GAMBLING CULTURES From bingo in the United Kingdom, to rdslots in Las Vegas and Sydney, and ‘jambo’ in Cameroon, gambli...
77 downloads
1034 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
GAMBLING CULTURES From bingo in the United Kingdom, to rdslots in Las Vegas and Sydney, and ‘jambo’ in Cameroon, gambling is a feature of societies across the world. Gambling Cultures explores the complex relationship between cash and culture as gambling emerges as a global phenomenon. Traditional accounts of gambling’s pleasures and dangers talk in terms of addiction, compulsion, greed, profit and play. By contrast, this work focuses on modern gambling as it has emerged as a commercial industry, analyses the ambiguous relationship between morality and risk taking and looks at the contradictory stance of governments. Providing a range of case studies from Africa, Australia, the USA and Europe, Gambling Cultures offers a unique, comparative framework for the historical and cultural analysis of contemporary gambling practices. Contributors: Vicki Abt, Gabrielle A.Brenner, Mark Dickerson, Rachael Dixey, David Dixon, John Dombrink, William R.Eadington, Sytze Kingma, Martial Lipeb, David Miers, Wendy Selby, Jean-Michel Servet, James F.Smith, Michael Walker, Peter Williams. Editor: Jan McMillen is Chairperson of the Australian Institute of Gambling Research and lectures in public policy at the Queensland University of Technology.
CULTURE: POLICIES AND POLITICS Series editors: Tony Bennett, Jennifer Craik, Ian Hunter, Colin Mercer and Dugald Williamson
What are the relations between cultural policies and cultural politics? Too often, none at all. In the history of cultural studies so far, there has been no shortage of discussion of cultural politics. Only rarely, however, have such discussions taken account of the policy instruments through which cultural activities and institutions are funded and regulated in the mundane politics of bureaucratic and corporate life. Culture: Policies and Politics addresses this imbalance. The books in this series interrogate the role of culture in the organization of social relations of power, including those of class, nation, ethnicity and gender. They also explore the ways in which political agendas in these areas are related to, and shaped by, policy processes and outcomes. In its commitment to the need for a fuller and clearer policy calculus in the cultural sphere, Culture: Policies and Politics aims to promote a significant transformation in the political ambit and orientation of cultural studies and related fields. ROCK AND POPULAR MUSIC: politics, policies, institutions Edited by: Tony Bennett, Simon Frith, Lawrence Grossberg, John Shepherd, Graeme Turner BIRTH OF THE MUSEUM: History, Theory, Politics Tony Bennett FILM POLICY Edited by: Albert Moran
GAMBLING CULTURES Studies in history and interpretation
Edited by Jan McMillen
London and New York
First published 1996 by Routledge 11 New Fetter Lane, London EC4P 4EE Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 29 West 35th Street, New York, NY 10001 Routledge is an International Thomson Publishing company This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2005. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge's collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.” © 1996 Collection and editorial material, Jan McMillen; individual chapters, the contributors All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book has been requested ISBN 0-203-99350-0 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN - (Adobe e-Reader Format) ISBN 0-415-06820-7 (Print Edition)
CONTENTS
1
2
3
4
5
6
7 8
9
10
List of illustrations
vii
List of contributors
viii
INTRODUCTION Jan McMillen UNDERSTANDING GAMBLING: HISTORY, CONCEPTS AND THEORIES Jan McMillen GAMBLING AND THE LEGALISATION OF VICE: SOCIAL MOVEMENTS, PUBLIC HEALTH AND PUBLIC POLICY IN THE UNITED STATES John Dombrink SOCIAL EVIL OR SOCIAL GOOD? LOTTERIES AND STATE REGULATION IN AUSTRALIA AND THE UNITED STATES Wendy Selby ILLEGAL BETTING IN BRITAIN AND AUSTRALIA: CONTRASTS IN CONTROL STRATEGIES AND CULTURES David Dixon WHEN IT’S BAD IT’S BETTER: CONFLICTING IMAGES OF GAMBLING IN AMERICAN CULTURE James F.Smith REPRESENTATIONS OF GAMBLING IN AUSTRALIAN POPULAR CULTURE Peter Williams BINGO IN BRITAIN: AN ANALYSIS OF GENDER AND CLASS Rachael Dixey WHY ‘SLOTS’ EQUALS ‘GRIND’ IN ANY LANGUAGE: THE CROSSCULTURAL POPULARITY OF THE SLOT MACHINE Mark Dickerson GAMBLING IN CAMEROON AND SENEGAL: A RESPONSE TO CRISIS? Gabrielle A.Brenner, Martial Lipeb and Jean-Michel Servet THE ROLE OF THE STATE IN THE EXPANSION AND GROWTH OF COMMERCIAL GAMBLING IN THE UNITED STATES Vicki Abt
1 6
40
60
79
93
107
125 140
153
164
11 A SIGN OF THE TIMES: THE POLITICAL CULTURE OF GAMING IN THE NETHERLANDS Sytze Kingma 12 THE MEDICALISATION OF GAMBLING AS AN ‘ADDICTION’ Michael Walker 13 ETHICAL AND POLICY CONSIDERATIONS IN THE SPREAD OF COMMERCIAL GAMBLING William R.Eadington 14 FROM GLAMOUR TO GRIND: THE GLOBALISATION OF CASINOS Jan McMillen 15 OBJECTIVES AND SYSTEMS IN THE REGULATION OF COMMERCIAL GAMBLING David Miers Index
182
204 222
240 263
285
ILLUSTRATIONS FIGURES
11.1
Distribution of casinos in the Netherlands, 1990
184
11.2
Gaming legislation in the Netherlands
189
TABLES
8.1
Frequency of gambling by form by adults in one Australian state (NSW) where all three forms had been available for at least ten years(%)
8.2
Average stake of adult gamblers in one Australian state (NSW) 144 on lottery, slots and off-course betting (A$)
8.3
Gambling characteristics of low/medium-, high-frequency and problem slots players
147
9.1
Preferred gambling type, Senegal(%)
155
9.2
Age distribution: lottery players and the total Cameroonian population
157
9.3
Age distribution: lottery players and the total Senegalese population
158
11.1 Consumer expenditures on legal gambling (million guilders)
142
187
12.1 Comparison of the DSM IIIR criteria for substance dependence 205 and pathological gambling 15.1 Commercial gambling outlets in the European Community
266
CONTRIBUTORS Vicki Abt has written extensively on the management of gambling and is co-author of The Business of Risk: Commercial Gambling in Mainstream America (University of Kansas Press, 1985). Dr Abt is a board member on the National Council of Problem Gambling and has been a book review editor for the Journal of Gambling Studies. She is Professor of Sociology at Penn State University, and is currently writing a book on the role of the media on changing definitions of deviance. Gabrielle A.Brenner is an Associate Professor of Economics at the Business School of the University of Montreal. She has published widely on gambling, including her book with R.Brenner, Gambling and Speculation (Cambridge University Press, 1990). She has done consulting work for a number of organisations, including the World Bank, UNIDO and CIDA. Mark Dickerson is Executive Director of the Australian Institute for Gambling Research and Associate Professor at the University of Western Sydney, Macarthur. He has conducted a sequence of studies exploring the psychological processes of problem gambling. More recently he has conducted multidisciplinary research into the social impacts of gaming machines, and advised governments on related policy issues. Rachael Dixey is a Senior Lecturer in the Faculty of Health and Social Care, Leeds Metropolitan University, England. She is currently researching women’s leisure and health. David Dixon is Associate Professor at the Faculty of Law, University of New South Wales in Sydney. He is the author of From Prohibition to Regulation: Bookmaking, Anti-gambling and the Law (Clarendon Press, 1991) and Law in Policing: Legal Regulation and Policing Practices (Clarendon Press, forthcoming), and is editor of the Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology. John Dombrink is an Associate Professor in the Department of Criminology, Law and Society in the School of Social Ecology at the University of California, Irvine. He has published numerous articles on the criminal law and vice, including several on gambling, and is author of The Last Resort: Success and Failure in Campaigns for Casinos (University of Nevada, 1990, with William N. Thompson). He is currently working on an analysis of the legalisation of physician-assisted suicide in the United States. William R.Eadington is Professor of Economics and Director of the Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commerical Gaming at the University of Nevada, Reno. He has written over fifty articles and edited five books that deal with various aspects of gambling and public policy. Dr Eadington has organised the International Conferences on Gambling and Risk-taking since 1974 which provide a forum for researchers in the field from several continents. He has also served as a consultant to private and public sector gambling organisations. Sytze Kingma is a sociologist with a general interest in consumer culture. He is a Research Fellow at the Universities of Tilburg and Amsterdam. He also teaches
sociology at the Tilburg Academy of Architecture and manages Pleasure Watch, a research and consultancy agency. Martial Lipeb lectures in management at the ESSEC of Douala (Cameroon), and is the editor of the Cameroon Review of Management. His field of interest includes savings in the informal sector—especially the phenomena of rotative savings and loans associations—and the role of lotteries in the African context. Jan McMillen lectures in public policy in the Faculty of Business, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane. She has published widely on gambling development and casino policy, and has been appointed to independent gaming commissions in Victoria and Queensland. She also chairs the Australian Institute for Gambling Research based at the University of Western Sydney, Macarthur. David Miers is a Professor of Law and Director of the Centre for Professional Legal Studies, Cardiff Law School, UK. He has many years’ experience analysing the regulation of commerical gambling markets, in particular in Great Britain. His most recent work concerns the regulation and implementation of the new National Lottery. In 1990 he was appointed Specialist Adviser to the parliamentary Home Affairs Committee to assist in its review of the regulation of betting, gaming and lotteries. More recently he has acted as a consultant to the Home Office on gambling issues. Wendy Selby is a Fellow in the Faculty of Humanities, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia. Her research interests include the impact of public policy on women, particularly health policy. Jean-Michel Servet is Professor of Economics at the Faculty of Economic Sciences and of Management at the University of Lumière-Lyon, where he heads the graduate program of Money, Finance and Banking. He has worked in West Africa since 1970, and currently works on the study of comparative monetary systems as well as the different theories of money and savings. He is also co-editor of the Complete Economic Works of Auguste and Leon Walras. James F.Smith, co-author of The Business of Risk (1985), is Professor of English and American Studies at Penn State, Abington—Ogontz Campus. His research interests include gambling, popular culture studies, and the post-Second World War baby boom generation. Michael Walker is a Senior Lecturer in Psychology at the University of Sydney. He is the author of The Psychology of Gambling (Pergamon Press, 1992). Peter Williams researches relations of culture and power in Australia since the 1940s, and lives in the La Trobe Valley, Victoria, Australia.
INTRODUCTION Jan McMillen
Gambling in one form or another has been a feature of all cultures, but it has been legalised and commercialised on a grand scale only since the 1960s. Fuelled by growing middle-class affluence and the liberalisation of social values in western industrialised nations, commercial interests have seen gambling as a new opportunity for profitable investment. Governments have been spurred to legalise gambling by the prospect of additional revenues and the need to control the spread of existing illegal activities. Popular gambling practices have been reorganised to conform to commercial criteria and new forms of gambling have been introduced to entice new players. In the case of horseracing and casino games, traditional gambling cultures have been incorporated into broad policies of economic development, notably the expansion of mass tourism and entertainment industries. While gambling has always attracted attention from observers intrigued by the universality and diversity of society and culture, until the 1970s articles on gambling were published mostly in peripheral journals as if it was not a serious subject for scholarly analysis. Since the proliferation of commercial gambling in Britain and the United States during the 1970s, however, the study of gambling has begun to emerge as a legitimate academic concern. The organisation of regular international gambling conferences by Bill Eadington at the University of Nevada-Reno has been the catalyst for the establishment of a number of national associations (in the United States, Australia, Britain and Europe), each with the goal of encouraging gambling research and analysis. These symposia are indicative of a mounting concern with the economic, social and cultural aspects of gambling development, and have yielded a growing body of literature about the complex character and dynamics of modern gambling. This book focuses on modern gambling from a variety of approaches. It examines the phenomenon of gambling both as a pervasive and diverse cultural expression and as a growing field of political and commercial activity. The book as a whole has an international focus which addresses the symbiotic and changing place of modern gambling in contemporary societies. There are many different forms of gambling, each with its own mix of institutions and relations. Some chapters emphasise a comparative approach between different types of gambling and between nations; others reveal both the diversity and the international character of contemporary gambling cultures. As well as exploring gambling in different social contexts, the various authors adopt different disciplinary approaches which encompass social history and cultural analysis, political economy, philosophy, feminist theory, social psychology and law. The individual chapters offer a sampling of the variety of current gambling research, providing a range of explanations of the ways that contemporary gambling and the policies which shape them have come to be enmeshed in social and cultural life. Although the collection of readings is far from comprehensive, its eclecticism reflects the
Gambling cultures
2
diversity of the modern gambling phenomenon and suggests lines of inquiry which could lead to still more fruitful research in the future. Despite these differences, I have tried to bring a measure of coherence to the book by formulating guidelines to authors and questions directed to socio-cultural aspects of gambling development. The fact that some authors have given more attention to political, economic and legal concerns than others reflects the issues being debated today and the increasingly critical state of thinking within the heterogeneous community of gambling specialists. At the risk of over-simplification, the very character of modern gambling is being challenged, both in economic assumptions of the merits of growth and in its social, political and human aspects as well. The fundamental aim of the book is to set gambling in the wider context of development and to pose questions which fall within the general considerations of policymakers. Every chapter focuses to some extent on the relationship between gambling policy and the socio-cultural environment, underlining the prominence of cultural factors in the practice and organisation of modern gambling. Several of the chapters also discuss this theme in the wider context of the new global order—that is, the rapid spread of (frequently American) commercialised gambling-practices and technology across national boundaries—which is increasingly coming to compete with traditional cultures and social practices in shaping the policy agenda. The authors express divergent views on these matters, but one theme which continually emerges is the importance of culture in gambling politics. The first chapter sets the scene by considering theoretical developments in gambling studies, focusing on the historical relationship between explanations for gambling, changing socio-cultural values and national gambling policies. Jan McMillen examines the various theoretical and empirical understandings of gambling by exploring the diverse and changing explanations of gambling in different countries. The chapter begins with a critical review of theories of gambling, examining contributions by historians, sociologists and policy analysts for their relevance for a general understanding of gambling as a set of social relations, popular practices and policies. The point is made that the varied and shifting national perspectives on gambling have reflected changing moral attitudes and specific political-economic contexts as much as the divergent and narrow disciplinary viewpoints of practising researchers. Set against a background of policy changes which have opened the way for more legal gambling, the next three chapters examine the transformation of gambling in various historical and geographical contexts. They focus on how modern gambling policies have been formed and the historical factors which have contributed to the changing relationship between gambling and different cultures. The complex system of legal statutes and enforcement mechanisms which regulate gambling is an important element in conveying a particular image of how a society should be organised and managed. In Chapter 2, John Dombrink examines the varied and contradictory process whereby gambling in the United States has come to be treated differently from other social ‘vices’ subject to official prohibition and sanction, and is now defined as a legitimate leisure activity. In Chapter 3, Wendy Selby continues the comparative theme by exploring the significance of public morality, national culture and policy priorities in the different histories of the lottery in Australia and the United States. In a similar way, David Dixon in Chapter 4 contrasts the different social control policies of British and Australian law
Introduction
3
enforcement agencies to deal with persistent illegal betting. Controls over gambling are applied selectively and unequally across society, sometimes reinforcing existing patterns and in others changing them. Issues common to these three studies include the ambiguous relation between public and private aspects of gambling, the complexity of moral debates and the diversity of interests around gambling issues, political struggles of the Church and other oppositional interests, and the significant and contradictory role of the state. The next four chapters present case studies which give a more specific focus to some of the general cultural concerns raised in earlier chapters. The emphasis here is on different forms of gambling as distinct cultural practices. By stressing the importance of cultural and non-material aspects of gambling, these chapters provide insights into the deeply entrenched popularity of gambling in different societies. In various ways, they distinguish between gambling under capitalism and gambling in other socio-cultural systems, exploring the implications of bringing informal and traditional aspects of gambling into the area of economic activity. In Chapter 5, James F.Smith examines the historical relationship between gambling and popular culture in the United States, and contends that by turning acts of spontaneous play into commercial transactions, the new culture of gambling has diminished its social value. Chapter 6 presents Peter Williams’s literary analysis of gambling as a consistent theme in the writings of Frank Hardy, one of Australia’s most notable writers and staunch defender of the working class. Hardy’s populist portrayal of gambling is seen as a representation of the political struggle by society’s ‘battlers’ to challenge economic uncertainty and the authority of the powerful. From a sociological perspective, in Chapter 7 Rachael Dixey explores the positive contribution of bingo to the lives of working-class women in a British community. Dixey explains the popularity of bingo in the context of broad social changes which occurred in British cities in the 1960s, arguing that bingo provided working-class women with valuable social interaction and stability when traditional social structures were being dismantled. Chapter 8 presents a psychological explanation by Mark Dickerson of the appeal of machine gaming for players. His research into regular players in New South Wales clubs seeks to identify the psycho-social factors which differentiate most players from those who develop a problem with their gambling. The next three chapters illuminate the relationship between modern commercial gambling policies, cultural practices and social structure. This section of the book raises questions about the political-economic aspects of modern gambling practices, highlighting the location of gambling in the structure and culture of contemporary society. Each chapter examines how commercial gambling and state policy can foster inequalities, national chauvinism and specific values within popular culture. In Chapter 9 Gabrielle Brenner and her colleagues discuss their studies of gambling behaviour in two African countries, Cameroon and Senegal, where lotteries are a growing source of government revenue. While the state has legalised lotteries to alleviate its economic problems, this research shows that the players, mostly young educated men, are attracted by games that offer prizes big enough to allow them to better themselves economically. In Chapter 10 Vicki Abt’s critical analysis of the rapid expansion of commercial gambling in the United States also considers the pressures which have prompted state governments to reverse their opposition to gambling, highlighting the implications for traditional American social values. In her view, the emphasis on consumerism and immediate wealth in the promotion of commercialised gambling has eroded the culture of
Gambling cultures
4
play in gambling, and conflicts with the productive ethos which has generated the material benefits of American society. In a different context, Chapter 11 presents Sytze Kingma’s analysis of the historical relationship between legalised gambling and the cultural underpinnings of the Netherlands. He makes the important point that a transformation of traditional forms of gambling often accompanies increasing commercialisation but does not necessarily lead to degeneration of the local or regional culture. The final group of chapters raises questions about the future directions of gambling policies from a variety of theoretical perspectives. In Chapter 12 Michael Walker offers a critical perspective on the tendency in some countries to continue to see ‘excessive’ gambling by some individuals as a medical problem. To the extent that definitions of problem gambling reflect the existing socio-cultural situation, the policy response is likely to represent and reinforce the views and interests of the more powerful groups. Walker challenges the adoption of the medical model of gambling ‘addiction’ which has been institutionalised in the United States and often accepted by researchers in other nations. In Chapter 13 William Eadington discusses the social ambiguities and moral dilemmas which have been associated with the legalisation of gambling in various nations. Although many of these concerns have been eased by changes in social values and the effects of government policy, so that gambling is increasingly accepted as a mainstream leisure activity, some old problems persist and new ethical issues have emerged which continue to challenge policy-makers. In Chapter 14, from a political perspective, Jan McMillen discusses the rapid expansion of legalised casinos around the world since the 1970s and considers the extent to which the basic culture and socio-political structure of each country conditions casino policies. Within the general trend to globalisation and transnational investment by casino corporations, she examines the means at the disposal of destination countries to ensure that casinos contribute to national goals and are compatible with the local culture. Chapter 15 examines these trends from a legal viewpoint. David Miers’ analysis of the various regulatory regimes which have evolved to control gambling development compares the underlying principles and characteristics of national regulatory systems, identifying factors which can result in the erosion of those control objectives. It is important to note that there have been significant changes to gambling developments and policies since these chapters were written. Debates about the sociocultural status of gambling, changes to the character and capacity of regulatory regimes, and the aggressive commercial pursuit of new gambling markets continue to reshape modern gambling at both national and global levels. In summary, the book points to the merits of an interdisciplinary understanding of gambling in contemporary societies. However, most of the analyses originate from western industrialised (often predominantly Protestant) countries; there are some obvious and important omissions from this collection. Despite my best efforts, I was unable to locate anyone to write a suitable chapter on gambling in, for example, Asia. Given the centrality of gambling to many Asian cultures and the emerging importance of Asia as a potential market, this is a major gap in the overall picture of gambling culture and policies. A comparative analysis of the social and cultural implications of gambling policies in countries with different religious traditions (Islam, Confucianism) and belief
Introduction
5
systems also would be illuminating. Nor is there much reference in this volume to the difference between gambling in countries which pursue a broadly socialist policy and those which do not. Apart from some state involvement in lotteries, in most of the countries discussed in the following chapters the private sector has been given a predominant role in gambling development. The studies offered here are only beginning to touch on the issues. In the field of gambling studies, as in any other, it will take time for a substantial body of knowledge and theoretical discourse to develop. This book represents one step in the attempt to analyse gambling in the light of different cultures and different theories. I hope the information and ideas raised here will serve as a stimulus to more coordinated and comprehensive explanations of gambling in the future.
1 UNDERSTANDING GAMBLING History, concepts and theories Jan McMillen
Gambling is one of the few social activities that occurs in nearly all cultures and in every period of time: in this respect it can be said to be virtually a universal phenomenon in human societies (Wykes 1964; France 1974). Chinese gambling, for example, can be traced back more than 4,000 years. Excavations at Ur (2000 BC), Crete (1800 BC), Egypt (1600 BC) and India (1000 BC) have unearthed dice and gaming boards; betting on horse-racing was common among the Hittites (4000 BC). Archaeological records show that for over 2,000 years many ancient Asian and Arabian societies have tossed tokens or coins to guide decisions; similar games were popular with the Greeks and Roman legions. Gaming was so popular with soldiers during the Crusades that in order to maintain discipline King Richard I forbade gambling among soldiers below the rank of knight. Governments and philanthropists long ago recognised the potential of popular gambling to generate extra revenues for public works. In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, during the reigns of Queen Elizabeth and Queen Anne, state lotteries raised funds for London’s water supply, to pay the salaries of civil servants, and to finance the colonisation of America. In North America throughout the eighteenth century, lotteries were an accepted means of financing public projects such as bridges and roads, churches and universities. Despite its apparent universality, the concept of gambling has no intrinsic meaning; rather, its meaning always depends on the socio-historical context in which it occurs. The perception and experience of gambling vary significantly—in its history, its organisation and its meanings—according to different types of gambling, the various groups involved, and the particular society within which the gambling takes place. As it is understood in modern societies, gambling commonly refers to risk-taking activities which can be found in almost every aspect of social life, from personal relationships to international politics. In contemporary academic research, however, ‘objective’ criteria are used to distinguish gambling from other risk-taking social behaviours. The convention is to define gambling narrowly in terms of financial transactions—the staking of money, or an item of economic value, on the uncertain outcome of a future event. It is significant that this definition excludes both informal private gambling, where money is merely circulated among players without generating a profit, and investment in the stock market, where speculation is for long-term financial or commercial gain through industrial activity (Abt et al. 1985:37; Huizinga 1949:52–3). Although this narrowly economic definition has currency in twentieth-century capitalism, gambling has different components and meanings in other socio-historical contexts. In pre-capitalist societies, such as Bali, China, Africa and Australian Aboriginal communities, gambling traditionally has been
Understanding gambling
7
primarily for socially defined ends, often organised around religious or communal activities with little direct economic significance (Altman 1985; Geertz 1972; Maclean 1984). In capitalist societies, gambling activity increasingly takes place in circumstances which allow an individual, group or organisation to extract a profit from the transaction. Yet until recently gambling has been subjected to considerable intellectual and political disapproval with strong moral overtones. There has been a long history of British and European states submitting gambling to a variety of regulations under the guise of preventing exploitation, public nuisance controls and the eradication of ‘vice’ (Miers 1980; Wykes 1964). Even when public lotteries were used to fund popular and prestigious causes, such as the establishment of the British Museum and north American universities, inadequate government supervision and the discovery of frauds and widespread cheating frequently caused a public outcry which fostered an anti-gambling response by governments. Analytical definitions of gambling are particularly sensitive to such shifts in social conditions and ideologies of control. Periodic reformulations of the relation between gambling and society have been related to culturally and historically accepted definitions of what gambling is, influenced by fluctuating conceptions of morality which reflect prevailing social and political-economic conditions. Understandings of gambling are determined more by the perspectives and purposes of the analyst than by the inherent nature of the subject. All commentaries on gambling, even the most determinedly ‘objective’, proceed from a particular historically and socially determined point of view.
THEORETICAL AND HISTORICAL FOUNDATIONS A central theme of this chapter is that studies of gambling, while entrenched in specific disciplinary traditions, have reflected the more general historical development of social science theories and the sensitivity of theorists to contemporary social issues. Within the broad intellectual developments of the post-war period emerged what has come to be understood as ‘gambling studies’ (Caldwell et al. 1985; Campbell and Lowman 1989; Eadington 1976, 1982d, 1986b; Eadington and Cornelius 1991; Frey and Eadington 1984; McMillen 1985; Walker 1987). This encompasses a fragmented and diverse body of work which includes behavioural studies of gamblers, the investigation of ‘problem’ gambling, mathematical analysis of different forms of wagering, economic analysis of gambling patterns and studies of gambling policy and the law. Many of the assumptions underlying different explanations for gambling derive from the particular disciplinary or theoretical perspective of the researcher. Differences in approach and subject matter also stem from the divergent origins of national philosophies and the changing national-cultural contexts of gambling itself. Even so, it is possible to recognise structural correlates and common trends in scholarship related to the changing status of gambling in society. Whenever gambling is being analysed, fundamental questions are raised about the actual and potential relationship between gambling, the state and civil society, both in general and in particular nation states. In American gambling studies, for instance, analysis has shifted since the 1970s from a focus on the dysfunctional and immoral aspects of gambling which prevailed in the prohibition
Gambling cultures
8
climate of pre-war years (Devereux 1968a; Frey 1984; Rosecrance 1988a:12–52, 58–62; Skolnick 1978:3–34) to a more recent emphasis on economic and legal-administrative factors associated with the smooth operation of a newly legal industry (Aronson and Miller 1980; Eadington 1976, 1982b, 1990, 1991; Dombrink and Thompson 1986; Lehne 1986; Rose 1987; Rosecrance 1988a: 63–7; Skolnick 1978, 1979b; Weinstein and Deitch 1974). The British state has taken a less moralistic but more regulated approach to most forms of public gambling, and the British analytical preoccupation with political and legal processes has been reflected in contributions from public administration, criminology and the history of law (Dixon 1980a, 1983, 1984, 1989; Miers and Dixon 1979; Hood 1972, 1976:169–207; Miers 1980, 1981, 1984, 1985, 1987). In turn, prevailing assumptions and knowledge about gambling have had important implications for policy outcomes. Either directly or indirectly, public morality and the type of information available about gambling at any specific time have been important factors in the state’s policy approach. The ostensibly neutral data and explanations which have resulted from academic research and government reports have provided normative and often ethnocentric accounts which variously endorse or condemn particular gambling practices and their effects. The understanding of gambling produced by researchers has informed policy decisions about the further expansion of gambling facilities or the type of legislation or regulation that is required. This chapter will discuss the divergent and changing explanations of gambling, situating different types of gambling analysis within their particular historical-national contexts and underlying philosophies. It will argue that explanations of gambling have been dominated by normative and culturally specific theories of liberal social science. The liberal and individualistic assumptions of these theories pose conceptual and methodological problems which limit their capacity to explain the emergence and nature of modern commercial gambling. When social scientists have investigated gambling, the emphasis in most studies has been on the empirical observation of individual behaviour rather than a broader understanding of the changing gambling phenomenon. A core theme of this critique is that liberal theories fail to recognise that contemporary gambling is not governed primarily by the actions of individuals, but is conditioned by capitalist social relations and political-economic forces, of which individuals are an integral part. Moreover, with an analytical emphasis on individual behaviour and motivations, many analysts have defined gambling in terms of generalised, abstract concepts such as ‘rational behaviour’ and ‘leisure’. Such perspectives make a number of covert assumptions about common, defining characteristics of gambling which do not stand up to historical scrutiny of its diverse forms and locations. Legal gambling shows marked variations in its composition, when and how it is introduced, whose interests it furthers and in its effects. Although often presented in terms of increasing public ‘access’ to gambling, legalised gambling is as oppressive of some activities as it is liberating. The ‘freedom’ to gamble is not universal or evenly distributed. Discriminations are embedded in institutions and routinised in commercial activities and administrative procedures, so that a distinction between legal and illegal gambling is rendered normal. Similar criticisms can be made regarding the overgeneralised explanations of gambling. Even those analysts who do acknowledge the close relation between gambling, culture and the nation state frequently do not take into account the heterogeneous character of the state and the lack of socio-cultural homogeneity. Analysis of the nature
Understanding gambling
9
and extent of modern gambling in capitalism requires examination of the profoundly contingent and selective content of government policies and commercial activities. From this perspective, research questions about the post-war global expansion of legalised gambling should probe the complex social relations lying beneath the surface data of legal gambling, rather than, as in conventional sociology, concentrating on what gambling means for participants (Goffman 1967; Caldwell 1974, 1985a; Rosecrance 1985, 1987), or as in liberal economics and political science, being content to merely identify what contributions gambling has made to economic development or successful government (Alchin 1989; Cabot and Schuetz 1991; Eadington and Hattori 1976; Gruen 1976; Haig 1976; Hood 1972, 1976:169–207; Johnson 1976, 1985; Lehne 1986; Suits 1977, 1979). It will be argued that conventional theories of gambling have diverted attention from the fact that contemporary gambling, whether legal or illegal, is as much an expression of capital-state relations and political-legal decisions as of individual behaviour. Gambling receives much of its definition from the institutions of state (Parliament, political parties, agencies of administration and law enforcement) and capital (private gambling corporations, marketing agencies) through which it is organised, regulated and experienced. From the vast range of possible ways that gambling could be conducted, state activities give certain forms of gambling an official seal of approval, and suppress, marginalise and erode others. An understanding of the changes and growth of modern gambling therefore must consider the role of the state in determining what types of gambling are available. Furthermore, gambling has become an important component of modern leisure industries, run as a business for profit by both private and public enterprises. The individualism of many liberal approaches to gambling analysis diverts attention from the historically specific system of power in capitalist society which produces and reproduces gambling and structures behaviour in the interests of profit. In summary, this chapter raises theoretical and empirical issues concerning the relation between gambling practices, policies and theories in different socio-historical contexts. It will examine: 1 the growth of legal gambling as a specific socio-historical phenomenon, with specific attention to the historical diversity of practices and trends in gambling policies; 2 the diverse and changing range of theories which have been applied to gambling in its various manifestations. The chapter proposes that gambling is best explained by investigating the interaction between political, industrial and socio-cultural forms in contemporary capitalism. The discussion is divided into four sections. The first section opens with a critique of negative explanations of gambling which have frequently been made by psychologists, economists and sociologists. Many past and present theorists have perceived gambling in a pejorative sense as a psychological, social and moral problem. This section will consider debates over gambling and social order, particularly the sociological view of gambling as deviant behaviour. Such perspectives on gambling have been compatible with the prevailing policies of constraint and prohibition in the major theoretical nations (Britain, the United States). The second section will discuss the post-war theoretical shift to a more liberal view which attempts to explain the social persistence and political liberalisation of gambling.
Gambling cultures
10
The main focus will be to summarise and critically evaluate the most influential post-war contributions to a general theory of gambling. This discussion begins by examining the shift in the focus of gambling analysis from deviance to leisure within liberal social science in the United States, Britain and Australia. While acknowledging the contributions of these studies to gambling policy and understanding, it will be argued that analysis needs to depart from the sociological conventions of associating gambling primarily with the leisure experience of individuals, and of using the concept in a universal sense devoid of politics. The third section will centre on the relevance of the public choice explanation of gambling policy which has dominated US explanations for the post-war evolution of commercial casinos and lotteries. This raises theoretical and empirical issues of the complicated relation between the contemporary gambling industry and state regulation. Finally, the chapter will conclude by considering critical contributions from within radical criminology and the history of law which explore the ambivalent character of modern forces of gambling control, whether concerned with liberalisation or with regulation. Gambling studies from Britain, Canada and the United States have exposed the dialectical relationship between the state and the private sphere in the production of social order. Their insights into the interactions between politics, law and public morality reveal both the complexity and the ubiquity of legalised gambling.
GAMBLING AND SOCIETY: CONVENTIONAL VIEWS Many analysts share several core—but problematic—assumptions about relations between gambling and society. With few exceptions, post-war accounts of gambling have been retarded by three interrelated influences on the approach and subject matter of gambling analysis. First, conservative moral forces have exerted subtle but powerful influences over academic inquiry. Historical-theoretical assumptions about relations between morality and legality, work and leisure, production and consumption, politics and economics, the past and the present, have combined to produce a conservative approach to gambling analysis which tends to legitimate the prevailing state of affairs. Second, the post-war dominance of the positivist tradition which assumes the existence of value-free facts has produced an unreflective approach which is blind to the sociopolitical construction of gambling illegality and legality. Third, most theories and explanations of gambling behaviour have been produced in isolation from histories of gambling politics and social relations. Changes in gambling legalisation are viewed merely as unproblematic sign-posts along the road to modern gambling practices (Blakey and Kurland 1978; Cornell Law School 1977; Cornish 1978). Rarely has contemporary gambling been examined with the objective of providing an account of the sociohistorical specificity of policy development or an adequate general explanation of the growing commercialisation of the industry (Dessant 1976; Herman 1976:115). In the absence of a theoretically informed critique of such changes, the narrow focus of gambling studies restricts the extent to which they explain the phenomenon. Several interrelated criticisms may be made of conventional gambling studies. In general, they
Understanding gambling
11
1 treat gambling as a universal constant, without adequate differentiation between various forms or considering the variable moral and political forces underlying their construction; 2 reflect liberal ideologies specific to the socio-historical development of capitalism, notably individualism and economic rationality. Changing conceptions of gambling have been linked to prevailing political and cultural norms and to disciplinary concerns for social order; 3 implicitly or explicitly have seen gambling as a ‘problem’ of social control and administration. Even in Australia, where gambling has been widely accepted, debates about the morality and legality of gambling often emphasise that it has potentially disruptive social tendencies; 4 adopt an economistic stance which prescribes analytical separation of economic and political realms and a conception of culture as a reflection of the economic base. This is most clearly manifest in the sociological conceptualisation of gambling as leisure, a social activity analytically distinct from the realm of work and production; 5 assume an ahistorical or static conception of gambling which does not account for the dynamics of gambling structures and processes; 6 adopt a positivistic approach to gambling research which apprehends the appearance of the social and political-economic relations in gambling as if they are natural; 7 suffer from empirical ethnocentrism, aggravated by the absence of an explicit comparative perspective of different political-cultural contexts; and 8 are unable to accommodate a dialectical conception of gambling relations—between competing classes, between capital and the state or between national and global dimensions. Conventional approaches to gambling analysis have constructed two distinct yet interrelated methodological tendencies—functionalism and positivism. Most studies generally have either implicitly or explicitly entailed a functionalist perspective (Newman 1972:11). With an emphasis on social harmony, this sort of interpretation concentrates on the functional and dysfunctional consequences of gambling in society, the role of gambling in reinforcing and enhancing social values and the ways that gambling has evolved or adapted to wider changes in the nature of other social institutions such as work, the family and public attitudes. Social theories of gambling reach their most sophisticated form in the sociology of gambling behaviour and social administration. While the social administration approach takes the distributional and developmental aspects of gambling participation as its major concerns, the sociology of gambling has traditionally looked more broadly at the social functions of gambling. That is, it has accepted (usually without question) the structural and political-economic aspects of gambling, concentrating on the content of gambling behaviour. The negative view: gambling as a social problem Many studies to some extent or other have continued to endorse the negative assumptions and legal sanctions towards gambling which prevailed in most western countries in the pre-war period. By and large, they pose the issue with three broad themes.
