2
Latin America and the Caribbean
Copyright © 2003 United Nations Environment Programme This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part and in any form for educational or non-profit purposes without special permission from the copyright holder, provided acknowledgement of the source is made. UNEP would appreciate receiving a copy of any publication that uses this report as a source.
No use of this publication may be made for resale or for any other commercial purpose whatsoever.
DISCLAIMER The content of this publication do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of UNEP or contributory organisations. The designations employed and the presentations do not imply the expressions of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNEP or contributory organisations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or its authority, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. United Nations Environment Programme Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean (ROLAC) Division of Early Warning and Assessment (DEWA) Boulevard de los Virreyes #155, Colonia Lomas Virreyes, 11000, Mexico, D. F., Mexico Tel.: (52) 55 5202-4841 Fax.: (52) 55 5202-0950 E-mail:
[email protected] Website: http://www.pnuma.org/dewalac/ UNEP (United Nation Environment Programme), 2003: GEO Latin America and the Caribbean: Environment Outlook 2003, UNEP Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean, Mexico, D.F., Mexico
ISBN: 92-807-2294-8 Printed in Costa Rica, November 2003 Printed using paper and material from sustainable sources and produced in a ISO 14000 certified process.
GEO Latin America and the Caribbean - 2003
Environment Outlook
3
GEO - LAC 2003 Produced by
In collaboration with:
With additional collaboration of:
Editor’s note: GEO repeatedly used in this publication is the acronym of the Global Environment Outlook.
4
Latin America and the Caribbean
Acknowledgements This publication was developed with the help of the GEO project Collaborating Centres, as well as close to one hundred experts, members of Non-governmental Organisations, representatives of governments and regional organizations. As a result, this publication is a collective effort. We would like to pay tribute to the memory of Manuel Alepuz Llansana, Director of el Centro de Ingeniería y Manejo Ambiental de Bahías y Costas (CIMAB), Cuba, a collaborator who passed away recently.
We would especially like to thank the contribution of the lead authors of this report and the technical teams at UNEP and the Development Observatory of the University of Costa Rica. We also acknowledge the important contribution of the participants of the GEO 3 regional consultation (Costa Rica, May 2001) and of the workshop to discuss the GEO LAC 2003 report (Cuba, February 2002) whose names are listed on Page 279.
The Production Team Coordinators
Lead authors
Kaveh Zahedi, Coordinator, Division of Early Warning and Assessment (DEWA), United Nation Environment Programme Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean (UNEPROLAC), Mexico.
This report is a collective work developed over a period of three years (2001-2003) in collaboration with experts in various countries of the region. The starting point was the draft texts about Latin America and the Caribbean prepared for the Global Environment Outlook 3 report that was published in 2002. Afterwards, the texts were further elaborated and developed. In the section below appear the names of the individuals who, with the production team of the report, contributed substantively to the writing and editing of the texts.
Edgar E. Gutiérrez-Espeleta, Director, University of Costa Rica Development Observatory (UCR-OdD), Costa Rica.
UNEP-ROLAC Team (Mexico) Ricardo Sánchez (Principal Reviewer), Kakuko NagataniYoshida (Editor, Researcher and Reviewer), María Eugenia Arreola (Researcher and Reviewer), Teresa Hurtado (Secretary), Luis Betanzos de Mauleón (Researcher), Marco Aurelio Pinzón (Reviewer, Chapter 2: Atmosphere), Enrique Leff (Reviewer, Chapter 3 and Chapter 5), Oscar Ramírez (Reviewer, Chapter 2: Freshwater and Coastal and Marine Areas), Rosana Silva (Reviewer, Chapter 3), Isabel Martínez (Reviewer, Chapter 3), Diego Masera (Reviewer Chapter 3), Myriam Urzúa (Reviewer, Chapter 3), Norberto Fernández (Reviewer), Fernando Tudela Abad (Reviewer).
UCR-OdD Team (Costa Rica) Álvaro Fernández-González (Lead Researcher and Editor), Julián Monge-Nájera (Editor), Freddy Abarca (Statistics Application Developer), Olmer Núñez (Statistician), Hazel Brenes (Statistician), Marcela Noguera (Secretary).
Overall and cover design Gerardo del Castillo Ramírez (Mexico)
GEO Latin America and the Caribbean - 2003
Eduardo Gudynas, Uruguay (Chapter 1); Kaveh Zahedi, Mexico (Chapter 2: Socioeconomic Trends and Chapter 5); Sebastián Miller, Chile (Chapter 2: Socioeconomic Trends); Álvaro Fernández-González (Chapter 2: Atmosphere, Desasters, Environment and Human Health and Chapter 5); Nicolo Gligo, Chile (Chapter 2: Land); Pascal Girot, Costa Rica (Chapter 2: Land, Forests, Biovidersity, Urban Areas); Ivan Tomaselli, Brazil (Chapter 2: Forests); Carlos A. Klink, Brazil (Chapter 2: Biovidersity); Oscar Cordeiro Netto, Brazil (Chapter 2: Freshwater); Daniel David Hoggarth, Barbados (Chapter 2: Coastal and Marine Areas); Indrani Lutchman, Barbados (Chapter 2: Coastal and Marine Areas); Kathleen Sullivan Sealey, United States (Chapter 2: Coastal and Marine Areas); Lee Kimball, United States (Chapter 2: Coastal and Marine Areas); Bruce Potter, United States (Chapter 2: Coastal and Marine Areas); Camilo Arriagada Luco, Chile (Chapter 2: Urban Areas); Carmen Marín, Costa Rica (Chapter 2: Environment and Human Health); Kakuko Nagatani-Yoshida (Chapter 2: Environment and Human Health and Chapter 5); Eugenia Wo-Ching, Costa Rica (Chapter 3); Ramón Pichs-Madruga, Cuba (Chapter 4); Francisco Brzovich, Chile (Chapter 4), y Eric Kemp-Benedict, United States (Chapter 4), and Edgar E. Gutiérrez-Espeleta, Costa Rica (Chapter 4 and Chapter 5).
Graphic application, illustrations, photographs and editorial production Roberto Burgos S. (Costa Rica)
Translation from Spanish to English Phil Linehan (Mexico) Editor (English version) Sylvia Howe (UK)
Environment Outlook
5
Index Acknowledgements .............................................................................................................................................. 4 Foreword ............................................................................................................................................................ 11 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................ 14
1: From Stockholm to Johannesburg: environment and development in Latin America and the Caribbean From Stockholm to Johannesburg: environment and development in Latin America and the Caribbean ...................................................................................................... 20 Stockholm: growth and population ............................................................................................................. 20 Environmental issues become international ................................................................................................ 21 “Our Common Future” and “Our Own Agenda” ........................................................................................ 23 The Earth Summit process ........................................................................................................................... 23 New economic conditions: 1990-2002 ...................................................................................................... 25 Laws and institutions ................................................................................................................................... 26 Nature and the Market ................................................................................................................................ 27 Ten years after the Earth Summit and future outlook ................................................................................... 27 References ................................................................................................................................................... 29
2 State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002 State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002 ............................................. 32 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................ 32 Socio-economic trends .................................................................................................................................... 33 Economy ..................................................................................................................................................... 33 Energy ......................................................................................................................................................... 35 Social situation ............................................................................................................................................ 36 Demography ............................................................................................................................................... 37 Science and technology .............................................................................................................................. 38 Governance ................................................................................................................................................ 38 References ................................................................................................................................................... 39 Land ................................................................................................................................................................... 40 Agricultural production ............................................................................................................................... 40 Land tenure ................................................................................................................................................. 41 Expansion of agriculture and livestock farming .......................................................................................... 42 Land degradation ........................................................................................................................................ 43 Agrochemical pollution .............................................................................................................................. 45 Desertification ............................................................................................................................................. 46 Policy responses .......................................................................................................................................... 47 References ................................................................................................................................................... 51 Forests ............................................................................................................................................................... 53 Deforestation trends and causes ................................................................................................................. 54 Pressures ..................................................................................................................................................... 55 Forest fires and hydro-meteorological threats ............................................................................................. 56 Impact of deforestation ............................................................................................................................... 58 Forest policies ............................................................................................................................................. 58 References ................................................................................................................................................... 61
6
Latin America and the Caribbean
Biodiversity ....................................................................................................................................................... 63 Diversity of ecosystems and species ........................................................................................................... 63 Genetic resources diversity ......................................................................................................................... 65 Threats to biodiversity ................................................................................................................................. 66 Policy responses .......................................................................................................................................... 70 References ................................................................................................................................................... 76 Freshwater ........................................................................................................................................................ 78 Availability of water resources and regional variations ............................................................................... 78 Pressure on water resources ........................................................................................................................ 82 Water policies: national and regional initiatives ......................................................................................... 86 References ................................................................................................................................................... 91 Coastal and marine areas ................................................................................................................................ 93 General ecological situation in the region’s coastal and marine areas ....................................................... 93 Principal anthropogenic pressures and their impact ................................................................................... 95 Policy responses ........................................................................................................................................ 102 References ................................................................................................................................................. 107 Atmosphere ..................................................................................................................................................... 109 Air pollution .............................................................................................................................................. 109 Impact of ozone depletion and regional responses ................................................................................... 114 Greenhouse gases and climate change ..................................................................................................... 117 References ................................................................................................................................................. 127 Urban areas .................................................................................................................................................... 129 Socio-economic dynamics ........................................................................................................................ 130 Solid waste ................................................................................................................................................ 131 Water quality ............................................................................................................................................. 133 Air quality ................................................................................................................................................. 135 Vulnerability .............................................................................................................................................. 135 Built environment ...................................................................................................................................... 135 Socio-environmental impact of regional urbanisation .............................................................................. 136 Policies on basic human settlements problems ......................................................................................... 137 References ................................................................................................................................................. 139 Disasters .......................................................................................................................................................... 141 Natural disasters in Latin America and the Caribbean .............................................................................. 141 Technological disasters ............................................................................................................................. 148 The region’s vulnerability to disasters ....................................................................................................... 149 Impact of disasters ..................................................................................................................................... 149 Prevention, mitigation and rehabilitation responses ................................................................................. 150 References ................................................................................................................................................. 156 Environment and human health ................................................................................................................... 158 Epidemiological and environmental risk transition ................................................................................... 158 Anthropogenic degradation of nature and health risks ............................................................................. 160 The impact of environmental risks on sanitation ...................................................................................... 166 Regional responses to environmental health problems ............................................................................. 170 References ................................................................................................................................................. 174 Conclusions .................................................................................................................................................... 176
3: Policy responses to environmental problems Policy responses to environmental problems ............................................................................................. 180 Multilateral environmental agreements and non-binding instruments ...................................................... 181 Environmental policies .............................................................................................................................. 188 Policy implementation and impacts .......................................................................................................... 192 Economic instruments ............................................................................................................................... 195 GEO Latin America and the Caribbean - 2003
Environment Outlook
7 Industries, new technologies and sustainable tourism ............................................................................... 198 Environmental financing sources and mechanisms ................................................................................... 205 Public participation ................................................................................................................................... 210 Environmental information ....................................................................................................................... 215 Environmental training and education ...................................................................................................... 218 References ................................................................................................................................................. 220
4: Regional development scenarios Regional development scenarios ................................................................................................................. 226 Unregulated market scenario .................................................................................................................... 228 Reforms scenario ....................................................................................................................................... 232 Great transitions scenario .......................................................................................................................... 236 Conclusions .............................................................................................................................................. 238 References ................................................................................................................................................. 241
5: Options for action Options for action .......................................................................................................................................... 244 Protecting and promoting the sustainable use of priority ecosystems ....................................................... 245 Managing the urbanisation process ........................................................................................................... 246 Addressing the increasing vulnerability of the region’s population and ecosystems ................................. 246 The challenges for the 21st century .......................................................................................................... 247 References ................................................................................................................................................. 249
Statistical annex Latin America and the Caribbean .............................................................................................................. 252 Mesoamerica ............................................................................................................................................. 258 Caribbean .................................................................................................................................................. 264 South America ........................................................................................................................................... 270 References: statistical annex ...................................................................................................................... 276 GEO Latin America and the Caribbean 2003 Collaborating Centres ................................................................ 278 Other collaborators .......................................................................................................................................... 278
List of boxes and illustrations Introduction: Conceptual framework ................................................................................................................ 16 1: From Stockholm to Johannesburg: environment and development in Latin America and the Caribbean Meetings of the Forum of Ministers of Environment of Latin America and the Caribbean ................................ 22 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002 Socio-economic trends Human development trends over the past 30 years ................................................................................... 34 Population in Latin America and the Caribbean per sub-region, 1970-2000 (in millions) ......................... 37 Expansion of communications media in Latin America and the Caribbean (per 1,000 inhabitants) ........... 38 Land Environmental restrictions on agricultural land use ................................................................................... 40 Land use and soil conditions: the case of Jamaica ..................................................................................... 42 Agricultural land as a proportion of total land area in the region ............................................................... 43
8
Latin America and the Caribbean
Land use change and greenhouse gas emissions ........................................................................................ Loss of soil nutrients ................................................................................................................................... Fertilizer consumption in Latin America .................................................................................................... Towards harmonizing regional public policies to combat desertification ..................................................
44 45 46 49
Forests Forest extent: Latin America and the Caribbean ......................................................................................... Countries with the highest percentage of forests in the world, 2000 .......................................................... Assessment of world forest resources: definitions, methods, and sources .................................................. Use of fuelwood as a source of energy in Mesoamerica ............................................................................ Subsidies for Mexico’s agriculture and livestock sector ............................................................................. Forest rangers: indigenous community forest management ........................................................................ Image of South American hot spots in 2000 ............................................................................................... Payment for environmental services in Costa Rica ..................................................................................... Forest policy: the international framework ................................................................................................. Towards sustainable management of natural forests ..................................................................................
53 53 54 55 56 57 57 59 60 61
Biodiversity Biodiversity in Latin America and the Caribbean (number of flora and vertebrate fauna species) ............. Endemism hot spots in Latin America and the Caribbean .......................................................................... Bioprospection and intellectual property: the conflict for frogs and analgesics in Ecuador ....................... Endangered animal species ........................................................................................................................ Dangers of introducing new species to the islands .................................................................................... Domesticating and breeding Paca (Agouti paca) ....................................................................................... Biotic inventory: a Caribbean necessity ..................................................................................................... Number of protected areas, total area and percentage of protected national territory in 2002 ................. Regional action within the CITES framework ............................................................................................. National response initiatives: the cases of Colombia and Mexico .............................................................. First Ministerial Meeting of Like-Minded Megadiverse Countries ..............................................................
63 64 65 67 69 70 70 71 73 74 75
Freshwater Mean annual precipitation and total renewable water resources in the region ......................................... The Amazon and Parana-La Plata, among the world’s largest water basins ............................................... Availability of water per capita in the region’s water basins ...................................................................... Annual freshwater use per sector ............................................................................................................... Access to drinking water and sanitation in the region ............................................................................... Urban and industrial sewage water pollution in Greater Buenos Aires (1968-1987) and Rio de Janeiro (1996-1998) .......................................................................................................... Regional integrated water resources management efforts ........................................................................... The Guaraní Aquifer .................................................................................................................................. The Cuban experience in water basin management – an on-going success story ......................................
79 80 81 83 84 85 87 88 90
Coastal and marine areas Large marine ecosystems of Latin America and the Caribbean .................................................................. 94 Impact of global warming and El Niño on coastal and marine areas in Latin America and the Caribbean ....................................................................................................... 95 Endangered coastal ecosystems ................................................................................................................. 96 Use and management of major coastal marine areas in Latin America and the Caribbean ........................ 97 Pesticide run-off into the Caribbean Sea .................................................................................................... 98 Degradation and coral loss in Jamaica ....................................................................................................... 98 Oil pollution in the Greater Caribbean ...................................................................................................... 99 Share of Peru and Chile in regional fish catch, 1970-2000 (1,000 metric tonnes) ................................... 101 Total fish catch by FAO regions in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1970-2000 (1,000 metric tonnes) ................................................................................... 102 Evolution of catch of small pelagic organisms in the southeast Pacific, 1970-2000 (1,000 metric tonnes) ..................................................................................................... 103 Concentration of aquaculture production in countries in in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1984-2000 (in percentage) ..................................................... 103 Principal multilateral agreements on regional coastal-marine areas ........................................................ 105 Programmes to protect regional seas and the marine environment from land-based activities ................ 106
GEO Latin America and the Caribbean - 2003
Environment Outlook
9 Atmosphere Air pollution from forest fires ..................................................................................................................... 111 National air quality controls, 1999 ........................................................................................................... 112 Pollution reduction: success stories ........................................................................................................... 113 Growth of the hole in the ozone layer (1985, 1999, 2000) ...................................................................... 115 Ozone risks in Punta Arena and Santiago ................................................................................................. 115 Global efforts to reduce ozone depleting substances ................................................................................ 116 Production and consumption of CFCs in the four main producing and consuming countries in Latin America and the Caribbean (metric tonnes of ozone depletion potential) ................................ 118 Compliance with the Montreal Protocol and its amendments (to September 2002) .................................. 119 The global effort against climate change .................................................................................................. 120 Per capita carbon dioxide emissions in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1970-1998 (metric tonnes) ... 121 Greenhouse gas emissions in carbon dioxide equivalent terms (100 year horizon) ................................. 121 National climate change inventories ....................................................................................................... 122 Regional climate impact associated with El Niño .................................................................................... 124 Climate change mitigating and adaptation activities in selected countries .............................................. 126 Urban areas Historic urban growth of Mexico City, 1973-2000 .................................................................................. Most populated cities in Latin America and the Caribbean ...................................................................... Solid waste collection and disposal in major Latin America and the Caribbean cities ............................. Excessive groundwater withdrawals in the Valley of Mexico ................................................................... Drinking water supply and sanitation services ......................................................................................... Restoring Havana’s historic centre ........................................................................................................... Santiago, Chile: Metropolitan Region Pollution Prevention and Decontamination Plan ......................... Limits to urban spread: the case of Mexico City ...................................................................................... Disasters Natural threats and disasters in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2001 ....................................... Ecological and social implications of earthquakes in El Salvador ............................................................ The eruption of the Soufriére Hills volcano of the Island of Montserrat ................................................... Forest fires in Central America associated with El Niño ........................................................................... Floods in the state of Vargas, Venezuela, 1999 ........................................................................................ Hurricane season in Mesoamerica and the Caribbean, 2001 ................................................................. Hurricane Mitch in Honduras .................................................................................................................. The catastrophe of small disasters ............................................................................................................ Vulnerability of Caribbean countries to natural disasters ......................................................................... Vulnerability to disasters: a geo-referenced index for Honduras .............................................................. Loss of human life from disasters in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1970-1999 ................................ Economic losses from disasters and affected populations in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1970-1999 .................................................................................. Regional disaster early warning action .................................................................................................... El Niño of 1997-1998 in Peru: impact, prevention and damage mitigation ............................................. Environment and human health Epidemiological and environmental risk transition: the WHO approach ................................................. Ecosystems degradation and impacts on human health ........................................................................... Infections related to lack of drinking water, sanitation and poor hygiene (as percentage of the total potential years of life lost through incapacity) ................................................................. Solid waste and associated health risks .................................................................................................... Burden of disease attributable to air quality (as percentage of disability adjusted life years) .................... Health impact of air pollutants ................................................................................................................. Health impact of El Niño .......................................................................................................................... Vector borne diseases ............................................................................................................................... Deaths potentially affected by enviromnental factors, 1994 (as a percentage of total deaths: 10 main causes) ............................................................................. Pan-American Health Organization: regional cooperation projects in the field of environmental protection and development, 2000-2001 .........................................................................................
129 130 132 133 134 136 137 138
142 144 144 145 146 147 147 150 150 151 152 152 154 155
159 161 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 171
10
Latin America and the Caribbean
3: Policy responses to environmental problems Parties to the principal environmental conventions ................................................................................. 183 Principal multilateral environmental agreements in the region ................................................................ 186 The evolution of PROALCOHOL in Brazil ............................................................................................... 189 Trade and the environment – at the crossroads ........................................................................................ 191 Examples of economic instruments for environmental management ....................................................... 194 Categories of economic instruments for environmental management ...................................................... 196 Categorization and regulation of Latin American and the Caribbean countries according to areas of certified organic agricultural production, in transition, or both, 1998-2001 ................................. 198 Area certified through different Rainforest Alliance programmes ............................................................. 199 Hectares of forest certified in Latin America and the Caribbean ............................................................. 200 ISO 9000 and ISO 14001 certified companies in Latin America and the Caribbean (to December 31, 2002) ............................................................................................. 201 National cleaner production centres in Latin America and the Caribbean ............................................... 202 Environmental Innovation Prize ............................................................................................................... 204 Investment in biodiversity in Latin America and the Caribbean ............................................................... 206 International cooperation sources (multilateral, sub-regional and bilateral) ............................................. 207 Monterrey Consensus: development financing ........................................................................................ 209 Millennium Declaration: advances in compliance .................................................................................... 211 National environmental information systems: some regional examples ................................................... 215 Latin America and the Caribbean environmental reports ......................................................................... 217
4: Regional development scenarios Preparing scenarios as a long-term environmental evaluation instrument ............................................... Unregulated market and reform scenarios: statistical data of base year (1995) and projections for 2015 and 2032 ................................................................................................... Comparative analysis of relevant environmental variables in the market and reforms scenarios, 1995-2032 .................................................................................................... Classification of rate of environmental deterioration in relevant scenarios ..............................................
GEO Latin America and the Caribbean - 2003
226 228 235 239
Environment Outlook
11
Foreword
T
he global scene is quite different today to how it was in 2000 when the first Environment Outlook for Latin America and the Caribbean was published. Security has become the main agenda for the global community, making it even more difficult to ensure adequate coverage and financing of environmental issues. At the same time, countries are grasping for ways to reap the rewards of globalisation while limiting its damaging effects. Environmental awareness and action has increased, but not enough to stem the destruction of the earth’s resources. In August 2002, over 190 nations and hundreds of representatives from civil society organisations gathered in Johannesburg, South Africa, for the World Summit on Sustainable Development. While there has been disappointment that nations failed to agree global timetables and targets for many issues, the Summit was an important step forward in areas such as the management of toxic chemicals, equitable access to genetic resources and the sharing of their benefits, reducing biodiversity loss, restoring fisheries, improving developing countries’ access to environmentally-sound alternatives to ozone depleting chemicals, and the provision of basic sanitation. It is within this context that UNEP is releasing the latest edition of the report, GEO Latin America and the Caribbean: Environment Outlook 2003. What this latest assessment tells us is that, unlike the global political scene, environmental trends in the region have changed little since 2000. The region’s rich natural resources, especially its forests, continue to be degraded at an alarming rate. At the same time, the environmental problems of cities, where over three quarters of the population live, continue to cause severe health consequences for city dwellers. Policies in the region, includ-
ing those dealing with pollution in cities, have had some success. Nevertheless, the environment is still not fully integrated into economic decision making. Indeed, of the three pillars of sustainable development, it is the economy that is driving development. Social issues such as poverty and inequality and environmental problems such as biodiversity loss and resources contamination have taken a back seat. At Johannesburg we saw a renewed commitment by the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean to confront this situation. The Latin America and the Caribbean Initiative for Sustainable Development approved during the Summit in many ways goes beyond the commitments made in the Johannesburg Plan of Implementation. The initiative signals the seriousness with which the countries of the region are treating their environmental challenges, as well as their commitment as a group to confronting these challenges. The Forum of Ministers of the Environment of Latin America and the Caribbean, through which the Initiative was developed and approved, provides a unique arena in which common problems are discussed and solutions sought. UNEP, as Secretariat of the Forum, is committed to continue providing all the support necessary so as to ensure that the LAC Initiative is implemented and concrete actions initiated in the areas of particular priority for the region. I hope that the GEO Latin America and the Caribbean: Environment Outlook 2003, as well as the many national and sub-regional GEO assessments already developed by UNEP and its partners in the region, form the foundation for informed decision making and inspire the region’s people in their quest for sustainable development.
Dr. Klaus Toepfer United Nations Under-Secretary General and Executive Director, United Nations Environment Programme
•
Introduction
14
Latin America and the Caribbean
Introduction
E
fficient environmental management requires a firm basis of up-to-date information on the state of the environment. The methodology used by UNEP to make integrated assessments answers four basic management questions: What is happening to the environment?; Why is it happening?; What is being done about it?, and What will happen if appropriate measures are not taken? The Global Environment Outlook project (GEO), was a response to the requirements of Agenda 21 for reports on the environment and to the UNEP Governing Council’s decision in May 1995 requesting that an in-depth report be prepared on the state of the global environment. An integrated analysis was to be prepared on the state of the environment that would include policy options that could lead to concrete action being taken. The project has also evolved by the efforts made at regional, sub-regional, national and municipal levels, using the same methodology and harmonised conceptual framework (See The Conceptual Framework in this section). This report has been prepared thanks to the participation, of a network of collaborating centres, scientists and politicians concerned with the environment. The project, therefore, provides a global and regional synthesis of existing environmental concerns, trends and policies. The GEO project has two main parts: a) A global cross-sectoral, participatory and consultative environmental assessment process. It incorporates regional views and builds consensus on priority issues and actions through dialogue among policy makers (particularly governments) and scientists at regional and global levels. It also aims to strengthen environmental assessment capacity through training and learning by doing. b) GEO material in printed and electronic formats, including the GEO report series. The series presents periodic reviews of the state of the global environment, trends and emerging issues, together with their social and economic impact. It provides guidance for decision making processes such as the formulation of environmental policies, action planning and resources allocation. The following reports have been published: global (GEO 1997, GEO 2000 and GEO 3); regional (GEO LAC 2000 and 2003); sub-regional (GEO Caribbean and GEO Andes); national (GEO Barbados, Brazil, Chile,
GEO Latin America and the Caribbean - 2003
Costa Rica, Cuba, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Panama and Peru); city assessments (GEO cities Bogota, Buenos Aires, Havana, Manaus, Mexico City, Rio de Janeiro, San Salvador and Santiago); technical reports (tropical forest fires) and GEO for Youth. The coordinated global network of collaborating centres (CCs) is at the core of the GEO process. These centres have played an increasingly active role in preparing GEO reports. They are now responsible for almost all the regional inputs, combining top-down integrated assessment with bottom-up environmental reporting. Other institutions provide specialised expertise, interdisciplinary and on thematic issues. Another essential component of the GEO process in the region is the participation of government environmental policy makers, scientists specialised in environmental questions and representatives of non-governmental organisations. Regional consultations are held and other advisory mechanisms are used to foster and contribute to the ongoing dialogue between them. Consultations help to direct the GEO process, serve to review preliminary material and ensure that each report is useful in formulating policies and planning environmental actions. The report GEO Latin America and the Caribbean: Environment Outlook 2003 is the result of a process undertaken in response to the request by the Forum of Latin American and Caribbean Ministers of the Environment continuously to assess the state of the environment in the region, using the GEO methodology (integrated environmental assessment). For the most difficult challenges, including improving the quality of life and conserving natural resources, this report provides a useful and timely instrument. Population growth is now increasing the demand for food, drinking water, shelter, health, energy, basic services and economic security, while at the same time increasing vulnerability of both natural and urban environments. It is a follow-up to the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg (September 2002) and in particular abides by the objectives of the Latin America and the Caribbean Initiative for Sustainable Development (ILAC). The report is an integrated environmental assessment on Latin America and the Caribbean designed to: ·
Update information about the state of the environment.
·
Establish a base to determine environmental priorities.
·
Establish criteria to prepare environmental policies and strategies.
·
Provide a mechanism to assess the efficacy of environmental strategies and policies.
Environment Outlook
15 ·
Strengthen capacities to evaluate and use the information.
