This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
4, a(B 2 O 3 ) = 1.710. c(SiO 2 ) 71 to 80: cp < 0.333, a(B 2 O 3 ) = 1.470; 0.333 < cp < 0.5, a (B2O3) = 1.760-0.12/cp; l 2, a(B 2 O 3 ) = 18. Surface tension in mNm~l
(20 to 400°C)
Silica: c(SiO 2 )<67, «(SiO2) = 3.8; c(SiO 2 )>67, c(SiO2) = 10.5-0.1 c(SiO2). Boric oxide: calculate ij/ = {c (Na2O) + c (K2O) + c (BaO) - c (A12O3) + 0.7 (c (CaO) + c (SrO) + c (PbO)) + + 0.3 (c (Li2O) + c (MgO) + c (ZnO))} /c (B2O3) then a (B2O3) = -1.25 i// except for xfj > 4 when the value is a(B 2 O 3 ) = -5.0. Lead oxide: a (PbO) = 13.0 for a) alkali-free glasses, b) alkali lead silicate glasses with X C ( R 2O) < 3> c) other glasses with E c (RO) + S c (RmOB)]/J] c (R2O) < 3; for other glasses not meeting conditions a) to c) it is a (PbO) = 11.5 + 0.5 X c (R2O).
31
1.2 Choice of Glass Compositions Table 1-4. Factors for calculating viscosity and room temperature thermal conductivity. Property Equation
Viscosity (1-2)
Thermal conductivity (1-1)
Unit of c{ Author
wt./wt SiO 2 Lakatos et al. (1976 b)
wt.% Iluss(1928)
A Li 2 O Na 2 O K2O MgO CaO ZnO BaO PbO A12O3 B2O3 (B 2 O 3 ) 2 SiO2 Constant (a0)
-3.180 -1.620 0.660 5.890 0.640 1.60 0.260 -0.500 -0.870 -4.650 16.27 — 1.713
B - 1 1 518 - 6 601 - 541 5 621 - 6 063 - 376.0 - 2 103 - 2 544 1 521 - 1 5 511 40 999 __ 6 237.01
To - 1 329 50.0 -236 -212 771 96.0 109 82.0 140 1203 - 2 765 — 149.4
10.70 13.40 4.55 8.80 8.65 11.85 11.70 6.25 3.70 3.00 -
_ 0.3448 0.3448 0.2564 0.2564 0.1695 0.1408 0.1000 0.3125 0.4255 — 0.4348 -
Viscosity The terms are summed to give the values of A, B and To to be put into the Vogel-Tammann-Fulcher equation, log(?//dPa s) = —A-\-B/(0 — 0o); note that there are both first and second order terms for B 2 O 3 . Thermal conductivity First calculate the notional volume percentage of each oxide from f f = 100 ct vt/Y, ct vn then sum the vi (1/Af) terms to obtain the reciprocal of the conductivity I/A'. To obtain the true room temperature conductivity (Wm" 1 K) take the reciprocal of this (Xf) and multiply by 418.7.
Young Modulus in kbar Silica: c (SiO2) < 67, a (SiO2) = 6.5; c (SiO2) > 67, a (SiO2) = 5.3 + 0.018 c (SiO2). Boric oxide: calculate cp as above and select as follows:
(1300°C)
* These oxides can have very variable effects on surface tension in different glass melts, even the sign of the term may change.
32
1 Classical Glass Technology
index. Weighting factors can be used to emphasize the influence of the most important properties. Indeed Westerlund et al. (1983) have taken the method two useful stages further. The first is to work with batch materials, not just glass composition; the second is to include raw material prices, allowing optimization of batch costs as suggested by Kiessling and Dressel (1979). 1.2.7 Choice of Raw Materials
Selecting the cheapest batch is not always the best choice because choice of batch can have very important effects on melting and glass quality which are not recognized by computer models. Nevertheless, the ability to examine the possibilities of savings in cost of the batch is a very useful tool and has been successfully exploited (Hatakka, 1986). As already indicated, choice of raw materials can have significant effects on ease of melting and glass quality as well as costs. Even though the commonest glasses use natural minerals and the cheapest of manufactured chemicals, the raw materials often cost more than twice as much as the fuel used in melting. This is a tribute to the efforts of the industry to achieve the most efficient use of the fuel and shows that using the cheapest raw materials is an attractive idea. However, this is not always the best choice. The overall melting cost depends on ease of melting and refining and the quality of the glass, also on furnace life. Sometimes a rather more expensive batch material proves worthwhile because of its influence on these other factors. West-Oram (1979) gave an extensive and very informative review of glass batch materials. Choice of batch materials may also be influenced by the need to control oxidation of the melt. For this purpose the Batch
Redox Number is often useful. Manring and Hopkins (1958) proposed that factors for oxidizing or reducing power could be assigned to each batch material and then summed in the traditional way to obtain a value that would describe the state of oxidation of the melt produced. These factors were based on a simple assumption about the reducing action of carbon but modified in the light of experience. The factors were given and their use also illustrated by Simpson and Myers (1978). The more recent modification of this concept in terms the chemical oxygen demand does not seem to have important advantages. Glass melting is discussed next. Here it is sufficient to note that what is called melting is complex and it is not always easy to predict what will produce the best result. The possibilities of including accurate predictions about melting, refining, or homogenizing in a computer data base are at present remote.
1.3 The Melting of Glasses 1.3.1 Introduction
It is important to recognize that glass makers do not use the word melting in its strict scientific sense; most glasses are melted at temperatures below the melting points of their major refractory constituent, most often silica. If a glass can be produced by normal melting that will nearly always be the preferred method on grounds of cost and scale of production: when it will produce a satisfactory product there is little reason to choose a more restricted and expensive method. However, alternatives to normal melting are very active research topics at present. Sol-gel and chemical vapour deposition techniques have important parts to play in high technology applications; these tech-
33
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
niques are usually expensive and limited to small scale production, they are discussed in the next chapter. It has often been said that sol-gel methods can save energy in the manufacture of refractory glasses, such as pure silica, because considerably lower temperatures are used and this is true when the energy consumption of only the final stage is considered. But when the energy consumed in making the starting materials for the sol-gel process is considered, that method is seen overall to use a great deal more energy and the prices of the raw materials demonstrate this. Similar statements are sometimes made about large scale electric melting. The efficiency of using the energy supplied in a well designed electric melting furnace should be more than twice that achieved in a good combustion heated furnace but the efficiency of using the energy in a well designed glass tank is considerably better than that achieved in a fuel fired electricity generating station. Therefore it is not generally more efficient to convert the thermal energy of gas or oil to electricity before using it. However, electric furnaces have other advantages for certain purposes, such as the melting of glasses containing some important volatile constituents, or if the electricity is produced hydroelectrically. Determining the economics of large scale glass production must consider all of the relevant factors including capital and running costs of the furnace. Electric furnaces are discussed in detail by Stanek (1977).
ing the raw materials at room temperature, heating them to these high temperatures but eventually cooling the glass produced to room temperature uses a great deal of heat much of which is apparently wasted. The efficient use of this energy must thus be examined. The energy required has two basic components, the heat of reaction and the sensible heat needed to raise the glass to the maximum temperature used. 1.3.2.1 Enthalpy of Reaction
Accurate data for glass melting reactions themselves are rare. It is therefore necessary to treat the glass as a mixture of appropriate compounds for which the basic data are available and assume that the heats of mixing of the silicate liquids are zero. Heats of mixing are not in fact zero but probably small enough for this procedure to be acceptable. For a simple sodalime-silica batch comprising carbonates one might use Na 2 CO 3 + SiO2 -• -+Na 2 SiO 3 + CO 2 T+2!iJ 1
(1-13)
Na 2 SiO 3 + SiO2 -> ->Na 2 Si 2 O 5 +zliJ 2
(1-14)
CaCO 3 -+CaO + CO2T
(1-15)
CaO + SiO2 -• CaSiO3 + AH4
(1-16)
The overall enthalpy of melting is then obtained by adding together the correct mole fractions of these energies to make up the correct glass compositions (1-17) AHM = nx AH1 + n2 AH2 + n3 AH3 + ...
1.3.2 Energy Requirements
Silicate glasses are usually melted at temperatures of around 1400-1600°C and forming operations need the melt to be held at a certain viscosity, which usually means temperatures of 1050-1200°C. Tak-
The data usually used and the methods of calculation employed are those given by Kroger (1953) and Kroger et al. (1958).
34
1 Classical Glass Technology
1.3.2.2 Sensible Heat Specific heat varies with temperature as well as composition so it is important to use the average over the proper temperature range. For glasses of the most common types the factors discussed in the previous section may be used. For many glasses the average specific heat to raise to melting temperature is close to l k J k g " 1 so that a rough estimate of the sensible heat is easily made. Calculations of this kind yield results similar to those given in Table 1-5 and some interesting observations arise from these values. First, the sensible heat considerably exceeds the enthalpy of reaction; when the glass is to be cooled again to room temperature this implies that energy could be saved by using as low a melting temperature as possible, for example, just above the liquidus, but this is a false conclusion. Second, it seems that lead crystal should be the easiest to melt of the glasses mentioned and this is true but the laboratory ware borosilicate is by far the most difficult to melt. Clearly the theoretical energy required for melting does not tell us about the ease of melting the glass. Ease of melting is determined by the kinetics of the important reactions and the dissolution of silica grains in essentially isothermal conditions is generally the slowest of these. Looking at the silica contents of these
Table 1-5. Theoretical heat required for glass melting inkJkg-1. Type
Lead crystal Borosilicate Container Flat
Heat of reaction 400 410 475 700
Total heat to raise to: 1200°
1500°C
1830 1820 2125 2420
2250 2250 2620 2940
glasses gives us a much better idea of how readily they melt; lead crystal has around 56wt.% SiO2 and Pyrex about 80wt.% SiO2 whilst the others will have about 72wt.% SiO2. Logic suggests that the use of raw materials which take part in exothermic glassforming reactions should be beneficial and some ingenious ideas based on the use caustic soda or soda-lime have been put forward from time to time, for example by Pugh (1968). Because of the exothermic reactions involving sodium hydroxide, it is dangerous to cast soda-rich glasses or fusions into water. However, the implied smaller enthalpy of melting is no guarantee of faster practical melting, quicker refining or better homogeneity, as shown by Cable and Siddiqui (1980). One of their findings was that mixing NaOH and CaCO 3 allows the reaction 2NaOH + CaCO 3 -> -> Na 2 CO 3 + Ca(OH) 2
(1-18)
to proceed almost to completion before any other begins. On the other hand, the major contribution of the sensible heat does mean that preheating of the batch can bring appreciable savings if it can be achieved. However, preheating must stop below the temperature at which the batch begins to react and form a sticky mass which will clog any apparatus in which it is reacting; this temperature can be below 500 °G 1.3.3 Preparations In both laboratory and large scale glass making it is a serious mistake to neglect batch preparation. The use of carefully prepared and homogeneous batch can have a great influence on the quality of the glass produced. It is not intended to discuss batch preparation and handling in detail
35
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
here, just to point out some of the important factors. Glass batches usually contain several, often seven or more, materials in a wide range of relative proportions and, perhaps, different particle sizes, which makes their mixing difficult. When these materials have a range of densities, shapes and frictional properties, it is difficult to achieve good mixing or, once attained, to prevent segregation before the batch is melted. Long mixing times, such as often used in the ceramic industry, are rarely desirable. There is ample evidence that the quality of the batch put into the furnace has an important influence on the quality of the glass produced. Even if the batch is well mixed some tendency to segregation during melting is inevitable. Much thought and experience goes into the design and operation of a successful batch mixing, transport and charging system on an industrial furnace. On a laboratory scale care over accuracy of weighing out materials, mixing and preventing segregation is equally beneficial. It can be claimed that the scientific principles of mixing solids are reasonably well understood and largely concern generating random diffusive motion in an assembly of particles. This can only occur when the particles are already in motion caused by stirring or tumbling the bulk of the material. However, the theory is little help in practice when particles having very different properties are concerned. Different sizes, shapes, and so on mean that different particles always have some tendency to behave differently under the influence of gravity. Hence the motion which is being used to achieve mixing always has some tendency to provoke segregation at the same time. It is easy to mix glass batch too long or to cause segregation by vibration or free fall between mixing and charging into the furnace. Deliberate addition of a
few percent of water can be very helpful in retarding batch segregation. Papers by Poole (1963) and Fletcher (1963), together with several others in the same issue of Glass Technology give some very useful insight into these matters. 1.3.4 The Stages of Melting Glass melting comprises a number of rather complex stages in which different physical and chemical phenomena predominate. It is therefore useful to consider it in several stages but it must never be forgotten that these overlap in time and space and considerably influence each other. Figure 1-11 shows the most useful way of dividing the whole process; each of these stages is considered in the sections that follow.
1500 i -
Q
Temperature
1000 Dissolve sand | BAICH-hHLb
• /I
500 -
"Ij\
Remove bubbles ~|SEED-FF
Homogenize
I 2
3
Time in h
Figure 1-11. Schematic diagram of the stages of glass melting. Region (i) is where the batch has not yet reached reaction temperature and (ii) shows the time occupied by vigorous reaction.
1.3.4.1 Batch Heating Melting reactions can be detected in common silicate batches at about 400 °C
36
1 Classical Glass Technology
but usually are not sufficiently rapid to be important until the temperature reaches about 600 °C. Some subsidiary processes, such as evaporation of moisture or the melting of minor constituents with lower melting points, may of course take place at lower temperatures. Glass batches are largely made from materials with poor thermal conductivities and the question of how to heat the batch deserves examination. This may be confirmed by taking a simple example. Suppose that a furnace is producing 120 tonnes of glass a day, which is equivalent to supplying 100 kg of batch per minute, and that the batch is charged as a continuous blanket 4 m wide and 0.15 m thick which hence must advance at a rate of 0.083 m min" x . If this were a slab of solid material with both of its surfaces suddenly heated to 1400 °C the time for its centre to reach 600 °C by simple conduction would, according to the classic theory, be given by at/I2 = 0.33. Here the half thickness / is 0.075 m and the thermal diffusivity of the batch may be estimated at about a = 2.8 x 10~7 m 2 s" 1 . The time needed for all of the batch to begin to react would thus be about HOmin during which time the blanket would advance 9.2 m down the furnace and it might travel as much as 20 m before melting was complete. This is clearly a serious overestimate of the length of furnace occupied by melting batch. Several factors cause this serious error. First, the thermal properties of the batch vary with temperature, largely due to them reacting; second, the batch blanket does not remain of constant thickness as reaction occurs; third, flow of liquid produced by reaction and convection of hot gases can both increase the rate of heat transfer. Jack and Jacquest (1958) studied the implications of the simple constant property model considered above and showed that
minimum melting length would be given by a particular blanket thickness for a given output. Measurements by Ito et al. (1954) in a layer of batch 150 mm thick charged on to a melt in a pot 1 m in diameter found that it took 60 min for all of the batch to reach 1000°C and thus react vigorously: our simple model predicts that it should take about 200 min for the centre to reach 1000 °C. Daniels (1973) found that the centre of a batch layer initially 40 mm thick charged on to glass at 1400°C reached 1000 °C in 24 min. Comparing these two observations suggests that the rule of time proportional to square of thickness expected for simple conduction in a solid does not apply to melting batch: if 24 min were correct for 40 mm one would predict 340 min for 150 mm. It is difficult to measure the thermal properties of reacting batch but some useful data were obtained by Kroger and Eligehausen (1959) who measured the temperature difference between the inner and outer walls of an annular space filled with batch when it was heated by a central axial heating element. When operating at steady state this is a standard method for determining conductivity; the energy input gives the heat flux and the measured temperatures allow the thermal conductivity to be calculated. Several important bold assumptions are made in applying exactly the same simple analysis to reacting batch but the data obtained are the best estimates that we have. Figure 1-12 shows the general trends found for measurements made during both heating and cooling after the batch had been converted to glass. The values for the latter are more influenced by radiant transfer. It can be seen that the apparent conductivity of batch changes little until reaction begins but then increases rapidly as temperature rises.
37
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
This brief discussion should have demonstrated that, although rarely discussed in the literature, how to charge batch into a large scale furnace to get the most rapid melting and also minimum melting segregation is a complex question of considerable importance. Batch is a good insulating material which greatly restricts heat transfer into the melt below it and thus to the under side of the batch layer. Covering the whole of the melting area with a uniform layer of batch may give the thinnest batch layer, which by itself should accelerate melting, but seriously restricts the melting of the bottom of the batch layer unless a powerful convection current of other energy source beneath the batch layer provides the necessary heat input. Optimizing the extent of cover of the melting area by batch piles, logs or blanket is a subtle matter. There is some discussion of this topic in Trier (1984). Some electric melting furnaces, for example the Gell type, rely entirely on the insulating properties of the batch to prevent heat loss from the top of the melt (Gell, 1956). 1.3.4.2 The Initial Melting Reactions
The rates at which the various materials in a batch tend to react together depend on temperatures as well as time. It is, of course, essential for the reacting materials to be in contact with each other and good contact cannot be guaranteed until some liquid has formed and is able to percolate around the solid grains still present. If the initial reactions occur in the solid state their particle sizes and efficiency of mixing must be important; reactions occurring at a solid surface must depend on the surface area available and thus on particle size. Varying the particle size for a given rate of heating can thus affect the extent to which some of the possible reactions occur. The
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
Temperature in °C
Figure 1-12. Estimates of the apparent thermal conductivities of reacting batch during heating and of the glass produced; after Kroger and Eligehausen (1957).
dependence of reaction rates on temperature also means that behavior can be modified by rate of heating. We have already seen that different parts of a batch layer cannot all be heated at the same rate, so some complications may be expected for that reason. As a result one cannot produce one reaction scheme which will always apply in a particular system and this is the reason for some of the discrepancies between the findings of different authors who have studied similar batches but used different methods or conditions. This is easily illustrated for potash-red lead-sand batches. Figure 1-13 shows the average reaction paths found for two somewhat different compositions in this system. There is no reason why the earliest reactions should have been greatly influenced by the difference in final glass composition, yet the results shown suggest this. However, both sets of results may be described fairly well by assuming the following general scheme: 1) All the potash reacts to form a potassium silicate. 2) This potassium silicate reacts with the red lead.
38
1 Classical Glass Technology Si0o
PbO
Figure 1-13. Average compositions of the liquid phase during melting of lead crystal glass according to Rosenkrands and Simmingskold (1962) and Bezborodov and Appen (1933). Idealized reaction sequences are shown dashed. The two investigations used different experimental methods, see text.
3) The potassium lead silicate dissolves the remaining silica to achieve the final glass composition. The important difference is in the composition of the potassium silicate first formed. According to Rosenkrands and Simmingskold (1962) it is the metasilicate, K 2 SiO 3 , but Bezborodov et al. (1933) found it to be the tetrasilicate, K 2 Si 4 O 9 ; the difference is explained by the experimental procedures used in the two cases. Rosenkrands and Simmingskold took small samples from a typical large pot melt being made in normal conditions but Bezborodov et al. used heat treatment of laboratory samples in 100 °C steps from 200 °C to 1200°C, keeping the sample at each temperature long enough for reaction to have almost ceased. This clearly explains why their results show much more silica reacted in the early stages than those of Rosenkrands and Simmingskold. Both sets of experiments agree about the main points: reaction first produces whatever product is most easily formed (a potassium silicate) which then undergoes a further se-
quence of reactions, ending with the slowest step (dissolving residual silica). Melting inevitably produces a range of compositions which can differ greatly in composition, density and viscosity and thus may easily segregate. Mixing these to make a homogeneous glass can be difficult, especially if density and viscosity difference have encouraged serious melting segregation. Few books discuss glass melting reactions; Bezborodov (1968) is a notable exception. If one or more of the raw materials, early liquid phases or the final melt has a strong tendency to lose a component by evaporation this can aggravate the difficulties of producing a homogeneous melt. Alkalis, sulphur, lead, boron and halogens are amongst the most volatile constituents. The kinetics of volatilization can be influenced by several factors including diffusion in the melt, transport in the gas phase and reaction with the atmosphere, see Cable (1978). Laboratory Studies The discussion above compared results obtained in the laboratory with some typical of industrial practice. The former type of experiment is convenient when it can be employed but, as we shall see, does not yield all the information that would be helpful. However, direct experiment on an industrial scale is difficult to organize and control and also very expensive, especially when the results are not directly beneficial. There is therefore a role for both the application of standard laboratory techniques and for empirical melting studies: both are needed to obtain the maximum insight that can be expected. The most obviously useful laboratory techniques are thermogravimetric analysis (at constant temperature),
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
differential thermogravimetry (with steadily rising temperature) and differential thermal analysis or its close analog differential scanning calorimetry. Thermogravimetry records only weight changes and so can record decomposition of carbonates, sulphates, nitrates and so on but cannot identify the fraction of silica reacted. Differential thermal analysis or scanning calorimetry are more versatile because they record evolution or absorption of energy, whatever its cause, but they likewise do no directly identify the process concerned. Constant temperature thermogravimetry should be the simplest kind of experiment to interpret and approximate theoretical models for solid state reactions in two component systems are available. Three are well known and widely used, the Jander model, the Ginstling and Brounshtein model and the Valensi- Carter model. Jander's (1927) equation was based on a qualitatively correct analysis of diffusion between two flat slabs of reacting solids which maintain constant volume. The important feature being that control by diffusion would make the thickness y of the flat layer of reaction product increase as y2 = kt
(1-19)
If the spherical shell on an idealized particle of radius a0 is assumed to behave like a flat slab and a is the mass fraction reacted, this transforms into [l-(l-a)ll3]2
= kt/a20
(1-20)
When examined quantitatively for a sphere the equation becomes /n)Dt/a2
(1-21)
where q> is the effective solubility; note that it appears as cp2.
39
Ginstling and Brounshtein (1950) improved this model to take the spherical symmetry into account but their analysis still ignores the motion of the boundary and any change in volume of the system and yields l-(2/3)a-(l-a)2/3 =
(1-22)
The Valensi-Carter (Valensi, 1935, 1936, 1950; Carter, 1961 a, b) model does allow for a change of volume as well as spherical or cylindrical symmetry. For spherical particles it gives [1 + (z - 1 ) a] 2 / 3 + (z -1) (1 - a) 2/3 = = z + 2(l-z)(pDt/a2 (1-23) where z is the volume of product per unit volume of the material in the sphere. The limited validity of all these equations has recently been examined by Cable and Frade (1991) who conclude that they are useful for seeing whether a reaction is diffusion-controlled but not at all suitable for estimating other parameters such as diffusivity. No good models exist for multicomponent systems or for ones with liquid present, where convection of that liquid is very likely to affect the reaction. Neither do any satisfactory theories exist for differential thermogravimetry. The main use of this kind of experiment is to indicate the temperature ranges where various reactions may be rapid and to amplify the information available from differential thermal analysis. In principle the area under the peak of a differential thermal analysis trace gives the quantity of heat evolved or absorbed. In practice it is extremely difficult to establish the base line with sufficient accuracy to make quantitative evaluation possible, largely because the thermal properties of the material change whilst it is reacting and the sample may also either swell or shrink at the same time. It is easy to show that better accuracy may be ex-
40
1 Classical Glass Technology
pected when a small sample is used and modern sets of apparatus are therefore often designed for no more than 50 mg. However, when one considers the size of particle often used in glass batches and the complexity of the mixtures concerned, it is clear that obtaining an accurate and reproducible result is by no means easy especially if it was intended to investigate the effects of minor constituents. Very finely divided powders must be used and one is thus unable to study the known effect of particle size on reaction kinetics with such apparatus. The latest improvements in the apparatus have not, in fact, helped workers studying reactions in glass or ceramic systems. One of the classic investigations of reactions in the soda-silica system is the differential thermal analysis work of Wilburn and Thomasson (1958, 1960). The second part of this investigation was concerned with the influence of minor additions on sodium carbonate-silica reactions. These workers necessarily used small samples and finely divided materials which were heated at 10 °C a minute. Their results for the basic system indicate differences according the particle size. Their main findings were that an endothermic reaction can begin around 550 °C, possibly influenced by but not due to the quartz inversion at 573 °C; that there is an important exothermic reaction at about 700 °C and an endothermic reaction at 780 °C. Glass was only detected (by the presence of an annealing peak) in samples heated to above 780 °C which agreed with the formation of some eutectic liquid. With coarser materials (0.156-0.210 mm) the main loss of CO 2 occurred at about 850 °C, the melting point of sodium carbonate, thus suggesting only limited solid state reaction in that case. The second paper investigated the effects of NaF, NaNO 3 , (NH 4 ) 2 SO 4 , and Na2SiF6
on Na 2 CO 3 -SiO 2 reactions. They found that the main effects could be summarized by putting each material into one of three groups: 1) Production of a liquid at a lower temperature by eutectic melting of the minor addition with sodium carbonate (NaCl, NaF, Na 2 SiF 6 ); 2) Reaction between the minor component and a major one producing a new compound which might or might not assist melting ((NH 4 ) 2 SO 4 , Na 2 SiF 6 ); 3) the minor phase melting to form a liquid at a lower temperature (NaNO3). Other studies of this kind were reported by Wilburn et al. (1965). Such work is evidently very useful but far from sufficient to reveal everything about glass making reactions. Devising other experiments that will reveal useful information is often a greater challenge than making the experiment. Cable and Martlew (1971, 1984, 1985, 1986) studied the corrosion of silica rods by a variety of liquids, and found that adding relatively small proportions of silica to molten sodium carbonate evolved proportions of carbon dioxide equivalent to the formation of the metasilicate, Na 2 SiO 3 . The various results available suggest the following kind of scheme as a basic model but it does not always show the exact sequence of reactions even in this apparently simple system. Na 2 CO 3 zSiO 2 (1-24) Na 2 O SiO2 + CO 2 t + (z - l)SiO 2 N a 2 O S i O 2 + ( z - l ) S i O 2 -+ -» Na 2 O • 2 SiO2 + (z - 2) SiO2
(1-25)
Na 2 O • 2 SiO2 + (z - 2) SiO2 -> (i _26) -> Na 2 O • n SiO2 + (z - n) SiO 2 , n « 2.5 Na 2 O • n SiO2 + (z - n) SiO2 -> -• Na 2 O • p SiO2 + (z - p) SiO2
(1-27)
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
Na 2 O • p SiO2 + (z - p) SiO2 -• Na 2 O • z SiO2
(1-28)
The value of n in the above equations may be the disilicate-silica eutectic composition and p the composition of liquid in equilibrium with silica according to the phase diagram (see below). This range of liquids differs considerably in density and viscosity so that segregation under the influence of gravity may easily occur. There may also be a definite tendency for undissolved silica to float to the surface of the melt. Of course these reactions overlap in time and space so that it may be very difficult to identify them beyond the second step. A recent study of melting reactions in 3 g soda-lime-silica batches by Sheckler and Dinger (1990) found a complex series of reactions clearly sensitive to silica particle size, when mixed with very fine soda and limestone but, they, unfortunately, do not specify their rate of heating which was probably 10 °C per minute. The samples were held for 5 minutes at each of seven temperatures from 775 to 865 °C and cooled for examination. Silica was the only compound to persist throughout this range but numerous others had a transient presence. For example, some double sodium calcium carbonate was always formed yet sodium disilicate was present only up to 790 °C and wollastonite occurred above 805 °C but only with the finest grade of silica (< 53 |im) in both cases. On the other hand, Na 2 O • 2CaO • 3SiO 2 formed towards the top end of the temperature range with all three grades of silica used. An intermediate carbonate, 5 CaO • SiO2 • CO 3 , was found for two grades of silica but not the finest. The authors correctly conclude that no existing model of melting can correctly predict the behavior to be found in even a relatively simple three component system. This behaviour depends on heating
41
rate (which cannot be uniform throughout a typical volume of batch) as well as on particle size. Most batches contain more sand, usually the most refractory constituent, than any other component and this must be dissolved by the liquid phase or phases. Dissolving the quartz which did not react during the early vigorous reactions often occupies the majority of the batch-free time. The dissolution of residual silica is normally controlled by diffusion in the melt with equilibrium conditions at the silica-melt interface (Kreider and Cooper, 1967; Hlavac and Nademlynska, 1969). Thus, even if the rest of the liquid were homogeneous, this would produce inhomogeneities in the form of silica-rich haloes around each sand grain, see the photographic demonstration of this by JebsenMarwedel (1956) and by Cable and Bower (1965). Figure 1-14 indicates what happens in the simple binary soda-silica system. Suppose that we choose to melt a glass with 34% soda at 1400 °C. The phase diagram shows that the liquid in contact with the sand grains will contain 12.7% Na 2 O and the concentration difference driving dissolution will be equivalent to Ac = 213% Na 2 O. Even when all the sand grains have just disappeared the melt must contain regions of compositions covering at least the range from about 13 to 35% Na 2 O. One useful way of minimizing the problem of silica dissolution is to use silicate minerals like feldspars or nepheline syenite to decrease the proportion of silica that must be supplied as quartz. This also has the advantage of decreasing the amounts of alkali that must be added as the expensive carbonates. It is usually a mistake to use oxides as raw materials simply to save the trouble of doing the necessary batch calculations because many of those that are stable (e.g. MgO, A12O3) are
42
1 Classical Glass Technology I 1600
I
I
I
I
I
I
j
-
AC _y
1400
/ /
o 1200
-
1000
-
CD Q.
I
\
V
800 I
I 40
I
i 60
I
| 80
100
wt. % SiCL
Figure 1-14. The driving force for dissolution of residual sand grains in a binary melt with 34% soda when melted at 1400 °C, assuming equilibrium at the silicamelt interface.
One of the most notable contributions not mentioned is that of Kroger who, with his colleagues, made a detailed thermogravimetric study of reactions in soda-lime-silica batches between 1933 and 1957. Some of the problems encountered in such work may be illustrated by a brief examination of Kroger's work. Such experiments reveal how quickly the carbonates decompose but nothing directly about the reaction of the silica or other refractory oxides. The only theoretical models available to interpret the results were the admittedly approximate equations derived for solid state reactions in binary systems which are often acceptable up to about 50% mass fraction reacted but not beyond (Frade and Cable, 1991 a). These did not fit Kroger's data which were for three component mixtures and reaction in the presence of liquid but he found that the following equation generally yielded straight lines, (1-29)
not at all reactive; materials that decompose on heating together are much more suitable. The above example shows that further mixing and diffusion beyond the batch-free time will be essential to produce homogeneous glass. Unfortunately diffusivities are low and mixing by diffusion alone will be effective only over distances of fractions of a millimetre even after many hours. Flow can stretch and intermingle different layers and considerably accelerate mixing; this is discussed under homogenizing. This brief discussion does scant justice to the work of numerous other experimenters who have studied various aspects of glass melting reactions but the processes are so complex and our theoretical framework for trying to understand them so inadequate that it is impossible to give an informative brief summary of their work.
He showed that this equation is equivalent to assuming
= k'l(yt)
(1-30)
but did not further justify this model. However, quite a lot of results showed an inflexion, and it may be very misleading to assume that this indicates a change in the reaction. This empirical analysis was however useful in demonstrating the temperature dependence of reaction rate and the sudden increase in it as soon as eutectic liquid has formed. Estimating how much silica has reacted is a difficult task. Some workers have attempted to do this by measuring the size of the differential thermal analysis peak due to the quartz inversion but this is not easy to make quantitative. Azm and Moore (1953) used an X-ray diffraction method to follow reactions in several soda-lime-silica
43
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
batches at temperatures between 900 and 1400°C, see Fig. 1-15 and confirmed that initial reaction is rapid even at 900 °C but at that temperature becomes extremely slow once about half the silica has reacted. Raising the temperature accelerates the initial reaction but, more important, increases the proportion of silica which reacts quickly. It is interesting to note that the liquidus temperature of this glass is about 1040 °C and that its primary crystalline phase is devitrite but it is near to the /J-wollastonite border; when a considerable proportion of silica has yet to dissolve it might produce Na 2 O 2CaO • 3 SiO 2 . This does not mean that it would be impossible to react all the silica at temperatures below 1040 °C but such reaction would be accompanied by the formation of one or more of these crystalline phases and such a reaction would proceed only slowly. This doubtless explains why the extent of reaction after 48 h was only about 57% at 900 °C and 78% at 1000°C but had risen steeply to 98% at 1100°C. From what we have already seen the course of reaction does not involve just one simple step; not surprisingly, Azm and Moore failed to find a simple model to describe the overall kinetics. More insight was shown by Botvinkin (1936) than some other workers when he suggested that one might be able to describe the progress of reaction by a modified boundary layer model
da/dt=DAt(CEQ-Ct)/S
(1-31)
where D is diffusivity, At the surface area of silica available at time t, CEQ the equilibrium silica concentration at the relevant temperature and Ct the actual concentration of silica in the liquid at time t. However, this still leaves some problems over the value of CEQ for a complex glass and determining At as well as severe complications in trying both to estimate Ct and to
1300°C
1200°C
10
20
30
40
50
Time in h
Figure 1-15. Variation of fraction of quartz reacted with time in small melts of a sodium carbonate-calcium carbonate-sand batch (11.2% Na 2 O, 10.0% CaO) at different temperature; Azm and Moore (1953).
predict the boundary layer thickness S. Today this remains a very difficult field in which to make sound theoretical progress, even for interpreting simple model experiments like those of Cable and Martlew (1971, 1984a, b, 1986). Empirical Melting Studies Because of the difficulties pointed out above, there is a place for observations made directly on glass melts. Whenever complex phenomena can be observed, seeing what happens (or appears to happen) can be a powerful stimulus to thought and understanding. Relying only on instruments which give strictly limited and predetermined information can be misleading. Simple qualitative and quantitative experiments involving batch melting thus have a useful role to play. One of the most important questions to be asked of any experiment is how to scale up the results to predict what will happen on a large scale. This
44
1 Classical Glass Technology
is impossible with standard laboratory methods of thermal analysis. It might be possible if melting were studied on a range of melt or batch charge sizes. The experiment recognized as useful to some degree by all glass makers is the batch-free time. This is simply the time needed to dissolve all of the original batch ingredients, silica usually being the slowest to dissolve completely. Because of the poor heat transfer properties of batch, if for no other reason, batch-free time must depend on the size of the sample. Another factor determined by the size of the sample is the influence of the gases evolved during reaction on the atmosphere in which melting effectively occurs. In a reasonably large sample the atmosphere is determined almost entirely by the gases given off by the reactions. However, with a very small sample mixing of these gases with the surrounding atmosphere may be so quick as prevent this. Where the influence of atmosphere is not important samples as small as 1 g may give useful information but, if the atmosphere and oxidation of the melt do matter, samples weighing less than about 50 g are not likely to give useful information. One obvious problem with measurements of batch-free time is the tendency for segregation to occur and another the sticking of some silica grains to the crucible walls above the level of the melt or the floating of some grains on the surface around the meniscus. In both cases those grains may take much longer to dissolve than any others and they should be discounted. Potts et al. (1944) used a slightly inclined furnace and rotated the melt so that grains near the meniscus were washed down and stirred into the melt, thereby decreasing the scatter of the batch-free time measurements. In one of the early classic investigations Preston and Turner (1940) showed a simple
linear relation between sand grain size and batch-free time which can be interpreted in the following disarmingly simple but inexact way. Assume that the inverse of batchfree time gives the average reaction rate just as the total surface area of a given mass of similar shaped particles is proportional to the inverse of particle size; the observed linear relation, with an intercept close to what can be justified by the time to heat to reaction temperature, can thus be taken to mean that rate of reaction is proportional to the surface area of silica available. This seems to be an unexceptionable conclusion but is not generally valid as shown by the other classic series of experiments by Potts (1939, 1941) and his colleagues at Owens Illinois (Potts et al, 1944). They found that batch-free time can go through a minimum when particle sizes are varied, the minimum being where all particle sizes are matched, see Fig. 1-16. The increase in batch-free time seen here for very fine sand was not observed by Preston and Turner because they used very finely divided chemical reagent sodium and calcium carbonates so that their silica was always coarser than the other materials. That the increase in batch-free time for very fine silica was largely due to segregation and inadequate contact between different types of particle is supported by results of Manring and Bauer (1964) whose experiments with dry batches also showed such a minimum but when water was added, so that soda-rich solution could coat all the sand grains, the minimum disappeared and the finest sand again gave the shortest batch-free time as shown in Fig. 1-17. Interesting experiments by Boffe and Letocart (1962), who used graded sands, showed that the real behavior is quite complex. The average rate of the initial reac-
1.3 The Melting of Glasses !
I
I
I
I
I
Sand
/ 300 -
/
Lime //
/ 200
/
Soda
/ /
/
/
•
s Cd CQ
-
100 -
I
0
0
I 0.2
I
I
0.4
I
I
0.6
Average particle grain size in mm
Figure 1-16. The effect of varying one at a time the particle sizes of the three raw materials on the batchfree times of small melts of a soda-lime-silica glass at 1427 °C; after Potts et al. (1944).
45
tions must be approximately proportional to the surface area of silica available but the final stage of dissolving the last few silica grains must depend on the size of the largest grains, even if there are only a few of them. Hence batch-free time is not always a simple function of either surface area of silica or of average particle size, as shown in Fig. 1-18. Hot stage microscopy can be very informative. Thus Manring et al. (1964) showed that molten sodium carbonate can prefer to wet cullet rather than sand grains and this led them to make some suggestions about how cullet should be charged into a furnace. In glass melting studies it is often much more difficult to devise a useful experiment than to carry out experiments by one of the standard but not very relevant laboratory methods. 1.3.4.3 Refining
A typical batch to produce 100 kg of glass weighs about 120 kg and thus evolves around 20 kg of combined gases during
sz o 05 CQ
10 -
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
Average sand grain size in mm
Figure 1-17. Comparison of batch-free times at 1482 °C of dry and moist batches of a soda-silica glass (25.6% Na 2 O) when using different sand particle sizes with a constant soda fraction (about 0.256 mm); after Manring and Bauer (1964).
Specific surface in m 2 kg' 1
Figure 1-18. The relation between specific surface of silica and batch-free time for melts made using graded sands. The anomalous values near the middle of the diagram are for sands containing small proportions of large grains; after Boffe and Letocart (1962).
46
1 Classical Glass Technology
melting. The majority of this gas is carbon dioxide from carbonates which, at a melting temperature of 1400 °C and 1 atm, occupies nearly 1500 times as large a volume as the melt produced. It cannot be surprising that vigorous gas evolution during the early stages of melting sometimes causes a melt to boil over the pot which contains it. Much of this gas is given off at somewhat lower temperatures during the course of the batch reactions and it provides the majority of the atmosphere in which the glass is produced. The presence of oxidizing or reducing agents in the batch can therefore have a considerable effect on the degree of oxidation of the freshly made melt. Much of the gas escapes easily by forming large bubbles which coalesce and quickly reach the surface where they burst. However, when the vigorous reactions have ceased the melt contains some residual dissolved gases, but may not be saturated with them, and also a considerable number of smaller bubbles some of which cannot rise rapidly through the melt. Refining is the elimination of these bubbles which are only easy to study beyond the batch-free time. Many melts contain less than 1 vol.% of bubbles at the batch-free time but the average size may be less than 1 mm and the number sufficient to make the glass almost opaque. Several factors influence the number of bubbles and their size distribution but a fairly typical number at the batchfree time would be 500 per mL, and the size distribution would range from about 25 jam up to 1 mm diameter. These small bubbles are called seed and normally represent a very tiny fraction of all those produced during melting. Bubbles bigger than about 2 mm in diameter are called blisters. The number and size distribution depend on the type of glass, choice of batch materials, refining agents used and size of sand
grains as well as melting temperature and size of melt. It is not easy to observe bubbles in a melt at high temperature so the majority of our information about refining is based on measurements made on samples cooled to room temperature. Such samples have to be prepared with care if reliable information is to be obtained from them. One of the main problems concerns relaxation of the glass during cooling. Near to melting temperature the viscosity of the melt is sufficiently low for a bubble to expand or shrink to maintain equlibrium internal pressure as temperature changes. Thus, assuming ideal behavior,
PiVJT1=p2V2/T2
(1-32)
or, if x is the diameter of the bubble, Pixl/T1=p2xl/T2
(1-33)
The pressure in the melt outside the bubble will be only slightly higher than the external atmosphere pressure p0 because the hydrostatic head will be small, so Eq. (1-33) may be written
•2a/pox2)xl/T2
(1-34)
Only if the bubbles are less than about 50 jim in diameter does surface tension a have a measurable effect on their behavior. Many bubbles will therefore maintain equilibrium pressure and shrink according to x 2 /x 1 = (T2/T1)1>3
(1-35)
On cooling the melt will eventually become too viscous for flow to occur and the bubble becomes frozen into the effectively solid glass. The size will now remain almost constant on further cooling but the internal pressure will change according to •2a/pox)/T2
(1-36)
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
The viscosity at which the glass becomes effectively solid in this respect is near the upper end of the annealing range and bubbles containing non-condensable gases usually have internal pressures close to 0.30 atm at room temperature. Figure 1-19 shows the behavior expected of bubbles on cooling provided there is no reaction of the contents with the surrounding glass. This question has recently been examined in detail by Cable and Frade (1991). If glass is cast then quenched below the annealing range some bubbles can behave in a startlingly different fashion. Consider a sphere of glass 100 mm in diameter which is rapidly cooled to room temperature and which before cooling contained one tiny bubble near its centre. The outer skin of the sphere may become solid at about 500 °C when the average temperature of the still fluid interior is perhaps 750 °C. As the sphere cools further the inner core is still able to flow under stresses down to about
500 °C, by which stage it will have wanted to contract by about an additional 4.6 mL (taking the volume coefficient of thermal expansion to be 3.5xl0~ 5 ). The glass is close to incompressible so that the sphere should be highly stressed, tensile in the centre and compressive on the outside, unless now annealed. However, since it contains a seed near the centre, the work needed to expand this is much less than the stored strain energy, so the bubble is expanded and its internal pressure decreases as the glass relaxes and much of the stress is relieved. This is why Rupert's drops sometimes contain relatively large bubbles. Only bubbles nearest the slowest cooling part of the glass are expanded in this way. Of course the real behavior is more complex and the volume of the bubble perhaps no more than a third of the volume estimated. The Role of Buoyancy in Refining Rise to the surface is the most obvious way in which seed might be removed once the vigorous melting reactions have stopped. Jebsen-Marwedel (1936) used model calculations for a typical range of bubble diameters, temperatures and viscosities, to show that it was doubtful whether this could be the only mechanism at work. Stokes's law is one of the classic exercises in hydrodynamics and shows that the terminal velocity Vs of an isolated solid sphere of diameter x in a large body of liquid is given by
Pressure
1.0 -
Vs=(l/lS)(Ql-Q2)x2g/r1 400
800
47
1200
Temperature in °C
Figure 1-19. Approximate changes in size and internal pressure in a bubble in a body of glass which is being cooled relatively slowly.
(1-37)
where QX and Q2 are the densities of solid and liquid and g is gravitational acceleration. Jebsen-Marwedel plotted a very clear diagram showing how this velocity varied with temperature and bubble diameter for a typical viscosity-temperature relation.
48
1 Classical Glass Technology
Bastick (1956) took this argument one step further by demonstrating that measurements of how total number of bubbles varied with time yielded a temperature dependence steeper than that predicted by allowing for the known changes in viscosity of the melt and variation in size of a bubble according to the perfect gas laws, see Fig. 1-20. Note that Bastick extrapolated his measured data back to a common
100
200
300
400
Time in min
Figure 1-20. Variation of rate of refining with temperature according to Bastick (1956). The rate changes more steeply with temperature than would be expected from the known dependence of viscosity.
intercept at zero time but, although this is an interesting observation, it is an unwise thing to rely on because the phenomena occurring during the shortest times (batch heating and gas-evolving reactions) are clearly different from those occurring later. Bastick used the slopes of the lines in his figures to show that combining Eqs. (1-35) and (1-37) would lead one to expect rate of disappearance by rise to the surface to be given by
= (im(Ql-Q2)x2g/t1 = = kx(T)2/r,(T)
(1-38)
Putting in the known variation of glass melt viscosity rj1 and x(T) showed that k was not a constant but increased as temperature rose. A possible explanation is
that the refining agents present made bubbles expand more than expected, thus increasing doubts about the role of rise. The fact that the Rybczynski-Hadamard analysis for a fluid sphere shows the terminal velocity (FB) of a fluid sphere of very low viscosity in a liquid of much higher viscosity to be given by VB = (3/2) Vs= (1/12)(Q 1 -Q 2 )x 2 g/f 1
(1-39)
does not affect this argument. Hornyak and Weinberg (1984) confirmed that bubbles in a glass melt obeyed Eq. (1-39). Hearing Bastick describe these experiments and his deductions from them led Cable (1958) to make similar experiments which then included measuring the size distributions of the seed as well as their total numbers in all samples. He reasoned as follows. The spatial distribution bubbles of particular size must be close to uniform at some time soon after the vigorous reactions have finished but before the batchfree time. Bubble formation may not cease until the melt is batch free but may be assumed unimportant from this time onward. If the melt is static all bubbles will rise towards the surface at a rate given by Eq. (1-39), so that the fraction disappeared at any particular time will be in proportion to the distance risen divided by the depth of the melt h. If the number of bubbles of a given size present per unit volume at the assumed beginning of the process is n 0 , the decay in number at longer times should be
n = no(l-k'x2t/h)
(1-40)
k! being obtained from Eq. (1-39) with t measured from the time when the random spatial distribution existed. When a range of sizes is present the total number of bubbles should be obtained by summing Eq. (1-40) for all sizes,
N=Yno-{k'lh)tY o
o
(1-41)
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
49
As indicated the summation must be made only for the sizes still remaining and cut off at
c' = (*/W 2
(1-42)
Bubbles obeying such a law could easily produce an exponential decay of total number with time as the average size and average rate of disappearance will both decrease with time. However, analysis of the recorded data shows the relation between n and t not to be linear but closer to log n = log n0 — b t
C/)
c o
(1-43)
Since d(logn)/dt = (l/n)(dn/dt% the predicted slope of such a graph should be b = x2/[h/k-x2t]
(1-44)
Figure 1-21 shows the predictions of this equation for appropriate times together with two sets of experimental data. It can be seen that bubbles large enough to disappear by rise and bursting do so but smaller bubbles disappear faster than expected and the discrepancy gets larger as the size becomes smaller; there is no indication that rate of disappearance approaches zero for x = 0 and rate of disappearance is, fortunately, less sensitive to bubble size than this theory indicates. Also note that the general features of the behavior are very similar for melts with and without refining agents. This model ignores convection of the melt. Horizontal velocities would affect the path followed by a bubble but not the time taken to rise to the surface but vertical velocities will affect time to rise and be able to burst at the surface. The internal circulation caused by thermal convection in a pot or tank must therefore have some effect. However, any flow system in a pot or crucible must have as much downward flow as upward and it is difficult to see how
0
0.1 Seed diameter in mm
Figure 1-21. Comparison of calculated rate of disappearance at 1400 °C of seed by rise to the surface (shaded area) and actual observations in small melts of a soda-lime-silica glass: without (•) and with (•) refining agent (0.50% As2O3); after Cable (1960).
thermal convection would accelerate the removal of most bubbles. Another possible mechanism is coalescence which is evidently important whilst the vigorous early reactions take place but is most unlikely to occur in such viscous liquids when small bubbles are on average a considerable number of diameters apart. Refining agents, that is minor constituents added to the batch to accelerate refining, have been known for a long time. The most important are sulfates, arsenic oxide, antimony oxide, and halides, especially chloride. Sulfate is the most used today. If refining were governed by rise to the surface they could only act by either affecting the density and viscosity of the melt or by making the bubbles bigger. At the levels used (< 1%) their effects on the properties
50
1 Classical Glass Technology
of the melt are too small to accept that explanation; the kind of analysis just described allows for any effect of bubble size and thus shows that refining agents affect the rate of disappearance of bubbles of the same size. Some other explanation must be found. The Role of Mass Transfer Since large volumes of gas are evolved during the melting reactions, most of which happen before the reacting batch has reached maximium temperature, the melt may or may not be saturated with gases and interaction between bubble and gases dissolved in the melt may make bubbles either grow or dissolve. The former would accelerate rise to the surface, assisting larger bubbles most, and the latter would make rise to the surface unnecessary. The first reliable evidence that mass transfer does occur between bubble and melt was reported by Appen and Polyakova (1938). These workers showed that the composition of the gas in bubbles in samples taken from a melt at different times changes during the course of refining. Bubbles from a melt without refining agents were largely carbon dioxide, as might be expected from the batch materials, but changes occurred when a refining agent had been added. At first the bubbles were still rich in carbon dioxide but they soon became rich in oxygen and later rich in nitrogen. Appen and Polyakova had to use primitive methods of gas analysis and their results represented a considerable experimental feat. Slavyanskii (1957) reported a larger body of similar data by Russian workers also obtained by the same methods. Since about 1960 it has been possible to analyse nanolitre and picolitre quantities of gas by several techniques and numerous
workers have confirmed and extended these early data for samples taken from melts then analysed at room temperature, see for example Cable and Naqvi (1975), Cable etal. (1969) and Mulfinger (1974, 1976). The relation between the rate of change of gas composition, the amount of refining agent used and the change in refining behavior, see Cable and Naqvi (1975), is very convincing qualitative evidence that refining agents do act by mass transfer. However, these data do not show whether growth or dissolution is the crucial process, or whether both are generally involved. The conditions in which bubbles are formed and in which refining occurs are far from equilibrium and simple models assuming that conditions around the bubble are at equilibrium may give seriously misleading predictions. Direct observation of bubbles during refining would be the best way to determine what happens but accurate observation in conditions typical of refining is difficult although several workers have measured bubble behavior in model experiments. The first notable experiments which demonstrated that bubble growth or dissolution is possible were by Greene and Gaffney (1959); Greene and Kitano (1959); Greene and Lee (1965); Greene and Platts (1969); Greene and Davis (1974). This work confirmed that oxygen bubbles subsequently formed and reheated in well refined glass could shrink in the conditions used. Also that equimolar proportions of SO2 and O 2 could easily dissolve. These experiments also showed that complete dissolution of a bubble is much influenced by low impurity levels in the initial gas or by gases dissolved in the melt, some of which will diffuse into the bubble in the early stages. Solinov and Pankova (1965) reported some data for bubble growth which showed that adding arsenic retarded
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
bubble growth but these were not typical refining bubbles. Nemec (1974, 1977a,b, 1980) has also published a considerable body of data on bubble growth. Cable and Haroon (1970) tried a different experiment in freshly made melts, one without and one with refining agent. They injected a few relatively large bubbles of carbon dioxide at 1200 °C, left the melts for a few minutes, cooled and annealed them, then recovered these bubbles, measured them and also analysed their contents. These bubbles had become enriched in oxygen but also shrunk, more in the melt containing the refining agent than in the other, showing that the refining agent had made transfer of CO 2 into the melt faster than transfer of O 2 from the melt into the bubble in those conditions. Both growth and dissolution can clearly occur in melts under different conditions, one of the obvious factors being the temperature dependence of gas solubilities in the melt, most gases becoming more soluble as temperature falls. However the melt is not at equilibrium during the short period of time which determines the conditions for refining and the age of the melt may affect behavior even at constant temperature. The widely accepted picture is that growth occurs at maximum melting temperature but that resorption allows dissolution of residual bubbles on cooling near the end of melting. This may often be true but will not apply to isothermal laboratory melts on which many studies have been made. Theoretical Models for Mass Transfer Two approaches are possible and both have some range of validity. The diffusioncontrolled change in size of a sphere is a very difficult problem to solve even when the spherical symmetry of the system is
51
maintained. As a result it is a considerable challenge to deal with a bubble assumed to be stationary in the melt and this is one model. The other is to use standard boundary layer approximations for a freely rising bubble. The latter should apply for relatively fluid melts and fairly large bubbles but must eventually fail for a dissolving bubble even if valid in its early stages. The classic model for a stationary bubble takes over the result of Carslaw and Jaeger (1959) for heat transfer in a region internally bounded by a bubble which has a constant temperature on its surface. This leads to da/dt=D[(CO0-Ca)/Cs](1-45)
-[I/a-
where C^ is the assumed uniform concentration of gas in the melt, Ca the value at the surface of the bubble and C s the concentration of gas inside the bubble. This equation is valid only for very low solubility and hence very slow change in bubble size; it also assumes that the bubble contains only one gas, which we know not to be true. Even this equation is difficult to integrate and both of the two not very satisfactory approximations obtained by assuming either I/a g> l/(nD t)lj2, a2 = a2 + 2D[(C^-Ca)/Cs]t
(1-46)
or l/(7i D 0 1 / 2 M M a = a0 +
(2/T^2)D1/2
[(C*, - Ca)/Cs] t^2
have often been used; the latter can be cast into the same form as Jander's Eq. (1-21). The motion of the boundary changes the area through which mass transfer can occur and also distorts the concentration profile in the liquid around the bubble. A change in composition of the bubble means that concentrations of the various gases at the surface of the bubble also
52
1 Classical Glass Technology
change with time; this further complicates solution of a realistic model of the process. Adding surface tension for small bubbles and the fact that Sieverts' law rather than Henry's law may be needed to describe conditions at the interface for water vapour increases the complexities. These complications mean that numerical methods must be used to obtain valid results and this family of problems in diffusion-controlled bubble growth and dissolution have been studied in detail by Cable and Frade (1987a,b,c,d, 1988) for both one component and multi-component bubbles. Growth of a one component bubble from zero initial size must follow R = 2p(Dt)1/2
(1-48)
as shown by Scriven (1959), where R is the dimensionless radius and the growth rate constant is a function of, but not in general equal to, (CO0 — Ca)/Cs. This also represents the asymptotic behavior of a bubble growing from finite initial size and most bubbles closely follow this regime for R > 5. Dissolving bubbles, on the other hand, are always in a transient regime and the only valid simple approximation for one component dissolving bubbles applies only for very low solubility and is Ri = l-D[(C^-Ca)/Cs]t
(1-49)
Over most of the range of values of solubility the form of JR (t) is sensitive to the values of the parameters. Multi-component bubbles can show several interesting features. Bubbles which continue to grow will always eventually achieve a constant composition which can be estimated from the properties of the particular case. If the bubble initially had this composition it would behave like a one component bubble but one with any other initial composition can show com-
plex transient behavior. It may, according to the deviation from equilibrium bubble composition, initially exhibit either shrinkage or accelerated growth: it seems that only one change in the sign of dR/dt is possible with a given bubble but this is difficult to demonstrate rigorously. Multicomponent bubbles which eventually dissolve can show either positive or negative values of dR/dt at the beginning, for the same reasons as with growing bubbles, but do not generally tend to an asymptotic constant composition because they cannot achieve a pseudo-steady state. Although it is difficult to predict the details of behavior there are simple rules for deciding whether the initial value of dR/dt will be positive or negative and for deciding whether the bubble will in the end grow or dissolve (Cable and Frade, 1987 d). If the dissolved concentration of each gas i is defined in terms of Fi = (C — C (oo))J C s , gt(0) is the mole fraction of each gas initially in the bubble and oct is the Ostwald solubility coefficient for that gas, the initial sign of dR/dt will be the same as that of I = I.(Fo.t-*igi(0))
(1-50)
whilst its final behavior is controlled by S = ItFOti/ai
(1-51)
If S is positive the bubble will grow, if S is negative it will dissolve. The asymptotic composition of a growing bubble could often be determined experimentally but the solubilities, diffusivities and saturations of each of the gases involved will rarely be known with sufficient accuracy to make a theoretical prediction. However, the bubble must have the most mobile species tending to diffuse into the bubble as its major constituent. The observation that seed eventually become rich in nitrogen towards the end of refining cannot be attrib-
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
uted to bubble growth because nitrogen normally behaves like an inert gas of low solubility and diffusivity. Bubbles which become rich in nitrogen late in their lives must be dissolving, the other gases which find it easier to diffuse out leaving the bubble rich in nitrogen. This does not exclude the possibility that other bubbles grew because those may have risen to the surface and burst by that stage of refining. It is interesting that Cable and Frade (1987d) could not match the observed CO 2 ->O 2 -> N 2 composition cycle or any plausible set of values of solubilities, diffusivities and dissolved concentrations. The theory confirms the finding of Greene and his students that a tiny impurity content in the initial gas or a very small residual content of other gases dissolved in the melt can greatly retard complete dissolution of a bubble and shows that it is not easy to tell which of these factors has affected any particular bubble. The standard boundary layer model for freely rising bubbles was applied to bubbles in glass by Onorato et al. (1981), using plausible model values for the properties of the gases but there is again a lack of accurate data for these parameters and also for experimental data to which the model is known to apply. It is difficult to claim that our knowledge of refining glass melts is qualitatively clearly understood and only in need of data for solubilities and diffusivities to resolve all the problems. Why, for example, does it seem to be frequently true that too little refining agent makes refining worse and that too much also makes performance fall off again? This appears to be related to the rate of conversion from carbon dioxide to oxygen; with too little refining agent this is not observed to happen, with too much it is retarded. The usually accepted model, proposed by Otto Schott,
53
assumes a process such as (1-52) and that it tends to go further to the right as temperature falls so that the melt is supersaturated at the maximum melting temperature and less than saturated on cooling to near working temperature. However, this does not explain why refining agents function in isothermal melts. Nor does it account for the more rapid transfer of carbon dioxide out of the bubble than of oxygen in observed by Cable and Haroon (1970). Refining requires that the melt around a bubble can rapidly absorb or desorb a small amount of gas; this may not necessarily require an increased equilibrium solubility, a transient kinetic effect would suffice. 1.3.4.4 The Homogenizing of Glass Melts The discussion of melting reactions has made it clear that a range of liquids which vary considerably in density, viscosity, reactivity, volatility and other properties will be formed at different stages of melting. These must be mixed together to attain the degree of homogeneity required of most glasses. Differences in refractive index lead to optical distortion and, as a result, optical glasses must have higher standards of homogeneity than any other material made on a large scale. Differences in thermal expansion can cause considerable and increasing internal stress as a glass cools from the glass transition range which can make inhomogeneous glasses very fragile at room temperature and this implies high standards of homogeneity in many glasses where optical properties are not the most important. Likewise not all properties are simple additive functions of composition so that accurate and reproducible measurements of many properties need samples of good homogeneity.
54
1 Classical Glass Technology
Diffusive Mixing In the end mass transfer working at an atomic level must make glass composition as uniform as can be achieved. Although the classic Stokes-Einstein relation between viscosity and diffusivity > = kBT/(6nrjR)
(1-53)
applies only to liquids comprised of large spherical molecules of radius JR, not to typical glass melts, it is sufficient to show that mass transfer diffusivities are very low in glass melts even at melting temperatures. Effective diffusivities for mass transfer are strongly dependent on both composition and temperature; values will not often exceed 10~ 1 0 m 2 s~ 1 . Unaided diffusion will require extremely long times to homogenize a viscous liquid. If an inhomogeneity could be represented as a slab of thickness 2 /, with a concentration of solute C o , immersed in a large bulk of material with uniform concentration C^, its centre concentration would decay with time according to
Table 1-6. Dimensionless times for the decay of concentration at the centre of inhomogeneities of thickness or diameter 2 /.