Gambling cultures
12
1 It is assumed that the primary determinant of gambling participation is individual choice, so that patterns of legalised gambling have little to do with the social environment in which they occur. A fundamental reason for this is the general perception that gambling is essentially an aspect of ‘play’ (Caillois 1961; Huizinga 1949). 2 Gambling can be distinguished from other forms of ‘playful’ or leisure activity in moral or ethical terms; it is assumed to be, at least potentially, a social ‘problem’ which needs to be controlled (Dielman 1979; Newman 1975). The negative and pejorative way gambling is presented, and acceptance of the state’s claim to authority and resources to determine the nature and extent of gambling in the community, rest on common ideas of its possible harmful implications. The genesis of the widespread condemnation of gambling is complex; but if one agency is more responsible than any other, it has been the strength of Protestantism in western capitalist societies (Weber 1976 [1904–5]; Rosecrance 1988a:32–7; Miers 1980). This approach derives from the notion, widely held during the period of post-war industrial reconstruction, that gambling is primarily an attempt by the gambler to make ‘easy money’ (Turner 1965) and thus is a denial of the work ethic and a threat to production. For example, the conceptual distinction historically made between gambling and stock market speculation or insurance investment rests on normative perceptions of gambling as devoid of useful economic functions (Paton 1946). This conception is reinforced by the a priori assumptions of economic studies which have perceived gambling as selfdefeating irrational behaviour leading to financial problems at a personal and social level (Rosett 1965; Rubner 1966; Cowan 1974), and of social science theories which considered gambling as destructive of the individual (Simmel 1920; Freud 1928; Bergler 1957; Oldman 1978) and of society (Bloch 1957; Herman 1967, 1976; Peterson 1951). Psychologists and psychiatrists have played a key role in arguing that a proportion of gamblers are unable to resist impulses to gamble and consequently compromise, disrupt and damage personal, family and work relations (Dickerson 1984; Halliday and Fuller 1974; Lesieur 1984; Lesieur and Custer 1984; Lesieur and Puig 1987). 3 Gambling and its consequences are examined within an implicit ethical framework which reflects prevailing legal definitions and discriminations. Political and legal interpretations of gambling and its supposedly disruptive social effects have permeated the analysis of gambling at every level. The conceptual connection between social science, rationalisation and social control in contemporary policy has produced a ‘social engineering’ approach which conceptualises gambling in terms of predetermined notions of legality and illegality, deviance and ‘normal’ behaviour. Underlying this view of gambling is an explicit endorsement of the liberal state as the proper mechanism of control. It is accepted as self-evident that state intervention to restrict certain forms of gambling is essential for the common good. This is aptly illustrated by sociological studies which present gambling as deviance or crime. Significantly, sociological studies of gambling increased during the 1960s and 1970s in Britain and the United States when it appeared to thrive in defiance of legal prohibitions. As sociology sought to establish itself as an independent and objective discipline, it demarcated a distinct object of knowledge—the gambler—thus separating the study of gambling from the workings and theory of social relations. Using aspects of ‘control
Understanding gambling
13
theory’ (Downes and Rock 1982), a structural link between gambling and socioeconomic conditions has been constructed through a variety of factors which indicate a decline in rational behaviour or moral standards—for instance, the erosion of positive social influences such as religion. Particularly in the United States, gambling studies have argued that gambling remains outside and in opposition to dominant values (Devereux 1968a; Grichting 1986; Rosecrance 1988a:58–63). As a threat to the equilibrium of society, gambling therefore must be constrained. Even radical sociologists who suggested that gambling may be in some respects rational with socially beneficial effects for working-class groups accepted, at least implicitly, the legal premise that gambling is a vice which if unconstrained has fundamentally harmful effects for society in general (Zola 1967 [1963]). A great deal of American research in this field has attempted to discover what people in ‘deviant’ minority groups (the poor, ethnic communities, prisoners) get out of gambling (Polsky 1971; Light 1977a, 1977b; McCall 1963). The answer initially was found in the fatalism and recklessness of these individuals and their socio-cultural predispositions, such as the ‘culture of poverty’ or the institutional climate of prisons. This negative psychologistic approach to gambling as deviance contrasts sharply with conventional interpretations of other leisure-related activities, which have been overwhelmingly positive with important beneficial consequences for individuals and society. Because these analysts accepted without question the legal restrictions and moral condemnation of gambling, they have not considered that gambling may be beneficial to individuals and society in the same way. Furthermore, by explaining gambling by reference to the intrinsic characteristics of gamblers themselves, these studies exclude any consideration of the character of law, of politics or socio-economic relations. Accepted definitions of legality also have meant that social science has stressed the criminal behaviour associated with illegal gambling. In America, strong moral and legal condemnation of gambling has been exacerbated by the traditional involvement of criminals, particularly in casinos (Albanese 1985; Chambliss 1978; Dombrink 1981; Dombrink and Thompson 1986; King 1969; Reuter 1983, 1984; Reuter and Rubenstein 1981). Some psychologists and medical practitioners have drawn a direct association between crime and ‘pathological’ gambling which presents a further threat to public morality (Brown 1987; Lesieur 1987; Blaszczynski et al. 1989). With the expansion of legalised gambling in the 1980s, however, the conceptual distinction between ‘social’ recreational gamblers and so-called ‘pathological’ or ‘compulsive’ gamblers is less certain, with no agreement about either the nature or the extent of the problem (Rosecrance 1985b, 1988a:106–21). In other nations, these analytical ambiguities and policy discriminations have taken different cultural forms. In Britain, legal constraints have reflected a view that gaming is a more likely source of criminal activity and greater potential threat to public morality than betting, especially among the working class (Dixon 1989; Miers 1980). In Australia, where unusually liberal laws have made a variety of gambling forms relatively respectable (McMillen and Eadington 1986; O’Hara 1988), it has been less common for gambling to be conceptualised as deviant or criminal behaviour. However, the possible involvement of criminals and political corruption associated with gambling and the possible disruptive social effects of ‘excessive’ gambling and criminal infiltration remain central themes for analysis and policy. Despite
Gambling cultures
14
its legal status, gambling is considered to be a marginal social phenomenon, a problem of control and technical administration. Underlying this common negative perception of gambling is a particular view of the relationship between gambling, society and the state; namely, the belief that the state provides the only viable or legitimate means for mediating between people and gambling operations. Deviancy theory was notable for the insight that ‘deviance is not a quality of the act the person commits, but rather a consequence of the application by others of rules and sanctions’ (Becker 1963:5). On this interpretation it would seem to follow that the concept of ‘the state’ which devised rules and sanctions would be at the core of the study of gambling. However, Becker’s influential critique, which pointed sociology towards the problematic operation of control institutions and macro-structural analysis, has had little impact on gambling studies. Sociological studies tend to understate the central role of the state in the creation of gambling deviance and to view the state’s role in the definition of gambling behaviour as devoid of moral choice and political decision. By definition, state intervention conventionally is seen in the liberal sense as neutral and necessary to sustain the preconditions of social order and conformity—the central concerns being gamblers’ behaviour and the precise mode of regulation. As Matza suggests, the ‘lofty subject’ of the state, ‘unrelated to so seamy a matter as deviation’ (1969:143), has been implicitly earmarked as the domain of political science. Even so, the work of deviancy theorists is important for gambling analysis because it heralds the more critical concern for the aetiology of illegality and problems of the state which became the concern of radical criminology in the 1970s and of British gambling studies in the 1980s. Positive perspectives: gambling as leisure What can be called a liberal sociological analysis of gambling gained strength in the years following the Second World War, presenting a more positive explanation of gambling as a legitimate leisure activity (Devereux 1968a, 1968b; Downes et al. 1976). In the post-war period, opportunities for the ‘affluent worker’ (Goldthorpe et al. 1969) to participate in organised gambling increased dramatically in several countries. With increased legalisation and respectability, gambling was no longer seen simply as a social pathology which would lead inevitably to moral decay and crime. From a functionalist perspective, it began to be investigated both as an instrumental activity directed to an economic end (‘winning’ defined primarily in terms of economic success) and as an expressive social activity enjoyed as an end in itself (the intrinsic social and personal rewards of ‘playing the game’). Long before, Veblen had suggested that members of affluent social groups in the nineteenth century were able to display their social superiority and wealth through conspicuous consumption of leisure activities such as gambling (Veblen 1953 [1899]). Post-war economists agreed that gamblers are capable of making logical choices to improve their wealth and socio-economic position (Friedman and Savage 1946; Gruen 1976). Economic explanations of gambling motivations have been inconsistent, however, some research showing that gambling participation is more typical of Veblen’s high-status ‘leisure class’, others that gambling is primarily a working-class activity (Pryor 1976). Sociologists have usually dealt with issues such as the social content of gambling situations—ethnographic studies of gambling settings, for example, or the nature of what
Understanding gambling
15
they term ‘gambling careers’. The most illuminating work within the post-war liberal sociology of gambling has been interactionist in its approach, concentrating on the immediate social relationships between individuals in the gambling context. The traditional focus by the sociology of deviance on ‘nuts, sluts and perverts’ permitted the flourishing of sympathy with social ‘outsiders’ and hostility to social control (Becker 1968). Even where gambling is considered as being apart from ‘normal’ behaviour, interactionist studies have considered the possibility of positive consequences and meanings of gambling from the player’s viewpoint. The central theoretical formulation which has provided the sociological basis for a more positive perspective on gambling was developed by Erving Goffman (1967). At one level Goffman ‘lifts gambling out of the moral abyss into which successive generations of commentators and reformers have consigned it and renders possible a consideration of its meaning which is freed from a priori associations of a negative kind’ (Downes et al. 1976:17). Rather than deviant behaviour, he argued that gambling provides players with an opportunity to demonstrate strength of character and commitment to valued social codes such as risk-taking, courage and honesty. At the same time, his analysis contains an implicit recognition that gambling contributes to the moral and political regulation of society by reaffirming conventional values. While gambling provides a substitute for challenges removed from ordinary life, it also is given an added civilising function as a beneficial agency of socialisation and social control. The major theoretical contribution of sociological studies has been a more positive conception of gambling incorporated into the realm of leisure. From this perspective, gambling is enjoyed and participated in for its own sake; hence, the majority of studies have been mainly concerned with questions about who gambles and why they gamble in particular ways (Scimecca 1971). Many studies have directed a psychologically orientated focus exclusively on the motivations and behaviours of individuals involved in the gambling process. From this broad view, participation in gambling is regarded as an institutionalised leisure activity compensating for the dysfunctional and unfulfilling aspects of contemporary society. Gambling, like leisure, is defined in terms of ‘play’ or ‘free time’, and juxtaposed to work and other activities with recognisable social obligations. Leisure activities such as gambling are considered to be an essential component in the maintenance and equilibrium of the social structure, an issue only because of the debilitating nature of modern work, which, it is argued, stifles creativity (Parker 1976; Goldthorpe et al. 1969). From this view, gambling, although often distinguished from other legitimate leisure activities by its illegality and social stigma, is normal and thoroughly integrated with other practices and institutions of the society within which it occurs. Drawing on a range of theoretical perspectives, sociologists have suggested that gambling functions both as recuperative ‘adult play’ or as an escapist ‘safety valve’ from the burden of work (Herman 1967; Devereux 1968a); as ‘deviant adaptations’ to anomie (Martinez 1983) or to alienation (Downes et al. 1976:72–5); as an integral element of working-class culture which seeks to overcome lack of success and security (Dennis et al. 1956; Herman 1976; Zola 1967 [1963]); as an outlet for gamblers to test chance and skill (Oldman 1974; Campbell 1976); and as an effective opportunity for self-realisation and creativity lacking in the workplace (Goffman 1967; Bloch 1957; Smith and Preston 1984). The attraction of contemporary gambling and the commitment of regular gamblers
Gambling cultures
16
even in the face of consistent losses have been explained predominantly in terms of the rewards gained from social interaction and group association (D’Angelo 1985; Hayano 1982; Martinez 1983; Rosecrance 1985a, 1986a, 1986b, 1986c, 1987, 1988a:53–87). Relatively few studies have recognised that for some players gambling constitutes work. These studies have examined the subcultural careers of professional gamblers whose disciplined and calculated approach embodies conventional cultural norms of economic gain and the development of specialised skills (Hayano 1984; Herman 1967; Rosecrance 1988b; Thorp 1962; Woung 1980). For many, the post-war understanding of gambling as ‘leisure’, rather than simply as vice or crime, seems to be a triumph of liberalism and humanity. Compared to pre-war attitudes and prohibitions, no doubt it is. But even among liberal sociologists in the United States, gambling has relatively low prestige; and persistent claims by psychologists and medical practitioners of its supposedly endemic dysfunctional tendencies have not made it any more convincing as a legitimate social activity. Clear sociological evidence for a positive social effect of gambling is still lacking (Abt et al. 1985:207; Rosecrance 1987:157). In marked contrast to the US and British experience, the pervasiveness of popular gambling in Australia is celebrated as an important part of the national culture. The characteristics of Australian gambling are such that many social scientists and popular commentators have claimed that Australia has developed a distinctive gambling culture (Ward 1958; Caldwell 1974; Hardy 1958; Inglis 1985; O’Hara n.d. 1988; Charlton 1987). More significantly, gambling has been seen as a positive force, reflecting the egalitarianism and hope of Australian society (Caldwell 1974; Lynch 1990; O’Hara 1988). Australian gambling policies have taken particular directions which reveal interesting comparisons with gambling policies in other nations. Few western societies have legalised gambling to the extent that it has been in Australia. Unlike Britain and the United States, where the fear of individual excess and threats to public order had prompted severe restrictions on most forms of gambling, in Australia gambling has been tolerated as an ‘instinct’ and a ‘natural propensity of workers’.1 This cultural attitude to gambling as the ‘right’ of every citizen has been reflected directly and indirectly in public and official statements since the nineteenth century. What has not been so well recognised is that gambling is also an essentially political issue, not least because Australian gambling has been characterised by an unusually high level of government involvement (McMillen and Eadington 1986; McMillen and Lafferty 1991; McMillen 1986a, 1986b, 1987–88, 1990, 1993; O’Hara 1988; Painter 1990, 1991). The cultural acceptance of gambling has emerged within a constantly changing political-legal framework which is the product of heated debates and conflicts over the specific nature of gambling policies. In Australia, in much the same way as the state assumed responsibility for protecting other valued aspects of social life such as health, education and recreation (Capling and Galligan 1992:20–69; Encel 1970:55–66), the legalisation of gambling and its administration by government agencies have meant it has been widely accepted as a legitimate activity from an early period. The state rhetoric which has legitimated the high level of legal gambling in Australia has been in keeping with prevailing views on morality and emphasised the state’s paramount concern for social priorities. While Australian governments have legalised
Understanding gambling
17
popular gambling to an unusual extent, and undoubtedly benefit from the revenues which are generated, they also have been concerned with the social disorder associated with illegal gambling, prevention of criminal exploitation and the use of gambling revenues for welfare services. Yet too often, analyses of Australian gambling which have celebrated and romanticised gambling as a ‘national pastime’ have avoided a close and critical examination of the historical links between gambling and powerful economic groups, political institutions and the nature of capitalist society in general (McMillen 1993). A recent interdisciplinary extension of the positive approach to gambling analysis has explored the link between changing public attitudes and the commercial and political processes generating policy change. In a landmark analysis of the gambling industry in the United States, Abt et al. (1985) have comprehensively traced the development of legal gambling into a powerful socio-economic force which has profound implications for the values and institutions of contemporary American society as well as important practical policy consequences. Whereas previous studies had shown that in its material causes and in the values it evoked, gambling relates to issues central to social order, this study is more alive to an interpretation of politics, law and socio-cultural change than earlier gambling analyses. In a theoretical break with the ‘sociology of the gambler’, Abt et al. have operated with a more holistic notion of the aetiology of gambling than the conventional, individualistic picture of the ‘irrational’ or ‘immoral’ gambler. By exploring the historical connection between the development of commercial gambling, cultural values and institutional conflicts, they reveal the social and moral ambiguities about gambling which persist in contemporary American society. They show that the legalisation of commercial gambling in America has been a contested process, paralleled by complex social and economic changes which ultimately benefit powerful business interests and the state. Abt et al. have made an important contribution to the understanding of contemporary gambling as a profitable and legitimate business which has an intimate and compatible relationship with American society and core institutions. Gambling in its various forms has become a highly organised and business-like enterprise, the focus of commercial competition and policy disputes. They argue that the erosion of cultural norms that had prohibited gambling permitted this form of entertainment to enter mainstream America. Historically, the impetus occurred at a time of general cultural re-evaluation, as it became clear that economic and state resources and opportunities were limited. In their view, the irony is that the mechanism responsible for this change, the revenue imperative, has rapidly transformed gambling and its social meanings. The very qualities that gave gambling a unique social value—excitement, safe risk, escape—have been changed into yet another set of rote behaviours that serve institutional purposes rather than social needs (Abt et al. 1985:202). This analysis has asked important questions about the objectives and effects of the growth of the gambling industry, but it repeats many of the functionalist assumptions common to liberal gambling studies. For example, they retain the culturalist notion of gambling as a leisure activity which mirrors and reinforces core social values. They propose that while the new gambling policy is the outcome of a changing but ubiquitous cultural consensus, these new values threaten social stability. The successes of capitalism paradoxically erode the traditional impulses which created them: ‘Gambling thus
Gambling cultures
18
exemplifies a reversal of American values: the ethic of saving, of self-denial and capital accumulation, has been replaced by an ideology of hedonistic consumerism’ (Abt et al. 1985:22). Heavily influenced by the American ideology of ‘free enterprise’ and a liberal suspicion of state intervention in the market, the critical thrust is directed towards the role of the state in gambling policy. Like American deviancy theorists, Abt et al. support the view that state intervention is necessary to correct malign tendencies which may appear in gambling relations. As gambling has become increasingly complex and differentiated, the state has a positive but limited role as guardian of public welfare. In this they share liberal assumptions which have characterised American and British social science; their conceptualisation of the state is narrowly defined as the institutional mediator of competing demands and market forces, responsible for sustaining the preconditions of a more crime-free, orderly and integrated society. However, they are sceptical of the capacity for the state to act in an impartial and altruistic way in gambling administration: ‘government is an interested party—both because of its extraordinary claim on gambling revenues and because it directly operates lotteries and off-track betting’ (Abt et al. 1985:217). They view with concern the increasingly central, active role of governments in American gambling administration, and consequently their influence over the nature of contemporary gambling, particularly the proliferation of state lotteries which began to appear in the United States in the late 1970s (Abt et al. 1985:218). Their view is that contemporary gambling will operate most effectively through a market economy and a pluralist polity. Whatever commercial ambitions individual gambling proprietors may have, in order to compete with other enterprises and to attract gamblers they must provide a high standard of integrity and service. Thus the profit motive is seen to be an adequate mechanism to constrain commercial excesses. Within the market, the picture presented is one of rational negotiation and fundamental harmony, expressing the interests of American commerce. Positive perspectives: social administration A number of official studies also have extended the analysis of gambling beyond the cultural or psychological world of the gambler. As part of the expansion of legalised gambling in the 1970s, in Britain and the United States an increasing number of large empirical studies of current gambling practices and institutions began to inform gambling policy (Campbell 1976; Commission of the Review of the National Policy toward Gambling 1976 [Morin Commission]; Downes et al. 1976; Kallick-Kaufman 1979; Royal Commission on Gambling 1978 [Rothschild Report]; Tec 1965; Weinstein and Deitch 1974). Many of these studies are tinged with a liberal concern for the injustice of social inequalities, investigating whether legalised gambling has had harmful effects on society. Others have attempted to integrate empirical knowledge about gambling with middlerange theories to investigate how its very nature and development are influenced by social and environmental factors. Significantly, most of these studies began to assert that gambling is related to features of the socio-economic structure within which it occurs. The research reorientation to large-scale empirical studies of gambling patterns was a product of changing political and social conditions in Britain and the United States in the 1970s. With policy shifts from gambling suppression to increased legalisation, academic
Understanding gambling
19
contributions increasingly were sought for policy formation. The revised liberal approach to gambling research and the methods of positivist sociology were compatible with contemporary policies of gambling expansion. Many of these studies had a strong institutional base, and were often made possible by state sponsorship or financial support to conduct research into the extent of gambling in the community. Underlying the institutional sponsorship of much of this gambling research was the state’s responsibility for crime control and the mitigation of dysfunctional features of the social structure through social and welfare policies. The state became involved in gambling research only after indications of the persistence, perhaps even of growth, of a wide spectrum of illegal gambling. There were, for example, persistent doubts about the prevailing philosophy of gambling prohibition, of directing public money at problems without demonstrable social gains (Morin Commission 1976; Downes et al. 1976; Kallick-Kaufman 1979; Rothschild Report 1978). The accelerated commercial promotion of betting and new post-war developments such as commercial casinos further boosted academic interest in gambling as a topic of inquiry.2 These empirical studies have been dominated by the domain assumptions and methods of positivism, expressed procedurally in an emphasis on the importance of quantifiable concepts and propositions in theory and research. Survey methods, recommended as the best means for systematically assembling hard data on gambling, have been seen to satisfy the disciplinary requirements of policy rationalisation and development in the field of gambling research. Yet, in the search for quantifiable data, survey methods examine only those social variables which are associated with gambling, arbitrarily defined in terms of official definitions (Reuter 1979). The most that such an approach can achieve, however rigorous and thorough, is to shed some light on empirical regularities in gambling participation; it does not provide an understanding of the historical origins of those regularities. Numerous detailed and somewhat inconclusive studies have outlined gambling patterns in terms of the natural, constitutional propensities of gamblers, such as sex, age, race, occupation, status and class (Adler 1966; Blascovich et al. 1976; Dowie 1975; Downton 1969; Kaplan and Maher 1970; Oldman 1974; Scimecca 1971). The tendency for the overwhelming majority of contemporary definitions to equate gambling with leisure also accounts for many of the analytical difficulties encountered by researchers. The sociological account of British gambling by Downes et al. is especially helpful in clarifying the methodological preoccupations which characterise the positivist approach. Questions of gambling provision and organisation were not considered; it was assumed that the primary motivation remained with the individual. Downes and his colleagues tested a number of theoretical propositions about gambling (anomie, alienation, workingclass culture, functionalism, decision-making, risk-taking, work-centred leisure or homecentredness). They reported that none of the theories alone could conclusively be substantiated as adequate explanations for participation in gambling. Rather, the social system itself is considered to be the main determining influence in gambling practice and institutions. The emergence and definition of gambling as a social problem was related primarily to the existence in society of opposing values of leisure and consumption, on the one hand, and work and production on the other (Downes et al. 1976:42). This contrasts with surveys in the United States which have shown that ‘the factors that most
Gambling cultures
20
consistently differentiate gamblers from non-gamblers are the degree of an individual’s exposure to gambling and the availability of that activity’ (Kallick-Kaufman 1979:24). Though sufficient for some policy purposes, these are very superficial views of gambling. Even when the same definition of gambling is shared between nations or across historical periods, the research procedures which apply the formal definition may embody different operational definitions. To this extent, positivist data on gambling can be conceived of as social products, rather than objective facts. The focus on individuals, in theoretical assumptions and in the neglect of collectivities, avoids conceptions of power and structure. Studies which insulate gambling from society and the state do not examine or explain why certain forms of gambling are more prevalent at certain times than others; nor do they explicate the structural factors and power relationships which influence, and are influenced by, the nature and direction of gambling development. They therefore underestimate the sources and nature of control over the gamblers and institutions they study. Contextual factors, such as the emergence of transnational gambling corporations and the state’s varied and contradictory role in the transition of gambling from illegality to legality, are rarely brought into the discussion. Inevitably, the explanations which result provide no more than descriptive and normative accounts of the prevalence of gambling and its latent social ‘functions’. They neglect to convey the dynamic and contested interdependence between gambling relations and the sociocultural context, thus preventing a systematic examination of shifting relationships and broader historical processes which are major mechanisms of change. Omission of the political and historical dimensions of gambling has produced a conception of gambling which postulates that it serves a sui generis function (leisure) for a society devoid of structural or cultural differences and conflicts. Yet gambling is open to subtle forms of social constraint and determination which contradict this definition. Although it has received little attention from researchers, studies of women’s experience of gambling, for example, have shown how it is structured by their subordinate position in capitalist society (Summers 1975:69–77; Dixey 1984). Just as they do in so many other areas, the economic, physical, social and ideological conditions of capitalist society constrain women’s gambling activities in ways that are significantly more restrictive than in the case of men. Gambling also is funda-mentally subject to the direct effect of systems of legitimation and power. The analytical importance of this lies in the fact that gambling, more than most other forms of leisure activities, is defined by state action and legislation which specify what is allowed and what is not. Positivist studies of gambling are not concerned merely with universally agreed practices, but with what is legally defined as legitimate or unacceptable behaviour. This is not to say that the research agenda of positivism (and its many variants) is worthless or theoretically unimportant. Social surveys and trend indicators are indispensable in social and policy analysis, providing statistical information about the composition, incidence and development of gambling patterns which is otherwise unavailable. Many of these studies have provided some valuable and insightful knowledge which confirms that gambling does have integrating qualities. However, the survey method confines itself to the measurement of gambling as it is found in contemporary capitalist society, without examining the vital questions of how these gambling relations have been produced and reproduced. Collectively, the diversity of positivist studies of gambling reveals that there is no general agreement about the social
Understanding gambling
21
constitution of gambling. Although games differ in their structural characteristics and their relevance for players (Abt et al. 1985:35–113) and in the historical forces which are particular to their development, the more precise structural qualities, cultural meanings and determinants of different forms of gambling have seldom been given serious consideration. Researchers do not ask, for instance, how the interplay of socio-cultural interests have combined, historically and materially, to produce discri-mination, sexism and racism in gambling, or why questions of power, profit and government capacity in gambling are (or are not) seen as social issues. In summary, conventional explanations of gambling have been restricted by analytical models which focus on gamblers rather than on gambling as a specific socially determined phenomenon. Conventional sociology, within a functionalist framework, makes certain theoretical statements about the social as opposed to the purely psychological aspects of gambling. But it does so ahistorically and within a theoretical context which accepts the status quo and discourages development of a radical critique. The positivist approach has provided valuable data on, for example, social differences in gambling participation or in gambling facilities, but it cannot, because of its atheoretical and static methodalogy, provide adequate explanations of the creation and sustaining of such differences. Such gambling studies on the whole have not reflected on the historical course of gambling development, its contemporary structural and ideological character, or its likely future direction. Social historians have pointed to the tendency of gambling to periodisation (Bolen 1976; Chafetz 1960; Dixon 1984, 1987, 1989; Hill 1987; Lemon 1972; McCoy 1980; McKibbin 1979; O’Hara n.d. 1986; Vamplew 1976). Accounts from several countries suggest that the nature, extent and intensity of gambling in any society fluctuate, with cyclical alternation between waves of extended gambling and phases of repression or social reform. In seeking to explain these periodic shifts in gambling, many historians also make primary reference to interrelations between leisure and the social system. Like sociologists, many place a functionalist emphasis on the conditioning of internalisable norms and values, relinquishing explanation of the degree of complementarity or tensions between issues of popular culture and collective agency on the one hand, and issues of social structure and conditioning specific to the social formation on the other. Very few of these studies have recognised that legal gambling is organised along business lines with organisational characteristics and commercial objectives similar to other industries. Most ignore the fact that gambling is commercially stimulated by public and private enterprises to the extent that it has become a major transnational industry operating within a complex system of nation states and cultural globalisation. Theoretical barriers inhibit a holistic account of the broad interrelations involved in gambling developments such as the recent incorporation of legalised commercial casinos into mass tourism (Eadington 1982c; McMillen 1991, 1993). Questions of why so much gambling is now organised on commercial principles or why traditional gambling cultures are being colonised by a global gambling culture are conspicuously absent. These issues form the basis for theoretical developments which are beginning to emerge from a more interdisciplinary and critical framework. Before turning to these, however, it is necessary to look at other contributions from the 1980s which offer systematic critiques of the nature and practice of modern gambling. What follows is a
Gambling cultures
22
brief outline of the development of the theory and practice of liberal policy studies and radical critiques of contemporary gambling in America and Britain, placed in their social and economic context. Analysis of gambling administration and the history of law have moved away from the positivistic approach and taken explanations of gambling relations considerably further, particularly with regard to the role of the state. Yet as analysts have moved from concepts like deviance and leisure, some analytical problems are solved but others are created. Gambling and policy analysis By the 1970s gambling was at the crossroads in many capitalist nations. In Britain, Canada and the United States, public lotteries were legalised for the first time since the nineteenth century and casinos acquired greater commercial importance and public respectability under new regulatory regimes. This period was most notable for the emergence of gaming (lotteries, casinos) as a major force exerting political and cultural influences over economic policy (Eadington 1982a, 1989; McMillen 1987, 1993; Miers 1981, 1983, 1989). The general trend towards legalisation and commercialisation of gambling encouraged research from a range of new theoretical perspectives. By the late 1970s and 1980s, the dominance of deviancy studies and positivism in gambling research was challenged from two quarters: economic and policy analysis in the United States and a more critical analysis of gambling law and the state in Britain and Canada. The rapid expansion of legalised commercial gambling in countries where it previously had been prohibited raised questions about policy and strategies of social regulation. As gambling acquired legitimacy and new forms were legalised, there was a shift in the nature of state regulation. The dramatic reversal of anti-gambling policies in these and other nations coincided with changing conceptions of gambling and renewed interest in its regulatory and administrative aspects. Theoretical interpretations shifted to a wider ‘macro’ focus on policy issues related to revenue collection (Abt et al. 1985:223–56; Rubner 1966; Suits 1977, 1979), to gambling law (Rose 1979–80; Rose 1986) and to the administration of gambling institutions and control agencies (Abt et al. 1985:211–22; Cabot and Schuetz 1991; Eadington 1984, 1990; Hood 1976:169–207; Lehne 1986; Kozlowski 1985; Newman 1972; Ransom 1991; Skolnick 1978; Weinstein and Deitch 1974). There are important linkages which exist between legal, political and economic theories which have emerged about contemporary legalised gambling. Different methodologies conceal these similarities. Thus economists often view government influence over gambling as a ‘public good’ with government as the market for supply and demand (Self 1989:92); their concern is with predicting and measuring the allocation of costs and benefits. Political scientists focus primarily on the institutions and processes of government policy-making, while legal analysts concentrate on the making and interpretation of gambling laws and the respective powers of government vis-à-vis citizens or, in federations, different levels of governments. It is significant that in Britain, Canada and the United States the boundaries between these different disciplines have become blurred as analysts have moved into one another’s traditional domains. In Britain, Miers and Dixon make considerable use of social, political and economic insights in their particular interpretations of gambling law.
Understanding gambling
23
Similar interdisciplinarity also has enriched the recent contributions of Canadian criminologists. In the United States, there has been a resurgence of studies which are both political and economic in character. In particular, public choice theory has been increasingly influential in the analysis of institutions involved in US casino policy. Taking its inspiration from neo-classical models of competitive markets, this approach is wedded to notions of consumer choice, competition between gambling providers and a limited role for government.3 As with other developments in social science, the priority of economic and policy studies in the United States and the versatility of state-centred critical criminology in Britain and Canada in the 1980s are as much a product of different social and political conditions in these countries as they are of separate intellectual traditions (Garland 1985:59–66; Young 1988). These theories also embody significant, and competing value judgements in their normative conclusions about the direction and effects of gambling policy. At one (mainly British and Canadian) extreme, a systematic interventionist state role is seen as necessary to rectify the various inefficiencies and injustices of pure market systems. At the other (predominantly American) extreme, it is assumed that state intervention should be minor, because resource allocation is best left to the operation of ‘free’ market mechanisms. In Britain and Canada, from the viewpoint of government and public opinion, gambling (and particularly the casino industry) continued to be seen primarily as a serious problem of crime and control (Campbell 1987; Campbell and Ponting 1984; Cornish 1978:213–28; Dixon 1980a, 1980b, 1982, 1983, 1987; Miers 1980, 1984, 1985, 1987, 1991). By contrast, in the United States, with the expansion of commercial casinos and state lotteries in the late 1970s, the context was set for the growth of economic and policy analysis which attempt to identify and respond to the problems and demands of the market. While there are variants on this approach, the most recent trend within gambling studies in the United States has been to depict gambling as a ‘democratised’ institution, an important product of the ‘post-industrial’ era of mass consumption which has required the intervention of state bureaucracies in the interests of rationalisation and consumer choice. Public choice analysis The public choice perspective which predominantly informs explanations of US casinos as a particular form of contemporary gambling closely reflects the political ideology of liberalism and economic growth behind the setting up of the casino industry. The earliest studies of American casinos explained casino development in terms of the deviancy model. The expansion of legal casinos in the United States during the 1970s was described as ‘the legalisation of deviance’ (Skolnick 1978:24–34), reflecting a conventional interpretation of the historical control of American casino gambling by ‘organised criminals’. However, during the 1970s commercial investment by respectable publicly traded corporations gave casinos a legitimacy lacking in other forms of gambling (Eadington and Hattori 1976; Eadington 1982a), a changing view recognised by social scientists who began to analyse casino gambling as an expanding new industry, albeit one subject to an unusual degree of state regulation. Gambling studies which emerged and flourished in the United States during the 1980s have been dominated by the study of commercial policies and practices, interest-group
Gambling cultures
24
politics, government-business relations, decision-making and change. This approach is distinguished by its policy orientation and also by its willingness to use insights from a range of disciplines in order to solve particular technical problems. Research demonstrates more concern for empirical detail of management strategies, policy-making and state organisations than other approaches to gambling analysis. Informed by a philosophical acceptance of market liberalism and the methodology and axioms of economics, specialist industry publications and business analysts apply marketing and management theories to the expanding and increasingly competitive American gambling industry (Eadington and Cornelius 1991b; Gaming and Wagering Business; Macomber 1984). From a similar perspective, public choice theory explains political decisions to expand legalised gambling and the dynamics of gambling policies in terms of state economic imperatives. The expansion of legal gambling is seen primarily as a rational, self-interested state response to upward trends in public expenditure. Compelled by pluralist politics to respond to pressure groups with costly spending programmes, governments have used gambling as a source of ‘invisible taxation’ both to secure an adequate revenue base and to obscure the pressures on public expenditures. Research questions are typically posed in terms such as the effects of legalisation on gambling patterns, what share of American gambling revenues should return to the state, and what proportion of this should be spent on the local community as opposed to the whole jurisdiction. Economic studies premised on the centrality of markets and consumer sovereignty have emphasised issues of profit maximisation, price competition and responses to market forces (Johnson 1976, 1985). Similarly, the problems to which most American casino studies have addressed themselves are usually connected with the functioning or malfunctioning of economic and regulatory policies. A great deal of the American literature on the contribution of casinos to economic development is devoted to narrowly defined cost-benefit analyses, particularly in terms of technical issues such as tourist flow predictions, factors determining casino location, and regional impacts of casino expenditures (Ebel 1990; Shonkwiler 1993); some analyses also include more imprecise comments on the socio-cultural effects of casino gambling (Abt et al. 1985:191–210). Other contributions have been within a public law framework, focusing on the issue of challenges to individual rights (Rose 1987, 1986), attempts to decriminalise illegal gambling (Dombrink and Thompson 1986; Thompson and Dombrink 1989) and constitutional tensions related to Indian gaming (Eadington 1990). Some analysts have been more concerned with the normative implications of constitutional conditions without which market exchange would not work, including the use of federal powers to provide public goods such as protection against organised crime and state guarantees of autonomy for American Indians (Cohen 1993; Rose 1986b, 1986c). Other analysts have suggested that state intervention has been the source of regulatory problems which have impeded commercial development (Cabot and Schuetz 1991; Lowenhar et al. 1991; Ransom 1991). The preference of US analysts for this view has been a major influence in the formulation and direction of casino policy. The trend to laissez-faire developments in Nevada, for example, reflects the concern of economists and policy-makers about the distorting effects of government regulation on the market and on governments themselves. The more interventionist regulatory regime in New Jersey is explained as a rational response by government to avoid the worse prospect of federal intervention to
Understanding gambling
25
ensure honest operations. The emphasis is on state decentralisation to avoid excessive concentration of power, and on individual rights and constitutional rules to control and limit the use of government power. In a number of areas (casino development, management strategies, regulatory objectives), scholars have played distinct roles in the actual creation and implementation of policy itself, creating an organic link between state policy and the study of that policy. The development of gambling research centres in Nevada universities following the expansion of the casino industry during the 1960s and 1970s is a clear reflection of the symbiotic relationship between academic study and casino development and policy. The contribution of American casino policy studies, especially that of the foremost and most prolific exponent, William R.Eadington, is important both for a proper understanding of the expansive nature of commercial casinos and because it marks a notable generation of interest in gambling from the perspective of mainstream American political and economic thought. Like those of many of his American contemporaries, Eadington’s analysis is built on an implicit advocacy of commercialisation, reflecting the pro-market philosophy of Nevada’s laissez-faire approach to casino development. More significantly, it involves a limited conception of state functions as the restriction of corporate misconduct and the bolstering of public morality. It therefore is firmly located within the notions of liberalism and capitalism which dominate American society. However, he is very much alive to the social and symbolic as well as the instrumental aspects of casino policies. Eadington investigates the legitimation and dramatic growth of the American casino industry and identifies the historical factors underlying the patterns of casino development which have emerged (Eadington 1982a, 1982b, 1987–88, 1989). In Eadington’s view, casinos and the regulatory agencies of the state are interconnected realms which cannot be considered in isolation from a broader analysis of the social context. For example, he is sensitive to the varied effects that different social and political circumstances can have on casino policies as well as the potential social costs of casino developments in terms of crime, moral and urban deterioration and ‘pathological’ gambling. Because adverse community impacts have the capacity to undermine the principles of social justice as well as to erode economic benefits, the potential for such problems justifies the exercise of a limited degree of coercion by the state. In this regard, Lehne’s analysis of New Jersey casino developments can be seen as an important advance within casino analysis, in that he is concerned primarily with both the processes and the content of casino policies (Lehne 1986). Lehne is one of the growing number of American analysts who recognise that problems can occur with a shift in political and economic power when casinos become a major political, social and economic force within a region.4 He attempts a detailed evaluation of the specific institutional arrangements and organisational dynamics of New Jersey’s control agencies as they attempt to balance competing public concerns with the drive for economic development. More than this, Lehne is concerned with the broader significance of the interdependent relationship between casinos and state agencies for power relations and policy implementation. One important contribution from Lehne’s research has been a more grounded understanding of the internal workings of the state’s institutions for gambling policy and legislative change. Focusing on the composition and practices of casino regulatory agencies, he shows that the casino policy process is shaped less by considerations of electoral representation and public demand than by the different
Gambling cultures
26
conceptions of rationality and public interest held by commercial and government organisations themselves. In general, US proponents of the public choice approach to gambling policy take the liberal view that state intervention is accepted as compatible and necessary to a competitive market economy, but only in so far as it remains unobtrusive and does not extend into the activities of individuals or the commercial activities of the casino corporations themselves. Irrespective of the particular disciplinary position taken, state intervention in casino development is advocated in limited terms as the necessary precondition for safeguarding the core of the ‘free-enterprise’ system and the rights of property, and to secure popular allegiance. The question thus becomes what are the most technically efficient ways in which the state can deal with the high social and crime risks of gambling activity? Questions are not asked of how the state balances the often contradictory requirements for public welfare and capital accumulation, and if this involves the subordination or the incorporation of citizens and their cultural practices. Such tensions span more than economics and politics to involve other aspects of social relations. There are other important questions of conceptualisation to be reconsidered. In public choice studies, the large commercial casinos which have been introduced to Nevada and Atlantic City are taken as an adequate analytical starting point, rather than as a complex historical product which itself requires examination. The specific commercial form of casino gambling is represented as natural, and therefore not modifiable. Because they remain within the liberal perspective, they have not developed the categories for a critical account of private ownership or of capital-state relations or of the variable socially determined uses to which casinos are put. The political effects of such thinking are to express both the typical viewpoint of American social science and the dominance of economic forces. In the absence of historical theoretical categories and a systematic methodology which explores beneath the surface data of state-endorsed commercialisation, public choice analysis merely confirms the apparent necessity of existing social relations. But for all its liberal and capitalist assumptions, this research reveals a network of economic and socio-cultural processes interplaying with political choice. Some of its advocates (Eadington, Lehne, Abt et al.) operate with a more ethical notion of the emergence of the casino industry than the standard view of the abstract rational economic actor in American social science. While sociology and the positivist school have contributed towards an understanding of patterns of gambling behaviour, the liberal public policy approach has helped explain the relationship between gambling, the state and social and legal order which was ignored by most analysts for decades. Through an understanding of institutional processes it can contribute to the development of a more critical understanding of commercial gambling and social welfare. Information concerning historical differences in gambling policies and practices, the different utilisation of gambling facilities and state resources by different social groups, and regional differences in gambling patterns are all important in building up a picture of the characteristics of gambling under capitalism. In summary, while there is increased awareness of the dissensus and instabilities in gambling policies and the extended role of the state in seeking to deal with social turbulence, most of this research suffers from a common deficiency: despite the
Understanding gambling
27
contemporary concern for the processes and practices, functions and outcomes of stateregulated gambling systems, there is little consideration of the political or ideological implications of state involvement in what is essentially a profitable economic enterprise. As Lehne’s study shows, the increasing involvement in gambling of large, transnational corporations, often operating through government bureaucracies, has turned private interests into policy objectives. But policy studies have confined their investigations to identifying possible organisational obstructions to the achievement of possible policy outcomes, while sociologists and economists have concentrated mainly on revealing those outcomes. In neither case is there critical confrontation of the power behind the state machinery, or how or where it is directed. Yet the law, as the branch of the state which openly specialises in the social control of organised gambling, unabashedly claims its right to make political and economic as well as moral judgements. Criminology and the history of law A recent strand in the explanations of legalised gambling is the appearance of a critical analysis of gambling which explicitly recognises the complexity of its political-legal aspects. Of particular note has been the emergence of challenging and sophisticated explanations for gambling policy drawing upon substantive developments in criminology and legal history. Since the 1970s, the study of gaming law in Britain has been transformed within the realist tradition to examine the gap between legal theory and practice. Similar developments have occurred in Canada and the United States with the advance of critical criminology. These theoretical explanations of gambling policies returned to the criminology agenda during the 1970s when crime and law and order were important public issues, precipitating a decade of theoretical and political controversies about state-defined conceptions of crime (Young 1988). In Britain, for example, confidence in old liberal notions of self-adjusting social equilibrium was dwindling with the growing involvement of the state in facilitating economic development and controlling disorder. In Britain as in the United States, the political emphasis on social control went hand-in-hand with support for positivist social science to differentiate problems for gambling policy. Many commentators with social democratic ideals opposed the institutional links of establishment social science with the repressive strategies of the Home Office, forcing overt recognition of the increasingly interventionist role of the state in sustaining social order. Importantly, this theoretical reorientation sensitised criminologists to the analytical neglect of relationships of state agencies with socio-economic interests and of crimes of ‘the powerful’ more generally (Box 1983). A small number of Canadian and US criminologists have attempted to distinguish between different facets of state activity, such as tensions between the state’s general functions in preserving social order and creating the necessary conditions for accumulation and the specific use of state power to promote particular social and economic interests (Campbell 1987; Campbell and Ponting 1984; Chambliss 1976; Cressey 1969; Dombrink 1981; Kornblum 1976; Osborne and Campbell 1988; Reuter and Rubenstein 1978; Skolnick 1978, 1979a, 1979b). This issue became crucial as more and more Canadian provinces and American states legalised gambling, despite the long history of anti-gambling moralism. Dombrink, for example, drawing on O’Connor’s
Gambling cultures
28
understanding of the varied and often contradictory functions of the state (O’Connor 1973), suggests that legalisation of gambling has appealed to American authorities for several reasons. The primary attraction is that gambling provides significant tax revenues which have helped to ease the worsening fiscal crisis of the state. However, the state also acts to facilitate the accumulation of wealth by private sector interests in the gambling industry. The state’s role in legalising gambling legitimates the ‘free enterprise’ system to those who are not its prime beneficiaries, and thus helps to maintain the conditions necessary for social harmony. To the extent to which gambling contributes to these fundamental functions of the state (revenue allocation, accumulation and legitimation), it will appeal to policy-makers who may resist attempts by the anti-gambling lobby and regulatory agencies to restrict legalised gambling. These studies also make the important point that governments are constrained and complex forums for competing ideas, rather than the autonomous and single-minded organisations assumed from a paradigm of economics and public choice. They stress the importance of structural and local cultural factors to show how the power politics of casino development have been played out within a distinctive socio-cultural framework and how the limited institutional powers and contradictory economic choices available to the state have defined and restricted policy options. This emphasis on the way competing values, interests and resources are shaped by structural arrangements can be seen as giving a more complete understanding of the complexity and unpredictability of the gambling policy process. Significantly, there also emerged in Britain in the 1980s a conception of gambling, social order and control which is more alive to a critical interpretation than most American policy studies. These studies developed out of debates within criminology and the history of law which have altered the tone and conceptual structure of gambling analysis by examining in detail the structures, ideologies and interrelationships between the public and private. The British socio-political climate is more sympathetic to theoretical critique than America, producing a critical legal history which offers an alternative competing paradigm critical of the endemic problems of gambling policies. In British gambling studies, the illuminating historical works of Dixon and Miers have developed a theoretically informed analysis of the often contradictory aspects of the state and law. Dixon’s analysis of the 1906 Street Betting Act starts from the recognition that crime is a major problem precisely for the most vulnerable sections of the population (Dixon 1984, 1989). He reveals the ambiguous role of police who are obliged to enforce unpopular and unenforceable anti-gambling laws, showing how these ‘instruments’ of state authority in fact became critical agents for the liberalisation of betting policies. In a more contemporary vein, Miers’s evaluation of the rationale, actions and effectiveness of the British Gaming Board has examined the particular character of British casino law and regulations, identifying the political and legal problems associated with attempts to impose strict regulations on an industry which had operated on the fringe of the law for decades (Miers 1980, 1981, 1983, 1984, 1985, 1987). British insights into the origins, ambiguities and limitations of state authority have been extended by Canadian criminologists such as Campbell and Ponting (1984), who have investigated the historical tensions between federal and provincial governments and the fragmentation and inconsistencies of Canadian gambling laws. Their study highlights the structural and
Understanding gambling
29
cultural limitations of the regional state when dealing with national and transnational political-economic forces. It is notable that these contributions signal a change of focus from the equation of gambling with individual behaviour to a broader conception of gambling which explains specific legal developments in the context of broader political-economic and sociocultural transformations. As previously explained, in early post-war sociological studies, gambling as a legal or illegal activity involved a model of the coercive and punitive role of the state. The deeper theoretical reorientation of radical criminological studies involves a quite different conception of the political-legal order which examines the total system of social relations subject to regulation. A further modification in the treatment of gambling embodies revision of an historical materialist perspective and methodology. Although analysis of specific law-making has long been been part of liberal gambling studies, this new historical approach to gambling analysis involves a critical examination of the dynamic relation between state actions and the transformation of economic and social relations. It is a recognition that the legal definition of gambling no longer merely constrains the under-classes but also creates and mobilises the ideological legitimation of the capitalist social order. A further feature of contemporary developments in the analysis of gambling is that it rises above the intellectual sectarianism which characterised earlier studies. In its formative years of development, the study of gambling exhibited a narrow, disciplinary exclusivity; each perspective, in seeking to establish its own field, held to a rigid boundary maintenance. For example, most American studies of gambling law, dominated by legal positivism, tend to ignore the contributions of other disciplinary fields. The work of Campbell, Dixon, Dombrink and Miers makes a positive contribution to debates about the relation between the gambling industry and the state by locating them within a broader interdisciplinary perspective. Included in their point of contact with sociology and political economy are the key contemporary issues of power and control, as embodied in the philosophical traditions of Marx and Weber. This trend thus signifies a ‘leftist’ shift which rejects liberal sociology (gambling as a reflection of society) and positivism (gambling as a reflection of neutral and rational law).
CONCLUSION The purpose of this chapter has been to outline and evaluate prevailing explanations for gambling in order to illustrate the diverse points of entry into an understanding of contemporary commercial gambling which have emerged. It has traced the impacts of national gambling practice and policy on theoretical development and revealed the analytical limitations of narrow disciplinary frameworks. In the process, it argues for the ability of gambling analysis to go beyond the limits of earlier theoretical foundations which explained gambling by the behaviour and attributes of gamblers. This chapter does not claim to represent a comprehensive survey of the field. As an introduction to gambling theory it necessarily concentrates on only the major themes and contributors. There also are significant empirical and theoretical gaps in gambling research which have not been addressed: gambling in modern Asian cultures has rarely been studied; and the theories of signification and power deriving from Barthes (1973
Gambling cultures
30
[1957]) and Foucault (1974 [1969], 1980), and the broad area of women’s studies provide fertile sources of further insight and stimulation. It is difficult to understand why gambling has attracted so little attention from cultural studies and feminist analysis which have made such important contributions to explanations of contemporary society since the 1980s. National and historical differences in the dominant mode of explanation of gambling can be understood partly through changes in theoretical emphasis in the social sciences themselves and partly as the result of national policies prescribing stages of gambling legalisation which set the moral and research agenda. Despite their potential importance for a contemporary understanding, sociologists and policy analysts interested in gambling have made little use of the frameworks and concepts provided by other disciplines and accounts in other countries. In each case, analysis has been contained within a localised framework in which attention has been concentrated on particular groups of gamblers and policies to the exclusion of more general, international processes. The dominant values in analysis tend to reflect the dominant values of that society. The pluralism of recent American casino studies stresses the rise of markets, the progressive dispersal of power, the rise of elites and the separation of ownership from state control, whereas British and Canadian critiques have stressed the accelerating concentration of economic and state power. There has been a recent convergence towards acknowledgment of the central role of capital and state in gambling development and of the significance of their interconnections with socio-cultural forces. Research has shown that the quality as well as the quantity of gambling is historically specific. The nature of gambling in pre-capitalist societies differs from gambling under a system of global capitalism. The shape of modern gambling not only reflects the nature of social relations in any society, but also powerfully determines new social and political outcomes. Without grappling with these central conceptual issues, many gambling studies remain entrapped, albeit un-intentionally, within a narrow liberal orientation which limits their concerns to descriptive analysis of the functioning of gamblers and gambling institutions. An understanding of contemporary gambling and its rapid global expansion requires different conceptual tools and a more explicitly political project.
NOTES 1 See, for example, the Petition to the Queensland Legislative Assembly, 1 September, 1898; and the South Australian Report of the Commission on Betting (1933). 2 Although sharing a concern for social and welfare policies, it is worth noting that the Australian state has not supported academic gambling studies in the same way. There was no comparable institutional funding for academic research into Australian gambling during this period. Only in the 1990s have some Australian states (Queensland and Victoria) begun to investigate the social effects of their gambling policies (McMillen 1994). 3 For discussions of public choice theory, see Dunleavy 1991; March and Olson 1989; Olson 1965; Niskanen 1971; Posner 1974; Stigler 1971, 1972; Self 1985. 4 See also Skolnick (1979a, 1979b) and Dombrink (1981).
Understanding gambling
31
BIBLIOGRAPHY Abt, V., Smith, J.F. and Christiansen, E.M. (1985) The Business of Risk: Commercial Gambling in Mainstream America, Lawrence: University of Kansas Press. Adler, J. (1966) ‘Gambling, drugs and alcohol: a note on functional equivalents’, Issues in Criminology 2(1):111–18. Albanese, J. (1985) Organized Crime in America, Cincinnati: Anderson Publishing. Alchin, T.M. (1989) ‘Taxation of gambling in Australia’, Economic Analysis and Policy 19(2):167–84. Altman, J. (1985) ‘Gambling as a mode of redistributing and accumulating cash among Aborigines: a case study from Arnhem Land’, in G.Caldwell et al. (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm: 50–67. Aronson, P.H. and Miller, R.L. (1980) ‘Economic aspects of public gaming’, Connecticut Law Review 12(4):822–53. Barthes, R. (1973 [1957]) Mythologies, trans. A Lavers, St Albans: Paladin. Becker, H. (1963) Outsiders, New York: Free Press. ——(1968) ‘Whose side are we on?’ Social Problems 14:239–47. Bergler, E. (1957) The Psychology of Gambling, New York: Hill & Wang. Blakey, R.G. and Kurland, H.A. (1978) ‘The development of the federal law of gambling’, Cornell Law Review 63(6):923–1021. Blascovich, J., Ginsburg, G. and Howe, R. (1976) ‘Blackjack: choice shifts in the field’, Sociometry 39(3):274–6. Blaszczynski, A., McConaghy, N. and Frankova, A. (1989) ‘Crime, anti-social personality and pathological gambling’, Journal of Gambling Behaviour 5:37–52. Bloch, H. (1957) ‘The sociology of gambling’, American Journal of Sociology 57: 217–18. Bolen, D.W. (1976) ‘Gambling: historical highlights and trends and their implications for contemporary society’, in W.R.Eadington (ed.) Gambling and Society. Interdisciplinary Studies on the Subject of Gambling, Springfield, IL: Charles C.Thomas: 7–38. Box, S. (1983) Power, Crime and Mystification, London: Tavistock. Brown, R.I.F. (1987) ‘Pathological gambling and associated patterns of crime: comparisons with alcohol and other drug addictions’, Journal of Gambling Behaviour 3(2): 98–114. Bursik, R.J., Jr and Grasmick, H.G. (1992) Neighborhoods and Crime: The Dimensions of Effective Community Control, New York: Lexington Books. Cabot, A.N. and Schuetz, R.J. (1991) ‘An economic view of the Nevada licensing process’, in W.R.Eadington and J.A.Cornelius (eds) Gambling and Public Policy. International Perspectives, Nevada: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada-Reno: 123–54. Caillois, R. (1961) Man, Play and Games, trans. M.Barash, New York: Free Press. Caldwell, G.T. (1972a) ‘Leisure Co-operatives. The Institutionalisation of Gambling and the Growth of Large Leisure Organisations in New South Wales’, PhD thesis, Australian National University. ——(1972b) ‘Jackpot: the NSW club’, Current Affairs Bulletin (Sept.): 13–16. ——(1974) ‘The gambling Australian’, in D.Edgar (ed.) Social Change in Australia. Readings in Sociology, Melbourne: Cheshire: 13–28. ——(1983) ‘Statement to the poker machine inquiry’, Appendix to the Report of the Board of Inquiry into Poker Machines (Wilcox Report), Melbourne: Government Printer. ——(1985a) ‘Some historical and sociological characteristics of Australian gambling’, in G.Caldwell et al. (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm: 18–27.
