are in the prescribed homotopy classes. For a given metric on P, they can be made conformal (hence hannonic) by the choice of suitable conformal structures on M. We shall have to use two different constructions, according to the parities of k and d. i) d — 2a^2. We consider two copies of (P,h) and a—\ copies of S, viewed as Riemannian universal covering of {P,h}. We glue these copies together along s segments, s^a. Thus we cut the two first copies along the same segment (i.e., two segments such that one is the copy of the other) and join them crosswise along the slit. Then we adjoin the other copies, one at a time, using different segments; and attach the last one along the s - a +1 remaining segments. This defines a branched covering 0 : M — P which can be lifted to a branched covering of the oriented two sheeted coverings: M
s
£•
I M 4
I P.
0 is a d-sheeted branched covering of S by M , obtained by joining copies of S along 2s segments. Its ramification index f is hence 4s. Using Hurwitz' formula X(M) + r = 2a (S) X
(where x denotes the Euler characteristic) we obtain the genus of M, denoted by y(M)
k:2-k
= x(M)= ^ y ^ = 2 o - 2 s ; k=2s + 2-2a. Therefore k takes all positive
even values. Conversely, for any such k we obtain any positive value of a, and hence represent all classes associated to a positive degree (necessarily even). ii) d = 2a +1 £ 3. We repeat the construction, this time using a copies of S and one copy of P; for the genus of the branched covering we obtain k = 2s +1 - 2a. Thus k takes all positive odd values; and for any such k we get all positive values of a and represent all classes associated to a (necessarily) odd degree S 3. iii) Degree 0. k must be even and the class of maps of degree 0 can be represented by a harmonic map whose image is a closed geodesic. Indeed, let [a^ , be a set of generators of T C ( M ) , subject to the relation l=
t
1
naf=i We define a homomorphism from 7i,(M) to Z by mapping half the a,'s to 1 and the others to - 1 . Therefore the relation is preserved. The composition of this morphism with that from Z to Z defined by (0, l)-»(e , f.^) maps all a,'s to e,, and hence is oriented. Thus we ohtain the harmonic map as in the proof of Proposition (5.1). 2
0
iv) Degree i. (This case cannot be treated as in ii), for a branched covering of degree 1 would be a diffeomorphism.)
107 42
J. Eells and L. Lemaire
The two-sheeted orientable covering M of M is of even genus p = k — 1. As in Fig. 6 let us equip M with a metric symmetric with respect to three planes and S with a metric possessing the same symmetries (for instance the Euclidean metric):
Kg. 6
Using the same technique as in Sect. 4B, it was shown in [26, 28] that there is a harmonic map of degree one from M to S, equivariant with respect to the groups of symmetries. The line I, is sent onto l\ and the equivariance with respect to S S and S' S' implies that antipodal points of /, are mapped to antipodal points of f By identification of antipodal points, we obtain a harmonic map from a surface to P. Because this surface contains a Moebius strip, it is nonorientable and hence of genus k. 0
0
2
2
v
(C) Maps from a Nonorientable Surface A/->P: Nonoriented homomorphisms Let M be a nonorientable surface whose fundamental group is generated by =!
*•
(5.3) Proposition. Let 8 be a nonoriented homomorphism from JI,(M) to 7r,(P), mapping an odd number of the a,'s toe . There is precisely one homotopy class whose maps induce 8, and it contains a harmonic map. i
This is an immediate consequence of Theorem (1.1). Note that these maps do not factor through the circle as geodesies, because they must be of degree d = 1. When 8 maps an even number of a 's on e „ it is induced by two distinct homotopy classes. As in Sect. 3C we see that one of these classes contains a harmonic map minimising E in the union of the two classes; one of the classes contains a harmonic map whose image is a geodesic. 2
f
In the special case of the zero homomorphism, the associated maps lift to maps from M to S; and thus for certain metrics, both classes are represented, by Theorem (4-2). For certain other morphisms, constructions as in Sect. 5A give representatives in both classes; but again this does not seem to lead to a complete solution to the rendering problem.
43
Hannonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
(D) Example. Maps from the Klein bottle K-*P The fundamental group of K is generated by the elements a and a , subject to the relation a\a\ — 1. There are four homomorphisms from n^M) to n,(P), determined by the images of a and a . We have the following existence properties for these homomorphisms, thus solving the rendering problem: i
1
a
a
e
2
2
e
i) ( i, )~*( o> or- There are two homotopy classes associated with this morphism, composed of maps which lift to S. One of them contains the constant maps (which are harmonic). The other contains a harmonic map for certain metrics, deduced from a remark of Sect. 5C or from the explicit construction of Sect. 7B below. 2
(ii) (a a )^>(e ,e )or (e e ). There is only one homotopy class associated to each of these morphisms, and it always contains harmonic map by Proposition (5.3). v
2
0
l
v
0
We remark that if P carries the Euclidean metric (induced from its universal cover Sj, then such a map can be built explicitly (see Sect. 7B below). iii) (a ,a )-*(e ,e ). To this oriented morphism is associated an infinite number of homotopy classes of maps K->P; these are parametrised by the absolute value of the degree, taking only even values. l
2
1
1
For ti=0, the homotopy class can always be represented by a geodesic. For
6. Examples of Harmonic Gauss Maps Certain homotopy classes in [M, S] can be rendered harmonic as Gauss maps, as follows: The Grassmannian of oriented planes through the origin in R is the homogeneous space a
G ° = SO(4)/SO(2)xSO(2). 2
As a projective variety it is the complex quadric. It can also be described [12] as 2
4
G%_ = {xeA ]t\ :W\ 2
1
= l
and
OIACC-O}. Z
4
The de Rham-Hodge star operator on 2-vectors is an involution (setting A = A R )
109 44
J . Eells and L . Lemaire
with eigenspaces A corresponding to the eigenvalues ± 1 ; the oriented plane ae G° is sent by * into its oriented orlhogonal complement *a. Thus we have the orthogonal direct sum decomposition A=A ®A_ into 3-dimensional Euclidean subspaces. If we decompose each a€G^_ into the indicated form a = a +a_, then ot eS , the unit spheres in A . Thus we have a diffeomorphism ft :Gj{ - > S x S_ defined by fi(a) = (a ,a_). If ( e ) - is an orthonormal base for fR and we set e — e Ae then (e + e )/\/2, {e,i + e )f^2, (e + e )/}/2 is an orthonormal base for A . Let us note in passing that ±
2
+
+
2
±
±
±
2
+
4
+
k
p
;
12
1Sl
S4
i4
tJ
2A
ia
2i
±
f i ° * ° f c ( a , a _ ) = ( « , — ct_). _1
+
+
In fact, h is an isometric biholomorphic equivalence between these two EinsteinKahler symmetric spaces; see [24; Chap. XI, Exercise 10.6]. We note also that S x S_ is naturally minimally embedded in the sphere S( |/2) of radius \/2 in A; thus we find G° embedded in A with constant mean curvature. +
2
4
(6.1) Let M be a closed oriented surface embedded in 1R , with Gaussmapy .M — G\ . If c eH (G° _ \7L) are the images under h* of the generators in H {S ;Z), then 2
1
2
±
2
(6.2)
±
y*( )[Af> (Af)/2, C±
2
where x(M) is the Euler characteristic of M. That is a theorem of Blaschke [7]; we sketch the proof given in [12]: Let CBH (G% ; Z ) be the Chern class of the canonical circle bundle over G\ . Then c = c + c_. If y is the Gauss tangent map, then *°y is the Gauss normal map, and y*c and (* °y)*c are the Euler classes of the tangent and normal bundles of M in fR . Then ;t(M) = (y*c) [ M ] = ( y * c ) [M]+(y*c_) [A/]. On the other hand, since Af is embedded in IR , 0=(*°y)*c[A/] = ( j * c ) [ M ] - ( y * c _ ) [A/]. The equation (6.1) follows. Now we apply that result to certain of Lawson's surfaces [25]. For every pair of integers m^k^l he has constructed an oriented surface gLj of gen us mk with Euler characteristic j,) = 2(l -mk), minimally embedded in S . If y is the composition 2
2
2
+
4
t
4
+
3
±
where n denotes the indicated projection, then (6.1) shows that deg(y )= 1 -mk. A theorem of Ruh and Vilms [36] asserts that a submanifold isometricaily immersed in IR" has constant mean curvature iff its Gauss map is harmonic. Since t; is minimally embedded in S , it has constant mean curvature in IR , so y is a harmonic map. The composition rz °h is totally geodesic, so the composition map y 'i , -*S is harmonic. In summar,y/or every closed orientable surface Af of genus M — p, the homotopy class in [M, S] of degree 1 — p can be rendered harmonic via the above procedure involving Gauss maps. Of course, we could have started with the polar map d>- :Af->S of the immersion 0:M-*S , described in [25, Sect. 10] as follows: Set d> =d>, and let ±
±
mk
i
4
±
±
n k
3
3
+
110 Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Belween Surfaces
45
a e T ( M ) be the unit 2-vector of the orientation of T [M): then define 0_(x)eS_ by 0_(x) = *(0(x)Aa(T^ (jW)). If tp is minimal, then d>_ is a harmonic map with a finite number of branch points. Let us note that if we treat 0 <x)eIR , then y(x) = 0 ( x ) A
Hxy
U)
4
±
+
2
m k
3
4
4
m
k
i
2
4
2
a 2
tl
^ 4 , 2 ~ (S+ xS_)/(i),
where
i(a , «_) = ( — a , a _ ) . +
+
Remark. For a simply connected complete minimally immersed surface M in IR which is not a hyperplane, Chern [11] has shown that the maps y :M-*S are — holomorphic and have dense images. ±
7. Surfaces of Constant Mean Curvature in IR
4
±
3
(A) Gauss Maps of Branched Immersions 3
{7.1} Proposition. Let M be a Riemann surface, and 0 : M - - I R a branched immersion. Then d> has constant mean curvature iff its Gauss map y:Af-»S is harmonic. That is established in general in [36] for nonsingular immersions. In the present case it is an elementary matter to verify that the Gauss map y is continuous on all M, and (2.6) and (2.10) of [23] imply that it is C and hence smooth; indeed, dy the seond fundamental form of
(7.2) Harm(M,S)/Iso(S) denote the set of equivalence classes of harmonic maps M-*S, two % y being equivalent iff there is an orientation-preserving isometry a of S such that y — a"y. Similarly, let 3
(7.3) Brim^M.^l/IsolIR ) denote the set of equivalence classes of branched immersions with constant mean curvature H. Thus we have the canonical map (7.4)
3
3
Brim^M, R )/Iso(IR )-» Harm(M, S)/Iso(S).
It follows from [1] that this is injective, provided tf#0; that restriction is well known to be necessary, for the catenoid and the helicoid have the same Gauss map. Let us also observe that by Sampson's unique continuation theorem [38], if there is an open UcM and ceSO(3) such that =a
y\v ''y\v< then y =ff->yon all M.
Ill 46
J . Eells and L. Lemaire
Suppose now that M is complete and simply connected; and H is a positive number. Then with every harmonic map y\M-*S there is an explicitly given branched immersion
2
_1
tb(z) = 2Re Ay o s
+ c,
z
where 2
A=
3
(A\A ,A ) 1
2
. -(1-y )
i(l + y )
-2y
nti+wv
\m+MT
H(i+m
We note that we have the conformality condition i
2
1
1
1
(A ) +(A ) -r(A )
2
= Q;
and 1
2
2
2
3
2
2
2
2
K | + | ^ | + | ^ | = 2//7 (l + | y | ) ; and furthermore, d> satisfies the mean curvature equation ,,_/4Rey
4Imy
U+Irr"
2
2(\y\ -l)\ i+lvl
2
/
on all M. In particular, (7.6) Proposition [23]. For any Riemann surface M, H>0, and harmonic map y.M-rS, we have a canonically defined branched immersion d>:M-*IR with constant mean curvature H. 3
Here M denotes the universal cover of M. 3
Example. If
1
3
WM ^IR . r
These are the associated surfaces of <j>. Presumably this is just the case of y associated with d>.
±
:M-*S
(B) The Gauss Map of Delaunay's Nodoid
In his Thesis [40] Smith constructed analytically certain harmonic maps from certain tori T-rS; these have degree 0, although some of them are surjective. In fact, suppose that T is a flat rectangular torus, expressed as R/flZ x R / 2 J I Z ;
±
112 Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
and (S,/i ) the Euclidean sphere of radius I. Let (x,y)e[0,a] x [0,2;r] be Euclidean coordinates on T, and (r,8) polar coordinates on S. A map d>:T--S of the form r =
(7.7)
1
dx
= sin $ cos*.
For a>2n an oscillatory movement of the pendulum of period a induces a harmonic map of degree 0 covering a band around the equator of S. For a suitable choice of coordinates the lines x = 0 and x = a/2 are fold lines of the map. For any value of a, a revolutive movement of the pendulum of period a/2 induces a twice surjective harmonic map of degree 0 from T to S, sending the collapse lines x = 0 and x = a/2 on the poles of S. Calabi has indicated to us that Smith's maps can be interpreted as the Gauss maps of the unduloid and the nodoid of Delaunay [13], see [16, Sect. 11.7] and [44]. The Klein bottle K has the representation as a connected sum of two projective planes; or as a cylinder with antipodal points of its boundary circles identified. Figure 7 is meant to indicate how this representation is related to the usual one:
Fig. 7
A map of the cylinder to S of the form r = $(x), 8 = y subject to the conditions
Using the method of Sect. 4, we see that a nonorientable surface M of even genus can be realised as a 3-sheeted branched covering of K. A suitable choice of conformal structure on M makes the projection conformal; and composition with the hannonic map K—S just constructed produces another harmonic map of degree 1 mod 2 from a surface of even genus to S. To obtain the explicit representation of the harmonic maps K—P announced in Sect. 5Dii), where P is given its Euclidean metric, we choose again Euclidean coordinates (x,y) on K and polar coordinates (r,6j on S:
113 4N
J. Eells and L. Lemaire
Ji X
Fig. 8
a A map tp from the rectangle of Fig, 8 to S of the form dt(x, y) = (4>(x), y) is harmonic iff * satisfies (7.7). A solution exists satisfying the conditions *(0) = 0,
8. On Harmonic Maps of Surfaces into Various Homogeneous Spaces Consider harmonic maps (b of S or P into the Euclidean n-sphere S", with n £ 3. In that case tp is a minimal branched immersion by (2.7). 3
(8.1) Every harmonic map tp.S—S factors through a totally geodesic map of an equator into S ; thus their classification reduces to that given in Sect. 3A. See Almgren [2]. In general, we have Calabi's theorem [9, 10; see also 3] that if S—*S ~ '(r)C R" is a minimal branched immersion and if the image lies in no hyperpiane o/R". then n is odd. 3
n
3
(8.2) Every harmonic map
3
s
5
2
i
immerses S (\j 3) isometrically into S ; and factors to produce ihe desired minimal embedding of P into S . Since every map tp-S--P" lifts to one into S", their consideration reduces to that of the previous case. 4
(8.3) We have Calabi's and Barbosa's theorem [3] '.Assigning the direct ix i^to a map
2k
114 Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
49
harmonic maps
lk
2
(8.4) Every harmonic map
3
is either constant
or factors
through a totally
3
Indeed, lift to S %
S
3
i I p ^ p • 3
now 4> factors, and hence so does
0*0. The maps [25, Theorem 3] (for any positive integers r, s) <£„(*,, x ) = (cosrxj cosxj, sinrx, cosx , cossxjsinxj, sinsx sinx ) are minimal isometric immersions of T=IR/27t2 x R/2JTZ into S . The m a p ^ , defines the Clifford torus T - » S ; (1,1) is the only pair giving an embedding. The map
2
1
2
3
3
s
3
In general [22], if
We obtain minimal immersions of T and K into P" by composition. (8.6) On the other hand, we recall a theorem of Frankel [ 1 8 ] : The inclusion map i of a minimal embedding of a compact hypersurface induces an epimorphism i :jtj(Af)-»jij(W);
M into a space N with Ricci
N>0
#
Therefore (8.7) Any minimal embedding never lifts into S .
into P
3
is homotopically
non trivial;
in particular, it
3
By Corollary (2.7) we obtain: (8.8) The homotopy classes of maps [ M , P"] = H {M; Z )f representatives, since n (P")—0 for n £ 3 . L
2
or
"=
3
a
l
1
have
harmonic
2
As specific examples, Lawson [25] has shown that every orientable M can be minimally embedded in P"(n^3), provided genus M > 0 . Furthermore, every minimal immersion of a compact surface into P" represents a nontrivial homotopy class. (8.9)
Suppose genus M S I ;
then there is no stable minimal immersion of M into S or 3
P . That is a consequence of a theorem of Schoen and Yau [39], which asserts the 3
115
50
J. Eells and L . Lemaire
same conclusion for range any compact oriented 3-manifold with positive scalar curvature. Before considering examples of harmonic maps M->W, let us note the r+ 1
+ 1
(8.10) Lemma. The natural embedding IR C C " given by (x , ...,x,)-<-(x ,..., x,, 0,..., 0) induces a totally real, totally geodesic embedding n: P -*IP" .furthermore n is homotopically nontrivial. 0
0
r
A real vector subspace W of a complex vector space (V,J) is totally real if J{ W)r\ W—0. A real submanifold of a complex manifold is said to be totally real if its tangent spaces are all totally real. Proof. The first assertions are immediate. To prove the final statement it suffices to consider the case*; ;P-»IP . Note that the tangent vector bundle of IP restricted toP decomposes: 2
2
r ( P % = T(P)e-/7'fP). Then n ^ T n ^ n - ' m ^(TW
2
, ) + wJTiPVvw^jnPV
+ WziJTiP))
2
= w (T(P)) = w (r
2
where 1 denotes the generator of H (P, Z). n
(8.11) Proposition. The composition n°d>:M-*P harmonic. If n = 2,
with any harmonic map
deg (0) = deg b7°
2
(8.12) There are many nonconstant harmonic maps S->rP". They are all minimal branched immersions; they are not ail ± holomorphic, but are necessarily strongly pseudoholomorphic, in the sense of Wood. Holomorphic examples are provided by rational functions. Note also that for each n2:2 the composition s i r P is a nonconstant harmonic map of degree 0; in particular, it is not + holomorphic. (8.13) For 2 we have [P, P"] = Z . Lemma (8.10) shows that the nontrivial class is harmonically represented by ff :P-*P ->IP". 2
2
l
l
3
(8.14) The natural embedding S {l/]/3) x S\\l]/l) X S {lfl/3>) in C is a minimal 3-torus in the unit sphere S . The natural action of C(l) on S induces a minimal embedding of a flat torus in P , which is totally real, but not totally geodesic [30]: 5
s
2
S ( V J/3) x S*(l/|/3) x S\XI]/% J
4 r
-» S
5
1" 4
2
• IP .
116
Harmonic and Holomorphic Maps Between Surfaces
51
The left-hand vertical arrow represents a trivial [/(l)-bundle, so 0 is a null homotopic map.
Acknowledgements. During the preparation of this paper the authors enjoyed the hospitality of the Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientiftques. The first-named (J.E.I thanks the Universite de Paris VI, where he wasProfesseur d'Echange. The secon d-named (L.L.) is Charge de recherches au Fonds National Beige de la Recherche Scientifique.
References t. Abe, K., Erbacher, J . : Isometric immersions with the same Gauss map. Math. Ann. 215, 197-201 (1975) 2. Almgren, F.J.: Some interior regularity theorems for minimal surfaces and an extension of Bernstein's theorem. Ann. of Math. 84, 277-292 (1966) 3. Barbosa, J . : O n minimal immersions of S in S Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 210, 75-106 (1975) 4. Barcus, W.D., Barratt, M.G. . O n the homotopy classification of the extensions of a fixed map. Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 88, 57-74 (1953) 5. Berger, M.: Lectures on geodesies in Riemannian geometry. Lecture Notes No. 33, Bombay: Tata Institute 1965 6. Berstein, I , Edmonds, A.L.: Classification of surface maps modulo self-equivalences. Am. Math. Soc Notices '78T-G42 (1978) 7. Blaschke. W.: Sulla geometria differenziaie delle superftcie S nello spazio euclideo S . Ann. Mat. Pura Appl. 28, 205-209 (1949) 8. Brouwer, L . E . J , : Aufzahlung der Abbildungsklassen endlichfach zusammenhangender Flachen. Math. Ann. 82, 280-286 (1921) 9. Calabi, E . : Minimal immersions of surfaces in Euclidean spheres. J. Differential Geometry 1,111¬ 125 (1967] 10. Calabi, E , : Quelques applications de 1'analyse complexe aux surfaces d'aire minima. In: Topics in Complex Manifolds, pp. 59-81 Montreal: University Press 1967 11. Chern, S.S.; Minimal surfaces in an Euclidean space of N dimensions. Diff. and Comb. Top, A symposium in honor of Marston Morse, pp. 187-198. Princeton: Princeton University Press 1965 12. Chern, S.S., Spanier, E . H . : A theorem on orientable surfaces in four-dimensional space. Comm. Math. Helv. 25, 205-209 (1951) 13. Delaunay, G ; Sur la surface de revolution dont la courbure moyenne est constante. With a note appended by M. Sturm. J. Math. Pures Appl. Ser 1, 309-320 (1841) 14. Edmonds, A . L . : Deformations of maps to branched coverings in dimension two. Ann. of Math. 110, 113-125 (1979) 15. Eells, J., Sampson, J.H.: Harmonic mappings of Riemannian manifolds. Am. J . Math. 86, 109-160 (1964) 16. Eells, J., Lemaire, L . : A report on harmonic maps. Bull. London Math. Soc. 10, 1-68, (1978) 17. Eells, J., Wood, J.C.: Restrictions on harmonic maps of surfaces. Topology 15, 263-266 (1976) 18. Frankel, T.: On the fundamental group of a compact minimal submanifold. Ann. of Math. 83,68-73 (1966) 19. Gulliver, R.D., Osserman, R., Royden, H . L . : A theory of branched immersions of surfaces. Am. J. Math. 95 750-812(1973) 20. Heins, M.: Interior mapping of an orientable surface into S . Proc. Am. Math. Soc. 2,951-952 (1951) 21. Hopf, H.: Beitragezur Klassifizierung der Flachen abbil dun gen. J. Reine Angew. Math. 165,225-236 (1931) 22 Kenmotsu. K - On minimal immersions of S into S". J . Math. Soc. Japan 28, 182-191 (1976) 23. Kenmotsu, K . : Weierstrass formula for surfaces of prescribed mean curvature. Math. Ann. 245. 89¬ 99 (1979) 24. Kobayashi, S., Nomizu, K . : Foundations of differential geometry. I. I i . New York: tnterscience 1963, 1969 2
2m
2
1
2
4
117 52
25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44.
