Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Cunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth
Related Titlesfrom WILEY-VCH
1I
F. Za...
77 downloads
4969 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Cunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth
Related Titlesfrom WILEY-VCH
1I
F. Zaragoza Dorwald
Organic Synthesis on Solid Phase Second, Completely Revised and Enlarged Edition 2002
ISBN 3-527-30603-X
C. Bittner e t al.
Organic Synthesis Workbook II
I
NO S::
3-527-30415-0
K. Drauz and H. Waldmann (Eds.)
1
Enzyme Catalysis in Organic Synthesis Second, Completely Revised and Enlarged Edition 2002
ISBN 3-527-29949-1
B. Cornils and W. A. Herrmann (Eds.)
Applied Homogeneous Catalysis with Organometallic Compounds Second, Completely Revised and Enlarged Edition 2002
ISBN 3-527-30434-7
Organic Synthesis Highlights V
Edited by Hans-Cunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth
Prof: Dr. Hans-Gunther Schmolz Institute of Organic Chemistry University of Cologne Greinstrage 4 50939 Koln Germany
This book was carefully produced. Nevertheless, editors, authors and publisher do not warrant the information contained therein to be free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate.
Prof: Dr. Thomas Wirth Cardiff University Department of Chemistry PO Box 912 Cardiff CFlO 3TB United Kingdom
Library of Congress Card No.: applied for A catalogue record for this book is available from the
British Library. Bibliographic information published by Die Deutsche Bibliothek
Die Deutsche Bibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data is available in the Internet at http:/dnb.ddb.de. 2003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim All rights reserved (including those of translation in other languages). No part of this book may be reproduced in any form - by photoprinting, microfilm, or any other means - nor transmitted or translated into machine language without written permission from the publishers. Registered names, trademarks, etc. used in this book, even when not specifically marked as such, are not to be considered unprotected by law. Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany. Printed on acid-free paper. Typesetting Asco Typesetters, Hongkong Printing betz-druck gmbh, Darmstadt Bookbinding j. Schaffer GmbH & Co. KG
Griinstadt ISBN 3-527-30611-0
Iv
Contents
Preface xiii List o f Contributors
xu
Part I. Synthetic Methods Direct Conversion o f Sugar Glycosides into Carbocycles Peter 1. Dalko and Pierre Sinai;
1
Synthesis o f Diary1 Ethers: A Long-standing Problem Has Been Solved Fritz Theil
15
Take The Right Catalyst: Palladium-Catalyzed CC-, CN- and CO-Bond Formation on Chloro-Arenes 22 Rainer Stiirmer Alkyne Metathesis i n Natural Product Synthesis Thomas Lindel
27
Transition Metal-Catalyzed Functionalization o f Alkanes Oliver Seitz An Eldorado for Homogeneous Catalysis? Gerald Dyker
36
48
New and Selective Transition Metal Catalyzed Reactions o f Allenes A. Stephen K. Hashmi
56
Controlling Stereoselectivity with the Aid o f a Reagent-Directing Group Bernhard Breit Solvent-Free Organic Syntheses Jiirgen 0. Metzger
82
68
vi
I
Contents
Fluorous Techniques: Progress i n Reaction-Processing and Purification U/f Diederichsen
93
Recent Developments i n Using Ionic Liquids as Solvents and Catalysts for Organic 105 Synthesis Peter Wassencheid Recent Advances on the Sharpless Asymmetric Aminohydroxylation Dmitry Nilov and Oliver Reiser Asymmetric Phase Transfer Catalysis Christabel Carter and Adam Nelson
118
125
Asymmetric Catalytic Aminoalkylations: New Powerful Methods for the Enantioselective 134 Synthesis o f Amino Acid Derivatives, Mannich Bases, and Homoallylic Amines Michael Arend and Xiaojing Wang IBX - New Reactions with an Old Reagent Thomas Wirth Parallel Kinetic Resolutions Jason Eames
144
151
The Asymmetric Baylis-Hillman-Reaction Peter Langer
165
Simple Amino Acids and Short-Chain Peptides as Efficient Metal-free Catalysts in Asymmetric 178 Synthesis Harald Groger, Jorg Wilken, and Albrecht Berkessel Recent Developments i n Catalytic Asymmetric Strecker-Type Reactions
187
Larry Yet Highly Enantioselective or Not? - Chiral Monodentate Monophosphorus Ligands i n the Asymmetric Hydrogenation 193 lgor V. Komarou and Armin Borner Improving Enantioselective Fluorination Reactions: Chiral N-Fluoro Ammonium Salts and Transition Metal Catalysts 201 Kilian Mufiiz Catalytic Asymmetric Olefin Metathesis Amir H . Hoveyda and Richard R. Schrock
210
Contents
Activating Protecting Groups for the Solid Phase Synthesis and Modification o f Peptides, 230 Oligonucleotides and Oligosaccharides Oliver Seitz Traceless Linkers for Solid-Phase Organic Synthesis florencio Zaragoza Donuald
251
Merging Solid-Phase and Solution-Phase Synthesis: The “Resin-Capture-Release” Hybrid Technique 265 Andreas Kinchning and Riidiger Wittenberg Polymeric Scavenger Reagents in Organic Synthesis Jason Eames and Michael Watkinson
280
Part II. Applications Total Syntheses o f Vancomycin 297 Lars H. Thoresen and Kevin Burgess Bryostatin and Their Analogues Uf Diederichsen
307
Eleutherobin: Synthesis, Structure/Activity Relationship, and Pharmacophore Uf Diederichsen Total Synthesis o f the Natural Products CP-263,114 and CP-225,917 Ulf Diederichsen and Katrin B. Lorenz Polyene Cyclization t o Adociasulfate 1 Thomas Lindel and Cordula Hopmann
326
342
Sanglifehrin A An Immunosuppressant Natural Product from Malawi Thomas Lindel Short Syntheses o f the Spirotryprostatins Thomas Lindel
360
The Chemical Total Synthesis o f Proteins Oliver Seitz
368
Solid-Phase Synthesis o f Oligosaccharides Ulf Diederichsen and Thomas Wagner
350
384
Polymer-Supported Synthesis o f Non-Oligomeric Natural Products Stefan Sommer, Rolf Breinbauer, and Herbert Waldmann
395
317
I
vii
viii
I
Contents
Explosions as a Synthetic Tool? Cycloalkynes as Precursors to Fullerenes, Buckytubes and Buckyonions 409 Rudiger Faust
Dendralenes: From a Neglected Class o f Polyenes to Versatile Starting Materials in Organic Synthesis 419 Henning Hopf Fascinating Natural and Artificial Cyclopropane Architectures Riidiger Faust
index
435
428
Development in chemical sciences in general and in organic synthesis in particular has a strong impact on our life. Synthesis as a central position within the field of organic chemistry is contributing to a large variety of different applications. Men’s ability to synthesize complex biologically active or functional molecules has dramatically improved during the past years. However, the art and technology of organic synthesis is still far from being fully developed. Intense research is performed worldwide, and it is important and fascinating to follow the steady development of increasingly powerful methods and tools for organic synthesis. The fifth volume of Organic Synthesis Highlights is divided in two parts. In the first part, recent developments in synthetic methodologies are described and new and improved techniques are highlighted including some general applications of those strategies. The second part of the book is devoted to the total synthesis of natural and non-natural compounds. The complexity and the efficiency of multi-step sequences is still highly challenging and success in this field often has to go hand in hand with the development of new methods. In continuing the tradition of Organic Synthesis Highlights, about 40 articles have been selected from the “Highlights” section of Angewandte Chemie (1998-2001),from the “Concepts” section of Chemistry - A EuropeanJournal(2000-2001), and from the review section of Nachrichten aus der Chemie (1999-2001),the members journal of the GDCh. The articles from the “Synthese im Blickpunkt” have all been carefully translated and updated by the authors ( U . Diederichsen, T. Lindel, 0. Seitz) and we would like to express special thanks to these colleagues and their co-authors. We are also grateful to all the other authors for their excellent contributions and for the good cooperation. We also like to thank the team at Wiley-VCH, especially Dr. E. Westermann, for the excellent and professional support and for the prompt help in all questions. We hope that this volume will stimulate interest in the field of synthesis across a broad range of chemists, from undergraduate students to research group leaders in industry and academia. Cologne and Cardiz September 2002 Hans-Giinther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth
List of Contributors
Dr. Michael Arend Fibrogen 225 Gateway Boulevard South San Francisco, CA 94080 USA Professor Dr. Armin Borner Institut fur Organische Katalyseforschung an der Universitat Rostock e. V. Buchbinderstrasse 5/6 18055 Rostock Germany Professor Dr. Bernhard Breit Albert-Ludwigs-Universitat Freiburg Institut fur Organische Chemie und Biochemie Albertstrasse 21 79104 Freiburg Germany Professor Kevin Burgess Department of Chemistry Texas A&M University Box 30012 College Station TX-77842.3012 USA Professor Dr. Ulf Diederichsen Institut fur Organische Chemie Universitat Gottingen Tammannstr. 2 37077 Gottingen Germany Professor Dr. Gerald Dyker Ruhr-Universitat Bochum Fahltat fur Chemie Universitatsstrasse 150 44780 Bochum Germany
Dr. lason Eames Department of Chemistry Queen Mary and Westfield College Mile End Road London E l 4NS U.K. Dr. Rudiger Faust Department of Chemistry Christopher Ingold Laboratories University College London 20 Gordon Street London WClH OAJ U.K. Dr. Harald Groger Project House Biotechnology Degussa AG Rodenbacher Chaussee 4 63457 Hanau Germany Professor Dr. A. Stephen K. Hashmi hstitut fur Organische Chemie Universitat Stuttgart Pfaffenwaldring 55 70569 Stuttgart Germany Professor Henning Hopf Institut fur Organische Chemie Technische Universitat Braunschweig Hagenring 30 38106 Braunschweig Germany Professor Amir H. Hoveyda Boston College Department of Chemistry Merkert Center Chestnut Hill
xii
I
List ofcontributors
Massachusetts 02467 USA Professor Dr. Andreas Kirschning Institut fur Organische Chemie Universitat Hannover Schneiderberg 1 B 30167 Hannover Germany Professor Dr. Peter Langer Institut fur Chemie und Biochemie Ernst-Moritz-Arndt Universitat Soldmannstrage 16 17487 Greifswald Germany Professor Dr. Thomas Lindel Department Chemie LudwigMaximilians-Universitat Munchen Butenandtstrasse 5-13 81377 Miinchen Germany Professor Dr. Jurgen 0. Metzger Carl-von-OssietzkyUniversitat Fachbereich Chemie der Universitat Carl-von-Ossietzky-Strasse 9-1 1 26111 Oldenburg Germany
Dr. Oliver Seitz MPI fur Molekulare Physiologie Abteilung Chemische Biologie Otto-Hahn-Strasse 11 44227 Dortmund Germany Dr. Rainer Stiirmer BASF AG Hauptlaboratorium GHF/D, A30 67056 Ludwigshafen Germany Dr. Fritz Theil ASCA Angewandte Synthesesysteme Adlershof GmbH Richard-Willstatter-Strasse 12 12489 Berlin Germany Dr. Peter Wasserscheid Institut fur Technische Chemie und Makromolekulare Chemie Bereich Technische Chemie Worringer Weg 1 52074 Aachen Germany
Dr. Kilian Mufiiz KekulC-Institut fur Organische Chemie und Biochemie Gerhard-Domagk-Strage 1 53121 Bonn Germany
Professor Dr. Herbert Waldmann MPI fur Molekulare Physiologie Otto-Hahn-Strasse 11 44227 Dortmund Germany
Professor Dr. Adam Nelson School of Chemistry University of Leeds Leeds. LS2 9jT U.K.
Professor Thomas Wirth Department of Chemistry Cardiff University P.Q. Box 912 Cardiff CFlO 3TB United Kingdom
Professor Oliver Reiser Institut fur Organische Chemie der Universitat Regensburg Universitatsstrasse 31 93053 Regensburg Germany Prof. Pierre Sinay Ecole Normale Supkrieure DCpartement de Chimie UMR 8642 24, Rue Lhomond 75231 PARIS Cedex 05 France
Dr. Larry Yet Albany Molecular Research, Inc. 21 Corporate Circle P.O. Box 15098 Albany NY 12212-5098 USA Dr. Florencio Zaragoza Dorwald Novo Nordisk A/S Novo Nordisk Park 2760 Milm Denmark
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
I’
Direct Conversion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles Peter 1. Dalko and Pierre S h y
Carbocyclic polyols are important constituents of many biologically active molecules. They exhibit far reaching biological effects ranging from cellular regulation, to the selective inhibition of enzymes, which play key roles in living organisms [ 1, 21. Some of the most prominent six membered representatives are cyclohexane hexitols such as inositol derivatives [ 11 or pseudo-sugars [2, 31, such as cyclophellitol [4],or valienamine [ 51. Structural analogues of the latter are constituents of compounds of key pharmacological interest such as acarbose [GI, adiposin [7], trestatin [8], and amylostatin [9]. Together with a growing number of structurally related alkaloids [lo] and purely synthetic compounds Ill], as well as five membered polyol-contain natural products [ 121, these small, but synthetically challenging molecules received growing interest in the last few years. The biological significance and the inherent structural challenge of these molecules have led to the development of a variety of different approaches in optically pure form [13]. To access this class of compounds both (1)a cyclization strategy of alicyclic, polyfunctionalized molecules and (2) transformations of conveniently substituted carbocycles into cyclitols were largely exploited. The former strategy includes Diels-Alder reactions [ 141, Wittigtype olefinations [ 151, radical cyclization approaches [ 161, ring-closing metathesis (RCM) [ 171, and a variety of anionic cyclization/organometallic coupling reactions of advanced polyhydroxylated compounds [ 181. Some of these allow the direct conversion of carbohydrate furanosides and pyranosides to carbocyclic polyols. The tandem fragmentation/Henry-type cyclization reaction provided the first examples in which cyclohexane [ 191 and cyclopentane [ 201 derivatives were obtained from carbohydrate derivatives. Likewise, the elegant application of the Fujimoto-Belleau reaction [21], and the anionic rearrangements of anhydrosugars [ 221 are examples of this transformation. The strategy which includes enantiopure carbocycles as starting materials features transformations of quinic acid 1231, inositols or conduritol derivatives [ 241, desymmetrization of meso cyclohexene derivatives using asymmetric palladium catalyzed hydroxycarboxylation [25], or other enantioselective reactions [ 261, transformation of homochiral carbocycles obtained either by microbial metabolites [ 27, 281, or by some other type of oxidation [29]. At this stage it is important to briefly examine the biosynthesis of carbocyclic polyols, concentrating on six membered rings. Myo-inositol derivatives, for example, are formed from D-glucose6-phosphate 1 by a stereospecific ring-closure under the catalytic influence of inositol cyclase (Scheme 1) [ Ib].
2
I
Direct Conversion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles
@o H
o
b
o
H
-
OH
HO
o a H
o
~
HO
~
~
~
o
~
o
OH
2
1
4
3
myo-inositol 1-phosphate Scheme 1.
Other mechanisms bear strong resemblances to that by which D-glucose is converted into shikimic acid (Scheme 2). This is the biogenetic path in which nature produces the benzoid rings of the aromatic amino acids and an extensive range of other metabolites. At an early stage of this sequence the hemiacetal intermediate Ga undergoes rearrangement and forms the quinic acid derivative 7. As Bartlett and Satake demonstrated, however, the unstable Ga, generated in situ from the 0-nitrobenzyl protected cc-glycoside Gb is rearranged spontaneously to 3-dehydroquinic acid without any specific enzyme [ 301. Moreover, this uncatalyzed reaction gives rise to a single stereoisomer identical to that of the biosynthetic path. This fact suggests the possibility that a key step in cyclitol biosynthesis may also be nonenzymatic.
5
6aR=H 6b R = o-nitrobenzyl
0 H0m.u ~ HO
'OH
0
7 3-dehydroquinic acid Scheme 2.
-
2H
o 8 H ~o ~ ~ 0 2 H HO
8
shikimic acid
Direct Conversion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles
13
Nature found a direct path to perform this tandem fragmentation cyclization reaction in a stereospecific manner and under neutral conditions. Human creativity and luck aimed to uncover synthetic variants, which can compete efficiently with it. With the advent of mild, metal mediated cyclization reactions, the early idea of Grosheinz and Fisher [19a], who converted 6-deoxy-6-nitrohexosesto nitroinositols in a single step, matured to a general strategy of broad interest. The direct conversion of sugar glycosides to a carbocycle can take place either by a domino sequence, or by a concerted reaction. In the former case the reaction combines two distinct steps: an opening step, liberating a highly reactive metal enolate (or equivalent) and electrophile functions (i.e. an aldehyde or oxycarbenium function), which undergo subsequent cyclization. The carbocyclization can proceed with ring contraction providing cyclopentanes and cyclobutanes [31], or alternatively may give rise cyclohexitols, or larger rings. Sugar enol-ethers, which inherently carry both the masked nucleophilic and electrophilic functions, were converted to carbocycles in different reactions. Among the carbocyclization methods the Ferrier (I I) cyclization of hex-5-enopyranosides affording six membered carbocycles in the presence of Hg(11) salts is perhaps the most popular one (Scheme 3) [ 321. This remarkable reaction has provided a practical route to a large variety of bioactive substances such as aminocyclitols [ 331, pseudosugars [34], inositols [35], and other complex hexitols [36].
Hg”
~ BnO ~ 0 %
[
B BnO n
O
OBn
9aR=H 9b R = OAc
-
q +B BnO n
OH OBn
OMe
L
~
OBn
h
O
]
OBn
OMe
10a R = H 10b R = OAc
BnO
O
lla R =H l l b R = OAc
J
Bno BnO
OBn OH
12a R = H (68%) 12b R = OAC(59-72%)
13a R = H (17%) 13b R = OAc (13 %)
Scheme 3.
According to the original protocol the six membered vinyl glycoside such as 9a undergo rearrangement under hydroxymercuration conditions providing cyclohexitols (Schema 3). Among the various conditions proposed for the Ferrier (11) reaction, both catalytic and stoichiometric methods were investigated, which afforded similar but not identical results [ 13, 371. Also, a “nontoxic alternative” consists of using a catalytic amount of palladium(I1) salt [38], instead of mercury(I1) [39]. This modification may alter the selectivity, which is not surprising given the different coordination pattern of the metal in the transition state. A
4
I
Direct Conversion of Sugar tlycosides into Carbocycles
basic feature of this transformation is the loss of the aglycon, for example methanol, and the fragmentation ring-closing aldol reaction. In this cyclization the carbanionic center (C6) attacks the electrophilic carbonyl center (Cl). The stereochemistry of the newly formed asymmetric center is determined by the conformational bias of the molecule, and by the chemical nature of the functions present. The stereoselectivity of the newly formed asymmetric center as well as isolated yields are highly dependent upon the experimental conditions used, however. This fact is mainly due to the preferred conformation of the given sugar derivative in the transition state and also to the formation of a sensitive 8-hydroxy ketone, which may undergo elimination and subsequent aromatization. The scope of the reaction was enlarged by showing that functionalized exocyclic olefins may be converted into carbocycles as well [40]. Accordingly, alkene-bearing oxygen substituents at C6, such as 9b, made from the corresponding aldehyde, were transformed to inosose derivative 121, with high stereoselectivity of each newly formed stereogenic center. Noteworthy, the geometry of the enol acetate of 91, does not affect the stereochemical outcome of the reaction, nor in the Hg(I1) neither in the Pd(I1) salt mediated cases [33c]. The Ferrier (11) reaction is quite efficient to form six membered carbocycles, but is unsuitable to prepare cyclopentitols. Five membered enollactone 14 was converted to the cyclopentanone derivative 16 as a single epimer upon treatment by LiAlH(OtBu)3 (Scheme 4) [41]. Spectroscopic studies established some mechanistic details. Accordingly, the hydride of the reducing agent rapidly added to the carbonyl and formed with the metal a stable aluminate complex. The carbocyclization occurred by protonation followed by fragmentation and aldol type cyclization process.
x-1 14
L
-
\/
1
15
16 (74%)
Scheme 4.
Under particularly mild conditions the triisobutylaluminium (TRIBAL) mediated rearrangement avoided the fragmentation of the “locked’ anomeric substituent in 9a, and even preserved its original configuration with high selectivity (Scheme 5) [42,43]. Lewis acid assisted endo activation, followed by a ring-opening step, generated the zwitterionic enolate intermediate 17 as the hypothesized intermediate of the reaction. The ring closure occurs via an intramolecular 6-em-trig aldol condensation. The “bonus” of the reaction is the stereoselective formation of a hydroxyl, resulting from the final reduction of the keto group probably by an intramolecular hydrogen delivery from the less hindered P-side. The reaction is fairly general and high yielding using a wide array of sugar starting materials. It is worthy to note the good selectivity in conserving the anomeric stereochemical information by retention
Direct Convenion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles
15
18
OMe
OMe
19 (79%)
Scheme 5.
The fact that both the stereochemistry and the substitution pattern of the sugar anomeric center is conserved allowed to realize a direct transformation of a hex-5-enopyranosides of sucrose 20 into a carba-disaccharide analogue 21 (Scheme G), and to achieve cascade rearrangements [45].
OBn
PhMe, 50°C
BnO""
Brio'“‘ OBn
20
21 (34%)
Scheme 6.
No synthetically useful rearrangement occurs, however, by replacing the TRIBAL by DIBAL-H, or by using stronger Lewis acids such as TiC14, Ti(OiPr), or BF3, SnC14, AlC13 under similar conditions [4G].In contrast, slightly modified conditions, by using Ti(OiPr)C13, prepared from TiC14 and Ti(OiPr),, the reaction afforded the rearranged cyclohexanone derivative with retention of the stereochemical information and substitution pattern on the anomeric center [47]. The a-D-glycoside 9a in the presence of Ti(OiPr)C13 provides the expected endo-cleavage of the glycosidic bond and forms the carbocyclic glycoside 23 (Scheme 7). Although the a-glycoside starting material affords nearly quantitative yield, the corresponding I(-glycoside gives rise to a mixture of different products. This Ti'" version
6
I
Direct Conversion of Sugar Glycosides into Carbocycles
Ti(OiPr)C13(1.5 equiv.), BnO
CH2C12, -78"C, 15 min. OMe
9a
OMe
23 (98%) Scheme 7.
involves milder reaction conditions than the triisobutylaluminium mediated rearrangement and does not result in the reduction of the keto function. Vinyl carbohydrate derivatives such as 24 or 27 can be converted to carbocycles 26 and 28 respectively by sequential treatment with "CpzZr" and BF3.0Et, (Scheme 8) [48]. The reaction offers complete cis-selectivitybetween the vinyl groups and the newly formed hydroxyl.
24
"1 * BnO
OBn
26 (65%)
>98% de.
OMe
"Cpzzr"
WoH +
BF3.OEt2 * OBn
27 Scheme 8.
(60%)
"'OBn
OH
*,'
OBn
Direct Conversion ofsugar Clycosides into Carbocycles
Although the major stereoisomer was expected to be trans to the adjacent cc-substituent, the overall selectivity of the reaction depends intimately on the stereochemistry and nature of the substituents present. Despite the difficulty encountered with different derivatives in controlling stereochemistry, the easy access and the seemingly unhindered choice of the vinyl carbohydrate starting materials renders this methodology appealing. Like the in situ generated propargyl-zirconium species, generated from vinyl-carbohydrate derivatives the intramolecular propargylation promoted by SmIz in the presence of a catalytic amount of Pd(0) complexes affords the ring-contracted carbocycle (Scheme 9). The reaction products are usually cyclopentanols and cyclobutanols. The transformation is characterized by high trans selectivity with regard the two newly created stereogenic centers. This procedure represents an extension of the “CpzZr” mediated ring-contraction reaction of vinylfuranosides or pyranosides in a sense that allows also the transformation of alkynylpyranosides [ 491. Like the earlier discussed zirconium mediated ring-contraction reaction the reaction is thought to proceed through the corresponding ally1 or allenylsamarium complexes that undergo cyclization in the presence of the carbonyl of the liberated aldehyde function [SO].
SmI2 (2eq),
OBn
P ~ ( O A C ) ~ . ~(5%) BU~P OBn
OBn
rt
29
30 (82%)
Scheme 9.
Samarium(11) iodide promotes comparable transformations of aldehydo sugar 31 to ring contracted product 34 (Scheme 10) [ 511. The presences of HMPA and tea-butyl alcohol as a proton source are necessary to obtain good conversion to cyclopentane derivatives. The reac-
rBuOH (2 equiv.)
BnO
31
32
OMe
BnO
&
BnO BnO
33 Scheme 10.
H
34 (63%)
8
I
Direct Conversion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles
tion is considered to proceed via the samarium ketyl intermediate, which is reduced to the disamarium species 32 under the reaction conditions. After fragmentation the system is ideally suited for a subsequent aldol cyclization, involving intramolecular nucleophilic attack of the samarium enolate onto the aldehyde through a 5-enol exo-trig process. As expected from the metal linked chelate, the major stereoisomer of the two newly created stereocenters is cis, and trans with regard to the adjacent substituents. A limited number of Sm12-mediated reductive rearrangements affording six membered carbocycles have been reported (Scheme 11) [52a]. The transformation occurs often with high stereoselectivity, and can be explained by assuming a chelation control model. The outcome of the reaction may depend, however, on the stereochemistry of the substitution pattern of the molecule, and the nature of the intramolecular trap. Six membered carbocycles are formed from the ally1 sulfides such as 35, in sharp contrast with a,p-unsaturated methyl esters of sugar pyranosides such as 37, which afford the corresponding five membered carbocycles (38) through a similar SmI2-induced cyclization [ 521. SPh I
b
o
H
Sm12
HOt,/(@H
THF / MeOH
BnO\\\\
'"OBn OBn
5: 1 (83 %)
BnO'"'
""OBn OBn
dr=3: 1
35
36
37
THF / MeOH 15: 1 (91 %)
OBn 38
Scheme 11.
Sugar spiroisoxazolines intermediates such as 40 undergo rearrangement under reductive conditions (Scheme 12) [53]. The starting material can be prepared by an intermolecular [ 3+2] cycloaddition by using pent-4-enofuranosides such as 39 and nitrile oxides. Although this reaction proceeds often in a high facial selectivity, the diastereoselectivity of this transformation is of no importance since the spiro-carbon loses the stereochemical integrity in the following step. The reduction of this intermediate by using Raney Nickel hydrogenation in MeOH-AcOH yield in high diastereoselectivity the corresponding cyclic enaminone 42. The reaction is a result of a selective N - 0 cleavage and a spontaneous aldol-like condensation of the resulted enamine or enone of type 41.This reaction allows the formation of both five and six membered carbocycles respectively. The efficiency of the transformation depends on the substitution pattern of the spiro-isoxazoline moiety.
Direct Conversion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles
eoMe Low,, 2,6-ClzC6H&NO (1.1 equiv.),
-
-:
:
i
-
2,6-C12C~H3
-.-~ --
Y
c
k 0
CH2C12, reflux, 4 h
39
40 (66%)
Raney Ni, MgS04, H2 (1 atm.)
.
MeOWCH&OOH, (6: 1) 20 "C, 90 min. 41 Scheme 12.
Let's now consider concerted skeletal rearrangements which allow the direct transformation of a sugar structure into a carbocycle. The Claisen rearrangement has been used for the direct conversion of sugar C-glycosides to eight membered carbocycles, respectively. The to reaction has precedents in the transformation of 2-methylene-6-vinyl-tetrahydropyrans cyclooctenone derivatives, a transformation that has been applied in the synthesis of several natural products [ 541. The rearrangement can be promoted by heat [55] or by using TRIBAL [%I. For example, simple heating of a solution of 43 in boiling xylene leads to the eight membered carbocycle 44 in 60% (Scheme 13).
43
44 (60%)
Scheme 13.
The rearrangement of methyl vinylketoside 45 can be accelerated by using TRIBAL. In this case the reaction affords at room temperature the corresponding cyclooctanol derivative 46 with a high preference for a syn-hydrogen delivery compared to the adjacent benzyloxy function (Scheme 14)[57]. An elegant method was devised in preparing pseudo-sugars using thermal [3, 31 sigmatropic rearrangement (Scheme 15) [58]. This methodology is based on the earlier works of Buchi [ 591. Although the generality of this approach using different sugar series remains to be demonstrated, the simplicity is attracting: the vinyl glucal derivative 47 affords the cyclohexene aldehyde 48 by heating. One of the advantages of this transformation is that
19
10
I
Direct Conversion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles
TRIBAL OMe
toluene OBn 45
46 (83%)
Scheme 14.
the formed pseudosugar retains the original configuration of the starting sugar: the D-glucal derivative gives entry to the pseudo-o-glucal series.
240°C
o-dichlorobenzene sealed tube, l h
BnO"" OBn
47
B n ~ " OBn
48 (84%)
Scheme 15.
The intramolecular nitrone cycloaddition (INC) has been used particularly for the synthesis of amino carbasugars [GO, 611. The following scheme illustrates this strategy (Scheme 16) [GO]. The cycloaddition of nitrone derived from lactol 49 and an excess of Nmethylhydroxylamine occurs from the least hindered face affording the isoxazolidine 51 (85% yield). The amino carbasugar 52 was obtained after the cleavage of the N - 0 bond.
F4
O
)"
MeNHOH-HCl, t
>
5
k 0
pyridine, rt, 12h,
49
50
.OH I
Me"\/
\ Scheme 16.
51(85%)
\
52
References and Notes
I
l1
Conclusion
The easy access to enantiomerically pure carbocyclic polyols from carbohydrate furanosides and pyranosides is an appealing transformation in organic synthesis. New methods made possible to carry out this transformation under mild conditions with high yield and with predictable and high stereoselectivity. Beyond elegance, the compatibility towards a large variety of substituents gives to the discussed rearrangements strategic importance.
References and Notes a) Y. CHAPLEUR (Ed.) Carbohydrate Mimics, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 1997; b) D. C. BILLINGTON,The Inositol Phosphates Chemical Syntheses and Biological Sign$cance, VCH, New York, 1993; c) L. C. HUANG,J. LARNER, Adv. Prot. Phosphatases 1993, 7, 373; d) G. ROMERO, Cell. Biol. Int. Rep. 1991, 15, 827; e ) M. J. MCCONVILLE, M. A. J. FERGUSON, Biochem.]. 1993, 294, 305; f ) R. H. MITCHELL, A. H. DRUMMOND, C. P. DOWNES, Inositol Lipids in Cell Signaling, Academic Press, New York, 1989; g) R. KAPELLER,L. C. CANTLEY, BioEssays 1994, 16, 565; h) K. HINTERDING, D. ALONSO-DIAZ, H. WALDMANN, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 668; i) R. I. G . J. WANG,Chem. Rev. HOLLINGSWORTH, 2000, 100, 4267; j) D. C. BILLINGTON, Chem. SOC. Rev. 1989, 18, 83; k) T. HUDLICKY, D. GONZALEZ, D. T. GIBSON, Aldrichim. Acta 1999, 32; 1) B. FRASERREID,Acc. Chem. Res. 1996, 29, 57; m ) B. FRASER-REID, K. TATSUTA, J. T H I E M(Eds) , Glycoscience: Chemistry and Chemical Biology, Vol. 1-111, Springer, Berlin, 2001. 2 a) T. SUAMI,S. OGAWA, Adv. Carbohydr. Chem. Biochem. 1990, 28, 41; b) A. BERCIBAR, C. GRANDJEAN, A. SIRIWARDENA, Chem. Rev. 1999, 99, 779. 3 Pseudosugars are carbohydrate derivatives in which the ring oxygen has been replaced by a methylene group. 4 S. ATSUMI, K. UMEZAWA, H. IINUMA,H. NAGANAWA, H. NAKAMURA, Y. IITAKA, T. Antibiot. 1990, 43, 49. TAKEUCHI,]. 5 T. K. M. SHING,L. H. WAN,Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34, 1643. 6 D. SCHMIDT, W. FROMMER, B. J U N G E , K. MULLER, W. WINGENDER, E. TRUTSCHEIT, Natunvissenschaften 1977, 64, 536. 1
a) S. OGAWA,Yuki. Gosei Kagaku Kyokai Shi 1985, 43, 26; b) Y. KAMEDA, N. ASANO, M. YOSHIKAWA, K. MABUI,S. HORII, H. FUKAWASE, ]. Antibiot. 1983, 36, 1157. 8 J. ITOH, S. OMOYO, T. SHOMURA, H. OGINO,K. IWAMATSU, S. INOUYE, J . Antibiot. 1981, 34, 1424 and 1429. 9 N. SAKAIRI, H. KUZUHARA, Tetrahedron Lett. 1982, 23, 5327. 10 a) R. L. POLTin Amaryllidaceae Alkaloids with Antitumor Activity, Series Organic Synthesis: 7'heory and Application, Vol. 3 (Ed. T. HUDLTCKY), JAI Press, Greenwich, 1996, pp 109-148; b) P. MAGNUS, I. K. SEBHAT,].Am. Chem. SOC.1998, 120, 5341. 11 S. VORWERK, A. VASELLA, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 1732. 12 M. ISHIBASHI, C. M. ZENG,J. KABAYASHI, ]. Nat. Prod. 1993, 58, 186. 13 a) R. J. FERRIER, S. MIDDLETON, Chem. Rev. 1993, 93, 2779; b) G. D. PRESTWICH, Acc. Chern. Res. 1996, 29, 503; c) P. 1. DALKO, P. SINAY,Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1999, 38, 773; d) P. SINAY,Pure Appl. Chem. 1998, 70, 1495. 14 a) S. ALLEMAN, P. VOGEL,Helv. Chim. Acta 1994, 77, 1; b) R. LEUNG-TOUNG, Y. LIU, J. M. MUCHOWSKI, Y.-L. Wu, ]. Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 3235; c) 0. ARJONA, C. BORRALLO,F. IRADIER, R. MEDEL, J. PLUMET, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 1977; d) E. ROMAN, M. BANOS,I. I. GUTIERREZ, J . A. SERRANO,].Carbohydrate Chem. 1995, 14, 703; e) S. C. PELLEGRINET, M. T. A. B. BAUMGARTNER, R. A. SPANEVELLO, PIERINI,Tetrahedron 2000, 56, 5311; f ) C. TAILLEFUMIER, Y. CHAPLEUR, Can.]. Chem. 2000, 78, 708; For a general review on the preparation of carbocycles by Diels7
12
I
Direct Conversion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles Alder chemistry see: g) K. GOTHELF,K. A. )0RGENSEN, Chem. Rev. 1998, 98,863. 15 a) H. PAULSEN, W. VON DEYN,Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1987, 125; b) H. J. M. GITSEN,C. H . WONG,Tetrahedron Lett. 1995, 36, 7057. 16 a) T. V. RAJANBABU, Acc. Chem. Res. 1991, 24, 139. b) A. MARTINEZ-GRAU, 1. MARCOChem. SOC. Rev. 1998, 27, 155; CONTELLES, c) I. MARCO-CONTELLES, C. ALHAMBRA,A. Synlett 1998, 693; d) M. MARTINEZ-GRAU, ADINOLFI, G . BARONE,A. IADONISI,L. MANGONI,Tetrahedon Lett. 1998, 39, 2021; e) J. MARCO-CONTELLES, P. GALLEGO, M. RODRIGUEZ-FERNANDEZ, N. KHIAR,C. DESTABEL, M. BERNABE, A. MARTINEZGRAU,J. L. CHIARA,J . Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 7397; f ) A. M. H O R N E M A N I. ,LUNDT, Synthesis 1999, 317; g) A. M. HORNEMAN, 1. LUNDT,J . Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 1919; h) A. M. HORNEMAN, I. LUNDT,Tetrahedron 1997, 53,6879; i) A. M. HORNEMAN, I. LUNDT,I. SOTOFTE,Synlett 1995, 918; j) A. M. GOMEZ,G. 0. DANELON, E. J. C. LOPEZ,Chem. MORENO,S. VALVERDE, Commun. 1999, 175; k) E. MAUDRU, G. SINGH,R. H. WIGHTMAN,Chem. Commun. 1998,1505; 1) A. M. GOMEZ,G. 0. DANELON, S. VALVERDE, J. C. LOPEZ,J . Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 9626; m) J. C. LOPEZ,A. M. GOMEZ, B. FRASER-REID,Aust.]. Chem. 1995, 48, 333; n) A. M. GOMEZ,S. MANTECON, S. VALVERDE, J. C. LOPEZ,J.Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 6612; 0) K. Y. HSIA, P. WARD,R. B. LAMONT,P. M. D. LILLEY,D. J. WATKIN, G . W. J. FLEET,Tetrahedron Lett. 1994, 35, 4823. 17 a) F. E. ZIEGLER, Y. WANG,J . Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 426; b) D. J. HOLT,W. D.