Gambling cultures
32
——(1985b) ‘Poker machine playing in NSW and ACT clubs’, in G.Caldwell et al. (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm: 261–8. Caldwell, G., Dickerson, M., Haig, B. and Sylvan, L. (eds) (1985) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm. Campbell, C. (1987) ‘Casino gambling and the peripheral state: charitable gaming in British Columbia’, in W.R.Eadington (ed.) Gambling Research, vol. 1. Reno: University of NevadaReno: 332–72. Campbell, C.S. and Lowman, J. (eds) (1989) Gambling in Canada: Golden Goose or Trojan Horse? Vancouver: Simon Fraser University. Campbell, C.S. and Ponting, J.R. (1984) ‘The evolution of casino gambling in Alberta’, Canadian Public Policy 10(2):142–55. Campbell, F. (1976) ‘Gambling: a positive view’, in W.R.Eadington (ed.) Gambling and Society, Springfield, IL: Charles C.Thomas: 218–28. Capling, A., and Galligan, B. (1992) Beyond the Protectionist State, Melbourne: Cambridge University Press. Chafetz, H. (1960) Play the Devil: A History of Gambling in the United States from 1492 to 1955, New York: Clarkson N.Potter. Chambliss, W. (1976) On the Take, Bloomington: University of Indiana Press. Charlton, P. (1987) Two Flies Up a Wall. The Australian Passion for Gambling, North Ryde: Methuen Haynes. Childress, S.A. (1991) ‘“Reel rape speech”: violent pornography and the politics of harm’, Law & Society Review 25(1):177–214. Cohen, K. (1993) Character and Circumstance. Thirty Years of the Totalisator Administration Board in Queensland. 1962–1992, Brisbane: Boolarong. Commission of the Review of the National Policy toward Gambling (1976) Gambling in America: Final Report of the Commission on the Review of the National Policy toward Gambling (Morin Commission), Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office. Cornell Law School (1977) The Development of the Law of Gambling 1776–1976, National Institute of Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice, Law Enforcement Assistance Administration, US Department of Justice, Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office. Cornish, D.B. (1978) Gambling: A Review of the Literature and Its Implications for Policy and Research, Home Office Research Study No. 42, London: Home Office Research Unit. Cowan, J. (1974) ‘The gambler’s fallacy’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 30:238–51. Cressey, D.R. (1969) Theft of a Nation, New York: Harper & Row. D’Angelo, R. (1985) ‘The social organisation of sports gambling’, Paper presented at the Sixth National Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Atlantic City (Nov.). Dennis, N., Henriques, F. and Slaughter, C. (1956) Coal is Our Life, London: Tavistock. Dessant, J. (1976) ‘The betting shop industry in Glamorgan, 1961–1967’, in D.M. Downes, B.P.Davies, M.E.David and P.Stone, Gambling, Work and Leisure: A Study across Three Areas, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul: 230–46. Devereux, E.C. (1968a) ‘Gambling in a psychological and sociological perspective’, International Encyclopaedia of the Social Sciences 6:53–62. ——(1968b) ‘Gambling and Social Structure: A Sociological Study of Lotteries and Horseracing in Contemporary America’, 2 vols, PhD thesis, Harvard University. Dickerson, M. (1984) Compulsive Gamblers, London: Longman. Dickerson, M. and Hinchy, J. (1987) ‘Minimal treatment for problem gamblers’, in M. Walker (ed.) Faces of Gambling. Proceedings of the Second National Conference of the National Association for Gambling Studies (NAGS), Sydney: National Association for Gambling Studies: 291–8. ——(1988) ‘The prevalence of excessive and pathological gambling in Australia’, Journal of Gambling Behaviour 4:4–21. Dielman, T.E. (1979) ‘Gambling: a social problem?’ Journal of Social Issues 35(3):36–42.
Understanding gambling
33
Dixey, R. (1984) ‘Bingo: “The only place to go”’, Society for the Study of Gambling Newsletter 6:1–7. Dixon, D. (1980a) ‘“Class Law”: the Street Betting Act of 1906’, International Journal of the Sociology of Law 8:101–28. ——(1980b) ‘The discovery of the compulsive gambler’, in Z.Bankowski and G. Mungham (eds) Essays in Law and Society, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul: 157–79. ——(1982) ‘The state and gambling: developments in the legal control of gambling, 1867–1923’, Paper presented at the Fifth National Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Las Vegas, NV. ——(1983) ‘Illegal gambling and histories of policing in Britain’, The Society for the Study of Gambling Newsletter 3 (April): 1–7. ——(1984) ‘Illegal gambling and histories of policing in Great Britain’, Paper presented at the Sixth National Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Atlantic City, NJ (9–12 Dec.). ——(1987) ‘Responses to illegal betting in Britain and Australia’, Paper presented at the Seventh National Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Reno, NV (23–26 Aug.). ——(1989) From Prohibition to Regulation. Bookmaking, Anti-gambling and the Law, Oxford: Clarendon Press. Dixon, D. and Fishwick, E. (1984) ‘The law and order debate in historical perspective’, in P.Norton (ed.) Law and Order and British Politics, Hampshire: Gower Press: 21–37. Dombrink, J.D. (1981) ‘Outlaw Businessmen: Organized Crime and the Legalization of Casino Gambling’, PhD thesis, University of California, Berkeley. Dombrink, J. and Thompson, W.N. (1986) ‘The Report of the Commission on Organised Crime and its implications for commercial gaming in America’, Nevada Public Affairs Review 2:70–5. ——(1990) The Last Resort: Success and Failure in Campaigns for Casinos, Las Vegas: University of Nevada Press. Dowie, J. (1975) On the Efficiency and Equity of Betting Markets. Studies in Economics, Canterbury: University of Kent (mimeo). Downes, D.M. (1979) ‘From raffles to heart-stoppers: the social regulation of gambling’, British Journal of Law and Society 6(1): 235–43. Downes, D.M., Davies, B.P., David, M.E. and Stone, P. (1976) Gambling, Work and Leisure: A Study across Three Areas, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Downes, D. and Rock, P. (1982) Understanding Deviance, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Downton, F. (1969) ‘A note on betting strategies in compound games’, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A 132:543–7. Dunleavy, P. (1991) Democracy, Bureaucracy and Public Choice: Economic Explanations in Political Science, Hertfordshire: Harvester Wheatsheaf. Eadington, W.R. (ed.) (1976) Gambling and Society. Interdisciplinary Studies on the Subject of Gambling, Springfield, IL: Charles C.Thomas. ——(1982a) ‘The evolution of corporate gambling in Nevada’, Nevada Review of Business and Economics 6(1):13–22. ——(1982b) ‘Regulatory objectives and the expansion of casino gambling’, Nevada Review of Business and Economics (Fall): 4–13. ——(1982c) ‘Casino gambling and tourism: recent experiences and future considerations’, in W.R.Eadington, Materials Pertaining to Casino Gambling in America, Reno: University of Nevada: 1–5. ——(ed.) (1982d) The Gambling Papers: Proceedings of the Fifth National Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Reno: Bureau of Business and Economic Research, College of Business Administration, University of Nevada, Reno. ——(1984) ‘The casino gaming industry: a study of political economy’, in J.H.Frey and W.R.Eadington (eds) Gambling: Views from the Social Sciences. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474:23–35.
Gambling cultures
34
——(1985) ‘Trend in the legalisation of gambling in America in the 1980s and the implications for Australia’, in J.McMillen (ed.) Gambling in the 80s. Proceedings of the Inaugural Conference of the National Association for Gambling Studies, Nathan: National Association for Gambling Studies. ——(1986a) ‘Impact of casino gambling on the community: comment on Pizam and Poleka’, Annals of Tourism Research 13. ——(ed.) (1986b) The Gambling Studies: Proceedings of the Sixth National Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Reno: University of Nevada, Reno. ——(1987–88) ‘The changing face of commercial gambling in America in the 1980s’, Nevada Review of Business and Economics 22(1):5–11. ——(ed.) (1988) Gambling Research: Proceedings of the Seventh National Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Reno: University of Nevada, Reno. ——(1989) ‘Issues and trends in world gaming’, in C.S.Campbell and J.Lowman (eds) Gambling in Canada: Golden Goose or Trojan Horse? Vancouver: Simon Fraser University: 3–26. ——(1990) Indian Gaming and the Law, Reno: University of Nevada. ——(1991) ‘Public policy considerations and challenges and the spread of commercial gambling’, in W.R.Eadington and J.A.Cornelius (eds) Gambling and Public Policy: International Perspectives, Nevada: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada, Reno: 3–12. Eadington, W.R. and Cornelius, J.A. (eds) (1991a) Gambling and Public Policy. International Perspectives, Nevada: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada, Reno. ——(eds) (1991b) Gambling and Commercial Gaming. Essays in Business, Economics, Philosophy and Science, Nevada: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada, Reno. Eadington, W.R. and Hattori, James S. (1976) ‘A legislative history of gambling in Nevada’, Nevada Review of Business and Economics 2(1):13–17. Ebel, R.D. (ed.) (1990) A Fiscal Agenda for Nevada, Reno: University of Nevada Press. Encel, S. (1970) Equality and Authority, Melbourne: Cheshire. Foucault, M. (1974 [1969]) The Archaeology of Knowledge, trans. A.Sheridan Smith, London: Tavistock. ——(1980) Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, ed. C.Gordon, Brighton: Harvester. France, C.J. (1974) ‘The gambling impulse’, American Journal of Psychology 13: 364–407. Freud, S. (1928) ‘Dostoevsky and Parricide’, in J.E.Strachey (ed.), Complete Psychological Works of Freud 21, London: Hogarth Press: 177–94. Frey, J.H. (1984) ‘Gambling: a sociological review’, in J.H.Frey and W.R.Eadington (eds) Gambling: Views from the Social Sciences, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474:107–21. Frey, J.H. and W.R.Eadington (eds) (1984) Gambling: Views from the Social Sciences, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474. Friedman, M. and Savage, L.J. (1946) ‘The utility analysis of choices involving risks’, Journal of Political Economy 56:288. Gaming and Wagering Business (1984–95) (various issues) New York: BMT Communications. Garland, D. (1985) ‘The criminal and his science’, British Journal of Criminology 25:109–37. Geertz, C. (1972) ‘Deep play: notes on the Balinese cockfight’, Daedalus 101:1–37. Goffman, E. (1967) ‘Where the action is’, in Interaction Ritual: Essays on Face-to-face Behaviour, New York: Anchor Doubleday: 149–270. Goldthorpe, J., Lockwood, D., Platt, J. and Bechhofer, F. (1969) The Affluent Worker in the Class Structure, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Grichting, W. (1986) ‘The impact of religion on gambling in Australia’, Australian Journal of Psychology 38(1):45–58.
Understanding gambling
35
Gruen, A. (1976) ‘An inquiry into the economics of race-track betting’, Journal of Political Economy 84(1):169–77. Haig, B.D. (1984) ‘Gambling in Australia 1920–21 to 1980–81’, Working Paper No. 20, Working Papers in Economic History, Canberra: Australian National University. Halliday, J. and Fuller, P. (eds) (1974) The Psychology of Gambling, London: Allen Lane. Hardy, F. (1958) The Four-legged Lottery, Sydney: Penguin. Hayano, D.M. (1982) Poker Faces, Berkeley: University of California Press. ——(1984) ‘The professional gambler: fame, fortune, and failure’, in J.H.Frey and W. R.Eadington (eds) Gambling: Views From the Social Sciences, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474:157–67. Herman, R.D. (1967) ‘Gambling as work: a sociological study of the race track’, in R.D. Herman (ed.) Gambling, New York: Harper & Row: 87–104. ——(1976) Gamblers and Gambling. Motives, Institutions and Controls, Toronto: D.C. Heath. Hill, C.R. (1987) Horse Power: The Politics of the Turf, Manchester: Manchester University Press. Hood, C. (1972) ‘The development of betting taxes in Britain’, Public Administration 50: 183–202. ——(1976) The Limits of Administration, London: Wiley. Huizinga, J. (1949 [1938]) Homo Ludens: A Study of the Play-Element in Culture, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Inglis, K. (1985) ‘Gambling and culture in Australia’, in G.Caldwell et al. (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm: 5–17. Johnson, J. (1985) ‘Gambling as a source of government revenue in Australia’, in G. Caldwell et al. (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helrn: 78–93. Johnson, J.A. (1976) ‘An economic analysis of lotteries’, Canadian Tax Journal 24 (Nov.–Dec.): 639–51. Kallick-Kaufman, M. (1979) ‘The micro and macro dimensions of gambling in the United States’, Journal of Social Issues 35(3):7–35. Kaplan, L. and Maher, J. (1970) ‘The economics of the numbers game’, American Journal of Economics and Sociology 29(4):391–408. King, R. (1969) Gambling and Organized Crime, Washington, DC: Public Affairs Press. Kornblum, A. (1976) The Moral Hazards: Police Strategies for Honesty and Ethical Behaviour, Lexington, MA: D.C.Heath. Kozlowski, P. (1985) ‘Privately financed gambling: New Jersey’s approach to regulating the casino industry’, in J.McMillen (ed.) Gambling in the 80s. Proceedings of the Inaugural Conference of the National Association for Gambling Studies, Nathan: National Association for Gambling Studies. Lehne, R. (1986) Casino Policy, New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press. Lemon, A. (1972) Racing and Politics. Victoria’s Great Totalisator Debate 1880–1906, Melbourne: Hornet. Lesieur, H.R. (1984) The Chase: Career of the Compulsive Gambler, Cambridge, MA: Schenkman. ——(1987) ‘Gambling, pathological gambling and crime’, in T.Galski (ed.) The Handbook of Pathological Gambling, Springfield, IL: C.C.Thomas: 89–110. Lesieur, H.R. and Custer, R.L. (1984) ‘The compulsive gambler: causes and treatments’, in J.H.Frey and W.R.Eadington (eds) Gambling: Views from the Social Sciences, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474:146–56. Lesieur, H.R. and Puig, K. (1987) ‘Insurance problems and pathological gambling’, Journal of Gambling Behaviour 3(2):123–37. Light, I. (1977a) ‘Numbers gambling among blacks: a financial institution’, American Sociological Review 42:892–904. ——(1977b) ‘The ethnic vice industry, 1880–1944’, American Sociological Review 42: 464–79. Lowenhar, J., Lonoff, C. and Smith, R. (1991) ‘Regulatory requirements and legalised casino gaming in New Jersey: the case for change’, in W.R.Eadington and J.A. Cornelius (eds)
Gambling cultures
36
Gambling and Public Policy. International Perspectives, Nevada: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada, Reno: 261–8. Lynch, R. (1990) ‘Working class luck and vocabularies of hope among regular poker-machine players’, in D.Rowe and G.Lawrence (eds) Sport and Leisure. Trends in Australian Popular Culture, Marrickville: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich: 189–208. McCall, G.J. (1963) ‘Symbiosis: the case of hoodoo and the numbers racket’, Social Problems 10:361–71. McCoy, A.W. (1980) Drug Traffic. Narcotics and Organised Crime in Australia, Sydney: Harper & Row. McKibbin, R. (1979) ‘Working class gambling in Britain 1880–1939’, Past and Present 82:147– 78. Maclean, N. (1984) ‘Is gambling “bisnis”?: the economic and political functions of gambling in the Jimi Valley’, Social Analysis 16:13–27. McMillen, J. (ed.) (1985) Gambling in the 80s. Proceedings of the Inaugural Conference of the National Association for Gambling Studies, Nathan: National Association for Gambling Studies. ——(1986a) ‘Winners and losers: dilemmas of gambling policies’, Labor Forum 8(2):65–9. ——(1986b) ‘The other revolution: the legalisation of commercial gambling in Australia’, Nevada Public Affairs Review 2:65–9. ——(1987) ‘Gambling for high stakes: developments in Australian casinos’, Current Affairs Bulletin 64(4):20–5. ——(1987–88) ‘A risky business: political control of Australian casinos?’ Nevada Review of Business Economics 12(1):12–24. ——(1988) ‘Gambling on casinos: a political economy of Australian developments’, Journal of Gambling Behaviour 4(2):21–32. ——(1989) ‘The future: golden goose or Trojan horse?’, in C.S.Campbell and J. Lowman (eds) Gambling in Canada: Golden Goose or Trojan Horse? Vancouver: Simon Fraser University: 371–410. ——(1990) ‘Casino policies: have Australians had a fair deal?’ Journal of Gambling Studies 6(1):3–29. ——(1991) ‘Casinos and tourism: what’s the big attraction?’, in P.Carroll et al. (eds) Tourism in Australia, Sydney: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich: 153–72. ——(1993) ‘Risky Business: The Political Economy of Australian Casino Developments’, PhD thesis, University of Queensland. ——(1994) ‘Social priorities in gaming policy: studies from two Australian states’, Paper presented to the Ninth International Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Las Vegas. McMillen, J. and Eadington, W.R. (1986) ‘The evolution of gambling laws in Australia’, New York Journal of International and Comparative Law 8(1):167–92. McMillen, J. and Lafferty, G. (1991) ‘The tourism workforce: service or servility?’, in P. Carroll et al. (eds) Tourism in Austalia, Sydney: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich: 82–96. Macomber, D. (1984) ‘Management policy and practices in modern casino operations’, in J.H.Frey and W.R.Eadington (eds) Gambling: Views from the Social Sciences, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474:80–90. March, J.G. and Olson, J.P. (1989) Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Bias of Politics, New York: Free Press. Martinez, T. (1983) The Gambling Scene: Why People Gamble, Springfield, IL: C.C. Thomas. Matza, D. (1969) Becoming Deviant, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Miers, D. (1980) ‘Eighteenth century gaming: implications for modern casino control’, in J.A.Inciardi and C.E.Faupel (eds) History and Crime: Implications for Criminal Justice Policy, London: Sage: 169–92. ——(1981) ‘The mismanagement of casino gambling’, British Journal of Criminology 21(1):79– 86.
Understanding gambling
37
——(1983) ‘Malpractices in casino gambling’, in M.Clarke (ed.) Corruption, London, Francis Pinter: 24–38. ——(1984) ‘The regulation of commercial gaming’, Journal of Law and Society 11(1): 33–63. ——(1985) ‘The impact of regulation on the commercial gaming market in Great Britain’, in W.R.Eadington (ed.) The Gambling Studies: Proceedings of the Sixth National Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, Reno, University of Nevada: 253–73. ——(1987) ‘The Gaming Board for Great Britain: enforcement and judical restraint’, in R.Baldwin and C.McCrudden (eds) Regulation and Public Law, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson: 81–106. ——(1989) ‘Developments in commercial gambling in Great Britain’, in C.S.Campbell and J.Lowman (eds) Gambling in Canada: Golden Goose or Trojan Horse? Vancouver: Simon Fraser University: 27–52. ——(1991) ‘The national regulation of gambling and the completion of the internal markets in the European Community’, in W.R.Eadington and J.A.Cornelius (eds) Gambling and Public Policy: International Perspectives, Nevada: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada, Reno: 409–24. Miers, D. and Dixon, D. (1979) ‘The national bet: the re-emergence of the public lottery’, Public Law: 372–403. Moody, G.E. (1972) The Facts about the ‘Money Factories’, London: The Churches’ Council on Gambling. Newman, O. (1972) Gambling. Hazard and Reward, London: Athlone Press. ——(1975) ‘The ideology of social problems: gambling, a case study’, Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 12(4):541–50. Niskanen, W.A. (1971) Bureaucracy and Representative Government, New York: Aldine-Atherton. O’Connor, J. (1973) The Fiscal Crisis of the State, London: St Martins Press. O’Hara, J. (n.d.) ‘The great Australian gambling tradition’, in R.Cashman and M. McKernan (eds) Sport, Money, Morality and the Media, Kensington: University of New South Wales Press: 68– 85. ——(1986) ‘Getting a stake: gambling in early colonial Australia’, in J.McMillen (ed.) Gambling in the 80s. Proceedings of the Inaugural Conference of the National Association for Gambling Studies (NAGS), Brisbane: Griffith University Reprographics, n.p. ——(1988) A Mug’s Game: A History of Gaming and Betting in Australia, Kensington: New South Wales University Press. Oldman, D. (1974) ‘Chance and skill: a study of roulette’, Sociology 8:407–26. ——(1978) ‘Compulsive gamblers’, Sociological Review 26:349–71. Olson, M. (1965) The Logic of Collective Action, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Osborne, J.A., and Campbell, C.S. (1988) ‘Recent amendments to Canadian lottery and gaming laws: the transfer of power between federal and provincial governments’, Osgoode Hall Law Journal 26(1):19–43. Painter, M. (1990) ‘At arm’s length with dirty hands: taxing the Australian punter’, Australian Journal of Public Administration 49(2):179–91. ——(1991) ‘Policy diversity and policy learning in a federation: the case of Australian state betting laws’, Publius: The Journal of Federalism 21:143–57. Parker, S. (1976) The Future of Work and Leisure, New York: Praeger. Paton, J.H. (1946) ‘Gambling’, in J.Hastings (ed.) Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics 6, Edinburgh: T.T.Clark: 163–7. Peterson, V.W. (1950) ‘Obstacles to enforcement of gambling laws’, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 269:9–20. ——(1951) Gambling: Should it be Legalised? Springfield, IL: C.C.Thomas. Polsky, N. (1971) Hustlers, Beats and Others, Harmondsworth: Penguin. Posner, R. (1974) ‘Theories of economic regulation’, Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 5:263–309.
Gambling cultures
38
Pryor, F.L. (1976) ‘The Friedman-Savage utility function in cross-cultural perspective’, Journal of Political Economy 84:823–4. Ransom, B. (1991) ‘Public policy and gambling in New Jersey’, in W.R.Eadington and J.A.Cornelius (eds) Gambling and Public Policy. International Perspectives, Nevada: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada, Reno: 155–68. Reuter, P. (1983) Disorganised Crime. Illegal Markets and the Mafia, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. ——(1984) ‘Police regulation of illegal gambling: frustrations of symbolic enforcement’, in J.H.Frey and W.R.Eadington (eds) Gambling: Views from the Social Sciences, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474:36–47. ——(1979) ‘Easy sport: research and relevance’, Journal of Social Issues 35(3):166–82. Reuter, P. and Rubenstein, J. (1978) ‘Fact, fancy and organized crime’, The Public Interest 53:46– 54. ——(1981) Illegal Gambling in New York: A Case Study in the Operation, Structure and Regulation of an Illegal Market, Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office. Rose, N. (1979–80) ‘The legalization and control of casino gambling’, Fordham Urban Law Journal 8(2):245–300. ——(1986) ‘Constitutional questions of Nevada gaming licensure: a rights-based analysis’, Nevada Public Affairs Review 2:15–20. ——(1987) Gambling and the Law, California: Gambling Times. Rosecrance, J. (1985a) The Degenerates of Lake Tahoe, New York: Peter Lang. ——(1985b) ‘Compulsive gambling and the medicalization of deviance’, Social Problems 32(3):275–84. ——(1986a) ‘Why regular gamblers don’t quit’, Sociological Perspectives 29:357–78. ——(1986b) ‘Racetrack buddy relations: compartmentalized and satisfying’, Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 3:441–56. ——(1986c) ‘The sociology of casino gamblers’, Nevada Public Affairs Review 2:27–31. ——(1987) ‘The invisible horsemen: the social world of the backstretch’, Qualitative Sociology 8(3):301–12. ——(1988a) Gambling without Guilt: The Legitimation of an American Pastime, Belmont, CA: Brooks/Cole. ——(1988b) ‘Professional horse-race gambling: working without a safety net’, in W.R. Eadington (ed.) Gambling Research: Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Gambling and Risk Taking, vol. 3, Reno: University of Nevada-Reno: 11–37. Rosett, R.N. (1965) ‘Gambling and rationality’, Journal of Political Economy 73(6): 595–607. Royal Commission on Gambling (1978) Royal Commission on Gambling. Final Report, 2 vols (Rothschild Report), London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office. Rubner, A. (1966) The Economics of Gambling, Melbourne: Macmillan. Scimecca, J.A. (1971) ‘A typology of the gambler’, International Journal of Contemporary Sociology 8(1):56–72. Self, P. (1985) Political Theories of Modern Government, Sydney: Allen & Unwin. ——(1989) ‘An economic perspective’, in B.Galligan (ed.) Australian Federalism, Melbourne: Longman Cheshire: 69–97. Shonkwiler, J.S. (1993) ‘Assessing the impact of Atlantic City casinos on Nevada gaming revenues’, American Economics Journal 21(2):50–61. Simmel, E. (1920) ‘Psychoanalysis of the gambler’, International Journal of Psychoanalysis 1:352–3. Skolnick, J.H. (1978) House of Cards: Legalization and Control of Casino Gambling, Boston: Little, Brown. ——(1979a) ‘The social risks of casino gambling’, Psychology Today 13(2):52–64. ——(1979b) ‘The dilemmas of regulating casino gambling’, Journal of Social Issues 35(3):129– 43.
Understanding gambling
39
——(1984) ‘A zoning merit model for casino gambling’, in J.H.Frey and W.R. Eadington (eds) Gambling: Views from the Social Sciences, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474:48–60. Smith, R.W. and Preston, F.W. (1984) ‘Vocabularies of motives for gambling behaviour’, Sociological Perspectives 27(3):325–48. Stigler, G.J. (1971) ‘The theory of economic regulation’, Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 2:3–21. Suits, D. (1977) ‘Gambling taxes: regressivity and revenue potential’, National Tax Journal 30(1):19–35. ——(1979) ‘Economic background for gambling policy’, Journal of Social Issues 3(3): 43–61. Summers, A. (1975) Damned Whores and God’s Police, Ringwood, Victoria: Penguin. Tec, N. (1965) Gambling in Sweden, New Jersey: Bedminster Press. Thompson, W.N. and Dombrink, J. (1989) ‘A politically acceptable model of casino gaming for American jurisdictions’, in C.S.Campbell and J.Lowman (eds) Gambling in Canada: Golden Goose or Trojan Horse? Vancouver: Simon Fraser University: 337–70. Thorp, E.O. (1962) Beat the Dealer, New York: Random House. Turner, W. (1965) Gambler’s Money: The New Force in American Life, Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Vamplew, W. (1976) The Turf: A Social and Economic History of Horse Racing, London: Allen & Unwin. Veblen, T. (1953 [1899]) Theory of the Leisure Class, New York: Mentor Books. Walker, M. (ed.) (1987) Faces of Gambling. Proceedings of the Second Conference of the National Association for Gambling Studies, Sydney: National Association for Gambling Studies. Ward, R. (1958) The Australian Legend, Melbourne: Oxford University Press. Weber, M. (1976 [1904–5]) The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, London: Allen & Unwin. Weinstein, D. and Deitch, L. (1974) The Impact of Legalised Gambling: The Socio-economic Consequences of Lotteries and Off-track Betting, New York: Praeger. Woung, S. (1980) Professional Blackjack, Atlantic City, NJ: Boardwalker Magazine. Wykes, A. (1964) The Complete Illustrated Guide to Gambling, New York: Doubleday. Young, J. (1986) ‘The failure of criminology: the need for radical realism’, in R. Matthews and J.Young (eds) Confronting Crime, London: Sage: 34–48. ——(1988) ‘Radical criminology in Britain: the emergence of a competing paradigm’, British Journal of Criminology 28(2):159–83. Zola, I.K. (1967 [1963]) ‘Observations on gambling in a lower class setting’, in R.D. Harmon (ed.) Gambling, New York: Harper & Row: 19–31.
2 GAMBLING AND THE LEGALISATION OF VICE Social movements, public health and public policy in the United States John Dombrink1
The politics of the criminalisation, decriminalisation, legalisation or recriminalisation of vice in America has deep roots and complex forms. Other western industrialised countries have used the criminal law to control vice, but in the twentieth century, the United States has displayed a stubborn attachment to the use of the criminal sanction in the area, a prime example being the prohibition of alcoholic beverages in the 1920s. Meanwhile, Britain and Germany have chosen less punitive forms of control, utilising medical and market models to restrict citizen access to possible harmful substances. However, a comparative approach examining various countries’ practices on regulating vice is beyond the scope of this chapter. What follows is a comparison within the United States of the status of legal treatment of several types of vice. While the discussion may not be easily related to other countries, even those with similar economic and social structure or shared cultural traditions, it is hoped that the comparative analysis of gambling to other vices within the United States is useful. I aim to explain why gambling has been an exceptional case in the legal treatment of vice, as well as to gauge the extent to which it resonates with elements of deep-seated debate over family, sexuality, privacy, the limits of the criminal sanction and the role of government in matters of personal morality. Skolnick and Dombrink (1978) have identified various factors which would lead towards or inhibit effective legalisation of the ‘classic’ vices—gambling, abortion, homosexuality, drug use, pornography and prostitution. This was more than a decade after a group of socio-legal scholars had argued for or predicted the liberalisation of criminal laws affecting these areas of victimless or consensual crime, advocating in the context of a model penal code the adoption of policies limiting the reach of the criminal sanction, an examination initiated by the British Wolfenden Report (Committee on Homosexual Offences and Prostitution 1963). Indeed, by 1978 the US Supreme Court had already provided American women with access to abortion through its 1973 ruling on Roe v. Wade;2 various states had addressed marijuana decriminalisation; and sodomy laws were changing. Above all, gambling was undergoing enormous change, as states legalised lotteries (Clotfelter and Cook 1989) and casino gambling in New Jersey (Dombrink and Thompson 1990) in what has been termed the ‘third wave’ of legalised gambling in American history (Rose 1980).
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
41
By 1992, however, there was a conservative backlash against the trend to liberalisation of vice. The thrust of the arguments of many who have analysed vice, morality, law and society is that resentment among the lower middle class and others who perceive threats to their social status is responsible for the endurance of vice as a political issue. In the United States, the issues of sexuality and drugs were central to many of the cultural shifts of the 1960s and 1970s, and the liberalised public policy responses of those times created social dissent across the dimensions of age, religion, region and political orientation. One of the emblematic phenomena in the United States in the 1980s was the furthering of a conservative social agenda, which can be mapped in several ways. Several authors (Himmelstein 1990; Hunter 1991; Luker 1984) have written about the ways in which issues related to law and morality have become a key feature of conservative activists, especially those referred to as the ‘religious right’ (Marty and Appleby 1992; Sullivan 1993). These issues can be contrasted with the economic issues on which other conservative activists and politicians focused. The treatment of abortion in American law and public policy in different eras— sometimes unregulated, sometimes prohibited, sometimes medicalised, sometimes regulated and legalised—represents a wide range of legal models for the treatment of vice. Abortion provided a key issue of this focus, with the main goal of many conservative activists being to overturn the right of a woman to choose an abortion, as held in Roe v. Wade. Luker (1984), in her study of pro-choice and pro-life activists, emphasises the extent to which their positions reflect disagreement on a constellation of values and issues related to the changing nature of women’s and men’s roles, of sexual mores and sexual practices, of women’s roles in the marketplace, and the changing natures and functions of the family. While stating that many media reports have provided caricatures of these conflicts, Hunter (1991) none the less describes them as ‘culture wars’ reflecting the deep division over definitions of personal and public morality involved. The ‘war’ against drugs had been as captivating as any public policy issue in recent times. While the American economy emerged as a topic of primary concern in the current recession, the issue of drug control had risen dramatically (from 1 per cent identifying it as the most important national issue rising to 38 per cent a few years later). Attempts by the National Endowment of the Arts (NEA) to limit funding for artists whose work offends certain social mores resulted in an explosive debate over freedom of expression, government censorship and the First Amendment rights of free speech (Bolton 1992). In a celebrated incident in 1992, President Bush removed the chief of the NEA when it became clear that Bush’s conservative challenger in the nation’s Republican primaries was prepared to make a campaign issue of that agency’s funding of art he thought obscene—in particular, a film about gay black males. This had followed widely publicised events in which the Senate debated the nature of the art funded by the NEA, such as the homoerotic photographs of the late Robert Mapplethorpe, which had also been the focus of an earlier obscenity prosecution against a Cincinnati museum director (Gurstein 1991; Paglia 1991). At the same time, attempts by state legislatures to pass laws mandating warning labels on recordings containing possibly offensive language have met with legal challenges, mixed judicial success, and strong opposition from the arts community and recording industry.
Gambling cultures
42
At another level, developments related to euthanasia, such as failed initiatives for physician-assisted suicide in Washington in 1991 and California in 1992 (Humphry 1991; Kamisar 1991; Vorenberg 1991) and public smoking controls (Pertschuk and Shopland 1989), have led to those topics being analysed along with the classic vices as situations involving consensus, willing ‘victims’ and public health. While smoking limitations were first sought as a classic vice control, in which smokers were segregated, such as in ‘smoking sections’ of restaurants or public facilities, recent emphasis on ‘second-hand smoke’ has spotlighted the non-smoker as unwilling victim. Legal reform related to homosexuality also has been a key issue of those with a conservative social agenda. In several municipalities, referendums reversed previously passed ordinances adding sexual orientation to the list of protected classes under civil rights provisions. In Oregon, a hotly contested referendum in 1992, which would have declared homosexuality a perversity and restricted state institutions from teaching, recognising or regarding it as an acceptable lifestyle, was defeated. However, Colorado passed a referendum that prevents any municipality from enforcing an ordinance that would provide civil rights protection for homosexuals. School prayer was a vibrant issue in a similar way, until a 1992 Supreme Court ruling held to the traditional separation of Church and state, despite the expectations of conservative activists. In both the abortion and school prayer issues, the election of Democrat Bill Clinton in 1992 portends that conservative court majorities for those issues might not be forthcoming in the near future. Certainly, conservative federal trial and appellate judges were appointed over the course of those eight years who were thought to have survived a litmus test on abortion, school prayer and other closely held beliefs held by the moral entrepreneurs in the ‘moral majority’, among them various pro-life groups (Becker 1963; Himmelstein 1990; Luker 1984; Tribe 1990). Some have commented that these federal judicial appointments could end up as the most significant legacy of the Reagan administration, one less likely to be overturned by changing domestic or economic priorities, evolving world events or shifts in public attitudes toward crime, vice or the range of personal and lifestyle issues at debate in the ‘culture wars’. Still, the politics of vice at the level of New Right consciousness and activity has been a chequered one. The issue of abortion has been problematic for the Republican Party, which has sought to maintain the allegiance of disenchanted Democrats (or ‘Reagan Democrats’)—often blue-collar, ethnic and religious— who left the party of ‘abortion, amnesty and acid’ (and affirmative action) in 1968 and thereafter. Many political analysts argue that these people did not gain economically from such political shifts, but did see their stances on issues like abortion, school prayer, homosexuality and, more abstractly, patriotism, affirmed in political discourse. The 1992 Republican National Convention in Houston was perceived as showing too much intolerance on these issues, however, and lost votes among more socially tolerant middle-class voters, especially women, as a price of allowing the religious right and other conservative activists too much say in the party’s platform (Wills 1992). Even so, the political organising of the Christian Coalition in school board races in small towns and big cities continues apace, even though their candidates are often referred to as ‘stealth candidates’, because of their purposeful low profiles. In New York City in 1993, the Christian Coalition distributed lengthy guides to the candidates in the usually low-turnout school board elections, in a city in which
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
43
multicultural curricula and the use of books explaining same-sex couples to primary schoolchildren were heatedly discussed (Sullivan 1993). Against this background, a core theme of this chapter will be developed: one way in which gambling has diverged from the other vices is that it has not played any role in this politicisation of vice. Gambling has been most noticeable for its inability to produce much in the way of moral resentment. Indeed, if gambling is now separate from the list of the classic vices—because of its acceptance, its legalisation, its pervasiveness, its perceived lack of seriousness—a primary reason is that it has not generated as much of the cultural conflict and moral resentment associated in the last decade with the other vices.
SOCIO-LEGAL ANALYSIS, VICE AND THE CRIMINAL LAW In the late 1960s, a group of legal scholars began a comprehensive and critical analysis of the limits of the criminal sanction in the area of vice in the United States. A series of studies and analyses called into question the philosophical and practical bases for the use of the criminal law in the legislation of morality, including at that time state proscriptions related to abortion, gambling, homo-sexuality, pornography, prostitution and drugs. In the aftermath of the Wolfenden Report in Great Britain, which argued for the decriminalisation of certain vices, a debate was conducted in the United States between these prominent legal scholars and defenders of the existing use of the criminal sanction in which the central issue was the effect on society of an individual’s choice to pursue activities, ingest substances or modify behaviour in ways which could cause them harm.3 In defence of existing criminal laws, Sir Patrick Devlin, a British jurist, attacked the precept of John Stuart Mill (1956 [1859]) that a person should be allowed to go to hell in his or her own way, and argued that the web of society is torn by the collective actions of individuals causing vice-related harm to themselves (Devlin 1965; Hart 1963). In this view the criminal law is an appropriate and necessary measure to maintain societal stability and to enforce common morality. Some involved in that debate cautioned against negative consequences in relation to the legitimacy and effectiveness of the criminal sanction by over-criminalisation (Kadish 1967). Others, like Skolnick (1968), decried the ways in which this ‘coercion to virtue’ was a misuse of the criminal sanction which engaged the police in the difficult enforcement of consensual crime, with few complainants and consequent evidential constraints. Packer (1968) discussed in depth how the effort to enforce morality through the legal system effectively proved the limits of the criminal sanction. Schur (1965, 1980; Schur and Bedau 1974) and later Geis (1972) elaborated on the variety of activity and lawenforcement activity associated with each vice, and drew the attention of an entire generation of socio-legal scholars and students to the significance of ‘victimless crime’, even as that generation was experimenting with new forms of drug use, sexual activity and sexual mores, and demanding liberalised abortion laws. Many of these scholars contributed to the drafting of the Model Penal Code, a practical effort to encourage implementation and standardisation by relevant jurisdictions of the reforms they espoused.
Gambling cultures
44
CHANGES IN THE LEGAL AND SOCIETAL TREATMENT OF VICE, 1967–92 Each of the six ‘classic vices’, even if they once occupied a relatively common conceptual place in the United States, has changed in so many significant ways between the 1960s and 1990s that they each seem to now represent a new type within a general typology of vice. In the sections that follow, the legal treatment of each will be discussed and contrasted with the legal treatment of gambling. Perhaps one of the most compelling differences, in addition to the perception of seriousness and harm, will be that several of the vices are concerned with sexuality. Consequently, they are more likely to strike a deep chord within ongoing cultural debates over the role of the family, gender roles, sexual identity and sexual practices than is gambling. At the same time, a key basis for the protection of these activities has been the right to privacy, which has not been a central factor in gambling legalisation discussions. Gambling Several studies have noted that gambling was deeply ingrained in colonial America. Like other societies, various forms of gambling have been tolerated at different times in US society. Indeed, lotteries were used in colonial times to support public works projects and the construction of some of America’s leading universities (Cornell Law Project 1977). Horse-racing was considered sport, especially among the new country’s ruling elites. The issue of the morality of gambling was of concern to Puritan groups, and the concept of chance argued to be at odds with their emphasis on hard work. However, it is clear that a deep-rooted ambivalence has existed in American law and public policy towards gambling throughout the country’s history (Skolnick 1978, 1988). During several distinct periods in US history, there have been movements to limit or repeal gambling, along with alcohol and other vices. The attacks on gambling because of its inherent immorality, however, have not usually been determinative, except when combined with fraud or public scandal—such as the Louisiana Lottery scandal of the mid nineteenth century—or corruption in the political process, such as when the Progressive Movement targeted the saloon as a corrupting institution, along with the worker safety and intemperance arguments of the anti-alcohol campaigns of the early twentieth century (Gusfield 1963). Skolnick and Dombrink (1978), in evaluating the potential commercialisation of the various vices, suggested that gambling would emerge as the most socially acceptable vice, for several reasons. First, gambling has been interpreted, both by public and scholars (Geis 1972), as being the least harmful of the vices and that which has been socially sanctioned in many societies. One reason for this assessment is the level of harm which gambling may do to an individual. For example, if much gambling is engaged in by those who are occasional or recreational gamblers, wagering discretionary funds, the harm of their gambling is perceived as minimal. Moreover, while some religious groups in western industrialised societies do oppose gambling, it is not perceived as severely as some of the sexually orientated vices. Nor is the physical harm of gambling as pronounced as drug use.
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
45
Second, the possibilities of state ownership, while not absent in the other cases, seemed more appropriate for gambling than state-operated drug clinics, as in the British model, or state-operated brothels. Third, the criminal justice system has been unable and unwilling for some time to assign penalties of even a moderate magnitude to gambling offences, making the arguments for their prosecution in a resource-scarce environment that much more difficult. Since the 1970s, legal gambling in the United States has changed in the following dramatic ways. Legal gambling has risen dramatically at double-digit annual increase in gambling handle figures throughout the 1980s, and diversified at the same time (Abt et al. 1985). This rise has been uneven, focusing more on some areas (for example, lotteries) than others (sports gambling, casinos). Tax revenues from such forms have risen in a corresponding manner, and increased as state-run lotteries, with their higher return to the state as operator, have increased as a share of the total gambling dollar (Christiansen 1990; Kaplan 1984). Gambling has been reduced in seriousness as a crime, as measured by crime seriousness surveys, judicial sentencing, prosecutorial decisions to charge and public opinion polls. American national policy towards gambling was examined and articulated in a national review, and the trend towards legalisation was furthered by the report of this inquiry (Commission on the Review of the National Policy toward Gambling 1976). Gambling has emerged as a serious public policy issue in the United States, examined in depth by an array of international scholars of a variety of disciplinary backgrounds, working through a network developed in large part by the University of Nevada, Reno, through more than a decade of international conferences, publications and sharing of research and practitioner results.4 The stigma attached to other forms of vice has not continued to attach to the player or consumer in the case of gambling as it attaches to the heroin-user or the prostitute. This has happened at the same time as excellent research on problem gambling in recent years has been published (Volberg and Steadman 1992). On the one hand, added knowledge of or focus on problem gambling, whether in celebrated cases or in society as a whole, presents a negative view of problem gambling in legalisation discussions. At the same time, the medical explanation for these problem gamblers can blunt the issue’s negative effect. In sum, the average gambler is not a problem gambler, and a problem gambler does not pose the threat that a drug addict or prostitute might. Some analysts have raised the issue of the regressivity of lotteries as a form of taxation (Clotfelter and Cook 1989), but the focus on the individual gambler has had its main impact on legalisation debates which question the desirability of certain urban centres as casino gambling sites, given the large poor and working-class population living in these cities. That focus limited the inclusion of New York City in the 1980s state proposal for casinos, has thwarted Chicago’s emergence as a potential locale, but has not foreclosed New Orleans. Recent efforts for casinos in the smaller north-eastern states of Rhode Island and Connecticut have yet to come to fruition. Where the stigma has attached, it has attached to the gambling operator, motivated by the fear of the influence of organised crime and political corruption. Several scholars have noted that, for these various reasons, the successful attacks on gambling have more often been on their collateral effects or institutional forms than the nature of gambling itself. These issues have proved paramount in the slowing of the anticipated trend
Gambling cultures
46
towards legalisation of Las Vegas-style casino gambling or sports gambling in the United States. Dombrink and Thompson (1990) argue for the salience of a ‘veto’ model to explain why the opposition of a single significant political or economic elite helped thwart casino legalisation in many states, in contrast with the seemingly painless approval of state-run lotteries by state after state (Clotfelter and Cook 1989). Yet in the face of the emerging riverboat gambling phenomenon and the expansion of gambling on Indian land, renewed interest in and enduring proposals for the legalisation of various forms of gambling suggest that the chequerboard pattern of gambling legalisation in the United States may change in the next decade. Abortion Of other classic vices, abortion remains one of the most problematic because, as some have stated, it is either a clear crime (resembling murder) or a clear surgical decision, related to privacy and the individual rights of women, and unrelated to the pursuit of pleasure as the other vices are. Abortion thus has had an historic and contested category in the earlier treatments of vice. Abortion also remains an active example of the mobilisation of public and resources, the definition and redefinition of an activity as legal or illegal, the interplay of politics, public opinion and influence matters, and the role of the legal system in personal spheres, issues which affect all of the vices discussed in this chapter. In the 1960s and early 1970s, abortion laws followed a medicalisation approach. For example, Californian physicians were approving 99 per cent of requests for abortion in the period preceding Roe v. Wade in 1973, thus begging the question of why abortion on demand should not be legalised, since the medical model was in fact delivering that (Luker 1984). In this instance, medicalisation, or the empowerment of trained professionals to use their expertise and discretion—sometimes under strict state rules, at other times under more ambiguous regulations—was a transitory phase. Once criminalisation was overturned, the women’s movement argued persuasively for the validity of personal choice and rights to privacy as imperative, rather than the empowerment of medical professionals. By 1992, however, analysts and activists were predicting that the growth of a conservative majority on the US Supreme Court was certain to lead to an outright reversal of Roe v. Wade, even as other decisions limited the access of certain types of women—those needing federal funding, or those under 18 years of age, for example. The resulting protests, organisation of electoral politics, drafting of new legislation, lobbying, and projected shifts in voting behaviour at the national level and other levels have made abortion an issue of extreme importance in the United States. When the Casey decision was handed down in 1992,5 it preserved the concept of Roe v. Wade, while allowing for some limitations on access. This surprising result reflected the new ‘centre’ of the court on this issue, with Justices O’Connor, Kennedy and Souter forming that bloc.
