Genital Autonomy
George C. Denniston · Frederick M. Hodges · Marilyn Fayre Milos Editors
Genital Autonomy Protecting Personal Choice
123
Editors George C. Denniston University of Washington Robbins Road 45 98358 Norland USA
Frederick M. Hodges University of Berkeley Post Office Box 5815 94705-0815 Berkeley USA
Marilyn Fayre Milos National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers San Anselmo California USA
[email protected]
ISBN 978-90-481-9445-2 e-ISBN 978-90-481-9446-9 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9 Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2010933645 © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010 No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Preface
Why would anyone object to circumcision? For that matter, why would anyone hold an international symposium on this subject? In those countries and cultures where circumcision is ubiquitous, most people would probably ask these questions when confronted with this book. Indeed, most people from circumcising cultures accept circumcision as normal, necessary, and good. These peoples cannot imagine that circumcision is a violation of human rights or that it is harmful to any degree. One might as well try to convince them that dentistry is a harmful violation of human rights. Fundamentally, most people in circumcising cultures condone circumcision not because they are evil, malicious, sadistic, or insane, but because they have been conditioned to believe that circumcision is good, desirable, and honorable. In cultures where circumcision is not the norm, however, an entirely different perspective emerges. People in (for want of a better word) “genitally intact” cultures are horrified at the idea that someone would cut off part of the genitals of another person—especially a baby. The act is seen as misguided at best and demented at worst. Where, then, does the truth lie? Can science provide objective answers? Most people—including most scientists—imagine that “science” can be likened to an impartial and omniscient calculating machine that emits absolute truths when questions are fed into it. Indeed, the mythos of “science” has come to replace the oracles of the ancients. The majority of intelligent and educated people in ancient Greece probably had as much faith in the oracle at Delphi as modern Westerners have in “science” today. Medical journals now occupy the space once reserved only for holy scriptures and are revered as sources of objective and inviolable truth. Instead of soothsayers and sacred texts, we have scientists and science journals that proclaim the newly discovered truths. The high level of credulity and absolute faith in the statements published in science journals does not appear to be threatened even when whistle blowers reveal evidence of fraud, data manipulation, scientific misconduct, cover-ups, and corruption (Vastag, 2006). Even though respected medical and science journals have made headline news for having published studies that used falsified data, the people’s trust and faith in these journals never wavers. The journals Science, The New England Journal of Medicine, the Journal of Clinical
v
vi
Preface
Oncology, Immunity, the Journal of Experimental Medicine, and The Annals of Internal Medicine are among the top journals to have published fraudulent studies in recent years (Black, 2006). How many published studies based on fraudulent data go undetected? One meta-analysis found that a pooled weighted average of 1.97% (N = 7, 95% CI: 0.86–4.45) of scientists admitted to having fabricated, falsified, or modified data or results at least oncea serious form of misconduct by any standardand up to 33.7% admitted other questionable research practices. In surveys asking about the behavior of colleagues, admission rates were 14.12% (N = 12, 95% CI: 9.91–19.72) for falsification, and up to 72% for other questionable research practices (Fanelli, 2009). We trust the praiseworthy scientific method and have faith that self-styled scientists adhere to the scientific method when producing their scientific studies, but should we? Most people do not feel qualified to judge whether a published paper in a science journal has adhered to the scientific method. Instead, we spare ourselves the difficult task of critical thinking and instead have faith that the paper was produced honestly. This faith, however, is at the crux of the circumcision debate. It is interesting to note that circumcision is usually ubiquitous in countries where science education in the public schools is weakest. In third-world Muslim countries, where circumcision is endemic and in the United States, where mass circumcision was forced on the populace starting after World War II, the teaching of science in the public schools is far less adequate than it is in European public school systems. As predicted, in Europe, circumcision is practically unheard of among native Europeans. Could this be because the Europeans are better educated in science and therefore better able to judge the merits of a claim made by a medical doctor? Is this because Americans have blind faith in doctors and Europeans are more skeptical? When doctors claim that the results of their research prove that circumcision can prevent AIDS, most Americans blindly accept the veracity of this claim. Obviously, without an adequate education in science, they do not feel themselves qualified to question either the methodology or the results. Moreover, not only are the claims unchallenged, but the doctor himself remains unchallenged. Few laymen question his motivations. After all, since circumcision is a good thing, any doctor claiming that circumcision is beneficial must be a good doctor. It would not occur to the average layman that a doctor could deliberately be perpetrating a hoax or conspiring to commit scientific fraud. We like to imagine that the scientific method has the power to strip away any and all personal biases, motivations, or dark and disturbing psychosexual impulses from the researchers. Unfortunately, it does not have this power. Human psychology, especially when disturbed, unbalanced, and determined, can have a corrosive and corrupting effect on any endeavor, including science and religion. The papers presented in this volume address these topics from a variety of angles. They are each infused with a healthy skepticism that questions and dissects the true motivations of the doctors, witch doctors, and “holy men” who promote and profit from circumcision. With the greatest compassion, many of our authors also examine the blind faith that the victims have in the perpetrators. It is difficult to convince
Preface
vii
someone that everything he has been told about circumcision is a lie. It is equally difficult to convince a man that the body parts taken from him and destroyed might have been of value. Nevertheless, our authors do not shy away from the challenge of gently awakening the world to the fact that much of the world’s people have been deceived and abused at the hands of a small group of perpetrators who have alternately used science and religion as a smokescreen to hide the truth in order to trick their victims into compliance. It is our hope that readers of this volume will have their eyes opened a bit wider and begin to have faith in their own abilities to think for themselves and question extravagant claims—especially those that result in the permanent loss of a body part or result in a child being injured to any degree. Seattle, Washington Berkeley, California San Anselmo, California
George C. Denniston Frederick M. Hodges Marilyn Fayre Milos
References Black A. (2006) Fraud in medical research: A frightening, all-too-common trend on the rise. NaturalNews.com. April 18, 2006. http://www.naturalnews.com/019353.html Fanelli D. (2009) How many scientists fabricate and falsify research? A systematic review and meta-analysis of survey data. PLoS ONE. 4(5):e5738, doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0005738. Vastag B. (2006) Cancer fraud case stuns research community, prompts reflection on peer review process. JNCI. 98(6):374–376, doi: 10.1093/jnci/djj118.
Acknowledgments
The work of putting on the symposium from which the papers in this book were drawn is the product of many hands. We would like to thank David Smith, Margaret Green, and the many members of NORM-UK who worked so diligently to make the symposium at Keele University a success. We are also honored to acknowledge Marie Fox and Michael Thomson, professors at Keele University School of Law, who co-sponsored our symposium, presented papers, and contributed significantly to this book. Special thanks are due to Gaye Blake-Roberts, Director of the Wedgwood Museum and renowned speaker and author on British ceramics, for the lovely Wedgwood plates with the International Child for Genital Autonomy that she had commissioned as a gift for each of the symposium presenters, and for hosting the reception of our gala dinner in the beautiful university rooms, where a fine collection of ceramics was made available for the enjoyment of symposium attendees. We thank Ken Brierley and Sheila Curran for their tireless efforts in helping to make the symposium a successful event. Of course, we would like to thank our contributors, whose papers have added to our body of information about a crucially important human rights issue. And, finally, we acknowledge those who have survived the pain and trauma of genital cutting, those who have the courage to speak out against harmful traditional practices, and everyone who works to protect the genital integrity rights of those who are too little to defend or protect themselves. Together, we are making a safer world for the children.
ix
Contents
1 “Three-Fourths Were Abnormal”—Misha’s Case, Sick Societies, and the Law . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Steven Svoboda
1
2 Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Marie Fox and Michael Thomson
15
3 These Goalposts Don’t Move: Non-Medical Circumcision of Boys in the Tasmanian and Australian Context . . . . . . . . . . Paul Mason
39
4 Mass Campaigns of Male Circumcision for HIV Control in Africa: Clinical Efficacy, Population Effectiveness, Political Issues . Michel Garenne
49
5 AIDS XVII, Mexico City: Reason for Hope or Panic? . . . . . . . . John Geisheker
61
6 Circumcision Psychopathology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . George C. Denniston
67
7 Physical Effects of Circumcision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . John Warren
75
8 Complications of Circumcision: A Urologist’s Viewpoint . . . . . . James L. Snyder
81
9 NOCIRC of Italy: Scientific Activities 2006–2009 . . . . . . . . . . Franco Viviani, S. Bobbo, S. Malaguti, and D. Paolini
85
10
A Project About Male Circumcision in the Veneto . . . . . . . . . . M. Gloria de Bernardo
95
11
The First Survey on Genital Stretching in Italy . . . . . . . . . . . Pia Grassivaro Gallo, Annalisa Bertoletti, Ilenia Zanotti, and Lucrezia Catania
97
xi
xii
12
13
14
15
16
Contents
Knowledge and Opinions of North Italian Health Operators About Female Genital Mutilation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pia Grassivaro Gallo, Ilenia Zanotti, Annalisa Bertoletti, Lucrezia Catania, and Miriam Manganoni
103
Stretching of the Labia Minora and Other Expansive Interventions of Female Genitals in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pia Grassivaro Gallo, Nancy Tshiala Mbuyi, and Annalisa Bertoletti
111
Preventing Infibulation: Mana Sultan Abdurahman Isse at Merka, Somalia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pia Grassivaro Gallo and Sandra Busatta
125
Writing Rites Gone Wrong: Autobiography, Testimonials, and Their Relevance to the Debate Around Genital Alterations . . Chantal Zabus
137
The Impact of Neonatal Circumcision: Implications for Doctors of Men’s Experiences in Regressive Therapy . . . . . . . . Robert Clover Johnson
149
17
Circumcision Memory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Thomas W. Hennen
167
18
Foreskin Restoration 1980–2008 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . R. Wayne Griffiths, J. David Bigelow, and James Loewen
189
19
Restoration: The Foreskin and the American Dream . . . . . . . . Ron Low
199
20
Genital Autonomy: The Way Forward . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David Smith
211
21
Circumcision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . George Wald
217
Appendix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
241
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
247
Contributors
Annalisa Bertoletti Working Group of FGM, University of Padua, Padua, Italy J. David Bigelow National Organization of Restoring Men, Concord, CA, USA S. Bobbo Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua, Italy Sandra Busatta Working Group on FGM, University of Padua, Padua, Italy Lucrezia Catania Resource Center for Preventing and Curing FGM and Its Complications, University of Florence, Florence, Italy M. Gloria de Bernardo University of Verona, Verona, Italy; University of Padua, Padua, Italy,
[email protected] George C. Denniston Doctors Opposing Circumcision (D.O.C.), Seattle, WA, USA Marie Fox School of Law, University of Keele, Staffordshire, UK Michel Garenne IRD (French Institute for Research and Development) and Institut Pasteur, Paris, France,
[email protected] John Geisheker Doctors Opposing Circumcision, Seattle, WA, USA,
[email protected] Pia Grassivaro Gallo Working Group of FGM, University of Padua, Padua, Italy,
[email protected] R. Wayne Griffiths National Organization of Restoring Men, Concord, CA, USA,
[email protected] Thomas W. Hennen Washington and California Bar Associations, Attorney Before the US Patent & Trademark Office, Des Moines, WA, USA,
[email protected] Robert Clover Johnson Gallaudet University Press, Washington, DC, USA,
[email protected] James Loewen National Organization of Restoring Men, Concord, CA, USA
xiii
xiv
Contributors
Ron Low Northwestern University, Kellogg Graduate School of Management, Chicago, IL, USA,
[email protected] S. Malaguti Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua, Italy Miriam Manganoni Working Group on FGM, University of Padua, Padua, Italy Paul Mason Commissioner for Children, Tasmania, Australia,
[email protected] D. Paolini Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua, Italy David Smith NORM-UK, Staffordshire, UK,
[email protected] James L. Snyder American Board of Urology, American College of Surgeons, Virginia Urological Society, Clifton Forge, VA, USA,
[email protected] J. Steven Svoboda Attorneys for the Rights of the Child, Berkeley, CA, USA,
[email protected] Michael Thomson School of Law, University of Keele, Staffordshire, UK,
[email protected] Nancy Tshiala Mbuyi Working Group on FGM, University of Padua, Padua, Italy Franco Viviani Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua, Padua, Italy,
[email protected] George Wald Professor of Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA,
[email protected] John Warren Royal College of Physicians, London, UK; NORM-UK, Staffordshire, UK,
[email protected] Chantal Zabus Universities of Paris XIII & III-Sorbonne Nouvelle, Paris, France; Institut Universitaire de France, Paris, France,
[email protected] Ilenia Zanotti Working Group of FGM, University of Padua, Padua, Italy
About the Authors
Peter Ball MA MB, BChir DA, is a retired family practitioner, Vice Chairman of NORM-UK, and the producer and director of a non-surgical foreskin restoration video. Tunbridge Wells, Kent, UK. Annalisa Bertoletti PhD, graduated in Psychology, University of Padua, and is a member of the Padua Working Group on FGM. Padua, Italy. J. David Bigelow PhD, earned his doctorate in psychology at Claremont Graduate School, is a retired college professor (Whittier College), therapist, clergyman, and author of The Joy of Uncircumcising% Exploring Circumcision: History, Myths, Psychology, Restoration, Sexual Pleasure and Human Rights. Pacific Grove, CA, USA. Sandra Bussata PhD, is Professor of Social Anthropology, University of Padua, and a member of the Padua Working Group on FGM, Padua, Italy. Lucrezia Catania is a member of the Padua Working Group on FGM. Padua, Italy. Georganne Chapin JD, is President and CEO of Hudson Health Plan, a non-profit Medicaid managed care company in New York’s Hudson Valley. She is also founder and President of the Hudson Center for Health Equity & Quality (Hcheq), an organization whose purpose is to contribute to policy and technology efforts toward healthcare reform. Georganne is the CEO of Intact America, an organization dedicated to keeping babies whole. She has taught Bioethics as well as Medicaid and Disability Law at Pace University School of Law, from which she received her law degree. She also holds an undergraduate degree in Anthropology from Barnard College and a Masters in Sociomedical Science from Columbia University. She serves on a number of non-profit Boards, including that of Attorneys for the Rights of the Child (ARC). Tarrytown, NY, USA. M. Gloria de Bernardo PhD, teaches Ethno-Anthropology and Social Anthropology, Surgery and Medicine Faculty, University of Verona and University of Padua. She is President of the Ethic Committee in “Clinical Practice, Hospital Institute of Verona, and has been a member of the Experimentation Committee, as an “Expert in Bioethic Science,” following her experience at the San Raffaele in Milan
xv
xvi
About the Authors
and at Lana Foundation in Padua. She is a member of the Medical Anthropology Italian Society (SIAM). She has written many articles for Etnoginecology Magazine, as a result of her personal research and her research with the Padua Working Group on FGM. She is the author of The Respect of Pain and Death in the Main Confessions. Padua, Italy. George C. Denniston MD (University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine), MPH (Harvard School of Public Health), founder and President of Doctors Opposing Circumcision (D.O.C.), co-author, Doctors Re-examine Circumcision, co-editor of the proceedings of the International Symposia on Circumcision, Human Rights, and Genital Integrity, Sexual Mutilations: A Human Tragedy, Male and Female Circumcision: Medical, Legal and Ethical Considerations in Pediatric Practice, Understanding Circumcision: A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to a Multi-Dimensional Problem, Flesh and Blood: Perspectives on the Problem of Circumcision in Contemporary Society, Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision, Culture, Controversy and Change, and Circumcision and Human Rights. He is also the former Associate Medical Director of the Planned Parenthood Federation of America. Olympic Peninsula, WA, USA. Marie Fox is Professor of Law at the University of Keele. Her main research interests are in the fields of Health Care Law, Animal Law and Feminist Legal Theory. Selected recent publications include: (with Jean McHale), 2nd edition of Health Care Law: Text, Cases and Materials (Sweet & Maxwell) 2006 (1204, xxxvi pages); “The Regulation of Xenotransplantation in the United Kingdom After UKXIRA: Legal and Ethical Issues” (with L. Williamson and S. McLean) (2007) 34(4) Journal of Law & Society 441–464; “Rethinking the Animal/Human Boundary: The Impact of Xeno Technologies” (2005) 26 Liverpool Law Review 149–167; (with Michael Thomson) “Cutting It: Surgical Interventions and the Sexing of Children” (2005) 12 Cardozo Journal of Law & Gender 82–97; (with Michael Thomson) “A Covenant with the Status Quo?: Male Circumcision and the New BMA Guidance to Doctors,” (2005) 31 Journal of Medical Ethics 463–469; (with Michael Thomson) “Short Changed? The Law and Ethics of Male Circumcision,” (2005) 13 International Journal of Children’s Rights 161–181; republished in M. Freeman (ed.) Children’s Health and Children’s Rights Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2006. Staffordshire, UK. Michel Garenne PhD (demography), is Director of Research at the French Institute for Research and Development and is currently working at the Pasteur Institute, Emerging Diseases Unit, in Paris. He is also honorary Associate Professor at the University of Witwatersrand, Johannesburg. He directed the Niakhar Demographic Surveillance System in Senegal in the 1980 s and has collaborated with the Agincourt Health and Demographic Surveillance System in South Africa since 1992. He is the author of numerous publications on population and health issues in Africa, and has taught demography at several universities in Europe (Paris, Clermont-Ferrand, Heidelberg, Antwerp), and in the United States (Harvard). Paris, France.
About the Authors
xvii
John Geisheker JD, LLM, is the General Counsel and Executive Director of Doctors Opposing Circumcision. Seattle, WA, USA. Pia Grassivaro Gallo PhD, Associate Professor of Anthropology, University of Padua’s Psychology Faculty, and former teacher of Applied Biology, Human Genetics, and Anthropogenetics. Her research on the biology of current human populations has taken place in several developing countries, particularly Somalia (from 1972 to 1985). At the invitation of the Somali Ministry of Public Health (1981), she was invited to take part in a scientific mission to Somaliland. From 1988, she has been responsible for the Padua Working Group on FGM, dealing with African immigrants in Italy. From 2000, she studied the expansive forms of the traditional interventions on female genitalia, carrying out field researchers in Central Africa (Uganda, Malawi, and Congo RDC). She was co-coordinator of the 8th International Symposium on Circumcision and Human Rights, Padua, Italy. R. Wayne Griffiths MS, MEd, a sociologist and educator, received his MS from BYU and his MEd from Oregon State University and did post graduate work at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles. He was an assistant professor of sociology and criminology at Armstrong State College in Savannah, Georgia. He is the co-founder and Executive Director of the National Organization of Restoring Men (NORM), which was founded in 1989. He has written and published a number of articles on foreskin restoration. Concord, CA, USA. Thomas W. Hennen JD, received a BS degree in Mechanical Engineering from Washington State University (1969) and a Juris Doctor in Law from the University of Maine School of Law (1973). He is a member of both the Washington and California Bar Associations and is admitted as an attorney before the US Patent & Trademark Office. He has spent 33 years of his professional career working as an Intellectual Property Attorney for government and corporate employers. Des Moines, WA, USA. Frederick M. Hodges Dphil (Oxon), is a medical historian, the co-author of What Your Doctor May Not Tell You About Circumcision: Untold Facts on America’s Most Widely Performed—and Most Unnecessary—Surgery (Warner Books 2002), and co-editor of the proceedings of the International Symposia on Circumcision, Human Rights, and Genital Integrity, Sexual Mutilations: A Human Tragedy, Male and Female Circumcision: Medical, Legal and Ethical Considerations in Pediatric Practice, Understanding Circumcision: A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to a Multi-Dimensional Problem, Flesh and Blood: Perspectives on the Problem of Circumcision in Contemporary Society, Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision, Culture, Controversy and Change, and Circumcision and Human Rights. Berkeley, CA, USA. Robert C. Johnson recently retired from a 24-year career as a writer and editor at Gallaudet University in Washington, DC, USA, where he wrote extensively about deafness-related research. He is co-editor of Testing Deaf Students in an Age of Accountability, published by Gallaudet University Press. In 2005, at the age of 60,
xviii
About the Authors
determined to understand and overcome the root cause of difficulties with intimacy he had experienced all his adolescent and adult life, he decided to pursue an eclectic form of regressive therapy for a second time. Much to his surprise, during one session of this therapy, he began to re-experience his neonatal circumcision, an event he believes originally occurred within hours or minutes after birth, without parental consent (a frequent occurrence in 1945), many hours before he met his parents. His paper describes his journey from that shocking discovery to his current status as an anti-circumcision activist. Alexandria, VA, USA. James Loewen Photographer, discovered his circumcised status at age seven, which sparked his outrage. Artistic abilitiesas a child led him to a career as a photographer and many fascinating assignments, including a three-month project in1975, photographing the activities at the sex-change clinic of the notorious Dr. John Brown. In 1993, Loewen happened upon Jim Bigelow’s book, The Joy of Uncircumcising, and began connecting with others opposed to infant and childhood genital surgeries. His lifetime of questioning gender, sexual roles, and orientation has informed his artistic and intactivist activities. Currently he is making videos related to intactivism and hosting a YouTube channel, “intactivist1,” with many collected video clips related to the issue. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. Ron Low BS, MS, markets TLC Tugger foreskin restoration devices (http:// TLCTugger.com), hosts the Circumspect iTunes podcast series, and moderates the Foreskin-Restoration/Intactivist Network Internet forum (http://ForeskinRestoration.net/forum). Ron was circumcised at birth and has been a foreskin restorer since 2001. He was cited in the book Everything you know about Sex is Wrong, featured in the BBC documentary Circumcise Me?, and interviewed by major newspapers and Time magazine. He appears in the 2007 intactivist film Cut, and he presented the topic of foreskin restoration to a Mensa convention and to the Everyday Edisons reality show. In August of 2008, Ron demonstrated foreskin restoration to Howard Stern and his radio/TV audience of millions. Ron earned a Bachelors degree in Industrial Engineering from University of Illinois and a Masters degree in Services Marketing and Entrepreneurship from Northwestern University’s Kellogg Graduate School of Management. Chicago, IL, USA. Miriam Maganoni is a member of the Padua Working Group on FGM. Padua, Italy. Paul Mason is the Commissioner for Children [CfC] for Tasmania. The CfC is an officer of Executive Government, independent of the elected government of the day, appointed to advise the Government and to increase public awareness of matters relating to the health, welfare, care, protection, and development of children. Paul is a family lawyer with 30 years experience. Nancy Tshiala Mbuyi graduated in Nursing Sciences, University of Padua, and is a member of the Padua Working Group on FGM. Padua, Italy. Marilyn Fayre Milos RN, is the founder and Executive Director of the National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers (NOCIRC), the
About the Authors
xix
coordinator of the International Symposia on Circumcision, Genital Integrity, and Human Rights, the editor of the NOCIRC Annual Report, and the coeditor of the proceedings of the International Symposia on Circumcision, Human Rights, and Genital Integrity, Sexual Mutilations: A Human Tragedy, Male and Female Circumcision: Medical, Legal and Ethical Considerations in Pediatric Practice, Understanding Circumcision: A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to a Multi-Dimensional Problem, Flesh and Blood: Perspectives on the Problem of Circumcision in Contemporary Society, Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision, Culture, Controversy and Change, and Circumcision and Human Rights. San Anselmo, CA, USA. David Smith was educated at St Joseph’s College, Market Drayton, and he qualified in business studies at Underwood College. He worked for Re-Solv, the solvent abuse charity, but he currently works full-time as General Manager of NORMUK, and is the organization’s only paid staff member. David created and is now the editor of NORM NEWS, the organization’s magazine for members. Staffordshire, UK. James L. Snyder MD, FACS, is a Diplomate of American Board of Urology, a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons, Past President of the Virginia Urological Society, Retired Commander, Medical Corps, United States Naval Reserve, who retired from medical practice in 2000. He has served as expert witness in several circumcision lawsuits. Clifton Forge, VA, USA. J. Steven Svoboda JD, focuses on civil litigation and human rights, and is the founder and Executive Director of Attorneys for the Rights of the Child (ARC), a non-profit organization addressing the illegality of involuntary genital surgery. Berkeley, CA, USA. Michael Thomson is Professor of Law, Culture & Society at the University of Keele. His research interests include Health Care Law, Law and Gender, and Law and Literature. His particular focus has been the regulation of reproduction and the relationship between law and gender. The focus of his most recent work is masculinity and the legal regulation of the male sexed body. He is the author of Reproducing Narrative: Gender, Reproduction and Law (Dartmouth, 1998) and Endowed: Regulating the Male Sexed Body (Routledge, 2007). Staffordshire, UK. Franco Viviani is Professor of Anthropology Applied to Psychology, Department of Psychology of Work and Socialization, Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua. His academic work has focused primarily on sport anthropology and then on the health-related issues that arise in the context of physical activity, fitness and health. He is President of the International Council of Physical Activity and Fitness Research and an active member of several scientific health-related associations, including the Presidium of NFH Shanghai, which organizes annual international congresses on nutrition, fitness and health. After developing an interest on female circumcision, he published books, research papers, and directed audio-visuals on the topic. He has published several papers and articles both on male and female circumcision and co-organized congresses, workshops and participated in debates on the
xx
About the Authors
topic. As he is the NOCIRC representative for Italy, informing the media whenever facts or public debates focus on male and female circumcision. John Warren MB BChir DCH FRCP, qualified in medicine at Cambridge University, England (1966). He obtained the Diploma of Child Health (1968), Membership of the Royal College of Physicians of London (1970), and was made a Fellow of the Royal College of Physicians (1987). After junior training posts, he was appointed a consultant physician in Harlow, Essex (1975), specialising in general internal medicine and respiratory disease. He became interested in problems surrounding infant circumcision when studying child health (1968), and followed up this interest in the early 1990 s, leading to the establishment of NORM-UK (1995), of which he has been chairman since its foundation. He retired from medical practice in 2006. Harlow, Essex, UK. Chantal Zabus is Professor of Postcolonial Literature and Gender Studies at the University Paris 13, a Researcher at the University of Paris 3-Sorbonne Nouvelle, and a Senior Scholar at the Institut Universitaire de France, Paris. She is the author of Between Rites and Rights: Excision in Women’s Experiential Texts and Human Contexts, Stanford UP, 2007); The African Palimpsest (Rodopi, 1991; rpt 2007); Tempests after Shakespeare (Palgrave, 2002). She has also edited Le Secret (with J. Derrida, Louvain, 1999), Changements au féminin en Afrique noire (L’Harmattan, 2000), Fearful Symmetries: Essays and Testimonies Around Excision and Circumcision (Rodopi, 2009), and she is currently editing Perennial Empires (with Silvia Nagy-Zekmi). Paris, France. Ilenia Zanotti PhD, received her degree in Psychology at the University of Padua. She is a member of the Padua Working Group on FGM. Padua, Italy.
Chapter 1
“Three-Fourths Were Abnormal”—Misha’s Case, Sick Societies, and the Law J. Steven Svoboda
Abstract Law, human rights, medical ethics, and social mandates reflect, transmit, and reinforce social norms. Well over a century ago, normality was redefined, and suddenly, “three-fourths of all male babies [had] abnormal prepuces.” Genital cutting presents a cluster of interwoven discriminations that violate law, human rights, and ethics. Differential terminology—MGC and FGC—facilitates differential treatment and unequal protection. Oregon’s Boldt v. Boldt case ended in the boy’s wishes being honored, but perhaps only due to the inexcusable 5-year delay in resolving the case and the conflation of custody and circumcision issues. This case eloquently demonstrates the law’s inability to effectively address male circumcision. Numerous authors from a variety of disciplines have forcefully contested the reigning paradigm whereby FGC is outlawed and MGC is legally tolerated. Some observers also note the further irony that cosmetic FGC by wealthy westerners is permitted while traditional FGC by developing world peoples is vilified. Activists against FGC are acknowledging their support of the movement for male intact rights. HIV/AIDS is the latest attempted justification for male genital amputation but utterly fails scrutiny, as even the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) is finding itself compelled to concede in the face of growing protests in favor of children’s rights. Not only do most of the reasons for FGC parallel the rationales for MGC, but a surprising number of similarities link cultures around the world that practice MGC. Parents (as in Boldt v. Boldt), doctors, and society seek treatment, not the infant. Thus, the problem cannot be solved by a medical procedure, which circumcision never was anyway. Only human compassion can end the nightmare. Keywords Law · Human rights · Medical ethics · Religion · Male circumcision Law, human rights, and medical ethics reflect, transmit, and reinforce social norms. These official mandates are ultimately enforced by a country’s police power. Social mandates including culture, mythology, and religion enforce social norms through J.S. Svoboda (B) Attorneys for the Rights of the Child, Berkeley, CA, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_1, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
1
2
J.S. Svoboda
less official channels but can operate at least as potently, often complementing and enabling (and indeed, often helping give rise to) official mandates. Such social mandates have powerfully supported infant male circumcision. Sarah Waldeck points out that “when circumcision rates in the United States were more than 70%, nearly 10% of parents thought the procedure was required by law, much like . . . the installation of silver nitrate drops into a newborn’s eyes shortly after birth.”1 Mythology such as scientific misinformation and misplaced desire that a son “look like” his father has further facilitated the continued persistence of this Victorian holdover.2 Genital cutting persists because it is perceived to provide real or imagined benefits and to connect the cut individual to society along a variety of dimensions— cultural, economic, class-related, medical, mythological, psychological, sexual, religious, “scientific,” etc. Desired societal values that may help justify and institutionalize mutilations encompass courage, pride, fulfillment of the assigned sexual role, religious devotion, willingness to sacrifice oneself for society’s greater good, and many others.3 Regarding MGC in primitive cultures, Paige and Paige comment that “the boy who is circumcised is not himself the object of the ceremony, which is, in fact, conducted to impress others. . .”4 This observation calls to mind Ford’s apt observation regarding intersex surgeries on infants, which is every bit as applicable to male circumcision: “It is the parents and doctors of intersexed infants who are experiencing a medical emergency, not the intersexed infant.”5 Circumcision, therefore, “solves” a non-existent problem, utterly failing to address the infant’s needs while treating the child as a means to society’s ends rather than an end in himself, thereby violating Kantian ethics. Male circumcision, like female circumcision, as Prescott notes, never has been primarily a medical issue. Rather, its roots go deep into powerful religious beliefs and social customs that defy rational analysis.6 As Voskuil shows, menstrual blood and male genital bleeding are closely connected. As one of many examples, “in ancient Egypt boys going to be circumcised wore girls’ clothes and were followed by a woman sprinkling salt, a common substitute for menstrual blood.”7 Romberg notes, “One possible, intriguing motivation for male genital mutilation (both foreskin amputation and subincision—the ritual slashing of the underside of the penis) is menstrual envy.”8 As Bettelheim discusses, penile subincision is called “men’s menstruation.” Thus, men mimicked women’s power in the very ritual that affirmed their maleness, their entitlement to exclude women from positions of importance in the tribe and in religious leadership.9 The transformational power of genital modification must be appreciated to understand these practices’ persistence. A Nineteenth century physician’s medical journal article by S.G.A. Brown states in all seriousness that, “Fully three-fourths of all male babies have abnormal prepuces.”10 Such a redefinition of normality is inherent in the process of genital modification, and can be one of its goals. MGC purges the male body of the “female” foreskin, while FGC purges the female body of the “male” clitoris. Genital modification can promise to redefine normality by turning a boy into a man, a girl into a woman, or a non-virgin back into a virgin. Our S.G.A. Brown for the modern era may be the notorious Brian J. Morris, writing on “Why circumcision is a biomedical imperative for the twenty-first century.”11
1
“Three-Fourths Were Abnormal”—Misha’s Case, Sick Societies, and the Law
3
The exoticization of “African” FGC contrasts with the normalization of “American” MGC. An almost missionary evangelism characterizes anti-FGC activists’ opposition to these practices, while a culturally inert prurience regarding male circumcision reinforces the status quo. Law helps both processes by reifying and reinforcing social norms. Circumcision is tied up with three of the most powerful discourses in modern society—science, medicine, and religion, and a variety of other uncomfortable, controversial and deeply emotional issues including psychological denial and parental authority. No wonder there is so much argument.12 Genital cutting presents a cluster of interwoven discriminations—racial, genderbased, age-based, and class-based—that violate law, human rights, and ethics. We know that human rights treaties—the supreme law of the land and applicable either through ratification or through customary law—forbid circumcision based on such important principles as the rights of the child, the right to freedom of religion, and the right to the highest attainable standard of health. Human rights treaties are binding in the US either through ratification (as with the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Political Rights) or through customary law (as with the Convention on the Rights of the Child, of which we remain the only non-ratifying country in the world with a functioning government). The United Nations has already endorsed in official documents the principle that male genital cutting (MGC) qualifies as a human rights violation, at least under certain circumstances.13,14 A presentation by Attorneys for the Rights of the Child and the National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers centrally addresses male circumcision as a human rights violation and is part of the official UN record.15 The legal status quo, whereby female genital cutting (FGC) is severely punished while MGC is not punished either criminally or civilly as long as it is done “competently” and with “consent” of the parents, must be unstable. Differential terminology—MGC and FGC—facilitates differential treatment. We do not speak of male rape and female rape. We do not speak of female incest and male incest. A priori, there is no reason (and no justification) for this gender-stratified taxonomy. Of course, it does help to obscure the clear violation of equal protection that otherwise might become evident whenever a legal action relating to MGC makes it into court. One recent lawsuit has already become the most famous circumcision-related legal case ever. In Boldt v. Boldt, the Oregon custody case filed in 2004 in which a recently converted Jewish father had been seeking the circumcision of his son Misha against the wishes of the boy’s mother, the Oregon Supreme Court (OSC) reversed the trial court’s and the court of appeals’ previous decisions in favor of the father. The OSC remanded (returned) the case to the trial court for further proceedings, including a determination of the boy’s wishes in the matter. The final paragraph of the OSC’s ruling held: If the trial court finds that M agrees to be circumcised, the court shall enter an order denying mother’s motions. If, however, the trial court finds that M opposes the circumcision, it must
4
J.S. Svoboda then determine whether M’s opposition to circumcision will affect father’s ability to properly care for M. And, if necessary, the trial court then can determine whether it is in M’s best interest to retain the existing custody arrangement, whether other conditions should be imposed on father’s continued custody of M, or change custody from father to mother.16
At the remand hearing, held in April 2009, the then 14-year-old boy testified privately to the judge with neither parent present. Misha told the judge he did not want to be circumcised, nor did he want to be Jewish, and the judge accepted that testimony on the record in the courtroom. In June 2009, she issued an order finding significant cause to warrant testimony as to whether custody should be returned to the mother. The great irony, as attorney John Geisheker points out, is that the unconscionable delay may be the very factor that saved him, giving him time to grow and develop self-confidence to the point where no one could fail to be swayed by his desires.17 Thus the most obvious solution, to let the boy grow old enough to make his own decision, was reached not deliberately but more or less by default and through the passage of time. Despite the happy end result, Geisheker was troubled by the gratuitous linkage of circumcision with custody. Ironically, this procedural point may be precisely what got the case onto the Oregon Supreme Court docket in the first place, as family law matters are rarely reviewed by courts of general jurisdiction [and in fact are exempt from such review]. It is appalling to put the child in the position of choosing surgery to stay with dad, or freedom from surgery with his mom.
