Explaining Tonality
Eastman Studies in Music Ralph P. Locke, Senior Editor Eastman School of Music (ISSN 1071–9989) A...
182 downloads
1467 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Explaining Tonality
Eastman Studies in Music Ralph P. Locke, Senior Editor Eastman School of Music (ISSN 1071–9989) Additional Titles in Music Theory, Analysis, and Aesthetics Analyzing Wagner’s Operas: Alfred Lorenz and German Nationalist Ideology Stephen McClatchie Berlioz’s Semi-Operas: Roméo et Juliette and La damnation de Faust Daniel Albright The Chansons of Orlando di Lasso and Their Protestant Listeners: Music, Piety, and Print in Sixteenth-Century France Richard Freedman Concert Music, Rock, and Jazz since 1945: Essays and Analytical Studies Edited by Elizabeth West Marvin and Richard Hermann Elliott Carter: Collected Essays and Lectures, 1937–1995 Edited by Jonathan W. Bernard Historical Musicology: Sources, Methods, Interpretations Edited by Stephen A. Crist and Roberta Montemorra Marvin Music and Musicians in the Escorial Liturgy under the Habsburgs, 1563–1700 Michael Noone
Music and the Occult: French Musical Philosophies, 1750–1950 Joscelyn Godwin “The Music of American Folk Song” and Selected Other Writings on American Folk Music Ruth Crawford Seeger, edited by Larry Polansky and Judith Tick The Music of Luigi Dallapiccola Raymond Fearn Music Theory in Concept and Practice Edited by James M. Baker, David W. Beach, and Jonathan W. Bernard The Pleasure of Modernist Music: Listening, Meaning, Intention, Ideology Edited by Arved Ashby Schumann’s Piano Cycles and the Novels of Jean Paul Erika Reiman The Sea on Fire: Jean Barraqué Paul Griffiths Theories of Fugue from the Age of Josquin to the Age of Bach Paul Mark Walker
A complete list of titles in the Eastman Studies in Music Series, in order of publication, may be found at the end of this book.
Explaining Tonality Schenkerian Theory and Beyond
Matthew Brown
University of Rochester Press
Copyright © 2005 Matthew Brown All Rights Reserved. Except as permitted under current legislation, no part of this work may be photocopied, stored in a retrieval system, published, performed in public, adapted, broadcast, transmitted, recorded, or reproduced in any form or by any means, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. First published 2005 University of Rochester Press 668 Mt. Hope Avenue, Rochester, NY 14620, USA www.urpress.com and Boydell & Brewer Limited PO Box 9, Woodbridge, Suffolk IP12 3DF, UK www.boydellandbrewer.com ISBN: 1–58046–160–3 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Brown, Matthew, 1957Explaining tonality : Schenkerian theory and beyond / Matthew Brown. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-58046-160-3 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Schenkerian analysis. 2. Tonality. I. Title. MT6.B87E9 2005 781.2⬘58–dc22 2005007617 A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library. This publication is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in the United States of America.
Contents Figures
vii
Preface
xiii
Introduction. Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues Basic Goals and Assumptions Building and Testing Theories Six Criteria for Evaluating Theories 1. Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy Fux and Strict Counterpoint “The Heinrich Maneuver” “The Complementarity Principle” 2. Semper idem sed non eodem modo Conceptual Origins Prototypes Transformations Levels Fallout 3. What Price Consistency? Sequences Reconsidered Sequences and Counterpoint Analytical Implications 4. Schenker and “The Myth of Scales” Modes and Scales in Traditional Theory Schenkerian Theory and Scales Schenkerian Theory and Modal Inflections Schenkerian Theory and Exotic Inflections Schenkerian Theory and the Emergence of Functional Tonality 5. “Pleasure is the Law” The Limits of Schenkerian Theory Debussy, “C’est l’extase langoureuse” Debussy, “La mort des amants” Schenkerian Theory and Twentieth-Century Music
1 2 12 18 25 27 41 56 66 67 72 76 83 91 99 103 117 126 140 142 146 151 158 162 171 172 186 192 202
vi
Contents
6. Renaturalizing Schenkerian Theory Naturalizing Schenkerian Theory Schenkerian Theory as a Model of Expert Functional Monotonal Composition Conclusion
209 211
Notes
239
Bibliography
267
Index
281
222 234
Figures I.1. I.2. I.3. I.4. I.5. I.6. I.7. I.8. I.9. I.10.
Explaining tonality A procedure for composing typical tonal melodies Five forms of passing tone Counterfactual conditionals ‘The Covering-Law Model’ Explaining suspensions A procedure for generating 7–6 suspensions ‘The Hypothetico-Deductive Method’ The logic of falsification Six criteria for evaluating theories
3 5 6 7 8 9 11 13 16 19
1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 1.4. 1.5. 1.6. 1.7. 1.8. 1.9.
From strict counterpoint to functional tonality Fuxian cantus firmi First Species counterpoint Prototypical counterpoints in Fifth Species Dissonances in florid counterpoint Triads in three- and four-voice textures First Species in three voices Cadence patterns in two, three, and four voices Parallel and direct perfect octaves and fifths in three and four voices Differences in the behavior of triads and Stufen The major-minor system Laws of melodic motion and closure Polyphonic melodies Parallels by doubling and figuration Beethoven, Piano Sonata, Op. 2, no. 3, 1st movement, mm. 47–51 Parallels by combinations of harmonic and non-harmonic tones Laws of relative motion and closure Laws of vertical alignment Consonant non-harmonic tones and dissonant harmonic tones
26 30 32 33 34 36 37 39
1.10. 1.11. 1.12. 1.13. 1.14.
1.15. 1.16. 1.17. 1.18.
40 42 44 45 47 48
49 50 51 52
viii
1.19. 1.20. 1.21. 1.22. 1.23. 1.24. 1.25. 1.26. 1.27. 1.28.
Figures
Neighbor tones and suspensions as passing motions Implied tones and the nota cambiata Successive seventh chords Displacement and accented dissonances Beethoven, Piano Sonata, Op. 81a, 1st movement, mm. 230–42 Laws of harmonic classification Chord function vs. chord derivation Laws of harmonic progression Laws of chromatic generation Rectification of Phrygian II
2.1. Schenker’s concept of prototypes, transformation, and levels 2.2. The non-recursive nature of Fuxian species counterpoint 2.3. Schenkerian Ursätze in C Major 2.4. Horizontalizing transformations 2.5. Filling in transformations 2.6. Harmonizing transformations 2.7. Reordering transformations (non-recursive) 2.8. Composing out 2.9. Schenker’s deep-middleground paradigms 2.10. Divided Urlinien 2.11. Derivation of divided Urlinien 2.12. The explanatory scope of Schenkerian theory 2.13. Schenker’s sketch of “The Representation of Chaos” from Haydn’s Creation 2.14. Alternative sketch of “The Representation of Chaos” 3.1. 3.2. 3.3. 3.4. 3.5. 3.6. 3.7. 3.8.
Sequences A typical ascending-fifth sequence Deriving ascending-fifth sequences Restacking ascending-fifth sequences Deriving ascending-third sequences Deriving descending-fifth sequences Deriving descending 5–6 sequences Deriving alternative descending-fifth sequences
52 54 55 55 56 59 60 61 62 63
69 71 73 78 80 81 82 85 86 88 90 92 94 97 102 104 105 107 108 109 111 112
Figures
3.9. 3.10. 3.11. 3.12. 3.13. 3.14. 3.15. 3.16. 3.17.
ix
Deriving ascending 5–6 sequences Simple mixture Double mixture Fux’s prototypical cantus firmi Typical two-voice counterpoint in First Species Typical two-voice counterpoints in Fourth Species Fux’s three-voice prototypes Typical three-voice counterpoints in Fourth Species Parallel motion in mixed species with three and four voices Parallel linear progressions within a single Stufe Parallel linear progressions between different Stufen Schenker’s analysis of Bach’s Little Prelude in C Major, BWV 924 Alternative analysis of Bach’s Little Prelude in C Major, BWV 924 Schenker’s analysis of Bach’s Prelude in C Minor, WTC I, BWV 847, mm. 1–18 Alternative analysis of Bach’s Prelude in C Minor, WTC I, BWV 847, mm. 1–18 Two analyses of the Prelude from Bach’s Partita No. 3 for Solo Violin Analysis of Bach, French Suite in D Minor, BWV 812, Minuet II
113 114 115 118 118 119 120 120
4.1. Scale membership and tonality 4.2. Schenker’s account of mixture 4.3. Beethoven, “Heiliger Dankegesang,” String Quartet, Op. 132 4.4. Graph of Beethoven, “Heiliger Dankegesang,” String Quartet, Op. 132 4.5. Brahms, “Vergangen ist mir Gluck und Heil,” Op. 14, no. 6 4.6. Graph of Brahms, “Vergangen ist mir Gluck und Heil,” Op. 14, no. 6 4.7. Chopin, Etude, Op. 10, no. 5 4.8. Graph of Debussy, Prélude à “L’Après-midi d’un faune,” mm. 30–37
145 148
3.18. 3.19. 3.20. 3.21. 3.22. 3.23. 3.24. 3.25.
122 123 125 127 129 131 132 133 135
152 153 155 157 159 160
x
Figures
4.9. Van den Toorn’s analysis of the opening of Stravinsky, Petrouchka 4.10. Cadences in fifteenth-century music 4.11. The Artusi-Monteverdi debate 4.12. Renaissance modal polyphony and functional tonality 5.1. Parallel dominant seventh chords 5.2. Free dissonances 5.3. Non-functional successions. Beethoven, Appassionata Sonata, Op. 57, 1st movement, mm. 62–87 5.4. Extreme chromaticism. Graph of Reger, Piano Quintet, Op. 64, mm. 1–8 5.5. Incomplete transferences of the Ursatz 5.6. Interpolations in Debussy, “La sérénade interrompue” (Préludes, Book 1, no. 9) 5.7. Graph of Debussy, “C’est l’extase langoureuse,” mm. 1–18 5.8. Graph of Debussy, “C’est l’extase langoureuse,” mm. 18–35 5.9. Graph of Debussy, “C’est l’extase langoureuse,” m. 36ff 5.10. Evolution of ‘The Sigh Figure’ in Debussy, “C’est l’extase langoureuse” 5.11. Global view of Debussy, “C’est l’extase langoureuse” 5.12. Debussy, “La mort des amants,” mm. 1–12 5.13. Debussy, “La mort des amants,” mm. 12–18 5.14. Debussy, “La mort des amants,” mm. 19–29 5.15. Debussy, “La mort des amants,” mm. 30–45 5.16. Global view of Debussy, “La mort des amants” 5.17. Prolonged dominant-seventh chords 5.18. Schubert, “Die Stadt,” Schwanengesang, no. 11 5.19. Functional tonality and twentieth-century tonal practices 6.1. Naturalizing music theory 6.2. Schenker’s derivation of the major system from ‘The Chord of Nature’
162 164 168 169 174 176 180 181 183 184 188 189 190 191 192 194 196 198 200 201 203 206 208 210 212
Figures
6.3. Lerdahl/Jackendoff’s derivation of Bach, Prelude in C, WTC I 6.4. Learning curve for expert monotonal composition 6.5. Sloboda’s “Diagram of typical compositional resources and processes” 6.6. Schenker’s account of expert monotonal composition 6.7. The scope of music theory
xi
218 221 228 231 232
Preface Few terms in music theory are more profound and more enigmatic than ‘tonality.’ First coined by Alexandre-Étienne Choron in his “Sommaire de l’histoire de la musique” (1810), it was popularized by François-Joseph Fétis in the 1830s and 1840s and has subsequently remained an essential part of theoretical discourse. Choron originally used the term to denote music in which notes are related functionally to a particular tonic, the tonic triad. This particular brand of tonality is often known as ‘functional tonality’ and is characteristic of works written by composers such as Handel, J. S. Bach, Scarlatti, C. P. E. Bach, Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert, Schumann, Mendelssohn, Chopin, and Brahms. But, as Choron’s term has gained currency, so it has expanded its meaning considerably. Nowadays, the term is often used in a very general sense to denote any music that focuses melodically and/or harmonically on some stable pitch or tonic. This definition covers a broad range of music from many cultures and many time periods, from Medieval plain chant to various twentieth-century idioms. Of the many attempts to explain the nature of functional tonality, perhaps the most comprehensive was undertaken by Heinrich Schenker (1868–1935).1 In his monumental triptych, Neue musikalischen Theorien und Phantasien, he systematically investigated the ways in which lines and chords behave in functional tonal contexts. In the first volume, Harmonielehre (1906), he explained how functional harmonies (or Stufen) are organized into progressions (or Stufengang).2 In the second volume, Kontrapunkt (1910, 1922), he explained the basic properties of tonal voice leading (or Stimmführung).3 And in the final volume, Der freie Satz (1935), Schenker showed how the principles outlined in the Harmonielehre and Kontrapunkt operate recursively across entire monotonal compositions.4 But what sorts of relationships did Schenker count as tonal or, to be more precise, functionally monotonal? Why do these relationships work in some ways and not others? Why should we prefer Schenker’s theory of functional monotonality to its competitors?
xiv
Preface
The purpose of this book is to try to answer these questions. The Introduction explores some of the general methodological issues that arise when we try to build, test, and evaluate a plausible theory of tonality. It begins by outlining the main ingredients of such a theory, namely concepts, laws, and procedures, and describes some of the problems that they raise. The Introduction goes on to discuss six criteria that theorists typically use to evaluate the success of their models. These criteria include accuracy, scope, fruitfulness, consistency, simplicity, and coherence. With this broad framework in place, the central portion of the book uses these six criteria to illuminate the foundations of Schenkerian theory. The conclusion describes some of the ways in which Schenkerian theory might develop in the future. There are several reasons why I have decided to address these issues at the present time. Like many music theorists, I am attracted to Schenker’s work because it offers us not only a powerful model for explaining the tonal system, but also a flexible tool for analyzing the practices of functional monotonal composition. The benefits of such an approach seem clear enough; instead of laboriously labeling each successive harmony with its own Roman numeral, the analyst can study the contrapuntal behavior of those harmonies, both within the local context of an individual phrase and within the global context of the piece as a whole. Although Schenkerian theory deals primarily with matters of functional harmony and voice leading, it often leads to important insights about a work’s motivic, rhythmic, and formal structure. This fact is amply demonstrated by Schenker’s best graphic analyses, such as those published in Der Tonwille (1921–24), Das Meisterwerk in der Musik (1925–30), and the Fünf Urlinie-Tafeln (1932).5 Furthermore, since the process of graphing particular pieces often teaches us new ways to hear music and understand the processes of musical composition, Schenkerian analysis can be of great help to performers and composers alike. At the same time, however, I am also intrigued by the formal properties of Schenker’s model. This fascination is something that I share with many other music theorists. Some, such as Milton Babbitt, Allan Keiler, Fred Lerdahl and Ray Jackendoff, have noted certain parallels between Schenker’s account of tonal relationships and Naom Chomsky’s account of grammatical relationships in
Preface
xv
natural language.6 Others, such as Michael Kassler, James Snell, and Stephen Smoliar, have even tried to model Schenkerian theory on the computer.7 I see my work as part of these particular traditions. That being said, Schenkerian theory is still the subject of considerable debate. For starters, although Schenker’s ideas are widely discussed in the music theory community, they are still shrouded in mystery. For example, Jonathan Dunsby has recently accused aficionados of promoting “a cabalistic image of Schenker” that treats his work as “a secret body of knowledge that can be applied but never fully exposed.”8 To make matters worse, when Schenker’s arguments are scrutinized, they often appear to be disjointed, cryptic, and even illogical. William Benjamin has described these shortcomings as follows: “While it is true in many instances that the problem lies with Schenker’s way of putting things and not with the formal relationships he has in mind, there are other cases where contradictory lines of reasoning go to the heart of his level-relating style. In these cases the problem results in a conflict between his artistic-compositional side and his formal-theoretic side.”9 Such conflicts are not, however, easy to resolve; as William Rothstein has observed, the ways in which theorists respond to these issues depends as much on their individual interests, temperament, psychological makeup, and their broader sense of the prevailing Zeitgeist, as on anything Schenker may or may not have written.10 Opinions vary enormously. Some regard Schenker’s work as a theory of musical structure, some as a theory of organic coherence, some as a theory of structural levels, some as theory of voice leading, and some as a theory of tonality.11 I prefer, however, to treat it as a theory of functional monotonal composition. It is this view that I will defend in this book with arguments drawn from analytical philosophy and cognitive science. Another point of contention is the widely held belief that Schenkerian theory is a closed system, incapable of adaptation. Edward Laufer expresses this view most strongly in his review of Ernst Oster’s English translation of Der freie Satz.12 According to him, “Schenker’s concepts as such are complete: they call for no extensions or modifications.” Elsewhere, he defends the narrow scope of Schenker’s project by noting: “It is ridiculous to demand as a criterion of validity that an approach be applicable to all times and
xvi
Preface
musics; for it is sufficient that Schenker revealed, in ever new ways, the masterpieces of the classic era: altogether more great music than anyone could hope to come to terms with in several lifetimes.”13 While I am certainly sympathetic to Laufer’s point of view, I would add two important provisos. First, no one has ever offered a convincing argument to show why we should accept Schenker’s concepts as necessary and sufficient for explaining functional tonality. As I see it, such an argument requires us to reconstruct the theory systematically from the ground up. This is precisely what I hope to accomplish in the present volume. Second, although I have no problem accepting that Schenkerian theory is designed to explain functional monotonal pieces of the Common-Practice Period, I acknowledge that such music is part of a broader historical continuum. Eventually, Schenkerians must respond to Joseph Kerman’s complaint that they treat tonal practice as “an absolutely flat plateau flanked by bottomless chasms.”14 I am not suggesting, however, that we should simply revive the approach adopted by Felix Salzer in Structural Hearing; much as I admire Salzer’s broad outlook on music history, I do not think his work provides a satisfactory response to this issue.15 What we need is a way to redirect our thinking about tonality so that we can explain not only why Schenker’s theory works so well for functional monotonal compositions, but also how this theory enhances our understanding of tonality in general. Another important area of debate concerns the ways in which Schenkerian analysis interfaces with the processes of hearing and composing. Although I have no doubt that the way in which we graph a piece depends on how we hear that piece, I do not accept the common view that producing a Schenkerian analysis simply means learning to hear music more effectively. For one thing, such a view leaves the theory open to the charge of circularity levelled by Eugene Narmour in his book Beyond Schenkerism.16 According to Narmour, when Schenker tried to demonstrate that a piece could be derived from a given prototype, he always knew in advance what the prototype should be. By bending the piece to fit his preconception, Schenker was guilty of circular reasoning. From a methodological standpoint, this is a very serious charge and, so far as I can tell, is one that has never been successfully dismissed by the Schenkerian community.
Preface
xvii
For another, there is strong evidence from Schenker’s own writings that he was not trying to explain how ordinary people hear a particular piece, but rather to explain how expert composers conceive of their music. For example, in his essay “Forsetzung der Urlinie-Betrachtung: I” from Das Meisterwerk I (1925), Schenker insisted that it is the composer’s business to compose out chords and that of the listener and the performer “to retrace” this path from foreground to background.17 Given this claim, I remain unpersuaded by the notion that Schenkerian analyses give us “artistic statements, in music, about music.”18 I firmly believe that, though they may be expressed as tones on a staff, Schenkerian analyses should be regarded not as pieces of music, but rather as models of music.19 Like any model, these graphs capture some aspects of the music and not others. I would argue that they model an expert composer’s internalized knowledge of functional monotonality.20 My goal, then, is to respond to these various challenges. Since I am mainly motivated by methodological concerns, I have adopted something of a compromise when referring to Schenker’s works. For one thing, Schenker’s views clearly changed over time; his goals in writing the Harmonielehre and Kontrapunkt I were not exactly the same as those of the Fünf Urlinie-Tafeln and Der freie Satz. Having said that, I still believe that there is an underlying continuity to Schenker’s thought. This continuity stems from two basic claims: 1) the laws of tonal voice leading are transformations of the laws of strict counterpoint and are intimately related to certain laws of functional harmony; and 2) complex tonal progressions can be explained as transformations of simple tonal prototypes. Given my interest in these claims and their theoretical implications, I will focus more on the unity of his thought, than on its evolution. Similarly, although one must always be sensitive to nuances in the meaning of particular Schenkerian terms, I have generally quoted from standard English translations. My rationale is simple; while I am aware of the extraordinary problems that arise whenever we try to render Schenker’s often convoluted prose into English, I do not want to become sidetracked with the daunting task of retranslating every passage. Anyone interested in Schenkerian theory must eventually compare the English translation with the original; I have
xviii
Preface
tried to give citations in such a way that this can be accomplished as easily as possible. Although this book has been largely written from scratch, it nonetheless draws on material from several published and unpublished papers. The Introduction develops ideas originally outlined in two published papers written with Douglas Dempster, “The Scientific Image of Music Theory,” Journal of Music Theory 33/1 (1989), pp. 65–106, and “Evaluating Music Analyses and Theories: Five Perspectives,” Journal of Music Theory 34/2 (1990), pp. 247–79. This work was subsequently updated in two unpublished lectures, “The Scientific Image of Music Theory: Ten Years On,” given at Eastman School of Music in the fall of 1996, and “Choosing between Music Theories: Six Things to Think About” delivered at SUNY Buffalo in the fall of 1998. Chapters 1 and 2 expand arguments first presented in my Ph.D. dissertation, “A Rational Reconstruction of Schenkerian Theory” (Cornell, 1989), and in my paper “Rothstein’s Paradox and Neumeyer’s Fallacies,” Intégral 12 (1998), pp. 95–132. Whereas chapter 3 is entirely new, chapter 4 draws on another unpublished paper, “Schenker and ‘The Myth of Scales,’ ” presented at the Oxford Music Analysis Conference and the annual meeting of the Society for Music Theory in Baltimore in 1988. Chapter 5 borrows from lectures delivered at the University of Texas at Austin in the fall of 2001 and at Oxford University in the spring of 2003. Chapter 6 is mostly new but draws on material that I have been developing with Panayotis Mavromatis. I would like to take this opportunity to thank several people for helping me along the way. Much of the blame for this book must go to Arnold Whittall for introducing me to Schenkerian theory in my undergraduate years at King’s College, London. Since then, he has been a pillar of support and very kindly read a draft of this manuscript. This particular project started life in 1983–86, when I was a Junior Fellow at the Society of Fellows, Harvard University. I would like to thank the Society for its unqualified support during those years. Since that time, my thinking about Schenkerian theory has also been shaped by discussions with four other people—Doug Dempster, Dave Headlam, Panayotis Mavromatis, and Bryce Rytting. The fact that I have collaborated with most of them should indicate just how much they have taught me. I must also thank all my
Preface
xix
graduate students at Eastman for listening to me and for reading chunks of text—Don Traut and Bill Marvin deserve special mention—and John Brackett for inviting me to be involved with his dissertation. Special thanks must go to Frank Samarotto for carefully reading the manuscript. Most recently, I must thank Wayne Alpern and the Mannes Institute for Advanced Studies in Music Theory for inviting me to discuss my work in three workshops in the summer of 2002. I am extremely grateful to the members of my workshop—Kofi Agawu, Richmond Browne, Allan Cadwallader, William Drabkin, Yayoi Everett, Dora Hanninen, Dan Harrison, Peter Kaminsky, Richard Kaplan, Steve Larson, Nicolas Meeus, Margus Partlas, Giogio Sanguinetti, Carl Schachter, and Joe Straus. In terms of the production of the book, I would like to thank Dariusz Terefenko and Ciro Scotto for help in preparing the examples, though I must admit that I was never able to reproduce Schenker’s interlocking slurs to my satisfaction. And I must thank my editors Louise Goldberg and Ralph Locke for their patience and encouragement. Finally, I owe a special thank you to Milton Babbitt for encouraging me to publish my ideas in book form. I would like to express my gratitude to the following people and publishers for permission to quote from their works and publications: Cambridge University Press, for permission to use materials from the English translation of Schenker’s Das Meisterwerk in der Musik: (The Masterwork in Music, ed. William Drabkin, trans. I. Bent, R. Kramer, J. Rothgeb, and H. Siegel), vols. 1 and 2, © 1994, 1996. MIT Press, for permission to use the figure showing the derivation of J. S. Bach’s Prelude in C Major, WTC 1, from Fred Lerdahl and Ray Jackendoff, A Generative Theory of Tonal Music, © 1983. John Rothgeb, for permission to use materials from his edition/translation of Schenker’s Kontrapunkt I & II (Counterpoint I and II, ed. John Rothgeb, trans. John Rothgeb and Jürgen Thym, 2 vols., [New York, Schirmer, 1987]). Universal Edition, for permission to use materials from Schenker’s Harmonielehre (1906) and from Schenker’s Der freie Satz (1935), copyright © Universal Edition A.G. Vienna.
Introduction
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues What should we expect from a successful theory of tonality? Why should we prefer one theory of tonality over another? To what extent do theories of tonality pose the same methodological problems as theories in other domains? Although these are surely basic questions for any music theorist to ask, they are by no means easy ones to answer. In part, the difficulties stem from the fact that the term ‘tonality’ has come to mean different things to different people; as mentioned in the preface, some theorists use it very generally to denote music that centers on a stable pitch or tonic, whereas others use the term more restrictively to denote music that centers functionally on a particular tonic triad. But difficulties also arise because theorists often disagree about what they take to be the goals of their work. Once again, opinions differ widely. Some believe that theory building is an explanatory pursuit akin to the natural and social sciences, whereas others believe that it is a critical activity, analogous to art criticism or literary theory. As a result, some theorists deal exclusively with the internal properties of tonal music, whereas others insist that these properties cannot be studied apart from their cognitive, aesthetic, historical, and ideological context. The purpose of this Introduction is not to address these issues in a systematic manner, but rather to pinpoint some of the methodological concerns that shape my own particular views about tonal theory. I will proceed from the assumption that, before we can assess the cognitive, aesthetic, historical, and ideological implications of a particular theory, we must first see how that theory explains why tonal music behaves in some ways and not others. Since I believe that, at some level, we process our knowledge of music separately from our knowledge of other domains, I find it useful to treat music
2
Explaining Tonality
theory autonomously from other disciplines. Furthermore, since I also believe that tonality is basically a general property of voice leading and harmony, I will focus my attention on explaining these phenomena. This does not mean, however, that I am uninterested in thematic, rhythmic, or formal relationships. Rather, I do so because I am concerned with explaining the tonality of music rather than explaining tonal music per se. In fact, I readily accept that there is much more to understanding the latter than simply explaining its tonality. My discussion has three main parts. Part 1 outlines what I take to be the main goals of any theory of tonality: 1) to develop a vocabulary of concepts for describing what relationships count as tonal; 2) to discover a set of covering laws for explaining why these relationships work in some ways in ways and not others, and 3) to devise procedures for explaining how to produce specific tonal relationships. Next, part 2 discusses some of the issues that arise in testing a particular theory of tonality. Finally, part 3 discusses six criteria that theorists frequently use to pick one theory of tonality over another: accuracy, scope, consistency, simplicity, fruitfulness, and coherence.
Basic Goals and Assumptions Although music theorists formulate theories of tonality for a variety of reasons, three seem to be especially important. The first is to develop a vocabulary of concepts for describing what relationships count as tonal or, more specifically, functionally tonal. Concepts are terms we use to categorize our observations into broad types. According to ‘The Classical Theory of Concepts,’ defining a concept involves establishing a set of necessary and sufficient conditions that something must satisfy if it is to fall under that concept.1 Music theorists have traditionally expended considerable effort on developing concepts to describe a wide range of tonal relationships. Many of these concepts allow us to describe how notes behave linearly. For example, when describing the tonal properties of the music shown in figure I.1a (Beethoven, Six Variations, WoO 70), we might observe that the thirty-second note B in the treble clef,
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
3
Figure I.1. Explaining tonality. a. Beethoven, Six Variations, WoO 70, mm. 13–16.
b. Beethoven, Piano Sonata, Op. 22, 4th movement, mm. 19–21.
m. 13, passes between A and C. This account presupposes that the concept ‘passing tone’ can be defined as an unaccented dissonance that moves by step between two consonances a third apart. Such a definition conveys the necessary condition that passing tones move by step and is sufficiently precise to differentiate passing tones from other dissonances, such as neighbor tones, cambiatas, and suspensions. Alternatively, we might use quite different concepts to describe how notes behave harmonically. In the case of figure I.1a, we might observe that the passage begins and ends on a G triad with the root in the bass. This description presumes that the concept ‘triad’ can be defined as a chord with a root and two other members a third and a fifth above. The latter definition conveys the necessary condition that triads are built from thirds and fifths, and yet is sufficiently broad to encompass major, minor, augmented, and diminished triads. It goes without saying that both of these descriptions tell us significant things about the tonal properties of figure I.1a. And yet,
4
Explaining Tonality
neither one actually explains why Beethoven’s music is ‘in’ G major. The problem is that to explain why the passage is tonal, it is not enough to describe what melodic tones and triads are present; we must also say why they are related to each other in some ways and not others. To do so, music theorists invoke various laws of harmony and voice leading. These laws are general claims about the ways in which melodic tones and triads usually behave in tonal contexts.2 They are often, but not always, expressed in a conditional form: if X occurs in context Y, then Z will happen. For example, to explain why the passage in figure I.1a establishes the key of G major, we might invoke the following law: “If the leading tone appears in tonal contexts, then it normally ascends by half step onto the tonic.” This law explains why the melody rises from F to G in mm. 13–14, why the alto part follows suit in mm. 14–15, and even why the same theme is in B-flat major when Beethoven transposes it up a minor third in his piano sonata, Op. 22 (see figure I.1b). Having said this, it is important to note that the law governing leading tones is not true all of the time. In figure I.1a, for example, the alto F in mm. 15–16 moves to B3 and not G4, presumably to avoid doubling the soprano part. Since most laws of tonality are generally but not universally true, they are best classified as law-like generalizations. Besides introducing concepts to describe what relationships are tonal and invoking law-like generalizations to explain why tonal music behaves in some ways and not others, theorists often have yet another important goal: to explain how specific tonal relationships are produced. This task requires them to develop a set of procedures. Procedures consist of strings of commands that are usually expressed in conditional form: to produce X, do Y, then Z, and so on. Over the centuries, tonal theorists have developed procedures for accomplishing a variety of tasks from harmonizing a scale to composing a prelude from a given figured bass. Take, for example, figure I.2 (A procedure for composing typical tonal melodies). This procedure has six basic steps. First, pick a final tonic for the melody as a whole (figure I.2a). Second, begin the melody on a member of the tonic triad and end with a stepwise descent onto the tonic (figure I.2b). Third, pick a climax note midway through the melody and not more than an octave above the tonic (figure I.2c). Fourth, reinforce the tonic at the opening (figure I.2d). Fifth, join the opening to the climax and
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
5
Figure I.2. A procedure for composing typical tonal melodies. a. Pick a final tonic for the melody as a whole. 1 b. Begin the melody on 8, 5, 3, or 1 and end with a stepwise descent onto the tonic. Cadence 3 2 1 c. Pick a climax about two thirds through the melody and not more than an octave above the tonic. Climax Cadence 4 3 2 1 d. Reinforce the tonic at the opening.