J. Eells and L . Lemaire
Lawson, H.B.: Complete minimal surfaces in S?. Ann. of Math. 92. 335-374 (1970) Lemaire. L . : Applications harmoniques de surfaces. C.R. Acad, Sci. Paris A280, 897-899 (1975) Lemaire, L . : On the existence of harmonic maps. Thesis, Warwick University 1977 Lemaire, L . : Applications harmoniques de surfaces riemanniennes. J. Differential Geometry 13, 51-78 (1978) Lemaire, L . : Harmonic nonholomorphic maps from a surface to a sphere. Proc. Am. Math. Soc. 71, 299-304 (1978) Ludden, G.D., Okumura, M., Yano, K . : A totally real surface in CP that is not totally geodesic. Proc, Am. Math. Soc. 53. 186-190 (1975) Morrey, C.B.: The problem of Plateau on a Riemannian manifold. Ann. of Math. 49, 807-851 (1948) Morrey, C.B.: Multiple integrals in the calculus of variations. Grundlehren Band 130. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer 1966 Olum. P.: On mappings into spaces in which homotopy groups vanish. Ann. or Math. 57, 561-574 (1953) Olum, P.: Mappings of manifolds and the notion of degree, Ann. of Math. 58, 458^180 (1953) Olum, P.: Cocycle formulas for homotopy classification; maps into projective and lens spaces. Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 103, 30-44 (1962) Ruh, E.A., Vilms, 3.: The tension field of the Gauss map. Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 149,569-573 (1970) Sacks, J., Uhlenbeck, K . : The existence of minimal immersions of the two-sphere. Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 83, 1033-1036 (1977) Sampson, J.H.: Some properties and applications of harmonic mappings. Ann. Ecole Norm. Sup. XI, 211-228(1978) Schoen, R., Yau, S.T.: Existence of incompressible minimal surfaces and the topology of three manifolds with non-negative scalar curvature. Ann. of Math. 110. 127-142 (1979) Smith, R.T.: Harmonic mappings of spheres. Thesis, Warwick University 1972 Tomi, F . : Eineinfacher Beweiseines Regularitatssatzes fur schwache Losungen gewisser elliptlscher Systeme. Math. Z. 112, 214-21B (1969) Wood, J . C . : Singularities of harmonic maps and applications of the Gauss-Bonnet formula. Am. J. Math. 99. 1329-1344 (1977) Wood, J.C.: Holomorptncity of certain harmonic maps from a surface to complex projective nspace. J. London Math. Soc. 20, 137-142 (1979) Eells, J . : On the surfaces of Delaunay and their Gauss maps. IV. Coloq. Inter, Geom. Dif.(in honour of E , Vidal), Santiago de Compostella, pp. 97-116(1979)
Received April 15, 1980
2
118
Proc. Indian A c i d . Sci. (Math. Sci.), Vol. 90, Number i , February 1981, pp. 33-45. ©
Printed in India.
Deformations of metrics and associated harmonic maps By J E E L L S and L L E M A I R E
1, Introduction In this paper wo establish a theorem ((3.1) below) concerning the dependence of harmonic maps on the Riemannian metrics used to define them. Our method is an application of tbe implicit function theorem in suitable manifolds of maps, In the case of a compact range of negative curvature, that result was obtained by Sampson [24], using derivative estimates for harmonic maps given in [10], Another special case has been found by Schoen-Yau [26], and applied by them to obtain theorem (6.3) below. Their proof is entirely different; it is based on a Dirichlet growth theorem of Morrey ([21] lemma 9.4.18) and thus is restricted to maps with two-dimensional domains. In some cases the geometry of the problem introduces irrelevant degeneracy. For instance, that can happen if M or JV" has a nontrivial group of isometries— or if the harmonic map under consideration factorises through a geodesic. More technical results concerning some of these cases are given in § 5. As applications, we offer proofs of two theorems on harmonic diffcomorphisms of surfaces, due to Sampson [24] and Schoen-Yau [26]. We are much indebted to Professor Sampson for many stimulating conversations, as well as for making available to us (many years ago) a preliminary version of his manuscript [24]— a primary source of motivation for the present work.
2.
Basic properties
(2.1) L e i M and TV be smooth (i.e. C") finite dimensional manifolds, with M compact. Unless otherwise specified, we suppose M and N without boundary. We denote by T(M) and T* (Af) the tangent and cotangent vector bundles of M. We are primarily interested in smooth Riemannian metrics on M and N and their associated smooth harmonic maps. However, our main tool is the implicit During the preparation of this paper the authors enjoyed the hospitality of the Institut des Bautes Etudes Scientifiques. The first-named thanks the Universite de Paris V I , where he was Professeur d'Echange. The second-named is Charge de recherches au FoDds National Beige de fa Recherche Scicntifique.
33 P. ( A ) - 3
119 34
J Eells and L Lemaire
function theorem, which in its simplest form applies to maps between Banach spaces. Therefore, at times we shall restrict ourselves to finite orders of differentiability. Furthermore, we need to solve certain linear elliptic equations, and we choose to do so in Schauder's context; see for instance [12]. Therefore, for r an integer such that 2 ^ r <, oo and 0 < a < 1, we shall consider the space C ° (Af, /V) of maps whose differentials of orders <, r satisly an -H61der condition. With the associated topology, C (Af, N) is a smooth manifold modelled on a Banach space, provided r < co. Let lVr • and N " be the spaces of C'-^-Riemannian metrics on M and N. These are open subseU of the Frechet spaces C ( O T* (M)) and C * ( O T* (A/)). If r < DO, M « is an open subset of a Banach space, since M is compact. +
Q
+
+
a
r +
+
+
8
a
2
r+
+,+
, + , +
(2.2) Given (g,A) e M ' » x N « and a C'+^-map tp: M -» N(sometimes written tp : (A/, g) -# (N, ft)), its energy is denned by £ ( p ) = £ ( > ; g , A ) = i J \d
Then
E :C
+ 3 + a
( A / , TV) - * ( > 0) is a C'+^Munction.
(2.3) The extremals of E are called harmonic maps, and satisfy the Euler-Lagrange equation [10] Tp - 0; i.e.
V , £(¥>)= -
S (r
= 0
r + S +
+ a
for all variations v e T ( C * (A/, TV)) of y . T is an element of ( C ' (Af, N)) called the tension field of p. At times we shall have to specify the metrics used and write T ^ = T iff 8> ft)- 1° I l coordinate systems {x } and {«°} on Af and Af, is represented by v
9
Q c a
1
where * T and T are the Christoffel symbols of g and ft. Given a harmonic map p : M -*. N, the second variation of its energy is described by the Hessian y*E(tp), characterised by the identity [20], [29] V * £ ( p ) (u, * ) = / < JfV(x% • where —
is the ./at-ofti operator along
w(x))dx, represented in the notations of ([9], §3
by - J (v) = Trace 9
v + Trace R" {df, v) dp,
where Rf is tbe curvature tensor of (N, ft), /p is a linear elliptic operator. Integration by parts, using the symmetry properties of R", shows that ; {JyV, w) dx= that Jq> is self-adjoint.
J {v J w)dx; t
9
i.e.,
120
Deformations of metrics and harmonic maps
35
2
The condition that S? E(p) is non-degenerate is that K e r / ^ ^ O (or equivalently Ker Jy = 0). The first equality implies that tp is an isolated critical point of E and the second that +e
+
J
T:C
r + a + a
1+
(M, N) X M'+ » X N ' +
t + l +
° -» T(C'
4a
(M, N)).
We work in a neighbourhood of a C'-harmonic map ip„ : (M, g ) -»(N, A ) where g and h are C, but in order to remain in the context of Banach spaces, we take r < co and restrict attention to an exponential chart U of C (Af, N) centred at p and such that the image of every map in the chart is contained in a fixed compact domain K of N. By the canonical identification through exp^ (using the metric ft ), we have 0
a
0
B
r + a - i o
a
0
T(C'+« {M, AO) |
u
= U x r
f t
( C ' « (A/, Af)).
We can represent r by its composition with the projection on the second factor, which we still denote by t : r+1
f
+1+
(2.5) * : U x M + ° X N'- * " -+ T
(C
n
+ a
(M, AO).
T is now a C*-map from an open set of a Banach space to a Banach space. (2.6) Lemma. Consider a smooth path {, i
v
fe&fti
*
M
'
+ w
r +
* x N *
starling at the given C*-triple (y> ;g ,h ) 0
0
0
+ 1 + 0
U
and put
X
~Js-
Ds
i
and
Z= " *
ivAere T, and T, are the Christoffel symbols associated to g, and A,. (Y depends on X, and is given by n,= //
| g*» ( 7 .
+ V , X» ~ 7 , *«,)).
p : (A/, g ) -*• (N, h„) a
(2.7)
is harmonic, then
0
d-r I ^
Trace, (y
s
= dr dpi; g , A ) ( r , * , Z) == Aw + Trace R" (d
0
a
pi) - Trace (Ydtp ) + Trace Z C# a
M
d^ ). a
The terms depending on « are derived in [29], and the others in [19].
121 36
/ Eells and L Lemaire
3.
The main dependence theorem
(3.1) Theorem : Suppose that p : (A/, g„) - • (TV, h ) is a C-harmonic map between C"-Riemannian manifolds such that S7'E(p ) is non-degenerate. Then for 1 < k < oo and r < oo there is a neighbourhood V of (g , A ) in M'" * *" X N +*+ + and a unique C-map S : V -* C (A/, TV) such that S (g„, A ) = j>, S (g, A) is a harmonic map tp ! (A/, g) -* (TV, ft). From (2.7) we note that the hypothesis on the Hessian is satisfied if the sectional curvature Riem" is strictly negative and p (A/) is not a point or a geodesic. 0
a
t
1
0
r
I
a
1
0
+ B + a
0
0
(3-2) Corollary: Lethal and r < oo. Consider a C-path (g„ A,)„ , of C-.mlrics in M'* " x N ' * and suppose that for each sel there is a unique harmonic map tp, : (Af, g ) -» (JV, A,) i« a fixed homotopy class, with each y' E(tp,) non-degenerate. Then the map I - J - C" " * (A/, AO given Aj> s -*
1+
+
w + a
1
(
1
2
0
r
(3.3)
s
Remark : In particular, the conclusion of (3.2) is valid if
(a) each ft, has negative sectional curvature; (b) each (TV,ft.)satisfies the growth conditions described in ([9]; (5-2'a))— always satisfied if TV is compact; (c) the homotopy class contains neither constant maps nor maps to closed geodesies. Application : Such continuous dependence in dimension 2 has been used by Earle-Eells (6) to construct a specific continuous section of the fibre bundle of complex structures over the Teichmiiller space of a closed surface. Proof of theorem (3.1). Consider the map T defined as in (2-5). From (2.7) and the non-degeneracy of v E(
w
e
+ i +
0
r + 2 + a
0
Q
t
4
U
(3.4) Remark. Real analytic ( = C ) harmonic maps have properties not generally shared by other C'-maps [32]. Let Af and TV be C"-manifoIds. It is known ([31], [23]) that the C-metrtcs are dense in M * x N". Furthermore, if tp : (A/, g) -* (TV, A) is a harmonic map between C -Riemannian manifolds, then tp e C°. Theorem (3-1) shows that any C™-harmonic map f between C -manifolds w
u
122
Deformations of metrics and harmonic maps
37
with C°°-Riemannian metrics for which y * £ ( p ) is non-degenerate can be Capproximated by C-maps which are harmonic with respect to suitable metrics.
4.
Dependence for the Dirichlet problem
(4.1) Suppose now that M has a boundary I M and consider the Dirichlet problem (4.2) if
=0 tp
|
=y>
DM
for a fixed map i c e E " (DM, TV), tbf space or restrictions to DM of maps in C - (M, TV). We denote by C$ (U, TV) the Banach manifold of maps tp . M -* N coinciding with \p on DM, r < oo. Its tangent bundle A
T(Cf(M,N))
={veT(C'+*(M,N))
!« \ba = 0 and
nov\ =y,}, QB
where JT : T'TV) -* TV is the canonical bundle projection. The Jacobi operator dip is now a map 2+a
Ttp (C$
(A/, TV)) -» T
For
v,weT
integration by parts as in § 2 shows that J" {Jq> v, w,dx = / (v, Jf w) dx, M H and the non-degeneracy of V E(f) means again that ftp is an isomorphism. 2
(4.3) With these modifications in the proofs, theorem (3.1) and corollary (3.2) remain valid when the harmonic maps are solutions of the Dirichlet problem (4-2), replacing C ' ^ ( M , N )
hI+
by C5 °(A/,7V).
Furthermore, remark (3-3) remains valid for the Dirichlet problem without conditions (6) and (c). Indeed, the existence and unicity of the solution to that problem are guaranteed simply by the curvature assumption (a) ([25]; the unicity follows also from [15]). (4-4) In [13] Goldstein establishes the smooth dependence cn tp of the solution of (4-2) in a neighbourhood of a hannonic map, under the hypothesis that Riem <, 0. His method uses the inverse function theorem and applies to ihe case of a harmonic map with non-degenerate Hessian (without hypothesis on the curvature). Adapting his proof, we see that in a neighbourhood in C ' " (M, AO of a map ¥»„ with V E ( f ) non-degenerate, the map
w
+ w
!
t
A : M'
+ 1 + a
r+i+:<
M
x N'+ x
m + a
f^m-m
+ 2
x C + ° (M, AO -* x
rp„ C '
+ a
r
S
(AT, TV X E -+ +»(S Af.JV)
defined by A (g, h, ) «= (g, h, proj. r(tp;g, k), \DM) is a diffeomorphism; here proj. T(f,g, h) denotes the projection defined in (2-4). It follows that if
123 38
/ Eells and L Lemaire
tp (Af, g ) -> (TV, /i ) is a C-solution of (4.2) with boundary data ip such that V £ ( $ » o ) is non-degenerate, then there is a neighbourhood V of (g , h„; y ) in M'+ - X iV+*+ +* X C ° (Af, TV) and a C-map V -* (A/, AO JUCA that S(g ,h ; \j/ ) — a}^; and S(g,h,i//) is a solution of (4.2) for all (g,h;\/j) e V . See ([16]; Thm 10.5.3) for an alternative treatment in tbe case N = R. a
0
0
a
3
0
I(
0
a
0
l
0
r + 2 +
e
a
(4.5) Example. A simple instance of degeneracy of V £ ( p ) is the following. Take Af — / , N = S" (— the Euclidean n-sphere, n > l j a n d ^ u carrying the endpoints of I onto two antipodal points of S" In this case the solutions of (4.2) are geodesic segments f. We observe that tp is not a continuous function of \j> at yf . B
9
(4.6) Problem. When is { f e E (aAf, N) : E : CJ° (Af, AO-* * is non-degenerate at every critical point} residual (i.e., a countable intersection of open dense subsets) in the space of y for which (4.2) has a solution? See ([22], ch. VII) for the case M = /. (4.7) Problem. In the same order of ideas, when is {(g, I I ) G M ° X N " : the function tp -* E(tp;g,h) in non-degenerate} residual? In that problem one may have to discard certain degeneracies, as was done by Abraham in [2]. (4.8) Example : Let tp : M -» N be a harmonic map. A theorem of Visik [30] applied to the operator J«, asserts that there is a number e > 0 such that for any smooth domain A f C Af of volume M' < we have V*#(j> | ifef') non-degenerate. e
5.
Killing degeneracies %
(5.1) Degeneracy of X} E(tp;g,H) is expressed by the presence of non-zero Jacobi fields along
defined by fayr) -*y/o
0
m
a
+2l
M
a
0
0
r
s
Proof. As in (5.2), I(N,h„) acts smoothly on C + +° (Af, A). By the hypothesis of surjectivity, this action is free on the component of
124
Deformations
of metrics and harmonic maps
39
For a chart U centred at f , let V = V/I(N, h ) denote the orbit manifold of /(TV, A ). Because the tension r is invariant under the action of /(TV, A ), it induces a C - m a p a
a
0
0
r
0
r : U X M +'+ -* T-
(Af, N)II(N,
A„))
as in (2.5). Since Ker — I (TV, A ), the partial differential of T at p in the I I direction is an isomorphism. Therefore, there is a neighbourhood V of g in 0
0
tt
+ , 4
M ' ° and a unique C - m a p S :V-*fj such that S(g ) = p and r(S(g%g) = 0 for all g e V. Following S (g) by the action of /(TV, ft ), we obtain the S of the proposition. 0
0
0
(5.4) By way of contrast, we see from (5.2) that I(M,g„) acts continuously but not differentiably on C (Af, A ). Consequently, we are unable to proceed as in (5.3). However, a satisfactory result can be obtained in an important case, found in the classical literature under the heading of Poincare's continuation method (see [22; Cb. IX] and [27; §21]). The case under consideiation is that of a non-trivial closed geodesic represented as a harmonic map p : S -*(N,h). Now the identity component I(S )'=S induces a one-dimensional degeneracy of V B(p), but does not act differentiably on C ° (S , TV). We follow the usual practice in ealling rp non-degenerate if its only Jacobi fields are those of I (S ). Tbe following result is surely known (We express our thanks to W Klingcnberg and D Sullivan for their comments.) j f + 2 + a
7
1
1
J
2
+ 2 +
1
1
(5.5) Proposition. The non-degenerate smoothly on small deformations of h.
closed
geodesies
of
(TV, A)
depend
Indeed, we identify the prime closed geodesies of (TV, A) with the periodic orbits of the geodesic flow on 2" (TV). The non-degenerate closed geodesies correspond then to the periodic orbits whose Poincare maps have no eigenvflue equal to one. One then applies tbe proof of ([27], §21), or of the stability theorem ([3], §24) to obtain the desired conclusion. (5.6) Let p :(A/,g ) "* (TV,A ) be a harmonic map which factorises through the circle S and whose only Jacobi fields are those induced by I (S ). Combining (5.3) and (5.5), we see that the hannonic map will depend smoothly on a sufficiently small smooth deformation of the metrics. The interest of this observation is that, if we exclude the trivial case of constant maps, that kind of degeneracy is the only possible one in the case Riem < 0. In particular, we can delete the condition (c) in remark (3.3). 0
0
0
1
1
w
6.
Harmonic difleomorphisms of surfaces
As an application, we give a new proof of the following result of Sampson [24] and Schoen-Yau [26] (their proofs involve a decomposition formula for the Laplacian of | dtp | : Af R and the maximum principle). 2
125 40
J Eells and L Lemaire
(6.1) Theorem. Let (Af, g) and (TV, A) be closed orientable surfaces of the same genus p^>l. Assume that the sectional curvature Riem" < 0. If tp : Af -* TV is a harmonic map of degree 1, then tp is a diffeomorphism. Proof. Suppose first that p > 2, so that Riem" ^ 0 . Our hypothesis ensures that tp is homotopic to a diffeomorphism tp . Let us consider a smooth path (g,\ , C M " such that g„ = tp*„ h and g = g. The diffeomorphism tp : (Af, g )-» (TV, A) is then harmonic. Since Riem" <, 0 and 0, for all s e I there is a unique harmonic map f, : (Af, g,) -* (TV, A) homotopic to tp„ [10], [15]. By unicity, p is the given diffeomorphism and p = tp. Furthermore, y^fifft) is non-degenerate, so that corollary (3.2) implies that (fp,),ei' continuous deformation of ? to p. Let S = {t : / ( f t ) > 0 for s < t] where / ( » , ) is the Jacobian of tp,. Since a map of degree 1 with positive Jacobian is a diffeomorphism, it suffices to show that S — I. Therefore we remark that Oe S and show that S is open and closed. That S is open follows from the compactness of Af and the continuity of the above deformation. To show that S is closed, we consider a sequence (/,) c S such that ! ( - * * » • Then J(ip )^.0. By Wood's classification of singularities [32], tp must be a branched covering. Since it is of degree 1, it is a diffeomorphism and r„ e S. a
e
t
0
0
0
x
s
a
a
la
lai
The case p = 1 follows from standard methods (see [9], § 7). By passing to the two-sheeted orientable coverings, we get the (6.2) Corollary. Let (M,g) and (TV, A) be non-orientable closed surfaces of the same genus # 2 * 1 . Assume Riem" <, 0. Any harmonic map £ : (Af, g ) - » (TV, A) homotopic to a diffeomorphism is a diffeomorphism. Once in possession of (4.3), we can simplify somewhat the proof of the fallowing result of Schoen-Yau [26] : (6.3) Theorem : Let (Af,g) be a compact surface with boundary and (TV, A) a compact surface with Riem £ 0. Suppose that ip : Af -» TV is a diffeomorphism onto (Af). Assume that y (£iAf) is convex with respect to (f(Af). Then there is a (unique) harmonic map tp : Af -» TV in the component of tp in C$ (Af, TV) such that q> ] H « -*•
l O U
e
i
0
2
s
2
2
7.