BARKER, P. R. JENKINS, D. L. DAVIES,S. G A R R A J.~ ,F A W C E D. ~ , R. RUSSELL, S. GHOSH,Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, P. VAN D E WEGHE!D. 3298; c) 0. SELLIER, LE NOUEN,C. STREHLER, J. EUSTACHE, Tetrahedron Lett. 1999, 40, 853; d) R. N. CONRAD,M. J. GROGAN,C. R. BERTOZZI, Org. Lett. 2002, 4, 1359; e) L. HYLDTOFT,R. MADSEN, J . Am. Chem. SOC.2000, 122, 8444; f ) I. HANNA,L. RICARD,Org. Lett. 2000, 2, 2651; g) P. KAPFERER, F. SARABIA, A. VASELLA, Helu. Chim. Acta 1999, 82, 645; h ) F. D. BOYER,I. HANNA,S. P. NOLAN, J . Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 4094; i) A. KORNIENKO, M. D’ALARCAO, Tetrahedron: AsymmeQ 1999, 10,827.
18 For aldol-type cyclization see: a) D. HAAG,
X. T. C H E N ,B. FRASER-REID, Chem. Commun. 1998, 2577; b) A. J. WOOD,D. J . HOLT,M. C. DOMINGUEZ, P. R. J E N K I N S , J . Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 8522; c) A. J. WOOD,P. R. JENKINS, J. F A W C E D. ~ , R. I. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. RUSSELL, 1995, 1567; d) A. H U I , A. J. FAIRBANKS, R. J. NASH,P. M. D E Q. LILLEY,R. STORER,D. J. WATKIN,G. W. J . FLEET, Tetrahedron Lett. 1994, 35, 8895; e) F. CHRETIEN,F. KHALDI,Y. CHAPLEUR, Tetrahedron Lett. 1997, 38, 5977; f ) V. C E R E ,F. PERI,S. POLLICINO,Tetrahedron Lett. 1997, 38, 7797. For related anionic cyclization see: g) A. J. FAIRBANKS, A. HUI,B. M. SKEAD,P. M. DE Q. LILLEY,R. B. LAMONT, R. STORER,J. SAUNDERS, D. J. WATKIN, G. W. J. FLEET,Tetrahedron Lett. 1994, 35, 8891. For Cr/Ni mediated carbocyclization see: h) A. LUBINEAU,I. BILIAUT,J . Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 5668. 19 a) J.M. GROSHEINZ, H. 0. L. F I S C H E R , ~ . Am. Chem. Soc. 1948, 70, 1479; b) for a n intermolecular tandem, ring opening cyclization variant of this reaction see: I . KITAGAWA, A. KADOTA,M. YOSHIKAWA, Chem. Pharm. Bull. 1978, 26, 3825. 20 S. 1. ANGYAL,S. D. GERO,Aust. J . Chem. 1965, 18, 1973. 21 S. MIZRA,L.-P. MOLLEYERES, A. VASELLA, Helu. Chim. Acta 1985, 68, 988. 22 a ) A. KLEMER, M. KOHLA,Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1986,967; b) A. KLEMER, M. KOHLA,Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1987, 683. 23 a) T. K. M. SHING,Y. CUI, Y. TANG,J . Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1991, 754;
b) T. K. M. SHING,Y. TANG,Tetrahedron 1991, 47, 4571.
M. BALCI,Pure Appl. Chem. 1997, G9, 97. B. M. TROST, L. S. CHUPAK,T. LUBBERS, J. Am. Chem. SOC. 1998, 120, 1732. 26 a) Y. LANDAIS, Chimia 1998, 52, 104; b) R. ANGELAUD, Y. LANDAIS,Tetrahedron Lett.
24 25
1997, 51, 8841. 27 For a reviev, see: T. HUDLICKY, D. A.
ENTWISTLE, K. K. PITZER,A. J. THORPE, Chem. Rev. 1996, 96, 1195. 28 a) M. BANWELL, C. DE SAW, K. WATSON, Chem. Commun. 1998, 1189; b) F. YAN, B. V. NGUYEN,C. YORK,T. HUDLICKY, Tetrahedron, 1997, 53, 11541; c) T. HUDLICKY, A. J. THORPE,Chem. Commun. 1996, 1993; d) T . HUDLICKY, K. A.
References and Notes ABBOUD,D. A. ENTWISTLE, R. FAN, R. B. MAURYA,A. J. THORPE,J. BOLONICK, MYERS.Synthesis 1996, 897. 29 A. MARAS,H.SEFEN,Y. SUTBEYAZ, M. BALCI,J . Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 2039. 30 P.A. BARTLETT,K. SATAKE, J . Am. Chem. SOC.1988, 110, 1628. 31 For a highlight on carbohydrate ring contraction reactions see: H . REDLICH, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1994, 33, 1345. 32 R. J. FERRIER,]. Chem. SOC.Perkin Trans. 1 1979, 1455. 33 a) D.H. R. BARTON,J. CAMARA,P.DALKO, S. D. GERO,B. QUICLET-SIRE, P. STUTZ,J . Org. Chem. 1989, 54, 3764; b) D. J. CLEOPHAX, M. V. DE DUBREUIL, ALMEIDA,C. VERRE-SEBRIE, J. LIAIGRE,G. VASS,S. D. GERO,Tetrahedron 1997, 53, 16747; c) H. TAKAHASHI,H. KITAKA, S. IKEGAMI, J . Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 2705. 34 a) D. H. R. BARTON,S. AUGY-DOREY, J. CAMARA, P. DALKO,J. M. DELAUMENY, S. D. GERO,B. QUICLET-SIRE, P. STUTZ, Tetrahedron 1990, 46, 215; b) S. AUGYDOREY,P. DALKO,S. D. GERO,B. QUICLETSIRE,J. EUSTACHE,P. STUTZ, Tetrahedron 1993, 49, 7997. 35 a) D. J. JENKINS, D. DUBREUIL, B. V. L. POTTER,J . Chern. SOC., Perkin Trans. 1 1996, 1365; b) S. K. CHUNG,S. H . Yu, Y. T. CHANG,J. Carbohydrate Chem. 1998, 17, 385; c) S. K. C H U N G ,S. H. Yu, Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 1996, 6, 1461. 36 a) S. AMANO,N. OGAWA,M. OHTSUKA,S. OGAWA,N. CHIDA,Chem. Commun. 1998. 1263; b) T. MOMOSE,M. SETOGUCHI, T. FUJITA,H. TAMURA,N. CHIDA,Chem. Commun. 2000, 2237; c) S. AMANO,N. TAKEMURA, M. OHTSUKA,S. OGAWA,N. CHIDA,Tetrahedron 1999, 55, 3855; d) S. AMANO,N. OGAWA,M. OHTSUKA,N. CHIDA,Tetrahedron 1999, 55, 2205; e) S. AMANO,N. OGAWA,M. OHTSUKA,S. OGAWA,N. CHIDA,Chem. Commun. 1998, 1263; f ) N. CHIDA,M. JITSUOKA, Y. YAMAMOTO, M. OHTSUKA,S. OGAWA, Heterocycles 1996, 43, 1385; g) N. CHIDA, S. OGAWA,J. Chem. SOC. K. SUGIHARA, Chem. Commun. 1994, 901. 37 C. TAILLEFUMIER, Y. CHAPLEUR, D. BAYEUL,A. AUBRY,J. Chem. SOC.Chem. Commun. 1995,937. 38 a) H. TAKAHASHI, H. KITTAKA,S. IKEGAMI, J. Synth. Org. Chem. Jpn. 2000, 58, 120;
b) H . TAKAHASHI, T. IIMORI,S. IKEGAMI, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 6939; c) H. OHTAKE,X. L. LI, M. SHIRO,S. IKEGAMI, Tetrahedron 2000, 56, 7109; d) H . OHTAKE, S. IKEGAMI,Org. Lett. 2000, 2, 457; e) H . TAKAHASHI, H. KITTAKA,S. IKEGAMI, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 9703; f ) T. IIMORI,H. TAKAHASHI,S. IKEGAMI, Tetrahedron Lett. 1996, 37, 649. 39 a) S. ADAM,Tetrahedron Lett. 1988, 29, 6589; b) P. LASZLO,A. DUDON,J. Carbohydr. Chem. 1992, 11, 587. 40 a) S. L. BENDER, R. J. BUDHU,J. Am. Chem. SOC.1991, 113, 9883; b) V. A. ESTEVEZ,G. D. PRESTWICH,].Am. Chem. SOC.1991, 113, 9885; c) J. CHEN,L. FENG, Org. Chem. 1998, 63, G. D. PRESTWICH,~. 6511; d) J. CHEN,G . D. PRESTWICH, J . Org. Chem. 1998, 63,430; e) Q. M. Gu, G. D. J. Org. Chem. 1996, 61, 8642; PRESTWICH, f ) A. CHAUDHARY, G. D. PRESTWICH, Bioconjugate Chem. 1997, 8, 680; g) 0. THUM,J. CHEN,G. D. PRESTWICH, Tetrahedron Lett. 1996, 37, 9017; h) J. R. PENG,G. D. PRESTWICH,Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 3965; i) J. C H E N ,A. A. PROFIT, G. D. PRESTWICH, J . Org. Chem. 1996, 61, 6305; j) J. CHEN,G. DORMAN,G. D. J . Org. Chem. 1996, 61, 393; PRESTWICH, k) G. DORMAN,J. C H E N ,G. D. PRESTWICH, Tetrahedron Lett. 1995, 36, 8719. 41 P. BEIANGER,P. PRASIT,Tetrahedron Lett. 1988, 29, 5521. 42 S. K. DAS, J.-M. MALLET,P.SINAY,Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 493. 43 see also: P. A. V. VAN HOOFT,R. E. J. N. LITJENS,G. A. VAN D E R MAREL,C. A. A. VAN BOECKEL, J. H. VAN BOOM,Org. Lett. 2001, 3, 731. 44 a) M. SOLLOGOUB, A. J. PEARCE, A. HERAULT,P. SINAY, Tetrahedron:Asymmetry 2000, 11, 283; b) M. SOLLOGOUB, J. M. MALLET, P. SINAY.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2000, 39, 362. 45 a) B. D u ROIZEL,A. M. P. HENRIQUES, A. J. PEARCE,P. SINAY,IsraelJ. Chem. 2000, 40, 317; b) A. J. PEARCE,J. M. MALLET,P. SINAY,Heterocycles 2000, 52, 819; c) A. J. PEARCE,R. CHEVALIER, J.-M. MALLET,P. SINAY,Eur. J. Org. Chem. 2000, 2203; d) J. PEARCE,M. SOLLOGOUB, J.-M. MALLET,P. SINAY,Eur.J. Org. Chem. 1999, 3105. 46 For related Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of cyclic vinyl acetals affording
14
I
Direct Conversion of Sugar Clycosides into Carbocycles
47 48
49 50
51
52
53
tetrahydrofuranes o r tetrahydropyranes see: a) N. A. PETASIS,S:P. Lu, /. Am. Chem. SOC. 1995, 117, 6394; b) N. A. PETASIS,S.-P. Lu, Tetrahedron Lett. 1996, 36, 141; c) H.-D. SCHARF,H. FRAUENRATH,Chem. Ber. 1982, 115, 2728; d) R. MENICAGLI, C. MALANGA, M. G U I D I ,L. LARDICCI,Tetrahedron, 1987, 43, 171; e) D. J. DIXON,S. V. LEY,E. W. TATE,/. Chem. SOC., Perkin Trans. I 2000, 2385; f ) R. MENICAGLI, C. MALANGA, L. LARDICCI,J. Org. Chem. 1982, 47. 2288; g) R. MENICAGLI, C. MALANGA, M. DELL’INNOCENTI, L. ~ R D I C C/.I Org. , Chem. 1987, 52, 5700; h) A. B. SMITH, I l l , K. P. MINBIOLE, P. R. VERHOEST,M. /. Am. Chem. SOC.2001, 123, SCHELHAAS, 10942; i) A. B. SMITH,P. R. VERHOEST, K. P. MINBIOLE, J. J. LIM, Org. Lett. 1999, I, 909; j) A. B. SMITH,K. P. MINBIOLE, P. R. VERHOEST, T. J. BEAUCHAMP, Org. Lett. 1999, I, 913 a n d references cited. M. SOLLOGOUB, J.-M. MALLET,P. SINAY, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 3471. H. ITO,Y. MOTOKI,T. TAGUCHI,Y. HANZAWA, /. Am. Chem. SOC. 1993, 115, 8835. Y. YOSHIDA, T. NAKAGAWA, F. SATO,Synlett 1996.437. a) J. M. AURRECOECHEA, B. LOPEZ,M. ARRATE,/. Org. Chem. 2000, 65, 6493; b) J. M. AURRECOECHEA, M. ARRATE,B. LOPEZ,Synlett 2001, 872. A. CHENEDB,P. POTHIER,M. SOLLOGOUB, A. J. FAIRBANKS, P. SINAY,J. Chem. SOC. Chem. Commun. 1995, 1373. a) T. KAN,S. NARA,T. OZAWA,H. F. MATSUDA,Angew. Chem. SHIRAHAMA, Int. Ed. 2000, 39, 355; b) F. MATSUDA, /. Synth. Org. Chem. Jpn. 1995, 53, 987; c) J. J. C. GROVE,C. W. HOLZAPFEL, D. B. G. WILLIAMS,Tetrahedron Lett. 1996, 37, 5817; d) 2. H . ZHOU,S. M. BENNETT, Tetrahedron Lett. 1997, 38, 1153; e) J. L. CHIARA,J. MARCO-CONTELLES, N. KHIAR, P. GALLEGO, C. DESTABEL, M. BERNABE,/. Org. Chem. 1995, 60, 6010. a) J. K. GALLOS, T . V. K O F T I S , ~Chem. . SOC. Perkin Trans. 12001, 415; b) J. K. GALLOS,
T. V. KOFTIS,A. E. KOUMBIS,V. I. MOUTSOS,Synlett 1999, 1289; c) J. K. E. E. SPATA,Eur. GALLOS,C. C. DELLIOS, /. Org. Chem. 2001, 1, 79; d) J. K. GALLOS, V. P. XIRAPHAKI,C. C. A. E. KOUMBIS, DELLIOS,E. COUTOULI-ARGYROPOULOU, Tetrahedron 1999, 55, 15167; e) J. K. GALLOS,A. E. KOUMBIS, N. E. APOSTO-
54
55 56
57
58 59 60
61
LAKIS, J. Chem. SOC., Perkin Trans. I 1997, 2457. a ) L. A. PAQUETTE, C. M. G. PHILIPPO, N. H. Vo; Can.J. Chem. 1992. 70, 1356; b) C. M. G. PHILIPPO,N. H. Vo, L. A. J . Am. Chem. 1991, 113, 2762; PAQUETTE, c) L. A. PAQUETTE,D. FRIERICH,R. D. ROGERS, J. Org. Chem. 1991, 56, 3841: M. A. M. FUHRY,A. B. HOLMES,D. R. MARSHALL, /. Chem. SOL., Perkin Trans. I 1993, 2743 a n d references. B. WERSCHKUN, J. THIEM,Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 2793. a ) W. WANG,Y. ZHANG,M. SOLLOGOUB, P. SINAY,Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2000, 39, 2466; b) W. WANG,Y. ZHANG,H . Z H O U , Y. BLERIOT,P. SINAY,Eur. J. Org. Chem. 2001, 1053. P. A. V. VAN HOOFT,G. A. VAN D E R MAREL,C. A. A. VAN BOECKEL, J. H. VAN BOOM,Tetrahedron Lett. 2001, 42. 1769. A. V. R. L. SUDHA,M. NAGARAJAN,/. Chem. SOC. Chem. Commun. 1998, 925. G . BUCHI, J. E. POWELL JR.,/. Am. Chem. SOC.1967, 89, 4559. For selected examples see: a) T. K. M. SHING,D. A. ELSLEY, J. G. GILLHOULEY, J. Chem. SOC. Chem. Commun. 1989, 1280; b) S. JIANG,K. J. MCCULLOUGH, B. MEKKI, G. SINGH,R. H . WIGHTMAN,]. Chem. SOC., Perkin Trans. 11997, 1805; c) S. D. JIANG,B. MEKKI,G. SINGH,R. H. WIGHTMAN,Tetrahedron Lett. 1994, 35, 5505; d) R. A. FARR,N. P. PEET,M. S. KANG,Tetrahedron Lett. 1990, 31, 7109; N. P. PEET,E. W. HUBER,R. A. FARR, Tetrahedron 1991, 47, 7537; e) K. VANHESSCHE, C. G. BELLO,M. VANDEWALLE, Synlett 1991, 921. S. JIANG,G. SINGH,A. S. BATSANOV, Tetrahedron:Asymmetty 2000, 1 I, 3873.
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
Synthesis o f Diary1 Ethers: A Long-standing Problem Has Been Solved Fritz Theil
Until quite recently the synthesis of diaryl ethers has not been an easy task unless the target molecule was not sensitive towards the very harsh reaction conditions employed. The diaryl ether structural unit (Figure 1) is found in natural products such as perrottetines (1) [l],their cyclic analogues [lb], riccardin B (2) 121, and a variety of more complex molecules containing sensitive functional groups and stereogenic centres [ 31 to which for example the cyclic peptides K 13 (3) [ 3 ] and vancomycin [4,51 belong. The diaryl ether formation in cyclic peptides was reviewed by Rama Rao et al. [6] in 1995. Furthermore, poly (aryl ethers) such as 4 are important commercial polymers used as engineering thermoplastics [ 71. Both the synthesis of highly functionalized molecules and the large-scale preparation of polymers are challenging tasks for synthetic organic chemists. However, the classical arylation procedure of phenols with aryl halides under Ullmann conditions [S] using copper powder or copper salts requires harsh reaction conditions as a result of the poor nucleophilicity of the phenoxide and the low reactivity of the aryl halides involved. The reactions have to be carried out in a temperature range of 120-250 "C by using high boiling solvents or neat reagents over an extended period of time. These conditions have been applied to the synthesis of relatively simple diaryl ethers such as riccardin B (2), which lacks sensitive functional groups, by using a copper phenoxide and an aryl bromide in refluxing pyridine for twenty hours. For the preparation of poly (aryl ethers), the most reactive electrophiles towards sodium phenoxides are aryl fluorides and triflates. In a model reaction complete conversion has been achieved at 150 "C in N-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone (NMP) within four hours if both the haloarene and the phenol are activated by a paracarbonyl group (Scheme 1)191. The structural relevance of diaryl ethers and the lack of a convenient, mild and general method for their preparation has resulted in increased efforts towards filling this gap in the synthetic methodology during the past decade. Yamamura et al. [lo] developed a method that encompasses the oxidative coupling of 2,6-dihalophenols with T1(N03)3to afford a 2-substituted quinone, which subsequently is reduced to the corresponding diaryl ether. This procedure has been applied by the Evans group [ 111 for the synthesis of the orienticin C aglycone. Despite the fact that this reaction is conducted under mild conditions, it is nevertheless a two step procedure that requires a
16
I
Synthesis of Diaryl Ethers: A Long-standingProblem Has Been Solved
R'
HO
OH
HO
2
1
HO
Y = S(=O),,
3
c=o 4
Fig. 1. Examples for the diaryl ether function in natural products and synthetic polymers. R', RZ in 1 = H,OH,OMe.
ONa
I
NMP, 150 "C
X = F, OSO,CF, Scheme 1.
Diaryl ether formation from para-carbonyl activated phenolates and arylfluorides or triflates
specific type of substituted phenol and a highly toxic thallium salt. These requirements preclude it from being a general user-friendly method. The recent development directed towards the synthesis of diaryl ethers in a milder and more efficient manner was mainly driven by the synthesis of complex natural products. Eicher and Walter [ 11 introduced an activating ortho-nitro group in their synthesis of diaryl ethers (Scheme 2a), thus increasing the reactivity of aryl halides towards phenoxides s i g nificantly so that a reaction temperature of 125 "C for less than one hour was required. By using this coupling procedure perrottetines (1) [la], and very recently their cyclic analogues
Synthesis ofDiaty/ Ethers: A Long-Standing Problem Has Been Sobed 117
X = CI. F
0 rlJ
0 N I
KN
kN CuBr-SMe,, K,CO,
xR'J (
+
HoQ R2
MeCNIpyridine, 80 "C*
R'
bOQ R'
X = Br, I Diary1 ether formation by orthoactivation. a) Methods of Eicher et al. and Zhu et al., (R' = 4-CHO, 4-C02Me, 4CH2CH(NHBoc)C02Me; R2 = 2-OMe-4-CH0, 2.3(OMe)2-4-C02Me, 4-CH2CH(NH B0c)COzMe), Scheme 2.
b) Method of Nicolaou et al. (R' = 3-Me, 5-Me, 3,5-Me2; R2 = 2-CI, 4 4 , 2-CI-4-Me).1) NaH, DMF, 125 "C (X = CI); 2) NaZCO3 or CsF, DMF, 25 "C (X = F).
[Ib] under even milder conditions, have been synthesized. As reported by Zhu [3], phenoxides react smoothly at room temperature when ortho-nitro fluoro arenes are used as electrophiles. This approach has been applied to the synthesis of a variety of macrocyclic diaryl ethers [ 31 including vancomycin [4a, b] and its subunits [ 12a] or related compounds [ 12b]. However, this method requires subsequent reduction and deamination steps in order to remove the nitro group unless the target molecule bears this functional group. The approach from Nicolaou [ 131 is similarly based on the activation of an aryl halide. Aryl bromides and iodides substituted with ortho-triazene react smoothly with phenols at 80 "C in the presence of KZC03 and CuBr.MezS to afford diaryl ethers in good yields (Scheme 2b). The use of this procedure requires the preformation of the requisite triazenes and the subsequent removal or transformation of this functional group. Alternatively, chloroarenes can be activated via the formation of manganese, chromium, iron or ruthenium n-complexes that react at low temperature with phenoxides to yield diaryl ethers [14]. Higher temperatures (DMF, 90 "C) require the formation of diaryl ethers from iodonium salts and phenoxides [ 151 and the coupling of bromo benzoquinones with phenoxides (DMF, 100-110 "C) followed by a subsequent reduction with dithionite [lG]. Palladium catalyzed couplings between sodium phenoxides and electron deficient aryl bromides have been reported by Hartwig et al. [I71 based on an in-situ-ligand exchange of dibenzylideneacetone (dba) with 1,l'-diphenylphosphinoferrocene(dppf) [ 17a] (Scheme 3a). Further improvements of this methodology have been achieved for unactivated aryl halides by the Hartwig group by using ferrocenyldi-tert-butylphosphine instead of dppf [17b] or the as the palladium ligand [ 17~1. Buchwald group by using 2-(di-tert-butylphosphino)biphenyl The reactions still need relatively high temperatures and long reaction times.
18
I
Synthesis ofDiary1 Ethers: A Long-Standing Problem Has Been Solved
a)
(CuOTf),PhH, EtOAc R2
R'
Cs,CO,,
toluene, 110 "C
X = Br, I Palladium- a n d copper triflate-catalyzed diarylether synthe. sis. a) R' = CN, CHO, COCFj, COPh; R2 = Me, O M e ; b) R' = 4-CI, 4-C02Et. 4-Me, 4431.1, 4-OMe, 4-NMe2, 4-CN, 4-COMe, 2,5-Me2, 3,sMe2; R2 = 2-Me. 4-Me, Z-iPr, 4-CI, 3,4-Me?. Scheme 3.
Another phenoxide activating approach published by Buchwald et al. [ 181 is based on the reaction of cesium phenoxides with aryl bromides or iodides in the presence of catalytic amounts of copper(1) triflate and ethyl acetate in refluxing toluene (Scheme 3b). In certain cases equimolar amounts of 1-naphthoic acid have been added in order to increase the reactivity of the phenoxide. The authors assume the formation of a cuprate-like intermediate of the structure [(Ar0)2Cu]-Csf as the reactive species. In addition, diaryl ether formation between phenols and aryl halides has been achieved using a phosphazene base forming naked phenoxide in the presence of copper bromide in refluxing toluene or 1,4-dioxane [19]. Besides, an enzymatic approach has been developed by Sih and his group by using an oxidative coupling of tyrosine or hydroxyphenylglycine units by hydrogen peroxide in the presence of peroxidases followed by a subsequent reduction step (Scheme 4). Yields in general are moderate and sometimes low. Dependent on the pH of the medium, diaryl ether formation is accompanied by more or less C-C-coupling reactions.
x+x
H,O,.
&:ex pH 4-6
R
CrCI, or NaHSO,
OH
R
R Enzymatic diaryl ether formation. X = F, CI, Br; X' = CI, Br, H; R = C H * C H ( N H A c ) C 0 2 H , (CH?)?NHAc, CH(NHAc)CO2Me.
Scheme 4.
Synthesis o f D i a v / Ethers: A Long-standing Problem Has Been Solved
Finally, the remarkably simple solution came from Evans et al. [2la] and researchers of DuPont [2lb] simultaneously. Their method allows the coupling of structurally and electronically diverse phenols and aryl boronic acids in the presence of copper(11) acetate, triethylamine or pyridine, and molecular sieves at ambient temperature (Scheme 5). Even phenolic amino acid derivatives react smoothly without racemization. The only limitation has been observed when using ortho-heteroatom substituted boronic acids which resulted in lower product yields. The initial step in the proposed pathway (Scheme G) is the transmetallation of the boronic acid residue with the copper salt.
RIW
$2
Copper(l1)-promoted coupling of boronic acids with phenols. R' = 4-Me, 2-CI, 2-1, 2-OMe, ~ - C H ~ C H ( N H B O C ) C O3,s. ~M~, tBu2; R2 = 4-Me, 4-F, 4-OMe, 3-OMe, 3-NO2, 2-Me, 2-OMe, 3-CI-4-F.
Scheme 5.
L
reductive
At-0-
/ Ar'
'OAr'
L Ar/\c$k \OAr' d elimination v e Scheme 6.
Proposed mechanism for the copper(l1)-promoted coupling o f boronic acids with phenols.
The solution of this long-standing problem has been achieved by application of this general method that allows for the coupling of diverse phenols with a variety of aryl boronic acids, many of which are commercially available. It overcomes problems associated with procedures used before and offers significant advantages such as a broad substrate variety, mildness and avoids the use of highly toxic materials. In addition, under the reaction conditions employed N-arylation of different types of Nnucleophiles has been achieved [ 21b]. By using this mild and versatile methodology, symmetrical diaryl ethers have been synthesized in a one-pot, two-step procedure starting from arylboronic acids and their partial conversion to the corresponding phenols by oxidation with hydrogen peroxide and a subsequent coupling of the formed phenols with the remaining arylboronic acids upon addition of copper(I1) acetate, molecular sieves and triethyl amine (Scheme 7) [22]. A much more detailed discussion of the most recent developments in inter- and intramolecular diaryl ether formation can be found in the literature [23].
20
I
Synthesis of Diary/ Ethers; A Long-Standing Problem Has Been Solved 1. HO ,,
CH,CI,
(30%)
-
2.Cu(OAc),, NEt, MS (4A). 25 "C
R
One-pot conversion of arylboronic acids into diary1 ethers. R = 3-NO2, 4-Me, 4-OMe, 4-Ac, 4-F, 4 4 , 4-Br.
Scheme 7.
References 1 a) T. EICHER,M. WALTER,Synthesis 1991,
W. LABADIE, J. L. HEDRICK,M. UEDA, Am. Chem. SOC.Symp. Ser. 1996, 624, 210-
7 J.
469-473; b) T. EICHER,S . FEY,W. PUHL,
2 3
4
5
6
E. BUCHEL,A. SPEICHER, Eur. ]. Org. Chem. 1998, 877-888. M. IYODA,M. SAKAITANI, H. OTSUKA,M. ODA,Tetrahedron Lett. 1985, 26, 4777-4780. a) J. ZHU, Synlett 1997, 133-144, b) A. BIGOT,M. BOIS-CHOUSSY, J. ZHU, Tetrahedron Lett. 2000, 41, 4573-4577. Vancomycin syntheses: a) D. A. EVANS, M. R. WOOD,B. W. T R O ~ E T. R , I. RICHARDSON, J. C. BARROW,J. L. KATZ, Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 2864-2868; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 27002704; b) D. A. EVANS,C. J. DINSMORE, P. S. WATSON,M. R. WOOD,T. I. RICHARDSON, B. W. TROTTER,J. L. KATZ, Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 2868-2872, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 2704S. NATARAJAN, 2708; c) K. C. NICOLAOU, H. LI, N. F. JAIN,R. HUGHES,M. E. SOLOMON, J. M. RAMANJULU, C. N. C. BODDY,M. TAKAYANAGI, Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 2872-2878 Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 2708-2714; d) K. C. NICOIAOU,N. F. JAIN,S. NATARAJAN, R. HUGHES,M. E. SOLOMON, H. LI, J. M. RAMANJULU, M. TAKAYANAGI, A. E. KOUMBIS,T. BANDO,Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 2879-2881, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 2714-2716; e) K. C. NICOLAOU, M. TAKAYANAGI, N. F. JAIN,S. NATARAJAN, A. E. KOUMBIS, T. BANDO,J. M. RAMANJULU, Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 2881-2883, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 2717-2719. Highlight on the vacomycin syntheses: A. J. ZHANG,K. BURGESS, Angew. Chem. 1999, 11 1, 666-669, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1999, 38, 634-636. A. V. RAMA RAo, M. K. GURJAR,K. L. REDDY,A. S. RAO, Chem. Rev. 1995, 95, 2135-2167.