Geisheker notes that the Court mentioned only the child’s right to be heard, but did not recognize its paramount duty to protect him.18 Misha’s case is a sad commentary upon American life and constitutional principles. Boldt v. Boldt eloquently demonstrates that in the US, at least, the law to date has not been able to effectively grapple with such a heavily contextual and cultural practice as male circumcision. To date, with one known exception, all awards and settlements have occurred in cases involving either a “botched” procedure or a lack of informed consent. At least three times, courts have avoided squarely addressing the legality of male circumcision by diverting the discussion into such peripheral, procedural issues as standing. Judicial views of standing are politically and culturally shaped in response to social mandates. Although MGC is currently illegal under existing laws and human rights treaties, if properly and objectively interpreted free of cultural bias, American cultural blindness has prevented recognition of this.19 Elsewhere in the world, Tasmania’s Law Review Commission recently released a lengthy issues paper questioning the legality of male circumcision.20 Sweden has regulated circumcision and the practice was recently made illegal in South Africa, with religious and medical exceptions included that threaten to swallow the rule. While the practice is not otherwise explicitly prohibited anywhere in the world, it is of course illegal worldwide under a broad range of prohibitions imposed by statute, common or civil law, human rights treaties, and customary law.” By contrast, world opinion has determined that girls’ bodies are more important than tradition, and that any cutting of the female genitals is female genital mutilation, now banned by law in many countries. Under the reigning paradigm,
1
“Three-Fourths Were Abnormal”—Misha’s Case, Sick Societies, and the Law
5
discrimination against men is regarded far less seriously than discrimination against women. Despite a blatant violation of the equal protection principles enshrined in the United States Constitution and human rights treaties, courts are reluctant to affirm claims of equal treatment not yet socially approved. A movement brought primarily or exclusively on behalf of males seems to cause discomfort to individuals, institutions, and society.21 However, signs are appearing on the horizon that such balancing acts are becoming more difficult to sustain. Numerous authors from a variety of disciplines are concluding that, due to basic issues of justice as well as equal protection principles, genital cutting is genital cutting, whether done on a male or female body.22 Two commentators have forcefully argued that given the American laws against FGC, MGC must also be illegal under the US constitutional principle of equal protection.23,24 After an exhaustive review of legal and human rights implications of circumcision, European human rights scholar Jacqueline Smith concludes that the differential treatment is simply indefensible. “By condemning one practice and not the other, another basic human right, namely the right to freedom from discrimination, is at stake. Regardless of whether a child is a boy or a girl, neither should be subject to a harmful traditional practice.”25 Dena Davis finds “troubling implications for the constitutional requirement of equal protection, because the law appears to protect little girls, but not little boys, from religious and culturally motivated surgery.”26 Sirkuu Hellsten concludes that “from a human rights perspective, both male and female genital mutilation, particularly when performed on infants or defenseless small children . . . can be clearly condemned as a violation of children’s rights.”27 Anthropologist Kirsten Bell notes the contradictory policies of international health organizations, “which seek to medicalize male circumcision on the one hand, oppose the medicalization of female circumcision on the other, while simultaneously basing their opposition to female operations on grounds that could legitimately be used to condemn the male operations.”28 R. Charli Carpenter criticizes the United Nations’ double standard with regard to “harmful traditional practices,” a term the UN defines to exclusively address women and girls while ignoring “the most obvious one of all—the genital mutilation of infant boys, euphemistically known as . . . circumcision.”29 In addressing male circumcision within an article primarily devoted to female circumcision of Egyptian Nubians, Fadwa El Guindi calls feminists to task for their “arrogant and ethnocentric” focus on saving ostensibly helpless African women while ignoring “the cruelty of American male infant circumcision.30 One of the anthropologists who has been working on FGC the longest, Janice Boddy, forthrightly asks, “Why is there no outrage remotely parallel to that which leads some writers to insist that circumcised women are entirely alienated from the essence of the female personality [citations omitted]? Is it because these excisions are performed on boys, and only girls and women figure as victims in our cultural lexicon?” A bit later in her article, Boddy proffers a possible explanation for the widely disparate views: “intuitively, men and boys are not ‘natural’ victims.”31 Fox and Thomson suggest a possible reason for this collective failure of our intuition.
6
J.S. Svoboda
They write that a “harm/benefit assessment [footnote omitted] lies at the heart of the male circumcision debate,” contending that legal and ethical tolerance of male circumcision can be attributed to traditional constructions of male bodies as resistant to harm or even in need of being tested by painful ordeals, and of female bodies, by contrast, as highly vulnerable and thus in need of greater protection.32 Oddly enough—and demonstrating the pervasive power of the “tough male” stereotype—although Fox and Thomson emphasize that MGC is always risky surgery, mentioning adverse outcomes, they neglect the most obvious harm of all: the harm of being deprived of an integral and erotically significant part of the penis. Sami A. Aldeeb Abu-Sahlieh argues forcefully and simply. “The right to physical integrity is a principle. We must accept or reject genital cutting in totality. If we accept this principle, we must refrain from cutting of children’s genitals regardless of their sex, their religion, or their culture.”33 Audrey Macklin34 and Christine Mason35 reach similar conclusions. From an ethical perspective, the procedures look even more analogous, for, as Bell comments, “each operation involves an unnecessary bodily violation that entails the removal of healthy tissue without the informed consent of the person involved.”36 Moreover, as ritual forms of MGC are medicalized under the influence of western health agencies and educational institutions, defenders of male circumcision justify the procedure with medical rationales that are strikingly similar to those used to support excision of female genitalia. Ylva Hernlund and Bettina Shell-Duncan note another disturbing form of unequal protection, an exception from the harsh treatment of FGC practices by foreigners that is carved out, as it were, for the benefit of usually wealthy women practicing cosmetic versions of FGC that are becoming popular in the US: If contradictory responses to nonconsensual genital surgeries on female and male minors respectively reveal inconsistencies, the same can be said when comparing FGC and an increasingly common type of plastic surgery, popularly referred to as female genital cosmetic surgeries or ‘designer vaginas.’ Such procedures include labia minora reduction, labia majora remodelling, pubic liposuction and lifts, and clitoral reduction (see www.altermd.com), some of which resemble quite closely—in results, if not in the context of the surgeries—genital cutting procedures done ‘traditionally’ in African societies.37
Fuambai Ahmadu finds physical parallels that belie the attempted distinction of the practices: Ironically, in the name of sexual liberation, these wealthy or middle-class Western women spend thousands of dollars to become as ‘closed’ as virgins, while ordinary Somali immigrants in Norway line up at hospitals to be ‘opened’ at public expense, under the same banner. Unlike these ‘mutilated’ African women, no one seems to question the credibility of Western women with surgical ‘designer vaginas’ who report increased psychological and physical sexual satisfaction after drastic genital operations.”38
Such clashes in interpretation cannot be reduced to theoretical conundrums but impact lives in concrete ways. In a fascinating turn of events, Somali women in Sweden who wished to perform a minor form of sunna circumcision that removes essentially no tissue from the girls were bewildered to be told that this was illegal. They found this hard to understand because pricking
1
“Three-Fourths Were Abnormal”—Misha’s Case, Sick Societies, and the Law
7
the clitoris to induce minor bleeding does not, generally speaking, lead to permanent changes. Besides that, such a procedure is far less invasive than what is done to male infants at Swedish hospitals during male circumcision and what is permitted on young women who have their genitals pierced, as well as on women who go through genital plastic surgery. In a strictly medical sense, then, there is no reasonable motive to forbid pricking girls’ genitalia while permitting male circumcision, genital plastic surgery, and genital piercing for aesthetic or erotic reasons.39
Thus, the equal protection puzzle has gotten one step more bizarre. To paraphrase Orwell, it is no longer simply “cut male genitalia good, cut female genitalia bad,” but rather now, “cut male genitalia good, cut Western female genitalia also good, cut African female genitalia bad.” Ahmadu, born in Sierra Leone and educated in the US, who returned to her homeland for a circumcision as an adult, is perhaps the person best positioned to comment on such disjunctions: “[T]he greatest irony of all is the increasing number of clinical female genital surgeries performed on women in the West for cultural reasons when the same are condemned for African women because ‘culture is no excuse for mutilation.’”40 Sally Sheldon and Stephen Wilkinson cogently ask if this differential treatment of FGC and cosmetic genital surgery can be justified. The authors propose several possible theories for distinguishing the two—consent, oppressiveness, injury, and offensiveness of the practices—and, one by one, demolish each of them. They conclude that each reduces to cultural privileging of certain practices over others.41 Lois Bibbings argues, reasonably enough, that: . . .any legal regulation of body-altering practices should be consistent. In addition if restrictions are to be imposed they should be constructed according to valid health concerns and should treat the practices according to the risks involved, rather than merely enforcing dominant notions of the acceptable body.”42 The parameters of the issues discussed often predetermine the conclusions reached. As Fox and Thomson note, pain is often entirely omitted from the discussion of MGC’s effects. Astoundingly, even Fox and Thomson neglect any discussion of loss of tissue, inadvertently following in the path of countless prior authors, who limit themselves to toting up “risks” v. “benefits.” If, as Fox and Thomson argue, the male body in general is regarded as less susceptible to injury than the female, the penis seems to be the most invulnerable part of all, nearly any injury to which (short of amputation) is construed as harmless. As Juliet Richters points out, dulling ourselves to the harm caused by loss of the foreskin is facilitated by conceiving of the penis as a battering ram (rock-hard and actively “masculine”), not an organ expected to receive pleasurable sensation (potentially implying softness and passive “femininity”).43 Margaret Somerville astutely observes that, while we would be shocked by the notion of amputating girls’ breasts to protect against later breast cancer, as a society we accept the idea of removing the foreskin as a prophylactic against cancer of the penis or HIV. The reason is simple. [W]e value breasts—we see it as a serious harm to women to lose them—and we do not value foreskins, in fact they are often devalued—spoken of as ugly, unaesthetic and unclean. Yet both are part of the intact human body, and both have sexual and other functions.44
8
J.S. Svoboda
The evidence thought to show a “potential health benefit” for MGC may in fact be an artifact of its cultural acceptability and long history in American society. As Miller45 and Waldeck46 have eloquently argued, MGC in the United States, despite the hospital setting, is more of a cultural ritual than a health measure, as most parents agree to the operation out of habit [and based on social mandates], because other parents agree to it, because they are accustomed to the appearance of the cut penis, and because they do not want their boys to look different. Regardless of one’s views about adults, one tends to see male babies and female babies as both equally innocent and equally vulnerable. It is now evident that activists against FGC agree on this point. In July 2008, I was in the audience at a London press conference as Efua Dorkenoo frankly told us that she wholeheartedly supported the genital integrity movement, and that the anti-FGC movement had simply made a strategic decision not to openly support intactivism as doing so would make protection of females harder. Two months later, on the eve of the symposium at which this talk was presented, two prominent UK organizations that hitherto have labored on opposite gender sides of the genital integrity battlefront, FORWARD and NOHARM-UK, launched a new joint campaign promoting the right of all men and women to say no to unnecessary genital surgery. This is a landmark development. At the press conference announcing this collaboration, FORWARD echoed Dorkenoo in noting that in the 1980s, the anti-FGC movement made a strategic decision not to support intactivism. FORWARD affirmed that male genital integrity is equal in importance to female genital integrity. Today the most striking asymmetries between male and female genital cutting lie in the fact that powerful international agencies are promoting the first as a “scientifically proven” health precaution while campaigning against the latter as a significant threat to health. The UNAIDS and WHO have failed to acknowledge the well-established fact that rates of new HIV infection have been declining for over a decade as the disease comes under increased control. AIDS is not, and never will be, a critical public health problem in developed countries, where the disease remains largely confined to the traditional sub-cultures: gay men and intravenous drug users.47 Even if the African studies are valid, their results are totally inapplicable to the developed world because the virus is a different strain, and because of radical differences in methods of transmission and in access to education, hygiene, and healthcare. Moreover, Lawrence Green et al., showed in Future HIV Therapy that, relative to circumcision, condoms are 95 times more cost-effective at preventing HIV. Posing circumcision as a vaccine may make it easier to compel its adoption, though as we move closer and closer to a genuine vaccine against HIV, they also may highlight the utter failure of this fanciful metaphor.48 And compelling its adoption is exactly the goal the US Centers for Disease Control (CDC) has, until recently, been vigorously pursuing. However, due to the worldwide pro-intact trends in media statements and popular opinion regarding intact rights, in September 2009 the CDC found itself forced to issue a statement on its website affirming its commitment to hearing both sides of the issue.49 To date, this promise remains unfulfilled. Only one token representative of intact rights
1
“Three-Fourths Were Abnormal”—Misha’s Case, Sick Societies, and the Law
9
has had any participation in the CDC’s process, while it has consulted a panoply of “experts” with anti-foreskin views. CDC edicts tend to be faithfully followed by US doctors and hospitals. If the CDC were to issue a pro-circumcision recommendation, circumcision could go the route of Hepatitis B vaccines in the US. After the CDC recommended that the first Hepatitis B shot be given to newborns while still in hospital (despite the fact that the virus is sexually transmitted and thus newborns are not at risk unless their mother is positive). Nurses and doctors then virally passed on the CDC recommendations to parents, to the point where today parents are informed at the hospital that a Hepatitis B shot is required, and all US newborns receive the shot more or less automatically right after birth. If this dire scenario came to pass with MGC, it would mean that circumcision would once again predominate among the vast majority of US newborns. Commonalities between the very diverse cultures that practice genital cutting are astonishing. In a study by Reed Riner of 144 pre-industrial cultures, genital cutting was performed in 23. Of the 23, some cultures cut the genitals of both boys and girls, or boys but not girls, but not a single culture cut girls and not boys. “This suggests,” Riner comments, “that female genital modification is somehow dependent on the cultural presence of male genital modification, and that if we explain the latter we have, for the most part, explained the former.”50 Clearly a powerful process of association is at work, contradicting current legal and popular conceptions of FGC and MGC as radically different phenomena. All of these 23 cutting cultures, without exception, and none of the 121 nonpracticing cultures, can be described, to quote another observer’s formulation, as subsistence “societies with powerful and sometimes massive fraternal interest groups, chronic internal warfare and feuds, and tight contractual control over women and marriage.”51 Cutting cultures invariably provide special training in aggression, in the manly behaviors associated with warfare, and the male role, for the boys. MGC thus represents a permanent, dramatic, bloody, public ritual of submission of the individual to the group, of the father to his “fathers.” Along similar lines, Hellsten observed that all forms of genital cutting are derived from ideas of the place of human sexuality in society, are intended to alter sexual function in some way, and are performed in the belief that the procedure—no matter how physically injurious—will in some way improve the subject’s life.52 In our society, circumcision’s popularity may have been facilitated by our tendency to solve problems by cutting things, often by cutting things out.53 Episiotomy, circumcision, and Caesarian sections are the most common forms of cutting, and all involve the genital tract. As famed anti-FGC activist Hanny Lightfoot-Klein demonstrated, parallel justifications buttress alteration of male genitals and of female, including claimed enhancement of physical beauty, medical reasons, improving sex, asserted universality, as an initiation rite, cleanliness, religion, and looking like other modified humans. Similarly, Dr. Robert S. Van Howe observes that “the reasons cited by families for altering the genitalia of their children are nearly identical whether it is a girl in Africa or a boy in the United States,” namely, “cleanliness,
10
J.S. Svoboda
preventing illness, religion, looking like other children or like their parents, fear of promiscuity, and acceptance of the altered genitalia as more attractive by the opposite sex.”54 As Henrietta Moore aptly summarizes matters, “The West, it turns out, has culture like everyone else.”55 In a recent article summarizing these issues inadvertently, as it were, famed author and new mother Erica Jong lays out her numerous “misgivings about circumcision,” but nevertheless in the end, offering no explanation, she allows her son’s genital cutting to proceed against her own instincts. “Don’t mark him! I wanted to shout, but instead I laughed hysterically at all the mohel’s jokes.”56 We cannot help but note Jong’s fascinating yet chilling mention of “hysteria,” a word that is etymologically and subconsciously related to hystera (womb) and thus to hysterectomy, itself another excision of a sexual organ to solve a perceived social problem and a procedure that is often unnecessary. The truth comes out. Regardless of the efforts of those who would keep it in, sooner or later, human compassion comes into full play, and the truth comes out.
Notes 1. Waldeck S. (2003) Using circumcision to understand social norms as multipliers. Univ Cincinnati Law Rev. 72:455–526 (citing Stein et al. 1982). 2. Scott S. (2006) Circumcision mythologies in conflict with logic, reason, and common sense. Presented at Ninth International Symposium on Circumcision, Genital Integrity, and Human Rights, Seattle. 3. Svoboda JS. (2001) The limits of the law: Comparative analysis of legal and extralegal methods to control child body mutilation practices. In: Denniston GC, Hodges FM, Milos MF. (eds.) Understanding Circumcision: A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to a Multi-Dimensional Problem. London: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Press. 4. Paige KE, Paige JM. (1981) The Politics of Reproductive Ritual. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, p 149. 5. Ford K-K. (2000–2001) ‘First, do no harm’—The fiction of legal parental consent to genitalnormalizing surgery on intersexed infants. Yale Law Rev. 19:469–488 [here, p 477]. 6. Prescott JW. (1989) Genital pain v. genital pleasure—Why the one and not the other? Truth Seeker. 1(3):14–21. 7. Voskuil D. (1994) From genetic cosmology to genital cosmetics: Origin theories of the righting rites of male circumcision. Presented at Third International Symposium on Circumcision, College Park, Maryland [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.nocirc.org/symposia/third/voskuil.html 8. Romberg R. (2005) Male circumcision as a feminist issue [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.noharmm.org/feminist.htm 9. Bettelheim B. (1965) Symbolic wounds. In: Lessa WA, Vogt EZ. (eds.) Reader in Comparative Religion. New York, NY: Harper & Row, pp 237–238. 10. Brown S.G.A. (1896–1897) The mosaic rite of circumcision: A plea for its performance during childhood. J Orificial Surg. 5:299–304. 11. Morris B. (2007) Circumcision: An evidence-based appraisal. Bioessays. 29:1147–1158. 12. Svoboda JS, Darby R. (2009) A rose by any other name?—Symmetry and asymmetry in male and female genital cutting. In: Zabus C. (ed.) Fearful Symmetries: Essays and Testimonies Around Excision and Circumcision. Amsterdam and New York, NY: Rodopi, pp 251–297. 13. United Nations Commission of Experts’ Final Report. (1994) UN Doc. No. S/1994/674 (1994), section IV.F
1
“Three-Fourths Were Abnormal”—Misha’s Case, Sick Societies, and the Law
11
14. United Nations. (2002) Fourth Report on War Crimes in the Former Yugoslavia (Part II): Torture of Prisoners [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.ess.uwe. ac.uk/documents/sdrpt4b.htm 15. Written statement submitted by the National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers (NOCIRC), a non-governmental organization on the Roster. (2002) [cited November 12, 2009]. UN Doc. No. E/CN.4/Sub.2/2002/NGO/1. Available at URL: www. unhchr.ch/Huridocda/Huridoca.nsf/(Symbol)/E.CN.4.Sub.2.2002NGO.1.En?Opendocument 16. In the Matter of the Marriage of Boldt and Boldt. (2008) Oregon Supreme Court Case No. S054714 [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.publications. ojd.state.or.us/S054714.htm 17. Geisheker J. (2009) Boldt case update. Atty Rights Child Newslett. 7(3):8–9 [here, p 8]. 18. Geisheker J. (2008) Special section—Boldt case commentary. Atty Rights Child Newslett. 6(3):6. 19. Smith J. (1998) Male circumcision and the rights of the child. In: Bulterman M, Hendriks A, Smith J. (eds.) To Baehr in Our Minds: Essays in Human Rights from the Heart of the Netherlands. Utrecht: Netherlands Institute of Human Rights (SIM Special No. 21), pp 465–498 [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: http://www.cirp.org/library/ legal/smith/ 20. Tasmania Law Reform Institute. (2009) Issues Paper 14: Non-Therapeutic Male Circumcision [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: http://www.law.utas.edu.au/reform/ malecircumcision.htm 21. Svoboda JS. (2006) Genital integrity and gender equity. In: Denniston GC, Gallo PG, Hodges FM, Milos MF, and Viviani F. (eds.) Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision—Culture, Controversy, and Change. New York, NY: Springer, pp 149–164. 22. Svoboda JS, Darby R. (2009) A rose by any other name?—Symmetry and asymmetry in male and female genital cutting. In: Zabus C. (ed.) Fearful Symmetries: Essays and Testimonies Around Excision and Circumcision. Amsterdam and New York, NY: Rodopi, pp 251–297. 23. Povenmire R. (1998) Do parents have the legal authority to consent to the surgical amputation of normal, healthy tissue from their infant children? J Gend Soc Policy Law. 7:7–123. 24. Bond SL. (1999) State laws criminalizing female circumcision: A violation of the equal protection clause of the fourteenth amendment. John Marshall Law Rev. 32:353–380. 25. Smith J. (1998) Male circumcision and the rights of the child. In: Bulterman M, Hendriks A, Smith J. (eds.) To Baehr in Our Minds: Essays in Human Rights from the Heart of the Netherlands. Utrecht: Netherlands Institute of Human Rights (SIM Special No. 21), pp 465–498 [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.cirp.org/library/legal/smith/ 26. Davis DS. (2006) Genital alteration of female minors. In: Benatar D. (ed.) Cutting to the Core: Exploring the Ethics of Contested Surgeries. Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, pp 63–75. Davis also finds a violation of free association under the First Amendment, in that some religions’ practices are lawful and other religions’ practices are criminalized. 27. Hellsten S. (2004) Rationalising circumcision: From tradition to fashion, from public health to individual freedom—Critical notes on the cultural persistence of the practice of genital mutilation. J Med Ethics. 30:248–253. 28. Bell K. (2005) Genital cutting and Western discourses on sexuality. Med Anthropol Quart. 19(2):125–148 [here, p 131]. 29. Carpenter RC. (2004) A response to Bronwyn Winter, Denise Thompson and Sheila Jeffreys, ‘The UN approach to harmful traditional practices: Some conceptual problems’: Some other conceptual problems. Int Fem J Polit. 6:2:308–313 [here, p 309]. 30. El Guindi F. (2007) Had this been your face, would you leave it as is—Female circumcision among the Nubians of Egypt. In: Abusharaf RM. (ed.) Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, pp 27–46 [here, p 42]. 31. Boddy J. (2007) Gender crusades: The female circumcision controversy in cultural perspective. In: Shell-Duncan B, Hernlund Y. (eds.) Transcultural Bodies: Female Genital Cutting in Global Context. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, pp 46–66.
12
J.S. Svoboda
32. Fox M, Thompson M. (2005) A covenant with the status quo: Male circumcision and the new BMA guidance to doctors. J Med Ethics. 31:463–469 [here, p 467]. 33. Aldeeb Abu-Sahlieh SA. (2007) Male and female circumcision: The myth of the difference. In: Abusharaf RM. (ed.) Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, pp 47–72 [here, p 72]. 34. Macklin A. (2007) The double-edged sword: Using the criminal law against female genital mutilation in Canada. In: Abusharaf RM. (ed.) Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, pp 207–223 [here, pp 211–212]. 35. Mason C. (2001) Exorcising excision: Medico–legal issues arising from male and female genital surgery in Australia. J Law Med. 9:58–67 [here, p 67]. 36. Bell K. (2005) Genital cutting and western discourses on sexuality. Med Anthropol Quart. 19(2):125–148 [here, p 130]. 37. Hernlund Y, Shell-Duncan B. (2007) Transcultural positions: Negotiating rights and culture. In: Shell-Duncan B, Hernlund Y. (eds.) Transcultural Bodies: Female Genital Cutting in Global Context. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, pp 1–45 [here, p 19]. 38. Ahmadu F. (2007) Ain’t I a woman too? Challenging myths of sexual dysfunction in circumcised women. In: Shell-Duncan B, Hernlund Y. (eds.) Transcultural Bodies: Female Genital Cutting in Global Context. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, pp 278–310 [here, p 284]. 39. Johnsdotter S. (2007) Persistence of tradition or reassessment of cultural practices in exile? In: Shell-Duncan B, Hernlund Y. (eds.) Transcultural Bodies: Female Genital Cutting in Global Context. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, pp 107–134 [here, p 126]. 40. Ahmadu F. (2007) Ain’t I a woman too? Challenging myths of sexual dysfunction in circumcised women. In: Shell-Duncan B, Hernlund Y. (eds.) Transcultural Bodies: Female Genital Cutting in Global Context. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, pp 278–310 [here, p 285]. 41. Sheldon S, Wilkinson S. (1998) Female genital mutilation and cosmetic surgery: Regulating non-therapeutic body modification. Bioethics. 12(4):263–285. 42. Bibbings L. (1996) Touch: Socio-cultural attitudes and legal responses to body alteration. In: Bentley L, Flynn L. (eds.) Law and the Sense. London: Pluto, pp 176–198 [here, p 188]. 43. Richters J. (2006) Circumcision and the Socially Imagined Sexual Body. Health Sociol Rev. 15:248–257. 44. Somerville M. (2000) The Ethical Canary: Science, Society and the Human Spirit. Toronto, ON: Viking, p 204. 45. Miller G. (2002) Circumcision: Cultural-Legal Analysis. Va J Soc Policy Law. 9:497–585. 46. Waldeck S. (2003) Using circumcision to understand social norms as multipliers. Univ Cincinnati Law Rev. 72:455–526. 47. See Chin J. (2007) The Aids Pandemic: The Collision of Epidemiology with Political Correctness. Oxford: Radcliffe Publishing. 48. HIV Vaccine Trials Network. (2009) AIDS Vaccine Study Reassures Skeptics [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.hvtn.org/media/news.html#thailand 49. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2009) Status of CDC Male Circumcision Recommendations [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.cdc.gov/hiv/ topics/research/male-circumcision.htm 50. Riner RD. (1989) Circumcision: A riddle of American culture. Presented at First International Symposium on Circumcision, Anaheim, CA. [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.nocirc.org/symposia/first/riner.htm 51. Paige KE, Paige JM. (1981) The Politics of Reproductive Ritual. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, p 123. 52. Hellsten S. (2004) Rationalising circumcision: From tradition to fashion, from public health to individual freedom—Critical notes on the cultural persistence of the practice of genital mutilation. J Med Ethics. 30:248–253 [here, pp 249–250].