Hannonic maps with non-negative Jacobian
We now examine briefly the possibility of extending the results of § 6 to other situations.
126 Deformations of metrics and harmonic maps
41
(7.1) It is unknown whether the curvature restriction in theorems (6.1) and (6.3) is necessary. (7.2) Almost nothing is known about the singularities of harmonic maps between manifolds of dimensions > 2. We note, however, that for n ^ 3, there are metrics g on the n-torus such that any harmonic map
S ( S
(7.3) In view of theorem (6.1), we could ask whether a harmonic map between surfaces which is homotopic to a surjective branched covering is itsell a branched covering. That this is not the case, even if the target has negative curvature, is shown by the (7.4) Example : Let N be a compact orientable surface without boundary. For any Riemannian metric h on N, there exist a Riemann surface M and a harmonic map ip : M-*(N, h) which is homotopic to a surjective branched covering but is not a branched covering. In particular, if N has negative curvature then the harmonic map is unique in its homotopy class, which therefore contains no harmonic branched covering. On the other hand, note that if N is a sphere, certain homotopy classes can contain two harmonic maps, only one of which is a branched covering [18]. We first construct the example in the case where genus AT= £ > 1. Take any Riemann surface P of genus q + 1. We represent P by the polygon afatfpto? • • - fa+ifta+ifSi*7+i with the usual identifications. Its fundamental group ni (P) is then generated by (a„ * , ) ( £ , i with the single relation I & g afifOT -JT* =• L We represent Afsimilarly, using ( c , < / ) i £ £ The homomorphism Jtj (P) -* Tii (AO defined by a, -* c , b ~* d, (1 < ( < q), u -+ 1 and Z>, -* I determines a homotopy class of maps P -* N of degree 1. By [17] that class contains a harmonic map y. l S
+
1
(
(
t
4
(
a
a + 1
+1
Let M be the surface of genus M — 2q + 1 obtained by joining cross-wise two copies of P . Icng a closed curve cutting the handle of P represented by ( a , r> ). M admits a complex structure such that the covering map fi • M -* P is holomorphic. The composition yo/f : M-*N is then harmonic and is not a branched covering. Since its degree is two and it induces an epimorphism on fundamental groups, it is homotopic to a branched covering by a result of Edmonds [7], That is a consequence of a theorem stating (in his terminology) that any map M ~* N is homotopic to a pinch followed by a branched covering. We remark that our map
0+1
127 42
J Eells and L Lemaire
8. Examples The results of §§ 3-5 affirm that a sufficiently small smooth deformation of metrics induces a smooth variation of the associated harmonic maps, provided that tbe curvature of N or the initial harmonic map satisfies some restrictive hypothesis. By means of examples, we shall illustrate now the nature of these restrictions. (8.1) Sampson has shown us the necessity of making some sort of hypothesis by studying the behaviour of a closed geodesic on a flat cylindei, deformed into a conical shape. His example can be made more explicit as follows. Let TV" be a piece of cylindrical surface (a, b) x S equipped in local coordinates (« ,w*)e(
I
1
U
1
M
l2
e
1
1
For any point c e (a, b), the tension of the map tp ; S -* TV defined by tp (x) = c, q> (x) = x is given by T (p) = — if, T*{p) = 0. Therefore, such a m3p is a geodesic iff / ' (c) = 0. I f / ' (c) < 0, the set { ( a \ « ) | W > c] is the concave side of the curve p. Suppose now that / is constant, so that Tv" is a piece of flat cylinder. For any c e (a, b), the map tp : 5* -» N defined above is a geodesic and the vector field along tp defined by v (x) = const., u ( x ) = 0 is a Jacobi field which is not a Killing field of S . Therefore, tp does net satisfy the hypothesis of proposition (5.5). If we now modify the metric on N in such a way that / becomes decreasing, we observe that iV does not carry any non-trivial closed geodesic, so that proposition (5.5) fails. Indeed, the image of any map tp : S -* N is situated on the concave side of the line a' «• minp . By Sampson's maximum principle [24], tp cannot be harmonic. In this example the degeneracy of # is due to the presence of a continuous family of closed geodesies, obtained by varying c in (a, b). That proposition (5.5) can fail also for an isolated geodesic (up to rotation on S ) can be seen by defining the initial metric by a monotone function / such that / ' ( c ) =• 0 = / " (c); for example / = 1 + («' c) . Then the curve u = c is a geodesic, and the vector field along the curve defined by w = const., = 0 is a Jacobi field. For the perturbed metric determined by / = 1 + (a — c ) + e (a — c), e > 0, there is no geodesic in a neighbourhood of a = c, by the maximum principle. In these examples, we have considered only a piece of surface N. Using partitions of unity, we can extend N to form a complete Riemannian surface. When that surface is compact, there is always a closed geodesic homotopic to a given curve; thus the examples show that a smooth deformation of metrics does not determine a continuous variation of harmonic maps, although the existence of such maps is not in question here. For N non-compact, however, an arbitrarily small deformation of metric could make a harmonic map disappear altogether. Indeed, we can deform the flat metric on an infinite cylinder to a metric such t h a t / ' < 0. Then the modified surface does not carry any closed geodesic. 1
1
2
J
1
2
1
1
1
1
a
1
1
1
1
3
1
128 Deformations
of metrics and harmonic maps
43
(8.2) In all the above examples, the hamonic map under consideration is a geodesic, so that the rotation group of S always induces a degeneracy of the Hessian of E . Therefore, these examples pertain to the situation considered in § 5. It is a simple matter to adapt the examples to suppress that Killing degeneracy. Indeed, it suffices in all the constructions to replace the maps S -> (a, b) x S by maps M(a, b) x M denned analogously, where M is a compact manifold with discrete isometry group. In that way, one sees that the hypothesis of nondegeneracy of the Hessian in theorem (3.1) is essential. 1
1
1
(8.3) In relation to deformations of the metric of M, we have tbe following partial result. Let M be the fiat torus RjlndZ X RjlnZ equipped with Euclidean coordinates (x, y) and N the piece of surface defined as above with u e (— b, b) and / = (b + A) — (u ) (where A > 0). It was observed in [18] that a map f : M ~* N of tbe form p (x, y) — {y/ (x), y) is harmonic iff yi satisfies the pendulum equation 1
1
1
2
For rf = 1, the " length " of the torus coincides with the period of the pendulum and there is a continuous family of harmonic maps. For d jt 1, the only harmonic map of the prescribed form is given by yi = 0, so that we do not have a smcoth variation of the harmonic maps in this restricted class. (8.4) It might be tempting to try to prove existence theorems for harmonic maps, by deforming a metric for which existence is known to another one. The following examples show that this cannot always work : (8.5) Let M be a closed orientable surface of genus 3 and (N, h) a 2-sphere. It is shown in [11] that there is a harmonic map p : (M,g) -> (N, Ii) of degree 3 iff g is a Hermitian metric associated to a non-hyperelliptic complex structure on M. Call E the set of such metrics. Now E is open in M ; although V E (p) is degenerate, we see that for any g e E , a small deformation of g will preserve the existence of a harmonic map. Along a path leadir.g from E to M \ E , however, existence will not be preserved. With respect to this observation, we stress that theorem (3.1) concerns only small variations of metrics, and leads to the global statemert of corollary (3.2) only if existence and unicity of the harmonic maps are assumed. 3
A similar disappearance occurs with respect to variations of Dirichlet data; see ([9], 12.6). (8.6) Let N be the infinite cylinder on which we define a metric h as above, using the function f— e~* + e(u') - The curvature of (N,h ) is negative for all e and a negative constant when t = 0. For any c > 0, (N, h ) carries the closed geodesic u = c, where c is the solution of tr-" = 2ec. For « = 0, the maximum principle implies thtt (N,h„) carries no closed geodesic. Note that (N,h„) does not satisfy the growth condition of remark (3.3). e
2
c
e
1
129 44
/ Eells and L Lemaire
(8.7) Finally, we recall [28] that if f i ^ 3 , A / = S " is the Euclidean sphere and N is an ellipsoid of revolution of dimension n, one of whose axis is A times the others, then there is a harmonic map tp : M -* N which is a suspension of the identity on S"- if A is small, but not if A is large. What happens along a deformation of the metric of N leading from one value of A to the other is not known. 1
References [IJ [2] [3] [4]
Abraham Abraham Abraham Calabi E
[5] (6]
(Papers in honour of K Kodaira) (Princeton : University Press and 1969 University of Tokyo Press) 101-117 Dieudonne J A 1960 Foundations of modem analysis (New York : Academic Press) Earle C 3 and Eells J 1969 A fibre bundle description of Teichmiiiler theory; / . Diff.
[7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] 114] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27]
R 1962 Lectures of Smale on differential topology. Columbia University R 1970 Bumpy metrics; Proc. Symp. Pure. Math. 14 1-3 R aad Robbin J 1967 Transversal mappings and flows (New York : Benjamin) 1969 A n intrinsic characterisation of harmonic one-forms; Global Analysis
Geom. 3 19^t3 Edmonds A L 1980 Deformations of maps to branched coverings in dimension two (to appear) Eells J 1966 A setting for global analysis; Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 71 751-S07 Eells J and Lemaire L 1978 A report on harmonic maps; Bull. London Math. Soc. 10 1-68 Eells J and Sampson J H 1964 Harmonic mappings of Riemannian manifolds; Am. J. Math. 86 109-160 Eelis J and Wood J C 1976 Restrictions on harmonic maps of surfaces; Topology IS 263-266 Gilbarg D and Trudinger N S 1977 Elliptic partial differential equations of second order (Grundlehxen 224 : Springer Verlag) Goldstein R A 1972 Stability of the boundary value problem for harmonic mappings; /. Math. Anal. Appl. 39 346-359 Hamilton R S 1975 Harmonic maps of manifolds with boundary. Springer lecture notes 471 Hartman P 1967 On homotopic harmonic maps; Can. J. Math. 19 673-6S7 Hormander L 1964 Linear partial differential operators (Grundlehren : Springer Verlag) Lemaire L 1975 Applications harmoniques de surfaces; CR Acad. Sci. Paris A280 897-899 Lemaire L 1978 Harmonic nonholomorphic maps from a surface to a sphere; Proc. Am. Math. Soc. 71 299-304 Lichnerowkz A 1961 Propagateurs et commutateurs en relativite generale; IHES Publ. 10 Mazet E 1973 L a formule de l a variation seconde de i'energie au voisinage d'une application hannonique; J. Diff. Geom. 8 279-296 Morrey C B 1966 Multiple integrals in the calculus of variations. (Grundlehren : Springer Verlag) Morse M 1934 The calculus of variations in the large; Am. Math. Soc. Colloq. Publ. 18 Royden H L 1960 The analytic approximation of difTerentiable mappings; Math. Ann. 139 171-179 Sampson J H 1978 Some properties and applications of harmonic mappings; Ann. Ec. Norm. Sup. 11 221-228 Schoen R M 1977 Existence and regularity of some s °metric variational problems; Thesis, Stanford Univ. Schoen R M and Y a u S T 1978 On univalent harmonic maps between surfaces; Invent. Math. 44 265-278 Siegel C L and Moser J K 1971 Lectures on classical mechanics (Grundlehren : Springer Verlag) e
130
Deformations of metrics and harmonic maps
45
(28] 129]
Smith R T 1975 Harmonic mappings of spheres; Am. J. Math. 97 364-385 Smith R T 1975 The second variation formula for hannonic mappings; Proc. Am. Soc. 47 229-236
[30J
Visik M I 1951 On strongly elliptic systems of differential equations; Math. Sbornik 29 615-676 Whitney H 1934 Analytic extension of differentiable functions defined on closed sets; Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 36 63-89 Wood J C 1977 Singularities of harmonic maps and applications of the Gauss-Bonne formula; Am. J. Math. 99 1329-1344
[31] [32]
J . Eells Department of Mathematics University of Warwick Coventry C V 4 7 A L ( U K )
Math.
L . Lemaire Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques 35 Rue de Chartres 91440 Bures-sur-Yvette, France Also Universite Libre de Bruxells (Belgium)
131 A CONSERVATTOH LA» FOE HARMONIC MAPS P. Baird and J . E e l l s
I . Motivation and back-ground.
(1.1)
R e l a t i v i t y theory has shown that the lavs of many s t a t i o n a r y aspects of
physics should be enlarged to include time. That can be done i n such a manner to provide u n i f i c a t i o n of various p h y s i c a l concepts, and to present them i n i n v a r i a n t form ; see
[ 1 9 , 5 3 . 2 ] and [33] . For instance,
a) energy and momentum are u n i f i e d by forming the energy-moment urn tensor ; b) then the conservation of energy i s j u s t the time-component of a lav which i s i n v a r i a n t under the Lorentz group - the other components being the
space-components,
which express the conservation of momentum. The ease of s t a t i o n a r y electromagnetic f i e l d s i s c a r r i e d out i n [40;pp75, 166]. We d e s c r i b e here b r i e f l y the case of s t r e s s - e n e r g y , following the exposition of Feynman [14,11-31-9]
.
The s t r e s s at .. point of an e l a s t i c body is described by a 2-tensor ( S J J ) in
Ttt^ , where
S. .
i s the i-component of .-. force associated to the j - v e c t o r i n the
following way. Consider a u n i t area of
S
S
orthogonal to
j
at
a . The m a t e r i a l on the
e x e r t s a force on the m a t e r i a l on the r i g h t and v i c e versa
are equal and opposite,
and we suppose depend only on the
of t h i s p a i r of f o r c e s , we obtain the s t r e s s i - v e c t o r . He assume that
S. .
S..
at
x
that the system be i n e q u i l i b r i u m implies that
S^.
as the rate of flow of the
corresponding to the
Vol. 894, pp. 1 25 (1981). 0 1 9 8 1 Springer-Verlag Berlin-Heidelberg.
S^^
be symmetric, and
so we could as w e l l
i-comconent of momentum through a u n i t
Reprinted with permission from Lecture Notes in Mathematics, T
j - v e c t o r . By choosing one
be divergence f r e e .
Now a force i s a time-rate of change of momentum , S .
these forces
behaves l i k e a tensor. Then one can show that the
law of conservation of momentum about some o r i g i n implies
describe
left
132 2
area orthogonal to
j . Thus
B
(8..) 1 3
are tbe P li
i,j
a c e
components of a 2-tensor
1.3
in four dimensional Minkowski space with components ( S . , ) nents f
i
e
X
are those of energy flow, and S d
f ..)
s
o
is the energy density. The tensor
ia traditionally called the stress-energy tensor
S
1 J
q
j thus the C-compo-
OSi.j s 3
of t h e s y s t e m . In intrinsic terms, we shall interpret a symmetric 2-covariant tensor field
S as a stress-energy tensor, as follows : for any timelike vector
v at a
point, we interpret a) S(v,v) as the energy density as measured by v ; b) S ( v , - )
as the momentum density {of the mass/energy distribution) as
measured by v ; c) S| ^ as the stress tensor as measured by V .
(1.2)
I f the field equations of the physical system are derivable from a varia
tional principle (1.3)
J"l,Cj 9)d* ,
I(s)
k
then by restricting attention to special variations we proceed to define the stressenergy tensor (1.4)
div
S ; at an extremal
s
of
I
i t can be shown that
S is conservative i
S- 0 .
That result is due to Hilbert [20] ; for an exposition, see [19,S3.3] . (1.5)
During a most instructive conversation many years ago (in April 1963), Profes-
sor A. H. Taub suggested that the stress-energy tensor should be useful in the theory of harmonic maps. Although that prospect has lain dormant in the meantime, recent developments have confirmed Taub's prediction. Indeed, if
$
:
(M,g) * (N,h)
is a map between Riemannian manifolds (here
and henceforth we shall use the notation and terminology of [10]), then its energy density
e
: H-»1H(>0)
is defined at each point
x £M by
133
0.6)
e <X) - | |d* < ) | 4
X
2
,
where the vertical bars denote the Eilbert-Schmidt norm in the space
For any compact domain M' in K we define the energy of (1.7)
E(*,M'>
j
1
by
,e {x)dx . 4
The Euler-Lagrange operator associated with of
+ in K
L(T (M),T,, (N)). x *(x)
E is called the tension field
t
(1.8)
Tj = div dt
where div
,
is the divergence operator of the Riemannian vector bundle
T*(M) a $ T(N),
And the stress energy tensor of * is found to be 0-9)
S
+
* «
t
g -••h .
A map t : (H,e) + (N,h)
is harmonic i f
t.=0 t
on
M . Such a map then
satisfies the conservation law (1.10) Here
div div
S, S 0 S,
is alternative notation for
covariant differential
?*S. , where V* is the adjoint of the
2
v : C(T*(M) • o T*(H)) -* C(T*(M)) .
The purpose of this paper is to derive that simple law (Theorem 2.9 below), and to show how i t unifies and simplifies various properties (both old and new) of harmonic maps.
134
2. Derivation of the stress-energy Censor.
Let us f i r s t consider tbe effect of v a r i a t i o n s induced by a vector X £ C(T(M)) . I f
( £ { t ) > denotes i t s t r a j e c t o r i e s , set
field
g
He derive two standard f a c t s .
( 2
.,)
3
j ^ . .
d
e
t
KW
t
Proof.
(2.2,
Trace (i^g) det g .
0
F i r s t of a l l , i n charts we have
U*&>
3t
H det | ( t )
t => 0
•Trace | | det
g(t)
t =0
Let
m - dim H . I f we take an orthomormal base (e.) with respect m * liiSn g =• g(o) on TjjtM) , l e t n 6 ft be the m-covector dual to B^A A e^ , 1
to so
n(e, L
e ) • 1 . Then m
det g ( t ) *
n(g(t)e ,...,g(t)e )
Then using
(2.1)
d dt
det
l
a
,
with
g(o) = I .
"<«<"•
g(t) t • 0
t - 0
thus (2.2) follows at once.
Secondly, by d e f i n i t i o n ,
the L i e d e r i v a t i v e S%g-8
at so
>W \ «<»•.'
lini
(2.1) follows from ( 2 . 2 ) .
135
(2.3) g(t)
Lemma. , then
«.4)
If
ri (c)
r, ( t ) -
-[det
5*(t)„
g(tY]
1 / 2
m
d x ' A . • - A ax
i s the volume element of
;
J a M
|
-
Proof.
At
1
Trace
8
- 1/2
( t ) ] ^
' ^ g t t )
n
te
1
Trace (L^g) [ d e t g(t)]
Now, for any vector f i e l d
(2.5)
l | M
t • 0 ,
• | ^ - i [ d e t
tion of
e
f given by
/
l
2
di
X€C(T(M))
1
A . . . A di" .
let
]L X e C ( * ' T ( N )
( s ) X{x) , for a l l x £M .
Lemma. L eo- s
< d * . V (*_X)>- 1/2 < L g , * * h > x
Proof.
L e = x
.
W e ) ( X ) -
t
+
2
t
A d i r e c t c a l c u l a t i o n gives ( 2 . 5 ) , using the standard i d e n t i t y
(2.6)
(2.7) have
(L.g) ^ ij
-
X. . l
Lemma. L
(2.8)
be that v a r i a -
,
+
J
X. . J
For any map
>
.
ft*£,j
S
*
e g -
» : (K,g) -* (N,b) <
t
8
Y '%
>
and vector f i e l d n
• "
h
e
r
X £ C ( T ( « ) ) we
e
2
t*h e C ( 0 T * ( H ) ) .
4
i s the s t r e s s - e n e r g y
Proof.
i m) .
1
(e^n ) -
x
( i n any c h a r t )
tensor of 4 .
Apply (2.5) and ( 2 . 4 )
He s h a l l denote the divergence of
S
to
by d i v
S
or by
7*S
. In a chart.
136
(div 5 ) - (S ) 9 * i il.i (2.9>
. Thus div
S £C(T*M).
Z
Theorem. The s Ires synergy censor
£ C(e T*(M)> of any map i : (M,g)+ffi, h)
has divergence (2.10)
div
S, - -
Consequently. a) — if i .is harmonic, then .. — .
S. $ is conservative (i.e,div S tSO)
b) i f $ i s a map which is a differentiable submersion almost everywhere on M> and i f
div
= 0 , then $ i s harmonic.
Proof.