225. 8 J. LINDLEY, Tetrahedron 1984, 40, 1433-
1456. 9 H. JONSSON, J. L. HEDRICK,J. W. LABADIE,
Polymer Prepnnts 1992, 33, 394-395. H. NODA,M. NIWA,S. YAMAMURA, Tetrahedron Lett. 1981, 22, 3247-3248. For further applications of this methodology by Yamamura's group and others see [ 61. 11 D. E. EVANS,C. J. DINSMORE, A. M. RATZ, D. A. EVRARD,J. C. BARROW,].Am. Chem. SOC.1997, 119,4317-3418. 12 a) D. L. BOGER,R. M. BORZILLERI, S. NUKUI,R. T. BERESIS, /. Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 4721-4736, b) L. NEUVILLE, M. BoisCHOUSSY,J. ZHU, Tetrahedron Lett. 2000, 10
41, 1747-1751. 13
14
15 16
17
K. C. NICOLAOU, C. N. C. BODDY,S. NATARAJAN, T.-Y. YUE, H. LI, S. B R ~ S E , J. M. RAMANJULU, J . Am. Chem. SOC. 1997, 119, 3421-3422. a ) A . J. PEARSON, J. G. PARK,P. Y. ZHU,]. Org. Chem. 1992, 57, 3583-3589; b) A. J. PEARSON, K. LEE,]. Org. Chem. 1994, 59, 2304-2313; c) A. J. PEARSON,P. 0. BELMONT,Tetrahedron Lett. 2000, 41, 1671-1675; d) M. F. SEMMELHACK in Comprehensive Organometallic Chemistry II? Vol. 12 (Ed.: E. W. ABEL,F. G. A. STONE, G. WILKINSON), Pergamon, NY, 1995, p. 979. M. J. CRIMMIN,A. G. BROWN,Tetrahedron Lett. 1990, 31, 2017-2020. B. SIMONEAU, P. BRASSARD,].Chem. SOC. Perkin Trans. 1, 1984, 1507-1510. For further applications of this method see (61. a) G. MANN,J. F. HARTWIG,Tetrahedron Lett. 1997, 38, 8005-8008; b) G . MANN, C. INCARVITO, A. L. RHEINGOLD, J. F. HARTWIG,]. Am. Chem. SOC. 1999, 121, 3224-3225; c) A. ARANYOS, D. W. OLD,
References 121
A. KIYOMORI,1. P. WOLFE,I. P. SADIGHI; S. L. BUCHWALD,]. Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 4369-4378. 18 J.-F. MARCOUX, S. DOYE,S. L. BUCHWALD, I.Am. Chem. SOC. 1997, 119,10539-10540. 19 C. PALOMO, M. OIARBIDE, R. LOPEZ, E. GOMEZ-BENGOA, Chem. Commun. 1998, 2091-2092. 20 a) 2. Guo, G. M. SAIAMONCZYK, K. HAN, K. MACHIYA, C. J. SIH,]. Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 6700-6701; b) 2. G u o , G. M. SAJAMONCZYK, K. HAN,K. MACHIYA, C. J . SIH,J. Org. Chem. 1998,63, 4269-4276;
21
c) I. MALNAR, C. J. SIH, Tetrahedron Lett. 2000, 41, 1907-1911 and references cited therein. a) D. E. EVANS,I. L. KATZ,T. R. WEST, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998,39, 2937-2940; b) D. M. T. CHAN,K. L. MONACO,R.-P.
WANG,M. P. WINTERS,Tetrahedron Lett. 1998,39, 2933-2936. 22 J. SIMON,S. SALZBRUNN, G. K. S. PRAKASH, N. A. PETASIS,G. A. OIAH,]. Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 633-634. 23 J. S. SAWYER, Tetrahedron, 2000, 56, 50455065.
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
** I
Take The Right Catalyst: Palladium-catalyzed CC, CN and CO-Bond Formation on Chloro-Arenes Rainer Sturmer
Chlorinated arenes are cheap to manufacture and therefore play a vital role as intermediates in chemical industry. However, in contrast to their - much more expensive - brominated and iodinated counterparts chloroarenes are quite unreactive in subsequent reactions. Classical functionalizations of the C-CI- bond in non-activated arenes usually require harsh conditions and side reactions may produce environmentally hazardous oxygenated chloroarenes. This leads to considerable problems in using these compounds as intermediates in the synthesis of higher functionalized biologically active molecules, e.g. agrochemicals and pharmaceuticals. Due to recent developments in catalysis former problems might be overcome: The groups of S. L. Buchwald, G. C. Fu and J. F. Hartwig among others reported significant improvements on the CC, CN and CO-Bond formation on chloroarenes. For all of these bond formations the right choice of catalyst is crucial for success. In other words: by ligand tuning all three bond forming reactions can be realized by palladium catalysis. The following account focuses on recent work, since the subject has been already reviewed [ 11. Heck and Suzuki type couplings have been described by Fu [2] et al. The reaction of chlorobenzene and styrene in refluxing dioxane in the presence of [Pd2(dba)3]and the electron rich tri-tert.-butyl-phosphane [eq. (a)] gives rise to trans-stilbene in 83% yield. Besides the choice of the ligand - aryl phosphanes, tri-n-butyl-phosphane or tri-cyclohexyl-phosphane show no conversion - the base is also crucial for success. Cesium carbonate gives the best results, although the cheaper potassium phosphate gives comparable yields.
\
*#
1.5 rnol-% [Pd2(dba)3]
(JQ-
/
(a)
6 mol-% P(Wu),
Cs2CO3 Scheme 1.
83 %
Take The Right Catalyst: Palladium-catalyzedCC, CN and CO-Bond Formation on Chloro-Arenes
Under the same conditions the sterically more demanding 2-chlorotoluene is coupled in 70% yield. However longer reaction times are necessary. Acceptor- as well as donorsubstituents are tolerated under these conditions. Tri-tea.-butyl-phosphane is the ligand of choice in Suzuki-couplings [ 31 as well: 2-chlorotoluene reacts with 2-methyl-phenylboronic acid to 2,2'-disubstituted biphenyl in 87% yield [eq. (b)].
B(oH)2
o("'+ 0:
1.5 r n o l - O h [Pd2(dba)3]
* 3.6 rnol-% P ( ~ B u ) ~
f l
(b)
87 Yo Scheme 2.
Another contribution from Fu [4]et al. describes the Stille-coupling of chloroarenes, in which vinyl-, allyl-, phenyl-, and even alkyl groups can be transferred in the presence of cesium fluoride. An improved procedure of Suzuki-couplings was recently described by Buchwald [ 51 et al. By using 0-(di-tert.buty1-phosphin0)-biphenylas ligand, palladium acetate and potassium carbonate couplings are facilitated at room temperature [eq. (c)].
B(OH)z OMe
1 mol-% Pd(OAc)2 >
(c)
2 mol-%
95 Yo
RT Scheme 3.
Catalyst concentrations may be kept quite low in the range of 0.02-0.05 mol%. In a similar context Hartwig [GI et al. published a screening method aiming at the rapid identification of efficient ligands in Heck-type couplings based on a fluorescence assay. Arylations of ketones and malonates with aryl chlorides have been recently published [eq. (d)] by the same research group [7]. Electron rich phosphanes are used to secure good conversions.
( ~ c +l /
6
2 mol-% Pd(0Ac)p
50'C, 12 h Scheme 4.
(a
2 mob% P ( C Y ) ~
93 %
I
23
24
I
Take The Right Catalyst: Palladium-catalyzed CC,
CN and CO-Bond Formation on Chloro-Arenes
0-(Di-tert.-buty1phosphino)biphenyl has been used by Buchwald IS] et al. as the most efficient ligand in the Pd-catalyzed amination of aryl chlorides. 2-Chloro-4-methyl-toluene can be aminated with pyrrolidine in 98% yield using sodium-tert.-butoxide [eq. (e)].
98 %
RT Scheme 5.
These reactions went to completion at room temperature within 15-20 hours; donor- and acceptor-substituents are tolerated. Pd-catalyzed CO- bond forming reactions were performed by Buchwald [ 8 ] et al. with 2-dimethylamino-2’-di-(tert.-butyl)-biphenyl as ligand. 3,4-Dimethylphenol can be arylated smoothly with 2-chloro-4-methyl-toluenein the presence of sodium hydride [eq. (f)].
1 mob% Pd(OAc),
*
2 mol-% P(m2
&p
(f)
78 %
Me2N Scheme 6.
Hartwig [91 et al. developed a novel ferrocene-based dialkyl-phosphine-ligand for this arylation: 2-methoxy-4-methyl-phenolis arylated with 2-chloro-pxylene in 81% yield [eq. (g)].
a:+ *no& (9)
OMe 2 mob% [Pd2(dba)s] 4 mol-% FcP(tBu)2
81 % Scheme 7.
Recent work from Lipshutz [lo] et al. even shows at least in CC-bond formations the replacement of the rather expensive palladium with nickel. Chloroarenes are coupled with organo zink compounds under nickel(0) catalysis.
References 125
After the original publication of this highlight in 1999 more than 300 related papers have appeared in the field. A complete coverage is well beyond the scope of this book. Therefore only an update on some selected developments is given. Carbonylations [ 111 and Cyanations [ 121 of chloroarenes have been described by Beller et al. Several new catalysts have been introduced during the past two years; especially noteworthy are nucleophilic carbene-ligand based catalysts developed [ 131 by Herrmann’s group among others. A saturated variant has been established by Hartwig et al. Related work with donor-substituted carbenes has been published [ 151 by McGuiness and Cavell. Several detailed mechanistic papers have been published by Hartwig [ 161 et al. Palladacycles [ 171 have been established as important class of catalysts, an unusual phosphine-free sulfur containing catalyst was introduced by Zim [ 181 et al. A phosphinite based palladacycle [ 191 proved to be very efficient in Suzuki coupling reactions. An N,P-Ligand type was synthesized by Kocovsky [20] et al. Tridentate pincer ligands [21] have been proved useful in the Heck reaction. Recent developments regarding Heck 1221 and Suzuki [23] reactions have been reviewed by Fu and Littke. A new catalyst especially suitable for Heck couplings has been introduced by Beller [24] et al. Carbene [25] - as well as phosphine [26] ligands have been attached to polymer supports and proved to be recyclable catalysts in the Heck reaction. With special regard to CO-bond formation including intra-molecular examples two papers by Buchwald [27] have been published. Recent advances in amination chemistry was highlighted by Buchwald [28] and Hartwig [29]. Besides palladium nickel [ 301 evolved as a suitable metal for several coupling reactions. For quite a long time chloroarenes were considered as too unreative for catalysis. However the significant improvements in various coupling reactions of chloroarenes by the use of electron rich phosphanes have rendered this statement as no longer valid. The use of these cheap intermediates as coupling partners in the synthesis of higher functionalized molecules of industrial relevance is now within reach. Since some of these ligands are already commercially available it’s probably only a question of time when we will see the first industrial applications of these improved procedures.
References a) M. BELLER, T. H. RIERMEIERin Transition Metals for Organic Synthesis, Vol. 1 (Hrsg.: M. BELLER, C. BOLM): Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 1998, S. 184-193; M. BELLER, T. H. RIERMEIER, G. STARKibid. S. 208Angew. Chem. 1998, 236; b) J. F. HARTWIG, 110, 2154-2177, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 2046-2067; c) B. H. YANG, S. L. BUCHWALD, 1. Organomet. Chem. 1999, 576, 125-146. z A. F. LITTKE,G. C. Fu,J. Org. Chem. 1999, 64, 10-11. 3 A. F. LITTKE,G. C. Fu, Angew. Chem. 1998,
1
110, 3586-3587, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 3387-3388. 4 A. F. LIITKE,G. C. Fu, Angew. Chem. 1999, 111, 2568-2570; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1999, 38, 2411-2413. 5 a) J. P. WOLFE, S. L. BUCHWALD,Angew. Chem. 1999, 111, 2570-2573; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1999, 38, 2413-2416; b) R. A. SINGER, S. L. BUCHWALD,Tetrahedron Lett. 1999, 40, 1095-1098. 6 K. H. SHAUGNESSY, P. KIM, J. F. HARTWIG, J . Am. Chem. Soc. 1999, 121, 2123-2132.
26
I
Take The Right Catalyst: Palladium-catalyzedCC, CN and CO-Bond Formation on Chloro-Arenes 7
8
9
10
11 12
13
14
15 16
17 18
M. KAWATSURA, J. F. HARTWIG,/. Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 1473-1478. A. ARANYOS, D. W. OLD,A. KIYOMORI, J. P. WOLFE,J . P. SADIGHI,S. L. BUCHWALD,/.Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 43694378. G. MANN,C. INCARVITO, A. L. RHEINGOLD, J. F. HARTWIG,/.Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 3224-3225. a) B. H. LIPSHUTZ, P. A. BLOMGREN, /. Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 5819-5820; b) B. H. LIPSHUTZ, T. TOMIOKA, P. A. J. A. SCLAFANI, Inorg. Chim. BLOMGREN, Acta 1999, 296, 164-169. M. BELLER, A. F. INDOLESE, Chimiu 2001, 55, 684-687. M. SUNDERMEIER, A. ZAPF,M. BELLER,J. SANS,Tetrahedron Lett. 2001, 42, 67076710. a) W. A. HERRMANN, V. P. W. BOHM, C. W. K. GSTOITMAYR, M. GROSCHE, C. P. REISINGER,T. WESKAMP, /. Orgunomet. Chem. 2001, 617, 616-628; b) T. WESKAMP,V. P. W. BOHM,W. A. HERRMANN, J . Organomet. Chem. 1999, 585, 348-352; c) C. ZHANG,J. HUANG, M. L. TRUDELL, S. P. NOLAN,/.Org. Chem. 1999, 64, 3804-3805. S. R. STAUFFER,S. W. LEE, J. P. STAMBULI, S. I. HAUCK,J. F. HARTWIG, Org. Lett. 2000, 2, 1423-1426. D. S. MCGUINNESS, K. J. CAVELL, Orgunometallics 2000, 19, 741-748. a) L. M. ALCAZAR-ROMAN, J. F. HARTWIG, A. L. RHEINGOLD,L. M. LIABLE-SANDS, I. A. GUZEI,/. Am. Chem. SOC.2000, 122, 4618-4630; b) A. H. ROY, J. F. HARTWIG, /. Am. Chem. SOC. 2001, 123, 12321233. V. P. W. BOHM, W. A. HERRMANN, Chem. Eur. /. 2001, 7,4191-4197. D. ZIM,A. S. GRUBER, G . EBELING, J.
19 20
21 22 23 24 25
26 27
28
29
30
DUPONT,A. L. MONTEIRO, Org. Lett. 2000, 2, 2881-2884. R. B. BEDFORD,S. L. WELCH,Chem. Commun. 2001, 129-130. P. KOCOVSKY, S. VYSKOCIL, I. CISAROVA, J. SEJBAL, 1. TISLEROVA, M. SMRCINA, G . C. LLOYD-JONES,S. C. STEPHEN, C. P. Burrs, M. MURRAY,V. LANGER,]. Am. Chem. SOC. 1999, 121, 7714-7715. D. E. BERGBREITER, P. L. OSBURN, Y.-S. LIU. J. Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121,9531-9538. A. F. LITTKE, G. C. Fu,/. Am. Chem. SOC. 2001, 123, 6989-7000. A. F. LITTKE, G. C. Fu,]. Am. Chem. SOC. 2001, 123, 2719-2724. A. EHRENTRAUT,A. ZAPF,M. BELLER, Synlett 2000, 1589-1592. J. SCHWARZ, V. P. W. BOHM, M. G. GARDINER, M. GROSCHE, W. A. H E R R M A N W. N , HIERINGER, G. RAUDASCHL-SIEBER, Chem. Eur. /. 2000, 6, 1773-1780. C. A. PARRISH, S. L. BUCHWALD,/. Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 3820-3827. a) S. KUWABE, K. E. TORRACA, S. L. BUCHWALD, /. Am. Chem. Soc. 2001, 123, X. H . 12202-12206; b) K. E. TORRACA, H U A N GC. , A. PARRISH, S. L. BUCHWALD, /. Am. Chem. SOC.2001, 123, 10770-10771. J. P. WOLFE,H. TOMORI;J. P. SADIGHI; J. J. Y I N , S. L. BUCHWALD, 1. Org. Chem. 2000, 65, 1158-1174. J. F. HARTWIG,M. KAWATSURA, S. I. HAUCK,K. H. SHAUGHNESSY, L. M. ALCAZAR-ROMAN, /. Org. Chem. 1999, 64, 5575-5580. a) D. ZIM,V. R. LANDO, J. DUPONT,A. L. MONTEIRO, Org. Lett. 2001, 3, 3049-3051; b) V. P. W. BOHM,T. WESKAMP, C. W. K. GSTOTTMAYR, W. A. HERRMANN, Angew. Chem. 2000, 112, 1672-1674; Angew. Chem. h t . Ed. 2000, 39, 1602.
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
Alkyne Metathesis in Natural Product Synthesis Thomas Lindel
The application of alkene [ 11 - and, more recently, enyne [ 21 and alkyne - metathesis to the synthesis of natural products has been triggered by the development of powerful catalysts that allow metathesis reactions to be carried out under mild conditions. Scheme 1 outlines two important cases of alkene and alkyne metathesis of particular interest to the synthesis of natural products (together with the general scheme of enyne metathesis, not discussed in this review). The metathesis products can be obtained in high yields, since ethene/2-butyne are formed as volatile products. After the alkene/alkyne metathesis, the substituents (R) of the alkenes/alkynes are located on the same multiple bond. Enyne metathesis can be considered as the more general case of alkene metathesis, because two new double bonds are again formed, albeit now connected by a single bond.
p== f+ II cat.
alkene metathesis
R
+
R
enyne metathesis
alkyne metathesis
Scheme 1 .
1
+
,(I k
cat.
R
111
+
111
R
Alkene, enyne, and alkyne metathesis.
This short review focuses on the application of alkyne metathesis in the field of natural product synthesis, which is central for the evaluation and ranking of synthetic methods. Natural products are often complex, with the simultaneous presence of different functional groups and novel molecular architecture. If a method works for chemicals bought from the
28
I
Alkyne Metathesis in Natural Product Synthesis
catalog, this does not necessarily mean that it works for important cases of application. After about four years of alkyne metathesis in total synthesis, the problems tackled have already become quite demanding and relevant. Alkyne metathesis reactions have considerable potential for the synthesis of novel polymers, not covered in this article. For a leading reference, see Bunz [ 31. Scheme 2 shows two pioneering experiments. The first homogeneously catalyzed alkyne metathesis was achieved in 1974, by Mortreux and Blanchard. In a sealed flask, 4-methyland resorcin, resulting in the tolane (1)was heated in the presence of 10 mol% of MO(CO)~ formation of the metathesis products tolane (2) and 4,4'-dimethyltolane (3) [4]. After three hours the statistical equilibrium was reached. The mechanism of the molybdenum-catalyzed alkyne metathesis is still unknown. In 1981, Schrock et al. reported the capability of tungsten alkylidyne complexes to catalyze alkyne metathesis [ Sa]. With the complex 4, the equilibrium of 1, 2, and 3 was reached under milder reaction conditions and with shorter reaction times than had been obtained with the Mortreux catalyst. As early as 1975, Katz and McGinnis had proposed metallacyclobutadienes as intermediates of alkyne metathesis [ 61. In 1984, Schrock et al. were successful in obtaining a crystal structure of the catalytically active triaryloxytungstate complex 5, and thereby proved the earlier hypothesis [ Sb]. The geometry of the planar four-ring, with an approximately trigonal bipyramidal-coordinated tungsten, is shown in Scheme 2. It should be mentioned that the metathesis of terminal alkynes, unlike the analogous reaction of terminal alkenes, is inhibited, due to the formation of catalytically inactive, deprotonated tungsten cyclobutadiene complexes [ Sc]. Hence, alkyne metathesis liberating acetylene instead of 2-butyne has no use in synthesis.
Mortreux and Blanchard, 1974 10 mol-% [MO(CO)~]/ resorcin (1:6), 160'C, 3 h
2 or 4 - t ~ ~ 4 mol-% [ ( t ~ ~ ~ ) 3] ~ toluene, rt, 1 h Schrock et al., 1981 1
2
3
5
Pioneering experiments by Mortreux et al. (1974) and Schrock et al. (1981). Geometry o f the tungstacyclobutadiene 5 in the crystal (OAr = 0-2,6-diisopropyIphenyl; bond lengths in pm).
Scheme 2.
A major drawback of alkene metathesis is lack of control over the stereochemistry of the newly formed double bond. For unstrained systems, E/Z ratios are virtually unpredictable. Alkyne metathesis, on the other hand, can always be combined with subsequent Lindlar hydrogenation, thereby giving access to stereochemically pure Z-olefins. In 1998, Fiirstner and Seidel were the first to report a ring-closing alkyne metathesis [7]. Under high-dilution conditions (0.02 M) and reduced pressure (20 mbar, removal of 2-butyne, solvent 1,2,4trichlorobenzene (b.p. 214 "C)) the Schrock catalyst was applied to assemble macrocyclic
Alkyne Metathesis in Natural Product Synthesis
lactones, lactams, and cyclic silyl ethers. Soon, various olfactory macrolides, such as the mint-scented yuzu lactone (7) or the strongly musk-scented ambrettolide (9), became synthetic targets, pioneered by Furstner et al. Scheme 3 gives the syntheses, both starting with 9-undecyn-1-01,using the "instant" Mortreux catalyst for ring-closing alkyne metathesis of 6 and 8 under high-dilution conditions, and finishing with Lindlar hydrogenation. The sim(civetone) has been obtained in a similar ple macrocyclic musk (Z)-cycloheptadec-9-en-1-one manner [8]by use either of the Schrock catalyst or of the quite harsh Mortreux conditions (5 mol% Mo(CO)~,p-trifluoromethylphenol, chlorobenzene, 140 "C, 7 h), as optimized by Bunz et al. [9].
68 Yo
6
1. 5 mol% MO(CO)~, 1 eq. pchlorophenol chlorobenzene. 14O'C 2. HP, Lindlar cat.
-~
8
c: 7 : yuzu lactone
-
-
9: ambrettolide
Scheme 3. Simple examples of natural products synthesis by alkyne metathesis with the Mortreux catalyst.
The Mortreux and Schrock catalysts have a somewhat different scope. In particular, secondary amides and silyl ether groups are not compatible with the Mortreux conditions. The high temperatures (140-150 "C) are also not desirable for complex, multifunctional natural products. Scheme 4 gives the key steps of the syntheses of several nitrogen-containing macrocycles, of which motuporamine (13) from the marine sponge Xestospongia exigua [ 101, and epilachnene (16) and homoepilachnene (17), defense secretions of the pupae of the Mexican beetle Epilachnar uariuestis [ 111, are natural products [ 121. In all cases the amino functions had to be protected as carbamates (Boc or Fmoc) prior to alkyne metathesis. The secondary amide present in the metathesis product 18, however, did not have to be protected for use of the Schrock catalyst at 80 "C. In the key reaction of the eight-step synthesis of motuporamine C (13), the open-chain, Nprotected bisalkyne 10 was exposed to Mortreux and to Schrock conditions [13]. The yields (67% vs. 71%) of the macrocycle 11 were comparable, but the reaction temperature (140 "C vs. 80 "C) and the reaction times (30 h vs. 1 h) clearly favor the Schrock conditions. Epi-
30
I
Alkyne Metathesis in Natural Product Synthesis
5 rnol% MO(CO)~, 1 eq. pchlorophenol chlorobenzene, 140aC,30 h, 67 Yo or: 10 rnol% (‘BuO)~WCCM~~, chlorobenzene 80‘C, 1 h, 65 Yo
e F;J
Frnoc
10
-~
Z 3 steps
H2 Lindlar cat., quinoline
Frnoc
Frnoc 11
-
Q L
12
N H
w NH,
13: rnotuporarnine C
1 . Mortreux cond., 67 %
or: 1. Schrock cond., 71 % 14: n=l; 15: n=2
-~
*
-
G
H
16: epilachnene (n=l) 17: hornoepilachnene (n=2)
2. H2, Lindlar cat., 94 % 3. TBAF, H20, 62 %
- O Z s S :I: 0 : a\ 18
cry;H
19: nakadornarin A
1. ‘BuC(NH)CCI3, BF3.Et20, CH2CI2, rt, 8 h, 83 % 2. Schrock cond., 66 % 3. Hz, Pd/C, MeOH, rt, 12 h 4. Frnoc-OSu, dioxane, O‘C, 76 %
*
h N H 0 20 Scheme 4.
BocHN
I l F r n o c ‘BuO~C 21
Alkyne metathesis affording nitrogen-containing natural products or synthetic intermediates.
Alkyne Metathesis in Natural Product Synthesis
I
31
lachnene (16) and its homologue 17 were obtained by starting from the homologous precursors 14 and 15 ( 6 2 4 9 % macrocyclization yields) [12]. For the structurally more complex molecule 18, only the Schrock conditions worked. Compound 18 has been synthesized as a synthetic precursor of the marine alkaloid nakadomarin A (19 [14]) from the marine sponge Amphimedon sp. Nakadomarin A (19) belongs to the manzamine alkaloids, which are also targets of biomimetic syntheses [15]. For both strategies, there is still some distance to go. Diaminosuberic acid (21, protected form) is used as a dicarba isostere of cystine in peptides to provide stable analogues of disulfide bridges. Occasionally, the conformational flexibility of diaminosuberic acid is a disadvantage and conformationally restricted cystine isosteres are desired. Rutjes, van Boom, et al. report the application of alkyne metathesis to the synthesis of analogues containing Z-alkene or alkyne functionalities [ 161. Moreover, orthogonal protection is frequently needed. Scheme 4 gives the synthesis of N’-Boc-N-Fmocdiaminosuberic acid mono-tert-butyl ester (21) (see also [ 171) starting from the open-chain bisalkyne 20. The established tungsten catalyst 4 ( G mol%) in chlorobenzene was used, affording macrocyclization in 66% yield. Alkyne metathesis can also be employed to synthesize open-chain natural products through intermolecular reactions. Fiirstner and Dierkes reported the total synthesis of the natural product (S,S)-(+)-dehydrohomoancepsenolide (24) from the gorgonian Pterogorgia citrina, to which it contributes to chemical defense (Scheme 5) [18]. The synthesis features both alkene and alkyne metatheses. The butenolide unit 23 was assembled first, by alkene metathesis starting from the open-chain precursor 22, in the presence of Grubbs’ catalyst [ 191. Interestingly, competing enyne metathesis was not observed. Subsequent alkyne metathesis with the Schrock catalyst and Lindlar hydrogenation successfully provided 24 from 23.
16 mob% (PCy&ClzRu=CHPh,
c
CH2C12, A, 24 h, 70 % 22
1. l o mol-% [(‘Bu0)3W-‘Bu] toluene, 100 ‘C, 10 h, 75 %
23
.
2. H P , Lindlar cat., quinoline, hexane/EtOH, rt, 30 min, 96 YO
0
24: (S,S)-(+)-dehydrohomoancepsenolide Scheme 5. Combined application of alkene and alkyne metathesis, affording the open-chain natural product 24.
32
I
Alkyne Metathesis in Natural Product Synthesis
It is of key importance for the success of a synthetic method that it be compatible with the greatest possible variety of functional groups. The tungstacyclobutadiene 5, for example, is ring-opened by pyridine and looses its catalytic activity [20]. In 1999, Fiirstner et al. found a new molybdenum catalyst with wider scope (Scheme 6) [21]. Dissolution of the trisamidomolybdenum complex 25 12.21 in dichloromethane results in the endothermic formation of the chloride 26, The catalytic activity of 26 was demonstrated with the alkyne metathesis of the pyridine-2,3-dicarboxylatediester 27 in toluene, affording the macrocyclic alkyne 28 in the very good yield of 88%. The new catalyst 26 has several advantages, including the tolerance of basic nitrogen functional groups, thioethers, and polyether chains. The probable reason for this is the steric hindrance of the Lewis acidic molybdenum center. Complex 26 is not compatible with substrates containing acidic protons, such as secondary amides, which are tolerated by the Schrock system. Despite intensive studies, no X-ray structures of reactive intermediates composed of both molybdenum and alkyne components have so far been obtained, and the mechanism of catalysis is still unknown. Fiirstner et al. give a detailed account of their work on trisamidomolybdenum complexes of the general type [Mo(('Bu)(Ar)N}3]in ref. [23].
10 mol% of 26 toluene, 80'C
88 % 27 Scheme 6.
28 Furstner's new molybdenum catalyst 26.
There are already advanced applications of the new catalyst to the synthesis of natural products. Scheme 7 gives the metathesis steps towards, and the structures of, the target molecules prostaglandin Ez methyl ester (31), its lactone 33 from the nudibranch Trtetys Jimbria [24], and the structures of the glycolipid sophorolipid lactone (34) from the yeast Candida bombicola [25] and of the microtubule-stabilizing epothilone C (35)from the myxobacterium Sorangium cellulosum 1261. To obtain the open-chain prostaglandin Ez methyl ester (31), the symmetrical Cl0 alkyne 30 was employed as the source of the Cs unit to be introduced into the starting material 29 (Scheme 7). The yield of this less symmetrical alkyne metathesis was 51% [27]. The macro-
Alkyne Metathesis in Natural Product Synthesis
I
33
1. 10 mol% [MO(N(~BU)(A~)}~], CH2C12,toluene, 80'C, 51 % 2. Hz, Lindlar cat. quinoline, hexane, rt, 87 %
3. aq. HF, THF, rt, 1 h , 88 %
HO 31 : PGE2 methyl ester
Ar = 3,5-dimethylphenyl
1:
1. 7.5 mol% [Mo(N('Bu)(Ar)J3],
CH2C12,toluene, 80'C, 16 h, 70 % 2. HP,Lindlar cat. quinoline, hexane, rt, 2 h, 86 % 3. aq. HF, MeCN, rt, 1 h , 88 %
HO 33: PGE2 lactone
'*m 13
U 34: sophorolipid lactone Scheme 7.
35: epothilone C
The most complex natural products so far obtained by alkyne metathesis.
cyclization of the bisalkyne 32 to the analogous lactone 33 proceeded in the higher yield of 70% [28]. The molybdenum catalyst 26 is compatible with esters, ethers, silyl ethers, tertiary amides, thioethers, pyridines, and ketones. Sophorolipid lactone (34) was obtained from an open-chain bisalkyne precursor (concomitant formation of 2-butyne) in a macrocyclization yield of 78% [29]. The epothilones have been obtained through non-stereoselective alkene metathesis [ 2Gd], making them worthwhile targets for the combination alkyne metathesis/Lindlar hydrogenation to assemble the C12-Cl3 Z double bond. Furthermore, epothilone C (35) shows the most complex array of functional groups among the substrates of alkyne metathesis. The macrocyclization yield, starting from the expected OTBS-protected precursor (not shown) was 81% 123, 301. Neither
34
I
Alkyne Metathesis in Natural Product Synthesis
the basic nitrogen not the sulfur of the thiazole ring interfered with the catalyst. The labile aldol and the already present alkene double bond stayed intact. Only the OH group had to be protected, as a TBS ether. Epothilone C (35)can be epoxidized stereoselectivelyto epothilone A by dimethyldioxirane [ 311. In summary, alkyne metathesis seems about to become one of the key reactions frequently employed in the synthesis of increasingly complex natural products. Recently, Trost et al. and Furstner et al. reported new hydrosilylation protocols for the convenient, chemoselective transformation of alkynes to E alkenes which will extend the value of alkyne metathesis for natural product synthesis [32].
References A. FURSTNER, Angew. Chem. 2000, 112, 3140-3172; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2000, 39, 3012-3043; b) R. H. GRUBBS,S. CHANG,Tetrahedron 1998, 54, 4413-4450; c) M. SCHUSTER, S. BLECHERT, Angew. Chem. 1997, 109, 2124-2145; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1997. 36, 2037-2056.
1 Reviews o n alkene metathesis: a)
2 Examples o f enyne metathesis in natural products synthesis: a) S. C. SCHURER,
S. BLECHERT, Synlett 1999, 1879-1882; b) B. M. TROST,G. A. DOHERTY,J. Am. Chem. SOC. 2000, 122, 3801-3810; c) D. BANTI,M. NORTH,Tetrahedron Lett. 2002, 43, 1561-1564 d) J. S. CLARK,F.
3
4
5
6
ELUSTONDO, G. P. TREVITT,et al., Tetrahedron 2002, 58, 1973-1982. e) M. MORI,K. TONOGAKI, N. NISHIGUCHI, J. Org. Chem. 2002, 67, 224-226. a) U. H. F. BUNZ,ACC.Chem. Res. 2001, 34, 998-1010.17) U. H. F. BUNZ,L. KLOPPENBURG, Angew. Chem. 1999, 111, 503-505; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1999, 38, 478-481. A. MORTREUX, M. BLANCHARD, J . Chem. SOC.Chem. Commun. 1974, 786-787. a) J. H. WENGROVIUS, J. SANCHO,R. R. SCHROCK,].Am. Chem. SOC.1981, 103, 3932-3934; b) M. R. CHURCHILL, J. W. ZILLER,J. H. FREUDENBERGER, et al., Organometallics 1984. 3, 1554-1562; c) L. G . MCCULLOUGH, M. L. LISTERMANN, R. R. SCHROCK, et al., /. Am. Chem. SOC. 1983, 105, 6729-6730; d) Summary: R. R. SCHROCK,Polyhedron 1995, 14, 31773195. T. J. KATz, J. MCGINNIS,J.Am. Chem. SOC. 1975, 97, 1592-1594.
7 A. FURSTNER,G. SEIDEL,Angew. Chem.
8 9
10
11
12
13 14 15
16
17 18 19
20
1998, 110, 1758-1760; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1998, 37, 1734-1736. A. FURSTNER,G. SEIDEL, J . Organomet. Chem. 2000, 606,75-78. L. KLOPPENBURG, D. SONG,U. H. F. BUNZ,I. Am. Chem. SOC.1998, 120,79737974. D. E. WILLIAMS, P. LASSOTA,R. J. ANDERSEN,J. Org. Chem. 1998, 63,48384841. A. B. ATIYGALLE, K. D. MCCORMICK, C. L. BLANKESPOOR, et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1993, 90, 5204. A. FURSTNER, 0. GUTH,A. RUMBO,et al., / . A m . Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 11,10811,113. A. FURSTNER, A. RUMBO,J . Org. Chem. 2000, 65, 2608-2611. J. KOBAYASHI, D. WATANABE, N.KAWASAKI, et al., /. Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 9236-9239. a) J. E. BALDWIN, R. C. WHITEHEAD, Tetrahedron Lett. 1992, 33, 2059-2062; b) J. E. BALDWIN, T. D. W. CIARIDGE,A. J. CULSHAW, et al., Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 2806-2808; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1998, 37, 2661-2663. B. AGUILERA, L. B. WOLF,P. NIECZYPOR. et al., /. Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 35843589. R. M. WILLIAMS? J. LIU,J. Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 2130-2132. A. FURSTNER, T. DIERKES, Org. Lett. 2000, 2, 2463-2465. P. SCHWAB,R. H. GRUBBS,J. W. ZILLER,/. Am. Chem. SOC.1996, 118, 100-110. M. L. LISTERMANN, R. R. SCHROCK, Organometallics 1985, 4, 74-83.