OAAC0 Isolated: Slab Cylinder Sphere Regular array: Alternate layers
-erf(//2(Dr)
)
(1-54)
If it were a cylinder the radial diffusion would proceed rather faster according to C(0) = 1 - e x p ( - l2/(4Dt))
(1-55)
if it were a sphere the result would be 12
C(0) = erf 1/2{Dt) ' - (2/^/n) (1/2 JDt) • •exp(-/ 2 /(4£>£))
(1-56)
All of these involve the dimensionless time Dt/l2 which shows that real time is inversely proportional to diffusivity and directly proportional to square of size. Table 1 -6 shows the predicted times for the maximum concentration to decay to a tenth and a hundredth of its original value for these cases. It can be seen that the geome-
0.05 AC0 0.01 AC0
31.67 2.37 0.854
126.8 4.87 1.42
3185 24.87 4.34
1.031
1.31
1.97
try has a very significant effect; a point which is reinforced by imagining that the flat slab has been stretched and folded numerous times to make a laminar structure with alternate layers of the two compositions. If these layers are assumed to be of equal thickness the dimensionless concentration is given by (-i)n (1-57) exp
1/2
2
Time (Dt/l ) to decay to:
Type of inhomogeneity
Dt
-
Jf2
cos
2/
and the concentration on the centre line of a layer by C(0)=^ exp
Dt
Jl2
(1-58)
This series converges rapidly for (Dt)/l2 >0.2; for short times the following is more convenient, ,. ^_Q.
Figure 1-22 compares the rates of decay of the central concentrations in an isolated layer and in one in a regular array: the
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
advantage of the latter is clear. The decay of the latter is much quicker for two reasons: 1) the maximum distance over which diffusion must occur is greatly reduced and 2) stretching and folding that layer p times to make one layer of thickness 2 / into a series of layers each of thickness only 2 l/p brings an extra advantage. These relations make clear that there are only three ways in which homogenizing by diffusion can be accelerated: 1) by increasing diffusivity by raising temperature, 2) by decreasing duffusion distances and 3) by decreasing the initial concentration difference which must be reduced. The first of these can only be achieved by raising temperature, which is only possible within specific limits; the second is the most attractive and achieved by stirring; the third is very important but often forgotten in general discussions; choice of batch materials and melting schedules can be very influential here. Preventing the development of inhomogeneity is better than trying to cure it afterwards.
1
102
10
10 3
2
Dimensionless time, Dt/I
Figure 1-22. Predicted decay by diffusion of the centre concentration for a single slab of inhomogeneity of thickness 2 / embedded in a melt and for a layer in a regular array of alternate layers and glass matrix each of the same thickness.
Convective Mixing Glass melts are sufficiently viscous for flow to nearly always be governed by viscous drag and so in the laminar flow regime. This is very convenient when wishing to describe and calculate flow patterns but the predictability of the flows implies that the degree of randomness required for good mixing is difficult to achieve. However, as is shown below, simple shear can assist homogenizing of viscous liquids. It can redistribute inhomogeneities on a large scale by convective flow so that diffusion distances are decreased and in doing so individual inhomogeneities can be dispersed, stretched and made thinner. Three cases need to be examined. The Deformation of Homogeneous Inclusions A homogeneous inclusion is one which is assumed to have the same viscosity as its surroundings although differing in other properties. Its deformation is thus a relatively simple exercise in analysis of flow patterns. The most useful model to consider is steady laminar flow with a constant velocity along a straight flow path but a velocity gradient at right angles, such as will occur in flow along a rectangular open channel. The inhomogeneities that concern us are generally much thinner than the overall body of fluid and it is reasonable to assume that the local velocity distribution is represented by a straight line although, in many cases, this will be part of a parabola. Consider a rectangular element of length / lying at an angle a0 to the direction of flow. Its two ends will be moving at different velocities so that it is stretched out and rotated, see Fig. 1-23. This model has been evaluated by several authors including Mohr (1960), McKelvey (1962) and Cooper (1966a,b).
56
1 Classical Glass Technology h cot a.
Ght
Figure 1-23. The geometry of deformation by simple shear of a layer initially lying at an angle <x0 to the velocity vector U.
The most important facts are that the layers are rotated to become almost parallel to the direction of flow but that the rate of stretching approaches zero as this occurs. For the two dimensional case where the velocity vector U lies along the x axis and dU/dx = 0 but dU/dy = G and the liquid is assumed incompressible, this leads to
large amounts of shear may be required merely to make these the same thickness as they were to start with. However much shear is applied there will always be a narrow range of angles for which matters will be made worse but sufficient shear means that these will occur infrequently. Of course, with almost perfect laminar flow, acceleration of the flow will attenuate inhomogeneities in an easily predictable way. The simplest way of achieving this is to make the melt flow through a reduced cross section, such as the throat of a furnace or the orifice of a gob feeder, when all the constituent parts of stream will be reduced in the same proportions as the cross section of the whole flow. However, if the stream expands again, as on exit from the throat, little may have been achieved. Unfortunately this is not likely to assist diffusive mixing very much because of the short
(1-60) b _ 1 Yo ~ [1 + G t sin 2 a 0 + G2t2 sin2 a o ] 1 / 2 Note that only the product Gt, the total shear, appears and neither of these variables is itself important. Some of the predictions of this equation are shown in Fig. 1-24. The decrease in thickness with amount of shear is roughly a double exponential of G t for favorably oriented layers and a factor of ten reduction in thickness is easily achieved but a factor of a hundred is hardly possible. If attenuation by a factor of more than about twenty is required, it is necessary to change the flow pattern and the orientation of the layers relative to the velocity vector. Note particularly that some layers in a randomly oriented array will be compressed rather than attenuated;
0.01 0
20
40
Total shear, Gt
Figure 1-24. Predicted changes in layers of initial thickness b0 by simple shear for a range of initial orientations according to Eq. (1-60) which ignores differences in viscosity.
57
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
Deformation of Inhomogeneous Inclusions Here this term means inclusions which differ in viscosity from their surrounding matrix. Most inclusions in glass will fall into this category. A rigid inclusion would not deform at all although it would rotate, so intuition rightly suggests that a more viscous inclusion should deform less than one of low viscosity subject to the same stresses. This problem can be elegantly treated by a method devised by Eshelby (1957, 1959) to deal with elastic inclusions which he kindly demonstrated to the author in 1968. By this method a simple relation can be deduced to describe the difference in deformation of a homogeneous two dimensional inclusion and an inhomogeneous one when both have been subjected to the same (but unspecified) amount of shear. Since deformation may be large it is defined in terms of the natural strain 5 f
d a
1
a = In s= J—
(1-61)
flo
The other parameter introduced is the relation between the two viscosities defined by * = (*1i-*iM)/tiM
(1-62)
where the subscripts refer to the inclusion (i) and the matrix (M). The relation between the deformation of the inclusions in the two cases is given by s a +(A/2) tanhs a = :
(1-63)
where sa is the elongation of the longer axis of, for example, the cross section of a long cylinder being deformed at right angles to its major axis, and saH is the deformation in the homogeneous case (k = 0). For the two
dimensional case and an incompressible liquid, the minor axis of the inclusion must decrease by the same factor as the major axis increases. Figure 1-25 shows how viscosity affects deformation according to this model; it can be seen that an inclusion of lower viscosity deforms rather more than a homogeneous one but increasing viscosity soon causes a considerable decrease in the deformation. This analysis is best used in two steps; the model in the previous section is used to obtain an explicit relation between shear and deformation for the homogeneous case and Eq. (1-63) used to determine the difference in deformation between the homogeneous and inhomogeneous cases. One important inference to be drawn from this is that any furnace will be unable to deal with inclusions significantly more viscous than those that usually occur; feasible changes in furnace operating conditions are likely to have very little effect: only removing the source of the viscous inclusions will cure the problem, Three dimensional inclusions were studied by Bilby et al. (1975) and Howard and Brierley (1976); the general features of these are very similar to Eshelby's original analysis. 1
fB '
J
I -J
I
I
^° w
8
£ o
x
\ \ \
0.1
1
1
-
X
\2 0
0.01 -
6
\
^
\
wNX
S\
\
\
\
0.002
1
1
i
0.1
l
l
'
20
\
X
CD O>
|
1
•
- — — .
in th
residence time in the narrow part of the system. The combined effects of shear and reduction in cross section were discussed by Rhiel (1976).
1
1
10" 2
\k
\
\ \ \
I 10" 3
i ^X
i
10~ 4
b/bQ for homogeneous case
Figure 1-25. Results of Eshelby's analysis of the difference in deformation of homogeneous and inhomogeneous (in the sense of viscosity) elliptical inclusions subject to simple shear; values on the diagram are viscosity ratios, see text.
58
1 Classical Glass Technology
Deformation Limited by Surface Tension Both of the above models assume that inclusions are, in principle, infinitely deformable and that only the total shear G t affects the result. This is not true when an interfacial tension exists, as is the case with gas bubbles. Here there is a discontinuity in pressure and normal stress at the interface because of the additional pressure which is given by Ap =
(1-64)
where a is the surface or interfacial tension and a and b are the principal radii of the curved surface. When this term is not trivial, because of the magnitude of a or the small values of the radii, a sphere reaches an equilibrium shape which depends on the rate of shear and this equilibrium shape may be more important than the rate at which it is approached. The classic analysis, limited to small deformations, was undertaken by Taylor (1934) and led to a-b = E1 a+b
=
16i?r
(1-65)
defined as cpa = n/4 + 0, the value of 9 is given by tan 2 6 = 19Griia0/{20&)
(1-67)
This shows that the equilibrium rotation increases with both rate of shear and viscosity of the inclusion. The shape is defined in terms of deviations from spherical shape as a/a o = l + ea and
b/ao = l— eb
(1-68)
which is related to the equilibrium values by
(1-69) £
E2 = ( e a " b)/(2 + sa + fib) «(e a - e b )/2 The equilibrium elongation of the longer axis (a) is given by E2 = E1cos2 6
(1-70)
Figure 1-26 shows some predictions based on Cox's theory which confirm that a high viscosity ratio, which makes the equilibrium angle soon approach 90° as rate of shear increases, is associated a very limited degree of deformation. A gas bubble thus is the most sensitive indicator of the stress around it as the glass melt solidified. Cox's
Since the second term can have values lying only between 1 and 1.1875, Taylor considered that the approximation = GrjMa0/a
(1-66)
would usually be satisfactory. A number of other authors re-examined this question within the last twenty years and some published results are incorrect. An analysis which gave the rate of deformation as well as the equilibrium shape was published by Cox (1969). Although limited to small deformations this analysis, involving spherical harmonics, is valid for any value of viscosity ratio. If the equilibrium angle relative to the shear vector is
Rate of shear parameter, E
Figure 1-26. The dependence of equilibrium shape on shear rate for elliptical inclusions where deformation is limited by interfacial energy according to Cox's model. The ratio of the major axes is plotted against rate of shear expressed by E1 (Eq. (1-65)). The values on the curves are viscosity ratios (inclusion/matrix).
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
theory shows the time dependence of shape to be approximately a sine wave superimposed on an exponential. Study of the shapes and orientations of bubbles in glass is capable of yielding information about the stress fields existing in the glass as it became effectively solid somewhat above annealing temperature. However, one of the most obvious types of such bubbles, namely the very long thin bubbles sometimes found in drawn sheet or rod and tube confirm their orientation to be essentially parallel to the main stress vector but their shapes are not elliptical, the tips being too pointed. However, this section is not in the plane of maximum shear. An exact analysis of this case remains to be undertaken.
1.3.4.5 Modern Furnaces
Glass making has evolved over a long period, the most significant advances being within the last century. Most glass is made in tank furnaces which appear from the outside to be merely large rectangular chambers. In fact they must be very sophisticated devices to meet the different needs of melting, refining, and homogenizing. Melting rates and requirements for refining and homogeneity vary considerably with the product and this leads to many apparently small differences in design and construction which nevertheless have important effects on performance. The design of a particular furnace can often be considered in two separate parts, the tank full of molten glass and the combustion space, with the only essential link between the two being the exchange of heat. The overall size of the melting end of the tank depends on the glass quality needed, the properties of the glass and the required output. Since the energy is transmitted through the free
59
surface of the melt it is usual to estimate the surface area of the tank in terms of daily output per unit surface area, which implicitly recognizes the energy input per unit area from the combustion space. Values in the range 1.3 to 2.2 t m~ 2 d" 1 are common. The ratio of length to breadth (L/B) depends on several factors, two of the most important are 1) a length sufficient to establish the desired longitudinal temperature profile and thus the required internal circulation of the melt and 2) the width must be large enough to allow efficient combustion of the fuel (in a crossfired tank) but not so great as to threaten the stability of the crown which is a free standing arch. As a result small furnaces (about 20 m2) often have L/B about 1.2 but larger furnaces have greater values of L/B, say 2.3 for a 90 m 2 furnace. The depth of the melt should be such as to prevent the melt at the bottom becoming to cool and thus too viscous to flow easily, allow the required internal circulation but also avoid the bottom refractories becoming too hot and thus easily corroded. The depth must thus take account of the transparency of the melt to infrared radiation. Depths from about 0.75 to 1.3 m are common but rarely exceed 1.0 m for strongly infrared absorbing glasses. Most tanks have a throat, a central passage at the bottom of the chamber, between melting end and working end. This helps to prevent unmelted batch or only partially melted glass being carried into the working end and also allows the melt to cool before entering the forehearths which supply the forming machines. Because of the cooling of the melt as it passes through the throat there is a tendency for a return flow of denser glass to develop from working end to melting end. Sunken throat designs which control this are often used. The tank may also in-
60
1 Classical Glass Technology
elude weirs or bubblers or supplementary electrodes to control the flow of the melt and, in the last case, also to increase energy input and melting rate. The combustion space must match the length and width of the melting area but its dimensions must allow the insertion of ports for fuel (if gas is used) and combustion air of a size and number sufficient to supply the necessary energy and establish the desired temperature distribution. Because there is a minimum effective flame length for any particular type of fuel and burner system small tanks often have a horseshoe or U-shaped flame, the entry and exit ports both being in the end wall of the furnace where the batch is normally charged. Such furnaces must have a dog house to charge the batch at the side. These factors are discussed by Trier (1984). Figure 1-27 shows a schematic diagram of a modern container glass tank and Fig. 1-28 a flat glass furnace. The main differences are in size and the absence of a bridge wall and throat in the flat glass furnace in which it is necessary to develop a better internal circulation. Energy distribution and hence temperatures inside the tank are carefully controlled ro retain partly melted batch near the dog house and to control the internal circulation of the melt, which is complex. The energy distribution is most easily controlled with cross fired tanks having several pairs of ports along the side walls. The internal circulation plays a very important part in mixing and homogenizing the glass. Since perfect homogeneity is rarely attainable, considerable effort goes into stretching out inhomogeneities and aligning them parallel to the direction of flow. Some of the important differences between furnaces for container glass and flat glass are due to the higher standard needed in this respect to minimize optical distortion in flat glass.
Figure 1-27. Layout of a typical gas fired modern tank furnace for container glass. Partially sectioned plan view and vertical section across the melting chamber, a) melting end, b) working end, c) throat, d) forehearths, e) combustion space, f) port neck, g) air regenerator, h) gas regenerator, i) crown.
The electrical resistivity of glass is sufficiently low at high temperatures to pass an electric current and heat the glass by the Joule effect. Heating by electricity avoids having to deal with very large volumes of combustion gases and their possible problems of controlling furnace emissions; it needs no regenerators or recuperators, although batch gases are still produced. It also uses the energy input much more efficiently inside the furnace but this does not necessarily make electric melting cheaper. Many electric furnaces are very similar in general appearance to combustion fired ones because the requirements for melting,
61
1.3 The Melting of Glasses
frvi
fT^l
ts^
IXN K ^ l ^ l k ^
^r^ i
IN.XWSN^XXX-'
Kkuuvvvvuv^^vv.uT
QDDDDDD
_Q O Q O
Q Q Q Q c
fl
c
—
,
d
e 0 1
1
10
20 m
1
Figure 1-28. Layout of a modern gas fired Float glass furnace showing sections just above the surface of the melt, vertical section along the center line and transverse section of the melting chamber, a) melting end, b) doghouse, c) working end or conditioning chamber, d) Float bath, e) regenerators, f) combustion space, g) port.
refining and homogenizing remain the same. The electrodes immersed in the glass are usually of molybdenum but graphite was used by some of the pioneers such as Borel (1958). Electric furnaces are discussed at length by Stanek (1977) and by Trier (1984). Electric furnaces are especially useful for small scale melting and for the melting of glasses which contain volatile constituents such as fluorides. One ingenious furnace of this type is that due to Gell (1956) which uses the very poor thermal conductivity of the batch cover to render a crown unnecessary in normal operation, see Fig. 1-29. This can also trap and recycle condensible volatiles evolved where the melting reactions take place. The complex internal flow of the melt means that the residence time distribution of glass inside the furnace is quite broad.
Figure 1-29. Layout of a small 'cold top' electric glass melting furnace using molybdenum plate electrodes set along the side walls. The insulation provided by the batch cover makes a crown unnecessary whilst operating normally.
62
1 Classical Glass Technology
This can be investigated experimentally when changing from one glass composition to another, or by introducing a new constituent as a tracer into the batch, and monitoring its concentration in the output. Such measurements show that some of the new glass usually appears six to eight hours after the batch was charged, the maximum concentration often occurs after 20 to 30 hours but a few percent of the glass is still inside the furnace after 150 to 200 hours. Understanding this behavior is very important in furnaces where the color or composition of the glass must be changed from time to time. Furnace design and operation probably owe more to accumulated experience than scientifically based analysis but some firms do now spend large amounts on the study of models, especially for flow patterns in the melt. The highest standards of homogeneity are required of optical glasses which, for about the last forty years, have been melted in small special tank furnaces which are partly lined with platinum and use mechanical stirring to achieve the attenuation of inhomogeneities necessary to satisfy quality standards. Given these conditions, making optical glass does not require long times and the average residence time for optical glass may be no more than about ten hours. Good homogeneity is much more difficult to attain in pots than in tanks because of the differences in flow within the melt. Mechanical stirring must be used in pots and crucibles if high standards are to be achieved. The author and his students have studied methods of measuring homogeneity (Cable and Bower, 1965; Cable and Walters, 1980; Afghan and Cable, 1983; Aylward et al., 1986) and made detailed studies intended to devise simple stirrers suitable for laboratory melts, see for example Cable and Hakim (1973). Very detailed
model studies were made by Sadeghi (1980) and these led to a very effective simple stirrer the performance of which in glass melts has recently been investigated by Joanni (1989); Joanni et al. (1989). These can make optical quality glass of many compositions on a very small scale, something that used to be considered impossible. Stirrers are sometimes used in full size furnaces but represent a rather different challenge because of the differences in geometry and throughput flow as well as the very high cost of making and installing them. Simple stirrers are quite often used in forehearths where they may do more for thermal than for chemical homogeneity.
1.4 Glass Forming 1.4.1 Introduction
Glass forming involves simultaneous fluid flow and heat transfer. Flow normally depends on the newtonian behavior of glass melts, which means that velocity may be assumed exactly proportional to the stress applied. However, the rapid change of temperature, and hence viscosity, as the glass cools during forming as well as often the complex geometry makes mathematical analysis of most glass forming operations a difficult task. The need to deal with both flow and heat transfer makes resort to numerical methods necessary for most problems of interest. The equations to be solved are usually easy to set up but problems often arise in setting realistic boundary conditions, especially for heat transfer, and in determining the effective thermal conductivity. In general flow occurs under quite low stressses and glass making machinery rarely needs to be massively built. In most cases the removal of heat from the glass is
1.4 Glass Forming
the slower and controlling process. The initial viscosity of the glass must be high enough to prevent excessive flow under gravity but not so great that high stresses are needed to complete the shaping as the glass cools. In the interests of efficiency the glass must then be cooled to become essentially solid as soon as possible after reaching the required shape. Table 1-7 gives some typical values of the viscosities at which various processes occur but some of these are rather crude estimates because so many operations do not take place in isothermal conditions. Two important features of industrial glass forming operations are that 1) it is normal to complete the whole process from raw materials to the finished product in one continuous cycle of operations and 2) mechanized glass forming operations are suited only to the production of large numbers of articles. The first of these arises partly from the brittle nature, poor thermal shock resistance of large pieces and other typical properties of glasses, partly from the fact that cooling and then reheating is a very inefficient use of energy. Very few large scale operators buy previously melted glass and then re-process it; it is however normal to remelt rejects produced during manufacture and many large scale producers also buy cullet (waste glass) to add to their batches. The second arises from the delicate non-equilibrium conditions under which molds, for example, must function for efficient processing. Molds can be preheated before fitting to a machine but cannot be brought beforehand to the actual non-isothermal conditions in which they operate efficiently. Forming processes can be classified in several different ways. Two of the more important aspects are: 1) whether a continuous stream of glass is used (flat glass, tube, fibers) or separate gobs formed (containers,
63
Table 1-7. Approximate viscosity values for glass forming operations in dPa s. Operation
logfa/dPas)
Melting 1.5 to 2.5 Seal glass to glass 3.5 Seal glass to metal 3.8 Forming gobs for containers 3.6 to 4.2 Drawing Fourcault sheet 4.0 to 4.4 Pressing 4.0 to 6.3 Surface of parison during forming 4.0 to 8.0 Glass at tip of Danner mandrel 5.5 Surface of bottle during blowing 5.7 to 10.0 Sinter glass powder to solid body 6.0 Littleton softening point 7.65 Sinter glass powder to porous body 8.0 to 8.8 Thick tube collapse under vacuum 11.0 Deform under gravity 11.3 Dilatometric softening point Mg 11.3 to 11.7 Lehr belt marks base of container 11.7 Annealing 12.0 to 14.0 Stress release occurs in a few seconds 12.8 Temperature for matching glass and metal expansion curves for seals 14.0 to 14.5 Stress release too slow to be useful 14.6
television screens) and 2) whether or not molds are used to shape the glass. Some processes, like container manufacture, require that the temperatures in one place, such as a particular point on a mold, keep repeating a certain time-temperature cycle whilst others, such as drawing tube or forming flat glass, require the temperature at a particular point to be as constant as possible but temperatures vary rapidly with position. In both instances the glass itself changes temperature rapidly as it flows during forming and the optimum conditions can only be established whilst the process is operating. Different types of process have different preferred viscositytemperature relations. Even with today's sophisticated controls it can take several hours to optimize operating conditions after making a change, such as fitting a new set of molds; frequent changes in operat-
64
1 Classical Glass Technology
ing conditions are thus very undesirable. Glass manufacturers usually expect to make very large numbers of individual articles between changes in operating conditions. Making quantities that represent only a few hours production (which could still mean more than 50000 containers) is inefficient and expensive because of the production lost during stoppages and the rejects produced whilst achieving optimum conditions. 1.4.2 The Manufacture of Containers
Forming by blowing in a split mold using compressed air permits complex shapes to be made and this has long been the preferred method for making most containers. The manufacture of containers by a skilled workman manipulating a gather on a blow pipe was practised for nearly two thousand years and required a complex series of operations to form a parison by rolling on a marver, using gravity to stretch or compress the length of the parison and blowing a little from time to time; the parison was then put into the blow mold and blown to the final shape. The pressure available when blowing by mouth is very low and too high a viscosity risks flow being very slow and possibly not complete; automatic machines use an effective pressure of only about 2 atm. Forming the mouth followed breaking the container off the blow pipe and reheating the neck; this led to the mouth being known as the finish. One of the early successes of pioneers in container production was to demonstrate that the process could be done in two steps using two body molds, a parison mold and a final blow mold. Of course the mouth now has to be formed first and held in a neck ring whilst performing the other operations but it is still called the finish. Although the whole process has many neces-
sary individual steps the essential seven are: 1) form a gob and feed it to the parison mold, 2) form the mouth or finish of the container, 3) form the parison, 4) transfer the parison to the blow mold, 5) blow the container to its final form, 6) cool in the blow mold until sufficiently rigid to keep its shape and 7) open the mold and remove the container. The container must then be annealed. The gob must be supplied in as near to an isothermal a state as is possible and at a viscosity sufficiently high to prevent too rapid flow under gravity whilst still ready to flow when blown. The viscosity for gob formation depends on the particular process and article being made but is usually around log r\ = 3.7 to 4.2 (dPa s). Later stages of the operations are less easy to characterize in terms of viscosity because the glass is being rapidly cooled and steep gradients of both temperature and viscosity exist within it; however the viscosity of the surface layers must be the most important value. As mentioned in the historical review, nearly all containers are now made on individual section (IS) machines. These are made up by coupling a row of identical sections which work independently of each other, except that feeding the gobs to each section in turn must clearly be coordinated. A machine may have only four or five sections but up to sixteen is known. All the parison molds sit along one side of the machine and all the blow molds along the other. These molds open and close as required but are otherwise stationary. The neck ring is swung vertically through 180° to transfer the parison to the blow mold. Figure 1-30 illustrates the steps in forming a bottle on an IS machine. Many of the details of construction of the IS and other machines then widely used are discussed by Giegerich and Trier (1964). Bollert et al.
1.4 Glass Forming
/! S
Figure 1-30. Schematic diagram of the blow-blow operation of the IS machine. The top row shows stages in parison forming and the bottom row blowing in the blow mold. In the center the neck ring is seen in the position occupied during parison formation. The parison is transferred to the blow mold by rotating the arm through 180° (position shown dashed). 1) gob entering mold, 2) blow down to ensure proper formation of neck, 3) blowing of parison complete, 4) parison enclosed by blow mold, 5) blowing just begun, 6) mold opened for bottle to be removed.
(1987) more recently reviewed the evolution of the IS machine and some of its most recent refinements. The majority of containers have necks which are relatively narrow compared with their bodies so it is normal to drop the gob into the inverted parison mold. Two differ-
65
ent methods of forming the parison may then be used, blow and blow or press and blow. When first developed the press and blow process was limited to wide mouthed articles like jam jars but it is now used for many narrow necked containers. If the parison is made by the blow and blow process the mold is at once covered by a blow head and compressed air applied to ensure that the mouth is properly formed; any distortion of the sealing surface will often make that container unusable. As soon as the mouth has been formed the opening is covered by a baffle plate and the parison blown to fill its mold. Failure to blow at least a small bubble as soon as possible risks the glass around the plug forming the inside of the mouth becoming too viscous to be blown at all. In the press and blow process a central metal plunger is used to form the central cavity in the parison and to ensure that the neck ring is properly filled. This process has several advantages which include being able to make the central cavity an exact shape and some simplification of the steps needed to form the parison. If the glass in the parison does not have the desired wall thickness as well as external contour, it may not give the required wall thickness distribution in the final article. Although the machine most widely used for the manufacture of containers was designed and brought into service many years ago, recent years have seen important improvements in it and in the containers produced. Reducing the weight of glass in a given type of container has several obvious advantages and such progress is steadily continuing, as demonstrated by Fig. 1-31 which shows how the weight of the standard English one pint (568 mL) milk bottle has changed over the recent past. Once formed the parison is transferred to the blow mold and blown in the same
66
1 Classical Glass Technology
600
500 -
400 O) c o
300 -
<1960
1965
1975
1985
1995
Year Figure 1-31. Changes in the weight of the standard English 568 ml milk bottle over the years. The development of the narrow mouth press and blow process has been an important factor. By courtesy of PLMRedfearn Glass.
gap between glass and mold, or the parison may be deliberately left for a period enclosed by the blow mold before beginning to blow. The mold surfaces are quite hot and simply introducing the air gap decreases heat transfer to the mold by a considerable factor. Whilst it is reheating the parison stretches under gravity and this must not be permitted to go too far. Figure 1-32 shows typical examples of temperature profiles in a parison at different stages. It is extremely difficult to study the flow of the glass during parison formation. Direct observation is impossible and it is necessary to resort to computing by finite element methods, solving for both heat transfer and fluid flow, or to use physical models. Interesting studies using model liquids were undertaken by Reinhardt (1965) and Schmid and Hertel (1968).
1000
way with both processes. On the IS machine the arm carrying the neck ring swings vertically through 180° to carry the parison to the blow mold which at once closes around it. A very important stage of foming the bottle or jar is reheating of the surface of the glass once blowing of the parison is finished. Reheat occurs when the surface of the parison is no longer in close contact with the metal mold and not having heat extracted so rapidly. The steep internal temperature gradient ensures that heat continues to flow towards the surface; as it is no longer being lost at the previous rate this heat accumulates just below the surface and the thin surface layer of the glass which has been cooled most by contact with the mold gains in temperature and becomes less viscous. To assist reheating the parison mold may be opened a fraction to make sure that there is a small air
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Fraction of wall thickness
Figure 1-32. Typical temperature distributions in the wall of a pressed parison at different stages of its formation: 1) just after beginning of pressing, 2) at the beginning of reheat, 3) at the end of reheat.
67
1.4 Glass Forming
Giegerich (1960) devised a simple scheme for comparing the main stages of the forming cycle on different machines and published some data which indicate why the IS machine has become so favored. The actual construction and operation of the Emhart IS, or any other machine, has innumerable complexities but it is possible to give a simple outline of the main features of the process by Giegerich's method. Figure 1-33 shows Giegerich's method of analysis. A gob is dropped into the inverted parison mold at t = 0. All the operations necessary to form the mouth and blow the parison are included in the parison forming time £P, then the mold is slightly opened to assist reheating for a time tR which includes the time needed to transfer the parison to the blow mold and close that mold. A time tB is needed for blowing in the blow mold, followed by a cooling time tc before the mold is opened and the container removed. The time between the delivery of successive gobs to the same mold is tG and the total time needed to make one article is tT. If the process were operating as efficiently as possible the idle time tY between removing one parison from the parison mold and supplying the next gob would be negligible and the total time would be divided equally between parison and blow molds. The idle or wasted time in each cycle may therefore be defined as tY=tG~\l2tT
(1-71)
Although part of the time tG—(tP-\-tR) *S needed to cool the parison mold it may be considered wasted; so may most of the cooling time tc for the blow mold as well as the time that it is actually empty. When times are measured in seconds, the actual productivity in bottles per minute is, B = 60/t G
(1-72)
Gob 1
Bottle 2
Figure 1-33. Schematic diagram of Giegerich's method of analysing container machine operations, see text.
whilst the ideal productivity would be B max =120/t T
(1-73)
Giegerich showed that tP increased more or less linearly with gob weight and the data for most machines fell very close to the same line. When total time (tT) was plotted against parison forming time (tP) all machines again showed similar behavior. However, the IS machine showed shorter reheat times (tR) than any other gob fed machine, although the suction fed Owens machine was slightly better from this point of view. However, when the various productivity figures were compared, the IS machine clearly outperformed most others and achieved about 80% of the maximum possible value whilst some other machines commonly used up to about 20 years ago worked at little more than half the maximum value. One of the most important aspects of container manufacture is the heat transfer between glass and metal mold. Perfect contact between the two would assist rapid heat transfer but implies that the glass adheres to the mold which would be disastrous. However, the perfect contact model
68
1 Classical Glass Technology
is the one to start with. If two relatively thick isothermal slabs of the same material at temperatures TA and TB were brought into perfect contact the interface temperature would be T{ = (TA + TB)/2. If the slabs have different thermal properties the dimensionless interface temperature T* should be given by £BCB)] 1 / 2
(1-74)
Although not given a particular name in English, the parameter XQC is called the Temperaturleitzahl in German. When typical values for the properties of glass (A) and cast iron (B) are taken and TA assumed to be 1100°C and TB 550 °C, the calculated value of T{ is found to be about 585 °C. It is important that this should not exceed the sticking temperature of the glass to the mold material which is often about 600620 °C; such intimate contact would be good for heat transfer but prevent removal of the glass from the mold or, at least, badly damage the surface of the glass. The fact that the glass contracts as it cools whilst the metal expands on heating helps to prevent sticking. However it is found on analysing glass-mold heat transfer that the heat transfer coefficient at the interface is strongly time dependent. This considerably complicates attempts to calculate temperatures and viscosities within the glass during forming. Figure 1-34 shows some data for the variation of glass to mold heat transfer during pressing reported by McGraw (1961). The mold surface of course cannot be absolutely smooth and clean, indeed it is usual practice to apply mold dopes to the inner surfaces of the mold to aid release of the glass and improve surface finish; these may contain graphite and oils which carbonize. Trier (1955) reported some interesting results of varying parison mold contact
1 0.4
0.8
Contact time in s
Figure 1-34. Variation glass-mold heat transfer coefficient during a pressing operation according to measurements by McGraw (1961).
times and total cycle times on a semi-automatic machine without changing any other parameters. These show that a proper balance must be maintained between heat removed from the glass and heat removed from the mold, see Fig. 1-35. Too short a total cycle time makes the mold overheat so that the glass sticks and too long a cycle time makes the mold too cool so that the glass is chilled and will not flow properly. Too short a time in the parison mold leaves the glass too fluid allowing it to distort too much under gravity but too long a parison forming time leaves it too viscous to be blown in the blow mold. Current cycle times on an IS machine would be considerably shorter than those seen here. The design of molds to ensure the desired rates of heat extraction from different parts and thus the temperature distribution over the inner surface is a complex matter. One of the most obvious features is that a considerable proportion of the heat transferred from the glass is lost again from the inner surface of the mold by forced convection cooling whilst the mold is open and empty. The inner surface temperature
1.4 Glass Forming 16
I
I
I
12 -
r
CD
o eg c o o
i
Sticks to mold _
I
450°C
-•
~-~ — —
/ * 6 1 (re
,
/ /•600°C
/ /
/
/•450
j /
1.4.3 The Production of Lamp Bulb Envelopes
I
Parison too viscous
610°C / 435°C y ^j
4 -
^avy surface
Parison too fluid
I
1
i
16
i
1
24
69
i
32
Total cycle time in s
Figure 1-35. The effects of varying parison mold glass contact time and total cycle time on parison formation on a semi-automatic machine. Some mold surface temperature readings are also shown. After Trier (1955).
typically varies by about 80 °C during the whole cycle of operations. Drilling cooling passages in the wall of the mold, parallel to the long axis of the container, is one of the ways in which the efficiency of the IS machine has been improved in recent years. The only easy measurement of the heat extracted from the glass during forming is to drop into a calorimeter 1) a gob, 2) a parison at transfer and 3) a just completed bottle. If good specific heat data are available these results can give the average temperatures of the whole article at each stage. Data of Giegerich indicate that the heat loss during forming of a container on an IS machine was equivalent to a fall in average temperature of about 320 to 400 °C with the loss during parison formation being rather greater than during blowing, which points out the necessity of reheating before blowing the parison.
The manufacture of bulbs for incandescent electric lamps is a very important branch of the glass industry. These differ from most other kinds of hollow ware in having much thinner walls, usually somewhat less than 1 mm. These are made by a rather different process which also uses a special machine. Thin walled articles of this kind, including some drinking glasses are made using paste molds. A paste mold is one which does much less damage to the surface of the glass during manufacture. This is achieved by using a mold with a relatively soft and porous lining which is used saturated with water so that the glass vaporizes the water when it is introduced into the mold and the glass is prevented from coming into close contact with the mold by a cushion of steam. This method is restricted to thin walled articles because of the limit on the heat that can be used in evaporating the water. The molds are usually relatively thin iron shells which are lined with a carbon layer produced by applying a layer of cork granules mixed with additives which is carbonized before use. The molds have a short life and the ware is normally rotated in the mold throughout blowing, partly to obtain as uniform and circular a section as possible also to avoid mold seams. Such bulbs are made at very high rates of production on the Corning ribbon machine the main features of which are shown in Fig. 1-36; the most notable features are the mounting of the blow heads and blow molds on two separate bands like caterpillar tracks, one above the other, whilst the continuous ribbon of glass carrying the bulbs advances between them.
70
1 Classical Glass Technology
n u n n n n n n( J n
(n n n n 1
M
TOO Figure 1-36. Schematic diagram of the Corning ribbon machine for making lamp bulbs. A stream of glass (a) passes between two rollers (b) which shape it slightly; it then falls onto a band of metal plates (c) each with a central hole through which the glass sags under gravity to begin parison formation. Blow heads (d) mounted on the upper belt press against the upper surface of the glass ribbon and begin to blow at (e). The paste molds (f) mounted on the lower belt close around the parison at (g) and the bulb then blown in the rotating mold. At (h) the blow heads are lifted away and the blow molds open leaving the bulbs suspended from the ribbon from which they are cracked off and collected at (i). The ribbon is then crushed and returned to be used as cullet.
1.4.4 The Manufacture of Flat Glass 1.4.4.1 Introduction
The requirements of buildings and vehicles make flat glass production one of the largest sections of the industry. As mentioned in the introduction, the crucial advances in flat glass manufacture occurred during the present century: the first successful processes for continuous drawing of sheet coming into production between about 1916 and 1930, to be followed by the development of the Float process in the fifties and sixties. Cast plate glass, made by grinding and polishing thick cast plate, was invented around AD 1680 but its large scale manufacture was greatly improved largely by Pilkington Brothers between 1920 and 1940; however, it has now been entirely replaced by Float glass. Although they are also now obsolescent it is worth
briefly outlining the important sheet drawing processes which are still in use. Whether drawn upwards or downwards a stream of any liquid, even one of high viscosity, is inherently unstable. Any attempt to draw a thin sheet of viscous liquid, for example using a knife blade dipped into a pool, shows that it at once necks and tends towards a circular section. Even a circular jet will break up unless rapidly cooled and made effectively solid. The break up of a circular jet is a classic and complex problem of hydrodynamics but some useful analytical approximations exist. By taking the simplest useful approximations for the equations governing the behavior of a circular jet Levich (1962) estimated the time to break up (TB) for either a low viscosity jet or a viscous jet. For a viscous jet of radius a this is approximately (1-75)
1.4 Glass Forming
which means that if its velocity is U9 the critical (break up) length is about LB= 5 Ur]a/a
(1-76)
High velocity, high viscosity and large diameter will all help to increase this length. It is clear that rapid increase in viscosity to make the glass essentially solid (rj >1012 dPa s) within say a quarter of the initial isothermal break up length will achieve reasonable stability of the process. Such an analysis done beforehand would have encouraged a pioneer of flat glass manufacture to proceed but emphasizes that very rapid cooling is necessary, something not favored, from the heat transfer point of view, by a large thickness. Because of its shape, forming and preserving the desired width and thickness of a sheet is a bigger problem than controlling a circular jet. Mathematical modelling of the drawing of a sheet from a pool at first looks relatively simple because it can be treated as a two dimensional problem symmetrical about the center line of the sheet. As the glass is so much more viscous than the air it can be assumed that shear stress and so velocity gradient go to zero at the surfaces. However, the positions of the surfaces where these boundary conditions apply are not known; indeed finding them is the main purpose of the exercise. The foot of the sheet could, for example, be assumed to be of hyperbolic or exponential form but, in practice, it may bulge into what is called the onion just above the surface of the melt. This therefore is a difficult problem to solve properly even if the conditions are assumed isothermal. When the heat transfer and rapid change of viscosity with position, which are essential features of the real process, are introduced the difficulties are considerably multiplied. The need for rapid cooling, in conditions where the effective conductivity is very lit-
71
tle greater than the true conductivity of the glass (largely because the sheet is usually of small optical thickness), is one of the main factors limiting the maximum thickness of glass that can be produced. Thin sheet must be drawn off at a higher speed and thus subject to greater stresses so that the danger of the sheet breaking is one of the limitations on minimum thickness. However, the critical factors controlling complex industrial processes are not always the most obvious ones. The most comprehensive description and discussion of sheet glass manufacturing processes is the book by Goerk (1966); a useful review is given by Hynd (1984). 1.4.4.2 Sheet Glass Processes The Fourcault Process Fourcault (1862-1919), the first inventor to make his process work, overcame the major difficulties by inventing the debiteuse (a word not translated into English) which is a kind of refractory clay boat which floats in the glass. It has in its base a slot of approximately elliptical shape, through which the glass will flow up. This rate of flow may be increased by pushing the debiteuse down into melt. If this stream is gripped and pulled up at the same volume rate of flow, without it being able to wet and fill the inside of the debiteuse, a sheet can be formed. Rectangular water cooled iron boxes extending across the whole width of the drawing chamber are placed very near to the surfaces of the sheet and not far above the top of the debiteuse to cool the glass sufficiently quickly to control its tendencies to neck down and try to form a circular jet or become unstable. The outer edges will cool more quickly than the rest so that the still deformable sheet is held between two almost rigid side strips from very close to the top of the debiteuse.
72
1 Classical Glass Technology
As soon as the surfaces of the sheet are sufficiently cool it is gripped very lightly by the first of a series of pairs of rollers (at least 12), which used to be covered with asbestos, and is drawn vertically upwards. The height of the first pair of rollers above the surface of the melt must have an important influence on the stability of the process. The minimum height of these depends on the rate of cooling and the upward velocity of the sheet. The main disadvantage of the Fourcault process is that the slot in the clay debiteuse is subject to forced convection corrosion and eventually threads of corrosion product, which obviously lie on the surfaces of the sheet, are drawn up and impair the optical quality. Because of the large difference in refractive index between glass and air, small surface imperfections cause the maximum optical distortion and the parallel lines that result are called piano or music lines. As a result the debiteuse must be changed at rather frequent intervals, often around 60 days. Not surprisingly, the waviness of the surfaces is usually least near the center and wide strips from the edges are sometimes cut off and discarded when the best quality sheet is required. Accurate control of temperatures is vital in such a process and this means that control of the convection of the air in the drawing chamber and in the vertical drawing tower is important. The rate of cooling in the middle part of the tower must be controlled carefully to achieve a reasonable degree of annealing before the glass is cut into sheets at the top of the tower. Figure 1-37 shows the essential components of the Fourcault system. The glass sheet may be up to 3 m wide but around 1.8 or 2.3 m is more common. The range of thicknesses (or substance) that can be produced is surprisingly large, from about 0.6 to 14 mm, but the whole of the
>5
El Figure 1-37. The essential components of the Fourcault sheet drawing process. The upper diagram shows a vertical section through the middle of the drawing chamber, the lower one a plan view and sections of the debiteuse (slightly larger scale). 1) Debiteuse, 2) water cooling box, 3) push rod holding debiteuse, 4) control for adjusting immersion of debiteuse, 5) drawing rollers.
potential range is not usually exploited and a range from about 0.7 to 6 mm is more typical. To exploit the whole range of thicknesses requires that the width of the slot in the debiteuse be varied. Drawing speeds can vary from around 3.5 m min" 1 for thin glass to 0.2 m m m " 1 for thick glass; surface distortion is difficult to avoid with sheet near to the maximum thickness. The height of the drawing tower rarely exceeds 6 m and this can mean that thick glass is not well annealed. The main controls over thickness being produced in a given installation are 1) the temperature of the drawing chamber, 2) the speed of drawing, 3) the depth of immersion of the debiteuse and 4) the positions of the water cooling boxes.
1.4 Glass Forming
73
The Pittsburgh Process The main difference in the Pittsburgh or Pennvernon process is that the debiteuse is replaced by a draw bar which is totally immersed in the melt so that the corrosion products eventually formed and drawn off lie buried near the centre of the sheet and do not cause the obvious defects seen on the surfaces of Fourcault glass. The immersed draw bar has its upper surface 60 to 80 mm below the surface of the glass and helps to stabilize the foot of the sheet. The shape has many variants; it sometimes has a central slot in it through which chilled glass from the just below the point of drawing can sink, mix with the rest, and be reheated. Two different ways of quickly cooling the edges have been used. The original method is to have edge cooling cups or forks about 250 mm in diameter and 100 mm deep, each with a radial slot from edge to center, so that the cup encircles and quickly chills the edge of the sheet very close to the surface of the bath, thereby making two almost rigid side strips. The other is to use air cooled edge rolls, ribbed or knurled, which actually grip the sheet immediately above the surface of the bath to form the two almost solid side strips, which are driven upwards at a controlled rate from this position. This method was originally part of the Colburn process and provides the closest control of the edges of the sheet during drawing. Figure 1-38 shows a typical Pittsburgh drawing chamber. Note that the actual drawing position is more or less isolated from the rest of the furnace chamber by the L-blocks. The Pittsburgh process is otherwise very similar to the Fourcault. Although capable of giving better surface quality than the Fourcault process the Pittsburgh process is not quite so versatile in range of thickness and requires more
Figure 1-38. Sketch of a Pittsburgh sheet drawing chamber showing 1) the skimmer block, 2) the immersed draw bar, 3) the edge rolls, 4) one of the water coolers, 5) one L-block, 6) the lowest pair of drawing rolls) and 7) the sheet of glass.
accurate control of temperatures and glass level. The maximum width of the sheet (including the edge strips) is about 3.05 m but 2.1 to 2.75 m is the common range. The thickness of the sheet made by this process is usually in the range 2.0 to 9.5 mm. Production of thinner glass is difficult partly because drawing speeds are generally rather higher than for the Fourcault process. The largest single sheets produced on the cutting floor are 3.0 m long (for 6 mm thickness) but a common size supplied to customers is 1840 x 1220 mm. The Libbey-Owens-Ford Process The vertical drawing of sheet is rather inconvenient from an engineering point of view. The height of the tower should be determined by rates of cooling need for annealing but given the need to handle all the glass at a considerable height above ground level, is obviously fixed and partly determined by engineering factors. Colburn, inventor of this process, who first made it succeed and founded the LibbeyOwens company in 1916, avoided this
74
1 Classical Glass Technology
problem by bending the sheet horizontally over a polished air cooled metal roller just before it became too viscous for this to be done. The feasibility of doing so may have been suggested by the opening and flattening of the cylinders long practised in the hand and Lubbers processes. The roller is about 0.2 m in diameter and approximately 0.7 m above the surface of the bath. Colburn also introduced air cooled edge rolls to control the stability of the point of drawing and the width of the sheet by producing two chilled strips along the edges of the sheet. Figure 1-39 shows a schematic diagram of a Libbey-Owens-Ford drawing chamber. The total length of the horizontal chamber can be much longer than the maximum feasible height of a Fourcault or Pittsburgh drawing tower and may be as much as 60 m; this permits good annealing of even the thickest sheet. The Libbey-Owens-Ford process can make glass up to about 3.5 m wide and is capable of a wide range of thicknesses, from about 0.6 mm to 25 mm, but 2 m wide and 1.0 to 10.0 mm thick represents a more typical range of production. Drawing speeds are higher than for the other two processes, about 2.5 m min" 1 for 2 mm
Figure 1-39. The layout of the Libbey-Owens sheet drawing process. 1) the conditioning chamber of the tank, 2) auxiliary burner, 3) the edge rolls, 4) water cooling box to chill sheet, 5) the bending roll, 6) water cooler.
and 0.7 m min 1 being typical. Lemaire (1965) published some interesting studies of temperature distributions and flow patterns in a Libbey-Owens drawing chamber. Downward Drawing Processes Several methods of drawing a stream downwards have been developed in recent years and are used to make much thinner sheet than the other processes can easily produce, such as that used for microscope slides. The most obvious is analogous to the Fourcault process with a stream of glass being drawn down from a slot in a platinum bushing but the surface quality is not as good as with the Float process. However, another method which avoids irregularities that would be produced by slight imperfections in the edges of the slot has been developed by Corning Glass Works. Molten glass is fed into one end of a trough with an inclined base to give a steadily decreasing depth; the upper edges also deviate very slightly from the horizontal. A proper combination of these geometrical features can make the rate of overflow the same along the whole length of the trough. The two streams flowing down each side meet at the central ridge along the bottom of the trough and the resultant sheet is gripped just below by edge rolls and is then drawn away by other rollers lower down. The melt in the trough has a viscosity of about 4 x 104 dPa s and coolers increase this to about 3 x 105 dPa s as it leaves the ridge or root at the bottom of the trough. Hynd (1984) gave some details of this process and it is mentioned by Dumbaugh et al. (1991). 1.4.4.3 Float Glass In the past high quality flat glass for mirrors, vehicle or shop windows and such
1.4 Glass Forming
like had to be made by mechanically grinding and polishing cast plate. Large scale manufacture involved considerable engineering difficulties and made the process costly; a continuous plate glass line was about 600 m long and used about 1.7 MW of electrical energy solely for grinding the glass. The development of the Float process has rendered polished plate obsolete. The idea of floating glass on a bath of molten metal, for a variety of purposes, some misconceived, can be traced back for about a century but older inventors lacked the insight and the sophisticated engineering skills needed to develop a successful process. The physical basis of the modern Float process is beautifully simple: a broad stream of glass is allowed to spread out and come to equilibrium whilst floating on a bath of molten metal. It is then cooled until almost rigid and lifted off. Both surfaces of the glass can have almost ideally flat and smooth firepolished surfaces so that grinding and polishing are unnecessary. A fascinating review of the evolution of flat glass manufacture and the early development of the Float process has been given by Pilkington (1969) and another account is by Hynd (1984). The Physical Principles of the Process The metal must be denser than the glass, which is not a problem: the other requirements are not so easily met. On considering the range of viscosities over which the deformation of the glass can occur and be controlled, it is clear that the metal must have a melting point below 600 °C and a boiling point above 1050°C. Both the molten metal and the atmosphere above it have very low viscosities compared with the glass which will therefore spread out to come to equilibrium under a balance between hydrostatic and surface tension
forces, so long as the atmosphere and molten metal are not vigorously disturbed. The cross section of a continuous ribbon is thus similar to a two dimensional sessile drop which, if sufficiently wide, will have a broad flat central region. Figure 1-40 shows the two factors which control the thickness of the sheet. The balance of the interfacial tensions gives a net force over unit length of this section of F(a) = ag + <jgm-Gm
(1-77)
which is balanced by the forces due to the hydrostatic pressures. If the thickness of the sheet is d and its depth of immersion in the molten metal bath (d — /*), Archimedes principle requires that Qgd
= Qm(d-h)
(1-78)
If one imagines that the left part of the ribbon has been removed, as shown in the Figure, it is necessary to apply forces to keep the remaining part in equilibrium. There are two contributions to this: 1) the hydrostatic pressure in the glass which increases linearly from x = 0 to d and 2) the pressure in the molten metal which acts in the opposite direction but only from x = h to d. The net force due to these over a section of unit length is (1-79)
Figure 1-40. The forces controlling the equilibrium thickness of Float glass, see text.
76
1 Classical Glass Technology
and equating F(o) with F(p) gives i-am
=
{Qgd2l2-Qm{d-h)2l2)g (1-80)
from which (d — h) can be eliminated through Eq. (1-78). On rearrangement this yields the equilibrium thickness d, (1-81) The other basic model is to calculate the time needed for a surface irregularity to be smoothed out. This may be determined by considering the decay of a sine wave disturbance of the surface. Three different mechanisms could be involved, 1) viscous flow due to gravity, 2) viscous flow due to surface tension forces and 3) surface diffusion. These would in turn predominate on decreasing scales with gravity controlling the behavior of long waves and surface diffusion only becoming controlling when the wavelength approaches atomic scale. The gravitational driving force is just the difference in hydrostatic pressure due to the amplitude (A) of the wave,
Ap=Agg
(1-82)
Since the amplitude itself represents the driving force, an exponential decay, A=.
(1-83)
may be expected. In a very viscous liquid the constant k in Eq.(1-83) is QgX/(4nrj) for control by gravity (Lamb, 1932). The driving force for flow when surface tension governs is the excess pressure due to curvature of the surface which, for a surface curved in only one plane, is Ap = a/a if a is the radius of curvature. For a sine wave this also leads to exponential decay (Mullins, 1970) A =A0Qxp( — (na/Xrj)t)
(1-84)
Gravity thus causes rapid decay of long waves but surface tension governs short waves. The two processes have the same rate of decay when X2rit = 4n2a/Qg
(1-85)
and waves of this critical wavelength are the slowest to decay. For typical glass properties Xcrit is about 23 mm and such a wave decays to 1.5% of its initial amplitude in 100 s if the viscosity is 104 dPa s. Cassidy and Gjostein (1970) confirmed that the decay of corrugations on glass of wavelengths around 5 to 15 \xm was controlled by surface tension and that more complex profiles become simple sine waves as they decay, experiment and theory agreeing quite well. In practice it is found that about one minute is needed at about 1050 °C (viscosity 104 dPa s) to achieve optical quality flatness. Chemistry of the Float Process The molten metal must have a low vapor pressure ( < 1 0 N m ~ 2 at 1050°C) otherwise condensation towards the cool end of the Float bath may be troublesome. Chemical interaction between the molten metal and the glass must be minimal. On examining the properties of all molten metals it is found that only gallium, indium, and tin satisfy these requirements (lead has too high a vapor pressure) and that tin is best in terms of vapor pressure and availability. Tin has the highest boiling point, which is above 2500 °C, and is the metal always used. Pure tin easily reacts with the oxygen in the air to form solid oxides but reacts less with the glass. It is therefore necessary to have a reducing atmosphere in the Float bath; 97% N 2 , 3% H 2 is commonly used. Very low levels of oxygen or sulfur impurity in the tin are sufficient to cause problems due to formation of stannous oxide or
1.4 Glass Forming
sulphide. If these compounds are formed they can condense near the cool end of the bath, be reduced to metal by the atmosphere, and form specks of tin adhering to the upper surface of the ribbon; because of its higher solubility sulfur is the greater problem. The glass itself contains a significant proportion of sulfur, as sulfate added to aid melting and refining, some dissolved water and some variable valence elements, chiefly iron, capable of being oxidized or reduced to absorb or evolve oxygen. A very delicate control of these factors is therefore required. Sodium is the most reactive major constituent of the glass and is also the most mobile ion within it. It is thus likely that reactions between sodium in the glass and the tin bath will be the most significant and some aspects of this have been discussed by Miiller et al. (1989). Float Glass Technology The overall layout of the process derives from the continuous casting of plate glass. A controlled stream of glass is delivered by the melting furnace onto the molten tin bath and drawn along it to the other end where it is lifted off. The glass is fed onto the molten tin at about 1050°C, allowed to become flat, cooled until too viscous to flow easily or be damaged (about lO^dPas), then lifted off it at the other end at about 600 °C. The melting tank may be up to about 65 m long and l l m wide with the melt about 1.3 m deep and capable of producing as much as 6000 tonnes a week. Energy consumption in the melting tank is now around 5800 kJ kg" *. A smaller conditioning section approximately 9 m wide and 25 m long is attached to the end of the melting tank; in it the glass is cooled and brought to a uniform temperature suitable for forming the stream which is fed onto
77
the Float bath. The Float bath may be about 5 m wide and 35 m long and the molten tin needs to be only about 100 mm deep. On leaving the Float bath the ribbon passes through an annealing furnace. At the end of the line the curved meniscus regions are removed then the ribbon is cut into whatever size sheets are required, taking into account any defects that have been detected before cutting it. One of the major problems of Float glass development was the production of a range of thicknesses. The natural equilibrium thickness of the ribbon is about 7 mm, which is very fortunate because the largest market used to be for 1/4 in (6.3 mm) polished plate. As was soon discovered, nature tries to insist on achieving this equilibrium thickness and attempts to control thickness simply by drawing faster have a greater effect on width than on thickness. The first method of making thinner glass was to allow the ribbon to spread out to equilibrium width and cool it to a viscosity of around 10 8 dPas (700 °C) at which position the edges were gripped by edge rolls; further downstream the ribbon was reheated to around 106 dPa s (850 °C) and stretched to the required thickness, with some reduction in width, by adjusting the rate of drawing. The roof of the Float bath thus needs to be fitted with both electric heaters and cooling panels to permit the adjustment of the longitudinal temperature distribution. This method permits glass of high quality to be produced at thicknesses down to 3 mm. Subsequently other methods were developed. At high furnace loads the drag force of the tin can be used to confine stretching largely to the cooler end of the Float bath, where width and thickness are decreased in the same proportions, instead of acting only at the hot end where thickness hardly changes. Another variant uses several pairs of
78
1 Classical Glass Technology
driven toothed wheels along the length of the Float bath to prevent excessive reduction in width; these wheels, which press on the edges of only the upper surface of the ribbon, are about 300 mm in diameter and 20 mm wide and mounted on long cooled shafts. They are especially useful in producing a wide ribbon at high loads. Glass thicker than the natural equilibrium thickness is produced by using graphite guides, which are not wetted by the glass, to prevent lateral spreading. This allows glass up to about 25 mm thick to be produced. Several types of process have been developed which permit coatings to be applied to the ribbon in the cooler end of the Float bath, or soon after its emergence from the tin bath. The Electrofloat process uses an electrolytic method to produce a surface layer on the top of the ribbon inside the Float bath by ion exchange. These processes are especially useful in making glasses with controlled heat transmission characteristics. Some information about them is given by Hynd (1984). Coatings are also discussed by Kirkbride and Williams (1991). 1.4.5 Rod and Tubing
A circular jet is inherently unstable, as pointed out in discussing flat glass manufacture, but drawing a circular rod or tube has fewer problems than maintaining a flat sheet. Rod and tube are made by very similar methods and have been little analysed in the literature, nor has their technology been discussed in detail. Although upward and downward drawing processes exist, those in which the rod or tube is drawn off sideways from the end of an inclined rotating mandrel are more widely used, rotation being necessary to cancel the effect of gravity. To make tubing it is necessary to have a mandrel with a central hole and to blow
air down it at a pressure only slightly greater than atmospheric. Rod is made in the same way but without the central air flow. 1.4.5.1 The Danner Process The Danner process may be regarded as the mechanization of hand drawing with a steady stream of glass falling on to the rotating blow pipe or mandrel at about 103 dPa s and running down to form a uniform layer then being drawn away from the lower end at about 5 x 104 dPa s and carried onto a horizontal series of rollers. The refractory sleeve of the mandrel is about 800 mm long and around 200 mm diameter; it is mounted on a heat resisting steel shaft about 50 mm in diameter. The nose of the mandrel may be of heat resistant steel, especially for tubing, because it can be machined and maintained to greater dimensional accuracy than a refractory nose. The mandrel rotates at around 8 rpm and is inclined at about 15° to the horizontal so that the glass will flow towards the tip. The tube is drawn away from the nose approximately in line with the axis of the mandrel and led onto a horizontal track about 50 m long where it is supported by rollers, see Fig. 1-41. Towards the end of the track, when quite cool, the tube is lightly gripped by two caterpillar driving belts which draw it away at the desired rate. These driving belts may be slightly angled across the line of draw so that the tube is rotated in the contrary sense to the rotation of the mandrel. As a result of these twisting forces the mass of glass just beyond the tip of the mandrel may look remarkably asymmetrical. The tube is cut into lengths just beyond these driving belts. One of the few detailed descriptions of the process is due to Sibilia (1939) and an approximate theoretical model was developed by Yamauchi (1977).
1.4 Glass Forming
Figure 1-41. Schematic diagram of a Danner tube drawing machine enclosed by a gas fired muffle chamber.