1
“Three-Fourths Were Abnormal”—Misha’s Case, Sick Societies, and the Law
13
53. Noble E. (1991) Just say no: Issues of empowerment. Presented at Second International Symposium on Circumcision, San Francisco, CA. [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.nocirc.org/symposia/second/noble.html 54. Hernlund Y, Shell-Duncan B. (2007) Transcultural positions: Negotiating rights and culture. In: Shell-Duncan B, Hernlund Y. (eds.) Transcultural Bodies: Female Genital Cutting in Global Context. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, pp 1–45 [here, p 19]. 55. Hernlund Y, Shell-Duncan B. (2007) The failure of pluralism? In: Shell-Duncan B, Hernlund Y. (eds.) Transcultural Bodies: Female Genital Cutting in Global Context. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, pp 311–330 [here, p 311] 56. Jong E. (2008) Next time boychick, we take the whole thing. Huffington Post [cited November 12, 2009]. Available at URL: www.huffingtonpost.com/erica-jong/next-time-boychick-wetak 1_b_83994.html
Chapter 2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions Marie Fox and Michael Thomson
Abstract On two occasions the Court of Appeal in England has addressed the legality of non-therapeutic circumcision performed on a minor unable to provide consent. Both cases involved disputes in post-separation families where one parent sought a male child’s circumcision against the wishes of the other parent. In January 2008, the Supreme Court of Oregon was faced with a similar factual situation in the case of Boldt v Boldt. However, the boy at the center of the dispute in Boldt was significantly older than in the English cases. The Supreme Court therefore concluded that the testimony of the boy himself, who is now 13, was required and remanded the case for a re-hearing in order that the trial court could specifically address his wishes with regard to circumcision. In this paper, we offer a critique of the Oregon Court’s somewhat elliptical reasoning in the Boldt case. We argue that cases involving male circumcision of older children raise important ethico-legal issues, which the Boldt judgments gloss over, and which English courts have yet to confront in the context of circumcision. Consequently, our aim in this paper is to use Boldt as a lens through which to explore and inform UK practice. We argue that this case fits into a characteristic pattern according to which judges, law makers, and professional bodies shy away from confronting key ethico-legal questions raised by the tolerance in Anglo-American society of non-therapeutic genital cutting of male infants. In raising explicitly for the first time the position of older minors, the factual situation in Boldt affords us an opportunity to begin to address the limits of parents’ rights to determine the future religious identity of their children. In seeking to analyze how Boldt and the questions to which it gives rise might inform UK law we focus on three issues. The first is the right of the boy at the center of the dispute to determine which medical treatments or interventions to his body are permissible. The
M. Thomson (B) School of Law, University of Keele, Staffordshire, UK e-mail:
[email protected] This paper, presented at the Keele University Symposium on Circumcision, Genital Integrity, and Human Rights (September 2008), was first published in Medical Law International, 2008, Vol. 9, pp 283–310 © 2008 A B Academic Publishers. It is edited here for inclusion in the publication of our symposium papers.
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_2, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
15
16
M. Fox and M. Thomson
father’s subsequent petitions for reconsideration and for certiorari mean that, when the boy’s testimony is finally heard by a court, it is likely that he will be 14 or 15 years of age. We aim to assess how a UK court might respond if faced with the task of determining whether a minor could choose circumcision for himself in such a scenario. A subsidiary question here is the extent to which circumcision procedures are appropriately categorized as “medical treatment.” Finally, we offer some more tentative thoughts on what limits may legitimately be placed on parental rights to make choices for their children when their choices are motivated by religious belief. Keywords Informed consent · Law · Human rights · Medical ethics · Male circumcision
Introduction In the UK, a very limited body of case law has addressed the legality of male circumcision. The issue has been confronted explicitly only in the context of disputes about the practice in post-separation families. Thus in two appellate level cases UK courts have been required to intervene where one parent—motivated by an understanding of the requirements of religious observance—has expressed an intention to circumcise a minor against the wishes of the other parent.1 In both cases the Court of Appeal emphasized that such an “important” and “irreversible”2 decision should not be taken against the wishes of one parent, and ruled that the children concerned should not be circumcised. This position is also adopted in the British Medical Association’s guidance on the issue, which stresses that “where a child has two parents with parental responsibility, doctors considering circumcising a child must satisfy themselves that both have given valid consent.”3 Where healthcare providers are aware of a conflict the issue must be referred to the High Court.4 The focus of our work on circumcision to date has considered secular and non-therapeutic neonatal circumcision—that is, those neonatal circumcisions that express non-religious parental choices. This work has been informed by feminist ethics, which values bodily integrity and embodied choices, and adopts the position that the legal status of non-therapeutic circumcision is less legally clear cut than is often assumed. In earlier work, and in the context of non-religious practice, we have questioned the extent to which courts and professional guidance have adopted an unduly narrow focus and sidestepped the fundamental issue of whether circumcision can ever be regarded as in the best interests of a child when not therapeutically indicated.5 Sherry Colb has observed that it is only parental conflict that “allows scrutiny of practices that would ordinarily go unexamined and permits us to ask a question that we usually refrain from asking: Is circumcision in the best interests of the child?”6 We would argue that her observation is equally applicable to UK law. Notwithstanding the dominance of the best interests standard in UK child law and its statutory enshrinement in s 1(1) of the Children Act 19897 pervasive common sense notions that male circumcision is a routine, accepted and safe procedure8 mean that the question Colb poses rarely surfaces explicitly.
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
17
Colb’s point is exemplified in the leading UK case, which concerned a dispute over a 5-year-old boy. His father—a non-practicing Turkish Muslim—wanted J to be circumcised so as to identify him with his father and confirm him as a Muslim. Having considered J’s probable upbringing, the Court of Appeal concluded that J should not be circumcised because he was not, and nor was he likely to be, brought up in the Muslim religion. Rather he had a mixed heritage and “an essentially secular upbringing”9 and was unlikely to have such a degree of involvement with Muslims as to justify circumcising him for social reasons. Wall J. consequently ruled that “The strained relationship between the parents, and the fact that as a circumcised child J would be unlike most of his peers, increases the risk that J will suffer from adverse psychological effects from being circumcised.”10 However, the judge accepted that the position was different where the parents were in agreement that the procedure be performed, notwithstanding his acknowledgement that “a case can be made for describing ritual male circumcision without any medical need for it as an assault on the bodily integrity of the child.”11 We argue that the court’s implicit assumption that where the family unit is intact the parents are best placed to decide is problematic. Given the tacit nature of this acceptance, it is perhaps unnecessary to add that the court failed to set out the parameters of this parental liberty or impose any limitations on it. The recent US decision by the Oregon Supreme Court in the case of Boldt v Boldt12 has prompted us to re-visit this fundamental issue of where appropriate limits may be placed on the exercise of parental rights to choose this procedure. Male circumcision is a contentious practice, which raises a host of ethico-legal concerns. The questions it prompts include, on what basis, if any, should elective surgery with its accompanying risks be carried out on healthy children? How are the risks and benefits of surgery to be calculated and to what extent, if at all, may documented medical risks be outweighed by putative social or cultural benefits, such as a sense of community or religious belonging? In deciding on surgical modification, how much value should be accorded to the notion of bodily integrity? Whose views should prevail when parents or those with parental responsibility disagree? In a multi-cultural society how far should religious practices be open to critical scrutiny, and what role, if any, should law play in scrutinizing choices made on the basis of religious belief? Clearly we cannot hope to do justice to such wide-ranging concerns within the compass of this paper. However, we argue that it is indefensible that courts on both sides of the Atlantic entrusted with resolving these disputes on the basis of the child’s best interests consistently downplay or ignore such questions. In particular, we contend that it is problematic for the Oregon Supreme Court to wholly disregard the central issue of what precisely is so compelling about religious beliefs that, prima facie, they seem to allow parents to choose non-therapeutic procedures that require their child to run risks and suffer pain, in order to excise healthy tissue for no proven health benefit?13 Scant attention has been accorded to this issue in the two English decisions, although we shall argue that in comparison to the US position, English law, while far from satisfactory, does at least offer greater safeguards to protect the minor’s decision-making power over his body. In seeking to analyze how Boldt and the questions to which it gives rise might inform UK law, we are concerned with three particular issues. The first is the right
18
M. Fox and M. Thomson
of the boy at the center of the dispute to determine which medical treatments or interventions to his body are permissible. Petitions by the father for reconsideration and for certiorari, which have now been denied, mean that when the boy’s testimony is finally heard by a court it is likely that he will be 14 or 15 years of age. We aim to assess how a UK court might respond if faced with the task of determining whether a minor could choose for himself in such a scenario. Specifically, given that this case concerns a minor on the threshold of adolescence, our aim is not to question legal responses to religious circumcision per se, but rather to consider at what point a minor may be entrusted with the decision himself. A subsidiary and linked question here is the extent to which circumcision procedures are appropriately categorized as “medical treatment.” Finally, we offer some more tentative thoughts on what limits may legitimately be placed on parental rights to make choices for their children when those choices are motivated by religious belief, and would entail surgical alteration. We examine the efforts of legal scholars who have attempted to formulate a framework to guide such balancing exercises. However, the problems which bedevil such accounts lead us to confine our exploration here to the narrower question of how the interests of religious parents can be balanced with the developing interests of a minor who is sufficiently mature to understand the procedure and its effects—both real and potential—on his embodied choices.14 In beginning our exploration of circumcision as an aspect of faith and how this marries with values that Anglo-American law claims to embody, such as respect for autonomy and bodily integrity, we start by outlining the Oregon case in order to explore the degree to which the case extends some of the issues raised in the English case law. It should be stressed that we are not offering a comparative analysis. Rather Boldt is being relied upon as a factual situation, which foregrounds questions English law has yet to address in this context.15 The analysis we offer focuses on omissions in the reasoning of the Oregon courts. Finally, we address how the judgment in the second of the two English cases—Re S—may sketch a way forward for the balancing of children’s rights and the collective religious or cultural interests of communities. In addressing this balancing or negotiation of interests, our starting point is a desire to reach decisions that will promote so far as possible the interests and autonomy of minors. To that end, in balancing the individual and collective interests at stake, we attempt to respond to a question posed by Priscilla Alderson when considering “who should decide and how” regarding surgical interventions on children. She poses the crucial question, “could we promote more just, benign, and efficacious ways of making decisions about surgically shaping children?”16
Boldt: Disputing Custody On 25 January 2008, the Supreme Court of Oregon reversed an earlier decision of the Court of Appeals and the judgment of the circuit court and remanded back to Jackson County Circuit Court the case of Boldt v Boldt. Specifically, the Supreme Court required the lower court to resolve the factual issue of whether Misha, the 12-year-old son of the estranged parties to the action, consented to the
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
19
circumcision, which lay at the heart of the dispute. Although the circumcision procedure constituted only part of an ongoing custody battle in the Oregon case, Boldt nevertheless replicates aspects of the UK case law, particularly given the nature of the parties’ religious commitment. During the parties’ marriage, Misha was raised in the mother’s faith as a member of the Russian Orthodox Church. On dissolution of the marriage the father converted to Judaism under the United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism. Having informed Misha’s mother of his own conversion, he raised with her the possibility that the boy, who resided with his father, would also convert and the necessity of circumcision in this event. The protracted litigation in Boldt prompted a complex set of hearings and rulings. The particular dispute regarding Misha’s circumcision commenced on 1 June 2004. On that date, the mother filed a motion for a temporary restraining order to prevent the father from having Misha circumcised that evening. In response, the father (who was legally qualified and represented himself) asserted that as sole custodian he had the (sole) authority to make the decision. Further, he claimed that Misha wanted the circumcision in order to convert to Judaism and that the boy’s doctor had recommended the procedure for medical reasons, and was prepared to perform the circumcision. In reply, the mother submitted an affidavit alleging that the father intended to have Misha circumcised against the boy’s wishes and claiming that Misha was afraid to contradict his father on the issue. She expressed concern about the possibility of permanent injury to her son, and sought a change in custody (supporting the ongoing action for such a change). Responding, the father contended that the court lacked authority to grant the mother’s motions, as it would breach his constitutionally protected freedom of religion. He also denied that there had been the requisite substantial change of circumstances that would justify a change in custody, and claimed that such a change would be contrary to Misha’s best interests in any event. He reiterated that surgery was medically advisable independent of the religious justifications, and claimed that although the child’s wishes were “legally irrelevant,”17 Misha wanted to be circumcised. In support of this final claim, he provided affidavits from his new domestic partner and from Misha’s half-brother. An affidavit was also submitted from Misha’s urologist, Dr Ellen, who stated that Misha understood the nature of the procedure and did not appear to be coerced. The medic also pointed to medical concerns that would justify the procedure, suggesting that Misha’s circumcision would greatly reduce his risk of penile cancer and certain infections. Following the filing of briefs and a hearing conducted by telephone, the court concluded both that it had jurisdiction over the parties and (in sharp contrast to the position in English law as outlined in Re J) that the decision whether a child should have elective surgery was reserved to the custodial parent. Nevertheless, given that the parties’ previous custody order appeals were still pending, the court prohibited Misha’s circumcision until those appeals were decided. Finally, the court held that the mother had not demonstrated sufficient grounds for an emergency change of custody. The form of the judgment was objected to by both parties. A further hearing was conducted by telephone, which resulted in a supplemental judgment affirming the
20
M. Fox and M. Thomson
court’s finding that his father’s decision to have Misha circumcised was not a change of circumstances sufficient to trigger an evidentiary hearing. The mother further appealed this supplemental judgment, leading to the Court of Appeals affirming without opinion. The Supreme Court allowed review of this decision. Concurring with the trial judge, the Supreme Court held that decisions regarding elective surgery for a child are reserved to the custodial parent. This supported the father’s contention that his decision to circumcise was insufficient basis for changing a custody order or holding an evidentiary hearing on the issue. In his action, the father was joined by amicus curiae American Jewish Congress, American Jewish Committee, Anti-Defamation League, and the Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America in support of the position that Misha’s attitude to the circumcision was “legally irrelevant.” In addition, the Court stated that notwithstanding the extensive medical evidence, which both parties and amici had presented (the mother and Doctors Opposing Circumcision noting “significant medical risks,”18 the father describing associated risks as de minimus19 ) the Court need not decide which evidence regarding the attendant risks and benefits was more persuasive. The Court concluded: [A]lthough circumcision is an invasive medical procedure that results in permanent physical alteration of a body part and has attendant medical risks, the decision to have a male child circumcised for medical or religious reasons is one that is commonly and historically made by parents in the United States. We also conclude that the decision to circumcise a male child is one that generally falls within a custodial parent’s authority, unfettered by a noncustodial parent’s concerns or beliefs—medical, religious or otherwise.20
Consequently, it ruled that, had the mother asserted a change in circumstances solely on the basis of her concerns or beliefs regarding circumcision this would have been insufficient. However, her assertion that Misha himself objected to the circumcision, prompted the Court to rule that: In our view, at age 12, M’s attitude regarding circumcision, though not conclusive of the custody issue presented here, is a fact necessary to the determination of whether mother has asserted a colorable claim of a change of circumstances sufficient to warrant a hearing concerning whether to change custody. That is so because forcing M at age 12 to undergo the circumcision against his will could seriously affect the relationship between M and father, and could have a pronounced effect on father’s capability to properly care for M. . .. Thus if mother’s assertions are verified the trial court would be entitled to reconsider custody.21 Ultimately, the case was remanded to the trial court in order to determine Misha’s state of mind regarding the procedure. In the meantime the father issued petitions which seek: first that the Supreme Court of Oregon re-consider its decision and secondly, a Writ of Certiorari that the Supreme Court of the United States consider whether the Oregon Supreme Court’s decision violates the First Amendment of the US Constitution (protecting free exercise of religion) and whether it violates the father’s parental rights, which are guaranteed by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the US Constitution. In October 2008, these petitions were refused.22 Although no reasons were stated by the Supreme Court for its refusal and the Boldt case undoubtedly raises important constitutional issues,
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
21
there is a general reluctance on the part of Federal courts to intervene in custody disputes, which are left to individual States to determine23 When the case is eventually re-heard by the Jackson County Circuit court, should that court find that Misha did oppose the procedure it would then have to determine whether his opposition is such that it will affect his father’s ability to care for him properly. If necessary, the court would then have to decide whether it would be in Misha’s best interests to nevertheless retain the existing arrangement, or whether conditions would have to be imposed on the father’s continued custody, or whether the court should order a change in custody to the mother. Hence, in view of Misha’s age, the Boldt case poses important questions, which English courts have yet to confront in the circumcision context, particularly regarding the limits of parental decision-making powers over an older child. In this paper, our focus is on the two novel issues that it raises—when the rights of older minors to make embodied choices accrue? and what, if any, limits may law place on parental rights to choose irreversible bodily interventions for their children? Although, as we discuss below, these questions have arisen in UK courts in other contexts—such as transplantation, blood transfusions, sterilization and abortion—they have not before been raised in a circumcision case. For reasons that we outline below, this procedure raises issues, which differ in significant respects from the earlier precedents. With regard to both novel issues raised by Boldt, we suggest that the Oregon courts left a number of important aspects of the case unexplored.
Acts and Omissions We contend that Boldt v. Boldt is most insightfully read as a narrative characterized by omissions: the trial court omitted to ask Misha directly his wishes regarding the circumcision or to determine whether he was competent to decide for himself; at each level the judgments omitted any consideration of whether his circumcision was therapeutic or non-therapeutic; similarly the judgments failed to carry out an adequate cost/benefit assessment of claimed benefits and risks in order to determine whether performance of a (non-therapeutic) circumcision was in Misha’s best interests, and finally each of the courts omitted to propose any limits on parental decisions made in accordance with religious belief. Our primary concern for the purposes of this paper is the omission to consult Misha or seek to determine his capacity to reach this decision for himself.
Misha’s Wishes and Competence Determining Misha’s state of mind regarding the circumcision appears to have been an afterthought24 ; worthy of consideration only when the litigation reached the Oregon Supreme Court. From a UK perspective, this complete disregard of the child at the center of the dispute seems startling, given the boy’s relatively advanced age and the emphasis placed by UK law on prior consent to medical treatment in order
22
M. Fox and M. Thomson
to protect self determination and bodily integrity.25 The failure to consult Misha is particularly surprising given the parents’ sharply divergent accounts of his views. Moreover, it is difficult to reconcile with international standards, although it does chime with the US failure to ratify the International Convention on the Rights of the Child. Apart from Somalia, the US is the only nation that has yet to do so. Doris Buss has argued that the US failure to ratify is motivated in part by Christian Right fears that it will undermine parental rights by allowing States (or the UN) greater freedom to intervene in families.26 Certainly, although one needs to be wary about generalizing in relation to US law, the reasoning underpinning decisions reached in US state courts suggest a reluctance to interfere with parental rights, and indicate that US courts lag significantly behind the UK in their readiness to accept that children are not the property of their parents and have interests that are separable from their parents. For instance, a 1990 Alaskan judgment contained the following dicta: In such matters as deciding on the need for surgical or hospital treatment, the wishes of young children are not consulted, nor their consent asked when they are old enough to give expression thereto. The will of the parent is controlling, except in those extreme instances where the state takes over to rescue the child from parental neglect or to save its life. Similarly the right to grant or refuse a medical examination of a child belongs not to the child but to the parents.27
In the light of such dicta, it is perhaps unsurprising that US courts should cling to essentialist views that children are not to be entrusted with choices about medical interventions, and that it is age rather than an enquiry into capacity that determines where the locus of decision-making power lies. By contrast, we share Sarah Elliston’s view that determinations of capacity grounded in age alone are overly crude, so that: if respect for autonomy has the central value generally accorded to it in law and health care. . . those who are capable of exercising it should not be denied the freedom to do so simply because they have not met whatever age it is that is set for adulthood.28
The relevant UK case law that engages with the assessment of adolescent autonomy following Gillick29 has concerned minors aged between 14 and 17 who refuse medical treatment. In a now extensive line of cases, the courts have been reluctant to spell out exactly what the minor in question should understand in order to be deemed sufficiently mature to be entrusted with decision-making powers. The clearest attempt to do so remains a statement by Lord Scarman in Gillick itself, where he refers to “the attainment by a child of an age of sufficient discretion to enable him or her to exercise a wise choice in his or her own interests,”30 and to the minor achieving “a sufficient intelligence to enable him or her to understand fully what is proposed.”31 As Simon Lee has noted, this standard seems to set the threshold of understanding so high that many adults would fail to satisfy the test.32 Perhaps it is not surprising, then, that post-Gillick English law has consistently undermined the choices of seemingly Gillick-competent adolescents aged 14–17, at least where they refuse treatment.33 Michael Freeman has summarized the implications of this line of case-law:
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
23
A child can say “yes” to medical treatment but cannot say “no.” This is the simple, indeed trite, conclusion to which one comes after an examination of the cases.34
The facts of Boldt are therefore an interesting prompt to consider whether a UK court might deem a 12- or 13-year-old competent to decide for himself whether to undergo irreversible surgery that involves the removal of healthy tissue. In the UK circumcision cases, the children involved were younger, allowing the courts to assume that competence was not an issue. Given the complex nature of the risk and benefits involved, this is supportable with regard to the 5-year-old subject of Re J, but it is at least arguable that more attention should have been devoted to the competence issue in Re S. Here, in relation to age, Baron J simply ruled that the children—then aged ten and almost nine years of age—were “too young to seek to favor one of their religions of origin in favor of the other.”35 It may well be true that a choice about the practice of religion requires greater maturity than a nine-yearold child will typically possess, and it is understandable that judges should prefer to engage with a definite criterion such as biological age. However, commentators have argued persuasively that relevant experience of illness, treatment, or disability may be a more salient factor than age in the acquisition of competence.36 This suggests that, in assessing competence, key factors are the situation in which children find themselves, how they are informed about the implications of a medical procedure, and the support they receive in reaching a decision about it. Provided such support is available, Alderson and Montgomery’s research with sick children suggests that even children as young as five years old may be capable of reaching at least some health decisions for themselves.37 In the case of circumcision, as recognized in Re J38 and the BMA’s 2006 guidance on the topic,39 the determination of best interests is complex, requiring medical risks to be weighed against social and cultural benefits. Nevertheless, we would argue that some older minors will be sufficiently mature to be entrusted with this decision themselves and that it is incumbent on courts to attend to this possibility. Our contention is supported by the ruling in Re S—that the decision should be deferred until the minor has attained legal competence, when he should be permitted to reach his own informed decision whether to be circumcised.40 We would argue that in reaching this conclusion the Court of Appeal exhibits a more informed understanding of the implications of surgical interventions for the older child than the Oregon courts. In Re S, of course, postponing the decision until the minor had attained capacity meant that the judges did not have to grasp the nettle and engage in an assessment of the minor’s capacity to decide about circumcision, though it did make it more likely that at some stage in the future UK courts will be faced with a dispute similar to Boldt. It is our contention that a UK court, faced with this issue, would, unlike the Oregon courts, be obliged to assess the ability of the minor to decide for himself whether the circumcision should proceed. Yet, even if a 12- or 13-year-old was deemed Gillick-competent, we accept that it would not necessarily follow that his wishes would be determinative—as the Oregon Supreme Court makes clear. This is also the legal position in the UK, where three of the most troubling English cases—Re E, Re S, and Re P41— have involved courts
24
M. Fox and M. Thomson
over-ruling the refusal of treatment on the basis of the adolescent’s religious beliefs. In each of these cases, the minors concerned seemed to possess the requisite maturity and understanding to decide for themselves, and were supported in their refusal by their parents; yet their wishes were disregarded in each case. In Re P, for instance, a 17-year-old’s refusal of blood products to treat his hypermobility syndrome was overridden, albeit with reluctance, by Johnson J., who acknowledged that P was almost an adult and that throughout his life he had been a “staunch and committed” Jehovah’s Witness.42 No justification is offered for disregarding the minor’s wishes in the light of these findings. One possible (unarticulated) reason may, however, be an unwillingness to accept that a child raised in a religious household could remain uninfluenced by such an upbringing. Such reasoning emerges more clearly in the case of Re E, where Ward J. stated, of a case involving a refusal of blood transfusions by a 15-year-old Jehovah’s Witness: Without wishing to introduce into the case notions of undue influence, I find that the influence of the teaching of the Jehovah’s Witnesses is strong and powerful. . . I am far from satisfied that at the age of 15 his will is fully free. He may assert it, but his volition has been conditioned by the very powerful expressions of faith to which all members of the creed adhere.43 This observation supports Margaret Somerville’s argument in relation to a comparable Canadian case: In our turn-of-the-millennium secular societies, a young person’s maturity is often assessed by how autonomous, independent, self determined and individualistic that person is. On these criteria a child from a family such as the Duecks’ [who were committed Christians] is unlikely to be found sufficiently mature to be held competent to consent to or refuse treatment.44
In the refusal of medical treatment cases, therefore, a key difficulty in assessing competence will be the complex judgment concerning the probable impact of the child’s religious upbringing on his competence to make an informed choice.
Medical Evidence and the Therapeutic/Non-therapeutic Boundary Grounds clearly exist for distinguishing the Boldt scenario from cases involving refusal of medical treatment by Jehovah’s Witness adolescents. The main distinction concerns the nature of medical evidence. In the refusal of treatment cases just cited, the refusal by the minor was potentially life-threatening and clearly flew in the face of well-substantiated medical evidence. The medical evidence in Boldt was much less compelling, and we argue that the cursory and unchallenged account of the medical evidence presented also fits into a familiar trajectory in debates about circumcision. We have contended elsewhere that circumcision has long existed as a procedure in search of a medical rationale.45 At different times, it has been promoted as a remedy for alcoholism, epilepsy, asthma, curvature of the spine, paralysis, malnutrition, night terrors, clubfoot, eczema, convulsions, promiscuity, syphilis, and
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
25
cancer.46 These justifications have all been debunked, while contemporary efforts to justify the practice have proven inconclusive and frequently are based on methodologies that have been contested.47 Only in very rare cases can circumcision be categorized as therapeutic treatment and therefore the evidence cited by Dr. Ellen—, “that M’s circumcision would greatly reduce M’s risk of penile cancer and certain infections,”48 should not have gone unchallenged by the Oregon courts. While there is some evidence that chances of contracting penile cancer are reduced by circumcision, such cancers are extremely rare and once the benefit is quantified it is likely that it is outweighed by the direct and quantifiable risks of the procedure. Similarly, Dr. Ellen’s extremely vague reference to risk of “certain infections,”49 seems to hark back to (outdated) notions of the foreskin as unhygienic and a reservoir of disease, which continue to re-surface periodically.50 No evidence is presented that Misha suffered from any of the conditions—such as pathological phimosis, balanoposthitis and paraphimosis—which might indicate that a medical justification for this procedure (or one of the non-surgical alternatives) in fact existed; with the only evidence pointing to “glandular adhesions” on his penis. We speculate that if the Oregon Supreme Court had considered critically the nature of the medical evidence it would have been forced to the conclusion that this procedure was in reality being performed for non-therapeutic reasons.51 Clearly a determination that a procedure is non-therapeutic has legal effects. We would suggest that in circumcision cases the first step should therefore be for the judge to assess whether the procedure is therapeutic or non-therapeutic; and to require much more compelling reasons for the determination that it is medically indicated than those advanced in Boldt. If it is accepted that surgery is non-therapeutic, judges, in our view, should be reluctant to authorize the procedure in the absence of clear evidence that it is sought by the minor. This contention seems particularly compelling if any refusal or ambivalence on the part of the minor is supported by one of the parents. We accept that very different issues are raised where the refusal is of life-saving treatment (although the line at which a refusal becomes life-threatening is inevitably contested).52 UK case law states that tests of capacity will vary according to the gravity of the treatment proposed.53 While Elliston is surely right to argue that it is “the complexity of the decision, rather than the gravity of the treatment or the outcome, which demands greater intellectual capacity and discrimination,”54 the fact that a refusal of a circumcision is not life-threatening and could always be revisited at a later stage supports our contention that the refusal of such a procedure by a 12-year-old should be respected, as should any ambivalence he displays. As a result of its failure to specifically address Misha’s decision-making capacity, the Boldt judgment left open the question of whether it would be possible for a parent to sanction the circumcision of a 12-year-old against his wishes. Although it found that the boy should have been consulted, the judgment gave no indication that his wishes would be determinative. Indeed, the judges seemed to implicitly accept that electing to have a child circumcised is a legitimate parental action regardless of the child’s wishes. If this is indeed true, when is parental choice limited by a minor’s objections? At 14 or 15 years? English courts have only fleetingly addressed the
26
M. Fox and M. Thomson
limits to a parent’s power to consent where procedures are non-therapeutic. In Re B Lord Templeman stated that “sterilization of a girl under the age of 18 should only be carried out with the leave of a High Court judge” with the parents being made parties to the action if they wish to appear.55 In the case of Re P, where parents opposed their 15-year-old daughter having an abortion on religious grounds, ButlerSloss J. directed that the pregnancy should be terminated in accordance with the girl’s wishes notwithstanding an acknowledgement that “I must give great weight to [the parents’] feelings. . . and I must take into account their deeply and sincerely held religious objection. . .”56 By contrast, in none of the cases on non-therapeutic circumcision have judges sought to place any limits on parental choices. However, the fact that parental wishes cannot be determinative seems to be enshrined in the BMA guidance, which notes that circumcision has medical and psychological risks and that it is essential that the procedure is carried out only where it is demonstrably in the child’s best interests.57 While stressing the importance of respecting parental rights, the guidance pays considerable attention to how the child’s best interests are to be assessed. It states unambiguously that parental preference alone is insufficient to justify circumcision—parents must explain and justify their preference with reference to the child’s interests. Relying on its publication, Consent, rights and choices in health care for children and young people,58 and thus offering a valuable insight into guidelines for wider medical practice, the BMA provides a checklist of factors that may be relevant to a best interests assessment for non-therapeutic circumcision. The criteria listed extend well beyond the medical and have an unambiguous focus on the patient. The guidelines foreground the relevance of the patient’s own wishes, feelings, and values; the patient’s ability to understand what is proposed and weigh up the alternatives; and the patient’s potential to participate in the decision if provided with additional support or explanations.59 This emphasis on the patient highlights the ethical desirability of patients being supported to make decisions about their own bodies where possible, rather than deferring to the judgments of others, including their parents.
