DEVELOPMENTS IN FOOD SCIENCE 37 B
F O O D FLAVORS: GENERATION, ANALYSIS A N D PROCESS INFLUENCE
This Page Intentiona...
72 downloads
1907 Views
69MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
DEVELOPMENTS IN FOOD SCIENCE 37 B
F O O D FLAVORS: GENERATION, ANALYSIS A N D PROCESS INFLUENCE
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
DEVELOPMENTS IN FOOD SCIENCE 37 B
F O O D FLAVORS: GENERATION, ANALYSIS A N D PROCESS INFLUENCE PROCEEDINGS OF THE 8TH INTERNATIONAL FLAVOR CONFERENCE, COS, GREECE, 6-8 JULY 1994 Edited by GEORGE CHARALAMBOUS
1995
ELSEVIER Amsterdam - Lausanne - New York - Oxford - Shannon - Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Molenwerf 1 P.O. Box 211,1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN: 0-444-82013-2 © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521,1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the USA - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the USA. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the USA, should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science B.V., unless othenA/ise specified. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
CONTENTS Forword Introduction List of Contributors Enzyme Reactions in Reverse Micelles A. GUPTE, R. NAGARAJAN and A. KILARA
VII VIII IX 1
Food Applications of Biopolymers - Theory and Practice I.S. CHRONAKIS and S. KASAPIS
75
Sorghum Grain and Quality of its Edible Products Y.G. MOHARRAM and A.M.A. YOUSSEF
Ill
GC-MS Analysis of Artemisia herba alba Asso Essential Oils from Algeria G. VERNIN, O. MERAD, G.M.F. VERNIN, R.M. ZAMKOTSIAN and C. PARKANYI
147
The Volatile Flavor of Fresh Gentiana lutea L. Roots I. ARBERAS, M.J. LEITON, J.B. DOMINGUEZ, J.M. BUENO, A. ARINO, E. de DIEGO, G. RENOBALES and M. de RENOBALES
207
Oriental Natural Flavor: Liquid and Spray-Dried Flavor of "Jeruk Purut" {Citrus hystrix DC) Leaves C. HANNY WIJAYA
235
Simple Analytical Technique for the Determination of Raspberry Flavor in a Complex Gelatin Matrix - Data and Methodology R.K. SALEEB
249
Stir-Fried/Saute Flavors - Recent Developments in the USA A.S. KIRATSOUS and M. ISHIKAWA
265
Formation of Sulfiir-Containing Flavor Compounds from AUylic Alcohol Precursors G.P. RIZZI
289
Changes in Chemical Composition of the Essential Oil of Chios "Mastic Resin" from Pistacia lentiscus var. Chia Tree During Solidification and Storage D. PAPANICOLAOU, M. MELANITOU and K. KATSABOXAKIS A New Method for Harvesting of Chios "Mastic Resin" in a Fluid Form D. PAPANICOLAOU, M. MELANITOU, K. KATSABOXAKIS, D. BOGIS and K. STAMOULA
303 311
VI
The Solubility and the Phase Equilibria of Essential Oil with Carbon Dioxide Calculated Using a Cubic Equation of State F.A. CABRAL and M.A. de A. MEIRELES
331
Authentication of Natural Flavours Using SNIF-NMR - New Developments on Mustard Oil and Safron G. MARTIN, G. REMAUD and GJ. MARTIN
355
Nitrogen-Specific Liquid Chromatography Detections of Nucleotides and Nucleosides by HPLC-CLND E.M. FUJINARI and J.D. MANES
379
Optimization of Virgin Olive Oil Quality in Relation to Fruit Ripening and Storage E. MONTELEONE, G. CAPORALE, L. LENCIONI, F. FAVATI and M. BERTUCCIOLI
397
Evaluation and Quantification of Potent Odorants of Greek Virgin Olive Oils G. BLEKAS and H. GUTH
419
Rapid Extraction and Determination of Phenols in Extra Virgin Olive Oil F. FAVATI, G. CAPORALE, E. MONTELEONE and M. BERTUCCIOLI
429
Effect of y-Radiation on Migration of Dioctyl Adipate Plasticizer from Food Grade PVC Film into Olive Oil A.E. GOULAS and M.G. KONTOMINAS
453
Subjective Odor Evaluation of Toasted Canola Oil D. PARK, J.A. MAGA and D.L. JOHNSON
465
Effect of Natural Antioxidants on the Stability of Canola Oil F. SHAHIDI and U. WANASUNDARA
469
The Aroma Components of Freshly Boiled Potatoes and Freeze-Dried Potatoes M.J. XU
481
Influence of Dips, Modified Atmospheric Packaging, and Storage Time on the Enzymatic Discoloration of Processed Raw Potatoes J.A. MAGA An Application of Deuterated Sex Pheromone Mimics of the American Cockroach {Periplaneta americana, L.), to the Study of Wright's Vibrational Theory of Olfaction B.R. HAVENS and C.E. MELOAN Testing Wright's Theory of Olfaction with Selectively Deuterated (E)-2-Hexen-l-al Compounds D.F. DeCOU (III) and C.E. MELOAN Properties of Extruded Rice Flour and Acorn Squash (Cucubita pepo) Blends G. MORINI and J.A. MAGA
491
497
525 549
Vll
Chestnut (Castanea molissimd) Flour Extrusion G. MORINI and J.A. MAGA
557
Changes in the the Fatty Acid Composition of Roasted and Boiled Chinese (Castanea molissima) and Italian (C. sativd) Chestnuts Grown at the Same Location G. MORINI and J.A. MAGA
563
Roles of Formulation and Extrusion Variables on the Properties of Potato-Based Half Snacks C.H. KIM and J.A. MAGA
569
Cereal Protein and Carbohydrate Digestibility as Affected by Extrusion K. DAHLIN and K. LORENZ Zinc Availability in Low- and High-Phytic Acid Extruded and non-Extruded Rat Diets D.E. BEST and J.A. MAGA
575 . . . . 595
Nutrition in the Critically 111 Infant D.E. WITHINGTON Nutritional Benefit of Edible Oil Processing to Decrease Cardiac Risk Factors: In vivo Studies with Mustard, Rape Seed Oils Low and High in Erucic Acid and Com Oil T. WATKINS, P. LENZ, R. SIDERITS, M. STRUCK and M. BIERENBAUM
625
633
Improving Atherogenic Risk Factors with Flax Seed Bread T. WATKINS, A.C. TOMEO, M.L. STRUCK, L. PALUMBO and M.L. BIERENBAUM
649
Cadmium in Cereal Products - Nutritional Importance K. LORENZ, A. WINATA and L. EOFF
659
The Red Microalga Rhodella reticulata as a Source of a Dietary Q-3 Highly Unsaturated Fatty Acid-Eicosapentaenoic Acid A. YARON, I. DVIR, M. MAISLOS, S. MOKADY and S. (MALIS) ARAD
665
Study of Emulsifying Porperties of Low-in-Cholesterol Egg Yolk Prepared with the Use of Polysorbate-80 A. PARASKEVOPOULOU and V. KIOSSEOGLOU
675
Volatile Nitrosamines in Foods - An Update R.A. SCANLAN
685
A Consumer Survey on Food Additives T. ALTUG and Y. ELMACI
705
Accelaration of Flavour Formation During Cheese Ripening M. EL SODA
721
Soy Bean Cheese L.G. SIAPANTAS
747
VIU
Proteolytic Enzymes of Lactic Acid Bacteria S. TAKAFUJI, T. IWASAKI, M. SASAKI and P.S.T. TAN Chemical and Volatile Organic Compounds Composition of Whey Protein Concentrate I. LAYE, D. KARLESKIND and C.V. MORR
753 . . . 769
Aroma Compounds in Green Coffee W. HOLSCHER and H. STEINHART
785
Formation of Furfuryl Mercaptan in Coffee Model Systems T.H. PARLIMENT and H.D. STAHL
805
Effect of Oxidation Products of Scented Tea Aroma Compounds on Flavor of Tea Infusion J. POKORNY, F. PUDIL, K. ULMANNOVA and E. FIKOVA
815
The Study on Aluminum State in Tea-Water by ^^Al NMR Spectroscopy Method D. QI, J. TONG, Y. SUN, S. CHEN and S. LUO
827
Flavour Composition of Some Lemon-Like Aroma Herbs from Lithuania P.R. VENSKUTONIS, A. DAPKEVICIUS and M. BARANAUSKIEN E
833
GLC Analysis and Comparison of the Flavor of Different Populations of Basil G. PETROPOULOS and A-M. VLACHOU
849
Microwave Extraction of Basil Aroma Compounds L.F. Di CESARE, M. RIVA and A. SCHIRALDI
857
Screening for Antioxidant Activity of Essential Oils Obtained from Spices V. LAGOURI and D. BOSKOU
869
Influence of Sleeted Additives on the Stability of Saffron Pigments in Aqueous Extracts O. ORFANOU and M. TSIMIDOU The Effect of Drying Kinetics on Peppermint Quality H. AKBABA and T. gAKALOZ Contributions of Nonvolatile Flavor Precursors of Garlic to Thermal Flavor Generation C-T. HO, T-H. YU and L-Y. LIN Volatile Compounds from Dried Jimbu {Allium wallichii) A. KATTEL and J.A. MAGA
. . . 881 895 . . . 909 919
Size Exclusion Chromatography with Nitrogen Detection of Peptides and Food Grade Protein Hydrolysates by HPLC-CLND E.M. FUJINARI and J.D. MANES
929
Application of GC-MS Analysis for Studies on Bioshythesis of Lower Terpenes Incorporating Deuterated Precursors in Plant Cultured Cells K. NABETA
951
Gas Chromatographic/Mass Spectrometry Analytical Characterisation of Smoke-Liquid Flavourings to evaluate the Opportunity of use as Antibacterial Agents F. TATEO, G. CASERIO, A. ORLANDI and S. GIOVANDITTO
971
Determination of Low Levels of Aziridine in Food-Simulating Liquids by Capillary Gas Chromatography P.G. DEMERTZIS, R. FRANZ and O. PIRINGER
981
Effect of Heat Treatment on Moisture Sorption Behavior of Wheat Flours Using a Hygrometric Technique 995 K.A. RIGANAKOS and M.G. KONTOMINAS Isolation and Identification of Off-Flavor Components from Soy Milk L. FL\SHIM and H. CHAVERON
1007
Carbohydrate Composition of Raw Vegetable Soybeans Grown at the Same Location O.O. FAPOJUWO and J.A. MAGA
. . . . 1021
Pyrazine Composition as Influenced by the Smoking Conditions of Hickory Sawdust Z. CHEN and J.A. MAGA
. . . . 1025
Functional and Sensory Characteristics of Quinoa in Foods K. LORENZ, L. COULTER and D. JOHNSON
1031
Processing Equipment and Food Quality A.E. KOSTAROPOULOS and G.D. SARAVACOS
1043
Non Enzymatic Browning in Air-Drying of Washed Raisins V.T. KARATHANOS, T. KARANIKOLAS, A.E. KOSTAROPOULOS, and G.D. SARAVACOS
1057
Microwave Heating of Water-Ethanol Mixtures A. PAOLI and A. SCHIRALDI
1065
Changes in Volatile Composition of Kluyveromyces lactis Broth during Fermentation J. JIANG
. . . . 1073
Isolation and Partial Characterization of Oilseed Phenolics and Evaluation of their Antioxidant Activity F. SHAHIDI, U. WANASUNDARA and R. AMAROWICZ The Effect of Polymers on the Vapor Pressure of an 0/W Microemulsion System J.L. CAVALLO and H.L. ROSANO Prediction of Moisture Barrier Requirements for an Effervescent Sinle Serve AspartameSweetened Tablet D. APOSTOLOPOULOS and R. FUSI
1087 1101
1119
Comparing the Rates of Development of Temperature Distributions in Foods Shaped as Spheres, Cylinders and Thick Films A.E. GROSSER
1133
Effect of Oxygen on the Ethyl Acetate Production from Continuous Ethanol Stream by Candida utilis in submerged cultures G. CORZO, S. REVAH and P. CHRISTEN
1141
Changes in Microstructure and Thermal Properties of Thermally Processed Comstarch/Soy Protein Isolate Model Food Systems F.A. NYANZI, J.A. MAGA and C. EVANS
1155
Evaluation of Cookeina sulcipes as an Edible Mushroom: Determination of its Biomass Composition
1165
J.E. S A N C H E Z , A . M . M A R T I N and A.D. SANCHEZ
Interactions Between Polysaccharides and Aroma Compounds S. LANGOURIEUX and J. CROUZET Water and Ethanol Adsorption on Starchy Substrates as Biomass Separation Systems G. VARELI, P.G. DEMERTZIS and K. AKRIDA-DEMERTZI
1173 . . . . 1187
Some Mulitvariate Perspectives on Shelf life Research R.H. ALBERT and C. ZERVOS
1201
Nitrite Alternatives for Processed Meats F. SHAHIDI and R.B. PEGG
1223
Potential for Growth and Inhibition of Listeria monocytogenes in Meat and Poultry Products J.N. SOFOS, W.B. BARBOSA, H.J. WEDERQUIST, G.R. SCHMIDT and G.C. SMITH
1243
Quality of Extrusion-Cooked Poultry Meat Products J.N. SOFOS, A.S. BA-JABER, G.R. SCHMIDT and J.A. MAGA
1265
Use of Starch for Water Binding in Restructured Beef Products J.N. SOFOS, J.A. PEREJDA and G.R. SCHMIDT
1281
Enzyme Generation of Free Amino Acids and its Nutritional Significance in Processed Pork Meats F. TOLDRA, M. FLORES and M-C. ARISTOY
1303
Isolation of Flavor Peptides from Raw Pork Meat and Dry-Cured Ham M-C. ARISTOY and F. TOLDRA
1323
The Effect of Fat Content on the Quality of Ground Beef Patties N.H. WONG and J.A. MAGA
1345
Fractionation and Characterization of Extracts of Chicken Fat Obtained with Supercritical Carbon Dioxide D.L. TAYLOR and D.K. LARICK BMP: A Flavor Enhancing Peptide Found Naturally in Beef. Its Chemical Synthesis, Descriptive Sensory Analysis and Some Factors Affecting its Usefulness A.M. SPANIER, J.M. BLAND, J.A. MILLER, J. GLINKA, W. WASZ and T. DUGGINS
1353
1365
Effects of storage Under Carbon Dioxide Atmosphere on the Volatiles, Phenylalanine Ammonia Lyase Activity and Water Soluble Constituents of Strawberry Fruits 1379 V. DOURTOGLOU, A. GALLY, V. TYCHOPOULOS, N. YANNOVITS, F. BOIS, M. ALEXANDRI, S. MALLIOU, M. RISSAKIS and M. BONY Studies on the Hydrolysis of Fish Protein by Enzymatic Treatment A.M. MARTIN and D. PORTER
1395
Production of Protein Hydrolysate from Lobster (Panulirus spp.) G.H.F. VIEIRA, A.M. MARTIN, S. SAKER-SAMPAIAO, C.A. SOBREIRAROCHA and R.C.F. GONCALVES
1405
Sensory Acceptance and Overall Quality of a Histidine Added Fish Sauce N.G. SANCEDA, T. KURATA and N. ARAKAWA
1417
Extraction of Value-Added Components from Shellfish Processing Discards F. SHAfflDI
1427
Protein Concentratres from Underutilized Aquatic Species F. SHAHIDI
1441
Extending the Shelf-Life of Seafood Using a Multiple Barrier Process S.M. CONSTANTINIDES, S.M. EINARSSON, Y. BENJA-ARPORN and A. PAPPAS
1453
Fresh Orange Juice Flavor: a Quantitative and Qualitative Determination of the Volatile Constituents M.G. MOSHONAS and P.E. SHAW
1479
Effect of Microwave Heating on Roasted Nut Flavor D.E. ZOOK, C. MACKU and D. DEMING
1493
Peanut Flavor Formation During Roasting as Affected by Atmospheric Conditions R.Y.-Y. CHIOU and C-Y. TSENG
1519
Color Sorting of Lightly Roasted and Deskinned Peanut Kernels to Diminish Aflatoxin and Retain the Processing Potency R. Y.-Y. CHIOU, P-Y. WU and Y-H. YEN
1533
Carbohydrate Metabolism in Peanuts During Postharvest Curing and Maturation J.R. VERCELLOTTI, T.H. SANDERS, S.-Y. CHUNG, K.L. BETT and B.T. VINYARD
1547
The Phenolic Composition of Table Grapes E. REVILLA, J.M. ESCALONA, E. ALONSO and V. KOVAC
1579
Selection of Spontaneous Strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae as Starters in their Viticultural Area A.I. BRIONES, J.F. UBEDA, M.D. CABEZUDO and P. MARTIN-ALVAREZ Hydrolysis of Grape Glycosides by Enological Yeast P-Glucosidases I. ROSI, P. DOMIZIO, M. VINELLA and M. SALICONE Analytical Research to Identify Illegal Modifications of D/H Values in Sugar Mixtures F. TATEO, G. CANTELE, B. DAMIA, G. RUSSO, L. PANZA and E. BOUSQUET Partial Characterization of P-Damascenone Precursors and Toxicity Studies of Free P-Damascenon in Cell Cultures of Vitis x labruscana cv. Concord Grapes K.B. SHURE and T.E. AGREE
1597
1623 . . 1637
1645
Influence of Nitrogen Compounds in Grapes on Aroma Compounds of Wines A. RAPP and G. VERSINI
1659
The Contribution of Oak Lactone to the Aroma of Wood-Aged Wine J.R. PIGGOTT, J.M. CONNER and J.L. MELVIN
1695
Possibilities of Characterizing Wine Varieties by Means of Volatile Flavor Compounds A. RAPP Classification of Italian Wines on a Regional Scale by Means of a Multi-Isotopic Analysis A. MONETTI, G. VERSINI and F. RENIERO
. . 1703
1723
Flavour Development in Whisky Maturation J.R. PIGGOTT, J.M. CONNER and A. PATERSON
1731
Investigation of Flavour Compounds in Whiskey Spent Lees K. MacNAMARA, P. BRUNERIE, F. SQUARCIA and A. ROZENBLUM
1753
An Application of Centrifugal Counter-Current Chromatography on Flavor Chemistry Separation of Aroma Substances in Whisky New Distillates T. TANIGUCHI, N. MIYAJIMA and H. KOMURA Aroma Compounds of Arbutus Distillates G. VERSINI, R. SEEBER, A. DALLA SERRA, G. SFERLAZZO, B. de CARVALHO and F. RENIERO
1767 1779
XIU
Aroma Components of Raki i. YAVA§ and A. RAPP
1791
Recent Evaluation of Malt Quality M. MOLL
1813
Lipolytic Activity of Cheese Related Microorganisms and its Impact on Cheese Flavour M. EL SODA, J. LAW, E. TSAKALIDOU and G. KALANTZOPOULOS Fermentation of Black Olives with Application of Starter Culture and Aeration M. BORCAKLI, G. OZAY and L ALPERDEN Changes in Soluble Sugars in Various Tissues of Cultivated Mushroom, Agaricus bisporus. During Postharves Storage S.O. AJLOUNI, R.B. BEELMAN, D.B. THOMPSON and J-L. MAU Concentration of Heavy Metals and Nutrients in the Leaves of Certain Forest Species Irrigated by Treated Wastewater P. DRAKATOS, G. KALLISTRATOS, I. FANARIOTOU, 1. KALAVROUZIOTIS, D. SKOURAS and M. STOYIANNI
. . 1823 1849
1865
1881
A Rapid Method for Determining the Water Dynamics (Uptake and Loss) of MoistureSensitive Foods S.G. GILBERT, G.W. GREENWAY, J.X. LIU and O. RAMON
1895
The Inhibitory Effect of the Essential Oils from Basil (Ocimum basilicum) and Sage {Salva officinalis) in Broth and in Model Food System Ch.Ch. TASSOU and G.J. E. NYCHAS
1925
Comparison of some Physicochemical Characteristics Between Solid and Fluid Chios Mastic Resin M. MELANITOU, D. PAPANICOLAOU, K. KATSABOXAKIS and K. STAMOULA Food Production in Arid and Desert Areas Using the "KALLIDENDRON" TECHNOLOGY G. KALLISTRATOS, P. DRAKATOS and I.-M. KALLISTRATOS
1937
1947
The Essential Oil of Allium Sativum L., Liliaceae (Garlic) N.A. SHAATH and F.B. FLORES
2025
Microbeam Molecular Spectroscopy of Biological Materials D.L. WETZEL
2039
Analysis of Drinking Water near and Far from Thermal Springs Using Instrumental Neutron Activation Analysis E.T. CONTIS Emulsifying Properties of Lupin Seed Proteins S. ALAMANOU and G, DOXASTAKIS
2109 2129
XIV
Multiresponse Optimization by a Normalized Function Approach J.D. FLOROS and H. LIANG Back Propagation Neural Networks: Theory and Applications for Food Science and Technology V. GNANASEKHARAN and J.D. FLOROS
2139
2151
Gentic Algorithms and Fuzzy Theory for Optimization and Control of Food Processes . . . . 2169 LG. VRADIS and J.D. FLOROS Volatile Compounds in Wheat Cultivars from Several Locations in Kansas L.M. SEITZ
2183
Autolysis of Lactid Acid Bacteria: Impact on Flavor Development in Cheese M. EL SODA, N. FARKYE, J.C. VUILLEMARD, R. SIMARD, N. OLSON, W. EL KHOLY, E. DAKO, E. MEDRANO, M. GABER and L. LIM
2205
SUBJECT INDEX
2225
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1101
The Effect of Polymers on the Vapor Pressure of an OAV Microemulsion System J. L. Cavallo^ and H. L. Rosano^ ^Kraft General Foods, Maxwell House Coffee Company, 555 South Broadway, Tarrytown, NY 10591, U.S.A. ^The City College, City University of New York, Department of Chemistry, 138th Street & Convent Avenue, New York, NY 10031, U.S.A. Abstract The vapor pressure of an oil-in-water microemulsion system consisting of n-octane/20cc of 5% NaCl + 0.01 N NaOH/lg of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)/ 3.7g of dodecyl dimethylamine oxide (DDAO) and n-octane/SDS/water/titrated to clarity with DDAO was determined as a function of the volume of hydrocarbon in the dispersed phase. In the presence of a cationic polymer. Polymer JR, the dispersed droplets are destabihzed due to surfactant depletion from the microemulsion droplet interface. In the presence of an anionic polymer, carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), the microemulsion droplets appear to be stabilized over larger volume fractions of oil. Introduction Emulsions play a key role in many cosmetics and industrial products in current use. Much has been written over the last three decades on the stability and formation of these oil-in-water (o/w) or water-in-oil (w/o) dispersions (1). Today's industrial formulator is primarily concerned with understanding and developing the most functional o/w or w/o systems possible for a particular appHcation. Stable transparent systems (whether o/w or w/o) called microemulsions can be formulated when the right surface-active ingredients are used (2,3). Possible appHcation for these systems range from products with extended shelf life for the food industry to dehvery systems for active ingredients in pharmaceuticals. More recently, fluorocarbon microemulsions have been developed as media for oxygen transport and as possible synthetic blood substitutes. Mixtures of oil and water in the presence of surface-active agents usually form coarse, optically opaque emulsions that separate on standing. In some
1102 cases, transparent mixtures of oil and water can be prepared when the initial emulsion is titrated to clarity (microemulsion) with a cosurfactant. Relatively small negative free energy changes may explain why the method of preparation plays an important role in microemulsion formation (4). The proper method of adding the ingredients appears to be responsible for producing a transitory zero interfacial tension due to diffusion of cosurfactant across the oil/water interface, during which time both maximum interface generation and spontaneous clearing of the primary emulsion occur (2, 3). The most significant difference between emulsions (opaque) and microemulsions (transparent) lies in the fact that while applying work on an emulsion or increasing the surfactant concentration usually improves stability. This is not the case with microemulsions, which appear to be dependent for their formation on specific interactions among the constituent molecules. If these interactions do not take place, neither applying work nor increasing the surfactant concentration will produce a microemulsion. On the other hand, once the conditions are right, spontaneous formation occurs and little mechanical work is required (5). Terms like microemulsion (6), swollen micellar solution (7), micellar emulsion (8, 9), middle phase (10), unstable microemulsion (11), and spontaneous transparent emulsion (12) have all been used to describe these systems. The broadest definition may simply be "a transparent dispersion of oil, water, and surfactant that forms spontaneously upon addition of a cosurfactant." As originally suggested by Schulman et al. (13, 14), microemulsions form when the surfactant and cosurfactant, in just the right ratio, produce a mixed adsorbed film that reduces the interfacial tension y^ to a value below zero. They concluded that y^ must have a metastable negative value, giving a negative free energy variation -y^ dA (where dA is the change in interfacial area) responsible for spontaneous dispersion. The interfacial tension y^ in the presence of a mixed film is given by Yi = Yo/w - ^i where yo/w is the o/w interfacial tension in the presence of the film and ni is the interfacial surface pressure of the film. At equilibrium y^ becomes zero. If this concept of zero interfacial tension is accepted, stabilization of the microemulsion is implied. This model does not seem to be conceptually valid; however, since a zero y^ would not require the dispersed phase to be distributed in spherical droplets, as is found in the systems under discussion (15). Rosano et al. (11) have considered the dynamic role of the cosurfactant in lowering the interfacial tension during the titration of a coarse emulsion into a transparent dispersion. They pointed out that during the addition of a cosurfactant to an emulsion (either o/w or w/o), excess cosurfactant accumulated at the oil/water interface during transport, reducing the interfacial tension to well
1103 below the positive equilibrium value. The surfactant retards the cosurfactant interfacial transport; a prolonged low interfacial tension helps in the formation of a large increase in the interfacial area. Eventually, YI regains a positive value responsible for the resolution of the system into microemulsion droplets. Emulsion and microemulsion stability appear to be dependent not on the value of the y^ alone but rather, and primarily, on the structure of the film surrounding each droplet (3, 16). For a given oil/surfactant pair, cosurfactant steric requirements determine the volume of the dispersed phase that can be stabilized. These systems apear to be oU and cosurfactant dependent. Surfactant, cosurfactant, the nature of the oil, and the nature of the aqueous phase are four interacting variables that determine the size of the dispersed phase droplet when microemulsions are formed. A wealth of experimental results show that only specific component combinations can produce transparent systems and that the various components must be put together in just the right order to produce a microemulsion. We are thus left with two basic questions: 1. Are these systems kineticaUy stable, since they may show path dependency in their formation? 2. Are they thermodynamicaUy stable, even though their occasional path dependency properties may reflect activation energy barriers that these systems must overcome during their formation? In a previous paper (4) it was shown that o/w emulsions of sodium long-chain sulfate/n-hydrocarbon/5% NaCl can be titrated to clarity with specific long-chain dimethylamine oxides. For the six systems investigated, all were found to have small negative free energy values associated with cosurfactant absorption during microemulsion formation. These small free energy values seem to explain why the manner of combining the various components is important during microemulsion formation. The right order of addition appears to lower activation energy barriers that these systems must overcome during their formation. In addition, microemulsion formation appears to be an entropy-driven process, as shown by titration experiments. It has always been assumed that microemulsions are composed of discrete individual spherical droplets (3). In a previous paper (17), we demonstrated that o/w microemulsions prepared with low volume fraction of hydrocarbon show an overall decreased vapor pressure relative to the vapor pressure of the continuous surfactant phase. This behavior is similar to that of a high molecular weight polymer solution or a regular coUoidal dispersion, where the vapor pressure of the solution is less than that of the continuous phase. It was also demonstrated, based on vapor pressure analysis, that o/w microemulsions clearly exhibit two distinct regions of transparency depending on the volume of hydrocarbon in the dispersed phase. For low volumes of hydrocarbon, encapsulated non-interacting droplets are formed in solution, while for higher volumes of hydrocarbon, a dynamic merging equilibrium exists in which the droplets are continuously breaking and reforming; i.e., percolation (17, 18). Similar phase behavior has been demonstrated by Weatherford (19) using vapor
1104 pressure analysis for w/o diesel fuel microemulsion systems composed of a surfactant mixture of oleyldiethanolamide, diethanolamide, and diethanolanmonium oleate. The results which indicate that two regimes of differing phase behavior exist as the water content is varied, suggest a transition from inverted micellar solutions, at low water concentrations to microemulsions at a higher water content. These results support the fact that the internal droplet structure can vary depending on the internal phase volume, an important physical-chemical property of microemulsion systems of considerable interest to the formulator of consumer goods. Since the dispersed phase volume governs the structure and properties of the droplets formed, microemulsions offer a broad array of applications. For example, microemulsion systems can be used to encapsulate and reduce the rate of oxidation and/or hydrolysis of oils (or oil-soluble ingredients). This effect is due to the fact that, for low volume fractions of oil, microemulsions offer complete encapsulation of the oil by the surfactant sheath surrounding the droplets. A specific example might involve the encapsulation of citrus oil in o/w microemulsions. In addition, since the presence of droplets (low volume fraction of oil) results in a lowering of the vapor pressure, these systems can be used to stabilize and deliver hydrocarbons with high vapor pressure (e.g., isopentane and pentane). This effect cannot be achieved with conventional emulsion systems. Droplet aggregation in w/o microemulsions has also been investigated and discussed by a variety of authors (3, 10, 17). For systems containing low concentrations of water, isolated non-interacting droplets have been found to be the primary droplet structure (18). At higher water concentrations, droplet interactions were found to be either repulsive, with short-lived collisions and no overlap between colliding droplet interfaces, or attractive, with collisions of larger durations and the formation of transient droplet clusters. It has also been shown that the probability of such transient merging in ternary systems is low (~ 10"3 per collision). For quaternary systems the merging probability between droplets is quite high (~ 1), indicating that the interactions between droplet cores play an important role in the droplet structure of these systems. The need to understand factors related to the stability of coUoidal dispersions has long been the central motivating factor in the study and development of surface science. "Stability" in this context is generally understood to mean kinetic stability; i.e., stability imposed by a strong repulsive barrier acting against contact between the suspended particles (20). For emulsion systems, London-van der Waals dispersion forces are at the origin of the tendency of coUoidal systems to coagulate and aggregate. The repulsive forces needed to stabilize the dispersion against these attractive forces are usually of two tj^es: 1. Coulombic repulsion due to electric charges on the particle surface; e.g., electrostatic interactions between the ionic double layers surrounding the particles. 2. Static repulsion introduced by large molecules or polymers adsorbed on the particle surface.
1105 In the case of microemulsions, stability concerns are similar to those encountered for emulsion systems (or colloidal dispersions), with emphasis placed on reducing and/or retarding the rate of droplet coalescence or aggregation. As suggested by Napper (21), the most functional stabilizers are amphipathic molecules that are either block or graft co-polymers. These molecules have been shown to be effective stabilizers when added to colloidal dispersions already formed (or vice versa). The most effective stabilizers consist of both anchor groups and stabilizing moieties. The stabilizing moieties must be soluble in the dispersion medium to be effective, whereas the anchor groups function most efficiently if they are nominally insoluble in the dispersion medium and have an affinity to adsorb at the particle (droplet) interface. This paper will present a basic overview of the physical-chemical properties of microemulsions. Topics highhghted will include microemulsion preparation, vapor pressure measurements, activation energy determination, and the relationship between vapor pressure measurements and microemulsion droplet size. In addition, the effect of dissolved polymers in the continuous phase of o/w microemulsions will be investigated in order to demonstrate the effect these large molecules have on dispersed droplet interactions. Both anionic and cationic polymers will be investigated. It is hypothesized that polymers added to the continuous phase of microemulsion systems may reinforce the encapsulated droplets or to some extent prevent the droplets from merging. If the presence of polymers in the aqueous phase can alter droplet interactions, this effect should be demonstrated by vapor pressure analysis. Experimental Section •
Chemicals
Polymer JR-400, a quaternary water-soluble cationic nitrogen-substituted cellulose ether (Union Carbide Corp.) and sodium carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), a low viscosity anionic water soluble pol5mier, 99.5% purity (approx. Mol. Wt. 90,000) (Hercules Inc.), were used. N-octane (99% + gold label) and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) were provided by Aldrich Chemical Company. Dodecyldimethylamine oxide (DDAO) 30% active was obtained from Ony^ Chemical Company. Freshly distilled water was used in all solution preparations. •
Preparation and Vapor Pressure Measurements of Polymer Microemulsion Systems
In a water-jacketed beaker maintained at 25°C, initial emulsions were prepared containing 15 cc of water, 1 g SDS, and various volumes of n-octane. These emulsions were titrated to clarity (92% T @ 520 nm.) with DDAO, using the titration technique (2). To these transparent systems 5 cc of a 0.1% JR-400 or 0.1% CMC polymer solution was added. At the concentration of polymer
1106 used, no viscosity changes were observed. In all cases the systems remained transparent upon addition of polymer. The microemulsions were then thoroughly stirred for 15 minutes to ensure complete mixing. For each microemulsion the vapor pressure was determined with an isoteniscope. The microemulsion was placed in the isoteniscope and submerged in a hot water bath, and the system was allowed to boil for 10 minutes to evacuate any excess air present. The bath was then slowly cooled untU an equilibrium between the liquid and vapor was obtained in the isoteniscope, at which the pressure within the system and the temperature of the water bath were recorded. The pressure was then further reduced, and the procedure was repeated. Using the ClausiusClapeyron equation
^ 0
R
IT
(1)
To J
where JO a n d p o ^^® the vapor pressures at T a n d TQ, AH^ is the heat of vaporization, and R is the gas constant, the vapor pressure and heat of vaporization were determined. •
Activation Energy
As shown in Figure 1, the slope of the vapor pressure curve increases with temperature. [This effect was thoroughly discussed in a previous paper (17)]. It has been hypothesized that this increase is due to the breaking and re-forming of droplets in solution (2, 17). As the temperature is increased, the rate of breaking increases, as does the breaking rate constant K = (dP/dV) T • Using an Arrhenius type equation: hi K.
n
I
^1
1.
I
(2)
where K^ and K2, are the slopes corresponding to temperatures T^ and T2 and R is the gas constant, an activation energy E^ of 35.4 kJ/mol was calculated, corresponding to the amount of energy required for hydrocarbon molecules within the droplet core to get into the vapor phase. This value is higher than that for the microemulsion prepared in a water continuous phase where E^ = 31.5 kJ/mol., and higher than the activation energy of pure n-octane, Ea = 8.8 kJ/mol., obtained through viscosity measurements by plotting In r\ vs. I/T- The difference appears to be related to both the strength of the surfactant sheath and the effect of poljmaers at the interface.
1107 Results The vapor pressure for each microemulsion was determined from Eq. 1 by plotting In p vs. 1/T. In each case a straight line was obtained, with excellent correlation (>0.99). From the slope of the line the heat of vaporization was determined. The same procedure was repeated for all systems investigated containing constant amounts of saline, surfactant, and cosurfactant, and various volumes of n-octane.
VOL. OCTANE • !
Figure 1: Vapor pressure diagram for the microemulsions systems: 5% NaCl (pH 12)/sodium dodecyl sulfate/n-octane/dodecyldimethylamine oxide between 15 and 40°C. Plotted as a function of amount of n-octane.
1108 Vapor pressure vs. volume of n-octane was determined for microemulsions between 15 and 40°C. The results, shown in Figure 1, demonstrate that two distinct regions are present, depending on the volume of n-octane used. Microemulsion systems prepared with up to 1.1 cm^ of n-octane show a decreased vapor pressure (e.g., at 30°C, 32.4 mm Hg for the system prepared with no oil to 25.4 mm Hg). Within this region the vapor pressure remains constant. This behavior is similar to that of a high molecular weight polymer solution or a regular colloidal dispersion where the vapor pressure of the solution is less than that of the continuous phase. Assuming that this region is composed of monodispersed noninteracting droplets, and using van't Hoff equation GMW =
RT — T
^^^
where GMW is the average gram molecular weight, R the gas constant, T temperature, C solution concentration (g/1), and n=pQ-p [i.e., the vapor pressure difference between the solution containing no oil (p^ and microemulsions containing various volumes of n-octane (p)], the GMW per droplet was calculated. GMW values were determined for systems containing up to 1.4 cm^ of n-octane. From our experimental results, for volumes of n-octane larger than 1.1 cm^, the increase in the value of the GMW indicates that the droplets start to percolate. It should also be noted that systems prepared containing 0.01-0.1 cm^ of n-octane clearly demonstrate that lamellar structures exist between SDS/ DDAO. The viscosity within this region was found to increase to ca. 100 cp and decrease to ca. 10 cp when the microemulsion contained 0.1 cm^ of n-octane. Although the vapor pressure of these systems was not determined, the addition of hydrocarbon clearly resulted in the resolution of the lamellar structures into microdroplets producing measurable osmotic pressures. Particle Size Measurements. From the average GMW we determined droplet radii by considering that the ratio of GMW to SW (the average weight of the associated surfactant and cosurfactant at the droplet interface) gives the number of surfactant molecules at the droplet surface. For spherical droplets of surface area 4nx^ GMW SW
=
^^ 4T"5"
(4)
where a is the average cross-sectional area per surfactant molecule, droplet radii values were determined, assuming o = 45A2 per molecule (7). These values were found to be in agreement with results obtained by photon correlation spectroscopy (8), as shown in Table 1.
1109 TABLE 1: Average GMW per Droplet and Radii Values Determined by Vapor Pressure Analysis (Assuming a = 45 A^ per molecule) and by Photon Correlation Spectroscopy as a Function of Increasing Volume of n-octane at 30°C Vol. n-octane, cm^ 0.1 0.25 0.5 0.75 1.0 1.1 1.25 1.4
GMW 30°C 4.95 X 105 5.9 X 105 4.99 X 105 6.14x105 6.03 X 105 6.29 X 105 1.77 X 106 1.98 X lO'^
radiuSyp, A 85.4 93.2 85.8 95.1 94.3 96.3 161.5 540.2
radiumpQg, A 80.8 76.8 85.6 80.5 94.4 115.0 198.0 958.0
Beyond 1.1 cm^ of n-octane, the vapor pressure increases, as shown in Figure 1. Within this region droplets appear to merge and re-form continuously. At 30°C, these systems remain transparent (90% transparent @ 520 nm) up to 1.5 cm^ of n-octane. Between 1.5 and 2.5 cm^ of n-octane the systems become cloudy, whUe at 2.5 cm^ of n-octane, separation is clearly visible. At 2.8 cm^ of n-octane, the vapor pressure increases to 52 mm Hg, the sum of the individual components (saline surfactant solution 32.4 mm Hg and 19 mm Hg for n-octane), suggesting an emulsification-failure instability (11). When droplets contain a small volume of n-octane, the hydrocarbon is strongly associated with the tails of the surfactant molecules. This interaction precludes the presence of any n-octane vapor in the vapor phase above the microemulsion system. The effect of increasing the volume of n-octane results in an increase in the total number of droplets and a lowering of the vapor pressure. As the volume of n-octane is further increased, the situation changes: the radius of the droplets increases, more n-octane is present in the droplet core, and the microemulsion shows the characteristics of bulk n-octane. At this point, closed and open microemulsion droplets exist, with a resultant increase in vapor pressure. Increasing the volume of n-octane results in a core showing characteristics of bulk hydrocarbon. The hydrocarbon vapor is free to enter the vapor phase, resulting in an increase in the measured vapor pressure. Similar droplet behavior has been shown to exist for AOT/isooctane/water microemulsions systems as the water content was varied (12). Figure 2 shows the vapor pressure behavior of an o/w microemulsion for various volumes of n-octane in the presence and absence of polymer (anionic and cationic) dissolved in the aqueous phase. Curve A represents the vapor pressure behavior of a microemulsion prepared with 1 g SDS / 20 cc water / 3.7 g DDAO and various volumes of n-octane in the dispersed phase. As indicated by this curve (see discussion of Figure 1) the vapor pressure above the microemulsion
1110 surface decreases when the dispersed phase contains low volume fractions of noctane. The structure of the droplets within this region of low vapor pressure is that of encapsulated droplets surrounded by a surfactant/ cosurfactant sheath. Increasing the volume of n-octane in the dispersed phase results in an increase in the measured vapor pressure above the microemulsion surface. This increase in vapor pressure is due to the existence of a dynamic equilibrium between the merging and re-forming of droplets in solution. The vapor pressure increases until a maximum vapor pressure is reached (-^ 50 mm Hg). Further addition of n-octane results in the separation of oil and water; i.e., a two-phase system is formed.
60
50
tyc
fy^ L*s-*^' 0-0—0—»~
VAPOR PRESSURE
A
B
40
(mm Hg) 30
20
m
10
m
y
i
VOLUME N-OCTANE (ml)
1 FIGURE 2:
1
1
Change in vapor pressure vs. volume of n-octane for a microemulsion prepared with water / 1 g SDS / n-octane and DDAO (curve A) containing Polymer JR (curve B) or CMC (curve C) in the continuous phase.
nil Curve B shows the vapor pressure behavior of a microemulsion prepared with 1 g SDS /15 cc water + 5 cc of 0.1% Polymer JR-400 / 2.4 g DDAO and increasing amounts of n-octane. It is observed that the vapor pressure decreased to approximately 24 mm Hg upon addition of 0.25 cc n-octane and remains low up to the addition of 0.5 cc. When the volume of n-octane exceeds 0.5 cc, a sharp increase in vapor pressure results. For a microemulsion prepared with 0.8 cc n-octane, a maximum vapor pressure of 41 mm Hg is reached. The vapor pressure was found to remain high up to the addition of 1.3 cc, where phase separation occurs. Curve C shows the vapor pressure of a microemulsion prepared with 1 g SDS /15 cc water + 5 cc of 0.1% CMC / 3.7 g DDAO and various volumes of noctane. Vapor pressure results indicate that when CMC is added to the continuous phase of microemulsions containing large volumes of n-octane, the vapor pressure is reduced compared to that for microemulsions prepared in a pure aqueous phase. This result indicates that CMC acts as a stabilizer for the microemulsion by preventing and/or reducing the rate of droplets merging. For 1 cc of n-octane, it can be seen that the vapor pressure is approximately equal to that of a microemulsion prepared in pure water. Increasing the volume of n-octane does not result in a sharp vapor pressure increase. It is also interesting to note that phase separation was observed for microemulsions prepared in pure water containing 2 cc of n-octane in the dispersed phase, but not for microemulsions containing CMC. This fact further supports the hypothesis that the role played by CMC in this particular system is that of a stabilizer. These results clearly demonstrate that the droplet interactions in microemulsion systems can be strongly influenced by the addition of polymers with the end result, in some cases, of stabilization or destabilization of the microemulsion. Discussion and Conclusion The results shown in Figure 2 demonstrate that cationic or anionic poljmaers added to the continuous phase of o/w microemulsion systems can significantly influence droplet-droplet interactions over a wide range of oil volumes. Surface tension measurements on solutions of Polymer JR in water show that the polymer is a weak surface-active agent. At a level of 0.1%, the polymer was found to reduce the surface tension of pure water by ca. 4 dyn/cm (23). This small reduction of the surface tension of water suggests that the polymer is very active in the bulk phase. Using surface tension data, Goddard (23) demonstrated that addition of Polymer JR caused a marked decrease in the surface tension of SDS surfactant solutions at low concentrations. He suggested that, in certain cases, complexes would form between cationic polymers and anionic surfactants. This interaction would modify the pol5nner and render it more surface active by adsorption of surfactant "head-head" onto cationic sites along the polymer chain. Modification
1112 of the polymer was demonstrated by an increase in the overall viscosity of the system. Addition of Polymer JK introduced into the continuous phase of an o/w microemulsion prepared with water / SDS / n-octane and DDAO seems to have a destabilizing effect on the microemulsion droplets. For relatively small volumes of n-octane, the vapor pressure was found to increase sharply, leading to a breakdown of the microemulsion and to eventual phase separation. It was thought that with the addition of a cationic polymer to a microemulsion prepared with an anionic surfactant, the polymer would "wrap around" the microemulsion droplets and enhance their stability over larger volumes of n-octane. Contrary to expectation, however, destabiUzation of the microemulsion occurred. These results are consistent with the formation of complexes between the cationic polymers and SDS. Adsorption of SDS onto the cationic sites along the polymer chain reduces the amount of surfactant at the o/w interface. The complex formed between Polymer JR and SDS reduces droplet stability. Microemulsion systems prepared with CMC in the aqueous phase are shown to exhibit a stabilizing effect when compared to microemulsions prepared in a pure water continuous phase or a continuous phase containing Polymer JR. Figure 2 shows that when CMC is added to the continuous phase of a microemulsion containing large volumes of n-octane, the vapor pressure is lower than for microemulsions prepared in a pure water phase. Since there is no association between the surfactant and the anionic polymer, there is no depletion of the surfactant at the o/w interface. In addition, since both surfactant and polymer are anionic, they produce a repulsive interaction. This interaction aids in keeping the surfactant at the o/w interface while enhancing the droplet stability. The interaction between hydroxyethylceUulose and SDS has been investigated by Goddard (23) using surface tension measurements . These measurements clearly show that there is Uttle or no association between hydroxyethylceUulose and SDS in the bulk phase; when hydroxyethylceUulose is added to an SDS solution, no appreciable surface tension lowering occurs. This suggests that microemulsions containing CMC in the aqueous phase contain only unassociated CMC. Free CMC in the bulk phase should therefore exhibit a repulsive interaction between other CMC molecules and the anionic surfactant heads of the microemulsion droplets. This effect should interfere with microemulsion droplet merging resulting in stable microdroplets over larger volumes of hydrocarbon. Figures 3 and 4 show the interaction between microdroplets in the presence of cationic or anionic polymers.
1113
Figure 3: Microdroplet behavior in solution; (A) water continuous phase; (B) water + Polymer JR.
F i ^ r e 4: Microdroplet behavior in a water + CMC solution.
1114 It has been shown that mixing surfactants and poljmaers in solution leads, under certain circumstances, to complex formation through binding or adsorption of the surfactant molecules either individually or as aggregates onto the macromolecule (24). In the case of a cationic pol5maer and an anionic surfactant, complex formation occurs at very low polymer concentrations (<0.1%), with precipitation of the complex. It has also been suggested, by Goddard et al. (25), that increasing the surfactant concentration can result in a resolubilization of the precipitate as a polyelectrolyte complex with a net charge opposite that of the original poljnner molecule. In reference to Figure 2 (Curve B), it is observed that as the volume of n-octane is increased, the vapor pressure decreases (between 0.2 cc and 0.8 cc n-octane). Beyond 0.8 cc n-octane the vapor pressure increases to 40.8 mm Hg whUe the system remains clear. Beyond 1.0 cc of n-octane, the system begins to cloud until phase separation occurs. A possible explanation for the extensive lowering of the vapor pressure (between 0.2 and 0.8 cc of n-octane) is that the lowering is the result of both the presence of microdroplets in solution and the formation of the surfactant/polymer complex between SDS and Pol5nner JR. Since the reduction in vapor pressure is a colligative property and is related to the concentration of both droplets and macromolecules in solution, increasing the concentration of the surfactant/polymer complex will reduce the vapor pressure above the microemulsion surface, as seen in curve B (Figure 2). Several authors (26, 27) have proposed theoretical accounts of the cooperative linking of surfactants onto polyions based on the Zimm-Bragg Theory of helixcoil transitions in polypeptides (28). These theories are best summed up as describing a nucleation and growth mechanism between the surfactant and the polymer. If CMC added to microemulsions stabilizes the droplets, the activation energy required to break the surfactant sheath surrounding the droplets should be slightly higher than in the absence of CMC. The activation energy for microemulsions prepared with CMC in the dispersed phase demonstrates that microemulsion droplets are significantly stabilized in the presence of CMC, as shown by the vapor pressure curve in Figure 2. The activation energy was found to be 35.4 kJ/mol. This value clearly demonstrates a stabilizing effect over microemulsions prepared in pure water, where the activation energy was found to be 31.5 kJ/mol. Surfactant/polymer association ment that activation energy values for microemulsions prepared in the presence of Polymer JR were not obtained, since these systems rapidly separated. Activation energy barriers to coalescence between two stabilized w/o microemulsion droplets have been determined (3). As two droplets approach each other, the interfacial films surrounding each of the droplets begin to mix. As the monolayers mix, solvent is dispersed from the interfacial layers, causing an increase in free energy as the film becomes locally more concentrated in surfactant and cosurfactant. When such a change in composition increases the free energy, the droplets wiU be stabilized against coalescence. In systems where the dispersed phase volume was increased from 1.0 to 1.44 ml while the
1115 droplet radius was kept at 25 A, a constant amount of surfactant caused an energy change of 2kT. Systems with smaller dispersed phase volume were found to have higher energy barriers against coalescence, since the concentration of surface-active components at the interface is higher. In conclusion, the vapor pressure results discussed in this paper demonstrate that two distinct regions of vapor pressure behavior exist depending on the volume of oil in the dispersed phase. At low volume fractions of oil, homogeneous, non-interacting droplets exist. These droplets are encapsulated by a surfactant/cosurfactant sheath. At high volume fractions of oil, a dynamic equilibrium exists between the breaking and re-forming of the droplets. It has also been shown that the presence of poljnners can stabilize or destabilize the microdroplets present in solution. A microemulsion formulated with an anionic surfactant (e.g., SDS) can be stabilized by an anionic polymer (CMC) present in the continuous phase. The mechanism proposed takes into account the repulsive interactions between the surfactant and the polymer. This interaction is responsible for maintaining the surfactant at the o/w interface and enhanced droplet stability. In addition, the presence of the anionic polymer reduces the rate of droplet merging, another factor that improves droplet stability. Microemulsions formulated with an anionic surfactant (e.g., SDS) and in the presence of a cationic polymer (Polymer JR) result in destabilization of the microdroplets. Droplet destabilization in the presence of a cationic polymer is due to the formation of a polymer/surfactant complex. The formation of this complex results in the depletion of surfactant from the droplet interface. The results highUghted in this article clearly demonstrate that microemulsions can be formulated for many industrial applications. The use of microemulsion systems offers many advantages over conventional emulsions. It is left to the industrial formulator to design these systems for specific product applications.
1116 References 1 H. L. Rosano, J. L. Cavallo, D. L. Chang, J. H. Whittam. J. Soc. Cosmet., Chem. 39 (1988) 201, 2 H. L. Rosano. Journal Soc. Cosmetic Chem. 25 (1974) 609. 3 W. E. F. Gerbacia, H. L. Rosano, H. L. CoUoid and Interface Science. M. Kerker, Academic Press, New York. Vol. II (1976) 245. 4 H. L. Rosano, J. L. Cavallo, G. B. Lyons. In Microemulsion Systems. H. L. Rosano and M. Clausse, editors. Marcel Better, Inc. New York, Basel. (1987) 259-275. 5 T. F. Tadros. Structure/Performance Relationships in Surfactants. M. J. Rosen (ed).. 253rd ACS Symposium Series ACS. Washington, DC. (1984) 154. 6 W. Stoeckenius, J. H. Schulman, L. M. Prince. KoUoidZ. 169 (1960) 170. 7 K. Shinoda, H. Kunieda. KoUoidZ. 42(a) (1973) 381. 8 A. W. Adamson. J. CoUoid and Interface Sci. 39 (2) (1969) 261. 9 W. E. Gerbacia, H. L. Rosano, M. Zajac. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 53 (1976) 101. 10 M. L. Robbins. in MiceUization, Solubilization and Microemulsions. R. L. Mital, (Ed). Plenum Press. New York, vol.2 (1977) 713-753. L. E. Scriven. in MiceUization, Solubilization and Microemulsions. R. L. Mital, (Ed). Plenum Press. New York. vol. 2 (1977) 877-893. 11 H. L. Rosano, T. Lan, A. Weiss, J. H. Whittam, W. E. Gerbacia. J. Phys. Chem. 85 (1981) 468. 12 T. P. Hoar, J. H. Schulman. Nature. 152 (1943) 102. 13 J. E. Bowcott, J. H. Schulman. Z. Electro-Chem. 59(4) (1955) 283. 14 J. H. Schulman, J. H. Montague. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 92 (1961) 366. 15 W. E. Gerbacia, H. L. Rosano. Journal Colloid and Interface Sci. 44 (1973) 242. 16 H. L. Rosano, T. Lan, A. Weiss, W. E. F. Gerbacia, J. H. Whittam. Journal CoUoid and Interface Sci. 72a (2) (1979).