References I 3 5 21
22 23
24 25 26
A. FURSTNER,C. MATHES, C. W. LEHMANN,].Am. Chem. Soc. 1999, 121, 9453-9454. C. C. CUMMINS, Chem. Commun. 1998, 1777-1 786. A. FURSTNER, C. MATHES, C. W. Chem. Eur.]. 2001, 7, 5299LEHMANN, 5317. G. CIMINO, A. SPINELLA, G. SODANO, Tetrahedron Lett. 1989, 30, 3589-3592. A. P. TULLOCH, A. HILL,J. F. T. SPENCER, Can.]. Chem. 1968, 46, 3337. (a) G . HOFLE,N. BEDORF, K. GERTH,et al. (GBF Braunschweig), Ger. Offen. DE 4138042 A1 19930527,1993 [ Chem. Abstr. 1994, 120, P526411; (b) D. M. BOLLAG, P. A. MCQUEENEY, J. ZHU, et al., Cancer Res. 1995, 55, 2325-2333; (c) G . HOFLE, N. BEDORF, H. STEINMETZ, et al., Angew. Chem. 1996, 108,1671-1673; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1996, 35, 1567-1569; (d) see also L. A. WESSJOHANN, G. SCHEIDin
Organic Synthesis Highlights Iy H.-G. (Ed.), Wiley-VCH, 2000, p. 251SCHMALZ 267. 27 A. FURSTNER, C. MATHES,Org. Lett. 2001, 3, 221-223. 28 a) A. FURSTNER, K. GRELA, Angew. Chem. 2000, 112, 1292-1294; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 2000, 39, 1234-1236; b) A. FURSTNER, K. GRELA, C. MATHES, et af., /. Am. Chem. SOC.2000, 122, 11,799-11,805. 29 A. FURSTNER, K. ~ D K O W S K J. I , GRABOWSKI, et al.,]. Org. Chem. 2000, GS, 8758-8762. 30 A. FURSTNER, C. MATHES,K. GRELA, Chem. Commun. 2001, 1057-1059. 31 D. MENG,P. BERTINATO,A. BALOG, et al.,j. Am. Chem. SOC.1997, 119, 10,073-10,092. 32 (a) B. M. TROST,2. T. BALL, T. JOGE, I. Am. Chem. SOC.2002, 124, 7922-7923; b) A. FURSTNER, K. RADKOWSKI,Chem. Commun. 2002, 2182-2183.
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
Transition Metal-catalyzed Functionalization o f Alkanes Oliver Seitz Introduction
Alkanes, which are the principal components of natural gas and crude oil, are still the preferred energy source of our society. In regard to the prime importance of alkanes as feedstock for the chemical industry, it appears a waste of resources “simply” to burn these precious raw materials. Unfortunately, attempts to transform alkanes into more valuable products are hampered by their low reactivity, as best illustrated by the use of alkanes as inert solvents. For example, the cracking process requires temperatures of about 1000 “C in order to convert long-chain alkanes into short-chain alkanes. Controlled conversion of hydrocarbons is difficult to achieve and limited to partial oxidations, such as the conversion of butane into acetic acid. It is obvious that processes that would enable efficient functionalization to occur at low temperature would have enormous potential application. Achievements towards this goal will almost certainly rely on the use of catalysts, which will have to activate the stable C-H bond (375-440 kJ mol-’) in order to induce its scission. C-H activation reactions can be induced by one-electron or two-electron transfer processes. Radical chain reactions, which operate in many alkane oxidations, belong to the first category (Scheme 1). In a “conventional” oxidation reaction, molecular oxygen effects the initiation and the propagation of the radical chain. Metals, transition metals in particular, are able to accelerate the cleavage of the formed hydroperoxides, thereby catalyzing the ratelimiting radical chain initiation. With a few exceptions, radical reactions of alkanes proceed relatively unselectively, but with tertiary C-H bonds being preferred [l].This is due to the high reactivity of radicals such as the hydroxyl radical and the differences in the C-H bond strengths (tea CH < sec CH < primary CH < CH3-H). In contrast, homogenous transition metal systems, which proceed by - for example - oxidative addition, show higher reactivity for primary C---Hbonds than for secondary and tertiary C-~Hbonds. The latter process is much more attractive when aiming for functionalization of linear alkanes. For this reason, this “account” focuses on transition metal-catalyzed two-electron processes. It is not intended to present a comprehensive overview, but to highlight some instructive examples for the generally interested reader, with a strong emphasis on newly developed catalysts. For a more detailed coverage the reader is referred to the review literature [ 2-51.
Alkane Functionalization with Homogenous Transition Metal Catalysts
I
37
One-electron transfer
Contribution of the metal: ROzH + M"
+
M"+'
+ RO- + OH.
Two-electron transfer M+RH
1
[M-RH]
2
Scheme 1.
-
A
0R
(%
M+RX+H2
H 3
4
C-H activation reactions proceed by transfer of one or two electrons
Alkane Functionalization with Homogenous Transition Metal Catalysts
To unlock its full potential, C-H activation has to be coupled with a functionalization event (e.g., 3-4). For instance, a hydride elimination occurring after the formation of metal complexes such as 3 furnishes olefins, versatile intermediates for further modification reactions. Transition metal-catalyzed atom- or atom group-transfer reactions that permit the introduction of oxygen-, carbon-, and boron-containing groups are also presented. The development of catalytic C-H activation reactions is one of the most challenging enterprises in organic chemistry. The only complexes able to activate C-H bonds by oxidative addition are coordinatively unsaturated at the metal center. The lifetimes of these highly reactive metal species, however, are usually very short. A key issue is therefore the development of stabilizing metal ligands. In addition, it is desirable that the ligands should confer a selectivity to the functionalization reaction, such that repeated functionalization can be prevented. Oxygenation
The most widespread efforts made towards the achievement of selective oxidation of alkanes are targeted on methane, a principal constituent of natural gas 16-81. Activation of the very stable C-H bond of methane is a particularly demanding problem. One example in which this has been achieved on industrial scales is the Degussa process "91. Methane is coupled to ammonia by heterogeneous catalysis in order to produce HCN, an important fundamental material for industrial chemistry. An unsolved problem is the selective oxidation of methane to methanol: a reaction that would convert the methane gas into a transportable liquid. In nature, monooxygenases have evolved. These are able to activate molecular oxygen and to
38
I
Transition Metal-catalyzed Functionalization of Alkanes
insert one oxygen atom into a C-H bond of an alkane. This process has inspired many efforts devoted to the development of biomimetic chemical model systems [ l o , 111. The most important catalysts for achieving selective hydroxylation of methane by two-electron transfer are based on the so-called Shilov system. Shilov and Shteinman reported a Pt(1v)mediated C-H activation as early as 1972 [12, 131. Typically, these reactions are performed under oxidative and highly acidic conditions, which results in the separation of a metal precipitate. This precipitation promotes the decomposition of the formed methanol and reduces the lifetime of the catalytically active species. Complexation with stabilizing ligands can substantially increase the lifetime of the catalyst. Periana and co-workers identified 2,2'bispyrimidine as a suitable ligand [14]. A solution of the bispyrimidine-Pt(I1) complex 5 in 20% oleum remained homogeneous even after 50 h at 200 "C, and no formation of insoluble platinum complexes such as (PtC12),or metal precipitates was observed (Scheme 2). The fact that metallic platinum dissolves upon treatment with a solution of bispyrimidine in 96% sulfuric acid is testimony to the remarkable affinity of the bispyrimidine ligand for platinum. It is this astonishing stability that renders the Pt(I1) complex functional under the drastic conditions of methane hydroxylation. At a temperature of 220 "C in concentrated sulfuric acid, complex 5 catalyzed more than 500 conversion cycles of methane to sulfuric acid methyl ester 6. The only liquid products detectable were sulfuric acid methyl ester 6 and methanol, which were formed in 73% yield and with 81% selectivity (based on methane). A mechanism similar to the Shilov process has been suggested [15]. According to this, acid treatment of the bispyrimidine-Pt(Ir) complex 5 results in the formation of the coordinatively unsaturated 14-electron complex 7. Subsequently, C-H activation proceeds by oxidative addition of methane to furnish complex 8. Periana and co-workers recognized the oxidation to the Pt(~ vcomplex ) 9 as the rate-limiting step. Finally, reductive elimination ejects methyl sulfate 6 and regenerates the active species 7. Recently, Sames and co-workers showed an interesting application, in which it was demonstrated that the Shilov chemistry permits heteroatom-directed functionalization of polyfunctional molecules [ 161. The amino acid valine (10) was allowed to react in an aqueous solution of the oxidation catalyst K2PtC14 and CU(11) chloride as stoichiometric oxidant (Scheme 3). At temperatures >130 "C a catalytic reaction was observed, and a regioselective C-H functionalization delivered the hydroxyvaline lactone 11 as a 3:l mixture of antilsyn isomers. It was noted that the hydroxylation of amino acid substrates occurred with a regioselectivity different from those for simple aliphatic amines and carboxylic acids. The authors therefore proposed that the amino acid functionalization proceeded through a chelate-directed C-H activation. Dehydrogenation
Specific dehydrogenation at the terminal positions of alkanes is a reaction that would be of high utility. The 1-alkenes obtained by such a reaction are the basis of a variety of additional products. Felkin and co-workers discovered that metal complexes are able to mediate the transfer of hydrogen from alkanes 13 to olefins 14 (Scheme 4) [ 171. The specific advantages of a transition metal catalyst can be applied to the benefit of the chemoselectivity of this reaction. In a kinetically controlled process, it is predominantly primary C-H bonds that add to the metal complex. A subsequent /?-hydride elimination affords the terminal alkenes
Alkane Functionalization with Homogenous Transition Metal Catalysts
I
39
5
CH4
+
2H2S04
+
CHBOSO~H
2H20
+
SO2
220’C,73%
6
+ X
N
X
ld
7
X = CI, HS04
-
\
HX
X
S o p + HpO
Scheme 2.
SO3 + 2 HX
Efficient Pt-catalyzed oxidation of methane
1 5 (R’ = R 2 = H). Successive isomerization reactions, which begin to dominate after a very short period of time, complicate the preparative usefulness of this reaction. A remarkable selectivity for the formation of cc-olefins has been reported by Jensen, Goldman, and co-workers [18].The iridium “pincer” complexes 20a and 20b were compared in the dehydrogenation of octane 17 (Scheme 5). When norbornene (Ma) was used as acceptor
40
I
Transition Metal-catalyzed Functionalization of Alkanes
5 mol% KpPtC14, 7 eq. CuCIp, 160’C, H20
1) BOQO 2) AcOH
NH2
NH-BOC
NH2
12
11
10
27 % (isolated yield)
56 % (crude in mixture with starting material) Scheme 3.
H
Pt-catalyzed oxidation o f amino acids.
R1#R3 R2 R4
13 Scheme 4.
metalcatalyst
R5
H
+ R6
Ra
-
14
H
R’
+ R2
R4
15
H
R5*R7 R6 Ra 16
Metal-catalyzed transfer (de) hydrogenation.
olefin, the highest cc-selectivities were obtained with the iPr complex 20a. After 5 minutes (12 turnovers) the 1-octene 21 had been formed with 91% selectivity. At prolonged reaction times and increased turnover the isomerization reaction began to dominate, and after 30 minutes (132 turnovers) 1-octene constituted only 30% of the product mixture. The use of a more reactive hydrogen acceptor such as 1-decene (18b) in combination with the sterically demanding tBu complex 201, enhanced the r-selectivity, particularly at prolonged reaction time. For instance, 1-octene was formed with 95% selectivity after 15 minutes (13 turnovers). After 90 minutes (111 turnovers) the product mixture still contained 84% of 1-octene and only 16% of the isomerization product 2-octene 22. The proposed mechanism involves a hydrogen transfer from the hydrido-iridium complex 20 to the alkene 18 as the first step. The formed complex 23 undergoes /3-hydride elimination. The coordinatively unsaturated iridium species 24 causes the oxidative oxidation of octane (24125). This C-H activation step is then followed by a reductive elimination, which gives rise to the formation of the dehydrogenation product 21. Recently, a new type of “pincer” complex has been introduced [19]. The “anthraphos” ligand confers a thermal stabilization on the iridium complex 26 (Figure 1). Hence, dehydrogenation reactions can be performed at temperatures (>200 “C) that would normally result in complete decomposition of the pincer complexes 20. Reluctant reactions, the kinetics and/or the thermodynamics of which require high temperatures, can therefore succeed. In spite of the remarkable improvement upon previously existing methodology, there is one disadvantage that remains. For the synthesis of an olefin, a second olefin has to be sacrificed. It is obvious that a process that would enable dehydrogenation to occur in the absence of sacrificial reagents would be highly desirable. Moreover, the selectivities that can be obtained at high turnovers are still too low for practical applications. Neither turnover frequencies nor turnover numbers of the catalysis are sufficient to be useful for industrial processes. These limitations are less of an issue in total synthesis, provided that the “quality” of the metal-mediated reaction justifies the use of stoichiometric processes.
Alkane Functionalization with Homogenous Transition Metal Catalysts
b
18a
catalyst 20a
5 rnin (TON = 12): 91% 21, 9% 22 30 min (TON = 132): 30% 21,67% 22
18b
catalyst 20b
15 min (TON = 13): >95% 21, 0% 22 90 min (TON = 1 11): 84% 21, 16% 22
mC8H1,
k
A
r( H
(PCP)lr,
23
H
mC6H13 CHz 17
- CH3
(PCP)lr 24
H
H
19
I Scheme 5.
A dehydrogenation with high a-selectivity (PCP = C G H ~ ( C H ~ P R ~ ) ~ ) .
I
41
42
I
Transition Metal-catalyzed Functionalization of Alkanes
H H Fig. 1.
A thermally stable pincer complex.
Such an example has been demonstrated by Johnson and Sames, who chose a platinummediated dehydrogenation as a key step in the synthesis of the antimitotic rhazinilam 33 (Scheme 6) [20]. The key intermediate 27 was converted into the imine 28, which was allowed to react with [ MezPt(,u-SMez)]z to afford the platinum complex 29. Subsequent treatment with triflic acid resulted in elimination of methane and furnished the cationic complex 30. Upon thermolysis in trifluoroethanol, the complex lost a second methane molecule, which resulted in the activation of the ethyl group. A subsequent P-hydride elimination gave the hydrido-Pt(I1) complex 31. Treatment with aqueous KCN followed by hydroxylamine removed the platinum and yielded the liberated amine 32. Johnson and Sames added a homologization and a macrolactamization and completed the total synthesis of rhazinilam (33) by removal of the carboxyl group.
c- C-Coupling Reactions that combine C-H activation with a C-C bond-forming event are invaluable synthetic tools, allowing concise construction of carbon frameworks. Rhodium( I ) catalysts have been shown to catalyze alkane carbonylation [ 211. Recently, Sakakura and co-workers succeeded in subjecting methane to a catalytic acetaldehyde synthesis [22]. They found that, in dense carbon dioxide, the complex [ RhC1(PMe3)3]catalyzed the carbonylation of methane with 77 turnovers. One problem that occurs when this class of catalysts is used is a concomitant dehydrogenation. To achieve a selective carbonylation, Murai and co-workers used substrates in which the metal complex was coordinated by a directing group, thereby placing the active metal center in close proximity to the C-H bond to be cleaved. This tactic was applied to the carbonylation of alkylamines (Scheme 7) [ 231. In the presence of ethylene, the rhodiumcyclooctadienyl complex 35 catalyzed the conversion of the pyrrolidines 34 into the saturated ketones 36. Different pyridine substituents were examined in terms of their suitability to support the rhodium-catalyzed carbonylation reaction. Electron-donating groups at the 5position (34, R = 5-Me) increased product formation. In the absence of the pyridine ring the reaction failed to take place. The introduction of electron-withdrawing (34, R = 5-CF3) or sterically demanding groups (34, R = 6-Me), reducing the basicity or accessibility of the pyridine nitrogen, gave decreased product yields. Murai and co-workers also explored the use of acyclic amines such as 36. Carbonylation to 37 and 38 proceeded, albeit in low yields. It is noteworthy that a preference for the sterically less demanding primary C-H bond (-37) as
Alkane Functionalization with Homogenous Transition Metal Catalysts
I
43
0
COOMe
27
phx 30
0
J
CF3CH20H, 70'C, 60h, 90%
& -
/
a) KCN, H20, 60% from 29 ~)%~OH,MeOH, ___)
/
phw N-Pt'H
II
NH2
\
/
32
31
33
Scheme 6.
@ -
fl 0
Pt-mediated dehydrogenation in the total synthesis of rhazinilam.
opposed to the energetically favored benzylic C-H bonds ( 1 3 8 ) was observed. Interestingly, the use of the ruthenium catalyst 39 allowed the introduction of ethyl groups [24]. Cyclic amines were more reactive than acyclic ones. For example, double alkylation occurred with the pyrrolidine 34, whereas monoalkylation was possible when the acyclic alkylamine 41 was
44
I
Transition Metal-catalyzed functionalization of Alkanes
d R=
R
34
H
36
40h
3-Me 60h
4-Me 60h
5-Me 40h
6-Me 60h
5-CF3 60h
68%
73%
73%
84%
12%
15%
Ph
CO, H2C=CHp
iPrOH, 160’C 36
37
18% (9:l)
34
Ph
41 Scheme 7.
38
40
Ph
42 (8%)
Ph
43 (20%)
Directed C-H activation for the carbonylation and alkylation of alkylamines.
Ph
44 (12%)
Alkane Functionalization with Homogenous Transition Metal Catalysts
employed as substrate. It is also interesting to note that the use of the ruthenium catalyst 39 changed the selectivity. The complex predominantly activated the benzylic C-H bond (+43) rather than the primary C-H bond ( 1 4 2 ) preferred when the C-H activation was catalyzed by the rhodium complex 35. At first glance, the requirement for the use of already functionalized alkanes seems to limit the applicability of the directed C-H activation approach. However, the utility of such a method is obvious for chemists familiar with the use of auxiliary groups during stereoselective synthesis (neighboring group participation was also applied in the total synthesis shown in Scheme 6). Borylation
The formation of carbon-boron bonds is one of the most versatile tools for the functionalization of hydrocarbons. The repertoire of functional group conversions in which organoboranes are transformed into alcohols, amines, ketones, alkenes, etc. is rich and characterized by broad applicability. Hartwig and co-workers recognized that the combination of a C-H activation with an alkane borylation can afford an exothermic process. Hence, the development of a catalytic alkane borylation seemed attainable. Hartwig's group first elaborated a photochemical means of alkane borylation [25]. Another impressive example of this hypothesis was also reported by Hartwig and co-workers, who described a thermal process for transition metal-catalyzed functionalization of alkanes [2G]. As an example, 5 mol% of the rhodium-bisethylene complex 46 catalyzed the reaction between n-octane (17) and the dioxaborolane 45 (Scheme 8). Complete conversion of the diborane 45 was achieved after 1 h at 150 "C. The n-octylborane 47 was formed in 84% yield after an additional 4 h reaction time. It has to be emphasized that both boron atoms of dioxoborolane 45 were transferred by the rhodium complex. Hartwig and co-workers showed that the pinacolborane 48 formed upon conversion of 45 is also a substrate and supports the catalytic octane borylation. The C-H activation was highly selective towards the primary position, GC-MS analysis attesting that n-octylborane was the only octylborane formed. Nevertheless, various ethylborane products were detected. Ethylborane formation seemed to be associated with a dissociation of ethylene ligands from rhodium complex 46a. Indeed, the use of the hexamethylbenzene complex 46b, which would dissociate by liberation of unreactive hexamethylbenzene, led to increased product yields. The driving force for this remarkably efficient alkane functionalization seems to be provided by the unusual thermodynamic properties of boron reagents. In the initial stage of the reaction, one octane C-H (412 kJ mol-') and one B-B bond (437 kJ mol-') are broken, while one B-C (470 kJ mol-') and one B-H bond (466kJ mol-') are formed. In total, an energy of 87 kJ mol-' is released. Analogously, conversion of the borane 48 gives rise to the formation of Hz (H-H bond: 437 kJ mol-') thereby releasing an overall bond energy of 29 kJ mol-'. This thermodynamic peculiarity enables C-H activation to occur even in absence of a catalyst. For instance, Knochel and co-workers showed that a thermal reaction can induce the activation of remote C-H bonds of acyclic tertiary alkylboranes to afford cyclic organoboranes [ 271. A theoretical study has suggested that even intermolecular C-H activation reactions such as direct methane borylation could succeed [28].
I
45
46
I
Transition Metal-catalyzed functionalization of Alkanes
46a =
46b =
Scheme 8.
* Rh
5 mol% Cat, 84% (5h); 1 mol% Cat, 64% (1 10h)
5 mol% Cat, 88% (25h); 1 mol% Cat, 72% (80h)
Thermal, catalyzed functionalization of alkanes t o organoboranes.
Conclusion
The first activation of an alkane C-H bond was described in 1969 [29]. Three decades were to pass until the development of the current catalytic procedures for dehydrogenation and G O , C-C, and C-B bond-forming reactions. Progress has been slow. Nevertheless, significant advances in catalyst research were achieved in the 1990s, aided by the development of improved metal ligands and the increased understanding of the mechanism of transition metal-catalyzed C-H activation reactions. Further improvements of catalytic cycles are nec-
Literature 1 4 7
essary, especially for the goal of application in economically useful industrial processes. As far as chemoselectivity is concerned, modern alkane functionalization reactions seem to suit the needs of laboratory practice, with the promise of a concise means of carbon framework synthesis. The examples presented here suggest that the goal of achieving both high catalytic efficiency and high chemoselectivity might be within reach. In particular, the thermally catalyzed alkane borylation indicates that C-H activation reactions present new opportunities and increase the repertoire of organic synthesis. It thus seems conceivable that alkanes will find a place not only as a source of energy but also as valuable building blocks in chemical synthesis. Literature
J. M. THOMAS,R. RAJA, G. SANKAR, et al., Acc. Chem. Res. 2001, 34, 191-200. 2 A. E. SHILOV, G. B. SHULPIN, Chem. Reti 1997, 97, 2879-2932. 3 G. DYKER, Angew. Chem. 1999, 111, 18081822; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1999, 38, 1699-1712. 4 C. G . JIA, T. KITAMURA,Y. FUTIWARA, ACC. Chew. Res. 2001, 34, 633-639. 5 R. H. CRABTREE,J. Chem. SOC.,Dalton Trans. 2001, 2437-2450. 6 R. H. CRABTREE, Chem. Rev. 1995, 95, 987-1007. 7 S. S. STAHL,J. A. LABINGER, J. E. BERCAW, Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 2298-2311; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998,37,2181-2192. 8 J. H. LUNSFORD,Catal. Today 2000, 63, 165-174. 9 For a mechanistic investigation: M. DIEFENBACH, M. BRONSTRUP, M. ASCHI,et al., J. Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 10,61410,625. 10 An overview of mechanistic aspects: A. E. SHILOV,A. A. SHTEINMAN, Acc. Chem. Res. 1999, 32, 763-771. I 1 For an overview of the scope of enzymatic alkane hydroxylation: H. L. HOLLAND, Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. 1999, 3, 22-27. 12 N. F. GOL’DSHLEGER, V. V. ES’KOVA,A. E. SHILOV, et al., Zh. Fiz. Khim. 1972, 46, 1353. 13 A. E. SHILOV, A. A. SHTEINMAN, Coord. Chem. Reu. 1977, 24, 97-143. 14 R. A. PERIANA, D. J. TAUBE,S. GAMBLE, et al., Science 1998, 280, 560-564. 15 M. W. HOLTCAMP, J. A. LABINGER,J. E. BERCAW,J . Am. Chem. SOC.1997, 119, 848-849. 1
16 17
18 19
20 21
22
23
24
25 26
27
28
29
B. D. DANGEL, J. A. JOHNSON, D. SAMES, J . Am. Chem. SOC.2001, 123, 8149-8150. D. BAUDRY,M. EPHRITIKINE, H. FELKIN, et al., J . Chem. SOC.,Chem. Commun. 1983, 788-789. F. C. LIU, E. B. PAK,B. SINGH,etal., J. Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121,4086-4087. M. W. HAENEL, S. OEVERS, K. ANGERMUND, et al., Angew. Chem. 2001, 113, 3708-3712; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2001, 40, 3596-3600. J. A. J O H N S O N , D. SAMES, J . Am. Chem. SOC. 2000, 122, 6321-6322. T. SAKAKURA, T. SODEYAMA, K. SASAKI,et al., J. Am. Chm. SOC.1990, 112, 72217229. J. C. CHOI,Y. KOBAYASHI,T. SAKAKURA, J. Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 5262-5263. N. CHATANI, T. ASAUMI,T. IKEDA, et al., J . Am. Chem. SOC.2000, 122, 12,88212,883. N. CHATANI,T. ASAUMI,S. YORIMITSU,et al., J. Am. Chem. SOC.2001, 123, 10,93510,941. K. M. WALTZ,J. F. HARTWIG,Science 1997, 277, 211-213. H. Y. C H E N ,S. SCHLECHT, T. C. SEMPLE, et al., Science 2000, 287, 1995-1997. H. LAAZIRI, L. 0. BROMM, F. LHERMIITE, et al., J . Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 69406941. B. GOLDFUSS, P. KNOCHEL, L. 0. BROMM, et al., Angew. Chem. 2000, 112, 4299-4302; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2000, 39, 41364139. N. F. GOL’DSHLEGER, M. B. TYABIN, A. E. SHILOV, et al., Zh. Fiz. Khim. 1969, 43, 2174.
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
An Eldorado for Homogeneous Catalysis? Gerald Dyker
Gold has always been the embodiment of something extremely valuable and evidently holds a fascination deeply rooted in the cultural history of mankind. As is generally known, the endeavour to produce gold synthetically played a significant role in the development of chemistry over a long period [2]. Concerning the search for catalysts gold has until recently lived in the shadows, which perhaps has its reason in the preconceived opinion that gold is expensive and inert. Indeed, gold is the most precious metal and was considered for a long time to be extremely chemically inert particularly in reactions with nonmetals such as hydrogen, carbon, and oxygen [3]. Through successes in heterogeneous catalysis, which are also of economic significance, this assessment has fundamentally changed [4a]: tetrachloroauric acid on active charcoal is currently the best catalyst for the hydrochlorination of ethyne, and gold clusters (diameter 2-5 nm) on iron oxide are particularly active for the oxidation of carbon monoxide [4b]. Other possible applications in environmentally relevant fields are the oxidative decomposition of halogenated hydrocarbons and the reduction of nitrogen monoxide with carbon monoxide and hydrogen to give nitrogen, carbon dioxide, and water [4c, 4d, 51. Surprisingly, gold can also catalyze skeletal rearrangements of hydrocarbons: for instance, the isomerization of 2,2-dimethylbutane to n-hexane has been achieved by Schmid with the aid of Auss clusters on titanium dioxide [4c, 61 and the aromatization of the dispirocycle 1 to tetrahydronaphthalene 2 was achieved by de Meijere et al. in a reactor with gold surface at 100 "C in a few seconds (Scheme 1) [ 7 ] .
Au-surface helium 100 O C . 10 s 1 Scheme 1.
2 (> 90%) Gold-catalyzed skeletal rearrangement of a strained hydrocarbon.
An Eldorado for Homogeneous Catalysis?
In the field of homogeneous catalysis only a few gold-catalyzed processes are known to date, which, however, are characterized by the need for extremely small amounts of gold salts. In view of the high catalytic activity of gold salts the higher price for gold is relativized in comparison to that for the corresponding palladium and ruthenium compounds. Recent developments in gold chloride catalyzed C-C and C-0 coupling reactions provide a fitting opportunity to highlight the current status [8] of homogeneous catalysis with gold salts and to show the potential for further developments. A first landmark in gold catalysis was made by Ito and Hayashi when they carried out an asymmetric aldol reaction in 1986 [9]: aldehydes 3 were treated with isocyanoacetate 4 to give oxazolines 5 (Scheme 2). The active catalyst is a ferrocenylphosphane-gold(I) complex (structure G sketches the complex with coordinatively bound reactants). In general, nearly quantitative yields and diastereo- and enantioselectivities of greater than 90% in favor of the 4S,SR-configurated trans-product 5 are achieved in this reaction. For instance, this method facilitates a two-step synthesis of the naturally occurring amino acid threo-3-hydroxylysine from 4-phthalimidylbutanal as the aldehyde component 3 [ 9d].
. cat. 6
R-CHO
(1 mol-%)
+
CHZC12 25 O C , 20 h
yo C
O v N
5
4
3
r
Me Me Me. Ph?
1
/
6 Scheme 2.
Synthesis o f oxazolines by a gold-catalyzed asymmetric aldol reaction.
Also in the activation of alkynes for nucleophilic attack, gold salts prove to be soft, exceptionally carbophilic Lewis acids, as confirmed by the examples shown in Scheme 3 [lo]. According to Utimoto and Fukuda both the addition of water as well as of amines to alkynes are catalyzed by gold(111) salts, in particular by sodium tetrachloroaurate; ketones such as 8 and imines such as the ant toxin 10 are obtained as products in excellent yields [loa-el. In the cyclization reaction giving the 1,4-dioxane 12 developed by Teles et al.,
I
49
50
I
An Eldoradofor Homogeneous Catalysis?
Au"'-cat. (2 mol-%)
MeOHiHzO reflux, 1 h
7
8 (929'0)
Ill
Au -cat.
(5 mol-%,)
MeCN
reflux, I h
10 (900/)
H', Au'-cat. (0.001 mol-%)
cfL
MeOjt,,
McOH
Me
55 O C , 20 h
\ L 13 Scheme 3.
12 (93%)
-3T.r Au 111-cat. ( 5 mol-%)
MeN02, H N 0 3 , N a N 0 2 , 50 'C
Gold-catalyzed additions t o alkynes; Ac
'0
14 (35%) =
acetyl.
the short reaction time and use of extremely small amounts of catalyst, in this case methyl(triphenylphosphane)gold(I), are particularly impressive [ 1Od-el. In the isoxazole synthesis according to Gasparrini et al., gold salts catalyze the addition of H N 0 3 to alkynes; under the oxidative reaction conditions nitrile oxides are formed, which undergo a cycloaddition to give final products such as 14 [ 1Of 1. In the gold-catalyzed carbonylation of olefins according to Xu et al., gold(I) carbonyl complexes are considered as active catalysts; this reaction proceeds already at room temperature in concentrated sulfuric acid at a CO pressure of 1 atm and leads after acid-catalyzedskeletal rearrangement to tertiary carboxylic acids such as 16, 18, and 19 (Scheme 4) [ll]. In a more recent publication Hashmi et al. reported that propargyl ketones such as 20 and allenyl ketones such as 21 can be cyclized to furans such as 22 in reactions catalyzed by gold(II1) chloride (Scheme 5) [12]. This type of reaction had already been described as a
An Eldorado for Homogeneous Catalysis?
I
51
Ab.03 (10 mol%) H2S04, 1 atm CO A,2h 15
16 (56%)
AU203 (10 mol%) H2SO4, 1 atm CO A.2h
18 (53%)
17 Scheme 4.
19 (25%)
Cold-catalyzed carbonylation of alkenes.
silver(I)-catalyzed process by Marshall et al. (typical reaction conditions: 20% catalyst and a reaction time of several hours) [13]; obviously. gold salts are the significantly more active catalysts, which is confirmed by the fact that quantitative yields are obtained after a few minutes at room temperature using only 1 mol% of the catalyst.
'0
20
or
AuC13 (1 mol-%) MeCN
E t q E t
20 T
22 (quant.)
Et 0
21
-
R
AuC13 (1 mol-%)
MeCN 2 0 OC R = CHZ-~-(TBDMSO)C~H~
23 Scheme 5.
R
24 (42%)
New gold-catalyzed C-C and C - 0 coupling reactions; TBDMS = tea-butyldimethylsilyl.
52
I
An Eldorado for Homogeneous Catalysis?
Of particular interest is the observation that in certain cases products such as 24 resulting from domino processes are obtained: After the formation of the furan, evidently a double Michael-type addition of these intermediates to the remaining starting material 23 can take place at the unsubstituted 5-position. Preliminary experiments to investigate scope and limitations of such addition reactions in the presence of gold salts also confirm the applicability to the functionalization of other electron-rich arenes (Scheme 6 ) : Besides furans, azulene 28 and di- and trialkoxybenzene are suitable as nucleophiles for the reaction with unsaturated carbonyl compounds [ 141. For instance, 2-methylfuran (25) reacts at the reactive 5-position with methyl vinyl ketone 26 to give the addition product 27, and with azulene 28 a twofold
20 OC, 40 min 25
26
27 (91%)
aAuC13 (1 mol-%)
+ 26 (3 equiv.)
\ \
MeCN, 20 OC 28
29 (49%)
Pd"-cat.
PhCOgBu 25
31 (67%)
30
Pd"-cat.
~
p C 0 2 E t
(1 mol-%)
OCH3 32
H 33
CF3C02H 25 'C, 45 h
OCH3 34 (78%)
Gold and palladium-catalyzed Michael-type additions o f electron-rich arenes to *,,&unsaturated carbonyl compounds.
Scheme 6.