3
4
7
1
Climax 4
Cadence 2 1
e. Join the opening to the climax and the climax to the cadence. Climax Cadence 4 4 7 3 1 2 3 2 1 f. Fill in any details and check to see that the melody has a good overall shape and that it satisfies any general laws of melodic motion. Climax Cadence 7 4 3 2 3 4 6 1 2 3 2 1
the climax to the cadence (figure I.2e). Sixth, fill in any details and check to see that the melody has a good overall shape and satisfies any general laws of tonal voice leading, for example, that leading tones normally ascend by half step onto the tonic (figure I.2f). The preceding discussion has highlighted the central role concepts, laws, and procedures have traditionally played in tonal theory, but it is important to realize that these components are a lot more difficult to deal with than we might initially suppose. Take, for example, concepts. While it is certainly possible to find necessary and sufficient conditions for many concepts, cognitive scientists have found that certain concepts cannot be defined in this manner. Instead, they tend to define such concepts by appealing to the notion of prototypes.3 As Alvin Goldman explains: Concepts are represented in terms of properties that need not be strictly necessary but are frequently present in instances of the concept. These
6
Explaining Tonality properties are weighted by their frequency or by their perceptual salience. A collection of such properties is called a prototype.4
He adds: “Under the prototype view, an object is categorized as an instance of a concept if it is sufficiently similar to the prototype, similarity being determined (in part) by the number of properties in the prototype possessed by the instance and by the sum of their weights.”5 Although Goldman does not explicitly say so, the ‘perfect’ prototype may not actually ‘exist’ in the world at all; it may be an idealization that combines features from many different individuals. We can illustrate these points by reconsidering our definition of passing tones (see figure I.3, Five forms of passing tone). Although we defined passing tones as unaccented dissonances that move by step between two consonances a third apart, some passing tones do not satisfy this definition. In figure I.3a, for example, the pitch B in m. 1 seems to behave as a passing tone, even though it is consonant, and in figure I.3b the notes F and E in m. 1 are both dissonant and seem to connect two consonances a fourth, not a third, apart. More remarkably, figure I.3c contains an accented passing tone, figure I.3d includes a chromatic passing tone, and, if you believe Schenker, figure I.3e contains a leaping passing tone (or springender Durchgang)!6 In other words, it is much easier to think about passing tones in terms of prototypes and variants, than it is to provide a necessary and sufficient definition that works in all cases.7 Laws, too, pose their own problems.8 To begin with, not all generalizations are law-like.9 Take, for example, the claim that all pieces in G major have a key signature of one sharp. Even if true, which it is not, this generalization does not stand up as a law because it does not explain why there is any connection between having a signature of one sharp and establishing the key of G. To ensure that particular Figure I.3. Five forms of passing tone.
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
7
generalizations are law-like, Nelson Goodman and others have suggested they should support so-called counterfactual conditionals.10 Counterfactual conditionals are hypothetical statements that suggest what would have been the case had things occurred differently (see figure I.4, Counterfactual conditionals). For example, when explaining why the cadence in figure I.4a establishes the key of G major, we might invoke our law governing leading tones. In this case, the F in the first chord ascends by half step to the G in the final sonority. We might support this law-like generalization by noting that if the phrase had been in F major, then the F in the first chord would have descended to E, before moving back onto F for the final chord (see figure I.4b). Since we know that the piece in question is in G major, our remarks about what might have happened if the piece were in F major are known as counterfactual conditionals. While counterfactual conditionals have proved very useful in helping us determine whether a particular generalization is indeed law-like, they nonetheless raise their own sets of questions; it
Figure I.4. Counterfactual conditionals.
8
Explaining Tonality
Figure I.5. ‘The Covering-Law Model’. ‘The Covering-Law Model’ Statement of initial conditions Statement of covering laws Statement about phenomena to be explained.
is unclear not only how to ensure that they are relevant in any given context, but also that they can be used to support all law-like generalizations. It is also debatable whether law-like generalizations are always necessary and sufficient for explanations. Certainly, many experts believe that scientific research is fundamentally law seeking or nomothetic.11 This prompted Carl Hempel and Paul Oppenheim to advance ‘The Covering-Law Model’ of explanation.12 According to them, explanations are arguments in which the premises are sets of covering laws and initial conditions, and the conclusion is some statement about the phenomena to be explained (see figure I.5, ‘The Covering-Law Model’). If the laws are universal and the arguments are deductively valid, then the result fits ‘The DeductiveNomological Model,’ and if the laws are not universal and the arguments are only inductively valid, then they conform to ‘The Inductive-Statistical Model.’ Figure I.6 (Explaining suspensions) illustrates what Hempel and Oppenheim had in mind. Suppose, for example, that we want to explain why a particular suspension C resolves by step to B (see figure I.6a). We might do so by invoking a simple law of tonal voice leading: namely, that suspensions normally resolve down by step onto consonances (see figure I.6b). Given the initial conditions that the seventh C–D on the down beat of m. 2 is dissonant and that the dissonance is a suspension, this law-like generalization allows us to deduce that the dissonant tone C on the down beat of m. 2 will resolve down by step onto the consonant tone B in m. 2. This is a perfectly acceptable explanation. Although ‘The Covering-Law Model’ certainly produces acceptable explanations, it is unclear whether covering laws are absolutely necessary for all plausible explanations. In particular,
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
9
Figure I.6. Explaining suspensions.
b.
c.
The seventh C-D on the down beat of m. 2 is dissonant
The sixth B-D on the weak beat of m. 2 is consonant
This dissonance is a suspension
This consonance is a resolution.
Covering Laws
Suspensions generally resolve down by step consonances
Suspensions generally resolve down by step onto onto consonances
Explanation
Resolution on weak beat is a consonant sixth
Suspension on down beat is a dissonant seventh
Initial Conditions
critics have suggested that some types of explanation, such as so-called functional explanations used in biology, or narrative explanations found in history, do not necessarily involve covering laws, at least not in any explicit way.13 Functional explanations explain how particular parts of a complex system help to reinforce the system as a whole. For example, when explaining the tonal motion of Beethoven’s “Waldstein” Sonata, we might note that, in the first movement, the function of the recapitulation is to recompose the tonal motion of the exposition, that the function of the exposition is to modulate from the first key (C major) to the second key (E major), and that the function of this modulation is to create a pattern of tonal tension, and so on. Though this explanation seems plausible enough, it is unclear what covering laws it uses. Historical narratives often proceed on similar lines. For example, when explaining why the climax of a given aria appears on a high ‘C’ we might note that this aria was written for a particular tenor to sing at La Scala, and that high ‘C’ was his top note. Although this explanation seems to make historical sense, we would never suggest that, as a general rule, composers always make sure that the climax of an aria necessarily corresponds to the highest note in the singer’s register.14
10
Explaining Tonality
By the same token, Sylvain Bromberger and others have raised doubts about whether covering laws are sufficient for all explanations.15 We can paraphrase their point by comparing the explanation given in figure I.6b with the one shown in figure I.6c. In figure I.6b, we explained why the dissonant note C on the down beat of m. 2 resolved down by step to a consonant note B by invoking the law-like generalization that suspensions normally resolve down by step. However, we can also use the same covering law in a quite different way. This time we might start with the initial conditions that the sixth B–D on the weak beat of m. 2 is consonant and that it resolves a suspension on the preceding down beat. Since our covering law states that suspensions generally resolve down by step, we can deduce that the consonant note B is preceded by a dissonant note C. Although this argument is logically consistent, it does not carry the same weight as the argument given in figure I.6b. The problem is that the argument in figure I.6b explains the causal connections between the suspension and the resolution, whereas the one in figure I.6c does not. This, in turn, suggests that it is not enough to invoke covering laws in our explanations; our explanations must also be able to explain how one event causes another. One way to guarantee such casual connections is by reformatting our covering laws in procedural form.16 As mentioned earlier, procedures are strings of commands that we express in conditional form: to produce X, do Y, then Z, and so on. This point is illustrated in figure I.7, (A procedure for generating 7–6 suspensions). This procedure involves three distinct steps: 1) take an upper voice that descends by step C to B (figure I.7a); 2) add a lower voice that moves in parallel sixths below, E to D (figure I.7b); and 3) displace the first note of the upper voice over the second note of the lower voice (figure I.7c). This step produces the 7–6 suspension. Significantly, this procedure implies all of the same knowledge as the explanation given in figure I.6b. In particular, it implies that suspensions generally resolve down by step. And yet, the procedure adds something extra: it also indicates that suspensions are caused by displacing the upper voice over the lower voice.
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
11
Figure I.7. A procedure for generating 7–6 suspensions. a. Take an upper voice that descends by step from C to B.
b. Add a lower voice that moves in parallel sixths below, E to D.
c. Displace the first note of the upper voice over the second note of the lower voice to create a 7–6 suspension.
Whatever advantages procedural explanations may give us, they can, however, be slippery things to deal with. Reconsider, for a moment, the procedure given in figure I.2. This strategy identified six basic steps for composing a typical tonal melody. In order for us to determine whether the procedure is successful or not, we must decide whether or not our new melody resembles the melody in figure I.1. But what does it mean to say that two melodies resemble one another? To answer this question we must invoke some notion of similarity, but it is by no means obvious what this step involves. As the philosophers Quine and Ullian explain: “Everything is similar to everything in some respect. Any two things share as many traits as any other two, if we are undiscriminating about what to call a trait; things can be grouped in no end of arbitrary ways.”17 In other words, we can judge similarity in different ways, depending upon what examples we take as prototypical and on how we decide to measure similarity. It seems, then, that in describing what relationships are tonal, explaining why these relationships create music that behaves in some ways and not others, and explaining how to produce specific tonal relationships, music theorists draw on a rich assortment of
12
Explaining Tonality
concepts, laws, and procedures. Although each component raises its own methodological issues, a given theory of tonality takes a specific cluster of concepts, laws, and procedures, and structures it in a particular way. If these theories are successful, then we normally expect that these knowledge structures will give us explanations and predictions that are coherent, reliable, and capable of being tested empirically by other theorists. And they should work for all and only all tonal music, or at least all and only all functional pieces. But how do we go about building such a theory? How, in fact, do we check to see that it actually covers all and only all music that we classify as tonal? Let us see how we might answer these new questions.
Building and Testing Theories According to conventional wisdom, theorists use a very simple strategy for coming up with their theories: they make guesses and then they test them.18 This approach is summarized in figure I.8 (‘The Hypothetico-Deductive Method’).19 In fact we can subdivide ‘The Hypothetico-Deductive Method’ (or H-D) into four basic steps: First, observe some distinct phenomenon in a well-defined test sample (figure I.8a). Second, guess some laws that seem to explain these observations (figure I.8b). Third, deduce some predictable consequences that are implied if these laws are correct (figure I.8c). Fourth, see if these predictions are confirmed by further observations (figure I.8d). If the predictions are indeed confirmed, then theorists carry on using their laws; if they aren’t, then they must either modify them, or they must replace them with new laws and start the procedure all over again. This final step is crucial to the entire process; ideally, it implies not only that the predictions are testable, but also that they are testable by someone else and under different conditions. Now, if we want to make a theory to explain the behavior of tonal voice leading and harmony, then we might adopt the following plan. We might begin by using certain familiar concepts to study a specific corpus of pieces that a given community regards as
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
13
Figure I.8. ‘The Hypothetico-Deductive Method’. a. Observe phenomenon in some well-defined test sample. b. Guess laws to explain these observations. c. Deduce some consequences that are implied if the laws are correct. d. See if these predictions are confirmed by further observations. If they are, then keep using the new laws, if they aren’t, then modify them or replace with some new laws and start procedure over.
quintessentially tonal. Chances are we would pick pieces by such composers as Handel, J. S. Bach, Scarlatti, C. P. E. Bach, Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert, Schumann, Mendelssohn, Chopin, and Brahms.20 Next, we might develop general laws that cover the behavior of these concepts. For example, we might generalize about how lines and chords behave in specific contexts. We could then predict how the lines and chords might behave in other contexts, preferably those that are slightly different from the ones used to make the original theory. If our predictions are confirmed, then we will keep on using our theory to explain the behavior of similar works from the same corpus; if, however, they are disconfirmed, then we must either modify the theory or find an alternative one that does work. So much for conventional wisdom; we find it perpetuated in many introductions to science. But when we look at how theorists actually work, we soon find that the process of building and testing theories is a good deal more complex than figure I.8 suggests. To begin with, it is very unlikely that any music theorists would actually build a new theory of tonality from scratch. Instead, they are more likely to start by taking some preexisting model and seeing if individual laws stand up to close scrutiny. Once they encounter a problem, then they will propose new covering laws. But disconfirming existing laws and confirming new laws is no easy task; on the contrary, these activities are riddled with problems and inconsistencies.21 These difficulties stem from the fact that, as David Hume famously remarked, “all inferences from experience, therefore, are effects of
14
Explaining Tonality
custom, not of [logical] reasoning.”22 Hume’s claim does not mean that inferences from experience are necessarily untrue; rather it suggests that they always fall short of certainty. As a result, our theories will always be fallible, though we may not always know where they will fail. Besides recognizing the general problems noted by Hume, philosophers have discussed several other difficulties. One of the most famous is ‘The Raven Paradox.’23 This paradox arises because law statements of the form “for all x, if x is F, then x is G” are logically equivalent to those of the form “for all x, if x is not G, then x is not F.” If x stands for piece of music, F stands for Beethoven and G stands for tonal, then the first law-statement “all pieces of music by Beethoven are tonal” is equivalent to the observation that a particular non-tonal piece, say Babbitt’s Philomel, is indeed not by Beethoven. What is paradoxical is that an atonal piece by Babbitt should count as evidence that confirms the generalization that all pieces by Beethoven are tonal; after all, Babbitt’s music appears to have little in common with Beethoven’s and it hardly seems relevant to any claims about whether the latter is tonal or not. Relevance also features prominently in another paradox known as ‘The Grue Paradox.’ This paradox was first discussed by Nelson Goodman.24 According to him, the issue of whether a generalization is supported by its instances depends on the nature of the properties that appear in that generalization. Paraphrasing Goodman, let us imagine a new property, ‘gronality’ which we define as follows: a piece is ‘gronal’ if it is classified as tonal before the year 2010 and atonal after that point. Now consider the following generalizations: 1) all works by Burt Bacharach are tonal and 2) all pieces by Burt Bacharach are ‘gronal.’ All works examined before the year 2010 will support not only the first generalization, but also the second one. This result is problematic because we want to use our generalizations to predict what will happen at some later date; as it stands, we have no basis for knowing whether the piece will be tonal or ‘gronal.’ To resolve this paradox, Goodman proposed that the law-like status of a generalization is a matter of entrenchment and projectibility. According to him, a predicate is entrenched if it is true as a matter of historical fact and has been used to formulate
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
15
true predictions.25 He suggests that this property is the only one that allows us to project what will happen in the future. Tonality is just such a predicate; it is a trait that we naturally project from past observation to future expectation. ‘Gronality’ is not, however, because we have no reason to suppose that Burt Bacharach wrote music that can been classified as tonal at one point in time and atonal at some later date.26 ‘The Grue Paradox’ leads to a more general problem in confirmation; even if we agree on the same body of evidence, there is no reason to suppose that this data can be explained by only one theory; as we have seen, we can always invent new predicates, such as ‘grue-ness’ or ‘gronality,’ that capture some aspect of the piece. This means that, in principle at least, the evidence always underdetermines theories; there are always a variety of theories that will accommodate any given set of data. Pierre Duhem and W. V. Quine have gone even further to claim that, taken on its own, a particular piece of experimental evidence is seldom used to falsify an entire theory, because each element of the theory is somehow related to another element in the theory. As Quine puts it, “our statements about the external world face the tribunal of sense experience not individually but only as a corporate body.”27 In other words, “any seemingly disconfirming observational evidence can always be accommodated to any theory.”28 This claim is usually known as ‘The Duhem-Quine Thesis.’ Although extremely controversial, ‘The Duhem-Quine Thesis’ is significant because it threatens to undermine the most famous alternative to H-D. Given the many paradoxes of confirmation, Karl Popper and others have suggested that, instead of defending their theories by finding more and more supporting evidence, scientists should actually spend their time trying to show that some hypotheses are false.29 In this sense, the guiding principle of testability is not confirmation but falsification. The rationale behind Popper’s thinking is simple enough and is apparent from the arguments given in figure I.9 (The logic of falsification). According to Popper, H-D seems to follow the plan given in figure I.9a. Let us assume that, if a particular explanation E is valid, then it will make a given prediction P. When researchers test this prediction and find that it is indeed accurate, they regard this as confirmation of their
16
Explaining Tonality
Figure I.9. The logic of falsification. a.
c.
If Explanation E is valid, then Prediction P is true.
b.
If X → Y
Prediction P is true
Y
∴ Explanation E is valid
∴ X (invalid)
If Explanation E is valid, then Prediction P is true.
d.
modus tollens If X → Y
Prediction P is false
⫺Y
∴ Explanation E is false
∴ ⫺X (valid)
explanation. But, according to Popper, this line of reasoning is invalid. Since explanation E was used to come up with prediction P, prediction P cannot then be used to confirm explanation E. That would commit the fallacy of affirming the antecedent (see figure I.9b). To avoid this problem, Popper insists that H-D should be used, not to confirm, but to falsify a theory. This means that, given explanation E and prediction P, knowing that P is false allows us to deduce that E is false as well (see figure I.9c). Such an argument follows the principle of modus tollens given in figure I.9d. Popper used the notion that H-D can be used to falsify an explanation to reach two important conclusions. First, he proposed that even our best knowledge is fallible or conjectural. To quote him, “we cannot reach certainty . . . all we can do is to criticize [our theories], and to test them, as severely as our ingenuity permits.”30 Second, Popper decided that “the criterion of the scientific status of a theory is its falsifiability, or refutability, or testability.”31 He even claimed that falsifiability serves as a criterion for making demarcations between science and non-science; whereas scientific theories must always have discrete boundaries and can be falsified, non-science need not have such boundaries and cannot be falsified. Critics, however, have responded that strict falsification is hard to uphold in light of ‘The Duhem-Quine Thesis.’ If, as Duhem and Quine insist, “any seemingly disconfirming observational evidence can always be accommodated to any theory,” then it is hard to see how we can decisively falsify any theory. Each time we come up with a counter example, we can simply adjust our theory to make it
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
17
fit. If we cannot use specific observations to falsify a given theory, then we cannot pick one theory over another on purely evidential grounds. Popper’s claim that falsifiability provides us with a definitive means of discriminating science from non-science seems, therefore, too strong.32 As it happens, Popper’s views have also been challenged by recent findings in cognitive science. Research by Tweney, Doherty, Mynatt, and others has suggested that scientists do not usually set out simply to falsify existing theories; on the contrary, they normally start out by seeking confirmatory data; only when this data has been obtained does it make sense to engage in rigorous falsification.33 Thus, while it might be true that successful theories are initially conjectural, the accumulation of supporting evidence will eventually move them beyond that status.34 Most people do, in fact, believe that theories become more strongly confirmed the more supporting evidence has been amassed. This point suggests that our understanding of what makes a successful music theory must eventually take account of the ways in which music theorists actually work, rather than simply relying on their logical or empirical content. All in all, just as ‘The Covering Law Model’ provides an idealized picture of explanation, so ‘The Hypothetico-Deductive Method’ presents an idealized account of how music theorists confirm or refute a particular theory. While the latter conveys many aspects of how music theorists work, the process of building and testing theories involves a far more complex interplay between confirmation and falsification. As we have seen, this process is always open ended; music theorists do not begin with a blank slate, they do not have foolproof methods, and they do not reach definitive solutions. Instead, they plunge in medias res. They start working within the context of an existing music theory, even if they know some portions of that theory are surely wrong. They then try to overcome certain specific problems, using the rest of the theory to support their work. To borrow an image from Neurath and Quine, this situation is like that facing sailors at sea on a leaking boat.35 Unable to rebuild their vessel from the keel up in a dry dock, the crew is forced to fix the leaks while adrift on the open water. As they work on leaks in one area of the boat, the
18
Explaining Tonality
sailors rely on the remaining timbers to keep the craft afloat. But as one leak is patched so another appears; bit-by-bit the boat becomes transformed into something new. In fixing the leaks, music theorists typically try to balance what Quine has described as “the drive for evidence and the drive for system.”36 According to him, the former demands that “theoretical terms should be subject to observable criteria, the more the better, the more directly the better, other things being equal” while the latter insists that these terms “should lend themselves to systematic laws, the simpler the better, other things being equal.” Quine adds, “If either of these drives were unchecked by the other, it would issue in something unworthy of the name scientific theory: in the one case a mere record of observations, and on the other a myth without foundation.”37
Six Criteria for Evaluating Theories It should be clear by now that the task of building and testing music theories is not only a lot messier than we might suppose, but it is also plagued by many of the same methodological problems as theories in other disciplines, especially the natural and social sciences. In very general terms, we have seen that these problems often involve finding effective ways to balance the drive for evidence with the drive for system. Although this all sounds reasonable enough, we can spell out more clearly how such a balance might be achieved. Following, Kuhn, Quine and others, we can invoke several concrete criteria for doing so: figure I.10 (Six criteria for evaluating theories) includes the notions of accuracy, scope, fruitfulness, consistency, simplicity, and coherence.38 The list is by no means exhaustive; other criteria, such as completeness, elegance, or even ‘coolness,’ could easily be added. Figure I.10, however, gives us a good place to start our inquiry. For convenience, the six criteria are divided into two types—those that relate to the evidential basis of theories and those which relate to the systematic aspects of a model. The horizontal arrow at the top of the figure suggests that there may be inherent conflicts between the evidential concerns (accuracy, scope, and fruitfulness) and the systematic concerns
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
19
Figure I.10. Six criteria for evaluating theories. Evidence
System
Accuracy
Consistency
Scope
Simplicity
Fruitfulness
Coherence
(consistency, simplicity, and coherence). The vertical arrows along the sides suggest that there may be a similar tension between members of the same type. The first criterion on our list is accuracy. Since a successful theory should explain why certain phenomena behave the way they do and predict what will happen in new situations, we will surely want the most exact explanations and predictions possible. Although our theories can never be completely accurate, we generally see increased precision as a virtue, so that, given two theories, we usually prefer the one that is more accurate, other things being equal. And yet, it is by no means obvious how to measure the accuracy of competing models. Norwood Hanson, Thomas Kuhn, Paul Feyerabend, and others have insisted that since our observations about the world may be theory-laden, decisions about what constitutes evidence will be determined by our theoretical prejudices.39 Indeed, to paraphrase Quine, “Our judgments about what there is are always embedded in some sort of theory; we can substitute one theory for another but we cannot detach ourselves from theory altogether and see the world unclouded by any preconception of it.”40 If competing theories reflect widely different values, there may be no neutral grounds for comparing their accuracy. In such cases the two theories are said to be incommensurate. Critics, however, have countered that the problems of theory-ladenness and incommensurability are greatly exaggerated. While it may be true that observations tend to be theory laden, this doesn’t mean that we can never distinguish observational terms from theoretical terms. Indeed, as Quine points out, “theoretical sentences grade off to observation sentences”; some observations come with
20
Explaining Tonality
negligible theoretical baggage, while others come with a lot.41 Compare, for example, the observation that the first movement of the “Eroica” Symphony begins with an E triad with the claim that the movement is “in” E. Whereas the former involves few theoretical assumptions and is readily apparent to most listeners, the latter is highly theory laden and presupposes an elaborate theory of key relations.42 But even though many of our observations are biased, theorists working with different frameworks are still able to reach some degree of consensus in specific cases. In this respect, the main issue is that of intersubjective testability rather than of objectivity per se. This notion of intersubjective testability through bias is most remarkable when the various biases are not only different, but also contradictory. I refer to this as ‘The Hostile Witness Principle.’ Very simply, this principle suggests that a particular claim gains force when it is confirmed by theories that are directly opposed to one another. Such situations often arise because, as Richard Boyd points out, “A particular experiment can be conducted on the basis of a methodology that—however theorydependent—is not committed to either of the two contesting theories.”43 The second criterion in figure I.10 is scope. Just as we want our theories to be as accurate as possible, so we also put a premium on their breadth of coverage. This means that, given two theories, we normally prefer the one that covers the larger array of pieces or wider range of properties, other things being equal. Perhaps the most common way to expand the scope of our theories is by subsuming hitherto separate theories under a single scheme. This is known as ‘Theory Reduction.’44 For example, if we proposed a theory of functional monotonality that subsumes the theory of tonal voice leading with the theory of functional monotonal harmony, then we should prefer it to a rival theory that explains only the behavior of tonal voice leading or that explains only the behavior of functional monotonal harmony. This does not mean, however, that generality is always a good thing; on the contrary, some theories are so general that they lose their explanatory force. That’s the snag with Anne Elk’s theory of the brontosaurus.45 While it may be true that the only thing common to all brontosauruses is that they “are
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
21
thin at one end, much, much thicker in the middle and then thin again at the far end,” this account is so general that it is trivial. The notion of ‘Theory Reduction’ has likewise been questioned. While there are certainly situations in which the model seems to apply, it does not explain every option. Kuhn, for example, has suggested that explanatory scope can expand through conceptual innovations or paradigm shifts, rather than the addition of new laws or the reduction of one theory into another.46 To overcome these difficulties Philip Kitcher and others have advocated the notion of ‘Theoretical Unification.’ According to Kitcher, the success of theories depends on “minimizing the number or patterns of derivation employed and maximizing the number of conclusions generated.”47 When evaluating the success of our theories, we do not simply want to keep duplicating results in familiar pieces; we also want to use our concepts, laws, and procedures to predict how things will behave in other, perhaps novel, works and disclose new phenomena or previously unnoted relationships among those already known.48 To do this, we must be able to predict every consequence and not merely a smattering of special cases.49 This idea represents the third criterion in figure I.10, namely fruitfulness. Very simply, given two theories of functional monotonality, we prefer the one that makes the more fruitful predictions, other things being equal. According to Kuhn, the criterion of fruitfulness “deserves more emphasis than it has yet received.”50 Just as it is hard to measure the accuracy of rival theories, it is also difficult to assess their fruitfulness, especially if the theories draw on widely different bodies of empirical data. This issue is troubling because successful theories often evolve considerably over time; it may take a long while for theorists to appreciate just how fruitful a theory may be and even longer to consider all of its ramifications. As a result, fruitfulness may not play a significant role when a theory is originally presented to the world but will become more significant as that theory matures. Whereas our first three criteria concern the drive for evidence, our fourth criterion concerns the drive for system. When formulating a music theory, we will want it to be as internally consistent as possible, other things being equal. Inconsistencies are bad because they prevent us from making concrete predictions; if we cannot make concrete predictions, then we cannot subject our work to
22
Explaining Tonality
rigorous testing, especially by other people. It is important to stress, however, that even internal consistency is a matter of degree; the more comprehensive our theories become, the less likely they are to be internally consistent. For example, although Schenker insisted that the process of composing out is bound to the laws of tonal voice leading and harmony, his graphs often violate the law prohibiting parallel perfect octaves and fifths. As we will see in chapters 2 and 3, this inconsistency has enormous consequences for understanding various tonal phenomena, especially sequences. Assuming one has satisfied the preceding constraints, the drive for system often prompts us to evaluate rival theories according to their complexity; as a rule we prefer a simple theory to a complicated one, other things being equal. This fifth criterion from figure I.10 is commonly known as Ockham’s Razor or ‘The Principle of Parsimony’ and is almost as old as theorizing itself.51 The rationale is obvious enough: the simpler the theory, the easier it is to apply and the less prone it is to error.52 Nevertheless, Ockham’s Razor can leave some scars. Simplicity is, to some extent, in the eye of the beholder; if taken to extremes it can end up being a downright liability.53 As we will see in chapter 1, the theory of functional equivalence seems to run afoul of this very issue. By restricting tonal harmonies to just three basic functions (tonic, dominant, and subdominant), the theory oversimplifies the richness of many tonal progressions. In such cases simplicity comes into conflict with other values, especially accuracy and scope. Finally, we come to the sixth criterion from figure I.10. Suppose that we are faced with two theories that are equivalent empirically and systematically, that is, both are equally accurate, both have a similar scope, both are fruitful, both are consistent to the same degree, and both are comparable in their level of simplicity. What grounds, then, do we have for picking one theory over the other? One answer is to see if they are coherent with theories in related disciplines, other things being equal.54 If, for example, one theory of functional monotonality is coherent with current theories of music cognition, whereas the other is not, then we have good reason for preferring the former to the latter. Conversely, if our theories cannot be embedded or made compatible with known principles of music cognition, then we have good reason to be suspicious of them.
