gale e-commerce sourcebook
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii Preface and User’s Guide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .xiii
VOLUME 1 ‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce Accounting Practices in E-Commerce . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Advertising on Your Web Site . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Advertising Your Web Site . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Anticipating the Size of Your Market . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Application Service Providers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Authoring Software . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Bandwidth Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Bricks-and-Clicks versus Pure Play E-Commerce . . 12 Business Planning for Online Enterprise . . . . . . . . 13 Business-to-Business Exchange (B2B). . . . . . . . . . 10 Business-to-Consumer (B2C) Exchange . . . . . . . . 17 Business-to-Government (B2G) E-Commerce . . . 18 Call Center Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Consumer Privacy Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 Currency Issues in Electronic Commerce . . . . . . . 23 Customer Relationship Management . . . . . . . . . . . 25 Customer Touch Points. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 Data Integrity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 Data Mining . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 Data Warehousing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 Databases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 Day Trading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 Differentiation Techniques in E-Commerce . . . . . 35 Digital Authentication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Disaster Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 E-Branding Strategies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 E-Commerce Business Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 E-Commerce Education and Training . . . . . . . . . . 43 E-Commerce Hardware Needs. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
E-Commerce Incubators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E-Commerce Standards. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Electronic Banking for Businesses . . . . . . . . . . . . . Employee Retention. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Essential Reading in E-Commerce . . . . . . . . . . . . . Establishing an Online Newsletter . . . . . . . . . . . . . Free versus Subscription-Based Services. . . . . . . . Harvest and Exit Strategies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hiring Consultants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Insurance Issues for Online Firms . . . . . . . . . . . . . Intellectual Property Online . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Internet Job Creation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Legacy Systems, Processes, and People . . . . . . . . Legal Considerations of E-Commerce . . . . . . . . . . Limitations of Online Enterprises . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M-Commerce . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Managing Change . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Managing and Evolving a Global Presence . . . . . Managing Industry Life Cycles in E-Commerce. . . . Managing Inventory. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Marketing Plans for Online Enterprises. . . . . . . . . Merchant Accounts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mergers and Acquisitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Metatag Strategy and Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Multilingual Issues in E-Commerce . . . . . . . . . . . . Multimedia in E-Commerce. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Network Topologies in E-Commerce . . . . . . . . . . . Ongoing Internet Marketing. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Online Auctions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Online Content Management and Provision . . . . . Online Freelancing. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Online Profiling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Online Sources of Market Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Online Transactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Operating Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
45 46 48 49 50 53 55 56 57 58 60 61 63 64 65 66 68 69 71 72 73 75 76 77 79 81 82 83 84 85 87 88 90 91 93 v
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Outsourcing Options . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 P2P Exchange . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 Package Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 Payment Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98 Performance Metrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 Product Life Cycles in E-Commerce . . . . . . . . . . 100 Product Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 Programming Languages. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103 Project Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104 Proprietary Systems versus Out-of-Box Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 Return on Investment (ROI) Metrics for ECommerce Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106 Securing Financing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 Security in E-Commerce Systems. . . . . . . . . . . . . 109 Servers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111 Shared and Co-Sponsored Sites. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112 Shopping Cart Software . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113 Software Development Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 Supply Chain Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 116 Supply Logistics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 Transforming Business Strategies . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118 Using Print Media to Support Online Media . . . 120 Voice Commerce . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Web Portals. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 123 Web Rings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 124 Web Site Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125
Web Site Interactivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Web Site Life Cycles and Maintenance. . . . . . . . Web Site Usability. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XML and Metadata . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Directory of E-Commerce Associations, Consultants, and Other Organizations Associations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Computer Software . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Consultants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
E - C O M M E R C E
133 172 325
VOLUME 2 Directory of E-Commerce Associations, Consultants, and Other Organizations (continued) Consultants (continued). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Educational Programs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Government Regulatory Agencies. . . . . . . . . . . . . Publications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Trade Shows & Conventions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Website Designers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Website Hosting Companies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Directory of Leading E-Commerce Companies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ranking by Revenue . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ranking by Number of Employees. . . . . . . . . . . . General Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vi G A L E
126 128 129 130
S O U R C E B O O K
487 537 660 667 689 758 871 891 919 921 923
INTRODUCTION
By the early 2000s, it seemed almost banal to assert that the Internet has effected revolutionary change, not only in the world of computers and communications, but in the broader realms of human civilization, including areas of economics, culture, social relations, language, and politics. That fact served to reinforce how thoroughly entrenched the transformation has become in society and in the public mind. In extending its tentacles to ever further spheres of human interaction, the Internet itself was being transformed as well. At the outset of the 21st century, users of the Internet at all levels—from the average Web surfer to the technician, from activists to policy makers, from consumers to entrepreneurs—were in the process of defining the Internet&rsquouo;s character and the place it would secure within society. A flexible technology and medium, the Internet was ultimately defined by its uses, which continue to develop and expand. Thus, with business developments playing a crucial role in the Internet’s makeup, entrepreneurs were well positioned to play a key role in impacting, if not determining, the Internet’s future and, accordingly, many aspects of society at large. Those entrepreneurs engaging in e-commerce activities, in particular, were of special importance in the early years of the 2000s as the initial dot-com hype wore off and the e-commerce industry began to search out new paradigms for online commercial activity. The literature on e-commerce—its opportunities for riches, its technical workings, its effects on culture and society, and its potential dangers—could fill miles of shelf space in our libraries. In particular, books seeking to instruct budding entrepreneurs in the art of conquering the dot-com jungle comprise a vast publishing niche in their own right. To date, however, the literature has lacked a single comprehensive reference source designed to be of use to existing and aspiring entrepreneurs, students, researchers, and interested laypersons. Such a comprehensive source can
be found in the Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook, which consists not only of practical knowledge and instruction, but also includes detailed directory data and resource contact-information, allowing readers to follow through with their research in an efficient and pragmatic way. The Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook exists to fill this gap in the literature, answering in simple terms the many questions that arise in the course of establishing or running an e-commerce firm.
E-COMMERCE: HOW WE GOT HERE The Internet, born in the 1960s of Pentagon-funded experiments into cutting-edge military communications, blossomed into a research and informationexchange medium of particular use to academics in the 1970s and 1980s, and finally into the backbone for email, the World Wide Web, and other popular communications in the 1990s. By the end of the 20th century, few people in the United States were completely without access to the Internet, either at home or via libraries or commercial venues. Meanwhile, the Web itself, designed to universalize Internet usage, grew into a sweeping economic force as, it seemed, the entire commercial universe was rapidly whisked into cyberspace through the mid- and late 1990s, all the while transforming the manner in which business is conducted. In this latter stage, businesses grew increasingly interested in these technologies for their own strategies, and looked to the Internet and the Web as a potentially vast new market, upon which one needed to capitalize quickly to establish a firm presence. Meanwhile, there arose a tremendous literature in business circles geared toward new business models centered on or incorporating Internet communications and technology. But coinciding as it did with the broader economic boom of the 1990s, and as Internet
A NEW ECONOMY?
vii G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
INTRODUCTION
stocks defied gravity and traditional economic logic in the late 1990s, this transformation in the economic landscape gave rise to a new crop of literature pointing to the Internet, e-commerce, and information technologies as hallmarks of a New Economy, a fundamentally new epoch in economic history in which the old rules—including the business cycle and traditional business models and wisdom—no longer applied. Such musings were fiercely debated, but the ideas were taken seriously enough to occupy huge quantities of space in the business press, economic journals, and political and popular discourse, while in the stock market the economic stalwarts appeared to shift from blue chips like IBM, General Motors, and General Electric to digital-age hot shots such as AOL, Amazon.com, and Yahoo!. Meanwhile, flamboyant and brash entrepreneurs such as broadcast.com founder Mark Cuban and Buy.com’s chief Scott Blum epitomized the business heroes of the day, displacing the more staid and conservative leaders of yesteryear. Cuban, for his part, grew highly visible in the late 1990s as a prolific public speaker, extolling his vision of e-commerce as the medium that would consume commercial activity as we know it. Blum, meanwhile, overtly and proudly eschewed all traditional business sense, styling his company as a daring trailblazer in e-commerce. On the way, Blum built Buy.com into the second-largest online retailer, after Amazon.com. All the while, commentators enthusiastic about the emergent New Economy held up these entrepreneurs’ business models as hallmarks of the future, chiding others to drop their antiquated Old Economy thinking and embrace the future in the making. Lending some credence to such seemingly extreme views, stock valuations in the dot-com revolution were divorced from traditional bases, such as fundamentals, profits, and long-term growth strategies. Those insisting that this constituted a mere speculation bubble were regularly denounced as cranks clinging to the old mode of thinking. And, for a while, the market kept proving the enthusiasts right. For instance, analysts insisted in 1997 that Yahoo!’s stock was grossly overvalued, but an investor who had accepted that analysis and sold out would have missed out on a tremendous financial windfall, as Yahoo!’s stock continued its upward surge through the rest of the decade. When the Dow Jones Industrial Average broke the unimaginably high 10,000 barrier in March 1999, even skeptics began to wonder if the economy had indeed entered unprecedented territory, and whether information technology now guaranteed us more or less continual economic expansion. THE DOT-COM BUSINESS MODEL. Through this period, a dominant model among dot-com firms (especially true for pure-plays) began to emerge, differing
markedly from any previous model and particularly novel given its tremendous success. In this model long-term plans for profitability, attention to the bottom line, and concern for internally funded growth and development were almost completely abandoned. The goal was to explode on the scene fueled by venture capital, make a lucrative initial public offering (IPO), watch the firm’s stock value catapult into the stratosphere, and then liquidate or sell out to a larger firm. Frequently, this process was repeated several times by the same individuals, producing a class of ‘‘serial entrepreneurs.’’ As noted, investors failed to disappoint. Convinced they were sitting on top of the greatest financial goldmine of the era, venture capitalists and others poured enormous sums into just about every company with a ‘‘.com’’ appended to its name. Thus, e-commerce firms stayed afloat overwhelmingly on investor dollars, which, during the boom years, proved to be an especially lucrative practice but one that planted the seeds of volatility. With few viable means of selfsustaining income, these companies were rendered almost entirely dependent on the whims of the stock market and the attractiveness of their firms in the venture capital markets, a market which, through this period, was in large part based on hype-driven trends and herd-like investment patterns. With such copious flows of investment capital, dot-coms could afford to engage in highly unorthodox pricing strategies, undercutting their competitors by wide margins to draw in customers. But with little planning or organizational preparation to handle the business that came in, e-commerce firms were notorious for their dismal order-handling performance, and the complaints rolled in and were echoed in the press, leading to the first wave of a backlash that would culminate in the tech-market crash. Meanwhile, although these pricing strategies succeeded in winning customers from competitors, there was little actual money being made due to the low pricing for products and services, and thus such firms still failed to generate their own stable revenue streams, continuing their dependence on investment capital. Finally, since rapid growth and staking a claim to the emergent Internet market were seen as chief priorities, dot-coms sunk enormous quantities of capital into splashy advertising schemes to grab the public’s attention. DOT-COMS
viii G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
GO
BUST,
AND
E-COMMERCE
MA-
Finally, in the first half of 2000, the New Economy began to come apart at the seams as the tech market went bust and the cushion of investment capital was pulled out from under the dot-com crowd. E-commerce outfits folded up their tents by the dozens, resulting in a massive shakeout as startups scrambled to make themselves attractive to acquisition or simply exited the market altogether. In the following
TURES.
S O U R C E B O O K
Following the crash, both established, surviving dot-coms and brick-and-mortar firms hardly retreated from e-commerce. Amidst the wreckage, larger firms swallowed up smaller ones and integrated their Internet expertise and market footings into their own operations. But the practice of emerging hard and fast on an endless supply of investment dollars, with only cursory planning for the long term and little grounding in traditional business wisdom, was simply no longer an available option, as this strategy rested on e-commerce’s novelty and hype, and investors’ attendant rush to capitalize on the trend. As for the New Economy, the reality in the early 2000s points to a middle ground between the hyperenthusiasts and the more vitriolic nay sayers. Technological innovations, and the Internet in particular, have indeed produced substantial alterations in the productive workings of the economy, and e-commerce has drastically transformed the ways in which business is conducted, but old laws, such as the importance of planning for sustainable profitability, remain firmly intact.
environment for the various actors with whom e-commerce firms regularly come into contact. Comprehending the relationship between e-commerce and these groups is a vital component of the entrepreneur’s arsenal of knowledge. Among the many lasting changes to the make-up of businesses as a result of e-commerce and its information-technology architecture was the organizational structure. Relative to their forebears, companies in the Internet age are diffusely organized, operating across vast, interlocking networks, often irrespective of geographical or international boundaries. Inter- and intrafirm networking are now the norm, and this calls for more than simply ‘‘getting connected.’’ Rather, networks must be strategically and creatively designed to foster specific kinds of relationships and flows of information for optimal efficiency and competitive advantage.
BUSINESSES.
Production methods have evolved from the mass production techniques of the Fordist era to flexible production procedures organized across diffuse networks, coordinated by highly integrated information technology incorporating all facets of the firm’s operations, from supply logistics to inventories, from orders to shipping information. The earlier, Fordist model proved simply too rigid and costly for the diversified and rapidly changing market conditions of the e-commerce era, and in its place are such developments as information technology-based supply chain management, just-in-time inventory, mass customization, and other innovations.
THE INTERNET AND E-COMMERCE: LASTING CHANGES
Also generally proven to be too rigid and antithetical to the needs of e-commerce and Internet-based production are the scientific management theories of Frederick Winslow Taylor, known as Taylorism, which served as the dominant mode of business management, particularly for large corporations with extensive bureaucracies, through the 20th century. Characterized by highly regimented flows of information and authority, Taylorism broke down corporations into their components and designed each for optimal efficiency via elaborate systems of rules. In this way, control was concentrated in the hands of skilled professional managers and organized hierarchically. In the Internet age, with a premium on ‘‘knowledge workers’’ and creative innovation, firms are increasingly organized more horizontally, with diverse and interweaving flows of information for maximum knowledge sharing.
Though the glory years may be over, and e-commerce entrepreneurs must come to terms with a rougher reality in which meticulous planning and innovative creativity are required for success, it is crucial to understand the ways that the Internet and ecommerce have transformed the economic and social
CONSUMERS. The experience of the customer was among the most dramatically transformed components of the e-commerce era. Accustomed to simple pricing comparisons, 24-hour access, without respect to geography, and without ever having to leave their homes, customers are afforded incomparable convenience,
The Internet economy didn’t consume the Old Economy, nor did brick-and-mortars triumph over ecommerce. Rather, the early 2000s are marked by a growing synthesis between these two realms, to the point where it no longer makes sense to dwell on divisions between two types of economies: there is now simply the economy, driven in part by, but also transforming, the Internet and e-commerce. E-commerce business models in the 21st century can no more afford to abandon traditional business thinking than brick-and-mortar firms can afford to ignore ecommerce.
INTRODUCTION
years, the stock markets continued to flounder, remaining well below their boom-cycle peaks. While these events were certainly couched within a broader trend in the economy and in the technology sector in particular, the tremendous hype about the e-commerce-driven New Economy and the novelty and brashness of the dot-com model produced a vicious backlash. E-commerce became the poster sector for late 1990s ‘‘irrational exuberance,’’ an apt term coined by Federal Reserve Board chairman Alan Greenspan.
ix G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
INTRODUCTION
and their expectations have been heightened accordingly. ‘‘The customer is always right’’ is an adage that has rarely carried such significance, as consumers grow familiar with the bevy of innovative customerservice schemes already in place. From easy access to account information to personalized shopping at their favorite Web sites, the demands of customers have never been as crucial to a firm’s operations; thus, any business’s successful e-commerce strategy must place a premium on getting to know customers and earning their trust. The Internet economy offered workers a markedly different environment than that in most traditional offices. Dot-coms lured many skilled knowledge-workers, who were looking to circumvent the standard corporate model, with flexible hours, a casual work environment, creative input, control over the work process, and cutting-edge business practices. One drawing card that proved unreliable over the long run, however, was the heavy reliance by e-commerce firms on stock options to attract new workers. When the economy tumbled and dot-coms went under, the lucrative gains expected from stock options often failed to materialize. Work in the e-commerce era is characterized by perpetual connectivity, knowledge of computer systems as a requirement, and completely overhauled and redesigned work processes—even for the most menial occupations—to incorporate information technology.
WORKERS.
INVESTORS. Internet technologies served to usher in a vast industry catering to investors of all stripes, from neophytes to professionals, from long-term speculators to day traders. Champions of online investing pointed to its low barriers to entry, technical ease of Internet trading, low commissions on trades, and greater investor control over portfolios as factors leading to the democratization of securities markets. But while profound changes were afoot in the investment world, online investment also posed its challenges to the e-commerce industry and the economy as a whole. With so many new investors entering the market, companies have had to adjust to increasing volatility, thus posing challenges to projections of long-term cash flow.
PURPOSE OF THIS BOOK The Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook is intended, first and foremost, to be a practical resource for entrepreneurs, researchers, high school and college business students, and lay readers with no special prior knowledge or training in business or information technology. It serves as a guide through the workings of e-commerce, providing answers to the major questions facing anyone seeking to break into the field, and instructing readers how to launch, develop, grow, and
maintain an e-commerce enterprise. In addition, the book helps general readers understand and appreciate the broader e-commerce landscape, and instructs ecommerce entrepreneurs, including existing brickand-mortar firms, how to transform their enterprises in order to make the foray into the e-commerce market. Wading into the murky waters of e-commerce literature and media commentary can be a confusing prospect. From the excessive optimism of the late 1990s to the often-dismal tone of the early 2000s, there has been precious little opportunity to read consistently level-headed analysis of the ins and outs of e-commerce for up-and-coming entrepreneurs. To be sure, there is good reason for healthy skepticism of some of the more dramatic claims about the Internet-based revolution, not the least of which was the massive ecommerce shakeout and the dramatic bust in the stock market, which discredited the hype and called into serious question the received wisdom of the Internet business models of the late 1990s. The Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook seeks to strike a balance between the positioning of e-commerce as a panacea for economic growth on the one hand and the deriding of it as a fraudulent money pit on the other. E-commerce, while still developing, is clearly here to stay, and thus it presents itself as a practicality and an opportunity. Moreover, a common hallmark of the typical 1990s instructional tome on e-commerce, seeking to impart wisdom to the aspiring e-commerce titan, was its inflated claims and promises, not to mention trendy jargon and irreverence for traditional business wisdom that some conflated with the very nature of innovation through its boom years. In place of hype, the Gale ECommerce Sourcebook attempts to impart practical knowledge to the reader in clear, sober language grounded in tried-and-true business practices. Avoiding the superficial and faddish extremes of much popular literature on e-commerce, the Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook hopes to aid readers in eluding the costly mistakes—and losses—that such thinking all too often produced. For entrepreneurs just starting out in e-commerce, so many questions arise that it often seems difficult to know where to begin. In addition to all the general considerations of launching a business of any stripe, the e-commerce model spills a host of new questions into the entrepreneur’s lap, ranging from the technical considerations of doing business on the Internet to the qualifications of traditional business methods that the Internet model demands. The Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook answers a great many of these questions and provides suggested avenues for further inquiry.
WHITHER E-COMMERCE?
x G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
E-commerce in the 21st century is a much more
market conditions, and wily enough to find their own niche within them or even to transform those conditions through innovation. Obviously, a reference source such as this cannot teach the kind of creativity and ingenuity that will produce the next batch of e-commerce giants and mark the development of the Internet; that remains the special provenance of the entrepreneurial spirit. What the Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook does help to provide is the basic tools—knowledge, clarity, and informational resources. In short, the foundation upon which such creativity and development can be realized.
INTRODUCTION
discriminating and competitive marketplace than that which surfaced in the 1990s. Because emerging entrepreneurs generally lack the economies of scale enjoyed by their more entrenched and established competitors, they need to be especially smart about where they direct their money in the early development stages, and they can no longer rely on an endless flow of investment capital to make up the difference. Ecommerce entrepreneurs in the 2000s and beyond need to be simultaneously creative and rational, grounded in extensive knowledge of the workings of existing
xi G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
PREFACE AND USER’S GUIDE
PREFACE In today’s rapidly evolving business landscape, more information on Internet commerce is essential for entrepreneurs establishing new enterprises. This first edition of the Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook (GECS) presents a comprehensive view of the topics and terms, organizations, and companies most relevant to the world of e-commerce. Designed to facilitate the start-up, development, and growth of e-commerce business, GECS combines instructional essays on a wide variety of e-commerce topics and directory listings of companies, services, and government agencies to provide readers with access to the most essential e-commerce information and resources. This two-volume work is an invaluable tool for new and seasoned e-commerce entrepreneurs, students performing industry research and analysis, and individuals interested in understanding the volatile Internet industry more fully. GECS features:
T ‘‘How To’’ essays covering the 100 most commonly asked questions relating to e-commerce, such as how to write business and marketing plans, secure financing, and evaluate candidates for designing a website. T Extensive directory of over 4,700 organizations, associations, and agencies related to the e-commerce industry, including computer software, trade shows and conventions, licensing and regulation, and management consultants. T Profiles of the top 250 e-commerce companies worldwide, including financial statistics and descriptive information. T Rankings by revenue and by number of employees of the e-commerce companies listed. T General Index to organization names, personal names, and subject terms. Readers new to the world of Internet business will find a wealth of
basic information designed to answer their immediate questions and light their research path. Those already versed in the specifics of the industry will find overviews of the biggest players in e-commerce for competitive positioning and in-depth market analysis.
USER’S GUIDE Launching an e-commerce business brings to the entrepreneur a host of new questions and general considerations—from what types of business models are available for e-commerce enterprise to how to recruit and retain talent, and which network topologies to use. Gale E-Commerce Sourcebook (GECS) provides information in a variety of forms and presentations for comprehensive coverage and quick navigation through a bevy of e-commerce topics, companies, and informative listings. Organized in two volumes, this sourcebook is divided into three main sections:
T ‘‘How-To’’ Topics in E-Commerce T Directory of E-Commerce Associations, Consultants, and Other Organizations T Directory of Leading E-Commerce Companies ‘‘HOW-TO’’ TOPICS IN E-COMMERCE. Volume 1 begins with instructional essays on over 90 key topics in the field of e-commerce and provides answers to the most common questions an entrepreneur or student will have, including how much business a site can expect and how users respond to advertising. Some of the key subjects include:
T Accounting Practices in E-Commerce T Data Warehousing T E-Commerce Business Models xiii
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
PREFACE AND USER’S GUIDE
T Legal Considerations of E-Commerce T Online Content Management and Provision T Web Site Design
Obviously, such topics easily merit more information than could be addressed in a book of this size and nature, and thus each essay is accompanied by suggestions and resources for further reading. Essays are arranged alphabetically by topic, and all essays are listed in full for easy perusal within the table of contents page. DIRECTORY OF E-COMMERCE ASSOCIATIONS, CONSULTANTS, AND OTHER ORGANIZATIONS. This second section, spanning Volumes 1 and 2, provides coverage on over 4,700 organizations, agencies, and associations relevant to the e-commerce industry. Entries contain organization name; contact information including contact name, address, and phone, toll-free and fax numbers; email and URL addresses; brief description of purpose and services; and descriptive data such as number of employees, date founded, publications, and awards. Entries are arranged alphabetically within the following categories:
and fax numbers; email and URL addresses; brief description of the type of business; and descriptive data such as annual revenue, number of employees, date founded, and major partners. The second half consists of rankings of these firms according to annual revenues and number of employees. A General Index is also included at the end of Volume 2 to provide easy access to organization names, personal names, industries, and subject terms. It is important to note that references are to book numbers rather than to page numbers, and that each section begins with book number ‘‘1.’’ Each book number reference is preceded by a letter denoting a section of the book: ‘‘T’’ denotes a ‘‘How To’’ topic, ‘‘O’’ denotes a listing within the Organization section, and ‘‘C’’ refers the user to a listing within the Companies section. Directory listings and company profiles in GECS were obtained using a variety of means: Direct contact with the associations, organizations, companies, and agencies through telephone surveys, Internet research, or through materials provided by those listees; government resources; and data obtained from other relevant Gale directories.
METHOD OF COMPILATION.
The editors gratefully acknowledge the wise counsel and helpful suggestions of our advisors:
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.
T T T T T T T T T
Associations Computer Software Consultants Educational Programs Government Regulatory Agencies Publications Trade Shows & Conventions Web Site Designers Website Hosting Companies
DIRECTORY
OF
LEADING
E-COMMERCE
Stephen M. Hayes, Business Services Librarian, Thomas Mahaffey, Jr. Business Information Center, University Libraries of Notre Dame, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, Indiana. Dr. Jerome Katz, Ph.D, Mary Louise Endowed Professor of Management at Saint Louis University, Missouri. Brenda Reeb, Director, Management Library, University of Rochester, Rochester, New York. COMPA-
Despite the massive shakeout of so many ecommerce firms, there were a number of highly successful companies who not only sustained the downturn in the dot-com market but managed to flourish and mature, acting as forebears of the kinds of firms that will emerge in the 21st century. This final section is devoted to those examples, and is subdivided into two parts within Volume 2. The first half arranges companies alphabetically by company name, with each entry containing complete contact information including contact name, address, and phone, toll-free NIES.
COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS Comments and suggestions regarding the Gale ECommerce Sourcebook are invited and encouraged. Please contact: Managing Editor, Business Product Gale Group 27500 Drake Rd. Farmington Hills, MI 48331-3535 Telephone: 800-347-GALE
[email protected]
xiv G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce This section provides information and answers to common questions related to e-commerce. Each essay concludes with suggestions for further information and resources.
❚1 ACCOUNTING PRACTICES IN ECOMMERCE
In the early days of e-commerce and through the thick of the dot-com boom, common wisdom held that the novelty of the new electronic business model, particularly as rendered over the Web, was enough to float a business. Thus companies put their efforts into creating the appearance of innovation, while some traditional business concerns were pushed to the back burner. This logic was fed by copious commentary in business journals that dot-coms heralded the death of the traditional business model. Only when the ecommerce bubble burst in the early 2000s did opinions begin to change in earnest, and e-commerce entrepreneurs discovered that a novel business idea wasn’t enough—it had to be backed up by solid practices, and accounting mattered to businesses, customers, and investors alike. So old-school bookkeeping practices are vitally important, but the process of selecting the best accounting practices for your firm depends on your specific business needs. These practices have to arise organically out of the practices and operations your firm employs in general.
NEW CONSIDERATIONS FOR THE INFORMATION AGE Some accounting considerations are fairly new in the e-commerce era, or at least take on new importance. E-commerce firms, especially pure-play, online-only firms, create new forms of value that must be accounted for in some way. Firms delivering fullfledged e-commerce services are more likely to focus their accounting strategies around the product or service they’re offering, paying special attention to factors like intellectual property and the firm’s unique business practices. Innovative practices may have innate value in a still-forming e-commerce market.
With the wealth of data at your firm’s virtual fingertips, it’s crucial to keep in mind that any information that can be transferred into useful knowledge has potential power to augment your financial situation. It’s important to not only harness such knowledge for your firm’s benefit, but to account for it as well. This doesn’t necessarily mean that the rules of the accounting game have changed; rather, established theories and methods of accounting have simply been intensified by the addition of new layers of detail. Accounting practices have to mirror the greater complexity and subtle detail of business the Information Age. Determining when and how to account for particular transactions can have a great impact on the company’s cash flow, assets, and profits. Your firm must devise stable models for allocating costs. Choosing whether to expense a cost, classifying it as a simple expense incurred immediatedly, or to capitalize a cost, classifying it as an investment that can be amortized over time, is one factor e-commerce firms must consider. For instance, you need to determine how best to account for internal-use software—software your business develops or uses exclusively within the firm with no plans to profit from the software itself. In general, accounting organizations favor expensing certain stages of software development as they are incurred, as well as all costs surrounding the software use, such as training, data maintenance, interest payments. However, certain direct development costs, usually the ones directly tied to writing and testing the software, are often capitalized as internal investments. Your company’s financial team will need to be familiar with published standards, such as those of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) and the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), in order to navigate through these complex decisions. Similarly, advertising costs can be expensed as incurred—at each step as the advertising program is developed—or when the advertisement actually hits the market. Less often, advertising costs may be amortized on the books, provided that the advertising meets certain characteristics of longer-term investments. The timing of the expense accounting may seem trivial, but it is hardly trivial. In financial statements that auditors, tax authorities, and investors need to make crucial decisions about your firm, the timing of such 1
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
decisions becomes very important for assessing the actual state of your firm’s financial position at a given time. Intellectual capital refers to the accumulated knowledge, expertise, and intangible assets in your firm. It comes from employees; equipment such as hardware, databases, and IT networks; and a host of other sources including patents, trademarks, and the scalability of existing hardware and software—anything that can be considered to add value in some vital way. Because the future value of intellectual capital is difficult to judge, it is likewise difficult to quantify intellectual capital for accounting purposes. Nonetheless, the increasing role of intellectual capital in assessing the value of businesses, particularly in the e-commerce markets, demands that your firm not let this asset go unaccounted for.
Honig, Susan A. ‘‘The Changing Landscape of Computerized Accounting Systems.’’ CPA Journal, May 1999, 14. Kupiek, Eva. ‘‘Shifting Strategies: Challenging the Traditional Business Knowledge.’’ CMA Management, May 2000, 15. Stout, William D., and Ronald E. Marden. ‘‘Accounting for Web Site Costs.’’ Ohio CPA Journal, January-March 2001, 34. Weintraub, Doug. ‘‘Integration of People Application and Technology Critical for Forward Success.’’ Ohio CPA Journal, July-September 2000, 38.
❚2 ADVERTISING YOUR WEB SITE
SOFTWARE Software packages come in all varieties and software consultants are readily available to help you integrate those software applications with your company’s specific ways of conducting business. While early electronic accounting applications consisted of basic spreadsheets, word processors, and databases, applications available in the e-commerce world harness all the power of modern information technology and telecommunications for almost unlimited options and tremendous power and efficiency. Accounting applications are generally able to track all relevant accounting information, from basic accounts payable and receivable to intangible assets, and can augment their usefulness by managing inventory, cutting checks, devising regular reports and accounting summaries, tracking customer and vendor accounts, and integrating with other vital systems, such as supply chain management applications, data warehouses, and internal networks and extranets. WHAT’S THE BOTTOM LINE? The challenge for your company is to create a strategy that will put your firm in the strongest overall position both internally and in the eyes of outsiders. This includes staying within the bounds of accounting ethics, which means not overstating your firm’s financial health by hiding, over- or understating any information vital to an outside observer. Such practices aren’t just important to outsiders. In order for you to make accurate assessments of your firm and sound strategic decisions, you need a clear accounting schedule. FURTHER READING Borthick, Sandy. ‘‘Call Accounting—for IP?’’ Business Communications Review, August 2000, 14.
Online advertising is not a mature medium. As it evolves, unresolved questions about its effectiveness remain. While studies have shown that simple banner ads will drive people to try new products, low clickthrough rates have caused the use of banner ads to decline. Although banner ads offer the possibility of clicking through to another Web site, advertisers should not look at online advertising only as a direct response medium. Online advertising also offers the possibility of building brand awareness. Creating such awareness is not necessarily measured by clickthrough rates. Since people generally go online to perform some type of task, it is not surprising that they are often unwilling to click-through an online ad. However, that doesn’t mean that the ad was not effective in terms of creating awareness and possibly some future action.
OBJECTIVES OF ONLINE ADVERTISING Owners who want to advertise their Web sites need to determine whether their strategy is to drive sales or to create greater awareness of their site. An early2002 study by AdRelevance based on interviews with marketing executives involved in online advertising found that 61 percent mentioned some aspect of branding as their main online advertising strategy. Creating awareness ranked higher than direct response, driving traffic, and driving sales as a primary objective. Other studies have shown that direct response and converting viewers to customers were more important to online advertisers than building brand awareness. A Nielsen/NetRatings study of new online advertising campaigns launched in the first quarter of 2001 found that nearly 90 percent were direct marketing campaigns and that only slightly more than 10 percent were branding campaigns.
2 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Ads that build brand or name awareness for a Web site are more successful if they also promote brand understanding. Name awareness alone is not sufficient to drive traffic to a Web site. Rather, successful brandbuilding ads offer multiple benefits to drive traffic. They explain overall brand positioning by spelling out the benefits of the site and how the site is able to deliver them. Recognizing that one of the principal motivations for searching the Web is to find information, successful ads for Web sites present informationbased benefits available at the advertised site, such as a product search feature, relevant content, or quality of information.
WHERE TO ADVERTISE Major Internet portals and other high-traffic sites account for a high percentage of Internet advertising. According to the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB), the top 25 sites in terms of traffic took in 88 percent of all online advertising revenue during the first half of 2001. Web sites seeking to launch large advertising campaigns that would involve ads appearing on several sites may use the services of companies that specialize in online advertising and operate advertising networks. Ad networks such as those operated by DoubleClick Inc., 24/7 Real Media Inc., and ValueClick Inc. serve as go-betweens between advertisers and Web site publishers. While the ad networks vary from agency to agency, they typically include higher traffic Web sites organized into categories. They also offer enhanced targeting capabilities that can deliver ad impressions to viewers based on their past actions.
sites where the ad appears. This model usually charges on a cost-per-thousand (CPM) basis. It is a model that is based on traditional advertising, where advertisers are charged according to the number of subscribers or size of audience. The cost-per-performance model, on the other hand, offers advertisers the opportunity to pay on the basis of measurable results. Online ads may be measured in term of cost-per-click (CPC), cost-peraction (CPA), cost-per-lead (CPL), or cost-per-acquisition (CPA). Cost-per-action pricing includes not only clicks but also sales and leads. Cost-per-lead pricing is often used in business-to-business ads, where the advertiser specifies how many leads it wants a specific promotion to generate and pays only for those that are delivered. Cost-per-acquisition is similar to CPL except that advertisers only pay when the user makes an actual purchase and is ‘‘acquired’’ as a customer.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
These types of mixed results indicate the dual nature of online advertising. On the one hand, direct response ads allow for feedback and a direct connection with the viewer, who can respond to an online ad with a single click. On the other hand, online advertising facilitates brand-building by spreading the word about a Web site. Advertisers may choose both objectives and assign a percentage of ads for sales and a percentage for brand-building. Ads that are designed to drive sales are measured differently than those intended to build brand awareness. Clickthrough and conversion rates are effective measures of ads designed to increase sales at a Web site. Brandbuilding ads, on the other hand, are measured by such factors as awareness, recall, and persuasion.
TYPES OF ONLINE ADS According to a December 2001 study by the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) and PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), banner ads accounted for 36 percent of U.S. online advertising revenue in the first three quarters of 2001. Sponsorships came in second with 27 percent, followed by classified ads (16 percent), slotting fees (8 percent), keyword search (4 percent), interstitials (3 percent), e-mail (2 percent), rich media (2 percent), and referrals (2 percent). While banner ads accounted for the highest percentage of online advertising revenue, their use declined in 2001 compared to 2000. Web site publishers often participate in banner exchanges with other Web sites, but they need to be careful that their ads are reaching an appropriate audience. Banner ad exchanges often result in less effective targeting.
AD PRICING MODELS
New ad formats include floating ads and cursor ads. Floating ads appear on screen and can’t be closed or scrolled past. Since they don’t open another window, software programs designed to suppress pop-up ads won’t find the floating ads. Such ads typically run for only a few days to avoid the risk of alienating users. Cursor ads involve attaching the advertiser’s logo to the user’s mouse arrow. Still other types of ads include sound effects, such as music and voiceovers, to gain attention. Known as rich media ads, they utilize JavaScript, dynamic HTML, and downloadable software to gain the user’s attention through interactivity, animation, and multimedia effects.
There are two basic models for pricing online ads, cost-per-impression and cost-per-performance. Costper-impression (also known as cost-per-view) means that advertisers are charged for the number of people who actually see the ad, based on traffic to the Web
Pop-up ads, while they may gain attention, are meeting resistance from Internet users, who have learned to close them even before they are loaded. Users resent that pop-up ads take away control of their computer screen. They serve to interrupt users 3
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
rather than engage them. However, pop-up ads and other interstitials were found to be effective in terms of ad recall. Text-based ads offer small advertisers a chance to appear on sites that receive a lot of traffic, such as the popular search engine Google (www.google.com). Google’s AdWords program allows small advertisers to mount a campaign of text-based ads for less than $100. An AdWords campaign at Google might consist of several text-based ads that rotate against the same set of keywords. Google is able to determine which ads have the highest click-through rate and subsequently can show those ads more frequently than ads with lower click-through rates.
ONLINE ADVERTISING STILL GROWING Advertising a Web site online is one of several ways to market and promote an e-commerce Web site. Online advertising was still evolving in 2002 as the industry sought to define and standardize performance measurements. Advertisers could choose from several different pricing models. While the largest online advertisers spent millions of dollars to build their brands and drive traffic to their Web sites, advertising opportunities also existed for small and medium-size ecommerce Web sites. During the first half of 2002, the number of unique online ads rose steadily, indicating that online advertising was making a comeback from the decline in 2001.
Krol, Carol. ‘‘Online Advertising Tide Turning as Unique Ads Continue to Rise.’’ BtoB Online, 13 May 2002. Available from http://www.btobonline.com. Rosner, Hillary. ‘‘Reality Check: Misconceptions about Online Advertising Abound.’’ Brandweek, 4 February 2002, IQ9.
❚3 ADVERTISING ON YOUR WEB SITE
The principal reason that Web site publishers take advertising is to generate revenue. However, several factors in 2001 caused many content sites to turn to other models of revenue generation. For example, the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) reported that the top 25 sites in terms of traffic took in 88 percent of all online advertising revenue during the first half of 2001. Another factor was the 18 percent decline in online advertising recorded during the first three quarters of 2001 compared to 2000. Among the new models considered for generating revenue were subscription services that made selected content available only to subscribers, syndication, co-branding, and ecommerce. Instead of looking for revenue from outside advertisers, some content sites began putting up ads on their sites for products and services they could provide themselves.
FURTHER READING Appelbaum, Ullrich. ‘‘Secrets of the World’s 10 Most Successful Advertising Campaigns for Dotcoms.’’ MarketingProfs.com, 20 February 2002. Available from http://www.MarketingProfs.com. Burt, Erin. ‘‘Made You Look.’’ Kiplinger’s Personal Finance Magazine, April 2002, 30. Calishain, Tara. ‘‘Less Is More: ASCII Might Trump Rich Media in the World of Online Advertising.’’ EContent, May 2002, 24. Dugan, Sean. ‘‘Brought to You By: The New World of Online Advertising.’’ Computer User, March 2002, 34. Hallerman, David. ‘‘Just Like Certs Mints.’’ eMarketer, 12 February 2002. Available from http://www.emarketer.com. Hallerman, David. ‘‘Mind-Share over Matter: Interstitials, Pop-Ups, and Pop-Unders.’’ eMarketer, 20 February 2002. Available from http://www.emarketer.com. Hallerman, David. ‘‘Online Ad Pricing: Count Heads or Count Results.’’ eMarketer, 5 March 2002. Available from http://www.emarketer.com.
TRENDS IN ONLINE ADVERTISING A survey by the Association of National Advertisers found that 79 percent of all U.S. companies advertised online in 2000, up from 67 percent in 1999. Those companies spent an average of $2.4 million each on online advertising, with about half of them saying their primary goal was to develop and improve brand loyalty. Overall, eMarketer estimated that $7.3 billion was spent on Internet advertising in the United States in 2001 and predicted that $8.1 billion would be spent in 2002. Most of that growth was expected to come from traditional advertisers. The top 10 companies spending the most on online advertising in 2001 were eBay ($45.1 million), General Motors Corp. ($42.3 million), Providian Corp. ($29.3 million), Amazon.com Inc. ($27.5 million), Barnes & Noble Inc. ($26.2 million), Bank One Corp. ($25.7 million), AOL Time Warner Inc. ($25.6 million), Classmates Online Inc. ($24.6 million), Vivendi Universal SA ($21.4 million), and Dell Computer Corp. ($21.1 million), according to a report from CMR.
4 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
AD NETWORKS ATTRACT LARGER ADVERTISERS Web sites with enough traffic to qualify may consider becoming part of an ad network, such as DoubleClick Media, 24/7 Network, or ValueClick Inc. Each network has its own characteristics and qualifications for joining. Double Click Media, operated by online ad agency DoubleClick Inc., is a collection of high-profile branded sites. DoubleClick uses its proprietary technology to deliver, target, and report on its customers’ campaigns. It also allows Web publishers to outsource ad sales for their Web sites to the company’s ad sales force. The 24/7 Network is operated by 24/7 Real Media Inc. It is a global online advertising network. As of mid-2002 it consisted of more than 600 high-profile Web sites and 3,000 small to medium-size Web sites in North America, South America, and Europe. The network offered a variety of value-added services to both advertisers and Web site publishers. ValueClick Inc. specializes in performance-based pricing for its ad networks. It operated a comprehensive network as well as 15 targeted categories grouped
according to content. Small and medium-size Web sites may join the ValueClick network by completing an online application. Other products and services offered to participating Web site publishers include real-time statistical reporting, payment management, and the ability to categorize each page of its Web site, among others.
APPEALING TO SMALLER ADVERTISERS
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
POTENTIAL ADVERTISERS AND HOW TO REACH THEM While online advertising revenue declined significantly in 2001, traditional advertisers spent more to advertise online in 2001 than they did in 2000. According to the IAB, online ad sales declined 18 percent during the first three quarters of 2001 (to $1.8 billion) compared to the same period in 2000. Much of the loss in online advertising revenue in 2001 was a direct result of the dot-com shakeout. However, traditional advertisers such as retailers and automobile manufacturers spent $4.6 billion on online advertising in 2001, compared to $2.7 billion in 2000, according to Forrester Research, which used a broader definition of online advertising than IAB. Forrester also reported that traditional advertisers accounted for 61 percent of online sales in 2001. Sites that take advertising were trying to establish longer-term relationships with advertisers that had been getting 30-day contracts. Such longer-term relationships employed payment models based on users acting on an ad rather than on a cost-per-thousand (CPM) impressions payment model. Performancebased models might be based on cost-per-clicks or on actual sales resulting from the ad. Some sites that were affiliated with offline properties in other media attempted to attract online advertisers by offering cross-platform packages. That is, online ads were offered as part of an overall package of advertising that might include print and outdoor media affiliated with the Web site owner.
Text-based ads appeal to smaller advertisers and can be sold for as little as $10 a month. They load faster than graphic ads and are more difficult to block. Plain text ads are also easier to integrate into Web site design. By appealing to smaller advertisers, Web site owners can greatly increase the potential number of advertisers on their sites. Other benefits include decreasing their reliance on large advertisers and devoting fewer resources to ad sales. A site may generate advertising revenue by offering its community of users the opportunity to advertise to other members of the community. A simple advertising program can be set up by the site’s Webmaster by purchasing an off-the-shelf banner ad system, tweaking it for text-based ads, and integrating it with an automated payment system such as PayPal. Although the use of banner ads declined from 2000 to 2001, joining a banner exchange network may be useful for attracting smaller advertisers who couldn’t otherwise afford to advertise their Web site. Generally, banner exchanges offer less targeting capabilities than ad networks or direct placement of ads.
PUTTING PRINT ADS ONLINE The use of online classified ads increased from 2000 to 2001. According to the IAB, the percentage of companies using online classified ads increased from 5 percent in the first half of 2000 to 15 percent in the first half of 2001. By 2002 online classified advertising had become a highly competitive area among print publishers. According to one newspaper’s Web publisher quoted in Editor & Publisher, ‘‘It’s instantly profitable.’’ Putting print classified ads online was only the first step in the print-to-Web phenomenon. Newspapers began putting other kinds of print ads, including retail display ads, inserts, and special sections, online. They trained their advertising sales representatives to offer the online ads as a bonus for advertising in print. Another advantage to the print publishers was that it didn’t take a lot of extra work to put the print ads online; much of the work was handled by vendors who hosted the service. 5
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
MEASUREMENT, PERFORMANCE, AND REPORTING Potential advertisers want verifiable performance measurements. As of early 2002 Web sites and ad networks were using different measurements to determine click-through rates, number of unique visitors, and similar metrics. To deal with this problem, the Interactive Advertising Bureau and PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) proposed a set of guidelines to standardize the measurement of online ads at the beginning of 2002. However, Web sites opposed to strict standards of measurement pointed out that online advertising was still a young and evolving medium. Online ads may be incorporated into a site in so many different ways that it is difficult, if not impossible, to standardize the measurement of their effectiveness. Online advertising can track a user’s actions and provide quantified sales. Click-through rates are a standard measurement of an ad’s effectiveness. Clickthrough refers to the number of people who actually click on an ad. Advertisers realize that click-through rates are not the only measurement of an ad’s performance. They do not measure an ad’s effectiveness as part of a brand-building campaign. Ads that are designed to create brand awareness need not rely on click-through rates as a measure of effectiveness. Online advertising is still an evolving medium. Web site publishers can attract advertisers in several ways, such as by joining an ad network or a banner exchange. An important factor is the ability to offer a relevant, well-defined audience to potential advertisers. Web sites that are not part of a network may come to the attention of potential advertisers through their own ads, search engine results, and other methods.
FURTHER READING ‘‘Advertising Online: That Was Then, What Now?’’ eMarketer, 17 October 2001. Available from http:// www.emarketer.com. ‘‘Business Description for DCLK DoubleClick Inc. from Multex.com,’’ 24 May 2002. Available from http:// yahoo.marketguide.com. ‘‘Business Description for TFSM 24/7 Real Media Inc. from Multex.com,’’ 24 May 2002. Available from http:// yahoo.marketguide.com. ‘‘Business Description for VCLK ValueClick Inc. from Multex.com,’’ 24 May 2002. Available from http:// yahoo.marketguide.com. Calishain, Tara. ‘‘Less Is More: ASCII Might Trump Rich Media in the World of Online Advertising.’’ EContent, May 2002, 24.
Daniels, Alex. ‘‘Internet Hawks: The Online Advertising Market Never Lived up to the Hype, but Traditional Advertisers Could Be Its Savior.’’ Washington Techway, 18 March 2002, 20. Davies, Phil. ‘‘Madison Avenue Freeze-Out: New Revenue Models Could Be the Saving Grace for Content Sites.’’ Computer User, March 2002, 26. Dugan, Sean. ‘‘Brought to You By: The New World of Online Advertising.’’ Computer User, March 2002, 34. ‘‘Hey Big eAd Spenders in 2001.’’ eMarketer, 11 March 2002. Available from http://www.emarketer.com. Rosner, Hillary. ‘‘Reality Check: Misconceptions about Online Advertising Abound.’’ Brandweek, 4 February 2002, IQ9. Sullivan, Carl. ‘‘Web Display Ads a Dime a Dozen?’’ Editor & Publisher, 8 April 2002, 9. Torres, Nichole L. ‘‘Calculating Clicks.’’ Entrepreneur, February 2002, 72.
❚4 ANTICIPATING THE SIZE OF YOUR MARKET
Knowing how many potential customers you have—and how much they’re willing to spend—is one of the most basic yet difficult problems businesses of all sorts face. Few businesses can know with certainty how much potential demand exists for their products, yet having some idea can help maximize revenues and prevent spending money on developing a product that will never sell. Large companies readily spend tens of thousands of dollars on detailed marketing studies to estimate potential demand, but even these methods aren’t foolproof. Since their marketing funds are often quite limited, small businesses in particular have to be flexible in order to cope with incomplete and sometimes inaccurate measures of market potential. Before you can estimate your market’s size, you need to spend a little time defining exactly whom it includes. Many new businesses make the mistake of assuming almost anyone will buy their product. They take a product-centered approach, thinking, for example, ‘‘anyone who uses word-processing software will subscribe to my new online resume-building suite.’’ It’s extremely rare to have a product that appeals so widely. In this example it might make sense, instead, to focus on selling to students who use public Web terminals and need a centralized online tool to access their information from different locations. Failing to define the target market realistically can lead to overblown sales forecasts and poorly focused marketing.
6 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Most businesses find they have one or two welldefined primary markets for their products, and perhaps one or two secondary markets as well. Defining a target market carefully, also called segmenting the market, takes into account a range of demographic traits, or so-called firmographics if you’re selling to other businesses. Among consumers, marketers regularly consider the buyer’s age, gender, income, marital status, geographic location, method of Internet access, even ethnicity. For businesses, relevant characteristics include annual sales, number of employees, number of locations, major software platforms, and line of business. Target markets are also commonly defined according to an earlier buying history, such as people who own luxury cars or businesses that use temporary staffing agencies. This information helps identify who is a qualified and likely buyer. As a rule, the number of viable buyers is smaller than the targeted demographic groups participating in the market. Once the target market is defined, you can begin to collect information about its size. If it is an established market, meaning that other firms already offer a similar product or service, published research may be available. This is also the case if it is a predictable demographic group that many marketers target, say, women over age 50 who use the Internet. A search of newspaper, business press, and trade journal databases at a library or directly over the Web can reveal whether such information has been published in the past. Trade journals, periodicals devoted to a particular industry or profession, can be an especially rich source of information. The same is true of trade associations, which often compile and release statistics for the benefit of their members. If your competitors include publicly traded companies, occasionally investment reports on the individual companies or the industry as a whole will contain estimates of market size. Sometimes even a competitor’s financial disclosures will include estimates of the total market size, or at least their share of it. If you can’t find statistics that relate directly to the market you intend to go after, you may be able to find related numbers which can serve as a platform for making other estimates. Aside from finding second-hand estimates published in newspapers or trade press, you could also look for marketing research firms that sell standardized, syndicated reports covering your target market or a similar one. These kinds of reports often supply the underlying statistics used in the press. Most industries have at least one research house that produces ongoing reports and sells them to companies in the industry along with industry analysts and the press. Many times research firms disclose some of their basic findings for free in press releases or summary sheets available on their Web sites. General e-commerce
studies are produced by research firms like Forrester Research, International Data Corporation, Jupiter Media Metrix, NetRatings, and the Yankee Group. Some of these and a good number of others also conduct customized studies to answer specific marketing questions that aren’t addressed in their standard reports.