An Eldorado for Homogeneous Catalysis?
alkylation occurs to give 29. In contrast to the catalysis of these reactions with hydrochloric acid and other protic and Lewis acids [15], gold(II1) chloride in acetonitrile guarantees sufficiently mild reaction conditions; the otherwise typical decomposition and polymerization reactions, particularly in the case of furans, are suppressed. On the basis of the results obtained so far, the acidic hydrate of gold(II1) chloride or tetrachloroauric acid works as a protic catalyst [14]. It is important to note that similar products are obtained from palladium-catalyzed reactions, but presumably through a different mechanism. In this case the reaction sequence clearly starts with an electrophilic metalation of the electron-rich arene, followed by intermolecular carbornetalation of the olefinic coupling component, a reaction sequence that by far is a domain of palladium and ruthenium catalysis [16, 171. As shown by the coupling reaction of 2-methylfuran (25) with the acrylate 30 developed by Tsuji and Nagashima [18], owing to the pronounced tendency of alkylpalladium intermediates for /I-H elimination the unsaturated product 31 is obtained; the generally associated reduction of the active palladium(11) catalyst necessitates the addition of an oxidizing agent such as a peroxy acid ester. Very recently Fujiwara et al. [ 191 reported that correponding coupling reactions with alkynes such as 33 in trifluoroacetic acid as solvent proceed already at room temperature with reaction times of several hours. Whether gold salts can also directly metalate electron-rich arenes under C-H activation in analogy to palladium and ruthenium catalysts will require detailed reactivity studies.
35
36 (95%)
Ar
AuCI~ (3 mol-%)
37
+
CH3CN
80 OC, 1 h
AAr
r
W
Ar
Ar
Ar = 4-anisyl 39 (43%)
38 Scheme 7.
Additional examples of protic catalysis provided by gold(ll1) chloride.
I
53
54
I
An Eldorado for Homogeneous Catalysis?
However, the ability of gold(111) chloride to provide protic catalysis under exceptionally mild conditions is further demonstated by two recent examples: the hydroxyallene 35 bearing a silyl protecting group is efficiently cyclyzed to give the 2,s-dihydrofuran 36 without deprotection [20]; other acidic catalysts which in principle sufficiently promote this type of cyclization - such as HCI gas or Amberlyst 15 resin - are of course much less compatible with acid sensitive functionalities. Also for the formation of macrocycle 39 gold(111) chloride turned out to be the catalyst of choice [21]. A new chapter for gold catalysis was opened up by Hashmi et al. when they found a highly selective gold catalyzed arene synthesis [ 221: the efficient formation of the annulated phenol 41 from furan 40 with a terminal alkyne in the side chain is certainly not a simple intramolecular cycloaddition reaction followed by rearomatization, since the oxygen atom obviously migrates during the transformation. According to a recent mechanistic suggestion even gold carbene complexes have to be taken into account as reactive intermediates [ 231. Clearly, it has been shown that gold salts display considerable catalytic activity under moderate conditions and gold catalysis will likely provide for some more surprises. Thus, an extensive development of gold catalysis with numerous new applications is anticipated.
AuC13 (2 mol%)
"3C
/
~
CH3CN 20 OC
40
H3C
OH 41 (94%)
Scheme 8.
References 1
2
An appeal to catalyst research from Faust 11: Man grefe nun nach.. . . Gold, dem Greijeenden ist meist Fortuna hold. a) 0. K R ~ T Z ,7000Jahre Chemie, Nikol Verlagsgesellschaft, Hamburg 1999; b) H. SCHMIDBAUR, Natunv. Rdsch. 1995, 48, 443-451; c) A. GROHMANN, H. SCHMIDBAUR, Organogold Chemistry in: Comprehensive Organometallic Chemistry rr, E. w. ABEL,F. G. A. STONE; G. WILKINSON (Edts.), Pergamon Press Ltd., Oxford, UK, 1994, 1-56; d) H. SCHMIDBAUR, Gold: Organometallic Chemistry in: Encyclopedia of Inorganic Chemistry, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., Chichester, 1994, 1226-1234; e) H. SCHMIDBAUR, Chem. SOC.Rev. 1995, 24, 391-401; f ) H. SCHMIDBAUR (Ed.), Gold -
Progress in Chemistry, Biochemistry and Technology, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1999. 3 L. JAENICKE, Chemie in unserer Zeit 1995. 29, 272-273. 4 a) J. SCHWANK, Gold Bulletin 1985, 18, 210; b) D. THOMPSON, Gold Bulletin 1998, 31, 111-118; c) D. THOMPSON, Gold Bulletin 1999, 32, 12-19; d) G. C. BOND, D. THOMPSON, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 1999, 41, 319-388. 5 a) T. AIDA,R. HIGUCHI, H. NIIYAMA, Chem. Lett. 1990, 2247-2250; b) T. M. SALAMA, T. SHIDO,R. OHNISHI,M. ICHIKAWA, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. 1994, 2749-2750. 6 G. SCHMID,Progress in the Science and Technology of Gold, Hanau, June 1996, see Gold Bulletin 1996, 29, 105.
References I 5 5
7 L.-U. MEYER, A. D E MEIJERE,Tetrahedron
Lett. 1976, 497-500. 8 For some special gold( I)-catalyzed processes, see: a) boration of vinylarenes: R. T. BAKER; P. NGUYEN, T. B. MARDER, S. A. WESTCOTT, Angew. Chem. 1995, 107, 1451-1452; Angav. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34, 1336-1338; b) dehydrogenative dimerization of trialkyltin compounds: H. ITO, T. YAJIMA, J. TATEIWA, A. HOSOMI,Tetrahedron Lett. 1999, 40, 78077810. 9 a) Y. ITO, M. SAWAMURA, T. HAYASHI,]. Am. Chem. SOC. 1986, 108, 6405-6406; b) T. HAYASHI, M. SAWAMURA, Y. ITO, Tetrahedron 1992, 48, 1999-2012; c) A. TOGNI,S. D. PASTOR, J . Org. Chem. 1990, 55, 1649-1664; d) P. F. HUGHES,S. H. SMITH,J. T. OLSON, J. Org. Chem. 1994, 59, 5799-5802. 10 a) Y. FUKUDA, K. UTIMOTO, J. Org. Chem. 1991, 56, 3729-3713; b) Y. FUKUDA, K. UTIMOTO,Bull. Chem. SOC.Jpn. 1991, 64, 2013-2015; c) Y. FUKUDA, K. UTIMOTO, Synthesis 1991, 975-978; d) J. H. TELES,S. BRODE,M. CHABANAS, Angav. Chem. 1998, 110, 1475-1478; Angew. Chem. lnt. Ed. Engl. 1998; 37, 1415-1418; e) J. H. TELES, M. SCHULZ(BASF AG), WO 97/21648 (CA 127:121499u); f ) F. GASPARRINI, M. GIOVANNOLI, D. MISITI,G. NATILE,G. PALMIERI, L. MARESCA,J. Org. Chem. 1993, 115,4401-4402. 11 Q. Xu, Y. IMAMURA, M. FUJIWARA, Y. SOUMA, J. Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 15941598. 12 A. S. K. HASHMI,L. SCHWARZ; J.-H. CHOI, T. M. FROST,Angew. Chem. 2000, 112, 2382-2385; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 2000, 39, 2285-2288.
J. A. MARSHALL, G. S. BARTLEY, J. Org. Chem. 1994, 59, 7169-7171. 14 A. S. K. HASHMI,G. DYKER, E. MUTH, unpublished results. 15 a) K. ALDER, C.-H. SCHMIDT,Chem. Ber. 1943, 76, 183-205; b) M. CATTALINI, S. Cossu, F. FABRIS,0. DE LUCCHI, Synth. Commun. 1996, 26, 637-647; c) M. YAMAGUCHI,M. SHIROTA, T. WATANABE, Heterocycles 1990, 31, 1699-1704; d) C. ROGERS,B. A. KEAY, Can.J. Chem. 1993, 71, 611-622. 16 G. DYKER, Angav. Chem. 1999, 111, 18081822; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1999, 38, 1698-1 7 12. 17 The addition of carbonyl-functionalized arenes to electron-rich alkenes and alkenes is achieved under ruthenium catalysis (Murai reaction): S. MURAI,F. KAKIUCHI, S. SEKINE,Y. TANAKA, A. KAMATANI, M. SONODA, N. CHATANI,Nature 1993, 366, 529-531. 18 J . TSKJJI, H . NAGASHIMA, Tetrahedron 1984, 40, 2699-2702. 19 C . J I A , D.PIAO,J. OYAMADA, W. Lu, T. KITAMURA, Y. FUJIWARA, Science 2000, 287, 1992-1995. 20 A. HOFFMANN-RODER, N. KRAUSE,Organic Lett. 2001, 3, 2537-2538. 21 G. DYKER, J. LIKJ,unpublished results. 22 a) A. S. K. HASHMI,T. M. FROST,J. W. BATS,]. Am. Chem. SOC.2000, 122, 1155311554; b) A. S. K. HASHMI,T. M. FROST, J. W. BATS,Org. Letters 2001, 3, 3769-3771; c) A. S. K. HASHMI,T. M. FROST,J. W. BATS, Catalysis Today 2002, 72, 19-27. 23 B. MARTIN-MATUTE, D. J. CARDENAS, A. M. ECHAVARREN, Angew. Chem. 2001, 113, 4890-4893; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 2001, 40,4754-4757.
13
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
New and Selective Transition Metal Catalyzed Reactions of Allenes A. Stephen K. Hashmi
Among the most popular organic substrates for transition metal catalyzed reactions are alkenes A and alkynes B. Allenes C have received much less attention. This is easily explained by increasing selectivity problems when we proceed from A to C. While in A we face the question of regioselectivity (Markovnikov versus anti-Markovnikov orientation leading to constitutional isomers, Scheme 1)and stereoselectivity of an addition reaction (cis- or trans-addition at possibly enantiotopic or diastereotopic faces of the double-bond leading to stereoisomers), in B we have to cope with the problem of chemoselectivity (single or double addition leading to different products) and for each addition the regio- and stereoselectivity problems apply as discussed for A. In C the situation is even more complicated: as with the alkynes chemo-, regio- and stereoselectivity are significant, but furthermore we face the question of positional selectivity (which of the two orthogonal double bonds will react in the case of a single addition, thus again leading to constitutional isomers).
R’
dR2 R’ = R2
regioselectivity
regioselectivity
regioselectivity
regioselectivity
stereoselectivity
stereoselectivity
stereoselectivity
stereoselectivity
chemoselectivity
chemoselectivity positional selectivity
A Scheme 1.
B
C
Selectivity problems in different types of unsaturated substrates A-C.
In early investigation of the reactions of allenes with transition metals, the conversions proceeded quite unselectively due to the enhanced reactiuity of the allenes [ 11. This observation led to the neglect of allenes as substrates in such reactions for a long time. In the past
Cyclopropyl Allenes
decade allenes have reemerged as interesting compounds for scientist working in the field of transition metal catalysis. Three major principles were used to overcome the selectivity problem: (1) In intermolecular reactions, the positional selectivity was often controlled by steric hindrance, that is, by substituents on only one of the double-bonds. (2) Intramolecularization of the reactions, usually by placing the reacting groups in such a distance that five- or six-membered rings are formed, automatically solved the positional selectivity problem. (3) Allenes bearing functional groups on the carbon atom next to the allene allowed to control the selectivity by both geometrical restrictions and electronic differentiation of the two cumulated double bonds of the allene, not only in intramolecular but also in intermolecular reactions. While approach ( 1) has allowed some very interesting transformations and numerous mechanistic details could be investigated [ 21, the substituents used to provide steric hindrance also limited the synthetic potential. Principle (2) seems to have a higher potential for organic synthesis [ 31. Principle (3), in paticular, seems to provide some interesting and truly new transformations, which shall be summarized here. The following section is organized along the different types of substrates that all belong to principle (3). If nothing else is mentioned, the reactions proceed with 0.5-5 mol% of catalyst. Vinyl Allenes
As mentioned in the introduction [Ic], no selectivity was observed in early dimerization experiments of 1. But when other partners were offered, the corresponding crossdimerizations were quite selective. Probably methylene metallacyclopentenes 2 [4], which could be isolated, are intermediates that then react with the other partners. Generally, the related 1,3-dienes are less reactive than 1 with its reactive allenic double-bond and do not react in a similar manner [4a]. Rh-catalyzed [4+1] cycloadditions with CO as a second reaction partner led to alkylidene cyclopentenones 3 and 4 [4, 51, while in Pd-catalyzed reactions where 1 was generated in situ and a base was present, only 4 [GI was formed. When Pt(0) was used instead of Rh(I) in the carbonylation reaction, both in the presence of the (R,R)DuPHOS-ligand, opposite enantiomers of 3 were obtained [ Sb]. This observation still needs a precise explanation. [ Fe(CO)5]-mediated reactions of diallenes form dialkylidene cyclopentenones 7 (Scheme 2, here 10 mol-% of catalyst are needed) [7]. Other partners like alkynes in Rh- or 1,3-dienes in Pd-catalyzed reaction led to arenes 5 [8] or vinyl alkylidene cyclohexenes 6 [9]. Since these [4+2] cycloadditions take place between two electronically quite similar partners, a direct Diels-Alder reaction is not feasible. With a certain substitution pattern even [4+4+1] cycloadditions that deliver ninemembered rings 8 [ 101 could be achieved (Scheme 3). With Rh' the very same substrate delivers 3. Cyclopropyl Allenes
Substrates 9 can be regarded as homoolefinic derivatives of 1. Here also the analogous vinyl cyclopropanes don't react similarly to 9, the allenic unit makes 9 more reactive [ll].In Ir'catalyzed reactions with CO the sixmembered analoges of 3, the cyclohexenones 11 [ll], were formed in a [ 5+1] cycloaddition (Scheme 4).
I
57
58
I
New and Selective Transition Metal Catalyzed Reactions of Allenes
R3
R'
R
R3
M"Lm
1
R4
-
y
i
M"+~L,,, R4
2
M"orPto = Rh'
co
Z 68-99%
+ HC=CR5
R3@Ri
* R4
R3
64-82%
3
R3xR R4
4
R'
4
8596%
5 (regioselective! for R4 = H) 15-94%
Scheme 2.
Reactions of vinyl allenes 1.
-@ R
2
R q o 4
Pdo
co R R = Ph, CH=CHZ Scheme 3.
61-8770
Formation of nine-membered rings from vinyl allenes and CO
On the other hand, Rh' in the absence of CO leads to 12 [12] formed via a vinyl cyclopropane/cyclopentene rearrangement. Such a rearrangement without a catalyst would require temperatures between 300 and 400 "C! Again one suspects metallacycles 10 as intermediates that either insert CO or undergo a reductive elimination immediately. With [ CozCOe] 1-hydroxycyclopropyl allenes 13 can be transformed into hydroquinones 14 and the corresponding diacetates 15, respectively, under mild conditions [ 131. This methodology can be used in the synthesis of vitamine E and K analogues (Scheme 5).
Allenes with Neighbouring OH- or NH-groups
I
59
co
9 10
I Scheme 4.
11 28~83% M" = Rhl
Reactions of cyclopropyl allenes 9.
R'
14
13
15 51-90% over two steps
Scheme 5.
Formation of dihydroquinones from cyclopropyl allenes 13
Allenes with Neighbouring OH- or NH-groups
The addition of hydroxy groups to the distal double bond of the allene, mediated by Hg" or Ag' and leading to dihydrofurans, has been known for quite a while [14]. Quite recently Krause et al. could show that Au"' is also able to catalyze such a reaction with complete axis to center chirality transfer, even with substrates that possess additional alcohol groups or silyl ethers therefore were notoriously difficult [ 151. Marshall et al. very successfully applied this principle to the synthesis of natural products and extended it to allenyl carboxylic acids like 16 [16], which can lead to lactones like 17 (Scheme 6).
HOAO
16 (-)-Kallolide B 68%
Scheme 6.
Silver-catalyzed lactonization i n Marshall's synthesis of (-)-Kallolide B (17)
60
I
New and Selective Transition Metal Catalyzed Reactions of Allenes
Further targets were analogues of pseudopteranes [ 171 and of (-)-deoxypukalide [ 181. comparable lactones 19 can be synthesized from allenyl alcohols 18 by a rutheniumcatalyzed carbonylative cyclization [ 191 and an extension of this procedure to the synthesis of lactames 21 has also been reported [ 20). In these examples with one more carbon atom between the allene and the OH or NH group, the corresponding sixmembered compounds could be obtained. With substrates 22 additional C-C bonds can be formed in Pd-catalyzed reactions with aryl halides as reaction partners (Scheme 7) [ 211. With enantiomerically pure bis(oxazoline) ligands ee-values up to 53% could be observed in such reactions [22].
RU3(CO)I2
p,4>**R2
R'
OH
R5
NEt,, dioxane 10 atm. CO,100°C
18
R4 R5
19
RU3(CO)12
R1<*=
NEt,, dioxane 20 atm. CO,100°C
NHR~
20 Scheme 7.
Carbonylative cyclization o f hydroxymethyl allenes 18 and aminomethyl allenes 20.
In the case of Pd-catalyzed reactions of aryl halides with allenyl carbinols 24, enones 27 [23] were obtained (Scheme 8). R
+
Ar-X
OH
22 Scheme 8.
X=Br, I
K2C03
59-79%
23
Combination o f C-C-bond formation and lactonization.
Interestingly, in DMF as solvent and with C032-, for 24 a cyclization leading to the corresponding vinyl epoxides 26 [24] could be achieved! Simple treatment of 24 with Ag' delivers 25. The silver(1)-catalystsshow significant lower reactivity, thus usually 20 mol% or even more are applied. Similar developments were possible for the amines 28, which either formed dihydropyrroles 29 or vinyl aziridines 30 (Scheme 8) [ 251. Here also the reaction heavily depends on the solvent, but no explanation has been provided so far. On the other hand, in the presence of a Pd-catalyst and CO, tertiary amines 31, which cannot form another C-N bond, gave a-vinyl acrylamides 32 (Scheme 9) [26].
Allenes with Neighbouring OH- or NH-groups
I
61
24
25 T R
l PPhl d oor Ph,l+BF;
i
h
l
DMF/CO:-
'
R-S
R d p h
0 27 (HZ-mixtures)
::-65?!0
54~88%
I
1
Mts
28 29
50%
!Zxane
a
30 [cis:trans = 82:18)
,ph
77-83%
1
Mts
Reactions of allenyl carbinols 24 and related amines 28. Mts = 2,4,6-trimethylbenzenesulfonyl.
Scheme 9.
R' R
p
R2
N-R3
R
R3'
Pdo
* R2
'
1 mol% pTsOH
31
At?:
co
R'
R~ R'
32 59-84 Yo
Scheme 10.
Formation of vinylacrylamides 32. p-TsOH = para-toluenesulphonic acid
An alkylative version of the dihydrofuran-synthesis, leading to 35, was developed by Ma et al. [27]. Recently Trost et al. reported that in vanadium-catalyzed additions of allenic alcohols 36 and aldehydes 37 aldol-type products 38 can be obtained in an atom economic manner [28]. Backvall et al. utilized a stereoconvergent palladium-catalyzed S N ~ reaction ' of cc-allenic acetates 39 for the synthesis of (Z,E)-2-bromo-l,3-dienes40 [29]. With different allenylcarbinols 41 a nickel-catalyzedliving polymerization was possible, but no regioselectivity of the C-C bond formation was observed (40% reaction of the @-double bond, 60% reaction at the P-double bond in 42) [ 301.
62
I
wR4
New and Selective Transition Metal Catalyzed Reactions of Allenes
+
R2>*=
R'
" c , R4 r
PdCI,
R2
DMA rt
R'
P
OH
33
34
35 57-86%
Scheme 11. Alkylative cyclization o f hydroxymethyl allenes 33.
R
+
Ph--(F*& OH
VO(OSiPh,),
LRI
-
CH2CI2, rt
36 Scheme 12.
0
37
0
OH
Ph+R' R 6O-88% usually syn preferred
38
Aldol-like products 38 from hydroxymethyl allenes 36.
R2
Pd(0AC)p R'-(=*&
R
'
b
OAc
39 Scheme 13.
2.5 eqs LiBr AcOH/acetone, 40°C
v
R Br
2
40 77-94%, de 86-99%
(E,Z)-Configurated 2-bromo-l,3-dienes 40 from 39.
1.. N!
WCF3 PPh3
/=*=
R
41 R = CH20H, CHMeOH, CMe,OH
Scheme 14.
42
M, = 9.6.103 M,/M,=1.13
Polymerization of hydroxymethyl allenes 41.
Allenyl Ketones
Here also a diversity of reactions was developed. With y,y-disubstituted derivatives 43 and [ Fe(C0)5] (again 10 mol-%), the lactones 44 were formed (Scheme 10) [ 311. Rh' or Ag' cause the cycloisomerization of 45 to the corresponding furan 46 [32]. Again this principle was used in the synthesis of natural products like the enantiomer of the furanocembrane rubifolide [ 331. Even greater is the diversity of substrates 47. Pd" leads to the formation of dimer 48 [ 341, Au"' to a constitutional isomer of 48, the dimer 50.When the latter reaction was performed in the presence of Michael acceptors, the addition products 49 were formed [35]. Finally, in the case of alkoxy-substituted allenyl benzyl ketones 51, the spirocycles 52 are obtained (Scheme 11) [ 361.
Allenyl Carboxylic Esters and Related Substrates R’
43
44 54-89%
45
46 72-99%
21-91Yo
50 24-51% 49 46-7470 Scheme 15.
Transition metal-catalyzed reactions o f allenyl ketones 43, 45 and 47
RO
Q
a=
+
ROH
0
51
80~84%
Scheme 16.
Hg(ll)-catalyzed formation o f spiro[4,5]decanes 52 from p-alkoxy allenyl ketones 51.
Allenyl Carboxylic Esters and Related Substrates
In Nickel(0)-catalyzed reactions these substrates 53 selectively delivered the head-to-head [ 2+2] dimers 54 [ 371.
2
=* dEWG 10 mol% Ni(PPh,), 53
toluene
EWG = COpR, CONRp, SOpPh, COR Scheme 17.
[2+2] Cycloaddition o f 53.
f EWG
54 33-81Yo
I
63
64
I
New and Selective Transition Metal Catalyzed Reactions of Allenes
Transition Metal Catalysis for the Synthesis o f Allenes with Neighboring Functional Groups
The last chapters might have led to the conclusion that transition metals will always react with allenes bearing functional groups in the direct neighborhood. But this is not automatically the case, such substrates can often be prepared by transition metal catalysis without reacting to another product in situ. For example, the copper catalyzed addition of Grignard compounds to alkynyl substituted p-lactones 55 delivers p-allenic acids 56 in high yields [ 381, During these reactions, the central chirality of one of the stereogenic centers of the p-lactone is transferred to the axial chirality of the allene. R3-MgBr
C02H
* 10 mol% CuBr or CuCN.2 LiBr " THF, -78°C
55
56 79-94?0 '
Copper-mediated ring-opening of 55.
Scheme 18.
Amino allenes of type 58 can be prepared by palladium-catalyzed reduction 57 [ 391.
N PG
Br 2 eqs EtJn THF, rt
57
80 - 90%
PG = MTS or Boc Palladium-catalyzed reduction o f amino allenes 58. Mts = 2,4,6-trimethylbenzenesulfonyl.
Scheme 19.
Ma et al. demonstrated that the palladium-catalyzed coupling of vinyl halides GO and allenyl/propargyl metal species 59 can deliver vinyl allenes 61 [40]. R'
Ph
+JR1
Ph+(
59
M
M
R' Pd(O)
b
R2?Od
R4
4-
R2
60 Scheme 20.
R3
xR4
x
X=Br, I
R3
61
5 - 77%
Vinyl allenes 61 by palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling.
2-Bromo-l,3-butadienes 62 can be coupled with nucleophiles to deliver allenylcarbinols and the related amines and phosphanes 63 [41]. In some cases even chloroprene can be used [421.
Conclusion I 6 5
T:
M-NU
R
62
-
[rr-allylPdCI],
R3 Nu
THF
63
M-NU= NaOPh, KN(Boc),, LiPPh,
Scheme 21.
Palladium-catalyzed allylic substitution at 62.
Palladium catalysts rearrange chiral 2-alkynyl sulfinates 64 into chiral allenyl sulfones 65
WI.
65
(Ss,S)-64 Scheme 22.
39-89% 60-89% ee
Palladium-catalyzed isornerization of 64.
The iron-catalyzed reaction of propargyl sulfides 66 and trimethylsilyldiazomethane 67 delivers allenyl cc-silyl sulfides 68 [44].
DCE, 83°C
66 Scheme 23.
67
d’ 68 48-90%
Iron-catalyzed synthesis o f 68.
The Latest Highlight: Selective Reactions between Two Allenes
As mentioned in the introduction, the reactivity of the allenes is high. Therefore the oxidative and cyclizative cross dimerization of two different allenic substrates just recently reported by Ma et al. can be considered to be a milestone in this field! They discovered that one equivalent of 2,3-dienoic acids 69 and five equivalents of allenyl ketones 70 with the simple PdC12(MeCN)2catalyst can deliver up to 92% of the cross dimerization product 71
PSI. Conclusion
The recent investigation in many groups made selective and synthetically interesting transformations of allenes available, one important motive for this achievement is the presence
66
I
New and Selective Transition Metal Catalyzed Reactions ofAllenes
.=
69
R.<
PdCI,(MeCN),
+ MeCN, rt * ''-H*"
R*
R'
+{ HO
ko
R4
0
70
71
61-92°/o
Scheme 24. Cyclizative cross-dimerization of two different allenic substrates 69 and 70
on fuctional groups in the direct proximity of the allene. Still, often the unique chemoselectivity still lacks explanation. A deeper mechanistic understanding of these selectivities might be the key for future developments of even more exciting and synthetically fruitful reactions. References a) B. L. SHAW,A. J. STRINGER, Inorg. Chem. Acta Rev. 1973, 7, 1-10; b) F. L. BOWDEN,R. GILES,Coord. Chem. Rev. 1976, 20, 81-106; for further efforts, see: c) H . SIEGEL,H. HOPF,A. GERMER,P. BINGER,Chem. Ber. 1978, 111, 3112-3118; d) G. ERKER,Methoden Org. Chem. (Houben-Weyl)4th ed, 1952-, Vol. E18, 1986, pp. 870-873 and 882-883. 2 For selected examples and additional references, see: L. BESSON,I. G o R ~B. , CAZES,Tetrahedron Lett. 1995, 36, 3853H . ALPER, 3856; W.-J. XIAO,G. VASAPOLLO, J . Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 2609-2612; R. C. LAROCK, Y. H E , W. W. LEONG,X. HAN, M. D. REFVIK,J. M. Z E N N E RJ,. Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 2154-2160; T. SUDO,N. ASAO,V. GEVORGYAN, Y. YAMAMOTO, J . Org. Chem. 1999; 64, 2494-2499; S. KACKER, A. S E N ,J. Am. Chem. SOC.1997, 119, 10028-10033; B. M. TROST,A. B. PINKERTON, J . Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 10842-10843; D. HIDEURA,H. URABE,F. SATO,J . Chem. SOC.,Chem. Commun. 1998, 271-272. 3 For selected examples and additional references, see: V. M. ARREDONDO, S. TIAN,F. E. MCDONALD, T. J. MARKS,J . Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 3633-3639; R. D. WALKUP,G. PARK,J . Am. Chem. SOC. 1990, 112, 1597-1603; R. GRIGG,J.M. SANSANO, Tetrahedron 1996, 52, 1344113454; C. JONASSON, J.-E. BACKVALL, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 3601-3604; 1
4
5
6
7 8
9
D. N. A. Fox, D. LATHBURY, M. F. MAHON, K. C. MOLLOY,G. GALLAGHER, J . Am. Chem. SOC.1991, 113, 2652-2656; M. LAUTENS,C. MEYER, A. V A N OEVEREN, Tetrahedron Lett. 1997, 38, 3833-3836; J. S. PRASAD,L. S. LIEBESKIND, Tetrahedron Lett. 1988, 29, 4253-4256; F. P. J. T. RUTJES,K. C. M. F. T J E N ,L. B. WOLF,W. F. J. KARSTENS, H. E. SCHOEMAKER, H. HIEMSTRA,Org. Lett. 1999, 1, 717-720; K. M. BRUMMOND, J. Lu,J. Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121, 50875088; for an example of a diastereoselec, FUJI, tive reaction, see: P. A. W E N D E RM. C. 0. HUSFELD, J. A. LOVE,Org. Lett. 1999, 1, 137-139. a) M. MURAKAMI, K. ITAMI,Y. ITO, Angew. Chem. 1995, 107, 2943-2946; Angew. Chem Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34, 2691; b) M. MURAKAMI, K. ITAMI,Y. ITO,]. Am. Chem. SOC.1996, 118, 11672-11673. a) M. MURAKAMI, K. ITAMI,Y. ITO,J . Am. Chem. SOC.1993, 115, 5865-5866. b) M. MURAKAMI, K. ITAMI,Y. ITO,J . Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121,4130-4135. T. MANDAI,J. TSUJI,Y. TSUJIGUCHI, S. SAITO,J. Am. Chem. SOC.1993, 115, 58655866. M. S. SIGMAN,B. E. EATON,J . Am. Chem. SOC.1996, 118, 11783-11788. M. MURAKAMI, M. UBUKATA,K. ITAMI,Y. ITO, Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 2362-2364. M. MURAKAMI, K. ITAMI,Y. ITO, J . Am. Chem. SOC.1997, 119, 7163-7164.
References I 6 7 10 M. MURAKAMI, K. ITAMI,Y. ITO, Angav.
Chem. 1998, 110, 3616-3619; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 3418-3420. 11 M. MURAKAMI, K. ITAMI,M. UBUKATA,I. TSUJI,Y. ITO,J. Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 4-5. 12 M. HAYASHI, T. OHMATSU,Y.-P. MENG,K. SAIGO,Angav. Chem. 1998, 110, 877-879. 13 Y. OWADA,T. MATSUO,N. IWASAWA, Tetrahedron 1997, 53, 11069-11086. 14 L.-I. OLSSON, A. CLAESSON, Synthesis 1979, 743-745. 15 A. HOFFMANN-RODER, N. KRAUSE,Org. Lett. 2001, 3, 2537-2538. 16 J. A. MARSHALL, K. G. PINNEY,J. Org. Chem. 1993, 58, 7180-7184; J. A. G. S. BARTLEY, E. M. WALLACE, MARSHALL, J. Org. Chem. 1996, Gl, 5729-5735. 17 J. A. MARSHALL, L. M. MCNULTY, D. Zou, J. Org. Chem. 1999, 64, 5193-5200. 18 j. A. MARSHALL, E. A. VAN D E V E N D E R , ~ . Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 8037-8041. 19 E. YONEDA,T. KANEKO,S.-W. ZHANG,K. ONITSUKA,S. TAKAHASHI,Org. Lett. 2000, 2,441-443. 20 S.-K. KANG, K.-J. KIM, C.-M. Yu, J.-W. HWANG,Y.-K. Do, Org. Lett. 2001, 3, 2851-2853. 21 S. MA, Z. S H I ,J. Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 6387-6389. 22 S. MA, Z. SHI, S. W u , Tetrahedron: Asymmetry 2001, 12, 193-195. 23 I. SHIMIZU,T. SUGIURA, J. TsurI, J. Org. Chem. 1985, 50, 537-539. 24 S.-K. KANG,T. YAMAGUCHI, S:J. PYUN, Y.-T. LEE,T.-G. BAIK,Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 2127-2130; S. MA, S. ZHAO,J. Am. Chem. Sac. 1999, 121, 7943-7944. 25 H. OHNO,M. ANZAI,A. TODA,s. O H I S H I , N. FUJII,T. TANAKA, Y. TAKEMOTO, T. IBUKA,]. Org. Chem. 2001, 66,4904-4914. H. OHNO,A. TODA,Y. MIWA,T. TAGA,E. N. FUJII,T. IBUKA,]. OSAWA,Y. YAMAOKA, Org. Chem. 1999, 64, 2992-2993; See also A. CLAESSON, C. SAHLBERG, K. LUTHMAN, Acta Chem. Scand. B 1979, 33, 309-310. 26 Y. IMADA,G . VASAPOLLO, H . ALPER,J. Org. Chem. 1996, 61, 7982-7983. 27 S. MA, W. GAO, Tetrahedron Lett. 2001, 41, 8933-8936. 28 B. M. TROST,C. JONASSON, M. WUCHRER, J. Am. Chern. Soc. 2001, 123, 1273612737. 29 A. H O R V ~ T H j.-E. , BACKVALL, J. Org. Chem. 2001, 66,8120-8126. 30 M. TAGUCHI,I. TOMITA,T. ENDO,Angav.