Theoretical and Meta-Theoretical Issues
23
Of course, coherence between theories in different domains is an extremely difficult thing to achieve, especially since the two spheres of inquiry may have such different methodological bases; it is no easy task to find appropriate bridge laws that bind one discipline to another. Nevertheless, coherence is still a goal worth striving for. So far, we have sketched some general reasons for invoking the six criteria given in figure I.10. We have also seen that these criteria are often at odds and that theorists are often forced to trade one off against another. These last ideas are significant because they help us to explain how different theorists can reach a consensus on certain methodological issues without agreeing on the particulars of any given theory. The reason for this is simple: music theorists might evaluate theories according to the same criteria, but weight each one differently in any given context. Take, for example, the differences between Schenker’s original theory and that of his student, Felix Salzer.55 As we will see in chapter 1, Schenker put a premium on the accuracy of his model. He went to great lengths to make sure that he could explain the minutest details of tonal voice leading. But, to achieve such a high degree of precision, Schenker confined himself to functional monotonal music of the CommonPractice Period. Felix Salzer, meanwhile, focused his attention on explanatory scope; he wanted to explain the tonal properties of a broad spectrum of music from the Middle Ages to the Twentieth Century. To do this, Salzer had to modify many of Schenker’s ideas, thereby sacrificing much of their accuracy and predictive power. History has shown that Salzer’s trade was not worth the price. As time has gone by, music theorists have generally found Schenker’s approach more robust than Salzer’s. This seems in keeping with the general notion that theorists value accuracy most highly among the evidential values; once accuracy is gained, theorists are unwilling to relinquish it without a fight. Just as theorists seem to value accuracy over scope and fruitfulness, so they also seem to value consistency over simplicity and coherence. Again the rationale is clear. Consistency guarantees that claims can be tested inter subjectively; and inter subjective testability is one of the hallmarks of rational discourse. Simplicity, meanwhile, is an advantage in application, but it is ultimately much better to be complex and consistent than simple and inconsistent.
24
Explaining Tonality
Besides providing us with a mechanism for evaluating rival theories, we can also use the preceding model to explain how music theory might progress as a discipline. Now, there can be little doubt that “progress” has become something of a dirty word in musicological circles these days. Indeed, as Richard Taruskin notes, “Few historians today subscribe to overtly teleological or deterministic models.”56 The reasons for this are not hard to find. Recent scholarship has tended to focus on those properties of music whose significance depends on historical or social context. Once music is treated as a social construct, the notion of progress simply smacks of anachronism and cultural imperialism. Change, yes; progress, no. Yet, even if we balk at the idea of progress in musical composition, we may still accept the notion of progress in music theory. The two things are, in fact, quite different. Whereas the former is concerned with producing aesthetic experiences, the latter is concerned with producing knowledge and understanding. Knowledge and understanding are two things that can clearly improve. They progress when a community of theorists acknowledges that a new cluster of concepts, laws, and procedures is more accurate, more expansive, more fruitful, more consistent, more parsimonious, and more coherent than its predecessors. It is for these reasons that Schenker’s theory of functional monotonality is superior to its precursors. And we have every reason to suppose that even more successful theories of tonality will be developed in the future.
1
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy Of all epistemic values, none is more important to the music theorist than the quest for accuracy. Whether formulating concepts, developing explanatory laws, or devising effective procedures, music theorists always try to provide accurate accounts of the music they are analyzing. If their methods fall short, then they will try to devise new concepts, laws, and procedures that fulfill these expectations. And so it was for Heinrich Schenker. He began from the simple observation that the laws of strict counterpoint (or Der strenge Satz) are not accurate enough to explain the richness of functional tonality (or Der freie Satz). To account for these anomalies, he transformed the laws of strict counterpoint through the addition of functional harmonies, or Stufen. To quote from the Harmonielehre: “[Tonal] composition, then, appears as an extension of strict [counterpoint]: an extension with regard to both the quantity of [tonal] material and the principle of its motion. What is responsible for all these extensions is the concept of the Stufe.”1 Later, in Kontrapunkt I–II, he reiterated this view, claiming that functional relationships must be understood only as transformations or “prolongations” of strict counterpoint.2 As it stands, Schenker’s claim can be interpreted in two quite different ways. It could mean that the laws of strict counterpoint still operate in tonal contexts but, through the intervention of Stufen, they operate more freely. This interpretation is the one endorsed by most music theorists.3 The disadvantage with this view, however, is that functional tonality extends or transforms strict counterpoint is some ways, but not in others. If we generalize about when or why these extensions occur, then we inevitably end up proposing a new set of covering laws. This latter option is precisely the one shown in figure 1.1 (From strict counterpoint to functional
26
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.1. From strict counterpoint to functional tonality.
tonality). Quite simply, it takes certain basic principles of voice leading and interprets them in three different contexts; interpreting them within a world of intervals allows us to explain the behavior of strict two-voice counterpoint; interpreting them within a world of simple triads allows us to explain the behavior of strict three- and four-voice counterpoint; and interpreting them within a world of Stufen allows us to explain the behavior of functional tonality. To defend this second interpretation, this chapter begins by taking another look at the laws of strict counterpoint as presented
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
27
by Fux in Gradus ad Parnassum. Part 1 shows that, even in Fuxian Species counterpoint, the laws of strict counterpoint actually change as the individual lines become more elaborate and as their context changes from the intervallic world of two voices to the triadic world of three or more voices. Continuing Fux’s line of argument, part 2 shows how Schenker changed the laws still further when they operate in the context of functional tonality. We will refer to these changes as ‘The Heinrich Maneuver.’ Finally, part 3 demonstrates that Schenker’s laws of functional voice leading are intimately related to various laws of tonal harmony. We will refer to this interconnection between harmony and counterpoint as ‘The Complementarity Principle.’ The conclusion explores some ramifications of this argument; it suggests that, by eliminating some familiar anomalies from conventional theories of voice leading and harmony, Schenker upheld an utterly traditional epistemic value— the quest for accuracy.
Fux and Strict Counterpoint Few music theory treatises have been more influential than Johann Joseph Fux’s Gradus ad Parnassum.4 First published in 1725, this volume became an instant success, circulating throughout Europe both in its original Latin and in German, Italian, French, and English paraphrases and translations. Indeed, Fux’s discussion of species counterpoint not only shaped the thinking of composers such as Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven, but it also served as model for later treatises, such as Schenker’s Kontrapunkt.5 Yet, as Joel Lester and others have stressed, the Gradus stands out more for its pedagogical success than for the originality of its ideas. Fux is famous for his Five Species, but as Lester and others have shown, the notion of the species can be traced all the way back through Berardi’s Documenti armonici (1687) and Miscellanea musicale (1689, Book 1) to Bononcini’s Musico prattico (1673, 1688), Zacconi’s Prattica di musica seconda parte (1622), Diruta’s Il transilvano Part 2 (1609) and even to Lanfranco’s Scintille di musica (1533).6 Furthermore, these treatises endorse many of the same laws as texts written by Zarlino, Gaffurius, Guilielmus Monachus, Tinctoris, and Prosdocimus, to name but a few.
28
Explaining Tonality
When thinking about Fuxian species counterpoint, it is important to underscore a few basic points. First, like many of his predecessors, Fux distinguished between the artificial world of counterpoint and the real world of musical composition; in the former, notes are considered as abstract entities, independent of any motivic, rhythmic, or formal implications, but in the latter, they are understood in terms of their motivic, rhythmic, and formal function. Such distinctions are not, of course, unique to music theory. For example, physicists invariably begin by studying particular phenomena under idealized conditions with perfect vacuums and frictionless pulleys. Only when these simplified situations can be explained do they extend their arguments to cover real world situations where vacuums leak and pulleys move more erratically. Even when physicists model the real world, they do not mistake the model for the real thing. After all, when simulating nuclear reactions, researchers don’t expect to blow up their laboratories. Second, to explain the behavior of contrapuntal lines, Fux tried to formulate an explicit set of covering laws. These laws cover three main areas: 1) how individual lines move and reach closure; 2) how polyphonic lines move in relation to one another; and 3) how unstable (or dissonant) tones behave in relation to stable (or consonant) tones. Nevertheless, Fux’s generalizations are not as precise as we might like them to be: sometimes they are inconsistent and sometimes they are demonstrably incomplete. For example, Lester has noted that Fux’s treatments of raised leading tones and melodic tritones are contradictory.7 Meanwhile, David Lewin has proposed a new ‘Global Rule’ which states that “for every note X of the counterpoint line lying above (below) the cadence tone, some note lying one step lower (higher) than X must appear in the line at some point subsequent to X.”8 Lewin also claims that the counterpoint should not be “overarticulated by a strong closure before the final cadence is reached.”9 Third, even within the realm of strict counterpoint, Fux assumed that the behavior of contrapuntal lines changes as the individual lines become more elaborate and as the number of voices increases from two to three or more. To explain changes of the first type, Fux used the notion of the species. He identified five distinct species, with First Species corresponding to simple note-against-note
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
29
counterpoint and Fifth Species to florid counterpoint. Second, Third, and Fourth Species are intermediate stages that introduce progressively more complex dissonances: Second Species introduces the passing tone, Third Species, the nota cambiata, and Fourth Species, the suspension. To deal with changes of the second type, Fux systematically discussed all five species, first in two voices, then in three, and then in four. Let us now look at these changes in more detail, starting with First Species in two voices. When we think about First Species counterpoint, it is important to begin by considering the structure of the cantus firmus. For convenience, these are presented in figure 1.2 (Fuxian cantus firmi). According to Fux, the six tunes shown in figure 1.2a epitomize the principles of good melodic writing. Globally, each one constitutes a single phrase of music; each has a clearly defined beginning, a single climax, and an emphatic cadence at the end. They are also clearly modal; each one begins and ends on a given modal final and each one is strictly diatonic. Locally, Fux’s cantus firmi primarily move by half or whole step, they avoid successive unisons, and they avoid leaps of a seventh or diminished/ augmented intervals, as well as consecutive leaps in the same direction (see figure 1.2b). These simple observations are expressed as general laws in figure 1.2c. These laws set out to explain why particular notes appear in a given cantus firmus and why they behave in specific ways and not others. For convenience these laws are classified in several ways. On the one hand, figure 1.2c distinguishes between main laws, which explain what normally happens in a melody, and subordinate laws, which explain significant exceptions to the norm. On the other hand, it distinguishes between local laws, which operate from one note to the next, and global laws, which operate across the melody as a whole. Turning to figure 1.3 (First Species counterpoint), we see that First Species counterpoints resemble cantus firmi in some ways but not others. Like a cantus firmus, each counterpoint in figure 1.3a forms a single coherent phrase with a clear beginning, a welldefined climax, and a stepwise motion onto the final cadence. Locally, it primarily moves by whole- or half-step and uses leaps only sparingly (see figure 1.3b). Unlike a cantus firmus, however, the counterpoint contains repeated notes (e.g., B in mm. 8–9) and
30
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.2. Fuxian cantus firmi. a. Fux’s prototypical cantus firmi.
b. Interval content. Melody 1 Melody 2 Melody 3 Melody 4 Melody 5 Melody 6
U m2 M2 m3 M3 P4 A4 P5 m6 M6 m7 M7 P8 – 2 5 1 1 1 – – – – – – – – 2 3 2 1 – – – – – – – 1 – 1 5 2 2 – – 1 – – – – – – 1 4 2 3 3 – – – – – – – – 4 4 2 1 – – – – – – – – – 3 4 2 1 1 – – – – – – –
Total 10 9 11 13 11 11
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
31
Figure 1.2. (continued). c. Laws of melodic motion/closure for a cantus firmus. If a cantus firmus is perfectly closed, then it begins on 1 and ends 2–1.
GM
If a cantus firmus moves from one note to another, then successive notes are usually a whole- or a half-step apart and never repeat the same note.
LM
If leaps do occur, then they are never larger than an octave and never encompass diminished/augmented intervals or the interval of a seventh.
LS
(G⫽global, L⫽local, M⫽main, S⫽subordinate)
ends by ascending chromatically G–A at the final cadence.10 Since Fux promoted the independence of lines, he put a premium on contrary motion between the cantus firmus and the counterpoint (see figure 1.3c). At cadences, for example, the final perfect consonance is always approached in contrary motion from the nearest imperfect consonance, either with a major sixth expanding to an octave or a minor third contracting to a unison. Furthermore, Fux insisted that when the cantus firmus and counterpoint do move in the same direction, they can never produce parallel or direct perfect octaves and fifths between successive notes. Figure 1.3d also shows that First Species counterpoints are always consonant with the cantus firmus; we will refer to this idea as ‘The Consonance Constraint.’ According to Fux, unisons, octaves, fifths, and their compounds are classified as perfect consonances, whereas thirds, sixths, and their compounds are classified as imperfect consonances. All other intervals, seconds, fourths, sevenths, and their compounds plus all diminished/augmented intervals, are counted as dissonant. Although figure 1.3d suggests that First Species textures often include more imperfect than perfect consonances, Fux insisted that the cantus firmus and the counterpoint always begin and end on perfect consonances. These generalizations are presented as covering laws in figure 1.3e. Once again, these laws are classified as main or subordinate and as local or global.
32
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.3. First Species counterpoint. a. Prototypical counterpoint in First Species.
b. Interval content of the counterpoint. U m2 M2 m3 M3 P4 A4 1 3 3 2 – 1 –
P5 –
m6 1
M6 –
m7 –
c. Relative motion between cantus firmus and counterpoint. Contrary Oblique Similar Parallel 3 6 1 1 1 d. Vertical intervals between cantus firmus and counterpoint. U 2 3 4 A4 5 6 – – 4 – – 1 5 e. Laws of melodic motion/closure for a counterpoint. If a counterpoint is perfectly closed, then it begins on 8 or 5 and ends 7–1.
GM
If a counterpoint moves from one note to another, then successive notes are usually a whole- or a half-step apart, though they can occasionally repeat the same note.
LM
If leaps occur, then they are never larger than an octave and never encompass diminished/augmented intervals or the interval of a seventh.
LS
If leaps occur, then they seldom appear consecutively in the same direction and are normally approached/departed by step in the opposite direction.
LS
(G⫽global, L⫽local, M⫽main, S⫽subordinate)
M7 –
P8 –
Parallel 6 2
7 –
8 2
Total 11
Total 11
Total 12
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
33
Figure 1.4. Prototypical counterpoints in Fifth Species. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Figs. 82 and 87.
Significant as they may be, the differences in behavior between cantus firmi and simple counterpoints are less pronounced than those between simple and florid counterpoints. We can see this very clearly by comparing the examples in figure 1.3 with those in figures 1.4a–b (Prototypical counterpoints in Fifth Species). For example, whereas the counterpoint in figure 1.3 has only one note for every member of the cantus firmus, those in figures 1.4a and 1.4b have up to four. And, unlike the counterpoint in figure 1.3, the one in figure 1.4a crosses the cantus firmus (e.g., m. 2) and includes the chromatic tone B (e.g., m. 5). But the most striking difference between the counterpoints in figure 1.3 and those in figures 1.4a and 1.4b is that the latter are no longer strictly consonant with the cantus firmus. In fact, we find three specific forms of dissonance (see figure 1.5, Dissonances in florid counterpoint). First there is the passing tone. These dissonances move by step in a single direction between two consonances a third apart. For example, in figure 1.4a, the dissonant E in m. 2 passes by step from D to F. Although passing tones usually move between two adjacent consonances, they can appear consecutively: if, for example, the cantus firmus holds the note B, the counterpoint can descend by step from the sixth G, through the diminished fifth F and perfect fourth E onto a third D.11 Fux’s second type of dissonance is the nota cambiata.12 Whereas passing
34
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.5. Dissonances in florid counterpoint. Passing tone
Nota cambiata
Appears on beat 2 and moves by step between two consonances a third apart.
Second Species
Two/three notes in the counterpoint against one in cantus firmus.
Appears on beats 2, 3, and 4. Consecutive passing tones of a diminished fifth and a perfect fourth can appear on beats 2 and 3.
Third Species
Four notes in the counterpoint against one in the cantus firmus.
Appears on beat 2, a step below consonance on beat 1 and leaps to a consonance a third below on beat 3.
Third Species
Four notes in the counterpoint against one in the cantus firmus.
Fourth Species
Two notes in the counterpoint against one in the cantus firmus.
Lower neighbor can sometimes appear on beat 2. Suspension
Appears on beat 1. Sounds as a consonance on previous weak beat and resolves onto a consonance a step below.
tones always move by step, the cambiata is approached by step and departed by leap. Consider figure 1.4b, m. 2. Here, the dissonant G on beat 2 is preceded by a consonant A and followed by a consonant E. The third type of dissonance is the suspension. Whereas passing tones and cambiatas fill in the space between two consonances, suspensions displace one strand of counterpoint against another. This is clear in the final cadence from figure 1.4a. Here the two voices basically move in parallel sixths F/D–E/C before arriving on the octave D/D. The suspension is formed when the consonant D of the counterpoint in m. 10 is displaced over E in the cantus firmus on the down beat of m. 11. Having become dissonant, D finally descends onto the consonant C at the end of the bar. Since suspensions stem from displacements rather than diminutions, Fux classified them as essential dissonances and passing tones/cambiata
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
35
as non-essential dissonances.13 That being said, figure 1.4a contains several cases where the resolution of a suspension can be ornamented by step (e.g., mm. 7–8) or by leap (e.g., mm. 8–9). So far, we have noted that the behavior of intervals can be specified precisely in two-voice counterpoint: consonances (unisons, octaves, fifths, thirds, sixths, and their compounds) are stable and control the contrapuntal motion, whereas dissonances (seconds, fourths, sevenths, and their compounds, as well as all augmented and diminished intervals) are unstable and play a subordinate role. But Fux realized that when two, three, or more counterpoints are added to a cantus firmus, the behavior of these additional lines changes even more: “as the number of voices increases, [so] the rules are to be less rigorously observed.”14 According to him, these changes occur because three-voice textures are no longer controlled by intervals per se, but rather by specific amalgamations of intervals known as triads: “[T]he harmonic triad should be employed in every measure if there is no special reason against it.”15 We will refer to this idea as ‘The Triadic Constraint.’ According to Fux, harmonic triads are three-note collections that include unisons, thirds, fifths, or octaves above a given bass note. According to this definition, diminished triads are not harmonic triads, nor are so-called first- and second-inversion triads. There are, in fact, only twelve harmonic triads within the modal system: these are listed at the top of figure 1.6 (Triads in three- and four-voice textures). Significantly, Triads 1–8 contain members of the Gamut; some include only the white notes, while the others include B. Meanwhile, Triads 9–12 contain the chromatic notes C, F, and G; they normally appear at cadences in Dorian, Mixolydian, and Aeolian modes. Fux sometimes replaced the diminished triad B–D–F with the minor triad B–D–F, especially in Mixolydian mode. Although Triads 13–17 are not harmonic triads per se, they appear in figure 1.6 because they do occur at cadences; the diminished triads D–F–B and G–B–E contain members of the Gamut, whereas the others use the chromatic tones C, F, and G. The shift from the intervallic world of two-voice counterpoint to the triadic world of three- and four-voice counterpoint has several important implications. For one thing, it erodes the distinction
36
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.6. Triads in three- and four-voice textures. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
C D E F G G A B
E F G A B B C D
G* A* B* C* D* D* E* F*
Major Minor Minor Major Major Minor Minor Major
5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3
9. 10. 11. 12.
D E A B
F G C D
A* B* E* F*
Major Major Major Minor
5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3 5/3 or 6/3
[Mixolydian] [Aeolian] [Dorian] [113–114]
13. 14. 15. 16. 17.
D G E A B
F B G C D
B E C F G
Diminished Diminished Diminished Diminished Diminished
6/3 6/3 6/3 6/3 6/3
[Dorian] [Mixolydian] [Aeolian]
* ⫽ Fux’s harmonic triads
between perfect and imperfect consonances. We have already seen that two-voice textures always begin and end on perfect consonances. This, however, is no longer the case in three- and four-voice textures. As shown in figure 1.7 (First Species in three voices), threevoice textures often begin and end on imperfect consonances: figures 1.7a and 1.7b both open with sonorities that contain the third, but not the fifth and figure 1.7c begins and ends in the same way. The only time when Fux still favors perfect over imperfect consonances is in the final cadence; figure 1.7a ends on bare octaves and figure 1.7b ends on an octave plus a fifth. Besides weakening the distinction between perfect and imperfect consonances, ‘The Triadic Constraint’ also blurs the distinction between consonant and dissonant intervals. Since the behavior of intervals is determined from the bass, the upper voices can be consonant with the bass and dissonant among themselves. The cadence in figure 1.7b offers a good case in point. Although perfect and augmented fourths are always dissonant in two-voice counterpoint, they behave as consonances when they appear
37 Figure 1.7. First Species in three voices. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Figs. 104, 105, 106.
38
Explaining Tonality
between the upper voices in three- and four-voice contexts. In this case, the final measures contain the perfect fourth A–D followed by an augmented fourth G–C. Since the behavior of the fourth depends upon its harmonic context, the distinction between harmonic and non-harmonic tones starts to be more significant in threeand four-voice textures than the distinction between consonance and dissonance. The significance of ‘The Triadic Constraint’ is easy to see in figure 1.8 (Cadence patterns in two, three, and four voices). In two-voice textures, cadences are normally marked by a stepwise descent 3– 2– 1 in the cantus firmus and a stepwise motion 1– 7– 1 in the counterpoint (see figures 1.8a–b). Since it does not matter whether the counterpoint is above or below the cantus firmus, these lines are completely invertible at the octave. But in threevoice textures, things are more complicated. Using our two-voice cadence as a prototype, figures 1.8c–e show what happens when the third voice is added to them. If the cantus firmus is in the bass, then the third voice usually contains the notes 5–4– 5 or 5–4– 3 (see figures 1.8c and 1.8d). Significantly, this new line is only partially invertible at the octave: it can appear above or below the counterpoint 1– 7– 1, but never below the cantus firmus. This is because 5 creates a dissonant fourth with 1. If, however, the third voice is added below the two-voice prototype (see figure 1.8e), then it typically leaps 1–5– 1. Unlike the other voices, this one is never invertible at the octave; on the contrary, it is the quintessential bass part and as such is quite different in character from the cantus firmus and the other counterpoint. Figure 1.8f then shows how these prototypical voice-leading patterns normally appear in four-voice cadences. ‘The Triadic Constraint’ has other effects on the behavior of contrapuntal lines. In two-voice textures, counterpoints rarely contain consecutive leaps in the same direction, but in three- and four-voice textures, such phenomena are actually quite common. Figure 1.7c offers us some good examples: in mm. 5–9 the middle counterpoint leaps from F via C to E and back through C to A, and in mm. 2–5, the lowest counterpoint leaps from F to D to A to F. We can find similar adjustments to the laws of relative motion (see figure 1.9, Parallel and direct perfect octaves and fifths in three and
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
39
Figure 1.8. Cadence patterns in two, three, and four voices. Two-voice cadences.
Both voices are completely invertible at the octave. Three-voice cadences.
3–2–1 and 1–7–1 are completely invertible at the octave, 5–4–3 is partially invertible at the octave (never in bass), and 1–5–1 is never invertible at the octave (only in bass). Four-voice cadences.
3–2–1 and 1–7–1 are completely invertible at the octave, 5– 4 –3 is partially invertible at the octave (never in bass), and 1–5–1 is never invertible at the octave (only in bass).
four voices). In two-voice contexts, for example, parallel perfect octaves and fifths do not occur between successive down beats when they are separated by a falling third (see figures 1.9a and 1.9b). Yet they can occur in three- or four-voice textures, “for the sake of the harmonic triad” (see figures 1.9c and 1.9d). Notice, too, that repeated tones and consecutive leaps appear in both of the counterpoints. The preceding discussion has shown that, even according to Fux, the laws of strict counterpoint change as the individual lines become more elaborate and as their context changes from a texture
40
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.9. Parallel and direct perfect octaves and fifths in two, three and four voices. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Figs. 29, 27, 28, 120, 173.
with two-voices to one with three or more voices. This is because two-voice textures are controlled by ‘The Consonance Constraint,’ whereas three- and four-voice textures are controlled by ‘The Triadic Constraint.’ As these contexts change, so the laws of voice leading change as well. But, as Fux was fully aware, species counterpoint is still several steps removed from actual tonal practice. We are left to wonder how the laws of strict counterpoint must be altered to account for the idiosyncrasies of functional tonality.
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
41
Figure 1.9 (continued).
“The Heinrich Maneuver” One writer who specifically addressed this issue was Heinrich Schenker. In his Harmonielehre (1906) and Kontrapunkt I–II (1910, 1922), he demonstrated that, in functional contexts, the behavior of lines is influenced by a new condition, which we will refer to as ‘The Stufe Constraint.’ As he explained in the Harmonielehre: “[Tonal] composition differs from strict counterpoint, in so far as the former possesses Stufen, which articulate its content, and in so far as [they] allow for a much wider range of freedom in voice-leading.”16 He added: Where in strict [counterpoint], we have notes consonant to those of the cantus firmus, we have, in [tonal] composition, the Stufe. Where, in strict [counterpoint], we have a dissonant passing tone, we have, in [tonal] composition, free voice-leading, a series of intermediate chords, unfolding in free motion.17
According to him, “Stufen then resemble powerful projector lights: in their illuminated sphere the parts go through their evolution in a higher and freer contrapuntal sense, uniting in [discrete harmonies], which, however, never become [an] end in themselves but
42
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.10. Differences in the behavior of triads and Stufen. a, b. Influence of Stufen on harmonic progressions. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Figs. 118, 117.
Reordering of diminutions. c. First Species.
d. Third Species.
e. Tonal Counterpoint.
always result from the free movement.”18 For convenience we will classify these extensions of strict counterpoint under the rubric of ‘The Heinrich Maneuver.’ This point is clarified in figure 1.10 (Differences in behavior of triads and Stufen). Take, for example, the passages shown in figures 1.10a and 1.10b. Although both satisfy the laws of strict counterpoint and are triadic, the progression I–II–I6 in figure 1.10a is extremely rare in tonal contexts, whereas the progression I6–VII6–I
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
43
in figure 1.10b is very common. This suggests that there may be constraints on what strings of triads can appear in tonal contexts. These constraints are connected with chord function. Figures 1.10c to 1.10e show another important difference. Figure 1.10c gives a simple cadence in First Species. Although there are many ways in which this pattern can be elaborated in Third Species, Fux insisted that the final 1 must always be preceded by 7 (see figure 1.10d). In functional tonal composition, however, this cadence pattern can be transformed in other ways (see figure 1.10e). Assuming that this cadence articulates the progression I6–VII6–I, then the upper voice actually implies two strands of counterpoint: a soprano voice that moves 1–7– 1 and an alto voice that descends 5–4 – 3. In other words, it is a so-called polyphonic or compound melody. The descending line 7–6 – 5–4 actually connects the soprano voice C with the alto voice G. Since the measure expands a single Stufe, the soprano C need not sound on the final beat; according to Schenker, this pitch is “mentally retained” throughout the entire measure before it resolves onto D. But what exactly are Stufen and how do they influence tonal voice leading? Very simply, whereas triads are merely collections of stacked thirds and fifths, Stufen are triads that function within a tonality, this function being indicated by a Roman numeral. For us to assign a Roman numeral to a given triad, we must be able to show that triad is related to the tonic. The notion of functionality helps to explain why some chord strings are possible in tonal contexts and others are not. As shown in figure 1.11(The major-minor system), Schenker acknowledged that there are seven possible Stufen. In major keys, I, IV, and V Stufen are represented by major triads; II, III, and VI Stufen by minor triads; and the VII Stufe by a diminished triad (see figure 1.11a). Meanwhile, in minor keys I, IV, and V Stufen are represented by minor triads; II, III, VI, and VII Stufen by major triads; and the II Stufe by a diminished triad (see figure 1.11b). Schenker invoked the concept of simple mixture to swap triads between parallel keys and the concept of secondary mixture to change the qualities of II, III, VI, and VII in major, and II, III, VI, and VII in minor.19 These are shown in figures 1.11c and 1.11d. According to Schenkerian theory, double mixture allows the composer to borrow triads from the parallel key and change their
44
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.11. The major-minor system. Mixture is a transformation that allows us to move from one quadrant to another: simple mixture allows us to move from one diatonic quadrant to another; secondary mixture allows us to move from a given diatonic quadrant to its secondary; double mixture allows us to move from a given diatonic quadrant via the other diatonic quadrant to the other secondary quadrant. Major
Minor o
o
a. Diatonic
|I, ii, iii, IV, V, vi, vii
|
i, II, ii , III, iv, v, VI, VII| b. Diatonic
c. Secondary
|I, II, III, IV, V, VI, vii, VII
|
i, ii, iio, iii, iv, v, vi, vii | d. Secondary
Tonicization is a transformation that derives the missing triads by shifting locally to another major-minor system. Diminished triads serve as position finders in the new system: iº iiº iiiº iiiº ivº ivº/vº iv/v IV/V vº viº viº viiº
viiº/II, iiº/vii viiº/II, iio/vii viiº/III, iiº/ii viiº/IV, iiº/ii viiº/IV(V), iiº/iii viiº/V, iiº/iii iv/II, iii/II, iii/III, ii/III, ii/IV, vii/V, vii/VI, vi/VI, vi/VII, v/VII IV/II, III/II, III/III, II/III, II/IV, VII/V, VII/VI, VI/VI, VI/VII, V/VII viiº/VI, iiº/iv viiº/VI, iiº/iv(v) viiº/VII, iiº/v viiº/VII, iiº/vi
quality. Since diminished triads appear only as VII in major keys and II in minor, they serve as position finders; for example, instead of treating the diminished triad C–E–G as io in C major-minor, we can regard it either as VII of D major or as II of B minor.20 Although figure 1.11 covers a wide range of Stufen, it does not include those on IV/V. This omission suggests that these Stufen cannot be derived directly from the tonic by mixtures. Instead, Schenkerian theory explains them by another process, tonicization. Tonicization allows an individual note or Stufe to function temporarily as a tonic and, in so doing, implies that the piece temporarily shifts to a new major-minor system. For example, to generate the major triads F–A–C and G–B–D in C major, we must temporarily shift to a new key; these triads can then arise as the subdominant of D major (IV/II), the dominant of B major (V/VII), the Phrygian II of F minor (II/IV), the mediant of E minor (III/III), the submediant
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
45
Figure 1.12. Laws of melodic motion and closure. a. Fux’s Laws of Strict Counterpoint
b. Revised Laws of Tonality
If the cantus firmus is perfectly closed, then it begins on 1 and ends 2–1.