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
47
Prostitution Prostitution, in many ways, remains a vice that resists full or formal decriminalisation or legalisation but which is not seen as a serious issue by the American public, prosecutors, juries and judges, or police officers (Symanski 1981). In only a few places has it grown in importance in the policing of public disorder (Bursik and Grasmick 1992; Skogan 1990). Community organisations in affected communities have opposed prostitution and used zoning laws to preserve community stability. Still, because of the lesser seriousness and lower sentencing, police forces have treated prostitution as a crime to be controlled, rather than eradicated. There have been no wide-scale moves for the legalisation of prostitution in the United States, and the movements for legalisation described by Weitzer and Jenness (Jenness 1993; Weitzer 1991), whether organised by sex workers or others, have not even achieved the referendum stage. At the same time, there has been an increase of solid research, much of it historical, including important feminist treatments of the meaning of tolerated prostitution, easily integrated into all sectors of society (Goldman 1981; Walkowitz 1980). Some European countries could serve as models generally for the alternative treatment of prostitution, but Americans have not been anxious to adopt such models. Several reasons might be given for this. First, there is no perception that an expensive police effort is producing mixed results in the case of prostitution, as is being argued regarding the ‘war on drugs’, despite estimates of the cost to the legal system of each prostitution case processed. Second, there has been little suggestion of the tax revenues or economic development possible by either a state-owned and -operated or privately run legal prostitution operation. Only Nevada, in its sparsely populated rural counties, has a tradition of legalised prostitution (Symanski 1981). This is a direct contrast to the appeal of legal gambling. Third, the civil rights of sex workers are not as clear a focus (and do not represent as many persons) of a movement for equal treatment, as is the case of lesbian/gay rights. Fourth, unlike abortion, prostitution has neither been defined as a woman’s choice as a right of privacy, nor as instrumental in the development of women’s lives, careers or standards of living. There has been no connection to larger movements or larger concerns, and the incidence of AIDS among street sex workers, while raising public health issues such as that which fuelled earlier ‘purity crusades’ (Pivar 1973), has probably undercut whatever slim chance there was in any locality for a decriminalisation movement. There are no current situations that indicate that the types of rationale that have prompted gambling legalisation since the 1970s will lead to any substantial reform of prostitution laws in the United States. Pornography The issue of pornography and obscenity is fraught with difficulties of definition, as US Supreme Court cases and enforcement efforts as well as public discussion and policymaking efforts have shown (Hawkins and Zimring 1988). Several themes characterise sexually explicit images and their production and distribution at this time. First, there is an active debate in which some feminist scholars and activists have taken the role of opposition previously occupied by conservative and religious opponents. In some cases
Gambling cultures
48
feminists have formed unlikely coalitions with those groups (Downs 1989; Greek and Thompson 1991; Kimmel 1990; Segal and McIntosh 1992; Zurcher and Kirkpatrick 1976). Second, the growth of home video technology has enabled the use of sexually explicit materials in the privacy of one’s own home, as opposed to pornography or ‘sex’ shops, creating a new population of consumers. Third, the availability of more ‘couplesorientated’ sexually explicit material, or material with more of a woman’s perspective (Williams 1989), has weakened some of the charges of sexism. Fourth, the separation of child pornography as a category without redeeming value and illegal by definition (since it involves under-age actors) has made it more difficult to combine other forms with it legally and morally. Whereas prostitution has encouraged feminist analysis of the complexity of roles and power relationships surrounding gender, pornography and obscenity have generated a strong debate over their effects on violence and aggression against women, rape fantasies and the degradation of women in general. Psychologists have attempted to measure and predict the propensity for aggression among subjects who watch sexually explicit movies with violent themes, while others see the suppression of erotic works as censorship and denial of freedom of speech and expression (Childress 1991, 1992; Kutchinsky 1992). One development in this debate has been a previously missing feminist critique of pornography and pornography laws, seen as reflecting the male domination of the legal profession, policy-making and social science research. The battle over pornography has generated new uses of the law to control its distribution, as in the passage of various municipal ordinances to counteract the perceived negative effects of pornography. With the structure of gambling laws, however, most of the focus has been on state laws and state legislatures. Even as the legal basis for local ordinances has been challenged, pornography has been included as a predicate crime under the Racketeer Influenced Corrupt Organisations (RICO) statute resulting in, among other things, the controversial forfeiture of property (a video store) under ‘proceeds of crime’ legislation (in a case reviewed in 1993 by the US Supreme Court). Yet the United States Supreme Court refused to hear a case which struck down a municipal ordinance using civil remedies under civil rights provisions to sanction pornography distri- butors. The Canadian courts have upheld a similar law, and some state legislators in the United States are considering bills to effect similar legislation (Downs 1989). Homosexuality Homosexuality was one vice identified in the Wolfenden Report as an activity which warranted the withdrawal of the criminal law (Committee on Homosexual Offences and Prostitution 1963). In the decades since that report, discussions and social movements in many western industrialised societies have brought the issue of sexual orientation to the forefront, with several possible legal reforms available. In the United States, Altman notes that movements among homosexuals for better treatment by society have followed the model of the African-American civil rights strategies, falling into groups Altman described as pursuing ‘assimilationist’ strategies, and those choosing confrontation (Altman 1982). Over more than two decades, as Greenberg (1988) and others (Faderman 1991) have noted, the struggle over the
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
49
‘construction’ of homosexuality has been waged in American culture at the same time as legal reform has been sought. One legal reform model is represented by states such as California, which chose to decriminalise sodomy. However, not all American states did so, and the US Supreme Court ruled in the 1980s that sodomy laws were constitutional. Another type of legal reform effort is directed at states, counties, municipalities and other entities to add sexual orientation to the list of protected classes under civil rights laws. Only a few states have adopted wide-scale protections for gays and lesbians using civil rights laws, and most of those have limited the scope to state or public employment. Several dozen cities and counties have enacted legislation affecting all employment, most forms of housing, accommodation and other areas (Meeker et al. 1985). A major effort to protect gays and lesbians in the US military is generating public discussion and debate (Shilts 1993). Another type of legal reform has been the increased focus on the use of ‘hate crime’ statutes to prosecute those whose assaults and other crimes against gays and lesbians are accompanied by selection of their victim because of his or her actual or perceived sexual orientation (Comstock 1991). This reform has been applied to a variety of other groups, especially to racial minority groups, but has been limited to date by a US Supreme Court ruling. The growth in anti-discrimination protections for lesbians and gays has flattened out, in some cases because of the diversion of resources to the fight against AIDS (Hunter and Rubenstein 1992; Shilts 1987). However, the organising potential of gay rights as a rallying cry for fundamentalist religious groups and conservative activists has been pronounced (Greenberg 1988:478–80). Groups like California’s Reverend Louis Shelton and his Traditional Values Coalition and the Christian Coalition have become commonplace lobbyists against attempts by public entities such as school districts to discuss sexuality, abortion, AIDS and other issues in the classroom. One strategic decision they have made is to run candidates for local school board seats, often a public office for which few citizens vote. A 1993 New York City campaign by the Christian Coalition, whose guide to candidates was also distributed by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese, followed a nationally prominent debate over the use of multicultural curriculum items, including stories for primary school students about gay couples. Unlike the other vices, gay rights have followed more of a civil rights model, as Altman (1982) and others (D’Emilio 1983; Marotta 1981) have pointed out, rather than a commercial model (as with gambling), and without the possibility of a wide selfinterested support of the kind an abortion rights movement might have. By comparison, gambling eludes much of the acrimony of the divisions which characterise debates over homosexuality, for better or worse. In the United States, at least, the comparability of the public debate and discourse over these issues has radically diverged. They may have shared common elements twenty-five years ago, but it is difficult to find such commonality in the present and projected near future. Drugs The drugs that are currently criminalised in the United States and draw the most attention because of the frequency of their use are primarily heroin, cocaine and crack cocaine, and marijuana. There are also law enforcement emphases on methamphetamine, debate over
Gambling cultures
50
the appropriateness of weight-related minimum sentencing laws which include the weight of the wrapping around LSD doses, and concern over synthetic ‘designer’ drugs, such as ecstasy. Many brilliant analyses of the genesis of American drug laws have been published since the 1970s (Bonnie and Whitebread 1974; Grinspoon and Bakalar 1976; Himmelstein 1983; Kaplan 1970, 1983; Lindesmith 1965; Musto 1973) at the same time as policy discussions of the appropriateness of the criminal sanction have taken place (Currie 1993; Kleiman 1992). In the most salient example of decriminalisation, the seriousness of marijuana use diminished during the 1960s and 1970s, as a result of either the evaluation of its effects or its increased use by white middle-class college students. Members of the elite whose children were users were outraged that lengthy prison sentences could be given for possession of minor amounts of the substance. Also, the ageing of many marijuana users placed them in positions of legal authority, such as judges or legislators. As Himmelstein (1983) notes, the reformulation of marijuana from ‘killer weed’ to ‘drop-out drug’ accompanied this transformation. Several states decriminalised marijuana use, issuing only citations for possession of amounts under 28 grams. Full-scale legalisation generally lost support after these reforms. In recent years, the United States has witnessed attempts to recriminalise marijuana. The Director of the President’s Drug Policy Office argued in the 1980s that marijuana’s legal treatment undercut the efforts to target drugs with stiffer penalties, and argued for recriminalisation. At the same time, mandatory sentences and mandatory minimum sentences, a movement typifying criminal justice reform in the 1980s, began to have an impact on America’s legal system, criminal justice system and correctional system. The ‘war on drugs’ became an important feature of the Reagan and Bush administrations, coinciding with this rise of mandatory prison sentences, increased use of the death penalty, a steep rise in the use of imprisonment (and gaol and prison overcrowding accompanying it), and a reduction in emphasis on the rehabilitative ideal, the use of probation and parole, and attempts to address the root causes of crime. During that time, despite the vociferous arguments for legalisation by sociological scholars, policy-makers and other influential persons of liberal, libertarian and even conservative bent (such as former Secretary of State George Schultz, and economist Milton Friedman) (Nadelmann 1991; Vila 1993), the public has often viewed drugs as America’s most important public policy issue (Colasanto 1990).6 The federal criminal justice system reports that roughly half of its criminal cases are concerned with drugs, a pattern reflected in the prison population. The rise in drug sanctioning (for sales and use) at the state level has crowded courts to the extent that there is a crisis in the ability of courts to handle civil cases. Even conservative jurists have called for more attention to be paid to ‘early intervention, treatment, education, and investigation of the basic cause leading to the proliferation of drug use’ (Administrative Office 1991:8). In 1993, statements from the new Attorney-General of the United States indicated that increased emphasis on treatment for drug use would be accompanied by a reduction in the criminalisation response. However, the vitality of drugs as a vice issue with connections to other features of American life has operated in at least three ways. With the rise in rock cocaine, or crack, use among non-white urban populations, as opposed to the affluent, largely white use of
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
51
powder cocaine during the 1970s, drug-control policies can be seen as resonant of larger racial and class-based cleavages in American society. Thus, the punishment of drug users can be seen in the same traditional light as the rationale for other punishments of dangerous classes, such as burglary or robbery. At the same time, African-American policy-makers, like New York Congressional Representative Charles Rangel, or progressive criminologists such as Currie (1993), are reluctant to endorse drug legalisation, because of the adverse public health effects such a legal change would have on America’s non-white population, without addressing the problems of poverty and unemployment that contribute to drug use and sales. Still others (Inciardi and McBride 1991; Jacobs 1990; Kaplan 1983; Kleiman 1992) have argued for prudence and scepticism in adopting drug legalisation as a response. At a second level, but closely related, drugs have become a surrogate term for all crime, carrying at the same time many of the preconceptions of race and class conflict that are mentioned above. As such, many anti-crime measures, whether expressly about drugs or not, use drugs implicitly or explicitly as the foundation for arguments about the need for stricter laws, longer sentences, less judicial discretion, fewer rights and more uses of incarceration as a sanction. In recent years, new twists, such as the criminalisation of pregnant women who are drug users, the intervention of the state into the lives of ‘crack babies’, the loss of public housing privileges, school loans, drivers’ licences and the like, and even the suggestion of revived orphanages in drug-impacted neighbourhoods, can be seen as representing the depth of drug use as a public health topic. At a third level, consistent with many of the other forms of vice, drug use and drug sales—in this case, no matter where they take place in the social strata—are portrayed as a sign of general moral weakening in society, and part of the permissiveness that threatens American economic and social strength. The 1960s and 1970s witnessed the emergence of several viable grassroots movements for the decriminalisation or legalisation of many forms of drug use. By comparison, the calls for re-examination of American drug policies in the 1990s have come from judges, academics and an elite group of societal influentials. The opinion and editorial pages of newspapers are rife with arguments for the reform of drug law from liberal, libertarian and even conservative commentators, as noted above, but the movement in legislation so far has been toward recriminalisation, not liberalisation. However, other western industrialised countries have produced very different models over the twentieth century for dealing with drugs. British medical models have long been suggested as a possible alternative for American laws (Kaplan 1983). Skolnick and Dombrink (1978) have suggested a variety of models that might be followed. Unlike homosexuality or abortion, the issue of illicit drugs contains some similar elements to the case of gambling. Commercial models could be employed, although most proponents of legal reform in the drug area emphasise the substitution of public health goals rather than revenue raising (Skolnick 1992). However, the fiscal crisis of states and cities is implicit in arguments for shifting the law. Rather than emphasising the state tax revenues that would proceed from legalisation, which is the most common argument in gambling campaigns, the emphasis has been on the reduction of expenditures on the ‘war on drugs’.
Gambling cultures
52
At the same time, it must be stated that gambling has not been the subject of the recriminalisation sentiments. There has been very little gambling backlash or ‘rollbacks’, such as in the gay rights or marijuana examples. Admittedly, there have been campaigns that failed, and types of gambling, such as sports gambling (Frey 1992), that have not been legalised, and declines in lottery excitement and revenues over time in certain places. But gambling has not drawn a renewed moral wrath, nor been deeply associated with crime problems in general.
GAMBLING’S STATUS AMONG THE VICES What, then, can be said about gambling’s position between 1967 and 1992 in America, and its position vis-à-vis the other vices? One of the central themes of this chapter has to do with the models of legalisation which apply in the area of vice. More directly, the questions that need to be addressed relate to a social change or social movement model. For example, does the passage or proliferation of smaller forms of legal gambling, in a revenue sense (for example, riverboat gambling), make the case for or build the momentum for more large-scale development? Or, conversely, does the passage or proliferation of those smaller forms satisfy the demand for gambling, thus limiting the perceived need for further expansion in form, type or size? For example, one reason commonly given why the decriminalisation of marijuana in the 1970s in the United States did not lead to legalisation of the substance was that the reduced criminal penalties satisfied the majority of users, and thus undercut any simultaneous impetus for legalisation of cultivation and sales. Similarly, one argument given by at least some members of the five-member majority in the US Supreme Court’s ruling that upheld the state of Georgia’s sodomy statute was that it was not really enforced.7 Therefore, under that de facto decriminalisation, the statute did not essentially threaten homosexuals in that state or in the other states which still maintain such laws. Consequently, its removal was not mandated by a compelling civil rights protection argument (Harvard Law Review Editors 1990). In the case of gambling, divergent theories can be seen as possibly being supported. For example, in 1990, some US gambling operators expressed fear that if there was a potential scandal in a state initiating relatively small-scale riverboat gambling, it might impair the eventual ability of larger operators and larger developments to follow.8 An opposing theory would hold that the proliferation of smaller-scale gambling erodes the opposition to other forms and larger venues, ‘softening’ or increasing the conduciveness of populations to accept legal gambling. None of the other classic vices has demonstrated in any way the powerful commercial potential of legal gambling, an activity which, while at once representing the most harmless of the vices (Geis 1972), has almost moved beyond the other vices in its sense of legal inevitability so as to warrant exclusion from the category of vice. Lotteries have become so widespread since New Hampshire became the first state to bring back the state-sponsored lottery in 1964 that it is hard to remember a time without them. Even as their sales dip, and new games attempt to rekindle the public participation, even as people grumble about the real fiscal impact upon education, law enforcement or other targeted beneficiaries of the lottery revenues, the vitality of the lotteries reminds us of the colonial
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
53
days when they were commonly used as revenue-raising mechanisms for universities (Harvard, Columbia) and public works projects, or the nineteenth-century presence of the lottery, before scandal and prohibition caused their decline (Cornell Law Project 1977). During the same period as lotteries have flourished, casino gambling has only spread in its Las Vegas style to one state (New Jersey), despite the attempts by many others to permit it. In the last few years, however, small-scale casino gambling has been permitted in states along the Mississippi River, in the context of ‘riverboat gambling’, and even California is considering offshore gambling ships again. Old Western towns like Deadwood, South Dakota, and its Colorado counterparts have also legalised small-scale casino gambling, at the same time as Indian reservation gambling has proliferated under the unique jurisdictional laws governing American Indian sovereignty (Eadington 1990; Rose 1992). Sports gambling, admittedly the largest illegal form of gambling, and one that would have an enormous legal market in the United States, has been kept from legalisation in large part because of the efforts of a professional sports organisation, the National Collegiate Athletic Association, and fears that such gambling would lead to a rise in corruption in sports. This fear of corruption, and of the political process generally, has been behind some of the casino opposition, as have fears of collateral vice growth, such as prostitution. Still, unlike the other vices, gambling has emerged from this remarkable period of growth—what Rose has termed the ‘third wave’ of legal gambling in the United States— with neither the political concern for damages to the individual who engages in the activity, nor with an active social movement supporting either its legalisation or criminalisation. Certainly, powerful and influential elites, organisations and coalitions have arisen during campaigns to defeat certain types of gambling legalisation (Dombrink and Thompson 1990). However, the image of the wilful, affluent gambler using discretionary income in limited betting has supplanted images of the problem gambler, even as valuable research about the incidence and prevalence of such problem gambling has been undertaken. In part, this is reinforced by the notion that gambling is something done on vacation, on time away. However, it is largely because of the careful publicrelations work of legal gambling operators. Legalisation has been accompanied by the growth of legal gambling industries, consultants and experts, in lieu of a wide-scale social movement, so that the battles for gambling growth are often conducted by competing groups of business and political elites, with the public included generally as referendum voters responding to the packaged media efforts for the opposing sides to portray revenues or crime/corruption as the inevitable outcome of such a legal reform. This is far different from the mobilisation, marches and intense public scrutiny placed on the ‘constituency-based’ vices or the highly politicised activities such as abortion rights. In fact, one could postulate that gambling, as it has inched away from the other vices, adds both protection and vulnerability—protection because it is perceived as less harmful and possesses socially valued fiscal abilities, vulnerability because it could easily be portrayed as a ‘special interest vice’ in the same way that the tobacco and alcohol industries and lobbies are limited in their opportunities for advertising, sponsorship and public use. Indeed, public opinion polls show strong public support for assessing higher taxes on both alcoholic beverages and tobacco products, as ‘sin taxes’, to raise more revenues for increased health coverage nationally. In this context, critiques questioning the actual performance and contribution of lotteries and casinos (Clotfelter and Cook
Gambling cultures
54
1989; Sternlieb and Hughes 1983) represent a new era of scholarship, challenging not the moral basis of a vice activity but its actual societal contributions.
CONCLUSION Many of the classic studies of the criminalisation of vice have described the role of class conflict, racial issues, moral entrepreneurs and moral panics in the establishment of laws prohibiting vice. Alongside other studies of the class-based nature of the emergence of non-vice laws, these studies provided a framework for understanding the symbolic power of vice in American society. Gusfield’s classic study of the symbolic politics of alcohol prohibition (1963) spawned later studies, such as Himmelstein’s analysis of the transformation of marijuana from ‘killer weed’ to acceptable recreational drug when white, middle-class college students (and some of their elders) began smoking marijuana in the 1960s (Himmelstein 1983). Luker’s depiction of the world view of opposing abortion activists (1984) amidst conflict over women’s roles, women’s workplace participation and the relationship between men and women is a powerful commentary on the larger connections of vice to the social structure generally. One classic commentary on vice and class resentment was made by Ranulf (1964), who located the impetus for much legal action against vice and other activities in the disinterested impulses and resentment of the lower middle class (see also Duster 1970). Certainly, the Republican Party was able, at least at the national level, during the 1970s and 1980s to reap political advantage out of the willingness of voters whose economic interests might not lie with Republican policies to vote Republican because of its positions on abortion, sexuality, race, sexual preference, drugs and ‘moral permissiveness’. The courting of these ‘Reagan Democrats’ was seemingly without cost until the emergence of white supremacist candidates, and the loss of the votes of prochoice middle-class women in the 1992 presidential campaign. It used vice issues as a critical wedge among persons with economic class similarities. The emergence of abortion as an important issue suggests that gender issues exist across the social strata. Meanwhile, public financing and health access issues accentuate class concerns. Drugs seemingly have become too integrated with the politics of race and crime in America for the failure of the war on drugs or the public cost of the criminal justice system’s being overwhelmed with drug cases to have much impact. Still, the analyses, arguments and opinion/editorial articles in leading newspapers keep the question of the legalisation of now illicit drugs in active discussion. Even if there were to be no legalisation of drugs, the discussion is more vibrant, and debated more nationally, than the discussion of the other vices, which is generally localised. This is certainly the case with gambling. Justice Blackmun, in his opinion in Roe v. Wade, may have provided the legal support for the philosophical underpinnings of the way in which vice and its legal treatment may ultimately have its most lasting impact on American society: the right of privacy.9 The location of the crux of the abortion rights argument on precisely the grounds that remove these activities from excessive public intervention—that of privacy—creates the possibility for the strength of a concept that transcends class and thus negates that which Ranulf describes. When the victims of a too intrusive state policy on vice are essentially
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
55
marginalised drug addicts, sex workers or degenerate gamblers, the rationale for liberalised social policy in this area is essentially other-considering. In other words, society shifts legal policy to avoid doing harm to some class of individuals, using various rationales, such as their illness or vulnerability. The limits for social movements, and legal reform, are derived by the size of constituencies, and their relative powerlessness. Reforms in which more persons have a stake, such as those concerning privacy or affecting tax revenues, have potentially wider bases of support. Against this background, gambling still maintains its curious membership on the list of vices, as used by socio-legal scholars. At one level, gambling has moved closer to the status of alcohol or tobacco in its treatment in the United States, perceived as an acceptable, middle-class recreational activity. Both tobacco and alcohol have high levels of revenues and are well integrated into American society. Thus, they do not fear outright prohibition. Still, public health themes have fuelled movements for the limitation or reduction of use of these two substances, and, at least in the case of smoking, have severely changed the expectations of public behaviour, if not commercial availability. None the less, gambling operators, both private and public, might well settle for such an entrenched status. At the same time, the notion of a ‘sin tax’ is often viewed as a mature and reasonable approach for societies as they consider the mechanisms for the treatment of some of the above-mentioned vices. One of the attractions of legal gambling is that it provides tax revenues for its jurisdictions. Unfortunately, taxes have their own problems in regard to support from the citizenry, and the current anti-incumbent mood in the United States suggests that a sin tax may not necessarily have as stable a status as it might seem. If gambling operations come to be viewed as privileged special interests, or criticised for failing to meet their proponents’ expectations, their vulnerability to control and restriction might increase (Rose 1991). Because legalisation of this vice has been framed in the language of privilege, rather than right, maintaining legal gambling will depend more on lobbyists, corporate entities and government bodies rather than the protesters in the streets that abortion rights or gay rights can provide. Consequently, support for the continuation or expansion of various forms of gambling might be perceived as limited to a small number of well-placed and self-interested public and private parties, rather than any grassroots movement or wider public good. As such, the movement of gambling towards acceptability and legitimation, and its separation from the other classic vices listed in the 1960s, might present it with a host of new vulnerabilities in future years.
NOTES 1 Earlier versions of this chapter were delivered at the Eighth International Conference on Risk and Gambling, London, 15–17 August 1990, and the 50th Annual Meeting of the American Society of Criminology, San Francisco, 20–23 November 1991. The author thanks Nicole Negrete, Audra Simon, Karol Kurata, Mark Kimura, David Maples, Aric Lasky and Biljana Korac for their contributions, and Gilbert Geis, Jerome Skolnick and Joseph Scott for their helpful comments. Ms Negrete’s participation was supported by the Pregraduate Mentorship Program of the Office of Academic Affairs of the University of California, Irvine, and the National Science Foundation Research Experience for Undergraduates Site Grant at the Program in Social Ecology, University of California, Irvine, Gary W.Evans, Principal Investigator.
Gambling cultures
56
2 Roe v. Wade 410 US 113 (1973) established this right through its reading of the US Constitution and the right to privacy. 3 On harm, see Feinberg 1985, 1986, 1990. 4 The Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gambling, and its director, economist William R.Eadington, have been the leaders in this effort for almost two decades. 5 Planned Parenthood v. Casey 1125 S. Ct 2791 (1992). 6 Drugs dropped as the most important policy item as the economy worsened in the late 1980s and early 1990s. 7 Bowers v. Hardwick 106 S. Ct 2841 (1986). 8 Comments of panel participants at the Eighth International Conference on Risk and Gambling, London. 9 For scholarly treatment, see Richards 1986; for popular treatment, see Brill 1990.
BIBLIOGRAPHY Abt, V., Smith, J.F. and Christiansen, E.M. (1985) The Business of Risk: Commercial Gambling in Mainstream America, Lawrence: University of Kansas Press. Administrative Office of the Courts, Judicial Council of California (1991) California Judicial System: Report of the Chief Justice, San Francisco: Administrative Office of the Courts. Altman, D. (1982) The Homosexualization of America, Boston: Beacon Press. Becker, H.S. (1963) Outsiders, New York: Free Press. Bolton, R. (ed.) (1992) Culture Wars: Documents from the Recent Controversies in the Arts, New York: The New Press. Bonnie, R. and Whitebread, C.H. II (1974) The Marihuana Conviction: A History of Marihuana Prohibition in the US, Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press. Brill, A. (1990) Nobody’s Business: Paradoxes of Privacy, Reading, MA: Addison Wesley. Bursik, R.J. Jr., and Grasmick, H.G. (1992) Neighborhoods and Crime: The Dimensions of Effective Community Control, New York: Lexington Books. Childress, S.A. (1991) ‘“Reel rape speech”: violent pornography and the politics of harm’, Law & Society Review 25(1):177–214. ——(1992) ‘Pornography, “serious rape”, and statistics: a reply to Dr Kutchinsky’, Law & Society Review 26(2):457–61. Christiansen, E.M. (1990) ‘US gaming handle up only 6% in ’89’, Gaming & Wagering Business 11(7):9–31. Clotfelter, C.T. and Cook, P.J. (1989) Selling Hope: State Lotteries in America, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Colasanto, D. (1990) ‘Widespread public opposition to drug legalization’, The Gallup Poll Monthly (Jan.): 2–8. Commission on the Review of the National Policy toward Gambling (1976) Gambling in America, Final Report of the Commission on the Review of the National Policy toward Gambling (Mann Commission), Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office. Committee on Homosexual Offences and Prostitution, Great Britain (1963) The Wolfenden Report, American edition, New York: Stein & Day. Comstock, G.D. (1991) Violence against Lesbians and Gay Men, New York: Columbia University Press. Cornell Law Project (1977) The Development of the Law of Gambling, 1776–1976, Washington, DC: National Institute of Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice. Currie, E. (1993) Reckoning: Drugs, the Cities and the American Future, New York: Hill & Wang. D’Emilio, J. (1983) Sexual Politics, Sexual Communities: The Making of a Homosexual Minority in the United States, 1940–1970, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
57
Devlin, P. (1965) The Enforcement of Morals, London: Oxford University Press. Dombrink, J. and Thompson, W.N. (1990) The Last Resort: Success and Failure in Campaigns for Casinos, Las Vegas: University of Nevada Press. Downs, D.A. (1989) The New Politics of Pornography, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Duster, T. (1970) The Legislation of Morality, New York: The Free Press. Eadington, W.R. (ed.) (1990) Indian Gaming and the Law, Reno: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming. Faderman, L. (1991) Odd Girls and Twilight Lovers: A History of Lesbian Life in Twentieth Century America, New York: Columbia University Press. Feinberg, J. (1985) Offense to Others: The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law, vol. 2, New York: Oxford University Press. ——(1986) Harm to Self: The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law, vol. 3, New York: Oxford University Press. ——(1990) Harmless Wrongdoing: The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law, vol. 4, New York: Oxford University Press. Frey, J.H. (1992) ‘Gambling on sport: policy issues’, Journal of Gambling Studies 8(4): 351–60. Geis, G. (1972) Not the Law’s Business?, Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office. Goldman, M.S. (1981) Gold Diggers and Silver Miners: Prostitution and Social Life on the Comstock Lode, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Greek, C.E. and Thompson, W. (1991) ‘Antipornography crusades and religious fundamentalism: a comparison of the United States and the United Kingdom during the 1980s’, Paper presented at the 50th Annual Meeting of the American Society of Criminology, San Francisco (20–23 Nov.). Greenberg, D.F. (1988) The Construction of Homosexuality, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Grinspoon, L. and Bakalar, J.B. (1976) Cocaine: A Drug and its Social Evolution, New York: Basic Books. Gurstein, R. (1991) ‘Misjudging Mapplethorpe: the art scene and the obscene’, Tikkun 6:70–7. Gusfield, J. (1963) Symbolic Crusade: Status Politics and the American Temperance Movement, Urbana: University of Illinois Press. Guskind, R. (1991) ‘Casino round the bend’, National Journal 37:2205–9. Hart, H.L.A. (1963) Law, Liberty, and Morality, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Harvard Law Review Editors (1990) Sexual Orientation and the Law, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Hawkins, G. and Zimring, F.E. (1988) Pornography in a Free Society, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Himmelstein, J.L. (1983) The Strange Career of Marihuana, Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. ——(1990) To the Right: The Transformation of American Conservatism, Berkeley: University of California Press. Humphry, D. (1991) Final Exit, Eugene, OR: The Hemlock Society. Hunter, J.D. (1991) Culture Wars: The Struggle to Define America, New York: Basic Books. Hunter, N.D. and Rubenstein, W.B. (eds) (1992) AIDS Agenda: Emerging Issues in Civil Rights, New York: The New Press. Inciardi, J.A. and McBride, D.C. (1991) ‘The case against legalization’, in J.A.Inciardi (ed.) The Drug Legalization Debate, Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications. Jacobs, J.B. (1990) ‘Who’s going to mind the government drugstore?’ Los Angeles Times (20 March): B7. Jenness, V. (1993) Making It Work: The Prostitutes’ Rights Movement in Perspective, Hawthorne, NY: Aldine de Gruyter. Kadish, S. (1967) ‘The crisis of overcriminalization’, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 374:157–70. Kamisar, Y. (1991) ‘An unraveling of morality’, New York Times (5 Nov.): A15. Kaplan, H.R. (1984) ‘The social and economic impact of state lotteries’, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 474:91–106.
Gambling cultures
58
Kaplan, J. (1970) Marijuana: The New Prohibition, New York: World Publishing. ——(1983) The Hardest Drug: Heroin and Public Policy, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Kimmel, M.S. (ed.) (1990) Men Confront Pornography, New York: Crown. Kleiman, M.A.R. (1992) Against Excess, New York: Basic Books. Kutchinsky, B. (1992) ‘The politics of pornography speech’, Law & Society Review 26(2): 447–55. Lindesmith, A.R. (1965) The Addict and the Law, Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Luker, K. (1984) Abortion and the Politics of Motherhood, Berkeley: University of California Press. Marotta, T. (1981) The Politics of Homosexuality, Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. Marty, M. and Appleby, S. (1992) The Glory and the Power: The Fundamentalist Challenge to the Modern World, Boston: Beacon Press. Meeker, J.W., Dombrink, J. and Geis, G. (1985) ‘State law and local ordinances in California barring discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation’, University of Dayton Law Review 10:745–65. Mill, J.S. (1956 [1859]) On Liberty, Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill. Musto, D. (1973) The American Disease: Origins of Narcotic Control, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Nadelmann, E.A. (1991) ‘The case for legalization’, in J.A.Inciardi (ed.) The Drug Legalization Debate, Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications. Packer, H.L. (1968) The Limits of the Criminal Sanction, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Paglia, C. (1991) ‘The beautiful decadence of Robert Mapplethorpe: a response to Rochelle Gurstein’, Tikkun 6:77–81. Pertschuk, M. and Shopland, D.R. (eds) (1989) Major Local Smoking Ordinances in the United States, National Institutes of Health Publication 90–479. Pivar, D.J. (1973) Purity Crusade, Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. Ranulf, S. (1964) Moral Indignation and Middle-Class Psychology, New York: Schocken Books. Reuter, P. (1992) ‘Hawks ascendant: the punitive trend of American drug policy’, Daedalus 121(3):15–52. Richards, D.A. J. (1986) Toleration and the Constitution, New York: Oxford University Press. Rose, I.N. (1980) ‘The legalization and control of casino gambling’, Fordham Law Review 8:245– 300. ——(1991) ‘The rise and fall of the third wave: gambling will be outlawed in forty years’, in W.R.Eadington and J.Cornelius (eds) Gambling and Public Policy: International Perspectives, Reno: Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gambling: 65–86. ——(1992) ‘The future of Indian gaming’, Journal of Gambling Studies 8(4):383–99. Schur, E.H. (1965) Crimes without Victims, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. ——(1980) The Politics of Deviance: Stigma Contests and the Uses of Power, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. ——and Bedau, H.A. (1974) Victimless Crimes: Two Sides of a Controversy, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Segal, L. and McIntosh, M. (eds) (1992) Sex Exposed: Sexuality and the Pornography Debate, London: Virago Press. Shilts, R. (1987) And the Band Played On: Politics, People and the AIDS Epidemic, New York: Penguin Books. ——(1993) Conduct Unbecoming: Lesbians and Gays in the US Military, Vietnam to the Persian Gulf, New York: St Martin’s Press. Skogan, W. (1990) Disorder and Decline, New York: The Free Press. Skolnick, J.H. (1968) ‘Coercion to virtue: the enforcement of morals’, Southern California Law Review 41:588–641. ——(1978) House of Cards: Legalization and Control of Casino Gambling, Boston: Little, Brown. ——(1988) ‘The social transformation of vice’, Law and Contemporary Problems 51: 9–29. ——(1992) ‘Rethinking the drug problem’, Daedalus 121(3):133–49.
Gambling and the legalisation of voice
59
——and Dombrink, J. (1978) ‘The legalization of deviance’, Criminology 16(2): 193–208. Sternlieb, G. and Hughes, J.W. (1983) The Atlantic City Gamble, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Sullivan, R (1993) ‘An army of the faithful’, New York Times Magazine (26 April): 33–5, 40–4. Symanski, R. (1981) The Immoral Landscape: Female Prostitution in Western Societies, Toronto: Butterworths. Tribe, L.H. (1990) Abortion: The Clash of Absolutes, New York: W.W.Norton. Vila, B.J. (1993) ‘Is the war on drugs an example of a runaway cultural process?’, in P. B.Kraska (ed.) Altered States of Mind: Critical Observations of the Drug War, New York: Garland Publishing. Volberg, R.A. and Steadman, H.J. (1992) ‘Accurately depicting pathological gamblers: policy and treatment implications’, Journal of Gambling Studies 8(4):401–12. Vorenberg, J. (1991) ‘Going gently, with dignity’, New York Times (5 Nov.): A15. Walkowitz, J.R. (1980) Prostitution and Victorian Society: Women, Class, and the State, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Weitzer, R. (1991) ‘Prostitutes’ rights in the United States: the failure of a movement’, The Sociological Quarterly 32(1):23–41. Williams, L. (1989) Hard Core: Power, Pleasure, and the ‘Frenzy of the Visible’, Berkeley: University of California Press. Wills, G. (1992) ‘The born-again Republicans’, New York Review of Books (24 Sept.). Zurcher, L.A., Jr and Kirkpatrick, R.G. (1976) Citizens for Decency: Antipornography Crusades as Status Defense, Austin: University of Texas Press.
3 SOCIAL EVIL OR SOCIAL GOOD? Lotteries and state regulation in Australia and the United States Wendy Selby
At a time when gaming and betting were thought to be immoral and socially threatening, the Queensland government owned and operated a lucrative and popular lottery, the Golden Casket Art Union. This lottery began in 1916 when the Queensland Patriotic Committee, a non-profit charitable organisation, sought permission to conduct a lottery for their soldier repatriation fund. So successful was this fund-raising activity that another four Caskets were held over the following three years to raise money for victims of the war. In 1919 the Home Office1 approved the use of another Casket to assist the Hospital for Sick Children in Brisbane, and in June 1920 the Queensland government decided to take over the Golden Casket Art Union and place all profits into the newly created Motherhood, Child Welfare and Hospital Fund. Today the Golden Casket continues to provide the state government with a much-needed source of revenue. Operating a lottery in 1920 was highly controversial. Lotteries, once popular fundraisers with governments in the Middle Ages, had been outlawed in most countries since the nineteenth century and were no longer seen as an area of enterprise suitable for governments. Attempts by private entrepreneurs to operate lotteries were also subject to restrictive legislation. Britain outlawed lotteries in 1809 and the United States began prohibiting lotteries from 1833 (Wilson 1980:41; Clotfelter and Cook 1989:38). Agitation for anti-gambling legislation came from the revitalised evangelical movement and those wanting to impose middle-class values of savings and industry, and their influence was most pronounced in the United States (O’Hara 1988). However, lotteries have always been a popular form of working-class gambling and lotteries have been common throughout the world, with or without legal sanction (Abt et al. 1985; Charlton 1987). This chapter will consider the unique set of circumstances that made the state government of Queensland the first Australian government in the twentieth century to own and operate a lottery. A combination of six factors persuaded the Queensland government of 1920 that public outcry would be minimal and that the lottery would be popular. The lead taken by Queensland was innovative in the climate of the early twentieth century and its special Motherhood Fund was arguably the first of its kind in the world. The Golden Casket’s success as a source of revenue was closely watched by other governments both in Australia and overseas, so it is of historical interest to understand the circumstances that enabled this lottery to survive and prosper. Other early Australian lotteries will be discussed also, especially George Adams Tattersall’s lottery which began to operate publicly from 1881. Tattersall’s is unique because it is the only
Social evil or social good?
61
privately owned and operated lottery to survive the legislative restrictions introduced to control private enterprise involvement in lotteries in Australia. North American lotteries make an interesting comparison to Australian lotteries because their legalisation and proliferation have been quite recent. A brief analysis of the differences between Queensland’s Golden Casket and the first state lottery to operate in the United States in the twentieth century will be undertaken, as well as a general overview of lotteries in the United States. The dominance of Puritan values blocked the legalisation of lotteries in the United States far longer than most other western countries (Abt et al. 1985:191–7). In Australia, especially Queensland, ‘socialist’ state governments led by the Australian Labor Party (ALP) were keen to use a revenue source that did not require increasing income taxes, and were not blocked from doing so by federal policies and legislation, as were the state governments in the United States. Despite the importance of access and legitimacy as factors which influence participation, it will be shown that legislation banning lotteries does not necessarily mean that people were not enjoying the prospect of winning large amounts of money. The proliferation of illegal lotteries throughout the seventy-year ban on lotteries in the United States suggests that lotteries have been, and continue to be, one of the most popular working-class gambling practices.
OUTLAWING LOTTERIES Lotteries were popular fund-raisers with governments in the Middle Ages, and the first lottery with cash prizes was held in Florence in 1530 (Wilson 1980:63). England’s first national lottery was sanctioned by Elizabeth I in 1567 and lotteries continued to flourish in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries (O’Hara 1988:5). Between 1769 and 1826, for instance, there were 128 state lotteries in England, yielding £35 million to government revenue (Wilson 1980:72). A series of lotteries was held to assist British settlement in the ‘New World’, principally Virginia. Revenues from the lotteries, provided at a critical time in Virginia’s early European colonisation, saved the venture from extinction (Wilson 1980:64). Lotteries continued to be popular in colonial America and were viewed as charitable contributions for public purposes (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:35). However, since the nineteenth century, lotteries as well as other forms of gaming and betting have been subject to increasing censure and control. During and immediately after the Industrial Revolution, the revitalised evangelical movement and the establishment of the industrial work discipline by the middle classes together transformed traditional leisure and recreation in many countries such as England and the United States. Gaming and betting, previously tolerated and even encouraged as a form of recreation, came to be seen not only as immoral but also as a threat to individual and national efficiency (Dixon 1991:63). According to Dixon (1991), gambling, along with alcohol and ‘idleness’, was regarded as having damaging social consequences for both the individual and the community as a whole. Legislation was introduced world-wide to ban most forms of gambling, and the lottery, a particularly popular working-class gaming activity, was specifically targeted by the legislators in the early nineteenth century. Lotteries offered the possibility of a large return for a small investment and it was feared that sudden windfalls to the lower classes
Gambling cultures
62
would undermine the middle-class value system of savings and industry (O’Hara 1988). Lotteries were outlawed in England in 1809 and in the United States from 1833. Most other lotteries held in Europe were banned throughout the nineteenth century. In Australia, reformers had less impact upon gambling legislation. In the Australian colonies, the middle classes were small and lacking in political and cultural influence, while the Churches were preoccupied with educational and sectarian issues. Gambling reform movements were unable to win enough support to transform the widespread gaming and betting practices of the convicts and other immigrants, allowing gambling to be widely accepted in nineteenth-century Australian society (O’Hara 1988:28). Because Australian governments were more tolerant of gambling practices, it is often argued today that Australians are a nation of gamblers (Macintyre 1986:65; Ward 1958:34). However, during the anti-gambling crusades in other countries gambling practices continued, even where there was strict anti-gambling legislation such as the United States (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:39; Dixon 1991:321). Illegal lotteries were common in both England and the United States. For instance, a British Royal Commission investigating lotteries and betting in 1932–33 found that prohibition had failed to prevent gambling; in fact, gambling had greatly increased (Dixon 1991:320–1). As with most intrusive social legislation, prescriptions do not necessarily equate with practices. Despite Australia’s comparatively liberal approach to gaming and betting (McMillen and Eadington 1986), lotteries remained controversial because they are a highly visible and accessible form of gambling. Those forms of gambling which were legalised in Australia, such as totalisators, were strictly controlled not only in procedure, but also in the physical space in which the gambling operated. Lotteries, on the other hand, were conducted in areas frequented by the general population and open to all who could afford to buy a ticket. This made lotteries more suspect in their potential to attract both more clientele and criminal behaviour. Australian colonial governments may have been more tolerant of gaming and betting than other jurisdictions but they wanted it removed from the public eye. All colonies between 1876 and 1897 enacted legislation designed to stop gambling in public spaces (O’Hara 1988:115). The first known attempt to organise a state lottery in Australia was in 1844, when the New South Wales Legislative Council proposed a lottery to save the Bank of Australia. The idea was scrapped only because legislative changes to hold the lottery required approval from Britain (O’Hara 1988:41–2). The imperial government was no longer prepared to sanction an activity now seen by British authorities to be immoral. Although Australian colonial governments were unable to hold lotteries, other forms of mass gambling were beginning to appear, including sweepstake consultations and land lotteries. Sweepstakes, lotteries based on the results of horse-races, were an innovative way of sidestepping laws forbidding games of chance and they became very popular in Australia from the 1870s (O’Hara 1988:77; Wilson 1980:28). The first public sweep was held in Sydney in 1881 by the most successful gambling entrepreneur of this period, George Adams. Adams’s business was based at his famous Tattersall’s Hotel in Sydney and until 1881 Adams restricted sales of tickets to members of his club (Wilson 1980:28– 46).2 It was the growth of sweeps beyond the boundaries of clubs and into the public sphere that intensified anti-gambling reformers’ criticisms of lotteries and forced the New South
Social evil or social good?