From (2.6) we obtain
Applying the divergence theorem and integration by parts to ( 2 . 7 ) , assuming that
X has compact support we obtain
0-[ J
I- (e n) H
X
JM
*
Because that is true for a l l compact
*
( + v*S )Xn . *
J K *
X , we find (2.10) satisfied ; the rest of
the Proposition follows immediately. (2.11) Kemarlc.
In case
b)
i t suffices to assume that * is
c'-diffeomorphism between compact surfaces, then
div
I,E 0
2
C . If # is a insures that 6
is
harmonic [ 3 4 , Chapter 5 ] . In view of the basic regularity theorem [10,43.5] , i t seems natural to pose the 2
(2.12) Problem.
If t is a continuous
I^-map satisfying the hypotheses of
b)
above, then i s 4 harmonic ? (2.13) Corollary.
Let
X be a Killing field of
(M,g), and
S*
the contravariant
representation of the stress-energy tensor of a harmonic map $ : (M, g) •* (N,h) . Then the contraction
Y - <S
,X > is a vector field with
div 1 = 0.
In particular, the total flux over the boundary of any closed domain *
M
in
H of the
X-component of
S" i s 0
:
137
dx'J
atProof.
we get
divYdx - 0 , where » ia the unit outward normal field of
3M' .
) M' Killing fields
X are characterised by
L g = 0 . Thus from ( 2 . 5 ) x
div Y -
(2.14) There are various instances where stress-energy appears in the variational theory of Riemannian fibre bundles. For example, a) in the derivation of extremal Riemannian metrics ; that is in the s p i r i t of Hilbert'a work [20]; see [25] and [ 2 8 ] . b) in the study of the extremals of the elastic-energy functional (for fixed
X,u€E)
as given in [35] . c) in the theory of functionals of the elementary symmetric functions of the eigenvalues of \W
-
**h with respect to
g
o^
[41] . I f
a (g"'**h) dx, l£
then its Euler-Lagrange equation is Trace
vW+.T^, ( g ~ ' A ) 1 - 0 ;
and its stress-energy tensor S (t) - { o (g"'A)g k
where
k
•*h*T _ {E A) , - l
k
1
is the Newton tensor field [29,30,41] . d) in recent work of Toth [36] , using the stress-energy tensor to study
geodesic variations o£ harmonic maps into locally symmetric Riemmanian manifolds.
138
3. Various i l l u s t r a t i o n s ,
( 3 . 0 Example.
If
dim M -
(3.2) Example.
If
N = E , then
(3.3) Example.
Suppose that $ : ( n , g ) - t ( N , h )
iff
m- 2
such that and
and
I , then
S^ = -
|
u
g ) . Indeed, i f
0 • Trace S • (m-2)e , so f f
and
1 2 S = & d*I g - (U • • *
div
- -<
and
div S
.
*
» -
i s a nonconstant map. Then
$ i s weakly conformal ( i . e .
**h
2
S
=0
there i s a function p : M . » ] R ( a ) £
S
= 0 then * i s weakly conformal with u • e ; t * m = 2 . Conversely, i f **h - ug, then 2e • mu , •
BO
(3.4)
s
r
^
u
Furthermore, i f then
.
s
m>2
and
$: (M, g)
(N ,h)
i s harmonic and weakly conformal,
$ i s homothetic ( i . e . p i s constant). For Theorem 2 . 9 . a s s e r t s that div S : 0 ,
'
v
and from (3.4) (3.5) Remark.
we find
0 « —— p,^ g _
Ue f i r s t learned
of
(I < i < m) , whence
dp = 0
on
H .
that property i n a l e t t e r from Professor
J . H . Sampson i n 1975. Special cases can be found i n the l i t e r a t u r e ; e . g . ,
if m • n
see [15, Theorem 8b] and [23, Theorem 5.7] . And [21] for the general case with the requirement that p has isolated zeros.
(3.6) Example. then
A
If
$ : (M, g) * (N,h)
i s a t o t a l l y geodesic map ( i . e . ,
i s p a r a l l e l . Consequently,
e^
i s constant and
is parallel :
VS. = 0 . Proof.
For any
(3.7)
V [(A)(T,Z)] -
(3.6)
V [(dt)Y] x
because $ (3.9)
VJf X
X . T . Z 6 C(T(M))
we have
(V A)(Y,Z) • (A)(V„Y,Z) + (A)(Y,v„Z) ; V
(W*)(X,Y) * (d ){7 Y) T
x
(dtXvjY) ,
i s t o t a l l y geodesic. Now s p e c i a l i z e =
0
X , Y , Z so that
= V.
at a prescribed point
x 6 » . Then from
(3.7) evaluated at
S 0) ,
x
we obtain
139
(v i)*h)(Y,Z) -
7
x
X
J;
) . He conclude Chat
No«
2e
-
v(**h)
0
* <(d*)Y,v
(
on
x
M,
f ( 2 » ) - V
0
too.
(3.10) Example.
If
»: ( H , g ) ( N , h )
i s an isometric
immersion, then
S
• 4>
g , Z
whence
whether or not $
(3.11) L e t
i s hannonic
i; (M,g) • (N,h)
(i.e.,
i s a minimal immersion).
be a Riemannian submersion. Then
S_ - " g - t*h ;
and a)
5
s
* ^
"
i f f the f i b r e s of
[38, Prop. 4D] . Such a
$ are minimal ;
that
reaffirms
t i s an example of a harmonic morphism, of which more w i l l
be said i n ' 5 below. b)
VS
damental form
0 Vd*
of * vanishes on pairs of v e r t i c a l vectors-
Proof b ) , the Proof a) being s i m i l a r . 1 £ i,b,L £ m ,
i * i,j
£ n ,
Use
Then (V S . ) ( X ,X ) \ *
indices
(X^)
with
(X^)
horizontal and
(**h>(«„ X ,X > • (•*h)(X ,v x ) . Taking *b S
a
(X^) v e r t i c a L
a - r
and e
i
C
gives {V S ) ( X . , X ) X.
[38 S3] .
n*l £ r , s < m .
Take a l o c a l orthonormal frame f i e l d
c
4 are t o t a l l y geodesic i f f the second fun¬
i f f the fibres of
( t * h ) < X . , V X ) . Thus lX^^r v
VS •
0
implies that the horizon-
(VX^)" s 0 .
Conversely, i f
(VX ) r
H
= 0 , then (V S . H X . . X ) X^ I 1 r
(»*h)(X. v 1
-
\
X ) T
0 . Si¬
m i l a r l y ,
- (t*h)
^ g l X ^ )
• f
^
,
^
)
-
tt(v^s/^)
4
g U . , ^ )
, 0 .
•
In summary, (VX ) r
= 0
implies
?„ S , = 0 X *
for a l l
1 < b < m .
b
To prove the second equivalence
in
b, take
y £ N
and l e t
- 4 '(y),
140 10 and
i
: (F , k | y
y
)*(H,g)
the isometric inclusion map. From the composition law
y
[ 1 1 , ( 4 . 1 ) ] we find
whence for
X, Y 6 C(T(F^)) ,
zontal and t
i s an isomorphism on horizontal vectors,
t
iff
Vdi
a 0 . I.B.J
y
are t o t a l l y
vd*(X,Y) - - * , { 7 d i ^ ) ( X , Y )
Euclidean space
V . Let
the o r i g i n
* : (M, g) + (V, h)
and endow
is the Gauss map of a)
C denote the Grassmannian of
- ,
B, • b)
vd*
-
relationship
dy
b
fc
S
R " g
Y
(K,g) into a V
through : M -* G
L
K* •
itself)
, where
(using the repre-
K-fG i s the vector
with the d i f f e r e n t i a l of •
:
; is
y*k . Then we have the b a s i c i n t e r -
[27] .
y? y k - B?. "i ' j ab ij
If
L E G is
s
Y*k - < B . , * . > - S i c c i
i 12 |T^|
m-planes i n
$ can be i d e n t i f i e d
T(G)
the third fundamental form of j
S
fibres
then
bundle whose f i b r e over
(3.15)
the
G with i t s standard Riemannian metric k . I f y
sentation of the tangent vector bundle
2e
be an isometric immersion of
the second fundamental form B , of t
Tf
the r i g h t member vanishes
geodesic.
Let
(3.14)
y
?d(r vanishes on p a i r s of v e r t i c a l vectors i f f
(3.12) Example.
(3.13)
. Since ( V d i ) ( X , Y ) i s h o r i -
l J
,
A
;
-R.. . aB I J 0
i s the s c a l a r curvature of
H B . Consequently, e
S
the stress-energy
• g - B..T 2
a)
+ Ricci
K
(M»g) then we c a l c u l a t e tensor of y
is
.
t
the immersion has constant mean curvature, then
div S = 0 . That i s an a p p l i c a -
tion of the theorem of Ruh-Vilms c h a r a c t e r i s i n g such immersions v i a harmonicity of t h e i r Gauss maps [31] .
141
L e t us now interpret: that : F i r s t of a l l , E i n s t e i n ' s f i e l d tensor [I9,p..74] Ricci
- — g i s divergence free t
as a consequence of B i a n c h i ' s second i d e n t i t y . Secondly
therefore,
(3.16)
- B°- , T h
since
S. . ,
= < t „ T> g. . - B° • , TAU
" 8° i l , h
A
$ has constant mean c u r v a t u r e . The i n t e r p r e t a t i o n (3.13) gives 53 *
the second fundamental form of the map VS Y
div S Y
of
y , so (3.16) becomes
-
- <
T
Y
T(G)
1,
K*« K ,
, x > 5 0 . *
Remark : For any space form (V,h) of constant curvature e
(3.14) i s Y*k -
,
- Y *
Therefore, with the i n t e r p r e t a t i o n
(3.17)
g Y
, the analogue
[271. <8 , r > * *
(3.18) Remark.
Ricci
6
+ c ( m - i ) g , and ue can proceed with that as above.
Harmonicity of Gauss maps
of a Riemannian f o l i a t i o n
died i n [39] . That should be taken into account i n consideration (5.7)
F is stubelow.
142
12
4. Haps from Kahier manifolds.
(4.1) L e t
(M,g)
be <• Kahier manifold of
dim^M - m . Then the complex s t r u c t u r e
induces a decomposition of i t s complexified tangent bundle e
T (l©
T ' { « ) • T"(H) .
and hence a type decomposition of a l l tensor f i e l d s if
* : (M,g) +(N,h)
tensor has the
H . In p a r t i c u l a r ,
i s a map into a Riemannian manifold, then i t s
stress-energy
decomposition
2
(4.2) S
on
2
- S < ' ° > •. S " ' " •
S
<°> >
and s
(2.0)
(0^)
s
Similarly,
E C ( E
V*
( M ) )
.
the complex extension of the covariant d i f f e r e n t i a l of (H,g) ,
treated as a Riemannian manifold now, decomposes :
(4.3) 7 where
1
7'
7' + 7"
,
: C(T'(M)) x C(«T"H) •>• C ( » T * M )
, and s i m i l a r l y for
7" .
These decompositions provide greater p r e c i s i o n i n the a s s e r t i o n of Theorem 2.9 ; ,9 ; indeed, write out 2
vV
( V * * V"*)( < -°> * < » * » * S
and compare types, s i m i l a r l y for
(4.4) V * S 7<*
S
( 2
0
S
noting that
7'* c a r r i e s
7"* . He conclude that
' '
0 )
0
* 7"* S
( 1
'
l )
2
* 7"* S < ° - >
s
( 0
-
2 )
)
(p,q)-types
7*S, = 0
into ( p - 1 , q ) - t y p e s
; and
iff
0 , and/or = 0 .
Thus we obtain the (4.5)
Proposition.
If
4 : (H g)*(N h) 1
1
into a Riemannian manifold, then equations
i s a harmonic map of a Kahier manifold ( 4 . 4 ) are s a t i s f i e d .
143
13
(4.6)
Example•
Let
M be a Riemann surface and
g
a compatible Hermitian m e t r i c .
He s h a l l w r i t e the components of the stress-energy tensor of <. map i ; H •* (N,h) as follows
: Write
<
,
>
E
for the symmetric
Then i n terms of an isothermal chart on 2 <• , a> — > z z
e . g • p
I
Aziz
and the type decomposition of
(A)
(•*h)''
1
4
- 2 <* , 4 -
>
i
C
V -<* ,*-> 7
( 2
S '°> - - <
M,
,
$*h
is
s
dzd7
E
dz 1
He note that i n t h i s case
(4.7)
, > .
* >• dz ,
2
(
h - <
2
- < v
2 , 0
I - b i l i n e a r extension of
2
1
s' ' ' 5 0
11^* d z
V
2
, and
.
An a p p l i c a t i o n of P r o p o s i t i o n ( 4 . 5 ) produces the well-known properties [ 1 0 , ( 1 0 . 5 ) ] i If
$ : K -*(N,h)
(4.8)
i s a harmonic map, then 2
a)
(4*h) '^
i s a holomorphic quadratic d i f f e r e n t i a l on' M .
b)
(*"h) '° =0
2
Example•
iff
t
i s weakly conformal.
A holomorphic map
•;• : ( M , g ) - » ( N , h ) between Kahier manifolds i s
harmonic [11.S2C] and preserves type. He conclude that
2
(4.9)
S< '°>
, 0
and
0
V"* s f '
* 0 .
M ui denotes the Kahier form of
If
(4. 10) H, t
-
e,»" *
t o"
i s the Kahlerian analogue of We can a l s o w r i t e then
e^
1 0
-
2
Jen ™
- 2
S, . * m > ifl
t& ; for i f
$ i s holomorphic,
< m", 4 iu > . t h i s l a s t by a d i r e c t c a l c u l a t i o n .
2
N
Proposition.
In particular, i f class
fl. = <w t
|d'||
(M,g) then
If
* i s holomorphic, then i! *
M i s compact, then ^,!!)
morphic c h a r t s we have
. Indeed, div s ,
i s co-closed on
M : d*il = 0 4
$ determines the cohomology =0
iff
d*n
0 . For i n s t a n c e , i n holo-
144 14 H
/-I
— Hi from which i t follows that
N—
/-I 2
0,T"
/-I 2
h
T oB S.-r IJ Finally,
d*fl
- - *d*ft , we see that
cohomology c l a s s of
since
*S> i s closed, and therefore determine* a complex
H . We have also
(4.12) C o r o l l a r y .
f IU'VQ.
- (m-l) K(») ,
where 2
2
K{*) - J^(|d'* I ( | d ' j1' - -| d| "d*"| ") | ) dxdx - - IJ^k k dx . t
t
Thus as CQhomQlogy claasea [*")
u
l-n ] -
„ . Proof.
M „ LO A * ii
B U t
M , M,m-1 y, ... •u - ( a ) /(m-1) I
Therefore,
*
-
01 A*» U>
e
-
|d't|
M
-
ui A.n^
» ™
+ |d",|
If
mk —
2
*
k
*
, if t
i s holomorphic.
- k dx - (m-l)k dx .
t
ml $ : (M,g)VKN,h)
t Is a holomorphic and isometric imnersion,
- (m-1) M .
(4.14) Example. then
2
i
and —r - dx , ml
. , n.a )
*
then ft
T
dx
(4.13) Example•
#
M M M . . N I- • u AMU* - til A* U
*
•
lk dxl.
(
K
If
* : ( M , g ) * (N,h) i s a holomorphic Riemannian submersion,
0.* - noi - t'd* , where
Ii - dim.N it .
145 15
5 - Harmonic morjahiams •
(5.1)
A map $ : (M,g) -•• (N,h) 4 '(V)
tion on tant map
whenever
f
i s a harmonic morphism
for any
X - K i-K
^
Ker d$(x)
T
in
S
(K)
denote the modules of conformality
an open dense subset of
0
#
H . If
i s a harmonic funcV c: H . A noncons-
4 i s a harmonic map and i s h o r i z o n t a l l y con-
x e M at which the d i f f e r e n t i a l
to the orthogonal complement of let
f
i s a harmonic function on a domain
$ i s a harmonic morphism i f f
formal ; i . e . ,
if
d$(x)
\0
its
restriction
i s conformal and s u r j e c t i v e ;
; such a map i s a submersion on
x £ H i s a s i n g u l a r point,
then rank.
d$(x) - 0 ;
i s an open map.
The theory of harmonic morphisms of Riemannian manifolds i s due p r i m a r i l y to Fuglede
[15]
. See a l s o
[23] .
We s h a l l use the stress-energy tion of
(5.2)
[3, Theorem 2 . 3 ]
Theorem.
Let
; see a l s o
tensor to e s t a b l i s h the following
generalisa-
[23] :
$ : (H.g) -* (N,h)
be a submersion which i s a harmonic morphism.
Then ( s e t t i n g n • dim H) a)
if
n • 2 , the fibres are minimal submanifolds
b)
i£_
a \ 2 , then the following properties are equivalent :
t i v e l y closed
i)
the fibres are minimal submanifolds
ii)
ye
iii)
the h o r i z o n t a l d i s t r i b u t i o n has mean curvature
iv)
the c h a r a c t e r i s t i c
F i r s t of a l l , we have
Take a point r
X 1 indices :
is a vertical field
;
;
(m-c-)-form
x,
vo
/ 2e
;
of the f o l i a t i o n i s r e l a ¬
[32] .
Proof.
with
j
X n
I ja.bii
- OX 12 , consequently
x e H and an orthonormal frame
h o r i z o n t a l and
;
e
I Si,j s n ;
X ,, n* J
,X m
n'lii.iin .
(X ) , a 1 i « im
S
w
- ~
near
g - $*h .
v
v e r t i c a l . Use the following ranges of
146 16
The map t
(5.3)
i s harmonic, so div
o
V
a
-
0 ,
therefore
)
Since the frame i s orthonormal
(5.4)
o -
J
i
" I where
lAl^.x.)
(5.5)
i
« A(x.,7 _ .)] , J t
X
H denotes horizontal p r o j e c t i o n . Choose
(5.3)
J
^
X. ; then
X (**h(X^.X > a
a
X^(X) , and using (5.4),
equation
becomes X U) + A f
0 -
• ^
v
A
)
+
X..X • A ( X . . v
X )
I
««'I.-'IV J r - ' ^ j - ' X j ( X ) + J, (mean curvature of f i b e r in J
2
Thus we have proved ( a ) , and ( i ) i f f
Now choose
(5.8)
r
A('
direction).
( i i ) in ( b ) .
X. = X , Equation (5.3)
0 =|x (A)
X^
becomes
V V
x
1 - | X U ) - AglHv^ X , X ) i r
r
;
= fx U) , xs^.x.'V r
1
- I X (A) - nX(mean curvature of horizontal d i s t r i b u t i o n i n
We now choose and we obtain ( i i )
X^ iff
X
direction).
to be i n the d i r e c t i o n of the v e r t i c a l p r o j e c t i o n of
(iii)
in (b).
?e
.
147
17
F i n a l l y , l e t us consider twisted c h a r a c t e r i s t i c point
x £ M
T (* ' ( t ( x > ) x for a l l Y
° f the submersion by assigning to each
T
]
X
dx.(jt;x .
(
n+1
X ...... n+J
!
X £ T ($ { * ( x ) ) , Y £ T (M) we have m X
m
Then the equivalence of Example.
x £ H ,
X ,Y) - 0 .
n
t
x (with Riemmannian s t r u c t u r e
( M , g ) ) . Thus i f
the submersion) i f for a l l
(5.4)
x
X ,,...,X i s an orthonormal base 0+1 m , then x,(x;Y , Y ) det< X ,Y > 4' ' n+l m r s x Y^ £ W • Say that X i s r e l a t i v e l y closed (with respect to
of
t
(m-n)-form
[ | , 3 2 l , we define the p o s s i b l y
the volume element of the f i b r e through
induced from that of
Q
( i ) and ( i v ) is merely an a p p l i c a t i o n of
[32, Prop 1] .
There are submersions which are harmonic morphisms, but which do
not s a t i s f y the equivalent conditions of Theorem 5.2b. Here i s an example. For i : IR x K - IK
k - 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 , we r e c a l l the Hopf construction, which produces a map by the formula
2
2
, ( z , w ) • ( | z | - [ w | , 2 zu) , using the norm, m u l t i p l i c a t i o n and conn
jugation of the appropriate r e a l d i v i s i o n algebra. I f Q
in K * ' with c e n t r e
o
and radius
I t i s easy to v e r i f y that
r , then
(5.5)
for any Kahier metrics
due to Van de Ven [36]
: Suppose that
T
of
and there are holomorphic
(5.6)
N a Riemann s u r f a c e . Then . : (M, g ) - . (N, h)
dim^M > 1 ; but here i s an example,
satisfying
Wj A >",
M onto any compact Riemann surface 1-forms
is a
M i s a compact complex surface with two l i -
nearly independent holomorphic [-forms u , , i s a holomorphic map
• ••
E?^ - o , being compact.
g,h on H,H, every holomorphic map
harmonic morphism. Such maps are rather rare i f
j If" x IK' - o-> L-^
(k-^*epheres ; and for
M be a Kahlerian manifold and
Let
2
' ( r ) + S ( r ) ; and o - * '(o),
$ i s a harmonic morphism, and that
they cannot be minimal submanifolds of
Example.
denotes the sphere k
$ ; S
i s a l s o a submersion. However, i t s fibres are a l l k • 2,4,8
S (r)
8 . , 8^
on
0 . Then there
N of genus
N such that * * ( B )
Suppose t h a t i n Theorem 5.2 we have dim M
k
<\
dim N - 1 , and that
S i. 2 ;
CIS k s 2 ) .