1117 17 J. L. Cavallo, H. L. Rosano. Journal Phys. Chem. 90 (1986) 6817. 18 A. M. Cazabat, D. Chatenay, P. Guering, W. Urback, D. Langerin. Meunier J. 19 W. D. Weatherford. Journal Dispersion Sci. Technology. 6 (1985) 467. 20 C. S. Hirtzel, R. Rajagopalan. Chem. Eng. Commun. Science Publishers, Inc. 33 (1985) 301. 21 D. H. Napper. Journal Colloid Interface Sci. 58 (1977) 2. 22 D. L. Chang, H. L. Rosano, A. E. Woodward. Langmuir 1 (1985) 669-672. 23 E. D. Goddard, T. Phillips, and R. B. Hannan. Journal Soc. Cosmet, Chem. 26 (1975) 461. 24 L.Mars. Thesis. City University of New York. 1990. 25 E. D. Goddard and R. B. Hannan. Journal CoUoid Interface Sci. 55 (1976) 73. 26 I. Satake, J. T. Yang. Biopolymers. 15 (1976) 2263. 27 G.Schwartz. Eur. Journal Biochem. 12 (1970) 442. 28 B. H. Zimm, J. K. Bragg. Journal Chem. Phys. 31 (1959) 526.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1119
Prediction of moisture barrier requirements for an effervescent single serve aspartame sweetened tablet D. Apostolopoulos ^ and R. Fusi ^ a Kraft General Foods, Technical Center, Glenview, IL 60025, USA b Kraft General Foods, Technical Center, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA Abstract Competition is forcing food companies to be more aggressive and move new products into the marketplace rapidly. Package developers to meet such time constraints often select packaging for a new product based on best guess choices. The result of such practices is usually over or underpackaging at a substantial cost to the company due to associated product failures, excessive use of packaging materials, and delayed introduction to marketplace. For moisture sensitive foods, the use of a moisture transport model can help package developers to predict the packaging requirements of such foods, avoid problems of the nature described above, and maintain packaging cost at a reasonable level. This paper demonstrates the use of such a model to identify the packaging needs of aspartame sweetened tablets and confirm a 1-year shelf-life prior to product introduction. In our study, the tablets, being an effervescent product, provided a challenge in the effort to generate moisture sorption data needed for the model. Thus, existing experimental procedures were modified and new ones developed to overcome the problems stemming from the effervescent character of the tablets included in this study. 1. INTRODUCTION An effervescent single serve aspartame sweetened tablet was developed in several fruit flavors. Tablets are going to be packed into plastic cylindrical tubes which can be carried around in a pocket or a purse and conveniently used at home, office or wherever an individual needs to prepare and enjoy a glass of refreshing beverage. Two (2) tablets can be mixed with cold water and stirred until dissolved to make up an eight ounce serving of beverage. The dissolution of the tablets in water is facilitated by stirring and some effervescent action resulting from penetration of water into the tablet where it triggers the reaction between citric acid and potassium bicarbonate to form CO2 that upon its rapid release aids in the disintegration and dissolution of the tablets. Effervescent aspartame sweetened tablets are very sensitive to moisture.
1120 Exposure to any relative humidity that may result in moisture sorption can be detrimental to their quality. For instance, moisture sorption resulting in a rise of the moisture content of the tablets above a critical level can affect dissolution, which is very important for the performance of the product during its end use by the consumer. Moisture sorbed on the surface of the tablets starts diffusing into the compressed matrix, slowly dissolving and bringing into intimate contact potassium bicarbonate and citric acid. These ingredients react to form potassium citrate and CO 2 that slowly escapes during storage and before the product has reached the consumer. Premature loss of most CO2 results in loss of the effervescent action needed to aid the disintegration and dissolution of the tablet during the preparation of the beverage, thus, rendering the product unacceptable. Furthermore, moisture sorption followed by a significant increase in the moisture content of the tablets can cause expansion and disintegration of the tablets during distribution resulting in an unacceptable product (Hine, 1987). Thus, it becomes apparent that the beverage tablets storage stability depends on control of moisture pick up from the surroundings atmosphere. The water activity of the tablets is relatively low, about 0.35 and the water vapor pressure in the surroundings atmosphere can be as high as 100%. Such difference in water vapor pressures constitutes a potential which can drive the system to equilibrium by transfer of moisture from the environment to tablets. As a result, changes occur in the moisture content of the tablets which are usually directly proportional to vapor gradient. The rate at which the moisture content of the tablets changes depends on the makeup of the product, i.e. its hygroscopicity, the temperature and the atmospheric pressure (Hall, 1991). Nevertheless, moisture transfer to the tablets without any package protection can occur so fast that the shelf-life of the tablets could turn out to be very short. In packaged tablets the changes can be relatively slower. Packaging opposes this tendency by inserting an effective "moisture barrier" between the tablets and the potential gradient. Therefore, selection and use of any package that does not provide a sufficiently effective moisture barrier would result in inadequate protection of the product and a shelf-life shorter than desired. On the other hand, selection and use of a package that provides a perfect moisture barrier i.e. glass or metal it would completely isolate the tablets from any external environment, but such packaging may be very expensive, and usually unnecessary. Given that packaging may constitute a major component of the production cost, it was thought that the best package for the tablets would be a plasticbased package that is just good enough in moisture barrier properties to retard moisture transfer to such an extent that deterioration does not occur before the product is consumed. Obviously, knowledge of the WVTR or the protection that such a plastic-based package can offer is critical in making the right package selection. Traditionally, the selection of a package is accomplished through actual storage trials. For instance, tablets in various packages under evaluation can be stored either at the expected storage conditions or under "accelerated test" conditions. The package that delivers the shelf-life desired and yet is considered to be the most economic one, obviously, should be the package of choice (Mizrahi et al., 1970).
1121 Using actual storage trials to select the appropriate package for a moisture sensitive product can be very expensive and time consuming especially if a large number of package-product combinations have been included for evaluation. Reduction of the storage trial samples to those combinations of package and product that are likely to give the desired shelf-life would simplify the task of package selection and result in substantial savings. A means for identifying viable storage trial samples is provided through the use of a moisture transport prediction model. The latter is based on equations which describe the mechanism of moisture transport through a packaging barrier and which can be used to predict the packaging protection required to keep the product within certain A^ limits for its shelf-life period. The model described above is applicable for foods deteriorating through reactions sensitive to infiltration of atmospheric moisture, and is basically making use of interrelationships among variables, such as, the slope of the product's moisture sorption isotherm, the initial and maximum allowable water contents, the water activities that correspond to those moisture contents, the surface area of the package and the permeability of the packaging material in use, to obtain the required shelf-life at minimum cost under the storage conditions evaluated (Heiss, 1978; Eichner, 1985). In other words, the moisture transport prediction model relates shelf-life to the quantity of water that has to permeate through package to render the product unacceptable, and ultimately to the permeation properties of the package. It is this link between shelf-life and the permeation properties of the package that could provide the means for estimating the moisture barrier oi' the maximum WVTR of the package to yield the shelf-life desired. This WVTR value can then be compared to literature values of packaging materials to identify candidate materials. The chosen materials are therefore already screened for barrier performance. This offers an improved procedure for new product development because the materials that ultimately are entered into test are already prime candidates. Gross over or under packaging is therefore avoided, thus, resulting in substantial reduction of the product development cost. Savings would result directly through the reduction in trials, the choice of the most cost-effective packaging, as well as, indirectly through the reduced risk of failure for product packaged in the package of the right choice. The moisture transport prediction model can also provide guidelines for product formulation that may be effective in reducing demands on the protection expected of the package and thus reduce packaging costs. As indicated earlier, information required with the moisture transport prediction model includes the moisture sorption isotherm for the product under study at the storage temperature evaluated, as well as, the maximum allowable or critical moisture content and critical relative humidity at which the product is rendered unacceptable. Determination of the moisture sorption isotherm, critical moisture content, and critical relative humidity for m i s t moisture sensitive food products can be easily carried out by using the gravimetric method (Gal, 1981; Troller and Christian, 1978; Labuza, 1983). This method requires that samples of the product are suspended over various saturated salt solutions which at a given temperature provide a wide range of relative humidities.
1122 However, the gravimetric method as described in the literature, was considered unsuitable for determination of the moisture sorption isotherm for effervescent tablets. Such tablets would equilibrate with low relative humidity environments, but at higher relative humidities they would begin to effervesce and release CO 2 that would escape in the environment, thus, interfering with the accuracy of the gravimetric method. Equally challenging, was the determination of the maximum allowable or critical moisture content and critical RH for the tablets. The increased release and loss of CO2 that occurred as the tablets were exposed to higher RH, was found to affect the dissolution of the tablets, judged to be the most critical factor in impacting the product's shelf-life. Thus, samples exposed to various RH had to be monitored for CO2 release and not just visually inspected for caking in order to determine their critical moisture content and critical RH. Thus, the objectives of this study were: i) Overcome the problems stemming from the effervescent nature of tablets and determine accurately the moisture sorption isotherm, critical moisture content, and critical RH, ii) Apply the data above to a moisture transport prediction model for selecting an optimal packaging that would be cost effective, provide adequate protection against moisture, and deliver the shelf-life desired for effervescent tablets. 2. MATERIALS AND METHODS 2.1. Production of Tablets Aspartame sweetened lemon flavored tablets included in this study were produced for experimental purposes at the General Foods technical center in Tarrytown. Production consisted of ingredient mixing, tableting, alcohol glazing, and drying (Smith et al., 1993). Ingredients, such as, citric acid (provides tartness), mannitol (aids dissolving), potassium bicarbonate (aids dissolving), aspartame (sweetener), maltodextrin (from corn), lemon juice solids, natural lemon flavor, ascorbic acid (vitamin C), titanium dioxide (for color), potassium citrate (controls acidity), yellow 5, and BHA (preserves freshness), were preweighed and thoroughly mixed under controlled humidity (<20%). About 1.3 grams of powdered mix were fed manually into a punch tablet press and compressed to about 2000 psi to form a tablet. Tablets injected from the punches were collected on a non woven wire mesh tray and subjected to alcohol glazing for about 30 seconds. Alcohol vapor adsorbed on the surface of tablet partially solubilized aspartame and citric acid which upon drying fused together to form a coating that increased the hardness of the tablet without altering its ability to dissolve. The thickness of the coating was controlled by the concentration of the alcohol in the chamber and residence time of the tablets in the glazer. The concentration of alcohol in the glazer atmosphere was maintained at 81% saturation. This was achieved with direct heating of the air at a dry bulb temperature of 39°C and also by controlling the amount of heat used to vaporize the alcohol into the glazing chamber so the wet bulb temperature was at 35°C. After alcohol glazing, tablets were dried for
1123
15 minutes at 140°F to remove residual alcohol. Drying was carried out by placing the trays containing the tablets in a drying oven equipped with air circulation and exhaust. Following a cooling period glazed tablets were tested for hardness, thickness, diameter, dissolution, taste, and final product cleanliness and then packaged. Final product hardness, dissolution, thickness, and diameter targets were as follows: hardness: 30-40 newtons, dissolution: 30 seconds, thickness: 3 mm, and diameter: 22.41 mm. After testing tablets were foil overwrapped and packed by hand into glass jars to be protected from moisture until used for the study. 2.2. Moisture Sorption Isotherm Determination
MC m^^qWhere:
^^ 100-%/MC ^ 100
CI) ^ ^
= moisture content at a given salt solution relative humidity, in percentage of dry weight. Wi = weight of sample in aluminum weighing dish before exposed to any relative humidity, in grams. W2 = weight of sample in aluminum weighing dish after equilibrated at a given salt relative humidity, in grams. %IMC = initial moisture content of sample in aluminum weighing dish before exposed to any relative humidity, (wet basis). MCeq
Three replicate determinations were made of the moisture content for each mix and relative humidity. Equation 2 was used to calculate the moisture sorption isotherm of the full formula tablet from the moisture sorption data generated experimentally for the two mixes that make up the final product.
loo
^^^ ~ Where:
MCp MCi MC2 X
^^^ = Moisture content of the final product at a given salt solution relative humidity, in percent of dry weight. = Moisture content of the full formula minus the potassium bicarbonate at a given salt solution relative humidity, in percent of dry weight. = Moisture content of the potassium bicarbonate at a given salt solution relative humidity, in percent of dry weight. = percent of potassium bicarbonate in the full formula.
A plot of the equilibrium moisture contents obtained from the above equation versus relative humidities, resulted in construction of the sorption isotherm of
1124 the tablets at 73°F. 2.3. Initial Moisture Content Determination Knowledge of the initial moisture content (IMC) for the full formula tablets, full formula mix less the potassium bicarbonate, and potassium bicarbonate itself was necessary to calculate their moisture sorption isotherms, determine their critical moisture content, and carry out the moisture barrier/packaging requirements prediction process. The IMC of the tablets and the formula mixes mentioned above was determined by using a thermal drying method. Two tablets or about 3 grams of each mix included in this study were placed in pretared aluminum weighing dishes, weighed and placed in a vacuum oven over a drying agent (CaS04). The oven was set at 70°C and 30 in Hg of vacuum. The aluminum weighing dishes containing the samples were weighed until no further weight losses were observed (5-6 hours) and the moisture losses represented by the sample weight decrease were used to calculate the initial moisture content from Equation (A.O.A.C., 1975; TroUer and Christian, 1978). IMC = ^-^ Where:
^ 100 IMC W"! W2
(3) = Initial moisture content on wet basis, in percent. = weight of sample before drying, in grams. = weight of sample after drying, in grams.
2.4. Determination of Mode of Deterioration, Critical Moisture Content, and Critical Relative Humidity. For dry products, a rise in the moisture content or water activity above a critical level can cause microbiological, chemical, as well as physical changes such as agglomeration, caking, sogginess e.t.c, which usually constitute the major modes of deterioration and render the quality of dry foods unacceptable. These levels are defined as the critical moisture content and critical water activity or relative humidity, respectively (Taoukis et al., 1988). The critical moisture level can vary depending upon the different types of deterioration. As a result, the mode of deterioration needs to be systematically investigated in order to achieve the proper clarification of the problem (Heiss and Eichner, 1971). In cases where the mode of deterioration is manifested through physical changes the critical moisture content and critical water activity or relative humidity can be easily defined during the determination of their moisture sorption isotherm obtained by using the gravimetric method. Typically, dry product samples after equilibration over different relative humidities are visually inspected for agglomeration, caking, loss of any functional properties e.g. flowability, scoopability, and textural or color changes. The lowest relative humidity where those changes start taking place is recorded as the critical relative humidity or water activity. The moisture content that corresponds to critical relative humidity and which can obtained from the moisture sorption isotherm is the critical moisture content. However, for a product, such as effervescent tablets, the mode of deterioration determined to be limiting to the product's shelf-life does not involve changes
1125 that can be observed through a visual inspection of product equilibrated to different relative humidities. Preliminary experiments indicated that tablets exposed to higher relative humidities exhibited a CO2 loss that was found to have a significant effect on tablet dissolution. Tablet dissolution times increased with loss of CO2. Thus, formation and loss of CO2 with moisture sorption was considered to be the deterioration mechanism or mode most impacting the product's shelf-life. In order to determine the critical relative humidity, the relative humidity above which the tablets exhibited unacceptable dissolution times, samples exposed to various RH had to be monitored for CO2 release and tested for dissolution. 2.5. Monitoring of Carbon Dioxide Formation Four (4) tablets were placed in aluminum weighing dishes and suspended over salt solutions prepared and held in hermetically sealed half a quart Mason jars which were kept in environmental control chambers set at 73°F. The relative humidities of the salt solutions used ranged from 6% to 80%. Through a sampling port installed on the lids of the Mason jars and using a gas-tight syringe, periodically for about four weeks 1 ml headspace aliquots were withdrawn from the Mason jars and injected into a 3700 Varian gas chromatograph set up for CO2 analysis. The gas chromatograph was equipped with a thermal conductivity detector (TCD), a 6' x 1/4" CTR I chromatographic column, and a data-logger based on an IBM PC used with a Labtech Notebook data acquisition software. The gas chromatograph operation conditions were as follows: column temperature 25°C, injection port temperature: 40°C, detector temperature: 80°C, filament current: 157 ma, and carrier gas-helium-flow rate: 65cc/min. The percentage of CO 2 in the analyzed headspace aliquots was calculated by reference to a calibration curve constructed by injecting standards of known CO2 concentrations. 2.6. Dissolution Test Five (5) tablets were placed in aluminum weighing dishes and suspended over salt solutions held in half a quart Mason jars kept at 73°F. The relative humidities of the salt solutions ranged from 8% to 80%. During the 4 week period of sample equilibration, tablets exposed to various relative humidities were taken out of the Mason jars and tested for dissolution. Each tablet was dropped into a cup containing 120 ml distilled water at room temperature (73°F). Stirring of the water was initiated 10 seconds later and continued until the tablet was completely dissolved. The time required for dissolving the tablet was recordered as dissolution time. 2.7. Prediction of the Moisture Barrier/Package Requirements. As shown by Heiss (1958), Karel (1967), Heiss and Eichner, (1972), prediction of the shelf-life or determination of the moisture barrier/packaging requirements for moisture sensitive foods, such as the tablets, requires accurate knowledge of the rate of transport of water vapor across the packaging barrier. The moisture transport through the packaging barrier is described by a pseudo-steady state equation based on Fick's and Henry's laws.
1126
^
=
k/l^A{P,,,-P,,)
Where:
(4)
- rate of water vapor transport per day = permeance to moisture for packaging (g/day m2 mm Hg) A = package area (m2) Pin, Pout = water vapor partial pressure inside and outside the package, respectively (mm Hg) dw Idt kll
The equation above was converted to Equation 5, which contains expressions that can be obtained experimentally and conviniently applied to determine the shelf-life for a dry product in a package of a given moisture barrier. t=
(w,,-w,,) WVTR{%RH,,,-%RH,,)
w = ^^ cr
Where:
(5)
(6)
100
Wdr=Wi,,-
100
Wi,-%IMC 100
(7)
= the product oikll-A in Equation 4, which is the water vapor transmission rate for the package to deliver the shelf-life desired, grams of water per package and day. t - target shelf-life, in days. Wdr = weight of dry product in the package at the time of packaging, in grams. Wcr = weight of packaged product equilibrated at the critical relative humidity. ^in - weight of packaged product with a moisture content equal to the initial moisture content the product exhibited at the time of packaging, in grams. MCcr = critical moisture content or moisture content of product after equilibrated at the critical relative humidity, in percent. %RHout = storage relative humidity %RHin = relative humidity inside the package right after packaging as a result of the initial moisture content of the product WVTR
Experimental data obtained on the initial moisture content, critical relative humidity, and moisture sorption of the tablets, as well as other information pertinent to the storage conditions provided all the parameters needed to be applied by a computer program to Equation 5 to determine what should be the WVTR of the package that would ensure delivery of the desired shelf-life (Heiss and Eichner, 1971).
1127 Several basic assumptions must be made to predict the packaging requirements of the tablets using Equation 5. The first assumption was that the moisture rapidly equilibrates within the package; this has been found to hold true (Hendel et al., 1958; Heiss, 1958). In other words, it was assumed that the controlling mechanism is the moisture transport through the package, the resistance of moisture vapor diffusion into food being relatively negligible. Other assumptions were that the storage conditions, temperature and % RH remained constant, (which is not necessary correct,) and the moisture sorption isotherm is linear between the initial moisture content and the moisture content at the critical relative humidity (Labuza, 1982). However, what was considered to most affect the accuracy of the outcome resulting from the solution of Equation 5 is the fact that the inside package vapor pressure Pin is not constant but rather increases as the product gains moisture. Thus, there is no constant driving force; rather the driving force decreases with time, slowing down moisture gain. Using a constant-driving force assumption leads to overprediction of moisture exchange and thus to overprotection as well as increased costs (Karel and Labuza, 1969). In order to minimize the error introduced by the decrease of the driving force over time, an analytical solution was applied to Equation 5. The sorption isotherm between the initial moisture content and the critical moisture content was divided graphically into small linear segments. Water vapor partial pressure, (Pin) or relative humidity, (RHin) inside the package corresponding to the start of each linear segment was determined from the moisture sorption isotherm. Then Equation 5 was applied separately for each individual segment to determine the time interval required for the moisture that permeates through the package to be adsorbed by the product and move the moisture content of the product along each individual segment. The time intervals corresponding to those linear sorption isotherm segments were summed up to calculate shelf-life for a given WVTR. Then the shelf-life value obtained was substituted for the target shelf-life value and Equation 5 was solved for WVTR to determine what must be the WVTR for the package that would deliver the target shelf-life. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The initial moisture content for lemon flavored tablets, mix without potassium bicarbonate, and potassium bicarbonate itself are given in the table below. Table 1 Initial moisture content for lemon flavored tablets and mix variables Product Lemon Flavored Tablets Lemon Flavored Mix Less the Potassium Bicarbonate Potassium Bicarbonate
Initial Moisture Content-Wet Basis, (%) 1.70 ± 0.06 1.41 ± 0.07 0.046 ± 0.009
1128 The moisture sorption isotherms obtained experimentally for the mix less the potassium bicarbonate, as well as the potassium bicarbonate itself, are presented graphically in Figures 1 and 2, respectively. The moisture sorption isotherm as calculated for the tablets is shown in Figure 3.
20 40 60 80 Relative Humidity, (%)
100
Figure 1. Moisture/ sorption isotherm for lemonflaX^oredtablets total mix less the potassium bicarbonate at 73°F.
I"
" r"
r
20 40 60 80 Relative Humidity, (%)
100
Figure 2. Moisture sorption isotherm for potassium bicarbonate at 73°F.
As seen from the graph of Fig. 3, tablets exposed to various RH absorbed very little moisture up to about 45% RH. Moisture sorption started increasing gradually over the 45-65% RH range, and it rose sharply as RH increased above 75%. Figures 4 and 5 show the effect of moisture sorption over different RH on the formation of CO2 and the dissolution time of the tablets. Carbon dioxide started forming in significant amounts at 48.6% RH. The dissolution time was shown to be increasing over the lower RH range, 10-20%, and above 43.9%. The reason that dissolution time increased over the lower RH range is because tablets exposed to such very low RH overdried and hardened, therefore, it was difficult for water to penetrate the matrix. The average of the above two RH (48.6% and 43.9%) was selected as the critical RH or the RH above "1 \ r which the tablets are expected to 100 20 40 60 80 exhibit dissolution times greater Relative Humidity, (%) t h a n 30 seconds, something t h a t perceivably would render the prodFigure 3. Moisture sorption isouct unacceptable by the consumer therm for lemon flavored tablets at (see Table 2). 73'^F.
1129
I - "* r 40 60 Relative Humidity, (%)
r
80
100
Figure 4. Evolution of carbon dioxide with time for lemon flavored tablets over various RH at 73°F. 300250o
-e—Ohrs -B- - 75hrs ^ - - 175 hrs -X- - 530 hrs
200H
150X
lOOH
/
50-
/
0
/
—e—e—o
e-e-n 10
o
\ \ 1 20 30 40 Relative Humidity, (%)
\— 50
60
Figure 5. Dissolution of lemon flavored tablets exposed over time to various RH at 73°F.
1130 This data suggests that packaged tablets should not see RH that exceed 46.25% and moisture content should remain lower than 2.87%, in order for them to exhibit an acceptable dissolution (dissolution time of about 30 seconds) upon use by the consumer. Table 2 Critical relative humidity and critical moisture content for lemon flavored tablets at 73°F. Critical Relative Humidity, (%)
Critical Moisture Content-Dry Basis, (%)
46.25
2.87
Table 3 below provides a summary of the moisture barrier/packaging requirements as predicted for 10 single-serving portions or a number of 20 tables (total product weight: 25.56 grams), a target shelf-life of 1 year, and a range of storage conditions representing a temperate climate (73°F/50%-70% RH). Table 3 Moisture barrier requirements for lemon flavored tablets Target Shelf-Life
Storage Conditions
Package WVTR (grams/package.day)
12 Months
73°F/50%RH 73°F/60%RH 73°F/70%RH
0.016 0.005 0.003
As indicated by data presented in Table 3, the package i.e. a tablet holder tube intended for packaging of tablets should have a WVTR of 0.003 grms/day or lower in order to ensure a 1-year shelf-life under the storage conditions selected. Information such as the above is vital in terms of helping the package developer to select and develop the appropriate package for effervescent tablets. For instance, since such a low WVTR can be provided only by packaging materials with very good moisture barrier characteristics, such as high density polyethylene, (HDPE), which may be the packaging material of choice. Thus, with this in mind the package developer now can proceed with the development, for example, of HDPE tubes (and a suitable plug closure), sufficient in size to accommodate 20 tablets. Developed prototypes can be tested for moisture permeation to determine their W\^Ti?. A comparison of the measured WVTR to WVTR predicted would indicate whether the HDPE tube as designed would provide adequate protection for the tablets or whether adjustments need to be made on the wall thickness to match the protection required.
1131 An optimal wall thickness which can be achieved through downgauging or upgauging of the wall thickness of the prototype tubes would ensure the protection needed at minimal cost. 4. REFERENCES A.O.A.C. 1975. "Methods of Analysis", 11th ed. Assoc. Off. Anal. Cem., Washington, D.C. Bone, D.P. 1987. Practical applications of water activity and moisture relations in foods. In "Water Activity: Theory and Applications to Food", L.B. Rockland and L.R. Beuchat (Ed.), p.369. Marcel Dekker, Inc.New York and Basel. Eihner, K. 1985. The influence of water content and water activity on chemical changes in foods of low moisture content under packaging aspects. In"Food Packaging and Preservation", M. Mathlouthi (Ed.), p.67, Elsevier Applied Science Publishers. Gal, S. 1981. Recent advances in techniques for obtaining complete sorption isotherms. In "Water Activity: Influences on Food Quality", L.B. Rockland and G.F. Stewart (Ed.), p.89. Academic Press. Hall, J. 1991. Food product shelf-life. How long before it's gone? Medallion Laboratories Analytical Progress 8(1): 1. Hendel, C.E., Legault, R., Talburt, N.F., Burr, H.K., and Wilke, C.R. 1958. Water vapor transfer in the in-package desiccation of dehydrated foods. In "Fundamental Aspects of the Dehydration of Foodstuffs", p.89, Soc. Chem. Ind., Metchium & Son, Ltd, London. Heiss, R. 1958. Shelf-life determination. Modern Packaging 31(8):119. Heiss, R. and Eichner, K. 1971. Moisture content and shelf-life; Part 1, Food Manufacture, 46(5):53. Heiss, R. and Eichner, K. 1971. Moisture content and shelf-life; Part 2, Food Manufacture, 46(6):37. Hine, D.J. (1987). Shelf-life prediction. In "Modern Processing, Packaging and Distribution Systems for Food", F.A. Paine (Ed.), p.62, AVI, New York. Karel, M. 1967. Use tests-only real way to determine effect of package on food quality. Food in Canada 27:43. Karel, M. and Labuza, T. P. 1969. Optimization of protective packaging of space foods. U.S. Air Force contract F-43-609-68-C-0015. Aerospace Space Med. School, San Antonio, Texas. Labuza, T. 1982. Moisture gain and loss in packaged foods. Food Tech., April 1982, p.92. Labuza, T. 1983. Standard procedure for isotherm determination, Food Research, 28(4):258. Marsh, k. 1985. Computer-aided shelf-life prediction. In "Mastering Today's Packaging Needs", TAPPI PRESS, p.43. Marsh, K.S., Ambrosio, T. and Morton, D.K. 1988. Stability evaluation of a dynamic system. J. Packaging Tech., 2(6):260.
1132 Mizrahi, S., Labuza, T.P. and Karel, M. 1970. Computer-aided predictions of extent of browning in dehydrated cabbage. J. Food Sci., 35:800. Smith, S.L., Jackson, R.R., Albaum, J.D., Fusi, R.W., and Doherty, S.S. 1993. Process for beverage tablets and products therefrom. United States Patent, Patent Number: 5,254,355. Taoukis, P.S., Meskine, A.EL, and Labuza, T.P. 1988. Moisture transfer and shelf life of packaged foods. In " Food and Packaging Interactions", J.H. Hotchkiss (Ed.), p.243, Amer. Chem. Soc, Washington, DC. TroUer, A. J. and Christian, H.B. J. 1978. Methods. In "Water Activity and Food", J.A. Troller and J.H.B. Christian (Ed.), p.l2, Academic Press.
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1133
Comparing The Rates Of Development Of Temperature Distributions In Foods Shaped as Spheres, Cylinders and Thick Films. Arthur E. Grosser Department of Chemistry, MoGill University, 801 Sherbrooke St., W., Montreal, Quebec, H3A 2K6, Canada Abstract The rates of development of the thermal distributions that arise in heated foods are given by equations that do not lend themselves to simple computation. Nor do they make evident how the physical and thermal properties of the food control the process. The systems considered are foods of different geometries which are heated from ambient temperature by immersion in a heat bath. The half-heating time is the time necessary for the temperature at a given position in the food to increase by one-half the difference between bath and ambient temperatures. Using this quantity leads to simple relations which aid in estimating these distributions, the rate at which they develop, and how they depend on the properties of the material and the experimental variables. These expressions are compared to codify this method for spheres, cylinders and thick films, and it is found that one equation will describe the behavior of all these systems.
1. INTRODUCTION Foods that are heated from ambient temperature develop thermal gradients that determine the heat transfer through them and drive the rate constants for the chemical transformations. This may also be important for the packaging material if it is sufficiently thick relative to the food and not chemically inert. It is crucial to food chemistry to be able to calculate these gradients and the rates at which they develop. Unfortunately, the heat flow equations are of sufficient
1134 complexity that it is difficult to estimate these rates, even in a semiquantitative manner. Moreover, it is not apparent how the properties of the food (e.g., its size and geometry, heat conductivity and heat capacity) and the experimental variables (the initial ambient temperature of the food and the bath temperature) are related to these rates. Although useful approximations do exist for this problem [1,2], they do not present the food chemist with a transparent view of the process. The half-heating time offers a way to find this information in a relatively simple manner. We will present these results and show that a comparison of the expressions for various geometries leads to a one master equation valid for all cases over a wide range of conditions.
2. MODELS For the purposes of these models the object will be assumed to be of uniform composition with a thermal diffusivity, K, equal to k/pcp, k being the thermal conductivity and pcp the volumetric heat capacity, composed of p, the density, and Cp, the specific heat (or heat capacity per unit mass). The thermal diffusivity is assumed to be constant, and the surface heat transfer coefficient is assumed to be infinite. The food system is initially at a uniform ambient temperature, Ta, and at time, t, equal to zero, is placed in an infinite heat bath of temperature, Tb- The term (Tb- Ta) is denoted by AT. a.
Spherical Foods:
For a sphere of radius, a, the heat flow equations yield [3] the equation for the temperature, T(r,t), at a radial distance, r, and time, t: [T(r,t)-Ta]/AT = 1 + ( 2 a / j c r ) 2 { { - 1 ) " / nHsln(nJtr / a)}exp(-Kn^jt^t / a^) n=i
(1)
1135 b.
Cylindrical Foods:
Similarly, for an infinite cylinder of outer radius a, the heat flow equations [4] yield the equation for the temperature, T{r,t), at the radius, r, and time, t: [T(r,t)-T3]/AT=12 2 {exp(-Kp„2t/a2)}xJ^(p„r/a)/[PnJi(p„)l n=1
(2)
where Jo and J i are the zero-order and first-order Bessel functions, respectively, and Pn is the nth root of the zero-order Bessel functions.
c.
Thick Films:
For an infinite thick film of thickness 2a, the equation [5] for the temperature, T(r, t), at the distance from the center of the film, r, and the time, t, is: I T ( r , t ) - T a ] / AT =1 00
( 4 / Jl)
2 { { ( - 1 ) " / ( 2 n + 1 ) } { e x p [ - ( 2 n + 1 ) ^ r ^ K t / 4a^l}x n=0 {cos[(2n + 1)Jtr/ 2 a l } }
(3)
(For a model heated only on one side, with the other side held at Ta, 2a is replaced by a and the origin of r is at the side held at Ta.) An example of the relative behavior of these three systems is shown in Figure 1 below which displays the temperature rise for food samples of the three geometries with the same values of the physical properties, as given in the Figure caption.. The
half-heating
time,
T i / 2,
is the
time
at
which
temperature difference between the object and its surroundings the initial temperature difference, Tb-Ta-
the
is half
1136 200
That is, at T i / 2 r
sphere
r
20
?/ /
/ ^ /•^/
/
^.^""'"""^cyl
T ( r . T i / 2 ) - T a = 0.5(Tb-Ta)
^ _ ™ " - ™ -
^
-^ ^
1 1
'C^1r" 1 1
v-^"'"^
r
X
^,.- •-" film
In
Figure
1
at
left,
the
vertical arrows indicate the
_^,:^-"~
half-heating
__,„"
times
for
the
three cases.
i^^^
_
^
t, min
L_^
20
Figure 1. Temperature (^C) from exact computation (equations 1, 2 and 3) vs. time (min.) for the three geometries. Ta = 20^0, Tb = 200OC, K= 0.0020 cm^/min., a = 1.0 cm and r = 0.5 cm.
3. HALF-HEATING TIME APPROXIMATIONS The half-heating time equation for spheres is found to be [6] X | / 2(sphere)
=
( a ^ / 3r^K)[ln4 -7?T^ I 6 a ^ l
(4)
Similarly, the half-heating time equation for infinite cylinders is [7]: Xx/ 2 ( c y n n d e r )
=
( a ^ / K)[0.20133 - ( r ^ / 4 a ^ ) l
(5)
and that for thick films is [8]: X,/ 2(film)
=
( 4 a ^ / 3t^K)[ln(8/ n) - j c ^ r ^ / 8a^]
(6)
These equations may be more easily compared by using the
reduced
distance, a, defined as a = r/a.
position
dependence of T1/2
This allows us to plot
on one set of axes, as shown below.
the
1137 20
f
1 1/2,1
min
M
film
V
cyl
1 •"" •^ • ^+ k
The relative behavior of the half-heating times as a function of the reduced distance, a, is shown in Figure 2 at left.
'K
•
sphere
+ •
+
M
•
—i
0
a
t
__*
1
Figure 2. T i /2(nnin.) from equations 4, 5 and 6 vs. o for the models in Figure 1
4. COMPARISON OF HEATING TIMES BY GEOMETRY All the half-heating time equations can be put in the form
^1/2 = {a2/K)[B - Ca2]
(7)
where Table 1 below indicates the values of the B and C terms. geometry
B
sphere cylinder film
0.140461 0.20133 0.378824
c = (In4)/Jt2 = ln(1.223) = 4ln(8/3i) /3i2
1/6 1/4 1/2
Table 1. Values of the B and C terms for the three geometries. The most important consequence of this set of equations is the prediction of a linear dependencies of the half-heating time on o^, on a2, and on 1/K, Figure 3, below, shows a test of the first of these relations.
1138
.film ''1/2,
Figure 3. Ti / 2 (min.) from equations 4,5 and 6 vs. a2 for the same models as the previous Figures.
•s
''++cyl + + — • • sphere , 0 0
min
K
+
+
*
•
J
t It
a
1
As shown in references 6-8, these equations are accurate at all but the highest values of a, that is, at all regions away from the periphery of the food. They may be (conservatively) estimated to be valid when the reduced distance, a, defined as a = r/a, is less than or equal to 0.8. The largest errors will arise from the assumptions that K i s constant and the surface heat transfer coefficient is infinite.
5. DISCUSSION A way of analyzing the meaning of these equations is to define a2/K as the "response time", tr- The response time gives the Inherent time for the food's center to rise in temperature in response to a heat input. The reciprocal of tr is thus the speed with which a food characterized by the thermal diffusivity, K , and the dimension, a, shows such a temperature rise. The half heating time equations can therefore a l l be represented by tl/2
= tr[B - Ca2]
(8)
In this form, T 1 / 2 can be seen to be the manner by which the response time, t r , is modified by two factors.
The geometry of the food
1139 is reflected in the B term, while the C term gives the sensitivity of tr to the position In the food at which the temperature is measured. We may now ask if the quantitative value of these terms are reasonable. Taking the sphere as our reference geometry, we can compare the relatives values of these terms, as shown in Table 2.
B/B(sphere)
C/C(sphere)
1.000 1.436 2.707
1.0 1.5 3.0
geometry sphere cylinder [film
Table 2 Values of the B and C terms for three geometries, divided by the values for B and C for spherical geometry, respectively. It is, of course, clear that the sphere is the quickest, and the film the slowest to be cooked. The regularity in the variation of the C terms is intriguing. zero there. time
T1/2
At the center of the food
Is trB, since a is
As the measurement point moves outwards the
decreases,
but
much
more
sensitively
for
the
half-heating
film
than
cylinder, which In turn is more sensitive than the sphere.
the
But one
should be cautious in trying to rationalize the relative values of the B and C coefficients because the film and cylinder are "infinite" bodies, while the sphere is not. To determine the
regions of
validity
of these
equations
it i s
useful to use the limiting condition that T 1 / 2 must go to zero as a nears
unity:
instantaneously.
the
temperature
at
the
periphery
rises
almost
Our approximations are not valid at such large values
of a, for they predict
X-\ / 2 equal to zero at
B= Co^.
This gives an
upper limit to the range of validity of these expressions, namely, 0 ^ a ^ a c r i t i c a l . where Ocritical ^ critical
are
slightly
0.879, and 0.870 for
different
is given by (BIC)^f^. for
sphere, cylinder
always greater than 0.8.
each
of
the
and film,
The values of
geometries
respectively)
(0.918, but are
1140 Indeed, when we examine the ratios of the B and C constants it is evident that they must run in rough parallel or the a critical values w i l l not lie so close together. This can be seen in Figure 3 which shows the half-heating times going to zero at roughly the same values of a^. In conclusion, one equation serves to give accurate half-heating times for a variety of foods of simple geometry
5. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author thanks the Vernon W. Krieble Foundation Department of Chemistry for their generous support.
and
the
6. REFERENCES 1. I. J. Pflug, J. L Blaisdell and J. Kopelman, "Developing TimeTemperature Curves for Objects That Can Be Approximated by a Sphere, Infinite Plate, or Infinite Cylinder", ASHRAE Trans., 71(1), 1965, 238-248. 2. Ramaswamy, H. S. Lo, K.V. and A. Tung, "Simplified Equations f o r Transient Temperatures in Conductive Foods with Convective Heat Transfer at the Surface", J. Food Sci.. 47, 2042-2047. 3. H. S. Carslaw and J. C Jaeger, Conduction of Heat in Solids, 2nd ed., Oxford,London, 1959, 233. 4. ibid., 199. 5. ibid., 100. 6. A. E. Grosser, "Approximation Method for Thermal Gradients in Spherical Objects", J. Thermophyslcs and Heat Transfer, 7, (1993) 536-538. 7. A. E. Grosser, "Approximation Method for Rate of Appearance of Temperature Distributions in Cylindrical Foods", J. Food and Agricultural Chem., 42, (1994) 166-168. 8. A. E. Grosser and Sophie M. K. Brunet, "Approximation Method For Rate Of Appearance Of Temperature Distributions In Thick Films", Food Control (in press, 1994).
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1141
Effect of oxygen on the ethyl acetate production from continuous ethanol stream by Candida utilis in submerged cultures G. Corzo% S. Revah^ and P. Christen^ ^Dpto de Ingenieria de Procesos, Universidad Autonoma Metropolitana Iztapalapa, Apdo Postal 55-534, CP 09340, Mexico D.F., MEXICO. ^ ORSTOM (Institut Frangais de Recherche Scientifique pour le Developpement en Cooperation), Ciceron 609, Col. Los Morales, CP 11530, Mexico D.F., MEXICO. Abstract. The purpose of this work was to compare ethyl acetate production by C. utilis at different oxygen concentrations in an iron free medium. The study was achieved in a batch stirred tank reactor and gaseous ethanol was fed continuously in the air stream. The acetaldehyde production as well as the cell growth were increased when oxygen level was maintained between 5% and 15 % rather than 0% and 2%. It was also found that the ethyl acetate maximum concentration was inferior (5.1 g/l against 8.0 g/1) at higher oxygen levels but with a higher productivity (0.1 g/l.h) in that case. Finally, ethyl acetate and acetaldehyde productions were found to be directly dependent on the growth phase in both cases.
D^RODUCTION Since the end of the seventies, there has been an increased interest in the use of flavors that can be labeled as "natural" in the food industry. This trend has motivated research to look for new sources of these products. Among the alternatives are the production from plant tissue cultures [1], the enzymatic generation of flavor either by adding new enzymes or by using the native system of the substrate [2] or by generating de novo compounds from microorganisms [3]. In Europe, as in the USA, the natural flavoring substances are those obtained by appropriate physical process or enzymatic or microbiological processes from material of vegetable or animal origin [4]. Products, including food ingredients - such as flavor compounds - must obtain the GRAS (generally recognized as safe) status; which is the case for most of the biotechnological products likely to be used in the food industry. The list of microorganisms that can produce flavors or flavor enhancers is broad [3], and there are already a great number of processes successfully applied in the industry [5]. While microorganisms have a definite role in the production of the typical flavors in fermented foods, fewer are the cases where the microorganisms generate these flavors under controlled conditions to optimize the production of the flavoring agent. Nevertheless, some examples can be found for bacteria (e.g. Streptococcus lactis subsp. diacetylactis for diacetyl [6], Zymomonas mobilis for acetaldehyde [7], Pseudomonas fragi for strawberry flavor due to C4-C6 ethyl
1142 esters [8]), yeasts (e.g. Yarrowia lipolytica for 4-decalactone [9]) or molds (e.g. Penicillium roqueforti for ketones [10] or lactones [11], Ceratocystis fimbriata for banana-like aroma [12]). The role of yeasts, such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae, in the formation of secondary aromas in the alcoholic fermentation must be considered: fusel oils [13], acylated amines [14] or esters [15]. Among the diversity of flavoring compounds secreted by yeasts, acetaldehyde and ethyl acetate are of relevance as additives in the food industry. The former delivers a fresh or fruity flavor to food such as fruits, bread, vegetables, dairy products and candies. It is also known to be highly reactive and is used to produce chemicals such as acetic acid, ethyl acetate, butanol,...[16]. The latter, characterized by a fruity note, is present in almost all the fruits and used in ice creams, candies, baked goods or chewing gums [16]. Both are listed as GRAS by the US Food & Drug Administration and their annual consumption as flavoring agent, in the U.S. in 1987, was about 147 and 14 tons, respectively [17]. Although ester production by microorganisms was recognized since the beginning of the century, it was until the fifties that the formation of these compounds by yeasts was studied with special interest in ethyl acetate. Works with Hansenula and Pichia strains [18,19] grown on glucose demonstrated that ethyl acetate formation was due to the aerobic utilization of the ethanol formed. It was also shown that acetaldehyde and acetic acid were also produced and it was suggested t h a t the ester formation had a survival value for the yeasts by preventing the accumulation of toxic amounts of free acetic acid. For the cases of Hansenula mrakii and Geotrichum penicillatum, it was shown that not only ethyl acetate was formed but also other acetate esters, such as isobutyl, isopentyl or 2methylbutyl acetates from the alcohols formed from deamination and decarboxylation of amino acids [3,20]. Nevertheless the mechanism of ethyl acetate formation seems to be different from the other esters because it is produced in the growth phase while the other esters are formed in the stationary phase. In this phase the microorganisms are also able to convert added alcohols and carboxylic acids into esters. The authors pointed out that a clear diauxic effect was observed when glucose was exhausted in H. mrakii cultures [21]. Another yeast, Kluyveromyces fragilis, showed its ability to produce ethyl acetate from whey permeate but only if lactose and ethanol are both present in the broth [22,23]. The levels of dissolved oxygen were shown to have a primordial importance on the orientation of the metabolism [23]. Ester formation (specially ethyl and isoamyl acetates) has been also thoroughly studied in the alcoholic fermentation with Saccharomyces cerevisiae [24,25]. The membrane bound enzyme alcohol acetyl transferase has been suggested to produce the ethyl acetate [26]. S. cerevisiae fermentation produces also acetaldehyde which is very important due to its low sensory threshold value. Saccharomyces rouxii, used in the soy-sauce fermentation, is also known for producing ethyl acetate [27]. In that case, the yeast was found to produce large amounts of the ester from glucose and added ethanol (conversion yield about 16 %) but showed a poor ability to produce it from ethanol alone. An inhibitory effect of sodium chloride was established. The yeast Candida utilis has been shown to produce ethyl acetate and acetaldehyde from ethanol as sole carbon source [28-30]. The production of the volatiles was shown to be dependent on lack of iron in the medium. It has been
1143 suggested that this limitation inhibits the TCA cycle thus causing an accumulation of acetyl-CoA which, through an alcohol acetyl transferase, produces the ethyl acetate. Similar observations were made with C. pseudotropicalis, but inferior ethyl acetate concentrations were reached [31]. The ester is mainly formed when there are low ethanol concentrations in the medium. This has led some authors to propose that this transformation may be used as an alternative method to treat dilute ethanol streams such as those obtained in brewing [29]. When the alcohol concentration was increased in the medium beyond 35 g/1, the metabolism of the yeast shifts to produce acetaldehyde. Rapid accumulation of acetaldehyde may inhibit acetyl-CoA formation thus reducing the production of ethyl acetate. Acetaldehyde can be further oxidized to acetic acid which may in turn reduce the yeast activity by lowering the pH. As any production of microbial metabolites, ethyl acetate and acetaldehyde formation is strongly dependent on the environmental conditions. For <S. cerevisiae ethyl acetate formation is strongly reduced when maltose concentration is high in the wort [24]. Oxygen has shown to be very important since the earlier studies [18,19] which showed that ethyl acetate was only formed when the culture was aerobic. Aeration rate plays a very important role as it is directly linked to oxygen availability on the medium which, in turn, influences growth and ethyl acetate yields in H. anomala [32] and in C. utilis [29]. On the other hand both studies showed t h a t higher aeration rates bring about a reduction in ethyl acetate concentration in the medium, but this effect could be attributed to stripping. The pH is another important parameter for ethyl acetate production hyJL^ anomala [19] where acidic pH was studied and for C utilis where neutral pH was more suitable for acetaldehyde production [28]. For ethyl acetate production, a pH between 5.0 and 7.0 is preferred although values above 6.0 favor acetate formation [29]. The pH has shown to have an influence in the ethanol oxidation by C. utilis yeasts [33] where at a pH of 4.2, maximum respiration rates are observed. Besides the experiments for the production of volatile compounds by viable yeast cells, recent reports have shown other biotechnological possibilities. Ethanol has been converted into acetaldehyde by resting cells of Pichia pastoris [34,35] in a semi-batch fermenter with added ethanol in air. Also, dried Hansenula polymorpha cells have been tried in a gas solid bioreactor to transform gaseous ethanol into acetaldehyde [36]. Continuous conversions were achieved under a reduced water content (about 8%). In previous works, the culture of C utilis on solid supports was successfully achieved with glucose or partially hydrolyzed starch [37] or gaseous ethanol [38] as sole carbon sources. A particular attention was given on the kinetic parameters and a diauxic growth was shown as also observed by other authors for H. anomala. A clear limitation on growth was observed when low nitrogen concentration was used [38]. The aim of the present work was to study the effect on oxygen levels on growth and metabolites accumulation by C. utilis, in submerged cultures, when gaseous ethanol was fed as sole carbon source.
1144 MATERIAL AND METHODS Microorganism and culture medium Candida utilis ATCC 9950 was used throughout this study. It was grown on Potato Dextrose Agar slants for 3 days at 30°C and then maintained at 6°C. To prepare the inoculum, it was grown in 50 ml of dextrose (20 g/1) and malt extract (20 g/1) medium in 150 ml Erlenmeyer flask with continuous shaking at 200 rpm at 30°C. The yeast was then grown on the iron free minimal salts medium previously described by Thomas and Dawson [39] which has been already used in various studies [28,29,37]. Fermentation conditions Fermentation experiments were run in a 3 1 Bioflo III fermenter (New Brunswick, USA). To avoid evaporation of ethanol and other volatile products, a condenser fed continuously with a refrigerant at -10°C was installed at the gas exit of the fermenter. Culture volume was 2.2 1 and temperature was 30°C. The pH was maintained at 6.0 with NaOH 0.5 IM. Inoculum size was 10% to give an initial concentration of 1x10^ cells/1 and initial ethanol concentration was fixed to 3.0 g/1. Air was fed at a rate of 24 1/h (0.2 vvm) and agitation was controlled to keep dissolved oxygen levels in the vessel at levels below 3% for experiment 1 (Exp. 1) and between 5 and 15% for experiment 2 (Exp. 2). Agitation varjdng from 200 to 500 rpm for Exp. 1 and up to 600 rpm for Exp. 2 were required. Ammonium sulfate concentration was 2.5 g/1 in Exp.l and reduced to half in Exp.2 to limit yeast growth in the culture. Once the initial lag phase was finishing, ethanol was fed in the vapor form continuously by bubbling the incoming air through a flask containing liquid ethanol. Aeration was made with an appropriate flow to keep ethanol concentration in the fermenter below 25 g/1. This concentration was selected because it has been reported that ethanol concentrations above 25 g/1 favor acetaldehyde production over ethyl acetate production [29] and a strong decrease of respiratory quotient (q02) was observed for ethanol levels up to 30 g/1 [33]. Added ethanol in both experiments is represented in Figure 1. Analytical methods Total biomass was determined by dry weight method. Results are expressed as g/1. Cell mortality was determined by methylene blue coloring method and cell count in a Neubauer chamber and was expressed as % of total population [37] . Total acid production was related to the added NaOH required to regulate pH to 6. Ethanol, ethyl acetate and acetaldehyde in the broth were determined by gas c h r o m a t o g r a p h y . The analysis was made with a 5890 Hewlett-Packard chromatograph equipped with a flame ionization detector. Nitrogen was used as carrier gas at a rate of 4 ml/mn. Split ratio was 1:50. Temperature were: injector and detector, 180°C; oven, 40°C. Separation was achieved with a Megabore HP-1 column (Length, 5m; Inner diameter, 0.53 mm). Concentrations were reported as g/1. Respirometry (02 and C02 measurements) was realized with a Gow-lMac chromatograph equipped with a thermal conductivity detector and a concentric column CTR-1 (Alltech, USA). Helium was used as carrier gas (flow rate, 60 ml/mn). Carbon dioxide production rate (CDPR), oxygen uptake rate (OUR) were expressed in mmol C02 produced (or 02 consumed) / h. 1 reactor. Respiratory quotient (R.Q.) was calculated as follows : RQ = CDPR/OUR.
1145 Acetic acid and other organic compounds were determined by liquid chromatography using a 1081 Hewlett Packard chromatograph equipped with an UV detector (X= 210 nm). Separation was achieved with an Aminex HPX 87H column (Bio-Rad, USA). Oven temperature was 65 °C and 6 mmolar sulfuric acid was used as eluent at a rate of 0.8 ml/mn.
200 r
• Experiment 1
12
24
36 48 Time (h)
84
Figure 1. Added ethanol profiles for both experiments. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Figures 2a (Exp. 1) and 2b (Exp. 2) show the evolution of biomass, its mortality and the actual ethanol concentrations in the medium for both experiments. It can be seen that dissolved oxygen has an influence on the duration of the lag phase. The yeast needed only 12 hours in Exp. 2 to begin to grow on ethanol against more than 24 hours in Exp. 1, in this case dissolved oxygen was less than 2% since the 6th. hour. Growth stopped in Exp. 2 at 48 hours as a result of the limitation in the nitrogen source with a maximum value reached of about 10 g/1, this value was attained when ethanol concentration was 15 g/1. Further accumulation in this case was due to the input through the gas phase. In Exp. 1, no limitation was observed up to the final time and the biomass reached more than 18 g/1 under similar ethanol concentrations than Exp. 2. For Exp. 1, yeast mortality was 20% up to the 66th hour and then increased to reach 50% at the end of the fermentation. This augmentation corresponds to the second feed in ethanol (hour 62). Mortality was more important for Exp. 2 where it was 50% until the 50th hour and reached a value of 85% at the end. This was probably due to the increase in ethanol concentration and the accumulation of acidic compounds and acetaldehyde (see Figure 3b) in the medium at this time.