What if Misha Chose Circumcision? As we have noted, UK case law addressing adolescent autonomy generally has been concerned with refusal of treatment or procedures. This makes it intriguing to speculate on how a court would respond to a 12- (or 13- or 14-) year-old who purports to consent to an invasive and irreversible procedure like circumcision. It follows from our starting point, which seeks to promote autonomous decision-making that an adolescent should be free to make this choice provided he is sufficiently mature and well informed. In facilitating his decision-making, however, we think it would be important to acknowledge that a minor caught up in such a custody dispute is more likely to feel ambivalence than certainty about his decision. We also believe a court should bear in mind that electing to undergo the procedure has irreversible consequences, whereas refusing it does not. Whereas it would always be open to an intact boy to elect to be circumcised in the future, the child who is circumcised
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
27
lacks any meaningful choice once he has attained competence.60 Thus, in an interesting reversal of the general position in English law, choosing the procedure would seem to demand a higher level of competence than refusal, given the way that its irreversibility limits future choices. As we discuss below, recognition of the implications of such a choice is one of the positive features of the judgments by the English courts in the case of Re S. Furthermore, given our argument that the proposed circumcision in Boldt was non-therapeutic, such a choice seems more analogous to choosing other cosmetic body modifications than consenting to medical treatment. This poses the question of what, if anything, differentiates male circumcision from other bodily practices that many jurisdictions, including the UK, do not allow minors to consent to until they reach 16 or 18? Thus, for instance, no one under 18 can consent to be tattooed,61 and under UK law even a competent adult woman is deemed unable to validly consent to excision or other “mutilation” of her genitalia.62 Although it remains unclear whether UK legislation permits women to consent to cosmetic surgery on their genitalia,63 doctors in this jurisdiction would not accede to a request for transgender surgery from an adolescent.64 We would also question whether a girl under the age of 16 would be able to validly elect surgery purely in order to have a “designer vagina,” given the risks of such surgery.65 Nevertheless, given the hazy dividing lines between cosmetic and reconstructive surgeries and the inadequate regulation of private providers of various genital surgeries66 it is not inconceivable that such procedures would be carried out privately. It is interesting therefore to speculate on what approach a court might take in the event of litigation. We would suggest that, in line with the legislative prohibition on tattooing, English courts would be reluctant to find that a minor, however mature, could validly consent to such surgeries, even though transgender surgery may be considered therapeutic. If we are correct in this assertion, it begs the question of what, if anything would distinguish the choice of a minor to be circumcised, other than a specific exemption for religious beliefs. Thus, if the Boldt scenario were to arise in the UK, and a court found that, having reflected carefully, the boy wanted to be circumcised, to permit such a choice the court would, in our view, have to acknowledge a religious exemption to current criminal law standards. As we have noted, our starting position rooted in the promotion of adolescent autonomy suggests that a free, persistent, and properly informed choice of circumcision by a competent 12- or 13-year-old merits respect. However, the complexities of this decision, and analogies that may be drawn with other surgeries, some of which are legally prohibited, leads us to argue that the field of consent to various forms of bodily intervention and the age at which they may legitimately be chosen merits a fuller policy consideration. Currently, under both common law and statute the regulation of a range of forms of bodily interventions varies considerably—ranging from prohibition through oversight by a court to parental freedom to decide, and in our view such inconsistency is undesirable. Yet the UK Government’s failure to revisit the recommendations of the English Law Commission’s 1990 Consultation paper on the issue suggests that little political will exists to do so.67 In the meantime we would suggest that some form of court oversight is required when an older minor presents for a non-therapeutic circumcision and that good ethical practice requires
28
M. Fox and M. Thomson
a health professional to refer the decision to court.68 This at least means that the minor’s understanding of the documented risks that accompany the procedure,69 and the pain that an adolescent is likely to experience,70 as well as his motivations, can be fully examined.
Omitting Religious Freedoms The complex nature of the decision-making in such cases is complicated further when the religious rights of parents, accorded protection in the US under the First Amendment to the Constitution and in the UK under the Human Rights Act 1998 by Article 9 of the ECHR, are at stake. As James Dwyer notes, “Many people, including judges, find parents’ claims to exclusive child-rearing authority to be at their most compelling when motivated by religious belief.”71 In common with the other omissions we have identified, the Oregon Supreme Court side-stepped claims regarding the father’s exercise of his protected religious beliefs and practices. The father and amici argued that he had a “constitutionally protected right to circumcise his son”72 grounded in circumcision’s fundamental and sacred place in the Jewish tradition. The father further asserted that an evidentiary hearing would usurp the role of the custodial parent and violate his constitutionally protected rights.73 The Court explicitly accepted his contention regarding his rights as custodial parent, but failed to address itself to the question of his First Amendment rights. In accepting the primacy and exclusivity of the custodian parent’s authority and in failing to consider the question of the father’s religious freedoms, the (expansive) parameters of these rights and freedoms are left unclear. While we see the court’s reluctance to engage with this issue as regrettable, once again it is understandable, given the contested terrain it would require judges to negotiate. As Herrara notes, in adjudicating disputes between the state and religiously-motivated parents over medical treatment of their children: From a legal perspective, there exists no consistent body of principles or precedent that the court might enforce. . . From an ethical standpoint, it is hard to think of an action that the state might take that would not be problematic in light of its competing responsibilities. Central among the state’s duties are the need to protect the vulnerable and the need to protect the fragile structure of religious freedom.74 Since the balance between these values is so difficult to maintain it is unsurprising that judges want to duck the task of engaging in this exercise. Significantly, to the extent that the judges and legal scholars have sought to articulate these competing responsibilities, it has once again been in the context of refusal of life saving treatment by parents. Given this context, it is no surprise to find that the litigated cases have concerned minority faiths rather than established ones like Christianity or Judaism. Equally it is unsurprising that the outcome has been a judicial willingness to over-ride the beliefs of Jehovah’s Witnesses75 and members of the Amish community.76 As Herrara states, the “most familiar conflicts involve families affiliated with Amish, Christian Science and Jehovah’s Witness religions.”77 In fact this observation perhaps serves to question her assertion that religious freedom is
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
29
“fragile,” since in Anglo-American law it seems it is only fragile where the religion is not an established one, such as Christianity or Judaism. As Dwyer points out, in fact when it comes to established religions their practices are typically construed as simply not being harmful: We commonly excuse parents, legally and morally, for inflicting upon their children what most people would regard as harm, when parents act on the basis of religious belief. While states have prosecuted some parents for causing their children to die by failing to obtain necessary medical care, even though the parents had sincere religious objections to medical care, these cases represent only the most extreme situation and mask a quite widespread but generally overlooked phenomenon.78 Aside from refusal of life saving treatment, the only other context in which courts have addressed the issue of parental rights to determine their children’s healthcare is where parents refuse to have their children vaccinated on religious grounds. Here, as Silverman and May note, judges “have consistently held that public health concerns override religious beliefs. . . [and] found it legitimate. . . to evaluate the sincerity, strength and religious basis of a person’s beliefs in deciding whether to grant exemption from mandatory childhood vaccination.”79 Once again, it is notable that parents who oppose immunization have tended not to belong to established faith traditions,80 reinforcing the suspicion that law is less likely to protect the religious beliefs of those whose faith community is not well settled in law. A more intractable dilemma arises if one seeks to interrogate religious justifications for a procedure—such as male circumcision—which, in most cases, does not pose a life-threatening risk and is practiced by well-established religious communities. Questioning the legitimacy of these procedures becomes still more difficult where they are commonly and historically accepted to the point where, as Caroline Bridge notes, they have become “almost part of the mainstream.”81 In this paper, space precludes a full consideration of religious justifications for circumcision and of the limits that may be placed on a parent’s right to vindicate their religious beliefs. We do, however, endorse Dwyer’s argument that where religious beliefs are cited by parents in healthcare cases, this often results in a failure to separate out the interests involved in a way that would recognize the “separate personhood and distinct interests of children.”82 He notes that “lower federal and state courts have consistently interpreted the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment to guarantee parents a right to control the mental and physical lives of their children.”83 In our view, Boldt certainly fits into this pattern whereby children seem to be treated in law as objects rather than subjects.84 Yet, while we believe it is crucial to scrutinize the limits of parental rights to surgically alter their children’s bodies on the basis of religious beliefs, the dangers of addressing this question in the abstract are evident in those rare articles where legal scholars have attempted to suggest ways of legally regulating parental choices to circumcise male children. At the outset, we suggested the desirability of formulating a framework within which to consider limits to parental rights to choose for their children on the basis of religious beliefs. Such a project is too ambitious to attempt within the space constraints here, so instead we limit ourselves to some thoughts on attempts by these
30
M. Fox and M. Thomson
other scholars to do so. The most thoughtful attempt to frame a legal response to parents’ choice to circumcise their sons is provided by Margaret Somerville.85 We have much sympathy with Somerville’s ethical stance, and with the difficulties of her task, but here we use her framework to demonstrate how such attempts can lead to problematic, and in all probability counter-productive, legal proposals. Somerville suggests that “as our knowledge of the risks and harms of circumcision expands, the range of circumstances in which undertaking routine circumcision on any child is a breach of a reasonable standard of medical care also expands.”86 Having surveyed Canadian law, which is similar to UK law in relevant respects,87 she concludes that, given the limitations on parental rights to refuse treatment on religious grounds, “it is far from clear that the parent’s right to freedom of religion would validate infant male circumcision carried out for religious reasons,”88 and that circumcision would often amount to assault. Turning to the limits the state might place on parents’ rights to inscribe religious beliefs on the bodies of their children, Somerville proposes a seven-stage framework for addressing the competing societal interests in promoting religious freedom while protecting the rights of the vulnerable. Some of these proposals are eminently sensible—including her arguments that it is necessary to start from the position of respecting religious beliefs; and that coercive methods to interfere with religious practices should not be used unless there is evidence that serious harm to children cannot otherwise be avoided. However, others are more problematic. For instance, her proposal for religious exemptions to a general prohibition on male circumcision,89 seems to contradict her earlier assertion that religious belief cannot validate infant male circumcision. Similarly, Somerville contends that: when infant male circumcision is carried out as an absolute religious obligation, the burden of proof, which is usually on those carrying out infant male circumcision to show that the surgical procedure is justified, would shift to those opposing it to show that it should be prohibited.90
Leaving aside the inevitable quibbles about how an “absolute religious obligation” would be interpreted, this religious exemption and shift in the burden of proof seems to confront us squarely with the very question the Boldt judgments ignored, of what makes religious beliefs unique in that prima facie they can or should justify parents consenting to non-therapeutic procedures that require their child to run risks and suffer pain, in order to excise healthy tissue for no health benefit?91 In a UK context, Howard Gilbert has argued that the court in Re J erred in finding male circumcision lawful. In his view, the ruling failed to protect a vulnerable class of children and is inconsistent with the ECHR. In response, Gilbert proposes a range of legislative “solutions”: Parliament is faced with at least three possible options: (i) to prohibit male circumcision unless it is justified as medically necessary; (ii) ritual circumcision is only to be carried out on a male who can give his lawful consent; (iii) ritual circumcision is lawful provided it is carried out in accordance with the guidelines laid down by Parliament [e.g. that the procedure be performed by a registered physician].92 As with Somerville’s mooted framework, there is a failure to adequately flesh out how any of these schemes would work. More problematic is his invocation of the
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
31
criminal law to ban the practice, which fails to acknowledge the ineffective history of colonial attempts to stamp out circumcision in other countries. Such histories show that attempts to outlaw common practices almost inevitably generates reactance that simply mobilizes support for the procedure amongst the communities affected.93 These examples make us very conscious that to question whether limits should be imposed on parental rights to choose circumcision can easily lead one to propose sweeping, unworkable, or overly punitive recommendations. Thus, in recognition of the fine line we are treading, we limit our analysis here to the narrower question of what limits to religious expression might be suggested by the Boldt situation. Specifically, and returning to where we started with Priscilla Alderson, how can we promote more just and benign ways of making decisions about surgically shaping children,94 particularly where those children are approaching the age at which they can reach decisions for themselves? In the following section, we argue that where the minor is competent to decide for himself he should be entrusted with the decision, and in the case of an older minor on the threshold of competence the decision should be deferred until he has acquired sufficient maturity. This position goes some way to answering Alderson’s question: In cases of uncertainty and disagreement, are parents always the best choice makers? Surgically shaping children throws into extra sharp relief questions about coercion, rights, moral choice, and the “intimate family”. . .. But if parents override children’s reasonable views about their own body, the family is hardly intimate in terms of loving equality.95
In arguing for the inclusion of older minors in the decision making process (or indeed allowing competent minors to make the decision), we turn to a fuller consideration of the second of the two English cases to have considered circumcision decision-making in the post-separation family.
Deciding with Older Minors As in Re J and Boldt, Re S negotiated a dispute between parents, which stemmed in part from the parent’s different religious traditions. While the marriage endured, the children—a 10-year-old girl and 8-year-old boy—were brought up according to the tenets of the Jain faith. Upon separation, a joint residence order was made, and the High Court considered the mother’s application to circumcise the boy and convert him and his sister to the Muslim faith. The application was opposed by the children’s father, who was a Jain Hindu. The High Court judge, Baron J, whose ruling was upheld by the Court of Appeal, seemingly based her refusal of the application in part on the following finding: The mother is a devout Muslim but she has put her religion in second place when it has suited her. Her relationship with the father lasted from 1982 until 1998 and they continued in the same household until 2002. Whilst living with the father the household style was not Muslim but predominantly Jain.96
32
M. Fox and M. Thomson
Whilst it might be easy to read a convenient enmity into the judge’s characterization of the mother’s faith (a reading which would necessarily be pared of its specificity in the details of the parties before the court) the judgment deserves an open reading. Compared with the elliptical nature of the reasoning in Boldt, the judgment of Baron J., which was endorsed by the Court of Appeal in Re S, compares favorably. In the first place it is clear that a child may not be circumcised without reference to the court where one of his parents is opposed to the procedure. As we have argued above, this requirement could usefully be extended to all cases where an older child presents for a non-therapeutic circumcision. Secondly, in contrast to Boldt, the judgment seeks to disentangle the interests of parents and children, rather than assuming that they are synonymous. Thus, the judge observes that “the current problem stems not from the children’s needs but from the need of the mother to portray her marriage as being to a Muslim man.”97 Thirdly, as we have noted above, the Court’s recognition that the decision properly belongs to the boy himself when he reaches the stage of Gillick-competence squares with a better understanding of the embodied experiences of adolescents and a more robust defense of the values of autonomy and bodily integrity. Thus Baron J. observes that: Circumcision once done cannot be undone. It may have an effect on K if he wishes to practice Jainism when he grows up. He has been ambivalent about his religion and is not old enough to decide or understand the long-term implications. It is not in his best interests to be circumcised at present. . . By the date of puberty K would be Gillick competent and so he could make an informed decision.
We also suggest that this proposal accords with recent campaigns challenging the current paradigm for the surgical treatment of children born with intersex conditions,98 and which is gaining acceptance as the most appropriate approach in the case of male circumcision.99 Indeed, such an approach has also emerged in communities where circumcision is part of religious practice.100 This growing consensus on the desirability of postponing non-therapeutic surgeries until the child is competent to decide, has, as we have argued elsewhere, been the product of a movement to uncover the harms inflicted by early non-consensual intersex surgery. In the case of male circumcision, clearly much work remains to be done on this process of uncovering harms, given that so many of the harms of the practice are rendered invisible even to “caring” or “good” parents, and that the legitimizing power of legal culture and religious faith causes harms that it fails to recognize to effectively disappear.101
Concluding Thoughts The discourse of the intimate family that tries to exclude a public ethic of justice, by denying children’s rights, paradoxically invokes public concepts of parents’ rights, and thereby invites justice to reenter by the back door in its most dangerous form of defending the status quo, in which unaccountable power falls to the powerful.102
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
33
It is notable that circumcision is slowly gaining more attention in academic and medical publications and in the general media. In general, such discussion and reporting is limited to and focuses on (disputing or confirming) some of the medical risks briefly outlined above. Whilst this development is welcome and clearly contributes to the uncovering of harms that is required, it is also necessary for commentators (and indeed decision-makers) to take into account issues of bodily integrity,103 the desirability of keeping future choices open, and the possibility of psycho-sexual harms, as well as possible negative effects on future sexual experience and enjoyment. Such issues can be brought to the fore if we pay attention to accounts of the ways in which some men have experienced their circumcision status. Qualitative studies, such as that conducted by Hammond in the US and published in the British Journal of Urology International in 1999, do much to complicate the idea that male circumcision is sufficiently de minimus that it should be left to parental choice.104 Hammond’s study ably details the range of negative physical, sexual and emotional effects that may follow routine juvenile circumcision. While acknowledging the particularity of such experiences, simultaneously we need to recognize that a general failure to unpack these harms may be attributed not only to the unwillingness of doctors and parents to see them, but also to deeper rooted problems with the concept of harm. For this reason, although we find much of the critical discourse around female circumcision and the punitive legal response to it problematic, we would contend that one positive feature of how female circumcision is legally regulated is the unambiguous acceptance that the procedure is harmful. We would certainly argue that all forms of harm inflicted on young children whose bodies are molded and redesigned by surgeons are comparable, regardless of whether the motivation is to “normalize” or “perfect.” The harms of male circumcision have been rendered less visible and contentious by the long history and widespread acceptance of the practice in North America, the United Kingdom and Australia. We would argue that legal, medical and religious cultures have contributed to this. Stipulating that decision-making must include the older minor and deferring decisions until they can be taken by a competent minor, in our view marks a necessary shift to articulating the factors that are pertinent to regulating this form of genital cutting and promoting a more open dialogue about how harm is to be quantified. Acknowledgements We would like to thank Rohee Dosgupta for research assistance on this article, which was funded by the AHRC Centre for Law, Gender and Sexuality and the anonymous reviewer for helpful input. We also thank the following colleagues for offering helpful comments on earlier drafts and/or access to materials: Georganne Chapin, John Geisheker, Manolis Melissaris, Jean McHale, Shaun Pattinson, David Smith, and Steven Svoboda.
Notes 1. Re J (Specific Issue Orders: Muslim Upbringing & Circumcision). (1999) 2 FLR 678 [Family Division]; Re J (A Minor) (Prohibited Steps Order: Circumcision), sub nom Re J (Child’s Religious Upbringing and Circumcision) and Re J (Specific Issue Orders: Muslim Upbringing & Circumcision) [2000] 1 FLR 571 [Court of Appeal]; Re S (Specific Issue Order: Religion: Circumcision) [2005] 1 FLR 236 [Family Division]; S (Children) [2004] EWCA Civ 1257 [CA].
34
M. Fox and M. Thomson
2. Per Butler-Sloss P in Re J [CA], ibid., p 577. 3. British Medical Association. (2006) The Law and Ethics of Male Circumcision: Guidance for Doctors. London: BMA (unpaginated) available at www.bma.org.uk/ ap.nsf/Content/malecircumcision2006 (last accessed 19 August 2008). 4. Ibid. 5. Fox M, Thomson M. (2005) A covenant with the status quo? Male circumcision and the new BMA guidance to doctors. J Med Ethics. 31:463–469; Short changed? The law and ethics of male circumcision. Int J Child Rights. 13:161–181 (2005); Reconsidering “best interests”: Male circumcision and the rights of the child. In: Milos M. (ed.) Human Rights and Circumcision. New York, NY: Springer (2008). 6. Colb S. (2007) Divorce, religion, and circumcision: What a conflict tells us about parental rights. Find Law: Legal News and Commentary. November 28 (unpaginated). 7. See Elliston S. (2007) The Best Interests of the Child in Healthcare. London: RoutledgeCavendish. 8. See Buss D. (2000) The christian right and the international rights of the child. In: Bridgeman J, Monk D. (eds.) Feminist Perspectives on Child Law (London: Cavendish) for the argument that the US failure to sign this document has been motivated in part by Christian Right fears that it will undermine 306 parental rights by allowing the state (or the UN) to intervene in families, thereby undermining parental rights, as well as by broader concerns regarding threats to US sovereignty. 9. Per walljinrej [FD], supra n. 1, p 699. 10. Ibid., p 697. 11. Ibid., p 688. 12. Boldt and Boldt, p 344 Ore. 1; 176 P.3d 388 (2008). 13. Gey S. (1990) Why is religion special? Reconsidering the accommodation of religion under the religion clauses of the first amendment? Univ Pittsbg Law Rev. 52:1549–1595. 14. For a consideration of legal responses to bodily interventions and embodied choices see Fletcher R, Fox M, McCandless J. (2008) Legal embodiment: Analysing the body of healthcare law. Med Law Rev. 16:321–345. 15. We shall argue below that the decision to circumcise may differ in significant ways from other contexts, such as organ transplantation, blood donation or sterilization, in which English courts have, at least to a limited extent, confronted the older child’s right to decide for him or herself. 16. Alderson P. (2006) Who should decide and how? In: Parens E. (ed.) Surgically Shaping Children: Technology, Ethics and the Pursuit of Normality. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press, pp 157–175 at 157. 17. Boldt, supra n. 12, p 391. 18. Ibid., p 393. 19. Ibid. 20. Ibid., p 394. 21. Ibid. 22. Green AS. (2008) US Supreme Court rejects Oregon’s circumcision, abortion cases. The Oregonian. October 7, Both petitions are on file with the authors. 23. See, for instance, Newdow V. (2004) United States Congress, Elk Grove Unified School District et al., p 542 US 1. 24. See note 27 below for an indication of the reasoning underpinning disputed health choices, which seems to indicate that this failure to consult Misha may be characteristic of the practice in US courts. 25. On the central value of autonomy, see, for instance, Brazier M. (2006) Do no harm – Do patients have responsibilities too? Camb Law J. 397–422; Morgan D. (2001) Where do I own my body and how. In: His Issues in Medical Law. London: Cavendish, pp 83–104. 26. See Buss D. (2000) “How the UN stole childhood”: The christian right and the international rights of the child. In: Bridgeman J, Monk D. (eds.) Feminist Perspectives on Child Law. London: Cavendish, pp 271–294.
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
35
27. J.D. v. Vaughan Clinic, P.C. 572 So. 2d 1225 (Ala., 1990). Dicta to similar effect are to be found in Feldman v. Feldman 378 NJ Super 83, 874 A2d 606 (2005) at 611 and Bencomo v. Bencomo 112 Ha 511, 147 P3d 67 (2006) at 72. Unsurprisingly, these authorities are relied on by the father in Boldt in his petition to the US Supreme Court. 28. Supra n. 7, p 75. 29. The landmark House of Lords ruling. In: Gillick v. West Norfolk and Wisbeck Area Health Authority [1985] 3 All ER 402 held that parental rights to decide should yield to the rights of a child who possessed sufficient maturity and understanding to appreciate the implications of the decision. 30. Per Lord Scarman in Gillick, ibid., p 424. 31. Ibid., p 423. 32. Lee S. (1987) Towards a jurisprudence of consent. In: Bell J, Eekelaar J. (eds.) Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence, 3rd Series (Oxford: OUP). On the test for adults see s.1 Mental Capacity Act 2005. 33. Re R (A Minor)(Wardship: Medical Treatment) [1992] 1 F.L.R. 190; Re W (A Minor) (Medical Treatment: Court’s Jurisdiction) [1992] 2 F.C.R. 785; South Glamorgan County Council v. W and B [1993] 1 F.L.R. ; Re E (A Minor) (Wardship: Medical Treatment) [1993] 1 F.L.R. 386; Re S (A Minor: Medical Treatment) [1994] 2 F.L.R. 1065; Re L (Medical Treatment: Gillick Competency) [1998] 2 F.L.R 810 Re M (child: refusal of medical treatment) [1999] 2 F.C.R. 577; Re P (Medical Treatment: Best Interests) [2004] 2 F.L.R. 1117. For discussion of the retreat from Gillick and limits to the parental power to consent, see McHale J, Fox M. (2007) Healthcare Law: Text and Materials, 2nd ed. London: Sweet and Maxwell, pp 451–477. 34. Freeman M. (2005) Re-thinking Gillick. Int J Rights Child. 13:211–217 at 211. 35. Per Baron J in Re S [FD], supra n. 1, p 256. 36. For example, Hammond L. et al. (1993) Children’s Decisions in Health Care and Research. London: Institute of Education. 37. Alderson P, Montgomery J. (1996) Health Care Choices: Making Decisions with Children London: Institute for Public Policy Research. 38. Re J, supra n. 1. 39. Supra n. 3. 40. Re S, supra n. 1. 41. For citations supra see n. 33. 42. Re P, supra n. 33, p 1120. 43. Re E, supra n. 33, p 389. 44. Somerville M. (2000) The Ethical Canary: Science, Society and the Human Spirit. Toronto, ON: Viking/Penguin Canada, p 192 (discussing the case of Tyrell Dueck, a thirteen year old boy who was refusing chemotherapy on the basis of his Christian beliefs.) 45. Supra n. 5. 46. Miller GP. (2002) Circumcision: Cultural-legal analysis. Va J Soc Policy Law. 9:497–537 at 502–503. 47. In terms of the historically persistent claim that neonatal circumcision protects from sexually transmitted infections see Dickson NP, Van Roode T, Herbison P, Paul C. (2008) Circumcision and risk of sexually transmitted infections in a birth cohort. J Pediatr. 122(3):383–387. This study concluded that its findings were consistent with recent population-based cross-sectional studies in developed countries, which found that early childhood circumcision does not markedly reduce the risk of the common STIs in the general population in such countries. 48. Boldt, supra n. 12, p 391. 49. Ibid. 50. See Miller, supra n. 46. 51. Critics of routine circumcision have noted the tendency to characterize circumcisions performed for social, cultural, or religious reasons as therapeutically indicated: see, for
36
52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57.
58. 59.
60.
61. 62. 63. 64.
65. 66.
67.
68.
M. Fox and M. Thomson example, Derby R, Svoboda JS. (2007) A rose by any other name? Rethinking the similarities and differences between male and female genital cutting. Med Anthropol Quart. 21:301–323 at 304. See Bridgeman J. (1993) Old enough to know best? Leg Stud. 13:69. Re Wand, Re R, supra n. 33. Supra n. 7, p 80. Re B (A Minor) (Wardship: Sterilisation) [1988] 1 A.C. 199. In Re P (a minor) (1981) L.G.R. 301. Supra n. 3. Similarly in recently issued guidance the GMC emphasizes that [i]f you are asked to circumcise a male child, you must proceed on the basis of the child’s best interests and with consent’: GMC, Personal Beliefs and Medical Practice March 2008, para 14. BMA. (2001) Consent, Rights and Choices in Health Care for Children and Young People. London: BMJ Books. The remaining relevant criteria that are listed are: • the patient’s physical and emotional needs; • the risk of harm or suffering for the patient; • the views of parents and family; • the implications for the family of performing, and not performing, the procedure; • relevant information about the patient’s religious or cultural background; and • the prioritizing of options which maximize the patient’s future opportunities and choices. Attempts at foreskin restoration are enduring: see Gilman S. (1999) Making the Body Beautiful: A Cultural History of Aesthetic Surgery. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp 137–144; but have not proven successful: see Section 6 Foreskin restoration: Historical and contemporary considerations. In: Denniston GC, Hodges FM, Milos MF. (eds.) Male and Female Circumcision: Medical, Legal and Ethical Considerations. New York, NY: Kluwer/Plenum, 1999. The Tattooing of Minors Act 1968, s. 1 The Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003, s.1(1). Sullivan N. (2007) “The price to pay for our common good”: Genital modification and the somatechnologies of cultural (in)difference. Soc Semiotics. 17:395. See Groskop V. “My body is wrong” The Guardian August 14, 2008. Indeed even the less invasive option of administering puberty-suppressing drugs remains highly controversial, and in the UK is not available to those under 16: Giordano S. (2008) Lives in a chiaroscuro. Should we suspend the puberty of children with gender identity disorder? J Med Ethics. 34:580–584. For a discussion of the tensions that exist in legal responses to “Female Genital Mutilation” and cosmetic genital surgery see Sullivan, supra n. 63. On the inadequate regulation of cosmetic surgery more generally see Latham M. (2008) The shape of things to come: Feminism, regulation and cosmetic surgery. Med Law Rev. 16:437–457. See Consent in the Criminal Law, Consultation Paper 139 (London: Law Commission, 1995). Notwithstanding the wide-ranging nature of the consultations and the considerable academic literature it spawned—see for instance, Ormerod D, Gunn M. (1996) Second law commission consultation paper on consent: Consent—a second Bash? Crim Law Rev. 694–703—no proposals for legislation in the field have emerged. In the minutes of a Law Commission meeting on “Consent as a Defence” on May 28, 1998 it was noted that “The responses to the consultation papers were highly polarized, particularly on the issue of consent for non-sexual offences, and no consensus emerged. Bearing in mind the matters we have already reported on, the amount of work that would be required to reach conclusions on the very difficult and sensitive issues involved and the urgency attaching to our work, we have decided that it would not be worthwhile for us to produce any further report on this topic” [copy on file with authors]. However it should be noted that the GMC guidance to doctors stipulates only that “if parents cannot agree and disputes cannot be resolved informally, you should seek legal advice about whether you should apply to the court” supra n. 57, para 14.
2
Older Minors and Circumcision: Questioning the Limits of Religious Actions
37
69. While complication rates from routine circumcision are low, the chances of these complications being mutilatory, infective, or haemorrhagic are high: Williams N, Kapila L. (1993) Complications of circumcision. Br J Surg. 80:1231–1236; Gerharz EW, Haarmann C. (2000) The first cut is the deepest? Medicolegal aspects of male circumcision. BJU Int. 86:332–338. Indeed, complications are potentially catastrophic, since death, gangrene, and total or partial amputation are known adverse outcomes: Hodges FM, Svoboda JS, Van Howe RS. (2002) Prophylactic interventions on children: Balancing human rights with public health. J Med Ethics. 28:10. For a recent reported instance of death as a result of circumcision in the UK see Moyes S. “7-Day-Old Died After Circumcision” Daily Mirror February 15, 2007. 70. In this regard, it is interesting that advocates of neonatal male circumcision tend to argue — despite evidence to the contrary—that newborns do not experience pain: Benatar M, Benatar D. (2003) Between prophylaxis and child abuse: the ethics of neonatal male circumcision. Am J Bioeth. 3:35–48 at 37–38 and accompanying references; Warnock F, Sandrin D. (2004) Comprehensive description of newborn distress behavior in response to acute pain (newborn male circumcision). Pain 107:242–255. 71. Dwyer J. (1994) Parents religion and children’s welfare: Debunking the doctrine of parents’ rights. Calif Law Rev. 82:1371–1347 at 1377. 72. Boldt, supra n. 12, p 393. 73. Ibid. 74. Herrera CD. (2005) Disputes between state and religion over medical treatment for minors. J Church State. 47:823–839 at 824. 75. See e.g. Jehovah’s Witnesses v. King County Hospital 390 US (1968). 76. See e.g. Wisconsin v Yoder 406 US 205 (1972). 77. Supra n. 74, p 823. 78. Dwyer JG. (1996) The children we abandon: Religious exemption to child welfare and education laws as denials of equal protection to children of religious objectors. North Carol Law. 74:1321 at 1322. 79. Silverman RD, May T. (2001) Private choice versus public health: Religion, morality and childhood vaccination law. Margins. 1:505–521 at 505–506. 80. In a UK context see Re C (Welfare of Child: immunisation) [2003] 2 F.L.R. 1095. 81. Bridge C. (2002) Religion, culture and the body of the child. In: Bainham A, et al. (eds.) Body Lore and Laws. Oxford: Hart, pp 265–287 at 284. 82. Supra n. 78, p 1398. 83. Ibid, p 1403. In similar vein, Paula Monopoli writes that “Children in this country [the US] are still being martyred on the alter of their parents religious beliefs”. (1991) Allocating the costs of parental free exercise: Striking a new balance between sincere religious belief and a child’s right to medical treatment. Pepperdine Law Rev. 18:319–352 at 319. 84. O’Donovan K. (1993) The child as legal object. In: Family Law Matters. London: Pluto. 85. See her Altering baby boy’s bodies: The ethics of infant male circumcision. In: The Ethical Canary, op. cit. n. 44, pp 202–219. 86. Ibid., p 212. 87. The law governing assault in the Canadian Criminal Code is similar in relevant respects to the definitions of assault under the Offences against the Person Act 1861, as is the prevalence of the best interests test. 88. Supra n. 85, p 212. 89. Not only are the boundaries of such exemptions difficult to police, but they have been attacked as undermining the entire principle of child welfare/protection in other contexts such as education: see Monopoli, supra n. 83. 90. Supra n. 85, pp 216–217. 91. See Gey, supra. n. 13. 92. Gilbert H. (2007) Time to reconsider the lawfulness of ritual male circumcision. Eur Hum Rights Law Rev. 279–294 at 291. 93. See Zabus C. (2007) Between Rites and Rights: Excision in Women’s Experiential Texts and Human Contexts. California, CA: Stanford University Press, pp 35–37.