This is the scenario in which the second version of the Latin America and Caribbean Environment Outlook is published. It is the most important report on the state of the environment in Latin America and the Caribbean forming the basis for decisions and action. GEO LAC 2003 contains data, indicators and validated and updated information on better environmental management. It will alert and help countries to better prepare themselves to confront, both nationally and regionally, emerging environmental issues. It contains a general description of the state of the environment in the region, giving an overall view of economic, political, social and environmental aspects. The first chapter, The Environment and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean: Three decades of effort describes the historic process of the environmental theme in the region during the period 1972-2002 (Stockholm to Johannesburg), reviewing important events and debates such as the Brundtland Report and the impact of population growth, economic growth and ecological trends. This chapter will allow the reader to learn about the historic context of the regional environmental debate. The second chapter offers a look at the state of the environment with respect to priority themes for the region: land and food, forest, biodiversity, freshwater, marine and coastal areas, atmosphere, human settlements, health, natural threats and disasters. It reflects the situation by giving concrete national examples and up-to-date information. The third chapter offers a systematic description of environmental policies in the region, focussing on ongoing initiatives and policies, identifying gaps, weaknesses and barriers that prevent policies from being suc-
cessfully implemented. This chapter focuses on planning and environmental policy, on assessing how policies are executed and on legislation. In addition, examples are given that highlight the principal existing strengths, opportunities, weaknesses and dangers in responding to environmental problems. The fourth chapter presents three scenarios - a market scenario, a reforms scenario based on public policies, and a great transitions scenario for the region and seeks to identify environmental and development aspects most sensitive to present-day decisions . For each scenario, relevant factors are described for analysis: the general context, key economic aspects, the situation of technology, society and culture, demography, migrations, governance, and analysis of the effects on natural and urban environments. Finally, conclusions and recommendations formulated by experts involved in the process are presented based on the analysis in the document, enabling readers to join forces against environmental deterioration and helping them to become agents for the promotion of sustainable development. The GEO Latin America and the Caribbean: Environment Outlook 2003 report, like the GEO LAC 2000 report, hopes to heighten awareness about the regional environment so that decisions made are correct, pertinent and relevant. There is still a long way to go but, by uniting the efforts of governments, organizations, institutions and civil society in the region, issues concerning the environment can be brought together to formulate and execute policies and actions to improve the quality of life of everyone living in Latin America and the Caribbean, including those yet to be born, as reflected in the Latin American and Caribbean Initiative for Sustainable Development.
16
Latin America and the Caribbean
Conceptual framework
© R. Burgos
The conceptual framework used in the GEO project is based on the State-Pressure-Impact-Response (SPIR) methodology. The integrated environmental assessments that use this approach seek to respond to questions not only about the state of the environment, but also about why it is in that state, what we are doing about it and what will happen if the response is not the right one. The SPIR approach begins by depicting the state of the environment; that is, the environmental condition being analyzed: for example, land degradation, water pollution, or the loss of biodiversity. Since its first global report, GEO has used the following topics: · · · · · · · ·
Land Forests Biodiversity Coastal and marine areas Freshwater Urban areas Atmosphere Disasters
In this second regional report in the GEO series a new theme is included for the first time, that of Environment and Human Health. This theme will highlight the existing relations between the situation of the natural world and the human condition in Latin America and the Caribbean. In addition, GEO reports always include an initial section on socio-economic background to profile the
GEO Latin America and the Caribbean - 2003
development features that have such a determining influence on the environment. In this respect, pressure refers to the forces underlying the state and evolution of the environment. Much of this pressure comes from human activities such as those described in the socio-economic background section: the prevalent patterns of production and consumption; population growth; poverty and inequality; and governance mechanisms. However, it is also necessary to consider the pressure resulting from the dynamics of nature itself. These include geological, climate and biological processes that form the basis of human activity, as well as global conditions and waste processing limits. The impact is the effect of the environment – positive or negative, constructive or destructive – on human activity and on whether human beings can continue to subsist or survive as they do in natural surroundings. Principal effects on the population include people’s health, productivity and quality of life. As to truly natural effects, an assessment should be made of the capacity of ecosystems to develop their basic vital functions of providing the population with essential environmental services. The SPIR approach ends the cycle of integrated assessment by considering the human response to three issues: the situation of the environment; the pressure that causes it; and its effects on human activity and natural surroundings. The response to the pressure is strategic, given that only by eliminating the root causes
Environment Outlook
17 Conceptual framework (continuation) will it be possible to reverse environmental degradation and achieve sustainability. However, it is of great political importance to consider the effects of the present situation of the environment, and the response to them, since this will permit the identification of the core problems that will help mobilize social action in this field. The most important of these effects include those related to human health, so that the theme of Environment and Human Health is of particular relevance in this second regional report. The following responses are of particular interest for the GEO reports: ·
Ratification and implementation of multilateral environmental agreements and non-binding instruments (including multilateral global or regional agreements and action plans). These agreements and instruments are the global framework for environmental action, creating an international regime of opportunities, rights and duties in this field.
·
National environmental legal codes and institutions which form the basis for formulating and implementing policies.
·
Application of economic instruments in environmental policies, within the framework of other, non-environmental, sectoral policies and macroeconomic policies. These instruments are complementary to command and control policies and at times are more effective. However, consideration must be given to the effect –generally negative– of environmental policies implicit in agricultural, industrial or trade policies, as well as in fiscal or monetary macroeconomic policies.
·
Industries and new technologies related to the environment. Production and consumption initiatives, which often have important consequences for the environment.
·
Sources and mechanisms of financing for environmental action, both international (development assistance, direct foreign investment) and national (taxes, payment for environmental services).
·
Public participation in issues concerning the environment, perhaps the principal short-term driver for global and local change.
·
Environmental information that establishes the basis of scientific knowledge behind political decisions and public participation.
·
Environmental training and education, which makes possible medium and long-term transformations in decision makers and the public by building capacities.
For the first time since the beginning of the GEO project, this retrospective report attempts to prepare (as in the global report GEO 3, recently published), an analysis on the state of the environment with a thematic coverage of the whole SPIR cycle. For each theme the second chapter gives an account not only of the respective situations, but also of the main effects and responses during the period of analysis. However, given the role that policies play in helping to reverse environmental deterioration, this regional report presents, as did the first, a chapter specifically devoted to policies. Chapter 3 gives details of the types of responses mentioned above, dealing with many of the most important experiences on the themes of interest following the GEO approach. The thematic analysis used (land, forests, biodiversity, etc.) does not give a precise or specific description of existing relations between the different themes, although this is certainly mentioned when they are relevant either as pressures or effects. The growing expansion of land for agriculture, for example, leads to deforestation and land degradation or loss of natural habitats, with a great deterioration of biodiversity. Soil pollution from the use of agrochemicals has equally serious consequences for biodiversity, quality of continental waters, coastal and marine areas and, finally, the health of the regional population. Loss of biodiversity has negative medium- and long-term effects on sustainability of agriculture and human nutrition. The dynamics of unplanned urbanization and pollution by industry has adverse multiplying effects on the atmosphere, soils, forests, coasts and seas. The complex cause and effect relations fall outside the study’s specific scope, except for the section on Environment and Human Health, which analyses the inter-relationships, as far as quality of human life is concerned. In the rest of the study, however, they are not the focus of this analysis.
•
Chapter:
1 From Stockholm to Johannesburg: environment and development in Latin America and the Caribbean
20
Latin America and the Caribbean
From Stockholm to Johannesburg: environment and development in Latin America and the Caribbean
T
he United Nations Conference on the Human En vironment, held in Stockholm in 1972, was the first international conference on the environment that brought together 113 countries and other stakeholders to debate questions of common concern, and it was a turning point in modern thinking on the environment and development. Thirty years later, the Latin America and Caribbean region faces two huge interrelated challenges: how to introduce changes that are both productive and fair, and how to administer natural resources. The first is part of the region’s traditional aspirations and influences its politics. The second has been included more and more in the development agenda (Rosenthal, 1994). At the end of the 1960s, when the environment became an international concern, industrialised countries took the initiative by convening the Stockholm Conference. That may explain why the problem of the environment was initially considered from a rather narrow perspective, as a disease of the rich, a sequel to the economic growth from which they had derived unparalleled levels of wealth and prosperity. Developing countries saw this concern of the rich as a new limitation on their own development. They insisted that the dialogue should include questions related to poverty, underdevelopment, inequality and natural resources, closely and inextricably linked to their own environmental conditions and prospects (Strong, 1994). The Stockholm Conference made a significant contribution to the incorporation of the environment in policies and other public management instruments. Then, only a handful of Latin American and Caribbean representatives were interested in the subject, while today all countries in the region have an environmental institutional and policy base, and citizens’ organisations have multiplied. Over the past 30 years, substantial advances have been made by countries in the region. Environmental themes have been institutionalised, environmental ministries established, natural protected areas set up, environmental rights added to constitutions and a legal apparatus developed. Public opinion has also become in-
·
creasingly well informed and alert. Nevertheless, there is still an awareness that the situation continues to be serious and that much still needs to be done. Concern about the environment has spread: it can be found amongst farmers who seek new ecological alternatives for their crops, as well as amongst entrepreneurs interested in eco-efficient innovations; it is defended in universities and by civil society organisations. No longer regarded as either an issue for rich countries or even a curiosity, the environment has crossed national boundaries and continents and is now the focus of global attention. It has become relevant to the extent that development can no longer be defined without including it. This chapter will review some of the most important aspects of this three-decade history.
Stockholm: growth and population The Stockholm Conference was the first important governmental meeting to concentrate on what was being called the “human environment”. It took place in the context of growing citizen protest and increasing concern in industrialised countries about deterioration of the environment. The conference debate rapidly veered towards the environment’s relations with development, pollution and environmental degradation, the role of poverty and the effects of population growth. Two of these broad themes – the relations between environmental measures and economic growth, and the effects of population growth – had been dealt with a short time earlier in “The Limits to Growth”, a study undertaken for the Club of Rome by a team of researchers (Meadow and others, 1972). This analysis found that there were environmental limits to economic growth, and that if the direction taken during those years were continued, the end result could lead to environmental catastrophe, general famine and population decline. The discussion had become largely bogged down in fixed positions, generating conflict between environmental and economic policies. Several Latin American leaders viewed environmental measures of any kind as impediments to economic progress. This polarisation is possible in any context where material development is taken to mean economic growth. A number of diplomats in Stockholm defended the need to draw up their own environmental policies independently, arguing that the requirements of developed countries – perhaps an unattainable luxury - could not be applied in the region. They went as far as to deny that there was any cause for anxiety about the environment. Concern for economic progress explains the focus on purely economic problems such as international trade
Chapter 1: From Stockholm to Johannesburg: Environment and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean
Environment Outlook
terms and the role of relations between states and national sovereignty. Concerned that industrialised countries might start imposing conditions, Latin American and Caribbean countries insisted on maintaining their sovereign right to decide how their natural resources were to be used. Meanwhile “The Limits to Growth” was being discussed in Latin American fora. One example is the Bariloche Foundation’s “World Model”, with distinguished intellectuals declaring that “there are no absolute physical limits in the foreseeable future”, insisting on the abundance of Latin America’s natural resources, emphasising the political aspects of their distribution and renewing their faith in progress (Herrera, 1975). However, going further than raising reasonable doubts arising out of economic policy, there was also a minimalist view that played down environmental aspects and suggested the better use of available technical solutions and ideal state planning. Much attention was also paid in Stockholm to population growth. The warning about a “demographic time bomb” was heard everywhere, and some countries feared that they would be called to account because of their high birth rates (Ehrlich, 1968). Their response, led by the molecular biologist and environmental activist Barry Commoner of the United States, pointed out that over-consumption and social inequality should also be included as principal causes of environmental damage (Commoner, 1971). Thus, the questions connected with consumption of environmental resources and identifying the perpetrators quickly became part of the discussion. Questions kept being raised about the relations between ecology and the economy on the one hand, and environment and consumption, on the other.
impact in various international fora, including the Earth Summit of 1992 (Urquidi, 1994). In the 1970s an intermediate opinion emerged which, although it had no repercussions on its appearance, was to serve almost 10 years later as a basis of the notion of a new “sustainable development economy”. It was called “ecodevelopment” by the French economist Ignacy Sachs. A t the beginning of that decade, he had been one of the first to highlight the reconciliation of development and environmental policies (Urquidi, 1994).
Environmental issues become international In the latter part of the 1970s and at the start of the 1980s, development meant the greater deterioration of natural areas and environmental conditions, and the emergence and strengthening of a wide network of environmental organisations. A sense of commitment appeared in discussions about the environment, especially on flora and fauna conservation. During that decade the debate, which had so far been concentrated on tropical forests, especially in
One positive result of the conference, in addition to a declaration of policy, was the recommendation that a United Nations environmental agency be established. Months later, a UN General Assembly resolution created the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) with headquarters in a southern hemisphere country (Kenya) and offices in the different regions. The Latin America and Caribbean (LAC) office was established in Mexico. The debate between environmentalists and economists broadened after 1972. To begin with, Latin American economists took little part in the debate, but later “The Interaction between Styles of Development and the Environment in Latin America” by Chilean economist Osvaldo Sunkel was published as a joint project, running between 1978 and 1989, between the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC) and UNEP. In November 1979 a regional seminar was held in Santiago, Chile, out of which the Argentinian economist Raúl Prebisch published “Biosphere and Development”. Later, the thinking of these people and other Latin Americans was to have an
21
© R. Burgos
Chapter
1
22
Latin America and the Caribbean
Central America and the Amazon, began to broaden in recognition of the global value of national natural resources. Unlike the Stockholm era, other stakeholders as well as governments became involved: multilateral development banks such as the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) or the World Bank (WB); international and national non-governmental organisations (NGOs); later on, indigenous organisations such as the Co-ordinator of Indigenous Organizations of the Amazon Basin (COICA) also joined in. During the 1970s, more than one country defended the development of the Amazon “at any price” model. The creation of the Treaty for Amazon Cooperation in 1978 was a palliative that placed conditions on the role that NGOs and indigenous groups could play. The possibility of broadening the discussion was limited by authoritarian regimes in several southern cone countries and by political and military instability in Central America. For almost 20 years UNEP stressed the economic advantages of environmental protection and the costs of damage to natural resources. This resulted in: cleaning up the Baltic Sea and part of the Mediterranean; the Montreal Protocol of 1987 to reduce, and eventually ban, the production and use of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs); the Basel Convention of 1989 on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes; the initiation of negotiations on global climate change, and several other specific and regional agreements and action plans (see the section on Atmosphere in Chapter 2). In 1982 the Forum of Ministers of the Environment of Latin America and the Caribbean was created. The Forum is the longest standing, most representative and important political gathering for reaching agreement on environmental policies and responses on a regional scale. All the countries of the region are members. The Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP/ ROLAC) acts as the Secretariat. Since 1982 there have been fourteen meetings of the Forum in different cities of the region, helping to orient environmental activities and ensure that regional and international cooperation is more and more efficient and coherent and better targets the priorities identified by the ministers. Conservation organisations flourished, promoting their interests in protecting important ecosystems or endangered species. They quickly understood that the basic causes of such problems were to be found in development strategies, especially in economic practices. Promoted by the World Conservation Union (IUCN) with the support of UNEP and the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF), the first World Conservation Strategy was drafted in 1980 (IUCN, UNEP and WWF, 1980). This was a key document that recognised the importance of economics and development, and linked them in an
·
environmental strategy. Its proposals place emphasis on satisfying human needs (present and future) and the quality of life rather than simply pushing economic growth; this endorsed the doubts that had been cast during that era. For many years this was the reference document of the principal environmental agencies in Latin America and the Caribbean, and provided one of the first modern definitions of development as “sustainable”, with a new look on ecological limits.
Meetings of the Forum of Ministers of Environment of Latin America and the Caribbean 1982 1983 1984 1985 1987 1989 1990 1993 1995 1996 1998 2000 2001 2003
Mexico City Buenos Aires, Argentina Lima, Peru Cancun, Mexico Montevideo, Uruguay Brasilia, Brazil Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago Santiago, Chile La Habana, Cuba Buenos Aires, Argentina Lima, Peru Bridgetown, Barbados Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Panama City, Panama
In terms of better environmental awareness a number of events stand out: the denunciations regarding the burning of the Amazon forest in newspapers within and outside of the region, the impact of the trials of the Kayapo Indians in Brazil, and the assassination of the Brazilian leader Chico Mendes in 1998 (Gross, 1989). Strong international pressure included declarations by several European presidents to proclaim the Amazon as “humanity’s heritage”. Once again, several governments reacted by claiming autonomy and asked that the subject of the environment be included in the assistance provided by developed countries. In some countries, pressure from outside the region also had a strong impact on reformulating policies. Loans by multilateral development banks began to have environmental strings attached. From the middle of the 1990s, both the IDB and the WB introduced programmes on “institutional strengthening” of the environment. In other cases, this reformulation was associated with the economic integration process in the region. For example, changes were made to Mexico’s environmental administration as a result of the negotiations of the Free Trade Agreement with the United States and Canada (between 1990 and 1992).
Chapter 1: From Stockholm to Johannesburg: Environment and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean
Environment Outlook
“Our Common Future” and “Our Own Agenda” The political side developed during the mid-1980s in tandem with the establishment by the United Nations Secretary General in 1983 of a World Commission on Environment and Development. With Gro Harlem Brundtland of Norway as president, this body had 23 members (including four from Latin America). “Our Common Future”, the Commission’s report, suggested possible economic growth based on policies of sustainability and expanding the environmental resources base. The hope it expressed for a better future was, however, conditional as it depended on resolute political action permitting proper administration of environmental resources for sustainable human progress and also the survival of the human species. The Commission observed that many “development” examples were leading to increased poverty, vulnerability and even degradation of the environment. This demonstrated the pressing need for a new concept of development that would protect future human progress: “Sustainable development” was defined as “development that satisfies the present needs of people without compromising the capacity of future generations to satisfy their needs” (CMMAD, 1987). It recognises as the warning given by the Club of Rome that the biosphere had a limited capacity to absorb environmental impacts, but that other restraints it was calling for depended essentially on human beings, and therefore could be modified by social organisation and technology. The contradiction between conservation and economic growth, becoming apparent after the Stockholm Conference, was reinterpreted. The ecological framework, that had earlier been regarded as an insuperable obstacle to growth, then became essential to ensure it. The idea of conservation as a condition for growth had already been met in discussions in several contemporary fora. In 1987, for example, a document issued by the WB and the International Monetary Fund joint development committee had pointed out that economic growth was complementary to environmental conservation and the eradication of poverty (DC, 1987). Along these same lines emerged “Our Own Agenda” (1990), an initiative for Latin America and the Caribbean promoted by the IDB and the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) as a “Development and Environmental Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean” (CDMAALC, 1990). This proposal for the most part repeated the concepts of “Our Common Future”, placing emphasis on the fair distribution of the social benefits of natural resources. It is thought that the
23
limited effect of this agenda was due to the lack of backing by civil organisations of the work of the editing committee set up by the initiative’s organisers, hence its proposals had little effect on the preparation of the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro in 1992.
The Earth Summit process In response to the Brundtland Commission, in December 1989 the United Nations General Assembly convened a Conference on the Environment and Development destined to be held in June 1992. It was decided that countries would be represented by their heads of state or of government at this event, that later became known as the first “Earth Summit”. Resolution 44/ 228 made it clear that this would be a conference on “the environment and development” with the subjects integrated in every aspect from climate change to human settlements. It was hoped that a series of concrete measures would emerge from the conference, including the following (Strong, 1994): ●
An “Earth Charter” or declaration of basic principles to serve countries and individuals as a guide of conduct concerning the environment and development, ensuring a future for the Earth as a hospitable home for human beings and other forms of life.
●
An action agenda - “Agenda 21” - to establish the work programme agreed upon by the international community for the post-1992 period and the 21st century, with reference to subjects dealt with at the conference, together with setting priorities and goals, estimating costs, designing methods and assigning responsibilities.
●
The means of putting this agenda into practice, including: - financial resources, - transfer of technology, - strengthening institutional capacities and processes.
It took several years to prepare for the Earth Summit by mobilising governments, especially non-governmental organisations. During the preparatory phase, and at the Summit itself, the conviction emerged that the success of the conference would be judged not by what happened in June 1992, but by what would be achieved in the following years (Montaño, 1994). It proved impossible to separate documents endorsed by governments at the Earth Summit from other proposals presented in the process of the preparation of the Summit. Amongst the most important was the IUCN’s second World Conservation Strategy, prepared jointly with UNEP and WWF (1991), called “Caring for the Earth”. This defined sustainable development as improv-
Chapter
1
24
Latin America and the Caribbean
© R. Burgos
ing the “quality of human life without exhausting the capacity of ecosystems that sustain it”. The report added that a “sustainable economy” was the product of this type of development where it was possible to maintain the basis of natural resources and “may continue developing by means of adaptation and improved knowledge, organisation and technical efficiency, and greater understanding”. This strategy made it clear that profound cultural changes would be needed, and proposed nine principles for a “sustainable society”: respecting and caring for the community of living beings; improving the quality of human life; conserving biodiversity; reducing to a minimum the exhaustion of non-renewable resources; keeping within the Earth’s capacity; modifying personal attitudes and practices; empowering communities to care for their own environments; providing a national framework to integrate development and conservation; and building a world alliance. These contributions expanded the environmental agenda beyond just concern for endangered species and landscapes, to a wider outlook on the concept of using biodiversity (which ranges from genetic resources to ecosystems), relations with development strategies, the institutional base, and science and technology. At the same time, civil organisations and environmental groups were promoting their own ideas in different fora. An example is the “Ya Wananchi” Agenda approved at the international meeting on “Roots of the Future” (Paris, December 1991) (Ya Wananchi, 1991). This issued a warning that the essential question was not conservation of the environment itself, but rather how to administer natural resources to achieve the most effective social, economic and physical sustainable development. In Latin America and the Caribbean declarations and contributions were made like those of “Las Vertientes”·(Chile) and “Las Leñas” (Argentina). One outstanding aspect of the NGO participation at the Earth Summit was the generation of “alternative agreements”, with their own contributions and vision of the subjects under discussion (FIONGsMS, 1993). These offered a range of approaches, depth of analysis and suggestions for preparing proposals. ·
Latin American and Caribbean governments and organisations insisted on maintaining the close relationship between the region’s poverty and environmental circumstances, which often gave rise to problems. The meeting of environment ministers called by UNEP in 1990 concluded that “there is an indissoluble link between environmental deterioration and poverty” since both are interacting effects of the same world process of defective growth. “Improving economic and social conditions”, said the environment ministers on this occasion, “will be the essential factor in halting environmental degradation in the region” (UNEP/ROLAC, 1990). In 1992, the Rio Earth Summit marked a turning point by producing agreements that attempted to treat global environmental subjects more comprehensively by including sustainable development as a main goal. At the beginning of the 1990s, the five Earth Summit agreements provided the most universal political and articulated response to the problem of how to establish an international co-operation regime designed to achieve full inclusion of the environment into development. They are:, ●
The Rio Declaration on the Environment and Development;
●
Agenda 21;
●
The Declaration on principles relating to forests;
●
The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, and
●
The Convention on Biological Diversity.
The Rio Declaration was the cornerstone of the concept of sustainable development. For the first time, principles were introduced and accepted by all participants that serve to build new relations among countries and encourage economic, social and environmental balance between developed and developing countries. The following principles are especially important:
Chapter 1: From Stockholm to Johannesburg: Environment and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean
Environment Outlook
●
Principle 7: States shall co-operate in a spirit of global partnership to conserve, protect and restore the health and integrity of the Earth’s ecosystem. In view of the different contributions to global environmental degradation, States have common but differentiated responsibilities. The developed countries acknowledge the responsibility they bear in the international pursuit for sustainable development in view of the pressures their societies place on the global environment and of the technologies and financial resources they command.
●
Principle 8: To achieve sustainable development and a higher quality of life for all people, States should reduce and eliminate unsustainable patterns of production and consumption and promote appropriate demographic policies.
●
Principle 9: States should cooperate to strengthen endogenous capacity-building for sustainable development by improving scientific understanding by exchanges of scientific and technological knowledge, and by enhancing the development, adaptation, diffusion and transfer of technologies, including new and innovative technologies.
●
Principle 10: Environmental issues are best handled with participation of all concerned citizens, at the relevant level. At the national level, each individual shall have appropriate access to information concerning the environment that is held by public authorities, including information on hazardous materials and activities in their communities, and the opportunity to participate in decision-making processes. States shall facilitate and encourage public awareness and participation by making information widely available. Effective access to judicial and administrative proceedings, including redress and remedy, shall be provided.
●
Principle 11: States shall enact effective environmental legislation. Environmental standards, management objectives and priorities should reflect the environmental and development context to which they apply. Standards applied by some countries may be inappropriate and of unwarranted economic and social cost to other countries in particular developing countries.
●
·
Principle 15: In order to protect the environment, the precautionary approach shall be widely applied by States according to their capabilities. Where there are threats of serious or irreversible damage, lack of full scientific certainty shall not be used as a reason for posting cost-effective measures to prevent environmental degradation. Principle 16: National authorities should endeavour to promote the internalization of environmental costs and the use of economic instruments, taking into account the approach that the polluter should, in prin-
25
ciple, bear the cost of pollution, with due regard to the public interest and without distorting international trade and investment. The results of the Earth Summit are still being felt today. The Commission on Sustainable Development, with a copious agenda, was constituted within the framework of the United Nations. The different international agreements are still in force and have resulted in specific protocols (such as the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, and the Kyoto Protocol of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change). Agenda 21 has been diversified, especially regarding local initiatives. With the conference as a starting point, other regional initiatives have been developed, such as the Central American Alliance for Sustainable Development (1994), the Summit of the Americas on Sustainable Development (Santa Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia, 1996) and the commitments of the Andean Community to protect its biodiversity. The Action Programme for Sustainable Development in Small Island Developing States in the Caribbean deserves a special mention. The particular situation of the world’s small island states became obvious, both during the preparations and at the Earth Summit. This prompted the United Nations to call a special conference on how to make sustainable development feasible in those countries. As a result, the United Nations World Conference on Sustainable Development in Small Island Developing States was held in 1994. It issued the Declaration of Barbados and the Programme of Action, adopted by 111 participating governments, proposing principles and development strategies designed to protect the fragile environment in small insular developing states (ECLAC-UNEP, 2001b).
New economic conditions: 1990-2002 The debt crisis brought about political and economic changes in Latin America and the Caribbean. It also led to new conditions which, during the 1990s, had a great affect on the administration of the environment. These included liberalisation of foreign trade, reduction of state regulations, privatisation of public companies and services, liberalisation of financial markets, more flexible labour relations and contracts, and also the extension of property rights into new areas. In consequence, patterns of foreign trade and exports have been modified, leaving a number of national industrial sectors unprotected and increasing the export of raw materials. Markets were opened, countries began to import more goods at lower prices, and their consumption patterns converted to reflect short-life material goods that quickly became obsolete, and with more non-biodegradable components.
Chapter
1
26
Latin America and the Caribbean
Agricultural industries expanded with redevelopment that promoted the export of crops, in large measure those for livestock feed (sorghum, rice, soya beans), and in other cases those for specific consumption niches in developed countries (fruit from Central America and Chile, flowers from Colombia). This led to the expansion of agriculture into wildlife areas and to pollution of soils and water. Efforts were made to increase exports to the maximum and to lower costs; environmental controls were seen as impediments. While the importance of conservation was highlighted in Stockholm and at the Earth Summit, agriculture has always remained a subject for debate. Environmental regulation has been associated with restrictions on food self-sufficiency. This was made worse by the reduction of state functions and the weakening of sectoral development planning. A great deal of agricultural management is subject to market conditions, making it hard to include controls and environmental improvements (Escudero, 1998).