GM
If a melody is perfectly closed, then it begins on 8 , 5 , or 3 , and ends 2 –1.
If a cantus firmus moves from one note to another, then successive notes are usually a whole- or a half-step apart and never repeat the same note.
LM
If a melody moves from one note to another, then successive notes are usually a step apart.
If leaps do occur, then they are never larger than an octave and never encompass diminished/augmented intervals or the interval of a seventh.
LS
If leaps occur, then they do so when the melody shifts from one harmonic tone to another or from one contrapuntal voice to another.
If leaps occur, then they seldom appear successively in the same direction and are normally approached/departed by step in the opposite direction.
LS
(G⫽global, L⫽local, M⫽main, S⫽subordinate)
of B minor (VI/VII), or as the sub-tonic of A minor (VII/VI). In other words, although it is impossible to generate Stufen on IV/ V directly from the tonic, they can be generated indirectly from I as II/IV, II/III, III/III, III/II, IV/II, V/VII, VI/VII, VI/VI, or VII/VI. Elsewhere, Douglas Dempster, Dave Headlam, and I have referred to this idea as ‘The IV/V Hypothesis.’21 We believe that ‘The IV/V Hypothesis’ is sufficiently well confirmed to stand as a subordinate law of functional harmony. Having introduced Stufen into the mix, we can now assess their impact on tonal voice leading. Figures 1.12a–b (Laws of melodic motion and closure) compare Fux’s laws of strict counterpoint with Schenker’s laws of tonal voice leading. Starting with the structure of melodic lines, it is clear that although Schenker certainly accepted that functional tonal melodies mostly move by whole- or half-steps and normally end by descending 2 to 1 (this is part of what he meant by the term melodic fluency or Der fliessende Gesang), he also recognized that this motion is controlled by ‘The Stufe Constraint.’22 Indeed, Schenker went so far as to claim that “all melody is the composing-out of sonorities.”23 Since Stufen can only be expressed
46
Explaining Tonality
by major, minor, and diminished triads, it follows that melodic motion must always occur between triadic intervals, such as thirds, fourths, fifths, sixths, and octaves. Now the condition “between tones of the tonic triad” in the law of melodic motion forces us to change both of our main laws: globally, the essential melody need not begin on 1; it can now start on 5 and 3; locally, since 2 and 1 cannot be members of the same Stufe, the melody must end with the step wise descent 3– 2– 1. Of course, if melodies ultimately descend from 3, then they can immediately be classified as major or minor. By dropping the phrase “whole- or half-steps” the new law also allows for steps of an augmented second, provided that they appear between harmonic tones. Among other things, this means that lines can skip from 6 to 7 in progressions from II6 to V.24 Once the preceding adjustments have been made, we can explain how melodic leaps arise in functional triadic contexts. First of all, they can occur when the essential melody moves from one harmonic tone to another. The opening theme from the first movement of Beethoven’s “Eroica” Symphony is just such a melody: it arpeggiates the tones of the tonic triad E–G–E–B–E–G–B–E.25 Notice how this theme contains several consecutive leaps in the same direction. But melodic leaps can also occur when the essential melody moves to another voice in the essential counterpoint. This process gives rise to polyphonic or compound melodies. We can illustrate this idea in figure 1.13 (Polyphonic melodies) by comparing the Sarabande and Double from Bach’s Partita No. 1 for Solo Violin, BWV 1002. As shown in figure 1.13a, the Sarabande is a polyphonic composition built from at least four lines of counterpoint. Sometimes the four voices are given explicitly, such as at the start of the piece, but more often they are implied by the laws of tonal counterpoint. For example, since we know that tonal harmonies must always contain the third of the chord we know the dominant triad in m. 8 must have an A in the tenor voice. And, since it seems likely that the final B in m. 7 belongs to the alto voice, we can infer that the tonic chord at the start of m. 7 has B as its alto. Meanwhile, figure 1.13b shows how the Double horizontalizes this four-voice framework to create a seamless polyphonic melody. In other words, the prominent leaps of the Double are created by moving between different contrapuntal voices of the Sarabande.
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
47
Figure 1.13. Polyphonic melodies. a. Bach, Partita No. 1 for Solo Violin, BWV 1002, Sarabande, mm. 1–8.
b. Bach, Partita No. 1 for Solo Violin, BWV 1002, Sarabande: Double, mm. 1–8.
Just as Schenker used ‘The Stufe Constraint’ to explain why melodies behave differently in strict counterpoint than in functional tonality, so he also used it to explain anomalies in the relative motion between lines. Schenker was quite adamant that tonal counterpoint mostly moves by contrary or oblique motion and that
48
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.14. Parallels by doubling and figuration. Beethoven, Piano Sonata, Op. 2, no. 3, 1st movement, mm. 47–51. From Schenker ed., Brahms Octaven und Quinten, Ex. 5a.
the foreground “fundamentally prohibits parallel octaves and fifths.”26 But he also recognized that parallel perfect octaves or fifths sometimes occur in actual tonal pieces; in fact, he reconsidered almost 100 of the 140 or so examples cataloged in Brahms’s famous study Oktaven und Quinten.27 According to him, these anomalous parallels arise in two distinct ways. First, they stem from unessential voices. Figure 1.14 (Parallels by doubling and figuration) gives a simple illustration. This short extract from the first movement of Beethoven’s Piano Sonata, Op. 2, no. 3, contains two sets of parallel perfect octaves between the tenor and the bass, B/B–C/C in mm. 48–49 and A/A–B/B in mm. 50–51. These are marked by the parallel lines in the musical example. But, according to Schenker, these parallel octaves actually arise from doubling.28 The melody in the right hand is actually polyphonic: the soprano voice descends from D (m. 48) through C (m. 50) to an implied B (m. 51); the alto voice descends from B (mm. 47–48) through A (mm. 49–50) to G (m. 51); and the tenor voice articulates the neighbor motion G (mm. 47–48) F (mm. 49–50) G (m. 51). The imitation of the melody in the bass clef (m. 48ff.) simply doubles this counterpoint. Second, parallel perfect octaves and fifths can arise from unessential tones. In Der freie Satz, Schenker listed the following possibilities: a principal note with an accented or unaccented passing tone or with a neighboring note; a passing tone with an anticipation, with an accented passing tone, or with a neighboring note; a neighboring note with another neighboring note, with the concluding turn of a trill, or with a suspension; the resolution of a suspension with a passing tone, with another suspension, and so forth.29
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
49
Figure 1.15. Parallels by combinations of harmonic and non-harmonic tones. a. Passing tone with anticipation. Bach, St. Matthew Passion, Part 2, No. 16, m. 8. From Schenker ed., Brahms Octaven und Quinten, Ex. 29.
b. Accented and unaccented passing tones. Cherubini, Missa Solemnis in D Minor, Kyrie 2, mm. 70–73. From Schenker ed., Brahms Octaven und Quinten, Ex. 55.
c. Simultaneous neighbor tones. Mozart, Cosi fan tutti, Act 2, No. 19, m. 22. From Schenker ed., Brahms Octaven und Quinten, Ex. 53.
Figure 1.15 (Parallels by combinations of harmonic and nonharmonic tones) illustrates some of these configurations.30 In figure 1.15a, for example, the parallel perfect fifths B/E–A/D arise from a passing motion E–D–C in the tenor voice combined with an anticipation A in the soprano. Similarly, the parallel perfect fifths C/F–B/E in figure 1.15b occur because the soprano passes from C
50
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.16. Laws of relative motion and closure. If a counterpoint is perfectly closed, then it begins on 8 or 5 and ends 7–1.
GM
If a texture is perfectly closed, then the melody begins on 8, 5, or 3 and ends 2–1 , the alto ends 7 –1 , the tenor ends 5–4–3, and the bass leaps 5–1.
If a counterpoint moves from one note to another, then it mainly moves in contrary motion with the cantus firmus.
LM
If the contrapuntal lines move from one note to another, then they mainly move in contrary motion or in parallel thirds or sixths.
If a counterpoint and the cantus firmus move in the same direction, then parallel perfect octaves and fifths do not occur between successive notes.
LS
If two essential lines move in the same direction, then parallel perfect octaves and fifths do not occur between successive harmonic tones.
LS
If parallel perfect octaves and fifths occur, then they arise from doubling/figuration or from combinations of harmonic and non-harmonic tones.
(G⫽global, L⫽local, M⫽main, S⫽subordinate)
to A, whereas the alto passes from G to C. Finally, figure 1.15c shows how parallel perfect fifths arise when an accented neighbor tone C sounds against the chord tone F. Taking these various cases into account, we can revise our subordinate laws (see figure 1.16, Laws of relative motion and closure). These new laws state: “[I]f two essential lines move in the same direction, then parallel perfect octaves and fifths do not occur between successive harmonic tones”; and “[I]f parallel perfect octaves and fifths occur, then they arise from doubling/figuration or from complex combinations of harmonic and non-harmonic tones.” In other words, permissible parallels arise from complexities in the voice leading: “It is as if two people who have no contact with one another simply pass in the street without an exchange of greetings.”31 With regard to the behavior of unstable/stable tones, Fux’s laws again differ from Schenker’s (see figure 1.17,). Like Fux before him, Schenker certainly believed that Laws of vertical alignment consonances are more fundamental than dissonances. As he put it,
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
51
Figure 1.17. Laws of vertical alignment. If a counterpoint is added above or below a cantus firmus, then it always begins/ends on a perfect consonance.
GM
If contrapuntal lines are added to a melody, then they normally begin and end on members of the tonic triad.
If the counterpoint moves from one note to another, then each note is normally consonant with the cantus firmus.
LM
If the contrapuntal lines move from one note to another, then each verticality is basically triadic.
If dissonances occur, then they move by step to and/or from consonances.
LS
If non-harmonic tones occur, then they move by step between harmonic tones or by leap between contrapuntal lines.
(G⫽global, L⫽local, M⫽main, S⫽subordinate)
“[C]onsonance manifests an absolute character, dissonance, on the contrary, a merely relative and derivative one: in the beginning is consonance! The consonance is primary, the dissonance is secondary!”32 Nevertheless, one of the most important consequences of ‘The Stufe Constraint’ is that it erodes the distinction between consonance and dissonance. Indeed, figure 1.18 (Consonant non-harmonic tones and dissonant harmonic tones) shows that functional tonality not only contains dissonant harmonic tones, but also consonant nonharmonic tones. Figures 1.18b and 1.18c give two examples of the former; according to Schenker, the VII Stufe in figure 1.18b and the II Stufe in figure 1.18c may be diminished, but are treated as if they are consonant.33 Meanwhile, figure 1.18a gives a good example of a consonant non-harmonic tone: the pitch A in m. 1 serves as a passing tone, even though it is consonant with the bass. Schenker, however, tried to go one stage further by suggesting that all non-harmonic tones stem from passing motion. In Kontrapunkt I, for example, he noted that “the apparently free dissonance must be understood as the clearly established internal element of a latent passing motion.”34 This is shown in figure 1.19 (Neighbor tones and suspensions as passing motions). As shown in figure 1.19a, he suggested that the neighbor motion C–D–C is a transformation of the passing motion C–D–E, while in figure 1.19b he proposed that
52
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.18. Consonant non-harmonic tones and dissonant harmonic tones.
Figure 1.19. Neighbor tones and suspensions as passing motions. a. Schenker, Kontrapunkt II, Ex. 123.
b. Schenker, Kontrapunkt I, Ex. 400.
the suspension C–B is a transformation of the passing motion D–C–B.35 Later, in volume 2 of Der Tonwille (1921), he reiterated his claim that non-harmonic tones arise from passing motion: Consonance lives in the triad, dissonance in [the] passing [tone]. From the triad and from passing [tone] stem all the phenomena of tonal life: the triad can become a Stufe, the passing tone can be modified to become a neighbor
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
53
note or accented passing tone, anticipation, a dissonant syncopation, and the seventh of a chord.36
But by the time Schenker completed Der freie Satz, he had softened his position; in par. 66 he claimed that “the dissonance appears only as a passing tone or as a syncopation,” and in par. 106–12 he included neighbor motion as an independent transformation.37 Now he simply claimed that “the traversal of the Urlinie is the most basic of all passing motions.”38 Given that non-harmonic tones arise from step motion between harmonic tones, how do we explain cambiatas, appoggiaturas, changing notes, and other leaping dissonances? Once again, Schenkerian theory offers two types of explanation. The first relies on implied tones. In figure 1.20a (Chopin’s Mazurka, Op. 30, no. 4, mm. 129–30), Schenker explained in his graph the string of parallel seventh chords by invoking implied suspensions.39 The second explanation treats leaping dissonances as byproducts of motion between polyphonic voices. We can see how this might work in figure 1.20b. Here the nota cambiata is explained in terms of an implied motion to an inner voice: the alto voice passes B–C–D, while the soprano temporarily moves down through D to hit the alto C. Schenkerian theory uses much the same strategy to explain the behavior of consecutive non-harmonic tones. Although such things rarely occur in strict counterpoint, they are a dime a dozen in tonal composition. As John Rothgeb has pointed out, “The linear progression is but an extension of the basic passing-tone concept of second species counterpoint in that it allows for passing motions within larger intervals than a third.”40 Sometimes, however, consecutive non-harmonic tones arise from motion between different polyphonic voices. For example, a double neighbor tone C–B–D–C might be derived from flipping between the soprano and alto voices: in this case, the B might belong to the alto line, whereas the D might belong to the soprano. Rothgeb cites a more extreme example from Schenker’s unpublished Generalbasslehre that seems to contain adjacent seventh chords (see figure 1.21, Consecutive seventh chords). According to Schenker, this passage, “basically reduces to an 8–7 motion [above a stationary bass]; but the passing tone [A] in the bass disguises this
54
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.20. Implied tones and the nota cambiata. a. Implied tones. Chopin, Mazurka, Op. 30, no. 4, m. 129ff.
From Schenker, Der freie Satz, Fig. 54.6.
b. Nota cambiata. From Schenker, Kontrapunkt I, Ex. 347.
fact, and thereby causes insurmountable difficulty for the theory teacher and forces him to speak of a succession of seventh chords.”41 In other words, the consecutive non-harmonic tones arise from two separate, but simultaneous, levels of contrapuntal motion: the bass A is simply a passing tone and does not support an independent Stufe, whereas the soprano F is a passing tone between G and E in the underlying progression V–I in C major. This phenomenon is common in mixed species and will be discussed in chapter 3. Finally, whereas suspensions are the only possible accented non-harmonic tones in strict counterpoint, many other types of accented non-harmonic tones occur in tonal contexts through the concept of displaced intervals. Figure 1.22 (Displacement and
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
55
Figure 1.21. Consecutive seventh chords. From Schenker, Generalbasslehre, p. 47. From John Rothgeb, “Schenkerian Theory: Its Implications for the Undergraduate Curriculum,” Music Theory Spectrum 3 (1981): 146.
Figure 1.22. Displacement and accented dissonances.
accented dissonances) shows how displacements can used to generate accented passing tones (figure 1.22a), accented neighbor tones (figure 1.22b), and appoggiaturas (figure 1.22c). Displacement can even account for more radical deviations from strict counterpoint, such as the ones found in figure 1.23 (Beethoven’s Piano Sonata, Op. 81a).42 By displacing the right and left hands, Beethoven superimposed the tonic and dominant chords, thereby creating an effect of extraordinary beauty. So far, we have considered Schenker’s explanation of the relationship between strict counterpoint and functional tonality. Schenker saw many connections between the two; in both cases, melodic lines mostly move by step, converge on the tonic at final cadences, and move between stable and unstable verticalities. But he also saw subtle differences; these arise because strict counterpoint is bound either by ‘The Consonance Constraint’ or ‘The Triadic Constraint,’ whereas tonal voice leading is controlled by ‘The Stufe Constraint.’ We have seen that, through ‘The Heinrich Maneuver,’ Schenker not only
56
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.23. Beethoven, Piano Sonata, Op. 81a, 1st movement, mm. 230–42. From Schenker, Harmonielehre, Ex. 132.
reinterpreted the basic principles of melodic motion, relative motion, and the behavior of unstable/stable tones so that they applied to functional tonality, but he also supported these basic principles with an alternative network of subordinate laws. Schenker was well aware of what he had done: in Kontrapunkt I, for example, he promised to “justify each prescription and restriction and elaborate how the application of [these rules] more or less changes in the context of [tonal] composition.”43 He believed that “by this procedure,” he could “contribute best toward eliminating that unfortunate confusion of counterpoint and composition as well as its sad consequences.”44
“The Complementarity Principle” From the preceding discussion, it should be clear that ‘The Heinrich Maneuver’ ties the principles of tonal voice leading to the behavior of tonal harmonies. This observation reflects Schenker’s general belief that it is impossible to understand functional tonality adequately from a purely contrapuntal or a purely harmonic perspective. Indeed, as he put it in Harmonielehre: “[O]ne note, or even more, may be heard merely horizontally, while the vertical is to be totally disregarded; for other notes, on the contrary, the vertical concept is far more important.”45 For convenience, we will refer to this interrelation of line and chord as ‘The Complementarity Principle.’
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
57
This principle can, in fact, be stated even more strongly: although every tonal event can be interpreted contrapuntally or harmonically, any account that is purely contrapuntal or purely harmonic will necessarily be incomplete.46 ‘The Stufe Constraint’ does not simply list what essential harmonies are possible, it also explains how they conform to “their own secret law of progression.”47 To understand what ‘The Stufe Constraint’ involves, let us briefly compare traditional explanations of functional harmony with those offered by Schenker. In general terms, tonal theorists usually address three main issues. First, they are concerned with showing how stable harmonies are distinguished from unstable harmonies. Most theorists believe that functional tonal music is basically built from triads and seventh chords, which they classify in terms of their quality (major, minor, diminished, and augmented) and their inversion (root, first, second, and third). We can use the term ‘inversional equivalence’ to refer to the notion that the identity of a triad is independent of its vertical ordering. Most theorists also classify triads into seven types identified by seven Roman numerals. Second, tonal theorists are interested in determining how successive harmonies are arranged to create typical functional progressions. To do this, many theorists invoke the idea of ‘functional equivalence’: they propose that the seven essential harmonies fulfill three basic functions—tonic (I, VI, and III), dominant (V and VII), and subdominant (IV, II, and VI). They then suggest that prototypical tonal progressions follow the scheme tonic (T)–subdominant (S)–dominant (D)–tonic (T). Third, tonal theorists are concerned with understanding how chromatic harmonies arise in functional tonal contexts. Since most theorists assume that functional tonal music is fundamentally diatonic, they usually regard chromaticisms as surface deviations from this basic system. Schenker’s outlook on these three topics was, however, anything but conventional; by including voice-leading elements in his theory of harmony, he was able to simplify the principles of harmonic classification and harmonic progression considerably, thereby increasing their flexibility and accuracy. In the first case, he used the laws of tonal voice leading to limit the number of essential harmonies to major, minor, and diminished triads and he was very suspicious of inversional equivalence.48 To be specific, since the
58
Explaining Tonality
interval of the perfect fourth is dissonant when it occurs above the bass, Schenker seldom treated 6/4 sonorities as functional harmonies, and since augmented triads do not appear within the major or minor systems, he did not count them as essential either. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, Schenker rejected the idea that seventh chords normally behave as functional harmonies. To quote from the start of Kontrapunkt I: The Stufe exists in our perception only as [a] triad; that is, as soon as we expect a Stufe, we expect it first of all only as [a] triad, not as a seventh chord. In this sense, the seventh is absolutely not an a priori element of our perception comparable to the fifth and the third; it is rather an event a posteriori, which we understand best of all with reference to the function associated with it; that is, we understand it in retrospect as a passing tone, or as a means of chromaticization, or the like.49
Obviously, if seventh chords are ultimately created by contrapuntal motion, then so must more abstruse sonorities, such as ninths, thirteenths, and augmented-sixths. These are shown in figure 1.24 (Laws of harmonic classification). Schenker also used the laws of tonal voice leading to shed light on the behavior of harmonic progressions (or Stufengang). He was quite clear that cadential closure was not simply a contrapuntal phenomenon, it also depends on the distinctive motion from dominant to tonic: In order to gain insight into cadences in [tonal] composition it is important to recognize that there the closure is no longer based on the horizontal line alone but rather (and to a larger degree) on the harmony of the vertical [dimension], or, more precisely, on the succession from the V Stufe to I.50
But while he certainly accepted the functional priority of the tonic and dominant Stufen, Schenker rejected the notion of functional equivalence: he denied that the seven Stufen necessarily fulfill just three basic functions—tonic, subdominant, and dominant. To quote from Kontrapunkt I, “How can one claim to have understood the [tonal] ‘system’ if its individual Stufen, except I, IV, and V, are deprived of their independence and thus of their attractive capability of assuming various functions?”51 Schenker added, “[I]t is the functional versatility of the Stufe that is the basis of [tonal] practice,
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
59
Figure 1.24. Laws of harmonic classification. a. Traditional Laws of Harmony
b. Revised Laws of Tonal Harmony
If a melody is harmonized, then it is mainly supported by major, minor, diminished, or augmented triads, and seventh chords on seven degrees.
LM
If a melody is harmonized, then it is mainly supported by major, minor, diminished triads on seven degrees.
If these triads appear in succession, then these seven degrees serve one of three functions—tonic (T), subdominant (S), or dominant (D) (functional equivalence).
LM
If a triad appears, then it always has the root and the third, with any member in the bass (inversional equivalence).
LS
If a triad appears, then it has the root and the third, with only these members in the bass.
If the triad doubles notes, then it normally doubles the root, then the fifth, then the third, but not 7.
S
If the triad doubles notes, then it normally doubles the root, then the fifth, then the third, but not 7 .
If non-harmonic tones appear, then they arise from seventh chords or motion between triads.
LS
If non-harmonic tones appear, then they arise from motion between harmonic tones or contrapuntal voices.
(G⫽global, L⫽local, M⫽main, S⫽subordinate)
and this, of course, at least presupposes its independence!”52 Although there will certainly be times when II chords behave the same way as IV chords, there will be other times when they do not; this means that the notion of functional equivalence cannot be generalized across the entire range of tonal progressions.53 Taking Schenker’s argument further, even if two Stufen do behave in the same way, they need not arise for the same reasons (see figure 1.25, Chord function vs. chord derivation). Figure 1.25a gives a simple progression I–V–I with a descent 3– 2– 1 in the soprano. Next, figure 1.25b shows how we can compose out this progression by a leaping passing tone in the bass, thereby generating an incomplete upper neighbor motion in the soprano. We can assume that the II6 in figure 1.25c is generated in much the same
60 Figure 1.25. Chord function vs. chord derivation.
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
61
Figure 1.26. Laws of harmonic progression. a. Traditional Laws of Harmony If triads appear in succession, then they are normally arranged as T-S-D-T.
b. Revised Laws of Tonal Harmony GM
If a tonal progression is maximally closed, then it ends by moving from V to I.
LS
If another essential harmony occurs, then it does so from motion between I and V.
way. But what about the II Stufe in figure 1.25d? This one seems to be derived from the upcoming dominant rather than from the preceding tonic.54 The same can also be said of the D-major Stufe given in figure 1.25e. In other words, figure 1.25 indicates that different predominant chords may serve the same function, even though they may be generated in quite different ways. Schenkerian derivations are simply more accurate than functional explanations.55 Assuming that Schenker’s seven Stufen cannot be reduced to three functional categories, how can we explain the behavior of harmonic progressions? The answer is, in fact, surprisingly easy; according to Schenker, they arise from the process of composing out: As a consequence of voice-leading constraint[s], all those individual harmonies that arise from the progression of the various voices are forced to move forward. All the transient harmonies which appear in the course of a work have their source in the necessities of voice-leading [par. 178, 180].56
Since “Stufen are inextricably bound up with counterpoint,” we can reformulate some new laws, as shown in figure 1.26 (Laws of harmonic progression).57 Lastly, Schenker recognized that tonal voice leading has an important influence on the behavior of tonal chromaticisms. Obviously, one of the biggest differences between strict counterpoint and functional tonal composition lies in the area of chromaticism. As Schenker himself pointed out, whereas strict counterpoint is primarily diatonic and avoids direct chromatic successions, functional tonal composition uses mixture and tonicization to create the entire spectrum of chromaticisms.58 In some cases, these chromatic
62
Explaining Tonality
Figure 1.27. Laws of chromatic generation. a. Traditional Laws of Harmony
b. Revised Laws of Tonal Harmony
If a melody is harmonized by triads, then these triads are mainly diatonic.
LM
If a melody is harmonized by triads, then these triads are mainly diatonic.
If chromaticisms occur, then they substitute for or elaborate diatonic triads.
LS
If chromaticisms occur, then they arise from mixture or tonicization.
LS
If harmonies appear on IV/V, then they are always indirectly related to I.
successions will be direct: “In contrast to strict counterpoint (see Kpt. I, II/2, par. 28, and Kpt. II, III/1, par. 25), [tonal] composition permits a succession of chromatic tones.”59 But, since tonal composers still try to avoid juxtapositions of this latter sort, Schenker believed that “the prohibition is in a certain sense reestablished.”60 In particular, he suggested that they can be avoided by techniques such as motion from an inner voice, neighbor motions, and linear progressions.61 This point is summarized in figure 1.27 (Laws of chromatic generation). To illustrate what Schenker had in mind, we need only consider his discussion of the Phrygian II. As we all know, the supertonic Stufen are often used to reinforce the dominant Stufe in perfect authentic cadences (see figure 1.28a, Rectification of Phrygian II). In such contexts, the soprano voice will normally descend from 2 to 1 as the bass moves from V to I. But when the Phrygian II is added before the dominant, the voice leading becomes more complicated (see figure 1.28b). Since the Phrygian II typically has 2 in the soprano and since changing this scale degree to 2 for the dominant Stufe would create the direct chromatic succession 2–2, Schenker insisted that the melody should descend from 2 to 7 in the alto voice. He referred to the modification of 2 as rectification (or Die Richtigstellung).62 Occasionally, Schenker even used this same principle in reverse. For example, to explain the special ‘Phrygian’ effects at the end of Chopin’s Mazurka, Op. 41, no. 2, in E Minor, Schenker
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
63
Figure 1.28. Rectification of Phrygian II. Adapted from Schenker, Five graphic Analyses, No. 5, Chopin, Étude in C Minor, Op. 10, no. 12.
suggested that 2 or F is rectified in reverse to create 2 or F, though once again the music avoids a direct chromatic succession.63 In a paper cowritten with Douglas Dempster and Dave Headlam, I have described another more remarkable situation in which contrapuntal devices are used to eliminate one specific type of direct chromatic succession.64 We began by showing that, according to Schenkerian theory, direct connections between I and IV/V cannot occur in tonal contexts. We then considered examples in which Stufen on IV/V arise from contrapuntal motion. Among the most remarkable examples of this appears in the Scherzo to Beethoven’s String Quartet, Op. 59, no. 1. Although this movement is in B major, the coda contains a brief excursion to E minor. We argue that this outburst actually arises from a contrapuntal expansion of the dominant F, which is reached in m. 445. Instead of resolving onto a tonic B, it shifts to a diminished seventh on F (m. 446). This latter sonority tonicizes E (m. 450) before returning to F (m. 458) to set up the final arrival on B (m. 460). The F and E therefore serve as double neighbors to the dominant F, and, as if to draw attention to the significance of this pattern F–F–(G)–E–F, Beethoven presents it locally within the final cadence (mm. 469–76). In other words, the
64
Explaining Tonality
same procedures govern the behavior of surface melodies and larger harmonic progressions. All in all, ‘The Heinrich Maneuver’ and ‘The Complementarity Principle’ demonstrate the intimate connections between voice leading and harmony in functional tonality. These two basic principles allowed Schenker to show not only how the traditional laws of strict counterpoint are transformed in functional contexts by the influence of Stufen, but also how the traditional laws of functional harmony can be modified by grounding them in the laws of tonal voice leading. By classifying these laws along the lines suggested above, he had good reason for supposing that these new laws are both necessary and sufficient for explaining functional tonality. Schenker was able to make these connections between line and chord because he recognized that Stufen play a crucial role in both domains: in his words, they are “the essential generator of all [musical] content.”65 He was prompted to take these steps precisely because traditional theories of counterpoint and harmony proved to be inaccurate. Such observations are significant for several reasons. From a pedagogical perspective, we have good reason to update current textbooks on tonal theory. On the one hand, we can provide students with a more persuasive account of why Fuxian species counterpoint helps us understand functional tonality. We can tell them that Fux teaches us about the behavior of contrapuntal lines as they exist in the simplified world of intervals, whereas functional tonality exists in the messy world of functional triads, or Stufen. On the other hand, we can offer students an explicit list of laws that cover the behavior of functional voice leading. These new laws allow us to abandon the rather dubious notion that in free composition, great composers sometimes break the rules of strict counterpoint simply because they are great composers. From a methodological perspective, our observations also underscore the importance of accuracy to the development of music theories. Schenker was obviously very concerned about whether the laws of strict counterpoint were adequate for explaining the behavior of tonal voice leading. Instead of dismissing abnormalities by appealing to the liberties of genius or to the extra-musical allusions of specific
Schenker and the Quest for Accuracy
65
pieces, he tried to build a theory that provided a more accurate fit with the music he was studying. In this sense Schenker’s work falls within a quite normal pattern of theoretical inquiry. Indeed, as Quine puts it: The tension between law and anomaly is vital to the progress of science. The scientist goes out of his way to induce it. Sir Karl Popper well depicts him as inventing hypotheses and then making every effort to falsify them by cunningly devised experiments.66
Quine adds that “it is the tension between the scientist’s laws and his own breaches of them that powers the engines of science and makes it forge ahead.”67 Given that Schenker left us with an empirically testable theory of functional monotonality, our next job is to find the anomalies that it surely contains; if we are able to fix them up, then we can keep the engines of music theory firing on all cylinders.