38 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99.
100. 101. 102. 103.
104.
M. Fox and M. Thomson Alderson, supra, 16, p 157. Ibid., p 170. Per Baron J in Re S [FD], op. cit. n. 2, p 256. Ibid. Domurant Dreger A. What to expect when you have the child you weren’t expecting. In: Parens E. (ed.) supra n. 16, pp 523–566 at 259. Fortin J. (2005) Children’s Rights and the Developing Law, 2nd ed. London: Butterworths, pp 329–32, Elliston, supra. n. 7, pp 98–99; Hinchley G. (2007) Is infant male circumcision an abuse of the rights of the child? BMJ. 335:1180. Hinchley, ibid. Goldman R. (1998) Questioning Circumcision: A Jewish Perspective. Boston, MA: Vanguard Publications. See for a fuller discussion, West R. (1997) Caring for Justice. New York, NY: University Press and Fox and Thomson, “Short Changed?” Supra n. 5. Alderson, supra n. 16, p 170. Darby and Svoboda have argued that the “most obvious and universally experienced harm of all [is] the deprivation off an integral, visually prominent, and erotically significant feature of the penis”: supra n. 51, p 304. Hammond T. (1999) A preliminary poll of men circumcised in infancy or childhood. 83(Supp 1) BJU International 85. See also, Darby R, Cox L. (2007) Objections of a sentimental character: The subjective dimension of foreskin loss. unpublished paper (copy on file with authors).
Chapter 3
These Goalposts Don’t Move: Non-Medical Circumcision of Boys in the Tasmanian and Australian Context Paul Mason
Abstract This paper examines reasons given by proponents for circumcision of minors, which include clinical indications, prophylaxis, religion, and culture. It examines the legal authority by which the professional or lay operator performs surgery on a person with that person’s consent. The paper focuses on the capacity of a parent to give valid consent for surgery performed on children, in the context of Tasmanian and Australian Statute and common law, and the fountains of English common law. It considers the relevance of “Gillick-competence” of the child patient and discusses whether a legal response based on notions of residual parental “rights,” of “family rights,” and of “cultural/religious rights” and the paramountcy principle of the child’s best interests are consistent tests by which to protect the rights of the child. These rights issues are routinely absent from the reductionist arguments of proponents. The paper concludes that the only consistent way to challenge the arguments of child circumcision proponents is to insist on the individual rights of the individual child, including rights to choose a religion, rights to protection from cruel treatment and abuse, rights to be consulted in decisions that have permanent effects on the child’s life experience, and a right emerging from the international response to FGM—the right of genital autonomy. Keywords Genital autonomy · Informed consent · Law · Human rights · Medical ethics · Male circumcision
Human Rights Legal Context Australia does not have a Bill of Rights: rights are protected through legislation, common law, policy, and education.
P. Mason (B) Commissioner for Children, Tasmania, Australia e-mail:
[email protected]
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_3, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
39
40
P. Mason
A federal constitutional system—legislative, executive, and judicial powers— is distributed between various federal institutions and six states (Tasmania is one) and two self-governing Territories. Treaty-making power remains with the Commonwealth/Australian Government, but States may be responsible for legislation that affects compliance with treaty implementation (e.g., general criminal law of assault, murder, etc.). International law, including treaty law in the absence of legislation expressly applying it to domestic law, cannot impose obligations on individuals nor create rights in domestic law. It remains a legitimate and important influence on the development of the common law; may be used interpreting legislation and the common law. So, for instance, if a decision rests on a test of “reasonableness” or “best interests,” Australia’s international commitments will be an important head of argument. • Before ratification of a treaty, Commonwealth Government assesses conformity or consistency of existing legislation against treaty obligations, If State legislation is inconsistent with treaty obligations, the Commonwealth Government may consider passing its own legislation to bring Australia’s laws back into line with international obligations.
• Australia is a party to various international human rights instruments, including the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCROC), and an international obligation on Australian Government to “respect and ensure the rights set forth in the present Convention to each child within . . . jurisdiction without discrimination of any kind”1 and to “undertake all appropriate legislative, administrative and other measures for the implementation of the rights recognized in the present Convention.”2 Genital cutting of children for reasons not medically indicated amounts to a breach of rights set out in the UNCROC and other international conventions despite acknowledgement in UNCROC of the need to “respect the responsibilities, rights, and duties of parents . . . or other persons legally responsible for the child, to provide, in a manner consistent with evolving capacities of the child, appropriate direction and guidance in the exercise by the child of the rights recognized in the . . .” Convention.3 Routine circumcision for religious, cultural, or social reasons is a breach of Article 19 of UNCROC (State parties to take all appropriate measures “to protect the child from all forms of physical or mental violence, injury or abuse, maltreatment”) and of Article 24 (right to health, which obliges State parties to take all effective and appropriate measures with a view to abolishing traditional practices prejudicial to the health of children).4 Article 14 of UNCROC provides that State parties “shall respect the right of the child to freedom of thought, conscience and religion.”
3
Non-Medical Circumcision of Boys in the Tasmanian and Australian Context
41
Parental Authority Even if it is within the scope of parental authority and responsibility (in the sense described in Article 5 of UNCROC) to provide religious guidance and direction, does this extend to taking action that amounts to an irreversible marking of a child to conform to religious tenets and beliefs? Especially so where the child is of an age and maturity to be capable of expressing an opinion on the matter as provided in Article 12 of UNCROC (State parties “shall assure to the child who is capable of forming his or her own views the right to express those views freely in all matters affecting the child, the views of the child being given due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child”). There is no effective remedy for a child seeking to enforce any provision of UNCROC directly in an Australian court. A limited avenue of redress exists under the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (HREOCA). The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission has the function of inquiring into acts or practices that may be inconsistent with or contrary to the rights set out in the human rights instruments scheduled to or declared under the HREOCA, one of which is UNCROC. Where the Commission is of the opinion that an act done or a practice engaged in by a person is inconsistent with or contrary to any human right, it is required to report to the Attorney General in relation to the inquiry (leads to report tabled in Parliament). Relevant acts and practices are limited to an act or practice done by or on behalf of the Commonwealth or an authority of the Commonwealth. The Commission is required to perform this inquiry function when requested to do so by the Minister, when a complaint is made in writing to it that an act or practice is inconsistent with or contrary to any human right, or it appears to the Commission to be desirable to do so. There is no complaint avenue to the UN Committee responsible for monitoring compliance with UNCROC.
Domestic Protection • Reliance on criminal law and common law of each State and Territory with regard to assault, parental consent to surgery, or medical treatment of children unable to consent because of age and maturity, and it is the jurisdiction of Family Court to resolve disputes between parents about issues of parental responsibility and/or authorize performance of “special medical procedures” on children in circumstances where it is beyond the scope of parental authority to consent to such procedures. • The criminal law in Tasmania criminalizes “female genital mutilation”5 and provides that the consent of the person upon whom the operation was performed or
42
P. Mason
of that person’s parent or guardian is not a defense to a charge under the relevant section. Section 178C of the Criminal Code: ◦ excuses “a surgical procedure for a genuine therapeutic purpose” or “ a sexual reassignment procedure” • provides that the fact that a surgical procedure is performed as, or as part of, a cultural, religious, or other social custom is not, of itself, a genuine therapeutic purpose. There are no equivalent provisions specifically criminalizing (or permitting) the performance of non-therapeutic genital cutting of boys. • The sexual reassignment procedure exception is open ended and contains no safeguards that would ensure that performance of the procedure is in the best interests of the child as distinct from an attempt, however well meaning, to “normalize” that child’s genitalia.
Pros and Cons: The Medical Argument Proponents of routine circumcision of healthy baby boys and male children argue that the procedure is in the best interests of the child for medical reasons and cite endless studies and statistics to support their contentions that routine circumcision “confers a lifetime of medical, health and sexual benefits.”6 Many, if not all, of the claimed benefits of routine circumcision or male genital cutting have been questioned or disproved. It is beyond the scope of this paper and outside the expertise of the author to undertake a detailed analysis of the claims and counter claims. The Royal Australasian College of Physicians 2004 Policy Statement on Circumcision accepts that there is no medical indication for neonatal circumcision and sets out the accepted remaining indications for it. This Policy has been labeled as “ill-conceived”7 on the basis that it “downplays the wide-ranging lifelong benefits of circumcision in prevention of urinary tract infections (UTI’s), penile and cervical cancer, genital herpes and chlamydia in women, HIV infection, phimosis and various penile dermatoses, and at the same time overstates the complication rate. . ..” A response8 published in the same journal raises issues about definitions used in studies relied upon, statistics, assumptions inherent in the critique by Morris et al., and raises other questions completely ignored by Morris et al., such as “the genuine ethical concerns of parents about whether they have the right to consent on behalf of an infant to a procedure involving the permanent removal of a body part.”9 Proponents of male circumcision routinely assert in publications that “male circumcision is lawful.” Judges at all levels, from first instanced judges to ultimate appeal judges, routinely say the same thing, but always as obiter dicta, that is, an aside not essential to the logical process that resolves the immediate issue before the Court (the ratio decidendi). The consistent failure to give any reason for including circumcision in these asides indicates prejudice rather than impartial and balanced consideration.
3
Non-Medical Circumcision of Boys in the Tasmanian and Australian Context
43
It is the shame of the legal profession that judges continue to make this pronouncement with no proper authority according to their own rules of analysis and judicial reasoning.
Effective Consent The legal position of a medical professional performing a non-therapeutic circumcision on an otherwise healthy male baby or male child is unclear. A fundamental common law right to bodily integrity underpins the criminalization of unlawful assaults and has been endorsed by the Australian High Court and Family Court in the context of consideration of the appropriateness or otherwise of “non-therapeutic sterilization” and other “special medical procedure” cases under the Family Law Act 1975. The Tasmanian Criminal Code Act 1924 provides that any person who unlawfully assaults another is guilty of a crime but that an assault is not unlawful where a person consents (subject to situations where consent is ineffective because of public policy reasons). Generally speaking, any medical treatment or surgical operation requiring contact with the body of a patient has the potential to be an assault. If non-therapeutic male circumcision is a “surgical operation,” a medical practitioner can lawfully carry out that procedure so long as: • the operation is performed in good faith and with reasonable care and skill • the operation is performed with the consent and for the benefit of the patient. Where the patient is a child who is too young to exercise a reasonable discretion, consent may be given by the child’s parent or by any person having the care of the child • the performance of the operation is reasonable having regard to all the circumstances.10 The circumstances in which a child or young person has the right to make his or her own decision about medical treatment are not clearly delineated. The High Court of Australia in Marion’s case11 : “The common law in Australia has been uncertain as to whether minors under 16 can consent to medical treatment in any circumstances.”(27) See the analysis by Devereux, “The Capacity of a Child in Australia to Consent to Medical Treatment—Gillick Revisited?” (1991) 11 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 283 (hereafter “Devereux”), at pp 284–287. However, the recent House of Lords decision in Gillick v. West Norfolk AHA(28) [1985] UKHL 7; (1986) AC 112 is of persuasive authority. The proposition endorsed by the majority in that case was that parental power to consent to medical treatment on behalf of a child diminishes gradually as the child s capacities and maturity grow and that this rate of development depends on the individual child. Lord Scarman said (29) ibid., at pp 183–184: Parental rights . . . do not wholly disappear until the age of majority. . .. But the common law has never treated such rights as sovereign or beyond review
44
P. Mason and control. Nor has our law ever treated the child as other than a person with capacities and rights recognized by law. The principle of the law . . . is that parental rights are derived from parental duty and exist only so long as they are needed for the protection of the person and property of the child. A minor is, according to this principle, capable of giving informed consent when he or she “achieves a sufficient understanding and intelligence to enable him or her to understand fully what is proposed” (30) ibid., at p 189, and see pp 169, 194–195 (emphasis added).
• Neither a parent nor a fully competent minor can give an effective consent to all types of surgical operations or medical treatments. If the nature of the proposed treatment is invasive, irreversible and major surgery, and for non-therapeutic reasons, then court approval is required before such treatment can proceed.12 Marion’s case involved an application to the Family Court of Australia for an order authorizing performance of a hysterectomy and ovariectomy on Marion, who was a 14-year old intellectually disabled child. The purposes of the proposed procedures were prevention of pregnancy and menstruation and attendant psychological and behavioral consequences and to stabilize hormonal fluxes with the aim of helping to eliminate consequential stress and behavioral responses. The High Court decided that Marion’s guardian could not lawfully authorize the carrying out of the procedure without a Court authorization. The majority Judges in Marion’s case said: In a case such as the present one, it is primarily the prospect of surgical intervention which attracts the interest of the law. This is because the law treats as unlawful, both criminally and civilly, conduct which constitutes an assault on or a trespass to the person. Therefore it is the legality of the specific medical treatment amounting to a hysterectomy and ovariectomy . . . which must be the focus of this inquiry. However to characterize intervention compromising sterilization as ‘medical treatment’ is already to make assumptions and to narrow the inquiry, perhaps inappropriately. As will become clear, it is the very fact that sterilization implies more than medical, or surgical, treatment that is crucial to the central issue in this case13 (my emphasis).
The High Court went on to say: There are features of a sterilization procedure, or more accurately, factors involved in a decision to authorize sterilization of another person, which indicate that, in order to ensure the best protection of the interests of a child, such a decision should not come within the ordinary scope of parental power to consent to medical treatment.14
• The crux of the High Court’s decision is that Court authorization is required for a medical procedure that: ◦ Requires invasive, irreversible, and major surgery; and ◦ Is not for the purpose of curing a malfunction or disease ◦ Court authorization is required because of:
3
Non-Medical Circumcision of Boys in the Tasmanian and Australian Context
45
• the significant risk of making the wrong decision, either as to a child’s present or future capacity to consent or about the best interests of a child who cannot consent; and ◦ the consequences of a wrong decision are particularly grave. Subsequent cases about “special medical procedures” illustrate that the principles are not limited to sterilization and that there is a need to consider the specific procedure being contemplated from the perspective of what is in the best interests of the particular child. Other cases have concerned sex change therapy and surgery, again in pubescent and adolescent children. The Queensland Law Reform Commission15 concluded: The common law operating in Queensland appears to be that if the young person is unable, through lack of maturity or other disability, to give effective consent to a proposed procedure and if the nature of the proposed treatment is invasive, irreversible and major surgery and for non-therapeutic reasons, then court approval is required before such treatment can proceed. The court will not approve the treatment unless it is necessary and in the young persons’ best interests. It is not clear whether the test applied by the High Court is capable of extension to non-therapeutic circumcision of healthy boys.
Even if Court approval is required, the Family Court’s parens patriae does not extend to children whose parents have never married. If Marion represents the law, and if it applies to routine circumcision, then the Court of competent jurisdiction will be the Supreme Court of the State in which the child is resident.
Relevance of Paramountcy Principle—Best Interests The Family Court does have jurisdiction to determine disputes between parents (married or not) over “specific issues” relevant to parental responsibility, including circumcision. His Honor Strickland J in K and H [2003] Fam CA 1364 rejected a father’s application for an order permitting circumcision of an approximately 18-month-old boy for cultural and religious reasons and granted an application by a mother for an injunction restraining the father from permitting or causing to permit the child to be circumcised. The father, who was born in Tanzania and was raised a Muslim, argued that his Islamic faith and cultural issues obliged him to ensure his son was circumcised. Strickland J did not question that this was a procedure that parents are able to consent to as an aspect of their parental authority “unlike, for example, sterilization for non-therapeutic purposes.” Court involvement occurred simply because the parents could not agree. The Judge decided it was not in the best interests of the child to be circumcised, a procedure described as one that “is not medically indicated.” Factors of relevance included uncertainty about which religious path the child would follow, his ability to continue to be exposed to his father’s religion and culture even if uncircumcised, the fact he would be predominantly exposed to his mother’s culture and religion.
46
P. Mason
Medical Ethics The Royal Australasian College of Physicians 1998 publication “Ethics: A Manual for Consultant Physicians” lists the four moral values or obligations of most relevance in medicine as autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice.16 Autonomy Autonomy (or self rule) has been defined as the capacity to think and decide, and the capacity to act on the basis of such thought freely and independently. It is a basic moral obligation to respect each person’s autonomy. Respect for the autonomy of a patient is the moral principle on which the debate on informed consent has hinged. Beneficence The principle of beneficence relates to the obligation to do good/to act in the patient’s best interest. Non-maleficence Non-maleficence refers to the duty of not doing harm. Harm can include psychological, emotional, or social harm as well as physical damage.17 Justice This principle is related to the fair distribution of resources.
“Autonomy” is defined in the Concise Medical Dictionary18 as “selfdetermination, or the freedom to behave in ways that accord with one’s own values and objectives. Respect for the autonomy of the patient is one of the four principles of medical ethics.”
What Next? The Tasmanian Law Reform Institute is undertaking a project to review the current law regulating the circumcision of male children in Australia, with particular reference to Tasmania. The project will examine the criminal and civil responsibility of those who perform, aid, or instigate the procedure and will consider many of the issues raised above. This topic for law reform was suggested by the Tasmanian Commissioner for Children. An issues paper will be released in 2009.19
Notes 1. 2. 3. 4.
Article 2 UNCROC. Article 4 UNCROC. Article 5 UNCROC. Refer Narulla R. (2007) Circumscribing circumcision: Traversing the moral and legal ground around a hidden human rights violation. Aust J Hum Rights. 12(2):89–118, April 2007. 5. Section 178A of the Criminal Code Act 1924. 6. Taken from www.circinfo.net visited July 14, 2008. 7. Morris B, Bailis S, Castellsague X, Wiswell T, Halperin D. (2006) RACPs policy statement on infant male circumcision is ill-conceived. Aust N Z J Public Health. 30(1):16–21.
3
Non-Medical Circumcision of Boys in the Tasmanian and Australian Context
47
8. Richters J. (2006) A critical commentary on RACP policy statement on infant male circumcision: A response. Aust N Z J Public Health. 30(1):2–24. 9. Ibid., p 23. 10. S51 Criminal Code Act 1924 (Tasmania). 11. Department of Health and Human Services v JMB and SMB (Marion=s case) [1992] HCA 15 per Mason CJ, Dawson J, Toohey J and Gaudron J at p 7. 12. Ibid. 13. Marion=s case op cit at p 4. 14. Ibid., p 20. 15. QLRC Circumcision of Male Infants@ Miscellaneous Paper December 1993 at p 38. Statement of the law is based on the High Court of Australia decision Secretary Department of Health and Community Services v JWB and SMB (Marion=s case) (1992) 175 CLR 218. 16. Refer p 8 of the publication Ethics: A Manual for Consultant Physicians@ Ethics Committee of the RACP December 1998. 17. Concise Medical Dictionary. Oxford University Press 2007. Oxford Reference Online. Oxford University Press. State Library of Tasmania. 18. Aautonomy. (2007) n@ Concise Medical Dictionary. Oxford University Press. Oxford Reference Online. Oxford University Press. State Library of Tasmania. 19. http://www.law.utas.edu.au/reform/malecircumcision.htm
Chapter 4
Mass Campaigns of Male Circumcision for HIV Control in Africa: Clinical Efficacy, Population Effectiveness, Political Issues Michel Garenne
Abstract This paper reviews the demographic evidence for the relationship between male circumcision and HIV infection in national or sub-national African populations. A meta-analysis based on 18 countries, representing more than half of the population of sub-Saharan Africa, shows no relationship [standardized odds ratio = 1.00; 95% CI: 0.96–1.05]. There were even more countries in which HIV prevalence was higher among circumcised persons than countries where it was lower. In only five countries, the odds ratio of HIV prevalence (circumcised/intact) was significantly different from 1.0; three countries where it was higher, and two countries where it was lower. The contrast between lack of demographic impact and results from clinical trial is striking, and can probably be explained by the low clinical efficacy in situations of intense and repeated exposure, and by the interactions with the many other determinants of HIV spread. This paper also addresses some ethical and political issues, and in particular raises the question of power abuse, which may lie in the practice of genital mutilations and relevant international recommendations. Keywords Male circumcision · HIV/AIDS · Clinical efficacy · Population effectiveness · Randomized controlled trials · Ecological studies · Sub-Saharan Africa
Introduction In the study of the impact of public health interventions, two types of evidence can be opposed: the measure of “clinical efficacy,” or “biological effect,” shown in general by clinical trials or epidemiologic studies, and the measure of “population effectiveness,” or “demographic impact,” shown by their effect in large populations M. Garenne (B) IRD (French Institute for Research and Development) and Institut Pasteur, Paris, France e-mail:
[email protected]
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_4, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
49
50
M. Garenne
or by comparison between populations. Clinical trials aim primarily at demonstrating a biological effect, but they do not guarantee a large demographic impact. Conversely, a demographic impact is sometimes observed even when clinical trials tend to indicate a low effect. When clinical efficacy is very high (say above 95%), the population impact is usually marked, and close to what can be expected from clinical trials. When clinical efficacy is moderate (say around 50%), the population impact is often small, when not negligible. In rare studies, one also finds cases of population impact despite low clinical efficacy. Let us give a few examples in the field of vaccines. The measles vaccine has a very high clinical efficacy, considered to be above 95%. This has been shown repeatedly in numerous randomized clinical trials all over the world, and similar values are found in case control studies (Redd et al., 1999). The measles vaccine is also an “efficient” vaccine: when administered on a large scale, not only does it protect those who received it, but it also tends to reduce the transmission, and even to stop epidemics through herd immunity. Measles was virtually eradicated from the United States in the early 1980s by mass vaccination campaigns, and came back only because it was re-introduced from foreign countries (Wood and Brunell, 1995). The cholera vaccine has an efficacy of about 50% in clinical trials, but has virtually no demographic impact: it does not stop epidemics, and its protection is short lasting (Tacket and Sack, 2008). This is why it is not recommended in public health programs. The pertussis vaccine (whoopingcough) is a vaccine that has a very low efficacy in clinical trials, and has been shown to provide no protection against infection by the germ (Bordetella pertussis). However, it has a very large population effect, stopping epidemics and protecting individuals against the severe forms of the diseases, and its population effectiveness is close to that of the measles vaccine (Edwards and Decker, 2008; Pollard, 1980). This is why it is used in most vaccination programs, and it is part of the Expanded Program on Immunization recommended by the World Health Organization. Similar comparisons can be made in the field of contraception, an issue more closely related to the control of sexually transmitted infections (STIs). The hormonal contraceptives (pill, injectables, implants) or the barrier methods, such as the Intra-Uterine-Device (IUD), have a very high efficacy in clinical trials, usually above 99%. They also have very high population effectiveness: women who use them properly have no unwanted pregnancy, and populations who use them on a large scale have a low fertility, close to that desired by couples. On the contrary, the Rhythm Method (Knauss-Ogino Method), which is based on very sound biological evidence and has a moderate efficacy in clinical trials (around 50%), has virtually no population effect nor any individual effect: women who use it tend to become pregnant sooner or later, and no country was able to control its fertility only with this method (Labbok and Queenan, 1989). Its only visible effect is a lengthening of birth intervals, which does not permit to bring fertility from 7 or 8 children to 2 children, as do very effective methods. The withdrawal method (coitus interruptus) will never be investigated in clinical trials since it involves primarily
4
Mass Campaigns of Male Circumcision for HIV Control in Africa
51
a very personal behavior, but was shown empirically to have a major population impact since this was the most common method to control fertility in Europe before 1950. The case of efficacy and effectiveness of male circumcision for controlling HIV transmission bears some similarity with that of the rhythm method to control fertility. In a series of recent clinical trials, male circumcision was found to have an average clinical efficacy against HIV transmission (Auvert et al., 2005; Bailey et al., 2007; Gray et al., 2007). Is this enough to make recommendations for general use? Beyond clinical efficacy and demographic impact, are there not other issues related with such a practice? In this paper, we will focus on a lack of evidence showing a demographic impact of male circumcision on the HIV epidemics in sub-Saharan Africa, the continent most hard hit by the disease. We also address briefly some of the ethical issues raised by the recommendation for male circumcision (WHO/UNAIDS, 2007), viewed from an international health perspective.
Methods In order to investigate the population impact of male circumcision, we will use several comparisons: – Comparing population groups that are circumcised and not circumcised in the same country, which assumes comparable exposure to the disease (prevalence or incidence); – Comparing sub-groups known to have different risks, in the same way; – Comparing countries that are practicing or not practicing circumcision. There are serious caveats involved in these comparisons. In Africa, sub-groups practicing—or not practicing—male circumcision are usually defined by ethnicity or religion, sometimes associated with social status or urban residence, and may not be comparable in terms of exposure, since they have different value systems, different marriage patterns, and different sexual behaviors. The case is even worse for country comparisons, where many other factors could bias the comparisons, and we will see some examples later. Nevertheless, when a public health intervention is very efficient, its demographic impact is largely independent of any social variable, such as social status, religion, or ethnicity. There are many examples in the literature, and they apply similarly to the fields of vaccination, contraception, or medical treatments. The effect of vaccines, hormonal contraceptives, antibiotics, antimalarial drugs, etc., is basically the same in all countries in the world, and their population effect is simply proportional to the population coverage. Therefore, when there is no visible demographic impact, one can seriously question the usefulness of a public health intervention.
52
M. Garenne
Results HIV Prevalence and Proportion Circumcised at National Level The first comparison deals with HIV prevalence between circumcised and intact men in generalized epidemics, some 20–25 years after the onset of the HIV epidemic, that is the situation in years 2002–2007. It measures basically a net effect of circumcision, before changing behavior (condom use, reducing number of partners) really took off and changed the ecological correlations. The data are drawn from the Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS), which are large scale surveys based on representative samples of African populations [all available on the DHS website], and on a similar survey conducted in South Africa, not part of the DHS program (South Africa, 2002). For a statistician, this is the best scenario for testing a potential demographic impact, since the surveys display at the same time the HIV serologic status and the circumcision status for men aged 15–49 or 15–59 years. A first analysis was done a few years ago, and published in 2008 in the African Journal of AIDS Research (Garenne, 2006, 2008). The data were updated with more recent surveys (Congo, Zambia, South Africa), so that 18 countries’ surveys are now included, covering about 55% of the population of sub-Saharan Africa.
Table 4.1 HIV seroprevalence by circumcision status in African countries Percent
Percent HIV+
Ratio circumcised/intact
Country
Circumcised
Circumcised
Intact
RR
Burkina Faso Cameroon Côte d’Ivoire Congo Kinshasa Ethiopia Ghana Kenya Lesotho Liberia Malawi Niger Rwanda South Africa Swaziland Tanzania Uganda Zambia Zimbabwe Meta-analysis
89.7 91.8 96.0 97.7 92.3 95.3 83.4 48.6 97.8 20.7 99.5 11.1 35.3 8.2 69.7 24.9 12.5 10.5
1.8 4.1 2.8 1.0 0.9 1.6 3.0 22.8 1.1 13.2 1.0 3.5 12.3 21.8 6.5 3.8 10.8 16.6
2.9 1.1 3.8 0.0 1.1 1.4 12.6 15.2 0.0 9.5 0.0 2.1 12.0 19.5 5.6 5.6 12.5 14.2
0.62 3.73 0.74 1.00 0.82 1.14 0.24 1.50 1.00 1.39 1.00 1.67 1.03 1.12 1.16 0.68 0.86 1.17 1.00
Significance NS
∗
NS NS NS NS ∗ ∗
NS ∗
NS NS NS NS NS ∗
NS NS NS
Note: Sources of data are published DHS reports and HSRC study for South Africa. ∗ p < 0.05.
4
Mass Campaigns of Male Circumcision for HIV Control in Africa
53
Results show no effect of male circumcision in national African populations: the standardized odds-ratio was 1.00 (95% CI: 0.96–1.05), which means that, on the average, circumcised and intact men have the same HIV prevalence (Table 4.1). Out of the 18 countries studied, 12 have an odds ratio equal or higher than one (more HIV among circumcised men), 3 of them statistically significant (Cameroon, Lesotho, Malawi), and 6 have an odds ratio lower than one (less HIV among circumcised men), 2 of them statistically significant (Kenya and Uganda). Note that these results are based on large numbers: some 73,800 men sampled, who are representative of the general population. This is the most reliable evidence that we have on the population impact of male circumcision in Africa.
Case Studies Let us give a closer look at a few selected countries, for which, contrary to expectations, the risk ratio of HIV prevalence (circumcised/intact) is higher than 1. In Tanzania, HIV prevalence is moderate, with some 6.3% of men infected. The epidemic has been going on for about 25 years, since the western part of the country is close to the epicenter of the epidemic, located around Lake Victoria. There are some 110 ethnic groups recorded in Tanzania, some 70% practicing male circumcision. This is a quasi-experimental situation. In Tanzania, HIV prevalence is higher among the circumcised groups (6.5% versus 5.6%). This is due in part to a correlation with urbanization: urban areas are at the same time more circumcised and have more HIV. But even if one controls for urbanization, the HIV prevalence is the same in the two groups: 9.7 and 9.5% in urban areas; 5.2 and 4.6% in rural areas, none of these differences being significant (Tanzania, 2005). Lesotho is a tiny country embedded in South Africa. The main feature of Lesotho is its ethnic homogeneity, all people belonging to the same group: the Southern Sotho. The country has been exposed for about 15 years to HIV, and prevalence is very high, with 19.3% of adult men infected. About half of the men are circumcised, which is again a quasi-experimental situation, almost ideal given the homogeneity of the ethnic composition. Here again, the profile of HIV prevalence is contrary to expectations: circumcised men are more infected by HIV: 22.8% versus 15.2% for intact men, and this is true in both urban (28.6% versus 17.3%) and rural areas (21.8% versus 14.5%), in the various ecological zones, and for various measures of social status (Lesotho, 2005). Malawi is a country located in South-Eastern Africa. Malawi has a rather high prevalence, with about 10% men infected, and the epidemic has been going on for about 20 years. Malawi is characterized by a strong dichotomy between North and South, and the dozen of ethnic groups recorded have major differences in demographic profiles and sexual behavior. The North is less circumcised and has less HIV, whereas the South is more circumcised and has more HIV, again contrary to expectations. As was the case in other countries, controlling for urbanization does not change the main picture: more HIV among the circumcised men. Ironically, when stratified by region, the relationship between circumcision and HIV
54
M. Garenne
prevalence is inverted: the more circumcised in a region, the higher is the seroprevalence (Malawi, 2005). A recent publication, based on a 2002 survey, also showed a similar pattern in South Africa, where about a third of the population is circumcised and HIV prevalence amongst the highest on record: there was no difference in HIV prevalence in 2002 between the two groups, even after controlling for a variety of factors (Connolly et al., 2008).