ACTING ON MARKET ASSUMPTIONS E-commerce firms can also gauge market size from the ground up, estimating what a given marketing campaign or series of campaigns will yield. Tests or previous experience, for instance, may reveal that a direct e-mail campaign gets a 1.5 percent response, and that you typically end up selling to one out of every four potential customers who respond to direct marketing. By combining this information with other available statistics, such as the total number of businesses in your target market, you can arrive at a crude estimate of the total volume of business available via direct marketing. The calculations might work like this: you assume that the 1.5 percent represents the interested or qualified market out of, say, a total of 20,000 businesses you target. This would amount to a market of 300 qualified and interested businesses you will reach if you contact all 20,000. Multiply the 300 by your average completed sale, let’s say $10,000, and you arrive at a reachable market estimate of $3 million dollars out of a theoretical (and probably unrealistic) target market of $200 million (20,000 times $10,000). Your sales forecast would probably be onequarter of $3 million, or $750,000, based on the historical rate of converting one in four interested prospects into full-fledged sales.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
DEFINING YOUR MARKET
This example is simplistic and would not be suitable for many needs. Each step of the estimate is subject to error, and the sum of the potential errors could be very great indeed. In practice, the number of businesses that respond to direct marketing may not be a good indicator of the whole market at all. For one thing, a different e-mail message or a different list of recipients might alter the response rate greatly. Even with the ideal list and messaging, it may well be that the qualified market is better defined by another attribute, not simply those businesses having enough interest to respond to your marketing letter. This method also would not take into account important issues like repeat sales (do customers need your services again if they’ve already bought in the past?), competitor activity (are your competitors gaining market share and leaving you a dwindling portion?), and changes in market size (is the total market growing or shrinking?). Still, market estimates made from reliable, relevant past experiences have advantages over some ‘‘topdown’’ estimates, which may purport a huge potential 7
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
market that never materializes. Some large-scale estimates are based on a theory which can’t be fully realized because, for example, potential customers may find substitutes or work-arounds that prevent them from ever entering the market for your products. Statistics about the online world, especially, can be subject to errors in counting unique visitors and obtaining accurate visitor demographics. Similarly, broadly defined market studies may not arrive at an effective definition of who is a likely buyer just by using general demographic traits and statistics, and may overestimate as a result. Of course, any given method can underestimate the market as well, a phenomenon seen in the early expansion of the Internet in the 1990s. When you analyze a general study’s implications for your business, you should also look for assumptions in the study that vary widely from your firm’s experience. For example, if you have established lines of business in other areas, through cross-selling you may be able to reach buyers who are not generally considered part of the market. But by the same token, you may have greater difficulty reaching the recognized market. The bottom line is that market estimates are by nature open to interpretation and change. They are useful for planning and have many implications for your e-commerce strategy, but should not be taken as literal or fixed. More than likely, the market itself is changing over time, as is your position in it.
FURTHER READING Grossnickle, Joshua, and Oliver Raskin. Handbook of Online Marketing Research. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2000.
❚5 APPLICATION SERVICE PROVIDERS
Until the late 1990s, it was rare to hear the term ‘‘ASP’’ (pronounced A-S-P, short for application service provider) in business circles. Today the term has made its way into the vocabulary of commerce and e-commerce. According to information technology consultancy IDC, ASPs will grow into a $20 billion industry by 2006, up from $26 million in 1999. ASPs are third-party software hosts, independent firms that deploy, manage, and provide access to computer applications from their centralized location(s) and servers through a rental-like arrangement. Clients access the applications most commonly via the Web. In their article, ‘‘Application Service Providers: The Next Horizon in Software,’’ Marc Osten and Michael
Stein compare using an ASP to the voicemail service offered by most telephone companies. The technology itself is located at the phone company’s offices, on its equipment. The phone company is responsible for its management and maintenance, but you—and thousands of others—pay a monthly fee to access its capabilities. To callers who hear your personal greeting and leave a message that only you can retrieve, it’s a seamless process; the technology functions as if it were your own. ASPs have grown rapidly in the past few years due to the increasing presence of the Internet and faster, cheaper bandwidth. Their popularity may also be due to the realization that they can provide access, particularly for small and medium-sized businesses, to applications that would otherwise be out of financial and technological reach. Using an ASP, a small company can access sophisticated accounting software, for example, that it wouldn’t be able to afford to license or have the staff to install and manage. Another benefit of using an ASP is the speed of implementation. A firm can sign up with one or more ASPs (different ASPs host different applications) and within days or weeks have access to the application. If the firm were buying its own licenses and installing the software on site (or at multiple sites), it could take anywhere from weeks to months, depending on the complexity of the application, networking needs, and staffing. For a budget-conscious business or a firm with a small or overburdened IT (information technology) staff, ASPs can function as an off-site IT department of sorts. Today, ASPs offer just about any type of application a business might need, including accounting and e-commerce, human resources, database management, customer relationship management (CRM), project management and office productivity, enterprise resource planning (ERP), and sales force automation (SFA). Typically ASPs charge a monthly subscription fee based on the number of users at the client’s company. Some charge quarterly or annually, and some may charge based on the number of transactions or frequency of usage. There may be additional up-front set up fees or charges for training and customization. When deciding whether to work with an ASP, consider which applications you’ll need. Evaluate your existing hardware and software, whether you have high-speed Internet access (you’ll need to get it, if not), your IT staffing, and the cost of the applications if you were to license them yourself. Contact various ASPs to gather information. Depending on the application you’re considering, you might want to find an ASP that specializes in your industry, such as healthcare or e-commerce, or you might want to find an ASP that specializes in a functional area, such as
8 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Be sure when talking to representatives from ASPs that you ask the same questions of each to ensure a fair and accurate comparison. Your questions should cover whether customization of the applications is possible, or necessary, so that they function smoothly with your existing systems and data; what staff training and support the ASP will provide; and its response times and channels (can you call a toll-free number for help or must you email?). Ask about reliability (opt for companies with 1% or less ‘‘downtime’’) and security procedures, including results of security audits. You’ll want to know what the ASP’s data backup and storage procedures are, whether you have real-time access to your data, and what contingency plans the company has in case of natural disasters or power outages, for example. You’ll also want to know about the application’s ‘‘scalability’’; i.e., does it have the capacity to support your business in one, three, and five years? These items will likely vary by ASP, so be sure to ask, and then carefully weigh the answers. Ask about a ‘‘try before you buy’’ test period before making a final decision. When you have chosen your provider(s) of choice, you’ll sign a contract with your ASP, referred to as a service level agreement, Service level agreements (SLA) or SLA. Make sure your agreement spells out the details of your arrangement. It should include:
agreement. Certainly none of us wants to enter a business relationship with the worst in mind; a good selection process, a detailed agreement, and a contingency plan will facilitate a smooth and productive relationship.
FURTHER READING ASP Industry Consortium. ‘‘A Buyer’s Guide to Application Service Provisioning.’’ All about ASP. Available from: http:// www.allaboutasp.org.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
human resources or supply chain management. You may also consider more than one ASP, perhaps one for payroll and another for accounts payable.
Brain, Marshall. ‘‘How ASPs Work.’’ How Stuff Works, 1998-2002. Available from: http://www.howstuffworks.com/ asp.htm. Jilovec, Nahid. ‘‘ASPs: Rise or Demise.’’ Business Technology.com, October 2000. Available from: http:// www.businesstechnology.com. Osten, Marc, and Michael Stein. ‘‘Application Service Providers: The Next Horizon in Software.’’ Amherst, MA: Summit Collaborative. Available from http:// www.summitcollaborative.com/ NPQ_ASP_Next_Horizon.html.
❚6 AUTHORING SOFTWARE
T start and end dates of service, T an implementation schedule, T specific levels of customer support your firm is to receive, T reliability and performance standards and what you’re entitled to if the ASP fails to meet them, T provisions for system and data security, T detailed subscription and set-up fees and when they are to be paid, and T any training and customization that will occur as well as how and where (via the Web or on-site?) it will take place.
The SLA should specifically state that you are the sole owner of your company’s data for the duration of the agreement and termination conditions. Just as you’ll want to know that your ASP has a contingency plan in place for the unexpected, you’ll want to have such a plan, an exit strategy, in case your relationship with the ASP ends. Consider what your steps will be if the ASP goes out of business, is acquired, or is not meeting its commitments as spelled out in your
To construct a Web site, Web developers must use some form of authoring software. Typically, this software allows the site developer to move back and forth between a window that displays a Web site’s layout and a window in which the developer actually works. Many authoring software programs come with a variety of prefabricated site designs from which developers can choose. Other programs offer tools that allow users to develop a more customized design. Many programs offer both options. At the core of most authoring software programs is an HTML (hypertext markup language) editor, a program that helps users write and manipulate the necessary HTML coding for their Web sites. HTML codes, or tags, essentially tell the different pieces of your Web site what to do. For example, one code or set of codes might position a paragraph of text in a large, blue font on the first page of your site, while another code might create a link from a graphic on your site to another Web site. Along with facilitating HTML editing, many authoring software programs now automate the Web development tasks, including e-commerce and chat room functions, that once proved complicated for even the most technologically savvy designers. 9
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
CHOOSING AUTHORING SOFTWARE The type of authoring software designers use depends upon their experience level and what they want the site to be able to do. For example, developers who plan to create a highly sophisticated site tend to use a product such as Macromedia’s Dreamweaver 4. An October 2001 issue of PC Magazine states, ‘‘with unmatched design power and extensibility, Dreamweaver has become the de facto standard for professional Web designers. In short, if you want to build a truly advanced site, you’ll most likely use Dreamweaver... if it can be done on the Web, it can be done with Dreamweaver.’’ Available for both Macintosh and Windows operating systems, Dreamweaver costs roughly $300. It requires some degree of familiarity with HTML and basic Web site design, so it may not be the best choice for a novice. Another product for Web design professionals is Adobe GoLive 5.0, which offers various multimedia and frameediting tools along with its HTML editor.
COST AND PERFORMANCE More suited to beginners are products like Microsoft FrontPage 2002, which is about half the price of Dreamweaver, and NetObjects Fusion MX, an even cheaper alternative at $100. Neither program requires familiarity with HTML. Like Dreamweaver, Fusion targets developers wanting to build sites for businesses. The program, only available for Windows operating systems, includes e-commerce wizards and other prefabricated templates to lead novices through the Web design process. Fusion is considered the simplest of mainstream Web authoring tools; as such, it allows for quick site development. Some experts caution, however, that the program might not offer developers as much control over their Web sites as they would like. If you are looking for a beginners’ tool that offers a bit more sophistication, you might consider Microsoft’s FrontPage, which received a PC Magazine Editors’ Choice award in 2001. ‘‘If you wish, FrontPage can do everything for you via its wealth of prefab designs. Or you can use the familiar Office-like tools to create your own look. FrontPage’s one-click publishing, easy access to HTML code, discussion boards, image galleries, database connections, and other extras will tickle many a Web builder’s fancy,’’ according to the magazine. Depending on your needs, you may decide to opt for even less expensive Web authoring software. The CoffeeCup HTML editor, which costs $49, offers many of the same features as a program like Fusion at half the cost. Some experts assert that you don’t necessarily need additional software to build a basic Web site. Many leading word processing programs, such as Microsoft Word, include templates for Web pages. Be aware, however, that if you choose a more
limited HTML editing program, you may need to add additional tools, such as Adobe LiveMotion or Sonic Foundry Stream Anywhere, if you plan to add extras to your site at some point.
EDUCATION OPTIONS To learn more about Web page construction before deciding upon authoring software, you can visit sites like Builder.com and WebMonkey.com. Both offer extensive Web authoring resources, including various tutorials. Builder.com includes an HTML primer and sections dubbed ‘‘Web Building Essentials,’’ ‘‘Graphics 101,’’ and ‘‘Streaming Media 101’’ in the authoring and site design section of its how-to library. WebMonkey.com also offers a how-to library with various sections including authoring (which covers HTML basics), tables, frames, browsers, style sheets, and tools. If you are planning to use authoring software to design your own site, check with your hosting company to see which operating systems its servers support. Incompatibility can pose problems. For example, Linux-based servers may not support some features of the Windows-based Microsoft FrontPage authoring package. Also, keep your potential future needs in mind. While you don’t want to spend more money than you need to on authoring software (particularly if you end up getting a complex program with which you are uncomfortable working), it will be in your best interests to use an authoring system that allows for expansion and enhancements.
FURTHER READING Kooser, Amanda C. ‘‘Call to Arms.’’ Entrepreneur, June 2001. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com. Mendelson, Edward. ‘‘Web Wizardry—Whether You’re a Full-Time Designer or Just Creating Your First Page, Today’s Authoring Programs Give You the Right Tools for Creating Masterful Sites.’’ PC Magazine, 9 October 2001. ‘‘PC Magazine Editors’ Choice: Easy: Microsoft Frontpage 2002; Advanced: Dreamweaver 4.’’ PC Magazine, 9 October 2001. ‘‘Working on a Shoestring.’’ Entrepreneur.com, 10 April 2002. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com.
❚7 BANDWIDTH MANAGEMENT
Bandwidth refers to the amount of data that can be transferred over a communication channel in a
10 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Bandwidth management is simply the process of optimizing bandwidth to improve efficiency. When bandwidth is inadequate for the function being performed, such as loading a Web page or transferring a large file across a network, the slowdown that occurs is called a bottleneck. To avoid these bottlenecks, network operators use bandwidth management tools, which are also known as traffic or packet shapers. Among other things, these tools allow network managers to allocate more bandwidth for important electronic applications, such as e-commerce transactions, by labeling them as high-priority functions. Lower priority functions receive less bandwidth. Since the mid-1990s, bandwidth management demands have increased significantly as information transferred via the Internet, as well as via local area networks (LANs), has grown in both size and diversity. If you have chosen an Internet Service Provider (ISP) to host your online business, issues of bandwidth management will likely be handled by the ISP. The ability of an ISP to allocate appropriate bandwidth to your site depends upon the technologies used by the ISP and the capabilities of the ISP’s network mangers. When bandwidth management problems arise, ISPs may either add extra bandwidth to their networks, considered by many experts a short-term and rather costly solution, or they might employ various bandwidth management tools to control bandwidth allocation. Along with identifying and prioritizing the packets that carry information through networks, these tools allow ISPs to recognize network traffic patterns and to allocate resources appropriately. For example, a bandwidth management tool might recognize that certain Web sites receive higher volumes of traffic and allocate more bandwidth to those sites. One of the most popular bandwidth management tools used by large ISPs is PacketShaper/ISP, developed by bandwidth management technology firm Packeteer Inc. By classifying network traffic based on application, protocol, subnet, and URL, PacketShaper allows ISPs to prioritize network requests, allocating more bandwidth to the tasks deemed most important. PacketShaper can also analyze the efficiency and bandwidth allocation of a network and compile related reports and statistics. Another popular tool is Intel Corp.’s NetStructure 7340 Traffic Shaper, which allows ISPs
to prioritize and optimize network bandwidth by controlling the bandwidth allocated to each Web server. If you are hosting your own Web site, you are responsible for managing your own bandwidth. Bandwidth management issues can arise whether you are using a Web site to actually sell products online, to simply advertise products online, or to facilitate general business functions, such as file sharing between employees, communication between employees, and online inventory management. When deciding whether to add bandwidth or to improve the efficiency of your existing bandwidth, you should consider both the cost and logistics involved with each option. In some cases, you may be ready to upgrade from your analog modem to a broadband connection, such as DSL (digital subscriber line). While this is typically quite costly, it does dramatically improve performance. If you are not ready for such an upgrade, you can instead opt to enhance your existing bandwidth. To gain more information about this option, research the cost, availability, and reliability of various bandwidth management tools that will meet your needs. While most small businesses are unable to afford sophisticated products like Packeteer’s PacketShaper and Intel’s Traffic Shaper, various bandwidth management tools do exist for online entrepreneurs with limited resources. For example, Massachusetts-based Trellix Corp. offers bandwidth management tools, as well as Web hosting services, to small businesses. In addition, SpiderSoftware, located in British Columbia, Canada, has developed SpiderCache Lite, a product that helps boost Web server capacity and reduce the time it takes for Web pages to load, for small to medium-sized businesses. Also, California-based Sygate Technologies Inc. offers the Sygate Office Network, which allows clients to boost bandwidth by using multiple modems or by upgrading to broadband technology. In some cases, software companies sell bandwidth management tools separately, and in other cases, they offer them only as part of a Web hosting or electronic business services suite. If you’re looking to prepare yourself for future bandwidth demands, you might consider investing in fixed wireless (Wi-Fi) technology. According to Mike Hogan in the March 2002 issue of Entrepreneur, ‘‘the service best suited to entrepreneurs is the relatively new 802.11b technology. The same 2.4GHz Wi-Fi protocol that delivers 10Mbps worth of LAN bandwidth indoors can transfer data up to 1.5Mbps for 10 miles between an ISP’s transceiver and your own antenna.’’ As of March 2000, roughly 600 wireless ISP’s offered 802.11b services in 2,670 markets across the United States.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
specific amount of time. While bandwidth is most commonly associated with the time it takes to load a Web page, bandwidth also refers to the time in which other transactions, such as opening a word processing program on a personal computer, are completed. For digital devices, such as high-speed cable modems, transmission speed is expressed in bits per second (bps); for analog devices such as microprocessors and analog modems, transmission speed is expressed in cycles per second, or hertz (hz).
FURTHER READING ‘‘Bandwidth Management.’’ In Techencyclopedia. Point Pleasant, PA: Computer Language Co., 2001. Available from
11 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
http://www.techweb.com/encyclopedia/defineterm?term= bandwidthmanage. ‘‘Bandwidth Management Pays Off.’’ Communications News, November 2001. Everett, Carl. ‘‘Bandwidth, Processors Boost Small Business.’’ Business Courier Serving Cincinnati, November 5, 1999. Hogan, Mike. ‘‘On the Air.’’ Entrepreneur, March 2002. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com.
❚8 BRICKS-AND-CLICKS VERSUS PURE PLAY E-COMMERCE
The concept of bricks-and-clicks (B & C) was developed in the late 1990s, when dot.com hysteria was at its peak. During this time, the dot.com hype was so enormous that traditional firms felt threatened by the new way of doing business. In response, brick-and-mortar (traditional) businesses, searched for and found an effective way to combat the threat. They developed an in-between business model that wouldn’t drastically change their business operations. Imagine a spectrum: on one end of the spectrum is the traditional brick-and-mortar business model, on the other end is the pure cyber-business model, and in the middle are various degrees of these two combinations. This middle ground constitutes the bricks-and-clicks model.
MAIN ADVANTAGES OF A HYBRID BUSINESS MODEL? A hybrid-business model has important advantages over a pure play e-commerce model. For the most part, a traditional business has already established its operating model and a base of customers—as well as operating revenues. These elements are critical to the success of any business. Case in point, most dot.com failures occurred during the early stages of their life cycles, when they were trying to establish a customer base substantial enough to generate operating profits. Traditional businesses that have been around for some time establish recognition and branding, both of which are very important to the sustainability of any business. These are major elements in influencing the customer’s decision to purchase a product from someone they recognize and trust. Various studies on online shopping indicate that among Internet users, the majority first find information, then comparison shop, and finally go to the store to make the actual purchase. This is true mostly for
first-time buyers and high-ticket items. It is reasonable to assume that there will always be those who use the Internet to shop and then visit the store to ‘‘see and touch’’ the actual product. A B & C business can utilize both channels to drive sales and to mutually reinforce each other. While pure play e-commerce firms enjoy lower barriers to entry, they have few assets or brand recognoition to leverage en route to building their operations, rendering them largely dependent on venture capital through the often-lengthy process of getting the firms on their feet and independently profitable. The fickleness of the stock market and venture capital markets in the early 2000s are testimony to the dangers in relying too heavily on this route. Finally, the National Retail Federation released a study in the fall of 2000 reporting that customers shopping via multiple channels spent more money than did customers shopping through just a single channel. Clearly, then, as time goes on and Internet models mature, there were definite advantages to achieving some kind of convergence between the pure-play model and the brick-and-mortar model.
MAKING THE MOST OF BRICKS-ANDCLICKS Bricks-and-clicks firms can also leverage existing supply chains, rather than building new ones from scratch. On the other hand, this advantage has a few pitfalls. In particular, as companies begin to open their existing businesses to new online sales channels, there exists the danger of cannibalization, where the newer operations eat into existing ones rather than working in concert with them. And existing distribution channels will actively resist any new channels that seem to threaten their business or relationships with the firm. Another challenge to the brick-and-click firm is to achieve the maximum degree of symbiosis between their online and physical storefronts and strategies. To avoid cannibalization, your brick-and-click company needs to go to great lengths to provide a consistent shopping experience at all their channels, which is achieved through effective and flexible branding strategies. Customer service needs to be similarly consistent and integrated, bringing all systems into harmony with each other so that, for the customer, dealing with your firm is seamless whether online, at a storefront, or moving back and for the between the two.
CHOOSING THE CORRECT BUSINESS MODEL FOR MY VENTURE Despite all these advantages, the precise placement of your business along the pure-play/hybrid/bricksand-mortar spectrum is, in the end, a decision that
12 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
To determine where on this spectrum you should place your business, begin by determining what kinds of resources you have at your disposal, what products and services you plan to sell, and what kind of model—traditional, pure play, or hybrid—will most suit the needs of your target customer base.
enterprises were built on the same planning foundation as traditional businesses, and, as history shows, these enterprises were unable to continue operation. The issue of proper and valid planning for an online enterprise is of utmost importance in the process of online enterprise development. Remember that your planning stage is like a foundation of a building. If it is not sound and solid, everything that you will build on top of it will always be shaky and will likely collapse once it is subject to volatile and quaking market forces.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
you must make according to your specific needs and desires and the particular conditions of your market. To determine the right business model for your enterprise, you must first define your vision, then develop a strategy allowing you to leverage the elements in which you can excel.
ESSENTIAL DIFFERENCES FURTHER READING Bushko, David. ‘‘And the Walls Come a’Tumbling Down: The Rise of Bricks and Clicks.’’ Consulting to Management, September 2001, 34. The Cap Gemini Ernst & Young Center for Business Innovation, ‘‘Business Models for Incumbent Companies,’’ 2001. Available at www.cbi.cgey.com/cgi-bin/pubs.plx?sort= topic.
For the most part, a business is a business, and the ultimate objective of any business is to be profitable. Nevertheless, there are some major differences between conventional business plans and online business plans. The first thing to remember is that the same rules of sound business—profitability, controlled expenses, marketing, and product or service usefulness—apply to the online environment just as they do to in a traditional setting. Yet, there are a few areas where additional planning and considerations have to take place.
Davis, Jessica. ‘‘Going Multichannel.’’ InfoWorld, May 14, 2001, 46. ———. ‘‘What’s a dot.com to Do as Click-and-Mortars Offer Real Options to Customers?’’ InfoWorld, February 26, 2001, 86.
THE CONNECTED ECONOMY James, Geoffrey. ‘‘Clicks and Mortar,’’ Upside, November 1999, 209.
There are three primary elements that distinguish the traditional economy from the connected economy. These three elements are connectivity, interactivity, and speed. Everything else is essentially the same in both environments. For example, if you consider Ebay.com’s business model, there is nothing truly new about it. Auctions have been around for hundreds of years. What makes Ebay.com’s business plan specific to the e-commerce marketplace, however, is its ability to leverage connectivity, interactivity, and speed for connecting buyers and sellers all over the world.
‘‘Survey: E-Commerce-Something Old, Something New.’’ The Economist, February 26, 2000, 15. WizBizWeb, LLC, ‘‘The ABC’s of E-Strategy,’’ 2002. Available by request from www.wizbizweb.com.
❚9 BUSINESS PLANNING FOR ONLINE ENTERPRISE
One of the central questions on the minds of many business analysts is simple, yet of extreme importance: how could so many online businesses (dot.com’s) have failed? Is it possible that the failures were the result of poor planning or, perhaps, unqualified management? Unfortunately, there is no simple answer to these questions. The truth is that there are many reasons why so many online businesses failed during the early 2000s. Nevertheless, there is one element that has contributed to such failures more than any other. That element is poor planning, or, more precisely, lack of solid ebusiness strategic planning. In many cases, online
CONNECTIVITY. Connectivity is the ability to connect interested parties. In the traditional economy, connectivity was limited to the physical size of the place of business, or to its distribution reach. In the connected economy, there is no such limit. Anyone can become a participant as long as they have access to the Internet. INTERACTIVITY. Interactivity is the ability to interact directly with the source in real time. For example, when you are watching TV, you are experiencing a non-interactive media (one way communication) because you do not have the ability to interact with the source. On the other hand, when you read or watch the news online, you can interact with the source by voicing your opinion, or by searching for additional information on your topic of interest.
13 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
SPEED. Speed is an important part of the connected economy because it allows parties to communicate and interact in real time. For example, when reading a newspaper, you are reading information that was complied many hours ago. The speed in which the information flows from the reporters to the press and to the newsstand is very slow. On the other hand, you can view up-to-the minute news online with hardly any delay.
INCORPORATING THESE ELEMENTS INTO YOUR BUSINESS PLANS Interactivity, connectivity and speed are part of the early stages of your business plan. You should always start your online business plan with a phase called ‘‘vision.’’ The vision phase contains three elements:
T Desire: This is where you define the need and value for the proposed product or services that you are planning on providing online. T Drivers: In this category, you need to outline how you are going to leverage the properties of connectivity, interactivity, and speed to operate your new enterprise. For example, if you are planning on selling sunglasses online, you need to define how your customers will interact with your site (i.e. order, ask questions, see pictures of the product etc.), as well as how you are going to interact with suppliers and delivery entities. For an online business, this section of you plan should be given a lot of thought, and should be fully developed before you continue to develop the other components of your plan. T Landscape: The third and last component of the vision phase of your plan is the landscape. In this section you need to outline some of the research that you have conducted on your competition. Once you have done that, you need to analyze your competition and find out where their weaknesses are, and how you can take advantage of those weaknesses to develop a competitive advantage. Once you have developed your competitive advantage, and completed all the other components of the vision phase, you may continue to further develop your online business plan by defining your operations, marketing and financial parts of your plan.