Laws and institutions States in Latin America and the Caribbean have given different responses to the subject of the environment. In the first place, they have included it in their programmed goals. Secondly, they have expanded their coverage by using policy measures to regulate approaches to and management of the environment. It was only after the Earth Summit that consideration of the environment as a subject was accepted not only by governments but also by other stakeholders such as business leaders. Since that time the discussion has centred on how to harmonise environmental protection with economic development, and how to resolve conflicts. Taking as a focal point the preparation of general rules, nation states specify the subjects for inclusion and the methods for discussing them. This has led to different environmental laws being passed, both in general (for example, environmental codes, or on the assessment of the environmental impact) and specific laws (laws on water or forests). However, fewer advances have been made in making environmental management and participation more democratically accessible. Mention may also be made of the general trend towards institutionalising aspects which were considered earlier to be almost exclusively the province of private political action by environmentalists. This process is reinforced by external demands (industrialised countries, multilateral development banks, co-operation agencies), and by national pressure (the environmental movement itself, the press). Participating stakeholders have many different objectives and adopt different positions. Interactions between new and old policies, as well as the impulse of the Stockholm Conference and espe·
cially of the Earth Summit, have released a torrent of new legal and institutional environmental frameworks. These reflect the sustainable development concerns of society in Latin America and the Caribbean. This is perhaps one of the most concrete consequences perceptible at state level over the past 30 years (Brañes, 2001). The recent complex political history of most of these countries has brought about an institutional renovation that is reflected in constitutional changes. Between 1972 and 1999 the following new political constitutions incorporating the environment have been drafted: in Panama (1972); Cuba (1976); Peru (1979 and 1993); and Ecuador (1979 and 1998), amongst others. The Constitution of Panama (1972) was the first to indicate that the state should protect the environment and that of Cuba (1976) substituted the word “state” for “society” (Brañes, 2001). The “first wave” of legal and institutional reforms is associated with the influence of the Stockholm Conference; laws on environmental impact and general laws on the environment were promulgated, and the first governmental agencies on the environment were established. Colombia was the regional pioneer with a highlevel institutionalisation of the environment (National Code on Renewable and Protected Natural Resources, 1974). Later, Venezuela passed a decree on Organic Law on the Environment (1976) which led to the creation of the Ministry of the Environment and Renewable Natural Resources, an example followed by Ecuador, Cuba, Brazil, Guatemala, Mexico, Peru and Bolivia. The content of these laws is similar: national environmental policy, legal instruments to apply it and protection of certain natural resources (Brañes, 2001). In the English-speaking Caribbean, laws and policies to protect the environment came along later. The initial efforts were devoted to establishing ministerial responsibilities. After the Earth Summit, attempts were made to conclude regional agreements. The first comprehensive attempt was the National Conservation and Environmental Protection Act in Saint Kitts and Nevis (1987), followed by the Natural Resources Conservation Act in Jamaica (1991). Afterwards, laws of this type were established in Belize, Trinidad and Tobago, Saint Lucia and Guyana (UNEP, 2002). On a regional scale, there was a second wave” of reforms associated with the Earth Summit, expanding legislation and creating ministries of the environment. Until nearly 1990, only one such ministry existed in the region, the Ministry of the Environment and Renewable Natural Resources of Venezuela, created in 1976. In general, the environmental component used to be a dependency of an existing ministry or secretariat (Brañes, 2001). After the 1992 Summit, however, innovations were proposed such as the establishment in Bolivia of the Ministry of Sustainable Development (including environmental administration with economic planning), a national comptroller’s office for the environment, and
Chapter 1: From Stockholm to Johannesburg: Environment and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean
Environment Outlook
biodiversity, forestry and mining superintendents (with the exceptional attribute of being under parliamentary control). In addition, countries in the region have increasingly been ratifying or approving international treaties, conventions or agreements dedicated to the environment (Morán, 1996). This trend has been accompanied – and, to a great extent, counterbalanced – by extensive structural reforms in the 1990s that reduced the state’s presence in several countries. The effect was to transfer part of the administration to private stakeholders, and in some cases to fragment or reduce the size of secretariats or ministries (Acuña, 2000). There are still problems about applying legislation and how to relate it to other policies, especially economic (Brañes, 2001). In general, difficulties persist in the introduction of the environmental dimension at a high level in development strategies. For example, one recent IDB assessment warned that the mechanisms of environmental assessment “are not concretely incorporated”, limiting the possibility of exerting a high-level influence (Espinoza and Alzina, 2001). Much has been accomplished in the last three decades. Nevertheless, concern about the environment is growing. Numerous environmental authorities such as secretariats and ministries have been established and environmental policies have been developed and strengthened through institutional change and legislation. Most Latin American and the Caribbean countries have included the environment in their constitutions and different environmental laws enacted have resulted in progress. The number of international and regional environmental agreements has grown over the past 30 years, bringing greater awareness of the environment and better decision-making. Groups of citizens and nongovernmental organisations in the region now play a more important role in development and conservation activities that concern the environment. This is done with timely participation and based on open and transparent information, even if these steps have not been able to reverse the trends of poverty growth and environmental degradation.
Nature and the Market While the economy-ecology discussion has been going on for years, at the end of the 1980s a price began to be placed on nature, and ways were sought to introduce the environment into the market as yet another commodity. These ideas had already been mentioned in the Earth Summit declarations, but the most important regional step was taken by combining the ideas in Changing Productive Patterns with Social Equity by ECLAC with outside influences (ECLAC, 1990: Anderson, 1992, Baden and Stroup, 1992). The problem was how to assign the concept of capital to nature and thus change conservation into a type of investment; a price would be put on nature and it
27
would be given property rights. Ideas of this kind abound in proposals made during the past ten years by the WB, the IDB and other international agencies, and have been taken up by different regional institutions. This was an advance compared to the previous situation, where nature was ignored in economic terms. In many cases the economic cost of pollution or soil degradation had become evident; in others, encouragement was given to defending natural areas for their potential economic value. Attempts were made to introduce national corrections into environmental accounts by using environmental indicators, or by means of satellite accounts that included environmental assessments (Gligo, 1990). It was also important to identify legitimate competition by seeking the highest environmental quality to improve international trade (CEPAL, 1991). However, tensions also became evident. In some cases the whole of nature has been reduced to an expression of natural capital and environmental policy confined to technical questions, usually associated with determining the true price of natural resources and naming their owners. This is no easy task; some people assign a high value to wildlife while to others it is of little value. The situation is made even more difficult when conservation efforts bring no evident economic yields or, on the contrary, when exploitation turns out to be a profitable business (Leff, 1994). This problem has had a major influence on discussions of sustainable development. The trend on economic assessment inclines towards the so-called “weak sustainability” currents. Another trend which, rather than go against the first one, overtakes it, accepts economic assessment as one of several factors. “Super strong” sustainability brings back the plurality of values (economic or otherwise), accepting that open debate is needed if better results are to be achieved.
Ten years after the Earth Summit and future outlook In October 2001the Latin America and Caribbean regional preparatory conference devised an action plan that was presented to the Commission on Sustainable Development. As a leitmotif for the Johannesburg Summit in 2002, the countries put forward ideas for an equitable, inclusive and sustainable new globalisation, pointing out the need for “greater coherence and coordination between environmental, social and economic strategies and policies” (ECLAC-UNEP, 2001a). The thousands of participants at Johannesburg included heads of state and of government, national delegates, and leaders of non-governmental organisations, business and other main groups. Attention was centred on challenges such as improving the quality of life and conservation in a world of constantly increasing population, augmenting the demand for food, water,
Chapter
1
28
Latin America and the Caribbean
housing, energy, sanitation services and economic security.
●
Kyoto Protocol: when Russia ratified the Protocol there were enough signatures for it to enter into force.
At the extraordinary meeting of the Forum of Ministers of the Environment of Latin America and the Caribbean, held within the framework of the Johannesburg Summit, the Latin America and Caribbean Initiative for Sustainable Development (ILAC) was approved and included in the Summit’s implementation plan. Its objectives are to:
●
Natural resources: losses in seas and forests should be halted, “as soon as possible”
●
Sanitary installations: by 2015, the number of people without running water or access to sanitary services should be reduced by half.
●
Energy: it was agreed to increase renewable energy sources; however, neither goals nor timetables were set.
●
Increase the use of renewable energy sources until 10 % of the regional energy requirements are met.
●
Increase natural protected areas and forest lands.
●
Improve management of watersheds and marine and coastal zones, and reduce the discharge of pollutants.
●
Adopt regulatory frameworks for access to genetic resources, according to the fair distribution of benefits principle.
●
Reduce emissions into the air and increase coverage of drinking water services and sewage treatment.
●
Implement plans and policies to reduce urban environmental vulnerability in the face of anthropogenic disasters and those caused by natural phenomena, including the formulation of a regional early warning system.
●
Implement the Kyoto Protocol.
●
Develop technologies to ensure the quality and proper management of water.
●
Advance in areas such as health, the eradication of poverty and equity and sustainability of production and consumption patterns.
The Declaration of Johannesburg reaffirms the determination to work in the name of sustainable development. Furthermore, a Plan of Implementation was agreed with recommendations and objectives to reconcile economic growth, social justice and protection of the environment. Among the actions and goals established the following are of special interest: ●
·
Biodiversity: by 2010 there should be a “significant reduction” in the current rate of loss of animal and plant species.
●
Chemical products: by 2020 the significant adverse effects of chemical substances on human beings and nature should be minimised.
●
Fishery: there should be no excessive harvesting of fishery resources. By 2015 one of the goals is to restore damaged fish stocks.
●
Trade and globalisation subsidies that harm the environment should be eliminated.
The Declaration also left loose ends. The Plan of Implementation did not include a timetable to end rich countries’ agricultural subsidies or to end the crisis in international prices of basic products. The Plan urged all countries to “substantially increase” the use of renewable energy, but did not stipulate specific percentages or time limits to comply. Three decades after the Stockholm Conference, it is clear that environmental problems are problems arising out of development in a manner unfair to human societies and harming natural systems. The developed world bears the greater responsibility. It will be impossible to achieve environmentally and socially sustainable development if countries are not disposed to change their present growth patterns and how they use their natural patrimonies (Guimaraes and Bárcena, 2001). In seeking solutions to environmental problems on world and regional scales, and in the face of pressing needs of sustainable development, the efforts of countries in the region should be directed towards implementing ILAC by: setting action priorities to promote development by establishing models that put an end to poverty, inequity and environmental deterioration; improve environmental education in all its economic and social aspects; introduce sustainable energy use and increase the use of renewable energy sources; manage protected areas for sustainable use of biodiversity; adapt to the effects of climate change and sustainable management in urban and rural areas, with special emphasis on actions concerning health, environmental sanitation and minimizing vulnerability risks from natural disasters (UNEP/ROLAC, 2002). Amongst the changes proposed to the economic plan is a productive restoration that satisfies the three criteria of increasing competition, reducing social inequalities and stopping environmental deterioration associated with current specialisation in production. As for the social plan, a way must be found to cut the Gordian knot created by the deep socio-economic inequalities by which large majorities in the region are bound. (Guimaraes and Bárcena, 2001).
Chapter 1: From Stockholm to Johannesburg: Environment and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean
Environment Outlook
29
References ● Acuña, G., 2000: Reformas macroeconó-
micas en América Latina y el Caribe: su impacto en los marcos regulatorios e institucionales ambientales de nueve estudios de caso, Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, Santiago, Chile.
● Ehrlich, P.R., 1968: The population bomb.
Ballantine, New York, US.
amenidades del medio ambiente. Estudios Públicos, Santiago, 45: 147-174. ● Baden, J. y R.L. Stroup, 1992: Escassez de
● Espinoza, G., V. Alzina, 2001: Revisión de
recursos naturais, empresariado e a política econômica da esperança, in Economía e meio ambiente: a reconciliação, Instituto Estudos Empresariais y Ortiz, Porto Alegre, Brazil, pp 159-188.
la evaluación de impacto ambiental en países de América Latina y el Caribe. Metodología, resultados y tendencies, IDBCED, Santiago, Chile. ● FIONGsMS (Foro Internacional de ONGs y
ambiental Latinoamericano y su aplicación. United Nations Environment Programme, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
Movimientos Sociales), 1993: Construyendo el futuro. Tratados alternativos de Rio 92. Pacto de Acción Ecológica de América Latina, Montevideo, Uruguay.
● CDMAALC (Comisión de Desarrollo y
● Gligo, N., 1990: Las cuentas del patrimonio
Medio Ambiente de América Latina y el Caribe), 1990: Nuestra propia agenda. Inter-America Development Bank and United Nations Development Programme, Washington, D.C., US.
natural y el desarrollo sustentable. Revista CEPAL Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, Santiago, Chile, 41: 123-137.
● Brañes, R., 2001: El desarrollo del derecho
ambiental en algunos países de América Latina. Contribuciones, CIEDLA, 1, 7-17.
● Escudero, G., 1998: La visión y misión de
la agricultura al año 2020: hacia un enfoque que valorice la agricultura y el medio rural, in Agricultura, medio ambiente y pobreza rural en América Latina, L.G. Reca, R.G. Echeverría, eds., IFPRI and IDB, Washington, D.C., US. pp 21-54,
● Anderson, T.L., 1992: El mercado y las
● Morán, A.E., 1996: Situación de la política
● Rosenthal, G., 1994: “América Latina y el
Caribe ante los problemas ambientales y del desarrollo”, in La diplomacia ambiental. México y la Conferencia de las Naciones Unidas sobre Medio Ambiente y Desarrollo, A. Glender and V. Lichtinger, eds. Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores, Fondo de Cultura Económica, Mexico, D.F., Mexico. ● Strong, M., 1994: Conferencia de las
Naciones Unidas sobre Medio Ambiente y Desarrollo, in La diplomacia ambiental. México y la Conferencia de las Naciones Unidas sobre Medio Ambiente y Desarrollo, A. Glender and V. Lichtinger, eds. Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores, Fondo de Cultura Económica, Mexico, D.F., Mexico. ● UNEP (United Nations Environment Pro-
● CEPAL (Comisión Económica para América
Latina y el Caribe), 1991: El desarrollo sustentable: transformación productiva, equidad y medio ambiente. Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, Santiago, Chile. ● CMMAD (Comisión Mundial del Medio
Ambiente y del Desarrollo), 1987: Nuestro futuro común, Alianza, Madrid, Spain. ● Commoner, B., 1971: The closing circle,
Bantan, New York, US.
● Gross, T., 1989: Fight for the forest. Chico
gramme), 2002: Caribbean Environmental Law Development and Application. Environmental Legislative and judicial developments in the English-Speaking Caribbean countries in the context of the compliance with Agenda 21 and the Rio Agreements, Barbados.
Mendes in his own words, Latin America Bureau, London, UK.
● UNEP/ROLAC (United Nations Environment
desarrollo sostenible en América Latina y el Caribe desde Río-92 y los nuevos imperativos de institucionalidad. Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, Santiago, Chile.
Programme, Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean) 2002: Latin America Initiative for Sustainable Development, First Special Meeting of the Forum of Ministers of the Environment of Latin America and the Caribbean, Johannesburg, South Africa, 31 of August.
● Herrera, A.O., 1975: El modelo mundial
● —, 1990: Plan of Action for the Environment
Bariloche. Fundación Bariloche, Bariloche, Argentina.
in Latin America and the Caribbean. 7th Ministerial Meeting (Port of Spain), UNEP, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
● Guimaraes, R. P., A. Bárcena, 2001: El
● DC (Development Committee), 1987: Envi-
● IUCN, UNEP, WWF (World Conservation
ronment, growth and development. Development Committee, World Bank, Washington, D.C., US, 14: 1-33.
Union, United Nations Environment Programme, World Wide Fund for Nature), 1991: Caring for the Earth. IUCN, UNEP and WWF, Gland, Switzerland.
● ECLAC (Economic Commission for Latin
America and the Caribbean), 1990: Changing production patterns with social equity: the prime task of Latin America and the Caribbean development in the 1990s, ECLAC, Santiago, Chile. ● ECLAC-UNEP (Economic Commission for
Latin America and the Caribbean – United Nations Environment Programme), 2001a: Rio de Janeiro Platform for Action on the Road to Johannesburg, Regional Preparatory Conference of Latin America and the Caribbean for the World Conference on Sustainable Development, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 23 and 24 October. ● —, 2001b: The Sustainability of Develop-
ment in Latin America and the Caribbean: Challenges and Opportunities, Regional Preparatory Conference of Latin America and the Caribbean for the World Conference on Sustainable Development, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 23 and 24 October.
● —, 1980: The World Conservation Strategy.
IUCN, UNEP and WWF, Gland, Switzerland.
● Urquidi, V., 1994: Economía y medio
ambiente, in La diplomacia ambiental. México y la Conferencia de las Naciones Unidas sobre Medio Ambiente y Desarrollo, A. Glender and V. Lichtinger, eds. Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores, Fondo de Cultura Económica, Mexico, D.F., Mexico. ● Ya Wananchi, 1991: Agenda Ya Wananchi.
● Leff, E., 1994: Ecología y capital. Racionali-
dad ambiental, democracia participativa y desarrollo sustentable. Siglo XXI, Mexico, D.F., Mexico. ● Meadows, D.H., D.L. Meadows, J. Randers,
W.W. Behrens III., 1972: Los límites del crecimiento. Fondo Cultura Económica, Mexico, D.F., Mexico. ● Montaño, J., 1994: Hacia la consolidación
de la Cumbre de Río, Las Naciones Unidas y el Desarrollo Sustentable en Glender, Alberto y Víctor Lichtinger. In La diplomacia ambiental. México y la Conferencia de las Naciones Unidas sobre Medio Ambiente y Desarrollo, Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores, Fondo de Cultura Económica, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
Conferencia Raíces del Futuro, Paris, France.
Chapter
1
•
Chapter:
2 State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
32
Latin America and the Caribbean
State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002 Introduction This chapter presents a retrospective view of how the environment in the region has evolved over the past three decades, in the interval between the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment, held in Stockholm (Sweden) in 1972, and the World Summit on Sustainable Development, held in Johannesburg (South Africa), in 2002. In the 30 years under review, the state of the environment in Latin America and the Caribbean has reflected the ideas and policies that have prevailed in the region since 1972. As we shall see in this and the following chapters, the environment has come to occupy an important, although still secondary, place on the regional political agenda. Significant state regulations are being established and expanded in this field, and unprecedented action is being taken by the private sector and civil society. However, it is also clear that economic development has been the primary objective , in many cases at the expense of the environment. This situation is a confirmation of the opinions expressed by many of the region’s governments in Stockholm in 1972. As pointed out in Chapter One, at that time the regional mindset was reactive, and placed the demands of development – understood basically as economic growth – above the need to protect the environmental foundation of this development.
·
Thirty years later, there is more awareness about how development involves the environment, but it has not been possible to put a stop to the deterioration of indispensable environmental goods and services. If in 1972 the Stockholm Conference was inaugurated with participants willing to identify and respect environmental limits to growth, today there is a different reality facing Latin America and the Caribbean: the economy has not shown steady growth, there is more poverty and less security, and environmental deterioration has worsened. This chapter highlights the growing exploitation of natural resources, particularly by deforestation, loss of biodiversity and degradation, and pollution of soils and water (both on land and in coastal and marine zones). The place of exports at the top of the agenda has been accompanied by a widening of the income gap in much of the region. This, together with a high rate of urbanisation, has intensified the trend towards adopting lifestyles and consumption patterns that have a high environmental and sanitary impact, and this is reflected in the urban pollution (water, air) indices and the new disease and mortality characteristics in the region. Enormous damages have been caused by the vulnerability of the natural and urban environment, and an increase in natural disasters in the countries in the region.
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
Socio-economic trends
A
lthough democracy has advanced in many countries in Latin America and the Caribbean, it is an unstable political process. The fluctuating or downward trend of economic indicators over the past 20 years shows not only in the lost decade of the 1980s, but also over the most recent five-year period over 19982002- the lost half-decade. In this context, poverty, social inequality and environmental deterioration continue to be the main obstacles in the way of the region’s sustainable development.
Economy In the period 1972-2002, regional economic growth rates — in terms of gross domestic product (GDP) — dropped from an annual average above 5.6 per cent in 1971-1980 to only 1.2 per cent in 1981-1990 (the socalled lost decade) and to 3.3 per cent in 1991-2000 (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). Since 1980, growth rates have been lower than the annual average of 5.5 per cent for the period from 1945-1980, and are well below the annual average of –six to seven per cent that ECLAC believes is necessary to overcome the region’s serious poverty problems (CEPAL, 2000a). In spite of the relative growth of GDP in the 1990s, in 2001-2002 growth rates were even lower than in the 1980s (0.3 and 0.5 per cent, respectively). Average regional GDP growth rate per capita in the period 19982002 was 0.3 per cent and in 2002 it was two per cent lower than in 1997, which explains the talk of a “lost half decade” (CEPAL, 2002a, 2002c).
33
this strategic natural resource. As a result, regional average growth rate plunged from 8.4 per cent in 1973 to 2.2 in 1983 (World Bank, 2001). During the 1990s, countries in the region introduced economic reforms based on being more open to foreign trade and on liberalising national financial markets and foreign capital flows. Private initiative also played a role in producing goods and services, and in providing public services and social benefits. There was a significant decrease in inflation and the public sector deficit was kept under control. However, the impoverishment of the previous decade (income per capita in the 1980s fell to an annual rate of almost one per cent) was only just reversed in the 1990s with an average increase of two per cent per year in the rate of income per capita (Rodrik, 2001). Foreign debt continues to be high and is a serious impediment to development. There was a 21-fold increase in the foreign debt balance between 1971 and 1999 from US$46,300 to US$982,000 million, representing 38 per cent of total world foreign debt (World Bank, 2001). Accumulated foreign debt had reached about US$726,000 million by the end of 2001 (CEPAL, 2001b), and servicing it cost more than 45 per cent of income earned from exports of goods and services (IMF, 2001). Several countries suffered from hyperinflation - Argentina and Brazil in particular - as governments sought to finance the deficit by printing money. In the 1990s, severe macroeconomic imbalances carried over from the previous decade caused crises in Mexico (1995) and Brazil (1998) (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001), and more recently in Argentina (2001-2002). Argentina alone has a foreign debt of US$147,900 million. This represents about 18 per cent of the region’s total debt. Some highly indebted poor countries, such as Bolivia and Guyana, recently obtained the classification needed to allow them to reduce their debt to sustainable levels (World Bank, 2001).
It is important to point out that poverty in the region has kept close pace with these GDP figures (see Social situation in this section). In effect, while poverty was reduced between 1960 and 1980, it again increased during the 1980s until reaching a level in 1990 very similar to that recorded 30 years earlier (UNEP, 2000; CEPAL, 2002a). And, while it then dropped once more, it seems to have stagnated after 1997, showing an upward trend recently (CEPAL, 2002a).
In general, economic growth in the 1990s was volatile and reflected a pattern of increased dependence on foreign financing. In the first half of the decade, net transfer of resources to the region brought a boom in economic activity but at a cost of accumulating macroeconomic imbalances reflected in the region’s greater vulnerability to being affected by foreign financial crises (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001).
Since the middle of the 1970s, debt, macroeconomic imbalances and unfavourable terms of trade have blocked GDP growth in most countries in the region, seriously restricting possibilities for social development. The rise in petroleum prices in the 1970s – although certainly promoting growth in crude oil exporting countries (Mexico, Trinidad and Tobago and Venezuela) – made matters worse in countries that have to import
Direct foreign investments showed a notable growth during the 1990s, to reach a total of US$77,300 million in 1999 (ECLAC, 2001b). This was largely associated with the boom in asset privatisations. The world recession has caused these flows to lessen, especially in recent years. Estimates show that half the foreign investments in the 1990s were destined for the purchase of already-existing assets, and did not create new produc-
Chapter
2
34
Latin America and the Caribbean
Human development trends over the past 30 years Life expectancy at birth (years) 140
75
Mortality in children under 5 years (per 1,000 live births)
120
70
100 65
Per 1,000 inhab.
Years 60
80
60 55 40
50
1965-70
1970-75
1975-80
1980-85
1985-90
1990-95
1995-00
20 1970
2000-05
Adult literacy rates (percentage)(1)
1980
1990
2000
Gross primary education rate (percentage)
(2)
150
80
140
130 70 120
%
%
110 60 100
90
50
80 1970
1980
1990
2000
1970
1975
1980
1985
1990
1995
1999
(2) Measures exceed 100 per cent when the actual enrollment includes pupulation older or younger than the age established officially for this education level.
(1) Population over 15 years.
Gross domestic product per capita (in 1995 US dollars) 4500
Percentage of households below the poverty line (1980, 1990, 2000)
4000
60 50
3500 40
Latin America (19 countries)
30
3000
20 10
2500
0 1980* 2000
1990**
* ECLAC, 1999.
Latin America and the Caribbean Caribbean Mesoamerica South America
1500
1000 1975
1980
1985
1990
1995
1999
Sources: ECLAC, 1999, 2002a; UNEP, 2002; UNCIEF, 2002; UNESCO, 2002; World Bank, 2001.
·
2000**
** ECLAC, 2002a.
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
tive capacities; furthermore, this process strengthened the strategic position of transnational companies (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). After a significant upturn in the period 1992-1995, the growth of regional exports suffered a progressive reduction until it became negative in 1998. The upswing in 2000 did not last, and exports fell back to negative rates in 2001 and 2002 (CEPAL, 2002b). The region’s share of world exports continues to be low, and is still under six per cent (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). The boom in manufacturing exports in countries like Mexico, Central America and several in the Caribbean has largely been associated with the proliferation of assembly activities (maquilas), with little integration into national economies. International trade recently began to reflect integration processes, including free trade agreements and customs unions. Exports from the Andean Community countries grew by 37 per cent during 2000, while their intra-regional exports increased by 29 per cent. Similarly, in MERCOSUR intra-regional trade increased by 21 per cent and, for member countries of the North American Free Trade Agreement, by 20 per cent (BID, 2000). More recently, trade within MERCOSUR has contracted due to the effects of the crises in Brazil (1999) and in Argentina (2001-2002). Nevertheless, on the initiative of the United States, negotiations continue on the Free Trade Area for the Americas (FTAA) programmed to enter into force in 2005.
Energy Key factors in long-term regional economic development are the supply and consumption patterns of energy. Latin America and the Caribbean have 11 per cent of world petroleum reserves, six per cent of natural gas, 1.6 per cent of coal, 22 per cent of hydropower potential and 14 per cent of installed geothermic capacity (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). However, a large part of this wealth is under-used, or used inefficiently. An example is that, while only 15 per cent of regional hydropower potential is used, energy consumption per unit of output has increased in recent years. The regional share of world petroleum reserves - the strategic energy input in most countries - doubled over the past 20 years; Mexico and Venezuela have 40 and 50 per cent, respectively, of the total. Regional natural gas reserves grew still more (3.5 times in the period), again in Venezuela and México (with 51 and 28 per cent, respectively); nevertheless, their share of the world total grew by just one per cent because of increased reserves in the Middle East and the former Soviet Union. Regional coal reserves are mainly in Brazil and Colombia, who have 80 per cent of the total.
With some exceptions (Mexico, for example) most exports continue to be of raw materials, especially petroleum and its derivatives, minerals and agricultural and forestry products. Towards the end of the 1990s, more than 40 per cent of regional exports were primary products or manufactured goods that required intensive use of natural resources (CEPAL, 2001b). Between 1980 and 1995, the volume of regional exports using polluting production processes tripled (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). As a result, and since these activities are unsustainable over the long term, there was an increase in vulnerability and external dependence (because of limited access to markets and raw materials UNEP, 2000). Demands by international consumers have made the industrial sector, move towards improving the environmental quality of production, although the process is slower in the small and medium-sized companies sector (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). In several countries national industry has declined in importance (for example in Peru, Argentina and Chile), and imports continue to grow faster than exports (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). In the services sector, the tourism industry’s growth places great pressure on the environment, particularly in the Caribbean, although increased ecotourism can help to cushion this impact (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001).