Since tube drawing does not use a mold control of both viscosity and the main parameters of the process must be very precise if accuracy of tube dimensions is required. Bajorat and Weiss (1965) reported data on some of the factors affecting the dimensions of Danner tube; their most detailed data being for tube of 37 mm OD with a 0.9 mm thick wall being drawn at 25 m min ~1 with the mandrel rotating at 8.1 rpm and an air pressure of 2.9 x 10 ~ 3 atm. The measurements concerned both the magnitude and the frequency of variations in air pressure, pipe rotation and drawing speed. For example, air pressure fluctuations of up to 4% lasting for 0.2 to 0.4 s had no measurable effect on tube diameter but a variation persisting for 2 to 4 s had a clear effect. Douglas (1938) showed that the rate of expansion of a long tube under internal pressure can be calculated by analogy with the elastic strain of a solid tube. If the tube is of external radius a and wall thickness w its rate of expansion under a pressure difference ZIP is given by
da/dt = a2AP/(4wrj)
(1-86)
Bajorat and Weiss (1965) reported that a 1% change in diameter was caused by a
79
1.6% change in pressure lasting for 2 s; putting these values into the equation gives a viscosity of 4.2 x 104 dPa s, which is close to the viscosity of the glass at the tip of the mandrel and confirms the reasonableness of their findings. Variations in the rotation of the mandrel can trap bubbles where the stream of glass falls on to the mandrel and may also lead to ovality of the tube. The Philips process is very like the Danner but uses glass drawn from the inside of a heat resistant steel mandrel and may thus avoid contamination of the inside of the tube by corrosion products, which must eventually happen with the refractory mandrel of the Danner process. 1.4.5.2 Vertical Drawing Processes
The upward or downward drawing processes appear more straightforward but, like vertically drawn sheet, suffer from producing the tube or rod at a considerably higher or lower level than that at which the glass is melted, unless the tube is curved round. The Koroljov process is based on the Fourcault process with a central blowing nozzle fitted below the centre of the debiteuse and can produce tubing up to 175 mm diameter. The Schuller and Corning processes also function by drawing vertically upwards from a refractory ring immersed in a pool of glass with the tube passing through a circular cooler just above the pool from which the tube is drawn; the Schuller method uses a circular ring with holes which blow air down on to the tube but the Corning process uses a water cooler. The Velio process uses a stream of glass which flows out of the bottom of a forehearth orifice and is spread out by a cone suspended on the end of a hollow shaft through which air is blown; the formed tube is gently curved round to be drawn along a horizontal track. There is
80
1 Classical Glass Technology
also a Corning downward drawing process in which the glass flows over the inner rim of a circular channel and is pulled downwards. There is an inner concentric water cooled truncated cone through the centre of which air may be blown but this cone acts chiefly as a cooler and is not in contact with the glass at any time. The literature on tube and rod drawing is sparse; Giegerich and Trier (1964) report most of what is available. 1.4.6 Glass Fibers 1.4.6.1 Introduction
Manufacture of fibers has been an important branch of the glass industry for about sixty years but within the last decade fibers of an entirely new kind have become very important, namely those used for optical communication systems. The first fibers used for optical communication were of very pure silica but these are incompatible with most other glasses because of their very low thermal expansion, unusually high softening point and very high viscosity. Thus, apart from trying to develop glasses with even better optical properties, silica fibers were rather difficult to use in some applications and most recent research has been devoted to heavy metal halide glasses (see Chap. 8). Such fibers are made by specialized methods based on the same principles as those used for other fibers but differing in many details and are not considered here. Some of the most interesting aspects of glasses for optical fibers have recently been discussed by Parker (1989), and a full treatment will be found in Chap. 15. The more traditional kinds of fibers are widely used for low density insulation, for reinforcement of polymers, and in some kinds of textiles. Such fibers have small di-
ameters, typically from 5 to 20 jim, and a very high surface to volume ratio; as a result they need to be made from glasses of better than average chemical durability. The standard type of glass developed for this purpose is called E-glass which means a glass with specific properties rather than a specified composition; a typical composition may include a little fluoride, see Table 1-1. This glass has a liquidus temperature of about 1140°C and, because it has very little alkali to act as a flux during melting, needs melting temperatures of 1550 to 1600°C. Despite its low alkali content it is not very resistant to attack by mineral acids and C-glass was developed for the improved acid durability needed for some purposes; it has some alkali but about 10% more silica than E-glass, see Table 1-1. The two main products are continuous fibers and staple or short curled lengths. The latter are mainly used for low density insulating mat which is bonded by spraying on an organic binder. Continuous fibers may be chopped into short lengths and also used for mat but can be made into a large variety of rovings (untwisted bundles of filaments) or yarn (twisted bundles of filaments) and used in many different ways, including being woven into cloth. A high proportion of all the continuous fiber made is used as reinforcing for polymer composite materials. 1.4.6.2 The Physics of Fiber drawing
The simple criteria developed to describe the stability of a liquid jet introduced when discussing the drawing of flat glass are directly relevant here. It may be recalled that a very viscous circular jet of radius a leaving an orifice would break up in a time of about TB=5rja/a
(1-87)
1.4 Glass Forming
if a is the surface tension. A fairly typical nozzle radius for fiber drawing would be a = 0.5 mm and assuming a viscosity of about 104 dPa s, a jet of that size would break up in about 20 ms. However, the fiber is drawn away at such a speed that its radius is much decreased immediately below the orifice and its radius is so small that it cools and becomes rigid in less than the critical time, without needing special measures to achieve sufficiently rapid cooling as is essential in producing flat glass. The hydrodynamics of fiber drawing is nevertheless very interesting. In the conditions used in making glass fibers it may be assumed that the flow through the nozzle itself is governed by Poiseuille's law, that is to say the mass rate of flow M through an orifice of radius a will be nAPa4 M =Q SrjL
(1-88)
where AP is the pressure difference causing flow (the hydrostatic head) and L the length of the nozzle. Drawing the fiber more quickly reduces its final diameter without increasing the mass flow rate; it is generally better to control the flow by having a short relatively small diameter orifice rather one a longer one of greater diameter. The viscosity range used for fiber drawing is quite narrow; if less than about 500 dPa s at the orifice the jet breaks up into drops; if greater than about 1000dPas the stresses become too high and breakage is frequent. Although drawing the fiber from the nozzle might appear to be very simple it shows some unexpected features. It is possible to observe four different profiles just below the orifice in the range of conditions that might be used for fiber drawing: 1) the fiber diameter decreases steadily (approximately exponentially) with distance from
81
the rim of the orifice, 2) the jet emerges as a stream of the same diameter as the orifice, 3) the stream of glass bulges out, rather like the onion in Fourcault sheet drawing, immediately below the orifice, or 4) a thin fiber forms from a base distinctly smaller than the size of the orifice. Burgman (1970) investigated these and showed that they could be related to Reynolds number. Glicksman (1968) made calculations of the rate of cooling of a fiber then used these results to predict how fiber diameter would change with distance from the orifice and obtained good agreement between measured and predicted profiles. 1.4.6.3 The Technology of Fiber Production
Staple fibers may be produced directly by several methods. One common method uses two rows of platinum alloy nozzles in the bottom of a forehearth which has adjacent downward pointing steam jets on each side to accelerate and attenuate the filaments. Because both glass and steam have similar kinematic viscosities in these conditions there is a major interaction between the two flows and the turbulent flow of the steam also curls the fibers and makes them break into fairly short lengths. As the fibers fall on to a collecting belt they are sprayed with a binder to form mat suitable for insulation. The fiber diameter is likely to vary between about 5 and 30 jim. The Hager-Rosengarth process uses centrifugal forces produced by a thin stream of glass falling on to the centre of a rotating disk to produce fibers. The disk rotates at 3000-4000 rpm and produces fairly long fibers (about 500 mm) of diameter around 20 jim which are carried away by a current of air and often laid down to make a mat. The TEL process is a rather similar one in which a stream of glass falls into the center of a shallow dish or spinner made of heat
82
1 Classical Glass Technology
resistant steel which has several thousand apertures about 1 mm in diameter drilled around its circumference. The spinner rotates at about 3000 rpm and jets of glass fly horizontally out of the apertures to meet the combustion gases of a series of burners set around the perimeter of the spinner and pointing vertically downwards. The relatively thick jets leaving the spinner are thus reheated and further extruded to make the final fibers about 6jnm in diameter and about the same length as given by the Hager process. These are collected in a similar way. Some additional details of the processes are given by Giegerich and Trier (1964). 1.4.6.4 Continuous Fibers
The glass for manufacturing continuous fibers is generally melted in a small tank at about 1580°C and fed directly to the fiber drawing heads but it may be formed into 19 mm diameter marbles which are then fed directly into a separate drawing chamber, thus separating melting from fiber production. Although making marbles, cooling to room temperature and reheating, wastes a considerable amount of heat, the remelting and drawing is easy to control and is still the favored method for a few types of fiber. Continuous fibers are made by a process which relies on pulling the fiber away from a nozzle and using the velocity of drawing to attenuate the fiber to the desired diameter. The crucial nozzle dimensions are usually in the range of diameter 1 to 2.5 mm and length of the cylindrical part which controls flow rate 3 to 6 mm. The velocity of drawing may be more than 25 000 times the average velocity in the nozzle and the final fiber diameter as little as 6 jum; drawing speeds may be as high as 2500 mmin" 1 . Avoiding bubbles or crystalline inclusions in the glass is
thus very important. The large reduction in cross section also means that fibers are sometimes drawn under stresses not far short of the fracture stress and breakages may occur. The electrically heated platinum alloy bushing from which the fibers are drawn has several hundred nozzles (usually in multiples of 200) spaced as close together as convenient and is heated by the Joule effect. Having to stop the drawing for any reason, correct the defect and then restart drawing is a tedious operation; avoidable manufacturing defects are guarded against very carefully. A bushing has a working life of about 12 months and weighs 2 to 4 kg so that replacing it is a major expense. The drawing of a large number of fibers from a bushing creates a considerable flow of the air adjacent to the bushing and it is normal to supply an appropriate flow of clean air through inlets. The fibers are then sprayed with water before being coated with size by passing over a size applicator; this is often a rotating cylinder partially immersed in a bath of size. Next the fibers are gathered together by passing over a gathering shoe or wheel which may form one or several strands of yarn. The gathering shoe needs to be wetted to prevent the size adhering to it. Finally the strand is wound on a suitable core to make a cylindrical cake which is then dried and is ready for the final user. To make the strand easy to unwind it is wound on as a helix traversing from end to end of the bobbin. One important function of the size is to act as a surface lubricant to minimize damage by glass to glass abrasion during drawing and winding but it is very common for it to be formulated to act as a keying agent when the fiber is to be used in some kind of polymer composite; many different types of size exist for the latter use. The high drawing velocities mean that problems can
1.5 Polishing
sometimes arise over the rheological properties and wetting of the fiber by the size. An expert and detailed account of continuous fiber production is given by Loewenstein (1983). 1.4.6.5 Non-Circular Rod Tube and Fiber
Because glass flows as a perfectly newtonian liquid in most conditions it is possible to extrude preforms of many shapes and preserve their cross section, except for slight rounding off of sharp corners, provided that the extrusion is done at relatively high viscosity and fairly high stresses which minimize the effect of surface tension. The production of solid sections of a variety of shapes, such as rectangular and also hollow ones with internal ribs and partitions, was reported by Humphrey (1965). More recently Roeder and EgelHess (1987) have described the continuous extrusion of tubes with complex inner cross sections.
1.5 Polishing Most glass working operations are performed with hot fluid glass but polishing is the most important operation often necessary on cold glass. The Float process has made polishing unnecessary on large pieces of flat glass but it is still needed for high quality optical components and in preparing small samples for many kinds of laboratory measurements. Some glasses may also be polished by chemical rather than mechanical means but chemical polishing is not used when very accurate surface profiles are required. 1.5.1 Mechanical Polishing
Mechanical polishing is a rather slow and expensive process which consumes
83
large amounts of mechanical energy. The standard procedure is to wet grind the surface using in succession several grades of a suitable hard abrasive powder, each finer than the last, until a very fine frosted granular texture free from any pits or scratches left by the coarser grades is produced. The rate of removal decreases as the particle size and consequently chip size decrease. The liquid used at this stage is nearly always water and iron wheels are generally used. Large scale grinding of plate glass used to use quartz, which is a little harder than the glass but smaller scale operations usually use silicon carbide. Diamond wheels may be used for more rapid grinding or when making curved surfaces of specific radii but are much more costly. Having obtained a sufficiently fine texture the final stage of polishing uses a different very finely divided polishing agent in a similar way. Plate glass polishing used to use iron oxide but small scale operations frequently use specially prepared ceria on a cloth or felt covered wheel which is damp rather than wet. This eventually produces the required smooth and shiny surface. Polishing is an old art but one which is incompletely understood. The early stages of grinding to the necessary contour clearly operate by pressing the particles of grinding agent against the glass and breaking off chips of glass. The surface is formed by many small cracks which spread out and join together but also penetrate into the glass beneath. The use of several successively finer grades of abrasive is necessary to minimize the depth affected by this damage and thus avoid leaving sub-surface damage below the polished surface. The obvious simple physical model of polishing is to assume that the glass always behaves as an isotropic brittle material; using finer and finer grades of grinding and polishing agents is then assumed to produce essen-
84
1 Classical Glass Technology
tially similar surface texture on an ever smaller scale until the scale of the roughness is rather less than the wavelength of light and no longer gives scattering at the interface. Such a view has often been put forward in the past, for example by Newton in 1695 (see Thomson, 1922 and Preston, 1921). However, we now know that glass can flow on a small scale at room temperature: diamond pyramid micro-indentation tests can make permanent impressions in glasses, as in metals, so the possibility of some local flow cannot be ignored. A theory of flow in polishing was first elaborated by Beilby (1921) but has found few adherents. Its most obvious defect is that it attributes polishing entirely to flow of the surface layer but all quantitative studies show that polishing does remove material. It is now widely agreed that some chemical interaction between glass, polishing agent and liquid medium must be considered. This view was shared by Preston (1930) only a few years after his earlier championing of the abrasion theory. However, no theory yet put forward seems to be capable of explaining all the observations made in glass polishing studies. One of the most obvious pieces of evidence for a chemical interaction is that polishing efficiency is clearly not determined simply by particle size and hardness: most of the effective polishing agents are oxides of variable valence elements. The staining of the surface that can occur during polishing with iron oxide, chromium oxide, and ceria is another interesting demonstration of some chemical interaction. The liquid medium also has a definite influence and the pH of the medium can considerably affect both rate of removal of material and surface finish (Compton, 1989). One recent attempt to interpret the polishing of glasses is by Koucky and Matusek (1984) but, de-
spite its importance to the optical industry, mechanical polishing of glass remains only partially understood. 1.5.2 Acid Polishing
For many years it has been the practice of the lead crystal industry to polish cut (abraded) glass chemically by using hydrofluoric acid, the one readily available reagent capable of easily dissolving silicate glasses. It has also been known for a considerable time that etching away the surface layers of glass containing flaws which weaken it can increase the strength (Proctor, 1962). Such etching does not necessarily produce a polished surface, especially when the products of reaction are not removed, and commercial etchants of this type are often used for badging or otherwise producing frosted surfaces. Ammonium fluoride may be present in these mixtures. In recent years there have been many studies concerned with the safety of the operation and the disposal of the residues from the mixtures of hydrofluoric and sulfuric acids normally used but few concerned with details of the chemistry and the influence of the acid on the glass, however, some of these matters were discussed by Maskill and Ferguson (1950). A lengthy discussion by Kausch (1973) gives extensive descriptions of typical installations and useful information about the construction of baths and accessories sufficiently resistant to hydrofluoric and sulfuric acids for industrial use. Vacek and Kopackova (1977) concentrate more on some of the chemical aspects of the process. The essential step in the process may be considered to be 2 H + + SiF62~
n)H 2 O
(1-89)
1.6 References
When polishing glasses which contain lead or barium with a medium using sulfuric acid, the sulfates of these elements are also precipitated because they are considerably less soluble than the fluorides. Extraction of other alkali and alkaline earth ions also tends to neutralize the acid. It is thus necessary to replenish both acids from time to time as well as to dispose of the sludge which is formed. The low pH of the solution encourages the process ^ ^ 2 H + + SiF62~ -> H2SiF6 -> 2HF + SiF4 to proceed to the right and the evolution of both HF and SiF4 as vapors is an important health hazard which must be strictly controlled. The rate at which glasses are etched by hydrofluoric acid based solutions is strongly dependent on glass composition and Loftier (1954, 1957, 1964) used this to develop techniques for identifying various types of cord and ream by examining in an interferometer sections first polished and then acid etched, different types of cord giving different characteristic etching contours. Cable and Hakim (1973) used this technique to obtain a quantitative index of homogeneity.
1.6 References Abou el Azm, A.M.A., Moore, H. (1953), J. Soc. Glass Tech. 37, 129-154, 155-167, 168-181, 182189, 190-210. Afghan, M., Cable, M. (1980), Proc. XIII Internat. Glass Congress, Albuquerque. Amsterdam, New York, Oxford: North Holland, pp. 3-8. Anon. (1791), Encyclopedic Methodique. Paris: C. J. Panckcoucke, Vol. 8. Appen, A. A. (1949), Proc. Acad. Set USSR 69, 841 844. Appen, A. A. (1954), Silikattech. 5, 11-12. Appen, A. A. (1956), Proc. IV Internat. Glass Congress. Paris: Imprimerie Chaix, pp. 36-40. Appen, A. A., Polyakova, L. B. (1938), StekoL Prom. 1 (7), 18-21.
85
Appen, A. A., Kozlovskaya, E.I., Gan, E X . (1961), J. Appl. Chem. USSR 34, 975-981. Aylward, N.H., Cable, M., Wang, S.S. (1986), Proc. XIV Internat. Glass Congress, New Delhi. Calcutta: Indian Ceramic Society. Vol. 2, pp. 280-287. Babcock, C.L. (1977), Silicate Glass Technology Methods. New York/London/Sydney/Toronto: Wiley, Interscience. Backman, R., Cable, M., Karlsson, K., Pennington, N. P. (1990), Final Report EURAM Contract MA/ 1E/009/C; Glastech. Ber. 63K, 460-469. Bajorat, H., Weiss, W. (1965), Glastech. Ber. 38, 147152. Barton, XL. (1989), Glass Technol. 30, 115-116. Bastick, R. E. (1956), Compte Rendu Symposium sur L'Affinage du Verre. Paris: Union Scientifique Continentale du Verre, pp. 127-138. Beilby, G.T. (1921), Aggregation and Flow of Solids. London: MacMillan. Bezborodov, M. A. (1968), Synthesis and Structure of Glasses (in Russian). Minsk: Nauka i Tekhnika. Bezborodov, M. A., Appen, A. A., Korsukhina, T. E, Chodikel, E.P., Shinke, G. A. (1933), J. Soc. Glass Tech. 17, 305-319. Bilby, B. A., Eshelby, J. D., Kundu, A. K. (1975), Tectonophys. 28, 265-274. Bollert, X, Griffel, H., Seidel, H.-G. (1987), Glastech. Ber. 60, 406-410. Boffe, M., Letocart, G. (1962), Glass Technol. 3,117123. Borel, E. (1958), Fusion Electrique du Verre. Neuchatel: Paul Attinger. Bosc D'Antic, P. (1789), Oeuvres Paris 2 vols. Botvinkin, O.K. (1936), New Work on the Physical Chemistry of Glass (in Russian). Moscow and Leningrad. Bottinga, Y, Weill, D.F. (1972), Amer. J. Sci. 272, 438-475. Braginskii, K. I. (1973), Glass and Ceramics 30, 451454. Brill, R. H. (1965), Proc. VIIInternat. Glass Congress, Brussels. Part 2, Paper No. 223, pp. 1-13. Brown, S. C. (1979), Benjamin Thomson, Count Rumford. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. Burgman, X A. (1970), Glass Technol. 1, 110-116. Cable, M. (1958), J. Soc. Glass Tech. 42, 20-31. Cable, M. (1960), Glass Technol 1, 144-154. Cable, M. (1978), in: Borate Glasses: Structure Properties and Applications: Pye, L. D., Frechette, V.D., Kreidl, N.X (Eds.). New York/London: Plenum Press, pp. 399-411. Cable, M., Bower, C. (1965), Glass Technol. 6, 197205. Cable, M., Clarke, A.R., Haroon, M.A. (1969). Glass Technol. 10, 15-21. Cable, M., Frade, X R. (1987 a), J. Mater. Sci. 22, 149-154. Cable, M., Frade, XR. (1987 b), /. Mater. Sci. 22, 919-924.
86
1 Classical Glass Technology
Cable, M., Frade, J.R. (1987 c), J. Mater. Sci. 22, 1894-1900. Cable, M., Frade, J.R. (1987d), Glastech. Ber. 60, 355-362. Cable, M., Frade, J. R. (1988), Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A420, 247-265. Cable, M., Frade, J. R. (1991), submitted to J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. Cable, M., Hakim, J. (1973), Glass Technol. 14, 90100. Cable, M., Haroon, M. A. (1970), Glass Technol. 11, 48-53. Cable, M., Martlew, D. (1971), Glass Technol. 12, 142-147. Cable, M., Martlew, D. (1984), Glass Technol. 25, 24-30; 139-144. Cable, M., Martlew, D. (1985), Glass Technol. 26, 212-217. Cable, M., Martlew, D. (1986), Trans. J. Brit. Ceram. Soc. 85, 95-100. Cable, M., Naqvi, A. A. (1975), Glass Technol. 16, 2-11. Cable, M., Siddiqui, M.Q. (1980), Glass Technol. 21, 193-198. Cable, M., Smedley, J. W. (1987 a), Glass Technol. 28, 94-98. Cable, M., Smedley, J. W. (1987b), in: Early Vitreous Materials. Bimson, M., Freestone, I. C. (Eds.). London: British Museum Laboratory Occasional Papers No. 56, pp. 151-164. Cable, M., Smedley, J.W. (1989), Glass Technol. 30, 39-46. Cable, M., Swan, H.T. (1988), Glass Technol. 29, 144-149. Cable, M., Walters, S. D. (1980), Glass Technol. 21, 279-283. Carslaw, H. S., Jaeger, J. C. (1959), The Conduction of Heat in Solids. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Carter, R. E. (1961 a), /. Chem. Phys. 34, 2010-2015. Carter, R. E. (1961 b), J. Chem. Phys. 35, 1137-1138. Cassidy, D.C., Gjostein, N.A. (1970), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 53, 161-168. Clayton, R., Algar, J. (1989), The GEC Research Laboratories 1919-1984. London: Peter Peregrinus. Cobb, J.W. (1910), J. Soc. Chem. Ind. 29, 69-1 A, 250259, 335-336, 399-404, 608-614, 799-802. Compton, S. (1989), The polishing of ophthalmic crown glass. Ph. D. Thesis, University of Sheffield. Cooper, A.R. (1966 a), Glass Technol. 7, 2-11. Cooper, A. R. (1966 b), Chem. Engng. Sci. 21, 87-94. Cox, R.G. (1969), J. Fluid Mech. 37, 601-623. Daniels, M. (1973), Glastech. Ber. 46, 40-46. Diderot, D., D'Alembert, J. (1765), Encyclopedie ou Dictionnaire Raisonnee. Paris, Neufchastel: Plates vol IV Glacerie: (1772) Ibid vol XVII Verrerie. Douglas, R.W (1938), /. Soc. Glass Tech. 22, 206213; 259. Douglas, R.W, Frank, S. (1972), A History of Glassmaking. Henley on Thames: G. T. Foulis.
Dumbaugh, W H., Bocko, P. L., Fehlner, F P. (1991), in: High Performance Glasses: Cable, M., Parker, J. M. (Eds.). Glasgow: Blackie. Eshelby, I D . (1957), Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A241, 276-296. Eshelby, J.D. (1959), Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 252, 561-569. Everett, J. D., Everett, A. (1902), Jena Glass & its Scientific and Industrial Applications. London: Macmillan. Faraday, M. (1830), Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. 128, 1-57. Fletcher, W W (1963), Glass Technol. 4, 152-158. Fraunhofer, J. (1817), Reprinted in (1866), Bayer. Kunst und Gewerbeblatt 1-19, 34-49. Gardon, R. (1961), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 44, 305-312. Gell, P. A. M. (1956), J. Soc. Glass Tech. 40, 482-494. Genzel, L. (1953), Glastech. Ber. 26, 69-71. Giegerich, W. (1960), Glastech. Ber. 3, 441-449. Giegerich, W, Trier, W (1964), Glasmaschinen. Berlin, Gottingen, Heidelberg: Springer. Ginstling, A.M., Brounshtein, V.I. (1950), J. Appl. Chem. USSR (Consultants Bureau Translation) 23, 1327-1338. Glicksman, L.R. (1968), Glass Technol. 9, 131-138. Goerk, H. (1966), Tazeni Plocheni Skla. Prague: SNTL. Greene, C.H., Davis, D.H. (1974), Proc. X Internat. Glass Congress, Kyoto. Tokyo: Ceramic Society of Japan, Part 3, pp. 59-62. Greene, C.H., Gaffney, R. (1959), J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 42,211-212. Greene, C. H., Kitano, I. (1959), Glastech. Ber. 32K, V, 44-48. Greene, C.H., Lee, H.A. (1965), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 48, 528-533. Greene, C.H., Platts, D. R. (1969), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 52, 106-109. Griffith, A. A. (1920), Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 221, 163-198. Guido, M., Henderson, X, Cable, M., Bayley, X, Biek, L. (1984), Proc. Prehist. Soc. 50, 245-254. Hatakka, L. (1986), Glass 63, 449-450. Hlavac, X (1983), The Technology of Glass and Ceramics. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Hlavac, X, Nademlynska, H. (1969), Glass Technol. 10, 54-58. Hoover, H. C , Hoover, L. H. (1912), De Re Metallica (translation), London: Mining Magazine (1950) reprint, New York: Dover. Hornyak, E.X, Weinberg, M.C. (1984), Comm. Amer. Ceram. Soc. C 244-246. Hovestadt, H. (1900), Jenaer Glas und seine Verwendung in Wissenschaft und Technik. Jena: G. Fischer. Howard, I.C., Brierley, P. (1976), Int. J. Engng. Sci. 14, 1151-1159. Huff, N. T., Call, A. D. (1973), J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 56, 55-57. Huggins, M.L., Sun, K.-H. (1943), J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 26, 4-11.
1.6 References
Humphrey, R. A. (1965), Proc. VHInternat. Congress on Glass, Brussels. Charleroi: INdV, Paper No. 77, pp. 1-8. Hynd, W. C. (1984), in: Glass Science and Technology, Vol. 2, Processing I. Kreidl, N. X, Uhlmann, D. R. (Eds.). New York/London: Academic Press, Chap. 2. Ito, T., Hosoi, T., Suganuma, M., Uno, T. (1954), Res. Rept. Asahi Glass Co. 4, 98-106. Jack, H. R. S., Jacquest, I T. (1958), Symposium sur la Fusion du Verre, Brussels. Charleroi: Union Scientifique du Verre, pp. 339-360. Jander, W. (1927), Z. anorg. allgem. Chem. 163,1-30. Jebsen-Marwedel, H. (1936), Glastechnische Fabrikationsfehler, 1st ed. Berlin: Springer. Jebsen-Marwedel, H. (1956), Glastech. Ber. 30, 122129. Joanni, E. (1989), Homogenization of Laboratory Scale Glass Melts, PhD. thesis, University of Sheffield. Joanni, E., Smedley, I W , Cable, M. (1989), Proc. XV Internat. Glass Congress, Leningrad. Leningrad: Nauka. Vol. 3 a, 66-71. Kausch, J.C. (1973), Sprechsaal 106, 401-408, 522531, 627-630, 667-669. Kiessling, B., Dressel, H. (1979), Silikattech. 30, 210213. Kirkbride, B. X, Williams, G. (1991), in: High Performance Glasses. Cable, M., Parker, XM. (Eds.). Glasgow: Blackie. Koucky, X, Matusek, M. (1984), Glass Technol 25, 240-243. Kreider, K. G., Cooper, A.R. (1967), Glass Technol. 8, 11-13. Kroger, C , Fingas, G. (1933), Z. anorg. allgem. Chem. 213, 482-483. Kroger, C. (1948), Glastech. Ber. 22, 86-93. Kroger, C. (1953), Glastech. Ber. 26, 202-214. Kroger, C , Eligehausen, H. (1959), Glastech. Ber. 32, 362-372. Kroger, C , Marwan, F. (1955), Glastech. Ber. 28, 51-57; 89-98. Kroger, C , Marwan, F. (1956), Glastech. Ber. 29, 257-289. Kroger, C , Marwan, F. (1957), Glastech. Ber. 30, 222-229. Kroger, C , Vogel, E. (1955), Glastech. Ber. 28, 426437; 468-474. Kroger, C , Ziegler, G. (1952), Glastech. Ber. 25, 307324. Kroger, C , Ziegler, G. (1953), Glastech. Ber. 26, 346353. Kroger, C , Ziegler, G. (1954), Glastech. Ber. 27,199212. Kroger, C , Janetzko, W, Kreitlow, G. (1958), Glastech. Ber. 31,221-228. Kunckel, X (1679), Ars Vitraria Experimentalis, 1st ed. Frankfurt, Leipzig: Johann Bielcke. Lakatos, X, Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1972 a), Glass Technol. 13, 88-95.
87
Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1972 b), Glastekn. Tidskr. 27, 25-28. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1972 c), Glastekn. Tidskr. 27, 11-SO. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1973), Glastekn. Tidskr. 28, 69-73. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1974), Glastekn. Tidskr. 29, 43-47. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1975), Glastekn. Tidskr. 30, 7-8. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1976 a), Glastekn. Tidskr. 31, 31-35. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1976b), Glastekn. Tidskr. 31, 51-54. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1977), Glastekn. Tidskr. 32, 31-35. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1978), Glastekn. Tidskr. 33, 55-59. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1979), Glastekn. Tidskr. 34, 9-10. Lakatos, T., Johansson, L.-G., Simmingskold, B. (1981), Glastekn. Tidskr. 36, 51-55. Lamb, H. (1945), Hydrodynamics 6th. ed. New York: Dover, pp. 623-628. Lemaire, E. (1965), Proc. VII Internat. Congress on Glass, Brussels. Vol. 2, Paper No. 223, 1-10. Levich, V. I. (1962), Physicochemical Hydrodynamics. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall. Loewenstein, K. L. (1983), The Manufacturing Technology of Continuous Glass Fibres, 2nd ed. Amsterdam, Oxford, New York: Elsevier. Loffler, X (1954), Glastech. Ber. 27, 381-392. Loffler, X (1957), Glastech. Ber. 30, 457-463. Loffler, X (1964), Glastech. Ber. 37, 548-553. Manring, W.H., Bauer, W.C. (1964), Glass Ind. 45, 413-416; 449-451. Manring, W. H., Hopkins, E. W. (1958), Glass Ind. 39, 139-142; 170. Maskill, W, Ferguson, D. (1950), /. Soc. Glass Tech. 34, NR 115-121. Maurer, E., Bischoff, W. (1930), Stahl und Eisen 55, 477-484. Mazurin, O.V., Strel'tsina, M.V., Shvaiko-Shvaikovskaya, T.P. (1973-1981), Properties of Glass and Glass-forming Melts (in Russian), Six vols. Leningrad: Nauka. McGraw, D. A. (1961), / Amer. Ceram. Soc. 44, 353363. McKelvey, XM. (1962), Polymer Processing. New York: John Wiley. McMillan, P. W. (1979), Glass Ceramics, 2nded. London, New York, San Francisco: Academic Press. Merret, C. (1662), The Art of Glass. London: printed by A. W. for Octavian Pulleyn. Mohr, W. D. (1960), in: Processing of Thermoplastic Materials. Bernhard, E. C. (Ed.). New York: Reinhold, Chap. 3. Moody, B.E. (1988), Glass Technol. 29, 198-210. Moody, B.E. (1989), Glass Technol. 30, 191-192.
88
1 Classical Glass Technology
Moore, J., Sharp, E. E. (1958), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 41, 461-463. Morrell, I, Thackray, A. (1981), Gentlemen of Science. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Mulfinger, H. O. (1974), Glastekn. Tidskr. 29, 81-95. Mulfinger, H.O. (1976), Glastech. Ber. 49, 232-245. Muller, R, Lim, S.-K., Gebhardt, R, Kiistner, D. (1989), Glastech. Ber. 62, 369-376. Mullins (1959), J. Appl. Phys. 30, 77-83. Nemec, L. (1974), Glass TechnoL 15, 153-161. Nemec, L. (1977 a), Proc. XI Internat. Glass Congress, Prague. Praha: CVTS, Vol. 4, 155-165. Nemec, L. (1977 b), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 69, 436440. Nemec, L. (1980), Glass TechnoL 21, 139-144. Neri, A. (1612), L'Arte Vetraria. Pirenze: nella Stampa de'Giunti. Newton, I. (1704), Optics. London: (Reprint (1952) New York: Dover). Newton, R.G. (1985), Glass TechnoL 26, 93-103. Okhotin, M.V. (1954), Steklo Keram. 11 (1), 7-11. Onorato, P.I.K., Weinberg, M.C., Uhlmann, D.R. (1981), J. Amer. Geram. Soc. 64, 676-682. Parker, X M. (1989), Ann. Rev. Mater. Sci. 19, 21 -41. Pilkington, L.A.B. (1969), Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 314, 1-25. Poole, J.P. (1963), Glass TechnoL 4, 143-152. Potts, J.C. (1939), /. Soc. Glass Tech. 23, 129-150. Potts, J.C. (1941), J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 24, 43-50. Potts, J.C, Brookover, G., Burch, O.G. (1944), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 27, IIS-ISX. Preston, RW. (1921-1922), Trans. Opt. Soc. Amer. 23, 141. Preston, R W. (1930), J. Soc. Glass Tech. 14,127-132. Preston, E., Turner, W.E.S. (1940), /. Soc. Glass Tech. 24, 124-138. Proctor, B. (1962), Phys. Chem. Glasses 3, 7-27. Pugh, A.C.P. (1968), Glastekn. Tidskr. 23, 95-104. Ratcliffe, E. H. (1963), Glass TechnoL 4, 113-128. Reinhardt, H.P. (1965), Proc. VII Internat. Congress on Glass, Brussels. Charleroi: Institut Nationale du Verre. Vol. 1, Paper No. 73, 1-10. Rhiel, P.P. (1976), Glastech. Ber. 49, 217-226. Richet, P. (1987), Chem. Geol. 62, 111-124. Roeder, E., Egel-Hess, W. (1987), Glastech. Ber. 60, 177-181. Rosenkrands, B., Simmingskold, B. (1962), Glass TechnoL 3, 46-51. Russ, A. (1928), Sprechsaal61, 887-891; 907-913. Sadeghi, J.J. (1980), Ph.D. Thesis, University of Sheffield. Schmid, W, Hertel, H. (1968), Glastech. Ber. 41, 395408. Scholze, H. (1977), Glas: Natur, Struktur und Eigenschaften, 2nd ed. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer. Schuster, A. (1903), Phil. Mag. Series 65, 243-257'. Scriven, L. E. (1959), Chem. Engng. Sci. 10, 1-13. Sharp, D.E., Ginther, L. B. (1951), J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 34, 260-271.
Shaw, H.R. (1972), Amer. J. Sci. 272, 870-893. Sheckler, C. A., Dinger, D. R. (1990), J. Amer. Ceram.
Soc. 73, 24-30. Sibilia, V. E. (1939), /. Soc. Glass Tech. 23, 292-307. Silverman, A. (1939), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 22, 378384. Simpson, W, Myers, D. (1978), Glass TechnoL 19, 82-84. Slavyanskii, V. T. (1957), Gases in Glass (in Russian). Moscow: Gos. Izdat. Oboronoi Prom., pp. 87115. Solinov, F.G., Pankova, N. A. (1965), Proc. VII Internat. Glass Congress, Brussels. Charleroi: Institut Nationale du Verre. Paper No. 341, pp. 1-11. Stanek, J. (1977), Electric Melting of Glass. Amsterdam, Oxford, New York: Elsevier. Stein, G. (1958), in: Gunther, R., Glass Tank Furnaces (English translation). Sheffield: Society of Glass Technology. Stokes, G. G. (1871), Brit. Assoc. Reports 41, 38-44. Swift, H.R. (1947), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 30, 170174. Taylor, G.I. (1934), Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A146, 501-523. Thomas, W.R (1960), Phys. Chem. Glasses 1, 4-18. Thomson, E. (1922), J. Opt. Soc. Amer. 6, 843-847. Tober, H. (1990 a), Glastech. Ber. 63, 78-84. Tober, H. (1990 b), Glastech. Ber. 63, 172-182. Trier, W. (1955), Glastech. Ber. 28, 336-351. Trier, W. (1984), Glasschmelzofen. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, Tokyo: Springer. Turkdogan, E. T. (1983), Physicochemical Properties of Molten Slags and Glasses. London: Metals Society. Turnbull, D., Cohen, M. (1960), in: Modern Aspects of the Vitreous State, Vol. 1. Mackenzie, J. D. (Ed.). London: Butterworth, pp. 38-62. Turner, W.E.S. (1962), Glass TechnoL 3, 201-213. Vacek, M., Kopackova, J. (1977), Proc. XI Internat. Glass Congress, Prague. Praha: CVTS, Vol. 5, pp. 253-263. Valensi, G. (1935), C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris, 201, 602604. Valensi, G. (1936), C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris, 202, 309312. Valensi, G. (1950), /. Chim. Phys. 47, 489-505. Vernon Harcourt, W. (1844), Brit. Assoc. Reports 14, 82-85. Volf, M.B. (1961), Technical Glasses. London: Pitman. Walther, A., Eller, J., Dorr, E. (1953), Glastech. Ber. 26, 133-146. Westerlund, T., Hatakka, L., Karlsson, K. (1983), /. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 6, 574-579. West-Oram, R G. (1979), Glass TechnoL 20, 222-245. Wiedmann, K. (1954), Glastech. Ber. 27, 33-40. Wilburn, F. W, Thomasson, C. V. (1958), /. Soc. Glass Tech. 42, 158-175. Wilburn, RW, Thomasson, C.V. (1960), Phys. Chem. Glasses 1, 52-69.
1.6 References
Wilburn, F.W., Metcalf, S.A., Warburton, R.S. (1965), Glass Technol. 6, 107-114. Winkelmann, A., Schott, O. (1894), Ann. Phys. Chem. 51, 697-714, 730-746. Yamauchi, H. (1977), Proc. XI Internat. Glass Congress, Prague. Praha: CVTS, Vol. 5, 147-158. Zachariasen, W.H. (1932), /. Amer. Chem. Soc. 54, 3841=3851. Zeng, R.J., Cable, M., Harris, E.A. (1989), Supercond. Sci. Technol. 2, 47-51.
General Reading Babcock, G.L. (1977), Silicate Glass Technology Methods. New York: Wiley. Douglas, R. W, Franck, S. (1972), A History of Glassmaking. London: Foulis Co.
89
Giegerich, W, Trier, W. (1964), Glasmaschinen. Berlin, Gottingen, Heidelberg: Springer. Hlavac, J. (1983), The Technology of Glass and Ceramics. Amsterdam, Oxford, New York: Elsevier. Morey, G. W. (1954), The Properties of Glass, 2nd ed. New York: Reinhold. Rawson, H. (1967), Inorganic Glass Forming Systems. London, New York: Academic Press. Rawson, H. (1980), Properties and Applications of Glass. Amsterdam, Oxford, New York: Elsevier. Shand, E.B. (1958), Glass Engineering Handbook. New York: McGraw. Scholze, H. (1977), Glas, Natur, Struktur und Eigenschaften, 2nd ed. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer. Tooley, F. V. (Ed.) (1961), Handbook of Glass Manufacture, Vol. I and II, 2nd ed. New York: Ogden. Uhlmann, D.R., Kreidl, N.J. (1984), Glass Science and Technology, Vol. 2, Processing, I. New York: Academic Press. Zarzycki, J. (1991), Glasses and the Vitreous State. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials Jerzy Zarzycki Laboratory of Science of Vitreous Materials, University of Montpellier, Montpellier, France
List of 2.1 2.1.1 2.1.2 2.1.3 2.2 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.3 2.3.1 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.4 2.4.1 2.4.2 2.4.3 2.4.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.7.1 2.7.1.1 2.7.1.2 2.7.1.3 2.7.2 2.7.3 2.7.3.1 2.7.3.2 2.7.3.3 2.7.4 2.7.4.1 2.7.4.2 2.7.5 2.7.5.1 2.7.5.2
Symbols and Abbreviations Introduction Glasses and Amorphous Materials The Concept of "New Glasses" Different Routes to Non-Crystalline Solids Melt Quenching Techniques Unconventional Melting Ultrafast Quenching Vapor Quenching Techniques Evaporation Sputtering Reactive Deposition Solid-State Methods Radiation Damage Effects of Intense Shock Waves Slow Mechanical Actions Diffusion Effects Electrochemical Methods - Anodic Oxidation Pyrolysis Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses Methods of Gel Formation Gel Formation from Alkoxides Gel Formation from Sols Redispersion Methods Aging Effects Drying The Role of Capillary Forces Obtaining Monolithic Gels Structural Aspects Curing-Sintering Viscous Flow Sintering Devitrification Kinetics - Use of TTT Diagrams Forming Processes Bulk Glass Thin Films
Materials Science and Technology Copyright © WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co KGaA. Allrightsreserved.
93 94 94 94 95 95 95 95 98 98 98 99 100 100 100 101 101 102 102 102 103 103 105 106 107 107 108 108 110 110 Ill Ill 112 112 112
92
2.7.5.3 2.7.5.4 2.7.6 2.7.7 2.8
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
Fibers Hollow Glass Microspheres Advantages and Disadvantages of the Sol-Gel-Process Future Trends References
113 113 114 114 116
List of Symbols and Abbreviations
List of Symbols and Abbreviations
c
D E P r
r
critical point fractal dimension Young's modulus critical stress concentration coefficient pressure radius of the pore reduced time
V
fracture surface energy specific surface energy viscosity Poisson's number
CVD DCCA HSE ICF NMR rf SAXS TTT
chemical vapor deposition drying control chemical additives hypercritical solvent evacuation inertial confinement fusion nuclear magnetic resonance radio frequency small angle X-ray scattering time-temperature-transformation
7
n
93
94
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
2.1 Introduction 2.1.1 Glasses and Amorphous Materials Glasses, in the current sense of the term, are essentially non-crystalline materials obtained by fusing together silica (sand) with Na and Ca oxides (in the form of carbonates), which act as fluxes and lower the processing temperature. The resulting melt is cooled at a sufficient rate to avoid crystallization and then shaped into different forms: flat sheets, containers, fibers. This classical glass technology was the object of the preceding chapter. The glass-making process has evolved over the centuries and now represents a heavy industry with a yearly production of approximately 18 million tons for the European Community and about the same amount for the U.S.A. It is well known, however, that substances other than silica or silicates can exist in a non-crystalline form. Tamman (1933) coined the concept of the "glassy state of matter" to describe this situation, and glasses are often simply identified with non-crystalline materials. This definition is obviously too wide, as it encompasses materials which, though noncrystalline, frankly have different properties (e.g., gels). Furthermore, quenching a liquid is not the only way in which noncrystalline solids can be obtained. It would therefore seem more appropriate to reserve the term of "glasses" only for those noncrystalline solids which present the phenomenon of "glass transition", whatever their origin, and to call the remainder amorphous materials (Zarzycki, 1982 a). This classification however, has not yet been universally adopted. The terms "amorphous" and "non-crystalline" are often considered as synonymous; for instance, Elliott (1990) defines glass as "an amorphous solid which exhibits a glass transition".
2.1.2 The Concept of "New Glasses" Non-crystalline solids, glasses, and amorphous materials alike now play an increasingly important role in modern technology. Besides common glass, which is an indispensable material in today's economy in architecture, transport, lighting, conditioning, etc., there is a whole set of glasses and amorphous materials which enter into more and more sophisticated applications in optics, electronics, optoelectronics, biotechnologies, etc. The concept of "new glasses" emerged progressively and covers materials other than classical glasses. The Japanese experts consider the market for these new materials to be of the order of $ 1 billion in 1987 and estimate that it will reach $ 17 billion by the beginning of the 21st century. It should be noted that in many cases the methods of producing these materials differ so profoundly form classical glass technology that their manufacture is being taken over by firms not traditionally concerned with glass but rather with electronic equipment or chemistry. Most of these glasses are high-tech materials and their production is to be evaluated in tons rather than in millions of tons as is the case of classical glass. The purpose of this chapter is to review the various "unusual" ways of producing glass and amorphous materials. Some of these methods are of purely academic value or are still in the laboratory stages, while others have already gained industrial importance. Previous reviews of this subject have been made by Secrist and Mackenzie (1964) and Scherer and Schultz (1983). Particular attention will be paid here to the obtention of glasses from precursors using methods of soft chemistry which have shown particularly rapid development in recent years.
2.2 Melt Quenching Techniques
2.1.3 Different Routes to Non-Crystalline Solids
To obtain a glass or an amorphous solid, it is necessary either to retain at ambient temperature the disordered state of a liquid or gas, or, alternatively, to destroy (amorphize) the structure of a crystal. It is also possible to produce the disordered structure directly by means of suitable chemical reactions which may or may not be assisted by external fields (electrical or chemical potentials). The following general types of methods are at our disposal: • melt quenching • vapor quenching • crystalline solid disordering (other than melting) • interdiffusion and sintering • electrolysis • pyrolysis • reactions in solution
2.2 Melt Quenching Techniques
95
which leads to melting in an atmosphere of inert gas, often in sealed ampoules. Atmospheric control is also necessary for metallic glasses (see Chapter 9). For halide glasses (see Chapter 8) the melt is obtained by fluorination of corresponding oxides in an atmosphere containing HF. Melting under high pressure has seldom been used in practice. It was applied by Datta et al. (1964) under 1 kbar pressure to produce K 2 CO 3 -MgCO 3 glasses, as well as glasses combining Mn, Pb, or Ca carbonates. Operating under pressures of up to 10 kbar, in an Ar, H 2 O, or CO 2 atmosphere, Roy et al. (1964) produced glasses containing unusually large amounts of dissolved gases (up to 25mol% H 2 O and 4mol% Ar). While the quench in air is average, the quench in a liquid (water, mercury, or liquid nitrogen) is strong and may be used to achieve higher cooling rates. The quenching rate, however, is quickly limited in practice (up to 10 2o C/s) by the formation of an insulating vapor layer at the glass-liquid interface (calefaction effect).
2.2.1 Unconventional Melting
The usual way of obtaining a glass is by quenching a melt obtained by fusion of one or several crystalline substances. When the rate of the decrease in temperature is sufficient to bypass crystallization, the disordered state of the liquid is retained in the solid state (see Chapters 3 and 4). In classical glass technology, where glass formers such as SiO2 or B 2 O 3 are used, air quenching is sufficient, and the composition of the glasses is optimized to avoid the risk of crystallization (devitrification). For oxide glasses the melt can be obtained in air, although control of the Redox conditions may be necessary (see Chapter 1). For chalcogenide glasses (see Chapter 7) the exclusion of oxygen is essential,
2.2.2 Ultrafast Quenching
To achieve higher cooling rates it is necessary to use a contact with a solid of high thermal conductivity, generally a metal such as copper (see also Chapter 2 of Volume 15). The splat-cooling technique (Duwez etal., 1960) consists of projecting a droplet of a melt by the action of a pressure shock wave which propulses the sample towards a curved Cu-plate (Fig. 2-1). The glass is obtained in the form of thin flakes of a few microns in thickness resulting from high-speed conduction cooling (10 5 -10 9 °C/s). The quality of the contact between the liquid and the solid substrate controls the effective cooling rate, as shown by Ruhl (1967).
96
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
Pressurized He • I - High-pressure chamber - Breakable mylar diaphragm (~80um thick) -Low-pressure chamber Ar
-Furnace -Molten sample (~100mg) in crucible Molten jet
Opening
Copper reception strip
Figure 2-1. Duwez-type splat-cooling device (schematic).
-Furnace
Fast-moving hammer Figure 2-2. Hammer-and-anvil splat-cooling device (schematic). Stationary anvil
In another device, designed by Pietrokowsky (1963), a molten droplet is expelled from a crucible and smashed between two metallic plates, one of which is electronically triggered via a photocell by the droplet itself (Fig. 2-2). The advantage of this device is that it produces plates of uniform thickness devoid of holes as in Duwez' device, but quenching speeds are somewhat lower (10 5o C/s). The calculation of limiting cooling speeds in splat cooling was performed by Bletry (1973), and recent devices using laser sources for melting were developed by Krepski et al. (1975) and Veltri et al. (1979). The cooling of a molten droplet between two rapidly rotating steel rollers was used by Zarzycki and Naudin (1967) to produce flakes of B 2 O 3 -PbO-Al 2 O 3 glasses for unmixing kinetics studies (Fig. 2-3). Chen and Miller (1970, 1976) developed a similar device for obtaining metallic glasses, which was also used by Suzuki and Anthony (1974) to examine various binary systems of refractory oxides, some of which formed glasses. All the preceding devices produce small samples suitable only for laboratory examination of structure. The device of Chen and Miller (1976) opened the way to making continuous ribbons of metallic glasses, by the use of a metallic (Cu-Be) wheel spinning at 300-1800 rpm. A liquid stream impinges on the inside of the wheel's toruslike, convex surface. The quenched ribbon slips out of the wheel under the action of the centrifugal force. Ribbons 0.5 mm wide, 20 jam thick, and up to 100 m in length were produced. The technique was further improved by quenching the melt on the outside of the spinning wheel (Fig. 2-4). The liquid is spread in the form of continuous film with quench rates of 1 0 6 - 1 0 8 K s " 1 . Modern devices enable ribbons up to several deci-
97
2.2 Melt Quenching Techniques
C0 2 Laser (250 W)
J— Furnace Molten sample in crucible
Spun-off spherules
\ \
— Laser beam focussed onto the tip of the sample
High-speed (20000 rpm) Rotating sample rod
A Falling droplet
v)
Collecting —\ hopper \ Fast rotating steel rollers
\_
Steel collecting tray
Figure 2-5. Laser spin-melting device (schematic).
Splat Figure 2-3. Rollers splat-cooling device (schematic).
Gas pressure
Furnace Crucible Liquid metal
Quenched glass ribbon
Fast rotating wheel Figure 2-4. Melt-spinning device (schematic).
meters wide to be produced. More details on this important industrial technique will be given in Chapter 9 of this Volume. Reviews on splat cooling are to be found in Anantharaman and Suryanarayana (1971), Jones (1972), and Jones and Suryanarayana (1973). A variant of splat cooling is
laser-film melting, whereby the beam of a CO 2 laser is used to scan the surface of a specimen, producing a molten layer which quickly solidifies in perfect contact with the solid (not molten) substrate (United Technologies Research Center, 1976). In splat-cooling techniques one dimension (the thickness) of the splat or of the ribbon is kept small in order to speed up the heat exchange. It is also possible to subdivide the melt into droplets small enough to achieve a high cooling rate by radiation. In the method of laser-spin melting (Topol et al., 1973) small droplets are produced by spinning the target in the form of a rod at 8000-30000 rpm. The extremity of the target is heated by a CO 2 laser (Fig. 2-5). Cooling rates for droplets 500 jim in thickness were estimated at 4000 °C/s. Various refractory oxides and their mixtures (A12O3, Ga 2 O 3 , La 2 O 3 , Nb 2 O 3 , Ta 2 O 5 , etc.) were obtained in partly non-crystalline form. Other experiments were made in the preparation of glass-melting experiments in migrogravity conditions (Spacelab and Shuttle missions).
98
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
2.3 Vapor-Quenching Techniques Vacuum jar
The formation of non-crystalline solids may also be achieved by depositing one or several components in the vapor state onto a substrate. The vapor may be produced by heating a suitable compound and deposited as such without further modification (nonreactive deposition), or a chemical reaction may intervene (reactive deposition). These processes are typically used for producing thin films for electronic and optical applications. Reactive deposition, however, may also be used to produce either bulk glasses that are difficult to obtain from the melt or hyperpure materials, when are needed (e.g., blanks for optical fibers). 2.3.1 Evaporation
The evaporation method consists of emitting a vapor under vacuum and condensing it onto the specimen (Fig. 2-6). The various techniques differ according to the heating method employed to evaporate the substance: electrical resistance heating, electron beam heating, or high-frequency heating. The operation takes place in a re-
Sample at controlled temperature
Vacuum jar
-Shutter Residual atmosphere (1CTA-10-7Torr)
/N \±l
I
|
Heated evaporation boats
To pumping system Figure 2-6. Thermal evaporator (schematic).
Solid to be sputtered (cathode)
Sputtered atoms Specimen to be coated (anode)
Figure 2-7. Sputtering coating device (schematic).
sidual atmosphere (10 4 - 1 0 7 Torr), and the vapor pressure of the depositing material is kept below 10 ~2 Torr. Single metals can be readily evaporated in this way. For multicomponent systems several separate sources may be used or a metal alloy rapidly evaporated using the "flash" technique. In the case of oxides, their dissociation (e.g., SiO formation in the case of SiO2) may cause difficulties. 2.3.2 Sputtering
In the sputtering method the specimen to be coated and the solid source are both contained in a closed vessel in a low-pressure gas atmosphere (generally Ar), Fig. 2-7). A high d.c. voltage of a few kilo volts is used to produce a glow discharge, with the specimen as anode and the source as cathode. This discharge produces Ar + ions, which after being driven toward the cathode, eject (sputter) the atoms from the cathode. Some of these atoms will condense on the specimen forming a uniform, generally non-crystalline film of a composition close to that of the source material. (For the physics of sputtering, see Townsend et al., 1976.)
2.3 Vapor-Quenching Techniques
The method can be used to deposit both elemental metals or alloys. It is widely used in electronic and optical applications. In glass technology continuous sputtering devices are used to coat glass panes with metal or oxide layers for applications in architecture (light control). The industrial devices use alternating voltages and magnetic fields (magnetron sputtering) to increase the path of the ions and thus their collision frequency, which results in a better yield. A standard work on the deposition of thin films is that of Holland (1956). 2.3.3 Reactive Deposition In reactive-deposition processes a chemical reaction is initiated in the gas phase by supplying sufficient activation energy: thermal, in the form of heat, or electrical, in an rf glow discharge. Heterogeneous and homogeneous processes must be distinguished. For example, SiO2 glass may be produced by homogeneous or heterogeneous oxidation of SiCl4 vapor or by oxidizing the surface of a silicon wafer. In reactive sputtering, if the Ar gas contains O 2 or N 2 , the resulting sputtered film will be the oxide or nitride of the sputtered cathode metal. With an Si cathode, SiO2 or Si 3 N 4 films will be produced. Processes of this kind are extremely important in the electronics industry, where glass films are used for encapsulating integrated circuits and thin dielectric films as both active and positive components. Using these techniques, amorphous films can often be obtained in systems where the obtention of glasses by direct methods is impossible. For general reviews on these applications see Amick et al. (1977) and Pliskin et al. (1967). Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) involves a heterogeneous reaction and deposition from organometallic or metal halide
99
vapors at a heated solid substrate. For example, gas mixtures such as SiH 4 , PH 3 , and O 2 , or SiCl4, POC1 3 , and O 2 passing over a heated Si surface at temperatures below 1000°C, SiO 2 -P 2 O 5 glass layers are formed at a rate < 1 jim/min. Most of the work done concerns SiO2, Si 3 N 4 , SiO 2 -P 2 O 5 , SiO 2 -B 2 O 3 , and A12O3 both for low-temperature CVD (450 °C) or high-temperature CVD (850 °C). Glow discharge plasmas (rf or microwave) allow for low-temperature operations (310 °C). This method was used to prepare chalcogenide films and SiJCN}?Hz films. For details see Kern and Rosier (1977). Thermally activated homogeneous oxidation of mixtures of metal halide vapors is performed to obtain large bulk glasses of high purity and quality by vapor-deposition techniques. Metal halides (SiCl4, GeCl 4 , TiCl 4 , BC13, POC13) are generally used as starting compounds as are SiH4 and organometallics (e.g., (CH4)3B). At temperatures above 1500°C, a homogeneous oxidation reaction predominates, and without a catalyzing surface a finely divided glass particulate material called "soot" is obtained. The reaction SiCl4 + O 2 -* SiO2 + 2Cl 2
(2-1)
is obtained by passing a mixture of SiCl4 and O 2 in a burner through a methaneoxygen flame. The high specific surface of the soot (^20m 2 /g) provides a strong driving force for sintering (see Chapter 3). When soot is collected on a target heated at a sufficiently high temperature ( » 1800°C for SiO2), sintering and conversion into solid bubble-free glass occur, (Fig. 2-8). By this process very large glass "boules" (over 500 kg) were obtained for SiO 2 , either in pure form or with additions (TiO2, A12O3, B 2 O 3 ); see Dalton and Nordberg (1941) and Nordberg (1943).
100
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
5iCl^+ 0 2 ( +Dopants) — Burners
\l V ik
Soot-carrying flames
Y//////////////////
Deposited SiO2 "boule"
Slowly rotating substrate held at ~1800°C
Figure 2-8. Flame oxidation process for producing bulk silica (schematic).
Lowering the soot deposition temperature to less than 1500°C helps to retain the more volatile components (e.g., B 2 O 3 ); this results in a porous silica body which can then be sintered in a separate step at a higher temperature (Schultz, 1975). Deposition methods based on these principles are used to prepare preforms for glass optical fibers. These important techniques will be described in Chapter 16 of this Volume.
2.4 Solid-State Methods
particle to the neighboring atoms produces "thermal spikes" of the order of several thousand degrees Kelvin for 10 " 1 ° -10 " 1 1 s which extend to regions of the order of 104 atoms and may produce local melting followed by an ultrafast quench. Exposure of various ceramic materials to neutron doses of approximately 3xlO 2 0 neutrons/cm 2 renders these materials amorphous (Wullaert, 1964; see also Ch. 9, Sec. 9.2.5). The classic work of Primak (1958) has shown that on irradiation quartz and cristobalite are progressively amorphized and that their properties tend toward those of vitreous SiO2. Radioactive materials, e.g., complex uranium oxide minerals, become rnetamictized, i.e., disordered by their own radioactivity (Primak and Bohmann, 1962). Ion implantation may be used to modify the structure of superficial layers of materials. Some results are presented in Chapters 6 and 9. As yet, amorphization by irradiation effects has not been exploited in glass technology, but ion implantation has recently been used to modify oxide glass surfaces (Ch. 6). 2.4.2 Effects of Intense Shock Waves
Non-crystalline solids may be obtained from crystals without passing through the fusion stage. There are several other ways of destroying a regular crystal lattice. 2.4.1 Radiation Damage The collision of energetic particles with the atoms of a crystal produces lattice defects; the effect is cumulative and the process may end in the formation of a noncrystalline solid. Fast neutrons have a low probability of collision, but each collision produces a large number of defects; charged particles have a higher probability of collision but produce less displacements. The transfer of the kinetic energy of the
Powerful pressure shock waves of several hundred kilobars generated during explosions may produce amorphization of crystals without their melting. The external boundaries of the original crystal are conserved and show the absence of flow, but the crystalline lattice is destroyed. Such glasses are called diaplectic or thetomorphic. Impacts of meteorites produce such materials (Chao, 1967), and in particular, it was discovered that the surface of the moon is covered with glassy material. Research on glasses linked with the lunar exploration (Apollo program) was destined to determine whether these materials were
101
2.4 Solid-State Methods
of volcanic origin or the result of continuous meteorite bombardment (Pye et al., 1984). In the laboratory the first diaplectic glasses were produced by De Carli and Jamieson (1959) who amorphized silica with shock waves at pressures exceeding 350 kbar and Milton and De Carli (1963) who obtained diaplectic plagioclase (NaAlSi 3 O 8 -CaAl 2 Si 2 O 8 ) glass with pressures up to 800 kbar. For a review, see Stoffler (1972, 1974). Shock waves are produced in the laboratory by explosions in which a projectile (striking plate) is propelled at a specimen. Upon impact with the specimen, a pressure pulse of several hundred kilobars with a duration of a few microseconds is produced (Fig. 2-9). Methods of calculating pressures and temperatures thus generated were given by Wackerle (1962) and Gibbons and Ahrens (1971). In natural events (meteoritic impacts) much higher pressures are expected, reaching several megabars. This may induce partial or total fusion and even vaporization of the sample. Practical applications are as yet rare. The firm Schott Glasswerk has obtained a patent (Schott, 1968) for shock-produced oxide glasses (B2O3-La2O3-ThO2Nb 2 O 3 -Ta 2 O 5 ) and fluoride glasses (CaF 2 -SrF 2 -LaF 3 -AlF 3 -NaPO 3 ) with elevated refractive indices. The pressures employed were 5-10 kbar. The preceding oxide glasses cannot be obtained by conventional melting, and the fluoride glass has a refractive index superior to that of glass obtained by melting. Another use of shock waves which should lead to important applications in the field of metallic glasses is the explosive compaction of metallic glass particles into homogeneous cylinders or disks, first reported by Cline and Hopper (1979). Such bulk pieces cannot be obtained by sinter-
Sample Heavy steel block
Explosionpropelled projectile Striker plate
Figure 2-9. Shock-amorphization device (schematic).
ing without inducing crystallization, whereas shock-wave treatment preserves the amorphous character of the material. Dynamic compaction of metallic glass powders and ultrasonic welding of ribbons is being developed in Japan (Makino, 1985). For more details, see Matsumoto (1986), Negishi et al. (1985), Toda et al. (1985), and Aoki et al. (1986). 2.4.3 Slow Mechanical Actions The effects of shearing under prolonged mechanical grinding of a crystal can progressively destroy the crystalline order and lead to the formation of a non-crystalline solid. Mechanical alloying processes are used to prepare various metallic glasses (see also Ch. 9, Sec. 9.2.7 and Vol. 15, Ch. 5, Sec. 5.6.3). 2.4.4 Diffusion Effects Interdiffusion effects can be employed to produce non-crystalline materials. Using multilayers formed of superposed crystalline metallic thin films, Johnson et al. (1985) have examined the possibility of producing amorphous interlayers when pure metals characterized by a large negative heat of mixing are brought into contact under suitable kinetic conditions. The couples investigated were Au-La, Zr-Ni and Hf-Ni. Amorphous alloys can also be obtained from intermetallic compounds by hydrogen absorption. Yeh et al. (1983) found this
102
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
phenomenon for metastable Zr 3 Rh and subsequently (Aoki et al., 1985, 1986) for SmNi2 and GdCo 2 Laves phases. The phenomenon is found in many Laves phases consisting of transition metals and rare earth metals such as CeFe 2 , CeCo 2 , CeNi 2 , YNi 2 , etc., even at room temperature under 5MPa hydrogen gas pressure (Masumoto, 1986). The subject of interdiffusion amorphization will be treated in greater detail in Chapter 9.