1146 25 r
•-•O"" Mortality
—*—Biomass — -D — Ethanol
48 Time (h) Figure 2a. Evolution of biomass, ethanol and mortality yield for Exp. 1. 25 1
,^
§,_^
—O---- Mortality
— A - - Biomass - - D -- Ethanol
-1
i—1
z?"^
20
80
/,••
//
o
2
15
60 o
c« (/3
a
(5 o
100
/
10 _ [ y5 ~
- - d
%
-
. 40
.••
^JT
1
^ ^
r\m»^r
20
^' y
^ • • ^
0 ^ ()
/
-
p
1
24
•
Time (h)
1
48
n
•
72
Figure 2b. Evolution of biomass, ethanol and mortality yield for Exp. 2. Figure 3a and 3b represents the consumption of ethanol, as obtained from the mass balance, and the evolution of acetaldehyde, acetic acid and ethyl acetate in the medium.
1147
- • — Ethyl acetate - O- - Acetaldehyde T3
a — Acetic acid
>%
1 •i^
••it— Ethanol
73
^ ^ c> 4-J
(D cd ^ TJ
">.
:S PQ
§
48 Time (h) Figure 3a. Evolution of products and total ethanol consumption in Exp. 1.
25 r
>>^^*s 43
3 T^ dj
c> c3 C3
O cd
20 h
- # — Ethyl acetate - o- - Acetaldehyde a — Acetic acid -•^-" Ethanol
70
A
60
H o
50 15 h
40
o
d-o^.
4->
(U
o 10 h
o o 3
-I 30
cd cd T3
A 20
,__, c >. cd ^ W
o
-I 10 24
Time (h)
48
0 72
Figure 3b. Evolution of products and total ethanol consumption in Exp. 2. The ethanol consumption was slower in Exp. 1 which required to stop substrate feeding from hour 40 to hour 60, as seen in figure 1, to keep the concentration below 25 g/1. This problem did not occur in Exp. 2, despite a lower biomass concentration, and ethanol with an average flow rate of 3.7 g/h was fed
1148 without exceeding 22 g/1 in the fermenter. In this experiment, the lag phase was shorter and productivities in ethyl acetate and acetaldehyde were 0.105 and 0.437 g/l.h, respectively. To try to understand the evolution of these products in both experiments, the synthesis pathway of each compound was considered. It has been proposed that, in yeasts such as Hansenula, Kluyveromyces or Candida, ethyl acetate is formed according to the following reactions [32, 29, 22]: Ethanol + 1/2 02 Acetaldehyde + 1/2 02 Acetyl CoA + Ethanol
> Acetaldehyde + H2O > Acetic acid - Fe*++
+ Fe**+
> Acetyl CoA
> TCA Cycle
> Ethyl acetate + H2O
C. utilis was grown in iron limitation which resulted in decreased molar growth yield with respect to carbon substrates and in increased specific rates of oxygen uptakes [39]. Growth under reduced iron concentrations is limited by the available metabolic energy. IMoreover, ethyl acetate production, under these conditions, was favored because acetyl-CoA is diverted to ester formation rather than being oxidized through the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle [39]. In Exp. 1, ethyl acetate production began simultaneously with growth (after 40 h), to reach a concentration of more than 7 g/1 in the bioreactor. Acetaldehyde synthesis started before, as soon as ethanol was fed to the reactor. It did not accumulate and a concentration of 0.8 g/1 was attained. Acetic acid production seemed to be linked to ethyl acetate production and hence to growth. A concentration of 4 g/1 was attained. No inhibition in ethyl acetate synthesis was observed despite ethanol concentrations above 20 g/1. In Exp. 2, the accumulation of the three compounds started at the same time than growth, but with faster production of acetaldehyde than other compounds. In that case, a very high acetaldehyde concentration was observed (more than 22 g/1). This concentration has been reported to be inhibitory for ethyl acetate synthesis by C. utilis probably because it reduces acetyl-CoA formation, an intermediate in the synthesis of the ester [28]. It is also lethal for cells, as can be seen for the cell mortality after 66 hours. It must pointed out that the ethyl acetate concentration reached its maximum (5.2 g/1) rapidly (only 20 hours after the beginning of its production). It appeared that acetic acid production was not inhibited by the high acetaldehyde concentration and this is a confirmation of the inhibition of the esterification step. It can be concluded t h a t oxygen limitation may favor ethyl acetate production while acetaldehyde accumulation needs higher dissolved oxygen levels. This trend was also observed with K fragilis but at higher values (40 % and 70 % of dissolved oxygen for ethyl acetate and acetaldehyde, respectively) [23]. Besides the volatile compounds mentioned above, C. utilis produces other non volatile substances. Figure 4 relates the consumption of NaOH, to maintain a constant pH against the acetic acid produced.
1149 700
— # — Experiment 1 - - O - - Experiment 2
600
0
,^
200 100 150 Acetic acid (meq) Figure 4. Evolution of added sodium hydroxide against acetic acid production for both experiments.
50
It can be seen that the amount of sodium hydroxide needed to neutralize the acids released in the medium is much more important than the amount needed to neutralize the sole acetic acid. The slope of the curves are 3.95 for Exp. 1 and 3.18 for Exp. 2. Although consumption of ammonium sulfate, the nitrogen source, is known to reduce pH, it was only used in low concentrations (max. 2.5 g/1). From analysis of the broth by HPLC with an UV detector, pyruvic and lactic acids were identified by retention time comparison, and quantified at concentrations up to 2 g/1. The production of lactic [40], pyruvic and succinic acids [41] by Candida species were already reported. Such accumulations in both experiments may also be related to the formation of other compounds such as fusel alcohols or glycerol (which was detected in these experiments). Table 1 shows the yields of dry weight, acetic acid, acetaldehyde and ethyl acetate per gram of ethanol which were obtained from the carbon balance of both experiments. Yields (g compound / g ethanol) Biomass Ethyl acetate Acetic acid Acetaldehyde
Exp. 1 0.510 0.123 0.084 0.004
Exp. 2 0.201 0.194 0.088 0.240
Table 1 - Yields of some products during the growth of C utilis. These data show clearly the influence of nitrogen concentration on biomass production as well as the importance of the dissolved oxygen levels on the
1150 metabolites production. Medium used in Exp. 2 contained a concentration twice lower in nitrogen source than medium used in Exp. 1, which explains a lower biomass synthesis. This was already observed with the same media used in solid state cultures of C utilis [38]. The results given in table 1 show an increase of acetaldehyde and a decrease of biomass per gram of substrate on higher oxygen levels. Also, a slight increase on acetaldehyde and acetic acid production was observed in these conditions. So that, formation of end products was favored at high levels of oxygen. Also, higher oxygen levels enhance the formation of acetaldehyde over ethyl acetate. Furthermore, these conditions favored also higher specific productivities (expressed as grams of product per gram of biomass). While different distribution in biomass and products between the experiments was observed, both systems showed similar substrate carbon conversion capacities, (68% and 71% was transformed into biomass and products for Exp. 1 and Exp. 2, respectively). Hernandez and Johnson reported a value of 0.68 g of cells per gram of ethanol growing C. utilis in Erlenmeyer flasks in a non-iron-deficient medium. The iron-limited media decreases the efficiency of energy and growth yields with respect to the carbon sources, but it increases the specific rates of oxygen in microorganisms [42]. Therefore, it was expected to obtain low 3delds in the formation of cellular material, but the ethyl acetate production and acetaldehyde production were increased due to the presence of ethyl acetate substrates such as oxygen, acetic acid and ethanol. Table 2 resumes the results for ethyl acetate production from various studies. Yeast Candida utilis Hansenula anomala Kluyveromyces fragilis Saccharomyces rouxii Candida pseudotropicalis Candida utilis Candida utilis
Particular conditions
Yield (g/gEtOH) Nitrogen free medium+ ethanol (10 g/1) 0.254 Continuous culture (D=0.1 h"i) 0.014 0.300 Lactose + ethanol (10 g/1) 0.308 Glucose + ethanol (46 mg/1) Iron free mediima + ethanol (30 g/1) 0.191 This study, Exp. 1 This study, Exp.2
0.123 0.194
Ref.
29 32 22 27 31 _ -
Table 2 - Yields in ethyl acetate conversion from ethanol for various yeasts. Figures 5a (Exp. 1) and 5b (Exp. 2) show the rates of oxygen uptake, of carbon dioxide production and from the respiratory quotient (R.Q.). Carbon dioxide production followed approximatively growth evolution. Oxygen consumption was much more important than carbon dioxide production and this is reflected in the RQ. In Exp. 1, this coefficient is constant around 0.33 while in Exp. 2, it slowly increased from 0.15 to 0. 4. The values found agree with the carbon mass balance analysis as reported previously [43]. With the reported values in Table 1 mass balance predicts that lower RQ should be expected when increased volatiles and acid production. This is basically due to the oxidation of the ethanol. Moreover, increased biomass yields should also reduce RQ. Respirometry analysis gives a good indication of product and biomass productions.
1151 50 r-
J2
s
i
J, Pi
Q
u oi O 48 Time (h) Figure 5a. Respirometric activity for Exp.l. 35 r [ 30
f --B-R.Q.
^—s^
413
sO
B B
p^
25 20
U
g
10
O
L
5 0
V
U
15 r
-1
yf
r
Q
u
"1 0.6 H
—e—OUR --••-•CDPR
/
/
/
^V^&n \
-/
\
0
O
0.3
7 ^ ' •
• • ' '
i^—r^
0.4 -§ A "j
>v
ET
0.5
1
24
,
Time (h)
1
A
^
I
0.2
CD
3
.
48
72
Figure 5b. Respirometric activity for Exp. 2. Figure 6 shows the formation of cells versus the consumption of oxygen. It is observed that O2 consumption continues after the cells have reached their maximum growth. This is due to the continuous production of organic acids such as acetic which require ethanol oxidation. There is not much information available to compare these results with those reported in the literature. Hernandez and Johnson [42] reported a
1152 yield of 0.61 g of dry cells of C utilis per gram of oxygen when such microorganism was grown in ethanol medium. Moreover, Paca and Votruba [32], observed that different levels of the oxygen affected the growth rate of C. utilis 106, but no specific data were available in such report. Armstrong et al. [29] reported that high levels of aeration increase the ethyl acetate production, but also neither oxygen yields nor respiratory quotients were reported. 30 r c o '^ o
2
OH
c3
s
2
o H 20
120 40 60 80 100 Total oxygen consumption (g) Figure 6. Relationship between biomass production and oxygen consumption in both experiments. CONCLUSION Submerged culture of C utilis on continuously fed ethanol vapor as sole carbon source, was found to be a suitable process for the production of ethyl acetate as well as acetaldehyde by C. utilis. The production was favored by increasing the levels of oxygen in ethanol containing iron-deficient media. These conditions inhibit the formation of energy through the electron transport system. As a consequence of such inhibition, different mechanisms for fueling and biosynthetic pathways are present in the yeast and therefore, other products such as pyruvic and lactic acids, are formed as well. The oxygen supply to this media plays an important role during the growth of the yeast; for example, the specific substrate and end-product yields, and the respiratory quotient are dependent on oxygen concentration in the media. It was also observed that direct measurement of carbon dioxide production was a good indicator of growth. Respiratory quotient was found to reflect oxidized metabolites excretion in the medium. The physiology of C. utilis in these conditions is interesting for potential applications such as assimilation of ethanol in industrial gas streams. This work was achieved under research agreement between ORSTOM (France) and the UAM (Mexico).
1153 REFERENCES 1. R.J. Whitaker and D.A. Evans, Food Technol., 41(9) (1987) 86. 2. P. Christen and A. Lopez-Munguia, Food Biotechnol., Accepted for publication. 1994. 3. L. Janssens, H.L. de Footer, N.M. Schamp and E.J. Vandamme, Proc. Biochem. 27 (1992) 195. 4. P.S.J. Cheetham, The flavour and fragrance industry. In: Biotechnology. The science and the business, V. Moses and R.E. Cape.(eds.), Harwood Acad. London, 26 (1991) 481. 5. P.S.J. Cheetham, Trends Biotechnol., 11 (1993) 478. 6. G.M. Kempler, Adv. Appl. Microbiol., 29 (1983) 29. 7. M.S.A. Wecker and R.R. Zall, Appl. Env. Microbiol., 53(12) (1987) 2815. 8. F. Cormier, Y. Raymond, C.P. Champagne and A. Morin. J. Agric. Food Chem., 39 (1991) 159. 9. M.I. Farbood and B.J. Willis, (1985) US Patent No 4 560 656. 10. C. Creuly, C. Larroche and J.B. Gros, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 34 (1) (1990) 20. 11. P. Chalier and J. Crouzet, Biotechnol. Lett., 14(4) (1992) 275. 12. P. Christen and M. Raimbault, Biotechnol. Lett., 13(7) (1991) 521. 13. E. Peynaud and G. Guimberteau, Ann. Technol. Agric, 11 (1962) 85. 14. P. Schreier, F. Drawert, A. Junker, H. Barton, and G. Leopold, Z. Lebensm. Unters. Forch., 162 (1976) 279. 15. H. Suomalainen, J. Inst. Brew., 87 (1981) 296. 16. Fenaroli's handbook of flavor ingredients, 2nd Ed., Vol. 2, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Fla. 1975. 17. F. Welsh, W.D. Murray and R.E. WiUiams, Crit. Rev. Biotechnol., 9(2) (1989) 105. 18. R. Davies, E.A. Falkiner, J.F. Wilkinson and J.L. Peel, Biochem. J., 49(1951) 58. 19. J. Tabachnick and M.A. Joslyn, J. Bacteriol., 65 (1953) 1. 20. L. Janssens, H.L. de Footer, E.J. Vandamme and N.M. Schamp, Med. Fac. Landbouww. Rijskuniv. Gent, 52(4) (1987) 1907. 21. L. Janssens, H.L. de Footer, L. Demey, E.J. Vandamme and N.M. Schamp, Med. Fac. Landbouww. Rijskuniv. Gent, 53(4b) (1988) 2071 22. H. Kallel-Mhiri and A. Miclo, FEMS Microbiol. Lett., I l l (1993) 207. 23. H. Kallel-Mhiri, J.M. Engasser and A. Miclo, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 40 (1993) 201. 24. S. Shindo, J. Murakami and S. Koshino, J. Ferment. Bioeng., 73 (1992) 370.
1154 25. E. Longo, J.B. Velazquez, C. Sieiro, J. Cansado, P. Calo and T.G. Villa, World .J. Microbiol. BiotechnoL, 8 (1992) 539 26. K. Yoshioka and N. Hashimoto, Agric. Biol. Chem., 45(1) (1981) 2183. 27. F.M. Yong, K.H. Lee and H.A. Wong, J. Food TechnoL, 16 (1981) 177. 28. D.W. Armstrong, S.M. Martin and H. Yamazaki, Biotech.Lett., 6(3) (1984) 183. 29. D.W. Armstrong, S.M. Martin and H. Yamazaki, Biotech. Bioeng., 36 (1984) 1038. 30. W.D. Murray, S.J.B. DuflF, P.H. Lanthier, D.W. Armstrong, F.W. Welsh and R.E. Williams, In: Frontiers of Flavor. G. Charalambous (ed.). Proceedings of the 5th. International Flavor Conference, Porto Karras, Chalkidiki, Greece, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Amsterdam. (1988) 1. 31. A. Willets, Antonie van Leeuwenhoek, 56 (1989) 175. 32. J. BoL, W. Knol and B. ten Brink, Dechema-Monographs, 105 (1987) 235. 33. J. Paca and J. Votruba, Appl. Microbiol. BiotechnoL, 33, (1990) 438. 34. W.D. Murray, S.J.B. Duff and P.H. Lanthier, Biomass, 23(3) (1990) 229 35. H.K. Chiang, G.L. Foutch and W.W. Fish, Appl. Biochem. Biotech., 28/29 (1991) 513. 36. C.H. Kim and S. KRhee, BiotechnoL Lett., 14(11) (1992) 1059. 37. P. Christen, R. Auria, C. Vega, E. Villegas and S. Revah, BiotechnoL Adv., 11 (1993) 549. 38. P. Christen, R. Auria, R. Marcos, E. Villegas and S. Revah, Adv. Bioprocess Eng., (1994). In press. 39. K.C. Thomas and P.S.S. Dawson, Can. J. Microbiol., 24 (1978) 440. 40. A. Prell, J. Paca and K. Sigler, Appl. Microbiol. BiotechnoL, 36 (1991) 236. 41. A. CoUings, A.R. Holmes and M. G. Shepherd, Biomedical Lett., 46 (1991) 285. 42. E. Hernandez and M.J. Johnson, J. BacterioL, 94(4) (1967) 996. 43. L.E. Erickson, I. G. Minkievich and V.K. Eroshin, Biotech. Bioeng., 20 (1978) 1595.
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1155
Changes in microstructure and thermal properties of thermally processed cornstarch/soy protein isolate model food systems F.A. Nyanzi, J.A. Maga and C. Evans Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523, U.S.A.
Abstract
Fluorescent microscopy and differential scanning calorimetry were used to study the influence of thermal processing on the microstructure and thermal properties of cornstarch/soy protein model food systems. Both analytical methods showed that extrusion thermal processing at 50'C affected the physical characteristics of cornstarch/soy protein samples almost to the same extent as conventional heating at 150**C. For example, the enthalpies of transition were 0.8J/g for samples conventionally processed at IBO'C and 0.6J/g for samples extruded at 50'C. The micrographs also showed that the starch granules were not completely disrupted by conventional thermal processing at 150*C but extrusion thermal processing gelatinized the starch granules at 50'C. Overall, the greatest microstructure modifications of starch or protein were clearly shown to be due to extrusion when compared to conventional thermal processing.
1.
INTRODUCTION
Thermal processing of food systems induces changes in microstructure [1] and the thermal properties [2] of food components. Studies of these changes may contribute to the understanding of how food components can influence the functionality of food systems. Electron microscopy has been used by researchers [1,3-6] to study the microstructure of food systems. Other researchers [7-10] have followed changes in thermal properties of thermally processed samples by the use of differential scanning calorimetry. Fluorescent microscopy has received very limited attention in the study of microstructural changes in processed samples. A study by Goossens et al. [11] showed that fluorescent microscopy is a good method for identifying protein and starch in wheat samples. This method has not yet been shown to be applicable to thermally processed samples. Therefore, the purpose of the present study was to use fluorescent microscopy in conjunction with differential scanning calorimetry to determine the changes in microstructure and thermal properties induced by thermal processing method and temperature.
1156 2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1. Materials The ingredients consisted of commercial cornstarch (Pure-Dent B700: a gift from Grain Processing Corporation, Muscatine, Iowa) and commercial soy protein isolate (Ardex R: a gift from Archer Daniels Midland Company (ADM), Decatur, Illinois). 2.2
Cornstarch preparation for extrusion A 2kg starch sample was mixed with 188 ml of 0.08N sodium hydroxide solution for 10 minutes using a Hobart mixer. Model D-300 (The Hobart Manufacturing Company, Troy, Ohio, USA) set at the lowest speed. The prepared sample had 20% w/w moisture and pH=7. Samples were sealed in plastic bags and left at room temperature for extrusion processing the following day. 2.3
Protein pellet preparation for extrusion Two ml of 0.3N sodium hydroxide was mixed with 2.5 g of soy protein isolate, and a round pellet was manually made. The prepared pellet had a pH of 7. These pellets were stored overnight at room temperature in sealed plastic containers to prevent moisture loss, for extrusion processing the following day. 2.4
Soy protein isolate and/or cornstarch preparation for conventional processing Samples containing lOg of cornstarch or (75:25) cornstarch:soy protein isolate were mixed manually with a glass rod for 1 minute while adding 2 ml of 1.5N sodium hydroxide. Samples were left in sealed containers overnight at room temperature before an aliquot was packed in stainless steel tubes for processing. Stainless tubes 15cm long with an inside diameter of 0.40cm were used in this method. The samples were packed in the tubes and both ends were tightly sealed with metal screw covers. The tubes, with their respective samples, were temperature- and moisture-equilibrated overnight before thermal processing. 2.5
Extrusion processing Extrusion thermal processing was performed in a single screw Brabender Plasticorder Extruder, Model PL-V500 (C.W. Brabender Instruments, Inc., South Hackensack, New Jersey), equipped with a variable D-C drive unit, a tachometer, and a torque meter. The extruder barrel had a diameter of 19.05mm with a 20:1 length:diameter ratio and eight 0.79 X 3.18mm longitudinal grooves. In addition to a tapered screw with a 3:1 compression ratio, a die with a diameter of 4.8mm was used. The temperature of the extruder barrel was controlled by two electrically heated zones. The first heating zone was in the compression section and the second one in the metering section just next to the die. The dough temperature was maintained by compressed-air-cooled barrel collars. The compressed air was controlled by thermostats found inside the barrel wall. The preconditioned starch was fed manually into the feed zone of the extruder while bringing the screw speed to the processing speed of 120 rpm. After a steady state flow, as shown by a torque variation of +2.5 inch-pound, had been maintained and the processing dough temperature just before the die (either 50'C or 150'C) obtained, an experimental protein pellet was introduced in the feed zone. Immediately after a pellet was introduced, the extrudate strand was cut off and discarded. The subsequent exiting extrudate strand, which contained the protein sample, was
1157 cut off and saved. The presence of protein was determined by observing the difference in color of the exiting strand. 2.6
Conventional thermal processing An oil bath at 160'C was used to process the samples. The tubes to be processed, and another tube containing a thermocouple to monitor the temperature, were placed in metal racks, and immersed in the heated oil-bath. When the thermocouple registered the desired processing temperature (either 50'C or 150'C), the processed tubes were removed and immediately immersed into an icecold water-bath to stop the effects of thermal processing. For each set of tubes to be processed, a temperature-control tube containing the same soy protein and/or cornstarch preparation and a thermocouple was used. 2.7
Fluorescent microscopy Fluorescent microscopy was used to determine the microstructure changes in processed cornstarch/soy protein isolate samples. Samples were prepared by embedding 1 cm sections in paraffin blocks. The embedded samples were sectioned into 5 iim slices with a microtome and mounted on a microscope slide. Acridine orange fluorochrome was used in order to differentiate starch from protein structures as per Goossens et al. [11]. A Carl Zeiss fluorescent microscope equipped with 40X objective lens, 47 background filter, BG12 excitation filter, a 200W mercury arc lamp, and a camera body with automatic exposure control, were used to record microstructure of the samples on Ektachrome 100 ASA film. 2.8
Differential scanning calorimetry The method of Kugimiya and Donovan [12], with minor modifications, was employed to analyze thermal characteristics of experimental samples. A 2 to 3 mg sample of thermally processed cornstarch/soy protein isolate was weighed directly into a tared aluminum hermetic pan. A microsyringe was used to deliver lO^L of distilled water into the pan containing the sample and the pan was sealed by a press. The sealed pans were stored overnight at room temperature before thermal analysis. A DuPont 910 cell base and 9900 computer/thermal analyzer were used. The cell was purged with nitrogen gas at a rate of 40 ml per second. The heating rate was 10"C per minute from 20'C to 120'C. Enthalpies of transition ( A H ) , onset temperature (T^), and peak maximum temperature (Tp) were determined by a DuPont computer program General Analysis Utility Version 2.1.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1
Microstructure determination by fluorescent microscopy Figure 1 shows the microstructure of the starch-protein sample conventionally processed at 50'C. No observable structural changes were detected with the starch granules or the soy proteins. The starch granules and protein particles appear to be intact.
1158
Figure 1 Fluorescent micrograph of cornstarch/soy protein isolate (75:25) sample showing the effect of thermal processing by conventional method (oil-bath heating) at 50'C, 20%w/w feed moisture, on the protein and starch microstructure of the sample.
1159
Figure 2 Fluorescent micrograph of cornstarch/soy protein isolate (75:25) sample showing the effect of thermal processing by extrusion method at 50'C, 20% w/w feed moisture, on the protein and starch microstructure of the sample.
In contrast, a micrograph of an extruded sample at 50'C, shows "melted" starch and a possible aggregation of protein particles (Figure 2). Shear and pressure during extrusion thermal processing, regardless of the temperature levels, appear to drastically alter the microstructure of starch granules.
1160
Figure 3 Fluorescent micrograph of cornstarch/soy protein isolate (75:25) sample showing the effect of thermal processing by conventional method (oil-bath heating) at 150'C, 20% w/w feed moisture, on the protein and starch microstructure.
Increasing thermal processing temperatures to 150'C, for the conventional method, influenced the microstructure for both starch and protein. Figure 3 shows that most of starch granules have been disrupted and "melted" with a few unaffected granules. Protein particles appear to have been unfolded and spread over the "melted" starch mass.
1161
Figure 4 Fluorescent micrograph of cornstarch/soy protein isolate (75:25) sample showing the effect of thermal processing by extrusion method at 150'C, 20% w/w feed moisture, on the protein and starch microstructure.
Extrusion thermal processing at 150T causes protein unfolding and realignment as seen in Figure 4. Protein fibers are observed in the micrograph. The micrograph shows that the starch granules were completely "melted" and that some of the starch is intermeshed with the protein strands. Starch appears to be adsorbed to the protein fibers.
1162
m
3 Q. O fi-
IT
ro 3 3: ro o O
TQmpQraturQ (°C) Figure 5 Differential scanning calorimetry thermograms of cornstarch/soy protein isolate (75:25) samples. Thermograms indicated are for samples: Aunprocessed, B and D - conventional method processed at 50'C and 150'C, respectively; C and E extrusion method processed at 50*'C and 150'C, respectively. All samples had 20% w/w feed moisture before processing.
3.2
Differential scanning calorimetry thermoanalysis Thermoanalysis data (Table 1) and DSC thermograms (Figure 5) show thermal properties of cornstarch-soy protein isolate samples thermally processed by both procedures at 50'C and 150'C, along with a non-heat processed control.
A single enthalpy peak occurred for the unprocessed starch/protein blend as shown in thermogram A. The peak had an enthalpy of transition (AH) of 7.4J/g and peak temperature (Tp) of 74.3*'C. Unprocessed starch alone was determined to have an enthalpy of transition of 16.9 J/g which was within the range of 15.5 J/g to 31.8 J/g as determined by Stevens and Elton [13]. The peak appeared in the same temperature range where cornstarch gelatinization enthalpy normally occurs as
1163 reported by Stevens and Elton [13]. Therefore, the peak was attributed to the cornstarch gelatinization endotherm. The thermogram did not show other peaks generally attributed to the enthalpy of protein denaturation [14]. The reason for the absence of the protein peak might have been due to the nature of protein since commercial soy protein isolate had been shown to produce no detectable peaks with DSC thermoanalysis [10]. The thermogram for a starch-protein blend conventionally processed at 50'C (Figure 5, thermogram B) did not produce detectable thermal property changes in the sample components. The samples had virtually the same enthalpy of transition and T as the unprocessed sample. This may have been the result of a very short duration of heating or that heating the sample to 50'C was not enough to cause any thermal changes in the sample. Parsons and Patterson [15] showed that thermal properties of food systems are influenced by both temperature and duration of heat treatment. Therefore, increasing thermal processing duration might have caused some changes in at least the enthalpy peak of transition. The effect of thermal processing on the thermoprofile of a starch-protein blend was demonstrated when the samples were extruded at 50'C (Figure 5). Table 1 showed that the enthalpy of transition was decreased from 7.4 J/g (unprocessed sample) to 0.6 J/g for the extruded sample but only a slight decrease for a sample conventionally processed at 50"C. This showed that extrusion thermal processing affects the thermal properties of a food system differently than conventional thermal processing. The low temperature when coupled with shear and pressure during extrusion caused changes in the thermal properties of a food system. When the starch-protein sample was conventionally heated to 150'C, the enthalpy peak measured by DSC was virtually the same as that of samples extruded at SO^'C (Figure 5 ) . DSC thermograms showed that there was incomplete starch gelatinization even at a processing temperature of 150'C. This observation is in line with the observation that the amount of water [9,16,17] and the presence of protein [18] in a starch sample influence starch gelatinization, thus influencing the size of the enthalpy peak. In contrast, extrusion thermal processing of samples at 150*C caused the elimination of any detectable DSC enthalpy peak. Table 1 Effect of thermal processing method and processing temperature on onset temperature (To), peak maximum temperature (Tp), and transition enthalpy (AH) of cornstarch/soy protein isolate bend (75:25). All samples were thermally processed at 20% w/w feed moisture. Scanning was performed at temperatures form 20''C to 120^C at a heating rate of lO'^C per minute. Processing method Unprocessed Conventional Extrusion Conventional Extrusion
Processing temp. f'C)
50 50 150 150
TJ'C) 69.0 68.5 70.4 70.5
+ + + +
ND
Tp(^C) 0,2 0.5 0.2 0.2
74.3 74.8 75.0 75.1
+ + + +
ND
AH(J/q) 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.1
7.4 + 0.5 6.9 + 0.3 0.62 + 0.05 0.78 + 0.08
ND
1164 ND:
4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Not detected
REFERENCES L. Jing-ming and Z. Sen-lin, Starch, 42 (1990) 96. C.G. Biladeris, Food Chem. 10 (1983) 239. M.U. Taranto, G.F. Ceqla and K.C. Rhee, J. Food Sci., 43 (1978) 973. M.J. Gomez and J.M. Aguilera, J. Food Sci., 48 (1983) 378. L.C. Lin and T. Ito, J. Food Technol., 21 (1986) 133. M. Bhattacharya and M.A. Hanna, Lebensm. Wiss. Technol., 20 (1987) 195. J.W. Donovan and R.A. Beardslee, J. Biol. Chem., 250 (1975) 1966. A.M. Hermansson, J. Text. Studies, 9 (1978) 33. C.G. Biliaderis, T.J. Maurice and J.R. Vose, J. Food Sci., 45 (1980) 1669. S.D. Arntfield and F.D. Murray, Can. Inst. Food Sci. Technol. J., 14 (1981) 289. J. Goossens, F. Derez and K.H. Bahr, Starch, 40 (1988) 327. M. Kugimiya and J.W. Donovan, J. Food Sci., 46 (1981) 765. D.J. Stevens and G.A.H. Elton, Starch, 23 (1971) 8. F.W. Sosulski, R. Hoover, R.T. Tyler, R.T. Murray and S.D. Arntfield, Starch, 37 (1985) 257. S.E. Parsons and R.L.S. Patterson, J. Food Technol., 21 (1986) 123. J. W. Donovan, Biopolymers, 18 (1979) 263. D.J. Burt and P.L. Russell, Starch, 35 (1983) 354. R.a. Gryzybowski and B.J. Donnelly, J. Food Sci., 42 (1977) 1304.
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
Evaluation of Cookeina sulcipes of its B i o m a s s Composition
1165
as an Edible Mushroom: D e t e r m i n a t i o n
Jose E. Sanchez^, Antonio M. Martin^ and Angel D. Sanchez^ ^ Centro de Investigadones Ecologicas del Sureste, Apdo. Postal 36, Tapachula, Chiapas, Mexico
30700
^ Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, Newfoundland, Canada AlB 3X9 ^ Escuela de Qmmica, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Chiapas, Km. 2.5 Carr. Antiguo Aeropuerto, 30700 Tapachula, Chiapas, Mexico
Abstract Cookeina sulcipes is a relatively unknown edible tropical mushroom. This mushroom was studied with the aim of evaluating its chemical composition to estimate its potential for commercial production. Determinations were conducted of the following biomass components of the mushroom: amino acids, ash, carbohydrates, carotenoids, fatty acids, fibre, lipids, protein, mineral composition and water content. Among the main results, it was found that C. sulcipes possesses a high protein content, a relatively high content of phosphorus and a low content of lipids. All the essential amino acids were present, albeit the concentration of tryptophan was relatively low. Therefore, it may be concluded that this mushroom biomass could be considered a valuable human food.
1. INTRODUCTION Cookeina sulcipes is an ascomycete from the tropicgJ areas of the earth that grows in mushroom form on dead logs of the cacao plant Theobroma cacao. Few studies have been conducted on this species, and only two references have been found to report that C. sulcipes is eaten in the Mexican regions of Veracruz and
1166 Chiapas (Chac6n, 1988; Sanchez et aL, 1994). In addition to its value as food, this mushroom is attractive due to its pink colour and its shape, and it is frequently used as an ornament. Edible mushrooms are considered to be nutritious foods, due to their relatively high protein contents (15 to 50 % of the biomass, on a dry weight basis). In addition, edible mushrooms generally contain all amino acids essential for human nutrition, being especially rich in lysine and leucine. The scarcity of general scientific information about C sulcipes includes a lack of information about its chemical composition. The study of the composition of exotic edible mushrooms is important before their commercialization is attempted (Martin, 1992). Given the fact that the use of this mushroom as food is widespread among rural populations in the above mentioned Mexican regions, and because there is an absence of information about its nutritional characteristics, the present work was conducted with the objective of determining the chemical composition of C. sulcipes. It is expected that a deeper knowledge of the mushroom's characteristics will awaken interest in its commercial exploitation.
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS 2.1. Mushroom Fresh fi'uiting bodies of C. sulcipes were collected from the region of Soconusco, State of Chiapas, Mexico. To preserve the mushrooms, they were dried to a final moisture content of 10 % (total weight). 2.2. Analytical Methods The analyses of moistiire content, crude fibre and ash were conducted according to the methods of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists (Anon., 1984). The determination of the crude protein of the mushroom was done by finding the total nitrogen content by the Kjeldahl method, and multiplying the resulting value by the factor 4.38. This value was chosen instead of the usual conversion factor of N X 6.25 to accoimt for the non-protein nitrogen associated with the chitin of the mushroom cell wall (Bano and Rajarathnam, 1989). The mushroom biomass was analyzed for amino acids (Blackburn, 1968; Penke et aL, 1974), carbohydrate content (Quarmby and Allen, 1989), carotenoids (An et aL, 1989), and minerals (Anon., 1974). The total lipid content analysis was conducted following the method ofBligh and Dyer (1959). The fatty acid determination involved extraction by the method ofBligh and Dyer (1959), followed by a modified form of the procedure of Thompson (1969). In this procedure, the lipids were dried imder nitrogen, transmethylated (Keoiigh and
1167 Kariel, 1987), extracted into hexane, re-dried under nitrogen, dissolved in CSg, and analyzed using a Perkin Elmer model 8310 gas chromatograph, with a Supelco SP 2330 resin-packed colunm, at 170°C and 3 x 10"^° amp/mv sensitivity.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The general composition of C. sulcipes is presented in Table 1. The information is presented for both the cap (pileus) and the stem (stipe) of the mushrooms. It can be seen that there are differences between the compositions of the two main parts of the mushroom. The water content is high for both, being higher for the stems, which gives these a more tender consistency. The protein values for both parts compare well with those reported for other edible mushrooms. For example, Bano and Rajarathnam (1989) reported the following protein values, in % dry weight: Pleurotus ostreatus, 10.5 %; Volvariella displasia, 28,5 %; Agaricus bisporus, 26,3%; Pleurotus flabellatus, 21,6%; and Lentinus edodes, 17.5 %, The higher protein content in the caps than in the stems agrees with the findings of Jandaik et al, (1979) in wild Indian mushrooms. It is important to emphasise that some authors utilize the factor N X 6.25, which is generally used for cereals and other foods, for calculating the protein content of mushrooms (Manu-Tawiah and Martin, 1987). Therefore, their final protein content values appear to be higher than those reported in this work, in which the factor N X 4.38 is utilized, as mentioned above. The lipid contents are similar to those reported by Singh and Verma (1991) for Pleurotus djamor (2,75%) and Pleurotus platypus (2.59%). The values found for the lipids fall within the range of 2 to 6 % (dry basis) reported for mushrooms (Li and Chang, 1989). The crude fibre content of C. sulcipes is high, which is common for mushrooms grown on woody materials. Another example of this is Pleurotus limpidUy which attains a crude fibre content of 27.6 % of its total dry weight (Bano and Rajarathnam, 1989). The ash content of C. sulcipes is relatively high, but within the higher limit of ash contents reported for mushrooms (Bano and Rajarathnam, 1989). However, the carbohydrate content is low compared to those reported by Lau (1989). The reddish colour of the caps of C, sulcipes, collected in the soluble lipid fraction of the extract produced by the method of An et al, (1989), indicated the presence of carotenoids in the mushroom. Due to the presence of impurities, it was not possible to make a final analytical determination of the types of carotenoids and their concentrations. Further studies will need to be conducted
1168 in this regard. The presence of carotenoids in C. sulcipes could increase its value as a source of pigments for the food industry. Research is being actively conducted in finding carotenoid-producing microorganisms (Martin et al,, 1993a), and in optimizing the production by microorganisms of such important carotenoids as astaxanthin (An et al., 1989; Martin et al., 19936,c), which is responsible for coloured salmonid flesh. Table 1 Proximate composition of Cookeina sulcipes, % dry weight ^ Component Moisture Dry matter Ash Crude lipids Crude fibre Crude protein (N X 4.38) Soluble Carbohydrates Carotenoids
Cap 79.9 ± 1.5 20.01 ± 1.5 10.4 ± 1.5 ^ 2.95 ± 0.1 " 14.3 ± 0.32 24.79 ± 0.16 6.8 ± 0.15 ' present
Stem 85.4 ± 1.2 14.6 ± 1.23 9.5 ± 1.2 ^ 2.7 ± 0.12 ^ not determined 20.68 ± 0.27 6.2 ± 0.22 ^
Mean of three determinations ± standard deviations. Values in the same column with the same superscript are not statistically different (P < 0.05). Table 2 presents the amino add content of C. sulcipes. With the exception of asparagine, which is a non-essential amino acid, the mushroom contains all the amino adds commonly found. The concentrations of the essential amino adds are adequate, except that the content of trj^tophan is low in comparison with that reported for other mushrooms (Chang and Miles, 1989). The mineral contents are presented in Table 3. Phosphorous appears to be abundant, and the main constituent of the mineral fraction in the mushroom, espedally in the fruiting body (sporophore). The concentrations of Fe, Mg and Ca, among others, are high. However, Mn is present in very low amounts. Although most of the Mg is concentrated in the stem, the general pattern is that the cap has a higher mineral content than the stem. Fatty acid determinations were conducted for the caps (Table 4). The analysis reveals that C. sulcipes contains fatty adds with carbon chain lengths between 14 and 24. The most abundant ones are the so-called essential fatty adds with 18-carbon chain lengths, such as linoleic, oleic and stearic acids, and also palmitic add. They represent 92 % of the total fatty add content of the mushroom. Parent and Thoen (1979), while listing palmitic, palmitoleic, oleic and linoleic acids as the main fatty acids present in mushrooms, indicated that palmitoleic
1169 a d d s were not always present. Manu-Tawiah and Martin (1987) also reported that the fatty acid more abundant in Pleurotus ostreatus was linoleic.
Table 2 Amino a d d composition of Cookeina sulcipes (g / 100 g protein) Amino a d d Alanine Arginine Aspartic a d d Cystine Glutamic a d d Glutamine Glydne Histidine Isoleudne Leucine Lysine Methionine Phenylalanine Proline Serine Threonine Tryptophan Tyrosine Valine
Cap 3.72 1.66 5.6 0.60 8.04 3.33 2.27 0.78 1.76 2.24 1.92 0.52 1.80 2.99 2.34 2.36 0.03 1.47 1.88
± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ±
Stem 0.3" 0.15" 0.2 ^ 0.1" 0.4 ^ 0.4 ^ 0.5 ^ 0.2 " 0.1 ^ 0.2 " 0.3" 0.1 ^ 0.2 ^ 0.3 ^ 0.4" 0.1 " 0.01 ^ 0.2 ^ 0.3"
2.08 1.26 3.69 1.45 4.11 12.47 1.60 0.70 1.33 1.82 1.83 0.44 1.54 1.62 1.499 2.12 0.03 1.00 1.92
± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ±
0.1 ^ 0.3 ^ 0.2 ^ 0.1 ^ 0.3 ^ 0.5 ^ 0.1 ^ 0.1 ^ 0.1 ^ 0.2 ^ 0.2" 0.85 ^ 0.2 ^ 0.2 ^ 0.2" 0.3 ^ 0.02 ^ 0.1 ^ 0.2 ^
Mean of three determinations ± standard deviations. Values in the same column with the same superscript are not statistically different (P < 0.05)
4. CONCLUSIONS The chemical analysis of the mushroom C sulcipes revealed a high protein content (20.6 - 24.8 %), with the presence of all essential amino acids, although with a low tryptophan concentration. The mushroom biomass is abundant in phosphorus and has a low lipid content. Therefore, this mushroom could be considered a nutritious and healthy food.
1170 Table 3 Mineral content of Cookeina sulcipes (ppm) Mineral Calcium 42 Calcium 43 Copper Iron 56 Iron 57 Magnesivmi Manganese Phosphorus Zinc
Cap 313.9 238.5 214.25 1080.2 1146.1 632.1 3.88 12902 803.33
Stem
± 1.0 ± 5.2 ± 1.9 ± 8.5 ± 7.7 ±4.1 ± 0.2 " ± 30.0 ± 8.2
326.6 97 10.46 71.5 71.5 1385.1 3.08 3728 57.68
± 2.5 ± 3.1 ± 0.5 ± 2.3 ± 0.8 ± 10.4 ± 0.4 ' ± 5.9 ±3.1
Mean of three determinations ± standard deviations. Values in the same colimin with the same superscript are not statistically different (P < 0.05)
Table 4 Determination of fatty acids of the cap (pileus) of Cookeina sulcipes Fatty add name (chain length) (14:0) (14:1) Palmitic (16:0) Palmitoleic (16:1) Stearic (18:0) (18:1) Oleic (18:2) Linoleic (18:3N3) Arachidic (20:0) (20:1) (20:2) (20:5N3) Behenic (22:0) (22:1N11) (22:6N3) (24:0) Mjrristic
mg / 100 g dry fvmgal biomass 2.56 0.525 21.24 1.99 23.19 33.8 122.56 0.69 0.34 0.92 1.03 3.29 0.96 1.08 1.99 2.39
Mean of three determinations ± standard deviations.
± 0.48 ± 0.04 ± 0.9 ± 0.028 ± 0.57 ± 0.61 ± 0.03 ± 0.12 ± 0.01 ±0.04 ± 0.10 ± 2.1 ± 0.01 ± 0.01 ± 0.07 ± 0.01
1171 5, ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would Uke to thank Dr. G. Guzmdn of the mycological herbarium of the Instituto de Ecologia, Mexico, for the identification of the collected samples of C. sulcipes. Also, the authors wish to thank the Campo Experimental Rosario Izapa, Tapachula, Chiapas, Mexico, for the use of their facilities in the realization of part of this work. Thanks are also given to the following members of the Department ofBiochemistry, Memorial University of Newfoundland: Mr. D.Hall and Ms. S. Banfield for the amino acid analysis; Mr. K. Kean for the fatty acid analysis, and Mr. P. Bemister for his assistance with the manuscript.
6. REFERENCES An, G.-H.; Schuman, D.B. and Johnson, E.A. (1989). Isolation of Phaffia rhodozyma mutants with increased astaxanthin content. Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 55(1): 116-124. Anonymous (1974). Reference Analytical Methods Manual. Water Quality Branch, Environment Canada, Ottawa. Anonymous (1984). Official Methods of Analysis, 14*^ edn. (ed. William, S.). Association of Official Analytical Chemists, ArUngton, VA, pp. 38, 56. Bano, Z. and Rajarathnam, S. (1989). Pleurotus mushroom as a nutritious food. In: Tropical Mushrooms. Biological Nature and Cultivation Methods, 3""** edn. (eds. Chang, S.-T. and Quimio, T.H.). The Chinese University Press, Hong Kong, pp. 363-380. Blackburn, S. (1968). Amino Acid Determination: Methods and Techniques. Marcel Dekker, New York, pp. 21-22. Bligh, E.G. and Dyer, W.J. (1959). A rapid method of total lipid extraction and purification. Can. J. Biochem. Physiol., 37: 911-917. Chacon, S. (1988). Conocimiento etnomicologico de los hongos en Plan de Palmar, mimicipio de Papantla, Veracruz. Mic. Neotrop. Aplic., 1: 45-54. Chang, S.-T. and Miles, P.G. (1989). Edible Mushrooms and their Cultivation. C.R.C. Press, Boca - Raton, FL. Jandaik, C.L.; Bhandari, A.R.; Arora, C.L. and Rangad, C O . (1979). Chemical composition of some edible fimgi. In: Mushroom Science X (Part II). Proceedings of the Tenth International Congress on the Science and Cultivation of Edible Fungi (ed. Delmas, J.). Tardy Quercy, Bordeaux, France, pp. 685-688. Keough, K.M.W. and Kariel, N. (1987). Differential scanning calorimetric studies of aqueous dispersions of phosphatidylcholines containing two polyenoic chains. Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 902: 11-18.
1172 Lau, O.-W. (1989). Methods of chemical analysis of mushrooms. In: Tropical Mushrooms, Biological Nature and Cultivation Methods, S""^ edn. (eds. Chang, S.-T. and Quimio, T.H.). The Chinese University Press, Hong Kong, pp. 88, 94. Li, G.S.F. and Chang, S.T. (1989). Nutritive value of VbZi;arieZZa i;oZi;accae. In: Tropical Mushrooms. Biological Nature and Cultivation Methods, ^""^ edn. (eds. Chang, S.-T. and Quimio, T.H.). The Chinese University Press, Hong Kong, pp. 202-203. Manu-Tawiah, W. and Martin, A.M. (1987). Chemical composition of Pleurotus ostreatus mycelial biomass. Food Microbiol,, 4: 303-310. Martin, A.M. (1992). Study of the growth and biomass composition of the edible mushroom Pleurotus ostreatus. In: Food Science and Human Nutrition (ed. Charalambous, G.). Elsevier Science Publishers, Amsterdam, pp. 239-248. Martin, A.M.; Lu, C. and Patel, T.R. (1993a). Growth parameters for the yeast Rhodotorula rubra grown in peat extracts. J. Ferment, Bioeng,, 76(4): 321-325. Martin, A.M.; Acheampong, E.; Patel, T.R., and Chornet, E. (19936). Study of growth parameters for Phaffia rhodozyma cultivated in peat hydrolysates. Appl, Biochem, BiotechnoL, 37: 235-241. Martin, A.M.; Acheampong, E. and Patel, T.R. (1993c). Production of astaxanthin by Phaffia rhodozyma using peat hydrolysates as substrate. J. Chem, Tech, BiotechnoL, 58: 223-230. Parent, G. and Thoen, D. (1979). Considerations sur la teneur en proteines et en acides gras de quelques especes de champignons comestibles du Shaba (Zaire). In: Mushroom Science X (Part II), Proceedings of the Tenth International Congress on the Science and Cultivation of Edible Fungi (ed. Delmas, J.). Tardy Quercy, Bordeaux, France, pp. 689-693. Penke, B.; Ferenczi, R. and Kovacs, K. (1974). A new acid hydrolysis method for determining tryptophan in peptides and proteins. Analyt, Biochem., 60: 45-50. Quarmby, C. and Allen, S.E. (1989). Organic constituents. In: Chemical Analysis of Ecological Materials, 2""^ edn. (ed. Allen, S.E.). Blackwell Scientific, Oxford, pp. 160-200. Sanchez, A.D.; Chacon, S. and Sanchez, J.E. (1994). Produccion natural de Cookeina sulcipes (Ascomycotina, Pezizales) en la region de Tapachula, Chiapas (Mexico). Rev. Mex. Mic, 9: 47-56. Singh, S.M. and Verma, R.N. (1991). Nutritional and toxicological evaluation of Pleurotus spp. J, Food Sci, TechnoL, 28(4): 259-260. Thompson, W. (1969). Positional distribution of fatty acids in brain polyphosphoinositides. Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 187: 150-153.
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1173
Interactions between polysaccharides and aroma compounds S. Langourieux and J. Crouzet Laboratoire de Genie Biologique et Sciences des Aliments, Unite de Microbiologie et Biochimie Industrielles, Associee a I'lNRA, Universite de Montpellier H F 34095 Montpellier Cedex 05 Abstract The presence of interactions between several polysaccharides : modified and wayy^ starches, dextrin, dextrans, hydroxypropyl celluloses, galactomannans and model aroma compounds : limonene, isoamyl acetate, ethyl hexanoate and fi-ionone, was studied by the use of the exponential dilution technique. The observed decrease of the reduced infinite dilution activity coefficient of these compounds when the concentration of polysaccharides is increased shows that the retention of aroma compoimds occurs for gdl the polysaccharides studied excepted for dextrans. With these polymers, an increase of the reduced dilution activity coefficients of volatile compounds, indicative of a ssdting out effect, was noticed. The determination of aroma compounds solubility in water £ind in aqueous solutions of polysaccharides such as dextrin and fi-cyclodextrin by Dynamic Coupled Column Liquid Chromatography (DCCLC) allows the characterization of the complexes. 1. INTRODUCTION The stimulation of odour receptors by aroma compoimds is strongly dependent on the concentration of these compounds in the vapor phase present in the mouth. This concentration is influenced by the volatility of aroma compounds but also by their release from the foods. These two parameters being dependent of several factors such as the quantity of aroma compounds present, the partition coefficients between the gas and the condensed phases, the temperature, the composition and the viscosity of the food and naturally the interactions of aroma compounds between themselves and the interactions between aroma compounds and food components such as proteins, lipids or carbohydrates. The aroma compounds may be dissolved, absorbed or adsorbed, covalently linked, trapped or encapsulated or limited in their diffusion as a result of the presence of foods components. The relative importance of these phenomena varies according to the chemical properties of aroma compounds and the physiced and chemical properties of the food. For example volatile compounds are disolved by lipidic phases whereas they are probably included in starch when this compound is the most important constituant of a food product. A good knowledge of the interactions between aroma compounds and several major food components is of great interest in order to control the aromatisation process.
1174 More particularly the studies of interactions between aroma compounds were developped in order to overcome t h e difficulties encountered for t h e removal of off-flavours from products such as soy or fish proteins (1,2 ) or in the contrary, related to the flavoring of proteinaceous foods (3). The formation of inclusion complexes during drying of systems containing amidon or cellulose, water and aroma compounds was pointed out ( 4,5). Later the presence of these complexes with dextrins, pectins, agar, methyl cellulose, and foods containing these compounds was established ( 6 ). Interactions between aroma compounds and macromolecules i n aqueous solution are generaly studied using equilibrium methods. Several drawbacks : difficulty to determine the equilibrium, time required, non specific binding and volatilization of aroma compounds are associated to t h e use of these techniques. Morever the static equilibrium observed is quite different of the equilibrium occuring for volatiles released in the mouth. In t h e present work dynamic methods: exponential dilution and dynamic coupled column liquid chromatography (DCCLC) were used for the study of interactions between model aroma compounds and several polysaccharides : modified and waxy starches, dextrin, dextran, hydroxypropyl celluloses, galactomans and fi-cyclodextrin i n aqueous solution. 2, METHODS 2.1. Exponential dilution gas flow rate slow
liiylil
Figure l.Variation of the concentration of the solute in the gas phase versus stripping time When a dilute aqueous solution of a volatile compound contained in an equilibrium cell is stripped by an inert gas the concentration of the solute in
1175 the gas phase vary as indicated (Fig 1) (7-10). In a first step the concentration increase with time, then a plateau is reached with a constant concentration in the gas phase indicative of the equilibrium. This step is followed by a decrease of the concentration according to an exponential law. At hight gas flow rate, 30 to 100 ml.min-i, according to the nature of volatile compound, only the exponential decrease with a short equilibrium phase is observed. The concentration decrease is related to the infinite dilution activity coefficient T^i by the expression : logS = l o g S o . ^ ^ Y r t
(,)
where S is the GLC peak area, So the GLC peak area extrapolated to zero time, D the carrier gas flow rate (ml.min-^), N the moles of solvent, R the gas constant (ml at mg .mol'^.K-^), T the temperature (K), P^ithe vapor pressure of the pure solute (atm) and t the time (min). T^i is calculated from the values of the slope of the straight line obtained by plotting log S versus time. When interactions between volatile compounds and macromolecular systems occurs in aqueous solution the infinite dilution activity coefficient is modified, a decrease is indicative of the fixation of the solute whereas an increase agrees with a salting out effect. A reduced activity coefficient:
»ir
oo
^i
(2)
where T^im is the value of y^i in the presence of the macromolecular system may be introduced. This value gives indications concerning the nature and the intensity of the interactions (10-13). 2.2, Dynamic Coupled Column l i q u i d Chromatography (DCCLC) DCCLC was initially introduced by May et al (14,15) for the determination of aqueous solubility of hydrophobic compounds : polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. This method (Fig 2) is based on pumping water through a column, "generator column", containing glass beads coated with the aromatic compounds. The concentration of these compounds is determined by HPLC on a Ci8 reverse phase, "analytical column", either directly or after extraction on
1176 a short Cis column, "extractor column".