63
Wales government to outlaw sweeps, consultations and other games of chance in 1891. Adams and other sweepstake entrepreneurs moved their activities to Queensland, where it was thought there would be less opposition to sweeps. It was not long, however, before the Queensland government introduced the Suppression of Gambling Bill which aimed to prevent private gambling entrepreneurs from operating by defining sweepstakes as a form of lottery. The passing of this bill in 1895 forced Adams to move to Tasmania, where the state government allowed him to operate by post, after paying £10,000 for a licence. Despite this move, Adams’s successful business continued to attract controversy and obstructive government legislation. Wilson (1980) argues that no government was more active in its attempts to suppress Tattersall’s (as Adams’s business was known) than the federal government after 1901. The introduction of the 1901 Postal Act gave the federal government the right to refuse to handle or deliver mail. This began a thirty-year battle between Tattersall’s and the Postmaster-General who, in an effort to prevent the lottery from operating anywhere in Australia, blacklisted not only Tattersall’s mail, but also any business considered to be acting as an agent. Despite government obstruction, Tattersall’s survived to become Australia’s only privately operated lottery, with a profitable, state-protected monopoly in Victoria and Tasmania. In the early twentieth century every state other than Tasmania attempted to prevent Tattersall’s agents from operating. The South Australian government even made it an offence to be found in possession of a Tattersall’s ticket (Wilson 1980:153). In 1930 the Commonwealth postal ban was lifted, allowing Tattersall’s to operate interstate more successfully. In 1953 the Victorian government invited Tattersall’s to operate in the state and the business moved from Hobart to Melbourne in 1954, where it remains today. The move was a result of Tattersall’s fears of the Victorian government starting a state lottery coinciding with the Tasmanian government’s proposal to raise its lottery tax (Wilson 1980:186–91). Victorians were Tattersall’s major customers and the trustees decided the move was in the best interests of the company. This was a political coup for Victoria as it gained both a reputable operator and a new state tax. Tasmania responded predictably and initially banned Tattersall’s from operating in the state and attempted to start another lottery in 1954. The subsequent failure of the lottery forced Tasmania to allow Tattersall’s once again to operate legally in the state. Government encouragement of lotteries in the 1950s was a far cry from the situation in earlier decades. At the turn of the century no Australian state dared to operate a lottery because of the general fear of the moral implications of such an enterprise. Yet in 1920 one state dared to take the plunge. In doing so, the Queensland government stumbled upon a ‘sure bet’ with the Golden Casket Art Union.
QUEENSLAND’S GOLDEN CASKET If people must have a gamble, they might as well have a gamble on something that will do the community some good instead of on something that will make some private exploiter rich. At least one has contributed a few shillings to help the institutions along. (Hanlon 1938:1126)
Gambling cultures
64
Edward Hanlon, Queensland’s Secretary for Health and Home Affairs, was referring to the Golden Casket Art Union, the state government’s lottery. There are six factors that together explain the unique circumstances which led to the Queensland government owning and operating a lottery in 1920, a time when gambling was seen by many to be highly immoral and socially threatening. Desperate for post-war reconstruction and welfare programmes, the government was able to ‘purify’ the profits of gambling by using the money to finance an extensive state-operated maternal and infant welfare scheme. It was an ingenious way of silencing gambling opponents, conceding to popular demand, and solving the problem of growing demand for government assistance in health and hospital facilities. To understand why the Queensland government owned and operated a lottery before any other Australian government in the twentieth century, one needs to understand first the objectives of the Queensland branch of the ALP and its commitment at the time to state enterprises and the nationalisation of health. Labor was elected to power in 1915 and, with the exception of one term (1929–32), held office until 1957. In its early years the government was vigorously reformist, under the leaderships of Thomas Ryan (1915– 19) and Edward Theodore (1919–25). The reformist socialist philosophy of the government was clearly articulated at its biennial state conventions, when policies and issues of concern were debated. At the 1910 Labor-in-Politics convention the President of Labor’s central political executive, David Bowman, declared his firm belief in the principle of state socialism and the party’s aim for ‘every man and woman to be freed from the system of wage slavery’ (Bowman 1910:11). Once in power, the Labor government introduced a number of social reforms, such as making workers’ compensation compulsory, tightening laws governing industrial accidents and starting several state enterprises, including a state cannery, state butcheries and cattle stations.3 The government believed that only the state could be guaranteed to operate key industries fairly in the interests of the general public. Since 1905 Labor had been committed to the nationalisation of public and charitable hospitals, and it was of great concern to the rank and file members that this was not achieved after the party came to power in 1915 (Jordan 1980:314). Most hospitals in Queensland survived by voluntary subscriptions, with some assistance in the form of government endowments. It was estimated, however, that another £250,000 per year was needed to nationalise these hospitals, an amount far beyond the financial capabilities of the government in 1919. Lack of funds to carry out an important plank of the Labor Party’s platform was a constant source of embarrassment to the government. Labor had found that, once in office, it had more pressing needs for its limited revenue. The opportunity to gain access to an additional source of funds from lotteries without increasing taxation levels must have seemed very attractive. A second influence on the government was its concern about the military vulnerability of the state. As well as Germany’s and Holland’s imperialist ambitions in the Pacific, Queensland feared an invasion from its northern neighbours, a fear which intensified with the First World War. Queensland was a large state of 670,500 square miles but the majority of residents lived within 200 miles of Brisbane, in the south. Much of the state was unpopulated, especially in the northern and western regions.4 The population was considered far below a level sufficient for the state to prosper, and underpopulation remained an issue for much of the twentieth century. Once it was established that a white
Social evil or social good?
65
race could survive in the tropics, the Labor government was committed to encouraging settlement in the more remote regions (Cilento 1961–62:922).5 However, decentralisation policies, including the provision of social and health services, placed an additional drain on the public purse. In addition to these regional concerns, the Queensland government, together with other states, was alarmed about the declining birth rate, which had been steadily decreasing since the 1890s (Quiggin 1988:19–20).6 A federally paid maternity allowance of £5 for every birth after 1912 had done little to encourage women to have larger families. As it was a common view that better medical and hospital facilities would decrease maternal and infant mortality and encourage women to have more children, and as Queensland was in no position financially to provide these services in 1920, the additional source of funds was considered a ‘blessing’. This was the third factor which precipitated the decision to take over the lottery. A fourth and very important factor for the government lottery was the financial crisis of 1920, known today as ‘the Queensland loans affair’. At the time, all Australian state governments were dependent upon London financiers for loans for developmental works and special works requiring extensive capital outlay. Since 1915 the Queensland Labor government’s socialist policies had been monitored with concern by the propertied classes, both within the state and abroad (Cochrane 1989). The wartime European turmoil and the civil war in Russia only intensified their mistrust of socialism and the Labor Party. The final straw for Queensland’s capitalists was the passing of the Land Act Amendment Act in 1920, which enabled Labor to increase pastoral rents from 12 to 59 shillings per square mile. When the Premier of Queensland, Edward (Red Ted) Theodore, left for London in March 1920 to raise finance for the state, a delegation of three of Queensland’s ‘oldest active conservative men of influence’ also left for London (Cochrane 1989:7). The Labor government was seen as a threat to capital, and the conservatives aimed to bring down the government by convincing London to impose an economic blockade on Queensland. This blockade, which lasted until 1924, was without precedent in the history of Australia and its effect on Queensland was disastrous. Never before had an Australian state been refused loans from London. A recession, increased unemployment, forced retrenchments and the abandonment of many government schemes, including the state’s proposed steel works, were directly attributable to the blockade (Cochrane 1989:141–5). It was no coincidence, therefore, that the government’s decision to take over the Golden Casket was made within a month of the blockade being imposed. The government desperately needed funds and each Casket which had been held by the Queensland Patriotic Committee had yielded a profit of £7,300. It was an opportunity for revenue that was too good to lose. The fifth factor that was conducive to a lottery was the influence of the Roman Catholic Church in Queensland politics and society and the more secular and liberal form of Protestantism in Australia. According to O’Farrell, Queensland was the most Catholic state in Australia, not just statistically but ‘in the sense that [Queensland] most readily and warmly accepted its Catholic citizens’ (O’Farrell 1977:307). Of the sixty-seven Labor members in the Legislative Assembly during the 1920s, 44 per cent were Catholics (MacGinley 1982:159). Catholics exercised a disproportionate political influence in Queensland and, during the Ryan leadership in particular, many Catholics were promoted
Gambling cultures
66
into key positions in the public service (Fitzgerald 1984:11–14). The large Catholic sector of the Labor government and public service helped enable the lottery to proceed despite concern for its supposed immoral influence. Because lotteries both in Queensland and in southern states were popular with the working classes and because Australian Catholicism was based on working-class alignments and cultural values, the Catholic Church was not opposed to gambling per se (O’Hara 1988:132). The influential Archbishop of Queensland, James Duhig, supported the Golden Casket, claiming that ‘if a man had money to risk, neither he [n]or any one else could condemn him as doing a moral wrong’ (Duhig 1933). Finally, the Golden Casket owed both its inception and its operation during the first fifteen years to a key bureaucrat in the Home Office, Charles Chuter. Chuter joined the Queensland public service in 1898, rising through the ranks to become Assistant Under Secretary of the Home Office in 1922 and Under Secretary in 1935. In 1917 the government took over the finances of the Brisbane General Hospital from the hospital’s voluntary committee and Chuter, at that time Chief Clerk of the Home Office, was given responsibility for the hospital’s financial administration. This began a long involvement between Chuter and Queensland’s health and hospital administration. Government records held in the Queensland State Archives document Chuter’s astute business skills and suggest that Chuter was responsible for organising and implementing Queensland’s famous public hospital system. No person in the Home Office was more likely to have understood the government’s financial predicament in 1920. All correspondence from hospital committees requesting financial assistance was directed to Chuter. One hospital in particular, the Hospital for Sick Children in Brisbane, had for years been pleading with the government for help. So desperate was the children’s hospital for funds that the committee threatened to resign if no help from the government was forthcoming.7 The profits of the sixth Casket were used by Chuter in 1919 as a one-off solution to the hospital’s relentless pleas for financial assistance. In doing so, Chuter stumbled across an easy solution for the Labor government’s financial problems. Although it is not known who approached the government in 1920 with the plan for owning and operating the lottery, Chuter was most likely to have recommended the takeover. Once the government assumed responsibility for the Golden Casket, Chuter remained its key administrator and directed the spending of all the Casket’s profits for the next fifteen years. The most contrived aspect of the policy was the plan selected for the use of the Golden Casket Art Union’s profits. Gambling was a highly controversial issue in the 1920s, as the brief history just noted has shown. It would appear that the ALP wanted the state to benefit from lottery profits (which, as a party, Labor did not morally oppose), but at the same time had to be respectful of the wider community’s suspicions of gambling practices. British and American state lotteries of earlier centuries had set a precedent of using lottery profits for funding community projects. To ensure that the profits would be used on the most ‘sanitised’ community project, it was decided to direct all of the Golden Casket’s profits into financing maternal and infant welfare facilities. Improved facilities for mothers and babies was one of the most popular social reforms for Australian governments at this time, ‘motherhood’ being the most highly esteemed of female occupations.8
Social evil or social good?
67
So that the public could see the good use to which the Golden Casket’s profits were put, a special Motherhood, Child Welfare and Hospital Fund was created. Instead of adding the profits from the lottery to general revenue, all profits went to this fund. Furthermore, the State Treasury had no control over the fund; the Home Office was completely responsible for its distribution. The Motherhood Fund’s principal aim was to finance the building of maternity hospitals and baby clinics throughout Queensland, and Chuter began work on drafting the Maternity Bill to implement this plan in 1920. The Maternity Act was passed in 1922. Within three years, fifty-seven fully equipped maternity hospitals and ten baby clinics had been built, as well as a training centre established in Brisbane for infant welfare nurses. By 1938, ninety-four maternity hospitals and more than 100 baby clinics were in operation. The Motherhood Fund completely financed this extensive building programme. Any remaining profits of the Casket were used as special grants to hospitals. As the Golden Casket increased in popularity (and profitability), the Fund was increasingly the major revenue source for Labor’s public hospital scheme. Throughout the 1920s the Labor government repeatedly emphasised the ‘noble cause’ on which the profits were spent and, because of the popularity of the policy, were able to use the maternal and infant welfare programme to their political advantage. The Maternity Act was publicised as being ‘the noblest legislation ever placed on the Statute book’, responsible for ‘saving the lives of thousands of young Queenslanders and their mothers’ (Australian Labor Party 1926). The opening of every maternity ward or baby clinic was a gala occasion, with politicians making numerous speeches about Labor’s latest ‘monument to motherhood’ (Warwick Daily News 1939). The Casket’s profits neatly solved a number of problems confronting the government in 1920 and enabled them to provide a service widely thought to be important to the state. The government spent over £314,000 on maternity hospitals and baby clinics in the first ten years, and one Home Secretary, Edward Hanlon, stated clearly Labor’s feelings about the Golden Casket: ‘It was realised by the vast majority of citizens of the state that the mothers of the next generation, and the children being born in the world, were being given that idealistic treatment that only Casket funds have made an actuality’ (Hanlon 1933). The Golden Casket proved to be an enormous fund-raiser for Queensland. Initially tickets cost 5 shillings, each ticket holder hoping for the first prize of £5,000. The first Casket in 1916 took seventeen weeks to sell all the tickets, the second Casket took ten weeks and by 1922 a Casket was being drawn every three weeks. Each decade the lottery became more popular; by the 1940s there were drawings every few days. Every Casket made a profit of £7,300 for the Motherhood Fund and £1,250 in state taxation (Queensland Parliamentary Papers 1925).9 In its first year of government management the Casket made a net profit of £190,224, excluding taxation. After ten years of operation, £2,298,110 had been placed in the Motherhood Fund (Queensland Government, ABC of Queensland Statistics 1936:137). The Golden Casket Art Union was so popular that, in 1933, the government began to run ‘mammoth’ lotteries, where the prize money was greatly increased. In 1933 an ordinary Casket sold 100,000 tickets with a first prize of £6,000. A ‘mammoth’ Casket issued 200,000 tickets and, depending on the price of the ticket, had a first prize of £20,000, £25,000 or £50,000.10 Initially these ‘mammoth’ lotteries had a specific fundraising purpose, such as the building of the Women’s Hospital in Brisbane. While most
Gambling cultures
68
tickets for the Golden Caskets were sold in Queensland (66 per cent) and New South Wales (31 per cent), the Casket began to attract a large international patronage after 1932 (Home Office 1923–30; Queensland Parliamentary Papers 1937). So successful was the Casket and so much a part of the Queensland way of life, that the government never bothered to change legislation which had banned the operation of lotteries in the state since 1895. The Premier, Thomas Ryan, ignored this legislation in 1916 when he granted the War Council permission to hold the first Casket. Ryan was an ardent anti-conscriptionist, a stance seen by some to be unpatriotic, and it is thought that Ryan was concerned that his patriotism would be further questioned if he refused the War Council permission to raise funds (Charlton 1987:190). It is also likely that because the Suppression of Gambling Act was only introduced to block private gambling enterprises, such as Tattersall’s, from operating in Queensland, it was not seen by Ryan as an obstacle to government involvement in lotteries. Chuter was well aware of the technical illegality of the government’s lottery in 1920 but he either decided to ignore the legal implications or was unable to convince his Minister, William McCormack, of the importance of changing the law. It was only in 1930, when a new government made numerous inquiries into the Casket’s and Chuter’s activities, that legislation was quickly added to the Vagrants, Gaming and Other Offences Bill, which was passed in 1931.11 After fifteen years of operation the Golden Casket was legalised.
ENSURING SUCCESS Despite the success of the Golden Casket and the shrewd tactics used by the government to minimise criticism, the lottery did attract some controversy. When the Queensland government took over the Golden Casket in 1920, it rekindled the arguments against gambling and against lotteries in particular. The Home Office had a difficult time in the early years of the Casket’s operation, both ensuring that the lottery was run without fraud and convincing the general public that all ticket-holders had a fair chance at first prize. In order to prevent corruption and fraud, the government established two levels of control. The first level was a special subdivision of government office staff, controlled by a government-appointed manager. Their task was the handling of all the administrative and clerical work of the lottery, including the distribution of tickets and prizes. As the Casket grew, so did its staff, and in 1934 there were 129 people working in this subdivision of the Home Office. The second level of control was the Golden Casket Committee, also appointed by the government. The committee’s role was to oversee the work of the manager, recommend changes in the running of the Casket, attend each drawing and to scrutinise the accounts. Each member of the Committee was carefully selected, with the Premier’s wife appointed as the first president. Chuter was a member of this committee for sixteen years and president from 1924 (Home Office 1920–39). To protect the committee from charges of corruption, an audit of the Casket’s operations was conducted each year by the Auditor-General’s Department, and any member of the general public could inspect the books at any time. Despite these safeguards the Casket had some problems. The first scandal involved the manager of the Casket, Archer Lucas. It is not clear from the surviving records what his alleged misdemeanours were. However, Theodore and Lucas had fought continuously for
Social evil or social good?
69
two years over errors in the Casket’s accounts and cheques not being properly signed (Home Office 1920–39). When Lucas took three months’ salary and was ‘absent without leave’ in 1922, he was sacked and quickly replaced by a new manager, William Noble. To avoid losing public trust, the government announced that Lucas had resigned due to war injuries. On another occasion two members of staff of the Home Office were caught trying to cheat the Casket and were tried and imprisoned (Home Office 1920–39). The most serious problem for the Golden Casket’s smooth operation concerned the method chosen for drawing the lottery. The committee had considered many possibilities and initially selected a ‘double draw’ system, involving two octagonal revolving barrels. One barrel contained 100,000 marbles numbered consecutively and the second barrel had 813 marbles, with the values of each prize stamped upon them. In a public hall in Brisbane, a marble was drawn from each barrel simultaneously by two people from the audience (generally children), with the number of the ticket winning the value of the prize shown on the second marble (Queensland Parliamentary Papers 1925). At the conclusion of each drawing the barrels were sealed by the government inspector, generally Chuter, and the seal was left intact until the next drawing. In 1931 the method of drawing was changed to one barrel only, with prizes being awarded in order of the draw. This change was in response to public demand that every ticket-holder’s marble should be in the barrel for the drawing of the first prize. Unfortunately the new system made fraud simpler, and the drawing of Casket number 325 attracted world-wide attention in 1932 when an attempt was made to rig the lottery. Despite scrutineers from the Home Office, the Auditor-General’s Department and the Golden Casket Committee having supervised the sealing of the barrel at the previous draw, the boy called from the front of the audience to draw the lottery was found to be holding a marble with the number 65764 stamped on it. The resulting inquiry revealed that a sub-accountant in the Home Office had stolen the marble, colluded with a friend who bought ticket number 65764 and used his son to sit in the audience at the draw (Truth 1932). The boy had intended to pretend that this marble was the first marble he had drawn from the barrel, thereby winning first prize. The government moved quickly to restore confidence in the lottery by calling for ideas for a new method of drawing prizes. The committee chose an imposing machine designed by a Brisbane engineer, John Lund, which had rotating discs inside tamper-proof compartments. With the state’s maternal and infant programme completely dependent on a minimum of twenty-six Caskets each year and a public hospital system increasingly dependent on state grants, the government could not afford any drop-off in ticket sales. The Lund machine appears to have restored public confidence because sales increased not only locally, but also overseas. This increased patronage was also assisted by the government’s actively pursuing clientele. So proud was the government of the Lund machine that public drawings were organised to coincide with the schedule of tourist ships in port. The government also went to great trouble and expense to take the machine to outback towns of Queensland for country drawings, so that ‘residents could witness first-hand the method of drawing, and are thus given a fitting answer to any adverse propaganda indulged in by people desirous of hampering the Golden Casket operations or injuring its reputation’ (Queensland Parliamentary Papers 1937). In January 1950, a Royal Commission was held to investigate another scandal surrounding the winning ticket of Casket number 1367. It was alleged that the winning
Gambling cultures
70
ticket had been sold after the Casket had been drawn to the manager of a firm that distributed Casket tickets interstate and overseas. Numerous questions were asked in Parliament, and the government chose three highly respectable members of the community to hold the Commission of Inquiry: a senior judge of the Supreme Court, the State President of the RSL (the Returned Sailors, Soldiers and Airmen’s Imperial League of Australia) and the Auditor-General. After two months of inquiry, the commissioners found no dishonest or improper practice by any person and concluded that the Lund machine was completely efficient and the audit of the accounts effectively performed (Queensland Parliamentary Papers 1951–52). These scandals were dealt with quickly and the Queensland Home Office generally kept the Casket running smoothly. The Protestant Churches of Queensland, however, remained critical of the Casket for many years although the reduced influence of Protestantism in Queensland kept the Churches’ criticisms from having any serious impact upon the Casket. One exception was in 1933 when the first ‘mammoth’ casket was held. This Casket was to help finance the building of the Women’s Hospital and, for an outlay of £1, ticket-holders had a chance of winning £25,000. The Protestant Churches were outraged. The Queensland Council of Churches claimed that the Golden Casket was an ‘evil’ practice, which discouraged industry, contradicted the principles of honest commerce, accentuated the uneven distribution of wealth, and added nothing thereto. It involved gambling for personal profit in the name of charity, and was therefore founded on contradictory motives. It promoted hypocrisy and destroyed the true spirit of charity and philanthropy. It was wrong to raise money to cure physical disease by means which fostered and encouraged an infinitely worse moral and social disease. (Council of Churches 1933)12 The Council designated 25 June 1933 as a day for all Church people to protest against the lottery. The government was forced to respond to this unprecedented attack. After hearing about the planned ‘day of protest’, the Home Secretary, Edward Hanlon, issued a statement saying that the Casket was not the emanation of wickedness, but ‘a mild investment with a profitable result for the state’s institutions of healing. Had it not been for the Casket and its funds, where would the money have come from?’ (Hanlon 1933). The only Church to declare publicly its support for the Casket was the Catholic Church. Archbishop Duhig made a plea for ‘sane reasoning’, and said ‘that he looked upon the holding of the lottery as an emergency means of raising funds for certain laudable purposes’ (Duhig 1933). Despite the day of protest, the Protestant Churches did not prevent either the Golden Casket’s ever-increasing popularity or the Queensland government’s willingness to provide a lottery service to generate revenue. Any time there appeared to be a slump in sales, the government devised a new form of lottery, such as the mammoth series, to stimulate interest. Since 1937 a publicity officer has been employed to promote the Golden Casket both locally and interstate. By 1947, £10 million had been collected from 1,140 Caskets, with over £9 million deposited in the government’s Fund and nearly £1 million collected in state taxation (Queensland Parliamentary Papers 1947). Profits from
Social evil or social good?
71
the lottery provided sorely needed funds for social services. Only in 1989 did the government divert the profit of the lottery to consolidated revenue. Despite other governments watching with interest, the Casket’s success as a source of government revenue did not entice other state governments to follow Queensland for many years. New South Wales, in 1931, was the next state government to run a lottery. It is likely that the depression forced the Labor Premier, Jack Lang, into approving a lottery to obtain revenues. Although Golden Casket agents were banned from operating in New South Wales, many residents purchased both Casket and Tattersall tickets by post. The loss of this gambling revenue at a time of great economic hardship tipped the scales for the Premier, whose personal aversion to lotteries had prevented earlier proposals for a lottery (Charlton 1987:195). Unlike Queensland, New South Wales directed the profits of their lottery into consolidated revenue, suggesting that by the 1930s lotteries had become a more acceptable form of government revenue in Australia, especially when legitimised as supporting a ‘worthy cause’. Western Australia followed in 1933, but this government was more timid in its approach and the temporary legislation permitting the state lottery came up for renewal every five years (Charlton 1987:197). Victoria did not loosen its restrictions on lotteries until 1953, when it invited Tattersall’s to operate in the state. South Australia was the last state to introduce lotteries for public funding, when it passed the Lottery Bill in 1966. With the exception of Tattersall’s operations in Victoria and Tasmania, an important distinction was made in Australia between government-operated lotteries and those of private entrepreneurs. As long as gambling profits were seen to be helping worthwhile causes and as long as the government had full control of its operations, governments appeared more willing to accept lotteries as an inevitable part of Australian society. Private gambling enterprises faced more censure, possibly because they were unable to ‘sanctify’ their lotteries and because a number of gambling businesses had been fraudulent, especially in the late nineteenth century, making governments wary of criminal involvement (Wilson 1980:44).13 The inconsistency of government attitudes towards lotteries is exemplified by the differing treatment by the Postmaster-General of the mail of Tattersall’s and the Golden Casket in the 1920s. Whereas Tattersall’s faced federal postal bans that severely interfered with the successful running of the lottery for many years, no action was taken against the delivery of Golden Casket letters, enabling the Queensland government to advertise publicly and to sell tickets by mail throughout Australia (Wilson 1980:173). Another reason for the success of the Golden Casket was that successive Queensland governments prohibited any private lottery enterprise from operating in the state after 1895. Hanlon and all Queensland Labor government proponents were completely supportive of their own lottery, believing it to be a harmless form of recreation, beneficial to the social services provided by the state. However, it was one thing to have gambling profits help state revenue, quite another for private businesses to prosper from gambling. Although Queenslanders could and did buy Tattersall’s tickets by post, private lotteries were not tolerated. Interestingly, despite its ‘free enterprise’ philosophy, private lotteries were also prohibited in the United States.
Gambling cultures
72
LOTTERIES IN THE UNITED STATES Because the legalisation of lotteries in the United States has been fairly recent, it is worth examining the differences between the United States and Australia. As discussed earlier, Australia’s smaller and less influential middle classes, together with the reduced involvement of the Churches in gambling issues, allowed gambling to become a popular social activity in the Australian colonies. By comparison, anti-gambling legislators had more influence and support in the United States and were successful in preventing lotteries from operating legally anywhere in the country for seventy years. In colonial America, state-sanctioned private lotteries were popular and common and used to finance all kinds of public works (Abt et al. 1985; Clotfelter and Cook 1989). These lotteries were organised by volunteers, usually public-spirited citizens, with all proceeds after the payment of prizes going to a specific public programme. Projects such as the building of highways, schools and hospitals and the supply and support to troops during the Revolution were funded by the profits of these lotteries (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:34). Churches were also the beneficiaries of state lotteries, with the exception of the Quakers who consistently opposed lotteries on religious grounds. For example, sixty lotteries were authorised by Pennsylvania between 1790 and 1833 to benefit various Church groups (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:36). Although there was some criticism of lotteries on moral grounds by the Churches, it was not until the early nineteenth century and the emergence of private lotteries for profit that controversy surrounding lotteries intensified. The increased demand for public infrastructure in the United States motivated more lottery authorisations in the nineteenth century, which in turn attracted the attention of private enterprise. Initially private firms started handling the selling of tickets, opening numerous lottery shops throughout the country. So successful were these enterprises that they began to operate their own lotteries and soon private lotteries outnumbered the volunteer state-sanctioned organisations (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:35–7). As found in Britain and to a lesser extent in Australia, increasing evidence of fraud and dishonesty, as well as concern about the immoral influence of gambling, prompted concern from middle-class social reformers in the United States and legislation prohibiting lotteries was slowly introduced in various states from 1833. By 1860 only three American states still allowed lotteries to operate legally. The Louisiana lottery was the last to survive prohibition, closing in 1894 when Congress passed a series of restrictions on the use of postal services to conduct lotteries (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:38). No legal, government-sponsored lottery existed in the United States from 1894 until 1964. There are many theories as to why lotteries were prohibited for seventy years, and it would appear that arguments similar to those voiced against gaming and betting in England and Australia were more effective and more widely held by the middle classes in the United States. Those in power maintained that the values of thrift and prudence were major components of ‘what made America great’, and successfully outlawed popular gambling practices, such as lotteries, long after other industrialised countries had permitted their operation (Abt et al. 1985:191–203). Lotteries, more than any other type of contemporary gaming and betting activity, were seen to most threaten Puritan values
Social evil or social good?
73
which dominated middle-class American attitudes in the nineteenth century. It was thought that individual rise to wealth and social respectability could only be achieved by honesty, diligence and frugality. It was only when there was a shift from a productive to a consumptive ethic in the middle of the twentieth century, with success measured by material possessions, that gambling both as an activity and as a form of state revenue was tolerated (Abt et al. 1985:194–200). The United States’ relatively prolonged intolerance of legal gambling contrasts sharply with Australia’s, where legislators were more discriminatory in their suppression of gaming and betting. It has already been shown that many Australian state governments, Queensland in particular, were able to justify their operation of lotteries by using the profits for worthwhile purposes. Furthermore, at the time when the Queensland government took over the Golden Casket, the ALP was driven by the ideals of reformist socialism which philosophically endorsed public ownership of major enterprises in the state. It is no coincidence that the next Australian state government to own and operate a lottery (New South Wales) was also an ALP government. The capacity for state government autonomy and control over gambling was greatly assisted in Australia by constitutional protection from federal interference. The US Congress, by contrast, passed a series of effective restrictions against states still operating lotteries in the late nineteenth century, prohibiting all mail referring to lotteries and all lottery activity in interstate commerce (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:38). In both Australia and the United States private lotteries were seen as a potential source of corruption and fraud, and were either tightly controlled or prevented from operating. The first state in the United States to reintroduce a lottery was New Hampshire in 1964. It is interesting to compare the organisation and circumstances of this lottery to Queensland’s Golden Casket. New Hampshire had few conventional means of raising state taxes and was heavily reliant upon alternative sources of finance, including excise taxes on tobacco, horse-racing and alcohol (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:142).14 Revenue for state-funded projects was scarce and the state ranked lowest in state aid to education. Like Queensland in 1920, the government was under considerable pressure to find other forms of revenue and lottery bills had been proposed as early as 1937. Also, New Hampshire had a disproportionately high percentage of Catholics and a relatively high percentage of foreign-born residents. This lessened the political and cultural influence of ‘conservative Yankee puritanism’ (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:142–3). Unlike Queensland’s, New Hampshire’s lottery was in fact a sweepstake. Federal gambling laws in the United States would have imposed a tax on wagering if the state had organised a conventional lottery. The state only organised two drawings a year, and towns within New Hampshire could vote to exclude sweepstake tickets being sold in their area. Due to the restrictions on purchasing tickets and the limited number of drawings, the lottery proved to be unpopular, with sales declining each year. In contrast, Queensland’s Golden Casket was a huge success because it more effectively met working-class needs both in cost and in accessibility, with the Queensland government running as many lotteries as there was demand for tickets. Furthermore, lottery prizes in Australia are tax-free, therefore having an immediate capacity to transform lives. New Hampshire’s sweepstake, although operating nearly fifty years after the Golden Casket began, was a very tentative state enterprise in comparison.
Gambling cultures
74
The second state to operate a lottery in the United States, New York in 1967, had similar problems to those of New Hampshire, although twelve drawings a year were permitted (Abt et al. 1985:56–7). Neither New Hampshire’s nor New York’s lotteries was very successful and it was not until 1970, when New Jersey’s state lottery started, that lotteries became highly profitable state enterprises in the United States. The New Jersey lottery better suited purchasers’ needs. Tickets were only 50 cents each, drawings were weekly and any convenient retail business was allowed to be a lottery outlet. Sales totalled US$73 million in six months (Abt et al. 1985:57). Since the early 1970s lotteries have proliferated in the United States, although by 1989 there were still only twenty-eight states operating lotteries. Along with other forms of gaming and betting, lotteries have a high profile in the United States today and, where they operate, are one of the major enterprises provided by state governments. Another feature of lotteries in the United States is the absence of private enterprise control. Although a number of states allow non-profit organisations to sell charity game tickets, every American state government which has legalised lotteries has sole right to provide lottery games within its borders (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:238). Private industry is only allowed to supply and retail the government’s lottery product. Admittedly, the state governments’ agreements with private enterprise are substantial, with most states allowing private firms to manage their lotteries for a generous fee. Nevertheless, the involvement of private enterprise in lotteries is limited. As in Australia, it is thought that government monopoly is the result of nineteenth-century scandals involving private lotteries (Abt et al. 1985:63). Most privately operated lotteries were tainted by fraud and corruption and governments moved quickly to ban their operations. The laws prohibiting private lotteries in the United States have never been revoked. Considering America’s predilection for free enterprise, this is remarkable. Despite the relatively late legalisation of lotteries and other forms of gaming and betting in the United States, gambling practices continued. Charity raffles and church bingo were popular during the seventy-year ban on lotteries and Americans were major customers of the Irish Sweepstakes, started in 1930 (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:38). The persistence of numerous forms of illegal gambling practices throughout this period also suggests that middle-class reformers never achieved hegemony. The two most popular illegal lottery games were called ‘policy’ (or ‘insurance’) and ‘numbers’. ‘Policy’ was attractive because betting was cheap; one simply gambled on drawn numbers in a fashion similar to lotto today. ‘Numbers’ was also cheap and easy to play, with patrons guessing combinations of three numbers being drawn daily (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:39–40). So popular are these and other illegal gaming and betting practices in the United States that they have continued after laws on gambling were loosened. For example, in 1976 the Federal Bureau of Investigation estimated that over US$45 billion was spent that year on illegal wagering (Abt et al. 1985:204).
LOTTERIES TODAY For a government to legalise a lottery for its own economic and political purposes in 1920 was unusual. Although gambling as a social activity was firmly established in the Australian colonies in the nineteenth century, lotteries have been controversial and
Social evil or social good?
75
subject to severe anti-gambling legislation since the nineteenth century. The Golden Casket survived after the First World War because of a number of unique factors, including the Labor government’s desperate financial situation and because Chuter shrewdly channelled the profits into the most respectable area of government spending of that era: mothers and babies. Queensland’s success in owning and operating a lottery prompted other state governments in Australia to follow suit from the 1930s. In the United States lotteries continued to be seen as the antithesis of Puritan values and the middle classes kept a tight rein on anti-gambling legislation until the 1960s. The widespread popularity of illegal lotteries and similar games throughout the twentieth century in the United States, however, suggests that the middle classes were not successful in eradicating gambling practices or winning populist support. Gambling which requires small, frequent outlays of cash and where tickets are easily procured, attracts working-class clientele irrespective of the law. Today lotteries continue to be popular. In the 1990/91 financial year, Queensland’s total lottery sales were A$518.8 million, with a profit of A$152 million making a substantial contribution to state revenue (Courier-Mail 1991). In the United States, lotteries are the most profitable public enterprise owned by governments and rank second behind higher education as the most important state product sold to the public (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:238). By 1991 thirty-four states owned lotteries which together attracted 90 million players and US$20.6 billion in ticket sales that year (Time International 1991:74). Despite the introduction of other, more technically sophisticated games such as machine gaming and casinos, lotteries have continued to be well patronised, principally because lotteries have adapted their product to meet changing demand. Marketing attractions include the introduction of innovative games and huge ‘jackpot’ prizes which offer a windfall which will change people’s lives. According to Clotfelter and Cook (1989:53–4), lottery players today want more ‘play value’, more involvement than the simple, passive act of buying a ticket. In response, lotteries now offer instant ‘scratch-off’ games which offer not only simulated play value, but also immediacy in results.15 The popularity of instant rub-off games is reflected in Queensland’s Golden Casket for 1990/91 where sales for ‘scratch-its’, as they are called, rose 22 per cent while ordinary A$2 lottery ticket sales dropped by 18 per cent (Courier-Mail 1991). The enticement of becoming an instant millionaire has been another important factor in the continuing popularity of lotteries. It is estimated that more than 3,000 people in the United States have become ‘overnight’ millionaires as a result of lottery wins (Time International 1991:74).16 Governments’ commitments to lotteries today raise questions about the contradictory role of the state. In Queensland in 1920 it was thought that if people are going to gamble, then the government might as well benefit from the enterprise. At the time, this attitude towards gambling, and lotteries in particular, was distinctive although since then it has become common in other jurisdictions. As Dombrink has argued in the preceding chapter, other ‘vices’, such as prostitution and alcohol, have had neither unambiguous government sanction nor government encouragement. What is the special nature of lotteries that makes them so acceptable as a revenue source, then and now? The Queensland government in 1920 justified the takeover and use of the Golden Casket for the same reasons that the lottery was popular with the general public: wagers were small,
Gambling cultures
76
the profits went to a worthwhile cause and the government was thought to be better able to control the potential for criminal behaviour. The growth in state lotteries today and the extensive advertising campaigns used by governments to attract both new players and old players to spend more raises new questions about the role of the state in gambling enterprises. For instance, what criteria should governments use to evaluate the performance of their lotteries in the 1990s: on the basis of profit or by considering some notion of general public interest, or both? This is a perplexing, yet important, question in the light of recent leaps in the amount of per capita spending on legalised gaming and betting, especially in Australia where in 1991 per capita gambling was 60 per cent higher than in the United States (The Bulletin 1991:80). If, as the evidence suggests, people gamble more when there is a larger variety of ways to gamble, then governments must accept their partial responsibility for creating the problems (as well as the pleasures) associated with the current booming gambling industry. The existence of organisations such as Gamblers Anonymous (in Australia) and the Council on Compulsive Gambling (in the United States) highlights some of the social and behavioural problems resulting from the growing number of gambling choices. However, while people continue to support lotteries for whatever reasons, governments are likely to want a piece of the action. For better or for worse, lottery profits have become an essential and comparatively reliable component of state revenue.
NOTES 1 The Home Office in Queensland was based on the British model and was responsible for all domestic affairs of the state. In 1920 this included health, hospitals, police, prisons, outdoor relief, the register-general, electoral registration and Aborigines. The principal public servant of this department was called the Under Secretary and the Minister was called the Home Secretary. In 1935 the Home Office changed its name to the Department of Health and Home Affairs. 2 Wilson points out that there were many sweepstake clubs operating in the 1870s and 1880s, not all of them honestly. Many clubs disappeared before the draw was held. 3 Despite many state socialist achievements, a number of government reforms were blocked in the Legislative Council (the Upper House). Abolishing the Council was the first plank of the ALP’s policies and they were successful in 1922. 4 In 1914, Queensland’s population, excluding Aborigines, was 676, 707. By 1926, the population had increased to 875, 187 but averaged only 1.32 persons per square mile (Queensland Government, ABC of Queensland Statistics 1916, 1928). 5 In 1909 the Commonwealth government established the Institute of Tropical Medicine in Townsville, in northern Queensland. Its major concern was to investigate whether or not white settlers could colonise tropical Australia. 6 Quiggin notes that birth rates had been declining since the 1860s, but Queensland’s decline was erratic until the 1890s. The most famous inquiry into the declining birth rate in Australia was conducted in New South Wales in 1903–4. In 1916 Queensland decided to hold an inquiry and went so far as to appoint a commission to investigate reasons for Queensland’s declining birth rate. For unknown reasons, the inquiry was never undertaken (Home Office 1916). 7 The ladies’ committee was unable to raise enough money to meet the ever-increasing demand for the hospital’s services. In desperation they finally resigned in 1921 and the government took over the running of the hospital in 1924, along with all hospitals in south-east Queensland.
Social evil or social good?
77
8 The glorification of motherhood in early twentieth-century Australia is a complex issue, inextricably linked with concerns about the declining birth rate, eugenicist debates, and patriarchal definitions of a woman’s role in life. Marriage was deemed an essential part of every truly feminine woman’s life plan, and motherhood was designated the central content of feminine work (Matthews 1984:112, 174). 9 In 1921 the government increased the price of a ticket to 5s 3d, with 3d per ticket being used to pay state income tax. Federal tax was also subtracted until 1924. Total profit varied slightly from the 1930s but amounted to approximately 23 per cent of total revenue. 10 The value of these prizes at the time was enormous, considering a skilled tradesman’s wages was approximately £300–500 per year. 11 The Country and Progressive National government, which served for three years between 1929 and 1932, was very distrustful of Chuter’s power in the Home Office. They held a Royal Commission in 1930 which amounted to little more than an outright attack on Chuter and a removal of many of his duties on committees. In 1932 the new Labor government, which fully supported Chuter’s work, reinstated most of his duties. 12 The Council of Churches was an affiliated group composed of Anglican, Presbyterian, Methodist, Congregational, Church of Christ and Baptist Churches and the Salvation Army temples. 13 Continued government tolerance of Tattersall’s is attributable not only to the company’s apparent integrity and honesty, but also to the use of some of its profits for charitable purposes. For instance, in the period 1977–80, over ninety charities received donations in excess of A$1,000 annually, in addition to hundreds of smaller donations in the same period (Wilson 1980:208–10). 14 New Hampshire had neither a sales tax nor an income tax. 15 The ‘scratch-off’ ticket has a combination of numbers, letters or words hidden under a vinyl covering. Scratching off the covering shows whether or not a prize has been won. 16 The life-altering effect of a large lottery win in the United States is dampened by the common practice of the prize being paid in twenty annual taxable instalments. Australian lottery winnings are paid in a single lump sum and are exempt from both state and federal taxation.
BIBLIOGRAPHY Abt, V., Smith, J. and Christiansen, E. (1985) The Business of Risk: Commercial Gambling in Mainstream America, Lawrence: University of Kansas Press. Australian Labor Party Queensland Branch (1926) ‘Mothers of Queensland your duty is clear’, pamphlet, P 324.7 MOT, John Oxley Library, Brisbane. Bowman, D. (1910) ‘President’s opening address’, Queensland Labor-in-Politics Convention, Official Record of Proceedings, Brisbane: The Worker Newspaper. Charlton, P. (1987) Two Flies up a Wall: The Australian Passion for Gambling, Sydney: Methuen Haynes. Cilento, R. (1961–62) ‘Medicine in Queensland, Part 2, 1894–1962’, The Royal Historical Society of Queensland 6(4):908–41. Clotfelter, C. and Cook, P. (1989) Selling Hope: State Lotteries in America, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Cochrane, T. (1989) Blockade: The Queensland Loans Affair 1920 to 1924, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press. Council of Churches (1933) ‘To dishonesty. Casket provokes churches’ statement’, The Mail, Brisbane (23 June). Courier-Mail (1991) ‘Casket boom as gambling hits $2 billion’, Brisbane (28 Dec.).
Gambling cultures
78
Dixon, D. (1991) From Prohibition to Regulation: Bookmaking, Anti-Gambling, and the Law, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Duhig, J. (1933) ‘Matter solely for the individual’, Courier, Brisbane (26 June). Fitzgerald, R. (1984) A History of Queensland from 1915 to the 1980s, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press. Hanlon, E. (1933) ‘Queensland minister replies to church criticism of Golden Casket’, Smiths Weekly, Sydney (10 June). ——(1938) Queensland Parliamentary Debates, 173 (20 Oct). Home Office (1916) Correspondence with the Home Office, 16:10439, HOM/J215, Queensland State Archives. ——(1916–29) Correspondence with the Home Office, COL/359, Queensland State Archives. ——(1920–39) Correspondence with the Home Office re. the Golden Casket, A/4679, Queensland State Archives. ——(1923–30) Correspondence with the Home Office re. the Golden Casket, A/4678, Queensland State Archives. Jordan, P.K. (1980) ‘Health and social welfare’, in D.J.Murphy, R.B.Joyce and C.A. Hughes (eds) Labor in Power: The Labor Party and Governments in Queensland 1915–57, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press. MacGinley, M. (1982) ‘Catholicism in Queensland 1910–35’, PhD thesis, University of Queensland. Macintyre, S. (1986) The Oxford History of Australia, vol 4:1901–1942, Melbourne: Oxford University Press. Matthews, J.J. (1984) Good and Mad Women: The Historical Construction of Femininity in Twentieth-century Australia, Sydney: George Allen & Unwin. McMillen, J. and W.R.Eadington (1986) ‘The evolution of gambling laws in Australia’, New York Journal of International and Comparative Law 8(1):167–92. O’Farrell, P. (1977) The Catholic Church and Community in Australia: A History, Melbourne: Thomas Nelson. O’Hara, J. (1988) A Mug’s Game: A History of Gaming and Betting in Australia, Kensington: New South Wales University Press. Premier’s Office (1919) Copy of report of the deputation from the Australian Natives Association to the Acting Premier, Edward Theodore, 6 March, COL/165, Queensland State Archives. Queensland Government (1915–36) ABC of Queensland Statistics, Brisbane: Government Printer. Queensland Parliamentary Papers (1925) 3, Golden Casket Art Union Annual Report, 1924/25. ——(1937) 2, Golden Casket Art Union Annual Report, 1936/37. ——(1947) 2, Golden Casket Art Union Annual Report, 1946/47. ——(1951–52) 2, Royal Commission to Enquire into Certain Matters Appertaining to the Golden Casket Art Union. Quiggin, P. (1988) No Rising Generation: Women and Fertility in Late Nineteenth Century Australia, Canberra: Australian National University Printing Service. The Bulletin, Australia (1991) ‘Betting your life on it’, vol. 113, no. 5781 (6 Aug.). Time International (1991) ‘Life at the end of the rainbow’, vol. 138, no. 18 (4 Nov.). Truth (1932) (23 Oct.). Ward, R. (1958) The Australian Legend, Melbourne: Oxford University Press. Warwick Daily News (1939) ‘Monument to motherhood’ (11 Dec.). Wilson, T. (1980) The Luck of the Draw: A Centenary of Tattersall’s Sweeps 1881–1981, Melbourne: T.Wilson Publishing Co.