2
Semper idem sed non eodem modo In the previous chapter, we saw how Schenker’s concern for accuracy motivated him to refine the traditional laws of strict counterpoint and functional harmony; he did so by constraining the laws of counterpoint harmonically and by grounding the laws of harmony contrapuntally. If Schenker’s only contribution to music theory had been to devise more accurate laws of tonal voice leading and harmony, then his place in music history would have been assured. After all, these new laws overcome technical problems that had perplexed theorists for several centuries. But Schenker took another crucial step: he reformulated his new laws in a procedural form as a system of prototypes (Ursätze), transformations (Verwandlungen), and levels (Verwandlungs-Schichten, Stimmführungs-Schichten, or Schichten). This system allowed him to reach two important conclusions: 1) all functional monotonal pieces can be derived from a single prototype; and 2) there are only three possible prototypes for all functional monotonal compositions. There are several reasons why these conclusions are so important. On the one hand, they allowed Schenker to achieve the sort of theoretic unification described in the Introduction. Indeed, whereas music theorists had traditionally treated counterpoint and harmony as largely separate phenomena, Schenkerian theory insists that they are irrevocably intertwined. This synthesis is undoubtedly a major step forward in our understanding of tonal relationships. On the other hand, these results allowed Schenker to widen the explanatory scope of tonal theory; instead of simply explaining tonal motion across an individual phrase, he could now explain tonal motion across an entire monotonal composition. Schenker achieved this goal by showing that the same laws of functional voice leading and harmony operate both in the small and in
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
67
the large. This radical insight is encapsulated in his famous motto semper idem sed non eodem modo or “always the same but not in the same way.”1 Remarkable though it may be, Schenker’s system of prototypes, transformations, and levels does raise a number of interesting questions. How, in fact, are the individual components of the system related to the general laws of functional voice leading and harmony outlined in chapter 1? Why did Schenker insist that his prototypes, transformations, and levels have some forms but not others? Why was he so confident that this system is capable of generating all and only all complete, continuous monotonal pieces? Does his motto semper idem sed non eodem modo really stand up to critical scrutiny? This chapter will answer these questions. Part 1 starts by looking at the conceptual origins of Schenker’s work. Since Schenker’s system of prototypes, transformations, and levels has some obvious connections with Fux’s concept of species counterpoint, we will compare the one with the other. After part 1 has shown certain important differences between the goals of Schenker and those of Fux, part 2 examines Schenkerian prototypes in more detail. Among other things, it suggests that they summarize in an optimally compact way the main laws of tonal motion mentioned in chapter 1. Next, part 3 describes the various ways in which these prototypes can be transformed. In particular, it explains why these transformations are finite in number. Part 4 then looks at the various ways in which Schenker ordered his transformations into discrete levels. The main focus will be on showing how, in principle at least, the process of generation preserves the local laws of tonality outlined in the previous chapter. Finally, Part 5 considers some implications of the preceding discussion. In particular, it looks at Schenker’s preference for analyses in which the same patterns of transformation occur within and between levels.
Conceptual Origins As mentioned above, Schenker’s thinking about functional tonality is dominated by the basic idea that complex tonal progressions can be explained as transformations of simple tonal prototypes. For him,
68
Explaining Tonality
the processes of transformation have several implications. First, they imply that whenever a prototype is transformed, it will be elaborated with new harmonic and melodic material. Schenker drew attention to this idea by invoking a number of colorful terms, such as Auskomponierung (composing out), Mehrung (increase of content), and Auswicklung (unwinding).2 Second, these processes imply that when a prototype is elaborated, the new material may behave somewhat differently from the original prototype. For example, although Schenker’s prototypes are fundamentally consonant and diatonic, they can be transformed to create progressions that are highly dissonant and chromatic. Such changes are what Schenker had in mind when he used terms like Umwandlung (reshaping) and Umbildung (recasting).3 Schenker was not, of course, the first person to think about music in terms of prototypes, transformations, and levels; on the contrary, the same ideas lie at the heart of many theoretical projects, including Fuxian species counterpoint.4 Fux’s interest in the process of elaboration is obvious enough; in codifying the Five Species he set out to show how cantus firmi can be elaborated with simple or florid counterpoints. But as we saw in chapter 1, Fux also realized that the behavior of the contrapuntal lines alters from one species to the next; whereas counterpoints are always strictly consonant with the cantus firmus in First Species, they can be dissonant in Fifth Species. Furthermore, as counterpoints become more elaborate, so they can include progressively more repeated tones and even chromaticisms. But while Fuxian species counterpoint has some obvious connections with Schenker’s system of prototypes, transformations, and levels, it nonetheless differs in crucial respects. For one thing, the theoretical status of a cantus firmus is very different from that of a Schenkerian prototype. Fux’s cantus firmi are essentially examples of effective modal melodies. Each one begins and ends on the final of a given mode and each one moves onto the reciting tone at points of structural significance. Meanwhile, Schenker’s prototypes are far more general in scope. Instead of representing a specific melody per se, they encapsulate certain underlying principles of melodic construction. These principles guide both the local behavior of individual melodies and the global behavior of entire pieces. Schenker
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
69
Figure 2.1. Schenker’s concept of prototypes, transformation, and levels. From Schenker, Der freie Satz, Fig. 1.
conveyed such levels of abstraction very beautifully at the start of Der freie Satz, in a chart given here as figure 2.1 (Schenker’s concept of prototypes, transformation, and levels). This chart shows that the tonality of a given foreground (Vordergrund) can be generated from the diatony of the given background (Hintergrund) through various levels of the middleground (Mittelgrund). Each prototype (Ursatz) contains an upper line (Urlinie) in the upper register and a bass arpeggiation (or Bassbrechung) that articulates the upper fifth, i.e., it moves from I to V and back to I. To reinforce the global nature of his prototypes, Schenker even included a paragraph in Der freie Satz that differentiates prototypes from cadences.5 For convenience, we will refer to the notion that functional monotonal pieces derive from a single prototype as ‘The Global Paradigm.’ As it happens, ‘The Global Paradigm’ did not come to Schenker overnight; it actually developed in his mind over a period of at least twenty years. In fact, he started to toy with the concept of a prototype as early as the Harmonielehre and Kontrapunkt I and even criticized C. P. E. Bach for underestimating their significance. But at this point in time his prototypes were purely local phenomena and certainly did not control an entire piece.6 Over the next decade, however, they became wider in scope.7 In his edition of Beethoven’s Piano Sonata, Op. 110 (1914), for example, Schenker explained how the development section of the second movement
70
Explaining Tonality
could be derived from a single 32-bar progression. Six years later, in his comments to Beethoven’s Piano Sonata, Op. 101 (1920), he even coined the term Urlinie. Nevertheless, it was not until the early issues of Der Tonwille (1921) that he proposed a single Urlinie for an entire piece and the fifth issue (1923) that he derived a whole work from a single Ursatz.8 Another important difference between Fux’s conception of species counterpoint and Schenker’s system of prototypes, transformations, and levels is that the latter is recursive and rule preserving, whereas the former is not. Recursion is a term borrowed from mathematics. In very general terms, a musical system is recursive if it posits certain starting states, such as a prototypical harmonic progression, and derives more complex states, or progressions, by repeatedly applying a given set of transformations. This system is also rule preserving if every derived state or progression conforms to the same underlying laws of voice leading and harmony as the prototype. If the musical system is indeed recursive and rule preserving, then the processes of generation and reduction will be the reverse of each other. We will refer to these ideas as ‘The Recursive Model.’ There are good reasons to suppose that Fuxian species counterpoint is neither recursive nor rule preserving. To begin with, Fux never claimed that Fifth Species counterpoints can be generated by repeatedly elaborating First Species prototypes, nor did he suggest that Second, Third, and Fourth Species are intermediate stages of generation. Furthermore, if Fuxian species counterpoint were indeed recursive and rule preserving, then we would be able to reduce all of the species to First Species prototypes. But this is not necessarily the case. Figure 2.2 (The non-recursive nature of Fuxian species counterpoint) gives settings of a single cantus firmus in First, Second, Third, and Fourth Species. Although these settings all satisfy the laws of strict counterpoint, they cannot be reduced to a plausible First Species prototype, like the one in figure 2.2a. Take, for example, the counterpoint given in figure 2.2b. When we try to reduce the counterpoint in mm. 3–5 from two notes per measure to one, we soon run into difficulties. If we regard the G in m. 4 as ornamental, then parallel octaves occur between the downbeats of mm. 4 and 5. Conversely, if we regard the C in m. 4 as ornamental, then we create parallel fifths with the main note A in m. 3. Many
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
71
Figure 2.2. The non-recursive nature of Fuxian species counterpoint. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Figs. 11, 36, 57, 76.
of the same issues arise in mm. 4–5 of figure 2.2c. But the problems are even more acute in figure 2.2d. Here, the string of suspensions is created by displacing the counterpoint over the cantus firmus. If we try to normalize this displacement, then the resulting First Species prototype consistently violates the law prohibiting parallel perfect fifths (c.f., mm. 3–7). Whatever their similarities, it seems that Fux’s concept of species counterpoint and Schenker’s system of prototypes, transformations, and levels have quite different goals. Whereas Fux used his cantus firmi to illustrate a well-composed melody in each mode, Schenker used his prototypes to explain the general principles of
72
Explaining Tonality
melodic construction as they operate locally within a phrase and globally across an entire piece. And, whereas Fux’s species teach students certain general techniques of elaboration, Schenker’s system of prototypes, transformations, and levels explains how the extraordinary diversity of functional tonality stems from the working out of certain underlying principles of counterpoint and harmony. To show how this system is, in principle at least, both recursive and rule preserving, let us now consider its main components in detail, starting with Schenker’s prototypes.
Prototypes For anyone concerned with the explanatory scope of Schenkerian theory, it is important to reconsider the various covering laws mentioned in chapter 1. In very general terms, these laws cover six areas: 1) how individual lines move and reach closure; 2) how polyphonic lines move in relation to one another; 3) how unstable tones behave in relation to stable tones; 4) how stable harmonies are distinguished from unstable harmonies; 5) how successive harmonies are arranged to create typical functional progressions; and 6) how chromatic harmonies arise in functional tonal contexts. As such, these laws seem to be necessary and sufficient for explaining tonal relations. Within each domain, we classified these laws in several ways. On the one hand, we distinguished main laws from subordinate laws: the former explain how melodies normatively behave, whereas the latter explain significant exceptions to that norm. On the other hand, we distinguished local laws from global laws; the former explain how one note moves to the next, whereas the latter explain how the melody moves as a whole. The great advantage of classifying the covering laws in this way is that it allows us to structure our knowledge about tonal music; this structure becomes very important when we reformulate our laws as prototypes, transformations, and levels. As we saw in chapter 1, Schenker believed that, locally, melodies mainly move by step and, globally, they are maximally closed if they begin on 8, 5 , or 3 and end 2– 1. Similarly, he acknowledged that contrapuntal lines tend to move in contrary motion or in parallel thirds, sixths, and tenths and
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
73
never produce parallel perfect octaves or fifths between successive Stufen. Schenker also accepted that the only stable harmonies are functional triads in root or first inversion. According to him, chord successions are controlled contrapuntally, with closure most strongly articulated by the harmonic progression V–I. And, he recognized that functional progressions are primarily diatonic in nature. If we now look at Schenker’s prototypes, we soon see that they summarize these main laws in an optimally compact way. For convenience, the three parts of figure 2.3 (Schenkerian Ursätze in C Major) show the three basic prototypes for C major. Each one consists of a stepwise descent from a headtone (Kopfton), either 3, 5 , or 8, to 1. This simple passing motion is supported by a bass arpeggiation I–V–I. Whereas Schenker notated the upper line and bass arpeggiation in whole notes, he included a prototypical inner voice in black note heads. Elsewhere, he referred to the precise location of the prototype as the obligatory register (obligate Lage).9
Figure 2.3. Schenkerian Ursätze in C Major. Adapted from Schenker, Der freie Satz, Figs. 9, 10, 11.
74
Explaining Tonality
With respect to the laws of melodic motion and closure, it is clear that the upper line follows the local law of moving by step and the global law of beginning on 8, 5, or 3 and ending 2– 1. The upper line and bass arpeggiation likewise obey the main laws of relative motion: the three essential lines close 2– 1, 7– 1, and 5– 1, whereas the outer voices essentially move in contrary or oblique motion with the upper line descending from the headtone to 1 and the bass arpeggiation ascending from I to V. Similarly, each prototype follows the main laws of vertical alignment by beginning and ending on members of the tonic Stufe. Schenker’s prototypes also conform to the main laws of functional harmony: each one contains three Stufen arranged to form the quintessential functional progression I–V–I. This progression is not only diatonic, but it also defines the tonic C in the most unambiguous manner possible. Having shown how Schenker’s prototypes summarize the main laws of functional tonality in an optimally compact way, we can now respond to several alternative accounts of their structure. For starters, although we have seen certain connections between Schenkerian theory and Fuxian species counterpoint, one should not read too much into Carl Schachter’s claim that Schenker’s prototypes are basically Second-Species constructs.10 While Schachter is certainly right to suggest that their upper lines derive some of their logic from the principle of passing motion, it is important to remember that these lines do not belong to the purely intervallic world of strict counterpoint; on the contrary, they clearly belong to the world of Stufen, something that is underscored by the Roman numerals marked under the bass arpeggiation in figures 2.3a–c.11 We can use similar arguments to rebuff Peter Westergaard’s critique of 5 and 8 lines.12 Westergaard has suggested that, since these upper lines contain unsupported stretches (Leerlaufen), they are conceptually inferior to 3 lines. This notion seems to be confirmed by the fact that the Fünf Urlinie-Tafeln and Der freie Satz contain a deluge of 3-line graphs and a dearth of 8-line readings. The chief problem with Westergaard’s position is that Schenker himself did not insist the upper line should be completely supported; on the contrary, in par. 69 of Der freie Satz, he specifically acknowledged that they can contain passing tones.13 Since 5 and 8 lines do indeed conform to the general laws of tonal voice leading
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
75
outlined in chapter 1, there are no grounds for discriminating against them. This does not mean that 5 and 8 lines will necessarily be as common as 3 lines; on the contrary, there are good reasons why they may be rare. For example, 8-lines present the composer with a fairly narrow set of options; it is perhaps small wonder that they tend to be found in specific types of music, such as Baroque preludes.14 By the same token, we can respond to David Neumeyer’s revised list of prototypes. In a series of thought-provoking papers, Neumeyer has proposed that: 1) there are other forms of upper line, including some that rise, for example, 5–6–7– 8; 2) 8 lines properly belong to the middleground not the background; and 3) some pieces are controlled by three-voice prototypes consisting of “a structural soprano and a structural alto—above a bass.”15 These alternative prototypes stem in part from the work of Schenker’s pupil, Felix-Eberhard von Cube.16 The chief drawback with Neumeyer’s additions is that they no longer conform to the laws of tonal motion mentioned above. Most obviously, his rising lines contradict the law that melodies reach maximum closure when they descend 3– 2– 1. Since 8 lines satisfy this and our other laws, it is hard to see how they can be rejected as Neumeyer suggests.17 Having said that, Neumeyer’s case for three-part prototypes is utterly convincing. For one thing, it is certainly borne out by the examples shown in figures 2.3a and b. For another, Joseph Lubben has noted that in Der Tonwille, Schenker often used the term Aussensatz to denote “a structure of two upper voices above the Stufen.”18 Furthermore, since Schenker clearly used so-called polyphonic transformations (for example, unfolding and motion from an inner voice) at the deep middleground, it suggests certain inner voices must be present at some prior level or derivation. As we will see in chapter 3, these inner voices also help us resolve certain inconsistencies in Schenker’s generation of sequences. Finally, we can address Eugene Narmour’s charge that Schenkerian theory commits the fallacy of affirming the consequent.19 Narmour claims that Schenkerian theory is circular because it sets out to show that all tonal compositions can be generated from various prototypes. According to Narmour, however, the analyst must know the nature of these prototypes in advance in
76
Explaining Tonality
order to make a reduction. Since Schenkerian analyses seem to bend the notes to fit the theory, they are, in Narmour’s opinion, specious. Given the ways in which Schenkerian analyses are normally presented, it is hard to disagree with Narmour; at times the arguments do indeed seem viciously circular. But the foregoing account minimizes these problems by suggesting that the process of confirming Schenkerian theory is a lot more complex than Narmour suggests. We have seen that the explanatory laws underpinning Schenkerian theory were actually discovered empirically in the Harmonielehre and Kontrapunkt I, long before Schenker formulated his concept of a single tonal prototype. These laws are, in fact, extensions or transformations of well-established laws of counterpoint. By classifying them along the lines suggested in chapter 1, we have good reason to suppose that they are both necessary and sufficient for all functional tonal music. After spending the next decade studying a broad range of functional monotonal compositions, Schenker discovered empirically that he could reformulate this set of explanatory laws in terms of prototypes, transformations, and levels. There is a sense, then, in which the principles governing Schenker’s prototypes can be confirmed independently without the need for graphing; whatever circularity remains stems from the kind of bootstrapping process by which Schenker came up with his results.
Transformations So far, we have seen that Schenker’s prototypes summarize the main laws of tonal voice leading and harmony in an optimally compact way. They are the simplest possible expressions of a given key. But we also know from chapter 1 that these particular laws do not explain every aspect of functional tonality; on the contrary, we also introduced a number of subordinate laws to cover deviations from these norms. Among other things, these exceptions allow us to explain why leaps can occur in melodic lines, why melodic lines can contain a whole host of dissonances and not just the simple passing tone, why functional progressions can include harmonies other than I and V, and why these progressions can contain a variety of
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
77
chromaticisms. To explain these diverse phenomena and satisfy the various subordinate laws, Schenker invoked a set of transformations or prolongations. Although Schenker did not define his arsenal of transformations as precisely as we might wish, we can divide them into four main groups. The first group horizontalizes a given Stufe by presenting the constituent harmonic tones successively rather than simultaneously (see figure 2.4a), the first of Horizontalizing transformations.20 Of these, the simplest is repetition (Wiederholung). In a nutshell, repetition expands a particular Stufe by taking a note in the soprano or bass voice and duplicating it exactly. In figure 2.4b, the tonic chord in C major is composed out by repeating the soprano pitch G. Significantly, repetition can generate new material before or after the original Stufe: this new material is said to be “front-related” if it appears before and “back-related” if it appears after. Whereas repetition duplicates a particular tone in a given register, the other members of this group create leaps. To begin with, register transfer creates octave leaps by projecting a tone from one register to another. Schenker referred to this idea in general by the term Lagenwechsel and introduced specific transformations to denote ascending register transfers (Höherlegung), descending transfers (Tieferlegung), and alternations between a given pair of registers (Koppelung). An ascending register transfer is given in figure 2.4c. Like repetition, register transfer can occur in the soprano or the bass. Meanwhile, arpeggiation (Brechung) creates leaps by taking the soprano or bass note and moving to another member of the same Stufe. For example, in figure 2.4d the soprano voice arpeggiates the tonic Stufe by leaping from the third to the root. Significantly, arpeggiations can appear successively and even in the same direction. Just like repetition, they can be applied before or after the original Stufe. Just as register transfer and arpeggiation create leaps by moving from one harmonic tone to another, so unfolding, voice exchange, and reaching over create leaps by moving from one polyphonic voice to another. The simplest of these is unfolding (Ausfaltung). As shown in figure 2.4e, this transformation creates a single line by moving from the soprano E to the alto C. Following Schenker, it’s marked by a diagonal beam. Voice exchange (Stimmentausch), however, is more complicated; it involves swapping notes between two
78
Explaining Tonality
Figure 2.4. Horizontalizing transformations. a. Transformation
Domain
Schenker’s Discussion
Repetition (Wiederholung)
Single line Single harmony
None, but implied, DfS, Fig. 21
Register transfer (Hohelegung, Tieferlegung, Koppelung)
Single line Single harmony
DfS, par. 147–54, 238–41 Fig. 47–49, 106–8
Arpeggiation (Brechung)
Single line Single harmony
DfS, par. 125–28, 230 Fig. 40, 100
Unfolding (Ausfaltung)
Multiple lines Single harmony
DfS, par. 140–44, 234 Fig. 43–45, 103
Voice exchange (Stimmtausch)
Multiple lines Single harmony
DfS, par. 236–37
Reaching over (Ubergreifen)
Multiple lines Multiple harmonies
DfS, par. 129–34, 231–32 Fig. 41, 101
voices (see figure 2.4f). Here the soprano E in the first Stufe becomes the alto E in the second Stufe, while the alto C in the first Stufe becomes the soprano C in the second. The final transformation, reaching over (Übergreifen), seems to combine unfolding and voice exchange; as shown in figure 2.4g, the soprano and alto E/C of the first tonic Stufe are horizontalized, and then the soprano E connects with the alto D of the second Stufe and the alto C connects with the soprano F of the second Stufe.
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
79
Although the first group of transformations can create a wide range of material, they have an enormous limitation; since they cannot create step motions, they cannot generate non-harmonic tones. To overcome this deficiency, Schenker introduced four more transformations (see figure 2.5a, Filling in transformations). The simplest of these is neighbor motion (Nebennote).21 As shown in figure 2.5b, neighbor motion produces a step motion between two repeated tones. In this case, the neighbor tone F elaborates the repeated tone E in the soprano. The next transformation—linear progression (or Zug)—fills in the leap produced by a register transfer or an arpeggiation. Figure 2.5c shows how the third-progression E–F–G connects the harmonic tones E and G by a passing tone F. The next two transformations produce step motion between different voices of adjacent Stufen or repetitions of the same Stufe. Figure 2.5d gives a simple example of motion from an inner voice (Untergreifen). Here a single melodic line is created by a step motion between the alto C of the opening tonic Stufe and the soprano E of the adjacent tonic chord. Figure 2.5e shows an analogous example of motion to an inner voice. This time the melody is created by a step motion from the soprano E of the first Stufe to the alto E of the second. The fact that the soprano moves to an inner voice suggests that this transformation is closely connected with reaching over, hence the parallel nature of Schenker’s original terms.22 Besides accounting for an almost limitless array of melodic patterns, Schenker also needed to generate an array of new Stufen from the tonic and dominant triads of the prototype. This meant producing not only every diatonic Stufe, but all of their chromatic counterparts as well. He did this through a third group of transformations (see figure 2.6a, Harmonizing transformations). The term “harmonize” is easy enough to explain (see figure 2.6b). Once a given Stufe has been horizontalized, the derived tone can be supported harmonically by a root or first inversion triad, typically ()III, IV, V, and ()VI. In such cases, Schenker insisted that the generating Stufe is always conceptually present; he referred to this idea by the concept of a mentally retained primary tone (der festgehaltene Kopfton).23 Once the resulting span is filled in, the various non-harmonic tones can also be harmonized. Although these non-harmonic tones are usually harmonized by root or first inversion triads, they are sometimes supported
80
Explaining Tonality
Figure 2.5. Filling in transformations. a. Transformation
Domain
Schenker’s Discussion
Neighbor motion (Nebennote)
Single line
DfS, par. 106–12,196–202 Fig. 32, 76–80
Linear progression (Zug)
Single line
DfS, par. 113–24, 203–29 Fig. 33–39, 81–99
Motion from inner voice (Untergreifen)
Multiple lines Multiple harmonies
DfS, par. 135–39, 233 Fig. 42, 102
Motion to an inner voice
Multiple lines Multiple harmonies
DfS, par. 203
by a dominant-seventh chord. This latter option arises when the melody moves by step through 4 (for example, by passing motions 5 –4 –3 or 3 –4 –5 and neighbor motion 3–4 – 3). In such cases, we can support 4 with a dominant-seventh sonority.24 Instead of harmonizing derived tones by a complete triad, Schenkerian theory also allows another option. Suppose that a given Stufe has been horizontalized and that the space between its members has been filled in by step by a linear progression. This linear progression can be supported by adding a linear progression that proceeds in parallel thirds, sixths, or tenths. These thirds can then be harmonized as before (see figure 2.6c). We will discuss this strategy in more detail in chapter 3. Under normal conditions, harmonize and addition produce only diatonic Stufen—that is, major, minor, or diminished triads from the appropriate major or minor system. To create chromatic Stufen, Schenkerian theory introduces two transformations—mixture (or Mischung) and tonicization (or Tonikalisierung). As mentioned in
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
81
Figure 2.6. Harmonizing transformations. Transformation
Domain
Schenker’s Discussion
Harmonize
Single harmony Single/Multiple lines
None, but implied, c.f. Retained tones DfS, par. 93, 115
Addition
Single tone Single/Multiple lines
DfS, par. 221–29 Fig. 95–99
Mixture (Mischung, Phrygische II)
Single harmony Single/Multiple lines
DfS, par. 102–5, 193–95 Har., par. 26–30, 38–52 Fig. 28–31, 73–75
Tonicization (Tonikalisierung)
Single tone / harmony Single/ Multiple lines
Har., par. 132–62
chapter 1, there are three basic types of mixture: simple mixture allows for the interchange of triads between parallel keys (see figure 2.6d); secondary mixture allows for changes in the quality of triads in the major and minor systems (see figure 2.6e); and double mixture borrows triads from a parallel key and then changes their quality (see figure 2.6f). Meanwhile, tonicization creates chromaticisms by changing, albeit temporarily, from one tonal system to another. In the case of figure 2.6g, the chromatic tone F is created by tonicizing the dominant Stufe with an applied dominant harmony. Whereas the first three groups of transformations generate new tones and, as such can be used recursively, the final group modifies
82
Explaining Tonality
Figure 2.7. Reordering transformations (non-recursive). Transformation Delete (Vertretung) Displacement (Der uneigentliche Intervalle)
Domain
Schenker’s Discussion
Single line
DfS, par. 145–46, 235, 244–46, Fig. 46, 104.
Single/Multiple lines
DfS, par. 158, 261
or reorders tones that have already been generated (see figure 2.7a, Reordering transformations). These new transformations cannot normally be used recursively, though they can be used at early stages in the generative process. The first of these is known as deletion. Schenker clearly believed that the effect of a particular tone can sometimes be felt, even though this tone is not actually present in the score (see figure 2.7b). He described these virtual or deleted tones under the rubric of substitution (Vertretung); this more general idea suggests that particular notes do not behave exactly as they appear and can therefore by replaced by other notes. Schenker normally placed such implied notes in parentheses in his graphs.25 The second transformation is displacement and it shifts tones from one point to another (see figure 2.7c).26 Schenker referred to these tones as displaced or inauthentic intervals (Die uneigentliche Intervalle) and notated them with a diagonal line. As we noted in chapter 1, displacements can be applied to non-harmonic, as well as harmonic tones. Now that we have surveyed Schenker’s list of transformations, we are still left with a couple of nagging questions: why, in fact, should we suppose that this list is complete and why should we suppose that this list of transformations is powerful enough to generate all and only all tonal pieces? In answering these questions, it is important to remember that Schenker’s transformations are intimately related to the subordinate laws of tonal voice leading and harmony outlined in chapter 1; the list of transformations is
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
83
simply as comprehensive as this body of covering laws. For example, register transfer, arpeggiation, unfolding, voice exchange, and reaching over satisfy the subordinate law that melodic leaps arise when the melody shifts from one harmonic tone to another or from one polyphonic voice to another. These transformations account for every possible way in which a single line can be created from two polyphonic voices.27 Similarly, neighbor motion, linear progression, motion to and from inner voice, represent the only ways to fill in the space between horizontalized harmonic tones. When combined with displacement, these transformations can generate the full range of non-harmonic tones, ranging from suspensions and anticipations to appoggiaturas, cambiatas, and other more exotic phenomena. Finally, Schenker’s arsenal of harmonizing transformations conform nicely with the general laws covering the behavior of diatonic and chromatic harmonies; they allow us to generate not only the entire range of diatonic chord progressions, but also the full array of chromaticisms.