Gsneraior column
Figure 2. DCCLC experimental device This method which avoids several problems, such as stability of solutions and losses of compounds to surfaces due to adsorption, allows the determination of the solubility of hydrophobic compounds with a precision and a reproductibility better than ± 3 %. DCCLC was used for the study of cyclodextrin inclusion complexes and more particularly for the determination of the formation constants (16). When aqueous solution of cyclodextrin is used instead of water for the flowing of the generator column an increase of the solubility of PAH as a result of complex formation is noticed. The formation constant for the complex corresponding to the equilibrium:
1177 Cy + P ^
• CyP
[Cy] tSo
(3)
(4)
may be calculated assuming that the cyclodextrin concentration is not depleted to an appreciate extent by complexation (less than 0.1 %) according to : Kf:
[Cy] tSo
(5)
where So is the solubility in water, St the solubility in aqueous solution of cyclodextrin, [Cylt the initial cyclodextrin concentration. 3. CHARACTERIZATION OF INTERACTIONS BY EXPONENTIAL DILUTION 3.1. Interaction with starches Several modified corn starches or waxy corn starches were studied according to the numerous results concerning the interactions between aroma compounds and several starches. The depressive effect of starches is well illustrated by the decrease of the relative volatilety aiw:
Pw (6) in the presence of modified com starches (Fig 3). These results, indicative of the existence of low interactions is in good agreement with results previously reported for potato starch. The association constants obtained for several volatile ligands vary from 10 to 2600 M^^If the effect of the different com starches on the relative volatility of isoamyl acetate is roughly the same, more important interactions, between ethyl hexanoate and modified way corn starches (Clearan CH20® and CI20®) t h a n between this compound and modified corn starches (Clearan MB70® and MH20®). The decrease of volatility expressed by the reduced infinite dilution activity coefficient Y^ir is dependent of the quantity of starch added.
1178
•
00 00
^ 3C00-J
CVi
u
o
::;
CM O <0
2000
>
pi:
1000 H
o ^ ^ i^ ^ r-. S 00 S ?
i
Isoamyl acetate
•
30%
CleargumMB70
•
30%
CiearamMH20
S
30 %
Clearam CH 20
M 30% 00
c
water
Clearam a 20
CO
o o
m I
ethyl hexanoate
limonene
Figure 3. Variations of the reduced volatility at 25° C of aroma compounds in the presence of several modified com and waxy corn starches For modified corn starch Clearam MH 20® (Fig 4) the decrease of isoamyl acetate yooir is weak whereas a rapid decrease from 10 to 15 % of starch followed by a slow decrease was noticed. Simular results have been reported for Cleargun HB70®(17). 1.2
1,0
0.8 H 0.6
0.2-4
0.0
—r~ 10
— I —
20
— I —
30
40
Figure 4. Variations of the reduced activity coefficient of isoamylacetate ( • ) and ethyl hexanoate ( ^ ) as function of modified com starch per cent
1179 When modified waxy corn (Clearam CH 20®) was used (Fig 6) these two phases were not detected, the decrease is approximatively linear with a slope comparable to the one obtained for the second part of the previous plot.
0,1
0,2
0.3
0,4
weight fraction of waxv corn starch
Figure 5.Variations of the reduced activity coefficient of isoamyl acetate( • ) and ethyl hexanoate(A) as a function of modified waxy corn starch weight fraction (17). It may be assumed that the first phase observed for the modified com starch - the com starch is constituted of about 25 % of amylose and 75 % of amylopectin - is representative of the formation of inclusion complexes, with a hight affinity constant with amylose. T h e formation of inclusion complexes between several aroma compounds and the helicoidal conformation of potato starch molecules is well documented (18-20). The main parameter involved in the fixation being the structure of the helice in one hand, the molecular size and the polarity of ligands in the other hand. The second category of interactions with a low affinity constant may be explained by the binding of volatile molecules to the surface of the amylose helice or to the amylopectin chains. The waxy corn starch is constituted by 100% of amylopectin. However it was recently reported that the binding at the surface of amylase is hightly improbable and that a part of amylopectin is able to be imply in the formation of inclusion complexes (20). Unspecific interactions and particularly interactions with lipids present in corn starch may also contribute to the depression of volatile compound concentration in the gas phase.
1180 3 ^ . Interactions with dextrin The dextrin used (Tackidex JO60 K® Roquette freres) is a corn dextrin with a good solubility a n d a low viscosity in aqueous solution. The results concerning the interactions between this dextrin and limonene and ethyl hexanoate are given Figure 6.
0,00
0,01
0,02
0,03
0.04
0,05
0,06
weight fraction of dextrin
Figure 6. Variations of the reduced activity coeficient of ethyl hexanoate (A)and limonene ( • ) as a function of dextrin Tackidex JO60 K® weight fraction (17). For the two volatile compounds a linear decrease of y^ir as a function of increasing quantities of dextrin was observed. This result, in good agreement with previously reported data (22,23), is indicative of the existence of ouly one kind of interactions. Important differences may be noticed according to the nature of the volatile compounds. For a weight fraction of dextrin equal to 0.05 a 25 % decrease of the activity coefficient of ethyl hexanoate was noticed, this decrease is less important that the decrease observed for the same weight fraction of modified com starch. In the contrary the depressive effect on limonene is much more important in the presence of dextrin (50 %) than in the presence of modified corn starch. 3.3. Interactions with galactomannans Galactomannans, the main polysaccharides present in locust and guar flours are constituted by linear chains of fi-D-mannans linked in a(l-4) and irregularly substituted by galactose units Hnked in a(l-6). These compounds are used as stabilizers in foods.
1181 The curves obtained for the variations of yoo^r versus the weight fraction of the two galactomannans are simular for a same volatile compounds. The most important depressive effect was obtained when Umonene is used. 70 % of decrease for a weight fraction of hydrocoUoids less than 0.01. Only 25 to 40 % is reached when the volatile compounds used is ethyl hexanoate in the same conditions, morever the initial decrease is followed by a plateau. However the observed decrease of the volatility may be the result of the viscosity increase of the medium. Several authors (24,25) have established a connection b e t w e e n t h e i n c r e a s e of viscosity in t h e presence of galactomannans and the decrease of the sensory properties of the product. In the contrary according to Pangborn and Szczesmak (26) the decrease of odor and flavor intensities observed in the presence of hydrocoUoids is relatively independent of the viscosity and specific of the combination hydrocoUoidaroma compounds. The plateau obtained when the aroma compound used is ethyl hexanoate may be the result of mass transport limitations when the weight fractions of galactomann is increased. 3.4. Interactions with hydroxypropyl celluloses The general shape of the curves obtained when solutions of hydroxypropyl cellulose are used (Fig 7) is similar to t h a t obtained with galactomannans.
Figure 7. Variations of the reduced activity coeficient of ethyl hexanoate (A)and limonene ( • ) as a function of hydroxy propyl cellulose J K 491 per cent. According to the great variation of the viscosity developped by the two hydroxypropyl celluloses, 3.65 mPa.s for AA 111 and 348 m Pa.s for J K 491 for 2 % solutions it may be assumed that the observed decrease of yooj^ is not the consequence of the increase of viscosity. Moreover Richon et al (27) have report that valid infinite dilution activity coefficient may be obtained for viscous media, up to 1000 mPa.s when a special
1182 equilibrium cell was used as in the present work. In these conditions the depressive effect observed in the presence of hydroxypropyl celluloses are probably the result of interactions between these compounds and volatils compounds. 3.5. Interactions with dextrans Dextrans with molecular weight between 60 000 and 90 000 and 100 000 and 200 000 were used. As previously reported by King (23) and increase of "/^ir, indicative of a saltingout effect, was noticed (Fig 8). 1.8
•
:
1,6 J
•
ft ft
•
I
1,4 J
/iT" U-
1 m) • 1,0 ^HK^ 0,00
I
0,02
«
I
i
I1
'
T "— ,
0,04 0,06 0,08 weight fraction of dextran
J
0,10
,
0,12
Figure 8. Variations of the reduced activity coeficient of ethyl hexanoate ( • ) and limonene ( • ) as a function of dextran (MW 100 000 and 200 000) weight fraction (17).
3.6. Interactions with B-cydodextrins As for modified corn starch two slopes are detected in the curves giving the decrease of yooj^ of limonene and B-ionone as a function of fi-cyclodextrin per cent in the solution (Fig 9).
1183
0,75
0,50
0.25
0.25
Figure 9. Variations of the reduced activity coeficient of fi-ionone ( • )and limonene ( • ) as a function of B-cyclodextrin per cent. The important decrease of aroma compounds volatility detected at low Bcyclodextrin per cent is probably the result of the formation of 1-1 inclusion complexes (25 ). On the other hand the slow decrease may be the consequence of t h e adsorption of aroma compounds at the surface of the 6-cyclodextrin molecule or of the formation of inclusion complexes with a stcechiometry different from 1. 4. QUANTITATIVE STUDY BY DCCLC 4.1. Association constant between aroma compoiuids and dextrin The results obtained with limonene using dextrin solutions from 0.5 to 5 % are given table 1. The fact that no significative differences between the values was noticed shows t h a t the association constant of complexes is independent of the dextrin concentration.
1184 Table 1. Association constants (M"l) for dextrin-limonene complex as a function of dextrin per cent. dextrin per cent
Ka (M"l)
0.5 1.0
15 607 ± 2 094 16122 ± 2 573
2.5
13 316 1713
5.0
11963 ±603
In the case of 13-ionone (table 2) a regular decrease of the association constant when the elution volume is increased. According to Blyshak et al . (16) this phenomena is indicative of an irreversible adsorption of 6-ionone on dextrin molecules. Table 2. Association constants (M"l) for dextrin-B-ionone complex as a function of the elution volume (dextrin per cent: 2.5).
elution volimie (mL)
40 120 200 280
Ka (M"l)
31 3028 2728 2395
4.2. Association constant between aroma compounds and fi-cyclodextrin The determination of the association constants between limonene or fiionone and fi-cyclodextrin was performed for several fi-cyclodextrin percent, 0.01 and 0.5 % in the first case, 0.05 and 0.1 % in the second case. For the two compounds a decrease of the calculated association constant when the elution volume is increased (Fig 10, 11) is noticed. This decrease is associated to a sealing of the generator column probably by the insoluble complexes.
1185 1CCC
Eluticn volume "nir)
Figure 10. Variations of the association constant for 6-cyclodextrin/ fi-ionone complexes as a function of the elution volume for two B-cyclodextrin per cent (•)lg/L,(D)5g/L. bwCC i 5CCC -
N.
k
4CCC -
3CCG -
a •
"..
2CCC -
• \ l
1CCC 10C
2CC
3CC
^OC
5CC
6CC
Elution volume (mT!
Figure 11. Variations of the association constant for B-cyclodextrin/ limonene complexes as a function of the elution volume for two B-cyclodextrin per cent (A)0.5gn.,(B)lg/L. Association constant between B-cyclodextrin and aroma compounds giving soluble complexes such as 2-methoxynaphtalene, ethyl salicylate or 1-menthol were obtained using DCCLC (28).
1186 References 1. J.E. Kinsella and S. Damodaran.in Foods and Beverages. Acad. Press, New York, 1980, p 95. 2. S. Damodaran and J.E. Kinsella, J. Agric. Food Chem., 1983, 31, 856. 3. K.L.F. Franzen and J.E. Kinsella, J. Agric. Food Chem., 1974, ^ , 675. 4. H. Staudinger and M. Staudinger, Makromol. Chem. 1953,^,148. 5. M. Ulmann and F. Schierbaum, KoUoid Z. ,1958,156,156 6. H.G. Maier, Angew. Chem. Interat. , 1970, 9,917 7. J.C. Leroi, J.C. Masson, H. Renon, J.F. Fabries and H. Sannnier. Ind. Eng. Chem. Process. Des. Dev., 1977,16,135. 8. P. Duhem. Contribution a Tetude des melanges **eau-hydrocarburessolvant polaire". Representation des equilibres de phases par le modele NRTL. These Aix-Marseille H, 1979. 9. A. Sadafian and J. Crouzet. Flav. Frag. J., 1987, 2,103. 10. F. Sorrentino, A. Voilley, D. Richon. AIChE, 1986, ^ , 1988. 11. A. Sadafian and J. Crouzet.in Progress in Terpen Chemistry. Ed. Frontieres, Gif sur Yvette, 1986, p 165. 12. A. Lebert and D. Richon. J. Food Sci., 1984, ^ , 1301. 13. A. Lebert and D. Richon. J. Agric. Food Chem., 1984, ^ , 1151. 14. W.E. May, S.R Wasik and D.H. Freeman. Anal. Chem., 1978, 50,175. 15. W.E. May, S.R Wasik and D.H. Freeman. Anal. Chem., 1978, 50,997. 16. L.A. Blishak, K.Y. Dodson, G. Patonay; I.M. Warner and W.E. May Anal. Chem., 1989, 61,955. 17 S. Langourieux and J. Crouzet, Lebens.-Wiss. u Technol.,1994, in press 18. F. Osman-Ismail.and J. Solms, Lebens.-Wiss. u Technol.,1973, 6,147. 19. M.A. Rutschmann ,J. Heiniger,V. Pliska, and J. Solms,. Lebens.-Wiss. u Technol. 1989, ^ , 240. 20. M.A. Rutschmann and J. Solms, Lebens.-Wiss. u Technol.,1990, 23, 70. 21. M.A. Rutschmann and J. Solms, Lebens.-Wiss. u Technol.,1990,^, 83. 22. A. Lebert and D. Richon, J. Agric. Food Chem.,1984, S , 1156. 23. C.J.King,in Physical Properties of Food. AVI Publication Company, Westport CT,1983, p 399). 24. K. Paulus and E.M. Hass, J. Text. Stud., 1970 J , 502. 25. Y. Malkki, R.L. Heino, and K; Autio, Food Hydrocoll., 1993, 6, 525. 26. R. M. Pangbornand A.S. Szczesniak, J. Text Stud., 1974,4,467. 27. D. Richon, F. Sorrentino and A. Voilley, Ind. Eng. Chem. Des. Dev. , 1985,J4,1160 28. S. Langourieux. Interactions Ligand-Recepteur : Cas des Composes d'Arome en Solutions Aqueuses. These Montpellier II, 1993.
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
Water and ethanol adsorption biomass separation systems
on
starchy
1187
substrates
as
G. Vareli, P. G. Demertzis and K. Akrida-Demertzi
Laboratory of Food Chemistry, Department of Chemistry, University of loannina, 45110-loannina, Greece
Abstract Adsorption of water and ethanol on corn meal and wheat flour has been studied in the temperature range of 50-90 ^C using inverse gas chromatography (IGC). The results showed that adsorption of water was affected more significantly by the kind of starchy adsorber than the adsorption of ethanol. Values for thermodynamic parameters such as Gibb's free energy (AGs) and enthalpy (heat) (AHs) corresponding to sorption of water and ethanol by the substrates have been calculated using chromatographic retention data. It was found that adsorption was more spontaneous at lower temperatures as expected.
1.
INTRODUCTION
Interest in the production of energy from renewable resources was prompted by the 1973 oil crisis. For automotive transport, liquid fuels are considered essential, and ethanol derived from sugar or starch by hydrolysis and fermentation is one of the most studied renewable alternatives. Although the economics of pure ethanol as a fuel look less attractive at present, there is a growing interest in oxygenated organics as replacers for lead tetra-ethyl in high octane gasoline, and again ethanol is one of the contenders. Alcohols can be produced from either grains or biomass by first converting these materials to fermentable sugars [ 1-4 ]. The sugars are then fermented, typically with yeast, to give a broth containing 6 to 12 persent ethanol along with small amounts of aldehydes, ketones, amyl alcohols (fusel oils), and methanol [ 5 ].
1188 The final step, distillation to water-free alcohol, consumes 50 to 80 percent of the energy used in a typical fermentation ethanol manufacturing process [ 6,7 ], which is a major problem in the use of fermentation ethanol as a liquid fuel [ 6-8 ]. Recovery of ethanol from the fermentation broth is at least a three-step process: (a) distillation of dilute aqueous ethanol to its azeotrope ( 95.57 percent ethanol by weight ), (b) distillation using a third component - either an organic solvent or a strong salt solution- to break up the azeotrope and remove the remaining water, and (c) distillation to separate water from the third component so that it can be recycled. Trace constituents, including pentanol (fusel oil) and methanol, can be removed by additional distillation, but this is not necessary for ethanol to be blended with gasoline. Ladisch and Dyck [ 9 ] reported that most of the energy consumption occurs in the first stage when raising the distillate composition above about 85% ethanol. They and other investigators have proposed adsorption as an alternative to distillation, either by adsorbing alcohol from dilute aqueous solution, or by adsorbing water from a richer alcohol-water mixture. The alternative process, adsorption of water from ethanol, is in large-scale commersial use in the United States, and has been studied in the vapor phase by certain investigators in Purdue University [ 9,10-14]. They proposed a system in which distillation was used to concentrate the fermentation broth to between 75 and 90% ethanol, followed by treatment with a water-selective adsorbent such as CM cellulose, cornstarch, CaO etc. The system seems very promising, and can produce 99% ethanol with an energy consumption of about 3.9 MJ Kg'^-I compared with values of 6-9 MJ Kg'^-I for a distillation process. Although materials such as cornmeal and potato starch have been used as adsorbents [ 15,16 ], no systematic efforts have been made to elucidate the selectivity of these substrates, the effects of its composition and temperature on the relative separation potential of starch based materials. In this paper, an in depth study of the adsorption behavior of water and ethanol on corn meal and wheat flour of greek origin in the range of temperature 5090 oC using inverse gas chromatography (IGC ) is reported.
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS Inverse gas chromatography Inverse gas chromatography Is a well established technique and its main focus is the investigation of the interaction of solutes with a substrate which
1189 comprises the stationary phase of a gas chromatographic column [ 17-20 ]. If very small amounts of a solute are used, then the solute undergoes partitioning while being eluted. Although chromatographic systems are usually not in true equilibrium, use of small amounts of solute and low flow rates allows the approximation of equilibrium contitions. The time which elapses from injection of the sample to the recording of the peak maximum is the retention time. The net retention time is the difference between the retention of a solute and an unadsorbed
(unretained)
indicator. Air was used as the unretained compound in this work. If the net retention times of two solutes are compared, a separation factor can be obtained S= tNl/tN2
(1)
where : s is the separation factor, tNi is the retention time of the first solute, and tN2 is the net retention time of the second solute. It is also possible to obtain thermodynamic parameters using IGC. The volume of carrier gas which is necessary to elute an adsorbed solute from the column under the specific conditions of temperature and pressure of the column is called net retention volume and is calculated from the following equation : VN = i F c ( t R - t A )
(2)
where : Fc is the corrected flow rate at the conditions of the oven : Tov{Po-Pw) Fc=
(3) F
Tf,Po
F is the flow rate measured at the flow meter conditions, Tov is the temperature of the oven, Tfi is the temperature of the flow meter, Po is the outlet pressure of the column, Pw is the vapor pressure of water inside the soap bubble flow meter. Parameter j is the compressibility factor:
1190
j=
3 —
(Pi/Po)2-1
(4)
{Pi/Po)3-1
where : Pi is the column inlet pressure. The specific retention volume Vg° is the net retention volume corrected to standard temperature and pressure and is given by the following equation: VN 273.15 Vg°=
(5)
w^T
where : Ws is the weight of stationary phase and T is the temperature of the column. The partition coefficient Kp is calculated from : VgOpT Kp
(6) 273.15
where p is the density of the packing material. The free energy of adsorption, AGs°, of a solute on the column packing can be estimated using: AGs = RT InKp
(7)
the heat (enthalpy) of adsorption AHs is given by AHs R
d In VgO
(8)
d1/T
Preparation of columns Corn meal and wheat flour of 70% rate extraction were purchased from a local supermarket. Samples were dried in a vacuum oven at 50 ^C for 24h, then dessicated for 1 h. The 60-80 Mesh fractions were obtained and stored in the
1191 dessicator. The samples prepared in this way were diluted with an inert support, Chromosorb WAW, DMCS, 60-80 Mesh, purchased by Serva Germany. The inert support was dried under the same conditions and stored in a dessicator. To make retention time measurements with water, samples were diluted to 10 parts to 90 parts of inert support. The dilution was necessary because of the very long water retention times on starch-based materials which would otherwise make the experiments extremely time consuming. This proved to be a negligible source of error since water retention times on 100% Chromosorb WAW columns ranged from 0.07 min/ g at 90 ^C to 0.08 min/ g at 50C, while water retention times on food substrates ranged from 10.3 min/ g at 90 ^C to 48.5 min/ g at 50 ^C. To make ethanol retention times measurements, 50% starch-based material and 50% inert support columns were constructed. The greater percentage of starch was necessary because of relatively small retention times on both inert support and starchy materials. The retention time per gram for a 100% starchy material column (tNs/g) was estimated from the following equation:
( t N T - tNA/g M A ) tNs/g=
(9) Ms
where, tNj is the net retention time of the solute in the diluted sample column, T N A/g is the net retention time per gram of the solute in the 100% Chromosorb column at the same temperature as the diluted sample column. MA is the mass of the Chromosorb in the diluted sample column, Ms is the mass of the starch in the diluted sample column. The density
of the two starchy
materials was determined with a
stereopycnometer (model SPY-3, Quantachrome,USA ) and the average values of several measurements were 1.462 ml/ g for cornmeal and 1.490 ml/ g for wheat flour. Aluminium tubing was used for the construction of chromatographic columns with a 6.35-mm o.d. and a length of 1m. To begin packing the columns, the tubing was straightened, silane treated glass wool was used to plug one end, and this same end was attached to a vacuum pump. The container holding the stationary phase was weighed. A few grams were put in the column and packing was accomplished with the aid of a mechanical vibrator. The supported stationary phase was continually added and packed until the column was filled, at which time the container was weighed again. The other end of the column was sealed with glass wool; the column was then twisted into spiral form and placed in the chromatograph with only its inlet
1192 port connected. Each analytical column was conditioned at least 12 h by passing helium carrier gas through the column.
GC instrumentation A Shimadzu 8A gas chromatograph was used equipped with a thermal conductivity detector. The reference column was prepared in the same way as the analytical columns . Pressure was regulated with a two-stage regulator and set at 6 Kg / cm'^2. Inlet pressure to the column was determined by connecting a U-type mercury manometer to the inlet part of the oven. The manometer was allowed 5 min to equilibrate. Pressure drops in the column ranged from 0.19 atm to 0.338 atm depending on the flow rate of the carrier gas. The thermal conductivity detector temperature was set at 200 o C. The injection port was also set at the same temperature. The carrier gas velocities ( flow rates ) were measured with a soap bubble flow meter attached to the thermal conductivity detector outlet and adjusted to 35 ml/ min. Flow rates were determined for each column at each temperature after a steady baseline of the recorder indicated equilibration of the column. Injection port septa were conditioned at the temperature of the oven and changed every 40-50 injections, or when leaking was apparent by visual inspection. A 5|il syringe was used to inject 2^1 of the sample into the chromatograph.
3. RESULTS
AND
DISCUSSION
Figures 1 and 2 show the net retention time per gram of material for water and ethanol with both materials studied (corn meal and wheat flour), in the temperature range 50 - 90 ^C. It is observed that the net retention times of water are higher than those of ethanol at all temperatures and for both substrates. A second observation is that net retention times for both water and ethanol decrease as the temperature increases, but for water the decrease is more rapid than for ethanol. For example, the net retention time of water for wheat flour decreases from approx. 48.5 min/ g at 50 ^C to approx. 10.3 min/ g at 90 ^C, while the net retention time of ethanol for the same material decreases from approx. 0.11 min/ g at 50 ^C to approx. 0.05 min/ g at 90 ^c. Another observation is that retention times for water are higher for wheat flour, as compared to the respective for corn meal. For example, at 50 ^C the net retention time for wheat flour is approx. 48.5 min/g, while the respective one for corn meal is approx. 18.5min/g. This could be partially attributed to the higher fat content of corn
1193 50
O -O-
Wheat flour
-ffl—
Corn meal
40 H c
E <
o DC
30
LU Q-
LU
^ H Z O F Iz LU H
O 20
LU
OC h-
LU Z
10
I
40
50
I
60
I
70
I
80
90
100
TEMPERATURE,*'C
Figure 1. Net retention time per gram of material for water on wheat flour and corn meal.
1194 0.12 -H— O
"O-
corn meal wheat flour
0.1
O c E III
0.08 H
H Z O LJ
I-
LU
CC I-
0.06
LU
0.04
0.02
— I —
40
50
I
— I —
60
70
~n— 80
— I —
90
100
TEMPERATURE, ^'C
Figure 2. Net retention time per gram of material for ethanol on wheat flour and corn meal.
1195 500
<>
-m-
corn meal
•-0-
wheat flour
400
b. DC
O
o
h-
o < z g
300
< cc <
o
Q_ LU CO
200
100
40
I
50
—r60
I
I
I
70
80
90
100
TEMPERATURE, "C
Figure 3. Separation factor s for water and ethanol on wheat flour and corn meal
1196 meal. On the other hand, the net retention times of ethanol are also higher in case of wheat flour but the differences are less pronounced. To understand the separation potential of water from ethanol, a comparison of net retention times of water and ethanol by taking the ratio of the net retention time per gram of water to the net retention time per gram of ethanol is necessary (Fig. 3). From this figure it is obvious that this ratio, called separation factor s, becomes greater as the temperature decreases. For example, at 90 o C the separation factor for corn meal is equal to 152, while at 50 ^C it becomes 245. Greater values for separation factor s were obtained for wheat flour, suggesting better separation of the two solutes on this material than on corn meal. More specifically, at 90 ^C the separation factor for wheat flour is 193 and by lowering the temperature to 50^0 it increases to 452. This was expected, because as it was noticed above, the net retention time for water is affected more from the type of material than is the net retention time of ethanol.The above observations lead to the suggestion that wheat flour at 50 ^C, proves to have the higher separation factor. To gain a more detailed understanding of the adsorption process of the two solutes, two thermodynamic parametes were calculated from the specific retention volumes. The first thermodynamic parameter obtained is the free energy of adsorption, AGs°. The values of free energies of adsorption are shown in Table 1. Higher negative values are obtained for water than for ethanol, and this confirms that water is adsorbed more strongly than ethanol in all temperatures and by both materials. Besides, for both the solutes, it is shown that lower temperatures are more favourable for their adsorption, which is stronger for wheat flour than for corn meal. The second thermodynamic parameter is the enthalpy (heat) of adsorption, AHs. In figure 4, InVgO is plotted vs. 1/ T (eq.8), and the slope of the line is equal to AHs/ R. Values of enthalpies of sorption are reported in Table 2. Heats of adsorption of water are - 8.19 Kcal / gmol for corn meal and -9.16 Kcal / gmol for wheat flour. These values show that water is adsorbed more strongly by wheat flour. For ethanol, heats of adsorption are - 5.44 Kcal / gmol for corn meal and 5.81 Kcal / gmol for wheat flour. Although for ethanol the negative value of heat of adsorption is higher for wheat flour, the difference of the enthalpies between the two materials is not so pronounced. This suggests that adsorption of ethanol is not affected significantly by the kind of substrate used. Moreover, the AHs° values obtained are within the range of the average physical adsorption values (3- 9 kcal/gmol), but significantly smaller than chemisorption where typical heats of adsorption are in the range 20-40 kcal/gmol [21].
1197 Table 1 Free energy of adsorption, AGs° ( Kcal / gmol).
50
Temperature (°C) 60 70 80
90
Water Corn meal Wheat flour
-4.33 -4.98
-4.18 - 4.96
4.08 - 4.84
-3.97 -4.72
-3.95 -4.57
Corn meal Wheat flour
-0.80 -1.06
- 0.62 -1.03
Ethanol - 0.47 -0.88
-0.37 -0.78
-0.32 -0.76
Table 2 Enthalpy of adsorption, AHs^,( Kcal /gmol).
corn meal
Water Ethanol
8.19 5.44
wheat flour
-9.16 -5.81
REFERENCES 1. N.P. Cheremisinoff, P.N. Cheremisinoff, and F. Ellerbusch, Biomass. Applications, Technology, and Production, Marcel Dekker, New York (1980). 2. M. R. Ladisch, Process Biochem. 14, 21 (1979). 3. G.T. Tsao, M. Ladisch, T. A. Hsu, B. Dale, T. Chou, Ann. Rep. Ferment. 2,1 (1978). 4. M. R. Ladisch, C. M. Ladisch, G. T. Tsao, Science, 201, 743 (1978). 5. L. F. Hatch, Ethyl Alcohol, Enjay Chemical Company, New York, (1962).
1198
water
• >
BB
com meal
O
wheat flour
2H
ethanol
— I —
2.7
2.8
2.9 1 / T x IC'S,
3
3.1
3.2
K'^( -1 )
Figure 4. In Vg°vs.1/ T* 10''3, for water and ethanol, on wheat flour and corn meal.
1199 6. M. L David, G. S. Hammaker, R. J. Buzenberg, J. P. Wanger, Gasohol Economic Feasibility Study, Development, Planning and Research Associates, Inc., Manhattan, Kan. (1978). 7. T. K. Ghose and R. D. Tyagi, Biotechnol. Bioeng.,21, 1387 (1979). 8. W. 0. Burrows, C. M. Hudson, M. L. Kaesser, N. A. Santer, Changing Portable Energy Sources - An Assessment, John Deere Co, Moline,lll (1977). 9. M. R. Ladisch and K. K. Dyck, Science, 205, 898 (1979). 10. M. R. Ladisch, M. Voloch, J. Hong, P. Bienkowski, and G. T. Tsao, lEC Process Des. Develop., 23, 437 (1984). 11. M. Voloch, J. Hong, avd M. R. Ladisch, Second Chemical Congress of North American Continent, Las Vegas, NV, 1980, paper 43, Microbiol.Biochem. Technol. (1980). 12. J. Hong, M. Voloch, M. R. Ladisch, and G. T. Tsao, Biotechnol. Bioeng., 24, 725 (1982). 13. P. R. Bienkowski, A Barthe, M. Voloch, R. N. Neuman, and M. R. Ladisch, Biotechnol. Bioeng., 27, 960 (1986). 14. R. Neuman, M. Voloch, P. Bienkowski, and M. R. Ladisch, lEC Fundam., 25, 422 (1986). 15. A. A. Hassaballah, and J. H. Hills, Biotechnol. Bioeng. 35, 598 (1990). 16. V. Rebar, E. R. Fischbach, D. Apostolopoulos, and J. L. Kokini, Biotechnol. Bioeng. 26, 513(1984). 17. R. J. Laub, and R. L. Pecsok, Physicochemical Applications of Gas Chromatography, Wiley, New York (1978). 18. R. L. Grob, Modern Practice of Gas Chromatography, Wiley, New York (1977). 19. V. G. Berezkin, V. R. Alishoyev, and I. B. Nemirovskaya, Gas Chromatography of Polymers, Elsevier, New York (1977). 20. V. G. Berezkin, Analytical Reaction Gas Chromatography, Plenum, New York (1982). 21. A.W. Adamson, Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, Wiley, New York (1976).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1201
SOME MULTIVARIATE PERSPECTIVES ON SHELF LIFE RESEARCH 1
2
R.H. Albert, Ph.D., and C. Zervos, Ph.D. ^US FDA/CFSAN, Washington, DC 20204 US FDA/CDER, Washington, DC 20204 (deceased) (Contents do not necessarily reflect policies and decisions of the FDA.) The purpose of statistics is not mere numbers: the purpose of statistics is understanding. As a bonus, insight and inspiration may also be achieved. Multivariate statistics is a key to understanding but it is a set of tools, not an end in itself. These tools can find, and indeed, have found, application in most aspects of shelf life studies. Some specific areas may be cited here:the chemical analyzing of food components, the creating of relevant variables, the processing of foods, and the bringing of insights from different disciplines to bear on the problems of food technology. A. Chemical Analysis A crucial feature in shelf life research is the accurate identification of the chemicals present and the determination of their concentrations. The time course of the decomposition during the shelf life must be monitored by careful analysis of the metabolic products produced, with a view to determining the reaction kinetics of the decomposition. Whether deterioration is due to bacterial decomposition or to protein denaturation or to oxidation of linoleic acid or related unsaturated fatty acids, the researcher needs accurate and precise determination of the chemical intermediates that are involved in the complex process of food spoilage. Even such a routine problem of improving the resolution of the peaks in gas chromatograms has been attacked using multivariate techniques. Morgan and Deming {S.L. Morgan and S. N. Deming, J. Chromatogr. 112, 267-286 (1975)} determined optimal instrument settings, using a multivariate technique called simplex optimization {W. Spendley, G. R. Hext, and F.R. Himsworth, Technometrics, 4, 441-461(1962)}. Youden {W.J. Youden,"Critical Evaluation (Ruggedness) of an Analytical Procedure," in "Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemical Analysis, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1966, pp. 755-788} has popularized the standard statistical technique known as fractional factorial design, whereby chemical analysis methods are pre-optimized prior to being subjected to interlaboratory validation. Called by Youden "ruggedizing", this multivariate approach is an integral part of the AOAC International [formerly Association of Official Analytical Chemists] protocol for development of chemical analysis methods for regulating foods and drugs. To avoid "statistics shock" that could frighten away chemists , Youden furnished a "template" for optimizing over a
1202 set of up to seven operating variables, provided that the variables could take on only two states. Typical of such "binary" or two state control variables are temperature(high/low), solvent (ethanol/water), flow rate (fast/slow), and pressure(high/low). The variables ("features") need not be such mundane entities: they could be weighted sums of such mundane entities. In this way the researcher might find the fractional factorial exploration might be more effective if, say, principal components were used. The template from Youden consists of a prescribed set of 8 experiments to be run, each experiment having a different combination of binary states for each of the 7 variables. A more complete menu of experimental designs can be found in the text by Haaland {Perry D. Haaland, "Experimental Design in Biotechnology",Marcel Dekker,New York (1989)}. This text includes the "Plackett-Burman designs",which include an 12-experiment design for 8 variables. Even now such pragmatic simplifications as those made by Youden are needed to bring the benefits of multivariate statistics to those involved in food chemistry, and in particular to those involved in investigating shelf life. As Aishima and Nakai {Tetsuo Aishima and Shuryo Nakai, Food Reviews International, 7(1), 33-101(1991)} state, "When a new idea is introduced.., a strong suspicion of its practical value among scientists [develops and].. chemometrics[=multivariate statistics applied to chemical problems]... is still unpopular among flavor researchers." Calibration curves{D.L. Massart, B.G.M. Vandeginste, S.N. Deming, Y. Mischotte, and L. Kaufman, "Chemometrics: a Textbook", Elsevier, Amsterdam (1988)} have the potential of being more effective and less liable to noise and interferences when multivariate techniques are used. Fatty acids may absorb at more than one infrared frequency and by utilizing more than one of the peaks, in particular by using a weighted sum of the absorption peak areas, as the y-variable to plot vs. the true concentration or true concentration added as the x-variable. Obviously, such an approach can be applied as well to other absorption spectroscopies and even to mass spectroscopy. Meglen {Robert R. Meglen, Fresenius J. Anal. Chem, 338, 363367(1990)} has reported on the use of principal component analysis for multivariate quality control of food reference samples. He was able to uncover anomalous samples and to find suggestive groupings of the samples into meaningful clusters. For this particular study, he was concerned with how closely food reference materials match corresponding real foods. In addition, the author offers the tantalizing prospect, with some hypothetical sketches, of how principal components can be used for multicomponent data from foods to quantify the effectiveness of the standard reference materials being used. In the use of such standard reference materials, it is essential that the profile of the reference standard as to analytes and their concentration approximate as closely as possible the actual food matrix. Consider how inefficient and costly it would be to create one single reference material for just one analyte at a
1203 time. By thinking globally, by using a multivariate approach, optimal multipurpose reference standards can be developed. The author's work vividly illustrates how we need multivariate techniques in order to catch up with the large data bases now becoming available from our instruments. A more general discussion by the same author {R. R. Meglen, Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 3,17-29(1988)} treats of the role of chemometrics in chemical and measurement sciences. Currie {Lloyd A. Currie, "The Importance of Chemometrics in Biomedical Measurements"(chapter 6, pp. 74-100) in "Biological Trace Elements Research: Multidisciplinary Perspectives", edited by K. S. Subramanian, G.V. Iyengar, and K. Okamoto,ACS Symposium Series 445, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC (1991)}, in a review chapter, gives a good example of the use of the Youden ruggedizing approach in an air pollution study. He also gives an example of the simplex technique for optimizing instrument operating conditions and settings. Furthermore, he discusses multivariate quality control. Thus, he touches upon the key points addressed in this chapter. Even the basic processes of designing chemical determinations and evaluating the results can be improved by application of multivariate statistical techniques. Resistance to these techniques will wear away as their utility becomes evident and as the flood of data from our instruments force new perspectives on data processing, to go from raw data to meaningful information. B.DESIGNING RELEVANT VARIABLES Clearly multivariate statistical techniques can facilitate measuring chemical concentration. Now it will be shown that these techniques can be used as well to develop meaningful variables that go beyond mere individual chemical concentrations. Consider for example the problem of measuring rancidity. Oxidative rancidity in fats and oils has been with us since prehistoric times. Surely one of the reasons that the Europeans of Columbus' time were so avid for the spices of the Orient was to cover up the off-flavor and off-smell of meat in those prerefrigerator days. The efficacy of smoking meat, which deposits antioxidative phenols, must have been a serendipitous discovery. Typical rancidity is a result of a complex sequence of oxidations of fats and oils; consequently when a quantitative measure of rancidity is called for, some measure of extent of oxidation is thereby needed. Gray {J.I. Gray, "Simple Chemical and Physical Methods for Measuring Flavor Quality of Fats and Oils", chapter 12, pp. 223239, of "Flavor Chemistry of Fats and Oils, edited by David B. Min and Thomas H. Smouse, American Oil Chemists' Society (1985)} lists 5 analytical chemical procedures for assessing the extent of oxidation of fats and fat-containing foods. These methods are: peroxide value, TBA(thiobarbituric acid), carbonyl value.