4 ILLEGAL BETTING IN BRITAIN AND AUSTRALIA Contrasts in control strategies and cultures David Dixon
This chapter offers a comparative analysis of some responses to illegal off-course betting and bookmaking in twentieth-century Britain and Australia. The focus is on the development of public policy and law enforcement, and their interrelations with national popular cultures. Australia and Britain are fundamentally comparable in terms of economic and social structure, legal system, dominant political ideology and class relations. In addition, early Australian betting and sporting practices and laws were heavily influenced by those in Britain. However, specific differences (for example, in policing traditions, fiscal policies, working-class composition, and intra-state relations) can be identified as having produced divergent strategies in the control of popular gambling. The British and Australian anti-gambling movements both enjoyed their heyday in the decades around the turn of this century. Employing a common set of anti-gambling arguments (Charlton 1987: ch. 11; Dixon 1991: ch. 2; Fox 1988; O’Hara 1981:75–6; 1988: ch. 5), they had significant influences on public policy. In both countries, the keystone of the state’s strategy was prohibition of working-class gambling, combined with the preservation (in the interests of horse-racing and upper-class gamblers) of legal on-course betting and bookmaking (O’Hara 1988:115–18, 142–9; Dixon 1991: chs 3 and 4). In Britain, this class-discriminatory strategy reached its peak with the Street Betting Act 1906. Very similar legislation was passed in the same year in Victoria and in New South Wales (O’Hara 1988:142–8). A formal, concerted shift away from relying on criminal prohibition came in the 1950s and 1960s. Once again, Australia was influenced by Britain: the 1949–51 Royal Commission’s discussion of principles for the control of gambling (Willink 1951: ch. 4) provided a bench-mark for subsequent Australian inquiries (for example, Kinsella 1963:23–6). While the analysis of principle was the same, the resultant policies were very different, and from 1960 the paths of British and Australian betting controls diverged. Britain decriminalised off-course cash betting and bookmaking, and incorporated previously illegal operators into a legally regulated and taxed system of licensed betting shops. Led by Victoria, the Australian states generally maintained their prohibitions on off-course ‘SP’ bookmaking1 and attempted to compete with it by operating a system of state-run ‘TABs’, the Totalisator Agency Boards. The objective here is to account for why public policy in Australia and Britain diverged in this way and to comment on the relative success and failure of each strategy.2
Gambling cultures
80
INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION A crucial factor was the contrast in the policing of information by state agencies. Offcourse bookmaking depends upon information—betting odds and race results. Advances in the technology and marketing of communications—first, the growth of the new, popular sporting press in the nineteenth century, and later, the completion of national telegraph, telephone and radio services—resulted in the growth of off-course bookmaking operations upon which punters could rely. If the communication of information is prevented or even seriously disrupted, the bookmaking business becomes impossible. The British authorities never developed the policing of information as a tactic. The reasons for this included antagonism and lack of cooperation between the Home Office and the General Post Office, political sensitivity about the interception of communications and about press censorship, and the impossibility of distinguishing information required for (legal) off-course credit betting from that used by (illegal) offcourse cash bookmakers (Dixon 1991:167–72). In contrast, a number of campaigns against Australian SP in the inter-war years identified the communication of information as a legitimate target, and concentrated their attacks on it. Legislation (in Queensland in 1936 and New South Wales in 1938) ‘aimed at the total eradication of SP’ (McCoy 1981:43) by means of limiting or banning the broadcasting of results and the communication of odds from racecourses, and prohibiting newspapers from publishing betting odds or tips (McCoy 1981:41–5; O’Hara 1988:191– 2). The result, however, was the organisation of illegal systems of communication, beginning with the employment of tic-tac men signalling to observers outside the course (McCoy 1981:44; Hickie 1985:328–30) and leading (via corruption) to the unauthorised use of on-course press and police communications systems. Information became a commodity around which an illegal organisation was constructed (McCoy 1980:103, 149; 1981:36; Clark et al. 1978:18). Attempts at suppression away from the racecourse had similarly counter-productive results. In the intermittent crackdowns (from those in the 1920s to those designed to support the introduction and expansion of the TABs after 1960), the police aimed at the most visible and vulnerable part of the bookmaking system—independent SP bookmakers operating in clubs, shops or, most typically, bars. (SP’s place in bars has been demonstrated by its inclusion in the ‘goodwill’ costs at the sale of premises.) International experience shows that the main effect of this kind of policing is usually to encourage bookmakers (and suppliers of other illegal services and products) to organise cooperative arrangements and self-protection. Systematic corruption is likely to result. In Australia, a distinctive element of the bookmakers’ response to police crackdowns has been the use of telephone systems (Hickie 1985:337–8, 340; McCoy 1981:53). Punters contact bookmakers working by telephone either directly or via a runner or agent. This necessitates a complex illicit phone network: its scale became clear when, for example, New South Wales police ‘discovered’ a fullscale telephone exchange handling illegal bookmaking transactions (McCoy 1981:44–5). A consequence has been the apparently widespread corruption of the Postmaster General’s Department and (later) Telecom employees, whose services are needed to install telephones, connect lines and provide switching and diversion transmission arrangements (CJC 1990:30; Costigan 1984: ch. 6; Hickie 1985:356–60, 364; O’Hara 1988:233, 240). In response, gaming squads developed
Illegal betting in britain and australia
81
technological and investigative methods of tracing bookmakers. This increased enforcement capacity was countered by bookmakers turning to the use of portable and, more significantly, cellular telephones. A pattern emerges which is familiar from attempts to police illegal gambling since at latest the eighteenth century. As Blackstone put it, ‘the inventions of the sharpers’ are ‘swifter than the punishment of the law, which only hunts them from one device to another’ (1769:173). The ‘punishment of the law’ also suffers from lack of weight; even when available, prison sentences for betting offences are very rare. In the 1980s, pressure from the TABs to protect revenues led some states to strengthen penalties; but there have been problems in enforcing payment of fines where, as in Queensland, default imprisonment is not available. In New South Wales, imprisonment for SP offences was abolished in 1979. What might have been a first step towards legalisation was thwarted by the intervention of scandals about police corruption and organised crime. Imprisonment was reintroduced as a sentencing option in 1989. An additional consequence of pushing SP into the telephone system is that it is thereby encouraged to operate a credit system. This contrasts with Britain, where illegal bookmakers were normally unwilling to extend credit to working-class punters. The availability of credit gives SP a highly significant advantage over the TABs, which are permitted to operate only in cash, including predeposit accounts. A large-scale illegal credit betting system requires sanctions for punters who cannot or will not pay losing bets. SP bookmaking consequently involved the employment of standover men as debt enforcers (CJC 1990:3; McCoy 1981:45–9; Meagher 1983:31). This dependence upon the threat or use of violence pushed SP bookmaking further into networks of illegal activity.3 Accounts of how the modern SP system developed to become a functional part (particularly for money-laundering) of national criminal syndicates generally display the difficulties and weaknesses of an Australian obsession with ‘organised crime’, which in many respects echoes debates in the 1960s about the Mafia in the United States (cf. Block and Chambliss 1981: chs 6 and 9). Dominant accounts are sensationalised, in their journalistic priorities, individualistic, in their search for a ‘Mr Big’ and in the judicial style of official inquiries, and moralistic, in their monochrome view of the world as being ‘ultimately divided into “goodies” and “baddies’” (Brown 1984–85:10; cf. Hogg 1984; O’Malley 1985). The result is a distorted view of the subject matter; in particular, ‘organised crime’ is seen as a distinct field of operations rather than in terms of its intimate and functional (not merely individual) links with legitimate political and commercial activities. Nevertheless, the result was an illegal bookmaking business in Australia which was very different from that in Britain before 1960 in terms of organisation, functional links with other criminal activities, and relations with the authorities. For example, Sydney currently has three large-scale, franchised, SP bookmaking operations. SP is associated with race-fixing and other problems in the racing industry (CJC 1990:16–20). In consequence, legalisation of off-course bookmaking has been regarded as impracticable: SP bookmakers were not the kind of people whose operations could be legalised. Yet nor could they be completely suppressed. In these circumstances, factors such as the ease of revenue collection from a competitive betting structure became more influential than they might otherwise have done.
Gambling cultures
82
ENFORCEMENT AND CORRUPTION In Australia, corruption seems to have been accepted almost as an inevitable part of public life. The media have played a key role in this process of normalisation: exposure and condemnation have been tempered by the depiction of the corrupt as embodying supposedly fundamental Australian virtues of anti-authoritarianism, ‘larrikinism’ and individualism. Attitudes to police corruption have been very different from those in Britain, and must be explained in terms of contrasting histories of police-public and police-government relations (Finnane 1987; Proctor 1985). Political and commercial corruption may in fact be no more common than in Britain; but in Australia, the realities of power are nearer to the surface of political and commercial activities. Consequently, any corruption within them is more visible. Periodically, scandals emerge and individuals may be prosecuted or forced to resign. New South Wales, Western Australia and Queensland provided notable examples in the late 1980s and early 1990s. However, few people are surprised or expect anything to change in the long term: ‘who bribed whom for what is a commonplace of cynical Sydney conversation, and has been for 30 years’ (Clark et al. 1978:18; cf. Hickie 1985:259–326; McCoy 1980:150, 178–9; O’Hara 1985:382–5). Exposure creates scandal; but this usually does not amount to any general political or ideological threat. This tolerance, even acceptance, of corruption as part of the Australian way of public life means that reform efforts (in SP as elsewhere) have to cope with entrenched apathy about the possibility of change. It is tempting to say that all this is now changing. Between 1984 and 1991, the New South Wales police service was subjected to attempts at major organisational and cultural reform under the leadership of Commissioner John Avery (see, for example, Sparrow et al. 1990:73–7). Like other public bodies, it is supervised by an ombudsman and by the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC). In 1992, ICAC launched an investigation into New South Wales police involvement in corruption and other criminal activities, including SP. In Queensland, the late 1980s saw the exposure and downfall of the old political regime and the establishment of the Criminal Justice Commission (CJC) (Fitzgerald 1989). It soon began a major investigation of SP. While these are important steps, caution lingers about the prospects for long-term and comprehensive effects. There must be doubts about the limited focus of these inquiries and about the political will and ability to confront fundamental realities of the relations between crime, business and politics in Australia. In Britain, betting prohibition and its associated problems (including police corruption) occurred during a period when an enduring and powerful ideological construction was being completed—the ideal of the British police officer who has a special relationship with the public based on shared values and ‘consent’. Because of its threat to this ideology, police corruption was taken much more seriously in this period than it had been before, and was a major factor in leading to the early acceptance in Britain that prohibition would have to be replaced. Corruption in this period achieved an importance that was related not to its objective scale, but to what it signified for the state more generally. This perspective requires revision of the standard accounts in which the legalisation of off-course cash betting was a product of alleged features of post-war social change, such
Illegal betting in britain and australia
83
as ‘affluence’ and embourgeoisement. In fact, the change of state policy from prohibition towards administrative regulation was a product not of the 1950s, but of the 1920s and 1930s (Dixon 1991). The issue had been brought to a head by a series of scandals about police corruption in the 1920s. Decriminalisation was recommended by a Royal Commission in 1933 (Rowlatt 1933). Its concern about harmful contact between bookmaker and punter led to the proposal of an impracticable scheme: bets were to be deposited in a special letter box at the bookmaker’s premises. This, along with the continuing strength of anti-gambling sentiment, meant that the recommendation was shelved. However, the crucial matter was that the impossibility of prohibition and the inevitability of its eventual replacement had been publicly acknowledged (Dixon 1991:320–9). From the 1930s, it was widely realised that prohibition was unworkable and would be replaced sooner or later. Laws directed at street bookmakers were unsuccessful, and could not be made more effective because striking at the roots of the bookmaking system was politically out of the question. As noted above, the authorities were not prepared to use the kind of tactics against the media and communications systems which were a feature of this period in Australia. Police policy became one of containment. Regulated by a system of pay-offs and provision of stooges for arrest and conviction, illegal bookmaking was tolerated as long as public order was maintained (that is, betting was done discreetly), and business was conducted responsibly (that is, primarily with adult males). Prohibition relied on a sliding scale of punishments to act as a deterrent; imprisonment was available for a third offence. However, the organisation of the betting system meant that actual bookmakers were rarely brought to court. While a steady stream of defendants was produced for the courts (and the crime statistics), proceedings became increasingly ritualised, as magistrates realised that the defendants appeared by arrangement. They were rarely eligible for imprisonment, and even those who were often received only fines. This allowed all concerned to regard betting offences as not serious, not ‘real crime’ (Dixon 1991: ch. 7). These policing efforts were not enough and (despite the occasional employment of special squads) were not usually designed to drive bookmaking fully underground. The intention was regulation, not suppression. Consequently, bookmaking was able to remain at the level of small-scale operation. British bookmakers did not require the level of organisation or sophisticated communications systems developed in Australia. Bookmaking was part, not of a criminal subculture, but rather of a wider popular culture for which the laws and values of middle-class society had limited relevance (Chinn 1991; Clapson 1992; Davies 1992: ch. 6). This was of great significance when the issue of legalisation was finally faced in the 1950s. As a result of the factors noted above, the illegality of bookmaking was not an obstacle in considering what could be done: illegal bookmakers could be (and were) accepted as the basis of a new, legal bookmaking business.
Gambling cultures
84
TAXATION The Australian choice of TABs must be set in the context of a willingness by the states to take revenue from gambling which contrasts substantially with the attitude of British governments at mid-century. First, there was a long history of principled objections in Britain to the taxation of gambling. It was argued that the state demeaned itself by drinking at a poisoned well— gambling was inherently immoral and therefore the state should have nothing to do with it (Dixon 1991:120). State dependence on gambling revenue was thought to imply endorsement or approval of gambling. This, it was claimed, would lead to increased levels of gambling, with consequential social problems. The allegedly dire effects of the eighteenth- and nineteenth-century state lotteries were usually summoned as evidence. Indeed, the arguments against ‘state complicity’ in gambling included objections not just to taxation, but to any form of close regulatory contact. For this reason, state ownership and management of betting facilities were hardly even considered as serious possibilities by the major inquiries. Second, there was the experience of the 1926–29 Betting Duty (Dixon 1991: ch. 8). This attempt to tax betting was such a disaster that the Treasury and the Customs and Excise were reluctant to consider betting taxes for many years thereafter: ‘if a revenue Department is allowed to have a heart, the name of this duty is there inscribed’ (Crombie 1962:121). The Betting Duty had been introduced against the Home Office’s wishes and advice, and its humiliating failure ensured the dominance of the Home Office view in future discussions. The result was that, in the 1950s, betting and bookmaking were regarded as essentially a ‘social’, rather than a fiscal, issue; control, not potential revenue, was the priority. Consideration of reform was the concern of the Home Office, not of the Customs and Excise. When off-course cash betting was eventually legalised in 1960, it was not taxed initially: although a levy for horse-racing was introduced in 1961, the General Betting Duty was not imposed until 1966. In Australia, gambling taxation is attractive because it is not particularly unpopular among taxpayers and voters, and it provides considerable revenue which is under the control of state rather than national government. Lotteries have been a regular source of state income and states have increasingly looked to casinos as a source of revenue (McMillen 1986). Revenue potential was significant in the reconsideration of policy towards off-course betting in the 1960s (McCoy 1981:54; O’Hara 1988:220–6). Likely difficulties in collection of tax from SP bookmakers constituted an important objection to their legalisation (O’Hara 1988:234; Kinsella 1963:44–7, 58). In contrast, totalisators promised to provide a simple and assured source of state revenue. The New Zealand TAB, which began operations in 1951, provided an attractive and successful exemplar. In addition, there was a history of support for totalisators in Australia, from racing interests and from working-class leaders and more liberal politicians (McCoy 1981:36–7). This confidence in the potential product of taxing betting has proved to be well founded: for example, in 1991–92, the TAB contributed AS256.7 million to the revenue of New South Wales (NSW TAB 1992:2).
Illegal betting in britain and australia
85
ANTI-GAMBLING AND THE WORKING CLASS This section considers three significant contrasts between Britain and Australia: the role of religion, and attitudes towards bookmakers and towards punters. A distinctive characteristic of British anti-gambling campaigns in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century was the fact that they crossed class boundaries. In particular, the support provided by labour leaders was crucial to the anti-gambling movement; it legitimated legislative action against working-class gambling, providing a response to accusations that such legislation was ‘class law’. This is a clear example of the great influence of Nonconformism on the British labour movement. Arguments from the left against anti-gambling lacked influence, while the views of the ordinary punter rarely reached any public audience. More generally, the driving force of the anti-gambling movement was ‘new liberal’ paternalism, rather than class antagonism (Dixon 1991: ch. 2). As a result of these factors, the gambling issue in Britain has been relatively depoliticised. Policy has been developed on largely utilitarian, reformist lines. In considerable contrast, Australian gambling has frequently been a political issue (Fox 1988; McCoy 1980:147, 149; O’Hara 1985:277–8). The strong influence of Catholicism on the Australian Anglo-Celtic working class and its labour leadership contributed to a traditional tolerance of and sympathy towards gambling, although not necessarily towards its commercial exploitation (Charlton 1987:278; Inglis 1985; McCoy 1980:113–15; 1981:34–5, 38–9; O’Hara 1985:219–29; 1988:254). Anti-gambling sentiment has been rejected as class hypocrisy (O’Hara 1981:77–80). Consequently, the Australian debate about gambling has tended to divide on common class and religious lines, with anti-gambling essentially the preserve of middle-class Protestants. Realising the unpopularity of anti-gambling, modern moralists usually concentrate on other targets. Even moralistic zealots such as Fred Nile in New South Wales have not mounted significant opposition to the expansion of legal betting facilities. In contrast, they have campaigned against casino legalisation because of the potentially broader support for such opposition. Second, there is the image of the bookmaker. In Britain, a powerful weapon of the anti-gambling movement was the portrayal of the off-course cash bookmaker as an alien, exploitative parasite on the working-class community (Dixon 1991:34–7). The inaccuracy of this meant that legislation designed to suppress bookmakers was inappropriate and inadequate. There are lingering elements in the image of bookmaking as being somehow tainted by abuse, impropriety and immorality; this is a portrayal which the Rothschild Commission rejected (1978:29) and which bookmakers find particularly irksome (Ladbroke Group 1976). By contrast, a strong traditional image of Australian SP bookmakers is much more positive. They have been widely seen as part of the working-class community, benign purveyors of innocent working-class leisure, always willing to help people in financial trouble (McCoy 1981:35; see also Charlton 1987:209–10). McCoy (1980) has insisted that this romantic image is not only outdated (if it ever was accurate), but also that what Costigan calls a pervasive and entrenched ‘myth of innocence’ (1984:87) has had damaging effects on public policy. The growth in scale of SP bookmaking and its integration with other illegal activities (see above) has been ignored. The target of law
Gambling cultures
86
enforcement has been the individual bookmaker, when in reality SP operations are run at the level of state and interstate organisation (McCoy 1980; 1981). Third, in discussions of British betting (and gambling generally), the punter is a shadowy figure. The anti-gambler’s image of the punter as a dupe on an inevitable road to disaster no longer carries weight. But nothing has replaced it. Little attention has been paid to who gamblers are, how they see the business or why they gamble. This amounts to a significant inadequacy in the policy formulation process. The Rothschild Commission’s concern for punters’ interests was welcome, but seems to have had little impact. In contrast, gambling is an important part of a stereotypical (non-Aboriginal) Australian self-image. Australian literature is replete with references to the Australians as ‘natural gamblers’ (Charlton 1987; Costigan 1984:1). This is seen as being associated with or produced by other national characteristics: Australians are regarded as being ‘naturally’ anti-authoritarian, fatalistic, and ‘always willing to “have a go’” (Costigan 1984:1; cf. Inglis 1985; Caldwell et al. 1985). These complacent clichés have had historical force: the perception of Australians as natural gamblers has inevitably promoted disbelief in the possible effectiveness of anti-gambling legislation (O’Hara 1981:83).
LOCAL AND NATIONAL STATES In the late nineteenth century, the British authorities experienced difficulties with gamblers who exploited regional differences in legal provisions. It was frequently claimed that bookmakers and punters avoided by-laws prohibiting street betting by simply shifting their meeting place over the local boundary. This was one of the reasons why national legislation was passed in 1906. More serious problems emerged when gambling promoters worked from beyond national boundaries, running lotteries and betting operations via the post. However, these problems seem insignificant compared with those experienced in Australia’s federal system in which gambling law is the concern of the states: The history of gambling regulation in Australia has produced a chaotic federal system whereby gambling is in the hands of a network of fragmented and divided bureaucratic structures at the level of the separate states. In turn, each state government gambling agency operates within the boundaries of a narrowly defined area of responsibility, with authority over only limited segments of the total gambling scene. (McMillen 1985:7) In the case of SP, each state at various times launched police crackdowns, held its own inquiries and introduced its own legislation (see O’Hara 1988: Appendices A and B for full details). An activity with interstate and national dimensions is approached as if independent state efforts are sufficient. Far from there being a national strategy for control, there is not even systematic gathering and sharing of criminal intelligence about SP. The result has been incoherence and inconsistency which often simply drove
Illegal betting in britain and australia
87
bookmakers over the state border, usually from Queensland or Victoria into New South Wales (Costigan 1984:13–14, 89; Fitzgerald 1989:195; Hall 1986:165). This further encouraged the use of telephones for SP betting. While the telephone system is a federal responsibility, in recent decades (in contrast to the interwar years) the appropriate authorities have displayed little interest in policing its use (Costigan 1984:58; O’Hara 1985:324). None of this is likely to increase the Australian SP punter’s regard for the law. The problem is not merely a lack of national legislation; Australia has never even had a national inquiry into gambling. The numerous Royal Commissions have been judicial bodies with specific references and objectives. In particular, inquiries into casino development are usually established only after a decision to permit casinos has been made; legitimation of executive decisions is high on their informal agenda (McMillen 1986). This lack of general debate is reflected in the reluctance of state officials to sponsor or participate in research activities (cf. Caldwell et al. 1985:2). McMillen has argued forcefully that gambling policy formulation in Australia must be opened up and made democratically accountable, and that a national inquiry is a necessary part of that process. However, the trend is in the other direction. Commission reports are ignored unless they come to economically convenient conclusions (cf. Lloyd-Jones 1985 and Lusher 1977). Major decisions—for example, on casino development—have usually been taken without substantial public consultation or debate (McMillen 1986:66). Here at least there are similarities with Britain, where legitimation seems increasingly to be the function of consultation exercises. Searching public inquiries (and Royal Commissions in particular) were abandoned during the 1980s because of their alleged inefficiency and time-wasting.4 The Rothschild Commission’s recommendations that there was an ‘essential and urgent’ need for state-sponsored research into gambling and that developments in the betting business should be carefully scrutinised have been rejected or ignored (Rothschild 1978:20, 48).
CONCLUSION In Australia, the TABs are aggressively expanding their operations, upgrading facilities, providing new outlets in pubs and clubs, taking bets on sports other than racing (notably, Rugby League) and on special events (such as boxing championships and the Americas Cup), and introducing new services and technology (teletext, Sky Channel broadcasts, computerised betting options). The Victorian TAB is leading the way into diversification, with its role as a licensed poker-machine operator and its gaming-machine venue, ‘Tabaret’). The New South Wales TAB has moved into the international market by providing a betting system for Hungary. The TABs have responded to the drift in revenues from racing to gaming (McMillen 1991) by becoming increasingly entrepreneurial, using technological skills and marketing techniques to expand the betting market by targeting and attracting people who would not otherwise have laid bets. The New South Wales TAB can claim to be ‘the largest off-course betting organisation in the world’ (NSW TAB 1990:2), with a turnover of A$3,200 million in 1990–91 and (affected by the recession) A$3,190 million in 1991–92 (NSW TAB 1992:2). The illegal market continues, although to what extent and how it has been affected by the TAB is largely a matter of speculation because no reliable research on its operations
Gambling cultures
88
is available. If SP’s market share is no more than 10 per cent (a proportion which is often suggested, although admittedly based on rudimentary estimates), illegal bookmaking is big business. It is beyond dispute that the TABs have taken some of SP’s actual or potential market, although it is claimed that ‘despite the increase in legal racing turnover, SP bookmaking also continues to grow’ (CJC 1990:3). This apparent paradox is merely superficial; the crucial contemporary development is the bifurcation of the betting market, with SP and the TABs concentrating respectively on large- and small-scale punters. These are different kinds of business, with the result that SP and the TABs complement each other, rather than compete. It is sometimes suggested in New South Wales that the legalisation in 1983 of TAB agencies in licensed premises finished off small-scale SP betting. SP bookmakers increasingly directed small punters to the TAB and concentrated on taking only larger bets, which they are able to attract by offering preferable odds and, crucially, credit facilities. This is broadly the view of the TAB. However, Gaming Squad officers paint a very different picture: they suggest that, far from eliminating small-scale SP, ‘Pub Tab’ indirectly encouraged it. The Sky Channel broadcasting provided for TAB patrons boosted interest in horse-racing, and led to an increase in SP. Certainly, books confiscated during Gaming Squad raids show that by no means all small bets have disappeared into the TAB. In addition, the line between legal and illegal markets is not as clear as it may appear: although not deliberately, the TAB provides an opportunity for laying off SP bets.5 Similarly, there are links between SP and legal racecourse bookmaking (CJC 1990:2). In part, these competing views illustrate differing organisational interests. In particular, it is clearly in the interests of the Gaming Squad (whose staff was substantially reduced in 1991) to maintain that SP remains a significant problem. It seems to be beyond dispute that bifurcation of the betting market is in progress. This has major implications for the strategy of control by competition: SP is not threatened by TABs which are creating new markets of small-scale recreational punters. SP is able to consolidate its effective monopoly of large-scale, off-course betting. This can be tackled only by providing comparable (not alternative) legal services. A similar process of commercialisation has affected British bookmaking. Legal restrictions have been eased, allowing bookmakers to provide better facilities and services, notably in the communication of betting information. The result has been to accelerate trends towards oligopolisation of the British betting market by the ‘Big Three’, Ladbrokes, Coral and William Hill/Mecca. The previously entrenched policy of allowing only the provision of services to cater for ‘unstimulated demand’ is quietly being abandoned, as the bookmakers apply standard market techniques in attempts to expand their business, and particularly to attract a new generation (and class) of punters. A parallel development has been the growth of an illegal betting market. While legal bookmakers claim that the rate of betting duty is solely responsible, ironically, it appears also to be the case that commercial concentration in bookmaking (particularly the withdrawal of services from some areas) has itself encouraged illegal operations (Dixon 1991:349–55). Independent legal bookmakers suffered a substantial reduction in turnover in the early 1990s. This is likely to lead to further closure of premises and more illegal bookmaking. This chapter has discussed a selection of issues related to the control of illegal betting in Australia and Britain. A theme which emerges particularly strongly is one which is
Illegal betting in britain and australia
89
familiar in gambling studies: the difficulties which are experienced by state authorities in controlling commercialised gambling, whether legal or illegal. The primary control strategy of the modern state is not prohibition, but regulation. It has to deal not just with Blackstone’s ‘sharpers’ by enforcement of the criminal law, but also with legitimate commercial operators, some of which are themselves state agencies. Comparative analysis suggests that states face similar and serious problems in these areas. The legal market in Britain and both the legal and the illegal markets in Australia display similar tendencies of technological development, market concentration and rationalisation and resistance to regulation. Finally, the case of illegal betting exemplifies the need to understand crime and control not as distinct but rather as interactive and interdependent phenomena. Such illegal activities are shaped by the state’s attempts to suppress or control them. In turn, strategies of control have been moulded in response to the resistance and adaptability of the illegal activities.
POSTSCRIPT Since this paper was completed, the links between illegal gambling and corruption have continued to attract attention in Australia. The Independent Commission Against Corruption investigated the New South Wales Police Gaming Squad (focusing on the policing of illegal card games and amusement devices, rather than on SP bookmaking) in the course of its inquiry into New South Wales police corruption. As a result, the Squad was disbanded in December 1993: see Independent Commission Against Corruption (1994) Investigation into the Relationship between Police and Criminals: First Report, Sydney, NSW: part IV. In May 1994, a Royal Commission into the New South Wales Police Service was established, with wide-ranging terms of reference, including investigation of the ‘nature and extent of corruption within the Police Service, particularly of any entrenched or systemic kind’. A report is expected late in 1996. In Queensland, the Criminal Justice Commission published its report, SP Bookmaking and Related Criminal Activities in Queensland, in November 1992. Inter alia, this report argues that: SP bookmaking cannot be suppressed by law enforcement and can only be reduced by attracting its market share to legal operators; restrictions on legal operations must be eased in order to make them more attractive and competitive; there are few useful criminal intelligence data on SP bookmaking in Australia; and a coordinated national strategy to deal with SP is essential.
NOTES 1 SP bookmaking refers to the starting price odds of racehorses set by on-course bookmakers. In Australia, the meaning of SP has been extended by usage to signify the activity of off-course illegal bookmaking in general. 2 The historical account given here has obviously to be brief and highly selective, glossing over significant factors such as the restricted experiments with legal off-course bookmaking in Australia (for details, see Fox 1988; O’Hara 1988:189–91), other differences between developments in Australian jurisdictions, and the role of off-course credit bookmaking in Britain. For detailed historical accounts, see Dixon 1991; O’Hara 1985, 1988.
Gambling cultures
90
3 See, for example, Bongiorno 1985; Bottom 1979; Costigan 1984: ch. 2; Fitzgerald 1989:13, 73; Hickie 1985:327–71; McCoy 1980:176–82; 1981:52, 59–64; Meagher 1983:31–5; Moffitt 1985; Whitton 1986. For more sober and convincing accounts, see Hall 1986:162– 70; O’Hara 1988:204, 238–40. 4 However, a House of Commons Select Committee has recently examined the Home Office’s responsibilities for the control of gambling. In 1991, a Royal Commission (to investigate the criminal justice system) was established for the first time in thirteen years. 5 I am grateful to Mr Allen Windross, General Manager of the NSW TAB, and to members of the NSW Police Service for their comments on contemporary SP. They are, of course, in no way responsible for my comments in this chapter.
BIBLIOGRAPHY Blackstone, W. (1769) Commentaries on the Laws of England: Book 4, Of Public Wrongs, Oxford: Clarendon. Block, A. and Chambliss, W.J. (1981) Organizing Crime, New York: Elsevier. Bongiorno, B.D. (1985) ‘Gambling and crime’, in G.Caldwell et al. (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm, 208–16. Bottom, B. (1979) The Godfather in Australia, Sydney: Reed. Brown, D. (1984–85) ‘Organised crime: changing practices, markets and relations’, Australian Left Review 90:10–12. Caldwell, G. (1974) ‘The gambling Australian’, in D.E.Edgar (ed.) Social Change in Australia, Melbourne: Cheshire, 13–28. ——(1985) ‘Some historical and sociological characteristics of Australian gambling’, in G.Caldwell et al. (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm, 18–27. Caldwell, G., Haig, B., Dickerson, M. and Sylvan, L. (eds) (1985) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm. Cashman, R. and McKernan, M. (eds) (1981) Sport: Money, Morality and the Media, Sydney: New South Wales University Press. Charlton, P. (1987) Two Flies Up a Wall: The Australian Passion for Gambling, North Ryde, NSW: Methuen Haynes. Chinn, C. (1991) Better Betting with a Decent Feller: Bookmakers, Betting and the British Working Class 1750–1990, Hemel Hempstead: Harvester. CJC (1990) ‘SP bookmaking and other aspects of criminal activity in the racing industry: an issues paper’, Criminal Justice Commission, Queensland. Clapson, M. (1992) A Bit of a Flutter: Popular Gambling and English Society, c.1823–1961, Manchester: Manchester University Press. Clark, A., Wilkinson, M., Snow, D. and Suich, M. (1978) ‘The politics of organised crime’, National Times (16 Sept.): 18–20. Costigan, F. (1984) Final Report of the Royal Commission on the Activities of the Federated Ship Painters and Dockers Union, vol. 4, SP Bookmaking, Canberra: Government Printer. Crombie, J. (1962) Her Majesty’s Customs and Excise, London: Allen & Unwin. Davies, A. (1992) Leisure, Gender and Poverty: Working-Class Culture in Salford and Manchester, 1900–1939, Manchester: Manchester University Press. Dixon, D. (1988) ‘Responses to illegal betting in Britain and Australia’, in W.R. Eadington (ed.) Gambling Research, Reno: University of Nevada. ——(1991) From Prohibition to Regulation: Anti-Gambling, Bookmaking, and the Law, Oxford: Clarendon Press. Doig, A. (1984) Corruption and Misconduct in Contemporary British Politics, Harmondsworth: Penguin.
Illegal betting in britain and australia
91
Eadington, W.R. (ed.) (1988) Gambling Research, Reno: University of Nevada. Fitzgerald, G.E. (1989) Report of a Commission of Inquiry into Possible Illegal Activities and Associated Police Misconduct, Brisbane. Fox, C. (1988) ‘In search of a fair bet’, in V.Burgman and J.Lee (eds) Constructing a Culture, Fitzroy, Victoria: McPhee Gribble/Penguin. Haig, B. (1985) ‘Illegal betting 1920/21 to 1970/71’, Sporting Traditions 2:69–74. Hall, R. (1986) Disorganised Crime, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press. Hickie, D. (1985) The Prince and the Premier, North Ryde, NSW: Angus & Robertson. Hogg, R. (1984) ‘Gossip from underground’, Australian Society (Dec.): 6–8. Inglis, K. (1985) ‘Gambling and culture in Australia’, in G.Caldwell et al. (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm, 5–17. Kinsella, E.P. (1963) Report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Off-the-Course Betting in New South Wales, Sydney: Government Printer. Ladbroke Group (1976) Evidence to the Rothschild Commission, Unpublished document, London: Public Record Office. Lloyd-Jones, J. (1985) Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Gaming in New South Wales, Sydney: Government Printer. Lusher, E.A. (1977) Report of Inquiry into Legalising of Gambling Casinos in New South Wales, Sydney: Government Printer. McCoy, A.W. (1980) Drug Traffic: Narcotics and Organised Crime in Australia, Sydney: Harper & Row. ——(1981) ‘Sport as modern mythology: SP bookmaking in New South Wales 1920–1979’, in R.Cashman and M.McKernan (eds) Sport: Money, Morality and the Media, Sydney: New South Wales University Press, 34–67. McMillen, J. (1985) ‘Gambling policies: a sure bet or a stab in the dark?’, in J.McMillen (ed.) Gambling in the 80s, Nathan, Brisbane, Queensland: National Association for Gambling Studies. ——(1986) ‘The other revolution: the legalisation of commercial gambling in Australia’, Nevada Public Affairs Review 65–9. ——(1991) ‘Australian casinos: who gets the golden egg?’ Paper presented in the Non-profit Corporations Seminar Series, Queensland University of Technology (29 Nov.). Meagher, D. (1983) Organised Crime, Canberra: Australian Government Printing Service. Moffitt, A. (1985) A Quarter to Midnight, North Ryde: Angus Robertson. NSW TAB (1990) Annual Report 1989–90. ——(1992) Annual Report 1991–2. O’Hara, J. (1981) ‘The Australian gambling tradition’, in R.Cashman and M.McKernan (eds) Sport: Money, Morality and the Media, Sydney: New South Wales University Press, 68–85 ——(1985) ‘Gaming and betting in Australia 1788–1983: a social and cultural analysis’, Unpublished PhD thesis, University of New England. ——(1987) ‘Class and attitudes to gambling in Australia’, in W.R.Eadington (ed.) (1988) Gambling Research, Reno: University of Nevada. ——(1988) A Mug’s Game: A History of Gaming and Betting 1788–1985, Sydney: New South Wales University Press. O’Malley, P. (1985) ‘The illegal sector of capital’, Contemporary Crises 9:81–92. Proctor, C. (1985) ‘The police’, in A.Patience (ed.) The Bjelke-Petersen Premiership, Melbourne: Longman Cheshire. Rothschild, L. (1978) Final Report of the Royal Commission on Gambling 1976–78, Cmnd 7200: London: HMSO. Rowlatt, S. (1933) Final Report of the Royal Commission on Lotteries and Betting 1932–3, Cmd 4341, London: HMSO. Sparrow, M.K., Moore, M.H. and Kennedy, D.M. (1990) Beyond 911: A New Era for Policing, New York: Basic Books.
Gambling cultures
92
Whitton, E. (1986) ‘Crime and justice’, Sydney Morning Herald (8 April): 13–16. Willink, H. (1951) Report of the Royal Commission on Betting, Lotteries & Gaming 1949–1951, Cmd 8190, London: HMSO.
5 WHEN IT’S BAD IT’S BETTER Conflicting images of gambling in American culture James F.Smith
As members of a democratic society, Americans are socialised by means of various myths and rituals characteristic of our popular culture. Among the rituals that reflect, articulate and transmit cultural myths are those of play and games. Materialism and competition are two distinguishing traits of the American character that are reflected in the games we play—from the Superbowl, the national spectacle of championship professional football which is played as much for the profit of television networks and their sponsors as for sport, to Wheel of Fortune, a popular television game show in which players solve word puzzles for expensive prizes and which has been described as American materialism run amok. Present-day America encourages in its citizens unlimited expectations for material wealth and gratification through images in advertising and entertainment media while the constraints of real life put limits on opportunities to fulfil our dreams. The playing of gambling games can provide a form of recreation that is both a product of and a contributor to prevailing cultural myths. In his excellent study of the history of gambling in America, John Findlay (1986) has called Americans ‘people of chance’, because of both traditional risk-taking associated with the history of US frontier expansion and the pervasiveness of gambling recreation throughout our history. It should not be surprising that commercial gambling among adults has become such a significant social and economic issue in our time. In many respects, gambling is a dramatic example of pure conspicuous consumption: money is exchanged for the thrill of the experience— not for an increase in wealth—because most players lose over the long term. Nevertheless, the thrill of the game, coupled with the hope for a win, has proved to be a powerful attraction. But the nature of gambling in America has changed over time, particularly during the second half of the twentieth century, and the change is consistent with changes in the mass cultural values. This chapter argues that neither change is beneficial to American culture, although both may have some economic benefit. During 1991 Americans gambled more than US$304 billion in legal games (Christiansen 1992a:22), wagering about 6.3 per cent of their personal income. In fact, between 1982 and 1991, legal gambling wagers increased by more than 142 per cent while personal income increased by approximately 81 per cent (Christiansen 1992a:37). Over the past several years, the fictional ‘US Gambling, Inc.’ (the combined ‘win’ of legal gambling enterprises) has ranked in the top twenty of the Forbes Sales 500, a listing of the most successful US business enterprises; the 1991 total of US$26.7 billion in gambling revenue (‘sales’) places ‘US Gambling’ in nineteenth place, just ahead of American Express (Christiansen 1992b:18–19). A ‘real world’ comparison of popular leisure activities brings the numbers into focus: Americans spent five times more money
Gambling cultures
94
on gambling games than they did on movie tickets during 1991 (US$26.7 billion versus US$4.8 billion). The economic impact and resulting power of legal gambling interests are clearly implied by the magnitude and rate of growth of their wealth. What may not be so obvious is the fact that the culture of gambling has changed. With the increasing popularity of state-sanctioned lotteries and their mega-jackpot appeal, and the increasing reliance on the technology of coin-operated gaming devices by the sanitised, corporate-controlled casino industry (and today by state lotteries as well), the mythic archetype of a rugged individualist gambler—whether card sharp, pool hustler or horse-player—involved in a specific ritual of play is an endangered species, likely to become a thing of the past. Such players, whether found in real life or in legend, have assumed a larger-than-life stature. They have mastered or defied the odds against them; they have challenged their opponents and the vagaries of chance. In so doing, they have mirrored the risk-taking characteristic of an evolving nation, culture and economy even though they may have been acting outside the traditional boundaries of socially admired behaviour. Historically, the United States has had an ambivalent attitude towards gambling. On the one hand, gambling has been regarded as a sin, a vice, a crime and an unproductive waste of time. This attitude dates back to the time of earliest settlement, and persists among some Americans even to this day. However, since the legalisation of the first modern state lottery in New Hampshire in the early 1960s and at an accelerating pace in the past two decades, gambling has undergone a marked change in image. In fact, today gambling can be seen as harmless, recreational, charitable and even patriotic— particularly when it is in the context of playing state lotteries. This change in image has profound implications for American culture. Not only does it reflect changes in cultural values that have already occurred, but it also works to change cultural values further. In many ways, gambling was ‘better’ when it was seen as ‘bad’. Because it was a pariah enterprise of shady glamour, it had an attraction to the marketplace and, more importantly, a separation from the normal events of everyday life that kept the activity in its place which, for most people, was the differentiated world of play. As it has become more integrated into everyday events, gambling has actually become less ‘fun’ and, perhaps, even more insidious than any of the traditional negative images could portray. For Americans in earlier times gambling was a rebellious decision, replete with images of vice (gambling was seedy, if not immoral) and risk (gambling was a threat to one’s bankroll if not to one’s person). In spite of the often noted gamble that the European explorers and colonists experienced when they settled the New World in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, they were amazed and appalled at the extent of gambling among native Americans, the passion with which the various games were played and the magnitude of the wagers.1 Although British colonists from Virginia to Massachusetts were no strangers to gambling games themselves, their laws and their sermons proscribed card- and dice-playing as immoral wastes of time. Nevertheless, gentlemen were allowed to race their horses and wager on the outcome, and sanctioned lottery games were available, usually to benefit a community need. By the eighteenth century, gambling in America was essentially a private affair and usually associated with the aristocracy, for as John Findlay observes, in contrast to the ‘gambling shops’ in England, ‘Americans had no such public and commercial setting in which to gamble.
When it's bad it's better
95
More dispersed throughout the land and with little cash at hand, colonists did not develop an urban hierarchy of public houses in which gambling could flourish’ (Findlay 1986:29). Betting on games did occur in taverns, but wagers were made between individual patrons rather than against the house. Consistent with Enlightenment thought, private gamblers were expected to play at risk moderately and within their means. By the nineteenth century, however, ‘commercial’ gambling became more significant, and possibilities for immoderate losses became more available. New Orleans and other river towns offered gambling houses; private operators created ‘state’ lotteries; professional gamblers worked the steamboats, and frontier cattle and mining towns provided gambling saloons. Foreign visitors to America, such as Alexis de Tocqueville, contended that ‘the dynamics of capitalism and democracy in the new republic generated a restlessness and an infatuation with risk that heightened the urge to wager’ (Findlay 1986:50). At the same time, though, people who made their livelihood from gambling were regarded as ‘blacklegs’—if not outright criminals, at least not properly part of polite society. Cheating at games was rampant, and several of the most profitable lottery games were found to be corrupt. Card sharps and dishonest operators came to characterise the class of ‘professional’ gamblers, and those unfortunates who played with them were at best foolish sheep waiting to be fleeced. But while it was comparatively easy to pass and enforce legislation against lottery games, it was more difficult—in fact, impossible—to eliminate professional gamblers and the Americanised forms of commercial gaming from society.2 The twentieth century has seen both a continuation of the earlier attitudes, in the first half-century, and, in recent decades, a capitulation to the inevitability of gambling behaviour so long as it is regulated and taxed.3 The resulting status of gambling in contemporary America is ambiguous, with the state simultaneously prohibiting those forms in which it has no regulatory or financial interest and promoting those which it controls and taxes. Operators are regarded as either legitimate corporations and entrepreneurs or criminals; so they are either praised for their financial success or condemned by law enforcement agencies. Players and their interests are generally ignored unless they run afoul of the law or they become problem gamblers.4 But it is among people who gamble where the ‘rebellion’ of gambling persists. Whether a game is legal or not, a player’s decision to gamble still may be socially or morally suspect even though it is consistent with a cultural propensity for risk, particularly if the chosen game is not a legally sanctioned lottery. In the other more or less indigenous forms of gambling that have evolved in the United States, players test their mettle and become initiated into particular gambling subcultures: card games (poker, gin rummy and the like), casino play (blackjack, roulette, dice), pari mutuel wagering (at the races or jai-alai fronton) or sports betting (in Nevada or most often with an illegal bookie). In each of these subcultures, the players face a definite antagonist— whether another player, the vagaries of pari mutuel or bookmaker’s odds, or the inescapable house advantage. They test their judgement, money management and, finally, their knowledge of odds and their playing skills according to formal rules, bound by the etiquette of the particular subculture surrounding the game. Experience and knowledge pay dividends in this type of gambling because, even though the final outcome is influenced more or less by chance, the skill of players can help determine their destiny. Chance makes the games democratic and opens the possibility of winning to anyone; skill, knowledge and competition make winning a worthy pursuit.