Levels Besides proposing that any complex tonal surface can be explained as a composing out of some simple progression, ‘The Recursive Model’ also presumes that whenever a given progression is expanded by the recursive application of a given transformation, the resulting progression conforms to the same laws of voice leading and harmony as the starting progression. To quote from Der freie Satz, “The principles of voice-leading, organically anchored, remain the same in background, middleground, and foreground, even when they undergo transformations. In them the motto of my work is embodied, semper idem sed non eodem modo.”28 According to our classification of laws given in chapter 1, it is only the local laws that are preserved from one level to the next: these local laws guarantee that melodic motion will mostly move by step, that contrapuntal lines will not include parallel perfect octaves or fifths between successive harmonic tones, that harmonic progressions will mostly be triadic, diatonic, and follow the basic law of harmonic closure. It is important to mention, however, that Schenker
84
Explaining Tonality
wasn’t always able to achieve this goal; as we will see in chapter 3, he was sometimes inconsistent in his treatment of the laws prohibiting parallel perfect octaves and fifths. We can illustrate these ideas with a simple example (see figure 2.8, Composing out). Figure 2.8a gives a progression C–G–C with a step wise descent in the soprano E–D–C. The first thing we must do is to specify its function within a particular key. This step is especially important if we want to transform the triad chromatically, because we can specify whether it serves as a mixture or even as a member of some secondary key area. In this particular case, figure 2.8b places the progression within the context of C major, hence the Roman numerals I–V–I. Once we have interpreted the individual harmonies as Stufen within a key, we can also compose them out using the horizontalizing transformations from figure 2.4. In this particular case, we can arpeggiate the opening tonic Stufe to create the bass motion C–E. We can then harmonize the derived tone to create our first derived triad in figure 2.8d this creates a I6 sonority (see figure 2.8c). Although there may, in principle, be many options, ‘The Recursive Model’ prohibits those that violate the local laws of tonal voice leading and harmony. This means, for example, that the derived tone cannot produce parallel perfect octaves or fifths with members of the original progression. If we want to continue generating material, then we have two options: we can either repeat the same moves on our first derived triad, or we can fill in the tone space between this derived triad and our initial triad. The second option requires that we use a transformation from figure 2.5. In this case linear progression to produce the bass motion C–D–E (see figure 2.8d). Having created the passing tone D, it is then harmonized in figure 2.8e. Once again, the specific harmony will be constrained by the local laws of relative motion and vertical alignment; our derived Stufe cannot produce parallel perfect octaves or fifths with its neighbors and it can initially take the form of only a major, minor or diminished triad. Notice how the resulting progression I–VII6–I6 is slightly different from the underlying progression I–V–I, but it still conforms to our basic laws of tonal voice leading and harmony. In particular, the subordinate progression mostly moves by step, it does not include
85 Figure 2.8. Composing out.
86
Explaining Tonality
Figure 2.9. Schenker’s deep-middleground paradigms. From Schenker, Der freie Satz, Figs. 15, 16, 18.
any parallel perfect octaves and fifths, and it contains lines that converge on the tonic 7 –1 and 2 –1 . Although figure 2.8 illustrates several distinct stages of transformation, it marks a significant point in the generative process. Schenker referred to this stage as the deep, or first-level, middleground. In part 2 of Der freie Satz, Schenker cataloged a broad range of deep-middleground paradigms.29 These are listed in figure 2.9 (Schenker’s deep-middleground paradigms). Looking through these paradigms, it soon becomes clear that the main feature of this level is to fill in the tone space created by the first two notes of the bass arpeggiation. For Schenker, the most basic motion involves horizontalizing the opening tonic Stufe to produce the progression I–I6–V–I or I–III–V–I, the latter giving rise to what he referred to as a Terzteiler (third divider).30 But Schenker also supposed that the
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
87
bass arpeggiation is filled out by passing tones.31 He then explained the deep-middleground progressions I–IV–V–I and I–II–V–I, as incomplete passing motions in the bass; he even notated such progressions with a pair of interlocking slurs to convey the idea that they articulate “the contrapuntal-melodic step of a second.”32 Besides focusing on the paradigms given in figure 2.9, Schenker restricted the use of transformations in several other ways. First, to avoid violating the local law prohibiting parallel perfect octaves and fifths, he excluded the progression I–VI–V–I at the deep middleground because this progression creates parallel perfect fifths between the soprano and the bass 3/VI–2/V. Second, since he believed that each piece lies in a specific register, Schenker limited the use of transformations so that any derived tones remain as close to this register as possible. For example, he excluded ascending arpeggiations, linear progression, voice exchanges, or reaching over from the headtone, upper neighbors from 8, and so forth. Third, since prototypes are bound by the laws of melodic and harmonic closure, Schenker discouraged transformations between 2/V and 1/I. According to him, “at the first level, 2/V–1/I provides33 no opportunity for prolongation in contrapuntalmelodic terms.” At later levels, however, he relaxed his position; as he explained in par. 189, “the arpeggiation of the descending fifth can proceed through the third only.”34 Fourth, since Schenker wanted to preserve the distinction between different forms of prototype, he shied away from adding transformations that immediately convert one prototype into another. For example, he preferred not to compose out a 3-line with a preliminary descent from 5–3 since that transformation would create a 5-line descent at the deep middleground. Schenker also discussed one other important strategy for transforming prototypes at the deep middleground, namely, divisions of the upper line (der Gliederung des Urlinie-Züges). As shown in figure 2.10 (Divided Urlinien), these divisions have very distinct forms. In 3- and 5 lines, they involve an interrupted version of the descent (Unterbrechungen) followed by a complete descent. In the case of 3-lines, the result is an upper-line pattern 3–2//3–2–1; in the case of 5 lines, 5–4–3– 2//5–4– 3– 2– 1. Schenker used a divider symbol (Teiler) to mark the two segments. In 8-lines, however, he
88
Explaining Tonality
Figure 2.10. Divided Urlinien.
subdivided the upper line at 5, thereby producing the motion 8–7–6–5//5–4– 3– 2–1. He made this adjustment because the descending seventh from 8 to 2 can be reinterpreted as an ascending second from 1 to 2. This latter motion contradicts the notion that tonal melodies typically descend by step onto 1 and therefore conflicts with Schenker’s conception of the upper line. As it happens, Schenker had a very good reason for dividing the upper line at the deep middleground: this strategy provided him with a means for explaining the behavior of certain formal types, a point that he made perfectly clear at several moments in Der freie Satz. In par. 94, for example, he declared: “Interruption has the quality of heightening the tension toward 1; particularly, it opens the way to two- or three-part forms, a1–a2 or a1–b–a2.”35 He added
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
89
that “it is even the basis of the extended form of the sonata, with exposition, development, and recapitulation.”36 Provocative as they may be, divisions of the upper line do, however, raise an interesting question: how, in fact, do divided lines derive from prototypes? Unfortunately, Schenker gave inconsistent answers to this question.37 On certain occasions, he seems to suggest that the first 2/V belongs to the prototype and that the subsequent I–V progression is front-related to the final I. This interpretation seems to conform with graphs published in Der freie Satz, especially figures 21, 23–28, 32.7, and 33–35. At other times, however, he intimated that the final 2/V belongs to the prototype. This alternative implies that the dividing dominant is backrelated to the opening I. Such a view seems more consistent with the analyses presented in Fünf Urlinie-Tafeln, such as his sketch of Bach’s setting of the chorale “Ich bin’s, ich sollte büssen” from the St. Matthew Passion. If we accept the claim that prototypes summarize the main laws of tonal voice leading and harmony, then the latter response seems preferable to the former. In particular, we know that one of the main goals of the prototype is to explain why a given piece closes in the tonic. It is for this reason that the upper line descends 2– 1, the alto line ascends 7– 1, and the bass descends V–I. Unfortunately, the front-related prolongation of the final I advocated by Schenker in Der freie Satz seems to obscure the connection between the background dominant and the final tonic. Figure 2.11 (Derivation of divided Urlinien) shows how we might derive a divided upper line in the manner implied by his sketch of the Bach Chorale “Ich bin’s, ich sollte büssen.” First, the headtone is repeated; second, the opening repeated tone is harmonized with a tonic Stufe; third, this derived tonic is arpeggiated in the bass; and, fourth, the new bass tone G is harmonized with a new dominant Stufe. Besides adding intermediate Stufen and divisions of the upper line, the deep middleground is also the source of other transformations, though they appear at a slightly later stage of generation. For example, Schenker allowed the headtone to be composed out by preceding or front-related material, provided this material ascends onto the headnote. He referred to this as a preliminary ascent (Anstieg). Such ascents can derive from an ascending register
90
Explaining Tonality
Figure 2.11. Derivation of divided Urlinien.
transfer, an ascending arpeggiation, an unfolding, or an ascending linear progression. Schenker also allowed passing motions between the intermediate Stufe and its companions. These extra motions can be clearly seen in the deep-middleground paradigms given as figures 15–18 in Der freie Satz.38
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
91
Although it is fairly easy to describe the characteristics of Schenker’s prototypes and his deep middleground paradigms, the situation becomes a lot harder as we pass through the middleground and foreground levels. The reason for this is that as we approach the surface, our graphs will capture the individual characteristics of each piece with greater and greater specificity: above all, thematic and rhythmic features will emerge as the process reaches the surface. In this respect, background levels capture what is common among the entire class of tonal composition, whereas foreground levels convey what is idiosyncratic to a particular piece. Having said that, several specific possibilities should be mentioned. For one thing, Schenker showed how VI can be used as an intermediate Stufe, provided that another intermediate Stufe is added to eliminate the parallels mentioned earlier.39 For another, the progression from V to I can be filled out by a motion through III.40 Schenker also allowed transformations to the final tonic chord. In fact, these prolongations will often correspond to the coda.41
Fallout The preceding sections have shown that, according to Schenkerian theory, any complete, continuous, functional monotonal piece can be generated from a single prototype by the recursive application of certain transformations. As shown in figure 2.12 (The explanatory scope of Schenkerian theory), this idea expands the scope of traditional tonal theory not only by showing how line and chord interact with one another, but also how they do so both locally and globally. However, given the complexity of most functional monotonal pieces, we have every reason to suppose that there may be more than one way to derive a particular surface from a given prototype, provided that each derivational scheme follows the prescribed laws. In practice, however, it is clear that Schenker endorsed some derivations and not others. Our next job is to find suitable criteria for making such a choice. Why, in fact, are some readings deemed preferable to others? Unfortunately, this question is not an easy one to answer. Certainly, there is no magic formula. When pressed, Schenker
92
Explaining Tonality
Figure 2.12. The explanatory scope of Schenkerian theory.
and his disciples generally throw their hands in the air and insist that analysis is a ‘creative’ not a ‘scientific’ activity; they vehemently deny that it can be reduced to any sort of algorithm.42 Yet, in actuality, Schenker did leave us with a few tantalizing clues. In particular, his sketches show that he put a premium on analyses in which the same patterns of derivation appear not only at the same level of transformation, but also between different levels. This point was clearly made by Milton Babbitt some forty years ago: Schenkerian theory of tonality, in its structure of nested transformations so strikingly similar to transformational grammars in linguistics, provides rules of transformation in proceeding synthetically through levels of composition. Since many of the transformational rules are level invariant, parallelism of transformation often plays an explanatory role in the context of the theory (and, apparently, an implicitly normative one in Schenker’s own writing).43
In fact, Schenker took special delight when these patterns coincided with surface motivic shapes. He referred to them as hidden repetitions (Der verborgene Wiederholungen) and stressed that “repetitions
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
93
of this kind have nothing to do with ‘motive’ repetitions” in the normal sense of the term.44 We can see the pros and cons of such parallelisms when we consider figure 2.13 (Summary of Schenker’s sketch of “The Representation of Chaos” from Haydn’s Creation).45 Perhaps the most striking feature of Schenker’s reading is that it includes a recurring fourth progression C–B–A–G in the bass; this pattern appears five times at the foreground, each one being marked by square brackets. According to him, this progression is made up of two descending seconds—C–B and A–G. These two-note pairs are motivic in function and derive from the prominent descent A–G at the opening of the movement. Schenker also found the fourthprogression C–B–A–G projected across mm. 1–39 of the middleground: as shown in figure 2.13a, he linked the opening C to the B4^ in m. 31 to the A in m. 38 to the G in m. 39. While the sketch in figure 2.13 reveals many important insights about Haydn’s remarkable score, Schenker was sometimes a little overzealous in his search for descending fourth-progressions. Particularly dubious is the one he found in mm. 18–27. It is hard to see how the C and B in mm. 18–19 initiate a span; on the contrary, they articulate a clear half cadence in the key of E, with the C supporting an augmented-sixth chord. Similarly, by linking the B in m. 19 to the A and G in m. 27, Schenker glossed over the arrival onto D in m. 21. This is perplexing because m. 21 not only articulates the first, albeit weak, authentic cadence in the piece, but it also marks the introduction of what Tovey regards as the second group material.46 This material eventually returns over a dominant pedal in the Recapitulation in mm. 44–49. Other readings are possible, however; see figure 2.14 (Alternate sketch of “The Representation of Chaos”). The underlying prototype for the piece is shown in figure 2.14a. Next, figure 2.14b shows how this progression is composed out contrapuntally at the deep middleground by the descending fourth progression C–B–A–G in the bass and how upper voices are displaced over the structural dominant to create the progression I–V4^–3%–I. Notice how the augmented-sixth chord serves to tonicize the dominant Stufe. In figure 2.14c, this progression is transformed by an initial ascent from C to E in mm. 1–8. This motion is
94 Figure 2.13. Schenker’s sketch of “The Representation of Chaos” from Haydn’s Creation. From Schenker, The Masterwork in Music 2, pp. 102–3.
Figure 2.13. (continued).
95
96
Explaining Tonality
supported by a descending fourth-progression C–B–A–G in the bass. Figure 2.14d then fills out mm. 13–30 by two nested motions from an inner voice, the larger one of which extends from the alto A in m. 13 through B, C, and D, to the soprano E in m. 31, and the more local one extends from the alto A in m. 13 through B, C, and C, to D in m. 21. These rising spans are then harmonized in figure 2.18e. The former leads to the passing 6/4 sonority in m. 30 while the latter moves to D. This complex motion completely obscures Schenker’s fourth-progression C–B–A–G in m. 18ff. and suggests that the fourth span in mm. 13–19 is generated after the analogous spans in mm. 1–8 and 40–44. Besides preferring derivations in which the same patterns occur within and between levels, Schenkerians also prefer derivations that show connections with other related pieces. Such decisions suggest that composers actually learn by reworking tonal models from one piece to another. A nice case in point has been discussed by David Beach and others. When analyzing several piano sonatas by Mozart, Beach noticed an interesting pattern; he found that in certain cases the return to the tonic for the Recapitulation was accomplished not by a simple motion to the dominant, but by a large-scale harmonic progression V–III–I.47 Beach showed that this pattern appears in several sonatas: the first and third movements of the Piano Sonata in F, K. 280, the first movement of the Piano Sonata in F, K. 332, and the first movement of the Piano Sonata in B, K. 333. A similar pattern can be found in the first movement of Beethoven’s Sonata for violin and piano, Op. 24.48 Although other composers certainly used this strategy, it seems extremely likely that Beethoven learned the pattern from Mozart; many of Beethoven’s works are clearly modeled on those of his illustrious forebear.49 On one leaf from the “Kafka” papers, Beethoven admitted as much by noting that a passage in C minor was “stolen from the Mozart symphony in C minor [sic].”50 This chapter has shown just how important ‘The Recursive Model’ and ‘The Global Paradigm’ were to Schenker’s thinking. According to ‘The Recursive Model,’ Schenkerian transformations can generate an almost limitless range of tonal surfaces when they are recursively applied to their own output. Since the prototypes and
Semper idem sed non eodem modo
97
Figure 2.14. Alternative sketch of “The Representation of Chaos.”
transformations satisfy the various laws of tonal voice leading and harmony, recursive use of the transformations will necessarily produce new pieces that also satisfy them. If we insist that all complete continuous monotonal pieces can be derived according to ‘The Global Paradigm,’ then Schenkerian transformations provide us with a recursive definition of the infinite set of tonal pieces. In the words of Schenker’s motto, ‘The Recursive Model’ and ‘The
98
Explaining Tonality
Global Paradigm’ do indeed show us how functional monotonal pieces are “always the same, but not in the same way.” Seen in broader context, however, Schenker’s motto also gives us an insight into his overall goals as a theorist. Schenker is often criticized for reducing functional monotonal music to some Procrustean formula, akin to “Three Blind Mice.”51 In a trivial sense, this characterization is right on target. Schenker was clearly preoccupied with showing how tonal music conforms to certain very simple principles. But this observation disguises a more profound point: by showing that “all of the [tonal] master works manifest identical laws of coherence,” Schenker demonstrated “a diversity in essential nature among the masters.”52 According to him, we can appreciate the significance of specific works only if we understand the general mechanisms that shape them. Or, to put it another way, “It is an inevitable principle that all complexity and diversity arise from a single simple element rooted in the consciousness or the intuition.”53 This notion is not really so different from those of theories found in other empirical disciplines, such as biology: indeed, just as Darwin tried to explain the diversity of life through a few fundamental processes, so Schenker tried to explain the extraordinary richness of functional tonal music via a limited number of tonal prototypes, transformations, and transformational levels. Furthermore, Schenker’s motto also underscores his concern for the scope of his theory. ‘The Recursive Model’ shows that Schenker was indeed concerned with trying to explain the broadest range of surfaces possible. To do this, he introduced an array of transformations that was large enough to account for all conceivable melodic configurations, all conceivable non-harmonic tones, and all conceivable chromaticisms. In this way, ‘The Recursive Model’ is intimately connected with ‘The Heinrich Maneuver’ and ‘The Complementarity Principle.’ Meanwhile, ‘The Global Paradigm’ allowed him to account for the behavior of particular lines and particular Stufen not only within the local context of an individual phrase or period, but also in the global context of an entire composition. This move expanded the scope of tonal theory considerably.
3
What Price Consistency? There can be little doubt that music theorists value consistency as much as any epistemic value. The reasons for this are clear enough. Claiming that something and its opposite are both true creates difficulties in making predictions; though prediction may not be the sole purpose of scientific inquiry, it is always the bottom line. To quote Quine: “[Prediction] is what gives science its empirical content, its link with nature. It is what makes the difference between science, however high flown and imaginative, and sheer fancy.”1 When we confirm a theory, we do so through “the verification of its predictions.”2 The more predictions we verify, the more confident we will be about using our theory. The same can be said about building and testing music theories, as Schenker made perfectly clear near the start of Kontrapunkt I. According to him: In this study, the beginning artist learns that tones, organized in such and such a way, produce one particular effect and none other, whether he wishes it or not. One can predict this effect: it must follow. Thus tones cannot produce any desired effect just because of the wish of the individual who sets them, for nobody has the power over tones in the sense that he is able to demand from them something contrary to their nature. Even tones must do what they do.3
Several pages later, Schenker reinforced the point by noting that he was primarily interested in describing the abstract effects that a particular tone might have on the motion of a voice and not the psychological effects it might have on a listener: “Tones mean nothing but themselves; they are as living beings with their own social laws.”4 Although Schenker went to great lengths to ensure the consistency of his theory, he repeatedly ran into problems in one particular
100
Explaining Tonality
area: the treatment of parallel perfect octaves and fifths. To understand the source of these contradictions, it is important to remember that tonal voice leading is founded on the notion that contrapuntal lines tend to move in contrary motion or in parallel thirds and sixths. In strict counterpoint, if a given pair of lines moves in the same direction, then they can never produce parallel perfect octaves and fifths between successive notes. But in functional monotonality, a given pair of voices can contain parallel perfect octaves and fifths provided that those lines involve doublings and figuration or combinations of harmonic and non-harmonic tones. This subtle change from strict counterpoint to functional tonality is an essential component of ‘The Heinrich Maneuver.’ We can also infer from Schenker’s motto, semper idem sed non eodem modo, that this principle applies consistently at all structural levels. At least, that is what we are led to believe. Unfortunately, Schenker was not always able to preserve the laws of tonal voice leading from one level to the next; he ran into particular difficulties maintaining the laws prohibiting parallel perfect intervals. William Benjamin has described the problem as follows: [O]n the one hand, [Schenker] accounts for certain foreground events in terms of the need to get rid of parallel fifths or octaves at a middleground level; on the other, he justifies certain parallel fifths and octaves in the foreground by noting that they are no longer present once a reduction to the next-higher level (a middleground) is accomplished.5
For his part, Schenker was perfectly aware of these inconsistencies; in par. 161 of Der freie Satz, he claimed that the foreground “fundamentally prohibits parallel octaves and fifths,” but was forced to concede that “the middleground frequently displays forbidden successions, it is then the task of the foreground to eliminate them.”6 We can illustrate the problem with a simple example. Figure 3.1 shows mm. 1–16 of Minuet II from Bach’s French Suite I in D Minor, BWV 812. As shown in figure 3.1a, the passage has two eight-bar phrases, each of which ends with a cadence in D minor. Each phrase is sequential in nature. These sequences are normally explained either in terms of the texture’s outer-voice counterpoint, in this case the repeating intervallic pattern 5–10–5–10, or in terms of local bass motion—in this case the repeating pattern of descending
What Price Consistency?
101
fifths transposed by descending seconds. Such explanations are the ones we normally encounter in undergraduate theory classes or harmony textbooks.7 Nevertheless, difficulties arise when we try to reconcile such explanations with a Schenkerian derivation of the music. From a global perspective, the most striking feature of the sequences is that they both support a stepwise descent in the upper voices from A to D, with A ornamented by B, G by A, and F by G. If we remove the ornamental notes and their supporting harmonies, then we are left with a chord succession I–VII–VI–V–I that violates the law prohibiting parallel perfect octaves and fifths (see figure 3.1b, ‘The Parallel Problem’). These inconsistencies suggest that our common-sense distinction between structural and ornamental tones conflicts with the general laws of tonal counterpoint. This conflict, which we will refer to as ‘The Parallel Problem,’ is particularly vexing for those who believe that Schenkerian analysis give us “artistic statements, in music, about music.”8 After all, how can we support such a view if our analyses include relationships that do not typically occur in tonal surfaces? This is not, however, the only problem with sequences. If we take the distinction between structural and ornamental notes a step further, then we might suppose that the first chord in each portion of the sequence has priority over the second (see figure 3.1c, ‘The Top-Down/Bottom-Up Problem.’). According to this scheme, the A chord in m. 7 should have priority over the D chord in m. 8. But this reading is unconvincing; as the goal of the entire phrase, the final tonic D in m. 8 surely has priority over the dominant in m. 7. Thus, describing sequences in “bottom-up” terms as some sort of repeating melodic, contrapuntal, or harmonic pattern conflicts with treating the phrase in “top-down” fashion as a prolongation of the tonic D. This topic, which we will refer to as ‘The Top-Down/ Bottom-Up Problem,’ is significant because it suggests that there may be inherent differences between the conventional ways in which we describe musical surfaces and the more radical ways in which Schenkerian theory derives them. In short, sequences present us with some thorny questions. Can we, in fact, generate sequences like the one in figure 3.1 without violating the basic laws of tonal voice leading? Can we resolve
102 Figure 3.1. Sequences. a. Bach, French Suite in D Minor, BWV 812, Minuet II, mm. 1–16
What Price Consistency?
103
Figure 3.1 (continued).
‘The Parallel Problem’ and ‘The Top-Down/Bottom-Up Problem’ using Schenkerian theory? This chapter sets out to answer these questions. Part 1 takes another look at sequential patterns like the one in figure 3.1 and suggests some concrete ways to overcome the hazards mentioned above. Next, Part 2 shows how these solutions can be grounded in familiar principles of counterpoint and in Schenker’s own concept of combined linear progressions; among other things, it shows that there are interesting connections between sequences and pedals. Part 3 then considers the analytical consequences of these ideas and presents detailed readings of several pieces, including the Minuet shown in figure 3.1.
Sequences Reconsidered To shed light on the nature of sequences, we will begin by looking at some familiar patterns, starting with the one in figure 3.2 (A typical ascending-fifth sequence). This particular phrase has two main components: a sequence and a cadence. The former consists of pairs of fifth-related harmonies that are transposed down a third: C–G,
104
Explaining Tonality
Figure 3.2. A typical ascending-fifth sequence.
A–E, F–C, D–A. The latter, meanwhile, consists of a typical progression II5^ –V–I. Innocuous as these observations may seem, they actually suggest that each component encapsulates a quite different principle of voice leading. These differences are most obvious in the soprano and alto voices. Indeed, figure 3.2 clearly shows that, while the two upper voices move by parallel thirds during the sequence, they ultimately converge on the tonic at the cadence. This point has important ramifications; among other things, it confirms the intuition that parallel motion creates a sense of openness, whereas convergence creates a sense of closure. We might also note that the soprano and alto lines make contrapuntal sense on their own; the other voices could be omitted and the phrase would still define the tonic C. This point is supported by the fact the two upper voices can potentially be supported by a long tonic pedal in the bass. We will return to this connection between sequences and pedals later in the chapter. But for the time being, we can simply conclude that sequences are ultimately contrapuntal, rather than harmonic, in origin and that they might be generated from parallel voice leading, rather than from the outer voice counterpoint. This observation allows us to generate the pattern in the manner shown in figure 3.3 (Deriving ascending-fifth sequences). Figure 3.3a begins by presuming that the sequence occurs within the context of a single phrase, in this case one that descends by step 8–7 3– 2– 1 and ends with the cadential progression II5^ –V –I. Since this derivation is context-dependent, we can avoid ‘The Top-Down/ Bottom-Up Problem.’ Next, the soprano tone 3 is transferred up an octave and the intervening space is filled by a stepwise descent
What Price Consistency?
105
Figure 3.3. Deriving ascending-fifth sequences.
(see figure 3.3b). In figure 3.3c, this descent is harmonized by a string of parallel thirds. Finally, figure 3.3d harmonizes this string of thirds according to two principles: each third must be supported by a root triad and each triad should not produce parallel perfect octaves and fifths with its neighbors. Significantly, the laws of tonal
106
Explaining Tonality
voice leading dictate that only one such harmonization is possible from a given starting chord. For example, although the third D/B can belong to triads on G or B, the latter creates parallel perfect octaves and fifths with the initial tonic chord. This leaves G as the only option. Similarly, when the third D/B descends to A/C, the latter can be harmonized by triads whose roots are F and A. But since the triad on F creates parallel perfect octaves and fifths with the preceding G chord, the triad on A must be picked. In other words, we can resolve ‘The Parallel Problem’ by generating the sequence from the upper voices and not the bass. The same strategy can be used with suitable adjustments to derive other sequences. Perhaps the easiest way to change the pattern in figure 3.3 is to invert the voices contrapuntally, thereby transforming the chain of parallel thirds into a chain of parallel sixths. This process is shown in figure 3.4 (Restacking ascendingfifth sequences). In figure 3.4a, the soprano spans an octave 8 to 1. The final stepwise descent 2– 1 is harmonized by a cadential progression II5^ –V–I. Next, figure 3.4b supports the stepwise descent of the soprano with a string of parallel sixths from E to E in the tenor voice. Finally, these parallel sixths are harmonized by root triads (see figure 3.4c). As with figure 3.3, the starting chord and laws of counterpoint dictate that only one such harmonization is possible. With further adjustments, we can generate still more sequences (see figure 3.5, Deriving ascending-third sequences). Figure 3.5a starts again with a phrase model consisting of a descent 3– 2– 1 in the soprano supported by a simple cadential progression I–II5^ – V8–7–I. As before, the soprano tone 3 is transferred up an octave. The intervening octave space is then filled by step (see figure 3.5b) and harmonized by a string of parallel thirds in the alto voice (figure 3.5c). But in figure 3.5d, the soprano E from the first third E/C is displaced over the second alto note B to create the pattern 3–4–3. Similar displacements occur when C/A descends to B/D, when A/F descends to G/E, and when F/D descends to E/C. Instead of creating a chain of parallel thirds, this process produces the succession 3–4–3–3–4–3–3–4–3–3–4–3. Although figures 3.5a–d set the soprano and alto voices against a single tonic pedal, figure 3.5e harmonizes the descent 4–3 as a passing motion; E/B–D/B are supported by a triad on E, C/G–B/G by a triad on C, A/E–G/E by
What Price Consistency?
107
Figure 3.4. Restacking ascending-fifth sequences.
a triad on A, and F/C–E/C by a triad on F. For variety, several chromaticisms have been added; these introduce applied chords that tonicize the triads on VI, IV, and II. Whereas the sequence in figure 3.5 elaborates the chain of parallel thirds by displacing the lines to create the pattern 3–4–3, other sequences can be created by inserting intermediary tones (see figure 3.6, Deriving descending-fifth sequences). This sequence is, of course, analogous to the one in figure 3.1. Figure 3.6a begins with a stepwise descent 5 –4 –3 –2 –1 in the soprano. This motion is supported by a
108 Figure 3.5. Deriving ascending-third sequences.
What Price Consistency?