PLANNING STRATEGIES The best place to start planning for your online enterprise is with a valid strategic plan. A strategic plan is somewhat different from a business plan in that it is shorter and puts more emphasis on your
vision rather than on your operations. Remember that if your operational plans are perfect, you may find your new business going in the wrong direction if you have not fully developed and validated your vision phase.
FURTHER READING Klein, Karen E. ‘‘Building Your Business Plan: Where to Begin, Part 1.’’ BusinessWeek Online, June 20, 2000. Available from http://www.businessweek.com. Regan, Keith. ‘‘New Rules for Writing an E-Business Plan.’’ E-Commerce Times, October 30, 2001. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. WizBizWeb, LLC, ‘‘The ABC’s of E-strategy,’’ 2002. Available by request from http://www.wizbizweb.com.
❚ 10 BUSINESS-TO-BUSINESS EXCHANGE (B2B)
B2B exchanges are one example of how the Internet has affected corporate buying and selling practices and changed the way sellers interact with buyers. At the beginning of 2000, public marketplaces (including industry-sponsored marketplaces, or ISMs, and independent exchanges) appeared to be the most promising model for B2B exchanges. However, by mid-2001, public marketplaces had lost favor to private exchanges, also known as private hubs or marketplaces. Private exchanges were created by companies for their suppliers and trading partners. They allowed corporate buyers to collaborate better with their partners, including high-volume trading partners as well as small and medium-size suppliers. Private exchanges also offered more security for online transactions. The main benefit, though, was cost savings.
PUBLIC B2B MARKETPLACES There are two types of public B2B marketplaces: industry-sponsored marketplaces (ISMs), also known as consortia-led marketplaces, and independent or third-party marketplaces. ISMs are formed by a group of companies within an industry, many of whom are competitors. Independent marketplaces, on the other hand, do not involve collaboration among industry competitors. They are typically owned and operated by a B2B startup company that is not a trading partner with the exchange. Although most B2B marketplaces are focused on vertical industries, some are set up to facilitate transactions among a diverse group of buyers and sellers.
14 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
According to Jupiter Media Metrix, 58 B2B ISMs were launched in 2000. Examples include Covisint (auto industry), Aerospan (aerospace industry), and Worldwide Retail Exchange (retail industry). Advantages of ISMs over independent marketplaces include backing by large corporate sponsors, built-in talent, and transaction liquidity. ISMs require industry competitors to become collaborators. Since they are formed through alliances by competing companies, ISMs need to obtain regulatory approval from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and, in some cases, international regulatory agencies. Covisint, for example, was formed in 2000 by automakers General Motors Corp., Ford Motor Co., DaimlerChrysler AG, Renault SA, and Nissan. Its technology partners were Commerce One Inc., and Oracle. The FTC’s approval of Covisint was conditional, since the agency was unable to determine if it would cause any competitive concerns.
Suppliers would be expected to provide volume discounts. Another model focusing on streamlining supply chain operations would include a vendor-managed inventory system. Private exchanges can also focus on product development, where buyers shift their design activities with suppliers into a private hub. Each model has its own benefits. A private exchange concentrating on procurement can result in material savings. One that focuses on supply chain operations can save on inventory expense, while a product development-focused private exchange can reduce the R&D budget.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
Ariba’s Commerce Services Network offered a marketplace of nearly 10,000 suppliers in mid-2001. Those suppliers were directly connected to Ariba’s network and had established some 5,000 unique buyer-supplier relationships. These included buyers and suppliers that had integrated their systems into each other’s networks as well as suppliers that had become preferred vendors for a particular company.
A May 2001 report by Jupiter Media Metrix forecast that more firms would use private trading networks (PTNs), or private exchanges, for collaboration rather than sales over the next 12 months. The survey of more than 400 purchasing managers at U.S. companies with revenue greater than $500 million found that PTNs represented a new tool to link the interests of buyers, suppliers, and distribution partners. Among the collaborative online activities that PTNs were expected to facilitate were inventory level monitoring and product design. The purchasing executives cited closer relationships with their suppliers as the primary benefit of PTNs, while faster time to market and closer links to channel partners were also important considerations. Only 20 percent of those surveyed said they would concentrate on procurement applications.
PRIVATE EXCHANGES By mid-2001 private exchanges were more popular in the B2B sector than public marketplaces. They offered participating companies the chance to save as much as 10 percent of their cost of sales within three years, according to Forrester Research. The cost of building a private exchange could range from $6.8 million to $53 million, according to a mid2001 report from Forrester Research cited in CRMDaily.com. Forrester recommended that companies considering building a private hub should also consider the alternatives, such as EDI (electronic data interchange), an extranet that connects the firm’s legacy system to its business partners, or a public marketplace. Another mid-2001 study by AMR Research estimated that building a private exchange could cost a Fortune 500 company anywhere from $50 million to $100 million. Such an exchange would include a supply chain hub as well as external systems linking the company to its customers and other key trading partners. Private exchanges may be constructed on different models. A private exchange that concentrates on procurement, for example, would help a company aggregate its purchasing across several different categories.
THE COST OF PARTICIPATING IN ONLINE MARKETPLACES Integrating into B2B marketplaces could cost firms between $5.4 million and $22.9 million, according to a March 2001 report from Forrester Research. While that would result in big business for technology providers, it also put a lot of pressure on the marketplaces to deliver cost savings. Companies seeking to gain the benefits of lower prices and a streamlined purchasing process through B2B marketplaces would be required to make a significant up-front investment. They would need to spend money on changing internal procurement systems, integrating electronic marketplaces into their internal systems, purchasing B2B applications, and paying transaction fees associated with the marketplaces. Companies would spend different amounts depending on what they sought to gain from participating in the online marketplaces. According to Forrester Research, corporate buyers seeking to trim transaction costs associated with maintenance, repair, and operations purchases would spend an average of $5.6 million on transaction fees, integration software, and internal staffing. On the other hand, companies that wanted to make spot purchases of materials to help manage inventory and avoid shortfalls would spend 15
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
an average of $10.7 million on new software installation and related consultant fees. A third type of company that intended to use the B2B marketplace to manage all of its purchasing would spend an average of $22.9 million on consultants to implement its electronic marketplace strategy.
MARKET FOR B2B EXCHANGES At the beginning of 2001, Jupiter Media Metrix forecast that international spending on B2B online marketplaces would grow from $2.6 billion in 2000 to $137.5 billion by 2005. While North American companies accounted for 81 percent of total spending in 2000, that percentage was projected to drop to 60 percent of the total by 2005. Spending by North American companies on B2B marketplaces was forecast to increase from $2.1 billion in 2000 to $80.9 billion in 2005. During an economic slowdown, B2B electronic marketplaces offered such benefits as shortened product development cycles, collaboration, and lower product costs, according to Jupiter Media Metrix. The company surveyed executives at more than 90 marketplaces and found that they were implementing or planning to implement several new features. These included trading systems and marketing systems. Other features being added to B2B marketplaces were customer relationship management (CRM) components, electronic bill presentation and payment services, catalog management, and inventory management. Another study by the Boston Consulting Group, released in the fourth quarter of 2000, found that the greatest benefits of B2B exchanges were in the area of increased productivity rather than higher revenue. The study forecast that B2B exchanges would grow rapidly but would not generate significantly higher revenue. Rather, the benefits to buyers and sellers would lie in increased productivity, with gains equivalent to 1 to 2 percent of sales. The study also predicted that many of the 700 B2B marketplaces then in existence would find it difficult to survive, with specific industry segments being able to support only one to three major marketplaces. OUTLOOK FOR B2B MARKETPLACES A mid-2001 study of B2B marketplaces by Jupiter Media Metrix noted that many B2B buyers were reluctant to move online and would remain hesitant until late 2002. Rather than focusing on building transactions, the study found, B2B exchanges should add services that would improve productivity, such as collaborative product design and supply-chain inventory management. The evolution of public marketplaces from a transaction-based model to one that offered technology and
services was noted by eMarketer, which tracked the development of five leading independent B2B exchanges from the beginning of 2001 to the beginning of 2002. All five—Altra Market Place (commoditybased trade), Citadon (engineering and building industry), eMerge Interactive (cattle), MetalSite (steel trading), and SciQuest (life sciences)—had shifted their emphasis from a transaction-based business model to becoming technology vendors and service providers. Some were beginning to offer software and services to facilitate the development of private exchanges among their members. The challenge for the evolving B2B exchanges was not only to convince customers of the potential value of their technology offerings but also to help users adapt to the new systems. A late 2001 study by Giga Information Group and Booz Allen Hamilton found that one in two companies surveyed complained that the technology of B2B marketplaces was not mature enough to allow them to get online and become operational in a short time. Meanwhile, private exchanges had become the preferred model by the end of 2001. IBM predicted that there would be some 3,120 online B2B exchanges by 2003, according to eMarketer. Nearly all of those exchanges would be privately run or operated by large enterprises. IBM estimated there would be more than 1,400 large enterprises involved in the construction of B2B exchanges and that they would serve a market of 2 million small and medium-sized enterprises. Public exchanges were expected to evolve into supplier gateways to private exchanges, and they would also facilitate the setting of technology standards for their industries. On the other hand, there would be two types of private exchanges. One type would connect a large enterprise with its several small and medium-size business partners, while the other type would link two high-volume trading partners in a one-to-one connection. While private exchanges would offer more customized and tightly integrated supply chain connections, eMarketer noted that many companies were just beginning to make preparations for the build-out of these external networks.
FURTHER READING Butler, Steve. ‘‘Estimating the Cost to Build a B2B Exchange.’’ eMarketer, 25 May 2001. Available from http:// www.emarketer.com. ———. ‘‘Independent Exchanges: How the Survivors Have Evolved.’’ eMarketer, 7 January 2002. Available from http:// www.emarketer.com. ———. ‘‘Private Exchanges: Growing in Number.’’ eMarketer, 3 January 2002. Available from http:// www.emarketer.com.
16 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
prices and free shipping. Like many other B2C businesses launched in the mid- and late 1990s, the firm was much more focused on securing a wide base of customers than on earning a profit. As online shopping became more popular, established technology firms like IBM Corp. developed e-commerce services and began offering to build and even oversee sites for companies wanting to launch a B2C exchange. At the same time, a slew of e-commerce upstarts such as Scient Corp. began offering similar services. Along with merchandise like books, CDs, and computer software and hardware, B2C exchanges began to sell clothes, cosmetics, perfume, plants, toys, and other types of merchandise in the late 1990s.
———. ‘‘Productivity, Not Profit, Key to B2B.’’ ECommerce Times, 31 October 2000. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. ———. ‘‘Study: B2B Marketplaces Coming to Life.’’ ECommerce Times, 4 December 2000. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. ———. ‘‘Study: B2B to Reach $137B by 2005.’’ ECommerce Times, 8 January 2001. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. Morphy, Erika. ‘‘Ariba Throws New Punches in Private B2B Strategy.’’ CRMDaily.com, 26 July 2001. Available from http://www.crmdaily.com. ———. ‘‘IBM Forges Private B2B Link with iXL.’’ CRMDaily.com, 27 July 2001. Available from http:// www.crmdaily.com. ———. ‘‘Study: Spend Wisely on Private Marketplaces.’’ CRMDaily.com, 26 July 2001. Available from http:// www.crmdaily.com. Saliba, Clare. ‘‘Study: B2B Exchanges Need to Supply More Services.’’ E-Commerce Times, 24 May 2001. Available from http://www.ecommercetimes.com. ———. ‘‘Study: B2B Looks Beyond Sales to Collaboration.’’ E-Commerce Times, 23 May 2001. Available from http://www.ecommercetimes.com. Ward, Hazel. ‘‘B2B Exchanges Fail to Deliver.’’ Computer Weekly, 29 November 2001, 4.
❚ 11 BUSINESS-TO-CONSUMER (B2C) EXCHANGE
Business-to-consumer (B2C) exchanges are engaged in the process of electronic retailing, also known as e-tailing. Basically, a B2C business is one that sells goods and services to consumers via the Internet. Many bricks-and-mortar firms—like housewares retailer Bed, Bath, and Beyond and book retailer Borders—sell merchandise from their B2C Web sites as well as via traditional retail outlets. Other companies, like online retailing giant Amazon.com, are known as pure-play Internet businesses because they rely exclusively on Internet sales. Founded in July 1995, Amazon.com was one of the first viable B2C exchanges. Because the B2C model was relatively new then, Amazon had no choice but to develop its own technology and manage its own site. To attract customers, the firm offered low
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
Enos, Lori. ‘‘E-Marketplaces: At What Cost?’’ E-Commerce Times, 22 March 2001. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com.
Many analysts questioned the viability of B2C businesses in the late 1990s after several e-tailing problems gained national attention. For example, Toysrus.com was unable to handle an unexpected rush of orders during the 1999 holiday shopping season and failed to deliver shipments by Christmas day that year. Consumer confidence in online sales dipped, prompting speculation about the dim future of B2C exchanges. However, the B2C model continued to evolve as issues such as the security of online credit card payments were resolved by advances in technology. A multitude of B2C exchanges went bankrupt in 2000 and 2001 as investors, increasingly concerned about profitability, proved reluctant to continue funding unprofitable dot-com businesses. As a result, only the most solid B2C businesses remained operational. Even those based on ideas that appeared promising, such as online grocer Webvan Group, found themselves unable to stay afloat when they could not satisfy investors’ demands for a business model that had already produced profits or would produce profits in the very near future. In the case of Webvan, many analysts agree that the firm, in its quest to secure as many customers as possible, expanded too rapidly into other goods before stabilizing its core grocery delivery operations. Founded in 1999, Webvan was supposed to evolve into a vast delivery service that handled all types of online orders. Founder Louis Borders decided to start with groceries, launching operations in San Francisco, California. Visitors to Webvan’s Web site could select the items they wished to purchase and place them into an electronic shopping cart. To complete a purchase, shoppers were asked to select a 30-minute window in which the groceries would be delivered. According to many industry experts, the upstart made several sound marketing and customer service decisions. For example, to draw repeat business and to encourage larger orders, Webvan offered free delivery for orders over $50. Also, customers with questions about their orders could call a toll-free customer service line. As a result, within six months, Webvan had managed to reach 47,000 17
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
customers in a single market, compared to the 110,000 clients secured by its largest competitor, Peapod, which had operations in eight markets. However, despite the firm’s impressive growth, its continued losses began to concern investors in 2000. Rather than curb spending and focus its efforts on minimizing losses, Webvan launched new operations in Dallas, Texas, and Atlanta, Georgia. The firm also developed a new logo and branding strategy and redesigned its Web site, which was organized into eleven product categories. The changes were designed to communicate Webvan’s determination to become a leading force in online distribution of all kinds. However, many critics believed that the money and time would have been better spent on developing Webvan’s original brand, which had yet to be fully developed. According to a July 2001 article in The Industry Standard, ‘‘Webvan was so intent on meeting its longterm goal of building a behemoth that could deliver anything to anyone anywhere that it lost sight of a more mundane task: pleasing grocery customers day after day. In the process, it jeopardized the shorterterm goal of being a modest but profitable online supermarket.’’ In July 2001, Webvan declared bankruptcy. Failures like Webvan offer lessons for entrepreneurs planning to develop a B2C exchange. First and foremost is the lesson that securing a large base of customers is not more important than creating a profitable business. In fact, entrepreneurs in the early 2000s found it increasingly difficult to securing funding of any sort for a business plan that did not detail exactly how and when a company would begin earning a profit. Also important is deciding who your customers are and developing a close relationship with them. A May 2002 issue of Entrepreneur details additional strategies entrepreneurs should consider when planning to create their own B2C exchange. One tactic is to decide if you can be profitable and still offer a lower price than rivals. Buy.com, an electronics and computer hardware and software e-tailer is successful because it offers a wide range of products at arguably the lowest prices available. Also, if you are planning to sell some sort of specialty item, offer specialized content and services as well, as does Igourmet, which is ‘‘more than a place to buy gourmet food-it’s a gourmet food authority. While shopping, customers are treated to large product pictures and descriptive information about each item for sale.’’ The gourmet foods business also invests considerable resources in shipping its perishable items and offers a 100 percent satisfaction guarantee that can be redeemed within five days of receiving an order. Although the uncertain economic conditions of the early 2000s appeared daunting to many online entrepreneurs, the myriad of dot-com failures during those
years did help solidify some specific ‘‘dos and don’ts’’ for those wanting to launch a B2C business. One of your best bets for creating a successful B2C exchange is to examine carefully the successes and failures of other B2C businesses.
FURTHER READING Campanelli, Melissa. ‘‘Dot.common Sense.’’ Entrepreneur, May 2002. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com. Falla, Jane M. ‘‘Business-to-Consumer E-Commerce: What Is(n’t) the Problem?’’ e-Business Advisor, August 2000, 6. Helft, Miguel. ‘‘What a Long, Strange Trip It’s Been for Webvan.’’ The Industry Standard, 23 July 23 2001. Available from http://www.theindustrystandard.com. Vaturi, Diana. ‘‘Marketing Lessons from E-failures.’’ The McKinsey Quarterly, 27 November 2001. Available from http://www.mckinseyquarterly.com.
❚ 12 BUSINESS-TO-GOVERNMENT (B2G) E-COMMERCE
When you consider launching an e-commerce enterprise, there are several client models to choose from. The best publicized are business-to-consumer (B2C) and business-to-business (B2B). But government, at the local, state, and federal levels, is also a rapidly emerging client base for companies offering products and services through an electronic business. While governments at all these levels have been slow to adopt e-commerce strategies relative to enterprises in the private sector, the early 2000s saw public agencies reorganizing to take advantage of e-commerce in order to streamline their practices and provide better service to their citizenry. As a result, a tempting new market for e-commerce entrepreneurs has emerged.
AN OPENING MARKET According the research firm Gartner Group, government expenditures on information technology for e-government was expected to quadruple in the first half the 2000s, reaching $6.5 billion by 2005. Some 85 percent of all government agencies were actively planning e-procurement implementation in the early 2000s, signaling that governments increasingly planned to buy their goods and services of the Internet. In terms of sheer market volume, then, the business-togovernment model poses enormous earning potential. Moreover, while the bulk of this increase stems from governments overhauling to become viable for e-government operations, businesses that begin developing
18 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
The B2G market was greatly aided by the Government Paperwork Reduction Act, which requires federal agencies to move to electronic forms by 2003, and which signaled government’s commitment to electronically based services and communications with their citizens and with each other. In addition, agencies at all levels of government increasingly employ a chief information officer, a role implemented specifically, in most cases, for leading the transition to e-government operations. Often such officers deal with e-commerce providers directly, and it is likely to be the same group you proposition and target in your advertising and marketing schemes. Depending on the size and capabilities of your ecommerce firm, you may choose to specifically target governments or agencies at the federal, state, or local level. To be sure, the opportunities are prevalent at any level of government. At each level, officials express interest in developing greater electronic communication with their constituents, via e-procurement, Web portals, e-payments, and other government-to-citizen applications. One area of opportunity is in the e-solutions market, as governments seek out help from private-sector solutions providers to help them speed up and smooth their transitions to e-government services. A wide assortment of e-solutions is in demand in the public sector. The most immediate demand is for e-procurement infrastructure software and services while government agencies transform themselves into e-government organizations. But, with the experiences of the private sector to learn from, most government agencies will likely choose a more holistic approach to developing their new IT systems and processes, and thus will require a range of services, including everything from Web site design and management and backend set-up services to Internet security and systems integration. Once you’ve decided to jump into the B2G fray, the next step is figuring out how to sell to governments. One of the most successful marketing schemes in the early 2000s was creating Web-based B2G online marketplaces, similar to B2B exchanges but focused specifically around the products and services catering to government agencies. Either developing or joining one of these exchanges will put you in touch with a larger community of vendors and government agencies, allowing you to find customers through an established network, discover and focus your services toward government needs via online forums and other communication channels, and find other businesses for potential strategic alliances in the B2G field.
Federal purchases are frequently made with the SmartPay small-purchase credit card, and so to attract customers in the public sector, you need to advertise yourself as familiar with and capable of accepting the card electronically. You can download the SmartPay logo to advertise on your site from the federal government’s General Services Administration Web site.
CHALLENGES
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
relationships with governments during this rapid expansion and transformation period may eke out a competitive advantage over the long run by generating lasting business in the B2G sector.
However, working with governments poses some challenges. For one, sales margins tend to hover at 515 percent lower, on average, than those in the private sector, according to a report in Computer Reseller News. Still, the ability to carve out a viable and lasting niche in this booming market can allow you to make up for any lower margins. In addition, the buying process in government tends to be drawn-out compared with the private sector, requiring several layers of approval and rigid procedures for submitting and accepting bids. Such formalities add time to the process of securing contracts. Finally, the transition to e-government carries with it greater pressures for governments compared with commercial enterprises in the form of regulations as well as the sensitivity toward ‘‘consumer’’ tastes and rights. The protection of citizens’ privacy and other security and regulatory concerns are particularly pronounced in the public sector, and thus government agencies will likely proceed with some trepidation, so as to avoid wasting money on systems that need to be overhauled down the road.
FURTHER READING Frook, John Evan. ‘‘Wooing Uncle Sam for E-gov Business.’’ B to B, May 14, 2001, 13. Laurent, Anne. ‘‘E-invasion.’’ Government Executive, June 2000, 26. Sood, Rishi. ‘‘E-gov Initiatives Aim to Empower Citizens.’’ VAR Business, January 22, 2001, 91. Taft, Darryl. ‘‘The Next E-target: Uncle Sam.’’ Computer Reseller News, April 24, 2000, 1. ———. ‘‘Raising the E-government Banner.’’ Computer Reseller News, March 19, 2001, 32. Tillett, L. Scott. ‘‘Feds Closing IT Gap—Agencies Aim to Catch E-businesses During Downturn.’’ InternetWeek, July 9, 2001, 1.
19 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
❚ 13 CALL CENTER SERVICES
Call centers are essentially customer service centers that field all types of calls, from requests for additional information about a product or service to customer complaints. Some call centers are developed and operated by the companies they serve. For example, Continental Airlines operates five call centers, each housing roughly 3,500 agents. Other call centers are set up to offer call center services to a variety of different enterprises. Although a telephone call remains the most common method of contacting a call center, in many cases customers are also able to use e-mail and other Internet technologies to speak with call center representatives. Advances in technology have allowed call centers to offer increasingly sophisticated services. Depending on how much your business can afford to spend on call center services, you might be able to use skill-based routing to connect your customers with the individuals most qualified to handle their request; record calls; allow call center representatives to access and modify your existing customer database; and make use of interactive voice technology to allow callers to select various options without having to push the numbers on their telephone key pad. The rise of e-commerce since the mid-1990s has had a dramatic impact on call center services, not only changing how call centers interact with customers but also broadening the range of services that a call center can provide. A dramatic rise in business conducted via the Web eventually spawned the development of Web-enabled call centers, which offer consumers both telephone and online service. Many businesses have connected their call centers to their Web sites to provide more immediate customer service options to Web surfers. Enhanced services include instant chat, which allows online customers instantaneous access to a service representative via a text-based communications program. Some Web-enabled call centers also offer Web call-back, a feature that allows consumers to click on a specific button on a Web site if they wish to have a customer service representative call them via telephone in the next few minutes. Another innovative service, interactive voice response (IVR), allows online customers with a PC-based microphone to actually speak to a service representative over the Web; in some cases, video technology enables these clients to see the representative with whom they are in contact. Although it is less immediate, Web-based call center services also typically offer e-mail as a communication medium.
The need for improved online customer service stemmed from the fact that many online businesses saw potential customers abandoning their purchases before completing a transaction due to the limited availability of service online. In some cases, even if the answer to a question about a product or service was located on the Web site (in many cases in a prominent section dubbed ‘‘Frequently Asked Questions’’), customers still chose to abandon the purchase rather than sift through information. Many businesses believed that offering advanced call center services on their Web sites could help turn these lost sales into profits. According to an April 2001 issue of Informationweek.com, ‘‘The ability of Web-enabled call centers to enhance customer service and to close sales more quickly isn’t only appealing, it can be crucial to the bottom line. Call center agents who use e-mail, instant chat, and Web collaboration to interact with customers are able to more quickly and completely handle questions and resolve problems.’’ A Forrester Research study cited in the article predicts that Web sites and e-mail will each account for more than 17 percent of a typical company’s communication with customers by the end of 2002. Many small businesses offer informal call center services, which essentially means that employees responsible for a variety of tasks also answer the phone. If your business requires more formal call center services, particularly Web-enabled ones, you might decide to purchase call center services from an outside source. Such a decision does raise issues of staffing, training, and quality control, as you will lose some degree of control over what you may believe is the most crucial aspect of your business, customer service. However, outsourcing may also give you access to more sophisticated technology than you might otherwise be able to afford. In 2000, the cost of infrastructure for most integrated call centers—estimated at roughly $90,000 for a 20-agent center ($4,500 per agent), not including integration and implementation costs—was well beyond the reach of many small business. Technology firms hoping to target small and midsized companies began to develop less expensive options in the early 2000s. For example, in 2001 AT& T Corp. and Qwest Communications both began working to develop network-based call centers that would allow small businesses to tie into an existing call center network, eliminating the need to purchase new equipment. Via this type of structure, calls that come in to a networked call center, either by telephone or by a link from a company’s Web site, are first sent to a network server and then routed to a specific call center that can handle the request. In 2002, call center technology specialist Rockwell introduced FirstPoint Business Edition, a Web-enabled call center solution for small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs), at a
20 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Gartner Group estimates that small and mediumsized business will account for roughly 88 percent of the call center marketplace by 2005. As a result, technology firms will likely continue to develop new call center services designed specifically for smaller enterprises. Therefore, your best bet for obtaining the call center services best suited to your business is researching the most current options available.