Gambling cultures
96
Therefore, traditional gambling games and their subcultures can provide intrinsic rewards beyond the obvious material gain from a win. One way to understand games and play is to see them as social fictions. As in the case of reading or writing good fiction, playing a game can reveal truth about the human condition. In their world of makebelieve, games do not replace reality, nor do they alter it. However, they do suspend the consequences of real life for the duration of the game. Often the games we play mirror, if only obliquely, our real lives. In the context of play, the suspense, conflict and uncertainty of life become easier to manage because our play is conducted according to specific protocols within certain recognisable surroundings and because it is, after all, a game.5 Further, there is a marked coincidence between the principles that rule various kinds of games—whether they are games of chance or games of skill—and those that characterise the web of human interaction in culture. Among these are: • the need to prove one’s superiority • the desire to challenge or overcome an obstacle • the hope for and pursuit of the favour of destiny • the desire to test one’s strength, skill, endurance, or ingenuity • conformity to rules and laws, the duty to respect them, and the temptation to circumvent them. (Caillois 1979:64–5) In the context of a competitive and materialistic culture that has become increasingly regimented, standardised, predictable and bound by finite economic limits, allowing comparatively little room for individual creativity and personal achievement, games provide an important outlet for these human tendencies, offering at least the illusion of control over destiny and circumstance. David Sklansky, the son of a mathematics professor from Teaneck, New Jersey, studied for two years at the University of Pennsylvania only to drop out and become a professional poker player in Las Vegas. He has written three books on poker theory, but he makes his living at the tables. For a time, he worked in the ‘straight world’ as an actuary, but found that when he developed new methods for solving problems, his superiors were unimpressed: ‘I knew something no one else knew, but I got no recognition for it’ (quoted in Alvarez 1983:134). He continues, however, that the world of the gambler is very different, and, ultimately, more satisfying: In poker, if you’re better than anyone else you make immediate money. If there’s something I know about the game that the other person doesn’t, and if he’s not willing to learn or can’t understand, then I take his money. By rights that guy who ran the actuarial office should have been broke; he shouldn’t have been my boss. But in the business world things aren’t like that. I was always being told what to do by incompetent people, and I hated it…. But [Las Vegas] gives me what I want. I like the freedom of the gambler’s life, I like being my own boss. I like the way you are rewarded directly according to your ability, not according to what people think of you. (Quoted in Alvarez 1983:135)
When it's bad it's better
97
In addition, gambling games provide a clearly defined conclusion through the final outcome of play. Too often the circumstances of our lives do not immediately tell us whether our decisions are right or wrong, whether we have won or lost; by the end of a game, however, we have no doubt. Games are occasions to display important personal character traits: courage, integrity, gallantry and composure. These virtues, too, are part of a mythic American heroic stereotype which is today reinforced by games and athletic contests.6 In a very real sense, participants in a game gamble these traits—their sense of self—when they engage in the contest; and if they make a good showing, they can enhance their egos, whether they win or lose, so long as they act in culturally approved ways. Even today, gaming can produce heroes in a cultural context where knowledge and skill combined with other personal traits can affect the outcome of play. Expert poker players, such as Doyle Brunson, ‘Amarillo Slim’ Preston and Jack Strauss are admirable among their peers whether they win or lose a particular contest. The late blackjack guru, Ken Uston, was not only successful at beating the casino game and paving the way for other card counters to be allowed to play without being barred for their skill (at least in Atlantic City casinos), but he was instrumental in making the game of twenty-one the most popular casino table game in America during the past two decades. Handicappers such as Andrew Baker have shown that in the long run knowledge, perseverance and restraint can overcome the uncertainty of horse-races. Sports handicappers, such as Lem Banker, have the uncanny ability to figure the odds and sniff out an overlay in judging professional and collegiate sporting events. Even the legendary Nick ‘the Greek’ Dandalos, who is reputed to have won and lost millions of dollars during his gambling career, can be numbered among such ‘heroes’ because of his unflinching grace in the face of occasionally staggering monetary losses. Eric Stoner ‘The Cincinnati Kid’, Lancey Howard The Man’, Eddie Felson ‘The Hustler’, and other fictional gamblers contribute their bigger-than-life roles and risks to gambler heroism. The egos of all these players, not just their bankrolls, are put on the line whenever they make a bet, and although there is monetary consideration—and the realisation that their livelihood may be at stake (making gambling their real world of ‘work’ after all)—such players are still playing. It is significant to note that all these ‘heroes’ are unconventional, even ‘rebellious’ personae who live outside the boundaries of the world that most of us call ‘normal’.7 A corollary to the assertion that gamblers can be heroic is the notion that our heroes can—or must—be gamblers. One of the most popular ‘American’ heroes for over fifty years is found in Margaret Mitchell’s enormously successful novel about the Civil War, Gone With the Wind (1936). Rhett Butler is a classic American heroic type: handsome, intelligent, daring, resourceful and independent—in short, the only character ‘man enough’ for Mitchell’s heroine, Scarlett O’Hara. When this story was brought to the cinema in 1939 by producer David Selznick, there was only one actor who could play the part: Clark Gable, then the reigning king of Hollywood. The screenplay was a monumental task for Sidney Howard, who with Selznick himself and several consultants, including Ben Hect and the novelist F.Scott Fitzgerald, worked to pare the story to a reasonable length for filming while preserving the magic that Mitchell’s narrative worked upon her readers. Even so, the film runs for nearly four hours.
Gambling cultures
98
Nevertheless, the production includes a gambling scene which does not appear in Mitchell’s novel. After the South has fallen to the Yankees, Butler is held in a federal prison in Atlanta where Scarlett visits him in order to obtain money to pay taxes on her beloved plantation. Mitchell’s version of this scene has Rhett brought to Scarlett for the interview from his cell. The film version opens with Butler playing poker with a Union army major: ‘Kings and treys’, says the major. ‘Aw, too much for me, Major,’ replies Rhett. ‘You know, it’s a pity we couldn’t have fought the war out on a poker game. You would have done far better than General Grant with far less effort. My losses for the afternoon come to what?… Ummm, three-hundred-forty. My debts do mount up, don’t they, Major.’ This cavalier exchange ends just before Scarlett is allowed to see Rhett, against the rules, with the major’s observation to a subordinate: ‘It’s hard to be strict with a man who loses money so pleasantly.’ This addition to Mitchell’s classic story is meant to reinforce the dashing image of Rhett Butler, and it is significant that this literary and cinematic hero is portrayed in a gambling encounter, appropriately mirroring the colossal gamble the Confederacy took against the Union. After all, American heroes are known for taking chances, and it is fitting that Butler’s character traits are shown at the poker table. As Jack Binion, a Las Vegas casino owner and host of the World Series of Poker, observes: Let’s face it, gambling is a very romantic activity. Movies reflect what people are looking for. Well, I wonder how many gamblers a big star like Clark Gable played in his career. We all daydream about people doing something we are a little bit afraid to do, and we make heroes out of those who pull it off.8 By playing well, a gambler can win both self- and public esteem even while losing money. The opportunity to test one’s honour and the thrill of the game itself can be intrinsic rewards in a gambling encounter. Action in a gambling game is the primary attraction. As Erving Goffman explained, the ritual involves squaring off, in which a challenge is presented and rules are set; determination, the actual play producing an outcome; disclosure, the brief but suspenseful time between the completion of play and the participants’ realisation of the result; and finally the settlement, in which the players acknowledge the result (Goffman 1967:154). Action was paramount to Nick the Greek, whose apocryphal remark is now part of gambling folklore: ‘The best thing in the world is to gamble and win. The next best thing is to gamble and lose.’ The intangible rewards of a successful self-presentation in the ritual, the building of a reputation, become as important as monetary rewards. As one player observes: ‘It’s real important for me to show that I won’t freeze up or anything like that, and that I’ve got what it takes’ (Hayano 1982:88). For the best ‘heads-up’ players—world class poker professionals are a classic example—recognition for skilful play and a reputation for ‘heart’ or ‘the courage to bet all their money when they reckon that the odds are in their favor’ (Alvarez 1983:31) are at least as important as the money they win. Bobby Baldwin, one of the younger players on the high-stakes poker tournament scene, elaborates:
When it's bad it's better
99
Playing poker for a living gives you backbone. You cannot survive without that intangible quality we call heart. I don’t care how bad you are going or how good, you have to stand solid. Poker is a character builder— especially the bad times. The mark of a top player is not how much he wins when he is winning but how he handles his losses. (Quoted in Alvarez 1983:47) Such traditional gamblers are not motivated by a desire to ‘get something for nothing’. In fact, for professional poker players or expert handicappers, getting something for nothing is scorned. Luck is the last refuge of the novice or poor player, and money is regarded only as the ammunition needed to keep playing. Describing the action of tournament poker, Alvarez claims: ‘The chips were like rapiers in a fencing match—instruments to attack, parry, counterthrust until one or the other duellists delivered the coup de grace’ (1983:174). Further, Doyle Brunson explains that in order to play well at high-stakes poker: ‘you need to have a total disregard for money. It is just an instrument, and the only time you notice it is when you run out’ (quoted in Alvarez 1983:43). That is not to say that these gamblers have no regard for winning. On the contrary; they share aggressive characters and thrive on competition. Jack Strauss notes that ‘Winning is everything…. If I lose, I don’t give a damn about the money, but I just hate the embarrassment of being beaten’ (quoted in Alvarez 1983:107–8). At the annual World Series of Poker in Las Vegas, the top players gather from every state in the Union, and the Vegas professionals wait to be challenged by them, like knights in armour—or, rather, since this is the West, like the last of the gunslingers, loners in a dangerous profession. For them, the risk, challenge, and solitariness of their profession are a source of intense pride. (Alvarez 1983:113) But like the showdowns of fabled gun-slingers, heroic gambling is threatened by the passage of time and the advance of modernity. In America today gambling has been mainstreamed. There is no rebellion or even well-defined subculture to be found when a person buys a lottery ticket along with a carton of milk and pack of cigarettes at the local convenience store. Indeed, one of the attractions that figure prominently in the promotion and legalisation of lotteries is that playing (not gambling) is now synonymous with good citizenship. It is not surprising then that the relative mix of gambling opportunities available to Americans has changed. Gambling in the United States has been a growth industry during the past twenty-five years, with the most dramatic growth in games which have the lowest possible ‘entry barrier’ to the players and the most predictable profit for the operators. These games are the various lottery games, including the latest video lottery terminals, and the array of coin-operated gaming devices available in casinos and at other locations.9 Because commercial gambling, just as any other business, depends on profits to survive, the direction of modern-day gambling has been to produce a thoroughly predictable profit margin for the operator. This goal is best achieved if the last unpredictable factor—human ingenuity or skill—can be eliminated. Unlike poker and
Gambling cultures
100
blackjack, which are games of mixed chance and skill, lottery games, video lottery terminals and casino coin-operated machines are games of pure chance in which any human intervention other than the superstitious selection of numbers or machines is cheating and subject to prosecution. Games such as craps, roulette and baccarat are also games of pure chance; however, a player’s sophistication—knowledge of odds and money management—may help the player survive the house advantage long enough to benefit from a lucky streak. In contrast, the new gambling games are simply money machines operating according to a pay-out schedule that guarantees the operator a fixed percentage of win. Because lottery and slot-machine players find their primary reinforcement in winning money, almost hitting a jackpot is meaningless, and they can derive no pleasure from a losing bet, no matter how ‘close’ it comes to a win. One cannot play a lottery or a slot machine well; one can only play more by buying more tickets or dropping more coins into the slot and triggering the mechanism. In fact, the play of lottery games and most coin-operated devices defies the objective knowledge of odds and money management that can pay dividends in more ‘old-fashioned’ games. In reality, the more players know, the less they should play.10 Therefore it should not be surprising that no heroes can be found in this new gambling world because there is nothing that a lottery or machine player can do to become a better or ‘professional’ player. No amount of practice, skill or knowledge can improve a player’s luck or overcome the negative expectation of the games. What we find in the place of heroes are celebrities: people who become famous for the moment, usually because of the magnitude of their win. The public life-span of such winners is brief. Usually the publicity diminishes with time, barring some unusual personal circumstance or tragedy occurring after the win, and it may evaporate quickly if their win is surpassed by another player. Like other celebrities, they need not possess remarkable talent, character or other personal distinction. They are known for being well known, and their status depends upon attention from the media. Daniel Boorstin contends that celebrities are neither good nor bad, but an inevitable result of contemporary culture and media exposure, human ‘pseudo-events’ to satisfy our exaggerated expectations of human greatness.11 Were it not for their win, their play would be devoid of lasting meaning. In the long run, they have won only money, not genuine or lasting prestige. Traditional lottery games, including instant tickets and daily numbers games, have been accused of being a regressive tax, preying upon the people most in need of help (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:221–30). While it is true that people having higher incomes and levels of education spend more money on lottery tickets than do poorer and less educated players, the latter spend a greater proportion of their income on tickets (Kaplan 1984:100). Further, the demographics of lottery markets reveal that certain groups are more likely to play lottery games and to do so heavily: males, Hispanics, blacks, the middle-aged, Catholics, labourers, and those with less than a college degree (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:100). However, the popularity of lotto games, where the jackpots can grow to staggering levels, has begun to change the mix of players, bringing more middleclass and well-educated players into the fold. The larger the jackpot, the more likely players will impulsively buy tickets, even if they do not normally do so, or buy additional tickets if they are regular bettors.12 These players can only dream of having a day such as Leslie Robins had on 7 July 1993. After casually buying a ticket for the Powerball lotto game (played in a pool of fourteen states and the District of Columbia) shortly before the
When it's bad it's better
101
drawing, Robins, who is a 30-year-old junior high school English teacher, found that he held the only winning ticket for a jackpot worth US$111 million, or US$3.5 million per year, after taxes, for the next twenty years. The story of this winner and his fiancée, a nurse, is only beginning to unfold, but they claim in an Associated Press interview that they do not plan to live lavishly; instead, they hope to support the school and hospital in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, where they work, and to share their good fortune with friends and family (Philadelphia Inquirer, 11 July 1993: A2). Middle-class sentiments persist, and the free publicity surrounding this apparently wholesome, white, middle-class couple stimulates the sales of lotto tickets in every jurisdiction. And yet, it is also clear that Mr Robins did nothing special to deserve his windfall or to influence the odds of his win, nor was he particularly needy or desperate. He is no ‘hero’, as a co-worker observed: ‘He just wants to be an ordinary guy’ (Philadelphia Inquirer, 11 July 1993: A2). In lotto games where no player has a particular advantage, Americans may have found an ultimate democracy. The irony here is that there is little or no real play in the new world of gambling, while play (or action) is the raison d’être for traditional gambling games. It may be argued that busloads of slot-machine players heading to Atlantic City or groups of co-workers discussing the outcome of the lotto drawing against their pool-purchased tickets do, in fact, enjoy the sociability engendered by these gambling opportunities. But the games themselves are not comparable to other, more ‘personal’ games.13 Lotteries and slots are played in the hope of winning a long-odds jackpot; traditional games combining chance, skill and fateful encounters are played to play as well as to win. Accompanying this change is the fact that newer forms of gambling games are fast games, capitalising on intensity of experience and churn of gamblers’ dollars with each new generation of equipment. On-line video lottery games may cycle several times per hour, where lotto games occur once or twice per week. Microchips and computer technology make modern slot machines faster and more foolproof than the old mechanical or electro-mechanical models; blackjack and poker hands appear on computer screens faster than any human could deal them. This speed creates a kind of action, to be sure, but it is a narcotising action, numbing the players into a trance-like fixation. Handicappers and card players thrive on action, too, but their action is deliberate and thoughtful mental exercise as opposed to reflex response. In the new world of gambling, the meaning of play and games has been distorted, and many of the traditional social and psychological functions of true recreation are lost.14 At an individual level, these changes have negative impact. There is nothing a person can do to become a more skilful lottery or slot-machine player. The player can act on superstition by betting lucky numbers, buying from a lucky ticket vendor, or playing favourite machines in a lucky casino. On the other hand, through study, practice and experience, a person can improve skill at cards, handicapping and sports betting, and improved skill can bring success or, at the very least, active participation in determining one’s fate. However, if one is to play a game seriously, one must work at learning theory and practise the mechanics of applying the theory in order to succeed. For many modern players, this is too much like ‘real’ work. The twentieth-century cultural switch from a work ethic of production to the gratification ethic of consumption is illustrated neatly in the shift from our studying a racing form or counting cards in the game of twenty-one to letting a computerised ‘dream machine’ pick out lotto numbers. It is important to note
Gambling cultures
102
that automatic selection tends to increase ‘spontaneous’ play at those lotto games where it is available (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:176) and that a large number of lottery megawinners, including Leslie Robins, admit that the on-line computer chose their winning numbers at random. It is no accident, then, that lottery games have been until recently the most aggressive growth market in the gaming industry—a position lotteries expect to regain with the proliferation of video lottery terminals.15 Nor is it a coincidence that they have assumed a prominent position both in the finances of state governments, the most reliable source of ‘painless taxation’ given the typical 45–50 per-cent take-out rate, and in US popular culture, since they are legal in thirty-six states. The most successful casinos in Atlantic City and in Nevada earn at least half their revenue from coin-operated devices, the most dramatic of which accept US$100 tokens, three at a time.16 Effortless amusement appears to be a more marketable commodity in America today than is active involvement, and market analysts, not gaming experts, are the fast-track executives in the gambling industry. This fact is most evident in the promotion of state lotteries. In a fashion unprecedented for a government agency, lottery managers have adopted the techniques of consumer marketing to sell their games.17 Many observers of modern America note that we live in an age of diminishing real opportunities to match the dreams fuelled by advertising and such media-extravaganzas as Robin Leach’s television exposés of the lifestyles and runaways of the rich and famous. The work ethic has been critically eroded by promises of instant gratification and instant wealth. Cultural commentators such as Philip Slater (1970) and Christopher Lasch (1979) have noted the negative impact of recent history on American culture, making people lonely and narcissistic even as they become materially better off.18 In his exploration of success and middle-class culture, Loren Baritz (1990:289–318) claims that contemporary Americans have replaced traditions with a desire to escape restrictions, moral values with an imperative to satisfy psychological needs, and financial security with unrelenting demands for ‘more’ in a world where happiness is an acceptable substitute for genuine accomplishment. In this world, sin is regarded as a disease which therapists and other experts can try to cure. With Veblen’s ‘conspicuous consumption’ no longer only a ‘leisure-class’ trait, people in the United States seemingly live for the moment in an unpredictable world, and they are willing to consume wealth for the pleasure it can afford.19 It is no historical accident that the most explosive growth in gambling industries, both state lotteries and legal casinos, has occurred during the past twenty years. This time has seen both the collective realisation of the limits of our fiscal and natural resources, in fuel crises and tax revolts, and an acceptance of the ‘unreal’ wealth found in junk bonds and other extravagant market speculation. We have also demonstrated a growing tolerance for—and even the greedy expectation of—the unabashed public display of wealth. Gambling fits easily within these trends, being pure capitalism as an enterprise and conspicuous consumption as a game. This congruence is unfortunate, since many critics, including Lasch and Baritz, judge the trends to be signs of a civilisation in decline. Historically, values promoted by material consumption without thought of tomorrow were almost ‘un-American’, at least in the proper world of the middle class, though these values were always associated with gamblers and the world of play. Now ordinary citizens bet their future with unprecedented levels of personal and corporate debt in order
When it's bad it's better
103
to live the good life. In the past Americans held as an article of faith that ‘personal progress was an inspired and irrevocable law. Progress toward wealth might be slowed but could never be stopped’ (Baritz 1990:106). A recent Gallup poll reveals that one-fifth of the American population believe that the only way to get ahead is by playing the lottery (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:133). Gamblers have always bet on a quicker tomorrow and have tested their fate in rituals that were less ambiguous than their everyday lives. In the past, these gambling rituals were set apart from the ordinary; today, they are not only part of the everyday experience, but they are also sold as skilfully as consumer goods. Americans are consumers, particularly in their leisure, and their consumption feeds the social and industrial complex. Having great expectations but low motivation, many contemporary consumers look for new diversions and the proverbial quick fix. The new culture of gambling is only too glad to oblige, but the real value of games is lost in the process.
NOTES 1 Henry Chafetz (1960:3–12) offers several observers’ accounts of gambling among American Indians. Games which ranged from athletic contests, such as ‘football’, to primitive crap games in which participants tossed painted sticks, stones or multi-faced animal bones could last literally for days. Contestants and onlookers wagered passionately, even to the extent of offering wives, children and themselves (as slaves) when their other stakes were exhausted. Noteworthy was the fact that in spite of the seriousness of the gambling, participants, however reckless, remained in good humour, taking wins and losses with equanimity. 2 Findlay (1986:40–78) notes that the culture of the nineteenth-century United States supported a speculative, risk-taking ethos. The tendency to see gambling as a business made it fit somewhat easily with the secular side of our culture, despite any moral qualms to the contrary. While individual gamblers suffered at the hands of outraged citizens and some forms of gambling, such as lotteries, could be effectively prohibited, gambling adapted to American circumstances and flourished. 3 Prior to the 1930s, only pari-mutuel wagering on racing was allowed in limited jurisdictions, and until the 1960s and the rebirth of the lottery in New Hampshire, Nevada casinos and California card rooms were the only other legal betting alternatives. Nevertheless, casinostyle gambling, ‘numbers’ policy games and sports betting were widely available— particularly in urban areas—courtesy of illegal operators. When the legalisation of some of these activities, beginning with lotteries and spreading to casino gaming, was proposed by various jurisdictions, inevitably one justification was to compete with and thereby thwart illegal suppliers. 4 See Abt et al. (1985:211–22) for analysis of the relationship of political jurisdictions to gambling and gamblers, noting the status quo and offering an alternative scenario in which the state’s interest is to protect the public interest regarding gambling. 5 For a discussion of the specific rituals and settings of two popular forms of ‘social gambling’ in America, racetrack and casino gambling, see Abt and Smith (1983). The particular gambling cultures discussed place the recreational gambler in the mainstream of cultural values even though the gambler may appear to circumvent the work ethic. 6 From the swashbucklers and cavaliers of the seventeenth century, through the frontiersmen and cowboys of the eighteenth and nineteenth, to the athletes, soldiers, spies, cops and private-eyes of the twentieth, heroic figures have emerged in US life and literature. As Joseph Campbell (1956) suggests, heroes venture from the world of common dullness to the region of fleeting wonder, armed essentially with courage, an innate sense of justice and what is right, and the technical skill and composure to do what must be done in spite of all
Gambling cultures
104
obstacles. As all heroes, the popular heroes in the United States are human icons representing basic cultural myths, self-reliance and noteworthy accomplishment. In recent times, however, heroic personae are often the target of the tabloid press or debunking biographers who strive to reveal their flaws (or simply their human foibles). As a result, Americans turn more and more to fiction and fantasy for heroic types whose character is unimpeachable. 7 Elsewhere (Smith 1990) I have discussed the portrayal of these ‘outlaw’ characters. In the ‘serious’ films, gamblers generally fall into two types: the romantic gambler, who fits most easily with the heroic image discussed here, and the pathetic/tragic gambler, who reveals the underside of the gambling world and reinforces negative connotations. In either case, the demands of cinematic portrayal create ‘supercharged’ gambling situations where enormous—or at least critical—amounts of money are wagered or where a ‘title’ or distinction is at stake. Films such as Robert Rosen’s The Hustler (1961), Norman Jewison’s The Cincinnati Kid (1965), Robert Altman’s California Split (1974), Karel Reisz’s The Gambler (1974), Martin Scorsese’s The Color of Money (1986), and Ben Bolt’s The Big Town (1987) present distinctly American interpretations of gambling settings and action. It also seems no accident that the treatment of gambling themes in film has become more frequent in recent years as gambling has been mainstreamed in American popular culture. 8 Quoted in Alvarez (1983:117). For the record, it should be noted that Butler’s crime was supplying weapons to the South by running a Union blockade at sea. This, surely, was a more significant gamble than five-card draw, but in many ways it was more economical to reveal Rhett’s character traits over a card table! 9 Lottery sales more than quadrupled between 1982 and 1991, and accounted for more than US$20 billion in handle in 1991. Slot-machine handle increased by 486 per cent during the same period to a total of nearly US$85 billion in 1991. The money wagered at casino table games, in contrast, increased at the more modest rate of 72 per cent during these years (Christiansen 1992a:25). 10 This assertion has been shown not to hold true. Lottery players not only defy objective knowledge of the odds, but winners who are lucky enough to overcome the odds persist in their play despite newfound wealth and sometimes negative experiences after winning (Kaplan 1984:105). In the world of coin-operated gaming devices, one can argue that video blackjack and video poker machines allow for player choice and strategy; consequently, player knowledge and money management can influence the outcome of the game. Nevertheless, the machines’ payback/hold ratios are manipulated to comply with regulations (in New Jersey) or to live up to advertising claims of ‘looseness’, in terms of optimum player strategy. Thus the ‘best’ a knowledgeable player can do is play against the nominal fixed percentage of the machine; weaker players are disadvantaged even more. 11 Boorstin goes on to elaborate on the distinction between celebrities and heroes: heroes are distinguished by their achievement; celebrities by their image. Heroes create themselves through their actions; celebrities are created by the media. Heroes are ‘larger than life’ people; celebrities have big names (1972:57–61). Heroes symbolise and even defend the basic values of a civilisation; celebrities represent immediate cultural interests which are far more transitory. 12 Clotfelter and Cook (1989: chs 5 and 6) note that while instant game tickets may be impulsive purchases, on-line games, such as lotto, may have a higher proportion of planned purchases. Moreover, the larger the jackpot of the game, the more sales result. Therefore, jurisdictions have manipulated the game structure and, in some cases, joined multi-state pools, to ensure larger jackpots by increasing the chance for roll-overs and broadening the population base. Also Clotfelter and Cook define four types of players: the investor (who chooses when to participate by weighing odds against the jackpot); the plunger (who sees a win as the only hope of escaping a bad situation); the believer (who exercises the illusion of
When it's bad it's better
105
control by choosing lucky numbers); and the participant (who enjoys playing the game, particularly in pools or other ‘social’ settings). 13 In the on-line lottery games (lotto, numbers), many players allow the computer to select random numbers for their tickets, acknowledging the lack of any real control over the outcome of these games of pure chance. ‘Serious’ slot-machine players usually restrict their socialising to breaks in the action. While playing, they concentrate on their machines, protecting both their claim to a particular machine and their coins; they may even be mesmerised by the machine into a trance-like state until their money runs out or a loud signal and ‘frozen’ machine indicate that they have won a jackpot. 14 Huizinga defines play as follows:
Play is superfluous. The need for it is only urgent to the extent that the enjoyment of it makes it a need. Play can be deferred or suspended at any time. It is never imposed by…necessity or moral duty…. It is done at leisure in ‘free time’…. Play is distinct from ‘ordinary’ life both as to locality and duration…. It contains its own meaning. (1955:7–8) Abt and colleagues present a structural analysis of the major forms of contemporary commercial gambling in the United States, including casino games, lotteries and pari mutuel betting (Abt et al. 1985:35–51). 15 Clotfelter and Cook note that as lottery games ‘mature’ there appears to be an inevitable decline in player interest, presenting a challenge for managers to manipulate the games to keep the market strong (1989:114–15). Mature games tend to flatten their performance curve over time, and some decline. However, the introduction of a lottery in a new jurisdiction inevitably produces dramatic growth, which may cause observers to assume incorrectly that the growth will continue at the same rate. Christiansen notes that the introduction of video lottery terminals has rejuvenated ‘mature’ lottery games, and early figures suggest that a new wave of lottery growth will accompany the proliferation of this form of play (1992a:32). 16 In 1991, casino slot machines earned US$5.2 billion in Nevada and New Jersey, compared to US$3.2 billion earned by authorised table games. Lotteries earned even more in the same year than all casino games combined: US$10.2 billion (Christiansen 1992b:16). 17 Target marketing, in which segments of the population are ‘targeted’ for promotion, is used rather than mass marketing. The revenue-maximisation objective causes promoters to focus on increasing the play of established players and attracting likely players from identified pools within the general population (Clotfelter and Cook 1989:189–99). 18 Abt et al. (1985:191–210) discuss in more detail the relationship of gambling and American values. 19 Baritz contends that wealth has replaced all other cultural values in modern America (1990:307–9), and the existence of Leach’s programmes—not to mention their popularity for more than half a decade—seems to support this proposition. Leach himself has become a celebrity by means of his television shows, which do little more than allow viewer-voyeurs to ogle the possessions, homes, clothes and favourite resorts of wealthy celebrities.
BIBLIOGRAPHY Abt, V. and Smith, J.F. (1983) ‘Playing the game in mainstream America’, in F.Manning (ed.) The World of Play, West Point, NY: Leisure Press.
Gambling cultures
106
Abt, V., Smith, J.F. and Christiansen, E.M. (1985) The Business of Risk: Commercial Gambling in Mainstream America, Lawrence: University of Kansas Press. Alvarez, A. (1983) The Biggest Game in Town, Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Baritz, L. (1990) The Good Life: The Meaning of Success for the American Middle Class, New York: Harper & Row. Boorstin, D.J. (1972) The Image: A Guide to Pseudo-Events in America, New York: Atheneum. Caillois, R. (1979) Man, Play and Games, trans. M.Barash, New York: Schocken Books. Campbell, J. (1956) The Hero with a Thousand Faces, New York: Meridian. Chafetz, H. (1960) Play the Devil: A History of Gambling in the United States from 1492 to 1950, New York: Clarkson N.Potter. Christiansen, E.M. (1992a) ‘The gross annual wager of the United States—Part I: Handle’, Gaming and Wagering Business (July-Aug.): 22. ——(1992b) ‘The gross annual wager of the United States—Part II: Revenue’, Gaming and Wagering Business (Aug.–Sept.): 16. Clotfelter, C.T. and Cook, P.J. (1989) Selling Hope: State Lotteries in America, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Findlay, J.M. (1986) People of Chance: Gambling in American Society from Jamestown to Las Vegas, New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press. Goffman, E. (1967) Interaction Ritual: Essays on Face-to-Face Behavior, Garden City, NY: Anchor Books. Hayano, D.M. (1982) Poker Faces: The Life and Work of Professional Card Players, Berkeley: University of California Press. Huizinga, J. (1955) Homo Ludens: A Study of the Play-Element in Culture, Boston: Beacon Press. Kaplan, H.R. (1984) ‘The social and economic impact of state lotteries’, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 474:91–106. Lasch, C. (1979) The Culture of Narcissism: American Life in an Age of Diminishing Expectations, New York: Warner Books. Slater, P.E. (1970) The Pursuit of Loneliness: American Culture at the Breaking Point, Boston: Beacon Press. Smith, J.F. (1990) ‘Where the action is: images of the gambler in recent popular film’, in P.Loukides and L.K.Fuller (eds) Beyond the Stars: Studies in American Popular Film, vol. I: Stock Characters in American Popular Film, Bowling Green, OH: Popular Press.
6 REPRESENTATIONS OF GAMBLING IN AUSTRALIAN POPULAR CULTURE Peter Williams1 For myself, I will continue to take on the warriors of academia in the world of literary ideas and to write from the standpoint of the victims of the crisis which characterises our times. Frank Hardy (1983b:14)
SOCIAL USES OF LITERARY STATEMENTS This chapter discusses gambling practices in terms of their social relations and outcomes as these are treated in some recent Australian popular writing, primarily in the fiction and journalistic work of Frank Hardy. Compared with the frameworks and substance of more sociological, historical and political-economic analyses of gambling, this may seem like a trivial pursuit. However, persuasive literature presented to particular readerships can be used to address and, in certain limited ways (that is, not as direct ‘expressions’ or ‘representations’ of other prior and external realities), even help organise consideration and government of specific cultural and socio-political questions and policy issues such as gambling (Hunter 1984a, 1984b, 1991).
FRANK HARDY’S WRITING ON GAMBLING: AN INVENTORY OF STATEMENTS As Ken Inglis has demonstrated, the fiction and much of the journalistic and critical writing of Frank Hardy since the late 1940s significantly contributed to the repetition and survival of a particular populist and leftist version of the radical-nationalist ‘Australian legend’ (Inglis 1985:8–11). The erstwhile democratic, social-realist precepts which inform the political and cultural strategies mobilised by Hardy texts challenge the dominance of elitist and metaphysical literary-critical practices and values precisely over conceptualisations of popular cultural activities in Australia such as radical politics and gambling. Such challenges have regularly been met with elegant and powerful, but arrogant, classifications and effective critical marginalisations of Hardy’s writing (Mitchell 1981:130). Hardy’s writing selectively and intertextually quotes elements from the texts of, among others, Henry Lawson, A.B.‘Banjo’ Paterson and Katherine Susannah Prichard to establish plausible credentials as purveyor of the frameworks and values of an increasingly besieged democratic, popular cultural tradition (Hardy 1966). This chapter
Gambling cultures
108
attempts to summarise the array of statements in Frank Hardy’s writing that concern Australian gambling practices and the social dynamics they involve.
POWER WITHOUT GLORY: A QUESTION OF INTERESTS As Al McCoy has observed, Hardy’s first novel, Power Without Glory (1950), hypothesises the causes and effects of certain forms of ‘Australian political corruption’ between 1880 and 1950 (McCoy n.d.: 36). The novel’s narrative identifies a discontinuous but strategically interconnected apparatus, how what might be termed a ‘rhizome’ of power is initially capitalised by the proceedings of an illegal betting shop located in the inner-city, working-class area of ‘Carringbush’. Via the cynical assumption that everyone has their price, through consequent acts of bribery and violence, and despite resistance from certain sections of the police force, Protestant ‘wowser’ groups offended by the challenge of games of chance to Puritan disciplinary forms of government and doctrines of predestined certainties, some employees, equalitarian radicals in the labour movement and state and federal parliaments, the novel’s central character and anti-hero, John West, moves from poverty-stricken Irish-Catholic workingclass beginnings, and municipal machine politics, through relentless economic accumulation, to a formidable extent of wealth, social and (indirect) political power from a comfortable distance: ‘Power becomes more mighty and satisfying when exercised by remote control. He did not want glory, he wanted power—power without glory’ (Hardy 1975a:390). The novel commences with the image of a spinning coin flicked a corruptible policeman’s way. Metonymically this image connotes the ‘battler’ West’s gamble on the path to an always limited and resisted approximation of class power (Hardy 1975a:25, 60, 258). Because capitalism is conceptualised as legal robbery, anything is possible and justified for West’s organisation (Hardy 1975a: 252–4). With no certainties the stakes are high. Most noticeably, this enables West’s spectacular social mobility, which is presented by the novel’s organising political-economic framework as having been financed by battling punters habitually in need of money to tide them over in mundane material matters from day to day and week to week: ‘You mean to say that you blokes are goin’ to go round takin’ money from people who’ve hardly got the price of a feed, on a race that’s rigged?’ objects labour movement activist, character Eddie Corrigan, to little avail (Hardy 1975a:40; McLaren 1988:89–91). Constituted by the novel’s narrative as a Catholic, philanthropist and faceless man in the social-democratic Australian Labor Party (ALP), the West character’s use of entrepreneurial political-economic tactics either ignores or corrupts socialist strategies and policies that compete with his individualist rhetoric of self-improvement in political struggles for working-class support and affiliation (Hardy 1975a:66, 233, 158). West’s disdain of solidarity with radical sections of the working class, and eventually with his family, is exemplified by the degree of elevation of the prosperous businessman’s gaze over the river to working-class ‘Carringbush’—the location of his constituency and market—from his mansion atop a hill in a more salubrious suburb (Hardy 1975a:265). For the patriarchal West character, poor working men are simply ‘gripped by the hope of gain that prompts…[them] to gamble’ (Hardy 1975a:98). Accordingly, West can
Representations of gambling in australia popular culture
109
rationalise his affluence and power as the hard-earned reward for enterprising, even charitable provision of a range of gambling services otherwise proscribed by an upperclass ‘Establishment’. The latter is presented as supported by the luxury of inherited, landed wealth, exclusive clubs as well as such official apparatuses of legal and moral authority as the police force, judiciary and Protestant churches (Hardy 1975a:554). West prospers both economically and politically until, with the fateful inevitability of an elementary nemesis, domestic and wider social contradictions, the revenge of the novel’s—and, by implication, capitalism’s—dialectical structure and forces conspire to displace and disperse that power (Hardy 1975a:557 ff.).2 As a long and diffuse critical realist story, with all of its rich offering of references to and fictive accounts of other historically produced social realities such as the powerful historical individual, John Wren, the composition, reading and attendant legal trial over charges of criminal libel established Power Without Glory as a template for most of Frank Hardy’s subsequent writing and literary-political departures (Brennan 1971:205–24; Buggy 1977; cf. Hardy 1971c).
JOURNEY INTO THE FUTURE: A WORKABLE PROGRAMME? Legal, political and literary ructions followed the publication and circulation of Power Without Glory (Palmer 1951; Eldershaw 1950; McKernan 1984:143–4). Hardy’s next book, Journey into the Future (1952), consisted of a relatively uncritical account, or officially sanctioned witnessing, of late-Stalinist Soviet economic, social and cultural life during the Cold War era of post-Second World War reconstruction. The itinerary included a visit to the Moscow Hippodrome, and the account submits that in the USSR horse-racing was organised along ‘socialist lines’ with neither course nor SP bookmakers, only the totalisator with ‘express and doubles totes’ (Hardy 1952:119, 121; Prichard n.d.: 155). Compared with the situation in Australia, betting is said to run ‘a poor third’ to interest in the breeding of ‘good horses’ and entertainment of ‘the public’ in the USSR (Hardy 1952:119, 121). According to Hardy, this means ‘no bookmakers to “bag” horses and no big owners to plan betting coups by running their horses dead for a few starts’. It is ‘socially conscious’ trainers and drivers ‘who make very high earnings’ and share ‘the advanced social outlook and love of trotting’ more than ‘the vigilance of the stewards’ which prevents dishonest racing (Hardy 1952:122). Hardy announces a conviction that ‘one-two bets and doubles would be easier to pick here than winners in Melbourne’ (Hardy 1952:127). Journey into the Future linked these and other supposedly democratic dispositions of the Soviet socio-economic and cultural network to Henry Lawson’s 1890s writing in Australia ‘from the standpoint of the common man’ (Hardy 1952:321). This connection having been asserted and elaborated, Journey into the Future extends it to a policy dimension with a detailed call for implementation of the programme of the Communist Party of Australia (CPA), ‘Australia’s path to socialism’ (Hardy 1952:329 ff.).3 The book’s argument in this regard seems to be that the gambling identified by radical-nationalist cultural historians such as Ward (1958) as intrinsic to the idealised version of Australian national character could be positively corrected by a transcendence of the bad habit of compulsive gambling and the crime of race-rigging. Such a
Gambling cultures
110
transcendence is asserted as attendant on the emergence of the assumed essence of Australian national culture and the protocols of (Stalinist) communist internationalism: national in content, international in form, to rehearse the slogan of the day. It was precisely this sort of tourist-of-the-revolution romanticism, ‘the web of Stalinism’, which Hardy finally and openly repudiated after the 1968 Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia (Semmler n.d.: 142). That forthright rejection was made clear in Hardy’s 1968 series of articles for the London Sunday Times (reprinted in the Australian Bulletin), entitled ‘The heirs of Stalin’, working from Yevgeny Yevtushenko’s celebrated 1962 poem of that title (Semmler n.d.: 138–72). Similarly, Hardy’s later novel, But the Dead Are Many (1975b), calls for more democratically organised socialist institutions, social relations and policies.
THE FOUR-LEGGED LOTTERY: GAMBLING AS AUSTRALIAN SOCIAL TRAGEDY Following Journey into the Future, Hardy’s novel The Four-legged Lottery ([1958] 1977) took up Czech socialist, anti-fascist journalist Egon Kisch’s analysis of gambling on horse-racing in Australia as this was set out in the latter’s Australian Landfall ([1937] 1969). The Hardy text’s title echoes Kisch’s argument that ‘these days horse racing [has] ceased to be a valiant sport, and [has become]…a lottery, with four-legged tickets’ (Kisch [1937] 1969:222; Hardy [1958] 1977: epigraph and 43). Building on Power Without Glory’s indictment of a shadowy network of exploitative economic and political power financed, in the main, from the proceeds of bookmaking, The Four-legged Lottery is informed by evidence of the destructive social consequences of habitual gambling and, especially, of the inequitable socio-economic relation of power between gamblers and the local SP bookmaker (Kisch [1937] 1969:223; Marshall 1984). Presented in heroic and sympathetic terms through Hardy’s adaptation of critical-cum-socialist realist precepts, the working-class character, Jim Roberts, is almost an embodiment of major elements of ‘the Australian legend’ (Hardy [1958] 1977:9–10; Blakey 1979:10). He is situated as being exploited by capitalism in general and corrupted by an increasing dependence on the professional gambler’s regimen in particular. Through the technique of a split retrospective narrative, Roberts, like Power Without Glory’s West in his youthful phase, rejected active commitment to the work (as distinct from the argot) involved in radical social transformation (Hardy [1958] 1977:109). Roberts is finally hanged for murdering unremitting bookmaker Pittson in a fit of rage at the economic and social injustices involved in gambling transactions (Hardy [1958] 1977:218–19). Earlier in the novel, middle-class narrator Paul Whittaker gravitates to Roberts’s drinking and gambling group in search of both companionship and extra money to cater for what are presented as the excessive but socially ingrained consumerist desires of the woman to whom he is married. She is identified as a prime cause of Whittaker’s eventually compulsive gambling and consequent social disgrace.4 Consigned to prison for embezzlement of funds in his capacity as a bank teller, the Whittaker character enunciates his own and Roberts’s socially differentiated but gradually intersecting life histories. This narrative strategy is situated within a wider socio-political commentary and argument on the inter-sections of habitual gambling, imprisonment, ‘deformed’ sexuality and
Representations of gambling in australia popular culture
111
(in)justice in class-divided Australian society (Hardy [1958] 1977:9). Gambling is discussed as a collective addiction which induces debilitating levels of guilt and a desire for confession and expiation, an ensemble of cultural practices and spiritual exercises to which male, working-class Catholics of Irish extraction are particularly prone, according to the novel and much of Hardy’s other writing (Hardy [1958] 1977:18–20, 61, 115, 27– 8, 41, 43, 67–8, 78, 112, 118, 221). According to the novel’s narrative, the ‘degradation of unemployment and the dread of the dole’ during the socio-economic depression of the 1930s coincided with the proliferation of racing and football tipping competitions and other small games of skill and chance (Hardy [1958] 1977:100, 45–6). This articulation of poverty with inexpensive games of skill and chance is located as a cause of habitual gambling among the depression-bred generation of working-class and lower-middle-class Australians such as the Roberts and Whittaker characters respectively. Their generation is said to sustain a Micawberish optimism and ‘the desperate hope of increasing …earnings’, relying on luck to compensate for inadequate social conditions, becoming victims of the tyranny of the law of averages over the laws of probability (Hardy [1958] 1977:51, 73, 126, 182). Media-circulated accounts of what counts as popular memory of such historical events as the Australian colonies’ Gold Rush of the 1850s and its ‘gamble for gold’ has ensured that, as in the United States, ‘[g]ambling is part of our national psychology’ (Hardy [1958] 1977:74). But the novel affiliates itself with members of culture’s civilising mission of enlightenment who argued that the ‘mania’ of gambling ‘is a perversion of the daring and spontaneity of the Australian people’, ‘an expression of the cultural barbarism imposed on the people by our society, that will die only when the system which gives rise to it also dies’ (Hardy [1958] 1977:75, 77). Racing and all forms of gambling are classified as, more often than not, hegemonically corrupt components of ‘big business’, so that even a punter who manages to devise a marginally successful gambling system would have, in crypto-Faustian manner, ‘given his soul over to the devil of gambling. He would lose the taste for the fine things of life. He would be dehumanised by his very success’ (Hardy [1958] 1977:170–82). The ‘joyous expectancy of the gambler’ is diagnosed as a ‘symptom of [the battler’s] revolt’, an imaginary line of flight from the pressures and limits of past and current social predicaments (Hardy [1958] 1977:162). The populist, masculinist evaluation of gambling as a site par excellence of struggles between ‘battlers’ and ‘the system’ is followed by the prescription of a remedy; a condensed version of Journey into the Future’s nationalisation programme is invoked as the only viable alternative to a relentless social dialectic, constituted as symphonic in form and otherwise inevitable, of ‘the dreadful Australian tragedy’ of gamblers incarcerated and even executed (Hardy [1958] 1977:170, 224).