109
Figure 3.6. Deriving descending-fifth sequences.
simple cadential progression I–II5^ –V8–7–I. Next, the soprano part is elaborated with escape tones (see figure 3.6b) and the new line is harmonized by a string of parallel thirds (see figure 3.6c). Figure 3.6d then harmonizes the soprano and alto lines exclusively with root triads. Once again, there is only one possible harmonization. Although the
110
Explaining Tonality
third A/F belongs to triads on D and F, the former is impossible because it produces parallel perfect octaves and fifths with the opening tonic chord. Similarly, when the third A/F leaps to F/D, the latter can be harmonized only by a triad on B because a triad on D creates parallel perfect octaves and fifths with the preceding F harmony. Figure 3.4 modifies the sequence in figure 3.3 by inverting the lines contrapuntally; the soprano line in figure 3.4 was originally the alto line in figure 3.3, and the tenor line in figure 3.4 was originally the soprano line in figure 3.3. But, if the alto line in figure 3.3 is placed in the bass, below the tenor voice, then this no longer the case; the resulting pattern is now reclassified as a descending 5–6 sequence. Figure 3.7 (Deriving descending 5–6 sequences) shows how to generate such a configuration. Figure 3.7a starts with a descent 3– 2– 1 in the soprano, harmonized by the cadential progression I–II5^ –V8–7–I. In figure 3.7b, 3 in the soprano line is transferred up an octave and the intervening space is filled by a stepwise descent. Figure 3.7c then supports the octave descent with a string of parallel tenths in the bass. Finally, figure 3.7d adds inner voices to this parallel string. Although these tenths can be harmonized in other ways—perhaps by a string of parallel 6/3 sonorities—figure 3.7d follows the same scheme as figure 3.3, thereby underscoring the close connections between these two forms of sequence. In the same vein, we can develop further transformations of our model. One such transformation is shown in figure 3.8 (Deriving alternative descending-fifth sequences). Figure 3.8a starts with a descent 3– 2– 1 in the soprano, harmonized by the cadential progression I–II5^ –V8–7–I. In figure 3.8b, the alto voice G moves up by step through A and B to C, with each of these notes repeated. This motion from an inner voice is then harmonized in parallel thirds (see figure 3.8c). Finally, figure 3.8d harmonizes the chain of thirds with root chords. Given the starting chord and the laws of counterpoint, only one harmonization is possible. Notice how the tenor part rises by step from C to G before descending back to E. A similar strategy is shown in figure 3.9 (Deriving ascending 5–6 sequences). Once again, figure 3.9a starts with a descent 3– 2– 1 in the soprano, harmonized by the cadential progression I–II5^ –V8–7–I. In figure 3.9b, the alto moves up by step from G to C, and in figure 3.9c it is supported by parallel thirds with the tenor.
111 Figure 3.7. Deriving descending 5–6 sequences.
112
Explaining Tonality
Figure 3.8. Deriving alternative descending-fifth sequences.
Next, figure 3.9d repeats each new member of the alto and tenor voice; it also displaces them so as to create the pattern 3–4–3–4–3–4–3. Finally, in figure 3.9e, this pattern is then harmonized by alternating root and first inversion triads. As in figure 3.5, a few chromaticisms have been added; these allow us to treat the 6/3 sonorities as applied dominants.
113 Figure 3.9. Deriving ascending 5–6 sequences.
114
Explaining Tonality
Figure 3.10. Simple mixture.
We have already shown in figures 3.5 and 3.9 that sequences often allow composers to introduce chromaticisms; in both cases, applied chords were added to tonicize particular harmonies. But there is another important source of chromaticism in tonal contexts, namely the principle of mixture; figure 3.10 (Simple mixture)
What Price Consistency?
115
Figure 3.11. Double mixture.
and figure 3.11 (Double mixture) derive two chromatic sequences. Figure 3.10 presents a variant of the descending-fifth sequence that we derived in figure 3.6. Figure 3.10a begins with a stepwise descent in the soprano from 5 to 1, though the third is mixed 5– 4 – 3– 2– 1. This motion is supported by a simple cadential progression V8–7–I.
116
Explaining Tonality
Next, the soprano part is elaborated with escape tones (see figure 3.10b) and the resulting line is harmonized by a string of parallel thirds (see figure 3.10c). Figure 3.10d then harmonizes the soprano and alto lines exclusively with root chords. Again, this harmonization is the only one possible. Although the third A/F in m. 2 belongs to triads on D and F, the former is impossible because it produces parallel perfect octaves and fifths with the opening tonic chord. Similarly, when the third A/F leaps to F/D, the latter can be harmonized only by a triad on B because a triad on D creates parallel perfect octaves and fifths with the preceding F harmony. Notice how the D harmony II serves as a pre-dominant at the cadence. Figure 3.11 follows the same strategy, though the double mixture is created by changing the quality of the triads on B, E, and A from major to minor. To sum up, figures 3.3–3.11 resolve the problems of generating sequences in two quite different ways. On the one hand, they overcome the ‘The Top-Down/Bottom-Up Problem’ by deriving sequences within the context of a phrase. This move guarantees that the goal of the sequence is always specified before its surface features are completely worked out. On the other hand, figures 3.3–3.11 sidestep ‘The Parallel Problem’ by deriving the sequence from parallel motion in the upper voices and not necessarily from the counterpoint between the outer voices. Not only does this approach contrast with most conventional accounts of sequences, but it also confirms the notion that sequences are basically contrapuntal, rather than harmonic in nature. Indeed, by showing that the bass motion is ultimately controlled by the upper-voice counterpoint, figures 3.3–3.11 also imply that harmonic function in a Riemannian sense emerges from contrapuntal motion. This point is evident both inside the sequence, where functionally related harmonies derive from parallel step motion, and at the cadence, where the penultimate dominant chord converges on the final tonic, with the soprano descending 2– 1, the alto ascending 7– 1, and the predominant chord converges on the dominant chord, with 4 and 6 both moving to 5. These derivations even suggest that interesting connections can be found between sequences and pedals. But this contrapuntal view of the sequence begs its own set of questions: to what extent can we find precursors of sequences in traditional
What Price Consistency?
117
contrapuntal theory, especially Fuxian species counterpoint, and how do the derivations in figures 3.3–3.11 fit with Schenkerian theory? In order to answer these questions, we must take a closer a look at the principles of strict counterpoint as formulated by Fux and assess their impact on Schenker’s thinking.
Sequences and Counterpoint At first sight, it seems utterly perverse to search for the origins of sequences in the pages of Gradus ad Parnassum. After all, Fux called for variety in melodic writing and discouraged the use of recurring melodic patterns (or monotonia) in strict counterpoint.9 And yet, his examples often contain an important component of the sequence, namely, strings of notes that move in a single direction by some fixed interval. This point is clear from figure 3.12 (Fux’s prototypical cantus firmi): although these melodies avoid exact repetitions of given melodic shapes, many of them end with a string of descending steps. In fact, Melody 6 ends with a string of three, Melody 1 with a string of four, and Melody 5 with a string of five! The significance of these stepwise descents becomes more apparent when we add a simple counterpoint to the texture (see figure 3.13, Typical two-voice counterpoint in First Species). Indeed, although both voices primarily move in contrary motion, they often move by parallel thirds or sixths when the cantus firmus descends by step at the cadence. These parallel strings actually create a strong feeling of motion that makes the closure at the cadence all the more compelling. In Fourth Species, this sense of propulsion is heightened when the parallel intervals are displaced to create chains of suspensions (see figure 3.14 , Typical two-voice counterpoint in Fourth Species). Textures with three or more voices provide even more opportunities for parallel motion by step. The reasons are clear: if the new counterpoint moves in contrary motion with the cantus firmus, then it will inevitably move in similar motion to the existing counterpoint; and if it moves in contrary motion with the counterpoint, then it will inevitably move in similar motion with the cantus
118 Figure 3.12. Fux’s prototypical cantus firmi.
Figure 3.13. Typical two-voice counterpoint in First Species. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Fig. 22.
What Price Consistency?
119
Figure 3.14. Typical two-voice counterpoints in Fourth Species. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Figs. 73, 74.
firmus. Fux himself offered some intriguing examples in his discussion of First Species in three voices: instead of recycling one of the cantus firmi from figure 3.12, he introduced some new prototypes in which the lowest voice simply ascends by step from C through D, E, and F to G, before ending back on C (see figure 3.15, Fux’s threevoice prototypes). The first prototype (figure 3.15a) has three descending thirds between the upper parts, whereas the second (figure 3.15b) has three ascending thirds between the lowest voices. In both of these cases, the soprano essentially moves in contrary motion with the bass. It seems very likely that Schenker had these prototypes in mind when he showed how Ursätze are usually transformed at the deep middleground.10 Similar examples are shown in figure 3.16 (Typical three-voice counterpoints in Fourth Species). Figure 3.16a is interesting for a couple reasons. In the first place, Fux harmonized the chain or 7–6 suspensions in the upper-voice parallels at the end of the passage with a sequential bass line F–C–D–A–D. For another, he included a pair of 7–6 suspensions against the repeated tone G in the bass in mm. 3–4. In his text, Fux singled out this passage, noting that the bass can be extended to create a pedal
120 Figure 3.15. Fux’s three-voice prototypes. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Figs. 91, 92.
Figure 3.16. Typical three-voice counterpoints in Fourth Species. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Figs. 141, 142.
What Price Consistency?
121
Figure 3.16 (continued).
point as shown in figure 3.16b. According to him, the results are “not only correct but even very beautiful.”11 As it happens, figures 3.16a–b open the door for mixed species. Although Fux did not address this topic systematically in Gradus ad Parnassum, he did include a few tantalizing examples, given here in figure 3.17 (Parallel motion in mixed species with three and four voices). In figure 3.17a, he put the cantus firmus in the bass, the soprano in Second Species, the alto in Third, and the tenor in Fourth. Notice how the stepwise descent in the bass near the end of the example supports quasi-sequential motion in the upper voices. Similarly, in figure 3.17b, he showed a three-voice texture in which the melody moves in First Species, the alto in Fourth, and the bass in Second. In this case, the parallel motion of the upper voices starting in m. 4 is supported by a sequential bass part, F–G, E–F, D–E, and C–D. These examples suggest that pedals and sequences often spring from the same source: pedals can sometimes be created when chains of stepwise parallel lines move against a static voice, whereas sequences can arise when such strings are supported by a recurring bass pattern. This ties in nicely with our discussion of figures 3.3–3.11. Whereas Fux avoided sequences, Schenker was openly hostile to them. His response was simply to reject them altogether. For example, when discussing the passage in figure 3.1a, he scoffed at the idea that the progression I–IV–VII–III–VI–II–I in mm. 1–8 is an “idle sequence” and insisted that it simply defines the tonic D
122
Explaining Tonality
Figure 3.17. Parallel motion in mixed species with three and four voices. a. From Fux, The Study of Counterpoint, Fig. 204.
b. From Fux, The Study of Fugue, Ex. 61.
minor.12 Later, in the essay “Das Organische der Fuge” (1926), Schenker claimed that the word sequence “has no validity” and that “the mere fact of its existence as a theoretical term does not lend it any credibility as a concept.”13 And, in Der freie Satz (1935), he rejected the term on the grounds that it described local details without explaining global processes.14 Yet, like Fux, Schenker certainly recognized the significance of parallel stepwise counterpoint, especially over a pedal. This is already apparent in his discussion of mixed species in the latter portions of Kontrapunkt II (1922). Here, Schenker specifically referred to examples from Fux like those shown in figures 3.16–3.17. According to him, it is irrelevant whether the florid counterpoints are consonant or dissonant with the bass; all that matters is that they make contrapuntal sense with
What Price Consistency?
123
Figure 3.18. Parallel linear progressions within a single Stufe. From Schenker, Der freie Satz, Fig. 97.2.
each other.15 This crucial idea fits with our observation that the soprano and alto parts in figure 3.3 make contrapuntal sense in their own right. Matters become more complex when Schenker shifted his attention from the purely intervallic world of strict counterpoint to the triadic world of functional monotonality. Now the stepwise parallel strings are constrained by the underlying harmonic motion of the music. Schenker took up this particular issue with a vengeance in his discussion of parallel linear progression in par. 224–26 of Der freie Satz.16 In fact, these paragraphs appear in a general discussion of the various ways in which two or more linear progressions can be combined (par. 221–29); they mention sequences only in passing.17 The main thrust of Schenker’s argument is clear: when two or more linear progressions are combined, one is primary (or leading) and the others are secondary. To prioritize one linear progression over another, Schenker insisted that each progression must be evaluated according to the order in which it is generated from the background.18 This is readily apparent from figure 3.18 (Parallel linear progressions within a single Stufe). Here Schenker sketched a short passage from the third movement of Mozart’s Piano Sonata in A Minor, K. 310. He suggested that the soprano voice leads and the alto follows, and that both voices move over a pedal A. Given the essential role that Urlinien play in generating the melodic profile of a piece, leading progressions are frequently found in the soprano voice. But, as Schenker was quick to point out, they need not be confined to this register: “once one has decided whether the leading linear progression is in the lower or in the upper voice, one must understand the counterpointing progressions as upper or
124
Explaining Tonality
lower thirds, tenths, or sixths.”19 These points are implied in figures 3.3–3.11. Since these derivations proceed from a single stepwise descent that we subsequently harmonized in thirds or sixths, they necessarily treated one linear progression as the leader. Furthermore, we have already noted that the various parallel voices can be redistributed in the texture and even inverted contrapuntally. We used these strategies to derive the sequences in figure 3.4 from those in figure 3.3. Besides evaluating the status of linear progressions, Schenker also classified parallel linear progressions in two ways.20 The first way is according to the length of the leading progression. Since he believed that genuine linear progressions can span only the intervals contained within triads, this means that the leader will normally span a third, fourth, fifth, sixth, or octave; in the case of figure 3.18, for example, it articulates an octave span. That being said, it is important to note that the follower need not be the same length as the leader. Thus, whereas the leader in figure 3.18 projects an octave line, the follower is far more ad hoc in nature and barely a linear progression at all. Indeed, as William Rothstein has recently pointed out: “[T]he one instance in which Schenker admits non-harmonic Züge is in the case of two Züge moving in parallel thirds, sixths, or tenths.”21 In this respect, the “leading” Zug arpeggiates the harmony; the “follower” goes along passively for the contrapuntal ride. The second way in which Schenker classified parallel linear progressions is according to whether they horizontalize a single Stufe or whether they fill in the space between two Stufen. We have already seen the first possibility in figure 3.18; in this case the parallel linear progressions compose out a single A-major chord. The second possibility is shown in figure 3.19 (Parallel linear progressions between different Stufen). This figure derives an ascending 5–6 sequence along the lines shown in figure 3.9. Now, however, the phrase as a whole is controlled by a stepwise descent 5–4– 3 in the soprano and a cadential progression I–II5^ –V7–I (see figure 3.19a). Before reaching the cadence, the alto line ascends G–A– B–C–D–E (see figure 3.19b). In figure 3.19c, every note of the alto voice is repeated, and in figure 3.19d this string is harmonized with alternating thirds and fourths. Finally, in figure 3.19e the pedal is replaced by a string of alternating root and first-inversion chords.
125 Figure 3.19. Parallel linear progressions between different Stufen.
126
Explaining Tonality
As a result, the alto voice appears to span a minor seventh from G to F. But this span is not, in Schenker’s terms, a true linear progression; instead of composing out a single line of counterpoint, the span actually connects the alto voice of the opening tonic Stufe with the soprano voice of the II5^ . The span is therefore an example of what Schenker termed “motion from an inner voice.” Although he devoted a paragraph of Der freie Satz to so-called seventh progressions (Die Septzüge), Schenker conceded that they usually arise from changes of register between voices, rather than from genuine linear progressions within a single voice.22
Analytical Implications Having solved ‘The Parallel Problem’ and ‘The Top-Down/BottomUp Problem’ and grounded these solutions in contrapuntal principles and combined linear progressions, let us now consider some analytical implications. We will try to show how particular sequential patterns can be derived within the context of specific pieces. A good place to start is with Bach’s Little Prelude in C Major, BWV 924. This short through-composed prelude contains two sequences and a dominant pedal. The first sequence appears in mm. 1–3 and consists of the pattern C–G, D–A, E in the bass. This pattern leads to a second sequence in mm. 3–6 that descends A–B–C; E–F– G–A; C–D–E–F. The long dominant pedal in mm. 7–17 eventually resolves onto a tonic chord at the final cadence in m. 18. Schenker himself analyzed this prelude on at least two occasions: in Der Tonwille 4 (1923) and again in Der freie Satz.23 His feadings are conflated in figure 3.20 (Schenker’s analysis of Bach’s Little Prelude in C Major, BWV 924). In Der freie Satz, Schenker’s main insight was to suggest that the Urlinie is composed out at the deep middleground by a pair of unfoldings E–C and B–D (see figure 3.20a–b).24 He suggested that the unfolding E–C is inverted contrapuntally to create an upper sixth and that this interval is filled to create a sixth progression E–F–G–A–B–C. This sixth progression is then split into two segments, E–F–G and A–B–C, with the latter segment transferred down an octave (see figure 3.20c).25 In Der freie Satz and Der Tonwille, Schenker derived the first sequence from the
127 Figure 3.20. Schenker’s analysis of Bach’s Little Prelude in C Major, BWV 924. Adapted from Schenker, Der Tonwille, vol. 4, and Der freie Satz, Fig. 43.b.
128
Explaining Tonality
first segment by harmonizing it in parallel tenths with the bass E/C–F/D–G/E (see figures 3.20c–d). He followed much the same strategy in Der Tonwille to derive the second sequence (mm. 3–6). This pattern stems from a 5–6 motion between the outer voices that is subsequently elaborated by motion in the inner voice. As it stands, figure 3.20 offers a fascinating analysis of Bach’s prelude, one that captures both the broad sweep and subtle details of the musical fabric. And yet, this reading is not without its problems. Indeed, although Schenker deliberately avoided any mention of the term sequence and overcame ‘The Top-Down/Bottom-Up Problem’ by deriving both sequences from a global prototype, he was unable to avoid ‘The Parallel Problem’ because he still derived both sequences quite conventionally from the outer-voice counterpoint. In the first sequence, he sidestepped the parallels by omitting the inner voices altogether; he simply claimed that any middleground parallels are avoided by inserting intervening harmonies to create the pattern 10–5–10–5–10.26 In the second sequence, he finessed ‘The Parallel Problem’ by deriving all four voices simultaneously. Once again, he insisted that the purpose of the foreground was to cover up the implied parallel perfect octaves and fifths of the middleground, in this case by a string of 5–6 motions. Figure 3.21 (Alternative analysis of Bach’s Little Prelude in C Major, BWV 924) tries to overcome ‘The Parallel Problem’ in figure 3.20. Figures 3.21a–b correspond to the progressions shown in figures 3.20a–b. Unlike figure 3.20, which derives the two sequences from linear interval patterns in the outer voices, figure 3.21 derives them from chains of parallel thirds in the upper register. Figure 3.21c includes a chain of ascending thirds E/C–F/D–G/E– A/F. These thirds are elaborated in two ways: the ascent E/C–F/D– G/E is elaborated by lower thirds E/C–D/B–F/D–E/C–G/E, and the progression from G/E to A/F is transferred down an octave and filled in G/E–F/D–E/C–D/B–C/A–B/G–A/F (see figure 3.21d). Once the string of thirds in the upper voices has been generated, it can be harmonized in the manner shown in figure 3.21e. Significantly, there is only one way to harmonize this string; this harmonization inevitably produces the two sequences found at the surface of the music. Besides circumventing ‘The Parallel Problem,’ figure 3.21 also reveals some interesting connections between the
129 Figure 3.21. Alternative analysis of Bach’s Little Prelude in C Major, BWV 924.
130
Explaining Tonality
sequences in mm. 1–6 and the pedal in mm. 7–17; in particular, the ascending sixth progression E–C is balanced by a descending sixth progression B–D. The main difference between the sequence and the pedal is that the former harmonizes each successive parallel third with a new chord. We encounter many of the same analytical issues when we try to analyze Bach’s Prelude in C Minor, WTC I, BWV 847. Once again, Schenker discussed the piece on several occasions. In Harmonielehre (1906), he cited mm. 1–4 as examples of a subdominant fifth and a pedal point.27 Almost twenty years later, he published an extended analysis of the entire prelude in Die Musik (1923); this analysis was subsequently revised for the final portion of his essay “Das Organische der Fuge,” from Das Meisterwerk in der Musik 2 (1926).28 And, finally, in Der freie Satz, Schenker included a reduction of mm. 1–18 in his discussion of combined linear progressions; this reduction refines his analyses from the 1920s.29 Broadly speaking, Bach’s C-minor prelude follows the same basic format as the Little Prelude in C, though it is somewhat larger in scope.30 Like its diminutive cousin, the C-minor prelude begins with a long expansion of the tonic (mm. 1–18) that includes prominent sequential motion. The sequence eventually leads to an elaborate dominant pedal (mm. 21–33). This pedal finally moves onto a tonic harmony in mm. 34–38. With regard to the initial tonic expansion (mm. 1–18), Schenker rightly observed that it has four distinct components. As he noted in the Harmonielehre, mm. 1–4 use a simple pedal to establish the tonic C minor. Next, mm. 5–11 consist of a passing motion from E to B in the Urlinie. Although mm. 11–14 continue the downward trajectory of the Urlinie, they change the accompanying lines in order to avoid a premature arrival on C. Finally, mm. 14–18 use a 5–6 exchange to complete the octave descent E–E in the Urlinie and return to the tonic chord. Schenker’s derivation of mm. 1–18 is summarized in figure 3.22 (Schenker’s analysis of Bach’s Prelude in C Minor, WTC 1, BWV 847, mm. 1–18). Figure 3.22a gives the foreground graph that originally appeared in “Das Organische der Fuge.” Next, figure 3.22b gives the middleground reduction that he presented in Der freie Satz. When we compare these two readings, it is clear that they both rely heavily on the string of parallel tenths that occur between
What Price Consistency?
131
Figure 3.22. Schenker’s analysis of Bach’s Prelude in C Minor, WTC I, BWV 847, mm. 1–18. From Schenker, The Masterwork in Music 2, pp. 48–49.
the soprano and bass. According to Schenker, the main body of the sequence, mm. 5–11, is generated from a string of descending 7–6 sequences, akin to those found in Fourth Species textures like the one cited in figure 3.14a. His view of the prototypical voice leading is given here as figure 3.22c. Notice how Schenker suggested how the line might continue in mm. 12–18; he added the hypothetical bass tones F–E–D–C in parentheses. Although this interpretation initially seems plausible, it seems less satisfactory when we compare figure 3.22 with figure 3.23 (Alternative analysis of Bach’s Prelude in C Minor, WTC 1, BWV 847,
132
Explaining Tonality
Figure 3.23. Alternative analysis of Bach’s Prelude in C Minor, WTC I, BWV 847, mm. 1–18.
mm. 1–18). In figure 3.22a, Schenker proposed that mm. 5–11 project a string of parallel first-inversion chords, separated by applied chords. For example, the motion from A6 in m. 5 to G6 in m. 6 is elaborated by an applied harmony that tonicizes G6. But in figure 3.22b these applied chords are reduced out, leaving a succession of parallel perfect fifths E/A–D/G–C/F–B/E. Figure 3.23 tries to overcome these problems: it circumvents ‘The Parallel Problem’ that mars figure 3.22 and it maintains Schenker’s position that dissonances are ultimately passing in nature. Like figure 3.7 this derivation places the string of parallel tenths in the soprano and bass
What Price Consistency?
133
Figure 3.24. Two analyses of the Prelude from Bach’s Partita No. 3 for Solo Violin. BWU 1006 From Schenker, The Masterwork in Music 1, pp. 40–41.
(see figure 3.23a) and, like figure 3.9, it repeats each successive soprano note (see figure 3.23b). Finally, instead of harmonizing the repeated tones with root chords, figures 3.23c and 3.23d support them with inversions; this strategy preserves the prominent parallel tenths between the outer voices. One of the most interesting features of Bach’s C-minor prelude is the fact that it uses apparent sequential motion to support an octave descent in the upper voice. The descent occurs at the middleground in figure 3.22. But it does raise the possibility that such motions might occur at even deeper levels. This possibility is clearly shown in Figure 3.24 (Two analyses of the Prelude from Bach’s Partita No. 3 for Solo Violin, BWV 1006).31 Significantly, Schenker supported the descent 8– 1 in the Urlinie with a sequential harmonic progression I–V/VI–VI–V/IV– IV–V/II–II–V–I (see figure 3.24a). However, figure 3.24b presents an alternative derivation analogous to the one presented in figure 3.5; in particular, it adapts Schenker’s reading to
134
Explaining Tonality
highlight the chain of descending parallel sixths. This being said, it is important to stress that sequential settings of 8-line Ursätze are not common, and it is quite possible that Schenker himself would have regraphed the Prelude later in his career. One reason for this is that 8-line prototypes tend to divide 8–5 – 1 with an intermediate motion onto the dominant, rather than 8–4 – 1 as in this particular prelude.32 Nevertheless, the graph in figure 3.24 certainly captures many special features of the work, and it confirms David Smyth’s claim that 8 -line Ursätze often have important formal implications.33 Given that the preceding analyses have focused on the ways in which Bach used sequences and pedals, it seems fitting to round things off by reconsidering Minuet II from his French Suite No. 1. As we saw in figure 3.1a, the first part of this piece has two eight-bar phrases. These phrases both begin and end in the tonic D minor, and both are built from the same sequential progression I–IV–VII– III–VI–II–V–I. The second section also opens with another eightmeasure phrase (mm. 17–25), though it ends with a clear half cadence in D minor. Motivically, this phrase develops the main material from m. 1. Bach presents this gesture three times in the bass and tenor registers on D (m. 17), G (m. 18), and A (m. 19), and twice more in the soprano on C (m. 21) and D (m. 22). Just like mm. 9–16, these motivic statements are accompanied by continuous eighth notes. Having reached the half cadence in m. 25, Bach brings back verbatim the entire opening section (mm. 25–40). Unlike the first section, however, mm. 17–40 are not repeated. Although Schenker did not publish a graph of this particular movement, we can fill this gap in the manner shown in figure 3.25 (Analysis of Bach’s Minuet II, French Suite in D Minor, BWV 812). Figure 3.25a suggests that the piece can be derived from a 5line prototype in D minor. Figure 3.25b then shows how the half cadence in m. 24 is generated by a division of the Urlinie at the deep middleground. Next, figure 3.25c derives mm. 1–16 as a descent from 5 to 1 just like mm. 33–40. Figure 3.25d then shows how the descending fifth sequences in mm. 8–16 and 33–40 are generated from third chains in the upper voices; this derivation follows the general scheme outlined in figure 3.6. Finally, figure 3.25e derives the same sequence in mm. 1–8 and 25–32 from analogous chains of thirds. Unlike mm. 9–16 and 33–40, however, the
135 Figure 3.25. Analysis of Bach, French Suite in D Minor, BWV 812, Minuet II.
136
Explaining Tonality
chain of parallel thirds is submerged beneath a soprano line that rises from A (m. 1) through B (m. 2) and C (m. 3) to D (m. 4). Once m. 4 is reached, the soprano line takes over the lower third of the chain, thereby demonstrating Bach’s fondness for invertible counterpoint. Yet again, the derivation shown in figure 3.25 avoids both ‘The Parallel Problem’ and ‘The Top-Down/BottomUp Problem.’ In this chapter, we have used our discussion of sequences as a pretext for considering the consistency of Schenkerian theory. We have seen that Schenker was ultimately inconsistent in the way he treated parallel perfect octaves and fifths. Although he insisted that such phenomena do not occur when a given pair of voices move between successive harmonic tones, his analyses are littered with parallels, especially when the music is sequential. When these anomalies appear at the foreground, Schenker claimed that they can be eliminated by appealing to the behavior of the middleground, and when they appear at the middleground, he proposed that they can be eliminated at the foreground. To resolve these inconsistencies, we found a new way to generate sequences, one that focused less on the outer voice counterpoint and more on the stepwise motion of the upper voices. This strategy conformed very nicely with Schenker’s own discussion of combined linear progressions in par. 224–26 of Der freie Satz. Besides eliminating an important inconsistency in Schenkerian theory, this solution has several important consequences. For one thing, it suggests that, although certain aspects of tonal motion are controlled by the outer voice counterpoint, others can be understood only in terms of the inner voices. When graphing a particular piece, the analyst should not simply trace the motion of the soprano and bass voices; he or she should also monitor the behavior of the tenor and alto voices. This point ties in with our discussion of Ursätze in chapter 2. For another, our discussion has shown that harmonic function is intimately connected to voice leading. In particular, we found that bass motion by fifth inevitably arises when the upper voices move by step in a single direction by parallel thirds or sixths. This observation fits in nicely with our discussion of ‘The Complementarity Principle’ in chapter 1. In the same vein, we
What Price Consistency?
137
have also noted that sequences and pedals are actually related phenomena. This point is interesting for a couple of reasons. On the one hand, it provides further justification for 8- and 5-line Ursätze; instead of thinking of them as containing “unsupported stretches,” we can think of them as descending across a pedal. On the other hand, by showing connections between pedals and sequences we can explain why both often appear in the same piece. As we saw in our analysis of Bach’s Little Prelude in C, BWV 924, the underlying counterpoint of both can, in fact, be very close indeed. Another important consequence of this solution is that it underscores a fundamental methodological difference between Schenker’s concerns and those of many other music theorists. As mentioned in the Introduction, there are important differences between describing what happens in a piece of music and explaining why these things happen or how to make them happen. While many music theorists are concerned with describing music in “bottom-up” terms as a string of surface events, Schenker was intent on explaining how these surfaces are generated “top-down” from tonal prototypes. This dramatic shift in perspective does not mean that conventional descriptions of sequences are necessarily wrong or that Schenker himself never took time to describe surface events. Nothing could be further from the truth. All empiric inquiries must start from careful descriptions of phenomena and, like any good empiricist, Schenker often provided the reader with extremely vivid descriptions of how a piece sounds. For example, in his analysis of Bach’s Little Prelude No. 1 in C Major, BWV 924, he described the music in narrative terms, suggesting that Bach wanted “to spin a tale” and create suspense by “exquisite tensions and convolutions . . . an insatiable desire for first-rate suspense and intricacy.”34 Yet, Schenker’s emphasis on “top-down” processes underscores that there is more to understanding music than describing its local effects; describing pieces and deriving them are simply not the same thing. Derivation requires something more. But why should “top-down” derivations mean more to Schenker than “bottom-up” descriptions? Who, in fact, needs to understand the significance of global prototypes? To answer these questions, it is helpful to take Schenker’s narrative metaphor a bit further.