Chem. 2000, 112, 3813-3815; Angau. Chem. Int. Ed. 2000, 39, 3667-3669. 31 M. S. SIGMAN,C. E. KERR,B. E. EATON,]. Am. Chem. Soc. 1993, 115, 7545-7546; M. S. SIGMAN,B. E. EATON,J. D. HEISE, C. P. KUBIAK,Organometallics 1996, 15, 2829-2832; For the analogous allenyl imines, see: M. S. SIGMAN,B. E. EATON,J. Org. Chem. 1994, 59, 7488-7491. 32 J. A. MARSHALL, E. D. ROBINSON, J. Org. Chem. 1990, 55, 3450-3451; J. A. X. WANG,J. Org. Chem. 1991, MARSHALL, 56, 960; j. A. MARSHALL, X. WANG,J. Org. Chem. 1992, 57, 3387; J. A. MARSHALL, G . S. BARTLEY, J. Org. Chem. 1994, 59, E. M. WALLACE, 7169-7171; j. A. MARSHALL, P. S. COAN,J. Org. Chem. 1995, GO, 796; J. A. MARSHALL, C. A. SEHON,J.Org. Chem. 1995, 60, 5966; J. A. MARSHALL, j. LIAO,J. Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 5962. 33 j. A. MARSHALL, C. A. SEHON,]. Org. Chem. 1997, 62,4313-4320. 34 A. S. K. HASHMI,Angew. Chem. 1995, 107, 1749-1751; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34, 1581-1583; A. S. K. HASHMI, T. L. RUPPERT,T. KNOFEL,J. W. BATS,J. Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 7295-7304. 35 A. S. K. HASHMI,L. SCHWARZ,j.-H. CHOI, T. M. FROST,Angew. Chem. 2000, 112, 2382-2385; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 2000, 39, 2285-2288. 36 A. S. K. HASHMI,L. SCHWARZ, M. BOLTE, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 8969-8972. 37 S. SAITO,K. HIRAYAMA, C . KABUTO,Y. YAMAMOTO, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2000, 122, 10776-10780. 38 Z. WAN, S. G. NELSON,J.Am. Chem. SOL. 2000, 122, 10470-10471. 39 H . O H N O ,A. TODA,S. OISHI,T. TANAKA, Y. TAKEMOTO, N. FUJII, T. IBUKA,Tetrahedron Lett. 2000, 41, 5131-5134. 40 S.-M. MA, A,-B. ZHANG,Pure Appl. Chem. 2001, 73, 337-341. 41 M. OGASAWARA, H . IKEDA,T. HAYASHI, Angew. Chem. 2000, 112, 1084-1086; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2000,39,1042-1044. 42 M. OGASAWARA, H. IKEDA,T. NAGANO,T. HAYASHI,Org. Lett. 2001, 3, 2615-2617. 43 K. HIROI, F. KATO,Tetrahedron 2001, 57, 1543-1550. 44 R. PRABHARASUTH, D. L. VANVRANKEN,]. Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 5256-5258. 45 S. MA, Z. Yu, Angew. Chem. 2002, 114, 1853-1856; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2002, 41, 177551778,
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
I
Controlling Stereoselectivity with the Aid o f a Reagent-Dir e dng Croup Bernhard Breit
Introduction
Substrate control can be a useful tool to allow for high levels of selectivity in organic reactions. This is particularly valid for reactions in which the reacting substrate is equipped with a functionality suitable to allow for a precoordination of the reagent followed by an intramolecular reagent delivery. This type of reactions, named according to Evans et al. as substrate directable reactions, is of great synthetic value as proven in numerous total syntheses [ 11. However, known substrate directable reactions rely on the nature of the coordinating functionality present in a particular substrate. This clearly defines limitations to the set of reagents potentially directable by a specific functional group. A way to overcome such an intrinsic limitation may provide a specifically introduced reagent-directing group into an organic substrate (see Scheme 1).
Reagent Directing Group via precoordination
Concept of a specifically introduced reagent-directing group into an organic substrate as a selectivity control instrument.
Scheme 1.
Such a specifically introduced functionality should have the ability to precoordinate the desired reagent which would result in an intramolecular pathway for the desired chemical reaction with a corresponding reactive functional group within the substrate. By choosing the appropriate point of attachment of the directing functionality, as well as by choosing the appropriate geometry of this group, one should have complete control of the trajectory of a particular reagent, which of course should be the ideal basis to control any type of selectivity for a given chemical reaction.
Discussion I 6 9
Such an approach necessitates two additional synthetic operations: introduction as well as removal of the reagent-directing group. However, such a disadvantage at first sight should be acceptable if one could solve a selectivity problem for a synthetically valuable reaction which is otherwise not susceptible to stereocontrol. In this context transition metal catalyzed addition reactions have gained importance as a consequence of their intrinsic atom economy and efficiency which may be beneficial for enviromental and economic grounds [ 21. An example is the rhodium catalyzed hydroformylation reaction, which is an industrially important homogenous catalytic process [ 3 ] . In contrast, it is amazing that such an important transition-metal catalyzed CjC bond-forming process has been employed only rarely in organic synthesis [4]. Part of the reason stems from the difficulty in controlling stereoselectivity. Even though some recently developed chiral rhodium catalysts allow for enantio- and diastereoselective hydroformylation of certain specific classes of alkenes [ 5, 61, only little is known about the diastereoselective hydroformylation of acyclic olefins [ 7, 81. Discussion
The difficulty of this task became obvious in an attempt to achieve a diastereoselective hydroformylation of a simple methallylic alcohol system. It was expected that in analogy to the known substrate-directed rhodium-catalyzed hydrogenation reaction, substrate direction via the hydroxyl substituent would control diastereoselectivity in the course of the hydroformylation reaction [91. However, a completely stereorandom hydroformylation product formation was observed (1+3) [lo, 111.
1
2
3 syn : anti 50 : 50
Reagents and conditions (a) 0.35 mol% [Rh(CO)~acac], 7 mol% PPh,, 20 bar H 2 / C 0 (l:l),toluene, 90 "C, 6-24 h (83-95%); (b) PCC on A1203, CH2C12, 25 "C, 16 h (95%).
Scheme 2.
In contrast to the rhodium-catalyzed hydrogenation reactions, the hydroxyl group does not operate as an efficient catalyst-directing group in the rhodium catalyzed hydroformylation. This may be primarilly due to the carbon monoxide, itself an excellent ligand for rhodium(I), which is present in large excess under hydroformylation conditions. Hence, the hydroformylation reaction is an ideal first-test case for the concept of a specifically introduced catalyst-directing functionality with respect to its potential to control diastereoselectivity in the course of the hydroformylation reaction. Therefore, a specific catalyst-directing group needed to be designed, which itself had to (a) function as a good ligand for rhodium under hydroformylation conditions, (b) provide reversible coordination of the catalytically active rhodium
70
I
Controlling Stereoselectivity with the Aid ofa Reagent-Directing Group
species to allow for turnover, (c) enable facile introduction into the substrate as well as removal from the product and (d) allow for a highly ordered cyclic transition state for the stereochemistry defining step of the hydroformylation reaction.
(c-DPPBA) 4
Scheme 3. Design o f a catalyst-directing group for the control of diastereoselectivity upon hydroformylation of acyclic methallylic alcohols.
As an ideal catalyst-directing group for that particular problem the ortho-diphenylphosphino benzoate system (0-DPPB) was introduced [lo]. With the aid of the o-DPPB functionality a substrate-directed diastereoselective hydroformylation of methallylic alcohol derivatives could be achieved with high levels of acyclic stereocontrol to provide the syn-aldehydes6 as the major diastereomers [ 101.
5
syn-6
up to
96
anti-6 4
Scheme 4. o-DPPB-directed stereoselective hydroformylation o f methallylic alcohol derivates. Reagents and conditions (a) 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)zacac], 2.8 mol% [P(OPh)3], 20 bar Hz/CO ( l : l ) , toluene, 90 "C, 24 h (63-99%).
Support for the role of the o-DPPB substituent as a catalyst-directing group was provided in a control experiment with the benzoate 7. Thus, exchanging the phosphorus of the oDPPB group with a CH moiety, itself not able to coordinate to the catalytically active rhodium center, caused a complete loss of stereoselectivity in the hydroformylation reaction [lo].
Discussion
F X P . 2
P
h
Rh-Cat. H&O
q
0 p X P h 2
P
h
h
0 2 X P ~ 2
+
Ph% CH3 0
CH3 0
CH3
TOF [h-'1 X = P:
5a
21
syn-6a
92
:
a
anti-6a
X=CH:
7
1.4
syn-8
50
:
50
anti-8
Reagents and conditions (a) 0.7 mol% (Rh(CO)lacac], 2.8 mol% [P(OPh),], 20 bar H?/CO ( l : l ) , toluene (0.1 M), 90 "C, 2 h Scheme 5.
The o-DPPB-directedhydroformylation of methallylic alcohol derivatives could be applied for the construction of stereotriads - central building blocks of the polyketide class of natural products. Thus, starting from the methallylic o-DPPB esters 9, 11 the anti-syn and all-syn stereotriad building blocks 10 and 12 could be obtained in good yields and diastereoselectivities [ 121.
+
OTr
O(o-DPPB)
Rh-Cat. H$CO (a)
+
OTr
*
O(o-DPPB)
anti-syn
CH3 CH3 0
CH3 CH3
dr b 96 : 4 9
OPiv O(eDPPB)
YY
CH3 CH3
* 10
Rh-Cat. H$CO (b)
OPiv O(eDPPB) t
all-syn
CH3 CH3 0
dr 95 : 5
11
12
Scheme 6. Reagents and conditions (a) 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)zacac], 2.8 mol% [P(OPh),], 20 bar H 2 / C 0 ( l : l ) , toluene, 90 "C, 24 h (91%), (b) same as (a) (70%).
Interestingly, the same concept involving a catalyst-directing group allowed also to make efficient use of 1,3 asymmetric induction. This, of course, is a much more difficult situation, since additional degrees of freedom have to be controlled in the course of the stereo-
I
71
72
I
Controlling Stereoselectivity with the Aid ofa Reagent-Directing Group
chemistry defining step of the hydroformylation reaction. However, homomethallylic oDPPB esters 13 were reacted to give the anti-aldehydes 14 as the major diastereomer in selectivities of ca. 91:s) [13]. Rh-Cat.
13
anti-14
syn-14
o-DPPB-directed stereoselective hydroformylation of homomethallylic alcohol derivates. Reagents and conditions (a) 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)~acac],2.8 mol% [P(OPh),], 20 bar H2/CO ( l : l ) , toluene, 3O-5O0C, 24 h (72-90%).
Scheme 7.
In these cases, the interplay of a preferred substrate conformation as well as catalyst delivery via the catalyst-directing group form the basis for the diastereoselectivity observed ~31. Removal of the Reagent Directing Group
After successful hydroformylation one may decide to remove the catalyst-directing o-DPPB group, which may be achieved by simple alkaline hydrolysis (syn-Gaisyn-3) [lo] or via hydride reduction after transferring the aldehyde e.g. to an alkene via Wittig olefination (syn-6b+syn-23) [14]. OH
0
syn-2
syn-3 (92 : 8)
4
0
(*)-syn-sa (92 : 8)
O(eDPPB)
O(eDPPB) i-Pr
CH3 0
(+)-sy1~6b (96 : 4)
CH3
syn-15 (96 : 4)
Reagents and conditions (a) KOH, T H F / M e O H / H 2 0 (2:2:1), 50 "C,2.5 h (99%); (b) 2 equiv. PCC on A1203,25 "C, 16 h (95%); (c) Ph3P = CH2, THF, -78"+0 "C (89%); (d) LiAIH4, ether, 0 "C (95%). Scheme 8.
CH3
syn-16 (96 : 4)
Multiple Use of One Reagent-Directing Croup: Towards a RDC-Controlled Organic Synthesis
I
73
Multiple Use of One Reagent-Directing Group: Towards a RDC-Controlled Organic Synthesis
To increase the efficiency of a specifically introduced directing functionality one should make use of that functionality as often as possible to control selectivity in further skeletonconstructing processes (see Scheme 9). In an ideal scenario each reaction would generate the functionality required for a subsequent transformation. Hence, at the end an organic synthesis could be the result in which one reagent-directing group (RDG) would control the selectivity of each single reaction step.
8-9 Reagenta
R
reaction i
@ Scheme 9.
R-A
Reagentb
Reagent c
____)
reaction ii
R-A-B
reaction iii
8
R-A-B-C
Reagent-Directing Group: Controls selectivity of reaction i-iii
R
Organic Substrate
A
Via reaction 1 and reagent a introduced modification
Multiple use of a reagent-directing group - towards an RDC-controlled organic synthesis.
Towards this goal, the potential of the o-DPPB group to control diastereoselectivity in a carbon carbon bond forming reaction, following the hydroformylation step was explored [15]. Enoates 17, were chosen as the test substrates since the stereoselective 1,4-addition of a methyl would provide a structural building block found in biologically important natural products of the polyketide class (e.g. antitumor agent dictyostatin 1 and the ionophore calcimycin).
conjugate addition
Scheme 10. Working hypothesis for the o-DPPB group t o act as an organometallic reagent directing group for the conjugate addition of Cilman cuprates t o acyclic enoates.
The enoates 17 were obtained in good yield and diastereoselectivity by subjecting the crude hydroformylation products 6 to Horner-Wadsworth-Emmons olefination conditions (HWE). Reaction of enoates 17 with dialkyl Gilman cuprates gave the anti 1,4-addition
74
I
Controlling Stereoselectivity with the Aid ofa Reagent-Directing Group
product 18 in good yield as the major diastereomer (dr 2 95:s with respect to the newly formed stereogenic center) [ 151. Rh-Cat. H&O
O(o-DPPB)
O(o-DPPB)
HWEolefination
(b)
(a)
R?
R +
CH3 5
*
CH3 0 6
17
18 dr 595:5
dr294:6 E:Z > 95:5 Sequential use o f t h e reagent directing o-DPPB group t o control stereoselectivity in the course o f hydroformylation and subsequent conjugate addition with organocuprates. Reagents and conditions (a) 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)zacac], 2.8 Scheme 11.
mol% [P(OPh)j], 20 bar H2/CO ( l : l ) ,toluene, 90 "C;(b) (EtO)z(O)PCH2CO,Et, n-BuLi, DME, 20 "C (71-83% both steps); (c) 1.5 equiv. R'ZCuLi, ether, -78"+0 "C (61-93%).
Thus, combining o-DPPB-directed hydroformylation with the o-DPPB-directed cuprate addition afforded building blocks with up to four stereogenic centers (19-21). (?(o-DPPB)
OPiv O(o-DPPB) *OE' CH3 CH3 CH3 0 19
20
dr 8 5 : 15
dr 95 : 5
/--7
O(o-DPPB)
'UN
I 2o
-i-Pr
CH3 CH3 CH3 0 21 dr 95 : 5
lonophore A-23187 (Calcimycin)
Interestingly 1,4-addition product 21 is equipped with the same relative and absolute configuration of the four stereogenic centers found in the ionophore calcimycin.
o-DPPB-directed Hydroformylation as Part of Sequential Transformations
I
75
o-DPPB-directed Hydroformylation as Part o f Sequential Transformations
One may improve efficiency of an o-DPPB directed hydroformylation by incorporating this reaction into sequential transformations (domino reactions) [ 161. The hydroformylation itself should be ideally suited for such a purpose, since this reaction provides under fairly mild reaction conditions access to the synthetically valuable aldehyde functionality. The aldehyde itself should be ideally suited to allow for further skeleton-constructing reactions. One type of sequential transformations employing the hydroformylation reaction as a key step is the hydroaminomethylation of olefins originally discovered by Reppe [ 171. However, efficient control of diastereoselectivity in the course of this hydroaminomethylation reaction was unknown [18, 191. Employing the same concept and catalyst-directing o-DPPB group enabled the development of a substrate-directed diastereoselective hydroaminomethylation of acyclic methallylic alcohol derivatives 5 to give in diastereoselectivities of greater 94% the corresponding amines 22 [20]. This process allows, in one step, the formation of a C~-Cbond, a C-heteroatom bond, introduction of the ubiquitous amine functionality, and, additionally, generates a new stereogenic center with high levels of acyclic stereocontrol. The mechanism of this sequential transformation involves presumably three steps. First o-DPPB directed stereoselective hydroformylation of the methallylic o-DPPB esters 5 provides the aldehyde 6 . Enamine formation ( 1 2 3 ) with the secondary amine present and subsequent rhodium catalyzed hydrogenation finishes the sequence of reactions, and affords the saturated amines 22.
+
O(eDPPB)
Q(eDPPB)
HNR'z Rh-cat; CO/Hp t
CH3
syn/anti> 94 : 6 22
5
I
enamine hydrogenation
hydroformylation
I
'
6
2
3
Scheme 12. o-DPPB-directed hydroaminomethylation with secondary arnines. Reagents and conditions: 1.5 Equiv. HNR'?, 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)?acac], 2.8 mol% [P(OPh)3], 20-80 bar H 2 / C 0 ( l : l ) , toluene, 90"-120 "C (40-65%).
In addition to secondary amines, primary amines could be employed furnishing the corresponding secondary amine derivatives as the final products in equally high diastereoselectivity.
76
I
Controlling Stereoselectivity with the Aid ofa Reagent-Directing Group HzNR'
Rh-cat; CO/H2D
O(c-DPPB) R+NHR 1
CH3 syn/anfi 2 94 : 6 24
5
I
imine
hydroformylation
2
6
5
Scheme 13. o-DPPB-directed hydroaminomethylation with primary arnines. Reagents and conditions: 1.5 Equiv. HINR', 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)2acac], 2.8 mol% [P(OPh)3], 20+80 bar H2/CO ( l : l ) , toluene, 90"-120 "C (40-46%).
In these cases, the reaction sequence must have proceeded through an imine intermediate 25 followed by a rhodium catalyzed imine reduction. This appeared surprising, since known hydroaminomethylation attempts starting from primary amines and alkenes, employing similar rhodium-catalysts, under similar reaction conditions were found to stop generally at the stage of the imine [21]. Hence, a special situation may be given for o-DPPB derivatives 5. A plausible explanation for the increased reactivity towards imine hydrogenation may take into account the presence of the catalyst-directing o-DPPB group.
Catalyst-Directing Group (CDG)
[mine-Hydrogenation Scheme 14.
Possible role of the o-DPPB group in the course of the imine hydrogenatlon step.
Thus, it is likely, that after imine formation a second catalyst precoordination occurs and an intramolecular imine hydrogenation takes place. Such an intramolecular process should be kinetically favored compared to a corresponding intermolecular reaction pathway. Hence, the catalyst-directing o-DPPB group may be acting within one sequential transformation in
o-DPPB-directed Hydroformylation as Part of5equential Transformations
two different ways. Firstly, the CDG controls diastereoselectivity in the hydroformylation step and secondly controls chemoselectivity in the course of the imine reduction. Other sequential transformations employing the hydroformylation as the key step may be realized if other nucleophiles such as e.g. carbon nucleophiles are offered in the course of the hydroformylation reaction. A resulting domino reaction would approach an ideal synthetic method as defined by Hendrickson [21]. Thus, according to his definition, only skeleton-constructing reactions are inevitable and consequently an efficient synthesis should consist only of framework elaborating steps. Furthermore, if a particular target contains stereogenic centers the most efficient synthetic steps are according to Corey those which in addition to carbon skeleton construction allow for the generation of new stereogenic centers selectively [22]. A reaction in agreement with these efficiency criteria would be a domino stereoselectivehydroformylation-Wittig olefination process. This would require that the hydroformylation reaction be compatible with the presence of a Wittig ylid throughout the course of the reaction. Reacting both methallylic and homomethallylic alkenic substrates under hydroformylation conditions in the presence of stabilized Wittig ylids gave the corresponding domino hydroformylation products 26 in good yields and diastereoselectivities [24]. Whereas in the case of the disubstituted stabilized Wittig ylids the reaction stopped at the stage of the trisubstituted olefin 26, in the case of monosubstituted ylids a further hydrogenation reaction of the @'unsaturated carbonyl functionalities occurred and provided the corresponding saturated derivatives 27. Control of diastereoselectivity was provided via the catalyst-directing o-DPPB group making use of both 1,2- and 1,3-asymmetric induction.
O(PDPPB)
Ph3P=CMeCOR' Rh-Cat.; H2/C0 *
R+
CH3
O(@DPPB) CH3 ++R
0
CH3
synhnfi 5
up to 96 : 4 26
Scheme IS. Domino hydroformylation-Wittig olefination. Reagents and conditions: 1.1 Equiv. Ph,P = CMeCOR'. 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)zacac],2.8 mol% [P(OPh)p], 20 bar H2/C0 ( l : l ) , toluene, 90 "C (60-78%). R' = Me, OEt.
This domino reaction enables in one step the construction of two carbon carbon single bonds and additionally, generates a new stereogenic center with high levels of acyclic stereocontrol. Through the substituents R and R' this domino reaction may potentially be used as a fragment coupling step in the course of a convergent synthetic strategy. However, although synthetically useful, in terms of atom economy the Wittig olefination suffers from the stoichiometric loss of phosphane oxide as the byproduct. This deficiency of the above Domino protocol could be overcome employing the Knoevenagel condensation as the key olefination step. Thus, when methallylic o-DPPB esters were subjected to hydroformylation conditions
I
77
78
I
Controlling Stereoselectivity with the Aid ofa Reagent-Directing
O(oDPPB)
Ph3P=CHCOR', Rh-Cat.; H$CO R' = Alkyl, OEt
R+
Group O(oDPPB)
*
R R +8
0 CH3 syn/anfi 2 90 : 10 27
CH3 5
+
hydroforrnylation
hydrogenation
1 I
[
wittig olefination
.D
[
R*Rt]
CH3 6
28
Domino hydroformylation-Wittig olefination-hydrogenation Reagents and conditions: 1.5 Equiv. PhlP = CMeCOR', 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)2acac],2.8 mol% [P(OPh),], 20 bar Hz/CO (l:l), toluene, 90 "C (60-82%). R' = Me, OEt.
Scheme 16.
O(oDPPB)
JY
.EWG ( EWG
O(oDPPB) EWG R
Rh-Cat.; H$CO D EWG = COR', C02R'
CH3
W
W
G
CH3 syn/ani 2 92 : 8 29
5
hydroforrnylation
hydrogenation
t
[ 4-31
E
1 I
Knoevenagel
D
[
R%R\]
6
CH3
30
Domino hydroformylation-Knoevenagel condensationhydrogenation. Reagents and conditions: 1.1 Equiv. CH2EWC2, 1.2 equiv. piperidinium acetate, 0.7 mol% [Rh(CO)2acac], 2.8 mol% [P(OPh)3], 20 bar H*/CO (1:1), toluene, 90 "C (51-71%). Scheme 17.
in the presence of catalytic amounts of piperidinium acetate and 1.1 equivalent of a CHacidic compound (e.g. malonates, 8-ketoesters, 1,3-diketones) a Domino hydroformylationKnoevenagel condensation-hydrogenation reaction occured to furnish the saturated derivatives 29 in good yields and with excellent diastereoselectivities [ 2 5 ] .
Conclusion 179
o-DPPB-directed Allylic Substitution with Organocopper Reagents
When looking for a process to remove the reagent-directing o-DPPB group with concomitant formation of a new carbon skeleton bond, allylic substitution with organocopper reagents appeared to be a synthetically appealing candidate.
O(eDPPB) H
3
C
e
p
h
symaddition mol% CuBr.SMe2/ 1.1 equiv. MeMgl
CH3
*
H
3
(-)-31
C
d
P
h
(+)-32
€:Z>99:1 ee > 99 %
mol% CuBr.SMe2 €:Z
yield
2 98:2
95:5 > 9 9 % >99% 92 Yo 85 %
t Scheme 18.
o-DPPB-directed allylic substitution with organocopper reagents.
Interestingly, the o-DPPB group was found to serve as an efficient reagent-directing leaving group for copper mediated and catalyzed allylic substitution with Grignard reagents [ 261. The o-DPPB group provided almost perfect control over regioselectivity, alkene geometry and 1,3 chirality transfer, and could be recovered as the corresponding o-DPPB acid almost quantitatively. Conclusion
The introduction of an appropriately designed reagent-directing group allowed the development of a substrate-directed, stereoselective hydroformylation reaction of acyclic methallylic and homomethallylic alcohol derivatives. The potentially multifunctional character of the introduced reagent-directing o-DPPB group was explored in the course of a stereoselective addition of Gilman cuprates to acyclic enoates. Thus, by combining both o-DPPB-directed hydroformylation and o-DPPB-directedcuprate addition a short and efficient synthesis of the building blocks for polyketide synthesis were devised. Incorporating the o-DPPB-directed hydroformylation as part of sequential transformations allowed a further increase of synthetic efficiency. An efficient way to remove the o-DPPB group from the organic substrate, with concomitant extension of the carbon skeleton, was found to be its use as a reagentdirecting leaving group for allylic substitution. Thus, complete control over all issues of selectivity in the course of allylic substitution with organocopper reagents was obtained.
80
I
Controlling Stereoselectivity with the Aid o f a Reagent-Directing Group References 1
2
3
4
5
6
A. H. HOVEYDA, D. A. EVANS, G. C. Fu, Chem. Rev. 1993, 93, 1307-1370. a) B. M. TROST,Angew. Chem. 1995, 107, 285-307; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34. 259: b) B. M. TROST,Science 1991, 254, 1471-1477. For recent reviews see: a) J. A. MOULIJN, P. W. N. M. VAN LEEUWEN,R. A. VAN SAUTEN, Catalysis - A n Integrated Approach to Homogenous, Heterogenous and Industrial Catalysis, Elsevier, Amsterdam 1995, S. 199-248; b) C. D. FROHNING,C. W. KOHLPAINTNER in Applied Homogeneous Catalysis with Organometallic Compounds, (Eds.: B. CORNILS, W. A. HERRMANN), VCH, Weinheim 1996, Kap. 2.1.1, S. 29104; c) M. BELLER,B. CORNILS, C. D. FROHNING,C. W. K O H L P A I N T N EMol. R,~. Cat. A 1995, 104, 17-85; d) J. K. STILLEin Comprehensiue Organic Synthesis, (Eds.: B. M. TROST,I. FLEMING),Pergamon, Oxford 1991, Vol. 4, pp 913-959; e) F. AGBOSSOU,J.-F. CARPENTIER, A. MORTREUX, Chem. Rev. 1995, 95, J. C. BAYON, 2485-2506; f ) S. GLADIALI, C. CIAVER,Tetrahedron Asymrn. 1995, 6, 1453-1474. For exceptions see: S . D. BURK, J. E. COBB, K. TAKEUCHI, /. Org. Chem. 1990, 55, 2138-2151; T. TAKAHASHI, K. MACHIDA, Y. KIDO,K. NAGASHIMA, S. EBATA, T. DOI, Chem. Lett. 1997, 1291-1292; B. BREIT, S. K. ZAHN,Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 1901-1904; I. OTIMA, E. s. V I D A L ,Am. ~. Chem. SOC.1998, 63, 7999-8003. N. SAKAI, S. MANO,K. NOZAKI,H. TAKAYA, 1.Am. Chew SOC.1993, 115, 7033-7034: N. SAKAI, K. NOZAKI,H. TAKAYA,].Chem. SOC.,Chem. Commun. 1994, 395-396; K. NOZAKI,N. SAKAI, T. NANNO,T. HIGASHIJIMA, S. MANO,T. HORIUCHI, H. TAKAYA, /. Am. Chem. SOC.1997, 119, 4413-4423; T. HORIUCHI, T. OHTA,E. SHIRAKAWA, K. NOZAKI,H. TAKAYA, Tetrahedron 1997, 5, 7795-7804; K. NOZAKI, W. LI, T. HORIUCHI, H. TAKAYA, Tetrahedron Lett. 1997, 38, 4611-4614; T. HORIUCHI, T. OHTA,E. SHIRAKAWA, K. NOZAKI,H. TAKAYA, 1.Org. Chem. 1997, 62,4285-4292. J. E. BABIN, G. T. TODD(Union Carbide) IPN: W093/03839.
7 For a review on stereoselective hydrofor-
8
9
10
11 12 13
14
15
16
17
18
mylations see P. EILBRACHTin HoubenWeyl, Methods of Organic Synthesis, E 21, Stereoselective Synthesis, (Eds.:G. HELMCHEN, R. W. HOFFMANN, J. MULZER, E. SCHAUM A N N ) , Thieme, Stuttgart, 1995, p. 24882557. For substrate-directed diastereoselective hydroformylation of cyclic systems see S. D. BURKE,J. E. COBB,Tetrahedron Lett. 1986, 27, 4237-4240; W. R. JACKSON, P. PERLMUTTER, E. E. TASDELEN, J. Chem. SOC.Chem. Commun. 1990, 763-764. For a review see J. M. BROWN, Angew. Chem. 1987, 99, 169-182; Angew. Chem. Int. ed. engl. 1987, 26, 190-203. - See also ref. [l]pp 1331-1340. a) B. BREIT,Angew. Chem. 1996, 108, 3021-3023; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1996, 35, 2835-2837; b) B. BREIT, Liebigs Ann. 1997, 1841-1851. T. DOI,H. KOMATSU, K. YAMAMOTO, Tetrahedron Lett. 1996, 37, 6877-6880. B. BREIT, M. DAUBER, K. HARMS,Chem. Eur. /. 1999, 5, in press. B. BREIT,/. Chem. SOC.,Chem. Commun. 1997, 591-592; B. BREIT, Eur. 1.Org. Chem. 1998, 1123-1134. B. BREIT, unpublished results. B. BREIT, Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 535538; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1998, 37, 525-527. For the concept of domino reactions in organic synthesis see a) L. F. TIETZE, Chem. Rev. 1996, 96, 115-136; b) L. F. TIETZE,U. BEIFUSS, Angew. Chem. 1993, 105, 137-170; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1993, 32, 131-163; c) T. L. Ho, Tandem Organic Reactions, Wiley, New York 1992 d) H. M. R. HOFFMANN, Angew. Chem. 1992, 104, 1361-1363; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1992, 31, 1332-1334. a) W. REPPE,Experientia, 1949, 5, 93; b) W. REPPE, H. KINDLER,Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1953, 582, 133. a) A. F. M. IQBAL, Helv. Chim. Acta 1971, 45, 1440; b) R. M. LINE, J. Org. Chem. 1980, 45, 3370; c) K. MURATA, A. MATSUDA, T. MATSUDA, 1.Mol. Cat. 1984, 23, 121; d) F. JACHIMOWICZ (W. R. Grace and Co.) Belgian Patent 887630 (1980); Chem. Abstr. 1981, 95, 152491; e) F.
References I 8 1 JACHIMOWICZ, P. MANSON (W. R. Grace and Co.) Canadian Patent 1231199 (1984); Chem. Abstr. 1988, 109, 38485; f ) F. JACHIMOWICZ, J. W. RAKSIS, /. Org. Chem. 1982, 47, 445; g) E. E. MACENTIRE, J. F. KNIFTON (Texaco Development Corp.) European Patent 240193 (1987); Chem. Abstr. 1989, 110, 134785; h) S. TOROS,I. GEMES-PESCI, B. HEIL,S. MAHo, Z. /. Chem. SOC., Chem. Commun. TUBER, 1992, 858; i) E. DRENT,A. J. M. BREED (Shell Int. Res. M) European Patent 457386 (1992); Chem Abstr. 1992, 11 6, 83212; j) M. D. J O N E S , J . Organomet. Chem. 1989, 366, 403; k) T. IMAI (Uop Inc) US Patent 4220764 (1978); Chem. Abstr. 1980, 93, 239429; 1) G. DIEKHAUS, D. KAMPMANN.C. KNIEP, T. MULLER,I. WALTER, J. WEBER(Hoechst AG) German Patent DE 4334809 (1993); Chem. Abstr.
1995, 122, 314160. 19
For recent results on efficient hydroaminomethylation of functionalized derivatives see T. RISCHE, P. EILBRACHT, Synthesis 1997, 1331-1337; C. L. KRANEMANN, P. EILBRACHT,Synthesis 1998. 71-77.
20
B. BREIT,Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 51635166.
21
a) T. BAIG,P. KALCK,/. Chem. SOC.,Chem. Commun. 1992, 1373; b) T. BAIG,J. P. KALCK, /. Organomet. Chem. MOLINIER, 1993, 455, 219; c) A. L. JAPIDUS, A. P. RODIN, L. Y . BREZHNEV, I . G. PRUIDZE, B. I. UGRAK,Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Khim. 1990, 1448; Chem. Abstr. 1990, 113,
22
a) J.B. HENDRICKSON,/. Am. Chem. SOC. 1975, 97, 5784-5800; b) ibid. 1977, 99, 5439-5450; c) J. B. HENDRICKSON, Angew. Chem. 1990, 102, 1328-1338; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1990, 29,
171812.
1286-1295. 23 E. J. COREY, X.-M. CHENG,The Logic of Chemical Synthesis,Wiley, New York 1989, Chapter 4, pp 47-57. 24 B. BREIT, S. K. ZAHN,Angew. Chem. 1999, 1 1 1 , 1022-1024; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1999, 38,969-971. 25 B. BREIT,S. K. ZAHN,Angew. Chem. 2001, 113, 1964-1967; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 2001,40, 1910-1973. 26 B. BREIT,P. DEMEL, Ado. Synth. Cat. 2001, 343,429-432.