2.5 Electrochemical Methods Anodic Oxidation Amorphous oxide layers can be grown on the surface of a metal of semiconductor by making it the anode in an electrolytic cell in a variety of aqueous electrolytes (Fig. 2-10). Al, Zr, Nb, and especially Ta will oxidize when a current is passed through the cell under sufficient overvoltage, whereby a glass layer is formed with a thickness of up to several thousand angstroms (Young, 1961; Vermilyea, 1960). Amorphous silica films can be grown on Si substrate (Schmidt and Michel, 1957). Doped silica films have been obtained by Schmidt and Owen (1964) and Crosset and Dieumegard (1973). Anodic oxidation of
D.C. Power supply
GaAs (Hasegawa and O'Handley, 1979) and of InAs, InSb, GaP, and GaAsP (Schnable and Schmidt, 1976) have also been obtained. The technique, however, is not as widely used in the semiconductor industry as thermal oxidation.
2.6 Pyrolysis Pyrolysis is a method in which a suitable compound (the precursor) is subjected to controlled thermal decomposition, the residue being the product to be synthesized. Pyrolysis of organometallic precursors is an established way of producing advanced ceramics, namely polycrystalline SiC and Si 3 N 4 . As far as non-crystalline materials are concerned, pyrolysis is used in the synthesis of glass-like carbons. These were first obtained by pyrolysis of cellulose and then of thermosetting resins. Phenol-aldehyde resins were the starting materials for "vitreous carbon" (Cowlard and Lewis, 1967). "Glassy carbon" was obtained from furfuryl-alcohol resin (Yamada and Sato, 1962) and "vitro-carbon" from acetonefurfural resin. Carbon fibers were manufactured by pyrolyzing spinned phenol resin fibers (Kawamura and Jenkins, 1970). The details of these processes will be discussed in Chapter 10 of this Volume which also contains references to numerous patents.
2.7 Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses Cathode
Sample to be oxidized - (Anode)
Electrolyte Figure 2-10. Anodization cell (schematic).
In polymer technology non-crystalline or partly crystalline materials ("plastics") are currently obtained in a direct way using methods of organic chemistry. This important theme is the subject of Volume 18, "Processing of Polymers".
103
2.7 Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses
There exists, however, a large array set of methods in which inorganic glasses may be synthesized using methods of solution chemistry. Sol-gel processes belong to this last group of syntheses: they are based on the possibility of forming the disordered network of the glass, not directly at high temperatures from a melt, but at low temperatures from suitable compounds by chemical polymerization in a liquid phase. In this way a gel is first formed from which glass may be obtained both by the successive elimination of the interstitial liquid and by the collapse of the resulting solid residue by sintering. This "precursor-based" synthesis of glasses, ceramics, and composites is currently one of the most rapidly progressing fields of materials science and engineering. The "sol-gel" method of preparing glasses is being actively studied in leading laboratories all over the world, and in the last ten years, the number of scientific publications in this field has shown an exponential increase. Current research work in this field is to be found in the Proceedings of the International Workshops on Gels: Gottardi (1982), Scholze (1984), Zarzycki (1986), Sakka (1988), Aegerter (1990); the International Conferences on Ultrastructure Processing: Hench and Ulrich (1984, 1986), Mackenzie and Ulrich (1988), Uhlmann and Ulrich (1990); as well as in the series of symposia "Better Ceramics through Chemistry": Brinker et al. (1964, 1986, 1988). For general reviews, see Sakka (1982), Zarzycki (1984), Rabinovich (1985). The recent books by Klein (1988), Aegerter et al. (1989), and Brinker and Scherer (1990) present different aspects of sol-gel technology. The excellent treatise of Her (1979) should be consulted for details on silica sols and gels.
2,7.1 Methods of Gel Formation The main steps of sol-gel processing are summarized in Fig. 2-11. The different variants developed depend on the way in which the initial gel is obtained and on the forming process. As silica is the essential ingredient of most of the glasses prepared by sol-gel methods, our description will be centered on silica-based gels. There are three ways of obtaining them: (1) Hydrolysis and polycondensation of organo-metallic compounds (alkoxides) dissolved in alcohols in the presence of a limited amount of water. (2) Destabilization of silica sols (e.g., Ludox ®), pure of containing other metal ions added in the form of aqueous solutions of salts. (3) Redispersion of fine dry silica particles in a suitable liquid medium by mechanical (shearing) action to form a sol which gels spontaneously. 2.7.1.1 Gel Formation from Alkoxides Metal alcoholates, also known as metal alkoxides M(OR) n , where M is a metal (e.g., Si) and R an alkyl group (e.g., CH 3 or C 2 H 5 ), react with water and undergo hydrolysis and polycondensation reactions which lead to the progressive formation of a metal oxide. The overall reaction scheme consists of at least two main steps: (2-2) 3 (2-3)
The resulting metal oxide is produced in the form of extremely small particles ( « 2 nm) which may link to form a gel. In reality, the situation is more complex; the reactions (Eqs. (2-2) and (2-3)) proceed simultaneously and are generally incomplete. Hydrolysis may be achieved using a smaller quantity of water than that required by stoichiometry, and a number of radicals R remain unreacted. Polyconden-
104
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials Liquid ingredients
Mixing Reacting
Figure 2-11. Principle of sol-gel processing (from Zarzycki, 1987 a).
sation is incomplete and the final product corresponds rather to the formula (MOyOH),(OR) z
(2-4)
In cases where several different compounds (e.g., M(OR)n, M'(OR)J are reacted, a complexation step may precede reactions Eqs. (2-2) and (2-3). In this way complex networks involving several different cations, (e.g., M, M') may be produced: -M-O-M-O-M-
Bradley et al. (1978) and Andrianov (1955). Since alcoholates and water are immiscible, the reagents are dissolved in alcohol, generally methyl- or ethylalcohol. The use of a common solvent can be avoided, however, by subjecting the alcoholate-water Table 2-1. Alkoxides used in gel synthesis. M
M(OR)n
Si
Si(OCH3)4 Si(OC 2 H 5 ) 4 Al(O-iso C 3 H 7 ) 3 Al(O-sec C 4 H 9 ) 3 Ti(O-C 2 H 5 ) 4 Ti(O-isoC 3 H 7 ) 4 Ti(O-C 4 H 9 ) 4 Ti(O-C 5 H 7 ) 4 B(OCH 3 ) 3 Ge(O-C 2 H 5 ) 4 Zr(O-iso C 3 H 7 ) 4 Zr(O-C 4 H 9 ) 4 Y(O-C 2 H 5 ) 3 Ca(O-C 2 H 5 ) 2
(2-5)
The use of alkoxides of Si, B, Ti, Zr, etc., leads to the formation of complex gels composed of small particles which prefigure the network of corresponding oxide glasses. Table 2-1 gives a list of organometallic compounds most frequently used in the synthesis of glasses by this method. For details on the synthesis of alkoxides and chemistry involving these compounds see
Al Ti
B Ge Zr Y Ca
2.7 Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses
mixture to ultrasound (Tarasevich, 1984). The "sonogels" obtained in this way are more dense due to the absence of the solvent, and their structural properties are different from those of "classical" gels (Zarzycki, 1991). The water necessary for hydrolysis can be taken from the atmosphere (as in the case of thin coatings) or more generally added to the solution in a controlled amount. Other cations may also be introduced in the form of alcoholic or aqueous solutions of salts (nitrates, acetates, etc.). A carefully controlled amount of a catalyst, either an acid (hydrochloric, nitric, or acetic acid) or a base (ammonia, amines, etc.), is added. The gelling time depends on the pH, the temperature, the amount of water, and the nature of the catalyst. The structure of the gel depends very much on the nature of the catalyst used: acid catalysis leads to filamentous structures with a low degree of reticulation of the - M - O - M - chains, while basic catalysis produces more compact spheroidal particles with a higher internal degree of reticulation. 2.7.1.2 Gel Formation from Sols Most colloidal solutions of silica (silica sols) are either prepared by chemical condensation methods, acidifying solutions of Na silicates, K silicates, and NH 4 silicates, or made from hydrolyzable products such as SiCl4 or Si(OR)4, where R is an alkyl group. The formation of silicic acid in aqueous solutions is followed by polymerization of monomers Si(OH)4 when its concentration exceeds 100 ppm, which is the limiting solubility in water at 25 °C. The polymerization reaction is based on the condensation of silanol groups with the elimination of water. (2-6) -Si-OH + H O - S i - -> - S i - O - S i - + H 2 O
105
Amorphous spheroidal groupings of about 1 to 2 nm are formed by a nucleation process similar to what occurs in the formation of crystalline precipitates. At low pH values, particle growth stops once the size of 2-4 nm is reached. Above pH 7, particle growth continues at room temperature until particles of about 5 10 nm in diameter are formed, and then it slows down. At higher temperatures particles are negatively charged, and they repel each other. Growth continues without aggregation, resulting in the formation of stable sols. Commercial silica hydrosols (e.g., Ludox®, Nalcoag®, Nyalcol ®, Snowtex®) are stable sols with 20-50 wt.% SiO2. They are made up of dense silica particles with an average diameter of between 7 and 21 nm. The pH is between 9 and 11. To obtain a gel from a stable sol, the sol must be destabilized either by a temperature increase or by the addition of an electrolyte. An increase in temperature reduces the amount of intermicellar liquid by evaporation and increases thermal agitation, which in turn induces collisions between particles and their linking in chains by condensation of surface hydroxyls. The sol-gel transition should be distinguished from a precipitation or flocculation mechanism. In the latter mechanisms separate aggregates are formed, whereas a gelling involves a continuous three-dimensional particle network that invades the total volume of the sol (Fig. 2-12). By electrolyte addition the pH of the sol may be modified in order to reduce the electric repulsion between the particles (depending on the zeta potential). This is accomplished by adding an acid to diminish the pH to 5-6 to induce gel formation by aggregation. This conversion of sol into gel is progressive, the growing aggregates (microgel) gradually invading the whole vol-
106
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
temperature, the gelling time may vary from minutes to months. Sol
2.7.1.3 Redispersion Methods
Figure 2-12. Difference between gelling and precipitation of a sol (schematic).
ume originally occupied by the sol. When about half of the silica has entered the gel phase, a rapid increase in viscosity is noted (Fig. 2-13). The mechanism of interparticle bonding leading to microgels and gels involves the attachment of two neighboring silica particles via the formation of Si-O-Si bonds (Eq. (2-6)). Colloidal particles will form gels only if there are no active forces which would promote coagulation into aggregates with a higher silica concentration than the original sol. Metal cations, especially the polyvalent ones, may lead to precipitation rather than gelling: This is encountered with some multicomponent gels. In that case at least one gelling constituent (generally silica sol) is required. Other constituents may be added in the form of soluble salts (nitrates, sulfates, etc.) or organometallic compounds. By adjusting the temperature, concentration, and especially the pH of the resulting sol, a homogeneous solution is obtained which may then be gelled in a controlled way in order to avoid precipitation. According to the composition, pH, and
Fine dry silica particles such as the commercial "fumed silica" Cab-O-Sil®, or Aerosil® obtained by flame oxidation of SiCl4, can be mechanically redispersed in water using a shear blender. At pH 2-7, a sol is formed which will gel in a few hours. SiO2 particles form agglomerates which are linked by hydrogen bonds. SiO2 dispersions in organic liquids such as chloroform or n-decanol were also prepared; they can be readily gelled by the action of amines or ammonia vapor. Not only pure silica but also SiO 2 -GeO 2 particles, obtained by the method of flame oxidation for mixtures of gaseous SiCl4, TiCl 4 , GeCl 4 , were successfully gelled (Rabinovich, 1985).
J
2
i
-
o"
4> D
o
(S)
A
o
o
Q_
1 -
c* A
TO
Aoo
o
a
0
-
D
A
Q
D
a
° A A*o
A
O
_
A
A
-1
I
0.90 T/Tfgel
1.00
Figure 2-13. Evolution of viscosity of various TMOSalcohol-water mixtures approaching the gelling point as a function of the reduced time T/Tgel (from Mizuno et al., 1985).
2.7 Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses
107
2.7.2 Aging Effects
The freshly prepared "wet" gel consists of a network of particles holding an interstitial liquid - the solvent trapped during the gelling step is water in the case of hydrogels and mixtures of alcohols and water for the alcogels. The interstitial liquid still contains unreacted sol particles, which progressively attach themselves to the network. Furthermore, there is a transport of SiO2 from convex to concave parts due to solubility effects which smooth the inequalities between linked particles and convert the chains into filaments (Fig. 2-14). Additional deposition of SiO2 from solution may further "nourish" and thus stiffen the chains (Fig. 2-15). The syneresis effect then sets in, whereby the network slowly contracts and tends to progressively expel the interstitial liquid in order to reduce the internal interface. With time all these effects bring about a gradual increase in the Young's modulus, E, of the wet gel (Fig. 2-16); the gel stiffens progressively, even if evaporation of the interstitial liquid is prevented. Freshly gelled wet silica gel is an extremely fragile material, which behaves as a brittle solid with conchoidal fracture. Gels prepared from Si alkoxides are predominantly elastic while those from colloidal solutions (Ludox®) show partly visco-elastic or viscoplastic properties. Fig. 2-17 shows the critical stress concentration coefficient Klc of some SiO2 gels, and Fig. 2-18 the corresponding fracture surface energy.
Neck formation
Figure 2-14. Strengthening of particle chains by deposition of silica at the necks due to differential solubility effect (from Zarzycki et al, 1982).
Secondary deposition
Figure 2-15. Strengthening of chains during aging by secondary deposition of silica (from Zarzycki et al., 1982).
106
105
u
L
Days
H
Figure 2-16. Evolution of Young's modulus, E, as a function of time for a Ludox gel (v: Poisson's number) (from Zarzycki, 1988).
300 200 100
2.7.3 Drying
The drying stage is necessary to free the solid network of the gel from the accompanying interstitial liquid phase.
0
1
2
3 Days
A
5
Figure 2-17. Evolution of critical stress intensity factor K1C as a function of time for a Ludox gel (from Zarzycki, 1988).
108
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
0.1
T(Nm"
-0.05
0
1
2
3 Days
A
5
6
Figure 2-18. Evolution of the fracture surface energy as a function of time for a Ludox gel (from Zarzycki, 1988).
uid-air interface and inversely proportional to the radius r of the pore; 6 is the contact angle at the liquid-solid-air boundary line. Considerable stresses may be generated in this way: Ap = 7.3 xlO 7 Nm " 2 for a pore radius r = 2 nm filled with water, assuming perfect wetting (Fig. 2-19). Differential stresses due to adjacent pores then induce breaking if the tensile strength is exceeded. A detailed treatment of drying, comprising the analysis of stress redistribution due to interstitial liquid transfers was recently proposed by Scherer (1988).
2.7.3.1 The Role of Capillary Forces
Elimination of the liquid phase leads to dry gels, namely xerogels. When a "wet" gel is dried, the following sequence of events is generally observed on a macroscopic scale: • progressive shrinkage and hardening • stress-development • fragmentation The chief difficulty is encountered in the preparation of bulk glass, where specimens of gel without any cracks are required. This problem, occurring in monolithic gels, was recently the object of intensive research. Cracking during the drying stage is the result of non-uniform shrinkage of the drying body, a well-known phenomenon in ceramic technology. The stresses arise not only from the local differences in expansion coefficients due to variable water content but primarily from the action of capillary forces which become operative when the pores start to empty and a liquid-air interface is present in the form of menisci distributed in the pores of the drying gel. The magnitude of these forces is given by Laplace's formula: Ap = (2y cos9)/r
(2-7)
The change in pressure Zip is proportional to the specific surface energy y of the liq-
2.7.3.2 Obtaining Monolithic Gels
In practice, a very long drying time is necessary to preserve "monolithicity". This may reach hundreds of hours even for small specimens with surface areas of a few square centimeters. Much effort has therefore been spent to find more economical ways of drying gels and still preserving their integrity. All actions which tend to minimize the capillary stress and increase the mechanical resistance of the network should enhance the probability of keeping the gel
108r
Q_
a o
10£
10°
101 Pore radius in nm
102
Figure 2-19. Capillary pressure Ap in a drying gel as a function of pore-radius when the interstitial liquid is (a) water (b) alcohol (after Zarzycki et al., 1982).
2.7 Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses
monolithic. The following measures are possible: • Strengthening the gel by reinforcement (aging) • Enlarging the pores • Tending toward monodispersity of the pores • Reducing the surface tension of the liquid • Making the surface hydrophobic • Evacuating the solvent by freeze-drying • Operating in hypercritical conditions where the liquid-vapor interface vanishes The last two methods are the most efficient ways of eliminating the destructive action of the surface tension of the liquid suppressing the liquid-vapor interface. Hypercritical solvent evacuation (HSE) consists in treating the gel in an autoclave in hypercritical conditions for the solvent. It is directly applicable to alcogels produced from alkoxides. Hydrogels cannot be directly treated in this way as under hypercritical conditions for water, silica is solubilized. This has prompted the importance of the alkoxide method. Redispersion methods, on the other hand, permit the obtention of wet gels with large pores by a double redispersion treatment. These pores facilitate solvent evacuation without the danger of cracking in the gels (Rabinovitch, 1985). The HSE process is schematized in Fig. 2-20, which shows the equilibrium curve between the liquid and the gas phase of the solvent. In order to ensure the continuity of the liquid-gas transition, the path of the thermal treatment must not cross the equilibrium curve. To circumvent the critical point C, a path such as a, b, d, e may theoretically be used. In practice this path is modified in the following way: the open container which contains the gel is placed inside an autoclave, and to obtain hypercritical conditions, a given quantity of solvent (e.g.,
109
Temperature Figure 2-20. Principle of hypercritical solvent evacuation (from Zarzycki, 1984).
methanol) is added to the autoclave. The autoclave is then closed and electrically heated. When the critical temperature of methanol is exceeded, slow decompression followed by successive flushings with dry argon eliminate the last traces of alcohol. The autoclave is then cooled down and the gel removed at ambient temperature (path a,d,e). The gel, which contains air-filled pores, is termed aerogel A number of experiments has shown that monolithicity depends on many variables: • the speed of heating • the proportion of the additional solvent • the concentrations of organometallic compounds and • the water of hydrolysis • the geometry of the sample and its size • the previous aging of the gel Monolithic samples can be obtained with 100% certainty when these variables are optimized (Zarzycki, 1982). The aerogels are hydrophobic due to partial surface esterification and contain an appreciable percentage of adsorbed organic radicals. Their mechanical resistance, however, is sufficient for these radicals to be eliminated by subsequent
110
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
thermal treatment without loss of monolithicity, and they can finally be converted into a clear glass of excellent optical quality. Aerogels can be made with an exceedingly high porosity (close to 99%) and a pore size of a few nanometers, which makes them excellent thermal insulators. For silica aerogels thermal conductivity of the order of 0.01 W m " 1 K " 1 has been demonstrated. Their refraction index may be close to 1, and they can be made translucent hence their application in Cerenkov radiation detectors. (For these and other applications, see Fricke, 1986.) Another method consists in adding a suitable substance to the sol before gelling that will influence the subsequent behavior of the sol during drying. The most successful of these drying control chemical additives (DCCA) is formamide (Hench, 1986). Its effect seems to be a tendency toward the formation of gels with smaller but more uniform pores which favor drying in monolithic form. 2.7.3.3 Structural Aspects
The gelling process, the structure of the resulting wet gels, and that of the xero- and aerogels have been the object of numerous studies on various systems, the detailed description of which is outside the scope of the present article. The use of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) combined with spectroscopic methods (IR, Raman, NMR) and electron microscopy has permitted the various aggregation theories to be tested, and the results of these methods have led to structural models. Gelling may be explained either using Flory's theory, familiar in polymer chemistry, or by percolation theories, which are more in favor with the physicists. The structure of growing aggregates and of the
resulting gels may be described using fractal concepts (Mandelbrot, 1983). A fractal cluster has a structure which becomes increasingly wispy as its dimensions increase. In particular, its mass scales as r D , where r is the radius of the cluster, and D the "fractal dimension" which is smaller than three. The fractal dimension D may be obtained by a variety of methods. See, for example, Zarzycki (1987 b) for a synthetic presentation. 2.7.4 Curing-Sintering
The final structure of the dry gel will depend on the structure of the wet gel originally formed in solution; it is a contracted or a distorted version of the latter. The constituent particles are coated with residual OH groups which are partly eliminated during the transition from a particulate texture to a continuous solid. They may be detected and analyzed by conventional infrared spectroscopic techniques. To transform the particulate structure of a dried gel into continuous glass, the elementary particles must fuse together, resulting in progressive pore elimination. This is achieved by heating the gel in order to promote diffusion phenomena and viscous flow. During this heat-treatment the residual OH and OR groups will first tend to be eliminated in the form of H 2 O and ROH which is accompanied by an additional polymerization of the system: (2-8) - S i - O R + O H - S i - -> - S i - O - S i + ROH The escape of residual products from closed pores may constitute a problem; the organic residues are finally carbonized at a higher temperature which brings about a coloration of the gel and leaves carbonaceous particles in the glass. It is therefore important to favor the escape of residues
2.7 Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses
before complete closure of the pores, and oxidation treatments are often necessary to eliminate certain organic groups. For pure SiO2 gels this oxidation treatment is carried out at 300-400 °C. It is important to define the heating schedule in each particular case in order to eliminate the unwanted residues without impairing monolithicity before the onset of viscous flow. Occluded OH groups and H 2 O may cause bloating on heating at high temperatures - even if the specimen has remained monolithic up to this stage. Residual OH groups may be eliminated by chlorination treatments if very low OH levels are required in the final glass (e.g., for optical fibers applications). On the other hand, occluded water may be used in foaming processes, e.g., in blowing gel particles into microspheres (see Sec. 2.7.5.4). 2.7.4.1 Viscous Flow Sintering
Densification is essentially a sintering process by which the pores of a dry gel are eliminated, and the initially opaque material progressively converted into clear bulk glass. After elimination of residues, the driving force in this process is supplied by the surface energy of the porous gel. This tends to reduce the interface, thus eliminating the pores, the collapse being governed, in the case of glasses, by Newtonian viscous flow. Extra pressure, as in hot-pressing techniques, may be applied externally to speed up the process (Decottignies et al., 1978). The theoretica aspects of sintering are presented in Chapter 3 of this Volume.
111
tween phenomena which lead to densification and those which promote crystallization. The TTT (time-temperature-transformation) diagrams are a convenient way of studying the problem of devitrification versus compaction in order to define the appropriate thermal treatment (Zarzycki, 1982 b). The TTT diagrams show the time ty required to obtain a determined crystallized fraction y as a function of the temperature T. Treating y as a parameter, a set of Cy curves is obtained which represent the kinetic behavior of the system. In particular, if y0 corresponds to the smallest crystallized fraction detectable by analytical techniques, the curve Cyo represents a frontier not to be crossed during a thermaltreatment schedule if crystallization is to be avoided (generally y0 = 10 ~6 is adopted, see Chapter 3). The relative positions of the thermaltreatment path during densification and the Cyo curve of the gel determine the possibility of obtaining glassy or crystallized materials at the end of the compaction program. For example, (Fig. 2-21) if there is no danger of devitrification using path (a) for
2.7.4.2 Devitrification Kinetics Use of TTT Diagrams
During densification crystallize (devitrify) at successful conversion therefore depends on
the gel will tend to the same time. The of gel into glass a competition be-
Time Figure 2-21. Use of TTT diagrams for determining sintering heat treatment without crystallization (from Zarzycki, 1982 b. Reprinted by permission of the American Ceramic Society).
112
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
a gel corresponding to Cl9 this will no longer be true for the curve of C 2 , the same path would lead to crystallized material. The solution would then be either to shorten the sintering time, e. g., by applying a suitable external pressure (path (b)), or to increase the temperature for a short time using the technique of "flash-pressing" (path (c)). In the case of gels the position of the curves C strongly depends on the impurities of the material and, in the first instance, of water content which influences the viscosity, as well as the surface energy of the material. 2.7.5 Forming Processes In the classical process, the resulting melt is generally immediately formed into the desired end products: sheet glass, hollow ware, or fibers. In sol-gel technology the various forming operations have to occur before or during the gelling stage (e.g., molding an object, forming a thin coating, or spinning a fiber); the drying-curing and sintering stages simply consolidate the original shape produced at low temperatures (Fig. 2-11). The nature of the processes during gelling and subsequent drying, which are of a diffusional nature, favors, however, those configurations in which at least one of the dimensions is small: Thin films, fibers, and small particles (or shells) are current examples, and it is significant that the first established industrial applications of the sol-gel route were precisely in the field of thin coatings. 2.7.5.1 Bulk Glass It is possible to produce bulk pieces of glass if cracking of gels during drying is avoided. This problem of obtaining monolithic gels has been extensively studied in
recent years - hypercritical solvent evacuation and drying chemical control additives (DCCA) have proved effective against cracking. In the laboratory, pure SiO2 glasses, as well as those combining SiO2 with other oxides (e.g., B 2 O 3 , TiO 2 , GeO 2 , P 2 O 5 , ZrO 2 , etc.) were successfully prepared. Glasses containing oxides of alkali and alkaline-metals sometimes prove more difficult to obtain because of the tendency of gels to devitrify during the sintering stages. The difficulty linked with monolithicity can be avoided if hot-pressing techniques are used to compact gels in a granular form; this, however, limits the size of the specimens. In industrial practice the early attempt in 1970 by Owens-Illinois (USA) at commercializing bulk gel-made glass was discontinued because of the high cost. However, the manufacture of sizeable glass pieces of pure SiO2 for optical applications has been reported (Hench, 1986). Advanced glasses for optical-fiber preforms (SiO2 doped by GeO 2 , P 2 O 5 , or B 2 O 5 ) have been successfully made, but the corresponding industrial applications have not yet followed. 2.7.5.2 Thin Films At the present time, the main industrial applications recognized for sol-gel methods are in the production of thin glass coatings by Schott Glass (FRG). They use the alkoxide method to modify the spectral transmission of flat glass for architectural applications (Schroeder, 1969; Dislich, 1971, 1988). In the method of dip coating (Fig. 2-22), a sheet of glass is first immersed in a tank containing a dilute solution of suitable alkoxide precursors and then slowly withdrawn at a constant rate. This leaves a superficial film of equal thickness which is then reacted with water vapor from the
2.7 Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses
surrounding atmosphere to induce hydrolysis and polymerization. The glass is then dried and baked in an oven at ^500°C; successive layers of several hundred angstroms may be applied up to a total thickness of « 3000 A, Thicker films tend to craze or peel away. Other methods consist in applying an even initial liquid film by spinning (e.g., for optical components of circular shape) or spraying. Solar reflective TiO 2 coatings containing Pd or Au are manufactured by these methods. Antireflective coatings, contrast-enhancing coatings and protective coatings for optical surfaces against laser damage as well as electrically conductive layers have also been produced in this manner (Mukherjee and Lowdermilk, 1982; Dislich, 1988; Pettit et al., 1988). An interesting application of thicker solgel films of about one micron, which may be superficially patterned by pressing, is reported for the production of supports for recording disks for audio-visual purposes (Fig. 2-23), (Tohge et al, 1988).
7"~5OO°C
Glass sheet Film -=
H20 Vap. ROH Vap.
(a)
W////////////////M*--Gel
113
film
<=—Glass substrate
^-Stamper (b)
\
Electric furnace
(c)
////A Wn^BnfIIh7fIIhTfIJhTfIJhWI\<-Glass
(d)
film with fine pattern
Figure 2-23. Patterning process of gel coatings (from Tohge et al., 1988).
2.7.5.3 Fibers Continuous glass fibers may be produced by sol-gel methods. On approaching gelling point, the solution is drawn into a gel fiber, which is then converted into glass by heating. The composition of the starting solution must be carefully adjusted to render it spinnable. In general low water content for hydrolysis and an acid catalyst are thus required. The cross section of the fibers prepared in this way may not be circular. The process requires strict viscosity control. Pure SiO2 fibers as well as those of SiO 2 -Al 2 O 3 , SiO 2 -ZrO 2 , SiO 2 -ZrO 2 Na 2 O and SiC^-A^C^-I^C^ systems have been prepared (Sakka, 1988 b; Sowman, 1988; La Course, 1988). 2.7.5.4 Hollow Glass Microspheres
a b c Figure 2-22. Thin-film deposition by dip-coating process (schematic).
Hollow glass microspheres are used as fillers in plastic resins or paints and also in a more sophisticated version as targets for inertial confinement fusion (ICF) in ther-
114
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
monuclear fusion research. They are produced from gels which are first dried, then crushed and sieved. The resulting powder is subsequently fed into an electrical vertical drop tower furnace where the gel particles, falling freely, are blown and vitrified into spherical shells by residual gas contained in the gel. Shells of up to 1000 jim with uniform wall thickness of 0.4-20 Jim were produced for ICF experiments (Downs et al, 1988). 2.7.6 Advantages and Disadvantages of the Sol-Gel Process As the sintering operation is carried out at temperatures much lower than those required for the melting of glass-forming components - practically in the vicinity of the transition temperature - the process is particularly attractive for the production of those glasses which require high melting temperatures (e. g., SiO2 glass can be made at 1200 °C instead of at 2000 °C). The second important characteristic of the process is that final homogeneity is directly obtained in solution on a molecular scale. This can be compared to the difficulties of obtaining homogeneous glasses in the classical way, particularly when one of the components is more volatile or when the resulting melts possess a high viscosity which hinders efficient mixing of the constituents. In some cases it is then necessary to remelt the original batch several times to reach the necessary compositional uniformity. This in turn increases the likelihood of contamination from crucible walls, particularly at high temperatures, or during repeated crushing procedures. In the sol-gel route the wet gel may, in principle, be obtained with a degree of purity which depends only on the starting ingredients. The degree of purity of the final glass will depend on the sintering pro-
cess, which is performed at lower temperatures, and thereby reduces the risk of contamination. A substantially lower elaboration temperature, excellent homogeneity obtained directly, and a high degree of purity are the main advantages attributable to the sol-gel process. Is this enough to make the process competitive with the classical glass-melting practice? The lower elaboration temperature, from which energy saving might be expected, is largely offset by the high cost of the initial ingredients necessary for making the gel. In addition, organometallic precursors are not always available at present for the more exotic cations that might be required in some cases, and the initial formulation of the solution leading to a proper gel (without flocculation) can be a very difficult task indeed. The subsequent treatment of the gel, the drying-curing and sintering stages, are also more complicated and time-consuming in practice than the direct melting and fining involved in classical glass processing. Furthermore, they are specific to a given composition and the process has to be "tailored" for each new glass, which requires a complete preliminary study in each case. It seems therefore that the sol-gel process can only be competitive in areas of advanced technology (high-tech areas), and that neither window nor bottle glass will ever be made industrially in this way.
2.7.7 Future Trends
What really differentiates the sol-gel route from the classic igneous route is essentially the fact that an inorganic gel is a two-phase system where each of the two phases can be influenced separately by the preparative methods.
2.7 Solution Methods; "Sol-Gel" Processing of Glasses
In the classical method of obtaining glasses, the structural disorder is produced by progressive breakdown at high temperature of different crystalline components, and the resulting melt is a collection of more or less polymerized anions and fractions of chains with interdispersed accompanying cations. For a given melt the distribution of these entities depends essentially on the equilibrium conditions in the melt, i.e., on the temperature and atmosphere of the furnace which controls the oxidation-reduction changes. This hightemperature situation is preserved during quench, and the polyanionic distribution reflects the equilibrium conditions in the melt. Apart from systems which undergo phase separation (either in the liquid or sub-liquidus), the quenched melt is a onephase system with frozen-in local compositional fluctuations. The equilibrium conditions cannot be influenced to a great extent except by initial compositional changes. On the other hand, if we consider the processes which lead to the constitution of a gel, the various steps by which the disor-
115
dered network is built up are essentially chemical polymerization, polycondensation, cross-linking, etc., processes familiar in polymer chemistry. In this way elementary particles, filaments, etc., are produced which progressively link up to produce first a colloidal solution - a sol - and then a gel, when these elements unite into a reticulated network spanning the volume offered. A gel is essentially a system constituted of two phases: a solid backbone immersed in an interstitial liquid. The two phases are intimately mixed on a very fine scale. It is possible to change the nature of this second phase by various operations (Fig. 2-24). In the drying process the liquid was simply replaced by a gas-solvent vapor and air leading to aerogels. Using exchange processes, one liquid may be substituted for another; e.g., water may be replaced by alcohol to enable hypercritical treatment of aquagels. Foreign reactants may be diffused into gels via the interstitial liquid whereby chemical reactions, precipitation, etc., may be produced
Interstitial liquid Backbone
Solvent exchange ^
Hypercritical drying Aerogel
Reaction
-Sintering •
— Drying Dry gel
Figure 2-24. Examples of exchange methods combined with sol-gel processing to obtain composite materials (from Zarzycki, 1987 a).
116
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
within the second phase or also within the backbone if this is done during gel formation. Infiltration of foreign substances into dry gels permits the air pockets (pores) to be filled, e.g., by colored or index matching substances. In this way a whole range of glass composites may be obtained on a very fine scale, depending on the backbone configuration. The range of the scale may descend to a few nanometers, hence the name nanocornposites, which was proposed for this class of materials (Roy et al., 1984, 1986). For example, gels containing suitable dyes may be prepared for advanced nonlinear optical applications. On the other hand, the preparation of gels with a complex backbone combining inorganic and organic systems, opens up new and unlimited possibilities of synthesis of hybrid amorphous materials, which are intermediate between pure inorganic glasses and organic polymers. This is the field of "organically modified silicates" (Ormosils), which has barely begun to be explored (Schmidt, 1985). Attempts to apply the sol-gel techniques to obtain chalcogenide glasses are reported where the inherent heterogeneity of meltobtained glasses could be improved, or new systems produced. Halide gels are also being investigated initially and thus completely new sol-gel systems are likely to be explored in the near future.
2.8 References Aegerter, M.A. (Ed.) (1990), 5 th Intern. Workshop "Glasses and Ceramics from Gels" Rio de Janeiro, 1989. J. Non-Cryst. Sol. 121, 1-492. Aegerter, M. A., Jafelici, Jr. M., Souza, D.F., Zanotto, E. D. (Eds.) (1989), Sol-gel Science and Technology. Singapore: World Scientific, pp. 1-505. Amick, J. A., Schnable, G.L., Vossen, XL. (1977), /. Vac. Sci. Technol. 14, 1053-1063.
Anantharaman, T. R., Suryanarayana, C. (1971), J. Mater. Sci. 6, 1111-1135. Andrianov, K. A. (1955), Organic Silicon Compounds, Moscow: State Scientific Publishing House for Chemical Literature; Translation 59-11239: Washington D.C., U.S.A.: U.S. Dept. of Commerce. Aoki, K., Shirakawa, K., Masumoto, T. (1985), Sci. Rep. Ritu A-32, 239. Aoki, K., Yamamoto, T., Masumoto, T. (1986), Sci. Rep. Ritu A-33, 163. Aoki, K., Toda, Y, Fukamishi, K., Masumoto, T. (1986), Sci. Rep. Ritu A-33, 149. Bletry, I (1973), J. Phys. D 6, 256-275. Bradley, D.C., Mehrotra, R.C., Gaur, D.P. (1978), Metal Alkoxides. New York: Academic Press. Brinker, C.J., Scherer, G.W. (1990), Sol-Gel Science. San Diego: Academic Press. Brinker, C.J., Clark, D.E., Ulrich, D. R. (Eds.) (1984), Better Ceramics Through Chemistry, Vol. 32. Amsterdam: North Holland. Brinker, C. I, Clark, D.E., Ulrich, D. R. (Eds.) (1986), Better Ceramics Through Chemistry II, Vol. 73. Pittsburgh: MRS. Brinker, C. I, Clark, D. E., Ulrich, D. R. (1988), Better Ceramics Through Chemistry III. Pittsburgh: MRS. Chao, E. C.T (1967), Science 156, 192-202. Chen, H. S., Miller, C. E. (1970), Rev. Sci. Instrum. 41, 1237. Chen, H. S., Miller, C. E. (1976), Mat. Res. Bull. 11, 49-54. Cline, C.F., Hopper, R. (1979), Scripta Metall. 11, 1137. Cowlard, F. C , Lewis, J.C. (1967), /. Mater. Sci. 2, 507. Crosset, M., Dieumegard, D. (1973), J. Electrochem. Soc. 120, 526. Dalton, R.H., Nordberg, M. E. (1941), U.S. Patent 2239551, April 21. Datta, R.K., Roy, D. M., Faile, S.P., Tuttle, O.F. (1964), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 47, 153. DeCarli, P. S., Jamieson, D.C. (1959), J. Chem. Phys. 31, 1675-1676. Decottignies, M., Phalippou, I, Zarzycki, J. (1978), /. Mater. Sci. 13, 2605-2618. Dislich, H. (1971), Glastechn. Ber. 44, 1-8. Dislich, H. (1988), "Thin Films from the Sol-Gel Process", in: Sol-gel Technology for Thin Films, Fibers, Preforms, Electronics and Specialty Shapes: Klein, L. C. (Ed.). New Jersey: Noyes Publ., pp. 50-79. Downs, R.L., Ebner, M. A., Miller, W.J. (1988), "Hollow Glass Microspheres by Sol-Gel Technology", in: Sol-Gel Technology for Thin Films, Fibers, Preforms, Electronics and Specialty Shapes: Klein, L. C. (Ed.). New Jersey: Noyes Publ., pp. 330-381. Duwez, P., Willens, R. H., Klement, W. Jr. (1960), /. AppL Phys. 31, 1136-1173. Elliott, S. R. (1990), Physics of Amorphous Materials, 2nd. ed. Harlow: Longman. Fricke, J. (Ed.) (1986), Aerogels, Berlin: Springer.
2.8 References
Gibbons, R. V., Ahrens, I J. (1971), J. Geophys. Res. 76, 5489-5498. Gottardi, V. (Ed.) (1982), "1st Intern. Workshop Glasses and Glass-Ceramics from Gels, Padova 1981", J. Non-Cryst. Sol. 48, 1-230. Hasegawa, R., O'Handley, R.C. (1979), J. Appl. Phys.50, 1551-1556. Hench, L. L. (1986), "Use of Drying Control Chemical Additives (DCCAs) in Controlling Sol-Gel Processing", in: Science of Ceramic Chemical Processing: Hench, L. L., Ulrich, D. R. (Eds.). New York: Wiley, pp. 52-64. Hench, L. L., Ulrich, D. G. (Eds.) (1984), Ultrastructure Processing of Ceramics, Glasses and Composites. New York: Wiley, pp. 1-564. Hench, L. L., Ulrich, D. G. (Eds.) (1986), Science of Ceramic Chemical Processing. New York: Wiley, pp. 1-593. Holland, J. (1956), Vacuum Deposition of Thin Films. New York: Wiley. Her, R. K. (1979). The Chemistry of Silica. New York: Wiley, pp. 1-866. Johnson, W.L., Dolgin, B., Van Rossum, M. (1985), in: Glass-Current Issues. Wright, A. R, Dupuy, J. (Eds.). Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff Publ., pp. 172-187. Jones, H. (1972), J. Sheffield Univ. Metall. Soc. 11, 50-57. Jones, H., Suryanarayana, C. (1973), J. Mater. Sci. 8, 705-753. Kawamura, K., Jenkins, G.M. (1970), J. Mater. Sci. 5, 262. Kern, W, Rosier, R. S. (1977), J. Vac. Sci. Technol. 14, 1082. Klein, L. C. (Ed.) (1988), Sol-Gel Technology for Thin Films, Fibers, Preforms, Electronics and Specialty Shapes. New Yersey: Noyes Publ., pp. 1-407. Krepski, R., Swyler, K., Carleton, H. R., Herman, H. (1975), J. Mater. Sci. 10, 1452-1454. La Course, WC. (1988), "Continuous Filament Fibers by the Sol-Gel Process", in: Sol-Gel Technology for Thin Films, Fibers, Preforms, Electronics and Specialty Shapes: Klein, L. C. (Ed.). New Jersey: Noyes Publ., pp. 184-189. Mackenzie, J.D., Ulrich, D.G. (Eds.) (1988), Ultrastructure Processing of Advanced Ceramics. New York: Wiley, pp. 1-1014. Makino, Y. (1985), in: Current Topics on Non-Crystalline Solids: Baro, M.D., Clavaguera, N. (Eds.). Singapore: World Scientific, pp. 87-100. Mandelbrot, B. B. (1983). The Fractal Geometry of Nature. New York: Freeman. Masumoto, T. (1986), in: Current Topics on NonCrystalline Solids: Baro, M.D., Clavaguera, N. (Eds.). Singapore: World Scientific, pp. 73-86. Milton, D. X, De Carli, P. S. (1963), Science 140, 670671. Mizuno, T., Phalippou, X, Zarzycki, X (1985), Glass Technology 26, 39-45.
117
Mukherjee, S.P., Lowdermilk, WH. (1982), J. NonCryst. Sol. 48, 177-184; Appl. Opt. 21, 293-296. Negishi, T., Ogura, X, Ishii, H., Masumoto, T., Goto, T., Fukuoka, K., Syono, Y. (1985), J. Mater. Sci. 20, 399-406. Nordberg, M.E. (1943), U.S. patent 2326059, August 3. Pettit, R.B., Ashley, C. S., Reed, S.T., Brinker, C.X (1988), "Antireflective Films from the Sol-Gel Process", in: Sol-Gel Technology for Thin Films, Fibers, Preforms, Electronics and Specialty Shapes. Klein, L. C. (Ed.), New Jersey: Noyes Publ., pp. 80-110. Pietrokowsky, P. (1963), Rev. Sci. Instr. 34, 445. Pliskin, W. A. (1977), /. Vac. Sci. Technol. 14, 10641081. Pliskin, W A., Kerr, D. R., Perri, J. A. (1967), Phys. Thin Films 4, 257-324. Primak, W. (1958), Phys. Rev. 110, 1240-1254. Primak, W, Bohmann, M. (1962), Prog. Ceram. Sci. 2, 103-177. Pye, L.D., O'Keefe, J.A., Frechette, V.D. (Eds.) (1984), "Natural Glasses, Proc. Intern. Conf. on Glass in Planetary and Geological Phenomena". New York: Alfred (1983); J. Non-Cryst. Sol. 67, 1-662. Rabinovich, E. M. (1985), /. Mater. Sci. 20, 42594297. Roy, D. M., Faile, S. P., Tuttle, O. F. (1964), Am. Ceram. Soc. Bull. 43, 291 (Abstract only). Roy, R., Suwa, Y, Komarneni, S. (1986), in: Science of Ceramic Chemical Processing: Hench, L. L., Ulrich, D. R. (Eds.). New York: Wiley, pp. 247258. Roy, R., Komarneni, S., Roy, D.M. (1984), "Multiphasic Ceramic Composites Made by Sol-Gel Technique", in: Better Ceramics Through Chemistry, Vol.32: Brinker, C.X, Clark, D. E., Ulrich, D.R. (Eds.). Mat. Res. Soc, p. 347. Ruhl, R.C. (1967), Mat. Sci. Eng. 1, 313-320. Sakka, S. (1982), pp. 129-169, in: Treatise on Materials Science and Technology, Vol. 22. Tomozawa, M., Doremus, R. H. (Eds.). New York: Academic Press. Sakka, S. (Ed.) (1988 b), "4th Intern. Workshop Glasses and Glass-Ceramics from Gels, Kyoto, 1987", /. Non-Cryst. Sol. 100, 1-554. Sakka, S. (1988), "Fibers from the Sol-Gel Process", in: Sol-Gel Technology for Thin Films, Fibers, Preforms, Electronics and Specialty Shapes: Klein, L. C. (Ed.). New Jersey: Noyes PubL, pp. 140-161. Scherer, G. W. (1988), "Theory of Drying Gels", in: Ultrastructure Processing of Advanced Ceramics: Mackenzie, X D., Ulrich, D. R. (Eds.). New York: Wiley, pp. 295-302. Scherer, G. W, Schultz, P. C. (1983), in: Glass Science and Technology, Vol. 1: Uhlmann, D.R., Kreidl, N.X (Eds.). New York: Academic Press, pp. 4 9 103. Schmidt, H. (1985), /. Non-Cryst. Sol. 73, 681.
118
2 Special Methods of Obtaining Glasses and Amorphous Materials
Schmidt, P. R, Michel, W. (1957), J. Electrochem. Soc. 104, 230. Schmidt, P.F., Owen, A. E. (1964), J. Electrochem. Soc. Ill, 682. Schnable, G. L., Schmidt, P. F. (1976), J. Electrochem. Soc. 123, 310 C. Scholze, H. (Ed.) (1984), "2nd Intern. Workshop Glasses and Glass-Ceramics from Gels, Wiirzburg, 1983", /. Non-Cryst. Sol. 63, 1-300. Schott, Jenaer Glaswerk (1968), French Patent 1537617. Schroeder, H. (1969), Physics of Thin Films 5, 87142. Schultz, P.C. (1975), U.S. Patent 3 859073, January 7. Secrist, D. R., Mackenzie, I D . (1964), in: Modern Aspect of the Vitreous State, Vol. 3: Mackenzie, I D . (Ed.). London: Butterworths, p. 149-165. Sowman, H. G. (1988). "Alumina Boria-Silica Ceramic Fibers from the Sol-Gel Process", in: Sol-Gel Technology for Thin Films, Fibers, Preforms, Electronics and Specialty Shapes. Klein, L. C. (Ed.), New York: Noyes PubL, pp. 162-183. Stoffler, D. (1972), Fortschr. Mineral. 49, 50-113. Stoffler, D. (1974), Fortschr. Mineral. 51, 256-289. Suzuki, T., Anthony, A. (1974), Mat. Res. Bull. 9, 745-754. Tamman, G. (1933), Der Glaszustand. Leipzig: Voss. Tarasevich, M. (1984), Am. Ceram. Bull. 63, 500 (abstract only). Toda, Y, Ogura, T., Masumoto, T., Fukuoka, F., Syono, Y (1985), in: Proc. Intern. Conf. of Rapidly Quenched Metals V: Steeb, S., Warlimont, H. (Eds.). New York: Elsevier, p. 1755. Tohge, N., Matsuda, A., Minami, T., Matsuno, Y, Katayama, S., Ikeda, Y (1988), / Non-Cryst. Sol. 100, 501-505. Topol, L. E., Hengsteinberg, D. H., Blander, M., Happe, R.A., Richardson, N.L., Nelson, L. S. (1973), /. Non-Cryst. Sol. 12, 377-390. Townsend, P.D., Kelly, J.C., Hartley, N.E.W. (1976), "Ion Implantation, Sputtering and Their Applications". New York: Academic Press. Uhlmann, D. R., Ulrich, D.G. (Eds.) (1990), Ultrastructure Processing of Ceramics, New York: Wiley. United Technologies Research Center (1976), in: Machine Design, April 18, 6; Optical Spectra, April, 22. Veltri, R.D., Breinan, E.M., McCarthy, G.P., Galasso, F. S. (1979), /. Mater. Sci. 14, 3000-3002. Vermilyea, D.A. (1960), in: Non-Crystalline Solids: Frechette, V.D. (Ed.). New York: Wiley, p. 328347. Wackerle, J. (1962). J. Appl. Phys. 33, 922-937. Wullaert, R.A. (1964), in: Effects of Radiation on Materials and Components. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, pp. 277-402.
Yamada, S., Sato, H. (1962), Nature 193, 261. Yeh, X. L., Samwer, K., Johnson, W. L. (1983), Appl. Phys. Lett. 42, 242. Young, L. (1961), Anodic Oxide Films. New York: Academic Press. Zarzycki, J. (1982 a), Les Verres et VEtat Vitreux. Paris: Masson. Zarzycki, J. (1982 b), "Nucleation in Glasses from Gels", in: Advances in Ceramics 4, 204. Columbus: Amer. Cer. Soc. Zarzycki, J. (1984), "Processing of Gel Glasses", in: Glass Science and Technology, Vol. 2. Uhlmann, D.R., Kreidl, N.J. (Eds.). New York: Academic, pp. 209-249. Zarzycki, J. (Ed.) (1986), "3rd Intern. Workshop Glasses and Glass-Ceramics fom Gels, Montpellier, 1985". J. Non-Cryst. Sol. 82, 1-436. Zarzycki, J. (1987 a), "Advanced Glass by Sol-Gel Process", in: Proc. First Intern. Symposium on New Glass., Tokyo, Japan. Tokyo: The Association of New Glass Industries (Ed.), pp. 35-42. Zarzycki, I (1987 b), /. Non-Cryst. Sol. 95-96, 173. Zarzycki, J. (1988), J. Non-Cryst. Sol. 100, 359-363. Zarzycki, J. (1991), "Sonogels - Development and Perspectives", in: Ultrastructure Processing of Ceramics: Uhlmann, D. R., Ulrich, D. G. (Eds.). New York: Wiley (in press). Zarzycki, I, Naudin, F. (1967), Phys. Chem. Glasses 8, 11-18. Zarzycki, I, Prassas, M., Phalippou, J. (1982), /. Mater. Sci. 17, 3371-3379 (Published by Chapman and Hall).
General Reading Brinker, C. Y, Scherer, G. W (1990), Sol-Gel Science, San Diego: Academic Press. Gottardi, V. (Ed.) (1982), /. Non Cryst. Sol. 48, 1 230. Hermann, H., (Ed.) (1981), Ultrarapid Quenching of Liquid Alloys, Vol. 20, Treatise on Materials Science and Technology, New York: Academic Press Weeks, R. A., Kinser, D. L., Kordas, G., (Eds.) (1985), J. Non Cryst. Sol. 71, 1-456. Weeks, R. A., Kinser, D. L. (Eds.) (1989), Diffusion and Defect Data 53 (4), 920. Zarzycki, J. (1991), Glasses and The Vitreous State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. See also the following references listed in Sec. 2.8: Brinker et al. (1984), Brinker et al. (1986), Hench and Ulrich (1984), Hench and Ulrich (1986), Holland (1956), Her (1979), Mackenzie and Ulrich (1988), Pye et al. (1984), Sakka (1988 b), Scholze (1984), Zarzycki (1986).
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation George W. Scherer E.I. DuPont de Nemours & Co.,Wilmington, DE, U.S.A.
List of 3.1 3.2 3.2.1 3.2.1.1 3.2.1.2 3.2.2 3.2.2.1 3.2.2.2 3.2.3 3.2.3.1 3.2.3.2 3.2.3.3 3.2.3.4 3.2.3.5 3.3 3.3.1 3.3.2 3.4 3.4.1 3.4.1.1 3.4.1.2 3.4.1.3 3.4.1.4 3.4.1.5 3.4.2 3.4.3 3.4.3.1 3.4.3.2 3.4.3.3 3.4.4 3.4.4.1 3.4.4.2 3.5 3.5.1 3.5.1.1
Symbols and Abbreviations Introduction Glass Formation from the Melt Nucleation of Crystals Homogeneous Nucleation Heterogeneous Nucleation Crystal Growth Interface Control Diffusion Control Kinetics of Glass Formation Critical Cooling Rate Nonisothermal Analyses Simplified Model Heterogeneous and Transient Nucleation Factors Favoring Glass Formation Sintering and Crystallization Sintering Competition Between Sintering and Crystallization The Glass Transition Phenomenology Cooling Rate Dependence of Tg Fictive Temperature Hysteresis Nonlinearity Nonexponential Relaxation Function Thermodynamic Aspects Theories of Relaxation Rheological Models Kinetic Models Relaxation Models Phenomenological Models Tool's Equation Narayanaswamy's Theory Viscoelasticity Elasticity, Stress Relaxation, and Creep Elasticity
Materials Science and Technology Copyright © WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co KGaA. Allrightsreserved.
121 124 124 125 125 126 127 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 134 134 136 137 138 138 139 141 141 142 144 146 146 148 150 151 151 153 155 156 156
120
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
3.5.1.2 3.5.1.3 3.5.2 3.5.2.1 3.5.2.2 3.5.3 3.5.3.1 3.5.3.2 3.5.3.3
Creep and Stress Relaxation Viscosity Temperature Dependence Equilibrium Liquid Nonequilibrium Liquid Calculation of Thermal Stresses Glass-to-Metal Seals Tempering Annealing
157 159 160 160 162 163 164 166 169
3.6
References
171
List of Symbols and Abbreviations
List of Symbols and Abbreviations A a a (T) B b cp D d Dc DL E AE en / /(0) g {v) G Ag AgD Agn Agv Gd H h h(T) h hf Iv Jt J2 K K (T) kB kn Kp / Ltj mt Mp n n n* N1
constant coefficient, radius shift function constant coefficient isobaric heat capacity transport coefficient dimension of space kinetic coefficient for transport across interface lattice diffuson coefficient Young modulus activation energy embryo containing n monomers interface site factor function of 0 function of v shear modulus free energy change activation barrier for transport free energy of formation of an embryo of n monomers free energy difference between unit volumes of crystal and liquid delayed elastic strain enthalpy Planck constant function of T magnetic field molar heat of fusion rate of homogeneous nucleation shear compliance or creep compliance dilatational compliance bulk modulus function of temperature Boltzmann constant rate constants for the addition and removal of a monomer constant thickness of seal phenomenological transport coefficients number of neighbors in "up" position relaxation function of property p number of pores per unit volume of liquid phase stiffness ratio number of embryos larger than r* number of monomers remaining in the liquid phase
121
122
"d
nv P q r r, r* Re R s
s sc s
f
T t TiV % TK TL Tn Tr TR Ts TK u V V
vm
w wk W*
w,w0
X
x, y, z
z Z 1 ? —Z N
a
P y
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
Avogadro number refractive index of a liquid in equilibrium at Tx number of embryos with n monomers number of molecules of nucleating phase per unit volume pressure cooling rate heating rate distance vector biaxial relaxation function radius, critical radius critical cooling rate ideal gas constant interfacial area configurational entropy entropy of fusion temperature time fictive temperature for volume V fictive temperature glass transition temperature Kauzmann temperature liquidus temperature time corresponding with the "nose" method temperature corresponding with the "nose" method reduced temperature room temperature setting temperature temperature of crossover experiment growth rate volume volume fraction molar volume width of seal weighting factors thermodynamic barrier to nucleation relaxation rate, primary relaxation rate nonlinearity parameter stress axes number of molecules set of order parameters thermal expansion coefficient exponent with a value between 0 and 1 constant near unity interfacial energy (solid/liquid; liquid/vapor)
List of Symbols and Abbreviations
5 height of hierarchical energy barriers s volumetric strain rj viscosity 9 contact angle between crystal a n d nucleating heterogeneity x isothermal compressibility X j u m p distance size of the diffusing species Aji potential barrier per molecule hindering rearrangement v vibration frequency, Poisson ratio FITP Prigogine-Defay ratio Q relative density, density of sites o hydrostatic (or dilatational) stress G{ spin state T duration of period of transient nucleation T relaxation time TU uniaxial relaxation time 0X (t\
Adam-Gibbs cooperatively rearranging subsystem Kohlrausch-Wiliam- Watts partial fictive temperatures structural relaxation thermorheologically simple time-temperature-transformation viscoelasticity Vogel-Fulcher-Tamman
123
124
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
3.1 Introduction When a liquid is cooled below the liquidus temperature (TL) it enters a state of metastable equilibrium. If the thermodynamic barrier to nucleation can be overcome, a crystal of the equilibrium phase is formed and the volume of the system decreases discontinuously, as shown in Fig. 3-1. In Section 3.2 we briefly review the theory of nucleation and growth, and establish the parameters that control the degree of crystallization during cooling. The goal is to predict the critical cooling rate, which is the minimum cooling rate that prevents the formation of a detectable degree of crystallinity. Of course, as indicated in the preceding chapter, glasses are formed in many ways other than cooling from the melt. In Section 3.3 we examine the problem of form-
Equilibrium liquid Metastable liquid Glass transition £
Glass
ing a glass object by sintering of a powder compact or gel. The degree of crystallization that occurs during sintering is relatively insensitive to thermal history, but does depend strongly on pore size and applied pressure. If nucleation does not occur, the liquid remains in metastable equilibrium below TL and continues to contract at the high rate corresponding to the thermal contraction coefficient of the equilibrium liquid. At lower temperatures the atomic mobility of the liquid decreases, and eventually the atoms become trapped in fixed positions. This occurs over a range of temperature called the glass transition region, which is discussed at length in Section 3.4. The glass transition temperature (Tg) is generally defined as the point of intersection of lines extrapolated from the glass and metastable liquid ranges (see Fig. 3-1). In the glass transition range, the properties of the liquid vary with time at a rate that is readily detected by human observers. This has important implications for stress development during cooling (especially for glasscontaining composites), because the viscosity that controls the rate of stress relaxation is a function of time as well as temperature. This problem is discussed in Section 3.5.
Crystal
3.2 Glass Formation from the Melt Figure 3-1. Volume change during cooling of a liquid. If nucleation of crystals occurs easily, the volume decreases discontinuously at the liquidus temperature, TL. Otherwise, the liquid remains in metastable equilibrium until reaching the glass transition temperature, where structural rearrangement is kinetically arrested. Further contraction results from the decreasing amplitude of vibration of the atoms around fixed positions (as in the crystal), so the slopes are similar for the glass and crystal.
A glass is typically formed by homogenizing the components in the liquid state at a temperature well above TL, then cooling below Tg. The cooling rate must be great enough so that no significant quantity of crystals can form. The critical rate depends on the kinetics of nucleation and growth, so we begin by discussing the standard theories for those processes.