HIV Incidence, and Dynamics of the HIV Epidemic in South Africa Some authors have argued that male circumcision could change the dynamics of the epidemic by strongly reducing incidence and the net reproduction rate (Ro). This is not the case in South Africa, the only country where one can pursue this type of analysis, because routine HIV prevalence is recorded every year and published over a long period of time. South Africa also has a useful feature for analysis: about one third of men are circumcised; circumcision is primarily ethnic specific, and provinces are also largely ethnic specific. So, by comparing the dynamics of the HIV epidemic by province, one may infer the effect (or lack thereof) of circumcision in the general population. The nine provinces were classified into three groups: low, medium and high level of circumcision. Two indicators of the dynamics of the epidemic were computed: the average incidence between 1994 and 2004, and an estimate of the net reproduction rate of the epidemic between 1994 and 2004. Results again show no clear relationship between the prevalence of male circumcision and the prevalence of HIV: differences in incidence were small: 2.0, 2.5, 2.1%, and differences in net reproduction rates were even in the opposite order: higher in provinces with high level of circumcision than in those with low level (see details in Garenne, 2008). If one compares two contrasted provinces: one with no circumcision, the North-West province, populated by Tswana, and one with widespread circumcision, the Eastern Cape province, populated by Xhosa, one finds no difference in the dynamics of the epidemic from 1994 to 2004, and levels of seroprevalence were basically the same in 2004. In conclusion, large-scale demographic surveys, as well as routine seroprevalence surveys among pregnant women, do not show any consistent population impact of male circumcision on either HIV prevalence or HIV incidence. Male circumcision does not appear to be the “Magic Bullet” presented by other researchers and based on results from clinical trials.
Other Evidence of a Lack of Demographic Impact These findings are not really new, and could have been anticipated. Robert Van Howe conducted a large scale meta-analysis of the effect of male circumcision on
4
Mass Campaigns of Male Circumcision for HIV Control in Africa
55
HIV and other STIs in many risk groups, and found no protective effect. He even found a small increased risk in his meta-analyses (Van Howe, 1999a, b). Comparing the United States, where male circumcision is widespread, to Europe where it is rare, also goes rather in the opposite direction: more HIV in the former, and even more HIV transmitted heterosexually if one excludes cases imported from Africa in Europe. Even in the USA, the African-American population is more circumcised than average, and it is also more affected by HIV (Siegfried et al., 2007). Let us also remember that, in Africa, about 70% of men are already circumcised, probably the highest rate in any continent: this did not hamper Africa to host the largest epidemic in any continent. A quick comparison with Eastern Asia (China, Japan) where virtually no men are circumcised and where HIV prevalence is extremely low is illuminating: the correlation goes in the opposite direction— the less circumcision, the less HIV prevalence. In contrast, when one makes similar comparisons with vaccination coverage for diseases or with contraceptive use for fertility, one finds the expected correlations.
Controversy About Geographical Correlations Several studies conducted in the 1980s argued that African countries more affected by HIV were also less circumcised (Bongaarts et al., 1989; Moses et al., 1990; Weiss et al., 2000). This has been confirmed by recent population based studies, but is obviously correlated with other important confounding factors affecting sexual behavior, in particular, religion: Islam recommends male circumcision, but is very much opposed to any form of premarital and extramarital intercourse for women, therefore strongly reducing the risk of sexual transmission of diseases. In another paper, we argued that HIV was more closely related with marriage pattern and permissiveness, both being measured simultaneously by premarital fertility (having a birth prior to first marriage). The map displaying premarital fertility levels is in fact close to the map of HIV prevalence levels, revealing the other confounding factors (Zwang and Garenne, 2008). Therefore, the ecological correlation between HIV prevalence and male circumcision appears misleading, and seems to reflect primarily other determinants of HIV spread. However, one should note that no country for which we have reliable data where male circumcision is widespread (>85% circumcised), including non-Muslim countries, such as Congo-Kinshasa, had a high level of seroprevalence (>5% among adults 15–49). This fact has never been properly explained, and deserves more research. In summary, whatever the correlations, one has to remember that even a country half circumcised, such as Lesotho, can have a very large epidemic, with levels of seroprevalence close to the highest on record. This seems to give a far better picture of what could be the potential impact of mass circumcision campaigns: basically negligible in generalized epidemics.
56
M. Garenne
Population Impact Versus Clinical Efficacy The difference between the effect of male circumcision in clinical trials and the lack of any significant demographic effect may seem puzzling at first glance. The main reason seems to be the low level of clinical efficacy: a 50% reduction in risk is likely to have only a small demographic effect. Indeed, under repeated exposure, any circumcised man will eventually become infected, as will intact men. Circumcision does not really provide any protection, but simply reduces the risk at each exposure. This may delay the time to infection, but will rarely change the ultimate outcome, a situation similar to the effect of the rhythm method for contraception. The potential effect of mass circumcision campaigns will lead only to a very small impact, which will be buried into the many other factors of HIV transmission. If male circumcision had a 99% protective efficacy, the situation would have been different.
Discussion Rationale for Making Public Health Policies Let us ask now a simple question, based on the findings of the clinical trials: is a 50% reduction in risk enough to make a policy? The answer is clearly no. For instance, if one compares with the field of contraception: the rhythm method is also 50% efficient in clinical trials, but is not recommended, because there are much better strategies available for birth control. Likewise, the cholera vaccine is also 50% efficient in clinical trials, but is not recommended, because there are much better strategies available for controlling cholera. There are also better alternative strategies to control HIV, summarized under the acronym “ABC” (for Abstinence, Be faithful, Condom use), which have worked in Africa and elsewhere: changing risky behavior worked well, for instance, in Uganda (Low-Beer, 2002; Low-Beer and Stoneburner, 2003), and condom use worked extremely well in Thailand (Brown et al., 1994). We do not have a full account of what has been happening in Africa since year 2000, but in almost all countries for which data are available, prevalence and incidence among young adults have been going down over the past 10 years, as a result of changing behavior. These ABC strategies seem to be able to change the course of the HIV epidemics. On the other hand, no country has ever been able to control an STI with male circumcision only. Let us remember the case of Japan: this country has among the lowest rates of HIV and of any STI, and makes a very wide use of condoms. This seems to be a far better strategy for controlling sexually transmitted infections.
Ethical Considerations This paper focuses on the lack of demographic impact to be expected from male circumcision. Of course, there are many other dangers associated with mass
4
Mass Campaigns of Male Circumcision for HIV Control in Africa
57
circumcision campaigns. Firstly, at population level, shifting from ABC strategies, which, from experience, are the most likely to change the course of the epidemic to a strategy that has no chance of doing so, seems to be a serious mistake. Secondly, at the individual level, giving the impression that male circumcision “protects” against HIV transmission may have adverse effects: by giving a false sense of protection, it may induce riskier behaviors, and ultimately increase transmission. In this case, it will also have negative effects on the confidence that individuals have in the health system and in health education messages.
Ultimate Rationale of Male Circumcision Male circumcision is a form of genital mutilation with numerous implications, amply documented in this book and in the ten international symposia organized over the past 20 years. This in itself raises many ethical issues, widely documented elsewhere (Aggleton, 2007; Doctors Opposing (male) Circumcision, 2006; Clark, 2006). Beyond individual cases when it is recommended for medical reasons, at population level male circumcision appears as a form of power abuse, especially when made compulsory, or at least strongly recommended. It is especially questionable when used on infants, children, or adolescents since it violates their rights, but is also questionable when recommended for consenting adults. Numerous studies have highlighted the stakes behind this practice. For traditional societies, where circumcision is compulsory for adolescents, the power abuse comes from the elders. This is best expressed by Margaret Mead (1949), who had such a powerful insight on male circumcision. In her famous book, Male and Female, she says: . . . in South America, in Africa and in the South Seas, there are tribes in which the old men’s antagonism to the springing sexuality of the young induces fears that are later reduced in pantomine, cruel initiatory rites in which the young men are circumcised, their teeth knocked out, and, in various ways they are reduced and modified and humbled, and then permitted to be men.
When religious leaders recommend circumcision for newborns or young boys, the power abuse comes from religious hierarchy and applies to the whole society: by requesting the parents to accept the circumcision of their sons, the religious establishment ensures its power over the whole family. Robert Darby (2005) in his book, A Surgical Temptation, showed that the development of male circumcision for newborn infants in Victorian England is also a form of power abuse, this time coming from the medical establishment over the families. This came at a time when the political power of physicians and surgeons in society increased dramatically, and a new form of “biopower” emerged. The question that can be raised now is whether recommending mass circumcision campaigns for Africans, in the absence of clear evidence of any demographic impact, is not a new form of power abuse, this time from newly established groups:
58
M. Garenne
international institutions and lobbies? This question certainly deserves further comments and in-depth discussions.
References Aggleton P. (2007) Just a snip? A social history of male circumcision. Reprod Health Matters. 15(29):15–21. Auvert B, Taljaard D, Lagarde E, Sobngwi-Tambekou J, Sitta R, Puren A. (2005) Randomized, controlled intervention trial of male circumcision for reduction of HIV infection risk: The ANRS 1265 trial. PLOS Med. 2(11):e298, 1–111. Bailey RC, Moses S, Parker CB, Agot K, MacLean I, Krieger JN, Willams CFM, Campbell RT, Nidnya-Achola JO. (2007) Male circumcision for HIV prevention in young men in Kisumu, Kenya: A randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 369:643–656. Bongaarts J, Reining P, Way P, Conant F. (1989) The relationship between male circumcision and HIV infection in African populations. AIDS. 3(6):373–377. Brown T, Sittitrai W, Vanichseni S, Thisyakorn U. (1994) The recent epidemiology of HIV and AIDS in Thailand. AIDS. 8(Suppl 2):S131–S141. Clark PA. (2006) To circumcise or not to circumcise? Health Prog. 87(5):1–9. Connolly C, Simbayi LC, Shanmugam R, Nqeketo A. (2008) Male circumcision and its relationship to HIV infection in South Africa: Results of a national survey in 2002. S Afr Med J. 98(10):789–794. Darby R. (2005) A Surgical Temptation: The Demonization of the Foreskin and the Rise of Circumcision in Britain. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Demographic and Health Surveys. Web site: www.measuredhs.com Doctors opposing male circumcision. (2006) Medical Ethics and the Circumcision of Children. Report, 2006. Available on web site: http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/pdf/A4MedicalEthicsReport.pdf Edwards K, Decker M. (2008) Cholera vaccine. In: Plotkin SA, Orenstein WA. (eds.) Vaccines. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier-Saunders. Garenne M. (2006) Male circumcision and HIV control in Africa. PLoS Med. 3(1):e78.[Letter] Garenne M. (2008) Long-term population effect of male circumcision in generalized HIV epidemics in sub-Saharan Africa. Afr J AIDS Res. 7(1):1–8. Gray RH, Kigozi G, Serwadda D, Makumbi F, Watya S, Nalugoda F, Kiwanuka N, Moulton LH, Chaudhary MA, Chen MZ, Sewankambo NK, Wabwire-Mangen F, Bacon MC, Williams CFM, Opendi P, Reynolds SJ, Laeyendecker O, Quinn TC, Waver MJ. (2007) Male circumcision for HIV prevention in men in Rakai, Uganda: A randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 369:657–666. Labbok MH, Queenan JT. (1989) The use of periodic abstinence for family planning. Clin Obstet Gynecol. 32(2):387–402. Lesotho – Ministry of Health and Social Welfare (MOHSW), Bureau of Statistics (BOS), and ORC Macro. (2005) Lesotho Demographic and Health Survey 2004. Calverton, NY: MOH, BOS, and ORC Macro. Low-Beer D. (2002) HIV incidence and prevalence trends in Uganda. Lancet. 360(9347):1788. Low-Beer D, Stoneburner RL. (2003) Behaviour and communication change in reducing HIV: Is Uganda unique? Afr J AIDS Res. 1(2):9–21. Malawi – National Statistical Office (NSO), and ORC Macro. (2005) Malawi Demographic and Health Survey 2004. Calverton, NY: NSO and ORC Macro. Mead M. (1949) Male and Female: A Study of the Sexes in a Changing World. New York, NY: [Reprinted by Harper-Collins, 2002]. Moses S, Bradley JE et al. (1990) Geographical patterns of male circumcision practices in Africa. Int J Epidemiol. 19(3):693–697. Pollard R. (1980) Relation between vaccination and notification rates for whooping cough in England and Wales. Lancet. 1(8179):1180–1182.
4
Mass Campaigns of Male Circumcision for HIV Control in Africa
59
Redd SC, Markowitz LE, Katz SL. (1999) Measles vaccine. In: Plotkin SA, Orenstein WA. (eds.) Vaccines. Philadelphia, PA: W.B. Saunders, pp 222–266. Tacket C, Sack D. (2008) Cholera vaccine. In: Plotkin SA, Orenstein WA. (eds.) Vaccines. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier-Saunders. Siegfried N, Muller M, Volmink J, Deeks J, Egger M, Low N, Weiss H, Wlaker S, Williamson P. (2007) Male circumcision for prevention of heterosexual acquisition of HIV in men (Review). The Cochrane Library. South Africa. (2002) The Nelson Mandela/HSRC study of HIV/AIDS, 2002. Human Science Research Council, Cape Town, South Africa. [available on web site: www.hsrcpress.ac.za] Tanzania – Commission for AIDS (TACAIDS), National Bureau of Statistics (NBS), and ORC Macro. (2005) Tanzania HIV/AIDS Indicator Survey 2003–2004. Calverton, NY: TACAIDS, NBS, and ORC Macro. Van Howe RS. (1999a) Does circumcision influence sexually transmitted diseases? A literature review. BJU Int. 83(Supp 1):52–62. Van Howe RS. (1999b) Circumcision and HIV infection: Review of the literature and metaanalysis. Int J STD AIDS. 10:8–16. Weiss HA, Quigley MA, Hayes RK. (2000) Male circumcision and risk of HIV infection in subSaharan Africa: A systematic review and meta-analysis. AIDS. 174:2361–2370. Wood DL, Brunell PA. (1995) Measles control in the United States: Problems of the past and challenges for the future. Clin Microbiol Rev. 8(2):260–267. WHO/UNAIDS. (2007) Recommendations from expert consultation on male circumcision for HIV prevention. Available at: http://www.who.int/hiv/mediacentre/news68/en/index.html Zwang J, Garenne M. (2008) Premarital fertility and HIV/AIDS in Africa. Afr J Reprod Health. 12(1):64–74.
Chapter 5
AIDS XVII, Mexico City: Reason for Hope or Panic? John Geisheker
Abstract The XVIIth International Conference on AIDS in Mexico delivered a pleasant surprise to those of us who exhibited on behalf of the International Coalition for Genital Integrity: most of the African women delegates to whom we spoke, AIDS workers on the front lines, were skeptical that male circumcision (MC) would prove an HIV panacea of any worth. Indeed, many delegates described MC as a double trap for women. They worried aloud that “medically circumcised” men will tout themselves as uniquely immune to HIV and thus in no need of a condom. Delegates also noted that circumcision only protects HIV(–) men from HIV+ women, to only 60%, if it does that. It delivers no protection to HIV(–) women from infected men. Well-financed proponents of MC locked out any discussion or open forum on the issue in Mexico, and were quick to claim, “the train has already left the station.” How soon this first-time public health condemnation of a normal body part, an apparent well-financed fait accompli, stumbles remains the interesting question. Keywords Genital integrity · HIV · AIDS · Male circumcision · Cost benefits ratio In August 2008, three of us—the author, along with Georganne Chapin and Brian O’Donnell—traveled to Mexico City to staff a booth at the XVIIth International AIDS Conference. Georganne and I are lawyers by training. Georganne also runs Intact America and another nonprofit organization. Brian is a Physician Assistant, certified as an HIV specialist by the American Academy of HIV Medicine. Our intent was to highlight the risks and foolishness of the plan, floated by the World Health Organization (WHO), the US President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, the Joint United Nations Program on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), and the Gates Foundation, to introduce male circumcision (MC) as a putative HIV preventative. Our 10-foot banner, Male Circumcision: A Dangerous Distraction of Poor Ethics and Bad Medicine, stretched directly across from the main elevator, and—through J. Geisheker (B) Doctors Opposing Circumcision, Seattle, WA, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_5, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
61
62
J. Geisheker
pure good fortune—was the first thing the delegates saw upon entering the exhibit hall. Our message was highly controversial. Often, our booth was crowded with conference delegates waiting to engage us, and visitors, including other conference exhibitors, wanting to chat before and after official hours. Multiple delegates from virtually every country in Africa, except Liberia and Tunisia, and many others from around the world sought us out. Our most effective argument, if confined to 60 or 90 seconds, was a simple and effective four-part critique, which we adapted as the occasion warranted: 1. The cost of male circumcision (MC) would siphon off much of the available AIDS funding. Money should properly go to condoms and education, which are affordable and have been proven effective. These simple methods only wait strong endorsement from local governments. Such plans barely have been implemented, and have also been thwarted by previous US administrations, apparently responding to pressure from religious interests. 2. MC carries substantial risks in village settings, where trained personnel, antiseptic conditions, and even clean water are scarce, and where follow-up care for infection and botches are non-existent. 3. Even if MC confers the 60% protection for men claimed by its advocates, this is not vaccine-level protection. Presenting MC as a “magic bullet” yielding “lifetime protection” as proponents have done is an irresponsible and unethical invitation to an epidemiological disaster if proven methods of sexual hygiene are not also practiced rigorously. Moreover, if simple methods of sexual hygiene are necessary to decrease the risks of infection even in a circumcised male, why bother with the cost and risks of MC? 4. MC increases—inarguably and obviously—the risk of infection to women. Even the claimed effect only protects men from infected women and then only to 60%—if you believe the studies. Even if we accept the findings of the three randomized controlled trials that allege a protective effect for circumcision (and there is much criticism of the methodology in the scientific press), circumcision would do nothing to protect an HIV-negative woman from an infected male. Thus, we were able to argue that medically circumcised men are likely to present themselves, especially to poor or illiterate village women, as rendered surgically immune to HIV. This last point seemed to resonate best with those delegates with whom we spoke. To visitors who remained longer at our booth, we offered the following additional arguments: Some men are likely to boast that their “medical” circumcision confers unique protection from HIV, and is thus superior to tribal or bush initiation rites. Indeed, the white, North American proponents of MC for Africa publicly claimed in Mexico City that traditional African MC methods “are not thorough enough,” raising the lucrative, and for some proponents, a giddily titillating prospect of re-circumcising all of the hundreds of millions of
5
AIDS XVII, Mexico City: Reason for Hope or Panic?
63
already ritually circumcised males in Africa. Their own studies showed that circumcised men felt “confident” they would not catch HIV, which suggests a dangerous, misguided reliance on Western medicine. Proponents apparently sensed neither the risk nor the irony. Focusing on MC creates a parallel disincentive to use condoms, which provide other benefits—notably preventing unwanted pregnancies, as well as control of other sexually transmitted infections. Brian O’Donnell, who had worked in HIV programs in South Africa, observed that promoting condoms and emphasizing their correct use has never been made a priority. In that country, for example, the only condom available for free (and ironically called “CHOICE”) smelled medicinal, and was available in only one size. Two or three health ministers who stopped by our booth remarked that they were afraid that if the word got out in their predominantly Muslim countries that circumcision protected men from HIV, all the work they had done to encourage the use of condoms would be forgotten and the incidence of HIV and other STDs would go up. Many predicted that HIV would also increase in Sub-Saharan Africa, as a result of men believing that their newly performed circumcisions will confer protection. Medical care in Africa has already proved a vector for HIV infections, as expensive one-use supplies are routinely re-used, when HIV-infected men and women, not yet tested or as yet undetectable, seek medical attention for any reason.1 This problem will explode with mass circumcision, as the supposed “single-use” surgical kits will be redeployed within populations with high HIV prevalence. The shortage of skilled circumcisers will be an ongoing problem, and will exacerbate the already significant risks and harms of circumcision. Proponents of MC admitted that there will never be sufficient resources, financial or human, to enlist physicians or surgeons for their massive, continent-wide plan. Instead, they conceded that the best they could do is train paraprofessionals to perform this single procedure and no other. In fact, they admitted in Mexico City that most likely to be trained are “bush” circumcisers, men who for centuries have used unsanitary techniques that kill a hundred or more South African young men each year. It is unlikely those same practitioners will observe consistent antisepsis let alone be trained to deal with the many complications that MC creates even in the modern hospital settings of the developed world. “Bush” circumcisions are themselves a proven vector for HIV. Bush circumcisers will not suddenly begin to autoclave their pot shards, sharpened sticks, and discarded razor blades, simply because US medical consultants request they do so.2 Male genital cutting (MGC) might halt the progress made in discouraging female genital cutting (FGC), or worse, may cause it to spring up unbidden where it never flourished before. One reason is that, if mucosal tissue is the culprit, women have much more of the “warm, moist, mucosa,” so feared by male circumcision proponents, than men. Example: A Tanzanian study of
64
J. Geisheker
circumcised women shows a similar protective effect, though that study has received very little press for obvious reasons.3 We repeatedly emphasized that, from an ethical standpoint, there is no distinction between male and female cutting, and others were also pointing this out. Georganne reported that, at one session she attended, an African woman in the audience at a panel on male circumcision asked the question: “How shall we tell our people that girls must be left with the bodies that God gave them, while at the same time we propose to cut all of our boys?” Unfortunately, this perspective was not featured at the conference. Promoting MC pits one culture against another. In Kenya, the Luo tribe (the tribe of Barack Obama’s father) does not circumcise, yet they are being blamed for the HIV epidemic by the Kikuyu, who do practice circumcision. During recent hostilities, Kikuyu men kidnapped and forcibly circumcised any Luo men or boys they could entrap.4 Such tribal tensions will be exacerbated if circumcision is introduced indiscriminately, risking the same genocide that ravaged the Hutu and Tutsi in Uganda. Indeed, the Luo already blame white researchers for the perception that they are the source of HIV/AIDS. MC will enforce and propound genital cutting traditions for centuries to come. Anthropologists note that genital cutting, especially of children, is invariably intractable, as its victims grow up to impose it on the young and powerless as it was imposed on them. This cycle, as FGC opponents have noted, is difficult to break. Thus, the WHO HIV plan will have a tragic side-effect: genital cutting rituals, which South Africa, for instance, has tried to outlaw for minors, will become “medicalized” and normalized, blessed by the Western medical establishment, and hence nearly impossible to eradicate. The United States itself is an example of this phenomenon, with its 140-year genital-cutting tradition (girls were included for many decades) brokered and sustained by the medical establishment entirely for reasons of its own. The belief that genital amputations are the ultimate and preferred solution to sexually transmitted diseases will become a deeply rooted and unquestioned custom in Africa, which already has many different and ancient traditions of genital cutting imposed on children. Even if the WHO/PEPFAR/Gates Foundation plan eventually fails, for reasons of cost, or morbidity, or “patient” resistance—or an AIDS vaccine is eventually found—the notion of genital cutting as a first-line medical intervention will have done massive anthropological damage. It may take centuries to recover from this Western interference in diverse African cultures, and tens of millions of children are likely to pay the highest price. After 5 days of engaging about 800 people—many of whom were AIDS workers on the front lines in Africa—at our booth, in elevators, and on our daily bus-ride, we were able to draw some sobering conclusions: Europeans from all countries and backgrounds with only rare exceptions agreed with our message. Our few vocal critics were invariably North Americans,
5
AIDS XVII, Mexico City: Reason for Hope or Panic?
65
some doubtless with a financial, professional, personal, or religious stake in legitimizing and promoting male circumcision. African women were the most astute in their instant recognition of the social risks; African men were less so, as you might expect. The vast majority of these women—to be fair, educated, traveled, and urbane—thought the WHO, UNAIDS, PEPFAR, Gates Foundation plan was not only wasteful, but also a “trap” for village women. They often arrived already skeptical and took little effort to convince. The question remains whether their resistance will make a difference at the local level or whether they will be marginalized or steamrolled by the huge sums of money flowing toward their local officials from the proponents of MC.
All in all, this was an inspiring, if exhausting, experience. The conundrum remains how First-World circumcision proponents can remain so single-minded and intransigent while individual citizens of the target countries they claim to be “saving” understand the village-level risks and costs. We think this is simply a modern example of colonial medicine, complicated by a failure to learn from past failed efforts, such as vasectomy programs in India and an almost exclusive medical-model approach. A number of social scientists present complained to us that their warnings had been ignored in favor of purely biomedical computer modeling. Most of all, though, the increasing focus on male circumcision is due to the huge sums, hundreds of millions, made available by the Gates Foundation and UNAIDS, and publicly represented by former US president Bill Clinton, who appeared again, as he had in Toronto in 2006. We wonder whether a Health Minister of a small, impoverished African country (or a Johns Hopkins or Harvard professor reeling in lucrative grants) would turn away billions of dollars, no matter how it was earmarked. Indeed, we observed that much of that money is likely to evaporate through graft and political corruption and will never be used for its stated purpose. Flying back to the States, by chance I found myself seated next to Dr. Marcus Conant, an HIV physician from San Francisco (featured in the film And the Band Played On), who, before the advent of anti-retroviral therapies (ART), lost thousands of patients to AIDS. Initially, I did not know who he was. When he asked me whether I was at the conference, I offered him my Doctors Opposing Circumcision business card, to which he said, “Well, meet another doc opposing circumcision.” He went on to say, “I do not feel that widespread circumcision is a panacea for stopping the AIDS epidemic.” And, indeed, WHO and UNAIDS are already floating that plan, without the slightest qualm, having moved swiftly, in barely five years, from voluntary adult circumcisions (about which, epidemiological worries aside, there is little to say if there is honest informed consent) to MC for infants, where consent is irrelevant, mandates easy to impose, and the bioethics disgraceful. Since August of 2008, several interesting developments have changed the scheme to impose circumcision as a panacea for HIV: The recent Wawer study showed that circumcised men were more likely to transmit HIV to the female partner than the uncircumcised male, 21% vs. 13%, more
66
J. Geisheker
than a 150% differential. The study was aborted due to “futility.” It would be interesting to know what the long-term sero-conversion results might have been. Surely, this rate would rise over time. The author of the study, an admitted “MC-for-Africa” proponent, confessed that she was “disappointed” but admitted, “the data are what they are.”5 An HIV vaccine, actually a combination of two vaccines previously found ineffective individually, has shown a 30% reduction in HIV, though that conclusion has been hotly contested.6 If proven, even a vaccine showing a 30% reduction is in practice better than the 60% claim of prophylaxis via circumcision, since a vaccine has the potential to protect everyone in all directions, every vector—male, female, adult, or child, regardless of infection source or sexual practice. By contrast, even MC proponents admit that the African randomized controlled trials, if they are to be believed, indicate that MC only protects heterosexual men from infected women, a single, one-way vector among many. We strongly doubt, however, the veracity of the results of these studies. Campaigns to encourage condom use, “all the time, every time,” have been successful in Eastern Uganda, Senegal, Swaziland, and Thailand, and death rates and new infections are dropping due to better access to anti-retroviral therapies.7 Of course, a vaccine with an effective rate of 90% or more would still be the goal and, at that point, mass circumcision campaigns, by comparison, would be so expensive and cumbersome to implement they would be ludicrous to promote and would soon perish. Nevertheless, before that day finally arrives, how many African cultures and how many millions of men and boys will be damaged by circumcision? Acknowledgments I wish to thank my colleagues, Georganne Chapin and Brian O’Donnell, for their fellowship in Mexico City as well as their assistance in preparing this analysis of our advocacy there.
Notes 1. Brody S, Potterat JJ. (2005) HIV epidemiology in Africa: Weak variables and tendentiousness generate wobbly conclusions. PLoS Med. 2(5):e137. 2. Hrdy DB. (1987) Cultural practices contributing to the transmission of human immunodeficiency virus in Africa. Rev Infect Dis. 9(6):109–119. 3. Female Circumcision and HIV Infection in Tanzania: For Better or for Worse? Rebecca Y. Stallings, 2 Statisticus Consultoris, USA and Emilian Karugendo, National Bureau of Statistics, Tanzania. And see: http://www.ias-2005.org/planner/Presentations/ppt/3138.ppt 4. http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5gkiZSdchTFFEy7rFhYWAK4z6Zc8Q http://africanarguments.org/2009/07/watu-wazima-a-gender-analysis-of-forced-malecircumcisions-during-kenya’s-post-election-violence/ 5. www.thelancet.com “Circumcision in HIV-infected men and its effect on HIV transmission to female partners in Rakai, Uganda: A randomised controlled trial.” Wawer MJ, et al. The Lancet. 374(9685):229–237. July 18, 2009, doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60998-3. 6. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/8272113.stm 7. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8375297.stm
Chapter 6
Circumcision Psychopathology George C. Denniston
Abstract Circumcision psychopathology is defined as a personality disorder characterized by a cluster of interpersonal, affective, lifestyle, and antisocial traits and behaviors, including grandiosity, egocentricity, deceptiveness, shallow emotions, lack of empathy or remorse, irresponsibility, impulsivity, and a strong tendency to violate ethical norms. In this article, standard methods for the assessment of circumcision psychopathy are outlined. Circumcision psychopathy is conceptually similar to antisocial personality disorder (ASPD) from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV). However, at the measurement level, the former places more emphasis on interpersonal and affective features and their links to broad antisocial tendencies, while the latter emphasizes overt antisocial behaviors. Its association with antisocial personality disorder (ASPD) and its implications for clinical and forensic issues, including risk assessment, crime and violence are discussed. Circumcision psychopathy is associated with an increased risk for antisocial behavior, deviant sexual impulses, and presents the mental health and criminal justice systems with a formidable therapeutic challenge. Keywords Male circumcision · Antisocial personality disorder · Psychopathology · Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders · Antisocial behavior · Deviant sexual impulses
Introduction Circumcision psychopathy is a personality disorder common among medical and religious circumcisers as well as advocates of circumcision defined by a cluster of interpersonal, affective, lifestyle, and antisocial traits and behaviors, including grandiosity, egocentricity, deceptiveness, shallow emotions, lack of empathy
G.C. Denniston (B) Doctors Opposing Circumcision (D.O.C.), Seattle, WA, USA
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_6, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
67
68
G.C. Denniston
or remorse, ruthlessness, determination, irresponsibility, impulsivity, cognitive dissonance, sexual deviance, and a strong tendency to violate ethical norms. This disorder has a long history among circumcisers operating within specific religious (Jewish and Muslim) groups and now, more recently among Western (specifically United States) medical professionals since the imposition of mass circumcision on the United States population in the middle of the twentieth century. The ethical and legal principles and instruments that would prohibit circumcision include the Nuremberg Code of Ethics, the Hippocratic Oath, every one of The American Medical Association’s Principles of Ethics, and the Good Medical Practice Statement of the General Medical Council in the United Kingdom. Doctors afflicted with circumcision psychopathy may be aware of these documents, but they either consider them irrelevant to circumcision or a hindrance to be ignored and suppressed. Because circumcision psychopathy is associated with so much social, sexual, and personal damage and distress, the basic and applied research endeavors are now supplemented by the provision of forums for victims to discuss their problems. Groups such as NORM-UK, NORM (US), Doctors Opposing Circumcision (DOC), and the National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers (NOCIRC) have created affiliated groups where victims of circumcision are free to discuss their experience and seek counseling. Attempts to understand and deal with doctors afflicted by circumcision psychopathy, and to communicate research findings to professionals and the public, may be impeded by confusion about what is meant by the term. For this reason, we begin with a brief discussion of the construct of circumcision psychopathy, followed by a few comments about the conceptually related anti-social personality disorder (ASPD), described in the DSM-IV.