35
© R. Burgos
Chapter
2
36
Latin America and the Caribbean
Although the region has large energy supplies, consumption per capita (equal to 9.4 barrels of petroleum per year) is 20 per cent below the world average (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). In addition, while regional consumption has been constantly growing over the past 20 years, its share of world consumption (5.2 percent of the total) has not changed significantly. It is also notable that productive efficiency (measured in terms of energy consumption per unit of output) has stagnated or even deteriorated in these two decades (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). While industrialised countries’ energy intensity fell by 20 per cent between 1980 and 1999, at the end of that period Latin America and the Caribbean consumed seven per cent more energy with no increase in production. The failure to use better technologies, an obsolete industry, subsidised fuel prices (with respect to international market prices) and the automotive industry’s high and inefficient consumption are all explanations for regional energy intensity. The trend towards its increase– a consequence of industry repositioning towards productive processes and exports with high consumption of energy – has been notable in countries such as Brazil. This contrasts with the region’s considerable total supply of energy as a percentage of the gross domestic product, which is 40 per cent higher than that in industrialised countries (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). This reveals a serious problem of underutilisation of energy and is one of the sustainable development challenges facing the region.
Social situation It has been estimated that in 2003 the number of people living in poverty in Latin America and the Caribbean was 225 million or 43.9 per cent of the total population, and of these 100 million (19.4 per cent) lived in extreme poverty (CEPAL, 2003). There was a considerable reduction of poverty levels between 1960 and 1980 - from 51 to 40.5 per cent of the population (an estimated total of 135.9 million people). During the lost decade of the 1980s the percentage of poor people again increased until it reached the 1960 level of 48.3 per cent of the total population in 1990. While the percentage of poor people in 1960 and 1990 was similar, even more people, 200.2 million, were considered poor in 1990 then in 1960 (UNEP, 2000; CEPAL, 2002a, 2003). This figure fell to 43.5 per cent in 1997 and has remained constant since. The absolute number of poor has increased by close to 66% since 1980 (CEPAL, 2002a, 2003). Latin America and the Caribbean is the region with the world’s biggest income inequality (ECLAC, 2001a). In the global context, a notable feature is the large concentration of national income in the wealthiest 10 per cent of the population: in all cases, this sector received more than 30 per cent of total income (35 per cent in ·
most countries but reaching 45 per cent in Brazil). The poorest 40 per cent of the population does not receive more than 15 per cent of income. During the 1990s (in 13 of the 20 regional countries for which information is available), the wealthiest 10 per cent of the population had incomes more than 20 times greater than the poorest 10 per cent (UNDP, 2001). And in most countries the trend during the decade was towards greater rigidity – and even deterioration – in income distribution; of 17 countries studied by ECLAC, only two (Honduras and Uruguay) showed a substantial improvement (CEPAL, 2001a). This rigidity or deterioration remained in spite of a relative recovery in economic growth (up to 1997) and social spending. Poverty mainly affects rural areas but, in absolute terms, most of the poor live in urban areas where almost half are children and young people. In the affected population, there has been no evidence of the growth of a middle class or any emergence from poverty (CEPAL, 2000b). In 1999, the unemployment rate reached 8.8 per cent, the highest during the decade, and similar to the rate during the period’s most severe crisis (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). The slow reduction of poverty continues to be associated with a lack of economic growth and, in particular, with its limited effect on the labour market and flagging labour productivity. Between 1990 and 1997, 69 per cent of new jobs created, were in the informal sector, which accounted for 47 per cent of urban employment (CEPAL, 2000a). With the exception of Chile and Panama, the number of people employed in the informal sector grew while unemployment increased. In the 1990s, seven of each 10 jobs were in the informal sector - seldom permanent, unregulated and with no social security benefits (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). Women’s participation in the labour market is an important trend. In 1980, women accounted for slightly more than a quarter of the labour force in Central America and South America. By 1999, they represented a third of the labour force in Central America and almost two-fifths in South America. In the Caribbean, where women’s participation had been higher, it had reached 43 per cent in 1997 (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). This trend has been more pronounced than in any other region in the world. In general, there are more educated women in the labour force, although low family incomes have meant that more of the less educated women, girls and children are also working. The number of households headed by women has been growing until, according to the country, it has reached between a quarter and a third of the total. This puts more pressure on women to enter the labour market (CEPAL, 2001a). Estimates of work loads, income and unemployment rates reveal that women suffer great inequalities; furthermore, in some countries households headed by women tend to be the poorest (CEPAL, 2001a; UNDP, 2001).
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
There have been important improvements in education during the past two decades. Adult literacy rates are relatively high, with an average of 88 per cent in 1999 (UNDP, 2001) compared to 77 per cent in 1980 (UNESCO, 2000). However, inequality in income distribution is also reflected in differences in access to schooling, attendance and results (UIS, 2001). Coverage of basic services such as drinking water and sanitation has improved during the past 30 years. In 1960, only 33 per cent of the regional population had drinking water, and 14 per cent drainage. These figures are now 85 and 79 per cent respectively (PAHO, 2001). Violence, including homicide, has increased in the region. Family violence, particularly against women and children, has grown. It is estimated that half the women in Latin America experience at least one episode of family violence. (CEPAL, 2000b). In recent years, the trend towards finding peaceful solutions to conflict, whether internal (Central America, Mexico) or external (Ecuador, Peru) has continued, and this has encouraged the gradual advance of democracy. In Colombia, however, negotiations have failed to solve an internal conflict that has lasted for more than 40 years. Violence associated with drug trafficking continues to be a serious problem in many countries in the region. A solution is essential to ensure stability and sustainable development.
Demography The population grew by 85 per cent between 1970 and 2001 from 285 million to about 528 million (CELADE, 2002). However, the annual growth rate fell from 2.5 per cent to 1.5 per cent (CELADE, 2000), and if the current downward trend carries on, it could fall to one per cent in 2025 (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). Fertility rates were halved from 5.3 children per woman in 1970 to 2.6 children per woman in 2000 (CELADE, 2002). Other contributing factors include higher levels of urbanisation and income and, in some cases, government birth control programmes. Estimated population growth rates for 2001-2002 are highest in Mesoamerica (around 1.7 per cent) and lowest in the Caribbean (around one per cent). The rate in South America is 1.4 per cent (CELADE, 2002). There has been sustained growth in urbanisation over the past 30 years, and in 2000 the urban population reached 73.7 of the regional total (CELADE, 2000). Migration to urban areas has continued. More of the urban population have access to electricity, drinking water and sanitary services.
variations between countries, and even within countries, largely explained by per capita income differences (PAHO, 1998). The highest life expectancy is in the Caribbean (74 years), followed by South America (73.5 years). However, life expectancy at birth is 20 years more in Cuba and Puerto Rico than in Haiti, while it is 10 years more in Venezuela and Colombia than in Bolivia. With the exception of Haiti, all countries in the region reached the objective of a life expectancy of more than 60 years, projected for the region in 1977 as part of the Global Strategy for Health for All by the Year 2000 (PAHO, 1998). More efficient health systems contributed greatly to this improvement by reducing the infant mortality index from 86per thousand births in 1970 to 37.8 in 1995 (CELADE, 2002). Most countries are in an intermediate demographic transition phase; sub-national variations are due to social and territorial inequalities. A third of the population is under 15 years of age and rural zones have the highest levels of fertility and mortality. Ageing of the population is becoming evident in countries like Argentina, Chile and Uruguay where adults over 60 years of age already account for more than 10 per cent of the total population (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). A result of the temporary reduction of the dependent population (those under 15 years of age who usually do not yet earn their living and those older than 65 who are no longer wage-earners), is a phenomenon known as the demographic bonus. In the next two decades, in most countries in Latin America and the Caribbean it would be very useful to the transition to sustainable development if the economically-active populations improved their living standards by being able to save, spend or invest (ECLAC and UNEP, 2001). One response of the population to frequent economic crises is to migrate to developed countries. More than 17 million people in Latin America and the Caribbean live outside their country of birth, and half migrated during the 1990s. While the United States con-
Population in Latin America and the Caribbean per sub-region, 1970-2000 (in millions) 600 500 400 300
South America
200 100 0
Mesoamerica Caribbean
19 70 19 72 19 74 19 76 19 78 19 80 19 82 19 84 19 86 19 88 19 90 19 92 19 94 19 96 19 98 20 00
In a large part of the region, the greatest drop in the mortality rate was recorded in the middle of the 20th century. Life expectancy rose from 65.8 to 72.5 years between 1970 and 2000 but there are considerable
37
Source: UNEP, 2002.
Chapter
2
38
Latin America and the Caribbean
tinues to be the principal destination, migrations to Europe are increasing.. According to conservative estimates, the flow of remittances to the region increased from US$5,200 million in 1990 to US$18,000 million in 2000. In some of the smallest economies, these funds have come to represent more than 40 per cent of export income, for example in El Salvador (52 per cent) and Jamaica (42 per cent - ECLAC and UNEP, 2001).
Governance
Science and technology Traditional information and communications technology continues to expand; the number of newspapers, radios, telephone lines and television sets has increased significantly over the past two decades. In addition, the use of personal computers, the Internet and cellular telephones has started to become common. However, there are still marked inequalities between countries, and a notable lag in relation to more developed regions. For example, although in Latin America use of the Internet has been increasing by more than 30 per cent per year, in 2005 only 12 per cent of the population will have access to it. Low household income is one limiting factor to the use of these technologies (UNDP, 2001).
Expansion of communications media in Latin America and the Caribbean (per 1,000 inhabitants) Daily newspapers Radios Telephone lines Televisions Personal computers Internet users Cellular telephones
1980 76.2 260.5 40.6 99.0 No data 0.0 0.0
1999 70.7 418.8 130.1 271.8 37.7 18.9 14.8
Source: Prepared by the Development Observatory (University of Costa Rica), from World Bank data, 2001; CELADE, 2002.
With 8.6 per cent of the world’s population, the region has only 2.7 per cent of its scientists who, in 1988, produced 2.5 per cent of publications in this field (Massarani, 2001). There is still very little investment in scientific research: in 1999, it was about US$10,000 million or 1.9 per cent of the total global figure
·
(Massarani, 2001). Brazil invests about one per cent of its GDP in research and development (compared with the regional average of 0.53 per cent), and Mexico is in 11th place among the world’s principal exporters of high-technology products (UNDP, 2001). However, improvements in access to information and communications have reduced research costs, especially via the internet (Massarani, 2001).
The trend towards the decentralisation of authority is worldwide. Concern is growing about rights and opportunities, particularly in the field of human and women’s rights. The private sector reflects this trend with more horizontal corporative structures and decentralised decision-making processes. Some institutions have no formal command structures, for example the internet and NGO networks. In the public sector, the establishment of new democratic governments is evident, as is the empowerment of smaller and local government institutions, and the emergence of civil society as an important voice. During the past 20 years, two important political events have taken place in the region. The first is the change from military dictatorships to governments elected by popular vote, and all the countries now have popularly-elected governments. In recent years local governments and legal systems have strengthened, and the democratisation process has advanced. The second important achievement has to do with civil society participation and the creation of institutions such as NGOs. In 13 of 17 countries, 50 per cent or more of the population prefers democracy to any other form of government (Latinbarómetro, 2000). Increased citizen participation increased interest in aspects such as the environment, sustainable development and state reform, although some of these subjects have still not been included in decision-making policy processes. It is important to stress that the deterioration in the socio-economic situation of the region destabilizes government systems now in place and has recently given rise to serious political crises (most dramatically in Argentina, Bolivia and Ecuador). The configuration of stable and socially fair economic development is essential to sustainability in Latin America and the Caribbean.
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
39
References ● BID (Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo),
2000: Informe Anual 2000, BID, Washington, D.C., Estados Unidos. ● BID (Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo),
2000: Informe Annual 2000, BID, Wasington, D.C., Estados Unidos. ● CELADE (Centro Latinoamericano y Cari-
● —, 1999: Panorama social de América
Latina 1998, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile. ● ECLAC, UNEP (Economic Commission for
● —, 2000: GEO Latin America and the Car-
Latin America and the Caribbean, United Nations Environment Programme), 2001: The Sustainability of Development in Latin America and the Caribbean: Challenges and Opportunities, Regional Preparatory Conference of Latin America and the Caribbean for the World Conference on Sustainable Development, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 23 and 24 October.
ibbean: Environment Outlook 2000. UNEP Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
beño de Demografía), 2002: América Latina y Caribe: Estimaciones y proyecciones de población, 1950-2050, Boletín Demográfico (Santiago, Chile), No. 69 (in http:// www.eclac.cl, consulted on 1 February 2002).
● IMF (International Monetary Fund), 2001:
● —, 2000: “América Latina: Proyecciones de
World Economic Outlook, IMF, Washington, D.C., US.
población urbano-rural, 1950-2025”, Boletín Demográfico (Santiago, Chile), No. 63 (in http://www.eclac.cl, consulted on 1 July 2002).
Latina y el Caribe), 2003: Panorama social de América Latina 2002-2003, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile.
ta 1999, Latinbarómetro, Santiago, Chile.
short in science spending, Scidev, Londres, UK (in http://www.scidev.net, consulted on 7 January 2003).
● —, 2002b: Situación y perspectivas. Estudio
2001: Regional Report on the Evaluation in the Region of the Americas: Water Supply and Sanitation, Current Status and Prospects, PAHO, Washington, D.C., US.
económico de América Latina y el Caribe 2001-2002, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile.
● PAHO, 1998: Health in the Americas,
Latina 2001-2002, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile.
PAHO, Washington, D.C., US. ● —, 2002c: Balance preliminar de las
economías de América Latina y el Caribe 2002, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile. ● —, 2001a: Panorama Social de América
● Rodrik, D., 2001: “¿Por qué hay tanta inse-
guridad económica en América Latina?”, in Revista de la CEPAL, No. 73, April, Santiago, Chile, pp. 7-31.
Latina 2000-2001, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile. ● UNDP (United Nations Development Pro-
nomía latinoamericana, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile.
gramme), 2001: Human Development Report 2001, Mundi-Prensa, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
● —, 2000a: Equidad, desarrollo y ciudada-
● UNEP (United Nations Environment Pro-
● —, 2001b: Balance preliminar de la eco-
nía, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile. ● —, 2000b: Panorama Social de América
Latina 1999-2000, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile.
Latin America and the Caribbean: Regional Report, UNESCO Institute for Statistics, Société Editions, Provence, France.
entific and Cultural Organisation), 2002: UNESCOSTAT, UNESCO, Paris, France (in http://www.uis.unesco.org/en/stats/stats0. htm, consulted on 1 August 2002).
● Latinbarómetro, 2000: Informe de la encues-
● PAHO (Pan-American Health Organization), ● —, 2002a: Panorama social de América
● UIS (UNESCO Institute for Statistics), 2001:
● UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Sci-
● Massarani, L., 2001: Latin America falls ● CEPAL (Comisión Economica para America
grated Data (EWA-GRID), Geneva, Switzerland.
gramme), 2002: Global Environment Outlook 3 Data Compendium, UNEP/DEWA/ RS.02-5, UNEP Division of Early Warning and Assessment, Global and Regional Inte-
● —, 2000: UNESCOSTAT, UNESCO, Paris,
France (in http://unescostat.Unesco.org/indicator/indframe.htm, consulted on 1 August 2002). ● UNICEF (United Nations Children’s Fund),
2002: Statistics. Child mortality, UNICEF, New York, US (in http://www.childinfo.org/ cmr2.html, consulted on 1 August 2002). ● World Bank, 2001: World Development In-
dicators 2001, World Bank, Washington, D.C., US.
Chapter
2
40
Latin America and the Caribbean
verse: from slash-and-burn clearing with long fallow periods, to irrigated areas of intensive agriculture. Plantations of coffee, sugar cane, soybean, palm and banana use high levels of mechanisation and agrochemicals.
Land
T
he Latin America and Caribbean region has the world’s largest reserves of arable land with an es timated 576 million hectares (ha) equal to almost 30 per cent of the total territory of 1,995 million ha (Gómez and Gallopín, 1995). In 1998 grassland covered almost 80 per cent of the region’s potential agricultural land; of the 20 per cent cultivated, very little is used for permanent crops (WRI, 2001). The region also contains 16 per cent of the world total of 1,900 million ha of degraded land, after Asia and Africa. The impact is relatively greater in Mesoamerica (where it reaches 26 per cent of the total: 63 million ha), than in South America (where it affects 14 per cent of the total: almost 250 million ha) (UNEP, 2000). Agriculture is a key to the evolution of Latin America and Caribbean societies. A large number of domesticated plants such as maize, tomato, cocoa and potatoes, of enormous importance to production, trade and consumption throughout the world, are native to the region. Regional agricultural ecosystems, a prime source of the population’s food, forage and fibre, are very di-
The growth of agriculture has, in general, intensified the use of natural resources and, as a result, exacerbated many of the land degradation processes in the region where, for example, there is constant threat of desertification. The past three decades have seen an increase in arable land and grassland at the expense of forests and wetlands, as well as an increase in the irrigated area and the use of agrochemicals. Negative effects include the emission of greenhouse gases, and damage to human health. All is not lost. The success of some land recovery experiments indicates that corrective action is possible.
Agricultural production During the 1990s, profits from the region’s agricultural exports doubled at an average rate of 6.4 per cent annually (from 3.3 per cent annually over the previous decade). This growth was achieved in spite of adverse climate conditions, political instability in some countries and general financial crises during the 1990s. As the decade drew to a close, growth became more
Environmental restrictions on agricultural land use Land is the primary substratum for vegetal and animal life on Earth, as well as an indispensable resource for essential human activities: agriculture, forestry production, water collection, settlements and recreation. However, the use of land to satisfy human needs is limited by environmental factors such as climate, topography and soil characteristics, as well as by very diverse social and cultural factors: population density, land tenure, markets and agricultural policies. The expansion for agriculture of land with severe environmental limitations in Latin America and the Caribbean is shown in the following table. Sub-region
Total expansion
6
(10 ha) Caribbean 23.4 Mesoamerica 248.4 South America 1,777.6 2,049.4 Latin America and the Caribbean Developing countries 8,171.5 Developed countries 5,228.0 World total 13,399.5
Land with severe agricultural restrictions Total with Very Very With very restrictions cold dry steep inclinations 6 (10 ha) (%) (%) (%) (%) 15.7 67 0 0 15.8 184.8 74.4 0 31.5 26.3 1,251.8 70.4 0.5 10.6 7.5 1,452.3 70.9 0.4 13.0 9.9 6,235.5 76.3 2.7 34.4 12.8 4,231.8 80.9 29.6 15.8 10.2 10,467.3 78.1 13.2 27.1 11.8
Source: FAO, 2002b.
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
With poor soils (%) 65.8 59.7 63.6 63.2 60.9 70.7 64.7
Environment Outlook
41
Chapter
2
© R. Burgos
marked in large countries like Colombia, Brazil and Argentina. In countries with less agricultural production, the trend slowed, even though strong support was given to exports during the period, as in Costa Rica and Chile (CEPAL, IICA, 2001). During the 1990s great changes took place in the structure and dynamics of regional agricultural production. Although there were increases in some traditional crops, the greatest growth was in livestock. By 1999, there was a 4.6 per cent growth in agricultural production, up from only 1.8 per cent in 1998, a year in which El Niño had a considerable effect on agriculture. The main contribution to the good results in 1999 was the strong 5.1 per cent growth in production in South America; in Brazil, there was a notable increase of an estimated seven per cent. In that same year growth was more modest in Mesoamerica, although the rate of 3.4 per cent was a considerable improvement over the 1.1 per cent recorded in 1998. However, agricultural production contracted during most of the 1990s and in 1999 fell by 1.1 per cent in the Caribbean (FAO, 2001a). In 1999, livestock production grew by 5.8 per cent, following a growth rate of 1.5 per cent in 1998. Cereal production, after dropping by 2.7 per cent in 1998, increased by almost 4.6 per cent in 1999. On the other hand, transgenetic crops - principally maize, soybean and cotton - showed a great expansion worldwide throughout the 1990s, covering a total of 45 million ha in 1996. Argentina has the third largest extension of these crops, after the United States and Canada (CEPAL, IICA, 2001).
Finally, between 1980 and 1999, the economicallyactive population in the agricultural sector fell from 35 per cent to only 21 per cent of the region’s total labour force. This substantial change was a result of a productive reconversion of agriculture, which meant that more labour became available for non-agricultural rural activities and there was a significant growth in migration from rural to urban areas (CEPAL, IICA, 2001; see the section on Urban Areas).
Land tenure Land tenure is an essential element in defining how biological diversity management functions. Experience worldwide has shown that inequitable land distribution and the lack of a clear legal definition of land rights can lead to irrational use of land and even the destruction of land resources. The basic problems of land tenure in Latin America and the Caribbean are the concentration of property and the lack of titles to the land. Both problems have their historic origins in the colonial system of land grants,which produced an agrarian property structure dominated by large properties (latifundios), and very small properties (minifundios). In spite of the many agrarian reforms introduced in the region, there have been no great changes in land tenure, with a growing concentration of agricultural properties (van Dam, 1999). This process was stimulated by population increases and by modernising agriculture with technologies that favour large agricultural extensions and increase the
42
Latin America and the Caribbean
number of landless farm workers (van Dam, 1999). This inequality of land distribution has significant consequences regarding access to fertile soils, irrigation and technology. At present, 38 per cent of the region’s rural population are smallholders and 31 per cent are landless farm workers (Jazairy and others, 1992). In Brazil, for example, 1.3 million smallholders own 2.6 per cent of permanent cropland, with an average holding of 1.5 ha. Although the landless movement in Brazil has gained some ground in recent years, this is one of the region’s highest averages. In Panama, 71.5 per cent of farm properties are smallholdings, which occupy 4.2 per cent of agricultural land. In Mexico, the average size of agricultural smallholdings is 1.4 ha (van Dam, 1999). From the environmental point of view, both the large agricultural properties and the smallholdings have adverse effects. On large properties, extensive livestock grazing or the use of mechanised crops causes land to become eroded and compacted, and it suffers from salinisation (inadequate irrigation) and chemical pollution. Smallholdings tend to increase deforestation, erosion and loss of soil fertility because of intensive use
with insufficient fallow periods (Jazairy and others, 1992). The environmental effects of the large property/ smallholding combination are particularly dramatic in Central America where smallholdings and crops lie on highly vulnerable hillsides, while extensive livestock farming and export crops are concentrated on lowlands. In this sub-region, more than 80 per cent of basic grains are planted on hillsides. This happens most in Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras, where farm production is based on plots of less than five ha with very low technology. In addition, it is estimated that three-quarters of the total area of annual crops, and two-thirds of the total area of permanent crops, are planted on hillsides (López Pereira and others, 1995).
Expansion of agriculture and livestock farming The expansion of agricultural production led to the conversion of what used to be forest land; it also led to further exploitation of natural resources, particularly land
Land use and soil conditions: the case of Jamaica As in the rest of Latin America and the Caribbean, the land tenure regime in Jamaica is inequitable and few land conservation and recovery methods are used either on large properties or on smallholdings. In the 1970s, land reform favoured large properties in the form of cooperatives based on mechanisation, increased irrigation (on 12 per cent of arable land in 1983), intensified use of crops and monoculture. Environmental effects have been typical of large properties with intensive agriculture: land erosion and soil compacting from mechanisation, salinisation caused by deficient irrigation systems and chemical pollution although, unlike the rest of the region, Jamaica did not show any marked increase in the use of the agrochemicals that are a feature of this agricultural model. However, in these types of properties often only less than one-sixth of the land is cultivated so that absolute returns are low, however high the level of intensification in the part that is cultivated. In the 1980s one quarter of Jamaican territory was under cultivation and more than 90 per cent of farms covered 4 ha or less. These smallholdings were concentrated in ecologically fragile mountain areas of low fertility and were only suitable for forest protection of water sources. They used traditional agricultural methods including slash-and-burn cultivation and organic fertilisers, especially cattle manure. The farms had no physical infrastructure or basic services, farmers had little or no access to suitable technology for their ecosystems, little or no credit and very little schooling. In general, the expansion of large agricultural properties and the marginalisation of peasant farmers have meant that the land now has fewer fallow periods and there is less crop rotation. Other environmental effects of this agricultural model are deforestation of mountainsides and a reduction in the number of draught animals, since agricultural expansion often takes place at the expense of pastureland. In zones with smallholdings, land degradation tends to increase, especially the loss of fertility from erosion, which is reflected in a marked drop in production. Intensive use without fallow periods and the lack of crop rotation and adequate technologies are also reflected in floods and in a sharpening of the effects of drought in both the region itself and lowland and even in coastal ecosystems, especially in the small Caribbean islands. Comparative studies indicate that the effects of land ownership detailed here for Jamaica are common throughout Latin America and the Caribbean. Sources: van Dam, 1999 and Library of Congress, 2000.
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
and water, worsening the land degradation process. Between 1970 and 2000, the area of agricultural land (including grassland) expanded in Latin America and the Caribbean to five per cent of the total land area, reaching 37.7 per cent at the end of the period (FAO, 2002a). The largest increases were in the Caribbean and South America (16.1 and 15.8 per cent, respectively), although in the past decade less land has been devoted to agriculture in the Caribbean. It is important to note that most agricultural land in the region is grazing land; 79.2 per cent of the total agricultural land in 2000. This proportion decreased by 3.9 per cent between 1970 and 2000 (with a pronounced fall of 21.2 per cent in the Caribbean); this indicates the continued inefficient use of land, both in terms of regional food security and the environmental impact of livestock on land and water.
Agricultural land as a proportion proportion of total land area in the region 70 60 50 40 % 30 20 10 0 1970
1980
1990
2000
Year
Latin America and the Caribbean
Mesoamerica
Caribbean
South America
Source: FAO, 2002a.
bour force. This is the case of the Legal Amazonia in Brazil and of livestock companies in Bolivia that rented land to peasant farmers to be cleaned and cultivated, and then got it back deforested when their leases expired (UNEP, 2002). This change in land use had another significant impact, this time on a global scale. It increased the emission of three gases which play an important role in the global warming process (FAO, 2001b; IFA and FAO, 2001; see section on Atmosphere): carbon dioxide (a consequence of deforestation), methane (basically from using the land for livestock) and nitrogen oxides (from the use of fertilisers on crops and grasslands).
Land degradation © R. Burgos
The expansion of livestock farming in many areas, such as the Amazon, to meet national and international market demands has lessened the productive capacity of the land. In Nicaragua, the load capacity of pastureland has been reduced by between 50 and 85 per cent, from 1.0 to 0.15 and 0.5 animal units per hectare (Pratt and Jones, 1999). Breeding has also fallen by between 50 and 80 per cent, due to nutritional deficiencies in pastureland. Regional livestock expansion could not have been successful without strong support from governments through tax incentives, credit policies, the construction of roads and the availability of a trained and cheap la-
43
Land degradation, one of the most serious environmental problems in the region, originated in processes such as erosion and acidification, the loss of organic material, soil compacting, the loss of nutritive elements, chemical pollution and salinisation. As a consequence, it is estimated that more than three million square kilometres of agricultural land in Latin America and the Caribbean have suffered a significant loss of productivity. In the region, erosion is the main cause of land degradation, as well as subsequent losses of nutrients and productivity that affect 14 per cent of the territory in South America and 26 per cent in Mesoamerica (Oldeman, 1994). The Global Assessment of Soil Degradation (GLASOD) indicates that 74 per cent of Central American agricultural land was degraded in 1990
Chapter
2
44
Latin America and the Caribbean
Land use change and greenhouse gas emissions An important consequence of increasing cropland by eliminating forests is the emission of greenhouse gases, an effect aggravated when, after deforestation, the land is used for methane-emitting livestock raising. In 1994 carbon dioxide emissions caused by change in land use and forestry in the region accounted for approximately 28 per cent of the emissions from the energy and industrial sectors. In the Caribbean, on the contrary, the gases captured in reforestation and forestry plantations account for 55 per cent of the emissions generated by the other two sectors. Altogether, the region emits 48.3 per cent of the global total of carbon dioxide resulting from change in land use, principally through deforestation, and 9.3 per cent of the methane from anthropogenic sources, especially livestock. Concerning methane, while 30.0 per cent of world emissions come from livestock, the figure rises to 71.4 per cent in South America and is 48.0 per cent in Mexico (see the section on Atmosphere). Carbon dioxide emissions in Latin America and the Caribbean (in equivalent carbon tonnes), 1990-1996 * Region Latin America and the Caribbean (30) Caribbean (12) Mesoamerica (7) South America (11)
Energy 798,262 45,473 318,720 434,069
Industrial Processes 49,498 6,443 14,356 28,699
Land use change and forestry 241,034 -28,355 111,418 157,971
* The year 1994 is taken as a reference, with the following exceptions (due to data availability): 1990 for Antigua and Barbuda, Trinidad and Tobago, Guatemala, Mexico, Ecuador and Venezuela; 1995 for Honduras and 1996 for Costa Rica.