3.2 Glass Formation from the Melt
3.2.1 Nucleation of Crystals
stituted into Eq,(3-3), the critical radius is found to be
3.2.1.1 Homogeneous Nucleation The barrier to nucleation arises from the interfacial energy (ySL) between the crystal and liquid phases. The free energy change (Ag) on growing a spherical crystal to a radius r is given by (Uhlmann and Chalmers, 1965; Christian, 1975):
Ag=-(4n/3)r3Agv
(3-1)
where Agv is the difference in free energy between unit volumes of the crystal and liquid. Since energy is expended to form the interface, the high surface-to-volume ratio of small crystals inhibits their growth. The break-even point occurs at the critical radius (r*), where dAg dr
= 0
(3-2)
Crystals with radii smaller than r* are called embryos, and they tend to shrink because dAg/dr>0 when r
(3-3)
The interfacial energy can be related to the molar heat of fusion, Ahf, by (Turnbull, 1964)
" - '
"U,
(3-4)
where NA is Avogadro's number and Vm is the molar volume. The free energy change can be approximated by (Hoffman, 1958)
Agv*Ah(Tr(l-Tt)/Vm
125
(3-5)
where Tr is the reduced temperature, Tr = T/7J. As we shall see, the maximum nucleation rate occurs in the range 0.5 < Tr <0.7, so when Eqs.(3-4) and (3-5) are sub-
r*^4{VJNA)^
(3-6)
which is just 4 formula units for the crystallizing compound, so r * ^ l nm. However, at small undercooling (TL—T), the liquid and crystal are in equilibrium, so Agv = 0 and the radius of the critical nucleus is infinite; thus, homogeneous nucleation (where crystals form directly from the liquid) only becomes favorable at large undercoolings. Growth of embryos is assumed to occur by reactions of the type (3 ?) K '" " where en is an embryo containing n "monomers" (e.g., formula units) and the kn are constants for the addition and removal of a monomer. If equilibrium were established, the number of embryos with n monomers (Nn) would be
Nn=NlQxp(-Agn/kBT)
(3-8)
where Nt is the number of monomers remaining in the liquid phase and Agn is the free energy of formation of an embryo of n monomers. However, there is no equilibrium, because embryos larger than the critical size (ft* monomers, or radius r*) grow rapidly and are removed from the system. Instead, a steady state develops, where the rate of the forward reaction in Eq. (3-7) becomes independent of time and n. The nucleation rate increases during the transient period (of length T) while the steady-state distribution of embryos is developing. The t Thompson and Spaepen (1979) find that Hoffman's approximation is appropriate for materials with a large change in cp at TL, but it does not work well for metals; they recommend replacing the factor of Tx with 2 Tr/(1 + Tt). Takahashi and Yoshio (1973) also find that Eq. (3-5) is not accurate for alkali disilicates; better results are obtained by neglecting the factor of T .
126
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
kinetics of transient nucleation are very well described by the theory due to Kashchiev (1969), a fact that has been verified by experiment (James, 1974) and by computer simulations (Kelton et al, 1983). Substituting Eq.(3-6) into Eq.(3-1) we find the free energy of the critical nucleus, which is the thermodynamic barrier to nucleation: Ag{r*) = W* =
"5 A
(3.9)
The rate of formation of critical nuclei, or rate of homogeneous nucleation (Iv) is given by (James, 1985; Zanotto and James, 1985) ;n v vexp where nv is the number of molecules or formula units of nucleating phase per unit volume, v is a vibration frequency, v& kBT/h, where k is Boltzmann's constant and h is Planck's constant; AgD is the activation barrier for transport across the nucleus/liquid interface, and W* is the thermodynamic barrier to nucleation defined in Eq. (3-9). It is conventionally assumed that transport at the interface is related to a diffusion coefficient, D = v X1 exp ( - AgD/kB T)
(3-11)
where X is a jump distance, of the order of atomic dimensions. It is further assumed that D can be related to the viscosity (rj) by the Stokes-Einstein equation D=
kBT
(3-12)
so that W* exp
-
(3-13)
The validity of Eq. (3-13) has been extensively investigated. James (1985) gives an excellent account of this work. Rowlands
and James (1979) concluded from a study of nucleation in lithium disilicate glasses that the temperature dependence of the nucleation rate was well represented by the theory, except at very large undercoolings, but the magnitude of the measured rate was 20 orders of magnitude larger than predicted! Later it was shown (Zanotto and James, 1985) that the temperature dependence was indeed predicted correctly by Eq. (3-13), if viscosity values and nucleation rates were measured in the same glass; however, the magnitude of Iv was still grossly in error. Finally, James (1985) showed that the magnitude could also be brought into agreement by allowing for a weak (and physically reasonable) temperature dependence in y^. 3.2.1.2 Heterogeneous Nucleation In most real systems, crystals result from heterogeneous nucleation, where foreign material provides a surface that facilitates the formation of a critical nucleus. As indicated in Fig. 3-2, a nucleating agent (such as laboratory dirt, which is largely composed of aluminosilicates) is effective if it provides a low-energy interface with the crystal. In that case the energy invested to form the nucleus is smaller and the rate of t Weinberg and Zanotto (1989 a) argue that the use of the Stokes-Einstein equation, Eq. (3-12), is unjustified. Based on the very successful theory of Kashchiev (1969), they propose that the temperaturedependence of the transient time x gives a better representation of the kinetics of transport at the crystal/ liquid interface. Using measured values of x and Iv, they find that the predicted and measured values of the nucleation rate are not in agreement at large undercoolings. However, Kelton et al. (1983) found in their computer simulations that the temperature dependence of the transient time was not the same as for transport at the interface, and the difference was in the right direction to account for the results reported by Weinberg and Zanotto, so the standard theory is probably correct after all, even with the use of the Stokes- Einstein approximation.
127
3.2 Glass Formation from the Melt
Unfavorable
contamination by particles is most likely to occur at the surface, and these heterogeneities can be potent nucleating agents.
yr > yY sv SL
3.2.2 Crystal Growth 3.2.2.1 Interface Control
The standard theory for crystal growth is discussed in several good reviews (Jackson etal., 1967; Uhlmann, 1969, 1972 a). When growth is controlled by attachment of atoms to the interface, the growth rate (u) can be written
Crystal: Liquid i Vapor •
Figure 3-2. Schematic illustration of homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation; 6 is the contact angle between the crystal and the nucleating heterogeneity.
nucleation is faster. For a nucleus in the form of a spherical cap growing on a flat substrate, the barrier to heterogeneous nucleation is given by (Uhlmann and Chalmers, 1965) (3-14) where / (0) = (2 + cos 6) (1 - cos 0)2/4
(3-15)
and 6 is the contact angle between the crystal and the nucleating heterogeneity, as illustrated in Fig. 3-2. The function f(6\ shown in Fig. 3-3, substantially reduces the barrier to nucleation when the contact angle is small (<90°). This allows nucleation to occur at relatively small undercoolings, where homogeneous nucleation is improbable. Heterogeneities are responsible for the appearance of crystals at small undercoolings, and for the occurrence of crystallization originating at the surface of a body of glass. As illustrated in Fig. 3-2, a free surface is an unfavorable site for homogeneous nucleation, because of the high energy of the solid/vapor interface. However,
where Dc is the kinetic coefficient governing the rate of transport at the crystal/liquid interface, / is the interface site factor (i.e., the fraction of sites on the interface to which an atom can attach), and the quantity in brackets is the thermodynamic factor determining the probability that an atom on the crystal surface will remain there, rather than jumping back into the liquid; Vm is the molar volume, .Rg is the ideal gas constant, and Agv is the same free energy that appears in Eq. (3-1). The coefficient Dc is generally identified with D in
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
e Figure 3-3. Function f(0), defined in Eq. (3-15), causes drastic reduction in barrier to nucleation when contact angle 6 is small.
128
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
Eq.(3-ll) and approximated using the Stokes-Einstein equation, as in Eq.(3-12). A material with an entropy of fusion (Asf=Ahf/TL) less than 2Rg is expected to develop a rough liquid/crystal interface (Jackson et al, 1967), so the interface site factor will be near unity. In such cases, for small undercoolings Eq. (3-16) reduces to
Dc\ (As, RgT
(3-17)
where the second equality follows from Eq. (3-5). If the entropy of fusion is > 4 Rg, the crystal/liquid interface is smooth, and attachment is relatively difficult. If growth occurs at the ledge of a screw dislocation, then / increases in proportion to the undercooling:
ceeds, the rejected layer increases in thickness, so that diffusion must occur over greater and greater distances; consequently, the growth rate decreases with time according to uocr112
(3-20)
Once a diffusion layer forms, as indicated in Fig. 3-4, any perturbation that forms on the interface enters a region where the undercooling is greater, so it grows faster. This situation is called constitutional supercooling (Chalmers, 1964), and it accounts for the instability of smooth interfaces in systems crystallizing under diffusion control. Such systems typically exhibit dendritic ("tree-like") or spherulitic morphologies; the latter consists of den-
(3-18) If growth advances by formation of diskshaped nuclei on the smooth interface, the growth rate has the form
TL-T greater at tip of bump a)
B where A and B are constants (Hillig, 1966). b)
3.2.2.2 Diffusion Control In many systems, growth is not controlled by attachment kinetics. In rapidly crystallizing materials, such as metals, growth may be limited by the rate of transport of the heat of fusion away from the interface. In multicomponent systems (which includes most oxides of commercial or geological significance), the limiting step may be diffusion of solute. The rejected heat or solute builds up at the interface and decreases the driving force for crystallization (viz., the undercooling); growth will stop unless it diffuses away. As growth pro-
c)
Figure 3-4. Schematic illustration of diffusion-limited growth. Solute accumulating at the crystal/liquid interface reduces the driving force (TL—T) for growth; a perturbation on the interface enters a region with a greater undercooling, so it grows faster, leading to breakdown of the planar interface. The same phenomenon occurs when heat, rather than solute, is the diffusing species.
129
3.2 Glass Formation from the Melt
dritic needles with a common point of origin. An important feature of dendritic growth is that the growth rate is constant, rather than obeying Eq. (3-20). The reason is that the tip of the dendrite continually moves into "uncontaminated" liquid, so that diffusion occurs through a layer whose thickness is constant, rather than increasing (Christian, 1975).
1 -
i
i
A
0.8 ~
i
'•
-
0.6
0.4 -
0.2
\
''
o -
3.2.3 Kinetics of Glass Formation A variety of schemes have been proposed to account for the ability of certain compositions to form glasses; many are discussed in reviews by Uhlmann and Yinnon (1983) and Gutzow et al. (1985). Rules based on the ratios of the sizes of the atoms, the strengths of the bonds, or other structural features seem to work for certain groups of materials, but always fail for others. Such approaches are logically unsatisfactory, because glass formation is a kinetic phenomenon: even silica will crystallize if cooled too slowly, and water will vitrify if cooled fast enough. The answer to whether a given material is a glass former is not "yes" or "no". The answer is always "yes, in principle", because any liquid will form a glass if it is cooled rapidly enough. Dietzel and Wickert (1956) identified the quality of a glass-former by the reciprocal of its maximum crystallization rate. This would be reasonable if the nucleation behavior of various liquids were comparable, but it is not. The growth rate is not related to the interfacial energy that controls the nucleation barrier, so a liquid that crystallizes easily might be hard to nucleate. Turnbull (1969) suggested that the condition for glass formation should be the absence of any nucleation: (3-21)
i
• * u(max) / •
I p (max)
/
v\lvdt
i
0.5
;
\
\ 0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.1
T/Tr
Figure 3-5. Rates of nucleation and crystal growth in SiO2, calculated from standard theory, using parameters given by MacFarlane (1982).
where V is the volume of the sample. This is a rigorous definition, certainly, as it ensures that a material that is called a glass is truly free of any crystallinity. However, when this proposal was investigated by Vreeswijk et al. (1974) their calculations predicted that SiO2 would have to be cooled 1010 times faster than GeO 2 to form a glass, and that As 2 O 3 would have to be quenched at 10 7o C/s. These results are clearly inconsistent with experimental evidence. The reason for the failure of this approach is indicated in Fig. 3-5: for many materials, the temperature ranges where the nucleation and growth rates are significant do not overlap. It may be virtually impossible to avoid forming a nucleus, but those nuclei that do form may not be able to grow to any meaningful «i™ 1" ^ Note that the situation is quite different on cooling and reheating. During cooling, the concentration of critical nuclei is near zero as the liquid passes through the temperature of the maximum growth rate. However, once it has been cooled through the range where the nucleation rate is high, many nuclei are available to grow during reheating.
130
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
3.2.3.1 Critical Cooling Rate The most comprehensive method of predicting glass formation was introduced by Uhlmann (1972 b). The idea is to construct a time-temperature-transformation (TTT) curve as in Fig. 3-6: the curve defines the time required at any temperature to produce a particular volume fraction of crystallization, v. Uhlmann chose a fraction of v = 10" 6, on the basis that it represents the limit of detectability of crystallinity by current techniques; the results are not sensitive to this choice of v, as we shall see. Thus, a glass is implicitly defined as a material that contains an insignificant quantity of crystal. The TTT curve is used to calculate the critical cooling rate (Rc\ which is the minimum rate that results in a glassy product (i.e., one having a crystalline content < v). There is no clear-cut separation between glass-formers and non-glass-formers; instead, the glass-forming tendency of a liquid is quantified in terms of Rc.
The TTT curve is calculated using the Johnson-Mehl-Avrami theory (Christian, 1975), which relates v to the rates of nucleation (Iv) and growth (u): (3-22) 4 71
> = 1 — exp I —
Under isothermal conditions, when Iv and u are constant, this reduces to v = l — exp
« log t Figure 3-6. Schematic illustration of a TTT curve. The abscissa indicates the time required at each temperature to produce a volume fraction of crystals of v. The critical cooling rate (Rc) is the minimum rate that avoids crossing the curve. The "nose" of the curve, at time tn and temperature Tn, corresponds to the fastest rate of transformation. The nose method uses the approximation JRC «(TL — Tn)/tn, where TL is the liquidus temperature.
lv u i
(3-23)
or, when v is small, to v& —.
(3-24)
This expression can be modified (Christian, 1975) to account for those cases when the growth rate is not constant (e.g., under diffusion control, when u oc t~1/2) or is anisotropic (e.g., when crystals grow in the form of needles or plates). It must also be modified when heterogeneous or transient nucleation are important; these situations are discussed below. The TTT curve can be constructed using Eq. (3-24), together with measured or calculated values for Iv and u. The curve then represents isothermal crystallization, but we are interested in crystallization during constant cooling. A conservative estimate of the critical cooling rate is obtained by the "nose method": K*(TL-Tn)/tn
r
J/Jjudr df
(3-25)
where Tn and tn are the temperature and time corresponding to the nose of the TTT curve (see Fig. 3-6). The nose of the curve represents the fastest rate of transformation of liquid into crystal, and Eq. (3-25) gives the cooling rate that would be required if that crystallization rate applied over the whole temperature range from TL to Tn. The values of Rc found in this way,
131
3.2 Glass Formation from the Melt
using measured values for u, rj, and W*9 are generally in order-of-magnitude agreement with experiment (Uhlmann and Yinnon, 1983). Similar agreement has been obtained by other workers (e.g., Davies, 1976; Ramachandrarao et al., 1977; Tanner and Ray, 1979; Vil'kovskii, 1988) who used this approach to calculate Rc for metallic glassformers. 3.2.3.2 Nonisothermal Analyses An improved estimate of Rc can be obtained by taking proper account of the transformation rate at each temperature during a constant cooling treatment, rather than using the nose method. A simple way of adapting an isothermal TTT diagram to describe constant cooling is an averaging method suggested by Grange and Kiefer (1941): it is assumed that on cooling through a small temperature interval from T± at time t1to T2 at time t2, the amount of crystallization is equal to that produced isothermally at temperature (T1 + T2)/2 in a time period of t2-tv Onorato and Uhlmann (1976) adapted this method to calculate curves appropriate for cooling at a constant (dT/dt = constant) or logarithmic (dT/d (In t) = constant) rate, with the results shown in Fig. 3-7. The descending curves in Fig. 3-7 a represent constant cooling rates, and the one that barely misses the nose of the curve corresponds to Rc. When the constant cooling rate is taken into account, a smaller value of Rc is found, as expected, but the difference is typically less than a factor often. Note that Rc is relatively insensitive to the assumed value of v: a change o f ~ 5 x l 0 5 i n i ; causes a change by a factor of ~20 in Rc. Fig. 3-7 b shows that a logarithmic cooling rate (encountered in the cooling of many large bodies) produces a curve that falls between the isothermal TTT and the constant rate curve.
b) I
~
1500 U00 £ 1300 •1200 1100 1000
Figure 3-7. a) Isothermal TTT for v = 10" 6 and constant-rate cooling curves for v = 10" 6 and v =0.5-0.9; calculated for lunar glass 79155 (multicomponent silicate); b) Isothermal TTT and nonisothermal curves assuming constant (continuous) or logarithmic cooling rates, all for v =0.01; calculated for lunar glass 15286. From Uhlmann and Yinnon (1983).
A more rigorous nonisothermal analysis, suggested by Hopper et al. (1974), allows prediction of the distribution of crystal sizes following a given cooling treatment, or inference of the cooling rate from measurement of the size distribution. For the calculation of Rc it reduces to Eq. (3-22). A simpler method was suggested by MacFarlane (1982), based on the concept of additivity. This means that the rate of transformation depends on the current state of the system (i.e., v and T), and not
132
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
on the thermal history. Then it can be shown (Cahn, 1956) that (3-26) where h and g are functions only of T and v9 respectively. MacFarlane (1982) noted that Eq.(3-24) can be written in the form (3-27)
Then, when additivity is valid, for a cooling rate ofq = dT/dt = constant, Eq. (3-27) becomes /^ ~QX
- 0I
At'
Y K(T(t'))J)
f
(3-Z5)
dT
'Y
which is readily evaluated. However, as Cahn (1956) explained, Eq.(3-26) is not generally valid when both Iv and u are temperature-dependent, so it cannot describe concurrent homogeneous nucleation and growth. However, it is valid when growth occurs from a constant number of nuclei, as might happen when heterogeneous nucleation dominates. (It is also valid when Iv and u have identical temperature dependences, Iv oc w, but no example of this circumstance is known or expected. See Fig. 3-5, for an example of typical temperature dependence.) Weinberg and Zanotto (1989 b) compared the prediction of Eqs. (3-22) and (3-28) and found that the predictions of v were very different when homogeneous nucleation was assumed. However, since Rc depends on t?1/4, an error of 103 in v causes less than an order of magnitude error in Rc. 3.2.3.3 Simplified Model Actually, it is easier to measure Rc directly than to obtain all the data necessary to calculate it, even using the nose method. Therefore, Uhlmann et al. (1979) have de-
veloped various simplified methods to predict JRC from limited data. One method is to calculate tn from Eq. (3-24), using Eq. (3-16) for u and Eq. (3-13) for Iv; Agv is approximated using Eq. (3-5), and the transport coefficients are approximated using the Stokes-Einstein equation, Eq. (3-12). Further, based on experience with a wide range of materials, it is recognized that the temperature of the nose occurs near r n *0.77T L
(3-29)
With these approximations, Eqs. (3-24) and (3-25) lead to (Uhlmann and Yinnon, 1983) RCK
^-exp(-0.212b)(3-30)
where a = 0.04 J/cm 3 K, rjn is the viscosity at 0.77 TL, and b is related to the nucleation barrier at a reduced temperature of T=0.8: b=
0.8fe B T L
(3-31)
The cooling rates calculated from Eq. (3-30) were found to be in order-of-magnitude agreement with experiment, so the results were almost as good as when the more rigorous analysis was used. Of course, it is essential to make a good choice for the value of b, because a 15-20% change in b results in a 10-fold change in Rc. The performance of the simplified analysis is surprisingly good, considering that it assumes that nucleation occurs homogeneously and that crystal growth is interface-controlled. The presence of heterogeneous nucleation changes only the magnitude of the nucleation barrier, not the form of the equations, but it does have a profound effect on the transformation rate,
3.2 Glass Formation from the Melt
as we shall see. The reproducibility of experimental measures of Rc indicates that heterogeneous nucleation is minimal or that the samples are contaminated in a consistent way. In many of the systems studied, growth is certainly diffusion-controlled, so the implication (Uhlmann and Yinnon, 1983) is that Eq. (3-16) is reasonably accurate in predicting the rate of dendritic growth in the vicinity of Tn. This would certainly not be expected a priori. However, it is worth noting that Magill et al. (1973) have shown that the crystal growth rates for a variety of organic glass formers can be collapsed onto a single master curve by plotting
u(T)/u(Tmax) versus
133
320
0.95
310
0.90
0.85
Homogeneous, 0.80 nucleation only
250
-U
-3
- 1 0 1 2 Log t (mini
Figure 3-8. Continuous cooling curves for homogeneous 4- bulk heterogeneous nucleation in o-terphenyl with contact angles as indicated, as well as for homogeneous nucleation only. Curves calculated from Eq. (3-22). From Uhlmann and Yinnon (1983).
(T-TJ/(TL-TJ,
where Tmax is the temperature of the maximum growth rate and T^ is a parameter (which may be related to the glass transition temperature). Moreover, Dearnley (1983) has shown that growth rate data for a variety of minerals (basalts, plagioclase, and diopside) can be described by the same curve. The organic systems probably grow under interface control, but the latter almost certainly exhibit diffusion control; nevertheless, in spite of a range of several hundred degrees in TL, all of these materials show similar temperature dependence for w. 3.2.3.4 Heterogeneous and Transient Nucleation
The effect of heterogeneous nucleation on the TTT curve has been examined by Onorato and Uhlmann (1976) and by Yinnon and Uhlmann (1981). The latter study used Eqs. (3-13) and (3-14) to calculate the effect of heterogeneities with various contact angles, 9. The TTT diagrams were constructed using Eq. (3-22) together with measured crystal growth rates for anorthite (CaO • A12O3 • 2SiO 2 ) and the or-
ganic glass-former o-terphenyl. As shown in Fig. 3-8, heterogeneities with #<100° cause drastic reductions in the critical cooling rate, because they allow nucleation in the temperature range where crystal growth is rapid. When heterogeneities with a range of contact angles are present, those with the smallest 6 are depleted first during cooling and those with larger 9 become more important at greater undercoolings. Uhlmann (1972 b) concluded that transient effects in nucleation would have a negligible effect on the calculation of Rc, because the transient period (of duration T) is generally short compared to (TL — Tn)/ Rc. Gutzow et al. (1985) used the theory of Kashchiev (1969) for transient nucleation to modifiy Eq. (3-24). For isotropic isothermal growth, they obtained 3v
(3-32)
The transient effects were found to be important when very potent heterogeneous nuclei were present, in which case high critical cooling rate were required. Kelton and Greer (1986) used a numerical method to simulate cluster growth directly, rather than
134
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
using the Johnson-Mehl-Avrami analysis. They found that transient nucleation effects were insignificant for lithium disilicate, which is a good glass-former (Rc « 3.8 K/s), and were minor for (Au 85 Cu 15 ) 77 Si 9 Ge 14 , which is a relatively poor glass former (Rc«104 K/s). However, for Au 81 Si 19 , calculations including transient nucleation effects gave R c ^ 1 0 5 K / s , while steady-state calculations gave Rc « 2.4 x 107 K/s. Thus, when the critical cooling rate is high, transient effects become important, and ignoring them leads to a very pessimistic estimate of Rc. (See also Vol. 15, Chap. 9, Sec. 9.3.3.) 3.2.3.5 Factors Favoring Glass Formation Kinetic analyses suggest that the following factors are most important in reducing the critical cooling rate (Uhlmann and Yinnon, 1983): 1) High viscosity at the melting point or liquidus temperature (as is characteristic of silicate liquids) or a viscosity that rises rapidly with undercooling (as in organic glass-formers), since Iv and u are both inversely related to rj. 2) A high value of Tg/TL, since glass formation requires cooling from TL to Tg (this is clearly closely related to factor 1). 3) No heterogeneous nucleation. 4) A high barrier to homogeneous nucleation. 5) A large difference in composition between the crystal and liquid, since this makes crystal growth difficult. This condition, along with a small ratio of Tg to TL, is often met at eutectic compositions. Metallic glasses are most often found near eutectics. 6) Asymmetric molecules (as in o-terphenyl) that inhibit crystal growth. (See also Vol. 15, Chap. 9, Sees. 9.3.2 and 9.3.3.)
3.3 Sintering and Crystallization As explained in Chapter 2, glasses are formed in many ways other than cooling from the melt. One method that has achieved considerable importance in recent years is sol-gel processing, where wetchemical techniques are used to prepare an inorganic gel that is sintered to obtain a dense ceramic (Brinker and Scherer, 1990). In this section we discuss the factors that determine whether the sintered product crystallizes or remains glassy. This problem is closely related to that considered in the previous section, except that the glassy state is approached from below during heating of the gel, rather than from above, as during quenching of a melt. 3.3.1 Sintering A porous glass contains an excess energy equal to yLV S, where yLV is the liquid/vapor interfacial energy and S is the interfacial area. If the body is heated to a temperature at which the atoms have sufficient mobility, this energy provides a driving force for densification. The reduction of porosity through viscous flow or diffusion driven by surface energy is called sintering. This process is used to produce a variety of glassy objects, as described by Rabinovich (1985). In sol-gel processing, the surface area of the body is so enormous (typically 300-1000 m 2 /g) that the driving force is sufficient to permit sintering at very low temperatures. This raises the possibility of producing glasses that tend to crystallize or phase separate when prepared from the melt. For example, Yamane and Kojima (1981) made clear glasses in the strontium silicate system; since these compositions fall within a stable immiscibility region extending above 2000 °C, such glasses are virtually impossible to prepare by melting.
3.3 Sintering and Crystallization
On the other hand, sodium silicate glasses that are readily prepared by melting cannot be sintered, because crystallization of the porous gel is too rapid (Prassas and Hench, 1984). In glassy materials, sintering occurs by viscous flow. The kinetics of the process were first modeled by Frenkel (1945), who suggested that the energy gained by reduction in surface area must be equal to the energy dissipated in viscous flow. A variety of models have been developed based on that principle, differing principally in the geometry assumed for the pores (Mackenzie and Shuttleworth, 1949; Scherer, 1977). These models and their application to gels have been recently reviewed (Scherer, 1987; Brinker and Scherer, 1990). The prediction of these models, which is remarkable insensitive to the geometrical assumptions, is that the densification rate is given approximately by
135
(Scherer, 1984 b)
4na3
(3-34)
Sintering of crystalline materials is more complicated, because transport can occur simultaneously by diffusion through the crystal lattice, along grain boundaries, or across the surface of the particles, or by evaporation and condensation. As indicated in Fig. 3-9, there is a grain boundary at the point of contact (called a neck) between sintering crystalline particles, because the crystal planes do not generally align. Densification occurs when the centers of the particles move toward one another, and this requires that material be removed from the grain boundary and transported to the pore. This can be achieved only by diffusion along the grain boundary or through the lattice. Surface diffusion and evaporation/condensation reduce the surface area by moving material ,1/3 de to the neck (a process called coarsening), (3-33) 0.3 < Q < 0.9 dt but as indicated in Fig. 3-10, these processes do not cause densification. where Q is the relative density of the porous A large number of models have been body (i.e., the volume fraction of porosity = 1 — Q) and rj is the viscosity. The geomet- proposed to describe the kinetics of sintering when diffusion follows one or more ric parameter, n, is the number of pores per paths, and Ashby (1974) has developed unit volume of the liquid phase; for a body "maps" that indicate which process domicomposed of spherical particles of radius a, nates in a given range of temperature. For there is roughly one pore per particle, so
Path 2: Lattice diffusion Path 5: Lattice diffusion Path 3: Evaporation
Path 1: Surface Diffusion Path 4: Boundary diffusion
Figure 3-9. Schematic illustration of sintering of crystalline particles showing possible paths for transport of matter. For densification to occur, atoms must be removed from the grain boundary (dashed line) at the plane of contact (neck) between the particles.
136
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation Densification
Coarsening
ceramics can be made from amorphous aerogels, but only if the amount of crystallization during sintering is less than 5-10 vol%. To find a thermal treatment that will produce densification of a glass without excessive crystallization, it is necessary to combine the TTT diagram discussed in the previous section with information about the kinetics of viscous sintering.
Figure 3-10. Densification results when atoms move from the grain boundary to the pore. Coarsening occurs when atoms move from the surface of the particle toward the neck; the centers of the particles do not move toward one another.
our purposes, it is sufficient to consider a widely used model for densification produced by diffusion from the grain boundary through the lattice (Coble, 1961). The densification rate is given by 336 DL-
(3-35)
dt
where a is the radius of the particle, D L , is the lattice diffusion coefficient, y sv is the solid/vapor interfacial energy, and X is the size of the diffusing species. To compare the sintering rates permitted by viscous flow and diffusion, we use the Stokes-Einstein equation, Eq. (3-12), to replace DL with the viscosity, rj. Then, assuming that the surface energies are similar, Eqs. (3-33) to (3-35) lead to 2
dt
diffusion
dg dt
(3-36) flow
This indicates that sintering of crystalline materials is slower than sintering of glass, unless the particles are a few times larger than a molecule. Clearly, then, it is advantageous to densify a porous body before it crystallizes, if that is possible. A practical application of this principle is the demonstration by Thomas (1974) that dense glass
3.3.2 Competition Between Sintering and Crystallization From Eqs. (3-33) and (3-34) it can be seen that the time to achieve densification by viscous sintering is approximately TS * 1.6arj/yLY
(3-37)
Knowing rj (T) one can calculate the sintering time for a given particle size and plot it together with a TTT curve, as in Fig. 3-11. If the sintering curve does not cross the TTT curve, the sample can be sintered before it crystallizes. This variant on the TTT diagram was proposed by Uhlmann et al. (1975), who were interested in inferring the thermal history of a sample from examination of its microstructure. It is also useful if one seeks a sintering treatment that will be complete before significant crystallization occurs. Whereas a melt must be quenched to obtain a glass, a porous glass or gel must be heated to a temperature where viscous flow can occur. This generally means that the sample must pass through the temperature range where the nucleation rate is greatest, and the presence of abundant nuclei facilitates the crystallization that we seek to avoid. In fact most gels sinter in the vicinity of the glass transition temperature (Brinker and Scherer, 1990), where nucleation may be rapid; fortunately, growth in that temperature range is generally slow. Glass powders sinter at higher tempera-
3.4 The Glass Transition
137
U00 Breccias with crystallinities between 1% and 90% 1300
Completely crystalline breccias
Figure 3-11. Curve indicating sintering time (SINTERS) combined with isothermal TTT curves for various volume fractions of crystallization for a lunar glass. A breccia is a rock containing sharp fragments embedded in a finegrained matrix. The objective of this study (Uhlmann et al., 1975) was to infer the thermal history of the sample from the degree of crystallinity and extent of sintering.
6 8 log10 t (s)
tures (because the particle size, a, in Eq.(3-37) is larger), so they may have a significant growth rate as well as a high content of nuclei. The general guideline is that the particle size should be as small as possible, so that sintering can proceed at a temperature where the crystal growth rate is small. Of course, one should avoid heterogeneous nuclei, but even these are not important if the temperature is kept low enough. If the crystallization rate is fast even at temperatures too low for sintering, the densification rate can be accelerated by applying pressure (with a piston, for instance). However, to be effective, the applied pressure must be comparable to the capillary pressure, 2yLY/a, that drives sintering; for gels, this is on the order of 10100 MPa. In gels, the viscosity may be much lower than in a melted glass with the same oxide content, because gels tend to have high concentrations of hydroxyl (~ 0.1-0.3% OH). Therefore, the viscosity of a gel can be varied by low-temperature treatments that reduce the OH content, and one might expect this to have an impact on the ease of
sintering without crystallization. Zarzycki (1982) considered the question and concluded that chemical impurities that change rj will have the same effect on the rate of sintering and crystallization, since both processes are proportional to t/rj. Zarzycki found some evidence that OH could affect the barrier to homogeneous nucleation (probably by reducing ySL), but the differences in crystallinity among the silica gels he examined was attributed to heterogeneous nucleation.
3.4 The Glass Transition We have seen that a liquid can be cooled below the liquidus temperature if the rates of nucleation and growth are small enough. At moderate undercoolings the liquid is in metastable equilibrium, which means that physical properties such as specific volume, V9 are functions of temperature (T) and pressure (P), independent of time. Following small changes in state (caused, for example, by sudden heating or
138
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
cooling) the properties of the liquid gradually approach their equilibrium t values. The time-dependent variation in physical properties as the liquid approaches equilibrium is called structural relaxation or physical aging. The glass transition is a region of temperature (corresponding to a viscosity of t] ^ l O ^ - l O 1 3 Pas) in which the rate of relaxation is slow enough to be readily detectable by human observers. The process of structural relaxation is nonlinear and nonexponential, and this gives rise to a rich phenomenology that is described in the next subsection. The same behavior is found in every class of liquid, including network oxides (e.g., soda-limesilicates), fluorides (e.g., the heavy metal fluorides being considered for optical telecommunications), salts (e.g., 0.4Ca(NO3)2 • •O.6KNO3), molecular liquids (e.g., o-terphenyl), polymers (e. g., polycarbonate), and metals (e.g., Si 15 5 Cu 6 Pd 7 8 5 ). More detailed discussions of relaxation in glassforming liquids are presented in the books Relaxation in Viscous Liquids and Glasses (Brawer, 1985) and Relaxation in Glasses and Composites (Scherer, 1986 b). After a brief look at the thermodynamic implications of the glass transition, we review a variety of theories that attempt to explain the kinetics of relaxation based on different views of the microscopic nature of the relaxation processes. The most powerful tool for prediction of the kinetics of relaxation is a theory proposed by Narayanaswamy (1971) that makes no assumption about the microscopic processes of relaxation. In the "f In the remainder of this chapter we are exclusively concerned with relaxation processes that occur below the liquidus. When we refer to the equilibrium state of a liquid it is understood to mean the metastable equilibrium state of the undercooled liquid. Of course, large excursions in T or P can result in transformation to the true equilibrium structure - the crystal by nucleation and growth, but we exclude such cases from consideration.
final subsection we discuss that theory and its application to such practical problems as tempering, annealing, and fabrication of glass-to-metal seals. 3.4.1 Phenomenology
The glass transition is characterized by a change in the temperature dependence of properties such as volume (V) and enthalpy (H) during cooling. As illustrated in Fig. 3-12, the volumetric thermal expansion coefficient (av = d In V/dT) and isobaric heat capacity (cp = dH/dT) decrease near Tg from a high value characteristic of the equilibrium liquid (avl9 cpl) to a small value characteristic of solid glass (ayg, cpg). In the glass, the atoms are frozen into fixed positions, and the properties change only because the temperature affects the amplitude of vibration of the atoms around those positions. Stronger temperature dependence is found in the liquid, because the atoms are free to diffuse, so changes in temperature can produce different atomic configurations in addition to changes in vibrational amplitude. As the temperature is lowered toward Tg, the mobility of the atoms decreases and relaxation times (T) on the order of seconds or minutes are required for the liquid to achieve the equilibrium configuration. If the temperature is dropping at the rate of a few degrees per minute, it is evident that the structure will not be able to remain in equilibrium; the liquid will be trapped in a configuration characteristic of a temperature near Tg. 3.4.1.1 Cooling Rate Dependence of Tg
The higher the cooling rate (q = dT/dt), the higher the glass transition temperature, as indicated in Fig. 3-12. This is easy to understand if the process of cooling is regarded as a sequence of temperature jumps of size A T followed by isothermal holds of
3.4 The Glass Transition
139
V
(B) slow cool and heat at rate I a I 1
B
Figure 3-12. Change in property p (illustrated for specific volume V and enthalpy if) during cooling of a glass-forming liquid. As the cooling rate (q) increases, so does the glass transition temperature (Tg). Lower part of plot shows slope of curves in upper plot:
oc = d(\nV)/dT and cp = dH/dT; vg
pg
subscripts / and g refer to properties of equilibrium liquid and glass, respectively.
Temperature
length At=AT/q. The liquid remains in equilibrium as long as At is much longer than the relaxation time, which is proportional to the viscosity (Rekhson et al., 1971; Mazurin, 1977): xp = t1/Kp
(3-38)
where Kp is a constant and xp is the relaxation time for the property p that is being measured; for the relaxation of volume in oxides, Kp » 2.5 x 109 Pa. At high temperatures, T
quantified by Copper (1985), who identifies the glass transition with the temperature where 1 dT
dT
(3-39)
Expressions that are more useful for quantitative predictions of Tg (q) are discussed in Section 3.4.4.2. 3.4.1.2 Fictive Temperature
A convenient way of characterizing the structure of the nonequilibrium liquid is by the value of the fictive temperature (Tf), which is defined in Fig. 3-13. The continuous curve represents the change in property p during constant cooling of a glassforming liquid, until it reaches temperature 7\ at time t0. If a line is drawn from the
140
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
Constant cooling rate Quench
a.
t Tt
Tf(tn)Tf(t0)
Temperature Figure 3-13. The fictive temperature (Tf) is found by extrapolating a line with the glassy slope from any point on the nonequilibrium curve to its point of intersection with the curve of the equilibrium liquid. The continuous curve shows the path of property p during constant cooling, arriving at temperature Tx at time t0; if a line with the glassy slope is extrapolated from temperature Tx, the fictive temperature is found to be Tf (t0). If a sample were equilibrated at temperature T{ (t0) and then quenched to Tlt it would have the same value of p as the continuously cooled sample. During an isothermal hold at Tx, property p relaxes toward its equilibrium value, and T{ relaxes toward T,.
Figure 3-14. At high temperatures the liquid is in equilibrium and Tf = T, but on cooling into the glass transition region p lies above its equilibrium value and correspondingly Tf lags behind T. In the glassy state, T{ reaches a constant minimum value, which is called Tg.
nonequilibrium curve with the slope dp/dT characteristic of the glass (i.e., the "glassy slope"), it intersects the extrapolated equilibrium curve at the fictive temperature, Tt (t0). If another sample were equilibrated at temperature Tf (t0), then quenched to Tx, p for that sample would change along a line with the glassy slope, so the quenched sample would have the same value of p as the continuously cooled sample. Since the structure of the sample is assumed to be unchanged during the quench, the implication is that the structure of the continuously cooled sample is the same as that of a liquid in equilibrium at Tf. As we shall see, this is not strictly true: two samples with the same value of p do not necessarily have the same structure. However, the fictive temperature is a sim-
ple and useful measure of the structural state of the glass. If the sample is held isothermally at 7\, p relaxes toward its equilibrium value, which lies on the extrapolation of the equilibrium curve (heavy dashed line in Fig. 3-13). The fictive temperature decreases to Tf (tx) at time t1, and eventually becomes equal to Tx when the sample reaches equilibrium. The relationship between Tf and Tg is illustrated in Fig. 3-14. In the equilibrium liquid, the fictive temperature is equal to the actual temperature, but as the liquid is cooled into the glass transition region T{ decreases more slowly than T. By the time the liquid has frozen into the glassy state, Tf has reached the lowest possible value (for that cooling rate), and that value is called 71.
3.4 The Glass Transition
3.4.1.3 Hysteresis Fig. 3-12 indicates that the properties of a glass exhibit hysteresis during reheating through the glass transition range. At first the reheating curve bends toward the equilibrium curve, as we might expect, but then it crosses that curve and approaches equilibrium from below. Low atomic mobility prevents the structure from reaching equilibrium until the temperature is raised above Tg; then relaxation is rapid and the slope of the reheating curve is actually greater than that of the equilibrium curve. As shown in the lower portion of Fig. 3-12, the sudden approach to equilibrium causes an overshoot in cp (or <xv) on reheating. If the heating rate is much faster than the preceding cooling rate, the overshoot is particularly dramatic. On the other hand, if the reheating rate is relatively slow, there is plenty of time for relaxation during heating, so p(T) bends strongly toward the equilibrium curve. As shown in Fig. 3-15, this causes an undershoot in dp/dT below Tg, and relatively little overshoot. 3.4.1.4 Nonlinearity The kinetics of structural relaxation are most clearly revealed in experiments using temperature jumps, as shown schemat-
ically in Fig. 3-16, If a liquid in equilibrium at temperature T± is instantaneously cooled to T2, property p changes immediately because of the reduced vibrational amplitude of the atoms; thus, dp/dT has the value characteristic of the glass. During an isothermal hold at T2, there is a further change in p with time as the configuration approaches equilibrium. In terms of the fictive temperature, we could say that the sample arrives at T2 with Tf = T1, and relaxes until Tf = T2. A similar experiment can be performed by suddenly heating a liquid to T2 after equilibrating at T3. Structural relaxation is slower in this case, because the sample arrives at T2 with a structure characteristic of the lower temperature (Tf = T3). Therefore, the atoms have less mobility than those in the sample quenched from Tt, which arrives at T2 with a structure characteristic of the higher temperature. This is an illustration of the nonlinearity of structural relaxation: the rate of relaxation depends on the size and direction of the temperature jump, because TP depends on the structure of the liquid. The phenomenon is clearly illustrated in the data of Hara and Suetoshi (1955) for the relaxation of the density of window glass following jumps of 30 °C from above and below (see Fig. 3-17). If the temperature
j \ + qh (fast)
dT
q (slow)
141
qh (fast) »\q
\» qh (slow)
Figure 3-15. Hysteresis in dp/dT, where p is a property of the glass-forming liquid and T is temperature; if p is enthalpy, then this plot represents the heat capacity, cp. The overshoot on reheating is greater when the heating rate (qh) is greater than the preceding cooling rate (qc). If qh<\qc\ there is relatively little overshoot, but there is an undershoot below 71.
142
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation Glassy
slope
Equilibrium slope \
Pro erty p
bo
\
yf
\/ )h—
"eqm
/T
OH
I Temperature
Time
Figure 3-16. Approach to equilibrium following instantaneous jump to temperature T2 following equilibration at Tx or T3. During the jump (left side of figure), the change in property p reflects changes in the vibrational amplitude of atoms in fixed positions; time-dependent changes at temperature T2 (right side of figure) result from relaxation of the atomic configuration. 2.504
ation function of property p (Narayanaswamy, 1971):
l~p(oo,T)
Mp =
(3-40)
Structural relaxation in nonexponential, which means that Mp cannot be accurately represented by an equation of the form 2.492
200
Figure 3-17. Change in density with time at 530 °C for soda-lime-silicate glass previously equilibrated at 560 °C (•) and 500 °C (o). The temperature jump is 30 °C for both samples, but the sample quenched from the higher temperature relaxes faster. Data of Hara and Suetoshi (1955).
:
where t is the time following a jump to temperature T. Empirically, the relaxation function can be represented by a sum of exponential terms, t
Mp = jump is very small, then the configurational change is also small, and the relaxation appears linear; however, nonlinearity is clearly seen for oxide glasses following jumps as small as 7°C (Rekhson and Mazurin, 1974). 3.4.1.5 Nonexponential Relaxation Function
The shapes of the curves in Fig. 3-17 or the right side of Fig. 3-16 define the relax-
(3-41)
exp(--
(3-42)
where the xk are independent relaxation times and the wk are weighting factors, or by the stretched exponential, Mp = exp
-
(3-43)
where the exponent /? has a value between 0 and 1; a smaller value of /? corresponds to a broader distribution of relaxation times. (As written, the preceding equations apply only to linear relaxation; for temperature
jumps of more than a few degrees, it is necessary to take account of the time dependence of rp by replacing t/zp with j dt/ xp. This is discussed in Section 3.4.4.) Eq. (3-43) was originally used by Kohlrausch (1847) to describe creep of metals under mechanical stress, and later was applied for modeling of creep and stress relaxation in oxides by DeBast and Gilard (1963, 1965). Williams and Watts (1970) found it useful for describing dielectric relaxation. It is now often called the Kohlrausch-William-Watts of KWW function and, as we shall see, it emerges from a wide variety of theoretical models of the glass transition. If it is approximated by a sum of exponential terms, as in Eq. (3-42), exp
Hi
p
expl-
(3-44)
k= l
the distribution of weighting factors varies with the exponent /? as shown in Fig. 3-18. To describe structural relaxation, typical values of /? are in the range of 0.6 to 0.8 (Mazurin, 1977), whereas /?^0.5 for stress relaxation (Rekhson and Ginzburg, 1976). Although the KWW function has some theoretical support, it does not provide a perfect description of the relaxation function when the data cover several orders of magnitude in t/xp, either for stress relaxation (Kurkjian, 1963), or structural relaxation (Scherer, 1986 a). The nonexponential character of structural relaxation is most clearly illustrated in a crossover experiment of the type shown in Fig. 3-19. The sample is quenched from temperature 7\ to T2 and held there until the refractive index reaches nd = a, which is the index of a liquid in equilibrium at temperature Tx; thus, the fictive temperature for the sample is now Tf = Tx. Then the sample is immediately transferred to a furnace at temperature Tx and nd is measured as a function of time
3.4 The Glass Transition
143
l(f
10°
0.6
-o.i 10' l
(x /T
°Sio p *>
Figure 3-18. Distribution of relaxation times obtained when the KWW function is represented by sum of exponential terms, as in Eq. (3-44); ft = 1 corresponds to a single relaxation time. As p decreases the distribution broadens, but always remains skewed to short times.
(Fig. 3-19b). Since a -1.51493 is the equilibrium index at that temperature we would expect nd to remain constant, but it clearly decreases (apparently moving away from equilibrium) before relaxing toward the equilibrium value. As noted by Ritland (1954), this demonstrates that a glass with a fictive temperature of Tf = Tx does not necessarily have the same structure as a liquid at equilibrium at Tx. Macedo and Napolitano (1967) concluded that the relaxation process must consist of at least two processes that relax exponentially: a fast process with relaxation time rf and a slow process with relaxation time TS. During the hold at T2, the fast process relaxes almost to equilibrium (C) while the slow process barely rises above B, but the average of the two produces an index of a. When the sample is exposed to Tx9 the fast process effectively experiences a downward quench from equilibrium at T2, while the slow process is effectively up-quenched. The dashed lines in Fig. 3-19 b represent the paths of these two processes during the isothermal hold at Tx9 and the solid curve shows their aver-
144
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
a)
*d T
2
C
\
C
i a i \— 4
B (
m a
.i. ••-
\
TEMPERATURE
TIME
(t)
1.51600
b)
1
Fast component 1.51493 + .00103 exp( - tl 7.77)
75 i
^ ^
50 t i *
25 _
Z O P
nd = a
1.51500 1.51493 1.51475 -
w Pi
+' **
50 --
\ Average Curve
Calculated
t
25 .
^pp 1.51400 -
S/ow component 1.51493 - 0.0111 exp (- tl 64.4)
4 t
1.51375 0
30
60
TIME
90
120
150
Figure 3-19. Scheme of crossover experiment used by Macedo and Napolitano (1967). a) Sample quenched from temperature T± to T2 shows instantaneous increase in refractive index from A to B, followed by relaxation toward equilibrium at C; a is index of liquid at equilibrium at Tx. When index reaches a, sample is transferred to furnace at Tx and change in index with time is followed, b) Refractive index (sodium d-line) versus time at Tx (o); solid curve is average of two dashed curves with relaxation times of rf = 7.77 and TS = 64.4 minutes.
180
(MINUTES)
age (assuming that each process contributes equally to the refractive index). Note that both processes approach directly toward equilibrium, but their average value moves away and then returns. If the relaxation process were simply exponential, the index could not move away from equilibrium.
3.4.2 Thermodynamic Aspects
Fig. 3-20 illustrates a phenomenon that is called the Kauzmann paradox. Kauzmann (1948) noted that the configuration entropy (Sc)-of the equilibrium liquid decreases so strongly with temperature that it would fall below the entropy of the cor-
3.4 The Glass Transition
Equilibrium liquid
s
d
responding crystal if extrapolated below temperature TK. This unacceptable situation is prevented by the glass transition, which freezes the configuration and "locks in" Sc at a value characteristic of the equilibrium liquid at Tg. What is disturbing is that the thermodynamic catastrophe is apparently prevented by the coincidental intervention of a kinetic phenomenon - the glass transition. Moreover, the interval between the Kauzmann temperature (TK) and Tg is often quite small, even at moderate cooling rates (Angell, 1988), so one could imagine cooling at such a slow rate that Tg would drop below TK. Kauzmann (1948) suggested that crystallization would always occur before TK, but that does not seem to be true in every case (Angell et al., 1986). Various theories propose that the reduction in Sc is arrested by thermodynamic phase transitions of first order (Grest and Cohen, 1981) or second order (Gibbs and DiMarzio, 1958), while Stillinger (1988) argues plausibly that no phase transition is likely. The existence of a phase transition must be regarded as an open question, but it is clear that an adequate theory of the glass transition must provide a resolution for this paradox.
145
Figure 3-20. The configurational entropy of the equilibrium liquid is dropping so fast that the entropy would fall below that of the crystal at temperatures < TK. This thermodynamic catastrophe is averted by the glass transition, which freezes the configurational entropy. This apparent coincidence (i.e., a kinetic escape from a thermodynamic problem) is called the Kauzmann paradox.
Davies and Jones (1953) considered the thermodynamic implications of having a single order parameter, such as Tf, that determines the state of a glass. They showed that the Prigogine-Defay ratio,
must have a value of unity if only a single order parameter exists. In Eq. (3-45), Acp is the difference in heat capacity between the equilibrium liquid and the glass, and Ax and A a are the corresponding differences in isothermal compressibility and volumetric thermal expansion coefficient, respectively; Vm is the molar volume. Data collected by Moynihan and Lesikar (1981) indicate that nTP has a value of ~ 2-5 for a variety of glass-forming liquids, so none can be characterized by a single order parameter. Gupta (1988 a) suggested that the fictive pressure could be used as a second order parameter. Irreversible thermodynamics can be used to develop a theory of relaxation based on the existence of an arbitrary number of order parameters (Moynihan and Gupta, 1978; Berg and Cooper, 1978). These models (discussed in Section 3.4.3.2) lead to a relaxation function in the form of
146
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
a sum of exponential terms, so they can be made to agree with experimental observations; unfortunately, the theory offers no clue as to the nature of the order parameters, nor the temperature dependence of the relaxation times. 3.4.3 Theories of Relaxation A wide variety of theories of relaxation have been developed based on distinct microscopic models, and only a few of the more important ones are presented here. This material is drawn from a more extensive review by Scherer (1990). It is convenient to categorize theories of relaxation as rheological models, which predict the temperature-dependence of the relaxation time (zp), kinetic models, which describe the form of the relaxation function (Mp), and relaxation models, which endeavor to explain both. The principal features that a complete theory must explain are nonlinearity (i.e., dependence of xp on structure) and nonexponentiality. The latter property is well described by the KWW equation, Eq. (3-43), and there is now an astounding number of models based on different physical principles that lead to that expression. Theorists have exploited two means of obtaining nonexponential relaxation: requiring cooperative relaxation or invoking heterogeneity (distributions of density or energy, or randomly situated acceptor/donor sites). In real glasses, both these factors are likely to be important, particularly near Tg, and a few theories have attempted to embrace both. Phenomenological models, which make no assumptions about the molecular-scale processes involved in relaxation, are discussed in detail in Section 3.4.4.
3.4.3.1 Rheological Models As indicated by Eq. (3-38), the relaxation time is proportional to the viscosity, so models for xp are equivalent to models for rj. That is why the term "rheological" is used to describe theories that account for the temperature dependence of xp. One of the most famous of these is the free volume theory developed by Cohen and Turnbull (1959, 1961, 1970). The idea is that flow occurs by movement of molecules into voids of a size greater than some critical size. That is, the molecules rattle around in the cage created by the surrounding molecules, until density fluctuations create a hole large enough to jump into. The free volume (v{) is somewhat vaguely defined, but it represents roughly the space not occupied by the core volumes (v0) of the molecules. According to this model the viscosity can be written as (Scherer, 1984 a)
TJ(a,-a )dr
(3-46)
g
where y is a constant (close to unity), Tfv is the fictive temperature for the volume, To is the temperature where v{ = 0, and oq and ocg are the expansion coefficients for the liquid and glass, respectively. The free volume depends on the actual atomic configuration, rather than the equilibrium configuration, so v{ is written in terms of the fictive temperature, rather than the actual temperature. At equilibrium (T{ = T), if al — ocg is constant, Eq. (3-46) reduces to the empirical Vogel-Fulcher-Tamman (VFT) equation: T-Tn
(3-47)
147
3.4 The Glass Transition
where rj0, A, and To are constants. The VFT equation is the most successful 3-parameter expression for describing r\ (T). In a liquid out of equilibrium, it is clear that Eq. (3-46) can account for nonlinearity, since it implies that TP = TP(T{). However, it fails to explain experiments of the sort represented in Fig. 3-21. In addition to measuring the equilibrium viscosity, Mazurin et al. (1979, 1981) have measured the isostructural viscosity: the sample is equilibrated at a high viscosity, then quenched to a slightly lower temperature where the viscosity can be measured before a significant amount of relaxation occurs; thus, they obtain the temperature dependence of rj when Tf is constant. The measurements made on a variety of oxide glasses indicate that the isostructural viscosity obeys the Arrhenius equation, AE
(3-48)
where Rg is the ideal gas constant and AE is an activation energy. The equilibrium viscosity obeys the VFT equation, Eq. (3-47), and the concave form of that curve corresponds to an apparent activation energy, AEA(T% that increases as the temperature decreases. Typically, the isostructural activation energy is about half of AEA(Tf). Note that Eq. (3-46) indicates that rj is constant when Tf is constant, so it cannot account for the isostructural data. The free volume model also fails to predict the change in Tg with applied pressure (Goldstein, 1963; Angell and Sichina, 1976). Recent developments of the free volume theory that correct some of these defects are discussed in the section on relaxation models. An entirely different picture of viscous flow, developed by Adam and Gibbs (1965), traces its motivation back to Kauzmann (1948). Gibbs and DiMarzio (1958)
17 NBS 710 ISOSTRUCTURAL
16
/
Tf =522X1 15
14
1
13
o 11
10
10
12
13
14
15
io4/r(K) Figure 3-21. Viscosity of soda-lime-silicate glass NBS 710 under equilibrium (Tf = T) and isostructural (T{ = constant) conditions measured by Mazurin et al. (1979). Isostructural data obtained by equilibrating at very high viscosity (10 135 Pa s) then quenching and measuring f]{T) before significant structural relaxation could occur. Curves calculated using AdamGibbs model for viscosity (Scherer, 1984 a).
presented a statistical mechanical theory that predicted a second order phase transition at the Kauzmann temperature TK to an ideal glass with configurational entropy (Sc) equal to zero, thus avoiding the thermodynamic catastrophe. This transition cannot be observed in practice, because TK lies below Tg, so the laboratory glass transition is merely a kinetic manifestation of an unattainable thermodynamic transition. Adam and Gibbs (AG) argued that the increase in viscosity as T-> Tg could be attributed to the loss of configurations available to the liquid. Their model is based on the idea that relaxation requires cooperative rearrangement of a group of z molecules. As the temperature drops and
148
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
the liquid becomes denser, movement of one molecule disturbs an increasingly large number of its neighbors; i.e., z increases as T decreases. AG assumed that the barrier to rearrangement increased in proportion to z (AE = z A\x, where zl^u is the potential barrier per molecule hindering rearrangement), and determined the temperature dependence of z in terms of S c . Their result is , = T0
exp
(3-49)
where S* is the configurational entropy of the smallest cooperatively rearranging subsystem (CRS); it is generally assumed that the latter must contain 2 configurations, so S?^/c B ln2. Eq. (3-39) has several appealing features. First, it provides an escape from the Kauzmann paradox: even if there is no phase transition, Sc can never fall below zero, because xp diverges as that point is approached; thus, even in an infinitely long experiment, Sc = 0 can only be approached asymptotically. In fact, to avoid the paradox it seems inevitable that either there is a phase transition or the relaxation time is a function of S" 1 , or both. Second, it is clear how the relaxation time (or viscosity) depends on the fictive temperature, since we can write (Howell et al., 1974; Scherer, 1984 a) fH
TV
Ac
(3-50)
to the Kauzmann temperature (i.e., the temperature where Sc extrapolates to zero). If TfH is constant, then so is S c , and Eqs. (3-38) and (3-49) yield Arrhenius behavior for the isostructural viscosity. In fact, the curves shown in Fig. 3-21 for both the equilibrium and isostructural viscosity were calculated from the AG equation. In addition to its ability to reproduce the form of rj (T), the AG equation is much more successful than the free volume model at predicting the effect of pressure on Tg (Goldstein, 1963; Angell and Sichina, 1976). Gupta (1987) has shown that it is also in qualitative accord with the observation that some liquids decrease in viscosity when subjected to compressive pressure (Sharma et al., 1979; Mysen et al., 1980; Angell etal., 1982). 3.4.3.2 Kinetic Models The order parameter model begins with the assumption that the free energy (g) depends on a set of order parameters (Zl9Z2, ... Zjy), in addition to T and P (Moynihan and Gupta, 1978; Berg and Cooper, 1978). The parameters Z- are not identfied with specific physical characteristics, such as free volume. According to the principles of nonequilibrium thermodynamics, the rate of relaxation may be written as dAZt At
(3 51)
"
j
k
1
where Acp = cpl — cpg; we have assumed that Sc(TK) = 0 and that the configurational entropy is governed by the fictive temperature of the enthalpy, H. At equilibrium we can approximate (Angell and Sichina, 1976) Acp ^const/7; so that Eqs. (3-49) and (3-50) lead to the VFT equation, Eq.(3-47), with To identified with TK. This is consistent with the observation that the value of To found empirically is often close
where we have defined the affinities At = —dg/dZt, as well as AZi=Zi—Zie (where Zie is the equilibrium value of Zt) and atj = —dAJdZj. The constants L(j are phenomenological transport coefficients, equivalent to relaxation frequencies \/xk. Eq. (3-51) leads to the following relaxation function for the response of property p to a change in variable x: (3-52)
3.4 The Glass Transition
This approach leads to some important conclusions about the nature of these relaxation functions; for example, MVT = MHP 7^ MVP. That is, the relaxation of the volume in response to a change in temperature is different from its response to a change in pressure, but is equivalent to the response of the enthalpy to a change in pressure. A particularly interesting version of the order parameter model, introduced by Gupta (1988 b), is based on the idea that the free energy of the system is related to the spatial gradients in the order parameters. For a single parameter this leads to a relaxation equation of the form
where T 0 and D are constants. Eq. (3-53) leads to a continuous distribution of relaxation times for Z. This theme recurs in many of the models discussed below: inhomogeneity in the structure of the liquid gives rise to nonexponential relaxation. A group of models based on the formalism of chemical reactions is discussed in an excellent review by Blumen et al. (1986). One class of model involves direct transfer of energy from a donor to an acceptor site. If the sites are uniformly distributed, relaxation is found to occur by a simple exponential decay; however, if randomness is introduced into the structure through an inhomogeneous distribution of sites, the decay becomes nonexponential. Let the energy transfer rate w (r) depend on the distance r between donor and acceptor; neglecting back-transfer, the probability of decay of the donor at rD to an acceptor at rA is ~rD)] (3-54) and this leads to a relaxation function of the form M.(t,r D ) = ]
'jlf{t,rA,rD)y\
(3-55)
149
where g^ is the probability of having j acceptors at one site. For isotropic multipolar interactions, the transfer rate is given by w(r) = a lVs
(3-56)
When this is used in Eq. (3-55), the relaxation function reduces to the KWW function, Eq. (3-43), with ft = d/s (where d is the dimension of space) and xp = aj [VdpQr(l-d/s)]s/d, where Vd is the volume of the unit sphere in d dimensions, p is the concentration of acceptor sites, Q is the density of sites, and F is the gamma function. If the sites are assumed to be distributed on fractals, the fractal dimension (df) replaces d in the preceding results. Another type of model assumes that donors or acceptors make random walks on a lattice and react instantly on meeting (Blumen et al., 1986). This produces simple exponential relaxation in 3 dimensions, but the KWW function if the random walk is performed on a fractal. Thus, the nonexponential relaxation results in this case from geometric randomness. Alternatively, the randomness can be introduced by allowing a distribution of waiting times before each step of the random walk, and this also leads to nonexponential relaxation. In hierarchical models, a diffusing particle must surmount a series of barriers of height 5; given an excitation AE=j5, the particle can move among j levels. The randomness introduced through the energy levels leads to nonexponential relaxation at low temperatures, but at high temperatures where the particle can move freely among the levels, the relaxation reverts to simple exponential decay. This is consistent with the relaxation behavior of real liquids. Ngai et al. (1986) have developed a coupling model They assume that the system consists of primary species with a relaxation rate Wo that controls the initial re-
150
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
sponse to an impulse. After a characteristic time (co ~ 1 ), coupling between the primary species modifies the relaxation rate,
W{T,t): ^•"-V/KO"-.