Ve^
is ver-
2 t i c a l . Then i t s t r a j e c t o r i e s are geodesies, so
Ve,
i s a function of
h o r i z o n t a l d i s t r i b u t i o n ( i o t e g r a b l e i n t h i s case) has mean curvature »o i t i s a function of
e.
, too. Otherwise s a i d ,
e
e
. The
Ve^ /2e^ ,
: M + E { >0) i s an
148
18
isoparametric function i n the sense of E . Cartan. For l i t e r a t u r e concerning these remarkable functions, see
(5.7)
Remark.
[10,58.5] . And [ 2 ] for further developments and examples.
I t i s reasonable to expect that an analogue of Theorem 5.2
l i d for Riemannian f o l i a t i o n s
F of
M(i.e.,
[24] . The idea would be to i n t e r p r e t dle of
(5.8)
those with b u n d l e - l i k e m e t r i c s ) ; see
f as • harmonic s e c t i o n of the Grassmann bun-
M , and then c a l c u l a t e u i t h i t s stress-energy tensor
Problem.
is va-
S^. .
I t would be i n t e r e s t i n g to know the extent to which Theorem 5.2
i s v a l i d for a r b i t r a r y harmonic morphisms. In the case of compact f i b e r s , i t can be stated on account of the following lemma.
Lemma.
If
pact f i b r e s and
g : (M,g)-.(N,b)
7e
vertical,
i s a nonconstant harmonic morphism with com-
then
C
* Proof.
* \
.
*
Without l o s s , we s h a l l assume that
M i s connected and 4
tive . How C i s a polar set [15] . so M - C i s connected * * i s connected, too.
Suppose
C,
^ 4 ,
if
verges to some point of
and l e t C
Now take any point so a l l
se
I
. Then
Y1
Y- - Since 1
s t a r t i n g at
s -'e^(Y^(s))
(because
Ve
Since
|M
t
C
y.
F • * y
' ( y ) . Let y
in
H
*
i s a submersion, there i s a h o r i z o n t a l l i f t
T
con-
with endpoint
y , ( I ) E F . Then 1 y
1
by a y.
i s compact, a subsequence of
(y^(l))
x £ C fl F . That i s a contradiction, for T y
(5.9)
If
with
i(x) = k |x I
,
: K - IR 2
sup ^*\{x) I
n
is a Z 1 <
2
T
(x)
converges to some y E ( - | { C ) . $
k-homogeneous polynomial harmonic morphism
, and normalised so that
: I 11 - 1 j
1 .
L
e ( y . ( l ) ) - C. , becau$ 1 1
i s constant ; indeed, -gSj. e^(y^(s)) = < V e ^ ( y ^ ( s ) ) , Y ' ( S ) > = 0
y
m
1
^(C )
is vertical). F
x.
y. - * ( x . ) , 1
can be joined to
point
T
r
e (x.) * o .
y E 8 - ${C ) , and set *
x. x
N - (C.) *
be a sequence such that
t
c.
y. £ N - t(C^) ; furthermore,
smooth path over
(x.) ^ M - C
: therefore
i s surjec-
149 19
Setting
r
£ S
1 0 - 1
Z
:|4.(x)| =
, we have the following results
1)
m-2 £
2)
the function
3)
r
111
in JR
x
[4(x)|
2
1
;
is isoparametric on
is a smooth submanifold of
[2] :
S
m
' ;
S™ ^ ; both K r and the fibre over 0 +
are minimal cones through the origin in IR™ ; : r+S
n
4)
the map
^ is a harmonic Riemannian submersion.
5)
Thus, with reference to Theorem (5.2), we find that for such a harmonic
morphism, the fiber over the origin in IR
D
(which lies in the image of
C ) is a I
minimal cone. (5.10) Problem.
7 4 3 Consider the smooth fibrations f - £. . : S * S with fibre S h,J
and structural group
S0(4) . (Here
s"
denotes the Euclidean
n-sphere, of suita-
ble radius ; and we use the notation of [9] ) . Their Euler number 4 4 H(t j ) tS ] - b+j - 1 i and their Pontyagin numbers p ( S ^) [S ] h
with
(
h
• 2{2h-l)
h(h-l) = 0 mod 56 . Do either of the following assumptions imply that $ is
the Hopf fibration ( i . e . , 1)
h - 0,1) :
Suppose that $ is a harmonic map ; according to Theorem (2.9), that is
equivalent to assuming 2)
div
Suppose that
S,
=
0 .
^ is a harmonic morphism.
I t is known [13] that i f * is a Riemannian submersion with totally geodesic fibres ( i . e . , VS. s 0 ) , then : is the Hopf fibration. t If the response is negative in case I , then perhaps the class [ ]€ir T
7
(S*) = Z • Z
[ 2
has no harmonic representative.
We are indebted to Professor B. Fuglede for calling our attention to the pa¬ per [31
. Recently he
superfluous in Lemma 5.8. appear in due course.
1
has informed us that the phrase "with compact fibres' is His proof leads to substantial generalization
and will
150 20
Appendix to Example (3.1'2)
(3.19) Let * immersion
be as i n ( 3 . 1 2 ) , then we can consider the higher order geometry of the
f : H
t i n g at a point ce at
x
to
+
V ; see [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 1 8 ]
x
. Let
y : E-> H
be a smooth curve i n
M star-
Y(O) , and parametrized by arc length. The p'th o s c u l a t i n g spa-
y i s the span of
]
D Y(x)
where
D/ds
"'' '' '
of
M at
ves y
in
M s t a r t i n g at
x
i s the
V-covariant d e r i v a t i v e along
-r
r (x) P
. The p'th o s c u l a t i n g space
i s the span of a l l the p'th o s c u l a t i n g spaces at x . Of course,
The higher order osculating spaces dimension
y
may vary with
T
T ^'^
x
to a l l c u r -
i s j u s t the tangent space
T (M)
may depend on the immersion ; and i t s
x .
Let
G(n,r ) denote the Grassmannian of r -spaces through the o r i g i n of V : P P endowed with i t s canonical Riemannian m e t r i c , which ue now denote by k ' ' . Let p
U c K
be an open subset on which
r
i s constant. The p'th
Gauss map •
P of the immersion
(3.20)
Y
.
!
P
* defined by
)
: U -+ V
P
Gauss map
) ,
p
V . Thus
v«
is
the
t
x
y^ .
(3.21) The p—normal space to in
t p )
' (x) - T ^ ' , viewed as a subspace of
»
*
is
; (U,g)-.(G(n,r ) , k p x •+ Y '
,
1 1
T ' * ' * . He define
the
H at
(p+1) —
x
i s the orthogonal complement
N
P
P
' ' <** T ' ^
fundamental form of the immersion at
x
by the
formula
where
P
V (d.) *
the d e r i v a t i v e
C(« d,
p + 1
T*(K) •
; and at
As i n example (3.12)
x
, '(T(V)) ,
p
ir' ' x
i s the
p—
covariant d i f f e r e n t i a l of
i s the projection
we consider the d i f f e r e n t i a l
T , , ( v ) -* N *lxj x dy
p
* ' , and obtain the
151 21
analogue of
(3.13)
:
(3.23) P r o p o s i t i o n .
I n any common domain of d e f i n i t i o n we have
dy
- P (P*",
I n the s p i r i t of the theorem of Ruh-Vilms, we s h a l l say that the immersion $ p
has p— order constant mean curvature i f Trace (vfi ^ * ' ' ) = o . Then He have the
I (3.24) C o r o l l a r y . Gauss map y
(p)
The map $ has
order constant mean curvature i f f i t s p —
. i s harmonic.
*
I n g e n e r a l , even i f
.-. has constant Oean curvature, i t w i l l not have p—
order constant mean curvature for (3.25) L e t
p—
p > \ , as we s h a l l see i n Example ( 3 . 2 3 ) .
M be a Riemann surface and n
> :(M,g) • (JK
g
a conformal metric on
i s an isometric immersion, we decompose the s t r e s s energy 1
tensor of i t s a s s o c i a t e d p** Gauss map > * t 2
(3.26) S
' S -°> • S
w
H . If
( 0
'
2 )
.
where
: M->G(n,r ) , as i n ( 4 . 2 ) and ( 4 . 6 ) : P S
t 0
-
2 )
-
2
S< '
0 )
. Now from P r o p o s i t i o n
(3.23) we have
3
2 7
S
< ' >
((P) n l "" i l " . -
(3.28) Example•
If
"I * - T H i s an E i n s t e i n manifold and
f : ti^' ^ T1 > * :
IR
i s a minimal immersion, then * so
y
i s sn immersion of constant mean curvature ; and
i s harmonic. By a theorem of Huto [26] , y
i s homothetic. By Lemma (3.29)
below, we find T y
(
2
)
+
-
E
j
R
( l )
( d y (e ),dy ) dy ( e . ) » * • • 1
This w i l l be zero only i f
dy,
.
maps the tangent space of
H at each point into a
( subspace of
TG(n,r^)
be f l a t [26]
. I n c i d e n t a l l y , i n (3.25)
metrics
g
of zero c u r v a t u r e . A necessary condition for that i s that M
on Riemann s u r f a c e s .
we always have examples of such E i n s t e i n
152 22
(3.29) Lemma. 7dy « * Trace vdy '
Edy P
+
l
)
y ' ' #
is nomothetic, so that
. then
I
W
- V Trace dy .
(
where
P
In the case when
T
p
R* '
denotes the curvature of
mal b a s i s for
G(n,r ) , and P
1 ,
i s an orthono-
I < 1 £ D
H•
Proof.
For
x € M ; choose vectors
(e.) 1
form an orthonormal b a s i s for
Trace
(e.)
W, <**» +
(
e j
) •
T H • and 7 e. x e. j
I
V^/"*''
51 .
7
7
t.
e.
dy
. such that at 1 i i Sm - 0 . Then for each i
x
the e. 1
C^K*,) < P )
(e. ) .
I
But 7 , Trace Ij
{Trace
Tdy * •
vdy.
( p
p )
*"
-
£
.
7 7 d e. e. .
- 7 Trace
H
^
(
p
)
(e.)
T
7dY,
R <
P
t p )
W
,
*
1
.
) (e.)
P
>
(.,) 1
. d
p )
T
*
<*><,.» dy< (e.) J # 1
.
The authors record t h e i r thanks to Dr. John C. Wood for h i s correspondence concerning material i n t h i s s e c t i o n .
153 23
REFERENCES.
[]]
G. Andrzejczak, On some form determined by a distribution on a Riemannian manifold. C o l l . Hath. 41 (1978)), 79-83.
[2]
P. Baird, Warwick Thesis. (In preparation).
LJJ
A. Bernard, E.A. Cambell, and A.M. Davie, Brownian motion and generalized analytic and inner functions. Ann. Inst. Fourier 29 (1979), 207-228.
[4]
E. Calabi, Minimal immersions of surfaces in Euclidean spheres. J . Diff. Geo.
[5l
1 (1967), 111-125.
E . Calabi, Quelques applications de l'analyse complexe aux surfaces d'aire minima. Topics in complex manifolds. Univ. Montreal (1967), 59-81.
[6]
S.S. Chern, On the minimal immersions of the two-sphere in a space of constant curvature. Problems in Analysis. Princeton (1970), 27-40.
[7]
S.S. Chern, On minimal spheres in the four-sphere. Studies and Essays Presented to Y.H. Chen. Taiwan (1970), 137-150.
[8]
n
A.M. Din and H . J . Zakrzewski, General classical solutions in the CP ' model. Lapp. Annecy (1980).
[93
J . Eells and N.H. Kuiper, An invariant for certain smooth manifolds. Ann. di Mat. 60 (1963), 93-110.
[101
J . Eells and L . Lemaire, A report on harmonic maps. Bull. London Math. Soc. 10 (1978),
[11]
1-68.
J . Eells and J.H,Sampson, Harmonic mappings of Riemannian manifolds. Am. J . Math. 86 (1969),
109-160.
El2]
J . Eells and J . C . Wood, Harmonic spheres in projective spaces.To appear.
[13]
R.H. Escobales, Riemannian submersions uith totally geodesic fibres. J . Diff. Geo.
10 (1975), 2S3-276.
114}
The Feynman Lectures on Physics. Addison-Wesley (1964).
Il5]
B. Fuglede, Harmonic morphism between Riemannian manifolds. Ann. Institut Fourier
28 (1978), 107-144.
154 24 [16]
G. Gerardi, C. Meyers, and M. De Roo, On the self-duality of solutions of the Yang-Mills equations. Physics Letters 73B <1978), 468-470.
[17]
V. Giaser and R. Stora, Regular solution of the CP^ models and further generalizations. (Manuscript 1980).
[18]
P. Griffiths and J . Harris, Algebraic geometry and local differential geometry. Ann. E.N.S. 12 (1979), 355-432.
[19]
S-W. Hawking and G.F.R. E l l i s , The large scale structure of space time. Cambridge Monographs on Matb. Physics (1973).
[ 20]
D. Hilbert, Die Grundlagen der Physik; Nachr. Ges. Hiss. Gottingeo (1915), 395-407 ; (1917), 53-76. And Math. Ann. 92 (1924), 1-32.
[21]
D. Hoffman and R. Osserman, The area of the generalized Gaussian image and the stability of minimal surface in
[ 22]
S
n
n
and lR . Preprint (1980).
D. Hoffman and R. Osserman, The geometry of the generalized Gauss map. Preprint (1980).
[ 23]
I . Ishihara, A mapping of Riemannian manifolds which preserves harmonic functions. J . Math. Kyoto Univ. 19 (1979), 215-229.
[24]
F.W. Kamber and P. Tondeur, Harmonic foliations. Preprint (1980).
[ 25]
Y. Muto, Critical Riemannian metrics. Tensor, N.S. 29 (1975), 125-133.
[ 26]
Y. Muto, Submanifolds of a Euclidean space with nomothetic Gauss map. J.Math. Soc. Japan, vol 32, n°3 (1980).
[ 27]
M. Obata, The Gauss map of immersions of Riemannian manifolds in spaces of constant curvature. J . Diff. Geo. 2 (1968), 217-223.
[ 28]
E.M. Patterson, A class of c r i t i c a l Riemannian metrics. Univ. Aberdeen (1980X
[ 29]
R.C. Reilly, On the Hessian of a function and the curvatures of its graph. Mich. Math. J . 20 (1973), 373-383.
[ 30]
R.C. Reilly, Variational properties of functions of the mean curvatures for hypersurfaces in space forms.
[ 31]
E.A. Ruh and J . Vilms, The tension field of the Gauss map. Trans. A.M.S. 149 (1970), 569-573.
155
25
[32]
B- gummier, Quelques n o t i o n s simples en geomStrie riemannienne e t l e u r s a p p l i c a t i o n s aux f e u i l l e t a g e s compacts, Comm. Math- Helv. 54 (1979), 224-239,
[331
Sachs and H . H . Wu, General r e l a t i v i t y f o r mathematicians. Springer Graduate Texts 48 (1977),
[34]
H . C . J . Sealey,
Some p r o p e r t i e s o f harmonic mappings. Warwick Thesis (1980).
[35]
G. T a n y i , Harmonic maps i n mechanics. P r e p r i n t , Univ. Yaoundi ( 1 9 7 7 ) .
[36 ]
G. T o t h , One-parameter curvature. Preprint
[37]
f a m i l i e s o f harmonic maps i n t o spaces o f constant
(I960).
A. Van de Ven, On the Chern numbers o f surfaces
o f general t y p e . I n v . Math.
36 (1976), 285-293. [33]
J . V i l m s , T o t a l l y geodesic maps. J . D i f f .
Geo. 4 (1970), 73-79.
[39]
P.G. Walczak, On f o l i a t i o n s w i t h leaves s a t i s f y i n g some g e o m e t r i c a l c o n d i t i o n s . I n s t . Math. PAN 1980. n ° 2 1 0 .
[40]
H. Weyl, Space, t i m e , m a t t e r . Dover 1950.
[41]
C M . Wood, Warwick T h e s i s . ( I n p r e p a r a t i o n ) .
[42]
J . C . Wood, C o n f o r m a l i t y and h o l o m o r p h i c i t y o f c e r t a i n harmonic maps. print
1980).
(Pre-
156
MAPS OF MINIMUM ENERGY J. E E L L S AND J . C. WOOD
1. Introduction
It is well known that a holomorphic map
1
Any map
which minimises energy is
(We write these alternatives togelher as ±holomorphic.) In fact, we can take any Riemannian metric on P'. THEOREM
(Siu-Vau [15]).
1
Any map tp: P -» P" which minimises energy is
± hoiomorphic.
In fact, they draw that conclusion when the target is any compact Kahier n-manifold N with strictly positive holomorphic bisectional curvature and go on to provide a proof of Frankefs conjecture that N is biholomorphically isomorphic to P" THEOREM
(Siu [14]).
/ / M has genus 1, then any map
energy is + holomorphic.
As a consequence, let us note that such a tj> must have degree ^ ± 1 - It is not known to us whether there exists a harmonic map $: M -> P" of degree ± 1 , where genus M = 1 and n ^ 2. The purpose of this note is to generalise these results as follows. For any almost complex manifold N let $ denote the set of integral homology classes [yj in H (N) represented by holomorphic maps y: P -* N. Note that if such a y is nonconstant, ihen [v] has infinite order in H {N). 2
1
2
T H E O R E M . Let M be a closed Riemann surface and N a simply-connected Kahier manifold. Iftp: M -> N minimises energy in its homotopy class and i/[0] € then tp is holomorphic. (//[<£] 6 — M, then tp is antiholomorphic.) 1
The case where H {N) = Z and is generated by a holomorphic map P -* N is particularly imporlant; for then H iN) = i u ( — 3(\ and we have the following. 2
2
Received 18 January, 1980. [J.
LONDON MATH.
Soc.
(2), (1981),
303-310]
157 l EELLS AND J. C. WOOD
304
COROLLARY L Let M be a closed Riemann surface and N a simply-connected Kahier manifold with H (N) — Z generated by a holomorphic map P -» N. Then any map tp: M -*. N with minimum energy is + holomorphic. 1
2
There are two points in our proof (which, incidentally, is entirely different from those of [14, 15]). One is, an exploitation of the above-mentioned result of Lemaire—which in turn is an application of a construction due to Morrey [10; Theorem 1.2]; the argument is essentially 2-dimensional, being based on the conformal invariance of the energy functional (§3). The second point is a simple closure property for holomorphic maps between almost Kahier manifolds, based on an observation of Lichnerowicz [8]; specifically, we define f-holomorphic maps, which for 2-dimensional targets are like the e-conformal maps of Morrey [10; Chapter 1]. The authors express their gratitude to Luc Lemaire for discovering and analysing two errors in a preliminary version of this paper.
2. Discussion of the hypotheses, and examples
1. Tacitly we have assumed that all maps are continuous and belong to the Sobolev class L \ . That condition insures that an extremal of the energy functional is C " [2; §3.6]. See also [2; §10.12]. 2. The condition that \_4>~]e® (or [<£] e -®) cannot be omitted from the Theorem. For example, the maps P -> P x P defined by z -* (z\z~'), where k,l are positive integers, are of minimum energy in their homotopy classes, but are not ± holomorphic. 1
1
1
3. The condition of minimum energy cannot be omitted from Corollary 1, Tor there are harmonic maps P - » P " ( 0 2) which are not ±holomorphic [3]. 1
4. The theorem remains true if "'Kahier" is replaced by '"almost Kahier". However in this case it is difficult to determine when H {N,Z) is holomorphically generated. 2
5. Since N is simply-connected, a classical theorem of Hurewicz provides a canonical isomorphism h : n (N) -* H {N). Consequently our definition of i# could have been formulated in terms of homotopy classes. 2
2
If N is not simply-connected, then the conclusion of the theorem can be expected only under substantially modified conditions. For instance, suppose n,(N) £ 0 and it (N) — 0. Then every homotopy class H e [Ai, /V] is represented by a map of minimum energy [6, 11]—and these are not ±holomorphic, in general. Now, let Q be a Riemann surface of genus ^ 1. Then Corollary 1 fails for certain minimal maps tp : M -> P x Q: if we choose tp = 4>i) so that tp, : M — P' is holomorphic and 4> : M -* Q is not holomorphic but minimising energy, then E{ip) = E(4> )+E{
1
2
i
2
6. A theorem of Sacks-Uhlenbeck [11] asserts that if N is a compact simplyconnected Riemannian manifold, then H [N) is generated by maps P' -» N of minimum energy, each such map being a minimal branched immersion. 2
158 MAPS O F M I N I M U M
ENERGY
305
By way of contrast, there are compact simply-connected Kahier manifolds N for which any holomorphic map tp : M -* N is constant, where M is any compact Riemann surface. For instance, consider K-3 surfaces. (These are compact simply-connected Kahlerian surfaces, characterised by the conditions H {N, E> ) — 0 and c (S) — 0; they are all diffeomorphic to a nonsingular quartic in P , and H (N) — Z . ) According to a theorem of Yau [19], they all admit Ricci-flat Kahier metrics. It is known [9] that certain K-3 surfaces carry no curves. Consequently, any holomorphic map of a compact Riemann surface M into N is necessarily constant, (We are indebted to Mites Reid for instruction on K-3 surfaces.) Thus we have examples of compact simply-connected Kahier manifolds N with H {N) generated by maps of minimum energy which are not + holomorphic. l
N
t
3
2 2
2
2
7. On the other hand, there are many compact simply-connected Kahier manifolds N satisfying the conditions of Corollary 1. We note some standard examples, without proof. Example. Consider the Grassmannian G{k,k + n) of complex it-planes through the origin in C* . We have the homogeneous space representation + n
G(k,k + n) = U(k + n)/U(k)xU(n) and P" -
LHl+n)/U{l)xU(n).