Source: Prepared by the Development Observatory of the University of Costa Rica, based on UNFCCC, 2002, COPPE, 2002, and Perdomo and others, 1995.
(Oldeman and others, 1991). The countries most endangered by land deterioration are the smallest, such as many Caribbean islands (for example, Haiti), and Central American countries such as El Salvador. Also particularly vulnerable are countries such as Nicaragua, Guatemala, Bolivia and Paraguay, whose economies depend mostly on agriculture. Many of these processes vary in intensity according to location, inclination (land with a slope of more than eight per cent) or the use of irrigation and agrochemicals. The limitations imposed by the degree of fertility and inclination are also reflected in production levels. Soil fertility comes from an interaction among multiple factors: organic matter content, availability of nutrients (particularly nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium), water retention capacity, acidity, salinity and physical characteristics like soil structure and texture. The Latin America and Caribbean region has quality limitation parameters comparable to the world average (Wood and others, 2000). Only 12.4 per cent of its agricultural land has no fertility limitations (compared to a world average of 16.2 per cent).
·
However, some factors have alarmingly high levels, duplicating global averages: almost 40 per cent of land in the region has low potassium reserves and just under one-third, especially in the tropical zone, has aluminium toxicity. A reduction in cereal yields per hectare has been detected in some critical places (in rice, maize, wheat or sorghum), indicating nutrient deficiencies. Fertility is being lost in zones like the northeast of Brazil, the north of Argentina and some areas in Paraguay, Bolivia, Colombia and Mexico (WRI, 2000). It is true that yields are growing or remain stable in parts of Uruguay, Venezuela, Ecuador and Nicaragua. However, the growth in yields should not always be interpreted as a positive sign; it may be the result of unsustainable agricultural practices, based on intensive agrochemical use. Salinisation does particularly serious damage to the soil, because it is hard to treat and can lead to desertification. Salinisation from irrigation is particularly notable in Cuba (1.0 million ha), Argentina (0.6 million), Mexico (0.4 million) and Peru (0.3 million) and, more specifically, in arid regions in the Brazilian north-
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
east, the centre of Chile and some areas in Central America (UNESCO and others, 1978; FAO, 2000).
Agrochemical pollution
Land degradation has increased poverty in the region and this, in turn, has been the cause of greater environmental deterioration, particularly of soils; a cyclical phenomenon that has been observed especially in silviculture and agriculture (both peripheral and marginal activities). Economic losses resulting from this cycle may be high; for example, the losses from soil erosion in different regions of Mexico vary from three to 13 per cent of the agricultural gross domestic product (WRI, 2000).
Chemical soil pollution is another growing environmental problem of in Latin America and the Caribbean, a result of the intensification of agriculture and the use of pesticides over the past 30 years. Agricultural technology has increased production throughout the region, but environmental costs have been high. In particular, the loss and exhaustion of nutrients in the region may be an important cause of the increase in the use of fertilisers, which grew from 2.9 to 13.2 million tonnes between 1970 and 2000 (FAO, 2002c).
45
Chapter
2
Loss of soil nutrients Gradual intensification of agricultural production in the region has been the most important factor of soil nutrient exhaustion which, in South America, has affected 68.2 million ha (43.7 million to a moderate or severe degree). Organic material stored in the soil is an important indicator of the health of the agricultural ecosystem. It has been 2 estimated that the 6.2 million km of agricultural land in Latin America and the Caribbean contain some 59,000 million tonnes of carbon in the top metre of soil, equal to 15 per cent of the world total of agricultural land carbon. However, the average density of carbon in the region's soil is 95 tonnes per hectare, a value somewhat below the global average of 102 tonnes. The annual loss of nutrients for the period 1983-1985 was more accentuated in the Caribbean, with 67 kg of nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium lost per hectare annually, followed by South America with 65 kg. Ten years later these levels had improved, so that for the period 1993-1995 the Latin American average was 54 kg per hectare annually, compared to 59 kg in 1983-1985. Only Soil Fertility Hot Spots and Bright Spots (b) Trends in profits (c) Potentially critic Mesoamerica worse- (a) Balance of cereal resulting from cereals nutrients and positive areas ned between these two referenced periods, from 39 to 43 kg of nutrients lost per hectare annually, although the sub-region continued to be better off compared with the regional average.
Loss or increase of nutrients (kilogram of nitrogen, phosphate and potassium per hectare). < -100 -100 - -25 -25 - 0 =0 Not applicable
Decrease Stable Increase No data available
Potentially positive areas Some negative trends Potentially critical areas Not applicable
Note: Balances of cereal nutrients are obtained from calculating the difference between the application of mineral and organic fertilisers and recycled crop garbage (inputs) and the nutrients resulting from the cereal grains (products). The balances of nutrients were applied to specific geographic zones using subnational statistics for the period 1993-1995 and information on climate, soils and height. Trends in profits obtained from cereals are based in subnational data for the period 1993-1995 for rice, wheat, corn and sorghum. The map of potential hot spots and bright spots combines the maps of balances of nutrients and the trends in the profits from cereals.
Source: Wood and others, 2000.
46
Latin America and the Caribbean
Fertilizer consumption in Latin America When compared to global consumption, Latin America is an important consumer of fertilisers, representing 9 per cent of the world total and with an annual growth rate of 4 per cent. Although regional fertiliser consumption is cyclical, total consumption in 2000 was more than four times greater than in 1970. Brazil, the largest country in the region, accounts for about 50 per cent of regional consumption, Mexico 15 per cent and Argentina 8 per cent.
Fertilizer consumption in Latin America (million tonnes nutrients) N (Nitrogen)
P205 (Phosphate)
K20 (Potssium)
12 10 8 6 4
2 Brazilian consumption increased by 48 per cent between 1991 and 1994, when terms 0 70/71 80/81 90/91 2000/01 of trade were favourable for fertilisers and agricultural products. In 1995, credit problems caused a reduction of 9 per cent in consumption although, when the situation improved for Brazilian producers, total consumption of nutrients again increased, this time by 35 per cent. The cycle continued: in 1999 consumption decreased by 7 per cent, due to economic problems and low prices for agricultural products, with imports of fertilisers also falling by 6 per cent in that year. Between 1995 and 1998 there was a large increase in production of beans and soybeans, with nitrogen consumption rising by 0.3 million tonnes, while phosphate and potassium salts increased by 1.2 million tonnes.
Mexico is closely associated with the United States to which it sends close to 80 per cent of its exports, and it is affected by its neighbour's economic cycles. In 1999 drought in the north of Mexico had an effect on the consumption of fertilisers for wheat and maise. Finally, the shortage of urea that year was compensated by more ammonia imports.
Source: IFA, 2001, 2002a, 2002b.
The impact of agrochemical pollution on soil and water and, therefore, on human health, is of prime concern. One of the main impacts of the use of agrochemicals is the growing nitrification of the land and problems caused from eutrophication (in surface waters) and the appearance of red tides in coastal zones. There are also the effects of the emission of nitrogen greenhouse gases.
1990s. Consumption increased from 132,736 tonnes in 1980 to 446,400 tonnes in 1998, while imports grew from 5,577 tonnes in 1984 to 15,350 tonnes in 1997 (OdD-UCR and UNEP, 2001; UCH and others, 2000). In Peru the use of fertilisers in 1998 reached 520,411 tonnes, with an increase of 19 per cent over the previous year. However, in 1999 it fell by two per cent (CONAM, PNUMA, 2001).
Land pollution by agrochemicals does not happen only because of their excessive or inadequate use, but also when they are used according to the manufacturers’ technical recommendations. The environmental impact of agrochemicals is particularly notable in the case of fertilisers which cause massive global nitrification of land and water (UNEP, 2000; IFA, 2001). Serious pollution has also occurred as a result of the sterilisation of banana plantations; from the use of nematocide copper in Mesoamerican countries such as Costa Rica. This has also affected people and coral reefs (van Arsdale, 1991).
Desertification
Total consumption of fertilisers and agrochemical imports tripled in Chile between the 1980s and the
·
The United Nations Organisation defines desertification as the degradation of land in arid, semiarid and dry subarid zones, caused by such factors as human activities and climate variations. These ecosystems cover more than a third of the world’s land surface and are highly sensitive to inappropriate land use, especially to overexploitation. The land may lose productivity because of improper irrigation, deforestation, excessive grazing, poverty and political instability. This can result in a food crisis and even famine and desertification, and is therefore considered a global problem. Some crises begin in areas that suffer from
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
47
Chapter
2 © R. Burgos
land degradation and drought, and the situation becomes worse when food is in short supply or is not properly distributed.
pay for itself in only seven years (PNUMA/ORPALC, 2002).
Desert or arid areas cover a quarter of the territory in Latin America and the Caribbean (some 5.3 million km2). Water shortages and erosion increasingly affect a large number of islands in the eastern Caribbean, to which can be added arid zones in the Netherlands Antilles, Cuba, Haiti, Jamaica, Puerto Rico and the Dominican Republic. In Mesoamerica, Mexico, a predominantly arid or semiarid country (especially in the north) is of particular importance. In South America numerous countries are affected. Extensive semi-arid regions are covered by tropical savannah in the Brazilian northeast, and on the Pacific coast the desert extends from the south of Ecuador, along the Peruvian coast and the north of Chile. An arid strip stretches from Patagonia in the south of Argentina to the north of the Chaco in Paraguay. The dry Andean high plains cover extensive areas at altitudes of between 3,000 and 4,500 metres in Argentina, Bolivia, Chile and Peru (PNUMA/ORPALC, 2002; UNCCD, 2002a).
Policy responses
Overgrazing, poor irrigation techniques, deforestation and removal of vegetal cover for domestic uses, are among the factors that endanger 70 per cent of the highly vulnerable dry soils, which also suffer from a significant degree of desertification (FAO, 1998b). In Latin America and the Caribbean, 313 million ha are affected by desertification (250 million in South America and 63 million in Mesoamerica), causing annual losses of approximately US$2,000 million. While the cost of restoring the region’s degraded lands has been estimated to be US$13,000 million, it is an investment that would
In the past 10 years, and as a result of the United Nations Conference on the Environment and Development (Rio de Janeiro, 1992), the traditional focus of agricultural policies, previously concentrating almost exclusively on aspects of land production and productivity, has been broadened to include integrated and participatory planning for sustainable management of land resources (FAO and UNEP, 1997; FAO and UNEP, 2000). Agenda 21, which was a result of the Rio conference, proposed the integration of biophysical, social and economic themes, active participation by local communities and strengthening of institutions to satisfy sustainable development objectives. Substantial elements of the new integrated focus include considerations of the importance of food security and the capacity of agricultural ecosystems to provide a continuous supply of food, forage and fibre, among other environmental goods and services. The overuse of agrochemicals in Latin America and the Caribbean, which has been associated with a significant deterioration of the environment, brings with it a growing immunity to common pests and the appearance of new ones, as well as negative effects on human health. All this has led international organisations and governments to implement integrated pest control projects for an increasing number of crops (Hall and Menn, 1999). These initiatives have caused specific
48
Latin America and the Caribbean
policies to be adopted on integrated systems (FAO, 1998a). Many countries in the region have also undertaken important experiments on agricultural conservation designed to increase productivity while, at the same time, reducing erosion and reversing the loss of soil fertility, aimed at improving rural life and restoring the environment (FAO, 2001b). Some of the most notable of these experiments are reducing or eliminating slash-and-burn agriculture in some areas in Honduras, introducing minimum cultivation practices on Brazilian smallholdings, freeing areas for cultivation by intensifying livestock farming in Costa Rica, and the massive adoption of zero cultivation in El Salvador and organic agriculture in Cuba (FAO, 2001b; CIGEA, 2001). These experiments show that the development of intensive production systems in the tropics is technically feasible and economically profitable through improved land use, agricultural biodiversity and carbon fixing. For many decades, problems of land degradation have also featured in global and regional discussions. The principal declaration of policies in this field is the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD), drafted in 1994 as a result of the Rio summit of 1992. The 33 countries in Latin America and the Caribbean are parties to the convention and some countries have received financial support to prepare their national plans and reports (UNCCD, 2002a; 2002b).
action programmes; another 13 countries are in the process of formulating or approving similar programmes (UNCCD, 2002b). This action has encouraged the establishment of such programmes in countries like Peru and Argentina, as well as the creation of monitoring systems that are already in use (PNUMA/ORPALC, 1999; Universidad de Buenos Aires, 2001). The third round of Global Environment Facility (GEF) financing anticipates emphasising activities aimed at improving coordination between the conventions. At national level, in particular, there is an urgent need for greater efficiency in administering resources and combining efforts to combat desertification, to conserve biodiversity and protect wetlands. A regional programme has been prepared to apply the convention, with nine new priority projects and six sub-regional action programmes: the Great American Chaco, the American Puna, Mesoamerica, the Española, the programme of the eastern Caribbean islands on biodiversity and land degradation, and the bilateral Chile-Argentina programme on gender perspectives (UNCCD, 2002b). There is also a project under way on the harmonisation of regional public policies to combat desertification, starting with the Mexican government’s experience (PNUMA/ORPALC, 2003a).
At the World Summit on Sustainable Development, held in Johannesburg (South Africa) in 2002, participating countries reaffirmed the commitment to implement the UNCCD through national action plans, mobilising the necessary resources and seeking concerted action with other convergent multilateral agreements such as the Framework Convention on Climate Change and the Convention on Biological Diversity (UN, 2002). However, in the 28 national reports presented that year to the Committee to Examine the Application of the Convention, most countries in the region mentioned limitations encountered in applying it. One such limitation is a bias in the agenda towards policies that favour economics but ignore the economic implications of desertification. Also recognised are problems such as ineffectual national liaison officials, usually because they are frequently changed, and weak mechanisms to finance policies in this field (UNCCD, 2002b). Public awareness campaigns have been organised. National reports emphasise the importance of public participation in efforts to combat desertification, and nearly a third of the reports mention the vital contribution made by the International Network of Non-Governmental Organisations against Desertification and Drought (RIOD) in applying the convention (UNCCD, 2002b). In 2002, six countries in the region (Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Cuba, Mexico and Peru) approved national ·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
© R. Burgos
Environment Outlook
The Great Chaco sub-regional action programme involving Argentina, Bolivia and Paraguay, in spite of not having received all the funds needed to carry out its activities, has made important progress since its initial forum in May 2000. It has organised a meeting of NGOs on desertification and rural poverty (Argentina, June 2001) and prepared the Declaration of Cooperation for Sustainable Development in the Great American Chaco (Argentina, September 2001), which sets priority objectives. At the institutional level, monitoring units have been set up in participating countries; locally, various indigenous and agricultural communities have managed microprojects (UNCCD, 2002b). Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Ecuador and Peru participate in the Sub-regional Action Programme on Sustainable Development in the American Puna. At its coordination meeting in Bolivia in May 2001, advances were
made in defining the programme’s principles and concepts, priorities and strategies, its proposed institutional framework, and a programme of activities. The programme is concerned with the land tenure problem, deficient land regulation and the elimination of incentives for expanding the agricultural boundary. Participation of indigenous populations and community associations planning and implementing the programme is encouraged (including the Aymará Parliament for indigenous communities, established in 1996 to protect watershed resources and ecosystems affected by non-sustainable activities in the Andes). In January 2002, official recognition was given to the declaration on the sustainable development of the American Puna that makes express reference to the UNCCD, marking an important stage for this sub-regional programme. The programme’s institutional framework has been strength-
Towards owards harmonizing regional public policies to combat desertification Within the framework of the Convention to Combat Desertification, and with the support of the Global Mechanism created to channel technical and financial resources to apply the convention, the United Nations Environment Programme, Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean, is executing a project to harmonise regional public policies (PAPP). The project was approved by countries attending the convention's Fourth and Fifth Regional Meetings in 1998-1999; its objective is to contribute to the struggle against desertification by adopting appropriate management strategies for natural resources, taking as a basis the Mexican government's preliminary assessment, in 1998, of public policies and the degradation of natural resources. To contribute to improving the environment and implementing an early warning system on environmental problems, the project includes undertaking six pilot experiments in the same number of countries in the region, as well as holding methodology and systemisation workshops. A study will also be formulated on the international framework for reforms to rural development policies and a database prepared on policy instruments, both inputs designed to orient the countries' harmonisation work. The Mexican government has now prepared a design to integrate the National System to Combat Desertification (SNLD) and the results of the harmonisation work will be included in the legislation process on the Law of Sustainable Rural Development. This law includes the process of land use contracts that provide a suitable instrument to harmoniously coordinate three policy elements in this field: the application of publicly-funded programmes to support production, the concept of desertification as a global soil degradation process, and the SNLD itself, which is a national coordinating body. Congress is also debating a draft law on land conservation. As complementary support for these national exercises, the project to harmonise regional public policies has formulated, in coordination with the Chapingo Autonomous University, the preparation of a database on rural policy instruments. The database will provide systemised information on experiences in several countries throughout the world, starting with global research on public policy instruments meant to improve and conserve land. With this it is sought to learn from already formulated and executed experiments, and to make the countries' work on reform more effective. An international study has also been made on existing trends and margins to harmonise rural development policies against desertification. The study presents a panorama of the state of desertification in the region, gives a description of the instruments in use and profiles the main international bodies that define the international framework for policies in this field. Sources: PNUMA-ROLAC, 2003a, 2003b.
49
Chapter
2
50
Latin America and the Caribbean
ened by the creation of a secretariat and an operational technical committee composed of national liaison officers and representatives of indigenous communities (UNCCD, 2002b).
vention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as Waterfowl Habitat (Ramsar Convention) and the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Flora and Fauna (CITES).
The regional programme has also made important advances in developing parameters and indicators to create and monitor an information network to combat desertification and apply integrated watershed management (UNCCD, 2002b).
Among the most important actions directed at halting land degradation in Latin America and the Caribbean, priority should be given to those densely-populated countries with accelerated rates of output and fertility loss. These responses may be backed by policies that allow the participation of producers’ organisations, thus creating institutional conditions and incentives to increase land conversion capacities. Many local initiatives on land conservation, reduction or diversification of inputs, cover crops and agroforestry systems, have halted land degradation or even reversed it in many regions in Latin America. The boom in organic agriculture in some countries, is an encouraging sign; emphasis is on maintaining the soil’s natural fertility. These isolated experiences should be included in national and regional agricultural policy agendas.
Action has been taken, globally and regionally, to strengthen collaboration and exchange of information about combating desertification, including the Third High Level Forum on Cooperation between Africa and Latin America and the Caribbean, held in Venezuela in 2002 (UNCCD, 2002b). There is a trend for global multilateral agreements concerned with desertification to be converged and coordinated. To unify the collection and dissemination of information on environmental themes worldwide, under the coordination of UNEP, letters of understanding have been signed between the secretariats of global conventions such as UNCCD, the Convention on Biological Diversity, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, the Con-
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
51
References ● CEPAL, IICA (Comisión Económica para
América Latina y el Caribe; Instituto Interamericano de Cooperación para la Agricultura), 2001: Panorama de la agricultura de América Latina y el Caribe 1990-2000, CEPAL, Santiago, Chile. ● CIGEA (Centro de Información, Gestión y
Educación Ambiental, 2001: Panorama ambiental de Cuba, CIGEA, Editorial Academia, Havana, Cuba.
lines for land resources management in the 21st century, FAO y UNEP, Roma, Italia. ● Gómez, I. A., G. C. Gallopín, 1995: Poten-
cial agrícola de la América Latina, en el futuro ecológico de un continente: una visión prospectiva de la América Latina, Editorial de la Universidad de las Naciones y Fondo de Cultura Económica, Mexico, D. F., Mexico. ● Hall, F. R., J. J. Menn (eds), 1999: Biopesti-
● CONAM, PNUMA (Consejo Nacional del
Ambiente de Perú; Programa de Naciones Unidas para el Medio Ambiente), 2001: GEO Perú 2000, CONAM y PNUMA, Lima, Perú. ● COPPE (Instituto de Estudio Superiores e
Investigación en Ingeniería Alberto Luiz Coimbra), 2002: First Brazilian inventory of anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions. Background reports. Carbon Dioxide emissions from fuel burning: top-down approach, Ministry of Science and Technology, Brasilia, Brazil.
cides. Use and delivery, Humana Press, New Jersey, US.
● —, 2002b: Climate, soil and terrain con-
straints to rain-fed crop production, FAO, Rome, Italy (in http://www.fao.org/ag/agl/ agll/gaez/luc.css, consulted on 5 June 2002). ● —, 2002c: FAOSTAT Agriculture Data. Fer-
tiliser consumption, FAO, Rome, Italy (in http://apps.fao.org/page/collections, consulted on 30 September 2002). ● —, 2001a: El Estado Mundial de la agricul-
tura y la alimentación 2001, FAO, Rome, Italy.
tion), 2002a: Fertiliser nutrient consumption, IFA, Paris, France (in http://www.fertiliser. org/ifa/statstics/indicators/ind_cn_lam.asp, updated in October 2002, consulted on 19 June 2003). ● —, 2001: Fertilizer nutrient consumption,
by region, 1970/71 to 1998/99, Latin Ame rica and the Caribbean, IFA, Paris, France (in http://www.fertiliser.org/statsindcnlam. asp, consulted on 13 June 2001). ● IFA, FAO (International Fertiliser Industry As-
sociation; Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations), 2001: Global estimates of gaseous emissions of NH3, NO and N2O from agricultural land, IFA y FAO, Rome, Italy. ● Jazairy, I., M. Alamgir, T. Panuccio (eds),
1992: The state of world rural poverty, International Fund for Agricultural Development y New York University, New York, US. ● Library of Congress, 2000: Federal Research
Division: Land Tenure, Library of Congress, Washington, D. C., US (in http://memory.loc. gov/frd/cs/cxtoc.html, consulted on 31 March 2003).
Caribe en cifras. Informes sobre temas hídricos No. 20, FAO, Rome, Italy.
ridad alimentaria y desarrollo sostenible en las laderas de Centroamérica: retos futuros para la investigación y la formulación de políticas, International Food Policy Research Institute; Instituto Interamericano de Cooperación para la Agricultura; Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT)LADERAS, Tegucigalpa, Honduras.
● —, 1998a: Integrated Pest Control in Nica-
● OdD-UCR, PNUMA (Observatorio del
agrícolas: Desafíos y prioridades hacia 2030. Análisis Regional de América Latina y el Caribe, FAO, Rome, Italy. ● —, 2000: El riego en América Latina y el
en América Latina, in Revista Agricultura 21, noviembre, FAO, Rome, Italy (in http:// www.fao.org/ag/esp/revista/spot4.htm, consulted on 31 March 2003).
Desarrollo, Universidad de Costa Rica; Programa de las Naciones Unidas para el Medio Ambiente Oficina Regional para America Latina y el Caribe), 2001 : GEO Estadísticas ambientales de América Latina y el Caribe, OdD-UCR, PNUMA, San José, Costa Rica.
● FAO, UNEP (Food and Agriculture Organi-
● Oldeman, L. R., 1994: Global Extent of Soil
sation of the United Nations, United Nations Environment Programme), 2000: El Futuro de Nuestra Tierra: Enfrentando el desafío, FAO and UNEP, Rome, Italy.
Degradation, en D. J. Greenland, I. Szabolcs (eds), Soil Resilience and Sustainable Soil Use, CAB International, Wallinford, UK, pp. 99-118.
● —, 1997: Negotiating a sustainable future
● Oldeman, L.R., R.T.A. Hakkeling, W.G
for land: Structural and institutional guide-
Sombroek, 1991: World Map on the Status
ragua, FAO, Managua, Nicaragua. ● —, 1998b: La conservación de las tierras
Unidas para el Medio Ambiente; Oficina Regional para América Latina y el Caribe), 2003a: Proyectos Regionales - Armonización de Políticas Públicas en Latinoamérica y el Caribe (in http://www.rolac.unep. mx/deselac/html/armoni.htm, consulted on 4 June 2003).
de Armonización de Políticas Públicas (PAPP) para GEO-ALC 2003, PNUMA y ORPALC, Mexico D. F., Mexico. ● — 2002: La desertificación en América
Latina y el Caribe, PNUMA y ORPALC, Mexico D. F., Mexico (in http://www.rolac. unep.mx/deselac/index.html#ladeserti ficacion, consulted on 21 December 2002). ● —, 1999: Aplicación de la Convención.
Examen de los progresos realisados en la formulación y ejecución de los programas de acción subregionales y regionales en América Latina y el Caribe, PNUMA y ORPALC, Mexico D. F., Mexico. ● Pratt, L., C.A. Jones, 1999: The Environment
and Central America’s Competitiveness, Centro Latinoamericano para la Competitividad y el Desarrollo Sostenible, Alajuela, Costa Rica. ● UCH, CAPP, PNUMA (Universidad de
Chile; Centro de Análisis de Políticas Públicas; Programa de las Naciones Unidas para el Medio Ambiente), 2000: Informe País, Estado del Medio Ambiente de Chile, 1999, UCH, CAPP y PNUMA, Santiago, Chile. ● UN (United Nations), 2002: Johannesburg
● López, S., J. Scherr, F. Mendoza, 1995: Segu● —, 2001b: Estudio global sobre sistemas
● PNUMA/ORPALC (Programa de Naciones
● — 2003b: Nota técnica sobre el Proyecto ● IFA (International Fertiliser Industry Associa-
● FAO (Food and Agriculture Organisation of
the United Nations), 2002a: FAOSTAT Agriculture Data. Land use, FAO, Rome, Italy (in http://apps.fao.org/page/collections, consulted on 27 September 2002).
of Human Induced Soil Degradation, International Soil Reference and Information Centre y United Nations Environment Programme, Nairobi, Kenya.
Summit 2002, UN, New York, US (in http:/ /www.johannesburgsummit.org/, consulted on 07 October 2003). ● UNCCD (United Nations Secretariat of the
Convention to Combat Desertification), 2002a: Fact Sheet 13: Combating desertification in Latin America and the Caribbean, UNCCD, Bonn, Germany. (in http:// www.unccd.int/publicinfo/factsheets/ showFS.php?number=13, consulted on 20 December 2002). ● —, 2002b: Síntesis de la información
contenida en los informes nacionales de los países partes afectados de América Latina y el Caribe, UNCCD, Bonn, Germany (in http://www.unccd.int/cop/officialdocs/cop4/ pdf/3add2(d)spa.pdf, consulted on 30 March 2003). ● UNEP (United Nations Environment Pro-
gramme), 2002: Global Environment Outlook: GEO-3, Earthscan Publications Ltd, London, UK.
Chapter
2
52
Latin America and the Caribbean
● —, 2000: GEO Latin America and the Car-
● Universidad de Buenos Aires, 2001: Indi-
ibbean: Environment Outlook 2000, UNEP Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
cadores de la desertificación para su monitoreo con teledetección y SIG en el Valle de Santa María (Catamarca), Universidad de Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina (in http://www.rec.uba.ar/pc_98_00/htm/ag13. htm, consulted on 12 June 2001).