«:»i
<3 57)
-
The relaxation function is found from dM p_ _ = dt
-W(T,t)Mp
(3-58)
which leads to Eq. (3-43) with xp = \fia>l~p/ W0]1/fi. An example of the process envisioned in this model is the relaxation of a polymer, where the coupling comes from entanglement of chains, which interferes with the movement of a single chain only after an initial lag (Ngai et al., 1988). This model makes no assertions about the temperature or structure dependence of the relaxation process. It has been applied to the analysis of structural relaxation by making additional assumptions about those factors (Rendell et al., 1987), but Rekhson (1987) has challenged those assumptions. 3.4.3.3 Relaxation Models Nonlinear, nonexponential relaxation kinetics follow simply from the requirement that relaxation involve cooperative movement. This is consistent with the qualitative similarity seen in the relaxation kinetics of every class of liquid. That is, such behavior cannot be dependent on the details of bonding or structure, but must follow from some general phenomenon. A particularly nice example of this idea is the facilitated Ising model studied by Fredrickson and Brawer (1986) and Fredrickson (1986). Consider a set of Ising spins on a square lattice that are subjected to a magnetic field (h) that tends to make the spins flip down. A spin is allowed to flip only if two of its nearest neighbors are
"up", so the rearrangement is cooperative. To establish a connection with real glasses, the up and down spins could be imagined to represent regions of high and low density, respectively. As shown in Fig. 3-22, the smallest CRS in this model contains 4 configurations, rather than 2, as is often assumed in application of the AG model. The rate (Wt) at which a spin at site i flips from state ai to — o{ [where ot can be + 1 (up) or - 1 (down)] is
where co is an attempt frequency and mt is the number of neighbors in the "up" position. Monte Carlo simulations of this model indicate that it relaxes according to Eq. (3-43), with /? decreasing slightly with temperature. The relaxation time obeys the the AG equation, Eq.(3-49) [the configurational entropy is known exactly for this model]. The latter result requires a high degree of cooperativity: Fredrickson (1988) has extended this model to three dimensions, allowing a spin to flip when n neighbors are "up", and finds that the AG equation applies when n = 3, but not when n = 2. The beauty of the facilitated Ising model is that it assumes only a simple form of cooperativity, yet it reproduces the essential features of relaxation in viscous liquids.
\i
Figure 3-22. Smallest cooperatively rearranging subsystem (CRS) in the 2-spin facilitated Ising model has 4 configurations, since spins a and b can both flip.
3.4 The Glass Transition
Brawer (1984) has developed a much more specific model of relaxation that assumes that a local region of the liquid must be excited to a transition state with high energy and low density before that region can relax to a higher density. In this model, the size of the CRS is assumed to be independent of temperature. The most difficult problem in analyzing such a model is accounting for the overlap of the regions. Suppose the CRS has a radius of 10 atoms: then any single atom lies within ~ 103 such regions centered on different neighboring atoms, and it may participate in a rearrangement with any of those regions. This problem was ignored in the derivation of the AG equation. Brawer avoids it by limiting consideration to the earliest stage of relaxation (i.e., 1 — Mp<^ 1), when relatively few regions have transformed and the effect of overlap is negligible. The existence of density (or energy) fluctuations in the fluid produces a distribution of relaxation times, because the regions in a higher state of excitation relax first. The relaxation is nonlinear, because the distribution of energies depends on the temperature history. Thus, the model has all of the right features. Cohen and Grest (1979) and Grest and Cohen (1981) have developed a version of free volume theory that involves percolation of "liquid-like cells" (for a lucid discussion of percolation, and its connection to this theory, see Zallen (1983)). An atom vibrates in a cage in a solid-like manner unless the cage contains a sufficient amount of volume (v > vc\ in which case it is called liquid-like; free volume (vi = v — vc) is freely exchanged between liquid-like cells. Diffusion requires that vi exceed the molecular volume (vm); a cluster in which v{ >vm is liquid, rather than liquid-like. As the amount of free volume increases, the number of liquid-like cells increases to the point that a contiguous network (i.e., a percola-
151
tion cluster) appears, which gives macroscopic fluidity to the material. The free energy of the system is written explicitly in terms of the communal entropy, which is the contribution to the entropy resulting from the freedom of atoms in liquid-like cells to move within liquid clusters (i.e., it represents the accessible configurations of the system). The communal entropy biases the distribution of free volume so as to increase the number of liquid-like cells and suppress solid-like cells. This leads to a discontinuous change in the probability (px) of liquid-like cells as the temperature is reduced, which corresponds to a first order phase transition. The viscosity of the system is still given by Eq. (3-46), but an explicit expression for v{ is obtained that has a sufficiently complicated temperature dependence (involving 3 parameters) to account fully for actual viscosity data. Since the viscosity depends only on vf, this model still does not account for the isostructural viscosity. The above mentioned model was extended (Grest and Cohen, 1980) to account for structural relaxation by using Eq. (3-40) with p = Pi and xp given by Eq. (3-46); this allows for nonlinear exponential relaxation. Nonexponential behavior was obtained by assuming (Cohen and Grest, 1984) that each cluster relaxes independently at a rate proportional to its surfaceto-volume ratio (since relaxation involves diffusion of volume across the boundary of the liquid-like regions). This leads to a relaxation function in the form of Eq. (3-43). 3.4.4 Phenomenological Models 3.4.4.1 Tool's Equation
Phenomenological models (discussed in detail by Scherer, 1986 b) have been developed that permit accurate calculation of the changes in properties of liquids during
152
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
arbitrary thermal cycles. Great success has been obtained in the use of these models to predict stresses in composites, such as glass-to-metal seals, and in annealing and tempering of glass, as explained in Section 3.5. The first important step in the development of these models was taken by Tool (1945, 1946), who proposed, by analogy to viscoelastic stress relaxation, that structural relaxation of property p should obey pe(T)-p(T,t) dt
(3-60)
where pe(T) = p(T,oo) is the equilibrium value of the property at temperature T. Consider the relaxation following an instantaneous jump from temperature 7\ to T2. It is clear from Fig. 3-23 that the current value of p can be written as
a g (T 2 -T f (0)
p(T2,t)
(3-61 a)
i2
if
it
Temperature Figure 3-23. Relaxation of property p following jump from temperature Tx to T2; pe is the equilibrium value, a} and ocg are the values of dp/dT in the liquid and glassy states, respectively. The sample arrives at T2 at time t = 0 and relaxes toward p(T 2 , oo) = pe(T2).
(3-61 b) so (3-62) With Eqs. (3-61 b) and (3-62), Eq. (3-60) can be written in the form known as Tool's equation: (3-63)
dt
Tool's most important contribution was the suggestion that the effect of structure be incorporated by writing the relaxation time as , = T0
exp(-A1T-A2Tf)
(3-64)
Although this formula lacks theoretical justification, it was found to be quite effective in accounting for the nonlinearity of relaxation.
Ritland (1954) showed that Eqs. (3-63) and (3-64) can be used to predict the effect of cooling rate on Tg. The glass transition temperature corresponding to cooling rates q± and q2 can be shown to be related by (3-65) 1 In or dTa d\n\q\
(3-66)
Thus Tg increases logarithmically with the cooling rate, a result that was experimentally verified by Ritland (1954). The principal weakness of Tool's theory is that it uses only a single parameter, Tf, to represent the state of the glass. Ritland (1956) was the first to perform a crossover
3.4 The Glass Transition
153
experiment of the type shown in Fig. 3-19, and he did it to demonstrate that the structure is dependent on thermal history, so that glasses with a given value of property p (and hence a given Tf) are not structurally identical. The problem was clearly recognized, but was not resolved for another 15 years.
form of the VFT equation, Eq.(3-47), is needed to represent a wider temperature interval. If the relaxation function Mp is represented by Eq. (3-42), then the fictive temperature can be decomposed into "partial fictive temperatures" (PFT) (Rekhson, 1986; Scherer, 1986b)
3.4.4.2 Narayanaswamy's Theory
Tf= f> f c T f f c
A major stride was taken by Narayanaswamy (1971) who generalized Tool's theory by allowing for a distribution of relaxation times. (An essentially identical model was later proposed independently by Kovacs et al., 1979.) He obtained the following expression for the fictive temperature:
where each of the Tfk relaxes in a simple exponential manner with relaxation time ik (i.e., they individually obey Tool's equation). This is formally equivalent to the order parameter model described in Section 3.4.3.2, with each PFT representing an order parameter. When there is more than one, the Prigogine-Defay ratio, Eq. (3-45), will be greater than unity, as is found experimentally. Rekhson (1986) has shown how the crossover experiment can be understood in terms of the independent relaxation of the PFT. The measured property value reflects the average Tf, but the thermal history of the sample determines the distribution of PFT, and many different distributions can yield the same average. The two relaxation processes indicated in Fig. 3-19 b correspond to two partial fictive temperatures. Narayanaswamy's theory has been extensively tested [see e.g., Moynihan et al. (1976 b), Mazurin (1977), and Scherer (1986 b)] on many types of liquids, and it displays all of the necessary features. Nonexponentiality follows from use of Eqs. (3-42) or (3-43) to represent the relaxation function. The KWW function (introduced in this context by Moynihan et al., 1976 a) has been most useful, typically with 0.6 < ?<0.8. Nonlinearity is expressed using Eq. (3-69) with 0.4 < x < 0.6. The curves in Fig. 3-17 were calculated in this way (Scherer, 1986 a). A particularly striking ex-
(3-67) 0
where £ is the reduced time defined by (3-68) 0
T
p
and xr is the value of i p at some reference temperature. If the relaxation function is represented by a single relaxation time, as in Eq. (3-41), it can be shown (Scherer, 1986b) that Eq.(3-67) reduces to Tool's equation, Eq. (3-63). Narayanaswamy wrote the relaxation time in terms of the Arrhenius equation as xAE ,=
T0
exp
(l-x)AEl
(3-69)
where x, the nonlinearity parameter, divides the temperature dependence between the temperature and fictive temperature. This gives a better representation of the temperature dependence off/ or TP than Eq. (3-64), but still it is useful only over a limited range of temperature (typically ~100°C for a silicate glass). A function with the
(3-70)
154
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
575 540 494 420 (a)
0
40 80 120 240 280 320 t (min)
4
8
12 16
20
40
80 120 160 200 t (min)
78
(b)
0
100
90
Figure 3-24. Calculated curves and measured values (points) for change in length of specimen of soda-limesilicate glass (Tg = 524 °C): a) thermal history; b) isothermal holds at 494 °C (curve 1, lower time scale) and 540 °C (curve 2, upper time scale); c) entire thermal cycle. From Mazurin et al. (1975).
80
70
(c)
400
450
500
ample of the success of this theory is presented in Fig. 3-24: part a shows the thermal cycle, including cooling, reheating, and isothermal holds; part b shows the relaxation during the holds; part c shows the dilatometer curve for the entire cycle. The calculated curves in parts b and c are in excellent agreement with the data.
550
Experiments including temperature jumps, crossover, and continuous cooling can all be modelled quantitatively in this way, unless the range of temperatures examined is too broad. The origin of this limitation is not certain, but the most likely causes are (1) changes in the distribution of relaxation times (or, equivalently, changes
3.5 Viscoelasticity
in the exponent /? in the KWW equation) with temperature, and (2) the narrow range of applicability of the Arrhenius equation, Eq. (3-69). The first problem has been addressed by several models (Mazurin and Startsev, 1981; Scherer, 1986 a) but that seems to be less important than using a correct form for the relaxation time. A particularly effective modification (Scherer, 1984 a) is to represent xp by the AdamGibbs equation, using Eqs. (3-49) and (3-50). If, following Hodge (1987), we adopt the approximation J C p ^ c o n s t / T suggested by Angell and Sichina (1976), the relaxation time has the form
fit is equally good with Eq. (3-49) or (3-69), but the AG equation yields parameters that have physically reasonable values (e.g., pre-exponential factors with the correct order of magnitude). This version of the theory also provides an excellent description of the nonlinear relaxation behavior of the facilitated Ising model (Fredrickson and Brawer, 1986). Moynihan et al. (1974, 1976 b) showed that Eqs. (3.67) to (3-69) lead to an expression analogous to Eq. (3-66) for the dependence of T on cooling rate, q: dln(l/T g ) AE
,=?0exp
T(l-T K /T f )
(3-71)
At equilibrium, when T{ = % Eq. (3-71) has the form of the VFT equation, Eq. (3-47), with To identified with the Kauzmann temperature, TK, so it can correctly represent the shape of the equilibrium curve. Under isostructural conditions (Tf = constant), Eq.(3-71) has the form of the Arrhenius equation, Eq. (3-48), in keeping with experimental observations (see Fig. 3-21). In addition, Eq. (3-71) offers a theoretical foundation for the incorporation of the fictive temperature into rp9 and provides an expression for the nonlinearity parameter, x, (Hodge, 1987): : = 1-T K /T f
(3-72)
As noted by Howell et al. (1974), the AG equation is unique in that the parameters that control the shape of the equilibrium curve also dictate the slope of the isostructural curve. Hodge (1987) has found that incorporating the AG equation into Narayanaswamy's model gives a better fit than Eq. (3-69) to the enthalpy relaxation of polymers annealed far below Tg. In other cases (Scherer, 1984 a, 1986 a; Opalka, 1987; Crichton and Moynihan, 1988) the
155
(3-73)
Again, the shift in Tg with q depends on the temperature dependence of the equilibrium viscosity. Based on numerical evaluation of Eq. (3-67) with xp given by the AdamGibbs equation, Scherer (1984 a) concluded that the shift could be written in the general form dln(T.) iL —
(3-74)
Narayanaswamy (1988) has presented a rigorous analysis of the implications of Eq. (3-67) for the shift of Tg with q. The expressions derived by Ritland (1954) and Moynihan et al. (1974, 1976 b) were shown to be exact, regardless of the form of the relaxation function. Narayanaswamy finds that Eq. (3-74) is not exact, although it is numerically accurate.
3.5 Viscoelasticity The theory of viscoelasticity is presented in several texts, so only the essential elements are reviewed here. A mathematically rigorous treatment of viscoelasticity (VE) is given by Christensen (1982). A more readable discussion, with the emphasis on or-
156
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
2e
c)
a)
Figure 3-25. Modes of deformation of a unit cube: a) pure shear causes change of shape without change of volume; b) triaxial stress causes change of volume and, if the normal stresses are not all equal, change of shape; c) under uniaxial stress, the Poisson effect causes a strain in the directions normal to the applied stress, ex = —vaz.
ganic polymers, is provided by Ferry (1961). Scherer (1986b) presents the theory of VE, and shows how it can be combined with Narayanaswamy's theory of structural relaxation (1971) to calculate thermal stresses. This section is based on that book.
stress is applied, as in Fig. 3-25 b, there is a volumetric strain (e) given by AV
which is related to the hydrostatic (or dilatational) stress (a) by
3.5.1 Elasticity, Stress Relaxation and Creep
(3-77)
where
3.5.1.1 Elasticity The mathematical relation between stress and strain is called a constitutive equation. For an isotropic elastic material, such as glass, the constitutive equation requires only two parameters: the shear modulus (G) and bulk modulus (X), or Young's modulus (E) and Poissorfs ratio (v). A pure shear stress (Fig. 3-25 a) causes a change in shape without any change in volume, and the strain is related to the stress by azx = 2Gszx
(3-76)
(3-75)
The subscripts on atj and e^- indicate that axis i is normal to the plane on which the stress acts, and the stress acts in the direction of axis j ; for shear, i # j . When triaxial
(3-78) By definition, tensile stresses are positive; pressure (P) obeys the opposite sign convention, and is defined by P=-(crx + ay + oz)/3
(3-79)
If the stresses (ax, oy,oz) are not all equal, there is a change in shape as well as volume. For example, when the stress is uniaxial (Fig. 3-25 c), the stress and strain are related by az = Esz
(3-80)
In this case the stress can be shown to be 2/3 shear and 1/3 dilatation. The axial compression causes the cube to expand in
3.5 Viscoelasticity
157
the x and y directions; this is called the Poisson effect, and the strains are related by 8x = 8y = -V8z
(3-81)
For a general state of stress, the elastic constitutive equations can be written as (Timoshenko and Goodier, 1970) a)
1 ~E
(3-82 a)
1
(3-82 b) (3-82 c)
The constitutive parameters are interrelated as follows:
3(l-2v) E 2(1 9KG E= 3K + G 3K-2G v = 2(2K + G)
(3-83 a) (3-83 b)
Figure 3-26. Mechanical models of viscoelastic relaxation: a) the Maxwell element consists of a spring, corresponding to the elastic shear modulus G, and a dashpot (representing a piston moving through oil), corresponding to the shear viscosity \\\ b) dilatational relaxation is most simply represented by a spring, corresponding to the elastic bulk modulus K, in series with a Voigt element, which consists of a spring in parallel with a dashpot; the spring in the Voigt element limits the amount of volumetric contraction.
and the dashpot contributes the viscous flow. The compliance of this element is given by . , 1
(3-83 c) (3-83 d)
3.5.1.2 Creep and Stress Relaxation Stress causes flow of a viscoelastic (VE) material, so the constitutive parameters are functions of time. For instance, when a constant shear stress is applied, the shear strain is
t IT
(3-85)
If the viscosity is infinite (a fair approximation to the glassy state), the response is purely elastic (J1 = 1/2G); but if the viscosity is low, the elastic strain is negligible compared to the viscous strain. From Eqs. (3-84) and (3-85) it is clear that the viscous strain is comparable to the elastic strain when t = z, where T is the Maxwell relaxation time, (3-86)
If the Maxwell element is subjected to a constant strain, the stress relaxes accordwhere J1 is the shear compliance; the reing to sponse of a VE material to a constant stress is called creep, so J t is also called the tfz* = G«GiW (3-87) creep compliance. The simplest model for where the shear relaxation function is given viscoelastic behavior is the Maxwell eleby ment shown in Fig. 3-26 a. The spring provides the instantaneous elastic response G1(t) = 2Ge-«t (3-88)
6» =
(3-84)
158
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
At the instant that the strain is imposed, G1 (0) = 2 G, so Eqs. (3-87) and (3-88) indicate that the initial stress is the same as that in the purely elastic material, Eq. (3-75); the stress then decreases to zero as the sample flows in the direction of the applied stress. A VE material also relaxes under a purely hydrostatic load, but the volume cannot change very much, so the stress generally cannot relax to zero. When a constant hydrostatic stress is applied, the volumetric strain is given by
\ = aJ2(t)
(3-89)
where J 2 (0 *s the dilatational compliance. The simplest mechanical model representing dilatational relaxation is shown in Fig. 3-26 b. The compliance of this model is 1 3KD
xD = rjD/3KD
(3-91)
Note that the viscosity that controls volume relaxation is not necessarily the same as the shear viscosity; experimental evidence indicates that rjD is several times larger than r\, but has the same temperature dependence. These simple mechanical models faithfully represent the essential features of VE response, but the behavior of actual materials is more complex in detail. The shear relaxation function of oxide glasses must be represented by a distribution of relaxation times (which could be represented by a group of Maxwell elements in parallel), } E wk exp
G1(t) = 2 G e x p \ - l -
(3-93)
DeBast and Gilard (1963) showed that Eq. (3-93) gave a very good representation of the relaxation behavior of a soda-limesilicate glass, and Rekhson and Ginzburg (1976) showed stress relaxation in a wide variety of glasses could be described by Eq. (3-93) with /? = 0.5. This is only a good approximation, however, and very precise data cannot be adequately fit by Eq. (3-93). For example, Kurkjian's data (1963) for shear relaxation in a soda-lime-silicate glass require Eq. (3-92) with N = 6. The shear compliance of an oxide glass is given by
(3-90)
where the dilatational relaxation time is given by
N
or the KWW function,
(
t -
(3-92)
where 4>l (t) is a function that can be represented by a sum of exponential terms or the KWW function; thus, ^ ( 0 ) = ! and 0i (0 -~* 0 at t -> oo. Even when Gt and cj)1 (t) are both given by the same functional form, the relaxation times for relaxation and creep are not related in a simple way. The most convenient way to calculate G± from Jx, or vice versa, is to use the Laplace transform (Scherer, 1986 b). The second term in Eq. (3-94) describes the delayed elastic strain and Gd is the delayed elastic shear modulus. The three contributions to the shear strain can be understood schematically as follows. When the stress is first imposed, the instantaneous elastic response results from bond stretching with no change in the configuration of the molecules; the delayed elastic response results from gradual disentanglement of chains or clusters of molecules; viscous flow occurs as those structural elements slide past one another.
3.5 Viscoelasticity
When the stress is removed, the bonds immediately snap back to their natural length, so the elastic strain is recovered instantly. The delayed elastic strain is also completely recovered as the structure returns to its equilibrium configuration; this requires about the same period of time as the strain took to develop. The viscous strain does not recover. The dilatational compliance of an oxide can be written as z w
3K
3K D L
4>Z2V{t)] " /J
-t/Tu
ation time only by a factor of 3/2 (1 + v) « 1.2. For purposes of stress analysis, the dilatational relaxation can be entirely ignored, unless the sample is triaxially constrained, in which case shear deformation is inhibited. 3.5.1.3 Viscosity It can be shown that the shear viscosity is related to the shear relaxation function by
(3-95)
where 4>2 (t) is a function that can be represented by a sum of exponential terms or the KWW function. Corsaro (1976 a) showed that the dilatational relaxation of B 2 O 3 could be described by using the KWW function for (j)2 (t) with j8 = 0.60. The final strain was about three times greater than the instantaneous elastic strain, J2(ty/ j 2 (oo) = 0.30. He further showed (Corsaro, 1976 b) that, because of the nonexponential nature of the relaxation, the crossover effect (discussed in Section 3.4.1.5) could be produced by subjecting a sample to a series of pressure jumps. Since the dilatational modulus relaxes to a substantial fraction (typically ~ l / 3 ) of its original value, while the shear modulus goes to zero, it is not surprising that the relaxation of uniaxial or biaxial stresses is dominated by the shear behavior. For example, for a material whose shear response is given by Eq. (3-88) and which exhibits no dilatational relaxation at all (J 2 = 1/3K), the response to a constant uniaxial strain &z is (Scherer and Rekhson, 1982 a) (3-96)
Thus, shear deformation allows the uniaxial stress to relax to zero even though the stress is partially hydrostatic. The uniaxial relaxation time, TU , exceeds the shear relax-
159
(3-97) where x is an average relaxation time. If Gx is given by Eq. (3-92) (3-98) k =1
and if Gx is given by Eq. (3-93) (DeBast and Gilard, 1963), (3-99) where F is the gamma function. Comparing Eqs. (3-86) and (3-97) we see that the Maxwell relaxation time is the average relaxation time for the glass. Indeed, experimental studies confirm that the viscosity obtained from direct measurements (i.e., in creep experiments) agrees with the values found by integrating stress relaxation data, according to Eq. (3-97). Comparing Eqs. (3-38) and (3-97) we see that the structural relaxation time and the stress relaxation time are proportional to one another, but experiment (Rekhson, 1975) indicates that Kp is about an order of magnitude smaller than G, so stress relaxation is a much faster process. This is what makes it possible to measure the isostructural viscosity (Mazurin et al., 1979): a measurable amount of creep occurs before structural relaxation produces a significant change in 7^.
160
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
From Eqs. (3-84) and (3-94) it can seen that the shear strain rate in a creep experiment approaches the limit (3-100) If the applied stress is uniaxial (as is typically the case) rather than pure shear, the corresponding relation is At
3rj
(3-101)
Thus, the viscosity can be measured from the slope of a plot of strain versus time; it is only necessary to wait until the delayed elastic strain is fully developed. Oxide liquids exhibit Newtonian viscosity, which means that the viscosity does not depend on the magnitude of the stress that is applied. This also means that the relaxation time governing stress relaxation and creep is independent of the applied stress, so oxides are linearly viscoelastic. This is in contrast to the nature of structural relaxation in the same materials: the rate of structural relaxation depends on the size and direction of the temperature jump; the stress relaxation rate is the same for tensile or compressive stresses. Actually, this is only approximately true: if the stress is large enough to affect the structure of the liquid significantly, nonlinear effects appear. However, the stresses required to produce nonlinearity are large: for a soda-lime-silicate glass it can be shown (Scherer, 1986 b) that a pressure of 12MPa is thermodynamically equivalent to a temperature change of 1 °C. Nonlinearity is evident following temperature jumps of ~ 5 °C, so the same should be expected under applied pressures >60MPa. Indeed, Simmons et al. (1982) found non-Newtonian behavior under tensile stresses of that magnitude. Li and Uhlmann (1970) showed that alkali silicate
glasses exhibited non-Newtonian behavior under shear stresses exceeding ~ 100 MPa. In both cases, the viscosity decreased by an order of magnitude or more. This is consistent with molecular dynamics calculations which indicate that catastrophic changes in the structure of liquids occur under high stresses: the atoms arrange into layers that slide relatively easily. Particularly interesting effects are observed under purely hydrostatic loads. It is expected (intuitively, and particularly where the free volume model applies) that hydrostatic compression will increase the viscosity. However, Sharma et al. (1979) found that the viscosity of GeO 2 decreases under high compressive loads. It is known (Mysen et al., 1980) that network silicates exhibit this behavior when the average silicon atom has less than one nonbridging bond. Thus, highly modified networks, such as Na 2 O • SiO2 (with two nonbridging bonds per Si), show "normal" behavior (viz., rj increasing with pressure), but germania (with no nonbridging bonds) does not. This experimental result is supported by molecular dynamics calculations (Angell et al, 1982). 3.5.2 Temperature Dependence
The rates of relaxation and creep are strongly temperature-dependent. We first examine how the VE response varies in isothermal experiments at various temperatures, when the liquid remains in thermodynamic equilibrium during the experiment. Then we consider cases in which structural relaxation and stress relaxation occur simultaneously. 3.5.2.1 Equilibrium Liquid
Since the relaxation time is proportional to the viscosity, the rate of stress relaxation increases rapidly with temperature. For ex-
3.5 Viscoelasticity
161
and plot the data for T3 against log [t a (T3)], those data coincide with the other sets. In this way the shift function, a(T\ can be used to create a single master curve from all the data. This is possible for any materials whose relaxation function retains the same shape at all temperatures when plotted against \ogt. A material that exhibits this behavior is said to be thermorheologically simple (TRS). In terms of Eq. (3-92), TRS behavior is obtained when all of the relaxation times have the same temperature dependence (xk oc t] for all h) and the weighting factors
ample, if a constant shear strain is applied to a glass, the shear relaxation function varies with temperature as shown in Fig. 3-27. If the data are plotted against log £, as in Fig. 3-27 b, curves for different temperatures are identical in shape, but shifted along the abscissa. The distance, which we shall call log [#(71)], between points A and B is the same as that between points D and E. If the data for temperature 7\ are plotted against log t + log [a (T±)] = log [t a {T±)]9 they coincide with the data for temperature T2. Similarly, if we call the (negative) distance between points C and B log[a(T 3 )],
0.8
a)
25
1 0.8 0.6 2G
0.4 0.2 0
b)
0.001
0.01
1
i
i
0.1
1
10
log t
100
Figure 3-27. Shear stress relaxation function of thermorheologically simple material at several temperatures: a) relaxation rate increases with temperature; b) when plotted versus log t, the curves have the same shape, but are shifted along the abscissa.
162
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
are constant [w k ^w k (T)]t. If the relaxation function is represented by Eq. (3-93), TRS requires that the exponent /? be independent of temperature. In either case, the shift function represents the temperature dependence of the average relaxation time, (3-102) where, Tr is the reference temperature, the temperature of the data set onto which all of the others are shifted. In relaxation studies it is conventional to introduce the reduced time, (3-103) When T= TT, then £ = t; in general, £ is the time that would be required at Tr to relax to the same extent that occurs in time t at temperature T. Thermorheological simplicity was first noted by Leaderman (1943) in a study of organic polymers, and has been widely observed in oxides (see discussion in Scherer, 1986 b). It must be recognized that TRS is only approximately true: the distribution of relaxation times seems to become narrower at temperatures well above Tg. However, for oxides, TRS provides an excellent approximation at least within + 50°C of Tg, and this proves to be very helpful in analysis of thermal stresses, as we shall see in Section 3.5.3. 3.5.2.2 Nonequilibrium Liquid Hopkins (1958) pointed out that nonisothermal stress relaxation in a TRS mate-
t In principle, each of the relaxation times could have different temperature dependence and the weighting factors could change in such a way that the relaxation function retains the same shape. This seems improbable.
rial could analyzed by writing the reduced time in the form At1
= \a[T(t')]dt' (3-104) o
and replacing t with I; in the stress relaxation functions. During an isothermal test, £/T (Tr) = t/z; if T= Tr, then £ = t. This is an inescapable consequence of TRS of equilibrium liquids; however, it is not obvious that TRS will hold if the changing temperature causes the liquid to drift out of equilibrium. That is, the form of the relaxation function might change under nonequilibrium conditions. This proposition was tested in an ingenious experiment by DeBast and Gilard (1963), in which they measured structural relaxation and uniaxial stress relaxation simultaneously on the same sample. The equilibrium relaxation was found to obey a At)
MO)
-<-($]
(3-105)
with /? = 0.54. Nonequilibrium experiments were performed by equilibrating the sample at T1? then changing the temperature (by ~30°C) to T2 and simultaneously applying a load. Using measured values of rj (t) and assuming TU OC rj, they could predict the course of relaxation using
The calculated curves were found to be in excellent agreement with the relaxation function measured following the temperature jump. A similar study Rekhson et al. (1977) included changing loads as well as changing temperature; using measured values for rj (t% they obtained excellent agreement between calculated and measured creep strains. Thus, TRS does apply in nonequilibrium situations.
163
3.5 Viscoelasticity
3.5.3 Calculation of Thermal Stresses
this case, the true strain exceeds the free strain in layer A, so it is forced into compression, while layer B is stretched into tension. This type of thermal stress results from thermal expansion mismatch between dissimilar layers, and is common in composites. Another type of thermal stress results from temperature gradients within a compositionally uniform material; then layers A and B are the same material, but their free strains are different because each is cooled (or heated) by a different amount. This type of stress develops during rapid cooling of a liquid; it is exploited to strengthen glass objects by creating compressive stresses at the surface in a process called tempering (see Sec. 13.5.1). Such stresses are relieved by heat treatments near Tg, a process called annealing that allows VE relaxation; mismatch stresses cannot be removed by annealing, because new stresses develop on cooling from the annealing temperature.
Thermal stresses are of great importance in many applications of glasses, and the magnitudes of those stresses are dependent on both structural and stress relaxation. We briefly review the analysis of stresses caused by thermal expansion mismatch in composites, such as glass-to-metal seals, and the stresses that arise during rapid cooling of a liquid as it transforms into a glass. The origin of thermal stresses is illustrated in Fig. 3-28. Let layers A and B represent glass and metal components of a composite that shrink by different amounts when cooled by AT. The strains efA and efB are the free strains that occur if the materials are not bonded together; for example, if aA is the linear thermal expansion coefficient of A, then efA = ocA A T. When the layers are bonded together, then cooled, they are obliged to contract by the same amount, so the true strain, £A = £B, is a weighted average of the free strains. In
Free Strain A
A
True Strain A
£
fB
L a
e r
L a y e r
B
A
B
L a y e r
L a y e r
L a y e r
L a
A
B
A
Initial
y
Cooled
y e r
Joined
Figure 3-28. Stress caused by mismatch in thermal expansion: when layers A and B are cooled, they tend to contract by different amounts. The free strains, s{A and siB, are proportional to the thermal expansion coefficients of the layers. When the layers are joined, as in a composite, the true strain is the same in each, and is a weighted average of the free strains.
164
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
3.5.3.1 Glass-to-Metal Seals As a simple example of mismatch stresses in composites, we consider the sandwich seal shown in Fig. 3-29. To calculate the stress we begin with the elastic constitutive equations, modified to allow for the free strain. These equations have the form (Timoshenko and Goodier, 1970) 1
(3-107)
where the subscript i is G and M in the glass and metal layers, respectively. The symmetry of the problem requires that ax = oy, and sx = 8y; since there is no constraint perpendicular to the faces of the plates, az = 0. The force on the edge of each plate is axi 11 w, and the net force across the composite must be zero, so we require ^G'GW + ^MIMW = 0
(3-108)
The result is that the stress in the glass in the plane of the plate is
J (^G-^
(3-109)
where (3-110)
KG =
and n is a weighting factor called the stiffness ratio, given by lr
n=
W2
EM
(3-111)
Thus, the stress depends on the difference between the free strains in the layers. The free strain is calculated from the setting temper amre (Ts), the temperature below which the glass behaves elastically, to room temperature (TR). Typically such a composite is joined at a high temperature, where the glass layer flows readily, and
Figure 3-29. Planar composite called a sandwich seal consists of a plate of glass between two plates of metal (or conversely); total thickness of glass and metal layers is /M and / G , respectively, and width of seal is w.
stresses develop as the temperature enters the glass transition range. Choosing an appropriate value for Ts is something of an art, because the transition from liquid to elastic behavior does not happen suddenly at a given temperature, but develops continuously over a range of temperature. This problem does not arise in the VE analysis that we consider next. A rigorous calculation of the stresses in the sandwich seal can be obtained by starting with the VE constitutive equations, but they are complicated functions of time. Fortunately, for TRS materials the VE equations take on a simple form after application of the Laplace transform, and problems of thermal expansion mismatch can be solved in a straightforward way (discussed in detail in Scherer, 1986 b). If the uniaxial stress relaxation function for the glass is assumed to be given by Eq. (3-96), then Eq. (3-109) is replaced by (Scherer and Rekhson, 1982 b) TR
J
xG
r
t(TR)
dr/-i
— KoJexp - 1 f•(a G -oc M )dT
(3-112)
This differs from Eq. (3-109) in that the free strain is calculated from the temperature
3.5 Viscoelasticity
To where cooling starts, and the transition from liquid to glassy behavior is controlled by the relaxation time T G , given by T
*G=WT4
"
. ,
(3-H3)
[Calculations using a more realistic relaxation function for the glass lead to expressions more complicated than Eq. (3-112), but the average relaxation time for the composite is still given by Eq. (3-113).] The relaxation time for the composite depends on the stiffness ratio (a fact first recognized and explained by Rekhson and Mazurin, 1977) for the following reason. Suppose the sandwich consists of a very thin glass layer and thick metal layer, so that n is small. As the composite cools and the glass begins to stiffen, the larger metal component exerts a high stress on the glass, and forces it to flow, so the stress relaxes quickly. When n is small the glass cannot resist flowing under the force exerted by the metal until the viscosity becomes very high. On the other hand, if the glass layer is much thicker than the metal (n is large), the metal cannot exert much stress on the glass; then the glass 15
165
barely flows at all, and the stress relaxes slowly. This means that the effective setting temperature for the composite depends on ft, with Ts being lower when n is small, Rekhson (1979) (with experimental assistance from V. Ginzburg) studied the stresses in a series of sandwich seals made of the same materials, but with different stiffness ratios, and obtained the remarkable results shown in Fig. 3-30. Whereas the elastic solution predicts that the stress in the glass rises as the glass layer becomes thinner (because the elastic layer forces it to deform more), the data show the opposite trend. The reason is that the stiffness ratio controls the temperature at which the glass stops flowing, so the setting temperature changes with n. The elastic analysis provides no way to predict the magnitude of this effect, so the stresses are calculated assuming that Ts is independent of n. By taking account of both structural relaxation and viscoelasticity, Rekhson (1979) was able to predict the trend in stress with stiffness ratio (see curve 1 in Fig. 3-30). This result shows the importance of accounting for viscoelastic behavior in thermal stress analyses involving glass.
r-
10
20
30 lGl
40 I
60
Figure 3-30. Stress in sandwich seal (<JXG) at room temperature versus thickness ratio of glass and elastic layers (lG/lM), according to experiment (circles) and elastic solution, Eq. (3-109) (curve 2). Curve 1 is calculated taking account of both structural relaxation and viscosity. In these seals, the elastic layer is alumina. From Rekhson (1979).
166
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
10 Figure 3-31. Stress in sandwich seal (GXG) at room temperature versus stiffness ratio, n. VE analysis assuming single relaxation time, Eq. (3-112), yields curve 1; assuming three relaxation times (a good approximation to the measured relaxation function) yields curve 2. Both curves allow for structural relaxation in calculation of expansion coefficient and relaxation time, and agree with measured stresses (circles). Curve 3 calculated from VE analysis assuming three relaxation times, but ignoring structural relaxation.
When the VE analysis is used (Scherer and Rekhson, 1982 b; Scherer, 1986 b), the stresses are correctly predicted, as indicated in Fig. 3-31. Curves 1 and 2 represent VE calculations in which the uniaxial relaxation function of the glass is represented by one or three exponential terms, respectively, and they both give good agreement with the measured stresses. Both curves were calculated using Narayanaswamy's (1971) theory to account for the effects of structural relaxation on the thermal expansion coefficient and relaxation time. Curve 3 is obtained from the three-term relaxation function, but ignoring structural relaxation, and it is seriously in error. These results demonstrate two important facts: 1) it is essential to allow for the VE behavior of the glass to predict thermal stresses with accuracy, but it is acceptable to use a simplified expression for the relax-
ation function of the glass; 2) the VE analysis will be accurate only if proper account is taken of structural relaxation. 3.5.3.2 Tempering Tempering is a quenching treatment used to impart strength to a glass by creating high compressive stresses at the surface of the body (see Sec. 13.5.1). We include a brief discussion of tempering here, because the magnitude of the residual stress is controlled by viscoelastic and structural relaxation. The process is discussed in an excellent review by Gardon (1980). The residual stress distribution in a tempered plate is approximately parabolic, with tension
3.5 Viscoelasticity
The stored elastic energy in a tempered plate is also beneficial in the event of fracture, since it causes fragmentation into roughly cubic pieces, rather than the bladelike pieces created when an untempered plate breaks. Consider a plate of elastic material being quenched from a high temperature by air jets directed at its faces; as indicated in Fig. 3-32, a parabolic temperature distribution develops. The origin of the stresses can be understood from Fig. 3-28: B is the cooler surface layer and A is the hotter interior of the plate; the surface is stretched into tension, because the interior will not let it contract freely. As the plate cools, the interior and exterior both approach room temperature (7^), so the differential strain disappears and the stresses fade away. In a viscoelastic plate, if the initial temperature is
167
high enough, stress relaxation is so fast that the temperature distribution becomes established without creating any significant stresses. However, as the plate cools it becomes glassy, so that we have a stressfree elastic plate containing a temperature gradient (see Fig, 3-32 b, curve (2)), Suppose that the surface is at temperature Ts
L: (D and© \
CD a n d ©
Tension Compression
a) Elastic plate
b) Viscoelastic plate
Figure 3-32. Stress distribution during quenching of a plate of (a) elastic or (b) viscoelastic material. The stress, GZ (x), in the elastic plate is proportional to the parabolic temperature gradient, T(x), which is already parabolic by the time the surface has cooled to temperature Tx; az disappears when the plate reaches room temperature, TR (curve ®). In the viscoelastic plate, the stresses relax rapidly at high temperatures, so the temperature distribution is established without creating any corresponding stress (curves © and (J)). However, as the plate cools it solidifies; then as temperature becomes uniform at TR, the midplane contracts more than the surface, resulting in residual compression (curve (3)).
168
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
pression; in extreme cases, the transient' tension can cause fracture during cooling. This effect is indicated in Fig. 3-33: the maximum tempering is achieved only when the starting temperature exceeds ~ 650 °C, where stress relaxation is too fast to allow significant transient stresses. If the starting temperature is <550°C, the plate behaves like the elastic material in Fig. 3-32, and no residual stress is obtained. The preceding discussion ignored the influence of structural relaxation during quenching. In fact, the difference in cooling rate between the interior and surface of the plate causes a gradient in fictive tempera-
(Annealed glass)
5
2.5U -
^ o
2.512
o a>
Q. 2.510L ._ U)
c
a
2
2.508 --
2.506
\ \
Density N N "Stress-Free" \ as temperecT density p2 J P\ i
i
i
i
i
0.5
i
i
i
0.5 X/X n
-0.73 cm-
3000 Heat transfer coefficient cal/cm 2 °Csec
Figure 3-34. Density distributions in tempered glass shown by heavy curves, average densities by thin horizontal lines. Numbers identify specimens in order of increasing temper: 5, 4, 3, 1, 2; no. 1 represents commercial "full temper". Gardon (1978).
2500
S 5 Ok
I
2000
1500
1000 500 (natural convection)
500
600
700
800
Initial Temperature T' Figure 3-33. Degree of temper is a photoelastic measure of the tension at the midplane of a plate. In this study by Gardon (1965, 1980) it is shown to increase with quenching rate (characterized by the heat transfer coefficient), which increases the temperature gradient in the plate. If the starting temperature To is > 650 °C, the parabolic temperature gradient is established without significant stress, and the maximum tempering stress is achieved; no tempering is possible if T 0 <550°C, because the plate is elastic. Solid symbols represent samples that cracked because of transient tensile stresses at the surface.
ture, as well as true temperature. The magnitude of this effect is shown in Fig. 3-34: in the tempered plate, measurements of refractive index indicate that the density is high near the surface, but when the plate is broken into fragments to relieve the stress, the opposite trend appears. In the unbroken plate, the compressive stresses raise the density of the surface, but when the stresses are removed, the gradient in fictive temperature is revealed; the higher Tf produced by faster cooling at the surface corresponds to a lower density. Many models have been developed to predict the development of tempering stresses, and these are reviewed by Gardon (1980). The first to correctly incorporate viscoelastic effects was an analysis by Lee et al. (1965), which assumed TRS behavior
3.5 Viscoelasticity
169
in the glass. The result was o-z(x,t) = 3 j o
S
(3-114) f
7[sz(x,t')-aT(x,t
)]df
where R (£) is a biaxial relaxation function, the VE analogue of the quantity Ej 3 (1 — v). This is similar to the expressions for stress in composites given in Section 3.5.3.1, except that the reduced time is a function of position as well as time. The stress relaxes more quickly where the temperature is higher, and, since the stresses through the plate must balance, relaxation transfers the stress to the cooler layers. Thus, the stress that develops in any one layer is related to the stress development in all of the others, and the calculation is complicated. Narayanaswamy and Gardon (1969) compared the VE analysis, Eq. (3-114), to experimentally determined stresses, and found that it could successfully predict the transient stresses. Good predictions of the final stress were obtained only if the initial temperature was high, but in that case most of the stress comes from temperature equalization. Complete agreement with experiment was obtained only when Narayanaswamy (1978) included the effect of structural relaxation on the thermal expansion coefficient and stress relaxation time. As shown in Fig. 3-35, the stress is seriously underestimated if volume relaxation is ignored; neglecting the effect of structural relaxation on the viscosity is less important. This is similar to the comparison of curves 2 and 3 in Fig. 3-31, where accurate calculation of the stress in a composite was shown to require consideration of structural relaxation. For geometries more complicated than a plate, analytical solutions such as Eq. (3-114) are generally not available. Fortu-
500 600 700 800 Initial glass temperature 7^ (°C)
Figure 3-35. Effect of structural relaxation (SR) of density and viscosity (or stress relaxation time) on tempering stress calculated from viscoelastic model: without SR (dashed curve A); with SR (solid curve); structure dependence of viscosity suppressed (o, curve B); structure dependence of density suppressed (n, curve C). From Narayanaswamy (1978).
nately, finite element methods are now available that allow for both structural relaxation (using Narayanaswamy's theory) and viscoelasticity (see discussion in Scherer, 1986 b). Burke (1981) has applied finite element analysis to the problem of tempering, and obtained results in good agreement with the analytical result; the surface compression was found to be 89% greater when structural relaxation was incorporated in the calculation. 3.5.3.3 Annealing
Annealing is a process of controlled cooling that allows reduction of residual thermal stresses. For example, suppose a tempered plate is held near Tg until Tf (x) = Tg throughout the plate, so that the specific volume has its equilibrium value everywhere. If the plate is then cooled slowly enough so that no significant temperature gradients develop, the essentially elastic plate will arrive at room temperature with no residual stress. This is particularly important for optical glasses, because resid-
170
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
400
1
2 Time t (h)
500 T(°C)
600
Figure 3-36. Stress development during (a) cooling (3°C/min) and (b) annealing (4 h) of glass-toalumina sandwich seal using isothermal holds at (1) 500 °C and (2) 460 °C; inset shows strain versus temperature. Symbols are measured stresses; curves were calculated from VE analysis (Rekhson, 1979; see also Scherer and Rekhson, 1982 b).
3
ual stresses cause birefringence and inhomogeneity in refractive index. The effect of a given heat treatment can be calculated using the phenomenological theory development by Narayanaswamy (1971), and he discusses this application in a very good review (1986). In the case of a plate, the availability of an analytical solution allows the use of variational methods to calculate the optimal cooling schedule for annealing, providing the minimum stress for a given processing time (Narayanaswamy, 1981). Particularly interesting effects occur during annealing of composites, because the glass contracts during structural relaxation, but the elastic component does not. Therefore, structural relaxation causes the mismatch stress to rise, and VE relaxation
concurrently tends to reduce the stress. The results of this competition are illustrated in Fig. 3-36 by Rekhson's (1979) data for a glass-to-alumina sandwich seal. If the hold temperature is not far below Tg, the volume change during structural relaxation is not large and is completed quickly, and the rate of stress relaxation is relatively rapid, so the stress decreases substantially during the anneal (Fig. 3-36 a). At lower hold temperatures the glass is so far from equilibrium that the volume change accumulates throughout the hold, and the slow VE relaxation cannot eliminate the resulting stress; therefore, the net effect of the annealing treatment is an increase in tension (Fig. 3-36 b). If the hold were maintained long enough, the stress would pass
3.6 References
through a maximum at 460 °C (when structural relaxation was complete), and the stress would eventually relax to zero. In some cases, the stress developed during low-temperature annealing can cause fracture of composites. However, judicious use of annealing allows the stress in the composite to be adjusted either upward or downward.
3.6 References Adam, G., Gibbs, J.H. (1965), J. Chem. Phys. 43, 139-146. Angell, C. A. (1988), J. Chem. Phys. Solids 49, 863871. Angell, C. A., Sichina W. (1976), Ann. N. Y Acad. Sci. 279, 53-67. Angell, C.A., Cheeseman, P. A., Tamaddon, S. (1982), Science 218, 885-887. Angell, C. A., MacFarlane, D.R., Oguni, M. (1986), Ann. N. Y Acad. Sci. 484, 241-247. Ashby, M. F. (1974), Ada Metall. 22, 275-289. Berg, J.I., Cooper, A.R., Jr. (1978), J. Chem. Phys. (5^4481-4485. Blumen, A., Klafter, J., Zumofen, G. (1986), Optical Spectroscopy of Glasses. Hingham, MA: Reidel Publ. Co., 199-265. Brawer, S. A. (1984), J. Chem. Phys. 81, 954-975. Brawer, S.A. (1985), Relaxation in Viscous Liquids and Glasses. Columbus, OH: American Ceramics Society. Brinker, C. X, Scherer, G.W. (1990), Sol-Gel Science. New York: Academic Press. Burke, M. A. (1981), Report TR8102, MARC Analysis Research Corp., Palo Alto, CA. Cahn, J. W. (1956), Ada Metall. 4, 572-575. Chalmers, B. (1964), Principles of Solidification. New York: Wiley. Christensen, R. M. (1982), Theory of Viscoelasticity, 2nd. ed. New York: Academic Press. Christian, J. W. (1975), The Theory of Transformations in Metals and Alloys, Part I. New York: Pergamon Press. Coble, R.L. (1961), /. Appl. Phys. 32, 787-792. Cohen, M.H., Grest, G.S. (1979), Phys. Rev., B20, 1077-1098. Cohen, M.H., Grest, G.S. (1984), /. Non-Cryst. Solids 61/62, 749-760. Cohen, M. H., Turnbull, D. (1959), /. Chem. Phys. 31, 1164-1169. Cohen, M. H., Turnbull, D. (1961), J. Chem. Phys. 34, 120-125. Cohen, M. H., Turnbull, D. (1970), /. Chem. Phys. 52, 3038-3041.
171
Cooper, A. R (1985), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 71, 5-17. Corsaro, R. D. (1976a), Phys. Chem. Glasses 17, 1322. Corsaro, R. D. (1976 b), I Am. Ceram. Soc. 59, 115118. Crichton, S.N., Moynihan, C. T. (1988), /. NonCryst. Solids 102, 222-227. Davies, H. A. (1976), Phys. Chem. Glasses 17, 159173. Davies, R. O., Jones, G. O. (1953), Adv. Phys. 2, 370410. Dearnley, R. (1983), Nature 304, 151-152. DeBast, J., Gilard, P. (1963), Phys. Chem. Glasses 4, 117-128. DeBast, X, Gilard, P. (1965), IRSIA Comptes Rendus de Recherches, No. 32. Dietzel, A., Wickert, H. (1956), Glastech. Ber. 29, 1-4. Ferry, XD. (1961), Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers. New York: Wiley. Fredrickson, G.H. (1986), Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 484, 185-205. Fredrickson, G. H. (1988), Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 39, 149-180. Fredrickson, G.H., Brawer, S.A. (1986), J. Chem. Phys. 84, 3351-3366. Frenkel, X (1945), /. Phys. (Moscow) 9, 385-391. Gardon, R. (1965), Proc. Vllth. Int. Cong. Glass, Charieroi, Belgium. Paper 79. Gardon, R. (1978), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 61, 143-146. Gardon, R. (1980), Glass: Science and Technology, Vol. 5: Elasticity and Strength in Glasses. New York: Academic Press, 145-216. Gibbs, J.H., DiMarzio, E.A. (1958), J. Chem. Phys. 28, 373-383; 807-813. Goldstein, M. (1963), /. Chem. Phys. 39, 3369-3374. Grange, R. A., Kiefer, X M. (1941), Trans. ASM 29, 85-115. Grest, G.S., Cohen, M.H. (1980), Phys. Rev. B21, 4113-4117. Grest, G. S., Cohen, M. H. (1981), Advances in Chemical Physics, Vol. 48, New York: Wiley, 455-525. Gupta, P.K. (1987), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 70, C152C153, Gupta, P.K. (1988a), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 102, 231239. Gupta, P. K. (1988 b), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 102, 250254. Gutzow, I., Kashchiev, D., Avramov, I. (1985), /. Non-Cryst. Solids 73, 411-499. Hara, M., Suetoshi, S. (1955), Rep. Res. Lab. Asahi Glass Co. 5, 126-135. Heyes, D. M., Kim, XX, Montrose, C.X, and Litovitz, T.A. (1980), J. Chem. Phys. 73, 3987-3996. Hillig, W.B. (1966), Acta Metall. 14, 1868-1869. Hodge, I. M. (1987), Macromolecules 20, 2897-2908. Hoffman, X D. (1958), J. Chem. Phys. 29, 1192-1193. Hopkins, I.L. (1958), J. Polym. Sci. 28, 631-633. Hopper, R. W, Scherer, G., Uhlmann, D. R. (1974), /. Non-Cryst. Solids 15, 45-62.
172
3 Glass Formation and Relaxation
Howell, F. S., Bose, R. A., Macedo, P. B., Moynihan, C.T (1974), J. Phys. Chem. 78, 639-648. Huling, J.C., Messing, G.L. (1989), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 72, 1725-1729. Jackson, K. A., Uhlmann, D. R., Hunt, J. D. (1967), /. Cryst. Growth 1, 1-36. James, P. F. (1974), Phys. Chem. Glasses 15, 95-105. James, P. F. (1985), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 73, 517-540. Kashchiev, E. (1969), Surf. Sci. 14, 209-220. Kauzmann, W. (1948), Chem. Rev. 43, 219-256. Kelton, K.F., Greer, A. L. (1986), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 79, 295-309. Kelton, K . F , Greer, A.L., Thompson, C.V. (1983), J. Chem. Phys. 79, 6261-6276. Kohlrausch, R. (1847), Pogg. Ann. 12, 393. Kovacs, A. I , Aklonis, J. X, Hutchinson, J. M., Ramos, A. R. (1979), J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed. 17, 1097-1162. Kurkjian, C.R. (1963), Phys. Chem. Glasses 4, 128136. Leaderman, H. (1943), Elastic and Creep Properties of Filamentous Materials. Washington, D.C.: Textile Foundation. Lee, E.H., Rogers, T. G., Woo, T. C. (1965), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 48, 480-487. Li, J. H., Uhlmann, D. R. (1970), /. Non-Cryst. Solids 3, 127-147. Macedo, P.B., Napolitano, A. (1967), /. Res. 71 A, 231-238. MacFarlane, D. R. (1982), /. Non-Cryst. Solids 53, 61-72. Mackenzie, J. K., Shuttleworth, R. (1949), Proc. Phys. Soc. 62, 838-852. Magill, J. H., Li, H. M., Gandica, A. (1973), J. Cryst. Growth 19, 361-364. Mazurin, O. V. (1977), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 25, 130169. Mazurin, O. V., Startsev, Yu. K. (1981), Sov. J. Glass Phys. Chem. 7, 274-279 (Engl. transl). Mazurin, O.V., Rekhson, S.M., Startsev, Yu. K. (1975), Sov. J. Glass. Phys. Chem. 1, 412-416 (Engl. transl.). Mazurin, O.V., Startsev, Yu.K., Potselueva, L.N. (1979), Sov. J. Glass. Phys. Chem. 5, 68-79 (Engl. transl.). Mazurin, O.V., Stolyar, S.V., Potselueva, L.N. (1981), Sov. J. Glass. Phys. Chem. 7, 222-227 (Engl. transl.). Moynihan, C.T, Gupta, P.K. (1978), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 29, 143-158. Moynihan, C.T, Lesikar, A.V. (1981), Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 371, 151-164. Moynihan, C.T, Easteal, A.J., Wilder, J., Tucker, J. (1974), J. Phys. Chem. 78, 2673-2677. Moynihan, C.T, Easteal, A.J., DeBolt, M.A., Tucker, J. (1976a), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 59, 12-16; 16-21. Moynihan, C.T, Macedo, P. B., Montrose, C.J., Gupta, P.K., DeBolt, M. A., Dill, J.F, Dom, B.E., Drake, P.W, Easteal, A. I , Elterman, P.B.,
Moeller, R. P., Sasabe, H., Wilder, J. A. (1976 b), Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 279, 15-35. Mysen, B.O., Virgo, D., Scarfe, C M . (1980), Am. Miner. 65, 690-710. Narayanaswamy, O. S. (1971), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 54, 491-498. Narayanaswamy, O. S. (1978), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 61, 146-152. Narayanaswamy, O. S. (1981), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 64, 109-114. Narayanaswamy, O. S. (1986), Glass: Science and Technology, Vol. 3: Viscosity and Relaxation. New York: Academic Press, pp. 275-318. Narayanaswamy, O. S. (1988), /. Am. Ceram. Soc. 71, 900-904. Narayanaswamy, O. S., Gardon, R. (1969), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 52, 554-558. Ngai, K. L., Rendell, R. W, Rajagopal, A. K., Teitler, S. (1986), Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 484, 150-184. Ngai, K.L., Rajagopal, A.K., Teitler, S. (1988), J. Chem. Phys. 88, 5086-5094. Onorato, P.I.K., Uhlmann, D.R. (1976), J. NonCryst. Solids 22, 367-378. Opalka, S.M. (1987), Ph.D. thesis, Rensselaer Polytechnic Inst., Troy, N.Y, USA. Prassas, M., Hench, L. L. (1984), Ultrastructure Processing of Ceramics, Glasses and Composites. New York: Wiley, pp. 100-125. Rabinovich, E. M. (1985), J. Mater. Sci. 20, 42594297. Ramachandrarao, P., Cantor, B., Cahn, R. W. (1977), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 24, 109-120. Rekhson, S.M. (1975), Sov. J. Glass Phys. Chem. 1, 417-421 (Engl. transl.). Rekhson, S.M. (1979), Glass Technol. 20, 27-35; 132-143. Rekhson, S.M. (1986), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 84, 6885. Rekhson, S.M. (1987), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 95/96, 131-148. Rekhson, S. M., Ginzburg, V. A. (1976), Sov. J. Glass Phys. Chem. 2, 422-428 (Engl. transl.). Rekhson, S. M., Mazurin, O. V. (1974), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 57, 327-328. Rekhson, S.M., Mazurin, O. V. (1977), Glass Technol. 18, 7-14. Rekhson, S.M., Bulaeva, A.V, Mazurin, O.V. (1971), Sov. J. Inorg. Mater 7, 622-623 (Engl. transl.). Rekhson, S. M., Gonchukova, N. O., Chernousov, M. A. (1977), Proc. Xlth Int. Cong. Glass, Prague, Vol.1, 329-338. Rendell, R. W, Ngai, K. L., Fong, G. R., Aklonis, J. J. (1987), Macromolecules 20, 1070-1083. Ritland, H.N. (1954), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 37, 370378. Ritland, H.N. (1956), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 39, 403406. Rowlands, E.G., James, P.F. (1979), Phys. Chem. Glasses 20, 1-8.
3.6 References
Scherer, G.W. (1977), /. Am. Ceram. Soc. 60, 236239. Scherer, G.W. (1984a), /. Am. Ceram. Soc. 67, 504511. Scherer, G.W. (1984b), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 67, 709715. Scherer, G.W (1986a), /. Am. Ceram. Soc. 69, 374381. Scherer, G. W (1986 b). Relaxation in Glass and Composites. New York: Wiley. Scherer, G.W. (1987), Surface and Colloid Science, Vol. 14. New York: Plenum Press, pp. 265-300. Scherer, G.W (1990), /. Non-Cryst. Solids 123, 7 5 89. Scherer, G.W, Rekhson, S.M. (1982a), /. Am. Ceram. Soc. 65, 352-360. Scherer, G.W, Rekhson, S.M. (1982b), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 65, 399-406. Sharma, S. K , Virgo, D , Kushiro, I. (1979), J. NonCryst. Solids 33, 235-248. Simmons, J. H , Mohr, R. K , Montrose, C. J. (1982), J. Appl Phys. 53, 4075-4080. Stillinger, F. H. (1988), /. Chem. Phys. 88, 7818-7825. Takahashi, K , Yoshio, T. (1973), Yogyo Kyokai-Shi 81, 524-533. Tanner, L. E , Ray, R. (1979), Ada Metall 27,17271747. Thomas, I. M. (1974), U.S. Patent 3 791808 (Feb. 12, 1974). Thompson, C.V., Spaepen, F. (1979), Ada Metall. 27, 1855-1859. Timoshenko, S.P, Goodier, J.N. (1970), Theory of Elasticity, 3rd. ed. New York: McGraw-Hill. Tool, A.Q. (1945), /. Res. 34, 199-211. Tool, A.Q. (1946), J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 29, 240-263. Turnbull, D. (1964), Proc. Int. Conf. on Physics of Non-Crystalline Solids, Delft. Amsterdam: NorthHolland, pp. 41-56. Turnbull, D. (1969), Contemp. Phys. 10, 473-488. Uhlmann, D.R. (1969), Materials Science Research, Vol. 4. New York: Plenum Press, pp. 172-197. Uhlmann, D. R. (1972 a), Advances in Nucleation and Crystallization in Glasses. Columbus, OH: American Ceramics Society, pp. 91-115. Uhlmann, D. R. (1972 b), /. Non-Cryst. Solids 7, 337348. Uhlmann, D . R , Chalmers, B. (1965), Ind. & Eng. Chem. 9, 19-31. Uhlmann, D . R , Yinnon, H. (1983), Glass: Science and Technology, Vol.1: Glass-Forming Systems. New York: Academic Press, pp. 1-47. Uhlmann, D . R , Klein, L , Onorato, P.I.K., Hopper, R.W. (1975), Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf 6th., pp. 693-705.