FURTHER READING Dawson, Keith. ‘‘Rockwell Reaches for SMB Market.’’ Call Center Magazine, 10 May 2002. Available from http:// www.callcentermagazine.com. Henderson, Jay. ‘‘Platform Call Center Levels the Playing Field.’’ Communications News, June 2000, 50. Wallace, Bob. ‘‘The Modern Call Center.’’ Informationweek.com, 9 April 2001. Available from http:// www.informationweek.com/832/call.htm.
❚ 14 CONSUMER PRIVACY ISSUES
Online privacy, both real and perceived, is a critical factor to popular acceptance of e-commerce by consumers. The theft of information such as credit card, social security, and bank account numbers can have dire, lasting consequences for the victim. These consequences include nuisances such as unsolicited commercial email (spam), junk mail, and unsolicited phone calls from telemarketers as well as identity theft, which can destroy an individual’s reputation and cost him or her thousands of dollars. Unless users are confident that their sensitive personal information is secure from prying eyes, they will be reluctant to make purchases over the Internet. Consumers also hesitate if they believe e-merchants are likely to sell their personal information to other businesses without their knowledge. Hence it is important that online businesses take steps to safeguard the privacy of their customers. What precisely constitutes an online invasion of privacy differs greatly from person to person. Some individuals do not object to having their browsing behavior tracked and used for targeted marketing; some can tolerate a mail box full of spam; others object to any information being collected and exchanged without their permission. Unfortunately for privacy
lovers, the Internet is—almost by definition—an open system where private information can easily be uncovered, and the very act of going online puts one’s privacy at risk. Information is routed through numerous computers, all of which can monitor a user’s activities online and then pass that information to others. Many Web sites require users to provide personal information, including name, address, and email address, on registration forms before they are allowed to enter.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
price of $1625 per user. According to a May 2002 article in Call Center Magazine, ‘‘the tool is powerful, more powerful than an SMB could have hoped for at $1600 a seat just a few years ago.’’
Most commercial sites also use cookies, tiny text files placed on users’ hard drives—usually without their knowledge or approval—when a site is visited. In their most benign use, cookies enable Web businesses to monitor users’ visits to their sites, remember their identities, simplify signing in and the completion of forms, etc. More nefariously, however, cookies enable Web sites to track a user’s general activity online. The information can then be used to send ads, and occasionally spam and junk mail as well, based on a user’s personal interests. Most seriously, cookies provide a record of a Web consumer’s visits to Web sites that contain sensitive or controversial materials, such as pornography, drug information, or information about tax resistance. This is significant in a time when government agencies such as the FBI and the IRS have begun buying such records from list brokers. The greatest fear of online consumers is that credit card numbers can be stolen. Consumers should shop only with online merchants who maintain secure Web sites, which reduce the risk that a hacker or another third party will obtain information during its transmission. A secure Web site can be recognized by a closed padlock at the bottom of the screen or a URL that begins with https://. Nonetheless, a secure Web site alone is not sufficient to guarantee that hackers cannot access consumers’ information. If the e-merchant stores the information in unencrypted form, it is at risk from hackers. Hackers are not the only threat to sensitive information. Web site operators sometimes sell information— even credit card, social security, and bank account numbers—collected from their users. Most online businesses have formulated privacy policies covering the use of information they collect. These policies vary in thoroughness and are completely voluntary. There is no guarantee an e-businessperson will adhere to his or her own policy. Flagrant violations have occurred. Adherence by Web sites that display the seal of services such as TRUSTe or BBBOnline, however, is regularly audited. Prior notification is a fundamental issue for privacy advocates. Consumers often do not know how their personal information is being used by a site. Opt-in rules are one solution to the problem. Under such rules, no personal information could be given to third 21
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
parties without explicit permission from the consumer. Online marketing firms, which live from the sale and use of such information, oppose opt-in policies, maintaining that they would make Web site use too burdensome for Internet consumers. One study found that 84 percent of adults would be unlikely to opt in if given a choice; hence opt-in would likely make targeted marketing and the compilation of address lists much more difficult. The alternative is an opt-out policy, which would allow a Web site to use personal information freely until a consumer instructed it not to do so. Advocates of the rule say opt-out makes for much more convenience surfing the Internet. Opponents say that opt-out information is too frequently hidden away in fine print on an inconspicuous page of a site. A Forrester Research study conducted in 2001 found that 70 percent of those polled were ‘‘extremely interested’’ or ‘‘very interested’’ in laws guaranteeing Internet privacy. At the beginning of 2002, only one such law was on the books, the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) of 2000, a law that severely limits information a Web site can request of a preteen. That year, about 50 privacy bills were before Congress many of which dealt with Web issues. For instance, one would prohibit the production and use of so-called ‘‘spyware’’—software that collects and distributes information directly from a user’s personal computer without the permission of consumers; another would direct the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to develop regulations to protect the privacy of Internet users. In February 2002 the European Union took the first steps toward restricting the use of cookies, a move unlikely in the United States. The computer and dot-com industries see such legislation as an overreaction that would introduce unneeded government regulation. They have proposed self-regulation as an alternative to legislation. Legal scholars, on the other hand, believe that effective privacy laws are virtually impossible because they would violate the free speech provisions of the U.S. Constitution. In the meantime, in early 2002 the FTC began cracking down on the sale and use of personal information without a consumer’s consent and on the use of spam. It has also announced that Web sites must abide by their published privacy policies. Privacy is an important consideration for online businesspeople. Customers routinely abandon shopping carts online rather than give e-merchants personal information. One report estimated that nearly US$18 billion in online retail sales has been lost due to concerns about privacy. The costs could go even higher: If government believes that online businesspeople are unfairly intruding on the privacy of consumers, it could enact laws or regulations that severely impact the conduct of e-business. Heavy restrictions, on
cookie use, for example, could deprive Internet business of one of its prime advantages over bricks-andmortar businesses—the ability to identify and reach users based on demographic profiles. In the end eager sellers and suspicious buyers will have to reach some kind of compromise. Consumers and businesspeople can find additional background on privacy issues in general and on Internet privacy specifically at the following Web sites:
T Electronic Privacy Information Center, www.epic.org T Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, www.privacyrights.org T The Federal Trade Commission, www.ftc.gov T The Privacy Alliance, www.privacyalliance.org
FURTHER READING ‘‘Behind the Numbers: Privacy Practices on the Web.’’ Center for Democracy and Technology, 1999. Available from http://www.cdt.org/privacy/990727privacy.shtml. ‘‘Being Traced Over the Internet.’’ Privacy.Net. Available from http://www.privacy.net/Traced/. Benoit, Michael A., and Nicole F. Munro. ‘‘Recent Federal Privacy Initiatives Affecting the Electronic Delivery of Financial Services.’’ Business Lawyer, May 2001. Berman, Jerry, and Deirdre Mulligan. ‘‘Privacy in the Digital Age.’’ Nova Law Review, Vol. 23, no. 2, winter 1999. Beyer, Leslie, ‘‘For Whose Eyes Only?’’ Internet Retailer, July 2000, Vol. 2, no. 6, 40. Culnam, Mary J. ‘‘Protecting Privacy Online: Is SelfRegulation Working?’’ Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, Spring 2000, Vol. 19, no. 1, 20. ‘‘The Dark Side. ’’ Cookie Central. Available from http:// www.cookiecentral.com/content.phtml?area=2&id=2. ‘‘Fact Sheet 18: Privacy in Cyberspace.’’ Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, June 1995, revised August 2000. Available from http://www.privacyrights.org. ‘‘Fact Sheet 23: E-Commerce and You: Online Shopping Tips.’’ Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, Available from http:// www.privacyrights.org/fs/fs23-shopping.htm. Freeman, Reed, Jr., and Gonzalo Mon, ‘‘Listing Towards Privacy.’’ Promo, May 2002. Gellman, Robert. ‘‘Privacy, Consumers, and Costs: How the Lack of Privacy Costs Consumers and Why Business Studies of Privacy Costs Are Biased and Incomplete.’’ Electronic Privacy Information Center, 2002. Available from http:// www.epic.org/reports/dmfprivacy.html.
22 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Han, Peter, and Angus Maclaurin. ‘‘Do Consumers Really Care About Online Privacy?’’ Marketing Management, January/February 2002, Vol. 11, no. 1, 35. Hatlestad, Luc. ‘‘Consumers Want Complete Protection, But E-tailers Won’t Guarantee It: Why Both Sides Must Budge.’’ Red Herring, 15 January 2001. Kennedy, John. ‘‘EU Takes the Byte Out of Cookies.’’ Global News Wire, 22 November 2001. Mayer-Schoenberger, Viktor, ‘‘The Cookie Concept,’’ Cookie Central. Available from http://www.cookiecentral.com/ content.phtml?area=2&id=1 Milne, George R., and Andrew J. Rohm. ‘‘Consumer Privacy and Name Removal Across Direct Marketing Channels: Exploring Opt-In and Opt-Out Alternatives.’’ Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, fall 2000, Vol. 19, no. 2, 238. ———. ‘‘Privacy and Ethical Issues in Database/Interactive Marketing and Public Policy.’’ Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, spring 2000, Vol. 19, no. 1, 1. Miyazaki, Anthony D., and Ana Fernandez. ‘‘Internet Privacy and Security: An Examination of Online Retailer Disclosures.’’ Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, spring 2000, Vol. 19, no. 1, 54. Phelps, Joseph, Glen Nowak, and Elizabeth Ferrell. ‘‘Privacy Concerns and Consumer Willingness to Provide Personal Information.’’ Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, spring 2000, Vol. 19, no. 1, 27. ‘‘A Review of Current Privacy Issues.’’ Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, Available from http://www.privacyrights.org/ ar/Privacy-IssuesList.htm. Sheehan, Kim Bartel, and Mariea Grubbs Hoy. ‘‘Dimensions of Privacy Concern Among Online Consumers.’’ Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, spring 2000, Vol. 19, no. 1, 62. Volokh, Eugene. ‘‘Online Consumer Privacy Concerns.’’ Hearing on Privacy in the Commercial World. Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection, Federal Document Clearing House, 2001. Wilcox, Joe. ‘‘Customers Wary of Online Ids.’’ CNET News.com, 2002. Available from http://news.com.com/21001001-892808.html.
❚ 15 CURRENCY ISSUES IN ELECTRONIC COMMERCE
E-commerce, with its online stores, virtual shoppers, and sometimes even downloadable electronic
products, introduced a simple but unavoidable question: How could payment be digitized as well? Credit cards seem an obvious answer at first, but they have problems of their own. They are not cost effective for small purchases—so-called microtransactions—and many consumers simply can’t get one. Debit cards have to be physically swiped through a reader that few own. Furthermore, purchases made with credit and debit cards lack the anonymity of cold, hard cash, which can only be used for online purchases if one is willing to risk sending it through the mail. Checks and money orders are difficult to use for international purchases. If electronic trade is to succeed on a widespread scale, a digital medium of exchange is needed—a means for paying for things electronically, an e-currency.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
Given, Beth. ‘‘Privacy Expectations in a High Tech World.’’ Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, 2000. Available from http:// www.privacyrights.org.
There are three general types of electronic payment currently in use that online shoppers and businesses can use in exchange for goods and services. The first uses a trusted third party as an intermediary for transactions, usually a bank or other financial institution that holds the bank account numbers, credit card numbers, and other sensitive information of the buyer and seller. Such transactions are electronic only to the extent that the third party gets instructions via email. The second type is a form of fund transfer similar to a credit card purchase. Because sensitive information is changing hands, the system encrypts all data before transmission for security. This system is expected to become popular because the model is familiar to consumers. The third form of electronic payment, still in development, largely by corporations and central banks, is e-money. Electronic money is value reduced to its metaphysical essence. Unlike credit cards, notational fund transfers, or trusted third parties, e-money is not merely a transfer of financial information. E-money is money, pure and simple, like the bills we carry in our purses and wallets. It can change hands anonymously. It can be saved, spent, and stolen. A unit of e-money, like physical banknotes, has a unique serial number, a denomination, and an issuer that backs the money. All this information is rendered digitally as a numerical formula. If someone intercepts the code, that person has stolen the money. E-money can be stored on a computer or on a card, similar to some telephone cards, with a small computer chip. Obtaining digital cash, under most present schemes, would be very similar to making a withdrawal from one’s local bank, except everything could take place online. A customer would request a certain number of specific denominations, which are generated by special software. They are placed in an ‘‘electronic envelope;’’ that is, encrypted to disguise the serial numbers. The withdrawer ‘‘signs’’ the envelope using a private encryption key and transmits it to the 23
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
bank for verification that the funds are available. If so, the bank countersigns the envelope using its encryption key and returns to the customer. The e-cash can then be spent. There are two sorts of e-money, distinguished mainly by the financial trail they leave when spent. With identified e-money, the identity of the original user remains bound to the money. As a result the trail of the currency through the economy can be reconstructed at any time after it is spent. Anonymous e-money, like conventional cash, leaves no such trail. In general, though, the safeguards in place to prevent copying electronic currency would make it possible to trace users in case of unlawful duplication. Each of these two types is in turn divided into online emoney and offline e-money. The former can only be used via a computer network and with a bank acting as intermediary. It is stored in a computer. Transactions with offline e-money do not require a bank’s intervention; it is stored on cards known as smart cards or electronic purses. Offline anonymous e-money is the e-currency that most resembles conventional money and is sometimes referred to as true digital cash. The Center for Research in Electronic Commerce at the University of Texas at Austin speculates that the smart card will become the storage medium of choice for e-cash because the card can also be used to store other information, such as personal identification, house and office keys, and various personal preference files. E-cash’s existence as pure information raises an issue of fundamental importance, known as the double spending problem. Digital duplication would be simple, and copies would be indistinguishable from the original. How can this be prevented? The issue is less critical with online cash, which is checked against bank records when it is spent. One way offline e-cash double spending is controlled is by utilizing tamperproof smart cards equipped with special ‘‘Observer’’ chips. Another tactic is to encrypt and track the ecash in such a way that the identity of a doublespender is revealed when the duplicate reaches the bank. Under such a system, it would seem, all electronic money usage would be ultimately traceable. Nonetheless, the use of electronic cash has grown more slowly than expected. By one estimate the number of ventures issuing e-cash or something like it dropped from about thirty in 2001 to only ten a year later. The most successful system was PayPal, which established itself as a payment system for online auctions. PayPal proved that in certain e-commerce cntexts there is a real demand for e-cash. By spring 2002 it had 12 million users in 39 countries. In 2001 it generated about US$8.2 million. Three of the leading e-money firms, Beenz, Flooz, and CyberCash, went out of business in 2001. Speculation about reasons varied. Some believed that these systems did not
stick closely enough to known payment models— notably cash and credit cards—to make consumers feel comfortable using them. Others noted that, unlike PayPal, the failed e-cash types were not affiliated with established financial institutions that would inspire consumer confidence. Fraud was another threat. Flooz sold US$300,000 of its currency to international criminals using fradulent credit cards. Even PayPal was victimized by such a scam, a fact it revealed when it went public in 2001. A potentially critical disadvantage of offline anonymous electronic currency is that it makes money laundering easier because it requires no intermediary, its use is extremely easy, it is completely untraceable, and laundering can be done from any computer or cell phone. What makes for a successful e-currency?
It must be widely accepted and used It must easy to use as a medium of exchange Its value must be stable Its value must be backed by a trustworthy institution T It must be easy to access and transport T It must not cost merchants that accept it, as credit cards do The acceptance and spread of digital cash is intimately bound up with intangibles—the faith of its users in its value and its ability to retain its value. A key element of that faith will be the reliability of the issuers of e-money. Banks or firms that try to control its use too closely are unlikely to attract users. The acceptance of an immaterial novelty like e-currency will also take time. The transition to a money culture took hundreds of years. However fast the spread and acceptance of the Internet, and even of e-commerce, it is probably foolhardy to expect that consumers or businesses will easily give up their attachment to money that they can slip into their pockets or purses. T T T T
FURTHER READING Allewn, Catherine A., William J. Barr, and Ron Schultz. Smart Cards: Seizing Strategic Business Opportunities. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Professional Publishing, 1996. ‘‘Electronic Payment Systems.’’ The Center for Research in Electronic Commerce, Graduate School of Business, University of Texas at Austin. Available from http:// cism.bus.utexas.edu/resources/ecfaq/ecfaqd3.html. Derrick, Stuart. ‘‘Buying Power.’’ e.Business, 31 August 2000, 20. Dorn, James A., ed. The Future of Money in the Information Age. Washington, DC: Cato Institute, 1997.
24 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Miller, Jim. ‘‘E-money Mini-FAQ (release 2.0).’’ Available from http://www.ex.ac.uk/~RDavies/arian/money.html. Mungo, Paul. ‘‘Connected: Hard Cash.’’ Daily Telegraph (London), 26 August 1999, 8. O’Mahony, Donald, et al. Electronic Payment Systems for ECommerce. Boston, MA: Artech House, 1997. Punch, Linda. ‘‘The Shakeout in Online Cash.’’ Business and Management Practices, December 2001, Vol. 14, no. 9, 24. ‘‘Show Me the e Commerce Money.’’ New TV Strategies, 21 December 2000, 5. Smart, Victor. ‘‘Show Me the Money.’’ Guardian (London), 11 April 2002. Wilson, Chuck. Get Smart: The Emergence of Smart Cards in the United States and Their Pivotal Role in Internet Commerce: A Comprehensive Review. Richardson, TX: Mullaney Pub. Group, 2001.
❚ 16 CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT
Customer relationship management (CRM) refers specifically to the software that companies use to manage and track contact with their customers. Components of CRM systems include analytic programs that examine information on buying patterns to improve services and attract new customers, sales force software, e-mail response applications, and Webbased customer support, among others. CRM evolved from packaged contact management software, which was introduced in 1990. As companies developed sophisticated telemarketing programs and multi-tiered customer service solutions, the demand for software systems to support frontline customer contact appeared. The first packaged sales force automation (SFA) solutions appeared in 1999, as did customized CRM solutions. Increased customer contact over the World Wide Web since 1999 has fueled the growth of Web-based CRM solutions. When combined with an overall business strategy, CRM helps promote a customer-focused corporate culture. CRM strategies involve integrating people, processes, and technology in order to create a single view of the customer. A successful CRM strategy is based on quantifying the value of customer relationships and creating a strategy to maximize that value.
The promise of CRM lies in enabling companies to keep their best customers and acquire new ones. Companies can use customer information to maximize the value of existing relationships, to expand those relationships, and to extend an enterprise’s brand into other competitive markets. Objectives include keeping high-value customers, increasing the value of moderate- to low-value customers, and minimizing the cost of customers who take away value. Used properly, CRM can achieve the desired results of creating customer loyalty, retaining customers, and expanding current relationships.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
Lewis, Holden. ‘‘Guide to eMoney.’’ Bankrate.com. Available from http://www.bankrate.com/brm/news/emoney/ emoney1.asp.
Corporate spending on CRM systems reached $22 billion in 2001, a 10.6 percent increase over $19.9 billion in 2000, according to Dataquest Inc., a unit of Gartner Inc. The company predicted that CRM revenue would reach $25.3 billion in 2002 and $47 billion by 2006. Companies that had deployed a CRM solution by the end of 2001 were considered early adopters. They were primarily large enterprises with sales of $10 billion or more and were engaged in competitive industries such as financial services, software, and telecommunications.
CRITICAL FACTORS FOR SUCCESS OR FAILURE According to Gartner Group, some 65 percent of all CRM projects had failed as of early 2002. Lack of senior-level support was cited by the Data Warehousing Institute of Seattle as a leading risk factor to successful CRM implementations. Many companies that were early adopters focused on technology solutions instead of the broader business strategy that the technology can enable. In some cases CRM technology was used to generate more sales from customers rather than to build a long-term relationship with them. Companies also can improve their chances of a successful CRM deployment by keeping it simple. During the first phase of a CRM deployment, enterprises should limit themselves to a few critical areas of change and demonstrate clear benefits for senior management and shareholders, the company’s sales professionals, and its customers. Senior management and shareholders are interested in how CRM can measurably increase top-line revenue growth or anticipate order volume for key product lines. Sales professionals want software that enables them to spend more time with customers and makes it easier to provide sales quotes. CRM can benefit customers by making it easier for them to interact with the company through a variety of channels: telephone, Internet, face-toface, etc. Companies can improve their chances of a successful CRM rollout with better planning before implementation. They need to take an enterprise-wide view 25
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
and consider the impact any CRM application would have on the overall customer service experience. Instead of letting CRM technology dictate how they interact with their customers, companies should view CRM as a tool that helps the customer service process.
Leading CRM vendors include market leader Siebel Systems, followed by SAP AG, Oracle, and PeopleSoft. Other leading vendors include E.piphany, Salesforce.com, and Blue Martini Software.
Before selecting a CRM vendor, the following steps should be considered:
OUTLOOK FOR CRM Enterprises were cutting back on large information technology (IT) expenditures for CRM systems in 2002 compared to 2001. According to a Gartner/Dataquest survey of IT and business executives reported in CRMDaily at the beginning of 2002, the percentage of companies with more than $1 billion in annual revenue that would deploy CRM systems dropped from 35 percent in 2001 to less than 20 percent for 2002. By contrast, 35 percent of companies with sales between $500 million and $1 billion planned to deploy CRM systems within six months, compared to less than 15 percent that were involved in deploying CRM systems at the end of 2001. In terms of expenditures, only 3 percent of the survey respondents indicated that they would spend $10 million or more on CRM systems in 2002, while 34 percent planned on spending less than $100,000. CRM systems were expected to feature more multichannel integration, offering real-time information sharing among different customer channels, including customer service, field service, the Web, marketing, and sales. This will enable companies to offer customers the same experience regardless of which channel is used for customer contact. CRM will enable enterprises to create a true marketing portal through which they can obtain a comprehensive view of each customer. Since CRM makes use of customer data, companies were expected to focus their efforts more on the analysis and organization of data so that customer information can be more effectively used to implement CRM solutions. The result will be improved customer differentiation and segmentation, which will allow for more effective and measurable marketing campaigns. Rather than simply looking at what customers have bought in the past and making offers based on that behavior, an emerging CRM model will actually track attitudes and stated preferences and opinions. Traditional CRM has measured actions, not attitudes. Companies will recognize that customer satisfaction does not necessarily translate into customer loyalty. Enterprises will seek to find ways of offering customers better value for their money. They will develop metrics to measure customer loyalty and value-enhancing corporate performance.
T Strategy: determine what CRM means to the enterprise, then develop a strategic plan. T Determine how much customization is needed. T Establish who the decision-makers will be in the CRM process. T Plan for change management, including how and when employees and clients will be introduced to the new system, training, and demonstration of the system’s benefits. T Optimize network architecture for CRM applications. T Finally, select a vendor.
VENDORS AND DEPLOYMENT Many early CRM failures were due to simply selecting the wrong vendor. According to a Gartner/ Dataquest survey at the beginning of 2002 and reported in CRMDaily, the top two criteria in selecting a CRM consultant/vendor were an established track record and speed to solution. Being able to offer an integrated-solutions approach based on applications expertise ranked a close third. The biggest challenges facing companies considering a CRM system were the high cost of deployment and integration with internal applications and processes. The CRM marketplace may appear needlessly complex and confusing. There are a wide array of products, systems, and software to choose from. Companies that cannot afford to buy complete CRM product suites need to outline exactly which types of CRM applications would suit their needs. Ideally, a CRM vendor would work hard to truly understand a company’s business and then find the appropriate CRM technology to match the company’s business goals, strategies, and processes. In reality, companies have complained that CRM vendors often simply provide them with CRM technology and promise that it will solve their problems. In finding the right CRM vendor, companies must go through a process of due diligence to select a vendor that will work with them in advance of implementation to understand their business needs. Ideally, the vendor would then work with the enterprise as a partner to provide it with a customized solution.
FURTHER READING Budhwani, Karim. ‘‘Once You’ve Found Them, Never Let Them Go.’’ CMA Management, April 2002, 13.
26 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
time developing adequate Web-based customer service for this new touch point. If an existing customer decides to make a purchase via a company’s Web site, a negative experience with the site could drive the customer away from the company altogether. Similarly, customers unhappy with how a company responds to an e-mail message might decide to contact a rival company instead. This concern typically affects bricks-and-mortar businesses venturing online for the first time. If customers are used to receiving prompt assistance when the make a phone call to a company, they will likely expect equally prompt customer service online.