LEGENDS FROM BENSON’S VALLEY: LEARNING FOLKLORIC HABITS As a contribution to a then burgeoning, politically inflected folkloric movement, Hardy’s collection of interrelated short stories, Legends from Benson’s Valley (1963), repeats many of the evaluative statements put forward in The Four-legged Lottery concerning the
Gambling cultures
112
propensity to gamble as a profitably exploited aspect of what is ascribed as Australian ‘national character’, especially among depression-stricken, itinerant rural workers of the 1930s (Hardy 1966:242; Ward 1958; Wannan 1954; Smith 1985). In this collection’s first short story, ‘Cocky in Bungaree’, the no-risks tight-fistedness of the ‘cocky’, or small farmer, as both employer of labourers and spouse, is contrasted with hired potato digger Arty MacIntosh’s proclivities for women, ‘beer and horses’ and racing, here styled as the sport of both ‘the needy and the greedy’ (Hardy 1963:23–4). The MacIntosh character enshrines the ‘work and burst’ drinking, gambling and socialist attributes ascribed in ‘Australian legend’ mythology. In the collection’s story entitled ‘The Load of Wood’, Darky Nolan, virtually the only major ‘positive’ socialist-realist hero in any Hardy text, gambles against the likelihood of detection in transgressing the trespassing laws as well as the dogs and shotgun of an authoritarian squatter (or pastoralist) to appropriate and distribute firewood to towns-people generally out of wood, work, warmth and luck (Hardy 1963:42–3). The comically registered moral of ‘When Sandy Mitchell won the lottery’ is that ‘[n]o good ever came of a working man winning the lottery. He can’t solve his problems that way’ (Hardy 1963:149, 161). The story presents an account of the conflict between class solidarity with fellow workers and the use of the proceedings of a lottery win to provide conditions for accelerated social mobility (Morrison 1984:85–6). Sandy Mitchell’s winnings are spent on food and alcohol for his (male) mates and on their tactics for initiating a workers’ insurrection in the depression-divided rural town of ‘Benson’s Valley’. The revolt has to be abandoned because of their drunkenness and confusion (Hardy 1963:55, 63, 77, 80, 82). ‘The gambler’ is the collection’s story of a povertystricken, working-class household’s mounting excitement and eventual despair around the race broadcasts on the wireless on a Saturday afternoon. The story comprises indications of the domestication of gambling during the 1930s through the new communication technology of radio.5 It also suggests practical, material ways in which such a socially disadvantaged household forms and educates its younger members to potential dispositions for gambling through the tutelary examples of parental habits, routines, needs and pleasures. As Wittgenstein proposed, ‘the game can be learned purely practically, without learning any explicit rules’ (Wittgenstein 1979: no. 95, 15e; Wilson 1990:3–23).
THE HARD WAY: A DIVISIVE SUBJECT Hardy’s The Hard Way: The Story Behind ‘Power Without Glory’ (1961) chronicles the research, writing and publication of Power Without Glory by pseudonymous autodidactic writer ‘Ross Franklyn’, together with the notorious legal consequences of these processes for ‘Franklyn’s’ double, Frank Hardy (Hardy 1981; Fricke 1984:5, 8, 144–52; Doogue 1982:110–11, 131–3; Pollak 1990:227–60). The Hard Way provides a statement of record of the ‘real-world’ documents (from Royal Commissions, state and federal parliamentary debates, notebooks, diaries, newspapers, library research and memories of oral interviews) as well as the literary-political doctrines and writing strategies deployed in Power Without Glory’s narrative and its purported ‘exposure’ of economic, political and domestic corruption. Printing of that novel had been partly financed by a ‘stroke of
Representations of gambling in australia popular culture
113
gambler’s luck…an inside tip’ that produced £200 and the recitation of a piece of folkloric wisdom: ‘take you a long time to make that kind of money with an axe’ (Hardy 1971a:128; Frow 1982:34). But, to complicate matters, gambling is also bound up with the contradictory constitution of the authorial figure ‘Franklyn’–Hardy as divided between responsibilities to both professional writing and communist politics: ‘I’m a boozer, and a mad punter, and a knock-about battler from way back, an adventurer, a borrower and a leader. We were the man for an occasion, but the true leader is a man for all occasions’ (Hardy 1971a:254; Hardy quoted in Childs 1984:76).
BILLY BORKER YARNS: ‘THEM’ AND ‘US’ The distancing from Marxist-Leninist doctrines of political organisation and subsequent recourse to populist modes of address are clear in Hardy’s The Yarns of Billy Borker (1965) and ‘The Great Australian Lover’ and Other Stories ([1967] 1972b, published in some editions as Billy Borker Yarns Again). Initially devised for performance on (the then) Australian Broadcasting Commission television channel, these anecdotal yarns are presented as dialogic transcriptions of urban and rural folklore: ‘from my own experience or the experience of men I drank with in pubs up and down the coast’ and from ‘the first and best Australian yarn-spinner I ever heard…my father Tom Hardy’ (Hardy 1965:5–7, 149–52; Semmler n.d.: 63–70). Overwhelmingly, the anecdotes work in the demotic with the figure of ‘the Australian battler’—from racecourse tipsters and bagmen to seamen and wharf labourers—whose stoic motto is ‘you can’t win, but you’ve got to battle’ (Hardy 1965:152; Hardy 1975c:9, 38, 42, 49, 67, 80, 86, 99, 102, 107, 111–13, 123–5; Morrison 1984:18–34). Usually without class specificity, the populist ‘archetype of the Australian battler’ asserts as typical a character ‘ironic, democratic, suspicious of authority, contemptuous of pomp and privilege… [and] an inveterate liar’ (Hardy 1965:153). The 1930s depression practices of rigged hotel raffles, horse-races and betting coups are treated as continuing aspects of a unitary financial and social ‘system’ in which ‘[t]here’s no more thieving goes on [on the wharf] than on the Stock Exchange’, ‘Banks gamble with other people’s money, when you look at it right, and so do stockbrokers’ (Hardy 1965:62–9; 70–2, 22, 130; Hardy 1972b:76–80, 89–92, 93–8, 17–24, 140–3, 99). The reductive and oppositional populist demarcation of ‘us’ and ‘them’ allows, inevitably in such narratives that, in Hardy’s title, it is They [who] are the trouble’: I’ve been trying to find out who they are for years…. They are the trouble. …They throw heads when you back tails at the two-up. They run their horse dead. They rob you in the Parliament. They charge high rent. They start depressions. They cause wars. What they do is bad enough, but why can’t they ever learn? They’ll never learn. They wouldn’t wake up if an Adelaide River dunny fell on ‘em. They wouldn’t know horse dung from clay unless they tasted it. They can’t see any further than their noses. They’re sending the country broke. They say we’ve never had it so good. They won’t give a man a fair go. They conscript the twenty-year-olds. They sell the country out to the Yanks. They couldn’t run a raffle, mate; that’s for sure…. They start a lot of gossip, too. They say he married her
Gambling cultures
114
for her money. They say she had to get married. They say their marriage is on the rocks. They say he’s a bad pay. They say she’s a cupboard drinker…: Have another beer before they close the pub. (Hardy 1972b:150–2) Despite, or perhaps because of, such crudely conceptualised social relations of power, the ironically named ‘great Australian lover’, incarnation of the widely circulated 1970s figure of the ‘ocker’, prefers betting, shorts and thongs, fights, drinking, male mates and alcohol-induced vomiting to his wedding ceremony and honeymoon (Hardy 1972b:53, 1– 3; Harris 1974; Horne 1975). At best, some of Hardy’s Billy Borker yarns can be read as satirical criticisms of aspects of racism, economic exploitation and sexism as these practices are prevalent in various domains of popular culture, sites of gambling not least among them.
THE UNLUCKY AUSTRALIANS: POLITICAL WRITING AS THERAPEUTIC Hardy’s documentary-fictional The Unlucky Australians ([1968] 1972a) contrasts Borkertype ‘Australian gregariousness that leads a man to loneliness’ with the plight of Gurindji Aboriginal people on strike over conditions and rates of pay against the Vestey pastoral company’s organisation at Wave Hill in Australia’s Northern Territory (Hardy 1972a:1). Starting with the narrator’s ‘shame at the gambling debt’, the existentially formulated question ‘TAB or not TAB?’, the socially informed gambler’s Utopia of the Territory’s then legal betting shops where ‘there’s no racial prejudice’, and memories of a local wartime two-up school, the book comprises a narrative of transformation of introspective ‘guilt’ into energy for alignment with the Gurindji political struggle and for writing about ‘what has been done’ to Aborigines since white invasion and colonisation of the continent (Hardy 1972a:2, 8, 13, 20, 39, 68, 238; cf. Hornadge 1976:48–51). Socialist politics contest the gambling obsession by addressing dispossession, racism and cultural differences in both socio-economic and political terms. This political and cultural activity, made possible in Hardy’s case by a temporary resolution of the apparent contradiction between gambling and socialist practices, contributed to significant policy repercussions at a national level (Horne 1978; Whitlam 1978; Hardy 1978:319–40).
THE OUTCASTS OF FOOLGARAH: CARNIVAL OF THE OUTSIDERS The Outcasts of Foolgarah (1971b) is Hardy’s fictionalised and scatological story of a strike of garbage and night-soil carters. They are the workers involved as, in Marcuse’s words, ‘underneath the conservative popular base [in] the substratum of outcasts and outsiders’ (Marcuse 1964). Unincorporated into ‘the system’, they intrinsically oppose and resist that ‘system’ as ‘a rigged game’ (Hardy 1971b: epigraph). Such marginalised workers and lumpenproletarians are said to lack even the jockey’s benefit of ‘the percentage punter’ (Hardy 1971b: 8). Like Billy Borker, strike leader Chilla adheres to a
Representations of gambling in australia popular culture
115
populist rhetoric which demarcates ‘us’ and ‘them’ so it is once again ‘they’, including bookmakers and corrupt trade-union officials, who cause all economic trouble and social inequities (Hardy 1971b:189, also 129–30). Another major character in the novel is writer F.J.Borky, who is identified as an intellectual worker and soul-tortured by socialist history’s Stalinist vicissitudes. He is in solidarity with the strikers’ cause and enunciates the narrative’s Marcusian analysis. Borky is contextualised as typically surrounded by ‘racing paraphernalia’ which is used in an attempt to ‘supplement his income with racing systems’ (Hardy 1971b:98). Borky is beset by debts to, among others, bookmakers, and repeatedly distracted from literary and political commitments and work habits by an ostensibly irresistible attraction to TAB (that is, semi-independent state totaliser) establishments (Hardy 1971b:101). The novel’s narrative summarily diagnoses Borky as misled and divided by ‘the myth that he could make a big killing on the horses’ as well as by the, in many respects, sexist cultural mythology of’ Australian mateship’ and the Stalinist political mythology of ‘the just Communist society’ (Hardy 1971b: 167–8; Barthes 1973:145–8).
BUT THE DEAD ARE MANY: GAMBLING WITH SOCIALISM AT CHECKPOINT CHARLIE But the Dead Are Many: A Novel in Fugue Form (1975b) entails Hardy’s most fully elaborated critique of Stalinist political and social doctrines and policy arrangements, such as those concerning cultural and political mechanisms of representation, as these operated in both the Soviet Union and the increasingly fragmented Australian communist movement. The narrator-writer (the novel is formed and organised by multivocal narrative techniques), Jack, is ‘a compulsive gambler’, indulging in habits said to contribute to and enhance a writer’s creative capacity for alienation’: Jack was a compulsive gambler—but never played poker machines (never run up stairs, back odds-on favourites, take advice from a barber or play poker machines). Many of Jack’s characters were gamblers; he returned to the problem again and again. Of course, the test-of-fate theory of gambling came from one of Jack’s books. How did it go? A gambler fears to be rejected, so he tests fate. Jack claimed that a revolutionary shares this with the gambler: he fears rejection yet desires to be rejected by the society which has rejected and hurt him. He believed that the ambivalent psychological link of the revolutionary to the society he desires to destroy reflects the psychological link he has had with his parents. (Hardy 1975b:115–16)6 The intertextual resonances with complexly combined aspects of The Four-legged Lottery and The Outcasts of Foolgarah are evident. In the case of But the Dead Are Many, the nominated tensions between socialist politics and gambling practices are reconciled by the psycho-sociological mediating category of ‘creative…alienation’, as though the revolutionary-writer-gambler can somehow, at least intermittently, transcend
Gambling cultures
116
all social contradictions, pressures and limits other than the supposedly primary and determinant parental ones. In effect, But the Dead Are Many can be read as arguing that ‘the ultimate prize of life’s lottery’ is ‘the right to be transcended into memory’ (Hardy 1975b:116). This is presented as a democratically socialist alternative to existential liquidation and erasure of all material traces from official history, the fate of tens of millions of Stalinism’s victims (Hardy 1975b:270). For the Jack figure, a progressively more urgent ‘obsession’ with researching and writing about local and specific political issues, such as the suicide of his comrade John, ‘had long ago over-powered the gambling habit’ (Hardy 1975b:158–9).7 This sort of cultural and political integrity is contrasted with the character of Australian Stalinist functionary Trevor Duncan’s forging of strategic trade-union electoral ballots for the supposedly higher cause of progressive communist politics. Stalinism is thus shown as countenancing and even demanding corruption of various political and industrial forms of democracy as insurance against the (arrogantly ascribed) ‘false consciousness’ of those large sectors of the working-class constituency the historical best interests of which it claimed to represent.
LATER WRITINGS: LIFE’S A GAMBLE The catalogue of selected Hardy notations and statements concerning a plurality of different material cultural practices and social relations in which gambling is inscribed can be continued by noting the commentary of the comparatively recent short story, ‘Daily double’, on gambling as a sexually and economically compensatory obsession (Semmler n.d.: 218). According to this fictive account, gambling practices once again comprise an almost ritualistic consultation of ‘fate’—regarded as an unavoidable, fixed end—in order to divine its revelation as indicating either acceptance or rejection of the individual gambler (Semmler n.d.: 220, 227–9; Neumann and Eason 1990). At a less metaphysical level, the story may also be read as identifying successful gambling with the potential realisation of an intensely desired escape from restrictive limits of class and other social relations. Structured around patriarchal fantasies of flight to an idealised cosmopolitan lover, the short story articulates gambling with male-dominated heterosexuality in a witless and destructive politics of desire which elides any consideration or calculation of possible effects on those exploited by such a finally individualistic form of politics and pleasure. With different emphases, Hardy’s novel The Obsession of Oscar Oswald (1983a) suggests that ‘[d]ebt collection had become infiltrated by gangsters so that it had become the fourth biggest racket after drugs, prostitution and illegal gambling’ (1983a:132–3, 75). The short story, ‘The secret of Bandit Bertie’, positions the social ‘outcasts’ and ‘creatively alienated’ cultural workers as robbed by poker machines in ‘a game at which you’re not allowed to win’ (Semmler n.d.: 195, 200; cf. Lynch 1990). Despite the possibility of short-term successes, there is ‘never a perfect system’ (Hardy 1982:34). The group of short stories assembled under the title The Loser Now Will Be Later to Win (1985) restates the connections between gambling and other socio-political relations and practices. As almost an article of faith and antidote to the motif of ‘loss’, the
Representations of gambling in australia popular culture
117
collection uses as its epigraph some lyrics from a popular folk-song of the 1960s, Bob Dylan’s ‘The times they are a-changing’: And don’t speak too soon For the wheel’s still in spin And there’s no telling who that it’s naming ’Cause the loser now Will be later to win For the times they are a-changing. As a corrective to the Australian worker-battler’s perceived loss of control over the production of the future and prevailing accounts of the past, the stories assert that the ‘wheel’ of social fortune has not yet named its eventual victors. The ‘losers’ of the socioeconomic depressions of the 1890s, 1930s and 1970s to 1980s are nominated as the potential winners in a gamble of social change and transformation at the predicted end of capitalism’s history. The likely outcome of a national history of social contradictions and conflicts is thus calculated and bet on in Hardy’s politicised gamble of communication. The ideologies and rhetorics of 1890s radical nationalism, 1930s pro-Soviet Marxism, 1940s anarchism, 1960s Aboriginal cooperative cultural protocols, 1970s Eurocommunism and 1980s pro-feminist Trotskyism are presented as successively flawed but nevertheless indicative ‘form guides’ to a final triumph of the perpetual social ‘losers’ and resistant victims of a rigged capitalist ‘system’ (Hardy 1985:200). Worker characters are once more constituted as outcasts, as if outside a corporate capitalist system, and as having only a limited range of options of resistance and defiance. Hardy’s populist Marxist narrative strategies and explicitly politicised characterology connote fictive means of social transformation. In this making of books, they mortgage existing cultures to a future, more equitable polity and society. Frank Hardy continued to pursue gambling issues in his more journalistic writings for such popular and textually diverse ‘girlie’ and sensationalised ‘human interest’ magazines as People, Australasian Post and the Melbourne Herald-Sun newspaper, together with various plays. These widely read publications are overwhelmingly directed at and read by working-class male audiences in Australian cities and, in the case of the magazines, rural areas.8
CONCLUSIONS Power Without Glory and The Four-legged Lottery, respectively, are literary accounts of the power accrued by those organisations which manage gambling and the disastrous effects to which habitual gambling can contribute, from poverty and embezzlement to murder. They can be read as fictive supports of Hardy’s Journey into the Future call for Soviet-style public regulation of gambling and equitable distribution of those rewards paid out to gamblers. Thereby, it is contended, corrupt, illicit and manipulative bookmakers such as Power Without Glory’s West and The Four-legged Lottery’s Pittson would be displaced to the benefit of those working-class and other ‘battlers’ who engage
Gambling cultures
118
in gambling as a means of supplementary economic resistance to the depredations and exploitation of wage labour. However, these Utopian propositions beg the question of how state regulation of gambling procedures also deploys disciplinary powers through the techniques by which they individuate and police gamblers as, for instance, part of a ‘social problem’ to be addressed and governed medically and psychoanalytically. Despite Hardy’s relatively progressive notations and formulations on gambling, there is a less than socially equitable linking of gambling success to the assertion of patriarchal forms of (hetero)sexuality. For example, in Power Without Glory there is West’s tyrannical ‘after-all-I’ve-done-for-you’ household subordination of spouse Nellie and their daughter Mary; habitual gambling practices take place in exclusively male social groups in most of The Four-legged Lottery, with Jim Roberts and narrator Paul Whittaker justifying their gambling propensities as necessary to provide the women they are married to with what they deserve and what they crave respectively; in the short story ‘The system’, Australian artist Jack Cameron’s success at the roulette wheel in a European casino is presented as a precondition for the attraction, allurement and sexual conquest of both the Ruth and Collette characters; in the short story ‘Daily double’, gambling wins would make possible the male socialist artist character’s flight from a vauntedly stifling domestic and sexual relationship and to a European lover. Often in Hardy texts, accounts of the relations of gambling and art with household economic and other domestic arrangements presuppose socially produced gender differences and politics as simply the outcomes of ‘natural’, inevitable, irresistible and usually nonnegotiable desires (see, for example, Hardy quoted throughout Ridge 1982). These sorts of discriminations and emphases in the constitution of female and male characters, together with usual narrative and plot relations of subordination/ domination between them, quite precisely gamble with Hardy’s accumulated cultural and political capital as a notorious, egalitatian, socialist author writing at times when, increasingly, socially organised gender differences feature prominently in debates and political agendas of many institutional campaigns for changes in organisational and social policies. The texts, in dealing with gambling as a major theme, are also inseparable from ‘bets’ on how they will be made sense of and used by different readerships. They consist in compositional and distributional calculations or wagers on the likelihood of particular cultural and political effects and outcomes. That is to say, in the vernacular, the communicative gamble of the text is the risk incurred by the action of investing cultural capital, commitment and energy, of ‘putting your money where your mouth is’. For Hardy texts, when the politico-cultural lines of credit and credibility that had been available in the past, such as the plausibility of Soviet Marxism and Zhdanovite socialistrealist aesthetics during the 1940s, are no longer viable in the present, lines of flight are pursued. Fugitive tactics require the traverse of definite tracks leading to uncertain destinations and necessitating new estimations and mappings of different possibilities. For instance, But the Dead Are Many’s polyphonic form can be read as stressing the relative fluidity and possibility of equitably democratised institutional and wider social relations within and between classes, genders, cultural groups and political organisations. Frank Hardy’s writings have actively contributed to the repetition, with certain differences, of the selective and politically inflected tradition and mythology of ‘the Australian legend’, especially its emphases on collective egalitarian democracy and gambling proclivities. Overall, this work of composition has been carried out within a
Representations of gambling in australia popular culture
119
populist way of seeing the world’s historically produced realities, gambling practices among them.9 This way of seeing, or framework of techniques and assumptions concerning such popular cultural practices as gambling, demarcates an economic ‘base’ of state-supported monopoly capitalism that profits from its administration of gambling, and psychological ‘superstructures’ which impose relations of dependence on social individuals who become obsessed with gambling and its offerings of the elusive hope of financial security outside the pressures and demands of orthodox forms of wage-labour, taxation and capital accumulation (Dark 1966:13–14). From within such a framework, it can only be the ‘outcasts’ or ‘outsiders’ operating in the interstices of various institutions who battle to resist and evade incorporation into the allegedly pervasive and savagely functional socio-economic, political and cultural ‘system’. For all the problems of idealism, essentialism and residual Leninist politics entailed in this framework, at least Hardy’s writings address the ways in which gambling practices and social relations and differences are associated with cultural industries such as the media, the gambling of sport with the body, and tourism.10 Surrounded as it is by other accounts, especially in the press, his detailed attention to and intervention in the classdifferentiated but broadly popular cultural activities of gambling have earned Hardy literary-critical praise as ‘the chronicler of the turf’, on the one hand (Semmler n.d.: 11), and literary-political disdain as the creator of ‘the apotheosis of the racecourse urger’, on the other (Beasley 1979:55, 82, 88–91). Competing aesthetic and moral evaluations and judgements aside, however, Hardy’s consistently rewritten notations and statements (cultural hypotheses, proposals, propositions, deployments of particular rhetorical devices) suggest some significant social questions and knowledges about gambling as an item for cultural and policy agendas. In a career of living dangerously, Hardy’s writing has sustained as one of its conditions many calculated cultural strategies or gambles. Despite its popularity, but perhaps not surprisingly, such work has elicited more official denunciation than approval. In the end, readers are left with the unstably reconciled contradiction of But the Dead Are Many (and, to some extent, The Hard Way). Learned, habitual gambling affords socialist writer Jack a degree of ‘creative alienation’ from certain exploitative social relations, yet Stalinist functionaries such as the Trevor Duncan character can short-circuit forms of workplace democracy by ballot forgery. While there is an element of conscious voluntarism in Jack’s gambling activities, Duncan’s trade-union constituency loses without even knowing that it was in effect gambling in a rigged game where the die is already cast and certainty of outcome relatively assured.11 But if, as Jack Blake has argued, romantic voluntarism is a component of Stalinist and vanguardist insurrectionary politics, the other side of its ‘base’-‘superstructure’ model of social totality or ‘system’, then perhaps it is these voluntaristic practices and values which generate the contradictions and differences between gambling and socialist politics in Hardy’s writings (Blake 1971:49–73; and 1991:80–91). As with Stalinist politics, ‘means’ and ‘ends’ are functionally separated because of the uncertainty of the outcomes of gambling’s calculations.12 Yet, gambling is an attempt to overcome economic and social uncertainty just as Stalinism operated through the attempted erasure of political and historical uncertainty. A substantial gambling ‘killing’ on the horses or lottery or casino may comprise the undoubtedly pleasurable basis of a radically individualised social redistribution to relative wealth, security and status. However, this is a breach of anything
Gambling cultures
120
that can be classified as social solidarity because restricted access to the means of economic self-improvement through privatised economic expropriation does little to ameliorate or transform other social inequities of affluence and power. Indeed, it may serve to intensify them by focusing on the redistribution of wealth to thus privileged or ‘lucky’ individuals rather than on the social production, accumulation and use of it. The obsessive repetition, rewriting and intertextual echoes that mark Frank Hardy’s (re)presentations of gambling in popular cultural texts can be read as registering that the cultural practices and social relations involved in gambling are power-inscribed in terms of battling ‘punters’ acting to challenge an ostensibly rule-governed apparatus in the form of particular licit or illicit gambling establishments and authorities. Such social struggle entails relations of power between contradictory but necessarily connected positions, usually self-seeking and often tormenting, in differing and inequitable ways, for the different parties involved. The certainty of gambling’s uncertainty, its widely and often unconsciously learned conventions and rules, its enactment of socially grounded techniques and hopes—all of these culturally active factors are different from but not unrelated to the democratically organised forms of political and cultural work necessary for transformations that will produce more equitable social conditions and a halt to government of populations that brings with it very real material risks and threats of poverty, further disempowerment and cultural denigration. What Hardy’s writings on the politics of gambling practices and their effects enable us to conclude is that, socially and politically at least, there can be no last big bet, no absolute closure or final solution. As Polan has argued so convincingly, ‘the gamble is not a once-for-all attempt at liberty’ but, rather, the strategic condition for constant and never certain outcomes of incessant negotiations between different institutions, social agencies and groups (Polan 1984:193).13 For resilience and courage in promoting fairness and social justice in this and other regards, Frank Hardy should not be forgotten. After all, he may very well have taught his readers many valuable political and history lessons.
NOTES 1 Other, more historically and theoretically elaborated versions of this chapter were published in McMillen n.d.: unpaginated; in Williams 1987a; and in Williams 1987b: 564–622. For their constructive critical comments and bibliographical advice on this work I am very grateful to Catherine Greenfield, Noel King, Frank Hardy and Ian Hunter, also to Jan McMillen, Chilla Bulbeck, K.K.Ruthven and John Frow. Responsibility for the chapter’s final formulations is my own, of course. 2 In the novel’s straightforward dialectical structure the third section, ‘Decline of power’ (synthesis), is the narrative product of interaction between the second section, ‘Abuse of power’ (antithesis), and the first section, ‘Road to power’ (thesis). 3 This notion of the political correction of gambling habits and other diversions from forms of social solidarity was also put forward in the early Hardy short story, ‘A stranger in the camp’ (1944 in Hardy n.d.; see also Dutton 1991:40). 4 On the masculinist inflections of presentations of gambling milieu and ambience in Power Without Glory and The Four-legged Lottery, see Lees and Senyard (1987:26, 87–8). More broadly and historically, on the effects of gambling on women in Australia, see Summers (1975:70–4) and Morris (1992:40).
Representations of gambling in australia popular culture
121
5 On the popular cultural adjacency of gambling and radio, see Kisch ([1937] 1969:224), Andrews (1979:44) and, especially, Johnson (1981:168, 171, 175). 6 Connections between gambling practices, doctrinal certainties and fugitivity are also illuminatingly discussed in Robert Bradshaw’s autobiography (1986:102, 104, 222, 235, 243, 245). 7 On the formation and regulation of institutionally inscribed individual conduct in relation to ‘obsessions’ and dreams, see Hirst and Woolley (1982:137). 8 Many of these often recycled and rewritten pieces have been collected and assembled as books; see, for example, Hardy (1986:11–13, 28–30, 37–40, 67–71, 78–81, 123–5, 165–7, 186–9, 193–6) for repetitions of the Billy Borker populism and the figure of the Australian ‘battler’. On various cultural, economic and political forms and instances of gambling and associated corruption, see Hardy (1988:2–4, 7, 26, 39–40, 48–50, 52, 67, 74, 92–5, 107–8, 146–52, 157, 176–81; 1990:vii, 23–5, 55–9, 103–24, 146–60, 183–91; 1991a; 1991b; 1991c; 1991d; 1991e). Regarding Hardy the play-wright on gambling, see the tribute to his late sister (Hardy 1992:16–18, 52, 59, 66). 9 See Greenfield (1985) on the constitutive elements of populism. 10 This is a significant advance on, for instance, prevalent and generalised notions of gambling as a social leveller in the liberal cultural criticism of Horne and Beal (1967:41) and McGregor (1966:125–7, 148–9; cf. Crisp 1987). 11 On the ‘dual standards of morality’ that ‘substitute the party’s experience for that of backward and prejudiced workers’ through techniques of ‘ballot adjustment’, see Gollan (1980:323–4). See, also Hardy (1988:176–81; 1990:187–91). 12 On Stalinist separations of ‘ends’ from ‘means’ and the authoritarian political consequences, see Hirst (1986:27–47). 13 Concerning the material social conditions in which everyday and mundane decisions are made, the relations of power and styles of reasoning involved, see Hindess (1989).
BIBLIOGRAPHY Andrews, B. (1979) ‘The willow tree and the laurel: Australian sport and Australian literature’, in R.Cashman and M.McKernan (eds) Sport in History: The Making of Modern Sporting History, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press: 43–67. Barret, R.G. (1987) The Boys from Binjiwunyawunya, Sydney: Pan. Barthes, R. (1973) Mythologies, trans. A.Lavers, Frogmore: Paladin. Beasley, J. (1979) Red Letter Days: Notes from Inside an Era, Sydney: Australasian Book Society. Blake, J.D. (1971) Revolution from Within—A Contemporary Theory of Social Change, Sydney: Outlook. ——(1991) ‘Perestroika and the Stalinist legacy’, Journal of Australian Political Economy 28:80– 91. Blakey, G.G. (ed.) (1979) The Gambler’s Companion, New York: Paddington. Bradshaw, R. (1986) The Fugitive Years, Ringwood: Penguin. Brennan, N. (1971) John Wren: Gambler—His Life and Times, Melbourne: Hill of Content. Buggy, H. (1977) The Real John Wren, Camberwell: Widescope. Cantrell, L. (ed.) (1977) The 1890s: Stories, Verse, and Essays, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press. Cappiello, R.R. (1984) Oh Lucky Country, trans. G.Rando, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press. Carey, P. (1988) Oscar and Lucinda, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press. Carroll, J. (1977) Puritan, Paranoid and Remissive: A Sociology of Modern Culture, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Gambling cultures
122
Childs, K. (ed.) (1984) A Month of Lunches: Twenty-eight Lives Celebrate Melbourne, Melbourne: Oxford University Press. Crisp, L. (1987) ‘To share an obsession’, Times on Sunday (15 March): 24–5. Cusack, D. (n.d.) Picnic Races, Melbourne: Readers Book Club. Cusack, D. and James, F. (1988) Come in Spinner, North Ryde: Angus & Robertson. Dark, E. (1966) Lantana Lane, Sydney: Humourbook. Deleuze, G. and Guattari, F. (1981) ‘Rhizome: Introduction’, trans. P.Foss and P.Patton, I & C 8:49–71. Docker, J. (1984) In a Critical Condition: Reading Australian Literature, Ringwood: Penguin. Doogue, J. (1982) The Writer and the Law, Geelong: School of Humanities, Deakin University. Dutton, M. (1991) ‘The force of words’, Australian Left Review 125:39–41. Eldershaw, F.S. (1950) ‘Bastardry, bastardry, bastardry’, Meanjin 9(3):222–5. Fox, C. (1988) ‘In search of a fair bet’, in V.Burgmann and J.Lee (eds) Constructing a Culture: A People’s History of Australia Since 1799, Ringwood: McPhee Gribble/ Penguin: 77–95. ——(1990) ‘Hedging their bets: street bookmakers and suburban space’, Westerly 4: 18–25. Fricke, G. (1984) Libels, Lampoons and Litigants: Famous Australian Libel Cases, Melbourne: Hutchinson. Frow, J. (1982) ‘Who shot Frank Hardy? Intertextuality and textual politics’, Southern Review 15(1):22–39. Gollan, D. (1980) ‘The memoirs of “Cleopatra Sweet-figure”’, in E.Windschuttle (ed.) Women, Class and History: Feminist Perspectives on Australia 1788–1988, Auckland: Fontana/Collins: 313–29. Gordon, H. (1988) An Eyewitness History of Australia, Ringwood: Penguin. Greenfield, C. (1985) ‘“In the people’s name”: populism as a political form’, Australian Journal of Cultural Studies 3(2):89–103. Hardy, F. (n.d.) ‘The Man from Clinkapella’ and Other Prize-Winning Stories, Auburn: Capricorn. ——(1952) Journey into the Future, Melbourne: Australasian Book Society. ——(1963) Legends from Benson‘s Valley, London: Werner Laurie. ——(1965) The Yarns of Billy Borker, Sydney: Ure Smith. ——(1966) ‘Environment and ideology in Australian literature: a personal view’, in C. Semmler (ed.) (n.d.) A Frank Hardy Swag, Sydney: Harper & Row: 237–48. ——(1971a) The Hard Way: The Story Behind ‘Power Without Glory’, Hawthorn: Gold Star. ——(1971b) The Outcasts of Foolgarah, Melbourne: Allara. ——(1971c) ‘The life and hard times of John Wren revisited’, The Review 20–6 (Nov.): 186–7. ——(1972a) The Unlucky Australians, Hawthorn, Melbourne: Gold Star (London: Pan, 2nd edn, 1978). ——(1972b) ‘The Great Australian Lover’ and Other Stories, Melbourne: Thomas Nelson. ——(1972c) It’s Moments Like These, Melbourne: Gold Star. ——(1975a) Power Without Glory, Frogmore: Panther. ——(1975b) But the Dead Are Many: A Novel in Fugue Form, Sydney: The Bodley Head. ——(1977) The Four-legged Lottery, Sydney: Fontana. ——(1981) Who Shot George Kirkland? A Novel about the Nature of Truth, Port Melbourne: Edward Arnold. ——(1982) ‘The system’, Australian Short Stories, Christmas issue: 33–43. ——(1983a) The Obsession of Oscar Oswald, Carlton: Pascoe. ——(1983b) ‘Self-portraits’, Australian Book Review 52:13–14. ——(1985) The Loser Now Will Be Later to Win, Carlton: Pascoe. ——(1986) Hardy’s People, Fairfield: Pascoe. ——(1988) Great Australian Legends, Sydney: Hutchinson. ——(1990) Retreat Australia Fair and other Great Australian Legends, Sydney: Hutchinson. ——(1991a) ‘Tabaret’s a rort!’, Australasian Post (19 Jan.): 38. ——(1991b) ‘Casinos spell crime and doom’, Australasian Post (26 Jan.): 39.
Representations of gambling in australia popular culture
123
——(1991c) ‘Punting is a health hazard’, Australasian Post (9 Feb.): 39. ——(1991d) ‘Who’s behind the SP boom?’, Australasian Post (23 Feb.): 38. ——(1991e) ‘Me and me puntin’ mates’, Australasian Post (9 Nov.): 42. ——(1992) Mary Lives, Sydney: Currency. Hardy, F. and Mulley, A.G. (1975) The Needy and the Greedy: Humorous Stories of the Racetrack, Canberra: Libra. Harris, M. (1974) Ockers: Essays on the Bad Old New Australia, Adelaide: Maximus. Hayllar, T. and Sadler, R. (eds) (1982) Aussie Humour, Melbourne: Nelson. Headon, D. (1988) ‘Given by God, sport of kings, or a mug’s game: horse racing in Australian literature’, Sporting Traditions 5(1):30–50. Hindess, B. (1989) Political Choice and Social Structure: An Analysis of Actors, Interests and Rationality, Aldershot: Edward Elgar. Hirst, P. (1986) Law, Socialism and Democracy, Sydney: Allen & Unwin. Hirst, P. and Woolley, P. (1982) Social Relations and Human Attributes, London: Tavistock. Hornadge, B. (1976) The Yellow Peril: A Squint at Some Australian Attitudes towards Orientals, 2nd edn, Dubbo: Review Publications. Horne, D. (1975) ‘Ockerism’, Meanjin 34(4):462–7. ——(1978) ‘Foreword’ to Hardy, The Unlucky Australians, London: Pan. Horne, D. and Beal, D. (1967) Southern Exposure, Sydney: Collins. Hunter, I. (1984a) ‘Literary discipline’, Southern Review 17(2):129–34. ——(1984b) ‘After representation: recent discussions of the relation between language and literature’, Economy and Society 13(4):397–430. ——(1991) ‘From discourse to Dispositif: Foucault and the study of literature’, Meridian 10(2):36– 53. Ikin, V. (1984) Untitled review of D.Stivens Jimmy Brockett, Westerly 29(1):91–3. Inglis, K. (1985) ‘Gambling and culture in Australia’ in G.Caldwell, B.Haig, M. Dickerson and L.Sylvan (eds) Gambling in Australia, Sydney: Croom Helm: 5–17. Johnson, L. (1981) ‘Radio and everyday life: the early years of broadcasting in Australia, 1922– 1945’, Media, Culture and Society 3:167–78. Kisch, E. ([1937] 1969) Australian Landfall, trans. J.Fisher, I. and K.Fitzgerald, South Melbourne: Macmillan. Kramer, L. (1985) ‘The media, society and culture’, in S.R.Graubard (ed.) Australia: The ‘Daedalus’ Symposium, North Ryde: Angus & Robertson: 293–310. Lees, S. and Senyard, J. (1987) The 1950s: How Australia Became a Modern Society and Everyone Got a House and a Car, Melbourne: Hyland House. Lynch, R. (1990) ‘Working-class luck and vocabularies of hope among regular poker-machine players’ in D.Rowe and G.Lawrence (eds) Sport and Leisure: Trends in Australian Popular Culture, Sydney: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich: 189–208. McCalman, J. (1984) Struggletown: Portrait of an Australian Working-Class Community, Ringwood: Penguin. McCoy, A. (n.d.) ‘Sport as modern mythology: SP bookmaking in New South Wales 1920–1979’ in R.Cashman and M.McKernan (eds) Sport: Money, Morality and the Media, Kensington: New South Wales University Press: 34–67. McGregor, C. (1966) Profile of Australia, London: Hodder & Stoughton. McKernan, S. (1984) ‘“Literature in a straitjacket”’, in A.Curthoys and J.Merritt (eds) Australia’s First Cold War, 1945–1953, vol. 1: Society, Communism and Culture, Sydney: George Allen & Unwin: 137–52. McLaren, J. (1988) ‘Poets against novelists—Cold War courts and crusades’, Journal of Australian Studies 22:83–93. McMillen, J. (ed.) (n.d.) Gambling in the 80s: Proceedings of the Inaugural Conference of the National Association for Gambling Studies (NAGS), Nathan: School of Humanities, Griffith University.
Gambling cultures
124
Marcuse, H. (1964) One-Dimensional Man, Boston: Beacon Press. Marshall, A. (1984) ‘The bicycle race’, Australian Short Stories 2(6):1–5. Mitchell, A. (1981) ‘Fiction’, in L.Kramer (ed.) The Oxford History of Australian Literature, Melbourne: Oxford University Press: 27–172. Morris, M. (1992) Ecstasy and Economics: American Essays for John Forbes, Sydney: E M Press. Morrison, J. (1984) Stories of the Waterfront, Ringwood: Penguin. Neumann, M. and Eason, D. (1990) ‘Casino world: bringing it all back home’, Cultural Studies 4(1):45–60. O’Hara, J. (n.d.) ‘The Australian gambling tradition’, in R.Cashman and M.McKernan (eds) Sport: Money, Morality and the Media, Kensington: New South Wales University Press: 68–85. Palmer, V. (1951) ‘Australian letter’, Landfall 5(4):292–5. ——(1954) The Legend of the Nineties, Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Phillips, A.A. (1958) The Australian Tradition, Melbourne: Cheshire. Polan, A.J. (1984) Lenin and the End of Politics, London: Methuen. Pollak, M. (1990) Sense and Censorship: Commentaries on Censorship Violence in Australia, Balgowlah: Reed. Prichard, K.S. (1926) Working Bullocks, London: Jonathan Cape. ——(n.d.) The Real Russia, Sydney: Modern Publishers. Richardson, H.H. (1946) The Fortunes of Richard Mahony, Melbourne: William Heinemann. Ridge, V. (1982) ‘“I know ALL about women”’, Prime Time (Nov.): 2–3. Semmler, C. (ed.) (n.d.) A Frank Hardy Swag, Sydney: Harper & Row. Smith, G. (1985) ‘Making folk music’, Meanjin 44(4):477–90. Stivens, D. (1951) Jimmy Brockett: Portrait of a Notable Australian, Sydney: Angus & Robertson. Stoddart, B. (1986) Saturday Afternoon Fever: Sport in the Australian Culture, North Ryde: Angus & Robertson. Summers, A. (1975) Damned Whores and God’s Police: The Colonisation of Women in Australia, Ringwood: Penguin. Vamplew, W. (1988) ‘Tales we win: recent works on the history of gambling in Australia’, Sporting Traditions 4(2):234–9. Wannan, B. (ed.) (1954) The Australian: Yarns, Ballads, Legends, Traditions of the Australian People, Adelaide: Rigby. Ward, R. (1958) The Australian Legend, Melbourne: Oxford University Press. ——(1978) ‘The Australian legend re-visited’, Historical Studies 18(71):171–90. Welcome, J. (1967) ‘Nat Gould novelist of the turf’, London Magazine 7:54–9. Whitlam, E.G. (1978) ‘Introduction’ to Hardy, The Unlucky Australians, London: Pan. Wilkes, G.A. (ed.) (1980) A Dictionary of Australian Colloquialisms, Melbourne: Fontana/Collins. ——(1981) The Stockyard and the Croquet Lawn: Literary Evidence for Australian Cultural Development, Port Melbourne: Edward Arnold. Williams, P. (1987a) ‘Gambling with socialism: a Hardy obsession’, Southern Review 20(1):69–87. ——(1987b) ‘Writing, reading, politics: an analysis of some debates within and around the institution of literature in Australia with particular reference to the work of Frank Hardy’, two volumes, Unpublished PhD thesis, Griffith University. Williams, R. (1981) Culture, Glasgow: Fontana. ——(1989) Resources of Hope: Culture, Democracy, Socialism, R.Gable (ed.), London: Verso. Wilson, R.R. (1990) In Palamedes’ Shadow: Explorations in Play, Game and Narrative Theory, Boston: Northeastern University Press. Wittgenstein, L. (1979) On Certainty, G.E.M. Anscombe and G.H.von Wright (eds), trans. D.Paul and Anscombe, Oxford: Blackwell.
7 BINGO IN BRITAIN An analysis of gender and class Rachael Dixey1
The 1960 Betting and Gaming Act can be claimed as the most significant landmark in the history of commercial bingo in Great Britain. The Act was designed to clear up the confusion and anomalies which existed in Britain’s gaming laws. It was warmly received by both public and media as bringing legislation into line with the times. ‘Sense at last’, wrote the News Chronicle, whilst the Daily Telegraph exclaimed, ‘Betting and Gaming laws are a nettle which at last the Government—to its credit—has grasped’ (Newman 1972:4). The Act may have been successful in its primary objective, that of legalising and controlling ‘off-course’ cash betting, but it created a number of loopholes and opportunities such that the initial optimism surrounding its introduction quickly faded. The Act, it was felt, had two undesirable consequences. First, according to Levin, ‘although the blameless housewife and the deserving vicar had indeed benefited from the legislation, so had others far less innocent’ (Levin 1970:13). In other words, the gambling industry underwent rapid expansion and there emerged a highly respectable entrepreneurial sector. Perfect businessmen like Cyril Stein of Ladbroke’s with his accounting and banking background, took over from Rogue Honest Joe as the men behind the emergent safe industry of huge turnovers and high profits and low overheads…the legalised gambling entrepreneurs had come to stay. (Fuller 1974:43) Betting turnover increased by 154 per cent in 1961; by 1 June 1961, 13,340 licences for betting shops were in operation (Cornish 1978:22). Second, the Act appeared to encourage more people to gamble. In the absence of reliable research, it is not known whether this is the case; certainly cash betting turnover did in