1204 anisidine value, and the Kreis test result. Each of these tests actually detects a different aspect of the oxidation process. For example, the much-used TBA essentially just measures the malonaldehyde concentration in the food matrix. The author mentions some objections to this measure of rancidity, among them being the possibility of other materials absorbing at the 532 nm peak, where the TBA-malonaldehyde complex is traditionally measured. The complex also has an absorbance peak at 550 nm. Doesn't this suggest that some combination of the two peaks might be used to determine the concentration of the TBA-malonaldehyde complex? Pohle et al.{W. D. Pohle, R. L. Gregory, and B. Van Giessen, JAOCS 41, 649-?(1964)} did find that the flavor score could be estimated from the TBA value for the fats and oil that they studied. Similarly, the peroxide number could be used to predict what the flavor score would be. All 5 tests simply measure different aspects of oxidative degradation, like the five blind men describing an elephant. The peroxide test actually measures the concentration of the hydroperoxides that are the initial products of lipid oxidations but these are transitory and unstable. If it is assumed that the flavor score has some objectively-verifiable consistent meaning, the problem of combining the five measures to give a better fit to the flavor score would be an interesting research problem. Hopefully some of the weighting factors would be so small that those particular measures could be omitted as being insignificant. Multivariate techniques would also show which of the 5 measures are so highly correlated that some might be redundant and need not be considered. In short it might be fruitful to combine the scores for each of the measures for rancidity to create a new measure of rancidity. To further refine this rancidity assessment, the measures from the "dynamic methods" listed by Gray could be included: Schaal oven test, active oxygen methods, and various oxygen absorption tests. Even the results of standard spectroscopic and polarographic techniques could be incorporated into this suggested multivariate measure of rancidity. How important such a refinement of the rancidity measure might be is seen in the work of Verma et al. (Meat Sci. 14, 91-?,(1985), as reported by Ledward {Dave Ledward,Food Science & Technology Today, 1(3), 153-155(1987)}. The problem addressed was the role of iron-containing proteins (hemoproteins) in lipid oxidation during the spoilage of raw meat. The investigation entailed the study of the catalytic effect of various hemoglobin and myoglobin derivatives on the formation of thiobarbituric acid reactive compounds. Thus, the TBA score, as is usual, was used as a surrogate for the extent of rancidity. Despite the imprecision of such a measure, Verma et al. apparently were able to show that the ferric containing hemoproteins were the major catalysts for oxidative degradation. Duerr and Schobinger{P. Duerr and U. Schobinger, pp.179193,"Flavour '81", 3rd Weurman Symposium, Proceedings of the International Conference, Munich April 28-30,1981, ed. by Peter Schreier, Walter de Gruyter,New York (1981)} claim that about 330
1205 volatiles have been found in orange fruit and juice. Since offflavor in orange juice is indicated by the presence of alphaterpineol, the authors plotted the concentration of this volatile material in orange juice as a function of time, up to 90 days for storage temperatures of 4°, 20°, and 32° Centigrade in cardboard packages and in a glass bottle. Their conclusion was that the increase of alpha-terpineol was linear over 90 days and was strong in the glass bottled juice. As part of their shelf life experiments, they noted that neral and octanal decreased in the course of time over 90 days of storage and that, as expected, the decrease was greater at the higher temperatures. Why not sum up with appropriate coefficients the concentrations of these three well-defined volatiles—alpha-terpineol, neral, and octanal—to obtain a possibly more effective and reliable measure of orange juice deterioration? Such a synthetic variable may or may not have a physical interpretation. As in much of multivariate research, the scientist deals interactively with the statistical results and brings to bear his/her own skill and knowledge. Exploration is often necessary to seek reasonable conclusions. Multivariate statistics does not invariably give the right answer, but it does provide more choices for the statistician. In the case of apple juice, the authors report the work of Koch et al. who found that a simple sum of the 2-hexenal and 2-hexenol concentrations is highly correlated to the intensity of apple juice essence. In other words, the Koch composite variable, that could be used to monitor deterioration in apple juice, is simply : new variable = .5 x hexenal concentration + .5 x hexenol concentration= the simple average of the two concentrations. The researcher is invited to let his/her imagination soar above routine, one-variable-at-a-time computations, one variable at a time. Even in multivariate statistics, the imagination can come into play: an initial transformation of the raw data may provide more tractable variables, even prior to data reduction and manipulation via statistics. For example, a logarithm of a variable may be a better representation of reality than just the simple variable. In his study of off-flavors in canned beef sterilized by heat. Von Sydow{E. Von Sydow, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B. 191, 145-153(1975)} found a linear relation between the so called "retort off-flavor" and the following variable: the square root of the product of the hydrogen sulfide concentration and the 2-methylthiophene concentration. Another example of the need for a created variable arises from the term "shelf life" itself. People in the field would agree that the word puts too much emphasis on the time aspect and that other factors should be considered as well. Certainly temperature or storage temperature is crucial to how well a stored food or drug retains its desirable features. In fact, reality is a bit more complicated as far as temperature goes: a typical product may undergo several temperature environments as it goes from manufacturer to truck to warehouse to retailer. So temperature history is a factor. In fact, such a time-temperature-history based variable would be pertinent to the cyclic refrigeration
1206 scheme proposed by Scott,Steffe and Heldman {E. P. Scott, J. F. Steffe, and D.R. Heldman, in "Changing Food Technology",pp.189208, edited by M. Kroger and A. Freed, Technomic Publishing Co.,Lancaster, PA (1989)}. Also relevant to quality retention are the conditions under which the product is kept by the consumer after purchase. Certainly, a variable analogous to degree-days would be a less-misleading and a more informative indicator of durability than would a mere declaration of some expiration date or time period. Handling, processing, additives, acidity, and wrapping are among other key factors that need to be considered when trying to quantify the durability of the desirable features of a food or drug product. A composite score might be feasible that would in effect be a linear discriminant function, serving to indicate when the values taken on by the environmental factors/time /processing / etc. cause this function to exceed some critical value. Karel{Marcus Karel, Chapter 17, "Focal Issues in Food Science and Engineering", in "Food Product Development", ed. by Ernst Gaf and Israel Sam Saguy, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York(1991)} echoes the fact that shelf life is a function not simply of time but of conditions of storage. He alludes to a device that can be scanned at the checkout counter to indicate not only how long the product has been on the shelf but also the temperature conditions the product has been exposed to. The readout consists of the number of "equivalent shelf days"—a parameter that provides a measure of both time-on-shelf and abuse. A critical value for this designed variable can be determined to warn the consumer. Of course, nature does not usually make abrupt jumps: the transition from acceptable quality to unacceptable quality is arbitrary but the line must be drawn somewhere and thinking in terms of a linear discriminant function may help draw that line. Multivariate statistics can certainly help in determining a flavor score, that evanescent quantity often determined by the opinion of expert or not-so-expert panels. D. Thompson {David Thompson,Food Science and Technology Today 3(2),83-88(1989)} has been advocating a special multivariate approach to sensory panel evaluation. This approach, called Generalized Procrustes Analysis (GPA), differs from the usual flavor scoring. In the typical panel set up, a common set of vocabulary terms is established and the panel members are instructed on how to assign a score for each component of a flavor (e.g.,fruitiness, tartness, etc.) in the food items being tested. The GPA approach lets each panelist establish his/her own idiosyncratic set of variables and via a computer-intensive technique called multidimensional scaling the score space of each of the panelists is rotated to maximize the geometric similarity of the different spaces. Once a consensus score space is obtained, then the usual principal component analysis to adjust for correlations among the flavor components is performed. Use of principal components, that is, the use of special linear combinations of the separate flavor component scores may reduce the number of factors that need to be considered and my indicate superfluous variables and might point
1207 to suggestive high correlations among some of the flavor components. A recent book dedicated to application of multivariate statistics to sensory data has been written by Burgard and Kuznicki{David R. Burgard and James T. Kuznicki,"Chemometrics: Chemical and Sensory Data",CRC Press, Boca Raton (1990)}. It strives to bridge the gaps among analytical chemistry, sensory evaluation, and multivariate statistics. Individual chapters are dedicated to correlation and regression, discriminant analysis, and factor analysis. Factor analysis is the multivariate technique that is the most concerned with uncovering new variables but it is not primarily a routine tool. The mathematics can be formidable, even for a statistician, and a great demand is made on the researcher's creativity, insight, and luck. No pat formulas or algorithms exist in factor analysis and a certain ambiguity and arbitrariness exists in the artificial constructs of this technique. For example,an example using orange tea sensory attributes is presented, for which an "orangey" construct and a "spicey" construct are produced. However, Burgard and Kuznicki attractively present factor analysis for those who might want to explore the techniques. They exhaustively work through one particular data set and teach the essential features of this challenging tool in the tool kit of multivariate statistics. We (Zervos and Albert) have written a chapter in "Off-Flavors in Foods and Beverages" {C. Zervos and R. H. Albert, "Chemometries: the Use and Multivariate Methods for the Determination and Characterization of Off-Flavors", in "Off-Flavors in Foods and Beverages", edited by G. Charalambous, Elsevier Science Publishers, Amsterdam (1992)} that gives a sample of the use of multivariate statistics in dealing with off-flavors. In this survey, the work of Bertuccioli et al. {M. Bertuccioli, G. Montedoro and S. Clementi....,(1986)} among many others, was cited as typical of the kind of multivariate applications to flavor research actually being done. In our chapter, we demonstrated how clique analysis, a specialized version of clustering that lets an element belong to more than one group, can be applied to the Bertuccioli data to gain insight into the relationships among the variables used to measure the chemicals evolved during the storage of Provolone cheese. Variables that belonged together were flagged, wherein "belonging together" could mean, under favorable circumstances, that any variable in a clique might be able to act as a surrogate for all the other variables in the same clique. Thus, multivariate statistics can not only create new variables, it can reduce the number of variables that have to be dealt with. Subsequent correlation studies of the simplified variable set with sensory data could thereby be expedited. A much more recent paper on an aging index for cheese has been reported by Banks et al.{J.M. Banks, E. Y. Brechany, W.W. Christie, E. A. Hunter, and D. D. Muir, Food Research International, 25, 365-373(1992)} , who investigated the volatile
1208 components of Cheddar cheese as indicators of cheese maturity, flavor , and odor. Thirty-one gas liquid chromatograph peaks were studied from each of 12 cheese samples. A "partial least squares analysis"(which might have actually be a canonical correlation analysis) was carried out to relate the sensory scores (19 sensory attributes were used) from various panels and the chemical composition (31 peak areas). With only 12 samples, the use of multivariate statistics may be like using a sledgehammer to crack a walnut. Nevertheless, the authors do give for the few data points involved an interesting demonstration of how some multivariate techniques might be used, especially to generate those special linear combinations called principal components. Another dairy product of crucial concern in shelf life studies is milk. Leland {J.V. Leland, G. A. Reineccius, and M. Lahiff, J. Dairy Sci. 70(3), 524-533(1987)} studied 42 samples of milk, oxidized to various degrees using copper wire mesh. The oxidized material served as a surrogate for ordinary spoiled milk, but under controlled conditions. The authors analyzed 22 components via head space gas chromatography and concurrently used a panel of five experts to evaluate the milk for quality. In this study, they employed the special linear combination of variables called a linear discriminant function. Both a principal component and a linear discriminant function are linear combinations of variables, in this case linear combinations of component concentrations. However, the "essences" are different: the principal component is intended to capture as much of the variance structure, being that linear combination with the highest variance, subject to certain restrictions. By contrast, the linear discriminant function(which is just a variable too, of course) is that combination that gives a maximum separation among the centers of gravity of the sets of points corresponding to different groups (low quality, medium quality, high quality). The linear discriminant function often has associated with it a boundary value such that if the numerical value of the function for an unknown milk sample exceeds this critical value, it is assigned to one category, "high quality" for example, and if the value is not exceeded, the sample is assigned to a different category. Principal components are used for purposes of data reduction by capturing the variance structure of the data set by means of a reduced number of variables. Linear discriminant functions serve to categorize and to separate the data into distinct a priori groupings. A good example of a linear discriminant function is to be found in an article by Nishimura and Kato{Toshihide Nishimura and Hiromichi Kato, Food Reviews International, 4(2). 175-194(1988)} on the taste of free amino acids and peptides. The authors observe that proteins without taste, when hydrolyzed by proteases, produce bitter peptides. They studied the reported decomposition during storage of miso as indicated by the change in average peptide lengths with storage time, up to 50 days. In order to predict the bitterness on any given peptide they cite from the literature a table of coefficients for each of 16 key
1209 amino acids. A linear discriminant function is given by the sum of the number of occurrences of each amino acid in a given peptide, weighted by these coefficients divided by the number of amino acid residues in the peptide. If the numerical value of this sum, that is, if the value for this linear discriminant function, exceeds 1400, then the peptide will be expected to elicit a bitter taste. A chemical explanation is available for the relative values of these coefficients or weighting factors: the bitterness of peptides is caused by the hydrophobic property of the amino acid side chain. The authors sought a quantitative description of the frequent observation that the flavors of beef, pork, and chicken are actually improved by storage at low temperatures for certain periods of time. The linear discriminant score at least provides a handle on the problem. C. MULTIVARIATE STATISTICS FOR ASSESSING PROCESSING CONDITIONS Processing conditions can have a profound effect on the quality and stability of food and drug products. A wide range of factors can be involved in carrying out a process with the result that multivariate tools are required to monitor and control them. Alt and Smith{F. B. Alt and N.D. Smith, "Multivariate Process Control,",Ch. 17, in "Quality Control and Reliability", ed. by P. R. Krishnaiah and C. R. Rao, North-Holland Press, Amsterdam (1988)} develop some multivariate process control techniques that rely on the fundamental vector of means for each of the N processing conditions and on the corresponding N x N variancecovariance matrix. A useful way to quantify the effect of the array of processing conditions on the array of product quality indicators is the multivariate technique of canonical correlation. Canonical correlation is especially adept at relating a cluster of variables of one type with a cluster of variables of another type. Typically, one type of variable could be processing or storage conditions and the other type could be the cluster of "flavor notes" associated with the product. Also of potential value in assessing processing conditions are linear discriminant functions. These serve to delimit the values for the acceptable processing conditions, providing a multidimensional boundary between acceptable and unacceptable processing conditions. Here are some examples of multivariate processing studies. As an object lesson in how multivariate statistics might be of use, one can consider the paper by Lima and Cal-Vidal {A. W. O. Lima and J. Cal-Vidal, "Estimation of shelf life of film-packaged freeze-dried banana" in Journal of Stored Products Research 24(2),pp 73-78(1988)}, where the effect of various factors on the shelf life of film-packaged freeze-dried bananas was studied. For polyethylene films of different thicknesses, a plot is made of shelf life vs. water vapor pressure and a plot is made of
1210 shelf life vs the reciprocal temperature; a similar pair of plots is made for polypropylene files of varying thicknesses. Some three-dimensional plots might be useful to demonstrate the interactions between the factors of temperature, film thickness, and water vapor pressure as they combine to determine the shelf life. The actual estimation of the shelf life was based in part on some semi-empirical formulas for moisture transfer rates. Mittal et al.{G.S. Mittal, R. Nadulski, S. Barbut, and S. C. Negi, "textural profile analysis test conditions for meat products",Food Research International 25, 411-417(1992)} studied the effects of test conditions on the "texture profile"of three beef products: wieners, salamis and corned beef. The testing factors (which here may be viewed as processing factors) included diameter to length ratios, % compression, and the speeds of the compressing device; among the texture factors("parameters") were two different types of hardness, cohesiveness, springiness, chewiness and gumminess. Common-sense adjustment of the data, prior to analysis, was made to account for cross section area and for strain—an object lesson in the value of post-editing of raw experimental data to express the results in more meaningful terms. This was obviously a multivariate study that may or may not have benefited from application of canonical analysis. In fact, while multiple regression might have been of value, it could well be that, for a subtle reason, canonical analysis would be INAPPROPRIATE in this particular research. The hindrance is that each operating condition might be able to be assigned a level or value independently of the level or value or any of the other operating conditions. In such circumstances, the variancecovariance matrix for just the operating conditions could be manipulated to contain any values whatsoever. This would be a subtle but real violation of the assumptions underlying canonical correlation. In truth, the non-diagonal elements of the matrix for the processing factors are all zero if indeed the processing factors can be assigned values independently of one another. What the authors did calculate was the correlation of each of the separate operating conditions with each of the texture parameters. No variance-covariance matrix was used or needed by the authors. The authors could draw some valid conclusions as to the optimum testing conditions. Radiation to retard or prevent bacterial spoilage has been a controversial but often successful processing procedure. In a recent article, Narvaiz et al. {P. Narvaiz, G. Lescano, and E. Kairiyama, "Physicochemical and sensory analyses on egg powder irradiated to inactivate Salmonella and reduce microbial load",Journal of Food Safety, 112, 263-282(1992)} reported on the results of a study to identify adequate gamma radiation dose consistent with retaining egg powder quality. Four different radiation intensities were utilized to inactivate Salmonella : 0, 2, 5, and 10 kGy, where Gy represent a gray = 1 joule of absorbed energy per kilogram. These were the 4 processing conditions studies. Among the features of the resulting product measured over a 4 month period were: peroxide number, visible and
1211 ultraviolet absorption peak areas, foam stability and viscosity. Concurrently sensory panelists scored such properties as external appearance, odor, flavor, and acceptability. Microbial concentrations (MPN*s=most probable numbers) were also determined of course. No detailed attempt was made by the authors to apply multivariate techniques: each factor or feature was looked at separately, except to note that when rancidity( as measured by the peroxide number) was high so was the rejection rate by the sensory panelists. For the author's purposes, the nearlyunivariate approach used may be perfectly adequate. Four general types of quality deterioration during production, transportation, and storage are: (1) physical—e.g. drying; (2)chemical—e.g. rancidity; (3)enzymic—e.g., browning; and (4)microbiological—e.g., microorganism growth. In order to process food to ensure the removal or diminishing of this lastmentioned type of spoilage, a realistic predictive mathematical model of microbial growth and survival in foods is needed. This need has been discussed, for example, by G. Gould {Grahame Gould, "Predictive Mathematical Modelling of Microbial Growth and Survival in Foods", in "Food Science and Technology, Vol 3(2),pp 89-92,(1989)} The model must successfully predict the microbial behavior results for the many processing alternatives, including heating, irradiation, decontamination with gases, drying, acidifying, adding preservatives, decontaminating the ingredients. His work is an exemplar of how modern science now is so data-rich: he was able to capture simultaneously the growth patterns within 24 cultures with differing pH and salinity values. With the instrumentation used he could actually have studied up to 200 such cultures and could monitor the timedependence of the bacterial growth via automated optical density measurements. His report is part of a long-range data-base creation project to uncover and record the key determinants of microbial growth for a wide spectrum of microorganisms under a wide range of processing conditions. First comes data, then information, then finally wisdom. "Hurdle technology" in the processing and designing of food for safe storage is a multifactor approach that preserves food by combining methods. The "hurdles" may include such processing conditions as temperature, acidity, reduction-oxidation potential, atmosphere modification, presence of antioxidants, and presence of antimicrobials. "The concept is that for a given food the bacteria should not be able to 'jump over' all the hurdles present and so should be inhibited. If several hurdles are used simultaneously, a gentle preservation could be applied, which nevertheless secures stable and safe foods of high sensory and nutritional properties. This is due to the fact that the different hurdles in a food often have a synergistic (enhancing) effect."{anonymous, "Food Science and Technology Today",6(3), pg. 139(1992)} A good example of the application of hurdle technology is to be found in the paper by Chirife and Favetto {Jorge Chirife and
1212 Guillermo Favetto,"Food Research International" 25, 389396(1992)—Some physico-chemical basis of food preservation by combined methods}. They review such key processing and deterioration factors as water activity (a^), pH, solute effects, and temperature and consider the interaction of these factors. The water activity has historically been a more meaningful indicator than the simple moisture content because the activity includes the effects of the food matrix. Chirife and Favetto explore the combined effects of decreasing water activity and heating. By lowering the water activity, not so much heating is needed to deter bacterial growth. Be aware that the choice of the word "hurdle" to describe such a multivariate situation can mislead the reader, in that the process designer does not envision each of the conditions to be met sequentially, as in a hurdle race; rather, the process variables must be considered simultaneously. Chao and Rizvi {R. R. Chao and S. H. Rizvi, "Maximization of produce shelf life through modified microatmoshpere packaging", from the book "Changing Food Technology 2", pp. 175-178, ed. by Manfred Kroger and Allen Freed, Technomic Publishing Co., Lancaster, PA (1989)} must deal with multivariate processing conditions in their study of designing a modified microatmosphere packaging system to extend the shelf life of apples. Among the parameters to be juggled simultaneously were: storage temperature, time required to reach desired oxygen and carbon dioxide concentration levels, the surface for gas exchange, oxygen and carbon dioxide permeabilities of the wrapping film, and the packaging materials. Part of the strategy to cope with the complex interactions was to use mass balance equations for the gases within the packaging. Mass balance equations simply express the conservation of mass and facilitate the mathematical description of the processes taking place within the film-wrapped product as the product consumes oxygen and generates carbon dioxide, while simultaneously both these gases are permeating through the film. In thinking about such hurdle approaches, we could picture a three-dimensional space, with its three coordinate axes corresponding respectively to water activity, pH, and temperature. Any point in this space corresponds to a set of process conditions. Imagine a three dimensional figure like an icosahedron such that this figure is made up of all those points that correspond to an adequate combination of processing conditions. Any point lying outside this figure would correspond to an unacceptable combination of processing conditions. The shape of this figure—the boundary between acceptable and not acceptable — can be delineated with the help of multivariate techniques. Even if the boundary is more like a crumpled sheet than a polyhedron, application of techniques like piece-wise regression will help trace out this boundary and will help to indicate suitable combinations of operating conditions that will achieve the goal of safe product with less expenditure. As novel food products, such as low-acid foods or low-fat foods, designed
1213 to cater to new fads and fears, penetrate the market place, the application of hurdle technology and its inherent multivariate approach will gain in importance. TRANSCENDING STATISTICS AND PEEKING OVER THE FENCE INTO OTHER FIELDS Man does not live by statistics alone. The food technologist is truly confronted with the need to adopt a multidisciplinary approach to his/her problems. From ANTHROPOLOGY to ZOOLOGY, with important stops at ECONOMICS and PSYCHOLOGY, the cumulated store of many sciences must be tapped by those concerned with food sciences and new contributions to this store often have to be made. For example, the clique analysis referred to above, had its origin in SOCIOLOGY, with the first rigorous formula for complete enumeration of all cliques to be found in the journal Sociometry.IF. Harary and I.e. Ross, "A procedure for clique detection using the group matrix", "Sociometry",20(3),205215(1957)} Mathematics, and in particular multivariate statistics, can provide a unifying approach to assessing the results and estimating the uncertainties. To cite one example of how the scientist might have to adjust to a whole new paradigm: consider a simple sensory panel problem, involving just a paired comparison test. Each panel member is presented with two items and he/she is asked to select which item is "better" on the basis of some pre-agreed-upon protocol for evaluation. If three items are involved—cheese, chicken, and chocolate—• it is not inconceivable that the panelists (a) prefer cheese over chicken, and (b) prefer chicken over chocolate, and yet (c)prefer chocolate over cheese. Note how this set of preferences wreaks havoc on our ordinary quantitative training. Since Euclid, the third century B.C. geometrician and educator from Alexandria, every school person has been taught that if a is greater than b and if b is greater than c, then a is also greater than c. Mathematics label such behavior as "transitive." For example, 5 is greater than 3 and 3 is greater than 1, so 5 is greater than 1. Note that such is not the behavior in the cheesechicken-chocolate dilemma(trilemma?). Numerical instincts fail us. Merely assigning a "satisfaction value" or "util" can't possibly capture this counter-intuitive behavior. In one ECONOMICS textbook, Walsh {Vivian Charles Walsh, "Introduction to Contemporary Microeconomics",McGraw-Hill, New York(1970)} derides the use of utils, calling such a practice a relic from crude unthinking British empiricism of the nineteenth century. Walsh proceeds to explain "indifference curves" —curves that do not rely on exact numerical values, but instead depend on preference rankings. However the cheese-chicken-chocolate problem cannot be solved by this simple ruse of ranking and of "revealed preferences." If one insists on numerical values when transitivity does not hold, the researcher must literally rise above the "x-axis" and
1214 consider an item's utility to be expressed as a vector in multidimensional space; then the non-Euclidean preference ranking might be representable in a geometric fashion. Think higherdimensionally. Some of the more ambitious and daring might even want to explore the use of tensors to express utility. If this much trouble can realistically be expected to happen from time to time from a simple pair comparison, then imagine how creative the researcher needs to be in coping with the "duo-trio" test and the "triangular" test employed in sophisticated sensory panel evaluations.{Roland Harper,"A guide to sensory analysis and its development","Food Science and Technology Today",1(2),pp.7376(1987)} Much of the initial portion of this chapter has dealt with the concept, maligned above, of utility. Used by economists, philosophers, insurance companies, and management scientists (see below), the word "utility" is difficult to define: an adequate definition requires precision-honed mathematical symbolism. "Utility index" as defined by Dyckman et al. {T. R. Dyckman, S. Smidt, and A. K. McAdams,"Management Decision Making Under Uncertainty", Macmillan, London(1969)} is "a real number that gives a preference measure attaching to an outcome or the payoff for an outcome." The authors then go on to define a utility function as a function that assigns a value to a "gamble" such that if gamble g^ is preferred to gamble gg, then the corresponding value assigned by the utility function for the gamble g^ is greater than that assigned to the gamble g2. Note that, by the use of a definition in terms of real numbers, the transitivity condition is assumed to hold. From previous discussions in this chapter, it should be clear that use of principal components might be a fruitful means to composite several variables to create a utility function. Even the linear combination resulting from multivariate regression could be a candidate for utility function. Even adding cross terms in a regression, such as sweetness x density, is not out of the question as part of an exploration to find a suitable utility function. A realistic utility function must combine a widely disparate array of variables, both objective and subjective. Consider how difficult it would be to create a single utility function that mirrors the "healthiness" of food. "Is 5 units of vitamin B^g worth 3 units of vitamin A?" Such questions arise naturally as possible explicit formulas for a utility function are reviewed. Now try to contrive a solution to the harder problem of coming up will a utility function that mirrors the "quality" of food: in addition to "healthiness" variables, such as vitamin and fat content, all the "hedonistic variables, such as texture and taste, are to be considered. It may well be that in such situations the search for a single utility function is like the search for the holy grail: a noble enterprise but doomed to failure. It is perhaps not a matter of time and improved technology until such an explicit all-encompassing utility function can be devised; the goal may be illusory and may never ever be achieved.
1215 Another complication with utility functions as currently envisioned is that the utility indices are often erroneously assumed to be additive. What is after all merely an ordinal ranking is treated as a full-fledged continuous variable (i.e.,as a "ratio" variable). This mistake is particularly insidious when decisions are based on the results of multiplying the utility of each choice by the a priori known probability of some relevant conditions holding true. A utility index of 5 is not five times higher than a utility index of 1.: therefore 1/10 of 5 utils is not equivalent to 1 util in value. In fact, such a multiplication does not make any sense. Ranks don't work that way. This striving after utility functions does force the researcher to examine the actual physical problem closely. Therefore, the misuse of utility functions does not preclude them from being used as a crude guide. They're better than nothing. As discussed in the preliminary portions in this chapter, the transition from individual utility functions to an overall utility function must be made in order to intelligently assess options in foods and in life. Here we transgress into the realms of POLITICS and PHILOSOPHY. A name exists for such an overall merged utility function: it is called, by Nobel-prize-winning Kenneth J. Arrow and by others, the social welfare function. If conceptual and practical difficulties arise for individual utility functions, then no better can be expected from the social or communal welfare function. Arrow's definition, given on page 12 of his book "Social Choice and Individual Values"{Kenneth J. Arrow,"Social Choice and Individual Values",Yale University Press, New Haven (1963)} is as follows: "By a social welfare function will be meant a process or rule which, for each set of individual orderings R^,..., R„ for alternative social states (one ordering for each individual) provides a corresponding social ordering of alternative social states,R." Much of the book is devoted to establishing conditions under which such a function can exist. Clearly "not yet ready for prime time", the problem of integrating individual preferences into communal preferences is of deep, abiding concern that has important impact on how we vote, how we are governed, how we are taxed, and how we live. Associated with the problem of utility is that fact that utility is a function of how people perceive their needs and wants. Thus, the realm of PSYCHOLOGY is important in assessing and interpreting people's preferences. Shelf life is related to the retention of the quality of a food product, but the perception of quality is highly subjective. Even health aspects —matters of life and death— can be viewed differently by different peoples. Consider our attitude toward aflatoxin-contaminated grain versus the attitude toward the same grain of starving Somalis. As the proverb states, "Ones man's meat is other man's poison." ["One man's Mede is another man's Persian" might be an older version of this proverb.] Consider how different tastes are. Pork is anathema to both Jews and Muslims, yet some Polynesian islands are reputed to exist where pork is considered such a supreme
1216 delicacy that women are allowed to consume pork only on special occasions. New Englanders prefer brown eggs. As we mentioned in our chapter on the application of chemometrics to flavor studies {Zervos and Albert, op.cit.}, year-old decayed whale meat is considered a delicacy in Iceland and the off-flavor, as the nonafficionados would dub it, is essential to the enjoyment of this delicacy. As Williams et al.{Anthony P. Williams, Clive de W. Blackburn and Paul Gibbs, "Techniques to improve the safety and extend the shelf life of foods" in "Food Science and Technology Today" 6(3) 148-151(1992)} state, "... the criteria used to describe deterioration should be relevant to the cause for which the food would become unfit." In other words, good quality depends on both subjective and objective factors. Surveys are undertaken periodically to determine just what the salient factors are in determining food preferences. A study of food consumption trends in the United Kingdom has been described by A.M. Rees. {Ann Maree Rees,"Factors influencing consumer choice", in "Journal of the Society of Dairy Technology", pp.112116,vol 45(4),(1992)} She particularly focuses on the influence of such new phenomena as housewives' working, the introduction of microwave ovens, the increase in snacking, and the obsession with "natural" food. In the United States, the results of a survey of factors affecting food consumption has been described by C. I. Waslien.{Carol I. Waslien, "Factors influencing food selection in the American diet", pp. 239-269, in the book "Advances in Food Research Volume 32, edited by C. O. Chichester and B. S. Schweigert,Academic Press, New York(1988)} She describes the effects of age on food preference and food attitudes and on meal patterns. The complex issues of sex differences vis-a-vis senses of taste and smell, food values and attitudes, and actual food selection are also addressed. Moreover, racial and ethnic patterns are discerned. She describes the dramatic alterations in the make-up of U.S. society, in age distribution, and in life styles. In her conclusion, she states that "The marked changes ... demand research methodologies that can consider multiple factors simultaneouslyfitalics ours] and are still rapid enough to make predictions before the population has changed again." She also calls for techniques than can take advantage of computerized statistical procedures on the diverse populations needed to assess the full range of food-choice factors. The "hard sciences", in contradistinction to the "soft sciences" like economics, of course would also be expected to contribute to food technology and the understanding and prolonging of shelf life. CHEMICAL ENGINEERING is replete with multivariable approaches that apply to foods. A paper by Saguy and Karel {I. Saguy and M. Karel, "Modeling of quality deterioration during food processing and storage",Food Technology,34(2),pp.7885(1980)} on modeling quality deterioration during processing and storage exemplifies how chemical engineers approach the complex situations frequently encountered in food technology. A catalog of typical statistical routines is presented, including multiple linear regression and stepwise regression. Emphasis is on the
1217 kinetics of the decomposition of food. Lima and CalVidal{op.cit.}, by their model-based equations, also provide a useful illustration of the chemical engineering approach to coping with all the variables that must be considered in food processing, even though they may fail to go far enough. Even a certain mathematical technique from another of the "hard sciences", specifically from THEORETICAL BIOLOGY, may find application in shelf life work, especially in its chemical analysis and processing aspects. Called the "genetic algorithm", this technique, whose goal is to seek optimum values for instrumental and processing variables, is being actively explored for future routine application. Lucasius and Kateman{C.B. Lucasius and G. Kateman, "genetic algorithms for large-scale optimization in chemometrics: an application",Trends in Analytical Chemistry, 10(8),254-261(1991)}, in order to suggest fruitful application of the genetic algorithm, address the important chemical analysis problem of finding the wavelengths to use to estimate a complex mixture of chemicals, each having a different individual spectrum, i.e., each having a different functional relation between the absorbance, in the example used, of ultraviolet light and the wavelength of the ultraviolet light. The mixture dealt with in this feasibility study consisted of the four RNA nucleotides: adenylic, cytidylic, guanylic, and uridylic. The criterion of "goodness" is the selectivity, which can be calculated via the set of so-called Lambert-Beer equations and which is uniquely and directly calculable for a given choice of wavelengths. In the initial stage of the genetic algorithm, strings of I's and O's were generated at random. Because 36 absorption wavelengths had to be considered, each string was composed of 36 I's and O's, where a 1 at the n* position in a string indicates that the n wavelength is used, while a 0 in that position indicates that the corresponding wavelength is not to be used. Each string is a coding for what wavelengths are to be used concurrently and which are not to be used. For each of the starting set of 36-bit-long strings, a selectivity value — a measure of "goodness"— can be straightforwardly be computed. Since this selectivity is simply a numerical value, and not something so complicated as a preference vector alluded to above, the initial strings can be ranked in order from most selective to least selective. From this initial set, a certain number are selected with a probability proportional to the selectivity and these selected ones are allowed to "breed", creating a new generation. Then the strings in this new generation are evaluated and a sensitivity-based selection is again made to determine who shall reproduce the next generation. The algorithm resorts to this selection procedure, instead of picking say the top 35% of the strings, to ensure that every string has a chance, however small, of contributing to the ultimate goal of finding that string of I's and O's that yields the very highest numerical value for the sensitivity. Also, such a probabilistic approach prevents genetic dead ends, where the same situations keep recurring: in the genetic algorithm.
1218 something new and invigorating can always be introduced by chance alone. In mimicking nature, the genetic algorithm resorts to analogs of the crossovers and mutations found in genes. In crossovers, two strings are split at some random point along their respective lengths, say between position 29 and 30 and a pair of two new strings is generated: (a)the 29-bit portion of the first string is coupled to the 36 minus 29 = 7-bit string of the second and (b)the 7-bit segment of the first string is coupled to the 29-bit segment of the second string. As an analog to mutations, a certain number of bits are reversed at random, I's becoming O's and O's becoming I's. As each generation is created, the strings become associated with higher and higher sensitivity values. However, since the process is random, it is interesting to note that you can get different alleged optima for different random starting sequences of strings. A common-sense solution to this non-reproducibility problem is to resort to this efficient genetic algorithm to zeroin on a good '•fertile region" and to allow some more tedious optimization or "hill-climbing" algorithms slog through the computations to find the unique optimum. The food technologist may wonder why all this bit-playing is necessary, when it is a matter of just trying out all the possibilities and identifying that one set of conditions — t h a t one set of wavelengths— that yields the highest value. For some of the most interesting and important optimization problems, such a complete, exhaustive search may entail more computer time than is left in the life of the planet earth. The genetic algorithm is a powerful general-purpose search strategy that has its greatest strength in those large-scale problems that have no analytical solutions. The genetic algorithm, of course, could effectively be applied to the optimization problems of food processing. As such, it would provide an alternative to the already well-established bag of tricks employed by the discipline known as MANAGEMENT SCIENCE. Under the rubric of "operations research", this collection of procedures, seeks, inter alia, to uncover those values for a set of variables that optimize the value of some function. This function is called the "objective function", equivalent to the sensitivity in the above genetic algorithm. This function provides a measure of goodness. The search process strives to achieve the highest goodness, subject to the constraints imposed by limited resources. A frequent exercise is to calculate the least-cost nutritionally-adequate diet: given the nutrient composition of available foods and the price of these foods and the minimum daily requirements, the question is "What is the lowest cost diet consistent with the constraints of nutritional adequacy?" The well-developed arsenal in operations research {Frederick S.
1219 Hillier and Gerald J. Lieberman, "Operations Research",HoldenDay, San Francisco(1974)}includes the techniques called linear programming, non-linear programming, dynamic programming, integer programming, PERT (Program Evaluation and Review Technique) and CPM(Critical Path Method). Also part of operations research is a classic repertoire of problems addressed by these weapons, among them: the warehouse problem, the knapsack problem, and the optimal-reorder frequency problem. While not strictly in the domain of statistics, many of these areas of operations research rely heavily on statistics to model reality and to establish values for key parameters along with estimates of the uncertainty in these parameters. The following is a sample of some of the shelf life problems where operations research approaches may help provide the important answers: *The simplex method {Lloyd Currie, op.cit.},which was alluded to previously for optimizing experimental operating conditions, is a specialized development for chemists, based on the fundamental linear programming prescriptions of operations research. *The processing of food in preparation for storage should be as rapid as possible. PERT and CPM help identify bottlenecks in production processes and allow the manager to focus on streamlining just those step that make a difference in the overall time required. *The insight into process sequencing provided by PERT and CPM can be applied to the HACCP[Hazard Analysis of Critical Control Points] monitoring of a food production process, such as fish packing. HACCP is a form of quality control that is vital when rare but serious defects are involved. A good example would be contamination by Salmonella; the infestation in a food is unlikely, but when it does occur it can be lethal. Mere statistical sampling will not work well since to detect something that has a probability of .001 of happening will require prohibitively large samples. Instead, HACCP strives to identify those features of a process most liable to cause serious defects. It then focuses on assuring that those features are operating properly. A illustration of HACCP in practice would be the daily verification that the fish packers in an assembly line are wearing intact gloves. *The retail grocer doesn't want to have too much product waiting on the shelves. The Japanese have introduced the concept of "just in time delivery" in shipping parts to an assembly site that basically allows the manufacturer to keep no parts inventory at all. The grocer of course needs some inventory of the food product even though the ideal situation would be for the shipment of a unit of product to arrive just as the customer is about to buy. The strategy that is adopted by the grocer must take into account the fact that perishable products have a utility diminishing with time and have an availability that also diminishes with time as the consumer purchases the product. This type of problem is addressed in operations research under the general heading of inventory models. *The classic warehouse problem can help the food manufacturer decide from which storage facilities to ship to which retail outlets. The formulation of this problem is as follows: a
1220 manufacture has F factories, each producing a given amount of product and S stores that each demand some amount of product. The problem is to assign the product from the F factories to the S stores is such a way as to minimize the costs. For shelf life considerations, the cost might be taken to be transportation time. Here, as in any much of practical research, the problem is may not necessarily be solvable by simply plugging into a formula, even though the problem here is a classic one. Resorting to the tried and true formulation, the assignments will minimize the average transit time. What if, instead, it is more important to minimize the maximum transit or shipping time? That is, suppose it is imperative because of a spoilage threat that no single product shipment take more than 36 hours. No easy answer exists as to how to determine the optimum assignments in this case, but operations research provides at least a starting point for ferreting out a solution. Thus, many fields can contribute to the effective investigation and control of shelf life. IMPLEMENTING THE STATISTICAL PROCEDURES VIA COMPUTER SOFTWARE The value of multivariate statistics and of the multivariate approach has been demonstrated. However, unless the food scientist can actually apply the techniques, he/she is doomed to be a passive on-looker. It is obvious that there is very little that a scientist can do in the realm of multivariate statistics without resorting to a computer. A few simple multivariate approaches that require little if any computer power might be tried during preliminary data exploration: (a) Simply graphing one variable vs. another can suggest trends. (b) When the resulting so-called scatterplot is enclosed in a "convex hull", the limits of the variables are easier to spot. The convex hull of a set of points in a plane is simply the smallest polygon that contains all the points and has all its interior angles less than 180 degrees. If you have N points in your plot you can connect each point with every other point— there are N x (N-1)/2 such lines in all—and then trace out the outermost lines. At each corner of the convex hull is a data point, with any non-corner data points all contained within the convex hull. (c) You can plot one variable vs. another variable for several different categories and the respective convex hulls can provide boundaries to categorize new unknown samples. (d) You can fit a straight line to the scattered points— or you can transform the values—take the logarithm or raise to a power for example—and then fit a straight line, either via conventional regression formulas or by a minimax procedure.{Robert J. Blodgett, U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Washington, DC 20204. Personal communication. This minimax procedure is not generally known but offers an alternative to the ordinary regression procedure, which makes certain demands on the
1221 behavior of the data. The undemanding minimax-fitted straight line provides the minimum maximum "miss" or individual error: for each point in your set of plotted points, note how much this minimax line misses it as measured vertically. You will have N such values or misses. The worst of these N deviations is the maximum miss for the minimax line.. If you draw a straight line other than the minimax straight line, the fit will have at least one point missed by more than this maximum miss. To get the minimax line, draw the convex hull and find which corner is the furthest away from the opposite side of the convex hull. Then draw a line passing half-way between this corner and side, parallel to the side. This line is the minimax line, useful for spotting outlying data points and for indicating possible ranges for trends.} That's pretty much all you can do without computer power but fortunately the requisite computer power—both hardware and software—is available to apply multivariate statistics techniques to data. There is however both good news and bad news. The good news is that there are literally hundreds of software packages that include multivariate subroutines. And these proliferating software packages can be run on a personal computer: mainframe computers are not needed except for truly enormous data sets. That's also the bad news, namely, there are scores of multivariate statistics software packages. The uncontrolled growth of such packages makes selection difficult and some horror stories exist about the quality and validity of some of the programs in some of the packages. See, for example, the article by G.E. Dallal {Gerard E. Dallal, "Statistical microcomputing—like it is.", The American Statistician", 42(3) 212-216(1988)},where 5 different packages are put through the paces and so are found wanting. These were only 5 out of the more than 200 packages that Dallal claims are available just for the IBM PC alone.{Note that the naming of any commercial make of computer or software package is in no way to be construed as an endorsement. No conclusions may be drawn as to the relative merits of similar competing products.} Caution must always be exercised in the blind use of any technique and the very fact that a computer does the computations in no way relieves the scientist from the responsibility of knowing what's going on. Searle{Shayle R. Searle, "Statistical Computing Packages: Some Words of Caution", "The American Statistician", 43(4)189-190(1989)} issues the following warning: "With little or no knowledge of statistics, people with data can so easily have the data processed by a package that does the arithmetic for whatever sophisticated analysis they choose, whether the choice [of type of analysis] is appropriate or not." He recounts some horror stories of computer packages being abused. As far as mainframe packages are concerned, five are discussed in a book by Wolff and Parsons.{ Diane D. Wolff and Michael L. Parsons, "Pattern Recognition Approach to Data
1222 Interpretation",Plenum Press, New York(1983). Of these, at least three (namely SAS [Statistical Analysis System] and SPSS [Statistical Package for Social Sciences]) are available for personal computers and are we11-documented and supported. We ourselves use the software package called Statgraphics and we have seen references in British publications to a package called Genstat. Some shopping may have to be done but having a software package is the sine qua non for doing multivariate statistics. It is necessary but not sufficient however. A willingness to explore and to learn is required and a cheerful attitude in the face of adversity. Goethe, who was born before the golden age of multivariate statistics and computers and who was habitually successful in everything he undertook, always advised any friends fearful of failure in some enterprise:" Vertraue und verhandle!""Have faith and just do it!"
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1223
Nitrite alternatives for processed meats F. Shahidi and R,B. Pegg Department of Biochemistry, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, NF, AlB 3X9, Canada. Abstract Nitrite is an essential ingredient used in the curing of meat products. It is responsible for the characteristic color, flavor and extended shelf-life and microbial stability of cured products. However, it is also responsible for the production of carcinogenic A^-nitrosamines in certain cured products under some processing conditions. Nitrite-free meat products such as wieners and salami have been prepared using curing systems consisting of the preformed cooked cured-meat pigment, CCMP, an antioxidant, a sequestrant and an antimicrobial agent. The color, oxidative stability, and flavor of the cooked treated products, as determined by Hunter L, a, b values, 2thiobarbituric acid (TBA) test, and sensory means, respectively, were similar to those of their nitrite-cured counterparts. Absence of A^-nitrosamines in the nitrite-free cooked products was confirmed using a gas chromatography-thermal energy analyzer (GCTEA) methodology. Similar results were obtained when the above nitrite-free curing mixtures were used in fish-based products, where nitrite curing produced substantial amounts of A^-nitrosodimethylamine. Furthermore, rates of color fading of samples treated with either CCMP or nitrite were similar, thus suggesting that presence of residual nitrite in processed meats may not be necessary for color stability of such products. 1. INTRODUCTION Cured meats represent a large portion of the processed meat products consumed in North America. These processed meats are attractive in their color, texture and flavor and are popular with consumers because they combine this variety with the convenience of extended storage stability. With the advent of modem refrigeration, the importance of nitrite curing of meat for its preservation has declined, but consumers have acquired a taste for certain cured-meats and still demand their preparation.
1224 The origin of meat curing is lost in antiquity [1], but it was not until the turn of this century that nitrite was ascertained to be the fundamental ingredient of the curing process. This ubiquitous compound, whose regulated use has been in effect since 1925 in the USA [2], is responsible for the development of the characteristic pink color [3] and flavor of cooked cured-meats [4]. It also acts as an antioxidative agent, thus, delaying the onset of deterioration of meat flavor, thereby providing an extended shelflife to processed meat products [5-7]. Most importantly, nitrite, in combination with sodium chloride, has bacteriostatic action and inhibits production of Clostridium botulinum neurotoxin [8,9]. Even with all of the benefits conferred by this multifunctional food additive, addition of nitrite to meat and meat products is a source of concern, as it is responsible for the formation of carcinogenic A^-nitrosamines. These carcinogens may be formed by the reaction of nitrite and its dissociation products with secondary amines of muscle tissues during processing, cooking or after ingestion of nitrite-cured meat. A^Nitrosopyrrolidine and //-nitrosodimethylamine, examples of such reaction products, have been detected at low, ppb, levels in fried bacon [10,11]. Because the rate ofNnitrosamine production is proportional to the square of the concentration of residual nitrite in meats [12], a reduction in the level of nitrite added to meats has proven to be an effective measure in reducing the risk of N-nitrosamine formation. Use of A^nitrosamine-blocking agents such as a-tocopherol together with ascorbates has also been employed [13]. Due to the risks of botulinal poisoning, the meat industry is committed to the use of nitrite in cured products because they have no suitable alternative at hand. The necessity for studying the formation and occurrence of A^nitrosamines in cured meats and other food systems stems from the absolute nature of the Food and Drug Regulations in the USA and other regulatory bodies in Canada and Europe which deny the use of any food additive which in itself is carcinogenic or produces carcinogens in foods. Therefore, it is only reasonable that usage of nitrite in cured meats be reduced, or phased-out when effective and safe substitutes are found. Since it is unlikely that a single compound will be found that can perform all of the functions of nitrite, efforts in the past have been concentrated on developing alternatives which performed a selected function of nitrite. For example, a large number of colorants to substitute nitrite has been developed [14], but toxicity problems have prevented their use in meat processing. Sweet [15] was the first researcher to report the development of nitrite-free curing systems to confer the different functions of nitrite. In our laboratory, efforts towards the development of composite nitrite-free curing systems which bestow the characteristic and desirable attributes of cooked cured-meat products without the fear of A^-nitrosamine formation, and which may be employed at the industrial level, have continued. This chapter summarizes the benefits and drawbacks of nitrite in meat curing as well as the development and efficacy of compounds which have been examined and may be used in nitrite-free formulations to reproduce the desirable characteristics of nitrite-cured meats.
1225 2.
NITRITE ALTERNATIVES
2.1 Sensory Attributes 2.1.1 Color Characteristics. Visual appearance is one of the main factors influencing consumers when assessing the quality and palatability of meat products. Many experiments have been performed which support the idea that certain colors do, in fact, influence food acceptance [16]. The color of meat is attributable mainly to the hemoprotein, myoglobin [3]. Addition of nitrite to meat, followed by thermal processing, produces a relatively stable pink-colored pigment. The precise sequence of events resulting in the formation of the cured-meat pigment in meat is not fully understood. As well, the chemical structure of the resultant pigment after thermal processing of nitrite-cured meat has long been a subject of dispute. While Tarladgis [17], Lee and Cassens [18] and Renerre and Rougie [19] have concluded that the cooked cured-meat pigment is a dinitrosyl ferrohemochrome, Bonnett et al. [20] and Killday et al. [21] have shown that a mononitrosyl compound is responsible for the characteristic color of cured meats (Figure 1). Wayland and Olson [22] have also shown that a substituted dinitrosyl protoheme complex may exist under a positive pressure of nitric oxide. Although it is important to find a substitute for nitrite that reproduces the characteristic cured-meat color, the National Academy of Sciences [14] noted that there are few reports of attempts to find compounds or processes that mimic the selective color fixing effect of nitrite in muscle tissue. Toxilogical data on some of these potential colorants for cured meat are limited or non-existent. Sweet [15], in his composite nitrite-free curing system, used erythrosine as the colorant. In 1982, the National Academy of Sciences [14] reported that although a stable uniform cured-meat color can be achieved with as low as 50 ppm sodium nitrite, no suitable means of fixing color in cured meat, other than reduced nitrite levels, have been demonstrated to be effective in products made under commercial conditions. Shahidi and co-workers attempted to solve this problem by using the approach of Sweet, but their colorant of choice was the actual cooked cured-meat pigment (CCMP). The CCMP was preformed outside of the meat matrix and then applied to meat systems. The color characteristics of such nitrite-free systems have successfully duplicated those of nitrite, as will be outlined below. Smith and Burge [23] tried to mimic cured meat color using protoporphyrin-IX, but Hunter L, a, b values and spectra of pigments extracted from protoporphyrin-IX-treated systems were markedly different from those of nitritecured samples. Presence of iron in the protoporphyrin ring is essential for the development of the typical cured color in meats [24]. Preparation of CCMP from the reaction of bovine red blood cells with a nitrosating agent directly or indirectly through a hemin intermediate has been reported [25-28]; a flow diagram of its preparation is presented in Figure 2. Initially, it was proposed that this preformed pigment was a dinitrosyl ferrohemochrome, but citations in literature, as listed above, have suggested that the pigment may indeed be a mononitrosyl heme complex. The issue of the exact chemical nature of the pigment, before and after application to meat, is uncertain, therefore, we have simply referred
1226
HgC =
CH
HgC = CH =
CH
CH«
CH =
CHo
CH =
CHo
[NO], H"^ Reductant
HOOC NO
Nitric Oxide Myoglobin
[NO]
Thermal Processing
NO HgC =
CH
HgC =
CHo
-CH=CH2
H3C -^
/
[NO], H"^ Reductant
4^
H3C
- CHg
HgC -
HOOC
COOH
HOOC
Hemin
CH
CCMP
Figure 1. Formation of the cooked cured-meat pigment from myoglobin and hemin. to the colorant as CCMP. However, recent EPR {i.e., electron paramagnetic resonance) studies in our laboratory have confirmed that the preformed CCMP used in composite nitrite-free curing systems is a mononitrosyl hemochromogen not a dinitrosyl ferrohemochrome. The details of this study will be communicated elsewhere. The stability of the preformed CCMP is limited when light and oxygen are present
1227 [26], but the pigment remains stable for extended periods of time in sealed ampules under a positive pressure of nitric oxide [29]. Entrapment of the pigment in foodgrade wall materials such as cyclodextrins and modified and/or hydrolyzed starches forming a powdered cooked cured-meat pigment (PCCMP) was carried out. The PCCMP prepared from one or a combination of encapsulating agents protected CCMP for at least 18 months as shown by their visible absorption spectra and the Hunter L, a, b and hue angle (tan"^ b/a) values of pigment-treated meats (Table 1). The preformed CCMP, prepared directly or indirectly from bovine red blood cells, had identical spectral characteristics to that of the pigment extracted from a commercial sample of ham (Figure 3). Upon its addition to both comminuted and selected solid cuts of meat, the characteristic color of nitrite-cured meat was reproduced after thermal processing of the meats (Table 1). Since the preformed CCMP is the natural colorant of cured meat, it should be readily acceptable for industrial applications. Pilot-scale experiments for the preparation of wiener and Bovine Red Blood Cells HOAc/NaCl Mixing Protein Separation Formation of Hemin Base/Reductant/ [NO]
Liquids
i
Hemin Crystals
Formation of Pigment Separation Liquids Cooked Cured-Meat Pigment (CCMP) Figure 2. Flow diagram for the preparation of the cooked cured-meat pigment (CCMP) from bovine red blood cells.
1228 Table 1 Hunter L, a, b values of nitrite-cured and pigment-treated cooked pork/ Hunter Values Additives, ppm Control, no additive NaNO^, 150 CCMP, 12 Protoporphyrin-IX, 60 PCCMP, 35
L
a
b
Hue angle
63.3 62.4 60.7 52.1 58.5
4.1
11.6
11.6 11.8 6.8 11.7
9.4 10.1
70.5 39.3 38.5 54.1 40.8
9.5 9.4
^AU pork samples contained 20% (w/w) distilled water and 550 ppm sodium ascorbate. PP-IX - protoporphyrin-IX.
> \ s 0.6
o c
CO
o
0.4
V,,.,
;\
v.
-'^•.....
\ .
•
^\
\
\
< \
0.2
\
\
\
i •
\ \» \ \^ \ \\
Vv^ " - - ^
500
550
600
Wavelength (nm) Figure 3. Absorption spectra of 4:1 (v/v) acetonerwater extracts of: CCMP prepared from bovine red blood cells,--^-^- ; CCMP prepared from hemin,; pigments extracted from nitrite-cured ham — — - ; and pigments extracted from CCMP-treated cooked pork, . Adapted from reference [66]. salami products as well as evaluation of their color quality by subjective or objective methods of analyses have been reported [30-32]. The color intensity of wiener and salami products cured with nitrite or CCMP was practically indistinguishable from one another visually as was reflected in their Hunter L, a, b values (data not shown).
1229 Although pigment-treated samples had slightly lower Hunter L values denoting darker products, they were not visually unattractive and their color was in fact preferred to that of their nitrite-cured counterparts in some cases. Further studies showed that the color intensity of nitrite- or CCMP-cured products depended on the myoglobin content of the original meats. Table 2 shows the dependence of Hunter color parameters on the content of myoglobin in the samples. An increase in the myoglobin content of meat brought about a decrease in Hunter L and hue angle values and a corresponding increase in Hunter a values. Consequently, meats containing a higher myoglobin content when cured with either nitrite or CCMP gave products with a deeper red color. Furthermore, it was revealed that the level of CCMP required to impart a typical cured color to products, equivalent to that of nitrite, depended on the concentration of the native muscle pigments in meat. Muscle tissue richer in myoglobin necessitated addition of higher CCMP levels to attain the characteristic color of cooked cured meat (Table 3). As outlined in Table 3, Shahidi and Pegg [33] applied CCMP to a widerange of muscle foods with myoglobin concentrations ranging from 0.4 to 59 mg/g of wet tissue. Table 2 Dependence of Hunter color values of cooked ground pork systems on their myoglobin content.^ Nitrite-Cured (156 ppm)
Pigment-Treated (12 ppm)
Myoglobin mg/g
L
a
Hue Angle
L
a
Hue Angle
0.76+0.02 1.22±0.06 1.76±0.06
64.2±0.3 57.810.5 56.7+0.7
10.8±0.2 13.4±0.2 14.2+0.4
43.1 ±0.7 34.510.5 33.010.8
63.310.4 57.110.2 55.210.3
11.810.2 13.210.2 14.210.3
39.410.7 34.610.5 33.510.7
^AU samples were prepared with 20% (w/w) distilled water and 550 ppm sodium ascorbate to which either sodium nitrite or the cooked cured-meat pigment was added. Myoglobin (Mb) content was determined according to the procedure of Rickansrud and Henrickson [34], and its content is reported as mg Mb equivalents/g tissue. Table 3 Total hemoprotein pigment content of muscle foods and the amount of preformed cooked cured-meat pigment (CCMP) required to achieve a cured color in products^ Muscle Tissue Total Pigment (mg/g) CCMP (ppm)
Chicken Breast
Pork
Lamb
Beef
Seal
0.4 6
1.2 8
2.1 12
4.5 24
59.0 48
^AU systems contained 20% (w/w) distilled water and 550 ppm sodium ascorbate. Total pigment content determined according to the procedure of Rickansrud and Henrickson [34], and is reported as mg myoglobin equivalents/g tissue.
1230 The color stability of CCMP-treated and nitrite-cured samples was evaluated. Vacuum packaged samples were stored at 4°C underfluorescentlighting. This set-up was designed to simulate the extent of color fading of cured meats in display cases of supermarkets, but intense fluorescent lighting (375 lux) was used to accelerate the color fading process. Both CCMP-treated and nitrite-cured samples faded rapidly during the first 6 h period as reflected by increasing Hunter hue angle values (Figure 4). The rate of color fading of both systems was found to be similar. This trend was surprising because literature suggests that presence of residual nitrite in cured meats serves as a nitrosation source for refixation of disrupted NO molecules from CCMP. It may therefore by concluded that under extreme storage conditions, presence of residual nitrite has little effect on color fixation of cured meats.
Figure 4. Dependence of Hunter hue angle values of meats treated with varying concentrations of cooked cured-meat pigment (CCMP) or sodium nitrite (NaNOj) during exposure to fluorescent lighting over an 18 h period.
1231 2.1.2 Flavor and Oxidative Stability. The role of nitrite in cured meat flavor is complex and the chemical changes that are responsible for this unique flavor brought about in meat are not entirely understood [35]. Cured meat flavor is perhaps a composite sensation arising from the cumulative effect of many compounds. Research into cured meat flavor has been divided into two main areas, namely the sensory evaluation of flavor imparted to meat by nitrite, and the qualitative and quantitative identification of volatile and non-volatile components responsible for it, but caution must be exercised. A compound-by-compound search of meat flavor volatiles may misidentify the true nature of cured meat flavor because a mixture of two or more odors can produce an aroma that is perceived as qualitatively distinct from the odors of their components. Although presence of yet unappreciated substances, in minute quantities, may be responsible for cured flavor, there is no doubt that nitrite influences the flavor of cured meats by virtue of its antioxidative properties and stabilization of microsomal lipids and heme pigments [5,36-38]. The lipid component of freshly cooked meats contributes to their desirable and characteristic flavor, but its oxidation affects palatability, and products so formed may have adverse health effects [39]. Phospholipids are most susceptible to autoxidation and form products such as malonaldehyde, pentanal and hexanal [40,41] which are known to be correlated with off-flavor development in uncured meats. Cross and Ziegler [40] examined the volatile constituents isolated from uncured and cured hams by a GC methodology. Qualitatively, the volatile compounds of cured ham were similar to uncured samples, but were quantitatively different. They reported that hexanal and pentanal were present in appreciable amounts in the volatiles of uncured, but were barely detectable in the volatiles of cured ham. Swain [42] concurred with this finding and reported that nitrite appeared to retard the formation of higher molecular-weight aldehydes (i.e. > C5). Cross and Ziegler [40] also noted that the volatiles, after passage through a solution of 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine, had the characteristic cured-ham aroma, regardless of whether cured or uncured hams were used. Cured and uncured chicken and beef volatiles, after stripping their carbonyl compounds by passage through 2,4dinitrophenylhydrazine solutions, also possessed an aroma similar to that of cured ham. These authors concluded that treating meat with nitrite does not seem to contribute any new volatile compounds to the flavor of cooked meats, with the exception of nitrogen oxides that are not present in cooked uncured meat. Therefore, they postulated that cured-ham aroma represents the basic flavor of meat derived from precursors other than triacylglycerols, and that the aromas of various types of cooked meat depend on the spectrum of carbonyl compounds derived by lipid oxidation. Shahidi [35] reported that the elimination of lipid oxidation, either by curing or by stripping of carbonyl compounds from volatiles of untreated cooked meats, caused a major effect on the flavor perception of meats, but this author noted that qualitative differences due to the possible presence of less active flavor components can not be ruled out. Nonetheless, GC analyses of the volatiles of cured meat revealed a much simpler spectrum than their uncured counterparts; the concentration of carbonyl compounds produced from autoxidation of meat lipids was markedly reduced by the presence of nitrite in the system (Table 4). Shahidi [35] proposed that any agent, or
1232 combination of agents that prevents lipid oxidation, with the exception of nitrite precursors, would in principal, duplicate the antioxidant role of nitrite in the curing process, thereby preventing hexanal generation and meat flavor deterioration (MFD). According to Shahidi [43], this is in line with findings of other researchers and its validity was confirmed by preliminary sensory evaluations, but mutton was not included in these studies. A simplistic view, attempting to present a unifying theory of the origin of the basic flavor of meat, species differentiation, and MFD is as follows: when meat is thermally processed, it acquires a characteristic species flavor which results from volatile carbonyl compounds, such as hexanal and pentanal, formed by oxidation of its lipid components (i.e., primarily phospholipids). Further oxidation during storage of cooked meat results in the deterioration of its flavor. Curing with nitrite suppresses the formation of oxidation products. It may be assumed that the flavor of nitrite-cured meats is actually the basic natural flavor of meat from different species without being influenced by overtone carbonyls derived from oxidation of their lipid components. Further support for this view has recently been provided by Ramarathnam et al. [44], but the postulate does not easily explain the fact that the intensity of cured meat flavor is proportional to the logarithm of nitrite concentrations as reported by MacDougall et al. [45], or the apparent persistence of the characteristic "mutton" flavor after nitrite curing of sheep meat [46]. Table 4 Effect of curing with nitrite on the concentration of carbonyl compounds of thermally processed ground pork. Relative Concentration Carbonyl Compound
Hexanal Pentanal Heptanal Octanal Nonanal 2-Octenal 2-Nonenal 2-Decenal 2-Undecenal 2,4-Decadienal
Uncured
Nitrite-Cured'
Nitrite-Free Cured^
100 31.3 3.8 3.6 8.8 2.0 1.0 1.1 1.4 1.1
7.0 0.5 <0.5 <0.5 0.5 ~ — — 0.5 —
6.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.7 ~ <0.1 0.5 <0.1
^Sample contained 550 ppm sodium ascorbate. ^Sample contained the preformed cooked cured-meat pigment, 12 ppm; sodium tripolyphosphate, 3000 ppm; sodium ascorbate, 550 ppm; and tert-butylhydroquinone, 30 ppm. Adapted from references [35] and [66].
1233 To reproduce the antioxidative efficacy of nitrite, we have examined a number of antioxidants [47], sequestrants [48] and their combinations [49]. The concentration of carbonyl compounds produced in these systems from the autoxidation of meat lipids was markedly reduced when combinations containing polyphosphates, ascorbates and low levels of an antioxidant were used. The spectrum of notable carbonyl compounds was similar to the nitrite-cured system. Among the antioxidants used, BHA and TBHQ were the most effective, even at 30 ppm, for retarding oxidation during a 5week storage at 4°C, as measured by the 2-thiobarbituric acid test (Table 5). Among the food-grade sequestrants, sodium acid pyrophosphate (SAPP), tetrasodium pyrophosphate (TSPP), sodium tripolyphosphate (STPP) and ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) were most effective. A strong synergistic action was noted when ascorbates were used in combination with polyphosphates (Figure 5). Addition of small quantities (i.e., 30 ppm) of an antioxidant, such as BHA or TBHQ to the above systems, had a minor effect on the TBA values, but conferred a positive influence on their sensory characteristics as noted by untrained panelists [50]. Similar antioxidant effects were observed when plant phenolic compounds were used [51]. Interestingly, the preformed CCMP had a weak, but noticeable antioxidative effect of its own [47]. Good correlations between the TBA values and the sensory data, as well as between the hexanal content of the meats and their sensory acceptability existed [52]. Table 5 TBA numbers of cooked pork treated with different additives after a 5-week storage period at 4°C.^ Experiment Number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Additive(s), ppm Control, no additives Sodium nitrite, 150 Butylated hydroxyanisole, 30 tert-Butylhydroquinone, 30 Sodium tripolyphosphate, 3000 Tetrasodium pyrophosphate, 3000 Sodium hexametaphosphate, 3000 (5) + Sodium ascorbate, 550 (6) + Sodium ascorbate, 550 (7) + Sodium ascorbate, 550 (8) + (3) (8) + (4) Cooked cured-meat pigment, 12 (11)+ (13) (12) + (13) (14) + Sodium hypophosphite, 3000 (15) + Sodium hypophosphite, 3000
^Adapted from reference [66].