● UNESCO, MAB, SCOPE, UNEP (United Na-
tions Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation; Man and the Biosphere Programme; Scientific Committee On Problems of the Environment, United Nations Environment Programme), 1978: Environmental Effects of Arid Land Irrigation in Developing Countries, MAB, Paris, France.
Regional para Sud América), Santiago, Chile. ● Wood, S., K. Sebastian, S. Scherr, 2000: Pi-
lot Analysis of Global Ecosystems (PAGE), Agroecosystems Technical Report, World Resources Institute, Washington D.C., US.
● van Arsdale, C., 1991: Banana Develop-
● WRI (World Resources Institute), 2001:
ment In Costa Rica, in Multinational Monitor, Washington, D.C., US, Volume 12, Numbers 1- 2 (in http://multinational monitor.org/hyper/issues/1991/01/mm0191 _06.html, consulted on 31 March 2003).
IADB Environmental Indicator Briefing Report, WRI, Washington, D.C., US. ● —, 2000: World Resources 2000-2001. Peo-
● UNFCCC (United Nations Framework Con-
vention on Climate Change), 2002: Status reports 2002 (Greenhouse gas inventories), NFCCC, Bonn, Germany (in http://unfccc. int/program/mis/ghg/statrep2002.html, consulted on 30 March 2003).
·
● van Dam, C., 1999: La tenencia de la tierra
en América Latina. El estado del arte de la discusión en la región. Iniciativa global tierra, territorios y derechos de acceso, Unión Mundial para la Naturaleza (Oficina
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
ple and Ecosystems: The fraying web of life, WRI, Washington, D.C., US.
Environment Outlook
Forest extent: extent: Latin America and the Caribbean
Forests
I
n 2000 the Latin American and Caribbean region had 25 per cent of the world’s forest cover, some 960 million hectares (ha), on only a seventh of its territory (FAO, 2001a). The proportion of forested areas is much greater than the global average; 47 per cent of regional territory is covered with forests, while the world figure is 30 per cent (FAO, 2001a). South America has 92 per cent of regional forests, mainly in Brazil and Peru, which are among the 10 countries that account for two-thirds of the world’s forests (FAO, 2001a). Planted forests make up a little more than one per cent of the forested area in Latin America and the Caribbean and almost half are in Brazil (FAO, 2001a, 2001e). The woody biomass of Latin America and the Caribbean is the world’s largest, with more than 17 per cent of the global average of 109 tonnes per hectare (FAO, 2001a). South America has 54 per cent of the world total and Brazil alone has 27 per cent. This underlines the importance of the region –and Brazil in particular– in capturing or emitting atmospheric carbon because of changes in use, a key element in regulating the planetary climate change process. No detailed analysis is available of world or regional forest cover between 1970 and 2000, not only because
Latin America and the Caribbean is the most heavily forested region in the world, but it lost almost 47 million hectares in the period 1990-2000 (second only to Africa). Note: The dark green shows the closed forest (areas with more than 40% of trees higher than 5 meters); the medium green represents open forests (with a cover of between 10 and 40 percent) or fragmented trees, and the light green represents other forest lands, with bushes or wild grass.
Chapter
2
Source: FAO, 2001e.
information is lacking in many countries but because of changes in international statistical methods. However, the new estimates made by FAO for 1990-2000 indicate that, of the world’s total forest area that disappeared
Countries with the highest percentage of forests in the world, 2000 35
30
% of total area
25
20
15
10
5
0
Russian Federation
Source: FAO, 2001a.
53
Brazil
Canada
United States
China
Australia
Democratic Republic of Congo
Indonesia
Angola
Peru
Others
54
Latin America and the Caribbean
during that decade, half of the loss was in Latin America and the Caribbean (FAO, 2001a). According to these estimates, the regional percentage of global forest cover fell from 25.5 to 24.9 per cent in that period. During the past 20 years, world loss of natural forest has continued at approximately the same levels (FAO, 2001a, 2001c). In tropical forests, the loss continues at an “alarmingly high” rate of close to one per cent annually. In the specific case of the South American tropical forests, although there was a reported reduction in deforestation rates in the 1980s and 1990s, a sample taken from satellite data did not find any statistically-significant differences between the two periods (FAO, 2001c). Because of their socio-economic role in most Latin American and Caribbean countries, the fate of natural forests is critical for the region. These ecosystems supply wood for domestic and industrial consumption and for exports that earn foreign currency. Many communities have coexisted with forest ecosystems for generations. Forests provide traditional forest goods – such as food, medicines and other non-wood forestry products - to many rural populations (Bryant and others, 1997), as well as environmental goods and services (carbon
capture, containing natural disasters, recharging aquifers, halting erosion and soil loss).
Deforestation trends and causes The greatest reduction in forests during the 1990s was in Africa where 5.3 million ha were lost every year. Latin America and the Caribbean was in second place, with a loss of 4.6 per cent of its forest cover between 1990 and 2000, a total of 46.7 million ha, with an average annual deforestation rate of 0.5 per cent. This is over double the global average (FAO, 2001a). According to FAO, 88 per cent of the region’s forest areas are found – in descending order – in seven countries: Brazil, Peru, Mexico, Bolivia, Colombia, Venezuela and Argentina, with Brazil accounting for 56 per cent of regional forests or 544 million ha (FAO, 2001a). Almost half the total loss of cover between 1990 and 2000 was in Brazil (23 million ha, or 4.2 per cent of the country’s forests), with Mexico (6.3 million ha) and Argentina (2 million ha) far behind. Annual deforestation rates were more than twice as high in these two last-men-
Assessment of world forest resources: definitions, methods and sources The last assessment made by FAO of world forest resources –the 2000 FRA– establishes new reference statistics for the year 2000 and to analyse trends from 1990 (FAO, 2001a). In its new estimates, FAO includes (as it did in the earlier assessment for 1990) natural forests and forest plantations but now, for the first time, applies a uniform and broader definition of the concept of forest for all countries, both for 2000 and 1990, thus correcting its previous assessment. In the 1990 FRA, FAO applies the concept of forest to trees at least 7 metres high on areas larger than 100 ha, with crown cover of 10 per cent for developing countries, and 20 per cent for industrialised countries. The definition now includes all wooded territory with trees at least 5 metres high and a crown cover of more than 20 per cent on an area of more than half a hectare. Therefore, while estimated world cover for 1990 is 15 per cent higher in the new study, this is due in large part to the use of a broader definition of forest for all countries (FAO, 2001c). The increase is also explained by the use of new forest inventories after 1990 (as in the case of Mozambique), or by reclassifying as forest areas those previously classified as other wooded land (in Kenya, for example). For developing countries, the 1990 FRA estimated forest cover trends in the period 1980-1990 by using a mathematical model based on demographic factors to project the little national information available (FAO, 2001c). The model was not used for the 2000 FRA as it was recognised there was little relation between these factors and the change in cover. Instead, an extrapolation method was used for the years under review (1990, 2000) based on greater availability of data than in the earlier assessment, which in turn was corrected with experts' criteria and the results of satellite information sampling for tropical forests. The exercise encountered many limitations, one of them being that more than half of the developing countries had only one forest inventory, and more than a quarter had none at all (FAO, 2001a). Of 45 countries in Latin America and the Caribbean, 19 (four in the Caribbean) had inventories comparable by country, but 14 countries had no inventories (31 per cent, 13 in the Caribbean) and four had only a partial inventory. Furthermore, the inventories are very dissimilar as to their reference year; the most recent statistics for Brazil, for example, whose forest cover is the region's most extensive, are for 1989 (FAO, 2001e). The inventories can also differ from the statistics prepared by FAO; In Mexico, for example, the National Forest Inventory for 1993-2000 shows annual deforestation rates above 800 000 ha, while FAO indicates 631 000 in the period 1990-2000 (Morán and Galleti, 2002).
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
tioned countries (1.1 and 0.8 per cent respectively, compared to 0.4 in Brazil). Only three countries showed increases in their forest cover during the period, but to a much smaller degree than the losses suffered in countries with more forests: Uruguay (501,000 ha), Cuba (277,000 ha) and Guadalupe (15,000 ha) (FAO, 2000). Annual rates of change in forest cover varied considerably from one sub-region to another in the 19902000 period. Caribbean countries had the lowest average annual rate of change in forest cover (0.2 per cent), followed by South America (0.4 per cent) and Mesoamerica (1.2 per cent - FAO, 2000). There are also great differences within each subregion. In the Caribbean, for example, Saint Lucia and Haiti showed high rates of deforestation (4.9 and 4.6 per cent annually, respectively), which was not the case in Cuba and Guadalupe. In Mesoamerica, deforestation rates range from 4.6 per cent annually in El Salvador to 0.8 in Costa Rica. Nicaragua, Belize, Guatemala and Panama resemble El Salvador - their rates are above the sub-regional average; only Costa Rica, Honduras and Mexico are below the average. In South America, deforestation rates in Ecuador and Argentina are notably higher than the sub-regional annual average (1.2 and 0.8 per cent, respectively), while the others maintain rates similar to the sub-regional average. NB - in 1990-2000 South America had 40 per cent of the world’s deforested area (FAO, 2001a).
Pressures The main pressure affecting natural forests in the region is the conversion of forest land to other uses. More land is made available for agriculture, livestock
and urbanisation, as well as for road building and other infrastructure (electric networks, dams), or for mining. Other significant pressure comes from harvesting timber, forest fires and climate phenomena (Bryant and others, 1997). Negative effects are also caused by biological phenomena such as the proliferation of pests, often reflecting ecological changes caused by humans, particularly due to exotic forestry species monoculture (Monge-Nájera, 1997). Unlike other regions, the loss of forest cover is explained more by the expansion of transport networks, extensive livestock-raising and mechanised agriculture (especially soybeans) than by timber harvesting, which occurs in relatively few countries (Kaimowitz, 1996; Kaimowitz, 1997). Penetration roads into the forest, and associated timber harvesting, expand the agricultural boundary, and contribute to forest degradation through loss of biodiversity. Regionally, as in the rest of the developing world, timber is harvested, to supply fuelwood and, to a lesser extent, for industrial production and sawmills. In 2000, regional production of roundwood and sawnwood (including all kinds of industrial roundwood and fuelwood) was 432.7 million m3, almost twice the 1970 production (FAO, 2002a). In the same year, 61.6 per cent of this production was used for energy (fuelwood and charcoal), half in Brazil and almost a third in Mesoamerica (particularly in Mexico and Guatemala). Industrial production is concentrated on a regional market restricted to only a few species, which places them under great pressure. In particular, selective timber harvesting in remote areas is threatening important native species such as cedar (Cedrela odorata) and mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla -UNOFOC and others, 2000).
Use of fuelwood as a source of energy in Mesoamerica An analysis of the regional generation of energy from wood and its derivatives reveals that over the past 30 years there has been a constant increase, particularly in Mesoamerica and Brazil, where consumption is greatest and represents 48.0 per cent of the total. In Mesoamerica, with 17.5 per cent of the total for the region, the main consuming countries are Mexico (8.7 per cent of the regional total), Guatemala (3.4 per cent) and Honduras (2.0 per cent). Two-thirds of Mexico's timber potential is found in temperate forests, and half the timber produced comes from pine forests. Of total processed volume, 80 per cent is used for energy by producing fuelwood and vegetable carbon. In Central America, much of the fuelwood comes from agricultural land, live hedges and secondary forests. Of harvested wood, 92 per cent is used as fuelwood, both for domestic and industrial use, although with strong contrasts between the countries in the sub-region. For example, domestic fuelwood use reaches 1.5 cubic metres per capita annually in Honduras, but only 0.34 in Belize. Sources: UNOFOC and others, 2000; FAO, 2002a, 2002b.
55
Chapter
2
56
Latin America and the Caribbean
Subsidies for Mexico's Mexico's agriculture and livestock sector Mexico's agriculture sector grew by more than 4 per cent annually from the end of the 1940s until the mid-1970s, largely due to government funds allocated to provide direct and indirect support to this branch of economic activity. Added to the lack of adequate legislation and monitoring, this stimulated the expansion of agriculture into forest areas. Besides direct investments in the sector, end products including fertilizers, pesticides, fuel, electricity, water and seeds, were also subsidised. In addition, crops were insured, productive activities were promoted by parastate organisations and loans were given with little likelihood of repayment. Just the opposite was the case in the forestry sector, where credit was restricted and the few people with access to it had to discount their activities at very high rates because the sector was considered to be too risky. By 1965, most of the best land was already under cultivation and productivity per hectare had stagnated. From that time until 1980, the agricultural gross domestic product grew at only 2.4 per cent but protectionist policies continued from 1970 until 1998: measures included subsidies for maize, price guarantees, high taxes on permanent crops (sugar cane, coffee, cocoa) and trade restrictions. In recent years the government programme PROCAMPO has removed price subsidies and replaced them with direct payments to producers according to the areas planted. Although no systematic studies have been made on their influence, anecdotal evidence points to a great propensity in rural areas to clear forests in order to expand areas for cultivation and thus claim subsidies under the programme. Sources: Morán and Galleti, 2002.
Economic pressure and poorly-directed subsidies or incentives have been a main cause of the conversion of forest soils into land for agriculture and raising livestock. In some countries this has become worse as a consequence of policies to increase exports that provide the foreign currency needed to pay for imports and repay the foreign debt (Contreras-Hermosilla, 2000). Land tenure and institutional arrangements that govern forest management are also an important factor influencing forest degradation or conservation (Ostrom, 1990; Gibson and others, 2000; FAO, 2001a; Geist and Lambin, 2001; Gibson and Lehoucq, 2002). In many cases, strategies to protect forest environmental services depend on forms of community or socialised administration (such as may be developed by certain indigenous groups, community organisations or even the State itself). In the Amazon and Mesoamerica, indigenous people are the legal owners of significant areas of tropical forest as well as of temperate forest in the southern cone. In Mexico, ejidos and communal land predominate. In cases where much forest land is in the hands of the State, it releases part of them to private interests through private forestry concessions (as in Bolivia, Guyana, Suriname and other countries). When property rights over land are not clear, people tend to clear forests and build on those areas to establish a claim to them. A primary pressure on forests is the predominance of a short-term and strictly financial view of the economic benefit of identifying development options. Notwithstanding the important social and cultural function
·
of forests in the region – in particular for communities and social groups that directly depend on them for their subsistence – this feature of the forests is often not taken into account in infrastructure development plans and productive investments. In many investment projects, decisions on the permanence of forests, or on a change of land use. both private and public, are more frequently based on conventional cost-benefit analyses (focussed on financial gain) rather than more wide-ranging analyses that include economic, social and environmental considerations.
Forest fires and hydrometeorological threats Fires continue to affect important extensions of forests in the region. In Central America more than 2.5 million ha of forests caught fire during the 1997-1998 El Niño, and one million ha of agricultural land were also damaged. In Nicaragua, Guatemala and Honduras 900,000, 650,000 and 575,000 ha, respectively, were lost. In 1998 those countries suffered the impact of Hurricane Mitch, which caused loss of forest cover which exacerbated landslides and floods. In Bolivia, fires affected three million ha. In the state of Roraima in Brazil, fires devastated more than five million ha, including 1.4 million ha of tropical forests (Cochrane, 2002). In the same year another 850,000 ha caught fire in Mexico. In 1999, the NOAA-12 satellite images identified about 219,000 heat sources in South America. Approxi-
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
57
Forest rangers: indigenous community forest management There is an international dispute about the need to keep biodiversity users away from protected areas to guarantee their conservation. Many opponents of this thesis argue that biodiversity can be maintained and even improved through sustainable use by promoting different mechanisms –such as community management– to make conservation part of development. When it comes to forest resources, there are multiple experiences in Latin America and the Caribbean in community forestry (within and outside protected areas) that make this second thesis credible. The ancestral experience of many indigenous communities is of great value in this respect, especially in countries with large pre-Columbian indigenous populations such as Mexico, Guatemala and Bolivia. The importance of indigenous inhabitants to the sustainable administration of forests is also essential in places whose indigenous populations are proportionally smaller: Brazil, among countries in Amazon, and Chile, among countries in the southern cone. In Mexico, for example, it is estimated that 80 per cent of forest land is in the hands of one-seventh of the population living on ejidos and other indigenous community land. But even countries with very small aboriginal populations, like Costa Rica, bear witness to the notable function of indigenous groups as forest rangers. In that country, protected territory belonging to indigenous communities adds 22 per cent to protected wild areas with more than 41 per cent of the total extension under forest cover. Sources: Cabarle and others, 1997; Fernández-González, 1999; UNOFOC and others, 2000; FAO, 2001a; Gibson and others, 2000, 2002; Obando Acuña, 2002.
mately 66 per cent were in Brazil, 11 per cent in Argentina, 11 per cent en Bolivia, eight per cent in Paraguay (UNEP, 2000). In 1999-2000, the total number of incidents dropped by 29 per cent in the South American countries monitored. Although there was a decrease in Brazil, there were increases in Colombia and Venezuela. In general, human activity causes forest fires through land clearing, agriculture and hunting, but they are also due to earlier fires, bonfires and burning litter (Cochrane, 2002). Fragmentation following deforestation and a change in soil cover exposes the forest to more fires and increases the risk of accidental fires. Forest fires have significant sanitary, economic and environmental effects. Smoke causes cardiovascular and eye problems, as well as constrictive and obstructive pulmonary illnesses, asthma, pneumonia, bronchitis, acute laryngitis and bronchiectasis (Cochrane, 2002). At local level, environmental effects include soil degradation, an increase in the risk of flooding in the rainy season and of drought when there is no rainfall, a reduction in animal and plant varieties, and a greater possibility of recurrent fires. At world level, these effects include the release of greenhouse effect gases, a reduction in precipitation and the extinction of the animal and plant populations. No estimates have been made of the broad spectrum of effects mentioned here when assessing the economic impact of forest fires. However, in 1998 when fires destroyed at least 9.2 million ha throughout the region, estimates of damage ranged from US$10-15,000 million (Cochrane, 2002).
Image of South American hot spots in 2000
South American Hot Spots
Chapter
2
58
Latin America and the Caribbean
Impact of deforestation While over the past 30 years the extraction of fibre from natural forests and plantations has practically doubled in the region, it has been at the cost of other forestry goods and services. To begin with, a reduction in forest cover tends to cause deterioration in the amount and quality of water resources, and there is increased soil erosion and sedimentation of water courses. But perhaps the greatest evident impact is on biodiversity goods and services affected by the increase in the number of endangered species, the conversion and fragmentation of forest habitats, the extraction of wood and the introduction of exotic species. To all these is added a reduced carbon fixing potential as a consequence of deforestation and soil deterioration (FAO, 2001a). These effects – which represent a permanent loss of the potential capacity of forest resources to provide economic benefits (IDB, UNDP, ACT, 1992) – are more severe in some countries than in others. In the Caribbean, for example, imported forestry products represent 14.2 per cent of total consumption. Although it has dropped from a maximum of 22.8 per cent in 1984, this figure is much higher than in Mesoamerica (2.6 per cent and growing) or South America (0.3 per cent and decreasing) (FAO, 2002a). The high consumer imports into the Caribbean are mostly of sawnwood and wood panels (imported to meet about 80 and 60 per cent, respectively, of total consumption).
In countries with large extensions of forests like Brazil, deforestation has had fewer general effects although local effects may be important. In the past two decades, wood production in Brazilian Amazon has increased from 14 to 85 per cent of national production, 80 per cent of which is estimated to be illegal (UNEP, 2000). The southern states of Brazil import hard woods from the northern states and from Paraguay where most of the remaining forests are protected (Tomaselli, 2001).
Forest policies As a response to deforestation problems, degradation of forests and forest fires, some countries have adopted new forestry laws and policies that include better regulatory measures, sustainability principles, expanding protected areas, certifying forestry products and expanding forest plantations in non-forest areas. These countries include Argentina, Brazil, Costa Rica and Peru (BOLFOR and others, 1998; Gobierno de Perú, 2000; Tomaselli, 2000). Laws passed in the 1990s contemplate fiscal and economic instruments such as certification to promote sustainable management of natural forests and forest plantations. Countries with new legislation include Mexico (1992, 1997), Bolivia, Costa Rica and Guatemala (1996), and Cuba (1998) (Brañes, 2001). In some countries, the response to deforestation has combined
© R. Burgos
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
development based on forest resources with regulation of forest activities, recognising that policy and institutional aspects are often more important market factors in determining the rhythm and effects of deforestation (Kaimowitz, 1997). Bolivia’s new forestry law, for instance, places forest land at the disposal of private companies by awarding concessions and involving local and indigenous communities (Tomaselli, 2000). Managed forest areas represent 3.8 per cent of total forest cover (FAO, 2001e). These areas, listed in descending order, are in: Mexico (7.1 million ha); Bolivia (6.9 million); Guyana (4.2 million); Brazil (four million); Venezuela (3.9 million); and Paraguay (three million). More than two million ha have been certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC), an organisation with headquarters in Oaxaca, Mexico (FAO, 2001e). The FSC awards certificates to logging operations that comply with resource management standards, the fair distribution of benefits and environmental protection. As shown by the case of Mesoamerica during the 1990s, this has brought a boom in associative enterprises (cooperatives, community companies) that capitalise on agroforestry traditions to enter new markets.
59
Protected forests in South America occupy almost 123 million ha, or 19.5 per cent of the remaining world forests, and 62.15 per cent of the total protected areas (UNEP, 2001). This region still has vast tracts of intact tropical and temperate forest, including those in the northern Andes, which is one of the world’s richest biological zones. As indicated above, planted trees cover 1.2 per cent of the region’s forest surface for a total of 11.7 million ha (FAO, 2001a, 2001e). These plantations are concentrated in Brazil (five million ha) and Chile (two million), followed, in descending order, by Argentina, Venezuela, Peru, Uruguay, Cuba and Mexico which, together, have a total of 3.8 million ha. In general, they are industrial exotic species plantations (mainly eucalyptus and pine). These plantations will grow in size and economic importance as commercially-exploitable forests shrink, and by using more sustainable silviculture techniques, although there serious institutional and private sector weaknesses still limit their expansion. Although the plantations are being converted into an economic alternative to other soil uses (such as agriculture) and, thus, help to reduce deforestation, they always imply a loss
Payment for environmental services in Costa Rica In Costa Rica, the concept of payment for environmental services (PSA) is based on the principle that the proprietors of forests and forestry plantations have a right to compensation for the cost of preserving or restoring the benefits such ecosystems bring to the country and to the rest of the planet. According to the Forestry Law of 1996, these services include reducing, absorbing, fixing and storing carbon to lessen the greenhouse effect; protecting water for urban, rural or hydropower use; protecting ecosystems to conserve them and make them fit for sustainable use (scientific, pharmaceutical and genetic improvement); protecting ecosystems, forms of life and scenic natural beauty for tourism and scientific purposes. Since 1997 Costa Rica has applied a programme of payment for environmental services in 5 per cent of the national territory (more than 260,000 ha and 22,000 small and medium-sised properties); 85 per cent of the area consists of protected private forests and more than 9 per cent is under sustainable forest management for wood production. While in the period 1979-1995, reforestation accounted for 76 per cent of forestry incentives, from 1997-2000 this activity only received 7 per cent of the payments for environmental services. In 2001, the PSA received 5,412 million colons (about US$16.5 million) from fuel and hydrocarbon consumption taxes; the Tax Simplification and Efficiency Law of that year allocated a fixed amount of 3.5 per cent of such taxes to be paid to the programme. Other funds come from the sale of environmental services both nationally and internationally, including new experiments such as the municipal water tariff of the Heredia Public Services Company and the emission reduction certificates for renewable energy projects within the framework of the Kyoto Protocol (see sections on Freshwater and Atmosphere) The programme is administered by the Ministry of Finance which collects the resources, and the Ministry of the Environment and Energy (MINAE), which executes it through the National Conservation Areas System (SINAC) and the National Forest Financing Fund (FONAFIFO). Funds provided by the Ministry of Finance and other financing sources are administered by FONAFIFO. Requests by interested parties are processed by SINAC, which approves payments through conservation areas and each year determines the priority areas where the programme is to be applied. Sources: Obando Acuña, 2002; MINAE and UNEP, 2002; Proyecto Estado de la Nación, 2002; INBIO, 2002.
Chapter
2
60
Latin America and the Caribbean
of existing biodiversity in natural forests (Cavelier and Santos, 1999; FAO, 2001a). Experience with incentives and payment for environmental services, and other innovative financing schemes in the region, has shown the long-term feasibility of managing forest resources to be an excellent renewable resource (UNOFOC and others, 2000). In 1996, for example, Costa Rica established a mechanism in its Forestry Law for economic compensation for services provided by forests and forestry plantations. This has been a source of additional financing for several protected areas and in the practical implementation of many of the precepts of the Clean Development Mechanism in the Kyoto Protocol (1997) (State of the Nation Project, 2001; see Chapter Three). Other countries, including Chile, El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras, are exploring options to develop similar mechanisms (Rosa and others, 1999). Most governments receive international help in formulating environmental policies to address deforestation problems, strengthening institutions and establishing structures and mechanisms to improve monitoring and control. In general, the programmes and projects which are given international support are related to world concerns such as the conservation of biodiversity
and global warming. Silviculture programmes and projects with international support include the BOLFOR Project in Bolivia, the PPG 7 (Pilot Project to Conservation Tropical Brazilian Forests) in Brazil and the Iwokrama Project in Guyana. International organisations such as FAO and ITTO are active in the region. One of the challenges to forest policies in the region is the lack of recognition that the knowledge belonging to people living in forests can be protected by biodiversity patents. It is also necessary to develop sustainable logging practices that affect wood-yielding and non-wood yielding products. Ecotourism and recreation are particularly promising as a non-consumer use of forest resources. In spite of the efforts to respond to deforestation, and notwithstanding positive responses in recent years, most countries in the region have not faced up to the problem’s root causes. They do not yet implement policies that would effectively reduce deforestation by ensuring compliance with forestry laws and regulations. In particular, urgent and efficient measures are needed to put a stop to corruption in implementing laws. Demographic and economic pressure on agricultural land and human settlements often leads to overexploi-
Forest policy: the international framework The United Nations Conference on the Environment and Development (Rio de Janeiro, 1992) ended with the declaration of a set of forestry principles and a chapter in Agenda 21 on policies against deforestation. This led to a suggestion for a global-scale forest sustainability regulation. Following the Rio conference, forest policies became the subject of international discussion, first of all within the framework of the Intergovernmental Panel on Forests (IPF), and then of the Inter-governmental Forest Forum (IFF). These negotiations led to the creation in 2000 of the United Nations Forum on Forests. The work of the IPF-IFF produced proposals to be executed by the new Forum on Forests. These include the development of national forestry and land use plans; emphasis on the underlying causes of deforestation; the promotion and protection of traditional knowledge on forests; the assessment of forestry goods and services; the development of adequate institutional and legal mechanisms (among them the possibility of an international convention on forests); as well as financial matters and technology transfer. Another proposal was to prepare criteria for sustainable forestry regulation to allow more specific parameters to be established on the subject, and regional and sub-regional initiatives have been developed throughout the world. In general, Latin American and Caribbean countries have adhered to the three initiatives named after the places where they originated (FAO, 2001e): Tarapoto (in South America), Lepaterique (in Central America) and Montreal (Mexico, Argentina, Venezuela and Uruguay, here coinciding with Canada and the United States). An important focus of international debate in the Forum on Forests is the harmonisation of guidelines relating to forestry in the three conventions resulting from the Rio conference biological diversity, combat against desertification, climate change as well as other relevant multilateral agreements, such as the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) and the Ramsar Convention on Wetlands. Source: FAO, 2001a.