There are canonical embeddings ]
n
P -* P -*... -> U(k + n)/U(k)xU{n). 1
The embedding P -*G{k,k+n) H (G{k,k+n)) = Z.
is totally geodesic, holomorphic, and generates
2
Example. We may proceed similarly for the complex quadrics 1
6. = SO(2 + n)/SO(2)xSO(n) = {[z,
JjJeP *":^/
=0}.
We have canonical embeddings 1
P - SO(3)/SO(2)xSO(l)-
... - SO(2 + n)/SO(2)xSO{n)
Here H (Q„) = Z if n f 2; if n = 2, then H {Q„) = Z 0 Z , and since Q biholomorphic to P x P 2
2
1
t
is
l
m = ( ( r , s ) e Z © Z : r , s ^ 0} 2
We may proceed similarly for the space SO(2n)/U{n) of complex structures on R ": P' = S0(4}/U(2) -* ... -» SO{2n)/U(n)
(n > 2).
As an application of the Theorem with N — Q , we cite the following. n
159 306
J . E E L L S AND J. C WOOD 2
2. If
2
Proof. We recall that y* is antiholomorphic if and only if q) is a minimal immersion [1] and lhat y* is holomorphic if and only if M = S . Thus if n £ 2, the assertion follows immediately from Corollary 1. If » = 2 we appeal to Blaschke's theorem (see [3; §6] for details), which asserts that the homology class f_y*] e H (Q ) has the form [y*] = ( 1 - p ) [ S ] + (1-p)[S_], where Q is expressed as the product S+ x S _ of two projective lines and p = genus Af. Thus, in the case when n = 2, Corollary 2 follows from our Theorem. 2
2
+
2
2
n+ 1
Example. If N is a hyperplane in P or degree d < In, then iV contains a linear subspace P of P " ; and it generates H (N) = Z (n ^ 2). 1
+1
2
8. Problem. Is the Theorem valid if we define St more generally as the set of integral homology classes expressible in the form £ *f&i]> where J. ^ 0 and y,: P' -* N are hoiomorphic maps? ;
9. On any Kahlerian manifold N satisfying the hypotheses of our Theorem we may take any Kahier metric compatible with the given complex structure. 10. Problem. If M is a compact non-orientable surface with given conformal structure, is a map
Q
3. Nearly holomorphic maps Let M, N be Kahier manifolds with Af compact, and
dtp: T (M) -
0A
d$ = b%:T'-°(M)
dtp : T'-°(M) -* T '°(iV),
0
i
U0
T {N);
also, d^^dqS:
l
T°- (M)->
T (N),
->
T°-'(N).
That induces a decomposition of the energy density e(tp) = e'(
160 MAPS O F MINIMUM ENERGY 2
307
2
e'(tp) — \\dtp\\ and e"(
jV'Wdx
E{
M
= E'{
M
Setting K(tp) = E'(
For e > 0 we say that a map
E"(4>) < E. We say that a homotopy class Jf of maps M -* N contains nearly holomorphic maps if for every E > 0 there is an £-holomorphic map in jtf, that is, if inf£"| = 0 . r
Of course, a holomorphic map is e-holomorphic for all e > 0. There is an analogous notion of containing nearly anti-holomorphic maps. It is known [8] that if a homotopy class contains both a holomorphic map and an antiholomorphic map, then both are constant. PROPOSITION !. If contains nearly holomorphic maps, then any map tp of minimum energy is holomorphic.
Proof. If tp minimises E, then
are almost Hermltian manifolds, and
e"Wo
If M and N are compact, then ,
£"(i>oaS) ^ 2maxe'(i/')£"(^) + 2maxe"(^)£ ( >). v
Proof.
We have 1
e"(yo
2
^ \\m\\ i i ^ i i + i w i i i i t V i i , 2
2
1
2
^ 2 | | # | f | | ^ | | + 2||cty|| \\d
2
using {A + Bf % 2-4 -t-2B . The lemma follows immediately. PROPOSITION 2. Let M, N, P be almost Hermltian manifolds with M, N compact. Let Jr"e[M,/V], J f E [/V,/?] be homotopy classes. Suppose Jf contains nearly
161
308
I. E E L L S AND J. C WOOD
holomorphic maps and Jf contains a holomorphic map, or vice versa. o JC == \\p o tp '•
Then
Proof. Given E > 0, choose ^ e to be holomorphic. Then choose
4. Proof of our main results
The following lemma and proposition should be compared with Morrey [10; Theorem 1.2] and Lemaire [6,9]. L E M M A 3. Let D be the closed unit disc of C and S the Euclidean 2-sphere. For any point qeS, s > 0, and integer d there exists a continuous piecewise smooth map f: (£>, BD) - (S,q) of degree d such that E(f) < |tf|Area(S) + e and E"(f) < e if d^O, and £'{/) < eifdsi 0.
Proof. If d = 0, define f(D) = q. Otherwise, without loss of generality we may suppose that d > 0. Let (r, 6) be polar coordinates in D and let B be the concentric disc of radius | j let (R, w] be polar coordinates on S centred at q, and let C be the polar cap 0 ^ R < n (0 < n < n; the number n will be chosen in the course of the proof). We define / ; D -* S as follows. On B define / to be the unique holomorphic map [B,dB)-*(S-C,8C) with boundary values / ( i , 0 ) = (n,d &). On the annulus D — 8 define f: D-B -> C by f{r,8) = (2(1 -r)n, d • 8). Then e"{f\ ) = 0, and, for e
(r,8)eD-B, e"[f\ - )^e(f\ . ), D
e(f\ - ) D
2
where h = h ,dR Kf
E"(f)
B
0 B
= UW' + WM'/r
B
2
+ h „dca u
2
= h^-^
+
is the polar representation of the metric h on S; thus 2
s: (max /? )(4i! )Area(D-B) + m a x A c
2
h^d/r) ,
"
RR
fdY
-\dA. ,r,
o-a
Now as if -* 0 we have max /i^„ -* 0 and max h„ remains bounded. Therefore, given E > 0 we can choose i| sufficiently small that both right hand members are less than E/2. Then £ " ( / ) < s. Finally, E{f\ ) = Area (/| ) because f\ is conformal [4; §4]. c
B
c
B
E(f)
R
B
= £ ( / | ) - r £ ( / | . ) ^ rf. Area(S) + £. fl
D
fl
PROPOSITION 3. Let M be a closed Riemann surface and S the Euclidean 2-sphere: take q£S. Then for any E > 0 and integer d there is a smooth map f:M -* S of degree d such that
£ ( / ) < |d|Area(S) + e; £"(/) < e if
d>0;
162
MAPS
OF
MINIMUM
ENERGY
309
and E'(f) < £ if
i&Q.
Proof. Choose a disc D cz M; by the conformal invariance of E and £", we can assume that D is the unit disc. Define / ; D -» S as in Lemma 3, and f(M — D) — q. Then / is a continuous piecewise smooth map with the desired properties; clearly f can be approximated to satisfy the requirements of Proposition 3. Lemaire derives his result quoted in Section 1 from Proposition 3, by noting that if tp : Af -» S minimises energy, then E{tp) — Area (tp), and so tp is conformal. Proof of the Theorem. By Proposition 1, it suffices to show that the homotopy class Jf of tp contains nearly holomorphic maps. Firstly tb is homotopic to a map factoring through a standard 2-sphere S:
M
. Af
Indeed, we can take a CW decomposition of M,N in which Af is formed by attaching a single 2-cell to a bouquet of circles, and the 2-skeleton of N is a bouquet of 2-spheres. Then deform
t
References 1. S. S. Chern and R. Osserman, "Complete minimal surfaces in Euclidean n-space". J. Analyse Math., 19 (1967), 15-34. 2. J. Eells and L. Lemaire. "A report on harmonic maps", Bull. London Math. Soc, 10 (1978), 1-68. 3. J. Eells and L. Lemaire, "On the construction of harmonic and holomorphic maps between surfaces", preprint, Institut des Hautes Eludes Scienlifiques. 1978. 4. J. Eells and J. H. Sampson, "Harmonic mappings of Riemannian manifolds", Amer. J. Math., 84 (1964), 109-160. 5. J. Eells and J. C. Wood, "Restrictions on harmonic maps of surfaces". Topology, 15 (1976), 263-266. 6. L. Lemaire, "Applications harmoniques de surfaces riemanniennes", J. Differential Geom., 13 (1978) 51-78. 7. L. Lemaire, "Minima and critical points of Ihe energy in dimension two". Global Differential Geometry/Global Analysis, Proceedings of a Conference, Berlin, 1979.
8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
Lecture Notes in
Mathematics (Springer. Berlin, to appear). A. Lichnerowicz. "Applications harmoniques et varietes kahier iennes". Sjmp. Math 3 (1970) 341— 402. A. L Mayer, "Families of K-3 surfaces". Klagoya Math J.. 48 (1973). 1-17. C. B. Morrey. "The problem of Plateau on a Riemannian manifold", Ann. of Math., 49 (1948) 807-851. J. Sacks and K. Uhlenbeck, 'The existence of minimal immersions of two-spheres". Bull. Amer. Math. Soc, 83 (1977). 1033-1036. I. R. Safarevit, et al. Algebraic surfaces. Translations of the American Mathematical Society (American Mathematical Society, Providence. 1967). Y. -T. Siu. "The com plei-analy! icily of harmonic maps and the strong rigidity of compact Kahier manifolds", Ann. of Math., to appear.
163 310
MAPS OF MINIMUM ENERGY
14. Y. -T. Siu. "Some remarks on The complex analyticity of harmonic maps". Southeast Asian Bull Math.. 3 11979), 240-253. 15. Y. -T. Siu and S. -T. Yau. "Compact Kahier manifolds of positive bisectional curvature", preprint, Stanford University. 1979. 16. D. Toledo. "Harmonic maps from surfaces into certain Kahier manifolds". Math Scand., 45 (1979). 13-26. 17. J . C . Wood, •"Holomorphicity of certain harmonic maps from a surface to complex projective N-space". J. London Math. Soc. (2), 20 [1979), 137-142. 18. J . C . Wood. "Conform alky and holomorphicity of certain harmonic maps", preprint. University of Leeds, 1979. 19. S. -T. Yau. "On the Ricci curvature of a compact Kahier manifold and the complex Monge-Ampere equation". Comm. Pure & Appl. Mailt, 31 (1978). 339-411.
Mathematics Institute, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4 7AL. Department of Pure Mathematics. University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT.
164 latituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica Francesco Severi Symposia Mathematics Volume X X V I [ 19821
THE OF
EXISTENCE CERTAIN
AND CONSTRUCTION H A R M O N I C M A P S {*)
J . E E L L S and J . C . W O O D (**)
Introduction. This paper studies two types of interrelationships between harmonic and holomorphic maps. Pirstly, we recall some theorems asserting the holomorphicity of harmonic maps from a Riemann surface M to complex projective m-space P . These generalize a theorem of the authors [ E - W l ] which asserts that any harmonic map from a compact Biemann surface of genus j> (i£ 0) to the 2-sphere P is holomorphic if its degree ^p. This last result has the corollary that there exists no harmonic map of degree one from the 2-torus to the 2-sphere P' (whatever metrics these are given). n
!
For some time the question: does there exist a harmonic map of degree one from the 2-torus to P" has been open. We answer this by discussing a method of constructing certain harmonic maps of an arbitrary Riemann surface into P" and Grassmannians from holomorphic maps. This method is based on work of Din-Zakrzewski [D-Zl], Burns and Glaser-Stora [G-S] and gives all harmonic maps into P from the 2-sphere and all harmonic maps into P" of non-zero degree from the 2-torus. Using this method we can assert that, for n ^ 2, there exist harmonic non-holomorphic maps to complex projective n-space (i) of all degrees from the torus and the sphere, (ii) of degrees 0 or S p -f 1 from a compact Riemann surface of genus p. These results contrast sharply with the case n = 1. n
Full proofs of these results will appear in [E-W3]. We should like to thank K . Abe, M. Guest, M. Ishida, M. Murray, M. S. Narasimhan, J . Rawnsley and R . Stora for stimulating conversations on the above subject matter. (*) I risultati conseguiti in questo lavoro sono stati espoati nelle conferenze tenute il 26 maggio 1981. (**) Research supported by the Sonderforschungsbereioh t Theoretiache Mathematik s, Universitat Bonn.
165 124
J . E e l l s and J . C . Wood
1, Harmonic and holomorphic maps. m
{A) A map
9 ' = 2 T-JS*>
? =
2
The equation 3"y — 0 is a first order linear elliptic system for the » components (gj , ...,
n
Trace 3 ' 3 > = 0 where M as T r a c e 3 ' 3 " = y ~Ar=- . = i dz" dz a
a
The equation Traee d'd"q> — 0 is a second-order linear elliptic system in divergence form. We observe that every ± holomorphic map is harmonic. A comparison of the theories of harmonic and ± holomorphic maps shows, in particular, that each has substantial advantages that the other lacks. For instance, 1) ± holomorphic maps are closed under compositions; harmonic maps compose only under special circumstances ( s e e [ E - L l ] ) ; 2) harmonic maps are the extrema of the energy integral E(f) = iij\d
m
m
(integration with respect to Lebesgue measure on C over any compact domain in U). (B) Consider now the problem of transferring these notions to maps tp: M -> N between complex manifolds. The concept of ± holomorphic maps has an immediate extension, because of 1) above. On the other hand, globalization of the concept of harmonic maps is much more subtle. I n particular, starting from the characterization
166 The existence and construction of certain hormonio maps
126
of harmonic map in terms of the variational integral E defined in 2), we see that we need Hermitian metrics on both M and N in order to have a good norm for the partial differentials d'tp and d"
d'dY+VWV) yl
here 1%, = h (d hf ) a
x
=0
(1 ^ y < n);
are the Christoffel symbols of N.
(D) Our primary objective is to study the interrelationships between harmonic and ± holomorphic maps
2. Existence and holomorphicity of harmonic maps. (A) For a survey of existence theory relevant to these lectures we suppose that M and N are compact Eiemannian manifolds. The first major result was proved by the first author and J . Sampson [13-8] j
167 126
J . Eslla and J . C. Wood
namely, if N has non-positive Biemannian sectional curvatures then in any homotopy class of maps M N there exists a harmonic map which is a minimum of E in its homotopy class. Hartman [Ha] proved uniqueness (with some trivial exceptions) under the hypothesis that N has strictly negative Riemannian sectional curvatures. Such theorems can be used to study homotopy problems, for example the fundamental group of a manifold of negative curvature [Wo2]. {B) Now suppose that M is a Riemann surface. Then L . Lemaire [Le] and J . Sacks-K. Uhlenbeck [S-U] proved existence of a harmonic map under the weaker hypothesis that the seeond homotopy group of N is zero (see also [S-Y]). (<7) The first interesting case not covered by the existence theorem is when N is the 2-sphere S*. Let M denote a compact Riemann surface without boundary, of genus j i ^ O . Then we have a holomorphicity theorem: p
2
[E-W] Any harmonic map M„ S of degree 3: p is holomorphic. I n particular, any harmonic map S S is ^ holomorphic and any harmonic map from the 2-torus T' to the 2-sphere of non-zero degree is ± holomorphic. The last statement implies the first non-existence theorem for harmonic maps: 2
1
1
[E-W]
There is no harmonic map from the 2-torus to the 2-sphere of degree 1 .
I n these theorems the spaces may be given any smooth metrics. I n contrast to the holomorphicity theorem, Lemaire shows [Le2]: For any, d, 0 d g p — 1, there exists a Biemann surface M„ and a harmonic non-holomorphic map M ^>-8* of degree d. Here S is given a sufficiently symmetrical metric. For related non-orientable cases see [ E - L 2 ] . 1
v
(_Z>) I n the case that the domain is a manifold-with-boundary there are existence results for harmonic maps similar to these in [A) and [B), see [Ham, Le3], The second author announces the following non-existence result [Wo6]: m
Let
Here D may have its standard metric or certain other metrics and there are variants for harmonic maps from annuli etc., see [Wo6].
168 The existence and construction of certain harmonic maps
127
For m = 2, this result was given by Lemaire [ L e i ] : it is the first non-existence result for dimension greater than two; there are, as yet, no non-existence results in the boundaryless case for such dimensions. (E) We return now to the consideration of harmonic maps between manifolds without boundary. The second interesting case not covered by the existence theory is that of harmonic maps from a Riemann surface to complex projective space P" equipped with its Fubini-Study metric of constant holomorphic sectional curvature 4. Homotopy classes of maps M„ P" are classified by their degree = degree of the induced map on second cohomology. There are several known holomorphicity theorems generalizing that of § 2G: [Wo4] Let tp: M -s- P" be a harmonic map of degree p . Suppose that for all x e M, dxp. (T,M ) is contained in a one-dimensional complex subspace of T , P {i.e. a two real-dimensional subspace of T ^ P " which is closed under the action of the almost-complex structure). Then tp is holomorphic. I n fact, the last condition need only be approximately satisfied; note that it is automatic if ti = l and so the theorem reduces to that of §2(7. v
c
v
n
W l
[Wo4]
Any harmonic map M -> P" of degree 2j 2p — 1 such that the (0,1) energy E"(tp) s|f.3*$>||-* is less than jifdegrp- (2p— 2)} is holomorphic. v
M
For a further theorem of this type see [Wo5]. We have a different type of result involving minimality of the energy [E-W3] (given by Lemaire [Lei] for n = 1): Any harmonic map M -> P" of absolute minimum energy within its homotopy class is J~ holomorphic. B
For low genus the condition of absolute minimum energy can be relaxed: [Si-Y, S i l ] . For p = 0 or 1 any harmonic map M P" of index 0 is ± holomorphic (c.f. § 6B). A. Futaki [Fu] gives further minimum energy theorems for p — 0. s
(F) The results above show that harmonic maps M„ P" satisfying further conditions are ± holomorphic. We can get a second type of result by relaxing the condition of holomorphicity. Firstly, recall that a map tp: M ->• N between Riemannian manifolds is said to be (weakly) conformal if there exists a smooth function X: M -> - y [ 0 , co) such that ||<%(X)|| = for all xe M, XeT^M. A map between Riemann surfaces is weakly conformal if and only if it is ± holomorphic. A ±_ holomorphic map from a Riemann sur-
169 128
J . Eolls and J . C . Wood
face to an almost Hermitian manifold is weakly conformal; of course, the converse is false. The second statement of § 2C above generalizes to the theorem [Wol]: any harmonic map from the 2-sphere to an arbitrary Riemannian manifold is weakly conformal. This result can be improved for harmonic maps into P" as follows: say that a map tp: M - » P" from a Riemann surface M is (complex) isotropic (earlier terminology: strongly pseudoholomorphic) if it satisfies at each point of M
(2.1)
<(D')*V, <-*>")V> = 0
all
fi^l.
Here .D' and D" denote the (1, 0) and (0,1) parts of the connection D on
sm
[ D - Z l , G-S]
Any harmonic map tp: S*
P" is
isotropic.
[E-W3]
Any harmonic map cp: T ^ P" » / non-zero degree is isotropic .
!
These may be regarded as generalizations of the second and third results of § 2(7.
3. The clarification theorem. (A) I t is reasonable to expeet that in the near future we shall acquire a rather full knowledge of the harmonic maps of Riemann surfaces into irreducible Hermitian symmetric spaces—given knowledge of such holomorphic maps. Let us map out a strategy. The irreducible Hermitian symmetric spaces are divided into six classes of dual pairs [He]. Each pair has a compact and a noncompact form and canonical metrics of curvature s 0 and ^ 0 respectively. The compact form is a simply connected projective manifold. Tbe noncompact forms are naturally embedded as Stein manifolds in their duals [Bo]. I n fact the noncompact form is one of a finite
170 The existence and construction of certain harmonic maps
129
number of orbits of a certain Lie group action on the compact form; the others of these orbits have pseudo-Kahler metrics (not definite) [Wol]. (B)
EXAMPLE:
Let C "
+ 1
=
{(s",
z*): z* e C } .