TBA Number, ppm 15.46 0.63 0.44 0.35 1.86 1.66 7.71 0.27 0.23 0.29 0.20 0.18 9.89 0.34 0.24 0.28 0.21
1234
1.00
0.75 h
0.50 h E c
CM CO
ij in CO
0.15 h
8
C CO jQ
u.
O
0.10
cn
JQ
<
0.05 h
0.00 Storage Period at 4°C (Days) Figure 5. Synergistic effect of polyphosphates with sodium ascorbate in meat systems. Symbols (full) are: • , SHMP; • , STPP; A , TSPP; • , SAPP. Corresponding open symbols are for the same polyphosphates with sodium ascorbate. Adapted from reference [66]. 2.2 Safety Considerations 2.2.1 Antimicrobial Action. Nitrite exerts a concentration-dependent antimicrobial effect in cured meat products, including, but not limited to, inhibition of the outgrowth of spores of putrefactive and pathogenic bacteria such as Clostridium botulinum [53]. The degree of protection provided to cooked meats against microbial contamination
1235 depends on many factors including the concentration of residual nitrite present, duration of temperature abuse and extent of contamination. Nitrite also retards microbial spoilage of cured meats by anaerobic and aerobic spore-forming bacteria. The mechanism(s) by which nitrite inhibits the outgrowth of spores and the growth of vegetative cells and microorganisms is not fully understood, but it appears that a reaction with iron-containing enzymes is involved. A better understanding of the exact mechanism(s) of the antimicrobial role of nitrite is still required. Irrespective of future decisions on the fate of nitrite, its removal or reduction must be counter-balanced by alternatives that will assure the safety from botulinal hazards in abused products [54]. Furthermore, the traditional identity of cured meat products must be retained. According to Sofos and Busta [55], any compound to be considered as an alternative to nitrite should be suitable for use in all cured meat products and should control other microorganisms of public health significance, delay product spoilage, and not interfere with beneficial microorganisms such as lactic acidproducing cultures, necessary for the manufacture of fermented meat products. The compound of choice must also be (a) at least as effective as nitrite itself (b) safe, (c) heat stable, (d) flavorless, and (e) preferably effective at low concentrations. Several alternatives to nitrite for its antimicrobial action have been tested. These include sorbic acid and its potassium salt, sodium hypophosphite, fumarate esters, parabens, and lactic acid-producing bacteria (LAPB). These could be used either alone or together with low concentrations of nitrite [14]. Sorbic acid and its potassium salt have been found to be safe additives and are permitted in a variety of foodstuffs. Sofos et al. [56-58] reported that sorbic acid when used at a level of 2000 ppm delayed Clostridium botulinum toxin production in wieners to an extent similar to that of 156 ppm nitrite; but the effects were pH-dependent and were operative at pH < 6.0. Tanaka et al. [59] demonstrated that potassium sorbate addition to wieners at 2700 ppm provided an anticlostridial action similar to that of 100 ppm nitrite. Sodium hypophosphite is a GRAS (generally recognized as safe) substance and may perhaps be used at 3000 ppm level in meats. Microbiological studies indicated that a total or partial replacement of nitrite with this compound effectively inhibits production of Clostridium botulinum toxins [60]. Fumarate esters are effective at 1250 ppm or higher levels in bacon [61] while parabens had little antibotulinal activity in frankfurters. Wood et al. [62] evaluated the antibotulinal activity of sodium hypophosphite, potassium sorbate and monomethyl fumarate in nitrite-free curing systems. The treatment containing 3000 ppm sodium hypophosphite, together with CCMP, sodium ascorbate, STPP and TBHQ, most closely resembled that of nitrite at 150 ppm in its ability to prevent spore outgrowth and toxin production. Monomethyl fumarate at 1250 ppm was slightly less effective than sodium hypophosphite (Table 6). These additives had no adverse effect on the oxidative stability or the color of formulated pork products in model systems [63]. Various LAPB have demonstrated excellent protection against Clostridium botulinum toxin production in nitrite-free cured bacon. Moreover, some strains of LAPB produce bacteriocins (/.^., proteins with antibacterial activity) which prevent other bacteria such as Clostridium botulinum from flourishing. Research into the use of bacteriocins or bacteriocinogenic LAPB for meat preservation is still in its infancy, and existing difficulties must be overcome before
1236 LAPB can be used commercially to extend the storage life and to enhance the safety of meats [64]. Application of irradiation, at 5 or 10 kGy, to meats treated with CCMP not only ensured the keeping quality of the products, but it did not have any negative effect on their color stability [65]. Table 6 Effect of treatment composition on gas and toxin production by Clostridium botulinum in pork.* Incubation at 27°C (days) Treatment^ 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Control NaNO^, 150 (2) + ASC CCMP, 12 (4) + ASC + STPP + TBHQ (4) + SHP (5) + SHP (5) +PS (5) + MMF
1
2
3
34/34+ 0/36- 11/36+ 5/18+ 0/36- 0/32- 15/3017/17+ 12/37+ 25/25+ 1/18- 1/16+ 2/14+ 6/35- 3/27+ 1/240/39- 32/35+ 3/3+ 0/37- 1/33- 17/31+
4
6
8
27
8/13+ 5/14+
2/2+ 4/6+
0/1-
0/1-
4/12+ 6/22+
1/2+ 5/13+
0/11/2+
0/10/1-
9/18+
3/4+
0/1+
0/1-
* Adapted from Wood et al. [62]. Number of packs showing gas production/total number of packs. Toxin present, +; toxin absent, -; ^presence of toxin was not tested. ^Additives were: sodium ascorbate, ASC; cooked cured-meat pigment, CCMP; sodium tripolyphosphate, STPP; tert-butylhydroquinone, TBHQ; sodium hypophosphite, SHP; potassium sorbate, PS; and monomethyl fumarate, MMF. 2.2.2 The A^-Nitrosamines. Nitrite-free ingredients containing the preformed CCMP have been shown to duplicate the color, flavor and bacteriostases of nitrite in model meat systems as reported by Shahidi and co-workers [30,33,47,62,63,66]. Although we have proposed the use of these nitrite-free systems as an alternative to nitrite, the absence of carcinogenic A^-nitrosamines in formulated products must be confirmed. The presence of all possible volatile A^-nitrosamines was tested in various cooked treated muscle food systems, and only N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA) was detected, but only in some of the cooked treated systems examined. Table 7 summarizes the content of volatile NDMA in cooked, nitrite-cured and pigment-treated pork, cod, and cod surimi. No measurable amount of NDMA was detected in the control, nitritecured or CCMP-treated pork systems, but trace quantities of NDMA have been reported in nitrite-cured pork-containing products [11]. Additionally, no detectable amount of NDMA was observed in control fish systems. The occurrence of NDMA in nitrite-treated cod was expected because the formation of A^-nitrosamines in cured fish has been shown to occur primarily in salt-water species [67]. Only ca, 1 ppb of NDMA was detected which may reflect the very fresh nature and careful processing
1237 of the fish used. The precursor of NDMA, dimethylamine (DMA), is formed in the muscles of fish as a result of activity of endogenous enzymes on trimethylamine Table 7 Effects of nitrite and CCMP on the formation of A^-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA) in pork, cod or cod surimi systems.^ Species
Additive, ppm
NDMA, ppb
Pork
No additive NaNOj, 156 CCMP, 12 CCMP, 24
<0.2 <0.2 <0.2 <0.2
Cod
No additive NaNOj, 156 CCMP, 12
<0.2 0.9 <0.2
Cod Surimi
No additive NaNOj, 156 CCMP, 12
<0.2 <0.2 <0.2
^All meat systems were treated with 20% (w/w) distilled water and 550 ppm sodium ascorbate. Detection threshold of NDMA is 0.2 ppb. Adapted from reference [28]. N-oxide. Perhaps only partial degradation of trimethylamine A^-oxide to DMA had occurred in the fish muscle tissue by the time of its use. Although NDMA was detected in nitrite-cured cod, its absence was noted in CCMP-treated samples. This may imply that no disproportionation of CCMP had occurred or that it did not produce a sufficient quantity of nitric oxide to take part in possible transnitrosation reactions. Furthermore, absence of A^-nitrosamines in nitrite-cured cod surimi tends to suggest that washing of cod muscles may be an effective means to remove DMA, trimethylamine, and trimethylamine //-oxide in order to avoid their nitrosation. The effect of sodium nitrite and CCMP at 156 and 12 ppm levels, respectively, on NDMA formation in hybrid meat/fish systems is presented in Table 8. No detectable NDMA was noted in control formulations as expected, but addition of nitrite to hybrid pork systems containing 15 and 50% cod produced 0.3 and 1.0 ppb of NDMA, respectively. The quantities of NDMA in these systems are equal to or less than that found in nitrite-cured cod (Table 7). Again, no measurable amount of NDMA was detected in CCMP-treated hybrid products for the same reasons as stated for pigment-treated systems. Unlike the nitrite-treated cod surimi sample, NDMA was noticed at 0.2 ppb in pork/cod surimi hybrid formulations both at 15 and 50% substitution. Aqueous washing of minced cod flesh did not remove sufficient quantities of trimethylamine, trimethylamine N-oxide or DMA from the fish matrix to prevent nitrosation of DMA even though the 0.2 ppb concentration is at the detection limit of the TEA analyzer. Furthermore, CCMP-treated counterparts were free of detectable NDMA for the same reasons cited above for the pigment-treated cod.
1238 Table 8 Effects of nitrite and CCMP on the formation of N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA) in hybrid pork and cod or cod surimi systems.^
Species
Additive, ppm
NDMA, ppb
Pork (85%) + Cod (15%)
No additive NaNO^, 156 CCMP, 12
<0.2 0.3 <0.2
Pork (85%) + Cod Surimi (15%)
No additive NaNOj, 156 CCMP, 12
<0.2 0.2 <0.2
Pork (50%) + Cod (50%)
No additive NaNOj, 156 CCMP, 12
<0.2 1.0 <0.2
Pork (50%) + Cod Surimi (50%)
No additive NaNOj, 156 CCMP, 12
<0.2 0.2 <0.2
^AU meat systems were treated with 20% (w/w) distilled water and 550 ppm sodium ascorbate. Detection threshold of NDMA is 0.2 ppb. Adapted from reference [28]. 3.
SUMMARY
Several nitrite-free combinations consisting of the preformed CCMP, a sequestrant and an antioxidant, possibly together with an antimicrobial agent, have been formulated for meat curing. These mixtures have been found effective in reproducing the color, the oxidative stability and flavor, as well as the antimicrobial effects of nitrite. Use of other antimicrobial agents such as bacteriocins may prove advantageous. Additionally, nitrite-free curing systems containing the preformed CCMP can be successfully employed in the preparation of processed meat products without the fear of A^-nitrosamine formation. It has been demonstrated that nitrite-free curing of fish or fishery by-products in combination with red meats in the production of novel cured products, free of A^-nitrosamines, is now feasible. Hence, this would not only make use of underutilized fish protein, but it also has the potential to increase the nutritional and sensory quality of formulated products.
4.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are grateful to the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) of Canada for financial support. The A^-nitrosamine work was carried out by Dr. N.P. Sen of the Food Research Division of the Bureau of Chemical Safety, Health Protection Branch in Ottawa.
1239 5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
REFERENCES E.F. Binkerd and O.E. Kolari, Food Cosmet. Toxicol., 13 (1975) 655. R.H. Kerr, C.T.N. Marsh, W.F. Schroeder and E.A. Boyer, J. Agric. Res., 33 (1926) 541. J.B. Fox, Jr., J. Agric. Food Chem., 14 (1966) 207. J.I. Gray and A.M. Pearson, Adv. Food Res., 29 (1984) 1. J.O. Igene, K. Yamauchi, A.M. Pearson and J.I. Gray, Food Chem., 18 (1985) 1. P.A. Morrissey and J.Z. Tichivangana, Meat Sci., 14 (1985) 175. L.A. Freybler, J.I. Gray, A. Asghar, A.M. Booren, A.M. Pearson and D.J. Buckley, Meat Sci., 33 (1993) 85. J.N. Sofos, F.F. Busta and C.E. Allen, J. Food Prot., 42 (1979) 739. R.C. Benedict, J. Food Prot., 43 (1980) 877. N.P. Sen, B. Donaldson, S. Seaman, B. Collins and J.R. Iyengar, Can. Inst. Food Sci. Technol. J., 10 (1977) A13. N.P. Sen, S. Seaman and W.F. Miles, J. Agric. Food Chem., 27 (1979) 1354. S.S. Mirvish, J. Natl. Cancer Inst, 44 (1970) 633. J.I. Gray, S.K. Reddy, J.F. Price, A. Mandagere and W.F. Wilkens, Food Technol, 36(6) 1982 39. National Academy of Sciences, In Alternatives to the Current Use of Nitrite in Foods, National Academy of Science, Washington, DC, 1982. C.W. Sweet, US Patent 3,899,600. A.S. Kostyla and F.M. Clydesdale, CRC Crit. Rev. Food Sci. Nutr., 10 (1978) 303. B.G. Tarladgis, J. Sci. Food Agric, 13 (1962) 485. S.H. Lee and R.G. Cassens, J. Food Sci., 41 (1976) 969. M. Renerre and P. Rougie, Ann. Technol. Agric, 28 (1979) 423. R. Bonnett, S. Chandra, A.A. Charalambides, K.D. Sales and P.A. Scourides, J.C.S. Perkin I (1980) 1706. K.B. Killday, M.S. Tempesta, M.E. Bailey and C.J. Metral, J. Agric. Food Chem., 36 (1988) 909. B.B. Wayland and L.W. Olson, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 96 (1974) 6037. J.S. Smith and D.L. Burge, Jr., J. Food Sci., 52 (1987) 1728. G.G. Giddings, CRC Crit. Rev. Food Sci. Nutr., 9 (1977) 81. F. Shahidi, L.J. Rubin, L.L. Diosady, V. Chew and D.F. Wood, Can. Inst. Food Sci. Technol. J., 17 (1984) 33. F. Shahidi, L.J. Rubin, L.L. Diosady and D.F. Wood, J. Food Sci., 50 (1985) 272. F. Shahidi and R.B. Pegg, J. Food Sci., 56 (1991) 1205. F. Shahidi, R.B. Pegg and N.P. Sen, Meat Sci., 37 (1994) 327. F. Shahidi and R.B. Pegg, J. Food Sci., 56 (1991) 1500. F. Shahidi and R.B. Pegg, Food Chem., 38 (1990) 61.
1240 31
32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56
F. Shahidi, R.B. Pegg and N.P. Sen, In Proceedings of the First International Conference on The Impact of Food Research on New Product Development, R. Ali and PJ. Barlow (eds.), January 24-26, University of Karachi, Pakistan, University of Humberside, UK, pp. 221-245, 1993. R.B. Pegg, Ph.D. thesis, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, NF, 1993. F. Shahidi and R.B. Pegg, J. Muscle Foods, 2 (1991) 297. D.A. Rickansrud and R.L. Henrickson, J. Food Sci., 32 (1967) 57. F. Shahidi, In Flavor Chemistry. Trends and Developments, R. Teranishi, R.G. Buttery and F. Shahidi (eds.), ACS Symposium Series 388, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 188-201, 1989. K. Sato and G.R. Hegarty, J. Food Sci., 36 (1971) 1098. J.O. Igene, J.A. King, A.M. Pearson and J.I. Gray, J. Agric. Food Chem., 27 (1979) 838. J.I. Gray and A.M. Pearson, In Advances in Meat Research. Vol 3: Restructured Meat and Poultry Products, A.M. Pearson and T.R. Dutson (eds.). Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York, NY, pp. 221-269, 1987. R.J. Shamberger, T.L. Andreone and C.E. Wills, J. Natl. Cancer Inst., 53 (1974) 1404. C.K. Cross and P. Ziegler, J. Food Sci., 30 (1965) 610. F. Shahidi and R.B. Pegg, J. Food Lipids, 1 (1994) 177. J.W. Swain, Ph.D. thesis. University of Missouri, Columbia, MO, 1972. F. Shahidi, In Lipid Oxidation in Food, A.J. St. Angelo (ed.), ACS Symposium Series 500, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 161-182, 1992. N. Ramarathnam, L.J. Rubin and L.L Diosady, J. Agric. Food Chem., 39 (1991) 1839. D.B. MacDougall, D.S. Mottram and D.N. Rhodes, J. Sci. Food Agric, 26 (1975) 1743. D.H. Reid, O.A. Young and T.J. Braggins, Meat Sci., 35 (1993) 171. F. Shahidi, L.J. Rubin and D.F. Wood, J. Food Sci., 52 (1987) 564. F. Shahidi, L.J. Rubin, L.L. Diosady, N. Kassam and J. C. Li Sui Fong, Food Chem., 21 (1986) 145. F. Shahidi, L.J. Rubin and D.F. Wood, Food Chem., 23 (1987) 151. J. Yun, F. Shahidi, L.J. Rubin and L.L. Diosady, Can Inst. Food Sci. Technol. J., 20 (1987) 246. F. Shahidi and P.K.J.P.D. Wanasundara, CRC Crit. Rev. Food Sci. Nutr., 32 (1992) 67. F. Shahidi, J. Yun, L.J. Rubin and D.F. Wood, Can. Inst. Food Sci. Technol. J., 20 (1987) 104. M.D. Pierson and L.A. Smoot, CRC Crit. Rev. Food Sci. Nutr., 17 (1982) 141. F. Shahidi and R.B. Pegg, Can. Chem. News, 43(2) (1991) 12. J.N. Sofos and F.F. Busta, Food Technol., 34(5) (1980) 244. J.N. Sofos, F.F. Busta, K. Bhothipaksa and C.E. Allen, J. Food Sci., 44 (1979) 668.
1241 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67
J.N. Sofos, F.F. Busta and C.E. Allen, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 37 (1979) 1103. J.N. Sofos, F.F. Busta, K. Bhothipaksa, C.E. Allen, M.C. Robach and M.W. Paquette, J. Food Sci., 45 (1980) 1285. K. Tanaka, K.C. Chung, H. Hayatsu and T. Kada, Food Cosmet. Toxicol., 16 (1978) 209. R.J. Banner, Food Eng., 53(1) (1981) 130. C.N. Huhtanen, In Developments in Industrial Microbiology, Volume 25, Proceedings of the Fortieth General Meeting of the Society for Industrial Microbiology, August 14-19, 1983, Sarasota, FL, pp. 349-362, 1984. D.S. Wood, D.L. Collins-Thompson, W.R. Usbome and B. Picard, J. Food Prot., 49 (1986) 691. F. Shahidi, L.J. Rubin and D.F. Wood, Meat Sci., 22 (1988) 73. M.E. Stiles and J.W. Hastings, Trends Food Sci. Technol., 2 (1991) 247. F. Shahidi, R.B. Pegg and K. Shamsuzzaman, J. Food Sci., 56 (1991) 1450. F. Shahidi and R.B. Pegg, Food Chem., 43 (1992) 185. Z. Sikorski and S. Kostuch, Food Chem., 9 (1982) 213.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1243
Potential for growth and inhibition of Listeria monocytogenes in meat and poultry products J.N. Sofos, W.B. Barbosa, H.J. Wederquist, G.R. Schmidt and G.C. Smith Department of Animal Sciences and Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523, U.S.A. Abstract The widespread distribution of Listeria monocytogenes in food plants and products, its potential to multiply at cold temperatures and under vacuum, and the high fatality rate it causes in immunocompromised human populations, make it of importance to study its potential to proliferate or to be inhibited in various foods. Studies in our laboratory have examined the potential for growth and inhibition of this pathogen in meat and poultry products. Growth of the pathogen in vacuum-packaged, fresh ground beef stored at 4°C was slow and depended on pH and bacterial strain. At pH values of approximately 5.5, growth of various strains was either nonexistent or very slow. At pH values above 6.0, growth was more pronounced. In contrast to fresh ground beef, growth of the pathogen was rapid and extensive in cooked bologna-type sausage formulated with mechanically deboned turkey meat and stored under vacuum at 4°C. This extensive growth was significantly inhibited by inclusion of sodium acetate (0.5%), sodium lactate (2.0%) or potassium sorbate (0.26%) in the sausage formulation. 1.
INTRODUCTION
Listeriosis is described as a sporadic bacterial infection of animals resulting in encephalitis or meningoencephalitis in adult ruminants, septicemia or focal hepatic necrosis in young ruminants and monogastric animals, and septicemia with myocardial degeneration or hepatic necrosis in birds (Anonymous, 1986). It is also described as causing abortion or perinatal infection in all susceptible mammals, especially cattle and sheep in cold weather, where death can occur 4 to 48 hours after the appearance of symptoms. The agent of the disease is Listeria monocytogenes, and listeriosis has been characterized as a zoonosis and a potential hazard for owners and veterinarians who handle sick animals. However, L. monocytogenes is also considered a human foodbome pathogen, and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimate that approximately 1,850 human cases of listeriosis occur every year in the United States with 425 resulting in death (Schuchat et al., 1992). The clinical signs of the disease in humans are not different than those afflicting other mammals. Human listeriosis can manifest itself as an invasive or noninvasive disease (Schuchat et al., 1991). The invasive form is rare. Factors such as virulence of the
1244 infecting strain, susceptibility of the host and size of the inoculum may determine occurrence of the invasive disease. Listeriosis is usually associated with immunocompromised people, including pregnant women, causing meningitis or meningoencephalitis (Schuchat et al., 1991). The most common immunosuppressive conditions present in non-pregnant adults suffering listeriosis infections are corticosteroid therapy, cancer and AIDS or HIV infection. Many patients, however, had illnesses which are not considered immunosuppressive, such as heart or renal diseases and diabetes (Schuchat et al., 1992). Among pregnant women, abortion, stillbirth, preterm labor or early-onset infection of the neonate are major manifestations. The non-invasive or mild listeriosis syndrome has not been well characterized (Schuchat et al., 1991). Listeria monocytogenes is a Gram-positive, facultative bacterium widely distributed in the natural environment, which over the last several years has become increasingly recognized as an important foodborne pathogen. After the occurrence of several large foodbome outbreaks and associate deaths, L. monocytogenes became the object of considerable public concern (Gellin and Broome, 1989). The food industry, academia, and regulatory and health agencies have focused much attention on gaining an understanding of the nature of the problem, and developing strategies for prevention and control of foodbome listeriosis. Listeria monocytogenes is considered to be a threat to food safety because of its pathogenicity and its ability to proliferate at refrigeration temperatures, since it can grow at 0.4 to 45°C (Ryser and Marth, 1991). The pathogen can also survive freezing and dry conditions, tolerate very high salt concentrations and grow under a wide range of pH levels. Many questions are still to be answered about listeriosis and its transmission with foods. Several kinds of foods are known to carry the pathogen, and it is believed that foodbome transmission may account for a substantial portion of sporadic listeriosis (Pinner et al., 1992; Schuchat et al., 1992). However, very little is known about infective dosage, host susceptibility and strain virulence to establish a direct cause and effect relationship between foods containing L. monocytogenes and the onset of sporadic cases of listeriosis. Epidemiologic studies have reported that, among immunosuppressed patients, eating undercooked chicken increased the risk of listeriosis (Schuchat et al., 1992), but only one documented case of listeriosis in the United States has been directly linked to consumption of poultry products (Anonymous, 1989). Meat and poultry, however, may play a more important role in the epidemiology of listeriosis because the pathogen has been isolated from up to 92% of retail beef mince samples (Lowry and Tiong, 1988), and it is frequently found in slaughterhouses around the world (Genigeorgis et al., 1989, 1990; Gobat and Jenmii, 1990; Pociechaetal., 1991). The behavior of L. monocytogenes in meat or poultry, however, is not completely known; research has produced variable results. Although meat seems to offer all the necessary conditions for growth of the pathogen, studies have shown that the interaction of different factors may reverse this situation. The effect of factors such as L. monocytogenes strains, pH, gas atmosphere composition, spoilage flora, organic salts and temperature on the behavior of the pathogen in meat or meat products needs to be well understood. Strain differences may play a major role in the fate of the pathogen in food products. Listeria monocytogenes includes several strains of different pathogenicity, and perhaps, distinct growth behavior as well. However, most of the research published has tested the behavior of one particular strain (Scott A) in foods (Buchanan and Klawitter, 1991;
1245 Dickson, 1990; Fain et al., 1991; Harrison et al., 1991; Kallander et al., 1991), including meats. Very often, when Scott A is not the strain studied, a pool of different strains is used (Glass and Doyle, 1989; Palumbo and Williams, 1991; Sorrells and Enigl, 1990; Yen et al., 1991, 1992). Listeria monocytogenes is a particularly difficult organism to control in foodprocessing establishments. Refrigerated food plants, in particular, provide conditions which allow for L. monocytogenes survival and growth. Since L. monocytogenes can and will multiply at refrigeration temperatures and in the presence of nitrites and salt, attention is also being directed at investigating this pathogen in ready-to-eat foods, including meat and poultry products. Temperatures of 4 to 10°C are not uncommon in food distribution systems and in retail environments. Home refrigerators have been found to average close to 7°C (Junttila et al., 1988). In a study conducted by Grau and Vanderlinde in 1992, listeriae were detected on 93 of 175 samples of vacuum-packaged processed meats obtained from retail stores, and 5% of the samples contained more than 1000 colony forming units (CFU) per gram. Today, food manufacturers rely on a variety of processing techniques to produce safe and wholesome products with acceptable shelf life. The most common methods of food preservation include heating, cooling, freezing, drying, fermentation and modified atmosphere packaging, few of which can guarantee complete destruction of the hardy L. monocytogenes bacteria. Incorporation of chemical preservatives such as sodium chloride, sodium nitrite, sodium acetate, sodium bicarbonate, sodium lactate or potassium sorbate, may play an important role in the control of L. monocytogenes when used in combination with other processing techniques. Studies in our laboratory have examined the potential for growth and inhibition of L. monocytogenes in fresh and processed meat and poultry products. 1.1
Fate of Listeria monocytogenes in meat and poultry
It is well established that L. monocytogenes is frequently present in meat and poultry products, and that it is difficult to totally eliminate the pathogen from raw meat products. The role of meat and poultry in the transmission of listeriosis to humans, however, is still unknown. In general, meat products frequently carry the pathogen, but not many cases of listeriosis have been associated with consumption of meat or poultry (Barbosa, 1993; Wederquist, 1993). As mentioned above, one case of listeriosis resulting in death has been associated with consumption of turkey frankfurters (Anonymous, 1989). The patient was a woman who had breast cancer. A package of the product found in her refrigerator was contaminated with L. monocytogenes, and so were unopened packages of the same brand in a nearby store. 1.2
Raw meat and poultry
Theoretically, meat and poultry should offer good environments for growth of L. monocytogenes. Studies have shown, however, that this may not always be true, especially in red meats. Inexplicable differences in growth behavior of L. monocytogenes on different meats have been observed (Doyle, 1988), but overall, the number of cells will increase or stay the same after different periods of storage at refrigeration temperature (Sofos, 1992). Significant growth of L. monocytogenes strain Scott A was not detected in hamburger, irradiated hamburger, sausage, or chicken salad stored at 4°C for 7 days, but it was reported
1246 in milk at the same temperature (Buchanan et al., 1987). Survival of L. monocytogenes, but not growth, was observed in ground beef (pH 5.6 to 5.9) stored in oxygen-permeable or vacuum packages held at 4°C for 2 weeks (Johnson et al., 1988). The number of L. monocytogenes remained similar (10^ to 10^ CFU/g) throughout the 14 days of the study, and no differences were observed between the two strains (Scott A and V-7) tested. The authors speculated that meat might be deficient in a nutrient required by the organism to grow. Growth of L. monocytogenes was not observed in ground beef or liver stored at 4 and 25°C (Shelef, 1989), but the potential of meat lacking a necessary ingredient for growth of L. monocytogenes was not confirmed by the author. Three strains of L. monocytogenes (Scott A, Brie-1 and ATCC 35152) were inoculated in ground beef (pH 5.8) and liver (pH 5.6), and incubated at 4°C for 40 days. Despite the differences in composition and pattern of spoilage between the two meats, Listeria counts did not change during the storage period. In the same research study, water, glucose and calcium were added to some of the ground beef samples, but these ingredients did not change the behavior of the microorganism. Growth could only be observed in meat extract, obtained after blending and centrifugation of the meat. It was concluded that all the necessary ingredients for growth of L. monocytogenes should be associated with the water-soluble portion of the meat. According to the author, centrifugation must have either removed possible suppressing compounds associated with the muscle, or released vital nutrients which were not available to the bacteria before (Shelef, 1989). Another paper has endorsed the potential presence of an inhibitory factor against L. monocyro^^«^5 in beef (Buchanan and Klawitter, 1991). Listeria monocytogenes strain Scott A did not grow in either irradiation-sterilized or regular vacuumpackaged raw ground beef stored at 5°C for 800 hours, but growth was observed in cooked meat stored under the same conditions. Whatever was inhibiting L. monocytogenes in the raw meat was lost or was not present in the cooked product. Other studies, however, have contradicted the above findings. Packaging ground beef (pH > 6) under CO2 was more effective in inhibiting growth of L. monocytogenes than vacuum packaging (Gill and Reichel, 1989). Growth occurred in vacuum packages held at 0°C or above, but it was not observed at -2°C. The growth rate of the pathogen was always slower than the growth rate of the natural bacterial flora or other pathogens such as Yersinia enterocolitica and Aeromonas hydrophila. Listeria monocytogenes stopped growing or died in some occasions when the natural flora approached maximum numbers, showing that the native flora can interfere with its behavior in meat. Lag phase became longer as the temperature of storage decreased from 10°C to 5°, 2° or 0°C. Other studies have also speculated about the effect of the natural flora on the inhibition of L. monocytogenes (Buchanan and Klawitter, 1991; Kaya and Schmidt, 1991). Listeria monocytogenes was not able to grow in beef of pH 5.6 stored at 2 or 4°C for 9 weeks. At 7°C, growth occurred just after 3 weeks (pH 5.6). Lactic acid bacteria grew fast and became the dominant flora at 2 and 4°C (pH 5.6), overcoming the number of L. monocytogenes. In high pH beef (pH>6.0), however, growth of L. monocytogenes was observed at 2, 4, 7 and 10°C. At the lowest temperatures, growth started within one week of storage, while at 7 and 10°C, the number of listeriae cells increased more than one power of ten in less than 3 days. Brochothrix thermosphacta grew well in the high pH meat and surpassed L. monocytogenes. Lactic acid bacteria did not grow in the high pH meat, and the authors concluded that growth of listeriae was dependent on the interaction of temperature, pH and competing flora. Growth inhibition of L. monocytogenes in minced beef by lactic acid bacteria has been
1247 demonstrated previously (Gouet et al., 1978). Listeria monocytogenes could not grow in meat (pH 5.8) inoculated with Lactobacillus plantarum, but grew well in the presence of Pseudomonas fluorescens and Escherichia coli. The pH of meat samples inoculated with both L. monocytogenes and L. plantarum remained almost the same during the 17 days of study, but pH increased from 5.8 to 6.5 in 17 days in meat samples inoculated with L. monocytogenes in combination with P. fluorescens and E. coli (Gouet et al., 1978). Another study showed that L. monocytogenes Scott A was able to grow in vacuum packaged lean beef tissue held at 5°C (Dickson, 1990). A four log increase in the number of listeriae present was observed after 21 days of storage, but the microorganism started growing after 7 days. The pH of samples was not reported, however. Listeria monocytogenes, strain Murray B, grew in fat and lean beef striploins of pH between 5.5 to 6.1 packaged under vacuum and stored at 0 and 5.3°C (Grau and Vanderlinde, 1990). Growth was more pronounced in fat than in lean tissue at both 0 and 5.3°C. At 0°C (meat pH 5.5 to 5.7), growth in the lean tissue was severely inhibited until 61 days of storage, and after 76 days, the number of listeriae was just 5 times the initial number. At 5.3°C, growth started after a lag phase of 5 to 6 days. Listeria monocytogenes grew better in lean tissue with pH 6.0 to 6.1 than in the lower pH muscle, but growth in the fat portion was still more accentuated than in the lean. Different results were obtained by Chung et al. (1989), who found that L. monocytogenes strain Scott A grew better in lean than in fat beef tissue incubated at 5°C for a week. The pathogen was able to grow in chicken broth (pH 6.4) incubated at temperatures as low as -0.4°C (Walker et al., 1990). When listeriae inocula were pre-incubated at 30°C instead of 4°C, multiplication was observed above 0.5°C. It was reported that cultures preincubated at 30°C could have had a more intense "cold shock" when transferred to very low temperatures. Because these cultures were grown at optimal temperatures, they were probably more sensitive to extensive reductions in temperature (Walker et al., 1990). Under modified atmosphere packaging (72.5/22.5/5 %, N2/C02/02)L. monocytogenes multiplied in minced chicken incubated at 4, 10 or 27°C (Wimpfheimer et al., 1990). Neither listeriae initial number nor high initial aerobic counts affected changes of the microorganism under these conditions. The modified atmosphere packaging was more effective in controlling the natural flora, showing that growth could occur before spoilage of the meat. The pathogen failed to grow at 4, 10 or 27°C when oxygen was not present in the package (75/25, CO2/N2). Another study reported growth of L. monocytogenes in fresh chicken legs (pH 6.52) held at 6°C for 17 days (Zeitoun and Debevere, 1991). Growth was noticed after 6 days of storage under modified atmosphere packaging (90/10%, CO2/O2) or air. The pathogen was partially inhibited when lactic acid and sodium lactate were sprayed on the samples. Hart et al. (1991) described the behavior of L. monocytogenes in skinless chicken breasts (pH = 5.8) packed under different concentrations of CO2 (air, 30% CO2 + ah-, 30% CO2 + N2 and 100% CO2), and incubated at 1, 6 or 15°C. Counts of L. monocytogenes did not change in samples stored at 1°C for up to 17 days, independent of gaseous environment. Little growth was observed at 6°C when the listeriae inoculum was grown at 37°C, but incubating the inoculum culture at 1°C led to slow growth in the inoculated meat. At 15°C, counts of L. monocytogenes increased about 100-fold in two days when air was present in the package, but less growth occurred under 100% CO2. Although storage temperature was the major limiting factor for growth of the pathogen, modified atmosphere packaging determined the type of the spoilage bacteria present which could have
1248 affected the performance of L. monocytogenes. The pH of the chicken breasts (5.8), which was below the pH usually reported in other experiments (above 6), may be an important factor to be considered when analyzing the results. Listeria monocytogenes grew better in air-packaged than in vacuum-packaged chicken stored at 4°C for 15 days, but it could not be detected in air-packaged irradiated chicken (2.5 kGy) during the same period (Varabioff et al., 1992). Surprisingly, surviving cells were detected in vacuum-packaged irradiated chicken after 7 days of storage, indicating that the irradiation dose may not have been sufficient to eliminate the bacteria in poultry. Despite the differences in results presented by different studies, it seems that some growth of L. monocytogenes is expected to occur in fresh meat and poultry, with growth at refrigerated temperature being more extensive in poultry than in red meats. 1.3
Cooked or processed meat and poultry
The ability of L. monocytogenes to survive or grow in processed meat products will depend on the product itself (Glass and Doyle, 1989), the resistance of the organism to heat, presence of chemical additives, post-processing contamination and their interactions with temperature, pH and gas atmosphere. A composite of five strains of L. monocytogenes, representing two serotypes, was inoculated in several meat products, which were then incubated at 4°C for 12 weeks (Glass and Doyle, 1989). Listeria monocytogenes grew well in some wiener products, ham, bologna and bratwurst, but it grew exceptionally well (within 4 weeks) on sliced chicken and turkey. It survived but did not grow in summer sausage and grew slightly in cooked roast beef. Poultry and other products with pH above 6 offered the best conditions for growth. Listeria monocytogenes strain Murray B was able to proliferate in vacuum-packaged corned beef and ham incubated at different temperatures (Grau and Vanderlinde, 1992). In corned beef, the growth rate was determined by temperature of incubation. At 9 and 15 °C, L. monocytogenes multiplied at the same rate or faster than the natural flora, while at 5°C its growth rate was half of that of the natural flora. In ham, the growth rate of L. monocytogenes was determined by the interaction of temperature and sodium nitrite concentration. As the storage temperature decreased, the pathogen grew slowly in hams with higher levels of residual sodium nitrite. Growth of L. monocytogenes strain Scott A was detected on cooked chicken loaf stored under air and two modified atmospheres at 3, 7 and 11°C for 6 days (Ingham et al., 1990). Modified atmosphere packaging did not stop the growth of L. monocytogenes, but the microorganism grew better in the presence of oxygen. Similar results were observed in precooked chicken nuggets (Marshall et al., 1991). Buncic et al. (1991) reported growth of L. monocytogenes in vacuum packaged frankfurters stored at 4°C. The number of L. monocytogenes increased about 30-fold after 10 days and 420 tunes after 20 days of storage, but it failed to multiply in fermented sausages at room temperature (18 to 22°C) for 20 days. In fact, the number of L. monocytogenes decreased by approximately 2 logs in the first 11 days of storage and remained the same during the following days. The decrease in pH and water activity during the process, as well as the presence of Lactobacillus spp. were probably responsible for the inhibition of L. monocytogenes. Subsequent tests demonstrated that culture filtrates from strams of L. plantarum (pH 3.42 to 4.52) isolated from the sausage possessed inhibitory activity against L. monocytogenes in agar media (zones of inhibition of
1249 4.5 to 11 mm). Zones of inhibition decreased to diameters of 0.5 to 1.2, however, when the pH of the culture filtrates was adjusted to 7.0 1.4
Effects of additives on growth
1.4.a Effect of pH and water activity Traditionally, L. monocytogenes has been considered to be relatively sensitive to acidic environments below pH 5.5 (Gray and Killinger, 1966). However, several newer studies have revealed that in microbiological media, L. monocytogenes was able to grow at pH levels as low as 4.4 (Buchanan and Phillips, 1990; Conner et al., 1986; Sorrells et al., 1989). Consequently, the presumed minimum pH value for growth of the organism has been adjusted downward. The minimum pH at which L. monocytogenes can grow is, of course, dependent upon the incubation temperature, time, and the type of acidifying agent present in the growth substrate (Ryser and Marth, 1991). Sorrells et al. (1989) studied the effect of pH and other factors on the growth and survival of L. monocytogenes and found that inhibition of the pathogen in the presence of an acidic environment appeared to be a function of the synergism between the type of acid and the incubation temperature. At a given pH value, the authors concluded that the antimicrobial activity of the acids followed the sequence: acetic acid > lactic acid > citric acid > malic acid > hydrochloric acid at all incubation times and temperatures. The most inhibition of L. monocytogenes occurred at 35°C, the most growth was observed at 25°C, and the greatest survival was detected at 10°C. The final pH of the culture medium decreased to 3.8 in the presence of hydrochloric acid after 28 days of incubation. A significant observation made in this study was that L. monocytogenes was able to proliferate at the pH value of 4.4, which is much lower than that which had been previously reported (Gray and Killinger, 1966). In addition, the study may have significance in minimally processed and refrigerated acid or acidified foods, due to the observation that L. monocytogenes was able to tolerate a low pH at temperatures of 10°C. In additional work by Sorrells and Enigl (1990), the effect of pH, acidulant, sodium chloride and temperature on the growth of L. monocytogenes was investigated. The authors determined that the minimum pH/salt level for initiation of growth of the organism ranged from pH of 5.0-5.6 when combined with 8-10% sodium chloride (incubated at 25 and 35°C), to pH of 5.6 when combined with 8% sodium chloride and incubated at 10°C. In this study, L. monocytogenes appeared to persist and be tolerant in a system which combined a low pH, high salt and low temperature environment. Listeria monocytogenes, like most other bacterial species, exhibits optimal growth at a water activity (a^) of approximately 0.97 (Petran and Zottola, 1989). Yet, when compared to other microorganisms, L. monocytogenes also has the rather unique ability to proliferate at a^ values as low as 0.92 (Ryser and Marth, 1991). The effect of a^, however, is variable with different solutes. The minimum a^ values for glycerol, sodium chloride and propylene glycol were 0.90, 0.92 and 0.97, respectively (Miller, 1992).
1250 1.4.b Sodium acetate Sodium acetate is a derivative of acetic acid in the form of a sodium salt. According to the United States Code of Federal Regulations (21; 184.1721), sodium acetate is approved as a generally recognized as safe (GRAS) substance for miscellaneous and general purpose usage. It has been used as a pH control agent, flavoring agent and adjuvant, and shows antimicrobial properties (Doores, 1990). Maximum levels of sodium acetate that are recommended for various food product categories range from 0.007% in breakfast cereal to 0.5% in fats and oils. Some derivatives of acetic acid in the form of calcium, sodium or potassium salts can be substituted for acetic acid in certain formulations (Doores, 1990). One of the primary uses of acetic acid in food has been that of an acidulant, which has excellent antimicrobial properties. This activity has been attributed to lowering of the pH below that needed for optimal growth (Doores, 1990). The effect of organic acids, including acetic acid, on reducing microbial loads on poultry and red meat have been investigated. The decimal reduction times for Salmonella newport, Salmonella typhimurium and Campylobacter jejuni in scald tank water used in poultry processing dropped almost one log cycle after exposure to 0.1% acetic acid at 52°C (Okrend et al., 1986), while addition of either 0.5% or 1.0% acetic acid caused either a 99% reduction in plate counts or inmiediate death of the bacteria, respectively (Lillard et al., 1987; Okrend et al., 1986). Although numerous studies have shown that bacterial numbers can be reduced by 90-99% if beef or pork carcasses or primal cuts are washed and sanitized with 3.0% acetic acid (Anderson et al., 1979; BiemuUer et al., 1973, Cacciarelli et al., 1983; Marchall et al., 1977), few studies exist on the antimicrobial, and particularly the antilisterial, effects of its counterpart salt, sodium acetate, in vacuum-packaged or processed meat products. Mendonca et al. (1989) found that unmersing fresh pork in solutions containing 3.0% acetic acid effectively inhibited growth of enterobacteriaceae, lactobacilli, anaerobes and facultative anaerobes during storage in vacuum packages. Pork chops dipped in solutions containing 1.5% acetic acid/1.5% sodium acetate supported microbial growth significantly lower than controls dipped in sterile water. The authors concluded that surface treatment of beef steaks with a potassium sorbate-phosphate-sodium chloride-sodium acetate solution was very effective in extending their microbiological shelf life in vacuum packages during 12 weeks of storage at 2-4°C (Unda et al., 1990). Roskey and Lachica (1992) found that growth of L. monocytogenes in broth with 0.5% sodium acetate was inhibited at pH of 5.6 and temperatures of less than 35°C, but it proceeded at pH of 6.0. A concentration of 1.0% sodium acetate was required to inhibit L. monocytogenes at pH of 6.0, but it was effective only at temperatures below 15°C. The effectiveness of sodium acetate was not diminished in the presence of a high initial inoculum of L. monocytogenes. In presterilized beef, 0.5% sodium acetate inhibited L. monocytogenes growth, but in presterilized chicken, a 1.0% level of the additive was required for inhibition, presumably because of higher pH and fat content. The authors concluded that 0.5% sodium acetate may be a valuable and appropriate preservative for red meat and luncheon meats. These studies indicate that acetic acid is effective for controlling growth of a wide range of microorganisms in meat and other types of food. Sodium acetate may have potential as an antimicrobial additive for meat, since the salts of acetic acid are expected to have the same antimicrobial properties as the acid, when used at comparable pH levels. Research is needed to evaluate the antimicrobial
1251 and antilisteriai effects of sodium acetate, and to determine if the additive would affect physical and organoleptic properties of meat products. 1.4.C Sodium bicarbonate Sodium bicarbonate is a low-cost, nontoxic food additive which has GRAS status, and is widely used in the food industry at levels of up to 2% as a leavening agent, for pH control, and to contribute to flavor and texture development in food products (Lindsay, 1985). Although data on the antimicrobial properties of sodium bicarbonate are quite limited, the compound is used in dental preparations where it inhibits periodontal bacteria (Cerra and Killoy, 1982; Newbrun et al., 1984; Miyasaki et al., 1986). Montville and Goldstein (1987) found that sodium bicarbonate was effective in reducing survival of Aspergillus parasiticus and altering the distribution of aflatoxin in cells of the mold which did survive. Corral et al. (1988) noted that E. coli, L. plantarum, Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa counts were reduced 10,000-fold by 0.12 M (1.00% w/v) of sodium bicarbonate incorporated into the growth media. Moreover, plate counts for yeasts such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Hansenula wingei were reduced 100,000-fold by 0.06 M sodium bicarbonate. Bechtel et al. (1985) examined the effect of substituting sodium bicarbonate for sodium chloride in pork and beef frankfurter formulations with either 2% sodium chloride (control), 1% sodium chloride and 1% sodium bicarbonate, or 2% sodium bicarbonate. Frankfurters were stored vacuum-packaged for 30 days at 4°C, and results at 0, 15 or 30 days revealed no significant differences in total plate counts among treatments. The pH of the sodium chloride control was 6.0, while sodium bicarbonate at levels of 1% and 2% elevated the pH of the frankfurters to 7.5 and 8.2, respectively. Curran et al. (1990) reported that dipping cod fillets in 8.0% sodium bicarbonate or 12% ammonium bicarbonate solution resulted in marked reductions of microbial growth compared to untreated samples after storage at 4°C for 8 days. Total plate counts, proteolytic bacteria and hydrogen sulfide-producing bacteria were inhibited by the test solutions. Treated fish exhibited improved texture and moisture retention, yet also had significantly lower aroma and overall acceptability scores. Therefore, it appears that sodium bicarbonate may have some potential as an antimicrobial food additive, which may be useful in inhibiting the growth of acid tolerant microorganisms such as Lactobacillus spp., proteolytic bacteria and certain yeasts and molds. Since sodium bicarbonate, used at levels of 1.0 to 2.0%, may raise the pH of the food one full pH unit or greater, its uses are limited to certain foods in which this may be a desirable attribute. 1.4.d Sodium lactate Sodium lactate has been recognized in recent years as a food ingredient which enhances sensory properties and inhibits microbial growth. The preservative properties of sodium lactate can be attributed to various mechanisms, including feedback inhibition, intracellular acidulation, interference with proton transfer across the cell membrane and lowering of product water activity (Bacus and Bontenbal, 1991). Natural sodium lactate is commercially produced by fermentation; is considered GRAS by the Food and Drug Administration; and is approved by the U.S. Department of Agriculture for use in meat and poultry products. In addition, sodium lactate serves as a firming agent with humectant
1252 properties. Papadopoulos et al. (1991) recommended use of sodium lactate at levels of 2-3 % (of a 100% solution), based on final weight, to enhance flavor and extend shelf life of fresh and cooked meat and poultry products. Sodium lactate exhibits antimicrobial activity against many foodbome pathogens, including Clostridium botulinum. Maas et al. (1989) reported that incorporation of 2.0 to 3.5% (based on final product) sodium lactate into conmiinuted, raw turkey meat delayed toxin production by C. botulinum in cook-in-bag turkey products. Listeria monocytogenes, Salmonella spp., E. coli and S. aureus, were also reportedly inhibited by lactate (Bacus and Bontenbal, 1991). Shelef and Yang (1991) found that L. monocytogenes could also be inhibited by sodium or potassium lactate in broth, chicken and beef. Studies with tryptic soy broth showed that sodium lactate concentrations higher than 5.0% delayed growth of three strains of L. monocytogenes. Experunents in sterile, conmiinuted chicken and beef at 5°, 20° and 35°C demonstrated suppression of growth by 4.0% lactate, which increased with decrease in storage temperature. Listeria monocytogenes consistently exhibited greater sensitivity to lactate in beef than in chicken, displaying an extended lag phase of 1-2 weeks during storage at 5°C. When 4.0% lactate was combined with 3.0% sodium chloride or 140 ppm sodium nitrite, the antimicrobial effect was not enhanced. The authors also noted that incorporation of potassium or sodium lactate did not alter the pH of the chicken or beef, and no significant difference was observed between the effect of the two salts, inferring that the lactate ion may be responsible for the delay in listerial growth (Shelef and Yang, 1991). Unda et al. (1991) concluded that in temperatureabused (10, 25°C) beef roasts, incorporation of lactate into the brine afforded protection against the survival of Clostridia. Listeria survival was reduced by lactate and monolaurin in recooked surface-inoculated roasts. Research reported by Bacus and Bontenbal (1991) indicated that sodium lactate was effective when used to control growth of L. monocytogenes in both cured and uncured meat and poultry products. Frankfurter treatments formulated without sodium lactate allowed growth of 10^ CFU/g during storage for 46 days at 4°C, while L. monocytogenes counts actually decreased in test formulations containing 2 or 4% sodium lactate. Sodium lactate also extended the shelf life of the product by decreasing growth of the microflora normally associated with frankfurters. Sodium lactate used at 2% and 3% also inhibited for 14 or 21 days growth of L. monocytogenes inoculated postprocessing on uncured cooked chicken rolls (Bacus and Bontenbal, 1991). Chen and Shelef (1992) studied the relationship between water activity, salts of lactic acid and growth of L. monocytogenes in a meat model system consisting of cooked strained beef ranging in moisture content from 25 to 85% (wt/wt). Sodium lactate, when used at a level of 4.0% (based on finished product), suppressed listerial growth at moisture levels of greater than 55% (a^ > 0.964), and inhibited growth in meat with moisture levels of 25-55% (a^ < 0.964). The authors reported that lactate concentrations less than 4.0% were not listeriostatic, but combinations of 2.0 or 3.0% lactate with 2.0% sodium chloride in samples with 55 % moisture did inhibit growth. The potassium and calcium salts of lactic acid were as effective as the sodium salt in suppressing water activity of the meat system, and growth of L. monocytogenes. These studies suggest that incorporation of lactate into meat products may extend shelf life, suppress microbial growth, and even enhance flavor in some cases. Additional studies are needed to establish the optimum usage level for meat products, and to further evaluate the effect of sodium lactate on the microorganisms in meat.
1253 1.4.e Potassium sorbate Sorbic acid and potassium sorbate have been used throughout the food industry to extend the shelf life of many foods, including bakery items, cereals, fruits and vegetables, butter, cheese and meat products (Sofos, 1989). According to reviews by Robach and Sofos (1982) and Sofos and Busta (1981), sorbates can delay growth and toxin production by C botulinum, and extend the shelf life and decrease the growth of other pathogenic microorganisms in products such as bacon, fresh poultry and cooked, cured or fermented red meat and poultry products. Research conducted by El-Shenawy and Marth (1988) examined the effect of potassium sorbate against L. monocytogenes in tryptose broth adjusted to a pH of 5.6 or 5.0, and incubated at various temperatures. At pH 5.6 and storage at 4°C, L. monocytogenes was inactivated by 0.25 or 0.3% potassium sorbate after 66 and 60 days, respectively. The organism grew at all potassium sorbate concentrations (0.005-0.30%) when incubated at 13°C and pH 5.6, but maximum populations were directly related to the additive concentration. According to the data collected in this experiment, the ability of potassium sorbate to prevent growth of L. monocytogenes is directly related to temperature and pH. Ryser and Marth (1988) determined that four strains of L. monocytogenes were eliminated faster from cold-pack cheese food with a pH of 5.45, which contained 0.30% potassium sorbate than from cheese food manufactured at pH 5.2 without preservative. In additional studies, El-Shenawy and Marth (1991) reported that incorporation of organic acids such as acetic, tartaric, lactic or citric acid enhanced the antilisterial activity of potassium sorbate. Unda et al. (1991) examined the effect of selected antimicrobials in combinations including potassium sorbate on the survival and inhibition of L. monocytogenes and C. sporogenes in cook-in-bag beef roasts. Acetic acid- and potassium sorbate-containing brines exhibited significant inhibitory properties against anaerobic and facultative anaerobic bacteria in both refrigerated and temperature-abused beef roasts. These studies indicated that sorbate is a valuable food additive and is an effective inhibitor of several types of microorganisms, including bacteria, yeasts and molds, when used at appropriate levels. More research is needed to understand the mechanisms by which sorbate inhibits these microorganisms, and to examine the effect of sorbate on meat pathogens such as L. monocytogenes. 2.