138
Explaining Tonality
Imagine, for a moment, that we have just seen a “whodunnit” at the local theater. The production involves at least three different groups of people: the author of the play, the performers, and the audience. Of these, it is clear that the author must have some “topdown” sense of the play; if not, then, it is unclear how he/she could reveal the various clues in the right order so that the final revelation is convincing. Equally, the audience must not know who dunnit, at least on first viewing. Such knowledge would deprive them of the thrill of deducing that Professor Plum bludgeoned Miss Scarlet with the candlestick in the library. Their response will initially be governed by “bottom-up” concerns. The actors, however, seem to stand somewhere in between. To understand a character’s motivations and personality, the actors must know who perpetrated the crime and yet they must not give the game away to the audience. The ability to know something without betraying this knowledge would appear to be the essence of acting. By the same token, it is composers rather than listeners who must know in advance the global structure of pieces, and it is the task of the performer to mediate between these two groups. Schenker made his point quite clear on several occasions. In his essay “Forsetzung der Urlinie-Betrachtung: I,” from Das Meisterwerk in der Musik 1 (1925), he noted that “the composer’s business is the composingout of a chord; this task leads him from a background Ursatz through prolongations and diminutions to a foreground setting.” Meanwhile, “It is up to the reader or player, conversely, to retrace the path from foreground to the background.”35 Schenker reinforced his point a few lines later. When analyzing the opening to Mozart’s Sonata in A, K. 331, he uncharacteristically placed his foreground sketch above those of the middleground: “The voiceleading strata are deliberately viewed from the perspective of the observer not from that of the composer—that is, they are presented, as an exception, from the foreground to the background.”36 The same idea was apparently behind Schenker’s claim in Der freie Satz that “the ability in which all creativity begins—the ability to compose extempore, to improvise fantasies and preludes—lies only in a feeling for the background, middleground, and foreground.”37 In other words, the tension between traditional accounts of the sequence and Schenkerian derivations stems from the fact that the
What Price Consistency?
139
goals of traditional music theory are ultimately quite different from those of Schenkerian theory. Whereas traditional music theory is often motivated by a desire to describe how we, as informed listeners, experience a piece as it flows from beginning to end, Schenkerian theory is more concerned with explaining how expert tonal composers tacitly understand how their music fits together locally and globally. This does not mean, of course, that listening and composing are completely unrelated activities or that informed listeners understand music in fundamentally different ways to expert composers. If there were no points of intersection, then it is hard to understand why informed listeners are able to recognize and value exceptional feats of compositional prowess. But it is important to recognize that they may be different and that such differences have enormous consequences for the music theorist.
4
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales” “My [theory] shows that the art of music is much simpler than present-day [theories] would have it appear.”1 For anyone reading Der freie Satz, this statement sticks out like a sore thumb. Schenker’s intricate analyses often make pieces look anything but simple; at times they seem even more complex than the scores themselves. And yet, there can be no doubt that Schenker meant what he said; he expressed the same sentiment in various ways on other occasions. When discussing the structure of prototypical cantus firmi in Kontrapunkt I, for example, Schenker defended the quest for simplicity on ethical grounds, claiming that “it be may be artistically ethical to match a simple situation only with a simple beginning—that is, a beginning with a tonic—instead of contradicting its simplicity with a complicated beginning.”2 Similarly, at the end of his essay “Eläuterungen,” he announced: The art of geniuses is as simple as the simplest passing-tone progression; but for precisely that reason it is for ever inimitable and unattainable to nongeniuses. The latter lack a bond that is for them unfathomably God-derived, the bond which connects back to ultimate simplicity; consequently they go in a thousand different directions, always anxious because they have no sense of origin.3
In the same vein, he noted, “[W]here art is concerned, only geniuses pertain, for they bring to bear the utmost economy in feeling and creative activity.”4 Just as Schenker saw simplicity as a hallmark of musical genius, so philosophers also see it as a guiding principle of theory construction. Indeed, it was regarded as a basic epistemic value, long before William of Ockham supposedly authored the famous dictum Entia non multiplicanda sunt praeter necessitatem.5 There are times, however,
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales”
141
when simplicity is no longer a virtue: as the philosopher Paul Churchland notes, “simply to hold fewer beliefs from a given set is . . . to be less adventurous, but it is not necessarily to be applauded.”6 Churchland adds that the desire for simplicity may even end up being counterproductive, in which case the result is “perversity not parsimony!”7 Nevertheless, before we dismiss Schenker’s claims as mere wishful thinking, it is worth considering one specific situation in which the desire for parsimony was uppermost in Schenker’s mind: this is his treatment of modes and scales. Modes and scales have, of course, played a pivotal role in shaping our notions of music theory. Over the centuries, music theorists have expended considerable energy discussing a broad spectrum of modes and scales, ranging from the so-called Church modes to major, minor, and chromatic scales, and even a plethora of exotic scales. They have primarily been guided by the simple belief that the behavior of a particular piece is determined by intervallic properties of some source scale. In some cases, they have assumed that harmonic systems derive from scales. We will refer to this particular assumption as ‘The Myth of Scales.’ Seen from Schenker’s perspective, however, the musical soundscape looked very different. Instead of viewing the behavior of functional monotonal music in terms of diatonic scales, Schenker envisioned it in terms of prototypes and recursive transformations. His picture of the tonal universe was revolutionary because it proposes a single system of prototypes, transformations, and transformational rules, rather than myriad interacting scale-based systems. Through the concepts of mixture and tonicization, he was able to explain not only how tonal surfaces can be highly chromatic, but also how they can contain a wide variety of modal and exotic inflections. Conceptually, this new system represents a dramatic step forward in theoretical simplification. For convenience, we will address the issue of modality and exoticism in five stages. To begin with, we will discuss the role modes and scales play in traditional theory; we will see just how strongly entrenched ‘The Myth of Scales’ is in the theoretical community. Next, we will consider Schenker’s general discussion of scales and his case against ‘The Myth of Scales.’ We will then use Schenkerian theory to help us understand the behavior of
142
Explaining Tonality
Common-Practice works that have a strong Lydian or Dorian flavor. Next, we will analyze certain exotic passages from a Schenkerian perspective—these passages include pentatonic, whole-tone, and octatonic material. Finally, we will see how Schenkerian theory might shed light on the emergence of functional tonality in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. Once again, we will see that Schenker’s work provides a simplified solution to some familiar problems in the history of music theory.
Modes and Scales in Traditional Theory At least since Classical Antiquity, music theorists have tried to explain the behavior of melodies by appealing to some concept of mode or scale. Ancient Greek music theory developed a system of eight modes, a corrupt version of which was transmitted into Western music theory during the Middle Ages in order to classify plainchants. Medieval theorists adopted this system for several reasons.8 For one thing, performers needed an effective way to proceed from one chant to another; this was of paramount importance in singing antiphons and psalms. For another, performers needed a way to learn and teach the enormous repertory of chants that appear throughout the liturgical year; grouping them into families provided one way to do this. For some theorists, the impetus may have been purely academic—to widen the frontiers of knowledge. Whatever their motivation, Medieval theorists generally used four criteria to explain such classification schemes: final; range or ambitus; species of fourth, fifth, and octave; and reciting tone. Although these explanations worked for many chants, they were not always completely accurate; in some cases, chants were even rewritten to fit with theoretical norms; in others, recalcitrant chants were ignored completely. Theorists sometimes compensated for other anomalies by discussing irregular or imperfect modes. By the turn of the sixteenth century, however, theorists ran into problems when they tried to extend their system of modal classification to polyphonic music. At first, they classified pieces according to the mode of the tenor; but as they tried to be more specific, the difficulties soon multiplied. Some of them stemmed from the fact that individual strands of the polyphony had different finals
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales”
143
and different ranges, whereas others stemmed from the fact that each line was constrained by a growing sense of triadicity. Even today, the task of explaining mode in polyphony remains one of the thorniest problems in contemporary music scholarship. The problems of applying melodic categories to harmonic systems multiply when we try to use major and minor scales to explain tonal music written from the Common-Practice Period. Certainly, there has been no shortage of attempts to do so. Many music theory textbooks claim that the properties of functional triadic tonality derive from those of diatonic scales. According to William J. Mitchell, for example, “[T]he major and minor scales, which form the basis of this study of harmony, are diatonic.”9 Similarly, Edward Aldwell and Carl Schachter claim that “[f]rom the time of the ancient Greeks through the nineteenth century, most Western art music was based on diatonic scales.”10 Scholarly publications have likewise promoted this point of view. For example, Pieter van den Toorn has remarked: Tonality is viewed here in its more restricted sense as a hierarchic system of pitch relations based on the diatonic major scale (the C scale) . . . the historical development of which can be traced from the beginning of the seventeenth century to the end of the nineteenth.11
Or, to quote Richard Taruskin: Just as we get our sense of Mozart’s C major not only from his use of the “C scale on C” but also from the way the “black keys” are related hierarchically to the tones of the scale, so, if we are able to conceive of the octatonic collection as a tonality, we must be able to account for the use of the “other” four tones in relation to it.12
Taruskin adds that, in Mozart’s case, “even the simplest minuet or sonatina movement will contain tones foreign to the C scale that defines its key.”13 But what does Taruskin really mean when he says that Mozart’s C major is referable to the “C scale on C”? How does this scale define the key of C major? How are the chromatic notes in Mozart’s simplest minuet or sonatina related hierarchically to the members of this scale? Are these “wrong” notes really intrusions of some other scale type? Do the properties of the tonal system really depend on those of major and minor scales?
144
Explaining Tonality
As it happens, there are good reasons to be cautious about answering these questions. Even on an intuitive level, we know that scale membership is neither necessary nor sufficient for determining the tonality of a passage or piece (see figure 4.1, Scale membership and tonality). It is easy, for example, to imagine how a key might be defined by progressions that do not contain every note of the relevant scale. Take, for example, the progression I–V–I in figure 4.1a; this passage clearly lacks two members of the C-major scale—4 and 6 . Similarly, the mere presence of a given scale need not guarantee that a passage is “in” the corresponding key. As shown in figure 4.1b, a passage built exclusively from the notes of a C-major scale might actually be in A Aeolian, D Dorian, E Phrygian, and so forth. To complicate matters further, we can also establish a tonality using progressions built from pitches outside the diatonic collection. Figures 4.1c and 4.1d give some simple cases in point. Figure 4.1c shows a short progression in D minor. Here, the opening chords move from I to VI6 and back via VIIo7 to I5, while the final cadence tonicizes D by the familiar succession VII6–I. The progression contains several interesting chromaticisms. The B (m. 1) is a simple mixture. The A (m. 3) seems to imply a local tonicization of C (VII), though the leading tone is immediately raised to tonicize D. Meanwhile, in figure 4.1d, we find a progression from the tonic of E to the dominant of F. This motion is achieved by a common-tone progression onto a diminished-seventh sonority in m. 2. The chromatic tones D and F in this sonority are both mixtures. The B(⫽A) and D in m. 2 then appear as tonicizations; they inflect the subsequent V$5 of F in m. 3. These last two examples show very clearly that tonality does not simply depend on the presence of the “right” notes, but rather on the fact that particular notes appear in the “right” order according to some general laws of tonal voice leading and harmony. Figures 4.1c and d are particularly telling in this regard; although both passages are tonal, neither is referable to the appropriate diatonic scale. Figure 4.1c is not built exclusively from the notes of a D-minor scale and figure 4.1d is not derivable from an E-major scale. In both cases, the passages are built exclusively from the notes of the octatonic scale shown in figure 4.1e.
145 Figure 4.1. Scale membership and tonality.
146
Explaining Tonality
Schenkerian Theory and Scales One indication that Schenker was suspicious about ‘The Myth of Scales’ is that he seldom, if ever, discussed scales explicitly. Yet, through a number of passing comments, he left us in no doubt about his views. Among the most colorful of these appears at the start of Kontrapunkt 1, in a general discussion of prototypical cantus firmi. Although Schenker’s immediate goal was to discuss the essential behavior of tonal melodies, he took the opportunity to explain why a simple appeal to scale type provides an inadequate explanation.14 If we ignore his condescending attitudes to music written before Bach and to music theorists before him, Schenker’s objection to ‘The Myth of Scales’ is clear enough: since scales can at best describe only purely linear relationships, they are incapable of explaining how voice leading and harmony interact in functional monotonal contexts.15 In other words, scales may describe what pitches are present in a given context, they do not explain why these pitches are related in some ways and not others. Whatever value they may have as “descriptive tools” for classifying melodic patterns, scales have little power to explain the behavior of specific notes or chords.16 To support these bold claims, Schenker began his onslaught against scales with a brief synopsis of modal theory. According to him, the church modes were “modest efforts to categorize horizontally conceived melodies” whose purpose was “simply to capture theoretically the beginning and end of a given melody as well as other relationships in the course of the horizontal line.”17 He added, “Earlier periods further divided, for similar descriptive purposes, all modes into authentic and plagal or so-called perfect, imperfect, and mixed modes just to catalog and categorize the various melodic phenomena.”18 Schenker insisted, however, that once theorists began to recognize that melodic lines behave differently in polyphonic contexts, then it became necessary for them to consider the vertical as well as the horizontal dimension of music. As he put it: Consequently they need no longer limit themselves to providing a highly detailed horizontal description; rather, by the application of harmonic criteria (even to the horizontal line—compare Harmony, par. 76), therefore precisely by virtue of their deeper penetration, they are able to reveal all the more accurately the true inner core of the melody.19
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales”
147
Schenker made similar arguments about attempts to explain exotic harmonies by appealing to exotic scales: “Even though the intentions in all these cases seem to be so diverse, the error is one and the same, since neither the so-called church modes nor exotic scales should be considered real systems.”20 To be considered a ‘real system’ in any explanatory sense, Schenker insisted that the system must not only list what pitches appear, it must also explain how they behave. This inevitably requires formulating explicit laws of voice leading and harmony, and rejecting ‘The Myth of Scales.’ If Schenker thought that scales do not represent ‘real systems’ in any explanatory sense, how did he explain the diatonic nature of the tonal system? How did he get rid of any primitive notion of scale membership? Quite simply, Schenker believed that the diatonic properties of functional monotonal music arise from composing out triads. To quote from Der freie Satz: The series of tones thus created in the Urlinie, represents diatony (Diatonie). In the narrowest sense, Diatony belongs only to the Urlinie. But, in accord with its origin, it simultaneously governs the whole contrapuntal setting [of the Ursatz], including the bass arpeggiation and the passing tones . . .. Diatony therefore does not stem from the so-called Greek or Gregorian modes, but rather from the composing-out process, which is governed by the principle of the fifth.21
In other words, diatonic scales are not the basis of functional monotonality; rather they result from composing out triadic prototypes. But Schenker went further. Since he believed that tonal surfaces could be fully chromatic, Schenker proposed that modal and exotic effects could be produced by mixture and tonicization. For example, in the Harmonielehre, he included two charts that demonstrate how various modal inflections can arise from varying degrees of mixture (see figure 4.2, Schenker’s account of mixture).22 Figure 4.2a shows the major system, with its natural third, sixth, and seventh degrees, on the top staff, whereas the minor system, with its lowered third, sixth, and seventh degrees, appears on the bottom staff. Between these two extremes, there are six rows, each one corresponding to the six possible combinations of natural and lowered degrees. In Rows 1, 2 and 3, the lowered third, sixth, and seventh degrees appear individually: Row 1 illustrates the ascending melodic
148
Explaining Tonality
Figure 4.2. Schenker’s account of mixture. a. Schenker, Harmonielehre, par. 41, p. 110.
minor scale and Row 3 Mixolydian mode. In Rows 4, 5, and 6, the various pairs of lowered degrees occur: Row 4 illustrates the harmonic minor scale and Row 5 Dorian mode. The arrows along the right hand side of figure 4.2a indicate that mixture can occur in varying degrees.23 Figure 4.2b lists the tonic, subdominant, and dominant triads for each row.24 Since simple mixture cannot account for all modal inflections, Schenker was forced to invoke tonicization as well. For example, to explain so-called Lydian mode, Schenker suggested that 4 arises to tonicize 5; similarly, he suggested that Phrygian II arises from a mixture within the minor system. Although he did not discuss Locrian mode, he presumably derived it from mixtures of 2, 3, 5, 6, and 7. Once Schenker realized that he could explain a wide range of different modal inflections using mixture and tonicization, he was
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales”
149
Figure 4.2 (continued). b. Schenker, Harmonielehre, par. 48, p. 117.
able to reject the notion that the modes were systems equivalent to tonality. To quote him: In dropping the Dorian, Phrygian, Lydian, and Mixolydian “rows” we have apparently reduced the number of possible relationships into which each tone could enter, to the detriment of its vitality and egoism. However, this
150
Explaining Tonality loss is merely apparent only. The tone itself bravely stood its ground, and it seems it was the tone itself that forced the artist to leave the door ajar for relationships of a Mixolydian, Dorian, etc. character, even when the artist no longer believed in the validity of those systems.25
As he explained, “If the so-called Dorian and Mixolydian qualities are established by the major and minor systems alone (these understood correctly, of course), then why should we burden ourselves with still more independent systems?”26 Schenker made similar claims about the origins of exotic inflections in functional monotonal contexts. At the start of Kontrapunkt 1, he outlined the traditional view of exotic scales: Finally, a parallel exists in that the Orientals, exactly like our ancestors— and this is proof enough!—submit to the puerile preoccupation with scale systems they commit to paper simply by following the horizontal direction of the melodies. They assume, for example, a pentatonic system consisting of five degrees: C D E. G A.C or C D E. G A.C; or a heptatonic system consisting of seven degrees: F G A B C D E F (Chinese), D E F G A B C D (Japanese), C D E F G A B C (Gypsy), F G A B C D F (Chinese wholetone scale), or C D E F G A B C (Indian), and so forth. In addition, all these so-called systems, like our old church modes, can begin with any of its tones, whereby the number of systems is increased to monstrous proportions.27
But once again, he suggested that these phenomena stem not from alternative systems, but from transformations within the tonal system: Skillful artists, still, have always successfully limited the problem of musical exoticism in practice. They solved it by attempting to make the original melodies of foreign peoples (often original only because of their imperfections and awkwardness) accessible to us through the refinements of our two tonal systems. They expressed the foreign character in our major and minor— such superiority in our art, such flexibility in our systems!28
In short, Schenker did not deny that Common-Practice composers wrote music that sometimes sounds modal or exotic; rather, he denied that these inflections can be explained merely by invoking various independent scale systems. In place of this plethora of scale systems, Schenker drew on just two processes: mixture and tonicization. This
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales”
151
step represents a remarkable simplification of theoretical concepts. To see the consequences of Schenker’s arguments, let us now see how he analyzed some specific pieces with clear modal inflections.
Schenkerian Theory and Modal Inflections Schenker offered his most detailed account of modal inflections at the opening of the Harmonielehre in two chapters entitled “Die übrigen Systeme (Kirchentonarten)” and “Mischungen.”29 Here he used the notions of mixtures and tonicization to analyze various modal passages from works of the Common-Practice Period. One extract that he discussed in particular detail is given in figure 4.3 (Beethoven, “Heiliger Dankgesang,” String Quartet in A Minor, Op. 132).30 Beethoven apparently completed this piece after recovering from a serious illness in 1825. He celebrated his recovery by inscribing the score with the phrase “Holy Song of Thanksgiving to the Divinity by a Convalescent, in the Lydian Mode.”31 As if to underscore the highly personal nature of the movement, Beethoven even marked the contrasting D-major sections “Feeling new strength” and the final section “With most intimate feeling.” Although much has been written about this remarkable movement, most commentators take for granted that the opening section is indeed in Lydian mode. The signs are clear enough. As Schenker himself pointed out, there is the chorale-like feel of the half notes, the strong tendency to use triads in root position, the clear avoidance of any extreme chromaticisms, and perhaps most significantly of all, the consistent preference for B rather than B.32 Given these factors and Beethoven’s own title, the case for a Lydian interpretation seems almost overwhelming. Yet, while Schenker certainly acknowledged the strong modal tendencies of the “Heiliger Dankgesang,” he insisted that these traits stem not from the Lydian system per se, but from chromaticisms within the overall key of F major: It could be objected that the two B’s in measures 5 and 23 (first and fourth part) are incompatible with F major and can be explained only if we presuppose the Lydian system as [the] basic key. This objection can be countered: The two B’s, as they appear here, are in no way incompatible with our F
152
Explaining Tonality
Figure 4.3. Beethoven, “Heiliger Dankegesang,” String Quartet, Op. 132. From Schenker, Harmonielehre, Ex. 47.
major. They result from a trivial chromatic trick, which we use everyday and on only slight occasion to emphasize the cadence and to underline the F major character of the composition.33
In Schenker’s opinion, “[I]t is true that the composer’s intention to avoid the B-flat is particularly noticeable—an intention which, in art, unfailingly entails punishment; it is not true, however, that, in accordance with that intention, the Lydian mode is presented convincingly.”34 Schenker’s own analysis divides the opening section into five parts. The first ends with a deceptive cadence in F major (mm. 5–6);
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales”
153
Figure 4.4. Graph of Beethoven, “Heiliger Dankegesang,” String Quartet, Op. 132.
the second, modulates to C major and ends with an imperfect authentic cadence (mm. 11–12); the third is in C major and closes with a half cadence (mm. 17–18); the fourth leads back from C major to a perfect authentic cadence in F major (mm. 23–24); and the fifth modulates to D major and ends with a half cadence (mm. 29–30).35 The ramifications of this analysis are shown in figure 4.4 (Graph of Beethoven, “Heiliger Dankgesang,” String Quartet, Op. 132). It suggests that the passage is built from a distinctive prototype I–I6–V/V–V–I or VI. As shown in figure 4.4a, this prototype controls the opening phrase of the movement. Notice how the progression from I–I6 is mirrored by a descent from A to F in the upper voice. Figure 4.4b then shows how this same pattern governs the opening section as a whole. The local motion to V in mm. 4–5 is now projected as the larger tonicization of C in mm. 11–12. Beethoven eventually returns to F via the I6 in m. 20. This sonority leads to the
154
Explaining Tonality
prominent cadential progression V/V–V–I in mm. 23–24. Beethoven now presents the rising inner line C–D–E–F in the alto rather than the tenor voice. Despite the obvious modal tendencies of the surface, there are several clues that the music does not conform to the principles of sixteenth-century polyphony. For example, the descending fifths A–D–G in m. 7 of the second violin part are unlikely in Palestrina’s style, as are the successions C–F–G–B–C in mm. 11–12 and C–A–C–A–G–F–B–C in mm. 25–28. As it happens, the reading in figure 4.4 stands in direct contrast to the one presented in a paper by Kevin Korsyn. Besides many differences in detail, the most striking divergence between the two analyses is that the former is in F major, whereas the latter is interpreted in F Lydian. Although Korsyn’s sketch purports to be Schenkerian in nature, it is very hard to reconcile with Schenker’s own interpretation.36 For Schenker, the power of the tonal system was ultimately much greater than that of the Lydian system: “[Beethoven] had no idea that behind his back there stood that higher force of Nature [that] led his pen, forcing his composition into F major while he himself was sure he was composing in the Lydian mode, merely because that was his conscious will and intention.”37 He added, “Is that not marvelous? And yet it is so?” Before leaving Schenker’s explanation of Lydian inflections, it is worth noting that he used much the same arguments in his analysis of Chopin’s Mazurka Op. 24, no. 2 in Kontrapunkt 1. According to him: With this passage, however, Chopin by no means intends to establish the old [Lydian] system as equivalent (to major and minor) and as independent; this is sufficiently clear from the refined artistry he uses in the introduction as well as the harmonization in general to provide the listener with the absolute certainty of only C major and F major.38
Schenker concluded, “Thus, the passage in question simply contains a few features of artist archaism, a highly ingenious trick, such as could befall Chopin occasionally in the midst of his fantastic improvisations.”39 Whereas Schenker drew on the concept of tonicization to explain the Lydian features of Beethoven’s “Heiliger Dankgesang,” he invoked the notion of mixture to explain the Dorian qualities of the music shown in figure 4.5 (Brahms’s song “Vergangen ist mir
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales”
155
Figure 4.5. Brahms, “Vergangen ist mir Gluck und Heil,” Op. 14, no. 6. From Schenker, Harmonielehre, Ex. 50.
Glück und Heil,” Op. 48, no. 6). These qualities are not hard to spot. The song is written in four-part chorale style and is clearly centered on the tonic D. Except for a single B triad in m. 23, Brahms consistently favors the pitch B to its diatonic counterpart. To emphasize the modal qualities even further, Brahms frequently uses the lowered leading tone, C. Nonetheless, Schenker insisted that these modal inflections stem not from the Dorian system, but from mixtures within the key of D minor. His analysis is worth quoting at length: The artist here clearly aims at writing in Dorian mode on D. This results from the mere fact that he omitted the key signature B in a composition really written in D minor. Brahms, too, guided by his desire to compose in
156
Explaining Tonality Dorian mode (just like Beethoven, in the previous example, aiming at the Lydian) strictly avoids any B with one single exception in the second-to-last measure.40
He continued: And yet I insist: None of the B’s occurring in this beautiful chorale is to be derived, as Brahms believed, from the Dorian scale as such; we must substitute, rather the following explanations. The first bars constitute, basically, the A minor scale; hence the B is justified merely in consideration of that key. It is true that, with the C of m. 2, the composition changes to D minor. If in this D minor the IV Stufe is presented with the third B natural rather than with the diatonic third B, the idea of D minor remains nevertheless alive in the listener. More than that, we recognize here the very B natural which we employ in our daily practice in D major/minor (cf. par. 38ff.) and, to boot, in this same sequence IV3–V3, without sacrificing in any way the identity of the D minor! That Brahms abstains from using the B in the subsequent development (mm. 10–13) is simply explained by the motion that the composition is taking toward C major.41
Schenker concluded, “This example, too, demonstrates how music itself holds on to the minor mode even where the artist’s intention aims at the Dorian system.”42 As it stands, Schenker’s analysis leaves a lot to be desired. For one thing, the opening phrase does not really center on A minor; on the contrary, it clearly moves to a half cadence in D minor. For another, mm. 10–13 may indeed move towards C major, but this motion is temporary to say the least. In fact, the goal of the progression is the cadence in D at m. 16. An alternative interpretation is given in figure 4.6 (Graph of Brahms, “Vergangen ist mir Glück und Heil,” Op. 48, no. 6). The most obvious feature of this piece is that it repeats two basic chunks of material: mm. 1–6 are repeated as mm. 6–11, and mm. 11–16 are repeated as mm. 17–22. The piece ends with a single three-bar phrase. The tonal structure of mm. 1–6 (6–11) is particularly intriguing and provides clues to the layout of the piece as a whole. The passage consists of two distinct phrases: mm. 1–3 move from the tonic chord D (m. 1) to a half cadence on A (m. 3); mm. 4–6 then move back from the dominant (m. 4) to a perfect authentic cadence on the tonic D (m. 6). From a contrapuntal perspective, the motion to the dominant in mm. 2–3 (7–8) is quite distinctive; it is marked by a clear melodic motion
Schenker and “The Myth of Scales”
157
Figure 4.6. Graph of Brahms, “Vergangen ist mir Glück und Heil,” Op. 14, no. 6.
A–C–B–A–G–F–E over a bass motion A–E–F–C–D–A. The descending trajectory of this figure culminates in the motion from E to D at the cadence in mm. 5–6 (10–11). Seen in this context, the B’s in mm. 2 (7), 4 (9), and 5 (10) all arise as simple mixtures, while the C’s in mm. 3 (8), 4 (9), and 5 (10) serve to tonicize D. If we compare the counterpoint of the first chunk with that of the second, we see that the former is a variant of the latter. The second chunk begins with a sequential motion from a triad on A to a triad on C in mm. 11–14 (17–20). This motion is answered by a progression E–F–C–D–A–D that recalls the progression in mm. 2–3 (7–8). This time, however, the soprano motion B–A–G–F–E is buried in the inner voices: B–A appear in the alto, G–F–E occur in the tenor. The new soprano follows the alto line of mm. 2–3 (7–8). Once again, the B’s in mm. 12 (17), 13 (18), 15 (20) arise as mixtures and the C in m. 16 (21) serves to tonicize D. The closing three-bar phrase (mm. 22–24) then mirrors the end of the first chunk: the final cadential descent is almost identical in both cases, A–G–E–D. In both cases the Dorian traits arise from the process of simple mixture. It should be clear from the preceding analyses of the “Heiliger Dankgesang” and “Vergangen ist mir Glück und Heil” that in Schenker’s mind, Beethoven and Brahms were able to simulate modal music using the resources of the tonal system. Instead of invoking separate Lydian or Dorian systems, he explained these inflections through the concepts of mixture and tonicization. Schenker drew on these same ideas in his discussions of other modal pieces. In Kontrapunkt 1, for example, he claimed that,
158
Explaining Tonality
although the chorale melody “Gelobet seist du Jesu Christ” might appear to have a