Hill, Kimberly. ‘‘Consultants Vie for Smaller CRM Pie.’’ CRMDaily.com, 6 February 2002. Available from http:// www.crmdaily.com. Hirsh, Lou. ‘‘The Legends of CRM.’’ E-Commerce Times, 19 February 2002. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. Jaroneczyk, Jennifer. ‘‘CRM Stumbles on the Catwalk.’’ Internet World, April 2002, 14. ‘‘Keep CRM Simple.’’ Sales & Marketing Management, March 2002, 21. McDonough, Dan, Jr. ‘‘What a Drag—Execs Pinpoint CRM Pitfalls.’’ CRMDaily.com, 29 October 2001. Available from http://www.crmdaily.com. Morphy, Erika. ‘‘After the Fall: The Future of CRM, Parts 14.’’ CRMDaily.com, 6, 9, 13, and 16 November 2001. Available from http://www.crmdaily.com. ———. ‘‘IBM Deploys Siebel: An Enterprise-Level CRM Rollout.’’ E-Commerce Times, 20 February 2002. Available from http://www.ecommercetimes.com. Seben, Larry. ‘‘What Makes CRM Tick?’’ CRMDaily.com, 13 August 2001. Available from http://www.crmdaily.com.
❚ 17 CUSTOMER TOUCH POINTS
The rise of e-commerce in the late 1990s allowed businesses to interact with their customers in new ways. Along with the telephone and mail, businesses could interact with clients via e-mail and Web sites. For example, via the Web, customers could buy merchandise from a company without ever visiting a store, making a call, or mailing in an order. Also, e-mail allowed companies to do things like notify customers that their orders had been shipped. Along with providing a new medium for sales and communication, Internet technology also brought with it added responsibility. Businesses that added new touch points, which are essentially ways in which a client can interact with a company, were accountable for more types of customer contact. One of the most common difficulties businesses face when adding new touch points in ensuring customer service consistency. Many analysts point out that customers expect the same level of service no matter what their method of contacting a company is. Therefore, launching a Web site can be a risky endeavor for a business that has not spent the necessary
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
Greenspan, Robyn. ‘‘CRM Spending on the Upswing.’’ eCRMguide, 9 April 2002. Available from http:// www.ecrmguide.com.
Companies might also make the mistake of adding new touch points without considering how they impact other touch points, a practice that can also prove damaging to customer relationships. For example, many companies have built technology into their Web sites that allows them to recognize customers online and personalize their experience. For example, Amazon.com greets existing customers by name and showcases products in which customers might be interested, based on their previous purchases. ‘‘This can be a good thing,’’ explains a February 2001 issue of Business Courier Serving Cincinnati. ‘‘But beware, if this customer interaction is not shared with other channels, you might do more damage than good. For instance, if a customer places an order through your Web site, and your sales rep does not have knowledge of the order, his or her next interaction with the customer will most likely be embarrassing for the sales rep, the company and the customer.’’ Similarly, customer service representatives answering the phone might receive calls in reference to e-mails sent by customers. If they are not prepared to deal with such calls, customers will be left unsatisfied. Developing consistency across all customer service touch points is also essential for businesses hoping to implement a customer relationship management (CRM) system. Such a system tracks data gathered at various touch points to help businesses better understand their customers. Businesses can then use this data for things like targeted marketing campaigns. Many online companies use CRM technology to keep track of which pages visitors to their Web sites view most often. These companies are then able to send emails about specific products to those potential customers. Similarly, companies can send e-mail messages about sales or special promotions to the customers most likely to be interested in this news. Before expanding your customer touch points, be sure you are maximizing your existing ones. Any activity that brings your company in contact with a customer is a touch point, whether or not you consider it a customer service activity. For example, sending invoices, either paper or electronic, to customers creates a touch point. According to a May 2000 issue of 27
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
Global Best Practices, invoices ‘‘form independent connections with customers that provide strategic opportunities for companies to build relationships, increase satisfaction, and cross-sell. By taking full advantage of the opportunities each invoice provides to communicate with customers, companies gain strategic business advantage in the ongoing struggle to hold on to customers.’’ As a result, it is important to see activities like billing, which brings you in contact with your clients, in terms of customer service. It is also imperative to view your marketing efforts as customer touch points as well. For example, if you plan to embark upon something like an e-mail marketing campaign, analysts recommend that you consider the impact your e-mail message(s) will have on those you contact. If your customers prefer not to receive such messages, making that choice clear to you should be an easily available option. In some cases, Web sites are designed to ask customers making a purchase if they wish to receive future e-mails about new products, sales, etc. In other cases, e-mail messages include an e-mail address customers can use to send a message that they would like to be removed from a mailing list. Most analysts recommend creating a customer service strategy that takes into account all of your customer touch points. Having such a strategy in place can help business owners adding a new touch point decide how to maintain consistent customer service and, ultimately, retain their customer base while they grow their operations. With the acquisition of new customers costing an estimated 30 to 40 times more than the management of existing customers, most analysts assert that devoting time to developing this type of strategy is well worth the effort.
FURTHER READING Arthur Andersen. ‘‘Best Practices: Bill the Customer.’’ Global Best Practices. 2 May 2000. Available from http:// www.globalbestpractices.com. McCall, Kimberly. ‘‘Customer Retention Key to Business Success.’’ MarketingAngel.com, 14 March 2000. Available from http://www.marketingangel.com. Miller, Julia. ‘‘Dos and Don’ts of E-Mail Marketing.’’ HomeOfficeMag.com, September 2000. Available from http:// www.entrepreneur.com. Morphy, Erica. ‘‘The 21st Century Contact Center Rep.’’ CRMDaily.com, 28 February 2002. Available from http:// www.crmdaily.com. Taeschler, Debra. ‘‘Best CRM Practices Require Cultivation of Touch Points.’’ Business Marketing, 1 December 1999. Urbanowjcz, Rob. ‘‘Pay Attention to All Customer Interactions.’’ Business Courier Serving Cincinnati, 9 February 2001.
❚ 18 DATA INTEGRITY
Data plays an integral role in the operations of any online business. As stated in a February 1999 issue of E-Commerce Times, ‘‘Everywhere you turn these days, it seems you’re dealing with a database. If you want to be state of the art, the inventory in your Web store should be in a database. The same is true of your customer list, and your prospect list. The reports delivered by Web server logs or held by your ad agency are databases. You target ads by matching these databases against other databases. Personalization engines are all about databases. Even e-mail lists are databases.’’ Because it is such an important part of operations, preserving the integrity (accuracy and completeness) of data is crucial for businesses. Data integrity can be undermined by system crashes, errors made by the individuals who input data, and computer viruses and/or hackers. To protect data from system crashes, you can back it up by using something like a Zip drive or CD burner; keeping your backed up data in a separate location helps to ensure that it remains intact in the event of a fire or other catastrophe. You can also use a remote Internet-based backup service like Connected.com or Xdrive. For a monthly fee of $17.95 per personal computer (PC), Connected.com offers to back up and store on the Internet the hard drive contents of five to ten PCs. Customers who lose or damage files, can simply log onto the firm’s Web site and retrieve the most recent backup. Xdrive’s Workgroup is a similar Internet-based backup service that charges a monthly fee of $99 for up to 25 users. To prevent data input errors, which can be as harmless as minor typos or as serious as incorrect pricing, you can limit the number of individuals able to make additions or changes to your databases. You can also use programs that recognize common input errors and alert users when a mistake is made. You can also limit the number of databases you operate, which helps to ensure that the information you present to customers is consistent. It was data consistency that Delta Airlines sought in 2001 when it spent nearly $1 billion to integrate and condense hundreds of disparate databases. This effort allowed the airline to provide up-todate and consistent information to all of its customers, whether they were visiting a Delta display in an airport, calling a reservation agent, or visiting Delta’s Web site. One of the most serious threats to data integrity is hacking, which typically involves compromising the security of networks or creating malicious programs such as viruses. The most popular forms of network
28 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
If you run an online business that is hosted by a third party, you should become familiar with how it will go about protecting the integrity of your data. Find out what sort of firewalls the company has in place to protect against hackers and how it handles viruses. The security measures that hosting companies take vary widely, and it is worth your while to be sure your host is working to preserve the integrity of your data.
The malicious activities of some hackers include the creation of viruses, logic bombs, and worms. A virus is a program that has the potential to attack and corrupt computer files by attaching itself to a file and replicating itself. It can also cause a computer to crash by utilizing all of the computer’s resources. In May 2000, e-mail systems throughout the world were inundated with the ‘‘ILOVEYOU’’ and ‘‘Love Bug’’ viruses; the damage to individuals, businesses, and institutions was estimated at roughly $10 billion. Similar to viruses, logic bombs are designed to attack when triggered by a certain event like a change in date. Worms attack networks in order to replicate and spread. In July 2001, the ‘‘Code Red’’ worm attacked Microsoft Internet Information Server systems, defacing Web sites with the phrase ‘‘Welcome to www.worm.com! Hacked by Chinese!’’
FURTHER READING
While it is virtually impossible to prevent all hacking activity, you can take a number of protective measures to help preserve your data’s integrity. One of the most common methods of protection against viruses is anti-virus software programs such as those manufactured by McAfee and Symantec. Anti-virus software scans a PC’s hard drive for infected material and alerts users when bad files are found. ‘‘While virus protection should be considered a vital part of a security plan, it is definitely not the only security a company needs to stay protected,’’ asserts a February 2002 article in Entrepreneur. Many business also use a firewall, which acts as a deterrent to hacking by protecting private networks from the public and preventing all but the most determined outsiders from tampering with computer systems. Other software options include Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS), content filtering software, and sandboxing software. Considered one of the best protection methods for large networks, an IDS allows system administrators to monitor network requests and detect suspicious large-scale activity. Content filtering software is advanced anti-virus software that reads compressed files and allows information technology managers to use filters to block suspicious e-mail. Sandboxing software protects against malicious codes by creating a protected space within a computer where a suspicious code can run before it reaches the main operating system.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
hacking are denial of service (DoS) attacks and mail bombs. DoS attacks are designed to swamp a computer network, causing it to crash. Mail bombs act in a similar fashion but attack a network’s mail servers. When eBay was attacked in February 2000, its Web server was bombarded with fake requests for Web pages, which overloaded the site and caused it to crash. Network hackers also try to break into secure areas to find sensitive data. Once a network is hacked, files can be removed, stolen, or erased.
Blankenhorn, Dana. ‘‘The Grand Unified Database Theory.’’ E-Commerce Times, 19 February 1999. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. Bruck, Michael. ‘‘Going Beyond Antivirus Software.’’ Entrepreneur.com, 4 February 2002. Available from http:// www.entrepreneur.com. Preston, Robert. ‘‘Don’t Overlook Data Integrity in E-Biz Planning.’’ InternetWeek, 25 June 2001. ‘‘Data Integrity.’’ Ecommerce Webopedia. Darien, CT: Internet.com, 2002. Available from http:// www.webopedia.com/TERM/d/data_integrity.html.
❚ 19 DATA MINING
Data mining is the method of using various statistical analysis tools to unmask obscured patterns in a specified chunk of data. Considered an advanced form of data analysis, data mining goes beyond more commonplace data analysis practices, such as spreadsheet analysis and SQL (structured query language) queries. Quite often data mining tools are used in conjunction with data warehouses, multi-dimensional data structures that help businesses both organize and analyze the data created during daily business operations.
DATA WAREHOUSING CONCEPTS Data warehousing involves two main types of data: operational and informational. Operational data consists of the data businesses use on a daily basis, like customer orders and completed sales transactions. This data is typically stored in a relational database and is retrieved and updated by an online transaction processing (OLTP) system. Once operational data has been manipulated and summarized, such as daily sales totals excluding voided or returned items, it is loaded into the data warehouse, another database with a different structure and purpose, and becomes informational data. More advanced systems integrate operational data from multiple sources in the organization. 29
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
The goal of transforming operational data into informational data, which in many cases involves data standardization, is to create data that can be efficiently and accurately analyzed. Once data is standardized, it can be subjected to online analytical processing (OLAP), which allows users to analyze large amounts of data related to sales, products, customer service, and other business operations. This is where data mining tools are used most frequently. For example, data mining might be used to help an online retailer pinpoint customer purchasing patterns, insights that might be useful when the retailer develops its next marketing campaign.
EMERGING DEMAND FOR DATA MANAGEMENT In the 1990s, business trends such as the rise of e-commerce boosted demand for data warehousing and data mining technology. A growing number of companies began to gather customer data on the Web and needed ways to distill it all down to usable insights. According to an August 2001 report in the Wall Street Journal, ‘‘data mining uses algorithms to sift through those monstrous databases and reveal customer usage patterns. Once marketers get their hands on this juicy info, they can learn a range of valuable lessons, including what works and what doesn’t for customers on Web sites. They can also forecast future customer moves.’’ To organize and make use of this information, however, can be both costly and time consuming, and throughout the late 1990s, many small and medium-sized businesses were simply unable to afford either the technology or the staff necessary to manage it. However, by 2000, more affordable options began to emerge. For example, data marts—smaller, more focused versions of data warehouses—were created using data warehousing principles but on a much smaller scale, sometimes with the help of prepackaged templates and tools. In comparison to data warehouses, which are measured in gigabytes and terabytes, data marts are much smaller and less intricate. Several data mining companies also began to offer specialized data mining services to small and midsized companies.
IMPLEMENTING DATA MINING When deciding how to best manage and mine your data, consider how involved you wish to be in the process. You can purchase the data mining software you need and handle everything in-house, perhaps hiring data specialists. You can also hand off all your data mining needs to a third party. In addition, you might choose to outsource only certain tasks to a
specialized vendor. If you lack technical expertise in this area and are not willing to hire a data specialist, most experts recommend outsourcing. Keep in mind that data mining and data warehousing are closely related to customer relationship management (CRM), and many vendors offer ‘‘business intelligence’’ suites that include comprehensive ebusiness, CRM, data warehousing, and data mining solutions. According to a reader survey published in DM Review, some of the most popular business intelligence vendors in 2000 were SAS, NCR Corp., Oracle Corp., Computer Associates, Cognos Corp., MicroStrategy Inc., Microsoft Corp., IBM, Informix Business Solutions, and Hyperion. Many of these firms offer highly complex data warehousing, data mining, and CRM programs that are better suited to large corporations than to smaller businesses. One option for smaller businesses with data mining needs is an application service provider (ASP). Many ASPs will store your data on their servers and write programs that help you analyze your data most effectively. ASPs offering basic data warehousing and mining services to existing small businesses and start-up ventures include Exenet, Interland, ManagedOps.com, and StorageNetworks. ASPs that specialize in data warehousing and mining for small and mid-sized online businesses include Accrue Hit List, NetGenesis, and digiMine. For $15,000 to $50,000 per month, digiMine will install software in your current database that collects and compresses data before transferring an encrypted file to its own data server. Once digiMine gleans what it determines worthwhile from your informational data, it stores the data in a warehouse and launches a series of algorithms that mine the data. This entire process takes place daily, and, upon completion, digiMine posts completed reports, including graphs and charts, on its Web site. You can retrieve your reports via a password. You should determine, in detail, what you hope to gain from data mining prior to spending money on software, new staff, or vendor services. If you are setting up your own data management and analysis system, be sure you can afford the technology itself, as well as the costs associated with operating and maintaining such a system. When researching various vendors, inquire about their current customers to see if your business is similar in size and scope. Narrow your focus to vendors who offer the products and services your business needs. To reduce your costs, you might consider purchasing a suite of applications that serves a variety of your needs, including data mining. Many firms offer e-commerce suites that include integrated data mining, data warehousing, and similar applications specifically designed for online businesses.
30 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘2000 DM Review 100 Numerical Ranking.’’ DM Review, November 2001. Available from http://www.dmreview.com/ awards/top100/2000/. Harris, Nicole. ‘‘DigiMine Digs Deep in Web Sites to Uncover Users’ Experiences.’’ Wall Street Journal, August 9, 2001. Joch, Alan. ‘‘Buying Biz Smarts—ASPs Chip in to Cut DataDicing Costs and Time.’’ eWeek, January 1, 2001. Morphy, Erica. ‘‘CRM for Small Biz: Don’t Think Big.’’ CRMDaily.com, October 15, 2001. Available from http:// www.crmdaily.com.
which provides information about the data warehouse itself, is used mainly by system administrators. It is the business data that users seek most often for tasks such as forecasting sales or predicting trends. To perform such analyses, the data warehouse program uses applications known as data mining tools to interpret data and find patterns within the information. For example, a retail company, either online or traditional, might use data warehousing and data mining technology to pinpoint customer purchasing patterns and to gather additional information about its buyers.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
FURTHER READING
ORIGINS OF DATA WAREHOUSING
Moye, Joe, and Dave Upton. ‘‘Data Warehousing 101.’’ Strategic Finance, February 2001. Rogers, Martha. ‘‘There’s No Place Like Home.’’ Inc.com, March 1, 2002. Available from http://www2.inc.com.
❚ 20 DATA WAREHOUSING
Data warehousing technology helps businesses organize and analyze the data created during daily business operations. Two types of database processing, online transaction processing (OLTP) and online analytical processing (OLAP), allow users to both store and retrieve data. Stored in a data warehouse, also known as a multi-dimensional data structure, this information can be queried and analyzed as needed.
The concept of data warehousing dates back to the early 1980s, when relational databases were popular. Relational database systems were run on minicomputers for OLTP. They were commonly used to operate networks such as automated teller machines. By the 1990s, changing business trends such as business process reengineering, an increasingly globalized economy, the growing popularity of enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems, and the rise of e-commerce all helped fuel demand for data warehousing technology. Run on powerful client/server networks, data networks that could translate OLAP, as well as read OLTP, emerged. According to a February 2001 issue of Strategic Finance, data warehousing is useful because it ‘‘helps with analytical tasks—from identifying new market trends to evaluating customer service performance. It provides immediate, accurate information that’s unique to your business and produces results you can act on quickly. It can also help plug leaks you may not know exist. Applying the right analytical tools may reveal patterns that add up to widespread yet traceable financial discrepancies.’’
TYPES OF DATA The two main types of data involved with data warehousing are operational and informational data. Operational data, which consists of the data businesses use on a daily basis, is normally stored in a relational database and retrieved and updated by an OLTP system. Once operational data has been manipulated and summarized, it is considered informational data; this is what makes up a data warehouse. In the process of data warehousing, informational data is created from operational data via transformation or propagation tools. This process is a standardization of sorts that helps ensure that information can be retrieved quickly and easily at a later date. Multi-dimensional analysis, or OLAP, is the desired result of data warehousing. It allows users to analyze large amounts of data related to sales, products, customer service, and other business operations. The informational data stored in a data warehouse is also known as metadata, which comprises both technical data and business data. Technical data,
IMPLEMENTATION CONSIDERATIONS Implementing a data warehouse structure within your company can be both costly and time consuming. Data warehousing firms targeting small companies have developed data marts, smaller versions of data warehouses that are streamlined to serve a specific department and/or cover a specific topic. In comparison to data warehouses, which are measured in gigabytes and terabytes, data marts are much smaller and, therefore, measured in megabytes. You may find that this data structure is more appropriate for your business, particularly if you are just launching operations. Whether you are building a data warehouse or data mart for a traditional bricks-and-mortar company, an online venture, or both, you must decide how involved you want to be in the process. You can outsource the entire project to a qualified vendor, handle the entire process in-house, or work in tandem with a vendor. If you opt to hand off all or part of the project to a 31
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
vendor, a choice most analysts recommend if you lack technical expertise in this area, you’ll be faced with a vast choice of business intelligence vendors offering packaged e-business, customer relationship management (CRM), and data warehousing solutions. According to DM Review, the top 10 business intelligence vendors in 2000 were SAS, NCR Corp., Oracle Corp., Computer Associates, Cognos Corp., MicroStrategy Inc., Microsoft Corp., IBM, Informix Business Solutions, and Hyperion. However, many of these firms offer highly complex data warehousing and CRM programs that are better suited to large corporations than to smaller businesses. According to Joe Outlaw, a Gartner Group analyst quoted in an October 2001 issue of CRMDaily.com, ‘‘Rich functionality is obviously a desirable quality if you are a large company, but for a small company the package then becomes too difficult to use, especially if they don’t have the support staff to maintain it.’’ Outlaw also cautioned smaller businesses to be sure they could handle the cost not only of the technology itself but also of operating and maintaining the system. In addition, when selecting a vendor, you should investigate its current clientele to see if your business is similar in size and focus. Concentrate on vendors that offer the specific functions your business needs rather than those that offer additional bells and whistles. Finally, to save money, consider purchasing a suite of applications that serves a variety of your needs rather than individual programs that must be integrated. Many vendors offer e-commerce suites that include data warehousing applications specifically designed for online businesses. If you have already warehoused some of your own information, you might consider using an application service provider (ASP) to store your data on its servers and to write programs that help you analyze your data effectively. ASPs offering basic data warehousing services to existing small businesses and start-up ventures include Exenet, HostPro, ManagedOps.com, and StorageNetworks. ASPs that specialize in data warehousing for small online businesses include Accrue Hit List, digiMine, and NetGenesis. These firms focus on ‘‘clickstream’’ analysis, which means that they help businesses use data to figure out things like who is visiting their Web sites and which pages visitors access most often.
FURTHER READING ‘‘2000 DM Review 100 Numerical Ranking.’’ DM Review, November 2001. Available from http://www.dmreview.com/ awards/top100/2000/. Carroll, Sean. ‘‘Data Management.’’ PC Magazine, 3 April 2001, 128.
Morphy, Erica. ‘‘CRM for Small Biz: Don’t Think Big.’’ CRMDaily.com, 15 October 2001. Available from http:// www.crmdaily.com. Moye, Joe, and Dave Upton. ‘‘Data Warehousing 101.’’ Strategic Finance, February 2001. Silvon Software Inc. ‘‘A Seven-Step Approach to a Successful Data Mart Implementation.’’ 2000. Available from http://www.dmreview.com/whitepaper/martc.pdf.
❚ 21 DATABASES
Nearly every business uses a database of some sort. Databases can be as simple as the electronic address books used to maintain lists of e-mail contacts or as complex as electronic library systems or online flight reservation systems. Typically, some sort of query system allows users to gain access to specific information in a database. For example, online flight reservation systems are often designed to accept queries based on a user’s departure destination, arrival destination, and dates of travel. The process of storing and manipulating the information housed in a database is known as database management. The tools used to manage databases are grouped together into database management systems (DBMSs). Several types of DBMSs exist, including those designed for personal computers (PCs) as well as those running on large mainframe systems. Some of the most common database applications include Microsoft Access, which is included in Microsoft Corp.’s popular Office suite of products for PCs, and IBM Corp.’s DB2. IBM Corp.’s Information Management System (IMS), released in 1966, was the first commercially viable database application. IMS was considered a hierarchical database, in which standardized data records were organized within other standardized data records, creating a hierarchy of information about a single entry. In the late 1960s, firms like Honeywell Corp. and General Electric Corp. developed database applications based on a network data model, but the next major database breakthrough came in 1970, when a research scientist at IBM first outlined his theory for relational databases. Six years later, IBM completed a prototype for a relational DBMS. In 1978, Oracle Systems Corp. beat IBM to the punch when it released the world’s first relational database management system (RDBMS) using Structured Query Language (SQL). Relational databases eventually outpaced all other database types, mainly because they allowed for highly complex queries and could support various
32 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
In the late 1990s, the use of databases became increasingly widespread as the Internet grew in popularity. According to a February 1999 issue of E-Commerce Times, ‘‘Everywhere you turn these days, it seems you’re dealing with a database. If you want to be state of the art, the inventory in your Web store should be in a database. The same is true of your customer list, and your prospect list. The reports delivered by Web server logs or held by your ad agency are databases. You target ads by matching these databases against other databases. Personalization engines are all about databases. Even e-mail lists are databases.’’ In fact, the growth of e-commerce continues to fuel the development of new database features designed to allow users to take advantage of various Internetbased opportunities. At the core of many new database developments was the adoption of XML (extensible markup language), the language used to create Web documents, by database application developers like Microsoft, IBM, and Oracle as well as their smaller rivals. When deciding which databases are best suited to your business, you’ll need to keep in mind that beyond simply housing your data, an application ideally will allow you to sift through the data in various ways. Using a variety of different database applications could pose future problems if you ever need to integrate the data; however, finding a database program that meets all of your database needs can prove tricky as well. Many companies allow potential customers to download free trial versions of their database software. While it may prove time consuming to test various applications, this is an inexpensive way to find a suitable database program. To help you organize and analyze the data created during daily business operations, you might decide to use some sort of data warehousing system, although an application this sophisticated might prove unnecessary at first. You can also opt to use a data mart, which is essentially a smaller version of a data warehouse that is streamlined to serve a specific department and/or cover a specific topic. Another option is an application service provider (ASP)—such as Exenet, HostPro, and ManagedOps.com—which will store your data on its servers and write programs that help you analyze your data effectively. For example, an ASP can help you write queries to generate the information you need to analyze sales by region or by product. While gaining control of your internal data is an important part of managing your business, according to an April 2001 article in PC Magazine, it may only play a small role
in how you use databases. ‘‘For many companies, internal databases are only half the story—if that. Also essential is so-called clickstream analysis of their Web site. This involves tracking the behavior of visitors to a Web site, examining what they do there, recording where they’re geographically located, keeping track of who referred them to the Web site, and noting which pages resulted in the greatest number of further requests.’’ ASPs specializing in this type of database management include Accrue Hit List, digiMine, and NetGenesis. In the early 2000s, many leading database firms, like Microsoft, also began targeting small and mid-sized business markets. As database programs become increasingly comprehensive, database options for small business, both traditional and online, will continue to increase.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
tools that enhanced their usefulness. Database applications for PCs emerged in the early 1990s. In 1993 Microsoft Corp. created Access, which competed with FileMaker Inc.’s FileMaker Pro, a database application initially designed for Macintosh machines.