EXPERIMENTAL
As indicated above, several studies have reported conflicting results relative to the potential for growth of L. monocytogenes in fresh meat. In general, it is not clear whether the pathogen is able to proliferate in uncooked, refrigerated beef, and pH value is among the factors which may be responsible for such variability. Studies with ground beef of pH > 6.0 have detected growth of L. monocytogenes at refrigeration temperatures (Gill and Reichel, 1989; Grau and Vanderlinde, 1990; Kaya and Schmidt, 1991), while at pH values <6.0, no growth of the pathogen has been observed in most of the studies with refrigerated ground beef (Buchanan et al., 1987; Johnson et al., 1988; Shelef, 1989; Buchanan and Klawitter, 1991; Kaya and Schmidt, 1991). In addition to pH, physiological differences in strains may be a factor influencing the results of such studies. It is not clear at this time how important differences in strain behavior may be to the fate of L. monocytogenes in uncooked, refrigerated beef of different pH.
1254 In contrast to fresh beef, listeriae were detected regularly in samples of ready-to-eat processed meats obtained from retail stores (Grau and Vanderlinde, 1992; Johnson et al., 1990). Glass and Doyle (1989) reported growth of L. monocytogenes at 4.4°C on ham, sliced chicken and turkey products, wieners and fresh bratwurst. An important observation from this study was that processed meats with pH values of > 6.0 allowed for better growth of L. monocytogenes than meat products with a lower pH. Thus, the high pH (>6.0) of products from poultry meat, such as turkey bologna and frankfurters, may allow for the survival and growth of L. monocytogenes. If that is the case, then there is a need for inhibition of proliferation of L. monocytogenes in processed poultry products. Studies in our laboratory (Barbosa, 1993; Wederquist, 1993) have investigated the potential for growth of L. monocytogenes in refrigerated vacuum-packaged ground beef as affected by differences in strains and pH, and its potential for growth and inhibition with chemical additives in vacuum-packaged refrigerated turkey bologna-type sausage. 2.1
Fresh ground beef
Fresh ground beef samples from top rounds were selected on the basis of their pH, and were divided into those having an average pH of 5.47, which is normal for fresh beef, and others having an elevated average pH of 6.14. The fat content of all treatments was in the range 2.93-3.22%. The ground beef was formed in patties which were inoculated with one of two strains of L. monocytogenes (Na-16/serotype l/2a or Scott A/serotype 4b). The inocula of each strain were prepared in tryptic soy broth (TSB) containing 0.6% yeast extract (Difco Laboratories, Detroit, MI) at 4.0°C. Individual patties were inoculated with sterile distilled water or with the suspension of each strain at 3-4 log colony forming units - CFU/g. Each ground beef patty (approximately 80 g) was inoculated with 0.1 mL of cell suspension or sterile distilled water. Individual patties were vacuum packaged, stored at 4°C and analyzed at weekly intervals during 42 days of storage. During storage, the patties (two per treatment and sampling time) were analyzed for pH, total aerobic plate counts and L. monocytogenes counts. Each experiment was repeated 2-3 times. Total aerobic plate counts were determined on tryptic soy agar (TSA, Difco). Plates were incubated at 35°C for 48 hours. Counts of L. monocytogenes were determined by plating on lithium chloride-phenyethanol-moxalactam-tellurite (LPMT) agar plates incubated at 35°C for 48 hours. The fat content of the ground beef samples was determined by petroleum ether (Mallinckrodt, Paris, KY) extraction of moisture-free samples according to AOAC procedures (Association of Official Analytical Chemists, 1990). Moisture content was determined by drying under vacuum for 12 hours at 60-65 °C. The pH of the samples was determined on blends consisting of one part of meat and three parts of phosphate buffer solution with a Coming flat combination electrode (Coming Glasswork, Medfield, MA). Each experiment was repeated 2-4 times. 2.2
Turkey bologna sausage
A typical turkey bologna sausage product was formulated to contain 7.464 kg of mechanically deboned turkey meat, 0.908 kg of water, 181.6 g of dextrose, 181.6 g of com symp solids, 181.6 g of sodium chloride, 81.7 g of dry mustard, 36.3 g of phosphate, 1.416 g of sodium nitrite, 4.54 g of sodium erythorbate, 22.7 g of paprika, 4.54 g of onion
1255 powder, 4.54 g of garlic powder, 4.54 g of coriander and 4.54 g of white pepper. In addition to the control, experimental treatments were formulated to contain chemical additives, which included 0.5% sodium acetate, 1.0% sodium bicarbonate, 2.0% sodium lactate and 0.26% potassium sorbate. Raw, mechanically deboned turkey meat (MDTM) and the other ingredients were weighed in 9.08 kg batches which were mixed and chopped in a Meissner bowl chopper. The bologna emulsions were extracted into 7.62-cm diameter fibrous cellulose casings (Koch, Kansas City, MO), which were weighed and cooked in a smokehouse to an internal temperature of 70°C. The bologna sausage was then cooled by showering with cold water and stored at 4°C. After it was chilled for 12 hours, the bologna was peeled to remove the casings, and sliced (4-5 mm thick). Two bologna slices (30 g each) at a time were inoculated with 0.1 mL of inoculum dispensed in the center between the slices and spread evenly across the surface with a sterile bent glass rod. The inoculum consisted of a composite of seven strains (four serotype 1/2 and three serotype 4) prepared at 35°C in TSB. The two slices were then wrapped in plastic wrap, vacuum packaged at 120 mmHg and analyzed during storage at 4°C for 98 days. Two samples per treatment and sampling time were analyzed for L. monocytogenes counts by plating on TSA, incubated at 35 °C for 48 hours. The experiment was repeated two times. The pH of the bologna samples was measured in duplicate, at each weekly plating interval, similar to raw fresh beef. Moisture, fat and protein contents were determined according to procedures described above. 3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1
Raw fresh beef
Overall, there was a slight decrease in the pH of normal (5.47-5.48) initial pH ground beef patties during storage at 4°C, but no major differences were detected among treatments inoculated with different strains of L. monocytogenes (Table 1). Ground beef patties of high initial (6.12-6.14) pH showed no major changes in pH during storage at 4°C. Immediately after inoculation, the counts of L. monocytogenes of both strains in patties of normal and high pH were similar (Table 2). With storage in vacuum packages at 4°C, certain changes were detected in counts of L. monocytogenes. The changes, however, depended on L. monocytogenes strain and product pH. In normal pH ground beef, counts of strain Na-16 increased by approximately 1 log CFU/g, while those of strain Scott A decreased slightly. In ground beef patties of high initial pH, L. monocytogenes counts of strain Na-16 increased by more than 2 log CFU/g during the 42 days of storage, while those of strain Scott A increased very little ( < 1 log CFU/g). Total aerobic mesophilic plate counts were similar within each pH group of ground beef patties inoculated with L. monocytogenes (Table 3). In ground beef of normal initial pH, growth was similar (approximately 2 log CFU/g) irrespective of strain of L. monocytogenes inoculated in the ground beef. In high pH ground beef, growth was higher (approximately 4 log CFU/g) compared to normal pH ground beef, but still similar between strains of L. monocytogenes (Barbosa et al., 1994).
1256 Table 1 Changes in pH of ground beef patties of normal and high initial pH inoculated with each of two strains of Listeria monocytogenes (Na-16 and Scott A) during storage in vacuum packages at 4°C Normal initial pH
High initial pH
Days of storage (4°C)
Na-16
Scott A
Na-16
Scott A
0 7 14 21 28 35 42
5.48 5.49 5.58 5.43 5.39 5.36 5.31
5.47 5.54 5.47 5.35 5.47 5.25 5.45
6.14 6.15 6.08 6.16 6.16 6.29 6.20
6.12 6.24 6.13 6.09 6.15 6.26 6.19
Table 2 Counts (log CFU/g) of two Listeria monocytogenes strains (Na-16 and Scott A) inoculated in ground beef patties of normal and high initial pH, and stored vacuum-packaged at 4°C Normal initial pH Days of storage (4°C) 0 7 14 21 28 35 42 CFU: colony formmg umts.
High initial pH
Na-16
Scott A
Na-16
Scott A
4.23 4.26 5.30 5.10 5.48 5.34 4.63
4.00 3.01 3.43 3.37 3.53 2.94 3.67
4.51 4.54 5.61 6.38 6.75 6.80 7.06
3.58 2.60 3.88 4.05 4.30 4.39 3.42
Overall, multiplication of L. monocytogenes in vacuum-packaged ground beef stored at 4°C was very slow, while the spoilage or total aerobic bacterial flora multiplied faster and reached higher numbers than L. monocytogenes in ground beef of either normal or high pH. Growth of both, L. monocytogenes and total aerobic bacteria, however, was different depending on ground beef pH and strain of inoculum. When the pH of ground beef was greater than 6.0, multiplication of bacteria, including L. monocytogenes, was rapid and extensive. At lower pH, growth was less extensive, especially for L. monocytogenes. Actually, in normal pH ground beef, strain Scott A of L. monocytogenes decreased in numbers during storage, while strain Na-16 increased only slightly. Even in high pH ground beef, growth of strain Scott A was limited. Therefore, growth of L. monocytogenes in vacuum-packaged ground beef was influenced by strain of inoculum and pH of meat. Strain Scott A, which is used extensively in research, multiplied very slowly or not at all, while strain Na-16 multiplied faster, especially when the ground beef pH value exceeded 6.0.
1257 Overall, L. monocytogenes either did not multiply or multiplied very slowly in vacuum packaged ground beef of normal initial pH (5.47) at 4°C, but growth was more extensive in ground beef of high initial pH (6.14). Table 3 Total aerobic plate counts (log CFU/g) in ground beef patties of normal and high initial pH inoculated with two strains (Na-16, Scott A) of Listeria monocytogenes, and stored vacuumpackaged at 4°C Normal initial pH Days of storage (4°C) 0 7 14 21 28 35 42 CFU: colony forming units. 3.2
High initial pH
Na-16
Scott A
Na-16
Scott A
4.74 5.34 6.27 5.99 6.60 6.63 6.39
4.21 4.55 5.90 6.05 6.04 6.21 6.60
4.79 7.02 7.49 7.89 7.98 8.56 8.62
4.41 6.05 6.88 7.47 7.43 8.04 8.42
Turkey bologna sausage
The initial pH value of 6.58 for the control turkey bologna product increased with added chemicals, especially with sodium bicarbonate (Table 4). With storage in vacuum packages at 4°C for 98 days, the pH of all treatments decreased gradually but still remained above 6.0. These pH values should not be restrictive to L. monocytogenes growth (Wederquist et al., 1994). Table 4 Changes in pH of turkey bologna sausage formulated with various additives, inoculated with Listeria monocytogenes after processing and stored vacuum packaged at 4°C Days of storage (4°C) 0 14 28 42 56 70 84 98
Control 6.58 6.50 6.53 6.48 6.44 6.26 6.13 6.11
Sodium acetate (0.5%)
Sodium bicarbonate (1.0%)
Sodium lactate (2.0%)
Potassium sorbate (0.26%)
6.63 6.54 6.62 6.49 6.50 6.41 6.25 5.88
7.59 7.46 7.59 7.51 7.43 7.29 7.14 7.07
6.73 6.65 6.70 6.58 6.48 6.52 6.43 6.35
6.59 6.48 6.58 6.49 6.51 6.48 6.39 6.30
1258 Growth (Table 5) of L. monocytogenes in the vacuum-packaged turkey bologna sausage without additives (control) was very rapid, reaching 5.79 log CFU/g by 28 days of storage (4°C). After 42 days of storage, growth had exceeded 7 log CFU/g. Thus, in this product, which was cooked and of high pH, growth of L. monocytogenes inoculated on cooked slices after processing was very rapid and extensive, compared to fresh raw ground beef of lower pH (Table 2). Therefore, there is a need for inhibition of L. monocytogenes growth in cooked sausage products. Table 5 Counts (log CFU/g) of Listeria monocytogenes inoculated after processing in turkey bologna sausage which was formulated with various additives and stored vacuum packaged at 4°C Days of storage (4°C)
Control
0 2.59 14 4.49 28 5.79 42 7.86 56 8.88 70 8.71 84 8.43 98 8.51 CFU: colony formmg umts.
Sodium acetate (0.5%)
Sodium bicarbonate (1.0%)
Sodium lactate (2.0%)
Potassium sorbate (0.26%)
2.47 3.14 3.31 3.14 3.69 3.80 3.19 3.25
2.31 4.19 6.76 7.60 8.23 9.09 8.53 8.62
2.46 2.35 2.09 3.24 3.60 4.36 4.07 4.97
2.18 2.77 3.04 3.14 3.19 3.74 4.25 4.26
Of the four additives and at the concentrations tested, sodium acetate, sodium lactate and potassium sorbate were effective, while sodium bicarbonate, which increased the pH to above 7.0, was ineffective in inhibiting L. monocytogenes inoculated in turkey bologna after heat processing (Table 5). Counts of L. monocytogenes during the 98-day period increased by 1.33, 2.51 and 2.08 log CFU/g in treatments with acetate, lactate and sorbate, respectively. Growth in the control and bicarbonate treatments was 6.29 and 6.78 log CFU/g, respectively. Changes in total aerobic plate counts (Table 6) were similar to those forL. monocytogenes. The results show the potential for extensive growth of L. monocytogenes in turkey bologna sausage contaminated post-processing. The results also indicated that growth of L. monocytogenes in vacuum packaged refrigerated turkey bologna may be significantly reduced through inclusion in the formulation of 0.5% sodium acetate, 2.0% sodium lactate or 0.26% potassium sorbate. 4.
CONCLUSIONS
Growth of L. monocytogenes in ground top rounds of beef stored under vacuum at 4°C depended on strain of the pathogen and initial pH of the meat. In meat of pH less than 6.0, growth was limited, with one strain of L. monocytogenes multiplying slightly and the second decreasing somewhat in counts during storage. In ground beef of pH above 6.0,
1259 growth of the pathogen was more extensive, but still depended on strain. The commonly studied strain Scott A multiplied only slightly, while strain Na-16 increased by more than 2 log CFU/g during the 42 days of storage. Overall, however, growth of L. monocytogenes in refrigerated ground beef is limited, compared to total aerobic mesophilic bacteria. The limited growth of L. monocytogenes, especially of strain Scott A and at the lower pH, may have been due to competing microbial flora producing inhibitors such as bacteriocins. Buchanan and Klawitter (1992a,b) have reported on a strain of Camobacterium piscicola LK5 that was isolated from ground beef and inhibited L. monocytogenes strain Scott A in refrigerated foods. Meat pH values lower than 6.0 select for growth of lactic acid producing bacteria. Table 6 Total aerobic plate counts (log CFU/g) in turkey bologna sausage formulated with various additives and stored vacuum-packaged at 4°C Days of storage (4°C)
Control
0 2.75 14 4.52 28 5.80 42 7.88 8.96 56 70 8.75 84 8.52 98 8.59 CPU: colony forming units.
Sodium acetate (0.5%)
Sodium bicarbonate (1.0%)
Sodium lactate (2.0%)
Potassium sorbate (0.26%)
2.58 3.21 3.71 3.32 3.75 4.05 3.66 4.38
2.35 4.29 6.79 7.74 8.27 9.16 8.74 8.70
2.49 2.43 3.10 3.30 4.04 4.43 4.12 5.08
2.44 2.97 3.16 3.23 3.21 3.86 4.38 4.35
In contrast, growth of L. monocytogenes inoculated in cooked turkey bologna sausage after slicing was very rapid and extensive during storage in vacuum packages at 4°C. However, this growth was greatly inhibited by additives such as sodium acetate, sodium lactate and potassium sorbate. Sodium bicarbonate increased product pH and did not inhibit growth of L. monocytogenes. It should be noted that in addition to being cooked, the turkey bologna was different than ground beef in that its pH exceeded the value of 6.5. 5.
REFERENCES
Anderson, M.E., R.T. Marshall, W.C. Stringer and H.D. Naumann, J. Food Prot., 42 (1979)389-391. Anonymous. Listeriosis (Listerellosis, Circling disease). In: The Merck Veterinary Manual, 6th ed. Merck & Co., Inc., Rahway, NJ. pp. 382-385, 1986. Anonymous, Meat and Poultry, 35(5) (1989) 8.
1260 AOAC. Meat and meat products. In: K. Helrich (Ed.). Official Methods of Analysis of the Association of Food Chemists. Vol. 2, 15th Ed. Assoc, of Offic. Analyt. Chem., Inc., Arlington, VA. p. 931, 1990. Bacus, J. and E. Bontenbal, Meat and Poultry 37(6) (1991) 64-69. Barbosa, W.B. Fate of different species and strains of Listeria in broth and vacuum packaged ground beef. M.S. Thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, 1993. Barbosa, W.B., J.N. Sofos, G.R. Schmidt and G.C. Smith, J. Food Prot. (1994) (in press). Bechtel, P.J., F.K. McKeith, S.E. Martin, E.J. Basgall and J.E. Movakofski, Food Prot. 48 (1985) 861-864. BiemuUer, G.W., J.A. Carpenter and A.E. Reynolds, J. Food Sci., 38 (1973) 261-264. Buchanan, R.L. and J.G. Phillips, J. Food Prot., 53 (1990) 370-376, 381. Buchanan, R.L. and L.A. Klawitter, Int. J. Food Microbiol., 12 (1991) 235-246. Buchanan, R.L. and L.A. Klawitter, J. Food Safety, 12 (1992a) 199-217. Buchanan, R.L. and L.A. Klawitter, J. Food Safety, 12 (1992b) 219-236. Buchanan, R.L., H.G. Stahl and D.L. Archer, Food Microbiol., 4 (1987) 269-275. Buncic, S., L. Paunovic and D. Radisic, J. Food Prot., 54 (1991) 413-417. Cacciarelli, M.A., W.C. Stringer, M.E. Anderson and H.D. Naumann, J. Food Prot., 46 (1983) 231-232. Cerra, M.B. and W.J. Killoy, J. Periodont., 53 (1982) 599. Chen, N. and L.A. Shelef, J. Food Prot., 55 (1992) 574-578. Chung, K-T., J.S. Dickson and J.D. Crouse, J. Food Prot., 52 (1989) 173-177. Conner, D.E., R.E. Brackett and L.R. Beuchat, Appl. Envir. Microbiol., 52 (1986) 59-63. Corral, L.G., L.S. Post and T.J. Montville, J. Food Sci., 53 (1988) 981-982. Curran, D.K., B.J. Tepper and T.J. Montville, J. Food Sci., 55 (1990) 1564-1566. Dickson, J., J. Food Safety, 10 (1990) 165-174.
1261 Doores, S. pH control agents and acidulants. In: Food Additives. A.L. Branen, M. Davidson and S. Salminen (Eds.). Marcel Dekker, Inc. New York, NY pp. 447488, 1990. Doyle, M.P., Food TechnoL, 42(4) (1988) 169-171. El-Shenawy, M.A. and E.H. Marth, J. Food. Prot., 51 (1988) 842-847. El-Shenawy, M.A. and E.H. Marth, J. Food Prot., 54 (1991) 593-597. Fain, A.R. Jr., I.E. Line, A.B. Moran, L.M. Martin, R.V. Lechowich, J.M. Carosella and W.L. Brown, J. Food Prot., 54 (1991) 756-761. Gellin, B.G. and C.V. Broome, J. Am. Med. Assoc, 261 (1989) 1313-1320. Genigeorgis, C.A., D. Dutulescu and J.F. Garayzabal, J. Food Prot., 52 (1989) 618-624. Genigeorgis, C.A., P. Oanca and D. Dutulescu, J. Food Prot., 53 (1990) 282-288. Gill, C O . and M.P. Reichel, Food Microbiol., 6 (1989) 223-230. Glass, K.A. and M.P. Doyle, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 55 (1989) 1565-1569. Gobat, P-F. and T. Jemmi, Fleischwirtsch., 70 (1990) 1448-1450. Gouet, P.H., J. Labadie and C. Serratore, Zbl. Bakt. Hyg., 166 (1978) 87-94. Grau, E.H. and P.B. Vanderlinde, J. Food Prot., 53 (1990) 739-741. Grau, E.H. and P.B. Vanderlinde, J. Food Prot., 55 (1992) 4-7. Gray, M.L. and A.H. Killinger, Bacteriol. Rev., 30 (1966) 309-382. Harrison, M.A., Y. Huang, C. Chao and T. Shineman, J. Food Prot., 54 (1991) 524-527. Hart, C D . , G.C Mead and A.P. Norris, J. Appl. Bacteriol., 70 (1991) 40-46. Ingham, S.C, J.M. Escude and P. McCown, J. Food Prot., 53 (1990) 289-291. Johnson, J.L., M.P. Doyle and R.G. Cassens, Int. J. Food Microbiol., 6 (1988) 243-247. Johnson, J.L., M.P. Doyle and R.G. Cassens, J. Food Prot., 53 (1990) 81-91. Juntilla, J.R., S.I. Niemela and J. Him, J. Appl. Bacteriol., 65 (1988) 321-327.
1262 Kallander, K.D., A.D. Hitchins, G.A. Lancette, J.A. Schmieg, G.R. Garcia, H.M. Solomon and J.N. Sofos, J. Food Prot., 54 (1991) 302-304. Kaya, M. and U. Schmidt, Fleischwirtsch., 71 (1991) 424-426. Lillard, H.S., L.C. Blankenship, J. A. Dickens, S.E. Craven and A.D. Shackelford, J. Food Prot, 50 (1987) 112-114. Lindsay, R.C. Food Additives. Ch. 10. In: Food Chemistry. O.R. Fennema (Ed.). Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, NY. pp. 632-675, 1985. Lowry, P.D. and I. Tiong. The incidence of Listeria monocytogenes in meat and meat products: Factors affecting distribution. In: Proc. 34th Int. Congress Meat Sci. Technol., Part B. pp. 528-530, 1988. Maas, M.R., K.A. Glass and M.P. Doyle, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 55 (1989) 22262229. Marchall, R.T., M.E. Anderson, H.D. Naumann and W.C. Stringer. J. Food Prot., 40 (1977) 246-247. Mendonca, A.F., R.A. Molins, A.A. Kraft and H.W. Walker, J. Food Sci., 54 (1989) 1821. Miller, A.J., J. Food Prot., 55 (1992) 414-418. Miyasaki, K.T., R.J. Genco and M.E. Wilson, J. Dent. Res., 65 (1986) 1142. Montville, T.J. and P.K. Goldstein, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 53 (1987) 2303. Newbrun, E., C.I. Hoover and M.I. Ryder, J. Periodontol., 55 (1984) 658-659. Okrend, A.J., R.W. Johnston and A.B. Moran, J. Food Prot., 49 (1986) 500-503. Palumbo, S.A. and A.C. Williams, Food Microbiol., 8 (1991) 63-68. Papadopoulos, L.S., R.K. Miller, G.R. Acuff, C. Vanderzant and H.R. Cross, J. Food Sci., 56 (1991) 341-347. Petran, R.L. and E.A. Zottola, J. Food Sci., 54 (1989) 458-460. Pinner, R.W., A. Schuchat, B. Swaminathan, P.S. Hayes, K.A. Deaver, R.E. Weaver, B.D. Plikaytis, M. Reeves, C.V. Broome, J.D. Wenger and the Listeria Study Group, JAMA, 267(15) (1992) 2046-2050.
1263 Pociecha, J.Z., K.R. Smith and G.J. Manderson, Int. J. Food Microbiol., 13 (1991) 321328. Robach, M.C. and J.N. Sofos, J. Food Prot., 45 (1982) 374-383. Roskey, C.T. and R.V. Lachica. Effect of sodium acetate and sodium lactate on the growth of Listeria monocytogenes in broth and in meat. Institute of Food Technologists Annual Meeting, New Orleans, LA. Abstr. No. 658, 1992. Ryser, E.T. and E.H. Marth, J. Food Prot., 51 (1988) 615-621, 625. Ryser, E.T. and E.H. Marth. Listeria, Listeriosis and Food Safety. Marcel Dekker, Inc. New York, NY, 1991. Schuchat, A., B. Swaminathan and C.V. Broome, Clin. Microbiol. Rev., 4(2) (1991) 169183. Schuchat, A., K.A. Deaver, J.D. Wenger, B.D. Plikaytis, L. Mascola, R.W. Pinner, A.L. Reingold, C.V. Broome and the Listeria Study Group, JAMA, 267(15) (1992) 20412045. Shelef, L.A.. J. Food Prot., 52 (1989) 379-383. Shelef, L.A. and Q. Yang, J. Food Prot., 54 (1991) 283-287. Sofos, J.N. Sorbate Food Preservatives. CRC Press, Inc. Boca Raton, FL, 1989. Sofos, J.N. Listeria monocytogenes and its fate in meat products. In: G. Charalambous (Ed.). Food Science and Human Nutrition. Elsevier Science Publishers. New York, NY. pp. 743-760, 1992. Sofos, J.N. and F.F. Busta, J. Food Prot., 44 (1991) 614-622. Sorrels, K.M. and D.C. Enigl, J. Food Safety, 11 (1990) 31-37. Sorrells, K.M., D.C. Enigl and J.R. Hatfield, J. Food Prot., 52 (1989) 571-573. Unda, J.R., R.A. Molins and H.W. Walker, J. Food Sci., 55 (1990) 323-326. Unda, J.R., R.A. Molins and H.W. Walker, J. Food Sci., 56 (1991) 198-205. Varabioff, Y., G.E. Mitchell and S.M. Nottingham, J. Food Prot., 55 (1992) 389-391. Walker, S.J., P. Archer and J.G. Banks, J. Appl. Bacteriol., 68 (1990) 157-162.
1264 Wederquist, H.J. Thermal destruction of Listeria monocytogenes in turkey bologna. M.S. Thesis, Colorado State University, Fort CoUms, CO, 1993. Wederquist, H.J., J.N. Sofos and G.R. Schmidt, J. Food Sci., (in press), 1994. Whnpfheimer, L., N.S. Altmanand J.H. Hotchkiss, Int. J. Food Microbiol., 11 (1990) 205214. Yen, L.C., J.N. Sofos and G.R. Schmidt, J. Food Prot., 54 (1991) 408-412. Yen, L.C., J.N. Sofos and G.R. Schmidt, Lebensm. -Wiss. u. -TechnoL, 25 (1992) 61-65. Zeitoun, A.A.M. and J.M. Debevere, Int. J. Food Microbiol., 14 (1991) 161-170.
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1265
Quality of extrusion-cooked poultry meat products J.N. Sofos, A.S. Ba-Jaber, G.R. Schmidt and J.A. Maga Department of Animal Sciences and Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523, U.S.A. Abstract A series of studies in our laboratory have examined the feasibility of extrusion cooking of hand-deboned chicken meat (HDCM) and mechanically-deboned turkey meat (MDTM) combinations in a single screw extruder with various nonmeat binders. The results are useful in the selection of binders, meat combinations and concentrations that have the potential for use in the production of acceptable products. The studies reported here evaluated the twenty most acceptable product formulations, in terms of binding and texture, for their tenderness, juiciness, flavor and overall satisfaction. The eight most acceptable formulations were then evaluated for the effect of boiling on their cooking yield, proximate composition and appearance. Products with 20-60% MDTM (80-40% HDCM), 15-22% soy protein isolate (SPI) and 0.5-1.0% kappa-carrageenan (K-C), were the most acceptable, while those with 80-100% MDTM were the least acceptable. The average fat level of the boiled products was 1.3-10.3% and their protein content 24.5-33.4%. Therefore, it is possible to produce acceptable and nutritious extruded products from low cost meat when combined with appropriate binders. 1.
INTRODUCTION
Extrusion cooking of meat is difficult due to its high moisture content and the presence of fat. These ingredients result in product gushing out of the die in small granules or backflowing of the raw material from the extruder inlet (Megard et al., 1985; Ba-Jaber et al., 1992a; Sofos et al., 1992). These problems are caused because fat and moisture act as lubricants of the extruder die and screw resulting in product slippage or blockage of the die. Therefore, any material that exits the die is of limited cohesion, crumbly and friable. These problems may be avoided by drying or defatting the meat before extrusion, and/or mixing with nonmeat binders and gelling agents, such as soybean proteins, starches, wheat flour, potato products and gums. Use of nonmeat ingredients in extruded meat products eliminates the above technical problems; improves binding and texture; and reduces their total fat, while increasing protein contents. Several studies have indicated that, with various modifications, extrusion cooking of muscle tissues is possible and may be useful in upgrading animal products and by-products (Lawrie and Ledward, 1983; Areas and Lawrie, 1984; Kristensen et al., 1984; Alvarez et al., 1990).
1266 Mechanically deboned meat is an underutilized, economical source of animal protein, which was restructured with a twin screw extruder in the presence of gelling and binding agents such as soy protein isolates, wheat flour, com starch, egg white concentrate, carrageenan, sodium chloride, sodium phosphate, sodium alginate and calcium chloride (Megard et al., 1985). Another study on restructuring mechanically deboned chicken meat with a twin-screw extruder found that soy protein isolate and wheat gluten were less effective than starch for increasing apparent tensile stress and Wamer-Bratzler shear stress of extruded products. These parameters also increased as a function of temperature up to 104°C (Alvarez etal., 1990). Several other studies have been published and deal with development of meat-containing products, including low-fat snacks, processed by extrusion cooking, with nonmeat ingredients such as com products (Clarke et al., 1989; Chung et al, 1989; Tarte et al., 1987), modified potato starch and hydrolyzed vegetable proteins (Thomas et al., 1989), gums, maltodextrins and soybean proteins (Chung et al., 1989). Meats tested include beef, pork and mechanically deboned turkey meat, with nonmeat ingredient levels as high as 50-60% (Clarke et al., 1989) and meat up to 10% in the dehydrated state (Thomas et al., 1989). Other studies have used similar principles to develop extrusion cooked products based on raw materials from fish (Suzuki et al., 1988; Sasamoto et al., 1989; Bhattacharya et al., 1988). Texturized blends of meat proteins and com starch were formed with a twin screw extmder at various feeding rates, temperatures, shear rates and pH values (Chakraborty et al., 1987). The results indicated that lower extrusion temperatures and higher pH values produced extmdates of better quality. Ground meat with 20-40% moisture was extrusion processed to form an expanded meat product (Hale, 1970). Extrusion of meat mixed with plant materials can be used to produce meat-based snacks, chunks or powders for soups or stews, and pasta products fortified with meat. It should be mentioned again that these products are based on lower value raw meat; are of low fat; have no added sodium chloride; are of high protein contents; and if they can be made shelf-stable they should be very useful in development of value-added items which should increase overall consumption of meat by providing customers with nutritious, safe and reasonably priced food items. Both soy protein isolate (SPI) and mechanically-deboned meat have characteristic offflavors which may affect the acceptability of the final product. The off-flavor of the soy protein, which has been described as "beany" or "cereal-like" (Southard, 1985), had a significant effect in reducing the acceptability, especially when used at high levels (25%) in beef patties. Extruded products examined in previous studies in our laboratory contained both mechanically deboned turkey meat (MDTM) and SPI (Ba-Jaber et al., 1992a,b,c; Sofos et al., 1992). These products had no added salt or spices, factors which can significantly improve the acceptability of meat products (Sofos, 1983a,b; Sofos et al., 1977; Southard, 1985). The objective of this study was to evaluate the eating quality of extrusion cooked products formulated with MDTM, hand-deboned chicken meat (HDCM), SPI, kappacarrageenan (K-C) gum and oat fiber. Twenty combinations of these ingredients yielding products of acceptable particle binding and texture were evaluated for their juiciness, tendemess, flavor and overall satisfaction. The effect of adding salt to the eating quality of the products was also evaluated. Then the eight most acceptable formulations were evaluated for the effect of boiling on composition and quality.
1267 2.
EXPERIMENTAL
2.1 Product formulations The formulations found to possess acceptable particle binding and textural properties (Ba Jaber, 1990) and which were evaluated in this study are presented in Table 1. The table also shows the extrusion parameters of temperature and extruder screw speed used. The MDTM and the corresponding HDCM amounts tested were in the range of 0% to 100%. The SPI levels ranged from 14% to 26%, while those of K-C were in the range of 0% to 1.0%, and oat fiber 0% to 2%. The extrusion temperature ranged between 45°C and 105°C, and the extruder screw speed between 60 rpm and 100 rpm. Following this study, the eight most acceptable formations in terms of binding, texture and eating quality, which are shown in Table 2, were evaluated for the effect of boiling on their composition and quality. The MDTM and HDCM levels tested were 0-100%; the SPI levels 15-24%; the K-C 0-1%; and the oat fiber 0-2%. The extrusion temperature was either 95°C or 105°C, and the extrusion screw speed 100 rpm, with one exception, which was 80 rpm. Table 1 The extrusion variables and formulations of the 20 treatments of extruded products prepared for eating quality evaluation
Treatment
MDTM: HDCM
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 MDTM:HDCM = SPI = Soy protein
SPI (%)
Extrusion temperature (°C)
Extrusion screw speed (rpm)
K-C gum (%)
24 100:0 95 100 0.6 22 95 100 0.6 100:0 22 95 100 0.9 100:0 16 95 80 0.0 10:90 20:80 22 95 60 0.0 22 95 80 0.0 60:40 22 105 60 0.0 60:40 0.0 20:80 21 95 100 0.5 60:40 22 105 100 1.0 60:40 22 95 100 24 0.0 60:40 105 100 24 0.5 60:40 95 100 0.0 22 105 100 80:20 0.5 22 95 100 80:20 24 0.0 95 100 80:20 24 105 1.0 80:20 100 0.5 26 95 100 100:0 0.5 12 95 0:100 100 15 0.0 0:100 95 100 14 0.0 0:100 95 100 Mechanically-deboned turkey meat/hand-deboned chicken meat isolate; K-C gum = Kappa-carrageenan gum.
Oat fiber (%) 0.0 2.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
1268 Table 2 The extrusion variables and formulations of the 8 selected treatments to study the effects of cooking on the quality of the extruded products
Treatment 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
MDTMiHDCM
SPI (%)
60:40 20:80 60:40 60:40 80:20 80:20 0:100 100:0
22 20 22 22 22 24 15 22
Extrusion temperature (°C) 95 95 105 95 95 105 95 95
Extrusion screw speed (rpm) 80 100 100 100 100 100 100 100
K-C gum (%)
Oat fiber (%)
0.0 0.0 0.5 1.0 0.5 1.0 0.0 0.6
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 2.0
MDTM:HDCM = Mechanically-deboned turkey meat/hand-deboned chicken meat. SPI = Soy protein isolate. K-C gum = Kappa-carrageenan gum. The hand-deboned chicken meat used was derived from broilers purchased from a supermarket. The chicken meat was skinned, deboned and cut. Then it was ground through a plate with 0.3-cm diameter holes in a Univex grinder (#PB2, Univex Co., Somerville, NC) and mixed at low speed for one minute in a laboratory mixer (model K45SS, Hobart Mfg. Co., St. Joseph, MO). Next, the nonmeat ingredients were slowly added during low-speed mixing to avoid spattering. The mixing of the meat and nonmeat ingredients was continued at low speed for 5 min, after which the mixing process was stopped. All of the nonmeat ingredients on the sides of the bowl were pushed down with a plastic spatula. Mixing was then resumed for another 8-10 min until the ingredients became uniform and no lumps appeared in the dough. The dough was then removed from the mixer bowl and divided into two portions. Each portion was placed in a plastic bag, labeled A and B, and refrigerated (4°C) until it was extruded later on the same day. Extrusion was performed in a Brabender plasticoder extruder, model PL-V500 (C.W. Brabender Instruments, Inc., South Hackensack, NJ). The diameter of the barrel of the extruder was 19.00 mm, with a 20:1 length-to-diameter ratio and eight 0.79 x 3.18 mm longitudinal grooves. A screw configuration of 1:1 compression ratio was used, and the die plate used was 5.10 cm long with a 0.87-cm diameter opening. The two zones of the extruder were electrically heated and compressed air-cooled collars controlled by thermostats were used to control the temperature of the barrel. Two thermocouples were placed through the barrel wall and indicated the temperature of the dough in the extruder (Likimani et al., 1990, 1991). The extruder was equipped with a variable speed D-C drive unit, a tachometer and a balanced-type torque meter (model 7540, Eaton Corporation, Troy, MI). Ground, moistened com grits were choke-fed into the extruder until a steady state of operation was achieved. Samples of the mixtures from bag A were then fed manually and continuously into the extruder. Ground, moistened com was fed between treatments. After
1269 the A samples were extruded, the B samples were extruded in the same mamier. Each sample was collected from the die outlet in a plastic cup and transferred to a plastic bag. The extruded samples were allowed to cool for approximately 30 min and were stored for one day in the refrigerator (4°C) for subsequent evaluation. Observations on the behavior of the products during extrusion were recorded. 2.2 Sensory evaluation Seven experienced judges from the Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition at Colorado State University were asked to evaluate the product sensory quality parameters of juiciness, tenderness, flavor and overall satisfaction, based on 8-point hedonic scales. For juiciness, the score of 8 represented extremely juicy, and 1 extremely dry; for tenderness, the score of 8 was for products that were extremely tender and 1 for products that were extremely tough; for flavor and overall satisfaction, the score of 8 was like extremely and 1 dislike extremely. The panelists were asked to evaluate the products in two sessions on two consecutive days. The evaluation of the products was done on the second and third day after extrusion. On the day of evaluation, the products were taken from the refrigerator and allowed to reach room temperature (1-1.5 hours). An amount of approximately 1 kg from each treatment was cut into pieces of uniform shape (1.5-2 cm length). Each of the samples was then cooked separately in boiling water for 12 min (treatment 19 was also cooked in 2.5% salted water for 12 min). Each cooked sample was transferred to a plastic cup and again allowed to reach room temperature. The panelists were served in succession a 5- to 10-gram sample from each treatment on a plastic plate. Between each taste test of the samples, the panelists rinsed their mouth with cold water and cleansed their palates with cookies. 2.3 Effect of boiling As indicated, the treatments resulting in the most acceptable extruded products in terms of binding and eating quality from the above study were chosen for further study (Table 2). Samples (10 g) of extruded product from each of the eight treatments (Table 2) were weighed at room temperature and put into boiling water and allowed to cook for 5, 10 or 15 min. After cooking, they were taken out of the boiling water and drained, reweighed while hot, and then allowed to reach room temperature (approximately 10 min). Then the samples were packaged and stored in the refrigerator until the time of proximate analysis. 2.4 Proximate analysis and pH The proximate composition and the pH of the products were determined before and after extrusion. Moisture and fat were determined on a 5-7 gram sample which was weighed inside a fat extraction thimble and heated in a vacuum oven (model 5851, National Appliance Co., Portland, OR) for 24 hours at 65°C. The dry sample was then allowed to cool in a dessicator for 30 min before reweighing. The fat content of the dry sample was then determined by pentane extraction using the Soxtec #1043 extraction unit (Tecator, Inc., Herdon, VA). For protein determination, a 2-gram sample was weighed and analyzed with the Tecator system (Tecator, Inc., Hemdon, VA) for Micro-Kjeldahl nitrogen determination (% protein = N x 6.25). The pH of the products was determined by blending a 10-gram sample with 40 grams of distilled, deionized water for 1 min using an Osterizer Galaxie
1270 blender (Oster Corp., Milwaukee, WI). The pH was then determmed with a Coming pH meter 124 (Coming Glass Works, Medfield, MA). 2.5 Statistical analysis The results were analyzed by analysis of variance (Steel and Torrie, 1980) in order to determine significance of differences among treatments in product juiciness, tendemess, flavor and overall satisfaction. Analysis of variance was also used to determine the effect of salt on the acceptability of the final products. Means were separated with Duncan's procedure. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The results of the first experiment showed significant (P<0.05) panelist effects on juiciness, tendemess, flavor and overall satisfaction. But among the 20 extruded products evaluated, the treatment differences were not significant (P>0.05) in terms of flavor and overall satisfaction. However, a significant difference (P<0.05) in juiciness and tendemess was noted (Table 3). In general, the results showed that the higher the MDTM and/or SPI level, the less acceptable were the products (Table 4). Table 3 The significance, means and standard errors for juiciness, tendemess, flavor and overall satisfaction scores of 20 treatments of Table 1 (seven panelists) Evaluation description Juiciness Tendemess Flavor Overall satisfaction
Significance among treatments 0.05 0.05 N.S. N.S.
Significance among panelists
Mean
Standard error
0.008 0.005 0.000 0.000
4.68 5.17 4.66 4.59
0.9534 0.7784 0.9194 0.7960
N.S. = Not significant. Treatments number 10 and 12 were the most acceptable, and their corresponding formulations were 60:40 MDTM to HDCM, 22% SPI and 1% K-C, 60:40 MDTM to HDCM, SPI (24%), 24% SPI and 0.5% K-C. In general, the standard errors (Table 3) were very high, indicating large variation in scores. Using salt caused a significant (P<0.05) improvement in all of the four properties of treatment 19 (data not shown). It should be noted that three judges scored the salted product as "like very much" (7 points out of the 8point scale). This showed clearly the importance of the salt in the product. The pH, fat and moisture contents of the twenty products are presented in Table 5. The raw product pH was generally greater than 6.40 and it increased slightly after extrusion. The fat and moisture contents of the products were in the ranges 1.30-10.32% and 43.74-62.13%, respectively. This indicates that the products were not only of low fat, but also of high protein content. Thus, the products are desirable from a nutritional standpoint, but their high pH raises concems about their microbiological stability.
1271 Table 4 Means (seven panelists) and the significant (P<0.05) differences (abed . . .) in juiciness, tenderness, flavor and overall satisfaction scores among the 20 selected extrusion-cooked products of Table 1 Treatment
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Juiciness 6.14^
475ehdgf
S.SO"^'^'^ 3 75hgi
Tenderness 6.7P 6.38^"'^ e.D^^"'^
4g5ebdgcf
3.88^s 4.43^s 5.75^^^^^ 5.25^^^^ 4.25^s 5.25^^^ 6.00''^"'^ 4.75^^^ 5 7JLbdac
5 43ebdac
5 ;^4bdac
453ehdgcf
5.38^^^ 5.57''^'^ 5.86''^^ 6.57^^ 3.88^^ 3.57^s 3.29^
4.00^^^^
4 ggebdacf
4_50ehdgcf 3 75hgi 450ehdgf c ^gebdac 4 13ehgif
c i4ebdacf 5.71*^^^ 6.00^^ 3.25' 3.57^^ 3 j^hgi
Flavor 371bd
3.88'*''^ 3.25^ 438abc 4 57abc 5.00^ 4.75^ 4.63^*' 4.75^ 5.00^ 425abc 5.00^ 47pbc 5.00^ 4.86^' 5.00^ 457abc 425abc 4.86^ 4 29abc
Overall Satisfaction 3.57^
3 75bdac
3.5'^
4 cbdac 47lbac
4.88^*'
453abc 425bdac
4.75^ 5.29^ 3.88''^'^ S.OO"^'^ 457bdac
4.88^^^
47pbc
4.86*'"" 4 43bdac 4 ]^3bdac 4 72bac 4 2Qbdac
The eight most acceptable products (Table 2) were boiled to evaluate the effect of cooking on their stability. Table 6 shows the effect of boiling time on the moisture content of the eight extruded products. In general, boiling the products for up to 10 min resulted in a moisture gain. This increase in moisture was extended in some products by increasing the cooking time to 15 min, whereas some products started to decrease in moisture content when the cooking time was extended from 10 to 15 min. Overall, increasing the boiling time to 15 min increased ( P < 0 . 0 5 ) moisture content of the eight products. Among the eight products, there was a significant (P<0.05) difference in terms of moisture gain. Since the eight products had different nonmeat ingredients and MDTM levels and were treated with different extrusion variables, it is difficult to specify which factor had the greatest effect in causing the difference in the moisture gain among them. A general point which can be made here, however, is that the binding of the products was still acceptable after 15 min of boiling. The water gain of the products when boiled for 10 min was in the range of 3.5 percentage points (product-7) to 15.7 percentage points (product-8). When the products were boiled for 15 min, the water gain was in the range of 2.5 percentage points for product-7 and up to 18.6 percentage points for product-8 (Table 6). Since the levels of the SPI used were similar (22-24%) in most treatments (except for treatment 7), it is difficult to determine its real contribution to water gain, but it should have played an
1272 important role in moisture gain and in cooking yields, as indicated by other studies. The acceptable product binding, even after boiling, may probably be due to the interaction between the meat and the soy proteins and the matrix-forming properties of the soy proteins (Dudonis and Lasztity, 1986). The gelation characteristic of soy proteins is heat inducible and its strength increases to its maximum at boiling point temperatures and above (Schmidt and Morris, 1984; Hermansson, 1986). Table 5 The pH and proximate composition of the 20 products of Table 1 before and after extrusion After extrusion
Before extrusion Treatment
pH
Moisture (%)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
6.80 6.80 6.81 6.50 6.56 6.63 6.62 6.50 6.72 6.67 6.64 6.70 6.70 6.69 6.70 6.70 6.82 6.45 6.45 6.47
49.09 50.01 51.25 59.65 55.36 52.87 53.59 43.74 52.58 53.82 51.05 52.00 52.68 51.73 51.64 49.28 50.75 62.13 59.57 58.83
Fat (%) 9.51 8.17 9.71 1.98 1.30 7.60 8.19 2.75 7.90 6.79 6.93 6.59 9.64 9.22 9.42 9.90 10.32 2.23 1.77 2.94
pH 6.93 6.87 6.92 6.52 6.63 6.81 6.70 6.54 6.75 6.68 6.76 6.78 6.82 6.82 6.79 6.83 6.88 6.46 6.49 6.53
Apparently, the interaction between SPI and meat proteins resulted in very low losses (0.2-2.5%) of protein from the products when boiled (Table 7). Overall, however, the products were of very high (>20%) protein content. This makes them useftil in feeding programs for people on poor diets. Table 8 shows the effect of cooking time on the fat content of the eight treatments. Overall, the results show that by increasing the cooking time, the amount of fat released from the product increased significantly (P<0.05), and that differences in fat losses among the eight treatments were also significant (P<0.05). As the level of MDTM was increased in the product, more fat was released during boiling. Overall, however, the products were of low (< 12%) fat content, which is also nutritionally important.
1273 Table 6 The average (%) moisture content (± standard deviation) of the eight extruded products (Table 2) cooked in boiling water for various times Boiling time (min) Treatment 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
0 53.8 57.2 54.1 53.1 51.5 51.0 61.9 50.2
± ± ± + ± ± ± ±
5 0.4 1.5 1.1 0.9 0.5 0.1 0.6 0.8
60.8 62.4 60.7 61.4 62.9 62.3 64.5 63.3
+ ± + + ± ± + ±
10 0.4 0.3 0.7 0.8 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
64.8 65.3 62.5 63.0 65.8 64.4 65.4 65.8
± + ± ± ± ± ± ±
15 0.3 0.5 0.3 0.5 0.2 0.7 0.1 0.1
65.3 64.6 62.9 63.8 66.8 65.8 64.4 68.8
± ± ± ± ± ± ± ±
0.2 0.4 0.2 0.1 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.2
Table 7 The average (%) protein content (+ standard deviation) of the eight extruded products (Table 2) cooked in boiling water for various times (moisture adjusted to 60%) Boiling time (min) Treatment 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
0 28.5 34.4 29.8 28.4 28.4 27.9 36.2 26.8
± ± + ± ± + ± ±
10
5 0.3 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.5 2.0 0.3
28.3 34.2 28.6 28.4 28.5 27.7 33.5 25.5
± + ± ± + ± ± +
0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.3 0.2 0.6 0.3
28.5 33.5 28.5 28.4 28.1 27.7 33.8 25.0
± ± ± ± ± ± ± ±
15 0.3 0.3 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.3 0.3 0.7
28.0 33.4 27.6 28.4 28.4 27.6 33.1 24.5
± ± ± ± ± ± ± +
0.4 0.1 0.8 0.7 0.5 0.2 0.2 0.3
Table 8 The average (%) fat content (± standard deviation) of the eight extruded products (Table 2) cooked in boiling water for various times (moisture adjusted to 60%) Boiling time (min) Treatment 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9.4 3.1 7.5 8.1 9.4 11.1 1.2 11.8
± ± ± ± + ± ± ±
10
5
0 0.4 0.9 0.3 0.7 0.2 0.4 0.2 0.3
7.6 3.1 6.5 6.8 8.2 11.0 1.2 11.5
± 0.3 ± 0.6 ± 0.3 ±0.1 ± 1.2 + 0.5 ± 0.0 + 0.5
7.7 2.9 6.8 6.2 6.8 7.5 1.1 11.5
+ ± + ± + ± ± ±
15 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1
6.9 2.8 6.8 5.8 6.3 6.8 1.0 10.4
± ± ± ± ± ± ± ±
0.2 0.5 0.1 0.1 0.0 1.5 0.0 0.1
1274 The addition of oat fiber somehow improved retention of fat in the product when cooked in boiling water, as shown in treatment 8 (Table 8). In general, losses of fat can be explained by the fact that the matrix which forms between the proteins of the product is not strong enough to hold much fat when boiled, so the fat is released. It was evident that when the products were cooked for only 5 min, the emulsion characteristic of the nonmeat ingredients was contributing to the fat-holding property. Boiling of the eight products for 5-15 min resulted in weight gains of 4.46% to 21.70%, depending on formulation and boiling time (Table 9). These gains in water diluted the fat content of the formulations. It is interesting to note that the treatment with oat fiber absorbed more water. Figures 1-3 show various treatments of Table 2 in the unboiled and boiled state, and inmiersed in liquid. It is obvious that extrusion cooking yields some products of acceptable bind and integrity, even when mechanically deboned turkey meat was present in the formulation. 4.
CONCLUSIONS
The results of the first study indicated that: 1. Products containing 20 to 60% MDTM, 80 to 40% HDCM and SPI levels of 15 to 22% with 0.5 to 1 % kappa-carrageenan gum were judged as acceptable; that is, their overall satisfaction scores were in the range of "like slightly" to "like moderately," specifically 5 to 6 points out of an 8-point hedonic scale. However, the products that contained higher MDTM levels, 80 to 100%, and higher SPI, 22 to 24%, were disliked slightly (4 out of 8 points in the hedonic scale). 2. Addition of salt caused significant improvement in product acceptability, from "like slightly" (5 points) to "like very much" (6 points out of the 8-point hedonic scale). The results of the second study indicated that: 1. Protein and fat losses and moisture gains were significantly affected by cooking time (0-15 minutes). 2. There were significant differences among the eight treatments in terms of moisture gain, fat and protein losses. 3. The quality (binding and texture) of the products did not change when boiled for 15 minutes. 4. Under the conditions of this study, oat fiber had a tendency to weaken the matrix which is formed by the interaction of SPI and the meat protein, but it also held fat during cooking. Although there were statistically significant differences among the 8 treatments, from a practical point of view, that of the producer and the consumer, there were no major differences among the treatments in terms of their composition and quality when cooked for 15 minutes in boiling water. In general, they were well-bound before, during and after cooking. Actually, their eating quality was improved by cooking. Furthermore, all treatments were high in protein (in the range of 24 to 28%) and low in fat (an average of about 6%), which is important to consumers. Additional studies need to be done on these products in terms of improving their eating quality by using spices, salts and antioxidants, and in terms of shelf-life.
1275 Table 9 The total weight and weight gain of the eight products (Table 2) before and after boiling for 5 to 15 minutes Boiling (min)
Treatment
Weight before boiling (g)
Weight after boilmg (g)
Difference in weight (g)
% Total gain
5
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
6.457 6.055 7.218 6.494 8.234 7.171 4.284 8.007
7.167 6.492 7.830 7.052 8.751 8.071 4.507 8.831
0.710 0.437 0.612 0.558 0.517 0.900 0.223 0.824
11.00 7.21 8.48 8.59 6.28 12.55 5.21 10.29
10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
5.873 5.357 6.092 7.919 7.569 6.329 4.509 9.444
6.660 6.001 6.770 8.852 8.502 7.600 4.710 11.245
0.787 0.644 0.678 0.933 0.933 1.271 0.201 1.801
13.40 12.02 11.13 11.78 12.33 20.08 4.46 19.07
15
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
7.752 5.693 5.790 7.899 8.760 5.783 5.080 8.774
8.535 6.295 6.711 8.854 9.714 6.655 5.511 10.678
0.783 0.602 0.921 0.955 0.954 0.872 0.431 1.900
10.10 10.57 15.91 12.09 10.89 15.08 8.48 21.70
1276
BOILED
UNBOILED
MDTM(%): SPI(%): K«C{%): TEMPfX::):
Figure 1.