Circumcision Psychopathy Briefly, circumcision psychopathy is a personality disorder that includes a cluster of interpersonal, affective, lifestyle, and antisocial traits and behaviors. On the interpersonal level, medical professionals with circumcision psychopathy are grandiose, deceptive, dominant, superficial, and manipulative. Affectively, they lack guilt, remorse or empathy with their victims. The interpersonal and affective features are fundamentally tied to a deviant lifestyle that includes irresponsible, monomaniacal obsession with circumcision, ruthless determination to justify and impose mass circumcision, and a tendency to ignore or violate ethical conventions and mores. Typically, such offenders are circumcised males, though the disorder has been observed in female doctors.
Causes of Circumcision Psychopathy The common denominator linking all male offenders with circumcision psychopathy is that they themselves were subjected to circumcision in infancy. Latent post-traumatic stress disorder and other long-term psychological problems
6
Circumcision Psychopathology
69
stemming from infant circumcision have been well documented.1 This psychological harm may stem from the trauma of the surgery, which is usually performed without benefit of anesthetic. The harm may also result from the shocking realization, later in life, that a significant part of the body was amputated. Sufferers of circumcision psychopathy, however, appear to have evolved a psychological coping mechanism designed to protect the ego by justifying the loss of the body part and, as with the Helsinki Syndrome, by identifying with the goals of the perpetrators. Still, other sufferers of circumcision psychopathy appear to have adopted the aggressive stance of “If I cannot have a foreskin, then I will make sure that no one else can have one either.” The second commonality linking all male sufferers of circumcision psychopathy is that they have deliberately and assiduously maneuvered themselves into professional positions where they can unleash their impulses to perform circumcisions or advocate for circumcision. Sufferers, therefore, are to be found among any professional group that is normally charged with performing circumcisions, such as pediatricians, obstetricians, urologists, and family practitioners. Similarly, sufferers without the impulse to perform circumcisions in a professional setting may manifest their disorder by moving themselves into research positions where they can carry out studies that appear to support mass involuntary circumcision. Currently, all of the putative studies purporting that circumcision prevents AIDS, most of which come from the pens of a small handful of researchers, provide very strong evidence of being the product of sufferers of circumcision psychopathy, as will be explained below. Female sufferers of circumcision psychopathy are rare, but do exist. Typically, they are motivated by misplaced loyalty to circumcised male family members, loyalty to the medical profession, or loyalty to a traditionally circumcising ethnic or religious community, such as Jews or Muslims. Many female offenders are motivated to rationalize the circumcisions that they performed in the past or motivated to rationalize and justify their personal responsibility for the decision to subject their own male offspring to circumcision. One researcher was privately informed by a female medical circumciser that she was motivated to perform circumcisions because she wanted to punish males “where it counts” for perceived injustices done to her and to other females throughout history. Psychopathy of this sort provides evidence to support Freud’s theory that circumcision is a partial and a symbolic castration.2
CPCL Assessment of Circumcision Psychopathy The Circumcision Psychopathy Checklist (CPCL) is designed to measure the clinical construct of circumcision psychopathy; however, because of its demonstrated ability to predict recidivism, it may be used in forensic assessments, either on its own or, more appropriately, as part of a battery of variables relevant to forensic psychology and psychiatry. Briefly, the CPCL is a twenty-item clinical rating scale that uses case history information, observation of the subject in public settings where he or she has
70
G.C. Denniston
advocated for circumcision to the lay public, careful observation of the subject’s actions and reactions when debating circumcision with professional critics of circumcision, analysis of the subject’s published writings on the subject of circumcision, and, finally, specific scoring criteria to rate each item on a 3-point scale (0, 1, 2) according to the extent to which it applies to a given medical professional. The items and the factors they comprise are listed in Table 6.1. Table 6.1 Circumcision Psychopathology Checklist F1 Interpersonal 1. Glibness—superficial charm used when dealing with the media, the public, and other medical professionals 2. Grandiose sense of self-worth 3. Pathological lying—lying about medical and anatomical facts to the public, to patients, and to parents of potential victims 4. Conning—manipulative Affective 5. Lack of remorse or guilt 6. Shallow affect 7. Callous—lack of empathy 8. Failure to accept responsibility 9. Conscious disregard or disdain for medical ethical standards, which, if followed, would prohibit circumcision F2 Lifestyle 10. Unquenchable need to find justifications for personal circumcised status 11. Paranoia—frequently among Jewish offenders, ‘Holocaust paranoia’ 12. Unquenchable need to defend ethnic identity, perceived to be under attack 13. Ruthlessness in dealing with opponents of circumcision 14. Irresponsibility—jeopardizing professional reputation through single-minded circumcision advocacy 15. Monomaniacal obsession with circumcision—obsession with finding new rationales to impose the surgery on others Antisocial 16. Sexual deviance—pedophilic or homosexual arousal while performing, or fantasies about performing, circumcisions 17. Sadistic impulse to control and/or destroy the sexual functions of other males 18. Disgust for and refusal to acknowledge normal penile anatomy and function 19. Disgust for individuals and ethnic groups with intact genitalia 20. Willingness to falsify or distort research data in order to promote circumcision
Total scores can range from 0 to 40 and reflect the degree to which the circumciser matches the prototypical psychopathic person. A CPCL cut-off score of 10 has proven useful for classifying people for research and applied purposes as psychopathic. Analysis reveals that CPCL scores in the upper range appear to reflect much the same level of circumcision psychopathy in North American male doctor
6
Circumcision Psychopathology
71
offenders as they do in non-medical religious circumcisers. Nonetheless, we note that there are ethnic and gender differences in the functioning of individual CPCL items and in the external correlates of the CPCL and other measures of psychopathy. The patterning and significance of these differences are the subject of much of the current empirical research on circumcision psychopathy. When conducting an assessment, it is important to use all information available to provide a complete picture of the person. In each case, the CPCL must be used properly and in accordance with the highest ethical and professional standards. Clinicians who use the CPCL must be prepared to outline the information used to score the items and to explain and justify the manner in which they scored the items. There are no exclusion criteria for use of the CPCL. It can be administered to offenders with various professional involvements in the circumcision industry. Therefore, it is possible to have symptoms similar to psychopathy, as measured by the CPCL scales, and other psychiatric disorders (for example, delusions of grandeur in psychotic disorders, inflated self-importance in narcissistic personality disorder, and grandiose self-worth in psychopathy). A primary strength of the CPCL is its ability to provide empirical evidence that not all doctors who perform circumcisions are necessarily afflicted with circumcision psychopathy. Many doctors who perform circumcisions do so merely because they are innocently following orders and have no personal motivations behind their actions. While the excuse of “just following orders” does not exculpate a medical professional from a charge of wrong doing, as demonstrated in the Nuremberg Trials following World War II, it does elucidate the pressure placed on doctors to conform and obey while ignoring the ethical implications of their actions.
Factor Structure As shown in Table 6.1, F1 reflected the interpersonal and affective components of the disorder, whereas F2 was more closely allied with a socially deviant lifestyle (the lifestyle and antisocial factors in Table 6.1). The psychopathological factors are significantly interrelated. The pattern of correlations among the factors, as well as confirmatory factor analyses also confirm the presence of two broad factors, identical with the original F1 and the other the same as the original F2. Because the CPCL factors are substantially correlated, it is important to examine the combined effects of elevations on both of these factors. Put in more clinical terms, a syndrome of circumcision psychopathy is likely typified by a doctor who chronically presents with elevated scores on both factors, not just one of these factors. Consistent with this idea, preliminary research by this author found that the interaction of F1 and F2 was critical for predicting offenders’ ethical conduct in the professional setting, predisposition toward performing circumcisions, and violent and aggressive behavior toward opponents of circumcision.
72
G.C. Denniston
Antisocial Personality Disorder The DSM-IV states that Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD) “has also been referred to as psychopathy, sociopathy, or dissocial personality disorder The Disorders section for ASPD in DSM-IV clearly describes ASPD by personality features that are an essential part of the circumcision psychopathy construct.3 The association between ASPD and circumcision psychopathy is generally asymmetric: most people with ASPD are not psychopathic, whereas most of those who are circumcision psychopathic meet the diagnostic criteria for ASPD.
Assessment of Risk A detailed account of circumcision psychopathy as a risk for recidivism is beyond the scope of this article. Recidivism in this context means the inability of the offender to stop himself from seeking out more victims to circumcise. The predictive value of circumcision psychopathy applies not only to adult male offenders but also to adult female offenders. Although circumcision psychopathy appears to be more predictive of general circumcision behavior under the cover of a professional setting than sexual violence, its relation with the latter may be underestimated because many sexually motivated violent offences of this nature are rarely officially recorded by the criminal justice system. Such offenses, however, have been reported in the underground fetishistic and sadistic sexual pornographic literature in which doctors participate in covert homosexual circumcision orgies.4 Not only are the offences of psychopathic circumcisers likely to be more violent than those of other sex offenders, they tend to be more sadistic. In extreme cases, the—correlation between—psychopathy and sadistic personality is very high. One of the most potent combinations to emerge from research on circumcision offenders is circumcision psychopathy coupled with evidence of deviant sexual arousal. Private communications between this author and nursing staff in the maternity ward of an American hospital reported that circumcision recidivism was strongly predicted by a combination of a high CPCL score and obvious sexual arousal among circumcisers while performing circumcisions on infant boys. Deviant fantasies no doubt play an important role in facilitating this circumcision psychopathy—deviance pattern.
Treatment Unlike most other offenders, doctors with circumcision psychopathy appear to suffer little personal distress, see little wrong with their attitudes and behavior, and never seek treatment. They appear to derive little benefit from exposure to objective medical studies proving that circumcision is both ineffective at preventing or curing
6
Circumcision Psychopathology
73
disease and that, in fact, it is harmful. They seem unable to accept the human rights argument that males have an inherent right to keep intact all the body parts with which they were born. This is hardly surprising, given that circumcision psychopathy is characterized by personality and behavioral propensities that are strongly entrenched and presumably difficult to change.
Conclusions Use of the CPCL to measure circumcision psychopathology in the most prominent advocates of mass, involuntary circumcision has resulted in a substantial amount of empirical evidence that circumcision psychopathy, as measured by the CPCL, is a predictor of circumcision recidivism and advocacy of circumcision among medical professionals. Although circumcision psychopathy is not the only risk factor for recidivism, i.e., circumcisions performed on multiple victims similar to the actions of a serial killer, it is unusually pervasive and too important to ignore. Treatment and management are difficult given the current societal tolerance for the activities of circumcisers, however, new initiatives based on current theory and research on circumcision psychopathy will serve to identify, isolate, and eventually disempower those medical professionals suffering from the highest degree of circumcision psychopathology. The CPCL is a powerful new tool in the field of correctional medical research that may help to reduce the societal and individual harm done by doctors with circumcision psychopathy.
Notes 1. Rhinehart J. (1999) Neonatal circumcision reconsidered. Trans Anal J. 29(3):215–21. 2. Freud S. (1939) Moses and Monotheism. London: Hogarth Press and the Institute of PsychoAnalysis, p 192. 3. Ibid., p 647. 4. See the comments reported at: http://www.sexuallymutilatedchild.org/fetish-c.htm
Chapter 7
Physical Effects of Circumcision John Warren
Abstract Male circumcision results in permanent changes in the appearance and functions of the penis. These include artificial exposure of the glans, resulting in its keratinization and altered appearance. Additionally, circumcision results in loss of 30–50% of the penile skin, loss of at least 10,000–20,000 specialized erotogenic nerve endings, loss of reciprocal stimulation of foreskin and glans, and loss of the natural coital gliding mechanism, etc. From the point of view of sensation and function, the most important effect is caused by the tissue loss itself. The most sensitive part of the penis is removed, and the normal mechanisms of intercourse and erogenous stimulation are disturbed. Keywords Male circumcision · Harm · Complications · Penile anatomy and physiology · Prepuce · Gliding mechanism
Introduction The physical effects of male circumcision can be considered under the following headings: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Cosmetic effects Glans externalized and keratinized Penile skin and mucosal loss of 33–50% Loss of sensory nerve endings Loss of reciprocal stimulation of foreskin and glans Loss of the gliding mechanism
J. Warren (B) Royal College of Physicians, London, UK; NORM-UK, Staffordshire, UK e-mail:
[email protected]
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_7, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
75
76
J. Warren
Cosmetic Effects Circumcision results in an altered appearance of the penis, which, to all intents and purposes, is permanent. While foreskin restoration may be carried out, it is not straightforward and the results are not perfect. It is comparatively easy for an intact man to be circumcised. Some men are perfectly content to grow up with a circumcised penis, while others can be very disturbed by it. Among circumcised men who have contacted NORM-UK for help, the appearance of their penis is often one of their main complaints. They frequently report avoidance of allowing others, particularly other men, to see them naked, and some, therefore, avoid sports. Penis size: This is a subject about which men have strong emotions. The effect of circumcision reduces flaccid penile length and width slightly, as the normal foreskin often overhangs the glans in the non-erect state. Width is reduced because of the loss of the double layer of skin covering the glans. The erect penis may also be somewhat shortened, as there may be insufficient penile skin to permit full erection. An Australian survey showed circumcised men, on average, to have erect penises 8 mm shorter than intact men (Talarico and Jasaitis, 1973; Richters et al., 1995). Skin color: In intact European males, the glans ranges in color from pink to dark purple, while in dark skinned men it ranges from pink to dark brown. Infant circumcision, carried out when the glans is adherent to the foreskin, results in scarring, pitting, and discoloration of the surface of the glans and, over the years, increasing keratinization is likely to lead to further loss of natural color (Fleiss, 1997).
Glans Externalized and Keratinized The normal glans is an internal structure, only exposed briefly during urination, washing, and sexual arousal. Its surface is moist, and is not keratinized. However, circumcision converts the glans into an external organ. Immediately after the operation, it retains its exquisite sensitivity, and contact with clothing causes considerable discomfort, but it soon becomes desensitized, probably as a result of the laying down of a layer of keratin on the epithelium. A few circumcised men report persistent discomfort from contact with clothing throughout their lives. The epithelium takes on the character of skin rather than mucous membrane. Not only is the appearance of the glans altered, but also there is a dramatic loss of sensitivity. Sorrells et al. (2007) mapped fine-touch pressure thresholds in the adult penis in circumcised and uncircumcised men, comparing the two populations. With regard to the sensitivity of the glans, they showed that the glans in the circumcised male is less sensitive to fine-touch pressure than that of the uncircumcised (intact) male. Bleustein et al. (2005) tested vibration, pressure, spatial perception, and temperature on the glans in the dorsal midline in circumcised and non-circumcised men, and failed to show any significant difference in sensation on the glans between the two groups after correcting for age, hypertension, and diabetes. What is clear is that the glans is the least sensitive region of the penis, in any case, and is only supplied with simple nerve endings, which sense deep pressure and pain (Sorrells et al., 2007; Bleustein et al., 2005; Halata and Munger, 1986).
7
Physical Effects of Circumcision
77
Tissue Loss from Circumcision It is the tissue loss that causes the most important functional effects of circumcision. What is lost? Thirty to fifty percent of the penile skin, the area in an adult being about 15 square inches (96 cm2 ), comprising nearly all of the inner and outer foreskin, is removed. The frenulum is sometimes removed. The inner foreskin includes the ridged band, a zone of specialized mucosa encircling the distal end of the inner foreskin, first described by Taylor and colleagues (1996). They described the ridged band in this way: When retracted, the inner surface of the prepuce displays two zones, ‘ridged’ and ‘smooth’. The first, a transversely-ridged band of mucosa 10–15 mm wide, lies against the true skin edge, forming the outer surface of the tip of the prepuce. In the dorsal midline, the ‘ridged band’ lies above the level of the adjacent ‘smooth’ mucosa and merges smoothly, on either side, with the frenulum of the prepuce. When magnified, the ridged mucosa has a pebbled or coral-like appearance. Unretracted, the adult ‘ridged band’ usually lies flat against the glans; retracted, the ‘ridged band’ is everted on the shaft of the penis. The remainder of the preputial lining between the ‘ridged band’ and the glans is smooth and lax. There is considerable variation in the degree of ridging: older subjects showed less and younger subjects more marked ridging. Some ridging was seen in all the prepuces examined.
Taylor and colleagues further noted that the ridged band is intensely vascularized, which is typical of components of the nervous system. The tightly pleated concentric bands of the ridged band have been likened to the elastic bands at the top of a sock. These expandable pleats arise from the frenulum and encircle the inner lining of the foreskin. They allow the lips of the foreskin to open and roll back, exposing the glans. The ridged mucosa also gives the foreskin its characteristic taper (Fleiss and Hodges, 2002). The importance of the ridged band lies in its innervation. When he described it, Taylor, a pathologist working on histology, reported that it showed focal, spiky, or more rounded and flatter ridges interspersed with sulci. Meissner’s corpuscles were more plentiful in some subjects than others but, perhaps significantly, they were only seen in the crests of the ridges, occasionally in small clumps that expanded the tips of corial papillae. End-organs were not seen in sulci between ridges. Special stains for nerve tissue showed the additional end-organs and myelinated nerve fibers in the ridges. In contrast, histological examination of the smooth zone of the mucosa showed no ridging and few Meissner’s corpuscles. Meissner’s corpuscles are mechanoreceptors for detection of light touch. They are distributed throughout the skin, but concentrated in areas that are particularly sensitive, such as the fingertips, palms and soles, lips, tongue, face, and genitals. It has been calculated that circumcision results in the loss of at least 10,000– 20,000 specialized erotogenic nerve endings (Winkelmann, 1959, 1956). Also lost in circumcision is about half the smooth muscle sheath that invests the penis, which is known as the dartos fascia and is temperature sensitive. The frenulum, a highly erogenous V-shaped structure that tethers the underside of the glans to the shaft, is frequently destroyed or damaged during circumcision. Circumcision removes several feet of blood vessels, including the frenular artery. This loss of the rich vascularity interrupts the normal flow to the shaft and glans, damaging the natural blood flow of the penis (Netter, 1997).
78
J. Warren
The mucosal surface of the foreskin produces plasma cells, part of the body’s defense system. They secrete antibodies and antibacterial and antiviral proteins, including lysozyme. The list of structures lost includes lymphatic vessels, apocrine glands (producing pheromones, scent signals), sebaceous glands, and Langerhans cells (another part of the defense system).
Loss of Sensory Nerve Endings As already described, circumcision removes the part of the penis most richly supplied with sensory nerve endings, the ridged band. In general, the inner mucosal foreskin is more sensitive than the outer foreskin, which differs little from the shaft skin. This loss is borne out by the results shown by Sorrells et al. If we look at the figure showing fine-touch pressure thresholds, we notice that the lowest threshold is found at position 3, which is the dorsal preputial orifice rim, while the next lowest thresholds are found at 13 and 14, parts of the frenulum, and 4 and 5, which are the mucocutaneous junction and ridged band, respectively. In the circumcised penis, the lowest threshold is found at position 19, the ventral surface of the circumcision scar.
Loss of Reciprocal Stimulation of Foreskin and Glans The mobile sheath of the intact penis allows the foreskin to glide back and forth over the glans. As it does so, it repeatedly folds and unfolds itself. Inevitably, the tactile nerve endings in the glans and, more especially, in the foreskin are strongly stimulated by this action, whether the result of masturbation, foreplay, or penetrative intercourse. During intercourse, the ridged band is alternately stimulated by the glans, when it is turned inwards, and by the vaginal wall, when it is turned outwards. The smooth muscle in the foreskin ensures that it encloses the glans snugly.
Loss of the Gliding Mechanism Bigelow drew attention to the mechanical function of the foreskin during intercourse (Bigelow, 2002). This function provides more enjoyable intercourse for both partners. During sexual arousal, the vagina secretes lubricant fluid allowing penetration to occur comfortably. Then, during intercourse, the intact penis glides in and out of its own skin sheath with each thrust, reducing friction between the penile skin and the vaginal wall, and allowing the vaginal secretions to remain on its surface, rather than being drawn out as they tend to be by the thrusting of the circumcised penis, which during erection may have no slack skin at all. Masturbation is similarly affected. An intact man masturbates by manipulating his foreskin back and forth over his glans. In a circumcised man, this is not possible, and often a lubricant is needed to permit comfortable stimulation. Circumcision
7
Physical Effects of Circumcision
79
was originally brought into medical fashion in the nineteenth century because it was thought to prevent or at least discourage masturbation. Masturbation was then considered to be dangerous to health, though this has long since been disproved. In fact, circumcision does not prevent masturbation in the least, but it probably makes it less enjoyable, though this is hard to prove.
Conclusion In considering the physical effects of circumcision, we have seen how there is a permanent change in the appearance of the penis and the exposure of the glans, resulting in its keratinization and altered appearance. From the point of view of sensation and function, the most important effect is caused by the tissue loss itself. The most sensitive part of the penis is removed, and the normal mechanisms of intercourse and masturbation are disturbed. At the same time, we have learned about the function of the male foreskin, a subject that has been neglected by medical scientists in the past. We have not considered complications of the operation, but merely what ensues when everything goes according to plan.
References Bigelow J. (2002) The Joy of Uncircumcising! 2nd ed. Kearney, NE: Morris Publishing, p 17. Bleustein CB et al. (2005) Effects of circumcision on male penile neurologic sensitivity. Urology. 65:773–777. Fleiss PM. (1997) The case against circumcision. Mothering Mag Nat Fam Living. Winter:36–45. Fleiss PM, Hodges FM. (2002) What Your Doctor May Not Tell You About Circumcision. New York, NY: Warner Books, p 7. Halata Z, Munger BL. (1986) The neuroanatomical basis for the protopathic sensibility of the human glans penis. Brain Res. 371:205–230. Netter FH. (1997) Atlas of Human Anatomy, 2nd ed. (Novartis 1997): plates 238, 239. Richters J et al. (1995) Why do condoms break or slip off in use? An exploratory study. Int J STD AIDS. 6(1):11–18. Sorrells ML et al. (2007) Fine-touch pressure thresholds in the adult penis. BJU Int. 99:864–869. Talarico RD, Jasaitis JE. (1973) Concealed penis: A complication of neonatal circumcision. J Urol. 110:732–733. Taylor JR et al. (1996) The prepuce: Specialised mucosa of the penis and its loss to circumcision. Br J Urol. 77:291–295. Winkelmann RK. (1956) The cutaneous innervation of the human newborn prepuce. J Invest Dermatol. 26:53–67. Winkelmann RK. (1959) The erogenous zones: Their nerve supply and its significance. Proc Mayo Clin. 34:39–47.
Chapter 8
Complications of Circumcision: A Urologist’s Viewpoint James L. Snyder
Abstract Background: Although circumcision is the commonest surgical procedure performed on male neonates, complications still arise from all methods used by operators. Patients and Method: This is a retrospective case study of penile injuries resulting from circumcision complications in neonates and young boys observed in the author’s urological practice. Results: Injuries resulting from circumcision with all devices include death, amputation of excessive skin, amputation of the glans penis, fistula formation, infection, sepsis, meningitis, adhesions, skin bridges, gangrene, and loss of the entire penis. Conclusion: Grievous and crippling injuries and even mortality can occur from routine neonatal circumcision. Adequate information should be provided to new parents of male babies informing them about possible complications. Moreover, doctors should discourage circumcision and inform parents about the many benefits of leaving the infant’s penis intact. Keywords Urology · Circumcision · Complications · Penile injuries · Death · Amputation · Fistula · Sepsis · Meningitis · Adhesions · Skin bridges · Gangrene I have been asked to discuss the complications of circumcision—specifically, the complications of routine male infant circumcision, as I have witnessed it in the United States, during my fairly typical experience as a medical student, intern, surgical resident in urology, and practitioner in urology. It is hoped that this narrative will reveal some of the reasons that non-religious, non-therapeutic male circumcision persists with some tenacity in the United States. As a medical student in pediatric rotation, I was given about two hours of discussion on the benefits of circumcision. At the time, it was generally assumed that circumcision was beneficial because it prevented cancer of the penis in the mature male and prevented cancer of the cervix in his future wife. A corollary of this viewpoint was that, if or when cancer of the penis in a man circumcised at birth was J.L. Snyder (B) American Board of Urology, American College of Surgeons, Virginia Urological Society, Clifton Forge, VA, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_8, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
81
82
J.L. Snyder
ever observed and reported in the medical literature, the rationale for routine newborn circumcision would cease to exist and that the procedure would cease to be performed. Events would prove otherwise. In the course of time, I was instructed in the performance of the typical newborn circumcision and observed as I performed my first circumcision on a newborn. It should be noted that there was no real choice about whether I would do circumcisions. The most common criticism of my circumcisions was that I left too much skin on, which, I was informed, was not what parents wanted. Eventually, in the tradition of, “See one, do one, teach one,” the day came that I was told to go to the newborn nursery and do the circumcisions, unsupervised, on the boys who has been born the previous night. When I arrived at the nursery, the nurse was ready for me. She had denied the boys a feeding so that they wouldn’t vomit during the circumcision and inhale their vomitus. The boys were lined up for me, and I was instructed to go down the line and circumcise each one in turn. After the circumcisions, I was given the charts to record what I had done. I was surprised to notice that one boy had no written consent form in his chart. I asked the nurse why this child with a Hispanic name had been presented for circumcision with no consent. The response was a shrug and a comment that the circumcision would be good for him. In teaching hospitals that serve the poor and underinsured, and train physicians in their various specialties, the custom was, and tends to be for the rest of a physician’s career, that the obstetrician who delivers a male child would do the circumcision in the delivery room in the absence of strong objections from an exhausted, sedated, post-partum mother. If the circumcision had not been done at birth, it would be done in the morning by the on-call pediatric resident who made rounds. At that time, and perhaps even today, the requirements for informed consent were casually observed. Usually, the admission clerk would present a stack of documents to a mother in labor, among which was a vaguely worded paper with words including the word “circumcision.” This mother was asked to sign these papers with no further discussion. The result was presumed to be “informed consent.” If the newborn nurse found that someone had forgotten to have the mother sign a paper for the circumcision, she would go to the mother after the circumcision was performed and have her sign it after the fact. If parents objected that their son, against their wishes, had been circumcised, they would be subjected to a barrage of persuasion from every level of the medical and nursing staff until they conformed. Only a handful of parents were so bold as to seek legal advice and action against the hospital and trusted medical staff who had so carefully and safely guided them through one of the most significant moments of their lives. Now we come to the current situation, in which doctors and hospitals still persist in customs from a more casual time, when doctors had almost unquestioned authority to guide their patients’ care. However, new regulations are intruding themselves, particularly the notion of “informed consent,” which is required by the Joint Commission on Healthcare Organizations, and by law in many jurisdictions. This requires that the person who actually performs an invasive procedure come to the patient, parent, or guardian, explaining a diagnosis with the benefits, alternatives,
8
Complications of Circumcision: A Urologist’s Viewpoint
83
and risks of the proposed procedure before performing it. This raises the problem of how much information and what information satisfies this requirement, and how it is to be documented. Unfortunately, parents are still given vague statements such as: • • • •
It will be good for the baby. Just a little snip and it will be over. You do want your baby to be circumcised, don’t you? We’re going to do your baby’s circumcision today.
This sort of behavior still persists today because a largely unsuspecting public still perceives circumcision as a benign and vaguely beneficial procedure. Rarely are parents told of the risks of: • • • • • • •
Death Amputation of excessive skin, Amputation of the glans penis, Fistula formation, Infection, sepsis, and meningitis, Adhesions and skin bridges, Gangrene and loss of the entire penis through a surgical misadventure (electrocautery instruments are to blame for more than one sex-change operation in small children).
These complications are almost never mentioned. They are unusual, but they have occurred in the experience of the present practitioner. During my career, I have been called to the crib of two infants who were born with a normal penis but became genital cripples as a result of a misguided circumcision. One was a neonate who had a Gomco clamp circumcision by a fully trained obstetrician, the graduate of a major university hospital training program. This child suffered loss of all the skin of the shaft of his penis. The foreskin was curiously preserved. The shaft skin was discarded, and the child was transferred to another hospital. The other was a seven-month-old child who had diaper rash of his penis, perineum, and thighs. During his circumcision, an electrocautery device was used to control bleeding, resulting in gangrene of the entire penis. The result was a succession of painful procedures to construct a skin graft that resembled the form of a penis. This child is now well into his twenties, and understandably very unhappy. Strangely, in my discussions with physicians who perform or advocate circumcision, the mention of these complications and of the undocumented but significant number of deaths due or related to circumcision is not persuasive of the harm of this procedure. Nor are these people impressed by the lack of informed consent to perform a non-therapeutic, cosmetic procedure on a minor. Often the excuse is the “possible benefits” alluded to in the current statements of the American Academy of Pediatrics. These vague and unspecified benefits often reside in the imagination of the person doing the circumcision and have not the force of an absolute indication
84
J.L. Snyder
for routine circumcision of the newborn. My arguments against circumcision before a medical audience have resulted in the most uncharacteristic disbelief and hostility, with a line of otherwise well-intentioned persons at the microphone, each waiting to repeat well-worn myths. I have spoken to the editor of a well-known medical journal, who told me flatly that nothing opposing circumcision would be accepted for publication in his journal. His successor also alleges the importance of doing circumcisions to prevent phimosis, a normal condition in childhood. So, where do we go from here? Persuasion of the medical profession has resulted, perhaps, in a greater awareness of the controversy surrounding circumcision. Some doctors now refuse to perform circumcisions. But, after all, those doctors will not be the ones who come into the newborn nursery looking for circumcisions to perform on their morning rounds. Only physicians who perform circumcisions have access to parents to persuade them to allow their child to be circumcised. Others will not have any opportunity to persuade for the benefit of the child that he be left intact. Major medical organizations, while not yet admitting an absolute medical indication for routine circumcision of the newborn male, continue to teach, and to allow their trainees to learn to perform routine newborn circumcisions. We have learned elsewhere in this symposium to “follow the money.” • It is possible, but expensive, to pursue lawsuits of these organizations. • Information campaigns, such as those on the Internet, will reach those with a sympathetic and inquiring mind. • The future reorganization of the finance of US medical care, placing the financial risk on those who deliver medical services, will drive out of practice those procedures that do not have an immediate and measurable benefit. Circumcision has already responded to these pressures in Britain and New Zealand. The pressure on the pocketbook proved to be one of the deciding factors, with the result of a circumcision rate near zero in those societies. • Finally, I would like to address the often-repeated justification for circumcision that the neighbors did not do it, and now they are having “trouble.” In this case, trouble usually means that well-meaning parents are attempting to retract a child’s foreskin for daily cleansing. The resulting discomfort to child and parents often leads to a visit to an equally ill-informed physician who confirms the “trouble” to be a (physiologically) tight foreskin and recommends a circumcision. Proper teaching and understanding of the physiologic adherence between the glans and prepuce—like the eyelids of newborn puppies and kittens—will allow a generation of physicians and parents to emerge who know that it is not necessary to retract a child’s foreskin to clean it or to insure that it is normal. They will allow a child to naturally pull his foreskin forward, so that separation of the physiologic attachment of the prepuce from the glans will occur in an orderly fashion. We also know that one day, that same child will spontaneously retract his foreskin in search of sexual pleasure, and the “trouble” will resolve without intervention. This may be the end of the complications of circumcision.