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
82
I
Solvent-Free Organic Syntheses Jiirgen 0. Metzger
A consequence of the necessity to minimize the amount of toxic waste and by-products from
chemical processes is a need for the development of new, more environmentally friendly and resource-saving synthetic methods in which fewer toxic substances are used. Nowadays in the development of new syntheses, ecological points of view must also be taken into consideration and apportioned due importance in the assessment of viability [l,21. In this process the solvents are especially important, as they are generally used in large quantities. Many organic solvents are ecologically harmful, and their use should therefore be minimized as far as possible or even avoided altogether [ 2 ] . In industry they are of course recycled wherever possible. However, in practice this is only rarely accomplished with complete efficiency, which means that some organic solvent from chemical production will inevitably escape and severely pollute the environment. Alternatives under investigation as solvents for organic reactions are water [ 31 and supercritical gases, in particular COz [ 41. The best solvent from an ecological point of view is without doubt no solvent. There are many great reactions that can already be carried out in the absence of a solvent, for example numerous industrially important gas-phase reactions and many polymerizations. Diels-Alder and other pericyclic reactions are also often carried out without solvents. Reports on solventfree reactions have, however, become increasingly frequent and specialized over the past few years. Areas of growth include reactions between solids [S], between gases and solids [GI, and on supported inorganic materials [ 71, which in many cases are accelerated or even made possible through microwave irradiation [ 81. Some most important solvent-free routes for selective oxidations of hydrocarbons and aromatics [ 91, hydrogenations [ 101, and for a one step production of ecaprolactam from cyclohexanone with a mixture of air and ammonia using porous heterogeneous catalysts have been reported, in which the active sites have been atomically engineered [ 111.There are also reactions in which at least one reactant is liquid under the conditions employed, which means the solvent normally used can simply be left out. To begin with, two industrially important examples are discussed, which confirm that a reaction process that is more environmentally friendly can also be economically very acceptable. This is followed by some recent examples of solvent-free reactions covering a remarkably broad range of reaction types in which the term “solvent-free” refers solely to the reaction itself. On the other hand, workup processes, except for a few examples, invariably involve the use of solvent. The
Polymer Syntheses
examples show that these reactions proceed with similar and in many cases even higher yield and/or selectivity and, because of the higher concentration of the reactants, with a larger rate of reaction. Polymer Syntheses
The method for the manufacture of polypropylene by the Ziegler-Natta process, which has been in widespread use for several decades, involved some years ago a polymerization in a relatively volatile solvent, for example a light petroleum fraction. That was the drawback of this process, since in the separation and subsequent drying of the polymer formed the solvent could not be completely recovered. Problems are thus experienced in fulfilling environmental protection requirements. An additional obstacle was the large volume of aqueous waste that is generated during workup of the polymer suspension. The new polypropylene processes do not require solvents because of a new and highly efficient catalyst [12].Therefore, there are also no solvent emissions in the exhaust gases. Small amounts of gaseous hydrocarbons that are formed are incinerated. In the manufacture of the polymer the amount of aqueous wastewater accumulated is much smaller, since the amount of catalyst used can be reduced to such low levels that it no longer needs to be washed after the reaction. Comparable results have also been achieved in the manufacture of high-density polyethylene. Polycarbonates are amorphous polymers with excellent handling properties. Their spectrum of applications ranges from baby bottles to compact discs. Most of the polycarbonate produced is generated by the polycondensation of bisphenol A with phosgene in a biphasic system (sodium hydroxide/dichloromethane). The solution of the polycarbonate product in dichloromethane is washed with water to remove the by-product NaC1. However, in this washing process some 20 g . L-' of the dichloromethane ends up dissolved in the aqueous phase. The dichloromethane must also be removed from the polycarbonate, which is not easy. This means that the polycarbonate will invariably contain some chlorinated impurities, which adversely affects the properties of the polymer. Komiya et al. [ 131 recently introduced the novel, environmentally friendly process from Asahi Chemical Industry Co. for the production of polycarbonates, which requires neither phosgene nor solvent (Scheme 1). In this process bisphenol A undergoes a prepolymerization with diphenyl carbonate in the melt. A simple crystallization of the prepolymer is fol-
1
Scheme 1.
Solvent-free synthesis of polycarbonate from bisphenol A and diphenyl carbonate [lo].
I
83
84
I
Solvent-Free Organic Syntheses
lowed by a solid-state polymerization to a polycarbonate of high molecular weight. Its quality is superior to the product of the phosgene process, and the production costs appear to be similar. A variety of strategies for reducing or eliminating the use of traditional organic solvents in polymer synthesis and processing have been discussed recently [ 141. Radical Additions
For some time, intermolecular radical additions have been an integral part of the methodological arsenal of preparative organic chemistry. However, from an ecological point of view the methods that have been used to date suffer from a number of drawbacks that present obstacles to their broad-based industrial application. This applies particularly to the commonly used organotin compounds. Transition metal complexes and salts which initiate radical reactions through electron transfer processes are a highly promising alternative, and some recent examples even do not require the use of solvents [ 15, lG]. Thus, cc-iodo esters undergo addition to alkenes through an electron transfer initiated by metallic copper [15]. The reaction procedure is very simple: The alkene, iodo compound, and commercial copper powder are mixed together without any pretreatment and heated to 130 "C under an inert atmosphere (Scheme 2). After a simple workup the products were obtained in good yield; the entire reaction was carried out in the complete absence of solvent, as the product was distilled off directly from the reaction mixture. The iodo compound could be replaced by the corresponding, more easily accessible bromo compound; in this case an equimolar quantity of sodium iodide is added. The iodo compound is formed initially as an intermediate by a solvent-free Finkelstein reaction.
Scheme 2.
Copper-initiated radical addition of methyl 2-iodopropionate to methyl 10-undecenoate [15].
cc-Iodonitrile [ 151 and perfluoroalkyl iodides [ 161 underwent addition to alkenes in a completely analogous solvent-free reaction. Additional points in favor of these solvent-free radical additions are that the yields are generally better than with the conventional methodology and that they also permit additions to 1,2-disubstituted alkenes. Enzyme-Catalyzed Reactions
The selective enzyme-catalyzed acylation of carbohydrates is of great interest, as of carbohydrates fatty acid esters of carbohydrates have important applications in detergents, cosmetics, foodstuff, and pharmaceuticals because of their surface-active properties. Monoacylated sugars have been synthesized by lipase-catalyzed transesterifications of activated esters in pyridine and by protease-catalyzed esterifications in DMF. A most remarkable new development
Enzyme-Catalyzed Reactions
is the use of immobilized lipases for the selective acylation of I-0-ethyl glucopyranoside with free carboxylic acids in the absence of solvent. This afforded G-0-acyl glucopyranosides in 8 5 9 0 % yield [ 171, with small amounts of the 2,G-O,O-diacylglucopyranosides being formed as by-products. This reaction can also be carried out without problems on a large scale. Thus, 8 kg of glucose was allowed to react with ethanol in the presence of an ion-exchange resin to form 1-0-ethyl glucopyranoside. After removal of the ion exchange resin and the residual ethanol 12.7 kg of coconut oil fatty acids were added to the crude 1-0-ethylglucopyranoside, and the mixture was heated to 70 "C. Then 400 g of immobilized lipase from Candida antarctica was added, and the water of reaction that formed was removed under vacuum. After 28 h a conversion of greater than 90% was achieved. After the enzyme was filtered off, a crude product was obtained which contained 70% of the 6-0-monoester.After removal of the excess fatty acid (21%) by distillation, the final product had a 6-0-monoester content of greater than 85% (Scheme 3). HO
RC02H
RCO2
Lipase, 70"C, 24h .OEt
H
O
85 - 90%
O
E
t
H OH
OH
Lipase-catalyzed acylation o f 1-0-ethyl glucopyranoside with carboxylic acids t o 6-0-acyl glucopyranosides (R = n-C7H15, n-CgH19, nCII H23, n-C13H27, n-C15H31, n-Cl7H35) [171. Scheme 3.
In another solvent-free process with the same lipase as above, trimethylene carbonate underwent an almost quantitative ring-opening polymerization in 120 h at 70 "C to form poly(trimethy1ene carbonate) [ 181. No decarboxylation was detected (Scheme 4). wPentadecalactone was likewise polymerized with lipases in the absence of a solvent to form polyesters of high molecular weight [ 191. 0
II
0
O A O
70°C,48h Scheme 4. Lipase-catalyzed ring-opening polymerization of trimethylene carbonate t o linear poly(trimethy1ene carbonate) [18]
The latter two successful processes were combined in the solvent-free lipase-catalyzed reaction of 1-0-ethyl glucoside with trimethylene carbonate or c-caprolactone to form amphiphilic oligomers and polymers [ 201. The products are biodegradable polycarbonates and polyesters that are formed regioselectively by reaction with the primary hydroxyl group of the sugar moiety. Lipase catalyzed esterifications were performed favorably solvent-free [21] and were applied also to bulk polymerization for polyester synthesis [ 221.
86
I
Solvent-Free Organic Syntheses
Homogeneous Catalysis
Oxidations are of great importance, and it would be highly desirable to carry them out with environmentally friendly oxidants such as atmospheric oxygen and hydrogen peroxide -30% H202 if possible. Ideally such reactions should also be carried out without the need for any additional organic solvent. Noyori et al. [23] recently reported an efficient oxidation of secondary alcohols to ketones with sodium tungstate as catalyst and methyltrioctylammonium hydrogen sulfate as phase-transfer catalyst (Scheme 5). The yield in the case of 2-octanol was approximately 95%. Primary alcohols are four to five times less reactive and were generally oxidized to carboxylic acids. More remarkably, unsaturated secondary alcohols, including even allylic alcohols, were oxidized with high selectivity to the corresponding ketones. Moreover, using the same catalyst, cyclohexene was efficiently oxidized to give adipic acid [ 241. However, if a catalytic quantity of arninomethylphosphonic acid was added, an efficient epoxidation catalyst was obtained, and terminal alkenes could be oxidized to the epoxides in greater than 90% yield using 30% H 2 0 2(Scheme 6) [25].
Scheme 5.
Oxidation of secondary alcohols to ketones with 30%
H202
[23]
Scheme 6. Epoxidation of 1-alkenes with 30% H 2 0 2by addition o f aminomethylphosphonic acid t o the catalytic oxidation system shown i n Scheme 5 [25].
The chiral Cr"' - salen complex 1 is a highly efficient catalyst for the enantioselective ring opening of epoxides with Me3SiN3 [26]. For example, cyclohexene oxide underwent ring opening with 2% of 1 and MejSiNj in the complete absence of solvent - the product was removed by short-path distillations under reduced pressure from the reaction mixture - in 90% yield and with 84-88% ee (Scheme 7). The catalyst was easily recovered and could be reused without any loss of activity. The yield and enantioselectivity were similarly high as for the corresponding reaction in diethyl ether. Palladium complexes with phosphinooxazoline ligands such as 2 have been proven to be very efficient catalysts for the coupling of alkynes to enynes in solvent-free reactions (Scheme 8) and provided an efficient tool for regiocontrolled cross-coupling reactions between mono- and disubstituted alkynes [ 271. The neat Ru-catalyzed hydroesterification of 3,3-dimethyl-l-propene with 2-pyridylmethyl formates afforded exclusively a linear ester in 89% isolated yield using only 0.2 mol%
Homogeneous Catalysis
187
2% (R,R)-l, 20h D 91%,88% ee
+ Me3SiN3
(RR1-1 Catalytic enantioselective ring opening of cyclohexene oxide with trimethylsilyl azide using the chiral Cr(lll) - salen complex 1 1261. Scheme 7.
2
H13C6
Pd(0Ac)zi 2
2
*
C6H1 3
H13C6
'tBu
2 Scheme 8.
Pd-catalyzed coupling of 1-octyne 1271
Ru3( C0)12 [ 281. Furthermore, the Pd-catalyzed solvent free arsination of aryl triflates (Scheme 9) [ 291, and the hydroamination of phenylacetylene with aniline in the presence of [ Ru3(C0)12]/NH4PF6 proceeds with high regioselectivity giving the product by simple distillation with greater than 99% purity in 92% yield (Scheme 10) [ 301. Pd(OAc)Z P ~ ~ A115°C s,
40 - 50%
Fn
0
AsPh;!
Fn
-
Fn = COOMe, COMe, CHO, CN, NOz, OMe Scheme 9.
Pd-catalyzed arsination of aryltriflates with triphenylarsine (291.
88
I
Solvent-Free Organic Syntheses
Scheme 10.
Catalytic hydroamination of phenylacetylene with aniline [30]
Lewis Acid and Base Catalyzed Reactions
Several examples have been described on Lewis acid and base catalyzed Michael addiacid ethylester was added at room temperature to methyl tions. Cyclopentanone-2-carboxylic vinyl ketone using 2 mol% FeC13.G HzO as catalyst yielding > 90% of the addition product (Scheme 11) [31]. Cerium(II1) chloride in the presence of sodium iodide [32] and trifluoromethanesulfonic acid have been used as catalysts as well [ 331.
d
M0
e
2 mol% >FeC13 90%
- 6 H20*
W
C02Et M
e
I
Scheme 11. FeCI3-catalyzed Michael-addition of cyclopentanone-2carboxylic acid ethyl ester with methylvinylketone [31].
Modified guanidines 3 efficiently catalyzed the asymmetric Michael addition of a prochiral glycine derivatives with acrylate, acrylonitrile and methyl vinyl ketone under simple and mild conditions. Remarkably, both product formation and enantioselectivity were dramatically improved using solvent-free conditions (Scheme 12) [34]. The addition of alcohols to methyl propiolate was performed using fluorous phosphines such as P[(CH2)2(CFZ),CF3I3 and again better yields of 99% have been obtained under solvent-free conditions. Toluene was added to efficiently separate the product from the solid catalyst, which was then reused without loss of activity [ 351. Ph2C=NCH2COOtBu
+ //'\cooE~
+ 3(0.2 eq)
*
20"C, 3d, 87%, 97% ee
MeN
K
NMe
Ph
Ph 3
Scheme 12. Cuanidine-catalyzed asymmetric Michael-addition of tert-butyl diphenyliminoacetate with ethyl acrylate [34].
Ph2C=N Y O t B u COOEt
Reactions Using Organometallic Reagents
The indium trichloride-catalyzed Mukaiyama aldol reaction of 3-aminoketoesters with various silylenolethers gave under solvent-free conditions 1,3-amino alcohols with high stereoselectivity [ 361. Several Robinson annelation reactions have been carried out enantioselectively using (S)-proline as a chiral catalyst [ 371. Remarkably, the enantioselectivity was distinctly higher in the absence of solvent than in DMSO. The ytterbium triflate catalyzed Biginelli reaction of aldehydes, ethyl acetoacetate and urea to give in a one-pot synthesis dihydropyrimidones was performed again in higher yields without any solvent (Scheme 13) [ 381.
OEt
5mol% Yb(OTf)3 w
IOO'C, 20 tnin., 98%
Me H
Scheme 13.
Ytterbium triflate catalyzed Biginelli reaction [38].
The same Lewis acid has been applied also as a catalyst for the syntheses of 2J-dihydro1H-1,s-benzodiazepines in very good yields from o-phenylenendiamine and ketones [ 391.
Solvent-free coumarin [40] and porphyrin syntheses have also been reported [41]. The Baylis-Hillman reaction of aldehydes with methyl methacrylate can be catalyzed with tetramethylguanidine (TMG) whereby the activity of the catalyst is decreased when solvents are used in the reaction (Scheme 14) [42].
1,
Ph
+
5%TMG
fiCOOMe 20"C, 6h, 58%
Scheme 14. Tetramethylguanidine ( T M C ) is an efficient catalyst for the solvent-free Baylis-Hillman reaction [42].
A catalytic amount of aluminum chloride hexahydrate enables solvent-free tetrahydropyranylation of alcohols and phenols at moderate temperatures and a simple addition of methanol helps to regenerate the corresponding alcohols and phenols [43]. Reactions Using Organornetallic Reagents
Solvent-free enantioselective additions of diethylzinc to aldehydes and to N-diphenylphosphinoylimines using p-amino alcohols as chiral catalysts afforded chiral sec-alcohols and N-
90
I
Solvent-Free Organic Syntheses
diphenylphosphinoylamines, respectively, with high enantiomeric excess, and is faster than using organic solvents in these reactions (Scheme 15) [44]. Ph
EtZZn, 4 (1 eq.) phv,N, ,Ph O'C, 76%, 84% ee
;lPh
0
*
0
phMMe
HO
4
c-
Scheme 15.
Catalytic enantioselective addition of diethylzinc to N-diphenylphosphinoylimines [44b].
Indium mediated Barbier-type cross coupling between carbonyl compounds and allyl halides proceed efficiently under solvent-free conditions. No apparent competing pinacolcoupling or homo-coupling of the allyl halide was observed. The reactions were found to be mediated also by zinc, tin, bismut and copper [45]. Cycloadditions
The solvent-free asymmetric Hetero-Diels-Alder reaction of 14 different aldehydes with Danishefsky's diene was carried out with 0.1-0.005 mol% of chiral titanium complexes to afford dihydropyrones with up to quantitative yields and 99.8% ee. A library of chiral metal complexes was generated by combining one or two different chiral diol ligands e.g. 5 (13 different diols were applied) with titanium isopropylate (Scheme 16) [46]. OMe Ti-2.5 99%E
Me3Si-0
5 Scheme 16.
Asymmetric Hetero-Diels-Alder reaction of benzaldehyde w i t h Danishefsky's d i m e [46].
References I 9 1
+
[2 2lCycloadditions of cyclic ketene trimethylsilyl acetals with ethyl propynoate and other electrophilic alkines were run at room temperature, without a catalyst and solvent-free (47). Nucleophilic Substitutions and /I-eliminations
As has already been pointed out, the Finkelstein reaction can be conducted in situ in the absence of solvents. For example, alkylations of purine and pyrimidine bases with alkyl halides and dimethyl sulfate have been carried out by solid/liquid phase-transfer catalysis in the absence of any additional solvent [48], as have cyanation of haloalkanes [49] and peliminations [SO]. Noteworthy is the synthesis of glycosyl isothiocyanates by the reaction of potassium thiocyanate with molten glycosyl bromide at 190 "C [Sl]. To summarize, solvent-free reactions are not only of increasing interest from an ecological viewpoint, but in many cases also offer considerable synthetic advantages in terms of yield, selectivity, and simplicity of the reaction procedure. References 1
2
3 4
5
6
7
8
P. T. ANASTAS, T. C. WILLIAMSON in Green Chemistry, Designing Chemistry for the T. C. Environments (Eds.: P. T. ANASTAS, WrLLrAMsoN), American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 1996, pp. 1-17. M. EISSEN,J. 0. METZGER, E. SCHMIDT, U. SCHNEIDEWIND, Angew. Chem. 2002, 114, 402-425, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2002, 41, 414-436. C.-J. LI, T.-H. CHAN,Organic Reactions in Aqueous Media, Wiley, Chichester, 1997. P. G. JESSOP, W. LEITNER (eds.), Chemical Synthesis Using Supercritical Fluids, WileyVCH, Weinheim, 1999. a) F. TODA,Acc. Chem. Res. 1995, 28, 480A N D F. TODA,Chem. 486; b) K. TANAKA Rev. 2000, 100, 1025-1074; c) G. W. V. J. L. SCOTT,Chew. CAVE,C. L. RASTON, Commun. 2001, 2159-2169. a) G. KAUPP, J. SCHMEYERS, Angew. Chem. 1993, 105, 1656-1658; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1993, 32, 1587-1589; b) G. KAUPP, J. S C H M E Y E R Org. S , ~ .Chem. 199.5, 60, 5494-5503; c) G. KAUPP,Andreas Herrmann, lens Schmeyers, Chem. Eur. I. 2002, 8, 1395-1406, and references therein. J. H. CLARK, Catalysis oforganic Reactions by Supported Inorganic Reagents, VCH, New York, 1994. a) R. S. VARMA,Clean Prod. Proc. 1999, 1, 132-147; b) R. S. VARMA, Green Chew. 1999, 1, 43-55; c) A. LOUPY, Top. Curr. Chem. 1999. 206, 153-208.
9
10
11 12
13
14
15
16
J. M. THOMAS, R. RAJA,G. SANKAR, B. F. G. J O H N S O N , D. W. LEWIS, Chem. Eur. /. 2001, 7, 2973-2978. S. HERMANS, R. RAJA,J. M. THOMAS, B. F. G. J O H N S O N , G . SANKAR, D. GLEESON, Angew. Chem. 2001, 113, 12511255; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2001, 40, 1211-1215. R. RAJAQ, G. SANKAR, J. M. THOMAS,J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2001, 123, 8153-8154. a) J. HORNKE; R. LIPPHARDT, R. MELDTin Produktionsintegrierter Umweltschutz in der chemischen Industrie (Ed.: J. WIESNER) DECHEMA, Frankfurt/Main, 1990, pp. 17-18; b) A. N. THAYER, Chew. Eng. News 1995, 73(37), 15-20. K. KOMIYA,S. FUKUOKA,M. AMINAKA, K. HASEGAWA, H. HACHIYA, H. OKAMOTO, T. WATANABE, H. YONEDA, J. FUKAWA,T. DOZONO in Green Chemistry, Designing Chemistryfor the Environment (Eds.: P. T. ANASTAS, T. C. WILLIAMSON), American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 1996, p. 20-32. T. E. LONG, M. 0. HUNT,Solvent-Free Polymerizations and Processes, ACS Symposium Series 1999, 713. a) J. 0. METZGER, R. MAHLER, Angew. Chem. 1995, 107, 1013-1015; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34, 902-904; b) J. 0. METZGER, R. MAHLER, G. FRANCKE, Liebigs Ann. 1997; 2303-2313. a) 2.-Y. YANG,B. V. NGUYEN,D. J.
92
I
Solvent-Free Organic Syntheses BURTON,Synlett 1992, 141-142; b) J . 0. METZGER,R. MAHLER,A. SCHMIDT,Liebigs Ann. 1996, 693-696. 17 K. ADELHVRST, F. BJORKLING,S. E. GVDTFREDSEN, 0. KIRK,Synthesis 1990, 112-115. 18 K. S. BISHT, Y. Y. SVIRKIN, L. A. H E N D E R -
SON,R. A. GROSS,D. L. KAPLAN,G. SWIFT, Macromolecules 1997, 30, 7735-7742. 19 K. S. BISHT,L. A. HENDERSON, R. A. GROSS,D. L. KAPLAN,G. SWIFT,Macromolecules 1997, 30, 2705-2711. 20 K. S. BISHT, F. DENG,R. A. GROSS,D. L. KAPLAN,G. SWIFT,]. Am. Chem. Soc. 1999, 119, 1363-1367.
35 36 31
38 39
2001, 42, 3193-3195. 40
21 a) J. M. S. ROCHA,M. H. GIL, F. A. P.
GARCIA,1.Chem. Techn. Biotechnol. 1999, 74, 607-612; b) N. WEBER,P. WEITKAMP, K. D. MUKHERJEE, J . Agnc. Food Chem.
110-111.
2. GRVSS,N. GALILI,1. SALTSMAN, Angew. Chem. 1999, 111, 1530-1533; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1999, 38, 14271429; b) 2. GROSS,N. GALILI,L. SIMKHVVICH, I. SALTSMAN, M. BVTOSHANSKY, D. B L ~ S E RR., BOESE,I. GOLDBERG, Org. Lett. 1999, 1, 599-602; c) M. G. WARNER, G. L. SUCCAW, J. E. HUTCHISVN,Green Chem. 2001, 3, 267-
A. K. CHAUDHARY, J. LOPEZ,E. J. BECKMAN, A. J. RUSSELL, Biotechnol. Prog. 1997, 13, 318-325.
K. SATO,M. AOKI,J. TAKAGI,R. NVYVRI,]. Am. Chem. SOC.1997, 119, 12386-12387. 24 K. SATV,M . AVKI,R. NOYORI,Science 23
25
270.
1998, 281, 1646-1647.
42
a) K. SATO,M. AOKI,M. OGAWA,T. HASHIMOTO,R. NVYVRI,]. Org. Chem. 1996, 61, 8310-8311; b) K. SATV,M. AOKI, M. OGAWA,T. HASHIMOTO, D. PANYELLA, R. NOYORI,Bull. Chem. Soc.]pn. 1997, 70,
43
61
26
45
1261-1 264. 28 S.
Ko, Y. NA, S. CHANG,]. Am. Chem. SOC.
2002, 124, 750-751. 29 30
31
32
33
F. Y. KWVNG,c . w. h I , K. s. CHAN,]. Am. Chem. SOC.2001, 123, 886443865, M. TOKUNAGA, M . ECKERT,Y. WAKATSUKI, Angew. Chem. 1999, 111, 3416-3419; Angew, Chem. lnt. Ed. 1999,38,3222-3225. a) J. CHRISTOFFERS, Org. Synth. 2000, 78, 249-253; b) I. CHRISTVFFERS, J . Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 11997, 3141-3149. G. BARTOLI,M. Bosco, M. C. BELUCCI, E. MARCANTONI, L. SAMBRI,E. TVRREGIANI, Eur.]. Org. Chem. 1999, 617-620. H. KVTSUKI,K. ARIMURA, T. OHISHI,R. MARUZASA, I. Org. Chem. 1999, 64, 37703773.
34
T. ISHIKAWA, Y. ARAKI,T. KUMAMOTO, H.
N. E. LEADBEATER, c . VAN DER PVL,]. Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 12001, 28312835.
905-9 15.
L. E. MARTINEZ, J. L. LEIGHTVN,D. H . CARSTEN, E. N. JACOBSEN,].Am. Chem. SOC.1995, 117, 5897-5898. 27 U. LUCKING,A. PFALTZ,Synlett 2000,
T. SUGINO,I. TANAKA, Chem. Lett. 2001,
41 a)
2001, 49, 5210-5216. 22
SEKI,K. FUKUDA,T. ISOBE,Chem. Commun. 2001, 245-246. M. WENDE,R. MEIER,J. A. GLADYSZ,]. Am. Chem. SOC.2001, 123, 11490-11491. T.-P. LOH, J.-M. HUANG,S.-H. GVH, J. J. VITTAL, Org. Lett. 2000, 2, 1291-1294. D. RAJAGOPAL, K. RAJAGOPALAN, S. SWAMINATHAN,Tetrahedron:Asymmetry 1996, 7, 2189-2190. Y. MA, C. QIAN, L. WANG,M. YANG,]. Org. Chem. 2000, 65, 3864-3868. M. CURINI,F. EPIFANV,M. C. MARCVTULLIV, 0. ROSATI,Tetrahedron Lett.
46
47 48
V. V. NAMBVVDIRI, R. S. VARMA, Tetrahedron Lett. 2002, 43, 1143-1146. a) I. SATV,T. SAITO,K. SOAI, Chem. Commun. 2000, 2471-2472; b) I. SATO,R. KVDAKA,K. SOAI,J . Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 12001, 2912-2914. a) X.-H. YI, J. X. HABERMAN, C.-J. LI, Synth. Commun. 1998, 28, 2999-3009; b) P. C. ANDREWS, A. C. PEATT,C. L. RASTON, Green Chem. 2001, 3, 313-315. J. LONG,J. H u , X. SHEN,B. J I , K. D I N G , J . Am. Chem. Soc. 2002, 124, 10-11. M. MIESCH,F. WENDLING, Eur.]. Org. Chem. 2000, 3381-3392. G. BRAM,G . DECODTS,Synthesis 1985, 543-545.
Y.-Q. CAO,B.-H. C H E M ,B.-G. PEI, Synth. Commun. 2001, 31, 2203-2207. 50 a) J. BARRY,G . BUM, G. DECODTS, A. LVUPY,P. PIGEON,J. SANSONLET,].Org. Chem. 1984, 49, 1138-1140; b) P. VINCZER,S. SZTRUHAR, L. NOVAK,C. SZANTAY, Org. Prep. Proced. lnt. 1992, 24,
49
540-543. 51
T. K. LINDHVRST,C. KIEBURG, Synthesis 1995, 1128-1130.
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
I
93
Fluorous Techniques: Progress in ReactionProcessing and Purification Ulf Diederichsen
Fluorous solvents contain perfluorinated or very highly fluorinated alkanes. They have been developed within the last decade as an interesting alternative to classical organic solvents [I31. They are inert, thermally stable, non-polar, immiscible with water and most organic solvents, and non-toxic. The ecological reservations against fluorine hydrocarbons can be met by using higher perfluorinated alkanes with lower vapor pressure. Perfluorinated solvents provide a third liquid phase next to water and organic solvents; this can be advantageous both during reaction-processing and for purification procedures. As is known from phasetransfer catalysis, the distribution of starting materials, products, and reagents in triphasic systems extends the possibilities for planning of syntheses and separation strategies. Provided that they are not modified with fluorous tags, neither salts nor organic compounds are found in the fluorous phase. The heavier fluorous phase can easily be separated from the organic phase or water solution by simple phase-separation techniques. The biphasic system of fluorous phase and organic solvent is especially interesting, since the partition coefficient is temperature-dependent: while phase separation is suitable for successful extraction at room temperature, at temperatures higher than GO "C the phases form a homogeneous solution. Hence, reaction processes in homogeneous solution at higher temperatures can be combined advantageously with workup by extraction at room temperature. There are two main applications for fluorous-phase chemistry in organic synthesis. First of all, catalytic reactions can take advantage of thermoregulation of the two-phase systems, especially when the catalyst is soluble in the fluorous phase. On the other hand, the fluorous phase gives an additional dimension to traditional organic chemistry and parallel synthesis. For reactions, partially fluorinated solvents are usually preferred over perfluorinated solvents. Perfluorinated solvents are often not polar enough for many organic reagents, and this phase is therefore applied only for the workup procedure. Fluorous Biphasic Catalysis
Catalysts immobilized on resins are quite often used for catalytic reactions. Phase-transfer conditions, guaranteeing separation and recovery of the catalysts by use of water/organic solvent biphasic systems, are another possibility. Unlike homogeneous processes, these kind of catalytic processes take account of product loss and substrate selectivity. Furthermore,
94
I
Fluorous Techniques: Progress in Reaction-Processing and Purification
catalysts that are sensitive to hydrolysis cannot be used. In this respect, solvation of the catalyst in the fluorous phase offers an interesting alternative. The catalyst can be separated from the organic phase at room temperature, whereas at higher temperatures a homogeneous reaction mixture is provided. In order for the catalyst to be soluble in the fluorous phase, it needs to be modified at the ligands with perfluoroalkyl chains, the length of which (C6F13-C8F17)is decisive for the distribution between the fluorous phase and the organic solvent. The option of tailoring the partition coefficient provides conditions similar to those created by slow addition of reaction partners [4]. The fluoroalkyl groups are electronwithdrawing because of the high electronegativity of fluorine. In order to avoid influencing the catalytic activity, the fluorous tags are usually linked to the catalyst ligands through an ethylene, propylene, or CHzCHzSiMe spacer. To date, the following catalytic processes have been carried out within biphasic systems, taking advantage of the fluorous phase: hydroformylation of olefins [ 51, hydroboration [GI, hydrogenation of alkenes [ 71, hydrosilylation of ketones [8], oligomerization of ethylene [O],cyclopropanation [ 101, transesterification [ 111, various oxidations [ 12-18], asymmetric reduction of ketones [ 191, cross-coupling of organozinc bromides with aryl iodides [ 201, palladium allylic alkylation [ 211, the Heck reaction [22], Suzuki coupling [23], and asymmetric alkylation of aromatic aldehydes [24], as well as Friedel-Crafts acylation and Diels-Alder reactions (Figures 1 and 2) [ 25, 261. An application of the fluorous two-phase system to catalytic reactions is the hydroformylation of terminal olefins with CO and H2 [S]. Aldehydes 1 can be isolated, together with the branched side products 2. In the C6FI1CF3/toluene solvent mixture, the catalyst [HRh(CO){P[CH2CHz(CF2)5cF,]3}3]is obtained in situ. It acts in the hydroformylation reaction at 100 "C and can be separated afterwards in the fluorous phase. In this process, however, approximately 0.5% of the catalyst remains in the organic phase. Furthermore, the lower solubility of CO and Hz in the fluorous phase produces a lower catalyst activity. Accordingly, the hydroformylation of ethene can be conducted in a continuous process in an autoclave. The use of the fluorous analogue of the Wilkinson catalyst [RhCl{P[ CHzCH2(CF2)5CF3]3}3](3) is advantageous for hydroboration, because cleaning of the often inflammable organoborane is facilitated and destruction of the catalyst by the commonly used oxidative workup (H202/NaOH) is avoided [GI. In this case, the heterogeF ~ catecholborane 5 has even proven neous hydroboration of norbornene (4) in C ~ F I I C with to be better than the fluorous two-phase system. The organoborane can be extracted with THF, and the C6FllCF3 mother liquor containing the catalyst can be used for further synthesis cycles. Turnover numbers (TONS)higher than 10,000 are reached. For a practical transesterification reaction, next to high yields, an equimolar ratio of the reactants is desirable. The catalyst should be neutral and easily separable, and no special technology for alcohol removal should be needed [ 111.These requirements are fulfilled by the fluorous tagged distannoxane catalyst 6 . Transesterification yields are quantitative and the FC-72 solution (FC-72 and FC-75 are commercially available mixtures of perfluoroalkanes) of the catalyst can be reused. Asymmetric alkylation of benzaldehyde can be performed in a toluene/FC-72 biphasic system with Ti(O-iPr)4and the fluorous BINOL ligand 7 (Figure 2) with reasonable yield and enantioselectivity [241. The asymmetric hydrogen-transfer reduction of ketones works fairly
Fluomus Biphasic Catalysis
I
95
Hydroformylation
+
H
R
CH3
2 Hydroboration
5
Transesterification
-
MeOH I FC 72
+
*
CI C2H4-C6F13 C H -C6F13 .**' C6Fl,-C,H4,,, -c HjSn-O-Sn-CI 6 13 2 4 I I I I gCzH4-C6F~3
I
\
6 Fig. 1. Fluorous biphasic catalysis part I: hydroformylation, hydroboration, and transesterification with fluorous tagged catalysts.
similarly [ 191, hydrogen transfer taking place in a mixture of perfluoroalkane and isopropanol with iridium complexes in association with the chiral perfluorosalen ligand 8. Oxidation of aldehyde 9 can be accomplished at 64 "C with oxygen and a catalytic amount of nickel derivative 10 in a homogeneous phase consisting of the toluene/perfluorodecalin solvent mixture [12]. After phase separation at room temperature, the catalyst is kept in the fluorous phase by its fluoroalkyl chains and can easily be separated from the product, which remains in the organic phase. The catalyst can be used again, still yielding 70% of the oxidation product after six reaction cycles. No leaching of the catalyst was observed. Esters, chlorides, and silyl ethers are functional groups that are tolerated in this reaction. The high solubility of Oz in fluorinated solvents is of special advantage for this oxidation reaction. In analogous systems, sulfides can be oxidized to sulfoxides or sulfones in the presence of isobutyraldehyde, while epoxides are selectively obtained from substituted olefins [ 121. Further catalysts that take advantage of the fluorous phase and are used for alkene epoxidation are
EtOH
96
I
Fluorous Techniques: Progress i n Reaction-Processing and Purification Asymmetric alkylation
+
&H
Ti(0i-Pr), FC-72IToluene
Et,Zn
*
0""
3::
(C,F,,CH,CH,)3Si
\
/
(C,F,3CHzCH,)3Si 7 Reduction [Ir(COD)CI], i-PrOH/C,F,8/KOH
ph+dph F17c8
+OH tBu
a
tBu
Oxidation
10 (3 Mol.%)
AcO J y H
9
0, (1 atm) Toluene / Perfluorodecalin
AcO &OH
Cross coupling
Fig. 2. Fluorous biphasic catalysis part II: asymmetric alkylation, reduction, oxidation, and cross-coupling reactions with fluorous tagged catalysts.