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
61
Towards owards sustainable management of natural forests Among the principal subjects emerging from the discussion on forests is the concern for the loss of the region's natural forests –with their biodiversity and associated environmental functions– and the sustainable management of natural formations. Most countries provide incentives for managing their native forests: exemption from land taxes (Chile, Ecuador, Uruguay), technical assistance (Ecuador), subsidies (Argentina, Mexico, Colombia) or payment for environmental services (Costa Rica). In addition, most countries are demanding prior management plans and place limitations on changes in forest land use. Some countries demand prior studies on environmental impact before approving forestry projects of any importance (Chile, Guyana), while others are already applying forestry certification (Mexico, Belize, Costa Rica, Brazil). A positive initiative by some countries –for example, Argentina, Chile, Paraguay, Costa Rica and Mexico– is the establishment of model forests designed to demonstrate the application of sustainable management, taking into account productive and environmental aspects, and with wide participation by civil society, including community and indigenous groups. In Cuba, the creation of integrated forest farms has had notable success in rehabilitating vegetation in the Cauto basin (CIGEA, 2001; Granma Internacional, 2002). Sustainable forest management, taking into account all the elements involved, requires an enormous research effort, especially on how the region's complex natural forestry ecosystems function. However, regional forestry research is clearly deficient in this respect and in most countries concentrates on matters related to the establishment, management and utilisation of forest plantations, usually with introduced species. Source: COFLAC, 2001; FAO, 2001a.
tation of the environment and of remaining natural resources. More comprehensive policies are needed that recognise and include measures to counteract this.
dress the protection and restoration of forests (including purchasing land and maintaining personnel), research and citizen education, among other issues.
The main burden for their implementation, unfortunately, falls on regional governments. Their budgets and capacities are often insufficient to allow them to ad-
References ● BOLFOR, CIFOR, IUFRO (Bolivia Sustain-
● Cabarle, B., F. Chapela, S. Madrid, 1997:
● CIGEA (Centro de Información, Gestión y
able Forest Management Project; Center for International Forestry; International Union of Forest Research Organisations), 1998: Memoria del Simposio Internacional Sobre Posibilidades de Manejo Forestal Sostenible en América Tropical, 15-20 July 1997, Santa Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia
Introducción: El manejo forestal comunitario y la certificación, en L. Merino (coordinator), El manejo forestal comunitario en México y sus perspectivas de sustentabilidad, Centro Regional de Investigaciones Multidisciplinarias de la Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México; Secretaría de Medio Ambiente, Recursos Naturales y Pesca; Consejo Mexicano para la Silvicultura Sostenible; World Resources Institute, Cuernavaca, Mexico.
Educación Ambiental), 2001: Panorama ambiental de Cuba 2000, CIGEA, Editorial Academia, Havana, Cuba.
● Brañes, R., 2001: El desarrollo del derecho
ambiental latinoamericano y su aplicación, Programa de Naciones Unidas para el Medio Ambiente, Mexico, D.F., Mexico. ● Bryant, D., D. Nielsen, L. Tangley, 1997: The
last frontier forests: ecosystems and economics on the edge, World Resources Institute, Washington, D.C., US.
● Cochrane, M., 2002: Spreading like Wild-
fire: tropical forest fires in Latin America and the Caribbean – prevention, assessment and early warning, United Nations Environment Programme Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
● Cavelier, J., C. Santos, 1999: Efecto de plan-
● COFLAC (Comisión Forestal para América
taciones abandonadas de especies exóticas y nativas sobre la regeneración natural de un bosque montano en Colombia, in Revista de Biología Tropical, San Jose, Costa Rica, 47 (4), 775-784.
Latina y el Caribe), 2001: Situación forestal en la región - 2000, Serie Forestal N° 15, Oficina Regional de la FAO para América Latina y el Caribe, Santiago, Chile.
Chapter
2
62
Latin America and the Caribbean
● Contreras-Hermosilla, A., 2000: The Under-
● Gibson, C. C., F. E. Lehoucq, J. T. Williams,
● Ostrom, E., 1990: Governing the commons.
lying Causes of Forest Decline, in Occasional Paper, No. 30, Center for International Forest Research, Bogor, Indonesia.
2002: Does Privatisation Protect Natural Resources? Property Rights and Forests in Guatemala, in Social Science Quarterly, Oxford, UK, in press.
The evolution of institutions for collective action, Cambridge University Press, New York, US.
● FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization),
● Proyecto Estado de la Nación, 2001: Estado
2002a: Producción de madera en rollo y producción de leña y carbón, en FAOSTAT Forestry, FAO, Rome, Italy (in http:// apps.fao.org, consulted 8 August 2002).
● Gibson, C. C., M. A. McKean, E. Ostrom
● —¯, 2002b: FAOSTAT Forestry, FAO, Rome,
● Gobierno del Perú, 2000: Ley Forestal y de
Italy (in http://apps.fao.org, consulted el 25 February2002).
Fauna Silvestre, No. 27.308, 16 June, Lima, Peru.
● —¯, 2001a: State of the World’s Forests
● Granma Internacional, 2002: Los árboles
2001, FAO, Rome, Italy (in http://www.fao. org/forestry, consulted on 25 February 2002).
perdidos del diario de Martí, digital edition (http://www.granma.cu/), Havana, 14 November.
● ¯—, 2001b: Situación forestal en la región
● IDB, UNDP, ACT (Inter-American Develop-
de América Latina y el Caribe, FAO, Roma, Italia (in http://www.rlc.fao.org/organos/ coflac/98sf-s.htm, consulted on 25 February 2002).
ment Bank; United Nations Development Programme; Amazon Conservation Team), 1992: Amazonia Without Myths, Commission on Development and Environment for Amazonia, IDB, Washington, D.C., US.
de la Nación en Desarrollo Humano Sostenible: Sétimo Informe 2000, Proyecto Estado de la Nación, San Jose, Costa Rica.
(eds), 2000: People and Forests. Communities, Institutions, and Governance, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachussetts, US.
● Rosa, H., D. Herrador, M. E. González,
1999: Valoración y pago por servicios ambientales: Las experiencias de Costa Rica y El Salvador, en Boletín PRISMA, San Salvador, El Salvador, No. 35, 1-20. ● Tomaselli, I, 2001: GEO-3, Latin America
and the Caribbean. Forests, technical paper prepared for UNEP, Global Environmental Outlook-3, United Nations Environment Programme, Nairobi, Kenia. ● — 2000: Investing in the Future: The Pri-
vate Sector and Sustainable Forest Management – South America Perspective, paper prepared for the International Workshop of Experts on Financing Sustainable Forest Management, 22-25 de enero de 2001, Oslo, Noruega.
● ¯—, 2001c: FRA 2000: Comparison of For-
est Area and Forest Area Change Estimates Derived from FRA 1990 and FRA 2000, Forest Resources Assessment Programme, Working Paper 59, FAO, Rome, Italy. ● ¯—, 2001d: FRA 2000: Global Ecological
Zoning for the Global Forest Resources Assessment 2000. Final Report, Forest Resources Assessment Programme, Working Paper 56, FAO, Rome, Italy.
● INBIO (Instituto Nacional de Biodiversidad
de Costa Rica), 2002: El Pago de Servicios Ambientales en Costa Rica. Información General (in http://www.inbio.ac.cr/es/ conserv/psa.htm, consulted 15 October 2002).
● UNEP (United Nations Environment Pro-
gramme), 2001: An Assessment of the Status of the World’s Remaining Closed Forests, Early Warning and Assessment Technical Report, UNEP, Nairobi, Kenia.
● Kaimowitz, D., 1997: Factors determining
low deforestation: insights from the Bolivian Amazon, in Ambio, Stockholm, Sweden, 26 (8), 537-540.
● —, 2000: GEO Latin America and the Car-
ibbean: Environment Outlook 2000, UNEP Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
● ¯—, 2001e: Global Forest Resources Assess-
ment 2000. Main report, FAO Forestry Paper 140, FAO, Rome, Italy. ● ¯—, 2000: Forest Resources Assessment
● —, 1996: Livestock and Deforestation in
Central America in the 1980s and 1990s: A Policy Perspective, Center for International Forest Research, Bogor, Indonesia.
● UNOFOC, CICAFOC, UICN (Unión Nacio-
2000, FAO, Rome, Italy. ● Monge-Nájera, J., 1997: Moluscos de impor● Fernández-González, A., 1999: Sondeo ins-
titucional rápido sobre iniciativas de conservación en la Gran Talamanca, Proyecto WWF – Gran Talamanca (Costa Rica), Centro Científico Tropical, San Jose, Costa Rica.
tancia agrícola y sanitaria en el trópico: la experiencia costarricense, Editorial de la Universidad de Costa Rica, San Jose, Costa Rica. ● Morán, J.A., H. A. Galletti (editores), 2002:
● Geist, H.J., E.F. Lambin, 2001: What Drives
Tropical Deforestation? A Meta-Analysis of Proximate and Underlying Causes of Deforestation Based on Subnational Case Study Evidence, LUCC Report Series no. 4, Land Use and Cover Change International Project Office, New Lovaina, Belgium.
·
Deforestación en México, causas económicas, incidencia del comercio internacional, Centro Mexicano de Derecho Ambiental – Centro de Estudios del Sector Privado para el Desarrollo Sustentable, Mexico, D.F., Mexico.
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
nal de Forestería Comunal; Coordinadora Indígena y Campesina de Agroforestería Comunitaria Centroamericana; Unión Internacional para la Conservación de la Naturaleza), 2000: Comunidades y gestión de bosques en Mesoamérica, UNOFOC, CICAFOC y UICN, San Jose, Costa Rica.
Environment Outlook
Diversity of ecosystems and species
Biodiversity
B
iodiversity refers to the variability among all living organisms, on three basic levels: ecosystems, species and genes. The biodiversity of a country or a region in the world, marine or terrestrial, is reflected in the different types of ecosystems, the number of species, how species vary between one location and another and the number of endemisms, as well as subspecies and varieties or strains of the same species (UNEP, 2002). Latin America and the Caribbean contain an exceptional variety of species and genetic varieties, as well as ecosystems. This biological wealth is undoubtedly one of the region’s main assets, and its loss, one of its principal environmental problems. The greatest challenges are irreversible habitat loss or change, extinction, loss of genetic diversity, introduction of exotic species that damage native species, fragmentation of ecosystems and trade in endangered species.
The principal ecosystems in Latin America and the Caribbean, according to size (Dinerstein and others, 1995): ·
Broadleaf tropical forests, humid and dry(9.3 million km3; 42.8 per cent of the region’s territory).
·
Grassland (floodplains or montane), shrub and savannah (7.1 million km3 - 40.6 per cent of the territory).
·
Mediterranean shrub or chaparral and deserts (1.9 million km3; 11.5 per cent of the territory).
·
Temperate broadleaf forests and tropical or sub-tropical conifer forests (1.1 million km3; 5.1 per cent of the territory).
·
Mangroves (0.2 per cent of the territory).
Biodiversity in Latin America and the Caribbean (number of flora and vertebrate fauna species) 0
Brazil Colombia Mexico Venezuela Ecuador Peru Bolivia Costa Rica Argentina Panama Guatemala Paraguay Nicaragua Guyana Cuba Honduras Suriname Dominican Rep. Chile Haiti Belize Jamaica El Salvador Trinidad and Tobago Uruguay Source: WRI, 2000b.
63
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
Megadiverse Others
70000
Chapter
2
64
Latin America and the Caribbean
Endemism hot spots in Latin America and the Caribbean Worldwide, 25 endemism hot spots have been identified by their exceptional concentration of endemic vascular plants (at least 0.5 per cent of the world total), and because they suffer an exceptional loss of habitats (more than 70 per cent of their primary vegetation) (Myers and others, 2000). Vascular plants were selected as a guide because they have the best known taxonomy and form the basis for much of animal life. Together, the 25 hot spots contain more than 44 per cent of the world's vascular plants. The seven in Latin America and the Caribbean, which together have 16.2 per cent of the world's known endemic plants and 17.0 per cent of it vertebrates, are: the whole of Mesoamerica, the Caribbean, the Chocó-Darién region and western Ecuador, the Atlantic forests, the savannah of the Brazilian Cerrado, the tropical Andes, and central Chile. The variety and density of endemic species in these areas are a reflection of how biology has evolved in the Neotropics. Together, these hot spots harbour more than 46,000 vascular plants, 1,597 amphibians, 1,208 reptiles, 1,267 birds and 575 mammals, all endemic. Because it is insular, the Caribbean shows a high level of endemism, with 23.5 endemic plants for each 2 100 km , surpassing by 3, 4 and 12 times, respectively, the density in the Remaning % of Number of primary % of Brazilian Atlantic forest, the tropical Endemic endemic vegetation remaining ENDEMISM world Andes and Mesoamerica. protected plants HOT SPOTS
Although this is recognized as a useful tool to prioritize global conservation areas in situ, even its advocates confess that it excludes areas that may be important not only regionally or sub-regionally, but also globally. For example, Amazon is not one of the hot spots suggested by Myers and others (2000), not so much because it is not an important world biological diversity reserve, but because it does not have the loss of primary vegetation to be considered as such.
Tropical Andes
plants per 2 100 km
(% or original)
vegetation
20,000
6.7
6.3
25.0
25.3
Brazilian Atlantic forest
8,000
2.7
8.7
7.5
35.9
Caribbean
7,000
2.3
23.5
11.3
100.0
Mesoamerica
5,000
1.7
2.1
30.0
59.9
Brazilian Cerrado
4,400
0.014
1.2
20.0
6.2
Chocó/Darién/ Esmeraldas
2,250
0.007
3.5
24.0
26.1
Central Chile
1,605
0.0005
1.7
30.0
10.2
The principal ecosystems may be subdivided into large habitat types (biomass) and ecoregions (relatively well-defined units within the biomass); 178 ecoregions have been identified in Latin America and the Caribbean (Dinerstein and others, 1995; Olson and others, 2001). It is estimated that these ecosystems contain more than 40 per cent of the world’s vegetable and animal species (UNEP, 2000). Freshwater fish is a particularly good example of this wealth (WRI, 2000a). While North America has some 500 and Europe 150 fish species, some researchers estimate that Amazon harbours close to 2,500 species, or half the world’s total, although many ·
total
have still not been described scientifically. This diversity makes the Amazon region the richest deposit of freshwater fish in the world (Zimmerman, 1997). In Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Mexico, Peru and Venezuela, 190,000 of the world’s 300,000 known vascular plants have been identified (a third of the world total are in Brazil and Colombia) (Mittermeier and others, 1999). These six countries are part of the group of nations that, worldwide, has been identified as having biological megadiversity; together, they harbour between 60 and 70 per cent of all forms of life (CONABIO, 1998; CCAD, 2003). Their topography, climate variety, geology and biology have contributed to a mosaic of
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
many and diverse small-scale environmental conditions that support a large variety of habitats and life forms. Brazil is the country in the region with most species (57,704 species of plants, fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals), but some small Central American countries and Caribbean islands - Belize, Costa Rica, El Salvador, Haiti, Jamaica, Panama and Trinidad and Tobago (WRI, 2000b) - also have a high density. In Panama 732 bird species have been identified and in Costa Rica 600; there are 100 species of mammals known in Trinidad and Tobago and 3,308 plant species in Jamaica (WRI, 2000b). Endemism is the term for species that are only found naturally in a specific territory. Several countries and territories in Latin America and the Caribbean are distinguished not only because of the variety of their species but also for their high rate of endemism. Of the vascular plant species identified in Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Mexico, Peru and Venezuela, 37 per cent are endemic (Mittermeier and others, 1999). In the region, Mexico is outstanding in this respect; of 704 species of reptiles, 393 are endemic (56 per cent), 179 of 282 species of amphibians (62 per cent) and 139 of 439 species of mammals (32 per cent) (INE, 1995). The endemism of the tropical Andes (in Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia, the northeast of Chile, Paraguay
and the northeast of Argentina) and its great habitat losses (Myers and others, 2000) has made this place the world’s principal biodiversity hot spot.
Genetic resources diversity Genetic diversity, variations between the genes of individuals in a species, is the basis for evolutionary processes. Individual genetic differences determine different capacities to adapt to the environment; this explains why some individuals develop characteristics that allow them to adapt to the environment while others do not, and disappear. High levels of genetic diversity allow species to adapt to environmental changes, while low levels make it more likely they will become extinct (SCBD, 2001). An awareness of genetic diversity is an essential tool to satisfy basic human needs. Agricultural species are a reserve of genetic adaptability, and their loss endangers global food security when unforeseen environmental and economic changes occur (FAO, 2002; MMABI, 2002). Twenty-five per cent of the international pharmaceutical market consists of products based on biological material and, in 1999, world sales of products derived from traditional medicines reached US$4,300 million (WIPO, 1999).
Bioprospection and intellectual property: the conflict for frogs and analgesics in Ecuador The search for substances that control or eliminate pain must be as old as medicine itself, and with the passage of time it was discovered that an analgesic could have severe side effects, such as addiction to the drug. There can also be ecological and legal effects, as has been so well demonstrated by ABT-594, an analgesic derived from epibatidine, which is said to be 200 times more powerful than morphine. It is a compound of various substances extracted from the skin of a poisonous frog of the Latin American tropics (Epipedobates tricolor), and its habitat stretches from the Ecuadorian Andes to the north of Peru. Indigenous inhabitants in Ecuador poison the arrows of their blowpipes with this substance which has a very quick effect when it enters the hunted animal's circulatory system. The cause of the conflict is two-fold: appropriation of intellectual property and smuggling of a species of wildlife. As to intellectual property, the production of the analgesic is based on information on the physiological effects of the secretions which is the property of the indigenous and local communities. The discovery required trials with 750 frogs smuggled out of the country. This smuggling was exacerbated because this is the very species whose use as a source of genetic resources is prohibited by the Ecuadorian Forestry and Natural Areas Institute, a prohibition that has been in force since 1996. Ecuador has been a party to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Flora and Fauna (CITES) since 1975, so that the export and use of these frogs for commercial purposes requires a special licence that the manufacturer of the analgesic did not request. When it became public that the substance was being patented in the United States, and based on the Convention on Biological Diversity and on Ecuadorian laws, the Ecological Action Group requested that the patent be revoked, and that the benefits from the synthesized products be recognized and “shared fairly and equitably“. Source: GRAIN, 1998.
65
Chapter
2
66
Latin America and the Caribbean
Although some countries and indigenous communities have been using and protecting this biodiversity for thousands of years, they have so far derived very little benefit from it. Through a process recently described as biopiracy, private companies in developed countries take advantage of these communities’ knowledge and genetic resources, and exercise monopolistic control over them by means of patents or plant reproduction rights (CIPR, 2002). The resulting products sell for high prices in their domestic markets and in markets in developing countries, and provide continuous profits.
Threats to biodiversity Physical changes and habitat pollution, as well as direct damage to organisms, are among the main threats to biodiversity in the region. Changes in habitats are caused by excessive harvesting of renewable resources (water and forests, for example), mining, extraction of petroleum, infrastructure construction in coastal zones, forest fires, expansion of agriculture and raising livestock. Pollution comes from agrochemical products, urban and industrial waste, and sewage. Finally, the introduction of exotic species and illegal wildlife trade directly affects organisms.
Converting habitats Regions with their own climates, flora and fauna, like the Chaco or the Cerrado, are called ecoregions. As a result of conversion and loss of habitats, 31 of 178 ecoregions in Latin America and the Caribbean are critically endangered, 51 are endangered and 55 are vulnerable. Together these represent 77 per cent of the total (Dinerstein and others, 1995). Only 4.5 per cent of the ecoregions can be defined as relatively intact. A significant number of ecoregions are critically endangered or endangered in northern Mexico, Central America, the Caribbean, the northern Andes and eastern South America. There have been very serious changes in habitats in Central American forests, the Chaco, the savannah ecosystems of the Brazilian Cerrado, the Mediterraneantype shrub of the Pacific coast and the Brazilian Atlantic coast forests (Dinerstein and others 1995; Mittermeier and others, 1999). For example, the Cerrado — Brazil’s second largest biomass after the Amazon rainforest — that covers approximately two million square kilometres, was mainly used for extensive cattle raising until 40 years ago. Now nearly 47 per cent of its natural vegetation has been converted into grassland, cropland, dams, urban settlements and degraded areas. The main cash crops – besides grassland – are soybeans, maize, rice, coffee and beans. Only one per cent of the Cerrado is under any type of protection (Klink and others, 1995).
82.7 million hectares (ha) in 1990 to 73million ha in 2000 (almost 971 000 ha of forests annually), with a deforestation rate of 1.25 per cent annually — the highest in the region, and almost six times the global rate (FAO, 2000). The biggest losses were in Mexico (6.3 million ha) and Nicaragua (1.2 million ha); Belize, Nicaragua and El Salvador suffered the greatest relative losses of, respectively, about 20.9 and 37.3 per cent of the 1990 forest cover. The conversion and loss of habitats have a direct impact on the vulnerability and extinction of the species they contain. For example, critical sites in Mexico where almost half of all migratory birds (Hernández and others, 2000) take refuge during the northern hemisphere’s winter are endangered by pollution, deforestation and other land use changes (UNEP, 2000; de Alba, 2001).
Species threatened or endangered with extinction Most of the species endangered or threatened with extinction are found in countries with the most biodiversity, including Mexico, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador and Peru. Four of these countries —Brazil, Colombia, Peru and Mexico— harbour more than 75 per cent of the continent’s endangered bird species (BirdLife International, 2000). Between 1996 and 2000 the total number of endangered animal species grew from four per cent in Mexico and Peru to 10 per cent in Ecuador, 11 per cent in Colombia and 13 per cent in Brazil (Hilton-Taylor, 2000). In Peru alone, the number of threatened or endangered species rose from 162 in 1990 to 222 in 1999 (CONAM, PNUMA, 2001). However, the degree of danger varies: 12 per cent are in danger of actual extinction, 21 per cent are “vulnerable”, 27 per cent are classified as “scarce species” and no determination has been made about the remaining 40 per cent (CONAM, PNUMA, 2001). In Costa Rica, another country in the megadiverse group, barely two per cent of known species are endangered or threatened with extinction, but the situation is becoming alarming in the case of freshwater fish: practically all 135 known species are endangered to a greater or lesser extent (MINAE, PNUMA, 2001). Mexico accounts for 5.2 per cent of the species extinguished worldwide over the past 400 years: 15 species of plants and 32 species of vertebrates (CONABIO, 1998). The sea cow (Phocoena sinus), for example, is now only found in the northern part of the Gulf of California. It is estimated that in 1997 only 567 remained, mainly due to accidental fishing - it can be confused with fish or gets caught in shrimp nets (WWF, 2003b).
The Mesoamerican forest area was reduced from
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
67
Endangered animal species 450 Latin America and the Caribbean
South America
Mesoamerica
Caribbean
400
350 Vulnerable 300 Endangered 250 Critically endangered
Chapter
200
2
150
100
50
Mammals threatened or endangered
Amphibians
Reptiles
Fish
Venezuela
Mexico
0-8
0 - 12 13 - 27
Mammals
Birds threatened or endangered
Venezuela
Mexico
Birds
Amphibians
Reptiles
Fish
Mammals
Birds
Amphibians
Reptiles
Fish
Mammals
Birds
Amphibians
Reptiles
Fish
Mammals
Birds
0
Bolivia
9 - 21 22 - 39
28 - 63 64 - 140
Bolivia
Argentina
40 - 113
Argentina
Note: The colour represents the number of species threatened in each country in 2000. The dark area in pie charts represents the fauna species within all species threatened at the national level in sample countries. Source: Hilton-Taylor, 2000.
68
Latin America and the Caribbean
Trade in species Judging only by declared import values, probably underestimated, world trade in wild animals and plants (alive or as products), amounts to about US$159,000 million annually (Cook and others, 2002). It has been calculated that a quarter of this trade is illegal, making it the second largest illegal trade in the world, after drugs (WWF, 2003a). The value of the animal, which rarely is more than US$200 in the country of origin, may easily reach US$10,000 on the international market. One tordo chaqueño (charrúa, guira-hú or melro) bird, Gnorimopsar chopi, may be bought in southern Brazil for US$150 but, once in the United States, it sells for US$13,000. A tamarind monkey or golden-headed tití, Leontopithecus chrysomelas, is worth US$180 in Brazil and US$1,500 in Europe (Ecoportal, 2002). Countries in Latin America and the Caribbean are among the biggest exporters of wild organisms to consumer countries, especially the United States and the European Union (Cook and others, 2002). One estimate suggests that South America provides 47 per cent of animals illegally captured in the world; 37 per cent come from Brazil, the country with the world’s greatest biodiversity, and the rest from Peru, Argentina, Venezuela, Paraguay, Bolivia and Colombia (Ecoportal, 2002). It is estimated that illegal trade from Brazil represents an annual value of US$1,000 million, a tenth of the world total (UNEP, 2002). In Mexico, at least one of each five wildlife export cargoes checked by Customs in April 2002 was illegal, according to the Federal Attorney General’s Office for Environmental Protection (Ecoportal, 2002). Approximately half the cactus native to the Chihuahua desert in Mexico and confiscated in Europe and the United States, are protected from international trade by CITES (Robbins, 2003). In Colombia, smuggled organisms are sent to large cities and neighbouring Amazon countries, whence they are re-exported (MMA, 2000). In 2001, specimens protected by international conventions and worth almost five million US dollars were illegally traded in Chile; the main sources are in Peru and Bolivia, countries popular among traffickers because of their rich biodiversity. The number of organisms confiscated in a year suggests that, worldwide, vertebrates and plants are the main victims of illegal trade (Cook and others, 2002): primates (230,000), wild plants (1.1 million), live birds (1.1 million) and live reptiles (3.7 million). The pattern is not necessarily the same throughout the region. In Colombia, for example, confiscations indicate the following percentages of animal groups: birds (44.6 per cent), mammals (31.0 per cent), reptiles (16.8 per cent), fish (0.5 per cent) and crustaceans (0.1 per cent). A large number of mammals are primate and feline species, all considered to be critically endangered. Live examples ·
represent between 80 and 95 per cent, but there is also trafficking in stuffed animals, skins and various other products (MMA, 2000).
Introduction of exotic species Human beings can also dramatically change the distribution of species in an ecosystem. The introduction, by accident or design, of exotic organisms, has intensified with the boom in sea and air transport all over the world. Invading exotic species do not always manage to establish themselves immediately, but their populations could eventually explode and threaten ecosystems, habitats and native species (UICN, SSC, 2000), as changes in ecosystems make conditions favourable. In Latin America and the Caribbean examples include the introduction into freshwater ecosystems of exotic fishes mainly linked to aquaculture such as tilapia or trout. Invasion by aquatic plants such as water hyacinth and tifa has been detected in some wetlands. The problem is more marked in islands and isolated ecosystems like cloud forests, coastal habitats, high mountains, lakes and lagoons (UICN, SSC, 2000).
Genetic impoverishment of domestic species Human food comes from plants and domestic animals, although in some places fishing and other wild sources play an important role. The principal domestic species originated in areas with a high degree of biodiversity, ecologically varied (almost all mountainous zones) and with more advanced and diversified cultures. For example, two of the six hypothetical centres of origin of the principal cultivated plants are in Latin America and the Caribbean (FAO, 2002). Human beings have used thousands of species for food over many thousands of years, and domesticated a large number of them, but we now see genetic impoverishment because only relatively few are cultivated or bred. The impressive number of varieties of maize cultivated by the ancient Mexicans, as well as many varieties of potato that used to be seen in Andean markets, are long gone. At the beginning of the 21st century, only 150 vegetable species were cultivated, and only four produce more than half the food for human consumption (FAO, 2002; Sarukhán, 2002). The same applies to animals: of the 50,000 known species of mammals and birds, only some 30 have been widely bred and 15 account for more than 90 per cent of world livestock production. In the past 15 years, 300 of the 6,000 livestock species defined by FAO have been extinguished. At present, 1,350 of these species run the risk of extinction, and an average of two species disappear every week. Selection means that very few domesticated organisms, whether plants or animals, can still survive in nature without human intervention (FAO, 2002). There is
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
a natural, and very important, reason why genetic impoverishment must be prevented: to maintain the evolutionary potential of species and, thus, their capacity to adapt and survive (CONABIO, 1998). Similarly, mixed crops may provide better harvests because their genetic variety acts as a barrier against diseases and predators. Genetic impoverishment is indirectly associated with the relationship between international trade in agricultural products and the sustainability of the environment. Increasingly impoverished domesticated biodiversity earns more profits than wild biodiversity. However, both types require investment to resist, for example, a mutant virus which (because of a lack of genetic variability) could deal a severe blow to the dairy industry by finishing off a variety of dairy cattle The wild relatives of cattle and other domestic varieties make up the genetic reservoir that could prevent this. Domestic and wild varieties need to be kept in a delicate balance between facilitating trade and conserving biodiversity.