FURTHER READING Blankenhorn, Dana. ‘‘The Grand Unified Database Theory.’’ E-Commerce Times, 19 February 1999. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. Carroll, Sean. ‘‘Data Management.’’ PC Magazine, 3 April 2001, 128. Gill, Lisa. ‘‘Battle of the Databases.’’ NewsFactor Network, 7 May 2002. Available from http://www.newsfactor.com.
❚ 22 DAY TRADING
Day trading, when an individual buys and sells stocks in rapid succession in hopes of profiting from short-term price movements, stems from a convergence of factors in the 1990s and early 2000s. Among the factors:
T the rise of personal computers T the development of the Internet T the availability of real-time high level market information T the ability to buy and sell stocks online almost instantly T the rise of the dot-com economy and the plethora of volatile stocks it spawned
Day trading got its name because most day traders don’t hold a share position overnight; instead, they sell all their shares by the end of each day. This means day traders aren’t investors in any traditional sense. They care not for a firm’s long-term prospects or 33
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
management practices; they have no interest in putting together stock portfolios for the long run. Day traders are speculators who attempt to anticipate micro-movements in a stock’s price—often fluctuations of mere fractions of a point—then buying and selling large lots of that stock in a short period—often within minutes—to take advantage of those fluctuations. It is the direct access to up-to-the-minute market data along with the ability to execute trades within seconds that makes day trading possible as a lucrative, if high-risk, undertaking.
ORIGINS OF DAY TRADING Day trading had its origins in the U.S. stock market crash of 1987. Because many investors were unable to get through to their brokers on the phone to sell stock in the panicked trading that ensued, Nasdaq introduced the Small Order Execution System (SOES), a system designed to execute trades of up to 1,000 shares at the best available price within seconds. SOES was so efficient that it operated faster than Nasdaq’s main computer system, SelectNet, used by Nasdaq market makers. New prices appeared on SOES before they were registered on SelectNet. By monitoring both systems, early day traders—nicknamed SOES bandits—were able to pick off good prices on SelectNet before market makers could adjust their prices to SOES levels. The rise of ECNs—electronic communications networks which rapidly disseminated information and made possible quick trades—in the 1990s gave day traders another weapon. By 1997, SOES accounted for 17 percent of Nasdaq’s daily volume. In response to SOES bandits and the volatility they were said to be creating, Nasdaq replaced SelectNet with a new system, called SuperSOES which made current Nasdaq share information available to the entire market. With the introduction of SuperSOES, many veteran day traders left the business.
selling them at the higher price, then buying it later at the lower one. There is a great deal of risk involved in all these transactions. If a share’s price doesn’t move in the expected direction, the trader takes a loss—potentially thousands of dollars or more. In addition, most day traders must pay commissions on every transaction they make, which can cut deeply into profits and add to losses.
TRENDS IN DAY TRADING Historically, day traders have done most of their trading in Nasdaq’s high-tech and Internet shares— stocks that tend to experience large fluctuations in price every day. Day trading fever was fed by the bull market and Internet stock craze of the 1990s. When the dot-com industry collapsed in late 2000, many day traders, particularly non-professionals, left the field. By the end of the 1990s, at any rate, many day trading firms were moving away from retail clients, that is, individual traders, toward larger institutional clients, like mutual funds. By 2002 a significant consolidation was underway in the day trading industry, with many firms being purchased by larger traditional brokerage houses. By 2002 the typical day trader was not the getrich-quick dilettante portrayed by the popular press, but either a veteran of the exchange floor, a Ivy League business grad, or a business professional from another field. There was little agreement on how many day traders were active in the early 2000s. In July 2001 Forbes magazine estimated the number at about 75,000; by contrast the U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO), using figures from industry sources and regulatory bodies, put the number at about 5,000. However small day traders’ numbers, the GAO stressed the exaggerated influence day traders have on the Nasdaq market: while making up only one-tenth of one percent of all securities traders, day traders accounted nonetheless for about 15 percent of all Nasdaq trades in 2001.
HOW IT WORKS Day trading is performed through day-trading firms which maintain order-routing and execution systems. These firms have connections to the Nasdaq Level II screens, which display real-time market data like best bid and ask quotes and volume traded. The firms hire their own staffs of traders as well as allowing individual traders to use their facilities for a fee and commissions. Trading takes place either at the firm’s offices or from a day trader’s home via the Internet. Day traders buy in anticipation of small changes in price, sell after the change, and pocket the difference. It makes no difference whether a stock is going up or down. If a price is expected to drop, day traders sell short, borrowing shares they do not yet own,
REGULATION With its lure of quick profits and its existence on the margins of the securities industry, day trading inevitably became a target of government and regulatory bodies, including the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Some traders successfully manipulated share prices by planting false information on the bulletin boards and newsgroups frequented by day traders. The customer acquisition practices of day trading firms was another subject of SEC attention. Regulators maintained firms were violating suitability rules by taking clients who did not have the capital wherewithal needed for day trading. Some traders charged that firms encouraged customers to borrow
34 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Despite the promise of instant wealth held out by day trading, few traders actually become rich. The worst case was undoubtedly that of the unsuccessful, heavily indebted day trader who murdered a number of workers in his day trading firm along with his family and himself in 1999. His case was not entirely exceptional however. According to the Electronic Traders Association, 90 percent of all day traders lose money.
FURTHER READING Anuff, Joey, and Gary Wolf. Dumb Money: Adventures of a Day Trader. New York: Random House, 2000.
is to develop a competitive advantage that will differentiate your business, and allow you to capture your fair share of the market without spending money and resources on head-to-head competition with your competitors. Note, however, that this doesn’t necessarily mean ‘‘sustainable’’ competitive advantage. In the connected economy, it is very challenging to sustain a competitive advantage, simply because the ability of your competitors to copy your business model is relatively easy. Moreover, it is very difficult and expensive (and sometimes ineffective) to protect a business model, even if you have a patent for it.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
beyond their means to continue trading. In mid-2001 the SEC brought actions against a number of firms for infractions including margin lending, advertising, and short-sale rule violations. The SEC has no rules specifying how quickly orders should be placed; however, the most common complaint received by the commission in 2000 concerned order delays or technical systems failure that lost or delayed orders.
Therefore, your should strive to develop an advantage via differentiation, and establish your business as the leader in its particular category in the mind of the customer, rather than build ‘‘imaginary walls’’ around your business that can never truly be protected. Striving for differentiation in your business model and practices, then, is a never-ending task in the competitive and fast-paced e-commerce marketplace.
Bentley, Kassandra. Getting Started in Online Day Trading. New York: Wiley, 2000.
WHAT IS DIFFERENTIATION?
Emshwiller, John R. Scam Dogs and Mo-Mo Mamas: Inside the Wild and Woolly World of Internet Stock Trading. New York: HarperBusiness, 2000. Larson, Mark L. Trade Stocks Online. New York: Wiley, 2000. ‘‘Making A Killing: The Murder of 12 People Last Week in Atlanta.’’ Business and Finance, August 5, 1999. Newman, John. ‘‘Survey: Day Trading—So You Want to Be a Day Trader?’’ Investors Chronicle, May 11, 2001, 81-83. Smith, Geoffrey. ‘‘Day of Reckoning for Day-Trading Firms?’’ Business Week, January 18, 1999, 88. Turnick, Britt. ‘‘E-Brokerages in Danger?’’ Investment Dealer’s Digest, April 1, 2002. U.S. Congress. General Accounting Office. ‘‘Securities Operations—Update on Actions Taken to Address Day Trading Concerns.’’ Washington, November 27, 2001. Weinberg, Neil. ‘‘What Bear Market?’’ Forbes, July 9, 2001.
❚ 23 DIFFERENTIATION TECHNIQUES IN E-COMMERCE
Basically, there are only two ways to compete in the marketplace. One is to do the same thing and in the same way that the competition does, and the other
As a rule, head-to-head competition is an extremely difficult way for a new firm to stake out a share of the market. Business history has shown us that even corporate giants have failed when they attempted to overcome their competition by fighting head-to head with them. The main reason for this outcome is that competition does not occur in the marketplace—it occurs in the mind of the customer. Human beings have a limited capacity to remember all details. Therefore, our minds tend to prioritize, recalling only the top-rated items. When it comes to brands and products or services, most people can not recall anyone beyond the third place. Therefore, it is extremely difficult to uproot an existing position from the customer’s mind. The lesson here is that you want to differentiate yourself from the pack, and develop an advantage that hopefully you can maintain for a long time. Differentiation of a product or business is thus essential for success in e-commerce. It involves reaching out to customers while highlighting the key and advantageous differences between your firm and others in your market. This could inlcude anything from simple product differentiation, unique customerservice strategies, and even wildly innovative marketing schemes. In a free market society, it is expected that most beneficial products and services will have competition in the marketplace, and thus, one needs to find a way to effectively compete in order to maintain a viable business. 35
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
DIFFERENTIATION—NOW AND THEN
PRIORITIZING THE COMPETITION
The short answer is yes. The differentiation tactics of the pre-connected economy are very different than the differentiation tactics of today. Any business that is utilizing e-commerce in one way or another must plan on and develop differentiation based on the unique properties of the connected economy.
Start by making a list of your competitors. Again, do not just look at competitors that are doing the same as you do, but any entity that has an effect on your market target. Next, prioritize the list in terms of the influence that each of these competitors has on your market target. Number them in order of influence; one being the most influential competitor.
In the pre-connected economy, competitive advantage was largely based on the ‘‘four P’s’’ of traditional marketing: price, place, packaging, and promotion. Although these marketing elements are important, they are now taking second seat to the unique properties of the connected economy: connectivity, interactivity, and speed.
STARTING TO DIFFERENTIATE YOUR EBUSINESS Start by analyzing your landscape. Landscape is an overview of the elements in the marketplace that can directly effect your business, and a decision on how you can avoid or better yet leverage these elements to your advantage. No enterprise operates in a vacuum, and you will encounter competitive forces in the marketplace. Even if your business model is unique, and even if no one else does what you plan to do, you still have competition. For example, Amazon.com was the first to sell books online, but its competitors were brick-and-mortar bookstores. There are three main elements in your landscape that you want to review and analyze when defining the last component of your vision block:
T Competition
ANALYZING THE COMPETITION Once you have identified and prioritized your competitors, it is time to analyze them so that you can define your competitive advantage relative to your competitive set. A competitive set is a collection of your top competitors that have the greatest influence on your target market. The main purpose of this analysis is to identify and pinpoint the elements that you can leverage in order to differentiate your operation from the operation of your competitive set. This process includes three stages:
T List your competitive set in order of influence on your market. T Define the main categories—such as advertising savvy, customer service, branding, and so on— that are the most important to your operation. T Score each of your competitors and yourself, and sum up the result.
An analysis of the top competitors indicates that there are differences in the strengths and weaknesses of each one of them, and that your e-business model can gain a competitive advantage by focusing on the areas in which your competitors are relatively weak.
T Analysis T Advantage
DEVELOPING A COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE Competition exists everywhere and all the time. There are only two ways to overcome competitive forces; one is to fight them head on, and the other is to go around them via differentiation.
In order to build a competitive advantage in your market via differentiation, you need to secure your fair share of the market without spending money and resources on head-to-head competition with your competitors.
Going around your competitors simply means developing a competitive advantage that makes your approach so unique that customers see you as the leader in a newly created category or sub-category. Amazon.com, for example, could not compete head on with the existing bookstores in the brick-and-mortar category, so they created another category: cyber bookstores.
Based on the analysis of your competitive set, you can begin to discern opportunities for building a competitive advantage by developing and offering your customers a business model that is interactive as well as simple to use. Of course, you need to maintain a satisfactory level of connectivity and speed, but your focus of competitive advantage will be in the areas of interactivity and speed.
COMPETITION.
36 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
TROUBLESHOOTING YOUR DIFFERENTIATION PLANS To validate your comparative advantage, you need to ask the following question: Are the differentiation factors (interactivity and speed) that I am targeting relative to the competition offering enough added value to entice customers to use my business rather than to others. If your answer is yes, you have successfully developed a differentiation plan for your e-business. If you are unable to clearly define those factors that add value for your customers relative to the competition, you should review the process again and refine your approach.
foreign or corporate spy, or an outright thief. Disgruntled former employees with network information may also hack into an employer’s system for fun, revenge, profit, or political attention. The problem is exacerbated as publications and conferences within the hacker community spread information on security topics by identifying systems at risk, publishing passwords, and sharing hacking and exploitation software. To combat these virtual bandits and vandals, online shopkeepers can use digital authentication systems of passwords, encryption, and secret computer keys to authenticate the identity of their sites’ users, ensuring that payment information is valid and customer information is kept secret. They may also use authentication to restrict access to authorized users, like online magazine subscribers. For their part, customers use digital authentication to protect their credit-card and online-banking information.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
You will take maximum advantage of this competitive advantage by highlighting it in your branding, marketing, sales, and promotional programs. The value added to your customers will be the ability to interact with them and your trading partnets in the simplest, most cost-effective, and most user-friendly way possible.
WAYS TO AUTHENTICATE Authentication technology falls into three categories:
T what the user knows (a password) T what the user has (a token or card) T what identifies the user physically (i.e. a fingerprint)
FURTHER READING ‘‘Business: In the Name of Experience.’’ The Economist, November 25, 2000, 73. Malburg, Chris. ‘‘Differentiation Pays Off.’’ Industry Week, July 17, 2000, 21. WizBizWeb, LLC, ‘‘The ABC of E-strategy,’’ 2002. Available by request from http://www.wizbizweb.com.
PASSWORDS. The first method, what the user knows, or basic authentication, works via online user names and passwords. However, these elements are relatively easy to obtain and abuse by creative password thieves. Favored methods of stealing data include watching users log in, posing as a phony help desk technician, applying some one million passwords to a user name through special applications, guessing passwords, or catching a user unwittingly divulging information.
❚ 24 DIGITAL AUTHENTICATION
In 2002, a market research survey reported that credit-card payment fraud cost online merchants a minimum of $1 billion a year. One example cited a major credit-card company processing more than $900 billion in losses annually. Given this climate, digital authentication, technology for online identity confirmation, has become essential to protect both merchants and Internet users alike. Information theft presents the most obvious challenge to e-commerce security. Through unauthorized access, however, hackers can wreak havoc in many other ways, altering content during transmission, eavesdropping on confidential information, luring consumers through phony sites, or maliciously shutting down a web page. The online intruder may be a curious adolescent, a software inventor challenging company security, a
Online merchants have some defenses. Password security can be improved through mixed alphanumeric passwords, longer password lengths, mixed-language passwords, and case-sensitive passwords. Site users should be warned not to incorporate easily guessed personal information like birth dates or pets’ names into their passwords, and to use different passwords for other Web sites. In addition, password management strategies can include password content requirements, encrypted storage, limitations on the number of unsuccessful sign-on attempts, number of passwords per user, number of password changes, and management of lost passwords. By 2002, most online purchases and financial transactions were secured by the Secure Socket Layer (SSL), which displays a padlock icon in the browser 37
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
when enabled. Embedded in many web browsers, SSL creates a secure ‘‘tunnel’’ between a user and server by encrypting data, allowing for server or client authentication, and ensuring the integrity of messages. However, SSL only provides security during transmission from browser to server; collected credit card numbers and personal information are known to have been stolen from servers’ data storage. ENCRYPTION
KEYS,
TOKENS,
AND
CERTIFI-
The second authentication technology, proof of identity by what the user has, features unique identifiers to authenticate their holder. These include encryption keys, smart cards, digital certificates, and tokens. Many incorporate a cryptographic process whereby information is transformed to gibberish by a mathematical formula, or encryption key, before it is passed to another party.
CATES.
The length of encryption keys determine their relative security, while the complexity of algorithms used in their creation ups the ante even more. Using advanced guessing techniques and tools, a 40-bit key is fairly easy to crack, while the 128-bit keys used by many online banks were considered secure as of 2002. A different formula may be used for both encryption and decryption, depending on the level of trust between parties. When different formulas are used, they are called asymmetric, trap door, or one-way encryptions, and require a private key to decode. In this case, two different keys are created: a public key, made available on a key server, and a private key, which is known only to the owner. Digital certificates, also called digital IDs, associate a specific person to this pair of keys and prevent their misuse by phony users. They are issued by a third-party certification authority (CA), using the CA’s private key. Private keys are also used to verify a digital signature, which is considered legally binding by the federal government. The private key confirms that the message was sent by its signer and remained unaltered in transit. This is done by reducing the message to a short mathematical function, or ‘‘message digest hash,’’ that is further encrypted with the private key. Once sent, a message is decrypted by its recipient using the public key. If the technology works as intended, when someone uses a your public key to encrypt a message to you, they will know that only you, the private key’s owner, will be able to decrypt and read it. Another unique identifier, physical tokens, authenticate users through a two-factor process. The subject must enter into the computer the numeric data displayed on the token—data which changes every minute or so—along with a password. Once the security server determines what the data should be and matches the password, access is granted. This system provides an extra level of protection over simple password
security. Otherwise cumbersome token technology is being integrated into electronic devices the user already carries, like hand-held computers. Plastic smart cards incorporate similar technology, embedded in a computer chip storing data and read by computing systems. The third authentication technology, identifying something about the user, relies on biometric technology to authenticate individuals using unique identifying features from the iris, retina, palm print, voice, face scan, or chromosomes. Although biometrics is a relatively new addition to mainstream digital authentication products, major PC and peripheral manufacturers have begun integrating fingerprintscanning technology into their equipment.
BIOMETRICS.
FURTHER READING Carr, Jim. ‘‘Biometric Devices: The Next Wave.’’ Network Magazine, October 10, 2001. Available from http:// www.networkmagazine.com/article/NMG20011003S0009. Fu, Kevin, et al. ‘‘Dos and Don’ts of Client Authentication on the Web.’’ In Proceedings of the 10th USENIX Security Symposium. Washington, August 2001. Lemos, Rob. ‘‘Passwords: The Weakest Link?’’ CNET.com. May 22, 2002. Available from http://news.com.com/20091001-916719.html. Rappa, Michael. ‘‘Managing the Digital Enterprise: Security and Encryption.’’ Raleigh, NC: North Carolina State University, 1999. Available from http://digitalenterprise.org/ security/security.html. Richtel, Matt. ‘‘Credit Card Theft Thrives Online as Global Market.’’ New York Times, May 13, 2002. Rodgers, Anni Layne. ‘‘Hacking 101.’’ Fast Company, March 2002. Available from http://www.fastcompany.com/ feature/02/hackers.html. Schwartz, John. ‘‘Last Boom in Town: Demand Still Grows for Online Security.’’ New York Times, April 18, 2001. Webb, Cynthia L. ‘‘Digital Signature Technology Wins Agency’s Seal of Approval.’’ Washington Post, March 1, 2002.
❚ 25 DISASTER PLANNING
Disaster planning is the process of creating contingency plans for operating or recovering a business in the event of a major disruption. Most businesses, even virtual ones, need to consider how they will survive
38 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
In the wake of the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, businesses of all kinds began to revisit their disaster plans, and many of those operating without disaster plans began to create them for the first time. The attacks underscored the vulnerability of businesses operating without an adequate disaster plan that addresses questions such as these: Who is in change when disaster strikes? What is the chain of command to follow if various individuals are unavailable? What forms of backup communications are available to maintain contact? What backup locations are available to conduct business if facilities are such down or evacuated? Although small businesses are the ones most likely to operate without a disaster plan, they are often most vulnerable to disaster because they tend to operate from a single location and lack the variety of assets typically maintained by larger enterprises.
REDUNDANCY Many large companies can afford to add redundancy to their operations, which can lessen the impact of many kinds of disaster. For example, to maintain communications during storms and other natural disasters, some firms purchase accounts with more than one phone service provider. As long as the providers aren’t sharing lines or infrastructure, there is a good chance that an interruption in the services of one provider won’t happen at the same time as a service breakdown with the second provider. Many companies provide cell phones and wireless pagers to their employees, both of which offer alternative means of communications. Similarly, many businesses operate multiple offices, which means if disaster strikes in one area, other facilities are available from which business can be conducted. If you operate a small business that can’t afford multiple offices and communications systems, you can still achieve this kind of redundancy, although you may need to be a bit more creative. One option is finding another company with which to create a reciprocity agreement. This type of contract allows a small business to agree to share specified facilities with another business in the event of a disaster. For example, if a tornado levels your main manufacturing plant, a reciprocity agreement with a similar business 50 miles away might allow you to maintain manufacturing operations with minimal interruption while your facilities are being restored. Having this sort of agreement in place prior to a disaster could mean the difference between staying afloat and going bankrupt.
OTHER STRATEGIES For e-commerce firms, in particular, disaster plans must also include detailed strategies for dealing with data losses. Keep in mind that along with backing up your data by using something like a Zip drive or CD burner, it is a good idea to keep your backed up data in a separate location. This can be as simple a task as taking backup tapes home with you every evening. This way, if something should happen to your main office, your backups will remain safe. Many e-commerce companies opt for backing up their systems to remote computers over the Internet or over a private network. This can be affordable as well as highly reliable, and usually can be automated to occur according to a schedule. Firms like Connected.com and Xdrive offer another option: remote Internet-based backup services. For example, Connected.com offers to back up and store the hard drive contents of PCs for a flat monthly fee. These inexpensive services allow small businesses without many internal technical resources to create effective data redundancy in case of an accident. When preparing a disaster plan for an e-commerce venture, you will also need to specify how you plan to deal with server crashes, viruses, and online security breaches. If you are paying an outside company to host your site, find out exactly how the hosting firm deals with such problems. If you subscribe to a shared hosting service, find out how many companies are sharing your server and if the firm will automatically route your traffic to a backup server, located elsewhere, if your server does crash. Ask hosting companies to explain how they go about testing their Web sites and how often they do this. What sort of firewalls do they have in place to protect against hackers. How do they handle viruses? Like other businesses, your hosting company should have a disaster plan of its own to deal with problems like these. If you are using your own servers to operate your Web site, you should be able to answer these questions yourself. When you actually sit down to create your plan, keep in mind that the process can take several months. It can also prove difficult. It requires you to imagine the most likely and most damaging scenarios that could face your business—and the two may not be the same. Some of the most damaging events are impossible to foresee in their specifics. An effective plan will take into account physical assets such as buildings and equipment; data assets like software systems, databases, and other electronic files, as well as the human assets of the company’s staff and management.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
a disaster, whether it’s an earthquake, flood, burglary, fire, death, or some other interruption.
FURTHER READING Campanelli, Melissa. ‘‘Crash and Burn.’’ Entrepreneur, April 2000. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com.
39 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
Cook, Julia. ‘‘Expect the Unexpected.’’ Business Start-Ups, January 1997. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com. Chadderdon, Lisa. ‘‘8 Steps to Help You Develop a Disaster Plan.’’ Inc.com, November 6, 2001. Available from http:// www2.inc.com. McGarvey, Robert. ‘‘Guard Your Hard Drive.’’ HomeOfficeMag.com, March 2001. Available from http:// www.entrepreneur.com. ———. ‘‘Playing It Safe.’’ HomeOfficeMag.com, March 2000. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com. Page, Heather. ‘‘What You Can Do to Ensure Your Business Comes Out of a Data Disaster Alive.’’ Entrepreneur, September 1998. Available from http:// www.entrepreneur.com.
❚ 26 E-BRANDING STRATEGIES
Establishing a brand presence for your company is one of the more crucial steps for building an Internet business that can maintain itself through successive economic cycles and the ups and downs of consumer and investor confidence. Your brand is, in many ways, your company’s calling card, and the ability to build a lasting brand on the Internet can give you a tremendous advantage in drawing consumers and businesses to your site. If successful, branding can boost your company’s market valuation via increased investor confidence and the value of your intangible assets, aid your company in weathering downturns in market conditions or other business crises, and, finally, strengthen your profit margins. Your company’s brand identity is one of its most important intangible assets in an economic climate in which intangible assets are growing increasingly valuable and mission-critical. Companies, particularly in the still emerging and fickle e-commerce industry, ignore the power of their brands at their peril.
HOW BRANDING WORKS E-branding refers to the practice of capitalizing on brand recognition in the online world, and thus applies equally to click-and-mortar firms and to dot-com pureplays. The key is creating and promoting a viable and memorable brand presence in the online world, and using that brand recognition to achieve the maximum return on investments and optimal output from sales and marketing channels. In other words, branding is using your brand efficiently so as to create brand equity, or additional value customers perceive strictly because of the brand name. Branding, moreover, is a
crucial step toward shaping the perception of your company among customers, other businesses, investors, and even employees within your organization. A brick-and-mortar firm attempting to build its online presence, for example, could begin advertising its Web site along with its established logos on their storefront, in their print advertisements, in their directmailing campaigns, and so on. Affixing the address of the company’s Web site to a recognizable logo or other company marker is among the most common methods of e-branding. In this way, companies can not only use the Internet to attract new business, but also to give positive reinforcement to existing customers, thereby improving customer loyalty and reducing turnover. This carries the added benefit of keeping costs down, since in general it costs less to maintain an existing customer relationship than to develop a new one. And, as many analysts point out, Internet branding can be even more important than branding in the real world, since, in the real world, customers can simply run across physical advertisements, and needn’t even know the company name’s correct spelling in order to shop there. On the Internet, such a customer would have a much harder time finding the company in the absence of a strong and effective e-branding strategy. Ideally, your firm should strive to create a harmonious and symbiotic relationship between all its branding channels, including print, radio, television, billboards and other physical advertisements, and, of course, the Internet. The idea is to make discovering your company, shopping at its physical and online storefronts, and deriving information from and about the firm as easy and as useful as possible, while keeping costs low and maximizing the return on your investment.