Fluorous-Phase Strategy for lmprouing Separation Eficiency
I
97
a cobalt complex of a tetraarylporphyrin, an optically active (sa1en)Mn"' complex, and a catalyst generated in situ from a bipyridine, RuC13, and NaI04 [13]. In addition, M ~ ( O A C ) ~ . ~ H2O in a heterogeneous mixture with pivalaldehyde catalyzes aerobic epoxidation in FC-75 as a solvent [27]. Olefins are epoxidized with 5 mol-% perfluoroheptadecan-9-one and H z 0 2 in boiling CH2C12, in which the catalyst is not wholly soluble. Up to 92% of the catalyst can be recycled by crystallization at 0 "C. In addition, the Wacker oxidation of an olefin to the respective ketone can be successfully performed in the two-phase system of benzene and bromoperfluorooctane with tert-BuOOH and a catalyst similar to 10, with palladium as the metal [28]. The palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling of an aryl, alkenyl, or benzylzinc bromide 11 with aryl iodide 12 succeeds with 0.15 mol-% [ Pd{ P ( C G H ~ C ~ F in ~ ~toluene/l-bromo)~}~] perfluorooctane, taking advantage of variable miscibility through thermoregulation [20]. In this case the electron-deficiencyof the phosphanes, due to the perfluorinated side chains, appears to influence the reductive elimination step in the cross-coupling reactions. Finally, 10 mol-% of the lanthanide perfluoroalkylsulfone amide complex in CGH~CF3 catalyzes both Friedel-Crafts acylation and the Diels-Alder Yb(N( S02C4F9)2)3 reaction [ 261. The high Lewis acidity of the metal complexes seems to be crucial. Fluorous-Phase Strategy for Improving Separation Efficiency
Apart from its use for solvation and separation of catalysts, the fluorous phase can also be used advantageously for separation processes during workup. Strategic synthesis planning is facilitated by tagging with fluorous residues to overcome the frequently limiting recovery and purification difficulties [ 11. As in solid-phase syntheses, an excess of components can be used to drive the reactions to completion. Side products can easily be separated if, for example. only the product is tagged with fluorous alkyl residues and therefore precipitates from the reaction mixture or is extracted with the fluorous phase. Isoxazoline 13 is obtained by 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of nitrile oxide tBuCNO to olefin 14, labeled with a fluorous alkyl residue, with CH2C12 or C6H5CF3 as the solvent (Figure 3) [29]. Since these solvents are partially halogenated, all substrates appear to dissolve fully. After extraction with benzene, the fluorous-labeled product 13 remains. Cleavage of the fluorous alkyl tag from the product allows extraction into the organic phase by a three-phase extraction procedure (water, CH2C12,FC-72).The problem with this 'one-phase' reaction procedure is that phase separation does not distinguish between substrate 14 and product 13. An excess of reagents and reactants is required to overcome this problem and to drive the reaction to completion. Another way of avoiding the one-phase problem is to conduct a phase switch, as illustrated for Grignard addition to aldehyde 15. Acetaldehyde is soluble in the organic phase and is transferred into the fluorous phase during the course of the reaction, as the generated hydroxyl group is immediately silylated with a fluorous tag. Separation of derivative 16 from remaining starting material is therefore facilitated. Subsequent cleavage of the fluorous label lets alcohol 17 switch into the organic phase and thus facilitates efficient separation from both reactants and side products. In a fluorous variant of the Ugi and Biginelli multicomponent reactions, it has been
98
I
Fhorous Techniques: Progress in Reaction-Processing and Purification
One-phase reaction process 1. t-BUCNO. c6H5cF3
N
OSi(CHzCHzC6F13)3
-
2. extraction
14
OSi(CH2CH,C6Fl3), t-Bu 13
Reaction with phase change 1. PhMgBr 2. BrSi(CH2CH,C6F13)3
Si(CH2CH2C6F13)3 1. CsF
*
H3C 15 Fig. 3.
3. extraction in the fluorous phase
16
'h H3CP
2. extraction in the organic phase
"7
I I
Fluorous-phase reactions: single-phase reaction versus reaction with phase changes.
shown that larger molecules, with molecular weights of about 450, can also be synthesized through the advantages of fluorous-phase separation. The desired condensation products are obtained in good yields, even though only 6 weight-% of the reaction mixture belongs to the products [30]. At this point, atom economy [31] becomes an obvious problem of fluorousphase chemistry, with regard both to the starting material/product relationship and to fluorous labeling ((CloF21-C2H4)3-Sitags). This is particularly the case with rising polarity and size of the substrates, since an even higher degree of fluorination is needed. If protecting groups are required for synthetic transformations, fluorous tagging reagents can be introduced directly for the protection of functional groups, thereby meeting two needs without additional steps [ 321. After application of the fluorous benzyl protecting group Bnf, glucal 18 is converted by an excess of diacetone galactose 19 into the disaccharide 20, which, despite its relatively high polarity, is extracted into the FC-72 fluorous phase (Figure 4). Fluorous tags are also interesting as scavengers for an excess of starting material or of one of the reagents. Compounds that are not entirely converted after the reaction can be quenched with molecules bearing an alkyl fluorous group and can then be removed by fluorous-phase extraction [ 331. This principle has been applied, for example, to an excess of ~CH~CH~]~N isocyanate, which was quenched with the amine [ ( C ~ F ~ S C H ~ C H ~ ) ~ S ~ C H and then extracted into the fluorous phase. Although tin hydride is widely used as a reagent in ionic and radical reactions, it is prone to problems regarding its complete removal and its toxicity. The fluorous reagent tris[2(perfluorohexyl)ethyl]tin hydride ( ( C ~ F I ~ C H ~ C H ~21) ) ~has S ~normal H; tin hydride reactivity and can be completely extracted with perfluoromethylcyclohexane [34]. It can be used
Fluorous-Phase Strategy for lmproving Separation Eficiency
I
99
OH
p
OBnf I
I
'""0 (10 equiv.)
BnfO"' OH Br
9BnfBr
OBnf 18
OBnf
+
extraction in the FC-72 phase Fig. 4.
excess in the MeOH phase
Fluorous protecting group (Bnf): simultaneous function as protecting group and as fluorous tag.
advantageously in reactions carried out in a partially fluorinated solvent such as C ~ H S C F ~ , which provides a homogeneous reaction mixture. The rate constants for radical trapping by the fluorous tin hydride reagent 21 are about twice those of the reaction between Bu3SnH and the primary radical 22 [35]. This implies a convenient application of fluorous tin hydride reagents that can closely mimic tributyltin hydride in preparative chemistry (Figure 5). Another application of fluorous chemistry is offered by palladium-catalyzed Stille crosscoupling between fluorous aryltin reactants and organic halides or triflates [ 361. This reaction is catalyzed by [PdC12(PPh3)2] and carried out in a DMF/THF/C~FSCF~ solvent mixture, with LiCl as an additive. Workup is by extraction from the three-phase system of water, CH2C12,and FC-72. As an example, coupling of the heteroaryl tin derivative 23 with aryl triflate 24 (Figure 5) indicates the broad applicability of the fluorous Stille reaction. This fluorous variant of Stille coupling can be achieved in only two minutes (as opposed to 24 hours) by use of microwave irradiation in DMF. The fluorous allyltin reagent 25 is also valuable in the radical allylation of alkyl or aryl halides [ 371 and in a radical four-component carbonylation reaction (Figure 5) [ 381. Fluorous allyltin reagent 25 reacts with the acrylic ester 26 and the alkyl iodide 27 in the presence of CO (90 atm) in the partially fluorinated solvent C6HSCF3.The product 28 resulting from a radical tandem sequence is extracted from the two-phase mixture CH3CN/FC-72.The chainpropagating abilities of fluorous allyltin reagents have been found to be slightly weaker than those of conventional allyltin reagents.
100
I
Fluorous Techniques: Progress in Reaction-Processing and Pur$cation
Trapping of a primary radical (c6F1 3CH2CH2)3SnH u
p
h
d
I
P
21
h
kT
*
dPh @Ph
Stille cross coupling
eTfo& mo A
U
M~ PdC12(PPh& *
(C6F13CH2CH2)3Sn
\ I +I
23
/ \
LiCI, DMF
OMe
Radical allylation
+
&Br
(C6F13CH2CH2CH2)3Sn 25 (C6F1,CH2CH2CH2),Sn Br
Fluoroallylation in a four-component coupling
+
25
EtO
+
&COOMe 26
Ll
+
co
-
EtO*
0
COOMe
27
28 Fig. 5.
Reactions that have been performed with the aid o f the fluorous-phase approach.
Fluorous Reversed-Phase Silica Gel I 1 0 1
+
-
FH3
coz
(~FI3CH,CH,),SnH
I
21
Cbz
+
(C6Fl,CH,CH,)3Snl
\
Cbz
0
Fig. 6.
Radical cyclization in supercritical COz.
Reactions in Supercritical C 0 2
Although supercritical C02 is interesting as a reaction medium from the toxicological and environmental points of view, its use is limited because of the poor solubility of polar molecules. Organofluorine compounds are well known to be highly soluble in supercritical C02; this greatly extends synthetic possibilities in this medium [ 391. This is particularly the case for radical reactions, which require neither nucleophiles nor electrophiles and do not involve charged intermediates during the course of the reaction. Indeed, the fluorous alkyltin hydride 22 can be used for radical cyclizations in supercritical CO2 at moderate pressure. The formation of tin formate 29 (a side product often encountered in tributyltin hydride reactions in COz) is completely suppressed (Figure 6). The use of highly COz-soluble fluorous reagents, catalysts, and protecting groups should prove to be a valuable strategy for transportation of other reactions into supercritical CO2. In the long run, COZ should thereby serve as both the reaction and the separation solvent. Fluorous Reversed-Phase Silica Gel
A silica gel with a fluorocarbon bonded phase was first introduced in 1978 [40].It is ~C~FI~ commercially available with either of two residues, - S ~ ( M ~ ) ~ C H ~ C Hor -Si(Me)2CH2CH2CH2C(CF3)zCFzCFzCF3, attached to silica gel. These solid-phase materials retain fluorinated molecules with an affinity defined primarily by fluorine content [41-431. Fluorous solid-phase extractions are a first application of this material. As an alternative to liquid-liquid extractions, it is possible to extract fluorous products, catalysts, or reagents into the solid phase. Organic products are eluted with CH3CN, whereas various mobile phases of differing eluting power (hexanes, THF, partially fluorinated solvents, fluorocarbon solvents) are used afterwards to elute the fluorinated compounds from the silica gel. Another application is in fluorous chromatography: separation of fluorous compounds from other fluorous compounds on the basis of their respective fluorine content is possible. This chromatographic separation is quite sensitive, as shown by the following example of a small library synthesis of 100 mappicine analogues [44]. Starting with a mixture of pyridines 30, in which each residue R1 corresponds to a defined fluorous tag Rf, a series of cascade transformations and radical annulations is performed as indicated in Figure 7. Finally, a mixture
102
I
Fluorous Techniques: Progress in Reaction-Processing and Purijication OMe
A
-
,Me
2. BBr,
*a* TMS 30
I
0-Si(iPr),CH,CH,-
I
Rf
0-Si(iPr),CH,CH,-
Rf Five propargyl halides
Four pyridine derivatives
31 I 0-Si(iPr),CH,CH;
Rf- CH,CH,Si(iPr),-0
Rf
100 tagged mappicines R1
R2
H TBS Et H tBu H Bn H Ph Et
R3 Me iPr iPr iPr iPr
Rf (tag)
retention time (min)
C,H,, C,F, C,F,, C,F,, C,,F,,
2 11 16 24 30
Fig. 7. Synthesis of a library containing 100 rnappicine derivatives with fluorous tags (Rf): efficient separation on fluorous reversed-phase silica gel is possible on the basis of the fluorine content of the tag [44].
of tagged mappicines 31 is obtained, and these can be separated and deconvoluted on the basis of their fluorous tags. Separation is very efficient, as shown by the retention times of five derivatives. In fluorous synthesis, the possibility for separation on a fluorous solid phase allows for reduction of the fluorine content in the tags. Fluorous resins offer a way to confront the high molecular weight problem resulting from fluorous tagging and therefore the problem of atom economy in fluorous-phase chemistry.
References 1 a) B. CORNILS, Angew. Chem. Int.
Ed. Engl.
1997, 36, 2057-2059; b) D. P. CURRAN, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998, 37, 11751196; c) E. D E WOLF,G. VAN KOTEN,B.-J. DEELMAN, Chem. SOC.Rev. 1999, 28, 37-41. 2 M. VOGT; Ph.D. thesis, RWTH Aachen, 1991.
of fluorous phase chemistry see the following internet pages: http://www.fluorous.com and
3 For commercial use
http://www.ict-inter.net. TAKEUCHI, Y. NAKAMURA, Y. OHGO, et al., Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 86918694.
4 S.
References I103
I. T. H O R V ~ T HJ. , R ~ B A IScience , 1994, 266,72-75;b) I. T.H O R V ~ T G. H , Kiss, R. A. COOK,et a]., J . Am. Chem. SOL.1998, 120.3133-3143;c) S. KAINZ. D. KOCH. W. BAUMANN,et al., Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36,1628-1630. 6 a) J. J. J. JULIETTE, I. T. H O R V ~ T H J. ,A. GLADYSZ, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36.1610-1612;b) J. J. J. JULIETTE, D. RUTHERFORD,I. T. H O R V ~ T Het H ,al., /. Am. Chem. SOC.1999, 121,2696-2704. 7 a) D.RUTHERFORD,J. J. J. JULIETTE, C. ROCABOY, et al., Catal. Today 1998, 42, 381-388;b) C. M. HAAR,J. HUANG,S. P. NOLAN, et al.. Organometallics 1998, 17, 5018-5024;c) B. RICHTER,A. L. SPEK,G. VAN KOTEN,et al., /. Am. Chem. SOC.2000, 122,3945-3951. 8 L. V. DINH,J. A. GLADYSZ, Tetrahedron Lett. 1999, 40,8995-8998. 9 W. KEIM,M. VOGT,P. WASSERSCHEID, et al., /. Mol. Catal. A : Chem. 1999, 139,1715 a)
175. 10 A. ENDRES,G. MAAS,Tetrahedron Lett.
1999, 40,6365-6368. 1 1 J.XIANG,S. TOYOSHIMA, A. ORITA,et al.,
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2001, 40,3670-3672. I. KLEMENT, H. LUTJENS, P. KNOCHEL, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 1454-1456. a) G. POZZI,F. MONTANARI, S. QUICI. Chem. Commun. 1997, 69-70;b) G. POZZI, F. CINATO,F. MONTANARI, et al., Chem. Commun. 1998, 877-878;c) G. POZZI,M. CAVAZZINI, F. CINATO,et al., Eur. /. Org. Chem. 1999, 8,1947-1955;d) S.QUICI,M. CAVAZZINI, S. CERAGIOLI, et al., Tetrahedron Lett. 1999, 40,3647-3650;e) G. POZZI,M. CAVAZZINI, S. QUICI,et al., Tetrahedron Lett. 1997, 38.7605-7608. K. S. RAVIKUMAR, F. BARBIER,J:P. BBcuB, et al., Tetrahedron 1998, 54,7447-7464. T. NISHIMURA, Y. MAEDA,N. KAKIUCHI. et al., J . Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 1 2000, 4301-4305. B. BETZEMEIER, M. CACAZZINI, S. QUICI, et al., Tetrahedron Lett. 2000,41,43434346. B. BETZEMEIER,P. KNOCHEL,in ‘Peroxide Chemistry’ (Ed. W. ADAM),Wiley-VCH 2000,454-468. J.-M. VINCENT, A. RABION,V. K. YACHANDRA, et al., Angew. Chem. lnt. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36,2346-2349.
12 a)
13
14 15
16
17
18
19 D. MAILLARD, C. NGUEFACK, G. POZZI,S.
QUICI,B. VALADE, D. S I N O UTetrahedron , Asymmetry 2000, 1 I , 2881-2884. 20 B. BETZEMEIER, P. KNOCHEL,Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36,26232624. 21 R. KLING, D. SINOU,G. P o z z ~ et , al., Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39,9439-9442. 22 J. MOINEAU, G. POZZI,S. QUICI,eta].: Tetrahedron Lett. 1999, 40,7683-7686. 23 S. SCHNEIDER, W. BANNWARTH,Hela Chim. Acta 2001, 84,735-742. 24 Y. NAKAMURA, S. TAKEUCHI, Y. OHGO,et al., Tetrahedron Lett. 2000,41, 57-GO. 25 K. MIKAMI,Y. MIKAMI, Y. MATSUMOTO, et al., Tetrahedron Lett. 2001, 42,289-292. 26 J. NISHIKIDO, H. NAKAJIMA, T. SAEKI,et al., Synlett 1998, 1347-1348. 27 M. c. A. VAN VLIET, I. w. c. E. ARENDS, R. A. SHELDON, Chem. Commun. 1999, 263-264. 28 B. BETZEMEIER,F. LHERMITE, P. KNOCHEL, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39, 6667-6670. 29 a) A. STUDER,S. HADIDA, R. FERRITTO, et al., Science 1997, 275,823-826;b) A. STUDER,D. P. CURRAN,Tetrahedron 1997, 53,6681-6696. 30 A. STUDER. P. J E G E R , P. WIPF. et a]., /. Org. Chem. 1997, 62,2917-2924. 31 B. M.TROST,Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34,259-281. 32 a) D.P. CURRAN, R. FERRITTO,Y. HUA, Tetrahedron Lett. 1998, 39,4937-4940;b) T. MIURA,Y. HIROSE,M. OHMAE,eta]., Org. Lett. 2001, 3,3947-3950. 33 B. LINCLAU,A. K. SING,D. P. CURRAN,]. Org. Chem. 1999, 64,2835-2842. 34 D. P.CURRAN, S. HADIDA, /. Am. Chem. SOC.1996, 118,2531-2532. 35 J. H. HORNER, F. N. MARTINEZ, M. NEWCOMB, et al., Tetrahedron Lett. 1997, 38,2783-2786. 36 a) D.P. CURRAN, M. HOSHINO,J.Org. Chem. 1996, 61,6480-6481;b) M. LARHED, M. HOSHINO,S. HADIDA, et al., /. Org. Chem. 1997, 62,5583-5587;c) M. HOSHINO,P. DEGENKOLB, D. P.CURRAN, J . Org. Chem. 1997, 62,8341-8349. 37 D.P. CURRAN, Z. Luo, P. DEGENKOLB, Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 1998, 8,24032408. 38 I. RYU, T. NIGUMA,S. MINAKATA, et al., Tetrahedron Lett. 1999, 40,2367-2370.
104
I
Fluorous Techniques: Progress in Reaction-Processing and Purification 39 a) S. KAINZ, D. KOCH, W. BAUMANN,
et al., Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 1628-1630; b) S. HADIDA,M. S. SUPER,E. J. BECKMAN,et a!.,]. Am. Chem. SOC.1997, 119, 7406-7407; c) J. S. KEIPER, R. SIMHAN, J. M. DESIMONE, et al., J . Am. Chem. SOC.2002, 124, 18341835. 40 G. E. BERENDSEN, L. D. GALAN,].Liquid Chromatop. 1978, I , 403. 41 D. E. BERGBREITER,J. G. FRANCHINA, Chem. Commurz. 1997, 1531-1532.
a) D. P. CURRAN, S . HADIDA, M. HE,]. Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 6714-6715; b) S . KAINZ, 2. Luo, D. P. CURRAN, et al., Synthesis 1998, 1425-1427; c) D. P. CURRAN, Z. Y. Luo,]. Am. Chem. SOC. 1999, 121, 9069-9072; d) D. P. CURRAN, Synlett 2001, 1488-1496. 43 W. ZHANG,D. P. CURRAN, C. H.-T. CHEN, Tetrahedron 2002, 58, 3871-3875. Issue 20 is a special issue on fluorous chemistry. 44 Z. Luo, Q. ZHANG,Y. ODERAOTOSHI, et a!., Science 2001, 291, 1766-1769. 42
Organic Synthesis Highlights V Edited by Hans-Gunther Schmalz and Thomas Wirth Copyright02003 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co
I105
Recent Developments in Using lonic Liquids as Solvents and Catalysts for Organic Synthesis Peter Wasserscheid Introduction
An ionic liquid is a liquid that consists only of ions and has a melting point below 100 “C. The apparently somewhat arbitrary line drawn between molten salts and ionic liquids at a melting temperature of 100 “C is justified by the possibility to replace water and organic solvents in synthetic applications with salts melting below this temperature. Research in ionic liquids and in organic synthesis using ionic liquids as solvents and/or as catalysts is attracting a lot of interest today. More than 300 citations in the SciFinder database looking for the keyword “ionic liquid(s)” in 2001 clearly indicate this. However, the big interest in ionic liquid methodology has only developed quite recently. In the years before 1997, less than 10 publications per year referred to the progress in this research field. What are the reasons for this rapidly growing interest? As far as I can see, there are three main contributions which will be briefly summarised in the following sub-chapters. Availability of Hydrolysis Stable lonic Liquids
So far the historical development of ionic liquids has mainly been driven by combining imidazolium, pyridinium, ammonium and phosphonium cations with different classes of anions. Chloroaluminate ionic liquids were the first more detailed studied ionic liquids. As early as 1948 they were synthesized by Hurley and Wier at the Rice Institute in Texas as bath solutions for electroplating aluminum [ 11. Later in the seventies and eighties, these systems were further developed by the groups of Osteryoung [2], Wilkes [3], Hussey [4] and Seddon [4c, 51. Due to their chemical nature, chloroaluminate ionic liquids must be classified as extremely hygroscopic and labile towards hydrolysis. In 1992, Wilkes and Zaworotko described the synthesis of the first imidazolium tetrafluoroborate ionic liquids [GI. These systems together with the slightly later published [7] hexafluorophosphate analogues are the “working horses” of the actual research with ionic liquid. However, their use in many technical applications is still limited by their relatively high sensitivity versus hydrolysis. The tendency of anion hydrolysis is of course much less pronounced than for the chloroaluminate melts but still existent. The [PF,j- anion of 1butyl-3-methylimidazolium ([ BMIM]) hexafluorophosphate - for example - has been found in our laboratories to completely hydrolyse after addition of excess water when the sample
106
I
Recent Developments in Using Ionic Liquids as Solvents and Catalystsfor Organic Synthesis
Tab. 1. Comparison of some properties of well-established ionic liquid systems with the l-ethyl-3methyimidazolium ([EMIM]) ion
ionic liquid
phasetransition
viscosity‘ fCPl
density‘ fgWl
tendencyfor hydrolysis
ref:
7 (mp)
18
1.240
very high
10
[EMIM] [ B F4] [EMIM][CF3SO,]
6 kP) -3 (mp)
34
1.240
relatively low
11
45
1.390
very low
9
[EMIM][(CF~SWZNI
-9 (mp)
31
1.518
very low
12
“Cl ~
[ EMIM][ AIC14]
4 a t 25 ” C ; mp = melting point: gp = glass point
was kept for 8 h at 100 “C. HF (toxic and highly corrosive) and phosphoric acid was formed. Under the same conditions hydrolysis of the tetrafluoroborate ion of [BMIM][BF4] was observed as well, however to a much smaller extend [8]. Consequently, the application of tetrafluoroborate and hexafluorophosphate ionic liquids is effectively restricted - at least under a technical scenario - to those applications where water-free conditions can be realised at acceptable costs. In 1996, Gratzel, BonhBte and coworkers published synthesis and properties of ionic liquids with anions containing CF3-groupsand other fluorinated alkyl groups [9].These do not show the same sensitivity towards hydrolysis than [BF4]- and [PF6]- containing systems. In fact, heating [BMIM][CF3S02),N] with excess of water to 100 “C for 24 h did not reveal any hint for anion hydrolysis [8]. In addition to their hydrolysis stability, a number of other very suitable properties of imidazolium salts with [ CF3S02)2N]-anion should be mentioned here. In comparison to other well established ionic liquids they combine low melting points and low viscosity with high thermal stability (for a comparison of some physico-chemical data see Table 1). Moreover, they can be easily prepared in high quality due to their miscibility gap with water. Commercial Availability
Historically, the know-how to synthesise and handle ionic liquids has been treated somehow like a “holy grail”. Indeed, only a small number of specialised industrial and academic research groups were able to prepare and handle the highly hygroscopic chloroaluminate ionic liquids which were the only ionic liquid systems available in larger amounts up to the mid-nineties. The first publication describing the synthesis of tetrafluoroborate and hexafluorophosphate ionic liquids by metathesis reaction from the corresponding alkali salts [ 131 opened up the way towards a commercial ionic liquid production. Nowadays, a number of commercial suppliers offer ionic liquids even in large quantities [14]. Moreover, the availability of many ionic liquids on a rapid delivery basis has been established through internationally operating distributors [ 151. Without any doubt the improved commercial availability of ionic liquids is a key factor for the strongly increasing interest in this new class of liquid materials. In fact, a synthetic
Progress in lonic Liquid Design and Synthesis
chemist searching for the ideal solvent for his specific application usually takes solvents which are ready for use on the shelf of his laboratory. The additional effort of synthesising a new special solvent can be rarely justified especially in industrial research. Green Chemistry
For good reasons, ionic liquids are often discussed as solvents for a “Greener Chemistry” [lG]. In contrast to volatile organic solvents and extraction media, they have no measurable vapour pressure. Therefore there is no loss of solvent through evaporation. Environmental and safety problems arising through the use of volatile organic solvents can be avoided. For catalytic application where a transition metal catalyst is dissolved in the ionic liquid or the ionic liquid itself acts as the catalyst two additional aspects are of interest. Firstly, the special solubility properties of the ionic liquid enables a biphasic reaction mode in many cases. Exploitation of the miscibility gap between the ionic catalyst phase and the products allows, in this case, the catalyst to be isolated effectively from the product and reused many times. Secondly, the non-volatile nature of ionic liquids enables a more effective product isolation by distillation. Again, the possibility arises to reuse the isolated ionic catalyst phase. In both cases, the total reactivity of the applied catalysts is increased and catalyst consumption relative to the generated product is reduced. For example, all these advantages have been convincingly demonstrated for the transition metal catalysed hydroformylation [ 171. Therefore, the general trend towards a “greener” and more sustainable chemistry has contributed substantially to the growing interest in using ionic liquids for synthetic applications. Following the large number of original publications describing the use of ionic liquids in synthetic applications an extensive reviewing practise about this topic has developed over the last three years. Olivier-Bourbigouand Magna [18], Sheldon [19] and Gordon [20] published three excellent reviews presenting a comprehensive overview of the actual work carried out on catalysis involving ionic liquids with slightly different emphasis. All three up-date earlier published reviews by the author and Keim [21], Welton [22] and Seddon and Holbrey [23] on the same topic. Moreover, a whole book has been dedicated to the application of ionic liquids in synthetic applications [ 241. Obviously, it can not be the aim of this contribution to repeat or summarise the above mentioned reviews again. In contrast, a few selected recent developments in different areas of ionic liquid research should be highlighted which are believed to be of some general relevance for the future development of ionic liquids and their application in synthetic chemistry. Progress in Ionic Liquid Design and Synthesis
In the last two years, an interesting process could be observed in the research aiming for the development of new ionic liquids. Depending on the complexity of the combination of properties required and on the amount of ionic liquid consumed for a given application, the recently developed ionic liquids can be divided in two groups: The first group falls under the definition of “bulk ionic liquids”. This means a class of ionic liquids that is designed to be produced, used and somehow consumed in larger quan-
I
107
108
I
Recent Developments in Using Ionic Liquids as Solvents and Catalystsfor Organic Synthesis
r-
Fig. 1.
1
Examples for “bulk ionic liquids” developed in the last three years.
tities. Applications for these ionic liquids are expected to be solvents for organic reactions, homogeneous catalysis, biocatalysis and other synthetic applications with some ionic liquid consumption as well as non synthetic applications such as the application as heat carriers, lubricants, additives, surfactants, phase transfer catalysts, extraction solvents, solvents for extractive distillation, antistatics etc. Cation and anion of these “bulk ionic liquids” are chosen to make a relatively cheap (expected price on a multi-hundred litre scale: ca 30 (€/litre), halogen-free (e.g. for easy disposal of spent ionic liquid by thermal treatment) and toxologically well-characterized liquid (a preliminary study about the acute toxicity of a nonchloroaluminate ionic liquid has been recently published [25]). It can be expected that from all ionic liquids meeting these requirements only a very limited number of candidates will be selected for an industrial use on larger scale. However, these candidates will become well characterised and - due to their larger production quantities - readily available. Promising examples for this type of “bulk ionic liquids” include benzenesulfonate [ 261, toluenesulfonate [ 271, octylsulfate [ 281 and hydrogensulfate [ 291 ionic liquids. Some examples are given in Figure 1. On the other hand several research groups are active in developing highly specialised, task-specific ionic liquids that - of course - will be used in much smaller quantities. Fields of applications for the latter are expected to be special solvents for organic synthesis, homogeneous catalysis, biocatalysis and all other synthetic applications with very low ionic liquid consumption (e.g. due to very efficient multiphasic operation). Non-synthetic applications for these materials are analytic applications (stationary or mobile phases for chromatography, matrixes for MS etc.), sensors, batteries etc. These ionic liquids are designed and optimised for the best performance in high-value-adding applications. Consequently, in future research only the scientist’s fantasy will limit the number of used ionic liquids in this group. Interesting recently published examples include ionic liquids with fluorinated [ 301. functionalized [31] and chiral cations [32] and anions (331. Advanced Acidic Ionic Liquids
Acidic chloroaluminate ionic liquids were used as reaction media for Friedel-Craftsreactions as early as 1976 [ 341. Systematic investigations into Friedel-Crafts alkylations of benzene with the same acidic systems followed in 1986 by Wilkes et al. [35]. The alkylation of benzene with alkenes in acidic imidazolium chloroaluminate melts was disclosed in a patent by BP Chemicals in 1994 [36]. Here, as advantages over the reaction with aluminum trichloride in organic solvents, claims are made regarding the easy isolation of the product, the practically total reusability of the liquid catalyst and the better selectivity to the desired products.
Advanced Acidic fonic Liquids
Fig. 2.
Examples for task specific ionic liquids developed in the last three years.
Following up this initial work a large number of reactions have been published by academic and industrial groups wherein a Lewis-acidic chloroaluminate ionic liquid is used as the acidic catalyst. A comprehensive overview on these research activities can be found in several reviews on this topic and the literature cited therein [18, 22, 371. However, acidic systems based on chloroaluminate ionic liquids have some serious limitations. They are extremely oxophilic thus forming adducts with C-0 functionalities. This makes their catalytic use difficult if the substrate or product of the reaction under investigation contains such a functional group. Often, it is necessary in these cases to hydrolyse the ionic liquid prior to product isolation including complete loss of the acidic ionic liquid catalyst. Moreover, chloroaluminate ionic liquids are difficult to handle since they react irreversibly with traces of water to form HC1 and Al-oxides. In this chapter alternative acidic ionic liquids systems will be briefly presented that have been recently developed as alternatives to chloroaluminate ionic liquids. In spite of this selection, it should be noted that chloroaluminate ionic liquids may still be attractive catalyst phases in reactions where their tuneable acidity and solubility properties offer advantage over AlC13 in organic solvents. Non-chloroalurninate Lewis Acidic Ionic Liquids
Seddon and co-workers described the Friedel-Crafts acylation reaction of benzene with acetylchloride using acidic chloroferrate ionic liquids as catalysts [38]. In contrast to the same reaction in presence of acidic chloroaluminate systems the ketone product could be separated from the ionic liquid by solvent extraction, provided that the molar ratio of FeC13 is in the range 0.51-0.55 in the applied ionic liquid catalyst (Scheme 1).
Scheme 1.
Friedel-Crafts acetylation using an acidic chloroferrate ionic liquid
I
109
110
I
Recent Developments in Using Ionic Liquids as Solvents and Catalystsfor Organic Synthesis Examples for non-chloroaluminate ionic liquids formed by the reaction of a halide salt with a Lewis acid.
Tab. 2.
ionic liquid
anion species
references
[cation] Cl/FeClj [cation] CI/AlEtC12 [cation] CI/BCl, [cation] Cl/CuCI [cation] Cl/SnC12 [cation] X/SbF, [cation] CI/ZnC12
C1-, [FeC14][AlEtCl,] , [A12Et2Cls]-, [AlzEtC16]Cl-, [BC14][CuC12]-, [Cu2C1,]-, [Cu3C14][SnCI,]-, [Sn,Cl,]e.g. [SbFSXIe.g. [ZnC13]
38 39
cation
= pyridinium,
40 41
42 43 44
imidazolium, ammonium.
This simple example may illustrate that in general the reaction of an organic halide salt [cation]X with an excess of a Lewis-acid MX, can result in new catalytic materials even if other Lewis-acidsare applied than AlC13. In contrast, the use of other Lewis-acidsto form the ionic liquid of type [cation][MX,+l] + excess MX, (the excess of MX, may be dissolved in the neutral ionic liquid or may form acidic anionic species such as e.g. [M2X2y+l]-)gives access to new combinations of properties (e.g. a liquid, less oxophilic, Lewis-acidic catalyst with defined solubility and acidity properties). In Table 2 other examples of ionic liquids are presented which are formed by the reaction of an organic halide salt with different Lewis-acids. All these systems should be in principle useful acidic