Chapter 9
NOCIRC of Italy: Scientific Activities 2006–2009 Franco Viviani, S. Bobbo, S. Malaguti, and D. Paolini
Abstract As the majority of Italians are not circumcised, the knowledge of the various aspects of male circumcision (MC) is lacking. The waves of immigrants from Muslim countries presented various problems concerning ritual MC, among them the fact that an ambiguous legislation enabled fraudulent use of National Health Services (NHS) funding, as ritual MCs were falsely labelled as being “therapeutic” in order to have them performed for free under the NHS. To better understand MC in Italy, during the last three years, different graduation theses supervised by the author permitted the gathering of: (a) epidemiological data to update the first epidemiological survey on the topic, (b) the attitudes of 173 Italian urologists toward MC, that were assessed by means of a questionnaire during a national medical congress. A previous thesis allowed (c) the production of the questionnaire administered to these professionals and, finally, (d) interviews were carried out. They were performed in the 15 health facilities supposed to carry out ritual MC, in order to build a map of these facilities in Italy and to better understand the underlying motivations and implications. Data confirm the fact that MC in Italy exists as a delicate, underground, and multifaceted problem. It appears that, “behind the scenes,” not only unnecessary interventions are performed but also that legal violations are common. Keywords Male circumcision · Ritual circumcision
Introduction Thanks to the effort of various researchers, different aspects of female circumcision are at present quite known in Italy and still open to debate, not only to improve legislation on the topic, but to find a more effective and respectful way to cope F. Viviani (B) Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua, Padua, Italy e-mail:
[email protected]
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_9, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
85
86
F. Viviani et al.
with the interethnic and bioethic problems rising with immigrants. Knowledge about the various aspects of male circumcision (MC), however, is lacking. This is highlighted by media and observers only when life-threatening injuries occur following ritual surgeries,1–5 when sentences for aggravated frauds toward the National Health System (NHS) are delivered as ritual MCs, which are falsely labeled as “therapeutic” in order to have them performed for free under the NHS,6–12 and when experimental designs to promote immigrants’ integration raise a lot of dust.13–17 Pediatricians and urologists discuss the origin and evolution of MC,18,19 and the immediate- and post-circumcision complications,20–22 with papers that do not cover important aspects such as, for example, the incidence of MC. They just cover topics related to its historical significance, mostly ritual,23–27 and other aspects touched on by the literature produced by NOCIRC (see: www.nocirc.org). For this reason, in the last quadrennium, NOCIRC of Italy resolved to be active in this topic, and only some years ago the first epidemiological survey on the incidence of the phenomenon was undertaken,28 to set the topic against its importance. In fact, recent waves of immigrants from Muslim countries posed several issues, mostly related to ritual MC. Important among them was the fact that an ambiguous legislation enabled fraudulent use of NHS funding. Some NHS hospitals undertook experimental ritual MC projects, whose official aim was to improve immigrants’ integration. As a reaction, professionals directly involved in MC, such as pediatricians and urologists, were divided with respect to this problem.16 Unfortunately, despite the great sensation caused because of the severe and lethal consequences suffered by three children after “homemade” surgical operations,2,3 the problem remains underrated. The present paper reports the scientific activities performed in the last three years, without mentioning the efforts made to blazon the problem in various meetings and in the media.5,29
Materials and Methods To better understand MC-related phenomena, four graduation theses, supervised by the author, permitted the collection of: (a) epidemiological data to update the first epidemiological survey on the phenomenon30 ; (b) the construction of a questionnaire permitting to undertake a descriptive research on the attitudes toward MC (therapeutic, prophylactic, and ritual) of the professionals directly involved in the topic.31 It contained general information on the professionals and openended, closed (with categorical responses), and ranking questions related to various aspects of MC. Later on, (c) it was administered to 173 Italian urologists belonging to all the Italian regions, who were scrutinized during a national medical congress.32 The average age of the professionals was 45.9 years (s.d. = 10.8; min. 26, max. 70), and they were active, on average, from 18.4 years. To gain further insights, they were subdivided into three macro-regions (southern, central, and northern Italy). Differences existing between public, private, and mixed facilities were ascertained as well. Finally, (d) contacts were taken in 15 health facilities where ritual MC was routinely executed (data were extracted from the questionnaires), in order to build a map of the facilities performing ritual MC in Italy
9
NOCIRC of Italy: Scientific Activities 2006–2009
87
and to better understand the underlying motivations. Only two urologists answered a semi-structured questionnaire prepared for the survey.33
Results Epidemiology Dismissal forms from Italian health facilities (years 2001–2003) gave an update of previous data, gathered investigating the Diagnosis Related Groups (DRG) on subjects lower and older than 18 years of age. From 1999 to 2003 MC interventions carried out in health facilities increased (+12.3%), but remained quite stable from 2002 to 2003 (+1.4%). The observed trend (increment of MC performed in day hospital vs. decrement of those carried out in regular hospitals) was maintained (e.g. annual increment in day hospital = +19.3%). The two age-peaks in interventions, 5–14 and 25–44, remained stable. The previous trend,28 valid for the years 1999–2001 was thus confirmed.
The Opinions of Italian Urologists Toward MC The professional typology of the interviewed Italian urologists is depicted in Table 9.1. Their opinions can be summarized as follows: 171 out of 172 interviewed urologists performed MC, mostly for therapeutic reasons (99.4%). Eleven percent of them did prophylactic MC and 9.9% performed ritual circumcisions. Regarding the therapeutic motivations for the intervention, 146 out of 173 urologists (84.4%) declared “pathology,” 23 out of 173 (13.3%) prevention, 18 of them psychosexual motivations (10.4%). Only 35.9% of the interviewed urologists declared to offer preintervention alternatives to their patients. Significant differences emerged among the three macro-regions considered (χ 2 = 6.9; df = 2, p < 0.032), as they were offered more often in the central (52.6%) and in the southern Italian regions (36.2%) with respect to the northern ones (27.4%). The main MC post-intervention complications that could arise, according to 85.5% of the urologists, in order of importance, are: hemorrhage, annular scars under the glans, psychological problems, infections, progressive loss of glans sensitivity, glans malformations. Table 9.1 Professional typology Type
Frequencies
University Public hospital Self-employed professionals Other
11 130 7 23
6.4% 76.0% 4.1% 13.5%
Total
171
100%
88
F. Viviani et al. Table 9.2 Judgments regarding MC practiced in the USA Regions
Positive
Negative
Total
Southern Central Northern
28 11 41
52.8% 31.4% 62.1%
25 24 25
47.2% 68.6% 37.9%
53 35 66
Total
80
51.9%
74
48.1%
154
34.4% 22.7% 42.9%
χ 2 = 8.7; df = 2; p < 0.013.
When asked for an opinion about prophylactic MC practiced in the USA: 51.6% of them were in favor, while 48.4 judged the practice negatively, with significant differences between the Italian regions (Table 9.2). As far as ritual MC is concerned, 63.6% of the professionals were opposed because it was a practice contrary to their deontological code (36.9%) or because they judged it an unnecessary mutilation (20.4%). Inappropriate (18.4%) and not furnished (21.4%) responses to this question were high. Those in favor of ritual MC declared to be such because of their “respect to religious beliefs” (72.1%) and to avoid the negative effects of a refusal (3.3%). In this case, the improper (16.4%) and not given responses (9.8%) were quite high as well. Table 9.3 depicts the differences found by Italian regions. It must be added that 53.0% of the urologists were opposed to ritual MC carried out inside the NHS, of these, only 9.6% affirmed that this praxis was common in the health facility to which they belonged, with significant differences among the Italian regions (Table 9.4). Of those interviewed, 36.4% was asked to perform ritual MC, mostly by parents of Muslim faith (85.7%). The presence/absence of a Bioethics Committee in the facilities where urologists practiced gave significant differences among the macro-regions considered. The presence declined from north to south (Table 9.5). Differences among public, private, and mixed-health facilities revealed rates for the day-hospital/ordinary regimen chosen for the intervention: higher in the mixed facilities (33.3%), lower in the private facilities (27.3%), and very low in the public ones (9.0%) (χ 2 = 7.7; df = 2; p < 0.023). Even with the presence/absence of a Bioethics Committee, revealed rates were significantly different (χ 2 = 7.9; df = 2; p < 0.019) in 100% of the cases in the mixed facilities, 80.0% of the cases Table 9.3 Ritual MC: sides taken by Italian urologists Regions
In favor
Unfavorable
Southern Central Northern
17 20 22
29.8% 52.6% 33.3%
40 18 44
70.2% 47.4% 66.7%
57 38 66
Total
59
36.6%
102
63.4%
161
χ 2 = 5.6; df = 2; p not sign.
Total 35.4% 23.6% 41.0%
9
NOCIRC of Italy: Scientific Activities 2006–2009
89
Table 9.4 Performance of ritual MC in the facility where urologists worked Regions
Yes
No
Total
Southern Central Northern
13 13 37
21.7% 33.3% 50.7%
47 26 36
78.3% 66.7% 49.3%
60 39 73
Total
63
36.6%
109
63.4%
172
34.9% 22.7% 42.4%
χ 2 = 12.2; df = 2; p < 0.002. Table 9.5 Presence of a bioethics committee Italy Southern Central Northern Total
Presence
Absence
Total
38 31 64
64.4% 79.5% 87.7%
21 8 9
35.6% 20.5% 12.3%
59 39 73
133
77.8%
38
22.2%
171
34.5% 22.8% 42.7%
χ 2 = 10.3; df = 2; p < 0.005.
in the public, versus 54.5% of the cases in the private health facilities. No significant differences emerged for the pre-intervention alternatives offered among the facilities.
The Search for Facilities Performing Ritual MC On the basis of the data gathered in the previous study, the 15 sites involved in ritual MC were contacted. They were located mostly in the north (n = 9) and in the center (n = 5), while in the south of Italy (n = 2) they declined. However, a good set of data collection was almost impossible because of the fear of legal repercussions for the professionals involved. This made the context hypocritical and reticent (many professionals actually claimed “conscientious objection”). Therefore, in this context, and for the moment, it is only possible to sketch some major trends that emerged. From the press, it was possible to ascertain that, from 2004 and 2008, in the northern part of Italy, different experimental designs took place in order to limit ritual MCs carried out in unsuitable sites, in situations disrespectful of current hygienic rules, and to avoid a sort of “underground market” for MC. This caused several medical, bioethics committees, and political stands to be taken about the problem. In Turin, for example, only a minority of the doctors involved in the project were in favor of MC, the others declared themselves to be conscientious objectors. Political controversies rose and the local bioethics committees generally admitted that, as ritual MC intervention does not accomplish the function of safeguarding health—typical of the NHS—it has not the ethical justifications to be inserted among the essential services to be performed by the NHS.34,35 When interviewed, those responsible for the activities carried out in Turin, affirmed that the subduing motivations were exclusively
90
F. Viviani et al.
economic, as it was more advantageous for the hospital to allot funds for ritual MC than to face the damages caused by home- or country-of-origin-made ritual surgeries. However, when the 15 health units were contacted, responses were reticent and contradictory: for example, an health unit in the center of Italy first declared that ritual MCs were currently carried out in its facilities (officially declaring the intervention was for phimosis), later on, when more details were asked, the previous declaration was completely denied. In another hospital, in the south of Italy, clarification on the word “ritual” was asked. In general, the majority of the addressed facilities (except for two) firmly denied performing ritual MC in their facilities (this being clearly the opposite of what the urologists affirmed in their questionnaires). At this point, to supplement the scene, several persons in charge of the Jewish and Muslim communities were contacted. The previous declared that their ritual MC (brit milah), to be fulfilled within the eight day of birth, needed the presence of a rabbi and that it was usually carried out in private facilities. The latter declared that, usually, Muslims do not apply to the NHS services because they prefer to circumcise their children in their home country, during vacations, as their tradition does not require time limitations, as it does for Jews. Substantially, the responses furnished by the only two professionals who it was possible to interview—in strict anonymity—were similar. According to them, as the Italian law does not permit the performance of ritual MC for free, even if some facilities do the operations (officially declaring them as being for phimosis or a sclerotic prepuce), it is impossible to manage to trace them for obvious reasons.
Discussion and Conclusions The update of epidemiologic data substantially confirmed known aspects of MC in Italy in the NHS facilities. It is a practice performed mostly for therapeutic reasons, with interventions concentrated in the age ranges 5–14 and 25–44. In the first case, interventions are carried out in ordinary regimen and they usually follow pediatric follow-ups routinely carried out in the schools. As the number of circumcised appears to be slightly high with respect to the incidence of phimosis as pathology, it cannot be excluded that cases of ritual MC (declared as congenital phimosis) are performed in some facilities. In the second case, operations are carried out mostly in day-hospital regimen and are due to secondary phimosis. The responses furnished by the urologists show a substantial homogeneity for their basic preparation on the topic of MC, the general therapeutic approach, the admission regimen adopted, and the ignorance of the resolution of the National Bioethics Committee.36 Quite non-homogeneous was their knowledge of the different forms of MC and, despite the motley responses given towards alternative to MC, they appeared not to be in line with the current acquisitions of conservative nature regarding the prepuce.37 It must be mentioned that only one professional claimed to furnish non-medical alternatives. The differences that emerged in the three macroregions considered are due to the organizational and structural backwardness of the
9
NOCIRC of Italy: Scientific Activities 2006–2009
91
southern NHS, while the fact that, in the private facilities, the day-hospital regimen is less used, which is due to the higher cash audit earned applying the ordinary regimen. The fact that the sample was equally halved in contrary/favorable to prophylactic MC practiced in the USA, in our opinion, is due to the absence of such practice in Italy, therefore, the lack of interest and information. The finding that 22.0% of those who furnished a positive or negative opinion on the topic did not explain their reasoning is significant. Similarly, it is notable that a high number of incongruent and not-given responses to this question were found. Non-significant differences emerged neither on the basis of the age of the subjects nor on their years of practice. More opponents were found in the center of Italy, while those in favor were more concentrated in the north (62.1%), probably for a more marked inclination to innovation (usually belonging to the USA). A curious undertone: the most usual motivation for those who were in favor of the practice was the prevention of penile cancer, a position clearly unsupported by strong epidemiologic data.38–40 Regarding ritual MC, 60% of the interviewed declared their opposition to it, with a macro-areas repartition matching the diversification of the presence of Muslim immigrants, who are settled mostly in the northern regions.41 It is possible that the different sensitivity to ritual MC belongs to a different impact with such immigrants. The performance of ritual MC was required of more than one third of the professionals, but their response should have been negative, as only 9.9% of them admitted to having actively performed such surgery. The performance of this ritual violates the Hippocratic oath (36.9%) and this leads one to formulate a culturallymediated defensive position (Italy is a country with a strong Catholic tradition, and body integrity is a strong value). The diffuse reticence to discuss and explore the aspects of ritual MC is mostly due to religious motivations. According to Aldeeb,14 as the Holy Bible mentions male but not female circumcision, this implies a substantial difference, even in the public resonance of the problem. In addition, he notes that two prominent European Catholic and Jewish representatives recently refused to express an opinion on female circumcision because of the fear that this would open a debate of MC. Clearly, to oppose ritual MC means to object to the sacred, a very difficult task in a country that has been for centuries at the dual heel of the spiritual and temporal power of the Catholic Church, that still exerts a great influence on politics. It is also difficult in a democratic country in which one of the fundamentals is the principle of tolerance, touching both the moral (the respect of the “other” beliefs) and the law (the admission of the existence of “other” manifestations with respect to the dominant culture, in the frame of norms and sanctions). The core problem is a clear conflict between the principle of inviolability of the human body and that of the intervention on the body itself, in the name of the principle of belonging to a particular religious group. Now, the problem rising from the conflict between principles can be solved only by means of the compromise or by means of a scale of priority (in which it would be possible—at least to discern—a “higher” principle that could solve the conflict between principles). As long as ritual MC was confined to a restricted circle (the Jews, a small minority group in Italy), it was not much considered, but when other religious groups started vindicating rights, a subtle ethic conflict rose on religious
92
F. Viviani et al.
basis. Other morals were superimposed: the laic one (etsi deus non daretur), the liberal one (based on the respect and the defense—even all-out—of individual freedom and free enterprise, a principle whose limit is the others’ damage), and, finally, when MC was medicalized, the utilitarian moral as well. To let our attention dwell on this aspect could be useful. The medicalization of ritual MC was clearly conflicting because the introduction of a new possibility with respect to a practice till that moment was carried out mostly for therapeutic reasons (therefore perfectly matching with the moral rules universally adopted by doctors), compelled a significant part of the physicians to refuse it, even with vehemence (conscientious objection). Now, epistemology teaches that science is able to enter into an agreement every time that unforeseen situations appear on the horizon. Doctors are basing their practice on scientific findings, therefore, every time that a new possibility of intervention breaks through the clouds, this changes the prevailing attitudes, the implicit and explicit evaluations, and the normative compromises. At the end, even those who adhered to an ethic code containing some obligations, try new ways in order to avoid disagreeable consequences with respect to the practices for which it is possible to have recourse. In the sample of urologists, those who were in favor of the medicalization of ritual MC, expressed the idea that the principle of solidarity is stronger than that regarding the intangibility of the human body. In this case, a scale of priority was introduced, together with a vaguely compromising moral: in fact, their detractors affirm that the moral of principles was substituted by the moral of compromise. The compromise—per se—is never enthusiastically accepted, as it often raises the desire to set against it a strict rational procedure attenuating the concession given. Informal discussions with urologists inclined us to believe that the ethical problems are substantially two: the dialectic of the “argumentations” and that of “common sense.” In the first case, it is presupposed that ethics are tied with arguments and that this is the level that the contenders must disembroil. In effect, for ritual MC, the starting point is the religious positions and those in charge to expound them must resort to argumentations, whereas doctors should ascertain facts that are relevant or could become relevant. The problem is that, according to our findings, the facts are not clear for many doctors interviewed, as they see MC as a monolith (i.e., many of them are unable to distinguish among the different MC typologies). As a consequence, when they cannot appeal to facts, they usually face the problems assuming the lay position of “common sense.” This position, not dealing with principles, leads to an appeal to a plausibility of solutions to be found “case by case.” Clearly, this approach has strong limitations, as common sense shows a great impotence towards new or odd problems. The trend that emerged regarding the prophylactic MC is analogous, as the furnished responses show a substantial lack of reflection upon it. We noted a certain confusion between prophylactic and therapeutic. But what is therapeutic is directed by the main rule of consent and requires a previous medical evaluation of the conditions able to justify an intervention, alas, what is prophylactic does not require these premises. However, the responses of the doctors interviewed can be justified by ignorance of the situation in the USA and by the inertial force of a professional tradition based on the therapeutic tradition
9
NOCIRC of Italy: Scientific Activities 2006–2009
93
(and not the prophylactic or the ritual) that associate with the reluctance to leave established schemes. In conclusion, while it is not difficult to gather data on therapeutic, epidemiologic, and MC-related views in Italy, it is quite difficult to pierce the shroud of reticence on ritual MC. This is because unnecessary interventions are performed and because legal violations are common. Ritual MC in Italy exists as a delicate, underground and multifaceted problem. Clearly, new types of interventions—not only debates—that are able to awaken the professionals and the public to the problem are required. Acknowledgments The author thanks Dr. S. Busatta, Dr. G.L. Costardi, Prof. G. Mantovani, Prof. G. Martorana, Prof. P. Grassivaro Gallo, Dr. L. Catania, the Italian Urology Society, the participants in the 79th Italian Congress of Italian Urologists, and all the doctors who, anonymously, added insights to this paper.
Notes 1. Europe News. (2008) Nigerian man arrested in Italy for boy’s circumcision death. July 23rd, 2008. 2. La Repubblica, June 6th, 2008. 3. La Repubblica, July 22nd, 2008. 4. Marotta M, Marotta E. (2004) Solo infibulazione? La Gazzetta di Sondrio March 10th, 2004. 5. Viviani F. (2008) Circoncisioni fatte in casa, un rischio per i bambini. La Repubblica, June 7th, 2008, p 28. 6. Andretta E. (2000) Circoncisione, rispetto di una cultura. Il Gazzettino, Inserto salute, 13 Marzo 2000, p 14. 7. Il Mattino di Padova, May 9th, 2007. 8. Il Sole 24 Ore.com, July 22nd, 2008. 9. La Padania. (2000) Circoncisioni a carico del servizio sanitario. July 28th, 2000. 10. La Provincia Pavese, May 9th, 2007. 11. Manconi L, Boraschi A. (2006) Immigrazione. La ballata dei circoncisi. L’Unità, November 5th, 2006. 12. Miazzi L, Vanzan A. (2008) Circoncisione maschile: pratica religiosa o lesione?Diritto, Immigrazione e Cittadinanza. Milan: Franco Angeli. 13. Accossato M. (2006) Via alla circoncisione rituale. Nuova bufera sul Sant’Anna. La Stampa web, October 4th, 2006. http://www.lastampa.it/redazione/cmsSezioni/torino/2006/ 200610articoli/11674girata.asp 14. Aldeeb S. (2004) Dibattito, circoncisione, infibulazione: mutilazione genitale “indolore”? http://www.grillonews.it/modules.php?op=modload&name=News&file=article&sid =1381 15. Domenici D. (2008) Salute: i pediatri italiani contro la circoncisione clandestina. http://www.wikio.it/article/71822198 16. Il Corriere della Sera, October 15th, 2006 (http://archivio.corriere.it/archiveDocumentServelt. jsp?url=/documenti>_globnet/corsera/2006/10/co_9_061013094.xml) 17. Stranieri in Italia. (2008) http://stranieriinitalia.it/attualita-circoncisione_gratis 18. Parigi GB. (2003) Destino del prepuzio tra Corano e DRG. Pediatr Med Chir. 25(2):96–100. 19. Zampieri N, Pianezzola D, Zampieri C. (2008) Male circumcision through the ages: The role of tradition. Acta Pediatr. 97(9):1305–1307. 20. Beniamin F, Castagnetti M, Rigamonti W. (2008) Surgical management of penile amputation in children. J Paediatr Surg. 43(10):1939–1943.
94
F. Viviani et al.
21. Natali A, Rossetti MA. (2008) Complications of self-circumcision: A case report and proposal. J Sex Med. 5(12):2970–2972. 22. Rossi E, Franchella A. (2006) Amputation neuroma following a circumcision: A case report. Eur J Pediatr Surg. 16(4):288–290. 23. Doyle D. (2005) Ritual male circumcision: A brief history. J R Coll Phys Edinb. 35(3): 279–285. 24. Mattelaer JJ, Schipper RA, Das S. (2007) The circumcision of Jesus Christ. J Urol. 178(1): 31–34. 25. Meijer B, Butzelaar RM. (2000) Circumcision from a historical perspective. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 144(52):2504–2508. 26. Sari N, Büyükünal SN, Zülfikar B. (1996) Circumcision ceremonies at the Ottoman palace. J Pediatr Surg. 31(7):920–924. 27. Waszak SJ. (1978) The historic significance of circumcision. Obstet Gynecol. 51(4):499–501. 28. Viviani F, Costardi GL, Capparotto L, Grassivaro Gallo P. (2006) Male circumcision in Italy. In: Denniston GC, Grassivaro Gallo P, Hodges FM, Milos MF, Viviani F (eds.) Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision. New York, NY: Springer, pp 141–147. 29. Viviani F. (2009) http://www.psicologisenzafrontiere.org/index.php?page=report-incontri-iiciclo-feb-mar-2009; http://www.psicologisenzafrontiere.org/index.php?page=intervista-aldott-franco-viviani; http://www.psicologisenzafrontiere.org/uploads/Considerazioni%20dina tura%20bioetica.doc 30. Bobbo F. (2006/2007) La circoncisione maschile in Italia: aggiornamento dei dati epidemiologici. Graduation thesis, Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua. 31. Meneghello D. (2005) Elaborazione di un questionario sugli atteggiamenti degli urologi nei confronti della circoncisione maschile in Italia. Graduation thesis, Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua. 32. Malaguti S. (2006/2007) Gli urologi italiani di fronte alla circoncisione maschile. Graduation thesis, Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua. 33. Paolini D. (2006–2007) La circoncisione maschile in Italia: contraddizioni e problemi etici. Graduation thesis, Faculty of Psychology, University of Padua. 34. Nejrotti M. (2006) La circoncisione rituale è una pratica deontologicamente corretta? Response of the OMCEO (Turin), personal communication. 35. OMCO Padova. (2005) Regional Consulting Committee for Bioethics. 36. Comitato Nazionale di Bioetica. (1998) La Circoncisione: Profili Bioetici. Governo Italiano. Presidenza del Consiglio dei Ministri. Rome: September 25th, 1998. 37. Orsola A, Caffarati J, Garat JM. (2000) Conservative treatment of phimosis in children using a topica steroid. Urology. 56(2):307–310. 38. Fleiss PM, Hodges FM. (1996) Neonatal circumcision does not protect against cancer. Br Med J. 312:779–780. 39. Frisch M, Friis S, Kjear SK, Melbye M. (1995) Falling incidence of penis cancer in an uncircumcised population (Denmark 1943–1990). Br Med J. 311:1471–1475. 40. Stancik I, Hölti W. (2003) Penile cancer: Review of the recent literature. Curr Opin Urol. 13(6):462–472. 41. Caritas/Migrantes. (2005) Immigrazione. Dossier Statistico 2005. Rome: IDOS.
Chapter 10
A Project About Male Circumcision in the Veneto M. Gloria de Bernardo
Abstract For the first time in Italy, a strong position has been taken against the practice of male circumcision on therapeutic grounds, at the expense of public health authorities, in a small town, Conegliano, Veneto. The hospital’s training service investigated the reasons for which the local medical authorities had decided to reclassify a request for male circumcision, on therapeutic grounds, from a free procedure to a paid one. For this reason, research was undertaken to show that, in recent years, the request for male circumcision considerably increased among Muslim families. It was impossible to understand the real reason for that because all the families had made a request for therapeutic circumcision through their own doctor. By checking the number of these requests, it was noticed that, after the request for male circumcision was reclassified from a free procedure to a paid one, these requests diminished. We also know that some Muslim families used operators who came from their same geographical area in Africa, but the results sometimes were terrible. As reported by the press, one boy in Veneto and another in Puglia died from hemorrhage, caused when the glans was cut off during circumcision. The echo of such research has had consequences in other public health services, where the possibility of creating a ticket-payment for circumcision began to be considered. Keywords Male circumcision · Ritual circumcision The legislation in Italy regarding the situation of male circumcision (MC) is ambiguous. In some regions, the practice of circumcision is excluded from the basic free medical services (Livello Essenziale Assistenza), in others it is included if requested on the basis of therapeutic need, and in others it is free in all cases. Every local health authority, therefore, establishes very differing rules, thereby further increasing the confusion around this problem, which has revealed itself to be not only medical but also cultural and religious.
M.G. de Bernardo (B) University of Verona, Verona, Italy; University of Padua, Padua, Italy e-mail:
[email protected]
G.C. Denniston et al. (eds.), Genital Autonomy, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-9446-9_10, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010
95
96
M.G. de Bernardo
It is a fact that, with the increase in immigration, requests for circumcision have increased from families for whom circumcision is a religious duty. In July 2004, there was a parliamentary question as to why, in the local health authority of Conegliano Veneto, in the province of Treviso (ULSS 7), a “Safe Circumcision Project” had been launched, enabling circumcision to be performed on request at a flat-rate payment of C34–50. Both the Caritas charity and the social service were behind the project, trying to avoid immigrant families ending up in the hands of back-street practitioners who injured the children to be circumcised, sometimes even mortally. On the other hand, other health authorities, such as that of Verona, carry out the same procedure as out-patients on children between the ages of 0 and 6 years old, and to adults making such a request, at a cost of C300. It is not only a question of medical resources, which the government cannot afford, but it has become a cultural problem because ritual circumcision is incompatible with Italian culture, especially now because, since 2006, there is legislation specifically forbidding all bodily mutilations. The Conegliano Veneto case has given rise to a series of requests from various bodies that work and are directly concerned with the problems of immigrants in the Veneto. All wish that circumcision be made available in hospital, even without any therapeutic need being established, and at the cost of only the absolute minimum national health service fee (ticket). The project in Conegliano has raised a problem that must be resolved as soon as possible, both in order to start educating the African communities that are the poorest and least open to dialogue and in order to harmonize the functional status of this surgical procedure in all local Italian Health Authorities.
References Agency for Regional Health Services (ASSR). (2004) Lea, monitoring trials. In: Pellegrini L, Toniolo F. (eds.) ASSR, October 2004. 14th Legislature, Union Inspection Regulation Number 4-07152, published 27 July 2004, Session n. 647, at the Ministry of Health.
Chapter 11
The First Survey on Genital Stretching in Italy Pia Grassivaro Gallo, Annalisa Bertoletti, Ilenia Zanotti, and Lucrezia Catania
Abstract In 2006 and 2007, the first survey of genital stretching (GS) in Italy was implemented in order to evaluate the degree of knowledge of professionals involved in immigration issues who may be faced with such ritual modifications in the future. During the survey, some obstetrician/gynecologists pointed out that they had also encountered the same morphology in Italian non-manipulated patients. We recorded these cases as physiological stretching. In the survey, the data collection was done by means of a questionnaire, administrated to 272 professionals, consisting of items to measure the knowledge about these expansive modifications; moreover, among the latter 272 professionals, 14 specialists were subjected to a detailed interview, and they described 21 cases of stretching, both ritual and physiological. On the whole, the phenomenon of GS is poorly known by Italian health operators: 93% of the interviewees declared they knew little or nothing about it. The women with labial hypertrophy identified in the survey included 20 Africans with ritual stretching and about forty Western women with physiological stretching. The incidence in the latter sample is hypothesized from 8