173
Uhlmann, D . R , Onorato, P . I . K , Scherer, G.W. (1979), Proc. Lunar Planet. Sci. Conf. 10th., pp. 375-381. Vil'kovskii, S. S. (1988), Sov. J. Glass Phys. Chem. 14, 463-470 (Engl. transl.). Vreeswijk, J.C.A, Gossink, R.G., Stevels, J. M. (1974), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 16, 15-26. Weinberg, M . C , Zanotto, E. D. (1989 a), J. NonCryst. Solids 108, 99-108. Weinberg, M . C , Zanotto, E.D. (1989b), Phys. Chem. Glasses 30, 110-115. Williams, G , Watts, D.C. (1970), Trans. Faraday Soc. 66, 80-85. Yamane, M , Kojima, T. (1981), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 44, 181-190. Yinnon, H , Uhlmann, D.R. (1981), /. Non-Cryst. Solids 44, 37-55. Zallen, R. (1983), The Physics of Amorphous Solids. New York: Wiley. Zanotto, E . D , James, P. F. (1985), J. Non-Cryst. Solids 74, 373-394. Zarzycki, J. (1982), Advances in Ceramics, Vol. 4. Columbus, OH: American Ceramics Society, pp. 204-216.
General Reading Glass transition: Brawer, S.A. (1985), Relaxation in Viscous Liquids and Glasses. Columbus, OH: American Ceramics Society. Sintering and crystallization of gels: Drinker, C.J, Scherer, G.W (1990), Sol-Gel Science. New York: Academic Press; Chap. 11. Theory of nucleation and growth: Christian, J.W (1975), The Theory of Transformations in Metals and Alloys, Part I. New York: Pergamon Press. Tempering: Gardon, R. (1980), Glass: Science and Technology, Vol. 5: Elasticity and Strength in Glasses. New York: Academic Press; pp. 145-216. Annealing: Narayanaswamy, O.S. (1986), Glass: Science and Technology, Vol. 3: Viscosity and Relaxation. New York: Academic Press: pp. 275-318. Viscoelasticity, glass-to-metal seals: Scherer, G.W (1986 b), Relaxation in Glass and Composites. New York: Wiley. Kinetics of glass formation: Uhlmann, D. R , Yinnon, H. (1983), Glass: Science and Technology, Vol. I: Glass-Forming Systems. New York: Academic Press; pp. 1-47.
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids Philip H. Gaskell Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, U.K.
List of 4.1 4.1.1 4.1.2 4.1.3 4.1.4 4.1.5 4.2 4.2.1 4.2.1.1 4.2.1.2 4.2.2 4.2.2.1 4.2.2.2 4.2.2.3 4.2.3 4.2.3.1 4.2.3.2 4.2.4 4.2.4.1 4.2.4.2 4.2.4.3 4.2.4.4
4.3 4.3.1 4.3.2 4.3.3 4.3.3.1 4.3.4 4.3.4.1 4.3.5 4.3.5.1 4.3.5.2
Symbols and Abbreviations Introduction Rationale Background Liquids, Crystals, Glasses, Quasicrystals and "Amorphous" Solids Types of Order Outline Conceptual Models Randomness as the Paradigm Dense Random-Packed Hard Sphere Models Random Networks Crystallographic Order as the Paradigm Simple Microcrystallite Models "Quasi-Crystalline" Models "Paracrystalline" Models Non-Crystallographic Order as the Paradigm "Curved-Space" Models Polytetrahedral Models Constrained Disorder as the Paradigm. Stereo-Chemically Defined Models Similarity to Random Networks Similarity to Paracrystalline Models Local Order as a Consequence of Medium-Range Order Stereo-Chemically Defined Models for Close-Packed Oxides and Amorphous Metals Involving Medium Range Structure-Forming Operations Experimental Structural Techniques Neutron Scattering Techniques - Static Structural Methods X-Ray Scattering Effects of Disorder on Scattering Data "Termination" Smearing Polyatomic Solids Total Distribution Functions and Structure Factors Extraction of Partial Structure Factors Combination of the Results of X-Ray, Neutron and Electron Scattering . . Neutron Scattering with Isotopic Substitution
Materials Science and Technology Copyright © WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co KGaA. Allrightsreserved.
178 180 180 181 182 183 185 186 186 187 188 188 189 190 190 191 192 193 193 196 196 196
198 199 199 201 202 202 203 203 204 204 205
176
4.3.5.3 4.3.5.4 4.3.5.5 4.3.6 4.3.7 4.3.8 4.4 4.4.1 4.4.1.1 4.4.2 4.4.3 4.4.4 4.4.5 4.4.6 4.4.6.1 4.4.7 4.5 4.5.1 4.5.1.1 4.5.1.2 4.5.2 4.5.2.1 4.5.2.2 4.5.3 4.5.4 4.6 4.6.1 4.6.2 4.6.2.1 4.6.2.2 4.6.3 4.6.4 4.6.5 4.6.5.1 4.6.5.2 4.6.6 4.6.7 4.6.8 4.7 4.7.1 4.7.2 4.7.2.1 4.7.2.2
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
"Difference" Methods 205 X-Ray Absorption Spectroscopy 206 X-Ray Anomalous Scattering 208 Vibrational Spectroscopy 208 High Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy 210 Nuclear Magnetic Resonance 212 Modelling Techniques 214 Construction of Atomic Models for Amorphous Solids 214 Physical Models 215 Molecular Dynamics 215 Potential Energy Functions 217 Energy Minimisation 219 Monte Carlo Calculations 219 Validation of the Model: Calculation of Microscopic and Macroscopic Properties 220 Bond Length Distributions 221 Calculation of Dynamical Properties 223 Elemental Tetrahedral Semiconductors 223 Amorphous Ge and Si 224 Local Structure - Diffraction Data 224 Local Structure - Complementary Techniques. Medium-Range Structure . 227 Amorphous Carbon 229 Static Properties 229 Excitations 231 Network Models - Static Properties 233 Models for Amorphous Carbon 236 Amorphous Silica 238 Experimental Situation 238 Local Structure 239 Diffraction Data 239 Complementary Techniques 239 Medium-Range Structure 240 Random Network Models 241 Ordered Models 244 Quasi-Crystalline Models 244 Microparacrystalline Models 244 Simulation of Dynamical Properties 245 Molecular Dynamics Models 247 Monte Carlo Simulations 248 Binary Alkali and Alkaline Earth Silicates, Borates and Phosphates 250 Apologia 250 Local Structure Around "Network Modifiers" in Oxide Glasses 251 Diffraction and EXAFS Data 251 Complementary Techniques 256
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
4.7.3 4.7.3.1 4.7.3.2 4.7.4 4.7.4.1 4.7.4.2 4.7.5 4.7.6 4.7.7 4.7.8 4.8 4.8.1 4.8.2 4.8.3 4.9 4.10
Medium-Range Structure Centred on "Network-Modifiers" in Oxide Glasses Diffraction Data Complementary Techniques Speciation Borates Silicates Network Models Molecular Dynamics Microcrystallite Models Stereo-Chemically Defined Models Concluding Remarks Information Content Microscopic and Macroscopic Properties Structural Models - Present and Future Acknowledgements References
177
257 257 259 259 259 260 264 265 266 267 269 270 271 273 274 274
178
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
List of Symbols and Abbreviations b ca dhkl n-D E / (Q) F (Q) g (r) g (co) G (r) i (Q) / J (r) k kB M (Q) na N Nc NF N (r) Nj P*p{r) P* (r), P*fi (x) q Q Qn rap
neutron scattering length concentration of atomic species a distance between crystal planes with Miller indices hkl rc-dimensional energy atomic scattering factor reduced interference function pair distribution function vibrational density of states function reduced radial distribution function interference function intensity, nuclear spin radial distribution function photon or photoelectron wave vector Boltzmann constant modification function atomic fraction of species a coordination number, number of atoms number of constraints number of degrees of freedom running coordination number coordination number of j ' t h atomic shell P a i f correlation function between atomic species a and /? peak shape function phonon scattering vector scattering vector, modulus Q number of bridging oxygens (n) (around Si in this case) interatomic distance between atoms of species a and /? mean bond length of i'th shell radius o f / t h shell of atoms structure factor glass transition temperature melting temperature mean square displacement of atomic species i Debye-Waller factor for atomic species i weighting factor for atoms of species a and p electronic charge on atoms of species a atomic number
5 e X (k)
phase shift dielectric function; e l 9 s2 are real and imaginary parts /c-dependent normalised EXAFS signal potential energy
List of Symbols and Abbreviations
CO
wavelength photoelectron mean free path atomic (number) density average atomic (number) density standard deviation of a scattering angle (conventionally 2 6) frequency
CRN CTF DRP EELS ESR EXAFS fee hep HRTEM IR MASNMR MC MD NMR PE ppm PT RDF SCD TEM TM-m TMS XAFS XANES XAS
continuous random network contrast transfer function dense random packed (model) electron energy loss fine structure electron spin resonance extended X-ray absorption fine structure face centred cubic hexagonal close packed high resolution transmission electron microscopy infra-red magic angle spinning NMR Monte Carlo molecular dynamics nuclear magnetic resonance potential energy parts per million polytetrahedral radial distribution function stereo-chemically defined transmission electron microscopy transition metal-metalloid tetramethyl silane X-ray absorption fine structure X-ray absorption near edge spectroscopy X-ray absorption spectroscopy
X A Q(r) Qo
a (a) 9
179
180
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
4.1 Introduction 4.1.1 Rationale Knowledge of the structure of a material is central to any adequate understanding of its properties. For most classes of solids, for gases, many polymers - including biological macromolecules - such knowledge exists and there is a well-established link between structure at the atomic level and macroscopic properties. Liquids and glasses can be excluded from this statement. The structure of most glasses is not even understood in simple qualitative, conceptual terms. With the added complications of thermal motion, liquids present even more intractable difficulties. Reasons for this state of affairs are not difficult to find. Translational periodicity implies enormous simplification of the experimental, theoretical and conceptual problems. Experimentally, the phase-related response of atoms in identical unit cells to the stimulus of electromagnetic radiation, for example, results in strong signals of high information content, in energyor reciprocal-space. Theoretical models based on the small cluster of atoms comprising the unit cell are readily constructed and optimised to fit experiment. And the conceptual problem hardly exists; experiment provides many or most of the necessary clues. Glasses, on the other hand, have aperiodic structures and at some level are isotropic. Experimental data are therefore extensively averaged - scrambled, indeed - so that the signal is weak with low information content. Much of the symmetry information is lost. Theoretically, modelling loses its rigour: approximations are inevitable, computations become unwieldy because of the large (strictly infinite) size of the models and are constrained not only by limited experimental information but also by computational uncertainties.
The conceptual problem is perhaps the most unsettling. Many macroscopic properties become intelligible simply by recognising the essential microscopic behaviour at a qualitative level. Sharp lines in the vibrational spectrum of a crystal can be seen as the phase-related response of equivalent atoms in all unit cells. But how does one explain, to oneself or to a student, the residual effects associated with (crystal) momentum in an amorphous solid to which the concept is strictly inapplicable, since there is no unit cell; or, ionic migration, that in the crystal can be thought of in terms of defect-controlled mechanisms, when the glass is "all one big defect"? It is therefore relatively easy to argue that the art of modelling the structure of amorphous solids is central to any understanding of their macroscopic properties. Certainly, further progress in the development of this extensive family of sociallyimportant materials depends on it. A representative atomic model, with accurate interatomic forces, allows us to simulate nature. It then becomes possible to compute physical and chemical behaviour ranging from straightforward properties such as the density, through to electronic, optical and magnetic characteristics. Dynamic events can be followed on the computer including processes that occur on time scales that are impossible to achieve in the laboratory. New materials can be explored, computationally, by formation at quench rates that would not easily be attainable to practice. Techniques for producing and exploring atomic models have grown to represent a major area of computational science. Not principally for the reasons advanced in the previous paragraph - those attractions are largely for the future - but as a response to the experimental problem of translating incomplete, inadequate structural data in-
4.1 Introduction
to meaningful models. For the reasons discussed above, structural information available from an experiment on an amorphous solid is minute compared to that routinely acquired from an experiment on a crystalline powder. In 1983 it seemed "fairly safe to assume that no single experimental structural technique, nor perhaps any combination, will in the near future provide a sufficiently large bank of information that we can 'solve' the structure (of a glass) in the sense that the structures of crystals have been solved" (Gaskell, 1983). This statement may be more arguable now but the need to combine structural data from many techniques, or from a number of related techniques and several materials remains. And the task of combining that information is made easier by cross-reference and adaptation of models that try to represent that data - and is only complete when all of the information is encapsulated in an acceptable model. It is to this area that modelling has been attracted in the past, and has proved its worth. The speed with which computational power is now becoming accessible to the average experimentalist, as well as to the theoretician, implies that this movement will accelerate in the future. Indeed, user-friendly atomic modelling systems must become the essential tool of the experimental scientist or technologist working on materials in future years. This increase in available computational power exerts a new pressure - to develop adequate models that are consistent with experiment, rather than simplified, idealised models whose principal merit is the ease of programming. The challenge of this chapter is to set out the ground rules, to present the knowledge that has been established and that which needs to be gained. The approach is deliberately experimentally biased. Although
181
the mechanics of computer generation of models, for example, must form part of this chapter, the major thrust is to depict what experiments - including computer experiments - can tell us, where they are defective and how we need to make them more sophisticated. Secondly, it will be important to pare down the concepts and, not only to deconstruct, but also to reconstruct the bones of new approaches. 4.1.2 Background We begin by restating those characteristics of the glassy or amorphous states of matter that relate directly to structural questions; either by informing those questions or because the characteristics themselves require structural interpretations. By definition, glasses are non-crystalline solids. Conventionally, we regard the glassy state as that persisting below a characteristic glass temperature, Tg9 at which the material becomes metastable both with respect to the global thermodynamic ground state corresponding to the crystal and to the local equilibrium represented by the supercooled liquid. Separating the glass from the super-cooled liquid is a socalled "glass transition" that has resemblance to a thermodynamic second order transition but, operationally, can be regarded as a departure from equilibrium imposed by the increased viscosity of the melt. The transition thus has some characteristics related to the time-dependence of "structural relaxations" including wellknown hysteresis effects in differential scanning calorimetry signals, for instance. Apart from unsettled questions concerning the dynamical interaction responsible for the glass transition, the continuous nature of the transition has implications for structure. In contrast to the essential discontinuity that lies at the heart of the change of
182
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
state from the liquid to the crystalline solid - expressed through the appearance of a nucleus and extension of the crystal/liquid interface, discontinuous changes in energy, volume etc. marking the thermodynamic first order transformation - there is no evidence for any change of state during the glass transition. The structure of the glass and that of the liquid - whatever they may be - have essential similarities. Glass formation may be seen as a process in which crystallization is avoided - a feature that has been stressed by Turnbull (1969). Glasses are formed when the disordered structure characteristic of the liquid is preserved from temperatures above TM, where the disordered state is thermodynamically stable, to temperatures below Tg where the disordered, glassy state is kinetically stable. Crystallization, involving diffusional motion of atoms is, like all such transport processes, "frozen out" below T%. The tendency of the material to crystallize or devitrify has important structural implications, of course. In a real sense this is the obvious reference point for microcrystallite models for glasses, and yet there is still the need to reconcile this approach with structural changes that are implicit in the nucleation of a crystal. A further instability relates to the tendency of many multicomponent glasses to "phase separate". Microphase immiscibility is characteristic of many simple liquids and is well understood in that context in thermodynamic terms. Again, the transition from a single phase liquid at high temperatures to a multiphase immiscible liquid mixture as the temperature is reduced, can be seen as a progressive increase in the relative importance of energetic (ordering) parameters rather than entropic terms. Operationally, the boundaries of immiscibility have been defined in compositiontemperature-time space although a satis-
fying explanation in atomistic terms is still awaited. The implications of immiscibility for structural studies are two-fold. Firstly, there is the experimental problem that single phase glasses exist only over limited composition ranges, so that the experimentalist finds it difficult to explore many otherwise interesting compositions. Secondly, the obvious tendency of some glasses to become unmixed on a scale of micrometres implies - like the crystallization transition - the possibility of separation into two or more phases at an atomic level. "Granularity" at this level is thus by no means foreign, as judged by the behaviour of glasses in macroscopic terms. 4.1.3 Liquids, Crystals, Glasses, Quasicrystals and "Amorphous" Solids
The brief survey of the characteristic properties of glasses shows them to be intermediate between the ordered crystalline state on the one hand and the essentially disordered, time-dependent structure of liquids on the other. Glasses can be thought of as being liquids with diffusional atomic motion subtracted. Studies of the structure of glasses - although of intrinsic value - gain added importance as an entree into the more difficult studies on liquids. Not only are glasses necessarily more ordered than the corresponding melt, by virtue of a reduction in diffusive motion, vibrational motion is also suppressed as a result of lower measurement temperatures. Structural data therefore suffers less thermal broadening. Quasicrystals may provide another link. Several metallic alloys form quasicrystalline and glassy phases so that the relationships between them are currently a matter for considerable interest and speculation. Both phases require special preparation conditions - rapid quenching for in-
4.1 Introduction
stance - to avoid formation of stable or metastable crystalline phases. Both phases are clearly defective. Both may be related to an underlying structural principle - possibly the same structural principle. Sharing the same structural diagnostics - lack of order and metastability - are a whole family of "amorphous solids" typified by evaporated films of, say, Si, Se, H 2 O, and amorphous metals. These may or may not be, strictly, glasses under the above definition. Films deposited from the vapour phase or by atom by atom deposition do not necessarily relate at all to other condensed states of matter except that of the crystal. Structurally, deposited films range from those that may have more resemblance to a loose aggregate of molecules such as certain oxides or sulphides of As or P, or they may form giant frameworks entirely analogous to the network glasses. It has become customary to distinguish amorphous solids from "true" glasses by the presence or otherwise of a glass transition, rather than by any exclusively structural characteristic. Amorphous solids may thus defined by the absence of changes in the heat content near Tg9 although, in practice, such changes may be masked by crystallization. 4.1.4 Types of Order
By definition and from experience, glasses are disordered on some length scale. Experiment shows, however, that the vast majority of glasses have recognisable order over a length scale corresponding to first neighbour distances. How should the order in a structure be specified? Firstly, we recognise that if a complete set of atomic coordinates were, by magic, available to use, we would find this unhelpful - as anyone who has modelled
183
even a 1000-atom cluster knows. Structural information is required in the form of distribution functions, local symmetry, a geometrical description, orientational relationships, distribution of chemical species - features, in fact, that are most useful in discussing the structure of a crystal with a large unit cell. We consider the following facets of a structural description. Positional, or geometrical, order. Assuming that a local arrangement of atoms can be identified - a coordination polyhedron and a central atom - we can specify the extent of order through the mean, (rt >, and standard deviation, a(r£), (and higher moments if necessary) of bond length, bond angle distributions and the number of neighbours - the coordination number. An ordered arrangement implies a narrow distribution of first neighbour distances and, ideally, an identifiable coordination number, Nc - rather than a continuous increase in N(r) with increasing r. Comparison with a compositionallyequivalent crystalline phase may show some correspondence between values for crystals and glasses and this can be taken as further evidence for ordering - although not necessarily for a crystallographic model of ordering. If the parameters for higher order neighbour shells can be extracted - and usually they can, with more difficulty, to second neighbours - then
184
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
tural parameter. In many cases, symmetry information alone can be used to decide between alternative models with different local symmetries. In previous paragraphs it has been convenient to discuss structural parameters in terms of a length scale that is implicit in the word "local structure". This can be taken to mean the structural characteristics of the immediate environment of a given atomic species out to perhaps second neighbours. The upper limit is arbitrary but since it is usually only possible to analyse experimental correlation functions without recourse to models, out to second neighbours, then it has a certain aptness. At the other extreme of the length scale, glasses are clearly geometrically disordered and as experiment suggests a limit of about 1.5 to 2.0 nm to be the shortest distance at which deviations from randomness can be seen, then this marks the lower limit of what is often termed the long-range structure. There still remain deviations from a structureless solid but such deviations are confined to compositional inhomogeneities occurring on a length scale of about 2 to 200 nm. From second neighbour distances at 0.4-0.5 nm to 1.5 nm between the limits for local and long range structure - comes the "intermediate range" structure or "medium-range" structure. (Often the terms medium-range structure and medium-range order are used interchangeably, but since the latter, clearly, implies order it seems better to use the more neutral term, structure.) Medium range structure is less easy to define in terms of geometry or symmetry, so that topology generally provides a specification. In amorphous tetrahedral semiconductors, for instance, the network topology expressed as the relative proportions of nmembered rings, represents one of the few ways of clearly distinguishing competing models.
Compositional ordering represents a further structural characteristic. For a polyatomic solid, this may be relevant on all length scales: local (compositional) ordering in an amorphous Co-P alloy represents the distinction between models in which Co atoms preferentially cluster around P and alternatives in which Co-Co and P-P pairs are preferred, or in which the distribution is random - determined only by the relative numbers of each type of atom and their relative atomic radii. Compositional ordering, at local and medium-range structural levels, is also important as in certain polyatomic oxide glasses, and in Si: H "alloys". In crystalline lithium silicates, for example, the silicon-oxygen anions have formal charges that vary with the concentration of Li. Considering the mixture of oxides (Li 2 O) x (SiO 2 )i- x ; the composition with x = 0 corresponds to a structure in which all four oxygens are "bridging" that is, they are linked to two silicons. In NMR terminology this is usually specified by the notation Q4 representing four bridging atoms around the tetrahedral (Quaternary) atoms. As x increases, so does the number of non-bridging oxygens so that the fraction of Q4 atoms decreases with corresponding increases in Qn (n<4). The various silicate "species" are shown in Fig. 4-1 for random and compositionally-ordered silicate glasses. In a random model, all species are expected to be present in proportions governed by the average composition, energy and temperature etc. Experiment, especially NMR measurements, allows some definition of the relative proportions of each species so that anionic "speciation" becomes an important structural characteristic. We can thus specify the extent to which a given composition leans towards competitive models in which the majority of species present corresponds to that of the compositionally-equivalent crystalline phase.
4.1 Introduction
185
immiscibility, corresponding to TM
Figure 4-1. Various silicate species Q" in silicate glasses (schematic), a) Elementary g 3 tetrahedron with 3 bridging and 1 non-bridging oxygens, b) Example of isolated and paired non-bridging oxygens, c) Compositionally ordered glass, d) Random network.
Compositional ordering is also evident in the long-range structure of polyatomic glasses. As with other liquids, complete miscibility of several components is only conditionally possible. For reasons that are not always obvious in structural terms, the thermodynamically stable state of a glass in the liquid or super-cooled liquid states may be multi-phase rather than single phase. The boundaries in compositiontemperature-time space are understood in terms of well-established (thermodynamic) parameters. Experimentally, the multiphase nature of a particular glass becomes obvious as a separation into two or more distinct liquid-like phases on a length scale of a few tens of nanometres upwards. (Complete separation into two immiscible liquids can occur - stable immiscibility when the two-liquid state is preferred at temperatures above TM, but metastable
As a direct result of the limited amount of experimental data obtainable for all amorphous solids and glasses, it becomes necessary to extract all the information obtainable from a given technique or, preferably from a combination of complementary techniques. In order to interpret the data it is crucial to express it in terms of candidate models, then to compare models and experimental data and try to achieve agreement to the limits of accuracy, both of experiment and the simulation technique. Unless comparison is made at this level of detail, then the results can be disappointing and even misleading. Models of many different types can be made to agree with the general features of structural data if the only data available is the total correlation function with a relatively low information content. On the other hand, experimental data of the highest information content currently available - partial pair correlation functions - have not yet been modelled to the accuracy of experiment and of computation. An account of models for the structure of glasses must include, therefore, a critical analysis of the results of particular techniques, and a synthesis of results from other techniques or from other related materials. The strategy for this chapter is to begin (Sec. 4.2) with a discussion of the various conceptual models for amorphous solids starting with extreme models based on randomness on the one hand and crystal-like order on the other. We then pass to models that are ordered but without underlying
186
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
crystallographic order as the rationale. These are the so-called icosahedral, or curved-space models related, perhaps, to quasicrystallinity. We also try to express in words what is implied in other hybrid models that are less easy to describe: those based on twinning, or on constrained randomness, or stereochemically-constrained models. Section 4.3 discusses some of the experimental structural techniques in outline and presents a summary of the formal definition of structural parameters. Emphasis is placed not so much on the details of the techniques but on the results that are obtainable and their value in providing useful experimental data. Other chapters in this series provide the essential background. Section 4.4 considers how models can be made and tested either by computer simulation techniques such as Monte Carlo or Molecular Dynamics algorithms that exhibit little or no bias towards a particular model. We also consider models that are based on crystals - either as a convenient starting point or as the result of "intuition" and those within which certain structure-forming rules are embedded which restrict the range of possible outcomes. We then examine how these models may be validated by comparison with experimental data and the corrections necessary to allow accurate comparisons. Sections 4.5 to 4.7 is where all the above - which is essentially preamble - is tested against reality. Three case histories are given of structural campaigns. Examples are selected to allow conclusions to be drawn about the nature of the amorphous state in materials such as a-Si, through silica, to the relatively complex polyatomic silicates and similar oxide glasses. The final section attempts to bring together what has been learned and compares this with what can and should be
known, with some suggestions for new approaches. Structures of metallic glasses are treated in Vol. 1, Chap. 4, those of chalcogenide glasses in Chap. 7 of this volume. Structural relaxation is fully treated in Chap. 3, and the special case of structural relaxation in metallic glasses in Chap. 9 of this volume. The diffraction concepts used here are treated in depth in Vol. 2, Chap. 8.
4.2 Conceptual Models The plain experimental facts that glasses and amorphous solids are metastable with respect to crystals, that glasses and amorphous solids can be produced by rapid quenching from the melt or vapour, naturally tend to condition our views on structure. Glasses may be considered to be an approach to the crystalline state or as a departure from the liquid state. Extreme models for the structure of glasses - microcrystallite models or random packing models - encapsulate these two preconceptions. Even if only as a framework for discussion it is useful to try to classify models in terms of the paradigms or patterns they can be said to represent. 4.2.1 Randomness as the Paradigm
Experiment immediately dispels any notion that glasses or amorphous solids can be represented as some kind of completely chaotic "frozen atomic gas". Nearest neighbour distances only rarely show significant departures from values expected for crystals or those obtainable from tables of appropriate atomic radii. This would be expected on the basis of macroscopic properties: densities and enthalpies, for example, differ by only a few percent from values appropriate to crystals, so that a signif-
4.2 Conceptual Models
icant number of broken or extensively strained primary bonds is not expected. All random models for glasses start with atoms in contact in the case of DRP models or with essentially fully interconnected local polyhedral units for random networks. In both cases the first neighbour bond lengths are constrained. 4.2.1.1 Dense Random-Packed Hard Sphere Models Pioneering experiments by Bernal (1964) on the structure of monoatomic liquids have proved to be immensely influential in directing subsequent research on the structures of dense-packed alloys, amorphous halides and, by extension, oxides. Bernal's early experiments moulding ball bearings packed into rubber bladders, which were then kneaded and set in black paint, have since been replaced by computer simulation and 3-D graphics. Although the detail has changed, the basic concepts persist. Bernal showed that non-crystalline aggregates could be produced by constraining the exterior surface to an irregular contour. The interatomic arrangement could then be analysed in terms of five deltahedra, "canonical polyhedra" (Fig. 4-2), with a strong preference for tetrahedra and half octahedra.
187
Later computer modelling by Finney (1970) refined the figures for the relative proportion of each polyhedral type, but with the introduction of soft interaction potentials by Finney and Wallace (1981) in an energy minimization routine, the proportions of large polyhedra dropped significantly. The only major contributions remaining were from tetrahedral and half octahedral interstices. The influence of the DRP model can be gauged by the degree to which its salient features were retained in the modifications required to include new knowledge. An example is the extension of DRP monoatomic models to include additional elements. Models were proposed and tested in which atoms of two or more species were assigned randomly to sites in a monoatomic hard sphere structure. An alternative (Polk, 1972), designed for transition metal-metalloid glasses, incorporates the smaller metalloid in the large Bernal holes (Archimedean antiprisms or trigonal prisms). Recently, similar DRP structures have been simulated by sequential addition to a seed, using spheres of two sizes and realistic potential functions. Models of this type can, in principle, be constructed with polyatomic units of any shape and size. In practice, only rarely have attempts been made to construct
(i) Figure 4-2. Polyhedra formed by packing of equal spheres: i) tetrahedron, ii) octahedron, iii) trigonal prism capped with three half octahedra, iv) Archimedean antiprism capped with two half octahedra, v) tetragonal dodecahedron. After Bernal (1960).
188
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
models of randomly packed molecules, for example. 4.2.1.2 Random Networks
Closely allied to DRP models are random networks. Indeed the two are mutually interconvertible, by suitable decoration of a DRP model, say. The rationale here is that if a local structural unit can be defined - such as a silicon tetrahedron in amorphous silicon - then the random network is created by connecting such units with no rules other than on each addition of a unit to the existing cluster, their relative orientations shall be unconstrained. Additional restrictions, such as reduction of the number of "dangling" bonds to some arbitrary fraction, choice of ring statistics, or the inclusion of constraints relating to minimum strain energy or to a specified density, may be added at a later stage. Models of this type are very flexible in that the constrained unit can be considered to be as large as experimental data requires. That is, if it is clear that a local structural unit can be defined, random connection of these units then provides a realistic non-crystalline model - even if the size of the "local" structural unit is similar to that of a unit cell. Most, if not all, successful models could be considered to fall within this class. By common usage, though, the term has come to mean a random grouping of n-atom "molecular" units with n in the range 1 to 10. The term "random network" is inextricably linked with Zachariasen (1932) who proposed "that the atomic arrangement in glass is characterized by an extended threedimensional network which lacks symmetry and periodicity" (Fig. 4-3 a). This model gained support as a result of Warren's work on silica by X-ray diffraction (Warren et al., 1936) and the essential features
of the Warren-Zachariasen model persist today. Variations in the composition are easily incorporated as a random addition of species other than Q4 with associated alkali or alkaline earth cations, Fig. 4-3 b. That any random network can extend indefinitely to form a "continuous" random network, CRN, does not appear to have been proved. Phillips (1979) has suggested that continuity may be only conditionally possible - the key parameter being the relation between the number of mechanical degrees of freedom per atom, 7VF, and the relevant number of constraints, Nc. By defining constraints to mean the forces acting on an atom from its neighbours - given by the number of independent terms in a valence force field, Phillips suggests that Nc = NF represents the condition for "ideal" glass-forming compositions. In the chalcogenides NC = NF for a composition where the average number of bonds per atom is 2.4 - corresponding to As 2 S 3 . Amorphous Si, on the other hand, is "over-constrained" and, Phillips argues, cannot be represented by a CRN without intrinsic defects. Some of the defects may take the form of an extended mediumrange structure or interfaces in a granular structure.
4.2.2 Crystallographic Order as the Paradigm
Similarity between structural parameters, such as the structure factor S(Q) or the pair correlation function, for glasses and compositionally-equivalent crystals is a common circumstance. This provides support for the notion that glasses can be thought of as assemblies of microcrystals. Strain introduced due to lattice mismatch at grain boundaries, the presence of a disordered interfacial or matrix region, and
4.2 Conceptual Models
a
189
b
Figure 4-3. Schematic two-dimensional representation of the structure of a) SiO2 (only three bonds are shown); b) a sodium silicate glass. The Na atom marked with an asterisk is isolated. Greaves' "Modified random network", Fig. 4-63, does not include such atoms, see Sec. 4.7.5 (Zachariasen, 1932 and Warren et al, 1936).
defects such as dislocations, or stacking faults can be assumed to give rise to departures from periodicity at distances smaller than the average grain size. 4.2.2.1 Simple Microcrystallite Models In an unqualified form, a microcrystallite model for glasses rightly receives no experimental support. Cargill's early work on a possible model for amorphous Ni-P alloys showed that a model based on 2 nm regions with hexagonal close packing of Ni atoms (which make the major contribution to the X-ray scattering data) was inadequate to explain experimental data (Cargill, 1970). Variations in stacking fault density, dilatation and lattice symmetry proved insufficient to reconcile models
with experiment. Similarly, although the clear impression gained from comparisons of the rdfs of amorphous and crystalline Ge is that the structure to second neighbours is similar in both forms, beyond that, there is virtually no recognizable agreement. This is indicated by the almost complete absence of the third peak in a-Ge at about 0.47 nm, Fig. 4-4. Amorphous and crystalline Ge are thus fundamentally different and since the R 3 peak at 0.47 nm is due to correlations across 6-fold rings, its absence in the correlation function for a-Ge might suggest a relative decrease in the proportion of 6-fold rings in favour of 5-fold rings, in which three bond distances are equivalent to those to second neighbours. The structural differences may thus relate to essential topological variations.
190
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
lation length. Comparison with experiment may be through the reciprocal space
function, F(Q) = Q(S(Q)-1)
and F{Q)
calculated by the modified sine transform:
F ( 0 = ]Gc(r)F(r) sin (Qr)dr
(4-1)
o and Here, Qc(r) is the r-dependent atom number density and QC0 the average atom density for the crystal. Typical values chosen for L are about 1 nm. Although quasi-crystalline models give some agreement with experiment for the structure of the local environment, discrepancies are too large at higher values of r for the method to be considered as anything other than a first approximation. The problems again seem to stem from differences in topology rather than the detailed form of F(r), or the choice of L. 10 Figure 4-4. Experimental radial distribution function, J (r) = 4 n r2 Q (r), for a) crystalline Ge, b) a-Ge for two specimens deposited at substrate temperature of 350 °C (upper) and 150°C (lower). After Temkin et al. (1973).
4.2.2.2 "Quasi-Crystalline" Models Some time before the term "quasicrystalline" acquired its present meaning, models for glasses based on crystalline polymorphs with variable "correlation lengths" were investigated. An example is the early work of Leadbetter and Wright (1972); further, more recent, examples are quoted in Sec. 4-6. The correlation function for the crystal, Gc (r), is multiplied by some function, F(r), running from unity at r = 0 to zero for r>L, where L is the corre-
4.2.2.3 "Paracrystalline" Models Two authors, Hosemann et al. (1986) and Phillips (1982), have employed the term "paracrystalline" to describe their models for amorphous solids. Both use crystalline polymorphs as the basis for simulation and both introduce specific features that are essential ingredients for any degree of success the models achieve. The work of Hosemann and co-workers is the more general and extensive. The model is predicated on the observation that if the disorder is expressed in terms of interplanar distances, dhkU by
1/2
-1
(4-2)
where N is the number of lattice planes, then experimentally, the relation, N1/2 g = a*, with a* = 0.15, holds to a good approx-
4.2 Conceptual Models
imation for a wide range of semi-ordered materials. Relations such as Eq. (4-2) define the statistics of fluctuations in dhkl as a function of distance from an origin atom clearly correlations become more diffuse at longer interatomic distances. This alone is insufficient to provide agreement with experiment and for the case of SiO2 considered in Sec. 4.6.4.1, a "microparacrystal" with edge length of 1.25 nm is assumed, with a relative twist of 22° between adjacent SiO4 tetrahedra introduced to fit experiment. Glasses have also been pictured as an assembly of misoriented microcrystallites in which random relative orientations and the presence of several polymorphic microcrystalline phases represents the essential ingredients inhibiting devitrification. Most recently, this notion has been advanced by Goodman (1983) as a "strained microcrystallite model" - strain arising from the mismatch between the various sublattices thus giving rise to diffuse scattering. Phillips - among others - rejects this notion pointing out that a material such as As 2 Se 3 , which is an excellent glassformer, has only one known crystallographic phase. Phillips' extensive series of papers describe a variety of glasses, such as the chalcogenides and oxides through to amorphous solids such as a-Si and Ge. The underlying rationale for such models follows from the precept that the relation between the number of constraints - imposed by covalent bonds - and the number of degrees of freedom, implies that certain compositions are "ideal" for glass formation, others are not. Both under- and overconstrained structures are poor glass formers and lead to partially broken topological order - to discrete boundaries between amorphous aggregates and to broken chemical order. In the chalcogenides, for
191
example, deviations from chemical ordering lead to chalcogen-chalcogen bonding at the edges of GeS2 "rafts". In SiO 2 , Phillips argues that broken chemical order arises from a tendency of oxygen to form double bonds. In either case granular rather than "continuous" models result. Phillips' descriptions have the almost unique distinction among crystallite models in that both the nature of the crystallites and their intervening surfaces are prescribed in detail. 4.2.3 Non-Crystallographic Order as the Paradigm
The assumption that an ordering principle necessarily leads to periodic structures clearly has exceptions. It is well known that the lowest free energy configuration for clusters containing small numbers of atoms, involve arrangements based on tetrahedral close-packing. Atoms, or larger groups packed in this way contain symmetry elements - five-fold rotation axes for example - that are inconsistent with translational periodicity and therefore with a crystal lattice. Fig. 4-5 shows examples of some pentagonal structures produced by progressively extending the principle of packing tetrahedra. Hoare and Pal (1975) have enumerated several families of noncrystallographic clusters which can be shown to be more stable than crystallographic structures containing the same number of atoms. Icosahedral packing twelve atoms surrounding a central thirteenth, or twelve packed tetrahedra - is particularly stable, so that icosahedral, or incomplete icosahedral packing is a structure likely to be favoured in non-crystallographic packings. Polytetrahedral packing is not space-filling though, so that infinite aperiodic structures are not possible in general. The angu-
192
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
Figure 4-5. a, b) Non-crystallographic clusters produced by tetrahedral close packing; c) 55-atom "Mackay icosahedron" (Mackay, 1952); d) Thirteen, 13-atom icosahedra bridged by octahedra producing an icosahedron of icosahedra; e) 471-atom triacontahedron produced from 23 interpenetrating 55-atom Mackay icosahedra. After Barker (1977).
lar mismatch when five tetrahedra are packed around a common 5-fold axis is small (7.5°) but strain accumulates as a tetrahedrally-packed cluster grows. Larger structures thus contain considerable strain energy and eventually become unstable with respect to periodic structures and probably with respect to a composite of small aperiodic clusters in a "random" matrix. The "father" of icosahedral packing is often taken to be F. C. Frank (1952) (although he suggests that "countless generations of schoolboys may have proceeded him"). He pointed out the relative energy and volume savings involved. Subsequently, icosahedrality in randomly packed arrays has become a key issue largly through the work of Turnbull (1985), Sadoc and Mosseri (1982), Sachdev and Nelson (1985) and Yonezawa et al. (1987). The fact that tetrahedral packing is relatively stable for small numbers of atoms and the conflict between local and long range ordering suggests that local energy minimisation in the liquid or glassy state will lead to intercon-
nected, partially icosahedral groups. Further, that the barriers to crystallisation topologically imposed by the organisation of atoms at a local level - to form tetrahedra and octahedra, for instance - will lead to extended kinetic stability for the aperiodic structure. Turnbull (1985) has argued that the crystallisation process in glasses is essentially discontinuous. Whereas microcrystallite models might be expected to crystallise by progressive coarsening, through atomic migration at grain boundaries, devitrification generally occurs by a nucleation and growth mechanism. He then extends the argument to suggest that this provides evidence that the short range order in glasses is essentially different from that of the corresponding crystal, and that icosahedral arrangements provide that necessary difference. Yonezawa et al. (1987) have simulated the structure of Lennard-Jones or Stillinger-Weber monoatomic liquids as functions of temperature and time. Calculations of the local symmetry of nearest neighbour shells allow the proportion of icosahedral clusters to be recorded (as a movie) and show the development and clustering of icosahedral regions near the glass transition. 4.2.3.1 "Curved-Space" Models
An alternative to viewing aperiodic packing in terms of the relative energies of small groups of atoms is to consider polytetrahedrality or icosahedrality as a spacefilling tiling of a suitable non-Euclidean "curved-space". A planar triangulated network requires a mean coordination number of 6, local variations giving 5- or 7-fold coordination require curvature of the two-dimensional plane into 3-D. Similarly, perfectly periodic polytetrahedral tilings that are impossible in 3-D can be designed in a suitable space of higher di-
4.2 Conceptual Models
(a)
193
mension. Sadoc and Mosseri (1982) have developed this theme in a number of influential papers. A 4-D "polytope" may be constructed and can then be de-curved to bring the model back into 3-D space. Clearly, mapping back into Euclidean space involves breaks in symmetry comparable with the tears in the skin of an orange mapped from 3-D towards 2-D. Defect regions separating the polytetrahedral structures are thus an intrinsic property of this type of model, Fig. 4-6. 4.2.3.2 Polytetrahedral Models
Models for network glasses based on the above principle can also be constructed. Thus if a tetrahedrally-bonded atom is placed at the centre of each tetrahedron in an icosahedron, the dual - a pentagonal dodecahedron is formed. This is the basis for several models of amorphous materials: for instance, Tilton (1957) and Robinson's (1965) model for oxide glasses and Grigorivici and Manaila's (1967, 1968) "amorphon" model for amorphous tetrahedral semi-conductors. If the tetrahedra are decorated with sections of a diamond cubic lattice, then polytetrahedral structures, which combine amorphous cluster and microcrystallite models can be constructed, Fig. 4-7. To date, only the properties of complete, symmetrical, polytetrahedral structures have been examined although there is clearly a need to model the "connective tissue" which will not be polytetrahedral.
(c)
Figure 4-6. a) View of the central portion of a polytope constructed by Sadoc and Mosseri (1982) showing the first 13 vertices - with an icosahedral arrangement, b) 20 new vertices (shaded) are added, forming a dodecahedron, c) View of the polytope 'mapped' back into 3-D space.
4.2.4 Constrained Disorder as the Paradigm. Stereo-Chemically Defined Models
It is a common experimental fact that many glasses contain structural elements that are also characteristic of compositionally-equivalent crystals. What implications
194
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
{110)
Figure 4-7. Decoration of a tetrahedron with a 14atom diamond cubic lattice. Packing of such tetrahedra give large non-crystallographic cluster models for amorphous tetrahedral semiconductors (Gaskell, 1975).
does this have for structural models? The answer is not obvious. The experimental evidence, though, has prompted the development of a diverse and ill-defined family of structural models. In the most general description this family overlaps the territory occupied by the random models yet also extends into the province of the microcrystallite and amorphous cluster models. In many cases models have been generated as essentially ad hoc responses to specific structural data and the underlying general ideas that link them to other similarly isolated models have not been extracted. In other cases the models can be satisfactorily categorised under other headings - microcrystallite or random networks - and broader parallels have not emerged. Here we attempt to replace the specific solutions with a more general category, one that includes most glasses and amorphous solids.
As mentioned above, the limited structural similarities between crystals and the corresponding glasses represents the central unifying theme. Models are based on characteristic signatures of the structural features observed experimentally in each phase. The common feature may correspond to the presence of a local structural unit - a tetrahedron or octahedron - and include the mode of interconnection. Further analysis may then reveal similarities extending into the medium-range of structure and indicating a more spatially extensive structure-forming principle. The principle underlying the notion of constrained disorder as a model for the amorphous phase is that similarities in structure between a glass and a corresponding crystalline phase are the result of a set of, what can be termed, equivalent structure-forming operations. In the case of the glass, the operations are applied without further constraint. For the crystal, additional constraints are needed to generate translational periodicity. Disorder is central to the structure of the glass but now only within limits: the structure-forming operations - at the level of local or medium-range order - limit the extent of disorder. A simple example serves to illustrate the argument. In almost all the crystalline forms of SiO 2 , Si is tetrahedrally coordinated and each SiO4 tetrahedron is vertexlinked to its four neighbours. We take this as an undisputed structure-forming principle for most crystalline polymorphs of silica and are not surprised to find experimental evidence for the same local structural unit in a-SiO2. If there are no further rules governing the structure, then vertex linking with a random choice of oxygen bond angle, complete connectivity (ideally), leads to the familiar Zachariasen random network model. We could go further and
4.2 Conceptual Models
195
Figure 4-8. Formation of a chain by application of a) a structure-forming operation consisting of connecting triangles at two vertices. For the triangle marked with an asterisk, the choice is between A, B, C, or D (viewed from the local coordinates of the pair of triangles). In b) a random choice is made and the result is one of the infinite set of translationally aperiodic chains. Formation of a periodic chain requires additional rules: in c) the choice is constrained to "ABCD-ABCD" etc. (starting from the atom marked with an asterisk and working upwards).
argue that this model for a-SiO2 is the embodiment of the structure-forming principle in its purest or most idealised form since no other rules have been used to generate the structure. In order to generate a crystal, however, the structure-forming principle is further constrained to apply in only a limited sense - in one direction, say, to ensure that atoms lie in straight lines. A
simple illustration, a 2-D packing of triangles, is shown in Fig. 4-8. A descriptive name for models of this type is needed. The term "stereo-chemically defined" (SCD) model has some attractions. "Stereo-chemical" can be regarded as short-hand for the set of "structureforming" operations that are central to the model. The local structure, therefore, has
196
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
been stereo-chemically defined and the longer range structure becomes defined as a result of stereo-chemical constraints. 4.2.4.1 Similarity to Random Networks The principle of limited structural equivalence of crystalline and amorphous phases applied at different levels, can lead to structures that are indistinguishable from CRNs on the one hand or to microcrystallite models on the other. In the example above, the only structure-forming principle linking the crystalline to the amorphous phase involves local structural units, with all arrangements of these units equally probable. The general result is a random model: a random network (or random coil for the example of Fig. 4-8). A further example could be the network models for a-Si generated by Wooten and Weaire (1987) (see Sec. 4.5.3) in which the topology of a diamond-cubic crystal was progressively modified by switching bonds until agreement was reached with experimental data for a-Si. Again, the implicit structure-forming operations are retained as constraints - strictly fourfold, approximately tetrahedral bonding, no breaks in connectivity, and these are also characteristic of the crystal. Another example is the "boroxol ring" model for a-B 2 O 3 where a (medium-range) structural unit - the B 3 O 9 ring (Fig. 4-59 a) is connected randomly through the oxygens to form a CRN. 4.2.4.2 Similarity to Paracrystalline Models Variations in the geometry of a crystal without accompanying topological modification lead to structures that are probably best considered as paracrystalline models. For example, Yasui et al. (1983) modelled the structure of amorphous chain and sheet silicates starting from the corre-
sponding crystalline lattices with modification of the geometry of the chains, so that the SiO3 chains were bent regularly in one plane until agreement with experiment was achieved (see Sec. 4.7.7). Clearly, in so doing, none of the structure-forming principles characteristic of the crystal were violated. 4.2.4.3 Local Order as a Consequence of Medium-Range Order If the last two sections, describing the structures of end members of the series represented the entire picture, then there would be no reason to introduce a new category of SCD models. However, there are glasses for which the structure-forming principle relates to medium-range ordering and which are describable in the same language as the CRN and microcrystallite models. Before discussing these, it is necessary to introduce a connection between local and medium range structure. Several types of glasses exhibit local ordering similar to that of a crystalline phase but any explanation of the local order in either relates to medium-range ordering. Two illustrations serve to focus the discussion. Firstly, amorphous transition metal - metalloid (TM-m) alloys appear to be structurally similar to crystals in that the immediate environment of metalloids in the glass and crystal have similar ninefold coordination, trigonal symmetry and narrow bond length distributions. Secondly, the local environments of several alkali and alkaline earth cations in silicate glasses, mimic the local structure of the corresponding crystals. At first sight, these facts may seem unremarkable. Atoms like Si or B have well-defined coordination spheres in amorphous oxides: models incorporating well-defined coordination shells for B in, say, a-Ni4B or Na in a-Na 2 Si 2 O 3
4.2 Conceptual Models
should thus present no additional difficulty and random models for each should work. Indeed, random models for TM-m alloys have been built (Gaskell, 1979), and these can be considered to be CRNs with a trigonal prismatic BNi9 cluster as the local structural unit. Also, Greaves (1985) has proposed a "modified" CRN model in which the alkali network "modifiers" exhibit a preferred coordination, and exist in defined regions of the structure, giving random percolation channels intercalating the silicon-oxygen "network" sub-structure. The problem is to explain the structureforming principle - why do clusters like BNi9 or NaO 5 exist? Well-defined tetrahedral SiO4 units or triangular BO3 groups can be said to "exist" as a result of the strong, directional interatomic bonds. Although it could be argued that B-Ni bonds are strong too, there is no evidence for nine-fold directional bonding. It is difficult to see how this could be achieved as the central B atom has no available d orbitals. The case is even more compelling for alkali and alkaline earth oxide glasses with weak, ionic bonds to oxygen. In neither case can isolated "molecular units" be contemplated. For both types of materials, local geometry and symmetry observed around B in the closed-packed crystalline transition metal borides and around Li, Na and Ca in the close-packed regions of silicate crystals is an essential consequence of an ordered close-packing. In other words, local structural characteristics in these crystals derive from particular medium-range packing schemes in the crystal. There are reasons to believe that this conclusion extends to glasses also. For aTM-m alloys, the experimental evidence is the most clear-cut and details have now emerged - principally from neutron scattering experiments with isotopic substitu-
197
tion (Lamparter et al., 1982) that the local structure is well-defined, with nine-fold coordination of the metalloid by the metal. Evidence for a well-defined local structure implies the presence of a degree of mediumrange ordering, of some sort. We cannot say at the outset what the nature of the medium-range ordering is, but that it exists. Models for amorphous TM-m alloys were therefore constructed by Dubois, Gaskell and Le Caer (1985) (see Sec. 4.2.4.4) which incorporated the mediumrange structural principles observed in the crystal, to produce a SCD domain model that satisfactorily reproduced the partial distribution functions obtained by Lamparter and co-workers. For the "network modifier" cations in oxide glasses, similar arguments apply and experimental evidence for medium-range ordering is now emerging also and will be considered in Sec. 4.7. The point to stress here is that where experimental evidence shows that atoms in close-packed solids - or within closepacked substructures - have a well-defined local structure, then models for these materials could contain a "medium-range structure-forming principle" similar to that responsible for the structure of the corresponding crystal phase. More generally, evidence for well-defined local structures in materials where the local structural unit has a high connectivity, require definitions of the medium-range structure too. These points may be rationalised by accepting that many crystal structures represent a compromise between the space and coordination requirements of atoms in different sublattices. The result is that not all structures that are topologically possible do, in fact, exist as crystals: a point made clearly by Dent-Glasser (1979) for silicates. Constraints imposed by each of the constituent sublattices in a silicate crystal, lim-
198
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
it the range of existing crystals. Can we assume that glasses, because they are noncrystalline, avoid similar rules? The answer is - almost certainly, No. Pauling's rules on which the structure of crystals can be classified are essentially arguments based on considerations of local charge balancing, bond counting, valence, coordination numbers, density and overall composition. Clearly, none of these parameters is specific to the translationally-periodic solid: all should relate to the amorphous state too, so that Pauling's rules alone should constrain amorphous structures. The structure for the crystal is one successful solution to the problem - one of the many structures that could, hypothetically, exist, that does. Investigations of structures for an amorphous solid can use this as a sound starting point - especially if a "structureforming" principles can be extracted from the crystal and transferred to the glass. 4.2.4.4 Stereo-Chemically Defined Models for Close-Packed Oxides and Amorphous Metals Involving Medium-Range Structure-Forming Operations
Several authors have produced random models by modifying the topology of the crystal at the level of the medium-range structure. A recent example is the work of Barenwald (1988) et al. who attempt to model the structure of a chain phosphate, Ba(PO 3 ) 2 by a Monte Carlo method. The structure-forming operation preserved in this work is the essentially parallel packing of infinite, linear (PO3)W chains. PO 4 groups remain intact but the bond and torsion angles are varied randomly to produce a fit to experiment. A similar but more constrained SCD model is that reported by Gaskell (1985 b) for chain metasilicates, see Sec. 4.7.8. The starting point was a Na or Li metasilicate
crystal in which oxygen atoms form a distorted hexagonal close-packed (hep) sublattice. Si, Li (or Na) occupy the tetrahedral interstices (highly distorted for Na). Each (SiO3~)n chain is surrounded by six M-0 chains (M = Na, Li). For the glass, the hep oxygen sublattice was preserved and the tetrahedral interstices were populated with Si or M atoms to form randomly-coiled, self-avoiding silicate chains surrounded by M-O chains. The resulting model thus preserves the following structure-forming operations: oxygen close-packing, semi-infinite, nonbranching chains, chemical ordering, "repulsion" between Si atoms in adjacent chains and "attraction" between Si and Mcontaining chains. SiO4 tetrahedra are preserved, of course, with interconnections through "bridging" oxygens. Randomness while essential to the model, is applied only after taking account of the "stereochemical" constraints imposed by the structureforming operations. A final example comes from the work of Dubois, Gaskell and Le Caer (1985) on amorphous TM-m alloys. The apparently complex structures observed in TM-alloys can be considered as close-packed lattices of TM atoms with twinning at the unit cell level. Specifically, the cementite, Fe 3 C, structure used here as a template for the glass, is produced by inserting twinning planes in every three {112} planes of the hep structure. Capped trigonal prisms are thus formed which are linked through edges and vertices to form planes within which boron atoms are accommodated. These structure-forming operations are preserved in a model for the glass in that parallel twinning planes operate over a defineable correlation length (1 to 2 nm). Beyond, lie other domains also generated by twinning, but with planes lying in other orientations. Topological continuity of the
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques
local structural units (trigonal prisms) and the twinning planes is preserved by the interface atoms too so that the ground state of the model has no primary discontinuity at domain boundaries. These constraints lead to more detailed local restrictions on the arrangement of structural units and to a model that is topologically ordered (but not geometrically ordered) on a length scale of several nearest neighbour distances, but topologically and geometrically disordered beyond.
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques In this section, a brief account is given of the principal structural techniques used to study amorphous solids. Details are given in other volumes of this series. For completeness and to establish the basic formalism, some repetition is inevitable. Particular emphasis is placed on the methods required to obtain structural data of high information content. Quantitative results are expressed in terms of probability functions or distribution functions. We can define the probability of finding an atom at a position r, in an element of volume dr. This is a one-particle distribution function. Similarly, we can define a more useful quantity - the probability of finding two atoms simultaneously at positions r1 and r 2 , thus defining a two particle or pair distribution function. It is more convenient to place the origin to coincide with one atom and work with interatomic vectors, or for a homogeneous system, interatomic distances. Then the probability of finding an atom in an element of volume dV at a distance r from the origin atom equals Qog(r)dV= Q(r)dV. Here, g (r) is the pair distribution function, Q (r) is the r-dependent atom density and Q0 the
199
average atom (number) density. For amorphous solids, since g(r) = Q(r)/Q0, the function tends to unity at large values of r. Although experimental information on higher order distribution functions is difficult to obtain, we could define a triplet distribution function in terms of the probability of finding atoms simultaneously at r i •> ri j r3 Setting the origin at a given atom position allows a definition of the triplet distribution function in terms of the probability of finding one atom at an interatomic distance rt, a second at r2 with the included angle being 6. Often the terms distribution function and correlation function are used interchangeably. Strictly, the pair correlation function, h(r) = g{r)-\ so that this function tends to zero as r tends to infinity. Cusack (1987) gives an excellent account of the necessary formalism. 4.3.1 Neutron Scattering Techniques Static Structural Methods Neutrons have zero charge and do not interact with charges in the specimen, in contrast to X-rays and electrons. Neutrons interact with the (small) atomic nuclei and this considerably simplifies any description of the scattering equations, since the scattering mechanism is essentially independent of the scattering angle, if inelastic scattering is neglected. For an isotropic liquid or glass, vectorial information characteristic of a crystal is averaged, so that the intensity is Q-dependent but there is no other angular variation. In a typical (elastic) scattering measurement, the intensity of a monochromatic beam of scattered neutrons is measured as a function of the scattering angle - conventionally 2 9. Usually the result is expressed in terms of the modulus of a scattering vector, Q, \Q\ = Q = 4nsinO/A,
200
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
where X is the incident neutron wavelength. The experimental scattered intensity oscillates around a background, I*xpi term equal to the scattering from a structureless medium of the same atomic density and composition as the specimen - "self scattering". Neglecting inelasticity effects, 7fxp = Nb2 where b is the neutron (coherent) scattering length for the atoms of a monoatomic solid and TV is the number of atoms in the neutron beam. Generally there is also a degree of incoherent scattering that is subtracted from the total scattering to obtain the coherently-scattered fraction. Oscillations around /fxp are due to constructive and destructive interference from neutron de Broglie waves scattered from nearby nuclei and these oscillations contain the structural signals, I(Q) (Fig. 4-9). Thus,
= Nb2S(Q)
(4-3 a)
where S (Q) is the so-called structure factor and contains all the structural information. Often the same equation is re-expressed in terms of the "interference function"
i(Q)=I(Q)/Nb2-l
=
N
(4-4)
or, more simply, in terms of a "reduced interference function",
ivii
Each distance in the specimen thus exhibits its signature in the form of a sine wave of "period" AQ = 2n/rmn - short distances giving rise to long period fluctuations in Q-space and vice-versa (see Fig. 4-10). The Debye equation, Eq. (4-5), is convenient for simple calculations on molecular groups with discrete interatomic distances. For a solid or a liquid it is preferable to work with the atomic density, Q (r), defined as the number of atoms in a volume d3r, at
(4-3 b)
It is useful to obtain, at the outset, a conceptual grasp of what information S(Q) contains. For an isotopic specimen, Debye showed that the scattering from N particles separated by a constant distance rmn is given by: 1
Figure 4-9. Typical experimental neutron scattering data showing the "self-scattering", Nb2, from a structureless medium containing the same number of atoms per unit volume as the specimen.