For a, w e C
n + 1
define Q(z, w) = 2z*«5*. Then C"+'\0 = {z: Q(z, z) > 0} contains the i-o unit sphere = {z: Q(z, z) — 1}. Its tangent space T,S* has horizontal subspace TfS*** = {*>e TJ3** : BeQ{iz, w) = 0}. F i x c > 0 and set ft(X, J ) = 2/c ReQLX, J ) . Then fe| H . „ is positive definite. H+1
1
1
r
S n
The natural multiplication of C* = C \ 0 on the components of C " \ 0 is a free holomorphic action whose quotient is P": n: C"+'\0 -*• -*• P". The U(l) action on S is free and defines a submersion n: P» with tfoi(z): T f S*** -> T P " an isometry. + l
, n + 1
1
m
Alternatively,
set
5(2, w) = z*w° — ^z*w*. 2n+1
Then
TP=
n+
{zeC ':
+ 1
(f(*. •) > 0} contains S = { s e C " : Q(z, z) = l } . Its tangent space TjflM1 = ( w e C : Re#(», w) = 0} has horizontal subspace n f l
TfS""*
1
= {we T,S*-*>:
Re0(iw>, z) = 0} .
Fix c < 0 and set £(2T, Y ) = — 2/e Re<3(X, T ) . Then K L M U M is positive definite. Now Ty* is C*-stable in C"+ \0 and the quotient of W by C * is H " : = { M E C > : |W>| < 1{. I n fact we have a commutative diagram l
1
0
, B + I
where 5i{2 , «•) = ( a / ? , T h e set S is U(l) stable and the action of U{1) on it defines a submersion n: -> H", with 0
dn(z):
1
TfS "*
1
-> T
m
H" an isometry.
Now i is a holomorphic embedding of the complex hyperbolic space H" into P" and H", P" are duals in the sense mentioned in (A). The metric ft on P" is the Fubini-Study metric of constant positive holomorphic sectional curvature. The metric h on H" is the Bergman metric of constant negative holomorphic sectional curvature. Of course i is not an isometric embedding but it is possible to relate certain harmonic maps into H" with holomorphic maps via the classification theorem below; the details will appear elsewhere.
171 130
J . Eells and J . C. Wood
(C) The classification theorem. Let M be a Riemann surface (not necessarily compact) and let / : M P" be a holomorphic map which is full, i.e., does not have image in any projective subspace. We define its associated curves f : M G {C ) for O ^ K ^ » as follows: Let xeM. L e t /p: U —> C \ 0 be a lift of / over a coordinate open set V of M with complex coordinate z which contains x. To be consistent with our D', D" notation we let 3', 3" denote djds, djdz. Form the multivector /r/A37r/A--.A3'7o- If this is non-zero at x, set f„(x) = = (a 4" l)-dimensional subspace determined by the multivector. Then f is well-defined independently of the local coordinate used and (by holomorphicity) may be extended to points xeM where the multivector is zero {see [Wu]). Note that = it is convenient to set f_j = zero map. Using 3" derivatives in place of 3' derivatives, we can define in a similar manner the associated curves of an antiholomorphic map. We define the polar curve g: M P " of / as the antiholomorphic map g = f£_ M > f?„(C" ) A> fl|(C« ) = P"; / and g satisfy the isotropy relations +1
a
a+1
B + 1
a
+1
+1
l
(3.1)
f ign a
for a, ^ 0 ,
or, in terms of local lifts f
n
a
+
S < n - l
and g of / and g; G
W%r, d"%> = 0 + i
where < , ) is the standard Hermitian inner product on C " . Thus, given a full holomorphic map / : M P" and an integer r, 0^ « we may define a map
1
f,_,(x) -nf (x) r
or equivalently (3.3)
= (/,_ ^)0ff _.(a'))1
L
s
where g is the polar of / , and s = n — r. CLASSIFICATION T H E O R E M : Let M be an arbitrary Riemann surface. The formula (3.2) defines a bijective correspondence between full isotropic harmonic maps cp: M -> P" and pairs (f, r) xvhere f: M P" is a full holomorphic map and t an integer 0 £ r ^ n. (D) We shall not present a full proof of the theorem, for which we refer the reader to [E-W3]; but will sketch the most important points in § 4 and § 5.
172 The existence and construction of certain harmonic maps
131
R E M A R K : I f M is compact it is easily seen that deg
r
(E) Applications. Combining the classification theorem with the theorems of § 2F asserting isotropy we have COROLLARY: between
The formula (3.2) defines a bijective correspondence
i) full harmonic maps
a
ii) [E-W3] full harmonic maps
r-1
Two further cases are given in [E-W3]. (F) Remarks, (i) The case (i) was essentially given by DinZakrzewski [D-Zl, D-Z2] and Glaser-Stora [G-S] and was discovered independently by D . Burns. We believe that some difficulties in the analysis in [G-S] are clarified by our approach [E-W3] especially in our formulation of the inverse transform g> ~> (/, r) using associated curves. (ii) Say that a full holomorphic map /: M P tropic if f£_ = /, i.e., in terms of local lifts /„ of / :
n
is totally iso-
1
0"TV, d'%>
c
= 0
for all «, 8 £ 0 , a + 13 g n - 1
c
where <, > is the symmetric inner product on C be even, say n = 2r, and formula (3.3) becomes (3-4)
n + 1
. Then n must
{f -^)-\-Tnx)Y r
from which it is clear that g> has image in the real projective space viewed as the subset of real points of P . We thus recover the classification theorem of Calabi [Ca]; see also [Ba, B-G, Ch]. B
(iii) The transformation (/, r) ~>
173 132
J . Eells and J . C. Wood
4. Sketch proof of the classification theorem, I : Harmonicity and isotropy of
J f ^ J e „ = {(V, W ) e f l ( 0 » ) x f f , ( C - « ) : r
V±W}
F
B
1
and the map n: K , , - * P defined by n(V, W) = (V + TP)- -- Note that n is a Riemannian submersion (c.f. [O'N]) and ip is harmonic (since ± holomorphic). Furthermore, the isotropy relations between / and g show that y> is horizontal with respect to si. I t is easy to see that the composition of two such maps is harmonic. r
(B) A certain covariant differential. I n order to prove isotropy of the manufactured harmonic map tp we introduce a covariant differential on a certain bundle as follows: n
Let L -> P be the canonical fine bundle whose fibre at » e P " is the line L„ determined by iv. L e t C denote the trivial bundle over P" with fibre C equipped with its standard Hermitian inner product and connection 3. Then L is canonically a eomplex subbundle of and so inherits a Hermitian inner product and connection; these structures may also be given to the orthogonal complement L of L in C " . We have an exact sequence of complex bundles over P": n + 1
n + 1
L
+ 1
0 -> L <-* C "
+1
-UL^-^Q
where j is given by orthogonal projection. Let q>: M -s- P" be a smooth map from a Riemann surface M. Tensoring the above exact sequence with the dual L* of L and pulling back via tp gives an exact sequence of bundles over M: (4.1)
l
0 -^tp->(L*®L)
1
x
-^tp-'L*®C'+ ^
-*Q
B + 1
where C now denotes the trivial bundle over M. Note that tp- (L* (g) L) is also trivial and that tp-*(L*(x) L -) is isometrically isomorphic to tp^T^P" with a connection preserving isomorphism. Let B denote the Hermitian connection and < , > the Hermitian inner product on £((jj £ C ) induced from those of L and C . Let 0 denote the canonical section of Zitp^B, C ) defined by
1
-1
B + 1
n + 1
f
B + 1
x)
174 Tbe existence and construction of certain harmonic maps
133
n + ,
C \ 0 of
+1
(4.2)
(D'7)(e) = f\V{ )) e
- <3'(0(°»t *<£?)> n e ) K * ( e ) , * (e)>
with a similar formula for the (1, 0) part D' (= D ). I n this fashion we may form iterated differentials of the universal lift of
?
y
n + 1
(4.3)
<[jy*0,
= 0
« ^ 0 , jS^O,a +
8^1, l
where we now use the covariant differential D on t{rp~ L, C
n + 1
).
(C) Isotropy of q> obtained from (/, r). Let
n
n + 1
+1
n + 1
+ 1
To show that
r
1
L
t
1
r
r-1
p
r - 1
175 134
J . Eells and J . C . Wood a
x
Similarly, D' 0(x) has values in g,_i(x) = j {x) for all XEM. Since f _x(x), g._,(x) and tp(x) are mutually perpendicular by the definition of
T
5. Sketch proof of the classification theorem, I I : The inverse transform cp -~> (/, r). B
(A) Associated curves of
+1
B
spanned by D" &[x),
8= 1, 2,...)
MM
and s = max dim (subspace of C
n + 1
spanned by D'"&{x}, a =
l,2,...).
Isotropy of a> implies that r - f - g g n ; fullness implies this is an equality. Define the a-th (reduced) D'-associated curve of
(5.2)
yi(x) =
B'0(x)A...AD"(I>{x),
provided this multivector is non-zero. This is clearly independent of the local complex coordinate used. To define
1
A
l
x
A
A
a
k
0
t
J
B
a
a
+1
B+1
0
v
176 The existence and construction of certain harmonic maps
135
vector (5.2); equivalently, for all x e M,
the two subspaces being on tp. We may define m" using I?"-derivatives. I t -> t? (C ) equal to zero
orthogonal by the isotropy conditions (4.3) (a = 1, r) and
(B) Formula for f. P ~ M / , r ) of (3.2).
We can now define the inverse transform
a
n+1
0
tt
u
PROPOSITION: Let tp be a full isotropic harmonic map. by (5.1) above and set s — n—r. Define f: M -*• P" by (5.3)
nte) = (^.imm^m^
=
ft-iW
Define r
« $ N •
Tfteji / is holomorphic and full; and (5.3) is (fte inverse transformation of (3.2). This proposition completes the proof of the classification theorem; we shall prove here only the statement that / is holomorphic: Firstly, it is clear that the subbundle of C corresponding to f, is spanned almost everywhere by the values of
D'(s)
e
e(^*„ ) x
for all seCicp^,)
; i.e.,
is .S'-closed .
It follows easily that the orthogonal complement of ^ _! in f^-i n n tp,, is 5"-closed in ip,; but since
r
REMARKS:
(i) The formula for the polar g of / is similar to (5.2)
viz: 1
g(x) = ( ^ - ^ © y v V ) ) - - =
•
(ii) If r == 0,
177
136
J Bells and J . C . Wood
13. Ou spaces of maps. (A) Let M be a compact Riemann surface of genus p . Tbe space (with G™ uniform topology) C(M, P ) of smooth maps J f - j - P " has components classified by their degree. Letting Hoi (M, P ) and Harm (M, P™) denote the indicated spaces of ± holomorphic and harmonic maps and using a subscript 7c to indicate subspaces of maps of degree 7c, we have n
n
Hoi, (Jf, P")
Harm, (M, P») ** C (M, P"). b
Taking n = co, a theorem of Segal [Se] asserts that Hoi* {M, P") is a homology deformation retract of C„{M, P"). Afore precisely, H^CtJtf, P-),Hol (-M, P«)) = 0 t
for
2p){2n — 1).
(B) How Ml G„(M, P") - * R ( S 0) has Harm, (Jf, P") as its set of critical points; it would be interesting to interpret Segal's theorem from the viewpoint of Morse theory. Segal records a version of that question, due to Atiyah (see also [Gu]). We can show that if
a
Testo pervenuto il 9 luglio 1981. Bozze licenziate il 26 gennaio 1982.
178 The existence and construction of certain harmonic maps
137
REFERENCES
[ A - H - S ] M. F . A T I Y A H
[Ba] [Bo] [B-G] [Ca] [Ch]
[D-Zl] [D-Z2]
[D-Z3]
[E-Ll] [E-L2] [E-S] [E-Wl] [E-W2]
[E-W3]
[FuJ [G-S] [Gu] [Ham] [Ha] [He] [Ko]
- N. J . H I T C H I N
- I . M . S I N Q E R , Self-duality
in
four-dimen-
sional Riemannian geometry, Proc. R o y a l Soc. London, A 362 (1978), 425-461. J . B A R B O S A , On minimal immersions of S into S , Trans. Amer. Math. S o c , 210 (1975|, 75-106. A . B O B E L , Lea fonctions automarphes de plusieurs variables complexes. B u l l . Soe. Math. Franca, 80 (1952), 167-182. H . J .BOUCHERS W . D . G A B B E R , Local theory of solutions for the 0(2k + 1) a-model. Comm. Math. P h y s . , 72 (1980), 77-102. E . C A L A B I , Quelques applications de I'analyse complete aux surfaces d'aire minima. Topics in Complex Manifolds, Univ. Montreal (1967), 59-81. S . S. C H E R N , On the minimal immersions of the two-sphere in a space of constant curvature. Problems in Analysis, Princeton University Press (1970), 27-40. A. M. Dnr W . J . Z A E B Z E W S K I , General classical solutions in the C P " model, Nucl. Phys., B 174 (1980), 397-406. A . M. D I N W . J . Z A K E Z E W S K I , Properties of the general classical C P " model, Phys. L e t t . , 95 B (1980), 419-422. A . M. D I N - W . J . Z A S R Z E W S K I , Classical Solutions in Orassmannian o-models (preprint). J .EELLS L . L E M A I R E , A report on harmonic maps. B u l l . London Math. S o c , 10 (1978), 1-68. J . EELLS L . L E M A I R E , On the construction of harmonic and holomorphic maps between surfaces. Math. A n n . , 252 (1980), 27-52. J . EELLS J . H . S A M P S O N , Harmonic mappings of Riemannian manifolds, Amer. J. Math., 86 (1964), 109-160. J . E E L L S - J . C . W O O D , Restrictions on harmonic maps of surfaces, Topology, 16 (1976), 263-266. J . E E L L S - J . C . W O O D , Maps of minimum energy, J . London Math. S o c , 23 (1981), 303-310. J . EELLS J . C . W O O D , Harmonic maps from surfaces to complex projective spaces, preprint. A . F O T A H J , Nonexistence of minimising harmonic maps from 2-spheres, Proc. Japan Aoad., 56 (1980), 291-293. V. GLASER R . S T O R A , Regular solutions of the GP" models and further generalizations (preprint, 1980). M. G U E S T , Some relations between homotopy theory and differential geometry. Thesis, University of Oxford (in preparation). R . S. H A M I L T O N , Harmonic maps of manifolds with boundary. Springer Lecture Notes no. 471, 1975. P . H A R T M A N , On homotopic harmonic maps, Canad. J . Math., 19 (1967), 673-687. S. H E L O A S O N , A duality for symmetric spaces with applications to group representations. A d v . M a t h . , ' 5 (W70), 1-154. J . L . K O S Z D L , Lectures on fibre bundles and differential geometry, T a t a Institute, 1960. 1
l
n
- 1
-
1
179 138 [Lei] [Le2] [Le3] [Li] [Ni] [O'N] [Ru]
[S-TJ] [S-Y]
[Se] [Si-Y] [Sil] [Si2] [Wol]
[Wol] [Wo2] [Wo3] [Wo4]
[Wo5] [Wo6] [Wo7] [Wu]
J . Eells and J . C . Wood L . L E M A I R E , Applications harmoniques de surfaces riemanniennes, J, Difl. Geom., 13 (1978), 61-78. L . L E M A I R E , Harmonic nnn-holomorphic maps from a surface to a sphere, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., 71 (1978), 299-304. L . L E M A I R E , Boundary value problems for harmonic and minimal maps of surfaces into manifolds, A n n . Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa (to appear). A . L T C H N E R O W I C Z , Applications harmoniques et variet&s kahleriennes, Symp. Math. I l l Bologna (1970), 341-402. S . N I S H T K A W A , On holomorphic equivalence of bounded domains in complete Kahier manifolds of negative curvature, preprint. B . O ' N E I L L , The fundamental equations of a submersion, Mich. Math. J . , 13 (1966), 459-470. H . R U N D , Variational problems and Bdchlund transformations associated with the sine-Gordon and Korteweg-de Fries equations and their extensions. Springer Lecture Notes in Mathematics, 516 (1976), 119-226. J . SACKS K . U R L E N R E C K , The existence of minimal immersions of the twosphere. B u l l . Amer. Math. S o c , 83 (1977), 1033-1036. R. SCHOEN S . T . Y A U , Existence of incompressible minimal surfaces and the topology of three dimensional manifolds with nonnegative scalar curvature, A n n . of Math., 110 (1979), 127-142. G . B . S E O A L . The topology of spaces of rational functions. A c t a Math., 143 (1979), 39-72. Y . - T . S i u - S . - T . Y A U , Compact Kahier manifolds of positive bisectional curvature. Invent. Math., 59 (1980), 189-204. Y . - T . S i u , Some remarks on the complex analyticity of harmonic maps. Southeast Asian B u l l . Math., 3 (1979), 240-263. Y . - T . S i u , The complex-analyticity of harmonic maps and the strong rigidity of compact Kahier manifolds, A n n . of Math., 112 (1980), 73-111. J . A . W O L E , The action of a real semisimple group on a complex flag manifold, I ; Orbit structure and holomorphic arc components. B u l l . Amer. Math. S o c , 75 (1969), 1121-1237. J . C . W O O D , Harmonic maps and complex analysis, Proc. Summer Course in Complex Analysis, Trieste (1976), vol. I l l , 289-308. J . C . W O O D , A note on the fundamental group of a manifold of negative curvature. Math. Proc. Cambridge Phil. S o c , 83 (1978), 415-417. J . C . W O O D , Holomorphicity of certain harmonic maps from a surface to complex projective n-space, J . London Math. S o c , 20 (1979), 137-142. J . C . W O O D , On the holomorphicity of harmonic maps from a surface. Global Differential Geometry and Global Analysis, Proceedings, Berlin 1979, Springer Lecture Notes no. 838 (1981). J . C . W O O D , Confarmality and holomorphicity of certain harmonic maps, preprint. J . C . W O O D , Non-existence of solutions to certain Dirichlet problems for harmonic maps, preprint. J . C . W O O D , An extension theorem for holomorphic mappings. Math. Proc. Camb. Phil. S o c , 98 (1980), 125-127. H . H . W u , The equidistribution tkeory of liolomorphic curves, A n n . of Math. Studies, 64 (1970).
180 Reprinted from ADVANCES IN MATHEMATICS All Rights Reserved by Academic Press, New York and London
Vol. 49. No. 3 September I9B3 Primed in /1< Igivm h
Harmonic Maps from Surfaces to Complex Projective Spaces J . E E L L S AND J . C . W O O D Mathematics Institute, University af Warwick, Coventry CV4 7AL, England and School of Mathematics, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, England D E D I C A T E D TO PROFESSOR J. H. SAMPSON
Contents. I. Introduction. 2. Preliminaries. 3. Manufacturing harmonic maps from holomorphic maps. 4. A certain covariant differential. 5. Isotropy and other properties. 6. Manufacturing holomorphic maps from harmonic maps. 7. Cases where the isotropy relations hold, 8. Examples and remarks, 9. An estimate for the Morse index,
1. INTRODUCTION
In 117] the authors showed that any harmonic map from a compact Riemann surface M of genus p to the sphere M„ is holomorphic, provided its degree is greater than or equal to p. This gave the first indications of a possible classification theorem for certain harmonic maps in terms of holomorphic maps; it also showed that there exists no harmonic map of degree one from the torus M to the sphere M , whatever Riemannian metrics they may be given. p
i
n
It was clear from the outset that our methods (especially, an analysis of holomorphic quadratic differentials on M ) required that the domain be two dimensional. On the other hand, it was less obvious whether our theorem required the range to be two dimensional. In the present paper we shall replace the sphere M„ = C P by the complex projective H-space C P " with its Fubini-study metric; and show in particular if n > 2: p
1
(1) There exist nonhalomorphic harmonic maps from Af„ to C P " of all degrees greater than p (Theorem 8.10). (2) There exist nonholomorphic harmonic maps of M of all degrees >0.
a
and M, to C P "
These (nonholomorphic) maps are never minima of the energy functional, by a theorem of [18]. Other conditions which ensure that a harmonic map from M to C P " is holomorphic are given in [48-50, 58, 59]. p
217 Copyright © 1983 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
218
E E L L S AND WOOD
The source of these results is the Classification Theorem 6.9, which can be described roughly as follows: Let Af be a Riemann surface, not necessarily compact. A full map of Af into C P " is one whose image lies in no proper projective subspace. (Complex) isotropy of such a map is an orthogonality relation between its (1,0) and (0, 1) covariant differentials. Then we have T H E O R E M 6.9. There is a bijective correspondence between full isotropic harmonic maps 0 : A / - . C P " and pairs (f,r), where f:M-* C P " is a full holomorphic map and r is an integer (0 < r < n). If M is compact, the degree of $ is given in terms of the degree of f and its associated curves. We also give estimates for the Morse index of <j>. Recall that a weakly conformal map of a Riemann surface is harmonic if and only if it is a minimal branched immersion. An isotropic map is always weakly conformal, so Theorem 6.9 classifies isotropic minimal branched immersions of M in C P " . The isotropy condition is satisfied for an arbitrary harmonic map ^ A / p - C P " if
(i) (ii)
^ = 0 [ I I , 12, 20], p = 1 and | degree <j> | ^ 0, or
(ih) n = 2, immersion.
|degree $ | > 2p — 1 and (J is
a
minimal branched
Theorem 6.9 gives a complete classification of harmonic maps in these cases. On the other hand, examples {Section 7E} show that the isotropy condition is not satisfied for all harmonic maps M ->CP" of degree
C O R O L L A R Y 6 . I I . There is a bijective correspondence between full isotropic harmonic maps i W - + R P ' and full totally isotropic holomorphic 2
P
maps i W ^ C P " .