Transgenetic contamination Genetic diversity is the basis of biotechnology, particularly in the case of genetic engineering, which is generating great changes in agriculture, industry, medicine and even legislation (Munich Re Group, 2002). However, taking biotechnological advantage of natural diversity may eventually endanger it through “genetic contamination”. Natural genes pass uncontrolled from one species to another with no problem. That modified genes might do so is a real risk. The possible transgenetic contamination of Mexican maize is a good example of this con-
cern about the intromission of modified genes into domestic varieties and their wild relatives. One of the main dangers is that intromission would affect their characteristics, placing in danger a biodiversity essential for humanity’s food security. In Mexican maize fields in the remote mountains of Oaxaca, pieces of DNA produced by genetic engineering were detected (Quist and Chapela, 2001). The study was attacked with the argument that it was the result of a biased test and a misinterpretation of the literature (Metz and Fütterer, 2002), an accusation denied by the authors of the original study (Quist and Chapela, 2002). Although the debate continues (Aldhous, 2002), a cause for concern is the lack of cooperation from transnational companies that dominate the market (on the pretext of trade secrets) ; indeed, an attempt was made to disallow the study just before a meeting of the Convention on Biological Diversity (The Hague, Netherlands, 8-26 April 2002). There is a widely-held belief among geneticists and plant improvement specialists that contamination of traditional crops is inevitable (AGETC, 2002; ISIS, 2002; Pearce, 2002). Mexico’s National Commission on Biodiversity Knowledge and Use has reported that two independent studies found large-scale contamination in varieties of maize planted close to highways (ISIS, 2002; Pearce, 2002). Apart from the possible environmental consequences of transgenetic pollution, this causes concern about the medium- and long-term effects of genetically modified food on human health. Again, this debate polarises positions and touches on large commercial interests; until there is scientific consensus on the subject, precaution is advisable (Butler, 2002).
Dangers of introducing new species to the islands Implicit in human occupation of a region is the transfer of plants and animals, which often become established in the new territories. Almost always the introduction of species to new zones is uncontrolled and may produce serious alterations in ecosystems. When the new territories are islands, the consequences are even worse because, in most cases, there are no natural predators that control the growth of the introduced populations. Also, due to the isolation in which they have evolved, island species have not developed the defence mechanisms they need and are very vulnerable to attack by new predators. Furthermore, island species generally have low reproduction rates and long life cycles, so that their populations are smaller than continental populations and it is more probable that they will become extinct. There is a serious problem with fauna introduced to the islands: it is calculated that 75 per cent of the 484 species registered as extinct in the world since the 17th century were species endemic to islands and that 67 per cent of the extinctions are totally or partially due to introduced species. An example of this danger is Isabel Island, off the coast of the state of Nayarit in Mexico, where rats and cats were 2 introduced more than 80 years ago. The density of cats is now one of the highest, 113 cats per km , of any island in the world and they have had a serious impact on bird populations. Of the various bird species that nest on the island, an endemic tern (Stena fuscata), is the most affected; because it nests on the ground it is easy prey for the animals so that, in the absence of control measures, it has a an uncertain future. Source: CONABIO, 1998.
69
Chapter
2
70
Latin America and the Caribbean
Domesticating and breeding Paca (Agouti paca) Paca or tepezcuinte (Agouti paca), is a rodent found from Mexico to Paraguay and the southern part of Brazil, usually in woody areas close to freshwater. It lives in burrows in the ground and rests during the day to become active at night time when it goes in search of small plants, fruit and seeds. As it weighs up to 12 kg and its meat has an excellent taste, it is a good candidate for domestication. It has been suggested that its meat be used to feed rural populations which, for one reason or another, are unable to keep larger animals. Normally it is hunted for its meat; this has affected wild populations and led to the establishment of experimental captive breeding programmes in countries such as Costa Rica and Panama. It is hard to breed tepezcuintes: they form monogamous couples that reproduce slowly, are aggressive in defence of their territory and, therefore, do not tolerate overcrowding, and there are cases of cannibalism and infanticide. By being aware of how the young learn, Panama has been able to achieve an artificial tolerance to captive conditions. In Costa Rica, this has been done successfully for several generations and has enabled veterinarians to learn more about the animals; the cost of keeping them has taken an unexpected turn by selling the meat to luxury restaurants instead of using it as food for rural communities. Source: FAO, 1995.
Policy responses Responses range from national initiatives, generally connected to the establishment of protected areas, to the adoption of multilateral and regional environmental agreements which have recently stressed the subject of access to biodiversity resources. The establishment of new protected areas and better management of existing ones are among the most significant actions taken in the region to conserve biodiversity. There are 65 UNESCO-designated biosphere reserves in Latin America and the Caribbean, about 15 per cent of the global total of 411 reserves. In the last three decades of the 20th century, although the number of protected areas almost doubled, their extension only increased by 50 per cent, indicating a trend
to establish smaller areas. In the latter part of the 1990s, a total of 148 million ha of very varied ecosystems, classified under different management categories, received some type of protection (WRI, 2001); some countries have created extensive maritime-terrestrial protected areas, as Ecuador did with the Galapagos Islands. There are countries where a large proportion of the territory is protected, and Ecuador is again an example (42 per cent), followed by Venezuela (35 per cent), Belize (20 per cent) and Panama (18.8 per cent). In contrast, other countries in the region have a low proportion of protected territory: Jamaica (0.1 per cent), Haiti (0.3 per cent) and Uruguay (0.3 per cent) (WRI, 2000b; OdDUCR, PNUMA/ORPALC, 2001). In spite of advances in conservation in natural conditions (or in situ), this strategy needs to be perfected. In
Biotic inventory: a Caribbean necessity In the Caribbean, less than 10 per cent of original island vegetation is still intact. Worse still, only a part of that 10 per cent is protected by parks and reserves. As the small intact areas are generally found in the smaller islands, they are under greater pressure. In addition, the smaller the island, the more endemic species it has so that there is less margin for error in maintaining the biotic heritage of small islands than there is in preserving it in larger islands or on continents. To conserve and take advantage of this biotic heritage, an inventory is needed to identify existing resources. However, economic and conservation decisions are haphazard and pose a serious risk of errors and damage to the islands' heritage. Therefore, the need for a biotic inventory for the small Caribbean islands is urgent, in particular because the importance to global biodiversity of the species involved is out of proportion to the size of the islands. A recent analysis of vascular plants and biodiversity of land vertebrates classified these islands as one of the three locations whose biodiversity is most endangered, according to Mittermeier and others (1999). Source: Ivie, 2001.
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
general, national protected areas are still not representative, since they neither include the countries’ ecosystems nor protect all the organisms that need protecting. Also, as they are not connected, seasonal migration routes and the normal genetic flow between subpopulations and populations are often interrupted. Areas that have significant protection are often too small compared to actual needs, not only as to whether they are representative of the ecosystem, but in more organic aspects such as the minimum area required to maintain viable populations, especially in the case of predator vertebrates. To the problems of representation and size is added the sharp contrast between the legal situation of natural protected areas and their actual situation, so that – it is said – they are really fictitious areas that exist only on paper. However, a quantitative inventory of the efficiency of 93 protected areas in tropical countries, including Belize, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Mexico, Paraguay and Peru, found that — in spite of their limitations — most parks are successful in preventing land being opened up and, to a lesser extent, are efficient in putting a brake on logging, hunting, fires and grazing (Bruner and others, 2001). Just as the problem of representation has been addressed by increasing protected areas, an attempt is being made to link them by establishing biological corridors. These corridors are the result of new trends that favour protecting the whole ecosystem and integrating protected areas and agricultural, forestry and pasture land. Thus, people who live in or close to protected areas may join in conservation efforts by encouraging the restoration of the landscape and the maintenance of environmental goods and services. Biological corridors connect fragments of natural and managed forests so that fauna can move between them; this helps to keep their populations viable by preventing the in-breeding that can lead to genetic defects. Various corridors have been proposed and others are already in existence, such as the Mesoamerican Biological Corridor and the Amazon/Andes interface in the south of Peru and adjacent parts of Bolivia. The Mesoamerican Biological Corridor is a system of land regulation that connects buffer and multipleuse zones to the Central American Protected Areas System. It covers almost 30 per cent of Mesoamerican territory (including 19 per cent of Mexican territory) (CBM, 2001; OdD-UCR, 2003). It is expected to have a positive effect on problems like deforestation, forest fires, illegal hunting and fishing, indiscriminate extraction of basic natural resources and the fragmentation of the main protected areas in the eight Mesoamerican countries. In addition to strictly-protected areas, it includes restored ecosystems and private land whose proprietors will make voluntary ecofriendly use of the resources. The creation of the corridor was formally guaranteed by the Central American presidents (including the presi-
71
dents of Belize and Panama) at the Presidential Summit in Panama on 12 July 1997, and is a priority of the Central American Alliance for Sustainable Development. Its implementation is directed by the Central American Integration System in collaboration with the Government of Mexico and it receives international support (CBM, 2001). Buffer zones work with the corridors as a form of potentially important land regulation. They are spaces around the protected areas where only limited use is made of resources, because difficult access has prevented the market economy from penetrating. Whether legally constituted or not, buffer zones combine the objectives of conservation and sustainable use of resources. They may be attractive for future policies because it can be shown that they have contributed to the conservation of many renewable natural resources (Gierhake, 2002). Sustainable use of a resource has been demonstrated to be the best means of protecting and conserving it. It is therefore important to develop this biodiversity conservation component so that it can be incorporated in sustainable production processes. Experiments of this type are being fostered in various countries in the region, such as Brazil and Costa Rica.
Number of protected areas, total area and percentage of protected national territory in 2002 Percentage of sub-regional territory protected 20 15 10 5 0 Caribbean
Total Latin America and the Caribbean: 213.54 millions of ha (10.58%) (2,675 zones)
Mesoamerica
South America
South America: 182.89 million of ha (10.43%)
Mesoamerica: 26.39 millions of ha (10.91%)
526 zones
Caribbean: 535 4.26 millions zones of ha (18.62%)
Source: UNEP and WCMC, 2002.
1,614 zones
Chapter
2
72
Latin America and the Caribbean
The other important component in biodiversity environmental policies is the implementation of global, regional or sub-regional multilateral agreements. The implementation plan approved at the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg (South Africa) in 2002 includes among its goals achieving, by 2010, a significant reduction in the present rate of biodiversity loss. This plan reflects concerns expressed in a great many multilateral environmental agreements (MEAs), with biodiversity at their heart. Among the principal MEAs in which the region is involved are the global conventions on: ·
the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as Waterfowl Habitat (Ramsar), 1971;
·
the Convention on the Protection of World Cultural and Natural Heritage (World Heritage), 1972;
·
the Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals (CMS), 1979; and
·
the 1992 Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD).
There is also an important set of regional or subregional MEAs related to biodiversity. The most important of these is the Convention on the Protection of Flora, Fauna and Natural Scenic Beauty in the Countries of the Americas (1940). Among the main sub-regional agreements are ·
the Convention on the Conservation and Management of Vicuña (1979),
·
the Convention on the Protection of the Marine Environment and Coastal Areas of the south-eastern Pacific (1981),
·
the Cartagena Convention on the Protection and Development of the Marine Environment in the Greater Caribbean (1983) and its protocol on protected areas and wildlife (in force since 2000),
·
the Convention on the Conservation of Biological Diversity and the Protection of Priority Wildlife Areas in Central America (1992) and
·
the Central American Regional Convention on the Management and Conservation of Natural Forest Ecosystems and the Development of Forestry Plantations (1993).
Although ratification of global MEAs has been high in the region, with 75 per cent of the countries adhering to most of them (with the exception of the agreement on migratory species, which only a fifth of the countries have accepted), in practice their application differs from country to country. The CBD and CITES are of particular interest, because of the range of their cover.
·
The CBD, in particular, is considered to be a framework convention; it expresses a national and international commitment to the overall conservation and sustainable use of ecosystems, species and genetic resources, as well as fair and equitable participation in the benefits. In the region, the CBD or its objectives have been applied either by including it in general regulations (Brazil, Costa Rica, Peru and Venezuela), or by means of sectoral laws (Cuba, Costa Rica, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua and Panama). In 1994 Brazil established a National Programme on Biological Diversity. In Peru the Law on the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biological Diversity, which entered into force in 1997, covers most of the commitments of the CBD. Between 1998 and 2000, Nicaragua, Guatemala, Panama and Mexico also completed their country studies and formulated national biodiversity strategies. Costa Rica and Venezuela have had laws on biological diversity since 1996 and 2000, respectively. It is hoped that the nine Caribbean countries now preparing national biodiversity strategies – Antigua and Barbuda, Belize, Dominica, Guyana, Jamaica, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Suriname and Trinidad and Tobago – will support the implementation of the CBD with legislation, clear institutional mechanisms and adequate resources (UNEP, 2000). Putting the CBD into practice depends to a great extent on national and international financing. This includes the biodiversity funds of agencies such as the World Bank, the IDB, other international organisations, the Global Environment Facility, non-governmental organizations and bilateral cooperation agencies. By February 2000, the GEF had supported seven regional and 84 national projects on biodiversity in Latin America and the Caribbean, all declared to be in tune with the goals and objectives of the CBD (GEF, 2000). As part of the mandate of the CBD, the Conference of the CBD Contracting Parties held a meeting in Cartagena, Colombia, in February 1999 on the subject of biosecurity, resulting in a signed protocol. After arduous negotiations, the CBD Protocol on Biosafety was adopted by consensus in January 2000 in Montreal, Canada and, in May 2000, was opened for signature in Nairobi, Kenya. It has already been signed by 60 countries and it will enter into force when ratified by 50 countries. The protocol will regulate transboundary movements of genetically-modified live organisms, with clear measures to prevent their intentional introduction into the environment. It will also protect traditional agriculture and wild fauna and flora species against genetically-modified organisms. The most controversial items in Cartagena and Montreal were the commercial aspects of applying the protocol, especially the demand (on the principle of prior informed consent) that products with modified live organisms be clearly labelled, and handled differently to those without them. It obliges exporting countries to
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
73
Regional action within the CITES framework The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna y Flora (CITES) entered into force in 1975. To prevent international trade in certain excessively harvested species of flora and fauna, the convention established international prohibitions on endangered species (Appendix I), as well as regulations for those that might be endangered because of excessive or inappropriate trade (Appendix II). Appendix III lists species subject to national self-regulation and that require export permits from the regulating state and certificates of origin issued by other exporting states. At their biennial meetings, the parties review the list of species in each appendix and, by a two-thirds majority, decide which to include in Appendices I and II. Any contracting state may have reserves about one or several of the species included in these appendices, in which case they are considered as not being subject to regulations established for those particular species. At present, the lists include some 30 000 species, of which 25 000 are plants. More than 800 species of flora and fauna can be found in Appendix I, about 29 000 in Appendix II, and 230 in Appendix III. Two types of organisms in the region that have been paid particular attention within the framework of CITES are sea turtles in the Caribbean and mahogany in Mesoamerica and South America. In 1977, the parties to CITES agreed to prohibit international trade in the six species of Caribbean sea turtles, considered as under treat of extinction (three of them critically endangered) by the World Wildlife Fund. National compliance in the sub-region has differed widely, with high levels of concern, resources and compliance in some countries, but with very low levels in others. Only a third of the region's countries have ratified the InterAmerican Convention on Protection and Conservation of Sea Turtles (2001), the only international agreement in this field. It is estimated that Caribbean trade in sea turtles and their harvesting outside the sub-region continue, although they are dropping. Accidental catches predominate, above all because sea turtles are already so scarce that there is little profit to be had from catching them commercially.
Chapter
CANADA
2 EUROPE
UNITED STATES
MEXICO BELIZE GUATEMALA
CENTRAL AMERICA
NICARAGUA
Trade between
Central America
ASIA
PERU
BRAZIL
Flow of big leafed mahogany
BOLIVIA In the case of mahogany (Swietenia out of Latin America and the macrophylla), the agreement to regulate its Caribbean (1997) international trade was adopted at the twelfth conference of the parties (COP-12), held in Chile in November 2002. The other two American species were already included although there is practically no trade in them because overharvesting has exhausted the supply. About 14 countries in the region export mahogany, mainly to North America and Europe. In 1998 the United States imported about 60 per cent of the total volume, which originated mainly in Brazil (45 per cent), Peru (31 per cent) and Bolivia (17 per cent).
In 1998 Brazil, the world's principal exporter of mahogany in that year, decided to include it in Appendix III of CITES, and in 2001 prohibited its logging and export; Bolivia, Costa Rica and Mexico have also included the species in that Appendix. Exports from Bolivia have dropped since it decided to restrict logging, while Peruvian exports have increased since the government gave concessions for it to be harvested in the Biabo-Cordillera Azul region. Until Nicaragua and Guatemala proposed including Appendix II in the COP-12, most illegal exports came from Brazil, Peru and Bolivia and, to a lesser extent, from Central America. There has been good experience in certifying sustainable harvesting of mahogany in Brazil, Guatemala, Honduras and Mexico, in the three last-mentioned countries under the auspices of the Forest Stewardship Council. Sources: Fleming, 2001: Robbins, 2000.
74
Latin America and the Caribbean
give prior information to importing countries about the characteristics of these organisms. This implies particular attention to strengthening institutional capacity to apply these new control functions, with a view to protecting wild aquatic, marine and agricultural biodiversity in the region. An additional aspect closely linked with the CBD, on which it is sought to establish agreements, is access to genetic resources and equitable benefit sharing. This is one of the subjects that have recently caused most debate about standards and public policies, both nationally and internationally. The ultimate objectives of the CBD include “fair sharing in benefits derived from the use of genetic resources”, through adequate access mechanisms. The International Treaty on Phytogenetic Resources for Food and Agriculture, approved in 2001, recognises the rights of farmers in centres of origin and
diversity based on their contribution to conservation, improvement and availability of resources. These rights include their participation in the adoption of decisions and the “fair and equitable” sharing of benefits (FAO, 2001). In February 2003, the treaty had been signed by 13 countries in the region although none of them had yet ratified it. However, various countries —including those of the Andean Community of Nations (CAN) — have already formalised many of its principles (SEMARNAT, 2002a). Guatemala, for example, has established its own protection systems for genetic resources, and uses them to protect intellectual property. The Andean countries (Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and Venezuela) have developed a common legislation within CAN, in 1996 approving Decision 391 on a Common Access to Genetic Resources Regime, making it the cornerstone for
National response initiatives: the cases of Colombia and Mexico Colombia and Mexico have had good experience in designing and implementing public policies, with private sector participation, on the conservation and sustainable use of biodiversity. In Colombia, the Green Markets Programme (PMV) seeks to respond to the world demand for “ecofriendly” products that has grown between 20 and 30 per cent annually (more than for traditional products). This is a good opportunity for countries with great environmental wealth to reduce the environmental impact of productive activities and generate resources that satisfy local development needs. The PMV was created by the Ministry of the Environment to provide incentives for the production of environmentally friendly goods and services or of sustainable production to compete in national and international markets. It is expected to provide self financing for activities that help protect the environment, and allow consumers to choose products that not only protect the environment, but are also healthier than traditional products. In Mexico, two notable initiatives have been developed in the field of biodiversity knowledge and awareness. In 1992 the National Commission on Biodiversity Knowledge and Use was created as an cross-sectoral commission whose main objectives were to: set up and maintain the National Biodiversity Information System; support projects and studies on awareness and use of biodiversity; provide advice to government institutions and to other sectors; undertake special projects; disseminate information about biological wealth; follow up on international conventions and provide services to the public. Outstanding among the commission's achievements are: the creation of the Mexican Biodiversity Information Network; the automated system to detect hot spots; the programme to conserve biodiversity priority regions; the preparation of the “BIOTIC” information management system; and the publication of more than 190 titles. The commission is also the scientific authority for CITES and the focal point for the Clearing House Mechanism, OSACTT, IGT and other groups of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). In 1994 the Mexican Fund for the Conservation of Nature (FMCN) was established as a private civil association to conserve Mexico's biodiversity and promote the sustainable use of natural resources. The FMCN was capitalized with a contribution of US$10 million from the Mexican government and US$19.5 million from the United State International Development Agency. In 1997, the FMCN received a donation of US$16.5 million from the Global Environment Facility (GEF) to establish a fund to protect natural areas and it supports the management of 10 priority protected areas. These resources have permitted an additional US$14.5 million to be collected, including patrimonial contributions from the Mexican government and private foundations, for certain natural protected areas. A second GEF donation includes a project costing US$31.1 million, of which US$9.5 million of the patrimonial funds were spent in May 2002 on four additional natural protected areas. Sources: CONABIO, 1998; FMCN, 2001; FUNBIO, 2001; MMA, 2002.
·
Chapter 2: State of the Environment in Latin America and the Caribbean, 1972-2002
Environment Outlook
national policies and norms on access to genetic resources and benefit sharing. Bolivia’s Superior Decree 24676 (1997) very specifically regulates Decision 391. Colombia and Venezuela, for their part, are applying the decision without additional norms or regulations. Ecuador and Peru are in the process of approving regulations on access to genetic resources. The Regional Biodiversity Strategy of CAN is designed to define guidelines and take joint action regarding access. Both CAN and Costa Rica require informed consent about the source before issuing intellectual property rights on genetic resources (CIPR, 2002). These initiatives will probably be reflected in much of the region’s future legislation.
75
In the region, and particularly in megadiverse countries, some of the obstacles to access to resources and benefits are: ·
vast genetic resources have already left those countries (for example, in botanical gardens and collections);
·
it is hard to enforce access regulations in one country if other countries do not have them (in cases where resources are shared or are in more than one country);
·
practical difficulties in controlling access;
Chapter
First Ministerial Meeting of Like-Minded Megadiverse Countries In February 2002 Mexico convened the first Ministerial Meeting of Like-Minded Megadiverse Countries. The meeting was attended by ministers of the environment from Brazil, China, Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador, India, Indonesia, Kenya, Peru, South Africa and Venezuela, to establish agreements on the conservation and sustainable use of biodiversity and to seek coordination mechanisms on environmental policy. An additional objective was to present a common front at the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg. The meeting gave particular consideration to access to genetic resources and the fair distribution of benefits (including intellectual property and the respect and protection of traditional knowledge), the conservation and harvesting of biodiversity, biotechnology and bioprospection. Among the agreements reached –expressed in the Cancun Declaration– are the following: ·
To create the “Group of Like-Minded Megadiverse Countries” as a mechanism for consultation and cooperation to promote their interests and priorities related to the preservation and sustainable use of biological diversity to: coordinate efforts to present a common front at international fora dealing with biodiversity; promote in situ and ex situ conservation of biodiversity in the countries of origin; develop joint projects to make inventories of their resources; invest in the development and use of endogenous technologies to support local- level sustainable conservation of genetic materials and economic activities.
·
To ensure that the goods, services and benefits arising from the conservation and sustainable use of biological resources are utilized for the development of the populations, among other objectives seeking to improve food safety, solve health problems and preserve cultural integrity.
·
To jointly explore ways to exchange information and harmonize their respective national laws on the protection of biological diversity, including related knowledge as well as access to biological and genetic resources, and the sharing of benefits arising from their sustainable use.
·
To seek the creation of an international regime to effectively promote and safeguard the fair and equitable sharing of benefits arising from the use of biodiversity and its components.
·
To develop strategic projects and bilateral, regional and international agreements, within the framework of more effective South-South cooperation, for the conservation and sustainable use of biological diversity and genetic resources.
·
To encourage the current system of intellectual property rights to take into account traditional knowledge of biological diversity when evaluating requests for patents and other related rights.
·
To hold the first meeting of heads of state of the Group of Like-Minded Megadiverse Countries at the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg, South Africa.
Source: SEMARNAT, 2002b.
2
76
Latin America and the Caribbean
·
limited capacity to negotiate bioprospection projects;
·
lack of appropriate incentives to add value to resources within a country (and the passivity of national stakeholders);
·
difficulties in agreeing upon common positions in international negotiations;
·
pressure exercised by other negotiations (for example, the World Trade Organization); and
·
difficulties in effectively articulating the interests of indigenous communities.
To confront these obstacles, megadiverse countries in the region have begun policy and normative processes to legislate on the subject. At the same time, many academic institutions and private enterprises have adapted their access policies to the new reality of biological material. Access that was once free now requires, as a prior condition, information and transparency, negotiations on potential benefits, discussions on possible joint investments and the acceptance of other commitments with respect to each country’s norms, as well as the goodwill of the parties involved.
References ● AGETC (Action Group on Erosion, Technol-
● CONAM, PNUMA (Consejo Nacional del
● —, 1995: Guía FAO de Conservación N° 26,
ogy and Concentration), 2002: More on the Mexican GM Maize Scandal: Conquering Nature ... And Sidestepping the Debate Over Biotech and Biodiversity, AGETC, Winnipeg, Canada (in http://www.corpwatch.org/ bulletins/PBD.jsp?articleid=2229, consulted on 5 April 2003).
Ambiente; Programa de Naciones Unidas para el Medio Ambiente), 2001: Informe Nacional sobre el Estado del Medio Ambiente: GEO Perú 2000, CONAM y PNUMA, Lima, Peru.
FAO, Rome, Italy (in http://www.fao.org/ docrep/v9122s/v9122s12.htm, consulted on 4 April 2003). ● Fleming, E. H., 2001: Swimming Against the
Tide: Recent Surveys of Exploitation, Trade, and Management of Marine Turtles in the Northern Caribbean, TRAFFIC North America, Washington D.C., US.
● Cook, D., M. Robertos, J. Lowther, 2002:
than light”, in Nature, London, UK, volume 420, 730 - 731.
The International Wildlife Trade and Organised Crime: A review of the evidence and the role of the UK, World Wildlife Fund, Godalming, Surrey, UK.
● BirdLife International, 2000: Threatened
● de Alba, M.A., 2001: Guanajuato, cemen-
Birds of the World, Lynx Ediciones, Barcelona, Spain.
terio de aves migratorias (in http://www. cipe.org/pfc/recursos/articulos/2001/ art016.html, consulted on 21 June 2001).
(Fondo Mexicano para la Conservación de la Naturaleza), 2001: El Fondo Mexicano para la Conservación de la Naturaleza, FMCN, Mexico, D.F., Mexico (in www.fmcn.org, consulted on 4 April 2003).
● Dinerstein, E., D. Olson, D. Graham, A.
● FUNBIO (Fondo para la Biodiversidad Brasi-
leña), 2001: El Fondo para la Biodiversidad Brasileña, FUNBIO, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil (en www.funbio.org.br, consulted on 4 April 2003).
● Butler, D., 2002: “Europe gets tough on la-
Webster, S. Primm, M. Bookbinder, G. Ledec, 1995: A Conservation assessment of the terrestrial ecorregions of Latin America and the Caribbean, World Wildlife Fund and The World Bank, Washington, D.C., US.
belling genetically modified foodstuffs”, in Nature, London, UK, volume 418, 114.
● Ecoportal, 2002: Sudamérica, territorio favo-
● Aldhous, P., 2002: “Agribiotech: More heat
● FMCN
● Bruner, A.G., R. E. Gullison, R. E. Rice, G.
A. B. Fonseca, 2001: “Effectiveness of parks in protecting tropical biodiversity”, in Science, Washington D.C., US, volume 291, 125-128.
rito de los traficantes de animales, Ecoportal, B