BEYOND SIMPLE NAME RECOGNITION The other component of the e-branding strategy, beyond simple improving recognition and drawing customers to your storefront, is to simplify the customer’s online experience at your site and make it optimally useful to his or her tastes and desires. This can be accomplished in a number of ways. For instance, a few simple questions and a short registration form can create a customer profile, which you can then use in conjunction with databases and specialized software to personalize the customer’s visit to your site by alerting him or her to upcoming sales, matching advertising to the customer’s tastes, and other means. Based on a customer’s previous purchases or expressed interests on your site, for example, you can use your databases to send out e-mails tailored to his or her particular tastes.
40 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Your branding strategy should influence customer preference, ease the customer’s experience in dealing with your firm, and distinguish your company from your competition. In a sense, then, e-branding is not about branding the product you’re selling; rather, it’s about branding the user’s Internet experience at your site, making that experience an easy, enjoyable, useful, and identifiable endeavor.
IMPLEMENTING YOUR E-BRANDING STRATEGY In creating your e-branding strategy, you have a number of options, and the correct choices will be specific to your market, capabilities, and goals. For example, do you want to leverage an existing brand or create a completely new brand for the online environment? What kind of product or service is your ebrand trying to communicate, and how will your brand reflect that? E-branding is accomplished primarily in the synergy between a well-designed Web site and a comprehensive e-marketing scheme, which could include everything from banner advertisements and affiliate relationships to direct e-mail marketing. In addition, e-branding has grown into an industry in its own right. As a result, your options have expanded: instead of devising and implementing your own e-branding strategy, you can also choose to outsource the entire range of operations to one of the many firms specializing in e-branding services. FURTHER READING Chiagouris, Larry, and Brant Wansley. ‘‘Branding on the Internet.’’ Marketing Management, summer 2000, 34. Markowitz, Elliot. ‘‘Got Branding?’’ Computer Reseller News, August 7, 2000, 20.
a variety of business models available to e-commerce entrepreneurs (a few of which are described below). Some are indigenous to the Internet economy, and some are traditional business models adapted to the specific demands of e-commerce. In some ways, your business model will be dictated by the kinds of products and services you offer, but the unique environment of the Internet economy offers a great deal of flexibility and room for innovation, and you should work with and build the exact business model that suits your firm.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
Successful branding usually conveys, in a very short space, something unique and personal about your company, something that a customer will remember and find appealing enough to visit your Web site. Ideally, this means that when a customer visits your Web site, it appears that the logo and interface seem to be addressing them personally. Thus, successful branding means, above all, truly knowing your market and your customers.
BEFORE YOU BEGIN When developing a business model for the new economy, it is helpful to imagine a one-dimensional continuum. On one side of the continuum is the old economy business (brick and mortar), while at the other extreme is the dot.com pure play—an exclusively online business. In the space between the two business models lays the hybrid business, which was the most common in the early 2000s. There are numerous business models along the continuum, and their placement on the continuum depends on their degree of connectivity, interactivity, and speed. In other words, the higher the degree of interactivity, connectivity, and speed that the business is implementing in their operations, the closer it gets to the purely cyber side of the spectrum.
WHAT IS THE RIGHT MODEL FOR YOUR BUSINESS? To answer this question, you must first define two things:
T What is the current status of your business? Are you an established brick and mortar business that wants to develop an online channel? Or are you a startup trying to sketch out a business model from scratch? T Which combination of connectivity, interactivity, and speed is optimal for your product or service and for your customers?
TAKING AN EXISTING BUSINESS INTO THE INTERNET MARKET. ❚ 27 E-COMMERCE BUSINESS MODELS
Business models are the basic blueprints from which you build your business, defining at the outset what kind of business you will be running. There were
If you have an established business, let’s say a store that sells office supplies, your best bet is to start by establishing an online sales channel that will help you feature your products on your Web site. You can start, for example, by implementing an 80/20 ratio of brick-and-mortar and online operations, meaning that 41
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
you will have a simple Web site that will offer a description of your products, and the ability to view them online, but with limited interactivity. Then, continue to develop and upgrade your site to allow your customers to order online as well. Depending on your location, customer base, and competitive advantage, you might be able to conduct the majority of your business online at some point down the road. Another important element in your decision on your business model should include an accurate assessment of your customers’ needs. Before you develop any e-commerce application, do some research into the needs and wants of your customers. You might develop a questionnaire asking your customers what features and services that they would like available to them at your online storefront. Only then should you start the process of determining the best avenue for your expanding into electronic commerce.
CHOOSING THE IDEAL BUSINESS MODEL FOR A START UP Again, the answer to this questions depends on the type of product or service you offer, as well as on your potential customers. Generally speaking, it is faster and cheaper to start a small dot.com pure play than a brick-and-mortar business. But these lower barriers to market entry also mean you will likely be one of hundreds or even thousands of similar businesses. The biggest advantage of a combination of brickand-mortar and online business—often called the ‘‘brick-and-click’’ model—is that your brick-andmortar supplies you with the necessary cash flow while you are building and establishing your e-business. Remember that it can take two to three years (if you do everything right) for your online business to generate operating profit. Until then, you need the necessary capital to keep the business going. AFFILIATE MODEL. The affiliate (or click-through) model is characterized by a relationship in which your company agrees to pay an affiliate company in exchange for advertising space and a link to your site. Your firm pays the affiliate a small commission for each sale that can be traced back to a customer ‘‘clicking through’’ from an affiliate to the your Web site. The deal provides cash flow to affiliates and a steady stream of traffic to the your site, cutting customeracquisition costs and allowing your firm to target its desired audience.
You may opt to run your affiliate network in-house or farm it out to third-party service that will manae the network, issue regular checks to affiliates, and address technical problems. The sales commission paid to affiliates generally falls between five and seven percent, according to Forbes although, depending on the type of arrangement, the size of the firms, and the
click-through rates, commissions often reach as high as 15 percent. The most common format for routing visitors to a merchant was the ubiquitous banner advertisement, the electronic ‘‘billboards’’ sprawled across Web pages. These provide your firm with virtual storefronts all over the Web, rather than only on your own site. MERCHANT MODEL. The merchant model of e-commerce involves the establishment of an electronic storefront on your Web site; an information-technology infrastructure capable of receiving and processing orders; appropriate security measures to assure the safety, secrecy, and authenticity of transaction information; and means for procuring payments—either online or in the physical world—and completing orders via shipping and delivery. Under this broad outline, however, the specific definition of a merchant model depends on your particular market conditions, financial ability, and technological capabilities. COMMUNITY MODEL. The community model is a way to develop an online presence in which you essentially provide the space for interested individuals or busineses to congregate onlne and share information, concerns, and build commercial relationships. Web communities allow companies to use the Web to open up new channels for customer support and outreach, advertising, sales, ordering, distribution, and communication. Web communities were increasingly a key element of business plans, facilitating one-to-one, oneto-many, many-to-one, and many-to-many lines of communication and cooperation with such electronic tools as forums, chat rooms, email lists, message boards, and other interactive Internet mechanisms, usually tailored to the particular community.
The brokerage model refer to a variety of configurations in which your firm brings sellers and buyers together to engage in transactions, charging a small fee to at least one of those parties. Examples of the brokerage model include everything from Web sites posting simple online classified ads and Internet shopping malls (central sites selling items produced by many different companies) to businessto-business exchanges, online auction sites, and shopping bots.
BROKERAGE MODEL.
MANUFACTURER MODEL. If you’re in the business of building your own products, the manufacturer model of e-commerce takes maximum advantage of the benefits of e-commerce and modern information technology, allowing your firm to build products and deliver them to customers directly via direct Internet communication. In this case, you reduce or eliminate the expense of relying on wholesalers and distributors to get your products to your customers, rusulting in higher profit margins and lower costs for your customers.
42 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
Brenner, Ev. ‘‘Virtual Communities in the Business World.’’ Information Today, December 2000, 1. The Cap Gemini Ernst & Young Center for Business Innovation, ‘‘Implications of Networked Business Models for Incumbent Firms,’’ 2000. Available at http:// www.cbi.cgey.com/cgi-bin/pubs.plx?sort=topic. Radcliff, Deborah. ‘‘E-merchant Beware.’’ Computerworld, June 18, 2001. Rayport, Jeffrey F. ‘‘The Truth About Internet Business Models.’’ StrategyBusiness, Third Quarter, 1999. Available from http://www.strategy-business.com/toc/3q99.cgi. Schoenberger, Chana R. ‘‘Don’t Go There.’’ Forbes, October 2 2000, 174. Williams, Ruth L., and Joseph Cothrel. ‘‘Four Smart Ways to Run Online Communities.’’ Sloan Management Review, Summer 2000, 81.
❚ 28 E-COMMERCE EDUCATION AND TRAINING
E-commerce entrepreneurs vary widely in terms of their e-commerce education and experience. Some are information technology (IT) specialists with minimal training in business management. Others are seasoned business owners looking to launch online sales for the first time. A few have backgrounds in both technology and business, and many have experience with neither. Entrepreneurs looking for e-commerce education and training can turn to private companies, community colleges and universities, associations, and other organizations. And, not surprisingly, e-commerce courses and tutorials are offered via the Internet.
TYPES OF E-COMMERCE TRAINING If you are looking for a structured program that offers certification, you can visit a site like Ed-x.com, which allows users to search for certification programs by keyword. One option is the University of California Extension Online, which offers several courses covering specific e-commerce topics like marketing, business engineering, and systems design. Classes can be taken separately or as part of a certification program. JER Groups, Inc. also offers online certificate programs. Instructor-led course titles include WebSite 101: E-commerce Strategies for the Entrepreneur, and Proven Success in Building an E-Business. If you’re simply interesting in taking a class or two, or in offering e-commerce training to your employees,
Cardean University offers online e-commerce classes in areas ranging from business-to-business (B2B) ecommerce to online privacy. In a similar vein, Serebra Learning Corp. offers online courses in strategy and security, and the materials are also available on CDROM. Another education and training provider, ElementK.com, sells annual subscriptions to its E-Business Library to both individuals and businesses. The firm also offers various instructor-led and self-paced online courses covering basic concepts and managing e-commerce. Prices vary from a less than a hundred dollars for simple tutorial courseware to several thousand dollars for live on-site training.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
FURTHER READING
Many free e-commerce resources for entrepreneurs are also available. For general e-commerce information, the E-Commerce Times site offers a small business section, as well as news about the industry in general. Another site, E-Commerce News, also covers the latest e-commerce happenings. The Education Portal for Ecommerce offers news, industry reports, and discussion forums, along with training and a certification program. In addition, the entrepreneurial magazines Inc.com and Entrepreneur.com offer e-commerce sections on their sites. If you’re most concerned with a specific task related to e-commerce, such as Web site design, you can turn to a specialized education and training site like Session.com, which operates as an accredited online school of design. If you prefer to learn the basics of Web design on your own, you can visit sites like Builder.com and WebMonkey.com. Both offer extensive Web design and construction resources, including various tutorials, for free. Builder.com includes an HTML primer and sections dubbed Web Building Essentials, Graphics 101, and Streaming Media 101 in its How-To Library. WebMonkey also offers a How-to Library with various sections including Web authoring, which covers HTML basics, tables, frames, browsers, style sheets, and tools. Other sites offer extensive information and resources on applied topics of importance to e-commerce entrepreneurs, such as merchant accounts, shopping carts, and Web hosting. For example, MerchantSeek.com, along with listing the lowest-priced merchant account providers and information about what types of services each provider offers, provides detailed information about what a merchant account is and whether or not you need one.
CHOOSING THE APPROPRIATE EDUCATION FORMAT The types of e-commerce education and training you choose for yourself and your employees will depend on a wide variety of factors, including personal preference and learning styles, budget, training needs, 43
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
and time available for training. When IBM Corp. decided to shift its focus to e-business services, it embarked upon a three-year training program that cost millions of dollars. According to IBM executive Mark Frank, quoted in a May 2001 issue of Computer Weekly, IBM focused on creating very measurable goals. ‘‘The objectives had to be really straightforward. We were setting targets for numbers of people to reach specific skill levels. We had a one to five scale where five is extremely expert. And we reported back monthly to the board on our progress.’’ While you and your employees might not require such a regimented program, establishing specific goals can improve the results of education and training. Such goals will also assist in steering your education and training choices.
FURTHER READING Blacharski, Dan. ‘‘Building Web Sites.’’ Entrepreneur.com, July 17, 2000. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com. Goodwin, Bill. ‘‘Three-Year Training Overhaul Give Big Blue an E-Advantage.’’ Computer Weekly, May 24, 2001. ‘‘Online E-Commerce Courses & Degrees.’’ Calgary, Alberta: WorldWide Learn, 2002.
monitors and printers. Together, input and output components are known as peripherals. In addition, your computer needs internal storage systems, like a hard disk. Hard disk drives come preinstalled in most computers, and you can configure your own storage if you build your own system. However, a standard hard drive may not contain as much space as you need to store all the data you will use, and, at any rate, it is important to back up important data. Secondary or external storage devices can satisfy these needs. Often, these items, including CD-ROM drives, Zip drives, and so on, are sold with new computers, but you may wish to purchase separate drives with more power or more appropriate configurations. Computers can be classified according to their size and power into three general categories. Microcomputers include the typical desktop and portable PCs and workstations as well as hand-held devices. Most of these adhere to one of the two major standards: PC-compatible or Macintosh compatible. The one you favor depends largely on personal taste but also on the needs of your organization. Midrange computers are larger and more powerful, but also considerably more expensive. They typically have multiple processors and other features to maximize speed and throughput. Mainframes are the standard for running high-end corporate applications and some world-class Web sites, with tremendous storage, processing, and networking capabilities, but can be extremely expensive for smaller firms.
❚ 29 E-COMMERCE HARDWARE NEEDS
When it comes time to begin building your ecommerce business, the first thing you need, after a business plan, is the actual hardware necessary to run an Internet business. Hardware includes all the physical equipment used in a computing environment. Depending on the scale of your organization, this can range from a few items to a wide array of interconnecting hardware.
COMPUTER HARDWARE The basis of your Internet business is the computers themselves. At the heart of any computer is the central processing unit (CPU), the component that accepts, interprets, and performs all program instructions and functions. Strictly speaking, the CPU is just a small chip that would fit in the palm of your hand. But it can’t do anything on its own. It requires a motherboard, memory chips (RAM), and other components. In order to function at all, the CPU also needs to accept data from inputs and send its completed tasks along to outputs. Inputs include items like the standard keyboard and mouse, while outputs include
NETWORK HARDWARE Network adapters and modems are devices that allow computers and their peripherals to communicate with other computers. Network adaptors, also called network interface cards (NICs), allow your computer to participate in a local area network (LAN) and transmit data at relatively high speeds. The most widely used standard for network adapters, Ethernet, comes in a few different speeds. The standard 10/100 megabits per second (Mbps) Ethernet card is by far the most common. These adapters usually transmit at 10 Mbps, which is adequate for low-volume needs, but can be configured to run on a high-speed network at 100 Mbps. Actual transmissions, though, can be less than promised due to network traffic and other bottlenecks. For advanced applications, Ethernet cards are also available in 1 and 10 gigabit varieties. Meanwhile, the modem translates between the digital computer signals and analog media, like phone lines. Most often, modems connect computers-either workstations or mainframes-to wide area networks (WANs) like the Internet or other dispersed networks. Modems are available as stand-alone devices and as add-in internal cards.
44 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
A range of devices, many of which come in hybrid forms, are used to connect different portions of a network. Hubs act as stops on a network where circuits are connected. Routers pass information to each other in large switched networks, and communicate with each other, sharing information about the network. A router determines which path on a network a particular stream of information will follow. It acts as a traffic director sending data to the correct destinations within a network. Switches, taking orders from the router, determine the destination address, such as an IP address or hub or server within a larger network, and then sets up a transmission path, determining the precise course the data should take to get from the router to its destination. Firewalls are hardware-software combinations intended to protect sensitive information, and usually involves a two-server setup, where the firewall is placed between the two servers so that internal data is protected while those within the network can still interact seamlessly with users outside the firewall.
FINAL CONSIDERATIONS As always, the precise configuration will depend on the needs of your organization. You don’t want to over-invest in fancy, state-of-the-art hardware and peripherals if you’re running a low-key operation, nor should you try to run a sophisticated, ambitious enterprise on low-end equipment. As you grow your business from a start-up to a significant player, you’ll want to be sure your hardware is scalable. That is, rather than having to rebuild your network from the ground up every time your networking needs change, you’ll want to generate the greatest return on your initial investment by using hardware with speed and
storage capacities that can be easily upgraded in increments as your firm grows.
FURTHER READING Alexander, Steve. ‘‘Scalability.’’ Computerworld, June 26, 2000, 90. Hirsh, Lou. ‘‘Building the Perfect E-Business Server.’’ NewsFactor Network, April 19, 2000. Available from http:// www.newsfactor.com/perl/story/17346.html.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
A server is a computer that coordinates the interaction between shared computers and other devices, including peripherals. The configuration of your server depends on your business size, expected level and schedule of traffic, and security demand, among other factors. Depending and needs of your network, for instance, you may choose to have several different servers handling specific functions; a file server may act as a common storage facility for an entire network, while a print server may coordinate all the network’s printing activities. Particularly over the Web, a group of servers can also be arranged to work together in a cluster, where each server performs an identical or complementary function, say, retrieving Web pages. This helps manage large bursts of traffic without overburdening a single server and provides continuous uptime if one server fails. In general, the server will be the most powerful computer in a particular network, which may mean a sophisticated microcomputer with a high-power processor, or for larger networks, a midrange or mainframe computer.
Morrissey, Peter. ‘‘The Survivor’s Guide to 2002: Infrastructure. ’’ Network Computing, December 17, 2001, 69. Parker, Charles S. Understanding Computers: Today and Tomorrow. 98 ed. Fort Worth, TX: Dryden Press, 1998.
❚ 30 E-COMMERCE INCUBATORS
Business incubators are essentially business, government, or academic organizations that offer support to start-up companies in their earliest stages of development. Like an incubator for eggs, a business incubator offers a secure environment in which fledgling companies can grow and develop before they are ‘‘hatched’’ as independent entities.
ORIGINS OF BUSINESS INCUBATORS Business incubators emerged in the 1970s when universities began providing office space, materials, equipment, and other forms of support to both students and instructors working on business or technology plans that university officials considered promising. At roughly the same time, corporations willing to invest considerable sums of money in research and development started to use incubators to allow employees to develop innovative products ideas in-house. In the 1980s, venture capitalists began allowing entrepreneurs with a history of launching successful ventures to work in their offices on developing ideas for new companies. Small business organizations also began offering entrepreneurs incubation services for a fee.
E-COMMERCE INCUBATION A new form of business incubators emerged in the late 1990s as the Internet revolution took hold. At the time, speed-to-market had become the primary concern for Web entrepreneurs. For example, many business analysts believed that the success of Internet 45
G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
auction giant eBay was due to the fact that eBay had established itself first in the online auction market. By the time rivals launched their own auction sites, eBay had already secured millions of loyal customers who weren’t likely to try a new online service. As the Journal of Business Strategy reported in May 2002, ‘‘One way investors could enable inventors or entrepreneurs to bring their products or services to market at light speed was to take all the mundane care of building a business away from them... thus the incubator concept was copied from the R&D lab at universities and corporations.’’ These new e-commerce incubators were also different from their predecessors in that they operated as for-profit businesses. To make money, they required entrepreneurs to hand over as much as 75 percent ownership in their companies in exchange for office space, equipment like highspeed Internet connections and PCs, staffing, and additional services. The number of e-commerce incubators grew rapidly in the late 1990s, from 24 in 1997 to 213 in 2000. Firms like CMGI, idealab!, and Internet Capital Group focused solely on offering incubation services to Internet start-ups, believing that they would be able to cash in on lucrative dot-com initial public offerings (IPOs) as these firms matured. However, when investors became less willing to fund unprofitable dot-com upstarts in 2000, dot-com stock prices tumbled. Sources of funding for e-commerce ventures began to disappear, and many young businesses, unable to secure additional capital for expansion, were forced into bankruptcy. Suddenly firms like CMGI and idealab!, both of which had been valued at more than $40 billion in early 2000, found that many of the companies in which they held large stakes were no longer worth funding. Many analysts criticized e-commerce incubators for not requiring start-ups to submit business plans based on proven business models and for simply attempting to incubate too many different businesses. By the early 2000s, the number of e-commerce incubators had decreased. In addition, those that survived trimmed their ranks to focus on only those ventures most likely to be profitable in the near future. For example, the companies funded by CMGI decreased from 80 in 1999 to 9 by the end of 2000. However, many entrepreneurs continue to opt for incubation over other forms of funding, like venture capital or angel investments (those made by wealthy individuals interested in funding a start-up). According to Entrepreneur columnist Cynthia Harrington, ‘‘Angels and VCs don’t help as much on a dayto-day basis; the incubator, however, is always there. The incubator staff fills needed functions, freeing you up to focus on your company’s larger goals and strategies.’’
CHOOSING AN INCUBATOR If you plan to use an incubator, be aware that if you seek support from a for-profit incubator, you’ll be expected to transfer anywhere from 50 to 75 percent of your company’s equity to the incubator. Therefore, it’s essential that you research your options carefully. The National Business Incubation Association operates a Web site that allows you to search for incubators by region. Nearly all incubators will require you to submit some sort of a business plan, which explains clearly things like how you plan to launch operations, secure customers, and make a profit. Be as specific as possible. The most successful business plans establish a precise target market and are based on a proven business model. If you are accepted by an e-commerce incubator, you can expect your incubation period to last roughly two to three years. When you are ‘‘hatched’’, you may still need to secure outside funding for expansion. In this situation, being incubated will likely prove an advantage, according to a February 2001 issue of Entrepreneur.com. ‘‘When the incubated start-up seeks capital, the valuations are typically higher because the company has a launched site and a strong management team.’’
FURTHER READING Finer, Barbara, and Phil Holberton. ‘‘Incubators: There and Back.’’ Journal of Business Strategy, May 2002, 23. Harrington, Cynthia. ‘‘Peep Peep.’’ Entrepreneur, February 2001. Available from http://www.entrepreneur.com. Greenberg, Paul A. ‘‘Net Incubators: The Long Road Back.’’ E-Commerce Times, March 2, 2001. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. Regan, Keith. ‘‘Net Incubators Can’t Stand the Heat.’’ ECommerce Times, November 13, 2001. Available from http:// www.ecommercetimes.com. Wang, Andy. ‘‘Stock Watch: Internet Incubators Continue to Dazzle.’’ E-Commerce Times, January 4, 2000. Available from http://www.ecommercetimes.com. ‘‘What is Business Incubation?’’ Athens, OH: National Business Incubation Association, 2001. Available from http:// www.nbia.org.
❚ 31 E-COMMERCE STANDARDS
E-Commerce standards, relating to both technology and ethical business practices, have evolved rapidly since the mid-1990s as companies strive to create
46 G A L E
E - C O M M E R C E
S O U R C E B O O K
EDI is the exchange of business data by computer. In 1979, the American National Standards Institute created the Accredited Standards Committee (ASC) X12 to develop a uniform standard for exchanging electronic business data across industries. These standards are used for business documents including invoices, purchase orders, schedules, planning reports, shipping and receiving, and financial reports. Many EDI software packages are on the market, including bTrade DTNgine by bTrade Inc., Baan E-Enterprise by Bann N.V., Clearbridge Document Exchange Network by Clearbridge Inc., Epicor Vantage EDI by Epicor Software Corp., and Microsoft Corp.’s BizTalk Server. By adopting EDI standards, you can improve inventory management, accuracy, business relationships, and customer service, as well as cut costs and increase sales. In 2002, approximately 300,000 organizations utilized over 300 EDI-related standards.
late 1990s. Security issues are typically handled by your Internet Service Provider. However, if you host your own Web site, security software Entrust Technologies or from Certicom Corp., Novell Inc., IBM, Microsoft, or Sun Microsystems Inc. Along with technology-related e-commerce standards, you should generally follow a ‘‘best practices’’ code of conduct when operating an online business. BBBOnline’s Code of Online Business Practices includes five principles that it suggests should be followed by both online merchants and online advertisers. These principles are based on truthful and accurate communication, disclosure, information practices and security, customer satisfaction, and protecting children. BBBOnline also provides a Reliability Seal that can be placed on your Web site to inform customers that you are a member of your local BBB and a Privacy Seal, which is earned after you meet the BBB’s requirements related to handling private customer information.
‘‘How To’’ Topics in E-Commerce
universal practices that enable them to handle business transactions across industries and on a global basis. Use of such standards, including electronic data interchange (EDI), extensible markup language (XML), and standards related to security on the Web—such as secure sockets layer (SSL) and transport layer security (TLS)—has become increasingly widespread. Companies also adhere to ethical codes, including those that have been adopted by the Council of Better Business Bureaus Inc. and its Web-related subsidiary, BBBOnline. E-commerce standards, or ‘‘best practices’’, are typically set forth by consortiums made up of large computer-related firms or of industry organizations and government agencies.
Many organizations are involved in the creation and development of e-commerce standards. Most of them provide valuable information that can help you understand the standards and how they should be used. Some of the more popular include Microsoft’s BizTalk.org, the Data Interchange Standards Association (D