There are no full isotropic harmonic maps M -»1RP" if n is odd. Calabi's theorem was taken up by Chern [9, 10] and Barbosa [2]; in particular, Barbosa proved a rigidity theorem, and gave examples of branched minimal immersions 0 : A / - * S ' with energy E($) = 4nk for every k ^ r(r + 1 )/2. Borchers and Garber [3] have recently rediscovered Calabi's theorem, and have presented a very detailed exposition. Calabi's theorem revives interest in the memoir of Boruvka [4]—especially concerning the maps M„-*S by harmonic homogeneous polynomials. p
2
o
2r
The case p = 0 of Theorem 6.9 was discussed—without full mathematical rigour—by Din and Zakrzewski [ I I , 12]; more precision and clarity (from
182 HARMONIC MAPS
219
our viewpoint) was added by Glaser and Stora [20]. That case was also found by D. Burns [62]. Our results (announced in [19], with proofs sketched) have grown from an attempt to understand [11, 12, 20]. In that effort we have been patiently guided by R. Stora—who has shed much light and joy. We are also much indebted to M. Ishida for lessons on constructing a certain elliptic curve (Section 8); and to K. Abe, M Guest, L . Lemaire, M. Murray, M. S. Narasimhan, and J. H. Rawnsley for adjustments and other stimulating conversations. During the preparation of this paper we enjoyed the hospitality of the International Centre for Theoretical Physics, the Technical University of Denmark, and the University of Bonn. Dr. Wood was supported by the Sonderforschungsbereich "Theoretische Mathematik," Universitat Bonn. In Sections 3-6 we give a full proof of the Classification Theorem 6.9. First of all, in Section 3 we present a method (with fairly wide applicability) of constructing harmonic maps from holomorphic maps / In Section 4 we develop the properties or an important covariant differential, in terms of which we establish (Section 5) the fullness and isotropy of ty. In Section 6 we make the inverse construction, to produce the required bijectivity of Theorem 6.9. In Section 7 we find conditions to ensure that certain harmonic maps are isotropic; and in Section 8 specific examples are given. Finally, in Section 9 we use the Riemann-Roch theorem in conjunction with the second variation formula for harmonic maps to produce lower bounds on the indices of certain harmonic maps. 1
2.
PRELIMINARIES
A +
l
0
We let C = \v = (i> ,..., v"): u'G C | denote complex (n + 1 )-space equipped with its standard symmetric C-bilinear inner product { ) : c
c
(v, w) =
V o'w',
i=0 and associated Hermitian inner product H {v, w) = V ' ' = (o, v
w
C
W) , +
where w=(w',...,w") is the conjugate of w G C ' - As usual, we write | ti| = \f{v, v). Two subspaces V, W of C* are orthogonal if (v, w) = 0 for all v e V, w £ W; we write V1 W. 1
183 220
E E L L S AND WOOD
Et
Let £ be a complex vector bundle over a complex manifold M. Let ^(E) (resp. W^E) denote the space of smooth (= C°) sections a of E defined on M (resp. on an open subset U of M). TM denotes the tangent bundle of M, and TM = TM ® C its complexification. A Hermitian connected structure on E consists of (i) a smooth Hermitian inner product { , ) = { , ) on the fibres of £ , and (ii) a smooth connection E
E
D = D : &(TM)
X
-4 &(E),
-
denoted (Co )->D o, such that {
Si{a,p) = (D a,p) (
+ (a, D p) T
for all ( 7 , p G ? ( £ ) , C.e&iTM). This identity is often used to "shift" the covariant derivative from one factor to another. The bundle E so endowed will be called a Hermitian connected bundle. Decomposition of TM according to types TM = TM ® T'M induces a decomposition of D into (1,0)- and (0, 1 )-parts, by restricting % to T'M and T"M, respectively. If £ is a holomorphic vector bundle, we say that a (smooth) connection on E is compatible with the holomorphic structure if the (0, l)-part of D coincides with the d-operator of E\ thus o G ^ c ) is holomorphic iff D o = 0 for all ( 6 T"M. There is a unique such metric connection on any holomorphic vector bundle E with Hermitian metric—called the Hermitian connection of E. The Hermitian connection on a trivial bundle = MX is denoted by & j that notation is appropriate, in view of the canonical identification of the fibres of Q with C". L
1
t
N
A complex subbundle F of a Hermitian connected bundle E inherits a Hermitian inner product and Hermitian connection n%: f r „ ( / o - %{E)
A
%(E)
-
K(n
where C € W^TM); here the first map is induced by the inclusion FczE, and the third map is induced from orthogonal projection. More generally, if $:M-*N is a smooth map and E-> N is Hermitian connected, then there is a canonically defined Hermitian connected structure on the pull-back $-'E->M. Note that the holomorphic tangent bundle T'M of a Hermitian manifold M has a canonically defined Hermitian connected structure.
184 HARMONIC MAPS
221
C. Bundles over Riemann Surfaces Let M be a Riemann surface; i.e., a one-dimensional complex manifold. By a chart U = (U, z) of M we mean a nonempty open set U of M equipped with a complex coordinate z:U-*C, written x\—*z(x). It is convenient to represent the (1,0)- and (0, l)-parts of a connection D o n a complex bundle over M by D' = D with £ = djdz G & {T'M\ and Z>" = D with l^djdzE %(T"M). Write D' for D <-•-•• D ' (fc times) and set D' = identity map; similarly for D" We use similar notation for d, with d' = 8/8z, 8" = djdz. By a result of Koszul-Malgrange [33], (and |S8| to derive the equation dX/dz = X • p\ the reduction to log X in [58] is wrong, as noted by Professor M. F. Atiyah), if £ is a Hermitian connected bundle with connection D over a Riemann surface, there is a unique holomorphic structure on E compatible with D. Then £ is a Hermitian holomorphic bundle: and o 6 ^ ( £ ) is holomorphic iff D"o = 0. t
V
k
r
1
a
Let £ be a Hermitian connected bundle with connection D. A subbundle F is D"-ciosed if, on all charts U, D"(%{F)) c ^ ( £ ) ; similarly for the notion of F being D'-closed. The orthogonal complement of a D'-closed bundle is D"-closed. If £ is a Hermitian holomorphic bundle, a D"-closed subbundle of £ is just a holomorphic subbundle. For 0 < t < n + 1 there is a bijection between smooth maps a: A/-> G , ( C ' ) and smooth subbundles of rank t of C over M given by setting the fibre of the subbundle at x 6 M equal to a(x). We shall often use the same letter to denote the subbundle. It is easy to see that the subbundle is 8' (resp. d") closed iff a is antiholomorphic (resp. holomorphic). +
B + 1
D. Harmonic Maps [14, 16, 57] 0 0
A smooth (= C ) map M-* N between smooth Riemannian manifolds is harmonic if it is a critical point for the Dirichlet or energy integral E(
y
D
M
M
r($l) = Trace Dd<j> (r is the Euler-Lagrange operator of the energy integral £ ) vanishes identically. Here D is the connection on the bundle
185 222
E E L L S AND WOOD e
decompose the C-linear extension dip: TM-> TN into four maps dfi
d #: T M -»TN
T'M -* T'N,
of
&r- T"M -»
d$=d
its
differential
TN,
dj = ty: T"M -» T"N.
Then the energy density e(^){x) = \ \d$(x)\ of at xE M decomposes into the sum of the (1,0)- and (0, l)-energy densities 2
A
where e'(<j>)(x) = \d
E'tf, D)
3
- f |£W*)|
E*y, D) =
v (x), M
[ mxf
vjx)
are called the (1,0)- and (0, \)-energy integrals of $ (over D). $ is holomorphic iff 0$ = 0, and antiholomorphic iff 8$ = 0. We express these alternatives by saying that
M
M
v
manifolds
(i) (ii)
and if M is compact,
E'(^) — E"(^>) depends a ± holomorphic
map of minimum (iii)
then
energy
# is harmonic
map
[38] only on the homotopy
between
in its homotopy
Kahier
class
manifolds
of is a
§\ harmonic
class.
iff $ is a critical
point
of E' iff $ is a critical
point
ofE". E. Harmonic
Maps from
a Riemann
Surface
A smooth map fr.M^N from a Riemannian 2-manifold M has energy depending only on the conformal class of the metric of M. Thus we can speak of harmonic maps whose domain is a Riemann surface. In a chart (£/,z) of M the partial differentials d$,d
i
ll
D"8'$ = 0, where D is the connection on (j>~ T'N. A smooth map 0: M-*N is said to be weakly conformal if there exists a smooth function A:M-> [0, co) such that \d(x)(X)\=X(x)\X\ for all X€T M. By definition, a branched minimal immersion is a weakly conformal harmonic map. Such a map is a branched l
X
H A R M O N I C
223
MAPS
immersion in the sense of [24, 25]. For a weakly conformal map the area A(^) of the map is equal to the energy £((*).
$:M-*N
F . Riemannian Submersions A Riemannian submersion [43] is a smooth map n: Y-*N of Riemannian manifolds such that for all y€ Y, the differential dn(y): T Y-* T N maps the subspace T"Y of tangent vectors orthogonal to the fibre K~ {n(yi)\ isometrically onto T„ N. The space T"Y is called the horizontal subspace at y, and the space of tangent vectors along the fibres (= Ker dn(y)) is called the vertical subspace. y
n
l
ly)
The Fubini-Study metric on complex projective n-space C P " is characterized by the fact that the Hopf map n: S **' ->CP" (obtained by restricting the standard projection n: C " '\0 -> C P " ) is a Riemannian submersion; the value of the constant holomorphic sectional curvature on C P " is then c = 4. (Wherever the value of c matters (in fact only in Proposition 7.1) we shall leave it as c.) Real projective n-space R P " may be considered as the subset of real points of C P " ; its induced metric has constant Riemannian sectional curvature 1. We let G , ( C " ' ) (0 < t< n -f 1) denote the Grassmannian of r-planes (= r-dimensional complex subspaces) equipped with its standard metric [32]; we have an antiholomorphic isometry 2
+
+
If Y and /V are Hermitian manifolds and n: Y^>N is a holomorphic Riemannian submersion, then the horizontal space is closed under the almost complex structure •/ of Y. Then 8n:T'Y->T'N restricts to a C-linear isomorphism between the (1,0) horizontal tangent space T'"Y = (T" Y®C)nT'Y and TN. A similar statement hoids if n is antiholomorphic. y
G. Tangent Space to a Grassmannian +
It is well known that for any V€ G,(C '), the holomorphic tangent space 7"^G,(C" ) may be identified with V* ® V = Sf(V, V ) via a complex linear isometry h: T | , G , ( C " ) y(V, V ). For our purposes we may describe h as follows: Let w G T' G,{C +') and let v G V. If v =0, set h(w)(v) = 0. Otherwise, let
1
+ 1
x
L
V
+ 1
+
In the case of complex projective space C P " = G , ( C additional information: Let A:L = ( C
+
l
\0)x -C-.CP c
n
+ 1
) we shall need
187 224
E E L L S AND WOOD
be the holomorphic line bundle associated to the principal C*-bundle j r : C \ 0 - » C P ' ' defining CP": the fibre L over any y G C P " can be identified with the linear subspace of C determined by y; thus L is identified as a holomorphic subbundle of the trivial bundle C over C P " . Let k :L -» C P " be that subbundle of C " ' whose fibre at y is the orthogonal complement of L in C . Note that L is not a holomorphic subbundle of C ; instead we give it a holomorphic structure via the isomorphism: Z , ~ C / L - We endow both bundles L and L with the Hermitian metrics and metric connections induced from C " ; it is easy to see that L and L are Hermitian holomorphic bundles. We give L* © L the tensor Hermitian holomorphic structure. Define h: T'CP" -> L* ®L on each fibre as above. Then h is a connection preserving biholomorphic isometric isomorphism of these Hermitian holomorphic bundles. To see that h is holomorphic, note that we may choose holomorphic and w and v as holomorphic sections of T'CP" and L. From its formula, it is easy to check that h(w)(v) is a holomorphic section of V . That h is connection preserving now follows from the uniqueness of the Hermitian connection. , +
1
y
+
1
N
y
l
+
1
+
+
1
L
y
N + 1
i
+ 1
l
+ 1
1
1
l
1
H. Local Lifts Let f:M-* C P " be a smooth map from a Riemann surface to complex projective n-space. We say / is full if its image lies in no proper projective subspace of C P " . By a lift off on an open set U ofM (or simply a local lift) we mean a smooth map f : U-> C \ 0 such that n <>/(,=/ on U, where J T : C " \ 0 - » C P " is the standard projection; if / is holomorphic (resp. antiholomorphic), then it has holomorphic (resp. antiholomorphic) lifts over small enough open sets. M
v
+ i
Throughout this paper: Whenever M is used without comment, it denotes a Riemann surface (without boundary), not necessarily compact. Whenever f , g , f are used, they denote a lift off, g, > over an open set UczM. v
v
w
3. M A N U F A C T U R I N G HARMONIC M A P S FROM HOLOMORPHIC M A P S
A. Associated Curves of a Holomorphic Map Let / : M-> C P " be a holomorphic map. We describe the construction of associated curves of / for later comparison with the harmonic case. See also (61]. For 0 < a < oo, the ath order (augmented) osculating space B (x) = 8JS)(x) off at xeM is defined by Sjx) = span|5%(jc): 0 < y < a), where f is any lift of / over an open set containing x; this is clearly independent of lift and chart. As x varies, the osculating spaces may vary in dimension; but note a
v
188 HARMONIC MAPS
3.1.
LEMMA
225
If f is full, then at some xEM,
dim S„(x) = n + 1.
Proof. Suppose not. Then for all x on some nonempty open set f/, one of the B'J^x) would be linearly dependent on \d'"f {x)\Q<.a< y\ (whatever local lift f is chosen). By differentiation, all higher derivatives would be linearly dependent on these derivatives, so that all jets off,; would be in a proper subspace of C " \ and hence by real analyticity,/ would lie in the same subspace contradicting fullness. I u
l
v
+
Remark 3.2. map.
The converse to Lemma 3.1 is trivially true for any smooth
Now set A = \xEM:d[m§ (x)
< n + 1}.
n
For any integer a ( 0 < a < n ) define f : M\4 -» G a
LEMMA
AND DEFINITION
holomorphic map f : M -* G curve of f. a
(3.1) ') by
tt+
3.3. There is a unique extension of f to a i ( C ' ) . This map is called the ath associated a
+
a +
Proof. Let xE M. Choose a chart U containing x and a holomorphic lift fu of / on U. Consider the map w: U-*A C (sometimes called the Wronsklan) defined by a
+ >
my =$m a
+ >
•••
a
Note that w is holomorphic and for x & A,f (x) = {a -f l)-plane defined by w(x). If r £ A, we can write w{x') = (z(x') - z(x)) W(x) for all x' in some open neighbourhood U' of x, where p is a positive integer and IV: U' -> ^ a + i^-fl+i j holomorphic and nowhere zero. Since W{x') is decomposable for all JC' ^ x, it remains decomposable for x' = x, and we can define f (x) as the (a + I J-dimensional subspace defined by W(x). From the formula for w we see that this is independent of choice of chart U and local lift / „ . Uniqueness of the extension is clear since M\A is dense in M. | a
B
s
a
Remark 3.4. (i) Note that f =f; G ( C ) equal to the zero map.
it is convenient to set
a
f_ :M^> l
+ 1
0
(ii) The associated curves g : M-> G ,(C*') of a full antiholomorphic map g : A / ^ C P " can be defined in the same way, replacing d' fv by 8" g , where g is an antiholomorphic lift of g over a chart U. Equivalently, g (x) = (g) {x). a
y
y
v
v
a
a
a +
189 226
E E L L S AND WOOD
B. Construction of Harmonic Maps into C P " The construction of harmonic maps is based on the following observation (cf. [5, Lemma 1.2.5]; see [66] for further results): L E M M A 3.5. Let M, Y, N be Riemannian manifolds, s.: Y-» N a R iemannian submersion and M -* Y a harmonic map. Suppose thai i// is horizontal with respect to n; i.e., for each x G M dvj(x) maps T M into the horizontal space of n. Then $ = x o if/: M -> N is harmonic. S
Proof. By the composition law [15], at each point » £ M the tension field of <j> is given by ^ ) = Vv /7r(^( ,.), lv(e )), £
e
£
/
where Vdn is the second fundamental form of the map n and \e,\ is an orthonormal basis for the tangent space T,M. By hypothesis, each vector d\u{ej) is horizontal and by [43] we see that Vdn(e', e') = 0 for any horizontal tangent vector e' £ TY. It follows that r(^) = 0. | Now let r, s be nonnegative integers (0 < r + s < n), and define +
+
sft^j = {(V, W) jg G , ( C " ' ) X G ( C " ' ) : V 1 W\. S
Setting ( = (n + 1) - (r + s), we have the representation of JT as a flag manifold: the homogeneous space (U(r) denotes the unitary group) rs
JT = U(n+\ )/l/(r) X U{s) X U(t). m
If s — n — r, we have a Riemannian submersion n:^ _ -* C P " = U(n+ l)/U(n)xU(\) given by including U(r) X U(s) in U{n) in the standard way. Geometrically, x(V, W) = (V+ W)\' r
s
D E F I N I T I O N 3.6. Let f:M-*CP" be a full holomorphic map from a Riemann surface. We call g =f _ :M-> C P " the polar off. x
l
Note the following characterisation of polars in terms of local lifts:
LEMMA
3.7.
Let f:M-*
C P " be a holomorphic map.
1
+
We give £ £ the submanifold metric induced from G ( C " ' ) X G , ( C * ' ) . This is not the same as the standard homogeneous space metric, however the map n is a Riemannian submersion for either of these metrics. 4
r
190 HARMONIC MAPS
(i)
227
If f is full, its polar g is antiholomorphic and full. For any local
lifts n
0
for
al!
a,ff>+#<*~h
(d f {x),d" {x))±0 ,a
a
v
for all a,B^0,a
forsome
gll
(3-2)
x€M
(3.3)
+ B = n.
(n) Conversely, if g:M-> C P " is a smooth map satisfying (3.2) and (3.3) for some a, 8^0, a + B = n, then f and g are full and g is the polar off By analogy with (3.8) below we call (3.2) the isotropy relations between/ and g. Proof, (i) For B = 0 the first equation (3.2) is immediate. Since/is full, 8'%(x) does not lie i n / „ _ , ( * ) for xeM\4; hence (3.3) follows for B = 0. For other a and ft (3.2) and (3.3) follow by shifting d'. Antiholomorphicity of g is clear from its definition. To see that g is full, suppose that X^g^x) + ••• + X„d" g (x) = 0 at some point xEM where (3.3) holds. Taking inner products successively with/„(.>(), S'f^x),..., B'*f (x) shows that A„ = ••• = X = 0. By the converse of Lemma 3.1, g is full. The proof of (ii) follows similar reasoning. a
v
u
0
Remark 3.8. points x, where
(i)
This proof shows that if g is the polar of/, the sets of
dim spanja'Y^jc)} < n + 1
fl
and
dim span{,?" gir(*)l < n + 1
are the same; namely, the set A of (3.1). (ii) So
f
For
full
maps fg: Af — CP",
Eq. (3.2)
is
equivalent
to
n-I-a'
Now let / : A f - * C P " be a full holomorphic map and let r be an integer (0 < r < n). Let g be the polar off, and set s = n — r. Then we may define a map m M-^Mii y K * ) = Wr*»b
LEMMA 3.9.
The map v is horizontal with respect to n i ^ - t C P * . +
Proof. It is sufficient to prove that V: A / - » * « = - * G (C" ') X G,(C" ) is horizontal with respect to 77: t/-» CP", where 17= {(K, IV) £ G ( C ) x G ( C " ):dim(P'+ H 0 = " ! 77(K, HO = ( ^ + ^ O this it suffices to show that > and 3'V S 7"T/ are horizontal; we treat 5 > . Set (V, IV) =
+ I
n + l
r
+ l
a
!
r
s
n
d
1
T
o
d
o
228
E E L L S AND WOOD
d
'¥(x) = {d'f _ (x),0). We may identify the vertical subspace of T' „ U with T G (V® W)cz T' G (C *')^ ¥{V, V -) as in Section 2 G . Let f (resp. ) be a holomorphic (resp. antiholomorphic) lift of / (resp. g) on some neighbourhood of x. Define A czM as in (3.1); suppose that x€A. Then by Remark 3.8 {d'-f^x): 0 < a < r - 1| and \8" g {x):{i^B ^s - 1| are linearly independent. The first set of vectors spans V. Since d'd"-%{x) = d'%(x)e V for all i
l
(v
n
y
r
v
t
s
r
v
g u
&
v
+
v
7
x
r
1
r
1
l
1
r
x
&
v
PROPOSITION 3.10. Let f:M-*CP" be a full holomorphic map from Riemann surface and r an integer (0 ^ r < n). Define
^(.)=/ _,(,) n/ W; r
r
a
(3.4)
or equivalently t(x)={f _ {x)®g _ (x))\ r
1
s
(3.5)
1
where g is the polar of f and s = n — r. Then $ is harmonic.
Further properties of
r
i
s
Remark 3.11. (i) If r = 0, then $=f fli =g is antiholomorphic.
is holomorphic; if r = n, then
(ii) We may think of (f,r)-~0' as a type of Backlund transform [44]. It also has many of the features o