20 20 0 95
60 22 1 95
80 22 0.5 95
0 15 0.5 95
Unboiled and boiled products of treatments 2, 4, 5 and 7 of Table 2 (MDTM: mechanically deboned turkey meat; SPI: soy protein isolate; K-C: kappacarrageenan gum; TEMP: extrusion temperature).
mnM(%): SFI(%): K>C(%): TEMFfC);
20
W
0 95
60 22 0.5 105
60 22 1.0 95
m
22 0.5 95
m
24 1.0 105
0 15 0 95
M)ILED Figure 2.
Boiled products, shown in liquid, of treatments 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 of Table 2 (MDTM: mechanically deboned chicken meat; SPI: soy protein isolate; K-C: kappa-carrageenan gum; TEMP: extrusion temperature).
1277
SPI 20%
MDIM
BOILED Figure 3.
TEMP 9$**C
UNBOILED
Unboiled and boiled samples of treatment 2 of Table 2 (MDTM: mechanically deboned turkey meat; SPI: soy protein isolate; K-C: kappacarrageenan gum; TEMP: extrusion temperature).
MDTM 60%
SPI 22%
UNBOILED Figure 4.
K~C 0%
K-C 1%
TEMP 95°C
BOILED
Unboiled and boiled samples of treatment 4 of Table 2 (MDTM: mechanically deboned chicken meat; SPI: soy protein isolate; K-C: kappacarrageenan gum; TEMP: extrusion temperature).
1278
m%
Figure 5.
n%
03%
105X
Sample of treatment 3 (Table 2) stored in liquid after boiling for 10 min (MDTM: mechanically deboned turkey meat; SPI: soy protein isolate; K-C: kappa-carrageenan gum; Temp: extrusion temperature).
5. REFERENCES Alvarez V.B., D.M. Smith, R.G. Morgan and A.M. Booren, J. Food Sci., 55 (1990) 942946. Areas J.A.G. and R.A. Lawrie, Meat Sci., 11 (1984) 275-299. Ba-Jaber, A.S. Restructuring of poultry meat with nonmeat ingredients by extrusion cooking. Ph.D. Dissertation, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, 1990. Ba-Jaber, A.S., J.N. Sofos, G.R. Schmidt and J.A. Maga. Extrusion cooking of chicken meat with various nonmeat ingredients. In: Food Science and Human Nutrition, G. Charalambous (ed.). Elsevier Science Publishers, London, pp. 761-782, 1992a. Ba-Jaber, A.S., J.N. Sofos, G.R. Schmidt and J.A. Maga, Lebensm. Wissensch. und Technologic, 25 (1992b) 135-137. Ba-Jaber, A.S., J.N. Sofos, G.R. Schmidt and J.A. Maga, J. Muscle Foods, 4 (1992c) 2739. Bhattacharya, S., H. Das and A.N. Bose, Food Chem. 28 (1988) 225-231.
1279 Chakraborty, K.C., S. Richardson and R. Villota. Twin-screw extrusion performance of meat proteins and interactions with starch. Ann. Mtg. Inst. Food Technol., Abstr. 18, 1987. Chung, S., P. Bechtel and R. Villota. Production of meat-based intermediate moisture snack foods by twin-screw extrusion of expanded meat-based products. Ann. Meet. Inst. Food Technol., Abstr. 258, 1989. Clarke, A.D., F. Hsieh and S. Mulvaney. Processing of mechanically-deboned turkey and com flour mixtures by twin screw extrusion. IFT Annual Meeting, Abstr. No. 127, 1989. Dudonis, W. and R. Lasztity, Die Nahrung, 30 (1986) 434-436. Hale, D. 1970. Expanded meat product. Canad. Patent 842,723. Hermansson, A.M., American Oil Chem. Soc. J., 63 (1986) 658-666. Kristensen K.H., P. Gry and F. Holm. Extruded protein-rich animal by-products with improved texture. In: Thermal Processing and Quality of Foods. P. Zeuthen, J.C. Cheftel, C. Eriksson, M. Jul, H. Leniger, P. Linko, G. Varela and G. Vos (eds). Elsevier Appl. Science Publish., London, pp. 113-121, 1984. Lawrie R.A. and D.A. Ledward. Texturization of recovered proteins. In: Upgrading Waste for Feeds and Food. D.A. Ledward, A.J. Taylor and R.A. Lawrie (eds.). Butterworths, London, pp. 163-182, 1983. Likimani, T.A., J.N. Sofos, J.A. Maga and J.M. Harper, J. Food Sci., 55 (1990) 13881393. Likimani, T.A., J.N. Sofos, J.A. Maga and J.M. Harper, J. Food Sci., 56 (1991) 99-105, 108. Megard, D., N. Kitabatake and J.G. Cheftel, J. Food Sci., 50 (1985) 1364-1369. Sasamoto, Y., Y. Kammuri, K. Sawa, M. Araki, S. Morimoto, F. Mitsui and N. Miyazaki. 1989. Process for processing and treating raw materials of marine products. U.S. Patent 4,816,278. Schmidt, R. and H. Morris, Food Technol., 38(5) (1984) 85-96. Sofos, J.N., J. Food Sci., 48 (1983a) 1692-1699. Sofos, J.N., J. Food Sci., 48 (1983b) 1684-1691.
1280 Sofos, J.N., A.S. Ba-Jaber and G.R. Schmidt. Extrusion cooking of mechanically deboned turkey meat with soy protein, kappa-carrageenan and oat fiber. Proc. 38th Int. Congr. Meat Sci. and Technol., Clermont-Ferrand, France. Vol. 5, pp. 1125-1128, 1992. Sofos, J.N., I. Noda and C. Allen, J. Food Sci., 42 (1977) 879-884. Southard, C.L. Non-conventional extenders of processed meat products. M.S. Thesis, Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, 1985. Steel, R.G. and J. Torrie. Principles and Procedures of Statistics. 2nd Ed. McGraw-Hill Book Co., New York, NY, 1980. Suzuki, H., B.S. Chung, S. Isobe, S. Hayakawa and S. Wada, J. Food Sci., 53 (1988) 1659-1661. Tarte, R., R.A. Molins and M. Kazemzadeh. Development of a beef/com extruded snack model product. Ann. Mtg. Inst. Food Technol., Chicago, IL. Abstr. 284, 1989. Thomas, L., P. Bechtel and R. Villota. Effects of composition and process parameters on twin-screw extrusion of expanded meat-based products. Ann. Mtg. Inst. Food Technol., Chicago, IL. Abstr. 118, 1989.
G. Charalambous (Ed.), Food Flavors: Generation, Analysis and Process Influence © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
1281
Use of starch for water binding in restructured beef products J.N. Sofos, J.A. Perejda and G.R. Schmidt Department of Animal Sciences and Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523, U.S.A. Abstract Sodium chloride (salt), phosphates and mechanical treatment solubilize proteins which increase fat and water binding in meat products. The algin/calcium binding system also enhances meat particle cohesion, while starches may be added to foods to bind water and increase viscosity. Studies in our laboratory examined cooking yields and binding or cohesion in beef and in beef formulated with salt/phosphate (1.5%/0.3%) or the algin/calcium (0.4%/0.075%) binder with and without added starch (2%) and water (10%). The ground beef was mixed with the ingredients, packaged in casings, and cooked in a 70°C water bath for 90 min. The pH of the salt/phosphate products (6.03 + 0.06) was higher (P<0.05) than other treatments (5.81 ± 0.05 and 5.78 + 0.05). Cooking yields increased with added starch in both no-water-added and water-added all-beef and algin/calcium formulations, but not in the salt/phosphate products, which even without added starch had higher cooking yields than the other treatments. Salt/phosphate formulations with or without added starch had higher (P<0.05) binding values (Newtons) than all other formulations, while added starch had only a minor effect on binding. 1.
EVTRODUCTION
Lean mammalian muscle from which meat is derived has a typical composition of 75% water, 19% protein, 2.5% lipid, 1.2% carbohydrate and 2.3% miscellaneous soluble non-protein substances (Lawrie, 1985). The protein component is comprised of myofibrillar proteins (60%), sarcoplasmic proteins (29%) and connective tissue proteins (11%). The myofibrillar fraction which is mostly high-molecular weight, salt-extractable fibrous proteins is largely responsible for three physicochemical events; protein-water interactions, proteinlipid associations, and protein-protein aggregation (Acton et al., 1982). Functionally, these terms describe water-binding capacity, fat-holding capacity, and gelation. Each of these three is important in meat processing and can affect sensory attributes of the final product. The water component in beef interacts with hydrophilic groups of the side chains of the proteins via polar interactions (Shut, 1976). This has been determined to represent only 5-10% of the total water component (Shut, 1976; Acton et al., 1982). The remainder and majority is believed to be immobilized due to membranes and filaments of structural proteins via capillary action (Hamm, 1960; Shut, 1976; Acton et al., 1982).
1282 Protein-lipid interactions are involved in three events: gel strength, lipid particles surrounded by a protein film, and the physical characteristics of the fat, including melting point and degree of fat tissue disruption (Jones, 1984). Proteins act as emulsifiers because their polar side chains orient towards water molecules and nonpolar side chains surround fat particles (Acton and Saffle, 1971). Protein-protein interactions are evident as inter- and intra-molecular bonds that break during heating, and alter the secondary and tertiary structure of the proteins. Gelation occurs during subsequent altered bond reformation (Acton and Dick, 1984), and has been described to involve the orderly interaction of proteins, which may or may not be denatured, and which leads to the formation of a three dimensional well-ordered structural matrix (Hermansson, 1978). Beef processing traditionally involves addition of sodium chloride and alkaline phosphate with and without mechanical treatment to positively affect these three events and sensory attributes of the final product. 1.1
Effects of salt and phosphate
Processors, through the use of salt (sodium chloride), phosphate and mechanical treatment can offer consumers a variety of meat products, including sausages, which are desired for their palatability, shelf-life, cost and convenience. Most cooked sausage products contain approximately 2-3% salt (Offer and Trinick, 1983; Schmidt, 1988). However, salt has also been shown to act as a pro-oxidant accelerating oxidative reactions of unsaturated lipids, thus increasing rancidity (Gray, 1978; Obanu et al., 1980). Protein solubilization through addition of salt increases water-binding capacity of myofibrillar proteins. Salt is believed to produce a shift in the isoelectric point of proteins to a lower pH value (Hamm, 1960). This results in an increased net negative charge at the existing pH from ionizable carboxyl groups on the protein (Shut, 1976; Acton et al., 1982). Subsequent increased repulsion between charged groups produces greater separation between protein chains and creates a matrix capable of entrapping water (Hamm, 1960). Hydrated chloride ions are attracted to positively charged groups and cause inter- and intra-salt bridges to break further increasing water-binding capacity (Shut, 1976). Offer and Trinick (1983) suggested moisture losses/gains in rabbit psoas muscle were due to changes in meat myofibrils and the subsequent myofilament lattice upon treatment with pyrophosphate-saline solutions. Paterson et al. (1988) observed increased fiber swelling and extraction of myofibrillar proteins as salt concentration increased. Phosphates reduce salt concentrations required for maxunum swelling of myofibrils (Offer and Trinick, 1983) and help release proteins for gel formation (Siegel and Schmidt, 1979). Bendall (1954) reported a synergistic increase in water absorption in minced rabbit muscle after addition of salt and pyrophosphate. This was believed to be due to cleavage of actomyosin. Phosphates increase water and meat particle binding in meat products through one or more of the following ways: increasing pH, increase in product ionic strength, dissociating actomyosin into actin and myosin and binding to meat proteins (Hamm, 1970). Product pH, salt concentration and phosphate-type are also involved with phosphate functionality (Trout and Schmidt, 1986). The proposed mechanism suggests that as myosin molecules denature during thermal processing, unprotonated histidine residues are exposed, resulting in elevated pH when solvent protons are donated to negatively charged histidine residues (Goodno and Swenson, 1975).
1283 Effects of salt and phosphate on beef and pork frankfurters were studied by Whiting (1984b). Reducing salt levels from 2.5% to 1.5% increased water and fat exudate, while the addition of 0.12% or 0.25% sodium acid pyrophosphate (SAPP) counteracted these effects. SAPP reduced product pH, and after adjustment to typical pH levels, the exudate decreased. Huffman et al. (1987) reported phosphate additions (0.25%, 0.4%) resulted in lower thiobarbituric acid (TBA) values in structured beef and pork nuggets throughout twenty weeks of storage. Evaluating for off-flavors, a trained sensory panel was unable to detect significant differences (P < 0.05) between treatments with added phosphates and those without until the sixteenth and twentieth week of storage for restructured pork and beef nuggets, respectively. Meat protein solubilization and swelling of myofibrils has been found to be tune dependent and occurs primarily on the meat surface (Voyle et al., 1984). Mechanical treatment in the form of tumbling, massaging and brine injection increases meat surface area for the action of salt and phosphate to occur. The goal of the massaging process is to develop a protein-rich exudate without gross physical damage to the meat (Theno et al., 1978). Advantages include reduced processing time and improved tenderness (Siegel et al., 1978). This is accomplished without extensive physical damage which could compromise desired textural properties. 1.2
Beef consumption and health concerns
Current health concerns associated with food consumption arise from overconsumption of total calories, total fat, saturated fatty acids and cholesterol (National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council, 1988). Between 1976-1986, per capita consumption of beef as a percentage of total meat consumption dropped from 43% to 35%, while chicken consumption increased from 20% to 26% (USDA, 1988b). Data indicate a changing consumer environment that is affecting beef consumption. Consumer surveys in the United States indicate that interest in health and nutrition is at least affecting people's perception of their buying habits. While surveyors are aware that for various reasons what people say and what is actually done may be different, surveys can be accurate in measuring attitudes (Gallup Organization, 1987). Surveys conducted for the National Restaurant Association (NRA) in 1983 and 1986, indicated that consumers had changed food choices both at home and away because of health and nutrition concerns (NRA, 1986). Changes included increased consumption of vegetables, fish and salads, while decreasing salt, fat, meat and fried foods. Four polls conducted since 1982 indicated that 47-55 % of restaurant patrons surveyed would be likely or fairly likely to order low-salt meals (Gallup Organization, 1988). The National Food Consumption Survey, 1977-1979 and Continuing Survey of Food Intake by Individuals, 1985 support results from consumer surveys (USDA, 1985a,b). Another survey for the American Meat Institute and The National Live Stock and Meat Board examined consumer attitudes toward whole muscle cuts of beef (Yankelovich et al., 1985). Relative to 1985, respondents indicated decreased meat consumption for health reasons and were more concerned about salt and cholesterol in the diet. As many as nine out of ten reported exercising care over fat intake and there was a positive responsiveness to the concept of leaner and calorie-reduced meat products. Convenience had become increasingly important.
1284 1.3
Regulatory changes affecting fat levels in processed beef
In response to a petition from the American Meat Institute, the United States Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) responded to the desire for low-fat processed meat products by revising the standard of identity for frankfurters and similar cooked sausages (USDA, 1988a). New regulations allow for a maximum combination of 40% fat and added water in these products while continuing to restrict the maximum fat content to no more than 30% of the cooked product. This allows processors to formulate leaner products replacing fat with water. In the past, added water was limited to 10% of the finished product. In addition, use of the term "lite" in these products requires a 25% reduction in fat content. 1.4
Processed beef products with reduced levels of salt
Sodium chloride (salt) is added to meat for flavoring, as an antimicrobial agent, and for its effect on muscle proteins. Fat is an important contributor to the texture and taste of products. However, consumer interest to limit sodium and fat intake for health reasons has prompted continued research into low-salt and low-fat meat products. Low-salt, 0.5 %-l .5 %, meat emulsions have the potential for decreased emulsion stability as determined by increased cook losses and/or decreased gel strength (Sofos, 1983a,b; Whiting, 1984a; Barbut, 1988). In another study, Sofos (1985) reported that addition of potassium sorbate, 0.26% in low-salt meat batters, increased cook yields. Investigations into the sensory impact of reducing salt levels in beef and pork frankfurters indicated that levels below 2.0% resulted in products having unacceptable flavor, texture, overall acceptability and reduced shelf-life (Sofos, 1983b). Barbut (1988) reported reductions in texture profile analysis as salt levels decreased in mechanically deboned chicken meat. Addition of phosphate (0.4%) counteracted these losses and improved texture analysis scores. Lowering fat content in frankfurters has been reported to increase toughness and alter product quality (Sofos and Allen, 1977; Paul and Foget, 1983). 1.5
Alginate and interactions with protein
Alginates are naturally occurring long chain carbohydrate derivatives from brown seaweed, Pheaophyceae, consisting of uronic acid (D-mannuronic acid and L-guluronic acid residues) joined by 1,4-glycosidic bonds. The uronic acid ratio affects rheological, gelation and ion exchange properties of the alginate (Cottrell and Kovacs, 1977). Homopolymeric blocks of guluronic acid residues are responsible for the cooperative binding of calcium cations leading to gel formation (Smidsrod and Haug, 1972; Grant et al., 1973). Gel strength depends on the nature of the divalent cation with the order: Ba"'>Sr+>Ca"'> >Mg'" (Smidsrod, 1974). Grant et al. (1973) proposed the "eggbox" model to describe gelation. Evidence, however, supports a dimeric association rather than a buckled sheet structure suggested in the original "eggbox" model (Morris et al., 1977). Studies of algin/calcium gels interacting with proteins during gel formation indicate electrostatic forces to be mainly responsible for the formation and stability of proteinpoly saccharide gels (Bemal et al., 1987). Interactions were believed to be due to negatively charged side chains of amino acids in the protein (Imeson et al., 1977; Ledward, 1979). Ensor et al. (1991) reporting on differential scanning calorimetric studies of meat protein-
1285 alginate mixtures found that algin/calcium gels were responsible for thermal destabilization of crude meat protein extracts indicating changes in the physical state of the proteins. This provides evidence that algin/calcium gels interacting with meat protein components which could influence product texture. Stainsby (1980) discussed alginate and meat protein interactions involving lysine amino acids and the mannuronic acid component of alginate to develop thermostable covalent bonds. In addition, it was described that binding and retention of water in complex food gels containing large molecular weight components such as proteins and polysaccharides can show advantages from mutual interactions between the two components. Imeson et al. (1977) reported that electrostatic forces are responsible for interactions between charged polysaccharides such as sodium alginate and proteins leading to decreases in protein denaturation temperatures and development of high molecular weight protein-polysaccharide complexes. 1.6
Restructured meat
Restructuring requires binding between meat pieces while retaining desired textural characteristics associated with intact meat (King and Macfarlane, 1987). Raw materials are sectioned and formed or flaked and formed to produce a value-added meat product of intermediate cost (Berry, 1987). Meat particle size has been found to affect physical and sensory properties of restructured meats (Durland et al., 1982; Berry et al., 1987; Clarke et al., 1988a). Raw steaks made from large meat particles had large particles of fat and were judged to be too fatty in appearance, while those made from smaller particles were more acceptable (Durland et al., 1982). Deformation values, an index of elasticity, increased as flake size decreased (Durland et al., 1982). Berry et al. (1987) reported that as flake size increased, visually detected fibrousness, first bite hardness, cohesiveness and shear force increased. Other variables affecting the finished product include added proteins such as myosin or soy and processing conditions, mixing, cooking time and temperature (Berry, 1987). 1.7
Alg* ^/calcium restructured beef
Means and Schmidt (1986) reported on an algin/calcium meat binding system to produce restructured beef capable of binding in the raw state. Binding of meat particles was achieved by reacting sodium alginate and calcium carbonate to form an insoluble algin/calcium gel. The process was patented (Schmidt and Means, 1986) and approved for commercial use (USDA, 1986). Algin/calcium (AC) restructured beef products had raw bind values that were statistically greater than salt and phosphate added controls (alpha=0.10). Sensory analysis of raw products comparing color and percent discoloration found AC treatments to be statistically similar to pure ground beef products, while salt/phosphate treatments were darker and more discolored (Means and Schmidt, 1986). No differences in cooked aroma were detected. Increasing levels of sodium alginate did produce detectable off-flavors due to sodium alginate that had not yet reacted with calcium ions. Objectionable mouthfeel characteristics described as mealy/slippery were observed with high levels of sodium alginate (1.2%) or low levels of calcium carbonate (0.072%). The average raw pH of AC products was
:s6 significantly higher than no-additive controls. This was noted to be undesirable as high pH meat is known to spoil more quickly (Egan, 1984). Means and Schmidt (1987) included glucono-delta-lactone (GDL), a slow-release acid, in an attempt to alleviate the objectionable niouthfeel observed at higher alginate levels. Raw and cooked bind scores for AC steaks were significantly greater (P < 0.05) than all beef or salt/phosphate treatments, although GDL did not appear to be a factor in this. AC ingredients did not contribute to meat discoloration. Sensory scores for cooked AC steaks had significantly stronger (P < 0.05) off-flavors and less desirable mouthfeel, indicating that GDL was not effective. Shelf-life studies indicated that AC treatments under aerobic conditions were similar to all-beef controls, although in vacuo samples supported microbial growth sooner than controls. Clarke et al. (1988b) reported addition of a slow release acidifier, Capshure® (Balchem Corp., Slate Hill, NY), an encapsulated lactic acid/calcium lactate blend, to effectively reduce product pH at levels of 0.4% sodium alginate, 0.067% calcium carbonate, and 0.10% lactic acid/calcium lactate. Percent cook yield and cook bind scores were greater than all-beef controls (P=0.05) at this and higher binder levels reportedly due to inhibition of moisture migration. Schmidt et al. (1988) illustrated AC technology to be effective and acceptable in restructured beef which has been injected with aqueous solutions of soy protein concentrate. Subsequently, AC technology was shown to be effective in restructured turkey products (Ensor et al., 1989). Optimal raw and cooked product bind was achieved with combinations of 0.4% sodium alginate, 0.075-0.1875% calcium carbonate and 0.6% lactate acid/calcium lactate. Panelists detected no treatment differences (P>0.05) for aroma, flavor or juiciness of the cooked products. Higher levels of acidifier may have been responsible for this. 1.8
Starch
Starch is found in seeds, tubers and stems of plants. Native starch is composed of two carbohydrate polymers of anhydroglucose, amy lose and amylopectin, linked primarily through alpha-D-(l,4) glucosidic bonds. Amylose is a straight chain polymer containing 200-2000 anhydroglucose units, depending on botanical source. Amylopectin is a much larger branched chain molecule with molecular weights in the millions. Branching occurs via alpha-D-(l,6) bonds (Swinkels, 1985; Wurzburg, 1986). Properties of amylose and amylopectin differ significantly in aqueous solutions. Amylose is difficult to dissolve and unstable in aqueous solutions, as the molecules tend to aggregate and precipitate (retrogradation), whereas amylopectin because of its branched structure is more stable and less likely to retrograde (Kennedy et al., 1984). Through chemical treatment, starch can be altered to withstand chemical and physical abuses which would normally cause undesirable gelation or breakdown (Anonymous, 1978; Wurzburg, 1986). Starch manufacturers are able to control viscosity, texture, cold-water swelling and sensitivities to breakdown (McCleary, 1980). Also, gelatinizationbehavior and viscosity can be alTccted by coexistent substances such as sugar or salt (Yamada et al., 1986). CTOSS linking is an important chemical modification which can control swelling and suhscqucnl rupturing ol starch granules during cooking. Introduction of disfunctional agents c;ip;iblc of reacting with hydroxyl groups of two different molecules within the granule act to reinforce natural hydrogen bonding and retard the rate of granule swelling and reduce
1287 chance of rupture (Wurzburg, 1970). Cooked pastes are more viscous, heavily bodied and less likely to break down with extended cooking times, increased acid or severe agitation (Langan, 1986). Introduction of monovalent ions onto hydroxyl groups can increase freeze-thaw stability and lower starch gelatinization temperature (Wurzburg, 1972). Pregelatinization produces starches that are capable of cold-water swelling through simultaneous cooking and drying (Powell, 1967). Rate of rehydration and texture of the finished paste can also be varied through chemistry, processing techniques and physical form (Langan, 1986). 1.9
Processing using starch and other carbohydrates
Starch binders added to fresh and salami sausages served as functional ingredients to maintain juiciness, flavor and acceptability as rated by sensory panels (Sison and Almira, 1974; Sison et al., 1974). Bushway et al. (1982) tested frankfurters containing 3% potato starch or potato flour. Sensory panels rated potato starch and flour treatments to be more tender and juicy than controls containing wheat flour. Starch is often added to surimi to improve textural properties. Wu et al. (1985a) examined rheological and thermodynamic effects of several cook-up and pregelatinized starch types included in a surimi formulation. Textural properties of cooked surimi were dependent on gelatinization characteristics of the starches, such as gelatinization temperature, degree of swelling and water uptake of the starch granules. Starch gelatinization occurred at increased temperatures when included in surimi mixtures and was attributed to the presence of salt and sucrose in surimi (Wu et al., 1985b). Impaired protein gelation was observed when an instant tapioca starch was included. This correlated with shear stress measurements. Comer et al. (1986) reported wheat flour and modified com starch improved stability and textural firmness of a comminuted meat product. Scanning electron micrographs revealed the presence of birefringent starch molecules, indicating incomplete gelatinization. Bonnefin and Baumgartner (1988) examined the effects of seven starch-based binders added to a comminuted meat product at levels of 3 %, 6 % and 9 %. Treatments were cooked to 65, 70 and 75 °C. They found binders in general had favorable effects on reducing expressible moisture, but varying effects on product compression. 2.
EXPERIMENTAL
Heat-induced protein denaturation can cause weight losses in beef products as water and fat migrate to meat surfaces and are expressed as drip and through water vaporization. This is undesirable for processors selling products based on weight and also for consumers who identify tenderness and juiciness as desirable product attributes. Addition of sodium chloride (salt), alkaline phosphate and mechanical treatment solubilize proteins, developing a water and meat binding matrix during cooking. Consumers generally desire the characteristic flavor and texture that is developed. Restructured meats are based on this process resulting in an intermediate priced product providing added value to under-utilized cuts of meat with textural characteristics which resemble those of intact meat (Berry, 1987).
1288 However, there is a growing population who are reducing dietary sodium, fat and total calories for nutrition and health-related reasons. Researchers and processors have shown an active interest in developing low sodium products and replacing fat with water. As indicated, algin/calcium (AC) restructured beef utilizes the reaction between sodium alginate and calcium ions to develop a thermostable gel without application of heat; and is an alternative to the use of salt and phosphate (Means and Schmidt, 1986). The binder has been shown to increase bind of raw and cooked products (Means and Schmidt, 1986; Means et al., 1987; Clarke et al., 1988b; Ensor et al., 1989) and percent cooking yield relative to all-beef control products (Ensor et al., 1991). Preliminary studies in our laboratory comparing AC and salt/phosphate (SP) restructured beef cooked in a closed system showed that SP treatments had greater cooking yield and binding force than the AC counterparts. Starches and gums are added to many foods to bind water, increase viscosity and improve textural characteristics. They are allowed in sausage-type products in the United States in quantities up to 3.5% by weight (Schmidt, 1986). Starch and beef are two different food systems with the potential to bind water. Both develop a structural component which is time- and temperature-dependent. Within a single product, synergistic or cooperative effects would be based on compatibilities between the two systems. This would include processing requirements as well as mutual interactions between the two components. Since functional, nutritional and economic advantages exist for development of beef products that bind water through addition of starch rather than sodium chloride and phosphate, the experimental objectives of studies done in our laboratory were to measure differences in percent cooking yield and cooked product binding strength between three meat systems; all-beef, algin/calcium and salt/phosphate restructured beef; and to examine the ability of starch to compensate for differences in the meat restructuring systems (Perejda, 1991). 2.1
Experimental design
Through a completely randomized block design, changes in two dependent variables (i.e., percent cook yield and cooked particle binding) were measured as a function of addition of starch (2%) and addition of water (10%) to ground beef with no additives (control) or ground beef restructured with salt/phosphate (SP) and algin/calcium (AC). 2.2
Materials
Boneless riblifter beef (78.7% moisture, 4.2% fat and pH of 5.58) was purchased from a local processor and kept frozen (0°C) in vacuum packages until used over a threemonth period. Ingredients in the AC formulation included: 0.4% sodium alginate (Manugel DMB, Kelco, San Diego, CA), 0.075% calcium carbonate (Gamma Sperse 80, Georgia Marble Co., Tate, GA), and 0.6% encapsulated lactic acid/calcium lactate (CapShure® LCL-135-50; 30% lactic acid, 20% calcium lactate, 50% hydrogenated vegetable oil, Balchem Corp., Slate Hill, NY). Salt/phosphate treatments included 1.5% sodium chloride (Morton-Thiokol,
1289 Chicago, IL) and 0.3% sodium tripolyphosphate (FMC Corporation, Philadelphia, PA), both food grade. Starch-added treatments included a modified waxy maize starch designed for use in conmiinuted meat products (LoTemp 452, A.E. Staely Mfg. Co., Decatur, IL) at the 2% level based on the weight of the formulation. This granular starch had a pasting temperature of 36°C; and the peak viscosity of a 5% aqueous solution was 590 Brabender units at 70°C. Distilled and deionized water when added was at the 10% level. 2.3
Product preparation
Beef was thawed for 12-16 hours at 4°C, and then ground twice through a Hobart grinder (Hobart Corp., Troy, OH). First it was ground through a kidney-shaped plate (5 cm X 2 cm), and then through a 4.8-mm round hole plate. Sample aliquots were removed and frozen for later determination of fat and moisture contents. Treatment samples (350 ± 1 g) were portioned, covered with plastic and refrigerated (4°C) until processed 0-6 hours later. The processing room temperature was maintained between 4-9°C. Each treatment was mixed for 2.5 min in a Kitchen-Aid Mixer (model K45SS, Hobart Co., Troy, OH) at speed two with a paddle attachment. Based on dry weight, preweighed ingredients were added at 30-second intervals. Order of addition and ingredient levels are listed in Table 1. Samples were removed for raw product pH determination, while the remaining product was extruded into pre-weighed 6-cm diameter cellulose casings (Hutchinson and Co., Chicago, IL) using a hand operating extruder, they were tensioned and clipped closed. After weighing, the samples in the casings were vacuum packaged (Multivac, Allgau, W. Germany) and refrigerated 20-24 hours (4°C) prior to heat processing. Table 1 Sequence and time table for ingredient addition to treatments and controls Ingredient and time of addition (sec) Treatment
0
30
60
90
150
All-beef
Starch then Mix water
Mix
Mix
Stop mixing
Algin/calcium (AC)
Starch then water
Calcium carbonate (0.075%)
Acidifier^ (0.6%)
Stop mixing
Salt/phosphate (SP)
Starch then Salt (1.5%) and water phosphate (0.3%)
Mix
Mix
Stop mixing
Sodium alginate (0.4%)
Capshure® ~ lactic acid, calcium lactate blend. Packaged products were heated for 90 min in a water bath (70 ± 1°C). The final temperature was attained after approximately 30 min. Thermocouple probes connected to a Speedomax H recorder (Leeds and Northrup Co., North Wales, PA) charted a constant
1290 record of both internal sample temperature and water temperature. After cooking, the products were cooled 15 min in an ice water bath and refrigerated for twelve hours (4°C). 2.4
pH determination
The pH of previously frozen samples of the raw meat, in addition to refrigerated raw and cooked products, was measured within 48 hours after thawing or cooking. The pH was measured by combining 20 ± 0.1 g meat with 80 ± 1 g deionized distilled water and blending one minute (Oster Corp., Milwaukee, WI). A Coming Model 125 pH meter (Coming Glassworks, Medfield, MA), equipped with a Coming combination electrode (Cat. No. 476192) measured pH. 2.5
Percent cook yield determination
Casings as well as excess liquid and solid fat deposits were removed prior to cooked product weighing. Percent cooking yield based on meat and dry ingredients allowed for comparisons across different water levels: Cooking Yield (%) = cooked product weight x (theoretical weight plus water) x 100 raw product weight (theoretical weight less water) 2.6
Cooked product binding determination
Clarke et al. (1988a,b) reported significant (P<0.05) correlations between objective and sensory methods for texture determination of restructured products; indicating that penetration force measurements may be useful in predicting meat particle binding strength. Using an apparatus described by Field et al. (1984), meat particle binding was estimated by the force required for a 1.8-cm spherical brass probe to penetrate a meat sample placed over a 5-cm diameter opening. Meat samples (10 + 1 mm thick) were cut perpendicular to the long axis. The force was measured using a 100 Newton load cell transducer attached to a J.J. Lloyd Tensile Testing matching, type T5002 (Pacific Scientific, Santa Ana, CA) with a crosshead speed of 110 mm/min. Force measurements were recorded (J.J. Lloyd Recorder, model PL3 XY/t, Pacific Scientific, Santa Ana, CA) as peak deflection and intemal calibration standards allowed for length to force conversions. Average values of four to six readings per treatment, tested at room temperature, were taken within 48 hours after cooking. 2.7
Statistical analysis
When statistical analysis of variance of the results (SAS Institute, Inc., 1988) revealed significant (P<0.05) main effects, Duncan's New Multiple Range Test separated significant means (Duncan, 1955).
1291 3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1
Effects on pH
The restructured meat formulation had significant effects (P<0.05) on pH of both raw and cooked products (Table 2). The SP products had higher (P<0.05) pH values than the AC and all-beef treatments. The increase in pH resulted from the addition of phosphate, which has been previously reported (Bendall, 1954; Hamm, 1960; Goodno and Swenson, 1975; Trout and Schmidt, 1983, 1986a,b). The pH values of all-beef and AC products were not significantly (P>0.05) different from each other. The lack of statistical significance (P>0.05) in raw product pH values indicated that the addition of sodium alginate, calcium carbonate and the acidifier did not affect pH. This is in contrast to results of previous experiments with AC beef (Means and Schmidt, 1986; Means et al., 1987; Clarke et al., 1987), where pH values of similar products were reported to be above 5.8. However, pH values above 5.8 may present problems due to limited shelf-life (Egan, 1984). Previous attempts to reduce the pH by addition of 0.2% glucono-delta-lactone (GDL), a slow release acid, were unsuccessful (Means et al., 1987). Addition of CapShure®, an encapsulated lactic acid and calcium lactate blend, was found effective in reducing pH in AC products (Clarke et al., 1988b; Ensor et al., 1989). Therefore, inclusion of this acidifier was responsible for reduced pH of the raw AC treatment in the present study. Table 2 Effects of meat type, starch and water level on the pH of raw and cooked products Product Beef
Starch (%)
Water (%)
0 2 0 2
0 0 10 10
Mean ± SD AC
0 2 0 2
0 0 10 10
Mean ± SD SP
0 2 0 2
0 0 10 10
Raw product pH A B 5.53 5.56 5.52 5.55
5.58 5.60 5.50 5.60
Cooked product pH B A 5.72 5.79 5.75 5.82
5.83 5.88 5.85 5.83
5.56 ± 0.05*^
5.81 ± 0.05''
5.50 5.52 5.54 5.55
5.77 5.78 5.70 5.79
5.56 5.66 5.51 5.51
5.73 5.82 5.81 5.85
5.54 ± 0.04^
5.78 ± 0.05''
5.78 5.85 5.81 5.82
5.98 5.94 5.99 6.03
5.84 5.88 5.84 5.86
6.12 6.06 6.10 6.00
6.03 ± 0.06^ Mean ± SD 5.83 ± 0.02^ A ^ T " Replicates 1 and 2; AC: Algin/calcium restructured beef; SP: Salt/phosphate restructured beef; SD: Standard deviation. ^'^ Means in the same column with different superscripts are significantly different (P < 0.05).
1292 Replicate effects on pH (Table 2) were significant (P < 0.025) and may have been due to variability in the pH of the raw meat (5.54-5.68). These differences could have affected cooking yield (%) and cooked product binding values because small differences in pH potentially lead to larger differences in functional properties (Trout and Schmidt, 1983). 3.2
Percent cooking yield
To emphasize effects on water binding, the percent cooking yield was based on raw meat weight plus added weight of dry ingredients. This permitted percent cooking yield values to be in excess of 100% and was a measure of water that was added to the formulation originally and that was bound during cooking and retained after cooking. Within each water level and without addition of starch, all-beef products were lowest (P<0.05) in percent cooking yield; AC products were intermediate; and SP the highest (Table 3). Table 3 Analysis of variance table for cooking yields Source
DF
Model Error Meat type (MT) Starch level (SL) Water level (WL) Replication MTxSL MTxWL SLxWL
10 13 2 1 1 1 2 2 1
Mean squares 207.441 5.551 502.600 545.688 231.757 0.002 137.631 2.837 10.827
F-value
P-value
37.37
< 0.0001
90.54 98.30 41.75 0.00 24.79 0.51 1.95
< 0.0001 < 0.0001 < 0.0001 >0.9 < 0.0001 >0.6 >0.1
DF = Degrees of freedom. Analysis of variance (Table 3) of the results on cooking yield found significant (P<0.05) main effects due to meat type, starch addition and water addition. There was a significant meat type by starch interaction (P<0.05) indicating variable starch effects on cook yield for the different meat types indicating analysis of main effects could mask significant effects that would be revealed through analysis of individual treatments. Effects due to replication were not significant (P>0.9). Analysis of significant meat type effects averaged over starch and water levels showed that the SP meat products had greater cooking yields than AC products, which had higher yields than the all-beef product (P< 0.005). Salt and phosphate in meats increase pH and ionic strength, solubilize myofibrillar proteins, chelate metal ions and bind phosphate ions to meat products (Bendall, 1954; Voyle et al., 1984; Lewis et al., 1986; Trout and Schmidt, 1986a,b, 1987; Paterson et al., 1988). Concentrations of these two ingredients in SP products approximated an ionic strength of 0.32 based on calculations of Trout and Schmidt (1987). They reported that cooking losses were prevented in frankfurters having a raw pH of 6.0 when ionic strengths were above 0.32. Their use of a meat batter with raw pH of 6.0 would be expected to increase cooking yields compared to the coarsely ground beef and raw
1293 pH of 5.83 used in the present study. Despite these differences, SP samples in the present study were expected to maximize percent cooking yield. Significant differences (P<0.05) in percent cooking yield between AC and all-beef products may have been due to three potential reasons. The first and most simple one involves binding of water by sodium alginate, which is a hydrocolloid (Glicksman, 1982). Secondly, Morris et al. (1977) described the development of a three dimensional algin/calcium structure which may bind water. This is the same structure responsible for the meat particle binding described by Means and Schmidt (1986). Finally, protein-carbohydrate interactions as described by Imeson et al. (1977) and Stainsby (1980) and inferred by Means and Schmidt (1986) may have developed a matrix capable of binding water to increase cooking yields. It is not known whether one of the above potential mechanisms may prevent interactions from another by utilizing the same functional groups. Earlier studies with AC beef (Means et al., 1987) found significant (P<0.05) differences in cooking yield between all-beef, AC and SP meat products. This may have been due to the method of cooking, which was open-hearth grilling in these earlier studies, and would promote moisture loss through evaporation. In contrast, cooking in a closed system such as employed in the present study would promote moisture retention. The concentrations of sodium alginate and calcium carbonate and the acidifiers used were different in the earlier studies (Means et al., 1987). The results indicated that starch contributed (P<0.05) to increased cooking yield. Others have reported similar findings using wheat flour and modified com starch (Comer et al., 1986), potato starch (Comer and Dempster, 1981), various gums (Foegeding and Ramsey, 1987) and various starch binders (Sison and Almira, 1974; Sison et al., 1974; Bonnefin and Baumgartner, 1988). Added water significantly (P<0.05) increased cookings yield of all three types of meat products when starch was present (Table 4). In the absence of starch, only SP samples realized significant (P<0.05) increases in cook yield due to water addition, suggesting that under these processing conditions, starch addition to increase cook yield in meats containing salt and phosphate is unnecessary, but this may not be the case where levels of salt and phosphate are reduced. Cooking yield values of starch-added AC and SP samples at both water levels were not significantly (P>0.05) different (Table 4), which demonstrates the ability of starch to increase percent cooking yield in AC products. Addition of 2% starch significantly (P<0.05) increased percent cooking yield only for all-beef and AC treatments at both water levels (Table 4). This supports the conclusion that starch addition to SP samples was not needed to increase cooking yield. Differences in starch effects between SP and the other two meat types explain the significant (P<0.05) meat type by starch interaction. 3.3
Cooked product bind
Statistical analysis of the cooked product binding value results indicated significant main effects (P<0.05) to include: meat type, water level and interaction of the two (Table 5). Starch and replication effects were not significant (P>0.05).
1294 Table 4 Effects of meat type, starch and added water on the cooking yields and binding force of meat products* Product
Starch (%)
Water (%)
Cooking yield (%)
Beef
0 2 0 2
0 0 10 10
74.8 90.0 78.0 97.5
AC
0 2 0 2
0 0 10 10
87.8 95.5 90.8 04.1 104.1
± + + ± + +
Cooked product bind (N)
0.5^ 1.2"^ 0.3^ 0.3^ 1.9''
12.0 10.0 6.0 6.0
± ± ± +
0.00^ 1.4^ 0.0^ 0.0^
± 4.6^ ± 0.7''^ 0.7^^ + 3.1"* 3.1"* ± 2.7^
14.0 23.0 10.5 11.5
± ± + +
1.4^ 1.4^ 1.0** 0.7^
O.l'' 0 0 96.0 ± O.l*' 50.0 ± 9.4^ 97.9 ± 0.4^^ 2 0 0.4^^ 56.0 ± 1.4^ 04.7 ± 0.5^ 0 10 104.7 35.5 ± 4.9*^ 2 10 104.5 04.5 ± 3.2^ 37.0 + 1.4' * Numbers are means ± standard deviations. AC: Algin/calcium restructured beef; SP: Salt/phosphate restructured beef; N = Newtons. ^^ Means in the same column with different superscripts are significantly different (P < 0.05). SP
Analysis of meat type main effects indicated that the values for SP products were greater (P<0.05) than those for AC products, which were greater than those for all-beef. Water addition decreased (P<0.05) cooked product bind values when averaged over all treatments. Salt and phosphate should have affected cooked product bind of the SP treatment by mechanisms similar to those discussed for percent cook yield, which includes increased pH and ionic strength, phosphate binding to meat proteins, protein solubilization and chelating metal ions (Bendall, 1954; Voyle et al., 1984; Lewis et al., 1986; Trout and Schmidt, 1986a,b, 1987; Paterson et al., 1988). Table 5 Analysis of variance table for cooked product bind Source DF Model 10 Error 13 2 Meat type (MT) Starch level (SL) 1 Water level (WL) 1 Replication 1 MTxSL 2 MTxWL 2 SLxWL 1 DF = Degrees of freedom.
Mean squares 678.641 12.247 2982.125 40.042 570.375 0.042 20.042 76.625 18.375
F-value
P-value
55.41
< 0.0001
243.50 3.27 46.57 0.00 1.64 6.26 1.50
< 0.0001 >0.05 < 0.0001 >0.9 >0.05 <0.01 >0.05
1295 Ten percent water added to SP samples at both starch levels and for AC samples containing added starch significantly (P<0.05) decreased bind, but no effects were observed for all-beef samples (Table 4). Although cook bind for SP products was reduced following water addition, values were three and six times greater than AC and all-beef treatments, respectively. Differences in bind between water-added AC and all-beef treatments were not significant (P>0.05), although values for all-beef were 40-50% less than AC products (Table 4). The slight but nonsignificant increases in cooked bind for AC products without starch addition compared to the all-beef control suggest that the algin/calcium binder may have contributed to binding through a structural component similar to a protein matrix physically binding water or by absorbent water as a hydrocoUoid. Of more interest is the significant (P<0.05) increase in bind when starch was added to AC products, suggesting a synergistic effect between algin/calcium and starch. Starch also affected cook yield, but the increases were observed for both all-beef and AC, which does not imply starch and algin/calcium interactions, although they may exist. Measurements of cook bind in this experiment were described as the force required to fracture the bonds or interactions between adjacent particles, such as protein-protein, carbohydrate-carbohydrate or protein-carbohydrate. Differences between SP and all-beef samples illustrated increased protein-protein interactions followed with subsequent increases in percent cook yield and cook product bind resulting from salt and phosphate addition. Differences between AC and all-beef samples illustrated increased percent cooking yield and was supported by similarities between starch-added AC and SP products at both water levels. Addition of sodium alginate, calcium carbonate and acidifier has not been shown to increase protein extraction and protein-protein interactions, thus it is logical to assume that the increased cook yield was due to protein-carbohydrate or carbohydrate-carbohydrate interactions involving both starch and alginate reacting separately or in combination with beef proteins. Similar comparisons of cook bind show that salt and phosphate developed greater bind than AC at all combinations of starch and water addition. This suggests that there are differences in binding mechanisms between salt and phosphate and those for carbohydrate ingredients, such as alginate. 4.
CONCLUSIONS
The experimental results of the study have shown that percent cooking yield for algin/calcium restructured beef (AC) containing added starch (2%) and water (10%) was not significantly (P>0.05) different than that of salt/phosphate (SP) samples when cooked in a closed system. Addition of starch increased cooked bind of AC products, but cooked bind of AC samples was lower than that of SP treatments. The cooked bind of AC samples was higher, but was not different from that of all-beef samples, and addition of starch and water did not reduce cook bind relative to AC controls without added starch or water. There may be a synergistic effect on cook bind between AC ingredients and starch. Thus, AC beef may provide an alternative to the use of salt and phosphate in restructured meats that does not require the use of salt but maintains functional and economic advantages afforded by use of salt and phosphate. The ability to maximize the potential for this will be related to
1296 maintaining an acceptable level of cook bind. Differences in starch variety as well as modifications during starch processing may affect starch-starch and starch-protein interactions as related to cook bind. Sensory panel evaluations may better determine changes in texture resulting from addition of starch and subsequent increases in cook yield. The results of this study indicate the need for further work designed to investigate potential interactive mechanisms between the functional ingredients, beef proteins, algin/calcium gels and starch. Investigations on microbial growth resulting from starch addition to beef not having the preservative effects of salt would be necessary since combinations of starch and meat may present an environment well suited to undesirable microbial growth. 5.
REFERENCES
Acton, J.C. and R.L. Saffle, J. Food Sci. 36 (1971) 1118-1120. Acton, J . C , G.R. Ziegler and D.L. Burge, Jr., CRC Crit. Rev. in Food Sci. and Nutr., 18(2) (1982) 99-121. Acton, J.C. and R.L. Dick. Protein-protein interactions in processed meats. Cited in: Proc. of the 37th Annual Reciprocal Meat Conference, pp. 36-43. American Meat Science Association and National Livestock and Meat Board, 1984. Anonymous, Federal Register, 43 (1978) 11697. Barbut, S., J. Food Sci., 53 (1988) 1300-1304. Bendall, J.R., J. Sci. Food Agric. 5, (1954) 468-475. Berry, B.W. Texture in restructured meats. In: Advances in Meat Research, Vol. 3. A.M. Pearson and T.R. Dutson (Ed.). Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York. pp. 271-305, 1987. Berry, B.W., J.J. Smith and J.L. Secrist, J. Food Sci., 52 (1987) 558-563. Bonnefin, G. and P.A. Baumgartner. Use of starch based binders in cooked meat emulsions. Cited in: Proceedings of the 34th International Congress of Meat Science and Technology, Brisbane, Australia, Aug. 29-Sep. 2, 1988. Bushway, A.A., P.R. Belyea, R.H. True, T.M. Work, D.O. Russell and D.F. McGann, J. Food Sci., 47 (1982) 402-404, 408. Clarke, A.D., J.N. Sofos and G.R. Schmidt, J. Food Sci., 53 (1988) 711-713, 726. Clarke, A.D., W.J. Means and G.R. Schmidt, J. Food Sci., 52 (1987) 854-856, 860.
1297 Clarke, A.D., J.N. Sofos and G.R. Schmidt, J. Food Sci., 53 (1988) 711-713, 726. Comer, F.W. and S. Dempster, Canadian Inst, of Food Sci. and Technol., 14(4) (1981) 295-303. Comer, F.W., N. Chew, L. Lovelock and P. Allan-Wojtas, Canadian Inst, of Food Sci. and Technol., 19(2) (1986) 68-74. Cottrell, I.W. and P. Kovacs. Algin. In: Food Colloids. H. Graham (Ed.), pp. 438-463. Westport Publishing Co., Westport, CT, 1977. Duncan, D.B., Biometrics., 11 (1955) 1-42. Durland, P.R., S.C. Seideman, W.J. Costello and N.M. Quenzer, J. Food Prot., 45(2) (1982) 127-131. Egan, A.F. Microbiology and storage life of chilled fresh meats. Cited in: European Meeting of Meat Res. Workers Proc, Bristol, England, Sept. 9-14, 1984. Ensor, S.A., E.A. Ernst, J.N. Sofos and G.R. Schmidt, J. Food Sci., 54 (1989) 558-560. Ensor, S.A., J.N. Sofos and G.R. Schmidt, J. Food Sci., 56 (1991) 175-179, 190. Field, R.A., J.C. Williams, V.S. Prasad, H.R. Cross, J.L. Secrist and M.S. Brewers, J. Textural Studies, 15 (1984) 173-178. Foegeding, E.A. and S.R. Ramsey, J. Food Sci., 52 (1987) 549-553. Gallup Organization. The Gallup monthly report on eating out. 7(5) (1987) 6. Gallup Organization. The Gallup monthly report on eating out. 7(6) (1988) 1-6. Glicksman, M. Food applications in gums. In: Food Carbohydrates. D.R. Lineback and G.E. Inglett (Eds.). Avi Publishing Co., Westport, CT. pp. 270-295, 1982. Goodno, C.C. and C.A. Swenson, Biochem., 14(5) (1975) 873-878. Grant, G.T., E.R. Morris, D.A. Rees, P.J.C. Smith and D. Thom, FEBS Letters, 32(1) (1973) 195-198. Gray, J.L, J. Amer. Oil Chem. Soc, 55 (1978) 539-546. Hanmi, R., Advances in Food Res., 10 (1960) 355-463. Hamm, R. Proteins as Human Foods. R.A. Lawrie (Ed.), p. 65. AVI Publishing Co., Westport, CT, 1970.
1298 Hermansson, A.M., J. Texture Stud., 9 (1978) 33-58. Huffman, D.L., C.F. Ande, J.C. Cordray, M.H. Stanley and W.R. Egbert, J. Food Sci., 52 (1987) 275-278. Imeson, A.P., D.A. Ledward and J.R. Mitchell, J. Sci. Food Agric, 28 (1977) 661-668. Jones, K.W. Protein lipid interactions in processed meats. In: Proc. 37th Ann. Reciprocal Meat Conference, pp. 52-57. Amer. Meat Sci. Assn. and National Live Stock and Meat Board, 1984. Kennedy, J.F., Griffiths, A.J. and D.P. Atkins. The application of hydrocoUoids: Recent developments, future trends. In: Gums and Stabilizers for the Food Industry 2. G.O. Phillips, D.J. Wedlock and P.A. Williams (Eds.)., pp. 417-455. Pergamon Press, Oxford, U.K., 1984. King, N.L. and J.J. Macfarlane. Muscle proteins. In: Advances in Meat Research, Vol. 3. A.M. Pearson and T.R. Dutson (Eds.), pp. 21-72. Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York, NY, 1987. Langan, R.E. Food industry. In: Modified Starches: Properties and Uses. Wurzburg (Ed.), pp. 199-212. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1986.
O.B.
Lawrie, R.A. Chemical and biochemical constitution of muscle. In: Meat Science, 4th Ed., pp. 4