(4-5)
Q /nm"
Figure 4-10. The reduced interference function, F(Q\ for a monoatomic specimen. With a gaussian distribution, centered on R, the result is a damped sinusoidal wave of period 2n/R. The full line shows F(Q) for R1 = 0.246 nm,
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques
distance r; so that the number of atoms in a spherical shell, radius r, thickness dr is: J(r) = 4nr2Qog(r)dr
= 4nr2Q{r)
t (r) — 4 n r Q (r) or (4-6 b)
It may be shown (Warren, 1969) that:
Q
° (4-7) where Q0 is the average atom (number) density. Defining a "reduced" radial correlation function:
\ = 4nr(Q(r)-Q0)
(4-8)
then, 1 S(Q) = l+— fG(r)singrdr (4-9) Qo or, (4-10) F(Q)= fG(r)sinQrdr o The advantage of these forms of the Debye equation is that only deviations from the average atomic density contribute to F(Q). For liquids and glasses, the atomic density, g(r\ approaches Q0 at large r so that integration can be usually truncated at r& 1.5 to 2.0 nm. It is possible - and often desirable - to fit structural data in the form of S (Q) or F (Q) with computer data for a structural model that gives G (r). However, the structural information is easier to visualise in real space using the fourier (strictly sine) transform of S (Q) or F (Q). We thus have two symmetrical transforms: F(Q)= jG(r)sinQrdr 0
and
=
^F(Q)smrQdQ
(4-1 lb)
(4-6 a)
where J(r) is the so-called radial distribution function (rdf). A function t(r) is often used: T(r) = 4 n rb2 Q{T)
201
(4-1 la)
(In other conventions, G (r) is replaced with D (r) - the differential correlation function.) 4.3.2 X-Ray Scattering X-rays interact with atoms of the specimens chiefly through their electrons. (A term involving the nuclei is reduced by the ratios of the masses of electrons and nuclei.) Since electron orbitals - particularly the outer valence shells - have radii that are comparable to interatomic distances, interference terms arise from the "shape" of the orbitals. Assuming spherical shells, the effect is to replace the neutron scattering lengths, b, in the above equations with an atomic scattering factor, f(Q% i.e. atomic scattering factors are now g-dependent, due to interference from waves scattered by electrons within the shells. Such atomic scattering factors (or "form factors") are tabulated in standard works. Thus the scattered intensity is now related to a Q-dependent background, Fig. 4-11. With this modification, the remaining equations in Sec. 4.3.1 hold.
u Figure 4-11. Typical X-ray scattering data, oscillating around a Q-dependent atomic scattering factor, / (k). (Here, k is used instead of Q.)
202
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
For electron diffraction, interaction is again with the electrons but the charge on the nucleus now becomes important. If the atomic scattering factors for electron and X-ray scattering are fE(Q) and fx(Q) then:
^=
4n2(Z-fx(Q))/Q2
(4-12)
Electron scattering is much stronger (typically 104 larger) than X-ray scattering which is in turn very much stronger than neutron scattering. Thus very thin films are necessary for electron diffraction compared to specimens of 5 to 10 g for neutron scattering.
and the transform of the gaussian broadening function, which is another gaussian given by the exponential term in Eq. (4-13). Similarly, the transform of a product of two functions is the convolution of the fourier transforms of the two functions. Broadening of the distribution of interatomic distances arises partly from differences in the environment of each atom due to disorder - the static broadening, as. In addition, thermal motion leads to another contribution, ath. For the j t h interatomic distance the total effect is obtained by addition in quadrature: (c^)2 = (asj)2 + 2
4.3.3 Effects of Disorder on Scattering Data
4.3.3.1 "Termination" Smearing
F(Q) for a monoatomic specimen with all atoms at a constant distance, R, will be an infinite sine wave. Non-crystalline solids are characterised by a distribution of local sites rather than a single environment, so that the distributions are broadened. The corresponding F (Q) is a damped sine function, Fig. 4-10. For a peak shape in the form of a gaussian i.e.
Since scattering measurements are limited to a scattering angle, 2 6max = n9 g max is limited to 4 n/ 2, and for typical X-ray and neutron wavelengths of 0.05 to 0.1 nm, Qmax = 250 to 125 nm" 1 . Eq.(4-llb) involved a transform of the scattering function F(Q) over an infinite Q range. The effect of truncating the integral at Qmax is equivalent to multiplying F (Q) with a modification function, M(Q), such that:
G(r)ozQxp(-(R-r)2/2(i2)
M(Q) = M{Q) = \
then, F{Q)K
R
exp(-
(4-13)
For more general r-space distributions with a number of peaks in r-space, the transform of each is multiplied by the corresponding "damping function" exp(— Q2a2/2) and the contributions are then summed. The result is a smearing of F(Q) at high Q. The above is an example of the convolution or folding theorem. G (r) in this case is a convolution of a set of delta functions with a gaussian. The transform, F ( 0 , is a product of the transform of G (r)
Q < e max
From the convolution theorem, if G* (r) is the "true" real space function which would be obtained by transformation of F(Q) with <2max=oo, then truncation of the fourier transform of F (Q) at Qmax implies that G* (r) is convoluted with a peak shape function, P*(r) which is the cosine transform of M(Q): P* (r) = - J M (Q) cos (r Q) &Q 71
(4-14)
0
(See for example Waser and Schomaker (1953).)
203
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques
For M (Q) in the form of a step function, the peak shape function is a SINC function, Fig. 4-12. Thus if G*(r) is considered to be made up of a set of (5-functions, the effect of multiplying of ^-function by P (r) and then summing to obtain G (r) - which amounts to a convolution of G*(r) with P* (r) - is to broaden the features of G* (r) and to introduce satellite "termination ripples". The ripple may be suppressed, at the expense of further broadening, by using smooth modification functions. A number are quoted in Fig. 4-12.
4,3,4 Polyatomic Solids Scattering in polyatomic solids can be treated using the Debye equation but the terms involving the different atomic species, a, /?, etc. must now be accounted. We must now consider partial structure factors, Sap(Q), and partial pair correlation functions Gap(r). For a solid containing m atomic species, there are m(m + l)/2 independent partial functions. The number of atoms of type /? in a volume d 3 r at a distance r from an origin a is: )=
4nr2Qap(r)
(4-15)
The relative density can also be defined in terms of the mean density of atoms of type P,Q0(p) = npQ0 where np is the atomic fraction of species /?. Thus: 9ap(r) = Qap(r)/npQ0
(4-16)
The partial reduced radial correlation function is:
(4-17) Eqs. (4-11) now become:
= \Gap{r) sin(Qr)dr
(4-18a)
and Gap (r)=-$FaP
(Q) sin (r Q) dQ
(4-18 b)
4.3.4.1 Total Distribution Functions and Structure Factors
-40 Figure 4-12. Peak shape functions corresponding to a fourier transform of reciprocal space data truncated at Qmax by a modification function M (Q). A. M(Q) =
B.
with B = \oge(10/Q Leadbetter (1976)).
2
max).
C. M(fi) = l (Wright and
Partial distribution functions and structure factors give a detailed description of the environment of each atomic species and the information content is equivalent to G (r) or S (Q) obtained for a monoatomic solid. Experimental scattering measure-
204
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
ments from polyatomic solids do not directly give the partial functions. The measured total structure factor, S(Q) is a weighted sum of contributions from independent pairs of atom types, a a, /?/?, a/?, etc. Thus for a diatomic solid: 7
aeSaAQ)
(4-19 a)
a fi
where WaP is a weighting factor, nanfibab*
(4-19 b)
and b a , bp (or / a , /^ for X-rays) are the scattering lengths for atomic species a, /? and
The total structure factor is defined as:
S(0 = . ^
N\(by\2
(4-20)
+1
Again, the brackets, < >, refer to a compo2
m
sition average so that = Z (**«&«)• a=1
From iS (<2) the total reduced radial correlation function, G(r) can be obtained as: G(r) = I Z ^ G ^ ( r )
(4-21)
Since the weighting factors differ for X-ray and neutron scattering, S (Q) and G (r) measured by X-rays will not be identical to that measured using neutrons. 4.3.5 Extraction of Partial Structure Factors It will be obvious that averaging over three partials for a diatomic solid leads to a drastic reduction in the information content of a measurement. Peaks in one partial tend to overlap with troughs of another, so that the resulting destructive interference leads to smooth total functions in cases
where the underlying partial functions are strongly oscillatory. Furthermore, partials with small weighting factors are buried beneath the oscillations of strongly-weighted partials. For the most informative structural measurements, it becomes vital to extract partial structure factors from total structure factors and partial correlation functions from total correlation functions. Apart from a few simple solids like SiO2 where this can be done by inspection (see Mozzi and Warren, 1969), it is necessary to employ special techniques. We consider five possibilities. 4.3.5.1 Combination of the Results of X-Ray, Neutron and Electron Scattering For a binary alloy, if three experiments can be performed with three types of radiation thus providing three sets of equations of the form S (Q) = £ £ WaP Safi ( 0 , and if a fi
values of Wafi are sufficiently different for the three measurements, then the three equations can be solved for the three unknown quantities S aa , Safi9 Spp. The atomic scattering factors depend on the character of the probing radiation, as mentioned earlier. Furthermore, although X-ray and electron form factors increase monotonically with atomic number Z, the neutron scattering length, b, is determined by two contributions - "potential scattering" which increases very slowly with Z, and a "resonance scattering" term - that oscillates, apparently haphazardly. It is thus possible to choose systems for which the X-ray and neutron weighting factors, Wap9 are significantly different for the various types of radiation. Form factors for electrons are insufficiently different from those for X-rays for electron diffraction to be of much use as a third experiment (in addition to X-ray and
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques
205
Figure 4-13. Partial structure factors, Gij{f) for aCo 81 P 19 obtained by Sadoc and Dixmier (1976). 5
6
10
r(A)
neutron scattering). For elements with a magnetic moment, such as Co, the moment may be oriented with a suitable external magnetic field. The atomic scattering length for polarised neutrons depends on whether the atomic moment lies parallel or anti-parallel to the neutron spin, so that for Co-containing alloys, magnetic scattering offers two experiments. A classic investigation of a-Co 4 P was performed in this way by Sadoc and Dixmier (1976) using a combination of X-ray scattering, polarised and unpolarised neutron scattering to obtain the three partial structure factors for the alloy (Fig. 4-13). 43.5.2 Neutron Scattering with Isotopic Substitution
Not only do neutron scattering lengths vary sharply from element to element; they also vary from isotope of the same element. For example, Ni has isotopes in which b (in units l(T 1 5 m) varies from - 8 . 7 (62Ni) to 14,4 (58Ni). Three experiments with three isotopic mixtures of Ni in a binary alloy
thus allow extraction of partials from three sets of neutron scattering data. In another seminal measurement, Lamparter et al. (1982) obtained the partials for a-Ni 81 B 19 using alloys of X1B with nat Ni, 62 Ni, and a mixture of 62 Ni and 60 Ni giving a coherent scattering length of zero. X-ray scattering data was also collected for good measure. The results are shown in Fig. 4-14. 4.3.5.3 "Difference" Methods
For compounds with more than two atomic species, direct extraction of partials would be impractical. For a triatomic material, six independent measurements would be required. However, it is still possible to simplify the problem and to increase the information content of measurements by obtaining information on the environment of a selected atomic species. This is done by taking differences of the neutron intensities scattered by two samples of the same material, identical apart from the isotopic concentrations of one of the species, M, say. Writing the normalised neutron scattering
206
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
where bM and b'u are the neutron scattering lengths of the two isotopes. The technique, pioneered by Soper et al. (1977) in studies of molten salts and aqueous solutions has now been applied to many glasses (see Sec. 4.7).
geometrical packing model
4.3.5.4 X-Ray Absorption Spectroscopy
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12
Figure4-14. Partial structure factors Gtj(r) for aNi 81 B 19 obtained by Lamparter et al. (1982).
intensity per atom:
^'
a
a, B
(4-22)
The first term on the right hand side contains g-independent "self scattering" terms; the second, terms involving M such as: b^ HM(SMM(Q) -1) and terms involving pairs of atoms other than M. Only the terms involving bM are affected by isotopic substitution so that (apart from a difference of background levels) the difference between two intensities for the two measurements, A J ( 0 , contains only terms involving correlations between M and other species (including M) thus: M (Q) = Const + A (SMM (Q) - 1 ) +
where
Each element has a characteristic absorption edge, corresponding to excitation of a bound electron from a core shell to an excited state above the conduction band minimum. The energy involved lies in the X-ray region and is specific for each element. At energies, £, immediately above the threshold, £ 0 , the absorption coefficient exhibits a series of oscillations extending up to 1 keV above the absorption edge. After background subtraction and suitable normalisation, the oscillatory part of the signal, x (E), the X-ray absorption fine structure (XAFS) contains structural information on the environment of the excited atom. Specifically, x (E) represents interference between the photoelectron wave emitted by the excited atom and waves back-scattered from its neighbours. It thus has considerable similarity to the interference function in X-ray, electron and neutron diffraction and provides similar structural information. Similar effects occur after excitation with fast electrons: scattering processes that involve excitations from core states, appear in the electron energy loss spectrum (EELS) as saw-tooth peaks with an associated fine structure at higher energies. Such transitions can be observed in an electron microscope, for example, if the transmitted electron beam is energy-analysed. The fine structure in both types of spectra can be roughly categorised as the relatively sharp oscillations in the immediate
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques
vicinity of the "edge" and the gentler oscillation of the extended XAFS. The former involves strong scattering of low energy photoelectrons for E — Eo «100 eV and the latter region can be treated by a single scattering approximation (Sayers et al., 1971). Writing the latter approximation in terms of the modulus of the photoelectron wave vector, k2 = 2mQ(E—E0)/h2 then:
• exp ( - 2 o) k2) exp ( - 2 Rj/A (fc)) (4-24) This expression is clearly more complicated than the corresponding expression for X-ray or neutron scattering (Eq. (4-5)). However, the similarities become more obvious on inspection. Rj is the distance from the central atom to a shell of Nj neighbours. Eq. (4-5) contains a term in sin QRj whereas Eq. (4-24) has a similar term in sin 2 kRj. Each, therefore, indicates that a discrete peak in r-space at Rj gives rise to sine wave oscillations in Q-space or kspace, of period 2 n/Rj or n/Rj respectively. (In XAFS, the interfering wave travels from the central particle to its neighbours and back again - a distance of 2 Rj.) Complications inherent in Eq. (4-24) involve a phase shift term Sj(k% a 'Debye-Waller' term exp (— 2 a? fc2) where Oj measures the breadth of the r-space distribution, and a term exp (— 2 Rj/A (k)) representing the decay of the amplitude of the photoelectron wave due to inelastic processes. A is a measure of the mean free path. The back scattering factor, \fn(k)\9 corresponds to the term f(Q) in X-ray scattering (the n indicating 180° scattering). As with X-ray or neutron scattering, it may be preferable to convert Eq. (4-24) from its Debye-like form into a version that includes pair distribution functions,
,(*)_
207
3=n-l
kr2\fn(k)\
•exp(-2rM(fc))
(4-25)
Here, a corresponds to the excited element of species a, and /? to neighbours of other species which includes neighbouring atoms of species a. The important point is that in a triatomic alloy, say Xa involves terms in P aa , Pafi, Pay but excludes other terms not involving a. The structural information is thus analogous to that obtainable from neutron scattering with isotopic substitution of species a in the difference mode, or to X-ray differential anomalous scattering at the absorption edge of element a. The advantages, though, are that this element-specific technique is much more generally applicable since medium atomic number elements can be examined by Xray absorption techniques and light elements by EELS without any requirement for isotopes with contrasting scattering properties. Moreover, a high maximum value of reciprocal space or fc-space data is routinely available - typically kmax = 200 nm x equivalent to g max = 400nm x in neutron scattering. There is a major disadvantage, however, for disordered materials. If a peak in rspace is broad - as they are in glasses for second- and higher-neighbours, then the Debye-Waller term tends to zero except for the region below fc^40nm-1 - which is also the region corresponding to strong multiple scattering of low energy photoelectrons and where single scattering theory does not apply. The extended XAFS spectrum thus offers little information beyond the first peak in r-space and even then is not sensitive to broad features - shoulders or wings - that correspond to higher frequency fourier components in reciprocal space.
208
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
One answer to this problem, of course, would be to analyse the low energy region where information on high neighbour correlations is contained. The difficulty with this approach is that there is no method for inverting the data to obtain, directly, the real-space distribution. One must proceed by comparing experimental data with computed low energy XAFS or EELS data computed from trial structures. Although some success has been achieved by this method - for example work on a-Si discussed in section 5 - the accessible information content is limited.
4.3.5.5 X-Ray Anomalous Scattering In the vicinity of an absorption edge in the X-ray spectrum of an element, the atomic scattering factor, / , for that element becomes energy-dependent. Writing / in terms of its real (f±) and imaginary (f2) components: f=f0 +f1 + if2 - Here, f0 represents the contributions to the scattering factor from all processes other than that associated with the absorption. The imaginary (absorptive) part shows a step function change as the energy is increased through the region of the absorption edge, whereas fx is small and negative at energies below the edge, has a deep minimum at the position of the edge and then rises progressively beyond that. By taking scattering measurements at two incident X-ray energies on either side of the absorption edge, preferably using a tunable X-ray Synchrotron source, values of/ x can be sufficiently different that subtraction of the two scattering curves gives elementspecific information - as in the isotopic substitution technique. Thus, A/(g) can be written as a similar equation to Eq. 4-23 with weighting factors given by Ludwig et al. (1987). In principle, further measure-
ments can be taken at the absorption edges of other elements in the material. The magnitude of the changes in ft can be about 20 % but it has proved quite difficult to obtain good separation of the partials in binary alloys due to a combination of random and systematic errors. Moreover, the X-ray wavelength is determined by the position of the absorption edge which increases with atomic number, Z, so that to obtain X-ray scattering with a reasonably large Q range, the element of interest should have a high atomic number. On the other hand, there are none of the problems associated with the low Q cut-off that limit the usefulness of XAFS data. Pioneering measurements on the structure of Ge-Se alloys were performed by Fuoss et al. (1981) and more recent work includes studies of a-Ni2Zr (de Lima et al., 1988).
4.3.6 Vibrational Spectroscopy The static structural properties considered above give one view of the properties of an amorphous solid. Dynamical properties - the response of the solid to an excitation, not only give additional information on the static structure but also add new information. The simplest description of the vibrational properties of a material is given by the vibrational density of states function, g(co); the number of vibrational modes with frequencies between co + Aco. This quantity is not directly measurable but experimental methods provide information that can be related to g(co). However, for amorphous solids - in contrast to crystals - this transformation is by no means without uncertainty. Lack of periodicity in an amorphous solid has the important effect that the (crystal) momentum selection rule
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques
appropriate to crystals is no longer strictly valid. The infra-red absorption process in a crystal is governed by laws of conservation of energy and momentum, E(ko) = E(q); ko = q, where k0 and q are the wavevectors of the incident photon and the created phonon respectively, and a selection rule restricting the modes to those for which there is a net change in the dipole moment. For isotropic solids, k = \k\ = 2njX so that for the IR effect with 2^10 jim, k is effectively zero on the scale of the Brillouin zone boundary ( ^ l O n m " 1 ) and the IR spectrum therefore picks out the sub-set of modes in g (co) for which £ = 0. In an amorphous solid with no identifiable unit cell, k becomes a poor quantum number so that all modes in g(co) become potentially optically active. Similar statements applies to the Raman effect (although now it is the changes in polarisability rather than the dipole moment that provides one of the selection rules). Thermal neutrons with energies similar to vibrational quanta can also be scattered inelastically that is with the creation or destruction of one or more phonons. The static structure factor, S(Q), discussed above is thus replaced in a complete treatment by S(Q, co) - the dynamical structure factor. Certain nuclei - notably H - possess a spin, /, and since scattering of neutrons involves the properties of a compound nucleus, neutron + nucleus, with spin 7+1/2 or 7—1/2, the two states have different scattering lengths so that scattering from such nuclei is only partially coherent. H has a particularly large incoherent cross section and since incoherent scattering involves addition of intensities of scattered waves - the scattering intensity is given by a sum over essentially independent vibrating atoms. Thus the energy gain (or loss) of neutron scattered by such pro-
209
cesses is directly related to g(co), i.e. S(Q,co) = g(co)fN(Q,co) where, /N iQ,
210
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
In a glass like SiO 2 , or an amorphous semiconductor such as a-Si, the tetrahedrally-bonded atoms are extensively interconnected but without any simplifying periodicity. The vibrations of the atoms comprising the ensemble now depend on the relative phase of all the other atoms nearest-neighbour atoms being most important. Since there is no unit cell, the concept of a well-defined phase difference between equivalent atoms in adjacent unit cells is inapplicable and the independent, plane wave-like vibrational states no longer exist. Modes are therefore strictly hybrids of all others. We can still require that selection rules operate but now strictly over the total number of atoms in a macroscopic specimen. Progress has been made for example by Shuker and Gammon (1970), Galeener and Sen (1978) and others but the exact quantitative treatment depends on calculations of the properties of relatively large models. 4.3.7 High Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
High resolution transmission electron microscopy (HTREM) differs fundamentally from the diffraction techniques discussed earlier. Diffraction of X-rays, neutrons or electrons involves interference between waves scattered from neighbouring atoms as a result of phase and amplitude differences: structural information is conveyed in the angular distribution of the intensity of scattered waves but phase information is absent in the final signal. The information content is significantly degraded therefore. HRTEM images are the result of scattering of electron by atoms of the specimen but amplitude and phase information is preserved - albeit with some significant distortion introduced by the electron optics.
For sufficiently thin specimens, the electron wave incident on the specimen is weakly scattered and the wave function of the emergent beam can be represented in terms of an (almost) unchanged amplitude but with the phase shifted by an amount proportional to the specimen potential projected onto a plane perpendicular to the incident electron wave vector. This is related to the projected electron density of the specimen, so that the emergent wave can be considered as a 2-D mapping of the projected electron density of the specimen. An optically faithful electron microscope could thus give a magnified view of the electron density on the scale of interatomic distances, if this phase difference map were to be translated into- an intensity, or contrast, difference in the image. This is achieved in a "phase-contrast" image which makes use of changes in phase introduced by the imaging electron optics, in an analogous manner to phase microscopy in (light) optics. A microcrystalline specimen can thus be imaged as a series of lattice planes in which a suitably Bragg-oriented microcrystallite generates a periodic fluctuation of the phase of the scattered electron wave of period dhkl in a plane perpendicular to the electron beam direction, z. This phase grating is translated into a magnified periodic fluctuation in the contrast of the final image. One of the major differences between this structural information and that derived from the angular distribution of the scattered intensity is in the degree of averaging involved. In an X-ray measurement, the scattered information is a representation of the sum of interatomic vectors from about 1020 origin atoms. In a TEM image, structural information relating to a local region of the specimen is retained within a corresponding local region of the image. Consequently a cubic microcrystal-
211
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques
lite of, say, 4 nm edge length involves averaging over about 104 atoms. Moreover the image is a 2-D representation of a 3-D object, rather than a one-dimensioned picture as in electron diffraction. In practice, perfect transmission of structural information is not achievable and current high resolution images are significantly degraded maps of the electron density of the specimen. The problems arise from aberrations in the electron optical imaging system and from the difficulties inherent in unscrambling information from a projection of the atomic density over the thickness ( « 4 nm) of the specimen. Abberations in the objective lens of the microscope limit faithful imaging to waves scattered through angles, 9 to the optic axis that lie within "windows" where phase contrast is effective. Specifically, a so-called "contrast transfer function", T(Q), can be defined in terms of 6 and therefore Q, with the effect of an instrument response function. This function can be positive or negative (implying contrast reversal) and good imaging corresponds to a range in Q for which T(Q) has a relatively large and constant value (see Fig. 4-15). T(Q) for modern high resolution electron microscopes is large at moderate angles, corresponding to Bragg scattering from lattice planes with Q in the range 5 to 30 nm" 1 and interplanar spacings of about 1 to 0.2 nm. For Q values greater than this, the CTF passes through zero (with zero transmission of information, therefore) and then becomes oscillatory and this defines an effective resolution limit. Effects of beam convergence, chromatic aberration, incoherence etc. also limit the resolution to about 0.15 nm. The effects of the above are that a HRTEM image is only a partial representation - and in many cases a "scrambled" representation, at that - of the projected
Specimen periodicity (A) 2010 6 U 3 2 1.5 i
1 1 1
1
i
•
i
1
1 /
•
-
\
/ / /
C3
/
T 0
"
b)
J
L/ v/ J X /
\
/
a) /
V
\
\
f
31-
A
\ V s \ ________ f-A /' J! / \ t<'' 2 --
i \ \ \ — V- —
•,%
to
_
_
_
_
_
' \ / \ /- * / \
_
\
\
>
•
i
1
Figure 4-15. a) Contrast transfer functions, T(Q), for 100 kV microscopes (dashed line) and 500 kV (full line) corresponding to a generalised defocus value of 3 1/2 . b) Structure factors for a-Pd4Si taken from neutron scattering data (full line) and X-ray data for a-Ge (dashed line) (Gaskell et al., 1979).
specimen potential and electron density. In terms of the interference function, i(Q), high resolution images contain information limited to the first peak in i{Q) for amorphous semiconductors and only the best microscopes have resolution extending to the first peak for amorphous metals, which have smaller d-spacings. With modern high resolution microscopes, the problems are no longer severe for the majority of amorphous solids with relatively large d-spacings. However, much of the older work in the literature needs to be treated with caution due to neglect of the effects of the aberrations in 100 keV microscopes operated at or beyond their limits of resolution.
212
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
The second problem arises as a result of the effects of projection. Since the electron wave-function immediately after the specimen is a projection of the specimen potential over a column which is the thickness of the specimen, it becomes impossible to distinguish atoms that are, say, nearest neighbours, from those that appear to be at the same projected distance but in fact lie at the upper and lower edge of the foil and are thus separated by about 4 nm in the z direction. Moreover, ordered regions giving coherent Bragg diffraction, are unlikely to be larger than 2 nm in size so that there is at least as much material contributing information to the image which is either ordered but not Bragg orientated, or from a random matrix. The non-Bragg oriented material therefore contributes noise which significantly degrades the image. In practice, there is a third problem due to inelastic scattering which is especially prominent at low scattering angles and can submerge the coherently scattered electron intensity and thus further degrade the image. As a result of these problems, HRTEM has proved to be of only limited use in establishing the short-range structure of amorphous solids. It is important to recognise, though, that when the technique is used to complement diffraction studies, the information gained concerns the medium-range structure in the range 1 to 2 nm where diffraction methods are relatively powerless. Examples of the use of HRTEM will be discussed in Sec. 4.5.
4.3.8 Nuclear Magnetic Resonance In a strong applied magnetic field, Ho, the degeneracy of nuclear spin states is removed (Zeeman interaction). For nuclei with spin, /, the difference between the en-
ergy levels is given by:
E(m) = yhmH0
(4-27)
where, y is the gyromagnetic ratio characteristic of the nucleus and m is the magnetic quantum number. Application of exciting radiation results in a transitions between states with quantum numbers that differ by Am= ± 1, and the frequency at which this transition occurs depends, through y, on the excited nucleus. NMR is thus an element-specific structural technique. Sensitivity to the local environment of the nucleus comes from electrons near the nucleus which, by their motion, create small magnetic fields that add vectorially to // 0 , so modifying the local magnetic field at the nucleus. The nucleus can be said to be partially shielded from the external field by the electron distribution of the atom which, in turn, is determined by bonding interactions with neighbouring atoms. Since the electron distribution is, in general, non-spherical, the interaction is orientation-dependent, represented by a shielding tensor, a; the isotropic component being represented by the "trace" of the tensor: a{ = 1/3Tr(d) = 1/3(tT±1 +
4.3 Experimental Structural Techniques a)
Zeeman
-1/2 -
Chemical shift anisotropy
213
b)
T
Na 2 Si 2 0 5
1/2 < i
.
|
i r i T—y .
,
,
, ,
,
,
, ,
-50 -100 -150 -200 Parts per million from TMS
c)
d) Na2Si205 SSB
Rotation axis
CB
Flutes SSB
Sample rotor
Magic angle R.f. coil
Driving gas 1
I
T
Stator
-50 -100 -150 -200 Parts per million from TMS Figure 4-16. a) Energy levels for a nucleus such as 29Si with spin, 1 = 1/2 in an external magnetic field, HQ. The nuclear Zeeman splitting and the effect of chemical shift anisotropy are shown, b) The broad "powder" line-shape for sodium disilicate due to anisotropic chemical shielding, measured as the shift in parts per million (ppm) from the corresponding line for tetramethyl silane (TMS). c) MASNMR spectrum of Na 2 Si 2 O 5 showing the splitting of the spectrum into the resonance line (CB) at about 97 ppm and spinning side-bands, SSB. d) Magic angle spinning (schematic) (Oldfield and Kirkpatrick, 1985).
quencies (and including other interactions - nuclear dipole-dipole and nuclear quadrupolar interactions, for nuclei with / > 1). The result is therefore a broad spectrum with structural information contained in the shape of the distribution. Interpretation of such broad line spectra has allowed the composition-dependence of the various boron oxygen species to be identified in alkali borate glasses (see Sec. 4.7.4.1). In liquids, where rotational motion occurs on a time-scale faster than the characteristic time-scale of the NMR frequency, the anisotropic interactions are averaged
out leading to very narrow peaks corresponding to the frequency associated with the isotropic part of the chemical shift interaction, G{. For solids, similar effects can be achieved by spinning the specimen at a frequency, co, of the order of the peak breadth (a few kHz) at an angle 6 to Ho. This causes the anisotropic interactions to be multiplied by a term 3 cos2 0 - 1 , which equals zero for 0 = cos" 1 (3~ 1/2 ) = 54.74° the "magic angle". The effect of magic angle spinning is to cause the broad powder resonance, shown for 29Si in Na 2 Si 2 O 5 in Fig. 4-16b to collapse into an underlying frequency related
214
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
to (ji? and spinning side-bands associated with time-dependent terms in the various interactions. The true resonance (CB), at about 97 ppm in Fig. 4-16 c is independent of the spinning speed, the side bands are not. In favourable compounds, the lines are sufficiently narrow in relation to the frequency splitting associated with different bonding arrangements around the excited atom, that the species present can be quantitatively analysed (see Sec. 4.7.4.2 and an excellent review by Kirkpatrick et al., 1986).
4.4 Modelling Techniques In this section, a brief account is presented of computational methods for production, refinement and testing of atomic models for amorphous materials. References to the literature will suffice to direct the reader to examples of the major computational "experiments" and further details will emerge in Sees. 4.5 to 4.7. The subject conveniently divides into three sections - construction of the model, refinement and validation. 4.4.1 Construction of Atomic Models for Amorphous Solids
Perhaps the most difficult - certainly the most tedious - part of the modelling process is finished when a structural idea has been translated into a set of atomic coordinates in a computer. Ideally, generation also should be the preserve of the computer but increasingly, as models become more sophisticated, algorithms contain some form of human guidance - either actually through a physical model or implicitly through the construction algorithm. At the outset we should question the need for atomic models. After all, most structural information represents a one-di-
mensional average over 1020 or more atomic centres and, possibly, over the environment of several atomic species. What is to be gained by an approximate fit to these data by a model in the form of a finite cluster of atoms? Several answers to this question occur. Firstly, once a 3-D model has been constructed that is compatible with X-ray diffraction data, for instance, it is then possible to use the coordinates to calculate other properties - elastic moduli, vibrational spectra, optical properties - information that is not contained in the X-ray data and which would be difficult or impossible to calculate otherwise. Secondly, it becomes possible to compare the information contained in the results of two or more different types of experiments by reference to an atomic model that eventually can be adjusted to fit both datasets. In this way the amount of structural information is multiplied. Perhaps the most important factor is that a 3-D atomic model allows a rather complicated series of packing or connectivity constraints to be incorporated into the model - constraints that might be difficult or impossible to formulate otherwise. The fact that atoms cannot occupy the same region of space introduces constraints - involving rules that are not easily expressed analytically. Space-filling random structures encapsulate packing rules expressed through topology rather than geometry, and homotopy groups describe the connectivity rather than space group symmetry, as pointed out be Rivier and Lissowski (1982), Rivier (1983). Similarly, connectivity relationships in directionallybonded systems - especially the provision of particular fractions of ra-membered rings - can be incorporated in atomic models but, except for near neighbour correlations, become too clumsy otherwise.
4.4 Modelling Techniques
Finally, there is a sense that juggling atoms in a computer comes close to the processes that nature adopts to "choose" a particular structure. 4.4.1.1 Physical Models In the early history of the subject, almost every model was hand-built. Notable pioneers were Bernal (1964), Scott (1960) and Finney (1970). For network glasses, probably the most influential random model has been Bell and Dean's (1972) "ball and stick" model for SiO 2 , although Evans and King's (1966) work on the same material has historical precedence. Coordinates were established by metrology and properties then calculated by "digital" computation. Models of a similar kind for amorphous tetrahedral semiconductors were produced - notably by Polk (1971) and for a-Si:H by Mosseri and Dixmier (1981). In later work, computer algorithms enter at an earlier stage - physical models were used to establish the topology in a polytetrahedral model of a-Ge and to ensure close packing in models for amorphous TM-m alloys, the detailed coordinates then being computed from the topology of the physical model. The domain model of Dubois et al. (1985) for these amorphous alloys also started with a physical model. Until recently, there seemed little alternative for structures of some complexity but the advent of molecular graphics packages now offers real prospects of advance. Many hand-built physical models are clusters of no more than a few hundred atoms so that a high proportion lie near the surface. Apart from the problem of excluding underbonded surface atoms in subsequent calculations, near-surface atoms have additional degrees of freedom
215
not possessed by those comprising the interior. The problems of "imbedding" cluster models have been reviewed by Finney (1977). One alternative is to construct models with periodic boundary conditions. A rare example of a hand-built random model with periodic boundary conditions was the 61-atom cell constructed by Henderson in (1974), and more recently by Guttmann and Rahman (1988). Although periodic models are routinely constructed by Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics algorithms, physical models with periodic boundaries remain a rarity. 4.4.2 Molecular Dynamics The subject has progressed some way since the pioneering days of Alder and Wainwright (1959). Typically, the procedure involved construction of an initial starting structure - a random collection of atoms or a crystal structure - inside a periodic cubic box. Atoms are allowed to move under the action of an assumed potential energy function and Newtonian equations of motion are solved over time slices of the order 10~ 14 to 10~ 15 s. (See, for example, Soules (1990).) A typical example of a recent investigation is that of Vashishta et al. (1989 b) on a-GeSe2 in which the authors assumed an effective two-body potential involving a Coulomb term, charge-dipole interactions and steric repulsions. The motion of 648 atoms was followed over time steps, Af = 5 x l O ~ 1 5 s in a cubic box of side 2.75 nm, adjusted to provide agreement with the experimental density. The system was equilibrated at 1100 K for about 3 x 104 At and the properties average over a further 3.6 x 103 At to provide structural properties for liquid GeSe 2 . The glass is simulated by progressively reducing the particle velocities over about 3 x 104 steps (corresponding to a
216
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
2 0 Ge-Se _
12 10
Figure 4-17. Partial pair correlation functions, ga/?(r), for two simulations of a-GeSe2 at 300 K using a) a two-body potential; b) a potential including three-body terms. Coordination numbers are indicated (Vashishta et al. 1989 b; Vashishta et al., 1989 a).
8 r6 i
4 2 0 2 0 0 a
4
8 r(A)
12
0
quenching rate o f 5 x l 0 1 2 K s 1 )to values corresponding to T
4
8
12
has been reported by Stillinger and Weber (1983, 1985). The configuration generated by MD at any temperature is energy-minimised, using a steepest-descents algorithm and the resultant "mapping" of the initial configuration onto the nearby potential minimum produces a pronounced enhancement of all the structural features, Fig. 4-18 a, b. Apart from the obvious interpretation that the configuration has
9 2
Figure 4-18. a) Pair correlation function, g, for a MD simulation of liquid Si at a reduced temperature, T* = kBT/s = 0.0817 where s is proportional to the cohesive energy, b) The corresponding function obtained by allowing the liquid configuration at T* =0.0677 to settle to an energy minimum giving the "inherent" pair correlation function for liquid Si. The higher temperature structure for a liquid at T* = 0.1492 relaxes to essentially the same configuration. Stillinger and Weber (1985).
217
4.4 Modelling Techniques
been allowed to eliminate high energy unstable local bonding arrangements, Stillinger and Weber point out that mapping of liquid MD configurations at various temperatures leads to a relatively small set of underlying (temperature-independent) "inherent structures". That is, the temperature-dependence of pair correlation functions in simple liquids consists of variations in "vibrational" displacement away from potential minima; not in substantial shifts from region to region of configuration space, corresponding to other groups of potential energy minima. This procedure, involving potential energy mapping and averaging over a number of local configurations belonging to different potential energy minima, has been used to effect in simulations of metallic glasses by Hafner and co-workers (e.g. Hafner, 1988).
of a Coulombic (first term) and a repulsive (hard sphere) term. The BMH potential has been used extensively in MD simulations for covalent solids with the long range Coulomb term summed using Ewald's method. For amorphous semiconductors, a potential proposed by Stillinger and Weber (1985) has proved popular. This consists of a mixture of two- and three-body terms: (4-30)
where i is the index of one of N identical atoms. Neglecting the single particle potential terms, V1(r), the interaction can be expressed in terms of the pair and triplet functions, V2(r) and V3(r). For Si, Stillinger and Weber introduce the functions V2(r) and V3(r) in the form:
4.4.3 Potential Energy Functions Given adequate potential energy functions, molecular dynamics simulations could provide an entirely adequate description of the complexity of structure generation and the transformations involved in quenching from the melt. Many MD calculations - particularly the early ones - necessarily used simplified potentials. Woodcock etal. (1976) employed a Born-Mayer-Huggins potential:
•exp[(r-a) ']
V2(r) = 0
\
J r>a
(4-31)
Where e is an energy unit and a is a cut-off radius and r is a reduced radius. V(ri9rj9rk) = s[h(rij9rik, 6jik) +
^2)
+ h(rji9rjk9 9ijk) + h(rki9rkj9 6ikj)] Here 9jik is the angle at i between r>} and rk and h is given by:
b+ 7(rik-ay1] • exp
L
Q J
(4-29)
where za is the electronic charge on an atom of species a, n is the number of outer shell electrons, a is a distance parameter characteristic of the ionic radius and b and Q are constants. The function thus consists
(cos 0jik +1/3) 2 (4-33)
for rij9rik< a, otherwise h = 0. The effects of introducing three-body terms in simulations of covalent systems are pronounced. Most simulations of amorphous elemental semiconductors, oxides and chalcogenides are unrealistic in
218
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
a)
b) i
» Expt. 108AK — MD
2 — ~
1071 K
i
i
Liquic
T = 1070K
A
1 -
"
o^-
w <
a)
' ' I I I 2 -
I
I
I
1
Glass
1
1
T=300K
-
JL
1 _ t
8
12
16
20
U
i
.
i
.
i
.
8
12 Q (A"1) Figure 4-19. Comparison of experimental and computed total neutron structure factors S(Q) for a-GeSe2. Computer data was obtained using a) a two-body potential function and b) a Stillinger-Weber potential including three-body terms (Vashishta et al. 1989 a, b). Q (A"1)
that distortions are significantly greater than experiment: bond angle distributions are generally much broader with a high proportion of atoms with unexpected valence and ring sizes. Figs. 4-17 b and 4-19 b show the improved agreement between computed and experimental static structure factors for a-GeSe2 obtained by Vashishta et al. (1989) using three-body terms of the Stillinger-Weber type compared with pairwise functions of Vashishta etal. (1989). For amorphous metals, the simplest potential energy function is a Lennard-Jones function: >.-=4eiy
'•-Rfj)
(4-34)
where >-t is the potential of the ith atom and Rtj is a reduced distance; R(j = 2'1/6Rfj/riJ, where Rfj is the equilibrium internuclear distance and ri-J is the actual distance between atoms i and j . Hafner, in an extended sequence of investigations on metallic alloys has calculated interatomic forces on the basis of
pseudopotentials, see for example Hafner (1980, 1986). Energy minimisation techniques applied to elemental semiconductors and oxides often assume a Keating potential (Keating, 1966) that is computationally simpler than a valence potential. This consists of bond stretching and bending terms:
3a 3($
>rik~r20 cos 90)2
(4-35)
where a and p are stretching and bending force constants, r0 and rtj are the equilibrium and actual internuclear distances between atoms / and j and 90 is the equilibrium angle jik. Lapiccirella et al. (1984) have introduced a more sophisticated version of the valence force-field - the LipsonWarshel PE function, in calculations of the structure and properties of a-Si and a-Ge (Tomassini et al., 1987).
4.4 Modelling Techniques
Molecular dynamics simulations using empirical potential energy functions have the drawbacks noted above. A method for removing this difficulty has been proposed and applied by Car and Parrinello (1985) and coworkers. In this approach, the interatomic potential is derived from the electronic ground state of the system calculated with accurate density-functional techniques. Specifically, the sets of atomic coordinates and electronic wavefunctions of the occupied states are both considered as dynamical variables, governed by equations of motion for electron and nuclei. The minimum energy state is obtained by following the "motion", as the temperature is reduced, by a process described as "Dynamical simulated annealing" to compare with the "simulated annealing" method of Kirkpatrick et al. (1983) (using MC formalism). The method is effectively parameter-free so that such ab-initio calculations can describe the "true" structure of an amorphous material given only the electronic properties of its atoms. Applications to aSi and a-C are considered in Sec. 4.5.
4.4.4 Energy Minimisation Models constructed by hand or by various computer algorithms lack realism in that bonds are strained, broken, or the coordination numbers are unrealistic. By calculating the potential energy - essentially the elastic strain energy of the structure and the gradient, atoms can be moved in directions that minimise the energy. After a relatively small number of iterations the model settles into the potential energy minimum in the local region of configurational space corresponding to the starting structure: the model becomes "relaxed", implying an increase in geometrical order.
219
The extent of topological ordering depends on the detailed algorithm. The method embraces a number of minimisation algorithms. A popular and easy method is the steepest-gradients method which involves calculation of the energy and the force on each atom. Each atom is then moved either a distance proportional to the force or to an estimated position of minimum energy (Steinhardt et al., 1974). Another method is the so-called "conjugate gradient" method which attempts to find the minimum in configuration space by searching in orthogonal directions at each iteration. Like MC calculations, the potential energy functions and derivatives are reasonably simple to compute so that with the Keating potential energy function the method is computationally cheap. Various sophisticated potentials have been devised for silicon, and carbon compounds and are only marginally more difficult to deal with.
4.4.5 Monte Carlo Calculations Models may also be generated and refined using variations of the Metropolis Monte Carlo method. An initial, essentially arbitrary starting structure is chosen usually with periodic boundaries. An atom is selected at random and given a randomly chosen displacement. The state of the system, as characterised by the energy or the fit to an experimental variable such as the structure factor, is then tested. The move is accepted if the goodness of fit is improved, rejected if not. A variant is that the move may be accepted according to a Boltzmann probability, exp(— AE/kBT) where AE is a measure of the goodness of fit - the decrease in energy, say, and kBTis a suitable scaling factor. Thus the algorithm allows the system to explore con-
220
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
figurations that initially may be unfavourable, so that the procedure helps to prevent the model becoming trapped in a local minimum of configuration space. The process is repeated until the fit to experiment is judged to have converged. The method has been used extensively in constructing models for amorphous metals, chalcogenides, amorphous semiconductors and oxides. It has the advantage that a relatively large number of configurations can be explored quickly and cheaply in computer time. Moreover, it is generally possible to use more realistic potentials so that difficulties introduced by pairwise potentials have not been so prominent in MC as in MD simulations. McGreevy and Putztai (1988) have revised a method similar to that used by Renninger et al. (1974) in which the criterion for guiding the approach of the MC computation is the quality of the fit to experimental scattering measurements alone. The energy is not considered. The authors point out that the amount of information normally extracted from experimental diffraction data is generally small and that a fitting procedure offers a more detailed idea of the real 3-D geometric structure. The authors are clear that while it appears that a 3-D structure has been extracted from 1-D S(Q) or G(r) information, this is strictly impossible and that the final structure is only one (of many, perhaps) that is consistent with the data. Evans (1990) has commented on the apparent contradiction that higher order functions such as the three-body distribution should be obtainable from structural knowledge that contains no more than pairwise information (see Sec. 4.3). Evans points out that a simulation could succeed for an amorphous solid for which the atomic forces are describeable solely by a pairwise potential. For materials with sig-
nificant three-body terms in the PE function, such as the covalently-bonded amorphous semiconductors, this need not be so. Although the pair distribution function, g(r), depends on three-body terms, this dependence is insufficient to determine, uniquely, any higher order correlations. If two- and three-body terms are present in the PE function then experimental g (r) and triplet correlation functions would be necessary. 4.4.6 Validation of the Model: Calculation of Microscopic and Macroscopic Properties
Given a complete set of atomic coordinates, it is then possible to calculate microscopic properties such as G(r), S(Q), or S(Q), even S(Q, co). With further assumptions, vibrational and electronic densities of states functions can also be computed as described below. Macroscopic physical properties are also accessible - density, enthalpy of crystallisation, free energy, entropy, elastic moduli, gas solubility, diffusivity etc. These are often neglected or deemphasized when checking the validity of a model, which is generally a mistake. It comes as a surprise to find that a simple property like density is sensitive to structural details that appear to evade comparisons with microscopic properties - particularly when the latter are used in a qualitative or semi-quantitative fashion. An accurate fit to the experimental density should be seen as an essential prerequisite for further consideration of the model, and failure to agree should lead to its demise. Density values may be built into a simulation as a constraint. When this is done, it follows from the foregoing that it is a rather strong constraint. The most useful properties are probably G(r) and S{Q\ combined with density and heat of crystallisation data. For reasons
221
4.4 Modelling Techniques
discussed earlier, the information content of partial pair correlation functions and partial structure factors is so much greater than that contained in the total functions, that the former provide the most discriminating test of a structure model. For polyatomic materials, even models that are radically different produce adequate fits to S(Q) or G(r) - especially when experimental data is measured to low values of Q. Only by examination of the detail of these functions can differences be discriminated.
pulsed neutron sources), multiple scattering introduces low Q limitations also. The result of terminating S(Q) at g max leads to convolution of G{r) with a peak shape function so that a ^-function in G(r) is transformed into a broadened peak with side lobes - so-called termination broadening and termination ripple (see Fig. 4-20). Thus a
^ |
is replaced with: 4.4.6.1 Bond Length Distributions
Successful models must reproduce the details of each of the bond length distributions, that is, not only the interatomic distance corresponding to the peak and the integrated area leading to the coordination number, but the shape of the distribution as expressed through higher moments: standard deviation and (possibly) asymmetry (kurtosis). Such parameters are important structurally and represent valuable diagnostic information. Microscopic parameters computed from models and those derived by experiment must be compared in detail, as indicated above, and using equivalent data. Early models were relatively crude and thus the two data sets were compared only superficially without proper regard for equivalence. However, the efforts of a number of authors such as Wright and Leadbetter (1976) have emphasized the proper treatment. A major problem arises from the fact that experimental data are generally limited in reciprocal space. X-ray and neutron diffraction S(Q) data are often limited to values of Qmax in the region of 200 nm" 1 and whilst EXAFS data can routinely be extended to higher values (as can X-ray and neutron data with synchrotron and
a
p
0
(4-36)
where P*p(r-r') is a peak shape function given by: Pa%(x) = M(Q)cos(Qx)dQ (4-37)
E GO
o
-0.2 1
Figure 4-20. Experimental difference distribution function GCa (r) for a calcium silicate glass (bold line) and a fit to the data to about 0.5 nm (upper dashed line). The latter has been convoluted with a SINC function to compare with experimental data. The underlying (unconvoluted) sum of gaussian functions is shown by the lower dashed line. This function has more information, since the termination smearing is absent but is only one of the possible fits to the experimental data (Eckersley et al., 1988).
222
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
Here M(Q) is a modification function (see Sec. 4.3.3). For X-ray and neutron diffraction this could be a step function, M ( 0 = 1, for Q < Q m a x , and M(Q) = 0 thereafter, or some smoother function such as the exponential function. For neutron scattering where the atomic scattering lengths are Q-independent, or for X-ray scattering in those cases where the ratios fa{Q)ffi(Q)/Kf>\2 are essentially g-independent for all a and /?, then: P«%(x) = c*°^2 K\\U/\
TM(Q)cos(Qx)dQ o
(4-38) If M (Q) is a smooth function, it may be possible to replace P*p (x) with a gaussian,
(2nr1/2exp(-x2/2a2)
with a = l.6/Qmax
for approximate work. For accurate comparison, a convolution of the model G (r) is necessary before comparison is made with experimental realspace data. Even analysis of the experimental data to obtain parameters such as the first, second and higher coordination numbers and associated mean bond lengths and G values requires care. Although the coordination number can be obtained approximately from an integral: jG aj3 (r) n
where r1? and r2 represent the "limits" of the peak, such limits cannot be defined accurately - especially if termination ripple is present and peaks overlap. A better method involves fitting the experimental data with a series of gaussian peaks (say) convoluted by P*p (x). Once this has been done, the set of gaussians (unsmeared by the peak shape function) is narrower and may be more representative of the structure. Thus where available, this function should be quoted. An example is shown in Fig. 4-20 from recent investigations of Eckersley et al. (1988) on a-CaSiO 3 . Convolution by a peak shape function and the resulting smearing thus represents
some degradation of the structural information and efforts have been made to minimise the impact. One solution is to compare computed and experimental data in reciprocal space so that problems of termination broadening of the g-space data are circumvented. However, unless the model is large, with a radius greater than about 1.5 nm, truncation of the r-space data leads to a convolution of computed reciprocal space data with another peak-shape function. Ideally comparison of models with experiments should be made in both Q- and r-space since although they both contain the same information, certain features such as the first sharp diffraction peak, may be more evident in one than the other. Konnert, Karle and coworkers and others have attempted to devise methods to reduce the impact of termination at Qmax. Their treatment is based on the fact that if Qmax is reasonably large - say 150 nm" 1 for oxide glasses - then only the first one or two interatomic correlations are sufficiently sharp in r-space to contribute to S(Q) near Qmax. If the contribution from these peaks to S(Q) is removed, then Qmax c a n be set to infinity for the remainder with no loss in accuracy. Since the result is obtainable only by fitting the experimental data for the first few peaks, it represents a nonunique solution and lacks some of the objectivity of the Fourier transform. The choice of the fitting algorithm clearly biases the results and a question arises as to the most appropriate choice of function. Recently, the claims of maximum entropy techniques in this field have been enhanced by several workers. If experimental data is fitted by a procedure that maximises the (information) entropy, then this set of choices represents the least biased (maximally non-committal) choice. Wei (1986) has shown that experimental neutron scat-
4.5 Elemental Tetrahedral Semiconductors
tering data for a-Ni 64 B 36 (Cowlam et al., 1984), analysed using a maximum entropy technique provides more informative data in real space than the fourier transform technique (Fig. 4-21). This would be expected for most fitting algorithms - the advantage of the Maximum Entropy technique is that it allows an objective (unbiased) choice of one of the manifold of possible solutions that could fit experimental data. The use of ME techniques in extraction of partial distribution functions in a ternary Ag-Ge-Se alloy has been demonstrated by Westwood and Georgopoulos
223
(1989). In this case the data was from Xray anomalous scattering measurements at two energies at each of the K-edges of all the elements. 4.4.7 Calculation of Dynamical Properties
From the coordinates of an atomic model and an assumed PE function, the vibrational density of states function can be calculated. Description of the various computational techniques lies beyond the scope of this review and a brief list of references giving an entree into the subject must suffice. Vibrational frequencies are obtainable directly in a MD simulation - see for example Hockney and Eastwood (1981). A popular and efficient method for calculating the phonon states of a cluster is the "recursion method" reviewed in Heine et al. (1980). A similar method is the "equation of motion" method (Beeman and Alben, 1977). Electron states can also be calculated by the use of these techniques (Heine et al., 1980).
4.5 Elemental Tetrahedral Semiconductors
Figure 4-21. Reduced radial distribution function, G (r) for 58 Ni 64 B 36 obtained from the neutron scattering data of Cowlam et al., 1984 by fourier transform (FT) (a, c) and maximum entropy (ME) methods (c? d). Km is the maximum value of 4 n sin djX in the dataset (Wei et al., 1986).
Of all amorphous solids, silicon and germanium are perhaps the most extensively investigated. Recently, interest has mounted in a a third element - carbon - although this is not strictly a tetrahedral material the extent of tetrahedral bonding is variable and as yet, inadequately defined. The three materials have important properties - Si and Ge are semiconductors and, like the crystalline elements, can be doped to provide a range of useful electronic properties. Carbon, in its diamond-like form, can be very hard and has useful properties
224
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
as a damage-resistant coating and as a dielectric. Each can be prepared as an alloy with other elements - notably hydrogen. Indeed, some contamination with H is difficult to avoid but, more importantly, deliberate alloying with H decreases the number of energetic defects such as 'dangling bonds' thus improving optical and electronic properties. In this section, we concentrate on the structure of the essentially pure elements, recognising that H may be an almost unavoidable impurity. A recent review by Elliott (1989) extends the subject to alloys of Si containing large amounts of H and other elements. With the exception of amorphous carbon, there is no paucity of good experimental, data for amorphous semiconductors. The most complete data is for a-Ge and, since there are strong qualitative similarities between the results for all the Group IV elements (and their alloys) we concentrate on data for a-Ge and introduce deviant behaviour as appropriate amorphous carbon being the most important case. 4.5.1 Amorphous Ge and Si 4.5.1.1 Local Structure - Diffraction Data X-ray data for several specimens of aGe has been reported by Temkin et al. (1974) (see Fig. 4-4) and Kinney (1976). Neutron scattering data was obtained by Etherington et al. (1982) from the specimen of evaporated Ge used by Kinney. A small amount of H was observed (indirectly). Results of this work are shown in Fig. 4-22 as the experimentally-derived correlation function f (r) and the authors' best estimate of the true correlation functions t(r). The latter function was obtained by subtracting the contribution of the first peak (in r-space) to the reciprocal space data, Q(S(Q) — 1). This gives a reciprocal
Figure 4-22. Experimental correlation function (full line) t'(r) = 4n rg{r) for a-Ge, together with Etherington et al.'s (1962) estimate of the true correlation function t(r) (dashed line) obtained as a fit to the experimental scattering data.
space function that has effectively reached an asymptotic value below Qmax, so that fourier transformation is possible without any truncation effects. The overall tetrahedral nature of the material is confirmed, with
225
4.5 Elemental Tetrahedral Semiconductors
for a-Si is less accurate but results from X-ray and electron diffraction techniques on a-Si: H alloys suggest values of the first coordination number less than four and that the second coordination number is less than 12. For instance, Schulke (1981) finds
2.5
~~T~
2.0
a)
1.5
S 1.0 2 0.5
I 2-°
«_ £ i.o 0.5 0
2.34 A
'W
•2 0 £2.5 o
0
7
k 6 Radial coordinate (A)
Figure 4-24. a) Fourier transform of the EXAFS data, k2 x (fc), for a-Ge: H from 30 < k < 140 nm " 1 . b) Similar transform for c-Ge (Bouldin et al., 1984).
10 Figure 4-23. Partial pair correlation function, g (r), for a-Si: H obtained by H/D substitution (Bellissent et al., 1985).
Both a-Si, a-Ge and their hydrogen alloys have been thoroughly studied by EXAFS techniques. An example is the work reported by Bouldin et al. (1984). They measured the EXAFS spectrum for specimens of a-Ge that were nominally free of H and samples with around 5 6 at. % H. The fourier transform of the resulting data for the pure material (Fig. 4-24) shows a sharp peak corresponding to the first neighbour distance which is almost identical to that for c-Ge and the coordination number is 4.0 to within a few percent. In contrast to the data for crystalline germanium, Fig. 4-24 b, information on second- and higher-neighbour peaks is almost indistinguishable from the noise in the transform as Fig. 4-24 a indicates. This is the result of the limitation of
226
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
the data analysis procedure to values of the photoelectron wave-vector, k, greater than about 30 nm" 1 , where the effects of multiple scattering are not too large, as discussed in Sec. 4.3.5.5. The Debye-Waller term, Qxp(-2a2k2) in Eq. (4-24) has the values 0.24 at £ = 30 nm" 1 (with o2 = 0.028 nm deduced from Etherington et al., 1982) and only 0.08 at £ = 40 nm" 1 where the contribution of x(k) (weighted by a smooth windowing function) is significantly greater than zero. Information on second and higher-neighbour peaks is thus very difficult to obtain from the extended spectrum. On the other hand, the presence of the second-neighbour peak in the fourier transform can be used as a diagnostic test of partial crystallisation, as shown by Evangelisti et al. (1981) and by Menelle etal. (1986). Nonetheless, a signal due to second neighbours is present in the experimental data and recent work by Mobilio, Filipponi and coworkers has shown some progress in extracting this information. For example, Mobilio and Filipponi (1987) show that a weak higher neighbour signal can be extracted from accurate experimental x(k) data using the regularised least squares fitting procedure proposed by Babanov et al. (1981). In this way they reproduce the first and second peaks in g(r), extending to about 0.5 nm. In more recent work (Filipponi et al., 1989), the contribution to the EXAFS signal of a-Si arising from the first peak in g(r) is subtracted from the experimental data and the residual signal can then be analysed in terms of single and multiple-scattering terms from higher neighbours, Fig. 4-25. In fact, the residual signal cannot be satisfactorily analysed unless multiple scattering is included. The r-space feature corresponding to the difference signal occurs not at the position of the second peak as would be
Figure 4-25. Multiple scattering contribution to the XAFS signal in a-Ge. Each contribution is labelled by the number of atoms involved in the scattering event and the degeneracy. Thus, #3A 12 represents a wave emitted from the origin and scattered by two further atoms. There are 12 such paths in a fully bonded tetrahedral network (Filipponi et al., 1989).
expected, but at the position of a third neighbour in c-Si. Filipponi et al. show that this is the result of destructive interference between single scattering from second neighbours and multiple scattering arising from paths involving two, three, etc. scattering events, Fig. 4-25. An essential contribution to the signal comes, therefore, from paths involving a photoelectron wave emitted from an origin atom, which is then scattered by a neighbour of that atom, to another neighbour and then back to the origin atom, where it interferes with the outgoing wave, resulting in a modulation of the X-ray absorption coefficient. The importance of this type of analysis is that in addition to functions like g(r),
4.5 Elemental Tetrahedral Semiconductors
which represent the distribution of pairs of atoms, an exact fit to the EXAFS data for a-Si seems to require specification of triplet correlation functions g(r1,r2,9). The latter function expresses the probability that an atom lies at a distance rx from an origin atom, another at r 2 , with an angle 9 between the vectors to the two atoms. Clearly, this is data additional to that which can be derived directly from an analysis in terms of g (r), and this represents potentially new and valuable structural information. Another way of looking at this is to recognise that triplet correlation functions also relate to the local site symmetry, which again is not available directly from pair functions.
4.5.1.2 Local Structure - Complementary Techniques. Medium-Range Structure
Infra-red and Raman spectra of a-Si and a-Ge display the behaviour noted in Sec. 4.3.6, namely the broad double humped
227
structure, Fig. 4-26, characteristic of the vibrational density of states function, g (co) and with little resemblance to the sharp features seen in the IR or Raman spectra of crystalline materials. This is the result of the loss of translational symmetry which removes the force of the crystal momentum, k = 0, selection rule so that all modes of g(co) become potentially optically active (Sec. 4.3.6). In fact, the major features of g (co) for amorphous tetrahedral semiconductors are obtained by just broadening the density of states function for the crystal. Experimental g(co) data for a-Ge has been reported by Maley et al. (1986); Maley and Lannin (1987) and for a-Si by Kamitakahara et al. (1987). The former also made detailed comparisons with the Raman spectra of a-Ge, Fig. 4-26, which shows the close relationship between the Raman intensity and g(co) determined from neutron inelastic scattering. Dynamical structure factor data, S(Q,co) also exists for a-Ge (Maley et al. 1986) - Fig. 4-27.
Figure 4-26, Neutron inelastic scattering data (solid lines) and a) depolarised, c) polarised components of the Raman spectra for a "highly-ordered" specimen of a-Ge (substrate temperature =150 °C): b) and d) show similar data for a more disordered specimen prepared at a substrate temperature of 5 °C (Maley and Lannin, 1987). 100
200
300 0 100 Frequency (cm"1)
200
300
228
4 Models for the Structure of Amorphous Solids
Figure 4-27. Two-dimensional plot of the dynamical structure factor, S (Q, E\ of a-Ge (Lannin, 1987). O.O
High resolution electron microscopic examinations of a-Ge